THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WILL COME
TO ORDER GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY
AND WELCOME TO OUR COMMITTEE
HEARING TODAY THE SENATE
CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC
IN PERSON AND VIA THE
TELECONFERENCING SERVICE FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY'S
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS.
877-226-8163 AND THE ACCESS CODE
IS. FOUR FIVE THREE OH SIX NINE
FOUR WE ARE HOLDING OUR
COMMITTEE OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS
HERE IN THE- STREET BUILDING AND
I'M GONNA ASK ALL OF THE MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT
IN ROOM TWENTY TWO HUNDRED SO WE
CAN ESTABLISH OUR- OUR QUORUM
WE'RE GONNA START TODAY AS A SUB
COMMITTEE SO WE'RE GONNA JUMP
RIGHT INTO IT. WE HAVE SEVENTEEN
BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA THREE OR
PROPOSED FOR CONSENT THE CONSENT
ITEMS TODAY OUR FILE ITEM NUMBER
ONE AB FOUR THIRTY BY EIGHT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BENNETT FILE
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN A. B. TEN
NINETY FOUR BYE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
THREE OF US. AND FILE ITEM
NUMBER FOURTEEN AB FIFTEEN
TWENTY EIGHT BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON FILE NUMBER EIGHT AB
TWELVE SEVENTY FIVE BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER ARAMBULA HAS BEEN
PULLED FROM TODAY'S AGENDA. FILE
ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN AB FIVE
FORTY THREE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON WILL BE RECONSIDERED FOR
A VOTE ONLY AND WILL TAKE THAT
ITEM UP AFTER ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON PRESENTS HIS- OTHER BILL
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE. AND
ANNOUNCEMENT TO THE PUBLIC
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS WE WILL GO TO INTO
RECESS AT TWELVE FIFTEEN BECAUSE
OF THE SENATE FLOOR SESSION ONCE
FLOOR HAS ADJOURNED. THE RULES
COMMITTEE WILL BEGIN THEIR
HEARING IN THIS ROOM. SO IF WE
HAVE NOT FINISHED BY TWELVE
FIFTEEN WE WILL COME BACK AFTER
THE SENATE RULES RULES ADJOURNS
PUTS IT IN EVERYBODY'S INTEREST
TO GET HERE. AND MAKE SURE THAT
THEIR- SYNCING- THAT THE-
TELECONFERENCE. TAKES SOME TIME
AND SO- IT SOMETIME TAKES US A
LITTLE BIT LONGER TO GET THROUGH
BILLS HAVE TEN AUTHORS. SO WE'RE
GOING TO- BEGIN HEARING ARE ARE
PRESENTATION- WITH ASSEMBLY
MEMBER KALRA FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE- ASSEMBLY MEMBER-
CONNOLLY HAS- GRACEFULLY- GIVEN
THE FLOOR TO. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
KALRA. AB. EIGHT FOURTEEN SIXTY
NINE THE FLOOR IS YOURS. THANK
YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS I DO
WANNA THANK OF COLLEAGUE SUMMER
CONNELLY FOR HIS GRACIOUSNESS-
AND I LIKE TO FIRST BEGIN BY
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND I WANT TO THANK
THE COMMITTEE STAFF- AND SHARE
FOR THEIR TIME AND WORK ON- ON
THIS ISSUE WITH US ON THIS BILL
WITH US. AB FORTY SIXTY NINE HAS
ENJOYED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. AND
WOULD AMEND THE SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT ACT TO
EXPAND ITS STATUTORY PURPOSES
AND ALLOW CERTAIN RESOURCES TO
BE USED FOR OUTREACH COUNSELING
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING OR OTHER
SERVICES FOR UNSHELTERED PEOPLE
LIVING ON PUBLIC LANDS. AND
ALONG WATERWAYS WITHIN SANTA
CLARA COUNTY. ALI WATER OWNS A
MAN TO NINETY FOUR OF MILES OF
STREAMS AND HABITAT WITH THE
MISSION TO PROTECT MORE THAN A
HUNDRED MILES OF STREAMS
ROSEANNE KERN COUNTY. THE
202277% OF THE IN HOUSE
POPULATION CENTER COUNTY WERE
UNSHELTERED. WITH AN ESTIMATED
TWENTY THREE HUNDRED TAKING
REFUGE ON VALLEY WATERS PROPERTY
OR LAND EASEMENTS. SUCH
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THAT DOING
CAMPUS ALONG THE WATERWAYS BOTH
A HUMAN AND ENVIRONMENTAL
TRAGEDY. FOR EXAMPLE THE
WATERSHED THE CENTER COUNTY ARE
PRONE TO FLASH FLOODING. OF
SURPRISING UNSHELTERED PEOPLE
RESULTING IN DROWNINGS OR
SERIOUS INJURY. IN MARTIN V.
CITY OF BOYS THE U. S. COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
HELD THAT GOVERNMENTS CANNOT
COMPLY SLEEPING OUTDOORS ON
PUBLIC PROPERTY. IF THERE IS NO
REAL OPTION FOR SLEEPING
INDOORS. ADMITTED UNDER. NEED
FOR TRANSITIONAL TERM HOUSING
CENTER. COUNTY CITIES AND THE
COUNTY OFTEN DO NOT HAVE SUCH A
SPACE TO OFFER. VALUE WATER HAS
VERY LIMITED AUTHORITY TO EXPAND
ITS REVENUE OUTSIDE OF PURPOSES
LIST IN THE DISTRICT ACT.
LEADING SOME HUMAN HEALTH AND
SAFETY RISKS ON THEIR LANDS
UNADDRESSED. AB FORTY SIXTY NINE
WILL PROVIDE VALUE WATER WITH
THE FLEXIBILITY NEEDED. TO
DIRECT RESOURCES TO ASSIST I
SHELTER PEOPLE ON THEIR LANDS.
AND HUMANELY ADDRESS A CRISIS
THAT CAN NO LONGER BE IGNORED.
BUT BEEN REVISED PORTING
TESTIMONY. ARE BUYER BROOM.
OFFICER FOR STATE GOVERNMENT
RELATIONS FOR THE DISTRICT BUT
FIRST. OF OUR PERFORMANCE TEAM
COLLEAGUES TO SENATOR JIM BELL
WHO SERVES ON VALLEY WATERS
BORDER. DIRECTORS WELCOME CENTER
THANK YOU SACRAMENTO REMEMBER.
OF THE YOU FOR YOUR WELCOME I
SIR NOW A NUMBER. OF THE CENTER
VALLEY TO WHICH SEVEN PEOPLE.
ARE COLLEAGUES THAT REPRESENTS
SANTA CLARA COUNTY- WE HAVE.
TWENTY THREE HUNDRED PEOPLE
HOMELESS AND- THE LIVING IN THE
CREEKS IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY NO
I DON'T LIKE WHAT WE HAVE HERE
IN SACRAMENTO AND LOS ANGELES
AND- SOME OTHER COUNTIES- PEOPLE
NATURALLY TAKE REFUGE. ALONG THE
CREEKS AND STREAMS AND WERE OWN
WE OWN IT HUNDREDS OF MILES OF
CREEKSIDE PUBLIC LANDS. AND WE
HAVE THE RESPONSIBILITY TO DO
MORE THAN JUST A- ASSIST PEOPLE
LIVING AND SOMETIMES ACTUALLY.
DYING OR CREEK. SIX OUR CREEKS
ARE FLAT AND MEANING THE FLOODS
COME. AND FACT INTO SEVEN WE
HAVE FLOOD THAT FLOODED DOWN
SEVENTEENTH HOME. IT CENTER
COURT COUNT AND SANTA- THE L.
WATER- HI DAHLE. IN THEY'RE
DOING THE DEBATE THE BEST A
PREDICT MODERN NAY- WHEN THE
WATERS WILL COME. BUT- WE THAT
THE DANGER IS FOR THE- PEOPLE
THEY- AND THAT'S OUR PRIMARY
CONCERN. BUT THIS IS NOT ENOUGH
WE HAVE TO HAVE A LAW CHANGE
WITH OUR DISTRICT OUT- TO CHANGE
THE LAW TO HELP THE UNSHELTERED
PEOPLE AND HAVE THEM SAFELY
RELOCATED AWAY FROM OUR CREEKS
WE BELIEVE THIS LAW THAT WE
PROPOSE WILL ACTUALLY DO THAT-
YOU'RE THE FISCAL COMMITTEE SO
FISCALLY WELL WE JUST APPROVED A
BUDGET- LAST YEAR WE SPENT
TWENTY. TWO POINT FOUR MILLION
DOLLARS CLEANING UP HOMELESS
ENCAMPMENTS IN THE CREEKS- WE
HAD- NUMEROUS FIRES IN THE
CREEKS WERE WERE OUR PROPERTY
WAS BURNT FACT WE HAD A- A
RECENT SETTLEMENT WITH THE
INDIVIDUAL WERE THE NEIGHBORING
HOUSE WAS BURNED DOWN. DUE TO A
FIRE IN THE CREEK OF ALL THESE
VERY DANGEROUS SITUATIONS EXERTS
. SO WE NEED THIS BILL PASSED
ACTUALLY NOT WAIT TO THE PROBLEM
OCCURS BUT TO BE MORE PROACTIVE
IN MOVING PEOPLE. AND WE THINK
IT WILL GIVE US THE FLEXIBILITY
TO DO THAT AND WE'RE JULY VOTING
FROM THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF
THE VALLEY WATER DISTRICT THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. BERMAN
CHAIR MEMBERS BOARD ROOM ALSO
WITH VALLEY WATER. DUE TO
CONSTRAINTS ON OUR REVENUE
SOURCES IN MOST CIRCUMSTANCES
THE ONLY ASSISTANCE THE VALLEY
WATER CAN PROVIDE UNSHELTERED
PEOPLE IS TO CLEAN UP THE TRASH
AND OTHER WASTE IMPACTING THE
WATER QUALITY IN OUR STREAMS-
EIGHTY FOURTEEN SIXTY NINE WILL.
ENABLE US TO FULFILL OUR ETHICAL
RESPONSIBILITY TO DO MORE I'M
HERE TO HELP ANSWER QUESTIONS
AND I AM SURE I VOTE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH IS THERE ANYBODY IN
ROOM TO TWO HIGH THAT WOULD LIKE
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. I THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR JEAN HURST HERE TO
BE HALF OF THE SANTA CLARA
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
ANYONE ELSE. IS THERE ANYONE
HERE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION LIKE
TO INVITE YOU TO COME FORWARD.
THING NO ONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MODERATOR
IF YOU COULD QUEUE UP
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY EITHER IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION OF. AB FOURTEEN SIXTY
NINE. FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
FOR AB FOURTEEN SIXTY NINE PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE
KEYPAD. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
NINETEEN YEAH I DON'T THINK GARY
CITY COUNCIL MEMBER IN SUPPORT.
WELL GO TO LINE. SEVENTEEN THANK
YOU YOUR MEMBERS MY NAME IS NOEL
WHITLEY SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF
THE MISSION AND THE REGIONAL
OPEN SPACE DISTRICT WE ARE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. MADAM
CHAIR WE HAVE NOT PUT A
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH WILL BRING IT TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS. CENTER LIKE TO MOVE
THE BILL- THAT WOULD BE GREAT
BUT WE NEED AT QUORUM SO WE'LL
WAIT FOR A COUPLE MORE MEMBERS
AND THEN WILL ALLOW YOU TO DO
THAT AND I KNOW SOMEONE IT THANK
ALSO A- FORMER COLLEAGUE SENATOR
BILL FOR A- BI NEAR AND-
APPRECIATE. THAT YOU TAKE A
PROACTIVE APPROACH AND WANTING
TO DO MORE- WHEREAS MOST PEOPLE
ARE BARELY TRYING TO DO THE
MINIMUM AND YOU'RE TRYING TO DO
MORE SO THANK YOU. I ABSOLUTELY
AGREE WITH THAT- ASSEMBLY MEMBER
YOU MAY CONCLUDE. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR I THINK AS WAS THE
CASE WAS CENTER BELL WASN'T
LEGISLATURE HAS ALWAYS PUSHED US
WITH HIS HEART LEADING FIRST.
ARE THE FIRST THINGS HE DID AS
HE JOINED THE OF THE VALLEY
WATER DISTRICT BOARD IS REACH
OUT TO US IS THAT WE NEED TO DO
SOMETHING ABOUT THE IN HOUSE A
MOVE THAT ARE ABOUT A WATER
PROPERTY- AND SO IT'S NO
SURPRISE THAT WE SEE ON HERE
TODAY CONTINUING. THAT FIGHT FOR
THOSE THAT NEED HELP THE MOST
WITHOUT RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NEIGHBORHOOD APPROPRIATE TIME
VERY GOOD. WE'LL TAKE IT ONCE
ONCE WE GET A QUORUM. THANK YOU
MUCH FOR BEING HERE SENATE
BALLOTS GRAY TO SEE YOU. MOVING
ON TO OUR AGENDA WILL BE- TAKE
UP FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO AB NINE
THIRTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
CONNELLY. WELCOME
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS. IN 202263% OF
CALIFORNIA VOTERS VIA
PROPOSITION THIRTY ONE. ARE HELD
THE STATE LAW SB SEVEN NINETY
THREE. PROHIBITING TOBACCO
RETAILERS FROM SELLING MOST
FLAVORED TOBACCO PRODUCTS. SB
SEVEN NINETY THREE WAS
GROUNDBREAKING AND COVERS
FLAVORED E. CIGARETTES MENTHOL
CIGARETTES AND TOBACCO FRAUGHT
PRODUCTS FLAVOR ENHANCERS. IN
RETAIL LOCATIONS INCLUDING
STORES AND VENDING MACHINES
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. DESPITE THE
OVERWHELMING SUPPORT FROM VOTERS
TO RATIFY SB SEVEN NINETY THREE.
FLAVORED TOBACCO PRODUCTS
CONTINUE TO BE SOLD IN MANY
STORES ACROSS THE STATE. WHICH
ALLOWS MANY TEENAGERS TO
CONTINUE ACCESSING THESE
DANGEROUS PRODUCTS. AB NINE
THIRTY FIVE WILL EXPLICITLY
AUTHORIZE THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO ENFORCE
THE FLAVORED TOBACCO BAN
PURSUANT TO BUSINESS AND
PROFESSIONS CODE SECTION TWO TWO
NINE FIVE ZERO POINT FIVE ALSO
KNOWN AS THE STOP TOBACCO ACCESS
TO KIDS ACT OR ST ACT.
CONSISTENT WITH OTHER TOBACCO
ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS. EIGHTY NINE
THIRTY FIVE WILL ALSO REPLACE
THE SUBDIVISION FROM THE HEALTH
AND SAFETY CODE WHICH MAKES
VIOLATION OF S. B. NINETY SEVEN
NINETY THREE A MISDEMEANOR AND
CRIMINAL PENALTIES. INSTEAD
PURSUANT TO THE STATE ACT IT
WILL BECOME A CIVIL PENALTY TO
RETAILERS THEIR AGENTS FOR THEIR
EMPLOYEES WHO WHO ARE IN
VIOLATION. THE COST OF
IMPLEMENTATION WILL BE MINOR
ESPECIALLY WHEN COMPARED TO THE
COST OF HEALTH CARE FOR THOSE
WITH SMOKING RELATED ILLNESSES.
ANY IN THE NEXT GENERATION OF
CALIFORNIANS FROM BECOMING
ADDICTED TO SMOKING SHOULD BE A
PRIORITY AND I KNOW IT IS FOR
ALL OF US WHO CARE ABOUT THE
PUBLIC HEALTH. OF OUR STATE AND
THE WELL BEING OF OUR CHILDREN.
SB NET SEVEN NINETY THREE CAN
HELP TO ACHIEVE THIS GOAL BUT
ONLY IF THE LAWS PROPERLY
ENFORCED. AND EIGHTY NINE THIRTY
FIVE WILL MAKE ITS SPLIT SAID
ENFORCEMENT BY CDPH AND THE AG
IN ADDITION TO LOCAL AGENCIES TO
ENSURE COMPLIANCE AND PROTECTION
OF PUBLIC HEALTH. WHEN I PASS IT
ON TWITTER- PERMISSION TO OUR
MAIN WITNESSES OKAY SIR BRUCE
DIRECTOR OF ADVOCACY FOR THE
AMERICAN LUNG ASSOCIATION.
FOLLOWED BY DR JOHN MOM HE
SERVED AS A TWENTY EIGHTEEN
PRESIDENT OF THE SAN FRANCISCO.
MARIN MEDICAL SOCIETY. GOOD WHAT
THE TO THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU.
THE MORNING MADAM CHAIR SENATE
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS QI
SYBARIS AND I AND ADVOCACY- FOR
THE AMERICAN LUNG ASSOCIATION. I
WANT TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER
CONNELLY FOR BRINGING THIS BILL
FORWARD THIS INTERNET THIS IS AN
IMPORTANT STEP IN FULFILLING THE
PROMISE AND SB SEVEN NINETY
THREE TO ELIMINATE THE SALE OF
FLAVORED TOBACCO PRODUCTS. AS
MOST OF YOU KNOW THIS BILL WAS
PASSED IN TWENTY TWENTY AND
AFFIRMED BY VOTERS IN TWENTY
TWENTY TWO. THE REASON FOR THE
DELAY IS THAT TOBACCO COMPANIES
SPENT OVER TWENTY MILLION TO
QUALIFY A REFERENDUM TO BUY
TIME. TO SELL MORE THAN A
BILLION DOLLARS WORTH OF
FLAVORED TOBACCO PRODUCTS UNTIL
THE ELECTION. EIGHTY NINE THIRTY
FIVE WILL LINE STATE ENFORCEMENT
OF CALIFORNIA'S FLAVORED TOBACCO
LAW AND EXISTING STATE LAW. THAT
PREVENTS YOUTH ACCESS TO TOBACCO
PRODUCTS. IN ADDITION IT MAKES
SENSE TO BRING ENFORCEMENT OF
ALL USED TOBACCO LAWS UNDER THE
SAME UMBRELLA. THE TOBACCO
COMPANIES HAVE BEEN DOING
EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO EVADE THE
NEW LAW IN ORDER TO KEEP SELLING
KID FRIENDLY TOBACCO PRODUCTS.
FROM BLATANTLY DISOBEYING THE
LAW BY REAP REFUSING TO STOP
SELLING CANDY FLAVORED VAPING
PRODUCTS. TO INTRODUCING NEW
MENTHOL LIKE CIGARETTES DESIGNED
TO KEEP CUSTOMERS WHO ARE USED
TO NINETEENTH MENTHOL FLAVORED
HUH. THE TOBACCO COMPANIES ARE
STILL UP TO THEIR OLD TRICKS.
THEY HAVE SHOWN TIME AND TIME
AGAIN THAT THEY WILL SAY
ANYTHING DO ANYTHING AND SPEND
ANYTHING. TO KEEP ATTRACTING
USED TO THEIR DEADLY PRODUCTS.
WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE
VOTE. TODAY AND THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME. THE VERY MUCH. GOOD
MORNING CARE CAMARO AND MEMBERS
MY NAME IS MÀ IT'S AN HONOR TO
SHARE PERSPECTIVE OF THE SAN.
MARIE MEDICAL SO. WE IS INDOORS
EIGHTY NINE THIRTY FIVE. SMOKING
IS REALLY CAUSE OF FROM AMERICAN
CLAIMING LIVES AND COULD DETER
THE PAST YEARS THE COST TO
CALIFORNIA APPROXIMATELY TWENTY
FOUR BILLION DOLLARS EACH YEAR.
THE MEDICAL SOCIETY WAS PROUD TO
HELP DEFEND MAYOR AT LEAST FINAL
HEALTH PUBLIC HEALTH LEGACY THE
TWENTY SEVENTEEN FLAVORED
TOBACCO ORDINANCE. WHICH WAS
CHALLENGED BY TWIN REFERENDUMS
IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY
NINETEEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CONNELLY HAD THE VISION TO
EXTEND MERRILEES. LEGISLATION
INTO MARIN COUNTY AND TO
STRENGTHEN THE ENFORCEMENT NOW
OF SEVEN NINETY THREE TO
RESTRICT THE SALES OF MENTHOL
CIGARETTES AND FLAVORED LIQUIDS.
I LIKE TO THINK CHAIR CABALLERO
MEMBERS DRAW SO GLAZER SKINNER
AND WIENER FOR BEING CO AUTHORS
OF SEVEN NINETY THREE. AND ALSO
TO SENATOR DOLLY WHO JOINED IN
VOTING HIGH FOR SENATE NINE
SENATE BILL SEVEN NINETY THREE
ON THE SENATE FLOOR. ON AUGUST
TWENTY EIGHTH TWENTY TWENTY. WAS
SIGNED INTO LAW THE SAME DAY BY
GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM THAT WAS
ONE THOUSAND FORTY DAYS AGO.
WE'RE HERE NOW EIGHTY NINE
THIRTY FIVE BECAME NECESSARY
AFTER THE REPEATED LITIGATION
REFERENDUM AND CONFUSION THAT
WAS CREATED BY THE TOBACCO
INDUSTRY. THAT HAVE DELAYED THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEVEN NINETY
THREE. THREE DAYS AFTER GOVERNOR
NEWSOM SIGNED THE LAW. THE
INDUSTRY FILE FOR A REFERENDUM
THAT BOUGHT THEM TWO EXTRA YEARS
TO SELL. NEARLY EIGHT THIRTY
MILLION DOLLARS IN MENTHOL
CIGARETTES AND FLAVORED PRODUCTS
WILL COSTING OUR STATE HUNDREDS
OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN
TOBACCO RELATED HEALTH CARE
COSTS. THE DAY AFTER THE
ELECTION DAY WHEN THEY WERE
DEFEATED THEY FILED A FEDERAL
LAWSUIT AGAINST. SEVEN NINETY
THREE. AND AFTER THAT FAILED THE
APPEAL TO THE UNITED STATES
SUPREME COURT WHO REFUSED TO
HEAR THEIR PETITION. ANOTHER
STRATEGY TO THWART SEVEN NINETY
THREE AND LOCAL ORDINANCES HAS
BEEN TO INTRODUCE NEW PRODUCTS.
FIRST CAME SYNTHETIC NICOTINE.
SYNTHESIZED IN THE LABORATORY TO
EVADE FDA REGULATION. CONGRESS
STEPPED IN AND ENDED SALES OF
THESE LEGAL PRODUCTS. THEN RJ
REYNOLDS LAUNCHED ITS CALIFORNIA
COMPLIANT NON MENTHOL
CIGARETTES. WE READ THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL RECENTLY SENT THEM A
REQUEST TO STOP SALES OF THE
CIGARETTES. THE INDUSTRY
RESPONDED BY SUING THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA TO BE ABLE TO
CONTINUE TO SELL THESE PRODUCTS.
AB NINE THIRTY FIVE WILL EMPOWER
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL THE
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH WITH
THE TOOLS TO EDUCATE RETAILERS
AND BRING AN END TO THE SALES OF
THESE ILLICIT FLAVORED TOBACCO
PRODUCTS. I URGE THE COMMITTEE
TO VOTE ON IT FOR AB THREE NINE
THIRTY FIVE TODAY. THANK YOU.
FOR MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TEST IN OF
THE AND RE. TWENTY TWO HUNDRED.
GOOD MORNING MARK AND I'M BEHALF
OF AMERICAN ASSOC. IN STRONG
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. IS THIS
FULLER ON BEHALF OF- RING
CALIBERS. FORTY MORE CHAIRMAN
JIM MICHAEL PASSED CALIFORNIA
STRONG TO I FELT. THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT. IS THERE
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION ROOM.
TWENTY TWO HUNDRED. THE MANAGER
INTO MEMBERS JOHN WHEN YOU'RE
ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA FUELS AND
CONVENIENCE ALLIANCE WE DO HAVE
AN OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED
POSITION ON THE BILL RIGHT NOW
BUT WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR. A CONTINUING
DISCUSSIONS WITH US WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT. OUR STATION
OWNERS ARE AWARE OF WHAT'S BEEN
AND WHAT'S NOT- PRIOR TO BEING.
FINED WITHOUT SOME SIGNIFICANT
COMPLIANCE ISSUES- AT THE LOCAL
LEVEL A LOT OF INCONSISTENCY ON
HOW THINGS ARE ENFORCED- WE'VE
EVEN HAD SOME. STATION OWNERS
GET THEIR TOBACCO LICENSES
REVOKED FOR UP TO A MONTH- FOR
SELLING A PRODUCT THAT THEY
DIDN'T KNOW IT WAS. WAS BANNED-
WE'RE NOT EVEN BEING TOLD WHAT
IS BANNED- AND SO I JUST WANT A
LITTLE BIT OF CLARITY THERE SO
WE'VE HAD SOME GOOD
CONVERSATIONS AND LOOK FORWARD
TO CONTINUING THIS THANK YOU FOR
GOOD. IS ANYONE ELSE WHO LIKE TO
FRIEND UP. THING THEN WE'LL MOVE
ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE
AND- MODERATOR IF YOU COULD
QUEUE UP THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OR IN OPPOSITION PLEASE. FOR
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION FOR EIGHTY
NINE THIRTY FIVE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO AT THIS MOMENT. WE WILL GO
TO LINE TWELVE. THAT ARE GOING
TO HELP US THIRD TO FIFTY SURE
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. THANK YOU
. WHEN I GO TO LINE. TWENTY
THREE. GOOD MORNING KAREN
MEMBERS JUSTIN RANDALL THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. AND WITH
THAT MANAGER WE HAVE NO FOR
THEIR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION VERY
GOOD WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS COMMENTS
OR CONCERNS. I APPRECIATE THAT
THE RECITATION OF WHAT'S
HAPPENED IN THE INTERIM BECAUSE
YOU LOSE TRACK OF WHAT'S GOING
ON AND- VERY VERY IMPORTANT SO I
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
BILL FORWARD AND ALLOW YOU TO
CONCLUDE AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR AND APPRECIATE THE
BROAD COALITION WE BROUGHT
TOGETHER ON THIS FAILED TO WORK-
PRIOR LEGISLATIVE EFFORTS TO GET
US TO THIS POINT. THAT AS WAS
DOING NOTED AFTER IT'S OVER A
THOUSAND DAYS THAT THIS LAW HAS
BEEN OR THIS- EFFORT HAS BEEN IN
EXISTENCE. IT'S TIME TO- REALLY
STEP UP ENFORCEMENT THAT'S WHAT
THIS LAWS WHAT ARE THIS PROPOSAL
IS ALL ABOUT I RESPECTFULLY FOR
AND I HAVE A- VERY GOOD WE WILL
TAKE THIS UP ON WE HAVE A
QUORUM. THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR
YOUR PRESENTATION HERE TODAY. WE
WILL TO FILE NUMBER THREE IS
MEMBER TEAM. AB NINE SEVENTY
SIX. WELCOME THANK YOU THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR. SO EIGHTY NINE
SEVENTY SIX- HE'S GOING TO
CONTINUE TO HELP US BUILD MORE
HOUSING IN. CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY
EIGHTY USE ARE SUPPOSED TO
ESTABLISH OWNER OCCUPANCY AS OF
JANUARY FIRST. TWENTY TWENTY
FIVE A. B. NINE SEVEN SIX WOULD
REMOVE THE OWNER OCCUPANCY
PROVISION FOR ME TO USE. SO THAT
THEY CAN REMAIN. EIGHTY USE CAN
CONTINUE TO. BE BUILT BY PEOPLE
WHO ARE OWNER OCCUPIED OR ALSO
FOLKS WHO OWNED THE PROPERTY FOR
RENTAL PURPOSES RESPECT FAST
FIVE OUT ON A. B. NINE SEVEN SIX
WE HAVE JORDAN CARVE A HOLE
FROM. CALIFORNIA BE. WELCOME
GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE MY
NAME IS YET ANOTHER KIND OF A
HARD LESSON ADVOCATE FOR
CALIFORNIA BE A POSSIBLE ANSWER
HERE. BECAUSE SUPPORT OF AB NINE
SEVEN SIX. IN CALIFORNIA THE
STATEWIDE ORGANIZATION OF OVER
EIGHTY THOUSAND NEIGHBORS
DEDICATE TO MAKING CALIFORNIA
FOR OF A PLACE TO LIVE WORK AND
RAISE A FAMILY FOR ALL
CALIFORNIANS. AS THE NAME
SUGGESTS THAT ESPECIALLY JEWEL
UNITS EIGHTY OUR HOMES ARE BILL
AS A SEPARATE TO THE MAIN
DWELLING MODESTLY TO MODESTLY
INCREASE OUR STATE'S HOUSING
SUPPLY. IS REMOVING LOCAL
BARRIERS TO EIGHTY USED THEIR
CONSTRUCTION HAS GROWN RETURN IT
RESULTING IN THOUSANDS OF NEW
AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOMES ACROSS
CALIFORNIA. OVER THE PAST THREE
YEARS EIGHTY YEARS HAVE PROVIDED
ALMOST TEN THOUSAND NEW I'M
SUBSIDIZED AFFORDABLE HOMES TO
CALIFORNIA'S RIGHT TO SUPPLY
INCLUDING MORE THAN FOUR
THOUSAND AFFORDABLE FOR LOW
INCOME FAMILIES. IN ADDITION TO
POSTING A HOUSING SUPPLIES
EIGHTY USE CREE ADDITION HOME
VALUE IN FINANCIAL SECURITY FOR
CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNERS MOST
EIGHTY YEARS ARE BUILT BY
HOMEOWNER TO PROVIDE HOUSING FOR
FRIENDS OR FAMILY. GENERATE
RENTAL INCOME TO OFFSET THE
MORTGAGE BOTH GROW THEIR HOME
EQUITY EIGHTY NINE SEVEN SIX
PRESERVES THE ABILITY OF
PROPERTY OWNERS TO PROVIDE LOW
COST RENTAL EIGHTY USED BY
PARMALEE EXTENDING TEXAS
SUPERVISION ON LOCAL OCCUPANCY.
REQUIREMENTS REQUIREMENTS EIGHTY
YEARS OR PROVEN TO A- BECAUSE-
HOUSING SHORT IN WHICH DO ALL
CAN TO THERE CAN. SIX IT'S FOR
THIS ALWAYS REQUEST FOR SOME FOR
A BI SEVEN. THANK YOU. THINK
VERY. ANYONE ELSE IN. HI I'M
MIKE SNYDER ON BEHALF OF META IN
SUPPORT. VERY GOOD. ANYONE ELSE
IN SUPPORT. IS THERE ANYBODY
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION. IN OPPOSITION. THING
THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MODERATOR
IF YOU COULD QUEUE UP
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
DISTRICT EITHER IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION OF AB NINE SEVENTY
SIX. FOR SUPPORT OPPOSITION
EIGHTY NINE SEVENTY SIX PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS MOMENT. IF
WE'LL GO TO LINE EIGHT. MICHAEL
AND WHISPERED IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
HEY MAN I'M SURE WE HAVE NO
FURTHER SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. IT
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
YOU'RE YOU'RE LUCKY THERE'S A
THERE'S ONLY THREE OF US SO
YOU'RE NOT A LOT OF QUESTIONS
BEING ASKED TODAY IT LOOKS LIKE
THERE'S THERE ARE NO QUESTIONS
SO ASSEMBLY WHEN WE WILL LIKE TO
CONCLUDE THANK YOU JUST RESPECT
REYES FIVE VOTE AND THE LIKE TO
MOVE ON TO AB TEN THIRTY THREE
THAT'S OKAY. ABSOLUTELY WILL
TAKE IT UP WE HAVE A- GRAHAM
THANK YOU. AB TEN THIRTY TH
APPROVED PRO ON SEPARATELY
CONVEYING EIGHTY YEARS AND
ALLOWING EIGHTY USED TO BE SOLD
AS CONDOS IF A LOCAL THE
GOVERNMENT DECIDES TO ALLOW.
EIGHTY UCONN TO CONVERSION SO A
LOCAL GOVERNMENT WOULD HAVE TO
OPT INTO THIS PROVISION WERE NOT
MET WITH AND THIS IS NOT A
MANDATE. THIS IS JUST AN OPTION
FOR THE PROPERTY OWNER- THIS
WOULD CONTINUE TO CREATE MORE
HOME OWNERSHIP OPPORTUNITIES. WE
REALLY. APPRECIATE ALL THE
CONCERNS OF THE LENDERS AND THE
REALTORS HAVE BROUGHT UP THROUGH
THIS PROCESS WE BELIEVE WE'VE-
TAKEN AMENDMENTS TO SATISFY
THEIR CONCERNS WERE ALSO.
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
COMMUNITY MANAGERS AND- BELIEVE
WE'RE ON TRACK TO SATISFY THEIR
CONCERNS AS WELL- WE ALSO
FURTHER CLARIFIED THAT ANY.
PROPERTY OR WOULD NEED TO
SATISFY ALL LIENS ON THE
PROPERTY OR RECEIVE CONSENT FROM
THE LIEN HOLDERS PRIOR. TO CONDO
MAPPING AND AGAIN THIS IS VERY
SIMILAR. TO ANYONE WHO DOES A
CONDOMINIUM CONVERSION FROM A
DUPLEX OR FOR PLAQUES. THAT THE
LAWS ARE CONSISTENT WITH THIS
APPROACH. THE WASHINGTON OREGON
TEXAS ALREADY ALLOW THIS
PRACTICE TO OCCUR. THIS BILL
WOULD HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO
CONTINUE TO UNLOCK MORE HOME
OWNERSHIP OPPORTUNITIES. I
BELIEVE WE HAVE ALEX TORRES FROM
BEAR COUNCIL. AS WELL AS- MARC
NEUBERGER FROM CALIFORNIA. STATE
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES. VERY
GOOD. WELCOME GOOD MORNING NOT
INTERNET ALEX FORRESTER OF STATE
GOVERNMENT RELAY. FOR THE AREA
COUNCIL WE- THREE HUNDRED THIRTY
AND- IN THE NINE COUNTY BAY AREA
WE ARE PROUD. SPONSOR HERE OF AB
TEN THIRTY THREE. EXCITED TO
CONTINUE OUR WORK ON IMPROVING
EIGHTY LEGISLATION WHICH WE
BEGAN TWENTY SEVENTEEN. SINCE
ONE TWENTY SEVENTEEN AS- MR TANG
REFERENCED- ISSUES HAVE BEEN A
TREMENDOUS SUCCESS- PRODUCTION
INCREASED LOCALLY FROM SIX
HUNDRED EIGHTY USED TO ABOUT
TWENTY THOUSAND. PER YEAR AS A
RESULT OF STATE LEGISLATION THAT
YOU ALL HAVE WORKED ON AND VOTED
FOR SO WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
SUPPORT OF EIGHTY USE AS A TOOL
OF. INCREASING COURAGE IN
HOUSING PRODUCTION. COURT IN THE
UC BERKELEY TURNER CENTER
EIGHTIES TYPICALLY RENT FOR AN
AMOUNT THAT IS AFFORDABLE TO LOW
INCOME THIS MEANS ISSUES ARE
STEADY PIPELINE OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING THAT REQUIRES NO
SUBSIDY. MISTER CHANG MENTIONED-
THE IMPACT IN OTHER STATES AB
TEN THIRTY THREE CONTINUES THIS
WORK BY CREATING A PATHWAY FOR
AFFORDABLE HOME OWNERSHIP.
OWNERSHIP OPTIONS BUILDING ON
THE SUCCESS OF EIGHTY RENTALS
WHICH HAVE BEEN THE EXCLUSIVE
OPTION UNTIL NOW BECAUSE OF THE
STATE BAN ON SEPARATELY CONVEYED
. OR SELLING AND EIGHTY YOU.
THINK AROUND THE COUNTRY- THAT
ALLOW FOR SALE. EIGHTY USE SUCH
AS PORTLAND SEO ALSO AND PRINT
THESE EIGHT YOURSELF BETWEEN
THIRTY AND 60% LESS. THAN
COMMENSURATE HOMES IN THE SAME
MARKET GIVING MIDDLE CLASS
PEOPLE A CRITICAL FIRST STEP
INTO THE LATTER OF HOME
OWNERSHIP. ONE SUCH ISSUE NOTED
IN THE ANALYSIS WAS A CONCERN
THAT LENDERS WOULD NOT BE ABLE
TO SELL EIGHTY YOU CONDO
MORTGAGES ON THE SECONDARY
MARKET IMPORTANT PART OF THE
HOME ANY BUSINESS BUT THE
FEDERAL HOUSING. FINANCE
ADMINISTRATION HAS REVIEWED THE
BILL AND SAID THAT THEY DON'T
HAVE CONCERNS WITH IT AT THIS
TIME. IS WORTH NOTING THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT CURRENTLY
BUYS EIGHTY YOU CONDO LOANS ON
THE SECONDARY MARKET FROM OTHER
STATES. ANOTHER KEY POINT IS THE
BILL ONLY PERMITS IF YOU CONDOS
NOT WHAT'S WHAT'S SO THESE MANY
CONDO ASSOCIATIONS WOULD FORM
RULES ABOUT SHOULD UTILITIES
ACCESS AND OTHER ISSUES ARISING
FROM SHARING A PARCEL. UNDER THE
EXISTING LAWS REGULATING THOSE
AGREEMENTS IN SOME THIS BILL
CREATES A UNIQUE AND STRATEGIC
PATHWAY TO AFFORDABLE HOME
OWNERSHIP OPTIONS. THANK YOU MR
TANG FOR YOUR AUTHORSHIP
LEADERSHIP ON THE EIGHTY YOU
ISSUE WE ARE PLEASED TO URGE
YOUR SUPPORT HERE FOR IT TODAY
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
GOOD MORNING HOW MARK NEARER
THE- CALIFORNIA STATE
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES WANT TO
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IN THE
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR ALL THEIR
HARD WORK ON THIS BILL. SIX
EXPORTS AB TEN THIRTY THREE IS
THAT HELPS AS A WILL HELP
ADDRESS THE STATE'S HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS. WHICH IS A
COMPONENT OF THE STATE'S
HOMELESSNESS CRISIS. RECOGNIZE
THE NEED FOR MORE THOUGHTFUL
APPROACH TO ADDRESS THE STATE'S
WOMEN'S. THE STOCK HAS ENGAGE IN
DEVELOPING AT HOME PLAN TO
ADDRESS THE VARIOUS THERE IS
VARIOUS INDICATORS ARE
CHALLENGES THAT YOU ARE. DRIVING
STATE HOME SINCE CRISIS. AB
TENDER DISEASE REMOVAL- THE
STATE'S PROHIBITION ON CERTAINLY
CONTAIN EIGHTY USE WILL HELP TO
INCREASE THE AVAILABILITY HOMES
AT PRICES. AFFORDABLE THE
STATE'S WORKING FAMILIES AND
INDIVIDUALS THIS BILL ALIGNS
WITH THE SEX EFFORTS TO INCREASE
HOUSING SUPPLY FOR ALL
CALIFORNIANS ESPECIALLY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO SUPPORT
THE STATE'S FORMER POPULATIONS
INCLUDING SENIORS THOSE WITH
DISABILITIES. AND LOW INCOME
RESIDENTS. THANK YOU. VERY MUCH.
IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE THAT WOULD
. LIKE TO TEST FOR IN SUPPORT.
FIVE MAKES NO ON BEHALF OF MATT
AND SUPPORT. MUCH. BRYCE HAVE ON
BEHALF OF SPUR AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYBODY
ELSE IN SUPPORT. MOVE ON TO
OPPOSITION IS OR ANYBODY THAT
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION. AND I'M SURE MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE LOUIS BROWN
HERE TODAY ON BEHALF THE
COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE ACTION
COMMITTEE- AS MR KING SAID WE
HAVE BEEN IN ACTIVE
CONVERSATIONS WITH HIM IN A
STAFF- JUST IS THE BILL IS AN-
OPT IN FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
IT'S ALSO AN OPT IN FOR
COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS. AND SO
WE BELIEVE THAT THERE SHOULD BE
LANGUAGE OF PROVIDING NOTICE TO.
SEPARATE INTEREST OWNER OF A
COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION WITH AN
EIGHTY YOU THAT BEFORE THAT'S
CONVEYED. THE POTENTIAL
PURCHASER OF THAT AID YOU NEEDS
TO HAVE THE WRITTEN
AUTHORIZATION FROM THE
ASSOCIATION TO ALLOW THAT TO
HAPPEN. A LOT OF INTERESTING
ISSUES CAN COME UP WITH CREATING
A CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION WITH
ANY MASTER ASSOCIATION AND HOW
YOU DEAL WITH VOTING RIGHTS
ASSESSMENTS UTILITIES ALL OF
THAT NEEDS TO BE WORKED OUT ON
THE FRONT END AND SO WITH THE B.
AND OFTEN WE- TOTALLY APPRECIATE
THAT BUT BELIEVE THAT THAT
NOTICE SHOULD BE UP FRONT. FOR
THE IT REALLY AVOID ANY
CONFRONTATION GOING FORWARD AND
THAT THE OWNER POTENTIAL OWNER
OF THAT AID YOU KNOWS THE STEPS
THEY SHOULD GO THROUGH. PRIOR TO
ACTUALLY PURCHASING THAT EDIE
YOU SO WE HOPE TO GET TO A
RESOLUTION HERE REAL SOON HI AND
APPRECIATE THE WORK OF THE
AUTHOR AND- AND SPONSORS THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANYONE
ELSE IN OPPOSITION. SEEING NO
ONE WILL KNOW ON TO THE TELECOM
LINE IF YOU COULD KI¾M
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY EITHER IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION THAT WOULD BE
TERRIFIC. PERSIPURA OPPOSITION
AB TEN THIRTY THREE PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
TWENTY FIVE. MADAM CHAIR.
MEMBERS THIS IS BOB NAY LITERACY
DURING CELL IN A COUPLE THAT
HOWARD AHMANSON JR. IN ORANGE
FOR. IN STRONG. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. THE MANAGER WE HAVE NO FOR
THE SUPPORTER. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS COMMENTS
AND CONCERNS THANK YOU CENTER
DRIVE. THANK YOU- JUST A COUPLE
OF QUESTIONS TO THE AUTHOR AND
I- I SUPPORT OF WHAT YOU'RE
DOING- JUST A QUICK RESPONSE TO
THE OPPOSITION IS THAT SOMETHING
THAT YOU ALL. REALLY BELIEVE OUR
IT'S POSSIBLE BUT I THINK WE
WERE YOUR RESPONSE TO THEIR- I
THEY WERE VERY HOPEFUL WE CAN
REACH AGREEMENT OBVIOUSLY- THERE
ALREADY IT DOES ALREADY EXISTING
LAWS AROUND CONDOMINIUM
CONVERSIONS. OBVIOUSLY BUT WORK
WITH THEM TO MAKE SURE THAT
THEY'RE CONSISTENT- AGAIN
CONDOMINIUM CONVERSIONS OR
SOMETHING THAT ALREADY OCCURRED
IN THE STATE THE FORTY STATE
LAW. SYSTEM THAT WILL CONTINUE
TO COME TO WORK WITH THEM TO
KIND OF CLARIFY WHAT THEY WHAT
THEY NEED. AND SECOND THIS IS A
MUCH MUCH BROADER QUESTION NOT
SPECIFIC TO YOUR BILL BUT SINCE
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT EIGHTY USE
THAT WE HAVE FOR THE LAST THREE
YEARS. IT SEEMS LIKE THAT WAS
GOING TO BE. THIS BIG A FULL- TO
OF BIG PART OF OUR HOUSE PROBLEM
. HOW DO YOU. IS THIS JUST LIKE
ANOTHER WAY TO FIX THE AD YOU
ISSUE AND ALSO HOW DO YOU SEE
THIS. I GUESS MY QUESTION IS.
THE COST OF A BUILDING THEY DO
USE I'VE SEEN HAS. GROWN
ENORMOUSLY. AND SO HOW DO WE HOW
DOES THIS. A PART OF IT IS THE
COST AND I DON'T KNOW IF THE
MORE WE DO AROUND AD USER BRING
ATTENTION TO IT I DON'T KNOW
WHAT IS GOING ON THAT IS
CAUSING. THE PRICE OF EIGHTY
USED TO GO UP SO HOW DOES THIS
FIT INTO FIXING THE ISSUE I
THINK IT'S A GREAT QUESTION SO-
INSTEAD OF THE MORE GLOBAL
QUESTION I'VE ALWAYS THOUGHT
THAT HE TO USE ART PIECE OF THE
PUZZLE. BUT JUST TO BE CLEAR I
DON'T THINK THEY USE THAT TAKE
THE PLACE OF MORE DANCE MULTI
FAMILY HOUSING ESPECIALLY IN
URBAN MORE DENSE AREAS- DO USE
ARE DIFFICULT TO SCALE I MEAN
YOU CAN DO ONE TWO. THREE
SOMETIMES HERE AND THERE- BUT
THEY'RE NOT GONNA TAKE THE PLACE
OF TWO HUNDRED UNIT. IN A MULTI
FAMILY COMPLEX WHETHER YOU'RE
IN. DOWNTOWN LA OR DOWNTOWN SAN
FRANCISCO THAT'S- THOSE ARE SORT
OF TO ME APPLES AND ORANGES WE
DEFINITELY BOTH- I'VE BEEN
WORKING ON THIS ISSUE AND- I AM.
VERY VERY PLEASED AT THE
PROGRESS UNFORTUNATELY. SOME OF
THE ONLY UNITS BEING BUILT IN
THE LAST COUPLE YEARS ARE EIGHTY
YEARS WE HAVEN'T SEEN AS MUCH
PROGRESS. IN MULTI FAMILY OR
EVEN IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING AS WE
WOULD LIKE I THINK WE NEED ALL
OF THE ABOVE. SO THIS IS JUST A
PIECE OF THE PUZZLE. IN TERMS OF
BEING ABLE TO. SELL AT MARKET MY
IT GAS WILL BE. THAT THE BIGGEST
BENEFIT. WILL BE FAMILY MEMBERS
ARE QUITE OFTEN YOU KNOW WE
HEARD OF EIGHTY. THEIR
PROVISIONALLY AS IN LOS- IF YOU
HAVE MULTI JET. FAMILIES I KNOW
- WHAT THE STATE WE HAVE MULTI
CHEN. FAMILY LIVING. EDUS ARE
GREAT OP A LOT OF. YOU HEAR. A
FAMILY. WELL AS AS THE SHE HAD
TO GET OLDER ONE DOWNSIDE
THEY'LL MOVE INTO E. D. SO THAT
THEIR KIDS. AND GRANDKIDS COME
LIVE IN BAKER HOW. I THINK YOU
ARE TO KEEP- PROPERTY RIGHTS IN
THIS LIKE A NICE WAY TO. A
CERTAIN SEPARATE AROUND RIGHTS.
THE THING THAT PEOPLE CAN CAN I
INTO SO. IT JUST ALLOWING MORE
OPTIONS AND I THINK AT A TIME.
THAT WE NEED MORE HOUSING- THE
FLOSS MORE OPTIONS I'M NOT TOO
SURPRISED TO HEAR. THAT YOU
COSTS ARE GOING UP I HAD TO GO
BACK AND LOOK AT THAT AND LOOK
AT THE RESEARCH. ON MY GUESS IS
AT EIGHTY USE BECOME MORE
UBIQUITOUS AND PEOPLE KNOW HOW
TO BUILD THEM- THAT MY HOPE
WOULD BE THAT COSTS WILL COME
DOWN I MEAN YOU'RE HEARING.
ABOUT A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT-
TYPES OF THE TO USE. YOU KNOW
VERY COMMON IN LOS ANGELES YOU
HAVE SEPARATE GARAGES THAT ARE
DETACHED. GARAGES- I THOSE ARE
GREAT. EIGHTY YOU- THAT COMPLETE
LEAD TO TAP. ARE YOU ALSO HEAR
ABOUT- DIFFERENT. DIFFERENT
COMPANIES THAT ARE MAKING FAB
IDEAS OF THE BECAUSE DROP IT.
DROP IT. INTO THE HOPE IS THAT.
CONSUMERS ARE MORE ON. THAT WE
CAN GET HOUSING LIKE YOU SAID.
BILL CHEAPER AND FASTER- AND
AGAIN THIS IS TO ME A PIECE OF
THE PUZZLE WITH DEFINITELY NOT
THE SILVER BULLET WE HAVE A LONG
WAY TO GO TO REALLY. GET TO THE-
TWO MILLION HOMES. SHORTFALL
HAVING SAID THAT. IF THE
RESEARCH HAS ESTIMATED THAT. AS
A TO USE WEB UP THAT WE COULD
POTENTIALLY GET ABOUT BUILT
ABOUT FIFTY THOUSAND BT USE A
YEAR- AS THE INDUSTRY KIND OF
RAMPED UP WHICH IS GREAT. SO
IT'S A PIECE OF THE PUZZLE BUT
DEFINITELY I WOULD NOT I WOULD
NEVER CALTRANS AS THE ULTIMATE
SOLUTION. THANK YOU PRESIDENT
SORRY FOR GOING OFF A LITTLE. IT
IS QUESTIONS- COME INTO CAN.
SENATE MAKE. OR. SO I A LOT OF
THE EIGHTY YOU. ISSUES- LOOKS
GREAT- THEY SAW LIKE THEY'RE
GONNA SOLVE- BUT WE LIKE WHEN MY
COLLEAGUES POINTED OUT- I SEE A
BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHAT WE
IMAGINE IS GOING TO HAPPEN AND
WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENS ON THE
GROUND. ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT A
LOT OF PEOPLE- THAT USE THE
EIGHTY USE FOR THEIR OF THEIR
FAMILY MEMBERS THAT. PROBABLY
CURRENTLY LIVE INSIDE THE MAIN
HOUSE. AND AND SO THEY JUST.
BUILDING NAY DO YOU WHICH ONLY
INCREASES THEIR PROPERTY VALUE-
BECAUSE IN THE FUTURE THEY CAN
USE THAT AS AS A POTENTIAL
SOURCE. OF INCOME. FOR RENTING
IT OUT. BUT THEY'RE NOT GOING TO
RENT IT OUT. BEFORE LOWER
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THAT'S GOING
TO BE ON THEIR PROPERTY. THAT'S
THE PRACTICALITY AND I MEAN IT
SOUNDS LIKE YOU KNOW THEY'RE NOT
BE AND- YEAH A PART OF THE
SOLUTION SO WE'RE WE'RE DANCE TO
FIND AREAS THAT WEREN'T MEANT TO
BE DENSIFIED. AND- IN IN THIS
YEAR THIS PUSH TO. ATTEMPT TO
ACTUALLY HAVE LOTS WHICH I CAN
THINK OF AREAS AND SOME ARE
COMMUNITIES THAT I REPRESENT.
THAT THEY COULD POTENTIALLY DO
THIS. BUT THERE ARE SO MANY
THINGS GO INTO LOT SPLITTING.
CAN GO INTO. YOU KNOW A TRYING
TO. YOU KNOW EVEN LIKE IF A
FAMILY MEMBER THEY'RE NOT GOING
TO. BY THE HAVING A SEPARATE
PIECE OF PROPERTY ON THE
PROPERTY THAT THEIR FAMILY OWNS
IS NOT SOMETHING THAT I THINK
THEY'RE GOING TO BE EXPIRING TO.
SO DO THIS KIND OF OPENS UP A
CAN OF WORMS FOR PEOPLE WHO DO
PARTICIPATE IN OF CITIES AREN'T
ALLOWED TO GIVEN SOME OF THE
OTHER LEGISLATION TO HAVE MORE
OF A SAY IN WHAT'S GOING ON WITH
THESE- AND THEY LOSE THAT LOCAL
CONTROL MORE MORE- WE'RE GOING
TO HAVE A MISH MOSH OF HOUSING-
THAT WE HAVE HAD IN. OTHER
COMMUNITIES THAT I HAVE SERVED
AND- AND THAT TURNS IN TO PUBLIC
SAFETY ISSUES AND THEN ALL OF
THE OTHER THINGS THAT GO WITH.
UNITS IN THE BACK THAT WE DIDN'T
KNOW WERE THERE. AND- SO YOU
KNOW I STRUGGLE WITH THE ANYMORE
PILING ON ANYMORE EIGHTY YOU
BECAUSE IT HASN'T AS A MATED
LOOK AT DIFFERENCE IN OUR
REGION. AND THE REASON IS WE'RE
JUST PUTTING PEOPLE FROM ONE
HOUSE INTO THE HOUSE NEXT DOOR
SO THEY DON'T HAVE TO ACTUALLY
LIVE IN THE HOUSE. SO THE MY
PROBLEM WITH THE EIGHT YOU ISSUE
. AND IT NEEDS TO BE APPROACHED
BUT THE LOWER AGENCIES HAVE TO
HAVE. THEY HAVE TO HAVE A SAY.
IN IN CONTROLLING THIS IN THEIR
COMMUNITIES. BECAUSE IF THEY
DON'T- IT GETS OUT OF CONTROL
AND THEN THEY HAVE A WHOLE
DIFFERENT ISSUE ON OUR HANDS
FROM. THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME-
IMPART THAT ON YEAH I JUST DON'T
LIKE TO YEAH NOT VOTE FOR
SOMETHING. THAT YOU ARE NOT
UNDERSTANDING IT. WILL SO FOR AB
TEN THIRTY THREE IT'S A LOCAL
OFTEN. SO YOUR LOCAL CITIES
WOULD HAVE TO OPT IN SO IT'S
NOT. IT'S NOT AN- OPTION AT THE
LOCAL CITIES DECIDE. COUNTIES
DON'T DECIDE THEY DON'T WANT IT.
THEN THEY DON'T OFTEN. SO IT'S
NOTHING- SOMETHING MANDATORY
THIS IN THIS COMPLETELY
OPTIONAL. THE OTHER PIECE I CAN
ONLY GIVE YOU EXPERIENCE WITH
EIGHTY- IN MY COMMUNITY MY
NEIGHBORS AND I KNOW THIS IS
JUST. AN EXAMPLE IS NOT ONE SIZE
FIT ALL IT'S ALL BUT AGAIN. I
THINK EIGHTY USE ARE SOME OF THE
ONLY HOUSING THAT NEIGHBORHOODS
EXCEPT. ON THE TALK TO YOUR
NEIGHBORS MANY NEIGHBORS WOULD
RATHER HAVE BEEN A- BT USE THAT
HAVE. IN A THIRTY YEAR APART
BUILDING HI UNIPARENTAL DOWN THE
STREET SO I THINK. THAT'S SORT
OF WHY THERE'S BEEN SO MUCH IN
EIGHT YEARS. IN MY COMMUNITY.
WHAT WE'VE SEEN IS FOR E. UC'S
WE'VE SEEN ON. THEM THEY'RE
THEY'RE USUALLY- IS THE
FRANCISCO THE FLOORS GARAGE OFF
INTO. DOES GET BUILT OUT INTO A
STEP UNIT UPSTAIRS IS REALLY
BORED TRADITIONAL QUARTER HAS
BEEN. AND WHAT YOU'LL SEE IS
THROUGH A SEPARATE ENTRANCE-
THOSE GARAGES OFTEN ARE MORE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING YOU SEE IN MY
NEIGHBORHOOD WE HAVE
UNIVERSITIES NEARBY THAT DON'T
PROVIDE A LOT OF HOUSING SAN
FRANCISCO STATE UNIVERSITY OF
SAN FRANCISCO. HE LOVES
STUDENTS- AND UP BY AND YOU'RE
RENTING THOSE EIGHTY USED IN THE
UC. ALSO FAMILIES- LOT IMMIGRANT
FAMILIES WHO ARE JUST. KIND OF
STARTING OUT. I START OFF ON
EIGHTY USE BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT
THEY CAN AFFORD. I WOULD SAY
THEY ARE THEY A SOURCE OF MORE
OF FOR. MORE RATE HOW JUST BE.
THEY LESS DESIRE RIGHT YOU'RE
YOU'RE IN A LOT DESIRABLE YOU
KNOW YOUR SMALL UNIT. I BUT
THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE ON ARE
LOOKING FOR LOOKING FOR A-
THAT'S LOOKING WEISS MORE
CENTRAL. AND THEY'RE WILLING TO
SACRIFICE- THE AMOUNT THEY'RE
PAYING- AND- OF THE UNIT BECAUSE
THEY HAVE A- THERE DURING
SMALLER PROPERTY. CENTER BACK.
YES THEY YOU- JUST BRIEF I FEEL
THAT I TO WEIGH IN WITH MY
OPINION THAT EIGHTY ARE CLEARLY
STATES. ONE OF THE MOST
SUCCESSFUL TYPES OF HOUSING THAT
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO ADD IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA SO JUST BY
THE RAW NUMBERS- AND ALSO. THAT
THEY ARE AS YOU SAID AMONG THE
LEAST OBJECTIONABLE WAYS TO ADD
HOUSING SO SCATTERING DENSITY
INTO EXISTING NEIGHBORHOODS THAT
ARE ALREADY DEVELOPED. AND
ADDING JUST INCREMENTAL
INCREASES IN DENSITY IS A REALLY
GREAT WAY TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
HOUSING AND I THINK. I SAID TO
SOMEWHAT RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE
WITH MY COLLEAGUES I DON'T THINK
THAT A LOT OF TIMES THE PERSON
IS JUST MOVING OUT OF THE MAIN
HOUSE INTO THE A DEAL I THINK
THIS IS SOMEBODY WHO WAS LIVING
IN A SEPARATE UNIT- AND THE-
BECAUSE THEY WOULD LIKE TO LIVE
CLOSER TO FAMILY OR THEY NEED
THE FLEXIBILITY THAT THAT
PROVIDES. THEY MOVE INTO THE
EIGHTY YOU THAT THE FAMILY BILLS
AND SO EIGHTY IS REALLY PROVIDE
TREMENDOUS FLEXIBILITY FOR
FAMILIES TO ALLOW THE SOCIAL
SAFETY NET TO WORK FROM WITHIN A
FAMILY STRUCTURE. WHETHER IT'S
THE OLDER PARENT OR GRANDPARENT
IT'S A CARE GIVER IT'S AN ADULT
CHILD IS SOMEBODY WHO'S- GOTTEN
DIVORCED OR IS GRADUATING FROM
COLLEGE- OR IT'S THE CARE GIVER
IT'S- ANY NUMBER OF FAMILY
SITUATIONS. THAT ARE SPECIFIC TO
THAT FAMILY AND SO THIS ALLOWS
EIGHTY IS REALLY ALLOW
INDEPENDENCE BUT THEY ALSO ARE
CONNECTIVITY. AND THAT
COMBINATION OF BEING ABLE TO
SHARE MEALS OCCASIONALLY OR
RIDES ORG CHECK ON MOM IN THE
MORNING IN THE HOUSE ARE GOING
TO NEED ANYTHING. ALL OF THAT IS
JUST REALLY CRITICAL THAT WE
PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES. FOR OUR
FAMILIES TO GROW AND TO BE
HOUSED IN THIS WAY. SO I'M
ALWAYS SUPPORTIVE OF EIGHTY
LEGISLATION I THINK THIS ONE IS
REALLY- X. EXCITING IDEA AND
WE'LL SEE HOW MANY CITIES OFTEN.
HOPEFULLY A NUMBER OF THEM DO-
BUT I I'M GRATEFUL THAT YOU'RE
WORKING ON IT SO I FULLY SUPPORT
AND THANK YOU. THANK YOU CENTER.
SKINNER THANKS HERE- WITH THE
PRIEST THE AUTHORIZED- SOME
MEMBERS THAT MAY KNOW THE- HI. A
JOINT NORTH ON THE NO OF MISS US
MEMBER KINGS BILLS IN THIS
SECTOR AREA AND ALL WITH MISS
WHITE CAL SKIS. AND WHAT I'M
VERY HAPPY THAT THE STATE HAS
MADE IT EASIER DO EIGHTY USES
VERY IMPORTANT. BUT I ALSO
WANTED TO SAYS WE SPEAK ABOUT
THEM- WE ALSO NEED MULTI FAMILY
HOUSING SO I WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE'RE NOT- JUST. ATTACHED
LIKING EIGHTY YEARS BECAUSE OF
THIS LOW DENSITY WHEN WE LOOK AT
. THE AMOUNT OF. A STATE
CALIFORNIA LAND WHICH NOW DUE TO
VERY SMART OUR LEGISLATION IS NO
LONGER STRICTLY ARE ONE. BUT THE
MAJORITY OF RESIDENTIAL LAND IN
STATED CALIFORNIA UP UNTIL VERY
RECENTLY WAS. BASICALLY ZONED
ONLY FOR SINGLE FAMILY. AND THAT
WAS PART OF THE CONTRIBUTION TO
OUR HOUSING CRISIS BESIDES THE
FACT THAT. YOU KNOW WE WERE
SAYING NO ONE DIDN'T BUILD PART
OF THE WAY TO SAY NO IS TO JUST
HAPPEN R. ONE ZONE. BUT YOU KNOW
WE CHANGE THAT BOTH WITH VARIOUS
BILLS AND WITH THESE AS YOU
LEGISLATION BUT SPEAKING TO THIS
ONE DIRECTLY- I'M- AN EIGHTY
RIGHT NOW. YEAH IT IS- DEONTAY
IS THAT IT WILL HOW IS MY
DAUGHTER HER WIFE AND THE GRAND
BABY. AND I. I THINK A BILL LIKE
THIS IS IMPORTANT BECAUSE- LET'S
SAY AT SOME POINT. I CAN NO
LONGER LIVE ON THE PROPERTY FOUR
I PASSED AWAY. THEN BECAUSE
THEY'RE TWO STRUCTURES ON THE
PROPERTY. THE FIVE. I THINK IT'S
APPROPRIATE TO LEAVE SOME
FLEXIBILITY IF THE OTHER PERSON
DOESN'T WANT TO BECOME A
LANDLORD AND RENT. THEN BY THIS
ALLOWS FOR THERE TO BE TWO
STRUCTURES THAT CAN BE OWNED.
AND SOMEONE DOES NOT HAVE TO
BECOME A LANDLORD FOR EXAMPLE.
FOR EXAMPLE LET'S SAY- AND I
DARKEN WITH THIS DOES NOT
HAPPEN. BUT I GET TO THE POINT
WHERE I NEED TO THE KIND OF CARE
WHERE. HEY S. LEGISLATORS DON'T
HAVE PENSIONS YOU KNOW WHERE I
HAVE THE KIND OF CARE THAT'S
GOING TO COST A LOT MORE THAN
THE ABILITY FOR MY FAMILY TO BE
ABLE TO SEPARATE THEMSELVES. THE
OTHER UNIT ALLOWS THEM TO HAVE
SOME- ME TO HAVE SOME REVENUE TO
TWO FOR EXAMPLE COVERS THE COST
OF THAT CARE. SO I THINK THERE'S
MANY AND THERE'S MANY OTHER
REASONS BESIDES THE FACT THAT
WERE AT THE LOWEST POINT IN
CALIFORNIA'S HISTORY OF PERCENT
OF HOME OWNERSHIP. AND THE MORE
WE CAN CREATE THE OPPORTUNITY
FOR HOMEOWNERSHIP BECAUSE THAT
EQUITY. IN IN YOUR HOME IS WHAT
ALLOWS PEOPLE TO DO TO EITHER
FIND BUSINESSES PUT THEIR KIDS
THROUGH COLLEGE YOU NAME IT SO I
THINK THIS GIVEN THAT EDUS ARE.
BEING BUILT IN BIG NUMBERS NOW.
THIS HELPS TO. THEM AS ABILITY
FOR HOMEOWNERSHIP SO- WITH THAT
I SUPPORT THE BILL AND I WOULD
MOVE IT. CAN BEFORE WE MOVE IT
WE TO GET OUT TAKE TAKE ROLE BE
WE DID WE HAVE NO TO STAB
ECONOMY SO WHEN WE DO THAT RIGHT
NOW BEFORE I SPEAK. SENATOR
CABALLERO PRISON CABALLERO
PRESENTS A TO HEAR CHAIRED TO
PRESENT BREAKS BEER. LIKE SPARE
PARTS ALI. TO WRESTLE HERE TO
WRESTLE PRESENT PLACE. SKINNER
HERE SKINNER. WIENER YOU HAVE A
QUORUM FOUR MINUTES INSTEAD.
HERE WILL TAKE YOUR MOTION GREAT
AND IF I CAN ONE LAW COMMENT
TERMS OF. THE CURRENT CO. FORTY
HAVE GONE UP SOME BUT THAT'S IN
FOR. THE- THE THING THAT HAS
REALLY GONE UP. THE FOOD THAT WE
THE LEGISLATURE WANT TO LOOK AT.
OUR FEES. WATER DISTRICTS THE
UTILITY. THE OTHER FEES FOR
EITHER PUTTING IN A SEPARATE
METER. FOR THE CONNECTION AND
ALSO THE AMOUNT OF TIME IT TAKES
FOR THOSE AND THAT HAS BEEN NOW.
BOTH DELAYING EIGHTY USE IN
ADDING VERY SIGNIFICANT COSTS I
WON'T EVEN SAY IN THE MIKE WHAT
THE MY WATER UTILITY WANTS TO
CHARGE US FOR JUST THE METER.
RIGHT AND OTHER PROBLEM OF THE
BILL. SO WE DO HAVE A MOTION- MY
COMMENTS ON THIS IN YOU AND I
HAVE HAD EXTENSIVE CONVERSATIONS
I WANNA- ALIGNED I THINK THIS IS
BEEN A GOOD DISCUSSION- I
ABSOLUTELY SUPPORT EIGHTIES I
THINK THEY'VE BEEN AN IMPORTANT-
ADDITION TO OUR HOUSING MARKET I
THINK THAT- EVERY SITUATION IS
DIFFERENT SO LET ME JUST SAY
THAT. THE SITUATION YOU
DESCRIBED IN SAN FRANCISCO MAKES
A LOT OF SENSE IS A SEPARATE
UNIT IN YOU CAN SELL- SELL IT
WHEN I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IS THAT
IN RURAL CALIFORNIA THE WAY THAT
THE HOMES ARE BUILT AND IN MUCH
OF SUBURBIA QUITE FRANKLY. YOU
GOT THE MAIN HOUSE IN THE FRONT
AND IF YOU'RE GONNA PUT ANY DO
YOU AND YOU'RE PUTTING IT IN THE
BACK. AND ENTER YOUR DENSIFY
NEIGHBOURHOODS. AND WHICH IS
GREAT THAT IT WORKS. BUT THEN TO
UP TO HAVE THEIR PROPERTY BE
SOLD THE EIGHTY WOULD BE SOLD
AND PEOPLE SHARING. THE
BACKYARD. OF A HOME. IS CAN IN
IN MY MIND IS. AND I GET YOU
KNOW YOU GOT TO HAVE AN EASEMENT
SO THAT PEOPLE CAN ACCESS THE
EIGHTY YOU THROUGH THE YARD. BUT
IF YOU END UP. THE ROSY PICTURE
OF IT'S ALL ABOUT FAMILY FAMILY
MOVING IN AND YOU KNOW THE SIGNS
AND THEY TAKE CARE OF YOU KNOW
THAT THAT'S GREAT. BUT IF YOU
ALLOW IT TO BE SOLD. INVESTORS
HAVE COME IN. AND THEY'VE BEEN
BUYING THE HOMES IN ORDER TO
BUILD EIGHTY USE. AND IT YOU
SELL. THE PROPERTIES THE
POTENTIAL FOR DISAGREEMENTS
NEIGHBORHOOD DISAGREEMENTS. IF
SOMEBODY OWNS THE PROPERTY YOU
CAN ASK HIM TO LEAVE. THERE IN
YOUR BACKYARD WHAT IF THEY DON'T
HAVE THE SAME- SENSE OF SPACE
AND- AND APPRECIATION OF A
BACKYARD THAT. THAT THAT THAT
YOU HAVE AS IT AS THE OWNER OF
THE OF THE MAIN HOUSE SO I JUST
I GET CONCERNED ABOUT HOW YOU
DIVIDE HELLO. WHAT KIND OF
UNITS- THAT WORKS WELL IN AND-
AND SO I'M I'M I'M I'M PROBABLY
GONNA LAY OFF TODAY I DON'T WANT
I DON'T WANT YOUR BILL TO DIE
THAT'S NOT MY INTEREST BUT I
JUST HAVE REAL CONCERNS ABOUT.
COMMUNITIES WERE THIS JUST
DOESN'T WORK AND- AND CREATING
THE- THE DENSIFICATION RENT AND
WHEN I WAS ON THE CITY COUNCIL
MANY MOONS AGO WE HAD WE HAD
AREAS WHERE. THE LOTS WERE
BILLED THE COUNTY AND
INCORPORATED STANDARD SO NO
CURBS GUTTERS SIDEWALKS
STREETLIGHTS AND THEY WERE.
EIGHT HUNDRED SQUARE FOOT HOMES
ON THESE HUGE LIGHTS. AND AND
THE CHALLENGE WAS WHEN TO START
IDENTIFYING THOSE AND THEY WERE
. AREAS OF TOWN WERE VERY POOR
PEOPLE AFTER IT WAS BUILT DURING
THAT THAT- DUST BOWL ERA- THE
NEIGHBORHOODS WERE INUNDATED.
WITH CARS. AND ILLEGAL SHELTERS
IN THE BACKYARD THAT'D BE
CREATED. BLIGHT DETERIORATION
AND THE INABILITY FOR SERVICES
REALLY TO BE ADEQUATELY PROVIDED
AND SO WE HAD AND NO EIGHTY YOU
. PROVISION FOR THOSE KINDS OF
PROPERTIES- CERTAIN
NEIGHBORHOODS AND WHEN THE STATE
LAW CHANGED AND SAID YES YOU CAN
DO IT AND- THERE'S YOU CAN'T
PROHIBIT IT. I SUPPORTED THAT
DESPITE KNOWING THAT IN SOME
NEIGHBORHOODS. SOME
NEIGHBORHOODS IT'S GOING TO
HAVE- INSTEAD OF HAVING A
BENEFICIAL EFFECT IT'S A
DELETERIOUS EFFECT BECAUSE-
THOSE IN THE NEIGHBORHOODS WERE
FARMWORKERS ARE LIVING. AND
PEOPLE OWN THE HOME AND DON'T
LIVE IN IT BUT ARE RENTING IN
OTHER WORDS ARE SLIM LANDLORDS
AND SO. IT BY I GET CONCERNED
ABOUT THE ONE SIZE FITS ALL AND
ABOUT ALLOWING PEOPLE TO OWN
SEPARATE PIECES OF THE SAME
PROPERTY WITHOUT THAT KIND OF
CONTROLS. THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
CAN ISSUE THAT CAN REGULATE
THOSE CONTROLS- IT'LL IT'LL BE
UP TO THAT PROPERTY OWNERS- TO
DO THAT AND I'M NOT SURE IT'S
GOING TO BE A GOOD THING FOR
EIGHTY YOU CAN SINCE THAT'S
THAT'S MY CONCERN- I AM I CAN
GET THERE MAYBE BY THE TIME IT
GETS TO THE FLOOR BUT FOR
TODAY'S. HEARING AYE I WON'T BE
WON'T BE SUPPORTING THE BILL I
WILL KNOW BUT I WON'T I WON'T
FOR THOUSANDS ANSWER YOUR- YEAH
AND ALLOW YOU TO THE YOUNG TECH
EVERYBODY YEAH. SENATOR WIENER.
THANK YOU AND MY FOR. NOT OF THE
EARLY PART OF THIS OPERATION I'D
WANT TO SET AYE AYE SIR THE BILL
APPRECIATE THE TEARS. WE
SUPPORTED HOUSING AND- AND MOVED
IT OUT- I THINK IN THE END WE-
HERE WE WANT TO BUILD WE WANT
MORE HOMES ARE WE ALL. WE WANT
TO MANY MANY HOMES AND HEALTH
BUT WE TELL TO PUT A LOT OF
RESEARCH. ON OF TO CREATE. NEW
HOMES AND SO I'M JUST A BELIEVER
IN- FLEXIBLE. I'M TRYING TO
AVOID- A LEVEL OF
MICROMANAGEMENT THAT CAN-
UNDERMINE WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO
DO SO I DECIDED TO TEARS
CONCERNS I TOTALLY RESPECT THOSE
CONCERNS AND I'M NOT. SUGGESTING
THAT THERE ARE IN SITUATIONS
WHERE THE PROBLEMATIC BUT I
THINK OVERALL- THIS IS NOT THE
RIGHT APPROACH THANK YOU MANAGER
FOR THE INDULGENCE ABSOLUTELY.
AM I WILL ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE
GREG TO JUST MY CONCLUSION I
WOULD JUST SAY- AS IS QUITE
COMMON- FOR ANY LOCAL
JURISDICTION IF THEY ARE
ALLOWING. THAT CONNIE
CONDOMINIUM CONVERSIONS YOU HAVE
TO SUBMIT CC IN OURS. CCAR'S
DICTATE- YOU KNOW. MISTER BROWN
WAS TALKING ABOUT EARLIER A
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION WITH THE
RULES ARE HOW A COMMUNAL
PROPERTY SHARED WHETHER YOU HAVE
ACCESS TO A GARAGE WITH THE
ACCESS TO THE BACKYARD. ALL OF
THOSE ARE DICTATED IN THE CC IN
OUR TO GET OUT EXACTLY THE ISSUE
THAT YOU ARE. A RAISING SO THAT
IT'S NOT DRIVEN FROM PERSONALITY
TO PERSONALITY IT'S NOT. DRIVEN
BASED ON WHO'S THERE AND WHO'S
NOT- BUT AS PART OF. ANY
CONDOMINIUM CONVERSION GENERALLY
YOU ARE ASKED TO SUBMIT CCN OURS
WHICH WOULD GOVERN. THAT
ASSOCIATION AND HOW THE
ASSOCIATION WOULD IN PARTICULAR
ARE HANDLED SHARE PROPERTY OR
EVEN SHARED BILLS YOU HAVE
SOMETIMES- WATER BILLS THAT ARE
NOT SEPARATE. ELECTRICITY BILLS
ARE NOT SEPARATE A VARIETY OF
BILLS ARE NOT SEPARATE THIS IS
ALL VERY VERY COMMON AGAIN. THIS
IS A STATE LAW THIS IS NOT
SOMETHING THAT IS NEW TO SAY LAW
WE'RE NOT DOING SOMETHING
DIFFERENT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
WE ARE JUST ADDING. TO EXISTING
LAW AND THE ADDING TO WHAT
WHAT'S ALREADY GOING ON. UP AND
DOWN THE STATE HERE. SO. AGAIN I
KNOW WITH ANYTHING THAT NEW IT'S
A LITTLE. ON YOU HAVE TO KIND OF
WRAP YOUR HEAD. BUT IS EXISTING
LAW OUR CONDOMINIUM CA. ARE
HAPPY AS WE SPEAK ALL OF ALL OF
THE DOWN THE STATE- AGAIN. THE
WHOLE CARE. IN THIS WITH. WE
SURE THAT OUR- HARD BILL WAS IN
. WITH CONSISTENT WITH EXISTING
LAW FOR THAT TO GET EXACTLY WHAT
PROVISIONS YOU DESCRIBE MADAM
CHAIR. IN TERMS OF- MAKING SURE
THAT. BACKYARD SPACE IS VERY
CLEAR HOW THAT. HOW THAT CAN BE
UTILIZED GARAGES. DRIVEWAYS
AGAIN SHARED SPACE SHARED BILLS
THOSE ARE ALL THINGS THAT YOU
HAVE A LEGAL DOCUMENTS. THAT
THE- OWNERS HAVE TO SIGN. IN
ORDER TO GOVERN HOW THEY WILL
LIVE AND SHOP PROPERTY TOGETHER
SO THAT'S ALL VERY VERY
COMMONPLACE IN IN STATE LAW SO.
WITHOUT RESPECT FOR US FIVE VOTE
ON A. B. TEN THIRTY THREE VERY
MUCH APPRECIATE ALL THE
DISCUSSION. DO PASSED. THANK YOU
MUCH CHAMPS AND MEMBER THEM IS
TO PASS A PROBE. PLEASE CALL
ROLL. SENATORS CABALLERO. THERE
ARE TWO. THIRDS VOTE NO BREAKS.
LEG SPINNER HI DOLLY. TO WRESTLE
. THE SO I. SKINNER SKINNER I
WIENER. WIENER I. FORTY ONE- THE
THAT BILL WILL BE PUT ON CALL
FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU
FOR THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MOVIE
ON TO FILE ITEM AT MEMBER. LAST
OKAY MCCARTY. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MCCARTY. SORRY I DIDN'T SEE HERE
. YOU'RE TALKING EIGHT. YES YES
. THANK YOU SO I HAVE FIVE TWO
HERE- COMMITTEE PERCENT FIRST
TEN TWO THAT WOULD BE GREAT YEAH
. YOU YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
PRESS THIS IS A BILL RELATE TO
SACK CA THREE TO DISTRICT- YOU
KNOW WE HEAR A LOT ABOUT TRANSIT
DISTRICT AND FUNDING THIS IS AN
THIS IS AN OPERATIONAL FUNDING
ISSUE BUT IT'S MORE ON CAPITAL
IMPROVEMENTS IN THE OUT YEARS
AND FOCUSING ON. WHERE TO MAKE
THOSE IMPROVEMENTS AND HOW WE
CAN ENGAGE A LARGE DISTRICT
WHICH HAS MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS
IN ESSENCE THIS FOLLOWS WHAT WE
GET A COUPLE YEARS AGO FOR SAN
DIEGO AND ALLOWS A SPECIFIC AREA
OF THE TRANSIT DISTRICT IT TO
HAVE AN ELECTION TO FOCUS ON
TRANSIT IMPROVEMENTS IS NOT. IT
DOESN'T CHANGE THE VOTE
THRESHOLD IS STILL TWO THIRDS
WRESTLED AND DOESN'T YET
GERRYMANDER THERE YET BECAUSE IT
FOCUSES ON NOT SPLITTING THE
CITY BUT FOCUSING ON INDIVIDUAL
JURISDICTIONS WITHIN THE OVERALL
DISTRICT THAT SIMPLY GIVES OUR
LOCAL TRANSIT DISTRICT THE
FLEXIBILITY HAVE A BALLOT
MEASURE THAT COVERS A NARROW
PORTION OF ITS SERVICE AREA. FOR
EXAMPLE HERE IN SACRAMENTO WE
HAVE THE CITY CALLED RANCHO
CORDOVA KNOCKS IN MY DISTRICT
WHICH WOULD ALLOW. THEM TO BE-
YOU KNOW OUTSIDE OF AN AREA IF
YOU JUST FOCUS ON THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO. WITH ME TODAY ARE
REPRESENT FROM OUR TRANSIT
DISTRICT. I LIKE HIM TO HAVE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO UP TO PRESENT AS
WELL. AND RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
I THOUGHT. AGREEMENT MADAM CHAIR
MEMBERS MY NAME IS GREG FISHMAN
ON THE SCENE COMMUNITY. OFFICER
FOR SACRAMENTO. TO SECTOR TO IS
THE- TRADE PROVIDER IN THE CAMP
REGION OPERATE EIGHTY TWO BUS
ROUTES FORTY THREE MILES OF
LIGHT RAIL FIFTY THREE STATIONS.
A MICRO TRANSIT SERVICE AND ADA
PARATRANSIT SERVICES WITHIN THE
FOUR HUNDRED AND FORTY SQUARE
MILE. SERVICE TERRITORY
THROUGHOUT SACRAMENTO COUNTY
INCLUDING THE CITIES OF CITRUS
HEIGHTS ELK GROVE FOLSOM AND
RANCHO CORDOVA. WE'RE
CELEBRATING OUR FIFTIETH
ANNIVERSARY OF SERVICES HERE. WE
BELIEVE THAT SAFE CONVENIENT AND
INEXPENSIVE PUBLIC TRANSIT
BENEFITS EVERYBODY IN OUR
COMMUNITY WHETHER THEY RIDE
TRANSIT OR NOT. HOWEVER WE ALSO
RECOGNIZE THAT CERTAIN TRANSIT
PROJECTS. MIGHT PROVIDE MORE
BENEFIT TO SOME PARTS OF OUR
COMMUNITY THAN OTHERS.
CONSEQUENTLY WE WOULD LIKE TO
HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO ASK ONLY
SOME OF THE COMMUNITY WE SERVE
TO APPROVE A BALLOT MEASURE TO
PAY FOR PROJECTS IN THOSE
SPECIFIC JURISDICTIONS. AB TEN
FIFTY TWO WOULD GIVE SUCCOR TO
THE AUTHORITY TO PLACE A MEASURE
ON THE BALLOT. THAT WOULD AFFECT
ONLY JURISDICTION SPECIFIED IN
THE MEASURE FOR EXAMPLE THE CITY
OF SACRAMENTO ALONE OR
CONCEIVABLY THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO AND THE CITIES OF ELK
GROVE TOGETHER. SOME OTHER
JURISDICTIONS INCLUDING
NEIGHBORING PLASTER COUNTY ALSO
HAVE SIMILAR AUTHORITY TO THIS-
THE COMMITTEE AND ANALYSIS
RAISES SOME IMPORTANT
CONSIDERATIONS WE CAN COMMIT TO
CONDUCTING. A PROPORTIONAL SHARE
ANALYSIS TO ENSURE THAT ANY
REVENUE WAS SPENT IN THE
JURISDICTIONS WHERE IT'S RAISED
WERE. SOMEWHAT FAMILIAR WITH
THIS FROM PAST CONTRACT
AGREEMENTS WE HAD WITH CITIES
OF. CITRUS HEIGHTS FOLSOM ELK
GROVE BEFORE THEY WERE ANNEXED
INTO OUR SYSTEM. IF WE EVER DO
USED THIS AUTHORITY GRANTED WE
WOULD NEED TO INCLUDE AN
EXPENDITURE PLAN THAT SPECIFIES
HOW THE REVENUE WOULD BE SPENT.
PROJECTS WOULD ONLY BENEFIT THE
JURISDICTION RAISING THE FUNDS
AND AS THE SOMEONE I MENTIONED
WE WOULD STILL NEED A TWO THIRDS
VOTE TO PASS ANY SUCH MEASURE.
INDIVIDUAL CITIES ALREADY HAVE
THE AUTHORITY TO PUT REVENUE
MEASURES ON THE BALLOT- ONLY
WITHIN THEIR CITY IN FACT ALL OF
THE CITIES WITHIN SACRAMENTO
COUNTY. HAVE PASSED IN GENERAL
FUND TAXES LEADING TO A VARIETY
. OF DIFFERENT SALES TAX RATES
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY OR READ.
SECRETARY IS OLD. HAVE THE OF
THE TO CALL A PER TO. AND IN
THIS JUST CLARIFIED THAT
AUTHORITY. SECRETARY ALSO
ACCEPTED AMENDMENTS TO CLARIFY
THAT REVENUE FROM ANY PROPERTY
TAX WOULD ONLY BE USED FOR.
CAPITAL PROJECTS- THIS MEASURES
INTENDED TO GIVE SECRETARY
ANOTHER TOOL TO HELP US NAVIGATE
AN UNCERTAIN FINANCIAL FUTURE.
AND ENSURE EQUITY IN VOTING FOR
SECRETARY MEASURES LIKE ONLY
ASKING THOSE AFFECTED TO
ACTUALLY VOTE FOR A MEASURE. WE
MAY NEVER NEED TO USE THIS TOOL
BUT WE WOULD LIKE TO HAVE IT
AVAILABLE IN CASE IT IS NEEDED
AND WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THERE
ANYBODY ELSE WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. ALLISON WITH
SACRAMENTO TRANSIT ADVOCATES AND
WRITERS IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE. IS THERE
ANYBODY HERE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO AB. TEN
FIFTY TWO. SEE NO ONE IS THERE
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
EITHER IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU FOR
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION FOR EIGHTY
FIFTY TWO PRESS ONE AND YOUR AT
THIS TIME. ONE MOMENT PLEASE.
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
THIS IS SUSAN HENRY FROM THE
ENVIRONMENTAL COUNCIL OF
SACRAMENTO. AND WE SUPPORT A. B.
FIFTY TWO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU. ADELINE ELEVEN PLEASE
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON DOING
CONTROL PRESIDENT CEO OF THE
CRITICAL URBAN AND SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. ONE MOMENT PLEASE.
PLEASE STAND BY. AT LINE FIFTEEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES MATTHEW
CLICK EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
PLASTER COUNTY TRANSPORTATION
PLANNING AGENCY IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. ONE MOMENT PLEASE. MY
TWENTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD.
FOLLOW HERNANDEZ FROM THE CITY
OF SACRAMENTO CALLING IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MADAM CHAIR NO FOR THE COMMON
THANK YOU AT THIS TIME VERY GOOD
THE BRING THAT THE MAN BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE FOR COMMENTS
QUESTIONS CONCERNS A COUPLE
QUESTIONS. ALL RIGHT SO I'M
TRYING TO UNDERSTAND THIS LITTLE
BIT- IT'LL BE A PARCEL OR A
SALES AND USE TAX VOTED ON BY
JUST A PORTION OF STATE
COMMUNITY. SO LITTLE
NEIGHBORHOOD THEY DECIDE THEY
WANT TO DO THIS. NOT A
NEIGHBORHOOD FOR STABLE THAT ARE
TRANSIT DISTRICTS WE HAVE- SIX
RIGHT SIX BIG CITIES AND THE
UNINCORPORATED HERE IN
SACRAMENTO THE END OF CORPORATE
IS- INTO IS THAT RESIDENTIAL SO
ALLOW- SOME OF THE JURISDICTIONS
WITHIN THE OVERALL TRANSIT
DISTRICT BUT WE SPECIFY THAT WE
CAN'T CARVE UP WITHIN THE CITY
CAN'T BE JUST A SMALL AREA
BECAUSE V. DOING SALES AND USE
TAX. DOES DOES THIS THIS SECTION
ARE THIS CITY OR PORTION OF IT.
VOTE ON THIS AND THEN THE WHOLE
CITY HAS BEEN APPLIED TO THE
WHOLE CITY NOW IT THE WEEK WE
CLARIFIED THAT IT IT WOULD JUST
BE THE AREA THAT VOTES ON IT THE
IMPROVEMENTS- WOULD BE FOCUSED
ON THAT. THAT SPECIFIC AREA. SO
FOR EXAMPLE IF IT'S JUST WITH A
THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO IN THE
CITY OF VELCRO TWO NINE TWO U.
S. THEY GUYS IN THE COUNTY. THEY
VOTED ON IT THE CAPITAL
IMPROVEMENTS WOULD BE JUST FOCUS
ON THOSE AREAS. NOT THE AT THE
OUTSIDE AREAS. WITHIN THE COUNTY
AND THAT TRANSIT IS ACTIVE A NON
GO TAX ONCE THEY'VE PASSED IT
CORRECT AND THE IMPROVE THEIR
HAS TO BE FOCUSED ON THAT. YES A
CREDIT ON THE OUTSIDE HE DROVE
IN A BODY TV AT BEST BUY NOT
ELEVEN RANCHO COULD THAT YEAH
YOU HAVE TO AND ONCE. ARE INTO A
GO AWAY SO THE THERE IS A LONG.
SAID SO ONE ONE ONE AREA HAS TAX
IN THE OTHER AREA ACROSS THE
STREET MAY NOT MEAN. WHAT
HAPPENS WITH THAT IN OTHER WORDS
I HATE DOWN THE PERSON DRAWING
THE LINES YEAH BOB WHO'S GOING
TO BE ENTITIES OUT WELL THAT'S
SOMETIMES A CITIES WITH
DIFFERENT TACK MEASURING. I
COULD HAVE RIGHT ARE REPRESENT
THAT THAT THAT HAPPENED. LET ME
I. THEM HOW HERE. PERSONAL THIS
WOULD APPLY ONLY END IN. SO FOR
TWO MORE THAN ONE SEE- NOT CAR
OUT- BUT YOU BY ZIP. OR VOTING.
OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT SO IT'S
THE ENTIRE CITY OF. WOULD ON IT
AND WITH BE SET TO WHATEVER TO.
THE ENTIRE CITY FULTON. COULD
BOOK OR CONCEIVABLY FOR. OR L.
GROW OR YES- BUT- TO VOTER. AND
IN TERMS OF THE LAND THAT WOULD
BE. BY WHATEVER MEASURE WE ON
THE BALLOT. WE WOULD CAN. ASK
THOSE VOTE TO A TAX ON THE
BALLOT. A YOU KNOW A GIVEN
PERIOD OF- BUT THAT WOULD BE. IN
THE META MEASURE IT SO. IT IS
NOT INCLUDED IN THE THIS BILL
THE BIG DO THAT THROUGH THE OWN
COME. AB HAS IT THE CITIES ARE
HAVE THE AUTHORITY FUND IS
PROUD. THAT WERE. YES
CONCEIVABLY ALL RIGHT. THANKS
THANK YOU. OTHER COMMENTS
QUESTIONS OR CAN. THERE IS A
MOTION I DO- SOME QUESTION AND-
THE- WHAT'S ODD OF. ABOUT THE
DOING IT THIS WAY IS THE TRY.
THROUGH AND I SUPPORT TRANSIT I
WE NEED IN A MATTER FACT I THINK
WE NEED IT. TO BE MORE ROBUST
INTO THE SUBURBS AND INTO RURAL
AREAS AS WELL- IT'S NONEXISTENT
IN IN RURAL AREAS AND SO. BUT
BUT IF YOU'RE- WHEN YOU SET UP A
TRANSIT. ENTITY THEORETICALLY
IT'S EVERYBODY IN THAT. AREA
THAT BENEFITS RIGHT THE
EVERYBODY CAN TAKE TO TAKE THAT
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION AND IT'S-
INSTRUCTED AGAIN THEORETICALLY
TO BE CONVENIENT FOR PEOPLE TO
TAKE IT. BUT IF YOU START
EXCLUDING- SOME AREAS- HOW HOW
DOES THAT. IN ORDER TO THE
BENEFIT OF THE HOLD TRANSIT.
AUTHORITY AND- AND WHY DO WE SET
UP TRANSIT AUTHORITIES THEN IF
YOU COULD JUST DO THESE. THESE I
MEAN I KNOW WHY BECAUSE YOU
REALLY WANT IT TO FUNCTION AS A
SYSTEM BUT BUT IT JUST SEEMS TO
ME THE DIFFICULTY THAT I'M
HAVING IS THAT IS THAT WE'RE
WE'RE WE'RE PICKING. AREAS AND-
AND THEY MAY NOT BE THE AREAS
THAT DESPERATELY NEED IT THE
MOST I DON'T KNOW I MEAN I MEAN
YOU THEORETICALLY YOU YOU'D WANT
TO DO THAT AND I SO HERE'S THAT
THAT THE CHALLENGE FOR ME. IS
THAT WHATEVER WE DO HERE BECAUSE
ITS GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE IS
THAT. IS WE PASS RULES THAT THEN
OTHER ENTITIES LOOK AT AND GO
HEY I WANT TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT
TOO RIGHT IT'S SO. WHEN I TRIED
TO DO IS THE CHAIR IS TO MAKE
SURE IT'S FAIR TO EVERYBODY.
THAT WE'RE NOT SETTING UP
CERTAIN COMMUNITIES FOR FAILURE-
AND WE'RE NOT CREATING SOMETHING
THAT SO- HARD TO USE. THAT ON
THAT IT IT IT'S A BUREAUCRATIC
MESS SO I'M JUST CONCERNED. AT A
TRANSIT AGENCY COMING UP AND
SAYING OH WELL LET'S JUST DO
PART OF IT PART OF THE SYSTEM-
AND NOT INCLUDING EVERYBODY AS
PART OF IT SO. WHO CENTER LET
ME. PROVIDE A COUPLE OF
HYPOTHETICAL EXAMPLES WHERE THIS
WE FEEL IS VERY MUCH NEEDED AND
I THINK ANSWERS YOUR QUESTION.
WE WOULD LOVE TO BE ABLE TO
EXTEND THE LIGHT RAIL LINE FROM-
WORD CURRENT CURRENTLY
TERMINATES THE SOUTHERN END AT
CONSUMES RIVER COLLEGE IN ELK
GROVE. SO WE WOULD CONCEIVABLY
ASK THE CITIES OF SACRAMENTO AND
ELK GROVE TO APPROVE SOME- SOME
MEASURE THAT WOULD PROVIDE
FUNDING TO EXTEND THAT LINE IN
ELK GROVE THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO
IN THE CITY'S REAL GROWTH
BENEFIT MOST DIRECTLY FROM THAT
EXTENSION. BUT CERTAINLY SOMEONE
FROM RANCHO CORDOVA COULD GET ON
THE LIGHT RAIL LINE AND WRITE IT
DOWN ELK GROVE IF THEY WANTED
TO- SO IT DOES BENEFIT THE
ENTIRE COMMUNITY IN THAT WAY IT
ALSO REDUCES- VEHICLE MILES
TRAVELED IN AN AIR QUALITY
ISSUES. SO IT IT DOES PROVIDE
GENERAL BENEFITS BUT THOSE
COMMUNITIES BENEFIT MOST
DIRECTLY FROM THAT SERVICE- THE
SAME CONCEIVABLY IS TRUE WHAT I
MENTIONED WE OPERATE A MICRO
TRANSIT THIS IS- AN APP BASED.
ON DEMAND SERVICE SIMILAR TO
LIFT HER OVER- BUT IS IN A IN A
SHUTTLE BUS IT MAY BE MORE THAN
ONE PASSENGER WE TRY TO COMBINE
RIDES. WE WOULD LOVE TO BE ABLE
TO EXPAND THAT SERVICE INTO SOME
OF THE UNDERSERVED AREAS- IN OUR
SERVICE TERRITORY. AND
CONCEIVABLY WE WOULD ASK PEOPLE
TO- GIVEN COMMUNITIES TO
INCREASE THEIR. THE REVENUE TO
PAY FOR THAT AS WELL. SO LET ME
ASK IT THIS WAY- MY EXPERIENCE.
IN IN IN BOND MEASURES. ARE IS
THAT. WHEN YOU ASK POOR PEOPLE.
TO PAY FOR AN EDUCATION BOND
THERE IS THERE YEAH. AND THEY
PASS EDUCATION BONDS IN HIGHER
NUMBERS THAN WEALTHIER
NEIGHBORHOODS. I WOULD SURE HATE
TO SEE A TRANSIT DISTRICT
DECIDED THEY THEY COULD PASS
SOMETHING IN A POOR
NEIGHBORHOOD. BURDENS THAT
NEIGHBORHOOD. WHEN WEALTHIER
PARTS OF THE COMMUNITY. I DON'T
PAY THEIR FAIR SHARE. BECAUSE
THEY DON'T SEE THE BENEFIT OF
PUBLIC TRANSIT FOR THAT RIGHT I
I'M I'M JUST I'M CONCERNED WITH
PICKING AND CHOOSING AND BEING
ABLE TO- TO I YOU KNOW TAKE
CERTAIN NEIGHBORHOODS AND NOT
DOING THAT THAT JUST MY CONCERN
AND I. I GET IT DID THAT'S NOT
WHERE YOU'RE TRYING TO GO WITH
IT BUT BUT TO THE EXTENT THAT
THIS BECOMES THE- TEMPLATE. FOR
OTHER TRANSIT AGENCIES TO SAY
HEY WELL MAYBE WE SHOULD WE CAN
DO AT. THE SAME KIND OF THING- I
WOULD I WOULD HATE TO SEE THAT
SO THAT'S JUST MY CONCERN
RESPECTFULLY MADAM CHAIR- THAT'S
WHY WE'VE INCLUDED IT MUST
INCLUDE THE ENTIRE CITY SO WE
WERE NOT PICKING AND CHOOSING
ZIP CODES OR OR A VOTING
PRECINCTS- THIS WOULD. APPLY TO
THE FABULOUS FORTIES ANY
SACRAMENTO IS EQUALLY AS PARTS
OF SOUTH SEGMENT OF THAT ARE
PART MORE DISADVANTAGED. BUT
THAT'S THAT'S GOOD. SENATOR
BREAKS BURKE. THANK YOU YEAH I
WANTED TO ADDRESS SOME THE
CHAIRS. ARE EXPRESSED I SO THIS
SO I COME FROM BEING THE CHAIR
THE TRANSFER AGENCY SANDAG. AND
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO JUST
WROTE REMEMBER WHERE TRANSIT IS
AT THE MOMENT WHEN YOU LOOK AT
THE MACRO VIEW WHICH IS THAT. IN
SOME PARTS OF THE STATE IT'S ON
THE BRINK BUT IN OTHER PARTS OF
THE STATE IS JUST SLOWLY
DECLINING AND DECLINING AND
DECLINING IN TERMS OF THE
QUALITY. OF THE TRANSIT THAT'S
OFFERED EITHER LOOKING OUTSIDE
IT AT THE THREADBARE TRAINS
THEMSELVES OR THE AMOUNT OF
SERVICE THAT WERE ACTUALLY ABLE
TO SUPPORT. AND WHAT TRANSIT
AGENCIES ARE TRYING TO DO IS
FIND A SOURCE OF REVENUE TO BE
ABLE TO BOOST RIDERSHIP. AND SO
IT WOULD BE GREAT IF WE WERE
FUNDING TRANSIT AT THE STATE OR
FEDERAL LEVEL FOR ITS OPERATIONS
AND ITS CAPITAL EXPENSES. IN
ORDER TO BE GROWING TRANSIT IN
THE STATE BUT WE'RE REALLY NOT
AND SO WHAT SO THE QUESTION IS
WHAT WILL THESE TRANSIT AGENCIES
DO AND LOOKING. FOR THEM TO BE
REALLY SPECIFIC ABOUT WE KNOW
THAT THERE'S A NEED FOR
INCREASED TRANSIT SERVICE IN
PARTICULAR COMMUNITIES IF WE CAN
ASK THOSE COMMUNITIES TO SUPPORT
THAT. THEN THEN IN A MORE MICRO
WAY THEY'LL BE ABLE TO PROVIDE
TRANSIT THAT THEN CAN ALSO.
CREATE SOME MOMENTUM TO FOR MORE
TRANSIT. AND I THINK THE
ALTERNATIVE IF WE IF WE DON'T
ALLOW THIS KIND OF THING TO
HAPPEN. IS THAT THAT. EVERYTHING
WILL CONTINUE TO DECLINE. AND SO
I'M VERY MUCH SUPPORT THIS
BECAUSE I WANT TRANSIT TO
PROSPER IN THE STATE AND I.
DON'T SEE THAT WERE HAVING THE
KINDS OF INVESTMENTS AT THE
HIGHER LEVELS THAT WOULD BE
NEEDED FOR A SYSTEM WIDE.
RAISING OF ALL SHIPS. SO I SAY
IF THEIR COMMUNITIES THAT SEE
THAT THEY CAN GET TO YES. LET'S
GIVEN THE CHANCE TO GET TO YES
INSTEAD OF ALLOWING. A LOT OF
ANCILLARY COMMUNITIES. FOR THESE
BIGGER TRANSIT SYSTEMS TO SAY NO
AND THEN THEY BASICALLY HAVE NO
IT NO NEW REVENUE STREAMS.
BECAUSE THAT THAT'S VERY MUCH
WHAT THE PICTURE LOOKS LIKE
RIGHT NOW. AND SO THE IN SAN
DIEGO THIS WAS PASSED AND
ACTUALLY HASN'T BEEN USED YET-
BECAUSE IT'S DIFFICULT TO PUT
SOMETHING ON THE BALLOT. AND YOU
KNOW IT'S A PROCESS AND YOU HAVE
TO MAKE SURE THAT. YOU THINK
THERE'S A PATH TO VICTORY THERE.
BUT THIS IS JUST THE VERY
BEGINNING OF SAYING HEY GIVE IT
A TRY THERE IS AND THIS. THIS IS
AN IMPORTANT. FOR ME AND MANY I
THINK TO TRY TO BOOST TRANSIT.
AND I THINK THIS IS ONE WAY THAT
WILL WILL BE ABLE TO HELP IT A
LITTLE BIT- DIFFERENT DISTRICTS
DIFFERENT ISSUES. THANK YOU BYE
IT'S JUST- APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR
COMMENTS- I AM I AM- NERVOUS
ABOUT SETTING UP BUT A STANDARD
THAT. THAT THEN ALLOWS- EIGHT
EIGHT EIGHT. SEPARATION WITHIN
IT WITHIN AN ORGANIZATION ARE
IDENTIFYING AS SMALL. UGH SUBSET
WITHIN AN ORGANIZATION- AND I AM
GOING TO GO ON RECORD THAT I NOT
ONLY SUPPORT PUBLIC
TRANSPORTATION I TAKE IT. IT
DOESN'T WORK BIONDI TRAIN.
GETTING DOWN TO MY DISTRICT AND
NEVER HAS- BUT THE QUESTION
BECOMES. AND MAYBE THE QUESTION
REALLY IS MAYBE THE STATE SHOULD
BE FUNDING. TRANSIT BETTER. SO
THAT WE CAN BUILD OUT SYSTEMS
THAT WILL- CONNECT THE ENTIRE
STATE BECAUSE THERE ARE SOME
PARTS OF MY DISTRICT THAT YOU
CANNOT GET THERE UNLESS YOU HAVE
A CAR SO YOU START TALKING ABOUT
BE ICAL MILES TRAVELED. HEY YOU
KNOW WHAT THE ONLY WAY TO GET
THERE IS IN A CAR AND- AND SO
THE CHALLENGE BECOMES HOW DO WE
SET UP THESE ROBUST SYSTEMS
WITHOUT. MAKE IT WITH WHILE WE
MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE PROTECTING
THE MOST VULNERABLE IN OUR
COMMUNITY WHO. TAKE
TRANSPORTATION IN THE HIGHEST
NUMBERS. AND AND THAT THEY HAVE
THE INFRASTRUCTURE AND THEY'RE
NOT PAYING DOUBLE YOU'RE NOT
PAYING THE RATE BUT THEN ALSO
PAYING THE SALES TAX. AND NOBODY
ELSE IN THE IN THE COMMUNITIES
DOING AND SO I REALLY APPRECIATE
THAT YOU SAID YOU'RE YOU'RE
DOING ENTIRE CITIES YES MA'AM
BECAUSE THAT WILL MAKE
AMELIORATE. SOME OF THE CONCERNS
THAT I HAVE WHICH IS THAT- THAT
THE- PEOPLE THAT SEE THE BENEFIT
OF TRANSIT THE MOST BECAUSE THEY
HAVE TO TAKE IT YEAH FOR
FINANCIAL REASONS. DON'T END UP
PAYING DOUBLE AND DON'T END UP
BEING THE ONLY ONE TO SUPPORT
IT- BOTH. EITHER THROUGH IT
CELLS ARE USED TAX OR PROPERTY
TAX. IN ADDITION TO THE FIRST I
APPRECIATE YOUR COMMENTS AND I
THINK THAT. THAT TAKES CARE. OF
SOME OF THE ISSUES THAT I'M
THINKING ABOUT. I THINK AMOUNTS
ALL OF BE HONEST GIVE THE RAW
COASTER. OF TRANSIT FUND THAT
WE'VE BEEN FOR LESS MONTHS. COME
IS ALL IT LITTLE A LITTLE BIT
TRIGGERING- ME I'LL BE ON YOUR
SIDE. ME TOO. MANY GET INTO
MILES TRAVELED. TO GET RID-
EFFORTS I WON A- MY- WITH BLAKE
SPEERS- REMARKS WHICH WORK FOR
VERY MUCH- ON POOR. AND ALL- THE
CHAIRS. ABOUT MAYBE THE STATE
SHOULD BE DOING MORE. TAXI FINE
TRANSIT AND I JUST WANNA. AFTER
WE- YOU KNOW AND OF. I'VE OF THE
BILL IN ASSEMBLY TRANSFER. LATER
AROUND THE BEAR BECAUSE THE BAY
AREA'S THE- IMPERIL IN THE-
BECAUSE OF. MUCH RIGHT BEFORE
THE BAND AND WE'RE FAIR- TO FUND
THESE- BUT- I AM I SUPPORT THIS
- BECAUSE I WE THE- STATE OF. IS
SENT A CREW CLEAR MESSAGE IS
HERE AT THE WE EXIST OUR GO TO
SELL- FOR THE LOCAL COMMUNITY
ARE WISH YOU WERE DIFFERENT I
WANTED TO SEND A DIFFERENT
MESSAGE. AND I'M VERY GRATEFUL-
TO THE GOVERNOR AND LEGISLATURE
CLEANER BUDGET SUB SHARES ARE
BUDGET CHAIR FOR FIGHTING VERY
HARD TO RESTORE THE CAPITAL CUTS
THAT THE ADMINISTRATION HAD
PROPOSED- AND TO PUT MORE
OPERATIONAL FUNDING IN. ABOUT
THE OPERATIONAL FUND AND DURING
A BAD YEAR SOME NOT CRITICIZING
ANYONE I'M I'M GRATEFUL FOR THAT
IT DOESN'T EVEN COME CLOSE. TO
RESOLVING THE ACTUAL SHORTFALLS
OF THESE AGENCIES- FEES AND SO
WE HAVE SET UNLIKE NEW YORK. OR
MINNESOTA WHERE THE STATE'S
STEPPED IN AND SOLVED THE
PROBLEMS FOR THE NEW YORK CITY.
SUBWAY FOR THE MINNEAPOLIS
SYSTEM STATE ADOPTED NEW REVENUE
MEASURES IT'S BASICALLY SOLVE
THE PROBLEM. CALIFORNIA SO WE'RE
GOING TO SOLVE IN THE CASE OF
THE BAY AREA WE'RE GOING TO
SOLVE 16% OF YOUR PROBLEM. AND
SO THEREFORE THE OTHER 84% IS ON
YOU TO SOLVE THAT'S THE MESSAGE.
THERE IS AGAIN THE MOST EXTREME-
BUT THAT'S A MESSAGE A STATE.
HAS SEN AND SO WE NEED TO GIVE.
HER TRANSIT DISTRICTS ARE CAL
THAT THAT ARE- FLUX. TO RAISE
REVENUE FUND THE SYSTEM- AND
THIS BILL ONE OF THAT AND I'M
HAPPY TO SUPPORT. READ VERY
GOOD- WE HAVE A MO. IF THE NO
FURTHER. QUESTIONS COMMENTS OR
CONCERNS WILL ALLOW YOU TO
CONCLUDE. THANK YOU I APPRECIATE
THE CONVERSATION I WAS GONNA
TAKE YOUR COMMENTS AS MY CLOTHES
BUT JUST TO ADD A BIT. RIGHT
OUTSIDE TWENTY ARTS IN HERE WE
HAVE A LIGHT RAIL TRAIN. AND YOU
KNOW MANY OF YOU FOLKS CAME HERE
TODAY ON A FLIGHT AND WE HAVE
LUXURY OF HAVING SOMEBODY GIVE
US RIGHT HERE. SOME PEOPLE DON'T
HAVE THAT LUXURY AND ONE DAY THE
PLAN IS TO HAVE THIS LINE GO
FROM HERE TO THE AIRPORT. AND
WITHOUT MEASURES LIKE THIS- IT
WOULD NOT BE AS AS A VIABLE SO.
AS WE TRY TO GET PEOPLE OUT OF
THEIR CARS AND IMPROVE OUR LOCAL
AIR QUALITY WHICH IS VERY
PROBLEMATIC HERE IN THIS
REGIONAL BATHTUB SACRAMENTO HAS
A BOSS FIGHT CLIMATE CHANGE.
PUBLIC TRANSIT THE KEY PIECE OF
THE PUZZLE. AND THIS ALLOWS US
TO- MAKE NECESSARY IMPROVEMENTS
FOR THE FUTURE AND LAST YEAR I
BILL THANK YOU. VERY GOOD- THE
MOST IS TO PASS TO TRAIN. PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS COME.
CABALLERO I TO. EXPIRY THANKS I
DOLLY. RUSSELL BROWN I AGREE.
SKINNER WIENER. SKINNER AYE
WIENER WIENER I'M FOR DESERVE.
DOES THAT WILL PUT IT ON CALL
FOR THE APPS MEMBERS MOVING ON
FILE ITEM SIC WHICH IS AB NIGHT
ONE. FORAGERS OKAY THANK YOU
THANK YOU FOR WORK WITH US AND
YES WE DO. ACCEPT OUR COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS HAVE BEEN PROPOSED
HERE. THIS MEASURE IS A POLICE
THOUGHT THAT. INTO TRANCE.
SIMPLY STATING THAT AS OPPOSED
TO EVERY NOW AND THEN READING
AND LOCAL NEWSPAPER ONLINE ABOUT
IT SETTLEMENT FROM A LOCAL
JURISDICTION. FROM FOR POLICE
MISCONDUCT AT THE LOCAL CITIES
MUST HAVE A MORE ROBUST.
MEASURES CITIES AND LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS THAT ROBUST
MEASURES AND PROCESS TO MAKE
THESE. PUBLIC OUT OF THE GATE-
THERE IS NO OPPOSITION ON THIS
BILL AND A RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE VOTE. GOOD YOU HAVE A LEAD
WITH. IN THIS ARE I DO GO AHEAD
AND JUMP IN- I BELIEVE DO YES.
MORE CHAIRMAN ERICA LEGISLATIVE
OUT WITH THE SO YOU ACTION WHERE
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB NINETY
BECAUSE POLICE MISCONDUCT COSTS
CALIFORNIA TO. MAY OF EVERY. BUT
THE TOTAL SO AND THAT CAR ARE
HARDLY ACCESSIBLE BY THE PUBLIC.
CURRENT LAW ALLOWS CITIZENS TO
FILE CIVIL SUITS OR CLAIMS
AGAINST POLICE OR SHERIFF'S FOR
MISCONDUCT OR USE OF FORCE
INCIDENTS THAT RESULT IN DEATH
OR SERIOUS BODILY INJURY. STATE
LAW STIPULATES OFFICERS ARE NOT
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ECONOMIC
DAMAGES OF THESE LAWSUITS
INSTEAD THE SETTLEMENTS
TYPICALLY COME FROM THE GENERAL
FUND OF THE CITY INVOLVED. IF
THE LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
ITSELF PAYS ITS PART OF A LARGER
LINE ITEM FOR SETTLING OFFICER
MISCONDUCT LITIGATION THAT MEANS
CITY AND COUNTY BUDGETS ALLOCATE
FUNDS TO THEIR LAW ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES WITH THE EXPECTATION
THAT THEY WILL BE FINANCIALLY
LIABLE FOR THEIR WRONGDOING YEAR
OVER YEAR. WHAT TAXPAYERS PAY
FOR THE SETTLEMENTS THE PUBLIC
WILL OFTEN HEAR ABOUT THE
SETTLEMENT ONLY FROM NEWSPAPERS
INFORMATION ABOUT THE FINANCIAL
IMPLICATIONS OF THESE POLICE
MISCONDUCT SETTLEMENTS IS
DIFFICULT TO FIND AND FREQUENTLY
REQUIRES A P. R. EIGHT REQUEST
TO GET DETAILS. AB TWELVE NINETY
RICK CITIES AND COUNTIES TO POST
FINANCIAL DETAILS ABOUT POLICE
MISCONDUCT SETTLEMENTS AND
JUDGMENTS ON THEIR WEBSITES. THE
SETTLEMENTS RESULT IN LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS PAYING OUT
SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS OF TAXPAYER
DOLLARS THAT COULD BE USED TO
REINVEST IN THE COMMUNITY.
CITIZENS HAVE THE RIGHT TO KNOW
HOW THEIR GOVERNMENTS ARE
SPENDING HARD EARNED TAX
DOLLARS. BUT REQUIRING
MUNICIPALITIES TO PUBLICLY POST
FINANCIAL DETAILS OF THEIR LAW
ENFORCEMENT USE OF FOR
SETTLEMENTS. AB TWELVE NINETY
ONE PROVIDES MUCH NEEDED
TRANSPARENCY FOR TAXPAYERS ON
WHERE THEIR TAX DOLLARS ARE
BEING SPENT. AB TWELVE NINETY
ONE WILL HELP US UNDERSTAND
WHETHER THE MANY REFORMS THAT
THIS BODY HAS PASSED TO REIN IN
POLICE MISCONDUCT. SUCH AS THAT
RACIAL IDENTITY PROFILING ACT
REFORM OF THE USE OF DEADLY
FORCE MANDATE FOR INTERVENING
AND DE ESCALATING HAVE HAD THEIR
INTENDED OUTCOMES FOR THESE
REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR IPHONE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
. OTHERS IN SUPPORT. GOOD
MORNING. LESLIE CALDWELL HOUSTON
FOR THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION- AND WE
ARE IN SUPPORT OF AB TWELVE
NINETY ONE. I WAS A PUBLIC
DEFENDER OF SENATORS WIENER AND
SKINNER OF HEARD ME SAY NINETY
MILLION TIMES FOR NEARLY FORTY
YEARS IN TWO DIFFERENT COUNTIES-
AFTER I RETIRED I SERVED FOR TWO
YEARS ON THE SOLANO COUNTY CIVIL
GRAND JURY. ONE OF THE ISSUES WE
LOOKED AT WAS THE USE OF FORCE
BY LAW ENFORCEMENT IN OUR COUNTY
AND HOW MUCH TAXPAYER MONEY WAS
PAID OUT TO SETTLE LAWSUITS.
ALLEGING THE USE OF EXCESSIVE
FORCE BY OUR LOCAL AGENCIES.
FIVE MINUTES I HAD NEVER KNOWN
EXCEPT FOR NEWSPAPER ARTICLES
ABOUT NUMEROUS VERY LARGE
PAYMENTS BY THE CITIES AND
COUNTIES CITIES IN AND THE
COUNTY OF SOLANO. IN THESE
LAWSUITS I WONDERED AT THE TIME
WHY THERE WASN'T A TRANSPARENT
MECHANISM TO ALLOW THE CITIZENS
TO SEE HOW MUCH OF THE MONEY WAS
BEING SPENT. DUE TO THE USE OF
EXCESSIVE FORCE IT SHOULDN'T
TAKE A CIVIL GRAND JURY SUBPOENA
INQUIRY AND SUBSEQUENT REPORT OR
A PUBLIC INFORMATION ACT REQUEST
TO MAKE THIS INFORMATION FULLY
PUBLIC. CVA HAS A LONG STANDING
HISTORY OF ADVOCATING FOR POLICE
TRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY AND
ACCESSIBILITY WE FEEL THAT AB
TWELVE NINETY ONE PROVIDES
IMPORTANT PUBLIC ACCESS TO
POLICE ACTIVITY. EASY ACCESS TO
CRITICAL INFORMATION REGARDING
POLICE SETTLEMENTS AND JUDGMENTS
IS A MUCH NEEDED CORRECTION TO
THE OPAQUE INFORMATION AND
SECRECY THAT CURSIVE KURTIS.
CURRENTLY SHROUDS MUCH OF THIS
INFORMATION FROM PUBLIC VIEW. A
TWELVE NINE ONE WILL PROVIDE
TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
BY PROVIDING THE PUBLIC WITH A
CLEAR WAY TO LEARN ABOUT THE
ACTIONS OF OUR LAW ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES AND THE COSTS OF SOME
OF THOSE ACTIONS WE RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
ANYBODY ELSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL IN ROOM TWENTY TWO
HUNDRED. SINGMAN IS THERE
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
SUPPORT- SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
THING THEN WE'LL GO ON TO THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASK IS
THERE ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE.
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION. AB. TWELVE NINETY
ONE. SPEAKING OUT THIS IS. OF AB
TWELVE NINETY ONE OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE TO ZERO
AT THIS TIME. M. AND CHAIR NO
COMMENTS IN QUEUE AT THIS TIME
VERY GOOD WILL BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS
COMMENTS CONCERNS. SENATE
SENATOR SKINNER THERE IS A
MOTION BY. SENATOR WIENER HE
JUMPED BUT THAT'S OKAY SO-
ASSEMBLY MEMBER I'M GLAD YOU
BROUGHT THIS BILL BECAUSE-
WASN'T REFERENCED WAS VERY GOOD
WORK WE'VE DONE ON POLICE
RECORDS. AND SO OBVIOUSLY FOR
PUBLIC NOW HAS THE ABILITY TO
FIND OUT. IF THERE'S AN OFFICER
WHO HAS AN- IS HOW SUBSTANTIATED
AGAINST THEM ON A VARIETY OF
CATEGORIES OF MISCONDUCT- SO YOU
CAN FIND OUT NOW BUT WHAT YOU
DON'T KNOW. WHEN YOU FIND OUT IS
HOW MUCH MONEY YOU'RE
JURISDICTION MAY HAVE PAID OUT.
TO SETTLE A CASE RELATED TO THAT
OFFICER AND THERE CAN BE IN SOME
CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE A SINGLE
OFFICER. IS THE CAUSE OF NUMBERS
OF PAYOUTS IN SO THIS GIVES US A
MUCH BROADER PICTURE OF THAT
CIRCUMSTANCE AND APPRECIATE THE
BILL AND MR WINNERS ALREADY
LIFTED. WITH BROAD. WHAT SYNCING
FURTHER COMMENTS QUESTION OR
COULD OUR ALLOW YOU KIND. YES
THANK YOU SAN SKINNER WE DIDN'T
WRECK IT IN OUR TALKING POINTS
BUT THAT AFFECTS ANALYSIS BY MR
GROUNDS FOR MISTRIAL I'LL-
MENTIONS THE FORMAT. MEASURE
MORE IMPORTANT THIS GROUND
BREAKING RESEARCH LAST YEAR BY
THE PROFESSOR FORGET HER NAME.
TALKED ABOUT THAT MORE THE
PUBLIC KNOWS ABOUT THE THESE
THESE INCIDENTS AND HOW MUCH
IMPACTS TO TAXPAYERS THE MORE
LIKELY THEY'RE GOING TO DO
THINGS LIKE FROM THAT PROMOTE DE
ESCALATION I KNOW YOU SUPPORTING
YOUR BIG MEASURE FOR YEARS AGO
AND BRING ABOUT SMART REFORMS TO
JURISDICTIONS AND SO- THERE FOR
RESPECTFULLY ASK THE RIGHT. VERY
GOOD THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS A
IS COMMITTEE ON. SENATORS
CABALLERO CABALLERO I HERE TO.
LAKE SUPERIOR LEG SPINNER HI
DOLLY BLESS. RESO GLAZER SKINNER
. INNER AYE WIENER WIENER I FIVE
ZERO THE BILL IS WILL PUT A ON
CALL THE- MEMBERS MOVE ON FIVE
ITEM NINE. AB EIGHTY SO BY.
ALBUM WELCOME. GOOD MORNING
MADAM CHAIRS YOU VERY. I THANK
YOU ARE SENATORS A APPRECIATE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AB
TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN. TODAY FOR
YOU AND I WANT TO THANK THE
STAFFS OF WORK ON THIS BILL HAS-
NOTED IN A VERY WELL WRITTEN
ANALYSIS I MIGHT SAY ABOUT-
THIS. YEAR WITH SOMETIMES CAN BE
COMPLICATED LOS I PERCEIVE THAT.
ADDITIONALLY I WANT TO MAKE IT
CLEAR THAT I WILL BE IT I WILL
BE ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS. AB TWELVE EIGHTY
SEVEN REQUIRES A CEDAR COUNTY
GROUND ADDITIONAL DENSITY AND
CONFESSIONS OF AN APPLICANT
AGREES TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL
MODERATE INCOME UNITS FOR VERY
LOW INCOME UNITS ON TOP OF THE
MAX AMOUNT OF UNITS FOR LOWER
VERY LOW. OR CURRENT MODERATING
COMMUNITY BONUSES. AS YOU KNOW
ALL TOO WELL WE ARE THE MIDST OF
A HOUSING. WHICH NOT ONLY
RENDERS UNAFFORDABLE IN A LARGE
NUMBER OF LOW AND MIDDLE CLASS
INDIVIDUALS. BUT ALSO COST THE
STATE BILLIONS IN LOST ECONOMIC
OUTPUT ANNUALLY. ALL THE STUDIES
TELL IN DATA TELLS US THAT WE
NEED TO BUILD MILLIONS OF NEWS
HOUSING UNITS MUCH QUICKER THAN
WE ARE DOING SO TODAY. TO GET
OUT OF THE HOLE THAT WE HAVE
FOUND OURSELVES IN. COMMENTED
SEVERAL CRUCIAL MEASURES TO
ENHANCE PROVISION AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FOR EXTREMELY LOW AND
LOW INCOME INDIVIDUALS. AND WE
SHOULD DO THAT AS TO HOW THEY
ARE VERY VULNERABLE POPULATIONS
IN NEED OF HELP HERE IN OUR
STATE HOWEVER A LIPSTICK
APPROACH TO THE HOUSING CRISIS
REQUIRES THAT WE ALSO TALKED
TACKLE. HOUSING UNAFFORDABILITY
FOR MIDDLE INCOME EARNERS. THE
BERKELEY TURNER CENTER FOR
HOUSING INNOVATION FOUND THAT
40% OF MIDDLE INCOME RENTERS.
SPEND MORE THAN 30% OF THEIR
INCOME ON HOUSING. WHILE 10% OF
THOSE MIDDLE INCOME RENTERS ARE
SEVERELY COST BURDENED MEANING
THAT MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR
MONTHLY INCOME GOES TO THEIR
HOUSING EXPENSES. THIS COST
BURDEN HAS CONTINUED TO GROW AS
WE HAVE FAILED TO BUILD ENOUGH
MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING UNITS TO
REDUCE PRICES. AND RELEASE
PRESSURE FROM THE OVERALL
HOUSING MARKET. ALTHOUGH THERE
IS AN URGENT DEMAND FOR MILLIONS
OF HOUSING UNITS LAST YEAR'S
RECORDS FROM THE US DEPARTMENT
OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
INDICATE THAT ONLY A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY THOUSAND UNITS WERE
PERMITTED. HIDING A SIGNIFICANT
SHORTFALL IN UNITS. BY GIVING OF
BUILDERS AN ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE
UNDER THE CURRENT DENSITY BONUS
LAW TO BUILD MORE MODERATE
INCOME UNITS AB TWELVE EIGHTY
SEVEN IS A CRITICAL STEP TOWARD
PROVIDING. SOME OF THAT RELIEF.
I'D LIKE TO NOW TURN IT OVER TO
OUR WITNESSES FIRST TO WE HAVE
WILLIAM MORE. WITH WHOSE POLICY
COUNSEL WITH CIRCULATE SAN DIEGO
AND THEN WE HEAR FROM REMY
CORTES FROM REMI URBAN HIMSELF.
WELCOME HELLO THANK YOU SENATORS
MONEY IS WILLIAM MORE AM A
POLICY COUNCIL FOR CIRCULATE SAN
DIEGO CIRCULATE SAN DIEGO IS A-
NONPROFIT THINK TANK. IN THE SAN
DIEGO REGION OF THAT. BRINGS
TOGETHER A NUMBER OF. INTEREST
GROUPS DEVELOPERS NONPROFIT
DEVELOPERS. AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
ADVOCATES AND TRANSIT ADVOCATES-
TO FIND NEW AND BETTER POLICIES
THAT WILL HELP ENHANCE BOTH ARE
TRANSIT OPTIONS AND OUR HOUSING
OPTIONS. THE CIRCULATE SAN DIEGO
DID A STUDY OF THE- DENSITY
BONUSES- SANDIA. REGION AND
THEIR EFFECTIVENESS FROM THE
TWENTY FIFTEEN TO TWENTY TWENTY
PERIOD. SOME OF THESE VERY SAME
REFORMS WERE INSTITUTED IN
CALIFORNIA LAW IN TWENTY TWENTY-
AND HAVE BEEN EFFECTIVE SENSE
BUT- DURING THAT PERIOD OF TIME
WHEN. HOUSING STARTS WERE NOT.
NOT KEEPING PACE WITH WHAT WE
NEED. OBVIOUSLY THE INCENTIVES
AND THE DENSITY BONUS PROGRAMS
THAT WE HAVE IN SAN DIEGO WHICH
ARE THE ONES THAT WERE AMENDING
HERE TODAY- THOSE RESULTED IN
THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF
ADDITIONAL UNITS BOTH AFFORDABLE
AND MARKET RATE- THE THEORY HERE
IS OF COURSE THAT. ONE YOU
PRESERVE SOME ELEMENT OF LOCAL
CONTROL BY EXPANDING
OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL. ALL THE
ZONING DESIGNATIONS TO BE
ENHANCED. WITH THE- WITH THE
DENSITY BONUSES. AT EVERY LEVEL
THE SOAP SOMETHING SMALL CAN BE
SOMEWHAT LESS SMALL SOMETHING
LARGE COULD BE NOT
PROPORTIONALLY GROWTH IF THE
DEVELOPER ACCEPTS THE- DUTY TO.
PROVIDE LONG TERM FIXED-
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADDS A
SPECIFIC VERY LOW LOWER MODERATE
INCOME. THIS BILL WOULD ONLY
APPLY ONLY PROVIDE THAT
ADDITIONAL DENSITY BONUS IN THE
EVENT THAT ALL OF THE PREVIOUS
DENSITY BONUSES HAD BEEN
COMPLETELY USED UP SO THAT IT'S
ADDITIVE IT DOESN'T CANNIBALIZE
OUR PREVIOUS INCENTIVE PROGRAMS-
THE- AMENDMENTS PROPOSED TO MAKE
SURE THAT THERE'S NOT EXCESSIVE
CONCENTRATION OF- OF- LOWER
INCOME HOUSING- AND- THAT'S
THAT'S WELL TAKEN SO. WE'VE-
WE'VE ACCEPTED WE RECOMMENDED
THE ACCEPTANCE THAT AMENDMENT-
AND- WE ALSO HAVE HERE A
DEVELOPER WHO HAS TAKEN
ADVANTAGE OF THESE PROGRAMS AND
CAN ATTEST TO HOW EFFECTIVE THEY
ARE IN EXPANDING HOUSING BOTH
MARKET RATE AND- AND SUBSIDIZED-
IS A RUNNING FOR TALES OF SAN
DIEGO SO HE WILL BE ABLE TO.
COME UP AND TELL YOU A LITTLE
MORE ABOUT THAT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH APPRECIATED. GOOD MORNING
CHAIR MEMBERS MY NAME IS RANDY
CORTEZ AND I'M AN INFILL
DEVELOPER BUILDER OF TRANSIT
ORIENTED HOUSING IN SAN DIEGO.
VINER SOLD NOT ONLY TO HOUSING
CRISIS BUT HUMANITARIAN CRISIS
AS THE NUMBER ON HOUSE NEIGHBORS
CONTINUES TO RISE TO ARE DUE TO
OUR INABILITY TO BUILD HOUSING
AT ALL INCOME LEVELS. WITHOUT
DENSITY BONUS INCENTIVE BASED
PROGRAMS NONE OF MY PROJECTS
WOULD BE FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE
THAT DOESN'T MEAN SMALLER
PROJECTS WITH LESS UNITS MEANS
NO PROJECTS ZERO HOMES. 90% OF
ALL HOUSING ACROSS THE STATE IS
BUILT BY PRIVATE DEVELOPERS
WITHOUT GOVERNMENT SUBSIDY WILL
ONLY 10% OF HOUSING IS BILLED
GOVERNMENT FINANCIAL SUBSIDY
THIS IS ONE CENTER BASED PROGRAM
HOUSE HOUSING PROGRAMS. LIKE AB
TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN MIDDLE
INCOME DENSITY BONUS ARE SO
IMPORTANT. THE CURRENT
AFFORDABLE DANCE BONUS PROGRAM
IS WORKING GREAT AND INCENTIVIZE
IS VERY LOW INCOME HOUSING BUT
NOT MIDDLE INCOME. EVEN IN THE
CITY OF SAN DIEGO HAS MADE
STRIDES IN POLICY AND HOUSING
PRODUCTION IN OUR LAST REDUCE
CYCLE ENDING IN TWENTY TWENTY.
THERE WERE ONLY THIRTY SEVEN
MODERN HOME INCOME HOMES BUILT
OF THE FIFTEEN THOUSAND FOUR
HUNDRED SIXTY TWO TARGETED.
THAT'S LESS THAN ONE QUARTER OF
ONE PERCENT. I WAS BORN AND
RAISED IN SAN DIEGO JUST MILES
FROM THE U. S. MEXICO BORDER AND
MY MOM'S A FIRST GENERATION
IMMIGRANT FROM MEXICO. AND I'M A
LUCKY ONE TO BE ABLE TO AFFORD
TO LIVE NEAR MY PARENTS BUT DUE
TO THE COST OF HOUSING MANY OF
MY FRIENDS HAVE MOVED OUT MOVED
OUT OF THE STATE. AWAY FROM
THEIR LOVED ONES. THIS IS A JUST
TO FOR MY FRIENDS THE NUMBER ONE
CHALLENGE FOR RECRUITING
RETAINING POLICE OFFICERS
FIREFIGHTERS TEACHERS AND OTHER
ESSENTIAL MIDDLE INCOME WORKERS.
IS THEY SIMPLY CAN'T AFFORD TO
LIVE WHERE THEY WORK IN
CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL WOULD
SUPPORT MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING
PROJECTS I BUILD WHERE WE NEED
IT MOST ALONG TRANSIT CORRIDORS
AND JOBCENTRE. IMAGE WE ALL WANT
TO. COPY OF YOUR SO CAN MAKE
SURE THAT TRANS OR IN
DEVELOPMENT NOW HAPPEN. IN OUR
COMMUNITY AS WELL THERE ANYONE
ELSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL HERE IN
ROOM TWENTY TWO HUNDRED. MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS ALEX FOR
INSTRUCTORS I'M REALLY FOR THE
BEAR ACCOUNT. BECAUSE HANS
INSTRUCTS THANK YOU. VERY MUCH.
HI RISE HAPPEN BEHALF OF TO.
FEDERAL PROPERTIES BY I PROPERTY
THANK HOUSING SEVENTY EIGHT
DIEGO THEY CAN. AS DIFFICULT
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
VENTURA OF THE COMMITTEE THEN
PUT AN A KIND OF A HIGH ON
BEHALF COLOR. BE STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. VERY MUCH. NECRO
WE'RE STRATEGIES ON BEHALF
CALIFORNIA BUILDING IN SO. AND
THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE IN
SUPPORT. IS THERE ANYBODY HERE
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION. DESPITE OPPOSITION.
EMMANUEL MOVE ON TO THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE MODERATOR IF
YOU CAN KEEP INDIVIDUALS AT.
INTENSIFY EITHER IN SUPPORT OR
IN OPPOSITION. FOR SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION FOR AB FORTY SEVEN
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS
MOMENT. WE'LL GO TO LINE TWENTY
SEVEN. MICHAEL LANGUAGE PER PROP
CO SPONSOR IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU. WE HAVE NO
FOR THE SUPPORT OPPOSITION GOOD
WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS COMMENTS
THE MOTION. THE BILL IF THERE IS
A MOTION- THINK SAYING NO NO
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS PRESHEAF
WHAT YOU'RE DOING HERE-
APPRECIATE THE YOUR CUTE WORKING
TO TAKE THE AMENDMENTS AND WILL
ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE THANK YOU
I APPRECIATE- AGAIN THE
OPPORTUNITY COME BEFORE YOU. AS
I STATED BY THE TESTIMONY IT'S
AN OPPORTUNITY TO POTENTIALLY
BUILD- MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING
WHICH IS REALLY- A PART OF THE-
POPULATION THAT- I THINK WE NEED
TO WORK MORE ON AND THAT'S THE
ATTEMPT THIS BILL TO TRY TO
CREATE MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
MIDDLE INCOME INDIVIDUALS. AND
AGAIN FREESHEET THE WORK FROM
STAFF AND- WORKING TOWARDS-
BRINGING FORWARD A FINAL PRODUCT
THAT I HOPE I CONTINUE TO
RECEIVE UNANIMOUS SUPPORT
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. OCEAN IS DO
PASSES AMENDED DO APPROPRIATIONS
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL CENTRES
CABALLERO I SEVEN ZERO I SEAR
TWO. LAKE SUPERIOR AND LAKE
SUPERIOR I DAWALY DRESSEL
DRESSEL I GLAZER SKINNER FIVE
SKINNER AYE WIENER. WIENER I AM
FIVE ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WILL
PUT IT ON CALL FOR THE APPS OF
YOURS- JUST WANTED VICE A
COMMITTEE THAT I'VE BEEN
INSTRUCTED THAT WE SHOULD
TERMINATE AT. TWELVE FIFTEEN OR
WE SHOULD BREAK A TWELVE FIFTEEN
TERMINATE- SO WE'LL TRY TO SEE
WHO WHO COULD WE CAN GET IN
BECAUSE WE COME BACK LATE THIS
AFTERNOON AFTER SESSION. AND
AFTER. RULES SO IT'S LIKELY TO
BE LATE- FILE ITEM NUMBERS
NUMBER TEN- EIGHTY BE THIRTEEN
THIRTY TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER CUT
ME OFF. WELCOME SPECULUM. IN A
SIMILAR. THANK YOU FOR ME TO
PURSUE US BILL TWO THROUGH TWO.
BEFORE I BEGIN I WOULD LIKE TO
RESPECT EXCEPT THE COMMITTEE
SOME. WHICH ENSURE A PRO PLANS
REFLECT BILL CODES. THIS IS A
COMMON SENSE WHICH RISK BY SINCE
. ALSO LEVINE COLOR HAS FAILED
TO ANY NEAR AND NEW HOW UNITS
RECORD OUT WE THE MAN. OVER THE
SEVERAL TO THE LEGISLATURE HAS
AGREED THAT ACCESS REBELLING
UNITS OR EIGHTY USE SHOULD BE
PART OF THE SOLUTION. MAKING
VIDEOS MORE ACCESSIBLE AND MORE
AFFORDABLE SHOULD CONTINUE TO BE
A CORNERSTONE OF OUR EFFORTS TO
ADDRESS A HOUSING CRISIS.
WHETHER BY PROVIDING AFFORDABLE
OPTION TO FAMILY MEMBERS AND
LOVED ONES. FOR US RENTAL INCOME
BUILDING AND OWNING IN AB YOU
CAN BE A LIFE CHANGING MASSIVE.
AND FOR. ONE OF THE FIRST AREAS
HOMEOWNERS RUNNING ONE CLOSE
THAN THE YOU FUNNY TO SIGN IN
THE UNIT ITSELF. HOME SPENT
THOUSANDS OF THE TO FIVE OUT
COULD ONE ENGINE JUST FIND OUT
HOW MUCH BILL THE UNIT COST. FOR
MANY LOW AND MIDDLE IN HOME THIS
IS SIMPLY NOT AN OPTION. TO
ADDRESS THIS ISSUE SOME LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS HAVE STARTED TO
PROVIDE PRE APPROVED PLANS READY
TO USE INCLUDING LOS ANGELES.
AND SAN JOSE. AS WELL AS A SHARE
PROGRAM ACROSS SIXTEEN CITIES IN
NAPA AND SONOMA COUNTIES. AB
THIRTEEN THREE TWO WILL SPEED UP
THE PROCESS AND LOWER THE COSTS
WOULD BE LIMITED TO USE FAT
REQUIRES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
KEEP A CATALOG. OF PRE APPROVAL
TO USE. ABOUT TO GO ON TO BE ON
THEIR WEBSITE. THIS CATALOG OF
PRE APPROVED PLANS IDOLS THEY
MOVED BILL. OKAY WE HAVE A
MOTION- ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE I
THINK SHE'S TRYING TO SAY LET'S
. I THINK PEOPLE ARE IN SUPPORT
BUT I DON'T WANT TO PRE JUDGE
EVERYBODY'S AT- BEEN BUT WITH
WITHOUT A REQUEST OF
RESPECTFULLY HOW. WISEMAN DO YOU
HAVE WITH PER WOULDN'T HERE WE
DO HAVE UP. WE'RE. SIR PLEASE
COME FORWARD YOU. MISTER JORDAN
I'M A CO. THANK YOUNG MAKE SURE
TO KEEP IT SHORT- COMMITTEE
MANAGER MEMBERS A COMMITTEE YOUR
AT A OF A HIGHLY SET UP FOR CALL
. BE HE JUST BECAUSE OF COURSE
TV THIRTEEN THIRTY. THIRTY TWO
OF CALIFORNIA'S AT THIRTY FIVE
HOW HOMES OUR HOUSING SUPPLY
WITH LAST FIVE YEARS THE AS OF
THE RESULT OF. TO EIGHTY
LEGISLATION. EIGHTY YEARS OF
ALSO OFFER FOR THE TO BENEFIT
FROM FOR PREVIOUSLY IN A-
WEALTHY NEIGHBOR. WITH GOOD HIGH
HI CALL SCHOOLS PARK.
REPUBLICANS WERE. OTHER AMENITY
. BILLION THIS. MANY SEE HAVE
STARTED A PRE APPROVED EIGHTY
YOU PLANS THAT. STREAMLINES FOR
THE STREAMER THE PROCESS FOR
HOME LOOKING TO HELP AS- NEEDED
A NEW IN A BACK. AB THIRTEEN TWO
HILLARY THE PROCESS AND OR THE
COST OF A YEARS BY LOOK
GOVERNMENTS TO KEEP A CAT. FOR
PRE OF EIGHTY ON WEBSITE AND
WITH THAT RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR SUPPORT FOR BI THIRTY
THIRTY TWO THANKS MUCH FOR THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. WELL TO REMEMBER
NEGRO ON BEHALF THE SOUTH AND-
SO OF GOVERNMENTS. SUPPORT FROM
WITH A THE AUTHOR. HIS AMENDMENT
TO IN THE COMING- HOPEFULLY TO
WORK WITH- THE AUTHOR OVER THE
SUMMER A COUPLE DIFFERENT COLOR
FOR. THANK YOU FOR GOOD THANK
YOU. ALLOSAURUS BEAR IT COUNTS
ONCE THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
ANYBODY IN ROOM TO TWO HUNDRED
AND UP TO. SEAMEN WILL MOVE TO
THE TO. LINE MODERATOR FEW KEY
QUEUE UP OPPOSITE OR SUPPORT.
FOR SUPPORT. FOR EIGHTY.
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO PLEASE
PRESS. ONE THEN. ZERO I'M SURE
WE HAVE MOST OF OFF THE- VERY
GOOD BREED TO THE CA. WE DO HAVE
A MOTION ANYBODY. HAVE ANY
COMMENTS SAYING NONE WILL ALLOW
YOU TO CONCLUDE. WHY THANK YOU
VERY TIME I JUST RESPECT AS FROM
A VOTE THANK VERY GOOD THANK YOU
THE MOTION IS. TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
SENATORS COVER YOU AT ALL HI
COMING YET ALL I SEE ARE TWO
LAKE SUPERIOR. LEG SPINNER I
DOLLY THE RUSSELL THE REST SO I
GLAZER. GLAZER AYE SKINNER
SKINNER AYE WIENER. WIENER I AM
SIX TWO ZERO THANK YOU THAT BILL
IS OUT AND I WILL PUT IT ON CALL
FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS MEMBERS-
I DO NOT SEE ANY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
SO MAYBE WE CAN- I'M SORRY I'M
JUST TOTALLY MISSED YOU MY
APOLOGIES. LET ME LET ME DO A
COUPLE OF HOUSEKEEPING THINGS-
IF WE CAN TAKE UP THE CONSENT
AGENDA ITEMS- THE MODE THERE IS
A MOTION ON THE CONSENT AGENDA.
ITEMS PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MOTION IS SET UP CONSENT
CALENDAR SENATORS COME YET ALL
HI COVER YET- I HERE TO. LAKE
SUPERIOR LEG SPINNER I DOLLY
WOULD ALSO. DOURESSEAUX I.
GLAZER ICE. FIVE SKINNER I WE-
WIENER I AM SIXTY. THAT IS OUT
IN- WILL PUT IT ON CALL FOR
ABSENT. SENATOR WHEN YOU GO YES
I KNOW. HI GONNA COORDINATES
YOU'RE NOT GONNA KLUGER
COMMITTEE BEFORE HOW YOU'RE
GONNA. WITH ALL THE THING THAT
ARE HAVE THE SAP. WE AT THE DEAD
. THE ARE AFTER THE- OF CENTER
RULES SO WE'RE THEIR- AFTER
FLOOR SESSION AFTER FLOOR
SESSION. OKAY AND THEN SENATE
RULE HAS A ROOM AND WE COME
BACK. AFTER RULES THAT IS. ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU YEAH. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GARCIA LET'S LET'S GET TO
IN OKAY YOU VERY MUCH CENTER
EIGHT THIRTEEN EIGHTY FIVE YES
THANK YOU THAT'S A- BILL CHANGES
THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION'S.
SALES TAX AUTHORITY RIVERSIDE
COUNTY IS THE FASTEST GROWING
COUNTY IN THE STATE IN THE
FIFTH. FASTEST GROWING IN THE
COUNTRY AS A RESULT OF THIS
POPULATION GROWTH AND
INFRASTRUCTURE. DEMANDS AND
IMPACTS- WE WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THE COUNTY HAS THE
AUTHORITY TO GO TO THE VOTERS.
IF THEY CHOSE SO CHOOSE TO
INCREASE THEIR INVESTMENTS INTO.
ROAD INFRASTRUCTURE. I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
THE WITH THE CITY'S RELATIVE
DIRECTOR OF THE- RIVERSIDE
COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
. VERY GOOD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
COMING YEAR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS I'M MAYOR THE A-
DIRECTOR OF RIVERSIDE COUNTY
TREE. FOR CTC THIS OF THE BILL
AND AS MICHAEL TO BE HERE TODAY
RIVERSIDE COUNTY IS THE FOURTH
MOST POPULOUS COUNTY IN THE
STATE AND TENTH MOST IN THE
COUNTRY. RIVERSIDE COUNTY HAS
BEEN TASKED WITH BUILDING MORE
THAN ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTY SEVEN
THOUSAND HOUSING UNITS BY TWENTY
TWENTY NINE. OUR POPULATION IS
EXPECTED TO REACH THREE MILLION
RESIDENTS BY TWENTY FORTY EIGHT
UP FROM TWO AND A HALF MILLION.
IN TWENTY TWENTY TWO AS A SELF
HELP COUNTY ARE RESIDENTS OF
TWICE SELECTED TO TAX THEMSELVES
TO INVEST IN TRANSPORTATION.
THANKS TO BOTH THE VOTER
APPROVED HALF CENT SALES TAX
MEASURE MEASURE A OR C. T. C.
FOR NEARLY THIRTY FIVE YEARS HAS
GENERATED THOUSANDS OF JOBS AND
EFFICIENTLY PROVIDED MORE THAN
FOUR POINT ONE BILLION DOLLARS.
FOR ALL MODES OF TRANSPORTATION
PROMISES MADE. PROMISES CABS. IT
IS A PATIENT OF A POTENTIAL NEW
MEASURE IN TWENTY TWENTY OR C.
T. C. IDENTIFIED OVER EIGHT
POINT EIGHT BILLION DOLLARS IN
NEEDED MOBILITY INVESTMENTS.
OUTSIDE OF MEASURE A HOWEVER
THESE EFFORTS WERE PUT ON HOLD
DUE TO THE PANDEMIC. ALL THE
WHILE PROJECT DELIVERY COSTS IN
NEEDS HAVE GROWN EXPONENTIALLY.
AB THIRTEEN EIGHTY FIVE UPDATES
OR CTC SALES TAX AUTHORITY FROM
ONE CENT TO ONE AND A HALF CENT
PER DOLLAR. KEEPING OUR OPTIONS
OPEN IF WE ARE TO MATCH HISTORIC
STATE AND FEDERAL INVESTMENTS.
TO ADDRESS ADDRESS OUR
INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDS AND BUILD A
TWENTY FIRST CENTURY MULTI MODAL
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM. IS
IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THIS
BILL. DOES NOT CHANGE MEASURING
. IS STILL RIGHT A VOTE
RIVERSIDE COUNTY RESIDENTS TO
APPROVE A NEW TAX MEASURE IN THE
FUTURE. THE COMMISSION COMPRISED
OF ELECTED OFFICIALS FROM THE
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND THE
TWENTY EIGHT CITIES IN RIVERSIDE
COUNTY VOTED TO SPONSOR THIS
BILL. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME
TODAY AND THANK YOU TO
ASSEMBLYMEMBER GARCIA FOR
AUTHORING THE BILL HAPPY TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY
HAVE AN RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. THERE ANYONE ELSE
IN SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
KIANA VALENTINE ON BEHALF OF THE
COACHELLA VALLEY ASSOCIATION OF
GOVERNMENTS ALSO IN STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. I AM NOT SURE MEMBERS MARC
WATTS REPRESENTING
TRANSPORTATION CALIFORNIANS FROM
SUPPORT THIS MEASURE APPRECIATED
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE
IN ROOM TWENTY TWO HUNDRED IN
SUPPORT. THERE ANYBODY IN TWENTY
TWO HUNDRED IN OPPOSITION.
SEAMAN WILL MOVE ON TO THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE MODERATOR
FEW COULD QUEUE UP OPPOSITION
AND SUPPORT. SUPPORT OPPOSITION
FOR ABC THIRTEEN EIGHTY FIVE
PLEASE PRESS. ONE THEN. ZERO
MADAM CHAIR WE HAVE NO SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION VERY GOOD. WE DO
HAVE A MOTION BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
SENATOR DRIES UP ANY COMMENTS
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS. SEEING
NONE IT WILL ALLOW YOU TO
COMPLETE YOU CAN. RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. MOTION IS TO PASS TO
THE SENATE FLOOR SENATORS COVER
YOU AT ALL HI CABALLERO I
SEYARTO LAKE SUPERIOR. HI PLEASE
BEAR I DAWALY WRESTLE
DOURESSEAUX ICLEAR. SKINNER
WIENER. WIENER I'M FORTY ZERO
FORTY ZERO WILL BE PUT FUND FOR
THE ABSENT MEMBERS WE MOVE ON TO
FILE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB
FOURTEEN NINETY BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER LAKE WELCOME. HELLO THANK
YOU KAREN SENATORS FIRST ELECTED
THANK THE COMMITTEE STAFF AND
SHARE FOR WORKING WITH US ON
THIS BILL I'LL ACCEPT THE
AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE
COMMITTEE THE MINUTE SPECIFIED
THAT PROJECTS MUST RETAIN ANY
OPEN SPACE ON THE PARCEL.
REQUIRING ON SITE PROPERTY
MANAGER PROJECTS A FIFTY UNITS
OR MORE AND THE LOCAL AGENCY
MADE TONIGHT PROJECT IF IT IS ON
OR IT IS A JOINT TWO APOSS
DEDICATED TO INDUSTRIAL USES. AB
FORTY NINETY ONE COURAGE ADAPTER
REDUCE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROJECTS PROVIDING INCENTIVES
SUCH AS PROVIDING AN EXPEDITED
REVIEW PROCESS ARE EXPECTING
WILL CONTROL ADAPTIVE RE USE IS
WHEN THE REAP WHEN WE REPURPOSE
EXISTING BUILDING TO CREATE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AS A GOVERNOR
DID WITH PROJECT ROOM KEY. AB
FORTY NINETY REMOVE BARRIERS
THAT PROJECTS BY ENSURING
THEY'RE ELIGIBLE FOR A HOUSING
FUNDING AND DON'T GET STUCK IN
INTERNAL PROCESS FOR YEARS. AND
AFTER USE A FASTER AND LESS
EXPENSIVE THAN BUILDING NEW
HOUSING FROM SCRATCH WILL HELP
DRESS THE HOUSING CRISIS. I LIKE
TO DO IS MY WITNESS AND SUPPORT
RED MARTIN FROM THE AIDS
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION. AND
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL WHEN THE
TIME COMES. YOU SO MUCH. THANK
YOU MANAGER MEMBER- WE ALSO
APPRECIATE THE WORK OF AND ADAM
SHE INSTEAD ON THE AND THEN THAT
TO THE MEMBER JUST REVIEWED HIS
QUICK- THEY STILL FOUNDER NOW
HAS OVER FOURTEEN. UNITS OF LOW
INCOME VERY LOW INCOME HOUSING
IN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES THAT
WE DEVELOP THROUGH ADAPTIVE RE
USE OVER THE LAST FIVE YEARS.
SOMETIMES LOCAL GOVERNMENT IS
NOT ALWAYS AS NIMBLE AS WE'D
LIKE THEM TO BE AND THERE ARE
TIMES WHEN OUR- OUR THE PROCESS
HAS TAKEN LONGER THAN WE NEEDED
AND COST MORE. WHICH SORT OF
WORKS AGAINST THE ABILITY OF
ADAPTIVE REUSE TO GET- HOUSING.
UP AND READY AS QUICKLY AND AS
INEXPENSIVELY AS POSSIBLE. AND
WE THINK THE- CHANGES IN THIS
BILL WILL HELP TO SPEED THAT
PROCESS UP. AND GET MORE HOUSING
OUT- FOR LOW INCOME. PEOPLE AND-
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
WE APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
THERE ANYONE ELSE THAT WOULD
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. OF AB
FOURTEEN NINETY. SEEING NO ONE
ARE MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION IS
THERE ANYONE IN ROOM TWENTY TWO
HUNDRED THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
IN OPPOSITION. GOOD MORNING
MADAM CHAIR CAROL SOMETHING UP
THE CITY OF SAN MARCOS AND
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THE
BILL. FREE GOOD ANYONE ELSE. I
THINK NOBODY ELSE WILL MOVE ON
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE AND
ASK IS THERE- MODERATOR IF YOU
COULD QUEUE UP ANY. WITNESSES
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
EITHER IN OPPOSITION OR IN
SUPPORT OF AB FOURTEEN NINETY.
FOR SUPPORTER OPPOSITION FOR AB
FOURTEEN NINETY PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO AT THIS MOMENT. AND WITH
THAT MANAGER WE HAVE NO SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION PRETTY GOOD WILL
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
FOR COMMENTS QUESTIONS CONCERNS
OR MOTIONS. PACER IS A MOTION BY
. THIS CENTER BREAKS PAYER- NO
COMMENTS QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS
WILL ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE I
APPRECIATE YOU YOUR WORK ON
THIS- THINK IT'S REALLY
IMPORTANT IN. YES A
COLLABORATION WITH THE CHAIR THE
COMMITTEE STAFF AND THEIR
SUCCESS RIVAL. VERY GOOD THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS. SENATORS
CABALLERO HI CABALLERO I SEYARTO
LAKE SUPERIOR. WICKS I IN DALI
DOURESSEAUX DURACELL I AGREE.
SKINNER WE WIENER AYE FOR
DESSERT. THAT FEEL IT WILL BACK
ON CALL FOR ABSENT. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GIVES. FILE ITEM IN
FIFTY. AB SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN
YOUR OTHER BILL WAS ON CONSENT
AND- IT'S ON CALL FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH
ON UNDERSTAND THAT COMMITTEES
TRY TO GET OUT OF HERE SO I'M
GOING TO BE. VERY BRIEF AND
THANK THE COMMITTEE IN SO MANY
CHAIRED BY ALLOWING ME. TO
PRESENT IT ASSEMBLY BILL
SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN WHICH SEEKS
TO INCREASE TRANSPARENCY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY BUT LOCAL
AGENCIES THAT RECEIVE FEDERAL
FUNDS- WITH AN EXPIRATION DATE.
IF I COULD JUST BE- SO BRIEF TO
JUST CUT THROUGH THIS- THE
REASON WHY THIS CAME UP. IS
BECAUSE WOMEN ARE MODEST
APOLOGIES RECEIVE FEDERAL FUNDS
AND THEN ME REMOVE MYSELF AS AN
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BUT LET'S TALK
ABOUT ME AS A TAXPAYER AND THEN
FINDING OUT THAT MY CITY OF MY
LOCAL GOVERNMENT HAS TO SEND
MONEY TO THEY CANNOT USE. AND
THEN IT EXPIRES IN THE ABSENT
THAT MONEY BACK IN ONE OF MY
CITIES- THERE WAS A SITUATION
WHERE MONIES- WAS RECEIVED BY
THE FEDERAL THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT SINCE CITIES OF
CERTAIN AMOUNT OF MONEY ABOUT A
HUNDRED FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS-
TO DEAL WITH HOMELESSNESS. AND
THEN IT MADE THE NEWSPAPERS AND
THAT MONEY HAD TO BE SENT BACK
ON USE WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH
THE CRISIS IN OUR CITIES AND IN
OUR COUNTRY EXPRESSLY WHEN YOU
LOOK AT HOT MONEY TO SCARE MARC
TO ADDRESS THE HOMELESS
POPULATION. AND WE SEND THAT
MONEY BACK TO THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT AS IF WE DON'T NEED
IT BUT YET AND STILL WE HAVE A
CRISIS WITH THIS BILL SEEKS TO
DO ITS TRICK CREATE TRANSPARENCY
AND ACCOUNTABILITY AND IT
SIMPLY. I'LL BE ACCEPTING THE
DATES COMMITTEE- THE COMMITTEES-
AMENDMENTS AND THANK THE
COMMITTEE TO WORKING VERY
CLOSELY WITH MY- TEAM IN ORDER
TO STRENGTHEN HIS BAIL MANY
CAN'T THANK THE- THE CHAIR FOR.
INPUT THAT WENT INTO. THAT THIS
BILL THAT YOU HAVE BEFORE US. WE
NEED TO MAKE SURE. ON THE
TRANSFER. AND ACCOUNTABILITY IS
ON EVERY LOW AND SPENT INCOMES
TO. RESOURCES THIS COULD HAVE
BEEN PREVENTED- TO PREVENT
WASTEFUL I'M SPENDING AND ALSO
ENSURE THAT MONIES ARE USED FOR
THE PURPOSE- THAT IT WAS INTO
ATTENDED- AND SO THIS BILL
SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN. IS TRYING TO
GET AT MORE TRANSPARENCY AND
ALSO. PUT IN IN PLACE THAT THE
DEPARTMENT HAS NOTIFIED THE NOT
ONLY THE HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT
BUT ALSO THE ELECTED BODY OF
WHAT TRANSPIRED WHY THIS MONEY'S
BEING SENT BACK SO I
RESPECTFULLY IN ASPEN I VOTE.
GOOD IS THERE ANYBODY HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. IS THERE
ANYBODY HERE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION. HI GOOD MORNING
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS- I'M JEAN
HURST HERE TO STAND OUT FOR THE
URBAN COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA WE
ARE IN A RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION
AB SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN. YEAH AND
IS YOUR ANALYSIS RIGHTLY POINTS
OUT- BECAUSE OF THE CONSIDERABLE
COST OF THE BILL IN ITS CURRENT
FORM WILL IMPOSE ON LOCAL
AGENCIES I'M- GOING TO BE CLEAR
THAT NO LOCAL AGENCY IS
INTERESTED IN RETURNING FEDERAL
FUNDS. HOWEVER WE ARE- OFTEN
OFTEN CONSTRAINED BY COMPLEX AND
STRINGENT FEDERAL REQUIREMENTS
THAT MAKE UTILIZING FEDERAL
RESOURCES AND FEASIBLE- WE ARE
ALSO SUBJECT TO CONSIDERABLE
REPORTING BOTH AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL AND AT THE STATE LEVEL-
FOR ANY FEDERAL DOLLARS THAT WE
RECEIVE- WE DON'T THINK THAT THE
CURRENT VERSION OF AB SEVEN.
SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN ADDRESSES
THOSE ISSUES IN ITS CURRENT FORM
I WOULD REQUIRE PERPETUAL AND
DUPLICATIVE REPORTING WITH
LITTLE BENEFIT. WE UNDERSTAND
THAT THERE ARE AMENDMENTS THAT
ARE BEING TAKEN TODAY WE LOOK
FORWARD TO HER OF REVIEWING THAT
LANGUAGE BUT- AT THIS TIME WE'RE
REMAIN OPPOSED. TO THE BILL
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THE MORNING
UNDER CLEAR WITH THE ECHO. STATE
SO OF- ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
ASSOCIATION AND THE RURAL COUNTY
REPRESENTATIVES THE CALIFORNIA
AND OPPOSITION THANK. THANK YOU
. GOOD MORNING JOHNNY PINA WITH
THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES
ALSO RISK RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. BUT SENIOR FOR THEIR
OPPOSITION- I WILL WE'LL GO TO
THE MODERATOR AND ASK IF THERE
IS ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION- IN SUPPORT.
OF AB. SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN.
PERSIPURA OPPOSITION FOR AB
SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN PLEASE PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO. WE HAVE NO
SUPPORT OPPOSITION MADAM CHAIR
THANK YOU VERY MUCH BRING IT
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
QUESTIONS COMMENTS OR CONCERNS-
A MOTION AT. CENTER DRIVES OF
THE JUST- JUST SICK THE CLARITY
YOU SAID- IN TERMS OF
AMENDMENTS. TO THESE HAVE TO DO
WITH- THE- WE FORTY FOR ONLY
CERTAIN TYPES OF FEDERAL FUNDS.
AND OF SEXUAL AMOUNTS. TO ACTUAL
DOLLARS YEAH THOSE THOSE THOSE
ARE ALL OKAY YES WRESTLING OKAY
MOVE THE BILL THANK YOU. THERE
THERE IS A MOTION I WANT TO
THANK YOU FOR WORKING SO HARD ON
THIS BECAUSE I THINK THAT THE
AMENDMENTS WILL ADDRESS SOME OF
THE CONCERNS OF THE OPPOSITION
BUT FROM ONE ENCOURAGE YOU TO
CONTINUE TO HAVE CONVERSATION I
MEAN I UNDERSTAND. WHY THERE'S
OPPOSITION BUT I DO AGREE THAT
TRANSPARENCY IS REALLY IMPORTANT
AND- AND- AND IT'S TRUE THAT
THERE ARE RESTRICTIONS BUT YOU
CAN CALL OUT THE RESTRICTIONS
AND EXPLAIN WHY THAT IT DIDN'T
WORK IN YOUR CITY. OR YOUR
COUNTY OR YOUR JURISDICTION SO-
WITH THAT I'D LIKE TO BEGIN WITH
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I DON'T
THINK THE OPPOSITION FOR- FOR-
YOU'RE COMING OUT AND EXPRESSING
CONCERNS IN MY COMMITTED IT TO.
THE U. S. TO WORKING- WITH THE
OPPOSITION- AS IS BILL SEEKS TO
MOVE FORWARD MY ALSO POINT TO
POINT ALSO WANT TO MAKE IS THAT
WHEN THE CITIES AND COUNTIES
COMPETE. OFFER THESE FEDERAL
GRANTS OR ARM GET GRANTS THEY
COMPETE SO THAT MEANS THEY BEAT
OUT SOMEBODY. AND THEN IMAGINE
THEM BEATING OUT ANOTHER CITY OR
ANOTHER COUNTY. AND THEN TURNING
THAT MONEY BACK. IN THERE WE
COULDN'T USE IT. THAT'S MY
CONCERN. AND THE IT OFFICIALS
THAT OVERSEAS AND GOVERNS YOU'RE
LOOKING AT FACING WITH OF COURSE
BECOME A TRANSPARENCY
ACCOUNTABILITY LA TIMES AND
OTHER ARTICLES BEING WRITTEN.
AND THIS MONEY COULD BE USED FOR
THE PURPOSE IT WAS INTENDED FOR
AND THE U. LOOKING DUMBFOUNDED.
THIS IS A WAY TO MAKE SURE
THERE'S CHECKS AND BALANCES AND
KEEP EVERYONE ACCOUNTABLE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN I BUILT.
VERY GOOD KI¾M. THE MOTION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL SENATORS CABALLERO HI
CABALLERO I SEE ARE TWO THIRDS
DON'T KNOW BLAKE'S BEER. BRAKES
I DOLLY. WRESTLE BROWN I A GLAZE
. SKINNER WIENER. WIENER AYE.
FORTY ONE. THE BILL HAS FOUR
VOTE WILL PUT IT ON COFFEE
ABSENT. NUMBER YOU LEAVE WE'RE
GOING TO TAKE THAT FILE ITEM
NUMBER SEVENTEEN. WHICH IS AB
FIVE FORTY THREE FOR IT TO VOTE
ON THAT YOUR VOTE ON THE BILL-
AND SO I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION
ON THAT. I'M WITH. THANK CENTERS
HERE TO MOVES ABOUT ANY COMMENTS
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS BUT- THE
CITY I SAYS I DID NOT SUPPORT
THIS LAST WEEK- AFTERWARDS THE
AUTHOR AND I MET AND I TOOK A
MUCH DEEPER LOOK. AT THE BILL
AND ALTHOUGH HE I. MIKE MIKE ARE
LINGERING I THINK ONE BUT- IT'S
A REASONABLE BILL AND SOME TO BE
SUPPORTING IT TODAY. PRETTY GOOD
HI THE MOTION. IS. DO PASSED TO
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
. SENATORS CABALLERO HI
CABALLERO AYE SEYARTO SEYARTO I
PLAY EXPERIENCE LAKE SPIRIT
DOLLY. TO WRESTLE DOURESSEAUX I
GLAZER SKINNER WIENER WIENER I
FORTY ONE WITH THAT ON CALL FOR
ABSENT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MEMBERS WE HAVE BILL LEFT. YOU
YES WE CAN OPEN THE REAL FOR-
TO. CATCH EVERYBODY UP. WE DO
NEED ACT WE- THREE THAT WE NEED
MORE. ON THEY WERE UP FOR WE A-
QUORUM FOR WE START WITH- WE'LL
START WITH THE CONSENT AGENDA-
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION IS SET UP
THE CONSENT CALENDAR WITH THE
CHAIR VOTING I SENATORS SO
YOU'RE TOO SEE OUR TOE I. DOLLY
. SEVEN ZERO. I WILL PUT THAT
BACK ON CALL FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWO I NEED A MOTION.
MOTION BY SENATOR DURAZO. THE
MOTION IS. YOU PASSED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
SENATE SENATORS CABALLERO. HI
CARRILLO I SAY ARE TO. THERE
DON'T KNOW PLAGUE. LEG I DOLLY.
DRESS THE I PLEASE. SKINNER.
FIVE SKINNER I WIENER. WIENER I
AM VERY ONE. THE BILL IS OUT
WILL PUT IT ON FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS OR PUT IT ON CALL FOR
THE MEMBERS. FILE NUMBERS AND A
MOTION. DOUBLE MOST BY ASSEMBLY
HAS. YOU'RE AWESOME- THAT MOTION
IS PASS TO THE SENATE FOR.
SENATOR CABALLERO HI CABALLERO I
ARE TO SCARED TO KNOW BLAKE.
WICKS I DON'T. DRESSEL TAUGHT US
HE. RUSSELL I DON'T HAVE I.
GLAZER SKINNER FIVE SKINNER I
WILL. WIENER I AM PROUD TO ONE.
THE BILL IS OUT WILL PUT IT ON
FOR THE MEMBERS. FILE ITEM
NUMBER. FOR B. B. TEN THIRTY
THREE BY S. MEMBER CAME THE
MOTION IS TO PASS PROBE. BUT THE
TURN VOTER SENATORS AND- PLEASE
. FORTY PUT THAT BACK ON CALL.
FOR ITEM NUMBER FIVE. AB TEN
FIFTY TWO BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO TRY.
WHAT THE TERM VOTING SENATORS
SAY TOTAL SEYARTO NO DOLLY
GLAZER. RIGHT AWAY. THAT GOES
OUT WILL PUT IT ON BECAUSE- FILE
ITEM NUMBER SIX BY AB NAY ONE BY
SO MCCARTY. THE MOST IS TO PASS
IS A MAN TO THIS COMMITTEE ON
APPROACH. BUT THE CHAIRMAN I
CENTER SO YOUR TOTAL SCARED TO I
DAHLE. PLEASE. SIXTY PUT THAT
BACK ON FOR THE APPS MEMBERS
FILE I NUMBER AB TWO EIGHTY SO.
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS WHAT THE TERM
VOTING I SENATORS. THERE ARE TWO
NO DAHLE. GLAZER. BY TO ONE. PUT
THAT BACK ON CALL I NO TEN AB
THIRTY THIRTY TWO BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WANT. DEMO IS TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS WITH
THE CHAIR VOTING I SENATOR
SEYARTO. THERE ARE TWO I DON'T.
THANK ZERO WITH THAT BACK ON
CALL FOR THE ABSENT- FILE ITEM.
NUMBER ELEVEN EIGHT THIRTEEN
EIGHTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
GARCIA THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
THE FLOOR. BUT THE CHAIR VOTING
EYES SENATORS HERE. TO DOLLY
GLAZER SKINNER. FIVE SKINNER I
FRIDAY ZERO. THE BILL IS OUT TO
PUT IT BACK ON CALL. FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWELVE AB FOURTEEN SIXTY
NINE I NEED A MOTION ON THAT.
MOTION BY SENATOR DRIES OF. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE FLOOR. SENATORS CABALLERO HI
W. AT ALL I SEE ARE TOO SCARED
TO AYE LAKE SUPERIOR LEG SPINNER
I DOLLY. DOURESSEAUX THE REST SO
I GLAZER. SKINNER FIVE SKINNER
AYE WIENER WIENER AYE SEVEN
EIGHT ZERO SIX TWO ZERO THE BILL
IS OUT WILL PUT IT BACK ON CALL
FOR WE WILL PUT IT ON CALL FILE
ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB FOURTEEN
NINETY BY ASSEMBLY MEMBERS LEAVE
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS. WHAT THE
CHAIR VOTING I SENATOR SEYARTO.
THE R. TOKEN DOLLY. GLAZER
SKINNER. POSTED WHICH NUMBER. AB
FOURTEEN NINE. FILE I NUMBER
AFTER. SKINNER I'M FIGHTING.
FILE ITEM NUMBER. AB SEVENTEENTH
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS. WHAT THE CHAIR
VOTING EYES SENATORS DOLLY.
GLAZER SKINNER HI SKINNER I BUY
TO ONE. THE BILL IS OUT WILL PUT
IT ON CALL FOR ABSENT. AND
FINALLY AB FIVE FORTY THREE BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS. ADD TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS. BUT
THE CHAIR VOTING EYES SENATORS
DOLLY. GLAZER SKINNER. FORTY
ONE. AND PUT THAT BACK ON CALL
FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS MEMBERS-
WE ARE GOING TO TAKE A RECESSES
OF. YEP NO NO AND I NO. YEAH
THAT'S FINE WE'RE IT. I HAVE NO
IDEA. WOMEN WHAT.
FOR IF YOU'D LIKE TO MAKE A VERY
BRIEF PRESENTATION ON IT.
PROBABLY. THANK YOU- ASSEMBLY
MEMBER AGENTS OR REPRESENTING
THE SURPLUS HOW SORRY RESTAURANT
OVER HERE THAT'S OKAY JUST
RESERVING THE SURPLUS LAND ACT-
SO THAT WE IN THE CITY LOS
ANGELES WILL BE ABLE TO LOOK AT
THE SURPLUS LAND WE HAVE OVER A
THOUSAND PIECES OF PROPERTY IN
THE PHILOS ANGELUS BUT I'VE COME
TO THE END OF THEIR USEFUL LIFE.
WE WOULD LIKE TO EXPEDITE USING
THAT LAND FOR HOMELESSNESS WHO
WILL BE ABLE TO COULD NOT ONLY
NOT HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT BUYING
THE LAND BUT MOST IMPORTANT TO
BE ABLE TO A- IT TURNED AND
SLAMMED INTO HOUSING FOR THE
HOMELESS WHAT IS HAS THE
LARGEST. GROUP OF HOMELESS IN
THE TH HIDDEN IN THE COUNTRY FOR
RESPECTFULLY ASK THROUGHOUT BOTH
AND I WILL BE TAKING THE
AMENDMENTS BUT I BELIEVE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER APIECE THAT
SENATOR CABALLERO SUGGESTED THAT
WE TAKE THANK YOU AND I BELIEVE
YOU HAVE ONE- ONE. YES PERSON TO
SPEAK OKAY- GET IS BRIEF AS YOU
CAN POSSIBLY CAN WE'RE SUPPOSED
TO RECESS GOOD AFTERNOON- I WILL
BE AS BRIEF AS POSSIBLE MY NAME
IS TRICIA KEAN AND I'M THE
EXECUTIVE OFFICER FOR THE LOS
ANGELES HOUSING APARTMENT HERE
ON BEHALF OF LOS ANGELES MAYOR
CARE MASS WHO IS PROBABLY
SPONSORING THIS LEGISLATION. WE
ALL KNOW THAT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IS FACING HOUSE A
HOUSING AND HOMELESSNESS CRISIS
AND NOWHERE IS THIS CRISIS MORE
APPARENT. AND THEN IN THE CITY
OF LOS ANGELES. THIS OF AUSTIN
RUBBER ABOUT 10% OF THE STATE'S
POPULATION BUT HAS NEARLY 25% OF
THE STATE I'M HOUSE POPULATION
WITH OVER FORTY SIX THOUSAND
PEOPLE. I'M EXPERIENCING HUNGER.
RULING CAN YOU WRAP IT UP. THANK
YOU I'M MEHR BASS MADE
CONCERNING THIS ISSUE A HIGH
PRIORITY INCLUDING ADOPTING
EXECUTIVE DIRECTIVES. THAT
INVOLVE NOT MANY THINGS BUT MOST
IMPORTANTLY FOR THIS BILL. THE
REDUCE OF CITY PROPERTY. AND
THAT WAS THE IMPACT THE IMPETUS
FOR- BRINGING US AN ARMORED. I
SO WE YOU AND WHAT ARE AND I
VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND
ALSO A- OF LOS ANGELES MAYOR
FAST WITH THE- SIMILAR JONES
SAWYER FROM THIS MEASURE FORD
UNDERSTAND AND THEY ARE LOOKING
FOR. THAT THE COME. AMENDMENT
THAT THE AUTHOR FLANNER ACCEPT
IS A ONE TWO REMOVE THE PRO
HOUSE DOESN'T. BERMAN A GOOD
WE'RE ON- IN SUPPORT. K. THERE
IS A MOTION- IT'S A ANYONE ELSE
WOULD LIKE SPEAK AND- IN ROOM.
TWENTY TWO HUNDRED. SINGMAN IS
OR ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION IN ROOM
TWENTY TWO. THING THEN WE'LL
MOVE ON TO TELECONFERENCE LINE
AND ASK IS THERE ANYBODY THAT
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
OR IN OPPOSITION. REPORTER
OPPOSITION. AB SEVENTEEN THIRTY
FOUR PLEASE PRESS PRESS ONE THEN
. ZERO MANAGER WE HAVE NO
SUPPORT OPPOSITION VERY GOOD WE
DO HAVE A MOTION BRING BACK TO
COMMITTEE DOES ANYBODY HAVE A
BURNING DESIRE TO SAY ANYTHING
NOT. WILL ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE
A RESPECTED AS- VERY GOOD THE
MOTION IS I DO PASSED A HOUSING
WHERE THE AMENDMENT WILL BE
TAKEN. SENATORS CABALLERO HI
ABOUT YOU KNOW I SEYARTO SEYARTO
I OBLIQUES. LEG SPINNER I DOLLY
TO REST. THE REST I. SKINNER
SKINNER AYE WIENER WIENER I AM
SIX ZERO. THE BILL IS OUT WILL
PUT IT ON CALL FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THANK YOU THANK YOU SO
MUCH APPRECIATE IT THIS IS
RECORD TIME. YEAH. SO WHAT WE'RE
GOING TO BE DOING IS THAT WE
WILL BE RETURNING FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THIS AFTERNOON AFTER
THE- RULES COMMITTEE AFTER
SESSION AND AFTER RULES
COMMITTEE MEETING SO WE ARE IN
RECESS.
CALENDAR FILE ITEM NUMBER ONE
FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN IN THE
FILE ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN NO
ABSENT MEMBERS AT THIS TIME.
EIGHT EIGHT ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER. TO EIGHTY NINE THIRTY TO
NINE THIRTY FIVE BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER CONNELLY- THE
MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS WHAT THE CHAIR
BUT IN I SENATORS GLAZER. GLAZER
I. SEVENTY TWO THAT BILLS OUT
SEVENTY TWO. SIX SIXTY TWO SIXTY
TWO. NEXT IS FILE ITEM NUMBER
THREE AB NINE SEVENTY SIX BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER TING THE MET THE
MOTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
FLOOR. WHAT THE CHAIRMAN I AM
SENATORS GLAZER. FIVE TO THAT
BILL IS OUT FIVE TWO TWO. NEXT
IS FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR AB
THIRTEEN SKEWS ME AB TEN THIRTY
THREE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KING
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS. OKAY. CURRENT
CHAIR NOT VOTING. SENATORS
GLAZER OKAY FORTY TWO I. GLAZER
I AM FRIDAY TO THAT BILL IS OUT
. NEXT IS FILE ITEM NUMBER FIVE
AB TEN FIFTY TWO BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER MCCARTY THE MOTION IS DUE
PASSED. FOR DUE PAST TO
TRANSPORTATION. WHAT THE CHAIR
VOTING I- CURRENT BEAU IS FIVE
TWO TWO SENATOR GLAZERS. GLAZER
HI SIX TWO TWO THAT BILL IS OUT
FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX. A. B.
TWELVE NINETY ONE BYE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER MCCARTY THE MOTION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE SENATE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WHAT
THE CHAIR VOTING I AM SENATOR
GLAZERS. GLAZER AYE EIGHT TWO
ZERO BUT BILL IS OUT FILE ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN AB TEN NINETY SEVEN
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER LOOSE RIVAS I
WASN'T- I'M SORRY THE RIGHT-
FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AB TWELVE
EIGHTY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
ALVAREZ- THE MOTION IS TO PASS
AS AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING TIME
SENATORS. DOLLY GLAZER. FIVE TWO
ONE EIGHT TWELVE SEVENTY FIVE
TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN. PLEASE GIVE
OUR- ARAMBULA WAS AND AT PULLED
FROM THAT COMMITTEE. THAT
SERVICES TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN
OKAY. EARLY FRIDAY TO FRIDAY
ONE. OUR DAD BILLS OUT FIVE TO
ONE. FILE ITEM NUMBER TEN. AB
THIRTEEN THIRTY TWO BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER JUAN CARILLO MOTION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS. NO ABSENT
MEMBERS VOTE IS A TWO ZERO THAT
GOES OUT. NEXT IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER ELEVEN AB THIRTEEN EIGHTY
FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER GARCIA.
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE
FLOOR. WHAT THE TURBO DENYING
SENATORS GLAZER GLAZER HI. SIX
TWO TWO SIX TWO TWO THAT BILL IS
OUT NEXT IS FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE AB. FOURTEEN SIXTY NINE
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE FLOOR. WHAT THE CHAIR VOTING
IS SENATOR GLAZERS GLAZER I AM A
TWO ZERO LEAD BILL IS OUT EIGHT
TWO ZERO. FILE ITEM NUMBER
THIRTEEN AB FOURTEEN NINETY BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEAD THEM OUT
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS. WHAT THE
CHAIR VOTING ICE SENATOR GLAZER
. FIVE TWO TWO FIVE TWO TWO THAT
BILL IS OUT- FILE ITEM NUMBER
FIFTEEN AB. SEVENTEEN THIRTEEN
BYE ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS. BUT THE CHAIR
VOTING HÌNH SENATOR GLAZERS
GLAZER I AM SIXTY TWO SIXTY TWO
THAT BLOWS OUT. NEXT IS FILE
ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN AB SEVENTEEN
THIRTY FOUR BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
JONES SAWYER THE MOTION IS TO
PASS TO HOUSING. WHAT THE TERM
VOTING HI SENATOR GLAZERS GLAZER
I AM EIGHT TWO ZERO. AND THE GUY
THAT GOES OUT AND THEN FILE ITEM
NUMBER SEVENTEEN VOTE ONLY AB
FIVE FORTY THREE BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GIPSON. THE VOTE ON THE
MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
CURRENT BEAU IS FIVE TO ONE WITH
THE CHAIR VOTING HI. SENATORS
GLAZER GLAZER AYE SKINNER. SIX
TWO ONE BEDFELLOWS OUT SIXTY ONE
. THAT CONCLUDES OUR- COMMITTEE-
ON THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE
AND FINANCE SHOULD ANYBODY WISH
TO MAKE- TO SEND IN ANY PUBLIC
COMMENTS BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T GET
A CHANCE TO FEEL FREE TO VISIT
OUR WEBSITE AND DESCENDED IN WE
ARE ADJOURNED.