THE SENATE COMMITTEE. INSURANCE
WILL COME TO ORDER GOOD
AFTERNOON EVERYONE ONCE AGAIN-
THE SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME
THE PUBLIC IN PERSON AND VIA
TELECONFERENCE ORVIS FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENTS TODAY'S
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS.
877-226-8216 AND THE ACCESS CODE
IS. FIVE SEVEN ZERO ZERO ZERO
NINE SIX PLEASE NOTE WE WILL BE
HEARING FROM WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION BEFORE
TAKING ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS WERE
HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS
HERE IN THE- STREET BUILDING.
AND I ASK ALL MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT SO ANY
MEMBER LISTENING PLEASE ENSURE
THAT YOU COME DOWN SO WE CAN
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. WE HAVE A
BILLS ON THE CALENDAR TODAY TWO
OF WHICH ARE CONSENT BEFORE WE
HEAR PRESENTATIONS ON THE BILL
WE WOULD LIKE TO ESTABLISH A
QUORUM- SEEING THAT WE DON'T
HAVE ENOUGH MEMBERS WE WILL
START OUT THE COMMITTEE AS A SUB
HEARING UNTIL WE CAN'T ESTABLISH
THE QUORUM AT THIS TIME. THE
SUBCOMMITTEE EXCUSE ME
SUBCOMMITTEE I KNOW THAT- WE
HAVE KILEY THE TREES NORRIS WHO
IS ON HER WAY SO WE'RE GONNA
TAKE A BRIEF PONSE WEEPING WHEN
SHE GETS HERE WILL CONTINUE THE
MEETING THANK YOU.
WE WILL CONTINUE AS A SUB
COMMITTEE UNTIL WE ARE ABLE TO
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. YES SOLD
TODAY WITH US WE HAVE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER THREE OF US WELCOME WE
WILL BEGIN- THE COMMITTEE WITH
AB NINE SEVEN DIESEL WHEN YOU'RE
READY YOU MAY PROCEED THANK YOU
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
SENATORS I WANT TO START BY
THANKING JILL FOR HER WORK ON
THIS ANALYSIS AB NINE SEVENTY
SIX TO EXPAND INSURANCE OPTIONS
ESPECIALLY IN VULNERABLE AND
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES WHERE
CLIMATE RISKS ARE CURRENTLY
UNINSURED OR UNDERINSURED THIS
BILL ESTABLISHES EIGHT
GEOGRAPHICALLY DISTRIBUTED PILOT
PROJECTS WERE VULNERABLE AND
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES FROM
THE BAY AREA TO SAN DIEGO WILL
RECEIVE GRANTS UPON
APPROPRIATION BY THE LEGISLATURE
. FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF
INSURANCE FOR PILOT PROJECTS
PROTECTING RESIDENTS FROM
FLOODING AND HEAT WAVES
SPECIFICALLY AB NINE SEVENTY
WILL PRIORITIZE PROJECTS
PROMOTING RESILIENCY IN AREAS OF
RELATIVELY HIGH RISK AND LOW
INSURANCE. PARTICIPATION WITH A
FOCUS ON CLOSING PROTECTION GAPS
AS WELL AS DEMONSTRATING HOW
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS AND TRIBES
CAN ADDRESS GROWING CLIMATE
RISKS AND THEIR RESPECTIVE
COMMUNITIES. TODAY I HAVE WITH
ME TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY AND FOR
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS MIKE
PETERSON DEPUTY COMMISSIONER ON
CLIMATE. AND SUSTAINABILITY THE
SERVICE TIME WHEN YOU'RE READY
YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH A GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
RUBIO VICE CHAIR WYNN AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE I AM
MIKE PETERSON AND I SERVICE
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER FOR THE-
CLIMATE SUSTAINABILITY AT THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
INSURANCE AS THE SPONSOR OF AB
NINE SEVENTY INSURANCE
COMMISSIONER RICARDO LARA WOULD
LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RIVAS FOR HER LEADERSHIP IN
OFFERING THIS IMPORTANT MEASURE.
THAT WILL STRENGTHEN COMMUNITY
RESILIENCE ACROSS OUR STATE BY
STATE LISTING CLAIM INSURANCE
PILOT PROJECTS IN MULTIPLE AREAS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND IMPROVE
RISK COMMUNICATION COMMUNITY
RISK REDUCTION AND TEST NEW
INSURANCE CONCEPTS. AS CLIMATE
IMPACTS ACCELERATE VOORAL
COMMUNITIES OF HISTORICALLY HAVE
BEEN UNINSURED UNDERINSURED WILL
FACE DEVASTATING CHALLENGES FROM
THE IMPACTS BUT ALSO FROM A LACK
OF TIMELY RESOURCES TO REBOUND.
INSURANCE PLAYS A CRITICAL ROLE
IN COMMUNITY RESILIENCE FOR LESS
THAN 2% OF HOUSEHOLDS HAVE FLOOD
INSURANCE STATEWIDE AND THE
IMPACTS OF HEAT WAVES AND SEA
LEVEL RISE LARGELY LACKING
INSURANCE COVERAGE. THIS MEANS
THAT COST PHONE HOUSEHOLDS AND
LOCAL AND STATE GOVERNMENTS.
WITHOUT NEW INSURANCE WITHOUT
NEW TOOLS FOR RESILIENCE
COMMUNITIES ARE LIKELY TO FACE
ESCALATING RISKS LEADING TO
INCREASED LOSSES AND LINGERING
FINANCIAL IMPACTS WHEN THOSE
LOSSES ARE LARGELY UNINSURED.
INVERNAL COMMUNITIES IS LIKELY
TO EXACERBATE INEQUITY AND LEAVE
COMMUNITIES LESS RESILIENT TO
FUTURE CRIME INTENSIFIED EVENTS.
EIGHTY NINE SEVENTY WILL HELP
CLOSE CALIFORNIA'S INSURANCE
PROTECTION GAP BY DEVELOPING AN
ESTABLISHING I'M INSURANCE PILOT
PROJECTS IMPLEMENTED KEY
RECOMMENDATION OF COMMISSIONER
LARA'S CLIMBING INSURANCE
REPORT. THE FIRST OF ITS KIND
SET OF FORTY RECOMMENDATIONS
PUBLISHED IN TWENTY TWENTY ONE.
THE PROPOSED PROJECTS IN GRANT
PROGRAM THE PROPOSED PROJECT
PROPOSED IN AB NINE SEVENTY WILL
DEMONSTRATE HOW LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS. CAN REDUCE THE
INSURANCE PROTECTION GAP OF THE
RESIDENTS AND INTEGRATE NATURE
BASED SOLUTIONS THEREBY
INCREASING COMMUNITY FINANCIAL
RESILIENCE. THE PILOT PROJECT
WILL FOCUS ON DEMONSTRATING
COMMUNITY INSURANCE APPROACHES
THAT INTEGRATE RISK REDUCTION
ESPECIALLY IN VULNERABLE AND
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES WE'RE
CLIMATE RISKS ARE LARGELY
UNINSURED. EXAMPLES OF POTENTIAL
PILOT PROJECTS INCLUDE COMMUNITY
WHITE FLOODING EXTREME HEAT
INSURANCE APPROACHES THAT
COMBINE RISK REDUCTION IN
QUICKER ASSISTANCE TO VULNERABLE
RESIDENTS. ENSURING NATURE BASED
SOLUTIONS LIKE URBAN FORESTS
THAT PROVIDE COOLING IN PUBLIC
HEALTH BENEFITS. CALIFORNIA'S
BEEN A GLOBAL LEADER IN CLIMATE
POLICY INCLUDING EMISSIONS
REDUCTION IN CLIMATE ADAPTATION
INSURANCE AS PART OF THE CLIMATE
RESILIENCE IS AN AREA WHERE WE
NEED TO CONTINUE TO BE A LEADER.
DEVELOPING NEW WAYS TO PROTECT
OUR MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES
INVEST IN NATURE AND SUPPORT
RECOVERY AFTER DISASTERS. I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
VOTE ON A. B. NINE SEVENTY HAPPY
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THANK
YOU. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TESTIMONY NOW I WILL GO ON. AND
ASK FOR ANYBODY IN SUPPORT. TO
HEARING ROOM TWENTY ONE HUNDRED
. GOOD AFTERNOON MANAGER
COMMITTEE MEMBERS JOHN THE CLAMP
OFF THE PORT OF SAN DIEGO AND
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS SEREN TAYLOR ON BEHALF
OF THE PERSONAL INSURANCE
FEDERATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU. ANYBODY ELSE WISHING TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT WE WILL NOW
MOVE OVER TO LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION TO HAVE ANYONE
PRESENT. K. WE WILL NOW MOVE
OVER TO OUR WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM TWENTY
ONE HUNDRED. SEEING NONE WE WILL
NOW MOVE OVER TO THE
TELECONFERENCE- MODERATOR IF YOU
WOULD PLEASE PROMPT INDIVIDUALS
. THIS IS IN SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION. YOU MAY PROCEED. FOR
FOLKS ON THE PHONES TO-
REGISTERS FOR OPPOSITION FROM
NINE SEVENTY PLUS ONE M. ZERO ON
YOUR PHONE STUFF AND AT THIS
TIME. THE MANAGER WITH NO
COLLEGE YOU HAVE. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH WE WILL NOW BRING IT TO OUR
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ANYBODY
WISHING TO SPEAK. K. C. NO
INTEREST HERE- FIRST SO I WANT
TO JUST- SAY THANK YOU I KNOW
THAT THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER
HAS BEEN WORKING REALLY
DILIGENTLY ON THESE ISSUES AND-
HAD BEEN A WITNESS TO ALL OF
THE- HEARINGS THAT HE'S HAD
THROUGHOUT OUR STATE AND THANK
YOU FOR PARTNERING WITH HIM AND
JUST WANNA SEEKING TO WE DO
NEED. TO ENSURE THAT WE HAVE
THESE PILOT PROGRAMS IN PLACE TO
SEE WE CAN. FOCUS ON TOOLS THAT
CAN HELP ESPECIALLY
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND
WITH THAT I WILL GIVE YOU AN
OPPORTUNITY TO CLOSE. THANK YOU
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE WHEN APPROPRIATE. THANK
YOU ARE SINCE WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM WE'RE GONNA- TABLE THIS
AND OPEN IT UP WENT OUT A QUORUM
IS PRESENT THANK YOU SO MUCH
THANK YOU. SOME NOW I DO I SEE.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CUDDY PATRICE
NORTH. WE WILL NOW HEAR UP FROM
A FAMILY MEMBER COUNTY PATRICE
NORRIS AS SHE WILL. UP WHENEVER
YOU'RE READY YOU MAY PROCEED
THANK YOU GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM
CHAIR AND SENATORS AT PLEASED TO
JOIN YOU TODAY TO PRESENT. AB
FIVE SEVENTY ONE AND FIRST WOULD
LIKE TO BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS AND THANK
YOU. MADAM CHAIR. AND THANK YOU
TO YOUR STAFF FOR ALL OF YOUR
HARD WORK ON NOT ON THE SPELL. I
JUST THIS PAST WEEKEND- WE
RECOGNIZE THE ANNIVERSARY OF THE
JOB DECISION AND TO THE
OVERTURNING OF. ROE V. WADE'S IN
THE COURSE AS- LAST YEAR ONE IN
THREE WOMEN IN AMERICA HAVE LOST
ACCESS TO ABORTION SERVICES AND
THAT MEANS THAT. MORE AND MORE
WOMEN ARE COMING HERE TO
CALIFORNIA Q. RECEIVED
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE. HERE
IN CALIFORNIA WE OF COURSE HAVE
AT WORK DILIGENTLY TO PROTECT
AND EXPAND AT REPRODUCTIVE
FREEDOM AND- THE RIGHT TO
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE
SERVICES WE ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT.
OTHERS RIGHTS WITHOUT REAL
ACCESS R. I. SOMEWHAT
MEANINGLESS AND AT ONE OF THAT
THE MAJOR BARRIERS THAT
PROVIDERS REPORT RIGHT NOW I'VE
BEEN WRITING REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
CARE IS THE ACCESS. I IS THE
COST IN LIVES AND AVAILABILITY
OF LIABILITY INSURANCE FIVE FOR
PROVIDERS. OF REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS REPORT
BEING CHARGED ARBITRARY
SURCHARGES OR EVEN DENIED
LIABILITY INSURANCE ALTOGETHER
BECAUSE THEY PROVIDE ABORTION OR
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE. BOB THIS
BILL WILL PROHIBIT THAT
DISCRIMINATION AND ANY KIND OF
ARBITRARY SURCHARGES FROM BEING.
LEVIED ON REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
CARE PROVIDERS WHILE OF COURSE
ENSURING THAT ROBUST ACTUAL
ACTUARIAL ANALYSIS AND A DATA
DRIVEN ANALYSIS ARE AT ARE
MAINTAINED. AND NOW I AM PLEASED
TO WELCOME TO WITNESSES ALEXIS
RODRIGUEZ FROM THE CALIFORNIA
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION AND DOCTOR
JULIAN AND MILO AT. TWENTY NICE
FROM THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF
GYNECOLOGISTS. YOUR WALK TO STEP
FORWARD TO TESTIFY THANK YOU.
YOU'RE WELCOME TO COME TO THAT
THE TABLE TABLE OKAY. WELL SHE
CAN. KEEP UP WITH THE. ONE SEVEN
TABLE MY UP. I PROCEED OKAY
MADAM CHAIR THANK YOU VERY FOR
YOUR TIME TO THIS TODAY. MY NAME
IS DR I'M I AND I'M SO GOT. HERE
IN SOCCER. AND ALSO THE CO CHAIR
OF THE LEGISLATIVE COMMITTEE FOR
THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF
OBSTETRICIANS GYNECOLOGISTS
DISTRICT NINE CO SPONSORS OF AB
FIVE SEVEN ONE. ABORTION CARE IS
AN INTEGRAL PART OF MY EVERYDAY
PRACTICE. AS IS PRESCRIBING
BIRTH CONTROL DELIVERING BABIES
AND DURING CANCER SCREENINGS- I
HAVE THE PRIVILEGE OF PROVIDING
ALL OF THIS ESSENTIAL HEALTH
CARE THAT PEOPLE NEED. AND WHILE
I DO NOT COME DIRECTLY PROVIDE
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE MANY OF
MY- WILL BE DOING COLLEAGUES DO.
THIS BILL AND PROTECTING THIS
MEDICAL CARE AFFECTS EVERYONE
NOT JUST THOSE WHO NEED ABORTION
OR GENDER AFFIRMING CARE. IN A
TIME WHERE STATES ACROSS THE
COUNTRY ARE BANNING EVIDENCE
BASED LIFESAVING ABORTION AND
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE I AM PROUD
THAT CALIFORNIA SEEKS TO PROTECT
ACCESS TO THAT CARE. WE HAVE
MADE MANY GREAT STRIDES TO
ENSHRINE THE RIGHT TO ABORTION
IN OUR STATE CONSTITUTION AND
REDUCE BARRIERS FOR PATIENTS TO
RECEIVE THIS CARE. HAND IN HAND
WITH THESE ACTIONS WE SHOULD
ALSO FIND WAYS TO REDUCE
BARRIERS FOR PHYSICIANS AND
OTHER HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS. TO
PROVIDE THIS CARE THIS IS WHERE
EIGHTY FIVE SEVENTY ONE COMES
IN. AS AN OBGYN MY COLLEAGUES
AND I ALREADY PAY A LOT FOR
MEDICAL LIABILITY INSURANCE AND
ACCORDING TO SOME RESEARCH
PHYSICIANS MAY NEED TO PURCHASE.
ADDITIONAL COSTLY ABORTION
WRITERS WHICH IS CONCERNING
EVIDENCE SUGGESTS THAT LARGE
PREMIUMS FOR ABORTION WRITERS
ARE NOT PROPORTIONAL TO TRUE
LIABILITY RESTS ON THE MEDICINE
WE PRACTICES EVIDENCE BASED BUT
AS WITH ALL MEDICINE IT IS ALSO
FRAUGHT WITH POTENTIAL RISKS.
HOWEVER WHAT IS NOT RISKY IS
PROVIDING ABORTION OR GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE ABORTIONS ARE
VERY SAFE PROCEDURES. THEY'RE
MOST COMMONLY NOT PERFORMED IN A
HOSPITAL OPERATING ROOM AND THE
OVERWHELMING MAJORITY. OF
ABORTIONS ARE COMPLETED IN THE
OFFICE OR EVEN AT A PATIENT'S
HOME- IF THEY CHOOSE TO HAVE A
MEDICATION ABORTION. THE CURRENT
DIFFICULTY SOME POSITIONS
ANOTHER LICENSED PROVIDERS HAVE
IN SECURING PROFESSIONAL
LIABILITY INSURANCE HAS IMPACTED
THE NUMBER OF OTHERWISE ELIGIBLE
FOR PRACTITIONERS WHO COULD
OPERATE THESE. DESPERATELY
NEEDED SERVICES. IF YOU NEED TO
SHARE TIME. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES
EACH CHECK THE AMERICAN COLLEGE
OF OBGYN IS PROUD TO SPONSOR AND
ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF AB
SEVENTY ONE THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR YOUR TIME AND ATTENTION.
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES. GOOD AFTERNOON
ALEXIS RODRIGUEZ FOR THE
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
REPRESENTING FIFTY THOUSAND
PHYSICIANS AND MEDICAL STUDENTS
ACROSS THE STATE HOW TO
SPONSORED EIGHTY FIVE SEVENTY
ONE. THIS BILL WOULD ENSURE THAT
LICENSE MEDICAL PROVIDERS WHO
PROVIDE ABORTION CONTRACEPTION
OR GENDER AFFIRMING CARE ARE NOT
DENIED MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
INSURANCE COVERAGE OR CHARGING
UNFAIR PREMIUMS BECAUSE THEY'RE
PROVIDING CARE THAT HAS BEEN
OUTLAWED IN OTHER STATES- SINCE
THE DOG DECISION WITH ISSUE
TWENTY STATES HAVE. ENACTED
TOTAL OR SEVERE BANS ON MOST
ABORTION SERVICES MAKING IT
DIFFICULT IF NOT IMPOSSIBLE. FOR
PEOPLE TO GET HEALTH CARE IN
THEIR OWN COMMUNITIES THIS HAS
RESULTED IN CALIFORNIA
PHYSICIANS AND OTHER PROVIDERS
TREATING NOT ONLY CALIFORNIA'S
PATIENTS BUT AN INCREASING
NUMBER OF PATIENTS. WHO TRAVEL
TO CALIFORNIA THREE- TO RECEIVE
BASIC HEALTH CARE SERVICES. AB
FIVE SEVENTY ONE- IS ONE OF THE
FUTURE ABORTION COUNSEL BILLS
AND AS NECESSARY TO HELP
PROTECT. MEDICAL PROVIDERS WHO
MIGHT OTHERWISE BE DENIED
COVERAGE OR CHARGED HIGHER
PREMIUM THAT IS JUSTIFIED FOR
PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY INSURANCE
COVERAGE. THEY NEED TO- TO BE
ABLE TO PRACTICE MEDICINE. THIS
BILL WILL HELP ENSURE THAT
PATIENTS HAVE TIMELY ACCESS TO
CARE BECAUSE A PHYSICIAN OR
OTHER LICENSED MEDICAL PROVIDER
WON'T HAVE A BARRIER TO
OBTAINING AND MAINTAINING THEIR
MEDICAL MALPRACTICE COVERAGE-
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR SUPPORT TODAY. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU- I WILL TAKE A BRIEF
PAUSE SO WE CAN ESTABLISH A
QUORUM- IF I MAY. MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
CENTERS RUBIO PRESENT RUBIO
PRESENT WHEN. HERE WHEN HERE
ASHLEY. ASHLEY HERE JONES
MCGUIRE NERO. NEITHER OR- YOU
HAVE A QUORUM. NOW THAT WE HAVE
ESTABLISHED A QUORUM I WILL
PROCEED TO ASK LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION TO. PROVIDE TESTIMONY
TWO MINUTES PER WITNESS. THANK
YOU SIR. ARCHER MEMBERS MY NAME
IS GREG BURKE WITH A CALIFORNIA
FAMILY COUNCIL. I'M NOT BE
TALKING ABOUT THE- THE PORTION
ASPECTS OF THIS BILL BUT JUST
FOCUSING ON THE GENDER.
AFFIRMING CARE. AND I CAN
UNDERSTAND WHY MEDICAL
PROFESSIONALS WANT TO BE
PROTECTED FROM THE LAWSUITS
KNOWING THE NEGATIVE AFFECTS
THIS TREATMENT IS HAVING ON
NINERS. AROUND THE WORLD. I'M
SURPRISED THE BILL ANALYSIS
DIDN'T MENTION THE CALIFORNIA'S
TWO LAWSUITS FILED AGAINST
KAIZER. FORGIVING DOUBLE
MASTECTOMIES TO TWO TEENAGERS I
AS PART OF GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
THEY RECEIVE WHEN THEY WERE
THIRTEEN AND FIFTEEN YEARS OLD.
KHLOE COLE IS A- A WELL KNOWN
HERE IN CALIFORNIA THE NEW-
THIRTEEN YEAR OLD IS KAYLA LOW
VARDA. I'M GONNA RE I READ
THROUGH HER AYE CASE TODAY I
JUST WANTED TO GIVE YOU A BRIEF-
OVERVIEW OF WHY SHE FILED A
LAWSUIT- THIS IS FROM HER- CASE
THIS IS THE CASE IS ABOUT A TEAM
OF DOCTORS WHO DECIDED TO
PERFORM A DAMAGING. IMITATION
SEX CHANGE EXPERIMENT ALL KAYLA
A TWELVE YEAR OLD VERBAL GIRL
STRUGGLING WITH COMPLEX MENTAL
HEALTH COMORBIDITIES. WHO NEEDED
CARE ATTENTION PSYCHOTHERAPY NOT
CROSS SEX HORMONES AND
MUTILATING SURGERY. OCULAR
SUFFER FROM ALL KINDS OF- MIDDLE
HEALTH ISSUES ANXIETY SELF HARM
DEPRESSION. OF MANY OF THESE
SYMPTOMS ARE COMPATIBLE WITH
UNDIAGNOSED UNTREATED BIPOLAR
DISORDER A DIAGNOSIS THAT
KAYLA'S MOTHER REPEATEDLY. TOLD
HER DOCTORS THAT NEED ATTENTION
BUT IN EARLY ADOLESCENCE AROUND
ELEVEN CAILLAUX WAS EXPOSED TO
ONLINE TRANSGENDER INFLUENCERS
WHO PROMPTED KAYLA TO ENTERTAIN
THE AROMAS BELIEVE THAT SHE WAS
TRANSGENDER. SHE CAME OUT TO HER
PARENTS AS A BOY FRIBERG PRIOR
PRIOR TO HER EXPOSURE TO ONLINE
INFLUENCES CUBA. HAD NEVER
EXPRESSED TO ANYONE THAT SHE WAS
TRANSGENDER. THESE DOCTORS
SHOULD THEY REFER TO IMMEDIATELY
AND NEGLIGENTLY AFFIRMED
CARELESS SELF DIAGNOSIS
TRANSGENDERISM WITHOUT ADEQUATE
PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION THE
EVALUATION THEY DID TOOK A FIFTY
PLAYS FIVE OF YOUR TESTIMONY.
YOU MIGHT SECONDS SURE- IT. THE
WHOLE POINT IS SHE WAS SHE SELF
DIAGNOSED HERSELF- AND IF YOU
LOOK AT OTHER EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
THEY ARE CURED SAMOSET. SILENT
IN. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
AT ANY OTHER LEAGUE OF WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION. OKAY NOW WE WILL
MOVE OVER TO OF THOSE AND
SUPPORT HERE AND ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED. HI KAREN STOUT- I'M
REPRESENTING THEY WROTE PRO
CHOICE CALIFORNIA AS WELL AS THE
CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION WE
ARE SPONSORS OF THE BILL AND
INSTRUCTS THE PORT. THANK YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON TAYLOR THOMPSON
ON BEHALF OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR
AND MANY COULD UNLOCK THIS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
MICHAEL MARTINEZ FROM BEHALF OF
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER CARLOTTA
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. NOW
ANYBODY ELSE WISHING TO PROVIDE
TESTIMONY IN SUPPORT YOU MAY DO
SO NOW. NOW WE WILL MOVE ON TO
ANYBODY WISHING TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION HERE ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED MAY DO SO AT THIS TIME.
SEE NO INTEREST I WILL NOW MOVE
OVER TO OUR MODERATOR MODERATOR
CAN YOU PLEASE PROMPT
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION OF.
FIVE SEVENTY ONE. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR OR FROM THE PHONE
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO TO
TESTIFY ON FIVE SEVENTY ONE
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. WE DO HAVE
A COUPLE IN Q. ONE MOMENT PLEASE
WHILE WE GET THEM LOADED UP
HERE. THANK YOU.
IT LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE OUR FIRST
ONE IS READY WHERE TO GO TO LINE
ONE FIVE ONE ONE FIVE PLEASE. HI
FOR ON BEHALF OF TEACHER
TRAINING IN EARLY ABORTION FOR
COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH CARE IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
YOU AND JUST AS A REMINDER
YOU'RE WELCOME TO TAKE YOUR NAME
AND YOUR- POSITION. YOU MAY
PROCEED. AND WE CERTAINLY HAVE
FIVE MORE IN CUBA ONE ONE
SIXTEEN ONE ONE SIX GO AHEAD
PLEASE. THE ONE ONE SIXTEEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. BY ONE SIXTEEN
NOT RESPONDING OR WHAT THE PRESS
ONE ZERO TO RE QUEUE IF YOU
WOULD LIKE WE'RE GOING TO GO
NEXT TO LINE ONE THIRTEEN ONE
ONE ONE THREE. HI MY NAME IS THE
REPUBLICAN A FAMILY PHYSICIAN
AND THEN THE PROVIDER OF
ABORTION AND UNDER CARE ACT. AND
I AND II IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THE BILL THANK YOU. ANNEXES ONE
ONE SO. WELL SEVEN GOING TO. HI
THIS IS DR PLAN A LOT AND I AM
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE SPELL
I'M REPRESENTING MYSELF AS WELL
AS THE MY AND NETWORK A GROUP OF
. YOUR DOCTORS DO OFFER ABORTION
. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
LINE ONE TEN GO IT. HELLO MY
NAME IS DOCTOR SUSAN GEORGE AND
I AM A BOARD MEMBER OF TEACH P.
E. A. C. H. R. AND I AM VERY
STRONG SUPPORT OF. THE BILL.
EIGHTY FIVE SEVEN ONE THANK YOU
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
LINE ONE ELEVEN GO AHEAD. HI
THIS IS TERRY LAMBERT CERTIFIED
NURSE MIDWIFE- REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA NURSES MIDWIVES
ASSOCIATION OF WHO REPRESENT
APPROXIMATELY THIRTEEN HUNDRED
NURSE MIDWIFE IN CALIFORNIA IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF EIGHTY FIVE
SEVEN ONE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. I WILL TRY
AGAIN LINE ONE SIXTEEN GO AHEAD
PLEASE. YOU MIGHT BE MUTED ON
YOUR SITE CHECK TO CHECK IN ON
YOUR PHONE PLEASE.
STILL NO RESPONSE ONE ONE
SIXTEENTH MADAM CHAIR THERE ARE
NO FURTHER COLLEGE IN Q. THANK
YOU I WILL NOW BRING IT BACK TO
OUR COMMITTEE ANYBODY WISHING TO
SPEAK YOU MAY DO SO HI SENATOR
NEAL YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR SO THE PREMISE OF
THIS. IS THAT- INSURANCE
COMPANIES ARE CHARGING
ADDITIONAL FOR A PHYSICIAN TO
PROVIDE ABORTION CARE GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. AND FURTHER THE
IMPLICATION OF THE STATEMENTS IS
THAT- THEY ARE DOING SO WITHOUT
REGARD TO THE ACTUAL RISK
INVOLVED- IN PROVIDING THE
INSURANCE DO I HAVE THAT KIND OF
RIGHT. CORRECT THAT THE
PROVIDERS SIDE WHO WANT ONE OF
THE PROVIDERS WHO TESTIFIED HERE
TODAY AND OTHERS HAVE SHARED
THAT FIVE THEY ARE BEING CHARGED
ARBITRARY SURCHARGES THAT ARE IN
COMPLIANCE RATE WITH. THE LEVEL
OF ADDITIONAL PRESS CANCER WHILE
WE CERTAINLY WHEN IT ENSURE THAT
HI. ACTUARIAL PRACTICES ARE ARE
FIVE RESPECTED AND A DATA DRIVEN
ANALYSIS IS REFLECTIVE AND WE
CAN ALL AGREE THAT WE DON'T WANT
ARBITRARY SURCHARGES IN CHARGE
FOR. ANY I DON'T DISAGREE WITH
THAT BUT THE IMPLICATION IS THAT
INSURANCE COMPANIES. ARE
ENTIRELY UP PRO LIFE BECAUSE
THEY MUST HAVE A PROBLEM WITH
PEOPLE- PERFORMING ABORTIONS-
BECAUSE THE ALLEGATION OR THE
IMPLICATION IS THAT THE PREMIUM.
IS IN EXCESS OF WHAT THE
RELIABILITY OF SO THERE MUST BE
AN IDEOLOGICAL COMPONENT OF
THIS- I HAVE A HARD TIME
BELIEVING THAT- INSURANCE
COMPANIES ARE- YEAH IF NOTHING
ELSE- TOTALLY. RISK MOTIVATED
FOR PURPOSES OF DEVELOPING- THE
INSURANCE RATES THAT THEY CHARGE
. WITH REGARD TO GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE THERE COULD BE A
LITTLE BIT OF A DIFFERENCE AND-
THERE WAS A MENTION OF THE
KAISER SUIT BUT- ALL
SCANDINAVIAN COUNTRIES AND THE
UK HAVE HALTED GENDER AFFIRMING.
SURGERIES IN THEIR COUNTRIES.
DUE TO- THE EXPERIENCE THAT-
THAT THEY'VE HAD SO THERE THERE
COULD BE ISSUES THERE BUT I JUST
HAVE A HARD TIME BELIEVING THAT
INSURANCE COMPANIES AS A BLOCK.
OUR IDEOLOGICAL WITH REGARD TO-
THESE ISSUES. I APPRECIATE THAT
QUESTION AND OPPORTUNITY TO
CLARIFY. I DON'T THINK AND I
DON'T THINK OUR OUR SPONSORS
THINK THAT ALL INSURERS ARE
DOING THAT BUT WE CERTAINLY HAVE
HEARD REPORTS OF. INSTANCES
WHERE IT'S HAPPENING AND
PROVIDERS BELIEVE THAT IT'S
HAPPENING AND I SO INTERNET WE
ESTABLISH A UNIFORM POLICY WILL
KEEP ANY. RISK OF IDEOLOGICAL
INFLUENCE FROM COLORING HI
DECISIONS THAT ARE MADE FOR RISK
BASED ASSESSMENTS THAT ARE MADE
. AGAIN DO FUN HAVE A HARD TIME
BELIEVING THAT BUT I WOULD ALSO
ADD THAT- I AM A CONSUMER OF
INSURANCE AND NARRABEEN PLENTY
OF TIMES WHEN I FELT THAT- MY
PERSONAL RISKY EITHER ME
PERSONALLY OR- OR OR- AND THE
BUSINESS. WAS NOT BASED UPON
OBJECTIVE- MEANS. BUT THEY
BELIEVE IT WAS I WAS CANCELLED
ONCE BECAUSE MY SON WAS LIVING
IN A AT A ROTTWEILER AND THEY
FLAT CANCELED THE INSURANCE NOW
THE INSURANCE COMPANY ISN'T
IDEOLOGICALLY OPPOSED TO POST
ROTTWEILERS THEY FELT THAT THAT
WAS AN EXCESS. RISK I DIDN'T
THINK SO IT'S NOT AT ALL UNUSUAL
FOR THAT PERCEPTION TO BE THE
CASE ON THE PART OF THE SHIP
INSURED PERSPECTIVE OR OTHERWISE
. INDEED AND HAS CERTAINLY F.
FIVE THERE'S A DEMONSTRATION
THAT. WHATEVER THE PERCEPTION
MIGHT BE THAT SOMETHING IS
ACTUALLY BASED ON THE
FUNDAMENTALS OF REST THEN I. I
DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THAT I
SAID ATTACK. ANYBODY ELSE
WISHING TO SPEAK. CAME THANK
YOU- I JUST WANNA SAY THANK YOU
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD I
UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS JUST-
MERELY. SIMPLY MAKING SURE THAT
NO ONE'S TONIGHT- FIVE
PROFESSIONAL IT LIABILITY
INSURANCE IS BASED SOLELY ON THE
ON. THE SERVICES THAT THEY
PROVIDE SO- I WANT TO THANK YOU
FOR THIS- AND AT THIS POINT WE
DO HAVE A QUORUM SO- SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FOUR DO I
HAVE MOTION. SO WE WILL WAIT
UNTIL WE HAVE A FULL COMMITTEE
AND SO I WOULD HOLD THE ROLE
OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS THANK
YOU SO VERY MUCH AND- LAPTOP OUT
OF CARE AND THANK YOU SENATORS.
I DO SEE- MISTER GIBSON I
THOUGHT I SAW HIM IN HERE. OKAY
SO WE WILL NOW INVITE MR
CHANCELLOR TO COME AND JOIN US.
MY APOLOGIES I. THOUGHT I SAW
MISTER GIBSON HERE HE WAS. OKAY
SO I DON'T IMAGINE THAT GOOD TO
KNOW. THANK YOU WILL NOW WELCOME
MISTER JONES SAWYER THAT THAT
WILL PRESENT AB FOUR FIFTY EIGHT
YOU MAY PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE
READY THANK. A CHASE MISTER GIFT
AWAY SO. A GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR.
R. I WOULD LIKE TO START BY-
THANK IN A CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR WORKING WITH MY OFFICE
AND I WILL BE ACCEPTING. OF THE
AMENDMENTS THAT MERELY CLEAN UP
DRAFTING ERRORS TODAY JUNE
NINETEENTH VERSION OF THIS BILL.
MEMBERS ARE PRESENT A. B. FOUR
FIVE EIGHT WITHIN PLEASE CLARIFY
THE E. SCOOTER INSURANCE
REQUIREMENTS. IN ORDER TO ENSURE
PROPER INTERPRETATION OF THE
DIFFERENT STATUTE. LAST YEAR MY
BILL AB THREE SEVEN ONE WHICH
EXTENDED EXISTING E. SCOOTER
INSURANCE PROTECTION. PORT WAS
SIGNED INTO LAW IN DOING SO
PEDESTRIANS ESPECIALLY THOSE
WITH VISION IMPAIRMENTS AND
OTHER DISABILITIES WERE AFFORDED
COVERAGE FOR INJURIES CAUSED AT
NO FAULT OF THEIR OWN. BECAUSE
THE EXISTING STATUTES STATUS BY
MY BILL DOES NOT EXPLICITLY
STATE AND AGGREGATE LIMIT. THERE
HAS BEEN CONFUSION THAT
THREATENS PROPER IMPLEMENTATION
OF THE INSURANCE REQUIREMENT.
THOUGH SILENT ON THE ISSUE THE
EXISTING INSURANCE PRODUCT THAT
HE B. THREE SEVEN ONE WAS
MODELED AFTER ALLOWS FOR
AGGREGATE LIMITS ON THIRD PARTY
LIABILITY INSURANCE EVEN WHEN
THE ORIGINAL POLICY. IS
SIMILARLY SILENT ON AGGREGATE
LIMITS WITHOUT CLARIFYING
LANGUAGE THIS WILL BE A CONTINUE
PROBLEM FOR PROVIDERS AT THE
CURRENT INSURANCE QUOTE ARE
PROHIBITIVELY EXPENSIVE. AS SUCH
EXPLICIT CLARIFICATION IN THE
LAW IS WARRANTED WITH ME TO
SPEAK. IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
IS A LISA PRIEGO ARE A BEHALF OF
BIRD. THANK YOU YOU MAY PROCEED
REMEMBER- TWO MINUTES PER.
OUTING CHAU TESTIMONY THANK YOU
KAREN MEMBERS ONLY CREATE ON
BEHALF OF BIRD WHICH IS A MICRO
MOBILITY SERVICE PROVIDER THAT'S
PASSIONATE ABOUT VIBRANT
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE LESS
TRAFFIC. CLEANER AIR AND SAFER
STREETS WE ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT
OF AB FOUR FIFTY EIGHT AND THINK
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR THIS
BILL AND FOR THE COMMITTEE
ANALYSIS AS WELL WHICH OUTLINES
ISSUES COMPLETELY. WE BELIEVE
THIS LEGISLATION WILL HELP
CLARIFY EXISTING INSURANCE
REQUIREMENT LAWS AS WELL AS
ALLOWING SHARED MOBILITY SERVICE
PROVIDERS. TO MORE EFFECTIVELY
COMPLY WITH THE PROVISIONS LAID
OUT BY LAST YEAR'S EIGHTY THREE
SEVENTY ONE BUT CLARIFYING THAT
THE REQUIRED INSURANCE IS NOT
CONSIDERED A GROUP POLICY. AND
CAN HAVE AN AGGREGATE AGGREGATED
LIMITS WILL ALLOW COMPANIES
GREATER ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE
POLICIES FOR THESE REASONS WE
SUPPORT THE BILL AND ASK FOR
YOUR I. BOATS. THANK YOU. ANY
OTHER OF WISHING TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT. YOU MAY COME FORWARD AT
THIS TIME. MICHAEL MARTINEZ HER
BEHALF AS TRANSPORTATION RICARDO
LARA IN SUPPORT OF THIS MOTION.
I THANK THE AUTHORS OFFICE AND
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR WORKING WITH
US. ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU I DO
WE HAVE ANY LEAD WITNESS IN
OPPOSITION WISHING TO SPEAK. I
DON'T SEE ANY AT THIS TIME
ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION IN ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED. THANK YOU WE WILL NOW
MOVE OVER TO THE TELECONFERENCE
REAVIS MODERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE
PROMPT THE INDIVIDUALS WISHING
TO SPEAK. THANK YOU ADAM SURELY
THE GENTLEMAN PLEASE PRESS ONE
ZERO IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK ON
ITEM. EIGHTY FOUR FIVE EIGHT.
MADAM CHAIR THAT WAY WE HAVE NO
COLLISION Q. THANK YOU I WILL
NOW BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE ANYBODY WISHING TO ASK
QUESTIONS. THE BILL. OUT ITS
MOVE BY- SENATOR WENT. ON AN
ISLAND JUST DOES SAY THANK YOU I
NOTICES- JUST CLEAN UP FROM YOUR
AB THREE SEVENTY ONE WHICH WE
WORKED ON YES WE DID A LOT AND I
THINK YOU FOR ALWAYS BEING SO
FLEXIBLE AT THIS TIME I'M GOING
TO ASK- NINE. AM TO I'M SORRY
MOVE BY. ONCE I'VE SAID YES
THREE VOTE THANK YOU. FORGIVE ME
A PLEASE COVER ALL MOTIONS TO
PASS A AMENDED TO THE G.
COMMITTEE SENATORS RUBIO. HI
RUBIO I WENT HI WHEN I ASK.
JONES MCGUIRE. THE LOW FIVE NEW
PORT IN. SOME THREE ZERO THANK
YOU I HAVE THREE DOES HER THIS
BILL ON CALL F. MEMBERS THINK SO
MUCH THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE IT I NOW SEE- THE
GREAT SENATOR- I THINK CARSON.
CARSON I WILL BE PRESENTING AB
EIGHT FORTY FOUR I WHEN YOU'RE
READY MR IF YOU. MAY PROCEED
THANK YOU. WELL AS MEMBER EXCUSE
ME I WAS GOING TO ACCEPT THE
MOST. IT WILL. SIX THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MANAGE YOUR SEND.
THANK YOU ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT
ITS BILL. EIGHT FOUR FOUR WHICH
SEEK TO SUPPORT. THE ROW
DEVELOPMENT OF LEAN HEAVY DUTY
TRUCKS. BEFORE I BEGIN OUR WANT
TO RESPECTFULLY- THANK THE
COMMITTEE AND ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS PROPOSE AS
TECHNICAL IN NATURE AMENDMENTS.
THROUGH THIS BIPARTISAN BILL AND
I WENT ON TO SCORE BIPARTISAN
BILL CALIFORNIA PART OF
INSURANCE WILL LOOK AT HER
AVAILABILITY AND AFFORDABILITY
OF INSURANCES FOR HEAVY DUTY
VEHICLES. AS CALIFORNIA GOES
GREEN WE NEED ACCOUNT FOR. THESE
SOON TO BE OWNED BY THESE ZERO
EMISSION- VEHICLES HEAVY
VEHICLES TRUCKS. IT IS AND WILL
NOT BE CHEAP. AND WE NEED TO
CONSIDER THE AVERAGE TRUCK
DRIVER. WITH FAMILIES. WE'RE
TRYING TO MAKE ENDS MEET AND LET
ME JUST STOP THERE MY FATHER WAS
A TRUCK DRIVER OF THE FORTY
SEVEN YEARS- WHEN HE MY MOM CAME
TO CALIFORNIA FROM TEXAS A
LOPING- HE WORKED THE PACIFIC
RAILROAD WAS HIS FIRST JOB. AND
HIS SECOND JOB WAS A TRUCK
DRIVER. FORTY SEVEN YEARS OF MY
DADDY AND I STILL SAY MY DAD IS
A GROWN MAN MY DADDY. PROVIDED
FOR FOUR OF US INCLUDING MY MOM
AND IT WAS GOOD JOBS GOOD PAYING
JOBS AND I'M SIMPLY HERE TO
REPRESENTS NOT KNOWING MY DADDY
BUT ALSO THE PEOPLE THAT I
REPRESENT IN MY DISTRICT I
REPRESENT THE PORTS OF LOS
ANGELES. AND ALSO CHAIR OF THE
SELECT COMMITTEE ON THE PORTS
AND GOODS MOVEMENT IN CALIFORNIA
THIS AFFECTS MY DISTRICT AND WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE IT GETS WE GET
IT RIGHT ASSEMBLY BILL EIGHT
FORTY FOUR IS SUCH AN IMPORTANT
IMPORTANT CRITICAL. OF THE
POLICY SPECIFICALLY CALIFORNIA
CONTINUE TO WORK TO DEVELOP
RULES AND INCENTIVES- TO ACHIEVE
A 100% ZERO EMISSION TRUCKS
FLEET OVER THE NEXT DECADE. THIS
BILL WILL ENSURE THAT TRUCK
MANUFACTURERS PRODUCE AND SELL
AND MAKE AND MAKE AVAILABLE
AFFORDABLE ZERO EMISSIONS.
VEHICLES HEAVY DUTY TRUCK
VEHICLES IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA NEW TECHNOLOGY
WITHOUT LONG HISTORY. OF DATA
AND LET ME UNDERSCORE DATA.
WE'RE THIS IS THE ERA THAT WE'RE
NOT USED TO BEING IN SO WE HAVE
TO GET A RIGHT BECAUSE SO MANY
PEOPLE'S. FUTURE DEPEND ON US
GETTING A RIGHT MAKE IT
AVAILABLE AND AFFORDABLE. IN THE
HISTORY OF THE DATA AND THE
INSURANCE INFORMATION- AS FACING
CHALLENGES IN THIS IN THIS
STATE. PLEASE ADOPTION SLEEPER
DOPP LEAD ADOPTING. OF ZERO
EMISSION TECHNOLOGY MAY BE
FACING A LIMITED MARKET FOR
INSURANCE FOR INSURANCE. WHICH
SLOWS DOWN DEVELOPMENT OF ZERO
EMISSIONS HEAVY DUTY TRUCKS- THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS- COMING
A DEADLINE FOR FLEETS TO
TRANSITION TO NEW ZERO EMISSIONS
TECHNOLOGY INSURANCE.
AVAILABILITY AND AFFORDABILITY
COULD BE A FACTOR IN THE SPEED
OF THIS TRANSITION. AND AGAIN IT
COULD BE A FACTOR WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE WORK IN A VERY
PROACTIVE WAY IN ORDER TO MEET
ANY KIND OF BARRIERS- THAT IT
MAY POTENTIALLY BRINGS. BARRIERS
TO OBTAINING INSURANCE DATA-
GAPS- THAT THEY SHOULD BE
ADDRESSED NOW AS WE MOVE FORWARD
AND LOOK FORWARD SO THAT'S WHAT
THIS BILL ASSEMBLY BILL- EIGHT
FORTY FOUR SEEKS TO ADDRESS AND
THAT BILL IS BEFORE YOU TODAY.
HERE WITH ME TO PROVIDE
SUPPORTING TESTIMONIES A
REPRESENTATIVE FROM OUR
CALIFORNIA'S INSURANCE
COMMISSIONER CARLOTTA'S OFFICE
MISTER MIKE PETERSON WHO- IS
COMING ON BEHALF OF OUR
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER WHO WILL
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
BILL EIGHT FOUR FOUR. MISTER
PETERSON AFTER YOU MAY PRESS
WHEN YOU'RE A- THANK YOU A GOOD
AFTERNOON SHERRY RIO BUT YOU'RE
NGUYEN IN MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE I AM LIKE PETERSON I
SERVICE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER ON
CLAIMANTS. BILITY OF THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT INSURANCE
AS A SPONSOR FOR AB EIGHT FORTY
FOUR INSURANCE COMMISSIONER
RICARDO LARA WOULD LIKE TO THANK
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON. FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP IN OFFERING THIS
IMPORTANT MEASURE THAT WORK WITH
THE DEPARTMENT WITH NECESSARY
DATA FOR WORKING WITH THE AIR
RESOURCES BOARD TO UNDERSTAND
POTENTIAL BARRIERS AVAILABLE
INSURANCE FOR ZERO EMISSION
TRUCK FLEETS. THE COMBINATION OF
CLEAR ZERO EMISSION TARGETS
EXISTING AIR RESOURCES BOARD
REGULATIONS AND TECHNOLOGICAL
ADVANCES ARE FUELING
CALIFORNIA'S GOAL OF A NET ZERO
CARBON FUTURE. IN JUST THE PAST
FIVE YEARS THE STATE LEGISLATURE
AND GOVERNOR HAVE ENACTED
BUDGETS HAD INVESTED OVER ONE
BILLION DOLLARS IN INCENTIVES TO
ACCELERATE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
ZERO EMISSION. MEDIUM AND HEAVY
DUTY TRUCKS. IN TWENTY TWENTY
THEY'RE RESOURCES BOARD APPROVED
ITS ADVANCE CLEAN TRUCKS
REGULATION WHICH IS ANTICIPATED
TO RESULT IN ONE HUNDRED
THOUSAND ZERO EMISSION TRUCKS BY
TWENTY THIRTY. AND OVER
300-100-0820 THIRTY FIVE. IN
APRIL OF THIS YEAR THEIR
RESOURCES BOARD APPROVED ADVANCE
CLEAN FLEET REGULATION WHICH
WILL INCREASE THE NUMBER OF ZERO
EMISSION VEHICLES AT OUR PORTS
AND RAIL YARDS. AND INDUSTRIAL
COMBUSTION POWER TRUCKS IN
CALIFORNIA BY TWENTY THIRTY SIX.
AS WITH NEARLY ALL EMERGING
TECHNOLOGIES THERE IS LIMITED
DATA ON CURRENT INSURANCE
COMMERCIAL INSURANCE MARKETS FOR
HEAVY DUTY ZERO EMISSION TRUCKS
AND FLEETS. SPECIFICALLY AB
EIGHT FORTY FOUR WOULD ALLOW THE
DEPARTMENT TO COLLECT TIMELY AND
RELEVANT INFORMATION ON THE
AVAILABILITY OF INSURANCE FOR
THIS MARKET PLACE IN THE ROLE OF
INSURANCE IN MEETING. EMISSIONS
REDUCTION TARGETS INCLUDING THE
DEPLOYMENT OF ZERO EMISSION
TECHNOLOGIES. COMMISSIONER LARA
BELIEVE THAT REDUCING EMISSIONS
FROM TRUCKS AND OTHER MOBILE
POLLUTION SOURCES SAVE LIVES AND
BENEFITS THE HEALTH OF MANY. OF
CALIFORNIA MOST VULNERABLE
NEIGHBORHOODS AND COMMUNITIES
LIVING NEAR TRANSPORTATION
CORRIDORS INCLUDING THOSE
COMMUNITIES IN THE AUTHORS
DISTRICT. MANY OF THESE
COMPANIES HAVE BEEN IMPACTED BY
POOR AIR QUALITY FOR YEARS AND
REDUCING HEAVY DUTY TRUCK
POLLUTION WITH THE DEPLOYMENT OF
ZERO EMISSION. TECHNOLOGIES IS
URGENT FOR ADDRESSING PUBLIC
HEALTH IMPACTS. AS DEPLOYMENT OF
HEAVY DUTY TRUCK FLEETS RAPIDLY
INCREASES TO ME CALIFORNIA
SCHOOLS SMALLER FLEETS OR
CERTAIN TECHNOLOGIES COULD FACE
BARRIERS TO INSURANCE
ACCESSIBILITY. AB FORTY FOUR
PROVIDES A FORWARD LOOKING
APPROACH TO IDENTIFYING AND
ADDRESSING POTENTIAL INSURANCE
BARRIERS. TO RUB OF YOUR
TESTIMONY THANK YOU YOUR PAST.
YOUR TIME I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR I'VE VOTE ON AB EIGHT FOUR
HAVE AN- THANK YOU- ANYBODY ELSE
. TO SPEAK AND SO. CAME SEEN
NONE I WOULD NOW I'M OVER TO
LEAD WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE I WILL NOW ASK
ANYONE HERE IN ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED UP TO STEP UP IF YOU
HAVE ANY OPPOSITION ON THIS BILL
. BEING KILLED WE WILL NOW TURN
IT OVER TO THE TELECONFERENCE-
MODERATOR CAMPY'S PROMPT THE
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION OF THIS
BILL. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR TO
US BOTH IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
OF AB EIGHT FORTY FOUR PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THEN THE ZERO AT
THIS TIME WE HAVE CURRENTLY ONE
IN Q. WE WILL GO OFFLINE. ONE
NINETEEN ONE MAKING LAST WEEK'S
. SACRAMENTO BEHALF OF FROM FOR
THANK YOU. I WOULD HAVE TO
QUEUING UP WILL BE ONE MOMENT
GET A LITTLE NUMBER.
A LINE ONE OH NINE GO AHEAD
PLEASE. I ACTUALLY JERRY ON
BEHALF OF THE GREEN LINING
INSTITUTE AND SUPPORT. ONE OF
THE LAST ONE IN JUST A MOMENT.
THE TRUCKING ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. SORRY ONE ONE FOURTEEN
PLEASE SAY IT AGAIN YOU WEREN'T
OPEN YET. HAYDEN COLEMAN WITH
THE CALIFORNIA TRUCKING
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU MA'AM SURE THERE ARE NO
FURTHER COLLISION QUEUE AT THIS
TIME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TESTIMONY I WANNA BRING IT OVER
TO MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
WISHING TO SPEAK. A LITTLE BIT.
THANK YOU MOVED BY SENATOR WENT
ON THE- SECRETARY PLEASE. NO I'M
SO SORRY I KEEP DOING THIS BY
THE WAY I TO MY DAD DADDY TO
SELL YOU NOT THE ONES THANK YOU
BUT BEFORE YOU MOVE I DO WANT TO
JUST TAKE A MOMENT THINK- AGAIN
I KNOW THAT THERE'S BEEN A LOT
OF COLLABORATION WITH INSURANCE
COMMISSIONER THEY GOT A LOT OF
WHICH I THINK IT'S SO IMPORTANT-
YOU KNOW I KEEP YOU STATED.
EARLIER THAT THE AFFORDABILITY
AND AVAILABILITY OF INSURANCE
MAY BE A FACTOR MEETING OUR
CLIMATE GOALS SO IT'S IMPORTANT
THAT WE START LOOKING AHEAD AND-
HAS- THE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER
OFFICE STATED DOT COLLECTING
RELEVANT DATA IS IMPORTANT TO.
TO SEE IF THE INSURANCE MARKET
IS READY SO WITH THAT I SAY
THANK YOU AND YOU MAY CLOSE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH BUT I'M SURE
I'M GOING TO USE YOUR COMMENTS
AS MY CLOSE RESPECTFULLY ASK
WHEN I. SENATOR PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL MOTIONS TO AS A TO THE
GESTURE COMMITTEE SENATORS RUBIO
I RUBIO AYE WHEN I WHEN I. JONES
MCGUIRE NERO NERO IMPORTANCE. K.
WILL PAY ON COFFEE YOU FOR YOUR
TIME I OKAY I DO SEE WE HAVE OUR
LAST. WHAT WE HAVE TWO MORE TO
GO I WILL INVITE- ASSEMBLY
MEMBER TAKE UP PLEASE JOIN US AS
SHE WILL BE PRESENTING AB NINE
ONE SEVEN. WHEN YOU'RE READY YOU
MAY BEGIN. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
AND MEMBERS AT THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AB NINE
ONE SEVEN TWO NAY. I WILL BEGIN
BY ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND THANK YOU FOR
WORKING WITH MY TEAM. AB NINE
ONE SEVEN WOULD REMOVE THE FENCE
SAID OF THE CALIFORNIA LOW COST
AUTO INSURANCE PROGRAM. KNOWN AS
ELCA MAKING THE PROGRAM
PERMANENT. CALIFORNIA LAW
REQUIRES THAT ALL DRIVERS IN
VEHICLES WITH THE STATE
MAINTAINED DRIVERS INSURANCE
HOWEVER. TOO MANY LOW INCOME
DRIVERS REMAIN UNINSURED BECAUSE
OF THE HIGH COST OF STANDARD
INSURANCE PREMIUMS. INSTEAD OF
HAVING UNINSURED DRIVERS ON THE
ROAD THEY CAN PARTICIPATE IN
THIS PROGRAM WHICH PROVIDES THEM
WITH LIABILITY INSURANCE AT AN
AFFORDABLE PRICE. THIS PROGRAM
HAS BEEN RUNNING FOR OVER TWENTY
YEARS OF THE PILOT HAS
CONTINUOUSLY BEEN RENEWED AB
NINE ONE SEVEN WILL REMOVE THAT
SUNSET DATE. GOING SURE THAT
CALIFORNIA CONTINUES TO PROVIDE
NEEDED AUTO INSURANCE THAT MANY
LOW INCOME DRIVERS DESPERATELY
NEED. I'M HERE TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL AS MR
KEELAN LONI I WITH THE DEPUTY
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR WITH THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
INSURANCE AND MISS GAME MEANS NO
GARI DIRECTOR FOR THAT CLC A
PROGRAM. JUST A REMINDER YOU
HAVE TO EACH TO PRESENT MAY
PROCEED THANK YOU OKAY. GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIR RUBIO SIZE SURE
WINNER MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
MY NAME IS KAITLYN LOWNEY.
DEPUTY LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR HERE
ON BEHALF OF INSURANCE
COMMISSIONER RICARDO LARA AND
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
INSURANCE. AS THE BILL'S SPONSOR
COMMISSIONER LARA WOULD LIKE TO
THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER ORTEGA FOR
HER LEADERSHIP AND AUTHORING
THIS IMPORTANT MEASURE. THE
COMMISSIONER LARA IS SPONSORING
AB NINE SEVENTEEN BECAUSE THE
CALIFORNIA LOW COST AUTO
INSURANCE PROGRAM HAS BEEN
PROVEN. FOR OVER TWENTY YEARS TO
FILL A NEED FOR LOW INCOME
CALIFORNIANS. PROVIDING
AFFORDABLE LIABILITY ONLY AUTO
INSURANCE TO PEOPLE WHO NEED
TRANSPORTATION TO GET TO WORK TO
SCHOOL TO DOCTOR'S APPOINTMENTS
AND OTHER IMPORTANT LIFE
ACTIVITY. MAKING THE PROGRAM
PERMANENT WILL ENSURE THAT THIS
TRANSPORTATION WILL REMAIN
AVAILABLE. I RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS
MEASURE AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME
I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE. A
WITH ME IS IMMEDIATELY WANT
OTHER. A SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT
ON THE CFC PROGRAM. THANK YOU
YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES TO PRESENT
. I WOULD JUST LIKE TO ECHO MY
COLLEAGUES' WORD- THE NECESSITY
FOR THIS PROGRAM HAS WITHOUT A
DOUBT DOUBT BEEN SHOWN FOR THE
PAST TWENTY THREE YEARS. A
WITHOUT IT THOSE IN LOW INCOME
HAVE GONE UNINSURED AND WE JUST
WANT TO BE ABLE TO LIVE OFF FOR
THIS RESOURCE FOR THEM. AND WITH
THAT I REQUEST MY FROM. THANK
YOU WE WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO
THOSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM TWENTY
ONE HUNDRED. SEE NO INTEREST WE
WILL NOW GO TO THE
TELECONFERENCE- MODERATOR PLEASE
PROMPT INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
OF THIS BILL THANK YOU. THANK
YOU WILSHIRE TO PUT UP POSTERS
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
WE CURRENTLY HAVE NO COLLISION.
THANK YOU MODERATOR WILL NOW
BRING IT TO THE COMMITTEE ANY
QUESTIONS. IT WANTED. SENATOR
WHEN WAS THE BILL BUT I YOU
DON'T WANT TO SAY THANK YOU ONCE
AGAIN I THINK I WAS THE LAST
PERSON WHO ACTUALLY CARRIED THE
BILL TO MAKE THE EXTENSION THE
PREVIOUS TIMES SO I THINK AFTER.
TWENTY THREE YEARS IS
APPROPRIATE THAT WE MAKE IT
PERMANENT SO I THINK YOU AND I
WILL NOT AS A CLOT THERE AS
WELL- YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR IDOL. THANK YOU MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SENATORS RUBIO AYE RUBIO AYE
WHEN I WENT HI ASHLEY. JONES
JONES I'D MCGUIRE NEW LOW.
MIDDLE HIGH PORTANTINO THE BILL
HAS. HOW WILL YOU THIS ON CALL
FOR TO MEMBERS THANK YOU SO
MUCH. A I DO SEE US COMING.
VALENCIA. ASSEMBLY MEMBER EVELYN
WHO WILL BE PRESENTING AB
FIFTEEN SEVENTY EIGHT AND WHEN
YOU'RE READY YOU MAY PROCEED.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
CENTERS MORE WHEN I STATUS. I
WANT TO START BY THANKING THE
CHAIR AND THEN ALSO THE
COMMITTEE FOR WORKING ON AB
FIFTEEN SEVENTY EIGHT. AND A
KNOWLEDGE ARE CHEAP STAND. CHIEF
OF STAFF AND ROBERT ALSO FOR HER
EFFORTS ON THIS BILL THUS FAR.
AB FIFTEEN SEVENTY EIGHT
ALLIANCE REQUIREMENTS FOR EMAIL
WITHOUT OF PRINTED DOCUMENTS
WHEN INSURANCE AGENTS AND
AGENCIES SEND INSURANCE
CORRESPONDENCE. TO PLUG
CONSUMERS CURRENT LAW REQUIRES
AGENTS BROKERS AND ADJUSTERS THE
PRINTER LICENSE NUMBERS ON
RECORD SPONDON SO DISTRIBUTED
FOR INSURANCE PRODUCTS. IN
TWENTY TWENTY TWO THIS LAW WAS
MODERNIZE TO INCLUDE EMAIL.
HOWEVER AS WRITTEN THE BILL TAX
WAS CONFUSING AND HAS
CONTRIBUTED IN DIFFERENT WAYS BY
STAKEHOLDERS. AB FIFTEEN SEVENTY
WOULD CLARIFY THAT STATUTES
REQUIRE LICENSEES TO INCLUDE
ONLY THEIR INDIVIDUAL LICENSE
NUMBER ON EMAILS. WITH ME TO
PROVIDE TESTIMONY IS MISS
SHERRIN MCCUE ON BEHALF OF THE
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
INSURANCE. AND FINANCIAL
ADVISORS. TO SIR MINOR TO ME YOU
MAY PROCEED. YEAH I WILL BE DEBT
SURE THAT MINUTES FOR. I'M GOOD
AFTER SHERRY MCCUE REPRESENTING
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
INSURANCE AND FINANCIAL ADVISORS
WE ARE PLEASED TO BE A CO
SPONSOR OF AB FIFTEEN SEVENTY
EIGHT WE THINK THE AUTHOR AND
STAFF. FOR WORKING WITH US ON
THIS VERY SIMPLE CLARIFICATION
BILL. I S. B. R. TO THE AB
FIFTEEN SEVENTY EIGHT WILL HELP
TO ENSURE THAT CONSUMERS ARE NOT
CONFUSED BY MULTIPLE LICENSE
NUMBERS ON ELECTRONIC
COMMUNICATIONS. IT WILL ALSO
HELP TO ENSURE THAT LICENSEES
BETTER UNDERSTAND WHICH LICENSE
NUMBER TO PUT ON THEIR
ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS TO
THEIR CLIENTS. FOR THESE REASONS
WE ARE STRONG SUPPORT THE BILL
AND URGING MY VOTE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE WISHING TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT MAY DO SO AT
THIS TIME THANK YOU HI GOOD
AFTERNOON ERIN ORDER BEHALF OF
THE INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENTS
AND BROKERS IN CALIFORNIA. OR
PLEASE ALSO VEHICLES ON SOME OF
REFERENCE ID FOR CALIFORNIA WHEN
I THINK THE AUTHOR AND HIS STAFF
FOR ALL THE WORK ON THIS
CLARIFICATION BILL AND
APPRECIATE YOUR THOUGHTS SUPPORT
. THANK YOU. MARK SEVEN AMERICAN
CATCH SO. SUPPORTED BILL THANK
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON ALISON ON
THE OF THE PER INSURANCE THAT
ALSO IN SUPPORT YOU. THANK
ANYBODY IN THIS ROOM WISHING TO
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL
YOU MAY DO SO AT THIS TIME. CENA
WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO MODERATOR
PLEASE PERTAINING TO VISUAL
WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL THEY MAY
DO SO AT THIS TIME. I CAN ASSURE
ON THE PHONES PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO VOICES FOR A POSITION. AND
WE HAVE NO CONGRESS QUEUING UP.
THANK YOU I WANNA BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE. THIS ONCE
AGAIN MY SAVIOR HERE HAS SENATOR
WHEN WILL BE. SENATOR WAY WHEN
WAS THE BILL- AND I JUST WANT TO
SAY. THE YOU I KNOW THIS JUST A
SIMPLE COMMON. UPDATE THANK YOU
FOR THIS FORWARD YOU MAY CLOSE
HAPPY TO APPRECIATE TIME AND
RESPECTFULLY. US ABOUT. THANK
YOU SENATOR PLEASE COMMA. THE
MOST IS TO PASSED APPROPRIATE.
COMMITTEE SENATORS RUBIO HI
RUBIO I WIN BY WHEN I ACTUALLY
JONES YES JONES YES MCGUIRE.
NERO I KNEW I PORTANTINO. HAS
WITH TO COME CALL. HAS FOUR OF
FOR INPUT THE ON COFFEE YOU.
VERY YOU. YEAH YEAH. SO I THINK
IT'S A- SO AT THIS I'M GOING TO.
MY COLLEAGUE THAT SAID ON THE
ENTRANCE TO- TO PLEASE COME
WIENER TO MAKE THAT WE FORWARD
BUT I BELIEVE GONNA NEED TO A
RECESS TO ENSURE THE WE HAVE.
FOUND WE WILL DO CONSENT TO
ALLOW MEMBER TO LEAVE SO CONSENT
HAVE AB FOUR FIFTY ONE CAL AB
ELEVEN- ORANGE- COMMITTEE BILLS
- I WILL. ASK MADAM SIR TO CALL
THE- SENATE IT WAS MORE. YEAH
MOVE BY CENTER WENT. CENTERS
RUBIO HI RUBIO I WENT BY WHEN I
B. JONES JONES I MCGUIRE NEW.
NEIL I PORTANTINO. SEVEN THE NEW
PEOPLE. THAT'S WHAT. THE
CALIFORNIA MOTION OF THE OKAY.
SO I'M GONNA OPEN THE ROLE FOR
THE THAT HAVE RIGHT NOW PER
AMONG GO IN ORDER I MEAN IS WITH
. AB FOUR FIFTY EIGHT JONES.
MANA SECRETARY PLEASE THE ROLL-
VOTERS THREE TWO ZERO SAN ASK
JONES HI JONES I MCGUIRE FORTY.
BACK ON WITH THE FORCE. WHAT IF
OPEN WE WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO A
FIVE ONE TREES AND OF SECRETARY
PLEASE. I NEED A MOTION. K. WILL
CONTINUALLY THIS ON CALL FOR AB
MEMBERS WE WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO
A EIGHT FOUR BY A GIVES. MAN
SECOND PLEASE CALL ROLL THE
CURRENT VOTER THREE DOES TO ASK
JONES. S. B. I. JONES I MCGUIRE
FORTY. SAYS FIVE BACK ON CALL
FIVE TWO ZERO BILL IS BACK ON
BECAUSE WRAPS MEMBERS WE WANT
MOVE- OVER TO A EIGHT NINE ONCE
OR ON MADAM TO FOR CALL THE
CURRENT VOTERS FOR ZERO. ASHLEY
I AYE MCGUIRE FOUR TO. FIVE TWO
ZERO COME CALL. THIS HAS FIVE
ZERO WILL PUT IT ON FOR OPEN FOR
UP MEMBERS WE WILL NOW OVER TO
AB NINE SEVENTY LOUIS FREEH.
MANA SECRETARY- WE A MOTION TO
OF THIS BILL FORWARD MOVING.
MOVE VICE WHEN A MAN OF THE
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THE MOTION
IS TO PASS THE GOVERNOR AND
FINING COMMITTEE. RUBIO I RUBIO
WHEN. WHEN ASKED WE SB I. JONES
I AM. NAY NERO I FOR. IT HAS.
CAN CALL FIVE VOTES WILL YOU
COVER UPS AND THEN WE WANT MOVE
OVER TO A FIFTY SEVENTY BILLION
MATTER SECRETARY CALL THE
CURRENT VOTERS TO SEE. ASCENDERS
ASHLEY I MY- PORTANTINO. THIS
BILL IS FIVE TWO ZERO GONNA HAVE
TO PUT THE ON CALL FOR APPS AND-
IN I THINK THAT'S THE LAST ONE
THAT.
MOTIONS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE CENTERS
RUBIO HI RUBIO AYE WHEN. ASHLEY
ASHLEY I'D JONES JONES NO
MCGUIRE NEAT MCGUIRE I NEED LOW
. ZERO NO PORTANTINO HAS THREE
TEAMS ON CALL THREE TO HIS BILL
WILL REMAIN ON CALL- I. CONSENT
OR THREE I HAVE. OKAY SO WILL
NOW OPTING YOU WILL NOW CALLED
TO. CALENDAR CONSENT AB FOUR
FIFTY ONE AB ELEVEN FORTY- MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
CENTERS ASHLEY ASHLEY I MCGUIRE
MCGUIRE AYE PORTANTINO. BECAUSE
THIS BILLS BACK ON CALL FOR
ABSENT MEMBERS WE WILL NOW MOVE-
BACK OVER TO AB FOR FIFTY AGENTS
ORDERS MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL. CENTERS ASK ME S.
B. I. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE. THE
SIX ZERO ECHO THIS BILL HAS ZERO
WE WILL BUT THE BILL BACK ON
CALL WE WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO
EIGHTY FIVE SEVENTY ONE TO TREAT
NORRIS AMANAH SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL WE HAVE EVERYBODY
COME ON THE WILL CALL THAT HERE
KNOWLEDGE EVEN CALLS OF. CAN
WILL LEAVE THAT BILL BACK ON
CALL UP WRAPPED IN MY WE NOW
MOVE TAPE EIGHT FORTY FOUR-
MISTER GIBSON- MADAM TICKET
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL TERM VOTE
IS FIVE DOES SAN MCGUIRE.
MCGUIRE AYE SIXTY. THIS BILL HAS
IS A SIX ZERO IT WILL REMAIN ON
DROPS MEMBERS OF WE WILL NOW
MOVE OVER AB NOW ONE SEVEN BUY
ARE TAKEN INTO PLEASE THE ROLL
TERM VOTERS DISEASE SAN. MCGUIRE
I PORTANTINO. SIXTY THAT- HAS IS
SIX ZERO IT WILL REMAIN ON WE
NOW MOVE OVER TO A NINE SEVENTY
BY LOU. MAN I'M SO P. CALL THE
KERN VOTERS FIVES SAN WHERE.
MCGUIRE AYE PORTANTINO SIX. THE
BILL REMAINS SIX WE LEAVE IT ON
FOR AND WE WANT MOVE OVER TO A
BEEF SAID EIGHT BY. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER VALENCIA SECRETARY PIECE
THE ROLL FIFTEENTH THEM EIGHT
THE VOTER FIVE TWO. SHARE AND
VICE VOTING ICE WILL GO. MCGUIRE
PUT INTO. PORTANTINO HI THAT
BILLS OUT. OF THAT BILL IS SEVEN
ZERO THAT PHYLLIS OUT- WELCOME
PARDON. WILL NOW PULL- CONSENT
CAL WERE BACK TO A FOUR FOR ONE
K. A ELEVEN. INSURANCE MADAM
PLEASE THE ROLL. I'M SORRY YES
YES CONSENT AGAIN SO MUCH-
SENATOR PORTANTINO. PARDON HI
CAN KELLER'S OF SAN ZERO THEY
CAN THANK OUT SEVEN WE WILL NOW
MOVE OR TO AB. FOR FIFTY AGE
SAWYER SECOND PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL THE CURRENT VOTERS SIX TO
ZERO WITH ITS AND VICE CHAIR
VOTING ICE PER. PORTANTINO I.
YEAH THE BILLS OUT SEVEN A ZERO-
WE NOW MOVE OVER TO AB SAID YOU
PACKAGE NOR SECOND PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL. THE CURRENT VOTERS TO
TWO TWO WITH CHAIR VOTING I
SENATOR WHEN. WHAT FOR TO I IT'S
SUPPORT HELP FORTY TWO. BILLS
OUT FORTY TWO- WE WILL NOW MOVE
OVER TO A EIGHT FORTY FOUR GIVE
SENT MADAM SECRETARY COLOR
CURRENT VOTERS SIX TO ZERO THE
CHAIR VICE CHAIR I CENTER REPORT
TO. WHAT HI HOPES AND ZERO THE
BILL IS OUT ZERO- WE WILL MOVE
OVER TO A NINE SEVEN S. AND
MEMBER TAKEN MADAM. PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL THAT VOTERS TO ZERO
CHAIR VICE CHAIR VOTING ICE
PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO HI BUT-
THE BILL IS OUT SEVEN ZERO WE
WILL NOW MOVE OVER TO AB NINE
SEVENTY BY A ASSEMBLY MEMBER
THREE OF US FAN OF SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THAT VOTED
SIX TO ZERO CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR
VOTING ICE SENATOR PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO HI. THE BILL'S SEVEN
ZERO. WE'RE DONE OKAY. HE WAS
THROUGH. FROM SO WITH EVERY SO
YOU CAN. I WANT TO THANK. I
PRESENT A THROUGH THE TELECOM OF
- AND THEIR TESTIMONY OUR IF WE
DO GET TO YOUR- FEEL FREE TO
REACH OUT- TO OFFICE TODAY IT
FOR THE RECORD AT THIS. THE COME
IS ADJOURNED YOU.