ALL RIGHT WE CONTINUE TO WELCOME
THE PUBLIC IN PERSON AND VIA THE
TELECONFERENCE ORVIS- FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT- FORTY TODAY THE
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS. EIGHT
SEVEN SEVEN TWO TWO SIX. EIGHT
TWO ONE SIX ACCESS CODE IS. FIVE
SEVEN ZERO ZERO ZERO NINE SIX
WE'RE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
HEARINGS TODAY IN THE- STREET
BUILDING- ASK FROM MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE PRESENT IN TWENTY
ONE HUNDRED SO WE CAN ESTABLISH
OUR QUORUM AND BEGIN THE HEARING
- ALSO ASK AUTHORS TO COME ON
DOWN- WE'VE GOT A TOTAL OF EIGHT
BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA ONE OF
THOSE BILLS ON THE CONSENT
CALENDAR THAT'S ITEM ONE. AB.
FOUR OH SEVEN. I THINK THE VICE
CHAIR FOR HIS DILIGENCE AND
BEING HERE AND WELCOME CENTER
TARA. AS WELL SO IT'S MY
UNDERSTANDING AGUIAR-CURRY IS ON
HER WAY. TO PRESENT ITEM. TO
MANAGE AND THAT.
YES OKAY SO BEFORE I LET HER
PRESENT- WE'RE GONNA MAKE ONE
NOTE JUST REGARDING THE
COMMITTEE MEHMET SO PAGE NINE
YOU COME ON UP YEAH- THANK YOU
FOR COME ON DOWN. THE PAGE NINE
OF YOUR ANALYSIS IS ITEM TWO
FULL AB ELEVEN FIFTY NINE PAGE
NINE OF THE ANALYSIS. HI HAS TAX
TO THE COMMITTEE IS ASKING TO
AMEND INTO SUBPARAGRAPH B. THREE
A- AND BECAUSE OF SOME
CONVERSATIONS THAT WERE STILL
UNFOLDING AFTER ANALYSIS WAS
PUBLISHED THERE'S ONE FURTHER
CLARIFICATION TO ADD TO THAT
AMENDMENTS AWAY THE ANALYSIS
SAYS. QUOTE TO ENSURE THAT ALL
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
REDUCTIONS AND REMOVALS ARE IN
ADDITION TO ANY REDUCTIONS IN
REMOVAL THAT WOULD OTHERWISE
OCCUR WE WILL BE ADDING QUOTE
USED FOR ANY MARKET BASED
COMPLIANCE MECHANISM I THINK
WE'VE GOT PEOPLE FOR SHARING
WITH THE MEMBERS. INCLUDING OKAY
YOU HAVE TO SO TO BE CRYSTAL
CLEAR THE MOMENT THE COMMITTEES
ASKING FOR US TO ADD. QUOTE IN
THAT ALL GREENHOUSE GAS
EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS AND
REMOVALS USED FOR ANY MARKET
BASED COMPLAINTS MECHANISM. ARE
IN ADDITION TO ANY REDUCTIONS IN
REMOVAL THAT WOULD OTHERWISE
OCCUR TO THE EXISTING B. THREE A
AND WE'RE GONNA STRIKE B. THREE
B. I HAVE ONCE AGAIN. WE'RE
GONNA MAKE SURE THAT ALL THE
MEMBERS ARE GOING TO HAVE THAT
THAT PAPERWORK RIGHT FOR THEM IF
YOU DON'T ALREADY HAVE IT- THE
WITHOUT CLEAR FIDE WOULD LOVE TO
LET YOU. RAISE THE BILL. THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN REYES FIRST
OF ALL LIKE TO THANK AND I DID
JUST REMEMBER STAYING
SUBCOMMITTEE SO WE DON CORNELIA
YEAH. WELL. WHERE TO GET THOSE
OF. UP ARE LIKE TO THANK YOU
COMMITTEES FOR WITH MY OFFICE
FURTHER THE OF THE BILL OF JOKES
THE FROM. A COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
. LAST YEAR AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY
SEVEN WAS AN ACT AS PART OF THE
CLIMATE PACKAGE AT THE VERY END
OF SESSION. AB SEVENTY FIFTY
SEVEN DIRECTOR THE NATURAL
RESOURCES AGENCY TO SET A RANGE
OF TARGETS FOR NATURAL CARBON
SEQUESTRATION. AND NATURE BASED
CLIMATE SOLUTIONS TO REDUCE
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS. TO
SUPPORT THE STATE'S CLIMATE
GOALS. PROVISIONS WERE ADDED AT
THE END OF SESSION THAT WERE
INTENDED TO DISALLOW THE DOUBLE
COUNTING OF GHG REDUCTIONS. AS
WELL AS THE DOUBLE COUNTING AND
USE OF STATE FUNDING TO BUILD TO
DEVELOP OFFSETS. THE PROVISION
REGARDING STATE FUNDING HAS
CAUSED. SOME CONFUSION. AMONG
FORSTER'S CONSERVATION GROUPS
AND OTHERS WHO HAVE FOR
SEQUESTRATION PROJECTS. AND SIX
STATE FUNDING FOR OTHER
RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION
EFFORTS. AS AMENDED IN THE
COMMITTEE AB FIFTH ELEVEN FIFTY
NINE WILL REMOVE THE CONFUSING
PROVISION INSTEAD CLARIFIED THAT
ALL GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTIONS.
AND REMOVALS USED IN FOR IN THE
MARKET BASED COMPLIANCE
MECHANISMS ARE. IN ADDITION TO
WHAT WOULD OTHERWISE OCCUR.
SIMPLY PUT AS AMENDED THIS BILL
CLARIFIES THAT THE NATIONAL
SEQUESTRATION PROJECT MAY ONLY
SELL OFFSET CREDITS THAT ARE
ABOVE AND BEYOND WHAT WOULD
OCCUR UNDER OTHER REGULATORY
OBLIGATIONS ARREST DURATION
EFFORTS. THE PROVISION IN LAST
YEAR'S AB SEVENTY FIFTY SEVEN IT
WAS THEM BEING AMBIGUOUS FIGURES
AND- CONFUSING. THERE ARE
RESOURCES HAS PROVIDED GUIDANCE
ON HOW TO INTERPRET THIS
PROVISION WHICH HAS BEEN
EXTREMELY USEFUL HOWEVER IT DOES
NOT HAVE THE FORCE OF LAW. AB
ELEVEN FIFTY NINE PROVIDES THE
CERTAINTY NONPROFIT CONSERVATION
GROUPS TRIBES AND OTHERS
REQUIRED TO CONTINUE ACCEPTING
STATE FUNDING FOR ACQUISITION
RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION
PROJECTS. THIS BILL IS NECESSARY
TO ADDRESS THE UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES AND CONFUSION
CREATED BY LAST YEAR'S A. B.
SEVENTEEN FIFTY SEVEN. ARE WITH
ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT I
HAVE READ OUT AS PRINCIPAL
CONSULTANT FOR ENVIRONMENTAL AND
ENERGY CONSULTING ON BEHALF THE
CONSERVATION FUND. I THINK.
WE'LL PRETEND. ZERO I
RESPECTFULLY ASK. OKAY DO WE
HAVE FOR ANYONE WHO WAS
TESTIFYING SUPPORT OR- FOLKS
WANT TO VOICE SUPPORT FOR THE
BILL. THE OPPOSITION. OPPOSITION
TO THE BILL IS AB ELEVEN FIFTY
NINE- OKAY- ANYONE OKAY LET'S GO
TO PHONE LINES AB ELEVEN FIFTY
NINE ANYONE WANTS ME COMMENTS
WHY DON'T SUPPORT OPPOSITION AB
ELEVEN FIFTY NINE. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR ON THE PHONES PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO TO VOTE ON THE ON
OR SUPPORT FOR UP LOCAL
OPPOSITION FOR A BI ELEVEN FIFTY
NINE WOULD HAVE ONE IN Q.
ALREADY BOOK ONLINE NUMBER ONE
FORTY ONE THESE GOING UP. ONE
FORTY ONE LINES OPEN PLEASE ON
MUTE AND CONTINUE. I WAS CALLING
ABOUT ANOTHER BILL I'M SORRY. I
THANK YOU MISTER SUGAR NO OTHER
CALLERS IN Q. OKAY. LET'S READ
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS THOUGHTS
COMMENTS NO- WE WILL ENTERTAIN A
MOTION WHEN- WHEN WE HAVE A
QUORUM- BUT IT DOES ENJOY DO
PASS RECOMMENDATION WITH THE
ACCEPTANCE OF THE AMENDMENTS.
AND- BECAUSE AS MUCH AS WE TRY
TO DO PERFECT BILLS THERE ARE
TIMES THAT WE MISSED SOME THINGS
AND THIS IS ONE WHERE WE NEED TO
CLEAN IT UP. MAKE IT WORK FOR
THOSE THAT ARE THAT ARE
INTENDING TO USE SO I ASKED FOR
YOUR I. BILL THREE TIMES. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU SO MUCH
. ALL RIGHT LET'S SAID THANK YOU
THANK YOU MISTER PRICEY SUMMER
BARN K. HAND HERE TO PRESENT AB
TEN FORTY TWO THAT'S A- ITEM
THREE YEAR JANICE MEMBERS. THE
REPRESENT ONE READY. THANK YOU
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS GOOD TO SEE
YOU- I AM PROUD TO PRESENT AB
TEN FORTY TWO WHICH INSURES THE
DEPARTMENT OF PESTICIDE
REGULATION REGULATES ALL
PESTICIDES IN OUR FOOD SYSTEM
INCLUDE IN PESTICIDES. THAT ARE
ON OUR SEATS JUST TO BE CLEAR
THIS BILL IS NOT A BAN IT SIMPLY
ENSURES THE DPR REGULATES
PESTICIDES ON SEEDS THE SAME WAY
RIGHT REGULATES OTHER PESTICIDES
IN OUR SYSTEM. CALIFORNIA HAS
ONE OF THE STRONGEST AND BEST
FUNDED PESTICIDE REGULATORS IN
THE NATION. HOWEVER CALIFORNIANS
CAN BE EXPOSED TO A WIDE RANGE
OF UNREGULATED PESTICIDES IN ON
MONITOR MOUNTS. SIMPLY BECAUSE
THE PAST SIZE WERE USED TO TREAT
STEEDS INSTEAD OF. THE CROP ONE
IT'S GROWING. EITHER IT'S THERE
IN THE SOIL THEIR WATER IN THE
BECOME PLANTS. EVERY ELEMENT OF
THAT PROCESS WHERE WATER CROPS
CAN THERE BUT FOR BE AVENUES RUN
REGULATE PESTICIDE
CONTAMINATION. PUTTING
FARMWORKERS THE ENVIRONMENT AND
OUR FOOD SYSTEM AT RISK. SEED
TREATMENTS DO NOT REPLACE FOR
APPLICATIONS THEY SIMPLY ADD
MORE CHEMICALS OFTEN WITHOUT ANY
PATH TO JUSTIFY IT. LACK OF
REGULATION MEANS UNMITIGATED
EXPOSURE TO THESE PESTICIDES.
DPR STUDY LETTERS SHOW THAT. THE
USE OF PASS AYE THE LETTUCE
SEEDS THREE ANYWHERE FROM FIVE
TO THIRTY FIVE TIMES HIGHER THAN
KNOWN AND REGULATED USE. SINCE
THE PAIR DID NOT REQUIRE
REPORTING FOR SEED CALIFORNIA
HAS LITTLE IDEA HOW MANY
PESTICIDES ARE IN OUR SYSTEM.
AND WHAT EFFECTS THEY MAY HAVE.
THE BILL IS SIMPLE IT REQUIRES
DEEP HERE TO REGULATE PESTICIDES
USED ON SEATS. IT IS NOT
DETERMINE THE CONTENT OF THOSE
REGULATIONS OR BAN ANY USES IT
DIFFERS THAT. TO THE DEPARTMENT.
IF WE TRUST OUR PESTICIDE
REGULATOR THEY SHOULD BE
REGULATING ALL USES OF
PESTICIDES TO KEEP CALIFORNIANS
SAFE. WITH ME HERE TODAY IN
SUPPORT OF YOUR DEMAND DIRECTOR
ENVIRONMENT CALIFORNIAN HEARTY
KERN WITH THE AMERICAN BIRD
CONSERVANCY. WHO IS ALSO
AVAILABLE FOR TECHNICAL FASTER.
THANK YOU SEE BEFORE BEFORE YOU
THAT WAS JUST A VERY WARM AND
THEN WE'RE GOING TO YEAR. TO THE
WITNESS. AS IT'S ON CONSIDER
BECAUSE- SENATORS AL. HERE ALLEN
HERE DALLI. DALLI HEAR GONZALEZ.
HER TADO. HER TADO HERE
MENJIVAR. MENJIVAR HERE WHEN.
SKINNER OKAY WE GOT A QUORUM- SO
LET'S LET'S NOT PURSUE THAT
WITNESS. OKAY THANK YOU. AND MY
NAME'S LORI T. HEN AND THE STATE
DIRECTOR FOR ENVIRONMENT
CALIFORNIA'S STATEWIDE
ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS. AND WE'RE
SO THRILLED TO BE SPONSORS OF AB
TEN FORTY TWO AND TO SUPPORT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER THAT'LL PARTY
HAD AND- AND JOIN WITH THE
AMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY TO FOR
THIS. AND THIS BILL IS REALLY
NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE BIRDS
THE BEES AND ALL OF THOSE THAT
RELY ON AND HELP THE
ENVIRONMENT. WE ARE IN THE
MIDDLE OF WHAT MANY ARE CALLING
THE SIXTH EXTINCTION A STUNNING
DROP IN BIODIVERSITY THREATENING
THE WHOLE WEB OF LIFE THAT WE
ALL RELY ON. AND A RECENT STUDY
FOUND THAT AMERICA'S
AGRICULTURAL LANDSCAPE IS FORTY
EIGHT MORE TIMES MORE TOXIC
TODAY THAN IT WAS JUST A FEW
DECADES AGO. AND AUDLEY WHEN IS
A PESTICIDE NOT ACTUALLY HUNTED
OF THE PESTICIDE. AND THAT'S
WHEN IT IS TREATED ON STEEP. ARM
AND FOR DECADES CHEMICAL
COMPANIES HAVE BEEN TREATING
SEEDS WITH PESTICIDES AND
BECAUSE OF THIS LOOPHOLE IN THE
LAW THAT THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
DESCRIBED. THE USE OF THIS
ENTIRE USE OF PESTICIDES IS NOT
TRACKED OR MONITORED OR IN ANY
WAY RESTRICT IT I'M AND NOT
INCLUDE CHEMICALS THAT ARE NOT
EVEN APPROVED HERE AND
REGISTERED HERE IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AND THOSE ARE NOT
GETTING INTO THE ENVIRONMENT.
AND WE KNOW THAT WHEN PESTICIDES
ARE APPLIED ON CT GROW INTO
EVERY PART OF THE PLANTS THIS
LAW FAR AS DUST INTO THE
ENVIRONMENT THE SOAK INTO THE
SOIL WETTING CONTAMINATE OUR
WATER. AND AND THEY CAN ALSO
HARM HUMAN HEALTH AS WELL AS THE
HEALTH OF POLLINATORS AND OTHER
SPECIES THAT THIS BILL REALLY
CLOSES THIS LOOPHOLE WHICH IS
WHY. WE URGE YOUR AYE VOTE. AND
WE ALSO. NEXT- I THINK. THANK
YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU ASSEMBLY
MEMBER BAUER QUE HAN. LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN OF THE COMMITTEE GOOD
AFTERNOON MY NAME IS HEARTY KERN
AND I'M DIRECTOR OF GOVERNMENT
RELATIONS FOR AMERICAN BIRD
CONSERVANCY AND WE ARE ONE OF
THE ORGANIZATIONS CO SPONSORING
THIS FANTASTIC- PIECE OF
LEGISLATION. ALONGSIDE OUR GREAT
FRIENDS AND ENVIRONMENT
CALIFORNIA SO THANK YOU SO MUCH
FIRSTLY FOR YOUR WORK AND YOUR
CONSIDERATION OF THIS BILL. AB
TEN FORTY TWO CLOSES A MAJOR GAP
IN PESTICIDE OVERSIGHT LEFT BY A
LOOPHOLE IN FEDERAL LAW AMERICAN
BIRD CONSERVANCY STRONGLY
BELIEVES AND BALANCED
COMMONSENSE OVERSIGHT FOR STATE
AGENCIES WHICH IS WHY WE ARE SO
SUPPORTIVE OF TEN FORTY TWO.
THIS BILL IS NOT A BAN ON
PESTICIDES NOR DOES IT REMOVE
IMPORTANT PEST CONTROL TOOLS
INTEGRAL TO CALIFORNIA'S
AGRICULTURAL SUCCESS. TEN FORTY
TWO WOULD GRANT DPR THE ABILITY
TO TRACK PESTICIDE COATED SEEDS
WITH THE SAME AUTHORITY NO NOT
NECESSARILY BUT THE SAME
MEASURES AS IT DOES OTHER
PESTICIDES IN THE STATE. THAT
TWENTY TWENTY ONE PRESENTATION
THAT'S BEEN REFERENCED A COUPLE
OF TIMES TODAY WAS VERY VERY
CLEAR IN SAYING THAT ONLY ABOUT
43% OF CHEMICALS USED ON SEEDS
IN CALIFORNIA. ARE CHEMICALS
THAT ARE REGISTERED FOR SAFE USE
IN CALIFORNIA. PESTICIDE
APPLICATION WITHOUT OVERSIGHT
AUTHORITY OR FULL KNOWLEDGE OF
ACTIVE INGREDIENTS USED HURTS
PRODUCERS IT DOES NOT ALLOW THEM
TO ADEQUATELY MANAGE PEST
RESISTANCE IT MAY INTERACT WITH
OTHER CHEMICALS OR PEST
MANAGEMENT PROCEDURES THEY'RE
USING. AND IT COMES AT AN
INCREASED COST TO GROWERS WHILE
OFFERING MIXED RESULTS ON
EFFICACY. THOUGH THEY ARE AN
EXAMPLE OF PRECISION AGRICULTURE
THERE IS NO DATA SUPPORT THE
THOUGHT THAT C. TREATMENT
APPLICATIONS REPLACE OTHER TYPES
OF PEST CONTROL INSTEAD THEY'RE
OFTEN USED IN ADDITION TO THEM.
TEN FORTY TO ENSURE IS THAT ONLY
PESTICIDES WHICH ARE REGISTERED
FOR USE IN CALIFORNIA ARE USING
CALIFORNIA. AND INCLUDES A GRACE
PERIOD FOR GROWERS AND PESTICIDE
BENDERS TO ADJUST TO THE
REQUIREMENT THAT ALL PESTICIDES
IN THE STATE THAT YOU'RE TO A
LOT. TO MAKE GOOD POWER YOU NEED
GOOD INFORMATION AB TEN FORTY
TWO WILL CLOSE KNOWLEDGE GAPS
AND GIVE CALIFORNIANS THE TOOLS
NEEDED TO PROTECT THEIR
LIVELIHOODS AND ENVIRONMENT.
AMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY THANKS
YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND REQUEST
YOUR AYE VOTE ON A. B. TEN FORTY
TWO. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO
MUCH- ANY OTHER FOLKS YOU WANT
TO WIN SUPPORT OF THE BILL Z. BE
TEN FORTY TWO. BILL ALLEY- FOR
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ABIGAIL
ALVAREZ WITH THE PESTICIDE
ACTION NETWORK CALIFORNIANS FOR
PESTICIDE REFORM AND THE CENTER
FOR FOOD SAFETY. AND THEN ON
BEHALF OF A CLEAN WATER ACTION.
AND THAT FRIEND'S COMMITTEE ON
LEGISLATION AUDUBON AND FAMILY
ADVOCATES FOR ACT CHEMICAL
FACTS. AND THEY ALSO WANTED TO
INDICATE OUR SUPPORT THANK YOU
GREAT- THANK YOU ALL RIGHT.
LET'S GO TO OPPOSITION ****
REYES CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL.
GOOD AFTERNOON THANK YOU VERY
MUCH DENNIS I'LL BE ON OF THE
COUNTY OF THE CALIFORNIA FEW
SUFFICIENT. THANK YOU ARE- THE
SELLING MEMBER BRINGING THIS
ISSUE FORWARD. AND FRANKLY
TREATED SEEDS TO PROVIDE
BENEFITS AND DO REDUCE OVERALL
THE USE OF PESTICIDES IN
CALIFORNIA BY GETTING THE PLAN
OFF IN ITS INFANCY STAGE VERY
STRONG IT CAN RESIST A LOT MORE
PASSED VISAS. AND THEREFORE YOU
HAVE LESS FOLIAR APPLICATIONS
AFTER USING TREATED SEATS ARE
GENERALLY THERE'S A VERY
POSITIVE BENEFIT TO USING
TREATED SEATS AND WE AGREE. WE
AGREE WITH THE STATED INTENT OF
THE BILL WHICH IS TO CLOSE THE
LOOPHOLE THAT ALL MATERIALS THAT
ARE USED TO BEST OF GERALD THERE
USED TO TREAT THE TO CALIFORNIA.
AND ALMOST SIEGE SHOULD BE
REGULATED AND SO WE HAVE
PROVIDED. A AMENDMENTS TO THE
OFFICE THAT ADDRESSES THAT
LOOPHOLE AND ADDRESSES THAT
FROM- FROM YOU KNOW THAT AT
THAT. STAGE WHAT WE ARE
CONCERNED ABOUT AND WHAT THE
BILL ACTUALLY DOES IS IT DOESN'T
ONLY REGULATE PESTICIDES. WHICH
DPR REGULATES PESTICIDES AND
CDFA REGULATE SEATS. THIS BILL
WOULD HAVE DPR REGULATING THE
TREATED SEAT ITSELF. AND GIVE
THAT FULL OPEN ACCESS FOR DPR TO
MAKE A HOST OF- REGULATORY
REQUIREMENTS ON THE SEAT ITSELF
NOT THE PESTICIDE MATERIALS SO
THIS IS A COMPLETE CHANGE. IN
HOW PESTICIDES ARE REGULATED IN
CALIFORNIA AND ALSO HOW SEEDS
REGULAR CALIFORNIA WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT THAT SCHISM IS
NOT CROSSED AND THAT'S WHAT OUR
AMENDMENTS TO SAY DPR HAS FULL
AUTHORITY TO REGULATE THE PAST
SECRETARIAL. AND CDFA REGULATES
THE- THE SEAT ITSELF AND THEN
THERE'S OTHER THINGS THAT WE
BROUGHT FOR TO DATE. THERE IT'S
IN THE IT'S IN THE- ALL THE
ANALYSIS AND ALL THE DISCUSSION
THAT THERE LACKS DATA AND THAT'S
CLEAR. SO WHAT WE ALSO PROVIDE
IS A PESTICIDE USE REPORTED
SYSTEM TO USE CLOUT THAT.
DOVETAILS. NICELY WITH THE SEED
OF- THAT AND ALSO HOW DEEP YOUR
- THE BEST I'D USUALLY. AND DATA
COLLECTION. WE ARE IN THOSE SO
WE'VE ADDRESSED THAT ISSUE GOING
FORWARD THEN WE ALSO PICKED UP A
COUPLE OTHER ISSUES WHEN YOU
LOOK AT THE SEEDS AND HOW THE
REGULATED. THE LABEL NEEDS TO BE
TO CONFORM TO THAT SO YOU NEED
THAT TO SEE A DOCTOR REGULATED
BY CFA. TO HAVE AMENDMENTS TO
THE SEAT ACT ON THE LABEL INSIDE
AND FINALLY ENFORCEMENT AYE
COMMISSIONERS AND FORCE BESIDE
LOS AND SEED LOST. TO GIVE
AUTHORITY FOR STOP SALE IN OUR
AMENDMENTS. TO THE AYE
COMMISSIONER TO DO THEIR JOB AND
ENFORCE THIS. WEEK BROUGHT
FORWARD A VERY COMPREHENSIVE
MORE COMPREHENSIVE FRANKLY THAN
THE BILL. BUT WE ALSO KEPT
EVERYBODY IN THE REGULATORY
APPROPRIATE LANES AND THAT'S
VERY CRITICAL SO THAT'S WHAT
WE'RE OPPOSE LESS AMENDED.
HOWEVER WE HAVE BROUGHT FORWARD
SOME SOME AMENDMENTS
COMPREHENSIVE AMENDMENTS THAT
WILL ADDRESS THAT AND ADDRESS
ALL THE ISSUES. THAT WERE
DISCUSSED TODAY. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU AND I KNOW THE BILL'S
GOING TO AGRICULTURE COMMITTEE.
MORE I'M SURE A LOT OF THIS WILL
BE VERY CAREFULLY WEIGHED- AND
ENGAGE WITH. OTHER FOLKS ONE
RAISE CONCERNS YEAH ABSOLUTELY A
GOOD AFTERNOON TAYLOR RUSSIAN ON
BEHALF OF WESTERN PLAN HEALTH
ASSOCIATION AND VARIOUS
AGRICULTURAL ASSOCIATIONS WE
LIKE TO ECHO OUR COMMENTS OF MR
I'LL BE ON A- EVEN WITH OUR POST
POSITION WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH THE AUTHOR STAFF HAS BEEN
PHENOMENAL. ON IT BEING OPEN TO
OUR CONCERNS OUR INTERESTS I
THINK I JUST WANT TO ZOOM OUT TO
SAY THIS IS AN INCREDIBLY
COMPLEX SYSTEM. PESTICIDES HAVE
A COMPLEX SYSTEM WITH MULTIPLE
AGENCIES SEATS ARE CRITICAL TO
THE USE OF AGRICULTURE AND
OUTSIDE OF AGRICULTURE AND
COMMERCIAL USES WHILE. AND SO WE
NEED TO BE ABLE TO LOOK FOR
BOUNCE SOLUTIONS. THAT SERVE
BOTH OF THOSE FUNCTIONS AND THAT
WORK WITHIN OUR COMPLEX SYSTEMS
THAT IS WHAT OUR AMENDMENTS SEEK
TO DO- BUT WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
IN EARNEST WITH THE AUTHOR'S
OFFICE. THANK YOU- GOOD
AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE MATTHEW OFF
WESTERN GROWERS ASSOCIATION-
JUST A LINE MY COMMENTS WITH
THOSE MADE BY AND THIS RUSSIAN.
THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
MY NAME'S CHRIS RUDER REPS OF
THE CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU WE
WERE HERE ALSO IN OPPOSITION
HOWEVER WE LOOK FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR AND- WE
THINK THE AMENDED LANGUAGE WHERE
I THINK GETS US WHERE WE NEED TO
BE. SELF GOOD AFTERNOON JENNIFER
ROWE WITH CAPITAL ADVOCACY ON
BEHALF OF THE BIOTECHNOLOGY
INNOVATION ORGANIZATION. ALSO AN
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED POSITION
THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH ALL
RIGHT. I LET'S GO TO PHONE LINES
FOLKS ONE AWAY IN EITHER AND
SUPPORTER. OPPOSITION OR
CONCERNS ABOUT AB TEN FORTY TWO
. COARSELY JIM IF YOU WISH TO
COMMENT. OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE. THE BUREAU. WILL BE
GOING TO FIND ONE FORTY FIVE.
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MICHAEL CHAIRED
ON BEHALF THE CALIFORNIANS TO
PROVIDE OVERSEE SUPPORT ITSELF
THANK YOU. ESTERLINE ONE FORTY
EIGHT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. JOHN
POTTER COMPLETED FOR KIDS THAT
ARE STRONGLY SUPPORT. AND WE DO
HAVE ANOTHER THAT'S JUST QUEUED
UP ONE MOME WATER LINE NUMBERS
GIVEN. NEXT WE'RE GOING TO LINE
ONE FORTY. PLEASE GO AHEAD. B.
O. IN THE ON THE RAPTORS ARE
THE- SOLUTION. FOR AND THERE'S
CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR GREAT I WILL BRING
THEM BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
THOUGHTS COMMENTS. SO CAROLINE
MENTOR CENTER MOVES WHEN
APPROACH WENT WHEN READY TO
THANK YOU APPRECIATE THAT- AND
LET'S- LET'S GO TO ARREST HER
FOR QUESTIONS THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN GOOD TO SEE YOU. SENATE
REMEMBER SO- VERSUS WAS PROBABLY
SAY AND- ACTUALLY MISSY. ARMOR
WHAT I DO FOR A LIVING- BESIDES
THIS JOB- AND- I WON I'VE BEEN
OBVIOUSLY LOBBIED IN AND- AND A
LOT IN THIS AREA SO I ACTUALLY
HOLD. AND APPLICATORS PERMIT
THAT ALLOWS ME TO USE.
HERBICIDES AND PESTICIDES ON MY
FARM- BY THE WAY I AM 95%
CERTIFIED ORGANIC ON MY FARM AND
SO IT'S REALLY HARD. TO- MEETIC
THAT WE HAVE IN. AND I JUST WANT
TO SAY THAT- TREATED SEED IS. IS
QUITE FRANKLY VERY NECESSARY
AND- IF AND SOMETIMES YOU DON'T
KNOW THAT YOU HAVE- SO FOR
EXAMPLE IN CEREAL GRAINS WHICH I
PRIMARILY PRODUCE- WE HAVE-
FUNGICIDES CULTS MUCH. AND THE
PLANT GROWS EVERYTHING LOOKS
GREAT AND WHEN IT FLOWERS AND
GOES TO MAKE IT SEAT THE SEAT
ACTUALLY. TURNS TO DUST. AND YOU
HAVE NO CROP AFTER YOU'VE DONE
EVERYTHING ALONG THE WAY SO IF
YOU TREAT US SEE IT REDUCES THAT
IN YOU DON'T HAVE THAT PROBLEM
SO- I DO WANT TO NARROW IN ON
THOUGH I DO I READ. THE AUTHORS-
WHAT THIS BILL DOES ON YOUR
WEBSITE ACTUALLY- THE
FOURTEENTH- TO SIMPLY MANDATES
THE DEPARTMENT OF PESTICIDE
REGULATIONS DPR. REGULATE THE
PESTICIDE USE TO TREAT SEEDS
THIS MERS BIG. IT'S EXISTING
AUTHORITY OF REGULATE PESTICIDES
USED ON CROPS AND IS CONSISTENT
WITH THE WITH ITS CHARGE TO
REGULATED PESTICIDE USE- WITH
THAT BEING SAID- I WANT TO JUST.
MAYBE IT. NARROWING IN ON I
THINK THE REAL PART OF THIS BILL
THAT REALLY THIS IS CHALLENGING
FOR ME- THE CDFA GOVERNED SO
THAT THE INFAMOUS THAT THE- OF.
OPPOSITION BROUGHT FORWARD-
REALLY NEED TO BE IN THIS BILL
BECAUSE- WHAT WE HAVE IS WE HAVE
DEPARTMENT DPR WHICH REGULATES
PESTICIDES HERBICIDES WE HAVE
CDFA. THAT REGULATES C. N. THE
THEIR THEIR BLUR TOGETHER AND IF
YOU LOOK TO- ANALYSIS WHICH I
THINK WAS VERY AWESOME BY. STAFF
THE DID VERY GOOD WORK- IF YOU
GO TO- PAGE A- THE ANALYSIS
SECTION THREE. REGISTERED VERSUS
REGULATED THIS PARAGRAPH RIGHT
HERE REALLY EXPLAINS- I THINK
WHAT TO- THE SEED ASSOCIATION-
REPRESENTATIVE TALKED ABOUT AND
I THINK WE NEED TO FOCUS IN ON-
THAT AMENDMENT IT'S VERY
CRITICAL TO MAKING SURE THAT.
THE AGENCY STAY IN THEIR LANE
AND THAT WE DON'T HAVE THE
ABILITY FOR- DPR TO BE
REGULATING SEED AND CDFA- NOT
DOING IT STAYED IN OUR LANES AND
I THINK THAT IS SOMETHING I WANT
TO ASK YOU ABOUT. IS- WHAT
WHAT'S YOUR PLAN FOR THAT PART
OF THIS- AND I NOTICED IT AND I
WHEN I MET WITH THE- MANY PEOPLE
ON THE OPPOSITION SIDE. AND THEY
HAD SAID THEY HAD SUBMITTED
THESE AS AMENDMENTS AND YOU
HAVEN'T BEEN INTERESTED IN
TAKING ANY THESE MINUTES AND SO
I KNOW THAT- THE CHAIR MENTIONED
THAT YOU KNOW WE'RE GOING TO
TAKE A MINUTES AND THIS IS THE
POLICY COMMITTEE WILL REVIEW
TOXICS. THIS IS WHERE WE SHOULD
BE TALKING ABOUT THESE ISSUES IN
THIS COMMITTEE NOT IN THE ACT
COMMITTEE- LATER THIS IS THE
TOXIC COMMITTEE WHERE WE- WHERE
WE TYPICALLY DO THE DPR. AND THE
AND THE- CALIFORNIA PART TO NAG
STUFF WOULD HAPPEN IN THE OTHER
COMMITTEE SO CAN YOU DRESS THAT
ISSUE PLEASE YES THANK YOU
SENATOR- YOU SAID A LOT OF
ADDRESS SUBMIT. SO TO SAY
APERTURAL. HAVING SERVED ON THE
MIR COMMITTEE IN THE OTHER HOUSE
WITH YOU I KNOW YOUR EXPERIENCE
WHILE. I'M AND- I WANT TO SAY I
AGREE WITH YOU WHOLEHEARTEDLY
THAT I THINK TREATED SEEDS. ARE
NECESSARY THIS BILL DOES NOT
ATTENTION OR DO I INTEND TO GET
RID OF TREATED SEEDS SO I WANT
THAT TO BE REALLY CLEAR THAT
THAT'S NOT AN AREA OF
DISAGREEMENT BETWEEN US TOO. I'M
AS FOR THE AMENDMENTS THAT WE
HEARD FROM ISRAELI ARMY THEY
CAME TO MY- STAFF THIS MORNING.
SO THERE WAS DIFFERENT
AMENDMENTS AND I BELIEVE THERE
WERE NEW ONES TODAY THAT WHICH
IS WHAT WAS RALLY ANI PREVIEWED
AND HE'S SHAKING HIS HEAD SO YOU
CAN. INTERFERE WITH THAT- WE
HAVE BEEN WORKING REALLY CLOSELY
WITH THAT BECAUSE I THINK SINCE
THE BEGINNING. OF NO EFFECT. I'M
SO THE BEGINNING AND WE HAVE
AGREED THAT CERTAIN THINGS THAT
ARE NOT ALLOWED IN CALIFORNIA TO
BE SPRAYED SHOULDN'T BE
UNTREATED SEEDS AND THAT I MEAN
I DON'T WANNA MISS STATE WHAT
THE OPPOSITION IS SAID BUT
THAT'S BEEN SOMETHING THAT I
THINK WE'VE BEEN IN AGREEMENT
ON. PRETTY MUCH THROUGH THIS
PROCESS IN THE ASSEMBLY AND SO
GETTING TO A PLACE WHERE WE
ACHIEVE THAT GOAL I'M IS WHAT
WE'VE TRIED TO DO AND- THE PRIOR
AMENDMENTS DIDN'T DO EXACTLY
MISS ROBBIE ON HIS AMENDMENTS TO
TODAY SO I DO I HAVE BEEN. OUT
OF THE OFFICE LITERALLY ALL DAY
SO I HAVE NOT HAD THE
OPPORTUNITY REVIEW THEM- BUT DO
LOOK FORWARD TO DOING SO AND I'M
HOPE THAT WE CAN MEET OUR SHARED
GOAL HERE. SO I GUESS DON'T HAVE
TIME TO SAY ABOUT HIS AMENDMENTS
BUT TO YOUR POINT I THINK. I'M
HAVING BEEN A FORMER REGULATORY
LAWYER I AGREE I MEAN WE DON'T
WANNA MESS UP THE WAY THE
AGENCIES WORK AND- I'M HAPPY TO
TAKE A LOOK AT THAT. ONE ALSO
LIKE TO JUST MENTION THAT. THE
PROCESS OF IT OBVIOUSLY. THE EPA
DOES NATIONALLY PAY DOESN'T
REGULATE THIS AND THERE IS A
THERE IS A LOOPHOLE WE DON'T-
THAT'S NOT. PART OF THE
DISCUSSION THAT WE DON'T AGREE
WITH THAT THERE THERE NEEDS TO
BE BUT THE PROCESS. TO DO THAT
IS NOT SOME SIMPLE HEY WE'RE
JUST GONNA GO DO THAT THERE'S A
PROCESS FOR LABELING. AND THERE
THAT NEEDS TO HAVE SOME TIME. TO
BE ABLE TO BE ABLE TO HAVE
THOSE- JUSTIFIED. PESTICIDES GO
TO THE PROCESS TO ACTUALLY BE
LABELED- IT WE CANNOT. USE
STOPPING CALIFORNIA'S NOT LABEL
FOR CALIFORNIA SO THAT THIS BILL
WILL ACTUALLY DO THAT. AND SO.
TO FILTER IF TO DO GET THE
LOOPHOLE WE NEED TO ACTUALLY GET
THE- OF. THE ABILITY FOR THE
PROCESS TO HAPPEN. AND WHEN WE
TALK ABOUT I'D LIKE TO KNOW
FROM. FROM THE FOLKS THERE
SPONSORS- DO WE HAVE ANY. CASE
WHERE THE USE WHERE YOU ACTUALLY
HAVE- THE REGULATION TO YOU'VE
SEEN THIS HAPPEN WHERE YOU
THERE'S- DAMAGE. IN CALIFORNIA.
DAMAGE JESSICA REGARDING DAMAGE
FROM TREATED SEEDS YEAH WHERE
WE'VE SEEN LIKE IS WHAT THEY
MENTIONED A BIRD. THE FOLKS SO I
WE PLANT THE STUFF IN THE
GROUND. THAT YOU WOULD HAVE TO
DIG IT UP TO. EAT THE SEED.
PARTY KERN AMERICAN BIRD
CONSERVANCY BIRD GUY JUST BEING
REFERENCE YET ON THAT SO I. I
LOVE IT I LOVE IT PER DAY. SO
SORRY CAN YOU CLARIFY YOUR
QUESTION YOU'RE ASKING ARE THERE
IS THERE ANY EVIDENCE OF DAMAGE.
TO WILDLIFE FROM TREATED YEAH
WHAT- IS THERE BEEN A THERE'S A
BEEN DOCUMENTED IN CALIFORNIA
WE'VE SEEN THE ACTUALLY THE
TREATED SEED ITSELF HAS. CAUSED
DAMAGE TO THE WILDLIFE SAID THE
CURRENT LOOPHOLE IS PART OF THE
PROBLEM WHY THIS BILL IS SO
IMPORTANT THERE WAS A CASE. NEW
JERSEY SEVERAL YEARS AGO WHERE-
A FLOCK OF RED WINGED BLACKBIRDS
WAS FEEDING ON PESTICIDE COATED
SEED WOUND UP- DYING FROM IT AND
THERE WAS NO THERE WAS
ABSOLUTELY NO WAY TO. FULLY
TRACE IT BACK TO EXACTLY WHERE
THAT SOURCE MAY HAVE COME FROM
OR TO I TAKE ANYWHERE TO
INTRODUCED MITIGATIONS BECAUSE
OF THE LOOPHOLES IN THE FEDERAL
LAW WHICH IS WHY IT'S SO
IMPORTANT AND THIS IS TAKEN UP
AT THE STATE LEVEL. ESPECIALLY
IN STATES LIKE CALIFORNIA WHERE
THERE IS SUCH A LARGE AMOUNT OF
AGRICULTURE THAT HAPPENS
ADDITIONALLY I CALIFORNIA HAS
SEEN LARGELY ELEVATED. LEVELS OF
NEONICOTINOID INSECTICIDES WHICH
ARE ONE OF THE MOST COMMON OP
PESTICIDES THAT ARE USED AS A
SEED COATING AND A LOT OF ITS
SURFACE WATER AND GROUNDWATER
THAT'S BEEN TESTED. AND NOT
KNOWING EXACTLY HOW MUCH OR
WHERE PESTICIDE COATED SEED IS
USED IT'S HARD TO KNOW EXACTLY
WHERE SOME OF THAT CONTAMINATION
MAY HAVE COME FROM WHICH IS WHY
THE HEART OF THIS BILL WHICH IS
MAKING SURE THE DPR. HAS THE
AUTHORITY TO LOOK. MORE AT
TREATED SEEDS IS SO IMPORTANT.
OKAY TAKE THAT I YOUR- ARE ON IT
. BASICALLY THERE HASN'T BEEN A
CASE IN CALIFORNIA BUT THERE'S
BEEN A CASE SOMEWHERE ELSE THAT
IS- BEEN LATE SO I TOOK THE I
TOOK A NOTE OF WHAT YOU SAID. TO
MAKE GOOD POLICY YOU NEED GOOD
INFORMATION IS WHAT YOU ACTUALLY
SAID EARLIER SO IDENTITY AND
THANK YOU FOR THAT- INFORMATION
SO I WANTED TO- AGAIN I'D LIKE
TO THANK YOU I WANT TO ASK-
MISTER ALBION NEED TO COME UP.
AND IF HE COULD PROVIDE
INFORMATION ON THE AMENDMENTS
THAT WERE YOU PROVIDED TODAY
BECAUSE I THINK THESE ARE
CRITICAL TO THE FUTURE. OF
DECISION DISCUSSIONS THAT NEED
TO BE MADE FOR THIS BILL SO YES
SO ARE THE MEMBERS WE PROVIDE A
PER PREVIOUSLY BACK IN. MAY DID-
CLOSE THE LOOPHOLE AND ADDRESS
THAT NOW THEY ALSO ADDRESSED.
SOME CONCERNS THAT WERE BROUGHT
UP BY OTHER SIMPLY MEMBERS IN
THE IN THE ASSEMBLY- AND THAT
WAS. UP SOME TIMING ISSUES AND
WE HAVE A DIFFERENT TIME IN
STANDARD THE TWENTY SIX IS THE
BILLS TODAY. THIS WOULD HAVE TO
THE PROHIBITION I LOCAL BANK.
PROHIBITION PLANTED SEEDS THAT
ARE NOT TREATED WITH CALIFORNIA
REGISTER MATERIAL STARTED TWENTY
SEVEN- WE HAVE. THE DEPARTMENT
STARTING REGULATIONS IMMEDIATELY
AND AN EIGHTEEN MONTHS TO GET
THROUGH THERE THE REGULATORY
PROCESS. THAT'D BE TWENTY SEVEN
Y. TWENTY SEVEN. RIGHT NOW JUST
EARLIER THIS MONTH THE DPR. PUT
OUT A- REPORT. THAT THEY THAT
THEY'RE MANDATED TO DO AND HOW
LONG'S IT TAKE FOR PEST SIDE TO
GET REGISTERED. AND THE EARLIEST
ONE THE GOT RID REGISTER FROM
INTERACTIVE READ WITH THREE
HUNDRED NINETY SIX DAYS. THE
LONGEST WAS EIGHTEEN HUNDRED
THIRTY TWO DAYS. SO IT'S
ANYWHERE BETWEEN A YEAR AND A
QUARTER AND FIVE IN OVER FIVE
YEARS TO GET A MATERIAL
REGISTER. AND SO THIS MATERIAL
THE SO FOLKS IF IT'S NOT
CURRENTLY REGISTERED WHICH WE
AGREE LET'S LET'S PROHIBIT THAT.
THAT TIME BUT THEY START THAT
PROCESS TWENTY TWENTY SEVEN FROM
AN ACT IN THE BILL IS ONLY THREE
YEARS. SO YOU KNOW WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE OF- WE GET THAT IS
GENERAL FIRST TWENTY TWENTY SOME
BY THE WAY. SO IT GIVES THAT
TIME INSTEAD OF TWO YEARS THREE
OF ALSO AND AGAIN THERE'S SOME
DISCRETION WITH THE DEPARTMENT
ON HOW THEY HANDLE- IF THERE
ISN'T A MATERIAL OFFERS SPECIFIC
CROP AND THAT WAS A CONCERN OF
ANOTHER ASSEMBLY MEMBER IN THE-
IN IN THE EARLIER HOUSE. SO
THAT'S THAT'S THAT THEN WE WOULD
PROVIDE IT THE STOP SO REQUIRED
FOR THE AYE COMMISSIONER THAT'S
SOMETHING THAT THAT'S BEEN
AROUND BOB. IN THEIR AND SO TO.
WE PROVIDED ADDITIONAL
MEASUREMENTS. BECAUSE OF DATA
LIKE YOU SAID AND THE PREVIOUS
PERSON. HOW DO WE COLLECT THE
DATA AND IT'S VERY VERY VERY
CHALLENGE IS GOING TO BE VERY
VERY EXPENSIVE I THINK. PEOPLE
HAVE TALKED ABOUT THAT HOW DO
YOU BUILD. UP THIS SYSTEM WHEN
ALL THE INFORMATION ISN'T EVEN
PROVIDED. ACTUALLY TO THE ALL ON
THE LABEL TO THE FARMER. BECAUSE
THEY DON'T KNOW THE CAUGHT. THIS
IS EXPLAINED TO ME AS THE
COCKTAIL OF WHAT'S ON THE C.
NECESSARILY. THEY KNOW THE NAME
OF THE MATERIAL THE ACTIVE
INGREDIENT. BUT THERE ARE HOW
MUCH PER POUND IN THOSE KINDS OF
THINGS AND WHAT THE INNER TIRE.
IN THOSE SO. WE NEEDED. TO
ADDRESS THAT HOW DO WE GET THAT
DATA HOW DO WE CHANGE TO SEE LAW
REQUIRED TO GET BETTER DATA. ALL
THAT WAS AN ONGOING CONVERSATION
THAT WE'VE BEEN DOING. WITH
WITHIN THE INDUSTRY WITH
REGULATORS AND TRYING TO FIGURE
OUT WHAT'S THE RIGHT WAY TO DO
IT TO BE CONSTRUCTIVE. IN THIS
CONVERSATION AND MAKE SURE IT
DOESN'T RIGHT WE CANNOT HAVE.
THE INTERRUPTION THE FIELD
WITHERS- C. NOT AVAILABLE TO BE
PLANTED. AND THERE WOULD BE
DISEASE AND PEST ISSUES. AT THAT
TIME AND SO. WERE YOU KNOW WE'RE
TRYING TO DO THIS IN A MEASURED
AND APPROPRIATE WAY AND THEN
FRANKLY. DIVIDING THAT THE- THE
APPROPRIATE CDFA DOES THEIR JOB.
AND DEALS WITH THE LABEL'S
IMPORTING ALL THAT WHICH THEY
ALREADY REQUIRE AND THEY HAVE A
MILITIA CEMENT. ON THE INDUSTRY
TO PAY FOR THAT. UP DPR WHAT
THEY DO BEST AND HAVE THEM DO IT
AND THAT'S KIND OF WHAT WITH
THEIR BUT THE EARLIER STUFF WAS
ALL ABOUT THE CLOSING LOOPHOLE
NOT. BUT THE DATA WAS ADDED
TODAY AND SOME OF THE THINGS.
YOU THANK YOU I. JUST WANNA
THANK CHAIR FOR INDOOR ME AND
THE AUTHOR BECAUSE THIS IS A
VERY TECHNICAL YES AND I THINK
WE NEED TO GET IT RIGHT AND ONE
IS ONE OF I HAVE ONE LAST
QUESTION SO- FOR THE- WEEK. FOR
THE AG PEOPLE THAT DO THIS EVERY
DAY- WE THOSE OF US WHO HAVE
APPLICATORS MEANT WE USE OF
PESTICIDE WE CALL OUR COUNTY WE
TELL OF A TOMORROW WE'RE GOING
TO APPLY. THIS IS THE FIELD
WE'RE GOING TO APPLY IT ON. AND
THEY KNOW THAT THEY CAN COME OUT
INSPECT IF WE HAVE WIND. ALL
THESE REGULATIONS THAT ARE IN
LAW RIGHT NOW. THIS BILL- HOW
WOULD YOU SO WE ARE USED TO THAT
WORLD BUT WHEN YOU GO TO THE-
LOCAL HARDWARE STORE AND YOU GET
A BAG OF. GRASS SEED OR YOU GET
AT SOMETHING THAT IS A SEAT THAT
HAS BEEN- TREATED. HOW ARE WHAT
WHAT IS THE PROCESS FOR THE-
TRACKING OF THAT. SEED THAT GOES
ON SOMEBODY'S LAWN OR A GOLF
COURSE. OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT
THAT THAT AREA IS- KIND OF GRAY
HERE WHAT HOW WOULD THAT WORK.
YOU'RE ASKING. WELL I THINK AND
I THINK. SO TO YOUR POINT THE
REGULATIONS ON PESTICIDES CAN BE
VERY COMPLICATED RIGHT I MEAN
FOR EXAMPLE THE RECORDS THAT ARE
SPRAYED RIGHT THEY CAN'T BE
SPRING FLOWERS PRESENT ON THAT
GREAT I MEAN IT'S VERY
COMPLICATED DEPENDING ON THE
PEST SIDE HOW WHAT DPR PUTS OUT
AS THEIR RAGS- AND- I AM NOT
HERE TO SAY THAT I KNOW WHAT THE
RIGHT RIGHT SHOULD BE ON ANY ONE
OF THESE PESTICIDES. THAT ARE
TREATED ON SEEDS AND THAT IS FOR
THE DEPARTMENT TO DECIDE- AND
SO. I GUESS YOU'RE ENVISIONING A
COMPLICATED SITUATION WHERE YOU
CAN. NOT PLAN TO SEE IF PERHAPS
IT IS KNOWN I GUESS I'M I'M
SAYING THAT WE HAVE. TREATED
SEED NOW THAT YEAH A FIX A
LOOPHOLE WE GET. TO HER PERCENT
GREENWOOD THANKS YEP GOOD MOVE
THANK YOU. SO I LIKE. GOOD
REALLY DON'T THINK THIS BILL I
THINK A NEED. YEP SO I AND I
AND- BUT IT'S IT IS COMPLICATED
AND SO THE POINT I WANTED TO
BRING HOME WAS THAT. THOSE OF US
WHO HAVE APPLICATORS PERMITS AND
DO THIS LIKE. AG WHEN YOU TALK
ABOUT THE BIRD. THAT WAS. FOUND
HILL SOMEWHERE. THEY KNOW THAT
I'VE ONCE DPR DOES THEIR JOB OF.
TELL ME WHAT'S IN THE CHEMICAL
AND I'M SUPPOSED TO PLY IT AND-
WHEN I'M SUPPOSED TO FLY AND I'M
AND I'M REGULATED. REGULATE AND
I HAVE TO REPORT THAT. TO THAT
COUNTY AG COMMISSIONERS WHO I
CALL. AND SAY HEY TOMORROW I'M
GONNA. PLANT THIS SEED OR I'M
GOING TO RAISE THIS BILL. WE
HAVE A SYSTEM FOR THAT YEP THIS
BILL IS GONNA REGULATE SEEDS
THAT ARE SOLD. IN THE HARDWARE
STORE TO. MEGAN DALLY WHO
DOESN'T HAVE A PERMIT AND SHE'S
GONNA GO PLANT HER LAWN OR SHE'S
GONNA. DO A GOLF COURSE OR SHE'S
GOING TO DO SOMETHING ELSE OKAY
NOW YOU KNOW. SO YOU HAVE NO
TRACKING ABILITY YOU HAVE NO SO
THAT'S WHY. IT'S VERY CRITICAL
ON HOW WE- EACH DEPARTMENT DOES
THEIR JOB SO THAT WE CAN TRACK
THESE AND ACTUALLY DO WHAT
WE'RE- TRYING TO DO HERE RIGHT
TO. FOR EXAMPLE I THINK IT'S
MAKING HER NURSERY- SHE SOLD
SCOTT. WAS IN A DEFENDER WIFE
HERE WAS A NAME BRAND SHE-
ALWAYS USED TO JOKE AS- STILL.
YOU KNOW FERTILIZER AND SEEDS BY
THE POUND WE SELL BY THE TON YEP
AND SHE MADE MORE MONEY BY THE
POUND. BUT- SO MAYBE I'M IN THE
WRONG BUSINESS AND SHE WAS IN
THE RIGHT BUSINESS BUT TO THE
POINT GIVE US MY WIFE SIR. TO
THE POINT- HOW DO YOU TRACK DATA
NAY SO THOSE ARE THINGS THAT I
THINK ARE CRITICAL BECAUSE WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT YES. FIRST OF ALL
GET STE CLOSING THE LOOPHOLE AND
THEN AFTER THAT LOOPHOLES CLOSED
I THINK. IT POINTS TO THE FACT
IT DOES THINGS THAT- OPPOSITION
BROUGHT UP THAT NEED TO BE.
DEALT WITH IN THIS BILL YES AND
I THINK THAT'S WHY I GUESS THE
ADDRESS YOUR QUESTION WHY I'M
NOT DOING A BILL THAT. BANS
CERTAIN SEEDS- DICTATES HOW ANY
OF THIS IS DONE BECAUSE I THINK
THAT THE ANSWER IS THAT DEPART
ABOUT SAID REGULATION WHO
REGULATES YOU EVERYDAY AS AN
APPLICATOR. KNOWS BEST HOW TO DO
THAT FOR FARMERS SO THAT THEY
CAN COMPLY AND IN THE SAME WAY
THAT YOU'RE USED TO DOING IT AND
SO I DEFERRED APARTMENT TO MAKE
DECISIONS IN A WAY THAT WILL
WORK. FOR THE INDUSTRY ALREADY
WORK WITH EVERYDAY. RIGHT I
UNDERSTAND MY ROLE AND MY
OBLIGATION BUT IT'S THE PERSON
THAT DOESN'T HAVE TO HAVE THE
APPLICATORS RIGHT TO DO IT
THAT'S THE POINT I'M TRYING TO.
WELL IN CURRENTLY. URBANISED AND
REGULATIONS AS IT RELATES TO-
AGRICULTURE THAT HAVE DO NOT
APPLY TO ME AS A PERSON WHO DOES
NOT. GROW AT GREAT THAT'S TRUE.
AND SO THE SAME COULD BE TRUE
HERE. I MEAN IT'S DEPARTMENT OF
THIS EVERY DAY. SO THANK YOU FOR
ATTEMPTING TO TRY TO HELP ME OUT
WITH YOUR BILL I WANT TO JUST
SAY EXPERTS GREEN WITH MASON AYE
AYE. AYE I WANNA SAY TO THE
COMMITTEE. THAT I THINK THERE'S
A NEED FOR THIS BILL I'M NOT
OPPOSED TO THAT BUT I THINK IT
NEEDS. SOME WORK AND I WOULD
REALLY HOPE YOU TAKE A MINUTE SO
I CAN SUPPORT THIS BILL- AS A
SEED FARMER- WHEN HE GETS THE
FLOOR BECAUSE THE THESE REALLY.
THEY I THINK THEY'RE I THINK
THEY'RE AMENDMENTS THAT I'VE
THAT I'VE SEEN AND- I'VE THAT
THEY'VE- PROVIDED ME. ARE
COMMONSENSE GOOD AMENDMENTS-
THAT NEED TO BE IN THIS BILL. SO
I'M GOING TO NOT SUPPORT THE
BILL TODAY BECAUSE I KNOW IT'S
WORK- AND- HOPEFULLY WE CAN GET
THERE HOPEFULLY- WHEN IT GOES TO
AG. HEATING WE CAN HAMMER THOSE
THINGS OUT. HOW DID YOU WANT TO
DO YOU HAVE. YOU DON'T HAVE TO
ANSWER THIS NOW BUT YOU DO HAVE
KIND OF A- WIZARD. AT THAT
WHAT'S YOUR SENSE OF THE STATE
UNIVERSITY SINCE RIGHT NOW WHEN
THEY WAY I MEAN I AGAIN I WAS
NOT IN MY OFFICE TODAY BUT I
KNOW THEY HAD A GOOD MEETING I
APPRECIATE ALL THE OPPOSITION
AND I'M GETTING. HAVE NOTS
REMEMBER I WILL SAY THAT SOME OF
YOU KNOW ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS
THEM INFORMATION AND DON'T. ASK
ME WHICH OF HER MANY. AG CLIENTS
BROUGHT THIS TO US BUT ONE OF OR
MAYBE IT WAS MANY- WAS THIS
DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION WHICH WAS
NOT ORIGINALLY IN THE BILL AND
IMMEDIATELY WERE LIKE THAT MAKES
SENSE SO WE DID AND WE- YOU KNOW
YOU HEARD MISS ROBBIE ANI MAYBE
WE DIDN'T GET THE TIMELY RIGHT
WILL ACTUALLY CONTINUE TO HAVE
THAT CONVERSATION. BUT WE HAVE
BEEN IN CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM
SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THIS BILL
WILL CONTINUE TO. AND I CAN'T
COMMENT ON THE AMENDMENTS I
HAVEN'T SEEN. BUT I WILL LOOK
FORWARD TO IT AND PERHAPS MISTER
DALI WILL BE MY JOCKEY ON THE
FLOOR. I WOULD LOVE TO DO. YOU
CAN GET IT RIGHT I WANT TO
SUPPORT THIS BILL HAVE A DO
BETTER. IF WE CAN GIVEN THE
LANES. IN DEEP YARD A AND SEE IF
THEY WERE THERE SUPPOSED TO BE I
CAN SUPPORT THIS BILL. WE GET
DOZEN MEMBERS I THINK IT'S VERY
HAVE LED TO JOCKEY. CORRECT ALL
RIGHT. WELL THANK YOU THANKS FOR
ALL THE WORKERS YOU'RE DOING AND
YOU'RE GONNA CONTINUE TO DO AND-
WE'LL- WE'LL WE'LL SEE WITH THIS
ALL GOES BUT- BUT APPRECIATE
YOUR YOUR YOUR LEADERSHIP ON
THIS IN. A VARIETY OF PESTICIDE
RELATED ISSUES. SO I THINK I
HEARD A- MOTION FROM COUN MENTOR
FROM SENTIMENT OF OUR- AND-
LET'S LET'S. HOPE THIS. LETS YOU
CLOSE. RESPECT FASTER I'VE IT
SENATORS THANKS FOR THE
CONVERSATION. THANK YOU- TICKET
. KALRA AB TEN FORTY TWO. THE
MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
AGRICULTURE ALAN. HI ALLEN ON A
DAILY. DALLY NO GONZALES. HER
TADO. MENJIVAR END OF OUR AYE
NGUYEN. SKINNER THANK YOU
MEMBERS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH CENTER ALL RIGHT WILL
NEXT CALL UP THE SOONER FRIEDMAN
WHO'S HERE. I WE'RE GONNA LEAVE
THE ROLE BUT OBVIOUSLY FOR THAT-
BECAUSE THERE'S NUMBER NUMBERS
OR NOT HERE. THE CENTER FOR ME
IS ACTUALLY PRESENTING TO BILLS.
ONE AVENUE PESTICIDES LET'S
START FIRST WITH THEM. ATTICS
BILL ON ON- PLATE VERY MATURE.
INCOME THAT'S ITEM. FOR IT AB.
FIFTEEN THANK YOU. AB TEN FIFTY
NINE PROHIBITS THE SALE AND
DISTRIBUTION OF JUVENILE
PRODUCTS. MATTRESSES AND
UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE THAT
CONTAINS FIBRE GLASS AND ALSO
RESTRICTS THE USE OF FLAME
RETARDANT CHEMICALS IN ADULT
MATTRESSES WHILE THE ORIGINAL
FOCUS OF THIS BILL WAS
FIBERGLASS AS THE BILL MOVES
FORWARD I BECAME AWARE OF OTHER
FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICAL ISSUES
WITH MATTRESSES. I THINK ALL OF
US WANT TO KNOW THAT WHEN WE LAY
DOWN TO SLEEP AT NIGHT WE'RE NOT
UNINTENTIONALLY. PUTTING OUR
HEALTH AT RISK AND THAT'S WHAT
THIS BILL INSURERS IN TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN AB TWENTY NINE
NINETY EIGHT WAS SIGNED INTO LAW
THAT BILL BANNED THE USE OF
FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICALS IN THE
PHONE PART OF MATTRESSES WHICH
IS THE INNER PART OF MATTRESSES.
BUT STILL ALLOW FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS IN THE OTHER
COMPONENTS OF THE MATTRESSES. IN
ORDER TO ELIMINATE ANY
REGRETTABLE SUBSTITUTION
PROBLEMS THAT MAY ARISE FROM
BANNING THE USE OF FIBER GLASS.
AB TEN FIFTY NINE IS ADDRESSING
THOSE FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICALS
TO AND DOES SO BY ELIMINATING
THE EXEMPTION FOR THESE OTHER
COMPONENTS. BOTH THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT AND THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA HAVE SET STANDARDS
THAT LIMIT THE FLAMMABILITY OF
MATTRESSES FOR OBVIOUS. REASONS
AND ALSO UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE.
FOR A LONG TIME TOXIC FLAME
RETARDANT CHEMICALS WERE USED TO
MEET THOSE STANDARDS. BUT IN
RECOGNITION OF THEIR NEGATIVE
HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE LAWS AND
REGULATIONS WERE CHANGED AT BOTH
THE FEDERAL AND STATE LEVEL. TO
PROHIBIT THE USE OF THESE
CHEMICALS BECAUSE MANY OF THEM
ARE CARCINOGENIC. WHILE MOST
MANUFACTURERS ALTER THEIR
MANUFACTURING METHODS USE
NATURAL FLAME RETARDANT
MATERIALS. SUCH AS RAYON LATEX
AND WOOL TO MEET THE STANDARD
WHICH THEY DO VERY EASILY. SOME
TURNED A FIBRE GLASS AS A
THERMAL BARRIER. A FIBERGLASS IS
A MAN MADE MINERAL FIBER THAT IS
COMPOSED OF CILIA SAND LIMESTONE
AND RECYCLE GLASS AND SODA ASH.
THAT IS A LIFESPAN OF MORE THAN
FIFTY YEARS. WHEN INDIVIDUALS
UNDER PER OPEN MATTRESS COVERS
UNINTENTIONAL EXPOSURE TO
FIBERGLASS CAN OCCUR. IN
ADDITION THERE IS CONCERN THAT
EVEN WHEN THE MATTRESS OR COUCH
COVERS ARE NOT DISTURBED. THE
FIBERGLASS PARTICLE ESCAPES TO
THE SURFACE LEADING TO EXPOSURE.
NOW FIBERGLASS IS IRRITATING TO
THE EYES LUNGS AND SKIN. LONG
TERM EXPOSURE TO FIBERGLASS IS A
FOR SO SEATED WITH LUNG DISEASE.
INCLUDING INCLUDING PULMONARY
FIBROSIS. SHORT TERM ELATION
EXPOSURE TO FIBERGLASS MAY CAUSE
LUNG INFLAMMATION AND
BRONCHIOLITIS. FIBERGLASS FIBERS
CAN CAUSE VISUAL CHANGES
BLEEDING AND SCARRING IF THEY
END UP IN YOUR EYES. WE KNOW
THAT ONLY 13% OF MATTRESSES
COMPLAIN PROPER GLASSES OF
THERMAL BARRIER SO IT'S NOT
NECESSARY. THESE PRODUCTS CANON
ARE SAFELY MADE WITHOUT
FIBERGLASS AND THEREBY
EFFECTIVELY ELIMINATING
ACCIDENTS LEAKAGE OR OTHER
MISTAKES FROM HAPPENING. THAT
NEEDLESSLY EXPOSE THE PUBLIC AND
PEOPLE IN THE RECYCLING AND
DISPOSAL- INDUSTRIES TO THE
SUBSTANCE. MANUFACTURERS DO NOT
HAVE TO TURN TO FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS AS A SUBSTITUTE FOR
PROPER GLASS AND THAT'S VERY
IMPORTANT. GIVEN THE A SMALL
AMOUNT OF MATTRESSES ON THE
MARKET CONTAINING FIBERGLASS AND
THE AVAILABILITY OF ALTERNATIVES
TO MEET FEDERAL AND STATE PLAN
ABILITY STANDARDS. ARE BILL
WOULD BAN THE USE OF FIBER GLASS
TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH. NOW
I'VE BEEN WORKING VERY CLOSELY
WITH THE INTERNATIONAL SLEEP
PRODUCTS ASSOCIATION SINCE THE
BILL'S AND I WANT TO. THEM THEY
HAVE BEEN GREAT TO WORK WITH
THAT I KNOW THAT THEY SHARE OUR
GOAL OF GETTING RIVER ROAD OF
FIBERGLASS AND MATTRESSES AND
THEY WANT TO AVOID ANY
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES. AS THE
ANALYSIS POINTS OUT THE
REMAINING ISSUE FOR I. S. P. IS
WHETHER TO ALLOW AN EXEMPTION.
FOR MATA CRITIC FIBERS. AT THIS
TIME I'M NOT COMFORTABLE WITH
ADDING THAT EXEMPTION IT'S ONLY
USE THAT ABOUT 13% OF MATTRESSES
AND THERE'S A LOT OF EVIDENCE
THAT THE IT'S HARMFUL WE DON'T
SEE ANY REASON WHY WE SHOULD
CONTINUE TO ALLOW THEIR USE.
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF OUR
SUPPORT IN BEHALF OF OUR SPONSOR
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP IS
BILL ALJADA AND JORDAN WELLS
WITH THE NATIONAL STEWARDSHIP
ACTION COUNCIL AND I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY URGE AND I VOTE.
MAY I AM BILL ALLEY- WITH THE
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP AND
HAPPY TO BE- SPONSORING THIS
BILL. THE AUTHOR AND HE GIVES
YOU BECAME AWARE THE FIBERGLASS
ISSUED ABOUT THE SAME TIME LAST
YEAR WAS WRITTEN UP IN THE LOS
ANGELES TIMES ABOUT A WOMAN
SACRAMENTO WHO'S- OF WAS EXPOSED
FIBERGLASS AND GOT INTO HER
BEDROOM AND HER DAUGHTER WAS
EXPOSED. SO THAT'S HOW THE BILL
CAME ABOUT. I FROM THE START THE
INDUSTRY'S BEEN REPRESENTED BY
THE INTERNATIONAL SLEEP PRODUCTS
ASSOCIATION AND THEY DON'T
OPPOSE THE REMOVAL OF A
FIBERGLASS I THINK THEY SEE THE
HANDWRITING ON THE WALL. BUT AS
WE PROGRESS AS- MISS FRIEDMAN
SAID WE BECAME AWARE OF OTHER
CHEMICALS. THAT WERE NOT
NECESSARILY BANNED BY AB TWO
NINE AN EIGHT BY MISTER BLOOM
AND IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN. AND ALSO
NEW YORK STATE RECENTLY PASSED A
LAW BANNING THOSE TWO CHEMICALS.
WITHIN TWO YEARS ALL TOGETHER SO
WE'VE BEEN LOOKING AT THIS
CLOSELY. AND SO WE'VE BEEN AND
IN DISCUSSIONS WITH I. S. P. A.
AND I WOULD PUT IN A NOTE HERE
THAT. WE'VE BEEN SHARING SCIENCE
WITH THEM DISSECTING THE SCIENCE
TOGETHER. AND TALK TO THE
REGULATORY AGENCIES OF BOTH THE
STATE AND FEDERAL AGENCIES TO
TRY TO GET THIS RIGHT. ARE WE
REACHED A POINT WHERE ONE OF THE
TWO CHEMICALS ERA MINUTES WHICH
ARE USING KEVLAR AND NOMEX- WE
SET THAT ASIDE IT'S VERY LIKELY
NON HAZARDOUS TO THE CONSUMER
BUT WE'RE STILL CONCERNED ABOUT
MATA CRITICS. REMAKE OF MAIN
CONCERN OF THE HAZARD
ASSESSMENTS ON MODERN CRITICS
ARE NOW BECOMING OUT OF DATE. SO
WE'RE NOT COMFORTABLE WITH
SAYING GO AHEAD AND KEEP USING
THEM. WE KNOW THIS IS AN
INNOVATIVE INDUSTRY WITNESSED
THE BATON OF BOX WE RECENTLY I
DID ONE FOR MY- MY WIFE'S THAT
MONEY TAKEN OUT OF THE BOX AND-
SUDDENLY HAVE A- DOUBLE BED IN
FRONT OF YOU A COUPLE HOURS
LATER. SO AND THEY ARE
INNOVATIVE AND THEY'RE ALSO VERY
WHERE IF. CONSUMERS DON'T WANT
BAD CHEMICALS IN THEIR MATTRESS
AND ARE WORKING HARD TO GET
THOSE OUT. SO WE AREN'T THAT
COMBINED WITH ASSEMBLY MEMBER
FRIEDMAN STRONG COMMIT TO
CONSUMER SAFETY. SAYS THAT- I
THINK WE'LL GET TO A PRAGMATIC
SOLUTION ON THIS BILL THAT.
PROTECTS CONSUMERS AND WORKS FOR
THE MANUFACTURERS. AND NOW FOR
THE BIGGER PICTURE LONG TERM.
PICTURE THE NEXT WITNESS THANK
YOU. THANK YOU TURN MEMBERS I AM
JORDAN WELLS ON BEHALF OF THE
NATIONAL STORAGE OF ACTION
COUNCIL. A NONPROFIT THAT
ADVOCATES FOR EQUITABLE CIRCULAR
ECONOMY. I ALSO SET ON THE
STATE'S. MATTERS ADVISORY
COMMITTEE WHICH ADVISES THE
MATTRESS RECYCLING COUNCIL AS IT
IMPLEMENTS THE STATE WIDE
MATTRESS STEWARDSHIP PROGRAM.
THAT WAS CREATED BY A LAW PASSED
BY THE LEGISLATURE IN TWENTY
THIRTEEN. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT AB
TEN FIFTY NINE WHICH WOULD BAN
TEXTILE FIBERGLASS IN MATTRESSES
UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE AND
JUVENILE PRODUCTS AND RESTRICT
THE USE OF FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS AND ADULT MATTRESSES.
THE FIRST PILLAR OF ACHIEVING IT
IS AN EQUITABLE AND CIRCULAR
ECONOMY IS DOES DESIGN OUT WASTE
AND POLLUTION. OUT OF THE SYSTEM
WHICH IS LESS EXPENSIVE THAN
HAVING TO PAY FOR IT- FOR CLEAN
UP. FLAME RETARDANTS AND
FIBERGLASS NEGATIVELY IMPACT
HUMAN AND ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
THEY ALSO COMPLICATE THE
RECYCLING SYSTEM. ADDING
CHALLENGES OUT ADDING CHALLENGES
FOR RECYCLERS AND INCREASING
COSTS. AS STIPULATED BY TERRY
MCDONALD WHO ALSO SITS ON THE
ADVISORY COUNCIL I REPRESENTS
THE LARGEST. MATTRESS RECYCLER
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. AB TEN
FIFTY NINE WILL PROTECT
CONSUMERS AND RECYCLING WORKERS
FROM HARMFUL ADDITIVES THAT ALSO
MAKE RECYCLING MORE EXPENSIVE. I
WANT TO THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER
FRIEDMAN FOR HER LEADERSHIP AND
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO
MUCH ALL RIGHT LET'S GO TO FOLKS
WHO WANT TO WIN SUPPORT EXPRESS
SUPPORT FOR THE BILL. AB TEN
FIFTY NINE. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
AREN'T ABLE AND SEE A
REPRESENTING THE INTERNATIONAL
SLEEP PRODUCTS ASSOCIATION WE
ACTUALLY HAVE A SUPPORTIVE
AMENDED POSITION ON THE BILL
WE'VE BEEN WORKING REALLY GREAT
WITH THE AUTHOR'S OFFICE WITH
THE SPONSORS AND WE APPRECIATE
ALL THE CONVERSATIONS WE'VE HAD
ON THIS BILL. AND WORSE AS AS A
SOMEWHERE FRIEDMAN NOTED WERE
STILL DISCUSSING ONE PARTICULAR
FIBER INTO AND SPECIFIC IT'S NOT
A FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICAL IT'S
INHERENTLY FIRE RESISTANT-
MATTRESS MANUFACTURERS DO NOT
ADD FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICALS ON
THE CHEMICALS OF CONCERN IN AB
TWO NINE EIGHT. TWO THEIR
MATTRESSES- HOWEVER WITH THE
REMOVAL OF THAT- THAT EXEMPTION
AB TWO NINE EIGHT THAT DOES OPEN
UP THE QUESTION ABOUT TO
SPECIFIC FIBERS THAT ARE
INHERENTLY FIRE RESISTANT THE
COULD BE CAPTURED UNDER THE
BROADBAND. DEFINITIONS IN THE
BILL SO WE'RE CONTINUING TO HAVE
THAT CONVERSATION WE REALLY
APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATIONS ON
THE BILL AND WE HAVE SOME
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION WILL BE
SHARED WITH THE ON THE AUTHOR'S
OFFICE SOON AND WE- CONTINUE TO
WORK ON THAT ISSUE. THANK YOU SO
MUCH. CRIME THANK YOU. I'M OTHER
FOLKS WHO RISK AND ABOUT THE-
EXPRESS OPPOSITE- OKAY. LET'S GO
TO PHONE LINES THIS IS SOME
PEOPLE WANT TO COME IN AND MAYBE
TEN FIFTY NINE. JOHN IF YOU A
COMIC IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE. THEN ZERO.
WE'LL BE GOING TO LINE ONE FORTY
EIGHT. RIGHT YES. ONE OF THE
EARLIER TODAY WAS FOR THE- ONE
FORTY. ONE ON HEALTH. RIGHT WHEN
. I'M A FEMINIST. WE DO HAVE
OTHER THAT HAVE TO GET UP ON THE
OTHER LINE NUMBERS GIVEN. I NEXT
TO GO TO LINE ONE IF THE LEGAL
AT. THIS CAN CAUSE THE FROM
NONPROFIT NEIGHBORHOODS AND
WE'RE AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANKS
TO THE BACK TO ONE FORTY EIGHT
PLEASE GO AHEAD. I NEED TO GET.
RIGHT TO GET OPPOSITE DIFFERENT
STREET. EXETER LINE ONE SIXTY
ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE SIX
ONE. YEAH MY NAME IS JEREMY
MENTIONED AND I SUPPORT AB. ONE
ZERO FIVE NINE. NET STILL GOING
TO LINE ONE FIFTY PLEASE GO
AHEAD. ONE FIFTY YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON I'M
CRISTINA GARC AND GO AND I IN
THE PORT OF THE BILL. NEXT GO TO
LINE ONE FIFTY SIX PLEASE GO
AHEAD. I'M VERY VOCAL AND I
SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU.
NEXTCLOUD TO LINE ONE SIXTY
THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY
NAME IS ON GLORIA ARE BILL. AND
THERE'S CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN
THE QUEUE MISTER CHAIR. OKAY
THANK YOU MAN AND WE GET TO HEAR
A LOT OF INTERESTING THINGS ARE-
LET'S LET'S SEPARATE BACKS
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS COMMENTS
THOUGHTS WAS FIRST YEAR. I JUST
WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE BILL I
THINK IT'S A GOOD BILL- I VOTED
FOR THE BLOOM BILL I THINK I WAS
ONE OF THE FEW REPUBLICANS
ACTUALLY SUPPORTED THAT BILL AND
SO GLAD TO SEE YOU'RE WORKING
WITH THE OPPOSITION TO TRY TO
GET TO A EVEN MORE HAPPY PLACE
SO HAPPY TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL.
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT- WITH THAT
LET'S LET YOU CLOSE. TO US I
THINK WE CAN ALL SLEEP BETTER.
YES IN PLANO AND I SAID I WAS
REMOVED CENTER DOLLY AND SECURE
PLACE KALRA. AB TEN FIFTY NINE
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS PROFESSIONS AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ALAN. HI
ALLEN I. DALI. DALI I. GONZALEZ
HER TADO. HER TADO I. MENJIVAR.
WIND SKINNER. THREE ZERO WILL BE
THAT WILL OPEN FOR THE FIRST OUT
ON LET'S NOW GO TO ITEM FIVE
THIS IS THE B. THIRTEEN TWENTY
TWO. VERY MUCH- MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS I WANT TO THANK YOU AND
YOUR COMMITTEE STAFF FOR ALL OF
YOUR HARD WORK ON THIS BILL. AND
I'M ACCEPTING THE SUGGESTED
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS OUTLINED IN
THE ANALYSIS. IN TWENTY TWENTY
THE LEGISLATURE PASSED AB
SEVENTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT TO
MINIMIZE UNINTENDED POISONINGS
FROM ONE SUBSET OF PARTICULARLY
DANGEROUS RODENTICIDES. SECOND
GENERATION ANTICOAGULANT
RODENTICIDES AS CHART AS GARCES
THEY'RE CALLED BY PLACING A
MORATORIUM ON CERTAIN USES UNTIL
MORE COMPREHENSIVE RESTRICTIONS
WERE DEVELOPED. HOWEVER DESPITE
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF AB
SEVENTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT IN TWO
TWENTY TWENTY ONE RECENT
EVIDENCE FROM THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE
SUGGESTS ARE STILL WIDESPREAD
EXPOSURE AND DEATHS TO WILDLIFE.
FROM AS CARS AND OTHER
RODENTICIDES. AND THIS IS
BECAUSE ANOTHER SUBSET OF
RODENTICIDES FIRST GENERATION
ANTICOAGULANT RODENTICIDES
INCLUDES DIE SOUGHT BY SAUCE OF
. THE FASTENER. WHICH IT THANK
YOU WHICH IS THE MOST FREQUENTLY
DETECTED ESTAR IN NON TARGET
WILDLIFE. EXPOSURE TO THIS
CHEMICAL CAN RESULT IN BOTH
LETHAL AND SUBLEASE ALL FACTS
ARE NON TARGET WILDLIFE.
INCLUDING SEVERE SKIN DISEASES
AND DECREASE IMMUNE SYSTEM
RESPONSE. AB THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO
ADDS THAT DIE SASSA PHONE TO THE
EXISTING RODENTICIDE MORATORIUM
TO BETTER PROTECT WILDLIFE FROM
UNINTENTIONAL RODENTICIDE
POISONING. WHILE MAINTAINING
EXCEPTIONS FOR ITS USED TO
PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH WATER
SUPPLIES IN AGRICULTURE. IT ALSO
REQUIRES THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF
PESTICIDE REGULATION ENACT
STRONGER PERMANENT RESTRICTIONS
ON SECOND GENERATION
ANTICOAGULANT RODENTICIDES AND I
THOUGHT THE PHONE. TO LIMIT
UNINTENDED WILDLIFE POISONINGS
WHILE MAKING. THIS CHEMICAL A
RESTRICTED MATERIAL SO THAT YOUR
AVERAGE JOE IS AND JUST BUYING
AT THEIR LOCAL HOME DEPOT.
ANTICOAGULANT RODENTICIDE
CONTINUES TO RESULT IN AN
UNREASONABLE NUMBER OF PUBLIC
HEALTH INCIDENTS WITH OVER THREE
THOUSAND HUMAN POISONINGS IN TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY ONE. AT LEAST
TWENTY THREE HUNDRED OF THOSE
INVOLVING CHILDREN UNDER SIX
YEARS OLD ACCORDING TO THE
AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF POISON
CONTROL CENTERS. AB THIRTEEN
TWENTY TWO WILL PLACE GREATER
RESTRICTIONS ON SOME OF THE MOST
DANGEROUS FOR DENNIS SIDES.
WHILE MAINTAINING SHORT AND LONG
TERM EXCEPTIONS TO PROTECT
PROVIDE PUBLIC HEALTH
AGRICULTURE AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
I ALSO WANT TO RESPOND TO RECENT
POINTS MADE BY OPPOSITION ABOUT
MAKING DIED BY SASS BY SAXOPHONE
A RESTRICTED MATERIAL. THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA HAS ALWAYS TAKEN
STRONGER ACTION IN THE U. S. EPA
SUCH AS PULLING SECOND
GENERATION ANTICOAGULANTS FROM
THE SHELVES BEFORE THE U. S.
EPA. BECAUSE OUR STATE
RECOGNIZES THE DANGERS OF THESE
PRODUCTS AND ALSO THEY WERE NEAT
UNIQUE WILDLIFE THAT WE HAVE IN
OUR STATE. THE U. S. EPA'S
REEVALUATION PROCESS IS TOO SLOW
AND TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE OF
PRESENT PREVENT MORE POISON
MOUNTAIN LIONS CALIFORNIA
CONDORS. AND OTHER WILDLIFE.
ALSO DPR IS NOT ACTIVELY
REEVALUATING THE IT THIS
CHEMICAL. THEY HAVE ONLY SENT
OUT A NOTICE THAT THEY MAY DO SO
BUT THE PRODUCT IS NOT YET IN
REEVALUATION. ALSO DPR ALL RIGHT
SO THAT THAT WE ALSO KNOW THAT
THERE'S A WIDE RANGE OF SAFER
MORE SUSTAINABLE AND COST
EFFECTIVE ALTERNATIVES. TO THESE
MOST DANGEROUS RESET
RODENTICIDES AVAILABLE FOR YOU
TODAY BUT DON'T THREATEN OUR
WILDLIFE AND OUR FAMILIES. THE
ANIMALS THAT ARE BEING POISONED
OUR OUR PREDATORS AND THE BEST
WAY TO PREVENT A WIDESPREAD
OUTBREAK OF TEST IS ACTUALLY TO
ALLOW YOUR PREDATORS TO DO THEIR
JOB AND TO KILL THEM. IF WE HAVE
MORE OWLS WE HAVE THE MOUNTAIN
LIONS AND COYOTES HEALTHY. THEY
WILL DEAL WITH THE RODENTS AND
THE RACKS IN OUR WE AREAS WHICH
IS WHERE A LOT OF THESE
POISONINGS IS HAPPENING AND I
HOPE YOU DON'T MIND BUT I WANTED
TO SHOW YOU. WHAT THIS POISONING
LOOKS LIKE AND WE HEAR ABOUT
THIS FROM OUR CONSTITUENTS EVEN
AND URBAN LOS ANGELES ALL THE
TIME. THE TOP IS WHAT AMOUNT
MINUS SUPPOSED TO LOOK LIKE.
THIS WAS P. TWENTY TWO A PHOTO
THAT A SELFIE THAT HE TOOK. ON
USING A CAN OF ONE OF THE
CAMERAS THAT WAS PLACED IN
GRIFFITH PARK TO PHOTOGRAPH HIM.
THIS CAUSED WIDESPREAD OUTRAGE
IN LOS ANGELES THE REASON THAT
HE HAD THIS MEANS WAS BECAUSE
OF. OF THESE POISONS THIS MET
THESE OF. THESE ANTICOAGULANTS
WHICH ARE NOW SO INDICATE IS
THAT IT'S REALLY HARD TO FIND.
ANIMALS IN OUR WE AREAS THAT ARE
NOT SO HAVE BUT THAT HAVE NOT
BEEN POISONED. AND WHEN WE DO
NOT CROP SEIZE ON ANIMALS THAT
ARE FOUND DEAD MOUNTAIN LIONS
HAWKS AND OWLS THEY HAVE THESE
CHEMICALS IN THEIR SYSTEM THEY
ARE LITERALLY BLEEDING OUT FROM
WITHIN. THEIR BEING TORTURED
BECAUSE OF OUR NEEDLESS ACTIONS.
AND I HEAR IT ALL THE TIME FOR
MY CONSTITUENTS THEIR HEART IS
BREAKING EVERY TIME THEY SEE ONE
OF THESE ANIMALS IN THEIR
NEIGHBORHOODS. AND IT'S NOT
NECESSARY LET'S STOP THAT THE
CARNAGE AND PASS THIS BILL- THIS
IS REALLY REALLY IMPORTANT TO ME
AND TO MY CONSTITUENTS. SO
TESTIFYING TODAY IN SUPPORT. OUR
IT WAS TESTIFYING IT'S I'M SORRY
I. HOPE WE HAVE DOCTOR REBEKAH
COOLEY WHO'S A SMITH FELLOW AND
A POSTDOC AT UC DAVIS.
PERSONALLY THANKS FOR BEING HERE
YES. HI THANK YOU A GOOD
AFTERNOON CHALLAN AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS MY NAME IS DR REBEKAH
GOALIE. IN TWENTY TWENTY TWO I
WAS AWARDED THE DAVID SMITH
FELLOWSHIP TO INVESTIGATE THE
SUB LETHAL IMPACTS OF
ANTICOAGULANT RODENTICIDES IN
GOLDEN EAGLES. I HAVE OVER TEN
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE WORKING IN
CONSERVATION BIOLOGY DURING
WHICH TIME. I'VE BEEN A
SCIENTIFIC ADVISER FOR AT MANY
ENDANGERED SPECIES WORLDWIDE. IN
NINETEEN SEVENTY TWO THE EPA
DISCONTINUED THE USE OF DDT A
HEAVILY APPLIED INSECTICIDES DUE
TO THE ADVERSE IMPACTS THIS
POISON WITH HAVING ON OUR
ECOSYSTEM. INCLUDING THE BALD
EAGLE. FIFTY YEARS LATER WE FIND
OURSELVES IN A SIMILAR SITUATION
WHERE IDENTIFIED THAT HAVE AN
ADVERSE IMPACTS ON THE ECOSYSTEM
AGAIN. AND THE BALD EAGLE IS
BEING IMPACTED. AT TWENTY TWENTY
ONE NATIONWIDE STUDY FOUND THAT
OVER 80% OF BALD AND GOLDEN
EAGLES TESTED POSITIVE FOR
ANTICOAGULANT RODENTICIDES.
OUTSIDE OF THE SECOND GENERATION
ANTICOAGULANTS ALREADY COVERED
BY THE CALIFORNIA ECOSYSTEM
PROTECTION ACT OF TWENTY TWENTY
THEY FASTEN IS THE MOST COMMONLY
FOUND FOR IDENTIFIED IN
CALIFORNIA WILDLIFE. IT'S BEEN
FOUND A MOUNTAIN LIONS BOBCATS A
GREAT HORNED OWLS RED TAILED
HAWKS JUST TO NAME A FEW OF THE
SPECIES. AND WHEN THESE POISONS
DURING DIRECTLY AT KILL THE
INDIVIDUAL THEY CAN MAKE THEM
SICK AND WEAK THE SUBWAY FOR
IMPACTS CAN DYSREGULATED IMMUNE
FUNCTION CAN LEAD TO CHRONIC
ANEMIA. CAN DECREASE THAT
COORDINATION INCREASE THAT
STRESS HORMONE PRODUCTION WE'VE
SEEN HEMORRHAGING IN BONE HOT
LIVE UP KIDNEYS LUNGS. I WE'VE
SEEN AN INCREASE IN PARIS I'M
PATHOGEN LOAD AND WE NOW HAVE
EVIDENCE OF NEONATE TRANSFERRED
OVER DONE DECIDES TO YOUNG. A
TWENTY EIGHTEEN STUDY LED BY DR
DEVINE FRAZIER AT UCLA FOUND
THAT A CALIFORNIA POPULATION OF
BOTH CATS. HAD A DISRUPTED
IMMUNE FUNCTION DO YOU TO RETURN
TO SITES ONE OF THEM BEING DAY
FASTENERS THIS LED TO AN
OUTBREAK OF MANGE A PARASITIC
SKIN CONDITION THAT NEARLY WIPED
OUT THAT ENTIRE POPULATION. THE
LETHAL AND SUB LETHAL IMPACT OF
WRITTEN TO SITES POSE A SERIOUS
THREAT TO THE LONGTIME
POPULATION SUSTAINABILITY. OF
CALIFORNIA WILDLIFE. IN SENATOR
ANY. PRACTICES REMAIN THE MOST
EFFECTIVE LONG TERM SOLUTION FOR
RED OF MANAGEMENT. THERE IS A
GROWING MARKET AMONG CONSUMERS
FOR THESE SOLUTIONS AND ONCE
DONE JUST ONE TIME THEY PHAM
WILL COST EFFECTIVE IN THE LONG
RUN AND THEY PREVENT THE HOME OF
HIS NON TALK POISONING.
PREVENTION RATS FROM ENTERING
OUTBUILDINGS KEEPING OUT AREAS
FREE OF FOOD WASTE AND A BREEZE
MAINTAINING DUMPSTERS AND TRASH
CANS OUT ALL MANAGEMENT
STRATEGIES THAT HAVE LONG TERM
SUCCESS. IN URBAN SETTINGS
RAPHITOMIDAE CONTROL IS SHOWING
PROMISING RESULTS AT MANAGING
AND REDUCING ALREADY ESTABLISHED
RAT POPULATIONS. FOR EXAMPLE IN
A YEAR LONG BIRTH CONTROL STUDY
IN WASHINGTON DC RAT ACTIVITY
WAS ACTUALLY REDUCED BY 90%
ACROSS ALL MONITORED SITES IN
ONE FIVE. THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE
OF RIGHT OF SPRING OUT OLD.
OUTSIDE OF MANAGING COMMENSAL
RODENTS SUCH AS NORWAY AND RE
FRATS DAY FASCINATING IS
FREQUENTLY USED TO CONTROL
GROUND SQUIRRELS. HOWEVER A TWO
YEAR LONG STUDY IN VENTURA
COUNTY VENTURA COUNTY FOUND THE
INSTILLING WRAPPED THE PATCHES
AND AL BOXES. WAS ACTUALLY MORE
EFFECTIVE AND LESS EXPENSIVE
THAN POISON IN REDUCING THE
GROUND GROWING NUMBERS. THIS
APPROACH WAS SO SUCCESSFUL THAT
THE LA DEPARTMENT OF WATER AND
POWER JUST LAST MONTH REFERRED
INDECIPHERABLE THE NATURE
PRESERVE IN THE SAN FERNANDO
VALLEY AND INSTILLED RECTOR
PATCHES INSTEAD. THERE ARE
ALTERNATIVES AND WHILE SOME OF
THE PROPOSED OPTIONS MAY TAKE A
MORE UP FRONT INVESTMENT THEY
OFFER A MORE SUSTAINABLE AND
MORE COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTION
OVER TIME. ABOUT THIS BILL DAY
FAST AND WILL CONTINUE TO
IMPACTS CALIFORNIA'S INVALUABLE
WILDLIFE. THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH OTHER FOLKS
ONE OF VOICE SUPPORT FOR THE
BILL AB THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO.
REVENUE MISTER CHAIR JENNIFER
FEARING ON BEHALF OF SAN DIEGO
HUMANE SOCIETY'S PROJECT
WILDLIFE WHERE THE STATE'S
LARGEST LICENSED NATIVE WILDLIFE
WE HAVE OURS IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
MEMBERS MARK YOU SEE DRUM BEHALF
OF THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES IN
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON DANIEL
JENKINS WAS STOCKTON ANIMAL SAVE
IN SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON HARDY
KERN AMERICAN BIRD CONSERVANCY
IN SUPPORT. GREAT BIRTHDAY. I'M
ARE YOU HERE TO SUPPORT YOU.
KNOW OKAY THE OFFICE I WILL LET
YOU COME UP DON- EVERY FOC
WHENEVER CANCER IN A POSITION.
THANK YOU- MY NAME IS DILIP
KUMAR AND I'M HERE I'M OF. THE
CONTROL OPERATORS OF
CALIFORNIANS WHO ARE THE
LICENSED PROFESSIONALS WHO
MANAGE PESTS HERE IN CALIFORNIA
USUALLY IN STRUCTURAL SETTINGS
MORE OFTEN THAN STRUCTURAL
SETTINGS. BUT NOT EXCLUSIVELY-
YOU KNOW ART OF A OPPOSITION IS
NOT PREDICATED ON THE BELIEF
THAT THERE NEEDS TO BE CONTINUED
WIDESPREAD USE OF THESE
MATERIALS. IT IS PREDICATED ON
THE BELIEF THAT YOU HAVE A
POPULATION OF LICENSED
PROFESSIONALS IN CALIFORNIA WHO
ARE TRAINED IN HOW TO USE THESE
MATERIALS IN COORDINATION WITH.
OTHER EXCLUSION PRACTICES AS
MENTIONED BY THE SUPPORTERS AND
THE PROPONENTS- ABSOLUTELY THERE
ARE SANITATION ELIMINATING FOOD
PUTTING BARRIERS IN THE
BUILDINGS ARE ALL PART OF THE
PROTOCOL THAT GOES WITH.
EXCLUSION PARTICULARLY WHEN IT
COMES TO RODENTS. WHAT WE'RE
ARGUING IN AN OPPOSING TO
RECEIVE WHOLESALE BANNING OF THE
MATERIAL AS A TOOL FOR USE IN
STRUCTURAL PEST CONTROL ACROSS
THE STATE. AND THERE ARE
INSTANCES WHERE THESE OTHER
EXCLUSIONARY PRACTICES USED LESS
LETHAL EXCLUSIONARY PRACTICES
DON'T WORK AND YOU GET A
POPULATION THAT EXPLODES FOR A
VARIETY OF DIFFERENT REASONS.
AND THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN THOSE
EXCLUSIONARY PRACTICES ARE NOT
AS EFFICACIOUS AS THE SHOULD BE
WAR ONCE WERE WHEN YOU HAD A
LOWER POPULATION. THAT'S WHERE
THE USE OF MATERIALS LIKE THAT
FASTENED ON COMES INTO INTO
PLAY. IT COMES INTO PLAY TO
KNOCK DOWN LARGE POPULATION SO
THAT YOU CAN GO BACK TO THE
FIRST EXCLUSIONARY PRACTICE SO.
YOU KNOW THE FIRST ORDER OF
BUSINESS IS NOT TO PULL OUT OF
YOU KNOW A- CANISTER OF THE
FASTENER SUPPLY IT IS TO GO
THROUGH ALL THIS OTHER
MEANINGFUL. EXCLUSIONARY
PRACTICES. ARE PARTICULAR YOU
KNOW FOCUSING IN ON THE BILL IN
PARTICULAR WE ARE THANK YOU FOR
THE MOMENT ON THE IPM. WE WERE
CONCERNED THAT READY MULTIPLE
DEFINITIONS OF IPM WE'RE GOING
TO CREATE PROBLEMS ACROSS THE
STATUTE ACROSS IT YOU. KNOW
IMPLEMENTATION IN OTHER AREAS OF
LAW ACROSS THE STATE TO
APPRECIATE THAT. WE FIND THAT
THE 10% THRESHOLD INCLUDED IN
THE BILL FOR. SAMPLES IS
SOMEWHAT ARE ARBITRARY AN
AMBIGUOUSLY WRITTEN- SUCH THAT
IT'S IN BIGGEST TO THE OUTCOME
THAT WOULD BE PRODUCED SO. WE'RE
FOCUSING ON THAT AND WOOD IN
APPRECIATE SOME FURTHER DIALOGUE
ON HOW TO RESOLVE THAT'S GOING
ON THAT'S A NATURAL RESOURCES
YEAH YEAH WE'LL GET THAT. OKAY
AND I LOOK FORWARD TO TELLING
THAT'S RESOURCES THE SAME THING
YEAH SO- YEAH- YOU KNOW IN IN
THE IS YOU KNOW. THEY'RE A
PUBLIC HEALTH AND INPUT. OF AS
WELL. AND THESE APPLICATIONS ARE
CONSIDERED IN THIS BILL I MEAN
RODENTS CARRY DISEASE THE KERRY
TYPHUS THEY CARRY HANTAVIRUS
THEY CARRY PLAGUE- THERE ARE
OTHER INFRASTRUCTURE
CONSIDERATIONS TO BE CONSIDERED.
ROADWAYS AIRPORTS RAILWAYS.
WATER CONVEYANCE SYSTEMS. YOU
KNOW NUTRIA IS A RECENTLY ARRIVE
ARRIVES ROAD IN HERE IN
CALIFORNIA. IT'S AN INVASIVE
SPECIES IT'S MASSIVE AS COMPARED
TO OTHER RODENTS. AND IT IS
BEGINNING IT'S BEEN FOUND IN THE
LOWER REACHES OF THE DELTA WHICH
IS. ENTIRELY RELIANT ON. LEVY
SYSTEMS AND NATURE CAN WREAK
HAVOC ON LEVEE SYSTEM SO. YOU
HAVING THIS TOOL IS PART OF OUR
CONTROL STRATEGY I THINK WOULD
BE ESSENTIAL TO MAINTAINING- OUR
INFRASTRUCTURE HERE IN
CALIFORNIA AGAINST THE PROBLEMS
CAUSED BY ROADS. AND THEN LASTLY
WHAT I WOULD SAY IS. THIS IS
TRUE THAT THIS HAS NOT YET BEEN.
APPROVED FOR REEVALUATION BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF ASIDE REGULATION.
THERE'S A PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
IT'S OPEN RIGHT NOW TO COME TO
CLOSE VERY SOON. ALL INDICATIONS
POINT TO THE THIS MATERIAL WILL
BE SUBJECT TO REEVALUATION BY
DPR. AS WE HEARD IN EARLIER
TESTIMONY ON ANOTHER BILL.
THERE'S A LOT OF FAITH PLACED IN
THE DPR PROCESS AND REEVALUATION
IN THAT PROCESS THE PUBLIC
HEALTH AND SAFETY CONSEQUENCES
AND- A WILL BE STUDIED AND
ANALYZED WHICH IS NOT SOMETHING
THAT'S BEEN DONE HERE WITH A
VOTE. REGARD TO THIS BILL WE
THINK THAT THE OFFSETS IN THE
TRADE OFFS BETWEEN PUBLIC HEALTH
AND SAFETY AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL
BENEFITS OF LIMITING THE USE OF
THAT FASTEN AND NEED TO BE
CONSIDERED. AS THERE ARE SOME
PRETTY HIGH STAKES PUBLIC HEALTH
AND SAFETY OF CONSEQUENCES THAT
CAN ARISE FROM A MASSIVE RODENT
INFESTATIONS. AND THE
ELIMINATION OF THIS MATERIAL SO
FOR THOSE REASONS AND SEVERAL
OTHERS THAT I WON'T GO INTO
RIGHT NOW WE'RE OPPOSED TO THE
BILL AND WE WOULD ASK FOR
ANOTHER. NO THE WATER STATUS
EXEMPTED I MEAN IS IT YEAH OKAY
YEAH THAT'S GOOD- BUT OKAY.
THANK YOU BUT BUT LOTS OF GOOD
THINGS IN AND- I KNOW THAT THE
DISCUSSION ON THE REVERSE OF THE
YEAR AND THAT'S A RESOURCE I
HAVE WATER IN MY MIND SO YEAH
WELL WE ARE THERE- OKAY. YES IS
I GOOD AFTERNOON SIR TERRY
AROCHA ON BEHALF RISE I'D LIKE
TO ECHO THE COMMENTS OF MY
COLLEAGUE AND REITERATE THAT DPR
AS YOU HEARD EARLIER TODAY. HAS
A SCIENCE BASED IN LED PROCESS
FOR PRODUCT DEVALUATION
REGISTRATION REEVALUATION AND
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING ALL OF
WHICH- TO. INCLUDE THE ABILITY
AND POWER THE DEPARTMENT TO
RESTRICT PRODUCTS. WITH
MEDICATIONS OR CANCEL PRODUCTS
OUT RIGHT WITH THE WHICH THEY
HAVE DONE BEFORE. M. AS NOTED IN
THE ANALYSIS AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
TWO DISREGARDS THE CURRENT
PROCEDURE THAT'S IN PLACE.
IMMEDIATELY BANNING USED
DICTATING THAT THE FAST KNOWN AS
RESTRICTED USE MATERIAL AND THEN
CHARGES THE DEPARTMENT TO RE
EVALUATE THE PRODUCT. BASED ON A
SAFETY MEASURE THAT'S ARBITRARY
AND UNATTAINABLE I THINK FROM
OUR PERSPECTIVE. ON THE ONE THAT
WOULD RESULT IN FROM OUR
PERSPECTIVE THE FACT A BAN. THE
PAIR HAS A PROCEDURE THAT'S IN
PLACE IS ALREADY DOING DATA
COLLECTION OF FOR A POTENTIAL
REVALUATION TO STANDARD
OPERATING PROCEDURE. A FOUR DAY
FASTEN OWN AND HAS THE AUTHORITY
NECESSARY TO PROTECT PUBLIC
HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT IF
THE SCIENCE. DICTATES THAT
THAT'S NECESSARY. YEAH WILL BE
I'LL BE QUICK THE- OKAY THANK
YOU. ARE OKAY YOU- YOU CAN
DOMINIC TAKING UP ALL THE TIME
TO. OUR NOT APPRECIATE BRIDGET
PRESERVE THE COMMENTS IN THE-
FOR BOTH YOU AND- OKAY LET'S
LISTEN. LET FOLKS WHO ARE TO
RAISE CONCERNS. COME TO MAKE
THANK YOU KNOW OUT OF HALF OF
THE AND COMMERCIAL PRODUCTS
ASSOCIATION OF. GREAT THANK YOU
. OTHER FOLK ANYONE THE PHONE
LINES WENT AWAY ON A BEACH
TWENTY TWO. YEAH THE LADY WHICH
MAKE A COMMENT ORDER UP THE
SIMPLY ONE BUTTON ZERO WE'LL BE
GOING LINE ONE FIVE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. OKAY AFTERNOON CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE NAY NOT W. TRY.
ON BEHALF OF LEGAL THE FUND
STRONG. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
ECHO LINE ONE FORTY TWO PLEASE
GO AHEAD. KARAMAT ROBINSON WAS
SHOT DURING A COMMISSION OF
LAYING ON BEHALF OF THE MAKES.
OF THE UNITED STATES IN SUPPORT
. THAT COULD A LINES ONE SIXTY
TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE FIFTY
TO YOUR LINE IS OPEN. EXSULTATE
LINE ONE SIXTY SEVEN. PLEASE GO
AHEAD. I THIS IS AMERICA CALLING
ON BEHALF OF DIRECT ACTION
EVERYWHERE AT FULL SUPPORT FOR
ONE AB ONE THREE TWO TWO. S. R.
ONE ONE SIXTY EIGHT PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS ROCKY
SHELLING ON A CALIFORNIA
RESIDENT AND I OR II THIRTEEN
TWENTY TWO AND I HIGHLY URGE YOU
YOU AS WELL THANK YOU. CONNECT
RURAL LINE ONE THIRTY THREE
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH IN FRONT
OF AB ONE THREE TWO TWO. THANK
YOU. EXETER LINE ONE SEVENTY
FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MANY
WITH BRINGING AND I'M CALLING IN
STRONG WORDS WITHOUT. NEXT TO
THE LINE ONE SIXTY SIX PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HI THERE MY NAME'S CATHY
KING ON THE CALIFORNIA'S
LIFELONG RESIDENT AND I'M
CALLING IN SUPPORT OF AB
THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO THANK YOU.
THAT COULD ALIGN ONE SEVENTY
THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
BALTIMORE GOVERNOR AND I'M IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB THIRTEEN
TWENTY TILL. NATURAL ONE ONE
EIGHTY PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES THIS
IS REVEREND ROBERT WILL BE
INDUCTED TOMORROW THAT I'VE
DEALT WITH AT THE- PHOTO THEN
PUT HIS TEMPLE IN STRONG SUPPORT
. THANKS TO THE LINE ONE SEVENTY
NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME
. MY NAME IS MICHELLE LOW
QUICKTIME OF BERKELEY RESIDENT
AND I'M CALLING IN STRONG
SUPPORT FOR AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
TWO. NOT TO ALIGN ONE EIGHTY TWO
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
AND OUR SALAS AND- OUR LIFELINE
RESIDENT AND I SUPPORT A. B.
THIRTEEN TWENTY. NEXT TO THE
LINE ONE FORTY NINE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. MANY TECHNICAL ATTACK IT
ON THE OUTLOOK SOCIAL COMPASSION
IN LEGISLATION IN SUPPORT. NEXT
ON THE LINE ONE EIGHTY FIVE
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
IS LARRY- I'VE BEEN FARMS
SUPPORT OF AB ONE THREE TWO TWO
THANK YOU. THANKS TO A LINE ONE
FIFTY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
THANK YOU SO MUCH I'M CALLING ON
BEHALF OF THE ORGANIZATION OUR
HONOR MY NAME IS CARLA CABRAL
AND I AM IN STRONG SUPPORT OF AB
THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO. MEXICO LINE
ONE FIFTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD
. AFTERNOON ABIGAIL MILE ON
BEHALF OF THE MID PENINSULA
REGIONAL OPEN SPACE DISTRICT IN
SUPPORT. NEXT TO A LINE OF ONE
FIFTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD. DR
THE REDDIT MAYOR ON BEHALF OF
WISDOM GOOD WORK AND THE RAMSEY
SOCIAL JUSTICE FOUNDATION I AM
IN STRONG SCIENTIFIC SUPPORT-
EIGHTY THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO. NEXT
OTHER LINE ONE EIGHTY THREE
PLEASE GO AHEAD. JOHN BY DOOR
FOR THE CLEANERS FOR KIDS DOT
ORG IN STRONG SUPPORT OF AB
THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO. NEXT ON THE
LINE ONE THIRTY NINE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HI MY DEL WATER THE CARE
OF THE STANDING COMMITTEE
COMMITTEE OF THE STUDIO SITTING
EVER COUNCIL. YOU'RE KIDDING
NEVER HOT ACCOUNT AND SUPPORT OF
AB THE ASSEMBLY BILL THIRTEEN
TWENTY TWO WRITTEN BY LAURA
FRIEDMAN. AND I JUST WANTED TO
SAY THAT IN LA FOR A LOT OF
BLACK BOXES THAT ARE AROUND THAT
HAVE THE- I NOT. MUSCARINIC CAR
. NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE ONE
THIRTY SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
YES HI MY NAME IS TERRY FIVE PM
LIVE HERE IN LOS ANGELES AND I
STRONGLY SUPPORT. THIS BILL.
EXCELLENT ONE TWENTY EIGHT
PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE TWENTY
EIGHT YOUR LINE IS OPEN. NEXT
WE'LL GO TO LINE ONE FIFTY
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
THIS IS HIM CONCRETE NONPROFIT
NEIGHBORHOODS AND WE ARE IN
STRONG SUPPORT. NEXT ON THE LINE
ONE FORTY PLEASE GO AHEAD. NOT
TO ALIGN ONE FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE
GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS NOT
RON EDUCATION THEIR FOSTER CITY
I'M IN STRONG SUPPORT TWENTY
TWO. THANK YOU. NEXT TO THE LINE
ONE EIGHTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD
. GOOD AFTERNOON SENATORS THIS
IS TONY TUCCI CHAIRPERSON FOR
CITIZENS OR LOS ANGELES WILDLIFE
ALSO KNOWN AS CLAW. IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
TWO. NEXT TO THE LINE ONE NINETY
ONE PLEASE GO WHERE YOU GUYS GOT
LIKE. FROM HER DO NEXT PLACE.
EXCELLENT POINT BEFORE THE- HI
WERE BAFFLED THE METRICS FOR THE
PEST CONTROL INDUSTRY
REPRESENTING MAINE WILDLIFE
CONTROL TRADE ASSOCIATION AND WE
ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
BILL THANK YOU. NEXT OTHER LINE
ONE THANK YOU PLEASE GO AHEAD.
HI THIS IS JON VOTERS THIS NEAR
THE CITY OF UNDERGOING SUPPORT
OF AB THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO THANK
YOU. THAT'S ALIGNED ONE SIXTY
FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME
IS ALEXANDER TAYLOR I'M IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB ONE THREE
TWO TWO. EXCELLENT ONE SEVENTY
EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD. IN THE-
FORMER WITH COMPASSIONATE BAY
AND I AM CALLING IN STRONG FORCE
. S. R. ONE ONE EIGHTY SEVEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
IS THAT THE PROCTER I AM A
CALIFORNIA RESIDENT AND I
STRONGLY SUPPORT A. B. UNTIL.
EXETER LINE ONE SIXTY TWO PLEASE
GO AHEAD. ONE FIFTY TO YOUR LINE
IS OPEN. CAN YOU HEAR ME. YES
PLEASE PROCEED. MY NAME IS BRIAN
AND YVONNE I LIVE IN BERKELEY
AND I SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANKS
TO THE LINE ONE SEVENTY SIX
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE NEW YORK
HELLO. CAN YOU HEAR ME YEP WE
CAN HEAR YOU YEAH- THIS IS MERRY
ON THE CHECK FAMILIES COUNTY IN
SUPPORT. NEXT THE LINE FORTY
PLEASE AHEAD. ONE FORTY ONE YOUR
LINE IS OPEN. JOHNNY CARSON WITH
PLANNING AND CONSERVATION LEAGUE
IN STRONG SUPPORT. NEXT IN THE
LINE OF ONE SIXTY ONE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HELLO YEP WE CAN HEAR YOU
PLEASE PROCEED. MY NAME IS THERE
A MAXIMUM AND ON BEHALF OF THE
FARM ANIMAL PLANET AND
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDS OF CINEMA
COUNTY I FOUR EIGHTY THIRTEEN
TWENTY TWO. THANK YOU. NEXT TO
THE LINE ONE FIFTY SIX PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HI THIS IS HENRY BOB
CLARK AND I'M CALLING IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK YOU.
THANKS TO A LINE ONE SIXTY
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI GOOD
AFTERNOON I'M CRISTINA GARCIA
GOLF ON BEHALF OF FARM ANIMALS
PLAN AND ENVIRONMENT IN EUROPE
I'VE BEEN ON MY COUNTY AND I'M A
STRONG SUPPORTER SO. WELL TO GET
ON THE LINE ONE FORTY ONE PLEASE
GO AHEAD. JOHNNY CARSON WITH THE
PLANNING AND CONSERVATION LEAGUE
IN SUPPORT. AND THERE ARE NO
FURTHER IN THE QUEUE MISTER
CHAIR GREAT SORROW THREE BACKS
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS THOUGHTS
COMMENTS CONCERNS. AND SO THIRTY
THOUSAND IT WHEN APPROPRIATE
CENTER SKINNER'S QUESTION TH I'M
NOT A QUESTION A COMIC YOU FOR
BRING IT FORWARD AND IT'S NEEDED
ARE ALSO WANTED TO JUST. GIVE
DEPRECIATION FOR BOTH THE
COMMITTEES MEN BUT ALSO THE-
YOUR- YOU HAD A COUPLE OF
EXEMPTIONS THAT ARE. PARTICULATE
EARLY IMPORTANT AND- I WOULD
WOULD APPLAUD YOU FOR
RECOGNIZING THOSE AND OTHER THAN
THAT. ORTONVILLE SO HAPPY TO
SUPPORT IT. THANK YOU CENTER A
SENATE OUT. WELL FIRST I WANT TO
SAY- INTO THE AUTHOR THAT WHEN
HE SHOWED ME THAT PICTURE I MEAN
NOBODY IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WOULD
VOTE AGAINST THIS BILL IF YOU
SAW THAT PICTURE BUT WITH THAT
BEING SAID- WE HAVE DPR WHICH-
DVR WHICH DOES THE REGULATIONS
FOR- WHICH WE'VE- DELEGATED THAT
POWER TO THEM AS THE LEGISLATURE
NOT ME PERSONALLY BUT- PREVIOUS
LEGISLATURE. BODIES AND IT WAS
BIPARTISAN BY THE WAY- BUT I DID
I WANTED TO COMMENT ON THE FACT
THAT- FOR THOSE OF US WHO
REPRESENT- AREAS WHERE WE HAVE
LOTS OF OUTLINES WE HAVE LOTS OF
WILDLIFE AND WE ALSO HAVE A LOT
OF ILLEGAL MARIJUANA GROWS AND I
THIS IS. NOT TO USE YOUR BILL
AND I KNOW I KNOW THIS BILL'S
GOING TO PASS I GET THAT VOTE
I'VE BEEN VERY FRUSTRATED WITH
THE ILLEGAL USE OF. OF
COAGULANTS QUITE FACT FRANKLY IN
ILLEGAL GROWS AND IN PLACES
WHERE. WE'VE HAD A LOT OF PEOPLE
TRY TO DO THE RIGHT THING AND WE
HAVE SOME PEOPLE NOT AND THEN
THERE'S NO ENFORCEMENT. AND
WE'RE GONNA CONTINUE TO SEE
WILDLIFE DAMAGE NOT MAINLY BY
THE GOOD ACTORS WHO ARE TRYING
TO. DO WHAT WE DO IN AGRICULTURE
IS TRY TO CONTAIN PASSED ARE
HUGE PROBLEM- FOR AGRICULTURE I
KNOW YOU HAVE SOME EXEMPTIONS
FOR THAT- IN THIS BILL. BUT I
JUST WANNA SAY THAT I'M
FRUSTRATED THE FACT THAT WE
DON'T REALLY GO AFTER THE BAD
ACTORS OUT THERE WHO ARE NOT
ABIDING BY THE CURRENT LAWS WE
HAVE. AND ARE REALLY DESTROYING
OUR WILDLIFE THE SAME TIMES I
JUST WANT TO BRING THAT UP THIS
IS THE TOPIC FOR. THIS TYPE OF
LEGISLATION. THANK YOU. OKAY THE
THANK YOU I KNOW THE ALSO THIS
ME QUITE A BIT OF FURTHER
DISCUSSION AS THE BILL MOVES
FORWARD THAT'S RESOURCES AND
WATER NUMBER THE ISSUES THAT
WERE RAISED THERE ARE ISSUES
THAT RELATE TO THAT COMMITTEE-
BUT- BUT AGREED AFTER YOU CLOSE.
THANK YOU YES- WE DO HAVE
EXEMPTIONS FOR AGRICULTURE WITH
EXEMPTIONS FOR WATER WITH
EXCEPTIONS FOR PUBLIC HEALTH
EVEN IN URBAN SETTINGS SO WE DO
THINK THAT WE STRUCK THE RIGHT
BALANCE. AND I TOTALLY AGREE
WITH YOU SENATOR IT'S VERY
FRUSTRATING I WOULD ECHO THAT WE
SHOULD BE GOING AFTER PEOPLE.
GETTING SOME OF MORE OF THESE
PRODUCTS OFF THE SHELVES OFF OF
THE HOME DEPOT SHELVES.
HOPEFULLY WILL HELP WITH SOME OF
THAT PROBLEM I WAS GOING TO SHOW
ALL OF YOU MORE PICTURES BUT
I'LL SPARE YOU. I WOULD JUST SAY
THAT YOU KNOW WE HEAR IT. AND
THE REASON THEY'RE SO MUCH
INTEREST IN PEOPLE CALLING IN AS
WE JUST SEE THIS EVERYWHERE AND
IT'S JUST IT'S HEARTBREAKING. SO
THERE MAY BE BEST PRACTICES OUT
THERE WITH THE INDUSTRY BUT
SOMEHOW SOMETHING'S GOING WRONG.
AND WE ARE STOPPING NATURE FROM
FROM CREATING THE BALANCE THAT
IT NEEDS WITH WITH OUR PREDATORS
SO WITH THAT I WOULD REQUEST AN
AYE VOTE. TWENTY Q. THANK YOU.
ALL RIGHT- I WAS REMOVED SENATOR
CONCERT- SECTION PLEASE COLOR.
AB TWENTY Q. THE MOTION IS DO
YOU PASS AS AMENDED AND RE REFER
TO THE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL
RESOURCES AND WATER ALLEN. HI
ALLEN I DALY. DALLY NO GONZALEZ
. GONZALEZ I HER TADO. MENJIVAR
NGUYEN. SKINNER ALL RIGHT.
SKINNER I. ALL RIGHT- THANK YOU
THANK YOU SENATOR FOR MINUTE
THING COME. SUMMER DAY RULES
HERE CENTER WHICH IS IN WAITING
BUT WHAT CARE OF SNACKS IN LINE
- WHEN. HE LEARNING IS OBSERVING
THE QUEUE. ALL RIGHT. RESERVED
APRIL WHAT YOU MAY PROCEED OUT
OF SIX THIS IS YOUR OF ALL TAKE
OUR MARKETS AND WAS AB THIRTEEN
OH FIVE THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS I WANT TO START BY
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEES
AMENDMENTS AND I WANNA THANK YOU
AND YOUR STAFF FOR THE FOUGHT
FOR FEEDBACK AND ASSISTANCE. I
AM PLEASED TO BE PRESENTING AB
THIRTEEN OH FIVE WHICH WOULD
STOP US FIRST IN THE NATION
TRANSPARENCY START STANDARDS FOR
VOLUNTARY CARBON OFFSETS. IN
CONCERT IN CONCEPT CARBON OFFSET
CREDITS ALONE ENTITY TO REDUCE
ITS NET EMISSIONS BY INVESTING
IN PROJECTS OR ACTIONS
UNDERTAKEN BY ANOTHER ENTITY.
THAT REDUCE OR REMOVE GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSIONS. UNFORTUNATELY
THIS HAS NOT ALWAYS BEEN THE
CASE IN PRACTICE AS RECENT
REPORTS HAVE SHOWN THAT MANY
OFFSETS FAILED TO ACHIEVE THE
GREENHOUSE DOT REDUCTIONS
ADVERTISED. REASER APART BY THE
GUARDIAN FOUND THAT OVER 90% OF
OFFSET CREDITS RELATED TO A
REINFORCED PRESERVATION LISTED
ON ONE OF THE LARGEST PROJECT
REGISTRIES. DO NOT REPRESENT A
MEANINGFUL REDUCTION IN CARBON
EMISSIONS. CURRENTLY THERE
EXISTS NO GOVERNMENTAL STANDARDS
OR REGULATIONS FOR VOLUNTARY
OFFSETS LEAVING CONSUMERS WITH
LITTLE CONFIDENCE THAT WHAT
THEY'RE PURCHASING IS
LEGITIMATE. AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE
SIX TO ADDRESS THIS UNREGULATED
MARKETPLACE BY REQUIRING SIMPLE
DISCLOSURE OF CRITICAL
INFORMATION WERE OFFSET PROJECTS
ARE LOCATED HOW GREENHOUSE GAS
EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS ARE BEING
ACHIEVED. AND THE DATA
METHODOLOGY USED TO CALCULATE
THE AMOUNT OF CARBON THAT HAS
BEEN OFFSET. FOR BUSINESSES THE
PURCHASE THESE CREDITS AND MAKE
CLAIMS REGARDING EMISSIONS
REDUCTIONS AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE
WOULD REQUIRE THEM TO DISCLOSE
DETAILS REGARDING THE CREDITS
PURCHASED. AND HOW THIS
EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS CLAIMS WERE
DETERMINED TO BE ACCURATE. THESE
DISCLOSURES ARE NOT ONLY GIVE
CONSUMERS THE ABILITY TO COMPARE
CREDITS AND DECIDE WHICH OF THE
MOST IMPACTFUL BUT ALSO GIVE
RESEARCHERS THE TOOLS NEEDED TO
FURTHER EVALUATE THESE PRODUCTS
TO DETERMINE WHICH CREDITS
ENTITIES AND PRACTICES YOUR
LEGITIMATE RESULTS. AB THIRTEEN
OH FIVE REPRESENTS A MEANINGFUL
STEP TOWARD INCOME COMBATING
GREENWASHING AND PROTECTING
CONSUMERS FROM FRAUDULENT OFFSET
CREDITS. THAT DO NOT REPRESENT
GENUINE EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS.
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF BILLS DR BARBARA HYDE
DIRECTOR OF THE BERKELEY KARBI
TRADING PROJECT AT THE GOLDMAN
SCHOOL OF PUBLIC POLICY AT UC
BERKELEY. THANK YOU AND
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
. C. HI. THANK YOU AND I AM DR
BARBER HIGH- I DIRECT THE
BERKELEY CARBON TRADING PROJECT
AT UC BERKELEY. AND I STUDIED. A
CARBON OFFSET QUALITY FOR TWENTY
YEARS- AND OVER THE LAST TWO
DECADES- AS IN SAID- QUALITY ON
THE MARKET AND THE AFTERMARKET
HAS BEEN EXCEPTIONALLY POOR. FOR
EXAMPLE WE RECENTLY COMPLETED AN
ANALYSIS OF ONE OF THE FASTEST
GROWING OFFICE PROJECT TYPES
COULD IMPROVE COOKSTOVES. AND
FOUND THAT THIS PROGRAM ON
AVERAGE GENERATED SEVEN TIMES
THE NUMBER OF CREDITS THAN
ACTUAL IMPACT ON EMISSIONS. AND
WE FOUND THAT ACROSS MANY
DIFFERENT PROJECT TYPES FROM
AVOIDED DEFORESTATION TO IMPROVE
FOREST MANAGEMENT- TO RENEWABLE
ENERGY- INTERNATIONALLY AND- THE
VOLUNTARY OFFSET MARKET- IS.
CREATED MAINLY BY WERE PRIVATE
UNREGULATED CARBON OFFSET
REGISTRIES AND THESE REGISTRIES
DO FOUR THINGS BASICALLY THEY
DECIDE WHICH PROJECT TYPES ARE
ALLOWED TO GENERATE OFFSET
CREDITS THE DOT METHODS FOR
MONITORING HOW CHELATING. AND
VERIFYING THE CLIMATE BENEFITS
FROM EACH INDIVIDUAL
PARTICIPATING PROJECT THE ISSUE
CREDITS IN THE KEEP TRACK OF WHO
OWNS THEM AND WHO RETIRES THE
CREDITS. OF THE QUALITY MATTERS
BECAUSE THESE CREDITS CAN BE
BOUGHT BY COMPANIES TO MAKE
EMISSIONS REDUCTION OR CARBON
NEUTRALITY CLAIMS OR SELL CARBON
NEUTRAL PRODUCTS. COMPANIES BY
THESE CREDITS AND OFTEN IN PLACE
. OF PRODUCING THEIR OWN
EMISSIONS. I THE- SO IN THIS
UNREGULATED INDUSTRY BUYERS ARE
LEFT ON THEIR OWN TO FIGURE OUT
WHICH CREDITS ARE REAL BUT SAFE
TO BUY OR THEY RELY ON EXPERTS
TO REVIEW QUALITY BUT REVIEWERS
LIKE OURSELVES- DON'T HAVE THE
INFORMATION THAT WE NEED TO
FULLY ASSESS QUALITY. THE
REGISTRIES HAVE ALL OF THE
DOCUMENTATION AND ALL OF THE
CALCULATIONS NEEDED TO REPRODUCE
AND ASSESS THE CREDIT
CALCULATIONS THESE TOUCH
TYPICALLY ARE NOT MADE PUBLIC.
AND I BELIEVE THAT ONE OF THE
MOST IMPORTANT IN EASY STEPS
THAT A GOVERNMENT THAT THE
GOVERNMENT CAN TAKE TO REGULATE
THE VOLUNTARY OFFSET MARKET. IS
REQUIRE DISCLOSURE ALLOWING
FIRES TO KNOW WHAT THEY'RE
BUYING- AND- A ANALYST ANALYZE
QUALITY- IN THIS MOST IMPORTANT
OF MARKETS. OTHER FOLKS YOU
WANNA VOICE SUPPORT FOR THE BILL
AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE. IF YOU WANT
TO RAISE OPPOSITION CONCERNS
ABOUT THE BILL. LET'S GO TO
PHONE LINES YOU WANT TO WEIGH IN
ON THE THIRTEEN OH FIVE ON THE
PHONE LINES. LATEST GERMAN IF
YOU WISH TO MAKE A COMMENT OF
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. IF YOU IF
YOU NEW LINES THAT HAVE QUEUED
UP ONE MOMENT WHILE THEY'RE IN
LINE NUMBERS GIVEN.
IT WILL BE GOING TO LINE ONE
THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD.
AFTERNOON CATHY SCHAEFER ON
BEHALF OF THE SAN FERNANDO
VALLEY AND LOS ANGELES CHAPTERS
THE CLIMATE REALITY IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. NEXT DEADLINE ONE
FIFTY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. WE
ARE. HERE CALIFORNIA- IN ORDER
AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE THANK YOU.
THAT'S CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN
THE QUEUE AT THIS TIME MISTER
CHAIR. OKAY I WAS WRECKED THE
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS THOUGHTS
COMMENTS FROM THE MEMBERS. I
WOULD MOVE THE BILL ALL RIGHT I
THANK YOU S. CENTERS HERE
PROCEDURAL LEADERSHIP ON THIS
ISSUE OF THE TO CLOSE- THANK YOU
VERY MUCH I HAVE ALWAYS BEEN A
BIG FAN FAN OF TRANSPARENCY.
THIS WOULD BRING TRANSPARENCY TO
APARTMENT PART OF THE MARKET
WITH RESPECT TO A QUESTION
ABOUT. GREAT THANK YOU- BUYS THE
MOVE BY SOME SKINNER SURGERIES
KALRA. AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED AND
RE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
JUDICIARY SENATORS ALLEN AYE
ALLEN AYE DALY. GONZALEZ HER
TADO HER TADO I'D MENJIVAR
NGUYEN SKINNER FIVE SKINNER HI
THANK YOU THESE ARE MUCH
APPRECIATED ALL RIGHT- SHOWS
COME PORTS ASSEMBLY WOULD MEAN-
IF. ALL RIGHT I TECHNICALLY A
SHOVEL IN. THE NEXT IN LINE- I'M
SEVEN. AB FORTY TWENTY THREE. HI
THERE UNIVERSITY THANK YOU. FROM
THANK YOU SO MUCH TERRY MEMBERS
HAPPY FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
PRESENT ON AB FOURTEEN TWENTY
THREE A BILL TO PROTECT THE
HEALTH OF OUR YOUNGEST ATHLETES
OUR COMMUNITY AND OUR WATER- I
WANTED TO START BY SAYING I
APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE'S
DILIGENT WORK ON THIS AND- HAPPY
TO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS. MANUFACTURING
PATENTS IN STUDIES CONDUCTED ON
A NUMBER OF ARTIFICIAL TURF
SAMPLES USED THROUGHOUT THE
COUNTRY CHAU FIELD FIELDS
CONTAIN P. FOSS AND A CLASS OF
CHEMICALS THAT HARM HUMAN HEALTH
KNOWN OFTEN AS RUBBER CHEMICALS.
AS CHILDREN PLAY IN THE FIELDS
KICK SOCCER BALLS RUN WITH
CLEATS ON A SUNNY DAY AT THE
FIELD SLOWLY WEARS DOWN AND THE
MICRO PLASTIC DUST CREATES A
FIELD. THAT BREAKS DOWN AND IS
INGESTED OR INHALED AS WELL AS
CAN ENTER THE STORM WATER SYSTEM
WHEN FIELDS ARE WATERED OR WHEN
THE RAINS COME. A NEW FIELD CAN
LAST OVER A DECADE THAT'S AT
LEAST TEN YEARS OF P. FASTEST
AND TEN YEARS OF LEACHING INTO
WATER SYSTEMS AND TEN YEARS OF
CHILDREN READING IT AND-
CALIFORNIA MUST ACT TO PREVENT
AND PROTECT THE HEALTH. AND
SAFETY OF CHILDREN FROM NEW
FIELDS CONTAINING THESE
CARCINOGENIC AND DANGEROUS
CHEMICALS. AB FOURTEEN TWENTY
THREE WOULD BRING CALIFORNIA
ALONGSIDE OTHER STATES IN TAKING
SWIFT ACTION TO PROTECT PUBLIC
HEALTH BY PROHIBITING NEW
INSTALLATIONS AT THE START OF
THE YEAR AT ACADEMIC AND PUBLIC
FACILITIES AND PROHIBITING THE
SALE OF TIRTH. TURF CONTAINING
IN PEE FUSS. IN TWENTY TWENTY
SIX I AM JOINED TODAY BY BILL
ALLEY- CALIFORNIA DIRECTOR OF
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS- AT FROM THE
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP TO
TESTIFY AS WELL. CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS COMMITTEE I AM BILL ELIA
WITH ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP
ARE PLEASED TO SPONSOR THIS
BILL. AS THIS COMMITTEE KNOWS P.
FAST IS A HELPING HAND HAZARD-
DTS IS DETERMINED THAT THROUGH A
BUNCH OF WHITE PAPERS AND- AS
YOU KNOW WE NOW LIVE IN LAW
BILLS TO REGULATE IN FOOD
PACKAGING TEXTILES. JUVENILE
PRODUCTS COSMETICS AND THIS
COMMITTEE RECENTLY APPROVED
BILLS ON MENSTRUAL PRODUCTS AND
CLEANING PRODUCTS- P. FAST IS A
PROBLEM WE'RE WORKING ON GETTING
IT OUT WE SPECIALLY DON'T WANT
TO GET INTO DRINKING WATER. AND
USE ON ARTIFICIAL FEEL THROUGH
RUNOFF CAN LEAD TO THAT VERY
THING. THE DEPARTMENT OF DTS HE
HAS ACKNOWLEDGED- THAT THIS
LEGISLATURE WILL MOVE FORWARD ON
CONSUMER CHEMICAL PRODUCTS
COMBINATIONS THAT THEY CAN'T GET
TO YET AND THAT'S WE HAVE
ANOTHER ONE HERE- AS FAR AS
ISSUES IN THE BILL WE'RE WORKING
WITH THE OPPOSITION. AND TRYING
TO RESOLVE EACH OF THOSE WERE
PART OF THE BILL OF PROPOSED-
FEELS WOULD HAVE MORE TIME WE'VE
ALSO AGREED TO ALLOW FOR
TESTING. AFTER MANUFACTURING AND
BEFORE INSTALLATION TO ALLOW FOR
TO SEE WE GET CROSS
CONTAMINATION WE DON'T AGREE ON
THE HUNDRED PARTS MILLION THAT
THEY'RE PROPOSING IS A
THRESHOLD- WE NOTE THAT U. S.
EPA IS PROPOSING FOUR PARTS PER
TRILLION ON DRINKING WATER
STANDARDS. AND SO WE CAN GO WAY
BELOW THAT AND JUST COMMITTEE IS
GONE HELLO HUNDRED SEVERAL TIMES
NOW JUST AS RECENTLY AS LAST
WEEK. SO WE'RE CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH THEM AND WERE- AVAILABLE
FOR QUESTIONS AND ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU THANKS
SO MUCH OTHER FOLKS. WANNA WIN
SUPPORT. THE BILL. HI KATE
CONNOLLY WITH THE CALIFORNIA
WATER SERVICE AND SUPPORT.
JENNIFER WILLIAMS EAST BAY
MUNICIPAL UTILITY DISTRICT AND
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. JEFF NEAL
REPRESENTING THE CITY OF
MILLBRAE CONTINUES TO BE IN
SUPPORT. AND ALSO GIVEN OF AN I.
FOUR FROM OUR ADDRESS ENTER
CLEAN WATER ACTION IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. OKAY EVOKES MEMORIES
OPPOSITION CONCERNS ABOUT THE
BILL BEFORE TO TWENTY THREE.
YEAR OLD. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN SYNAGOGUE PRESIDENT
HERE THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
THAT- MISTER CHAIRMAN. MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE RANDY POLLOCK
IN BEHALF OF THE SYNTHETIC TURF
COUNCIL A WE FIRST WANT TO
APPRECIATE THE WORKING WITH
FAMILY MEMBERS OFFICE SPECIALLY
GRAYSON THE COMMITTEE. WHAT
WE'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH THIS
IS A COUPLE ISSUES THAT I'D LIKE
TO RAISE THE FIRST PART IS THAT
WE BELIEVE THAT THERE SHOULD BE
A DELAY IMPLEMENTATION FOR ALL
FIELDS UNTIL TWENTY TWENTY SIX.
THE WAY IT'S SET UP RIGHT NOW
IT'S SET FOR THE PRIVATE YOU CAN
HAVE UNTIL TWENTY TWENTY SIX BUT
FOR THE PUBLIC IT GOES INTO
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY. ADDITIONALLY
A TALKING ABOUT THE PARTS PER
MILLION AS BILL INDICATED I
THINK THAT THE SCIENCE IS ALL
OVER THE PLACE WE'VE HEARD THIS
FROM THE COMMITTEE IN THE PAST A
COUPLE OF WEEKS. AND WE ARE JUST
CONCERNED ABOUT TESTING DOWN TO
THAT LEVEL ADDITION I WANNA
RAISE ANOTHER CONCERN IS THAT IF
WE'RE GOING TO START RECYCLING
THIS STUFF. I THINK WE HAVE TO
DETERMINE WHAT IS GOING TO BE
THE LEVEL IN THE RECYCLING CARTS
IF WE'RE TRYING TO GET THIS OUT
OF THE LANDFILLS. AND I THINK WE
HAVE TO LOOK AT THE COULD BE
PARKED MILLION A FIFTY OR A
HUNDRED. WE THINK THAT HAS TO BE
TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION SO WE
THINK THE LEVEL OF TWENTY PARTS
PER MILLION IS OPEN TO ALL.
INITIALLY AS THE CARPET SAYS
ARTIFICIAL TURF CONTINUES TO GO
THROUGH A NEW OR IS BEING SOLD.
IN THE P. FIVE IS GOING TO BE
DIMINISH OVER THAT TIME. SO WE
LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO
WORK WITH THE COMMITTEE AND ALSO
WITH THE- THE AUTHOR THANKS.
THANK YOU THANKS FOR ANY. SHOULD
OTHER FOLKS WANT TO A RACE CAN.
ARE YOU HAVE YOU GUYS BEEN
HAVING GOOD DISCUSSIONS YOU FEEL
AND OKAY- YEAH THESE ARE TOUGH
ISSUES THEN WE YOU KNOW WE WERE
GOING OVER. ANOTHER SB FIVE
SPELL I'M NOT LONG AGO AND YOU
KNOW WHERE TO SET THE STANDARDS
IS REALLY HARD SOME OF THE
TESTING ISSUES IT'S ULTRA-
ESPECIALLY SINCE WE KNOW THAT.
THERE'S YOU KNOW NOPE LEVEL
THAT'S- CONSIDERED SAVING AT THE
SERVER. AND THERE FOREVER AND SO
ABUBAKAR SO I'M- HI ALL RIGHT.
FOLKS YOU WANT OTHER FOLKS ROOMS
CONCERNS ANYONE WANTS TO WAIT ON
THE PHONE LINES EIGHTY FOURTEEN
TWENTY THREE. THANK YOU
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION YOU MAY
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. FOR
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION AND WE WILL
GO TO LINE ONE THIRTY NINE. HI
MY NAME IS ADOPTION WATER AND I
AM IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE-
BILL. AS YOU KNOW THERE'S NO
SUCH STATE LEVEL PIZZA. URGE YOU
TO KEEP. A LEVEL DOWN THANK YOU
. THANK YOU ONE THIRTY SEVEN
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HI MY NAME
THIRTY FIVE CA BEHALF THE
CLIMATE REALITY PROJECT LOS
ANGELES AND SAN FERNANDO VALLEY
CHAPTERS. WERE IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU LINE ONE FIFTY THREE. ONE
ONE FIFTY THREE YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. HERE AGAIN YOUR CALL
CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
A FORTUNE TWENTY THREE THANK YOU
. THANK YOU LINE ONE NINETY FIVE
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HI MY- I'M
SORRY ONE NINETY FIVE HELLO. MY
NAME IS JOHN BARNES THE CLINIC
FOR KIDS AT OREGON IN STRONG
SUPPORT. THANK YOU LINE ONE
EIGHTY FOR YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
MORE THAN WELCOME TO HAVE TO THE
NATIONAL ACTION COUNCIL AND
TRANSPORT THANK YOU. RIGHT ONE
FIFTY YOUR LINE IS OPEN. IN
CURRENCY IN STRONG SUPPORT OF AB
. FOURTEEN TWENTY THREE. THANK
YOU LINE ONE FORTY THREE YOUR
LINE IS OPEN. YEAH ON THE CORNER
RESIDENTS OF SANTA CLARA COUNTY
STRONG SUPPORT OF ONE FOURTH TO
THREE. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE
HAVE NO FURTHER SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION IN KILL. OKAY THIS
MESSAGE MANY MISS RUSSIA. WELL
FIRST OF ALL IT THANK YOU BRING
GO FLORENCE SO. JUST A LITTLE
HISTORY HE WAS A FEW YEARS AGO
AND CHRISTY BOMBER WAS WITH THE
FIREFIGHTERS AND CAME AND TALKED
ABOUT P. FAST AND IT WAS FIRST
I'D EVER HEARD OF IT- AND WE
REALLY MOVED I THINK IN THIS
COMMITTEE. ALONG THE LINES OF
TRYING TO AND I'VE EDUCATED
MYSELF ON PEOPLE'S A LOT- AND
THAT'S WHY I THINK WE SEE THE
WATER AGENCIES IN HERE IT'S IN
OUR WATER IT'S EVERYWHERE. AND
SO I THINK THE STRUGGLE WE'RE
GOING TO HAVE IS WHAT LEVEL ARE
WE REALLY GOING TO GO TRY TO
FIGURE OUT IN THE SHORT TERM
TELL WE FIGURE OUT WHAT THE LONG
TERM LOOKS LIKE AND THAT'S WHERE
I THINK YOUR BILL SAID I MEAN.
I'M SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY BUT
I JUST I WASN'T ABLE TO BE HERE
ON THE MENSTRUAL PRODUCTS I
THINK THAT'S WHAT WE CALL THEM-
I MISSED THAT- AND I WANTED TO
COMMENT ON THAT BECAUSE- IN THE
MANUFACTURING SIDE OF IT- YOU
KNOW THEY'RE THEY'RE TRYING TO
GET THERE. AND WE DON'T REALLY
KNOW EXACTLY WERE ALL IN THE
WATER COMPANIES ARE REALLY THE
ONES I THINK ARE GOING TO
STRUGGLE BECAUSE IT'S IN. PIZZA
BOXES IT'S IN MICROWAVE POPCORN-
THERE'S IT'S REALLY EVERYWHERE
AND SO I THINK THAT- JUST I WANT
TO TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY BECAUSE
I DIDN'T HAVE THE- ABILITY AND
FOR THE LAST COUPLE BILLS UP.
THAT WE NEEDED- NO THE TRAINS
MOVING PRETTY FAST. AND I THINK
WE NEED TO LOOK AT WHAT PARTS
PER. BILLION OR MILLION THAT WE
REALLY WANT TO FOCUS IN ON AND
GIVE THE MANUFACTURERS. AN
OPPORTUNITY TO- COME ALONG WITH
THIS AND NOT JUST. DROP DEAD
DATES AND SO- IN MY LAST COMMENT
ON THE LAST BILL ABOUT DPR WE
HAVE A SYSTEM IN PLACE THAT
WE'VE- ALLOCATED TO DO THAT AND
WE NEED TO. WORK WITH THEM AT
THE SAME TIME SO I'M TO SUPPORT
YOUR BILL TODAY- IT'S AN AREA I
THINK THAT WE'RE GONNA SEE A LOT
MORE THESE BILLS I THINK WE'RE
GONNA SEE. HALF OF A LOT MORE
BECAUSE WE'RE SEEING IT AND- OUR
WATER AND IT'S AND IT'S- HARD TO
DETERMINE WHERE IT'S COMING
FROM. AND HOW WE REGULATE THAT
SO I JUST WANTED TO BRING THAT
UP BECAUSE- I KNOW THIS
COMMITTEE- IS GOING TO BE SEEING
A LOT MORE THESE. PIECES OF
LEGISLATION I WANTED TO- FIGURE
OUT HOW WE GO IN A- IN A MANNER
THAT ALLOWS MANUFACTURERS TO
COME ALONG WITH THIS AND NOT BE
SO HARMFUL TO SAVE TIME SO. YEP
THE YOU YES AND- I APPRECIATE.
SENATOR YOUR COMMENTS AND- YOU
KNOW IT'S ALWAYS A BALANCING ACT
. BUT YOU KNOW WE DON'T ALWAYS
KNOW WHAT WE DON'T KNOW. AND NOW
WE KNOW. ABOUT PASS AND WE KNOW
THAT IT'S FOREVER. WE KNOW IT IS
SERIOUSLY HARMFUL NOT ONLY ON
HUMANS BUT HI. AND I GUESS WHEN
WE LEARNED. ABOUT SOMETHING THAT
IS AS- HORRIBLE. AS THIS
PARTICULAR PRODUCT IS. AND AS-
BASICALLY. PERSISTENT IN THE
BACKWARDNESS. THEN WHILE I.
FREESHEET THAT IT IS A BURDEN.
WE NEED TO DO EVERYTHING WE CAN
TO GET RID OF IT NOW. WE DON'T
REALLY HAVE TIME. TO DELAY. AND
. HELLO I STRONGLY SUPPORT THE
BILL. AND HAVE SUPPORTED
PASSWORDS AND I THINK THERE
SHOULD BE A COMPLETE. ECONOMIC
QUITE BEYOND ON THESE AND I
THINK WE SHOULD PROBABLY STOP
DOING INDIVIDUAL BILLS TO KEEP
AFFECTING IN PARTICULAR AND JUST
FLAT OUT DO IT. BUT THAT'S OKAY
YOU'VE GOT IT IN FRONT OF US SO
I WILL MOVE IT. I'M DEFINITELY
SUPPORT I WOULD SUGGEST TO THE
CHAIRMAN AND SORRY FOR HIJACKING
YOUR BILL THAT WE DO A STUDY ON
THIS AS A COMMITTEE. AND LOOK AT
ALL THE AREAS THAT WE'RE WE HAVE
PEACEFUL I'M WITH I'M WITH THE
SENATOR FROM BERKELEY I THINK WE
DO HAVE AN OBLIGATION TO REALLY
DIVE INTO THIS AND I'D BE HAPPY
TO. SIT ON THAT COMMITTEE AND
LEARN MORE ABOUT ACROSS THE
BOARD BECAUSE LOOK I THINK IT'S
FAIR ONLY TO THE INDUSTRY TO
THAT HEY WE'RE WE'RE HEADING
THAT WAY. AND WE COULD MAYBE DO
A STUDY SESSION OUT OF THIS
COMMITTEES OF I THINK THE PUBLIC
COMMITTEE THAT'S GOING TO YOU
KNOW NOT AND I WOULD BE HAPPY TO
SIT ON I THINK WE NEED TO GET
BENEFACTORS OF THE TABLE BECAUSE
WE'RE GOING TO DO ONE OFFS FOR A
LONG TIME UNTIL WE GET THIS
FIGURED OUT SO. I'M WITH YOU
SENATOR SKINNER ON THIS ONE AND-
I THINK WE OWE IT TO THE-
MANUFACTURES WE OUGHT TO THE-
THE WATER AGENCIES THAT ARE
DEALING WITH THIS. AND LET'S
HAVE A CONVERSATION ABOUT IT-
BEFORE WE JUST KEEP DOING ONE
OFFS AND- SAT IN THE BAR AND-
MAYBE GET DPR AND FIGURE THIS
OUT. THIS COULD GUARANTEE A JOB
POST FELLOWSHIP. ARE THE I MEAN
WE AFFECT. YOU MENTION THE
MENTAL PRODUCTS BILL WE LOOKED
AT US WE CAN BEEN DOING A DEEP
DIVE INTO WHAT EUROPE'S MATURE.
EUROPE IS LOOKING AT A PRETTY-
SUBSTANCE SOMETHING VERY SIMILAR
VERY VERY SUBSTANTIAL- A SECTOR
WIDE. OUR STRATEGY ON ON P. FIVE
S. AND THEY'VE ALREADY. BANDPEY
FOE- AND- P. P. FIVE THOUGHT
PHOCAEA FO AT YEAH EXACTLY- PBS
GOTTA PFOS- BUT- BUT OTHER
LOOKING KIND OF SECTOR WIDE. AT
AT P. FIVE SO. WE SHOULD DO
SOMETHING SIMILAR. AND- THERE WE
GO. LET'S GO GET TO WORK. I WAS
REMOVED BY. A CENTER SKINNER
SECTOR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. AB
FOURTEEN TWENTY THREE THE MOTION
IS DO YOU PASS AS AMENDED AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SENATORS
ALAN. AYE ALLEN AYE DOLLY. DALI
I CAN SALAS. PALCA COMMITTEE
MEMBERS TOOK CARE OF IT FOR ME.
SORRY THIS AND MORE. WILLIAMS
APOLOGIES. OKAY SENATORS ALLEN
VOTED AYE DOLLY AYE GONZALEZ.
HER TADO. HER TADO I. MENJIVAR.
WHEN SKINNER RIGHT SKINNER ON-
CALL. AWESOME WE'RE REALLY THAT
ACROSS OTHER PEOPLE CANNELLA.
AND FINALLY THE EVER PATIENT
DECEMBER WOULD WE APPRECIATE
YOU- PASSED OVER BY YOUR
COLLEAGUES. FOR AND.
SO SORRY DON'T KNOW RESOLVED AT
ALL THANK YOU THANK YOU SENATOR-
THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS-
I'M HERE TODAY TO PRESENT SB
FOURTEEN EIGHTY NINE WHICH IS A
NARROWLY FOCUSED FOLLOW UP TO
YOUR SB FIFTY FOUR FROM LAST
YEAR. AS WELL AS WE ALL KNOW SB
FIFTY FOUR WAS A LANDMARK PIECE
OF LEGISLATION SAID IN THE
AMBITIOUS GOALS FOR PLASTIC
REDUCTION IN THE NATION. TO
REACH THESE GOALS SB FIFTY FOUR
REQUIRED TWO THINGS FOR ALL
SINGLE USE PLASTICS SOLD
DISTRIBUTED OR IMPORTED INTO THE
STATE TO BE EITHER RECYCLABLE OR
COMPOSTABLE BY TWENTY THIRTY
TWO. AND 425% REDUCTION IN THE
TOTAL AMOUNT OF PLASTIC MATERIAL
PRODUCED BY THE STATE BY TWENTY
THIRTY TO MAYBE FOURTEEN EIGHTY
NINE CLARIFIES THAT WITHIN THE
TO THAT 25% REDUCTION GOAL IT IS
NOT THE INTENT OF THE STATE TO
REQUIRE THE REDUCTION OF
COMPOSTABLE PRODUCTS. HOWEVER
THIS DOES NOT MEAN COMPOSED BY
MANUFACTURERS GET A PASS THEY
STILL HAVE TO PARTICIPATE IN SB
FIFTY FOUR IS PRODUCED A
PRODUCER RESPONSIBILITY
ORGANISATIONS THEY STILL HAVE TO
PAY FEES. AND THEY STILL HAVE
THE CERTIFIED THROUGH THE STATE
THAT THEY WILL BE COMPOSED OF
ALL STANDARDS WHICH THE FEDERAL
AND STATE GOVERNMENTS ARE
DEVELOPING. I WORK ON AMENDMENTS
IN RESPONSE THE CONCERNS RAISED
BY THE OPPOSITION THAT NAP THAT
NARROWED THE SCOPE OF THIS BILL
TO SO VOTE SOLELY FOCUSED ON
SOURCE REDUCTION. MEMBERS I
BELIEVE THIS IS A COMMON SENSE
FOLLOW UP THAT IS CRITICAL TO
CARRY OUT THE GOALS OF S. B.
FIFTY FOUR. WITH ME TO TESTIFY
IS AMY MAC YOU AND WITH NEW AI
TECHNOLOGIES AND BRUCE MAKE
NINETY A WITH THE BIODEGRADABLE
PRODUCTS INSTITUTE. FIRST
SENATOR AND CHAIR MEMBERS
BRIDGEMAN YANNI WITH THE BAT
AGRADABLE PRODUCTS INSTITUTE AND
I THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY.
TO TESTIFY TODAY AS AS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WOULD EXPLAIN- IN. IN SB
FIFTY FOUR- AND WE ALL KNOW WHAT
A DAUNTING TASK THAT WAS TO TRY
AND GET A COMPLETE E. P. R.
PROGRAM PUT TOGETHER- AND ADDS
THAT PLAYED OUT AS AS YOU KNOW-
TOWARDS THE END THE DEFINITION
OF PLASTIC ITSELF WAS. CHANGED
AND IT DIDN'T ALLOW TIME. TO
AFFECT TO MAKE ALL THE
AMENDMENTS NECESSARY TO THOSE
SECTIONS THAT WERE AFFECTED IN
COMPOSTABLE FOR ONE OF THOSE
SECTIONS. SO TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WHICH POINT THIS IS NARROWLY
FOCUSED IT'S CLARIFYING- IT
DOESN'T UPSET AND THE PLAINFIELD
OF WHAT SB FIFTY FOUR WAS
NEGOTIATED ON. AND IT JUST
SIMPLY WASN'T CONTEMPLATED NOR
WAS THERE TIME TO CONTEMPLATE IT
AND I'M HAPPY TO. REMAIN HERE TO
ANSWER QUESTIONS OF THE
COMMITTEE THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS MY NAME
IS AMY MOB YOU I'M WITH YOU LIKE
TECHNOLOGIES. I'M I'M HERE TODAY
IN SUPPORT OF AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY
NINE. NEW LIGHT AS A CALIFORNIA
GROWN COMPANY HEADQUARTERED IN
MANUFACTURING IN HUNTINGTON
BEACH CALIFORNIA WITH NEARLY TWO
HUNDRED GREEN JOBS. IS THERE
MORE THAN A DECADE RESEARCHING
ALLOWED TO TRYING TO FIND A WAY
THAT WE CAN HARNESS NATURE IN
GREENHOUSE GASES TO DEVELOP A
PRODUCT THAT COULD BE USEFUL.
I'M THE COMPANY HAS A DUAL
MISSION OF BOTH ADDRESSING
CLIMATE CHANGE AS WELL AS
PLASTIC POLLUTION REDUCTION.
WELL WE ARE A COMPANY THAT
MANUFACTURES COMPOSER MATERIALS
WERE VERY SUPPORTIVE OF
CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS. TO REDUCE
WASTAGE IN AUGUST PLASTICS WERE
FULLY SUPPORTIVE EFFORT TO POWER
CYCLE AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF
THROUGH THE SB FIFTY FOUR
IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS. EIGHT
EIGHTY FORTY NINE OF THE
TECHNICAL CLARIFICATION TO
ENSURE FAIR TREATMENT OF
COMPOSED MATERIALS. ARE THE
CURRENT LANGUAGE COMPOSER
MATERIALS WILL FALL UNDER THE
SOURCE REDUCTION REQUIREMENTS OF
THE BILL MEETING WILL HAVE TO
REDUCE OUR MATERIAL BY 25% FROM
TWENTY TWENTY THREE BASELINE.
FOR COMPANIES THAT ARE JUST
GETTING OFF THE GROUND RIGHT NOW
WE TAKE A BASELINE OF TWENTY
TWENTY THREE AND THEN REDUCE THE
AMOUNT OF MATERIAL THAT THOSE
COMPANIES ARE MAKING. WE'RE NOT
GONNA BE ABLE TO MEET THE GOALS
OF SB FIFTY FOUR WHICH IS TO
ENSURE THAT WE HAVE COMPOSTABLE
PRODUCTS BY TWENTY THIRTY TO.
CALIFORNIA STATE THAT PRIDES
ITSELF ON INNOVATION AND AB
FOURTEEN EIGHTY NINE OF THE
BILLABLE SIGNAL THE TECHNOLOGY
COMPANIES. THAT THEY SHOULD
CONTINUE TO INNOVATE AND IMPROVE
IN CALIFORNIA AND THE WORLD
ENVIRONMENT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TIME AND- ALLOW ME TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF FIFTY. UP TO FOURTEEN
NINETY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
PRESIDENT. ALL RIGHT I ANYONE
ELSE WANTS TO VOICE. FOR THE
BILL. OKAY GOING TO OPPOSITION-
FOLKS OF CONCERNS. JENNIFER HI
THERE GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS JENNIFER FEARING ON
BEHALF OF THE OCEAN CONSERVANCY
THE MONTEREY BAY AQUARIUM AND-
SHE AND THAT RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSED AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY NINE
. WHILE WE VERY MUCH APPRECIATE
THE WORK THAT THE AUTHOR IN THE
ASSEMBLY NATURAL RESOURCES
COMMITTEE CONTRIBUTED TO ADDRESS
OUR CONCERNS WITH THE INTRODUCED
VERSION OF THE BILL. WE BELIEVE
CALIFORNIA SHOULD STAY THE SB
FIFTY FOUR COURSE BY FOCUSING
FIRST ON REDUCING THE PRODUCTION
AND USE OF ALL SINGLE USE FOOD
OR IN PACKAGING AND MOVING
TOWARD A TRULY CIRCULAR AND
REUSABLE ECONOMY. WHICH IS
CRITICAL TO REDUCING THE HARMS
OF PLASTIC PRODUCTION AND
POLLUTION ON PEOPLE AND NATURE.
AB FORTINO NINE PROMOTES A
TRANSITION TO OTHER SINGLE USE
MATERIALS. COMBUSTIBLE PLASTICS
ALREADY GET A PREFERENTIAL
TREATMENT BY WAY OF A REDUCED
FEE IN SB FIFTY FOURS PRODUCER
RESPONSIBILITY PLAN. AND ADDING
AN EXEMPTION FOR COMPOSTABLE
MATERIALS FROM THE INDUSTRY WIDE
SOURCE REDUCTION MANDATE.
FURTHER ENCOURAGES EXISTING AND
NEW PRODUCERS TO USE COMPOSTABLE
PLASTIC MATERIALS. INSTEAD OF
PRIORITIZING REFILL AND REUSE.
SOME CERTIFIED COMPOSTABLE
PLASTICS CONTAIN FOSSIL FUEL
COMPONENTS AND SOME OF THE SAME
PROBLEMATIC ADDITIVES AS FOSSIL
FUEL DERIVED PLASTICS WHICH ARE
KNOWN TO CONTAMINATE WASTE
STREAMS. MANY CALIFORNIA
COMPOSTERS PERHAPS ALL OF THEM
REFUSED TO TAKE THESE MATERIALS
AND PICK THEM OUT BECAUSE THEY
CANNOT LABEL THEIR COMPOST AND
ORGANIC UNDER FEDERAL STANDARDS
. WE ARE ALSO WARY OF
SUBSTANTIVE AMENDMENTS THIS YEAR
TO SB FIFTY FOUR BECAUSE THEY
COMPROMISE CAL RECYCLE SWIFT
IMPLEMENTATION TIMELINE GIVEN SB
FIFTY FOURS AGGRESSIVE DIETZ.
AND IT COMPROMISES WHAT WAS
NEGOTIATED IN A ROBUST
STAKEHOLDER PROCESS WHICH WE
WERE KEY PARTICIPANTS IN SO WE
DO RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR NO
VOTE AND APPRECIATE YOUR
CONSIDERATION. THANK YOU. YES.
MISTER SHARON MEMBERS SILO
GONZALEZ FLETCHER WITH THE
NATURE CONSERVANCY WE WOULD
ALIGN OURSELVES WITH THE
COMMENTS MADE BY OUR COLLEAGUE
JENNIFER FEARING AND UNFORTUNATE
AND RESPECTFUL POSITION. THANK
YOU. OTHER FOLKS YOU WANNA RAISE
CONCERNS ANYONE ELSE OKAY NO
PHONE LINES PHONE LINES FOR AB
FORTY NINE. THANK YOU FOR
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
THAT IS ONE AND THEN THE OFFICE
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. MISTER
CHAIR WE HAVE KNOWN EACH YEAR.
OKAY OUR LET'S GO BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS THOUGHTS
CONCERNS- CENTER SKINNER- I'M
FAMILIAR WITH THE PRODUCT OF
THE- THE MEMBER THE PERSON WHO
TESTIFIED THEIR PARTICULAR
PRODUCT. AND I APPRECIATE WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO HOWEVER I AM
CONCERNED THAT. THERE ARE OTHER
PRODUCTS THAT ARE. THERE'S A LOT
OF DEBATE AS TO HOW COMPOSTABLE
THEY ARE YET THEY ARE BRANDED AS
COMPOSTABLE. AND SO I DO HAVE
THAT CONCERNED ABOUT THAT
SLIPPERY SLOPE ESPECIALLY GIVEN
THAT FIFTY FOUR DID ADDRESS. SO-
NO- SINCE THE MAIN AUTHOR CLOSE
A CO AUTHOR BUT THE MAIN AUTHOR
IS HERE AND THE CHAIR OF THIS
COMMITTEE I GUESS TO BOTH THE
AUTHOR AND TO THE CHAIR HOW ARE.
YOU KNOW HOW HAS WE HAVE
RECONSTRUCTED THIS TO WORK. SO
THAT- WE ARE NOT- SIGNALING THAT
PRODUCTS THAT ARE BRANDED AS
COMPOSTABLE BUT- NOT REALLY
PRACTICALLY COMPOSTABLE YEAH
FALL INTO THE CRACKS HERE SUITS
SO ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND TEAM HAD
A BILL ON THIS TOPIC THAT WE
REFER TO THE C. FIFTY FOUR THAT
SAYS THAT THEY HAVE TO BE
RESPECT VASSY COMBUSTIBLE. NOT
JUST. UNDER PERFECT CONDITIONS.
BUT THEY'VE GOT TO BE COMPOSABLE
UNDER REAL WORLD EXISTING
CONDITIONS IN CALIFORNIA- AT THE
COMMERCIAL COME YET THAT THE AT
THE INDUSTRY'S REYES JUST GOTTA
SCALE GONE COMPOSTABLE. SO THEY
WERE RELYING ON AND- CAL RECYCLE
TO BE ABLE TO DETERMINE NOT
EXACTLY THAT EXACTLY AND IT HAS
TO BE BASED ON A TRUE COMPOSED
ABILITY RIGHT. WHICH I DO KNOW
THIS PARTICULAR. MANUFACTURES IT
. BUT NOT ALL RIGHT. SO I'M HERE
TODAY- IT IS IT'S OUR UNDERSTAND
YOU KNOW I THINK THAT THE
CHALLENGE HERE IS- YOU KNOW I
MEAN IT'S OUR GENERAL FEELING
THAT THAT THE STANDARDS THAT ARE
HERE ARE ARE STRONG ENOUGH
BECAUSE- YOU KNOW WEIRD WEIRD.
BECAUSE WE THINK THAT THAT THE
COMPOST ABILITY CENTER THAT WE
HAD- ARE ARE STRONG ENOUGH I DO
KNOW THAT ONE OF THE
OPPOSITION'S CONCERNS IN GENERAL
IS THAT WE- NEED TO BE MOVING
AWAY FROM SINGLE USE OF ALL
FORMS INCLUDING. THOSE ITEMS
THAT ARE IMPOSSIBLE- THAT BEING
SAID. I HAVE SIGNIFICANTLY LESS
OF A PROBLEM WITH AN ITEM IF IT
REALLY IS COMPOSED OF NOT THE
FAKE APOSTLE AND I MEAN I START
AND THAT'S SOMETHING WE REALLY
WORKED HARD TO WORK ON IT WE
ALSO WORKED HARD TO. GET REALLY
GOOD LANGUAGE IS ABOUT TO
RECYCLABILITY BECAUSE THERE'S A
LOT OF STUFF THE CLAIMS TO BE
RECYCLABLE IT'S NOT RIGHT THAT
IS NOT- BUT IN GENERAL WE ALL
KNOW THAT. AS GOOD AS- YOU KNOW
RECYCLING IS BETTER COMPOSED AS
BETTER IF COMPOSING BETTER THAN
RECYCLING. WASTE REDUCTION IS
REALLY DIFFICULT. SOURCE
REDUCTION IS REALLY THE CALL AND
I THINK THAT'S AT THE HEART OF
THE OPPOSITION'S CONCERNS- YOU
KNOW I THINK THE BILL IS
REASONABLE BUT I DO APPRECIATE
THE- THAT THE POLICING THAT GUY
IS QUITE FRANKLY GOING ON THE
PART OF THE OPPOSITION BECAUSE
IN THE END OF THE DAY WE'RE
GONNA NEED. I'VE WE NEED THEM-
AS AS IS VERY SINISTER GROUPS
TRY TO GET. EXEMPTIONS ARE ONE
OFFS ARE LITTLE CHANGED SB FIFTY
FOUR. WHICH I THINK ARE GOING TO
DEFEAT ITS PURPOSE AND SO- YOU
KNOW I'M COMFORTABLE OR THIS
BILL AS- BUT I TOTALLY
APPRECIATE. THE COMMENTS OF THE
OPPOSITION- AND- AND WELCOME
THEIR CONTINUED PARTICIPATION
ALLEN THIS BILL BUT ALSO. ON ON
FUTURE. BILLS THAT IMPLICATE
FIFTY FOUR. BUT I BUT I'M HOW I
MEAN I AM NOT ASKING PEOPLE TO
VOTE FOR IT I I'M I'M I'M
COMFORTABLE TWENTY FOUR BUT IF
OTHERS. YOU KNOW WHAT I WANT TO
LAY OFF ABOUT NO I'M I'M- THE-
THAT'S WITH ME. YEAH SO. AREA
ALL THE.
OKAY ALL RIGHT THAT IS BEEN
MOVED I WOULD LIKE TO GIVE YOU A
CHANCE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU AND I
APPRECIATE THE APPRECIATE THE
DISCUSSION I'M PROUD MORE
COMFORTABLE TALKING ABOUT
RODENTICIDES AND OTHER THINGS
THAT I AM THIS ROBERT SINGLE
PAYER HEALTHCARE. IT'S A FAIR.
DID THAT YESTERDAY. BY THE PASS
ON THAT ONE- YOU KNOW WITH AND I
RESPECT THE OPPOSITION- AND I
THINK WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS GET
A CLARIFICATION- OUT THERE THERE
ARE GOING TO BE COMPANIES THAT
ARE GOING TO PRODUCE WHAT THE-
OBVIOUSLY WE ALL WANT TO REDUCE
SOURCE SOURCE. POLLUTION WE WELL
WHEN THEY DO THAT RIGHT THERE
WILL ALWAYS BE A NEED FOR SOME
PRODUCTS OUT THERE AND WE WANT
TO BE SURE THAT THEY ARE. GOOD
PRODUCTS AND REASONABLE
PRODUCTS- AND SO. THE OPPOSITION
SAID YOU KNOW BECAUSE WE'VE YOUR
SB FIFTY FOUR IS ON A SWIFT
IMPLEMENTATION PATH- I
APPRECIATE THAT AND THAT
ACTUALLY BAGS. THIS LEGISLATION
SO THAT WE CAN MAKE WHAT WE
BELIEVE WITH THE CURRENT WHAT A
CORRECTION- THE INTENT- OF THIS
OF SB FIFTY FOUR SO- SOMETIMES I
THINK ONCE THINGS ARE IN
REGULATION THAT'S A WHOLE LOT
HARDER TO MOVE THEM- SO I THINK
THIS BILL ACTUALLY GUIDES- THE
INTENT OF THE REGULATION A
LITTLE BIT BETTER. AND IN THE
LONG RUN IS BETTER IS BETTER
POLICY SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR ABOUT. THANK YOU THINK IS
OUR- SOME OF MY CENTER DOLLY A
SEARCH OF HIS COLOR. AB FOURTEEN
EIGHTY NINE THE MOTION IS TO
PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
SENATORS ALLEN. AYE ALLEN AYE
DALY. KELLY I GONZALEZ. HER
TADO. HER TADO AYE MENJIVAR.
MENJIVAR I WIN. WHEN I SKINNER.
FIVE SKINNER HI. THANK YOU THANK
YOU RICHARD THANK YOU ALL RIGHT
I THANK YOU SO MUCH EVERYONE
LET'S- LET'S LET'S LOOK AT THE
CALLS AND GO THROUGH EVERYTHING
LET'S FIRST ENTERTAIN A MOTION
FOR THE CONSENT CALENDAR- SO
MOVED BY CENTER DOLLY AS
EXCERPTED CORAL. SENATORS ALLEN
HI ALAN I DALI. DALI I.
GONZALEZ. HER TADO. HER TADO I
MENTOR OUR- IMAGE OF OUR AYE
WIN. WIN AYE SKINNER. HI SKINNER
HI. ALL RIGHT- THANK YOU I LOVE
TO ENTERTAIN A MOTION FOR IDEA
OCCURS AB ELEVEN FIFTY NINE.
OKAY ELEVEN FIFTY NINE THE
MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AS AMENDED
AND RE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
NATURAL RESOURCES I THINK WE
NEED A MOTION IS NOT ONE TO MOVE
THE BILL. OF HIS AGUIAR-CURRY IS
ELEVEN FIFTY NINE. YOU HAVE
MOVED BY CENTER HER TADO. AS A
TWO PIECE KALRA OKAY SENATORS
ALAN HI ALAN I DOLLY. DALY AYE
GONZALEZ. HER TADO. HER TADO AYE
MENJIVAR AYE. MENJIVAR AYE WIN.
WHEN I SKINNER. SKINNER HI. AT
SIX ZERO WILL LEAVE IT OPEN FOR
CENTER GONZALEZ THEM OUT ON.
LET'S GO TO- THE- DIRECT HYUNDAI
BE TEN FORTY TWO. AB TEN FORTY
TO THE MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
AGRICULTURE SHARE VOTING ON A
VICE CHAIR VOTING NO GONZALEZ.
WHEN NOW SKINNER ALL RIGHT
SKINNER NINE. OKAY THAT'S THREE
TWO WILL LEAVE IT OPEN FOR
CENTER GONZALEZ- AB TEN FIFTY
NINE FRIEDMAN. AB TEN FIFTY NINE
THE MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. SHARE
VOTING ON A VICE CHAIR VOTING ON
A GONZALEZ MENJIVAR MANY OF OUR
AYE NGUYEN. SKINNER RIGHT
SKINNER ONLINE. OKAY FIVE ZERO
WE WILL BE THAT OPEN FOR SENATE
AND SALAS I AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
TWO FRIEDMAN. AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
TO THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED AS
AMENDED AND RE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
AND WATER CHAIR VOTING I THOUGHT
I'D SHARE VOTING NO. MENJIVAR
MENJIVAR I WENT. WHEN OKAY WE
CAN CLOSE THE ROLE IN ITEM FIVE.
THAT'S A FORTY TWO. WITH ONE
ABSTENTION. I WAS GOING TO EXPEL
. AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE GABRIEL.
AB THIRTEEN OH FIVE THE MOTION
IS DO YOU PASS AS AMENDED AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
JUDICIARY. CHAIR VOTING I DALI.
DALI KNOWN GONZALEZ. MENJIVAR
MENJIVAR I WENT. WHEN NO. ALL
RIGHT THAT'S FOR TO LEAVE IT
OPEN FOR A MINUTE AND SALAS. I
SCHIAVO- YOU BEFORE TWO POINT
THREE. AB FOURTEEN TWENTY THREE
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
AND RE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SENATORS-
WHICH SORRY CHAIR VOTING I VICE
YOU'RE VOTING AYE GONZALEZ.
MENJIVAR MENJIVAR I WENT. THAT'S
FIVE ZERO WILL LEAVE THAT OPEN
FOR MEANING AND SALAS- CENTER AS
A MEMBER WOODS AB FOURTEEN
EIGHTY NINE OKAY CENTER GONZALEZ
IS NOT HERE YET. I THINK
OTHERWISE WE'RE JUST WAITING FOR
HER SO I WILL. I WILL GIVE
RECALL THANK YOU SO MUCH MR
MEISTER. PRITCHETT. I.
ALL RIGHT LET'S IT LIFT THE
CALLS LET'S START WITH THE
CONSENT CALENDAR. CONSENT
CALENDAR GONZALEZ GONZALEZ HI.
LET'S DO THIS CLOSE AT SEVEN
ZERO AGUIAR-CURRY ALLEN FIFTY
NINE AB ELEVEN FIFTY NINE MOTION
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
CHAIR VOTING ON A VICE CHAIR
VOTING AYE GONZALEZ SALAS I
SEVEN ZERO SEVEN ZERO THAT'S THE
CLOSER ON THAT- AMERICAN HINES
AB TEN FORTY TWO AB TEN FORTY TO
THE MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
AGRICULTURE. CHAIR VOTING ONLINE
VICE CHAIR VOTING NO GONZALEZ
AND SALAS. FOUR TWO THAT'S FORTY
THAT'S OUT LET'S NOW GO TO THE
NEXT SENTIMENTS FRIEDMAN AB TEN
FIFTY NINE ET TEN FIFTY NINE THE
MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS PROFESSIONS AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHARE
VOTING ONLINE VICE CHAIR VOTING
AYE GONZALEZ. THOSE ARE ALL
RIGHT THAT IS SIX TWO ZERO WITH
ONE ABSTENTION IT'S OUT FRIEDMAN
AB THIRTEEN TWENTY TWO AB
THIRTEEN TWENTY TO THE MOTION IS
DO YOU PASS AS AMENDED AND RE
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER- SO
THAT ONE'S DOES. OKAY APOLOGIES-
GABRIEL'S THIRTEEN OH FIVE HE AB
THIRTEEN OH FIVE DO PASSED AS
AMENDED AND RE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY. CHAIR
VOTING EYEING BY SHARE VOTING NO
GONZALEZ. AND SALAS HI- THAT'S
OUT THAT IS A FIVE TO VOTE. ALL
RIGHT NOW WILL GO TO- IF YOU ARE
SHOWS ON AB FOURTEEN TWENTY
THREE EIGHTY FOURTEEN TWENTY
THREE THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED
AS AMENDED AND RE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE CHAIR VOTING I. VICE
CHAIR VOTING I CAN SALAS. INCELS
I GONZALEZ IS AYE THAT IS NOW A
SIX TWO ZERO WITH ONE
ABSTENTION. FINALLY AB FORTY
NINE WOULD AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY
NINE MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AND
RE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS CHAIR VOTING
ONLINE VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE
GONZALEZ. SALAS I SEVEN ZERO OUT
. THE SEVEN ZERO OKAY THANK YOU
WILL WILL- DURING THE MEETING
WILL BE BACK FOR MORE. EQ FIND
NEXT WEEK IT'S GOING TO BE A
MORNING HEARING AT NINE THIRTY.
AS OPPOSED TO NINE NINE THIRTY-
THE DAY AFTER FOR THE JULY.
THANK YOU.