ALL RIGHT THE SENATE COMMITTEE
BEGIN IN SIXTY SECONDS MOST
LIKELY START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE
AS WELL.
ALL RIGHT THE SENATE COMMITTEE
ON PUBLIC SAFETY WILL COME TO
ORDER GOOD MORNING THE SENATE
CONTINUES WELCOME PUBLIC IN PART
OR IN PERSON AND VIA
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE- FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY'S
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
877-226-8160 THREE AND THE
ACCESS CODE IS ONE SIX ONE
EIGHTY FIFTY ONE. WE ARE HOLDING
OUR SOME COULD WALMART COMMITTEE
SLASH SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING- HERE
IN TWENTY TWO HUNDRED AND-
STREET BUILDING I ASK ALL
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE BE
PRESENT IN ROOM TWENTY TWO
HUNDRED SO WE CAN ESTABLISH A
QUORUM AND BEGIN OUR HEARING. WE
HAVE TWENTY SIX BILLS ON TODAY'S
AGENDA AND SIX OUR AND
CONSENSUS- CHANGE IT SEVEN ON
SEVEN ON CONSENT- WE HAVE A FULL
AGENDA SO WE WILL BE LIMITING
THE TIME ON- FOR THOSE THAT ARE
TRYING TO CALL INTO TEN MINUTES-
THIS IS THE ORDER WHICH WE'RE
GOING TO START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE
I DO JUST WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THAT
TODAY IT'S A LITTLE BIT
DIFFERENT ROOM TO START AS FIRST
COME FIRST SERVE THOSE THAT CAME
FIRST SIDS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ QUIRK-SILVA SANTIAGO
GIPSON ON BEHALF OF- TEACHING
AND- BONTA. SO THAT'S THE ORDER-
WE WILL HAVE THE VERY FIRST
INDIVIDUAL COME AND SPEAK-
SPECIFICALLY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
PRESENT YOUR BILL. AB FOUR SEVEN
FOR THE FLOOR IS YOURS. WHAT I
DO WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THAT WE
ALLOW TWO MINUTES FOR LEAD
WITNESSES YOU GUYS CAN ALL TELL
US HOW MANY WITNESSES YOU HAVE
IF IT'S ONE TWO OR ZERO- FOR
THOSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO MAKE ME
TOO COMMENTS- AND HAVE SEEN OUR
PREVIOUS. PUBLIC SAFETY MEETINGS
I LIKE TO GO THROUGH THIS VERY
VERY QUICKLY NAME ORG AND THAT
YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE- OTHER
THAN THAT YOU CAN BEGIN OKAY.
THANK YOU GOOD MORNING TURN
SENATORS AS CHAIR OF THE MONEY
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE I'M PLEASED
TO PRESENT A. B. FOUR SEVEN FOR
A BILL REQUIRING DISTRICT THE
STATE THREAT ASSESSMENT CENTER.
AT THE CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF
EMERGENCY SERVICES TO SUPPORT
STATE AND LOCAL FEDERAL TASK
FORCES AS YOU KNOW TRANSNATIONAL
ORGANISED CRIMINAL ORGANIZATIONS
ARE SUPPLYING THE DRUGS THAT ARE
ADDICTING AND KILLING OUR
CHILDREN. AS PART OF THE OVERALL
STRATEGY TO COMBAT IN THE
ILLEGAL OPIOID CRISIS WE MUST
DISTRICT THESE NETWORKS OF
CRIMINALS AND GET. DRUGS OFF OUR
STREETS IT IS CRITICAL THAT WE
DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO PROTECT
OUR STATE FROM THREATS TO OUR
PUBLIC HEALTH. THIS BILL ALSO
COMPLEMENT THE GOVERNMENT
GOVERNOR'S MASTER PLAN FOR
TACKLING THE FENTANYL AN OPIATE
CRISIS WHICH INCLUDES THIRTY
MILLION TO EXPAND THE CALIFORNIA
NATIONAL GUARD WORK. TO PREVENT
DRUG TRAFFICKING AND FIFTEEN
MILLION OVER THE NEXT TWO YEARS
TO ESTABLISH AND OPERATE THE
FENNEL ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM
WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE. TO COMBAT MANUFACTURING
DISTRIBUTION AND TRAFFICKING.
ADDITIONALLY THIS BILL ALSO
STRENGTHENED THAT MISSION OF
RECENTLY ANNOUNCED BY THE
GOVERNOR IN SAN FRANCISCO TO
STOP WAS A PARTNERSHIP. BETWEEN
THE CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROL
THE CALIFORNIA NATIONAL GUARD
THE SAN FRANCISCO POLICE
DEPARTMENT AND THE SAN FRANCISCO
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE. TO
COMBAT DRUG TRAFFICKING FOR ALL
THESE REASONS ARE SPECTACLES FOR
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU DO WE HAVE
ANY MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE OR-
ANY WITNESSES. NONE OKAY SEEING
NO WITNESSES- HERE IN SUPPORT DO
WE HAVE ANY ME TO. GOOD MORNING
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS CARE ROSS ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BURBANK IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU ANYBODY ELSE.
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO
OPPOSITION. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES
AND WE WILL TIME YOU. CAN GET.
BETTER KRAMER MATTER ON BEHALF
OF ACLU CALIFORNIA ACTION AND
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. AB FOUR
SEVENTY FOUR FURTHER ENTRENCHES
THE WORK OF THE FUSION CENTER
KNOWN AS THE STATE THREAT
ASSESSMENT CENTER OR STOCK. IN
WAYS THAT EXACERBATE THE HARMS
OF FUSION CENTERS. FUSION
CENTERS FUNCTION LIKE GOVERNMENT
RUN DATA BROKERS ENABLING
PROBLEMATIC SURVEILLANCE AND
FACILITATING THE D. INTEREST
AIRING OF PEOPLE'S DATA. WITHOUT
OF STATE ENFORCE THE THIRTIES
WELL ALSO EXACERBATING HARMFUL
POLICING PRACTICES. FUSION
CENTERS ARE ALSO SUSCEPTIBLE TO
ABUSE AND UNDERMINE THE RIGHTS
AND SAFETY OF COMMUNITY MEMBERS
INCLUDING LABELING PRO CHOICE
ACTIVISTS AS VIOLENT EXTREMISTS.
UNFORTUNATELY AB FOR SEVENTY
FOUR BUILT ON THIS PROBLEMATIC
THREE MINUTE FUSION CENTERS
INCLUDING THE TARGETING A
PARTICULAR COMMUNITIES. THE
BILL'S FINAL LEGISLATIVE FINDING
BATTLES OPIOID DISTRIBUTION WITH
IMMIGRATION AND THEFT OF
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY SINGLED
OUT PEOPLE FROM A PARTICULAR
COUNTRY AND USING HEATER HEATED
RHETORIC THREATENS TO THIRD
FURTHER EXACERBATE IMPROPER
TARGETING BASED ON NATIONALITY
OR FAMILY ANCESTRY. AB FOUR
SEVENTY FOUR HAS OTHER PROBLEMS
AS WELL. OPERATIVE LANGUAGE
MANDATE STOCK TO TAKE ACTIONS
AGAINST UNSPECIFIED CRIMINAL
ORGANIZATIONS WHILE PROVIDING NO
BASIS FOR ASSUMING THAT THESE
UNSPECIFIED ORGANIZATIONS
BECAUSE THE PROBLEMS THE BILL
HOPES TO REMEDY. NOR PROVIDE ANY
METRICS FOR GUIDELINES TO
ESTABLISH. WHAT SUCCESS LOOKS
LIKE IN THIS ENDEAVOR. RATHER
THAN A PRIEST THE DIM CAUSES OF
OPIOID. THE FUND NOT CRY. OR
PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR PROVEN LAW
ENFORCEMENT APPROACHES TO
CURTAILING THE DEMAND FOR THESE
DRUGS. THE BILL AS SOON AS THAT
TRANSNATIONAL CRIMINAL
ORGANIZATIONS ARE THE CAUSES FOR
THESE CRISIS AND FURTHER
ENTRENCHES THE MISGUIDED
ASSUMPTIONS THAT WE CAN POLICE
AND CRIMINALIZE OUR WAY OUT OF
OUR DRUG PROBLEMS. WE'VE TRIED
THIS BEFORE WITH THE FAILED WAR
ON DRUGS AND SEEN THE
DEVASTATING CONSEQUENCES ON
PEOPLE'S LIVES. HOW IT HARMS
COMMUNITIES MOST IMPACTED BY
DRUG ADDICTION WITHOUT
ADDRESSING THE PUBLIC HEALTH
ISSUES THESE LONGTIME. VENTURES
OFFICE DID IT NEXT WEEK- YOU
HAVE MAX TWO MINUTES HI I'LL BE
QUICK- GOOD MORNING TRACY
ROSENBERG FROM OPEN PRIVACY WE
ARE ALSO OPPOSED TO AB FOUR
SEVEN FOUR THIS BILL IS UNCLEAR
AND A MUDDLED. COMMANDED TO DO
THEY THING ABOUT MEXICAN
TRANSNATIONAL DRUG RINGS THE
RECORD OF UNCONSTITUTIONAL
POLICING AND CALIFORNIA'S FUSION
CENTERS IN THE PURSUIT OF
TERRORISM SHOULD MAKE US
HESITATE TO GIVE OUT MUDDLED
MANDATES. AS FAR BACK AS TWENTY
TWELVE SENATE OVERSIGHT
COMMITTEE SAID THE MAJORITY OF
THE REPORTS THE FUSION CENTERS
HAVE PRODUCED HAD NO CONNECTION
TO TERRORISM OUT ALL. AND THAT
THE REPORTS WERE LOW QUALITY AND
OFTEN NOT ABOUT ACTIVITY THAT
WAS IN FACT. ILLEGAL MORE
RECENTLY THE BLUE X. DATA
REVEALED THAT CAN OCCUR NOR
CAL'S FUSION CENTER HAD HAD
INTERPRETED COUNTERTERRORISM
INTELLIGENCE ASCENDING LISTS OF
FIRST AMENDMENT PROTEST
FOLLOWING. THE DEATH OF GEORGE
FLOYD INCLUDING ONE CALLED THE
SF KIDS PEACE MARCH. TO FOURTEEN
THOUSAND COPS TWICE DAILY WITH
THE TAGLINE. THESE EVENTS
INVOLVE CRIMINAL ACTIVITIES SUCH
AS LOOTING VANDALISM AND THREATS
OF VIOLENCE THE BILL'S VAGUENESS
AND LACK OF CLARITY IS A- RECIPE
FOR MISSION CREEP AND IT'S
DANGEROUS. WE ALREADY HAVE THE
DEA AND HIGH INTENSITY DRUG
TRAFFICKING AREAS ALL OVER THE
STATE WHOSE JOB IS BREAKING UP.
DRUG TRAFFICKING. AND A GROWING
EXTREMISM AND DOMESTIC TERRORISM
PROBLEM THAT WE SHOULD PAY
ATTENTION TO. PLEASE VOTE. THANK
YOU ANY OTHER ME TOO IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE STATE YOUR
NAME YOUR ORGAN THAT YOU POSE.
WELL ANY CONCERNS ABOUT PUBLIC
DEFENDER'S OFFICE OPPOSITION.
SANATANA SAN CASCIANO AND BEHALF
OF COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE WE OPPOSE.
PUBLIC VIEWS ON BEHALF OF THE
UNDERGROUND SCHOLARS INITIATIVE
AT UC BERKELEY- WEEKLY OPPOSED.
RAYMOND JONES ON BEHALF OF THE
JURY BE ON MARS FELLOWSHIP AND
WE OPPOSE. ARTIST Y. ON BEHALF
OF THE J. BEYOND BARS FELLOWSHIP
WE OPPOSE. THANK YOU ANYBODY
ELSE. ALL RIGHT MODERATOR CAN
YOU PRINT THE FIRST INDIVIDUAL
WAITING TO TELL TESTIFIED VIA
TELECONFERENCE. FOR SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION FOR EIGHTY FOURTH
FLOOR PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO
IN TELEPHONE KEYPAD. WE WILL GO
TO THE- LINE NUMBER THIRTEEN. HI
DADDY WHICH IS IMPACTING
OPPOSITION AT EIGHTY FOURTH AND
FOURTH. ONE MOMENT FOR NEXT
COMMON. WE'RE GOING TO LINE
NUMBER SIXTEEN. IF THE **** OF
MASS OF THE CITY OF BAKERSFIELD
IN SUPPORT. MOVOTO LINE. TWENTY
SEVEN. FINALLY THIRTY TWENTY
HALF OF YOUNG WOMAN FREEDOM
CENTER IN OPPOSITION. I WILL GO
TO LINE TWENTY SIX. HELLO MY
NAME IS NOT ON THE MARKET OUT OF
CALLING ON BEHALF OF LEGAL
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS WITH
CHILDREN IN OPPOSITION THANK YOU
. I'M SURE WE HAVE NO FURTHER
SUPPORT OPPOSITION THANK YOU
WILL MOVE THE CONVERSATION TO
COMMITTEE MEMBERS SAYING NONE
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE YES-
RESPECT AS RIVAL THANK THANK
YOU- WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO WAIT
FOR MOTION BUT I APPRECIATE YOUR
PRESENTATION THANK FOR MUCH
PRESSURE THANK YOU. OUR NEXT
SPEAKER IS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
QUIRK-SILVA. ASSEMBLY MEMBER YOU
ARE PRESENTING GIVE ME TWO
SECONDS. WHERE IS THE FIRST. AB
FOUR FIVE FIVE YES GOOD MORNING
MADAM CHAIR AB FOUR FIVE FIVE
AUTHORIZES COURTS TO TEMPORARILY
TEMPORARILY RESTRICT FIREARM
OWNERSHIP FROM DEFENDANTS IN
MENTAL HEALTH DIVERSION. IF THE
PROSECUTION CAN PROVIDE PROOF
WITH CLEAR AND CONVINCING
EVIDENCE THAT THE DEFENDANT IS A
DANGER TO THEMSELVES OR OTHERS
THE COURT CAN ORDER THE
PROHIBITION UNDER UNTIL
DIVERSION IS SUCCESSFULLY
COMPLETED IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN
CALIFORNIA PENAL CODE ONE
THOUSAND ONE POINT THIRTY SIX
ESTABLISH THE STATE'S MENTAL
HEALTH DIVERSION PROGRAM. MENTAL
HEALTH DIVERSION ALLOWS
INDIVIDUALS WITH DIAGNOSED
MENTAL HEALTH DISORDERS TO
PARTICIPATE IN A MENTAL HEALTH
TREATMENT PROGRAM FOR UP TO TWO
YEARS IN LIEU OF CRIMINAL
PROSECUTION. CALIFORNIA HAS LONG
IMPOSED GUN RESTRICTIONS ON
INDIVIDUALS CONVICTED OF
FELONIES AND CERTAIN MISDEMEANOR
CRIMES. I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR
I UNDERSTAND THE VAST NUMBER OF
PEOPLE WHO SUFFER FROM MENTAL
ILLNESS DO NOT ACT OUT VIOLENTLY
OR COMMIT CRIMES. HOWEVER
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE BEEN
CHARGED WITH SPECIFIED CRIMINAL
OFFENSES AND CHOOSE TO
PARTICIPATE IN MENTAL HEALTH
DIVERSION PROGRAMS SHOULD ADHERE
TO GUN RESTRICTIONS WELL IN THE
PROGRAM. OUR STAFF WHAT THE
SERVICES ASSISTANCE TO THE
COMMITTEE CONSULTANT HAVE BEEN
WORKING WITH THE OPPOSITION. WE
ARE COMMITTED TO WORKING OUT A
FINAL DETAIL IN ORDER TO MAKE
SURE THE BILL IS CONSTITUTIONAL
AS WELL AS CONSISTENT WITH OTHER
GUN PROHIBITIONS WITH US TODAY
IN SUPPORT OF AB FOUR FIFTY
FIVE. IS MISCONSTRUING OF THIS
OF STONE ADVOCACY REPRESENTING
THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION THE
SPONSORS FOR THIS BILL THANK YOU
FOR YOUR ONLY WITNESS. YES OKAY
YOU WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES THANK
YOU CHAIR- AND MEMBERS ON BEHALF
THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION KIM STONE
OF STONE ADVOCACY THANK THE
AUTHOR. AND HER- HER CO AUTHOR
FOR OFFERING THE BILL- THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S ASSOCIATION
DOES RECOGNIZE THAT. WHILE ON
MENTAL HEALTH DIVERSION- IT IS
APPROPRIATE FOR INDIVIDUALS TO-
BE PROHIBITED FROM OWNING GUNS
THAT THEY IF THEY HAD- PLED
GUILTY OR BEEN CONVICTED OF
THAT. OF THAT ACTION WOULD HAVE
SUFFERED A FIREARM CONSEQUENCE
WE DO ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT THE
VAST MAJORITY OF PEOPLE WITH
MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES ARE ARE NON
VIOLENCE BUT THIS IS SOMEBODY
WHO HAS CONDUCTED AN ACTION
THAT. LED THEM TO BE ARRESTED
FOR THAT ACTIVITY WE ALSO
SUPPORT DIVERSION AS BOTH
HELPING THE INDIVIDUAL- AND LEAD
TO ADDITIONAL COMMUNITY SAFETY
AND WE SUPPORT COMMONSENSE. GUN
RESTRICTIONS WE HAVE HAD-
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE PUBLIC
DEFENDER'S OFFICE ABOUT AN
ADDITIONAL CHANGE THAT THEY SEEK
GOING FORWARD AND OUR-
TENTATIVELY OPTIMISTIC THAT WE
WILL REACH RESOLUTION WITH THEM
ABOUT THAT ISSUE. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH- DRIVE OUT. THANK YOU DO WE
. HAVE ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT. NAME ORG AND I USE. BUT
REMEMBER STAND FULL ON A LOT
ANGELES JUST ATTORNEY'S IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE.
OKAY GOING TO OPPOSITION.
MORNING LESLIE CALDWELL HOUSTON
FOR THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION- AS
CURRENTLY AMENDED AND WE- THANK
THE AUTHOR FOR ALL THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE AGREED TO
THUS FAR- AS CURRENTLY AMENDED
AB FOUR FIFTY FIVE- PROCREATE
LEE LET'S A JUDGE DECIDE AFTER
HEARING EVIDENCE. WHETHER IT'S
NECESSARY TO DENY INDIVIDUALS ON
MENTAL HEALTH DIVERSION THEIR
RIGHTS TO GUN OWNERSHIP. ARE
REQUESTED AMENDMENT WOULD LET
JUDGES DECIDE ALSO WHETHER TO
RESTORE THAT RIGHT TO AN
INDIVIDUAL WHO DID NOT COMPLETE
MENTAL HEALTH PROBATION IN A
PROCESS SIMILAR TO THE PROCEDURE
FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE TAKEN
HAVE BEEN TAKEN INTO CUSTODY. AS
A DANGER TO SELF OR OTHERS OR
CERTIFIED FOR INTENSIVE
TREATMENT AND THEREFORE LOST
THEIR GUN OWNERSHIP RIGHTS THIS
IS AN EQUAL PROTECTION CLAUSE
ISSUE UNDER THE US CONSTITUTION
BECAUSE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
SIMILARLY SITUATED. ARE BEING
TREATED DIFFERENTLY BY THE STATE
WE URGE YOUR NO VOTE UNLESS
AMENDED THANK YOU- ANY OTHER
OPPOSITION WITNESSES THING NON
MODERATOR WE WOULD YOU PROP THE
FIRST INDIVIDUAL. FOR SUPPORT
OPPOSITE FOR AB FIFTY FIVE PRESS
. ONE TO ZERO. AND I'M SURE WE
ALL KNOW SUPPORTER OPPOSITION
THANK YOU- WILL MOVE THE
CONVERSATION TO MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE NO COMMENT- WOULD YOU
LIKE CLOSE. ASSEMBLY THAT WILL
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
OPPOSITION AND- OUR GOAL HERE
LIKE MANY OF THESE TYPES OF
BILLS IS. TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
HAVE A SAFE ENVIRONMENT FOR. OUR
PUBLIC THANK YOU AND WITH THAT
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I
APPRECIATE IT- THE WE WILL DO
THE MOTION AFTERWARDS BUT I DO
APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENTATION
THANK YOU THANK YOU. OUR NEXT
PRESENTER IS ASSEMBLYMEMBER
SANTIAGO AB NINE FIVE EIGHT
FIRST AND THEN FOLLOWED BY A B.
TWELVE SIXTY ONE.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU MENTOR FOR
SOME I THINK CHAIRED THE
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK- THIS
BILL WILL STRENGTHEN VISITATION
RIGHTS FOR FAMILY MEMBERS OF
INCARCERATED PEOPLE BY RESTORING
VISITING RIGHT- VISITING IS A
RIGHT AND ESTABLISH A MINIMUM OF
THREE DAYS. OFFER VISITATIONS.
IN RESPECT TO THE COMMITTEE I
WILL BE BRIEF HELLO MY TO
PRESENTERS TO SPEAK- THANKS.
THANK YOU WILL THE FIRST WITNESS
SPEAK YOU WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES
YOU WILL BE TIME. YOUR TIME HAS
BEGUN. MY NAME'S KEN HARTMAN I'M
THE ADVOCACY DIRECTOR FOR THE
TRANSFER OF IN PRISON A WORK
GROUP I SERVE THIRTY EIGHT
CONTINUOUS YEARS CALIFORNIA
PRISON SYSTEM I WAS THERE WHEN
VISITS FOR A RIGHT AND IT WAS
THERE WHEN THE RIGHT WAS TAKEN
AWAY. I FELT THE DIFFERENCE WAS
MOSTLY AND HOW HARD BECAME TO
GET A VISIT FROM YOUR MOM OR
YOUR WIFE FOR YOUR CHILD IT
BECAME PAINFUL I WATCHED
FAMILIES DISINTEGRATE UNDER THE
WEIGHT OF THE PRECARIOUSNESS AND
CAPRICIOUS NOUS. OF HOW BUSY WAS
TERMINATED CLOSE DELAYED AFTER
THE RIGHT WAS TAKEN AWAY THE
MONTHS OF WAITING ON APPROVALS
THE CONSTANT HARASSMENT. THE
PEOPLE WHO WERE HURT MOST FOR
OUR CHILDREN. MY RELATIONSHIP
WITH MY DAUGHTER WAS CONTINGENT
ON VISITING- WHICH- WHICH WASN'T
ALWAYS ALLOWED TO RUN AND IT
WASN'T COMPELLED TO BY LAW AS IT
IS AND STILL. PRISON VISITING
ROOM TO CALIFORNIA'S NOT FAMILY
FRIENDLY. THE CURRENT SYSTEM
UNDERMINES CRITICAL CONNECTIONS
TO MAKE PRISONS SAFER IN SUPPORT
REENTRY IT PUNISHES THE FAMILIES
OF INCARCERATED PEOPLE. NOW
CALIFORNIA'S EMBARKED ON A GRAND
EXPERIMENT RUNNING PRISONS
CLOSER TO THE NORDIC MODEL. ONE
OF THE BEST PLACES TO START THIS
TRANSFORMATION WHICH I SUPPORT
WOULD BE IN THE VISITING ROOMS
MAKE THEM FAMILY FRIENDLY TRAIN
VISITING STAFF TO VIEW VISITORS
AS FELLOW CITIZENS NOT SUSPECTS
. MAKE VISITING A PRIORITY AS IT
IS IN NORWAY I'VE BEEN THERE
THREE TIMES AND I'VE TOWARD
THEIR PRISONS I SAW THE I SAW
THAT THERE PRISON VISITING
SYSTEM IS BASED ON MAKING IT AS
FAMILY FRIENDLY AND CHILD
FRIENDLY AS POSSIBLE. I THINK
WOULD BE ALTOGETHER HUMANE AND
COMPASSIONATE TO MAKE THE
VISITING PROCESS AND ARE
VISITING ROOMS WELCOMING TO OUR
CHILDREN. PLEASE SUPPORT THIS
BILL IT'S SIMPLY THE RIGHT THING
TO DO. THANK YOU NEXT WEEK- YOU
WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES AS WELL.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS LAWRENCE
****- I'M A POLICY FELLOW AT
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS
WITH CHILDREN. I'M ALSO SYSTEM
IMPACTED I DID SIXTEEN HALF
YEARS IN PRISON. AND I SUPPORT
AB NOT FAR AWAY BECAUSE I'M
IMPACTED AND I'M WELL AWARE OF
HOW THEY IMPACT ABSORBS. BY MY
FRIENDS AND MY FAMILY WHO ARE
INSTANCE IN A SENSE THE TIME
ALONG WITH ME. I BELIEVE THE
RIGHT TO MAINTAIN FACILITATE
NURTURE AND RESTORE FAMILY
CONNECTIONS ELEVATES THE BELIEVE
A MESSAGE THAT WE TRULY VALUE
PUBLIC SAFETY OF OUR COMMUNITIES
THE INSTITUTION OF FAMILY AND
FOR REHABILITATION. WHICH ALL OF
OUR KEY AND GO HAND IN HAND AND
REHABILITATION AND UNIMPEDED
ACCESS TO FAMILY SHOULD NOT BE
VIEWED AS A PRIVILEGE. THE TOOLS
AND MECHANISMS WE UTILIZE TO
ACCOMPLISH WITH THE TATIAN
SHOULD NEVER BE UTILIZED AS A
PUNISHMENT OR TAKEN AWAY WHEN AN
INDIVIDUAL FALTERS. FALLING
SHORT OF THE MARK ONLY MEAN ONE
NEEDS FOR THE WORK NOT THAT ONE
NO LONGER NEEDS ACCESS TO ONE OF
THE MOST IMPORTANT APPARATUSES.
CCR HAS TO FACILITATE
REHABILITATION WHICH IS
VISITING. WHEN INCARCERATED
INDIVIDUALS RECEIVE DISCIPLINARY
INFRACTIONS C. C. R. DOES NOT
RESPOND BY REMOVING THEM FROM
THE COLLEGE COURSES OR THEIR A
IN IN A PROGRAMS WHICH IS
INVALUABLE TO REHABILITATION. SO
WHY WOULD WE LOOK. AT THE RIGHT
TO VISIT IN THE SAME LIGHT. A
FAMILY STRUCTURE IN OUR
COMMUNITY. TIES IN WITH PUBLIC
SAFETY- WE HAVE KIDS STATE COURT
WHAT WITH THE LACK OF PARENTS IN
THE HOUSEHOLD IN. THE BEGIN TO
DEAL WITH TRAUMATIC ISSUES AND
IT SERVICES IN SCHOOLS A
SERVICES IN THEIR BEHAVIOR.
EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT DICTATES WHO
THEY BECOME AND HOW TO RESPOND
THEY ARE THEY DO WITH MENTAL
ISSUES THEY DEAL WITH EMOTIONAL
ISSUES. THEY HAVE PROBLEMS
BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS TO HAVE
PROBLEMS FOCUSING IN SCHOOL IN A
LOT OF THESE THINGS COULD BE
STOPPED IF THESE KIDS HAVE THEIR
PARENTS IN THEIR LIFE. I THINK
SOCIETY HAS THIS NOTION BECAUSE
YOU'RE CONVICTED OF A FELONY AND
YOUR CRIMINAL THAT YOUR LISTING
HUMANE AND THAT YOU HAVE NOTHING
WORTHY OR VALUABLE TO GIVE TO
ANYONE THAT'S OUTSIDE THE
STREET. BUT REHABILITATION IS
KEY. REHABILITATION IS KEY FOR
THOSE THAT YOU SEEN BACK TO THE
STREETS OF PUBLIC SAFETY IS
TRULY THE ISSUE. THEN WHY WE
WANT TO SEND ANYBODY BACK TO THE
STREETS WHO HAVE. BEEN TRULY
REHABILITATED THANK YOU CREATED.
ANY OTHER SPEAKERS IN SUPPORT
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME THAT YOU
SUPPORTING YOUR ORG. LESLIE
CALDWELL HOUSTON CALIFORNIA
PUBLIC DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION. IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. MORNING
MEMBERS FAITHFULLY WITH ASIAN.
IF JUSTICE OF THE HELL. WERE IN
SUPPORT. WE SHOULD IT. CANACCORD
ON ON BEHALF OF THE GREAT TRAIN
INSTEAD. AND MY PERSONAL
CAPACITY IS THAT DIRECTLY
IMPACTED FAMILY MEMBER IN
SUPPORT. MICHAEL MENDOZA WITH
THE ANTI RECIDIVISM COALITION IS
FROM SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ONLY
SEVEN OF IT AS LUIS. FOR ON
BEHALF OF A LANCER BOYS
MEDICALLY. ATTACHMENTS FOR
PROSECUTORS LINES OF
CALIFORNIANS SMARTEST OF
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. THANK YOU
. BUFFALO DESTA A BIGGER
SENTIMENT. SUPPORT THANK YOU.
EDUCATION ELEVATE CENTER IN
SUPPORT. SONYA THOMAS AND PASS
ONE NOW WITH COMMUNITIES UNITED
FOR START OF YOUTH JUSTICE PROUD
CO SPONSOR AND SUPPORT. PIANO
WHAT LEGAL SERVICES FOR PER WITH
CHILDREN IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. GOOD MORNING A LITTLE ON
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIANS FOR
SAFETY AND JUSTICE AND SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING KATIE DIXON ON
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA COALITION
FOR WOMEN PRISONERS IN SUPPORT.
HI GOOD MORNING ASPEN WITH ANTI
RECIDIVISM COALITION APART
BECAUSE SPONSORED SUPPORT THANK
YOU. GOOD MORNING ALEX DEALS
WITH UNDERGROUND INITIATIVE A UC
BERKELEY STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. ARTIST WHITE WITH
COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND SUPPORT
. GOOD MORNING RAVE ON JONES
HERE ON BEHALF OF COMMITTEES OUT
OF OR STARTED YOU JUSTICE WHERE
PRAGUE COSTA AND WE SUPPORT.
SUELO CAR WITH ORGANIZATION
COURAGE AND I SUPPORT. ARLENE
WAS SALAS FOR THE DREAM BEYOND
BARS. HELLO RIDOLFI WITH HE
WOULD BURN INSTITUTE IN SUPPORT
. THANK YOU MELENDEZ IS STILL
CAL ACTION IN SUPPORT. SIT THERE
CHANDLER ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU ANYBODY ELSE IN
SUPPORT. SEEING NONE IT WILL
MOVE TO OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
SEEING NONE MODERATOR WOULD YOU
PLEASE UP FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. WHAT THE POOR
OPPOSITION TO EIGHTY NINE FIFTY
EIGHT PRESS ZERO WE'LL GO TO
LINE TWENTY THREE. GOOD MORNING
CEMEX KIDDING I'M A DIRECT
IMPACT FAMILY IN STRONG SUPPORT
. LOCAL CLIENTS. THIRTY FOUR.
SENATE BANKING CHAIRMAN
EDUCATION AND I INFORMED. EIGHTY
NINE EIGHT. OVER TO TWENTY FIVE.
GOOD MORNING JIM WOOD BURKE- ON
BEHALF OF THE MEETING ON THAT IN
STRONG SUPPORT. WE'LL GO TO LINE
THIRTY EIGHT. CHRISTOPHER'S
MONTHS AGO BUT WESTERN CENTER ON
LAW AND POVERTY STRONG SUPPORT.
HELLO TO LINE THIRTY NINE. HELLO
MY NAME IS CHARACTERIZED IN ON
WITH A NEW WAY OF LIFE AND I AM
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF AB
598-959-1880 NINE FIFTY SORRY
THANK YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE
FORTY. IT BROUGHT WITH
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU. GO TO
LINE. SEVENTEEN HELLO A BRUNO WE
STARTED WITH THE CALIFORNIA
IMMIGRANT POLICY CENTER AND
STRONG WORK. WE'LL GO TO LINE
TWENTY SIX. HELLO GOOD MORNING
EVERYONE MY NAME IS TONY
MARGIELA FALLING ABOUT THE LEGAL
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS WITH
CHILDREN BOB BOTH MONSTERS AND
FOR OF AB NINE FIFTY EIGHT THANK
YOU. BECAUSE THE LINE. TWENTY
SEVEN. I LOVE THE MULTIPLE
PEOPLE QUICKLY ON THANK YOU. THE
MOMENT ONE MOMENT STEP ONE OF
THE FIRST AND QUEUING UP. W. I.
FIFTEEN. NICOLE WATERMAN ON
BEHALF OF THE CHILDREN'S
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT. I WILL
KNOW FOR THE SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION MANAGERS THANK YOU
I'D LIKE TO ESTABLISH QUORUM-
CHEMICAL ROLE PLEASE. BOB HERE
UP HERE- JOB OKAY BRADFORD.
SKINNER HERE WIENER. AS A CLEAR
HERE THANK YOU- WE MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE LIKE TO SPEAK AS
THE CENTERS. THANK YOU- GOING
TO. SUPPRESS MY PRE TO THE
AUTHOR FOR THIS AS YOUR WITNESS
SPOKEN IS USED BY THE WE KNOW
IMPORTANT VISITATION IS NOT ONLY
FOR THE FAMILIES MEAN THE
CHILDREN BEING DENIED THAT
ABILITY TO SEE THEIR LOVED ONES
BUT ALSO FOR THE- ABILITY FOR US
TO HAVE SUCCESSFUL RE ENTRY AND-
REDUCE RECIDIVISM SO. WHILE SOME
PEOPLE MAY NOT UNDERSTAND THE
VALUE OF THAT IT'S
EXTRAORDINARILY VALUABLE AND I
APPRECIATE THIS BILL WITH THAT
ON THE THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
TO LIKE CLOSE. LASSEN AB THANK
YOU WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
SKINNER. MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS WILL HOP ON HOP I
AM A TOWBOAT BRADFORD SKINNER HI
SKINNER AYE WIENER WIENER AYE.
THANK YOU THAT BILLS ON CALL US
MEMBER WHICH LIKE TO PRESENT
YOUR NEXT BILL AB TWELVE SIXTY
ONE YES MANAGER- PRINCIPLE WE
WILL TO WE WANT TO CLEAR STAN
PROCEDURES THE ANY ELIGIBLE
PERSON WHO. QUALIFY UNDER UV
SAYS HE SAID- OR T. V. WOULD BE
L. A. TO FEEDING CAL. I
CURRENTLY THAT IS NOT THE CASE
THAT WE WILL WITH- WITH- THE A
GAS GOING TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS
IS IMPLEMENTED ACROSS THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. IF THEY'RE
ELIGIBLE THEY SHOULD BE ABLE TO
HAVE A PATHWAY TOWARD
CITIZENSHIP. RESPECTFULLY ASK
RIVAL THANK YOU TO HAVE
WITNESSES. YES ONE ONE WITNESS
TO HOPE TO I PLEDGE TO WITNESSES
YOU WILL EACH HAVE TWO MINUTES-
THANK YOU. THE TERM EMBERS DAY
ALL ON BEHALF THE LAWSUIT CA
DISTRICT OFFICE. ANTI IMMIGRANT
CRIME IS RISING AT ALARMING
RATES IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
LAW ENFORCEMENT ROUTINELY.
ENCOUNTERS IMMIGRANTS TERRIFIED
TO REPORT CRIMES FILE FOR
PROTECTIVE ORDERS. OR THE
SERVER'S WITNESSES- OUT OF FEAR
OF DEPORTATION. THE CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SYSTEM DEPENDS ON ALL
MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY BEING
WILLING TO REPORT CRIMES
COOPERATE WITH INVESTIGATIONS
TESTIFIED IN COURT AND JOIN IN
EFFORTS TO PREVENT FUTURE
VIOLENCE WE CANNOT EXPECT.
PEOPLE TO COOPERATE WITH THE
GOVERNMENT THAT THEY DON'T TRUST
RESEARCH SHOWS THAT IMMIGRANT
COMMUNITIES ARE LESS LIKELY TO
CONTACT OR COOPERATE WITH LAW
ENFORCEMENT IF THEY'RE AFRAID.
THAT LAW ENFORCEMENT WILL
INVESTIGATE THEIR IMMIGRATION
STATUS OR THE IMMIGRATION STATUS
OF THEIR LOVED ONES. A MAJOR
TOOL AVAILABLE FOR TO LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO ENCOURAGE
UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS TO
COOPERATE WITH AUTHORITIES OR
THE U. T. M. S. B. SO PROGRAMS
WHICH PROVIDE A LEGAL PATHWAY
FOR NON CITIZENS. WHO REPORT
CRIMES. TO LAW ENFORCEMENT TO
STAY IN THE COUNTRY. THESE
PROGRAMS WERE DESIGNED A DUAL
PURPOSE OF PROTECTING NONCITIZEN
VICTIM WITNESSES. AND TO PROMOTE
. COOPERATION BETWEEN LAW
ENFORCEMENT AND THESE
COMMUNITIES FEDERAL LAW GRANTS
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES AND
PROSECUTORS SIGNIFICANT
DISCRETION TO DETERMINE WHO IS
ELIGIBLE TO RECEIVE. THESE VISAS
IN THEIR JURISDICTIONS AB TWELVE
SIXTY ONE WILL ESTABLISH FAIR
AND TRANSPARENT POLICIES FOR
THESE PROGRAMS BY CLARIFYING THE
EXISTING LAWS SURROUNDING THESE
VISA PROGRAMS. AB TWELVE SIXTY
ONE PROVIDES CLEAR DEFINITIONS
OF THE DIFFERENT TYPES OF VICTIM
WITNESS IS ELIGIBLE TO RECEIVE
THESE RESULTS. IT ALSO PROVIDES
GUIDANCE TO LAW ENFORCEMENT AND
PROSECUTORS ON THE REQUIREMENTS
AND FACTORS THAT ARE AND ARE NOT
REQUIRED FOR YOU T. OR S. VISA
TO BE ISSUED. LAW ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES AND PROSECUTORS WHO
FAILED TO CERTIFY VISA
APPLICATION. THANK YOU NEXT WEEK
OR TWO MINUTES WE DO TIME YOU
WENT A LITTLE OVER HIS OKAY.
HELLO AND THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH YOU
THIS MORNING HI MICHELLE CAREY A
DIRECTING ATTORNEY FROM THE LOS
ANGELES CENTER FOR LAW AND
JUSTICE. A NONPROFIT IN EAST LA
THAT PROVIDES FREE LEGAL
SERVICES TO LOW INCOME SURVIVORS
OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SEXUAL
ASSAULT AND HUMAN TRAFFICKING
INCLUDING REPRESENTATION ON
THEIR U. AND T. VISA PETITIONS.
WHAT CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN A
LEADER IN CREATING UNIFORMITY
AMONG YOU THE CERTIFICATIONS
THERE IS MORE WORK TO DO. IN MY
NEARLY TWENTY YEARS OF
EXPERIENCE REPRESENTING
UNDOCUMENTED CRIME VICTIMS I'VE
WORKED EXTENSIVELY WITH LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO OBTAIN U. VISA
CERTIFICATIONS. I'VE SEEN
SITUATIONS WHERE LAW ENFORCEMENT
FAILS TO UNDERSTAND WHO
QUALIFIES AS A VICTIM OR CREATES
REQUIREMENTS THAT GO FAR BEYOND
THE WORLD CONGRESS INTENDED FOR
THEM. SUCH AS DENYING A
CERTIFICATION REQUEST BASED ON
THE LEVEL OF HARM THE VICTIM
SUFFERED FOR THE INABILITY TO
PRODUCE A SPECIFIC FORM OF
IDENTIFICATION. I'VE ALSO SEEN
SITUATIONS WHERE A CHILD IS LEFT
OUT OF HER MOTHER'S PETITION
BECAUSE THE CERTIFICATION IS DOC
REVIEWED QUICKLY ENOUGH. MISSING
WHAT COULD OTHERWISE BE A LIFE
CHANGING OPPORTUNITY FOR THAT
YOUNG PERSON. THE ONLY CENTER
FOR LINE JUSTICES IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF AB TWELVE SIXTY ONE
BECAUSE IT PROVIDES ENHANCED
ACCESS AND EQUITY IN THE
CERTIFICATION PROCESS. THIS
HELPS LAW ENFORCEMENT DO THEIR
JOBS MORE EFFECTIVELY REDUCING
THE VERY REAL FEAR SO MANY
VICTIMS HAVE ABOUT COMMUNICATING
WITH THEM AND REPLACING THAT
FEAR WITH AN AVENUE FOR TRUST
CREATING A BRIDGE BETWEEN TWO
COMMUNITIES THAT NEED TO
COOPERATE BUT- SO OFTEN FAIL TO
DO SO. AB TWELVE SIXTY ONE ALSO
REDUCES BARRIERS AND INCREASES
SAFETY NOT JUST FOR VULNERABLE
IMMIGRANT VICTIMS BUT FOR ALL OF
US. OVER TWENTY YEARS HAVE
PASSED SINCE CONGRESS CREATED
THE U. N. TV. EVERYDAY VICTIMS
OF CRIME IN CALIFORNIA ARE STILL
UNFAIRLY DENIED THEIR RIGHT TO
APPLY WITHOUT AB TWELVE SIXTY
ONE THESE ON JUSTIN AISLES WILL
CONTINUE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FOR YOUR TIME TODAY AND FOR
ENSURING THAT ALL ELIGIBLE CRIME
VICTIMS IN CALIFORNIA ARE ABLE
TO ACCESS THE PROTECTIONS AND
REMEDIES. TO WHICH THEY ARE
ENTITLED THANK YOU. FOR THE THAT
ARE WHICH TO SPEAK SUPPORT
PLEASE LINE UP AND WE WILL QUICK
NAY ORGANIZE. THAT YOU SUPPORT
AGAIN WE WOULD LIKE TO MOVE
QUICKLY THROUGH THIS PROCESS.
GOOD MORNING MARTY CETRON BEHALF
THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU. THE BACHELOR POLICY CHIEF
OF THE ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE. LOOKING
TO OPPOSITION WITNESSES TO HAVE
ANY OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE.
SEEING NONE ANY OPPOSITION ME TO
SING NINE MODERATOR PROF THE
FIRST INDIVIDUAL PLEASE. BUT FOR
OPPOSITION TO AB PLUS SIXTY ONE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. MANAGER WE
HAVE NO SUPPORTER OPPOSITION
THANK YOU WILL TURN THE
CONVERSATION TO COMMITTEE
MEMBERS CENTER SKINNER. THANK
YOU AGAIN MOVE THE BILL. THANK
YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER TO LIKE
CLOSED AFFECT LASSEN IDLE THANK
YOU WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
SKINNER CAN WE CALL MOTIONS TO
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS WILL HARM
I. I SPOKE TO ABOUT BRADFORD.
ADVERTISING FIGHT SKINNER AYE
WIENER. WIENER ARE THANK YOU THE
BILL'S ON CALL APPRECIATE YOUR
TIME- ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON I
WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT AB TEN
EIGHTY NINE- HIS BILL FIRST AND
THEN- THE TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
TING THREE. AB TEN EIGHTY NINTH
. GOOD MORNING THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ABOUT HIM CHAIRED MEMBERS
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL. I JUST
WENT CRAZY ASSEMBLY BILL TEN
EIGHTY NINE WHICH SEEKS TO BAN
THE SALE OF THE PURCHASE THE
POSSESSION AND THE RECEIVING OF
A GHOST GUN TECHNOLOGY BY
LIMITING THE USE OF A THREE D.
PRINTER. AND COMPUTERIZE
NUMBERING CONTROL THE CNC MILL
MACHINE- TO LICENSE- GUNMEN OF
FACTORS IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA ASSEMBLY BILL TEN
EIGHTY NINE STRENGTHENS THE
LEGACY. OF UP THE ROOF A
PREVIOUS BILLS- THAT HAS GONE
THROUGH THE LEGISLATURE ASSEMBLY
BO ON TEN EIGHTY NINE- IS BEFORE
TODAY- WE ALSO BROUGHT ASSEMBLY
BILL- SIXTEEN TWENTY ONE IN TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY TWO WHICH BAN
GHOST GUNS AND IT THEIR KIDS.
ASSEMBLY BILL TEN EIGHT TEN A
STUDENT AT SYMBIO EIGHT SEVENTY
NINE WAS ALSO INTRODUCED IN TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN WHICH REQUIRES
A SALE OF OUR ARMED PRECURSOR
PARTS. TO BE POSSESS- AND TO BE
ALSO PROHIBITED BY VENDORS
CALIFORNIA. IS IN THE LEAD WHEN
IT COMES TO PREVENTING GUN
VIOLENCE YET PEOPLE ARE STILL
FINDING THE LOOPHOLES WITHIN THE
LAW- THIS BILL HERE TODAY UNTIL
EIGHTY NINE SEEKS TO CLOSE THAT
LOOPHOLE. THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO
ARE GAINING ACCESS TO HOMEMADE
UNTRACEABLE GUNS BY USING THREE
D. PRINTING- MIL PRESS MACHINES
THIS TECHNOLOGIES ALLOW SOMEONE
TO CREATE A SEMI AUTOMATIC
WEAPON. WITH A SERIAL NUMBER
WITH NO SERIAL NUMBER AND NO
BACKGROUND CHECKS NO WAITING
PERIOD- OR OTHER REGULATIONS- IT
IS ESSENTIAL THAT WE DO
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE CLOSE THIS GAP- IN THE
THREE D. PRINTER WORLD. THIS
BILL DOES NOT SEEK TO BAN AND I
WANT TO REPEAT DOES NOT SEEK TO
BAN- THREE D. PRINTER THIS BILL
TARGETS THREE D. PRINTERS. OF
GUNS BY THOSE WHO ARE ON LICENSE
TO DO SO JOINING ME TO PROVIDE
SUPPORTING. TESTIMONY WELL- OF
REPRESENTATIVE FROM DIFFERENT.
WHO WAS INTO ALL BRADY AS WELL
SO YOU HAVE TO. I DO OKAY TWO
MINUTES THANK YOU HI GOOD
MORNING MY ON BEHALF OF THE
GIVER LOS TO PREVENT GUN
VIOLENCE THE SPONSOR OF AB TEN
EIGHTY NINE. I WANT TO THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR HIS INSPIRING AND
UNWAVERING LEADERSHIP ON THIS
ISSUE I'M IN RECENT YEARS AND
ESPECIALLY SINCE THE START OF
THE PANDEMIC CALIFORNIA HAS
SUFFERED AN EXPLOSION IN THE
MARKET OF DIY OR DO IT YOURSELF
GO SCAN BUILD KITS. THAT ALLOW
PEOPLE TO EASILY ASSEMBLE THEIR
OWN FIREARMS WITHOUT ANY
BACKGROUND CHECK OR OTHER
PROTECTIONS THE GHOST GOT
INDUSTRY SOLD ITS GONE KIDS
PRODUCTS DIRECTLY IMMEDIATELY
AND OFTEN ANONYMOUSLY OVER THE
INTERNET TO BUYERS INCLUDING
CHILDREN AND TEENS. WHO NEVER
PASS A BACKGROUND CHECK OR GUN
SAFETY TESTS AND NEVER SHOWED ID
VERIFYING THEIR AGE OR IDENTITY.
OUR ORGANIZATION IS PROUD TO
HAVE PARTNERED WITH ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GIVES IN THIS COMMITTEE
THE L. A. IN THE LEGISLATURE. TO
INTRODUCE THE NATION'S FIRST
COMPREHENSIVE GHOST GUN REFORM
BILL BACK IN TWENTY SIXTEEN AS
WELL AS THE NATION'S STRONGEST
GOES GUN REFORM LEGISLATION LAST
YEAR. HOWEVER REALLY WE HAVE
ALSO SEEN SOME COMPANIES SEEK TO
CIRCUMVENT THESE NEW REFORMS BY
OPENLY SELLING AND MARKETING.
DIGITALLY PROGRAMMABLE MACHINES
INCLUDING GO SCAN PRINTING THREE
D. PRINTERS. THAT ENCOURAGE
ANALYZING MANUFACTURES TO
PRODUCE KEY FIREARM PARTS WITH
THE PRESS OF A BUTTON. THESE
COMPANIES ARE ENCOURAGING ON
MICE AND MANUFACTURES TO BREAK
THE LAW AND PRINT THEIR OWN
FIREARMS WITHOUT ANY BACKGROUND
CHECK OR SERIAL NUMBER. THIS
LEGISLATION WOULD BUILD ON
CALIFORNIA'S RECENT GHOST GUN
REFORMS AND STRENGTHEN OUR LAWS
TO PROACTIVELY STOP THESE
ABUSIVE AND DANGEROUS PRACTICES.
AND STOP THE SALE AND PURCHASE
OF GHOST GUNS MANUFACTURING
MACHINES. CALIFORNIA'S
LIMITATIONS ON THE SALE GOES CAN
MANUFACTURE MACHINES FULL WILL
HOLD INDIVIDUALS ACCOUNTABLE FOR
HARMS CAUSED BY THEIR
DISTRIBUTION OF DIGITAL
BLUEPRINTS FOR PRINTING. AND
MANUFACTURING GUNS A KEY FIREARM
COMPONENTS. THESE EFFORTS WILL
URGENTLY ADDRESS DANGEROUS
ATTEMPTS TO UNDERMINE
CALIFORNIA'S. LIFESAVING GHOST
GUN REFORM IS BEFORE THEY TAKE
BROUGH IN FUEL THE NEXT GEN. OF
PROLIFERATION OF UNREGULATED
GHOST GUNS IN OUR COMMUNITIES
FOR THESE REASONS DIFFERENT
STRONGLY SUPPORTS THE V. TEN
EIGHTY NINE THANK YOU. YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES. GOOD MORNING TERM
MEMBERS DIRECT MARKETS
REPRESENTING WHEN THE COMES
SPONSORS BRADY CAMPAIGN IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB TEN EIGHTY
NINE WHETHER ASSEMBLED FROM
UNREGULATED PARTS OR PARTS
PRINTED FROM A THREE D. PRINTER
GUYS KINDS OF CAUSED HAVOC IN
COMMUNITIES ALL ACROSS OUR
STATE. LAST YEAR YOU ALL SET
ENOUGH AND PASSED TWO OF THE
STRONGEST LAWS REGULATING GHOST
GUNS HOWEVER DESPITE THE
IMMEDIATE AND LIFESAVING IMPACT
OF THE PASSAGE AND
IMPLEMENTATION OF THESE BILLS.
CERTAIN GHOST GUN INDUSTRY
MEMBERS HAVE WORKED DILIGENTLY
TO FIND A WAY AROUND THE LAW AND
SUBSEQUENTLY CONTINUE TO SAUGUS
KIND MANUFACTURING MACHINES.
THESE MACHINES ARE SPECIFICALLY
DESIGNED AND INTENDED TO ALLOW
ANYONE TO PRODUCE FIREARMS OR
FIREARMS FRAMES RECEIVERS WITH
LITTLE MORE THAN A PRESS OF A
BUTTON. THIS MEANS MORE UNDER
REGULATED AND SERIALIZED GHOST
GUNS IN OUR COMMUNITY. THESE
INDUSTRY MEMBERS ARE
INTENTIONALLY CIRCUMVENTING THE
INTENDED PURPOSE OF BOTH AB
SIXTEEN TWENTY ONE AND AB TWENTY
ONE FIFTY SIX. AT THE RISK OF
PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY. THE
ORIGINAL VERSION OF THIS BILL
CAN PART THAT. THIS BILL CAN
PREVENT THESE BUSINESSES ARE
UNDERMINING YOUR WORK FOR THEIR
PROFIT FOR THESE REASONS WE ARE.
YOUR VOTE THANKS. THANK YOU- FOR
THOSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
AS A ME TOO PLEASE STATE YOUR
NAME THAT YOU SUPPORT- AND THE
ORGANIZATION YOU REPRESENT WE
LIKE. TO GO THROUGH THIS PRETTY
QUICKLY. REMEMBER STAND FELIZ
ALL ON BEHALF THE LAWSUIT
COUNTY. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN
SUPPORT. CENTER WESTON VOLUNTEER
WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN
SUPPORT. CRISTALLO BLOTTER WITH
EVERYTOWN FOR GUN SAFETY AND
SUPPORT. AARON CHAMBERLIN WITH
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
LINDA WHEATON VOLUNTEER WITH
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
SUSAN BURNS VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
CAPTAIN ORDER A VOLUNTEER WITH
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IS STRONG
SUPPORT. AND FREDDIE A VOLUNTEER
WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN
SUPPORT. ALEX NAVARRO WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT. THE
NAY I ON BEHALF OF MARCH FOR OUR
LIVES IN SUPPORT. CYNTHIA TAYLOR
POLICY CHIEF OF ALAMEDA COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU DO YOU HAVE
ANY OPPOSITION WITNESSES. AS
LEAD OPPOSITION YOU WILL BE
HAVING TWO MINUTES. WE WILL TIME
FROM THE TIME ABOUT ONLY THE
CHAIR RIGHT NOW. MADAM CHAIR
LITTLE HISTORICAL FACT. THERE
ARE TENS OF MILLIONS OF GUNS IN
PUBLIC PRIVATE POSSESSION THAT
ARE TOTALLY LEGAL THAT HAVE NO
SERIAL NUMBERS. SERIAL NUMBERS
WERE NOT REQUIRED UNTIL NINETEEN
SIXTY THE PASSAGE OF THE SIXTY A
GUN CONTROL AXLE THERE ARE
LITERALLY MILLIONS OF THEM
ANOTHER HISTORICAL FACT NOW THAT
THERE IS A DEFINITION FOR GHOST
GUNS EVERY TIME THAT A CRIMINAL
TAKES A FIREARM THAT HAS. THE
SERIAL NUMBER ON IT AND
OBLITERATES THE SERIAL NUMBER IT
BECOMES A GHOST GUN AND I WOULD
ARGUE THAT THERE ARE FAR MORE.
CASES WITH THAT THEN THERE ARE
THOSE THAT ARE PRINTED BY LAWFUL
CITIZENS NUMBER THREE. ANY AND
ALL THREE D. PRINTERS. CAN
CONDUCT THIS ACTIVITY THEY CAN
THEY'RE ALL CAPABLE OF DOING
THAT YOU ARE TARGETING THOSE
THAT ARE MARKETED- FOR
MANUFACTURING OF- SO CALLED
GHOST GUNS- RIGGAN'S HAVE HAD
THE RIGHT TO MANUFACTURE HOW
FIREARMS IN THEIR OWN HOMES
SINCE BEFORE THE COUNTRY WAS
FOUNDED AS A MATTER OF FACT. WE
MIGHT NOT EVEN WON THE
REVOLUTIONARY WAR HAD AMERICANS
NOT HAD THE ABILITY TO DO THAT
AND THAT IS TO MAKE ALL GUNS IN
THEIR OWN HOMES. WHAT WE NEED TO
BE DOING AS WE NEED TO BE.
POLISHING THOSE PEOPLE WHO USE
GUNS OF ANY KIND. AND SEPARATING
THEM FROM SOCIETY. FOR THESE
REASONS GOVERNOR'S CALIFORNIA
THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
ASSOCIATION AREN'T STRONG
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL THANK
YOU NEXT WEEK OR YOU WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES. THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR FOR THE RECORD AND READ
WESTERN REGIONAL DIRECTOR OF THE
NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION ALSO
YOUR FOR NATIONAL SHOOTING
SPORTS FOUNDATION. BUT WERE IN
OPPOSITION TODAY- I ECHO THE
SENTIMENTS MISTER PRATT AS-
THERE'S A NUMEROUS GUN LAWS-
SURROUNDING HOMEBUILT FIREARMS
ALREADY IN EXISTENCE. AND
CRIMINALS CONTINUE TO CIRCUMVENT
THESE LAWS AND ARE OPERATING
OUTSIDE IN THIS IS ONE MORE
RESTRICTION THAT WILL REALLY
PENALIZE LAW ABIDING CITIZENS
WHO HAVE BEEN. MAKING HOMEBUILT
FIREARMS SINCE THE REVOLUTIONARY
WAR RIGHT. AND THIS THIS BILL
ALSO PREVENTS OF OUR PRESENTE-
FIFTH AMENDMENT TAKINGS ISSUE
AS- PEOPLE WHO LAWFULLY
POSSESSES NOW WILL HAVE TO
DISPOSE OF THEM BY TWENTY TWENTY
FOUR- WITH THAT WERE OPPOSITION
THANK YOU THANK YOU DO WE HAVE
ANY OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN
THE ROOM AS ME TO USE. THE NONE-
MODERATOR WHICH PROMPT FIRST
INDIVIDUAL PLEASE. REPORTER
OPPOSITION AB AT TEN EIGHTY NINE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. WE'LL GO TO
LINE FOURTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
PARDON ME- THAT IS YOU LOOK INTO
IT. PATRICK MY NAME IS NOT GEARY
I WOULD THE I. P. THE OPPOSE.
BROUGH LIFE FIFTY ONE. MY NAME
IS JOHN OF. WITH THIS YEAR ALL
CLIMBED OPPOSE SENATE BILL. A
NINE THINKING. GO LINE. FORTY
YEAH. C. R. P. AVON. UNIVERSE
CAL. EMPLOYEE ASSISTANCE BILLION
OTHERS. ARE WHY BY ARE A CONCERN
THE BILL. OF MODERATOR.
TECHNIQUE OR OTHERWISE LAWFUL.
LOCAL JULY. FORTY EIGHT. HI GOOD
MORNING NAME IS DURING BATTLE
MEMBER OF CAL RIGHT AND PISTOL
FOOTAGE DOLLARS OF HEALTH AND
I'M CALLING STRONG TO THE BILL
COULD YOU KNOW THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. PHOTO LINE NINE. HI MY
NAME IS GERRY I BEEN IN MEMBER.
REMEMBER AND I FROM WAS THE
BEGINNING NINE THANK YOU. OKAY
TO FIT. MARK ROSS CERTAIN
CALIFORNIA'S STRONG URGING. IF
YOU TO OPPOSE ANY. NINE PHOTO
LINE. TWO YEAH MARSHALL REPORTER
RIFLE ASSOCIATES BONTA WORK
MEMBERS. LET ME. MALCOLM
STRONGLY OPPOSE THE SENATE NINE.
WE STARTED USING THE THANK YOU
NEXT.
I'M SURE WE HAVE FOR THEIR
SUPPORT OPPOSITION THANK YOU
WILL MOVE THE CONVERSATION TO
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. SEEING
NONE I WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE YES I
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OF THE COMMITTEE SENATE BILL TEN
OF EIGHTY NINE WILL- THIS BILL
IS AGAIN FOCUSING ON THE THREE
D. PRINTER- THOSE IN OPPOSITION
TALKED ABOUT THE CIVIL WAR WE
DON'T LIVE IN A TIME- WHERE
THAT'S RELEVANT OUR TECHNOLOGY
HAS FAR EXCEEDED OUR LAWS AND WE
MUST MAKE SURE THAT ALL LAWS.
PARK A CATCHING UP TO OUR WHAT'S
GOING ON IN OUR SOCIETY ASSEMBLY
BO TEN EIGHTY NINE WILL LIMIT
ACCESS TO THOSE WHO CAN USE A
THREE D. PRINTER IN THE CD AS A
CNC. MILLING MACHINE- FOR
LICENSED MANUFACTURERS WHO ARE
LICENSED BY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA- WE MUST DO THIS
BECAUSE OF ALL THE GUNS BODIES
TAKING PLACE IN OUR COMMUNITY I
RESPECTFULLY ASK. FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU TO HAVE A MOTION.
SENATOR BRADFORD IT. THANK YOU.
WE CAN WE CALL. MOST IS THE PAST
TO THE COMMITTEE BOB HI BOB BY
TO TELL BOTH. BRADFORD BRADFORD
AYE SKINNER AYE AND WIENER THANK
YOU THAT BILLS ARE CALL. I
MEMBER WOULD YOU TO PRESENT ON
BEHALF OF A MEMBER TEAM THAT
START WITH THE FOUR NINE FIRST
ALL. FOUR FOUR NINE. THANK YOU
AGAIN I'LL BE PRESENTING THIS
BILL MAY CHAIR MEMBERS ON BEHALF
. SOMEONE FEEL TING I LIKE TO
BEGIN BY X. THE CAN- AND THANK
THE COMMITTEE FOR WORKING-
FONDEST. ASSEMBLY FOUR FOUR NINE
REQUIRE A LONG SOME AGE TO ADOPT
A- CRIME POLICY AND FOR WITH GUY
. WHEN RESPOND TO INCIDENTS HATE
. HAVE SURGED IN CALIFORNIA AND
NATIONALLY SINCE TWO THOUSAND
AND FIFTEEN ESCALATING THE MORE
THE MORE SENSE OF THE START OF
THE PANDEMIC IN MY CITY MEANING
SAN FRANCISCO OF THE AUTHOR
POLICE DEPARTMENTS REPORTED THE
HATE CRIME AGAINST API. INCREASE
WATCH THIS FIVE HUNDRED AND 67%
IN TWO THOUSAND TWENTY ONE- LOS
ANGELES SPACE- A HUNDRED AND 73%
INCREASE IN THAT SAME YEAR ON
THE NUMBER OF REPORTED INCIDENTS
OF INCIDENTS PUBLICLY REFLECTS
ONLY A FRACTION OF THE ACTUAL
NUMBER- BECAUSE OF INSUFFICIENT
INSUFFICIENT INSUFFICIENT DATA
COLLECTED- AND REPORT IT'S AN
UNDER REPORTED. VICTIMS DO NOT
HAVE THE SAME RESPONSE OR
TREATED IN EVERY JURISDICTION
THE SAME WAY I WANT TO ALSO BE A
CO AUTHOR THIS BILL AS WELL-
THIS BILL DOES NOT EXPAND
PENALTIES OR EXPAND WHAT A HATE
CRIME IS THIS BILL MERELY.
PRIORITIZE VICTIMS AND HOW WE
RESPOND TO THEM- HERE TO SUPPLY
SUPPORTING TESTIMONIES OUR
REPRESENTATIVES WHO WILL STEP
STEP STEP UP IN SELF INTRODUCED
YOU ONLY HAVE ONE WITNESS
CRACKED- YES OKAY YOU WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES. GREG YEAR WITH THE
CAR CAN YOU TO REPUBLICAN.
VERSION THE RECENT HISTORY OF
THE BILL THE FACT RELEASE TWENTY
EIGHTEEN WITH THE JOINT AUDIT
CAN. ORDERED AN AUDIT OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT. WHAT IT FOUND THAT
LAW ENFORCEMENT HAS ADDED.
IDENTIFIED REPORTED A RISK TO A
CRIMES THIS BILL. THERE ARE MANY
OF OUR IS THE TOP OF THE AUDIT
SOME NOT DISABILITY INJURIES ALL
WE WILL. OF. THE- SOME OF THE
AND ASKING DO YOU MEET ON THEIR
- IT'S A LONG LIST WHICH RATHER
AND OUT RESOLVED SAY IT'S LONG
AND- THANK YOU. NEXT FIGURE YOU
HAVE TO. SEEING THAT OKAY WILL
TO MEET USE. WITH I'M SURE
MEMBERS FULL SOUTHERN RAFFLE
ANGELES JUST ATTORNEY'S. THE
**** THAT. GOOD MORNING MY
CHAIRMAN A LIST THAT'S WHEN I ON
THE OF THE K. COMMUNITY LIVING
UP AND- THANK YOU. ANY
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. YOU WILL
HAVE TWO MINUTES CAN STONE STONE
ADVOCACY ON BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
ASSOCIATION WE'VE AN OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION NOT AT
ALL OPPOSED TO THE PREMISE OF
THAT THEY'LL MERELY RECOMMEND
REMOVING NON FIRST RESPONDERS
LAW ENFORCEMENT. CORNERS OF
FRAUD AND ARSON INVESTIGATORS
AND DA INVESTIGATORS FROM THE
TOP THANK YOU. ANY OTHER
OPPOSITION ME TO SING NON
MODERATOR PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. BUT FOR OPPOSITION
FOR AB FOUR FOUR NINE PRESS ONE
AND ZERO. GOOGLE TO FIND. EIGHT
ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
IN SUPPORT. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
FIFTY SEVEN. HELLO IS WELCOME
VISIBILITY RIGHT CALIFORNIA.
THANKS. GO TO LINE SIX PLEASE
CALL. I AM READING YOUR CALL I'M
A DISCUSSION COULD BE. PORTION
WORKERS HELD FEBRUARY FOURTH ALL
. I'M GOING TO LINE. FORTY NINE.
MORE THAN FORTY NINETY LINE IS
OPEN.
SURE WE HAVE NO FOR THIS OP
THANK YOU WILL MOVE THE TO THE
COMMITTEE MEMBERS I WILL START
BY SAYING FIRST OFF THERE IS NO
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS- SO I JUST
WANNA MAKE SURE THAT
ASSEMBLYMEMBER TING'S STAFF IS
AWARE OF THAT- SEEING NO
CONVERSATIONS FROM COMMITTEE
MEMBERS ASSEMBLY MEMBER TO LIKE
CLOSE. RESPECTFULLY ASK WHAT I
VOTE THANK YOU DO WE HAVE A
MOTION. THANK YOU OUT WIENER HAS
MOVED. AB FOUR FOUR NINE MOTION
IS TO PASS TO APPROACH WILL HOP
NINE FIVE I- TURBO BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER. WIENER
WIENER AYE THANK YOU THAT BUILD
ON CALL. AB FIVE OH FIVE
ASSEMBLY TING- MEMBER GIPSON
WITH THANK YOU VERY MUCH AGAIN
BOB PRESENTING BEHALF OF MR TANG
ASSEMBLY BILL FIVE OH FIVE HAS
OF THREE KEY COMPONENTS ONE
SITTING ALL YOUTH RELATED
RESPONSIBILITIES FROM THE BOARD
STATE AND COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS
THE B. C. B. THE B. S. C. C. TO
THE OFFICE OF THE OF YOUTH AND
COMMUNITY- RELATIONS- SECONDLY-
INSURE THAT THE ODDS **** PERSON
HAS RESTRICTED HAS UNRESTRICTED
ACCESS- TO THE U. THREE AND
VITAL. REQUIRES THE WHOLE YC ARE
TO REVIEW AND APPROVE CURRENT
GROUP- COUNTY PLANS ENSURING
THAT THE STATE FUNDS ARE USED-
FOR THE PURPOSE UP IN WHICH HE
WAS ATTENDED BY THE LEGISLATURE
AND REQUIRES A COUNTY PLANT TO
BE DEVELOPED WITH THE REGULAR
LOCAL COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION
THIS BILL ENSURE. THAT THE STATE
IS BEING CONSIDERATE- WITH THE
EFFORTS OF SHIFTING FROM THE
CORRECTIONS MODEL TO MORE
APPROPRIATE HEALTH BASED
APPROACH WHEN DEALING WITH- ARE
INCARCERATED YOUTH ASSEMBLY BILL
FIVE OR FIVE- IS A FOLLOW UP- TO
THE JUVENILE JUSTICE. REFORM WE
PASSED IN THE BUDGET S. B. EIGHT
TWENTY THREE IN TWO THOUSAND
TWENTY BY OUTLINING THE
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE ALL Y.
C. ARE IN THE OFFICE- WE CREATED
SPECIFICALLY- TO FOCUS ON YOUTH
JUSTICE I RESPECTFULLY ASK WHAT
I BUT WE HAVE SOME WITNESSES.
THAT WHO WAS SELF- TESTIFIED
FROM THE REGION RESTORATIVE
JUSTICE COALITION. OUR POSITION
. YOU HAVE TO WITNESSES ARE ONE
. I HAVE ONE WITNESS ONE WITNESS
YOU WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES THANK
YOU PETER PRISON WHILE MEMBERS
OF COMMITTEE MY NAME IS MICHAEL
MENDOZA DIRECTOR OF ADVOCACY
WITH THE ANTI RECIDIVISM
COALITION HERE SUPPORT. IN TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY THE LEGISLATURE
AND GOVERNOR SAID CALIFORNIA ON
COURSE TO TRANSFORM YOUTH
JUSTICE FIFTY FROM THE
CORRECTIONS BASED MODEL TO ONE
FOCUSED ON HEALTH. KILLING
OPPORTUNITIES FOR GROWTH AND
CREATING THE FIRST EVER STATE
OFFICE YOU JUSTICE THE OFFICE OF
YOUTH AND COMMITTEE RESTORATION.
FONG THIS PLAN NEXT CALIFORNIA
WILL CLOSE JUVENILE PRISONS. AND
AB FIVE OH FIVE IS A NECESSARY
NEXT STEP TO ENSURE THAT THE
TRANSFORMATION OF YOUTH JUSTICE
THAT THIS BODY ENVISIONED
BECAUSE RIGHT. AND TO PROVIDE
CLARITY ON THE ROLE AND
AUTHORITY OF THE Y. C. R. I
REMEMBER CLEARLY WHAT IT WAS
LIKE TO BE YOUNG AND VERY ALONE
AND STARK SALVAGEABLE ALL THOSE
WALLS TELL YOU NO ONE CARES. I
LOOK BACK IN NOW NO THAT WAS A
MOMENT WHEN I NEEDED THE STATE'S
SUPPORT THE MOST AND TO PROVIDE
AND AB FIVE OH FIVE IS ABOUT
THAT THE STATE BEING THERE FOR
OUR YOUTH. WE'VE ALL HEARD THAT
THERE IS A CRISIS HAPPENING LOS
ANGELES JUNE ALL'S. WHAT IS NOT
JUST A LEAVE. WE HAVE REPORTS ON
CONDITIONS IN SEVENTEEN
COUNTIES. OVERDOSES LACK OF
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
INSUFFICIENT PROGRAMMING THE USE
OF SOLITARY CONFINEMENT.
RETALIATION FOR ATTEMPTED TO
REACH THEM BUT PERSON. AND
VIOLENCE. BUT WHAT'S YOURS NO
AUTHORITY TO ACT AND THE BSE C.
HAS ONLY ONE TOOL. THE NUCLEAR
OPTION OF SHUTTING DOWN THE
HALLS. ALSO THE BCC HAS ZERO
AUTHORITY TO MAKE ANY KIND OF
FINDING ON THE SUITABILITY OF
THE SECURE USED TREATMENT
FACILITIES. THAT MEANS THE
HIGHEST NEED YOU'D HAVE NO STATE
OVERSIGHT AT ALL. AB FIVE
FIREWOOD FOR. ALL OTHER THAN IF
SHOULD. WICKS IS CHANGE THE LOOK
LEVEL BE THINGS GET TOO BAD. IT
IS CLEARLY NEEDED AND AB FILE
FIVE WILL DO JUST THAT. NOW IS
THE MOMENT TO ENSURE YOU JUSTICE
TRANSFORMATION YOU ENVISIONED
STAYS ON COURSE. I RESPECTFULLY
ASK RIVAL. SEEING NO OTHER
WITNESSES WE WILL FOR ME TO
SUPPORT AGAIN NAME ORGANIZATION
AND THAT YOU SUPPORT WE MOVE
THROUGH THIS QUICKLY SO ANYBODY
LINED UP. BUT TO KEEP IT MOVING.
THANK YOU LAURA RIDOLFI THOUGHT
HE WOULD BIRDS INSTITUTE CO
SPONSOR IN STRONG SUPPORT.
THIRTY TWO SEN CAST MONO WITH
COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR START
JUSTICE AND SOME. MY NAME IS
CHRIS FOR HERNANDEZ COPPER
FICTION AND SO OF AB FIVE FIVE.
I WOULD ALSO LIKE RECOGNIZE
OTHER ORGANIZATION IN SUPPORT
THIS BILL. COMMUNITIES UNITED
FOR RESTORATIVE YOU JUSTICE.
CENTER FOR JUVENILE LAW AND
POLICY AT LITTLE. LAW SCHOOL
SANTA CRUZ WARRIORS YOU NEED US
. THE GATHERING FOR JUSTICE.
IT'S A LOT. ASIAN PRISONER
SUPPORT. ALLIANCE FOR CHILDREN'S
RIGHTS ARE. LEGAL SERVICES FOR
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN. HE'S
BAKER LAW CENTER. POLITICAL A-
PUBLIC. CHILDREN SERVANTS ONE
CAUGHT. FRESH LIFE FOR YOUTH
SILICON VALLEY DE BUG HUMAN
RIGHTS WATCH. YOUNGER IN TERMS
OF- AND- CALIFORNIA FOR YOU
THINK THREE. THANKS MUCH FOR
THREE FIVE THANK YOU. DAN
AMMUNITION JEFF OF. CHRIS LUNCH
AND EVERYTHING CALL ME IN
SUPPORT. LESLIE CALDWELL HE FOR
THE PUBLIC ASSOCIATE AND SOME.
BASICALLY WITH A SHIMMER OF
JUSTICE CAL OR IN. MELANIE
KANSEN CISCO PUBLIC TO OFFICE
SUPPORT. SANTA LU WELL ALL OF US
MANAGE SUPPORT. MOSCOW WITH THE
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS CHILDREN
SUPPORT. ALYSSA MORE WITH LEGAL
SERVICE FOR PER WHICH ALL OF US
ARE NOT. A JUVENILE LIFE IN FULL
SUPPORT. ARTIST WHY WITH
COMMUNITY UNITED FIRST YOU
JUSTICE AND SO. BREMANGER OF THE
DREAM BEYOND BARS FELLOWSHIP
SUPPORT. THANK YOU HAVE A IS
STILL YOU CAL ACT AND SUPPORT.
THAT'S WHAT I'M BEST A BIGGER
PAYMENT RATES IN SUPPORT. I WAS
USED IN A GARAGE A PARTLY
STRUCTURE WITH. IT LITTLE ON
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIANS FOR SAFE
AND JUST SINCE THE THANK YOU.
SIGNAL OTHER SUPPORT WHEN WILL
MOVE TO OFFICE WITNESS. SAYING
NO. OPPOSITIONIST OKAY WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES THANK YOU TERRY
MEMBERS DANIEL SANCHEZ ON BEHALF
OF THE CHEAPER OFFICER AND HERE
TODAY OPPOSITION TO EIGHTY FIVE
OH FIVE ALTHOUGH WE CERTAINLY
HAVE SHARED GOAL ABOUT
SUPPORTING CAN THAT YOU JUSTICE
SYSTEM IN A TRAUMA. AWAY WE ARE
OPPOSED TO THE APPROACH SUGGEST
BY THIS DUE TO ITS DEEP. IT
IMPACT ON THE IMPLEMENTATION
WORK CURRENTLY BEING OUT THE
LOWER LEVEL AS IT RELATES TO-
DJJ REALIGNMENT AND THE ODD.
FOCUS ON SERVING ALL YOUTH IN
TWENTY TWENTY THE LEGISLATURE
REALIGNED ALL JUVENILE JUSTICE
RESPONSIBILITIES TO COUNTIES
WITH THE GOAL OF KEEPING YOU
CLOSER TO HOME. AND ALLOWING
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THE ABILITY TO
DEVELOP LOCALLY RESPONSIVE
APPROACHES TO SERVING YOUTH AND
IMPORTANTLY THAT WOULD ACHIEVE
ENHANCED OUTCOMES. COUNTIES A
PROVISION OF BEEN DOING THIS
WORK EARNESTLY TO IMPLEMENT THIS
POLICY WITH THE ENTIRE CLOSURE
DJJ AND THE REMAINING YOUTH
RETURNING IT JUST A FEW DAYS. I
WANT TO VERY STRONGLY
UNDERSCORED THAT THE CHANGES IN
THIS BILL ARE NOT IN A VACUUM
NOR DO THEY MAKE CLARIFYING
CHANGES AROUND THE EDGES. THEY
RECAST MAJOR COMPONENTS
INCLUDING PHYSICAL COMPONENTS OF
THE S. B. EIGHT TWENTY THREE DJJ
REALIGNMENT FRAMEWORK. THESE
CHANGES INCLUDE NEW REQUIREMENTS
TO THE FISCAL STRUCTURE SUCH AS
REQUIRING THE STATE'S APPROVAL
OF LOCAL PLANS AND DIRECTING THE
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND HOW
THEY MAKE ALLOCATIONS. MAKING
ADDITIONAL CHANGES TO REMOVE THE
PROBATION OFFICERS THE CHAIR OF
THE LOCAL PLANTS PLANNING SUB
COMMITTEE. THAT BRINGS TOGETHER
THESE VERY IMPORTANT STAKEHOLDER
CONVERSATIONS CHANGING THE SCOPE
OF THE EXISTING TRAINING PROGRAM
AND MANY RELATED PROVISIONS.
THESE CHANGES CREATE BARRIERS
AND INSTABILITY AND DEVELOPING
RESOURCE SEEN IN CARRYING OUT
THE LOCAL PLANTS ABOUT SUPPORT
YOUTH. FOR THESE REASONS WE MUST
OPPOSE THE APPROACH OUTLINED AND
SOUGHT IN EIGHTY FIVE OH FIVE.
AND JUST WANT TO NOTE OUR
CONTINUED. COMMITMENT TO THE
GENERAL DISCUSSION AROUND HOW TO
BEST SUPPORT USE THAT AGAIN HAVE
TO OPPOSE THE APPROACH LAID OUT
IN THIS BILL. THANK YOU
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME DO WE HAVE
ANY OTHER OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
MORNING MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
COMMITTEE OVER A TRICKLE ME UP
WITH CLOSURE. ORGANIZATION
PURPOSE THE RANK OF OFFICERS
AROUND. OF OPPOSITION THANK YOU
FOR YOU. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
MEMBER A LIST OF ESTADO HERE TO
ON THE OF THE BOARD SUPER. IN
THE OF VENTURA ALSO AND- THANK
YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
OPPOSITION WITNESSES SEEING NONE
MODERATOR PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. FOR SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION FOR AB FIVE OR FIVE
PRESS ONE AND ZERO. WE'LL GO TO
LINE EIGHTEEN. GOOD MORNING THIS
IS DANIELLE ONE GROW WITH
CHILDREN NOW FALLING IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. BROUGH TO LINE.
TWENTY ONE. THE CRAWLED UNDER
PETER LOT OF THE NEED OF JUSTICE
ADVOCATE INDIO CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GO TO LINE
TWENTY FIVE. MORNING JIM WOOD
BURKE ON BEHALF OF A FRIEND
COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION OF
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. BOTH LINE
. FIFTY FIVE. THE WATER WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF AB. FIVE OH
FIVE. GO TO LINE TWENTY SEVEN.
GOOD MORNING HOW TO RETURN. ON
BEHALF YOUNG MEN BE A BETTER
ACCOUNT FUNDS AS A AS BEHALF OF
TWO STORY YOU DON'T CALL. SIX
WE'LL GO TO LINE EIGHT. THE MORE
MEREDITH THE POWER ON BEHALF OF
THE LIFE AND HER TRONG PART
THANK YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
SIXTY I THINK WE'RE HELP MENASHE
OF THE OF WORKERS FELL OFF KEPT
STRONG WITH BUT THE. I AM SURE
WE HAVE NO BRITISH FLORIDA OFF
THANK YOU THE COMES TO MY OF THE
SEEING NONE- SENATOR PATRICK. I
GOT A CALL AN INJURY NOT FAIR
THE HOUSE TO MISTER GIBSON SINCE
HE'S NOT THROUGH THE BUT THERE'S
TRAILER BILL LANG RIGHT NOW
TEAMS. RENTING COMP AND- WHAT
THE BILL IS TRYING TO AND I WANT
TO IF THE AUTHOR ANYWAY ON HOW
HE'S GOING TO ADDRESS THE- GOING
FOR WE HAVE SO MANY TECH.
QUESTIONS IS THE QUESTION AROUND
THE TRAIL BILL AND FOR. SECURITY
TREATMENT FACILITY UP YES SO
WHAT THIS BILL YOU WOULD
CONSOLIDATE ALL OF THAT WORK
UNDER THE OFFICE OF USING
COMMUNITY RESTORATION SO IT
DOESN'T CONFLICT WITH WHAT
EXISTS BUT IT DOES TRANSITION
ALL OF THE FUNCTIONS OF
OVERSIGHT FROM THE BOARD OF
STATE AND COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS
TO THE OFFICE IF YOU THINK. AND
COMMUNITY RESTORATION. AND THAT
OFFICE IS JUST BEING STOOD UP
AND IT HASN'T BEEN FULLY STAFFED
SO WILL THIS BE A STAFFING ISSUE
AND HOW LONG WILL IT. TAKE TO BE
FULLY STAFFED AND BILL TO
IMPLEMENT INTO THE PROGRAMS THAT
YOU. AS FAR TO DO IT CERTAINLY
THE OFFICE IS A NEW OFFICE. BUT
IT'S A REALLY CRITICAL IMPORTANT
OFFICE AS WE ALL KNOW WE ARE ON
A PATHWAY IN OUR STATE TO
TRANSFORM YOUTH JUSTICE FROM AN
APPROACH THAT IS CORRECTIONS.
BASED TO ONE THAT IS HEALTH
FOCUSED IN THIS OFFICE THAT
SITUATED IN AGENCY FOCUSED AND
HEALTH IS THE WAY TO DO THAT
CERTAINLY IF THERE IS THE NEED
TO HAVE MORE TIME TO. ENSURE
THAT THE OFFICE IS POSITIONED TO
TAKE ON THAT ROLE I THINK THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TANG IS. MORE
THAN WILLING TO ENTERTAIN ANY
PROPOSALS FOR- A TIMELINE THAT
IS MORE- THAT THAT'S MORE IN
LINE WITH THAT. ALL RIGHT.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER YOU LIKE CLOSE
ESPECIALLY AS WHEN I VOTE THANK
YOU TO HAVE A MOTION. DO WE HAVE
A MOTION AT CENTER WINNER MOVES
THE BILL- CAN. VOTE THE MOTION
IS THE PAST TO APPROPRIATE. WHAT
BY HOP BY THE TOWBOAT. BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER. HI SKINNER
AYE WIENER. WIENER AYE. OKAY
THAT BILLS ON. BEFORE WE MOVED
HERE. BILL I JUST LIKE TO- ASK
FOR A MOTION FOR COULD. OKAY
CENTER WIENER HAS THE BILL. BRAD
SORRY. WAHABI HI BOB- TO ABOUT.
BRADFORD BRADFORD ICE. SKINNER I
. WIENER AYE THOSE THOSE ARE ON
CALL- I'M GONNA ALL ASK FOR
MOTION FOR A BEEF FIVE FIVE US
MEMBER FOR. FILE NUMBER. TEN
MOVED VICE SKINNER. HE RECALLED
THE. MOTIONS TO PAY TO APPROACH
WAHHAB I AM BOB I TO ABOVE
BRADFORD. BRADFORD ICE. SKINNER
AYE WE- WIENER AYE. RATE THAT
THE ON CALL CAN WE ALSO THE MOST
TO MOVE FOUR SEVEN FOUR ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ROB ROY. ITEM NUMBER.
ELEVEN COULD WE GET A MOTION
FROM SENATOR WIENER HAS MOVED.
MOTIONS TO PASS TO OR BEHIND
FIVE HI I ABOUT BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER SKINNER
WIENER. WIENER THAT BILLS ON
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WHICH LIKE TO
FORWARD YOUR FOR BILL FOR A SIX
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TANK THROUGH
AGAIN THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND
HAVE A OF SOME MEMBER TO. AB SIX
HUNDRED OR FIRST PER AND- A
TECHNICAL ISSUE WE REESE PROCESS
EXPAND TO JURORS AUTHORITY AND-
CLARITY TO THE CORE WHEN
APPLYING THIS LAW SECOND LOOK-
IS THE OPPORTUNE TO A- THE
MASSIVE ARE EFFORTS. OF THE PAST
BY GAINING. INTO ONE THE- THE
DISK TURNING AND THE OF PAROLE.
OF HEARING AND THE SECRETARY OF
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATION
TO AUTHORIZED TO REFER PEOPLE
BACK TO COURT FOR SECOND LOOK AT
THEIR SENTENCING ASSEMBLY
MEMBER- TAKING- HAS BEEN WORKING
DILIGENTLY IN THE SPACE THE
AUTHORED ASSEMBLY BILL FIFTEEN
FORTY AND TWO THOUSAND TWENTY
ONE WHICH SEEKS TO ADDRESS MANY
OF THE PROCEDURAL ISSUES. AND
RESULTED IN THE SAFE RELEASE OF
INCARCERATED PEOPLE IN THE LAST
IN LAST YEAR'S HOWEVER- THERE
ARE STILL SOME IMPLEMENTATIONS
BARRIERS IDENTIFIED AND WAYS
THAT THE STATE CAN IMPROVE THE
CURRENT PROCESS ASSEMBLY BILL
SIX HUNDRED- IS FILLED WITH-
ASSEMBLY BILL SIX HUNDRED- FEELS
THAT THE GAP- CREATED. AND
CREATE A FAIR AND DUE PROCESS IN
TERMS OF RESENTENCING I
RESPECTFULLY ASK BUT I VOTE WE
HAVE SOME WITNESSES- THE TASHA
FROM THE PROSECUTION ALLIANCE
HERE WHO WILL SPEAK. IN SUPPORT
OF ASSEMBLY BILL SIX HUNDRED.
GOOD MORNING. FOR ON BEHALF OF
THE PRESS ALLY OF. SPA OF EIGHTY
SIX HUNDRED AS WELL AS ON BEHALF
OF SMART DRESSES CALIFORNIA IN
STRONG SUPPORT. SB SIX HUNDRED
WILL EMPOWER JUDGES TO ADDRESS
SENTENCES THAT ARE OUT OF DATE
IN LIGHT OF CURRENT SENSING LAW
INTO RECOGNIZED REHABILITATION
AND REDEMPTION. CALIFORNIA HAS A
SECOND WHAT SENTENCING PROCESS
WHICH ALLOWS DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
IN THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
TO REFER SOMEONE BACK TO A JUDGE
TO RECONSIDER SENTENCE. MANY
SENSING LAWS IN CALIFORNIA HAVE
RECENTLY BEEN CHANGED AND THERE
ARE PEOPLE SERVING LENGTHY
SENTENCES WHO WOULD NOT SERVE
THOSE SENTENCES IF THEIR CASE
WAS CONSIDERED TODAY. SB SIX
HUNDRED BUILDS ON EXISTING LAW
BY GIVING JUDGES THE POWER TO
CHANGE A SENSOR CONVICTION WHEN
THERE HAS BEEN A CHANGE IN
EXISTING LAW AND THE JUDGE
BELIEVES THAT IS THE RIGHT THING
TO DO. SB SIX HUNDRED ALSO
RECOGNIZES RE-ATTEMPT
REHABILITATION AND REDEMPTION.
THE BILL INSTRUCTS JUDGES TO
CONSIDER EVIDENCE OF
REHABILITATION AND POST
CONVICTION FACTORS WHEN ENGAGING
IN A SECOND LOOK SENSING AND
RESENTENCING. AB SIX HUNDRED IS
BASED ON FEEDBACK FROM
PROSECUTORS JUDGES AND
PRACTITIONERS IT WILL MAKE THE
SECOND LOOK SENTENCING PROCESS
IN CALIFORNIA ONE THAT IS FAIRER
AND BRINGS MORE JUSTICE AND
EQUITY TO SELL DISTANCES WE ARE
CHEN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU. MISTER
. THANK YOU ARE RUNNING THE SHOW
. ARE THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT. THEN YOU JUST NAME
AND ME TOO DAN ACCORD I'M
HONESTLY JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
LESLIE CALDWELL HOUSTON FOR THE
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC DEFENDERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
INJECTION IN REPRESENTING THE
ELLA BAKER CENTER FOR HUMAN
RIGHTS AND SUPPORT. WELL ANY
CONCERNS IT'S GO PUBLIC
DEFENDER'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU THOMAS AND GAS LINE ON
BEHALF OF COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
CHANNELER POLICY T. FOR THE
ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT. A
LITTLE BIT FOR CALIFORNIANS FOR
SAFETY AND JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU HAVE A LENDS ACLU
CALIFORNIA ACTION IN SUPPORT.
**** LEGAL SERVICES FOR WERE
CHILDREN SOME. LISTEN MORALLY
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS WITH
CHILDREN ALL OF US NONE OKAY IN
STRAW SUPPORT. SAN LUIS WELL OF
US IN MANAGEMENT SUPPORT. I
WOULD USE THAN A GIRL BECAUSE
INITIATIVE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
RIGHT ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT SEEING NINE LET'S SEE IF
THERE'S A MAJOR. THE PRIMARY
OPPOSITION WITNESS. GOOD MORNING
CHEN MEMBERS CAMPUS JOHNSTONE
ADVOCACY ON BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
ASSOCIATION AND RESPECTFUL
OPPOSITION- OF THE BILL ALLOWS
RECALLING RESENTENCING AT ANY
TIME WITHOUT A SHOWING OF
PREJUDICE OR ERROR THE
CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION DOES
REQUIRE THAT THERE IS A JUDGE IT
BEFORE DOING THAT- SELBY OF THE
OPINION THAT THE ERROR
COMPLAINED OF HAS RESULTED. IN A
MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE AND SINCE
THIS BILL DOESN'T DO THAT- WE
FEAR IT MAY VIOLATE THAT SECTION
OF THE CONSTITUTION AND STANDARD
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION THANK YOU
. ALL RIGHT ANY OTHER WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION. FIGHT SCENE NINE
FIVE MODERATOR WOULD YOU PLEASE-
HAVE OUR PHONE. CALLERS. WE
SUPPORT OFFICE. EIGHT SIX. PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO. WE'LL GO TO FIND
THREE. NUMBER ONE WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CAP COPPER APART
THANK YOU. GO TO LINE. TWENTY
FIVE. DILLON FRIENDS ON THE- CAL
AND STROKES OF. BOTH ONLINE.
SEVENTY FOUR. CREATING COMMITTEE
WOMEN IN IN FOR THE. PHOTO LINE
. FIFTY TELL THE NATIONAL OF
SOCIAL BECAUSE SHOP WHICH THE
BILL THANK YOU. DON'T GO. TO
TWO. NINE SEVENTY TWO NINE IS A
- HI THERE MY NAME IS RICHARD
TYLER AT FULTON CALIFORNIA
MINISTRY OPPOSITION THAT THEY
WERE IN IN REBUILDING- THAT
THANK YOU THIS IS A ME. TOO
MA'AM SHE A BILL FOR THIS UP
OFFICE. THANK YOU ALL RIGHT SO
WE ARE BRINGING UP TO THE OR
THEIR- COMMENTS MOTION THROUGH
THE BILL OF RIGHTS CENTER WIENER
MOVED BILL YOU MAY CLOSE THANK
YOU VERY MUCH I WANT TO ON
BEHALF OF MR OF FILL TANKS THANK
ALL OF THE- THE SPONSORS AS WELL
AS THOSE WHO CAME. TAKING TIME
OUT OF BUSY SCHEDULE TUES AT
THEIR SUPPORT FOR ALL OF HIS
BILLS- AND- THANK THE SPONSORS
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK BUT I VOTE
. ALL RIGHT LET'S SAID ROLL CALL
IN THAT MOTION- WE HAVE A MOVE
MOST VICE WE MOTION IS TO A- BOB
. A TO OF BRADFORD HI FRED AYE
SKINNER HI I WIENER. WIENER AYE
TH. RIGHT THAT BILLS CALLS
VETERANS BUSINESS CONTACTS OKAY
SO ASSEMBLY MEMBER BOND YOU MAY
. COME INCREASE JOHN- AB. SEVEN
THREE. THE MEMBERS FOURTEENTH.
THANK YOU MADAM SPEAKERS AND I'M
TODAY PRESENT AB SO NINETY THE
STOCK SURVEY ARE BY ACT I FIRST
WANT TO START OUT WITH BEING
CLEAR ON THE COULD I MAY ON THE
FLOOR ON THIS BILL I COME TO PHÐ
THIS OF THE PROTECTIONS THIS
BILL. THE ONLY APPLY TO
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE THIS COMMITMENT
HAS NOT CHANGED MY OFFICE HAS
BEEN HARD AT WORK TO MEET ITS
COMMITMENTS. AND WE EXCHANGED
LANGUAGE WITH OPPOSITION HAD A
MEETING THAT INCLUDED BOTH
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY AND
JUDICIARY CONSULTANTS AND ASK
FOR OPPOSITION TO PROVIDE
LANGUAGE IN RESPONSE TO THE
DRAFT WOULD PROVIDE THEM. I'VE
BEEN LOOKING CLOSELY IN
REVIEWING THAT LANGUAGE. I
CANNOT EXPRESS TO YOU ENOUGH HOW
HARD WE'VE BEEN WORKING ON THIS
BILL TO MAKE IT WORK. IT IS A
DIFFICULT TASK TO DO BOTH
FOCUSED ON THE SCOPE OF THIS
BILL WHILE ALSO ATTEMPTING TO
PROVIDE BROAD ENOUGH PROTECTIONS
TO ENSURE PEOPLE SEEKING
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. ARE CERTAIN IN
THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY WITH THE
SAFETY AND PROTECTIONS OF OUR
LGBTQ BROTHERS SISTERS AND
SIBLINGS WITH WOMEN'S OVERALL
HEALTH AND SAFETY ON THE LINE WE
HAVE TO GET THIS BILL RIGHT THE
ANNIVERSARY OF THE DOBBS
DECISION THIS PAST WEEKEND.
REMINDS US OF HOW HIGH THE
STAKES ARE. AS A MEMBER WAS LED
ON REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
LEGISLATION I AM PROUD OF THE
STATE THAT IS A SAFE HAVEN FOR
THOSE SEEKING SCARED
REPRODUCTIVE CARE AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. THE CONTINUED
ERODING OF OUR RIGHTS ACROSS THE
COUNTRY POST ROW. SHOW US
HOWEVER THAT OUR JOB IS NOT
DONE. REVERSED DEMANDS. HI THE
SUBJECT OF THIS BILL CAN LEAVE
PEOPLE WHO NEED REPRODUCTIVE OR
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE VULNERABLE
TO A DIGITAL SURVEILLANCE
APPARATUS. THAT COULD BE USED
AGAINST THEM. REVERSE DEMANDS
ARE DANGEROUS IN A POST WORK BRO
ERA. AND IN A WORLD WHERE A
NUMBER OF STATES HAVE ANTI LGBTQ
LAWS ON THE BOOKS. ARE REVERSED
WARRANT CAN SEEK IDENTITY OF ALL
PEOPLE WHO WERE PRESENT AT A
PARTICULAR LOCATION WHICH IS
GEOFENCE DEMAND. WHO LOOK. WHO
LOOK UP A PARTICULAR TERM IN THE
SEARCH ENGINE KEYWORD DEMAND.
SIMPLY BECAUSE OF WHERE THEY
WERE. OR WHAT THEY WERE SEARCHED
WHAT OR WHAT THEY SEARCH FOR.
YOUR FENCE DEMANDS HAVE ALSO
BEEN USED TO TRACK THE LOCATIONS
AND IDENTITIES OF PEOPLE
PROTESTING POLICE VIOLENCE. AND
COULD BE USED TO TRACK THE
LOCATIONS AND IDENTITIES OF
PEOPLE VISITING REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CLINICS AS WELL. PEOPLE
IN CALIFORNIA HAVE A FUNDAMENTAL
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO PRIVACY.
IN THE REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND
GENDER HEALTH DECISIONS IT'S
TIME TO MAKE SURE THAT RIVERS
DEMANDS RESPECT. THAT PRIVACY
INTERNET TOOLS THAT ARE
MANIPULATED TO HARM PEOPLE. WHO
ARE PROVIDING A SAFE HAVEN.
AGAIN WE ARE. ARE ACTING OUR
COME. ON THE BILL AND WE WILL BE
WORKING WITH SENATE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE THE FINALIZE LANGUAGE
THAT REFLECTS THE NARROW SCOPE
OF THE BILL. I WANT TO THINK
AGAIN THE A COMMITTEE STAFFER
WORKING SO HARD ON THIS ENDS
WITH ME TODAY AS WITNESSES I
HAVE CHECKS NOW. FROM A SELL YOU
AND ALICIA BENNETT B. THIS LOOK
AT LOUIS- WHO SERVES ON THE
BOARD OF DIRECTORS FOR
CALIFORNIA LATINAS FOR
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE. GREAT
THANK YOU WITNESSES. MORNING MY
NAME IS JACOB SO A SENIOR STAFF
ATTORNEY AT THE ACLU OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA WHERE I WORK ON
PRIVACY SURVEILLANCE AND FREE
SPEECH ISSUES. I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF A SO YOU CALIFORNIA
ACTION- SPONSORS OF IT SAID BE
SEVEN NINETY THREE. AND LET'S
TALK ABOUT TWO ISSUES TODAY.
FIRST RIVERS DEMANDS ARE
EXTREMELY TROUBLING TWENTY FIRST
CENTURY VERSION OF THE GENERAL
WARRANT. WHICH INSPIRED THE FOR
THE FOURTH AMENDMENT- WHEN THE
BRITISH CAME WOULD RUMMAGE
THROUGH PEOPLE'S BELONGINGS AND
HOMES. MUCH LIKE GENERAL
WARRANTS AUTHORIZED UNRESTRICTED
SEARCHES WITHOUT ANY PROBABLE
CAUSE REVERSE DEMANDS GIVE THE
GOVERNMENT THE POWER TO FIND
EVERYONE WHO IS IN A PARTICULAR
PLACE AT A PARTICULAR TIME. OR
EVERYONE WHO SEARCHED FOR
PARTICULAR PHRASE. THAT ALLOWS
THE GOVERNMENT TO TRACK PEOPLE
AS THEY GO ABOUT THEIR LIVES
INCLUDING IS THE SEEK
REPRODUCTIVE OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE. THE TECHNICIAN WHO RIVERS
DEMANDS ARE INEFFECTIVE AND
THERE RISKY SURVEILLANCE TOOL
THAT THREATENS EVERYONE'S
PRIVACY. WHAT COMES TO
IDENTIFYING PEOPLE WHO MIGHT BE
CRIMINALS FOR RESTRAINTS ARE
GOOD INCREASING THE SIZE OF THE
HAYSTACK BUT THEY'RE NOT VERY
GOOD AT FINDING THE NEIL. FIRST
A MAN SAID GOOGLE EXAMPLE. MIGHT
REVEAL A HUNDRED AND FIFTY
PEOPLE WHO ARE IN A PARTICULAR
PLACE- BUT THAT DOESN'T GIVE YOU
VERY MUCH INFORMATION ABOUT WHO
THE PERSON WHO COULD BE A
SPECTER COMMUNITY CRIME WAS. AND
WHAT IF THE PERSON WHO WAS THE
ACTUAL SUSPECT. HAD AN IPHONE
FOUR WAS NOT CARRYING PHONES
TIME. THIS LEADS LAW ENFORCEMENT
CHASING DOWN A HUNDRED FIFTY
DEAD ENDS AND LEAVING THE
ACTUAL. A PERSON WHO'S WHO'S
BEING SEARCH FOR- COUNTY. EFFECT
IS PRODUCED CAN PUT PEOPLE AT
RISK HOWEVER BECAUSE THOSE
PEOPLE COULD HAVE BEEN SEEKING
REPRODUCTIVE OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE. AND THEIR INFORMATION IS
NOW IN THE HANDS OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT AND POTENTIALLY
PUTTING THEM IN HARM'S WAY.
STATES AROUND THE COUNTRY ARE
ATTACKING PEOPLE WHO NEED
REPRODUCTIVE AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. AND HAVING
INFORMATION ABOUT THOSE PEOPLE
IN THE HANDS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT
PUT THOSE PEOPLE AT RISK. SIX
ARE CRIMINALIZING PEOPLE FOUND
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS THAT MEANS
THAT PEOPLE'S RELATIONSHIP WITH
SURVEILLANCE HAS TO- CHANGE.
OCCURS AND I VOTE UNDERSTANDING
THE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT THE
LANGUAGE ARE CONTINUING. AMONG
VERY STABLE STAKEHOLDERS. AS YOU
WORK TO FIND A LANGUAGE TO FOCUS
THE BILL OR PEOPLE SEEKING
REPRODUCTIVE AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. THE STAKEHOLDERS
INCLUDE THE AUTHOR'S OFFICE THE
SPONSORS. AND LARGE COALITION.
OF CIVIL RIGHTS REPRODUCTIVE
RIGHTS AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
GROUPS SUPPORT THE BILL. THANKS
VERY MUCH THANK YOU. GOOD
MORNING TURN MEMBER ONLY OF YOU
TO LOUIS HE ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA
LATINAS. FOR REPRODUCTIVE
JUSTICE RIGHT PROBABLY SO. BOARD
MEMBERS. STAFF WAS UNABLE TO
ATTEND TODAY DUE TO URGENT
TRAINING WORK TAKING PLACE. IS A
PRESSING TIMES AN ADVOCATE
CAPACITY IS UNDERSTANDABLY
LIMITED. SEALER JAMES A
STATEWIDE ORGANIZATION
COMMITTING TO HONORING THE
EXPERIENCES OF LATINAS AND
ADVANCING REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE
WHAT THE INTERSECTIONAL SCOPE-
SOCIAL JUSTICE LENS THAT PEOPLE
CAN DECIDE WHEN IF AND HOW TO
START THEIR FAMILIES. FEEL RJ
ALONG WITH NUMEROUS OTHER
REPRODUCTIVE ORGANIZATIONS AND
ADVOCATES THE STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS MEASURE. WE KNOW THERE'S
BEEN A LOT OF WORK TO DRAFT A
BILL THAT FOCUSES LANGUAGE ON
THE WAY THE AUTHOR COMMITTED IN
EARLIER IN THE ASSEMBLY. AND
THAT WORK CONTINUES TO MOVE
FORWARD. I'M HERE TODAY TO RE
CENTER US AS TO WHY IT'S
IMPERATIVE THAT WE CONTINUE
MOVING THIS MEASURE. AND
REAFFIRM OUR COMMITMENT TO
ENSURING CALIFORNIA LIVES UP TO
THE PROMISE OF BEING A TRUE
SANCTUARY STATE FOR THOSE
SEEKING REPRODUCTIVE AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. WE KNOW THAT IN
ORDER TO DELIVER ON THAT PROMISE
REPRODUCTIVE CARE MUST BE
AVAILABLE ACCESSIBLE AND FREE
FROM DRAGNET SURVEILLANCE THAT
EXPOSES PEOPLE'S HEALTH CARE
DECISIONS TO LAW ENFORCEMENT.
WELL SO MUCH HAS BEEN DONE TO
ADDRESS AVAILABILITY AND ACCESS.
AB SEVEN NINETY THREE TAKES THE
STEPS NECESSARY TO ADDRESS THAT
THIRTY VITAL COMPONENT. TAKING
REVERSE DEMANDS OFF THE TABLE
FROM INFORMATION FROM WHICH ONE
FIRST ENFORCEMENT. CAN INFER
ABOUT WHO SOUGHT RECEIVED
SUPPORTED OR PROVIDED
REPRODUCTIVE OUR GENDER FROM
HEALTH CARE WAS SOLIDIFIED
CALIFORNIA'S PLACE AS A
PROTECTOR OF PEOPLE. SEEKING
THIS KIND OF HEALTH CARE
SERVICES AND PROVIDE NEEDED
CLARITY TO COMPANIES. AS MANY
LOOK TO CALIFORNIA AS A SAFE
HAVEN TO SEEK OR RECEIVE
REPRODUCTIVE OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE. REFERS TO ME AS OF THIS
NATURE AND DANGER THAT SAFETY.
THEY GIVE OUT OF STATE LAW
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES SEEKING TO
INVESTIGATE OR PROSECUTE MORAL
PEOPLE ABROAD TOOL TO SECRETLY
GATHER PRIVATE INFORMATION AND
IDENTIFYING INFORMATION. AND AS
WE'VE ALREADY SEEN. WITH OTHER
FORMS OF SURVEILLANCE EVEN WENT
CALIFORNIA LAW PROHIBITS SHARING
IT FOR. WITH THE STATE'S
CALIFORNIA FOUR AGENCIES HAVE
STILL CONTAIN DO SO SOME CERTAIN
. WE STRONGLY URGE HER AYE VOTE
AND HELP FULL POPULATIONS YOU.
THANK OTHER WITNESSES SUPPORT
THIS IS THE ME TOO. LESLIE
CALDWELL HOUSTON FOR THE- SCHISM
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC DEFENDER'S
OFFICE IN SUPPORT. BAKER KRAMER
MATTER ON BEHALF OF A FULL IN
HOUSE LAWYERS FOR REPRODUCTIVE
JUSTICE AND ELECTRONIC FRONTIER
FOUNDATION BOTH CO SPONSORS. AS
WELL AS FOR IMMIGRANT LEGAL
RESOURCE CENTER AND GREEN
LIGHTING IN SUPPORT. HI TRACY
ROSENBERG ON BEHALF OF OAKLAND
PRIVACY IN SUPPORT. J. CENTRAL
TO HER ABOUT THIS TECHNIQUE IN
STRONG SUPPORT. BERMAN ANY OTHER
SUPPORT IN THE ROOM. OKAY NOW
WE'LL HEAR FROM- THE PRIMARY
OPPOSITION- GOOD MORNING TEN
MEMBERS KIM STONE OF STONE
ADVOCACY ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
ASSOCIATION WE DO APPRECIATE THE
AUTHORS OF COMMITMENT TO LIMIT
THE BILL TO ABORTION GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE THE DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S. ASSOCIATION HAS NO
INTEREST IN- PROMOTING- SEARCHES
OR ADAMS INVESTIGATING FOR
COMING PERFECTLY LAWFUL ACTIVITY
DESPITE THE FACT THAT WE HAVE AN
AGREEMENT OVER THE MINDS OF THE
PRINCIPLES OF THE BILLS- AS IS
OFTEN THE CASE WITH LAWYERS AND
WE HAVE HAD MULTIPLE MEETINGS
WITH MULTIPLE LAWYERS OVER
MULTIPLE DAYS. AT SOME OF WHICH
YOUR STAFF IS HAD THE- GOOD
FORTUNE TO ATTEND AND HAVE NOT
YET- REACHED AGREEMENT ON
LANGUAGE THAT DOES LIMITS- THE
BILL TO ABORTION AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE- THE BILL
IMPRINTS PROHIBITS THE USE OF
THESE WARRANTS IN ALL CASES SO
EVEN IF THERE WAS LIKE A BOMBING
OF A PLANNED PARENTHOOD. THE LAW
ENFORCEMENT WHO IS TRYING TO
INVESTIGATE WHO BOMBS THE
PLANNED PARENTHOOD WOULD NOT TO
BE ABLE TO TRY TO FIND OUT WHO
WAS THERE BY TRYING TO LOOK UP
CELL PHONE DATA OR- FIRST
WARRANT SEARCHES. WE UNDERSTAND
THAT IS NOT WITH THE AUTHOR
INTENDS TO DO- BUT THE LANGUAGE
IN PRINT DOES DO THAT AND SO WE-
WE REMAIN OPPOSED BY ACCIDENT
THE BILL MOVE ON WE WILL
CONTINUE. NEGOTIATIONS THANK YOU
. ANY OTHER MAJOR WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION. ARE YOU ARE ARE YOU
LISTED AS A PRIMARY PHYSICIAN
ASSISTED ME TOO ME TOO ME TOO
OKAY GO AHEAD. SURE MEMBERS
JONATHAN FELDMAN WITH THE
CALIFORNIA POLICE CHIEFS
ASSOCIATION YOU KNOW WE ALSO
APPRECIATE WHAT THE AUTHOR IS
TRYING TO DO HERE WE HAVEN'T GOT
THEIR OWN LANGUAGE BUT WE HAVE
THE SAME POSITION AS THE DA'S
WE'RE NOT INTERESTED IN-
INVESTIGATING TOP PEOPLE SEEKING
ABORTIONS OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE HERE- SO WE HOPE WE CAN
FIND THAT BALANCE. THANK YOU.
NOT INSURANCE ENTERS MATTHEW
SETTLING ON BEHALF THE
ASSOCIATION FOR LOS ANGELES
DEPUTY SHERIFFS IN THE
CALIFORNIA PEACE OFFICERS
ASSOCIATION THANK THE AUTHOR
STAFF ON THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR
HARD WORK. NO TO CONTINUE TRYING
TO THREAD THE NEEDLE ON THIS
BILL THANK YOU. RIGHT ANY ME TO
USE ON THAT OTHER ME TOOS
WITHOUT ANYTHING BUT TO ME TO.
PLEASE THANK YOU FOR. MARIO A.
THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY SHERIFF'S
DEPARTMENT ON BEHALF OF SURE
ROBERT LUNA OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED. ANY OTHERS. RIGHT
MONTEREY KEEP UP THE PHONE LINES
PLEASE. FOR SUPPORTER OPPOSITION
AB SEVEN THREE PRESS ONE AND
ZERO. WILL GO TO LINE TWENTY. I
AM. GRATEFUL FOR THE APPLE CAL.
AND. GO TO NINE SEVEN SEVEN. BUT
WITH CAPITOL AVENUE ON OF THE OF
THE OF OR COUNTY SHERIFFS THE
CALIFORNIA FOR ORDER OF POLICE.
THE CALIFORNIA STATE LONG FOR AT
THE LONG BEACH POLICE UP
ASSOCIATION THE FACT MY COUNTY
TO SURE BEFORE. AND THE THING
BERNADINE COUNTY EMPLOYEE BUT
ASSOCIATION OF IN AND OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED. WE'LL GO TO LINE
EIGHTY. HELLO PROSECUTORS ARE
BEHALF OF THE VIDEO BROTHERLY IN
WITH OPPOSITION THANK YOU. WE'LL
GO TO LINE. TWENTY SEVEN. ONLY
THREE FOUR BEHALF YEAH. SOME
PEOPLE. WE'LL GO TO LINE SIXTY.
TOP OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
OF SOCIAL WORKERS CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER WHICH STRONGLY SUPPORTS
ITSELF THANK YOU. I'M GOING TO
LINE. SEVENTY ONE. THANKS
EVERYONE YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HOW
DID YOU I'M QUITE PREPARED
READING ASSOCIATES ON BEHALF OF
THE PEACE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
OF CALIFORNIA FOR ACT AND THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
HIGHWAY PATROLMEN C. H. P. IN
OPPOSITION. MADAM CHAIR WE HAVE
NO THIS OFFICE. I HAVE A NEED TO
FOR CAN I DO IT QUICKLY SORRY A
SAN DIEGO DEPUTY ATTORNEY SAYS
IS DIEGO I GUESS CRIME THANK YOU
. ALL RIGHT SO WE'RE NEVER TO
THE DIE. THAT I WILL- ASSEMBLY
MEMBER BY THANK YOU FOR THIS
THIS. YOU KNOW I REALIZE THAT-
SO OR- IT'S KIND OF THREADING
THE NEEDLE ON THE RIGHT LANGUAGE
ALWAYS TRUE AND I CAN. WHAT ON
ONE LEVEL WHAT IS TRYING TO BE-
IT. WHAT D. AND OTHERS ARE
TRYING TO YOU KNOW MAKE SURE
THIS DOESN'T DO BUT I THINK THAT
FOR MY FOR MY POINT OF VIEW THE
IMPORTANCE OF WHAT IT DOES DO.
IS WHAT'S- WHAT NEEDS TO PREVAIL
HERE BECAUSE WHEN WE HAVE THE
CIRCUMSTANCE THAT WE HAVE AS YOU
POINTED OUT WHERE- WE WHERE
STATES ARE CRIMINALIZING PEOPLE
FOR THINGS THAT ARE ESSENTIAL
HEALTHCARE IN COMPLETELY LEGAL
IN CALIFORNIA THERE SHOULD BE NO
ABILITY TO USE. THESE ARE CRAZY
DEVICES TO TRACK THEM DOWN AND-
IN CARD CRIMINALIZE THEM SO I
COMPLETELY SUPPORT THE BILL I AM
BEING CHAIR RIGHT NOW WHILE YOU
CONTINUE TO THE- REAL CHAIR SO I
CAN MOVE THE BILL. AND I MOVE IT
THANK YOU- ANY CLOSING OF
SERVICE TO WE JUST GOT INTO A
CAR ACCIDENT TO THE YEAH
COMMITTEE COMEDIA. SO AM. I
APPRECIATE INTO- AND WELCOME AND
MEMBER BY THE- HAVE TO HAVE YOU
HERE. I APPRECIATE THE INTO OF
PER- MEDICAL- I REALLY DO IN IN
THAT REGARD THE CONCERN THAT I
HAVE- AND I APPRECIATE THE
WITNESSES THE FIRST WITNESSES-
WITH REGARDS TO THE COMMENTS- IN
AB PROTECTING- AT THE PRIVACY OF
AB AND MORTON SEARCHES. FOR
PERSONAL HOMES AND JUST KEEPING
THAT PRIVACY FIRM I AM SO NOT A
BIG BROTHER KIND OF A PERSON-
AND THIS CASE. I APPRECIATE THAT
THE CONCERN THAT I HAVE RIGHT
NOW IN SUPPORTING THE BILL- IN
THE COMMITTEE IS THE FACT THAT.
WE DON'T. HAVE ANY- ANY LANGUAGE
IT JUST GOING AND IT'S THE IT
JUST KEEPS PASSING WITH THE
FAITH IT WILL BE. AT RESULTED
SOME POINT I WHICH I HOPE THAT
IT DOES BY THE TIME IT GETS TO
THE FLOOR- BUT I HAVEN'T SEEN-
WE HAVEN'T SEEN ANYTHING
CONCRETE DO YOU HAVE ANY
ESTIMATE. AS TO WHEN WE COULD
SEE THE ACTUAL LANGUAGE- FOR IT
THE BILL IN ADDRESSING THE
CONCERNS SO THAT WE DON'T.
IMPEDE THE UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES OF THE BILL WHICH
WOULD BE THE INABILITY TO TRACK-
CRIMINALS THAT ENGAGED IN HUMAN
TRAFFICKING- IN OTHER CRIMES SO.
DO YOU HAVE ANY ESTIMATE AS TO
WHEN WE COULD SEE THAT LANGUAGE
WITH THAT WOULD BE READILY
AVAILABLE FOR US TO SEE. SURE I
MEAN FIRST JUST TO CLARIFY THERE
ARE CERTAINLY A LOT OF THAT TOOL
STILL AVAILABLE TO LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO BE ABLE TO PURSUE
ISSUES RELATED TO HUMAN
TRAFFICKING BOMBING ANY OF THE
SORT. THOSE AGE OLD AT
ENFORCEMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN USED
FOR THE PAST HUNDRED YEARS IN
LAW ENFORCEMENT- INCLUDING
SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION WARRANTS
OR THE ABILITY TO. HAVE LAW
ENFORCEMENT BE ABLE TO STILL
WITH A AN IDENTIFIED PERSON BE
ABLE TO IDENTIFY PARTICULAR
DEVICE AND SEEK INFORMATION
FURTHER INFORMATION ABOUT THAT-
GATHERING SURVEILLANCE
INFORMATION. THROUGH AT THAT
AUTOMATIC LICENSE PLATE
RECORDERS FROM. FROM BODY
CAMERAS WHAT WHATEVER IT MIGHT
BE- THE INTENTION IS TO BE ABLE
TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE
THAT IN THERE ARE MANY VERSIONS
OF THIS IN. IN IN DRAFT FORM
ALREADY HAVE PRIOR TO THAT THE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE WHICH WILL
HAVE TO GO TO. SO BUT THREE DO
YOU. HAVE THE DRAFT LANGUAGE
AVAILABLE. WE HAVE A VERSION OF
DR LANGUAGE THAT IS. DOES NOT
MEET THE- COMMITMENT THAT I MADE
RIGHT NOW TO ENSURE THAT ITS AND
NARROWLY SCOPED IN A WAY THAT.
ENSURES THAT THE SPONSORS AND
STAKEHOLDERS OF THE BILL ARE
COMFORTABLE WITH AND THAT IS.
REALLY KIND OF STRIKES A BALANCE
OF PROVIDING A BROAD ENOUGH
PROTECTION TO OUR CIVIL
LIBERTIES AS WE SEEK. MEDICAL AT
TREATMENT AND CARE ABOUT WHILE
ALSO ENSURING THAT LAW
ENFORCEMENT HAS THE ABILITY TO
USE THIS UNDER CERTAIN
CIRCUMSTANCES. THE BILL IN PLACE
RIGHT NOW AS WE SEE IT- THE
INTENT OF THE BILL PROTECTING
THE PRIVACY AND THE IMPORTANCE
OF- REJECTING MEDICAL. PRIVACY
FOR INDIVIDUALS I THINK IT'S
ALSO MERITS THE- OPPOSING SIDE
OF HOW VALUABLE THIS IS. IN A AS
A TOOL FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT TO BE
ABLE TO LOCATE HUMAN TRAFFICKERS
AND MISSING CHILDREN WHICH IS
WHY I AM VERY VERY CAREFUL AND
MAKE ENSURING THAT WE DON'T LOSE
THIS IS A TWO FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT AS WE MOVE FORWARD.
SO IT'S EQUALLY IMPORTANT WEEK
EIGHT WHICH IS WHY YOU HAVE THIS
FAILED TRYING TO USE THAT TO
PROTECT. THOSE USING SORRY-
THOSE INDIVIDUALS. AS IS AS A
TOOL TO DO THE OTHER PART SO I'M
I'M GONNA RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE
THE BILL TODAY. BUT I LOOK
FORWARD TO LOOKING AT THE
LANGUAGE AND I HOPE I REALLY DO
HOPE THAT THERE IS A LANGUAGE OF
THE COMES TOGETHER. HE WOULD
DRASTIC CIRCUMSTANCE- PROTECT
MEDICAL PRIVACY AS WELL AS
ENSURING THAT WE HAVE IT AS A
VALUABLE. INDISPENSABLE TOOL FOR
HUMAN TRAFFICKING AND MISSING
CHILDREN THANK YOU. THANK YOU
SENATOR- ASSEMBLY MEMBER WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
VOTES. WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
ON THIS AND BELIEVE THAT WE WILL
BE ABLE TO STRIKE THAT- VERY A
CAREFUL BALANCE THAT WE NEED TO
ENSURE THAT WE ARE NOT ONLY
PROTECTING OUR MEDICAL PRIVACY.
BUT ALSO OUR CIVIL LIBERTIES OUR
FOURTH AMENDMENT RIGHTS AGAINST
. UNREASONABLE SEARCH AND
SEIZURES. AS WELL AS BEING ABLE
TO IN THAT. HAVE THE FOR- FOR AT
THE- AT. A STOP THEIR THANK YOU
THE BILL BEEN MOVED BY SENATORS
. CAN CALL THE MOTION IS TO PASS
YOU JUST TO DO COMMITTEE WILL
HOP ON HOP OFF OWE TO ABOUT. THE
JOB NOW FRED. SKINNER HI SKINNER
WIENER. WIENER AYE. THANK YOU
THAT BILLS CALL ASSEMBLY- BEFORE
WE MOVE TO A ELEVEN SIX I JUST
LIKE TO ADD MY TO- LET THE CALL
FOR BI SIX FIFTEEN. ITEM NUMBER
. NINE MOTIONS TO APPROPRIATIONS
VOTE THREE DAYS ONE. BY HOP I
BURKE. NORTH YEAH. A. B. C.
NINE. NO KETUBAH. ON THE IS
FORTY ONE THE BILL IS OUT. WITH
THE CONTROLS YES I CAN WE THE
CALL FOR ITEM TWO TWO A. TEN
NINE. MOTIONS TO PASS TO DO TO
HERE COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU CHEN MEMBERS I WOULD
LIKE TO EXPRESS MY APPRECIATION
TO YOUR COMMITTEE STAFFER THEIR
TIME WORKING ON THIS BILL I
AUTHORED THIS BILL BECAUSE OUR
CURRENT YOUTH RESTITUTION SYSTEM
IS BROKEN RESTITUTION WAS MEANT
TO MAKE CRIME SURVIVORS HOLE BUT
IN REALITY IT'S JUST CREATING A
PERPETUAL CYCLE OF DEBT
ESPECIALLY FOR POOR BLACK AND
BROWN FAMILIES YOUNG PEOPLE AND
THEIR FAMILIES CANNOT AFFORD TO
PAY RESTITUTION AND FACE
SIGNIFICANT FINANCIAL BURDENS
FROM THESE ORDERS. THE INABILITY
TO PAY RESTITUTION OFTEN CREATES
LONG LASTING FINANCIAL HARM AN
INSTABILITY THAT PREVENTS YOUNG
PEOPLE FROM MOVING FORWARD IN
THEIR LIVES THE SYSTEM IS NOT
WORKING FOR CRIME SURVIVORS
EITHER EACH YEAR ABOUT TWELVE
THOUSAND USED IN CALIFORNIA- ARE
ORDERED TO PAY RESTITUTION THE
AVERAGE AMOUNT OF RESTITUTION
ORDERED IS ABOUT FIFTEEN HUNDRED
AND FIFTY NINE DOLLARS HOWEVER
HOWEVER BECAUSE MOST USE CANNOT
PAY. ONLY A FRACTION OF CRIME
SURVIVORS EVER RECEIVED ANY
COMPENSATION PUBLIC RATE RECORDS
DATA INDICATE THAT- SHOWS THAT
STATEWIDE ONLY ABOUT 20% OF USE
RESTITUTION ORDERED SINCE TWENTY
TEN HAS BEEN COLLECTED. MUCH OF
THE OUTSTANDING USE RESTITUTION
OWED IN YEARS AGO IN YEARS OLD
AN UNLIKELY IS YEARS OLD AND
UNLIKELY EVER TO BE PAID. TO ADD
TO ALL THIS MANY YOUNG PEOPLE
WHO CAUSE HARM OUR CRIME
SURVIVORS THEMSELVES AND WHO
HAVE EXPERIENCED TRAUMA. AB
ELEVEN EIGHT EIGHTY SIX THE
REPAIR ACT. FIXES THIS BROKEN
SYSTEM. AB ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX
ELIMINATES THE EXISTING SYSTEM
OF DIRECT RESTITUTION FOR YOUTH
AND MAKES CRIME SURVIVORS HARMED
BY YOUTH ELIGIBLE FOR FINANCIAL
ASSISTANCE. THROUGH THE
CALIFORNIA VICTIM COMPENSATION
BOARD. USE WILL BE ORDERED TO
PARTICIPATE IN NON MONETARY
ALTERNATIVES TO ENCOURAGE
REFLECTION ON THE IMPACTS OF
THEIR ACTIONS INCLUDING
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE CONFERENCES
COMMUNITY SERVICE PROGRAMS SKILL
BUILDING AND JOB OPPORTUNITIES.
AB ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX MAKES ARE
YOU SOURCES TEACHERS IN THE
SYSTEM WORK BETTER FOR EVERYONE
BOTH FOR CRIME SURVIVORS AND
YOUTH WHO- RESTITUTION BY
PROVIDING CRIME SURVIVORS WITH
MORE EQUITABLE TIMELY AND STABLE
COMPENSATION. AND SETTING BOTH
THE YOUNG PERSON AND THE HARM TO
PERSON ON A STRONGER PATH
TOWARDS MEANINGFUL
ACCOUNTABILITY REHABILITATION
AND HEALING. THANK YOU AND IS
WITNESSES TODAY I HAVE ARTISTS
WHITE WHO IS A DREAM BEYOND BARS
FELLOW WITH COURAGE. AND YOU
ONLY HAVE ONE WITNESS ONE
WITNESS YOU WILL HAVE TWO
MINUTES THANK YOU. I'M A
COMMUNITY ORGANIZER WITH
COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE USE JUSTICE AND THE
YOUNG WOMEN'S FREEDOM CENTER.
I'M A JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEMS
IMPACTING YOUNG PERSON AS A
YOUTH I EXPERIENCED FIRSTHAND
THE HARMFUL EFFECTS OF
RESTITUTION GROWING UP POOR I
FACE ALL TYPES CHALLENGES
ESPECIALLY WHEN IT CAME TO BASIC
NEEDS. SUCH AS FOOD HOUSING I
VIVIDLY REMEMBER A TIME IN NINTH
GRADE WHEN MY FRIENDS AND I WILL
LEAVE THE HIGH SCHOOL CAMPUS FOR
LUNCH WHAT I COULD AFFORD TO PAY
FOR FOOD MY STOMACH WILL GROW
WITH TENDER. AT THAT POINT AT
THE AGE OF FOURTEEN I FELT THE
NEED TO RESORT TO ILLEGAL
ACTIVITIES JUST TO FEED MYSELF.
SADLY THE DECISION IS STILL LED
TO MY FIRST INTERACTION WITH THE
JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM AND
INCARCERATION THROUGHOUT THE
LEGAL PROCEEDINGS I WAS NEVER
ASKED WHAT RESOURCES I NEEDED.
INSTEAD I WAS CRIMINALIZED WHICH
PUSHED ME FURTHER INTO POVERTY
AT SEVENTEEN YEARS OLD I WAS
HOMELESS PROBATION WASN'T
HELPING ME SO I ENDED UP GOING
BACK TO JUVENILE HALL SO THAT I
COULD QUALIFY FOR FOSTER CARE AB
TWO OF HOUSING. AGAIN I WAS
CHARGED WITH RESTITUTION FEES
WHICH FOR A SEVENTEEN YEAR OLD
ARE EXTREMELY DIFFICULT TO PAY.
EVEN THOUGH I WORK IT'S STILL
NOT ENOUGH TO SURVIVE THIS
SYSTEM LET ME TO DROP OUT OF
HIGH SCHOOL DUE TO INCARCERATION
AND THEY NEED TO MAKE MONEY AND
WORK. AND NOW RESTITUTION DATE
COULD HINDER MY ABILITY TO
SECURE HOUSING A GOOD CREDIT
WHEN MY FOSTER CARE HOUSING
EXPIRES. IT IS WORTH MENTIONING
THAT IN THE CASE FOR WHICH I
CURRENTLY OWE RESTITUTION NO
THIRD PARTY WAS HARM YET I WAS
STILL ORDERED TO PAY WHICH IS
SUPPOSED TO BE FOR MAKING A
PERSON HOLDEN. USED OFTEN RESORT
TO COMMITTING CRIMES TO PAY OFF
RESTITUTION HAS SURVIVED. AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY SIX TO REPLACE USE
RESTITUTION WITH STATE FUNDS FOR
SURVIVORS OF CRIME WHICH WOULD
REDUCE BARRIERS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE
TRYING TO GET BACK ON THEIR
FEET. AND STREAMLINED SUPPORT
FOR FAMILIES WHO ARE IMPACTED.
PLEASE VOTE YES ON AB ELEVEN
EIGHTY SIX SO OTHERS. DO NOT
HAVE TO GO THROUGH WHAT I DID.
SO WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO MEET
USE THE NAME. MAYES AND THAT
USED. A WE LIKE TO MOVE THROUGH
THIS QUICKLY DETACHMENTS SMART
JUSTICE CALIFORNIA AND THE
PROSECUTORS LINES OF
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. PATTERSON
RAZA OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL
BONTA IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
CANNAGROW DARNELL NISHIOKA
JUSTICE LAWYERS COMMITTEE FOR
CIVIL RIGHTS THE TRANSFORMATIVE
IN PRISON A WORK GROUP AND
GUIDING REGION POWER IN SUPPORT
. ST LOUIS WILL LEGAL SERVICES
FOR PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN AS
CHILD SUPPORT. AS WELL AS THE
MAY HAVE BEEN COLLABORATIVE AND
DIGNITY AND POWER NOW THANK YOU
. THE FIRM DOES SO WITH THE
ELEVATORS AN AGREEMENT RIGHT AND
SUPPORT. A LITTLE ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIANS FOR SAFETY AND
JUSTICE PRO COSPONSOR AND
SUPPORT. LAWRENCE **** WITH
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS
WITH CHILDREN AND ALSO ALL OF US
IN ON HIS STRONG SUPPORT. HE
MELANIE CONCERNS GO PUBLIC
DEFENDER'S OFFICE CO SPONSOR AND
SUPPORT AND ON BEHALF OF THE SAN
FRANCISCO FINANCIAL JUSTICE
PROJECT ALSO A CO SPONSOR AND
SUPPORT. JUSTIN COLOR ONLY TO
COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S
OFFICE IN SUPPORT. IN OLYMPIA
ACLU CALIFORNIA ACTION IN
SUPPORT. RAYMOND JONES ON BEHALF
OF THE DREAM BEYOND BARS
FELLOWSHIP STRONG SUPPORT. ALEX
DEALS ON BEHALF OF THE
UNDERGROUND SCHOLARS INITIATIVE
AT UC BERKELEY HAS STRONG
SUPPORT. LESLIE CALDWELL HOUSTON
FOR THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
. SANATANA SANDCASTLE AND ON
BEHALF OF COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND STRONG
SUPPORT AS A CO SPONSOR THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT SEEING NO OTHER
WITNESSES CAN WE MOVE ON TO
OPPOSITION- YOU WILL HAVE TWO
MINUTES KIM STONE STAR ADVOCACY
ON BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION MARSY'S
LAW IN THE CALIFORNIA
CONSTITUTION DOES- GIVE VICTIMS
ARE RIGHT TO RESTITUTION. AND
NOT ALL KINDS OF CRIMES ARE
ELIGIBLE FOR RESTITUTION UNDER
THE VICTIM COMPENSATION BOARD
AND SO WE FEAR THAT SOME VICTIMS
MAY BE LEFT OUT AND THEREFORE
MUST STAND IN RESPECTFUL
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. THANK YOU
ON ANY OTHER OPPOSITION
WITNESSES THING NON MODERATOR
PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. NAME OR CLAIM THAT
YOU'VE SUPPORTER POSTS. BUT FOR
OPPOSITION FOR AB ELEVEN EIGHTY
SIX PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. GO TO
LINE TWENTY FIVE. GOOD MORNING
BURKE FRIENDS COMMITTEE-
LEGISLATION OF CALIFORNIA AND
STRONG SUPPORT. THE BOTTOM LINE
TWENTY SEVEN. AND ONLY THIRTY
ONE BEHALF OF YOUNGER THREE
INCENDIARY PARTICLES THERE AS
WELL AS THE STORY IF YOU CAN
COALITION STRUCK. FOR WE'LL GO
TO LINE TWENTY ONE. BRENT THE
GLOBAL STANDARD BEATING A LOT
THE COOKING OF THE DISFIGURED
REPORT OF JUSTICE PROGRAMS THE
COMMUNITY CO CREATOR OF THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S ABOUT THE
VERSION PROGRAM IN SUPPORT.
HELLO TO LINE SIXTY. THE COUPLE
FROM THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORKERS
CALIFORNIATRUSTSWOMEN STRONG
SUPPORT ITSELF WHICH- I. AM SURE
WE HAVE TO OFFER THE SUPPORT
OPPOSITION THANK YOU WILL MOVE
THE CONVERSATION TO COMMITTEE
MEMBERS SENATOR JOE BOGAN THANK
YOU. SO THERE'S A FINE BALANCE
ARIF I'VE BEEN VERY SUPPORTIVE
OF- MEASURES THAT HAVE TRIED TO
FIND THAT BALANCE OF HOLDING
PEOPLE ACCOUNTABLE AND ALSO-
GIVING VICTIMS THEIR OPPORTUNITY
TO BE- COMPENSATED. MY QUESTION
IN JUST FOR CLARIFICATION JUST
FOR THE- FOR THE IDEAS AND FOR
MYSELF- AS IT STANDS RIGHT NOW
IT AND I DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS
WHEN IT COMES TO THE RESTITUTION
THAT. THE YOU'D HAVE TO PAY BUT
IS THAT EQUIVALENT TO HOW DO
THEY HOW DOES THE RESTITUTION
COME TO BE HOW DO THEY DECIDE.
WHAT HOW MUCH THE YOUTH HAS TO
PAY. FIRST SO THAT'S MY FIRST
QUESTION AND THEN TO FOLLOW UP
THAT IN THE CASE M. OUR PARENTS
AT SUBJECT TO THOSE RESTITUTION
TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THIS ISSUE
WHEN THE YOUTH IS NOT. ABLE TO
PAY THAT BACK. SO YES PARENTS
ARE CURRENTLY LIABLE FOR THE
YOUTH RESTITUTION WHICH IS WHY
THIS IS THAT CHILDREN AND
FAMILIES- BILL ESSENTIALLY AT
JUST TO ADDRESS SOME OF THE
OTHER QUESTIONS THAT WERE RAISED
OR- COMMENTARY THAT WAS RAISED
UNDER MARSY'S LAW PROPPING PROP
NINE- THEY WERE UNAMBIGUOUSLY IN
LIMITING THE RIGHT TO SEEK AND
SECURE RESTITUTION. FROM PEOPLE
CONVICTED OF CRIMES NOT FROM
JUVENILES ADJUDICATED DELINQUENT
AND SO A USER RESTITUTION IS
ESSENTIALLY SET BASED ON- IN
ORDER DETERMINED BY THE JUDGE
RELATIVE TO THE- RELATIVE TO THE
HARM THAT WAS CAUSED. BY A AND
DETERMINING THE IN QUANTIFYING
BIT THE COST OF THAT THE COST OF
THAT- RESTITUTION- ON AVERAGE WE
KNOW THAT IT'S ABOUT FIFTEEN
HUNDRED DOLLARS TO BE ABLE TO DO
THAT- THE OTHER ISSUE IS THAT.
WE ARE ALREADY NOT ACTUALLY
ENSURING THAT VICTIMS HAVE THE
ABILITY TO BE COMPENSATED- THIS
LEADS TO MANY INSTANCES WHERE-
OVER EIGHTY PERCENT- IN THE LAST
S. SINCE TWENTY. TEN HAVE
ACTUALLY NOT RECEIVED THE
COMPENSATION THAT THEY SHOULD
HAVE RECEIVED FROM OUR FROM THIS
TO THE WAY THAT THE SYSTEM IS
SET UP RIGHT NOW IS THAT FROM
THE YOUTH. SO THERE'S IT CURRENT
IT SAID COMPANY FROM THE YOUTH
BY AT. BUT WE SPEND THREE POINT
LOCALITY SPEND ABOUT THREE POINT
ONE MILLION DOLLARS ANNUALLY TO
TRY TO COLLECT THAT RESTITUTION-
THEY'RE UNSUCCESSFUL IN DOING SO
AND- AND AS YOU HEARD FROM OUR
OUR WITNESS. WHO IS A USE THAT
THAT JUST FOLLOWS THEM AND THEIR
PARENTS SO THE RESTITUTION
DOESN'T HAVE TO BE PAID WHILE
THEY ARE IN THE JUVENILE JUSTICE
SYSTEM OR ON. PROBATION IT CAN
I'M TRYING TO FIND A HOWEVER
THEM THROUGH ADULTHOOD SO LET ME
ASK YOU SOMETHING WHEN THERE ARE
IN THE YOUTH FACILITY ARE THEY
ALLOWED TO WORK HOW ARE THEY
EXPECTED TO BE HOW DOES THE
COURT IN THE SYSTEM EXPECT. THE
USED TO PAY THIS RESTITUTION ARE
THEY ARE THEY SUPPOSED TO BE
WORKING WHILE THERE I'M IN THE
JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM. ARE
THEY SUPPOSED TO DO BE DOING
COMMUNITY SERVICE THAT EQUATES.
TO THE TO THE RESTITUTION THAT
IS- I'M ASSUMING THE JUDGE'S
DISCRETION. THE AMOUNT THAT IS
BEING. FELT NOT ALL YOUTH WHO
ARE ORDERED TO PAY RESTITUTION
ARE IN THE FACILITY. THEY ARE
SADDLED WITH DEBT THAT THEY NEED
TO PAY. I THINK THE COURTS ARE
ESSENTIALLY SILENT ON HOW THAT
GETS PAID WHAT WE KNOW IN
PRACTICE IS THAT YOUTH END UP
HAVING TO WORK A JOB WHILE THEY
ARE TRYING TO GO TO SCHOOL. THE
A. AS WE SHARED A SEEK TO BE
ABLE TO GAIN QUICK CASH WOULD
COULD COULD COULD CAUSE THEM TO.
COMMIT ANOTHER CRIME- INCREASING
THEIR LIKELIHOOD TO RECIDIVISM
IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT.
AND ARE ESSENTIALLY SADDLED WITH
DEBT HI THERE THEM AND THEIR
FAMILY TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE
THAT. PROVIDE THOSE FUNDS WHICH
THEY DON'T HAVE ALTERNATIVELY-
US CHILD WHO HAS THE ABILITY TO
OR FAMILY WHO HAS THE ABILITY TO
WRITE A CHECK. BASIS ABSOLUTELY
NO CONSEQUENCES FOR THERE'S NOT
ACTUALLY RIGHT NOW AN
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE MEANINGFUL
ACCOUNTABILITY. FOR USE- AND
IT'S ENTIRELY BASED ON WHETHER
OR NOT YOU HAVE THE ABILITY. TO
PAY THAT. SO THIRTY YOU
MENTIONED THE FOR THAT THERE
PARENTS ABLE TO WRITE A CHECK IN
JUST PAY THEIR- WE IS THE
RESPONSE. REALLY I WOULD SAY YOU
KNOW IF THE YOUTH IS NOT BE HELD
RESPONSIBLE BY THE PARENTS TO
PAY THAT RESTITUTION THREE JOBS.
OR THROUGH WHATEVER IT MEANS YOU
KNOW. FULLY AWARE OF MAKING THAT
MONEY TO PAY THAT RESTITUTION-
THEN THE PARENTS RESPONSIBILITY
AS AS A PARENT YEAR FALLS ON ME
ON ME TO USE TO MAKE THAT. THE
CASE WHETHER IT'S YOU KNOW. YOU
KNOW WRITING A CHECK IF YOU HAVE
THE ABILITY TO WRITE THE CHECK
OR TO WORK ACCESS TO MAKE SURE
THAT THAT- THAT THAT IS BEING
DONE IS A RESPONSIBILITY. I
THINK THE CONCERN THAT I HAVE IN
IN IN PRINCIPLE. IS THE FACT
THAT- IF WE REMOVE THIS AND I
UNDERSTAND THE CONCERNS THAT YOU
HAVE ABOUT THIS BEING CARRIED ON
IN AND- BEING ACROSS THAT THE-
CHILD OR THE YOU'D HAVE TO CARRY
THROUGH ADULTHOOD. I THINK THE
CONCERN THAT I HAVE IN PRINCIPLE
IS THE FACT THAT. IF WE DON'T
HOLD THE YOUTH ACCOUNTABLE
FINANCIALLY FOR WHATEVER.
FINANCIAL REPERCUSSIONS THEIR
ACTIONS MAY HAVE HAD. OR HOLD
APPEARANCE ACCOUNTABLE FOR
THEIR- THEIR CHILD'S. BEHAVIOR
I'M AS A RESPONSE REALLY VERY
THEIR PARENTS SHOULD BE- IS THAT
NOW. IF I UNDERSTAND THIS
CORRECTLY IT WILL NOW FALL ON
EVERY TAXPAYER. TO FILL THAT. AT
THAT RESPONSIBILITY. OF THAT
USED AND THAT PARENT IS NOW
FALLING ON EVERY TAXPAYER.
RESPONSIBILITY TO BE ABLE TO PAY
THAT IS THAT IS THAT THE WAY
THAT THE SYSTEM WOULD BE
CHANGING WITH THIS CONCURRENT
BILL MAKE NO MISTAKE IN THE
CURRENT SYSTEM RIGHT NOW EVERY
TAXPAYER IS PAYING. FOR THE
BROKEN SYSTEM AS I'VE STATED
THREE POINT ONE MILLION DOLLARS
A YEAR. IS SPENT BY LOCALITIES
TO TRY TO SEEK THAT RESTITUTION
SO EVERY TAXPAYER IS ALREADY NOT
BEING WELL SERVED BY THIS AND
QUITE FRANKLY AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
A USED TO HAVE MEANINGFUL
ACCOUNTABILITY THAT. LEADS TO-
OPPORTUNITIES TO PARTICIPATE IN
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE TO BE ABLE
TO PARTICIPATE IN YOUTH
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS TO BE ABLE
TO HAVE. A FULL OPPORTUNITY TO
UNDERSTAND THE CONSEQUENCES OF
THEIR ACTIONS AND TO SEEK
ACCOUNTABILITY THROUGH THE
OPPORTUNITY TO- TO BE
REHABILITATED IS A FAR BETTER.
MEASURE TO ENSURE THAT THAT.
COLLECTIVE COMMUNITY IS WELL
SERVED- AS WELL AS. THE PERSON
THE INDIVIDUAL WHO IS HARMED AT
AND- AND THE IN THE- WHO HAS
HARMED THE WHO HAS HARMED THEN-
THE SIMPLE ACT OF. IN INSTANCES
WHERE THEY CANNOT WRITING A
CHECK OR HAVING TO DEAL WITH THE
FINANCIAL COSTS AND CONSEQUENCES
OF BEING BURDENED WITH- BEING
BURDENED WITH DEBT OVER TIME.
WITHOUT A DOUBT I STEM FROM
BEING ABLE TO GET A JOB WHICH
KEEPS THEM FROM BEING ABLE TO-
OFTEN OF. OF GETTING BAD CREDIT
OF NOT BEING ABLE TO GET HOUSING
AN ACTION AND A DECISION THAT
THEY MAKE HAS FAR REACHING
IMPACTS ON THEIR ABILITY TO BE
WHOLE AND CONTRIBUTING MEMBERS
OF OUR COMMUNITY- FROM. HAS
YOUTH AND INTO ADULTHOOD AND
THAT IS NOT A PRACTICE THAT WE
SHOULD BE PROMOTING IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. COMMEMORATIVE FOR
THE RECORD I ABSOLUTELY AGREE
WITH YOU ON ON THE ALTERNATIVES
AND WHAT ARE YOU SHOULD BE
HAVING OR EXPERIENCING YOUR TO
BE PRODUCTIVE. CITIZENS OF THE
COMMUNITY ABSOLUTE WITHOUT A
DOUBT I THINK THE COULD THAT
CONSEQUENCE- THE CONCERN THAT I
HAVE RIGHT NOW IS THE WAY THAT-
IT THIS BILL WOULD. REQUIRE RE
ORGANIZE IT. I DON'T IS A BETTER
. WITH REGARDS THE FINANCIAL
COMPONENT OF IT I'M NOT SURE
THAT- THE TAXPAYERS WOULD BE IN
A BETTER POSITION EITHER WHETHER
ONE WAY I'M NOT SURE THAT. THIS
IS THE OLD AND I HAVE TO LOOK AT
I HAVEN'T LOOKED INTO THE SPACE
A LITTLE FURTHER BUT I DON'T
THINK THAT THIS IS- THIS FIXES
THAT THE THEIR FINANCIAL BURDEN.
ON THE TAXPAYER REPEATING THREE
ONE POINT MILLION IN THE CURRENT
SYSTEM BUT I'M KIND OF CURIOUS
TO SEE WHAT IT WOULD LOOK LIKE
WITH THIS NEW SYSTEM WITH A
TAXPAYERS ALSO BEING
RESPONSIBLE. FOR THAT FINANCIAL
RESTITUTION SO I COMPLETELY
AGREE WITH THE MERIT OF THE
RESTORATIVE. EDUCATIONAL
OPPORTUNITIES THAT YOU MENTIONED
ABSOLUTELY WITHOUT A DOUBT I AM
1100% ON ON THAT ON THAT ON THAT
END. BUT THE FINANCIAL. COST OF
IT. I THINK WILL PROBABLY BE
VERY SIMILAR- WITHOUT REGARD
WITH NO. WITH NO PERSONAL
RESPONSIBILITY ON THE PARENTS I
HOPE. REALLY TAKE- APPLAUSE AT
THE IDEA THAT PARENTS ARE NOT A
PERSON IS SEEKING PERSONAL ARE
NOT INVOLVED PERSONALLY AND
TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR. THE
ACTIONS OF THEIR OF THEIR
CHILDREN WHEN THEY ARE NEEDING
TO BE ABLE TO SUPPORT THEIR
CHILD IN SEEKING ALTERNATIVE
MEANS OF ACCOUNTABILITY BEYOND A
FINANCIAL. ON THE FINANCIAL
INCENTIVE AND THE REALITY IS
THAT OUR PARENTS AND OUR
TAXPAYERS ARE ARE PAYING AND
VICTIMS ARE NOT RECEIVING THESE
FUNDS EITHER SO IF WE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE TO
REORGANIZE. AS YOU SAID THE
CALIFORNIA VICTIM COMPENSATION
BOARD PAYMENT SO THAT VICTIMS
CAN ACTUALLY RECEIVE THE MONEY
THAT THEY HAVE THAT THEY DON'T
GET. RE INJURED EVERY SINGLE
TIME THEY DON'T GET A CHECK-
THAT THE GET REINJURED EVERY
SINGLE TIME THEY HAVE THEIR HARM
NOT ACTUALLY TAKING CARE OF I
THINK THAT THOSE THAT WERE
MOVING IN THE STEP IN A STEP IN
THE RIGHT DYRRACHIUM THING ARE
FINALIZED MY COMMENTS WITH THE
FACT THAT. I BELIEVE
WHOLEHEARTEDLY IN THE MERIT OF
THE BILL I'M NOT SURE THAT
FINANCIALLY- IT IT WORKS FOR ME
WITH REGARDS TO I DON'T THINK A
LOT OF TEXTURES WOULD AGREE THAT
FINANCIALLY IT'S GOING TO BE-
DIFFERENT. ON THE TAXPAYER I
THINK IT'S THE SAME THING
WITHOUT THE RESPONSIBILITY
COMPONENT OF FINANCIAL- OWNING
OF THE OF THE ACTIONS THAT WITH
THAT I'M STUDY I'VE SEEN ON THE
BILL BECAUSE I DO BELIEVE IN THE
MERITS. BUT I DO NOT BELIEVE
THAT- IT'S GOING TO BE A BETTER
SYSTEM NECESSARILY LIKE TO LOOK
A LITTLE BIT FURTHER ON THAT
THANK YOU SENATOR- NO FURTHER
COMMENTS ASSEMBLY MEMBER WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU I
THINK IT'S TIME TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE CREATE A YOUTH
RESTITUTION. REDUCE RESTITUTION
SYSTEM THAT BETTER SUPPORTS
CRIME SURVIVORS AND ARE USE AND
THEIR FAMILIES AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR VOTE
THANK YOU- DO WE HAVE ANY
MOTIONS. THE MOTION. MOTIONS
THANK YOU SENATOR WINNER HAS
MOVED. THINK OF A- AB LEVY SIX
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS BOB HI BOB BY.
JOB BRADFORD. SKINNER WIENER
I'VE WIENER I THANK YOU THAT ON
CALL PROCEDURE TH SO I JUST WANT
TO SAY FOR THOSE THAT BEEN
WAITING IN THE AUDIENCE ARE NEXT
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS IS SUPPOSED TO
BE ASSEMBLY MEMBER BERMAN-
PRESENTING. AB FOURTEEN TWENTY I
SAW HIM EARLIER NOT SURE IF HE'S
HERE OR NOT HERE- NEXT WOULD BE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BAUER QUE HAN.
AB THREE OH ONE ASAR EARLIER NOT
SURE IF HE'S STILL HERE.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER OF THE APPROVED
WHILE. SORRY I BUTCHERED YOUR
NAME- SEVEN OH ONE- AND THEN-
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FONG SEVEN
THIRTY TWO AND SEVEN THIRTY
THREE AND THEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER
KALRA- SO I WILL GO FIRST WITH
AT ASSEMBLY MEMBER IF. YOU WOULD
LIKE TO PRESENT ON SEVEN A ONE.
THE YEAR MEMBERS. I AM PROUD TO
PRESENT AB SEVEN ONE TO CRACK
DOWN ON FEB EPIDEMIC AND SAVE
LIVES CALIFORNIA. I THINK BY NOW
WE ALL KNOW THE STATISTICS. THAT
NO IS FIFTY TIMES STRONGER THAN
HEROIN HAS BEEN RESPONSIBLE 483%
OF THE OPIOIDS RELATED DEATHS.
IN THE STATE OVER THE RECENT
YEARS. WE ALL HEARD ABOUT AND
SEEN THE CHILLING EFFECTS THIS
POISON HOUSE ACROSS OUR STREETS
IN EVERY DISTRICT. IT KNOW
TRAFFICKERS HAVE. EXASPERATED
OPIOIDS ADDICTIONS THROUGHOUT
THE STATE. SO IT IS TIME TO
START HOLDING THEM ACCOUNTABLE
FOR THE DESTRUCTION THAT COSTS
A. B. SEVEN OH ONE PROVIDES
EQUITY. AND CLOSES THE LOOPHOLE
LIPPOLD FOR HALLOWEEN FENNEL
COMPARE TO OTHER DANGEROUS
SUBSTANCE. MEMBERS IS SIMPLY
DOESN'T MAKE SENSE THAT OUR
JUDGES SYSTEM IS MORE. LENIENT
ON ON DISPLAYS THE COMPARE TO
OTHER SUBSTANCES THAT ARE FAR
LESS LETHAL. BY ADDRESSING THIS
DESPERATE THIS DISCREPANCY WE
CAN BE WE CAN BEGIN TO SHOW HOW
FAMILIES CRY FAMILIES CRYING FOR
HELP THAT WE ARE TOWARD ARE
TAKING THIS GET THIS CRISIS VERY
SERIOUS. A. B. SEVEN ONE
ESTABLISHES A HIGH POSITION
THRESHOLD OF ONE KILO ALLOWING
US TO TARGET THE TRAFFICKERS AT
A HIGH LEVEL DEALERS RATHER THAN
THE USERS WITH ME TO TESTIFY
TODAY. IS OUR SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY RON FREITAS.
GOOD MORNING COMMITTEE MEMBERS
THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME THIS
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CARLOS BILL COULD WAS ASSEMBLY
BILL SEVENTY ONE. AS YOU ELECTED
DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF SAN JOAQUIN
COUNTY I SEE FIRSTHAND THE
DAMAGE PAIN AND LOSS THE FEDERAL
CLICKS UPON THE CITIZENS. I'VE
BEEN ELECTED TO SERVE. ASSEMBLY
BILL SEVENTY ONE UNIQUELY
PROVIDES EQUITY AND HOW WE
ENFORCE PENDLE COMPARED TO OTHER
DETAILED THE SUBSTANCES. AND
CLOSES A LOOPHOLE THAT IS
PREVENTED DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
SUCH AS MYSELF. RACKING DOWN ON
FIDDLE AS WE ARE ABLE TO DO WITH
OTHER LETHAL DRUGS. JUST LAST
WEEK I'M SURE YOU MAY HAVE HEARD
THE CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY PATROL
SEES A NUFF FIDDLE IN SIX WEEKS
THE KILL THE ENTIRE CITY IS SET
ONE UP STANFORD FRANCISCO. THREE
TIMES OVER. LAST YEAR IN SAN
JOAQUIN COUNTY ALONE WE SEIZED
OVER NINE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY TWO
THOUSAND DOSES TWENTY POUNDS
WORTH ENOUGH TO KILL EVERY MAN.
WOMAN AND CHILD IN MY COUNTY. HI
I'M ASKING FOR PASSAGE OF
ASSEMBLY BILL SEVEN ONE TODAY
NOT JUST TO ALLOW MYSELF AND
OTHER DISTRIBUTARIES. TO
ADEQUATELY DEAL WITH LARGE SCALE
DEALERS TO FEND OFF BUT FOR
JUSTICE FOR BOTH THE- FOR THE
VICTIMS AND FAMILY MEMBERS
POISONED BY THIS. DRUG IN OUR
COMMUNITY. COURAGE HI VOTE ON
BILL SEVENTY ONE THE YIELD BACK
MY TIME TO THE AUTHOR. THANK YOU
SO MUCH- DO YOU HAVE ANY OTHER
WITNESSES OKAY SO WE'RE GONNA
MOVE ON TO SUPPORT WITNESSES
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME YOUR FORM
THAT YOU SUPPORT WE MOVE THROUGH
THIS QUICKLY HIM STONE STONE
ADVOCACY FOR THE CALIFORNIA
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. WELL TO
REMEMBER STENCILS ON BEHALF THE
LOS ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT.
LANTERN MEMBERS MATTHEW
STARTLING TO BE HAPPY SO
STATIONS LOS ANGELES DEPUTY
SHERIFFS IN THE CALIFORNIA PEACE
OFFICERS ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. SEEING NO OTHER
WITNESSES OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES. GOOD
MORNING MELBOURNE TERRACE MY
NAME IS GENETIC BUT BEING ON THE
CALIFORNIA STATE DIRECTOR FOR
DRUG POLICY ALLIANCE HERE
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO EIGHTY
SEVEN OH ONE. DPA IS A NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATION PROMOTING THAT
POLICY GROUNDED IN SCIENCE
COMPASSION IN HEALTH AND HUMAN
RIGHTS ONE OF MY MAIN CONCERNS
IS THAT THIS APPROACH WILL NOT
HELP SOLVE THE OVERDOSE CRISIS
IN CALIFORNIA BUT WILL INSTEAD
MAKE IT WORSE. AB SEVEN NO ONE
IS PROMISED IN THE SAME LOGIC
THAT INCREASING PENALTIES FOR
FENTANYL WILL DIS INCENTIVIZE
THE POSSESSION OF THE SUBSTANCE
HOWEVER THIS IS A FLAWED
ASSUMPTION AS THE DRUG MARKET IS
DRIVEN BY DEMAND RATHER THAN
SUPPLY. IN FACT IN TWENTY
EIGHTEEN THE PEW CHARITABLE
TRUST POINTS OUT TO THE
AGGRESSIVE APPROACH TO DRUG
CRIMES DOES NOT TRANSLATE. INTO
LOWER DRUG USE ARRESTS OR
OVERDOSE RATES PACIFIC LEE SEVEN
OH ONE WOULD APPLY A RANGE OF
ENHANCEMENTS THAT WILL NOT
REDUCE THE AVAILABILITY OR USE
FENNEL THAT WILL LIKELY
CONTRIBUTE TO LONG TERM
INCARCERATION. OF LOW LEVEL DRUG
SELLERS ARE PERSONS IN
POSSESSION OF SUBSTANCES THAT
MAY BE CONTAMINATED WITH FEDERAL
WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE OF THE PERSON
IN POSSESSION OF A CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCE. PENTYL OFFENSES
ALREADY COVERED UNDER CURRENTLY
ENHANCEMENT AND A DEFENDANT
CONVICTED OF A DRUG OFFENSE
INVOLVING A MIXTURE. OF HEROIN
AND FENTANYL OR COCAINE AND
FENTANYL WOULD BE SUBJECT TO THE
SAME WEIGHT ENHANCEMENT UNDER
CURRENT LAW. LOW LEVEL SELLERS
REALLY KNOW THAT THEY ARE
DISTRIBUTING FENTANYL AND HAVE
NO CONTROL OVER THE AMOUNT IN
THEIR PRODUCT. THIS BILL WOULD
NOT REDUCE THE INCLUSION OF
FENNEL AND THE DRUG SUPPLY AS A
TAKES PLACE HIGHER IN THE
DISTRIBUTION CHAINS.
ADDITIONALLY CHAINS ARE USUALLY
THE COST OF INCARCERATION FOR
THREE YEARS UNDER THIS BILL AND
CDCR WILL BE AT A COST OF THREE
HUNDRED AND EIGHTY THOUSAND. OF
THREE HUNDRED EIGHTY THOUSAND
FOR THOSE THREE YEARS IF WE
INCARCERATED FIFTEEN INDIVIDUALS
AND COUNTY JAIL FOR THREE YEARS.
IN STATE PRISON- IT WOULD COST
THE STATE ABOUT FOUR POINT SEVEN
SEVEN MILLION IN COMPARISON IF
WE INSTEAD TOOK A PUBLIC HEALTH
APPROACH. THE CLUSTER FROM THE
METHADONE FOR AN INDIVIDUAL IS
SIXTY FIVE HUNDRED. AND THE COST
FOR MEDICATED ASSISTED TREATMENT
IS SIX THOUSAND IT WOULD BE
HEALTHIER SAFER AND. BETTER FOR
PUBLIC SAFETY TO SEND P. WHAT A
MESS TREE. OR BE FOR YOU FOR THE
INFANTRY. THAT OF COURSE FIFTEEN
PEOPLE THREE. SENDING A PERSON
IN PRISON AN ADDITIONAL FIVE
YEARS MAKE NO. IN THE DRUG
AVAILABLE. FUNDING A ROBUST
VOLUNTARY DRUG TREATMENT SYSTEM
IS FAR MORE. FISCALLY PRUDENT
INVESTMENT WE ARE FACING A
HUMANITARIAN CRISIS THE DEMAND
HEALTHY SOLUTION TIME. THANK YOU
THANK YOU. NEXT WEEK ARE YOU
ALSO HAVE TWO MINUTES. GOOD
MORNING LESLIE CALDWELL HOUSTON
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA.
PUBLIC DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION AND
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. SB SEVEN
NO ONE FEELS LIKE THE SAME WAR
ON DRUGS MENTALITY WE ALREADY
KNOW THAT RELYING ON EVER
INCREASING PENALTIES DOES NOT
WORK. WE KNOW THAT THIS BILL
WOULD NOT REDUCE THE
DISTRIBUTION OF FENTANYL IT
WOULD NOT PREVENT OVERDOSES IT
WOULD NOT REDUCE THE SUPPLY OF
FENTANYL. NOR WOULD IT REDUCE
THE DEMAND FOR THIS DRUG WORSE
IT COULD DISCOURAGE THE
EFFECTIVE METHODS OF DEALING
WITH THE OPIOID CRISIS. THE
PRIMARY RISK OF OVERDOSE ON
FENTANYL. WHAT IS THE LOS FROM
ITS OWN KNOWING INGESTION THIS
PROCESS OF ADDING FENTANYL TO
OTHER DRUGS ARE MAKING IT LOOK
LIKE OTHER DRUGS IS DONE EARLY
IN THE PRODUCTION PROCESS.
THEREFORE WE KNOW THAT SELLERS
OFTEN DON'T EVEN KNOW THEY'RE
DISTRIBUTING FENTANYL. AS IT
TAKES PLACE HIGH IN THE
DISTRIBUTION CREEK PLATE CHANGE
SORRY. CALIFORNIA VOTERS HAVE
SIGNALED AGAIN AND AGAIN THEIR
PREFERENCE FOR A HEALTH APPROACH
TO DRUG OFFENSES AND THEIR
DESIRE TO UNWIND THE WAR ON
DRUGS. EFFORTS SUCH AS THIS BILL
NEED TO STOP WE NEED TO PIVOT TO
A NEW AND BETTER APPROACH THAN
THE WAR ON DRUGS IDEAS FOR THESE
REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR NUMBER. THANK YOU SO MUCH
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME ANY OTHER.
OPPOSITION WITNESSES ME TO USE-
AGAIN NAME OR THAT YOU OPPOSE
VERY QUICKLY. THE FUNDUS OF THE
ELEVATORS AND I CAN WRITE
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. IN
ADDITION ELLA BAKER CENTER IN
OPPOSITION. WELL ANY CONCERNS
PUBLIC DEFENDER'S OFFICE IN
OPPOSITION. SOME PEOPLE AND SET
A SEAL YOU CALIFORNIA ACTION IN
OPPOSITION. SANATANA SAM KATZ
LINE OUT COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
STARTED HIS JUSTICE OPPOSE. A
REMIND JOHN DURING THE- ANBAR'S
FELLOWSHIP. THANK YOU MODERATOR
PLEASE FROM THE FIRST INDIVIDUAL
. BUT SUPPORT OPPOSITION AB
SEVEN OH ONE THE FIRST ONE THE
GENERAL. WE'LL GO TO LIVE.
MORNING MANAGER NUMBER OF COLD
WAR GOLD MINE ON BEHALF OF THE
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS AND SUPPORT. WE'LL
GO TO LINE FORTY ONE. GOOD
MORNING MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BURBANK
IN SUPPORT. WE'LL GO TO LINE
TWENTY FIVE. JIM WOOD BURKE
FRANK COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
OF CALIFORNIA THE OPPOSITION.
WE'LL GO TO LINE SIXTY. HELLO
FROM THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORKERS FOR THE
CALIFORNIA SO YOU. PUBLIC LINE.
SIXTEEN I'M SIXTEEN YOUR LINE IS
OPEN- EASY MEGA TO THE CITY OF
BAKERSFIELD IN SUPPORT. WE'LL GO
TO LINE EIGHTY FIVE. NATALIE
PATE BROTHER BONTA VICTIM
POISONINGS SUPPORT. NINE SEVENTY
ONE. THANKS EVERYONE. GILLUM
PREPARED REDUCE THE FUTURE THE
HALF THE CALIFORNIA HI PATROLMAN
AND FACTORS RESEARCHERS
ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT
. I AM SURE WE HAVE FOR THIS OF
THANK YOU WILL MOVE THE CONVERSE
TO COMMIT MEMBERS MEMBERS ANY
CAN THOUGHTS OKAY SEEING NONE A
SIMPLE OKAY SENATOR WIENER THANK
YOU. THANK YOU SOMEONE NUMBER-
ALL BE ON I'LL BE HONEST I'M SO
I'M STRUGGLING WITH THIS BILL
BECAUSE NO ONE AN OBVIOUS IS A
REALLY LARGE AMOUNT OF FENTON
HOME ONE OF THE ONE OF THE HUGE
CHALLENGES OF FENTON ALL IS IN
TERMS OF INTERDICTION- DOESN'T
TAKE MORE THAN A FEW TRUFFLES
OFFENSE ALL ENTERING THE COUNTRY
TO SPACE WE SUPPLY THE WHOLE
COUNTRY. SO EVEN REALLY
AGGRESSIVE IN THE SYSTEM I KNOW
SO MUCH INTERDICTION BUILT
PARTIALLY EVEN THE MOST
AGGRESSIVE INTERDICTION YOU KNOW
DOESN'T TAKE THAT MUCH SLIPPING
THROUGH TO- REALLY FOR REAL-
ARE- SUPPLY RESTRICTION- PLANS
AND- ON THE ONE HAND HIM THERE
ARE- I DON'T PROBLEMS THIS IS
LIKE DIRECTED AT. PEOPLE WHO YOU
KNOW OUR SERVICE THE DRUG
CAMPAIGN KIND OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE
HUGE QUANTITIES BECAUSE THE
FOLKS WHO ARE DEALING ON THE
STREET OR PROBABLY I'M LIKELY TO
HAVE THIS QUANTITY. I DON'T HAVE
A PROBLEM WITH THAT- BUT THE
CITY HAS SINCE ALSO APPLY
BROADLY FOR EXAMPLE TRANSPORTING
SOMEONE COULD BE DRIVING A TRUCK
. JUST A LITTLE BIT WITH A
LITTLE PER WHO'S DRIVING A TRUCK
AND A COMMAND GOT STUCK WITH
TWENTY FIVE YEARS AND- IN STATE
PRISON OR THEM. IT'S IT EVEN ON
CLEAR TO ME IF YOU HAVE TO EVEN
THOUGH- THAT YOU'RE WHAT YOU'RE
TRANSPORTING I DON'T KNOW ALL
THE CASE LAW ON THAT BUT IT'S
NOT CLEAR FROM THE STATUTE
ITSELF SO- MEMBER STOCK NOT NOT
ONLY THE PERSON BEING IN PRISON
FOR A LONG TIME BUT WE DON'T
HAVE TO PAY FOR IT- YOU KNOW I
KNOW. GENERALLY CASES OF THIS
SIZE ARE PROBABLY MORE LIKELY TO
GO FEDERAL- REGARDLESS- SO I ON
I'LL JUST BE HONEST I'M I'M
STRUGGLING WITH THIS BECAUSE I
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
DO IN HUGE QUANTITIES ARE YOU
KNOW. ARE ARE PROBLEMS. ON THE
COULD YOU. COMMENT ON- YEAH THAT
KIND OF. SITUATION WHERE- WHERE
SOMEONE IS HIM PROPS DRIVING A
TRUCK AND- MAY OR MAY NOT. YOU
MAY KNOW THERE'S DRUGS MAY NOT-
IF THEY DO THEY MAY NOT EVEN
KNOW WHAT KIND OF DRUGS AND-
THEY'RE MORE OF A LOW LEVEL
PERSON AND THEY MIGHT GET HIT
WITH A MULTI DECADE ENHANCEMENT.
OKAY SO LET ME. STATE THAT. WE
ARE NOT GOING AFTER THE USER.
OKAY AT ALL WE'RE NOT GOING
AFTER THE NICKEL AND DINER-
YEAH- DRUG DEALER. I MEAN.
PERSON THAT'S CARRYING A KILO
DOES NOT. THEY HAVE TO KNOW
THAT. I MEAN THEY'RE NOT.
THEY'RE IN IT FOR THE MONEY.
THEY'RE THEY'RE IF THEY'RE
CARRYING A KILO MORE. FINALLY
ARRIVES ON DRIVERS DRIVING TRUCK
STARTED. I GET IF YOU'RE IF YOU
HAVE IT ON LATER K. OUT I GOT
THAT YOU PROBABLY KNOW. RIGHT
LET SOMEONE SIX TRÊN. IS ALSO
PART OF THIS IS SOMEONE WHO SAYS
SOME LOW LEVEL. AND LIKE TO
DRIVE THIS TRUCK FROM HERE TO
THERE. I'M JUST CURIOUS- WHAT
YOUR TAKE IS ON- AND ESPECIALLY
IF THEY MAY OR MAY NOT EVEN KNOW
WHAT EXACTLY. THEY'RE CARRYING.
RIGHT FOR ME. AS A- OKAY. THE
SOONER YOU BRING UP A VERY GUY
QUESTION- CANCER WOULD NOT APPLY
TO. WITH NON. OF THE POSITION OF
THE DRUGS OF THE KILO. YOU COULD
NOT BE CONVICTED OF THE
TRANSPORTATION WHILE BEING
TRANSPORTED TO THE
TRANSPORTATION GUILTY OF THE
TRANSPORTATION. YOU WOULD NOT
THEN BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE
ADVANCEMENT PROJECT IS A KEY SO
BECAUSE IT'S IN THE STATUTE
ITSELF IT DOESN'T SEEM. TO SAY
THAT AGAIN I DON'T WANT TO. GO
AND SO I'M IS THAT WHERE WE'RE
GOING TO NOT FROM YOU CAN ONLY
PROSECUTE INDIVIDUALS ARE NO.
GOING ALSO- THIS IS NOT GOING
AFTER THE VICTIM SUPPORT. THE
USERS OF THE CRIME WHAT WE SEEN
IN THE LAST THREE YEARS. IS THAT
THERE SIX TIMES ABOUT OVERDOSES
SINCE SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY ALONE.
SO THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT THAT
WE DO- IMPOSES AND HELPLESS. BUT
BENEFIT WHERE IN TERMS. OF
KNOWING. BECAUSE THE STOCK
ITSELF. SAY KNOWING AND WANTED
TO TELL ME WHERE YOU GOT THE
FROM AS- IT'S OUR THE HILTON
SAFETY CODE LET ME FIFTY TWO
FOR. I DON'T I DON'T SEE IT
THERE AND THAT'S- AND AGAINST ON
THAT SOMEONE IF THIS IS. FROM
CASE LAW. INTERPRETING I CNN THE
STATUTE ITSELF ANALYSTS FORECAST
HERE GRIFFITH QUESTION I JUST
WANNA YEAH WE HAVE AN ORIGINAL
AGE. SO THIS. MERELY WITH ALAN.
A WOODEN- AND I IN ALL DA'S HELD
TO THE STANDARD THE STATE IS
THAT NOW AND FOR FROM ITSELF. NO
IT- HIM FOR ITS ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE
. SO EITHER FOR THE SIR. OR
OTHER FOR LEADING UP TO THE
CIRCUMSTANCES BE TO THE FAT OF
THE QUANTITY BECAUSE I KNOW LIKE
EXAMPLE- MAYBE IF YOU HAD A- I'M
SORRY FOR. GO HEAD NUMBER LICIT
YEAH IF YOU A IF YOU AND AGAIN
I'M TALK FOCUSING MORE ON THE-
LAYER OF SOMEONE A KERRY A YOU
KNOW. THREE KILOS FENTANYL THAT
THERE'S PRETTY CHANCE A VERY
VERY NO WITH DOING- IF I DON'T
THINK THAT. A BAG FLOUR MOST
LIKELY- BY TRANSPORTING ON A
TRUCK WHERE THERE COULD BE
TWENTY THINGS YOUR TRUCK. AND
THEN THERE'S A FEW KILL IN A FEW
KILLERS IS NOT. TAKE A THAT MUCH
SPACE- YOU KNOW. I'M JUST
CURIOUS HOW HOW ARE YOU HELLO.
WHAT THE QUANTITY ITSELF BE
ENOUGH TO SAVE YOU'RE
TRANSPORTING THREE KILOS SO YOU
MUST'VE KNOWN BECAUSE FOR LIKE
INTO. POSSESSION WITH INTENT TO
SELL DRUGS AT MY UNDERSTANDING-
SOMETIMES A QUANTITY WILL COME
IN AS EVIDENCE TO SAY YOU HAD SO
MUCH ON. YOUR THAT WAS NOT FOR
YOUR PERSONAL USE YOU'RE
INTENDING TO SELL IT. RIGHT AND
THOSE ARE VERY GOOD QUESTIONS
AND I THINK THE DEVIL IS IN THE
DETAILS IF AN INDIVIDUAL HAD
THREE KILOS IN A BACKPACK AND
THEY WERE GETTING ON A BUS. THEN
THAT WOULD BE TRANSPORTATION
WOULD AGREE WITH THAT AND THEN
PUT THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES WOULD BE
HARD TO SAY THAT THAT INDIVIDUAL
DIDN'T KNOW THAT THEY WERE
TRANSPORTING THREE KILOS. IF A
PERSON HAS AN EIGHTEEN WHEELER
AND ONE KILO WAS FOUND SOMEWHERE
IN THE FRAME OF IT- THE VALUE
WOULD BE VERY HARD FOR US TO
SHOW KNOWLEDGE ANYTHING DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ACROSS THE STATE
WITHOUT ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE SUCH
AS FINGERPRINTS ON THE
PACKAGING. OR OTHER- PHONE CALLS
OR OUT OF THE OTHER STATEMENT
SHOWING THAT THERE WAS NO ANSWER
COULD NOT PROSECUTE THAT CASE.
HOW WITHOUT THERE BEING
KNOWLEDGE SO I THINK THE DOUBLE
WITH THE ON THE DETAILS. OKAY
THANK YOU- WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE HER WOULD. SENATOR
BRADFORD NO I. I DO HAVE
CONCERNS WITH THIS BUT THE STATE
KNOWINGLY I'M I'VE KNOWN. DOZENS
OF INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE DOING
TIME RIGHT NOW. WHO IS IN A CARD
NOT KNOWING THAT THERE WAS A GUN
IN THE CAR OR DRUGS IN THE CAR.
STILL THAT'S A LITTLE TOO SHAKY
FOR ME TO SAY YOU KNOW. I'M YET
TO SEE ANYONE EXONERATED TRISTAN
I DID NOT KNOW. AND STILL WORK
WAS CONVICTED SPECIALLY BACA
BROWN PEOPLE WHO WERE NAIVE SO I
NEED TO MORE INSURANCES THAT I
MEAN. THAT SOMEONE UNKNOWINGLY
AT SOMETHING A CAR IS NOT GOING
TO BE CHARGED. WITH A CRIME.
OKAY WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THE
WOULD- AGAIN I MEAN I'M I'M NOT
GOING AFTER THE USER I AM TAX.
SORRY WHICH I JUST WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT. WE YEAH WE- ARE NOT
GOING AFTER THE USER I'M
ACTUALLY GOING AFTER THAT THE
PERSON ITSELF THERE. YOU KNOW-
NOT EVEN THE NAY EVEN PERCENT
SELLING YOU KNOW THE- PUSHING IT
ON THE STREETS. ACTUALLY GOING
AFTER THE- FOLKS THAT ARE
BRINGING THE SAND. BY THE KILOS-
I VISIT. REHABS IBM VISIT YOUR
REHAB IN SAN FRANCISCO I VISIT
RECAPS ALL OVER THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. AND TRYING TO SEE
WHAT WORKS WHAT DOESN'T WORK-
DELANCEY IS A GREAT. IT'S A
GREAT PLACE. BUT I MEAN TO TELL
YOU. SENATOR THE THIS IS NOT A
DRUG. THIS IS PLEASANT. AND YOU
KNOW IT YOU KNOW IT IN YOUR
STREET YOUR SEEN. WERE SEEN
ACROSS THE STATE. I VISIT SAN
FRANCISCO. AND YOU CAN JUST SEE
IT. I MEAN IT'S ALL OVER. AND
CRAP ALL OVER THE COUNTRY RIGHT.
LIVE WITH THEM BUT IT'S NOT A
DRUG IT'S A PLEASANT I KNOW AND
IT'S- NOT JUST FOR AMAZON ECHO
IT'S EVERY IT'S EVERYWHERE AND I
NOTICED. I NOTICE SO I JUST TRY
TO POINT TO SELF. PEOPLE ARE
DYING. EVERY DAY. AFTER CALLING
A- YEAH THE BEST TESTER YOU
FOLKS. YOU KNOW A P. OF COLOR.
BASICALLY SAYING MY KID HAS DIED
FROM THIS. AND IT'S- I WILL AND
WE'RE UPSET WE'VE WE'VE WE'VE
WE'VE HAD FOLKS TRY TO COME UP
HERE. TO TESTIFY AND WE'RE JUST
NOT BEING HEARD AND WE CANNOT
TURN OUR BACKS TO THE CITY MORE.
D. YOU KNOW ALL OF YOU GUYS UP
HERE NO THIS. AND WE CONTINUE TO
TURN OUR BACKS TRYING TO SAY
THAT. WERE WERE DISCONNECTED
CARCERI MORE PEOPLE. YES THAT'S
NOT THE WAY IT IS OKAY WE ARE
GOING AFTER THE PERSON THESE ARE
FOLKS THAT ARE BRING IN IT. BY
THE KILOS THE HERE. YOUR GUY
GETTING CAUGHT IN THIS BILL DOES
SOMETHING. THIS SAVES LIVES. BUT
I UNDERSTAND THIS IS NOT. A IS
NOT A DRUG THIS IS POISON. IT'S
CHANGED OUR STREETS. HAS CHANGED
OUR WHOLE COMMUNITY STOP THEIR-
GETTING WORSE AND WORSE- SO
BEHIND. IF WE DON'T DO SOMETHING
TODAY GUESS WHAT. WE'RE GOING TO
TALK ABOUT THIS THE NEXT THREE
FOUR FIVE YEARS AGO AND SAY THAT
WE WHICH WOULD HAVE DONE
SOMETHING. IT'S SAD. WITH THAT-
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR LIVE UP
THANK YOU. TO HAVE A MOTION.
MOVED BY SENATOR. BUDGET. THE
EXORCIST MOVED BY SENATOR
SHOWBOAT- YOU RECALL. ONE DID
YOU WANT TO QUESTION WE MOVED
LAST NIGHT OF. SO I. DON'T FOR
PERSONAL- YEAH. AND I THINK THAT
MIGHT HAVE TURNED IT ON SO MY
QUESTION IS- THEY HEAR A LOT OF
CONCERN WITH REGARD TO AB I'M CO
AUTHOR THIS BILLS. HAPPY TO
SUPPORT IN WHICH IS WHY A MOVE
THAT THE BILL BECAUSE IT HAVE IN
THE THAT IT'S ALL RIGHT INCLUDED
AS SUCH I THINK IT'S GREAT IDEA
THAT YOU ARE TAKING THE
INITIATIVE TO DO THAT BUT I DID
HAVE A QUESTION THROUGH THE
CHAIR. FOR MY COLLEAGUES IF
THEY'RE WILLING I'M I'M A LITTLE
. I'M A LITTLE. I'M NOT SURE
WHAT THE WORD IS CONCERNED I
GUESS I'M KIND OF CURIOUS THAT
ACTION FIGURES MIND RIGHT NOW IS
TO THIS NOTION OF YOU KNOW. THAT
PEOPLE ARE AWARE THAT HEARING OR
WHERE THEY'RE SELLING IT IN THE
QUANTITIES OF AMOUNTS THAT
THEY'RE CARRYING A BACKPACK OR
SOMETHING- BUT IT ALSO I'M HERE
TO SEE WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE
BECAUSE- ANYBODY CAN SAY WELL I
DIDN'T KNOW BUT WHEN. I MEAN DO
WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING MORE
NARRATIVES FAR AS A BILL GOES-
THAT SAYS WELL WHEN CAN YOU NOT
SAY I DID NOT KNOW OR WIND AND
WHAT IS ACTUALLY KNOWING THAT
YOU'RE ACTUALLY SELLING BECAUSE
I MEAN NOBODY'S GONNA SAY WELL I
DIDN'T YOU KNOW I KNEW IT WAS
SELLING THIS OR- LESS. THAN AND
SO WHAT DOES THAT LOOK LIKE-
THIS YEAR YES YEAH I MEAN IS
SOMETHING THAT CRIMINAL DEALS
WITH. THREE HUNDRED SIXTY FIVE
DAYS A YEAR ALL THE TIME IN A
MILLION CONTACTS HAVING NOTHING
TO DO WITH DRUGS HAVE TO PROVE.
KNOWLEDGE BECAUSE WE ARE TALKING
ABOUT. SENDING SOMEONE TO STATE
PRISON FOR. ENTER TWENTY FIVE
YEARS OR THREE YEARS OR FIVE
YEARS OR FIFTEEN YEARS THESE
ARE. THESE ARE NOT. SET HI
ENHANCEMENTS THESE ARE.
SIGNIFICANT ENHANCEMENTS THAT IF
YOU'RE GOING TO. DO THAT- IT'S
NOT UNREASONABLE. TO HAVE SOME
SORT OF KNOWLEDGE REQUIREMENTS
AND PROSECUTORS PROVE KNOWLEDGE.
EVERY DAY IN KNOWLEDGE IS NOT
JUST ABOUT LIKE DID THEY SAY. I
KNEW THIS YOU'VE PROVEN DOLLARS
THROUGH. VARIOUS FORMS OF
EVIDENCE. THAT IS NOT LIKE A
WEIRD THING FOR PROSECUTORS TO
HAVE TO DO AND THAT'S WHAT WE
HEARD. FROM DA FROM I THINK SAN
JOAQUIN COUNTY- THAT THEY THEY
THINK THEY HAVE TO PROVE.
KNOWLEDGE HERE I DON'T SEE IN
THE STATURE BUT THERE MIGHT BE
THE CASE LAW REQUIRES I DON'T
PRETEND TO BE AN EXPERT- IN THE
CASE LAW AND- ON. ON DRUG SALES
- BUT- IT'S NOT- THAT'S NOT AND
I'M NOT THINGS PROCESS. TO HAVE
TO. HAVE TO. SOME LEVEL INTO OR
NOT. SO I JUST WANT TO HIGHLIGHT
THAT- OBVIOUS. YOU KNOW THAT
THIS COMMITTEE HAS TAKEN ON A
NUMBER OF ISSUES AND OBVIOUSLY
SENTINELS A GROWING CRISIS IN
OUR STATE. AS WELL AS MANY
PEOPLE VERY DEEPLY CONCERNED
ABOUT IT. YOU KNOW THE MAIN GOAL
THAT I THINK A LOT OF MEMBERS
HAVE IS NOT TO INCARCERATE-
INDIVIDUALS- DUE TO PURE
IGNORANCE OR- NOT UNDERSTAND
EXACTLY YOU KNOW WHAT THEY'RE
DRIVING OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT- I
OFTEN WANT TO HELP MEMBERS- PUSH
THEIR BILL- I I'M WONDERING IF
YOU WOULD BE OPEN TO ANY
AMENDMENTS TO JUST CLARIFY
LANGUAGE. AS YOU HEARD FROM MY
COLLEAGUES OF THEIR CONCERNS- I
UNDERSTAND WHAT WAS STATED BUT
WE ALSO HAVE OTHER INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE ALSO LAWYERS AND HAVE-
SEEN KIND OF. WHAT EXACTLY
HAPPENS WHEN PEOPLE ARE. YOU
KNOW HAVE CHARGES AGAINST THEM-
YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE INDIVIDUALS
THAT ARE SUPPORTIVE AS IS BUT
WOULD YOU BE WILLING TO MAKE A
AMENDMENT- TO CLARIFY SOME
LANGUAGE AND CONCERNS THAT OUR
TWO SENATORS HERE. I WOULD HAVE
SO I'M A- I'M GOING TO MAKE
BROAD SUPPORT MOVING THIS BILL
OUT OF. COMMITTEE TODAY- I
RESERVE MY RIGHT ON THE FLOOR
BUT- BUT YOU KNOW I'M- I'M
WILLING TO HELP. OUT SUPPORT
MOVING THIS OUT OF COMMITTEE I
WOULD LIKE- SOME MORE
INFORMATION. ABOUT KNOWLEDGE.
REQUIREMENTS BECAUSE ARE VERY.
ANNOUNCEMENTS BUT- MULTIPLES
MOVING OKAY TEST ERIC SANCYA SO
WOULD YOU LIKE TO AGAIN AND JUST
. I WOULD I WILL I'LL I'LL LET.
WORK WITH STAFF AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NIGHT OUT
THANK YOU SO- AND WE HAVE A
MOTION TO REMOVED YES. ALL RIGHT
CHEMICAL VOTE MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS BOB. HI BOB I
OCTOBER OKAY I TELL THEM I
BRADFORD. SKINNER WIENER WIENER
AYE. THANK YOU THAT BILLS ON
CONCRETE FIGURE TIME- OUR NEXT
PRESENTERS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
BERMAN. FOURTEEN TWENTY. GOOD
YEAH. THANK YOU MANAGER AND
CENTERS AB FOURTEEN TWENTY. WHAT
IS SURE THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE HAS THE AUTHORITY TO
INSPECT AND WRITE CITATIONS FOR
ANY VIOLATIONS RELATED TO THE
SALE TRANSFER AND STORAGE OF
FIREARMS. CALIFORNIA HAS ONE OF
THE STRONGEST FARM LAWS IN THE
COUNTRY AND THESE LAWS SAVE
LIVES. HAVING THESE LAWS ARE
IMPORTANT BUT IT'S EQUALLY
IMPORTANT TO ENSURE THE LAWS ARE
BEING ADEQUATELY ENFORCED.
CURRENTLY THE BUREAU OF FIREARMS
IN THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
LACKS INSPECTION AUTHORITY ON
MANY OF CALIFORNIA'S STRONG FARM
LAWS. THERE ONLY A HANDFUL OF
STATUTES THAT ALLOW FOR BUREAU
FARMS TO INSPECT AND EVEN FEWER
STATUTES THAT ALLOW FOR ANY SORT
OF CIVIL FINES TO BE ISSUED. AB
FOURTEEN TWENTY WILL BROADEN THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE'S
INSPECTION AUTHORITY. TO INSURE
THESE LAWS ARE BEING ENFORCED
AND ANY VIOLATIONS ARE REMEDIED.
AND HERE WITH ME TODAY- IS
CANDACE CHONG WITH THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
. THANKS FOR FASTER AND I WROTE.
YOU WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES GOOD
THAT INSURANCE. AND AMOS CANDICE
CHIMED I'M A DEPUTY ATTORNEY
GENERAL WITH THE OFFICE OF
ATTORNEY GENERAL ROB BONTA WHO
IS PLEASED TO SPONSOR THIS BILL
- OF EIGHTY BONTA LIKE TO THANKS
MEMBER FIRSTLY. ON THIS ISSUE
AND FOR AUTHORING THE SPELL.
HELP HAS ENACTED SOME OF THE
STRONGEST FIREARM SAFETY LAWS IN
THE NATION BUT UNFORTUNATELY THE
LAWS AUTHORIZING DOJ TO INSPECT
INSPIRE INSIGHT FIREARMS DEALERS
HAS SIMPLY NOT KEPT UP WITH THE
EVOLUTION OF OUR GUN SAFETY LAWS
. FOR EXAMPLE THE CURRENT LIST
OF VIOLATIONS THAT DOJ AGENTS
CONCERT FOR DOES NOT INCLUDE A
SLEW OF IMPORTANT SAFETY
MEASURES HAVE BEEN PASSED THE
LAST THIRTEEN YEARS. SUCH AS-
THE WEATHER DEALER SOLAR
TRANSFERRED SOLD WEAPONS WHETHER
THEY AB THEY CALL THE DEEP BIG
STATE VALIDATORS WEAPONS PERMIT.
FOR KEEPING RECORDS OF ALL
FOSTER WEAPONS SALES. AB
FOURTEEN TWENTY WILL GET THE DOJ
AUTHORITY TO CHECK FIREARMS
DEALERS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THE
MORE COMPREHENSIVE UPDATED LIST
OF LAWS. MORE IMPORTANTLY THIS
BILL WILL EXPAND AUTHORITY TO
ASSESS PROGRESS TO PENALTIES
INCLUDING CIVIL FINES WHEN
DEALERS FAILED TO CORRECT
VIOLATIONS. WHICH WILL WILL
INCENTIVIZE COMPLIANCE. THIS IS
AN IMPORTANT MEASURE TO ENSURE
THAT FIREARM SALES AND TRANSFERS
ARE BEING CONDUCTED IN A SAFE
AND LAWFUL MANNER NAY. RESPECT.
LAST WEEK RIGHT. THANK YOU. ON
DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER SUPPORT
WITNESSES. IF YOU ARE IN TO USE
YOUR NAME YOUR ORGAN THAT YOU
SUPPORT WE LIKE TO THROUGH THIS
PRETTY QUICK. CRISTOBALITE OF
EVERYTOWN FOR GUN SAFETY AND
SUPPORT. THE CENTER WHAT STONE
VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS DEMAND
ACTION IN SUPPORT. OF. I AM
COMMITTEES WITH LOS ANGELES
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT IN
SUPPORT. LINDA WHEATON WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. ERIN CHAMBERLAIN WITH
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
CATHERINE A MURDER WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION INSTRUCTS SUPPORT
. SUSAN BURNS MOMS DEMAND ACTION
STRONG SUPPORT. YEAH CAN MEN
FREDDIE MOMS DEMAND ACTION
SUPPORT. ALEX NAVARRO MONTHS MAN
ACTION IN SUPPORT. JUSTIN
KOEHLER ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT.
JAMIE MINOR REPRESENTING THE
GIFFORDS GUNS LAWCENTER TO
PREVENT GUN VIOLENCE ALSO IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU SEE NO OTHER
SUPPORT WITNESSES CAN WE GET OUR
OPPOSITION OPPOSITION AGAIN
YOU'LL HAVE TWO MINUTES. THANK
YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS THE
COMMITTEE FOR THE RECORD AND
READ NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION
ALSO HERE FOR NATIONAL SHOOTING
SPORTS FOUNDATION. IN STRONG
OPPOSITION- LICENSE FIREARMS
DEALERS ARE ALREADY SUBJECT
INSPECTIONS AND SCRUTINY IN A
LITANY OF FEDERAL AND STATE. AND
LOCAL LAWS THAT ALLOW FOR
INSPECTIONS THESE ARE GOOD LAW
ABIDING BUSINESSES- IT'S WE
DON'T FEEL THAT THERE NEEDS TO
BE MORE MORE ONUS PUT ON THEM-
ALSO THAT OUR BIGGEST OBJECTION
COMES TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE
EMAIL ADDRESS IS PART OF FIREARM
TRANSFERS- WE HAVE A LOT OF
QUESTIONS ABOUT WHAT'S THE
PURPOSE OF REQUIRING. EMAIL
ADDRESSES NGUYEN- RECEIVING
TRANSFERRING- PURCHASING
FIREARMS WHAT ARE THESE EMAIL
ADDRESSES CAN BE USED FOR WHAT
HAPPENS WHEN SOMEONE DOESN'T
HAVE AN EMAIL ADDRESS BUT I'M
AS- YOU ARE AWARE THERE'S BEEN.
A LEAK OF GUN OWNER INFORMATION
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU ALSO
ATTACH EMAIL ADDRESSES TO IT
ALSO- RECENTLY- THERE IS A
PASSAGE OF EIGHTY ONE SEVENTY
THREE WHICH MANDATED PERSONAL
IDENTIFYING INFORMATION ON GUN
OWNERS BE TURNED OVER TO THE
SECOND BALANCE RESEARCH CENTER
ALONG WITH. OTHER NON PROFITS
THERE'S LITIGATION CURRENTLY ON
THIS- NOW NOT ONLY ARE YOU GOING
TO TAKE ALL THE PERSONALLY
IDENTIFYING INFORMATION. BUT
ALSO INCLUDE EMAIL ADDRESSES
DOES THIS MEAN GUN OWNERS ARE
GOING TO GET OUT REACH FOR
RESEARCHERS WHAT HAPPENS IS THIS
GOING TO LINK TO SOCIAL MEDIA
ACCOUNTS- THERE'S A WHOLE HOST
OF ISSUES AND I SEE THAT YOU. BY
TWO MINUTES ARE UP AND SO I
APPRECIATE YOUR INDULGING ME BUT
WITHOUT WERE IN OPPOSITION THANK
YOU. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES. I'M
SURE MEMBER SAMPRAS REPRESENTING
CALIFORNIA. I AM A LICENSED
DEALER IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AND ALSO CALIFORNIA
STATE FARM STEELER. I CAN TELL
YOU THIS THAT THAT THE BATF
ALREADY REQUIRES AND PROVIDES
INFORMATION. FOR DEALERS TO USE
IN TRAINING THEIR THEIR
EMPLOYEES- THEY GIVE SEMINARS
AND WORKSHOPS WHEN THEY COME AND
INSPECT. THEY MAKE SURE THAT THE
OWNERS OF THE STORES- ARE
SHARING THIS INFORMATION WITH
EVERYBODY WHO'S ELIGIBLE TO DEAL
WITH FIREARMS OR AMMUNITION IN
THEIR IN THEIR BUSINESSES. SO WE
HAVE A SITUATION HERE WHERE THIS
LEGISLATURE CONTINUES. TO KEEP
MORE RESPONSIBILITIES THAT ARE
MANDATED IN STATUTE ON THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE WHEN IT IS
WOEFULLY CLEAR THAT THEY ARE.
INCAPABLE OF FULFILLING ALL OF
THE RESPONSIBILITIES THAT THEY
HAVE NOW WE HAVE A SEVERE
PROBLEMS WITH THE CERTIFICATES
OF ELIGIBILITY AND BEEN ABLE TO
PROCESS THOSE. IN A TIMELY
MANNER- WHICH CAUSES DEALERS TO
HAVE TO SHUT DOWN BECAUSE THEY
CAN'T GET THEIR C. ALWAYS ON
TIME WE HAVE THE INABILITY OF
THE- OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE TO HANDLE THE APPS
PROGRAM- IT IS CLEAR THAT
THERE'S OF. A PROBLEM IN RIVER
CITY BECAUSE- EVERY TIME THEY
SAY OH WE HANDLE SEVERAL
THOUSAND OF THEM AND THEN THE
NUMBERS GO BACK UP TO TWENTY
FIVE WITH. FOUR OR MORE THOUSAND
CASES THAT DIDN'T NEED TO BE
IDENTIFIED OR OR PORK. OR WORKED
ON- DO YOU RIGHT NOW CAN IN SOME
. ANY DEALER IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AT ANY TIME. THEY
ALREADY HAVE THAT ABILITY TO DO
SO. THEY HAVE WISELY GIVEN THE
RESOURCES THE P. Y. AS IN THE
BUDGET THAT THEY HAVE. CHOSEN TO
GO AFTER AND INSPECT THOSE THAT
THAT THEY THINK. NEED THE MOST
ATTENTION MANY OF THE SMALLER
DEALERS WITH SMALLER VOLUMES OF
SALES OF TRANSACTIONS. THEY WAIT
A LITTLE BIT LONGER AND SURE
ENOUGH THEY GO AND INSPECT THEM
AND THEY COME OUT WITH FLYING
COLORS. THE INFORMATION THAT WAS
PROVIDED IN THIS BILL AND
ANALYSIS SHOWS THAT THE NUMBER
OF CASES WHERE- THE ATF FOUND
VIOLATIONS OF THE LAW IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA WAS NUMBER
NINE THANK YOU. CAN WE MOVE ON
TO OPPOSITION WHICH IS ONLY IN
SUPPORT I'M TIMING YOU. BY YOUR
NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION AND THAT
YOU OPPOSE. THE TRAVIS
CALIFORNIA RIFLE PISTOL
ASSOCIATION OPPOSITION THANK YOU
. MANY AYE A CALIFORNIA CIVIL
LIBERTIES ADVOCACY IN OPPOSITION
UNLESS AMENDED I APPRECIATE
THAT. ANY OTHER OPPOSITION
WITNESSES. THING NINE WILL ASK
MODERATOR PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. REPORTER OPPOSITION
TO. K¾T FOURTEEN TWENTY PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND ZERO. WE'LL GO TO
LINE. SEVENTY SIX. MICHAEL
CROTEAU NUMBER OF HERE PNN ARE A
OPPOSED. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
EIGHTY THREE. THANK YOU CARLENE
ELLIS. NUMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA
RIGHT POLITICAL. AND THEY ARE
WOMEN OF AMERICA IN A RESPECTFUL
OPPOSITION TO AB FOURTEEN TWENTY
THANK YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
NINETY THREE. HI GOOD MORNING-
MY NAME IS AARON BUT WELL I AM A
MEMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA RIGHT.
THE FUSION INVENTOR OF THE
CALIFORNIA AND I'M CALLING TO
VOICE MY OPPOSITION TO AB.
FOURTEEN TWENTY. THE LOCAL
CAROLINE. SIXTY ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORKER CALIFORNIA CHAPTER
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THAT THE-
OKAY. WE'LL GO TO LINE. SIXTEEN
PETER MAKE A MESS OF THE CITY OF
MOUNTAIN VIEW IN SUPPORT. FUKOKU
LINE. NINETEEN SHARES TO MY FAN
I'M NOT SURE OF THE SOUTH'S
ARGUMENT WAS AFTER THE
CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL.
STANDS BURKE AND OPPOSITION.
MARK ROBINSON A CONCERN
CALIFORNIA RESIDENT STRONG
OPPOSITION AB. FORTY FOUR. MADAM
CHAIR WE HAVE NO FOR THEIR
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION THANK YOU
WILL MOVE THE CONVERSATION TO
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
MEMBERS THING NO CONVERSATION
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TO LIKE CLOSE
RESPECT US FOR A VOTE THANK YOU
DO WE HAVE A MOTION. I SENATOR
BRADFORD MOVES CAN CALL VOTE.
THE MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS WAHHAB I HAVE I
OWE TO ABOUT TWO BY BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER. WIENER
THAT BILLS ON CALL THING YOU
ASSEMBLY MEMBER- WE WILL NOW ON
TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER BARRICADE
HAND PRESENTING AB. THREE OH
ONE. THANK YOU CHAIR SENATORS
I'M HERE TO PRESENT AB THREE OH
ONE WHICH ALLOWS A COURT TO
CONSIDER ACQUISITION OF BODY
ARMOR AS EVIDENCE WHEN
CONSIDERING A GUN VIOLENCE
RESTRAINING ORDER FOR GB RO.
BODY ARMOR. IS AN IMPORTANT
THING FOR THE COURT TO CONSIDER
WHEN DECIDING IF A GUN VIOLENCE
RESTRAINING ORDER IS NECESSARY
BECAUSE WE'VE SEEN THE PEOPLE
MAYBE BUYING ASSAULT WEAPONS AND
BODY ARMOR TOGETHER TO USE IN
MASS SHOOTING INCIDENTS FOR
EXAMPLE IN MAY TWENTY TWENTY TO
THE SAN JOSE POLICE DEPARTMENT
OBTAINED A G. VERO. AFTER AN
INDIVIDUALS CHARGED WITH FELONY
STALKING AND FOUND IN POSSESSION
OF ASSAULT RIFLES HIGH CAPACITY
MAGAZINES AND HUNDREDS OF ROUNDS
OF AMMUNITION AND BODY ARMOR.
WITH TWENTY ONE MASS SHOOTERS
WEARING BODY ARMOR DURING THEIR
ATTACKS IT IS CLEAR WE NEED TO
PLACE GUARDRAILS AROUND THE
PURCHASE BODY ARMOR OUTSIDE OF
FEDERAL LAW PROHIBITING
INDIVIDUALS CONVICTED OF VIOLENT
FELONIES FROM POSSESSING BODY
ARMOR. THERE ARE NO OTHER
REGULATIONS ON BODY ARMOR
ALTHOUGH BODY ARMOR ALONE MAY
NOT BE INDICATIVE OF VIOLENCE IT
IS HIGHLY RELEVANT OF A PERSON
IS ALSO PURCHASED GUNS OR
AMMUNITION WITHIN THE SIX MONTHS
WHICH IS ALSO A FACTOR. IN THE
GB RO DECISION WITH ME J. IN
SUPPORT IS CRISTALLO POLITO
COUNCIL FOR EVERYTOWN FOR GUN
SAFETY IN THE KNOTT YAHA.
DIRECTOR POLICY FOR MARCH FOR
OUR LIVES SO YOU HAVE TO
WITNESSES YES THANK YOU OKAY YOU
WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES OF YOUR
TIME. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME
IS CRYSTAL OF A LOT OF MONEY
SERVICE POLICY COUNCIL FOR
EVERYTOWN FOR GUN SAFETY
TOGETHER WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION
INSTANCE MAN ACTION BY THE
LARGEST GUN VIOLENCE PREVENTION
ORGANIZATION IN THE NATION.
WE'RE GRATEFUL TO ASSEMBLY
MEMBER OF OUR CAMP FOR BRINGING
THIS BILL FORWARD. EIGHTY THREE
OH ONE ONE UPDATE CALIFORNIA'S
LANDMARK GUN VIOLENCE
RESTRAINING ORDER LAW TO INCLUDE
THE ACQUISITION OF BODY ARMOR ON
THE LIST OF FACTORS THE COURT
MAY CONSIDER. IN DETERMINING
WHETHER GROUNDS EXIST TO ISSUE.
AND AS WE SAW ON HER. TRY LIKE
THE TOP. SHOOTING IN BUFFALO
LAST YEAR. IN SAN BERNADINO.
HERE IN TWENTY. MEASURE ARE
INCREASINGLY PUTTING ON BODY
ARMOR TO PROLONG THEIR DEADLY
RAMPAGES. BODY ARMOR IS A
SPECIAL TYPE OF EQUIPMENT THAT
ENABLES A SHOOTER TO INFLICT
GREATER INJURY AND DEATH. BY
MAKING IT MORE DIFFICULT FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO DISARM THEM. IT
IS BECOMING INCREASINGLY COMMON
ACCESSORY. WORN BY EXTREMISTS
AND PEOPLE INTENT ON TERRORIZING
COMMUNITIES. BODY ARMORS PRIMARY
PURPOSE IS TO PROVIDE A
DEFENSIVE BARRIER TO ONE'S BODY
WHILE IN THE LINE OF FIRE. BY NO
MEANS IS THE ACQUISITION OF BODY
ARMOR ALWAYS REFLECTIVE OF
INTENT TO COMMIT CRIMES OR
SPECIFICALLY MASS SHOOTINGS. BUT
WHEN A CIVILIAN PURCHASES
BODYARMOR. INDICATING THEY
ANTICIPATE BEING IN A
CIRCUMSTANCE REQUIRING
PROTECTION FROM BULLETS. AND
THERE IS OTHER EVIDENCE OF
VIOLENCE BEHAVIOR. BUT THE
BEHAVIOR THREATS LEADING TO A
GUN VIOLENCE RESTRAINING ORDER
PETITION. COURTS SHOULD BE
ATTUNED TO THE FULL
CONSTELLATION OF RISK FACTORS
PRESENTED- I KNOW MEMBERS OF
THIS COMMITTEE ARE FAMILIAR WITH
OUR DE VERA LOS SO I'LL JUST
NOTE. THAT BY ITS NATURE PENAL
CODE SECTION ONE EIGHT ONE FIVE
FIVE ASKS COURTS TO CONSIDER
HOLISTIC SET OF CIRCUMSTANCES IN
DETERMINING WHETHER TO ISSUE A
GUN VIOLENCE RESTRAINING ORDER.
THIS BILL REALLY SEEKS TO DRAW
THE COURT'S ATTENTION TO ANOTHER
RELEVANT RISK FACTOR ONE WHICH
COULD TIP THE SCALES IN FAVOR OF
MORE ACCURATELY IDENTIFYING.
INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY BE PLANNING
DEADLY RAMPAGES OR GUN VIOLENCE
MOTIVATED BY AN EXTREMIST
IDEOLOGY. WE ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
ON AB THREE ONE THANK YOU THANK
. YOU NEXT PERSON YOU HAVE TWO
MINUTES AS WELL. THANK YOU CHEN
COMMITTEE- FOR THE UP. TODAY MY
NAME IS ANNE I AND THE DIRECTOR
OF POLICY AT MARCH FOR OUR LIVES
ONE OF THE COUNTRY'S LARGEST
YOUTH FOCUSED GUN VIOLENCE
PREVENTION ORGANIZATIONS. IN THE
LAST DECADE BODY ARMOR HAS
BECOME INCREASINGLY COMMON
ACCESSORY FOR THOSE COMMITTING
TERROR AGAINST COMMUNITY IS.
ALWAYS SUCCESSOR USED BY THE
SHOOTER IN THE AURORA MOVIE
THEATER SHOOTING IN TWENTY
TWELVE THE SAN BERNADINO
SHOOTING IN TWENTY FIFTEEN. AND
LAST YEAR AS A TOP MARKET TOP
SUPERMARKET SHOOTING IN BUFFALO
NEW YORK WHERE TEN PEOPLE WERE
MURDERED AND THREE WERE INJURED-
ACCORDING TO A DATABASE OF MASS
SHOOTINGS COMPILED BY THE
VIOLENCE PROJECT WHICH IS THE
NONPARTISAN ORGANIZATION. AT
LEAST TWENTY ONE MASS SHOOTERS
OR THE LAST FOUR DECADES HAVE
ONE BODY ARMOR AND THE MAJORITY
HAVE BEEN DURING THE PAST TEN
YEARS. BODY ARMOR RANGES FROM
BULLETPROOF AND STAB WHO. STAB
PROOF VESTS TO CERAMIC PLATES
AND WHEN A SHOOTER IS EQUIPPED
WITH BODY ARMOR IT MAKES IT
DIFFICULT FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT TO
DE ESCALATE THE SITUATION. AB
THREE OH ONE WILL PROVIDE
SAFEGUARDS TO THE SECURITY FOR
COMMUNITIES- BY ALLOWING JUDGES
TO CONSIDER THE ACQUISITION OF
BODY ARMOR IS A CRITICAL PIECE
OF EVIDENCE WHEN DECIDING
WHETHER TO GRANT. A GPRS. OTHER
STATES HAVE BEEN WORKING ON
REGULATING THE SALE AND
POSSESSION OF. BODY ARMOR IN THE
LAST FEW YEARS SUCH AS NEW YORK-
AND THIS LEGISLATION WILL ALLOW
CALIFORNIA TO JOIN STATES LIKE
THEM TO ADDRESS IS DEADLY
CONNECTION. FOR THESE REASONS WE
ASK FOR AND FIVE VOTE ON AB
THREE OH ONE THANK YOU WILL MOVE
TO SUPPORT WITNESSES- PLEASE
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR ORG AND
THAT YOU SUPPORT. AGAIN WE'D
LIKE TO MOVE THROUGH THIS
QUICKLY. I'M SURE MEMBERS STAND
FOR ON BEHALF OF. ANGELES JUST
ATTORNEY'S. AND XANDER WHAT SOME
VOLUNTEER MOM DEMAND THAT. AND
JUST K. CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
. FOR LINDA WHEATON VOLUNTEER
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
CATHERINE NO MARTHA VOLUNTEER
WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN
STRONG SUPPORT. SUSAN BURNS
VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS DEMAND
ACTION IN SUPPORT. ERIN
CHAMBERLAIN VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT. CAN
MEN FREDDIE VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT. ALEX
NAVARRO WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION
IN STRONG SUPPORT. JUSTIN
KOEHLER ONLY TO COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SEE NO OTHER SUPPORT
WITNESSES I'D LIKE TO MOVE ON TO
THE OPPOSITION WITNESSES IF YOU
WERE IN OPPOSITION- YOU WILL
HAVE TWO MINUTES. SEEING NONE-
WILL MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION
WITNESSES IN THE ROOM STATE YOUR
NAME YOUR ORGAN THAT YOU OPPOSE.
THING NINE A MODERATOR PLEASE
FROM THE FIRST INDIVIDUAL TO
SPEAK. I SUPPORT OPPOSITION FOR
AB THREE ONE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO. WE'LL GO TO LINE
FOURTEENTH. OKAY MOVING ON TO
THE NEXT PATERNO DOKEY. WE'LL GO
TO LINE. TWENTY FIVE. RECURRENCE
COMMITTEE LEDUC OF CALIFORNIA
SUPPORT. AND MEDICARE WE HAVE NO
FOR THE SUPPORT OF OUR THANK YOU
MOVE COMES AS TO MEMBERS THE
COMMITTEE SAYING NONE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WHICH LIKELY BACK LAST
YEAR THANK YOU TO HAVE A MOTION
. SENATOR WE HAS MOVED THE BILL
CAN WE CALL VOTE MOTION IS THE
TO THE FLOOR WELL HI TIME I CHAU
BOKE. BRADFORD SKINNER WIENER
AYE WIENER AYE THAT BILLS ON
CALL YOU SOMETHING THANK YOU
CENTER- WE ARE GOING MOVE ON I
WANNA MAKE ANOTHER AND I OKAY SO
WE ASSEMBLY MEMBER. PRESENT S.
THREE M. SEVEN THREE TWO SEVEN
THREE THREE ASSEMBLY MEMBER AS
MEMBER ASSEMBLY OF PATTERSON-
AND FOR ASSEMBLY MEMBER C. IF OR
FIRST FOR WHAT PLEASE COME IN
BECAUSE YOU WILL THE LAST ONE-
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FONG- PLEASE
PRESENT SEVEN THIRTY TWO. GOOD
MORNING MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
ASSEMBLY BILL SEVEN THREE TWO
STRENGTHENS THE PROCESS FOR
REMOVING FIREARMS FROM PEOPLE
WEREN'T ALLOWED TO OWN AND TO A
CRIMINAL CONVICTION I'D LIKE TO
START BY THANKING YOUR STAFF FOR
THE WORK AND EFFORTS ON THIS
BILL I WILL ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS. THIS IS
ONE OF SEVERAL BILLS THAT HAVE
BEEN WORKING ON AS A RESULT. THE
TRAGIC MASS SHOOTING IN MODERN
PARK IN MY DISTRICT. THIS BILL
INCREASE THE COURT AND
PROSECUTING ATTORNEYS ROLES. MR
IN A FARMS ARE TURNED OVER AT
THE TIME OF CONVICTION. WILL
ALSO REQUIRE INCREASED
COORDINATION BETWEEN THE
DEPARTMENT JUSTICE. AND LOCAL
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES TO
ADDRESS. A BACKLOG OF
INDIVIDUALS HERE ILLEGALLY. WHO
MAY LEGALLY OWNED FIREARMS.
TOGETHER THESE EFFORTS WILL MAKE
OUR COMMUNITIES SAFER. HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. IS DISTRICT
ATTORNEY PAMELA PRICE FOR
ALAMEDA COUNTY. AND IT'S AWESOME
IT'S. GOOD FOR THE PROSECUTORS
ALLEGE THE CALIFORNIA. A
DISTRICT ATTORNEY YOU WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES THANK YOU VERY MUCH-
THE ARM PROHIBITS PERSON SYSTEM
. AT A STATE DATABASE FOR
TRACKING INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
PROHIBITED FROM OWNING A
FIREARM. YEAH HAVE A FIREARM
REGISTERED IN THEIR NAME IS AN
IMPORTANT TOOL FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT. FOR US TO BE ABLE
TO INSURE- THAT PEOPLE WHO
SHOULD NOT HAVE A FIREARM WHO
ACTUALLY PRESENT A DANGER TO OUR
COMMUNITY. ARE FORCED TO
RELINQUISH THAT FIREARM AND
WITHIN FORTY EIGHT HOURS VERSUS
FIVE DAYS WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
THIS LEGISLATION AND APPRECIATE-
THE- THE ASK FOR YOUR VOTE IN
SUPPORT OF IT BECAUSE WE BELIEVE
IT WILL SAVE LIVES. IT IS
CRITICAL THAT EACH INDIVIDUAL
WHO HAS AT LEAST ONE FIREARM
REGISTERED IN THEIR NAMES. EVEN
THOUGH THEY'RE PROHIBITED ONCE
WE ARE TAKING ACTION TO MAKE
SURE THAT THEY'VE BEEN CONVICTED
OR THAT WE HAVE A RESTRAINING
ORDER. THAT WE HAVE A THE
ABILITY TO IMPLEMENT THE LAW AND
TO ENFORCE THE LAW AND IT
STRENGTHENS THE COMMUNICATION
BETWEEN OUR OFFICES. LOCAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT INCLUDING
PROSECUTORS IN OUR EFFORTS TO
CLEAR THE BACKLOG OF PEOPLE IN
THE ARMED PROHIBITED PERSON
SYSTEM. IT RESEARCH SHOWS THAT
REMOVING GUNS FROM OUR COMMUNITY
AND FROM PERSONS WHO SHOULD NOT
BE OWNING GUNS WILL SAVE LIVES
WILL MAKE OUR COMMUNITY SAFER.
ONE PROVE PUBLIC SAFETY BY
IMPROVING HELPING US AS
PROSECUTORS JUDGES AND LAW
ENFORCEMENT REMARK FACT. IT IS
SURE THAT WE SWIFTLY REMOVE
FIREARMS FROM EVERY SINGLE
PERSON WHO IS PROHIBITED FROM
OWNING THEM AS A RESULT OF
CONVICTION GUN VIOLENCE IN OUR
COMMUNITIES IS A TRAGEDY IS A
PLAGUE IT'S A PUBLIC HEALTH
CRISIS THAT WE NEED TO BE PART
OF MAKING SURE. THAT WE ARE
REDUCING THE NUMBER OF FIREARMS
THAT ARE IN POSSESSION OF PEOPLE
ILLEGALLY OR EVEN LEGALLY IF
THEY HAVE SHOWN THEMSELVES IF WE
HAVE REASON TO BELIEVE THAT THEY
ARE A THREAT. TO THEMSELVES OR.
TO OTHERS THAT WE HAVE THE TOOLS
AVAILABLE CARRILLO THAT THANK
YOU TIME THANK YOU I REALLY
PREFER IT. THE DUTCHMAN'S
PROSECUTORS ONCE COME SPAHN HERE
TO ANY. THANK YOU AND ANY ME TO
USE AGAIN NAME OR THAT USE VERY
QUICKLY. J. MINOR BEHALF
DIFFERENCE SAID IN GUN ALL SAID
. I'M SUPPORT ON THE OF MY
COLLEAGUE AT THE BRADY CAMPAIGN
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. BECAUSE
WITH EVERYDAY FOR GUN SAFETY AND
- KANDERSTEG FOR THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE IN SUPPORT
. SANDRA WHAT STERN VOLUNTEER
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN SUPPORT.
IN ORDER TO VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS
DEMAND ACTION AND STRONG SUPPORT
. LINDA WHEDON VOLUNTEER WITH
MOMS DEMAND ACTION IS SUPPORT.
SUSAN BURNS MOMS DEMAND ACTION
IN SUPPORT. ERIN CHAMBERLAIN
VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS DEMAND
ACTION AND SUPPORT. THE MAN
FREDDIE MONTEIRO MOMS DEMAND
ACTION IN SUPPORT. ALEX NAVARRO
WITH MOMS DEMAND ACTION IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU SEE NO OTHER
SUPPORT WITNESSES WILL MOVE ON
TO OPPOSITION WITNESSES. SAYING
NONE- ME TOO AWFUL SEEING NONE
WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO MY
MODERATOR FOR THE FIRST.
INDIVIDUAL BUT SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION FOR EIGHTY SEVEN
THREE TWO PLEASE CRISIS LONDON
ZERO. WE WILL GO TO A LINE FEB.
SIX WITH. THE MESSAGE. I HAVE A
SIX YOUR LINE IS. I ASSEMBLY
OKAY. WE'LL GO TO LINE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. BRUCE ARIANS WILLIS. THIS
IS. WE WILL GO TO LINE NINETY
SEVEN PEACEFUL. FOR MORE MONEY
TO YOUR ONLINE AND JUST HERE OF
THE- EUROPEAN CARE IN RIVERSIDE
COUNTY. OVER SEVEN BEEN AND
FAMILY MEMBERS OF IN OPPOSITE OF
THE SAID. THIRTY I. WILL GO. TO
SURE THE STOMACH PHANTOM THE
CHAIR OF THE SOUTH SACRAMENTO
CHAPTER OF THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE
AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION AND I
REMEMBER IN STRONG OPPOSITION.
WE'LL GO TO LINE SIX. I FELT THE
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL
WORKERS CALIFORNIATRUSTSWOMEN
STRONGLY SUPPORTS THE BILL- ONE
DIFFICULT TO ALIGN. NINETY FIVE.
MORNING MY NAME IS DARREN BUT
WELL MEMBER THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE
AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION AND
OPPOSITION. I WILL GO TO LINE.
NINETY EIGHT. HI MY NAME IS THE
INITIALS M. AND LIFETIME- CRP A
MEMBER AND I AM OPPOSING- THE
BILL. WE HAVE ONE LAST PERSON IS
KILLED OFF ONE MOMENT.
MOVING ON- WE WILL ASK MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE- COMMITTEE
MEMBERS DO YOU GUYS HAVE ANY
QUESTIONS COMMENTS OR THOUGHTS
SEEING NONE ASSEMBLY MEMBER TO
LIKE CLOSE THANK YOU SO MUCH I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NEIGHBORHOOD THANK YOU I CAN I
ASK FOR A MOTION. SO MOVE THANK
YOU THE IT HAS BEEN MOVED BY
SENATOR SKINNER I CAN CALL VOTE
MOTION IS TO PASS TO APPROACH AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS WILL
HOP HI HI- TOWBOAT. SURE ABOUT
AYE BRADFORD. BRADFORD AYE
SKINNER SKINNER WIENER. THAT
BILLS ON CALL FOR YOU SOME OF MY
SOMEONE WHICH LIKE TO ALSO
PRESENT AB THREE THREE. SIX MUCH
AMOUNTS MEMBERS ASSEMBLY BILL
SEVEN THREE WILL STATE AND
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND
DEPARTMENTS FROM SELLING
FIREARMS FIREARM PARTS
AMMUNITION AND BODY ARMOR I
THANK YOUR STAFF FOR WORKING
WITH ME ON AMENDMENTS TO ADDRESS
OPPOSITION'S CONCERNS. IN THE
WAKE. OF THE MEMBERS TAKING IN
TODAY HERE WALAU PUBLIC
ADMINISTRATORS PUBLIC GUARDIANS
REPUBLICAN CONSERVATIVES THE SUB
FARMS A BODY ARMOR IN THE
PERFORMANCE OF THEIR DUTIES AS
THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF
THE STATE. OR CONSERVATOR
GUARDIAN OVER A PERSON WHETHER A
STATE THE SECOND MEMO ALLOWING
THE TAKEN TODAY AS A WOULD ALLOW
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES THE
CELL CURIOS AND RELICS THE
NONPROFIT HISTORICAL SOCIETY
MUSEUM WHAT IS INSTITUTIONAL
COLLECTION FOR EDUCATIONAL.
DISPLAY OR PRESERVATION PURPOSES
THE THIRD AMENDMENT TAKING
TODAY'S ALLOWS LAW ENFORCEMENT
TO SELL FIREARMS TO OTHER LAWS
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES PATEL
LICENSE FARM TAYLOR WHO ONLY.
SELL TO OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES. IN THE WAKE OF THE
TRAGEDY SHOOTING IN PARK IT WAS
A POOR THAT A LOCAL ENFORCEMENT
AGENCY OR- TO SURPLUS FIREARMS.
IN ONGOING TALKS THAT WEEK OF
THIS. THE REVEALING GAP IN OUR
CURRENT. THERE'S CLEARLY NO
STATE LAW THAT PREVENTS STATE
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
AND DEPARTMENTS. FROM SELLING
FOR OF SURPLUS FIREARMS TO
MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC ASSEMBLY
BILL SEVEN THREE THREE ONE SURE
THE GOVERNMENT ENTITIES ARE NOT
PLAYING A ROLE. IN INCREASING
ACCESS TO DEADLY WEAPONS IN OUR
COMMUNITIES HERE TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT. OF THIS DISTRICT
ATTORNEY PAMELA PRICE FOR
ALAMEDA COUNTY. AND THAT'S
AWESOME IT'S GOOD FOR THE
PROSECUTORS ALLIANCE OF
CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU YOUR FIRST
WITNESS HAS TWO MINUTES TIMING
YOU. YES AGAIN EMERALD PRICE
FROM ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE. OUR RESEARCH
SHOWS THAT REDUCING THE NUMBER
OF GUNS IN THE COMMUNITY IS
CORRELATED WITH REDUCE GUN
VIOLENCE. AND ALAMEDA COUNTY AS
ACROSS THE COUNTRY AS ACROSS THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA WE'RE
EXPERIENCING AN EPIDEMIC OF
TRAGIC GUN VIOLENCE WHERE ACCESS
TO GUNS BY PEOPLE WHO. USE THEM
ILLEGALLY TALK HARM OTHER PEOPLE
IS A TERRIBLE. SITUATION FOR US
TO HAVE TO DEAL WITH AS
PROSECUTORS WE ARE. THE PERSONS
WHO ARE BEHIND THE CURVE AFTER
THE FACT WE ARE COMING IN BUT WE
NEED TO GO UPSTREAM. AND STOP
THE FLOW OF GUNS INTO OUR
COMMUNITY USING EVERY POSSIBLE
MEASURE. THAT IS AVAILABLE TO
LESS REDUCING- THE DISTRIBUTION
OF FIREARMS BY LAW ENFORCEMENT
IS A KEY ELEMENT IN A KEY
FEATURE OF THAT TO ENSURE THAT
OUR TAX DOLLARS ARE NOT USED. TO
SUBSIDIZE THE DISTRIBUTION OF
FIREARMS AND GUNS THAT WERE ONCE
USED BY LAW ENFORCEMENT SHOULD
NOT. END UP ON OUR STREET THIS
IS A SMART. PUBLIC SAFETY
MEASURES THAT WILL TAKE OUR
STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS OUT
OF THE BUSINESS OF SELLING GUNS.
LOCAL OUT TO THE PUBLIC AND TO-
REDUCE THE NUMBER OF GUNS ON OUR
STREETS EITHER INTENTIONALLY OR
UNINTENTIONALLY. WE. KNOW THAT
ALLOWING THE DISTRIBUTION OF GUN
AND BY ALARM FOR. THE PUBLIC'S
WILL IN FACT INCREASE THE HIGH
IN THE DAY TO PUBLIC. IN OUR
COMMUNITY AS SOME. I APPRECIATE
ASSEMBLYMEMBER FOR FROM BROUGH
THIS JUST. AND URGE YOU TO IT
WITH AND I'VE THANK YOU THANK.
RETIREMENTS FOR PROSECUTORS
ALLIANCE SPONSORED BILL HERE ANY
QUESTIONS THANK YOU APPRECIATE
THAT ANY SUPPORTER. ME TOO AGAIN
NAME ORG. FOR MEMBERS TO ALL ON
BEHALF LAWSUIT COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE. NJT MINOR
ALSO ON BEHALF OF GIFFORDS AND
BRADY CAMPAIGN. YEAH ALL RIGHT
SEEING NO OTHER OFFICE I MEAN I
SUPPORT WITNESSES TO HAVE ANY
AUTO. C. NINE WILL MOVE ON
MODERATOR PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL TO SPEAK. LADIES AND
GENTLEMAN FORCE FOR OPPOSITION
TO. AB SEVEN THIRTY THREE PRESS
ONE AND ZERO LOCAL TO LINE.
EIGHTY THREE. WE'LL GO TO LINE
SEVENTY SIX. MICHAEL CREDITO
CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
ASSOCIATION AND THE NRA. OPPOSE
. WE'LL GO TO LINE TWENTY FIVE.
IN LYNCHBURG ON BEHALF OF A
FRIEND COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
IN CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. WE'LL
GO TO LINE NINETY FIVE. MORNING
DURING BATTLE CALIFORNIA RIFLE
AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION IN
OPPOSITION. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
NINETY SEVEN. GOOD MORNING MY
LITTLE IN THE RIVERS. OPPOSE OR
SUPPORT. THE BOARD OPPOSING
SEVEN THIRTY THREE THANK YOU.
WHO GO TO LINE NINETEEN. FEDERAL
CHURCH OF A GRAND ULTRA
SOUTHSIDE MIDDLE CHAPTER THE
CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
ASSOCIATION AND ALREADY MEMBERS
TRONG OPPOSITION. WITH WE'LL GO
TO ONLINE. SEVENTY ONE. THE
WANNACRY FROM ERIN READ YET BUT
BEHALF OF THE C. H. IMPORT BOTH
GROUPS- ARE CURRENTLY IN
OPPOSITE HELD BASED THE
AMENDMENT THE CHP WILL GOING
PARK THE REVIEW TO- WE'RE GONNA
MOVE ON SEARCHING. TO OKAY.
BECAUSE WHEN I FOUR SO IN A LOT
OF. GOOD MORNING MY FELLOW
NUMBER OF THE COUNTY OF THE R.
P. AND ARE YOU STRONGLY OPPOSED
THANK YOU. KAMALA VOTE ONLINE
NINETY EIGHT. IT SHOWS WHY
MEMBERS PAY STRONG WITH. WILL GO
TO LINE EIGHTY THREE. THANK YOU
FOR HELLO NUMBER OF THE CAL
RIGHT AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION ARE
GOING ON THE AMERICA SEVERAL.
THAN REGULAR OPPOSING SAID
THIRTY AT ALSO LIKE TO READ UP
TO THE PREVIOUS BILL SEVEN THREE
AM NOT ALL ON THANK YOU. OKAY
WILL- TIMELINE. SIXTY THE
NATIONAL GRID OF WORKERS
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER WHICH FROM
THE- MADAM CHAIR WE HAVE NO FOR
ASSIST OFFICE THANK YOU WILL
MOVE THE CONVERSATION COMMITTEE
MEMBER SEEING NONE MOVE ON TO
SOME MEMBER WHICH I TO CLOSE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH I RESPECT ASK
FOR NINE BUT THANK YOU TO HAVE
A- RIGHT SENATOR BRADFORD MOVE
THAT CAN CALL VOTE.
PLEASE CALL VOTE. MOTION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO GOVERN
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE BOB HI
BOB I- TOBA. TURBO NOW BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER WINNER OF
SKINNER AYE WIENER- THAT BILLS
ON CALL APPRECIATE YOUR TIME- WE
WILL NOW MOVE TO SOME MEMBER
CALL IF IS HERE- YOU ASSEMBLY
MEMBER- ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA
WILL BE PRESENTING. AB. TWELVE
SIXTY SIX. THANK YOU CHAIR. A.
B. TWELVE C. SIX ADDRESSES THE
DISPARATE PUNISHMENT OF LOW
INCOME PEOPLE THAT DOES LITTLE
TO IMPROVE PUBLIC SAFETY BY
PROHIBITING THE ISSUANCE OF A
BENCH WARRANT IF THE UNDERLYING
CHARGE IS AN INFRACTION. LOW
LEVEL INFRACTIONS ARE MINOR
OFFENSES SUCH AS TRAFFIC
VIOLATIONS THAT ARE PUNISHABLE
BY A FINE I DO NOT REQUIRE A
COURT APPEARANCE IS ON THE
TICKET IS PAID BUT DESPITE
RECENT REFORMS JUDGES CAN STILL
ISSUE BENCH WARRANTS FOR ARREST
IN CASE WHERE A PERSON FEELS TO
IMPEDE APPEAR IN COURT FOR PAY
CITATION. SO FOR INFRACTIONS OF
THE LAW INTENTIONALLY DEAN DOES
NOT RISE TO LEVEL REQUIRING CAR
SERRATION INDIVIDUALS ARE BEING
SUBJECT TO ARREST AND
INCARCERATION FOR SIMPLY NOT
RESULTING IN UNPAID FINE.
ARRESTING A PERSON UNABLE TO PAY
A FINE NOT ONLY FURTHER DRIVES
THEM INTO POVERTY BUT CAN HAVE
ADVERSE LONG TERM AN IMMEDIATE
IMPACT ON THEIR ABILITY TO
SECURE HOUSING EMPLOYMENT AND
HIGHER EDUCATION THEREBY
CREATING A GREATER SOCIETAL
COSTS OUTWEIGHING ANY REASONABLE
BENEFIT DETERRING MINOR
OFFENSES. FURTHERMORE A TWENTY
SIXTEEN REPORT SHOWCASE EVENT
ONCE I JUST TO SUPPORT YOU
TARGET LOW INCOME PEOPLE OF
COLOR FOR EXAMPLE IN SAN
FRANCISCO ALMOST 49% OF THE
PEOPLE ARRESTED FOR FAILURE TO
APPEAR OR- OR TRAFFIC FINES. FOR
TRAFFIC FINES WERE BLACK DESPITE
BEING ONLY FIVE POINT 8% OF THE
POPULATION. FOR TOO LONG AND
FRACTION BENCH WARRANTS A
FUNCTIONS A DEBTORS PRISON
CREATING A SYSTEM WHERE PEOPLE
HAVE MONEY REFINES. NEVER HAVE
TO APPEAR IN COURT. FOR THOSE
UNABLE TO PAY COULD BE ARRESTED
FOR MINOR TICKETS. AB TWELVE
SIXTY SIX ADDRESSES CALIFORNIA'S
I'M JUST DEBT COLLECTION
PRACTICES. BY ENSURING
INDIVIDUALS ARE NOT INORDINATELY
PUNISH WHAT IS ESSENTIALLY A
CRIME OF POVERTY. HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS REBEKAH
MILLER SENIOR LITIGATOR WITH THE
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
POVERTY. THANK YOU TWO MINUTES.
THAT INSURANCE. WHY CENTER IS A
CO SPONSORING A TWELVE SIXTY SO
TOGETHER WITH OUR PART. IN THE
FREE TO TELL. CUT LISTEN TO AND
- PRACTICE THAT CRIMINALIZES
POVERTY. NO PERSON SHOULD END UP
IN JAIL SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY
CANNOT PAY A FINE GET UNDER
CURRENT LAW A PERSON CAN BE
ISSUED A BENCH WARRANT FOR
FAILING TO PAY A FINE OR RESOLVE
AN INFRACTION TICKET. HE'S OUR
LOW LEVEL OFFENSES THAT
OTHERWISE CANNOT BE PUNISHED
WITH JAIL TIME THEY SHOULD BE A
MATTER OF COLLECTION NOT ARREST.
ONE OF OUR COALITION MEMBERS
FACED A NUMBER OF INFRACTION
VIOLATIONS AT A TIME WHEN SHE
WAS UNEMPLOYED AND FACING
HOUSING INSECURITY. WHEN SHE
SHARES HER STORY SHE POINTS OUT
THE POLICY FAILURE OF USING
BENCH WARRANTS TO ENFORCE
INFRACTIONS. FACING ARREST AND
FURTHER LATE FEES DID NOT MAKE
HER MORE LIKELY TO PAY TICKET
SAID SHE COULD NOT AFFORD.
ENDING THE USE OF WARRANTS FOR
INFRACTIONS ALSO PROMOTES RACIAL
JUSTICE BECAUSE- BY CALIFORNIANS
ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE STOPPED
AND MORE LIKELY BE CITED THAN
WHITE CALIFORNIANS AND BLACK AND
BROWN CALIFORNIANS ARE ALSO MORE
LIKELY TO BE ARRESTED ON A
FAILURE TO APPEAR AND FAILURE TO
PAY WARRANT. CURRENT LAW. OTHER
WAYS TO ENSURE ACCOUNTABILITY
WHEN PEOPLE DO NOT RESOLVE AN
INFRACTION TICKET LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS CAN USE COLLECTION
AGENCIES WAGE GARNISHMENT SOME
TAP UP TAX OFFSETS. THROUGH THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD UNRESOLVED
CITATIONS ALSO SHOW UP ON
BACKGROUND CHECKS FURTHER
INCENTIVIZING PEOPLE TO RESOLVE
THEM. WELL TRAFFIC COURTS HAVE
MOVED AWAY FROM RELIANCE ON
BENCHMARKS MANY COUNTIES
INCLUDING LOS ANGELES SACRAMENTO
AND STANISLAUS STILL ISSUE
WARRANTS. AGAINST PEOPLE WHO DO
NOT PAY CITATIONS FOR NON
TRAFFIC INFRACTIONS. CALIFORNIA
HAS BEEN A NATIONAL LEADER IN
CLOSING THE DOOR TO DEBTORS
PRISONS WHEN PEOPLE CANNOT OF.
AFFORD TO PAY FINES AND FEES NOW
IS THE TIME TO ELIMINATE THE USE
OF BENCH WARRANTS FOR INFRACTION
TICKETS. AND THIS AND EFFECTIVE
ANTIQUATED TOOLS OF THE MASS
INCARCERATION. THANK YOU. ANY
OTHER LEAD WITNESSES THING NINE
WILL MOVE ON TO SUPPORT
WITNESSES. CANACCORD I'M ON
BEHALF OF THE LAWYERS COMMITTEE
FOR CIVIL RIGHTS OF THE SAN
FRANCISCO BAY AREA CODE SPONSOR
AND INITIATE JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. PIMPLES ALL BAFFLE US
IN CA. ATTORNEY OFFICE IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. JUSTIN
CALDERON TO COUNTY. FOR OFFICE
IN SABAH. EGYPTIAN ELEVATOR
CENTER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS IN
SUPPORT. CLOSELY CALDWELL
HOUSTON FOR THE CALIFORNIA
PUBLIC DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. TWENTY VOLUNTEER A SEAL
YOU CALIFORNIA ACTION IN SUPPORT
. A LITTLE BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIANS FOR SAFETY AND
JUSTICE IN SUPPORT. SONYA THOMAS
AND KATHLEEN ON BEHALF OF
COMMUNITIES UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IN SUPPORT.
WHERE WAS I- COURAGE
ORGANIZATIONS SUPPORT. KATIE
DIXON WITH THE CALIFORNIA
COALITION FOR WOMEN PRISONERS IN
SUPPORT. BREVAN JONES FROM
COURAGE DREAMY ANBAR'S
FELLOWSHIP IN SUPPORT. ARTIST
WHY WOULD GIVE UNITED FOR
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND STRONG
SUPPORT. ATTACHMENTS CURSE
MARTYRS OF CALIFORNIA AND THE
PROSECUTORS LINES OF
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. ATTY HI
CALIFORNIA CIVIL LIBERTIES
ADVOCACY AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
DO WE HAVE ANY OPPOSITION
WITNESSES. TWO MINUTES. GOOD
MORNING TERROR NUMBERS CAME
STONE STONE ADVOCACY ON BEHALF
THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION WE HAVE A
RESPECTFUL OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED- POSITION SO FOR THE
VEHICLE CODE IF YOU FAIL TO
APPEAR THE COURT COULD SEAL
ADJUDICATE THE UNDERLYING CASE
AND RETAIN SOME SORT OF-
JURISDICTION OVER IT FOR. OTHER
INFRACTIONS- THE THERE IS NO
SUCH PROVISION- ALLOWED BY THE
CODES AND SO THERE IS NO WAY TO
HOLD CONSEQUENCES FOR ANY- OF
THOSE INFRACTIONS WHAT THAT MADE
LEAD TO IS THERE ARE CERTAIN
VIOLATIONS- THAT ARE CALLED WHAT
BETS THAT COULD EITHER BE AN
INFRACTION OR MISDEMEANOR THAT
MIGHT. LEAD TO A SOME
PROSECUTORS FILING THOSE AS
MISDEMEANORS RATHER THAN
INFRACTIONS- ADDITIONALLY THERE
SOME INFRACTIONS THAT ARE
ESCALATING IF YOU REPEAT THEM
OVER OVER TIME THEN THEY COULD
BECOME A MISDEMEANOR AND THIS
WOULD ELIMINATE THERE IS
THEREFORE WE'VE PROVIDED SOME
SUGGESTIONS- WE WOULD REMOVE OUR
OPPOSITION IF THE BILL WAS
AMENDED IN THAT FORM UNTIL
OTHERWISE WE MUST REMAIN
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK.
YOU APPRECIATE YOUR TIME ANY
OTHER OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE
MODERATOR PLEASE FROM THE FIRST
INDIVIDUAL. REPORTER OPPOSITION
TO AB TWELVE SIXTY SIX PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO. THE GLOBAL TO LINE.
TWENTY FIVE. CALIFORNIANS. I
TWENTY FIVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
WE HAVE NO FURTHER SUPPORT
OPPOSITION MANAGER THANK YOU
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE WOULD
YOU LIKE TO SPEAK. OF SENATOR
WHICH- VOGUE. HELLO AND WELCOME
GOOD MORNING THANK YOU. SO.
WOULD LIKE TO FIRST GIVE ME AN
OPPORTUNITY TO ADDRESS THE
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS THAT WERE
GIVEN BY THE OPPOSITION TO
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS OF THIS
CURRENT BILL. SO I WOULD LIKE TO
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS ARE ALWAYS
IN IN TWO WAYS ONE IS IT'S NOT
TRUE THAT INDIVIDUALS ARE NOT
HELD ACCOUNTABLE- FOR NON
TRAFFIC OFFENSES LAWS ALLOW THE
CITATION TO BE DEEMED AS
DELINQUENT DEBT THAT COULD BE
SENT TO CIVIL COLLECTIONS IN
ADDITION. OF IF PEOPLE DO NOT
APPEAR PAYING APPROX CITATION
THE CASE WE REFERRED TO COURT
COLLECTION PROGRAMS INTO PENAL
CODE FOURTEEN SIXTY THREE POINT
ZERO ZERO SEVEN AND THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD COURT ORDER
DEBT PROGRAM ADDITIONALLY EVEN
WITHOUT BENCH WARRANTS
UNRESOLVED REFRACTION SHOP IS
OPEN CRIMINAL CASES ON
BACKGROUND CHECKS AND POLICE
RECORDS PROVIDING FURTHER
INCENTIVE FOR SOMEONE TO RESOLVE
IT I THINK THAT IS. PLENTY
COMMENSURATE TO THE CONDUCT THAT
LEADS TO AN INFRACTION A RATHER
THAN JAIL TIME AND ADDITIONALLY
I WOULD JUST SAY I THINK I HAVE
MORE FAITH IN THE PROCESS AND
THE PROSECUTORS AND THE CDA DOES
BECAUSE I DON'T THINK
PROSECUTORS ARE GOING TO CHARGE.
SOMETHING GREATER THAN WHAT THEY
FEEL IS DEEMED NECESSARY IN
ORDER TO HOLD. SOME KIND OF- IN
ADDITIONAL- FOR- CONTROL OVER
THE CASE OF THE ALTAR. WE TALK
ABOUT OTHERS AND I SPENT ELEVEN
YEARS AGO EITHER TO WILL. BE
DEALING WITH- DOES ATTORNEYS AND
JUDGES AND OFTENTIMES A CASE
REGARDING LOCKLEAR'S- AND
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS A BASE. THERE
BOB A TO THEY THEY THEY THEY
THEY A JUDGE WHAT SHOULD BE A
WATER BASED ON THE FACTS OF THE
CASE AND I TRUST THE DISK
INTERNEES WILL CONTINUE TO DO
THAT. RATHER THAN HOLDING SOME
LEVEL OF THEIR PERSONAL
ACCOUNTABILITY OVER A CASE
RATHER THAN THE OTHER MEANS
UNDER WHICH SOMEONE CAN BE HELD
ACCOUNTABLE FOR NOT APPEARING OR
PAYING A FINE FOR. AN INFRACTION
WHICH IS NOT REQUIRED JAIL TIME.
THANK YOU. I WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
. SPECTER YES FOR ABOUT THANK
YOU TO HAVE A MOST. TO HAVE A
MOTION. THANK YOU SENATOR
BRADFORD MOVES THE BILL. YOUR
CALL VOTE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS WILL HOP ON HOP
I'LL CHOKE. BRADFORD FIVE
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER. WIENER ALL
RIGHT THAT BILLS ON CALL YOU
SOMEONE TO GET. WHAT HAPPENS WE
HAVE MANY BILLS WERE HAVE TO
OVER JUST AS AN FYI I'M PUTTING
TO RECORD TOO MANY BILLS- NO I
APPRECIATE THAT- AND I DO WANT
TO THANK ALL THE WITNESSES WE
JUST LIKE TO KIND OF MOVE.
QUICKLY WE ALSO HAVE A BUDGET-
THE CONVERSATION THAT WE NEED TO
HAVE A STARTING ROUGHLY AT NOON
TO TWELVE THIRTY SO WE WANT TO
MOVE A LITTLE BIT FASTER.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CARILLO WOULD
YOU LIKE TO PRESENT AB. THIRTEEN
OH SIX. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
AND MEMBERS. PROUD TO PRESENT AB
THIRTEEN OH SIX THE HOT THE
HARMONIZING OUR MEASUREMENTS OF
THE QUALITY- OR THE HOME ACT
THIS BILL WILL ENSURE THAT
IMMIGRANT CALIFORNIANS ARE NOT
EXCLUDED FROM RECENT CRIMINAL
JUSTICE AND COMPASSIONATE
RELEASE REFORMS. PASSED BY THE
LEGISLATURE IN RECENT YEARS THE
LEGISLATURE HAS RECOGNIZED THAT
OVER INCARCERATION HURTS OUR
STATE AND OUR COMMUNITIES AND
WE'VE GIVEN THE INDIVIDUALS WHO
RECEIVED. HARSH SENTENCES AS
YOUNG PEOPLE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
EARN PAROLE. THE LEGISLATURE HAS
RECOGNIZED THAT THERE SHOULD BE
AVENUES FOR THOSE WHOSE
CONVICTIONS WERE TAINTED BY
RACIAL BIAS OR THOSE WHO WERE
CONVICTED UNDER STATUES THAT WE
HAVE MORE RECENTLY REFORMED. THE
LEGISLATURE HAS ALSO RECOGNIZE
THE NEED TO GIVE JUSTICE
IMPACTED INDIVIDUALS A DIGNITY
TO LEAVE UP LIVE OUT THEIR FINAL
DAYS WITH THEIR LOVED ONES AND
WITH ADEQUATE ACCESS TO MEDICAL
CARE. BUT AS A STATE WE HAVE
RECOGNIZED THOSE NEEDS- AS A
STATE WE HAVE RECOGNIZED THOSE
NEEDS BUT IMMIGRANT CALIFORNIANS
ARE ARBITRARILY LEFT OUT FOR NO
REASON OTHER THAN WHERE THEY
WERE BORN. IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT
TO RECOGNIZE THAT THE WORD
IMMIGRANT IS NOT SYNONYMOUS WITH
BEING UNDOCUMENTED THERE ARE
INDIVIDUALS WITH PERMANENT
RESIDENCY REFUGEE OR ASYLUM
STATUS. INCOME COUNTLESS OTHER
DEFINITIONS WHO ARE NOW BEING
DOUBLE PUNISH AFTER THEY HAVE
RECEIVED PEARL. OUR STATE PRISON
SYSTEM TURNS THEM OVER TO
IMMIGRATION CUSTOMS ENFORCEMENT
FOR A DOUBLE PUNISHMENT.
INDEFINITE INCARCERATION
IMMIGRATION DETENTION CENTERS
WHICH IS A SENTENCE THAT IT'S
NEVER BEEN HANDED DOWN BY A
CRIMINAL COURT OR A JUDGE. THIS
ARBITRARY DOUBLE PUNISHMENT IS
SERVED IN FACILITIES BEYOND.
CALIFORNIA STATE OVERSIGHT WHERE
ABUSES ARE WELL DOCUMENTED AND
WHERE THERE IS NO RIGHT TO LEGAL
COUNSEL OR TO BAIL. THE WHOLE
MATTER AB THIRTEEN OH SIX WELL
AND THE DOUBLE PUNISHMENT OF
IMMIGRANTS WHOSE CONVICTIONS ARE
THE SUBJECT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE
REFORMS. ALREADY SIGNED INTO LAW
THE WHOLE MAC BRINGS. OUT TO
LIGHT A DUAL SYSTEM OF JUSTICE
THAT IS UNEQUAL THAT TREATS
IMMIGRANTS AS LESS THAN. THAT
PERPETUATES PERPETUATES A BAD
IMMIGRANT NARRATIVE AN INVALID
IT'S THAT IS. OF THE PAROLE
BOARD ENTRUSTED WITH THE
DECISION MAKING AN INDIVIDUAL'S
REHABILITATION. AND ABILITY TO
RESTART THEIR LIVES HERE TO
TESTIFY. THAT IN SUPPORT AS
AVELLINO RICHARDSON WITH ASIAN
LAW CAUCUS. INFILL MELENDEZ WITH
MARCH EIGHTH TWO INDIVIDUALS
CORRECT OKAY YOU GUYS WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES AND WE DO TIME THANK
YOU. OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
AVELLINO RICHARDSON AND I'M
PROUD TO BE HERE TODAY IN
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTEEN OH SIX
THE HOME ACT. AND TO SHARE MY
FAMILY STORY WITH YA. MY FATHER
WAS INCARCERATED THROUGHOUT MY
LIFE AND BECAUSE OF THIS MY
UNCLE PLAYED A MAJOR ROLE IN
RAISING ME HE TOOK ME TO MY
FIRST DAY OF KINDERGARTEN HE
BRAIDED MY HAIR BEFORE SOCCER
GAMES. AND MOST OF ALL HE SHOWED
UP. FOR MY SIBLINGS AND I AS A
FATHER FIGURE MY UNCLE MIGRATED
TO THE UNITED STATES WITH MY
MOTHER IN THEIR SKILLING'S. TO
ESCAPE THE VIOLENCE THEY FACED
IN MAY HE GO. UNFORTUNATELY
WHILE REBUILDING THEIR LIVES MY
FAMILY EXPERIENCE THE SAME
VIOLENCE THEY HOPE TO ESCAPE MY
UNCLE WITNESSED HIS YOUNGER
BROTHER BEING MURDERED. AND
AFTER THIS TRAGEDY HE DID NOT
HAVE THE RESOURCES TO COPE WITH
THE TRAUMA. AND BECAME ADDICTED
TO DRUGS WHICH LATER LANDED HIM
IN PRISON WHEN I WAS ELEVEN
YEARS OLD MY UNCLE WAS
INCARCERATED. DURING HIS
INCARCERATION HE WORKED VERY
HARD TO RETURN TO US. MY UNCLE
QUALIFY FOR THE FENDER PRO
PROGRAM AND IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN
HE DEMONSTRATED TO THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARINGS. THAT HE WAS
ABLE FOR RELEASE I LOOK FORWARD
TO HIM COMING HOME AND REUNITING
WITH THEIR FAMILY. I WAS MOST
EXCITED FOR HIM TO ATTEND MY
GRADUATION FROM UC BERKELEY IN
TWENTY NINETEEN. BECAUSE HE
SUPPORTED ME IN PREPARING MY
COLLEGE APPLICATIONS. HOWEVER ON
MY UNCLE'S REALLY STATE HE WAS
TRANSFERRED TO ICE AND DEPORTED
TO MEDICAL. IF THE HOME MAX HAD
EXISTED MY UNCLE WOULD HAVE HAD
THE CHANCE TO REUNITE WITH US.
AFTER EARNING HIS RELEASED.
SINCE MY UNCLE'S DEPORTATION
EVERY MONTH I WATCH MY ELDERLY
GRANDPARENTS IN THEIR DECLINING
HEALTH. TRY TO MANAGE TAKING A
BUS. EIGHT HUNDRED AND FIFTY
MILES INTO MAKE UP. TO REUNITE
WITH MY UNCLE. IN TWENTY TWENTY
ON ONE OF THEIR TRIPS MY GRANDMA
WAS HIT BY A CAR. AND HAS NOT
BEEN ABLE TO WALK SINCE.
DEPORTATION IMPACTS MULTIPLE
GENERATIONS WITHIN A FAMILY.
HERE IN THE U. S. MY UNCLE WOULD
HAVE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY.
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE HOUSING. AND
A DECENT JOB TO SUSTAIN HIMSELF.
HOWEVER IN MANY COULD HAS BEEN
VERY DIFFICULT FOR HIM TO REJOIN
SOCIETY. GIVEN THE LIVE THE
MAJORITY OF HIS LIFE IN HERE IN
THE US. I'M THANKFUL FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE MY FAMILY
STORY WITH YOU ALL. AND I WOULD
LIKE TO TAKE THIS TIME TO REMIND
YOU THAT THERE ARE MANY OTHER
FAMILIES. WHO ARE EAGERLY
AWAITING. THE RETURN OF THEIR
AUNTS UNCLES SISTERS. BROTHERS
FATHERS AND MOTHERS. I URGE
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. TO
VOTE I FOR THE HOME ACT ENSURE
THAT THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN GRANTED
RELIEF BY. CRIMINAL JUSTICE
REFORM. ARE NOT PUNISHED YOU TO
THURMOND. STATUS HI NAY OR DO
YOU TO VOTE AND- OF KEEP.
FAMILIES TOGETHER. YOU TO- NEXT
WEEK OR TWO MAY. AGAIN WE TIME.
A GOOD MORNING SHOW HOW.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS SOME MONDAY. A
SPECIAL PRODUCT DIRECTOR WITH
MUCH OF HIS CO. AND PROUD TO
SAY. HERE TODAY. IN SUPPORT OF
THE HOME MAX- BECAUSE AS YOU'VE
HEARD WE HAVE A TWO TIERED
SYSTEM OF JUSTICE TO TREAT YOU
DIFFERENTLY BASED ON WHERE YOU
WERE BORN. AND THAT GOES AGAINST
EVERY FIBER OF WHO WE ARE AS A
STATE. IT'S TIME WE STOP THAT
DOUBLE PUNISHMENT AND LIVE UP TO
OUR SHARED VALUES OF EQUALITY
FAIRNESS AND COMMON HUMANITY.
AND THAT POINT OF COMMON
HUMANITY IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT
FOR ME BECAUSE WHEN. I WAS
NINETEEN YEARS OLD I WAS
SENTENCED TO LIFE IN PRISON.
AFTER NEARLY TWENTY YEARS OF
INCARCERATION I WAS ABLE TO
RETURN HOME TO MY KIDS AND WIFE
THANKS TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE
REFORM. REFORMS PASSED THAT
RECOGNIZED MY HUMANITY AND
POTENTIAL. TO TRANSFORM MYSELF
AND CONTRIBUTE TO MY COMMUNITY-
SPECIFICALLY HAVE BENEFITTED
FROM A LAW THAT GAVE- PEOPLE WHO
RECEIVED CONVICTIONS AS USE. AN
OPPORTUNITY TO SEEK THEIR
FREEDOM. SOONER BUT MY STORY IS
NOT UNIQUE. EARLIER THIS YEAR. A
SMART JUSTICE VISITED PELICAN
BAY IN CRESCENT CITY WHERE WE
SPOKE WITH MEN WHO WERE. TAKING
COLLEGE COURSES TO NOURISH THEIR
MINDS. AND PARTICIPATING IN
PERSONAL GROWTH AND
ACCOUNTABILITY PROGRAMS TO HEAL
THEIR SOULS. AND HELP THEM BE
SCRIPT WE DISCOVER THEIR
COMMUNITIES. THESE MEN HAD TAKEN
A DEEP HARD LOOK AT THE HARM
THEY CAUSED AND WE'RE READY TO
RETURN TO GIVE BACK TO THEIR
FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES. WE MET
SEVERAL MEN WHO WOULD SOON BE
RELEASED. BUT FOR SOME OF THEM
THAT JULIA FINALLY LEAVING
PRISON AND- RECONNECTING WITH
THE LOVELAND WAS DAMPENED BY THE
REALITY THAT THEY WOULD. NOT GET
TO COME HOME. THEN THAT THERE
WOULD BE TO. AND I SAW SO MUCH
MYSELF AND MY CHEN IN THEM.
NUMBER REMINDED THAT WHILE KERR.
HAS DONE THE HARD WORK OF OVER.
OUR FROM JUSTICE. TO ADDRESS
HARSH SENTENCES. ANGEL BY
FINANCE COMMUNITIES. AND WELL
BEING. WE STILL HAVE MUCH WORK
TO DO TO APPLY THE FORM REFORMS
EQUALLY. THE HOME ACT DOES NOT
ERASE HARM THAT WAS CAUSED. NO
IT ISN'T A RACE INDIVIDUALS
LIFELONG COMMITMENT TO MAKING
AMENDS. RATHER THE HOME ACT
RECOGNIZES PERSONAL
TRANSFORMATION. AND GIVES PEOPLE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO CONTINUE THE
WORK. THEIR WORK OF GIVING BACK
TO THE COMMUNITIES EFFECT IF
THEY ARE QUALIFY FOR EXISTING.
PROBABLY SUPPORTED LOS SO
LETTERS- THE LEGISLATURE TO PASS
THE HOME ACT. TO ENSURE THAT
EXISTING LAWS THAT THEY WERE
TALKING PASS. THROUGH THE
PRESENT CORPORATION. RACES AND-
SYSTEM A. I THANK JEFF. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER YOU WOULD LIKE TO JUST.
APPROACH THE FRONT. THANK YOU
AND THEN- FOR THE- THAT ARE.
LOOKING TO. PLEASE STATE YOUR
NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION AND THAT
YOU SUPPORT AGAIN WE WOULD LIKE
TO. MOVE VERY QUICKLY. LESLIE
CALDWELL HOUSTON FOR THE
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC DEFENDERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. I THINK
SOME. THE REST OF OUR ON BEHALF
OF. PRIVACY. REALLY LOOK A WITH
ONE VERSE. FROM BEEN TO COUNTY
SUPPORT. MY GUT SAYS ON A FIRM
CENTER FOR EMPIRE A FEW KEY AND
- THE ARE INISH JEFF IN THE
GROUP TRAIN INSTITUTE IN SOME.
BASICALLY ASIAN AMERICAN
ADVANCING JUST SOMETHING OR IN
SUPPORT- CURLED K. WITH ASIA
AMERICANS THE TO. ASIAN LAW
CAUCUS I COAST. CAN WIN THE BID
RIGHT I KNOW COUNTY WITH. IN THE
EVELYN C. IS STILL YOU CAN ACT
IS THE- KATIE DIX LOOK COALITION
FOR HIS PRISON SPROUT CO SPONSOR
PROP WORK ON THIS IT WAS THE. ST
LOUIS WITH THE ALL OF US AND
MANAGE TRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. LAWRENCE **** WITH
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS
WITH CHILDREN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU LET'S PICK UP THE
SPEED TO. MELENDEZ THE ELEVATORS
AT A FUNERAL. FOR CAN HARTMAN
TRANSFORM IN PER WORKGROUP
STRONG SO. MARKET DRUM BEHALF OF
THE LOS ANGELES CA BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS AND SUPPORT. ANDREA
THIS GONNA BE OFF OF THE
CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT POLICY
CENTER CO SPONSOR OF THE BILL IN
SUPPORT. I WAS DESIGNED GONZALEZ
INITIATIVE A BERKELEY STRONG
SUPPORT. ARLENE SALAS OKAY
STRONGLY SUPPORT. DISPASSIONATE
FOR CHINESE FIRM ACTION IN SO.
SUELO KILEY BE BE BE I SUPPORT.
REMINDS WITH IS A BECAUSE WE
STRONGLY SO. ARTIST WHITE WITH
CAN UNITED FOR YOU TEST SUCH SO
. YOU CAN SEVEN CISCO DEFENDER
OFFICE SPONSORED SUPPORT. HE AND
WHEN WE ASIAN PRESS SUPPORT
COMMITTEE AND- ALSO IN SUPPORT
EIGHTEEN MILLION RISING ALMOST
LIBRES BAEZ'S COLLECTIVE
AMERICAN FRIENDS SERVICES
COMMITTEE SAN DIEGO A PAIR RISE
BEND THE ARC BRAVO AND BRAVO
CLERGY. AND LAITY UNITED FOR
ECONOMIC JUSTICE VENTURA COUNTY
COUNCIL ON AMERICAN ISLAMIC
RELATIONS CALIFORNIA FRIEND'S
COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION LATER
OF CALIFORNIA HARBOR INSTITUTE
FOR IMMIGRANT AND ECONOMIC
JUSTICE HOME RIGHT SAN
FRANCISCO. HOME THE HOME IS
UNIQUE MIROS THANK INDIVISIBLE
SAN FRANCISCO CLAY A COMMUNITY
SYNAGOGUE IMMIGRATION COMMITTEE
KNOCKS IMMIGRATION TEAM L. A.
COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER'S UNION
LOCAL FOURTEEN EIGHT. LABOR
COUNCIL FOR LATIN AMERICAN
ADVANCEMENT SHORE AVENUE BAPTIST
CHURCH PEOPLE'S BUDGET ORANGE
COUNTY SELFIE PEOPLE POWER
STARTING OVER IN TRANSFORMING
JUSTICE ORANGE COUNTY SUICIDE
LITERACY AND COMMON LAW. AND
YOUTH JUSTICE COALITION. OF LOS
ANGELES. SORRY WESTERNS LOS RIO
IN SUPPORT. A LOT ON BEHALF
CALIFORNIANS FOR SAFE AND
JUSTICE IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
THANK YOU EVERYBODY WHO SHARED
THEIR STORY AND TESTIFIED AS
WELL I DO HAVE ANY OPPOSITION
WITNESSES. SAYING NONE WE WILL
MOVE ON TO ANY OPPOSITION
WITNESSES HERE IN THIS ROOM
SINGING ON MODERATOR PLEASE FROM
THE FIRST INDIVIDUALS SPEAK.
FIRST FOR OUR- TO AB THIRTEEN OH
SIX PRESS AND ZERO WE WILL GO TO
LINE THEIR- PLEASE GO AHEAD.
TWENTY FIFTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN
. THE ONLINE HEALTH SERVICES
RIGHTS AND EDUCATION NETWORK IN
SUPPORT OF AB. THIRTY SIX THANK
YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE ONE
TWELVE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. ABOUT A
LOT OF REALLY GOOD NINE ONE. IN
SUPPORT. PUBLIC LINE. ONE
SIXTEEN. FIRST OBVIOUSLY SPECIAL
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE C. OF WHAT
PALM IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU
. WE'LL GO TO LINE. NINETY HI
COMMITTEE FIGUEROA- WITH THE
ORANGE COUNTY COALITION AND
SUPPORT AND ALSO REPRESENTING
THE COUNTY RAPID RESPONSE
NETWORK IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE. SIXTY A
CALL FROM THE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
CALIFORNIATRUSTSWOMEN STRONG
PART OF ITSELF. WE'LL GO TO LINE
. ONE SEVENTEEN. HIGH
MAINTENANCE AND IDEA AND YOU
HAVE OF ORGANIZATION WHAT ARE
THEY HERE IN LONG BEACH AND TALK
PART OF THE HEALTH. THE COURT
LINE. FOURTEEN THANK AGAIN FOR
MEDICAL FOR HIM IMMIGRANT RIGHT
TO CLIENTS SUPPORT. WE'LL GO TO
LINE ONE FISH. THE AMNESTY
INTERNATIONAL LOCAL GROUP THIRTY
SAN FRANCISCO IN VERY STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU. NUMBER TWENTY
ONE ALL Q. THIS IS SO THEY DON'T
SEE IF IT'S SOMETHING THAT HE
THOUGHT HE WOULD- IF MOVEMENT
FORTY MILLION- THE SHARKS OF.
BUT I'M SURE WE HAVE TO OFFER
THE SUPPORT OPPOSITION THANK YOU
WILL MOVE THE CONVERSATION TO
MEET THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS-
SENATOR BRADFORD MEANS THE BILL
I DO HAVE A QUESTION OR MAYBE
JUST A CONCERN. SO I AM I WANNA
JUST STATE FOR THE RECORD FOR
THOSE THAT ARE LISTENING AND FOR
THE PUBLIC AT THIS PARTICULAR
BILL AND WOOD- WOULD EXCLUDE
ANYBODY FROM BEING REPORTED TO
ICE IS THAT ARE IN RELATED
RELEASED- BASED ON MEDICAL
PAROLE. FELONY MURDER
RESENTENCING. RACIAL JUSTICE ACT
YOUTH OFFENDER PAROLE ELDER
PAROLE COMPASSIONATE RELEASE
VICTIMS OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING. OR
INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE AND
ALL WHAT PRESENTING I WANNA MAKE
SURE THAT WE HAVE THAT ON
RECORD- AND THE REASON BEING IS
MY QUESTION IS AND YOU I'M NOT
SURE WHETHER YOU CAN AND CANNOT
ANSWER BUT- DO INDIVIDUALS WHO
HAVE ANY OF THESE- THAT FALL
UNDER THESE CATEGORIES. WOULD
THEY BE. ABLE TO FOLLOW- THE
IMMIGRATION PROCESS TO BECOME
CITIZENS OR THE DISEASE EXCLUDE
HIM FROM BEING- EVENTUALLY
APPLYING TO BEFORE CITIZENSHIP
IN THE U. S. THAT IS MORE OF A
FEDERAL QUESTION SAID I DON'T
HAVE THE ANSWERS TO. OKAY THE
REASON I'M ASKING IS BECAUSE
THIS IS AFFECTING. PEOPLE
WITHOUT A LEGAL STATUS HERE IN
IN THE U. S. THAT'S INCORRECT
CAN YOU CLARIFY THAT FOR ME THIS
IS NOT ABOUT PEOPLE WHO ARE
UNDOCUMENTED THIS IS ABOUT
ANYONE THAT'S A NON CITIZEN
FLOODING THAT CAN INCLUDE A
PERMANENT RESIDENT IT COULD
INCLUDE SOMEONE WITH REFUGEE
STATUS SOMEONE WITH ASYLUM
STATUS AND ANY OF THE OTHER
COUNTLESS STATUS THAT WE HAVE
ACROSS THE COUNTRY. THAT DOES
NOT INCLUDE CITIZENSHIP SO
IDEALLY SOMEONE THAT IS A
PERMANENT RESIDENT THAT IS A
REFUGEE THAT IS AN ASYLUM STATUS
HOLDER CAN POTENTIALLY APPLY FOR
PERMANENT RESIDENCY OR
CITIZENSHIP STATUS AND GO
THROUGH THAT PROCESS. IN THESE
IN THESE CATEGORIES WILL THEY
AND I MEAN YOU'RE OBVIOUSLY VERY
KNOWLEDGEABLE IN THE IMMIGRATION
I'M NOT BUT WITH THESE IMPEDE
THEM FROM BE ABLE TO BECOME
CITIZENS. AGAIN THAT'S MORE OF A
FEDERAL CONGRESSIONAL QUESTION
THAT I DO NOT HAVE THE ANSWER
FOR. OKAY WELL IT SEEMS LIKE YOU
KNOW A LOT OF THAT ONE PART BUT
NOT THE OTHER PARTS THAT WHAT
YOU'D HAVE TO LOOK AT SENATOR
YOU WOULD HAVE TO LOOK AT EVERY
INDIVIDUAL CASE. SOMEBODY WITH
THE REFUGEE STATUS IS NOT GOING
TO BE A REFUGEE STATUS FOR THE
DETERMINANT. YOU KNOW REST OF
THEIR TIME IN THE UNITED STATES
I WOULD IMAGINE THAT SOMEBODY
WITH REFUGEE STATUS WOULD LIKE
TO HAVE. AN OPPORTUNITY TO APPLY
FOR PERMANENT RESIDENCY AND
POTENTIALLY BECOME A CITIZEN OF
THE UNITED STATES WHAT THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT IS DOING. A
RELATED TO- CONVICTIONS AND
OTHER PROCESSES RELATED TO
POTENTIAL CITIZENSHIP. IS NOT
SOMETHING THAT I HAVE THE
INFORMATION FOR YOU ON AT THIS
MOMENT SINCE SINCE IT'S BEYOND
WHAT THE STATE LEGISLATURE CAN
DO HOWEVER. THIS BILL IS ABOUT
ENSURING THAT THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND
REHABILITATION. DOESN'T GO
OUTSIDE OF THE STATE BOUNDARIES
AND DO THE JOB. OF IMMIGRATION
ENFORCEMENT IMMIGRATION
ENFORCEMENT CAN DO ALL OF THAT
ON THEIR OWN WITHOUT US USING
OUR STATE RESOURCES TO HELP THEM
. OKAY AND. I NEVER HAVE TO RUSH
THROUGH THIS I HATE RUSHING
THROUGH BILLS AND NOT HAVING
PROPER DISCUSSION ON THEM. M. I
KNOW IT'S BEEN MOVED I KNOW I
KNOW I KNOW. I JUST FEEL THERE'S
SOMETHING ELSE THAT WE NEED TO
ADDRESS. SO SENATOR I'M GONNA.
GO AHEAD MOVE NO NO OKAY SO I DO
JUST APPRECIATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
BRING THIS BILL- AS A DAUGHTER
OF REFUGEES MYSELF- I THINK
THAT. THE IMMIGRATION SYSTEM IN
THE UNITED STATES IS BROKEN US
SENATOR I DO ALSO UNDERSTAND
YOUR CONCERNS AS WELL- BUT IT IS
A CASE BY CASE BASIS I'M SURE
PLENTY OF THESE PEOPLE OTHER
CASES ARE SO COMPLICATED. AND
THE WOULD NEED LEGAL ASSISTANCE
TO BE ABLE TO. KIND OF
CIRCUMVENT. ANNE'S SYSTEM TO
GAIN CLARITY TO. YOU KNOW SO
MUCH AND A LOT OF IT I DO JUST
WANNA HIGHLIGHT YOU KNOW WE
OFTEN TALK ABOUT ICE ICE WAS
CREATED IN A POST NINE ELEVEN IN
TWO THOUSAND THREE GRAY. AND SO
I THINK THAT THIS JUST ALLOWS
FOR US TO BE ABLE TO MOVE
FORWARD AS A STATE AND TAKE CARE
OF WHAT WE NEED TO TAKE CARE OF
AND PROVIDE THOSE CLEAR. LINES
SO OTHER THAN THAT I DO
APPRECIATE IT WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR-
THERE IS A TWO TIERED SYSTEM OF
JUSTICE IN OUR STATE. AND WE
HAVE PASSED INCREDIBLE
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE REFORMS THAT
AIM TO. ENSURE THAT INDIVIDUALS
ARE ABLE TO RETURN HOME. WE
SHOULD NOT JUDGE A CITIZEN AND
NONCITIZEN UNEQUALLY IF BOTH
INDIVIDUALS HAVE PAID THEIR DEBT
TO SOCIETY HAVE SERVED THEIR
TIME AND HAVE BEEN. PAROLED AND
REHABILITATED WITH THE PAROLE
BOARD SAYING IT SHOULD BE YOU
SHOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO RETURN
HOME. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT WE'RE
TRYING TO DO WITH THAT DOES NOT
IMPEDE ICE FROM DOING ITS JOB ON
THEIR OWN. ONCE THE INDIVIDUAL-
IS BACK TO THEIR COMMUNITY
WITHOUT RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU THE BILL HAS
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR BRADFORD
CAN CALL THE ROLL. MOTION IS TO
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS BOB HI
BOB I- TO ABOUT. BRADFORD I
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER. WINNER
THANK YOU. ARE THE BILL'S ON
CALL I APPRECIATE IT ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER PATTERSON WHO
WILL BE PRESENTING AB EIGHT
NINETY. A WE WOULD LIKE TO MOVE
QUICKLY THROUGH THIS SYSTEM WE
ALSO HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
SANCHEZ WHO HAS TO PRESENT TO.
WELL THANK YOU I APPRECIATE YOUR
FISH AND SEA. THANK YOU CHAIR
AND SENATORS I'M HERE TO PRESENT
AB EIGHT NINETY. UNDER CURRENT
LAW AFTER CONVICTIONS OF A
CERTAIN DRUG RELATED CRIMES YOU
HAVE TO TAKE A PROBATION CLASS.
AND THIS ONE CREATES A FAN ALL
SPECIFIC. I'M CLASS FOR THOSE
CONVICTED OF FEDERAL CRIMES. AND
SO IT'S PRETTY SIMPLE BILL NOW
WE THINK IT'S MORE RELEVANT HELP
PEOPLE UNDERSTAND YOU KNOW THE
DANGERS OF FAT AND ALL. THAT NOT
ONLY PERSONALLY BUT TO SOCIETY I
DO WANT TO ADDRESS A COUPLE
THINGS ABOUT THE FEES INVOLVED
HERE I AM MORE THAN WILLING TO
TAKE A COMMITTEES PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS I DO JUST WANT TO
COMMENT. FOR A SECOND THAT UNDER
CURRENT LAW AND IT IS HEALTH AND
SAFETY CODE ELEVEN THREE SEVEN
THREE A PERSON CAN'T GO TO
PRISON IF THEY'RE UNABLE TO PAY
FOR- THAT IS CURRENT LAW IF
THEY'RE UNABLE TO PAY FOR- THEIR
PROBATION CLASS AND TYPICALLY
WHAT HAPPENS IS COUNTIES WILL.
FRONT ABLE TO AFFORD WILL WAIVE
THE FEE ANYWAYS AND MY WITNESS
WILL ATTEST TO THAT SHORTLY BUT
WHAT I WANTED TO CREATE WAS A
CONSISTENT WITH OTHER MEASURES
IS A SYSTEM IN WHICH PEOPLE ARE
ABLE TO PAY. THAT THEY SHOULD
PAY FOR THE FI YOU KNOW I DON'T
WANT A RICH PERSON WHO'S BEEN
CONVICTED OF A CRIME HAVING A
FEE WAIVER. BUT WE ARE MORE THAN
WILLING TO TAKE THE AMENDMENTS I
THINK POLICY IS REALLY WHAT'S
MORE IMPORTANT TO ME. AND WITH
THAT SO I AM HAPPY TO INTRODUCE.
MY FRIEND AND PLUS COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY MORGAN GEYSER.
THANK YOU YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES
GOOD MORNING. TO ROB PHIL
COMMITTEE MEMBERS THANK YOU I'LL
BE QUICK- AB EIGHT NINETY
PROVIDES CRITICAL EDUCATION FOR
THOSE WHO INTERSECT WITH THE
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM AND ARE
AT THE EPICENTER OF THE FINAL
CRISIS- AND I WILL. ECHO WHAT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER PATTERSON SAID-
WITH REGARD TO THE FEE I AM
AWARE OF THE OPPOSITION'S
CONCERN. THAT SOMEONE WHO WAS
UNABLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE
CLASS BECAUSE THEY COULDN'T
AFFORD IT WOULD END UP VIOLATING
CURRENT LAW SAYS WE CAN'T DO
THAT AND FRANKLY AS A
PROSECUTOR. I WANT PEOPLE IN OUR
COUNTY WHO ARE GRANTED PROBATION
TO SUCCEED ON PROBATION I DON'T
WANT TO GET THE INFORMATION THEY
NEED THAT WILL SAVE THEIR LIFE
AND THE LIFE OF SOMEONE ELSE. SO
WITH THAT IT SERVES ME NO GOOD
TO- TO HAVE A SYSTEM IN WHICH
SOMEONE WHO CAN'T AFFORD THAT-
WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE
SO AB. EIGHT NINETY PROVIDES
THAT CRITICAL INFORMATION AND I
Y. TO THANK. MEMBER IN THE FOR
THE- THANK YOU- DO WE HAVE ANY
OTHER LEAD WITNESSES NOW. THANK
YOU ON ANY. WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME YOUR
ORGAN THAT YOU SUPPORT. CAN
STONE STRONG ADVOCACY ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
. STEPHANIE HERRERA ON BEHALF OF
THE IN POWER AND RESILIENCE
PROJECT IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
GOING TO OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
YOU WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES. GOOD
MORNING I'D LIKE TO TALK THEORY
VERSUS PRACTICE- AS I'VE STATED
BEFORE THIS BODY BEFORE I HAVE
FORTY YEARS OF EXPERIENCE AS A
CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY. IN
TWO DIFFERENT COUNTIES PUBLIC
DEFENDER'S OFFICES. AROUND THE
SOLANO COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER'S
OFFICE FOR TEN YEARS- MY
EXPERIENCE MY COLLEAGUES
EXPERIENCES AROUND THE- THE
STATE. HAVE BEEN THAT WHEN
THERE'S A SLIDING SCALE IMPOSE.
THERE IS NEVER A FEE WAIVER
THERE'S ALWAYS SOMETHING. I DO
WANNA SAY THE DID TAKE AMENDMENT
SO THERE'S NO SLIDING SCALE ANY
FURTHER. SO THERE'S NO FEE
WHATSOEVER- IT'S FOURTH YES IT'S
EXPLICITLY NOT ALLOWING THERE TO
BE. SENATE NOTICE THERE IS I WAS
NOT IF. THE OR THE YES SO
WITNESS ASSEMBLY MEMBER CAN YOU
CONFIRM THAT YOU HAVE TAKEN THE
MOMENT AS SUGGESTED BY THE YES I
HAVE TAKEN THE AMENDMENT
INTEREST STATING ON RECORD WAY
BACK YOU KNOW JUST GENERAL
CONCERNS ABOUT IT YES BUT- IF
YOU WANT TO BE CLEAR ON THAT
BECAUSE WE WERE PROMISED THAT
AMENDMENT. IN THE ASSEMBLY
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE. WE
OBJECTION LAST IN THE SHUFFLE
ACTUALLY NOT THAT'S OKAY SO WE
HAVE. IT'S TAKEN PASSED HERE
QUIT TAKING YOUR TIME I
APPRECIATE IT VERY MUCH ANY
OTHER WITNESS IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE MODERATOR PLEASE
PROMPT THE FIRST INDIVIDUAL TO
SPEAK. FORTY FOUR OPPOSITION AB
EIGHT NINETY THREE FIRST ONE
THEN ZERO WE'LL GO TO LINE FIFTY
ONE. YOU KNOW I'M A QUICK FROM
HERE ARENA SOCIUS ON THE ACT
BEFORE ASK IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
. WITHOUT WELL WE HAVE ONE OTHER
PERSON QUEUED UP. ALL RIGHT WE
WILL MOVE ON- DO WE HAVE ANY
COMMENTS FROM COMMITTEE MEMBERS
SEEING NONE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. WELL
THANK YOU A CHAIR AND SENATORS
APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS IN
HELPING TO COMBAT THE FAN ALL
CRISIS AND WITH THAT I ASK FOR A
VOTE THANK YOU TO HAVE A MOTION
. WE MOVED THIS BILL- BY SENATOR
WHICH WILL BLOW HAS MOVED THIS
BILL WITH AMENDMENTS- CHEMICAL
ABOUT RUSSIA'S THE PROCESS
MONITOR APPROPRIATIONS BOB FIVE
HOP I'LL CHOKE. JOB AYE BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE SKINNER WIENER.
THANK YOU THAT BILLS ON CALL
THANK YOU THANK YOU ASSEMBLY
MEMBER SANCHEZ YOUR FINAL
PRESENTER. YOU WILL BE
PRESENTING SORRY AB EIGHTY EIGHT
CORRECT. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
AB EIGHTY EIGHT IS A REASONABLE
BILL THAT WILL HELP CRIME
VICTIMS THEIR NEXT OF KIN AND
FAMILY MEMBERS MEANINGFULLY
EXERCISE THEIR RIGHTS DURING
PAROLE AND RESENTENCING
HEARINGS. SPECIFICALLY AB EIGHTY
EIGHT REQUIRES THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARINGS PROVIDED CRIME
VICTIMS NEXT OF KIN MEMBER OF
THE VICTIM'S FAMILY VICTIMS
REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL
REPRESENTATIVE REPRESENTING ANY
OF THESE PERSONS OR VICTIMS
SUPPORTING PERSONS MORE
FLEXIBILITY TO ATTEND A PAROLE
SUITABILITY HEARING. THE BILL
ALSO ENSURES THAT THERE IS A
CLEAR PROCESS FOR CRIME VICTIMS
TO HAVE THEIR VOICE HEARD ON A
PETITION OF RESENTENCING EVEN IF
THE DEFENSE AND PROSECUTION BOTH
AGREE TO WAIVE HEARING THIS IS A
COMMON SENSE BILL THAT
SAFEGUARDS THE CONSTITUTIONAL
RIGHTS OF CRIME VICTIMS. AND
THEIR LOVED ONES FOR THAT REASON
I URGE YOUR SUPPORT ON THIS
MEASURE TODAY TESTIFYING WITH ME
IS. JULIO DALY ON OF THE
RIVERSIDE COUNTY SHERIFF'S
DEPARTMENT THANK YOU YOU WILL
HAVE TWO MINUTES. THANK YOU A
MANAGER COMMITTEE. THE IMAGES OF
COMMITTEES TIMEKEEPER- AB EIGHT
WILL HELP ASSURE THE VICTIMS OF
CRIMES AND THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS
ARE TO MEANINGFULLY EXERCISE.
THAT RIGHT STERN PAROLE AND
RESET IN HEARINGS. CDCR REESE
ENACTED. ARE REQUIRED NOTICE
REQUIREMENTS FOR CRIME VICTIMS.
AND THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS FOR
THIS PARTICIPATING PRO HEARINGS
THESE NEW REGULATIONS IMPOSE ON
RECENTLY REQUIREMENTS FOR FAMILY
MEMBERS AND VICTIMS. IN THIS WAY
THE PARTICIPATION OF PAROLE
HEARINGS AB EIGHT INSURERS THAT
CDC ARE WILL ONLY ACCEPT A
FIFTEEN DAY NOTICE. TO ATTEND
PRO HEARING SIMILARLY A RECENT
RECENT LAW ENACTED A PERMITS A
COURT TO DISPENSE WITH HAVING AN
IN COURT HEARING. ON THE
PETITION FOR RESENTENCING OF ALL
PARTIES STIPULATE THE LAW
CONFLICTS OF MARCHES LAW. BUT
NOT FOR NOT BY NOT INCLUDE
PROVISIONS TO A LOT OF CRIME
VICTIMS TO HAVE THEIR VOICES
HEARD. AB EIGHTY EIGHT EMPOWERS
VICTIMS AND THE FAMILY MEMBERS
TO MEANING FREE EXERCISE OUR
RIGHTS. AND HOW THE VOICES HEARD
ON PAROLE AND RESENTENCING
HEARINGS. I'VE READ THE
OPPOSITION AND IT SEEMS A LITTLE
SHORT SIGHTED BECAUSE THIS ALSO
DISMISSES THE FACT THAT
SOMETIMES. VICTIMS HAVE A CHANGE
OF HEART- FOR THEIR OFFENDERS
AND EVEN THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS
HAVE CHANGE OF HEARTS. SO THIS
GIVES A VICTIMS ALSO THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN FRONT OF
A PRO BOARD. OR A HEARING
OFFICER TO LET THEM KNOW THAT
THEY HAVE FORGIVEN THE OFFENDER
FOR WHAT HAS WHAT HAS BEEN DONE
TO THEM. SO THAT WILL HELP THE
RESENTENCING OR THE PAROLE
DECISION EASIER TO MAKE. FOR
THE- YOUR ENOUGH. TO WITHOUT WE
HAVE TO SHARE VIA. WE ASK FOR I
TODAY'S YOU THANK YOU DO WE HAVE
ANY WITH AND SOME. PLEASE STATE
YOUR NAME YOUR ORGANS YOU SCORE.
HIM STONE AVENUE ON ACCOUNT. IS
ATTORNEYS THIS IS AND SOME THANK
YOU DO YOU HAVE ANY OTHER
SUPPORTERS. SING NON OFFICE.
SAYING NONE MODERATED PRINT
FIRST IN OF. FOR SUPPORT ON. FOR
ABA EIGHT PRESS ONE THEN ZERO.
M. SURE WE HAVE SUPPORTER
OPPOSITE THANK YOU I SHOULD BE
TO. WE HAVE ONE SEVENTY ONE
PLEASE GO AHEAD. DO YOU WANT TO
QUIT FROM ERIN RESISTANCE IT'S
ON BEHALF OF BLACK SUPPORT THANK
YOU. I WE WILL NOW HAVE THE
CONVERSATION MOVED TO COMMITTEE
MEMBERS COMMITTEE MEMBERS WOULD
YOU LIKE TO COMMENT SAYING NOT.
OKAY ASSEMBLY MEMBER WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE I RESPECTFULLY ASK
RIVAL THANK YOU AND SENATOR-
OCHO BOGE HAS MOVED THE BILL-
CAN WE CALL VOTE MOTION IS TO
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS WAHHAB I
HOPE I HOPE TO ABOUT. TO VOTE HI
BRAD. ON BRADFORD AYE SKINNER.
WIENER THE BILLS ON CALLED YOU
REMEMBER. OUR RIGHTS SO WE'RE
GOING TO CALL A RECESS AND- I
SAW WE CAN. OKAY LET'S LET'S. WE
CAN GET A CALL BY MARK. OKAY
WE'RE GONNA LIFT THE CALL JUST
WITH CAN. OCTOBER. HI WHATEVER I
. THE CONSENSUS. CAN IS OUT.
FIVE ZERO. AB THREE OH ONE HOUR
HAND MOTIONS TO PASS TO THE
FLOOR. BRADFORD ROAD FOR HIGH.
SCHOOL THAT BILLS ON CALL. AND
AB FOUR FOUR NINE MOST WAS TO
APPROPRIATE UP TO ABOUT.
NOW IS THAT BILLS OUT. FORTY
ONE. AB FOUR FIVE FIVE
QUIRK-SILVA MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTERS
FORTY ZERO A TOWBOAT. ITEM
NUMBER TEN YES HI FOR TURBO HIGH
THAT THOSE OUTSIDE. THAT BILLS
OUT FIVE ZERO EIGHTY FOUR SEVEN
FOUR RODRIGUEZ MOTION IS TO PASS
TO GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
CURRENT VOTERS FORTY ZERO TOBA.
TOBA BY. THAT DOES OUT. FORTY
FIVE FIVE ZERO SORRY. AB SEVEN
NINE BY MOTIONS TO THE JUST YEAR
CARVE OUT A THREE TO ONE BRAD.
ON SPREAD AYE THAT'LL WANT THAT
DOES NOT FOUR WHEEL. AB ELEVEN
EIGHTY SIX THIS. SEVEN THIRTY.
MY. JUST READ WHAT. YEAH WHEN WE
- IF YOU'RE EIGHTY SEVEN EIGHTY
SEVEN THIRTY MOTIONS TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO AND- RIGHT. YOU YOU
PUT IT ON THE RELEVANT AT YEAH A
. OKAY CERTAIN M. L. EIGHTY SIX
BONTA MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROACH CURRENT VOTE IS. TO TWO
ZERO. AB FIFTEEN. BRADFORD BRAD
I. OKAY ASSEMBLY BUT SHE WAS NOT
.
THERE.
AND THAT IS. YES JUST NOW JUST
GIVE US TO YOUR GRANDMOTHER YEAH
. ABOUT I THOUGHT YOU DID.
SOMETHING ABOUT OKAY OKAY AND
THE BILLS ON COST. M. AB SIXTY
SIX ITEM A MO TO PASS TO
APPROACH CURRENT LOTUS TO ONE
WIENER A WELCOME CALL KALRA.
WE'LL GET NOT YET. WE HAVE A
TWELVE WE CAN GO BACK DURING
ABOUT LET'S WE GO THROUGH AND
THEN WE'LL GO BACK AGAIN. AB
FIFTY EIGHT I NUMBER TWENTY
MOTIONS PASSED APPROACH CURRENT
VOTE THREE TO ZERO CHAVEZ WHICH
ABOVE NOW. BRADFORD I BILLS
HEALTH PORTAL. THE BILL IS OUT
FOR ONES AB TWELVE TO ONE SO
MOTION TO PASS TO APPROACH
CURRENT VOTE IS FOR TWO ZERO
CHAU WHICH ABOUT OUR. THE BILL
IS OUTRAGEOUS. AB THREE OR SO
ITEM TWENTY THREE MOTIONS THE
PAST APPROPRIATE KERN VOTE IS.
ZERO WIENER. WIENER HIGH. WE'LL
START WITH BILL REMAIN ON CALL.
AND AB FOURTEEN TWENTY ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY SO MOTIONS TO
PASSED APPROPRIATE KERN BY THE
STREET ZERO WIENER. WIENER AYE.
MAINER CALLS. AB SEVEN A ONE
ITEM NUMBER SIX MOTIONS TO PASS
TO APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE
IS THREE TWO ZERO BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE. THINK SOME CALLS
THAT WOULD REMAIN. MORE THAN.
OKAY YEAH I'M ITEM TWELVE A. B.
C. THIRTY MOTIONS TO AS A TO A-
KERN THAT IS SUPPORTED WINNER.
WINNER HIGH. FIVE ZERO AND L. IS
OUT FIVE ZERO ITEMS A SEVEN
THREE FONG MOTIONS PASS AS A TO
GOVERN AND FIND CURRENT BELT IS
TO ONE WE- I CLEANER HIGH. THE
BILL BELFOUR. THE BILL IS OUT
THE ONES.
WE'LL RECESS AND RETURNED TO
THIS ROOM UP IN A GERMAN OF
SESSION TO LIFT THE CALLS FOR
THE MISSING MEMBERS THANK YOU.
PUBLIC SAFETY RECONVENES- WE
HAVE SENATOR SKINNER- PLEASE
LEAVE THE CALL THANK YOU. YOU
READY YES FIVE ITEM TWO WAS AB
EIGHTY EIGHT TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE IS
FOUR TWO ZERO SKINNER SKINNER I
. FIVE ZERO THAT BILLS OUT ITEM
THREE EIGHTY THREE OH ONE
MOTIONS TO PASS TO THE FLOOR
CURRENT VOTE THREE TO ZERO
SKINNER HI SKINNER I. THAT TELLS
US WHERE THAT THOSE OUT FOR ZERO
ITEMS EIGHTY SEVEN OH ONE
VEHICLE DO IT MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE
FORTY ZERO SKINNER. IT'S
ACTUALLY FOR YES OKAY I SKINNER
HI THAT BILLS ZERO OUT ITEM
SEVEN EIGHTY FOUR FOUR NINETEEN
MAR MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT THAT IS
FOUR ZERO SKINNER HI SKINNER I.
THAT'S FIVE ZERO BILLS OUT ITEM
EIGHT FIVE OH FIVE HE X. NO
CARDS. WHAT ABOUT YOURSELF THE.
WITH ONE POINT. OKAY ITEM
FIFTEEN A WOULDN'T ONE EIGHT SIX
BY MOTIONS TO PASS APPROPRIATE
KERN VOTE IS TO SKINNER. THIS IS
A ONE ONE EIGHT SIX CORRECT FIVE
IT'S GOING BY. SKINNER HI THAT
BILL IS FOR ZERO THAT IS OUT. I
AM SIXTEEN EIGHTY EIGHT NINE
PATTERSON MOTIONS TO PASS AS
AMEND TO A PRO CURRENT VOTE IS
FOR ZERO. OKAY SKINNER I THAT
GOES OUT FOR ZERO. I AM A- AB
TWELVE SIXTY SIX CALL MOTIONS TO
HAVE TO PROVE SO VOTE THREE TO.
SKINNER ALL RIGHT SKINNER I.
THAT BILL IS OUT FOUR TO ONE. I
AM TWENTY THREE AB THIRTEEN OH
SIX CARILLO MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE IS
THREE TO ZERO SKINNER. FIVE
SKINNER HI. ON THIRTEEN OF SIX
FORTY ZERO ON THIRTEEN OH SIX
THAT BILLS OUT I'D I'D AT TWENTY
SIX EIGHTY FOURTEEN TWENTY
BERMAN MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE IS
FOUR TWO ZERO SKINNER. HI
SKINNER HI ZERO FIVE ZERO THAT
BILL IS OUT- PUBLIC SAFETY IS
NOW THANK YOU.