MORNING THE SENATE GOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE WILL COME
TO ORDER. THE SENATE CONTINUES
TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC IN PERSON
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY PARK THE
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS.
877-226-8163 THE ACCESS CODE IS
. THREE EIGHT SEVEN FOUR THREE
EIGHT ZERO WE'RE HOLDING
COMMITTEE HEARINGS HERE IN THE-
STREET BUILDING I ASK ALL
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE TO BE
PRESENT REAL TWELVE HUNDRED SO
WE CAN ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM. WE
HAVE NINETEEN BILLS ON TODAY'S
AGENDA HOWEVER FILE ITEM NUMBER
SIXTEEN AB THIRTEEN EIGHTY ONE
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER WEBER HAS
BEEN PULLED BY THE AUTHOR.
BEFORE WE NOPE WE'RE NOT DOING
THAT BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM- SO WE'RE GONNA START AS
A SUBCOMMITTEE. WE HAVE AN AWFUL
IN THE ROOM. ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE
NUMBERS THIS NUMBER ONE AB
THIRTY EIGHT GOOD MORNING ONE OF
HIS CHEN SANDERS I AM PRESENTING
TO BILLS TODAY BUT I'M GOING TO
START WITH AB THIRTY EIGHT. I'LL
BE ACCEPTING COMMITTEE MEMINTA
SPECIFIED THIS BILL APPLIES TO
NEWLY INSTALLED LIGHTS AND
EXEMPTS FAIRGROUNDS UP BY BY
DISTRICT AGRICULTURAL
ASSOCIATION FROM THE BILL. AB
THIRTY EIGHT LIMITS OUTDOOR
NIGHT LIGHTING ON STATE
BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES TO
PROMOTE SAFETY FOR PEOPLE
ECOSYSTEMS AND OTHER WILDLIFE
INDISCHE IN THIS REFORM
CONSERVES ENERGY AND REDUCES OUR
CARBON FOOTPRINT. ARTIFICIAL
LIGHT AT NIGHT OR ALLEN HAS
INCREASED TO UNPRECEDENTED
LEVELS GLOBALLY AND IN
CALIFORNIA THIS IS RESULTED IN A
DISRUPTION TO CIRCADIAN RHYTHMS
IN PLANTS AND ANIMALS WHICH
HARMS ECOSYSTEMS. ACCORDING TO
THE NATIONAL AUDUBON SOCIETY 70%
OF BIRD SPECIES MIGRATE EACH
YEAR AND OF THOSE BIRDS 80%
MIGRATE AT NIGHT USING THE NIGHT
SKY TO HELP THEM NAVIGATE TO AND
FROM THEIR BREEDING GROUNDS.
EVERY DAY IN THE UNITED STATES
AT LEAST ONE MILLION BIRDS DIED
DUE TO BUILDING OR STRUCTURE
COLLISIONS RELATE TO ALAN
EXCESSIVE ARTIFICIAL LIGHT.
ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING ALSO HAS
DETRIMENTAL EFFECTS ON HUMANS
TEENS AND ADOLESCENTS WHO LIVE
IN AREAS AT HIGH LEVELS OF
ARTIFICIAL LIGHT AT NIGHT. FOR
HIGH ARE MORE LIKELY TO HAVE
MOOD AND ANXIETY DISORDERS AND
INTERRUPTED SLEEP PATTERNS AND
AT LEAST NINETEEN STATES
DISTRICT COLUMBIA AND PUERTO
RICO. HAVE LAWS IN PLACE REDUCE
LIGHT POLLUTION CLING LIMITING
ARTIFICIAL LIGHT NIGHT. ALL
ADDRESSABLE CONCERNS CENTRAL TO
THIS BILL PROTECTING HUMANS
ECOSYSTEMS AND OTHER WILDLIFE
FROM HAZARDS CAUSED EXCESSIVE
NIGHT LIGHTING. AND TWO DRESSES
ISSUE AB THIRTY WILL REQUIRE
OUTDOOR LIGHTING FIXTURES ON
STATE BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES.
INCLUDING STATE PARKS AND LANDS
HAVE EXTERNAL SHIELD. DIRECT
LIGHT TO WHERE IT IS. TO WHERE
IT IS NEEDED OR BE WITH THE SHUT
OFF IT. DEVICE SENSIBLE REFORM
SAFE FOR MIKE BIRDS EXIST AND
PEOPLE WHO AND WITH THAT I'D
LIKE TO INTRODUCE MY- EYE
WITNESSES SCIENCE FOR TODAY
MICHAEL SIMONE OF ITCH A LEADING
PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF
CALIFORNIA DAVIS. GOOD MORNING.
GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING MY
NAME IS- MICHAEL SMIDOVICH I'M A
PROFESSOR AT UC DAVIS. AND I'M
THE DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
LIGHTING TECHNOLOGY CENTER AND
I'M PLEASED TO BE HERE THIS
MORNING TO PROVIDE. EDUCATIONAL
INPUT BASED ON OUR YEARS OF
RESEARCH OF DAVIS. ON A DAVIS
WE'VE DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH ON
EXTERIOR LIGHTING IS OUR STRONG
CONTENTION. THAT OUR PRODUCTS WE
50% OF THE LIGHT THAT WE PRODUCE
HERE IN CALIFORNIA IS TOTALLY
WAIT WASTED. DISAGREE JUST WASTE
OF ENERGY RESULTING TO A COST
BURDEN TO THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. CAN BE LARGELY
ELIMINATED USING BOTH ADVANCED
LIGHTING CONTROLS. AND
APPROPRIATE OPTICS TO SHIELD THE
WHITE WHERE IT NEEDS TO GO.
THERE ARE TWO IMPORTANT OUTCOMES
IT BECAME REALIZE BY MORE
CAREFUL AND PRUDENT APPLICATION
OF LIGHTING AT NIGHT. FIRSTLY A
SIGNIFICANT ENERGY AND COST
SAVINGS TO THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. THIS ALIGNS VERY
CLOSELY RECOVERY NUISANCE
AGGRESSIVE GREENHOUSE SCHOOLS
AND- MITIGATION GOALS. SECONDLY
IS REDUCING THE NEGATIVE
BIOLOGICAL IMPACTS OF LIGHT HAS
ON HUMANS. AND OTHER SPECIES AT
NIGHT SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN
RECENTLY PUBLISHED AN ARTICLE ON
THIS. CLEARLY ARTICULATES THE
ISSUE ASSOCIATED WITH NIGHTTIME
LIGHT POLLUTION. THIS ISSUE WAS
ALSO ADDRESS IN TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN. BY THE AMERICAN MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION WHICH CALLS FOR
LIMITING THE AMOUNT OF LIGHT
THAT WE SEE AT NIGHT. THE USE OF
ADAPTIVE CONTROLS TO REDUCE LIKE
DURING DURING NIGHT TIME USING
VACANCY SENSORS. SCHEDULING AND
DEMING. HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED TO
BE HIGHLY COST EFFECTIVE IN
CALIFORNIA BUILDINGS WE OFTEN
SEE 5270% SAVINGS IN MANY OF
THESE KINDS OF APPLICATIONS. IT
IS BURDEN BROADLY IMPLEMENTED
THROUGH TITLE TWENTY TWENTY
TWENTY FOUR. AND HAS BEEN SHOWN
TO SAVE A LOT OF ENERGY. AND
CLOSING AS EDUCATIONAL INPUT WE
BELIEVE THAT THERE ARE COST
EFFECTIVE AND PROVEN
TECHNOLOGIES THAT ARE AVAILABLE
TODAY. THAT CAN REDUCE THIS 50%
WASTE THAT WE SEE IT LIGHT UP IN
AT LIGHT IN IN CALIFORNIA. ALSO
REDUCE THE IMPACT ON HUMANS AND
OTHER SPECIES. THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IS BUILDING PORTFOLIO
SHOULD BE A LEADERSHIP MODEL FOR
ALL OF US IN TERMS OF MITIGATING
COST- INCREASING ENERGY
EFFICIENCY. AND ALSO THE BURDEN
ON OUR ON OUR SPECIES. I THANK
YOU FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY FOR
INPUT THANK YOU THANK YOU SIR.
NOW LET'S HEAR FROM ANY OTHER
SUPPORT WITNESSES HERE IN ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED. THESE BREAKS ARE
LIKE. RIGHT TO RISE EXCESSIVELY
LINE. COME ON STAGE HIGHEST
SAMANTHA SAMUELSON FOR DEFENDERS
OF WILDLIFE AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU. NOW WE'LL MOVE ON AT ANY
LEAD WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
SEEING THAT ANYBODY IN THE ROOM
IN OPPOSITION PLEASE COME
FORWARD. UGH IT'S NOT AS- ALL
RIGHT SO- WILL MOVE ON THE
WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
THE TELECONFERENCE ORVIS. THIS
INCLUDES ANYONE EITHER IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR FILIATION
AND POSITION ALONG LIKE. I'M
LIMITING THE ME TOOS TO A TOTAL
OF TEN MINUTES I DOUBT WE'RE
GOING TO GET THAT ON THIS ONE
BUT- MODERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE.
CALL FOR. ANY WITNESSES FOR A-
CERTAINLY CERTAINLY THANK YOU BE
THIRTY EIGHT ALL I AM. A PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME
AGAINST ONE ZERO. IT WILL FIRST
GO TO LINE. TWENTY SIX. I'M
TWENTY SIX EUROPEN. HE MADE IT
SOUND. NEXT CALLER. WELL NEXT
COURT A LINE THIRTEEN. GOOD
MORNING CATHY SAFER ON BEHALF OF
CREDIT REALITY PROJECT LOS
ANGELES AND SAN FERNANDO VALLEY
CHAPTERS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
THANK YOU. EXCEPT OUTLINED CAN.
WARNING ABOUT MILE ON BEHALF OF
THE ATTENDANCE THE REGIONAL OPEN
SPACE DISTRICT AND BREAST CANCER
PREVENTION PARTNERS AND SUPPORT
. AND THEN FURTHER AT THIS TIME
. THANK YOU MODERATOR- SO WE'LL
BRING IT BACK TO OUR- MEMBERS
ANY MEMBERS HAVE ANY QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS CENTER WILK. IT'S
NOT A QUESTION JUST A COMMENT I
THINK THIS IS A GREAT BILL WE
HAVE A STATE BUILDING- IN MY
COMMUNITY AND COURSE IT CAUSES
THE STATE BUILDING X. EXEMPT
FROM LOCAL ORDINANCE AND THAT
EXTERNAL LIGHT SIGN OUTSIDE I
SWEAR YOU CAN SEE FROM SPACE. IS
TOTALLY IS TOTALLY INAPPROPRIATE
YEAH I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT DOES
TO WILD LIFE BUT I KNOW IT IT
ANNOYS THE HECK OUT OF ME AND
EVERYBODY ELSE WHO SEES IT SO
THIS IS LONG OVERDUE AND HAPPY
TO MOVE THE BILL WHEN WE HAVE A
FULL COMMITTEE THE CENTER.
MISTER YES SIDEROXYLON YES YOU
BRING IN THE BILL FORD MY
QUESTION WOULD BE ARE WE ABLE TO
IN SOME OF THESE BUILDINGS TURN
DOWN THE LIGHTS A LITTLE BIT- IN
MY DINING ROOM YOU CAN JUST TURN
IT UP. TURN IT DOWN WE'RE GONNA
BE ABLE TO REDUCE THAT. 20% 30%
ARE WE LOOKING FOR PERCENTAGES
WELL. SO MY BILL IS DEALING WITH
THE NEWLY INSTALLED SO ONCE SAVE
THIS LIGHT BULB BURNS OUT RIGHT
WHEN YOU INSTALL IT. YOU INSULT
TO THE HIGHER STANDARD SO OF
COURSE THE CURRENT EXISTING
BUILDINGS RIGHT NOW WE DON'T DO
THAT. YES UNLESS THEIR PROFITS
TO BE DONE. DIMMING FEATURES ARE
GOING TO BE SOME OF THOSE
UPGRADED FEATURES WE'RE TALK
ABOUT INCLUDING SHIELD DIMMING
OR THOSE LIKE TIME TURN OFF LIKE
IF YOU WERE IN THE ROOM WHO
TURNED OFF KIND OF THING SO I
WENT. AROUND SPACE I GUESS
BECAUSE OUTSIDE OUTSIDE SO THOSE
WOULD BE THINGS DONE IN THE
FUTURE WHEN YOU SEE A LIGHT
BURNS HOW. OKAY VERY GOOD THANK
. OKAY SO WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM
BUT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AS FAST FIVE BUT
WHEN THE TIME COMES I THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- I HAVE TO GO PRESENT
YEAH THAT COMMITTEE HEARING SO-
VICE CHAIR WILL WILL. BE TAKING
OVER NOW THANK YOU. GAVEL PLEASE
. GAVEL PLEASE KNOW. ALL RIGHT
WELL WE'RE GONNA MOVE ON TO FILE
ITEM TO AB EIGHT THIRTY FIVE
ONCE AGAIN IT IS ASSEMBLY. LEE
AND GO AHEAD AND PROCEED. I
THANK YOU CHEN SANDERS I WANT TO
START BY SAYING ACCEPT THE
AMENDMENT ON PAGE FIVE THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS. CURRENTLY
CALIFORNIA REQUIRES TO STEER
EXIT ROUTES IN PART IN BUILDINGS
ABOVE THREE STORIES TALL.
HOWEVER THEY ARE MID RISE
BUILDINGS THROUGHOUT EUROPE WITH
SINGLE STAIRCASES. MANY EUROPEAN
COUNTRIES ALLOW BUILDING THE
SINGLE STAIRCASES AND BETTER AND
HAVE BETTER. RECORDS ON FIRE
SAFETY THE UNITED STATES.
EUROPEAN BUILDINGS GENERALLY
HAVE MORE MODERN SAFETY FEATURES
LIKE SPRINKLERS WHICH COULD ALSO
BE INFLUENCE IN AMERICA. THE
BILL WILL HELP BRING THIS TYPE
OF BUILDING TWO NIGHTS STATES BY
DIRECTING THE STATE FIRE
MARSHALS RESEARCH STANDARDS FOR
SINGLE STAIRWAY MULTI UNIT
RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS. AND
SUBMIT A REPORT TO LEGISLATURE.
VERTICALLY FOR INFLUENCE THE
SINGLES THERE THE SINGLE
STAIRCASE PROHIBITION ADDS COST
ME REDUCE NUMBER UNITS BUILT ON
THE PROJECTS FOOT PRINTS. I
BELIEVE HAVING THE FIBERS
CONNECT THE STUDY. WILL START
THE CONVERSATION ABOUT
LEVERAGING EXISTING FIRE AND
EMERGENCY RESPONSE ANALOGIES.
AND STRATEGIES TO MAXIMIZE
HOUSING PROJECTS AND WITH THAT
LIKE INTEREST MY WHEN IT'S IN
SUPPORT. LOUIS MARATHI FROM THE
BAY AREA COUNCIL. AND YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES WHENEVER YOU'RE
READY. THING WAS CHAIR GOOD
MORNING MISTER MEMBERS LUIS
MARIN TODAY ON BEHALF OF BURY
COUNCIL I REPRESENT VERY COUNCIL
WHICH- FOR ON HOUSING ISSUES
WHICH REPRESENTS ABOUT THREE
HUNDRED OR SO OF THE BERRIES
LARGER EMPLOYERS. INCLUDING
ABOUT SIXTY OR SEVENTY FIRMS IN
THE DEVELOPMENT INDUSTRY. I'M
WE'VE TALKED EXTENSIVELY ABOUT
BUILDING CODE ISSUES LAND USE
REFORM ISSUES. I IN RECENT YEARS
I'M BUT THIS IS I THINK A GREAT
IDEA THAT WORKS WITHIN EXISTING
ENVELOPES- DOESN'T. GO AROUND
ZONING DOESN'T DO ANYTHING LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS HAVE AREN'T HAVE
ALREADY NOT DECIDED TO. I DO GET
CREATIVE ABOUT WAYS TO REDUCE
THE COST OF BUILDING. I'M THIS
IS GONNA BE PARTICULARLY HELPFUL
FOR THOSE SMALLER INFILL
BUILDINGS THE FOUR PLEXUS
TRIPLEX IS THOSE TYPES OF
THINGS- BUT IN GENERAL. IT IS
SINGLE SIR REQUIREMENT CAN
REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF INTERIOR
FLOOR CIRCULATION FROM ABOUT
2225% OF THE BUILDING UNDER THE
DEAL LOADED CORRIDOR SYSTEM WE
HAVE TODAY. TO ABOUT 12% SO YOU
GET ABOUT HALF OF YOU HALF THE
COST GOING TOWARD CIRCULATION
HALF THE LAND COSTS GOING TO
CIRCULATION HAVE THE
CONSTRUCTION COSTS GOING TO
CIRCULATION. THAT YOU OTHERWISE
WOULD I THINK THAT'S AN
IMPORTANT STEP FORWARD IN MAKING
IT EASIER AND CHEAPER TO BUILD
HOUSING CALIFORNIA. AND I URGE
YOUR SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL TODAY
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYBODY
ELSE IN THE ROOM IN SUPPORT.
SEEING NINE DO WE HAVE ANY
PRIMARY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
. ANYBODY ELSE WANTS TO LEND
THEIR VOICE IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE LET'S MOVE TO THE
PHONES MODERATOR WE WILL TAKE
BOTH PRO AND CON. ON FILE ITEM
TO AB. EIGHT THIRTY FIVE. AB
EIGHT EIGHT THIRTY FIVE PLEASE
PRESS ONE AT ZERO AT THIS TIME.
HERE'S. AND IT'S ONE ZERO GIVE
ME JUST A MOMENT HERE WILL GO
FIRST A LINE NUMBER TWENTY EIGHT
.
OCT TWENTY EIGHT YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. LEVINE CAROLINE ANOTHER
WOULD TAKE THAT AS A MAGAZINE.
HI I'M SAID. GO AHEAD. HI MY
NAME'S HEALTH GOOD IN- I LIVE IN
LAUGHING. AND MAKE. DORADO I AM
CALL IN SUPPORT OF AB EIGHT
THREE FIVE THE THING OF THEIR
CASE BILL- NOT ONLY DO I THINK
IT'S SO GREAT FOR SUPPORTING
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THE
ISSUES THAT WERE JUST MENTIONED
BUT- IT'S ALSO GOING TO MAKE HER
CITY MORE BEAUTIFUL OR SO SICK
OF THE STERILE RECTANGULAR BOXES
THAT. ARE JUST THE HIGHLY NAP IN
THIS CITY AND THIS BILL ACTUALLY
CAN INCREASE BEAUTIFUL
DEVELOPMENT WHILE ALSO
INCREASING THINGS LIKE.
VENTILATION AND GREEN SPACE AT
THE SAME ABILITY AND- VERBAL
HOUSING LIKE THERE'S SO MANY
BENEFITS TO SUPPORTING THE SPELL
AND I YOU KNOW I THINK THAT
ASTHMA AND NEW. TO BUILD
NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER AND HOW
CAN CHO HE AND THIS IS ACTUALLY
A BEAUTIFUL WAY FOR AND THAT
MAKES THE PEOPLE HAPPY GREAT
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
MOVING FORWARD WE'RE NOW IN THE
ME TOO PARTY TESTIMONY SO IT'S
YOUR NAME IN YOUR POSITION SHE
HAD A LOVELY VOICE AND SHE WAS
VERY ENTHUSIASTIC SO I ALLOWED
IT THAT. MOVING FORWARD WE'RE
NOT GONNA DO THAT. OKAY
MODERATOR ANYONE ELSE. YES
CERTAINLY YOU I WILL GO TO LINE
UP. HI MY NAME'S LOW I'M CALL ON
BEHALF OF THE LIVABLE
COMMUNITIES INITIATIVE AND I AM
IN SUPPORT OF- THIS BILL PERFECT
THANK YOU EARLY OKAY PERFECT.
NOW TOTALING NINE PERFECT. PARTY
NIGHT NEXT A LITTLE LINE.
FOURTEEN I AM FOURTEEN YOUR LINE
IS OPEN. AND I WILL TAKE THAT AS
A YES SQUARE THE NEXT LINE. LINE
. ELEVEN I GUESS I ALREADY SPOKE
HELLO HI ALL RIGHT LET ME SEE
HERE I. AM AMENDMENTS YEAH I
THINK THEY'RE HAVING TROUBLE
ASSIGNING A LOT. JUST A MOMENT
HERE. SHE CALLED YOU I DON'T
YEAR OLD WILL. THE NEXT COULD
ALIGN TWENTY ONE. HELLO CAN YOU
HEAR ME YES. HI MY NAME IS LEE
LINDEN WILD AND I LIVE IN LOS
ANGELES CALIFORNIA- I'M CALLING
BECAUSE I SUPPORT IN B. EIGHT
THREE FIVE I TO BELIEVE IN THE A
LIVABLE COMMUNITY INITIATIVE. I
THINK WE NEED TO GO FORWARD WITH
BETTER BUILDINGS HEALTHIER
BUILDING AFFORDABLE BUILDING SO
ARE FOUND LINE CHILDREN CAN LIVE
LIKE NINETY THANK YOU PLEASE GO
AHEAD. THE TWENTY FIVE YEAR OPEN
. HI MY NAME IS RENEE THREE- I
LIVE IN LOS ANGELES AND I AM
ALSO IN SUPPORT OF THE SPELL ON
BEHALF OF THE LIVABLE
COMMUNITIES INITIATIVE- I THINK
THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT AS WE
MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT THANK YOU
. I KNOW. EIGHTEEN I DIDN'T. IF
I DON'T GET. I DIDN'T GET A
NUMBER BUT I'M IN A WEEK
EIGHTEEN MY NAME IS FRANCINE
HANDS THE I LIVE IN LOS ANGELES
I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT OF AB
EIGHT THIRTY FIVE. MY MAIN ISSUE
ABOUT THIS IS THAT THE VALUE OF
THE WAR. MAN AT THIS POINT WE'RE
JUST TAKING ME TO TESTIMONY SO
NAME BILL NUMBER POSITION SO
THANK YOU DULY NOTED. NEXT
HEADLINE. HI MY NAME IS ONE OF
THE SERMON AND I LIVE IN LOS
ANGELES AND I'M CALLING IN
SUPPORT OF AB EIGHT THIRTY FIVE
AS WELL. PERFECT THANK YOU. LINE
. TWENTY FOUR. IF I HAD LIKE
TWENTY FOUR. YOU CAN GO TO LINE
NINETEEN. RIGHT YOU HEAR ME YES
. HI MY NAME IS STEVEN MARTIN I
LIVE IN LOS ANGELES SENATOR
GARAGES DISTRICT AND I AM
SUPPORT EIGHTY. THREE FIVE THANK
YOU. AND CURRENTLY NUMBERING Q.
THANK YOU MR MODERATOR GREAT JOB
PULLED BACK TO. MY COMMITTEE
MEMBER. GREAT QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS THANK YOU MR VICE CHAIR
DOING A GREAT JOB THANK YOU- I
LIKE THE BILL AND- I'M JUST
WEIRD HOW WE- GOT IT TO
CALIFORNIA. DID WE SEND SOMEONE
OUT TO EUROPE THEY SAW WHAT WAS
GOING ON AND- WE WERE INSPIRED-
WE REALIZE OUR AFFORDABLE.
HOUSING CRISIS WHAT WHAT
PROMPTED THIS BILL TO COME
BEFORE US YEAH I WOULD SAY IT'S
A- COALITION OF OUR SPONSORS AND
SOME FOR MY PERSONAL EXPERIENCE
TO IS THAT YOU KNOW ESPECIALLY
IN A LOT OF DEVELOPED COUNTRIES
WE ARE APPEARS WITH- ESPECIALLY
IN URBAN INFILL CITIES LIKE IF
YOU IMAGINE A LOT THAT'S NO
BIGGER REALLY THAN THIS
COMMITTEE ROOM. AND OFTEN TIMES
THESE FOR THREE FOUR FIVE SIX
STORY BUILDINGS ONLY HAVE ONE
STAIRCASE RIGHT AND THEY'RE ABLE
TO OBVIOUSLY SERVE EVERYONE
THERE AND STILL BE VERY SAFE FOR
EVERYONE ESPECIALLY STATE.
POIGNANT FOR WHY WE CALL IT
SKINNY BUILDINGS ESPECIALLY
THOSE LOTS ARE VERY SMALL AND
CITIES IF YOU'RE GOING TO
DEDICATE MORE SPACES THE
STAIRWELLS THAT'S LESS SPACE YOU
CAN DO FOR HOMES RIGHT AND YOU
SEE IS VERY SUCCESSFUL IN ASIA
AND EUROPE SO WE THOUGHT TO
REPLICATE THIS AND AT LEAST WITH
THE STUDY RIGHT NOW SAYS NOT
MANDATING DOES NOT REQUIRE
ANYTHING IS A SAYING HEY LET'S
LET THE FARMERS WILL. DECIDE IF
THIS IS SOMETHING WE SHOULD OPT
FOR THREE OR MORE STOREYS ABOVE
BECAUSE RIGHT NOW IF YOU HAVE A
TOWN HOME THREE STORIES YOU KNOW
YOU ONE SINGLE FAMILY. RESIDENCE
YOU CAN OBVIOUSLY HAVE ONCE
THEIR CASE FOR YOUR WHOLE. THREE
STORY FAMILY HOUSE. HER GOOD.
ALL OF. OBVIOUSLY SUPPORTED BILL
AND- AT PROPER TIME AND MOVE IT.
GREAT WELL I DIDN'T MENTION
THIS. SO MUCH AND NOW IT'S TO
PAY. THE RECOMMEND. TO AND TO
PRO. COMMITTEE THIS. IS SUPPORT
SUPPORT AND YOU MAY CLOSE. SO
FAST RIVAL IN TIME COMES THANKS
SO MUCH. WELL DONE THANK YOU. WE
GOT FILE ORDER IN THE SENATE BUT
I DON'T SEE THE AUTHOR FOR FILE
ITEM THREE SORGEN MOVED A FILE
ITEM FOR. SOME WOMEN WARD FROM
THE GREAT CITY SAN DIEGO. AB
THREE OH TWO. RECOMMENDATIONS DO
PASSED TO JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
AND WITH THAT. CLOSURES THANK
YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
CALIFORNIA'S LEADING THE WAY IN
ADOPTING AUTOMATED DECISION
MAKING SYSTEMS ACROSS THE STATE
AGENCIES. TO MODERNIZE AND
DELIVER SERVICES MORE
EFFICIENTLY WHEN HE'S PROPERLY
THE SYSTEMS CAN BENEFIT
CALIFORNIANS HOWEVER. IF THE
SYSTEMS ARE NOT DESIGNED AND
IMPLEMENTED CORRECTLY THEY CAN
CREATE UNFAIRLY BIASED OR
INACCURATE ALSO HARM SOME
CALIFORNIANS AB THREE OH TWO
WILL REQUIRE THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT TECHNOLOGY. TO
CONDUCT A COMPREHENSIVE
INVENTORY OF ALL HIGH RISK
AUTOMATED DECISION SYSTEMS BEING
USED BY STATE AGENCIES THE BILL
WILL ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIANS
HAVE TRANSPARENCY INTO THE
GOVERNMENT'S USE OF HIGH RISK
ATS SYSTEMS. AND PROVIDE STATE
AGENCIES WITH THE TOOLS TO
ANALYZE THE USE OF THE SYSTEMS
AND MINIMIZE THE RISK OF
DISCRIMINATORY IMPACTS I LIKE TO
PRESENT MY WITNESS IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL CAROLINE SIEGEL SINGH
REPRESENTING THE GREEN LINING
INSTITUTE AND WHEN THE TIME
COMES. I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
HER AYE VOTE. TWO MINUTES IN
PROCEED. GOOD MORNING VICE CHAIR
AND MEMBERS NAME IS CAROLINE
SIEGEL SINGH I AM HERE TODAY ON
BEHALF OF THE GREEN LINING
INSTITUTE WHERE I WORK TO ENSURE
THAT TECHNOLOGY CAN HELP CLOSE
THE RACIAL WEALTH GAP. AND BUILD
GREATER ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY FOR
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. I'M HERE
TODAY A SPONSOR OF AB THREE OH
TWO A CRUCIAL GOVERNMENT
TRANSPARENCY MEASURE THAT WOULD
PROVIDE MEMBERS OF THE
LEGISLATURE. WITH BOTH AWARENESS
OF AND OVERSIGHT OVER THE USE OF
AUTOMATED DECISION MAKING
SYSTEMS OR ADAS. WHICH ARE
ALREADY BEING USED BY STATE
AGENCIES. IN PARTICULAR THIS
BILL FOCUSES ON ACCOUNTING FOR
EIGHTY S. TOOLS THAT MAKE
CRITICAL DECISIONS WHICH IMPACT
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS ACCESS TO
THINGS LIKE HEALTH CARE. PUBLIC
BENEFITS CRIMINAL JUSTICE
HOUSING AND CREDIT. AB THREE OH
TO WOULD DO THIS BY EMPOWERING
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
TECHNOLOGY. TO CONDUCT A
COMPREHENSIVE INVENTORY OF THE
MOST IMPACTFUL AUTOMATED SYSTEMS
BEING USED IN CALIFORNIA STATE
GOVERNMENT. AND THEN SUBMITTING
THIS INVENTORY INTO THE
LEGISLATURE ON AN ANNUAL BASIS.
CALIFORNIA LIKE MANY OTHER
STATES AND FEDERAL AGENCIES
INCREASINGLY USES ATS TOOLS TO
INCREASE THE EFFICIENCY OF
GOVERNMENT SERVICES AND IMPROVE
DECISION MAKING. THESE SYSTEMS
CAN PROCESS SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS
OF DATA AUTOMATE TASKS LIKE
DOCUMENT VERIFICATION AT THE DMV
OR IDENTIFY POTENTIAL FRAUD AND
UNEMPLOYMENT AND TAX FILINGS AT
THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD. WITH
THE INCREASING USE OF THESE
AUTOMATED DECISION MAKING TOOLS
CALIFORNIANS. CALIFORNIA HAS A
RESPONSIBILITY TO HAVE PROPER
INSIGHT INTO BOTH WHERE THE
SYSTEMS ARE USED WHAT THEY'RE
DESIGNED TO DO. AND HOW
POTENTIAL RISKS IN THE USE OF
THESE SYSTEMS ARE BEING
ADDRESSED. FOR THE ABOVE REASONS
WERE ASKING FOR YOU TO SUPPORT
AB THREE OH TWO WHICH WILL HELP
US BUILD TRUST AND
ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE USE OF
GOVERNMENT ATS. THANK YOU GREAT
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
THE ROOM IN SUPPORT. ANY
WITNESSES IN THE ROOM IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NINE WILL
MOVE TO THE PHONES MISTER
MODERATOR. THANK YOU AGAIN LATE
INTO MY PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME. I GUESS. ONE ZERO.
CURRENTLY NOBODY IN Q. ALL RIGHT
WITH THAT WILL PULL IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS I'M SURE. CENTER ARE TO
LET HAS A COMMENT WELL. I GET TO
DO THAT I WAS YOUR BRIGHT
NATALIE- ABSOLUTELY WE WERE HERE
ON TIME. ANYWAY THANK YOU BRING
THIS FORWARD OBVIOUSLY WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT PUBLIC SERVICES
AND YOU KNOW FRAUD IT COMES INTO
PLAY AS SHE JUST MENTIONED BUT
WHEN I TURN THE CLOCK BACK A
LOOK BACK AT EDT. THE ISSUES WE
HAD IF WE HAD THIS IN PLACE
WOULD THAT HAVE BEEN PREVENTED I
KNOW IT'S CRAZY QUESTION BUT
WE'VE GOT TO DO SOMETHING. TO
ENHANCE WHAT WE TRYING TO DO IS
SERVE THE GENERAL PUBLIC AND IF
WE CAN DO IT WITH TECHNOLOGY YES
THIS IS A STEP FORWARD AND WE
HAVE TO ANALYZE A SYSTEMS WE
HAVE IMPROVED AND WE CERTAINLY
HAVE TO. FUND WHAT WE NEED TO SO
WE DON'T HAVE PROBLEMS LIKE WE
DID WITH EDT OR EVEN ISSUES
WITH- THE DMV THAT WE HAD A
COUPLE THREE YEARS AGO. CHAU AYE
AYE THANKS FOR BRINGING THIS.
BILL FORWARD AND AGAIN. I WILL
MOVE IT AT THE PROPER TIME- MY
QUESTION TO YOU AT. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WITH YOUR EXPERT- ARE WE
LOOKING TO REALLY CHANGE THE
SYSTEM- IN REFERENCE ET DE AND
FRAUD. THANK YOU FOR THE IN
THOSE- FULLY AGREE WITH YOU AND
I THINK WE RECOGNIZE AS THE
LEGISLATURE A STUDY REALLY
CLOSELY THE EXPERIENCES THAT WE
SAW EDT. FIRST WITH THE
FRAUDULENT CASES- REALLY BAD
ACTORS EVEN SOME THAT WERE
CURRENTLY IN CAR CURRENTLY
INCARCERATED AT THE TIME. ON
THAT WERE ABUSING THE
OPPORTUNITIES THAT WE ARE FORTY
CALIFORNIANS TO BE ABLE TO
RECEIVE UNEMPLOYMENT-
INCORRECTLY DOING SO- THE
PRODUKTIVNOST AND WE ALMOST.
OVER CORRECTED FOR THAT AND THEN
WHEN THE HEIGHT OF THE REQUESTS
WERE COMING IN FOR CONSTITUENTS
TO BE ABLE TO ACCESS THEIR
BENEFITS AND I'M PRESIDENTE
LEVELS. TOO MANY AS WE ALL
EXPERIENCE FOR GETTING TRIPPED
UP IN SOME OF THE SYSTEMS. MANY
OF THEM THAT WERE- RELATED TO
TECHNOLOGY BECAUSE SOMETHING IS
SELF HELP AND PROCESSES CUT IT'S
ALMOST THAT WE SORT OF SET THAT
LIKE THRESHOLD A LITTLE BIT TOO
FAR OVER HERE. AND IT WAS
CAPTURING MORE PEOPLE TRIGGERING
THEM FOR A FRAUD RISK AND THEN
WE WERE HAVING TO GO ON THE BACK
END CORRECT ALL THAT AS FAST AS
POSSIBLE SO PEOPLE COULD. PAY
THE RENT- BUT YES- ET DE BEING
ONE OF THE AGENCIES THE DMV YOU
MENTIONED AS WELL SOME DOCUMENT
PROCESSING. AND THE ABILITY FOR
OUR DEPARTMENTS OR AGENCIES TO
BE ABLE TO MAKE DECISIONS ON
WELFARE SERVICES. ON HEALTH CARE
REIMBURSEMENTS ON CLIMATE
INVESTMENTS THERE'S A BROAD
RANGE OF CALIFORNIA AGENCIES
THAT USE EIGHTY S. BUT WE DON'T
KNOW THE TOTALITY OF THAT SO
THAT'S PART OF WHAT THIS BILL
DOES IS BE ABLE TO SORT OF. A
LOOK AT ALL OF OUR STATE
AGENCIES. AND THOSE BOARDS AND
COMMISSIONS APPOINTED BY THE
GOVERNOR AND OTHERS IS DEFINED-
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE UNDERSTAND
THAT AND THEN WITH IN THOSE THAT
USE EIGHTY S. AS THE FINE. WHAT
IS THE DECISION THAT IS RENDERED
WHAT IS SOME OF THE RESEARCH
THAT MIGHT BE OUT THERE THAT
UNDERSTANDS HOW THAT- DECISION.
WHAT THE- YOU'RE THE EFFICACY OR
THE BENEFITS ARE OF USING EDS
WHAT ARE SOME OF THE- INACCURATE
OR DISCRIMINATORY OR UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES. THAT MIGHT BE
BEING PRODUCED- AS WE SEE OUR-
COMMUNITIES OF CONCERN A LITTLE
BIT MORE DISAFFECTED- ARE.
SENIORS UP MORE- DISAFFECTED IN
THEIR ABILITY TO EITHER PROCESS
OR- GET- GET FLAGGED. FOR
CERTAIN DECISIONS SO THESE ARE
ALL VERY IMPORTANT THINGS AS WE
ARE DOING MORE AND MORE. HE AYE
AND MORE AND MORE USE OF TECH G.
IMP. WE SHOULD BE A- WE WANNA
MAKE THERE'S NO A- CONSEQUENCE.
LONG ANSWER TO ANSWER YOUR
QUESTION YES I THINK THERE'S
SOME INTERNAL IN THE NATION-
WITH THE ABILITY TO IMPROVE THE
EFFICACY OF DELIVERING EDB
SERVICES. WITHOUT INCREASING THE
RISK OF FRAUD- BUT I THINK THAT
THE BENEFITS HERE ARE GOING TO
BE FAR MUCH BETTER FOR US TO BE
ABLE TO BE COMFORTABLE- WITH THE
INCLUSION OF ATS SYSTEMS ACROSS
ALL STATE AGENCIES. VERY GOOD
THANK YOU SO MUCH I MEAN THAT
YOU'RE CLOSE. I WOULD BE HAPPY
TO CLOSE A RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
DRIVE OUT. THANK YOU SIR. OUR
NEXT AUTHORS NOT HERE SERENA
CONTINUE DOWN WE'RE GOING TO
MOVE TO FILE ITEM EIGHT A. B.
TEN THIRTY ONE ASSEMBLY MEN.
LOWENTHAL THE RECOMMENDATION
FROM THE CHAIRS DO PASSES
AMENDED TO THE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE. AND WITH THAT SIR
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY. PLEASE
PROCEED THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
AND SENATORS. MISTER CHAIR ARE
YOU OKAY IF I USE PROPS. YES IS
TO PRESENT AB TEN THIRTEEN WHICH
WILL REQUIRE TYPE FORTY EIGHT
LICENSEES THOSE ARE BARS OR
TAVERNS. TO OFFER FOR SALE TO
CUSTOMERS DRUG TESTING DEVICES
SUCH AS TEST STRIPS. HAS
COASTERS. THAT CAN DETECT THE
PRESENCE OF CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCES. THAT ARE COMMONLY
USED TO SPEICHER LACE. IN
INDIVIDUALS DRINK THAT'S CALLED
ROOF BEING. I'D LIKE TO START BY
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND WOULD LIKE TO
THANK THE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR THEIR WORK ON THE
BILL. THE UNDER REPORTED
EPIDEMIC OF RIFFIAN CONTINUES TO
PLAY CALIFORNIA IN THE WORLD.
UNFORTUNATELY ROOFING IS OFTEN
USED TO FACILITATE THE
COMMISSION OF OTHER CRIMES. SUCH
AS SEXUAL ASSAULT. AND RAPE.
RIFFING IS OFTEN ELUSIVE CRIME
CAN BE DIFFICULT TO CATCH
PERPETRATORS IN THE ACT.
ADDITIONALLY VICTIMS WHO HAVE
ALREADY BEEN DRUGGED. THEY MAY
BE DISORIENTED INCAPACITATED
APPEARED TO BE INEBRIATED UNABLE
TO IDENTIFY OR COMMUNICATE WHO
THE PERPETRATOR MAY BE OR MAY
NOT EVEN KNOW WHO SPIKE THEIR
DRINK IN THE FIRST PLACE. ONCE
SOMEONE HAS HAD THEIR DRINKS
SPIKED A ROOF FEED. IS
FREQUENTLY TOO LATE TO PREVENT
THE DRUG INDIVIDUAL FROM FALLING
VICTIM TO ANOTHER CRIME. SUCH AS
SEXUAL ASSAULT OR RAPE I LIKE IN
THIS CRISIS. TO THE DRUNK
DRIVING EPIDEMIC THAT WE HAD FOR
SOME TIME ONCE SOMEBODY IS
ALREADY IN THE ACT OF DRUNK
DRIVING IS TOO LATE. THE WAY WE
NEED TO DEAL WITH IT IS THROUGH
PREVENTIVE MEASURES. FURTHERMORE
ONCE SOMEONE HAS BEEN DRUGGED
THE CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES
USUALLY PASSED THROUGH THEIR
SYSTEM OVERNIGHT. THE PRESENCE
OF THESE SUBSTANCES IS
UNDETECTABLE AFTER THE
INDIVIDUAL FIRST URINATES IN THE
MORNING. AND WOULD NOT BE
DETECTABLE WITHOUT LABORATORY
TESTING OF HAIR FOLLICLES WITHIN
APPROXIMATELY THIRTY DAYS AFTER
INGESTION. WELL ANYONE CAN HAVE
THEIR DRINK SPIKED. THE
INDIVIDUALS OF THESE CRIMES ARE
ALL TOO OFTEN WOMEN. AND LGBTQ
PLUS INDIVIDUALS I OPINE AS A
MATTER OF FACT. THAT IF IT WERE
MEN THAT WERE VICTIMS TO THIS
CRIME WOULD BE A HOLY WAR IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. BUT BECAUSE
IT IS WOMEN AND LGBTQ PLUS
INDIVIDUALS WE'VE LET IT GO ON
THIS LONG. DO TO THE CHALLENGES
OF ADDRESSING IN PROSECUTING
THIS CRIME AFTER IS TAKING
PLACE. PREVENTIVE MEASURES ARE
COMMON SENSE WAY TO TRY TO CURB
INSTANCES OF DRUGGING. DRUG TEST
DEVICES LIKE THESE. THESE ARE
COASTERS. TEST STRIPS YOU CAN
SIMPLY TAKE A FEW DROPS. OF YOUR
DRINK. AND PASTE PLACE THE MON
AND KNOW IMMEDIATELY IF YOUR
DRINK HAS THE PRESENCE. OF GHB
KATAMON REFUND ALL. THESE
DEVICES ARE ABLE TO DETECT THE
PRESENCE OF CONTROLLED
SUBSTANCES USUALLY AND MOST
COMMONLY USED TO SPIKE IN
INDIVIDUALS DRINK. THE READILY
AVAILABLE AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY
BEING USED AT BARS AND NIGHT
CLUBS AT US MILITARY BASES
NUMBERS OF COLLEGES AND
UNIVERSITIES NOT JUST IN THE
UNITED STATES. THE UK HAS ROBUST
PROGRAM NOW AUSTRALIA'S ROBUST
PROGRAM AND SO FORTH. REQUIRING
THAT THESE ARE AVAILABLE FOR
SALE OR FOR FREE A TYPE FORTY
EIGHT LICENSE ESTABLISHMENT IS A
COMMON SENSE WAY TO PROTECT
INDIVIDUALS FROM BEING DRUGGED.
AND FALLING VICTIM TO OTHER
CRIMES. ARE BEFORE I INTRODUCE-
THE EXPERT DOT HERE LIKE TO
INTRODUCE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT THAT I AM
A BAR AND RESTAURANT OWNER. HAVE
BEEN FOR DECADES IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THE VERY LAST THING
ANYONE WHO OWNS AND ESTABLISH
SOME WOULD WANT. IS TO KNOW THAT
THEIR ESTABLISHMENT HAS
FACILITATED- THE ACT OF SEXUAL
ASSAULT VIOLENCE IN ANY CAPACITY
WHATSOEVER. I CAN ALSO TELL YOU
THAT THE ALCOHOL COMPANIES
THEMSELVES AND HIGHS ARE BUSH
CORONA CORES AND SO FORTH WE
EXPECT THEM ONCE WE THIS DOES
BECOME LAW. TO GET IN ON THE ACT
TO PARTICIPATE BY PROVIDING
THESE TO THE ESTABLISHMENTS AS A
BRANDING EXERCISE. IN A VERY
SIMILAR WAY THAT THEY ARE
INVOLVED NOW IN ANTI DRUNK
DRIVING INITIATIVES. THEY WANT
AS DO THE OWNERS OF THE
ESTABLISHMENTS A SAFE
ENVIRONMENT. FOR PEOPLE TO GO
OUT FOR YOUNG PEOPLE TO GO OUT.
OF PLEASED TO BE JOINED TODAY BY
MISTER MICHAELS SKIP PAS-
SHIPPER. WITHOUT CALL JUSTICE
HERE TO SUPPORT IN TESTIFIED THE
BILL EXCUSE ME IF I BUTCHER YOUR
LAST NAME SIR. YOU CAN CLOSE ITS
SKIPPER THANK YOU. MISTER
CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE MIKE
SKIPPER WITH THE ALCOHOL
JUSTICE- ALCOHOL JUSTICE IS A
PUBLIC HEALTH ADVOCACY
ORGANIZATION BASED IN CENTER
FELL. OFF FOR THIRTY FIVE YEARS
WE HAVE ADVOCATED FOR EVIDENCE
BASED POLICIES DEALING WITH
ALCOHOL AND DRUG ISSUES. WE SEEK
TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH AND
SAFETY IT ISN'T OFTEN. THAT WE
GET TO A SUPPORT A BILL MOST OF
THE TIME WE'RE UP HERE POSING.
UP BAD POLICIES THAT WE KNOW
WILL HURT A PUBLIC HEALTH AND
SAFETY THIS BILL HOWEVER GOES IN
THE OPPOSITE DIRECTION. AND WE
ARE TOTALLY SUPPORTIVE. THE
ACTUAL INCIDENCE OF HAVING A
DRUG PUTTING ONE'S DRINK WITHOUT
ONE'S KNOWLEDGE SPIKING A
ROOFING. VARIES FROM AROUND
6225% DEPENDING ON THE SURVEY.
YET EVEN THE LOWEST RATE ONE IN
TWENTY MEANS THAT YOU CAN LOOK
AROUND ANY GIVEN BAR ON A FRIDAY
NIGHT. AND KNOW THAT AT LEAST
ONE PERSON IN THAT ROOM HAS OR
WILL BE COME A VICTIM OF A
SPIKED DRINK. EVEN IF THE ONLY
RESULT IS UNWANTED EXTREME
INTOXICATION. THE EXPERIENCE CAN
BE DEEPLY UPSETTING WITH
FEELINGS OF ANXIETY AND OR
MISTRUST THAT LASTS FOR YEARS.
THIS IS NOT THE ONLY RESULT
HOWEVER ALONG WITH ACQUAINTANCE
RAPE. OTHER FORMS OF SEXUAL
ASSAULT THIS PERSON MAY BE
HUMILIATED ROBBED AND WERE
INJURED WORSE YET HOWEVER. IS
THE RISK OF DEATH. NOT ONLY ARE
THE MOST COMMON ADDITIVES
BENZODIAZEPINES INDOOR GHB. OR
OTHER HYPNOTICS SYNERGISTIC WITH
ALCOHOL THUS LOWERING THE
THRESHOLD FOR LIFE THREATENING
ALCOHOL POISONING. THE RECENT
CHANGES IN THE ILLEGAL DRUG
ACTIVITY AND SUPPLY IN THE
STATE- POSE A RISK THAT THAT
MICKEY- COULD INCLUDE FENTANYL.
OR OTHER ADULTERANTS THAT ARE
FATAL ON THEIR OWN. THIS
PROPOSED BILL GOES FAR FOR
EMPOWERING INDIVIDUALS TO
MONITOR THEIR DRINK AND
NORMALIZE THE ACTIVE ADDITIVE
TESTING FOR THOSE WHO MIGHT BE
HESITANT TO ENGAGE IN IT. WE
BELIEVE THIS HAS THE POTENTIAL.
TO REDUCE INCIDENCE OF DEEP
TRAUMA FOR THOUSANDS OF BAR
PATRONS AND REDUCE ALCOHOL HARM
IN THE STATE WE TOTALLY
SUPPORTED THANK YOU FOR BRING IT
FORWARD. THANK YOU SIR ANYONE
ELSE IN THE ROOM IN SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING SENATORS FRED JONES
ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA COUNCIL ON
ALCOHOL PROBLEMS AND SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. RIGHT MOVING TO
OPPOSITION ANYBODY IN THE ROOM
WANTING TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
TO THE BILL. SEEING NONE WE WILL
MOVE TO THE PHONES WERE WE WILL
TAKE. TESTIMONY YAY AND NAY
MISTER MODERATOR. ARE YOU READY
SO THIS IS FILE ITEM NUMBER
EIGHT A. B. TEN THIRTEEN. THANK
YOU AND PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME AGAIN IT'S ONE ZERO.
AND GIVEN MOMENT HERE AND NOBODY
IN Q. CURRENTLY. THANK YOU SIR
PULL IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
CENTER ARCHULETA. NO. ABOUT OVER
HERE AB. I WAS GETTING THERE.
THANK YOU CHAIR ASSEMBLY MEMBER
LOWENTHAL- THANK YOU FOR
BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD THIS
IS ACTUALLY REALLY EXCITING TO
ME- TO HEAR KIND OF THE OTHER
AND- YOU. DRUG ASSISTED RAPE HIS
ONE OF THOSE TOPICS THAT AB OR
VERY NEAR AND DEAR TO ME AND
I'VE BEEN WORKING ON LEGISLATION
TO KIND OF HELP UP. PERPETRATORS
BE ACCOUNTABLE- I THINK YOU
PROBABLY KNOW THAT IT'S LESS OF
AN OFFENSE- TO RAPE SOMEBODY- IF
YOU DRUGGED THEM FIRST SO YOU
GET LESS OF A CONSEQUENCE IF YOU
GO TO THE EXTRA STEP TO DRUG
THEM BEFORE YOU RATE THEM WHICH
TO ME. JUST DOES NOT MAKE SENSE
IN CALIFORNIA SO WE'RE WORKING
ON THAT IN THE SENATE- WHEN I
READ YOUR BILL SOME QUESTIONS
CAME TO MIND FOR ME AND
TYPICALLY I DON'T LIKE ANYTHING
THAT MANDATES ARE SMALL
BUSINESSES TO DO THINGS LIKE
REQUIREMENTS- BUT AS I READ
THROUGH YOUR BILL. WHAT THIS
REALLY SPOKE TO ME WAS THAT
PARTNERSHIP THAT PARTNERSHIP
BETWEEN BARS AND RESTAURANTS TO
MAKE SURE THEIR PATRONS ARE
SAFE- SO THANK YOU FOR TAKING
THAT ANGLE- ONE QUESTION I HAVE
IS WHAT IS THE COST OF THESE
DEVICES- I KNOW YOU MENTIONED.
THAT WORKING WITH THE BEVERAGE
DISTRIBUTORS TO POSSIBLY USE IT
AS A MARKETING TOOL- PARTICULAR
THE COASTERS I LOVE THAT IDEA I
THINK IT'S A GREAT WAY. TO BRING
BRANDING AND- THE CURIOUS ABOUT
COST HAVE YOU EXPLORED THAT- FOR
SO CENTER THANK YOU FOR YOUR
QUESTIONS THANK YOU FOR YOUR
WORK- I LOOK FORWARD TO
PARTNERING WITH YOU ON FURTHER
LEGISLATION IF THERE'S ANYWAY I
CAN BE ASSISTANT. COURSE OF YOU
I WOULD LIKE TO DO SO. I CAN
TELL YOU FROM EXPERIENCE AS A
BAR OWNER. THERE ARE THINGS THAT
I'LL CALL COMPANIES ARE ABLE TO
PARTICIPATE WITH AND THINGS ARE
NOT THEY'RE NOT ALLOWED. TO
PARTICIPATE BY PROVIDING FREE
I'LL CALL- WHICH AS MANY AS- ARE
GETTING- OPEN- THAT'S SOMETHING
THAT THEY COULD USE BUT THEY
DON'T BUT WHAT THEY ARE ABLE TO
PROVIDE OUR BAR SUPPLY. IF YOU
WALK INTO AN ESTABLISHMENT
YOU'LL OFTEN SEE UMBRELLAS
PROVIDED BY CORONA- THE FELT ON
A POOL TABLE BY ANHEUSER BUSCH-
YOU KNOW VARIOUS I'LL CALL
COMPANIES THAT ARE PROVIDING
COASTERS AND SO FORTH. SO THIS
FITS VERY MUCH IN LINE WITH THAT
I EXPECT THEM FULLY. AND OF AND
FRANKLY ALREADY ENGAGED IN
DISCUSSION WITH MANY OF THOSE
COMPANIES. TO GET THEM READY FOR
THIS AND THEY'RE VERY EXCITED
FOR THEM. TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE.
A PARTICIPATE IN A SAFE
ENVIRONMENT MEANS THEY'LL IT'S
BETTER BUSINESS FOR THEM- TO
ANSWER YOUR QUESTION
SPECIFICALLY ABOUT THE COST. IN
BULK. WE EXPECT THE COST TO BE
VERY MUCH NOMINAL. ARE THE
CONSUMER CAN BUY FOR EXAMPLE ON
AMAZON FOR LESS THAN A DOLLAR.
OKAY PROTEST AT. THE BILL DOES
NOT MANDATE WHETHER OR NOT THESE
SHOULD BE FOR FREE OR SOLD. OKAY
I CAN BE UP TO THE BAR GREAT THE
BAR OWNER AS MATTER OF FACT. THE
LAST THING WE WANT TO DO IS TO
PUT. ANYTHING ONEROUS ON ANY
SMALL BUSINESS AND I'M ONE OF
THEM SO I CAN TELL YOU I CAN
RELATE TO THIS. TOTALLY AND
COMPLETELY. I'D LIKE TO JUST
CONCLUDE ANSWERING YOUR QUESTION
BY GIVING YOU AN ANECDOTE. MY
RESEARCH FOR THIS. I SPOKE WITH
MY BEST FRIEND'S SON. WHO'S THE
SOCIAL DIRECTOR. OF HIS
FRATERNITY AND A BOUNCER AT A
BAR AT ALL MISS. SO NOT HERE IN
CALIFORNIA. BUT COLLEGE RIGHT.
AND I SAID YOU KNOW WHAT WE ARE
ARE YOU DEALING WITH THE ROOFING
CRISIS ON CAMPUS HE SAID YES
IT'S WIDESPREAD IT'S A BIG
PROBLEM. SO WHAT ARE YOU DOING
ABOUT IT. HE SAID WELL WE MADE
THE DETERMINATION IN OUR
FRATERNITY. TO NO LONGER OFFER.
CONTAINER I'LL CALL WHATSOEVER.
EVERYTHING MUST BE CLOSE
CONTAINER. SO IF SOMEBODY COMES
TO A PARTY THEY MUST. WAS THE
EFFECT OF THE- HE SAID OUR
PARTY'S TRIPLED IN SIZE
OVERNIGHT. REALLY ALL OF THE
YOUNG WOMEN WANTED TO COME TO
THESE PARTIES BECAUSE THEY FELT
SAFER. AND THEN ALL THE MEN
WANTED TO COME BECAUSE THE WOMEN
WERE THERE. HE SAID THAT THANK
YOU FOR THAT INFORMATION THAT'S
REALLY HELPFUL THANK YOU MAN
IT'S A PLY GOTTEN- THANK YOU
ANOTHER QUESTION THAT I HAD A
PART OF YOUR BILL TALKS ABOUT
POSTING REQUIREMENTS IN THE REST
ROOM YES- ONE OF THE CAMPAIGNS
THAT I FELT WAS VERY SUCCESSFUL
WAS. AROUND THE DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE CAMPAIGN AND
PARTICULARLY IN THE WOMEN'S
RESTROOM WHERE THERE WERE SIGNS
THAT SAID DO YOU FEEL SAFE AT
HOME YEAH CALL THIS NUMBER- TELL
ME WHAT HOW YOU PICTURE AB THIS
THIS REQUIREMENT BEING- BEING
POSTED IN THE RESTROOMS WERE YOU
VISITING. WAS SENATOR THE IDEA
HERE IS TO INCREASE AWARENESS
WE'RE AT THE BEGINNING OF A
JOURNEY. AGAIN I GO BACK TO THE
ISSUE AROUND DRUNK DRIVING WITH
DRUNK DRIVING IT TAKE IT TAKES
AN ALL IN CAMPAIGN. LAW
ENFORCEMENT IS INVOLVED THE
DRINKING ESTABLISHMENTS ARE
INVOLVED THERE'S PUBLIC
INFORMATION CAMPAIGNS THAT WE
PARTICIPATE AS MATTER OF FACT IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS ARE DOING SO. AND
WE NEED TO AND ENGAGE UPON THAT
WITH THIS REVIEW IN CRISIS- THIS
THIS IS THE FIRST BILL ACTUALLY
ANOTHER BILL THE TIME CONSENT
THAT DEALS WITH ITS- WHICH IS
HAVING THESE MATERIALS INVOLVED
AT COLLEGE CAMPUSES. BOB BUT WE
NEED TO START. AND JUST LIKE IN
NOW IN THE CASE OF DRUNK DRIVING
YOU HAVE DESIGNATED DRUNK
DRIVERS YOU HAVE. YOU KNOW
DIFFERENT MECHANISMS THAT PEOPLE
ENGAGE AND- WE NEED TO EDUCATE
IN EVERY WAY POSSIBLE THAT THAT.
EVERYONE NEEDS TO BE PART OF THE
SOLUTION. SO IT'S NOT JUST
PROTECTING YOURSELF. IT'S ALSO
BEING AWARE. THAT THE ENTIRE
ESTABLISHMENT IS BEING VIGILANT
ABOUT IT. AND THAT ALL THE
PATRONS HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO
LOOK OUT FOR ONE ANOTHER TO
REPORT IT. IF THEY SEE IT. AND
TO YOU KNOW LET EACH OTHER KNOW
THAT THOSE TEST STRIPS ARE
AVAILABLE SO THIS IS AN
EDUCATION PROCESS. WE'RE GOING
TO LEARN FROM IT. WE DON'T KNOW
HOW PERFECT IT'S GOING TO BE
BECAUSE THIS IS UNPRECEDENTED.
SO I THINK YOU'RE GONNA SEE ME
BACK HERE YEAR AFTER YEAR AS
WE'RE LOOKING AT THESE THINGS.
AND TRIED TO MEASURE THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF THIS. CENTER
ONE LAST THING I DO WANT TO TELL
YOU. THE EXTENT OF THIS PROBLEM
IS MASSIVE. IT IS IT IS MASSIVE.
PEOPLE IN THE BUILDING HERE.
HAVE BEEN RECEIVED PEOPLE MY
STAFF. HAVE BEEN REVIEWED. R. I
WAS SPEAKING TO SOMEBODY IN THE
THIRD HOUSE. AND TALKING TO HER
ABOUT THE BILL. AND AS I WAS
SPEAKING ABOUT IT HER EYES BEGIN
TO WATER UP. SHE TOLD ME A
PERSONAL STORY. OF BEING
REVIEWED AND ASSAULTED. AND
WE'RE NOT DOING ANYTHING ABOUT
IT. THIS IS A VERY. EASY WAY TO
STEP INTO THIS BUT IT'S NOT
GONNA BE THE LAST. THANK YOU FOR
THAT- I DON'T HAVE ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS BUT I'D LIKE TO MOVE-
WHEN APPROPRIATE. I THINK SHE'S
ABSOLUTELY CENTER JONES THANK
YOU. MISTER CHAIR. ASSUME RIGHT
I AM LIKE YOUR BILL TO I DIDN'T
I THINK YOU AND I HAVE TWO
QUESTIONS I THINK YOU ANSWERED
THE FIRST ONE ALREADY- YOU KNOW
MY ONE OF MY CONCERNS IS THIS
MIGHT GIVE SOMEBODY A FALSE
SENSE OF SECURITY. BUT I THINK
YOU KIND OF. DON'T WANT THAT ON
THE EDUCATION- ACT AVENUE OF IT
YOU KNOW ONE OF THE THINGS SO
MAYBE YOU COULD. ANSWERED I MEAN
DO YOU ENVISION PEOPLE. TESTING
MULTIPLE TIMES AN EVENING. YOU
KNOW THEIR DRINKS OR IS IT A ONE
TIME THING. AND THEN THE SECOND
QUESTION I HAD WAS MOVING
FORWARD AS- HOW DO YOU ENVISION
GOING FOR WHEN. NEW DRUGS COME.
AROUND AND THEY'RE NOT PART OF.
THE FLAG OF A BETTER TERM MENU
TODAY OF YOU KNOW WHAT'S OUT
THERE WE WILL SEND OUR GREAT
QUESTIONS- WE WILL HAVE TO
ADJUST AS WE GO AND LEARN AS WE
GO AND YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT
THIS WILL EVOLVE. AS AS WE SEE
YOU KNOW FOR EXAMPLE THE FEDERAL
CRISIS WE SEE EVOLUTION. IN DRUG
UTILIZATION IN DRUGGING OTHERS
AND SO FORTH. AS FOR YOUR FIRST
QUESTION. I'M A FATHER. OF THREE
DAUGHTERS AND THEY'RE NOT YET AT
THE AGE WHERE THEY'RE ABLE TO GO
OUT BUT I'M THINKING ABOUT THEIR
FUTURE. AND AS THEIR DAD WHAT I
WOULD DO. ASIDE FROM MAKING SURE
THAT THEY HAVE- FREE UBER'S TO
COME HOME YOU KNOW FOR THEM AND
THEIR FRIENDS IN ANY GIVEN TIME.
IS ALSO TO GIVE THEM EXTRA MONEY
. AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY HAVE
THESE TESTS COASTERS AVAILABLE
FOR ALL THEIR DRINKS WHY. NOT
BECAUSE OF FALSE SENSE OF
SECURITY. BECAUSE I WANT ANYBODY
WHO THINKS THEY CAN REVIEW THEM.
TO SEE THAT THEY HAVE THE TEST
STRIPS OUT THE TEST COASTERS AND
THAT THEY'RE TESTING THEIR
DRINK. AS A PREVENTIVE MEASURE
IF WE CAN CUT DOWN. ON 10%
THAT'S A VICTORY. ANYTHING WE
CAN DO. I KNEW YOU COULDN'T HELP
YOURSELF I COULD I CAN'T. I
CAN'T. I'VE GOT MAKE UP HERE YOU
HAVE THE DEVICE THERE. SO IT'S
JUST A MATTER OF JUST POURING A
LITTLE BIT ON THEIR OF WHAT- HOW
DOES IT WORK. LITERALLY A DROP.
IN EACH ONE OF THESE BECAUSE
THESE THESE SPECIFIC ONES TEST
FOR GHB. AND KETAMINE WHICH ARE
THE TWO DRUGS THAT ARE BEING
UTILIZED THE MOST. THIS IS WHAT
BILL COSBY WAS DOING BY THE WAY
EVERYONE ALLEGEDLY ALLEGEDLY.
I'M COMFORTABLE SAYING NOT A-
AND LITERALLY PUTTING A DROP OR
TWO ON YOUR DRINK AND OF YOUR
DRINK ON THE COASTER AND IT WILL
CHANGE COLOR IMMEDIATELY. THE
TOUGH THING ABOUT THESE DRUGS
SENATOR. IS THAT THEY LEAVE YOUR
BODY QUICKLY THEY DON'T TASTE
ANYTHING THEY'RE CLEAR THEY'RE
IMPOSSIBLE TO DETECT THE GOOD
THING ABOUT THESE DRUGS IS ONCE
YOUR DRINK HAS BEEN SPIKED.
THEY'RE EASY TO DETECT WITH
THESE TEST TRIPS. WE'RE GOOD
THANK YOU. WELL THIS IS
FASTENING SO I WENT BACK EAST
FOR. A FAMILY EVENT AT THIS
WEEKEND AND I WAS ON A FLIGHT IN
THE WOMAN SITTING NEXT TO ME HER
HUSBAND. HAVE A CONDO IN FLORIDA
NEXT VERY FAMOUS BAR SHE WENT
THERE ONE AFTERNOON SHE'S GONNA
MEET HER HUSBAND THEIR NEXT
THING SHE KNOWS SHE WAKES UP IN
A JAIL CELL. AND SO CLEARLY
DREADED CLEARLY DRIVE INS LIKE
WHAT ARE YOU GUYS DOING ABOUT IT
I CAN'T WAIT TO TEXT HER AND LET
HER KNOW ABOUT YOUR BILL AND IN
THESE THINGS SO. THIS AND SHE'S
AN OLDER WOMAN SO I MEAN THIS
CAN HAPPEN TO ANYBODY AT ANY
TIME AND NO ONE SHOULD BE.
SHOULD I NOT THINK THAT THEY
THEY CAN'T BE A VICTIM BECAUSE I
THINK THEY CAN. SO WITHOUT THE
RECOMMENDATION IS AGAIN DO PASS
AND YOU MAY CLOSE. I THANK YOU
SENATORS I WANT TO REITERATE
THAT I HAVE ACCEPTED THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS AND LIKE TO
THINK THAT SHARING COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR ALL THEIR WORK ON THE
BILL. AND ALSO TO POINT OUT THAT
THIS BILL RECEIVED UNANIMOUS
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN THE
ASSEMBLY. THANK YOU SIR THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM NINE A. B. TEN TWENTY THREE
BY ASSEMBLYWOMAN PAP IN. WELL
SERVING. YOU SEE CENTER VERSION
OH I'M SORRY. I APOLOGIZE. LIKE
THE NEW HAIR CUT THIS IS FILE
ITEM SIXTY B. SEVEN EIGHTY ONE
ASSEMBLY MEN MAIENSCHEIN
RECOMMENDATION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE AND
WITH THAT FLOOR IS YOURS THANK
YOU. I GOT MY HAIR CUT TO
IMPRESS YOU FIRST OFF AND IS
THAT WHAT IT WORK AND I AM GLAD
TO HEAR THAT AND SECONDLY THANK
YOU BECAUSE I'M RUNNING AS YOU
AT YOU AS YOU KNOW I'M TURN THE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND NEED TO
GET BACK SO I WILL ALSO BE VERY
BRIEF. A. B. SEVEN EIGHTY ONE
REQUIRES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
DESIGNATE EMERGENCY SHELTERS
WARMING CENTERS AND COOLING
CENTERS. THAT ARE ABLE TO
ACCOMMODATE PEOPLE WITH PAT'S
THE RATE OF NATURAL DISASTERS
AND EXTREME WEATHER IS RAPIDLY
INCREASING ACROSS CALIFORNIA
CAUSING SIGNIFICANT REST OF
PUBLIC HEALTH AND COMMUNITY
SAFETY. AB SEVENTY ONE WILL HELP
ENSURE PERSON NEVER WILL BE
FACED WITH THE UNFORTUNATE
CHOICE OF SEEKING SAFETY OR
STAYING WITH THEIR PETS. HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF AB SEVEN
EIGHTY ONE IS BRITNEY BITMAIN'S
IN ASKING THE SENIOR LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR THE S. P. C. A. AND
I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE
VOTE. THANK YOU GOOD MORNING
VICE CHAIR WELL MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE. I THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY ON AB
SEVENTY ONE WHICH WILL ENHANCE
PUBLIC SAFETY AND EMERGENCY
PREPAREDNESS ACROSS THE STATE.
WHILE HELPING TO ENSURE THAT NO
CALIFORNIAN BE FACED WITH THE
DEVASTATING DECISION BETWEEN
SEEKING SAFETY AND STAYING WITH
OUR BELOVED PETS. AS YOU MAY
KNOW THE SPCA HAS A LONG HISTORY
OF SUPPORTING LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
IN EMERGENCY RESPONSE. OUR FIELD
TEAM IS SEEN FIRST HAND THE ROLE
THAT PETS PLAN PEOPLE'S DECISION
MAKINGS DURING AN EVACUATION.
AND THE BENEFITS THAT PLANNING
FOR CO SHELTERING WHERE PEOPLE
CAN TAKE AND STAY WITH OR NEAR
THEIR PETS. HOUSE IN REDUCING
RISK. RESEARCHERS FOUND THAT PET
OWNERSHIP IS THE HIGHEST RISK
FACTOR FOR EVACUATION NON
COMPLIANCE AND IT IS ESTIMATED
THAT 80% OF PEOPLE WHO REENTER
AN EVACUATION SITE ILLEGALLY DO
SO TO RESCUE A PAT. A RECENT
SURVEY OF CALIFORNIANS FOUND
THAT 16% OF THE OF THE 16% OF
RESIDENTS WHO PLAN TO UTILIZE AN
EVACUATION CENTER. 76% PLAN TO
STATE TO BRING THEIR PET WITH
THEM. IN OVER HALF OF ALL
RESPONDENTS REPORTED THAT THEY
WOULD ONLY EVACUATE IF THEY
COULD BRING THEIR PET.
CALIFORNIANS EMERGENCY
MANAGEMENT OFFICES AND ANIMAL
SERVICES AGENCIES RECOGNIZE THE
BENEFITS OF COACH ALL TRAINED
WITH MANY HAVING ALREADY
INTEGRATED THIS INTO THEIR
EMERGENCY PLANS. MANY ALSO HAVE
WEB PAGES DOES IT DEDICATED TO
ANIMAL PREPAREDNESS HOWEVER THE
MESSAGE GENE IS TYPICALLY
SOMETHING AND ALL ALONG THE
LINES OF IDENTIFY A HOTEL NEAR
YOU THAT IS PET FRIENDLY
IDENTIFY FRIENDS OR FAMILY THAT
COULD TAKE YOUR PET. WHICH IS OF
COURSE PROHIBITIVE FOR THOSE WHO
CANNOT TAKE ON A SUDDEN HOTEL
EXPENSE NOR HAVE A LOCAL
NETWORK. ADDITIONALLY THE RATE
OF PET FRIENDLY WARMING AND
COOLING CENTERS VARIES WIDELY
ACROSS THE STATE WITH SOME
COUNTIES OFFERING A ONE HUNDRED
PERCENT- PET FRIENDLY COOLING
CENTERS IN RECENT HEATWAVES.
WHEREAS OTHERS APPEAR TO HAVE
OFFERED ZERO. AB SEVENTY ONE
WILL HELP TO ENSURE THAT WHEN
THE NEXT EXTREME HEAT WAVE-
FLOOD WILDFIRE OR WHATEVER THE
UNIVERSE CHOOSES TO THROW AT US
NEXT. COMES DOWN OUR COMMUNITIES
WILL BE BETTER PREPARED AND
CALIFORNIANS WILL KNOW THAT
SEEKING SAFETY THAT THEY WILL BE
ABLE TO SEEK SAFETY WITHOUT
HAVING TO CHOOSE BETWEEN THAT
SAFETY AND OUR PETS. ON A THINK
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MAIENSCHEIN FOR
HIS LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE AND
THINK THE COMMITTEE FOR YOUR
TIME I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE. GREAT THANK YOU ANYBODY
ELSE IN THE ROOM IN SUPPORT.
REMEMBER SOMEONE MENTIONED NEED
TO GET BACK TO. YOU CHAIRED A
MEETING SO. GOOD MORNING THIS IS
BARBARA SCHMITZ I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE SAN FRANCISCO SPCA
AND WE SUPPORT ASSEMBLY BILL
SEVENTY ONE THANK YOU. GOOD
MORNING ELIZABETH ESPINOSA HERE
THIS MORNING ON BEHALF OF THE
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS IN THE
COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU. HELLO
NICOLAS SACKETT- HERE FOR SOCIAL
COMPASSION IN LEGISLATION IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU GOOD TO SEE
YOU. MORE MISTER ABOUT ROBINSON
WITH THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE
UNITED STATES AND CAL ANIMALS IN
SUPPORT THANKS. THANK YOU.
SEEING NO OTHERS ANYONE IN THE
ROOM IN OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE-
MODERATOR CAN WE MOVE TO THE
PHONES. AGAIN FILE ITEM SIX
EIGHTY B. SEVEN EIGHTY ONE BY
SOME WOMEN MAIENSCHEIN. THANK
YOU PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO. GETS
. ONE ZERO. THE LINE NUMBER
THIRTY TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
MORNING IF YOU'RE A MEMBER OF
THE MATTER NOT W. TRAGEDY ON
BEHALF OF ANIMAL LEGAL DEFENSE.
IN STRONG SUPPORT IN THE THANK
YOU. AND CURRENTLY NONE FURTHER
AND CAN'T. GREAT WE'RE GONNA
PULL IT BACK TO. TO COMMITTEE
WITH THE REMINDER THAT THE
ASSEMBLY MINISTER CHAIR
COMMITTEE CENTER JOHN SCOTT AT
TWO TWO QUICK QUESTIONS I THINK-
AND- I KIND OF AGREE WITH THE
PREMISE MY MOM LIVES IN LAUGHLIN
NEVADA. AND IT'S GOING TO BE A
HUNDRED FIFTEEN THERE THIS WEEK
SHE HAS A SMALL DOG THERE'S NO
WAY. SHE WOULD GO WITHOUT ARE
DOGS SO THIS WEEKEND I MOVED TO
COLORADO SO SHE CAN AVOID THAT
HUNDRED FIFTEEN DEGREE-
TEMPERATURES IN LAUGHLIN. BUT I
TO CONCERNS ONE- SPACE IS
LIMITED. IN THESE. RESCUE A
SHELTER PLACES AND SO THE PET.
MIGHT BE OCCUPYING A SPACE THAT
A PERSON COULD HAVE. AND THEN
THE SECOND CONCERN IS-
CONTROLLING THE PET'S BEHAVIOR
SO THAT YOU'RE NOT GETTING INTO
A DOG VERSUS CATS. OR DOGS WORSE
IS DOG SITUATION HOW DO YOU
ENVISIONED YET SO TWO SITUATIONS
SO THE INTENT IS THAT NOT
EVERYONE HAVE TO MOVE FROM
LAUGHLIN TO COLORADO. YOU KNOW
IT IT AS SOMEBODY WHO YOU KNOW I
ACTUALLY WENT THROUGH THE
SITUATION TWICE IS AS YOU KNOW
WHEN RANCHO BERNARDO HAD THE
FIRE IN OH SEVEN AND SCRIPTS
RANCH IN THE FARM TWO THOUSAND
THREE AND THE THESE WERE REAL
CHOICES THAT PEOPLE WERE MAKING.
ME PEOPLE LITERALLY WERE STAYING
IN THEIR HOMES BECAUSE THEY
DIDN'T WANT TO LEAVE THEIR PAT.
MANY PEOPLE CONSIDER THEIR PATH
TO FAMILY MEMBER AND THEY AND
SECONDLY SO THERE'S THAT AND
TRYING TO GET THEM OUT AND
SECONDLY ONCE THEY'RE IN A
SHELTER YOU KNOW THEY'VE JUST
LOST EVERY SINGLE THING THEY
OWN. EVERYTHING THEY OWN IS
LITERALLY ASHES SO HAVING THEIR
PETS THEIR WITH THEM IS SOME
SMALL WAY OF HELPING WHAT WE
WERE ABLE TO DO TO AVOID EXACTLY
WHAT YOU WERE SAYING WE DID THIS
AND IN. THE TWO TIMES THAT I HAD
TO LEAVE THE REBUILDING EFFORTS
AFTER FIRES IS WE BROUGHT THE
ASPCA WE BROUGHT THE HUMANE
SOCIETY THERE TO ASSIST WITH THE
EXACT ISSUES THAT YOU WERE
TALKING ABOUT. SO WE DID NOT
HAVE THAT PROBLEM WHERE ANYONE
EVER WAS BEING DISPLACED AND
SECONDLY TO YOUR POINT ABOUT
SORT OF ANY OF THESE ANIMALS
CAUSING ANY SORT OF PROBLEM WE
HAD TRAINED PEOPLE THEIR- ON
SITE TO MAKE SURE NONE OF THAT
HAPPENED. WELL AS A PET LOVER IN
AS A DISTRICT A TWO THIRDS OF IT
IT'S IN WILDFIRE COUNTRY THINK
THIS IS A GREAT IDEA AND WILL
SUPPORT WE- EVENTUALLY HAVE. A
FULL COMMITTEE BUT YOU MAY CLOSE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- I AM VERY.
SORRY YEAH HE DOES HAVE A
COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN YES I HAD
OKAY VERY VERY QUICKLY SO MY
NUMBER- SO YOUR DEFINITION OF
PETS SO I HAVE A REPRESENT. A
FAIR RULE COMMUNITY. AND SO- CAT
AND DOG DOESN'T CUT IT FOR US
SOMETIMES- HOW HOW CAN YOU WORK
TO EXPAND THAT DEFINITION TO
INCLUDE OTHER DOMESTICATED
ANIMALS SO WE HAVE I MEAN WE'VE
I'VE DONE SINCE. I'VE DONE OTHER
THINGS ABOUT HAVING LOOKED
REQUIRE LIKE I'VE DONE ANOTHER
BILL THAT REQUIRES LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO HAVE AN
EVACUATION PLANS YOUR GET YOUR
TALK ABOUT HORSES I ASSUME COPY
EGGS REPTILES ARAR. YES YEAH I
WANT TO THROW AN ALPACA ALPACA
HELP. THANK OKAY I'LL PACK AS WE
HAVEN'T QUITE I'M GETTING SHE'S.
ROLLED DOWN I. WILL BRING
ALPACAS. YEAH I THINK BUT KNOW
WHAT WE DONE IS HAVE A- IN.
BILLS THAT I'VE DONE WE HAVE
REQUIRED A PLAN WHICH WOULD TAKE
INTO. ACCOUNT LARGER ANIMALS
OBVIOUSLY. IF FOR THE ISSUE
RAISED BY MISTER JONES. YOU
WOULDN'T HAVE LARGE ANIMALS IN
THAT IN THE SAME SHELTER AS YOU
WOULD HAVE HUMAN BEINGS AND I
WAY POSSIBLE. SO WE HAVE
ADDRESSED YOUR VERY ISSUE WE'VE
DONE AND IN A SEPARATE BILL. IN
A SEPARATE BILL OKAY AND THEN-
QUESTION IN TERMS OF QUANTITY
SO. IN MY HOUSE AT ANY ONE TIME
I HAVE FOUR DOGS AND A PIG. OUT
ALL DOMESTICATED WITH WOULD WE
BE ABLE TO BRING OUR WHOLE
FAMILY INTO A SHELTER OR IS
THERE A LIMIT OF HOW MANY. PETS
YOU CAN YEAH I MEAN THE BILL
DOESN'T ENVISION A LIMIT WHAT I
WOULD SAY IS TYPICALLY WHAT
HAPPENS. IS YOU HAVE THIS THAT
RESOURCES THAT ARE THERE SUCH AS
THE HUMANE SOCIETY SPCA. SO IN
YOUR CASE THAT WE BECAUSE THAT'S
A LITTLE BIT LARGER NUMBER OF
ANIMALS THAT WOULD HELP ASSIST
WITH MAYBE IT KEEP ONE WITH YOU
AND- NOT THAT THAT- AND AGAIN WE
DID THIS EXACT ISSUE. THAT WAS
MORE OF A CASE BY CASE ISSUE
CLEARLY AGAIN THE PAID WOULDN'T
BE THERE. BUT IN TERMS OF MORE
YOU KNOW SORT OF SMALLER MORE
DOMESTICATED ANIMALS I THINK
THAT'S A LITTLE BIT EASIER. BUT
THE RESOURCES ARE THERE WITH THE
HUMANE SOCIETY SPCA IS TO TAKE
CARE OF THE LARGER WEST MESQUITE
ANIMALS SO DOES YOUR BILL ALLOW
FOR THE COUNTIES TO KIND OF MAKE
THAT DECISION A BUILT INTO. THE
PLAN A DESPERATE THANK YOU SO
MUCH OF. ANYTHING ELSE. ARCHER
LET. YOUR ST CAN BE BROKEN ALL
RIGHT. AGAIN IS DUE. TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE YOU MAY
CLOSE THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
TERRY APPRECIATE IT AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE
VOTE. THANK YOU SIR. SHARE THE
WEALTH. ALL RIGHT NOW WE'RE
GONNA MOVE. TO FILE ITEM NINE.
ASSEMBLY WOMAN PATTON AB. TEN
TWENTY THREE. AND THE
RECOMMENDATION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. AND SO
WHENEVER YOU'RE COMFORTABLE.
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU SO
MUCH MISTER TERRY GOOD MORNING
NICE TO BE WITH YOU. SO THIS
BILL IS ABOUT CYBER SECURITY IN
SCHOOLS IN INADEQUATE
CYBERSECURITY PRESENTS A REAL
SERIOUS THREAT- BECAUSE BREACHES
HAVE THE POTENTIAL NOW IS SHUT
DOWN OPERATIONS. THEY CAN
COMPROMISE SENSITIVE STUDENT
DATA AND STAFF DATA. EQUIPPING
SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND COUNTY
OFFICES OF EDUCATION WITH THE
TOOLS. TO SUPPORT- AND BETTER
DEFEND AGAINST AND RESPOND TO
CYBERATTACKS. IS OF. A CRITICAL
ASPECT OF. SCHOOL SAFETY THESE
DAYS- WE'VE WE'VE HEARD LOTS OF
STORIES ABOUT RANSOMWARE BECOMES
A VERY VERY TRICKY PROPOSITIONS
SO AB TWENTY THREE IS REALLY A
SIMPLE BILL. IT WILL INCLUDE T.
K. THROUGH TWELVE M. SCHOOLS IN
THE CALIFORNIA CYBERSECURITY
INTEGRATION CENTER OR COLD CAL
SICK. AND CAL SECOR NEED CYBER
INTELLIGENCE AND INFORMATION
SHARING WITH LOCAL STATE AND
FEDERAL AGENCIES NGOS AND
ACADEMIC INSTITUTIONS
IMPORTANTLY ACADEMIC
INSTITUTIONS ARE TYPICALLY
REFERS TO HIGHER READ POST
SECONDARY INSTITUTIONS SO WHAT
THIS BILL DOES IS EXPLICITLY
INCLUDES. T. K. THROUGH TWELVE-
IN OUR CYBER DEFENSE AND- IN
THIS THE M. C. SIX SERVICES SO-
IT'S VERY SIMPLE BILL AND WITH
ME TODAY I HAVE TESTIFYING THIS
ERICA HOFFMAN WHO IS WITH THE
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
ASSOCIATION. THINGS ARE GOING TO
GET TWO MINUTES AS YOU KNOW YOU
KNOW THAT THEIR- TWO MINUTES
THIS IS EASY. MAYBE CURRENTLY
THERE ARE OVER A THOUSAND SCHOOL
DISTRICTS- WITHIN CALIFORNIA
REPRESENTING SIX MILLION
CHILDREN OVER FIVE HUNDRED
THOUSAND EMPLOYEES TEN THOUSAND
SCHOOL SITES- ALL ORGANIZATIONS
ARE VULNERABLE TO CYBER ATTACKS
AS YOU WILL SEE IN THE PAPERS
WITH REGARDS TO YOUR LOCAL
DISTRICTS- THIS BILL IS JUST A
VERY SIMPLE ONE. IT WOULD
SPECIFICALLY INCLUDE K. TWELVE
WITHIN THOSE ENTITIES THAT CAN
RECEIVE INFORMATION SHARE
INFORMATION GET MORE INFORMATION
IN ORDER DRESS CYBER A LOT OF
DISTRICTS DON'T HAVE THE STAFF.
THAT'S HIGHLY TRAINED IN THIS
THEY'RE BUILDING IT UP THIS IS
ONE MORE WAY THOUGH TO MAKE SURE
THEY'RE INCLUDED THOSE
CONVERSATIONS. SO FOR THOSE
REASONS WE ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
THANK YOU EXCELLENT TESTIMONY
ANYONE ELSE IN THE ROOM IN
SUPPORT. COME ON UP. GOOD
MORNING MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
PAMELA GIVES REPRESENTING THE
LOS ANGELES COUNTY OFFICE OF
EDUCATION AND WE STRONGLY
SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU. GOOD
MORNING TURN MEMBERS SOCIAL WERE
WITH LOS ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
SEEING NO OTHERS IS MOVED
OPPOSITION ANYONE IN THE ROOM IN
OPPOSITION THEY'LL LIKE TO
TESTIFY. SEEING NONE WE'RE GOING
TO MOVE TO THE PHONES MISTER
MODERATOR AGAIN THIS IS- ITEM
NINE E. B. TEN TWENTY THREE. AND
IF WE DO HAVE PEOPLE TESTIFYING
IS NOW ME TO TESTIMONY SO YOUR
NAME ORGANIZATION IF YOU HAVE
ONE AND YOUR POSITION ON THE
BILL. THANK YOU AND PLEASE PRESS
ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME AND SO.
AGAIN IT'S. ONE ZERO. AND
CURRENTLY NOBODY IN Q. THANK YOU
MR MODERATOR AND RIGHT NOW WE
WILL PULL IT BACK TO SENATOR TO
LETTER FOR ANY QUESTIONS
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- IN ONE OF MY SCHOOL
DISTRICTS AND MY- IT IS EXACTLY
WHAT HAPPENED. AND IT WAS COSTLY
IT INVOLVED A LOT OF PEOPLE SO
I'M I'M GLAD THIS BILL IS HERE
BECAUSE WE NEED THIS ACROSS THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA WORKING WITH
LAW ENFORCEMENT. SCHOOL DISTRICT
SCHOOL POLICE EVERYONE AND THE
COST WE JUST HEARD FROM THE LA
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT IMAGINE
WHAT IT WOULD DO TO THAT
ENORMOUS ENORMOUS. A GROUP OF
PEOPLE THERE CHAU I'M GLAD THIS
IS HERE NOW WE HAVE TO MOVE IT
AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. Q. NO
ONE ELSE I HAD A SIMILAR
SITUATION WITH AN ELEMENTARY
SCHOOL SO YEAH THIS IS
DEFINITELY AN IMPORTANT ISSUE
WITH THAT SAYING NO QUESTIONS
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS WILL LOOK
TO YOU FOR A CLOSE. JUST
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
AND THANK YOU FOR BEING SO
RECEPTIVE TO WHAT AB PERILS DO
LIE AHEAD IF WE DON'T DO IT
ABSOLUTELY. THANK YOU SIMPLY
WOMAN. OKAY LOOKING MAKE SURE. I
DON'T A CALL ON HER. NO OKAY UP
NEXT SHE'S HERE IN THE ROOM SB
FILE ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN AB TEN
EIGHTY EIGHT BY ASSEMBLY WOMAN
RUBIO. AND WHENEVER YOU'RE
COMFORTABLE PLEASE PROCEED YES
THANK YOU MISTER TURN OFFER THE
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AB TEN
EIGHTY EIGHT WHICH WOULD EXTEND
DIRECT TO CONSUMER SHIPPING
FLEXIBILITIES FOR SMALL. CRAFT
DISTILLERS THROUGH TWENTY TWENTY
FOUR IN CALIFORNIA THERE ARE
OVER TWO HUNDRED CRAFT
DISTILLERS WHICH ON AVERAGE
EMPLOYEE FIVE TO TEN DAY VIGILS.
THESE ARE SMALL BUSINESSES WITH
SUBSTANTIAL LOCAL FOOTPRINTS IN
EACH OF OUR DISTRICTS WHICH WERE
CRITICALLY IMPACTED DURING THE
PANDEMIC. IN THE MONTHS
FOLLOWING THE ONSET OF THE
PANDEMIC THE LEGISLATURE AND THE
ADMINISTRATION WERE COLLECTIVELY
ABLE TO PROVIDE A LIFELINE FOR
THESE BUSINESSES. THROUGH DIRECT
TO CONSUMER SHIPPING A
FLEXIBILITY ALREADY AFFORDED TO
OTHER STAKEHOLDERS IN THE
INDUSTRY. AB TEN EIGHTY EIGHT
CONTINUES OUR EFFORTS TO SUPPORT
THIS GROWING INDUSTRY AS TASTING
ROOM VISITS ARE STILL DOWN FROM
THE CALL THAT PICKED NINETEEN
PANDEMIC. THIS IS SIMPLY AN
EXTENSION NOW REPEAT IT'S TO
SIMPLY AN EXTENSION OF
FLEXIBILITIES PREVIOUSLY
AFFORDED. TO THESE CRAFT
DISTILLERS AND NOW SUCH THIS
MEASURE HAS NO INDUSTRY
OPPOSITION HERE TODAY AS OUR
PRIMARY WITNESSES MADE FALL OF
ON BEHALF OF THE ARCTIC
ARTISANAL DISTILLERS GUILD. I
THINK YOU SENATORS AND WITH
THAT. LET FOR. YOU HAVE TO
MINUTES. CHAIRED MEMBERS ALL OF
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA.
DISTILLERS GUILD OVER TWO
HUNDRED CRAFT DISTILLERS IN THE
STATE WE JUST WANT TO. THANK THE
AUTHOR THE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS AND STAFF FOR THEIR HELP
YOU HELP KEEP THIS INDUSTRY
ALIVE OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS
THEIR ABILITY TO DO ONLINE
SALES. AND SHIPPED TO CONSUMERS
AS ALLOW THESE TWO HUNDRED
DISTILLERIES TO KEEP THEIR DOORS
OPEN KEEP PEOPLE EMPLOYED THIS
IS SIMPLY A ONE YEAR EXTENSION
OF THAT PRIVILEGE THAT YOU'VE
ALREADY GRANTED THEM APPRECIATE
YOUR SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
YOU WELL DONE. ANYONE ELSE IN
THE ROOM IN SUPPORT. SEEING NONE
ANYONE IN THE ROOM IN OPPOSITION
. HELLO SENATORS FRED JONES
AGAIN ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA
COUNCIL ON ALCOHOL PROBLEMS BUT
WE ARE A MEMBER OF THE
CALIFORNIA. ALLIANCE ALCOHOL
POLICY ALLIANCE WHICH IS A BUNCH
OF- ORGANIZATIONS INCLUDING
TREATMENT FACILITIES LOCAL
ORGANIZATIONS SOME OF THEM MICRO
JUST ONE CITY THAT ARE CONCERNED
ABOUT CERTAIN BARS AND
RESTAURANTS SO DOZENS OF
ORGANIZATIONS THROUGHOUT THE
STATE THAT ARE CONCERNED ABOUT.
THE INAPPROPRIATE- CELL OR
CONSUMPTION MARKETING OF ALCOHOL
. I JUST WANT TO JUST BRIEFLY
GIVE A HISTORY BECAUSE THIS BILL
IN THE VACUUM SOUNDS REASONABLE.
ONE YEAR EXTENSION. OF WHAT.
THIRTY TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN
THERE WAS NO SUCH SCENE AS A
CRAFT DISTILLERY LICENSE. AND IN
TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN CRAFT
DISTILLERY LICENSE CREATED WERE
ALLOWED TO SELL DIRECTLY TO
CONSUMERS. WHO WERE IN THEIR
TASTING ROOMS. BUT THEN WHEN
CALVET STRUCK THERE WERE NO
TASTING ROOMS. SO THERE WAS AN
EXEMPTION AND EMERGENCY
EXEMPTION BASED ON COBIT. TO
ALLOW THEM TO SELL DIRECTLY TO
CONSUMERS THROUGH THE MAIL.
AGAIN NOT ATTACHED TO A TASTING
ROOM SO NOW WE ARE GOING TO
EXTEND THIS ANOTHER YEAR. SO WE
WERE CONCERNED ABOUT THE LICENSE
ABOUT THIS DIRECT TO CONSUMER
CELLS UNDERMINING TIED HOUSE
RESTRICTIONS. AND THIS JUST
CONTINUES TO PERPETUATE IT AND
THEY'LL LIKELY BILLION A BILL
NEXT YEAR. AND MAYBE THE YEAR
AFTER THAT SO FOR THOSE POLICY
REASONS WE HAVE TO OPPOSE THIS
BILL. THANK YOU SIR ANYONE ELSE
THE ROOM COME ON UP. MISTER
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MIKE
SKIP WITH ALCOHOL JUSTICE- THIS
BILL FUNDAMENTALLY UNDERMINES
THE THREE TIER SYSTEM. AND
ALLOWING PRODUCERS TO ALSO
BECOME DISTRIBUTORS AND
RETAILERS. THE TIED HOUSE LAWS
THREE TIER SYSTEM IS IN PLACE
FOR VERY GOOD REASONS- MANY OF
WHICH HAVE TO DO WITH PUBLIC
HEALTH AND SAFETY. IN PARTICULAR
DIRECT TO CONSUMER- SALES MAKE
IT NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO
CONSISTENTLY ENGAGE IN
RESPONSIBLE BEVERAGE SERVICE
PRACTICE. DELIVERY CARRIERS HAVE
NO RBS MANDATE NO ABILITY TO
CONSISTENTLY IDENTIFY AND REFUSE
SERVICE UNDER DANGEROUS
CIRCUMSTANCES. AND BOTH
TECHNICAL AND ECONOMIC PRESSURES
THAT REDUCE THE ABILITY TO
PROPERTY TO PROPERLY PREVENT
DELIVERY TO UNDER AGE
RECIPIENTS. FOR THIS REASON WE
ARE OPPOSED TO DIRECT TO
CONSUMER SALES AND TO THIS BILL
THANK YOU. THANK YOU SIR ANYONE
ELSE IN THE ROOM IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
TO THE PHONES WE'LL TAKE THE A
AND NAY TESTIMONY AT THIS POINT
IT'S JUST ME TOO SO YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION IF YOU ARE PART OF
ONE AND YOUR POSITION ON THE
BILL. MISTER MODERATOR. I THINK
YOU'RE MUCH AND AGAIN IT IS ONE
ZERO AT THIS TIME PLEASE PRESS.
ONE ZERO. GIVING IT A MOMENT
CARDINAL PRETTY IN Q. CURRENTLY
. ALL RIGHT PULL IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS. AND MOVE THE BILL
INAPPROPRIATE. THAT WAS IT THAT
WAS IT YOU'RE NOT GONNA SAY
ANYTHING YOU'RE GONNA BREAK YOUR
STREAK. WELL IF YOU'D LIKE ME TO
LET ME GO AHEAD AND I UNDERSTAND
THIS I ACTUALLY WANT YOU TO
BECAUSE I'M NOT A SCRIPT AND IT
BECAUSE ARE THERE ANY MINISTER
THIS BILL YES. NO OKAY GOOD
SEARCHES DO PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS YOU DON'T HAVE TO
COME IN NOW SINCE I'M ON THE BUT
I'M ALREADY ASIAN OKAY SO LIKE
SO WOULD LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR
BRING THIS FORWARD BECAUSE I
KNOW THE- TEACHERS AND-
DISTRIBUTORS ARE WORKING
TOGETHER. AND I HOPE THAT THEY
DO COME TOGETHER. NEXT YEAR
THANK YOU THANK YOU. SAN
ARCHULETA YOU'RE GONNA MAKE A
FINE CA- EXCITED ABOUT THAT OKAY
WITH THAT- WE ALREADY HAVE A
WHO'S PLAN TO MOVE YOUR BILL
WHEN APPROPRIATE WHEN WE HAVE A
FULL COMMITTEE AND YOU MAY CLOSE
THANK YOU RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NICK. VERY WELL DONE THANK YOU
THANK YOU. GREAT WHO'S IN THE
ROOM NO ONE'S IN THE ROOM. I'M
OPEN TO HAVING A JURY. MOTION TO
ADJOURN. IT'S ALWAYS IN ORDER
RIGHT. ALL RIGHT STAFF BE IF
YOU'RE WATCHING AND YOU HAVE A
MEMBER THAT HAS YET TO PERCENT.
NOW TO BE A GREAT TIME TO COME
DOWN. OH OH MAKE ME. THERE WE GO
. WE DIDN'T PRESS GRACED BY THE
PRESENCE OF ASSUMING GABRIEL
HE'S GOT TO BILLS UP THIS
MORNING.
WITH EARTH FILE ITEM THIRTEEN AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY FIVE IS THAT RIGHT
FOR YOU THAT DOES THANK YOU SIR
OKAY GREAT. LOWERED SHARES.
THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS I
WANNA START TODAY BY THANKING
THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
ASSISTANCE ON THIS BILL AND I AM
PLEASED 28% ALLAYED. AB ELEVEN
EIGHTY FIVE WHICH WILL FURTHER
STRENGTHEN THE CALIFORNIA STATE
NONPROFIT SECURITY GRANT
PROGRAM. THIS PROGRAM HAS FUNDED
CRITICAL SECURITY ENHANCEMENTS
AT RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS LGBTQ
COMMUNITY CENTERS REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH FACILITIES AND OTHER NON
PROFITS DEEMED TO BE AT RISK
FROM VIOLENT EXTREMISM. HAS
BECOME THE OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
SERVICES MOST POPULAR GRANT
PROGRAM BUT SADLY THE INTEREST
IN NEED FOR THIS FOR FUNDING
ONLY CONTINUES TO GROW. RECENT
HATE MOTIVATED SHOOTINGS IN LOS
ANGELES AND SAN FRANCISCO
TARGETING THE JEWISH AN API
COMMUNITY SHOWS THAT OUR WORK IS
NOT COMPLETE. THESE COMMUNITIES
AND MANY OTHERS LIKE THEM ARE IN
SERIOUS NEED OF COMMUNAL
SECURITY INFRASTRUCTURE AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY FIVE MAKES CHANGES
TO THE NONPROFIT SECURITY GRANT
PROGRAM BASED ON FEEDBACK FROM
OUR MOST IMPORTANT STAKEHOLDERS
AND WILL REMOVE BARRIERS TO THIS
PROGRAM SO THAT ALL
ORGANIZATIONS WHO NEED SUCH
SECURITY. SUCH CRITICAL SECURITY
SUPPORT CAN APPLY WITH ME TODAY
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS CLIFF
BURKE REPRESENTING THE JEWISH
PUBLIC AFFAIRS COMMITTEE OF
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU AND WOULD
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU. THE SERVER YOU
HAVE TWO MINUTES THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR RUN- CLIFF BURKE
HERE BEHALF OF J. PACKED THE
JEWISH PUBLIC AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
R. J. PACK REPRESENTS OVER
THIRTY THREE CALIFORNIA'S
STATEWIDE. AND REGIONAL JEWISH
ORGANIZATIONS IN CALIFORNIA
NONPROFITS FROM THE JEWISH
FEDERATION OF GREATER BAY AREA
TO THE JEWISH FEDERATION OF LOS
ANGELES TO JEWISH FAMILY
SERVICES. OF SAN DIEGO LOS
ANGELES THE BILL THE BAY AREA
DAWSON. EIGHTY L. A. J. C. ARM
THE LIST GOES ON- WE'VE BEEN
VERY PLEASED TO WORK WITH THE
SELLING GABRIEL- SINCE HE
ENTERED THE LEGISLATURE AND
PRIOR TO HIS ENTRY TO THE
LEGISLATURE. TO ESTABLISH THE
NONPROFIT SECURITY GRANT PROGRAM
IN CALIFORNIA WE STARTED SLOWLY
SECURING THE FIRST YEAR ONE
MILLION DOLLARS IN THE STATE
BUDGET. INCLUDED FIFTY MILLION
DOLLARS LAST YEAR THIS YEAR THE
LEGISLATURE IS SEEN FIT TO PUT
TWENTY MILLION DOLLARS IN THERE.
J. PACK WORKS VERY CLOSELY WITH
COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS TO
ENSURE THAT THE PROGRAM REFLECTS
THE NEEDS OF THE NONPROFIT
COMMUNITY. UNFORTUNATELY WE
HAVEN'T INCREASING TIDE OF
VIOLENCE HATRED ANTI SEMITISM.
AND HATE CRIMES DIRECTED AT BOTH
THE JEWISH COMMUNITY THE LAUNDRY
WAS COMMUNITY THIS PROGRAM
BENEFITS AND SOMETHING LIKE 90%
OF THE GRANTS LAST YEAR WENT TO
NON JEWISH ORGANIZATIONS FROM
AFRICAN AMERICAN LATINO LGBT.
CHRISTIAN CHURCHES AND MUSLIM
MOSQUES BY WORKING CLOSELY WITH
OUR ORGANIZATIONS- WE HAVE
ENACTED THE PROGRAM IN STATUTE
THIS BILL UPDATE SOME OF THE
IMPORTANT NEEDS OF THE
COMMUNITY- IN TERMS OF HOW. THE
MONEY CAN BE USED. WE URGE YOUR
SO- IT'S IN EXTREMELY IMPORTANT
PROGRAM THIS TIME UNFORTUNATELY
IN OUR SOCIETY WITH THE CONSTANT
THREAT THAT WE HAVE BOTH. AIMED
AT THE JEWISH COMMUNITY MUSLIM
COMMUNITY AND ALL ETHNIC
MINORITIES THAT'S WHY THIS BILL
IN THE FUNDING HAS BEEN
SUPPORTED BY ALL THE ETHNIC
CAUCUSES IN THE LEGISLATURE URGE
YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU SIR ANYONE ELSE IN THE ROOM
IN SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
MEMBERS SOME ARE PALCO WITH
CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. MISTER
TURN MEMBERS TAYLOR JACKSON ON
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA HEALTH PLUS
ADVOCATES WE REPRESENT ALMOST
THIRTEEN HUNDRED COMMUNITY
CLINICS INCLUDING REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CENTERS IN CALIFORNIA
WE'RE HERE IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. ANYONE IN THE ROOM IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WE WILL
TRANSITION TO THE PHONES SO MR
MODERATOR QUEUE UP ITSELF FILE
ITEM THIRTEEN A. B. ELEVEN
EIGHTY FIVE BY STONE THURMOND
GABRIEL. IN AT THIS POINT
ANYBODY WANT WANTING TO TESTIFY
NAME ORGANIZATION IF YOU HAVE
ONE AND YOUR POSITION ON THE
BILL. THANK YOU AGAIN FOR AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY FIVE PLEASE PRESS
ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME AGAIN ONE
ZERO. CURRENTLY NINE Q. THANK
YOU SO MUCH APPRECIATE THAT PULL
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE. WELL
I'LL MAKE A QUICK COMMENT A SO
AGAIN I WAS IN CALIFORNIA BUT I
WAS BACK EAST- THIS WEEKEND
RELATIVES- BUT NHTSA. AND I WAS
HORRIFIED AT THE NOTICE ACUITY
WE HAD WE HAD TO GO THROUGH NO
NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO ENTER THAT
BUT A I GUESS IT'S A IT'S A
REALITY NOWADAYS. SO I THINK
THIS IS A GREAT MEASURE AND I'M
I KNOW SUPPORT SUPPORT AND YOU
MAY CLOSE. YEAH THANK YOU VERY
MUCH APPRECIATE THOSE KIND
COMMENTS IT IS- IT IS A VERY
DIFFICULT AND COMPLICATED MOMENT
I REMEMBER GROWING UP GOING TO
SYNAGOGUE THERE'S NEVER SECURITY
AND NOW. YOU KNOW ON A WEEKLY
BASIS WHEN I WALK MY KIDS INTO
THE PRESCHOOLER SYNAGOGUE WE GO
THROUGH METAL DETECTORS SO IT'S
A VERY COMPLICATED WORLD WE'RE
LIVING AND- AS- AS OUR WITNESS
MENTIONED THIS IS A PROGRAM THAT
HAS SUPPORTED- ORGANIZATIONS. AT
FOR PEOPLE FROM ALL FAITHS AND
BACKGROUNDS ACROSS CALIFORNIA
PARTIALLY SO MANY OF OUR
COMMUNITIES ARE UNDER THREAT IN
THIS IS GONNA HELP HOPEFULLY
HELP TO STRENGTHEN THAT PROGRAM
AND MAKE SURE THAT WE CAN DO
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO PROTECT
THOSE ARRESTS SO. APPRECIATE THE
SUPPORT AND WOULD RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE OKAY GREAT
THANK YOU AND WE WILL. WE WILL
APPROVE THAT ONCE WE HAVE A FULL
COMMITTEE NOW WILL MOVE ON TO
FILE ITEM FOURTEEN A. B. TWELVE
SEVENTEEN. THIS MEASURE HAS A DO
PASS TO HEALTH COMMITTEE. AND
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY. YEAH
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS ALSO PLEASE TODAY 2% AB
TWELVE SEVENTEEN WILL STILL
SUPPORT CALIFORNIA'S
RESTAURANTS. THAT HAVE BEEN
IMPACTED BY COVERT NINETEEN AND
INFLATION BY HELPING TO PRESERVE
OUTDOOR DINING ACROSS OUR STATE.
NEIGHBORHOOD RESTAURANTS ARE THE
BACKBONE OF COMMUNITIES ACROSS
CALIFORNIA CONTRIBUTING GREATLY
TO CULTURAL AFFAIRS AND THE
LOCAL ECONOMY. WHILE ALSO
SERVING AS AN ENGINE OF ECONOMIC
OPPORTUNITY AND SOCIAL MOBILITY.
OVER THE COURSE OF THE PANDEMIC
OUTDOOR DINING PROVED TO BE A
CRITICAL LINE THE LIFELINE TO
HELP STRUGGLING NEIGHBORHOOD
RESTAURANTS. IN TWENTY TWENTY
ONE THE LEGISLATURE PASSED AB
SIXTY ONE WHICH PROVIDE
RESTAURANTS WITH INITIAL
REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY DOTING
COVE IT. TO FOSTER OUTDOOR FOOD
SERVICE AND EMPOWER RESTAURANTS
TO USE THEIR OWN SPACES. FOR
INCREASED OUTDOOR DINING
CAPACITY. RESTAURANTS HAVE
SURVIVED THE PANDEMIC CONTINUE
TO STRUGGLE WITH RISING
OPERATING COSTS DUE TO
INFLATION. AS WELL AS THE ALL OF
THE CHEN JUST THAT THEY ARE
STILL. FACING AS A REAL. OF THE
PEN. IN SHORT HEALTH.
RESTAURANTS ARE STILL IN NEED OF
REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY TO HELP
THEM RECOVER FROM ECONOMIC
LOSSES ASSOCIATED WITH THE
PANDEMIC. AB TWELVE SEVENTEEN
WILL PRESERVE EXISTING
REGULATORY FLEXIBILITY RELATED
TO OUTDOOR PATIO AND ALFRESCO
DINING BY EXTENDING THE CURRENT
TEMPORARY CATERING
AUTHORIZATION. THAT ALLOWS
RESTAURANTS TO SERVE GAS AND
EXPANDED OUTDOOR DINING AREAS.
IN SO DOING THIS BILL HELPS TO
KEEP OUR BELOVED NEIGHBORHOOD
RESTAURANTS A FLOAT IN A SYSTEM
ON THE LONG ROAD BACK TO
ECONOMIC RECOVERY. THIS BILL
SUPPORTED BY A COALITION OF
SMALL BUSINESSES LOCAL
RESTAURANTS AND HOSPITALITY
COALITIONS. BUSINESS COUNCILS
AND CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE FROM
ACROSS THE STATE HERE WITH ME
TODAY IS MATTHEW SON ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU AND
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I
THINK YOU MISTER SIGN YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS MATT SUDDENLY
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
ASSOCIATION WHEN I THINK THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE- YOU'VE
SEEN THIS ISSUE BEFORE. IT'S AN
EXTENSION OF EXISTING LAW. AND
WHAT IT DOES BASICALLY IS IT
DOES TWO THINGS WE'RE TALKING
ABOUT RESTAURANT DINING SPACES
THAT ARE OUTDOORS THAT ARE NOT
NECESSARILY ON PREMISE OR
CONTIGUOUS TO THE RESTAURANT SO
AT SOME OF THESE EXPANDED AREAS.
THAT YOU HAVE IN YOUR
COMMUNITIES AND WHAT IT DOES IS
IT CREATES- IF YOU'RE PERMITTED
INSIDE THE PHYSICAL RESTAURANTS.
THIS BASICALLY ALLOWS SOME OF
THE SAME ACTIVITY IN THOSE
EXTENDED SPACES WHETHER THEY BE
PARK WHAT'S OR OTHERWISE AND
THAT INCLUDES- ALCOHOL SERVICE
AND IT ALSO INCLUDES UNLIMITED
FOOD PREPARATION SO WHAT WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT ESSENTIALLY IS
ALLOWING WHAT'S ALLOWED IN THE
RESTAURANT TO TAKE PLACE AND
SOME OF THESE NON CONTIGUOUS
SPACES. A. B. C. IS CURRENTLY
WORKING ON A REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK- TO PROVIDE FURTHER
GUIDANCE FOR THESE KINDS OF
SPACES BUT AS IT IS NOW AND AS
IT HAS BEEN FOR THE LAST FEW
YEARS. THE PROGRAM IS HIGHLY
SUCCESSFUL THERE'S ABOUT ELEVEN
THOUSAND RESTAURANTS CURRENTLY
BENEFIT FROM IT. MORE WILL BE
ABLE TO IF THIS. MOVES FORWARD
AND WITHOUT THIS EXTENSION. THE
LAW WILL EXPIRE EARLY IN TWENTY
TWENTY FOUR SO WE WOULD ASK FOR
YOUR CONTINUED SUPPORT AND WE
WOULD POINT OUT. THAT PUBLIC
SAFETY PROTOCOLS AND PROTECT SHE
AND GUARD. HAVE BEEN ADDED. TO
THIS PROGRAM OVER THE LAST FEW
YEARS AND IT REMAINS HIGHLY
SUCCESSFUL SO THANK YOU AND WE
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
ANYONE ELSE HERE IN SUPPORT.
PLEASE COME FORWARD. MISTER
CHAIR CHRISTMAS CEILIDH ON
BEHALF THE LOS ANGELES AREA
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE ALSO IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU SIR. GOOD MORNING
MELISSA HIGHS DUE ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA TRAVEL
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
THANK YOU. ANYONE IN THE ROOM IN
OPPOSITION. WELCOME THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE
MIKE SKIPPER. ON BEHALF OF
ALCOHOL JUSTICE. AS THE PUBLIC
HEALTH INTERVENTIONS. IN
RESPONSE TO KOVI. WIND DOWN SO
TOO SHOULD EXEMPTIONS TO RULES.
THAT WERE MEANT TO PROMOTE
PUBLIC SAFETY INCLUDING EXPANDED
FOOTPRINTS FOR ALCOHOL LICENSES
. THE EXPAND THE FOOTPRINTS
ALLOW BY ABC. AND THEN EXTENDED.
UNDER TEMPORARY ORDER BY THE
GOVERNOR WERE INTENDED TO ALLOW
RESTAURANTS TO OPERATE WITHOUT
FORCING CUSTOMERS TO GATHER.
INSIDE HOWEVER THEY WERE
EXTENDED WELL BEYOND AND WELL
PAST THE LOCKDOWN ORDERS. VASTLY
INCREASING THE FOOTPRINT OF
NEARLY ANY OF THE VENUES WHO ARE
INTERESTED IN DOING SO. THIS
FORM JUST ONE PART OF A
CONSTELLATION OF ALCOHOL
DEREGULATORY MEASURES THAT IT
HAD IMMEASURABLE LEAF FULL
IMPACT ON THE RESIDENTS OF OUR
STATE. CCORDING TO THE CURRENT
CDC NUMBERS ALCOHOL RELATED
RELATED DEATHS IN CALIFORNIA IN
OF ROSE FIFTEEN POINT 9% FROM
TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN TO TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY. SEVENTEEN POINT
7% FROM TWENTY TWENTY TO TWENTY
TWENTY ONE. THIS IS A STUNNING
SPIKE IN THE STATE THAT HAS
ALREADY EXPERIENCED INCREASES IN
ALCOHOL RELATED DEATHS OUT OF
PROPORTION TO POPULATION GROWTH
. THIS MORTALITY
DISPROPORTIONATELY AFFECTS YOUNG
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS. WITH MORE
THAN ONE IN FOUR DEATHS AMONG
TWENTY TO THIRTY FOUR YEAR ROLES
. DRINKING OUTDOORS DOES NOT
CAUSE THIS MORTALITY HOWEVER
INCREASING THE DENSITY OF PEOPLE
DRINKING IN ANY GIVEN AREA DOES.
EXTENDING THOSE PRIVILEGES
OUTSIDE THE CONFINES OF A
RESTAURANT CLEARLY INCREASES THE
RISK OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND
SAFETY. AND FATALITIES IN THE
STATE. WE ASK YOUR NO VOTE THANK
YOU THANK YOU SIR. NEXT SENATORS
AND ASSEMBLYMEN. FRED JONES ON
BEHALF OF MY CLIENT CALIFORNIA
ALCOHOL POLICY ALLIANCE- BOTTOM
LINE IS COBIT IS OVER. AT LEAST
AS IT RELATES TO BARS AND
RESTAURANTS ALL OF YOU IF YOU'VE
EATEN OUT RECENTLY OR GONE TO A
BAR THEY ARE BACK. THEY'RE BACK
AND NOT JUST BECAUSE OF EXTENDED
FOOT PRINTS. THE CONCERN WE HAVE
WITH THIS BILL AS MICHAEL JUST.
ALLUDED TO IS THIS IS REALLY
AIMED AT PERMANENTLY CHANGING
LAWS THAT ARE SUPPOSED TO
PROTECT COMMUNITIES AND
INDIVIDUALS. BECAUSE WHEN TWENTY
TWENTY SIX ARRIVES WHICH IS WHEN
THIS BILL WOULD SUNSET. THERE
WILL HAVE BEEN SIX YEARS OF BARS
AND RESTAURANTS INVESTING IN
THESE EXTENDED FOOT PRINTS AND
AS THE REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION JUST
TESTIFIED IF THIS BILL PASSES
THERE WILL BE MORE BARS AND
RESTAURANTS THAT TAKE ADVANTAGE
OF THIS EXTENDED FOOTPRINT. AND
INVEST MORE IN THEIR
INFRASTRUCTURE. AND SO CAN YOU
REALLY LOOK ME IN THE EYE AND
SAY THAT IN TWENTY TWENTY SIX
YOU WILL EXTEND THIS ANOTHER TWO
YEARS OR MAYBE PERMANENTLY. SO
THE QUESTION IS WHERE THE LAWS
BEFORE KOPET RESPONSIBLE OR NOT.
BECAUSE THIS BILL IS INTENDED TO
PERMANENTLY ALTER THOSE LAWS. SO
FOR THOSE REASONS WE HAVE TO
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE THANK YOU
OKAY THANK YOU SIR ANYONE ELSE
IN THE ROOM IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE WE WILL MOVE TO THE
PHONES AGAIN THIS IS FILE ITEM
FOURTEEN AB TWELVE SEVENTEEN AT
THIS POINT IS SIMPLY ME TO TEST
IT- TESTIMONY SO YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION IF YOU HAVE ONE AND
YOUR POSITION ON THE BILL.
MODERATOR THANK YOU VERY MUCH
AGAIN IT IS ONE ZERO AT THIS
TIME. PLEASE PRESS. ONE ZERO.
AND CURRENTLY NOBODY IN Q. THANK
YOU MODERATOR PULLED BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS. SEEING NONE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER YOU MAY CLOSE. YEAH JUST
. WOULD IT WOULD WOULD ADD- YOU
KNOW THIS IS I THINK SMALL
BUSINESSES ARE THE BACKBONE OF
COMMUNITIES ACROSS CALIFORNIA
NEIGHBORHOOD RESTAURANTS
CONTRIBUTE SO MUCH TO ALL OF
OUR- THE VIBRANCY OF ALL OF OUR
JURISDICTIONS THAT THESE FOLKS
ARE REALLY STRUGGLING MANY OF
THEM A MAJOR MAJOR INVESTMENTS
AND OUTDOOR DINING DURING
COVERED THEY'RE STILL TRYING TO
RECOUP THOSE INVESTMENTS. AND
EVEN THOUGH THE PANDEMIC MAYBE
OVER IN ONE SENSE. THEY'RE STILL
WORKING REALLY HARD TO COME OUT
OF THAT SITUATION WHICH WAS VERY
VERY CHALLENGING FOR THEM AND I
KNOW CHAIRMAN DON WAS A LEADER
IN TRYING TO SUPPORT- ARE SMALL
BUSINESSES AND PROVIDE FOR THE
VIBRANCY COMMUNITIES- ACROSS THE
STATE WE THINK THIS IS SOMETHING
WE'VE HEARD FROM THEM THAT THEY
DESPERATELY NEED A WEAK SHOT TO
CONTINUE TO GIVE THEM THAT.
REGULATORY FLEX ME PARTICULARLY
BECAUSE- RESTAURANTS ARE ONE OF
THE MOST DIVERSE WORK FORCES IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND REAL
ENGINES OF ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
AND SOCIAL MOBILITY SO WITH THAT
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SIR. AND
WITH THIS I RETURN THE GAVEL TO
OUR FEARLESS LEADERS TO THE-
SECTOR CALL THE ROLL ALL WE
FINALLY GET. NO NO WE DON'T HAVE
A MOTION OVER STILL NOT A QUORUM
HERE NO NO OR NOT I THOUGHT YOU
WOULD HAVE PROGRESS. SORRY NO WE
NEED WE NEED YOUR LEADERSHIP TO
MAKE THAT HAPPEN. SO WE'LL HAVE
MORE. TIME OKAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR MAKING VERY MUCH
APPRECIATED. SHE IS. THANK YOU
THE- CHAIR. I THOUGHT YOU WORKED
BACK. I AM NOT TO TWELVE. AB
ELEVEN SIXTY THREE. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER RIVAS. GOOD MORNING IN.
PLEASE FEEL FREE TO BEGIN. GOOD
MORNING MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. I
WANT TO START BY THANKING BRIAN
FOR HIS WORK AND THOUGHTFUL
ANALYSIS ON THIS BILL. I ALSO
WANT TO ACCEPT. ON THE
AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE
COMMITTEE. AB ELEVEN SIXTY THREE
TAKES. VITAL STEPS TO REDUCE
WELL BEING DISPARITIES FOR LGBT
COMMUNITIES. THIS BILL AMENDS
THE LESBIAN GAY BISEXUAL AND
TRANS GENDER DISPARITIES
REDUCTION. ACT TO REQUIRE
ADDITIONAL STATE ENTITIES TO
COLLECT VOLUNTARY. SELF
IDENTIFICATION INFORMATION
PERTAINING TO SEXUAL ORIENTATION
AND GENDER IDENTITY. IN TWENTY
FIFTEEN THE U. S. TRANSGENDER
SURVEY ISSUED THE LARGEST SURVEY
EXAMINING THE EXPERIENCES OF
TRANS GENDER PEOPLE IN THE
UNITED STATES. THE SURVEY FOUND
THAT 33% OF TRANSGENDER PEOPLE
SEEKING HEALTH CARE SERVICES.
REPORTED HAVING NEGATIVE
EXPERIENCES INCLUDING REFUSAL OF
TREATMENTS VERBAL HARASSMENT AND
PHYSICAL ASSAULT THAT ALSO
STEMMED FROM BEING MISGENDERED.
IT'S CLEAR THAT THE MISGENDERING
OF MEMBERS OF THE L. B. G. L. G.
B. T. Q. PLUS COMMUNITY HAS
PROVED PREVENTED THEM FROM
RECEIVING THE SERVICES THAT THEY
NEED TO SURVIVE AND THRIVE WITH
THIS BILL FOR THE STATE WILL
UNDERSTAND THE SCOPE AND
SEVERITY OF THE ISSUES AND THE
DANGERS FACING. THIS VULNERABLE
POPULATION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
NOW LET'S HEAR FROM MANY LEAD
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. SEE NOBODY
IN THE ROOM ANYBODY ELSE- IN
SUPPORT PLEASE COME FORWARD
THANK YOU. OBERG ON BEHALF OF
LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR A LINCOLN
LAKIS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. ANY
THOMAS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES- IN SUPPORT
. THANK YOU. ANY WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION. SEE NOTE IN THE ROOM
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO THE PHONE
LINES MODERATOR ANYBODY IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. TO- AB
ELEVEN SIXTY THREE THEY CAN
TESTIFY NOW. EIGHT ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME AGAIN IT'S. ONE ZERO.
IT WAS JUST A MOMENT HERE. WE
CAN GO FIRST TO LINE NUMBER.
THIRTY NINE. GOOD MORNING BILL-
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA MEDINA
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE ADVOCATE
DELIVERED IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
AND NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE TWENTY
NINE. HELLO THE BUBBLY.
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. CURRENTLY
NONE FURTHER IN Q. OKAY WELL
THANK YOU- BEGIN TO TURN BACK TO
OUR MEMBERS ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. SEEING NONE OBVIOUSLY
WE DON'T HAVE A CORD YET- JUST
WANTED TO SEE IF YOU ARE CLOSE
THANK YOU AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE WHEN YOU DO
VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH MEMBER
RIVAS PER SHEET YOU BEING HERE.
WE'RE LOOKING FOR ASSEMBLY
MEMBER EDUARDO GARCIA PLEASE
COME IN AND PRESENT YOUR BILL.
IN ANY MEMBERS OF THE G. O.
COMMITTEE THIS WILL BE OUR LAST
BILL. SO WE'LL BE DOING THE ROLE
. THAT THEY DON'T COME. AND THIS
IS ALL FOR NOT. IT. YEAH HAVE A
INTENDED TO FUN WITH THAT YEAH.
RIGHT.
WE'LL.
FOR THE REST OF THE TOP OF THE.
YEAH I DIDN'T RECOGNIZE.
AND. YEAH WE WILL RECORD. USA.
YEAH HE DID.
WHAT IS. FOR WHAT I. SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL DODD ALL
RIGHT HERE RIGHT HERE WILK
PRESIDENT WILL PRESENT ELDORADO
KILL OF RADICAL HERE ARCHULETA
FEAR PARTULIDAE HERE ASHLEY.
ASHLEY HERE BRADFORD BRADFORD
HERE. WE ARE DEEPLY PLEASE JONES
. JONES HERE WHEN HERE OCHO GO
FOR THE S. PORTANTINO ROTH HERE
ROTH RUBIO SIERRA WILL DO
CONSENT YEAH RIGHT. OKAY THAT'S
CAN WE CALLED- THE ON THE CAN.
THERE ARE SOME BY WILK. LIKE
THAT IT'S BEEN MOVED BY WILK THE
ROLL PLEASE GOD. I DODD I WILL
HI WILK I EL DORADO HILLS OF
RENTOKIL I ARCHULETA AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY ASHBY EYES
FOR. ADVERT I GLAZER JONES JONES
I WHEN I SHOW AGO AT THE S.
FOURTEEN. ROTH I RAF AYE RUBY
SEYARTO. NINE THE BILL NINE WILL
LEAVE THE OPEN. THEY WILL GO TO
ITEM. YES TO HIS. YOUR CENTER DO
YOU WANT TO PRESENT- ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GARCIA'S BILL POLICE. THE
NEW YORK. I GET ALL THESE
CONSULTANTS APPEAR TOLD ME WHAT
TO DO. PUT IT THERE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT MISTER
CHAIRMAN. MEMBERS I'M HAPPY TO
PRESENT- AB FORTINO THREE ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
GARCIA IT WILL ALLOW THE OFFICE
OF THE STATE FIRE MARSHAL TO
IDENTIFY MATH METHODS IT WILL
CAPTURE MORE DETAIL DATA
RELATING TO FIRES DAMAGES AND
INJURIES CAUSED BY THE MOST
DANGEROUS FIREWORKS- AND SAFE
AND SANE FIREWORKS THE BILL
ENSURES THAT THE LOCAL
NONPROFITS IN OUR COMMUNITIES
WHO ARE SELLING SAFE AND SANE
FIREWORKS ARE GIVEN FUNDS WILL
BE USED FOR PUBLIC AWARENESS
CAMPAIGNS REGARDING THE SAFE AND
RESPONSIBLE USE. OF SAFE AND
SANE FIREWORKS IN THE DANGERS
AND RISKS POSED BY THE USE OF
ILLEGAL FIREWORKS WITH ME TODAY
I HAVE JASON GONZALEZ
REPRESENTING TNT FIREWORKS.
FOLLOWING HIS TESTIMONY I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I'VE.
TWO MINUTES. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
CHASING AND SOLVERS REPRESENTING
TEAM TO FIREWORKS AS WELL AS THE
CITIES OF NORWALK IN OAK GROVE
IN STRONG SUPPORT. THIS BILL AS
PART OF A MULTI PRONGED APPROACH
A MULTI YEAR APPROACH TO TRY TO
TACKLE THE ILLEGAL FIREWORKS
AND- GIVE THE OFFICE STATE FIRE
MARSHAL AND OTHERS THE TOOLS
NECESSARY TO GO AFTER. THE
ILLEGAL FIREWORKS IN THE STATE-
PIGGY BACKING ON SAID ARCHULETA
LEGISLATION FROM LAST YEAR SO WE
APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE'S
CONTINUED SUPPORT OF THIS EFFORT
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU ANY
OTHER WHAT THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
WATER IT OR GO TO PHONE LINES-
FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION FOR A.
B. FORTINO THREE. THANK YOU
AGAIN PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME. CURRENTLY NOBODY IN
Q. I'M SORRY GIVE ME JUST A
MOMENT WE DO HAVE ONE PARTY IN
Q. THE- NEWS. I'M JUST GOING TO
GO. WITH. ALRIGHT WE'LL GO TO A
LINE NUMBER FORTY PLEASE GO
AHEAD. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS EVERY QUARTER ON THE
HAPPY PHANTOM FIREWORKS IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU AT THIS TIME
. BRING BACK TO OUR MEMBERS SAID
ARCHULETA YES- THANK YOU- CENTER
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GARCIA- LAST YEAR WE PRESENTED A
BILL THAT- FIRE MARSHAL IS
LOOKING INTO- DESTROYING. THE
ILLEGAL FIREWORKS THAT WE
OBTAINED NOW WE'RE LOOKING AT A
BROADER LOOK INTO COMMUNITIES
ALL OVER THE CITY CALIFORNIA
ESPECIALLY WHEN WE HAD FIRES
LOOK BACK INTO. THIS IS OPENING
THE DOOR TO RESEARCH DATA AND
GIVE US ALL A LOOK AT WHAT WE'RE
FACING WHEN IT COMES TO ILLEGAL
FIREWORKS I KNOW SAFE AND SANE
AND A LOT OF COMMUNITIES AS WE
APPROACH FOURTH OF JULY IT'S A
GREAT THING FOR A LOT OF THE
FUNDRAISING FOR THE BOY SCOUTS
IN VETERANS AND SO ON. BUT
THAT'S NOT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ILLEGAL
FIREWORKS AND EVENTUALLY WILL
ENHANCE THE LAWS THAT MAKE SURE
THAT WE CAN STOP THAT TYPE OF
ACTION AND I THINK- ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GARCIA FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD AND I WILL- MAKE THE
MOTION AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
YOUR IT WE'RE GOOD YES- WHAT
MAKE A MOTION. THE STATE THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR CENTER I HAVE A
QUESTION- FOR WHAT TIME SAFE AND
SAY WE TALK ABOUT. FIRE UP IN
THE AIR HERE'S WHY CULTURALLY IN
THE ASIAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY
DURING LUNAR NEW YEAR THEY
ALWAYS HAVE THOSE LITTLE RED
FIRECRACKERS. ARE THOSE PART OF
THIS AND WE TALKING ABOUT I MEAN
I'M I'M JUST. I'M JUST TRYING TO
UNDERSTAND WHAT WE'RE TALKING
ABOUT AND YOU KNOW CHILDREN
LIKES TO HAVE THOSE LITTLE
POPPERS THROUGHOUT THE- THE YEAR
AS WELL. SO WHAT WHAT WHAT KIND
OF FIREWORKS ARE WE TALKING
ABOUT. IT IS MY UNDERSTANDING
THAT THERE. SPECIFICALLY HOW
THAT'S VIEWED- THEY'RE ALSO
STATEWIDE GUIDELINES BUT ALL AT-
THE WITNESS ADDRESS THAT
DIRECTLY. THANK YOU CENTER
PRETTY AND THANK YOU SENATOR NO
WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT SAFE
AND SANE FIREWORKS THAT ARE
LIMITED TO TWELVE FEET FROM THE
GROUND SO NOT THE AERIALS THAT
YOU SEE. IN THE AIR THAT
UNFORTUNATELY WE SEE TOO TOO
FREQUENTLY SPECIALLY ROUTE FOR
THE JULY. SO YOU'RE TALKING
ABOUT JUST THOSE THAT- LET IT.
ON THE GROUND ON THE GROUND UP
TO TWELVE FEET. SO THAT ALSO
INCLUDES THE RED FIRECRACKERS
DURING THE LUNAR NEW YEAR.
THERE'S FIRE CRACKERS ARE
POPPERS IF YOU WILL BUT NOT THE-
WHAT ARE A LITTLE THERE ARE
ILLEGAL ONES THAT HAVE TOO MUCH
GUN POWDER IN ON THAT. THE SO
ARE ILLEGAL FIRECRACKERS AS WE
CALL OKAY SO YOUR TIME OF THE
THOSE OTHER ONES THAT CAN. FLY
IN THEY CAN MANIPULATE AND IT
SHOOTS OFF WE'RE NOT TALKING
ABOUT THE LITTLE FIRECRACKERS IN
THE POPPERS. NO SENATOR NOT THE
POPPERS THAT YOU CAN GET AT-
RETAIL OUTLETS THROUGHOUT THE
YEAR SOME SUMMER LEGAL
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR SAFE AND
SANE FIREWORKS YOU HAVE ABOUT A
WEEK'S PERIOD OF TIME TO SELL.
IN ANTICIPATION FOR THE JULY
PERFECT THANK YOU THANK. THE
OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE. THE
NEXT TO ME OF THE ABUSING. I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NAY BUT-
OKAY. TO CALL THE ROLL PLAY WE
HAVE A FROM CENTER ARCHER. AB
FOURTEEN THREE IF PASSED INVITE
CALL COMMITTEE GOD. I TODD I
WILL RIGHT WILK I DORADO GIL HI
OUR RUNNING GUILT I ARE CHILE.
AYE ARCHULETA AYE. ASHBY I
BRADFORD. BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER. GLAZER AYE JONES JONES
WENT. WHEN I OTOBO. AYE THE.
NUMBER ONE. SKEWS ME. WELL
THAT'S GOOD TO. OKAY NO NO AB
THIRTY EIGHT BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
LEE. LET'S DO CONSENT SINCE WE
HAVE THERE'S- THE CONSENT FIRST
OKAY SO WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO CALL
CONSENT. WHICH HAPPENS TO THIRTY
GUYS ON WHAT YOU HAVE JUST LIKE
ABSENT MEMBERS ART SHOW ABOVE
ALL. DANGER. OKAY WE'RE GOING TO
AN OPEN THE ROLE THE CONSENT
CALENDAR. ABSENT MEMBERS GLAZER
. LASER EYE- TOWBOAT. FIVE OCHO
ABOUT I PUT THE FOR THE I PO.
ROOF SEYARTO I. THERE I. THE
BILL HAS THIRTY VOTE. WILL LEAVE
THE- ROLE OPEN WILL BE OUT OF
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO. AB I DON'T
KNOW WHY YOU ME AB THIRTY EIGHT
SO MEMBER LEE. WE NEED MOTION
WILK MOST IT BECAUSE I SAID I
WOULD SO THE MOTION BY WILL PUT
CALL THE ROLL. MOTION IS TO PASS
AS- MOTION IS DEEP AS AMENDED TO
A PRO THIS IS A THIRTY EIGHT DOT
FIVE DOT I WILL I. WILK AYE
EVERADO GIL. ARCHULETA ARCHULETA
ASHBY THIS IS THIRTY EIGHT YES I
WOULD ASK THE AYE BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER. GLAZER AYE
JONES NO. JONES NO NO WHEN. A
CHOI BO. VIA FOR THE AYE
PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH AYE ROTH
AYE RUBIO SEYARTO. SEE I DON'T
KNOW. SEVEN EIGHT TO TWO.
1-522-023-4567 EIGHT EIGHT. OKAY
SO WE'LL KEEP THAT OPEN. WELL
NOW I'M MOVED TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWO AB EIGHT THIRTY FIVE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE. ARCHULETA
MOVES SECRETARY PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE. AB EIGHT THIRTY FIVE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD I THOUGHT I
WILL HI WILK AYE ELDORADO GIL HI
OF ROADKILL I ARCH AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ASHBY AYE ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD. BRADFORD AYE GLAZER
GLAZER AYE JONES JONES I'D WIN
WIN I OTOBO OCHO BOAKYE IDEA.
THE I PORTANTINO DRAFT AYE RAFT
AYE RUBIO. SEYARTO ZERO I.
THIRTEEN THE HAS THIRTY VOTE
WILL KEY THE ROLE OPEN. MOVED
OUT OF FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR A
THREE OH TWO SOME MEMBER. ARCHER
ARCHER A LOT OF PLEASE OF THE
ROLE MOTION IS PASSED TO THE
YEAR YOU COMMITTEE DODD I DODD
AYE. WILK ALL RIGHT WILK I OUR
OUR RIDERS GIL OF RADICAL I
ARCHER. AYE PART I AM AYE ASH I
. BRADFORD AYE. GLAZER JONES
JONES I WHEN I- CHOKE THE CHAU I
PUT- THE I POURED. ROTH AYE RAF
AYE RUBIO ZERO. I THIRTY VOTES
PUT THAT ON CALL. NOW MOVED FIVE
ITEM NUMBER AB SO ONE BY SEVEN
MEMBER MAN. MOTION IS DUE PASSED
TO CORPORATE THE- GOOD DODD I
DODD AYE WILK DO YOU. I WILL AYE
ALVAREZ GIL ALPHARETTA GIL I ARE
ALETTA AYE ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY.
ASHBY I BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER GLAZER JONES JOHN I WENT
WIN WHICH OBOE.
SO WHAT. IT WAS ME NOT OUR CHILL
OUT ON THAT ONE. YEAH THIS THE
SAKE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ITEM
NINE AB. TWENTY THREE. AT THE DO
LOT OF ITEM. EIGHT AND EVEN
THOUGH I HAVE THREE AND HAVE A.
HOLD A SECOND. OKAY WE'LL GO
FOLLOW OR EIGHT. FILE ITEM EIGHT
TEN THIRTEEN MOST IS DO YOU AS A
TO JUDICIAL COMMITTEE. RIGHT THE
MOTION NO WAY OUT I ALREADY FEEL
MADE IT YES DOT AYE DODD I WILL
WRITE WILK AYE ALBER AYE GIL ALL
RIGHT OKAY I LET. ARGYL I. ASHBY
I BROUGHT. BRADFORD AYE GLAZER
GLAZER AYE JONES. JONES I WHEN
I- CHIU. PHOTOBOOK I PUT THE
HEAD VIA PORN RAS- RAF I RUBIO
SEYARTO ZERO THAT'S THIRTEEN.
THIRTY VOTES WILL HOLD OPM NOW
BE TO FOLLOW ITEM NUMBER NINE AB
TWO AND THREE. BY ITSELF MEMBER
HAPPEN- BY OUR ALETTA SO PLEASE
OPEN ROLE MOTION IS PASSED
APPROPRIATE COMMITTEE DOT BY DOT
I WILL ALL RIGHT WILK I ALREADY
GET HI A BROTHER I LET. PARTIAL
I. AYE AYE BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER GLAZER AYE JONES JONES I
WENT. WHEN I- SHOBO- CHILDREN I
VIA. THE I A.
WHICH WAS MADE BY I'M GONNA MAKE
A RIGHT NOW WILK. CALL THE ROLL
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE DODD
AYE DODD AYE WILK HI WILK I EL
DORADO GILL OF ROADKILL AYE ARCH
ALETTA AYE PARTULA AYE ASHBY'S
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD. BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER GLAZER AYE JONES RIGHT
JONES I WENT WHEN I CHOI BO I BO
BO I PUT THE FOR THE I. ROTH ALL
RIGHT RAFI I RUBIO SIERRA. ERATO
I LAST YEAR- THIRTEEN. KEEP THAT
ARE CALLED WILL MOVE FILE ITEM
TWO A LOT SIXTY BY LUIS WE HAVE
A MOTION. SO WE WANT TO HAVE
EMOTIONAL THE MOVEMENT I CENTER
ROTH PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE AS YOU
AND AMENDED TO G. COMMITTEE DOT
BY DOT ALL RIGHT WILK. I GIL HI
AB RIGHT OKAY I TO LET AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ASH AYE ASH
EYEBROW. BRADFORD AYE PLEASE.
AYE GLAZER AYE CHEN. WHEN OCHO.
VIA IDEA I. ROTH I ROTH AYE
RUBIO R. TO. THE BILL HAS EIGHT
VOTES WILL PUT THAT ON. NUMBER
I'LL- ITEM NUMBER THIRTY. AB THE
BY SEVEN MEMBER K. WELCOME WILL
MOVE. PLEASE OPEN ROLE MOTION A
TO PASS THROUGH FOR COMMITTEE DA
. HI DODD I WILL. LOCAL HI WILK
I DORADO GIL HI HOWEVER GILL I
ARCHER. ARCHULETA I AM. ASHBY I
BROUGHT. BRADFORD AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE JOE. JOHN I WENT.
THAT OPEN WILL NOW MOVE TO FILE
ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN AB TWELVE
SEVENTEEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GABRIEL I DO WE HAVE A MOTION.
BOSHART A LETTER PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE. WHICH IS TO PASS A HEALTH
COMMITTEE DOT I DOT I WILL I
WILL CRY ALL RIGHT AGO RIGHT AB
RIGHT IF YOU'LL AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY AYE
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER. THESE ARE AYE JOHN JONES
I WENT. BOB WHEN I- CHILL ABOUT
HI OTOBO I HAD THE A HAVE YEAH
I'VE. ROTH- ALL RIGHT ROTH I
RUBIO SEYARTO I HERE TO ALMOST
THIRTY HOLD THAT- OPENED NOW
WILL FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN IS
FOUR THREE BITES GARCIA DO WE
HAVE A MOTION THIS MONTH YES
WHAT SHOULD OUR JULY. OKAY WHO
THE MOST. YEAH OKAY WE'RE ON
CALL SO GO AHEAD PLEASE AND IT
THIS ONE'S DO PASS TO. QUALITY
ABSENT- CHOI. THE FORTINO. THREE
FOURTEEN GARCIA YES FILE ITEM S.
ROUTE. I'M SORRY PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I RUBIO. AT THIRTEEN
THIRTEEN. YEAH I'M SORRY OKAY. I
BELIEVE THAT AS THIRD. IS A WE
EXPECTING RUBIO HERE OKAY. OKAY
SHARE THANKS FOR THE ASSISTANCE
. SO WE'RE IT'S I THINK THAT WAS
A- IT'S A.
OKAY WE'RE GONNA OPEN THE ROLE.
SO WELL LET'S START WITH THE
CONSENT OKAY. WITH THE ROLE
PLEASE CONFIGURABLE TO MEMBERS
PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO AYE RUBIO
. BILLS FOURTEEN LEAVE THAT ON
CALL. SO WE MOVED FIVE FILE ITEM
NUMBER ONE AB THIRTY EIGHT BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEE PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE OF RADICAL WHEN I SHOBO
PORTANTINO HI PORTANTINO AYE
RUBIO. NINETY THE BILL HAS NINE
WILL LEAVE THAT OPEN FOLLOW
NUMBER TWO AB THIRTY FIVE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE OPEN THE
ROLE PORTANTINO ORANGE YOU KNOW
I'D RUBIO AS FOURTEEN VOTES
LEAVE THAT OPEN. FILE ITEM
NUMBER FOUR AB THREE OH TWO.
PORTANTINO PORTANTINO AYE RUBIO
. THAT'S NOT A VOTES WILL LEAVE
THAT OPEN FOURTEEN BOTH HANDS ME
RIGHT. OKAY ITEM NUMBER SIX
SEVEN EIGHTY ONE PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE PORTANTINO PORTANTINO AYE
RUBIO THIS CORTINES THAT OPEN
FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TEN
TWENTY THREE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
PABON EIGHT YEAH MISSTATING YEAH
LET'S START WITH EIGHT IT'S GOT
THIRTEEN VOTES PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO I
RUBIO FOURTEEN ZERO. IT'S GOT
FOURTEEN PUT THAT ON CALL FILE
ITEM NUMBER NINE TWO TWENTY
THREE. PORTANTINO PORTANTINO I
RUBIO. WAS FOURTEEN. WELL NOW
MOVE TO FILE ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN.
A. B. TEN EIGHTY EIGHT OVER THE
ROLE PLEASE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I RUBIO WILLIS
FOURTEEN VOTES FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER RIVAS
SECTOR PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE.
WELL JONES WHEN A TURBO.
PORTANTINO PORTANTINO I RUBIO.
ZERO NINE VOTES WILL NOW MOVE TO
FILE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY FIVE. PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE PORTANTINO PORTANTINO I
SEE OUR- ROUTE. THE BILL HAS
FOURTEEN TO LEAVE IT OPEN WILL
NOW MOVE I'VE NEVER FOURTEEN. AB
TWELVE SEVENTEEN OVER THE ROLE
PORTANTINO PORTANTINO I RUBIO
BILLS FOURTEEN BELIEVE THAT OPEN
ONE NEW MOVE TO FILE ITEM OR
SEVENTEEN FOURTEEN OH THREE
GARCIA SECTOR PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE. A TURBO. RUBIO LOS ANGELES
THIRTEEN BELIEVE THAT. RIGHT YES
. THERE YOU.
OKAY WE'RE GONNA LEFT THE CALLS-
WE'RE GONNA START WITH CONSENT-
CALENDAR SECTOR OPEN ROLE RUBIO
HI HI FOURTEEN ZERO FIFTEEN ZERO
SORRY FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT. WILL MOVE THE FILE ITEM
NUMBER ONE AB THIRTY EIGHT BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEE PLEASE OPEN
THE WILL ROLL WHEN THE CHOKO
RUBIO HI RUBIO I. TENDED TO THE
BILL IS OUT TENDED TO. FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWO AB EIGHT THIRTY FIVE
BY SEVEN MEMBER LEE SECTOR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE RUBIO HI
RUBIO I FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS
OUT FIFTEEN ZERO. FILE ITEM
NUMBER FOUR AB THREE OH TWO BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER WARD. RUBIO FIVE
RUBIO HI FIFTEEN ZERO WAS AT
FIFTEEN FIFTY ZERO THE BILLS OUT
BY THE- THE NUMBER SIX AB
SEVENTY EIGHTY ONE PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE RUBIO HI RUBIO I
FIFTEEN BILLS OUT FIFTEEN ZERO
FOLLOWED A MEMBER NINE AB TEN
TWENTY THREE. I DID IT AGAIN.
THAT'S NUMBER EIGHT PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE. RUBIO RUBIO I FIFTEEN
ZERO FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS OUT
. FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TEN
TWENTY THREE. RUBIO HI RUBIO AYE
TÍNH ZERO FIFTEEN ZERO THAT
BILLS OUT FILE ITEM OR ELEVEN AB
TEN EIGHTY EIGHT PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE RUBIO. RUBIO I FIFTEEN ZERO
FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS OUT FILE
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE AB ELEVEN
SIXTY THREE PLEASE OVER THE ROLE
WELL. JONES WHEN ADOBO RUBIO
FIVE RUBIO ICE HERE TO. IT'S TEN
ZERO TEN ZERO THE BILL'S OUT
FILE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB
ELEVEN EIGHTY FIVE PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE RUBIO. RUBIO AYE.
FIFTEEN ZERO FIFTEEN ZERO THAT
BILL IS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER
FOURTEEN AB TWELVE SEVENTEEN
RUBIO RUBIO AYE FIFTEEN ZERO
FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS OUT.
FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN AB
FOURTEEN OH THREE PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE A TURBO RUBIO. RUBIO
AYE FOURTEEN ZERO FOURTEEN ZERO
THAT BILL IS OUT WE HAVE
CONCLUDED THE AGENDA THE SENATE
GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
COMMITTEE IS A JERK.