THIS HEALTH COMMITTEE WILL COME
TO ORDER GOOD AFTERNOON
EVERYBODY WELCOME TO MY SAID
THREE MEMBERS WHO ARE HERE ON
HEALTH COMMITTEE AND INVITE ALL
OTHER HEALTH COMMITTEE MEMBERS
TO COME ON DOWN- WE CONTINUE TO
WORK ON THE PUBLIC IN PERSON AND
VIA OUR TELECONFERENCE ARIES
ALLOWING SIX MINUTES PER PERSON
PER TESTIMONY SIDE- DON'T FEEL
OBLIGATED BUT PEOPLE WHO ARE
WISHING TO CALL IN OUR
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
877-226-8163 AND THE ACCESS CODE
IS THREE THREE ZERO EIGHT EIGHT
ZERO FIVE. AND WE'RE ALL GONNA
TAKE TESTIMONY FOR FIFTEEN
MINUTES TOTAL TODAY TODAY WE
HAVE FIFTEEN BILLS ON OUR AGENDA
EIGHT OF THOSE BILLS ARE ON
PROPOSED CONSENT THOSE ARE AB
THREE SIXTY FIVE AB FIVE FIFTY
ONE A. B. FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN
A. B. NINE SEVENTY NINE AB TEN
FIFTY SEVEN AB TWELVE EIGHTY TWO
AB THIRTEEN OH NINE. IN AB
THIRTEEN SEVENTY SIX ALL RIGHT
AND I SEE WE DO HAVE OUR FIRST
AUTHOR HERE TODAY WHAT WE DON'T
HAVE A QUORUM WE CAN BEGIN AS A-
SUB COMMITTEE. AND WHY DON'T WE
START THEN WITH. SEVEN IRWIN
WELCOME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS I AM
PLEASED TODAY TO PRESENT EIGHTY
SIX SIXTY. FOR TOO LONG
CALIFORNIA'S OF AND MISLED BY
UNCLEAR LABELS ON FOOD STORE
OFFER STORES OFFER PRODUCTS WITH
ALL SORTS OF DIFFERENT LABELS
LIKE EXPIRES UPON BEST BEFORE
ENJOYED BY CELL BY JUST TO NAME
A FEW. THESE LABELS CONSISTENTLY
MISLEAD AND CONFUSE CONSUMERS
SELL BY DATES FOR EXAMPLE ARE
MEANT TO SHOW GROCERS WANT TO
ROTATE STOCK AND THEY ARE
GENERALLY COMPLETELY MEANINGLESS
TO THE CONSUMER. THE RESULT OF
THIS CONSUMER CONFUSION IS
STAGGERING. THERE'S A STAGGERING
AMOUNT OF FOOD WASTE WITH ONE
STUDY ATTRIBUTING AS MUCH AS 20%
OF FOOD WASTE TO THESE LABELS.
THIS ULTIMATELY COST THE
CONSUMERS MONEY AT THE GROCERY
STORE AND CONTRIBUTES TO CLIMATE
CHANGE AS THE WASTED FOOD ROTS
IN LANDFILLS. OUR TEAM CONDUCTED
OUR OWN SURVEY OF FOOD DATE
LABELS AND WE FOUND SIXTEEN
DIFFERENT TYPES OF DATE LABELS
IN A SURVEY OF A HUNDRED AND
FIFTY ITEMS. OF THESE ITEMS ONLY
ABOUT 25% OF THE PRODUCTS USE
THE LABELS THAT ALIGNED WITH THE
INDUSTRIES PHONE VOLUNTARY
STANDARD. AB SIX SIXTY WOULD ADD
THIS CONFUSION IT TAKES THE
INDUSTRY'S OWN ADOPTED STANDARD
AND REQUIRES FOOD ITEMS THAT USE
DATE LABELS TO USE STANDARD
TERMS. BEST IF USED BY TO
INDICATE QUALITY DATA FOOD OR
USED BY TO INDICATE THE SAFETY
OF FOOD. I WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS
MY CONTINUED APPRECIATION TO THE
INDUSTRY FOR ENGAGING IN
PRODUCTIVE CONVERSATIONS WITH
OUR OFFICE TO FIND A PATH
FORWARD ON THIS BILL. THE
AMENDMENTS OUTLINED ON PAGE SIX
OF THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS WHICH
I. AM PRESENTING WITH THIS BILL
TODAY WILL ADD- REYES SELF WELL
YOU CAN YOU CAN READ THE
AMENDMENTS HERSELF OF. WE ARE-
WE DO HAVE THEM AND WE WILL BE
PASSED HIM OUT SINCE HER AUTHOR
AMENDMENTS. OF THE AMENDMENTS
THAT WE HAVE TAKEN WILL REMOVE
CONSIDERABLE OPPOSITION AND I AM
COMMITTED TO FURTHER AMEND THEN
SPECIFICALLY FOCUSING ON X. AND
ALCOHOL TO ADDRESS THE CONCERNS
RAISED BY STAKEHOLDERS. FOCUSED
ON THESE PROVISIONS WITH ME TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
AREN'T IN THE COLD CURRY AND
REPRESENTING. CALIFORNIANS
AGAINST WASTE AND A AND COLLINS
FOR. THE NATURAL. RESOURCES
COUNCIL. FIRST PERSON PLEASE I
HOPE THIS WILL HURT THE GIN
FIZZES RIGHT AT THE JAN AND THE
EGG. HOW. GOOD AFTERNOON SURE
THERE FOR. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON MEMBERS CYNICAL KOREAN
CALIFORNIA AGAINST WAY- WE ARE
PROUD BECAUSE BY IT IS SIX.
WHICH STREAMLINE X. RAY DATE
LEAVE FIRE. THE USE OF
CONSISTENT TERMINOLOGY NEXT TO
AN EXPIRY DATE TO INDICATE THE
QUALITY AND SAFETY OF THE FOOD
PRODUCT. AS I'M SURE YOU'RE
AWARE CONSUMERS ARE BOMBARDED
WITH ALL TYPE OF EXPIRATION DATE
LABEL FORMATS. EACH TERM CAN BE
USED TO MEAN DIFFERENT THINGS
WHEN USED BY DIFFERENT BRANDS
AND SOME EXPIRY DATES HAVE NO
PHRASE NEXT TO THE MIDDLE. A
STUDY BY REFERRED FOUND THAT
STANDARDIZING THESE LABELS IS
THE SINGLE MOST COST EFFECTIVE
WAY TO REDUCE FOOD WASTE. TWENTY
TWENTY ONE DATA ALSO SHOWS THAT
HOUSEHOLDS MAKE UP A WHOPPING
55% OF FOOD WASTE. BY FAR THE
LARGEST CATEGORY FOOD WASTE WHEN
BROKEN DOWN BY SUPPLY CHAIN
STAGE. THIS IS MORE THAN WASTE
FROM ALL OTHER SECTORS INCLUDING
RETAIL FARMS MANUFACTURING AND
FOOD SERVICE COMBINED. IN TWENTY
SEVENTEEN THE INDUSTRY'S TWO
LARGEST TRADE ASSOCIATIONS
ANNOUNCED THAT THEY WOULD
IMPLEMENT UNIFORM DATE LABELING.
USING THE RECOMMENDED TWO
PHRASES AND FOLLOWED WITH A
REPORT ENTITLED BEST IF CLEARLY
LABELED. WHICH FOUND AMERICANS
WOULD FEEL SAFER ABOUT THEIR
FOOD THROW LESS AWAY AND SAVE
MONEY WITH THESE PHRASES. THE
PROMISE LARGE SCALE ADOPTION AND
COMMITTED TO A 100%
IMPLEMENTATION BY TWENTY TWENTY.
THE LEGISLATURE ALSO CODIFIED
INDUSTRIES PROPOSED TERMINOLOGY
AS A VOLUNTARY STANDARD. HOWEVER
IF YOU RECENTLY SENT FROM YOUR
FRIDGE OR PANTRY AND SQUINTED A
LABEL YOU KNOW THAT VOLUNTARY
IMPLEMENTATION IS CLEARLY
INSUFFICIENT. FURTHER CONSUMER
EDUCATION AS TO WHAT FREEZES ON
WHICH FOODS MEANING WHAT ISN'T
POSSIBLE UNTIL WE STREAMLINED IT
LABELS. WASTED FOOD IS A
SOCIETAL ECONOMIC AND
ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS. AS A
STATE WE THROW AWAY SIX MILLION
TONS OF FOOD EVERY YEAR
RELEASING METHANE EMISSIONS TO
HAVE A CLIMATE IMPACT EIGHTY SIX
TIMES GREATER THAN CO TWO. NOT
TO MENTION THE AMOUNT OF MONEY
CONSUMERS SPEND ON FOOD THAT
NEVER GETS EATEN. AND THE COST
OF DEALING WITH THIS ACCESS
WASTE. AB SIX SIXTY SIMPLY
REQUIRES BRANDS TO USE THE
CURRENT STATE VOLUNTARY
STANDARDS WHICH ARE THE SAME
TERMS THAT THEY THEMSELVES HAVE
IDENTIFIED TO REDUCE CONSUMER
CONFUSION. AND ARE SUPPORTED BY
THE CFA FDA AND USDA. THIS SMALL
CHANGE WILL HAVE HUGE
RAMIFICATIONS AND FOR THIS
REASON WE ARE DR- THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH TAX PERSON
SPEAKING IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
CHAIR EGGMAN AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS MY NAME IS ANDREA
COLLINS WITH THE NATURAL
RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL. AND
WE SUPPORT AB SIX SIXTY BECAUSE
IT ADDRESSES A SYSTEMIC BECAUSE
OF FOOD WASTE. WITH IMPLICATIONS
FOR OUR HEALTH OUR ENVIRONMENT
AND OUR ECONOMY. TOO MANY OF US
LOOK AT A CONTAINER OF MILK SEE
THAT THE DATE HAS PASSED AND
DECIDE TO DUMP IT RATHER THAN
RISK GETTING SICK. HOWEVER THE
DATE ON MILK IS OFTEN A SELL BY
DATE THAT'S MEANT TO HELP
GROCERY STORES WITH STOCK
ROTATION. AND MANY OF THE OTHER
DATES ON FOOD OR INTENDED TO BE
AN INDICATOR OF PEAK QUALITY.
AND FOR SOME FOODS THERE SEEMS
TO BE A HIDDEN CODE ABOUT HOW
LONG A PRODUCT IS AT PEAK
QUALITY THAT A FEW PEOPLE WHO
ARE IN THE NO I UNDERSTAND. BUT
THE REST OF US ARE REALLY LEFT
CASTING ABOUT IT. AND RIGHT NOW
THERE'S NO WAY TO KNOW WHICH
STATES ARE ACTUALLY SAFETY DATES
AND COULD TELL THE CONSUMER NOT
TO EAT THE FOOD PASSED DATE.
INSTEAD CONSUMERS ARE LEFT TO
GUESS AT WHAT INFORMATION IS
INTENDED BY THE DATE ON THE
PACKAGE. AND MORE THAN 80% OF
AMERICANS REPORT TOSSING FOOD
SIMPLY BECAUSE IT'S PAST TO
DATE. INCOMPREHENSIBLE FOOD DATE
LABELS ARE A LEADING CAUSE OF
FOOD WASTE IN OUR COUNTRY. WE
NEED A CONSISTENT DATE LABEL
SYSTEM SO THAT PEOPLE STOP
TOSSING GOOD FOOD PREMATURELY.
AND ALSO SO THAT WE HAVE MORE
CLARITY ON WHICH FOODS ARE
REALLY A HEALTH CONCERN.
CONFUSION OVER THESE SO CALLED
EXPIRATION DATES IS RESPONSIBLE
FOR ABOUT 20% OF THE WASTED.
FOOD IN OUR HOMES. AND AMERICANS
SPEND THIRTEEN HUNDRED DOLLARS
ON DISCARDED FOOD EVERY YEAR.
ELIMINATING CONFUSION OVER
WHETHER FOOD IS STILL GOOD WILL
HELP KEEP SOME OF THAT MONEY IN
THE POCKETS OF CALIFORNIANS. WE
HAVE ENOUGH FOOD YET EIGHT
MILLION COP CALIFORNIANS FACE
FOOD INSECURITY. FOOD PACKAGING
DATES ARE A CHALLENGE FOR FOOD
BANKS AND FOOD PANTRIES THAT
HELP ENSURE THAT OUR SENIORS ARE
FAMILIES. AND FOLKS IN NEED OF
EMERGENCY FOOD ASSISTANCE HAVE
ENOUGH TO EAT. WHO RECEIVE FOOD
FROM PANTRIES MAY BE RELUCTANT
TO TAKE ITEMS THAT ARE NEAR OR
PAST STATE BECAUSE THEY BELIEVE
THE ITEMS ARE UNSAFE AFTER THAT
DATE. WHETHER THAT'S THE CASE OR
NOT. AND THE NEED FOR FOOD
ASSISTANCE IN OUR STATE IS A
MEANT. PUTIN SECURITY IS
DETRIMENTAL TO HEALTH AND MENTAL
HEALTH. PHYSICAL HEALTH. AND
WITHOUT COMES THAT INCLUDE
DIABETES HYPERTENSION BEHAVIORAL
CHALLENGES AND CHILDREN IN THESE
NEGATIVE RAMIFICATIONS SHOULD
MAKE ANY ATTEMPT TO IMPROVE FOOD
SECURITY A PRIORITY FOR PUBLIC
HEALTH. ADDITIONALLY PEOPLE IN
FOOD DESERTS ARE FOOD APARTHEID
REGIONS ARE LARGELY INDIGENOUS
BLACK. BUTTON IN RURAL
COMMUNITIES AND THOSE WHO ARE
DEPENDENT ON THE EMERGENCY FOOD
SYSTEM ARE PURCHASING RECEIVING
FOOD THAT'S CLOSER TO THE DATE
ON THE LABEL. MEANING THAT
THEY'RE OFTEN MORE. MORE OFTEN
PLAGUED WITH THE QUESTION AS TO
WHETHER OR NOT COST FOOD THAT'S
PAST STATE. MAKING THIS AN
EQUITY CONCERN. FURTHERMORE
LARGER PART. OF THEIR BUDGET IS
SPENT ON FOOD TO THE
CONSEQUENCES OF TOSSING OUT FOOD
MAKE A BIGGER DENT IN THEIR
HOUSEHOLD FINANCES. ENSURING
THAT ALL OF US UNDERSTAND WHEN
FOOD IS STILL GOOD TO EAT WILL
HELP ALLEVIATE PRESSURE TO PASS
THROUGH THAT COULD HAVE
NOURISHED US. DEFINING A
STANDARD FOR CONSUMER TARGETED
LABELS PROVIDES CLARITY ON WHEN
FOOD ACTUALLY POSES A SAFETY
RISK AND IT REDUCES THE
LIKELIHOOD OF DISCARDING GOOD
FOOD. FOR THESE REASONS WE ARE
PROUD TO SUPPORT THIS KEY
LEGISLATION THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH NOW IT'S TIME FOR
OTHERS WHO WANT TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL JUST NAME
AND AFFILIATION PLEASE. WHAT IS
A STELLAR BEHALF THE CITY AND
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
KNOW GO TO THOSE WHO MIGHT WANT
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
BILL. SEEING NONE- NO WILL GO TO
THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR. WITH
A- OKAY WE HAVE AN OPPOSITION.
YOU ARE IN OPPOSITION NO
REMOVING REMOVING A LOVELY. ONE
ONE REMOVE OPPOSITION PLEASE
SUPPORT. EXACTLY EXCITING. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH WE WERE WITH WELL
ACTUALLY THIS. WAS DONE FOR. JOB
ON THIS AND DENNIS ABI ONLY BE
HALF OF THE CONSUMER SUCH FOR.
THERE ARE ISSUE THAT THAT ARE.
ALL THE ANY COMING INTO THE BILL
. CLARIFYING OPT IN. OF FEDERAL
HARD. THOSE ARE ALL ISSUES THAT
THAT WE UNDERSTAND THE NEXT STOP
WILL BE AMENDED ON BEHALF OF THE
PACIFIC AGRICULTURE ASSOCIATION
AND ASSOCIATES CALIFORNIA
FARMERS. AS EGGS THEY HAVE A
PLETHORA OF STATE REQUIREMENTS
WITH THAT ACTUALLY REQUIRE THE
SELL BY DATE INCLUDING
CALIFORNIA. AND SO WITH THAT
THERE'S- A JUSTIFICATION TO KEEP
THAT SYSTEM GOING THANKS WITH
THAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND WE
REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. GOOD JOB SEND. AND
YOUR STAFF. ANYBODY ELSE WOULD
TO REMOVE ANY OPPOSITE AT THIS.
PLEASE OKAY NOW WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. WATER RAIDERS ARE
WHICH TO SPEAK IN. OR
OPPOSITION. AB. SIX SIXTY. THREE
WISHES OF POOR OR UP TO. THE
FIRST ONE THEN ZERO DOES. LET'S
START WITH THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON CAN I
PRESS DATA HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
K. PRODUCTS YOU'RE CHIN CAL.
STOP WASTING. THANK YOU THANK
YOU. THANKS CALLER PLEASE. WHY
FORTY PLEASE AHEAD. WELCOME OF
THE NATIONAL DIRECTOR ACTION
COME FROM SUPPORT THANK YOU
THANK YOU NEXT CALLER PLEASE.
ONE TWENTY EIGHT GO AHEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON STORY WITH LEGAL
VOTERS A- AND STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU TO OUR NEXT
CALLER. ONE THIRTY NINE PLEASE
GO AHEAD. THANK YOU CARE MEMBERS
MANY IS NO LEAST ON BEHALF OF
RETHINK WHY AND COME COALITION
OF. THANK YOU NEXT PLEASE.
THANKS FOR THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD
. AFTERNOON REBEKAH MARQUEZ ON
BEHALF OF IN SUPPORT. THANK NEXT
COLOR.
SURE WE HAVE NO ONE ELSE IN
TUITION SPEAK THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ALL RIGHT THAT CONCLUDES-
THE CULTURAL RETURNED BACK TO
THE DAY FOR QUESTION OR COMMENTS
OKAY WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM AT
THIS TIME I JUST LIKE TO SAY I
REALLY APPRECIATE THIS BILL I- I
AM. I AM TARGET ON ON- FUND
TURNED REDUCE FOOD WASTE AND I'M
A FOURTEEN YEAR OLD THAT IF
THERE'S ANY KIND OF DATE IT SHE
WON'T EAT ANOTHER BITE I KEEP
SAYING GET A SNIPPET BUT SMELLS
OKAY OKAY. BUT SHE SHE WON'T GO
FOR SMITH AFTER SO I IT'S GOING
TO GOAL WAY KEEPING US KEEP US
HEALTHY REDUCE FOOD WASTE AND
THINGS WORK AND UNDER FOR A-
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE SOME OF
THE THANK YOU IT I APPRECIATE
THAT AND- I TWO OF US. YOU SEE
SELL ANY TO IT IN THE TRI AND
WHEN YOU SEE SO BY DATE COULD BE
GOOD FOR MORE DAY OR COULD BE
GOOD FOR ANOTHER TWO MONTHS SO.
I THINK THIS IS A REALLY
IMPORTANT BILL AND WE WILL
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH. THAT HAVE
CONCERNS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
GET THIS THROUGH THE AG
COMMITTEE SOAP THANK YOU VERY
MUCH AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NIVEAU THANK YOU- I DON'T THINK
YOU HAVE ANOTHER ONE BEFORE US
TODAY DO. I THOUGHT IT WAS GONNA
SEND YOU RIGHT COULD READ. TO
OKAY BUT I DO SEE BEST GIPSON
HERE. MISTER GIBSON THIS ON A B.
SEVEN SEVEN. TALKING ABOUT
PARAMEDICINE WELCOME. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH DR ED MINUTES THE
COMMITTEE. THANK YOU FOR
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT. AB
SEVENTY SEVEN. WHICH AIMS TO
AUTHORIZE LOCAL EMERGENCY
MEDICAL SERVICE. TO A PRO. TO
PROVIDE A COMMUNITY. SIR I WANT
TO THANK THE CA TO WORK WITH
MICE- WITH. AND THROUGH
AMENDMENTS WILL BE THE AMEND-
JUST. COMMUNITY PARAMEDICINE
ALLOW SPECIFICALLY TRAINED
UNDERSCORE TRAINED. MEDICINES
OUR PARAMEDICS TO PERFORM DUTY
OUTSIDE THEIR TO. ROLES TO
ENHANCE ACCESS TO CARE- A. B.
SEVEN SIX SEVEN CONTINUES TO
GIVE LOCAL AGENCIES THE
AUTHORITY TO DEVELOP THESE
PROGRAMS THAT REQUIRE THE STATE.
TO AUTHORIZE AND TO DEVELOP A
MINIMUMS MEDIC THE MINIMUM
MEDICAL STANDARDS. IT IS A
THOUGHTFUL AND BALANCED
APPROACH. THAT GIVES LOCAL
AGENCIES THE FLEXIBILITY WHILE
ENSURING. A HIGH STANDARD OF
CARE TO BE MET THROUGH EACH AND
EVERY PROGRAMS STUDY COMPLETED
BY- A STUDY COMPLETED AFTER THE
FIRST PILOT PROGRAM CONDUCTED BY
UC SAN FRANCISCO- SHOWS THAT
COMMUNITY PARAMEDICINE PROGRAM
RESULTED IN AN OVERWHELMING.
POSITIVE OUTCOME. FOR EXAMPLE
TAX ASSESSMENTS OF THE OF NINE
THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED EIGHTY TWO
PATIENTS ENROLLED IN VARIOUS
PROGRAMS FOUND THAT OVER OVERALL
IMPROVEMENT OF PATIENTS WELL
BEING NO ADVERSE HEALTH
OUTCOMES- NO DISPLACEMENT OF
OTHER HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS
AND IN MOST CASES SAVING FOR
SAVING FOR BOTH HOSPITALS AND
HEALTH. PLANS RESOURCES IN
ADDITION THE PROGRAM- FROM
FREQUENT EMTS USERS CASE
MANAGERS AND INTERVENTION
RESULTED IN NINE ONE ONE CALLS
REDUCED LOAD UP FOR
TRANSPORTATION HOSPICE SUPPORT
PROGRAMS REDUCE THE OVERALL
NUMBER ONE CALLS VOLUMES FOR
TRANSPORTATION- TO EMERGENCY
DEPARTMENTS FOR PATIENTS FROM
80% TO THE 28% ALTERNATIVE
DESTINATION PROGRAMS ALSO
PROVIDE SUCCESSFUL IN DIVERTING
AND NON EMERGENCY PATIENTS. FROM
THE EMERGENCY ROOM TO MORE
APPROPRIATE FACILITIES AMONG THE
POST. DISCHARGE- FOLLOW UP-
GRAHAM'S HAAS OR ME HOW- READ
WITH AND DAY DOES. DEEP IN FROM
EIGHT OF THE TEN OPPORTUNE.
AREAS SO PUT THIS IS THE
CHANGER- WE HAVE A LOT OF
STAKEHOLDERS WHO SUPPORT THIS
PROGRAM I THINK THE STUDY WILL
BEAR OUT THIS PROGRAM- IF
IMPLEMENTED- WIDER- SAVE LIVES
SAVE MONEY AND DO THE RIGHT
THING IN OUR DAY AND AGE WITH ME
TO PROVIDE SUPPORTING
TESTIMONIES OUR REPRESENTATIVES-
ONE FROM THE PROFESSIONAL
FIREFIGHTERS AND THE OTHER FROM
CALIFORNIA EMERGENCY POSITIONS
THEY WILL BOLT SELF INTRODUCE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FIRST
PERSONS AS- THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS TO MADDEN
REPRESENT THE CALIFORNIA CHAPTER
OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF
EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS WERE A CO
SPONSOR OF AB SEVEN SIX SEVEN
ONE THANK MISTER GIPSON FROZE
EFFORTS OVER THE YEARS. HAS
MISTER GIPSON GIPSON MENTIONED
THERE ARE SEVERAL INNOVATIVE
COMMUNITY PARAMEDICINE PROGRAMS
CURRENTLY BEING OPERATED
THROUGHOUT THE STATE TESTING OUT
THE IDEA OF USING PARAMEDICS AN
EXPANDED ROLE THESE PROGRAMS IS
MISTER GIBSON IS NOTED A SHOWED
PROMISING RESULTS TO DATE. WITH
THE REGULATIONS FOR COMMITTEE
PERMISSIVE PROGRAMS ONLY
BECOMING EFFECTIVE IN NOVEMBER
LAST YEAR NO NEW PROGRAMS HAVE
BEEN ESTABLISHED WE BELIEVE
EXTENDING THE SUNSET TO ALLOW
FOR NEW PROGRAMS TO BE SET UP
AND PURSUED WILL PROVIDE A
BETTER PICTURE OF THE BENEFITS
OF COMMUNITY PARAMEDICINE ON OUR
HEALTH CARE SYSTEM FOR THESE
REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY ASK
RIVAL. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANKS PERSON SPEAKING IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU MEADOW CHAIR
AND SENATORS DUCKS ARE WE HAVE
THE CALIFORNIA. FOR WHICH WOULD
LIKE THANK US AND MEMBER GETS.
FOR BRINGING THIS MATTER FORWARD
AND DON'T WANT TO BE REDUNDANT
OF MR MADNESS THEN THE AUTHOR SO
WE WOULD JUST SAY THAT THIS
ALLOW WILL ALLOW LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS TO LEVERAGE
TRUSTED COMMUNITY RESOURCES AND
FIREFIGHTER PARAMEDICS TO
DELIVER. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES TO
COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND FILL GAPS
IN CARE AS MR GIBSON SAID IT
DOESN'T REPLACE OTHER WORK FORCE
BUT HELP FILLS GAPS IN CONNECTS
BEEN A PATIENT CENTERED APPROACH
TO THAT HAPPY HEALTH CONNECTS
PATIENTS. WITH THE RIGHT CARE AT
THE RIGHT TIME I THINK- AS MANY
OF YOU KNOW ON A LIKELY HEAR
FROM US ARE CHALLENGES IN THE
PRE HOSPITAL EMS SYSTEM WITH
REGARD TO AMBULANCE PATIENT
OFFLOAD TIME. AND OTHER
STRESSORS AND WE THINK THIS IS
ONE- TOOL- PART OF THE SOLUTION
WHILE CONNECTING PATIENTS WITH
THE RIGHT CARE AT THE RIGHT TIME
TO ALLEVIATE THE BURDEN ON SOME
OF THE SYSTEM SO FOR THOSE
REASONS ARE PERFECT. CREATE YOUR
CONSIDERATION I'VE A THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYBODY ELSE
BECAUSE SUPPORT NOW JUST THE
TIME FOR NAME AN AFFILIATE. GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS COUNTY DELGADO BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA EMERGENCY NURSES
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR
MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE. MARC
WITH THE CAL. MET ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON RYAN SUES ON BEHALF OF
LEADING EDGE CALIFORNIANS
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
ANYBODY SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL TODAY. THAT WOULD BE
THE TIME TO COME FORWARD. SEEING
NONE. ANYBODY WILLING TO REMOVE
ANYTHING. OKAY WE'LL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. MODERATOR THERE ANY
CALLERS IN THE QUEUE SPEAKING IN
SUPPORT. OR OPPOSITION TO AB
SEVEN SIXTY SEVEN. THANK YOU. IT
HE WISH TO SPEAK SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO AT THIS TIME. THE MANAGER
HAVE KNOWING KING UP TO SPEAK AT
THIS TIME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
NUMBER THE TIME TO BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS THEY MAY
HAVE. OKAY WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM AT THIS TIME MISTER
GIBSON BUT I ALSO WANT TO THANK
YOU FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD
THIS IS A I THINK IMPORTANT
PIECE OF LEGISLATION I KNOW
YOU'VE BEEN A LEADER IN THIS
SPACE- I HAD THE- ILL FORTUNE OF
SPENDING MOST OF LAST NIGHT IN
THE EMERGENCY ROOM AT OUR LOCAL
HOSPITAL. AND I WILL SAY- AND WE
DIDN'T HAVE TO EXPERIENCE TOO
LONG WAIT TIME TO MY FIREFIGHTER
FRIEND. BUT I COULD I COULD WITH
MY TRAIN DIES FOR UNTRAINED EYES
COULD VISUALLY SEE THERE'S A LOT
OF FOLKS FILLING UP AND HE ARE
THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT. WHO
THERE WERE A LOT MORE SERVICES
THAT COULD BE PROVIDED FOR THEM
I THINK IN A MORE COST EFFECTIVE
MANNER SO WHATEVER WE CAN DO TO
RELIEVE THE PRESSURES ON OUR
HOSPITAL EMERGENCY DEPARTMENTS I
THINK. IS INCUMBENT UPON US TO
DO WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE AND
WE WILL APPROVE THIS BILL WHEN
THERE'S A QUORUM PRESENT I THANK
YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS AND JUST
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHAT I BOTH
APPROPRIATE TIME THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU THANK YOU. OKAY
WE HAVE I SEE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CALDERON HERE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OF PRESENTING AB NINE ZERO
FOUR. DEALING WITH DELICIOUS
WHICH. I DID NOT USE LAST NIGHT
. I'M GLAD YOU'RE OKAY. AND IT.
GOOD AFTERNOON GOOD AFTERNOON
CHAIRMAN. I WANT. BEGIN BY
THINKING THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
WORKING. MY STAFF ON. AMENDMENTS
FOR THIS BILL AND I WILL BE
ACCEPTING ALL THE COMMITTEES
AMENDMENTS. ASSEMBLY BILL NINE
OH FOUR REQUIRES PRIVATE HEALTH
CARE PLANS TO DEVELOP A
MATERNAL. AND INFANT HEALTH
EQUITY PROGRAM BY JANUARY TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE. THIS PROGRAM AIMS
TO REDUCE RACIAL INEQUITIES. AND
BIRTHING OUTCOMES THROUGH THE
USE OF TO LESS. CALIFORNIA FACES
STARK RACIAL DISPARITIES IN
BIRTH OUTCOMES. BLACK INDIGENOUS
AND PEOPLE OF COLOR ARE MORE
LIKELY TO DIE OF PREGNANCY OR
BIRTH RELATED COMPLICATIONS.
RESEARCH SHOWS THAT DILUTES
SERVICES CAN PREVENT NEGATIVE
BIRTH OUTCOMES. LIKE PRETERM
BIRTHS. AND CAESAREAN SECTIONS
BY PROVIDING SUPPORT THROUGHOUT
PREGNANCY AND CHILDBIRTH. THE
MEDICARE PROGRAM STARTED
COVERING TO LIVE BENEFITS ON
JANUARY FIRST TWENTY TWENTY
THREE HOWEVER THEY ARE NOT YET
COVERED BY PRIVATE HEALTH PLANS.
SOME COMMERCIAL HEALTH PLANS
LIKE BLUE SHIELD OF CALIFORNIA
AND HEALTH NET HAVE SPONSORED
TULIP PILOT PROGRAMS THROUGHOUT
THE STATE WITH PARTICIPANTS
REPORTING POSITIVE HEALTH
OUTCOMES. AB NINE OH FOUR WOULD
MAKE CALIFORNIA ONE OF THE FIRST
STATES TO EXPAND ACCESS TO DO
ELIZABETH. FOR PEOPLE INSURED
THROUGH PRIVATE HEALTH PLANS.
THANK YOU CAN'T. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. OTHER PEOPLE SPEAKING
SUPPORT TODAY. OF AB NINE OH
FOUR I DON'T HAVE ANY WITNESS
QUITE KNOW WHAT WAS IN SUPPORT
OKAY ALL RIGHT GOOD YOU CAN TAKE
IT ON YOURSELF I LIKE THAT I DO
SEE SOMEBODY APPROACHING THE
MIKE. THROWN A SISTER LIFELINE
GOING REALLY BE MUCH HEALTH OF
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH ANYBODY ELSE SPEAKING
IN SUPPORT OF THIS TIME. MAHLER
OF SIMPLY IMPAIR OUT OF PHILLY
CAL PART THANK YOU MUCH. HERE IN
START SPEAKING UP OF NAY
APPROACH CALIFORNIA AND THE
CALIFORNIA HOMES. AND SUPPORT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR
AND SENATORS MICHELLE TREMBLE
FORK WITH THE CALIFORNIA
COMMISSION ON THE STATUS WOMEN
AND GIRLS IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANKS TO SEE MICHELLE ALL RIGHT
HUBRISTIC IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
BILL TODAY. NOW WOULD BE THE
TIME TO COME FORWARD. WHEN
EXPRESS YOUR SUPPORT FOR YOUR
OPPOSITION OKAY GOING TO THE
PHONE LINES MODERATOR THERE ANY
CALLS ON THE LINE. WE HAVE SOME
ON THE LINE FOR AB. NINE ZERO
FOUR. MODERATOR THANK YOU ENTER
. AND IF HE WISHES IN SUPPORTER
. AB NINE OH FOUR PRESS ONE ZERO
AT THIS TIME WE'LL START WITH
LINE THIRTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD
. GOOD AFTERNOON THIS IS FOND
POOL WITH CONSIDER ON LAW AND
POVERTY IN. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
NEXT CALLER. PINE PLEASE GO.
GOOD AFTERNOON WELCOME DOLLARS
WHAT THE NOW ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL CALIFORNIA. INSTANCE FOR.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANKS
CALLER PLEASE. I FIND TWO PLEASE
AHEAD. THE LOCAL KILLER THANK
YOU ALIANT FOR. THANK YOU THANKS
CALLER PLEASE. HERE WE HAVE NO
IN ELSE IN KEY WISHES. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH NOW BRING IT TO THE-
ANYBODY HAS ANY QUESTIONS OR
CALL. NO OKAY I THINK A THE GIRL
GREEN. ME FEDERAL A REAL WITH
THAT IS IN TRYING TO FOR WAYS TO
BE ABLE TO HIM WITH. SERVICES SO
THAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. HI
YES- I JUST WANNA THANK YOU
COMMITTEE SO. FOR HELPING THIS
THROUGH THIS BILL AND I WAS ASK
AN IPHONE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MIDDLE CALL. IN THE. ALL RIGHT
WE'LL TAKE OUT OF WHEN WE GET A
CORE THINKING SENATOR VERY.
RIGHT NOW WE'RE LOOKING AUTHOR
AS WELL AS HELL COMMITTEE MAY.
THE COULD.
WHAT WOULD BE THE- LAST GET THE
FIVE MEN AGO SHORTAGE NO ONE AT
ALL OF THE BILLS WILL HELP MAKE
A CRUCIAL.
SOME JACKSON WELCOME. YOU'RE
HERE TO PRESENT TODAY AB. TEN
SEVENTY NINE. COULD WE HAVE A
SOCIAL WORKER PRESENT TO OTHERS
ARE NOW I LOST ONE- THREE WE
TOOK IS BY ALL RIGHT NOW GO
AHEAD- MY MADAM A COMMITTEE. LET
ME START BY STATE THAT I WILL
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEES MMN AND
THINK THE CHAIR. COMMITTEES FOR
OVER TO CONTAIN TO- TWO AND THIS
MEASURE- A TWO SEVENTEEN SIX TWO
CA. A HATE ENTERED PRO WITH THE
CAL DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
TO RESEARCH COME INTERVIEW IN
CONJUNCTION WITH THE IN ORGANISE
IN COMMUNITY MOST BY CRIMES THE
BILL ALSO THE CAL SO RIGHTS
DEPART TO CREATE AN CARE OUT
STATE WIDE MEDIA CAMPAIGN TO
DISCOVER DISCRIMINATE. AGAINST
INDIVIDUALS OR GROUPS BASED ON
IMMUTABLE CHARACTERISTICS WE ALL
REMEMBER THE VARIOUS COMMERCIALS
THAT WE'VE GROWN UP IN ONLY YOU
CAN PREVENT FOREST FIRES THIS IS
YOUR BRAIN THIS IS YOUR BRAIN ON
DRUGS AWRY AND LOVE MEANS LOVE
LOVE IS LOVE. WE MUST MAKE SURE
THAT WE GO ON THE OFFENSE WHEN
IT COMES TO ANTI RACISM ANTI
HATE AND ANTI XENOPHOBIA. IN
TWENTY TWENTY ONE CALIFORNIA SAW
A WHOLE HORRIFIC SURGE IN HATE
CRIMES REACHING NUMBERS AND SEEN
SINCE THE AFTERMATH OF NINE
ELEVEN. IN TWENTY TWENTY ONE
THERE WERE ONE THOUSAND SEVEN
HUNDRED AND SIXTY THREE BY A C.
VANCE A THIRTY TWO POINT 6%
INCREASE FROM TWENTY TWENTY. THE
HIGHEST NUMBER REPORTED SINCE
TWO THOUSAND AND ONE. ANTI BLAKE
ANTI BLACK HATE CRIMES THE MOST
FREQUENT OF ALL HATE CRIMES BOTH
NOW AND EVEN SINCE WE EVER BEGAN
TO TRACK THESE NUMBERS IN
NINETEEN NINETY ONE. THAT EVEN
INCREASED BY TWELVE POINT 5%
ANTI AP I HATE CRIMES EVEN
SKYROCKETED BY ONE HUNDRED AND
SEVENTY SEVEN POINT FIVE
PERCENT. HATE CRIMES MOTIVATED
BY SEXUAL ORIENTATION ROSE BY
NEARLY FIFTY PERCENT. AND ANTI
SEMITIC BY YOU SEE VANCE.
INCREASED BY THIRTY TWO POINT
TWO PERCENT. ALONGSIDE HISTORIC
INCREASES IN HATE CRIMES. THE
AND HATE VIOLENCE WHITE
SUPREMACIST PROPAGANDA
DISTRIBUTION INCIDENTS AND
EVENTS TO REACH. ALL TIME HIGHS
IN THE UNITED STATES IN TWENTY
TWENTY ONE. IN FACT- IT IS HARD
TO BELIEVE THAT CALIFORNIA HAD
THE SIXTH MOST INCIDENTS. OF
WHITE SUPREMACIST PROPAGANDA
DISTRIBUTION IN THE COUNTRY
NEARLY DOUBLING AND TWENTY
TWENTY ONE. CALIFORNIA WAS
SECOND IN THE COUNTRY. AND WHITE
SUPREMACY VANCE AND THIRD IN
INCIDENTS OF WHITE SUPREMACIST
PROPAGANDA DISTRIBUTION ON
COLLEGE UNIVERSITY AND K.
THROUGH TWELVE SCHOOL CAMPUSES.
WHILE THERE ARE SERIOUS EFFORTS
TO COMBAT HATE CRIMES THROUGH
THE PARK- CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE. WE MUST DOUBLE DOWN
ON THE FACT THAT RACISM IS A
PUBLIC HEALTH CRISIS THEREFORE
WE MUST ALSO ADDRESS IT FROM A
PUBLIC HEALTH LENS. JOINING ME
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS
THERESA- GERMANIC THE END FROM
REGIONAL DIRECTOR OF THE ANTI
DEFAMATION LEAGUE CENTER CENTRAL
PACIFIC REGION. WELCOME THANK
YOU- GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR EGGMAN
AND FACED HERE NEWMAN AND
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE HEALTH
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS ADDRESS I
CAN I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
ANTI DEFAMATION LEAGUE FIRST
SAID LIKE TO THINK ASSEMBLY
MEMBER JACKSON FOR SPONSORING
THIS VERY IMPORTANT BILL.
FOUNDED IN NINETEEN THIRTEEN ADL
IS A LEADING ANTI HATE AND CIVIL
RIGHTS ORGANIZATION WHOSE
MISSION IS TO STOP THE
DEFAMATION OF THE JEWISH PEOPLE.
AND SECURE JUSTICE AND FAIR
TREATMENT FOR ALL ADL IS A
LEADING ADVOCATE ON HATE CRIME
LEGISLATION THAT HATE CRIME
PREVENTION. WE KNOW THAT HATE
CRIMES ARE MESSAGE CRIMES THEY
ARE UNIQUELY DEVASTATING AND
HARMFUL AS WELL AS DEEPLY
PERSONAL BOTH TO THE TARGETED
INDIVIDUAL. AS WELL AS TO THE
ENTIRE COMMUNITY WHO SHARES THAT
INDIVIDUALS PROTECTED
CHARACTERISTICS. WE KNOW FROM
EXPERIENCE THAT THE CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SYSTEM AND PENALTY
ENHANCEMENTS ARE ABOUT ONE
SINGULAR TOOL IN COMBATTING BIAS
MOTIVATED CONDUCT. TRUE IMPACT
AND LASTING CHANGE REQUIRE A
HOLISTIC MULTIPRONGED COMMUNITY
AND IMPORTANTLY VICTIM CENTERED
APPROACH. THIS IS WHY ADL IS
PROUD TO SPONSOR AB TEN SEVENTY
NINE WHICH WOULD ESTABLISH A
HATE CRIMES INTERVENTION UNIT TO
DEVELOP RESEARCH BASED
STRATEGIES TO ADDRESS HATE AND
CREATE THE CALIFORNIA OUT
COUNCIL TO DEVELOP A MEDIA
CAMPAIGN ADVOCATING AGAINST BIAS
DISCRIMINATION AND HATE. AB TEN
SEVENTY NINE RECOGNIZES HATE NOT
ONLY AS A PUBLIC SAFETY ISSUE
BUT ALSO AS A PUBLIC HEALTH
ISSUE AND A PUBLIC HEALTH CRISIS
BECAUSE HATE AND BIAS CAN DENY
ACCESS TO RESOURCES. CERTAINLY
INCREASED STRESS AND ANXIETY AND
ALL OVER ALL IMPACT QUALITY OF
LIFE FOR INDIVIDUALS AND
COMMUNITIES. THIS APPROACH
PRIORITIZES EDUCATION COMMUNITY
BUILDING AND VICTIM SUPPORT.
ALTHOUGH CALIFORNIA HOME TO MANY
DIVERSE COMMUNITIES THE TRUE
IMPACT AND SCOPE OF HATE IN THE
GOLDEN STATE IS OFTEN
UNDERESTIMATED ACCORDING TO
NEWLY RELEASED FBI AYE DADDY
DATA IN TWENTY TWENTY ONE
REPORTED HATE CRIME INCIDENTS
ACROSS OUR COUNTRY INCREASED. TO
TEN THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND
FORTY INCIDENTS. THAT IS THE
HIGHEST LEVEL RECORDED IN MORE
THAN TWO DECADES IN CALIFORNIA
AND OUR OWN STATE WE THOUGHT
IT'S 33% INCREASE IN REPORTED
HATE INCIDENTS AND THAT IS THE
HIGHEST SINCE TWO SINCE TWO
THOUSAND AND ONE. HATE CRIMES
INTERVENTION UNIT AND PUBLIC
AWARENESS CAMPAIGN WOULD DEVELOP
A HOLISTIC COMMUNITY BASED
APPROACH TO ADDRESSING THIS
TROUBLING RISE OF HATE IN THE
GOLDEN STATE. WE URGE YOU TO
SUPPORT AB TEN SEVENTY NINE AND
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
TIME TODAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND WILL SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
THIS BILL TODAY. JUST OTHER
PEOPLE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
GENERAL SUPPORT NOW WOULD BE THE
TIME TO COME FORWARD. OKAY SEE
NONE OUR TO MOVE TO ANYBODY
WANTING TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
TO THIS BILL TODAY. GREG HERE
WITH THE ARK AND UNITED TERRIBLE
POLITY CALIFORNIA A
COLLABORATION- WE'RE SUPPORTING
AMENDED AND WE THANKED OUR
CONTRACT PERSONALLY ON THE AND
IMPORTANT BUILT. THE. WE SIT
COMPLETELY SO THE- FOR THE PRICE
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES PEOPLE
WHO AFFECT OF HATE CRIMES
RESEARCH SHOWS. THAT PEOPLE. WHO
ARE VICTIMS BECAUSE OF HE CRY.
SERVER WORSE AND LET TRAUMA THE
PEOPLE WHO WHO ARE VICTIMS OF I
DO. CRIMES COMMITTED FOR OTHER
REASONS AND THIS THING THEY NEED
THIS KIND OF SUPPORT WE- MUCH
ALSO SUPPORT THE- OF THE AD
CAMPAIGN. A PORTION OF THE OF
THE BILL. I PROBLEM IS AS THE
BILL AS AS DRAFTED. BELIEVED
OPEN FOR. USING A FOR THAT WILL
- X. IN THE- ADDS THIS IT. IT I
DESERVE HERE WE KNOW NOT THE BUT
IS THE LANGUAGE OF THE BILL
WE'VE BEEN SOME GOOD. WITH OUR
JACKSON MINISTER WITH NARROW THE
DIFFERENCE- WE NOW AGREE WITH
HIM. THAT THE- THE BASELINE. FOR
ALLOCATING THE PERCENTAGE OF.
SHOULD BE THIS DOJ. BECAUSE THEY
ARE THE MOST TIME. FIGURES OF
THE THEY WILL REFLECT- SPIKES
THAT THAT SHOULD ADDRESSED IN PM
THE ONE TO THE IS THAT THE SPLIT
. BUDGET FIGURES EPIC. CRIMES
ARE USELESS BECAUSE THEY PEOPLE
DO NOT READ THEM TO THOSE TO THE
POLICE AND THE POLICE TO NOT TO
COME. SO IF LOOK AT THE IF YOU
BELIEVE THE OFFICIAL. ARE
VIRTUAL NO AND DISABILITY HATE
CRIME KILLED WE WHICH WE KNOW IS
QUITE HOLES. TO
THIS. IS WORK AND WE'LL THE BILL
GOES OUT TODAY SO WE CAN
CONTINUE TO WORK ON IT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH ANYBODY ELSE
SPEAKING. IN OPPOSITION. ISHE
GREAT. OKAY OKAY. OKAY SEE NO
GOOD THE PHONE LINES ANYBODY
SPEAKING SUPPORT AND OR
OPPOSITION TO A. B. TEN SEVENTY
NINE. THANK YOU. ORDER
OPPOSITION PRESS ONE AND ZERO.
FOUR GOT A LINE THIRTY PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON PROBLEM
ANNOUNCED INVESTIGATION OF THE
WORK FOR OUR CHAPTER IN THE PARK
THANK YOU THANKS CALLER PLEASE.
BLIND FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. ON
BEHALF OF THE FACULTY FIFTY AND
THE CAL. ACADEMY AND CAL
COLLECTED BY KIND REPORT YEAH
THANK YOU FOR CALLING. THREE THE
MANAGER HAVE NO ONE ELSE IN
SPEED OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
BE THE TIME TO BRING THIS BACK
TO THE DIANCIE REYES NAY
QUESTIONS OR- OKAY SO-
UNDERSERVED IS REALLY
INTERESTING THAT TAKING A THINK
UPON AD MAKES YOU'RE RIGHT IT'S
THEIR ATTACKS IN. INDIVIDUAL AN
ANGER JUST KIND OF BUBBLING UP
LIKE WHY FIRES OF. AND I THINK
OF THOSE KIDS CAMPAIGN A LEAST
HELP AND COULD TO SOMEWHERE- AND
I THINK I JUST WANNA MAKE THE-
THAT WE HAVE. ON OUR KEEP LOSING
ONE BUT ONE TO THREE FOUR M. AS
DOUBLE ZERO WOULD BECOME AS YOU
BECOME AS- ABOUT. COULD YOU TO
CLOSE IT WAS MORE AND WORKING ON
IT IT'S BEEN A AND I TO WORK ON
A BILL SUCH AS THIS AND. OF
COURSE THE WE'VE HAD A
HEIGHTENED SENSE OF BIG MY WORK
IN ANTI RACES AFTER MURDER OF
FLOOR- AND DOING QUIRKY
RIVERSIDE COUNTY- BUT IS ALSO OF
THE PRIVILEGE OF ONE OF THE
PRIVILEGES OF MY LIFETIME TO BE
TO WORK WITH A AS A SUCH AS THE
ANTI DE. LEAGUE TO MAKE THAT WE
THIS MY- I IN HIS AT THAT CALL A
NEW CHEN- TO DO AS PART- IN
ADDRESS ANTI HATE- XENOPHOBIA-
AND- THE ENTIRE RACES. SO I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU WILL
FULL DO THAT AS SOON AS WE GET A
CALL AND AGAIN. CALLING HEALTH
COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO ON DOWN
THANK YOU CHECKS. ASSEMBLY
SANTIAGO. THE NEW HEAR ON AB
FOR. EIGHTIES WELCOME. I THINK
YOU MENTIONED. IN THE INTEREST I
WILL BE IN A FOR THE WHAT. TO
PER. THEM PRESENT AT BEFORE- IT
SEVEN WERE IS STEP. THE TGI
REENTRY FOR THIS FUND UPON A-
REGRET WOULD PROVIDE GRANTS TO
INTERPRET. IT WILL THE- OF. WHO
THE PEOPLE WHO FACED RELEASED
ACROSS AFTER WITNESS FOR ME SELF
. AND- TESTIFIED THANK YOU MUCH
FIRST PERSON PLEASE. THERE AND
STAFF MY NAME IS TO K. PROGRAM.
OF THE READING PRO WITH THE TO A
COLLEGE. THAT PROVIDE COMP.
SUPPORTIVE AND DIRECTS TO OUR
TEACHER PLANS A VERY AND IT'S A
SIX P. I AM THE COORDINATOR OF
FIBROUS TO PRO. THAT ARE WITH
THOSE WHO CAR IN PRINCE.
IMMIGRATION DUE TO COUNTY JAILS
AND. WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT FOR
THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN AFFECTED BY
WAR ON DRUGS THE GOAL OF THESE
PROGRAM IS TO PROVIDE INTENSIVE
CASE MANAGEMENT IN PREVENTING
RECIDIVISM THAT TRANSLATES INTO
COALITION IS WORKING WITH
TRANSIT THE UP TRENDS CALIFORNIA
COUNCIL CANDOR VARIANTEN
INTERSEX POLICY ALLIANCE HE T.
PA. AND ASSEMBLY MEMBER MIGUEL
SANTIAGO WE ARE ASKING TO
ESTABLISH THE TRANSGENDER GENDER
VARIANT INTERSEX WELLNESS
REENTRY PROGRAM AND BE
APPROPRIATED FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS THAT WILL HELP OUR TGI
PEOPLE EXITING FROM CALIFORNIA
STATE PRISON. HAVE BEEN A
CULTURALLY UNDERSTANDING GUIDE
IN RE ENTRY PROGRAMMING CAN HELP
TGI PEOPLE FUND ARE FOR I MEAN
THE COMMUNITY NETWORKS HOUSING
SUSTAINABLE EMPLOYMENT AND
ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE. THAT
INCLUDES A FOR ME TO HEALTH CARE
AND MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES
FUNDING PROGRAMMING LIKE THIS
REDUCES RECIDIVISM AND FURTHER
DRAMATIZATIONS ORGANIZATIONS
LIKE THE TRANS GENDER VARIANT.
AND INTERSEX RESOURCES T. T. I.
G. P. IN THE BAY AND SO THAT
RESOURCES T. I COMMUNITIES FOR
REACH THE GAPS TO PROBLEMS THE
STATE WANTS TO FIX AND SOME
DON'T KNOW HOW TO EXIST LIKE
DISCRIMINATORY HOUSING. AND
SAVES- TRANSITION A TORY HOW
PROGRAMS AND ON MENTAL HEALTH
NEEDS THE TRUTH IS THAT T. J.
PEOPLE RIEN TX GRANDSON NOT
CONSIDERED FAMILIES FRIENDS AND
FAMILY MEMBERS FROM THE
TRANSITION AND HAVE NO ONE TO
RELY ON AND- SOME HAVE BEEN IN
THE SYSTEM SINCE THEY WERE YOUNG
AND I HAVE NO WAY OF OTHER
SURVIVING THIS IS WHY WE ARE
ASKING. TO INVEST FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS TO GROW T. T. I. RE
ENTRY PROGRAMS TO GET PEOPLE A
SECOND CHANCE AND TRULY LIVE
LIFE WITH THE LOVE THEY ARE
SPEAKING FROM A COMMUNITY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH TAX
PERSON PEAK SEEKING SUPPORT PLAN
UNDER AND STAFF HELLO MY NAME IS
A BREATH OF FRANKLIN AND AFTER
SPENDING TWENTY THREE YEARS IN
CALIFORNIA STATE PRISON. I'VE
BEEN OUT FOR A YEAR AND NINE
MONTHS. I COME BEFORE YOU TODAY
. TO LET YOU KNOW THE IMPORTANCE
OF ESTABLISH SEEN AN APPROPRIATE
IN THE FIVE. DOLLAR TO THE TRANS
GENDERED. VARIANT AND INR SAY
WILLING RE ENTRY FOR. THIS FUND
CAN IMPAIR A LOT OF THREE READ.
A NEW. AND THOSE WHO ARE ABOUT
TO BE RELEASED. MY GREATEST FEAR
UPON BEING RELEASED WAS BEING RE
INCARCERATED BUT I FELT AS IF I
ONLY HAD THREE CHOICES AS A
TRANSGENDER EX OFFENDER. ONE
RETURNED TO PRISON HOMELESSNESS
OR DEATH AND THAT IS NOT
SOMETHING ANYONE SHOULD HAVE TO
GO THROUGH. AFTER SERVING ALMOST
TWENTY FIVE YEARS IN CALIFORNIA
STATE PRISON. MENTAL HEALTH
ISSUES THAT ARE FACED BY THE TGI
COMMUNITY IS SOMETHING I HAVE
DEALT WITH FIRSTHAND. BUT I HAVE
BEEN ONE OF THE LUCKY ONES. WELL
RECEIVING MY A DEGREE IN PRISON
ONE OF MY PROFESSORS INTRODUCED
ME TO THE CHANCELLOR KEY NO
COALITION. I WAS ABOUT SIX
MONTHS TO BE READ RELEASED. AND
THEY WROTE ME AND TOLD ME OF
THEIR RE ENTRY PROGRAM THAT I
MIGHT QUALIFY FOR. THE SECOND
DAY I WAS OUT I DID GO TO THE
CONCERTINA COALITION AND FOR THE
FIRST TIME I FELT RELAXED
BECAUSE OF THE EASE OF GETTING
ALONG WITH THE MANAGE CASE
MANAGERS THERE. ONE BEING TERRY
J. WHEN I WAS FIRST GIVEN HOW
THROUGH PAROLE AGENT. DOWN TO
SKIP ROW IN TOUCH DID. BUT
ORGANIZE. PLACED ME IN THEIR
TRADITIONAL HOUSING THE HOPE
HOUSE THIS HAD A POSITIVE EFFECT
ON MY MENTAL STATE OF MIND AND
WITHIN WEEKS TRANSACTION A
COALITION GAVE ME AN INTERNSHIP
WITH PAY. WITH MY INTERNSHIP IN
MY A I WAS FEELING POSITIVE I
WORKED HARD AND WAS A BIT SOON
ABLE TO BE GIVEN A POSITION AT
TRANSIT TO THE COALITION. AT THE
HOPE HOUSE COORDINATOR AFTER
PROVING MY CAPABILITIES AND THE
NEW AFFIRMING. ENVIRONMENT I WAS
PROMOTED TO FRONT DESK ASSOCIATE
AND SOON BECAME A CERTIFIED HIV
COUNSELOR TESTER I WAS THE FIRST
TO PASS MY TEST AND INSPIRED
OTHERS OF MY STAFF. TO GET THEIR
CERTIFICATION AS WELL ALL THIS
WAS MADE POSSIBLE BECAUSE OF A
TGI ORGANIZATION THAT WAS THERE
WHEN I REALLY NEEDED IT. THIS
TGO REENTRY FUND WILL INDEED GO
A LONG WAY IN HELPING THOSE
WHOSE FAMILY WANT NOTHING TO DO
WITH THEM BECAUSE OF THEIR
GENDER IDENTITY AS IN MY CASE.
LET US LOOK FOR OTHERS THAT NEED
HELP. THIS FUND COULD ADDRESS
MENTAL HEALTH CONCERNS AND GIVE
WELL DESERVED HOPE. I WOULD LIKE
TO ALSO THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
MIGUEL SANTIAGO AND THE C. T. PA
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU FOR INVESTING IN
YOURSELF. THANK YOU- ANYBODY
ELSE BECAUSE SUPPORT OF THIS
BILL AT THIS TIME PLEASE COME
FORWARD EVEN IF. GOOD AFTERNOON
IS ON BEHALF OF THE SANFORD
EIGHT FOUNDATION SUPPORT THANK
YOU. NORBERT'S ON BEHALF OF A SO
YOU CAL ACTION IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU THANK. ALRP THEM WITH
PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF ACCOUNT.
PART THANK YOU. CRIPPLE FROM
BEHALF OF A CALL CAL VERY SO.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYBODY
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL
TODAY NOW WOULD BE THE TIME TO
COME FORWARD. THE SEEING NONE OF
US COULD THE PHONE LINES
OPERATOR IN THE PHONE LINES.
THANK MANAGER IF YOU WISH TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT
THIS TIME WE'LL GO TO LINE
THIRTY PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON REBEKAH GONZALEZ BUT
THE NOW ASSOCIATION SOCIAL WORK
CAL CHAO IN. THANK YOU. ANY
OTHER COLOR. WE HAVE NO ONE ELSE
QUEUING SPEAKER THIS TIME. OKAY
THINK YOU VERY MUCH NO TIME TO
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
NOTHING. OKAY WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE RESPECTFUL AYE BERMAN OKAY
THANK YOU MUCH FOR THE FOUR IS A
GOOD AN IMPORTANT BILL OBVIOUS
WE'VE SEEN SIGNS OF SUCCESS
ALREADY- PORTA AND I THERE'S NO.
APPROPRIATE BUT THERE'S UPON
READING A FUN TO BE ABLE TO PUSH
THIS LATER WHEN THEY'RE WHEN
THERE'S WHEN THERE'S FUNDS OKAY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I WILL TAKE
THIS UP WHEN THERE'S- THANK YOU
. OKAY ASSEMBLY MEMBER. CAREER.
YOU ARE HERE ON THE B. FOURTEEN
THIRTY TWO HEALTH CARE COVERAGE
. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS- I'D LOVE TO PRESENT A
SIMILAR BILL FOURTEEN THIRTY
TWO. WHICH WOULD REQUIRE OUT OF
STATE HEALTH INSURANCE CARRIERS
TO PROVIDE COVERAGE TO
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS AND HOME
ARE CURRENTLY ACCEPTED EXEMPTED
FROM STATE LAWS TO COMPLY. WITH
CALIFORNIA STATE LAWS PERTAINING
TO COVERAGE OF ABORTION AND
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE THIS
CHANGE IS CONSISTENT WITH
CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENT WHICH PROVIDES
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM AS A RIGHT
CURRENTLY THERE IS AN EXCEPTION
FOR POLICIES ISSUED OUTSIDE OF
CALIFORNIA TO AN EMPLOYER. WHOSE
PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS AND
MAJORITY OF EMPLOYEES ARE
OUTSIDE OF CALIFORNIA THIS
EXCEPTION IS A MAJOR CONCERN
BEACON SINCE THE U. S. SUPREME
COURT OVERTURNED. THE FIVE
DECADE OLD OLD A CONSTITUTIONAL
RIGHT TO OBTAIN AN ABORTION
THERE HAS BEEN A WAVE OF ANTI
CHOICE LEGISLATION ACROSS THE
NATION THEN THERE HAS ALSO BEEN
A GROWING NUMBER. OF STATES
BANNING GENDER AFFIRMING CARE WE
SHOULD DO AS MUCH AS WE CAN TO
ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
AND WORKERS HAVE ACCESS TO THESE
HEALTHCARE SERVICES REGARDLESS.
OF WHERE THEIR HEALTH INSURANCE
POLICY OR CERTIFICATE OF HEALTH
CARE SERVICE PLAN CONTRACTED IS
ISSUED OR DELIVERED. AB FOURTEEN
THIRTY TWO IS A PRIORITY TO THE
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS. AND
THE FUTURE OF ABORTION COUNSEL
THIS BILL IS SPONSORED BY THE
CALIFORNIA THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE AND
EQUALITY CALIFORNIA. WITH US
TODAY TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OUR
REPRESENTATIVES FROM OUR CO
SPONSORS JOSEPHINE FIGUEROA
CHIEF DEPUTY FOR THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF INSURANCE. AND
CRAIG PUBLISHER LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR QUALITY CALIFORNIA
FOR ANY TECHNICAL SUPPORT. US
DISHA HODGES WITH THE DEPARTMENT
OF INSURANCE IS ALSO AVAILABLE
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FIRST PERSON SPEAKING SUPPORT
PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON INTERNET
CORRECT FROM THE OF A CAL. PROUD
CO SPONSOR. AS YOU ALL KNOW
CALIFORNIA HAS SOME OF THE
STRONGEST PROTECTIONS IN THE
NATION FOR ABORTION AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. ACCESS TO THESE
SERVICES IS UNDER ATTACK ACROSS
THE COUNTRY LIKE NEVER BEFORE.
FOLLOWING THE SUPREME COURT'S
DECISION TO OVERTURN ROE V. WADE
MOST ABORTIONS ARE NOW BANNED
AND OVER A DOZEN STATES. AND
THIS YEAR ALONE AT LEAST
EIGHTEEN LAWS HAVE BEEN ENACTED
RESTRICTING ACCESS TO GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE FOR TRANS YOUTH.
CARE THAT IS BACKED BY DECADES
OF RESEARCH AND SUPPORTED BY
EVERY MAJOR MEDICAL ASSOCIATION.
IN FACT JUST YESTERDAY A FEDERAL
COURT BLOCKS ARKANSAS'S BAN ON
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE CONCLUDING
THAT WAS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND
VIOLATED DUE PROCESS AND EQUAL
PROTECTION RIGHTS OF TRANS
YOUTH. NO ONE IN OUR STATE
SHOULD BE SUBJECT TO THESE
DISCRIMINATORY AND
UNCONSTITUTIONAL OUT OF STATE
LAWS. UNDER EXISTING LAW
INSURANCE PROVIDED BY EMPLOYERS
LOCATED OUT OF STATE WITH OTHER
STATE INSURANCE CONTRACTS MAY
NOT COVER ABORTION OR GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. AB FOURTEEN
THIRTY TWO IS AN IMPORTANT AND
NECESSARY STEP TO ENSURE THAT
ALL CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS HAVE
ACCESS TO THE CENTRAL HEALTH
CARE THEY NEED. DESPITE THE
DISCRIMINATORY ACTIONS OF OTHER
STATES THAT RESPECTFULLY OR
DRIVE OF. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
NEXT PERSON SPEAKING IN SUPPORT
PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM
CHAIR MEMBERS JOSEPHINE FIGUEROA
CHIEF DEPUTY LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF
INSURANCE. UNDER THE LEADERSHIP
OF INSURANCE COMMISSIONER COMES
A LOT OF- WE ARE PROUD CO
SPONSORS OF AB FOURTEEN THIRTY
TO AT FIRST LIKE TO THANK THIS
AMERICAN VIEW FOR AUTHORING THIS
IMPORTANT MEASURE. BODIE ECONOMY
AND- UNDER THROUGH THE UNITED.
WE ALL HEARD ABOUT THE BANS ON
ABORTION AND GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE AND THESE ATTACKS ARE ONLY
GETTING WORSE ABORTION IS
OUTRIGHT BANS IN THIRTY STATES
WITH ANOTHER TWELVE STATES.
LIMITING ACCESS BETWEEN SIX AND
TWENTY TWO WEEKS. AS OF MARCH OF
THIS YEAR THIRTY STATES HAVE
EITHER RESTRICTED GENDER FOR ME
CARE ARE CONSIDERING LAWS THAT
DO. NINE STATES HAVE ENACTED
LEGISLATION BANS ON GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE FOR YOUTH AND
YOUNG ADULTS. SEVERAL PROPOSED
BANS WOULD LIMIT ACCESS FOR
YOUTH UP TO AGE TWENTY SIX. THE
MISSOURI GENERAL ISSUED AN ORDER
RESTRICTING GENDER FROM HEALTH
CARE FOR MINORS AND ADULTS. WE
MUST ENSURE THAT THESE AGREE
JUST LAWS DO NOT FIND THEIR WAY
INTO HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE
FOR CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS.
ALTHOUGH CALIFORNIA DOES HAVE
STRONG CONSUMER PROTECTIONS IN
PLACE REGARDING ABORTION. AND
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE IN HEALTH
COVERAGE THERE ARE CERTAIN
INSTANCES WERE CALIFORNIA
RESIDENTS AND THEIR DEPENDENTS
ARE NOT AFFORDED PROTECTIONS
FOUND IN STATE LAW. AB FOURTEEN
THIRTY TO SIX TO ELIMINATE THIS
LOOPHOLE TO ENSURE THAT
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS ARE
AFFORDED THESE PROTECTIONS. AB
FOURTEEN THIRTY TWO IS JUST ONE
STEP WE CAN TAKE TO RECOGNIZE A
PERSON'S ABILITY. TO MAKE
DECISIONS ABOUT THEIR OWN BODY
WHICH IS FUNDAMENTAL TO THE
ABILITY OF A PERSON TO FULLY
ENJOYING THEIR RIGHTS. AS A
STATE WE HAVE A DUTY. TO PROTECT
CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS FROM THE
LAWS OF OTHER STATES THAT POLICE
THE BODIES AND THE BODIES OF
THEIR LOVED ONES. ON BEHALF OF
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER RICARDO
LARA I ASK FOR YOUR I. BOATS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
SPEAKERS SUPPORT NOW WOULD BE
THE TIME TO COME FORWARD WITH
JUST YOUR NAME AND AFFILIATION.
REFERENCES ON BEHALF OF THE SAN
FRANCISCO AIDS FOUNDATION IN A
PALE LIKE HEALTH IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. CAN STOP A BEHALF OF
NARAL PRO CHOICE CALIFORNIA AND
THE CALIFORNIA NURSES
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. GLOBAL TEL ON BEHALF
OF A SO YOU CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU ONE MOMENT
MISTER BARTEL. YEAH I UNDERSTAND
YOU MY NEPHEW MUCHAS CASSIDY'S
FRIEND FROM STAFF INDEED. ZERO
WELCOME TO THE CAPITAL AND
INTERNSHIP CELIA. NEXT PERSON
PLEASE JENNIFER A LESS HEALTH
CODE IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. MADAM
CHAIR AND SET MICHELLE TO WILL
FOR WITH THE CAL COMMISSION THE
STATUS AND GIRLS IN SERVE. OF AB
THIRTY THANK VERY MUCH FOR SOME
. ALEXIS RODRIGUEZ OF THE BUT
SAYS AND FOR THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON GENESIS GONZALEZ ON
BEHALF OF THE TENET GOVERNOR
LENNY GONNA LOCK IS IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
BHAIRAB THREATENED HAD A PLACE
CALIFORNIANS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. OKAY ANYBODY SPEAKING IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL NOW
WOULD BE THE TIME TO COME
FORWARD. YEAH. YOUR MEMBERS MY
NAME IS A BIRD WITH THE CAT
FAMILY CAL AND WE ARE OPPOSE TO
A FORTY THIRTY TWO. I JUST WANNA
BRING UP IMPORT POINT THAT HAS
BEEN BROUGHT UP SO FAR- FIRST
CALIFORNIA STATE OFFICIALS JUST
AGREED LAST MONTH. TO PAY OUT
ONE POINT FOUR MILLION DOLLARS
TO TAXPAYER MONEY TO COVER THE
ATTORNEY FEES FOR VIOLATING THE
FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS OF FOUR
CHURCHES. ONE OF THE CASES WAS-
SKYLINE WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY- OF
CHURCH VERSES CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT IMAGINE MANAGED
HEALTH CARE. THE FATHER LAWSUIT
BACK IN TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN
WHEN THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT
OF HEALTH CARE DECIDED ON ITS
OWN TO REQUIRE ALL HEALTH
INSURANCE PLANS. TO COVER
ABORTION WITH NO EXCEPTIONS FOR
RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATIONS OPPOSED
TO ABORTION SO CORRECT ME IF I'M
WRONG BUT I SEE NO- EXEMPTIONS
IN THIS BILL FOR RELIGIOUS
ORGANIZATIONS. SO I'M NOT SURE
HOW YOU CAN AVOID BEING SUED
AGAIN- SO LOOK AT THAT QUESTION
ANSWERED. SECONDLY THIS BILL
MAINTAIN- MANDATES INSURANCE
COVERED THE MEDICAL
TRANSITIONING A MINERS WERE
DRUGS AND SURGERY- THE YOU CALL
GENERAL FIRMING CARE AS THOUGH
THOSE TREATMENTS ARE WELL
ESTABLISHED HARMLESS WAYS TO
TREAT. KIDS WITH GENDER
DYSPHORIA. YEAH THE SAME TIME
THE COUNTRY'S NOT KNOWN FOR
BEING CONSERVATIVE ARE TURNING
AWAY FROM THESE TREATMENTS
BECAUSE THE TERRIBLE SIDE
EFFECTS. AND SCIENTIFICALLY
UNRELIABLE RESEARCH. ON THESE
TREATMENTS. SWEDEN FINLAND
NORWAY IN ARE ALL TURNING A FROM
GENDER. CARE FOR MINORS. IN
THESE ARE NOT RED STATES- WE
DELIVER TO YOUR OFFICES
YESTERDAY A SUMMARY OF THE
RESEARCH SHOWING THE SCIENTIFIC
EVIDENCE- HAS NOT SHOWN THE
CROSS SIX TREATMENTS ARE
BENEFICIAL TO CHILDREN OR
ADOLESCENTS- HERE'S A- QUOTE
FROM SWEDEN'S NATIONAL BOARD OF
HEALTH CARE- WHICH IT SAYS DEEMS
ADOLESCENCE. THAT ARE AT RISK OF
THAT THE RISK OF PUBERTY
SUPPRESSING TREATMENT AND GENDER
AFFIRMING HORMONAL TREATMENT
CURRENTLY OUTWEIGHS THE POSSIBLE
BENEFITS BASED ON THE CONTINUED
LACK OF RELIABLE SCIENTIFIC
EVIDENCE. CONCERNING THE
EFFICACY. AND THE SAFETY OF BOTH
TREATMENTS. IS WORKING NASH
SERVICE US. THEY DETERMINED THAT
JINDER INCONGRUENCE USUALLY DOES
NOT PERSIST INTO ADOLESCENCE AND
IT'S PSYCHOLOGICAL SUPPORT AND
WATCHFUL APPROACH ARE GENERALLY
RECOMMENDED INSTEAD OF SOCIAL
TRANSITIONING DUE TO THE RISK
THAT PURITY WILL AND THE- PURITY
BLOCKERS ACROSS THE COLD MOONS
WILL ONLY BE ALLOWED FOR MINORS.
IN A RESEARCH STUDY. SO I GUESS
MY POINT IS THE SCIENCE IS NOT
SETTLED AND YOU CAN'T SIMPLY
DISMISS THESE COUNTRIES
REVERSING COURSE ON GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE IS MOTIVATED BY
HATE- THAT CLAIM IS NOT GOING TO
WORK ANYMORE SO I PLEAD YOU TO
HONESTLY DEAL WITH THESE
CONCERNS I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR
WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT WHAT'S
HAPPENING IN EUROPE. THANK YOU.
NEXT PERSON SPEAKING IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINES NOW MODERATOR
THERE ANY CALLS ON AB FOURTEEN
THIRTY TWO. NOTICE YOUR NAME AND
AFFILIATION PLEASE AND YOUR
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. IF YOU
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO THIS TIME. WE'LL START WITH
THE WIND. BECAUSE GOOD AFTERNOON
BECAUSE ALL BUT THE NAY. OF THE
OF SOCIAL WORKERS. CHAPTER IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT CALLER
PLEASE. PINE FOURTEEN PLEASE GO
AHEAD. AND THE HEARING
TEMPERATURE DIEGO CA AND UP TO
THIS. THANK THANKS CALLER PLEASE
. THE MANAGER WITH NO ONE ELSE
IF YOU WISH BEING OKAY THAT IS
THE TIME TO BRING IT BACK TO THE
DAY. SENATOR WINNER. THANK YOU
ADVENTURE I AM FOR SO I'M TO THE
BILL. THANK YOU ALL FOR THIS- TO
MAKE CLEAR THAT CAN COME
ACCOUNTS TRANSCRIBERS DESCRIBE
NO MATTER WHERE THEY'RE- HEADED
- YOU KNOW I DO THIS ON TO SAY
ARE NO- ALWAYS. THE SORT OF WING
FORCES THAT WANT BE. HAVE THE
HAVE LGBTQ. DISAPPEAR THERE'S
LITERALLY US TO. EVAPORATOR
GROUP IN A CALL OR WHATEVER IT
IS A TO WITH US- AND A THEY TRY
TO MAKE IT UP TO ONLY ABOUT
TRANS. THERE WERE ONLY WORRIED
ABOUT TRENDS COULD OF COURSE TRY
KIDS ABOUT TO HEALTH CARE
BECAUSE JUST LIKE ELSE- WE SAW-
TODAY- OR THE VERY RIGHT WING
THE COURT OF APPEALS FROM FIFTH
CIRCUIT RULE. THAT- FIVE
EMPLOYERS CAN FIRE L. G. B.
PEOPLE OR OR NOT THEM SOLD BASED
ON THE FACT THAT THEIR DAY OR
LESBIAN. OR TRANS. SO THE THIS
FIGHT IS BECAUSE WELL BEYOND-
YOU KNOW- L. FOR TRANS.
HEALTHCARE TRUST AND IMPORTANT
BUT THIS A BROADER FIGHT IS MY
AS. THE OPPOSITION TRIES. TO
CALL THAT SOME VERY NARROW
CONCERN OUT ITS NOT THEY WANT
ALL US TO THIS. AND BECAUSE OF
THE LIKE THIS ARE INCREDIBLY.
AND SOMETHING YOU FOR FORWARD.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE FAMILY
MEMBER. THANK YOU- MADAM CHAIR
AND THINK YOU SENATOR YOUR CALL
- AT THE END OF THE DAY NO
MATTER AND SHE COME IS. AT THE
STATES CAL- THE STRONG PROTECT
FOR RE FREEDOM IN THE ENTIRE
NATION AND CALIFORNIANS NOT SET.
TO LAW OF OTHER WHEN THEIR
HEALTHCARE RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS
MY VOTE WILL TAKE IT UP WE HAVE
CORE THING YOU THANK. HEY WE
HAVE TO OVERCOME HERE WELCOME.
AND YOU ARE HERE. FOR FINAL
PRETTY OF THE DAY FIND I THINK I
AM AB NINE FIVE. WOULD INCUR MY
CARE MAY. TO COME ON DOWN.
PLEASE AHEAD. THANK YOU CHAIRMAN
OF THE AFTERNOON. INTO TWO TO
SIX THREE PER OF. VOTERS SUPPLY
PROPOSITIONS. ONE THE STATE LAWS
BILL SEVEN NINETY THREE
PROHIBITING TOBACCO RETAILERS
FROM SELLING MOST FLAVORED
TOBACCO PRODUCTS. SB NINE SEVEN
NINETY THREE WAS GROUNDBREAKING
THAT COVERS FLAVORED E.
CIGARETTES MENTHOL CIGARETTES
AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS FLAVOR
ENHANCERS IN RETAIL LOCATIONS
INCLUDING STORES AND VENDING
MACHINES THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA.
DESPITE THE OVERWHELMING SUPPORT
FROM VOTERS TO RATIFY SB SEVEN
NINETY THREE FLAVORED TOBACCO
PRODUCTS CONTINUE TO BE SOLD IN
MANY STORES ACROSS THE STATE
WHICH ALLOWS MANY TEENAGERS TO
CONTINUE ACCESSING THESE
DANGEROUS PRODUCTS. EIGHTY NINE
THIRTY FIVE WILL EXPLICITLY
AUTHORIZE THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO ENFORCE
THE FLAVORED TOBACCO BAN
PURSUANT TO BUSINESS AND
PROFESSIONS CODE SECTION TWO TWO
NINE FIVE. POINT FIVE WHICH IS
ALSO KNOWN AS THE STOP TOBACCO
ACCESS TO KIDS OR ST ACT I
CONSISTENT WITH OTHER TOBACCO
ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS. EIGHTY NINE
THIRTY FIVE WILL ALSO REPLACE
THE SUBDIVISION FROM THE HEALTH
AND SAFETY CODE WHICH MAKES
VIOLATION OF S. B. NINE SEVEN
NINETY THREE A MISDEMEANOR AND
CRIMINAL PENALTY. INSTEAD
PURSUANT TO THE STATE TO ACT WE
WILL BECOME A CIVIL PENALTY TO
RETAILERS THEIR AGENTS OR FOR
THEIR EMPLOYEES WHO ARE IN
VIOLATION. THE COST OF
IMPLEMENTATION WILL BE MINOR
ESPECIALLY WHEN COMPARED TO THE
COST OF HEALTH CARE FOR THOSE
WITH SMOKING RELATED ILLNESSES.
AND IN THE NEXT GENERAL OF
CALIFORNIANS FROM BECOMING
ADDICTED TO SMOKING SHOULD BE A
PRIORITY FOR ALL OF US TO CARE
ABOUT THE PUBLIC HEALTH OF OUR
STATE AND THE WELL BEING OF OUR
CHILDREN. SB SEVEN NINETY THREE
AND SOME CAN HELP ACHIEVE THIS
GOAL BUT ONLY IF THE LAW IS
PROPERLY ENFORCED AND EIGHTY
NINE THIRTY FIVE WILL MAKE
EXPLICIT ENFORCEMENT. BY CDPH
AND THE AG IN ADDITION TO LOCAL
AGENCIES TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE
AND PROTECTION OF PUBLIC HEALTH.
SO WITH THAT- I'LL NOW PASS IT
TO GEORGE OSBORNE WHO REPRESENT
THE BILL'S SPONSOR UNION OF
AMERICAN PHYSICIANS AND DENNIS.
MR OSBORNE WELCOME. THANK YOU
MEADOW CHAIR MEMBERS. YOUR
OSBORNE'S A PLEASED TO BE HERE
AND- THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CONNELLY FOR BRINGING FORTH.
THIS MEASURE. THIS IS SUCH AN
IMPORTANT ISSUE. BOTH THE
LEGISLATURE IN CALIFORNIA VOTERS
SUPPORTED THE PASSAGE. OF THE
FLAVORED TOBACCO BAN. SO WE NEED
TO ENSURE THAT IS BEING ENFORCED
PROPERLY. BECAUSE AS IT STANDS
THESE LEGAL PRODUCTS ARE STILL
FALLING. INTO THE HANDS OF
TEENAGERS WHICH IS INEXCUSABLE
AND UNACCEPTABLE. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CONNOLLY WELL STATED THE
CASE FOR A BI NINE THIRTY FIVE
AM WILL BOTHER YOU TO REPEAT HIS
COMMENTS. SO ON BEHALF OF YOU
EPD. WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR SUPPORT FOR A BI NINE
THIRTY FIVE THANK YOU THANK YOU
NICE TO SEE YOU NEXT IN APRIL
SPEAKING IN SUPPORT THIS TIME
COME FORWARD. NAME AN
AFFILIATION. STAFF JAMIE MARC ON
B. OF THE HEART ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR
MEMBERS OUT OF MONCTON SMITH
WITH THE AMERICAN CANCER SOCIETY
CANCER ACTION NETWORK ALSO IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
PRESS THE ROUND OF THE
CALIFORNIA DENTAL ASSOCIATION
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. ALEXIS
RODRIGUEZ FOR THE CALIFORNIA
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THIRTEEN BIRD ASK ME
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
. VERY SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL TODAY BUT BY THE TIME
TO COME FORWARD. JOHN WHEN
YOU'RE ON THE OF THE CALIFORNIA
FUELS GIVING IS LIGHTS WE DON'T
HAVE A POSITION ON THE BILL JUST
WANT TO THANK THE AUTHORED
STAFFER- THE CONTINUED
CONVERSATIONS AROUND THE BILL-
WERE. HAPPY TO SEE MORE
STATEWIDE ENFORCEMENT HAVING
SOME CLEAR GUIDANCE WE JUST-
WITHOUT A LOT OF COMPLIANCE
ISSUES AT THE LOCAL LEVEL WITH
DIFFERENT INTERPRETATIONS OF
WHAT'S BEEN AND WHAT'S NOT AND
SO- WE WANT TO CONTINUE TO HAVE
SOME CONVERSATIONS ABOUT PUTTING
SOMETHING IN THE BILL. TO WHERE
WE GET SOME CLEAR GUIDANCE FROM
THE STATE ON WHAT WHAT EXACTLY
IS BANNED WHAT'S NOT BEFORE
REPORT CIVIL PENALTIES ON OUR
STATION OWNERS AND SO WE- LOOK
FORWARD TO THE CONVERSATIONS AND
WE'LL WE'LL KEEP YOUR STAFF OF
PRIZES CONVERSATIONS AS WELL
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SWINGS. ALL
RIGHT HEY BUDDY ELSE OKAY THE
OVER THE PHONE LINES FOR ANYBODY
SPEAKING IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION. TO AB NINE THIRTY
FIVE. IF ANYONE OR SPEAK INTO OR
OPPOSITION OF AB NINE THIRTY
FIVE PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO.
WE'LL GO TO LINE THIRTY TO
PLEASE GO AHEAD. AFTERNOON IS
AREN'T BETTER WITH THE HELP
OFFICER REFERS OF CALIFORNIA
SUPPORT THANK YOU. PLEASE FIND
FORTY SO PLEASE GO AHEAD. AND
I'M ON MY 20% OF THE MIND THAT
THE FIVE. FONG FOR. THANK YOU.
CALLER NO ONE ELSE HUMAN IS TO
BE THANK VERY MUCH THAT WOULD BE
THE TIME TO IT BACK THE
COMMITTEE. COMMENTS AND RUBIO.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THE
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD
TO US. HELLO I WAS SEE ORIGINAL
CALL THERE HOW ONE OF THE CALL
TO SEVEN AND THREE. HAVE DONE A
LOT OF WORK IN SPACE UP BE AS A
TEACHER I. RECOGNIZE YOU KNOW
DIFFERENT THAT ARCH ARE SORT OF
AND- IN USING SOME OF THESE-
NAMELY THE USE OF TO THE THAT
EITHER BUBBLE GUM AND COTTON ALL
THESE OTHER. PLAYERS THAT ARE
STRATEGIC TARGETED R. K. SO I
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR BEING
A FOR AND I THINK THAT. THIS
BILL- YOU'RE A SB SEVEN I THREE
WORK IF THERE IS A FORCE IN
WHICH I THINK. EXTREMELY AND
SELF THANK YOU FOR THAT AND I.
WANT TO BE ADDED A CLUB AND I
WOULD WANT TO MOVE THE BILL IN A
TO PROVIDE THANK YOU THINK YOU
SO THERE'S A ON THAT BILL- WHAT
WHY DON'T. CAN LEAD CAN WE CALL
THE ROLL ESTABLISH. OKAY LET'S
DO THAT. WHEN. SENATE EGGMAN.
EGGMAN HERE'S WHEN HE GLAZER.
GONZALEZ FOR GROWTH HERE GROWTH
HERE HER TADO. THEY MOUNTAINS
MENGE OF. INJURY HERE ROSS. ROSS
HERE RUBIO. PRESENCE RUBIO
PRESENTS WHAT HA.
GET OUR SUBJECT MATTER- FLAVORED
TOBACCO WITH OUR KIDS. I DO HAVE
A CONCERN THOUGH AND THIS IS MY
CONCERN BECAUSE I HEARD IT FROM.
A LOT OF MY AND- BUT A SICK
PERVERT MY SICK COMMUNITY MAY
SEE COMMUNITY PLAN JOB A
COMMUNITY ON SEVERAL OF THESE
LIKE CONVENIENCE STORES. AND
THEY'RE IN DIFFERENT
JURISDICTIONS AND SO THERE IS A
PROBLEM THAT THEY SEE IN THE
BILL THAT- THIS CAN BE ENFORCED
OR INTERPRETED BY DIFFERENT
JURISDICTIONS AND SO I GUESS ARE
YOU WORKING WITH THE-
CONVENIENCE STORES TO ADDRESS
THAT ISSUE I FEEL LIKE A CERTAIN
ISSUE MISTER WINNER WAS RINGING
UP AS THAT'S RIGHT HERE. SO I'VE
BEEN MIGHT SINCE YOU ARE IN THIS
COMMITTEE TODAY MIGHT I HAD TO
RUN AT A RULES BECAUSE THEY'RE
LIKE YOU'RE NOT THERE YOU'RE NOT
THERE. AND SO I NEED TO ASK YOU
THAT QUESTION- THEY'RE HUGE
CONCERN AS THEY OPERATE IN
DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE STATE
SAME TYPE OF- CONVENIENCE STORE
SHELL STATION THE TACO BELL OR
SUBWAY THINGS LIKE THAT BUT THEY
HAVE HUGE CONCERNS THAT YOU KNOW
IN ONE JURISDICTION THEY MIGHT
SAY IT'S THIS WAY AND THEN
ANOTHER JURISDICTION THEY MIGHT
SAY IT'S THIS WAY AND THEN THEY
GET FINDER TAXED- FEED ON. THEY
GET FINED FOR COMPLAINT YOU KNOW
NOT COMPLAIN WHERE YOU IT'S JUST
CONFUSING SO. IS THERE A WAY TO
UNIFORMITY. I ACTUALLY ARGUE
THAT THAT IS TO IS THE VERY AND
PUT A FOR THIS BILL OKAY BECAUSE
A LOT END OF A KERN SYSTEM. IS
ON WAY A LOCAL JURISDICTION
DECIDE TO ENFORCE AND IF SO HOW
. THIS IS REALLY DESIGNED TO
BRING IT BACK TO A MORE UNIFORM
STATEWIDE LEVEL. NOW THERE STILL
MAY BE SOME ISSUES WE HAVE TO.
CONTINUE TO WORK THROUGH AS PART
OF THAT AND SO WE ARE WORKING.
WITH GROUPS ON THAT BUT I
CHANGE. LITERALLY THE ISSUE YEAR
TEEN- IS WHY THIS BILL CAME
ABOUT OKAY. SO OKAY. WELL I THEY
HAVE M. I DON'T WANT A
CONVENIENCE STORE K. I. YOU KNOW
IN THE REAL WORLD I WANT A JOB
PLACEMENT COMMITTEE BUT I DON'T
RUN A CONVENIENCE STORE SO. I
UNDERSTAND THAT IT'S JUST THERE
CAN MY CONSTITUENTS AND THEY'RE
REACHING OUT TO ME SAYING THIS
IS NOT GOOD FOR THEM BECAUSE
THEY OPERATE IN MULTIPLE
JURISDICTIONS. SO I'M JUST
TRYING TO CONVEY A MESSAGE AND
LIKE I SAID I DON'T RUN IT CAN
BE. APPRECIATED THAT THOSE
CONCERNS ARE LONG STANDING. I
MEAN BASICALLY. EVERY SENSE- THE
BILL IT ORIGINAL BILL SB SEVEN
NINETY THREE HAS BEEN ENACTED.
WHICH WE ALL AGREE IS GREAT
POLICY- THERE HAS NOT BEEN
UNIFORMITY OR- FOR THAT MATTER
EVEN ENFORCEMENT TO BEGIN WITH
IN MANY CASES SERVICES REALLY
DESIGNED TO. BRING THAT
UNIFORMITY STANDARDS AND MORE
CONSISTENT ENFORCEMENT. TO THE
PROCESS SETS THE NATURE OF THE
BILL OKAY THANK YOU AND THEN SO
I HAVE A QUESTION ON ON SO YOU
DID SAY THE BILL PASSES GET
SIGNED BY THE GOVERNOR
ENFORCEMENT IS THERE AND THERE'S
A FEE. OR PENALTY YES- FOR
SOMETHING THAT HAPPENS TO
CONVENIENCE STORY SELLER PRODUCE
YOU KNOW SOMEBODY WHO SELLS THIS
PRODUCT. OR IS- WHAT DOES THAT
MONEY GO TO THE GENERAL FUND IS
A PART OF PROP FIFTY SIX. NOT
THAT I MEAN NOT PART OF IT BUT
LIKE THAT WE'RE GO BACK TO-
PEOPLE WITH LUNG IS. DOCTORS
MEDICAL RE. IT DOES AND I HAVE A
SUPPOSED AND TO BECAUSE- I'M
LOOKING FOR MY NOTES RIGHT NOW
BECAUSE I ANTICIPATE THIS
AGREEMENT AND TOBACCO PRODUCTS
COMPLIANCE FUND THANK YOU. YES
SIR THE VERY KIND OF GOALS A
YEAR STATING. WIDGET SERVICER
FIVE SO MEDIC CAL- RATES OUR
MEDIC HELP PROVIDERS THAT ARE
YOU KNOW PROVIDING KIDS HEALTH
CARE I GUESS. IT WOULD GO BACK
TO THOSE INDIVIDUALS THEY WOULD
GO INTO THIS FUND AND THEN BE
DISPERSED PURSUANT TO LAW OKAY
AND THEN DOES THAT INCLUDE-
FUNDS THAT ARE COLLECTED BY
LOCALS. YES **** DOES FOUR
PURSUANT TO THIS YES OKAY SO THE
LOCAL ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
COLLECTS THIS MONEY IT STILL
GOES BACK TO THIS ONE FIGURES
PER THIS STATUTE OKAY. AND I
APOLOGIZE AGAIN I'M BOUNCING
BETWEEN COMMITTEES AND I MAY
HAVE MISSED A LOT OF STUFF AND I
DO REALLY APOLOGIZE. AND DID A
IS THERE AN. ESTIMATE ABOUT WHAT
THOSE FUNDS WOULD BE- IN TERMS
OF WHAT THE INFO. FOR WHERE
SANTANDER AND OF FIND MANY
ANSWERS A KING. THAT AND WE
DON'T AN A OF THAT'S OKAY I WAS
JUST CURIOUS OKAY APPRECIATE
YOUR THANK YOU VERY MUCH GOOD
MICHAEL. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
THANK YOU. CARAMEL WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE YES SIR YOU FOR
CONCERN. AND REALLY SAN YOU TO
THE COALITION THE COME TO. SUCH
AS A THIS IMPORTANT EFFORT AND I
WOULD RESPECT ASK FOR NINE. OKAY
IT JUST FOR CLARITY THANK OF-
THE FUND IT IS UNABLE PROVIDE A
REVENUE AS- AT THIS FOR THOSE
BECAUSE WE DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH
HOW MANY IT'S GOING TO BE THANK
YOU. YOU'RE VERY YOU'RE VERY
WELCOME. OKAY SO WE HAVE A-
WHICH IS VERY EXCITING OR FIRST
TIMER BE ABLE TO CALL THE ROLL.
COULD COULD YOU PLEASE POST CALL
THE ROLL. THE. I'M SORRY AND THE
MOTION THAT PASS THROUGH TO THE
ON GOVERNMENT AND FINANCE.
SENATORS EGGMAN. EGGMAN EYEING
WHEN. GLAZER GONZALEZ. GROW NOT
. HER TADO. FOR TODD- I THINK
LIMÓN. MENJIVAR TWINGE OF OUR I
ROTH. ROSS I RUBIO HI. RUBIO I
WILL HOP. WIENER WE AYE. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH WILL OUT HOPE
THANK. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND
IF WE GET MOST ON THE PRO
CONSENT CAL BEFORE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OF THAT IS- CONCERT
COMES REYES E. B. SIXTY FIVE
THANK YOU ARE. AB FIVE FIFTY ONE
BENNETT AB FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN
FOR ONE AND QUIRK-SILVA AB EIGHT
NINE SEVENTY NINE ALVAREZ. AB
TEN FIFTY SEVEN WEBER AND THAT
IS WITH AMENDMENTS AB TWELVE
EIGHTY TWO LOWENTHAL AB THIRTEEN
OH NINE REYES. AND AB THIRTEEN
SEVENTY SIX CARILLO WITH
AMENDMENTS- MOVED BY SENATOR.
GROWTH PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR EIGHT BY EGGMAN AYE WHEN
I WHEN I GLAZER FINS. GROW GROW
BY FURTADO. CONTATO I LIMÓN.
MENTION WE MENJIVAR I ROTH. HAS
AYE RUBIO FIVE RUBIO I JOLLA.
WINNER WIENER AYE. HE IS A IS-
WILL HOLD THE OPEN FOR APPS
MEMBERS WERE ON SO ARE. ON TIME
MEMBERS CAN MOVE ON THEIR BILL-
P. SIX SIX BY. THE BILL BY
SENATOR MEANT. AND THAT IS DUE
IN ROOF TO COME ON. SECTOR
PLEASE THE ROLL. SENATE EGGMAN
HI A MAN I WENT. GLAZER AND-
GROWTH. HER TADO. LIMÓN MENJIVAR
MENJIVAR AYE ROTH. ROSS I RUBIO
HI RUBIO I LA JOLLA WIENER FIVE
WIENER AYE. FIVE IN GET THAT WAS
COMMUNITY. THAT WAS. TO PUT.
THROUGH LIKE IT'S OKAY OKAY AB
SO SIXTY SEVEN GIPSON. THAT IS
PASS AND TO THE COMMITTEE
APPROPRIATIONS. WE HAVE A MOTION
ON. THANK YOU VERY MUCH CENTER
WILL MOVE THAT I. IF SIGNATURE
IF YOU CALL THE ROLL. SAN EGGMAN
. EGGMAN WENT. WHEN I GLAZER.
AND GROWTH. HER TADO FURTADO I
LIMÓN. ENGE OF OUR- MENJIVAR I
ROSS ROTH HI GROUP HI RUBIO I
WILL HAUNT. HA I WINNER. WINNER
I. OKAY THAT IS EIGHT I WILL
HOLD OPEN FOR APPS MEMBERS AB
MEMBERS ON DO MOVING ON NOW TO
AB NINE ZERO FOUR. THAT IS TO
PASS AS A MAN AND REFERRED THE
COMMITTEE APPROVED HAVE TO DO
WITH. IS THERE MOTION ON THAT
RIGHT NOW I THINK YOU. BY CENTER
WILL HOP CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
A BY EGGMAN AYE WHEN. FIVE WHEN
I.
THE- I WILL HOT BOB I WINNER.
WIENER AYE THINK THIS WOULD
JACK'S FILE ITEM TEN AB SEVENTY
NINE AND THAT IS PASS AS MAY
THANK VERY MUCH MANY MORE AS
AMENDED AND RE REFER THE
COMMITTEE TO DO. SECRETARY CALL
THE- SENATORS EGGMAN BY EGGMAN
AYE WENT. GLAZER GONZALEZ.
GROWTH TADO FOR TODD- I LIMÓN.
MENJIVAR JAMAR I ROTH. ROTH HI
RUBIO. RUBIO I WILL HAN BOB I
WINNER. WE I. SEVEN SEVEN HOLD
THAT VOTE FOR AB MEMBERS MOVING
ON TO FILE ITEM FOR AB FOR
THIRTY TWO THE MEMBER CAREER
THAT IS TO PASS AND REFER TO THE
CAN ON A. A WINTER MOVE THAT
BILL DO WE HAVE A CALL THE ROLL
. SENATORS EGGMAN EGGMAN WHEN.
AND NO GLAZER. AND GROWTH GROWTH
NO HER TADO FURTADO I LIMÓN.
MENJIVAR MENJIVAR I ROTH ROTH HI
RUBIO RUBIO I WILL HOP BOB HI
WINNER.
BOB MOVES THAT BILL- AND THAT IS
TO PASS AND REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
SIGNATURE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
SENATORS EGGMAN EGGMAN HI WHEN.
GLAZER GONZALEZ GROWTH HER TADO
. HER TADO ICE LIMÓN. VENTURA.
IMAGE OF OUR AYE ROTH. ROTH AYE
RUBIO. RUBIO I HOP. BOB HI
WINNER. WIENER AYE. SEVEN
DIFFERENT SEVEN ZERO HOLDEN OPEN
FOR MEMBERS THINK YOU ARE MUCH
HEAR THROUGHOUT THE COMMITTEES
DEPRECIATE YOU. PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MORE ONLY THIS ROLL OVER
FOR ABOUT ANOTHER MINUTES OR SO
.
HI FROM OKAY. LET- LET'S SAY RE
OPEN THE ROLE ON AB SIX IRWIN
AGAIN IS DUE AND REFERRED
COMMITTEE A AG- PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. SEN WHEN GLAZER GONZALEZ
GROWTH. FOR TWO BOB BOB. THIS
SIX NOW YOU VERY. AND THEN ON
THE CAL WHAT'S- KALRA ONE AGAIN
. SAID GLAZER GONZALEZ MON WHAT
BOB HI HE SAID AND I ALSO NEED.
AND ON ON ITEM SEVEN AB NINE
THREE FIVE CONNOLLY TO PASS AND
ROUTE TO COME ON AND- PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL SENATORS WHEN
GLAZER. GONZALEZ GROWTH MOAN
COPYRIGHT SWAB ICE THINK.
ALL RIGHT SO LET'S OPEN THIS
WITH THESE ROLES ONE MORE TIME
THREE REASONABLE AMOUNT OPES
QUICK IN HERE- BUT FIRST WE
HAVE- ON OUR CONSENT CALENDAR WE
HAVE A MOTION ON THAT ALREADY
AND WE'D HAVE TO SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
GLAZERS LASER AYE GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ I LIMÓN. ELEVEN ZERO
ELEVEN ZERO OKAY NOW MOVING ON
TO EIGHTY SIX SIXTY IRWIN WHICH
IS TO PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON AG SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL SENATORS WHEN
GLAZER GLAZER I. GONZALEZ HI FI
GONZALEZ I. GROWTH FURTADO. OKAY
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM FIVE AB
SEVEN SIXTY SEVEN GIPSON MANAGE
TO PASS AND REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
SECRETARY. SENATOR GLAZERS
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ HI THIS IS
ALL THIS I. GROWTH LIMON.
INSTANCE EURO HOLE THAT OPENED
UP FOR FILE ITEM SIX AB NINE OH
FOUR CALDERON DO PASSED AS
AMENDED AND RE REFER TO
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
SENATOR GLAZERS. THESE ARE AYE
GONZALEZ HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH
AMONG. TEN ZERO HOPE OPENED. UP
ITEM SEVEN AB NINE THIRTY FOR
CALL TO PASS AND REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNOR'S
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SECRETARY
. SENATOR WHEN GLAZER GLAZER AYE
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I LIMÓN. NINE
TWO NINE ZERO HOPE THAT OPEN A
LITTLE WHILE LONGER AB TEN
SEVENTY NINE JACKSON TO PASS AS
AMENDED AND REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY.
SECRETARY SENATOR WHEN. SENATOR
GLAZERS GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ I GROWTH LIMON. ZERO
ZERO HOLD OPEN FOR THE NOT FOR A
LOT OF FOURTEEN FOURTEEN THIRTY
TWO CARILLO DO PASS AND REFERRED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS. SENATOR GLAZERS
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I
LIMÓN. NINE TWO NINE TO HOLD
OPEN AND FINE EIGHTY FIVE ITEM
FIFTY AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY SEVEN
SANTIAGO TO PASS AND REFERRED TO
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
SECRETARY SENATORS WENT GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ HI GONZALEZ
I GROWTH FOR THE MONTH. THANK
YOU SINCE
. ZERO
ON THE CONSENT. US SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
LIMÓN. OKAY HI. HELLO MY I
TWELVE ZERO TWELVE ZERO THAT IS
OUT IN THE ROLE THIS CLOSED AB
SIX SIXTY IRWIN TO PASS AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON AG
SECRETARY. IN ORDER WHEN. GROWTH
HER TADO THE MOUNTAIN THE MOAN
HI NINE ZERO NINE ZERO THAT
BILLS OUT THE RULES CLOSED AB
SEVEN SIXTY SEVEN GIPSON TO PASS
AND REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS SECRETARY.
SENATORS GROWTH LIMON THANKS
LIMÓN I TWO ELEVEN ZERO THAT
BILLS OUT THE RULE IS CLOSED
FILE ITEM SIX AB NINE ZERO FOUR
CALDERON THAT- I'M MOTIONS TO
PASS AS AMENDED AND REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
SECRETARY SENATOR GROWTH LIMÓN
HI LIMÓN I. SEVEN ZERO FOUR
SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT THE
ROLE IS CLOSE OKAY THE PILOT TEN
AB TEN SO NINE. JACKSON DURING-
TO PASS AS A MAN AND REFERRED
THE COMMITTEE TO DO. SENATOR
WHEN. GROWTH LIMÓN THANKS MALONE
I. TEND. NINE THIRTY OKAY- FILE
ITEMS AB NINE THIRTY FIVE
CONNOLLY TO PASS AND REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNOR AND
FINANCE SECRETARY. SENATOR WHEN
. GROWTH RAMON THANKS LIMÓN I
TEND TO TEND THAT IS OUT I WILL
BE ON TO FILE ITEM. FORTY FILE
ITEM YES FOR A LITTLE FOURTEEN
EIGHT THIRTY FOR THIRTY TWO
WENDY CARILLO TO PASS AND
REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS. AND SURGERY.
THANK A SENATOR LAMONT. LIMON
ICE. TEN ZERO TEN SAID TO THAT
BILL IS OUT IN THE RULES CLOSE.
BY LITTLE FIFTY AB FOURTEEN
EIGHTY SEVEN SANTIAGO DO PASS
AND REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS SECRETARY SENATOR
WHEN. GROWTH LIMON LOW HI ZERO
ZERO THAT BILL OUT THROUGH IS
CLOSE THAT COULD THE THIS
COMMITTEE HEARING OF THE HEALTH
COMMITTEE. BUT.