THE SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
WILL COME TO ORDER- I. WE HAVE
HAD- WE WERE JUST ONE SHORT OF A
QUORUM SO IF MEMBERS WOULD
PLEASE REPORT MEMBERS OF THE
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE WOULD
PLEASE REPORT TO ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED WE WOULD ALL BE GRATEFUL
- GOOD AFTERNOON THE SENATE
CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC
IN PERSON VIA TELECONFERENCE
SERVICE FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING
TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS.
877-226-8216 ACCESS CODE SIX TWO
ONE SEVEN ONE SIX ONE. WE'RE
HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS
TODAY IN THE- STREET BUILDING
ASK ALL MEMBERS I'LL REPEAT IT
AGAIN ALL MEMBERS PLEASE PRESENT
THEMSELVES IN ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED SO WE CAN ESTABLISH
QUORUM WE ARE ONE SHORT. OF
BEFORE WE HEAR TODAY'S BILLS-
I'M GOING TO ANNOUNCE THE ITEMS
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR. IF TEN
ITEMS ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR
TODAY THEY ARE AS FOLLOWS FROM
NUMBER FIVE AB NINE FOUR SEVEN
BY SEVEN MEMBER GABRIEL FILE
NUMBER EIGHT AB ONE ONE SIX SIX
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER BAINES FILE
NUMBER TEN AB FOUR SIX NINE BY
SEVEN MEMBER VINCE FONG FILE
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN A. B. ELEVEN
THIRTY NINE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
GARCIA FILE NUMBER TWELVE AB
TWENTY BY SELLING OVER GIPSON
FILED UNDER FOURTEEN AB. NINE
SIX EIGHT BY SEVEN MEMBER
GRAYSON WITH THE MEMBERS FILE
NUMBER FIFTEEN AB TWELVE EIGHTY
BY SEVEN MEMBER OF. MAN MAIN
MAIENSCHEIN OF PHYLUM NUMBER
SIXTEEN A. B. NINE FIVE NINE BY
SOON MCCARTY FOUND OVER EIGHTEEN
A. B. EIGHTEEN EIGHTEEN BY SEVEN
MEMBER PETRIE-NORRIS. AND
FINALLY FILE ITEM NUMBER TWENTY
ONE A. B. SEVEN ONE SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER. THE UP WITH US.
ALL RIGHT- LET'S GO OVER THE OF
. THE GROUND RULES AGAIN. TODAY
SO. HIS TESTIMONY TODAY WILL GO
AS FOLLOWS FOR EACH BILL WILL
PERMIT TWO PRIMARY WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT AND TWO PRIMARY
WITNESSES OPPOSITION EACH
WITNESS WILL GET TWO MINUTES TO
SPEAK. AFTER THE MAIN SUPPORT
WITH THE SPEAKS WILL TURN TO THE
ME TOOS IN SUPPORT ANOTHER WORDS
THOSE ARE HERE THE COMMITTEE
HEARING ROOM. WE APPEAR AT THE
MICROPHONE THEY SHOULD ANNOUNCE
THEIR NAME. THEIR POSITION AND
THEIR AFFILIATION THE OTHER
WORDS IF THEY'RE ON BEHALF OF AN
ORGANIZATION NAME THAT
ORGANIZATION- THAT WILL DO THE
SAME THING WITH THE OPPOSITION
TWO MINUTES EACH. AFTER WE
FINISH THE IN PERSON SUPPORT IN
OPPOSITION TESTIMONY WILL IN
TURN THE PHONE TESTIMONY WE'LL
HEAR FROM BOTH SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION. PHONE TESTIMONY AT
THE SAME TIME THOSE OF YOU WHO
ARE LISTENING ON THE PHONE YOU
ANNOUNCE YOUR NAME YOUR
ORGANIZATION IN YOUR POSITION.
THERE'LL BE A FIFTY MINUTE LIMIT
ON PHONE TESTIMONY THAT MEANS
THAT SOME OF YOU WHO ARE
CURRENTLY WAITING ON THE PHONE
WILL NOT BE ABLE TO TESTIFY.
HOWEVER WE WILL ACCEPT AND WE DO
ACCEPT ANY- WRITTEN
COMMUNICATION YOU SHOULD GO TO
THE COMMITTEE WEBSITE FOR
INSTRUCTIONS AS TO HOW TO SUBMIT
WRITTEN COMMUNICATION- IF YOU
WISH TO EXPAND AGAIN ON YOUR
POSITION. YOU CAN SEND US A
LETTER OR ANY OTHER WRITTEN.
MATERIAL FIRST BILL WE'RE GONNA
HERE TODAY IS AB SIX SIX FIVE
FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CARILLO
WE'RE GOING TO BEGIN AS A SUB
COMMITTEE. OF I SEE SOME NUMBER
CARILLO. IS HERE. SO THE FLOOR
IS YOURS. THANK YOU MISTER CARE
WE ACTUALLY HAVE TWO BILLS TO
PRESENT SHOULD WE DO ELEVEN
NINETY FOUR FIRST FOLLOWED BY.
SIX PANELISTS TO SIX SIX FIVE
FIRST I THINK THERE'S A NUMBER
OF FOLKS WHO WISH TESTIFIED SIX
EIGHT MONTHS OKAY. THANK YOU FOR
THAT ONE SECOND- BEFORE WE GO
THOUGH BEFORE YOU START LET'S
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. SO MADAM
SECRETARY IF YOU WOULD CALL THE
ROLL FOR PURPOSES OF
ESTABLISHING A QUORUM. AND THEN-
I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION ON THE
CONSENT CALENDAR. I'M BURKE YOUR
NUMBER HERE WILK PRESIDENT WILL
PRESENT ALAN. ALLEN HERE ASHLEY.
ASHLEY HERE CABALLERO. RUSSELL
RUSSELL HERE LAYERED HERE
LAYERED HERE MEN. NEW LOW. STERN
WIENER. YOU HAVE COR RIGHT WE
HAVE A POOR MISS ARCHER I WOULD
MOVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR CENTER
THEY'RE MOST CONCERNED
KELLERMAN'S SECTOR IF YOU'D CALL
THE ROLL ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR
. UMBERG OF BY A BIRD I WILL CRY
WILK. OWN ALLEN AYE ASH. AYE
ASHLEY AYE COME. RUSSELL RUSSELL
I. HI CLEARED I MEN. THE LOW.
STERN WIENER SIXTY ZERO IN THE
CONSENT ALL RIGHT IS ZERO WILL
PUT THE BILL ON BECAUSE CONSENT
ON. ALL RIGHT SOME CHRIS.
PLEASURES INDIVIDUALLY GREAT
THANK YOU MAY CHAIRMAN THANK YOU
MA'AM AND TO FOR A SIMILAR BILL
SIX FIVE. WHICH WOULD EXPAND
ACCESS TO MENTAL HEALTH CARE FOR
YOUNG PEOPLE USING MEDICAL
ACROSS THE COUNTRIES ARE
COMMUNITIES ARE FACING YOUNG
YOUNG PEOPLE ACROSS OUR
COMMUNITIES ARE FACING A MENTAL
HEALTH CRISIS AND THE NUMBERS
ARE SHOCKING. FROM MASS
SHOOTINGS IN PUBLIC SPACES IN
PARTICULAR SCHOOL SHOOTINGS AS
WELL AS BUT NOT ALL OVERDOSES
AND SOCIAL MEDIA BOWLING YOUNG
PEOPLE ARE EXPERIENCING A NEW
REALITY DIFFERENT THAN WHAT WE
DID GROWING UP A NEW REPORT FROM
THE CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL
AND PREVENTION STATES THAT TWO
IN FIVE TEENS. FELT PERSISTENT
SADNESS OR LONELINESS AMONG
TEENAGE GIRLS IT'S THREE AND
FIVE THAT'S A 60% THIRTEEN YEARS
AGO THERE WAS A BIPARTISAN
AGREEMENT THAT WE NEED TO
TWINPOWER OUR YOUNG PEOPLE TO
ADDRESS OUR MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS.
AS EARLY AND AS QUICKLY AS
POSSIBLE. BUT YOUNG PEOPLE THAT
ARE MEDICAL RECIPIENTS WERE LEFT
OUT ONLY ABOUT 20% OF YOUNG
PEOPLE RECEIVING MEDICAL. CAN
GET SCREENED FOR DEPRESSION BUT
WE KNOW THE NEED AS MUCH HIGHER.
WITH IT WE ALL DESERVE A LIFE
FULL OF PRIDE AND FULL OF
DIGNITY AND WHAT WE ARE DOING
TODAY IS SIMPLY EXPANDING CARE.
FOR THOSE THAT ALREADY RECEIVE
MENTAL HEALTH ACCESS AND
RESOURCES THROUGH PRIVATE
INSURANCE AND EXPANDING IT TO
MEDICAL. IT STARTS WITH
OURSELVES A STARTS WITH OUR
PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS TO
ACKNOWLEDGE THE TRAUMA OF
FAMILIES. THAT FAMILIES HAVE
LIVED THROUGH AND RECOGNIZE THAT
THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE.
BETWEEN SURVIVING AND LIVING
HERE TO TESTIFY AND TALK MORE
THE NEED OF THE BILL AS WELL AS
ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS.
R. TAYLOR. CHAMBERS THE ATTORNEY
LEGAL FELLOW AT THE NEW ASH
CENTER OF YOUTH LAW. AND NESTOR
ALLOW STUDENTS. COALITION FOR.
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. THANK
YOU. MA'AM THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS TAYLOR
CHAMBERS I'M AN ATTORNEY AT THE
NATIONAL CENTER FOR YOUTH LAW A
CO SPONSOR AND STRONG SUPPORTER
OF EIGHTY SIX SIX FIVE. SB SIX
SIX FIVE ADDRESSES A DEEPLY
INEQUITABLE POLICY THAT CREEP
ADDED BARRIERS FOR YOUTH ON
MEDIC HOW TO ACCESS MENTAL
HEALTH COUNSELING. WE ALL WANT
YOU TO BE HEALTHY. AND THRIVE.
TO ENSURE THAT. YOUNG PEOPLE
NEED ACCESS TO QUALITY
HEALTHCARE INCLUDING MENTAL
HEALTH SUPPORT FROM TRUSTED
PROVIDERS. CALIFORNIA LAWMAKERS
HAVE LONG RECOGNIZED THAT. MORE
THAN FORTY YEARS AGO THE
LEGISLATURE PASSED A LAW
ALLOWING YOUTH AGES TWELVE AND
UP. ACCESS OUTPATIENT MENTAL
HEALTH CARE BASED ON THEIR OWN
CONVENTION SOME CIRCUMSTANCES.
THIS LONG STANDING RIGHT HAS
BEEN A CRITICAL PATHWAY TO CARE
. DO YOU INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN
THE PARALLEL SECTIONS OF THE
FAMILY CODE AND THE HEALTH AND
SAFETY CODE. USED TO RELY ON
MEDIC HOW MUST MEET
SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER LEVELS OF
ACUITY BEFORE INSURANCE WILL PAY
FOR THEIR CARE. IN PRACTICE THIS
MEANS THAT YOU FROM PRIVATE
INSURANCE CAN ACCESS NEEDED CARE
AT AN EARLIER STAGE WILL USE
AUTOMATIC HOUSE MUST EFFECTIVELY
BE IN CRISIS BEFORE THE
INSURANCE WILL PAY FOR THEIR
CARE. YOU FOR A MEDIC CAL ARE
PREDOMINANTLY YOUTH OF COLOR AND
YOUTH EXPERIENCING POVERTY AND
THIS STRICTER STANDARD COMPOUNDS
THE ALREADY HEIGHTENED RISK
FACTORS THE FACE. SB SIX SIX
FIVE WOULD ADDRESS THIS IN
EQUITY BY ALIGNING THE STANDARDS
AND FAMILY COAT WITH LONG
ESTABLISHED LAW AND HEALTH AND
SAFETY CODE. ALL YOU CAN ACCESS
THE SUPPORT THEY NEED REGARDLESS
OF WHAT INSURANCE THEY HAVE.
REMOVING THIS BARRIER IS
CRITICAL GIVEN THE CURRENT
MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS THAT OUR
CHILDREN FACE RIGHT NOW. CDC
DATA SHOWS HEARTBREAKING RATE OF
ATTEMPTED SUICIDE AND PERSISTENT
SADNESS AND HOPELESSNESS
INCREASING AMONG YOUTH MAKING IT
EVEN MORE IMPORTANT TO OPEN
EVERY POSSIBLE DOOR TO CARE. I
URGE YOU TO VOTE YES ON THIS
IMPORTANT BELL. ENCOURAGE YOUR
CONSIDERATION THEY GIVE NEXT
WITNESS. GOOD AFTERNOON TURN
MEMBERS MY NAME IS A STREET
WHILE I'M A STUDENT ADVOCATE
FROM THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA
AND I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF AB
SIX SIX FIVE WHICH WOULD ALLOW
YOUTH RELYING ON MEDICAL TO
CONSENT TO OUTPATIENT MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES. HOLDING ON TO
THE SAME STANDARD AS YOUTH ON
PRIVATE INSURANCE. AS A LOW
INCOME STUDENT WHOSE FAMILY HAS
HEAVILY BENEFITTED FROM PUBLIC
ASSISTANCE PROGRAMS INCLUDING
MEDICARE ALL CALFRESH AND
SECTION EIGHT HOUSING AND
EXPERIENCE WHAT IT'S LIKE TO
SEEK MENTAL HEALTH SUPPORT.
MEDICAL SYSTEM. IN MY SOFTWARE
HIGH SCHOOL DURING THE HEIGHT OF
PANDEMIC ARE STRUGGLING WITH
MENTAL HEALTH LIKE MANY OTHERS
WERE AT THE TIME. MY PARENTS
WORKED INCREDIBLY UNDERSTANDING
AND SUPPORTIVE ENCOURAGING ME TO
SEEK MENTAL HEALTH SUPPORT. BUT
AS FIRST GENERATION IMMIGRANTS
THEIR QUITE UNFAMILIAR WITH THE
HEALTHCARE SYSTEM SO I WAS A
PRIMARY POINT OF CONTACT AND NOT
GET THE MEDS MEDICAL SYSTEM
MYSELF. I ASK MY PROVIDER FOR
ACCESS TO THERAPY BUT DUE TO A
NUMBER OF REASONS LIKE LONG
WAITLISTS ADMINISTRATIVE
COMPLICATIONS AND THE
BUREAUCRATIC NATURE OF MEDIKAL I
WAS DENIED ACCESS TO MENTAL
HEALTH CARE. LUCKILY WITH THE
HELP OF THE INTERNET I
DISCOVERED I LIVE NEAR ALL CODES
A MENTAL HEALTH CLINIC
ESTABLISHED IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
STANFORD UNIVERSITY THAT
PROVIDES FREE SHORT TERM THERAPY
TO YOUTH. I'M INCREDIBLY
GRATEFUL THAT THE SUPPORT I
RECEIVED ALL WHO WAS. FOR FROM.
HEALTH FUND. IT'S RARE FOR USED
TO LIVE IN CLOSE. TO FREE MENTAL
HEALTH CLINICS LIKE THESE WHICH
IS WHY SB SIX SIX FIVE IS SO
IMPORTANT. BY ALIGNING STANDARDS
OF ACCESS FOR MEDICAL USE AND
YOU THOUGHT PRIVATE INSURANCE.
SB SIX SIX FIVE AFFIRMS THE
ACCESS TO MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES
IS ESSENTIAL HEALTH CARE AND
HUMAN RIGHT. FOR THESE REASONS I
URGE AYE VOTE THANK YOU. OTHERS
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM HORROR
IN SUPPORT. OF AB SIX SIX FIVE
PLEASE APPROACH MIKE FROM GIVE
US YOUR NAME ASSOCIATION. AND
YOUR POSITION. BY KRAMER MATTER
ON BEHALF OF THE ACLU CALIFORNIA
ACTION IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. I TRACY ROSENBERG ON BEHALF
OF OAKLAND PRIVACY IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF AB SIXTY FIVE THANK
YOU. IT RESULTED ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE OF CHILD
AND FAMILY SERVICES PROUD
BECAUSE ONCE YOU'RE IN SUPPORT.
BLISSFUL OF AUTO ON BEHALF OF
THE COUNTY SANTA CLARA IN
SUPPORT. ANGELA VASQUEZ THE
CHILDREN'S PARTNERSHIP CO
SPONSOR IN STRONG SUPPORT AND
I'VE BEEN ASKED TO READ THAT
LIST OF SUPPORTERS. CALIFORNIA
ALLIANCE OF CHILD AND FAMILY
SERVICES THE CHILDREN'S
PARTNERSHIP NATIONAL HEALTH LAW
PROGRAM NATIONAL CENTER FOR
YOUTH LAW. GEN UP CAL VOICES
CALIFORNIA CHILDREN STRESSED A
GREATER HOPE ACC ACTION ACLU
CALIFORNIA ACTION. ALAMEDA
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
ALLIANCE FOR A BETTER COMMUNITY
ALUM ROCK COUNSELING CENTER
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS.
API EQUALITY LA ASIAN AMERICANS
ADVANCING JUSTICE SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA EXPERIMENT LUCILLE
THE CALIFORNIA BOARD OF
BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES. CALIFORNIA
ACADEMY OF FAMILY PHYSICIANS
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
CERTIFIED FAMILY LAW SPECIALIST.
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATE ASSOCIATION
OF SOCIAL REHABILITATION
AGENCIES CALIFORNIA COALITION
FOR YOUTH. CALIFORNIA FAMILY
RESTORE ALL RIGHT THANKS THANK
YOU WHAT WOULD LET ME JUST MAKE
SURE THAT THE RULES ARE CLEAR-
THAT WHEN YOU APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE FOR WHAT WE CALL ME
TWO TESTIMONY IT YOU SHOULD.
GIVE US THE ORGANIZATIONS WITH
WHICH YOU'RE AFFILIATED SO FOR
EXAMPLE IF YOU'RE A BOARD MEMBER
OF YOUR PRESIDENT OF THE
ORGANIZATION OR IF YOU'VE BEEN
RETAINED BY THE ORGANIZATION LET
US KNOW OTHERWISE. WE HAVE THE
LIST OF SUPPORTERS SO WE
ACTUALLY CAN READ I KNOW MANY
DON'T THINK WE CAN BUT WE CAN'T
SO OKAY IF I COULD ADD TO THAT
ARE NOT IN THE ANALYSIS RIGHT
THE YOU REPRESENT ARE YOU
AFFILIATED WITH. I AM AFFILIATED
WITH THE COALITION AND A CO
SPONSOR. OF THE BILL ALL RIGHT.
VISY ON ECONOMY SO HE WOULD BURN
TO RT YOU. OTHERS WHO ARE HE IN
THE ROOM IN. SAYING NO ONE ELSE
APPROACH IN MY FROM THE SMELTER
THE OPPOSITION SAME RULES APPLY
THE OPPOSITION AS DID OF. TO
THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT. OF IT
. I'M SORRY I PRIVATE HEROES FOR
THE SENATORS ALL RIGHT WITH
THANK YOU. WILL THE SERGEANT
DESTROY THE MATURE. OUT OKAY ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU CLOSURE. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH THE CULTURES AN
ATTORNEY FAXED LOT TREAT JUSTICE
REPRESENTING TENS OF THOUSANDS
OF CALIFORNIA FAMILIES. ASSEMBLY
WOMAN CARILLO IN CENTER SCOTT
WIENER CLAIMED THAT EIGHTY SIX
SIX SIX FIVE IS DESIGNED JUST TO
EXPAND ACCESS TO MENTAL HEALTH
SERVICES TO KIDS ENROLLED IN
MEDICARE. IF THIS IS REALLY
ABOUT FINDING WOULD BEEN HARNESS
PREPARATIONS COMMITTEE AND IT
HAS NOT. IT WAS REALLY ABOUT
EXPANDING ACCESS ALL THE AUTHORS
NEEDED TO DO WAS STRIKE ONE WORD
FROM THE WELFARE AND
INSTITUTIONS CODE NOT. WHICH
CONTROLS FUNDING BUT THEY DID
IT. INSTEAD THEY WANT TO AMEND
THE FAMILY CODE AND STRIKE A
FORTY FOUR YEARS OF GUARDRAILS.
THAT ENSURE THAT MENTAL HEALTH
PROVIDERS ONLY PLACE A CHILD
INTO A RESIDENTIAL SHELTER IF
THAT CHILD IS IN DANGER OF ABUSE
INCEST OR HARM OF SELF TAPPED.
TO THEMSELVES OR OTHERS THE
AUTHORS WANT TO CHANGE THE LAW
TO LET A TWELVE YEAR OLD OPT OUT
OF THEIR HOME ON A WIN. INVOKING
PARENTAL SEPARATION EMANCIPATION
OF MINORS WITHOUT ANY CLAIM OF
DANGER OR PARENTAL CONSENT. THIS
IS CHILD EMANCIPATION. WE HAVE
HEARD NOTHING AS TO WHY THEY
WANT TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR KIDS
TO BE TAKEN TO SHELTERS AGAIN IF
THE AUTHORS WANTED TO EXPAND
ACCESS. ALL THEY HAD TO DO WAS
STRIKE ONE WORD FROM THE WELFARE
AND INSTITUTIONS CODE AND WE'RE
DONE. BUT AB SIX SIX FIVE IS NOT
ABOUT OBTAINING MEDICAL COVERAGE
OR LINING TWO COATS IT'S ABOUT
TAKING CHILDREN FROM PARENTS.
WITHOUT A CLAIM OF ABUSE. THE
BILL PRESENTATION HAS BEEN LOW
BALLING WITH THE AUTHORS WANT TO
PRESENT SAYING IT'S ABOUT PARITY
IN EXTREME SITUATIONS. USING
MINORITIES IN AN INDIGENOUS AND
THE LGBT COMMUNITIES TO HIDE THE
ACTUAL INTENT AND IMPACT OF THE
BILL. WHEN REALLY IT'S A BROAD
AND CLEAR AND RICK BADLY WRITTEN
DANGEROUS BILL. WENT MEMBERS
WHEN IT'S YOUR TURN PLEASE ASK
THE HARD QUESTIONS OF THE
AUTHORS YOU HAVE DEMOCRAT. AND
REPUBLICAN PARENTS HERE IN A
PANIC. ASK THE REAL QUESTIONS
AND VOTE NO OR ABSTAIN ON EIGHTY
SIX SIX FIVE I'M HERE TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE
THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. NEXT WITNESS IN
OPPOSITION. HELLO MY NAME IS
WENDY MEET US I AM A MOTHER OF
FIVE AGES TWO TO NINETEEN AND
I'M FROM LOS ANGELES. AND FOR MY
CHILDREN ATTEND L. A. U. S. T. I
DROVE HERE WITH MY CHILDREN WHEN
I FOUND OUT AB SIX SIX FIVE ONE
MASSIVE PETE TWELVE YEAR OLDS TO
SELF CONSENT TO LIVING IN A
GROUP HOME. OR RESIDENTIAL A
FACILITY BY RISK REMOVING THE
EXISTING GUARDRAILS FOR PROOF OF
ABUSE OR DANGER PRIOR. EACH OF
YOU USE YOUR ELECTED PLATFORMS
AND NETWORKS TO INFORM AND SPEAK
WITH THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA.
IT DOESN'T SEEM SO BECAUSE WHEN
I TALK TO MY COMMUNITY NO ONE
KNOWS ABOUT IT AND WHEN THEY
HEAR ABOUT IT. THEY ARE SHOCKED
AND ANGRY THAT YOU WOULD
CONSIDER PASSING AND EXTREME
BUILD THAT WOULD BREAK APART
FAMILIES DURING A CHILD'S MOST
DIFFICULT. AND CHALLENGING
YEARS. YOU HAVE PASSED LAWS
PUTTING IN PROTECTIONS OF INTAKE
INTERROGATION AND BABY BECAUSE
YOU KNOW WHAT THE PRE FUNK
FRONTAL CORTEX ISN'T FULLY
DEVELOPED UNTIL AGE TWENTY SIX.
YOU KNOW CHILDREN TWELVE AND UP
ARE AT THEIR MOST VULNERABLE IN
THEIR EMOTIONAL AND MENTAL
DEVELOPMENT AND EVEN MORE SO
UNDER CURRENT SOCIAL MEDIA
INFLUENCES. AND CORBETT. KIDS
CAN BE IMPULSIVE INFLUENCED AND
REBELLIOUS AND INSTEAD OF
EMANCIPATING THEM WE SHOULD BE
CREATING PROGRAMS THAT SUPPORT
HUMAN COMMUNICATION I KEEPING
FAMILIES TOGETHER. AS PARENTS WE
ARE CONSTANTLY NAVIGATING HOW TO
SUPPORT OUR CHILDREN IN THEIR
GROWTH. WHILE PROTECTING AND
GUIDING THEM THROUGH CHALLENGING
SITUATIONS. WHAT ABOUT WHEN YOUR
DAUGHTER STARTS TALKING TO THE
MUCH OLDER BOY OR YOUR SON IS
ACCESSING UNHEALTHY MEDIA SITES.
OR WHAT IF THEY ARE JUST HANGING
OUT WITH KIDS THAT ARE GETTING
IN TROUBLE. AND YOU TRY TO AND
GUIDE THEM THROUGH THAT WITH
BOUNDARIES AND THE REBEL AB SIX
SIX FIVE ONE MASSIVE PEEP THEM
TO LEAVE HOME AND BE ABLE TO
CONTINUE THE DANGEROUS BEHAVIOR
AND- ALSO BE SUBJECT TO.
ADDITIONAL DANGEROUS CIRCUS
CIRCUMSTANCES AND GROUP AND- OF
GROUP AND RESIDENTIAL
FACILITIES. A CHOCOLATE READY GO
TO SCHOOL ONE DAY AND NOT COME
HOME AND NOT REALIZE THEY HAVE
JUST ENTERED THEMSELVES INTO THE
STATE'S OUT. WHAT WELFARE
SYSTEM. AND YOU AS A PARENT ARE
LEFT TRYING TO FIND THEM AND
FIGHT TO GET THEM BACK. I KNOW
THE SYSTEM AND WE SHOULD ALL BE
DOING EVERYTHING TO KEEP.
CHILDREN OUT OF IT AND KEEP
FAMILIES TO GATHER. WHO-
APPEARED. IT BETTER FOR OUR- TO
BE AWARD OF THE STATE. AND NOT
BE WITH THE PARENTS I GUESS
YOU'LL SHOWS ALL WITH YOUR BOWL.
THANK YOU. ARE THANK YOU ALL
RIGHT. OF FOR THOSE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE GIVE US YOUR NAME
YOUR FILIATION AND YOUR POSITION
. ERIN FRIDAY OUR DUTY DEMOCRAT
OF THIRTY SEVEN YEARS MOTHER TO
TWO CHILDREN I OPPOSE. MY NAME
IS IN THE DETAILS AND I OPPOSE
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. MY NAME IS
DENISE SECULAR CO FOUNDER OF
FREEDOM ANGELS AND WE OPPOSE.
YOU TARA THORNTON CO FOUNDER
FREEDOM ANGELS AND WE OPPOSE
THIS BILL. ALI SNYDER MOTHER OF
TWO REGISTERED VOTER I OPPOSE
THIS BILL. TRAIL LATCH MOTHER OF
THREE. CPU MEMBER AND A MEMBER
MEMBER OF EDUCATE ADVOCATE AND-
IN STRONG OPPOSITION THIS PHONE
ASKING FOR NOW ABOUT THANK YOU.
DON'T TAKE OUR CHILDREN THANK
YOU. HER CENTER IS A SINGLE DAD
OPPOSED ALSO PLEASE A MAN NINE
FIVE SEVEN THANK YOU. STEPHEN
BERASA I OPPOSE GENDER AFFIRMING
SEX CONVERSION WITHOUT PARENTAL
CONSENT. HEY THE PAINTER OF WITH
MOM ARMY I'VE- THANK YOU.
MARGARET A RAIDER I AM A
SURVIVOR OF GROOMING AND ASSAULT
IN AN ADOLESCENT TREATMENT ALL
RUNNERS A YOU OPPOSE. THANK YOU
. GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBER SPECIAL
WILLIAMS ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
PARENTS UNION- SPECIAL INTEREST
GROUP FOR PARENTS GRANDPARENTS
TEACHERS WE ARE IN A POSITION TO
AB SIX SIX FIVE THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON SHANNON KURTZ A MEMBER
OF CALIFORNIA PARENTS UNION AND
I'VE REPRESENTS- OVER A HUNDRED
PARENTS FOR CALIFORNIA PARENTS
RIGHTS ACT. AND WE OPPOSE THANK
YOU. HELLO I'M LISA DISBROW
VETERAN PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER
REPRESENTING TEACHERS AGAINST
GROOMERS LUMBER RENDON'S FOR
EDUCATION AND INFORM PARENTS OF
CONTRA COSTA AGAINST THIS ISSUE
THANK YOU. THEY BALK ON BEHALF
OF THE LOS ANGELES AREA SAN
FERNANDO VALLEY PARENTS IN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. SABRINA
WILLIAMS MOTHER OF SEVEN HEY
ALSO- AND THAT CAPTAIN MOM ARMY
SACRAMENTO AND WE OPPOSE THANK
YOU. HI MY NAME IS VERONICA
MOTHER OF FIVE FORMER- YOUTH
PASTOR AND I OPPOSE THANK YOU.
HELLO MY NAME IS PATRICIA DAN
TRACHOMA REGISTERED NURSE AND A
MOTHER OF FIVE AND I STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU. MY
NAME IS STEPHANIE HEWITT I AM
WITH CATHOLIC FAMILIES FOR
FREEDOM AND I OPPOSE THIS BILL.
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
CHARLOTTE JOHNSON AND THE MOTHER
OF TWO A REGISTERED INDEPENDENT
VOTER AND I VEHEMENTLY OPPOSE
THIS BILL THANK YOU. MY NAME IS
CALLING BRITAIN WITH CALIFORNIA-
LEADERS NETWORK AND CALIFORNIA
LEGISLATIVE VOICE OF STRONGLY
OPPOSE THANK YOU. MY NAME IS
SUSAN CRADLE AND REGISTERED
DEMOCRAT MOTHER AYE OPPOSED. WE
WISH LISTS OUT OF THEM REPORTER
IN THE NEWS ANALYSIS NOW ON THE
PERCENT OPPOSES. HI ON BEHALF OF
MYSELF MY FAMILY MY FRIENDS BACK
IN LOS ANGELES I OPPOSE. THE
NUMBERS BUT THE SECOND VIOLATED
BELOW THE PROBLEM WITH AND IF
THEY WILL GIVE AYE. THE BOSTON I
NOTICED WHEN THAT IS THE YOU
KNOW BE SEEN. NOTHING TO GET ON
. YEAH THAT SEGMENT ACCOUNT
MOTHER OF TWO GRANDMOTHER ONE
AND I THIS THANK YOU. I'M A PAST
AND MEMBER OF P. YOU ALLY IF YOU
GUYS PASSED THE IS ON. I MEAN A
POSITION. MY NAME SUSAN WATER
SOME OF THREE GRAMMAR THREE IN
OFFICERS. A STRONG OPPOSE AB SIX
FIVE AND THE AMOUNT. OF TWELVE
OLD ALREADY THANK YOU. I AM
AMANDA CO THE TIME. I LIVE IN
THE SENATE COUNTY. I MOLESTED A
WRITER AND LONG TIME ACTIVIST
AND THEN. I JUST OPPOSE. THANK
YOU IT. I'M BARBARA HYDE FROM
FREMONT. AND I'VE BEEN A VOTER
ON THE DEMOCRATIC TICKET FOR
FIFTY SEVEN YEARS AND I STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU.
SHERRI MAKE I LIVE IN OAKLAND
CALIFORNIA I'VE BEEN A LIFELONG
DEMOCRATIC VOTER AND I STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU. I'M
CHANGE JACKSON I'M FROM ALAMEDA
I'M A MOTHER AND A GRANDMOTHER
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU AND THE GROOMING OF
CHILDREN THANK YOU. JESSICA BONE
ALAMEDA COUNTY I'M A GRANDMOTHER
OF TWO AND I OPPOSE THIS BILL AS
IT IS ELOQUENTLY STATED ALREADY
ARE PARTICULAR MUCH THANK YOU.
MAGELLANIC WHAT BEERS AND THAT
MEANS WE NEED AND THEY MAY NOT
THAT NOT ENOUGH YOUR UP ON THE
TO BE A THREAT OF THE DAY S. S.
MACSWINEY WITH THREE CAL.
SACRAMENTO RESIDENT TO VOICE
STRONG. YOU UNIFICATION ALL
REGISTERED DEMOCRAT I'M A MOM
I'M AGAINST THIS BILL THANK YOU
. LEARN WHAT SANCHEZ FORMER
LIFELONG DEMOCRAT OF FORTY PLUS
YEARS AND PUBLIC HEALTH
PROFESSIONAL I STRONGLY OPPOSE
THIS BILL THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
A. K. AGING NEVA- THIS IS JAY
AND I'M AN OPPOSING THIS BILL
FOR ALL THE KIDS IN ORANGE THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT- GO AHEAD. THE TO
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE SO WE
CAN HEAR YOU. ALEXIS RODRIGUEZ
OF THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
. TAYLOR JACKSON CALIFORNIA
HEALTH PLUS. REPRESENTING
CALIFORNIA'S ALMOST THIRTEEN
HUNDRED COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS
AND CLINICS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
. IS A STELLAR SUGAR INTO CELLS
ARE LYING ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION CLICK HIGH
INTEREST IN THE CALIFORNIA
ACADEMY OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT
PSYCHIATRIST THANK YOU. JENNIFER
ALLEY WITH CALIFORNIA
PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. KELLY BEING
MY BEHALF OF HEALTH NET OF
CALIFORNIA SERVING OVER TWO
MILLION MEDICAID ENROLLEES IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. SEVENTY ONE
WITH A C. ARE YOU CALIFORNIA AND
SUPPORT THANK YOU. CAN LEWIS
REPRESENTING US WE ARE NOT IN
THE CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR
YOUTH IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
RISES ON BEHALF OF THE CENTRAL
ACCESS HELP AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU- NORTHLAND ON BEHALF OF
CHILDREN NOW IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. CHRISTINE CAMPBELL- I'M
CONCERNED MOTHER AND THEN STUFF
NOT OPPOSITION THANK YOU. HELLO
MIKE MATTINGLY WITH THE FUNKY
FATHERS IN THE WHO OWNS YOUR
BODY IS A WHO OWN YOUR BODY IF
YOU OWN YOUR BODY WHEN YOU DON'T
ON YOUR BODY AND I'LL WRITE YOU
A SLAVE OR ARE YOU A ARE YOU
OPPOSED- I'M OPPOSE ALREADY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OUR. THE
NAME IS STEPHANIE TRAILER I'M
HERE FROM REBUILD CALIFORNIA AND
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BEING A
MOTHER A GRANDMOTHER AND GREAT
GRANDMOTHER STAY AWAY FROM THE
KIDS THANK YOU. MY NAME IS
MICHAEL HAWES I'M HERE WITH THE
FREEDOM RIDERS AND WE STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU. I'M
CATHERINE BELUS THIRTY FIVE YEAR
SACRAMENTO COUNTY VOTER AND
SACRAMENTO PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU. ON A MEDIUM OF LANKA
YES LIKE WHENEVER ACOSTA UP
SACRAMENTO COUNTY HISTORY AND
PERCY OWN DAYS THEY'LL BE ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU. HI MY NAME IS
YOU CAN WE WITH THE FAMILY CAN I
VEHEMENTLY OPPOSE THIS THE YOU.
MY NAME IS CARA BUTLER FROM
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY I HAVE TWO
TEENAGE SONS WHO OPPOSE THIS
BILL ALONGSIDE ME THANK YOU. HI
GOOD AFTERNOON SIR MARTINEZ I'M
AMONG FROM CONTRA COSTA COUNTY
AND I OPPOSE AB SIX SIX FIVE
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON MY
NAME IS LESLIE BAND I'M A MOTHER
AND I'M ALSO A REGISTERED VOTER
IN SACRAMENTO COUNTY AND I
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK
YOU. PRINA SHE HE ON BEHALF OF
PERK ADVOCACY IN OPPOSITION TO
AB SIX SIX FIVE AND YOUR GYNO
VOTE THANK YOU. TERRY MILLER
SACRAMENTO RESIDENTS STEP MOTHER
STEP GRANDMOTHER CASA WORKER I
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK
YOU. CHECK SHE BOCUSE PRESIDENT
OF SACRAMENTO COUNTY YOU DO NOT
HAVE THE RIGHT TO TAKE CHILDREN
AWAY FROM ALL RIGHT THANK EARNS
. ERIC MALAL ELDER OF LIGHT OF
MINISTRIES WE OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU. CALIFORNIA NATIVE.
BORNEO OPPOSING SIX SIX FIVE
ANIMATRONIC I HIGHLY OPPOSE I'M
SORRY THANK YOU. HANGING OPEN
YOU HAVE TO SPEAK AT THE
MICROPHONE. ELIZABETH CADY
OAKLAND CALIFORNIA I'M A MOM AND
A GRANDMOTHER AND I REPRESENT
MOTHERS OVER OVER REACHING HANDS
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU SEE THAT
. THANK YOU NEXT PLEASE A LOT
MORE ABOUT STUDENT. SHYMANSKI
CENTRAL MAY FOR THE COUNTY PARTY
AND GEN Z. STRONGLY OPPOSE YOU.
HI MY NAME IS RUTH AND I
EXTREMELY OPPOSE SOME OF MOTHER
AND A GRANDMOTHER THANK YOU YEAH
. I'M LISA MULLINS FROM CONTRA
COSTA COUNTY I'M A MOTHER OF TWO
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU. BARBARA WALKER FROM
ALAMEDA A MOTHER OF THREE
REGISTERED DEMOCRAT ON BEHALF OF
REALITY I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
BILL THANK YOU. SCOTT DEAN
PASTOR OF OUR BAPTIST CHURCH
WERE STRONGLY OPPOSED YOU.
ASCERTAINED IN THE FIELD OF
CORNERSTONE BAPTIST CHURCH IN
MODESTO AND FATHER OF THREE AND
ASK FOR NO VOTE ON EIGHTY SIX
EXACTLY THANK YOU. MISTER
BRANDON CAMPBELL FAITH BAPTIST
CHURCH IN WHEATLAND AND NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA DIRECTOR OF THE
CALIFORNIA CAPITOL CONNECTION
FOR INDEPENDENT BAPTISTS IN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. VERY HIGH
CALIFORNIA'S OF LIBERTIES
ADVOCACY UNFORTUNATELY OPPOSE
YOU. PICTURE SHOULD BE V. NO
PARTY PREFERENCE LAST CALIFORNIA
DOT COM STRONGLY OPPOSE THANK
YOU. CATHERINE CARLSON SAN MATEO
CALIFORNIA I STRONGLY OPPOSE
THANK YOU. MIKE CARLSON I LIVE
IN THE UNITED NATIONS STRONGHOLD
OF SAN MATTEO CALIFORNIA RIGHT
IN THE BACKYARD OF STANFORD
RESEARCHERS ALREADY THANK YOU
FINALLY OPPOSED ALL RIGHT THANK
YOU. MY NAME IS STEPHANIE
CALIFORNIA NATIVE REGISTERED
VOTER AND I AM STRONGLY AGAINST
THIS BILL ABOUT THE HEINOUS
CRIME AGAINST HUMANITY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. FORESTER BODY ROCKLIN
CALIFORNIA I'M A REGISTERED
REPUBLICAN AND I AM A FATHER AND
AYE OPPOSED THANK YOU. JESSICA
WAGNER MY PARENTS IN THE TEACHER
I REPRESENT- JIM SHOEMAKER FOR
CONGRESS AND SAN JOAQUIN C. R.
A. AND WE OPPOSE THANK YOU. TERM
MEMBERS LIZ CHRISTIANSEN VICE
PRESIDENT CALIFORNIA POLICY
CENTER STRONG RISE IN STRONG
OPPOSITION TO SB SIX SIX FIVE
ALREADY THANK YOU SEE NO ONE
ELSE APPROACH IN THE MICROPHONE
MODERATE LET'S TURN THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE YOU ON THE PHONE
LINES WE ARE OH I'M SORRY. OF
THE RIGHT. SPEAK TOO SOON GO
AHEAD. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE WHO
WISHES TO TESTIFY IF THEY DO
THEY NEED TO APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE GIVES THEIR NAME
THEIR FILIATION IN THE POSITION
ON THE BILL. ALI A CAR AVAIL
SACRAMENTO RESIDENT AND I
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU VERY MUCH ALL
RIGHT NOW C. NOEL'S APPROACHES
MICHAELIS TURNED THE PHONE
LINES- FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE
ON THE PHONE LINE- WE'RE GONNA
PERMIT FIFTEEN MINUTES OF
TESTIMONY BOTH SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION. I EXPECT THAT- WE
ARE NOT GOING TO GET TO ALL THE
CALLERS YOU CAN SUBMIT WRITTEN
TESTIMONY IF YOU WISH ALL RIGHT
MODERATE PLEASE OPEN THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION AB SIX SIX FIVE. IF
YOU WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. TWO
EIGHTY SIX SIXTY FIVE PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
FIRST WE WILL HEAR FROM LINE.
ONE FIFTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY
APOLOGIES LINE ONE FORTY TWO. HI
I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF. MY
BOOK THE TEACHER HUSBAND. HIS
NAME IS DANIEL MACKINNON
MINORITY ARE YOU SUPPORTER OF.
AND MY- IS A MODERATE I A RIGHT
TO BE FIFTY MINUTE OF OUR-
FUELING TO STATE THERE'S NO ALL
RIGHT. THE PEOPLE THANK YOU MUCH
ALL RIGHT LET'S GO TO THE NAY
CALLER. ALL RIGHT THANK YOU. AND
WHERE LAND SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD
. HI HELLO. DURING BORN ALL. I'M
WRITER I AM A WASN'T IN WE
STRONG OPPOSE SO. MY FOR SHOCK-
AND I AM A MOTHER AND A FULLER I
OPPOSE THE BILL. FOR IT RIGHT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. LINUM
NINETY. HELLO JOHNSON CLASS
COUNTY IN A MATTER OF THREE I
STRONG OPPOSE THIS. THERE WHY
TWO TWENTY SO. HI MY IS NOT
BONTA OF. STRONGLY OPPOSE A. B.
SIX SIX FIVE. NEXT WE'LL HEAR
FROM TO TWENTY TWO. HELLO MY
NAME IS CLOSE GREEN AND I AM A
MOM AND A HOME FULLER AND I
SHOULD SUPPORT OPPOSE THIS
HORRIFIC BILL. ONE ONE FIFTIES.
YES MY IS NICOLE YOUNG I'M THE
CAL CHAPTER CARE MOM REVERDY AND
ALSO A MOTHER A SIX I REPRESENT
OVER THOUSAND IN THE COUNT AREA
AND WE OPPOSE THE BILL THANK YOU
. ALAINA ONE EIGHT FIVE. MY NAME
IS LINDA MY- CALLING A MOMENT
CALIFORNIA BACK FOR COUNTY FROM
ME AT THIS BILL. THANK YOU. LINE
. TO TWENTY NINE. HELLO MY IS
HEATHER HUMAN I'M FROM HERE I'M
UP AND EARLY EDUCATOR I SUPPORT
WHO- ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE BUT I
PULL THE GARDAWORLD BEING ROOM
FOR CHILL. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK.
LINE. EIGHTY FIVE. HI MY NAME'S
PERRY CHRYSLER FROM THE FOUNDER
OF CALIFORNIA RISE UP IN A
LOVING MOTHER I STRONGLY OPPOSE.
THANK YOU GIVE. LINE. ONE THREE.
HI HERE AND I'M AT NUMBER EIGHT
EIGHT MINUTES AND FOUNDER AND
THE MAKES YOU FOR AND WE HAVE
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. ONE NINETY
FIVE. FOR A LOCAL SUMMERS HOUSE
NEXT AT THE AB SIXTY FIVE THANK
. THANK YOU. ONE ONE EIGHTY
FIVE. LEGISLATE WHO CAN ENACT
FROM ELDER ON COUNTY OFF OF THE
MOTHER OF THE NEW DIE TO WITH.
EIGHTY I STRONGLY AT THIS BOMB
AND OF THE BILL AB THANK YOU SIX
FIVE THREE THANK YOU ALL RIGHT
THANK YOU. WHY THIRTY SEVEN. MY
NAME IS HEARST I AM A FAN LOST
AND MEDIATOR I'VE BEEN SORT OF
BY THE STATE BAR AS A FAMILY LAW
SPECIALIST. I HAVE DEGREES IN
TROUBLE AND PSYCHOLOGY THANK YOU
TO SUPPORTER OPPOSE. I WILL MORE
YOU AS AN UP AS ALL RIGHT THEY
YOU NEXT CALLER. ONE EIGHT SIX.
HI MY NAME IS FOR NOT THE TRUE
I'M NOT THREE AND MIGHT AND I
STRONG OPPOSE THE THANK YOU
THANK. BY ONE SEVENTY. MANY IS
ERICA OTHER. TO WOULD YOU FOR
MUSIC APPROVED. SPORTS
TRANSPOSITION THANK YOU THANK
YOU. THANK YOU FOR. HI MY IS
FERNANDO AND I'M FROM LA COUNTY
AND I STRONG OPPOSE THIS BILL
THANK YOU.
FIND ONE SEVENTY FOUR. HELLO
THANK YOU. WHEN THE BACK NOW BUT
YESTERDAY VOTER IMPOSTER COUNTY
I AM AN OFFICER TO FIX. EIGHTY
SIX FIVE. READY THANK YOU- LINE
. ONE FIFTY EIGHT. HI MY NAME IS
MICHELLE AND I'M A PARENT A
GRAND AND SMALL. EMPLOYER AND
CAL STRONGLY OPPOSED THE L.
THANK YOU. BLIND ONE FORTY
EIGHT. HI MY NAME TO PRE WE
CAMPUS SINGLE MOM AND MEDICAL
RESEARCH MISTER OPPOSE. EIGHTY
SIX SIX FIVE. THANK YOU. LINE.
ONE FIFTY FIVE. RIGHT RIGHT FONG
ALL. AND I OPPOSE THE EIGHT SIX
SIX FIVE THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
ONE OR ONE TENTH. MY NAME DAN
BARON I AN ART COUNTY RED AND
SMALL BIT OWNER HELP MAKE FROM
THERE SENATE EIGHTY SIX FIVE.
THANK YOU. ONE ONE TWENTY.
TRANSPARENT IN OPPOSITION THANK
YOU. LINE ONE FORTY FOUR. HELLO
MY NAME IS JULIE I HAVE FUN I
OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU. ONE
ONE THIRTY ONE. GOOD AFTERNOON
MY NAME IS ROSE BONTA NOT AS MY
MOTHER GRANDMOTHER I'M AN
EDUCATOR AND STUDENT ADVOCATES
AND AYE OPPOSED TO FILL. ONE ONE
SIXTY THREE. YES MY NAME IS
CAPTAIN MCBRIDE PLASTER COUNTY
YOUR AND MOTHER OF THREE WITH
CARE CALIFORNIA PARENTS UNION
STRONGLY OPPOSES.
UNCONSTITUTIONAL BILL AB ALREADY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THE NEXT
CALLER PLEASE. BLIND ONE EIGHTY
THREE DO HI MY IS ROSE THE WHOLE
RECORD HON AND AMMAN INSTEAD OF
CAL NURSES UNITES LIFE THIS.
THANK YOU. BY. ONE EIGHTY FIVE.
MY UNCLE FROM THE COUNTY AND I
IT THE FIELD. FIND. ONE EIGHTY
EIGHT. MY NAME IS JOE NEED OR
I'M NOT AND A PAPA OF SAN MENTAL
PLEASE DON'T SUPPORT BILL THAT.
WOULD BE A YOU VERY MUCH THANK
YOU. BLIND EIGHTY NINE. ONE ONE
EIGHTY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. WHY
WHY. NINETY I THE FELDBLUM CAL.
BOTHER OF THREE STRONGLY OPPOSE
THANK YOU. ONE ONE NINETY. FOX
KAMPAR TELEPHONE AND I TO SELL.
LINE ONE NINETY NINE. HI MY NAME
IS TIFFANY BETTER I'M A SINGLE
PAYER THANK YOU AT THE END OF
BECAUSE- MARKING AT AT THE
THOUGH THANK YOU THANK. BLANK.
OH THREE. MY IS AMBER I NINE BY
AND HOW CARE FOR IN CALIFORNIA
AND I WRONGLY OF. EIGHT FIVE.
THANK YOU. LINE. ONE SIX. SANDRA
THE FROM ABOUT CAL CALL TO A.
EIGHT SIX FIVE SIX. ONE ONE
TWENTY SEVEN.
AFTER A FEW AND I STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS BILL. FLANK. TO
SIXTEEN. CURTIS LEWIS EIGHTY
ANTI HUMAN TRAFFICKING COALITION
AND PASTOR OF THE CHURCH AND
STRONGLY OPPOSE THE STOCK. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU EIGHTEEN. BUT NOT
THOSE ARE FROM- PLASTER COUNTY
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE AB SIX SIX
FIVE THANK YOU. LIKE TO OH FOUR.
MY NAME IS THE NAME FOR HENRY I
AM A AND ALL OF HEAVEN OPPOSES
SIX FIVE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
BLANKE WELL. SEVEN THANK YOU A
SEVEN YEAR MIKE UP AND PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HELLO PARENTS AND- OF.
EIGHTY SIX SIX FIVE. THANK YOU
BLANK BYE. TWENTY SIX. YES
LEARNING OF MY COHN I'M A THREE
AND I OPPOSE THE BILL- ONE ONE
TWENTY FIVE. MY NAME IS ITEM
THREE I'M A MOTHER OF AND I JUST
OPPOSE AB. SIX SIX FIVE. THANK
YOU. WHY NINETEEN. HELLO MY NAME
IS VICKY YOUR OWN THE MOTHER I
GREW. A FOLLOWER IT HE CHRIST
AND I GOT THIS AB SIX SIX I
IDEAS THEY- LIKE. TO TWENTY ONE.
HELLO WE CAN HEAR YOU HELLO MIKE
. YOU MIGHT WANT NATHANIEL
REPRESENTING EVERY YOU AND I
FROM THE OPPOSE. GIVE LINE TWO
FORTY ONE. THE NEW CALL KLEINMAN
HIS- CAL POLY SCHOOLS FOR THANK
YOU. WITH WHITE ONE OKAY. HI MY
THANK YOU FOR KEEPING MY MOM OF
TWO I STRONGLY OPPOSE THANK YOU
. LINE ONE SIXTY. HI MY NAME
THREE WHELAN I'M MOTHER OF ONE
OF FISCAL MONTH AND I A THE BILL
. THANK YOU THANK TO ONE. I TO
FORTY SO. I MY NAME YOU KNOW
MCKINNEY I A IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY
AND RECOVER GIMMICK AND I IN
STRONG TO THE BILL THANK YOU.
ONE ONE FIFTIES. I NAME IS KAREN
FROM CONTRA ACCOUNT AND I'M A
MOTHER FIVE AND I FROM OPPOSE
THE BILL. THANK YOU. LIKE TO
TWENTY. HI MY ONE NUMBER THREE
MELANIE TO CARRY YOU SHOW
OPPOSES BILL THANK YOU. ONE ONE
EIGHTY FIVE. YEAH MY NAME IS
LINDA I'M CALLING FROM AND I
STRONGLY OPPOSE THE SALE IS NOT
.
NINE ONE SIXTY ONE. HI MY NAME
IS SYLVIA NOT ALL REMEMBER THANK
COUNTY MOTHER AND CHRISTIAN
FATHER IS A CRISIS STRONGLY
OPPOSE THE BILL THANK YOU. BLANK
TO FORTY SO. I AM VERY OFF.
SACRAMENTO COUNTY REPRESENTS
SOME OF THE THAT. YEAH. YOUR
STUFF. THANK YOU. LAKE. FIFTY
SIX. HI IS THAT ME YEAH GO
AHEAD. I DON'T. VERY CONFUSING
THANK YOU MA'AM GO AHEAD STATE
YOUR NAME PHILLY AND YOU
POSITION. LINE. THREE EIGHT.
THIS IS. ONE OF THE- THANK YOU
SIXTY PLEASE GO AHEAD- HI NUMBER
TWO CRUZ I ON TOM- NUMBER
DISTRICT- I AND I HOPE THAT COME
ON WILL THE SAYING OFF. I THANK
YOU. NINE TWO SEVENTY. HI MY
NAME IS RICK CAL HOKKIEN I
REPRESENT KAPPA FAMILIES FREEDOM
SAMBAR DINO REPLACE COUNTY WE
STRONGLY OPPOSE. I. THANK YOU.
TWO SIX NINE. HI MY NAME IS TINA
COBIA I'M STILL ON BEHALF OF
HILLARY COOLEY FOR FREE BUT I
THINK THE LIBERTY IMPORTANT AND
- COUNTY RED ROVER CHILDREN
ADVOCATE GROUP CAL BY YOU TRY
AND WHAT CHU. JOINT.
YEAH A STRONG WILL HOLD THE BILL
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WHY
SEVENTY EIGHT. HI MY NAME IS
WENDY ALLERGY I AM FROM WHAT THE
HELL CALIFORNIA I STRONGLY
OPPOSE THIS EXTREMELY DEFEATING
AND INJURED SO ALREADY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. LINE. ONE FIFTY FOUR.
I AM BRENT MACK CO FOUNDER OF
THE FREEDOM FIGHTERS AT AND
ANOTHER AND STRONGLY OPPOSE
EIGHTY SIX BLOCKS. YOU THANK YOU
ALL RIGHT MORE COLORS. HE FIFTY
SIX ADVOCATE REBECCA BUT THE
NATIONAL THAT'S OF WORKERS
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN STRONG
SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANK YOU ONE
. END OF THE LAST THEY WILL HEAR
FROM LINE. EIGHTY FOUR. THE
MIDDLE THE SUN MOTHER THREE AND
THE POST THANK YOU ARE MODERATOR
THE IT IN TERMS OF CALLERS OUR
NOW GOING TO BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE- FOR THOSE YOU ON
THE LINE YOU CAN SUBMIT WRITTEN
INFORMATION IF YOU LIKE. OUR
COMING MEMBERS. QUESTIONS THERE
- ALL RIGHT SO RUSSELL MOVES THE
- THAT AROUND. I'M SOME I LOVE
TO ADD. DID YOU TAKE ON SOME OF
THE CONCERNS RAISED BY THE-
OPPOSITE AND I WAS THIS IS BEEN
PATIENTS RESPECTS CREATING
PARITY WITH- KIDS WHO HAVE
ACCESS TO INSURANCE- THOSE THAT
HAVE MANY COW- I THAT THE BUT
THE YEAH BUT AS WAS MENTIONED
RIGHT IF THAT WERE THE CASE
THEN. THAT WITHOUT PORTION OF
THE- CURRENT CODE WOULD BE IN
OBVIOUSLY THERE'S SOME LANGUAGE
ADDED AND THEN. THE FOCUS ON AND
ALLOW. I CAN TOO AND I IT SEEMS
LIKE. WELL I'M A KID TO CONSENT
TO- RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WITHOUT
THE OF THE OR GUARDIAN IF. IN IN
IRAQ PARENTAL OR FOR. IN LESS
THAN PER. DETERMINES THE
INVOLVING WOULD BE INAPPROPRIATE
AND YOU KNOW IDEALLY I HOPEFULLY
THAT THERE'S SOME CRITERIA THERE
IT TO THE GUYS THAT BUT ON CAN
YOU GIVE US A BETTER SENSE OF.
WOOD THERE'S OBVIOUSLY A LOT OF
CONCERNS OUT THERE ABOUT HOW
THIS MIGHT IMPACT PRINTER RIGHTS
AND- SB KIKI K. LOVE LETTERS
YOUR YOUR YOUR REACTION TO SOME
OF THE ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN
RAISED AND IN THE COURSE OF THIS
DEBATE. SURE AD HELLO THE THING
ON THANKS FOR THE QUESTION
SENATOR I WOULD LIKE TO BRING UP
OUR- SPONSORS FOR THE MORE
TECHNICAL ASPECTS OF THE BILL
HOWEVER THE LIES AND
MISINFORMATION ON THIS BILL HAVE
BEEN SO GROUND. THAT THE
ASSOCIATED PRESS HAD TO THROUGH
A PROJECT THAT THEY'RE DOING ON
MISINFORMATION AND LIES
REGARDING POLICY TOOK AN INDEPTH
ANALYSIS OF THIS BILL AND
CONCLUDED THAT THE SOCIAL MEDIA-
ADVOCACY AGAINST THE POLICY AS
WELL AS SOME OF THE LIES AND
MISINFORMATION REGARDING THE
BILL ARE COMPLETELY ON FACTUAL
AND UNTRUE. THIS BILL DOES NOT
TAKE AWAY PARENTAL RIGHTS. THIS
BILL DOES NOT- ALLOW AN
OPPORTUNITY FOR A PARENT OR
GUARDIAN TO BE INVOLVED. IT DOES
HOWEVER- ALIGN ITSELF WITH
EXISTING POLICY THAT WAS SIGNED
INTO LAW TEN YEARS AGO
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. SIGNED INTO
LAW BY A REPUBLICAN GOVERNOR.
OUT WITH NO OPPOSITION.
UNFORTUNATELY OF THE
CONVERSATION HAS FAR EXCEEDED
WHAT THE INTENT OF THIS BILL IS
IT'S NOW A NATIONAL CONVERSATION
RELATED TO MENTAL HEALTH IN
YOUNG PEOPLE. THAT ALSO BRINGS
INTO. THE NATIONAL CONVERSATION
ABOUT LGBTQ PLUS RIGHT. OUT THE
TWO ISSUES ARE SEPARATE HOWEVER
IF A YOUNG PERSON LET'S SAY A
SEVENTH GRADER. GOES TO THEIR
COUNSELOR AT SCHOOL AND SAYS I'M
CONTEMPLATING I'M THINKING ABOUT
SUICIDE. THAT COUNSELOR IS
MANDATED THROUGH THE AD CODE TO
REPORT THAT. AND SO IT IS
IMPORTANT THAT WE REALIZE THAT
THIS DOES NOT CHANGE EXISTING
LAW. AS TO THE PARENTAL RIGHTS
OF THE CHILD MEANING THAT THE
CHILD WILL RECEIVE CARE THE
CHILD WILL RECEIVE COUNSELING
AND THE PARENTS WILL BE INVOLVED
IN THE CONVERSATION THERE ARE
OVER. A HUNDRED AND EIGHTY SIX
THOUSAND HOMELESS YOUTH ANY
GIVEN DAY. IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA MANY ARE NOT IN THE
FOSTER CARE SYSTEM. MANY ARE
LIVING ON THE STREET AND THERE
IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE
YOUNG PEOPLE TO BE HOUSE. AND TO
RECEIVE RESIDENTIAL CARE. I AND
SO IT ALIGNS A LOT OF POLICIES
THAT ARE CURRENTLY EXISTING BUT
AGAIN I LIKE TO. BRING UP OUR
OUR SPONSORS AS WELL TO ADDRESS
THE TECHNICAL CONCERNS OVER THE-
THAT ONE PARTICULAR ITEM IN THE
BILL. ALL RIGHT SENATE ALLEN
DECIDED TO QUESTION YOU KNOW I'D
LOVE TO HEAR FROM OUR IT IS YEAH
. YOU FOR THE QUESTIONS. I WOULD
JUST SAY THAT SB SIX SIX FIVE
DOES NOTHING TO CHANGE CHILD
CUSTODY LAW. IT DOESN'T PROVIDE
THE OPPORTUNITY FOR YOUNG PEOPLE
TO CONSENT TO IN PATIENT CARE IT
DOESN'T PROVIDE THE OPPORTUNITY
FOR YOUNG PEOPLE TO. ACCESS
MEDICATION OR ANY TYPE OF
SURGERIES WITHOUT THEIR PARENTS
CONSENT IT REALLY IS MENTAL
HEALTH COUNSELING AND TREATMENT.
AND THE RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER
PIECES TED TO CLARIFY AS WELL
THERE'S TECHNICAL DEFINITION IN
THE EXISTING IN. FAMILY CODES
THAT REALLY ARE TEMPORARY OR
EMERGENCY SERVICES SO THOSE ARE
THE RESIDENTIAL SHELTERS
SENATE'S REFERRING TO YOU- AND
THAT THE LAST SORT OF FINAL
TECHNICAL PIECE I WOULD JUST
MAKE IS THAT. THIS BILL DOES
NOTHING TO NEGATE THE EXISTING
PARENTAL NOTIFICATION THAT'S
CURRENTLY WRITTEN IN THE LAW. SO
ANY PROVIDERS OF RESIDENTIAL
SHELTER SERVICES OR OF
OUTPATIENT MENTAL HEALTH CARE.
ARE REQUIRED TO GO TO THEIR BEST
EFFORTS TO NOTIFY PARENTS- THAT
THE YOUNG PERSON IS RECEIVING
THE TREATMENT. AND THIS BILL
DOES DOES NOTHING TO CHANGE
THAT- IT'S REALLY AS AS ASSEMBLY
WOMAN REAL HIS ADDRESS TRYING TO
CREATE EQUITY BETWEEN YOU'VE ON
PRIVATE INSURANCE AND- ON THAT
ACCOUNT. NINETY THANK YOU. IT
THE ROUND AND ELSE BOB MARLETTE
I MEAN YOU SEE TO WHAT WHAT
LET'S WIENER AS QUESTIONS I MEAN
MORE ALL RIGHT YEAH. THANK YOU I
MISS TERM FOR ALL MOVED BILL I'M
PROUD TO CALL HOME TO RELEASE
THE AUTHOR FOR MOVING IMPORT
BILL. OFFER AND TAKING A LOW OF
THE- HE BASED ON THIS EXTRA-
MISSING. I MEAN INCLUDING YOU
KNOW- THE ONE OF THE- PRIME
CREATORS IN THIS. IS COUNTRY
MARJORIE TELL AGREE- ONE OUT YOU
ON THE- A BILL I KNOW WHAT
THAT'S- GENERATE JUST APPLE OF
FILE TALK. ALL STUFF. THANK YOU
FOR THIS FILM FOR- THIS BILL IS
COMMON SENSE- DID I IT EXPANDS
ON TO- TO COUNSELING FOR- PEOPLE
WHO NEED TO- PROVIDE. THE
ABILITY TO SHELTER FOR Q. HOME
WE KNOW. THAT WE HAVE IN OUR
REGION. NUMBER OF HOMELESS YOUTH
UNDER THE AGE OF EIGHTY AND THE
CIVIC. THEY'RE ALL ON THEIR OWN
. ON THIS- AND TO PUT THEM
THROUGH HOOPS TO TRY TO. A
RESIDENTIAL SHELTER- ISN'T AND
HE THIS SIMPLY BE ABLE TO OPT A-
A CHILD WHO IS WHO IS BEING
ABUSED SHOULD BE ABLE TO OBTAIN
SHELTER WITHOUT HAVING TO JUMP
THROUGH HOOPS ON THIS AT THIS
BILL PROTECTS CHILDREN IT MAKES
CHILDREN SAFER IT MAKES
CHILDREN. HEALTHIER AND IT'S
UNFORTUNATE THAT THIS BILL LIKE
SO MANY- HAS BEEN CAUGHT UP IN
THIS THIS THIS RIGHT WING
OUTRAGE MACHINE THAT IS LIKE
EVERY TWELVE HOURS. WE NEED
ANOTHER- ANOTHER SUMMIT ANOTHER
ISSUE OR ANOTHER BILL- OR
ANOTHER OR SAYS SOMETHING THAT'S
COMPLETELY MADE UP TO TRY TO
STOKE L. RATES ONLINE- TO SCARE
PEOPLE TO SCARE PARENTS TO. TO
FEED THIS- JUST ABSOLUTELY FALSE
MORAL PANIC. PEOPLE RUNNING
AROUND. TRYING TO STEAL PEOPLE'S
. OUR CHILDREN ARE WE KNOW THAT
THAT THAT THERE ARE A WHO TRULY
AT RISK- AND THE- GALLERY TO
MISS. COME MMHM IT ON. OUR
EFFORTS TO A ACTUAL AT RISK BY
MAKING PRETEND THAT ALL
CHILDREN- OR SOMEHOW ARE BEING
TARGETED AND THAT THE MENTAL
HEALTH PROFESSION IS TARGETING
THEM AND THEIR TEACHERS ARE
TARGETING THEM AND I'LL GIVE YOU
T. Q. PEOPLE ARE TARGETING THEM.
IT IS OUTRAGEOUS- AND THIS IS A
GOOD IMPORTANT BILL AND I WANT
TO THANK YOU AGAIN FOR MOVING
FORWARD. THANK YOU OTHER
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS THE
RUSSELL YEAH I TO ONE TO THANK
THE AUTHOR VERY MUCH- ONE OF THE
MOST IMPORTANT PIECES OF Y.
APPRECIATE THE BILL IS THAT
THERE IS. A HIGHER BAR FOR
ACCESS TO CARE FOR MY DISCOVERED
FROM BY MEDICAL. AND THAT MEANS
LOW INCOME VERY LOW INCOME
FAMILIES AND MINERS WHO WOULD
NOT HAVE ACCESS TO DO THAT TO
THE CARE THAT THEY NEED SO THAT
IN PARTICULARLY STRUCK ME AS
SOMETHING THAT YOUR BILL IS
CORRECT AND SO THANK YOU. RT
THANK YOU OTHER COMMENTS THE ALL
RIGHT OF CENTER WHAT DID YOU
WANT TO COMMENT SURE WHY NOT.
WELL IT I IF I WAS IN THE YOU
KNOW YOU ME SO I WILL. ANYWAY
GREAT RESPECT FOR THE AUTHOR YOU
KNOW I REALLY. OUR OUR
CONVERSATION WE HAD EARLIER IN
THE WEEK AND GOING IN SPEAKING
TO A LOT OF YOUNG PEOPLE I
TOTALLY UNDERSTAND- JUSTIN THE
NEED THE NEED FOR IT FOR MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES. NOW SO. YOU'RE
JUST TRYING TO EXTEND A POLICY
THAT WAS ALREADY DONE BACK IN
TWO THOUSAND SIX. I PERSONALLY
DON'T THINK WE SHOULD HAVE
PASSED THAT BACK IN TWO THOUSAND
SIX BUT BUT WE DID. BUT ONE OF
THE THINGS THAT THE OPPONENTS
SAID THAT I THAT STRUCK ME IN
JUST. MAYBE SOMEBODY COULD
ANSWER THIS THAT ALL WE HAD TO
DO WAS STRIKE ONE WORD IN UNDER
WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS.
INSTITUTIONS CODE SECTION FOUR
ONE FOUR ZERO TWO NINE POINT
EIGHT. IT CURRENTLY READS
SECTION THAT SECTION OF THE
HEALTH AND SAFETY CODE SHALL NOT
APPLY TO THE RECIPIENT OF
BENEFITS UNDER THE MEDICARE
PROGRAM ALL WE HAD TO DO WAS
STRIKE NOT. AND THEN ALL OF
THOSE GROUP OF. CHILDREN WOULD
BE ABLE TO ACCESS IS SO I'M JUST
CURIOUS WHY WE TOOK THIS OTHER
APPROACH WHEN THAT WAS VERY
SIMPLE AND ELEGANT. THANK YOU
FOR THE IN THE CALM AND
QUESTIONS. IF IT WERE THAT
SIMPLE WE WOULD HAVE DONE IT.
BUT AS- ARE CALLING FROM LOS
ANGELES MENTIONED THE- OTHER
CHALLENGES AND OBSTACLES FOR
MEDICAL RECIPIENTS TO RECEIVE
MENTAL HEALTH CARE IS MUCH
HIGHER. THAN FOR PRIVATE
INSURANCE SO THEREFORE WE HAVE
TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE GET MENTAL
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES TO
MEDICAL RECIPIENTS. SO THEY'RE
ABLE TO ACTUALLY ACCESS THAT
CARE I'M GONNA ALLOW A IF I MADE
TO RE INTRODUCE OUR OUR SPONSOR
FOR MORE A TECHNICAL APPROACH.
SENATOR WELLS. I WOULD JUST ADD
THAT. EXCUSE ME MODERNER MODE I
JUST ADD THAT- EVEN IF WE- DID
GO THE ROUTE OF AMENDING THE WAY
CODE AS OUR OUR OPPOSITION HAS
STATED. WE STILL WOULD HAVE TO
EXISTING CODE THAT WOULD CAUSE
CONFUSION FOR PROVIDERS IN TERMS
OF BILLION AND CREATING ACCESS.
AND THAT WOULD STILL ULTIMATELY
NOT CREATE THIS PARITY AND
EQUITY THAT WE ALL WANT FOR ALL
YOUNG PEOPLE SO IN ORDER FOR ON
THE GROUND AND IN PRACTICE TO
MAKE THIS ARE REALLY CLEAN
DELIVERY OF SERVICES FOR ALL
YOUNG PEOPLE. AND THIS WAS THE
ROOT OF AMENDING THAT THE FAMILY
CODE THAT FOLKS AND MEDIKAL ARE
ARE USING TO CONTINUE THEIR
BILLION VERSUS GOING OUT WITH
GROUP. THANK YOU FOR THE
QUESTION. THANK YOU. FOR ANOTHER
ONE CUT YOU OFF DID YOU FOR
QUESTION. I APPRECIATE JUST ME
THE A STORY THAT WAS JUST
REFERENCE I'M READING IT'S VERY
HELPFUL AND I. COMMIT TO FOLKS.
YEAH IT'S AN- IT'S WAS A IS
REFER TO BY THE ON OF HEALTH
BILLING YOUTH MENTAL SERVICES
STUDENTS OF MEDIA BY KARENNA.
ALL RIGHTS OF CHECK. OKAY THANK
YOU THIRD THERE ALSO IS MOVE THE
BILL. SO NUMBER CRITICAL. THANK
YOU MISTER THANK YOU TO THE
MEMBER FOR THE CONVERSATION. TO
OUR SPONSORS AND YOU KNOW TO THE
PARENTS ARE CONCERNED. WE WOULD
NEVER MOVE A PIECE OF POLICY
THAT TAKES AWAY PARENTAL
DISCRETION THAT WOULD ALLOW
CHILDREN TO HAVE ACCESS TO. THAT
WOULD ALLOW CHILDREN TO NOT HAVE
ACCESS TO THEIR PARENTS THAT'S
NOT THE INTENT OF THE BILL IT
WASN'T THE INTENT OF THE BILL
TEN YEARS AGO IS NOT THE INTENT
OF THE BILL NOW. SO THERE'S BEEN
A LOT OF MISINFORMATION AND LIES
ABOUT THIS BILL TO THE POINT.
THAT IT HAS NATIONAL AND
INTERNATIONAL ATTENTION AS TO
HOW WE TREAT MENTAL HEALTH
SERVICES FOR YOUNG PEOPLE IN THE
UNITED STATES AND IN CALIFORNIA.
THE BILL WAS ORIGINALLY A BI
PARTISAN EFFORT SIGNED BY A
REPUBLICAN GOVERNOR IT HAD NO
OPPOSITION. BUT IT EXCLUDED
MEDICAL RECIPIENTS BECAUSE IT
WAS PASSED DURING A RECESSION.
WE ARE FINALLY CORRECTING THAT
WRONG AND ENSURING THAT THE
BILLING PROCESS FOR MEDICAL. OF
RECIPIENTS IS CORRECTED IN THE
FAMILY CODE AND THAT YOUNG
PEOPLE FROM LOW INCOME HOUSING
AND LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
ACROSS THE STATE MOST OF WHOM
ARE YOUNG PEOPLE OF COLOR. AN
OLD PERCENTAGE OF THOSE WERE ON
HOUSE HAVE THE RESOURCES AND
OPPORTUNITIES TO RECEIVE MENTAL
HEALTH CARE AND WITHOUT I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I BUILT
ALREADY THANK YOU MEMSIC IF YOU
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER ONE AB SIX SIX FIVE
MOTIONS TO PASS AMERICA. AMERICA
AYE WILK. NO WILL CANNELLA ALAN.
ALLEN AYE ASHBY. CABALLERO
RUSSELL. RUSSELL I LAYERED. MEN
NERO. NERO NO STERN. WIENER
WIENER I. FORTY TWO MEMBERS
MISSING ALL RIGHT FOR TO PUT ON
CALL. ALL RIGHT ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CARRILLO AB. ELEVEN NINETY FOUR.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I'M-
GONNA HEAD TO ASSEMBLY HEALTH AN
ADD ON TO. BILLS BUT LET ME WE
CAN GET THROUGH THIS ALL RIGHT
OKAY. THANK YOU GO AHEAD
PLEASURES. AT THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN BIRDS I'M PROUD TO
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL ELEVEN
NINETY FOUR WHICH WILL PROTECT
CALIFORNIA'S RIGHT TO PRIVACY
WHEN IT COMES TO REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CARE DECISION AND THE
SHORE. THAT COMPANIES CANNOT
CIRCUMVENT CALIFORNIA STRONG IS
IN THE NATION PRIVACY
PROTECTIONS IN THIS CRITICAL
SPACE. A SINCE THE FATAL DOBBS
DECISION LAST YEAR THERE HAS
BEEN A RENEWED NEED TO ENSURE
THE ACCESS TO ACCURATE IN THE
TOWARD OF INFORMATION ABOUT ALL
OF ONE'S OPTIONS WHEN IT COMES
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE ARE
AVAILABLE. HOWEVER IS JUST NOT
ENOUGH TO BE ABLE TO FIND THAT
INFORMATION ONE SHOULD BE ABLE
TO ACCESS IT WITHOUT THE THREAT.
OF BEING SHARED WITH OR SOLD TO
THIRD PARTIES OR OF IT BEING THE
SUBJECT TO A DATA BREACH THE
CALIFORNIA PRIVACY RIGHTS ACT
GIVES INDIVIDUALS AGENCY OVER
HOW THEIR ONLINE ACTIVITY IS
STORED AND USED CALIFORNIANS
HAVE COME TO EXPECT THAT THEIR
PRIVACY WILL BE PROTECTED IN
THIS BILL CLOSES A POTENTIAL
LOOPHOLE. THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR
FLOOD CONCLUSIONS AND
MISINFORMATION ABOUT THE SAFETY
REPRODUCTIVE CARE BUT ALSO MAKES
ACCESS TO GOOD INFORMATION
HARDER CLOSING THIS LOOPHOLE
WILL ENSURE THAT PRIVACY IS
UPHELD IS ONE OF THE SITUATIONS
WHEN IT IS NEEDED. MOST
CRITICALLY NO ONE SHOULD BE WARY
OF USING RESOURCES AVAILABLE TO
THEM TO ACCESS CARE I'M HERE TO
TALK MORE ABOUT THE NEED OF THIS
BILL IS TRACY ROSENBERG AT RISK
THE DIRECTOR OF LOCAL PRIVACY.
YEAH GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR- ON
BURKE AND MEMBERS. OF THE HARD
TO FOLLOW THEIR BUT I'M TRACY
RESUME WITH. WITH OPEN. THE R. A
CITIZENS. COALITION THAT
ADVOCATES FOR PRIVACY.
REGULATIONS WITH RESPECT FOR.
CIVIL RIGHTS AND- COMMUNITY.
CONTROL AB ONE ONE NINE FOUR IS
A SIMPLE BILL AND I KNOW THAT
EVERYBODY. SAYS FOR THIS BUT IN
THIS CASE. IT APPS. ABSOLUTELY
TRUE. THE BILL CLOSES A LOOPHOLE
IN THE CALIFORNIA PRIVACY RIGHTS
ACT THAT WOULD ALLOW A BUSINESS
TO SELL OR OR SHARE DATA.
RELATED TO REPRODUCTIVE MEDICAL
CARE. BY CITING A DANGER TO LIFE
OR HEALTH. AFTER THE SUPREME
COURT JOBS THE DECISION
UNLEASHED A WAVE OF. ABORTION
RESTRICTIONS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
PRACTICES SUCH AS TRACKING YOUR
PERIOD. BECAME INCREASINGLY
PRECARIOUS ENDEAVOR. DIGITAL
REPRODUCTIVE TOOLS AND. APPS
COLLECT. UNLIKE A GREAT DEAL OF
SENSE AND- OFF. WITHOUT GIVE.
USERS THE ABILITY TO CONTROL
THAT INFORMATION SO THERE'S A
FALSE SENSE OF SECURITY THAT
THEIR DATA IS PRIVATE SAFE AND
SECURE. EIGHT VIRTUAL ID APPS
STUDY FOUND THAT ON AVERAGE
THREE POINT EIGHT TRAFFICKERS
WERE ACTIVATED AT THE MOMENT OF
. INSTALLATION OF ONE OF THESE
APPS ONCE THIS DATA REACHES
GOOGLE FACEBOOK OR OTHER LARGE.
COMPANIES IT CAN THEN BE SOLD TO
AGGREGATORS WHO IN TURN SELL TO
ENTITIES LIKE LAW ENFORCEMENT
WORK BOUNTY HUNTER SO AB ONE ONE
NINE FOUR WILL COMPEL THE
PROTECTION OF SENSITIVE.
REPRODUCTIVE INFORMATION UNDER
THE CALIFORNIA PRIVACY RIGHTS
ACT WITHOUT LEAVING LOOPHOLES OR
ESCAPE HATCHES WE THANK ASSEMBLY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CARILLO AND THE
LEGISLATURE CONTINUED LEADERSHIP
ON. REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM AND ASK
FOR YOUR SUPPORT FOR AB ONE ONE
NINE FOUR RT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT THING
NO ONE ELSE THE PRO. OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. IS A
STELLAR SHOW YOUR INTEREST LAWS
ARE LYING ON BEHALF THE SITTING
SITTING COUNTY OF SERVICES GOING
SUPPORT THANK YOU. HELLO
RODRIGUEZ TO THE HELP MEDICAL IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. PRICES ON
BEHALF OF THE CENTRAL ACCESS
HEALTH IN SUPPORT ALREADY THANK
YOU. OTHERS IN SUPPORT. THEY
KNOW OF THOSE BELTS APPROACHING
THE MICROPHONE THOSE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE THING KNOWN
APPROACHING THE MICROPHONE-
LET'S NOW TURN TO THE PHONE
LINES. THERE'S NO ONE ELSE IN
THE HEARING ROOM WHO'S AND SPORE
OPPOSITION WILL TURN THE PHONE
LINES MODERATOR PLEASE OPEN THE
FOLLOWING. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
. TO EIGHTY ELEVEN NINETY FOUR
EIGHT PRESS ONE ZERO. FIRST BILL
HERE FROM LINE. ONE SIXTY SEVEN.
WELL YOUNG UP IN OPPOSITION. I
THANK YOU. LINE. ONE FIFTY FIVE-
NINE ONE FIFTY FIVE OR MAKE IT
UP PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE TO
THIRTY TWO. ERIN ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA MEXICO I SUPPOSE
HM AND RALPH- TWENTY OF NETWORK
THANK YOU. THANK YOU PM. GOOD
AFTERNOON REFER GONZALEZ THE
NATIONAL THAT THE OF FOLKS
WORKERS. CHAPTER FOUR THANK YOU
. AND WE DO HAVE ONE MORE TIME
COMING THROUGH IT IS THE ONE
PLEASE WE PROVIDE THEM WITH THE
LINE NUMBER. AND- LINE ONE OH
THREE GO AHEAD. I MEAN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU I THANK YOU
. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE
NO FURTHER COMMENT AT THIS TIME
ALL RIGHT BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
MEMBERS. OKAY UP ALL RIGHT IN
SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION IN SUPPORT
HI ANTHONY FROM THE AG'S OFFICE
I'M SORRY THOUGHT CAUGHT OUTSIDE
IN THE HALL THAT THE EIGHTIES
ABOUT TO SUPPORT ELEVEN NINETY
FOUR THANK YOU THANK YOU ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU- IS THERE A
MOTION. SENATE ALSO MOST THE
BILL ALL RIGHT- PHONE NUMBER
CARRILLO CARE CLOSE THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO
THANK THE FUTURE OF ABORTION
COUNSEL AS WELL AS THE
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS FOR
MAKING THIS A PRIORITY. TO OUR
CAUCUS AND RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
AN AYE VOTE I THANK YOU MADAM
SECRETARY CALL THE ROLL THIS IS
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO AB ELEVEN
NINETY FOUR THE MOTION IS TO
PASS THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE NUMBER. NUMBER I WILL
CRY WILK AYE ALLEN. ALLEN AYE
ASHBY ASHBY I CABALLERO. RUSSELL
RUSSELL LAYERED. MEN NILA. STERN
WIENER. FIVE TWO ZERO MEMBERS
NOTHING. FIVE ZERO PUT THAT ON
CALL ALL RIGHT WE'RE LOOKING
FOR- ASSEMBLY AUTHORS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER HANEY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GABRIEL ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEVY.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BRIAN. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GIBSON'S. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MCCARTY. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
VALENCIA OR ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WILSON. NO WAITING. FOR ONE
THIRD. THERE'S ASSEMBLY MEMBER
HANEY ASSEMBLYMEMBER HANEY THE
FLOOR IS YOURS AB TWELVE ITEM
NUMBER. THREE ALL RIGHTS THANK
YOU- MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS
I'M I KNOW WE ARE HEARING FROM
OUR CONSTITUENTS ABOUT HOW
CHALLENGING IT IS TO MANAGE THE
COST OF HOUSING IN OUR STATE
THERE ARE SEVENTEEN MILLION
FAMILIES AND INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
RENTING OUR STATE AND RENTS ARE
SKYROCKETING THE MEDIAN RENT IN
CALIFORNIA HAS INCREASED BY 35%
SINCE TWO THOUSAND WHILE MEDIAN
RENTER HOUSEHOLD INCOME HAS ONLY
INCREASED BY SIX PERCENT. WITH
THE SECOND MOST EXPENSIVE STATE
FOR RENT AND HAVE THE MOST
RESIDENTS AT OUR HOUSE COST
BURDEN IN THE COUNTRY THIS
INCREASE IN RENT HAS LED TO
INCREASED BARRIERS IN EVEN
GETTING INTO HOUSING THAT IS
APPROPRIATE FOR A PERSON IN THE
FAMILY UNDER CURRENT LAW EVERY
RENTER CAN BE REQUIRED TO PAY UP
TO THREE MONTHS RENT FOR
SECURITY DEPOSIT. THIS LAW WAS
PUT INTO PLACE IN NINETEEN
SEVENTY SEVEN AND HASN'T BEEN
CHANGED SUBSTANTIALLY IN DECADES
THREE DECADES THIS OUTDATED LAW
IS FORCING RENTERS WHO LIVE IN
SOME MARKETS TO PAY AS MUCH AS
EIGHT THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR
SECURITY DEPOSIT. WHICH ALONG
WITH THE FIRST MONTH'S RENT CAN
BE UPWARDS OF TEN THOUSAND
DOLLARS FOR AN AVERAGE UNIT.
THAT'S A DOWN PAYMENT ON A HOUSE
IN MANY PARTS OF THE COUNTRY.
THE RESULT IS THAT FAMILIES HAVE
TO FOREGO NURSING SSC SUCH AS
FOOD AND UTILITIES TO A FOR THE
DEPOSIT. OR ACQUIRE MORE DEBT IN
ORDER TO BE APPROVED FOR
HOUSING. IN SOME CASES THERE
EVEN FORCED TO STAND HOUSING
THAT'S INSUFFICIENT. UNSAFE OR
CROWDED. AT TIMES FAR FROM
SCHOOL WORK OR THEIR FAMILY OR
EVEN STAY ON THE STREET OR
LIVING IN THEIR CARS ARE THE- TO
HELP ENSURE ACCESS TO SAVE
HOUSING AB TWELVE WILL LIMIT THE
AMOUNT A LANDLORD CAN CHARGE FOR
SECURITY DEPOSIT. THE ONE
MONTH'S RENT. THIS BALANCES THE
NEEDS OF THE RENDERING THE
LANDLORD AND WOULD MAKE
CALIFORNIA THE TWELVE STATE IN
THE COUNTRY TO GRANT THIS
PROTECTION FOLLOWING STATES LIKE
DELAWARE RHODE ISLAND NEW YORK
MASSACHUSETTS AND ALABAMA. I'D
ALSO LIKE TO KNOW THAT THIS BILL
DOES NOT TAKE AWAY THE LANDLORDS
ABILITY. TO HOLD THEIR TENANTS
ACCOUNTABLE TENANTS ARE STILL
FULLY LIABLE IN A VERY RARE
CASES IN WHICH DAMAGES EXCEED
ONE MONTH OF RENT. THIS BILL GOT
WIDESPREAD SUPPORT IN THE
ASSEMBLY FROM OUR COLLEAGUES
THAT ARE RENTERS HOMEOWNERS AND
LANDLORDS. BECAUSE IT'S FAIR AND
BALANCED COMMONSENSE SOLUTION.
AND I'M SURE THAT LANDLORDS SO
MISS OUT ON GOOD TENANTS AND
PROVIDE MUCH MEET NEEDED REALLY.
FOR MILLIONS OF CAL. WITH ME TO.
AND OF THE IS BRANDED. IN
OPERATIONS MANAGER FROM SAN
FRANCISCO MEDICAL RESPITE AND
SOBERING CENTER. AND BEATRIZ
HERNANDEZ FROM THE CALIFORNIA
IMMIGRANT POLICY CENTER. ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU FLEISCHER'S.
AFTER HEARING CHAIR AND MEMBERS
MY NAME IS BETTY SAID MAN THIS I
AM A STATE AWAY ORGANIZED WITH
THE CALIFORNIA IMMIGRANT POLICY
CENTER. AND ALSO A RENTER HERE
IN CALIFORNIA. I'M HERE TO
SHARE. WITH YOU MY PERSONAL
EXPERIENCE OF RENTING AS AN
EMIGRATE INTERSTATE- MY TIME AS
A COLLEGE STUDENT I USED TO
MERCED THEY'VE BEEN IN THE
CENTRAL VALLEY. WAS REMARKABLY
MORE REASONABLE COMPARED TO
OTHER COLLEGE TOWNS. THE ADDED
ADVANTAGE WAS THAT YOU WE EVEN
RECEIVE MORE LIVING SPACE FOR
MONEY. AND FRESHLY BUILT HOMES
THAT WERE CLOSE PROXIMITY TO
CAMPUS IN QUITE NEIGHBORHOODS.
HOWEVER HAVING A ROOF OVER MY
HEAD WAS NOT WITHOUT ITS
CHALLENGES. AS AN UNDOCUMENTED
STUDENT WITHOUT DACA. I FACING
HER OF MANAGING TO PAY A
SECURITY DEPOSIT UP FRONT
DESPITE NOT HAVING A SIMPLE
ACCESS TO EMPLOYMENT. THE
SITUATION WAS FAR MORE IDEAL.
FAR FROM IDEAL BUT ATTENDED
COLLEGE DEGREE WAS EXTREMELY
IMPORTANT TO ME. SO I ACCEPTED
EVERY OPPORTUNITY I CAN GET MY
HANDS ON WHETHER WAS WORKING
OVER AT NIGHT. CLEAN ENOUGH FOOD
MAX OR DOING AN INTERNSHIP AT AN
ORGANIZATION THAT THEY DON'T
CLOSE THE DOOR SUMMIT DUE TO MY
STATUS. SINCE GRADUATED. I HAVE
MORE FIVE TIMES WITH THREE OF
THOSE MOVES OCCURRING WITHIN A
SPACE OF LESS THAN A YEAR HERE
IN SACRAMENTO. EACH TIME I MOVE
A FORCING CIRCUMSTANCES. FORCED
ME TO CHANGE MY LIVING
SITUATION. IN MY CURRENT
APARTMENT MY SECURITY DEPOSIT
SIX DOLLARS THAN MY MONTHLY
RENT. MY LANDLORD EXPLAINED THAT
BECAUSE OF MY RENTAL HISTORY OF
MOVING FREQUENTLY. I HAD TO PAY
A HIGHER DEPOSIT. THE REASONS
FOR MY MOTHER'S WERE OUT OF MY
CONTROL BUT I STILL HAVE TO. BUT
I STILL HAVE TO UNFORTUNATELY
DEAL WITH THE REPERCUSSIONS. TO
ME HIGH SECURITY DEPOSITS FEEL
LIKE A PUNISHMENT FOR RENTING
RATHER THAN OWNING. HOWEVER HOW
CAN WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
OWN WHEN COLLINS VERY SUCH AS
THIS ONE STATE AND OUR WAY. I
SAY WE BECAUSE I AM NOT THE ONLY
ONE DEAL WITH THIS UNFORTUNATE
REALITY. CONSIDER THE HUNDREDS
OF COMMUNITIES AND FAMILIES AND
THE CENTRAL VALLEY. WHO WERE
DISPLACED FROM THEIR HOMES DUE
TO RECENT FLOODS. FORCING MANY
OF THEM TO RESUME LOOKING FOR
OTHER RENTAL SITUATION AND
FORCING OTHERS INTO SHELTERS.
HAD THIS BILL BEEN IMPLEMENTED
WHY WAS A STUDENT. IT WOULD HAVE
SIGNIFICANTLY HELPED ME FOCUS
MORE ON SCHOOL AND THAT'S SO
HARD TO MAKE ENDS MEET. IT IS
EVEN MORE URGENT NOW AS WE
CONTINUE TO SEE RISING COST OF
LIVING AND THEN. LIVING AND
NATURAL DISASTERS THAT KEEPS
TAKING PLACE. IMMIGRANT
CALIFORNIA'S DESERVE FOR ACCESS
TO HOUSING AND AB TWELVE WILL
HELP ENSURE THIS. THANK YOU AND
I RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR EIGHT.
THANK YOU. HELLO GOOD AFTERNOON
EVERYBODY MY NAME IS BRANDON
DAWKINS I AM DEVICE PRESIDENT
ORGANIZER FOR SEIU LOCAL TEN TO
ONE I AM ALSO A HELP WORK WITH
THE SAN FRANCISCO DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH. AND YOU KNOW I
KNOW FIRST HAND HOW DIFFICULT IT
IS FOR YOU KNOW A LOT OF THE
WORKING CLASS OF FOLKS IN SAN
FRANCISCO. TO AFFORD HOUSING A
NUMBER ONE. NOT ONLY THE RIGHT
TO HIGH BUT NUMBER TWO THE
SECURITY DEPOSITS ARE EXTREMELY
HIGH- WE HAVE SIXTEEN THOUSAND
OF OUR MEMBERS THAT WORK FOR THE
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN
FRANCISCO. HOWEVER EIGHTY FIVE
THOUSAND EIGHTY FIVE HUNDRED OF
US DO NOT LIVE IN SAN FRANCISCO
IN ONE OF THE BARRIERS. IS B. IT
IS THE SECURITY DEPOSIT. A
SECURITY DEPOSIT SKILL CAN COME
YOU KNOW IT'S CLOSE TO LIKE
SEVEN THOUSAND DOLLARS ON TOP OF
YOU KNOW THIRTY FIVE HUNDRED
DOLLARS A MONTH FOR RENT. WHICH
YOU KNOW BECAUSE AS YOU KNOW
EXTREME BARRIERS FOR US TO THE
FACT THAT TO THE POINT THAT-
FOLKS ARE LIVING IN SACRAMENTO.
AND COMMUTING TO SAN FRANCISCO
ON A DAILY BASIS BECAUSE- THAT'S
WHERE THEY CAN AFFORD- IN
ADDITION TO THAT YOU KNOW. ON
TOP OF A SECURITY DEPOSIT EVEN
THOUGH YEAH THEY'RE ASKING FOR
THAT UP FRONT. BUT MANY OF OUR
MANY OF THE WORKERS DO NOT HAVE
THAT SECURITY DEPOSIT TO PAY UP
FRONT. SO THAT MEANS THAT THEY
ARE SCRAMBLING TO TRY TO. FIND
SOMEBODY WHO CAN LOAN THEM THE
MONEY FOR SECURITY DEPOSIT. AND
IS NO GUARANTEE THAT THEY'LL GET
THAT SECURITY DEPOSIT BACK. SO
WE ARE ASKING FOR YOU ALL FOR A
YES VOTE ONE. AB TWELVE SO THAT
READERS WILL ACTUALLY HAVE A
FAIR CHANCE. OF NOT ONLY A SAN
FRANCISCO BUT ACROSS THE STATE.
ACTUALLY AFFORD TO LIVE WHERE
THEY WORK. AND NOT HAVE TO PAY
OUTRAGEOUS. SECURITY DEPOSIT SO
THAT THEY COULD ACTUALLY HAVE A-
QUALITY OF LIFE. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT OTHERS PART
OF YOUR PRO TO MY- GIVE US YOUR
NAME YOUR PHILLY. BECAUSE BACK I
CRAVE MATTER BEHALF OF A SEAL.
CAL ACT. IS A- BURKE IS TO DRUM
OF THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD
OF SUPERVISORS AND SUPPORT. YOU
GOOD AFTERNOON SYLVIA SO LEASE
SHAH HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
OF SANTA MONICA AND STRONG
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. HI
FAITHFULLY WITH ASIAN AMERICANS
ADVANCING JUSTICE SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA HERE. IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU- TRACY. ROSENBERG JUST
SPEAKING ON MY OWN BEHALF AS A
CALIFORNIA RENTER IN SENATOR
SKINNER'S DISTRICT. FOR TWENTY
YEARS THANK YOU. AND WHERE IS
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
COALITION FOR YOUTH IN SUPPORT.
MATT WAS A ABOUT BUT AS YOU
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. MITCH
SNIDER WITH THE CALIFORNIA LABOR
FEDERATION ALSO IN SUPPORT.
JONTRON CALIFORNIA NURSES
ASSOCIATION IN STRONG SUPPORT.
IS THIS SOME OF THE SAN
FRANCISCO BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
IN SUPPORT. MONEY LAWLER ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA RURAL
LEGAL ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION THE
NATIONAL HOUSING LAW PROJECT IN
THE BERKELEY RENT BOARD IN
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON JANICE
MELLIE ASKS ME IN SUPPORT. HELLO
KATHY MANZINI ON BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT. GOOD
AFTERNOON MY NAME IS POOREST
KAMAN ON BEHALF OF THE WESTERN
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
HELLO CLOSE STUCK THE CALIFORNIA
IMMIGRANT POLICY CENTER IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT
LET'S TURN TO OPPOSITION NOW-
THOSE OPPOSITION. GOOD AFTERNOON
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS DIFFICULTY
WITH THE CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
ASSOCIATION WE CERTAINLY
APPRECIATE THE GOAL. OF AB
TWELVE I THINK THE CHALLENGE FOR
RENTAL PROPERTY OWNERS AND
CERTAINLY SMALL RENTAL PROPERTY
OWNERS IS IT IS VERY EXPENSIVE
TO OPERATE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA
TODAY- YOU KNOW IN THE
UNFORTUNATE SITUATION WHERE THE
LANDLORD IS UNABLE TO WORK IT
OUT WITH THE TENANT WHO DOESN'T
PAY THE RENT AND THEY HAVE TO
GO. TO COURT TO EVICT AGAIN
UNFORTUNATE SITUATION I'M IT CAN
TAKE MONTHS UP TO SIX MONTHS IN
COURT- IN THE TYPICAL COSTS AND
LOSS OF RENT IN THOSE SITUATIONS
AS WELL OVER TEN THOUSAND
DOLLARS. YOU KNOW REDUCING THE
SECURITY DEPOSIT IS GOING TO BE
HELPFUL FOR THE OWNERS IN THIS
SITUATION I'M SURE LAMB OR CAN
GO TO COURT AFTER AN ATTEMPT TO
COLLECT. BUT MOST OF THOSE
CASES- THAT A DEBT IS NOT GOING
TO BE COLLECTIBLE- IN IN THE
LANDLORD IN THE NEXT SITUATION-
IS NOT GOING TO KNOW THAT THE
TENANT- FAILED TO PAY THE RENT
BECAUSE IN CALIFORNIA WE MASK.
OUR COURT PROCESS FOR EVICTION
SO. UNFORTUNATELY IT MAY HAPPEN
THIS THE SECOND OWNER AGAIN SO I
THINK WHAT'S HAPPENING
CALIFORNIA IS THOSE SECURITY
DEPOSITS HAVE EITHER GONE TO THE
MAXIMUM AMOUNT WHICH IS
TYPICALLY TWO TIMES THE AMOUNT.
THREE TIMES IS IF YOU HAVE A
UNIT THAT IS FURNISHED WHICH IS
PRETTY RARE BUT I THINK WHAT
WE'RE WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH IS
SOME OF THE UNFORTUNATE
SITUATIONS. IN THE COURT COSTS
AND WHAT OWNERS ARE FACING CODE
HAS CERTAINLY LED TO THAT
UNFORTUNATE SITUATION FOR
EVERYONE SO THANK YOU VERY. MUCH
FOR HEARING OUR CONCERNS THANK
YOU. OTHERS IN OPPOSITION THINGS
ONE ELSE APPROACHING. LET'S NOT
. OVER THEY WERE GO ONE MORE.
ARE THOSE TODAY SO THAT OF MORAN
IN REDUCED TRIP SOMETHING.
HOUSING IS. AND UP FOR SOME
REASONS- STATED BY THIS CALLED.
I THINK YOU MISTER MORAN ALL
RIGHT. ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION
ALL RIGHT LET'S TURN THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION. TO A. B.
ONE TWO AB TWELVE. IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO H. E. TWELFTH.
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO. AND
FIRST WE'LL HEAR FROM LINE
EIGHTY SEVEN. MY NAME IS
RAMBLING SHANDERMAN NUMBER
ADELINE APARTMENT SO SHE XIN AND
ARE PROUD TO BE A- AB TWELVE DUE
TO. JERRY DAMAGES ARE NOT SIZE
ALLOWED THANK YOU. SO OF YOU WAY
ON THE PHONE LINE GIVE US YOUR-
YOUR- AND YOUR FILIATION. AND
THAT'S IT ALL. RIGHT LINE TO OH
FOUR. HELLO YES WE CAN HEAR YOU.
HI I'M A SMALL PROPERTY OWNER
AND- SO IN CALIFORNIA AND I HAVE
DONE SOMETHING UNHEARD OF WHICH
IS HOLDING MY PROPERTY RENTS FOR
HONORABLY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MA'AM ARE YOU TO PUT YOUR POST.
ALL RIGHT LET'S GO THE NEXT
ONLINE THANK YOU. LINE TO FORTY
. THANK YOU FORTY PLEASE GO
AHEAD. YES SORRY MY NAME IS THE
NEED FOR AN END OF THE NINE THE
RENTER IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY AND
I AM. THE PORT THANK YOU. FIND
FREE. GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS GREEN GREASE ON BEHALF
CALIFORNIA'S THIRTIETH OF
REALTORS STRONG OPPOSITION
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST A NO VOTE
THANK YOU THANK YOU. NINE ONE
FORTY SEVEN. HELLO COMMITTEE ON
THEIR THE VALUE OF THE TOTAL THE
TERROR. IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
FIVE THREE THIRTY FOUR. HI WILL
FIVE I- SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF
THE LITTLE THAT FOLLOW. AS WHICH
WRAPS OVER AND THOUSAND WE FOUND
BY TO THEM I'M MORE ARE FOR
THANK YOU. FIVE THREE THIRTY
SIX. HELLO MEDINA THAT WALLET
YEAH TO W. F. AND FROM STRONG
THANK YOU. BY THREE THIRTY
EIGHT. BROWN'S SPEAK ON BEHALF
OF THE COUPLE TEACHES US. VERY
OUR THANK YOU. WHY FORTY. GIVE
ME MY ON THE OF CS HE IS SUPPORT
THANK YOU. FOUR NINE THREE FOUR
FOUR. GREGORY CRIME ON BEHALF OF
THIS RIGHTS CALIFORNIA IN FROM.
THANK YOU MY. THREE DAN OKAY
BECAUSE THE BACK HALF OF THE
POINT SUNDAY FOR AN LIVING AND
IN SOME. THANK YOU LIFE LINE.
THREE FOUR SEVEN. I GET
AFTERNOON REBEKAH WITH THE NASA
THOSE OF WORK HELLO CHAU IN PORT
THANK YOU. MISTER CHAIR THERE
ARE NO FOR COMMA THAT TIME ALL
RIGHT LET'S BRING BY COMMITTEE
QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
OUR THE NEW YELLOW. THANK YOU
CHAIR- SO I APPRECIATE WHICH
TRYING TO DO THEIR NO DOUBT
THAT- HOUSING AND RENTAL PRICES
ARE VERY HIGH AND CALIFORNIA FOR
ANY NUMBER OF REASONS. WEEKEND I
TRY TO- DELINEATE THEM ALL BUT-
RIGHT MERRILY COST SUPPLY- IT
CETERA. OTHERS AND I UNDERSTAND
THAT- A SECURITY DEPOSIT HIGH
SECURITY PROJECT CAN BE A
BARRIER TO RENTING. BUT AT THE
SAME TIME A LIMITATION ON A
SECURITY DEPOSIT IN THERE FOR A
LIMITATION ON A LANDLORD. BEING
ABLE TO MITIGATE- HIS OR HER
RISK TO ANY NUMBER OF THINGS-
BUT THAT CAN HAPPEN IN A RENTAL
AGREEMENT NONPAYMENT OF RENT
DAMAGE AT THE END OF THE- OF
RENTAL PERIOD- THAT PRESENTS A
BARRIER TO- THE LANDLORD. SO SO
WHICH IS IT- THE- A PROVIDING
LOWER COST TO THE RENTER. OR
PERHAPS DOING THINGS THAT.
DISCOURAGE THE VERY SUPPLY
ITSELF I MIGHT ALSO ADD BY THE
WAY THAT THERE ARE VARIOUS WAYS
THAT. A LANDLORD COULD MANAGE
THIS. IF WE PASS THIS AND IT CAN
ONLY BE ONE MONTHS SECURITY
DEPOSIT A LANDLORD COULD DECIDE
WELL. THAT'S NOT ENOUGH FOR ME
TO MITIGATE MY RISK OF
NONPAYMENT OR DAMAGE AT THE END
SO I'LL JUST RAISE MY MONTHLY
RENT BY FIFTY BUCKS. IF THERE'S
RENT CONTROL OBVIOUSLY THAT'S A
LITTLE BIT MORE DIFFICULT BUT
THEN EXACERBATES THE SUPPLY
QUESTION BUT I REYES SO. IT
SEEMS TO ME WITH ATTEMPTS LIKE
THIS WE END UP. CHASING OUR
POLICY TALE. AND I THINK IT'S A
FLAWED APPROACH. ALL RIGHT DO
YOU WANT TO RESPOND THAT YOU'RE
CLOTHES ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS YES
THAT OUR S. B. THANK YOU. NICE
TO SEE A SIMILAR RAINY AND THAT
. THANKS FOR BRINGING US THE
SPELL I AM IN A SUPPORTED TODAY
BY I HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS FOR
YOU AND ALSO STATEMENT ABOUT WHY
I'M GONNA SUPPORT THIS SO. I WAS
A SINGLE MOM FOR A LONG TIME I
LIVE IN LOW INCOME HOUSING HERE
AND THERE THERE WERE A COUPLE
PEOPLE IS SPOKEN ONE OF THE
PRIMARY SPEAKER SAID YOU HAVE TO
MOVE A LOT THAT'S REALLY TRUE
WHEN YOU'RE- LIKE A YOUNG SINGLE
PARENT I HAD TO MOVE BECAUSE
THEY RAISE THE RENT YOU KNOW
EVERY YEAR OR SOMETHING YOU KNOW
YOU'RE IN THIS BRACKET SO YOU
CAN ONLY. STAY THERE AS LONG AS
THE RENT IS IN THAT BRACKET AND
THEN YOU HAVE TO FIND ANOTHER
PLACE SO- AND THERE WERE
CERTAINLY TIMES THAT I HAD TO
WEIGH IN. TO THAT FACTOR IN CAN
I AFFORD THE SECURITY DEPOSIT OR
THEY ASK ME FOR FIRST AND LAST
SO. I HAVE NOT TOO LONG AGO
FIRSTHAND EXPERIENCE WITH THAT
RECOGNIZE IT'S A BIG ISSUE AND
ESPECIALLY FOR THIS YOUNGER
GENERATION AND OUR OLDER
GENERATION BOTH OF WHOM. ARE
TRYING TO FIND THEIR SPOT IN ALL
OF THIS- WITH WITH LIMITED
INCOME. SO BUT I DO HAVE THREE
QUESTIONS FOR YOU BECAUSE AS I
HAVE. TALKED TO THE SUSSEX
SITUATION WITH SOME OF MY
COLLEAGUES IN THE SENATE. WHEN
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT RENT AND
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT RENTAL
HOUSING IT LOOKS SO DIFFERENT.
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AND PEOPLE YOU SAN FRANCISCO AS
AN EXAMPLE BUT- SAN FRANCISCO IS
SO DIFFERENT. THAN LA IN LA SO
DIFFERENT IN SACRAMENTO IN TERMS
OF WHO OWNS THESE RENTALS WHO'S
MANAGING THESE RENTALS. AND WHAT
IT'S LIKE IN IN MY DISTRICT
THERE ARE A LOT OF SMALL.
LANDLORDS LIKE. LIKE AN OLDER
PERSON WHO KEPT THEIR FAMILY
HOME USE ASIDE AS PART OF THEIR
INCOME THEY'RE NOT WEALTHY. THEY
RELY ON THAT AND THEY YOU KNOW.
ARE THEY NEED THAT THERE'S A LOT
OF THAT ACTUALLY IN SACRAMENTO
SO. THESE ARE MY THREE QUESTIONS
FOR YOU. YOU ALREADY HAVE MY
SUPPORT BY LOVE TO KNOW WHAT
YOU'RE WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT
THESE THREE THINGS AND HOW YOUR-
HOW YOU'RE FEELING ABOUT THEM I
KNOW YOU'VE WORKED REALLY HARD
WITH THE OPPONENTS TO AND I
APPRECIATE THAT ABOUT YOU. I
KNOW THERE WAS A REQUEST FOR THE
IMPLEMENTATION TO BE DELAYED BY
SIX MONTHS AND YOU HAVE YOU
AGREED TO THAT ALREADY. ALL WELL
MAYBE OKAY YEAH I HAVEN'T AGREED
TO ANYTHING ELSE BUT ALL OKAY
BECAUSE HE'S ALRIGHT. OKAY SORRY
I MISUNDERSTOOD I THOUGHT THAT
YOU HAD SAID THAT ONE WAS JUST
TO GIVE PEOPLE AN OPPORTUNITY
FOR COMPLIANCE IT WASN'T LIKE. A
FOR ANY PARTICULAR REASON OTHER
THAN IMPLEMENTATION. AND THEN.
THAT THE THAT THIS WOULD BE A
FORWARD FACING BILL MEANING NOT
RETROACTIVE SO THAT FOLKS THAT
JUST ENTERED INTO LEAST WOULDN'T
HAVE TO GO BACK AND RENEGOTIATE
OR- DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT THAN
WHAT THEY HAD DONE. BECAUSE IT
MAY CHANGE THE PROCESS FOR WHAT.
EITHER SIDE HOW THEY WOULD HAVE
HANDLED IT OR WHAT THEY WOULD IT
WHERE THEY WOULD HAVE GONE. AND
THEN THIRD MY LAST ONE IS HAVE
YOU THOUGHT ABOUT THAT SMALL
LANDLORD ISSUE AND ARE YOU DO
YOU HAVE A PLAN TO TALK TO THE-
SALES OF THE THREE MATCH. GREAT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER. THE YOU. THANK
YOU SENATOR. AND EVERY. ALL ALL
THREE OF. IN CERTAIN- INCOME. TO
WORKING WITH OPPOSITE. ON ALL
THREE OF THOSE ISSUES MOVING
FORWARD. I CERTAINLY OUR OUR IN
OUR INTENTION WAS NEVER TO HAVE
THIS BE. RETROACTIVE IF YOU'VE
ALREADY. GIVEN AT A SECURITY
DEPOSIT- THIS WOULD NOT MEAN
THAT A PORTION OF IT WOULD BE
RETURNED- THEY'VE ALREADY MADE
THAT- EXCHANGE- SO THIS WOULD BE
MOVING FORWARD AND WOULD BE
HAPPY TO MANDATE TO. TO MAKE
THAT CLEAR. I'M I'M OPEN TO SOME
SORT OF. DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION
AND I WANT TO TALK ABOUT WHAT
MAKES SENSE THERE SO THAT. THEY
HAVE THE TIME YOU KNOW IF YOU
ALREADY HAVE A LISTING UP IN THE
YOU KNOW I. GET GET THAT AS WELL
SO. DEFINITELY OPEN TO THAT AS
WELL. AND I'VE AND I'VE ALWAYS
SAID- AND I. DIDN'T SAID THIS IN
THE ASSEMBLY AS WELL- MOVING
FORWARD IF THIS GOES OUT OF
COMMITTEE. WE WILL LOOK AT. SOME
WAY OF TREATING SOME SET OF
SMALLER PROPERTY OWNERS
DIFFERENTLY UNDERSTAND IF IT'S
YOUR ONE HOME OR ONE OR YOU KNOW
YOU. OWN YOU LIVE IN ONE AND YOU
RENT ONE OF THE LEVEL OF RISK
THAT YOU'RE TAKING ON IT. IS A
BIT DIFFERENT. AND SO- WE WILL
WORK ON THAT WITH THE OPPOSITION
MOVING FORWARD I THINK WE'RE- AT
A POINT OF SORT OF DISCUSSING
WHAT'S THE RIGHT NUMBER OF UNITS
AND- AND THAT KIND OF THING BUT-
WHEN IT. IF IT COMES OUT
COMMITTEE. I WILL COMMIT TO
DOING SOMETHING ON THAT AND
HOPEFULLY IN AN AGREEMENT. WITH
THE OPPOSITION. OKAY AND IN THE
MEANTIME YOU'RE GONNA HELP A LOT
OF YOUNG PEOPLE AND PEOPLE ON
FIXED INCOMES AND SINGLE MOMS
AND ASPIRANTS SO. HE JOB IN WITH
US AFTER SOME ALL MOVE YOUR BILL
T. PAY. THANK YOU AND THERE'S
YEAH WOULD WANT TO KNOW THERE'S
A HUGE NUMBER WERE. PEOPLE WHO
ARE HERE WELL. WHO I THINK ARE
SUPER. IT THE- OF. THAT ALL IF
YOU YOUR JOB OR YOUR- OUR- AWAY
WHERE YOU WORK OR YOUR KIDS GO
TO SCHOOL YOU NEED TO BE CLOSELY
WITH YOUR FAMILY THERE'S A LOT
OF REASONS WHY. WORKING PEOPLE
HAVE TO MOVE. OUT YOU KNOW YOU
HAVE ANOTHER BABY IS A LOT OF.
REASONS AND RIGHT NOW I THIS
PRESENTS A HUGE BARRIER AND IT
HAS A LOT OF RIPPLE EFFECTS AND
I KNOW YOU. UNDERSTAND THAT
FIRSTHAND AS WELL THANK YOU.
READY THANK YOU- ROSS THANK YOU
MISS. CHAIR IF YOU. HAVE A ONE.
IN AN AVERAGE. STATE IS EIGHTEEN
HUNDRED DOLLARS. IF YOU MAKE
MINIMUM WAGE YOU HAVE TO WORK
NINETY HOURS A WEEK. TO BE ABLE
TO AFFORD THAT. THAT RENT. SO
CLEARLY. THERE'S A REAL. SERIOUS
PROBLEM- I HAVE A VERY
SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE OF. OF
THE PEOPLE IN MY DISTRICT ARE
RENTERS ONE OF THE HIGHEST
PERCENTAGES. IN THE STATE SO
THIS IS OF. GREAT CONCERN. BUT
IT'S OBVIOUSLY NOT A GREAT
CONCERN JUST IN CALIFORNIA. IF
TWELVE STATES. TWELVE STATES
FROM ALABAMA TO NEW YORK. OF
RHODE ISLAND I MEAN WE COULD GO
ON AND ON TWELVE STATES HAVE
PASSED- THAT. A REQUIREMENT OF
NO MORE THAN ONE. OR ONE AND A
HALF MONTHS MONTHS RENT SO. THIS
IS SOMETHING THAT IS HAPPENING
ACROSS THE COUNTRY. NOT JUST IN
CALIFORNIA- AND- YOU ALL RIGHT I
UNDERSTAND THAT WE BOUGHT A
SIMILAR BILL- JUST A FEW YEARS
AGO. THAT WOULD LOWER THE
SECURITY DEPOSITS FOR ACTIVE
SERVICE MEMBERS A WHICH IS A
GREAT THING TO DO BUT I DO THINK
THAT IT'S TIME TO DO THIS FOR.
ALL RENTERS AND NOT HAVE. OF
SOME COVERED IN SOME NOT COVERED
SO- BE GLAD TO SUPPORT YOUR
BILL. THANK YOU OTHER COMMENTS
OR QUESTIONS SEEING NONE. ALL
RIGHT- THANK YOU SUMMER HANEY
AND- ALAMY JOINTS OF MY
COLLEAGUES I APPRECIATE YOUR
FLEXIBILITY IN DEALING WITH SOME
OF THESE DIFFICULT ISSUES- THE
IMPACT ON SUPPLY WHICH
ULTIMATELY IS. MY HOPE THAT WILL
REDUCE. THE COST OF HOUSING THE
IMPACT ON DISCRIMINATION TERMS
OF THOSE WHO MAY DISCRIMINATE
BECAUSE THEY NO LONGER HAVE A
CAMP KIND OF SECURITY THAT THEY
ONCE HAD. THE IMPACT ON
IMPLEMENTATION AND HOW SOON IT
WOULD BE IMPLEMENTED INTO HOME
IT APPLIES SO APPRECIATE YOUR
FLEXIBILITY ON ALL THOSE ISSUES
YOUR CONSIDERATION OF SUPPLYING
DISCRIMINATION. IN WITH THAT
WOULD YOU COULD CLOSE THANK YOU
MISTER KAREN THANK YOU GOT TO
YOUR STAFF AS WELL- IN
ABSOLUTELY HAVE MIKE- I SO-
COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE TO WORK
ON THOSE ISSUES AS YOU MOVE
FORWARD. I TOTALLY AGREE AND
APPRECIATE THAT ULTIMATELY WHEN
WE THINK ABOUT HOW WE SOLVE OUR
HOUSING CRISIS IN OUR STATE WE
HAVE TO BUILD A LOT MORE HOUSING
WE HAVE TO INCREASE. THE SUPPLY-
THAT'S GOING TO TAKE SOME TIME
THIS BILL WILL PROVIDE SOME
IMMEDIATE RELIEF TO FOLKS WHO
ARE TRYING TO FOR THE RENTER
NEED TO MOVE TO ANOTHER PLACE
AND RIGHT NOW THEY'RE GOING INTO
DEBT THEREFORE GOING OTHER.
NECESSITIES WHETHER STAYING VERY
FAR FROM WHERE THEY WORK OR GO
TO SCHOOL I'M I BELIEVE THIS IS
A BALANCED APPROACH AND IT'S
FAIR I UNDERSTAND- THAT THE
CONTINUING ISSUES THAT WE HAVE
TO WORK ON MOVING FORWARD AND
YOU HAVE MY COMMITMENT ON THAT
AND- WITH THAT RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR RIVALS. RT THANK YOU
ASSEMBLY AS CENTER ASHLEY'S MOVE
THE BILL. M. SECTOR IF YOU WOULD
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER THREE AB TWELVE THE
MOTION IS TO PASS NUMBER. HI
BURKE AYE WILK. L. ALLEN I.
ASHBY ASHBY. COVER YOUR- THE
REST. RUSSELL I LIVE. MEN NEW
LOW. YOU STERN. RIGHT STERN AYE
WE- A FIVE TO ONE MEMBER'S
MISSING FIVE FIVE ONE WILL PUT
THAT ON CALL. NEXT YOU HAVE A.
B. EIGHT SIXTEEN I. UNDERSTAND
THAT THERE IS NO AT LEAST
OPPOSITION ON FILE- THANK THANK
YOU- I KNOW THIS THIS IS A- IN
ISSUE YOU ALL A VERY FAMILIAR
WITH IN A LOT OF WAYS- AND THE
NEED THAT WE WORK IN EVERY WAY
WE CAN TO MAKE IT A LOT HARDER
TO GET. THAT THE OPIATES LIKE
FENTANYL A LOT EASIER TO GET
TREATMENT- THAT HAS TO INCLUDE
OUR- YOUNG PEOPLE- OPIOID
OVERDOSES NOW ACCOUNT FOR ONE
OUT OF EVERY FIVE DEATHS OF
MINORS. AND ENROLLING. PEOPLE
ESPECIALLY YOUNG PEOPLE IN
MEDICALLY PROVEN TREATMENTS AS
EARLY AS POSSIBLE IT'S ONE OF
THE BEST TOOLS WE HAVE TO SAVE
LIVES. THE MOST EFFECTIVE
TREATMENT FOR OPIOID ADDICTION
IS BUPRENORPHINE ALSO OFTEN
REFERRED TO AS SUBOXONE IT DEALS
WITH THE DEVASTATING PHYSICAL
SYMPTOMS OF WITHDRAWAL CAN HELP
PEOPLE GET OFF DRUGS ENTIRELY.
IT CONTAINS NALOXONE WHICH IS
THE PRIMARY SUBSTANCE IN OUR
CAMP SO YOU CAN'T OVERDOSE ON ON
IT AND IT'S SAFE UNDER THE USE
OF A SUFFICIENT AS- A
SUPERVISION OF A PHYSICIAN.
RIGHT NOW YOU SEE WHO ARE
ADDICTED TO OPIOIDS NEED CONSENT
FROM THEIR PARENTS WENT WRONG
DEEPER NORTHEAST. TREATMENT AND
THANKFULLY MOST YOUNG PEOPLE WHO
HAVE SUPPORT FROM PARENTS AND
WILL HAVE SUPPORTING PARENTS IN
SEEKING THIS TREATMENT. BUT SOME
YOUNG PEOPLE TRAGICALLY WILL
HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO SEEK
TREATMENT ON THEIR OWN OFTEN
BECAUSE THEY'RE HOMELESS. HAVE
PARENTS WHO THEMSELVES ARE
ADDICTED OR ABSENT OR HAVE A
LEGITIMATE FEAR OF ASKING FOR
HELP. UNDER CURRENT LAW THESE
USE WILL BE PROHIBITED FROM
GETTING INVOLVED IN
BUPRENORPHINE TREATMENT.
EVERYONE CONCERNED ABOUT THIS
EPIDEMIC SHOULD FIND COMMON
GROUND AND LOWERING BARRIERS TO
ACCESS- THIS EVIDENCE PROVING
TREATMENT I AM TURNING AWAY
SIXTEEN AND SEVENTEEN YEAR OLDS
IS ONLY APPLYING TO SIXTEEN AND
SEVENTEEN YEAR OLDS. WHO ARE
ONLY ALLOWED TO EAT- IN ROLE IN
THIS UNDER THE FDA APPROVAL. A
TURNING THEM AWAY WOULD BE OUR
RECKLESS WRONG AND POTENTIALLY
DEADLY. I'M WE SHOULD BE
ENCOURAGING PEOPLE TO SEEK
TREATMENT I'M A WILL SAVE LIVES.
I AND SO HERE TO TESTIFY WITH ME
TODAY IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
IS DR CONGDON A CERTIFIED A
PEDIATRICIAN WAS TESTIFYING ON
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY
OF PEDIATRICS. WHO ARE THE
SPONSORS OF THIS BILL. THANK YOU
DR FLOOR. GOOD AFTERNOON I'M DR
JIM KHANDAN A PEDIATRICIAN ON
BEHALF OF THE- ACADEMY OF
PEDIATRICS. CALIFORNIA YOUTH AND
FAMILIES ARE FACING AN
UNPRECEDENTED OPIOID CRISIS THE
RATES OF YOUNG PEOPLE DEVELOPING
OPIOID ADDICTION AND OPIOID
OVERDOSES HAVE SKYROCKETED.
SUBSTANCE USE IS NOW THE THIRD
LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH IN KID.
WE HAVE A SAFE AND EFFECTIVE
TREATMENT FOR OPIOID ADDICTION
BUPRENORPHINE IS FDA APPROVED
FOR AGES SIXTEEN AND UP. AND IT
IS RECOMMENDED BY THE AMERICAN
ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS. HOWEVER
LESS THAN 5% OF YOUNG PEOPLE
WITH OPIOID ADDICTION HAVE
ACCESS TO THIS LIFESAVING
TREATMENT. KEY BARRIER THAT
PREVENTS YOUNG PEOPLE IN
CALIFORNIA FROM GETTING
TREATMENT WITH BUPRENORPHINE IS
THE NEED FOR CARE GIVER CONSENT.
I WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT
PEDIATRICIANS ALWAYS MAKE EVERY
EFFORT TO ENGAGE PARENTS AND
CARE GIVERS IN THE TREATMENT OF
MINORS. HOWEVER SOMETIMES THIS
IS JUST NOT POSSIBLE. TO
ILLUSTRATE HOW THE PRINTER
CONSENT REQUIREMENT SOMETIMES
PLAYS OUT I'LL SHARE THE STORY
OF THE PATIENT WILL REFER TO A
CV. CV IS A SEVENTEEN YEAR OLD
GIRL WHO HAD BEEN USING FENTANYL
DAILY FOR THE PAST YEAR. SHE
CAME IN FOR TREATMENT WITH HER
MOTHER A SINGLE PARENT WHO ALSO
HAD A COULD USE DISORDER AND HAD
BEEN DOING WELL AND HER OWN
TREATMENT PROGRAM. WHEN WE FIRST
MET CB SHE WAS HOSPITALIZED FOR
ACUTE OPIOID WITHDRAWAL. AND
WITH HER MOTHER SUPPORT SHE
SUCCESSFULLY STARTED PEOPLE ARE
FLEEING DURING HER HOSPITAL
STAY. SHE WAS SCHEDULED TO AFTER
DISCHARGE SEE AN OUTPATIENT
PROVIDER FOR PEOPLE WORKING
MAINTENANCE TREATMENT. HOWEVER
BEFORE CV'S OUTPATIENT
APPOINTMENT HER MOTHER SADLY
RELAPSED. AND LEFT THEIR HOME.
THE CITY CAME HER FOLLOW UP
APPOINTMENT ALONE BUT WE WERE
NOT ABLE TO GIVE HER ONGOING
TREATMENT WITHOUT. CONSENT. FOR
EXISTING CALIFORNIA LAW. CITY
MADE A DISH TIME WE RISK. HER
SHE SHOULD HAVE SOME TIMES
WITHOUT HER. OR HER MOTHER.
NEVER ULTIMATELY SHOW. AN THEN
WITHOUT ACCESS TO TREAT. CITY
ULTIMATELY RELAPSE HERSELF. I
CAN TELL YOU ABOUT OTHERS MINERS
WERE AND HOW. OF HER AND SEE
LIVING SITUATIONS. AB EIGHT
SIXTEEN IT WOULD INCREASE ACCESS
TO CARE ESPECIALLY AMONG THESE
MOST VULNERABLE YOUTH FOR WHOM
THE CONSENT REQUIREMENT IS OFTEN
DELAYING TREATMENT OR PREVENTING
TREATMENT ACCESS ALL TOGETHER.
WHICH IN THE CASE OF OPIATE
ADDICTION. MEANS HI IMMINENT
RISK OF OVERDOSE FOR DA. THE
UNFORTUNATE REALITY IS THAT
TEENS ARE ALREADY THANK YOU
DOCTOR IF YOU WRAP IT UP. THE
IMPORTANT REALITIES THAT ARE
ALREADY GETTING FENTANYL WITHOUT
PARENTAL CONSENT. WE'VE HEARD
AGAIN AND AGAIN FROM TEAM SAID
IT IS SO MUCH EASIER TO GET
FENTANYL THAN IT IS TO GET
TREATMENT FOR FENTANYL
ADDICTION. SO IN THE MIDST OF
THIS OPIOID CRISIS EIGHT I'M
CONFIDENT THIS TO MAKE A HUGELY
IMPACTFUL ARE NOT INCREASING
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OKAY. OTHERS
IN SUPPORT. SEEING NO ONE ELSE
PRO TO MY PHONE IS- EXCEPT FOR
ME TO TESTIMONY GO AHEAD. YES
CAN LAST REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR YOUTH
IN SUPPORT. THIS IS YOUR MEMBERS
THE COMMITTEE BRAND IN MARCH
WITH THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU. RISES ON BEHALF OF THE SAN
FRANCISCO AIDS FOUNDATION IN
SUPPORT. NORTHLAND ON BEHALF OF
CHILDREN NOW IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. IS THIS ONE ARE BEHALF THE
CHILD CALIFORNIA ACADEMY OF
CHILD AND ADOLESCENT
PSYCHIATRIST IN THE CALIFORNIA
CITIES ASSOCIATION PSYCHIATRIST
AND SPORT THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
LET'S TURN THE OPPOSITION. OF
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION TO A.
B. ABOUT EIGHT SIXTEEN THING
KNOWN APPROACH TO MY PHONE'S
TURNED THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR
PLEASE QUEUE UP THOSE. WORDS
SUPPORT OR IN OPPOSITION TO AB
EIGHT SIXTEEN. IF YOU WOULD LIKE
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION. TO EIGHTY EIGHT
SIXTEEN PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
ZERO. FIRST WE'LL HEAR FROM LINE
. THREE FIFTY ONE. GOOD
AFTERNOON WORK BACK IN BOTH OF
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORKERS CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER IN SUPPORT. BLIND. FIFTY
TWO. FIVE THREE FIFTY TWO YOUR
MIKE SO PLEASE GO AHEAD- YEP
THAT THE CUMBERSOME JUST THE
HOMEOWNER WITH AN H. AWAY AND
THE REGISTERED. IN THE HILLCREST
OF TEN BECAUSE CITY OKLAHOMA DAY
FOR AND NOT THE L. B. T. Q.
HIGHER THIS. THANK YOU. WHY TWO
FIFTY FIVE. THANK YOU CHAIR
MEMBERS CORY HAS WITH STEINBERG
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK
YOU. MISTER CHAIR THERE ARE NO
COMMENT TO THIS TIME OUR BRING
IT BACK CAN QUESTIONS ARE CALM.
SIX NEAR. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
I'M A LITTLE STE AT THEIR- THE
SORT OF UP TO THE FIRST BILL
THAT WE HEARD- THERE IS LITTLE
DOUBT IN MY MIND THAT. THAT
TEENS WHO HAVE DRUG PROBLEMS
DON'T WANT TO TALK TO THEIR
PARENTS ABOUT IT. NOT BECAUSE
THEIR PARENTS ARE ABUSIVE OR
UNREASONABLE- IT WOULD NOT BE
UNNATURAL THAT. PERSON WOULD
WANT TO TALK TO THEIR PARENTS
ABOUT IT. BUT THE USE OF THIS-
DRUGS I'M NOT GONNA TRY TO
PRONOUNCE IT- REQUIRES ON GOING
CARE. IT ALLOWS THE PATIENT TO
CONTINUE USING THE DRUG WITH
THE- COUNTERING MEDICATION. SO
ONGOING CARE IS CRUCIAL. AND IT
SEEMS TO ME HE THE BEST WAY TO
ENSURE THAT ON GOING CARE- IS TO
INVOLVE. OF A DEDICATED AND
CARING PATIENT NOW. IF THERE IS
NO PARENT. SKEWS ME- AVAILABLE
FOR WHATEVER REASON I GET THAT
IN THIS CASE. I RATHER DOUBT
THAT THAT IS THE VAST MAJORITY
OF CASES- AND IF WE ARE WHERE
THERE IS A PARENT AVAILABLE
WE'RE GOING TO ALLOW THIS
BECAUSE WE'RE AFRAID OF AN
ABUSIVE PARENT. OR UNREASONABLE
PARENT OR NON CARING PARENT I
JUST ASK THE QUESTION WHAT
PERCENTAGE OF PARENTS FALL IN
THAT CATEGORY- I WOULD SUBMIT
ITS RATHER SMALL. AND THAT WERE
IMPOSING THIS- ALLOWANCE AND
THEREFORE A VIOLATION OF THE
PARENT PARENTS RESPONSIBILITY-
IN THIS CASE- WERE APPLYING IT
TO ALL FAMILIES. BOB ON A
BLANKET BASIS AND IT SEEMS TO ME
THAT THE BEST CARE FOR. THE
MINOR. FOR THE PATIENT IS THE
INVOLVEMENT OF A DEDICATED AND
CARING PATIENT SO. I JUST I
CAN'T SUPPORT THIS BILL FOR THAT
REASON. IS THERE MOTION CENTER
STAR MOST THE BILL. LOOMER HANEY
WOULD LIKE CLOSE YES AND I
APPRECIATE THAT I THINK IN THE
VAST MAJORITY OF CASES BECAUSE
AFFECTIVE TREATMENT GENERALLY
AND BEST PRACTICES AS THE
PEDIATRICIAN SPOKE TO I WILL
INVOLVE PARENTS VERY HARD TO
STAY ON THE BERNARR FIEND I
WITHOUT THAT TYPE OF SUPPORT IF
IT'S THERE FOR YOU. BUT IN THOSE
RARE CASES WERE OFTEN DEALING
WITH SOME OF THE MOST VULNERABLE
YOUNG PEOPLE DIED THERE ON THE
STREET THEIR PARENTS THEMSELVES
ARE ADDICTED THEIR PARENTS ARE
NOT AROUND AND ABLE TO EVEN COME
TO APPOINTMENTS THEY LIVE IN
SHELTERS THOSE KIND OF
SITUATIONS ARE ESPECIALLY
VULNERABLE AND- I SADLY WHEN IT
COMES TO OPIATE ADDICTION ARE
OFTEN DEALING WITH THOSE. TYPES
OF YOUNG PEOPLE ARE SO- THIS IS
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT TO GET
THOSE FOLKS IN THE CARE AND
TREATMENT AND GET THEM HELP IN
OFF OF DEADLY DRUGS AND WITH
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL.
THANK YOU MA'AM IF YOU WOULD
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER FOR AB EIGHT SIXTEEN THE
MOTION IS TO PASS A BURKE HI
AMERICA I WILK. ALLEN ALLEN I SB
SB I. CABALLERO. RUSSELL RUSSELL
I LAYERED. LAYERED I AM MEN MEN
ON A NEW LOW. MILANO'S. STERN I
MEAN. SEVEN TWO ONE MEMBERS
MISSING ALL RIGHT PUT THAT ON
SEVERAL. I HAS A YOU'RE GOING TO
PROVE- ITEM NUMBER NINE AB NINE
FIVE FOUR WHICH ALSO HAS NO-
FILED OPPOSITION. GREAT HI THIS
IS A BILL ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
MEMBER BRIAN THAT WHILE I
CONTINUE OUR EFFORTS TO STOP
PUNISHING POVERTY IN THE CHILD
WELFARE SYSTEM. HE WANTS TO
ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
AND THANK THE CHAIR AND STAFF
FOR THEIR WORK THIS BILL WILL
ENSURE THE COURTS DO NOT DENY
FAMILY REUNIFICATION OUR FAMILY
MAINTENANCE TO APPARENT SOLELY
BECAUSE- THEY CANNOT AFFORD TO
PAY FOR COURT ORDERED SERVICES.
BECAUSE IT HAS NO OPPOSITION I
WILL GO ALL THE WAY TO THE END
HERE AND- OFFER AN OPPORTUNITY
FOR. THE WITNESS WE HAVE
NATALIE- BASH IN A SOCIAL WORKER
INVESTIGATOR WITH THE L. A.
DEPENDENCY LAWYERS ALREADY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU GET. MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS MY NAME IS NOT FASHION
AND I'M A SOCIAL WORKER
INVESTIGATOR OUT LOS ANGELES
DEPENDENCY LAWYERS WE ARE THE
LARGEST FAMILY DEFENSE
ORGANIZATION OF OUR KIND IN THE
NATION. AND WE REPRESENT NEARLY
TWENTY THOUSAND PARENTS ON ANY
GIVEN DAY IN THE CHILD WELFARE
SYSTEM. WE ARE HONORED TO
SPONSOR AB NINE FIVE FOUR TO
ENSURE A PARENT'S FINANCIAL
ABILITY TO PARTICIPATE IN CORPS
ORDERED PROGRAMS. TRANSPORTERS
THE PATIENT SERVICES INCREASES
THE OPPORTUNITY FOR A SAFE AND
SUCCESSFUL REUNIFICATION. A
BARRIER TO REUNIFICATION IN THE
CHILD WELFARE SYSTEM EXISTS
BECAUSE THE MAJORITY OF OUR
PARENTS ARE POOR. AND LACK FUNDS
TO PAY FOR CORPS ORDER SERVICES
THAT MUST BE COMPLETED IN ORDER
TO REUNIFY WITH THEIR CHILDREN.
THIS SITUATION IS DIRE AN
EXISTING POLICY IS NOT ENOUGH.
AN ILLUSTRATION ASKED HOW SEVERE
THE SITUATION IS ONE OF OUR
PARENTS WHO ARE STRUGGLING TO
MAKE ENDS MEET HARD TO CHOOSE
BETWEEN DINNER AND A PARENTING
PROGRAM. THERE ARE ALSO PARENTS
LIVING IN THEIR CARS- HOMELESS
SHELTERS WHO ARE COLLECTING AND
RECYCLING CANS IN AN ATTEMPT TO
ACCUMULATE ENOUGH MONEY TO
AFFORD THESE PROGRAMS- ORDERED
CLASSES COSTS ANYWHERE FROM
FIFTEEN DOLLARS A SESSION TO
FORTY FIVE DOLLARS A SESSION.
MOST OF WHICH ARE TWENTY WEEK
PROGRAMS IN ORDER TO EARN A
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION.
FURTHERMORE CORE ORDERS LIKE
INDIVIDUAL COUNSELING CAN COST
ANYWHERE FROM THIRTY FIVE
DOLLARS A SESSION TO ONE HUNDRED
FIFTY DOLLARS A SESSION
DEPENDING ON THE AGENCY AND
DEPENDING ON WHETHER OR NOT THE
PARENT HAS MEDICAL INSURANCE.
LACK OF FUNDS LIMITS A PARENTS
CAPACITY TO COMPLY WITH COURT
ORDERS WHICH PREVENTS CHILDREN
FROM REUNITING WITH THEIR
PARENTS WERE MORE THAN WILLING
BUT UNABLE TO COMPLY WITH COURT
ORDERS. DUE TO THEIR FINANCIAL
CIRCUMSTANCES. THIS BILL DOES
NOT REQUIRE PAYMENT OF FUNDS TO
THE PARENT BUT IT DOES ENSURE
THAT A PARENT'S INABILITY TO PAY
FOR PROGRAM IS NOT USED AS A
BASIS TO FIND THEM NON
COMPLIANT. IT DOES NOT REQUIRE
THE COURTS TO OVER LOOK COMPLETE
THANK YOU FEW COULD WRAP IT UP
YES. COMPLETE NON COMPLIANCE AND
LACK OF EFFORT BUT RATHER
SUPPORT THE PARENTS WERE
ACTIVELY TRYING TO COMPLETE
THEIR CASE PLAN AND REUNIFY WITH
THEIR CHILD. IT ENCOURAGES
COUNTIES TO USE EXISTING FUNDS
TO ASSIST WILL. ASSUME YOU'RE
URGING AN AYE VOTE YES ALL RIGHT
MY LAST LINE ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH LOS ANGELES DEPENDENCY
LAWYERS STRONGLY AND WITHOUT
RESERVATION SUPPORTS AB NINE
FIVE FOUR. THANK YOU OTHERS IN
SUPPORT. NICOLE WATERMAN ON
BEHALF OF THE CHILL PARTNERSHIP
SUPPORT THANK YOU OTHERS HERE IN
THE HEARING ROOM IN SUPPORT. OF
AB. A NINE FIVE FOURTHS SINGH
KNOWN APPROACH TO THE MICRO.
OPPOSITION IF YOU'RE AN
OPPOSITION TO AB NINE FOUR FIVE
FOUR PLEASE APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE. THING KNOWN APPROACH
TO MY FULLEST TURN THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE WHO WERE BOTH IN
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION TO AB
NINE FIVE FOUR. IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION. TO EIGHTY NINE FIVE
FOUR PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO.
AND WE HAVE A COMMENT FROM LINE
THAT THREE FIFTY ONE. GOOD
AFTERNOON REBECCA GONZALEZ OF
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORKERS CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. N.
LINE THROUGH- FOR. I AM OPPOSED
ONLY BECAUSE THERE'S NO LIMIT ON
THE AMOUNT OF POOR PEOPLE WE
KEEP READING WRITING NOTHING
VERY MUCH ALL RIGHT NEXT PLEASE
. MR SURE THERE ARE NO FURTHER
COMMENT AT THIS TIME OKAY- LET'S
TURN TO THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS
BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS. SEEING
NONE IS THERE MOTIONS. FOR
CERTAIN THERE ALSO MOVES THE
BILL- ALL RIGHT. I'M HAPPY
BRIONES. POLICIES CAN BE HERE
RESPECT ASK THAT ALL RIGHT THANK
YOU ONE OF SIX TWO IF YOU WOULD
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS ITEM
NUMBER NINE AB FIVE. THE MOTION
IS PASS AMENDED THE SENATE
SERVICES COMMITTEE NUMBER I
BURKE I WILL. ALAN ALLEN AYE
ASHBY. SB I CABALLERO TO WRESTLE
. SO I LAYERED. LAYERED I MIN
AYE MIN AYE HELLO. STERN AYE
WIENER. SEVEN ZERO MEMBERS
MISSING. SEVEN TWO ZERO ALL
RIGHT WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL L.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MCCARTY. JUST
BEATEN BY SELLING NUMBER LOW-
THIS IS LESS OF A SEVEN MEMBER
LEVY EXCUSE ME COLLEEN G. I KNOW
IS BEEN HERE BUT WHY BUT TO.
WITH IN FOR ORDER SO. PLEASE
WAIT YEAH ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
ASSEMBLY MEMBER. RIGHT THAT
OLDER THAN MY PARENTS SENIORITY
. SO THAT'S BY RIGHT HIS. WIFE I
WAS SOME NO. WE DON'T GO BY AGE
ON FOR FROM. SO ARE. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CARD GO AHEAD YOU I THIS
IS THE JUDAS COMMITTEE
APPARENTLY BUT I'VE WHICH- BILL
BUT HERE WE ARE NONE THE LESS-
THIS IS A BILL WITH A TWO OUR
AIRPORTS THROUGH CALIFORNIA NOW
JUST MY DISTRICT BUT HELP.
EXPLAIN AIRPORT IN FOR IN
THROUGHOUT- OP- GHANIMA SUPPORT
DATE IS THAT TO FALL REALLY AT
ONE IN IRAQ LIMON A SUNSET DATE
RELATE BECAUSE FEET THAT CHARGE
FOR RED CARS IN EUROPE TO ISSUE
BONDS EXCITEMENT. AND SECONDLY
REMOVES THE REQUIREMENTS THAT
RENTAL CAR FACILITIES HAVE
OUTSTANDING DEBT TO THEM M.
IMPOSE FEES TO ALSO FOCUS ON
AIRPORT INFRASTRUCTURE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL I HAVE A
RIGHT FROM THE SACRAMENTO
AIRPORT AS WELL AS THE STATEWIDE
AIRPORT COUNCIL ALL RIGHT IF
YOU'RE IN SUPPORT PLEASE
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE. JIM
LIGHTS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA AIRPORTS COUNCIL-
WITH THE SPONSORS OF THE BILL
THERE'S TO EXISTING LAW FEES
THAT AN AIRPORT CAN CHOOSE FROM
TO FINANCE THE CONSTRUCTION OF A
RENTAL CAR FACILITY ONE OF THOSE
FEES HERE IS A FRONT END SUNSET
DATE WHERE BY THE AIRPORT MUST
BEGIN THE PROCESS. TO IMPLEMENT
THE FEE- FOR YOU CAN NEVER DO IT
AND THIS BILL WILL ELIMINATE
THAT SUNSET. FIND OUT TO BE AN
ARTIFICIAL DATE WE HAD A NUMBER
OF AIRPORTS THAT HIT THE PAUSE
BUTTON DURING CODED. ON CAPITAL
PROJECTS AND SACRAMENTO IS NOW
NEXT UP AND- CHRIS WITH THE
AIRPORT WILL EXPLAIN THE
PARTICULAR DILEMMA. THAT THEY
HAVE- WITH THE SUNSET. DATE I
THANK YOU. THANK YOU- MY NAME'S
CHRIS WHY WITH THE FACT COUNTY
DEPARTMENT AIRPORTS- IN OF A
FIVE THREE FOUR- PASS OF AB.
THIRTY FOUR WOULD ALLOW AIRPORTS
IN THE STATE TO CONTINUE MAKING
CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE
INVESTMENTS AND IS PARTICULARLY
VITAL FOR SACRAMENTO COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF AIRPORTS AS WE
EMBARK. ON A RECENTLY ANNOUNCED
PLANS FOR A SERIES OF
SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENTS AT THE
AIRPORT TOTALING ONE POINT THREE
BILLION DOLLARS KNOWN AS
ESTIMATE FOR. THE LARGEST
COMPONENT OF THE ESTIMATE FOR
CAPITAL PLANS FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION OF ABOUT FOUR
HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR
CONSOLIDATED RENTAL CAR
FACILITY- BUT BEFORE
CONSTRUCTION AND FINANCING CAN
BEGIN IN EARNEST ON THAT
CONSOLIDATED RENTAL CAR
FACILITY. WE HAVE A FEW VERY
COMPLEX ENABLING PROJECTS THAT
HAVE TO GO SOME DOMINOES SO TO
SPEAK THAT THE FULL FIRST.
INCLUDING THE CONSTRUCTION OF
NEW PARKING FACILITIES AND THE
REROUTING OF ROADWAYS- UNDER
STATE LAW AS IT CURRENTLY STANDS
WE WOULD HAVE TO. BASICALLY
ISSUE BONDS TO FINANCE THIS
PROJECT BY THE END OF THIS YEAR-
WHICH IS- THREE TO FOUR YEARS
AHEAD OF WHEN WE WOULD OTHERWISE
IN ORDER TO FINANCE THE PROJECT-
IT'S ALSO HISTORICALLY VOLATILE
BOND MARKET SO. IT'S NOT A
REALLY GREAT ENVIRONMENT TO
ISSUE BONDS SEVERAL YEARS IN
ADVANCE- AND FOR THOSE REASONS-
WE SUPPORT. EIGHTY FIVE ALL
RIGHT OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
MICHELLE ONE HOUR WITH NIELSEN
MARKS FOR ON BEHALF OF THE OPEN
AIRPORT IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. JOHN MOFFETT ON BEHALF OF
ENTERPRISE RENT A CAR AND SPORT
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT LOSES
SUPPORT. THING KNOWN OPPOSITION
ANYONE OPPOSITION PLEASE
APPROACH MIKE FROM SEEING KNOWN
APPROACH IN MY PHONE. LET'S TURN
THE PHONE LINES FOR THOSE IN
SUPPORT AND- IN OPPOSITION TO.
A. B. FIVE THREE FOUR. IF YOU
WOULD LIKE THAT- TESTIFYING
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS. ONE IF AND ZERO AT THIS
TIME. MR SURE THERE ARE NO
COMMENTS ALL RIGHT BRING IT BACK
TO COMMITTEE. S. B. YEAH I JUST
WANT TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER
MCCARTY WE SHARE THE SACRAMENTO
AIRPORT APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING
THIS FORWARD IN DOING THE HARD
WORK TO GET THIS BILL IN PLACE.
THANK YOU FOR ALL OF YOUR HARD
WORK IN THE- TESTIMONY AND THAT
HAPPY TO MOVE HIS BILL. THANK
YOU ALL RIGHT OTHER QUESTIONS
COMMENTS MOVE BY CENTER SB ONE
QUICK CRITICAL QUESTION. LISTEN
ANYWAY IMPACT ORANGE COUNTY TO
SACRAMENTO SERVICE. IN THE
POSITIVE. ALL RIGHT OKAY ALL
RIGHT. THANK YOU BENCIC IF YOU
WOULD CALL ROLL. CLOSE- I'M
SORRY WHICH I CLOSE.
RESPECTFULLY YOUR AB EXXON
CLOTHES ARE. THANKS THIS IS FILE
I SEVEN A FIVE THREE FOUR THE
MOTION IS TO PASS A BURKE HI
AMERITAS WILL. ALAN ALLEN AYE
ASHBY. AS I COVER YOUR- RUSSELL
. THE RUSSELL ARE LAYER. LAYERED
ON MEN MEN I LOW. HELLO I. STERN
I AM WIENER. YOU HAVE EIGHT MY
MUST. ALL RIGHT WELL A ZERO PUT
THE ON CALL YOU VERY NEXT WE
HAVE A SOME MEMBER LEE AND I A
SO MEMBER. WE TYPICALLY GO. A
FILE ORDER BUT- ULTIMATELY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WILSON RIGHT
AFTER SIMPLY MEMBER LEE. THANK
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR ASSEMBLY
RELIEF HERE TO RESENT MY FELLOW
AB SIX ZERO FOUR THIS IS A
FOLLOW UP TO MY BILL AB TEN
SIXTY ONE WHICH WAS SIGNED LAST
LEGISLATIVE SESSION CURRENTLY AB
TEN SIXTY ONE PROHIBITS MOBILE
PARK MOBILE HOME PARK
MANAGEMENT. FROM CHARGING
TENANTS FOR THE SUB METER WATER
SERVICE BEYOND CHARGES PAID BY
MANAGEMENT DIRECTLY TO THE WATER
SERVICE PROVIDER AND IT AT A
REASONABLE ADMINISTRATIVE FEE.
UNFORTUNATELY PARK OWNER
AFFILIATE ORGANIZATIONS HAVE
ARGUED A CERTAIN MOBILE HOME
PARKS EXEMPT FROM THE STATUTE AS
WRITTEN IN ABOUT HIS CURRENT LAW
TODAY IN RESPONSE TO THIS BILL
AB SIX OF FOUR CLEAR FIDE SCOPE
OF. EXISTING LAW LAWS CAPS ON
WATER SERVICE CHARGE FEES TO
APPLY TO ALL MOBILE HOME.
RESIDENTS THESE CHARGES MAY
INCLUDE MANGLER NEBULOUS CHARGES
SUCH AS CUSTOMER CHARGES OR
SERVICE CHARGES THAT FAR EXCEED
THE CHARGES BILLED TO THE PARK
BUT SERVING WATER UTILITY.
WITHOUT YOU JUST MY WITNESS TO
WITNESSES TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT
ROGER JOHNSON FROM G. S. AND-
WELL AMBER STAND LEGAL COUNTS
FOR JUST AWHILE G. S. M. A WELL
TO ANSWER QUESTIONS ONLY. ALL
RIGHT THE PUSH MICROPHONE.
ACTUALLY GOOD AFTERNOON I'M
MICHELLE MONNING I AM ACTUALLY-
HERE IN SUPPORT OF REPRESENTING
THE GOLDEN STATE MOBILE HOME
BENEFIT OR MANUFACTURED HOME
OWNERS LEAGUE WHICH IS GSM WELL.
AND IT WAS JUST TWO YEARS AGO
THAT WE ACTUALLY WERE HERE- IN
THE SAME ISSUE THE- REPRESENTING
THE SAME ISSUE. BOTH THE
LEGISLATORS AND THE GOVERNOR.
AGREED WITH US THAT MOBILE HOME
RESIDENTS SHOULD PAY FOR THE
WATER WE CONSUME. AND WE SHOULD
PAY A PRO RATA SHARE. WHERE THE
WATER SERVICE FEES AS THEY ARE
THE WATER COMPANIES BILL THE-
THE PARK OWNERS. THEY ALSO YOU
ALSO AGREED THAT WE WOULD BE SO
THAT ANYONE. IT WAS SEVENTY
THIRD. THE PART OWNERS WOULD NOT
BE ALLOWED TO MY UP THE WATER
PRICE AND MAKE AND ON PRICE.
HOWEVER EVEN AFTER ASSEMBLY
MEMBER LEESVILLE WAS-
LEGISLATION PASSED AND WAS
SIGNED INTO LAW MANY PARK OWNERS
CONTINUE TO. MAKE UP THEIR OWN
FEES AND CHARGES SB SIX OH FOUR
WILL CLARIFY WHAT'S LEGAL AND
WHAT'S ILLEGAL FOR PARK OWNERS
TO CHARGE US SO WE ASK FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ALL RIGHT OTHERS IN SUPPORT
. EVERY MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE BRIDGE STANTON
CORPORATE COUNSEL G. S. M. O. L.
STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS
CLARIFYING LEGISLATION THANK YOU
RT THANK YOU OTHERS HERE IN THE
HEARING ROOM WERE IN SUPPORT OF
A. B. SIX ZERO FOUR PLEASE
APPROACH GIVES YOUR NAME
AFFILIATION IN YOUR POSITION.
ROGER JOHNSON GSM WHILE IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. WHEN KIM PARK
RESIDENT- THANK YOU VILLAGE
MOBILE HOME PARK IN ST SUPPORT
THANK YOU. MY NAME IS JOANNE
LEWIS LAKE VILLAGE SISTERS
HEIGHTS I'M IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
. GARY KID A RESIDENT OF THE
LAKE VIEW VILLAGE MOTOR HOME
PARK AND I AM IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT OF OPPOSITION.
THOSE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
APPROACH MICROPHONE. GOVERNOR.
ENTER GOVERNOR GOVERNMENT
ADVOCATES ON BEHALF OF WMA-
WE'RE OPPOSED TO SIX OH FOUR
FIRST AND FOREMOST THE CPUC
ACTUALLY DID A TEN YEAR RATE
MAKING AND RULEMAKING ON WATER
CHARGES IN MOBILE HOME PARKS. A
WE ARE ACTUALLY PARTICIPATE IN
THAT BELIEVE THE CPUC DID AN
AMAZING JOB OF COMING UP WITH
SOMETHING THAT'S FAIR AND
BALANCED WOOD MISTER LEE
INTRODUCES BILL TWO YEARS AGO WE
ACTUALLY OFFERED AN AMENDMENT
THAT SAID WANT YOU SIMPLY TAKE
THE CPC'S RATEMAKING APPLIED
ACROSS THE STATE SPECIFICALLY
THAT RATEMAKING SAYS THAT OWNERS
CAN'T PROFIT OFF OF WATER. WHICH
WE DO NOT SO HERE WE ARE TWO
YEARS LATER AFTER THEY REJECTED
THAT AMENDMENT AND NOW WHAT THEY
WANT TO DO IT SUPERSEDE THE
CPC'S ABILITY AND AUTHORITY AND
SIMPLY INTERJECT THEIR OWN
FORMULA FOR HOW WATER SHOULD BE
DELIVERED A MOBILE HOME PARKS. I
WILL TELL YOU THAT AB TEN SIXTY
ONE NEVER WENT THROUGH ONE
COMMITTEE ON EITHER SIDE THAT
HAD TO DO WITH UTILITIES OUR
WATER WENT THROUGH HOUSING ON
THE ASSEMBLY INTRODUCED ON THIS
SIDE. I AM NOT A WATER EXPERT
NOR DO I BELIEVE THAT ANY OF US
THAT DEALT WITH THAT BILL TWO
YEARS AGO OUR WATER EXPERTS AS A
MATTER OF FACT. NOW WHAT WE'RE
DOING IS SIMPLY CHARGING THE
GROUP RATE FOR EVERYBODY IN A
PARK BECAUSE OF HOW THE BILL WAS
WRITTEN. SO THAT IF YOU'RE A
SINGLE PERSON YOU'RE PAYING THE
SAME RATE AS A FAMILY BECAUSE
WE'RE SIMPLY DIVIDING THE RATE
AMONG EVERYBODY IN THE PARK.
THAT DOESN'T HELP WATER
CONSERVATION IN CALIFORNIA NOR
DOES IT HELP WATER RATES WE
BELIEVE THIS BILL IT'S BAD. AND
THAT WE SHOULD DEFER TO THE CPC
WHO IS THE EXPERT ON THIS ISSUE
A MOBILE HOME. PARKS AND FOR
THAT WE OPPOSE THE BILL. HI YOU
SCOTT ALL RIGHT OTHERS
OPPOSITION APPROACH THEM. SAYING
NO APPROACH MIKE FROM START OF
THE LINES. PLEASE QUEUE UP THOSE
WORDS. IN OPPOSITION TO AB SIX
ZERO FOUR. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
. TO EIGHTY SIX ZERO FOUR PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AND
MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE NO PROBLEM
AT. ALL RIGHT THIS RESPECT
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
MEMBERS. SOME OF THE RUSSELL YES
YES I WAS LIKE DOES THE AUTHOR I
WILL BE SUPPORTING BUT- COULD
YOU RESPOND TO. THE
OPPOSITION'S- ARGUMENTS WERE
PRESENTED RIGHT NOW WITH. SOME
REALLY. SORRY COULD YOU REPEAT
THAT. IF YOU COULD RESPOND TO
THE OPPOSITION'S ARGUMENT YEAH
I'M GONNA DEFER THAT TO- EARLY
ACCOUNTS ADJUSTABLE. IT'S
INTERESTING TO US THAT. WMA
SEEMS TO BE SPEAKING ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
UTILITIES COMMISSION SENATOR WHO
OBVIOUSLY IS NOT HERE AND HAS
VOICED NO OPPOSITION THAT WE
KNOW OF. THE PROBLEM HERE IS
THAT. WMA IS THE TRADE
ASSOCIATION HE REPRESENTS. HAS
TAKEN THE POSITION THAT. AB TEN
SIXTY ONE CREATED A SEPARATE AND
PARALLEL SCHEME OF REGULATION
AND THAT THAT. VISION THAT THE
LAW DOES NOT IN ANY WAY APPLY.
TO C. P. YOU SEE REGULATED PARKS
. PROBLEM THEN IS THAT BECAUSE
OF THAT INTERPRETATION LETTERS
HAVE GONE OUT TO THOSE PARK
UNDERSTAND YOU DON'T HAVE TO PAY
ANY ATTENTION TO TEN SIXTY WHEN
IT DOES NOT APPLY TO YOU. WE
HAVE A NUMBER OF THOSE
SITUATIONS IT'S CONFUSING COUNTY
WEIGHTS AND MEASURES SANTA CRUZ
COUNTY CONTACTED US AND SAID. WE
HAVE SOME MASS CONFUSION HERE
BECAUSE THIS INTERPRETATION. AND
IN FACT OUR POSITION IS THAT THE
TERM WATERPROOF MAYOR WAS
INTENDED TO BE AND IS BROADLY
DEFINED AS APPLYING TO ANY WATER
PURVEYOR- AND THAT THERE'S NO
SAFE HARBOR CPUC SAFE HARBOR
CONFLICT IF YOU WILL BECAUSE OF
THAT. SO I'M NOT SURE IF I'M
RESPONDING THE WAY YOU WOULD
HAVE TO HAVE TENDED BUT- WE
DISAGREE COMPLETELY THAT THERE
IS A PARALLEL OR SEPARATE SCHEME
. THIS IS CLARIFYING LEGISLATION
THE INTENT HERE IS NOT TO RE
ARGUE THE WHOLE POSITION- BUT
IT'S IMPORTANT I THINK TO
CLARIFY THIS SO THAT WE DON'T
HAVE CONFUSION. IN THE INDUSTRY
WE DON'T HAVE THE COURTS HAVING
TO GET INVOLVED TO CONSTRUED THE
STATUTE. RT THANK YOU SENATE
ALSO EARLIER. LET ME ASK THE
AUTHOR QUESTION LET ME TRY TO
CUT THROUGH WHAT THAT EXCHANGE
JUST WAS. IT'S BASICALLY THAT
YOUR ORIGINAL BILL. YOU BELIEVE
COVERS THIS BUT THERE'S
QUESTIONS ABOUT IT AND IT'S NOT
BEEN LEGALLY OVERTURNED OR
PROBLEM. AND THIS BILL IS
BASICALLY TO CLARIFY A SITUATION
THAT YOU BELIEVE TO DO YOUR
PRIOR BILL ALREADY EXISTS IS
THAT CORRECT CORRECT. OKAY THANK
YOU. ADJUSTED TO THE ADULT IF I
MAY MISTER IS THAT YOU KNOW
EXISTING LAW WE USE UPON THE
DEFINITION OF A WATER PREPARE IS
ANY PERSON WHO. ANY PERSON
FURNISHES WILL FURNISHES WATER
TO ANOTHER PERSON NOW THERE'S
SOME CREATIVE INTERPRETATION
HAPPENING IN REALITY THE
LEGISLATIVE INTENT OF THE BILL
THE RITUAL THAT WAS SIGNED INTO
LAW PASSED BY BOTH HOUSE
LEGISLATURE WAS THE TO APPLY TO
ALL. THE LOCAL PARK RESIDENTS
BALLPARKS. YES OUR THANK YOU
OTHER QUESTIONS. SAYING NO OTHER
IS THERE A MOTION. SENATE
THEY'RE ALSO MOVES THE BILL ALL
RIGHT. SEVEN OVERLY CARE CLOSE
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL I BELIEVE
THIS IS A MODEST CLARIFICATION
TO EXISTING LAW TO PROTECT
MOBILE HOME PARK RESIDENTS ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU VERY MUCH. YEAH
ALL RIGHT MANAGE ACCOUNTS OF YOU
WOULD THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE
ITEM SEVEN A. B. SIX OH FOUR BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEVY THE MOTION
IS TO PASS TO THE SENATE ENERGY
UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
COMMITTEE. UMBERG HI NUMBER I
WILK. ALLEN ALLEN AYE ASHBY.
ASHBY I GO YELLOW. THE RUSSELL.
RUSSELL I LAYERED. LAYERED I AM
IN. MEN I KNEW LOW. MILONE STERN
. STERN AYE WIENER. YOU HAVE.
SEVEN TO ONE SO FAR WITH MEMBERS
MISSING ALL RIGHT WE'LL PUT THAT
ON CALL SEVEN ONE. OF WITH
ASSEMBLYMEMBER GABRIEL'S
PERMISSION GONNA HAVE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WILSON PRESENT ALL RIGHT
THANK YOU SOMEONE MEMBER WILSON
THANK YOU CIVIL MEMBER GABRIEL.
SO WE'RE NOW GOING TO MOVE TO
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY TWO A. B.
SEVEN SIXTY. THE MEMBER WILSON
WELCOME BACK CLOSURES. THANK YOU
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE I AM
PLEASED TO PRESENT AB SEVEN
SIXTY WHICH WOULD ENSURE
STUDENTS ARE AFFORDED THE RIGHTS
AND PROTECTIONS. PROVIDED TO
THEM UNDER THE EQUITY IN HIGHER
EDUCATION ACT OF TWO THOUSAND
SEVENTEEN. A. B. C. A. B. SEVEN
FIFTY WOULD SPECIFICALLY ALLOW
STUDENTS AND FACULTY ATTENDING A
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY OR
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA TO
DESIGNATE THEIR FIRM NAME WHILE
AT THE INSTITUTION PER THE
INDIVIDUALS REQUEST. CURRENTLY
SOME COLLEGES DO NOT PROVIDE AN
OPTION FOR TRANSGENDER AND NON
BINARY STUDENTS FACULTY AND
STAFF WHO CHOOSE AND CHOSE THE
NAME IS DIFFERENT FROM THEIR
LEGAL NAME TO HAVE. THEIR
CHILDREN AND REFLECTED IN THEIR
SCHOOL RECORDS BY ALLOWING
INTERNAL RECORDS SUCH AS CLASS
ROSTERS ARE CAMPUS
IDENTIFICATION CARDS TO REFLECT
AN INDIVIDUAL'S OR FIRM'S NAME.
THE CSU AND UC SYSTEM CAN
ELIMINATE SYSTEMIC THAT NAMING
OF TRANSGENDER AND NON BINARY
STUDENTS. I SAID STUDENTS. OR
STAFF SO INDIVIDUALS AB SEVEN
SIXTY WILL HELP TO SUPPORT
CURRENT STUDENTS STAFF OR
FACULTY MEMBERS WHO WISH TO USE
IN A FIRM NAME. AND GENDER
IDENTIFICATION AN IMPORTANT STEP
TOWARDS FOSTERING A CAMPUS
ENVIRONMENT THAT IS INCLUSIVE
AND SUPPORTIVE WITH ME HERE TO
TESTIFY. I HAVE CRAIG PULSIPHER
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
QUALITY CALIFORNIA. STE POSE
FOR. A GOOD AFTERNOON TURN
MEMBERS CRIPPLES FROM BEHALF OF
QUALITY CALIFORNIA PROUD TO BE
HERE TODAY IN SUPPORT- I JUST
WANNA FIRST BEGIN BY EMPHASIZING
THAT USING SOMEONE'S PREFERRED
NAME AND GENDER IS SIMPLY NOT A
MATTER OF COMFORT- PREFERENCE
PREFERENCE BUT ALSO ABOUT SAFETY
AND PRIVACY. BEING DEAD NAME BY
INCORRECT STUDENT RECORDS CAN
COST TRANSIT AND TO BE ADDED
AGAINST HER WILL. AND RESULT IN
HARASSMENT DISCRIMINATION AND
EVEN VIOLENCE. ACCORDING TO A
RECENT SURVEY OF ROUGHLY THIRTY
FIVE HUNDRED TRANS PEOPLE IN
CALIFORNIA. ONLY 15% REPORTED
THE AUTHORITIES HAD THE NAME AND
GENDER THEY PREFER. AND A THIRD
OF RESPONDENTS WHICH SHOWING ID
WITH THE NAME AND GENDER THAT
DID NOT MATCH THEIR GENDER
PRESENTATION WERE HARASSED
DENIED BENEFITS- EVEN INSULTED.
LAST YEAR QUALITY CALIFORNIA WAS
PROUD TO CO SPONSOR AB TWENTY
THREE FIFTEEN WITH A MEMBER
ARAMBULA. WHICH REQUIRED
COMMUNITY COLLEGE CAMPUSES TO
UPDATE THEIR SYSTEM SO THAT
STUDENTS AND FACULTY COULD
UPDATE THE RECORDS WITH THE
PREFERRED NAME AND GENDER.
EIGHTY SEVEN SIXTY IS A LOGICAL
NEXT STEP. HE CAN TO ENSURE THAT
BOTH CSU AND UC CAMPUSES ALSO
UPDATE THEIR SYSTEMS SO THAT
STUDENTS AND FACULTY HAVE THIS
OPTION. I WOULD NOTE THAT THIS
BILL IS PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT
FOR STUDENTS WHO MAY NOT HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLORE THEIR
IDENTITIES AT HOME. AT THE FEAR
THAT THEY MAY NOT BE ACCEPTED BY
THEIR FAMILIES AND COMMUNITY.
AND FOR MANY STUDENTS COLLEGE IS
THE FIRST TIME THEY'RE ABLE TO
BEGIN EXPLORING THESE PARTS OF
THEIR IDENTITY. AB SEVEN SIXTY
WILL HELP TO ENSURE THAT
STUDENTS CAN HAVE THEIR RECORDS
UPDATED TO ACCURATELY REFLECT
THEIR GENDER IDENTITY. AND
CREATE A MORE FIRM IN SPACE ON
CAMPUS. AND WE EXTEND OUR THANKS
OF COURSE TO THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD.
AND HER ONGOING COMMITMENT-
PROTECTING TRANS YOUNG PEOPLE IN
CALIFORNIA I RESPECTFULLY URGE
DRIVE UP. MANY THANKS VERY MUCH
OTHERS IN SUPPORT SAYING NO ONE
ELSE UP THERE WE GO. JENNISON
ALLEY WITH ASKED ME IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. AND I'M NOT THE IS A
PROVOCATIVE CESSATION OF THE
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. VENICE'S
GONZALEZ ON BEHALF OF LIEUTENANT
GOVERNOR LINEKER LAKIS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. BACKER KRAMER
MATTER ON BEHALF OF ACLU
CALIFORNIA ACTION WAS STILL
REVIEWING THEM AND MEN'S BUT WE
ARE VERY SUPPORTIVE OF EXTENDING
AB TWENTY THREE FIFTEEN TO CST
IS ALL RIGHT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
ALL RIGHT. OF LET'S NOT TURNED
OPPOSITION. THOSE IN OPPOSITION
TO AB SEVEN SIXTY PLEASE
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE. THING
NO ONE APPROACHING THE
MICROPHONE- LET'S TURN TO THE
PHONE LINES. WATER IF YOU WOULD
QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION AB SEVEN
SIXTY. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
. TO EIGHTY SEVEN SIXTY PLEASE
PRESS ONE THANK ZERO. AND WE'LL
HEAR FROM LINE. THREE FIFTY ONE.
BILLION REBEKAH GOOD POLICY FOR
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
SOCIAL WORK FOR CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER IN THE PARK. THANK YOU.
ANALYZE TO- FOR. I BELIEVE THAT
THIS IS ANOTHER VERY EXPENSIVE-
FOR THE OR THERE ALREADY. VERY
MUCH I AM OF NASCO PLEASE.
MISTER TERRY ARE NO FURTHER.
OKAY THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT ALL IS
TO BRING BACK TO COMMITTEE
QUESTIONS COMMENTS BY COMMITTEE
MEMBERS- CENTER ASHBY IS MOVE
THE BILL- LIMON WILSON COULD
CLOSE. THANK YOU SO MUCH I
APPRECIATE THE- SUPPORT. OF THAT
THE COMEDIAN RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AND I BOTH. ALL RIGHT THANK
YOU. MADAM SIXTY IF YOU WOULD
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY TWO EIGHTY SEVEN
SIXTY THE MOTION IS TO PASS THE
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
I'M BURKE HI I'M BURKE AYE WILK.
ALLEN ALLEN I ASHLEY. ASHLEY I
CABALLERO RUSSELL RUSSELL I
LAYERED LAYERED AYE MAN AYE MIN
AYE A NEW LOW. STERN ALL RIGHT I
MEAN. SEVEN ZERO MEMBERS MISSING
ALL RIGHT SEVEN ZERO PUT THAT ON
CALL I SEE SOME REMEMBER GABRIEL
HERE. ASSEMBLY MEMBER GABRIEL
AND THEN WE WILL TURN ASSUMING
HE IS HERE TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON FOLLOWED BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER. ON THE VALENCIA. WITH. I
REMEMBER SIX AB FIFTEEN FORTY
SIX. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS I AM PROUD
TODAY 2% EIGHTY FIFTEEN FORTY
SIX WHICH WOULD HARMONIZE THE
STATUTES OF LIMITATIONS AND
ENSURE THAT THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL. HAS THE SAME AMOUNT OF
TIME TO BRING A CIVIL ACTION TO
ENFORCE THE CALIFORNIA CONSUMER
PRIVACY ACT THAT THE PRIVACY
PROTECTION AGENCY HAS TO BRING
AN ADMINISTRATIVE ENFORCEMENT
ACTION UNDER THE SAME LAW. MANY
OF YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA BECAME A
NATIONAL LEADER IN ENSURING
CONSUMER PRIVACY PROTECTION FOR
ALL OF OUR RESIDENTS FIRST WHEN
THE LEGISLATURE PASSED THE CPA
TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN AND NEXT
WHEN THE VOTERS PASSED
PROPOSITION TWENTY FOUR THE
CALIFORNIA PRIVACY RIGHTS ACT IN
TWENTY TWENTY. UNDER THE CCPA
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
AUTHORIZED TO BRING A CIVIL
ENFORCEMENT ACTION FOR
VIOLATIONS AND PROPOSITION
TWENTY FOUR CREATED THE PRIVACY
AGENCY AND GAVE IT A FIVE YEAR
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS TO BRING
AN ADMINISTRATIVE FORSMAN
ACTION. I'M FORTY DUE TO A
DRAFTING OVERSIGHT PROPOSITION
TWENTY FOUR DOESN'T SPECIFY THAT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL ALSO HAS
FIVE YEARS TO BRING A CIVIL
ENFORCEMENT ACTION. UNDER
CALIFORNIA LAW IF THERE IS NO
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS SPECIFIED
IN LAW THE E. G. ONLY HAS ONE
YEAR TO INITIATE A LAWSUIT FOR
CIVIL PENALTIES. ONE YEAR IS FAR
TOO SHORT A TIME TO DEVELOP A
CASE UNDER A LAW AS COMPLEX AS
THE CCPA. AND SO THE ALTERNATIVE
TO PASSING THIS BILL AND LEAVING
THE ONE YOU'RE STATURE
LIMITATIONS IN PLACE WOULD
RESULT IN TO ONE OF TWO LIKELY
OUTCOMES. THE FIRST IS THAT THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL WOULD QUICKLY
FILE SUIT BEFORE THAT ONE YEAR
PERIOD EXPIRES OR TO PRESERVE
THE RIGHT TO SUE. MEETING THE
BUSINESSES WOULD BE QUICKLY
FORCED TO DEFEND THEMSELVES EVEN
IF FURTHER INVESTIGATION AND
CONVERSATION. PROVED THAT NO
LAWSUIT WAS ACTUALLY NECESSARY.
ALTERNATIVELY THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL FILED SUIT ALLEGING NON
CCA CCPA PRIVACY VIOLATIONS AND
THEN THE PRIVACY ACT AGENCY
WOULD BRING A PARALLEL
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION. MEANING
THE BUSINESSES WOULD HAVE TO
DEFEND AGAINST TWO DIFFERENT
ACTIONS AT THE SAME TIME. THIS
BILL WOULD ADD. ADDITIONAL
MINISTRY TO BURDEN AND CREATE NO
NEW RISK OF DATA BREACHES FOR
BUSINESSES. COMPANIES ARE
COVERED BY THE C. T. PAY ALREADY
HAVE TO PRESERVE RECORDS AND
DATA FOR FIVE YEARS IN CASE THE
PRIVACY AGENCY. BRINGS AN
INVESTIGATION OR ENFORCEMENT OR
IN PROCEEDING IN THAT TIME. TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT I HAVE WITH
ME TO WITNESSES FROM THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE. HE LONG AS A DEPUTY
ATTORNEY GENERAL IN THE PRIVACY
UNIT AND ANTHONY LEWIS THE
DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL WITH THE
OFFICE OF LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS.
THANK YOU FOR YEARS. HI GOOD
AFTERNOON MY NAME IS ANTHONY LEE
I'M WITH THE- DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE OFFICE OF LEGISLATORS
AND- ATTORNEY GENERAL BONTA IS
THE PROUD SPONSOR OF THIS
LEGISLATION. WANT TO THANK
ASSEMBLY RICK GABRIEL FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP IN AUTHORING EIGHTY
FIFTEEN FORTY SIX. BILLS FAIRLY
SIMPLE IT JUST AMENDS THE CCPA
TO EXPRESSLY PERMIT DOJ. THE
FILE CIVIL ACTION WITHIN FIVE
YEARS OF A VIOLATION INSTEAD OF
THE CURRENT ONE YEAR OF STATUTE
OF LIMITATIONS. IN DOING SO THE
BILL WOULD ALIGN CIVIL
ENFORCEMENT FTC. YEA BY THE
EIGHTEEN. BUT THE FIVE YEAR.
THAT'S A LIMITATION FOR
ADMINISTRATIVE ENFORCEMENT
PROVIDED. TO THE CALIFORNIA
PRIVACY PROTECTION AGENCY AND
MOST IMPORTANTLY IT WOULD
ENHANCE THE O'JAYS ABILITY. TO
CARRY OUT ITS DUTY TO ENFORCE
CCPA WE JUST CALIFORNIA'S
LANDMARK. CONSUMER PRIVACY LAW.
THIS THIS ALIGNMENT BETWEEN THE
AGENCY STATURE LIMITATIONS ON
THE AG'S THANKS FOR LIMITATION.
IS SO IMPORTANT AND OUR VIEWS
BECAUSE- IT'S NEEDED TO ENSURE A
COHESIVE COHESIVE FRAMEWORK. FOR
ENFORCEMENT BETWEEN THE AGENCY
AND THE AG'S OFFICE. AS
DESCRIBED ON PAGE FOUR AND. FIVE
OF THE EXCELLENT COMMITTEE AND
THE HEALTH. SO RESPECTFULLY I
FOR I VOTE. TODAY FIFTY FORTY SO
AND I WOULD LIKE TO INTRODUCE WE
LAW. OUR SUBJECT MATTER EXPERT
FOR DOJ WHO CAN ANSWER TACTIC
QUESTIONS ABOUT THE BILL AND HAS
A COUPLE MORE COMMENCEMENT.
THANK YOU AND GOOD AFTERNOON MY
NAME IS HERE ALONG THE DEPUTY
ATTORNEY GENERAL AT THE PRIVACY
YOU KNOW THE AG'S OFFICE. WE'VE
BEEN ACTIVELY ENFORCING THIS IS
VA SINCE TWENTY TWENTY. THIS
BILL ADDRESSES A CRUCIFIX IN THE
LAW TO LINE THE STATURE
LIMITATIONS FOR BOTH STATE
ENFORCERS OF THE CCPA. PRIVACY
INVESTIGATIONS AND ENFORCEMENT
ARE INHERENTLY COMPLEX AND TAKE
TIME AND RESOURCES TO DETERMINE
IF THE LADEN VIOLATED. REVIEW
CONSUMER COMPLAINTS INTERVIEW
WITNESSES EXAMINED WEBSITES AND
APPS CONSULT WITH EXPERT
TECHNOLOGISTS REVIEW BUSINESS
POLICIES AND CONTRACTS OFTEN
THESE HIGHLY TECHNICAL
INVESTIGATIONS REQUIRE
SIGNIFICANT TIME TO COLLECT
EVIDENCE. IN SOME CASES REQUIRE
COURT PROCESS INCLUDING
SUBPOENAS AND WITNESS
INTERVIEWS. BECAUSE WE TYPICALLY
INVESTIGATE MULTIPLE TARGETS OF
THE GIVE ME IN ANY GIVEN MOMENT
WE ARE EVEN FURTHER PRESSED FOR
TIME AND LIMITED RESOURCES. WE
NEED A FIVE YEAR STATUTE TO
EFFECTIVELY ENFORCE THE CCPA AND
LYFT OF THESE REALITIES AND
LIMITED RESOURCES. MOREOVER THE
FIVE YEAR STATUTE PRESERVES THE
AG'S ROLE AS THE CHIEF ENFORCER
OF THE LAW. AS THE AG'S OFFICE
HAS THE AUTHORITY TO STAY
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS BY
THE AGENCY IN SOME
RESPONSIBILITY OF ENFORCEMENT
ACTIONS. THIS POWER ONLY MAKES
SENSE IF OUR STATUE LIMITATIONS
IS EQUAL TO THE FIVE YEARS OF
THE AGENCY. IF THE AGENCY WERE
TO INVESTIGATE AND TAKE A LONGER
THAN A YEAR TO DO THAT
INVESTIGATION WE WOULDN'T BE
ABLE TO EXERCISE AUTHORITY TO
MANAGE AND STATE- IN MINISTRY OF
ACTIONS THIS IS CLEARLY NOT WAS
INTENDED BY THE LAW. AND IT
SHOULD BE CORRECTED. LASTLY AB
FIFTEEN FORTY SIX SAVE STATE
ENFORCEMENT AND COURT RESOURCES.
IF THE AGE HE DOESN'T HAVE THE
FIVE YEARS TO INVESTIGATE BRING
CLAIMS THE AGENT AGENCY MAY HAVE
TO STEP FILE SEPARATE ACTIONS
AGAINST THE SAME TARGET. WHICH
WOULD INVOLVE TWO SEPARATE STATE
AGENCIES AND. THE SUPERIOR COURT
RESOURCES. ONE ACTION BY THE AG
IS. THE MORE IF USE OF STATE
RESOURCES HERE WE ASK FOR YOUR
I. BOATS THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
HI THIS IS SUPPORT. BACCA KRAMER
MATTER ON BEHALF OF A CELL YOU
CALIFORNIA ACCIDENT SUPPORT. HI
TRACY ROSENBERG ON BEHALF OF
OAKLAND PRIVACY IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT THOSE IN
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR TO THE AUTHOR RUNOFF ALONG
WITH CALCHAMBER RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSED AB FIFTEEN FORTY SIX.
FUNDAMENTALLY I THINK WE
DISAGREE IT REGARDING VOTER
INTENT AND ALSO THE NEED FOR
THIS BILL WE ARE CONCERNED IT
HURTS BUSINESSES AND THEIR
CONSUMERS. FIRST TIMELY ACTIONS
BETTER SERVE ALL PARTIES IT
PLACES BUSINESSES ON NOTICE OF A
POTENTIAL VIOLATION AND IN TURN
THAT CAN MITIGATE POTENTIAL HARM
TO CONSUMERS IN THE FUTURE THIS
PROPOSAL UNDER MY SUCH POLLS.
SECOND VOTERS INTENSELY DIVIDED
RESPONSIBILITIES FOR
ADMINISTRATIVE AND CIVIL
ENFORCEMENT UNDER THE CCPA.
SPECIFICALLY STATED THAT QUOTE
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS MUST BE
COMMENCED WITHIN FIVE YEARS AND
ARE SILENT ON CIVIL ONES SIMPLY
PUT SILENCE CANNOT INDICATE
INTENT. OF PARITY IS THE GOAL
HERE THE BILL NOTICEABLY FAILS
TO EXTEND THE EIGHT TO THE AG
OTHER PROVISIONS THAT ALLOW THE
PRIVACY AGENCY TO PROVIDE
BUSINESSES AN OPPORTUNITY HERE.
AND ALSO TO PROVIDE BUSINESSES
GUIDANCE BIRD WERE UNAWARE OF
ANY CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE THE
AGENT WAS TIME BARRED FROM
PURSUING ENFORCEMENT THE CCPA
BUS FAR IN FACT WOULD ARGUE
THERE HAS BEEN A ROBUST
ENFORCEMENT TO DATE. OUR CONCERN
IS THAT EXTENSION WOULD MERELY
ALLOW PENALTIES TO ACCRUE FOR
FIVE YEARS EVEN WHEN THERE'S
KNOWLEDGE OF A VIOLATION IN YEAR
ONE. WE KNOW THE ABSENT THIS
BILL CONSUMERS ARE PROTECTED
YEARS TEACHER FIVE BY WAY OF
AGENCY ACTIONS SHOULD THE AG
FAILED TO BRING AN ACTION YOU'RE
ONE. FOR THE MORE THERE'S
LITERALLY NO DIFFERENCE IN THE
PENALTIES THAT THE AGENCY CAN
PURSUE I SUPPOSE THE AG. ABSENT
A PROBLEM UNDER EXISTING LAW
THIS PROPOSAL THAT IS UNFAIR TO
BUSINESSES AND PARTICULARLY ILL
TIMED GIVEN THE COMPLIANCE
EFFORTS HAVE BEEN HINDERED BY
THE SIGNIFICANTLY DELAYED AND
STILL INCOMPLETE REGULATIONS
IMPLEMENTING THE LAW. AND
FINALLY I'LL TO SAY THE
LIABILITY EXPOSURE SIMPLY
DIFFERENT WHEN BUSINESSES ARE
SUBJECT TO ENFORCEMENT BY TWO
DIFFERENT AGENCIES THAT HAVE
INCONSISTENT INTERPRETATIONS OF
THE LAW. ONLY ONE OF WHICH HAS
TO PROVIDE GUIDANCE TO THE
BUSINESSES. STILL OF WHEN YOU'RE
STILL SHORT WE JUST HOPE THE
AUTHOR WILL CONSENT AT CONSIDER
MIDDLE GROUND TO JUST THREE
YEARS WHICH IS WHAT'S USED IN
OTHER STATES. ADDRESS KINDLY
IMPROVEMENTS AND PERSONALLY I.
THINK RT YOU. OTHERS IN A POP
UPS. I COULD AFTERNOON JAMIE
HALF WITH JUSTICE ASSOCIATE OF.
RISING WITH. UP WE BELIEVE THAT
THIS BILL IS AN- IN A PREMATURE
TO. OF THE- LIMITATIONS CC. AND
COULD SERVE TO UNDERMINE THE
STATE'S PRIVACY GOALS.
INCREASING THE STATURE
LIMITATIONS FROM ONE TO FIVE
YEARS BEFORE THE UNDERLYING LAW
HAS EVEN HAD A CHANCE TO BE
FULLY ENFORCED IS HASTY. THIS
EXTENSION IT WOULD FORCE
BUSINESSES TO HOLD ON TO DATA
FOR A LONGER PERIOD OF TIME.
THERE BY INCREASING THE
LIKELIHOOD OF DATA BREACHES AND
THE SUBSEQUENT LIABILITY THAT
BUSINESSES WOULD WHICH WOULD
FLOW NATURALLY FROM THAT. ALSO
FORCING BUSINESSES TO HOLD ON TO
THE STATE OUT LONGER THAN
NECESSARY DOES NOT ALIGN WITH
OUR STATE'S DATA MINIMISATION
PRINCIPLES. ENFORCEMENT STAGE OF
THE CCPA IS STILL IN ITS INFANCY
AND THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
OFFICE HAS BEEN CLEAR PUBLICLY
THAT THEY INTEND TO VIGOROUSLY
ENFORCE THE LAW. SO THERE'S NO
REASON TO EXTEND THE EXTENSION.
OF BEYOND WHAT IS ALREADY A LOT.
OF WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT THE
COST OF RETAINING INFORMATION
OUTWEIGHS THE RISK OF A
LIABILITY TO BUSINESSES. HAVING
SAID THAT WE HAVE GREAT RESPECT
FOR THE AUTHOR. AND THE INTENT
BEHIND THE BILL AND WE HOPE THAT
THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO COME
TO. A REASONABLE AGREEMENT ON
SOMETHING THAT IS A LITTLE MORE
AND- MAYBE IN THE MIDDLE AS
CHAMBER AT SEVENTY THREE YEARS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT. OTHERS IN
OFFICE. GOOD AFTERNOON TURN
MEMBERS NAMELY PETRONE ON BEHALF
OF THE COMPUTER AND
COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION IN RESPONSE
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. WE ANY
TARGET WITH TECH THAT
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE. THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION
SIGNALING THE START OF THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION AB
FIFTEEN FORTY SIX. IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO EIGHTY. FIFTEEN
FORTY SIX. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
. ZERO FIRST WE'LL HEAR FROM
LINE THREE FIFTY EIGHT. ON YEAH
. LOS THREE FIFTY EIGHT PLEASE
GO AHEAD. YEAH ARE NEXT COLOR
OKAY. LINE SIXTY TWO. I BAY ON
BEHALF THE COMMUTER FEDERATION
CALIFORNIA THE THANK YOU. LINE
THREE FOUR SIX. GOOD AFTERNOON
BETTER INCOME HAVE OF THE NASH
PAPER REPORTING SINCE AND THE
LEAGUE FOOD PRODUCER BOTH IN
OPPOSITION THANK. IN LINE OUT. I
AMPLE. ALL RIGHTY THANK YOU. AND
THE PICTURE THERE ARE NONE
FURTHER OKAY THIS PREFECT
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
MEMBERS THIS CENTENNIAL. THANK
YOU MISTER- HE STATED THAT
YOU'RE CORRECT ADDRESS ERROR OF
THE PROPOSITION. WHAT'S YOUR
BASIS FOR THAT I THINK IF YOU
LOOK THERE'S ACTUALLY THE WITH A
COUPLE ANSWERS A WONDERFUL
HOUSES HERE ALSO IN THE ASSEMBLY
PRIVACY COMMITTEE ANALYSIS WENT
THROUGH AND LOOKED AT THE WAY IN
WHICH THAT- THE THAT THE
PROPOSITION WAS DRAFTED THE
LANGUAGE THAT WAS USED WAS
CLEARLY AN INTENT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THERE WAS ROBUST
ENFORCEMENT THERE- IN THE IDEA
THAT YOU WOULD HAVE. A FIVE YEAR
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR THE
AGENCY AND A ONE YEAR STATURE
LIMITATION FOR THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL DIDN'T SEEM TO COMPORT
WITH ALL OF THE- WITH WITH WITH
THE PURPOSE AND INTENT OF THE
STATUTE. HAVE THE DRAFTERS OF
THE INITIATIVE TESTIFIED TO THAT
EXTENT. I DON'T I'M I'M YOU KNOW
WHAT I DON'T I'M NOT SURE ABOUT
THAT- TO BE HONEST I MEAN IF
WE'RE DEALING WITH INTENT- BE
INTERESTING TO KNOW WHAT THEY
SAY. AND WITH REGARD TO ROBUST
ENFORCEMENT- THAT DOESN'T.
NECESSARILY MEAN ENFORCEMENT
OTHER THAN ADMINISTRATIVE
ENFORCEMENT SO- I JUST SUGGEST
THAT THERE'S- CONCLUSIONS HERE
THAT. MAY OR MAY NOT BE
JUSTIFIED BUT- I HEARD. HIS NAME
AS TOUGH. FROM J. LACKS DATA
COMPROMISE. HAS THERE BEEN. A
COMPROMISE OFFERED SPECIFICALLY
. AS FAR AS I'M AWARE THE FIRST
OFFERED THREE YEARS IT WAS BUT
IT WAS IN THE HALLWAY ABOUT FIVE
MINUTES AGO SO WE HAVE NOT HEARD
FROM THE OPPOSITION ON THAT
POINT. THANK THE QUESTION.
QUESTIONS THAT YES THERE S. B.
YEAH I JUST WANTED TO I KNOW
THAT THIS IS A BILL IT'S A HIGH
PRIORITY TO OUR ATTORNEY GENERAL
AND I HEARD THE CONCERNS OF. THE
OPPOSITION AND I JUST WANTED TO
MAKE SURE THAT YOU PLAN ON
WORKING WITH THEM IN ADDRESSING
SOME OF THOSE CONCERNS THERE.
PRETTY VAST. YEAH I MEAN WE'RE
WE'RE ALWAYS OPEN TO HAVING
CONVERSATIONS WITH PEOPLE WOULD
WELCOME THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE
A CONVERSATION TO DIVE INTO THE
DETAILS I THINK THE THING THAT-
I'M I'M STRUGGLING TO UNDERSTAND
FROM THE OPPOSITION IS THE
ARGUMENT THAT THIS REQUIRE FOLKS
TO PRESERVE INFORMATION DATA
LONGER BECAUSE THERE'S ALREADY A
FIVE. YOUR STATURE LIMITATIONS
BECAUSE A PROPOSITION TWENTY
FOUR VOTERS BY SO THEY'RE GONNA
HAVE TO PRESERVE THAT
INFORMATION IN ANY IN ANY CASE I
DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW HARMONIZING
THE STATUTES OF LIMITATIONS.
WOULD IN ANY WAY PLACE ANY
ADDITIONAL BURDEN ON YEAH THEY
HAD OTHER VARYING ISSUES THOUGH
TO THAT MAYBE YOU MIGHT BE ABLE
TO TALK TO MY SON TO MAKE SURE
THAT. YOU ARE WILLING TO
CONTINUE WE'LL SEE IT AGAIN ON
THE FLOOR AND- I'M HOPING THAT
THERE WILL HAVE BEEN SOME
ADDITIONAL CONVERSATION YEAH A
HAPPY HAPPY TO HAVE A
CONVERSATION WITH THEM-
OBVIOUSLY WOULD WANT TO HAVE OUR
PARTNERS FROM THE TWENTY
GENERAL'S OFFICE BE PART OF
THAT- I THINK YOU KNOW THEY HAVE
STRONG PERSPECTIVES ON THIS
PARTICULAR ISSUE HARD. THESE ARE
EXCEPTIONALLY TECHNICAL CASES
THEY OFTEN REQUIRE EXTENSIVE
DISCOVERY TECHNICAL EXPERTS- AND
I'M ALSO A BELIEVER OF THE FACT
THAT IF YOU GIVE PEOPLE SOME
TIME RATHER THAN FORCING THEM TO
RATIONALIZATION. YOU CREATE
ADDITIONAL POSSIBILITIES FOR
FORMAL OR INFORMAL SETTLEMENT
RESOLUTION SO. I UNDERSTAND
THAT- YOU KNOW THE CHAMBER AND
OTHERS ALWAYS HAVE A HAVE AN
APPROACH OF A SHORTER STATURE
LIMITATIONS BETTER AND THAT'S
CERTAINLY A PERSPECTIVE THAT.
THAT I THINK IS A IS A VALID ONE
FOR BUSINESS TO TAKE BUT I
ACTUALLY THINK THERE'S A LOT OF
ARGUMENTS. IN A SUBJECT MATTER
THIS TECHNICAL THAT HAVING A
LITTLE BIT MORE TIME FOR READY
TO WRAP THEIR HEADS AROUND THINK
SURE BUT BUT HAPPY TO HAVE A
COMMERCENTRE LITTLE BIT MORE
THAN. YOU KNOW JUST CHAMBER
VOICE OVER THERE TOO THAT'S A
LOT OF JUDICIAL EXPERIENCE SO I
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT YOU'RE
GOING TO STAY IN CONVERSATIONS
WITH THEM BECAUSE THEY HAD A LOT
OF. ISSUES BUT I I'LL BE
PREPARED TO SUPPORTED TODAY AND
APPRECIATE THAT IT IS A PRIORITY
FOR THE ATTORNEY GENERAL. AND
FOR YOU. THANK YOU. BYE OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. C. NG
NONE- YES ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GABRIEL. THANK YOU FOR THAT.
CONVERSATION IN THE HALLWAY JUST
A LITTLE WHILE AGO- THIS. IS A
CHALLENGE BECAUSE A ONE YEAR
STATURE LIMITATIONS. IS CLEARLY.
SHORT AND WAS PROBABLY A
MISTAKE- AT. THE OUTSET NUMBER
ONE. AND THEN NUMBER TO NOW WE
HAVE A FIVE. YEAR STAY. ON THE
ADMIN. AGENCY THAT'S PURSUING
IT. AND SO THUS TO. BASICALLY
MAKE THEM. COMPLIMENTARY TO ONE
ANOTHER WERE IN A POSITION WHERE
WE HAVE TO MAKE. THIS FIVE YEARS
OR AT LEAST THAT'S WHAT'S BEING
PROPOSED. IT IS MY EXPERIENCE
THAT THIS IS A DIFFERENT KIND OF
WRONG THOUGH THIS. GOING ON THIS
IS. A CONTINUING WITHOUT A BANK
ROBBERY WE HAVE A BANK ROBBERY.
THERE'S AN EVENT IT'S OVER. YOU
INVESTIGATE THIS IS. A PROBLEM
THAT MAY BE CONTINUING AND SO
WE- I THINK AS A- AS POLICY
MAKERS WANT. THAT ISSUE THAT
WRONG THAT HARM IF THERE IS ONE
TO STOP AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. AND
SO FIVE YEARS STATUTE BASICALLY
SAYS HEY LISTEN YOU KNOW YOU CAN
RUN THIS OUT FOR FIVE YEARS I
REALIZE THAT THERE ARE SOME
INTERMEDIATE REMEDIES THAT CAN
BE PURSUED. BUT SO THAT THAT
GIVES ME PAUSE THE SECOND THING
IS WE PAUSE THE TRADITIONAL THE
LONGER THE STATUTE THE MORE
CHALLENGING IS JUST TO DEFEND-
AND THEN THAT. GIVES ME SOME
PAUSE AS WELL I'M NOT SURE
EXACTLY HOW TO FIX THIS- WE
PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE BEEN MAYBE
I WAS AROUND WHEN WE- FIX THE
ADMINISTRATIVE SUCH LIMITATION
FIVE YEARS THREE YEARS TO ME
SEEMS TO BE MORE APPROPRIATE. IT
IS ALSO MY EXPERIENCE THAT.
WHETHER YOU'RE A CIVIL LITIGATOR
YOUR CRIMINAL LITIGATOR IS THAT
YOU ARE MINDFUL SESSION
IMITATIONS IN YOUR WORK SEEMS
TO. GET A LITTLE MORE FOCUSED AS
YOU APPROACH THE STATUE
LIMITATIONS AND IF YOU HAVE A
FIVE YEAR STATUTE YOU'RE NOT
VERY FOLKS AT THREE OR FOUR
YEARS YOU START TO GET FOLKS
THAT FOUR AND A HALF YEARS. SO
HAVING SAID THAT I AM GRATEFUL
FOR YOUR FLEXIBILITY I. DON'T
KNOW HOW WE EXACTLY REMEDY THIS
ONE YEAR AGAIN IS TOO SHORT FIVE
YEARS IN MY VIEW IS TOO LONG BUT
I'M THE SUPPORT THE BILL. SO
THERE YOU GO WOULD LIKE CLOSE
YEAH THANK YOU AND I APPRECIATE
THAT AND I. CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND
THE CONCERNS IN YOUR- YOU KNOW
VERY EXPERIENCED LITIGATOR AND I
KNOW THAT YOU BRING ALL THAT TO
BEAR I THINK THE CHALLENGE THAT
WE'RE TRYING TO WRAP OUR ARMS
AROUND IS THAT. THE VOTERS HAVE
SET THAT THE SATCHEL MEDITATION
AT FIVE YEARS AND SO THAT'S WHAT
WE HAVE AND THAT'S OR HAVE
TRYING TO WORK AROUND AND- AGAIN
I THINK ALL THESE CONCERNS THAT
YOU HEARD ABOUT JUDICIAL ECONOMY
AND HAVE POTENTIALLY HAVING
BUSINESSES DEFENDING IN TWO
DIFFERENT FOR US. AT THE SAME
TIME WITH DIFFERENT SETS OF. OF-
LAWS AT ISSUE. I'M CERTAINLY ONE
THAT WE WOULD WANT OVER. SO HOW
TO HAVE CALLED. I THINK WE ALL
SORT OF WANT TO GET TO THE SAME
PLACE HERE- APPRECIATE THE
SUPPORT AND RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
AND I'VE- ALREADY THANK YOU. I
THINK IT'S BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR
ASHLEY THAT'S CORRECT. NO IT
WASN'T THAT'S NOT CORRECT IS
THERE A MOTION. YES CENTER L.
MOVES THE BILL. ALL RIGHT MA'AM
SECTOR IF YOU CALL THE ROLL.
THIS IS FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX AB
FIFTEEN FORTY SIX THE MOTION IS
TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. BURKE
HI. AMERICA I WILL GROW. WILK
KNOW ALAN. ALLEN HI ASHLEY.
ASHLEY I CABALLERO. RUSSELL
RUSSELL ODD. LAYERED OTTOMAN.
THEN I IN THE LOW. THE LOW NO
STERN. WIENER. SIXTY TWO. SIX
TWO WE'RE GONNA PUT THAT ON CALL
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APRIL ALL RIGHT SO HERE'S WHAT
WE'RE GONNA DO FOR THE REST OF
THE- AFTERNOON. I'M HOPING THIS
AFTERNOON- I SEE SOME REMEMBER
GIPSON EUROPE. AFTER SIMILAR
GIPSON NICE I THOUGHT I SAW SOME
REMEMBER VALENCIA. WHO'S HERE-
JUST FOR THOSE WHO ARE
LISTENING. AFTER SOME REMEMBER
VALENCIA THEN WE WILL HAVE NO
FURTHER BILLS TO BE CONSIDERED
THIS AFTERNOON SO WE'LL BE
OPENING AND THEN CLOSING THE
ROLE RELATIVELY QUICKLY TODAY.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON- AG ARE
FIVE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN FLOORS
YOURS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH-
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND SENATORS.
AND I WILL TRY TO MAKE MY
PRESENTATION VERY QUICK VERY
POIGNANT. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING
ME TO PRESENT H. A R. FIVE.
WHICH SEEKS TO- DENOUNCE. THE
INEXCUSABLE ACTION OF THE
TENNESSEE LEGISLATURE DISMISSING
REPRESENTATIVE APPEARS AND
REPRESENTATIVE JONES THE
RESOLUTION ALL HAVE ALREADY
BOLSTERED OVER SIXTY THREE- CO
AUTHORS BETWEEN THE S. SENATE
AND THE ASSEMBLY AS WELL AS
RECEIVED- RECEIVED SIXTY THREE
VOTES- ON THE FLOOR OF THE STATE
ASSEMBLY. EVEN THOUGH
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE
REPRESENTATIVES HAVE BEEN
REINSTATED- THEY WERE NOT
REINSTATED BY THE TENNIS
LEGISLATOR LEGISLATURE DIRECTLY
IT TOOK THE CITY AND THE COUNTY
INTERVENTION. ON MARCH THE.
TWENTY SEVEN TO TWENTY TWENTY
THREE A SHOOTING OCCURRED. AT
THE CONVICTS SCHOOL TENNESSEE
THANK THE LAW OF THREE CHILDREN
AND THREE ADULTS. MORE THAN ONE
THOUSAND PEACEFUL PROTESTERS I'M
RALLIED AROUND THE TENNESSEE-
STATE CAPITOL ON MARCH THE THIRD
OF TWENTY TWENTY THREE CALLING
FOR RESTRICTIVE GUNS AS WELL AS
SENSIBLE GUN CONTROL LAWS. IN
THAT STATE THE RALLY TO THE
CAPITAL AND WOOD MADE ITS WAY ON
THE CAPITOL FLOOR THREE
DEMOCRATS MEMBERS OF THE
TENNESSEE LET OF HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES- GLORIA JOHNSON
AND- JUSTIN. AND JUSTIN JONES
WERE THREATENED WITH EXPULSION-
FROM THE OFFICE THAT THEY HOLD
BECAUSE OF THE PROTESTS ON APRIL
THE SIX TWENTY TWENTY THREE THE
TENNESSEE HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES VOTED ON WHETHER
OR WHETHER NOT TO- TO SUSPEND
THESE THREE REPRESENTATIVE.
BECAUSE THEY VIOLATED THE
DECORUM ON THE FLOOR UNDERSCORED
THEY THEY VIOLATED THE DECORUM
ON THE FLOOR JUSTIN PEARSON AND
JUSTIN JONES WHO ARE AFRICAN
AMERICANS WERE EXPELLED WHILE
THE OTHER COLLEAGUE WAS NOT
ALTHOUGH THE REPRESENTATIVES
WERE REINSTATED- THROUGH THIS
THROUGH THE COUNTY INTERVENTION
AS WELL AS TO THE CITY- BUT THEY
WERE. STILL NOT REINSTATE IT BY
THE LEGISLATURE THEY HAVE THEY
HAVE THE ABILITY- THIS HAVE THE
ABILITY TO- HURTS. MORE THAN A
HUNDRED AND FORTY THOUSAND
RESIDENTS THAT THE ELECTED THEM
TO REPRESENT THEM- AND THEY
REMOVE THOSE INDIVIDUALS FROM
REPRESENTING THE PEOPLE WHO
ELECTED THEM TO THOSE OFFICES I
WISH TO DRAW TO ATTENTION- THE-
THE UNDERLYING THE ON DEMOCRATIC
IN ON A DEMOCRACY THAT EXISTS-
WE WERE ABLE TO INVITE- BOTH
REPRESENTATIVES. I'M JONES CAME
TO THE. FLOOR THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSEMBLY- AND- WE- PASSES
READ WITH HIM IN THE AUDIENCE-
SIXTY THREE VOTES AGAIN OUR FEAR
IS THAT WHAT THE TENNESSEE
LEGISLATURE DEMONSTRATED WILL BE
PICKED UP AND GALVANIZED BY
OTHER STATES AND CALIFORNIA AS
LARGE AS WE ARE WE KNOW THAT
CALIFORNIA'S SPEAKS AND WE KNOW
THAT POLICIES WHEN WE MAKE
POLICIES OTHER STATES FOLLOWS
CALIFORNIA. AND SO WE CANNOT BE
SILENT ON THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE
BECAUSE SILENCE IS A FORM OF
BETRAYAL- SENATORS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN I VOTE ON
H. A R. FIVE. ALL RIGHT- THOSE
IN SUPPORT PLEASE APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE. SEEING NO ONE
APPROACHING THE MICROPHONE IN
SUPPORT- ANYONE ELSE MOM GOING
ONCE GOING TWICE ALL RIGHT LET'S
TAKE THE OPPOSITION IF YOU'RE
OPPOSED TO A G. R. FIVE PLEASE
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE. THING
KNOWN APPROACH IN MY PHONE LET'S
NOW TURN TO THE PHONE LINES
MODERATOR PLEASE OPEN THE PHONE
LINES FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION AJ ARE
NUMBER FIVE. IF YOU WOULD LIKE
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO AJ ARE FIVE PLEASE
PRESS ONE AT THE END ZERO. AND
WE HAVE NO COMMENT AT THIS TIME
ALL RIGHT LET'S BRING IT BACK
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
MEMBERS. SIR YES SIR BOTH
SENATOR YELLOW IN SOME TO WELL
I'LL START WITH SOME OF THE LOW
. I'M TORN ON THIS BILL- I'VE
THOUGHT THAT THE MOVE BY THE
MAJORITY OF THE TENNIS LEGIS
TENNESSEE LEGISLATURE WAS- KIND
OF A BONE HEADED MOVE- THEY HAD
OTHER OPTIONS FOR- ACKNOWLEDGING
THAT- THOSE MEMBERS HAD.
VIOLATED THE DECORUM OF THE
INSTITUTION- BUT AT THE SAME
TIME THEY DID INDEED DO THAT
AND- I AM WONDERING. WE HAD OF A
LITTLE DISAGREEMENT. IT HERE A
COUPLE OF WEEKS AGO WITH REGARD
TO A PARTICULAR. INDIVIDUAL
CONTROVERSIAL INDIVIDUAL THAT
WAS- HONORED AS PART OF THE-
PRIDE RESOLUTION- CEREMONY- NOT
WITH REGARD TO ANYBODY ELSE IT
WAS HONOR JUST- SISTER ROMA.
THAT REPUBLICANS CERTAINLY IN
THE SENATE. I HAD ISSUE WITH.
BUT WE DID NOT DISRUPT THE
CEREMONY THAT WOULD NOT BE THE
RIGHT THING TO DO I DO WONDER
THOUGH NOT ASKING THIS OF YOU
BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT IN THE
LEADERSHIP IN THE SENATE. I DO
WONDER THOUGH WHAT WOULD HAVE
HAPPENED HAD REPUBLICANS REACTED
TO SISTER ROMA THE WAY THAT
THESE REPRESENTATIVES
REPRESENTATIVES ACTED IN- THE
TENNESSEE LEGISLATURE I'LL JUST
LEAVE THAT QUESTION OPEN BECAUSE
I DON'T THINK ANYBODY HERE. WELL
MAYBE SOMEBODY HERE TODAY AS
AFTER IT BUT I'M NOT ASKING FOR
AN ANSWER BUT THAT'S WHY I'M
TORN. WHY I'M TORN ON THE BILL.
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU CENTER WILK
. ONE GONNA I'M GONNA SUPPORT
YOUR RESOLUTION TODAY BUT I
CAN'T ANSWER YOUR QUESTION
BECAUSE I REMEMBER ONCE WHEN
IT'S- SENATOR JANET NGUYEN WAS
TALKING ON THE CONDITION OF THE
FILE I'M TOM HAYDEN AND SHE AND
THE PRESIDING OFFICER ORDERED
THAT SHE BE REMOVED BY FORCE
FROM THE SENATE FLOOR AND I KNOW
THAT BECAUSE SHE SAT RIGHT NEXT
TO ME. AND WATCH TO GET CARTED
OFF- I GOT ANOTHER QUESTION I
GUESS MORE RHETORICAL OKAY. I
LOVE YOU YOU'RE A GREAT GUY BUT
YOU TALKED A LOT ABOUT DEMOCRACY
NOT AGREE. I'M IN THE MINORITY
HERE I FEEL OPPRESSED SO I FEEL
THEIR PAIN IN TENNESSEE. BUT IN
YOUR HOUSE YOU CARE ABOUT THE
MEMBERSHIP IN YOUR HOUSE IF IT
CHAIR PERSON DOES ONE EVEN HERE
UNTIL. YOU'RE EVEN HERE BILL TO
ME THAT THAT'S REALLY ANTI
DEMOCRATIC I DON'T THINK WE DO
THAT HERE I DON'T KNOW IF ANY
BILLS. THAT NEVER BEEN HURT BUT
IF YOU COULD BRING THAT BACK
YOUR KICK A NEW LEADERSHIP
COMING ON BOARD. I WOULD IF YOU
WOULD I WOULD LOVE IT IF YOU
WOULD ENCOURAGE THEM. TO HEAR
ALL BILLS WERE THEY AGREED WITH
THEM OR NOT BECAUSE THAT'S THE
DEMOCRATIC PROCESS. I WILL
CENTER THANK YOU VERY MUCH I WAS
CERTAINLY- TAKE BACK YOUR YOUR
CONVERSATION YOUR WORDS- AND
SHARE IT. ALL RIGHTY THANK YOU
COMMENTS QUESTIONS GRIEVANCES.
ALL RIGHT- ALL RIGHT CENTER S.
B. MOVES ITEM YOU. YOU COULD.
RESEARCH ASK NINE. RT THANK YOU
VERY ALL RIGHT. MA'AM SIX TRIP
YOU CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS FILE
AND NUMBER THREE. A ARE. THE
MOTION IS THAT THE RESOLUTION BE
ADOPTED. UMBERG HI I'M BURKE I
WILL CRY. WILK AYE ALLEN. ALLEN
HI ASHLEY. ASHLEY I CABALLERO.
RUSSELL RUSSELL I LAYERED.
CLEARED BY MEN. MAN I NEED LOW.
STERN STERN AYE WIENER. EIGHT
ZERO MEMBERS MISSING. ALL RIGHT
EIGHT ZERO WILL PUT THAT ON CALL
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
ALL RIGHT SO THE LAST AUTHORS
HERE PRESENT WE TYPICALLY
RESERVE. A PLACE OF HONOR FOR
THE LAST AUTHOR. SO TODAY THAT
PLACE OF HONOR IS YEARS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER LYNSEY SOMETIMES PEOPLE
DON'T THINK THAT'S A PLACE OF
HONOR ELEVEN O'CLOCK AT NIGHT
BUT LET ME ASSURE YOU THAT.
BEING THE LAST AUTHOR IN SENATE
JUDICIARY IS TRULY. TRULY A
PLACE OF HONOR SO- FOR THOSE OF
YOU LISTENING AFTER ASSEMBLY
MEMBER LET'S SEE WE'RE GOING TO
CALL THE ROLL WE'RE GOING TO
SHUT DOWN RELATIVELY QUICKLY.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER VALENCIA A. B.
SIX FOUR EIGHT ITEM NUMBER
NINETEEN. WONDERFUL THANK A
FRIEND THANKFULLY IT IS NOT
ELEVEN PM AT ABOUT FOUR PM- WHEN
I STARTED MISTER CHAIR AND
SENATORS- AB SIX FORTY BUILT OFF
THE EFFORTS LED BY THE SENATE BY
THE PERMANENTLY. ALLOWING
HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION MEANS TO
TAKE PLACE BY TELECONFERENCE
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT
CENTER MEN ALSO CARRIED AT THE
LEGISLATION THAT ALLOWED FOR
THIS TO TAKE PLACE DURING THE
COPA PANDEMIC. THE BILL DOES NOT
MANDATE TELECONFERENCE MEETINGS
BUT RATHER CREATES AN ADDITIONAL
OPTION FOR MEMBERS TO
PARTICIPATE. HOMEOWNER
ASSOCIATIONS ARE PERMITTED TO
DECIDE HOW THEY WISH TO MEET. SB
SIX FORTY CONTAINS IMPORTANT
SAFEGUARDS FOR TELECONFERENCE
MEETINGS THAT ENSURE ADVANCE
POSTINGS OF MEETING NOTICES
CLEAR INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO
PARTICIPATE AND TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE. THROUGH THE COVERT A
MERGING SEE WHAT ASSOCIATION HAD
FLEXIBILITY TO MEET REMOTELY.
THE REPORTED SIGNIFICANT
INCREASES IN PARTICIPATION COST
SAVINGS AND ENHANCED A
PARTICIPANT DIVERSITY. ONE
ASSOCIATION RESIDENT AND WE
BROWN WILL ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT
MA'AM FLOOR'S YOURS. YOU TO GO
TO. MY NAME IS STORING DATA AND
I HAVE BEEN IN THE CHOI INDUSTRY
FOR OVER TWENTY YEARS. I HAVE
WITNESSED FIRSTHAND THE IMPACT
OF VIRTUAL MEETINGS IN TODAY'S
FAST PACED BUSINESS LIFESTYLE
AND IT HAS DEFINITELY BEEN FOR
THE BENEFIT- I JUST WANNA GIVE
YOU A FEW KEY POINTS HERE AND
LET'S SEE. THIS IT. BUT THEY
CONDUCT THE- THIS IS AB INDUCTED
AND ENABLES A CHOICE OVERCOME
GEOGRAPHICAL BARRIERS
STREAMLINED COMMUNICATION
ENHANCE COLLABORATION AMONGST
OWNERS. ALLOWING FOR THESE
TELECONFERENCE AND VZNIKU
MEETINGS IS ALSO A VERY LOW COST
OPTION FOR ALLOWING BOARD
MEMBERS TO PARTICIPATE IN THEIR
COMMUNITIES. IN MY EXPERIENCE A
LARGER VOLUME OF DATA VERSUS A
GROUP OF HOMEOWNERS ARE ABLE TO
ATTEND BOARD MEETINGS FIGHT
CABLE TO MAKE HIM FEEL ASSUME. I
AM HERE TO SUPPORT THIS AND
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO BE
HERE THANK YOU ALL RIGHT OTHERS
IN SUPPORT MR BROWN. MR CHAIRMAN
PERSIK MANY LOUIS BROWN HERE
TODAY ON BEHALF OF COMMUNITY
ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE ACTION
COMMITTEE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
AND ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK
YOU. JENNIFER WHAT ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
COMMUNITY MANAGERS AND SUPPORT
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT
SAYING NO ONE ELSE APPROACH THE
MICROPHONE UP OPPOSITION I KNOW
NO OPPOSITION ON FILE. IF YOU'RE
NOT EXIST PLEASE APPROACH
MICROPHONE SING KNOWN
APPROACHING MODERATE PLEASE
QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE BOTH IN
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION A. B.
SIX FOUR EIGHT. IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO EIGHTY SIX FOUR
EIGHT PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME. AND WE HAVE A COMMENT
FROM LINE THREE SIXTY ONE. I'LL
ALWAYS REGRET ONE I THOUGHT
EIGHT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH- I
OPPOSE- THE- BILL. FOR OUR GUNS
WAY THAT ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH THANK YOU MA'AM NECK
CALLER. ALL RIGHT THE ADDRESS
THERE NOVEMBER OBVIOUSLY IS.
SOMEWHERE IN THE INVISIBLE INK-
OKAY- QUESTIONS RIGHT
COMMITMENTS THAT THEY'RE LAYERED
I JUST MAKE A BRIEF COMMENT I AM
A MEMBER OF A- OF AN ASSOCIATION
WITH MY CONDO HERE. AND BECAUSE
I LIVE IN TWO PLACES. IT HAS
BEEN REALLY NICE OCCASIONALLY TO
ZOOM IN FROM A HUNDRED AND FIFTY
MILES AWAY AND THIS IS. WHY
SUPPORT IMPLEMENTING THIS. FOR
OTHER THINGS THESE ARE NOT LIFE
AND DEATH THINGS THIS IS A
MATTER OF CONVENIENCE AND I
WOULD MOVE THE BILL ALL RIGHT.
SIR LEARN MOST OF THE OTHER
CLOSER ANY AILMENTS COMMON ALSO
. I DO NOT COMMENDED BE FULL
PARTICIPATION ON H. AWAY BOARDS.
BUT BOB SIMON VILLAGE COULD YOU
WORK TO ME WHERE IN YOUR BILL
YOU'RE TAKING GUNS AWAY FROM
PEOPLE. IN THE PROVISION THAT
RAISES TAXES SELF INTEREST RIGHT
THAT'S BY THE WAY THAT'S THAT'S
THE JOKE JUST FOR THE RECORD NOW
RIGHT NOT A RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE
TODAY IS THE FINAL. RIGHT GOING
CENTER WHAT DID YOU WANT COMMENT
I ABSOLUTELY DO SO I LIVE IN H.
AWAY FIVE THOUSAND HOMES LIVE
NINE HOURS AWAY AND I GET TO
PARTICIPATE AND YELL AT THOSE
BOARD MEMBERS FROM FROM UP HERE
WHICH IS GREAT SO. I'M FEELING
IT SOMEBODY SAID OF THEM YELLING
AT ME SO I THINK THIS IS A GREAT
DEAL OKAY. AND SETTLEMENT- THANK
YOU SOMEONE MEANT I DO KNOW THAT
I RAN A BILL LAST YEAR MAYBE TWO
YEARS AGO NO YEAH TWO YEARS AGO-
ALLOWING FOR VIRTUAL MEETINGS
DURING EMERGENCIES AND WE- AT
THAT POINT. TIME WE RAN INTO A
LOT OPPOSITION. REALLY ARE YOU
ARE PROCEDURAL SAY. IN AND I'M
GONNA SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY BUT
I JUST WANT TO NOTE THAT THAT-
FOR THE RECORD THAT. THERE ARE
DEEPLY HELD CONCERNS BECAUSE
HOAS DO HAVE INCREDIBLE
INFLUENCE ON THE LIVES OF MANY
MANY PEOPLE HERE IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. AND WE DO NEED TO
BALANCE- PARTICIPATION WHICH
YOUR BILL DOES WITH PROCEDURAL
SAFEGUARDS TO MAKE SURE THAT
THERE ARE NOT ABUSES SO. I THANK
YOU FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD
AND I GUESS. YOU KNOW A WE
ALWAYS HAVE THE ABILITY TO BRING
FUTURE BILLS BUT IF THERE ARE
POTENTIALLY PROBLEMS WITH THIS
BILL AS IS- LOOK FORWARD TO
SEEING YOU TRY TO CLEAN IT UP.
I'M HAPPY TO DO THAT ONLINE
THANK YOU IT'S BEEN MOVED BY
CENTER LAYERED SIMILAR VIOLENCE
YOU CARE CLOSE RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YES VOTE ALL RIGHT THANK
YOU. BUT I'M SICK TO PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL THIS IS FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINETEEN SB SIX FORTY
EIGHT THE MOTION IS TO PASS ON
BURKE HI NUMBER I WILL CRY. WILK
AYE ALLEN. ALLEN I ASK B. SB I
COVER YOUR- TO ROSS. DURING I
LAYERED. I AM IN YES YES YES.
SILICON THAT ONCE MEN RIGHT I
KNEW LOW. THE LITTLE AYE STERN.
STERN I. YOU HAVE NINE ZERO
MEMBERS MISSING RIGHT NOT ZERO-
THIS IS LAST BUILDING. TODAY I
KNOW SENATOR WIENER IS SHARING
HOUSING COMMITTEE HE AND I ARE
GOING TO SWITCH PLACES IN JUST A
MOMENT- SO- SOMEONE WILL ANSWER.
A. B. THREE FOUR TWO. THANK YOU
I WANNA START OFF BY THANKING
THE COMMITTEE FOR WORKING ON
THIS PARTICULAR BILL- THIS IS AN
INDUSTRY SPONSORED MEASURE THAT
WILL PROMOTE DIVERSITY EQUITY
AND INCLUSION EFFORTS AND
HISTORICALLY HOMOGENOUS
PROFESSIONS. IN THE STATE OF
THAT PROCESS CALIFORNIA THROUGH
THE CENTRAL DAY OUR BUILT
ENVIRONMENT AND REALISTIC
VALUATIONS REFLECT A RANGE OF
EXPERIENCES AND PERSPECTIVES. OF
A DIVERSE COMMUNITIES. AB THREE
FOUR TWO WILL GIVE THE
CALIFORNIA ARCHITECTS BOARD AND
THE BUREAU OF REAL ESTATE
APPRAISERS THE AUTHORITY TO.
REQUEST DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION
. ON RACE ETHNICITY AND GENDER
EXPRESSION. BY ALLOWING YET NOT
MANDATE THE COLLECTION OF THIS
DATA. WE'LL GET A BETTER
UNDERSTANDING OF THE STATE OF
DIVERSITY IN THESE PROFESSIONS
AND DEVELOP TARGETED STRATEGIES
TO PROMOTE GREATER INCLUSIVITY
AND EQUITY. THE COLLECTION OF
THIS AGGREGATED DATA WILL BE
PUBLISHED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF
CONSUMER AFFAIRS THIS BILL
CREATES PARITY WITH OTHER
PROFESSIONAL LICENSING BOARDS
WERE ALREADY COLLECTING THIS
TYPE OF INFORMATION. AND WITH ME
TO PROVIDE QUICK TESTIMONY IS
MISTER MICHAEL. THANK YOU MISTER
BLOAT. MEMBERS MICHAEL OUT ON
BEHALF OF TO OUR OUR FIRM'S
CLIENTS THE- AS WILL INSTITUTE
CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
COMMITTEE. AND THE AMERICAN
INSTITUTE OF ARCHITECTS
CALIFORNIA BOTH CASES THE
NATION'S LARGEST PROFESSIONAL
ASSOCIATIONS THE FACTS ARE A
LITTLE DIFFERENT OBVIOUSLY THE
ACTIVITIES ARE DIFFERENT BETWEEN
APPRAISERS. AND ARCHITECTS I WAS
SURPRISED TO BE TOLD THAT ACTUAL
STATUTORY AUTHORIZATION NEEDS TO
BE GIVEN. TO VOLUNTARILY REQUEST
THIS INFORMATION BUT THAT'S WHAT
WE'RE TOLD I THINK THE STORY IS
EXACTLY THE SAME IF YOU WERE
GONNA PROMOTE EQUITY DIVERSITY
AND INCLUSION. YOU HAVE TO START
WITH THE BASELINE OF HOW YOU'RE
DOING I'M TOLD. THAT
PROFESSIONAL LICENSING BOARDS
THAT ALREADY ASKED THIS GET
ABOUT 70% COMPLIANCE INCLUDING
THE STATE BAR. AND SO I THINK
IT'S A STEP AND WE STRONGLY
SUPPORTED PASSWORD I. ALL RIGHT
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT
SAYING NO ONE ELSE UP. YOU HAVE
TO BE QUICK IN THIS COMMITTEE.
WELL HI MY NAME'S ALAN THE DEAL
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
INTERNATIONAL INTERIOR DESIGN
ASSOCIATION. OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA AND SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA CHAPTERS IN FULL
SUPPORT THANK YOU ALL RIGHT
OTHERS IN SUPPORT. SEE NO ONE
ELSE APPROACH MY PHONE
OPPOSITION IF YOU'RE NOT
POSITION PLEASE APPROACH
MICROPHONE SING KNOWN OF.
APPROACH TO MICROPHONE- LET'S
TURN THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR
PLEASE QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT AND IN OPPOSITION AB
THREE FOUR TWO. AND WE ASK THE
SENATOR WIENER- IF HE WOULD
APPEAR AND THEN I WILL LEAVE.
AND HEAD DOWN TO HOUSING SO-
MODERATOR PLEASE KILL CLOSE IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION AB THREE
FOUR TWO. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
TO EIGHTY THREE FOUR TWO PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
WE DO HAVE A COMET COMING
THROUGH. ONE MOMENT PLEASE WHILE
WE PROVIDE THEM WITH THEIR LINE
NUMBER. AND WE'LL HEAR FROM LINE
ONE SEVENTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD
. HELLO THIS IS CINDY RIGHT ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ARCHITECT FORTY DEPORTED
DIFFICULT. THANK YOU. AND MISTER
CHAIR THERE ARE NO FURTHER
COMMENT AT THIS TIME ALL RIGHT
COMMENTS QUESTIONS CONCERNS
CENTERMAN. I THINK IT'S A GREAT
BILL AND WOULD ASK TO BE ME A CO
AUTHOR OF THE APPROPRIATE TIME
AS VICE CHAIR THE EIGHT K.
LEGISLATIVE CAUCUS I. WE ALL
SEEN THE ANECDOTAL STORIES OF
HOW- APPRAISALS CAN MATTER AND
THEY CAN BE. SUBJECT TO RACIAL
INFLUENCE- IMPLICIT BIAS AND THE
LIKE AND SO I THINK THIS IS VERY
IMPORTANT TO GET A HANDLE ON. SO
THANK ACKERMAN THE AUTHORING THE
BILL SENATE I'LL MOVE IT AS-
YOU'VE MOVED IT ALL RIGHT
THURMOND MOVES THE BILL ALL
RIGHT. ALL RIGHT. SURVEILLANCE
IT CARE CLOSE APPRECIATE TIME
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YES ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU MUCH ALL RIGHT
MA'AM SECTOR PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. THIS IS FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWENTY AB THREE FORTY TWO OF THE
MOTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE A BURKE
HI. I'M BURKE I WILL CRY WILK
AYE ALLEN. ALLEN AYE ASHBY. SB
I. CABALLERO. COPYRIGHT TWO
RUSSELL. RUSSELL ARE HIGHLY.
LAYERED I AM IN. MEN I HELLO
RIGHT NEIL AYE STERN. STERN I.
TENDER ZERO MEMBERS MISSING ALL
RIGHT TEN ZERO WE'RE GONNA PUT
THAT ON CALL THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THE MEMBER LENSA. CELL WE'RE
GOING TO WAIT JUST ONE MOMENT
I'M I'M GOING TO CHECK ON THE
STATUS OF SENATOR WIENER IF HE'S
GOING TO BE HERE SOON I'M GOING
TO. ONE SECOND. ALL RIGHT IF
HE'S ON HIS WAY UP RIGHT NOW ALL
RIGHT. FAMOUS LAST WORDS BUT
WITH. ALL RIGHT ALL RIGHT- INTO
THE WORLD. YES WE'RE GONNA WAIT
JUST WAIT WAIT A MINUTE OR SELL
- THE WE SEE CENTER HUESO IS
HERE. ALUMNUS RIGHT. HUESO YEAH
I DON'T THINK I CAN DO THAT SO
ALL RIGHT. I DON'T WANT. YES
OKAY ALL RIGHT LET'S LEARN IT
WILL OPEN UP OF THE ROLE ON ITEM
NUMBER ONE THE- ALL RIGHT I
REMEMBER ONE OF FILE ITEM NUMBER
ONE AB SIX SIX FIVE CHAIR VOTING
BY ASHBY. SB I. CABALLERO.
APPAREL I LAYERED. LAYERED HI
MEN MEN I STERN. STERN I. NINE
TWO TWO. NINE TWO THAT BILL IS
OUT. ALL RIGHT THEN I THINK THE
VOTE ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR
ALSO. ALL RIGHT LET'S LET'S OPEN
.
ALL RIGHT- MADAM SECRETARY WE'RE
GONNA GO THROUGH THE ROLE ONE
TIME- BENCIC THREE IF YOU WOULD
CALL THE ROLL. ON ALL THE BILLS
THAT ARE CURRENTLY ON CALL. ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR CHAIR
VOTING I CABALLERO. I AM IN. IN
A NEW LOW. THIS IS THE CONSENT
CALENDAR NERO. STERN I JUST TURN
AYE WIENER. THE TECHNICAL WIENER
I. A YOU HAVE TENDED ZERO TEN
ZERO PUT ON CALL FOR A MOMENT.
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO AB ELEVEN
NINETY FOUR CHAIR VOTING I
CABALLERO COPYRIGHT I LAYERED
LAYERED I AM MEN MEN I AM THE
LOW. STERN STERN AYE WIENER.
WIENER I TEND ZERO ONE MEMBER
MISSING ZERO- WITH WITH THE ON
CALL. FILE ITEM NUMBER THREE AB
TWELVE VOTING AYE WILK.
CABALLERO CAREER I LAYERED
LAYERED I AM IN. MEN KNOW WIENER
WIENER I. YOU HAVE A TWO TO ONE
NUMBER MISSING EIGHT TWO. NO I'M
SORRY IT'S A TO EVERYONE ABOUT
IT EIGHT TWO OF BILLS OUT. FILE
ITEM NUMBER FOUR AB EIGHT
SIXTEEN CHAIR VOTING AYE WILK.
NO WORK NO CABALLERO. AYE WIENER
. WIENER I. NINETY TO NINETY TWO
THE BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER
SIX AB FIFTEEN FORTY SIX
TRAVELING I FEDERAL. BUREAU AYE
STERN. STERN AYE WIENER. WIENER
I NINETY TWO. NINE TWO BILLS OUT
. FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB SIX
OH FOUR CHAIR VOTING AYE WILK NO
BOOK NO CABALLERO CAREER ALL AYE
WIENER. WIENER I. NINE TWO TWO.
NINE TWO BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINE AB NINE FIVE FOUR
CHAIR VOTING AYE WILK. ZERO ZERO
I KNEW LOW. WIENER WIENER I.
NINE TWO ZERO ONE MEMBER MISSING
. NINE ZERO NINE ZERO BILLS OUT
. OKAY I'M SORRY PUT BACK ON
CALL OKAY. FILE ITEM NUMBER
THIRTEEN H. A R. FIVE TO VOTING
I CABALLERO COPYRIGHT I KNEW
LOW. WINNER WIENER I. TEN ZERO
ONE MEMBER MISSING. BILLS ON
CALL. TEN ZERO. THIS IS FILE
ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN AB FIVE
THIRTY FOUR CHAIR VOTING I WILL
CRY WILK HI CABALLERO CAREER AYE
WIENER. WIENER I. ELEVEN ZERO
ELEVEN ZERO BILLS OUT. FILE
ITEMS NINETEEN AB SIX FORTY
EIGHT VOTING I CABALLERO. OUR
BUREAU I WINNER WIENER I ELEVEN
ZERO ELEVEN ZERO BILLS OUT. FILE
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY VOTING AYE
WIENER. WIENER AYE ELEVEN ZERO.
SEVEN ZERO BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY TWO EIGHTY SEVEN
SIXTY VOTING I WILL. WILK
CABALLERO. SO I WOULD GO WITH IT
CABALLERO I HELLO. WIENER WIENER
I. OKAY THE NINE TWO ZERO
MEMBERS MISSING ALL RIGHT WE'LL
PUT THAT BACK ON CALL NINE ZERO-
I'M GONNA HAVE TO LEAVE HERE IN
JUST A MOMENT I THINK SENATOR
WILL. WE'LL TAKE CONTROL THANK.
IF YOU ARE JOB NUMBER HAVE
PLAYED. THAT IT WE.
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR NERO WHY
HELLO I LIVE IN ZERO ABSENT
MINDED. ELEVEN ZERO AND THE
CONSENT CALENDAR IS ADOPTED
CENTER WILL KEEP AN OUTSTANDING
JOB THANK YOU SIR. THEY'RE MORE
I THINK HE NO I KNOW HE
PURPOSELY DID NOT VOTE ON THOSE
THREE YES THEY WILL. OKAY OKAY
FILE ITEM TO AB ELEVEN NINETY
FOUR MEELO. ATTENDED. ZERO
REFERRAL FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO
YOUR BROWSER FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWO OUT TEND IS ZERO. FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINE AB NINE FIVE FOR
YOUR VOTING I WILK MEELO. NINE
ZERO OKAY NINE OH AND MEASURES
OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN
AJ ARE FIVE VOTING I YOU WILL. A
TENNIS HERO. AND THE RESOLUTIONS
ADOPTED. TEN ZERO. AND I BELIEVE
THAT IS A RAFT. WE JUST DIDN'T I
THOUGHT WE JUST DID TWENTY TWO.
NOT WHILE I WAS GIVEN THE
QUALITY THANK YOU FILE ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY TWO EIGHTY SEVEN
SIXTY TWO VOTING ON A WILK
MEANWHILE. NINE ZERO AND THAT
ITEM TWENTY TWO OUT NINE ZERO.
AND WITH THAT. IF YOU'RE WORKING
WITH EVERYBODY HERE TODAY GOOD
JOB WHERE GERMS.