OKAY THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON
HOUSING- WILL COME TO ORDER FIVE
GOOD AFTERNOON EVERYONE- THE
SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME BOTH
IN PERSON PUBLIC TESTIMONY AS
WELL AS REMOTE PUBLIC TESTIMONY
FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY- BY
PHONE THE PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
. EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN TWO TWO SIX
ONE SIX THREE AND THE ACCESS
CODE IS THREE THREE ZERO EIGHT
EIGHT OH FIVE- WE ARE HOLDING
THE COMMITTEE HEARING IN OUR
OWES THREE- BUILDING- AND I
WOULD ASK MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE- TO COME COME ON DOWN
SO WE CAN ESTABLISH QUORUM. WE
HAVE THIRTY BILLS ON TODAY'S
AGENDA SEVEN OF THEM ARE ON
CONSENT- AND I WANT TO JUST MAKE
ONE ANNOUNCING BEFORE YET BEFORE
WE BEGIN ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN AB
FIVE THREE ONE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
IRWIN- HAS BEEN PULLED FROM THE
AGENDA WE WILL NOT BE HERE IN
THE BILL TODAY- WHAT WOULD NOT
HAVE A SO START UP CAN AND A I
NEED TO OUT TO A COMMITTEE AND
SO I'M GOING TO. OFFERS WALK MR
SUB OF. TWO PRESENTS. AB FORTY
TWO- AND I'M GOING TO. OUT OF
THE CAPITAL OVER. TO CENTERS.
THANK YOU I WILL SEE YOU.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER RAMOS WHENEVER
YOU'RE READY. THANK YOU A MISS
CHAIRMAN US. AB TWO AIM TO HELP
PROGRAMS THIS. WHEN IT TO US.
THOSE X. OR AT RISK OF A-
HOMELESS. AS CHAIR OF THE SELECT
COMMITTEE ON YOUTH. ASSEMBLY
COUNTY I UNDERSTAND THAT HOME
WITH YOU SO. IN AB. FOR TWO TO
ONE. HAS ITS THE CURRENT. OF
HAVING TO INSTALL FOR SPRING. IN
TEMPER SLIP CAP. PROVES TO BE A
SICK. COST PER. THE BILL EGGS SO
TO SO K. FROM THE RECALL OF
FIRES. BUT ALSO AND VARIOUS
MANDATORY PROVISIONS TO ENSURE
THE SAFETY OF THE OCCUPANT. TO
ALLEVIATE FIRE SAFETY CONCERNS
WE HAVE LOWERED THE SQUARE
FOOTAGE CHANGE THE DEFINITION OF
THE UNITS AS WELL AS ADDED
ALTERNATIVE FIRE AND SAFETY
REQUIREMENTS TO ENSURE SAFETY
AND ADDRESS OPPOSITION'S
CONCERNS. WE ALSO REQUIRE THE
UNIT TO BE MADE OF NON
COMBUSTIBLE MATERIALS
ADDITIONALLY EACH SLOT WOULD BE
ABLE TO HOLD A MAXIMUM OF FIFTY
UNITS EACH UNIT SITUATED SIX
FEET APART WITH FIRE ALARMS FIRE
EXTINGUISHER AND TWENTY FOUR
SEVEN FIRE WATCH. I UNDERSTAND
THERE'S STILL SOME OPPOSITION
BUT WHERE DO MAKING OUR WAY
THROUGH IN ADDRESSING THOSE
CONCERNS BUT WE HAVE BEEN ABLE
TO ENGAGE IN THOSE CONVERSATIONS
AND WILL CONTINUE. AB FORTY TWO
IS A UNIQUE SOLUTION TO ALLOW
FOR THE CREATION OF NEW
TEMPORARY SLEEPING CABINS TO
SERVE THE STATE'S HOMELESS
POPULATION ESPECIALLY FOR YOUTH
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS. WITH
ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL IS VITA PUTS
SYRIANS FROM THE FAMILY
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM LOCATED IN
SAN MARINO COUNTY. GOOD
AFTERNOON MY NAME IS V. THAT WAS
SITTING AND I REPRESENT THE
FAMILY ASSISTANCE PROGRAM OR
NONPROFIT AGENCY THAT SERVES
FAMILIES FAMILIES AND HOMELESS
YOUTH IN SAN MARINO COUNTY. I'M
HERE TODAY REGARDING ASSEMBLY
BILL AB FORTY TWO THIS BILL IS
IMPORTANT BECAUSE THERE ARE
THOUSANDS OF TEMPORARY SLEEPING
CABINS THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. DECEMBER YOU
SLEEPING CABINS WERE BUILT TO
HELP GET PEOPLE OFF THE STREET
AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE THE
TEMPORARY SLEEPING CABINS HAVE
ALWAYS BEEN A TEMPORARY FIX TO
HELP ADDRESS OUR HOMELESS CRISIS
IN THE STATE. THEY'RE MEANT TO
BE BUILT QUICKLY IN A COST
EFFECTIVE MATTER TO HELP THAT
FOLKS OFF THE STREET AND BEGIN
THEIR TRANSITION INTO HOUSING
AND SELF SUFFICIENCY AS QUICKLY
AS POSSIBLE ACROSS THE STATE
THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF TEMPORARY
SLEEPING CABINS THAT WERE BUILT
AND ARE WORKING UNDER THE
EMERGENCY DECLARATION THAT MANY
CITIES ADOPTED. WHEN THIS
EMERGENCY DECLARATION ENDS AND
IT WILL AND THEY WILL HAVE TO
TURN DOWN THOUSANDS OF UNITS.
AND WHERE WERE ALL THESE PEOPLE
GO THEY MUST GO SOMEWHERE AND
UNFORTUNATELY I'M NOT CONFIDENT
THAT WE WILL HAVE ENOUGH UNITS.
WITH THE PROPER SUPPORT SYSTEM
TO HELP EVERYONE FIND A ROOF
QUICKLY. NOW SOME CITIES HAVE
NOT BEEN ABLE TO MAKE THIS
EMERGENCY DECLARATION AND OUR
REGION FOR EXAMPLE VERY FEW
CITIES HAVE MADE THEM. AND. SO
WE TURNED INWARD TO A X. TO
LEARN HOW WE HELP ADDRESS THIS
HOUSE CRISIS WILL KEEP OUR COME.
SAFE WE MET WITH OUR RETIRED
FIRE CHIEF IN OUR REGION AND HE-
SHARED WITH THOSE THAT FIRES
FOR. SO WOULD NOT IMPACT THE
SAFETY OF A PERSON WHO LIVES IN
A TEMPORARY SLEEPING CABIN. FIRE
SPRINKLERS ARE MEANT TO KEEP THE
PERSON SAFE AS THE EXIT THREE
LARGE BUILDING. THESE HOUSING
UNITS THAT WE'RE WORKING WITH
ARE UNDER TWO HUNDRED SQUARE
FEET AND SO IT DEFEATS THE
SAFETY PURPOSE THAT THE FIRE
SPRINKLER SYSTEMS WERE MOUNTAIN
TIME. AND IT DOUBLES THE COST TO
BUILD THEM WHICH OF COURSE MEANS
THAT WE ARE. THAT OUR COMMUNITY
HAS TO SAY ON THE STREETS LONGER
. WHEN WE TALK TO OUR OFFICIALS
ABOUT THIS. THEY SAY THAT THEY
HAVE TO CALL THE STATE BUILDING
CODES. AND SO WE HAVE TO ADDRESS
THAT AND SO WE HAVE TO ASK
SOMETHING THAT OUR FIRE CHIEF
STATES IT'S NOT REQUIRED. AND WE
HAVE TO KEEP OUR PEOPLE ON THE
STREETS LONGER. WE DON'T WANT TO
BOIL DOWN ON THE COSTS TOO MUCH
BUT IT IS SOMETHING THAT WE AS A
PROVIDER HAVE TO CONSIDER. THE
COST OF THESE TEMPORARY SLEEPING
CABINS IS ABOUT FIFTEEN THOUSAND
DOLLARS PER UNIT AND THE FIRE
SUPPRESSION SYSTEM IS ALSO ABOUT
FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS PER
UNIT. WHICH MEANS THAT WE'RE
BUILDING ONE UNIT FOR THE COSTA
TO AND KEEPING ABOUT HALF OF THE
PEOPLE WAITING FOR UNIT ON THE
STREETS. WHERE THEY ARE LIVING A
HARSH LIFE AND SAFE LIFE AND
WITH FAR FEWER SAFETY STANDARDS
AND WE COULD EVER PUT THEM
THROUGH. A SPEAKING OF SAFETY
STANDARDS AND THEN YOU START TO
WRAP IT UP ACTUALLY WE'RE ONLY
STRESS OUT TWO MINUTES FOR EACH
SPEAKER SURE. AND- SO YEAH IF
YOU CAN GET TO WRAP UP THAT YEAH
ABSOLUTELY THIS BILL HAS A HOT
FAR HIGHER. SAFETY THEN UP THEN
THAN. THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK
YOU MUCH SIR TO THREE OFF KEY
BUT- YES DIDN'T GET THE CHANCE
TO. IT ARE. SPEAKERS WILL HAVE
TWO MINUTES. AND- AND THEN. THE
OPPOSITE SPEAKERS ALSO HAVE
MINUTES. AND WE HAVE TO SEE.
FREE. ONE JACKSON. SO YOU HAD
ONE PART. WITNESS FOR PRIMARY
WITNESS RIGHT THIS FEATURE.
DURING THE HAVE. ANY BY ELSE IN
ROOM. WOULD LIKE TO ADD. ON
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL. THERE'S
NO. ELSE IS THERE ANY. IN ROOM
THAT SPEAK OPPOSITE. TO THIS.
SIR COME ON UP. STATE YOUR NAME
. GOOD AFTERNOON. BRADY GARDEN
ON BEHALF OF THAT. BUILD
OFFICIALS. IN OPPOSITION TO THE
MATH. AS CURRENTLY. ONE OF THE
FIRST THING THE AUTHORS OF. FOR
THE CONTINUE DIALOGUE AND BILL
THE BILL'S BEEN AND- CONSISTS
CONSIDERABLE. AS FROM I WAS
FIRST. IN WE APPRECIATE THAT. WE
DO SO SOME SAFETY CAN. FOR THE
FOR SPRINKLER ISSUE WE THINK
THAT THERE'S- COMMON GROUND WITH
A FINALLY. AND WILL TO WORK
THEM. FOR THAT BUT WE- TO HAVE
TO THE- OF IT SO. TO EXAMPLES
OF. SPRINKLER BEING USED. FOR
SAFETY. MARCH TWENTY TWENTY
THREE THE- PEOPLE'S BILL YOU
CAN. OF TWO FIVE HOMES FOR THE
UNSHELTERED FIRE THE AFTER.
FORTUNATELY NO ONE WAS IN OR
KILLED AND A LOOK FARMER IN THE
CAN. GET CREDIT TO THE FIRES FOR
AND SUPPRESSION SYSTEM. GIVING
RESIDENTS A PEACEFUL TIME WINDOW
TO ESCAPE UNITS REDUCE SPREAD OF
FIRE TO OTHER UNITS. HAVE THESE
FIRE SPRINKLER UP AND- THERE'S A
BALLOT CAN THAT MORE PEOPLE
WOULD HAVE LOST THEIR LIVES OR
BEEN INJURED IN THIS UNFORTUNATE
EVENT. A SECOND EXAMPLE OCCURRED
IN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES ON
SEPTEMBER TWENTY TWENTY TWO WERE
TINY HOME VILLAGE OF HOMELESS
VETERANS THAT VALIANTLY SERVED
OUR COUNTRY CAUGHT FIRE. AGAIN
LUCKILY NO ONE WAS INJURED OR
KILLED BY RESIDENTS NOTED IN
INTERVIEWS UP THE FIRE
EXTINGUISHER DID NOT WORK TO
EXTINGUISH THE FIRE AND SMOKE
ALARM SYSTEMS WENT. UNHEARD FOR
SOME RESIDENTS IN THE VILLAGE
HAD FIRE SPRINKLERS BEEN PRESENT
IN THE BILL IT'S TWELVE TWENTY
HOMES MAY NOT BEEN DESTROYED AND
TEN MAY NOT HAVE BEEN DAMAGE IF
THEY WERE. PRESENT CHALONER
COALITION OF BUILDING SAFETY
GROUPS HAVE CONCERNS AT THIS
BILL COULD RESULT IN EVEN WORSE
EVEN IF IT PASSED INTO LAW.
THESE ARE JUST TWO EXAMPLES
ABOUT FIRE SPRINKLER SYSTEMS CAN
PROVIDE THE STRONGEST PROTECTION
FOR RESIDENTS WHICH IS THE GOAL
OF OUR COALITION. WE'RE
CONCERNED THAT REMOVED REMOVING
. THE ABILITY. TO IT'S FOR PRICE
FOR JUST RESULT. FURTHER INJURED
UP FOR HOME. OR AB. IN THE- WITH
FORWARD TO CONTINUE PART. WITH
A- LEADERS AND THE AUTHOR OFFICE
OF. COMING ABOUT THE- I BELIEVE
THAT THERE'S SOME CALL. GROUND
LETTING LOW AGENCY. CHOOSE L.
FOR LIFE SEE. MEASURES IN THIS
BILL. OR FIRE SPRINKLERS AT TO
DISCUSS OF THE LOCAL FARMERS.
AND FOR THOSE REASONS WE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE
TODAY THANK YOU. THREE YOU VERY
MUCH IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE
SPEAKING OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL
. YES MA'AM. FIFTH PORCHES ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS OPPOSED FOR THE SAME
REASON. THANK YOU. ARE THERE
ANYBODY ELSE IN THE ROOM. IF NOT
WE'LL GO TO THE EIGHTEEN T.
OPERATOR EIGHTEEN YEAH OPERATOR
IF YOU CAN. GET ANYBODY ON THE
LINE WOULD LIKE TO ADD- THEIR
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. PLEASE IF
YOU'RE ON THE LINE AND YOU'RE
CALLING IN JUST STATE YOUR NAME.
ORGANIZATION YOU REPRESENT AND
WHETHER YOU ARE FOR OR OPPOSED
TO THE BILL. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR FOR THOSE WHO WISH TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
TO THIS BILL PRESS ONE AND ZERO
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO ONLY ONE
TIME AS PRESIDENT WHEN INTEREST
SECOND TIME WILL REMOVE YOU FROM
THE COMMENTS KILL. AND WE'RE
GOING TO GO TO LINE FORTY NINE.
FIVE FORTY NINE YOUR LINE IS NOW
OPEN. AFTERNOON MY NAME
FINANCIAL I THOUGHT CALLING ON
THE BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
COALITION FOR YOUTH CALLING IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU HAVE A GREAT
DAY. RESEARCHER THERE IS NO ONE
ELSE TO SIGNAL THAT THEY WISH TO
SPEAK TO. BRING IT BACK TO THE
DIE HERE FOR ANY QUESTIONS
MISTAKES PRAYER. THANK YOU. I'VE
REALLY VERY MUCH SUPPORT THIS
BILL AND I WOULD BE HAPPY TO BE
A CO AUTHOR IF YOU ARE LOOKING
FOR MORE OR ONE- I JUST I JUST
WANT TO SHARE THAT AS THE MAYOR
OF MY CITY EVENTS NEED US WE-
REALLY STRUGGLED TO HELP
ILLEGAL. EIGHTY USER EIGHTY USE
THAT WERE ON PERMITTED COME UP
TO CODE AND ONE OF THE ISSUES
WAS THE COST AND THE BURDEN AND
HASSLE OF THE OF THIS FIRE
SPRINKLERS. AND SO FINDING
ALTERNATIVE WAYS TO REDUCE THE
COST AND THE ADMINISTRATIVE
BURDEN. IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT IF
WE'RE GOING TO ACTUALLY PROVIDE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR PEOPLE TO
SLEEP INSIDE AND NOT BE
HOMELESS. SO ALL OF THE- THE
THINGS THAT YOU'VE DONE IN THIS
BILL THE SIZE THE TESTIMONY FROM
YOUR FROM YOUR SPEAKER SUPPORTER
TALKING ABOUT THE FACT THAT FIRE
SPRINKLERS ARE REALLY NOT NEEDED
IF SOMEONE'S LEAVING A TWO
HUNDRED OR TWO HUNDRED FIFTY
SQUARE FOOT SPACE IT'S NOT
THEY'RE NOT GOING TO IN. A LARGE
APARTMENT COMPLEX ARE OFFICE
BUILDINGS I THINK THAT MAKES A
LOT OF SENSE AND IT'S JUST
IMPORTANT THAT WERE CREATIVE
ABOUT SOLUTIONS TO GET HOUSING
BILLS FASTER. ESPECIALLY
HOMELESS SERVING HOUSING SO
DOING THE STREAMLINING IN THIS
TALK ON THIS TOPIC IS JUST
CRITICAL AND I'M REALLY GRATEFUL
THAT YOU BROUGHT THIS BILL
FORWARD THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO
MUCH OF WE HAPPY TO ADD YOU AS A
CO AUTHOR THANK YOU AND I WILL
MOVE THE BILL. OKAY WE DO WE ARE
NOT. WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM YET
SO WE'RE JUST STAFF OPERATING
SYSTEM COMMITTEE. SO WE'LL TAKE
THAT INTO ACCOUNT WHEN WE DO
HAVE. ENOUGH PEOPLE- ANYBODY
ELSE. IF NOT I'LL ADD MY TWO
CENTS- ACTUALLY IS A REALLY GOOD
BILL BECAUSE IT KIND OF FINDS
THE SWEET SPOT BETWEEN FILE LIFE
SAFETY. AND PRACTICALITY- IF WE
WERE GOING TO ADD THE COSTS.
THAT WE ARE WHO WOULD ADD FOUR
FIRE SPRINKLERS THEMSELVES. TO
EACH OF THESE. IT PUTS IT
BEYOND- THAT HELP FOR A LOT OF
PEOPLE THERE WILL BE A LOT OF
PEOPLE CAN BE HELPED. THAT WE
WON'T BE ABLE TO BECAUSE WE'RE
PUTTING IT ALL INTO THIS ONE
LIFE SAFETY THING- A LOT OF THE
MITIGATION MEASURES THAT YOU
HAVE TAKEN. ADDRESS THE LIFE
SAFETY. ISSUE YOU TALK ABOUT A
ONE IN ONE ROOM MMHM. DOMICILE
AND- IN. AND HE GENERALLY SMOKED
. AND AND A FAST EXIT IS
SUFFICIENT FOR THE LIFE SAFETY
PARK. ONE OF THE OTHER ASPECTS
OF PEOPLE DON'T TALK A LOT ABOUT
IS- YOU KNOW THE OTHER PARTY
SPRINKLERS IS MOST OF THE DAMAGE
FROM SPRINT BECAUSE AS FAR AS
FROM THEM GETTING KNOCKED OFF.
AND CREATING A FLOOD INSTEAD.
AND SO ZERO THERE IS THAT AS FAR
AS IS WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT THE
COSTS FOR DAMAGE- SO YOU KNOW IT
WHEN YOU HAVE A FIRE IN A ONE
ONE BEDROOM PLACE OUR ONE ROOM.
FOR UNIT- YOU KNOW THAT HEY
WHATEVER DAMAGES IS GOING TO BE
YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO RENOVATE
ALL PLACE. THAT YOU'RE NOT EVER
GOING TO GET AROUND THAT-
WHETHER IT'S A SPRINKLER HEAD
GETTING KNOCKED OUT FOR A FIRE.
AND AND SO WITH ALL THOSE
MITIGATION MEASURES. THIS IS
DENNIS YOU'VE DONE EVERYTHING
YOU CAN. TO FIND THAT SWEET SPOT
I THINK YOU HAVE AND- I'LL BE
SUPPORTING THE BILL WHEN IT
COMES UP AND I WANT TO THANK YOU
FOR IT AND IF YOU HAD ANY OTHER
READ THINGS YOU LIKE TO ADD.
THANK YOU- FOR THE CO AUTHORSHIP
IN THE AND THE KIND WORDS I MEAN
IT IS THE NUMBER ONE ISSUE IN
THE STATE AND I KNOW OUR LOVE
OUR- LOCAL AGENCIES IN. THIS
BILL- IS MEANT TO BE A
COMPONENT- NOT TO. BRING A
PERMANENT SOLUTION BUT A
COMPONENT TO GETTING PEOPLE INTO
HOUSING AND GETTING PEOPLE WHERE
THEY NEED TO BE. SO I ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE WHEN THE TIME IS
APPROPRIATE. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
GREAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SO
THE BRINGS US. MONTH RANGE TO
MAKE. WENT THAT BRINGS US TO
ITEM NUMBER. I BELIEVE. I THINK
WE HAVE. SOME MEMBER IS HE- THE
PRESENT. COMING UP CERTAINLY
MA'AM. THIS IS A AB THREE OH
NINE. CORRECT WHEN YOU'RE READY
GO HEAD THANK YOU THANK YOU
CHAIR AND MEMBERS I HAVE SOME
VISUAL AIDS. ARE BEING PRESENTED
HERE FOR YOU AS WELL. THANK YOU.
MEMBERS I'D TODAY IN PRESENTING
AB THREE OH NINE THE SOCIAL
HOUSING ACT. REDUCE AND
PRESERVE. AFFORDABLE HOUSING
ACROSS CALIFORNIA THE HOUSING WE
PUBLICLY BACKS SUSTAINABLE
COLLECTIVELY OWN AND AFFORDABLE
FOR ALL. INCOME LEVELS AND
FINANCIALLY SELF SUSTAINING IN
THE UNITED STATES IN MONTGOMERY
COUNTY IN MARYLAND THEY ARE
BUILDING SOCIAL HOUSING THEY
HAVE ALREADY BUILT ONE
DEVELOPMENT WITH TWO HUNDRED
SIXTY EIGHT UNITS AND HAVE A
THOUSAND MORE UNITS IN THE
PIPELINE. THIS THE PICTURE ON
THE LEFT HAND SIDE WHICH IS MORE
TYPICAL OF AMERICAN ARCHITECTURE
IS THAT SITE IN MARYLAND AND
THEY ARE IN FACT THE LEADERS IN
THE UNITED STATES WHEN IT COMES
TO IMPLEMENTING SUCH HOUSING.
BUT WE STILL HAVE A LOT TO CATCH
UP SEATTLE WASHINGTON JUST
PASSED ABOUT MEASURE TO DO SO TO
CREATE A SOCIAL DEVELOPER IN
FEBRUARY OF THIS YEAR BECOMING
THE FIRST JURISDICTION IN THE
NATION TO DO SO BY BALLOT. IN
OTHER STATES LIKE HAWAII NEW
YORK MASSACHUSETTS RHODE ISLAND
HAVE INTRODUCED THEIR OWN SOCIAL
HOUSING BILLS ALL OF THESE
PLACES ARE LANDING ON SOCIAL
HOUSING AS A SOLUTION BECAUSE OF
ITS DEMONSTRATE SUCCESS AND
UNIVERSALITY. AND TREATING
HOUSING AS A HUMAN RIGHTS
VARIOUS OTHER COUNTRIES HAVE
ALSO FACED HOUSING CRISIS OF
THEIR OWN AND FOUND SUCCESSES
THROUGH SOCIAL HOUSING TODAY 62%
OF RESIDENTS IN VIENNA AUSTRIA
LIVE IN SOCIAL HOUSING. AND
RIGHT HERE ON THE LEFT THIS IS
ALL TO ALLOW ONE OF THE MORE
ATYPICAL STRUCTURES IN VIENNA
BUT MUCH MORE. ALIGNED WITH
ASIAN SOCIAL THE STRUCTURES. IN
SINGAPORE IN ASIA. I WHICH BEGAN
ITS LEASEHOLD OWNERSHIP SCHEME
IN NINETEEN SIXTY FOUR. 87% OF
ITS RESIDENTS LIVE IN SOCIAL
HOUSING. SO TO GIVE YOU SOME OF
THE PRIVATE OR SOME OF THE
CONTRACTS SAMPLES AS WE HAVE
AMERICAN SOCIAL INVOLVEMENTS
WHICH LOOK VERY TYPICAL TOO MUCH
OF THE VIOLENCE THAT WE SEE
ACROSS. OUR STATE. AND THEN OF
COURSE WE HAVE. A MUCH OLDER
EXAMPLES BUT PERHAPS A LITTLE
DIFFERENT ARCHITECTURAL STYLE
THAT WE SEE ACROSS THE WORLD. AB
THROUGH NINE BUILDS ON THE
SUCCESS OF SOCIAL HOUSING
INTERNATIONALLY AND IT'S RAPIDLY
GROWING SUPPORT IN THE UNITED
STATES. IN CALIFORNIA WE'VE BEEN
SCHOOLS AND ROADS ARE FOR
EVERYONE BUT HOUSING IS NOT BE
THE SAME WAY SOCIAL HOUSING
ALLOW SIX A MAJOR STEP FORWARD
ADDRESSING THE HOUSING CRISIS.
AND WE HAVE SO MANY SUCCESS
MODELS TO DRAW UPON. WITH THAT I
WOULD LIKE TO USE MY LEAD
WITNESS IN SUPPORT DURING CRIMES
FROM. THE GREEN BELTS A LINE
IT'S- THAT WOULD BE STRICTLY S.
RIVAL WHEN THE TIME. THANK YOU
WELCOME MISTER GRAHAM YOU HAVE
TO MINUTES. THING YOU. GET UP
SURE AND MEMBER. MY NAME IS CRY
I'M- ON THE- OF GREEN LINE. WE
ARE A- IN. WE'RE GONNA- WHICH
HAS FOR THE LAST SIXTY FIVE
YEARS WORK TO FOR THE PROTECTION
OF. OPEN SPACE AND PROMOTE
STABLE GROWTH PATTERNS ACROSS
THE NINE COUNTY AREA. FOR
DECADES WE A GREENBELT ALLIANCE
HAVE RECOGNIZED AND CHAMPION THE
UNDERSTANDING. THAT SHIFTING OR
HARMFUL LAND USE PATTERNS FROM
SPRAWL TO URBAN INFILL IS
ESSENTIAL TO PRESERVING OPEN
SPACE PROTECTING HABITAT AND
BIODIVERSITY. AND PROVIDING
IMPORTANTLY ENOUGH HOUSING FOR
ALL OF THOSE WHO WANT TO CALL
CALIFORNIA HOME. UNFORTUNATELY
SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS TO INFILL
HOUSING HAVE PERSISTED. THIS IS
RESULTED IN SKYROCKETING HOUSING
PRICES AND STATEWIDE
DISPLACEMENT. PUSHING PEOPLE TO
THE FRINGES. WHERE THEY MUST
ENTER. SUPER COMMUTES.
CALIFORNIA'S DIVERSE PATTERN ARE
THUS. HAVOC NOT ONLY WITH
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY. IN OUR
ENVIRONMENT BUT ARE FUELING THE
CLIMATE CRISIS AS WELL. 38% OF
CALIFORNIA'S GREENHOUSE GAS
EMISSIONS COME FROM THE
TRANSPORTATION SECTOR A DIRECT
RESULT OF SPRAWL. IF WE ARE
SERIOUS ABOUT MEETING OUR
CLIMATE GOALS IT IS IMPERATIVE
THAT WE SHIFT HOW AND WHERE WE
BUILD. IN ORDER TO ADDRESS OUR
HOUSING AND CLIMATE CRISES WHICH
ARE INEXTRICABLY LINKED WE MUST
BE INNOVATIVE AND WILLING TO
EMBRACE NEW IDEAS THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING AUTHORITY CHIEF AMONG
THEM. AUGMENTING OUR HOUSING
PRODUCTION WITH THE PUBLIC
SECTOR MODEL. IS IN FACT ONE OF
THE MOST POTENT POTENTIAL TOOLS
WE HAVE TO ADVANCE PROGRESS ON
ALL OF OUR GREATEST CHALLENGES
AT OUR FEET AT THE SAME TIME.
OUR DIVERSE AND SIGNIFICANT
NEEDS REQUIRE DIVERSE AND
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS BY GIVING
THE STATE THE ABILITY TO PRODUCE
NEW SUSTAINABLE MIXED INCOME
HOUSING BOTH RENTAL AND
OWNERSHIP WE CAN PROVIDE HOMES
FOR THE MOST VULNERABLE AS WELL
AS THE MIDDLE CLASS. KEEP THE
CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE INTACT
THE NEW UNITS FLOWING DURING
ECONOMIC DOWNTURNS AND
SUPERCHARGE THE INFILL HOUSING
GROWTH OUR STATE SO BADLY NEEDS
IN THE RIGHT PLACES TO ENSURE
THAT CALIFORNIA REMAINS A
PROSPEROUS AND ACCESSIBLE STATE
FOR ALL. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
YOUR TIME. AND THANK YOU AND
YOU'RE RIGHT ON THE TIME. YOU
HAVE A SECOND WITNESS SURGES THE
FIRST WITNESS HEY DO YOU HAVE
ANYBODY ELSE IN THE ROOM AT THIS
TIME WOULD LIKE TO COME UP. AND
JUST STATE YOUR NAME AND WHETHER
YOU SUPPLIER AND YOUR SUPPORT
FOR THE BILL AN. ORGANIZATION
YOU REPRESENT THANK YOU. JOHN
BROWN CAL NURSES. IT'S A POOR.
THANK YOU BERNARD- CAL AND OF
STATES. A COALITION OF OVER A-
ACTIVISTS GRASSROOTS
ORGANIZATIONS ACROSS THE STATE
IN SUPPORT OF. AB THREE HONORING
. GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS UNDERESTIMATE AS ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BERKELEY
IN SUPPORT. SURE MEMBERS RANDY
MARTIN ON BEHALF OF THE AIDS
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION AND
HEALTHY HOUSING FOUNDATION IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU. SECURE
MEMBERS MICHAEL GUNNING HERE
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF OF VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
IN SUPPORT. THE NEW JERSEY
MEMBERS THIRTEEN BIRD ASK ME
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. I AM VERY
GOOD- AT THIS TIME IF THERE'S
ANYBODY THAT CAN OPPOSITION
WITNESS PRIMARY WITNESS THAT
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK. IF TWO
MINUTES. YES SIR. MISTER VICE
CHAIR MEMBERS BOB NAIL
REPRESENTING FEELS DEAD AND
COMPANY- THAT'S HOWARD AHMANSON
JUNIOR A AN ORANGE COUNTY
PHILANTHROPISTS WHO OPPOSES
EMINENT DOMAIN. ON SOCIAL EQUITY
GROUNDS AND I AM HERE TO OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED TO EXCLUDE
EMINENT DOMAIN- HI A SITE IS
DOES. THIS IS A THORN FOR THE-
TRUCK THAT EMINENT DOMAIN HAS A
REAL ON. MY NEW CAN OVER THE
YEARS THE. REPARATIONS WHICH HAS
A CHAPTER ON EMMA DOMAIN. AND
AMONG THE WORST. ATROCITIES WAS
SAN FRANCISCO. WHICH IN THE
NINETEEN FIFTIES THANKFULLY
BULLDOZED THAT LARGER IS OF THE
FILLMORE DISTRICT WHICH THERE
ARE TWO FOUR WAS KNOWN AS HARLEM
OF THE WEST. DESTROYING FORTY
FIVE HUNDRED VICTORIANS HOMES.
FOUR THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED
EIGHTY THREE BUSINESSES AND
DISPLACING. FORTY FIVE HUNDRED
FAMILIES- WE INVEST THE AUTHOR
TO ACCEPT AN AMENDMENT. AS HAS
BEEN ACCEPTED BY OTHER AUTHORS
PROMINENT IN THIS LEGISLATURE.
CENTER COM LOGGER AND ESPYS SIX
SEVENTY NINE FOR LOS ANGELES.
COUNTY REGIONAL HOUSING
AUTHORITY- ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHIU
AND AB 1-487-200-0194 THE SAN
FRANCISCO BAY AREA REGIONAL
HOUSING AUTHORITY. AND MOST
RECENTLY SENATOR SKINNER AND S.
B. FOR FORTY HAS ACCEPTED THE
AMENDMENT YES THE AUTHOR TO
ACCEPT SUCH AN AMENDMENT
OTHERWISE WE URGE YOU TO OPPOSE
THE BILL THANK YOU. THANK YOU
MISTER NAYLOR. ANYBODY ELSE'S
LIKE TO SPEAK IS A PRIME WITNESS
IN OPPOSITION. IF NOT IS THERE
ANYBODY IN THE ROOM WOULD LIKE
TO JUST ADD THE ERROR- AFTER
OPPOSITION THEIR VOICE TO THE
OPPOSITION. IN THE ROOM NONE
OKAY SO WE'RE GONNA TAKE IT TO
THE PHONE LINES A. T. T.
OPERATOR ANYBODY ON THE PHONE
LINE JUST LIKE TO CALL IN AND
EXPRESS YOUR OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT ONLY. HAVE PLEASE STATE
YOUR NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION AND
YOUR WHETHER YOU OPPOSE OR
SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR FOR THOSE
WHO WISH TO SUPPORT TO TURKS
PRESS A SUPPORTER OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO. GOING TO GO TO LINE FIFTY
TWO YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN. ONE
FIFTY TO YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
WHERE TO MOVE ON THE LINE FORTY
SEVEN. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
TEMPERATURE MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE JENNIFER STACK ABOUT
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS HERE IN RESPECTFULLY-
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED TO
SPECIFICALLY FOCUS THE MEASURE
ON- CREATING NEW SUPPLY. AND NOT
ON THE ACQUISITION OF EXISTING
UNITS THAT WILL ONLY SERVE TO
DRIVE UP HOME PRICES THANK YOU.
FOR AND A FINAL CALL FOR WHO TO
SPEAK CONSERVE OP TO THIS BILL
PRESS. THEN ZERO. SURE THERE IS
NO ONE TO SAY THEIR WAY TO SPEAK
. GREAT YOU VERY MUCH BACK TO
THE DICE ANY QUESTIONS FROM CALL
. READ. THANK YOU- I WANTED TO
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD IT'S- A REALLY BOLD AND
IDEA AND I AM. TO YOU BIRD DOG
IT OVER A DIFFERENT YEARS AND
I'M EXCITED THAT YOU'RE PUTTING
IT OUT THERE AND GENERATING THE
SUPPORT AND SOCIALIZING THE IDEA
I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT BUT I
WAS ALSO VERY. EXCITED TO SEE
JORDAN CRIMES DOING YOUR
TESTIMONY HE IS ONE OF THE MOST
ENTERTAINING CHRONICLERS OF
LOCAL CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS. I
LOVE TO WATCH HIM ON TWITTER-
TALKING ABOUT WHAT'S HAPPENING
RELATED TO HOUSING AND SO I'VE
I'VE SORT OF A FAN GIRLING HIM
SO THE FACT THAT HE WAS HERE
TALKING. WAS REALLY FUN SO THANK
YOU VERY MUCH AND I WILL BE
SUPPORTING IT ALL BIG SLABS FOR
YOU. THANK YOU. CENTER CARRIER.
THANK YOU MISTER VICE CHAIR- IS
MEMBER NINE HAD TO DO. ABOUT
THIS BILL ACTUALLY IT- IF IT IF
IT FITS FOR THE DAY BILL IN THE
NEXT BILL- WILL COME THROUGH
KEVIN FINANCE AND I KNOW MY
PREDECESSOR USED TO NOT VOTE ON
BILLS IN COMMITTEES THAT- WHERE
THAT SUB TO COOK COMMITTEE WOULD
BE- HE'D BE CARRYING BUT I DO
THINGS A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY
I MEAN TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL
TODAY BUT WE HAD SOME.
DISCUSSION ABOUT SOME OF THAT-
AMENDMENTS AND CHANGES THAT WE
MAY NEED TO MAKE- IT GOVERNMENT
FINANCE AND OUR ROLE IS TO
PROTECT LOCAL GOVERNMENT MAKE
SURE THAT THE INTERFACE BETWEEN
THE STATE. AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT
WORKS- AS AT AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE
WITHOUT RESENTMENT- AND ALSO TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE BUILDING-
SUFFICIENT NUMBER OF AFFORDABLE
UNITS AND- AND WORKING AT- MAY
BE STARTING UP FOR SOME PROJECTS
THAT ARE. ARE A SURPLUS PROJECTS
SO I REALLY APPRECIATE- WHAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO AND DON'T
WANT TO MAKE SURE IT WORKS
WITHIN OUR EXISTING SYSTEM- WHAT
OTHER COUNTRIES MAY DO. MAY NOT
WORK GIVEN THAT WE HAVE A
DIFFERENT HISTORY BUT IF I CAN I
WANT TO I WANT TO WORK WITH YOU
ON IT SO. SHE YOU- AT THE
DISCUSSIONS THAT WE'VE HAD UP TO
THIS POINT I WAS PRETTY BAD
TODAY THANK YOU. MR PADILLA
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR JUST. ONE
TO THANK THE IT IS BOLD
COMPREHENSIVE IT'S THOUGHTFUL. I
WOULD ECHO THE SENTIMENTS CALL
AND INTERESTED IN TRACK SOME OF
THE CLUB. THAT OCCUR. IN
THROUGH. THE OTHER POLICY
COMMITTEE AND PARTICULARLY HOW
WHEN WE GET TO GET TO FLOOR
SITUATION HOW WE LOOK AT DEALING
WITH THE ACQUISITION SIDE.
COUPLE OF FINE TUNING THAT MAY
NEED TO HAPPEN THERE AND ONE
PERSON'S OPINION- AND
HARMONIZING WITH THE LOCAL
GOVERNMENT PROCESS BUT- YOU KNOW
ON A VERY BROAD LEVEL WE NEED
EVERY TOOL- IN THIS CRISIS AND
APPRECIATE YOUR LEADERSHIP ON
IT. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN. THIS
BLAKE'S BEER THANK YOU SORRY IS
YOUR TO GO SHORT RETURN IT IT'S
A VERY SHORT QUESTION BUT I JUST
WANTED TO ASK ABOUT THE EMINENT
DOMAIN. CAN YOU JUST ADDRESS
THAT CONCERN THAT WE HEARD. YEAH
AS AN ASPECT OF THIS ASPECT OF
STATE AGENCIES SPECIALLY WHEN IT
COMES TO LAND USE THE TYPICALLY
HAVE THE ABILITY TO ACQUIRE
PROPERTY RIGHT. I WOULD SAY. IN
THE AND IN THE BILL IS EXPECTED
TODAY IN A NECESSARY ASPECT IS
ACQUIRED LAND TO TEN DEVELOP
PROPERTIES RIGHT BUT ALSO PART
OF THE BILL IS STUDENT ALSO SAVE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT MIGHT BE
AT THE END OF ITS DEED
RESTRICTION AND THAT'S SOMETHING
WE WORK WITH A LOT OF- ACTIVE
THE FOLKS. THAT THIS COULD BE A
COMPONENT PRESERVING OF
AFFORDABLE EXISTING FOR THE
HOUSING THAT COULD THEIR
COVENANTS COULD EXPIRE YOU CAN
IMAGINE SEEING THE TWENTY
THIRTIES. YEAH BUDGET FOR THE
HOUSING ENTERED COMPANIES
EXPIRED TO COULD BE ALL
PRIVATIZING THESE BECOME FOR
SALE. SO AND PRESERVE THAT
OPTION WHICH YOU COULD SAVE. A
DEED RESTRICTED HOUSING AND KEEP
THEM IN AFFORDABILITY AFFORDABLE
IN PERPETUITY. BUT ALSO HAVE
THAT SAME POWER TO ALSO AND WE
HAVE SOME CARTOON THE BILL
ABOUT. PURCHASING PROPERTY LAND
THAT'S UNDERUTILIZED NOT EXACTLY
WITH THIS PEOPLE ON IT. BUT SO
THAT WE CAN EXPAND THE MISSION
OF BUILDING MORE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING UNITS BECAUSE- THERE
WILL COME A DAY WHEN WE RUN OUT
OF ACCESS SITES HOPEFULLY. AND
THEN WILL HAVE TO START THINKING
ABOUT WELL HOW DO WE- PROPERTY
FOR A SCHOOL DISTRICT HOW DO BY
SOME PRIVATE LAND THAT'S
SUITABLE THAT SOMEONE WANTS TO
SELL. RIGHT WELL I THINK I HOW
DO YOU ACQUIRE LAND TO IN
FUTURE. SERVICE YOU'RE SAYING IS
YOU BUYING LANNISTER FROM M. AND
A DOMAIN BUT WHAT YOU'RE SAYING
IS YOU DON'T WANT TO. IT OFF
TABLE IS THAT WHAT YOU'RE SAYING
YEAH BECAUSE THINK- AND THERE'S
THIS. THEM I DID THAT SOME. IT'S
A- TOOL TO SAVE RESIDENTS-
THERE'S EXAMPLES OF MY DISTRICT
WHERE YOU KNOW THERE WAS A FOR A
HOUSING COMPLEX THAT WAS ABOUT
TO HAVE ALL THE DETECTION- GO
AWAY AND THE COUNTY SAID HEY IF
YOU DON'T. WORK AND AGREE WITH
US WE'RE GONNA DO THIS RIGHT I
THINK COMMITTEES FOR POSSIBLE IF
AND I DO WANT TO KNOWLEDGE
OBVIOUSLY IN THIS COUNTRY. THERE
BEEN SOME UGLINESS. IN THIS
COUNTRY THAT HAPPENED IN SEPSIS.
CASE FOR I THINK THERE'S A-
REPLY OVER TWENTY. FREEWAYS IT'S
A- THE- WHEN YOU CENTER. ONE
PLACE INTO ANOTHER. OR KEEPING
THEM. HOW YOU KNOW IT'S JUST A
TOOL. THAT HAS BEEN USED MISUSED
THE PAST BUT IT TOOK ME. FOR
GOODNESS. SO THAT'S WHY RIGHT.
NOW NOW I. TO THINK THAT. IN THE
CONSTRUCTION THE BILL. THAT
IT'S- PART ITSELF. OKAY THANK
YOU. YEAH ALL RIGHT- GOSH I
KEEP. PUSHING BY AGAIN- SO WE'VE
- COME. FOR THE BILL HAS. YEAR
HAVING CHANGE A WHOLE LOT OF MY-
ON THIS APPROACH. TO AT.
INCREASING AFFORDABLE. FOR
HOUSING TO ME IS. LEVEL HOUSING
. THAT WHERE ISSUE. IS ENTRY
LEVEL HOUSE- SO THAT- IN. PEOPLE
ARE READY ENTER THE- MY- CAN DO
SO AND- THAT HOUSE THAT ENTRY
LEVEL POINTED AT A POINT WHERE
THEY CAN- THE FOURTEENTH IN
THERE SOME- IF YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
. OKAY THANK YOU OF COURSE ARE.
ON AYE BUT WHEN THE TIME WHEN
THERE IS A- BY- ALLUDING SOME
CONVERSATION I WAS SENT A COPY.
AND COMMITTEE I RE HOPE TO SPUR
IS THIS A PROPOSAL I REALLY SURE
THAT WE'RE- SUCCESS PEOPLE OF. I
THERE'S A- OF POTENTIAL EXIST-
PROGRAMS POTENTIAL ESPECIALLY
ACCESSOR SITES THAT WE CAN START
WITH AND I THINK THERE'S A LOT
OF POTENTIAL TO DEMONSTRATE A
RIGHT. BUT OF COURSE BEING
COGNIZANT THAT WE ARE IN A RACE
TO DEMONSTRATE WHICH STATE WILL
BE MOST SUCCESSFUL SOCIAL IN
FIRST MARILYN IS. UP IN AHEAD OF
US WITH A LOT OF CONSTRUCTION
HAPPENING RIGHT NOW- AND HAWAII
GEN HELLO A LOT OF OTHER STATES
THEY JUST PASSED THE PROPOSALS
TO DO SO. AND SEATTLE'S OF. SO
NOT INITIATE BY LEGISLATORS BUT
BY ACTRESS EMMA PEOPLE THE
COMMUNITY. AND AS SOME HAVE
STATED YOU KNOW THERE'S PLENTY
WORK TO GO AROUND WE NEED A
PRIVATE SECTOR STEP UP IN A
NONPROFIT SECTOR STEP UP BUT
JUST LIKE IN EUROPEAN ASIAN
COUNTRIES WE NEED A STRONG-
PUBLIC SECTOR IS ALSO BEING. IN
THE LOOP- AND I REALLY HOPE THAT
WE GET ALL THESE TOOLS IN THE
TOOL BELT. CAN SOLVE OUR HOUSING
CRISIS SO RESPECT THAT'S RIGHT
BUT WHEN THE TIME COMES THANK
YOU. GREAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
WE GET A QUORUM WILL. WILL PUT
THAT OUT THERE FOR EVERYBODY
AND- IN THE MEANWHILE. WE'RE
GOING TO GO ON TO AB FOURTEEN
NINETY MISTER LEE WOULD YOU LIKE
TO GO AHEAD WITH THAT ONE. YES
THANK YOU SO MUCH INSPIRATION
MEMBERS. AB FOURTEEN NINETY ONE
COURAGE ADAPTIVE RE USE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECTS
PROVIDING INCENTIVES. SUCH AS
PROVIDING EXPEDITED REVIEW
PROCESS WHILE RESPECTING THE
CONTROL. ADAPTIVE RE USE IS WHEN
WE REPURPOSE AN EXISTING
BUILDING TO CREATE A FORM
HOUSING HAS THE GOVERNOR DID
WITH PROJECT ROOM KEY. AB FORTY
NINE YOU REMOVE BARRIERS TO
THESE PROJECTS BY ENSURING THEY
ARE ELIGIBLE FOR FORT HOUSING
FUNDING AND DON'T GET STUCK IN
ENTITLEMENT PROCESS FOR YEARS.
ADAPTER USES MUCH FASTER AND
LESS EXPENSIVE THAN BUILDING NEW
HOUSING FROM SCRATCH WILL HELP
ADDRESS THE HOUSING CRISIS. WITH
THAT I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE MY
WITNESS IN SUPPORT RAND MARTIN
FROM THE AIDS HEALTHCARE
FOUNDATION AND RESPECTFUL YES
RIGHT BUT WHEN THE TIME COMES.
MISTER MARTIN WELCOME YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES THANK YOU THANK YOU
MISTER MEMBERS RANDY MARTIN HERE
ON BEHALF OF THE- AIDS
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION. SCARES ME
AND IT'S HEALTHY HOUSING
FOUNDATION. WHICH WAS CREATED
ABOUT FIVE YEARS AGO IN ORDER TO
DEVELOP. AFFORDABLE HOUSING
OPPORTUNITIES FOR VERY LOW AND
EXTREMELY LOW INCOME PEOPLE-
PRIMARILY ACROSS THE CITY OF LOS
ANGELES SO FAR HOPEFULLY IN
OTHER PARTS OF THE STATE AS A-
AS AS THE FEET. FUTURE PRESENTS
ITSELF. WHAT WE HAVE FOUND FROM
ADAPTER FOR USES MISTER LEE AS
INDICATORS THERE IS A- SENSE-
SPEEDIEST. IT AS WELL AS A
REDUCE COSTS. IN TERMS OF
ACHIEVING THE SAME KIND OF
AFFORDABLE HOUSING OPPORTUNITIES
HAS GROUND UP CONSTRUCTION. ONE
OF THE CHALLENGES THAT WE FOUND
IS THAT CITIES ARE NOT ALWAYS
AS- ACCOMMODATING OF THAT
SPEEDIER PROCESS- AND SO. WE
HAVE RUN INTO CHALLENGES WITH
ENTITLED. TAKING LONGER THE THEY
SHOULD- WE RUN ITS SYSTEMS.
REQUIRE THAT ALSO. AT TIME. WITH
RUNNING PROBLEMS WITH SIR- LOCAL
. PROGRAMS WITH. FUNDING
AVAILABLE THAT DOES A CALM AND
FOR YOU- AND THIS THIS IS INTO
TO DEAL WITH EACH OF THOSE VERY
MODEST IN TERMS OF HIS OFFICE
PRESS. BUT WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL
TO AN ORGANIZATION LIKE HF IN
TERMS OF EXPANDING ON THE
FOURTEEN HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE
UNITS OF LOW INCOME HOUSING THAT
WE'VE ALREADY BEEN ABLE. TO
DEVELOP- SO WITHOUT I'LL LEAVE
IT AND- AFTER I WHEN THE TIME IS
RIGHT YOU. GREAT THANK YOU DID
YOU ANOTHER. PROMISE OKAY JIM
ELSE THE ROOM WOULD LIKE TO COME
UP AND ASK THEIR- SUPPORT FOR
BILL. IF NOT WE'LL GO OVER TO UP
. YOUR ANYBODY WHO'D LIKE TO
SPEAK IS A PRIME WITNESS. IN UP
TO THE- IF NOT. IN I WOULD ASK
OF ANY WANTS TO JUST COME AND
SAY THE OPPOSED. CALIFORNIA
GOING TO DO THAT SINCE DON'T
SEEM SCREW TO MIKE WE'RE TO GO
AHEAD AND GO TO THE PHONE LINES
AGAIN EIGHT TI. PICKING TO
PEOPLE THE PHONE EXPRESS OUR- OR
SUPPORT THE BILL. MEMBER NAME.
ORGANISER AND WHETHER YOU OPPOSE
YOUR SUPPORT AND THAT'S ALL. IT
YOU MISTER CHAIR THOSE WISH TO
IN SOME OR UP. TO THIS BILL
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN. ZERO HE
WAS CHAIR NO ONE IS SIGNALED
THAT THEY WISH TO SPEAK. WELL
THEN IT'LL COME BACK TO THE DÍAS
TO EVERYBODY ON THE SAME IN MY
COLLEAGUES WOULD LIKE TO ASK
QUESTIONS HAVE EXPRESSED
CONCERNS. I HAVE TO COMMENT ON
EVERY BILL PLEASE. DISCOVER YOUR
OWN WOULD YOU LIKE. THERE'S NO
ONE ELSE LATER YOU'RE GOING.
WANT TO SPEAK FOR. I REALLY LIKE
THIS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MR
LEE WOULD YOU LIKE CLOSE. I'M
SORRY I CAN'T HEAR YOU KNOW I.
THIS IS ANOTHER BILL WILL COME
TO HEAVEN IT'S IN FINANCE AND
PAN AM REALLY PER WHAT YOU'RE
TRYING TO DO HERE WHICH IS PRINT
PROVIDE AN OFFER. TO TO CREATE
THE HOUSING. THE PEOPLE OFF THE
STREET NINE IF THERE'S THING
THAT WE- THE IN IN EVERY SINGLE
THAT I BEEN. IN IN IN THE
ASSEMBLY WE'VE BEEN WE'VE HAD
THIS JUST OVER AND OVER AGAIN
WHICH PROGRAM WORKS THE BEST AND
HOW CAN WE GET- HOW CAN WE DO
HOW CAN WE HOUSE PEOPLE IN A
RESPECTFUL. AND IN A QUICK
MANNER IN USING EXISTING
RESOURCES IS REALLY IMPORTANT-
WHAT WHAT I WAS WORRIED ABOUT IN
THIS AND- IN OUT I'LL TAKE A
LOOK AT IT A LITTLE BIT MORE
CAREFULLY OVER A GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCES IS THE WHOLE ISSUE OF
INDUSTRIAL. MOVING INTO AN
INDUSTRIAL AREA AND- AND I DID
WHAT I DO APPRECIATE IS IF
THERE'S INDUSTRIAL RIGHT NEXT
DOOR THEN IT YOU CAN'T DO THE
HOUSING- AND I THINK WE'VE BEEN
WORKING WITH ADAPTIVE RE USE. IN
REYES. IN KNOWN. COMMERCIAL AND
RETAIL AND NOT ALLOW IT NEXT TO
INDUSTRIAL AND THE REASON THIS
BECOMES IMPORTANT ISN'T IN RURAL
COMMUNITIES TO HAVE A MISHMASH
MIX. OF INDUSTRIAL AND HOUSING
AND COMMERCIAL- BECAUSE THAT
COMMUNITIES ARE A LOT SMALLER I
AM I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE IT
WORKS WELL- THE END COMMUNITIES
THAT I REPRESENT THAT- THEY
DON'T HAVE SUCH A DEFINITIVE.
LINE ON HERE'S OUR INDUSTRIAL
AREA- WHICH IS ENTIRELY SEPARATE
FROM OUR OUR RESIDENTIAL AREA SO
I WILL SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY
AND THANK YOU FOR THINKING
OUTSIDE THE BOX ON THIS. IT IS
WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE. YEAH JUST
TO SAY THAT YOU KNOW YOU THIS IS
ANOTHER BILL WHERE WE HOPE TO
GIVE MORE TOOLS LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
THE QUEEN RIGHT AWAY ESPECIALLY
NEED TO HOUSE A LOT ON HOUSE
PEOPLE AND- THROUGH THE SUCCESS
BEDROOM KEY AND NOW A LOT OF
PRIVATE ACTORS WHO ARE TRYING TO
ADAPT TO SPECIAL INCOMES HOTELS
AND MOTELS. THOSE ARE READILY
EASILY CONVERTED PLACES TO
BECOME NEW APARTMENTS ACTUALLY
AND WE SHOULD REALLY DOING DOING
OUR BEST TO BE ABLE TO ENCOURAGE
FOLKS TO THINK CREATIVELY. USING
HOTELS MOTELS THAT PERHAPS
AREN'T NECESSARY NOR THE SELLERS
WANT TO SELL THEM AND TURN THEM
INTO. HOUSING FOR FOLKS- SO WE
WISHED WANNA LOWER THE BARRIERS
IN ORDER FOR LAKSHMI'S BE ABLE
TO HOUSE OF FOLKS HOUSE IN A
RESERVE HAVE HOMES OVER
SUCCESSOR AYE BUT WHEN THE TIME
COMES. ALL RIGHT WHEN TIME
COMES- WILL- WILL. NEVER FOR
THAT- IF YOU WANT TO OPEN GATE
FROM ADDRESS B. R. IN SHE CAN
COME UP AND PRESENT HER BILL.
FENECH BILL UP ON THE DOCK IS AB
THREE. MY ASSEMBLY MEMBER AT.
WELL THANK YOU THINK YOU WILL
THINK YOU ARE. MAY CHERRY
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. I'M
HERE WITH YOU TO US YEARS- I'VE
ON. THREE EIGHT. POINT SIX THE
DEBT. FOR THEM. HOME RESIDENCY
LAW PROTECTION PROGRAM OR THE M.
R. L. P. P. BY THREE YEARS.
DOING SO EXTENDS PROTECTIONS FOR
MOBILE HOME RESIDENTS ACROSS THE
STATE WHO HAVE ENCOUNTERED
VIOLATIONS IN THEIR PARKS. IT
WOULD ALSO ENABLE A SELF FUNDED
PROGRAM TO CONTINUE TO OPERATE
WITHOUT INCURRING ADDITIONAL
COST PRESSURES FOR THE STATE.
AND IT WOULD ALLOW VULNERABLE
AND OFTEN IGNORED POPULATION OF
CALIFORNIANS THE RIGHT TO SEEK.
THE RIGHT TO SEEK JUSTICE WHEN
IT COMES TO THEIR HOUSING. AND I
DO WANT TO EMPHASIZE THREE
POINTS ON THIS BILL. THE BILL
MERELY EXTENDS THE DEADLINE FOR
THE PROGRAM A PROGRAM WHICH THIS
COMMITTEE PREVIOUSLY VOTED ON
AND PASSED TWICE. BY EXTENDING
THE SUNSET WE ARE FOLLOWING THE
ORIGINAL INTENT OF THE LAW TO
FULLY EVALUATE THE SUCCESS OF
THIS PROGRAM. AND BY SUPPORTING
THIS BILL TODAY WE WOULD ALLOW A
MUCH NEEDED PROGRAM TO CONTINUE.
SO THE INCEPTION OF THREE
EIGHTEEN AND TWENTY EIGHTEEN THE
STATE ESTABLISHED THE MOBILE
HOME RESIDENCY LAW PROTECTION
PROGRAM. OF FIVE YEAR PILOT
PROGRAM TO COORDINATE THE
RESOLUTION OF COMPLAINTS FROM
HOMEOWNERS. AND THIS PROGRAM IS
FUNDED BY RESIDENTS ACROSS THE
STATE- PAY JUST TEN DOLLARS FOR
THIS ADDITIONAL PROTECTION
ANNUALLY. HOWEVER THE PROGRAM IS
SET. TO EXPIRE IN TWENTY TWENTY
FOUR. THIS WOULD LIKE FIVE YEARS
HAS PASSED BUT A REAL IT HAS.
AND THIS IS BECAUSE THE PROGRAM
NOT REALLY STATUTORILY PERMITTED
TO ACCEPT COMPLAINTS UNTIL JULY
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY AND EACH CD
DID NOT START REFERRING
COMPLAINTS TO THE LEGAL SERVICE
PROVIDERS UNTIL JUNE TWENTY
TWENTY ONE AND MUCH OF THAT
DELAY. HAD TO DO WITH THE ISSUES
RELATED TO CODE RED SO REALLY
THE PROGRAM IS ONLY BEEN ACTED
FOR TWO YEARS. ADDITIONALLY
THERE ARE REMAINING FUNDS FROM
THE EXISTING TEN DOLLAR FEE THAT
MOBILE HOME RESIDENTS HAVE
ALREADY PAID INTO THE PROGRAM-
SO MOST RECENT REPORTS SHOW THAT
THE REVENUE COLLECTED IS ABOUT
NINE MILLION EIGHT HUNDRED
NINETY FOUR. THOUSAND SIX
HUNDRED AND SIXTY FIVE SIX
HUNDRED AND FIFTY SIX DOLLARS TO
TOTAL EXPENDITURES AT ABOUT
THREE POINT FIVE MILLION- THIS
IS DUE TO THE SHORT TIME FRAME
THAT THE- PROGRAM HAS BEEN
ACTIVE. WITH PROGRAM SOLVENT WE
REALLY WANT TO DO EVERYTHING WE
CAN TO PROTECT AND PRESERVE THIS
TYPE OF HOUSING FOR SENIORS FOR
WORKING FAMILIES FOR VETERANS.
AND FOR OTHER COMMUNITY MEMBERS
ON FIXED INCOMES SO WITH THAT
I'D REALLY LIKE TO TURN IT OVER
TO OUR WITNESSES TO SURE WHY
THIS BILL IS NEEDED WE'VE GOT
TWO WITNESSES TODAY. ROGER
JOHNSON THE MOBILE HOME RESIDENT
AND BRUCE STANTON COUNCIL. FOR
GSM- WELL. ED THANK YOU VERY
MUCH HER ATTENDING TODAY IN BOTH
WERE. OF A REMOTE. PRIMARILY
THIS IS A MINUTES EACH. TO
PRESENT THEIR THEIR INFORMATION
THANK YOU. GREAT THANK YOU AND
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME ROGER
JOHN. WHICH YES ALL IT'S OF THE
BILL. THE MORE HOME RESIDENCY
LAW PROTECTION PRO. HELPS
SENIORS VETERANS AND IMMIGRANT
FAMILIES WITH MODEST INCOMES TO
RESOLVE VIOLATIONS OF STATE LAW
. THESE VIOLATIONS INCLUDE
FICTIONS FORMER HOMES. PARK
OWNERS TAKING RESIDENTS
ELECTRICITY TO POWER THE
RECRUITMENT. HELLO AUTHORIZED
FEES FOR WATER AND UTILITIES.
ELDER ABUSE HOUSING
DISCRIMINATION IN MORE. THE
PROGRAM WAS SIGNED INTO LAW IN
TWENTY NINETEEN HOWEVER THE
FIRST COMPLAINT COULD NOT BE
FILED. UNTIL JULY THE FIRST OF
TWENTY TWENTY. IN ORDER TO GIVE
H. C. D. TIME TO SET UP THE
PROGRAM. IT WAS ONLY UNTIL JUNE
OF TWENTY TWENTY ONE. H. C. D.
STARTED REFERRING COMPLAINTS TO
NONPROFIT LEGAL LEGAL SERVICE
PROVIDERS. A. B. THREE EIGHTEEN
EXTENDS THE EMERALD PP BY THE
DIVISIONAL THREE YEARS. GIVING
MOBILE HOME RESIDENTS. THE
BENEFIT OF THE FULL FIVE YEARS
ORIGINALLY INTENDED BY THE FIVE
YEAR PILOT PROGRAM. TO FUND THE
PROGRAM WE SELF IMPOSED AN
ANNUAL TEN DOLLARS SPACE FEE
THAT WE PAY. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION. THANK YOU SIR MY
NEXT SPEAKER PLEASE. THANK YOU
SO MUCH FOR STAYING ON THE TWO
MINUTE LIMIT YES GOOD AFTERNOON
I'LL DO EVEN BETTER THAN THAT
BRUCE STANTON CORPORATE COUNSEL
FOR GSM WELL HERE IN SUPPORT
ASKING FOR YOUR AYE VOTE AS WELL
AND HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
THANK YOU. GREAT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OKAY SO AT THIS POINT WILL
WILL PASS FOR ANYBODY ELSE IN
THE ROOM WOULD LIKE TO COME UP
TO THE MIKE AND- JUST EXPRESS
THEIR ADDITIONAL SUPPORT. NAME
MANDATE YOU ANY ORGANIZATION YOU
MAY REPRESENT. TODAY I LIVE
THAT- MY JOURNAL PARK SUCH
HEIGHTS GROUP VILLAGE I'M IN
FAVOR BILL THANK YOU SIR. THANK
STEP. MY NAME IS JOANNE. I LIVE
IN CITRUS HEIGHTS LIKE BE. N.
I'M IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON WELL IN MY KIM LAKE
FEW VILLAGE SUCH AS I SUPPORT
BILL. THANK YOU. CAN BE ELSE. IS
NOT WE'LL GET UP WITH IF THERE
IS A OP OP WILL. THAT WOULD LIE
TO TALK AS A PRIME WHEN YET TO.
SIR WELCOME. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS- J. TONIGHT ON
BEHALF OF THE CAL MOBILE PARK ON
ALLIANCE. STILL AN OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED POSITION. AND I SAY
REGRETTABLY BECAUSE I THINK
WE'RE ACTUALLY QUITE CLOSE ON
THIS BILL IT WOULD BE VERY EASY
FOR US TO BE NEUTRAL ON IT WE DO
NOT DISAGREE THAT THE PROGRAM
SHOULD BE EXTENDED AT LEAST FOR
ANOTHER YEAR. BUT THAT IS WHERE
WE DIFFER IS THAT WE BELIEVE
THAT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT IT ONLY
BE EXTENDED FOR ONE OF THE YEAR
BECAUSE YOU KNOW WHERE WHILE
SENATOR- THE JOINT LEGISLATIVE
AUDIT COMMITTEE APPROVED AN
AUDIT. OF THIS PROGRAM IT IS NOT
PERFORMED AS IT WAS EXPECTED TO
PERFORM TO DATE. PERHAPS SOME OF
THAT'S DUE TO THE PANDEMIC
PERHAPS SOME OF ITS DUE TO THE
PROGRAM STRUCTURE. BUT THE
RESULTS OF THAT AUDIT WILL BE
AVAILABLE AT THE END OF THE
YEAR. AND WE BELIEVE THAT IT
WOULD BE FAR MORE APPROPRIATE TO
HAVE THAT IN HAND TO WEIGH THE
RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE STATE
AUDITOR. AND NEGOTIATING DEBATE
TOGETHER ON HOW THE PROGRAM
SHOULD PROCEED IF IT SHOULD
PROCEED WHAT FORM IT SHOULD TAKE
THE FEE STRUCTURE AND IT. TO
DATE THE PROGRAM'S COLLECTED
MORE REVENUE THAN IS NEEDED IT
SEEMS PREMATURE TO DO A THREE
YEAR EXTENSION WHEN AN AUDIT IS
STILL PENDING. AND SO FOR THAT
REASON WE REGRETTABLY REMAIN
OPPOSED AND- UNLESS THE BILL
COULD BE AMENDED TO JUST BE A
ONE YEAR EXTENSION WE AFTER A
QUESTION NO VOTE TODAY. THANK
YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS NEXT
SPEAKER YET TWO MINUTES THANK
YOU. UNDER GOVERNOR MAPP OF W.
M. ECHO THE SAME CALM AS MISTER
I GUARD. WE'RE SIMPLY ASKING FOR
WHEN YOUR EX. THERE'S A SEVEN
POINT THREE MILLION SIR. OF NINE
CHEN FUND. IF THIS PROGRAM GOES
ON ANOTHER YEARS YOU'LL BE
LOOKING AT UPWARDS OF TEN
MILLION DOLLARS NOW IN SURPLUS
WITH RESIDENTS AND AN OWNER'S
PAYING TEN DOLLARS A SPACE.
JOINT LEGISLATIVE THE AUDIT
COMMITTEE IN THE STATE AUDITOR
OF. HAS ASSIGNED CERTAIN HOURS
AND CERTAIN AMOUNT OF MONEY TO
GET THE AUDIT DONE THAT WILL BE
DONE BY DECEMBER OF THIS YEAR.
SO WHY WOULD WE SIMPLY INTRODUCE
A BILL NEXT YEAR. FINE TUNE
WHATEVER IT IS WITH THE PROGRAM
MAYBE A TEN DOLLAR FEE IS TOO
MUCH BASED ON THE SURPLUS. MAYBE
IT SHOULD BE A DOLLAR. MAYBE THE
PROGRAM SHOULDN'T EXIST BUT WHY
DON'T WE LOOK AT WHAT THE
AUDITOR COMES BACK AT THE END OF
THE YEAR. AND NOT SIMPLY GO FOR
ANOTHER THREE YEARS. OF HAVING
THE MONEY ADD UP AND THE
COMPLAINTS NOT REALLY BEING-
DEALT WITH. BECAUSE WHAT WE'VE
SEEN AS A MATTER HOW MANY
COMPLAINTS THE PROGRAM GETS.
OVER THREE YEARS ONLY SEVENTY
SEVEN COMPLAINTS REFERRED ON TO
A LEGAL SERVICE PROVIDER. THAT
IS 95% BELOW EIGHT CITIES OWN
EXPECTATIONS. ATD EXPECTED
ALMOST FOUR THOUSAND COMPLAINTS
BE REFERRED ON. WE BELIEVE THE
PROGRAM IS BROKEN WE'RE NOT SURE
THAT IT SHOULD BE RENEWED. BUT
HAVING SAID THAT THE STATE
AUDITORS LOOKING AT IT AND WHY
WOULD WE JUST COME BACK NEXT
YEAR AND FINE TUNE TO RE
EVALUATE THE PROGRAM. AND NOT TO
SIMPLY BUILD UP A SURPLUS FOR
ANOTHER EXTRA TWO YEARS UPON
THAT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR
YOUR COMMENTS SIR. IS THERE
ANYBODY ELSE IN THE ROOM THAT
WOULD LIKE TO COME UP AN AD ON
OPPOSITION. TO THIS BILL. HE NOT
WE'RE GONNA GO TO THE FOR. LINE
MYSTERY. TI IF YOU CAN GO AND
OPEN PHONE LINE FOR ANY. WANTS
TO EXPRESS OUR OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL REMEMBER
NAME ORGANIZATION AND WHETHER
YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE THE BILL.
THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN. FOR THOSE
WHO WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME
. THE SECURE KNOWN AS SIGNALED
THAT THEY WISH TO SPEAK WELL
THEN WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
DIETS AND- HAVE ANY MY
COLLEAGUES HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
THIS CAN EURO WILL GO BACK AND
FORTH. ON THIS ONE. SO AT. B.
THE- OPPOSITE MAKES. COGENT ARE
. ABOUT YEAR DOING A ONE YEAR-
EXTENSION OF THE CENSUS AND I
READ THE COULD YOU SEE THERE
WERE THREE THINGS DOES IT IT
REALLY ALL IT DOES IS IT IT IS.
X. NOW THERE'S A LOT MORE GOING
ON IN THE REGION BILL- AND- AND
I DIDN'T HAVE A LOT OF
INFORMATION BECAUSE I WASN'T
PART OF THAT J. LACK HEARING
THAT. TALKED ABOUT- WHETHER THE
PROGRAM IS BEEN SUCCESSFUL OR
NOT SO I'M REALLY INTERESTED IN
SEEING THE REPORT IN DECEMBER SO
COULD YOU COULD YOU ANSWER WHY
WHY A THREE YEAR SUNSET AT THIS
POINT RATHER THAN WHEN YOUR
SENSES SO WE CAN TAKE A LOOK AT
THE PROGRAM AND DECIDE- WHAT
CHANGES MIGHT BE APPROPRIATE.
SURE AND YOU KNOW AT ITS CORE
THE LEGISLATURE PROVED IT FIVE
YEAR PROGRAM THE GOVERNOR SIGNED
A FIVE YEAR PROGRAM- IN A SINCE
THE PROGRAM'S REALLY ONLY HAD
TWO YEARS THE FIRST COMPLAINTS
WERE REFERRED IN TWENTY TWENTY
ONE. WOULD LIKE TO HAVE TIME FOR
THE TO GET THROUGH THAT AUDIT TO
SEE WHAT THOSE ARTISTS FIND
WE'RE NOT SURE IF THOUGHT ABOUT
IT REALLY WILL TAKE. UP THE
AMOUNT OF TIME THAT WE THINK IT
IS SUPPOSED TO TAKE. AND THE
OTHER PIECE OF THAT IS THAT THE
PROGRAM. MAY- IT MAY NOT HAVE
HAD THE PUCK. THE IT NEEDS TO
GET TO ENOUGH RESIDENTS SO THEY-
THAT THE PROGRAM. GIVEN WHAT
HAPPENED IN CO BUT MANY PEOPLE
ARE DISTRACTED BY THE COBIT
CRISIS- AND REALLY FACED SERIOUS
SERIOUS ISSUES DURING THE COPA
CRISIS MAY NOT HAVE HAD TIME TO
BRING THEIR COMPLAINTS FORWARD
SO. THERE'S SORT OF A NUMBER OF
REASONS AND AT ITS CORE WE WANT
TO BE ABLE TO GIVE THIS PROGRAM.
AT THAT TIME THAT WE ORIGINALLY
SET OUT TO GET BUT WHICH WAS
THOSE FIVE YEARS SO BY EXTENDING
AT THE THREE YEARS WE'D GET THAT
FIVE YEARS. TO BE ABLE TO MAKE
THOSE DECISIONS. YEAH THANK YOU
. ARE WE SURE NO PRESSURE.
PRESSURE OKAY. ANY OTHER I LIKE
THIS BILL AND ALSO. THANK YOU.
MANY OTHERS COMMENTS QUITE OR
MAKE. IF NOT YOU MAKE. MISS OUT
WELL I REALLY A- YOUR TIME AND
YOUR ATTENTION TO THIS VERY VERY
IMPORTANT MATTER. IN MY OWN
DISTRICT OF REALLY WITNESS THE
CHALLENGES THAT MOBILE HOME
RESIDENTS FACE ESPECIALLY COMING
OUT OF THE STORM'S IN THE FLOODS
AND WE SEE THIS AS A VALUABLE
AND IMPORTANT MECHANISM TO.
ENSURE THE GOALS THAT ALL OF US
HAVE THAT THE COMMUNITY HAS
DIGNIFIED AND SAFE LIVING SPACES
SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
I. BOATS. THANK YOU WHEN WE GET
A QUORUM- I WILL OPEN THE ROLE
AND TAKE A VOTE ON IT THANK YOU
SO MUCH THANK YOU SO MUCH TODAY
BRING THE BILL FORWARD. MISTER
KING ASSEMBLY TEAM WELL. I
BELIEVE YOU HAVE TO BUILD YOU TO
JUST. YES I THINK I HAVE THREE
ONE SENTENCE PERF WHICH WERE
ONCHAN TO BELIEVE IT'S- A. B.
NINE THIRTY. THIRTY NINE THIRTY
TWO YEAH SO NEED YOU TO ABOUT AB
NINE YOU SAY. GREAT. YOU'RE
DOING. THE PORTALS OF ON SECOND
OKAY. PERFECTS AB NINE SAID
THREE. IS- QUITE SIMPLE REFER TO
EIGHTY- THE IS A- THE-
REQUIREMENT FOR OCT COME UP AT
OF JAN. TWENTY TWENTY FIVE
MEANING THAT IF YOU WANT TO
BUILD NAY DO YOU YOU HAVE TO BE
A OWNER ON. THIS BILL RE. THAT.
VISION WE THINK THAT WE WANT TO
CONTINUE THE SIX OF PT ALLOW
EVERYONE. TO KEEP BUILDING A TO
USE WEB YOU'RE TALKING IT OR NOT
. HEY TO RESPECT HAS TRIED ON A
B. NICE OF SIX COULD YOU RAINY
WHEN FOR US TO. LISTEN TO THE.
THE PRIMARY WITNESS. IT TO ME.
THANK YOU FOR YOU GOT NEW CHAIR
MEMBERS TO COME TORN APART I'M
MY NAME IS TRUMP A COUPLE A
AFRICAN FOR CALIFORNIA HERE A
POLICY OF AB NINE SAID SIX
CALIFORNIA MAY JUST WHERE
ORGANIZATION OVER EIGHTY. NAY
DEDICATE TO MAKING A- FOR
REPLACE LIVE WORK AND RAISE THE
FAMILY FOR ALL COME. ESPECIALLY
DEALING UNITS YOU OUR ARE BILL
ON X. PROPERTY EXPAND SUPPLY OF.
WHAT EIGHTY IS CAN YOU BILL IN
BOTH SINGLE AND MULTI. NEIGHBOR
THEY COULD NOT BE SOLD AS
SEPARATE UNITS MEETING THEIR
MOST YOU AS LOW FRIEND PLAY A
KEY ROLE IN INCREASING THE FOR
HOUSING IS A NETWORK A COLOR.
NOT ONLY DO A YEARS OFF FOR WHAT
FOR TENANTS BUT THEY ALSO OF
FURTHER FOR HOMEOWNERS AS WELL.
FOR MANY THIS RENTAL AND
CONSERVE A SIMPLE PART OF SOURCE
OF SECURITY AND MANY. CASES
PROVIDE OF THE THING THE BILL
FOR LOWER INCOME D. HOME.
ACCORDING RESEARCH THE UC TURNER
SENT EIGHTY USE PRODUCE MORE
AFFORDABLE TO ARE. BY LOW INCOME
FAMILIES IN INDIVIDUALS AB NICE
SERVICE THE THREE FORCE.
APPARENTLY X. THE EXISTING WHICH
IS ON OXY. USAR ARPU TO TOUCH
CALIFORNIA HAS THIS. IN WE
SHOULD DO ALL WE CAN TO ENSURE
THIS THE CAN CONTINUE SIX. WE
THIS MEASURES THE RIGHT BALANCE
IS FOR THE REASONS WE'VE REQUEST
YOUR SUPPORT FOR A BI SEVEN.
THANK YOU FOR VERY MUCH. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH DO WE HAVE ANY
OTHER WITNESSES NO. OKAY DO WE
HAVE ANYBODY IN THE ROOM LIKE TO
COME THE NEXT SERVICE FOR THE-
JUST ME TO SEE. NAME IN.
ORGANIZATION REPRESENT SOME LIKE
THAT OKAY MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
OF BROWN ON BEHALF OF THE BERRY
CAL. AND BECAUSE HE TO CALL HERE
IN SUPPORT YOU OKAY. RIGHT AND
THIS TIME OF ANYBODY AND I.
PRIMARY WITNESSES AND UP. THERE
NOBODY'S ON. ANYWAY IN THE ROOM
WOULD LIKE TO JUST COME UP AND
SAY I OPPOSED BILL TELL US YOUR-
AND YOUR TO DO. NO ALL RIGHT NOW
WE'RE GONNA GO TO THE PHONE
LINES AGAIN ONCE AGAIN FROM HIS.
TI ON THE- IF THEY WANT US. OR
OPPOSE THIS. NAME WORKING. AND
WE YOU SUPPORT FOR OPPOSE.
GLOBAL THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
FOR THE WHO WISH TO CONSERVE OF
UP TO THIS. PLEASE PRESS. THEN
ZERO. WE'RE GOING TO GO TO.
FORTY SO. LINE FORTY YOUR LINE
IS NOW. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
JENNIFER AB CALIFORNIA'S OF
REALTORS RESPECT. OF UNLESS
AMENDED. NINE SIX. FOR THE
MOMENT REQUESTED ON A RELIGION
WAS. AMENDMENTS A COMMENT LOW
GOT CHURCH CAME A BILL. TO LIMIT
STREAMLINING EIGHTY LOT WITH
OWNER OCCUPANT BY OR- THANK YOU
. HOW NOW GO TO LINES ONE. POINT
SIXTY ONE YOUR IS NOW. MY NAME
IS LISA DANCE I LIVE IN MY CAL
AND I SUPPORT BILL. MISTER CHAIR
THERE IS NO ONE ELSE IS SICK BUT
THEY WERE TO SPEAK ALL RIGHT
THEY WERE GONNA IT BACK TO THE
DAY MRS BLAKE'S. THANK YOU DID
YOU KNOW. BOTH SO WE ALL KNOW
THAT IS ONE OF THE BRIGHTS IN
OUR HOUSING PAUL IN THIS WHERE
WE HAVE SEEN FROM GROWTH DUE TO
THE LIBERALS OF A LOT OF
DIFFERENT THAT PREVIOUSLY.
EIGHTY YOU- DEVELOPMENT SO THIS
SEEMS ANOTHER AN LINE WITH THAT
AND I WILL BE HAPPY SUPPORT IT
TO BUT I WANTED TO DO ASK YOU
QUESTION ABOUT WHY. THE THERE'S
A CONCERN ABOUT- ABOUT
INCREASING CORPORATE OWNERSHIP
OF HOMES SO WHETHER THEY'RE
LARGE TRACTS THAT ARE JUST
CORPORATELY OWNED AND BOUGHT UP
OR- MORE OR MORE OF THESE ARE
INDIVIDUAL HOMES THAT WOULD
POTENTIALLY OF EIGHTIES ATTACHED
OR OR UNATTACHED BUT DO YOU. DO
YOU SEE THAT IS A CONCERN OR OR
WHAT WOULD BE YOUR RESPONSE TO
THAT. I THINK THAT WE'VE BEEN
WATCHING THAT IT SHUTTING VERY
CLOSELY- NOT SO MUCH AROUND
EIGHTY USE BUT AROUND CORPORATE
OWNERSHIP. BUYING SINGLE FAMILY
HOMES- I DON'T THINK THAT THIS
IS SOMETHING THAT'S IN. YOU
KNOW. A CORPORATE PLAN TO DO A
DO YOU DEVELOPMENT IS NOT
REALLY. EASY TO SCALE. AGAIN
WHAT THIS IS DOING IS ALLOWING
SOMEBODY IF THEY IF THEY OWN A
HOME MAYBE THEY INHERITED THEIR
FAMILY HOME TO BUILD AN EIGHTY
YOU- WE THINK THIS IS ONE OF THE
BEST WAYS TO BILL PROPERTY
VALUES ESPECIALLY FOR- OWNERS
WHO JUST. OWN THEIR HOME OR OWN
A PIECE OF PROPERTY THAT THEY
DON'T RESIDE. PREZIOSO YOU YOUR
YOUR EXPECTATION IS IT'S MORE
THE SECOND HOMES VACATION HOME
WHERE SOMEONE WOULD BUILD AN
IDEA ON THAT PROPERTY THAT'S
RIGHT ON THE CORNER SHALL- YOU
KNOW FOR ME MY IT MY FATHER.
AWAY OF MY BIRTH NINE HERE- THAT
WHOLE- YOU WE HAD KEPT IT THAT'S
IN THE WEEK HAVE DONE WITH IT
THAT'S THAT'S REAL WHAT I WOULD
SEE IS. US SOMEONE KEEPING A
FAMILY. AND DOING OR SOME. AGAIN
THAT- HOME HAD ALWAYS BEEN A
RENTAL PER. IN MY FOR SO WE
ALWAYS DO THAT IT WAS NEVER.
PURCHASE TO SAY BUT ALWAYS FRANK
. YEAH OKAY THANK YOU THANK YOU
. RIGHT WITH THAT YOU MAY CLOSE
DISRESPECT FOR ABOUT A BEAST
LICENSE. RIGHT THANK YOU AND YOU
WANT TO GO A. TEN THIRTY THREE.
SURE IS THAT YOUR NEXT BILL AB
TWO OF THE THREE ALSO WIN FOR
THREE TEN THREE YES YES- LET ME
JUST THINK. CAN FOR AMENDMENT
HAPPY TO. ACCEPT THE- THE- ON
THE BILL ON MAYBE TEN THREE IS A
ANOTHER A YOU. WHAT IT DOES IS
IT WILL US CAN. OF EIGHTY YEARS
AND SO- FOR ME TO IS VERY COMMON
- HI. IN THE PAST PURCHASE- I DO
. YOU GO THROUGH A CONDOM COME
PROCESS IF YOU THROUGH CON
CONVERGED PROCESS YOU CAN SELL
EACH OF THOSE UNITS. SEPARATELY
THIS WAS. THAT VERY SAME- THE
BILL WOULD. THE BILL HAS MADE
SURE IT IS LINE WITH- OTHER WHAT
THE SAME WAY THAT YOU WOULD DO
THAT BECAUSE- COME. PROCESS WE
KNOW OF STATE. REYES CAN. WITH
THAT WAS THIS. WE THE BANKS
ASSOCIATE MORE BANKERS.
CALIFORNIA UNION LEAGUE- THEY
HAVE PROPOSED AMEND WE HAVE IT.
IT WORKED OUT EVERY STEP AND-
THE THEY HAVE US TAKE. A JUST SO
YOU ARE TO SEE UNDERSTAND THEY
WERE IN THE PAST WAS. CLARIFYING
ABOUT CONSUMER PER. DISCLOSURE
CLARIFYING THAT ANY MODIFICATION
TO A CONDO MAP CREATED AS A
RESULT OF THIS BILL WILL REQUIRE
CONSENT OF THE LIEN HOLDERS. AND
CLARIFYING THAT PARCELS WITH AN
EXISTING MORTGAGE RECEIVE LENDER
CONSENT UNDER APPLICABLE FEDERAL
GUIDELINES- AGAIN THIS PRACTICE
READY DONE IN WASHINGTON OREGON.
AND TEXAS IN THIS JUST FURTHER-
UNLOCKS. THE POWER OF. OPERATING
AND- HOMES SELL I BELIEVE WE
HAVE TO WITNESSES. I TO SPEAK UP
OKAY CHAIR. IT IS A AS LONG AS A
TWO FOR TWO. EACH WELCOME. THAT
IN TURN COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
MARK AND RIVER ROAD THE K.
STATE. OF COUNTIES. THAT WE DO
BURNED STRONG OF AB TWO THIRTY
THREE AND WE- THE AS A CAN TO
ADDRESS STATE'S HOME CARS- THE
WHICH IS CURRENCY. EXACT
DEVELOPED A CONFERENCE PLAN WE
IS THAT AB TEND TO THREE LINE OF
THIS PLAN EFFECTIVE ADDRESS THE
STATE'S HOME SUBSCRIBE. THE KEY
L. OF THE STATE'S HOMES THE LACK
OF THE HOUSING OF AFFORDABLE IN
THIS. EIGHTY USE SHOWN
THEMSELVES TO BE EFFECT METHOD
TO AN INCREASING THE PRICE OF
THE FORD BY HOUSING THE STATE.
COVER THE CURRENT PER EIGHTY YOU
BEING CONVEYED AND OR AND OR
PERKS WE CAN CORRECT PRESENT
ACCEPTING NEAREST. AB TEN THIRTY
THREE WERE BIRTH FROM THE
STATE'S PROBATE AGAINST SOME
EIGHTY YEARS. AND ALLOW LOCAL TO
CHOOSE HOW AND TO SAY OF USE
WILL ALLOWED THROUGH OREGON.
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THE WANT TO
STE HOME FOR SALE WILL THE
CHANCE TO. AMEND THE EIGHTY YOU
LOT CREATE A MORE OF FOR SELL
OFFS IN THERE. THAT'S FOR THESE
REASONS SEEKS EXPORTS TENDER
THREE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT
WEEK. AFTER MR CHAIRMAN RESIST
BONTA BE THE BEAR COUNCIL IN
SOME OF AB TEN THIRTY THREE- I
WANT TO IT SHORT BUT I JUST WENT
INSIDE THAT THIS IS A OPTION OPT
BILL FOR LOCAL GOT. OR P. THE
STATE BAN ON SEPARATELY CAN A
USE- WHICH THEN LED LOCAL DECIDE
HOW OUR- TO OPT IN. TO BILL ON
PRETTY PERSONAL RULES I WANT TO
THINK THAT AND HIS WONDERFUL
STAFF WORKING THROUGH. LOTS OF
OPPOSITION ON THIS BILL I THINK
IT BILL GOTTEN TO A MUCH BETTER
SPOT- I AM HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTION THAT ARE RELATED TO
SOME OF THE TECHNICAL LENDING
CONCERNS- STILL OUTSTANDING WITH
THE BILL HAVING TO TAKE ANY
OTHER TECHNICAL QUESTIONS- BUT
WE ARE WORKING THROUGH- GETTING
MAKING SURE THAT THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT WILL CONFIRM THAT
THESE. LOANS MADE TO THESE
SEPARATELY CAN AVAILABLE AT USE.
OUR LEGAL THAT THAT'LL THAT
THEY'LL BUY THEM ON THE
SECONDARY MARKET WHICH IS
CRITICAL TO THE SUCCESS OF
LANDING IN THE STATE. I'M
CONFIDENT WE'RE GONNA GET THERE
WE'VE ALREADY GOTTEN INITIAL
CONFIRMATION FROM FHFA THAT.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT THEY'RE
WILLING TO BUY AND THEY DO BY
THE LOANS. ON THE SECONDARY
MARKET FROM THE FOR AT LEAST
FOUR OTHER STATES THAT HAVE.
REALLY COMPATIBLE EIGHTY KIND
AS- AGAIN OR YOUR SUPPORT FOR A
BI TENDER THREE I THINK IT'S IT
AT A PROBABLY. COULD BE ONE OF
THE STATE'S MOST SUCCESSFUL I.
FOR INCREASING HOMEOWNERSHIP
AMONG ESPECIALLY LOW AND
MODERATE INCOME FAMILIES IN THE
STATE- AND AGAIN HAPPY ANSWER
ANY TECHNICAL. QUESTIONS THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. THIRTY VIDEO IN
THE ROOM WOULD LIKE UP AND JUST
. HER EX THEIR- FOR AB TENDER
THREE. AND JUST YOUR NAME ORGAN.
OR HI ME TODAY HAS USE OF HAS
PUT AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF SPUR
CIVIC IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
ANYBODY ELSE. GOING ONCE TWICE
SO OKAY WE'RE GONNA TO OFFICE IS
ANY OP. WOULDN'T IN THE ROOM
LIKE UP IN SPEAK AS A PRIME
WITNESS IN OPPOSITION. YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES THANK YOU. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE. LOUIS BROWN HERE
TODAY ON BEHALF COMMUNITY
ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE THE
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE ACTION
COMMITTEE WE REPRESENT THE
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS IN THE
CITY CALIFORNIA. WE'VE BEEN
ACTIVE CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S OFFICE BUT HAVE
NOT REACHED AGREEMENT YET. ON
AMENDMENTS WHILE THE BILL DOES
PROVIDE A PROCESS FOR THE LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO GO THROUGH BEFORE
THEY WOULD ACTUALLY PERMIT THAT
WE'VE ASKED FOR SIMILAR PROCESS
FOR. HOAS WE BELIEVE THIS
IMPORTANT NOT ONLY A BOARD. OF
THE ASSOCIATION. ELECT TO MAKE
THIS HAPPEN BUT THE ACTUAL
ASSOCIATION MEMBERS VOTE TO
ALLOW THIS TO HAPPEN AS WELL.
THE BILL WOULD AUTHORIZE THE
CREATION OF A CONDOMINIUM
ASSOCIATION WITH IN A MASTER
ASSOCIATION. WE THINK THAT THIS
WOULD CREATE SIGNIFICANT
DISRUPTION. AND WITHOUT
EDUCATION AND OUTREACH WITHOUT
UNDERSTANDING OF EVERYONE WITHIN
THE COMMUNITY COULD CREATE SOME
VERY INTERESTING NEIGHBORLY
ISSUES AND SO WE BELIEVE THAT
YES WHILE IT IS PERMISSIVE WE
THINK YOU SHOULD ALSO STATE
ACTIVELY. THAT TO IN ORDER FOR
THAT ASSOCIATION TO MOVE FORWARD
AND PROVIDE THIS HIS FIRST A
BOARD VOTE AND THEN SECONDLY A
VOTE OF THE MEMBERS IF THAT
OCCURS IN THE ASSOCIATION COULD
MOVE FORWARD ALLOW FOR THE
SEPARATE CONVEYANCE OF THESE
ISSUES. HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
OTHER QUESTIONS YOU MIGHT HAVE.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
HEY COMING UP AS A ABA PRIME
WOULD. OKAY OPPOSITION OKAY WITH
A COUPLE COMMENTS. SOUNDS LIKE A
FROM OKAY I BE A PRIME SURE ALL
RIGHT WHAT ON BEHALF OF THE- SO
. OF COMMUNITY. WE WOULD ALIGN
OUR CALL WITH OF THE COMMUNITY
ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE WE ALSO
BELIEVE THAT. WITH ISSUES
RELATED TO ASSOCIATIONS AND SUB
ASSOCIATIONS BEING CREATED AND-
INSIDE OF LARGER ASSOCIATIONS
NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED. THEIR
ISSUES SUCH AS HOW HOW DO
ASSESSMENTS WORK WHAT ARE THE
VOTING RIGHTS OUR MAINTENANCE
RESPONSIBILITIES DELINEATED-
ISSUES SUCH AS THAT WE HAVE BEEN
IN CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
AUTHOR'S OFFICE. LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUED CONVERSATIONS BUT AT
THIS TIME REMAIN OPPOSED UNLESS
AMENDED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH ALL
RIGHT AT THIS TIME OF GO TO THE
ROOM IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE AND
WOULD JUST LIKE TO COME UP AND
STATE TODAY OPPOSED BILL TELL US
YOUR NAME. NOW GOING ONCE TWICE
SOLD AGAIN ALL RIGHT THAT'S
GONNA TAKE US TO THE PHONE LINES
AGAIN MISTREATING T. OPERATOR.
HE HAD TO DRUM UP SOME PEOPLE ON
THE LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
EXPRESS THEIR OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT. FOR A BI TEN THIRTY
THREE AND- I REMINDER AGAIN JUST
TO NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION
WHETHER YOU OPPOSE OR SUPPORT
THE BILL. AND SUFFICE THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR FOR THOSE WHO WISH
TO SPEAK SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO AB TEN THIRTY
THREE. PLEASE PRESS ONE BUTTON.
ZERO THE SECURE WE HAVE AT LEAST
ONE PERSON IS SIGNALED THAT THEY
WISH TO SPEAK JUST A MOMENT
PLEASE.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO GO TO LINE
FIFTY SIX YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN
. BEATEN MEGLER A MAP OF THE
CITY OF YOU STILL IN RESPECTFUL
OPPOSITION. AS CHAIR THERE IS NO
ONE ELSE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH-
WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE DIETS
FOR SENATOR BLAKE SPEIR GO AHEAD
THANK YOU. SO I JUST WANTED TO
UNDERSTAND WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE
SO IS THERE A NEW PARCEL NUMBER
THAT'S CREATED. SO- THIS IS I
DON'T KNOW IF YOU'RE FAMILIAR
WITH HOW. CONDOMS ARE CREATED OR
HOW UNITS CAN BE CREATED INTO A
CONDOMINIUM SO THERE'S A NEW
PARTIAL NUMBER THERE'D BE A NEW
ASSESSMENT- YOU HAVE THE SAME
PROPERTY THERE IS A- SPECIFIC
SET OF LAWS SO THAT WE DON'T
TOUCH ABOUT HOW THE PROPERTY
WOULD BE SUBDIVIDED INTO TWO
SEPARATELY OWNED UNITS- I'M
INTERESTED IN A FALLS ACCORDING
TO CURRENT LAW. OKAY SO THE
BUYER OF THE OF THE NEW EIGHTY
YOU WOULD PAY PROPERTY TAXES AND
WOULD HAVE A SEPARATE UTILITY
SEWER HOOKUP WOULD BE IT'S
BASICALLY CREATING ADDITIONAL
DENSITY OF I MEAN FOR CITIES-
GENERAL PLANS AND- ALL OF THIS
WOULD BE IN ADDITION RIGHT OKAY
RIGHT OKAY SO IT WOULD BE A- IT
WOULD BE A- HOMEOWNERS. OF ONE.
OR I MEAN WHEN WE'RE TAUGHT WHEN
THERE'S THIS DISCUSSION ABOUT
THE H. O. A.'S AND THERE'S IF
THERE'S ONE EIGHTY YOU. THIS IS
A FEATURE OF TWO BECAUSE HAVE
THE HOW AND YOU HAVE THE EIGHTY
YOU YOU COULD HAVE A HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION OF TWO SO I'VE IN
THE PAST AGAIN PURCHASED A
DUPLEX. I LIVED UPSTAIRS MEMBERS
OF THE DOWNS. POINTED TO CONDEMN
. THE ASSOCIATE WAS TWO OF US.
AND YOU HAVE YOU KNOW A LOT
FIFTEEN HOURS A YOU WRITE JUST
TO BE SAFE YOU DON'T YOU DON'T
HAVE TO PAY. GENERALLY SHOULD
HAVE C. C. OURS JUST MAKE SURE
THAT- ONCE THEY ARE SIMPLY CAN
IN YOU'RE NO LONGER. FAMILY
WHICH IS WHAT WE DO THANK DID
YOU ACTUALLY HAVE A SET OF RULES
GOVERNING THE ASSIST. RIGHT OKAY
OKAY AND- SKIPPING SO THE REAL
LITTERS A- AND THERE WERE SOME
THERE SOME OFFICE. SO IS THAT
TAKEN OFF NOW YOU TAKE THE AMEND
OR DOES THE OPPOSITION REMAIN.
ADJOURNMENTS. WE THINK WE SALAS
THE LENDERS- BUT WE'RE STILL
WAITING OFFICIAL NOTICE BY IT
BUT AGAIN. EVERYTHING
SUBSTANTIVE THAT THEY'VE ASKED
ABOUT. THE FAST US TO DUPE THE
BILL WE HAVE DONE. THE ONE THING
THAT THEY ASK ONE TO GET. A
RESPONSE FROM THE HELP WITH A
HEAVY FROM THE FOR EFFORT. IN
TERMS OF MAKE SURE THAT ANY LOAN
WHAT BE PURCHASED BY- FANNIE
FREDDIE. AND OF COURSE YOU KNOW
GETTING RESPONSE FOR THE FED IF
IT PIXEL BIT OF TIME RIGHT. OKAY
EVEN FROM. AT THE AGE OF TALK.
OKAY THANK YOU RIGHT WE'RE GONNA
TAKE A BREAK RIGHT NOW AND-
QUORUM WE HAVE IT. SO- FEW COLOR
. SENATOR WIENER THE TROUBLED
CARE TO VOTE PRESENT LIKE SPEAR
HERE LIKE PRESENT KERRIER.
FOR THE SENATOR CAMBODIA. MMHM
ASSEMBLY MEMBER YEAR- YOUR BILL
WILL COME TO GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE AFTER AFTER THIS
COMMITTEE- BUT I HAVE SOME
CONCERNS AND I GUESS WHAT WE'LL
SEE WHETHER- YOU GET A LETTER
FROM THE LENDERS- INDICATING
THAT. THE ISSUE'S BEEN RESOLVED
TO THEIR SATISFACTION HERE'S MY
HERE'S MY CONCERN IS THAT-
ALTHOUGH SOME PEOPLE MAY PUT
EIGHTY USE ON A SEPARATE SEWER
AND A SEPARATE ELECTRICAL LINE
AND THE SEPARATE WATER LINE- I
DOUBT THAT EVERYBODY WOULD DO
THAT- AND IF THAT'S NOT DONE.
THEN IT IN IT IN EXTRACTS STRICT
IN- JOINS THE TO- UNITS EVEN IF
YOU SEPARATE THEM AND SELL OFF
YOUR SPHERE YOU'RE RECEIVING
YOUR YOUR SERVICES FROM FROM THE
MAIN UNIT AND- MY CONCERN IS
ALTHOUGH- I UNDER WHAT YOU DID
WITH YOUR BROTHER AND THAT'S
GREAT- IN RURAL CALIFORNIA
PEOPLE ARE NOT GOING TO BE A
SOPHISTICATED AND KNOW HOW TO BE
ABLE TO SET UP THE CONTRACTUAL
OBLIGATIONS. THAT WILL MAKE IT
CLEAR AS TO WHAT THEY'RE SELLING
AND- AND WHAT THEY'RE- RIGHTS
AND OBLIGATIONS ARE IN REGARDS
TO THAT SALE AND THE ABILITY TO-
TO GET A LOAN SO I I'M JUST I'M
CONCERNED AND SO WILL IT WILL
TAKE A LOOK AT IT GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCIAL SUPPORT IT TODAY BUT-
IT DAVID SAYS SOME OF THE-
QUESTIONS AND THE ANSWERS MAKE
ME MORE WORRIED THAN I WAS WHEN
I FIRST READ THIS SO- WHAT WILL
HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A
CONVERSATION. ABOUT HOW THAT ALL
WORKS I DON'T WANT TO SET UP A
SITUATION WHERE PEOPLE ARE SUING
EACH OTHER BECAUSE- IT DIDN'T
WORK OUT HOW THEY THOUGHT.
BECAUSE THEY SOLD A PIECE OF THE
- AND- AND THAT PERSON THE BUYER
GOD DIDN'T WHAT THEY THOUGHT
THEY WERE GETTING SO- I
APPRECIATE WHAT WHAT WHAT YOU'RE
TRYING TO DO HERE BUT I'M A
LITTLE BIT NERVOUS ABOUT IT.
THIS SECOND SENATOR THIS IS THIS
PROCESS IS NO DIFFERENT THAN
EXISTING LAW I MEAN YOU HAVE-
EXISTING LAW THERE ARE. DUPLEXES
YOU KNOW FOUR PLEXUS ALL OF OUR
STATE RULE CALIFORNIA IRVINE
CALIFORNIA YOU YOU MAY HAVE MORE
TO BOXES IN YOUR DISTRICT AT ME
. TO BE FRANK AND THERE. A
PROCESS STATE. TO TURN THEM INTO
CONDOMINIUMS. AND THERE'S A
PROCESS HERE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
YOUR LOCAL CITIES- TO GOVERN
THAT PROCESS- THIS LAW DOES NOT
CHANGE ANY OF THAT SO HOWEVER.
CITIES IN YOUR JURISDICTIONS
WOULD GOVERN A CONDOMINIUM
PROCESS THAT THAT IS HOW IT
WOULD BE GOVERNED IN ANY OF YOUR
CITIES OR UNINCORPORATED COUNTY
. THAT DOES NOT CHANGE ALL THIS
IS IF THIS. WORKABLE TOURISTIC
INTO IN OPT IN. DAN DATE COULD-
ALLOW THE- OF THAT JURISDICTION
TO SEPARATELY. CONVEY THE EIGHTY
YEAR AND AGAIN IT'S A- IT'S NOT
A NOT SO AGAIN YOU. RULE CAL
JUST OF CITIES WITH TO OPT IN.
AND I MISS THE IF THE FROM THAT
THAT WE UP IN THAT THE THAT'S
WHAT THEY WERE USE IN OTHER
STATES DO SO. I ASSUMED. RIGHT
SO IT'S- WE'RE NOT FOR. ANYBODY
TO DO FOR THEIR WANT TO DO I AND
MOST OF PERHAPS. FOR THE
PROPERTY OR NEED DON'T WANT TO
DO IS THIS IS ALL AT. HEY WE
THIS IS A HOW. FIRST TO CREATING
MORE. OPPORTUNITIES WE SEE MANY
TIME FOR A LOT OF THE TO USE
FOR- WE KNOW HOW EXPENSIVE IT IS
TO PER HOME I BAD MIGHT MIGHT IS
A LOT OF THE- WILL BE CONVEYED
TO CHILDREN. FRANKLY BECAUSE
IT'S FROM A ODDS ON HOW BOTH YOU
ARE OR WHERE YOU LIVE TO- SEE
YOUR CHOI BE ABLE TO BUY
PROPERTY NEAR YOU ESPECIALLY IN
ANYWAY ALONG COAST AND HIGH SO
AGAIN DID IS SOMETHING PEOPLE
THAT CITIES WOULD OPT IN TO THAT
IT I. HOPE WE WOULD HAVE. WITH-
YOU KNOW SOLVE THIS- IF THE THAT
SELL THEY WOULD DO SO KNOWING I
. THAT THE IS ISRAEL AND WE JUST
SOME REALLY BAD X. WITH- CONDOM
TO. THAT WERE. BUILT BY PER
DEVELOPERS AND SOLD LOW INCOME.
WHO THEN- BECAUSE THEY HAD NO
MANAGED X. BE. SUFFER AND DIDN'T
BUILD UP RESERVE AND THEY FELL
APART IN THE CITY HAD TO COME
AND- PRIVATE STREETS THAT MEANT
. WHICH JUST IT WAS IT. INTO I
I'M I'M WANT TO MAKE SURE IT'S A
OFTEN. POSTED BECAUSE THOSE
THOSE PROJECTS- WE'RE NOT CITIES
THAT WERE PRIVATE SPA. COULD I
DO. BUT IT DIDN'T SET UP
INTEREST NECESSARY TO BE ABLE TO
MAINTAIN. THE VIABILITY OF THE
PRIDE OF THE PRIVATELY OWNED.
PIECES OF THE OF THE PROJECT SO
I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE DOING
HERE IS AN OFTEN THANK YOU. ANY
OTHER QUESTIONS FROM THE DYESS
IT'S NOT. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
CHANGES THOSE I STRUGGLED ON A.
B. THIRTY THREE. RIGHT SO. THIS
IS A DO PASS. TO HOUSING FINANCE
. TO LOSE YEAH. THE NEW PASS IN
A RE TO GO FINE. SO WANT TO GROW
. TWO THREE HELLO YEAH SO HE THE
MOST. FOR SUPERIOR I MOVE. WE
HAVE A MOTION BY BLAKE'S BASS
AND BLAKE'S. GOING KALRA THANK
YOU. SENATOR WIENER BUT CHAO.
CLICK HERE FIVE SIX VERIFY.
AND AT ON. OKAY LET'S SEE NEXT
UP WE HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER TEAM
TO DETERMINE MAKE MASTER
QUESTION. WOULD IT BE POSSIBLE
FOR US TO DO SINCE WE HAVE A
QUORUM FOR US TO DO THE ONES
THAT WE'VE ALREADY HEARD. BUT
THEN YOU WANT TO ESCAPE NINE
TOOL FOR WHEN IT ALL ENDS I'D
RATHER BE ABLE TO LEAVE INSTEAD
OF EATING OUT ALL THE REGULARS.
YEAH I WAS I WAS ACTUALLY HOPING
TO GET MISTER TEEN DONE AND THEN
WE WERE GOING TO DO THAT OKAY
ROLE IN BETWEEN WELL WE CHANGE
OKAY PURPOSE THAT FOLKS MISTER
TECH IF YOU LIKE TO GO AHEAD
WITH YOUR- AB SIXTEEN THIRTY
THREE. THANK YOU CENTER AB
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE STRENGTHENS
THE HOUSING KILLED
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT IT REALLY
HELPS PROVIDE A LITTLE MORE.
CERTAINTY FOR DEVELOPERS TRYING
TO BUILD MUCH NEEDED HOUSING
ACROSS OUR STATE THOUSAND KILLED
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT WAS. WRITTEN
BY THE STATE TO ENSURE THAT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACTED.
PROPERLY WHEN THEY WERE
REJECTING WAR. ALLOWING THAT
DEVELOPMENTS TO GO THROUGH THEIR
PROCESS- THIS LAW REALLY BECAME
NEEDED VERY FAMOUS CASE AND- MY
CITY AS WELL AS OUR CHAIR CITY
AROUND FOR SIXTY NINE STEVENSON
WHICH WAS A- VALET PARKING LOT
FOR A. NORDSTROM SAID WAS A
BLOCK AWAY. THIS WAS DIDN'T PASS
APPROVED BY OUR PAPER BUT THEN
HELD UP BY OUR STATE BAY OF.
UNDERSEA WHAT FROM UNFORTUNATELY
WAS HELD IN SEEK REALLY DID NOT
ALLOW THE TO- ANY FEEDBACK TO A
THE- OR FIGURE OUT HOW TO HOW TO
PAY FORWARD. YOU MIGHT HEARD THE
GOVERNOR HIMSELF HAD TO
INTERCEDE IN THIS. PROJECT TO
MOVE FORWARD HOWEVER BECAUSE HE
DID SO AT SUCH A TIME THAT THE
ECONOMY'S SORT OF CHANGED- THE
DEVELOPER AT THIS POINT IT'S NOT
MOVING AHEAD WITH THE PROJECT
WHICH IS VERY UNFORTUNATE
BECAUSE WE NEED. HOUSING IN SAN
FRANCISCO JUST LIKE WE NEED
HOUSING IN THE REST OF. THE
STATE THIS WOULD THIS BILL WOULD
CREATE A REMEDY FOR CRITICAL
PROJECTS ARE UNFAIRLY DENIED
INSURERS THAT THEY ARE NOT HELD
IN AN ENDLESS CYCLE- TO BE HELD
IN PURGATORY. LOCAL DECISION
LOCAL AGENCIES WOULD HAVE TO SAY
AMOUNT OF TIME TO MAKE DECISIONS
A AND- SHOULD THERE BE ANY
CONCERNS. THE DEVELOPER DOES
HAVE THE ABILITY TO. TAKE THEM
TO COURT THIS ALLOWS. FOR THE
DEVELOPMENT OF CERTAINTY- THE
PROJECTS OR ARE LIMITED TO
CERTAIN AREAS ARE LIMITED TO
URBANITES OWNS THEY HAVE A
MINIMUM TEN THROUGH APARTMENT
FIFTEEN UNITS PER ACRE. AND THEY
MEET THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AN
EXEMPTION OR HAS GONE THROUGH
LEGALLY SUFFICIENT ENVIRONMENTAL
REVIEW FOR THIS IS NOT
CIRCUMVENT. THE SECRET PROCESS
THIS PROCESS JUST ALLOWS- FOR A
LEVEL OF CERTAINTY WHAT'S THE
SECRET PROCESS IS DONE SO THAT
THE DEVELOPER WOULD BE TOLD. IF
IT WAS BEING THE PARTY COULD BE
HELD UP THAT THEY COULD ACTUALLY
REMEDIATE OR DO SOMETHING TO
ADDRESS- WHATEVER THE CITY
COUNCIL BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
CONCERNS MIGHT BE. WITHOUT
RESPECTFULLY ASK PRIVATE. ON AB
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE. OKAY AND
DID YOU HAVE ANY PRIOR WITNESS
TODAY. THIS TO US OKAY LET'S
EACH OF YOU HAVE TO ME. THANK
YOU MARK OF THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. THANKS TO
ALL THE LEGISLATURE- WE HAVE A
NUMBER OF EXEMPTIONS THAT APPLY
IN SECRET TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
THEY'RE ALSO CLEAR PROCESSES FOR
UNDER WHICH LOOK GOVERNMENT'S
CONNECTION DOT MITIGATED
NEGATIVE DECLARATIONS. HOWEVER
THOSE EXEMPTIONS AND PROCESSES
ARE ONLY SO GOOD AS THE PAPER
THEY'RE PRINTED ON. IF LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS ARE NOT WILLING TO
RECOGNIZE THEM OR UTILIZE THEM
IN AN INDIVIDUAL COULD AN
INDIVIDUAL CASES AND SO. WE AT
THE PARTNERSHIP WORK WITH OF
DEVELOPERS AFFORDABLE HOUSING
RENTS THIS OFTEN WHERE. THE
DEVELOPMENTS CLEARLY- ELIGIBLE
FOR EXEMPTION AND THE LOCAL
GOVERNMENT. JUST WILL DENY IT-
AND COOK BUT THREE THROUGH A AN
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW PROCESS
THAT CAN TAKE A LONG TIME IS
THEN SUBJECT TO LEGAL CHALLENGE.
AND SO WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO
HERE IS CREATE CERTAINTY WE'RE
KIND OF TRYING TO CREATE
CERTAINTY THE WANTED DEVELOPMENT
MEETS THE ACTUAL- ELIGIBILITY
REQUIREMENTS FOR AN EXEMPTION
THAT WE CAN UTILIZE AN EXEMPTION
TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THE
DEVELOPMENT. OF THIS BILL
ESSENTIALLY CODIFIES THE
POSITION OF THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT HOUSING COMMUNITY.
THAT HAS BEEN IN PLACE FOR SOME
TIME. AND SO WE THINK THAT TO
STRENGTHENS THAT THAT POSITION
OF THE STATE TO ENSURE THAT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND ALL
NEEDED HOUSING. CAN MOVE FORWARD
WHEN WE'VE WHEN IT COMPLIES.
WITH THE RULES THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN
VERS L'EST BONTA WOODBURY
COUNCIL I BEAR COUNCIL PROBABLY
REPRESENTS MANY OF THE FIRMS
THAT WERE INVOLVED IN TRYING TO
BUILD FOUR SIX NINE STEVENSON-
AND ARE HERE TO SUPPORT. HIGH AB
TENS AT. SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE
TOO MANY BILLS TODAY SORRY- IN
IN LARGE PART BECAUSE THE
RESPONSE THAT PROJECT- THE
HOUSING IN THE STATE'S HOUSING
KIND OF BILLIONS IS PERHAPS THE
STATE'S MOST IMPORTANT LAW THAT
RELATES TO HOUSING. IT
ESTABLISHES PENALTIES FOR LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS THAT. WILLFULLY DENY
OR OR OR WILLFULLY FAIL TO
FOLLOW BOTH THEIR OWN LAWS AND
STATE LAWS WITH REGARDS TO
HOUSING. TERENCE'S GO VERY
CREATIVELY DISCOVER THAT IF YOU
WRONGFULLY DENY PROJECT. VIA THE
SECRET DOCUMENTATION PROCESS
THAT THE- IT J. CLAIMS ARE NOT
REVIEWABLE THIS BEER GARDENS
ARTS GIVEN THAT THOSE PLANS ARE
NOT REVIEWABLE. UNDER THE
STATE'S HOUSING COUNT ABILITY
ACT MEANING THAT THERE'S- FREE
RANGE TO DENY PROJECT FOR ANY
REASON- AS LONG AS YOU DO SO BY
FAILING TO ADOPT THE SECRET
DOCUMENTATION. THIS BILL DOES
NOT AFFECT SEEK WITH THE
STATUTE. IT SIMPLY DECIDES THAT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS HAVE TO MAKE A
DECISION IN A TIMELY MANNER AND
RESPOND TO THE FACTS PRESENTED.
ABOUT SECRET DETERMINATIONS OR
WRONGFUL DENIALS ESPECIALLY
THOSE THAT ARE WILLFULLY MADE
WRONGFULLY ARE REVIEWABLE UNDER
THE STATE'S HOUSING
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT. AGAIN JUST
CREATING THAT PENALTY APPLYING
THAT PENALTY SO THAT THERE ISN'T
A WAY TO EVADE STATE LAW OR
LOCAL LAW- IN THE SORT OF
CREATIVE FASHION. A HAPPY ANSWER
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS YOU HAVE
ABOUT THE BILL BUT STRONGLY URGE
YOUR SUPPORT FOR A BI. TEN SIX
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE TODAY THANK
YOU. BAGUETTES YOU AT THIS TIME
WILL TAKE ON FOR PEOPLE THAT ARE
INTO. JUST YOUR NAME AND YOUR
GONNA. OR A MAN YOU WERE YOU
REPRESENT AND HOLLY FOR MANY IS
THAT PUBLIC AFFAIRS TODAY IN
SUPPORT OF A OFFICE FOR AND
CIVIC. THANK YOU TECH SPEAKER.
AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN ON THE
- US ON BEHALF OF THE NON. HOW
THIS IS OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. VERY
ANNOYING WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING CONSORTIUM IN SUPPORT.
BOB NEUTROPHILS SEVEN COMPANY
HOWARD AHMANSON JUNIOR IN
SUPPORT. CHAIRMAN OF THE
COMMITTEE YOUR THEM BUT IN A
KIND OF A HOT HERE ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIA YIMBY. HERE'S A PRO
COAL SPONSOR IN SUPPORT OF
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE THANK YOU
SO MUCH. STEPHEN STANDS THERE
WITH BROWN STAIN ON BEHALF OF
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION IN
SUPPORT. HEY GOOD THANK YOU- SO
NOW WE'RE GONNA GO TO OPPOSITION
IS THERE ANY PRIMARY OPPOSITION
WITNESSES WHO WOULD LIKE TO COME
UP AND SPEAK FOR. TWO MINUTES.
WE HAVE ONE WELCOME. GOOD
AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
CHRISTINA KERO I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL.
RESPECTFULLY IN OPPOSITION TO AB
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE. HI MY
FIRST YOU WANT TO. ACKNOWLEDGE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TANG AND HIS
STAFF THE SPONSORS FOR. MEETING
WITH US EARLIER IN THE SESSION
TO HEAR OUR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
BILL HOWEVER WE'VE NOT BEEN ABLE
TO RESOLVE THOSE AND REMAIN
RESPECTFULLY NOT POSITION TODAY-
I WOULD NOTE. THAT AB SIXTEEN
THIRTY THREE IS NOT GOING TO
ACCELERATE HOUSING PRODUCTION
CONTRARY TO SOME OF WHAT YOU'VE
HEARD TODAY. THE BILL ACTUALLY
CREATES A LITIGATION TOOL FOR
DEVELOPERS TO CIRCUMVENT THE
SECRET PROCESS AND SKIP THE
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS THAT
APPLIES TO ALL LAND USE
PROJECTS. BY CHALLENGING THE
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW PROCESS FOR
THEIR PROJECTS IN COURT BEFORE
THAT PROCESS IS COMPLETE. THIS
DIRECTLY UNDERMINES THE
ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC
PARTICIPATION MANDATES OF SYKORA
BY PENALIZING AGENCIES FOR
RESPONDING TO EVIDENCE IN ORDER
TO MITIGATE THE HARMFUL EFFECTS
OF PROJECTS. AND THAT IS
PRECISELY THE PURPOSE OF
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. RECENT
AMENDMENTS TO THE BILL FOCUSED
ON DENSE HOUSING IN URBANIZED
AREAS AND WHILE THAT IS A
LAUDABLE GOAL. THOSE FACTORS MAY
ACTUALLY INCREASE IMPACTS WHICH
REQUIRE MITIGATION UNDERSEA
QUEST. BECAUSE WHEN YOU
CONSTRUCT HOUSING PROJECTS IN
DENSE URBAN AREAS. THE
CONSTRUCTION IMPACTS TEND TO
HAVE A CUTE. IMPACTS ON LOCAL
RESIDENTS AND WORKERS WHO LIVE
AND WORK NEAR THE PROJECT SITE.
THIS BILL WOULD ALSO RESULT IN
LITIGATION COSTS IN ATTORNEY'S
FEES AND FINES BEING LEVIED
AGAINST AGENCIES SIMPLY FOR
COMPLYING WITH SEQUEL BEFORE THE
PROJECT IS EVEN APPROVED OR
DENIED. THAT'S CONTRARY TO THE
PURPOSE OF BOTH THE CALIFORNIA
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT AND
THE HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY ACT
AND IT DOES NOT INCREASE HOUSING
PRODUCTION. NO RECENT STUDIES
HAVE SHOWN THAT SECRET IS
ACTUALLY NOT A MAJOR OBSTACLE TO
HOUSING FOR TWENTY TWENTY THREE
STUDY JUST FOUND THAT OF ALL THE
PROJECTS UNDERGOING
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW IN THE
STATE. ONLY ONE POINT 9% OF
THOSE ARE SUBJECT TO SECRET
CHALLENGES AT ALL AND OF THOSE
ONLY A QUARTER OF THEM ARE
HOUSING PROJECTS. THAT'S LESS
THAN ONE HALF OF 1% OF ALL
PROJECTS IN THE STATE. THAT ARE
HOUSING PROJECTS UNDERGOING A
SECRET CHALLENGE THAT IS NOT A
STATEWIDE PROBLEM. I ON THE
OTHER HAND THE BILL'S VERY
EXPENSIVE AND MAY ACTUALLY DELAY
THE PROJECTS WHICH INVOLVES A
GLASS TO THE ASSEMBLY
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE FOUNDED
THAT THE BILL WOULD COST ABOUT
EIGHT HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS.
IN TAXPAYER FUNDS FOR JUST TEN
NEW LAWSUITS FILED UNDER THE
BILL AND EACH OF THOSE LAWSUITS
IN THE COURTS IS LIKELY TO BE
DELAYED. FOR A SUBSTANTIAL
AMOUNT OF TIME POTENTIALLY
YEARS. SO FOR ALL THESE REASONS.
CRIMINALIZING ENVIRONMENTAL AND
PUBLIC HEALTH PROTECTIONS IS A
BAD IDEA FOR CALIFORNIA SO WE
URGE YOU TO VOTE NO ON AB
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
TODAY. DEALS I WOULD LIKE TO
SPEAK AS A PRIMARY WITNESS IN
OPPOSITION IF NOT WE'LL GO TO.
ANYBODY IN THE ROOM WHO WOULD
LIKE TO COME UP AN AD ON THEIR
OPPOSITION. TO AB SIXTEEN.
THIRTY THREE. IF NOT WE'RE GOING
TO GO TO THE PHONE LINES
EIGHTEEN T. OPERATOR IF YOU CAN
GET SOME PEOPLE ON THE LINE
WOULD LIKE EITHER TESTIFYING.
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION TO AB
SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE REMEMBER
JUST YOUR NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION
REPRESENT. AND WHETHER YOU
SUPPORT OR OPPOSE. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR FOR THOSE WHO WISH
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS
TIME. PRESS ONE THEN. ZERO MR
CHERRY DO PEERS THERE IS NO ONE
WHO SIGNALED THAT THEY WISH TO
SPEAK. IF THERE IS NO ONE WHO
WISHES TO SPEAK I WILL BRING IT
BACK TO THE DYESS AND WE'LL SEE
IF ANYBODY. HAS ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS THEY WOULD LIKE TO ADD
. SENATOR JOE BROKE. I JUST
WOULD LOVE TO HAVE GIVE THE
MEMBER- AN OPPORTUNITY TO
ADDRESS SOME OF THE CONCERNS
THAT WERE BROUGHT UP FROM THE
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
CENTER- AGAIN- THIS BILL DOESN'T
TOUCH ANY OF THE SECRET STATUTES
AT ALL. WHAT IT WHAT YOU HEARD
FROM THE OPPOSITION IS THAT-
THIS. ALLOWS A DEVELOPER SOME
OPPORTUNITY TO INSERT THEMSELVES
. IF THEY ARE STUCK IN AN
ENDLESS SEQUENCE LOOP. SO WHAT
WHAT THE OPPOSITION TALKED ABOUT
WAS- BEFORE DETERMINATIONS MADE
WHETHER IT IS AFFIRMATIVE OR
NEGATIVE DETERMINATION QUITE
OFTEN WHAT WE SEE WITH A NUMBER
OF HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS IS THAT
NO DISINTERESTED. AND YOU'RE
JUST HELD THERE IN SORT OF
GOVERNMENT BUREAUCRATIC
PURGATORY WAITING FOR A DECISION
TO BE MADE. SO WHAT THIS BILL
DOES HERE'S THE SET A CERTAIN
TIME FRAME ASKING THE GOVERNMENT
AGENCY TO MAKE A DECISION EITHER
FROM TO NEGATIVE DOESN'T
PRESCRIBE BY THE DECISION- AND
ALSO THAT IF THERE IS. A
DECISION AROUND IN. DENIAL OF
SEQUENCE THAT YOU HAVE TO
ARTICULATE WHY UNDER SEQUENCE HE
WAS LIKE YOU CAN'T JUST DENY IT
BECAUSE THEY FELT LIKE IT THEY
HAVE TO TONIGHT FOR. CERTAIN
ENVIRONMENTAL REASONS SAID SO
AGAIN GIVING THE DEVELOPER
OPPORTUNITY TO REMEDIATE THIS
AGAIN WE TRY TO KEEP IT NARAL
AROUND URBANIZED AND SLIGHTLY
MORE DANCE FRANKLY BECAUSE-
THAT'S WHERE THERE SHOULD BE A
LOT OF FOCUS TO GET MORE HOUSING
BUILT IN OUR DENSER AREAS. IN
OUR AREAS THAT ARE BLOW MORE
URBANIZED YOU CAN YOU CAN HAVE
THAT. KIND OF DENSITY SO AGAIN.
THIS PROVIDES A CERTAIN OF SIR
WE TOUCHING THE SEACOAST. IN AT
ALL. FORCES LOCAL TOURIST. TO
MAKE A DECISION NOW AGAIN THIS
COULD BE TONIGHT THE PROJECT
THAT'S FULLY IN THAT LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS ARE PERFECT. BUT BUT
AGAIN I THINK RIGHT NOW WE HAVE
A HOUSING CRISIS WE CAN'T. FORCE
EVERY DEVELOPER INTO THIS
UNKNOWN SITUATION FOREVER AND WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY HAVE
A CERTAIN LEVEL OF CERTAINTY SO
THAT THEY COULD EITHER FIGURE
OUT WHAT TO DO WITH THAT
PROPERTY OR MOVE ON TO THE NEXT
PROJECT. I THINK IT'S RATHER
UNFAIR AGAIN. I THINK THAT WAS
ONE OF THE TACTICS OF THE
OPPONENTS OF THIS PROJECT WAS
THAT. THEY WERE JUST GOING TO
LAY DOWN THAT THE DELAY DELAY
DELAY AND THEY FINALLY ALLOWED
THE APPROVAL TO HAPPEN BECAUSE
BY THEN IT DIDN'T MATTER BECAUSE
ECONOMY HAD TURNED. THE NEW THE
DEVELOPER WASN'T GOING TO BUILD
IT COULD JUST FINANCIALLY DIDN'T
PENCIL. THAT TO ME IS NOT HOW.
COVER SHOULD. POORLY HOW A
STATEWIDE HOUSE CRISIS SO AGAIN.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT. DOESN'T
JUST IMPACT MY CITY. SO MANY
OTHER CITIES ALL ACROSS THE
STATE. THANK YOU. HERE THE
QUESTIONS. COMMENTS AGAIN-
ÓRDENES AND ALLOW THAT TO BE A
CLOSING I WILL CLOSE JUST TO SAY
THAT THANK YOU CENTER. ALL RIGHT
- THAT SEE THIS IS A DO PAY IN
THE RE REFER TO. ON ENVIRONMENT
QUALITY DO I HAVE A MOTION. WHO
LET'S MOVE BY SENATOR. SO YOU
MAY CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER BUT CHAU BUG. HI THE
TROUBLED BY LEG SPINNER. LIKE
SPEAR HI CARRIE BY CARRIER HI
COURTESY. COURTESY HI. PADILLA I
VIDEA HI SIR TO. ZERO TWO HI
SKINNER NUMBER WILL HOP. SIX
ZERO. RIGHT AT THIS TIME WE JUST
GOING TO A COUPLE SECONDS
THROUGH THE ROLLING UP- SO THAT-
THERE MAY IT MIGHT TO GO TO. ON
ANOTHER MADE SO. SO WILL BE
START WITH ADAM NUMBER ONE. OKAY
SUFFERED THE ROLL ON ITEM ONE
THAT'S. FORTY TWO. MOTIONS FOR
THE MOTION ON I NUMBER. AB FORTY
TWO. MOTION LIKE BEER GOOD KALRA
. THIS A FREE TO BUY SOME AROMA
MOTIONS TO PAY A REFER THE
COMMITTEE THE RENTS AND FINANCE
CENTER WE UNTIL BOTH BY THE
TROUBLED BY BLIX. CLICKS THERE I
KABIRU CAN I. PARTISI HI MICHAEL
VIDEA.
BY CENTER CORTESE. AND KALRA.
THIS IS A DIFFERENT NUMBER SOME
NUMBER LEAVE THE MOTION IS TO
PASS AND REFER THE COMMITTEE AND
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SIR
WIENER THE TROUBLED NO BUT CHAU
BOOK NOW LAKE SUPERIOR I PLEASE
VERIFY CABALLERO I CAN I PHOTO
COURTESY I REQUIRE VIDEA. VIDEA
I HERE TO KNOW THEIR TO KNOW
SKIN NUMBER BOB FORTIES WHO WILL
HOLD THAT OPEN FOR BRING JUST A
NUMBER FOUR EIGHT FOR NINETY LEE
ALSO THE A MOTION FOR. THE
MOTION TO MOVE THE BILL A WITH.
CENTER PADILLA. MOTIONS TO AND
REFER THE COMMITTEE UNDER TO
FIND SENATOR WIENER UNTIL BOTH
BY THE TO BY BLIX HERE CLICKS
THERE I. OKAY CARRERO I HEARD HE
HAS A HI MCGUIRE THE D.
SURE. ALL THE PROMOTION BY
BLAKE'S. CRITICAL ROLE THE
MOTION IS TO PASS A REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE OF JUDICIARY SENATOR
WIENER THE TROUBLE. CLICK HERE
FIVE SIX HERE I CARREIRO HI CARE
HI COURTESY COURTESY I MCGUIRE
VIDEO. VIDEO HI HERE TO KNOW
SERCO NOW SKINNER AMBERG BOB
THAT IS. FOR TO ONE. SORRY AND
THE THAT. TAKES US TO ITEM TWO
ONE. AND THAT IS- B. NINE
SEVENTY SO. ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
HAVE A MOTION FOR THEM. MOTION
BY CENTER COURT. THE MOTION IS
TO PAY AND REFER THE CAN
GOVERNMENTS AND FINANCE.
HI SKINNER AMBERG BOB THAT IS
FIVE TO ONE. SIX ONE ZERO I
DON'T KNOW SENATE OUTSIDE NO
THOSE NINE SEVENTY SO CORRECT.
THANK YOU THE. YEAH WE'RE GOING
TO TWO THOUSAND. YEAH WHAT IS
THE. YEAH OKAY THANK YOU THANK
GOD SINCE FOR PRESIDING LINE OF
THE STUMPS OUT- JOB. TWO HUNDRED
YOU'VE- OKAY SO WE ARE GOING TO
NOW TAKE UP TO CONSENT. CALLON
WHICH IS ITEM TO AB. FOR OH
EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN AB THREE TWO
THREE ITEMS A FOURTH- ITEM
FOURTEEN AB SEVENTY SIXTY FOUR.
I DON'T. EIGHTY NINE THIRTY.
RIGHT IN TWENTY AB FOR FOUR AND
EIGHTY TWO EXCUSE ITEMS NINE
EIGHTY THIRTEEN EIGHTY SEVEN.
FOUR THE COUNTRY'S EMOTION ON
THE. MOVE BY CENTERS THERE ARE
NO WE WILL CALL THE ROLL CENTER
WIENER BY WIENER HI CHILDREN. I
THE TROUBLED BY CLICKS HERE.
FOR THAT ITEM ON CALL- WE WILL
NOW TRANSCONTINENTAL'S TO COME
UP- TO. PRESENT ITEM. SIXTY
THREE NINETEEN. GOOD AFTERNOON
CHAIR AND MEMBERS PLEASE 2%
EIGHTY THREE NINETEEN TODAY
WHICH CODIFIES IMPORTANT
CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICIES
FOR MOBILE HOME INSPECTORS AS
RECOMMENDED BY THE CALIFORNIA
STATE AUDITOR. IN TWENTY TWENTY
THE STATE AUDITOR RELEASED A
REPORT ON THE DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT FOR EACH CD FINDING
THAT THAT NOT TAKING ADEQUATE
STEPS TO DETERMINE WHETHER
MOBILE HOME PARK INSPECTORS HAD
POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
RELATED TO THE PARKS THAT WERE
RESPONSIBLE FOR INSPECTING. THE
REPORT ALSO FOUND THE DEPARTMENT
HAD NOT PROPERLY REPORTED
CERTAIN COMPLAINTS OF INSPECTOR
MISCONDUCT. AB THREE NINETEEN
REQUIRES EIGHT CD TO ADOPT
STRAIGHTEN CONFLICT OF INTEREST
POLICIES FOR MOBILE HOME PARK
INSPECTORS ESTABLISH A BETTER
SYSTEM TO PROCESS COMPLAINTS AND
EXTENDS A SUNSET ON THE MOBILE
HOME PARK INSPECTION PROGRAM BY
ONE YEAR TERM INSURANCE FACTORS
ARE ALLOWED TO CONTINUE TO
PERFORM HEALTH AND SAFETY
CHECKS. THIS BILL HAS NO
OPPOSITION WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT IS ANDREW GOVERNOR FROM
THE WESTERN MANUFACTURED HOUSING
COMMUNITIES ASSOCIATION. HERE
MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE HE UNDERGO
GOVERNMENT LED BY SOME OF THE
MAY INNS OF THE MEASURE- ATTY A
CON OF INTEREST PROVISION FOR
THE INSPECTORS WE THINK IT'S A
GOOD IDEA- MY WILL JUST NOTE
THAT WE WOULD SUPPORT MORE THAN
ONE YEAR SUNSET. ON THE MOBILE
HOME PROGRAM ESPECIALLY
CONSIDERING THAT OUR PREVIOUS
BILL AB THREE EIGHTEEN WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT A THREE YEAR
SUNSET FOR A BILL THAT HAS AN
AUDIT DUE IN DECEMBER AND YET
WE'RE ONLY EXTENDING A PERMANENT
PROGRAM BY ONE YEAR SO WITH THAT
WE SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU.
IS THERE ANY OTHER- ANYONE ELSE
. OKAY WENT OVER THE PHONE LINES
. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE
IT FOR THOSE WHO WISH TO SPEAK
TO SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. WAY TO GO
TO LINE AT SIXTY NINE YOUR LINE
IS NOW OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON I
NEED A ONE OFF OR WHAT WOULD.
YOU CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. SURE
THERE IS NO ONE OUT TO SIGNALED
THAT THEY WISH TO SPEAK OKAY
THANK YOU OVER AND BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE- ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS COLLEAGUES. OKAY MOTION
BY CENTER IN MY CLOTHES. HELLO
I'M SORRY- CONFUSED BECAUSE HAD
A LITTLE BIT OF OTHER IS THERE
ANY OPPOSITION AND HEARING ROOM
. OKAY VALERIE ABOUT SECURITY
REMOTE MYSELF COURT AS- YOU KNOW
BECAUSE THANK YOU RESPECT ASK
FOR AND I HAVE A- WE WILL CALL
THE ROLL. MOTIONS TO PASS REFER
THE COMMITTEE IN A PER. SENATE
WIENER RIGHT WIENER I THE JOB OF
BY THE CHURCH BY EXPERIENCE
CLICKS YEAR CAREER. CAREER HI
BECAUSE HE BECAUSE HE HI MCGUIRE
IDIA VIDEO HI SIR TO. THIRDS BUY
IN NUMBER. FOUR
TO GO IN A DIFFERENT ORDER CAN I
START WITH AB THIRTEEN NINETEEN.
TWELVE AB THIRTEEN NINETEEN AND
I'M ALSO PRESENTING- AT THE END
OF TWO ASSEMBLY MEMBER OF RACES
BILLS ONE HALF OKAY. A. B. C.
NINETEEN- SB THIRTY NEXT HER
MIGHT OF TO STATE LAW THE BERRY
HOUSE FIND AUTHORITY ALL KNOWN
AS OFTEN. BAFANA'S CRITIC AND-
BY EIGHT BY EIGHTY FOUR TWO SO
TWENTY ALL BY DAVE CHIU FOR I
WAS A PROUD CO AUTHOR. IT WAS
CREATED TO HELP THE BERRY TO
TAKE A REGIONAL PERSPECTIVE TO
REGIONAL PROBLEM WHICH IS OF
COURSE OUR HOUSING AFFORDABILITY
ISSUE SINCE BOTH OF US CREATED
IT HAS HIRED AN EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR AND STAFF DEVELOPED A
BUSINESS PLAN RECEIVED TWENTY
MILLION DOLLARS FROM THE STATE
TO IMPLEMENT PILOT PROGRAMS. AND
BEGIN PREPARATIONS FOR A BALLOT
MEASURE TO RAISE FUNDS TO
SUPPORT THE CREATION. AND
PRESERVATION OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING. BOB IS GOVERNED BY AND
IN A BAG OR THE SPONSORS OF THIS
BILL ALONG WITH AB FOR HOUSING.
AND GETTING BY OF A MORNING DAY
AND IN THE HOW COMMUNITY THAT
THERE WAS A HAND OF PLACES WHERE
THE LAW. LACKED CLARITY IT HOME
CHALLENGING SPORT AND REFLECT
RECENT EVOLUTIONS AND BEST
PRACTICES SUCH AS THE
HOMELESSNESS PREVENTION
TECHNIQUES WE LEARNED DURING THE
PANDEMIC. THE BILL INCLUDES THE
MODIFICATIONS NECESSARY TO
ADDRESSES EXISTING ISSUES SET UP
OFFICE CAN BEST FULFILL ITS
MISSION TO HELP INSURE HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY FOR LOWER INCOME
RESIDENTS IN THE AREA HERE WITH
ME TO TALK IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL IS JULIE SNYDER. THE
PRINCIPLE ADVOCATE FOR NPC IN A
BAG. PLEASE COME FORWARD. GET
OUT MR TURN MA'AM TO SNYDER WITH
TO SEE A BAG- THE BAY AREA
HOUSING FOR AT THE- IS OUR-
ENTITY. IT'S CHARGED WITH TO.
REGION WIDE SO. TO OUR HOUSING
FOR TO. I TELL THAT HAS IMPACT
WHETHER NOT WILL BE ABLE TO MEET
OUR CLIMATE GOALS MOBILITY AND
EQUITY GOALS. AB THIRTEEN
NINETEEN GIVES US ADDITIONAL
TOOLS TO CARRY OUT THE STATE'S
MANDATE HAS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WICKS OUTLINED WERE PREPARING TO
PLACE A TEN TO TWENTY BILLION
DOLLAR HOUSING BOND ON THE
NOVEMBER TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
BALLOT. AND IN ORDER TO MAXIMIZE
THE IMPACT OF THIS FUNDING AB
THIRTEEN NINETY MAKES A SERIES
OF TARGETED MODIFICATIONS- ALL
STOP THEIR ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
ABOUT SPECIFIC PROVISIONS- AND
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH- IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT. FOR AB THIRTEEN
NINETEEN PLEASE COME FORWARD.
SAY YOUR NAME AND YOUR
AFFILIATION. GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS UNDERESTIMATE
AS ON BEHALF OF THE NONPROFIT
HOUSING ASSOCIATION NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA FULL HOME THE CITY OF
HALF MOON BAY FALL IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THE BILL THANK YOU.
HI THERE MARK STIVERS OF THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU. IT IS THE
LEGACY OF CLAIMS ON BEHALF OF
ENTERPRISE COMMUNITY PARTNERS
AND STRONG SUPPORT. GOOD
AFTERNOON SURE NUMBERS JORDAN
CRIMES ON BEHALF OF GREEN BUILT
ALLIANCE IN STRONG SUPPORT. FOR
ANY SUPPORT IN THE HEARING ROOM
. THREE IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION
IN THE HEARING ROOM. SIMILAR TO
THE PHONE LINES. FOR ANYONE WHO
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO PRESS ONE THEN ZERO.
THERE IS NO NEW SIGNALED THAT
THEY WISH TO SPEAK. OKAY WILL
BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
COLLEAGUES IN QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS YEAH CENTER CRITICIZING
. THANKS TO CHAIR IN IN THIS
PERHAPS IS FOR THE WITNESS. THE
FIRST WAS THE YOU WILL THE
BACKGROUND OF THIS AND WE
APPRECIATE AUTHOR BRENE FOR HELP
THE- THE HELPING PAW IN THE- IN
THE COMMISSION THAT'S THIS IS A
BEHIND THE- KEEP ME FORWARD ON
THE- SOME OF PROVISIONS. LAID
OUT IN THE ANALYSIS LIKE HAVE
SWORE ALREADY IN THE- IN THE
AUTHORS A BUT- MAYBE THEIR
SYSTEM. THE THAT- CAUGHT MY EYE
AND IMPOSE FOR NOT HAVING AN
OPPORTUNITY BETWEEN THE BRIEFING
AND NOW TO US THIS QUESTION-
THIS IS LET HIM SIX IN THE
ANALYSIS. ON PAGE SIX SAYS BUS
BUS WAS ABOVE HIS POWERS- I'M
SORRY- PICKED UP THE ITEM HERE
TO. I'M LOOKING FOR THE ITEM IS
BY FOR HIS HERE WE GO SEVEN FIVE
ANNIE POPPED CREATE ONE OR MORE
COME THAN BY CO. HELLO OTHER
WORDS WHICH- THE OF WHICH FALLS
IS THE SOLE MEMBER AN EXERCISE
THE POWER GRANTED. THROUGH THOSE
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANIES
WHOSE BASICALLY ALLOWING-
OFFERED DELEGATE TO AN L. O. C.
THE POWERS IT DOES SAY THAT
BOFFO WOULD BE THE SOLE MAY BUT
IS THERE BEEN. DISCUSSION I AS A
THE COMMISSION I'M I'M MY WORK
IS THAT THE MAGICAL TO
COMMISSIONS IN FACT THE BOARD
FOR BY. IS WITH CAN WITH THE OF
TO THE OF THE L. THAT REALLY MY
ONLY. OR HAVE THEY DISCUSSED
THE- THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION
SENATOR- AND YOU'RE EXACTLY
RIGHT THE M. TO SEE BOARD DOES
SEE IT AS THE BOARD OF THE
BEARING HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY
AND THEN THE ASSOCIATION OF BAY
AREA GOVERNMENTS HAS ADDITIONAL-
GOVERNANCE AUTHORITY OVER
EXPENDITURE PLAN. IN THIS CASE
THE MTC BOARD WOULD STAY AS THE
BOARD THIS PARTICULAR PROVISION
WAS REQUESTED BY A NUMBER OF THE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THAT WE WORK
WITH IT WILL ENABLE US TO ISSUE
REVENUE BONDS. TO FINANCE
MODERATE INCOME APARTMENTS- WITH
THE BONDS REPAID BY RENTS SO
IT'S A TECHNICAL CHANGE FOR THAT
PARTICULAR- TYPE OF- CORPORATION
STRUCTURE- BUT THAT'S THE ONLY.
THE ONLY SPACE IN WHICH WE
ENVISION UTILIZING THAT
AUTHORITY THAT'S AN EXCELLENT
EXPLANATION THANK YOU VERY MUCH
I APPRECIATE THE INFORMATION
THANK MR THANK YOU ANSWER SOME
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS- SEEING
NONE WE HAVE A MOTION IN PLACE
SENATE. FIVE COURTESY- AND IS.
TO SORRY. FOR THAT IS THE PAST
THE BILL TO GOVERNOR AND FINANCE
. YOU MAY CLOSE RESPECT ASPIRIN
I'VE COULD WILL CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR WINNER WINNER HI THE
CHILL THE NEW PHOTOBOOK NO
CLICKS HERE THANK CLICKS THERE I
.
LET'S GO TO EIGHTY FOUR FORTY
OKAY THIS ITEM ELEVEN EIGHTY
FOUR FORTY YOU MAY PROCEED THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR LAST YEAR I
CARRIED A B. TWO THREE THREE
FOUR WHICH CHANGE THE DEFINITION
MACKSON DENSITY OR BASIN. INDO
AND DENSITY BONUS LAW TO MAKE
CLEAR THE MAXIMUM DENSITY IS
CALCULATED BASED ON THE GREATEST
AND SEE ANY OF THE UNDERLYING IS
ON DOCUMENTS THE ZONING
ORDINANCE THE LAND USE ELEMENT
OF THE GENERAL PLAN OR A
SPECIFIC PLAN. WHEN AMENDING THE
DEFINITION WE LEFT IN A SENTENCE
THAT SAYS IF THERE IS
INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN THE LAND
USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN
AND A SPECIFIC PLAN THE GREATER
DENSITY OF THE TWO PREVAILS.
THAT IS PRETTY CONFUSION BECAUSE
IT IS- IS MORE SPECIFIC THAN THE
PRIOR SENTENCE THIS BILL
CORRECTS THAT CONFUSION
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
AND MARIA ONE IS HERE TO ANSWER
ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS SHOULD
WE HAVE ANY. OKAY FIGURE FOR
QUITE SERVICE I CAN SPEAK TO.
WHATEVER YOU LIKE. YOU KNOW WHAT
THE HELL. IN SEARCH AND WE WERE
A SPONSOR TWENTY THREE THEY FOUR
IN THIS IS REAL. QUITE MINOR A
BILL TO CLEAR A SOME OF THE CAN
THAT HAS ARISEN. IN PRACTICE OF
THE DEAF. I REALIZE YEAR HAPPY
ANSWER. AND- DRY- TODAY YOU. ANY
EFFECT ANY ADDITIONAL IN THE
ROOM. OKAY SAY NOT AS ANY OTHER
IN THE- PRETTY SUPPORTER OF
OFFICE. PLEASE COME FORWARD.
THANK YOU MICHAEL GETTING HOUSE
PUBLIC AFFAIRS SINCE THE ON
BEHALF OF CIVIC WELL THANK YOU.
AND IT IS THE MOST. ANY IN THE
HEARING. PLEASE COME FORWARD.
OKAY OVER THE PHONE LINES. THANK
CHAIR FOR THOSE IS SUPPORTER UPS
PLEASE PRESS ONE THE NEW ZERO
PRESS. ONE ZERO. MISTER NO ONE
IS SIGNALED THEY WISH SPEAK.
OKAY WE'LL BRING BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS ARE.
CENTER BIKES FOR THANK YOU I
THOUGHT YOUR PREVIOUS BILL. THE
REP ANY OTHER PROBLEM I WAS A TO
SEE THAT THIS CREATED A MORE
INTO- I'M HAPPY TO SERVE IT AND
I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WANT TO GIVE
A LITTLE BIT MORE. OF HOW THE
CREATED THE ABOUT WAS I WASN'T
CLEAR ON THAT SURE I MEAN MARIE
MARIE MY MEAL TO GO A BETTER
BECAUSE SHE'S A- MORE OF A
PRACTITIONER IN THE SPACE-
BECAME ISSUER EACH THE WAS
PROVIDE TECHNICAL. AND
PARTICULAR IN BECAUSE THERE WAS
OF A DEAL IT ROUGHER OF GRAY IT
CAN A BIT TOURNEY'S WHICH- ABOUT
THE PRIOR SO THAT WERE KEEP IN
WAS THEY DID. CENTER OR IF IT
WAS THE GREATER THE AND IT'S IN
THE SECOND SENTENCE. AND IT WAS
THE TOURNEY'S WERE LIKE A
LEANING TOWARDS THE LESSER OF
THE GREATER AND WE WANT TO
CLARIFY THAT IS THE CREATOR OF
THE GREATER. OKAY WITH THAT I
WILL. RETURN. SOME OF THE STUFF
. THANK YOU. OKAY- MOTION BY SIR
PLACE ANY OTHER OR- OKAY- SEEING
THAT- YOU MAY CLOSE. RESPECT
FASTER AND I'VE THAT WILL THE
ROLL. THE MOTION IS TO PASS
SENATOR WIENER. WIENER HI THE
TROUBLE BY FLETCHER BOTH BY
CLICK BEER. PLACE CARO. CARRERO
HI COURTESY. COURTESY BY MCGUIRE
VIDEA. VIDEA ICE TO. SETTLE NOW
SKINNER I'M BURKE BOB.
WHICH WOULD PLACE A TEN BILLION
DOLLAR HOUSING BOND ON THE MARCH
FIFTEENTH TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
PRIMARY BALLOT TO FUND
PRODUCTION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
IN SUPPORT OF HOUSING- I THINK
WE ALL KNOW AND ALL CAN AGREE
THAT THE NEED FOR MORE MONEY FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS CRITICAL
WE ARE DUE TO RUN OUT OF OUR
FUNDS BY THE END OF NEXT YEAR OF
OUR PREVIOUS BOND MONIES- THE
BOND THAT WAS- VOTER ON IN
TWENTY EIGHTEEN SO THIS WILL
HOPEFULLY HELP. BACKFILL IN MY
OPINION THIS IS A SMALL PIECE OF
A LARGER PROBLEM OF FIGURING OUT
SUSTAIN ONGOING FUNDING FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING I WHICH I
THINK WE HAVEN'T FULLY COMMITTED
TO AS A BODY YET WHICH I THINK
WE SHOULD- SO THIS IS A STEP IN
THE RIGHT DIRECTION I'M ALSO
COGNIZANT OF AND RECOGNIZE THE
FACT THAT THERE ARE OTHER- ABOUT
MEASURES OUT THERE THE
GOVERNOR'S OBVIOUSLY- PART OF
THAT CONVERSATION AS ARE SOME OF
MY COLLEAGUES AND- I WILL SCAN.
OBVIOUSLY WORK WITH THEM TO
ENSURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE A
MULTI HOUSING BOND BALLOT
SITUATION ON EITHER THE MARCH OR
NOVEMBER BALLOTS BUT ENSURE THAT
WE ARE- TO FEELING WHAT I VIEW
AS OUR MORAL OBLIGATION TO FUND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AND WITH THAT WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
I ALSO MARINO WENT HERE. AS OUR
PRIMARY WITNESS TO ALSO DISCUSS
THE NEED FOR THIS MEASURE. YOU
MAY PROCEED THANK YOU WERE YOU
KNOW WHITE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING CONSORTIUM- THIS BILL
COMES AT A REALLY CRUCIAL TIME
FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTER CYCLICAL INVESTMENT IN
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. IS READY IN
MOST IMPORTANT WAYS THAT WE CAN
CLOSE THAT HOUSING SO
AFFORDABLE. SUPPLY GAP- BECAUSE
IT ALLOWS AFFORDABLE DEVELOPERS
TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF LOWER COSTS
AND TO KEEP THE CONSTRUCTION
WORKFORCE EMPLOYED AS MARKET
RATE DEVELOPMENT SLOWS-
ADDITIONALLY AS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WICKS MENTIONED- WE ARE ABOUT TO
RUN OUT. OF ALL OF THE BOND
FUNDS ARE AUTHORIZED IN TWENTY
EIGHTEEN- WHILE WE ARE CURRENTLY
HAVING. AN OVER SUBSCRIPTION AT
THE FOR A STATE HOUSING
DEPARTMENT FUNDS OF FOUR TO ONE
IN PARTICULAR FOR THE MULTI
FAMILY HOUSING PROGRAM WHICH THE
MAJORITY OF THESE BONDS ARE BE
DESIGNATED TO. ARE
OVERSUBSCRIBED TEN TO ONE- IN
THIS MOMENT TODAY WE HAVE OVER
FIFTY THOUSAND UNITS THAT ARE
CHAU. READY AND UP FOR. IN
ENTERED AWAITING. AND THAT'S WHY
THIS IS SO A CRITICAL MEASURE
AND I URGE YOUR SUPPORT TODAY
THANK YOU. FIVE THANK YOU
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PLEASE COME
FORWARD AND SAY YOUR NAME AND
AFFILIATION IF ANY. THAT MARKS
DIVERSE OF THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AND I WILL
DECIDE ONE BRIEF COMMENT WHICH
IS THAT. IN ORDER TO DRAW DOWN
THE MAX AMOUNT OF FEDERAL LOW
INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDITS WE
NEED THOSE STATE FUNDS TO FILL
IN THE FINANCING GAPS AND IF. HE
TO THE PROGRAMS THAT WE RELY ON
TO DO THAT HAVE NO LONGER HAVE
FUNDING. WILL ACTUALLY THEN LOSE
ACCESS TO A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT
OF FEDERAL RESOURCES AS WELL SO
WE PERJURE SUPPORT THANK. SIXTY
YOUR- TWO WEEKS LATER WITH THEM
TO SEE A- AND PARK THANK YOU.
FOR GOOD AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN
OF THE CEILING OF CARING. ON
BEHALF OF ENTERPRISE. PARTNERS
SINCE A- SIX FIGURE BUT AFTER
THAT THE KIDS ARE SHOT YOU INTO
MALLS ARE LAYING HERE BEHALF OF
THE- OF THE- HILLS. AND WEST. AS
WELL THE CALIFORNIA FACT IS. AND
THANK. AMY BROWN ON BEHALF OF
THE CITY OF- IN SUPPORT.
JONATHAN BAFT CITY EVEN NEED US
IN SUPPORT. I THINK THE GUSTY ON
BACK OF WESTERN CENTER ON LAW
POWER IN SUPPORT. STEVE SENSOR
WITH BROWN'S ON BEHALF OF THE
HOUSING ACTION CO. AND HOUSING.
AND SO. UNDERESTIMATE AS ON
BEHALF OF ALL OF THEM AS WELL AS
THE CITIES OF FREMONT CONCORD
AND SOLEDAD AND SUPPORT. ABRAM
DS WITH THE NONPROFIT HOUSING
ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT. MOREOVER
BARKER WITH THE GREEN LINING
INSTITUTE IN STRONG SUPPORT- SO
TEARS HIGHS ON BEHALF OF THE
GREEN LINE IS TO CHOOSE FROM
SUPPORT. BUT IN ANY EVENT IS
ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE GREEN
LENDING INSTITUTIONS STRONG
SUPPORT. CENTRIC BROWN ALSO ON
BEHALF OF THE GREEN LIGHTING
INSTITUTE IN STRONG SUPPORT.
JORDAN CRIMES ON BEHALF OF
GREENBELT ALLIANCE IN STRONG
SUPPORT. MICH MICHIGAN ON BEHALF
OF SERVICE BECAUSE INTEL
INCORPORATION AND SPORTS.
HOWEVER WE NEED TO THIS IS WHAT
HAS PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF
THE UNITED WAY OF GREATER LOS
ANGELES IN SUPPORT AND HABITAT
FOR HUMANITY CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT BECAUSE OF THE INCLUSION
OF HOMEOWNERSHIP AND NOT JUST
RENTAL HOUSING THANK YOU.
DIGITAL SUPPORT FOR AB. SIXTEEN
FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE COME FORWARD
. OKAY WHEN I MOVED OPPOSITION
IF THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION AB
SIXTEEN FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE COME
FORWARD. SEEING WILL GO TO THE
PHONE. FOR THOSE WHO WISH TO
CONSERVE OR- TO THIS BILL PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO. WE'RE GOING TO NOW GO
TO LINE FIFTY EIGHT LINE FIFTY
EIGHT YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
AFTERNOON MISTER KAREN MEMBERS
WARRANTY OLYMPIA REPRESENTING
THE AMERICAN PLANNING.
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
NOW GO TO LINE FORTY SEVEN LINE
FORTY SEVEN YOUR LINE IS NOW
OPEN. SURE IMAGINE SECOND THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS WE ARE AN OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED POSITION BEGIN TO EXEMPT
ACQUISITION OF ONE BEFORE
HOUSING- AND ESPECIALLY REQUEST
THAT CONSIDERATION OF THE NUMBER
FOR THE MOST PART THANK YOU. TO
FIND SEVEN TWO YOUR LAW IS NOW-
OPEN. AND ARE NOT THAT A
CALIFORNIA CREDIT YOUR NETWORK
ALL ENDED CANNON OF WHITE. SO
FIND SEVEN ONE. AFTERNOON CARRY
TURNS ON THE ON THE OF THE
LEAGUE CAL CITIES AND THE POOR.
MISTER CHAIR THE IS NO ELSE OKAY
WILL BE BACK TO COMMITTEE
COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
CENTER PLAY HERE THANK YOU I
THINK THIS IS A REALLY WELL DRAW
. AFFORDABLE HOUSING BOND AND
JUST TO RECOGNIZE THAT THE FIVE
POINT TWO FIVE BILL FOR THE
MULTI HOUSING PROGRAM REALLY
CRITICAL- AS WELL AS THE SUPPORT
OF HOUSING ADMINISTERED FOR
THROUGH THE M. H. P. ONE POINT
FIVE BILLION FOR AFFORDABLE
PRESERVATION AND REHABILITATION
ONE BILLION TO CAL HOME AND MY
HOME DOWN PAYMENT ASSISTANCE
PROGRAMS FIVE HUNDRED MILLION
FOR FARMWORKER HOUSING. ALL OF
THAT STRIKES THE RIGHT BALANCE
FROM MY PERSPECTIVE OF THE
PROBLEMS THAT WE'RE FACING IN
CALIFORNIA WHEN IT COMES TO
REALLY ENDING OUR HOMELESSNESS
PROBLEM- AND WE KNOW THAT WE ARE
NOT SEEING FIVE FEEL WE ARE NOT
SEEING THE SUFFICIENT POLITICAL
OR SOCIETAL WILL. TO FINANCE
THAT AT THE EFFORT THAT IS
NEEDED AND SO HAVING THIS TYPE
OF A BOND IS JUST REALLY
CRITICAL RIGHT NOW SO I'M I'M-
AND HIS YESTERDAY SUPPORTER AND
I HOPE THAT IT'S. ABLE TO MAKE
IT ALL THE WAY THANK YOU. OKAY
SEEING. OUR MOTION BY SO FOR THE
I JUST WANNA COME ON A THANK YOU
FOR GIVING US FOR IMPROPER CALL
. OF THE- WE NEED A MUCH GREATER
GOVERNMENT INVESTMENTS AND
HOUSING TO COMPLEMENT. A PRIVATE
SECTOR INVESTMENT- AND THIS WILL
HELP US MOVE IN THAT DIRECTION I
DO MAKE TWO COMMENTS AND I KNOW
YOU AND I ARE LINES ON THIS BUT
I WILL SAY THIS BECAUSE- THERE
ARE- HELLO. IT YOU WILL NOTICE
THAT THERE WAS LIKE A S. NO
OPPOSITE WAS THE- HAVE A
SPECIFIC PARTIAL CAN BUT THERE
OPPOSED TO THE BOND A WHOLE. AND
THERE'S NO JUST LIKE GENERAL
OPPOSITION. FROM AND A LOT THERE
ARE A LOT OF CITIES GROUPS THAT.
ARE EXCITED- HAVING MORE MONEY
BUT THERE ARE NOT AS EXCITED
ABOUT ACTUALLY MAKING IT EASIER
AND LESS EXPENSIVE TO BUILD
HOUSING- AS WE INVEST MORE-
PUBLIC MONEY AND HOUSING. WE
NEED TO BE. MORE EFFICIENT IN
HOW WE DELIVER ABOUT HOUSING AND
A TWO WAY WAY TOO EXPENSIVE. TO
BUILD IN SOME OF THOSE SOME OF
THE FACTORS ARE MARKET
CONDITIONS BEYOND OUR CONTROL WE
CAN'T ALWAYS CONTROL THE SUPPLY
CHAIN OR THE COST OF.
CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS- BUT WE
CAN CONTROL THE OBSCENE- IMPACTS
. SOME INCLUDING MY OWN CITY OF
SEVERANCE- ALREADY PLACE ON NEW
HOUSING FRANCISCO I THINK IT'S-
TWO HUNDRED. DOLLARS A YEAR.
REASONS TO COULD THOUSAND
DOLLARS PER. UNIT IN AN EXAM.
ALMOST. HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
. TRUST AN EXACT POSITIVE
SEPARATIST AND THERE ARE OTHER
CITY THAT TO THIS AS WELL
WITHOUT REYES. PARK FEES OR
OTHER- IF USERS THAT YOU KNOW TO
IT REALLY REALLY. FOR MARKET
RATE- AND ALL FOR HOUSING ALL OF
THE FEES OF- FOR HOUSING BUT A
BUNCH THEM TO- WE ALSO MADE IT
WAIT LOW AND ARDUOUS AND
UNPREDICTABLE TO BUILD. A
HOUSING AND SO WE'VE BEEN DOING
OBVIOUSLY A LOT OF WORK AND THE
AUTHOR HAS CERTAINLY BEEN A
LEADER IN THAT REALM. AS WELL-
TO TRY TO MAKE IT FASTER IF
WE'RE GONNA PUT THIS PUBLIC
MONEY AND IN NEW AFFORDABLE
HOUSING WE SHOULD IT SHOULD BE
APPROVED IN A MATTER OF MONTHS.
NOT YEARS MONTHS AND THAT MEANS
SOME OF THE SUPPORTERS OF THE
BILL TODAY YOU ARE NOT ALWAYS A
LINES WITHOUT ACCELERATION OF
PERMITTING I HOPE WE'LL
REEVALUATE AND NOT TO SUPPORT
THE MONEY BUT ALSO SUPPORT.
EFFICIENT EFFICIENTLY
IMPLEMENTING THAT MONEY SO WE'RE
BUILDING THE HOUSING QUICKLY
GETTING PEOPLE OFF THE STREETS
STABILIZING PEOPLE WHO WERE RISK
OF BECOMING HOMELESS US. COMING
HOMELESS- AND IT'S A COMPLETE
PACKAGE BUT WITHOUT SAID- I
THANK YOU FOR DOING THIS AND YOU
MAY CLOSE- THANK YOU. MISTER
CHAIR AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU
SAID I THINK THE WAY I THINK
ABOUT IT IS TO DO EVERYTHING WE
CAN TO CREATE A STREAMLINED
ENVIRONMENT TO MAKE IT EASIER
AND QUICKER TO BUILD HOUSING
THAT WE YOU KNOW WE NEED. THAT
INCLUDES THE FEES IT INCLUDES-
HOW DEVELOPERS ACCESS THESE
FUNDS. ON MAKING IT A
STREAMLINED PROCESS STREAMLINING
THE SEQUEL REFORMS THAT YOU KNOW
WE NEED TO DO ALL OF THE ABOVE.
THAT'S THAT IS A BIG BUCKET OF
WORKS OF THE LEGISLATURE IN PART
T. BIG PARTIR LEADERSHIP HAS
BEEN WORKING ON OVER THE LAST
SAY SIX OR SEVEN YEARS AND I
THINK WE'VE ACHIEVED A LOT WITH
THERE'S MORE TO DO AND TOWARDS
THAT AND- THEN THE- OTHER PIECE.
TO YOUR POINT IS THAT WE HAVE TO
INVEST RIGHT WE HAVE TO MAKE
SURE THAT WE'RE DOING BOTH OF
THOSE THINGS AND FRANKLY THE
SPOT IS IMPORTANT. BUT IT IT'S A
FRACTION OF WHAT WE NEED TO
ACTUALLY BE INVESTING FOR REALLY
GOING TO GET OUT OF THIS SUMMER
AND HAVE REAL STRUCTURAL CHANGE.
ON SOLVING THE HOMELESSNESS
CRISIS THAT PLAGUES OUR
COMMUNITIES IT'S SIGNIFICANT
INVESTMENTS COUPLED WITH THE
STREAMLINING IN THE BILL IS
FILLED MORE QUICKLY. I KNOW
THAT'S WHAT I'M COMMITTED TO AN
END I THINK EVERYONE HERE ON IN
THIS COMMITTEE IS AS WELL SO
HAPPY TO WORK IN PARTNERSHIP
TOWARDS THAT END IN RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. WE HAVE A MOTION BY
CENTER COULD BE- AND WE WILL
CALL THE ROLL. MOTIONS TO. AND
RIVER. TO COMMITTEE GOVERNMENTS
AND FINANCE. FREDERATOR CLEANER
HI. THE TWO. OF BLIX. CLICK
SPIRIT BY. CARREIRO. CARRERO HI
PARTISI. COULD I. VIDEO INDIA HI
THERE TO. SKINNER NUMBER. BOB
BOB I. SIX ZERO. THREE SIX ZERO.
THAT BILL. ON AND THEN I KNOW.
YOU'LL BE. ITEM NUMBER TWO. SIX
TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN. FIRST
MEMBER. YES PRESENTING ON BEHALF
OF. THE MEMBER. RESTO MAY NOT BE
THE- ON THE- BILL AND THE WAY
THAT HE- BUT I'M IN. GIVEN MY-
SHOT- IT THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING
ME TO PRESENT HIS BILL- AB
TWELVE SEVEN AB TOLD IT SEVEN
RICK A COUNTY OR AND COUNTY TO
GRANTED DONE. AND CAN IF AN
APPLE. AGREES TO INCLUDED MODEL
INCOME UNITS ON TOP OF THE-
AMOUNT UNITS FOR. LOW VERY LOW
OR MY INCOME. WE ALL OF THE COST
OF IS EGGS ARE CAL. INDEED TO IT
BEING CHARGING FOR VERY LOW
INCOME IN LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
IT'S ALSO FOR OUR MIDDLE IN.
FAMILIES AS WELL THE COST BURDEN
HAS CONTINUED TO GROW AS WE HAVE
FAILED TO BUILD ENOUGH MIDDLE
INCOME HOUSING UNITS TO REDUCE
PRICES AND RELEASE PRESSURE ON
THE OVERALL HOUSING MARKET BY
GIVING DEVELOPERS AN ADDITIONAL
INCENTIVE UNDER DENSITY BONUS
LAW TO BUILD MORE MODERATE
INCOME UNITS. AB TWELVE EIGHTY
SEVEN IS A CRITICAL STEP TOWARDS
PROVIDING RELIEF AS NOTED I
FIRMLY BELIEVE IN SUPPORTING THE
DEVELOPMENT OF VERY LOW AND LOW
INCOME HOUSING WHICH IS WHY-
MISTER ALVAREZ WROTE THE BILL.
SO THAT EXISTING INCENTIVES MUST
BE MAXED OUT BEFORE YOU CAN TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THIS NEW ONE AND
HAVE ADDED AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD
INCLUDE AN ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE
FOR VERY LOW INCOME UNITS
THEREFORE A. TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN
NOT ONLY INCENTIVIZES THE
CREATION OF MODERATE INCOME
UNITS. BUT ALSO CREATES NEW
ECONOMIC REASONS TO MAXIMIZE
DEEPLY AFFORDABLE UNITS
PRODUCTION- APPRECIATE YOU ALL-
HEARING ON THIS BILL TODAY
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE. AND HERE TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IS COLIN
PARENT EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR. OF
CIRCULATE SAN DIEGO. AND GRAMMY
CORTEZ FOR MIAMI URBAN SELL.
URBAN ITSELF. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH- GOOD AFTERNOON- MISTER
CHAIR. AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS COLIN
TERRENCE I'M THE VICE MAYOR OF
THE CITY OF MESA- WHICH IS IN
THE THIRTY NINTH SENATE DISTRICT
FOR REFERENCE IN THE SEVEN NINE.
ASSEMBLY DISTRICT I AM ALSO THE
CEO AND GENERAL COUNSEL OF THE
NONPROFIT CALLED CIRCULATE SAN
DIEGO WE'RE ONE OF THE CO
SPONSORS OF THIS BILL- AND AS-
YOU KNOW. AS AS WAS BEEN
MENTIONED PERHAPS A FEW TIMES-
IN THIS COMMITTEE WE HAVE A-
HOUSING CRISIS- IN CALIFORNIA.
DEFINITELY- THE SEVERE SHORTAGE
OF VERY LOW INCOME HOMES. AS
WELL AS A SHORTAGE OF MODERATE
INCOME HOMES. THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE STATE DENSITY
BONUS LAW- WE ACTUALLY CIRCULATE
WAS ONE OF THE CO SPONSORS OF
THE- ONE OF THE ENHANCEMENTS IN
TWENTY TWENTY TO GET TO A 50%
BONUS- MY ORGANIZATION CIRCULATE
SAN DIEGO PUBLISHED RESEARCH- A
FEW YEARS AGO. SHOWING IT'S
REALLY WORKING GREAT LIKE IT'S
PRODUCING ALL SORTS OF A VERY
LONG COMMUNITIES AND THAT'S WHAT
AND THAT'S TERRIFIC- AND WHAT
THIS PART WITH THIS BILL DOES IS
IT SAYS THAT IF YOU MAXIMIZE OUT
THE AFFORDABLE PRODUCTION END
AND SEE BONUS. AND YOU CHOOSE TO
BUILD ADDITIONAL UNITS THAT ARE
DEED RESTRICTED AT MODERATE
INCOME THEN YOU CAN GET AN
ADDITIONAL BONUS SO IT TAKES
INTO ACCOUNT BOTH THE NEED FOR
BOTH AFFORDABLE FOR BOTH VERY
LOW INCOME AND MODERATE HOMES.
AND ALSO TAKES INTO ACCOUNT THAT
THE- THE THAT WE NEED TO MAKE TO
PRIORITIZE THE BURIAL DELIVERY
LOW INCOME THEY'RE THE MOST
SEVERELY. RENT BURDENED AND
MAKING SURE THAT THE- THE
EXISTING POLICIES ARE MAXING OUT
PRODUCTION UP FRONT. AND SO
THAT'S WHAT STRIKES THAT RIGHT
BALANCE AND MAKE SURE THAT WE
CAN HAVE A REAL WIN WIN SO- WE
REALLY APPRECIATE. YOUR
CONSIDERATION. THIS BILL AND
REQUESTED I THOUGHT. THANK YOU
OUR NEXT SPEAKER. INSTEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON MY IS RAINY. NUMBER
DEVELOPER INSANE. AND BUILDER
TRANSIT ORIENTED HOUSING- WE
FIND OURSELVES NOT ONLY A
HOUSING CRISIS BUT HUMANITARIAN
CRISIS. HAS THE NUMBER ON HOUSE
NEIGHBORS CONTINUES TO RISE DUE
TO OUR INABILITY TO CREATE
HOUSING AT ALL INCOME LEVELS.
I'M HERE SUPPORTING AB TWELVE
EIGHTY SEVEN. THE MIDDLE INCOME
BONUS PROGRAM BECAUSE IT'LL HELP
BUILD MUCH NEEDED HOUSING ACROSS
OUR STATE. WITHOUT WITHOUT
DENSITY BONUS INCENTIVE PROGRAMS
THAT ALLOW FOR BY RIGHT
DEVELOPMENT. NONE OF MY PROJECTS
WOULD BE FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE.
THAT DOESN'T MEAN A SMALLER
PROJECT WITH LESS HOMES. THAT
MEANS NO PROJECT BUILT ZERO
HOMES. 90% OF ALL HOUSING ACROSS
THE STATE IS BUILT BY THE
PRIVATE SECTOR. BUT ONLY 10% OF
HOUSING BILL WITH HIS BILL WITH
GOVERNMENT FINANCIAL SUBSIDY.
THAT'S ONE SET OF BASE HOUSING
PROGRAMS THAT SUPPORT MIXED
INCOME PROJECTS WITHOUT RELYING
ON PUBLIC SUBSIDY ARE SO
IMPORTANT. THE CURRENT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DENSITY BONUS
PROGRAM INCENTIVIZES VERY LOW
INCOME HOUSING BUT NOT MIDDLE
INCOME HOUSING. EVEN IN THE CITY
OF SAN DIEGO WHICH HAS MADE
STRIDES IN HOUSING POLICY IN
PRODUCTION IN OUR FIFTH ARENA
CYCLE THAT ENDED IN TWENTY
TWENTY. THERE WERE ONLY THIRTY
SEVEN MODERATE HOMES BUILT OF
THE FIFTEEN THOUSAND FOUR
HUNDRED AND SIXTY TWO MODERN
HOMES TARGETED. THIS IS LESS
THAN ONE QUARTER OF 1% OF THE
RENEWAL. THIS BILL WITH THE
MIDDLE INCOME HOUSE IN PRAGUE I
DO WHERE WE IT MOST. ALONG
TRANSIT AND JOHN CENTERS THANK
YOU. THANK YOU I NEED TO SUPPORT
. OTHER COMMON. PLEASE COME
FORWARD. THANK YOU PLEASE COME
FOR. THE NEW FOR FIELD COMPANY
THAT'S HOWARD ON IN JUNE AND-
HOWEVER MANY DAYS IS A
LIGHTHOUSE AFFAIRS BEHALF FOR.
THE FOOTBALL- HERE HOW
COMMISSION THAN TO HELP PROP ON
. SHARE MEMBERS OF THE SILICON
JORDAN BUT I A COUPLE ON BEHALF
A CALL FOR BE SUPPORT THANK YOU
. JORDAN CRIMES ON BEHALF OF
GREENBELT ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. ANY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENTS SAYING
NINE IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION.
PLEASE COME FORWARD. GOOD
AFTERNOON LIZZIE COULD SIGN ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY
HILLS AND RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION
APOLOGIES FOR MISSING MISSING
THE LETTER SUBMISSION DEADLINE
THANK YOU. PEDRETTI ADDITIONAL
OPPOSITION. OKAY OVER THE PHONE
LINES. THOSE WHO WISH TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME
. GOING TO GO TO LINE SEVENTY
THREE CELL LINES NOW OPEN. GOOD
AFTERNOON MR LEWIS MARIN CAN BE
HALF THE DAY AREA COUNCIL HERE
AND SUPPORT ATLANTICO THERE'S
THANK YOU. THERE IS NO ONE ELSE
. OKAY WE'RE BACK TO COMMITTEE
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. OKAY GREAT. YES
CABALLERO. COULD YOU TELL VERY
BRIEFLY IN A- I DIDN'T TAKE OUT
. HI FIFTY BILLS THREE LESS
NIGHT SO I'M I. THE COASTAL ACT
CAN YOU TELL ABOUT THE COSTA ACT
AND IT RELATES TO THIS BILL
BECAUSE THOUGHT THIS WHICH ISN'T
BY AND THEN OBVIOUSLY THAT NIGHT
BECAUSE ACTED- RED FLAG GO. YET
I CAN GO SAID BE BUT BELIEVE THE
MAY PROVISIONS RELATED CO
LECTERN FROM THE BILL. I'M SORRY
I BELIEVE THAT FOR TO CO ACTOR
MOVED FROM THE REMAIN OKAY SAID
. SOLVE MY ISSUE OKAY WELL I ONE
I COME TO SORT OF CALL ON THAT
BECAUSE IT'S OF ON THE- I DON'T
HONEST WITH YOU I NOT AGREE WITH
THE REASON VERSION OF THE BILL
WHICH IS AN- VERSION WHICH- I
WISH AMERICANS THE OFF MISTER.
FOR BRING THE VERSION OF THIS
BILL FOR. AND I WISH THAT THE
ORIGINAL. WORKING WORK WERE IN
THE SIGHTS COMMITTEE- I DO NOT
AGREE RESPECT- WITH THE- AND
MEN'S THAT WERE. THE COMMITTEE
AND THIS NOT SO RESOURCE I'M NOT
TO CREATE A HEALTH ISSUE YOU
KNOW IT'S TO STIR ALLEN
COMMITTEE- AND I'M ALL OF NO
INTEREST I RE I CAN AND I JUST
HAVE A RESPECT- DISICK. THE
ORIGINAL VERSION OF THIS BILL.
PART OF WHAT IT DID- WHAT TO OUR
- MAKE CLEAR THAT THE- STATE
DENSITY LAW ACTUALLY APPLY. YEAH
IN THE COAST ZONE BECAUSE RIGHT
NOW UNDER. LAWS IT AFFECTS. DOES
NOT APPLY ARE VERY MINIMAL-
APPLY TO COSTA LACKED- IF- THE
TIME BONE LAW- IN FACT- AND WE
KNOW. THE COSTA ZONE- IS WHITER
AND HIGHER AND- THING CAL. AS A
WHOLE. I JUST DO NOT AGREE AT
FIVE. DISAGREE WITH I'VE TALKED
TO EXAM- THE COASTAL SO. FROM
VARIOUS. KILLER STATE HOUSING
LAW. TO VERY VERY AND I- AND-
THE COASTAL COMMISSION DOES A
LOT OF GOOD WORK. AND I RESPECT
THE CAN ON A LOT OF ITS- I THINK
THE CONS PUSH. AGAINST APPLYING
STATE HOUSING LAWS TO THE
COASTAL ZONE IS WRONG AND I WISH
TO THE COASTAL COMMISSION. WOULD
TAKE A DIFFERENT APPROACH IN
MARIN CONVERSATION RIGHT NOW. I
WANTED TO BILL WITH THE COASTAL
CAN- AND SO- I THINK THAT THIS
IS AN AREA AND NEED OF-
SIGNIFICANT DISCUSSION AND I
HOPE THAT GOING FORWARD NOT IN
THIS BILL THAT NEXT YEAR- THE
TITLE- HAPPEN ON A BROADER
LEVEL- BUT THAT'S- MY
UNDERSTANDING WHAT HAPPENED HERE
- SHEET THE DECK. BECAUSE IF THE
IF IN SOME WAY IT WAS COMMITTEE-
EXEMPTED- I JUST WANTED TO.
CHANGE MY OPINION ON THE BILL
BECAUSE OF THE COASTAL
COMMISSION HAS BEEN VERY- WELL
PASSED BECAUSE OF COASTAL
COMMISSION BECAUSE I'VE HAD
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE MORE
RECENTLY. AND I THINK THEY'RE
INTERESTED IN CHANGING A LITTLE
BIT OF HOW THEY'VE VIEW
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ALONG THE
COASTAL ZONE BUT UP BUT THERE
BEEN TOO MANY INSTANCES WHERE
THEY'VE INTERFERED WITH- THE
DEVELOPMENT OF FARMWORKER
HOUSING IN FARMWORKERS COMMUNITY
SAID COULD MOVE INTO THE COASTAL
REGION AND- I JUST WANTED TO
MAKE SURE WE ARE DOING THIS IN
THIS BILL. AND THAT I HAD MISSED
IT SO I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU JUST
SAID MISTER CHAIR AND I AGREE
WITH YOU A 100% THANK YOU THANK
YOU FOR YOUR CURRENT THIS BILL.
AS AMENDED ASSEMBLY KEEPS THE
STATUS QUO IN TERMS OF THE
COASTAL ZONE- YEAH IN TWENTY
TWENTY ONE THE SENATE. WHEN THE
PRO TIME CAN BE IN THE WORKING
GROUP. OF OF CENTERS ACROSS THE
SPECTRUM IN TERMS OF USE ON
HOUSING- IT WAS ACTUALLY AFTER
SB FIFTY FAILED IN THE
SPRINGTIME CONVENED A DIVERSE
WORKING GROUP. ONE OF THE
PRINCIPLES THAT CAME OUT OF THAT
WORKING GROUP WAS NOT TO EXEMPT
THE COASTAL ZONE. FOR EXIT
HOUSING LAWS BECAUSE IT IS
HIGHLY HIGHLY INEQUITABLE- SO-
AGAIN I WILL SAY NO HE'S NOT
HERE BUT THANK THE AUTHOR FOR AT
LEAST TRYING. TO SAY THE DENSITY
BONUS LAW SHOULD APPLY. IN THE
COASTAL ZONE AND- HOPE SPRINGS
ETERNAL FOR THE FUTURE- ARE
THERE. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. OKAY YOU MAY CLOSE
JUST ON BEHALF OF A- L. RESEARCH
HAS ANSWERED I VOTE AND PER. I
ALSO WITH THE SAN SIX HER. OKAY
THAT IS- SOLUTION. WE DO HAVE A
LARGE. FOR THESE ARE THE SOME.
MOISTURIZER COURTESY. AND THAT
IS. TWO PATHS TO COVER- FINE.
SOMEONE CALLED THE. SENATOR
WIENER. WIENER HI THE TROUBLED.
FLICKS PLEASE VERIFY SEVERAL.
CABRERO THANK YOU TO HE- BECAUSE
HE- MCGUIRE. VIDEO.
THE STOCKS FOR SOME QUIRK-SILVA
. THERMOS BURNABY- FILER. YEAH
YEAH. SO YOU. SIX ZERO FORTY.
THANK YOU- QUIRK-SILVA- AB THREE
FOUR SIX. COULD HAVE MR CHAIR
AND MEMBER OF THE- WITH
GOVERNOR'S APPROVAL OF A THREE
ZERO OR AB ONESIE ONE OF TWO
NINE THE STATE BUDGET AND IT'S
AN IN THE LOW INCOME HOUSING.
CREDIT PROGRAM BY FIVE HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS PER YEAR AB
THREE FORTY SIX PROVIDES A
BIGGER BANG FOR THE BUCK AND
HELPS MAXIMIZE OUR PRODUCTION OF
AFFORDABLE HOMES BY ALLOWING THE
TAX CREDIT ALLOCATION COMMITTEE
TO PREPARE THE STATE TAX CREDITS
WITH EITHER A 4% NINE PERCENT.
FEDERAL TAX CORP CREDIT AS
CONDITIONS BEST DICTATE AND
TWENTY NINETEEN CALIFORNIA
PAIRED THE STATE CREDITS WITH
FOUR PER CENT FEDERAL CREDITS
BECAUSE THE 4% FEDERAL CREDITS
WERE UNDER SUBSCRIBED AT THE
TIME. BUT GO BACK TWENTY
NINETEEN A LOT HAS CHANGED SINCE
THEN AS WE KNOW- CONDITIONS HAVE
DRAMATICALLY TRAINED- CHANGED 4%
FEDERAL CRITICS ARE NOW
OVERSUBSCRIBED THREE TO ONE AND
FEDERAL RULES DO NOT ALLOW US TO
EXPAND THAT PROGRAM EACH 4%
CREDIT DEVELOPMENT THAT RECEIVE
STATE CREDIT SIMPLY DISPLACES
ANOTHER WORTHY DEVELOPMENT
DURING THIS HOUSING CRISIS
HOWEVER THERE IS NO FEDERAL
BARRIER TO EXPANDING THE 9%
FEDERAL CREDIT PROGRAM.
THEREFORE IF UNDER THESE
CONDITIONS WE PAIR THE STATE
CREDITS WITH 9% FEDERAL CREDITS
WE CAN FUND ADDITIONAL
AFFORDABLE HOMES AB THREE FORTY
SIX DOES NOT INCREASE TAXES IN
ANY WAY BECAUSE AMOUNT OF
CREDITS IS FIXED IN THE BUDGET
EACH YEAR. AB THREE FORTY SIX
SIMPLY IS A MORE EFFECTIVE AND
IMPACTFUL WAY FOR CALIFORNIA TO
DEPLOY ITS SCARCE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING RESOURCES WITH ME TODAY
TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY AND ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS. HERE IS MISTER
MARK STIVERS DIRECTOR OF
LEGISLATIVE AND REGULATORY
ADVOCACY WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. THANK YOU
SO MEMBER MY STIVERS THE ISN'T
TO TWO QUICK POINTS- AS ANY YEAR
WHEN THE BUT IS A DEFICIT WE ARE
TRYING TO WORK ON MAKING
PROGRAMS MORE EFFICIENT AND
FORTY STATE RESOURCES TO BETTER
USE. IS THIS BILL HAS TO KIND OF
VERY CLEAR PROVISIONS ONE THAT
ALLOWS US TO USE THE STATE
CREDITS MORE EFFICIENTLY TO PAIR
THAT PUT THEM WITH THE FEDERAL
PROGRAM WHERE THEY'RE MOST
NEEDED. AND SECONDLY BY
CLARIFYING WHEN DEVELOPERS CAN
START CLAIMING STATE CREDITS
ACTUALLY INCREASES THE PRICING
THAT PRIVATE INVESTORS WILL PAY
FOR THE SAME DOLLAR STATE CREDIT
I SEVEN CENTS. WITH WITH FIVE
HUNDRED MILLION STATE CREDIT
THAT MAKES FOR A THIRTY FIVE
MILLION DOLLAR INCREASE IN AND
IMPACT WITH NO IMPACT TO THE
STATE BUDGET THE SAME AMOUNT OF
CREDITS AVAILABLE SO WE URGE
YOUR SUPPORT TODAY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. EXPECT. I'M JUST NOT
HAS INSISTED OR THINK. SUPPORT.
WITH THE CONSENT OF THE SHAH
YOUR ENTRY SMALLS ARE LAYING
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CITY AND
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO IN
SUPPORT. YOU KNOW I WITH THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM IN
SUPPORT. HELLO ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT PLEASE COME FORWARD OKAY
SITTING ON IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION. TO EIGHTY THREE
FORTY SIX. OKAY WE'LL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. FOR THOSE WHO WISH
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION. PLEASE PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO. THIS YEAR THERE IS NO
ONE OKAY OVER ABOUT THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. KISSING YEAR CLOSE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
OKAY DO WE HAVE A MOTION. A
MOTION BY SEVERAL HOBBY WILL
CALL THE ROLL. MOTIONS TO PASS
AND REFER THE COMMITTING
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SENATOR
WIENER. WIENER HI THE TROUBLED.
CLICK HERE- THANKS. ZERO FIVE.
ZERO I. BECAUSE HE AYE MCGUIRE
VIDEO. YEAH THERE TO. SKINNER
NUMBER BOB. BOB HI. SIX ZERO.
OKAY SIX ZERO WILL PUT THE ON
CALL AND NOW WE'RE GOING TO
YEARS. JOB ITEM AB FORCE. EIGHT
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS FINE HERE TO PRESENT AB
FORCE EIGHT WHICH EXISTE
INSPECTION AND CODE. TO BILL YOU
FOR Q. HAVE A- REGARDLESS OF HIS
AND IMPROVES TENANT PROTECTIONS
WHEN BUILDINGS ARE DEEMED UNSAFE
CALIFORNIA STATE HOUSING LAWS
ARE SOME OF THE MOST
COMPREHENSIVE IN THE NATION
ESTABLISHING HEALTH AND SAFETY
PROTECTIONS THROUGH BUILDING
STANDARDS TO ENSURE DECENT SAFE
AND SANITARY HOUSING FOR ALL
HOWEVER THE REALITY IS
INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES WHO ARE
UNABLE TO FIND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING ARE TAKING UP SHELTER IN
BUILDINGS THAT HAVE NOT. BEEN
ZONED RESIDENTIAL THIS HAS
ENHANCED A PROBLEM WHERE BOTH
WAREHOUSES AND FACTORY SPACES
ARE NOW BEING CONVERTED TO
RESIDENTIAL USE WITHOUT THE
KNOWLEDGE OF LOCAL OFFICIALS AND
WITHOUT WITHOUT THE BUILDING
BEING HABITABLE AND DECEMBER
TWENTY SIXTEEN A DEADLY FIRE AT
A TWO STORY WAREHOUSE IN OAKLAND
KNOWN AS THE GHOST SHIP KILLED
THIRTY SIX PEOPLE THE HIGHEST
DEATH TOLL FOR A STRUCTURAL FIRE
IN THE UNITED STATES IN OVER A
DECADE. AGO SHIP WAS A WAREHOUSE
IT WAS A LEGALLY BEING LEASED TO
ARTISTS WHO LIVED AND WORKED IN
THE BUILDING AND PERIODICALLY
USING UP FOR EVENTS.
UNFORTUNATELY THIS TRAGEDY IS
NOT AN ISOLATED INCIDENT THE
RECENT SHOOTINGS IN HALF MOON
BAY THAT TOOK THE LIVES OF SEVEN
FARMWORKERS LIVING IN SHIPPING
CONTAINERS CAST MORE LIGHT ON
THE GRIM. REALITIES OF UNSAFE
HOUSING CONDITIONS THAT HARD
WORKING CALIFORNIANS. MUST LIVE
WITH UNHEALTHY AND UNSAFE
HOUSING AND SERVED AS AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FOR FAR TOO MANY PEOPLE
AND FOR FAR TOO LONG WE NEED TO
BETTER EMPOWER LOCAL AND STATE
AGENCIES TO DEAL WITH THE LAP
ATTAINTED. COMMERCIAL AND
INDUSTRIAL BUILDINGS BEING USED
AS HOUSING WITH ME TODAY TO
PROVIDE TESTIMONY IN SUPPORT AND
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS BUT I
HAVE FAITH FORGES. ON BEHALF OF
THE BILL'S SPONSOR THE CAL. THE
ASSOCIATION OF CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS AND MR BRADY GERD TEN
PUBLIC AFFAIRS MANAGER OF THE
CALIFORNIA IN CALIFORNIA
BUILDING OFFICIALS. THANK YOU
GOOD AFTERNOON FAITH FOR JUST ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS. VERY BRIEFLY CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS ARE THAN
MEN AND WOMEN ON THE FRONTLINES
OF ENFORCING HOUSING CODES AND
THEY DEAL WITH ALL ASPECTS OF
ENSURING SAFETY AND QUALITY OF
LIFE FOR CALIFORNIANS. IT'S A
PRIVILEGE TO REPRESENT THAT HERE
TODAY. CENSUS DATA SHOWS THAT
APPROXIMATELY TWO MILLION
CALIFORNIANS LIVE IN SUBSTANDARD
CONDITIONS WITH THE HOUSING
SHORTAGE AND CO THAT HAVING
WORKED IN THOSE NUMBERS. UNDER
EXISTING LAW A BUILDING IS
DEEMED SUBSTANDARD WHEN AN
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER DETERMINES
THAT SPECIFIED CONDITIONS EXIST
BUT ENDANGER LIFE HEALTH SAFETY
AND THE PUBLIC FROM THE PUBLIC
OR OCCUPANTS. THIS BILL
CLARIFIES ANY AMBIGUITY IN
EXISTING LAW BY CLEARLY STATING
THAT A SUBSTANDARD BUILDING FOR
PURPOSES OF THE STATE HOUSING
LAW. MEANS OF RESIDENTIAL
BUILDING OR ANY BUILDING USED
FOR HUMAN HABITATION THAT IS SUB
STANDARD REGARDLESS OF THE
ZONING DESIGNATION. STATE
HOUSING LAW PROVIDES FOR
RELOCATION ASSISTANCE TO A
TENANT DISPLACED FROM A
RESIDENTIAL RENTAL UNIT AS A
RESULT OF AN ORDER TO VACATE BY
LOCAL ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES.
UNDER SERIOUS CONDITIONS THAT
INCLUDE A LACK OF RUNNING WATER
AND ADEQUATE LAVATORIES
INFESTATIONS AND OTHER SERIOUS
CONDITIONS. THIS BILL DEFINES
THE TERM RESIDENTIAL RENTAL UNIT
FOR THOSE PURPOSES FOR
RELOCATION RELOCATION ASSISTANCE
FOR A LAWFUL TENANTS. TO INCLUDE
ANY UNIT RENTED FOR HUMAN
HABITATION THAT IS A SUBSTANDARD
BUILDING. DESPITE BEING RENTED
ITS HOUSING FACTORIES COMMERCIAL
AND INDUSTRIAL BUILDINGS AND
WAREHOUSES SUCH AS THE GHOST
SHIP ARE NOT IN RESIDENTIAL
ZONES AND THEREFORE HAVE INVADED
MUCH NEEDED SAFETY INSPECTIONS.
CODE ENFORCEMENT AND TENANT
PROTECTIONS. FOLLOWING THE
HORRIFIC SHOOTINGS IN HALF MOON
BAY THE SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE
REPORTED THE SUBSTANDARD HOUSING
CONDITIONS THAT TWENTY SEVEN
FARMWORKERS INCLUDING THEIR
FAMILIES WERE LIVING IN AND
CONVERTED TRAILERS WITH NO
RECORD AT HOUSING PERMITS OR
INSPECTIONS. THESE CONDITIONS.
WERE A CONTRIBUTING FACTOR TO
THE AND HEALTH CHALLENGE OF THE
SHOOTER THAT TOOK THE LIVES OF
FIVE. HUSBANDS WIVES FATHERS AND
DAUGHTERS WE CAN THINK OF NO
BETTER CLOSING THEM TO ASK FOR
YOUR SUPPORT HERE TODAY THANK
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON TERM MEMBERS
RETURN ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE
WE OUR MISSION IS TO PROMOTE
PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY AND
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TO
RESPONSIBLE LEGISLATION
EDUCATION AND BUILDING CO
DEVELOPMENT. AB FOUR SIXTY EIGHT
WOULD PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
LOCAL ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES TO
INCREASE COMPLIANCE WITH STATE
HOUSING LAW AND BETTER ENFORCE
IMPROVEMENTS TO THE NECESSARY
DIET. DIET TOTALIDAD BUILDINGS
AS WE'VE SEEN BEFORE THROUGHOUT
HISTORY WITH THE GO SOMEWHERE
ELSE WHERE AS A POINT ON THE
FARM WORKER HOUSING IT IS REALLY
IMPORTANT THAT OUR LOCAL
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES CAN BETTER
PROMOTE PUBLIC HEALTH AND
SAFETY. AND UNSANITARY AND
UNSAFE HOUSING WERE PLEASE
DESCENDANTS SUPPORTERS AND I
VOTE ON THIS BILL AND HAVE IT
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THANK YOU.
THANK YOU NEXT FIGURE THANK YOU
. GOOD AFTERNOON BRANDON COULD I
GOT WILL REGIONAL MAN AND FOR.
IN SUPPORT. IN ADDITION SUPPORT
PUBLIC. IN THE ROOM SAYING NINE
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION. SIGNAL
WILL MOVE TO THE PHONE LINES.
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO IF
YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL. THERE
IS NO ONE. OKAY WE'RE ABOUT TO
THE COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS CENTER PODIA JUST.
THANK YOU JUST BRIEFLY MISTER
CHAIRMAN TO THE AUTHOR
APPRECIATE YOU BRING THE BILL
ANALYSIS MAKES A NOTE WITH
RESPECT TO UNLAWFUL OCCUPATION
AND PETITION FOR UNLAWFUL
DETAINER. CLARIFYING HOW WE
MIGHT. MEASURE THAT AS AN
EXEMPTION IS ARE YOU WILLING TO
TAKE UP THAT- SORT OF INPUT YOU
ANTICIPATE PROVIDING ADDITIONAL
CLARIFICATION AS A BONUS FOR. AT
THIS POINT WE HAVEN'T HAD THAT
RAISED AS A AS ON MANY OTHER
THAN YOUR NET YOUR COMMENT RIGHT
NOW SO WE'RE ALWAYS WILLING TO
WORK ON. THIS I DO WANT TO MAKE
IT CLEAR IT'S A LITTLE BIT OF A
TRICKY OF AN ISSUE AS- MANY OF
US HERE IN THIS COMMITTEE ROOM
ARE WORKING TIRELESSLY ON THE
HOUSING CRISIS SO WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE. THAT WE DON'T OVER
REACH ON THIS POLICY WHICH HOOK
YOU KNOW SOMETIMES WHEN YOU'RE
LOOKING AT CODE ENFORCEMENT
WHERE PEOPLE ARE LIVING AND IT
GOES BECOMES- OF AN OVER REACH
WHERE THERE MIGHT BE UNITS THAT
COULD BE FIXED AND PEOPLE COULD
STAY IN THEM FORCES MOVING THEM
OUT. SO I'M NOT REALLY ANSWER
YOUR QUESTION I THINK BUT- JUST
MEANS WITH RESPECT TO THE FACT
THAT THE BILL LANGUAGE-
PRESCRIBES. THE SCENARIO WHERE
AND IT MAY MAKE A HOMEOWNER
IMMUNE- UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES
IT JUST POINTS OUT THAT YOU MAY
WANT TO CLARIFY HOW WE MEASURE
THAT. IF IN FACT THAT'S THE CASE
AND THAT THAT WAS SORT OF THE
GENESIS. YES WE WILL CONTINUE TO
WORK ON THIS AND LIKE I SAID
OUR- OUR GOAL IS TO KEEP PEOPLE
SAFE BUT NOT TO EVICT PEOPLE
UNNECESSARILY. OKAY ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. THEME
NONE- TO WE HAVE A MOTION. OKAY
AND THAT IS A- MOTION TO PASS TO
THE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE CORRECT
. YOU MAY CLOSE- LIKE I SAID I
THIS IS A LITTLE BIT OF A TRICKY
WHERE WE WANT TO WALK A FINE
BALANCE WHICH- MEANS KEEPING
PEOPLE SAFE NOT HAVING REPEAT-
DEATH. THAT WE'VE SEEN BUT ALSO-
ONE POSSIBLE KEEPING PEOPLE IN
THEIR HOMES WITH THAT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE. OKAY RIVER MOTION FASTER
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ON WILL CALL
THE ROLL. SENATOR WINNER. WINNER
BY THE TROUBLES. TROUBLED BY
CLICKS HERE. CLICKS VERIFY. FOR
BECAUSE HE BY MCGUIRE VIDEO
VIDEO HI SIR. SKINNER BURKE BOB
. BOB BY. SIX ZERO THIRTY SIX
PHOTOS ON CALL. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OKAY- MISTER HAN- BECAUSE
TWO BILLS. WILL START WITH FOR
WHICH WOULD YOU LIKE START WITH-
FIVE SEVENTY TWO I THINK OKAY SO
WHAT I EIGHTY A FIVE SEVENTY TWO
YOU MAY. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS HEY FIVE SEVEN TWO K.
AND H. INCREASE. AT FIVE PER
FROM MY RATE HOMEOWNERS TO
PROHIBIT EXORBITANT H. AWAY FEE
FEE INCREASES WHICH PURSUE THESE
HOMEOWNERS OFTEN INTO FOR
CLOSING ON THEIR HOMES. PMR
HOMEOWNERSHIP PROGRAMS TARGET
FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS FOR LOW
OR MODERATE INCOME THE
HOMEOWNERS AT HOME BUYERS HAVE
TO GO THROUGH A RIGOROUS
VERIFICATION PROCESS TO SHOW
THEIR INCOME ELIGIBLE AND THEIR
MORTGAGE RATE CAN ONLY BE A
THIRD OF THEIR MONTHLY INCOME
FIFTY UNITS ARE USUALLY CONDOS
AND MIXED INCOME BUILDINGS WITH
MONTHLY H. AWAY FEES. AND IN
MOST CIRCUMSTANCES THE MIXED
INCOME BUILDINGS ARE 8290%
MARKET RATE AND 10220% BELOW
MARKET RATE OWNERS. CURRENT LAW
CAPS IN YOUR H. AWAY FEES
INCREASES AT 20% FOR ALL
HOMEOWNERS REGARDLESS OF WHETHER
THEY ARE BELOW MARKET RATE UNITS
ARE NOT. THIS IS CAUSING THE H.
AWAY FEES FOR BELOW MARKET RATE
OWNERS TO INCREASE SO RAPIDLY
THAT IS BECOMING MORE THAN THEIR
ENTIRE MONTHLY MORTGAGE PAYMENT.
THERE'S CLEARLY A DEFICIENCY IN
OUR CURRENT POLICY WHERE WE HAVE
A MAXIMUM ON HOW MUCH THE
MORTGAGE OF A BMR UNIT CAN BE
BUT NOT ON THE MAXIMUM OF THEIR
ANNUAL H. AWAY FEE INCREASES.
ESPECIALLY BECAUSE THE BENEFITS
OF H. AWAY FEE INCREASES ARE NOT
ENJOYED EQUALLY AMONG ALL OF THE
HOMEOWNERS MARKET RATE OWNERS
GET TO RECOUP THE COSTS OF H.
AWAY FEES THROUGH THE EVENTUAL
SALE OF A UNITS AT A NEW
APPRECIATED PRICE. PMR UNITS
DON'T HAVE THE SAME LUXURY
PRICES BECAUSE SALE PRICES ARE
LIMITED- BASED ON THE FACT THAT
THESE ARE CAPPED UNITS. HIS BE A
MARS. I 5% CAP WILL BALANCE
AFFORDABILITY AND STABILITY FOR
THE PMR OWNERS WITH HOAS NEED TO
KEEP UP WITH EXPENSES AND I WANT
TO BE CLEAR- IT SETS THE. CAP ON
REGULAR ASSESSMENTS SAYS SPECIAL
ASSESSED FOR. ONE TIME. FORCED
PER. ARE NOT A- I AMENDED BILL
IN THE- TO ONLY A- H. AWAY GOT.
DOC SIGNED AFTER JANUARY FIRST
TWENTY TWENTY FOUR SO MOVING
FORWARD- THIS AMENDMENT REMOVED
THE OPPOSITION FROM THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS. BANKERS ASSOCIATION
AND THE ASSOCIATION OF COMMUNITY
MANAGERS THE TIMELY PIECE OF
LEGISLATION TO MAKE SURE FOLKS
ARE PROMISED HOMEOWNERSHIP. AT
AN AFFORDABLE COST ARE ABLE TO
REMAIN IN THEIR UNITS AND AREN'T
FORCED TO FORECLOSE ON THEIR
HOMES. WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT R. MICH MAN CAN FROM.
THE SAN FRANCISCO HOUSING
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION ABRAM
DÍAS FROM. NON PROFIT HOUSING OF
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. YOU MAKE
AFFORD. HI FOLKS. THANK YOU
SENATORS FOR TIME TODAY. HIS
WHICH MAN CAN I'M WITH SAM'S
COUSIN DRONE CORPORATION WERE
COMMUNITY BASED FOR A HOUSING
DEVELOPER AND A HOT CAL SOON
AGENCY. OR SEVEN THE BAY AREA
ESPECIALLY THE BLACK COMMUNITY.
OVER THE LAST YEAR'S HEARD
INCREASING NUMBER OF COMPLAINTS-
DRUG COUNSELORS FROM CLIENTS
ABOUT HIGH H. AWAY FEE
INCREASES. PMR OWNERS BEING
PUSHED TO DEFAULT IN THE
FORECLOSURE OR HAVING LEANS BY
THE HOMES. BECAUSE OF THESE H.
AWAY FEES SOMETIMES EQUIPS THEM
MORTGAGE PAYMENTS. AND
CONVERSATIONS OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS WITHOUT IT'S NOT
START CLIENTS THIS. IS PROBLEMS
HAPPEN ACROSS THE MY PROGRAM. SO
THE PRO SLOW EIGHTY FIVE TWO IS
GOING FOR TO LIMIT INCREASES AND
REGULAR H. AWAY FEE ASSESSMENTS
ON BMR HOMES 25% PER YEAR. THAT
GIVES B. R. OWNERS PICKED
BUILDING STABILITY. THAT
MITIGATES THE MOST DIFFICULT
INCREASES WHILE LEAVING TYPICAL
INCREASE UNTOUCHED. A DECREASE
IN FEES IS OFF WITH A SMALLER
INCREASE AND FEES ON THE MARKET
UNITS THAT THE H. AWAY AS A
WHOLE MAINTAINS FINANCING. SO A
TYPICAL DEVELOPMENT AS MENTIONED
WITH 10220% OF THE UNITS BELOW
MARKET RATE. EACH MONTH FOR YOU
KNOW WHAT THE INDIVIDUAL NOT
THAT'S EQUAL TO BETWEEN A
QUARTER AND NINE FOR THE
DECREASE IN FEES ON EACH
AFFORDABLE HOME. SO WE ACTUALLY
TOOK THIS INVOLVED ABOUT THIRTY
YEARS AHEAD. THE- THE INCREASES
ON MARKET RATE. UNITS ARE QUITE
SMALL. FOR US WHERE IS THE
DECREASE AND BELOW MARKET RATE
UNITS ARE QUITE SIGNIFICANT. AND
ADDITION I WANT TO MENTION THIS
DOESN'T. CHANGE H. REYES ABILITY
TO LEVY A SPECIAL EMERGENCY
ASSESSMENT. IN CASE OF MORE
SERIOUS PROBLEMS WITH THE
BUILDING. HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS OR CLARIFY AS A FROM
DÍAS HERE FROM AND PH. THANK YOU
. THANK YOU FOR. THANK YOU
COMMITTED TO MEMBERS AND THANK
YOU TO OUR AUTHOR FOR CARRYING
THIS BILL- IS ROOM DO WITH AND-
REPRESENT. FOR THE HOUSE
BUILDERS ALL. NORTH CAL. SO
STATE LEGISLATURES CA. SUPPORTED
AS A KEY PATHWAY BUILD ACT
ENGINE. WEALTH FOR LONG
CALIFORNIANS ACCORDINGLY BUDGET
AND LET'S. TO NEW HOME.
OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL CA.
ESPECIALLY OUR MOST VULNERABLE.
WE WILL BE WITH ADVANCED AS LOW
INCOME HOME OWNERSHIP BECAUSE
THEY'LL IF ON ONE HAND WE GIVE
THESE FAMILIES A PRECIOUS
OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD EQUITY AND
ANOTHER HAND HAVE TO FIX FOR
CLOSURE DEFAULT. OR LOSS OF THE
HOME OF THREE CHOICES. THIS BILL
PROVIDES A STRAIGHTFORWARD FEE
FRAMEWORK HAS DISCUSSED A
RESPONSIBLE CAPITALIST FAMILIES
TO PLAN FOR INCREASES BUT ALSO
HAS A CHOICE CAN FULFILL THEIR
NEIGHBORHOOD RESPONSIBILITIES.
WE WORK REALLY CLOSELY WITH YOUR
RESERVATIONS TO ADDRESS THEIR
CONCERNS AND- DRIVER ON THIS
BILL. THANK YOU THEY NEED TO
SHOW SUPPORT ME ROOM. THANK IS
RUNNING UP AS- PLEASE COME
FORWARD. GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRED MEMBERS STEVE CRUZ ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION.
WE ARE IN A OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED. POSITION AND PRIMARILY
BECAUSE OF THE COST SHIFTS THAT
WE BELIEVE WILL OCCUR. IF YOU
PUT A CAP ON THE BELOW MARKET
RATE HOMEOWNERS- THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER DID. REFERENCE THE I
GUESS THE INTENTION OF PERHAPS
COVERING 10220% RIGHT NOW THERE
IS NO SUCH CAP IN THE BILL SO
THAT IS ONE. OF THE AMENDMENTS
THAT WE ARE. TRYING TO HAVE A
CONVERSATION WITH THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ABOUT WE'VE HAD SEVERAL
CONVERSATIONS AND HOPEFULLY WE
CAN GET THERE SO ONE OF WHICH
WOULD PUT A- CAP AT FIFTEEN
PERCENT. ON OF THE HOMERS IN
WHICH YOU CAN PROVIDE THE CAP IN
THE SECOND WAS TO MOVE THE
EFFECTIVE DATE TO TWENTY TWENTY
FIVE THERE ARE PROJECTS THAT ARE
IN THE PIPELINE THAT APPLY FOR
D. R. E. WE DON'T WANT TO
DISRUPT TO DELAY THE PROJECT
THROUGH THE PIPELINE BUT- AGAIN-
WE ARE CLOSE. BUT TO LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
AUTHOR. ANY ADDITIONAL
OPPOSITION. THREE MILLION GO TO
THE PHONE LINE. FOR THOSE TWO TO
SPEAK INTO OF YOUR OPPOSITE.
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN. ZERO THE
SECURE THERE IS NO. ONE OKAY
OVER ABOUT THREE COMMITTEE
ANYHOW. OR CENTER BOBBINS PLEASE
. ONE I JUST WANTED THIS
REMEMBER BRING THIS. I BUY OFF
COMPLAIN ABOUT WAY FOR AND THE
THAT THEY- ARE MORE THAN A CAR
RAY THERE ABOUT HITTING FIVE
HUNDRED DOLLARS- IN THE BAY AREA
SOME SIX HUNDRED DOLLARS SOME A
LITTLE LESS- IT'S UNSUSTAINABLE.
MORE INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE
LOOKING TO DOWNSIZE US
SPECIFICALLY THOSE ONES IN FIXED
INCOMES- THIS IS A VERY BALANCED
POLICIES I REALLY DO APPRECIATE
YOU WORKING ON THIS AND- ONE
THING THAT I DO WANT TO
HIGHLIGHT IN PARTICULAR. IS THE
FACT THAT- H. WAS ALSO KIND OF
HATE INDIVIDUALS WITH. OUT OF
NOWHERE COSTS AS WELL RIGHT FOR
ANY DAMAGE OR IMPROVEMENT THAT
ARE NOT REALLY CLEARLY
ESTABLISHED FOR INDIVIDUALS
THAT. HAVE JUST RECENTLY
PURCHASED THE PROPERTY- THERE'S
ALSO NO TRANSPARENCY OR REAL
ACCOUNTABILITY- AND THERE OF
THEIR OWN LOCAL JURISDICTION
ALMOST STRAIGHT- SO I DO REALLY
JUST ONE HIGHLIGHT THAT FOR
FOLKS THAT WE DO HAVE TO
ACTUALLY WORK ON SOME OF THE
EFFORTS AROUND EACH WAYS AND-
REALLY JUST BOUNCING POWER
THERE. BUT ONE OF THE THINGS I
DID WANT TO SAY IS THAT BESIDES
BRING THIS FORWARD IT'S
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT TO ALSO
IDENTIFY THAT. HOAS FOR CONDOS
AND TOWNHOMES SAD IN THE AIR
OVER ONE POINT THREE MILLION
DOLLARS- IS QUITE SIGNIFICANT
FOR EVEN STARTER HOMES- AND IT'S
LIMITING THE POTENTIAL PEOPLE
PURCHASING THESE THESE
PROPERTIES BECAUSE THEY FEAR THE
H. WAY WHERE THEIR PAYMENTS
ALMOST HALF THEIR PAYMENT- SO I
WILL BE MOVING THIS ONE
APPROPRIATE BUT I REALLY JUST
WANNA APPRECIATE. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER FOR BRING THIS FORWARD
AND REALLY. TACKLING ISSUE
THAT'S OVERLOOKED. CONSIDER
VOICE- YES I JUST WANTED TO SAY
MANY OF COMMON THAT THE H. AWAY
FEES ARE THE UNPREDICTABILITY OF
THEM AND THE FACT THAT THEY CAN
GO UP- TO UNKNOWN AMOUNTS AND
PEOPLE ARE ON THE HOOK FOR THAT
I THINK IT IS REALLY TROUBLING
AND- AND IT IS SOMETHING THAT
IT'S ALMOST LIKE A HIDDEN FEET
BECAUSE SOMETIMES PEOPLE AREN'T.
ASKING THAT AT THE BEGINNING OF
THE DISCUSSION ABOUT WHETHER TO
RENT OR TO BUY A PROPERTY. SO TO
ME WHEN YOU. LOOK AT THE BALANCE
OF THE ENTRANCE. IF SOMEBODY'S
ABLE TO SELL THEIR UNIT FOR
MARKET RATE THAT THEIR AGE AWAY
FEES SHOULD BE HIGHER THAN THE
PERSON WHO'S- DEED RESTRICTIONS
MEAN THAT THEY WILL BE SELLING
IT POTENTIALLY FOR LAUGHS. OR
WHAT WHEN OR IF THEY MOVE OUT
SO- SO I DO THINK THAT THAT
MAKES A LOT OF SENSE I'M NOT
SURE. THE OPPOSITION TALKING
ABOUT THE CAP I'M NOT SURE WHERE
YOU ARE WITH THAT. BUT I WANTED
TO INVITE YOU TO RESPOND IF YOU
WANTED TO. SURE SURE AND I. THAT
I THINK THIS THAT THAT'S ONE OF
THE REASONS WHY THIS. MADE A LOT
OF SENSE TO ME IS RIGHT NOW.
SOMETIMES YOU'RE EITHER H. AWAY
FEE- IS GOING TOWARDS IMPROVING
THE PROPERTY IN A WAY THAT LISTS
THE PROPERTY VALUES UP WHICH I
TOTALLY UNDERSTAND. BUT IF YOUR
BMR DEED RESTRICTED YOU CAN'T-
IN E. A. GAIN THE BENEFIT OF
THOSE PROPERTY INCREASES IN THE
SAME WAY. SO THAT'S ONE OF THE
FLAWS IN THE SYSTEM AS WELL AS
THE FACT WE HAVE OBVIOUSLY
RECOGNIZE THAT. THESE FOLKS HAVE
TO HAVE THEIR MORTGAGE CAPPED AT
A CERTAIN LEVEL BECAUSE THEY CAN
ONLY AFFORD SO MUCH. AND YET
THOSE HIDDEN FEES OF HOAS ARE
MAKING IT TOTALLY UNAFFORDABLE
TO THEM. SO THIS FELT FAIR I
ALSO WILL SAY IT DOESN'T
NECESSARILY NEED TO BE COSTS
PASSED ON TO THE MARKET RATE
FOLKS BECAUSE- I AGREE THIS. H.
AWAY FEES ARE OFTEN. TOO
EXPENSIVE FOR EVERYONE THAT
ACTUALLY MAYBE THIS CAN LEAD
THEM TO NOT INCREASE IT. AS MUCH
FOR EVERYBODY AND THEN TO
CONSIDER IT THAT ASPECT OF IT- I
DEFINITELY WE ARE GOING TO. COME
TO AN AGREEMENT- AT SOME LEVEL
OF- A CERTAIN PERCENTAGE- WITHIN
A BUILDING RIGHT NOW WE HAVE A
HUNDRED PERCENT. SO IT'S A 100%
AFFORDABLE THIS WOULD NOT APPLY.
BUT I THINK WE'RE WE'RE TRYING
JUST TRYING TO FIND THE RIGHT
PERCENTAGE- TO MAKE THIS FAIR
AND BALANCED IN THAT WAY. I AND
SO I DEFINITELY HAVE THAT
COMMITMENT TO DO THAT AND I
ALSO. UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE OF
THERE ARE SOME. BUILDINGS THAT
ARE ALREADY MOVING FORWARD IT
WHICH THIS COULD CREATE SOME
CHALLENGES FOR THEM IN THE NEAR
TERM SO. I'M ALSO OPEN TO THAT
AMENDMENTS THAT CPI. FORWARD AND
JUST ONE MORE COMMENT I MEAN
WHAT THE ONE OF THE MAIN ISSUES
IS THAT. THE H. AWAY FEES REALLY
DO THEY GO TO IMPROVE THE
PROPERTY- AND- THEIR COMMON
SPACES ARE LANDSCAPING THEIR
MAINTENANCE. AND SO. THEY HAVE
IT SEEMS LIKE. THERE'S NOT ANY
WAY. I DON'T SEE A WAY FOR THERE
TO BE AN EXTERNAL PRESSURE THAT
SAYS THAT THESE HAVE TO BE
LOWER- UNLESS WE'RE GONNA
SUBSIDIZE IT. SO BASICALLY IT I
MEAN IT DOES IT IS A BIT OF A
CIRCULAR PROBLEM BECAUSE- ALL OF
THE MAINTENANCE COSTS AND- AND
ALL THE OTHER THINGS ARE GOING
UP AROUND CONSTRUCTION INFLATION
AND EVERYTHING. AND OF HITTING
THE H. AWAY. THAT'S INTERNALLY.
MANAGED SO PEOPLE LIKE THERE ARE
ON A- YOU KNOW SO. YOU'RE
THINKING ABOUT IS THAT THE WE
CAN. MAKE SURE THAT IS FAIR AS
POSSIBLE. SO THAT'S WHY I IDEA
DOES STAY TO STRIKE THE- BALANCE
I MEAN EIGHTY EIGHT. IDEAL THE
IDEAL SITUATION MIGHT BE THAT
WE- TO HELP CISOS SUBSIDIZE
THESE IN IN SOME WAY SOME OURS
WERE SUBSIDIZING. THE UNIT
ITSELF WE HAVEN'T SET UP THE
SYSTEM THAT WAY AND SO WE HAVE
TO FIGURE OUT WHAT'S THE FAIREST
WAY IN RECOGNITION. OF THAT
BOTH- THE LIMITATIONS. OF INCOME
AND ALSO THE BENEFITS THAT ARE
RECEIVED IF YOU CAN'T SELL YOUR
UNIT. YOU'RE NOT GETTING SOME OF
THE SAME BENEFITS OF SOME OF
THOSE INVESTMENTS AND- AND SO
THE STAGE WE MIGHT BE MAKING
DECISIONS. TO MAKE INVESTMENTS
THAT THEY FEEL ARE IMPROVING THE
PROPERTY VALUE THAT IF YOUR BMR
OWNER. YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO PAY
AT THE TURN YOU CAN'T SELL YOUR
UNIT OR YOU CAN'T PUT THE EQUITY
OUT OF YOUR HOME OR- IN THE SAME
WAY. YEAH THANK YOU FOR. OKAY SO
YOU KNOW THERE ARE COMMON. I'M
SORRY A CENTER CHAU. COMES RIGHT
INTO. SEVEN I EIGHT. I UNDER.
THE. CONCERN WITH H. I KNOW THAT
A NEW PLACE IS FUN UP HERE- I'M
SO. HOW QUICKLY SAID THE PRICES
HAVE GONE UP BUT- I'M I'M I
WANTED TO ASK SOMETHING- I
WANTED TO. THE 5% THAT YOU- YOU
STIPULATE IN IN THIS BILL WHITE.
5% HOW DID YOU COME UP WITH THAT
FIGURE AND NOT SAY. SOMETHING
THAT HAD. TO BE RELATABLE TO THE
CPI- WELL NOW THERE'S A CAP OF
20% FOR ALL- SO WE- REALLY JUST
TRY TO THINK OF WHAT WHAT WOULD
BE MOST FAIR THAT. WOULD BALANCE
THE FACT THAT IN SOME CASES THAT
THAT DIFFERENCE WOULD BE SPREAD
OUT AMONGST- SOME OF THE OTHER
OWNERS- WITH WHITE. FOLKS COULD
LIKELY AFFORD SO WE HAVE A
CAPTAIN RIGHT NOW AND SO WE
THOUGHT- 5% WAS THE MOST FAIR
THAT IN TERMS OF YOU KNOW SOME
OF THE MATH THAT WE TALKED ABOUT
WHAT'S THAT WHAT THE ACTUAL
IMPACT WOULD BE IN THESE
BUILDINGS. FAIRLY MINIMAL FOR
THE OTHER OWNERS BUT SIGNIFICANT
BASED ON WHAT SOME OF THE
INCREASES THAT WE'RE SEEING ON
THESE PMR FOLKS WHO. BECAUSE OF
IF THEY'RE GETTING 15% EVERY
YEAR HI IF YOUR BMI BAR OWNER IT
QUICKLY BECOMES AT A LEVEL
WHERE. WE KNOW BASED ON YOUR
DOCUMENT INCOME YOU JUST CANNOT
AFFORD. SO WE DECIDED THAT IT
WAS FAIR AND MIGHT HAVE THAT 20%
THAT ALREADY EXIST THAT THIS
WOULD BE. THE RIGHT BALANCE. IN
K. FOURTEEN YOU THANK YOU.
GREAT- ICE THIS BILL. I THINK IT
IS TENSION BIG BARRIER TO.
OWNING BM- AND I APPRECIATE
FIRST VOTE THIS ONLY. TO NEARLY
CREATE H. O. BECAUSE. FULL
RELIED ON EXISTING ARRAY AND
PERKS SO. AND COURSE AS CENTER
WILL HOG. MENTAL OF PEOPLE- ARE
BUYING BECAUSE RETAIL. ARE DATA
A.'S AND A RE AT MARKET RATE.
THAT ARE RELEASED. AND COMPARE
MAKE THEIR- MORTGAGE INITIAL
PAYMENTS OF AN ON ARE. OWNERS
BUT THEY'RE STILL- SEVERELY.
CONSTRAINED IN THE RELEASED. AND
YOU KNOW I AM IN AS A WIDE. OF
CHOICES A RETAIL THAT ARE OF
MASS. AND VERY TO SCAN I.
PERHAPS FROM IN THE HOMEOWNERS
ON OWN MY OWN A AWAY THIRTY
UNITS- YOU KNOW WE WE'VE RAISED
TO DO FROM HAVE YOU KNOW NEW. TO
DO OR INSURANCE PREMIUM GO. OR
WHATEVER SO IT IS A VERY CALM
ISSUE AT LEAST MAKING IT GOING
FORWARD TO NEW AGE CHOI ALLOWS
ALL OF THAT TO. SERVICE OUT
PEOPLE CAN MAKE INFORMED.
DECISION SO I APPRECIATE YOU
BRING BILL AND I'M HAPPY TO IT
AND TO UNSERVED OF EMOTION
CENTER WALK. OKAY CENTER A MOVE
THE BILL AND MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
I APPRECIATE THE COMMON AND THE
ZIP IN OUR FIRST ASK RIVAL. THIS
CALL ROLL. MOTIONS TO PASS
REFERRED THE COMMITTEE ON
JUDICIARY CENTER WINNER. WINNER
I THE CHOKE NO THE TROUBLED NOW
LOOKS HERE. CLICKS THERE HI
CAMARO COURTESY PHOTOS HE HI
MICHAEL VIDEA. VIDEA HI THERE TO
SKINNER. BURKE WILL HAVE. HOP BY
. BY TWO ONE FIVE TWO PUT ON
CALL MEMBERS BILL. ITEM NUMBER
NINETY AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE.
HI THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AB FOR
EIGHTY WITH CAL A BILL TO IN
STATE HOUSE LAW DOES SO BY
GIVING THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
COMMUNITY. OR C. AND ATTORNEY.
THE ABILITY TO THE IN IMPENDING
ACTIONS FILED BY THIRD FOR FIVE
OF STATE HOW LAW RIGHT NOW CAL
ARE FACE A HOUSE CRISIS OF EPIC.
WHICH I KNOW YOU ALL KNOW FOR
WELL HOW NEED TO PRODUCE TWO
POINT FIVE MILLION HOUSING UNITS
OVER THE NEXT EIGHT YEARS TO
KEEP UP WITH HOUSING DEMAND BUT
WE ARE ONLY CONSTRUCTING ABOUT
EIGHTY THOUSAND UNITS PER YEAR
SO WE NEED EVERY TOOL AT OUR
DISPOSAL TO GUARANTEE WE MEET
OUR HOUSING GOALS. AND ENSURE
THAT HOUSING IS ACTUALLY BEING
BUILT EXISTING LAW EMPOWERS THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL TO BRING SUIT
FOR A VIOLATION OF STATE HOUSING
LAW IT ALSO ALLOWS THIRD PARTIES
TO FILE LAWSUITS TO ENFORCE THE
HOUSING LAWS BUT UNDER CURRENT
LAW WHEN A THIRD PARTY FILES A
LAWSUIT RELATED ENFORCEMENT OF
STATE HOUSING LAWS. THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S OFFICE CAN ONLY BECOME
A PARTY TO THE LAWSUIT BY
PETITIONING THE COURT TO
INTERVENE. THIS PROCEDURAL
HURDLE DELAYS HOUSING FROM BEING
BUILT BECAUSE THE COURTS CAN
TAKE MONTHS TO SCHEDULE A
HEARING ON THE PETITION. EVEN
ONCE A COURT HEARING IS
SCHEDULED THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
ABILITY TO INTERVENE IN THE
CASES AT THE COURT'S DISCRETION.
DURING GENERAL SHOULD HAVE THE
ABILITY TO ENFORCE STATE HOUSING
LAWS AND REPRESENT THE STATE'S
INTERESTS AND HOUSING CASES.
REGARDLESS OF WHETHER THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL OR A PRIVATE
PARTY FILES ACTION FIRST.
IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL LACKS WHILE THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL LACKS THE
STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO INTERVENE
IN THIRD PARTY SUCCEEDS ON.
HOUSING LAW THEY HAVE THE
STATUTORY RIGHT ARE READY TO
INTERVENE ON OTHER CRITICAL
ISSUES LIKE ENFORCING
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. HOUSING LAW
IS JUST AS IMPORTANT IN GRANTING
THE STATUTORY RIGHT. TO
INTERVENE WILL HELP INSURE THAT
THE STATE'S INTERESTS ARE
REPRESENTED IN COURT AND HELP US
REACH OUR HOUSING GOALS. HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT ME TODAY IS
JANICE STANFORD FROM THE OFFICE
OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL. AND
STEVEN STANDS OR ON BEHALF OF
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION
THEY ALSO HAVE DAVID PIPE FROM
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE.
ON ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU. PLEASE PROCEED AS-
WHEN YOU'RE READY THANK YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON. MADAM CHAIRMAN
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
JANICE STANFORD I'M A DEPUTY
ATTORNEY GENERAL. FOR
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCATE NEED TWENTY
GENERAL'S OFFICE. ON BEHALF OF
ATTORNEY GENERAL ROB BONTA I
WANT TO START BY THINKING
ASSEMBLY MEMBER HANEY FOR
AUTHORING THE BILL AND EVEN
THOUGH HE'S NOT HERE THINK
GENERATOR FOR A CO AUTHORING THE
BILL AS WELL. THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL IS PROUD TO SPONSOR A.
B. FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE. AS YOU
KNOW CALIFORNIA IS FACING SEVERE
HOUSING SHORTAGE AND
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS. THE
LEGISLATURE HAS PASSED STRONG
HOUSING LAWS IN RECENT YEARS TO
ADDRESS THIS CRISIS. AND THOSE
LAWS MUST BE ENFORCED. BY
LEADERS MUST BE HELD
ACCOUNTABLE. ATTORNEY GENERAL
ROB BONTA HAS MADE ENFORCEMENT
OF HOUSING LAWS A TOP PRIORITY.
AND WILL CONTINUE TO EXERCISE
HIS AUTHORITY TO HOLD VIOLATORS
ACCOUNTABLE. BUT UNDER MANY OF
THE STATE'S HOUSING LAWS THIRD
PARTIES LIKE HOUSING ADVOCATES
AND DEVELOPERS. ARE ALSO
EMPOWERED TO FILE THEIR OWN
LAWSUITS CHALLENGING LOCAL LAND
USE PLANNING AND PERMITTING
DECISIONS. THIS BILL WOULD
ADDRESS THE PROCEDURAL HURDLE.
THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FACES
WHEN A THIRD PARTY FILES
ENFORCEMENT ACTION FIRST. UNDER
EXISTING LAW THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S OFFICE HAS TO FORMALLY
FILED A PETITION. WITH THE COURT
FOR PERMISSION TO INTERVENE IN
PENDING THIRD PARTY HOUSING
ENFORCEMENT CASES. THIS
REQUIREMENT CAUSES UNNECESSARY
DELAY. IN ONE ONGOING CASE FOR
EXAMPLE IT TOOK OVER SEVEN
MONTHS AND SEVERAL HEARINGS
EMOTIONS JUST INTERVENE IN THE
CASE. AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE
WOULD REMOVE THIS PROCEDURAL
HURDLE BY GRANTING THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL AND UNCONDITIONAL
STATUTORY RIGHT TO INTERVENE. IN
THIRD PARTY HOUSING CASES. THE
TWENTY GENERAL ALREADY HAS THIS
RIGHT TO INTERVENE IN OTHER
CONTEXTS INCLUDING AN
ENVIRONMENTAL CASES. WE
ROUTINELY USE THIS RIGHT TO
INTERVENE AND ENVIRONMENTAL
JUSTICE CASES FOR EXAMPLE. AB
FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE WOULD GRANT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL THE SAME
RIGHT TO INTERVENE TO ENFORCE
THE HOUSING LAWS. CALIFORNIA'S
ATTORNEY GENERAL SHOULD HAVE THE
RIGHT TO REPRESENT THE STATE'S
INTERESTS AND FOR STATE HOUSING
LAWS REGARDLESS OF WHICH PARTY
FILES THE ENFORCEMENT ACTION
FIRST. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME
CONSIDERATION MEMBERS WHO
RESPECTFULLY AFTER I BOUGHT.
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
AND MEMBER STEVEN SENSOR WITH
BROWN STAIN ON BEHALF OF THE
HOUSING ACTION COALITION A PROUD
SPONSOR MAYBE FORTY FIVE.
HOUSING ACTION COALITION IS A
MEMBER SUPPORTED NONPROFIT THAT
ADVOCATES FOR BUILDING MORE
HOMES AT ALL LEVELS OF
AFFORDABILITY. TO HELP ALLEVIATE
CALIFORNIA'S HOW HOUSING
SHORTAGE DISPLACEMENT AND
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS. THIS BILL
IS A COMMONSENSE MEASURE TO
ALIGN THE OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL STATUTORY AUTHORITY WITH
ITS MISSION TO SUPPORT NOT HOLD
THE STATE'S HOUSING LAWS. THE
STATUTORY RIGHT TO INTERVENE WE
GAVE THE AG AND AT I'M
CONDITIONAL RIGHT TO JOIN
LAWSUITS TO ENFORCE STATE
HOUSING LAW. THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL ALREADY HAS THIS RIGHT
TO INTERVENE OTHER CONTEXTS
INCLUDING MY STATE STATUTE OR
REGULATIONS BEEN DECLARED
UNCONSTITUTIONAL BY A COURT. THE
LEGISLATURE MAKE GREAT STRIDES
TO ENSURE THAT STATE LAW
SUPPORTS EQUITABLE SUSTAINABLE
AND EXPEDIENT DEVELOPMENT OF
HOUSING. THAT THESE LAWS ARE
ONLY AS GOOD AS THEIR
ENFORCEMENT. THIS IS A
STRAIGHTFORWARD SOLUTION TO AN
ISSUE THAT SUPPORTS THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S ABILITY TO INTERVENE
AND TO REPRESENT THE STATE'S
INTERESTS AND HOUSING CASES FOR
THESE REASONS WERE PLEASED TO
SPONSOR AB FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE.
URGE YOUR SUPPORT IN THE
COMMITTEE TODAY AND THANK
ASSEMBLY MEMBER HANDICAPPERS
WORK ON THIS ISSUE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH WILL NOT PROCEED WITH
ANY SUPPORT WITNESSES HERE ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED. AFTER MADAM
CHAIR MICHAEL GUNNING WHITE
HOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS HERE ON
BEHALF OF CIVIC WELL IN SPURTS
THANK YOU. CAN CARE- BOB NAYLOR
FOR FEELS THAT IT COMPANIES
HOWARD AHMANSON. ORANGE COUNTY
PHILANTHROPISTS IN SUPPORT. BUT
I'M SURE MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE YOUR THEN PUT IN A
KIND OF A HARD ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIAN BEACON SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. I LOVE THE WAY HE
SAID KIND OF A HIGH. MADAM CHAIR
AND MEMBERS CRIMES HAVE GREEN
BELT ALLIANCE. THE. STEVENSON'S
WITH BROWN SKIN BEHALF OF CAL.
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU VERY THE NO OTHER
WITNESSES INTO OF AB FOURTEEN A
FIVE ALARM PROCEED WITH ANY LEAD
. OUT WITH THIS ENOUGH. TO AB.
FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE. SEE NONE
WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ANY
WITNESSES HERE IN ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED IN OPPOSITION. SEE NOW
WILL NOW MOVE ON TO WITNESSES
WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA THE
TELECONFERENCE ARVEST. MODERATE
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT THE
INDIVIDUALS WAIT TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION. IT WILL
BE BEGIN. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
FOR THOSE WHO WISH TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE. ZERO FIRST ONE ZERO
AT THIS TIME. WE'RE GOING TO GO
TO LINE SEVENTY THREE YOUR LIFE
IS NOW OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON
MADAM CHAIR WITH MONTANA GAP
WILL BURY COUNCIL TRANSPORT
FIGURE. THERE IS ONE OUT THROUGH
THAT WISH TO SPEAK. THANK YOU-
THIS MODERATOR WILL NOW AM WHEN
I THINK I OUR SUPPORT IN
OPPOSITE WITNESSES IT WILL BRING
DISCUSSION BACK TO OUR MEMBERS.
YOU HAVE ANY COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS ON BEHALF OF OUR
MEMBERS. ENOUGH WE HAVE A
MOTION- BY SENATOR BY THE END.
AND I'M SORRY HIS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ANY WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE THANK YOU- PREVIOUS
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL. THANK
YOU. SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
MOTION IS TO PASS A REFERRED
COMMITTEE AND- SENATOR. POTOMAC
NO JOKE OPEN LOOKS. LIKE SPEAR I
. CORTEZ BUT HAS HE FIVE. PATEA
. VIDEO HI THERE TO. SKINNER
NUMBER BOB. BOB HI FORTY ONE IT
FOR THE WONDERFUL KEEP THAT. ON
ON THE CALL FOR MEMBERS THING
YOU VERY MUCH. NUMBER EIGHT FOR
BEING TODAY. AND THEN THE FIRST
OLYMPIC ORDERS. OKAY BOTH MOVE
FORWARD SENATOR OUR ASSEMBLY
MEMBER. THANK YOU SO MUCH THINK
AB FIVE FORTY EIGHT IS CORRECT
YES SO I DON'T KNOW SIXTEEN YEAH
- COULD I. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
FIRST I LIKE TO ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS AND LIKE
IT'S STUFF FOR THEIR WORK ON THE
BILL AB FIVE FOUR EIGHT WOULD
LOW ENFORCEMENT. TO DEVELOP AND
FOR INSPECTING BUILDING WITH
MORE UNITS HAVE BEEN OR COATING
ON. DETERMINES THAT THE D. OF
CAN REASON IF OTHER UNITS IN THE
BUILDING. IN TWENTY ONE THE U.
S. CENSUS BUREAU AMERICAN
HOUSING SURVEY FOUND THAT OVER
THREE AND A FIFTY THOUSAND
RENTAL UNITS HAD SIGNS OF MOLD
THAT NOT ONLY EXACERBATE
EXISTING AS MOTHER ALSO BECAUSE
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ASTHMA. THAT
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACT RENTAL
HOUSING RATHER THAN OWNER
OCCUPIED HOUSING. PHYSICAL
CONNECTION BETWEEN THE
DISPROPORTIONATE FRAZIER TO
UNHEALTHY HOUSING CONDITIONS AND
MANY OF THE HEALTH INEQUITIES
FUND IN LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES.
AND COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. EIGHTY
FIVE FORTY EIGHT WOULD ESTABLISH
A STANDARD OF PRACTICE BY
ALLOWING CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS. TO INSPECT ADDITIONAL
UNITS WHEN UNCOVERING SEVERELY
SUBSTANDARD CONDITIONS DURING AN
INSPECTION TO CATCH PROBLEMS
THAT PREVIOUSLY WENT UNREPORTED.
OR BEFORE THE PROBLEMS CAN GROW
INTO SERIOUS HEALTH HAZARDS. THE
BILL WOULD PROVIDE FLEXIBILITY
FOR LOCAL AGENCIES TO CONTROL
THE SPECIFICS OF THE POLICY IS
DEVELOPED. DEPENDING ON THE
NEEDS. WITHIN THEIR JURISDICTION
IMPROVING OUR SYSTEM FOR
ENSURING HEALTHY AFFORDABLE
HOUSING CONDITIONS FOR RENTERS
IS ESSENTIAL TO SOLVING OUR
HOUSING CRISIS. REDUCING THE
DISPROPORTIONATE EXPOSURE TO
UNHEALTHY HOUSING CONDITIONS IN
LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES AND
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THAT I HAVE HERE WITH ME BRANDON
COULD AGO A SENIOR POLICY
ASSOCIATE WITH REGIONAL ASTHMA
MANAGEMENT. PREVENTION THE
SPONSORS OF THIS BILL. THANK YOU
AND GOOD AFTERNOON- COMMITTEE
MEMBERS- CAN MY NAME IS PER CAN
I GOT WITH READ ASTHMA MANAGED
AND PER. WORLD OF THE PUBLIC
HEALTH INSTITUTE. OUR MISSION IS
TO REDUCE THE BURDEN OF ASTHMA
WITH A FOCUS ON HEALTH EQUITY.
OR WORK TO REDUCE EXPOSURE TO
ENVIRONMENTAL ASTHMA TRIGGERS
HAS LED US TO PARTNER WITH
TENANTS RIGHTS ORGANIZATIONS
PUBLIC HEALTH AGENCIES AND LOCAL
CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. TO
ADDRESS SUB STANDARD HOUSING
CONDITIONS SUCH AS PEST
INFESTATIONS AND MOLD- WHICH CAN
NOT ONLY EXACERBATE BUT ALSO
BECAUSE ASTHMA AND OTHER HEALTH
ISSUES. EXISTING STATE LAW
REQUIRES LANDLORDS TO ADEQUATELY
MAINTAIN THE RENTAL HOUSING
WHILE DESIGNATING LOCAL CODE
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES RESPONSIBLE
FOR ENFORCING THESE HEALTH AND
SAFETY STANDARDS. MOST
JURISDICTIONS RELY ON TEN
COMPLAINTS TO IDENTIFY POTENTIAL
SUBSTANDARD CONDITIONS. AS A
RESULT OF THIS REACTIVE SYSTEM
MANY PROBLEMS GO UNADDRESSED FOR
A VARIETY OF REASONS- TENANTS
MAY NOT KNOW THAT THEY HAVE THE
RIGHT TO MAKE A COMPLAINT. ABOUT
THE MAY HAVE A PROBLEM
NAVIGATING THE SYSTEM FOR MAKING
COMPLAINTS. OR THEY SIMPLY DON'T
WANT TO UPSET THEIR LANDLORDS.
WHEN TENANTS TO MAKE A COMPLAINT
CODE ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES.
GENERALLY ONLY INSPECT THE UNIT
TARGETED IN THE COMPLAINT-
MISSING OTHER POTENTIAL
VIOLATIONS AT THE PROPERTY.
RECOGNIZING THIS CHALLENGE AB
FIVE FOUR EIGHT SIX TO MAKE A
MODEST CHANGE TO THE STANDARD OF
PRACTICE FOR CODE ENFORCEMENT.
THAT CAN THAT CAN IMPROVE ITS
ABILITY TO CATCH THE MOST SEVERE
BUILDING LIGHT PROBLEMS. THIS
BILL WOULD ALLOW CODE
ENFORCEMENT TO CATCH SEVERE
BUILDING MY PROBLEMS WITH A
SINGLE COMPLAINT BY
SUPPLEMENTING A COMPLAINT BASED
INSPECTION WITH ADDITIONAL
INSPECTIONS WHEN NEEDED.
JURISDICTIONS WILL BE ABLE TO
CATCH PROBLEMS THAT PREVIOUSLY
WENT UNREPORTED OR BEFORE THEY
CAN GROW INTO MORE SIGNIFICANT
HEALTH HAZARDS. TO RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR ITEM. THANK YOU.
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PUBLIC
COMMENT PLEASE COME FORWARD.
YOUR LITTLE BEHALF OF CHILDREN
NOW IN SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
PUBLIC COMMENT. THE FOCUSING ON
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
ROOM. OKAY SIGNAL WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. PLEASE PRESS ONE
AND ZERO AT THIS TIME IF YOU
WISH TO COMMENT ON THIS BILL.
THE TEACHER WE HAVE AT LEAST ONE
PERSON IS SIGNALED THAT THEY
WISH TO SPEAK JUST A MOMENT
PLEASE.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO GO TO LINE
THE SIXTY EIGHT YOUR LINE IS NOW
OPEN. A GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS GREEN GREETING
THE HAPPY CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
OF REALTORS. WE ARE OPPOSED TO
THE BILL AND PRINT HOWEVER WE DO
LOOK FORWARD TO REVIEWING THE
BILL IS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
BY THE PROPOSED DR AMENDMENTS
AND THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS I WANT
TO BE ANALYSIS. WE WISH TO THANK
THE AUTHOR OF THE COMMITTEE FOR
THEIR WORK ON THE BILL THANK YOU
SO MUCH. SURE THERE IS NO ONE
ELSE SIGNALED THAT THEY WISHED
OKAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
BRINGING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. A
CENTER TO AGO. HELLO NUMBER AND
VOTER HAVE A QUESTION M. OR S. A
QUESTION I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE
YOUR ON IT THE FOLLOWING AND- IT
IS MY UNDERSTANDING THAT- THIS
BILL MAY BE UNNECESSARY BECAUSE-
I HAVE A- IT UNDERMINES THE
NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT REACHED
WITH THE AUTHOR AND SPONSORS AB
EIGHT THIRTY EIGHT SURE I CAN
AND THEN THE QUESTION. I AM
THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN A FARTHER
ON THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR SO I MIGHT
HAVE A ROUTE NINE OCCUR OKAY SO
LET ME JUST SAY THE RECORD FOR
THE PURPOSE OF THE AUDIENCE.
UNDERSTANDING WE'RE GOING WITH
AND SO IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING
THAT AB EIGHT THIRTY TWO GEARS A
WORK STARTING WITH AB THIRTY
THREE FIFTY TWO FRIEDMAN IN
ORDER TO ENSURE THAT THE STATE
LAW. INCLUDED A MECHANISM FOR
PROCESSING COMPLAINTS REGARDING
LEAD HAZARDS AND SUBSTANDARD
BUILDING CONDITIONS THAT WORK
FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS SMALL
HOUSING PROVIDERS AND TENANTS
SO. I'M HAVING THAT LOVE TO HEAR
YOUR YES- SO THIS WAS A COMPLAIN
THAT CAME FROM THE REALTORS-
RIGHT BEFORE IT WENT TO THE
SIMPLY FOR THE AND NEVER TALK TO
ME OR MY STAFF ABOUT. THE
FRIEDMAN DAHLE I TALKED TO
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FRIEDMAN ABOUT
THIS AND SHE SAID YOUR BILL HAS
NOTHING TO DO WITH MY BILL. HER
BILL HAD TO DO WITH HAVE A CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER CAME IN
BECAUSE THEY THEY THERE WAS A
COMPLAINT ABOUT MOLD AND THEN
SOUGHT OTHER. CODE VIOLATIONS
FOR THE COULD START REQUIRING
LIKE THE ROOF TO BE FIXED AND
STUFF LIKE THAT THAT'S WHAT HER
BUILT UP WITH. MY BILL DOESN'T
DEAL WITH US MY BILL SAYS IF YOU
GO AND INSPECTION BECAUSE-
INSPECTIONS ARE USUALLY COMPLAIN
PASSED. THE ONE TENANT MAY
COMPLAIN ABOUT MOLD AND IF IT'S
REASONABLE THAT THIS CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. SAYS WELL
IF THERE'S MOLD HERE THERE'S
GONNA BE MORE THERE. RATHER THAN
WAITING FOR THE OTHER TENANT WHO
MAY OR MAY NOT WANT TO COMPLAIN.
BECAUSE MAYBE THERE ARE LOTS OF
REASONS WHY PEOPLE DON'T FILE
COMPLAINTS. WITH THEIR FEAR OF
ACTION MAYBE THERE'S OTHER
PROBLEMS- THAT THEY CAN
REASONABLY GO AND SAY FROM THE
LOOK FOR MOLD AND THAT OTHER
THING SAYS VERY NEARLY FOCUSED
ON HEALTH AND SAFETY. DOES NOT
HAVE TO DO WITH BUILDING CODE
VIOLATIONS WHICH IS WHAT THE
FREMANTLE LISTENING. OKAY SO
FOLLOWING UP ON THAT- IT'S MY.
M. IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING OF THE
X. TIME TO. READING HERE- IT'S
MY UNDERSTANDING THE SUBJECT. D.
HAVE SEX ONE SEVENTY NINE
SEVENTY. FIVE OF THE HEALTH AND
SAFETY. CURRENTLY REQUIRES A
CITY OR COUNTY TO PROVIDE FOR.
CERTIFIED COPIES OF AN
INSPECTION. IS CITATIONS ISSUED
IF ANY. TO THE COMPLAINING
TENANT RESIDENT OCCUPANT OR
THEIR AGENT- SO IF THE
INSPECTION REVEALS A CONDITION
POTENTIALLY AFFECTING MULTIPLE
TENANTS. RESIDENTS OR OCCUPANTS
INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO
CONDITIONS RELATING TO THE
PREMISES COMING EREKLE LAW. M.
THE REST OF THE- OF THE TENNIS.
COULD BE NOTIFIED. THIS IS PER
THE DISCO IS THE COULD BE
NOTIFIED BUT THIS IS A LONG THEM
TO DO IS NOT JUST NOTIFY THE
TENT THAT THEY MAY HAVE
SOMETHING WRONG. IT ALLOWS THE
CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER TO FROM
ACTIVELY GO IN THERE. AND MOST
GOOD LANDLORDS WANT THIS MOST
GOOD LANDLORDS IF YOU'RE GONNA
COME OUT AND ABATE MOLD AND ONE
UNIT WANT TO KNOW THAT THERE'S
MOLD AND MULTIPLE UNITS THAT'S
WHAT THE GOOD BY AND LARGE AND I
WANT TO DO. SO WHEN I TALK TO MY
LOCAL REALTORS AND EXPLAINED THE
BILL THEY WERE LIKE ACTUALLY WE
WOULD LOVE IT IF SOMEBODY TOLD
US THAT THEY THINK IT'S MULTIPLE
UNITS AND THEY INSPECTED ALL ONE
TIME. BECAUSE ACTUALLY CHEAPER
FOR US TO COME OUT AND FIX IT
ALL AT ONE TIME. SO I THINK
THERE'S ONE THING ABOUT
NOTIFYING THE TENANTS ANOTHER
THING ABOUT GIVING THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER THAT RIGHT.
TO GO IN AND I CAN GIVE AN
EXAMPLE WHEN I WAS WALKING WHEN
I WAS RUNNING FOR. CITY COUNCIL
AND CITIZENS ACTUALLY NOT TOO
FAR AWAY FROM WHERE I USED TO
LIVE- WE KNOCKED ON A DOOR. AND
I OPEN THE DOOR AND- THE TENANTS
DIDN'T WANNA LET ME IN BUT I CAN
SMELL THE MOLD I COULD SEE THE
BLACK MOLD. AND THERE MAYBE TWO
OR THREE FAMILIES LIVING IN A
ONE BEDROOM UNIT IN THIS
APPLICATION. AND SO I COULD
UNDERSTAND THE HESITANCY OF
SOMEBODY IN THAT SITUATION. NOT
WANTING TO CALL CODE
ENFORCEMENT. BUT THERE WERE
CHILDREN IN THE HOUSEHOLD AND SO
WHEN I ACCEPTED THE SPONSORED
BILL. YOU KNOW I HAVE A LOT OF
TOUCH SHOULD BE SPECIAL SERVICES
SPONSORED BY. I ACTUALLY THOUGHT
BACK AND SAID. WHAT HAPPENS FELT
FAMILY. FOR THOSE TWO FAMILIES
LIVING IN THIS UNIT. BECAUSE
THEY WANT TO STAY THERE THEY
SOME HONESTY THEY'RE GOING TO
THOSE GREAT SCHOOLS. BUT THOSE
KIDS GROWING UP THEIR DISTANCES
THE HIGHER A PROPENSITY THAT
THERE HAVE ASTHMA. IS NOT WHAT
WE SHOULD BE DOING IS CALIFORNIA
AND WE SHOULD BE PROTECTING
THEM. AND IF SAY THAN THE UNIT
NEXT DOOR. CALLS AND THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER BECAUSE
THERE. IS THIS MASSIVE MASSIVE
ROOF LEAK. THE LANDLORD WOULD
WANT TO FIX THE WHOLE ROOF FOR
THE ONE TIME. NOT JUST THAT ONE
AND THEN NOTIFY THE OTHERS AND
THEN YOU'RE PUTTING A BURDEN ON
THEM. THEY DON'T WANNA GET
AFFECTED. AND SO THIS IS REALLY
ABOUT KEEPING CHILDREN OF
CALIFORNIA SAFE. FROM. REALLY
SUB STANDARD HEALTH. HI HEALTH
CAN. AND SO THAT'S WHY I'M- THIS
SO THEY CAN. THE PRO THAT YOU
KNOW YOU'RE NOT WAITING FOR A
CLAYTON TO COME FORWARD. THE
LEADING THE CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICER GO INTO WHAT THEY'RE
SUPPOSED TO DO. LET THE LANDLORD
KNOW. BUT THE LANDLORDS FIX IT.
AND MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE
HEALTHY HOUSING FOR ALL
CALIFORNIANS SO I. KNOW COMPLAIN
AND NOT ON THAT FRONT. SO THE SO
THE FOLLOWING. FOLLOW UP
QUESTION WOULD BE. SO THAT WITH
THIS BILL- AND POWER THAT HOME
INSPECTOR OR THAT. THAT PROPERTY
INSPECTOR. TO GO INTO THOSE
HOMES WITHOUT THE OWNERS OR THE
TENANTS PERMISSION. TO BE ABLE-
YES I CAN ANSWER BECAUSE A CODE
ENFORCEMENT WANTS TO ONLY
CONSENT FROM THE TENANT. BEFORE
ENTERING THE UNIT THAT MEANS THE
CODE ENFORCEMENT. MUST CONTACT
THE TENANTS. INFORM THEM OF
THEIR DESIRE TO INSPECT THE UNIT
AND THEN SEEK THEIR CONSENT
BEFORE ENTERING THE UNIT. TO ITS
COULD US THE CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICER TO COME BACK IN A- MORE
CONVENIENT TIME. AND THE WORST
CASE SCENARIO WHERE YOU'RE DOING
WITHOUT A REAL HEALTH AND SAFETY
LIKE WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT BLACK
MOLD THAT'S LIKE A REAL HEALTH
AND SAFETY ISSUE RIGHT- THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT COULD KEEP. SEEK AN
INSPECTION WARRANT. THAT ALLOW
THEM TO INSPECT THE UNIT WITHOUT
THE CONSENT. IF THE COSTA CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FEELS
THERE'S AN IMMINENT RISK TO
HEALTH AND SAFETY. SO THERE'S A
THERE'S A THERE'S A WARRANT
PROCESS THAT IS IN PLACE THAT WE
HAVE NOW THIS BILL DOESN'T
EMPOWER THEM TO DO THAT AT THAT
ALREADY EXISTS. WHAT THIS DOES
IS IT JUST MAKES IT EASIER FOR
THEM TO GO IN. AND MAKE A LIVING
CONDITIONS EASIER BECAUSE RIGHT
NOW. ALL BECAUSE YOU KNOW IF YOU
WERE SERVED ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
YOU KNOW IT'S A COMPLAINT BASED
SYSTEM. AND YOU KNOW LOTS OF
PEOPLE DON'T COMPLAIN FOR LOTS
OF REASONS. I'M ONE OF MY IT
ASKING THE QUESTION BECAUSE YOU
KNOW. IN ON ONE POINT YOU'RE
SAYING PEOPLE WON'T COMPLAIN
BECAUSE THEY'RE AFRAID TO.
INFORM THE LANDLORD TO INFORM
THE POWERS THAT BE THAT THERE'S
MULTIPLE. FAMILIES BUT ON THE
OTHER SIDE. MORE COMPELLING THEM
TO BE A TO COME IN AND IS.
BECAUSE OF- THEY STILL HAVE.
CONSENT THIS THIS. SO THE- WHEN
KNOW. IF LARGER. IT'S NOT JUST
MOLD IN THE BATHROOM BECAUSE
SOMEBODY DIDN'T EVEN LATER THAN
MIDNIGHT OR BROKE DOWN RIGHT
LIKE THAT'S NOT WHAT B. B. YOU
KNOW MY THING IS IF THERE IS A
ROOF LEAK. AND IT'S REASONABLE
TO EXPECT THAT MULTIPLE UNITS
WOULD BE AFFECTED. THERE'S NONE
I DON'T THINK ANY OF US WOULD
SIT THERE WANNA. OWN A HOUSE-
YOU KNOW BLACK MOLD GROWING FOR
THAT REASON YOU KNOW I'M ONE OF
FOR RENTERS IN THE ASSEMBLY-
I'VE- I'VE LIVED IN RENTAL
HOUSING WHERE I HAVE A COMPLAINT
TO THE LANDLORD BECAUSE- I HAD A
GOOD DEAL AND- SAID I CAN FIX IT
MYSELF RIGHT. THERE'S LOTS OF
REASONS FOR SOMEBODY CAME TO ME.
AND SAID HEY THERE WAS A ROOF
WEEK MAYBE YOU HAVEN'T SEEN IT.
CAN WE GO IN AND CHECK AND SEE
IF IT'S IN YOUR UNIT. AND I HAVE
MY LITTLE BABY WHEN MARTY WAS A
BABY I GET RIGHT LIKE THAT'S
WHEN IT STARTS I GUESS. I'M A
HEARTY PERSON I GET YOU. THAT'S
WHAT IT'S ABOUT IT'S NOT ABOUT
LIKE OVERSTEPPING ANYBODY'S
RIGHT WE PUT A LOT OF
GUARDRAILS. TO MAKE SURE THAT
WE'RE NOT OVERSTEPPING TENANTS
RIGHT OF PROPERTY RIGHT. YOU
KNOW OWNERS. RIGHTS WE WANT TO
STRIKE THAT BALANCE AND THAT'S
WHAT WE THINK THIS BILL THAT.
WERE BEFORE YOU THE CENTER LOGS
ZERO COMMENTS OR- OKAY CENTER
HARD MOVES A BILL- OKAY- WITH
THAT- I THINK YOU'VE- CLOSED
ALREADY BUT IF YOU WOULD LIKE
THAT CLASS FOR. LOVE IT THANK
YOU- WE WILL CALL THE ROLL THE
MOTION IS TO PASS. AS AMENDED.
TO THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
. SENATOR WINNER. WIENER I
TROUBLED. CLICK HERE. SIXTY AYE
A CAREER. EYES CABRERA FIVE
BECAUSE HE- COURTESY I MCGUIRE.
VIDEO VIDEO FIVE ZERO. SKINNER
UMBERG. NUMBER I WILL HAVE. HA
BY. SEVEN ZERO SEVEN ZERO FOR
THE ALONG CALL BEFORE YOU TO THE
NEXT BILL WITH. USED TO- IF YOU
THOUGHT CALIFORNIA CONSUMER
QUICKLY LEFT THE RESPONSE BOB
FIRST CALL ON BILLS THAT ARE ON-
THEN WE'LL PUT WITH SPELL. US
WE'LL START- THE TOP WITH A
NUMBER ONE. PERSON THROUGH THE
CONSENT- CALENDAR. LET'S CALL
THE ABSENT. REQUIRE SKINNER
NUMBER. NUMBER I BOB. THE HOBBIT
. NINETY
BOB I. NINE ZERO NINE ZERO
FEDERAL CUT BACK ON CALL COGNEX
IS ITEM NUMBER THREE EIGHTY
THREE OH NINE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
LEAVES CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
SENATOR WIENER. WIENER HI
MCGUIRE SKINNER NUMBER. FIVE
HUNDRED FIVE BOB. FIVE SIX TWO
SIXTY TWO POINT OF ON BECAUSE
MAX IS A FOR IT BEFORE TO BY
SOMEONE SOMEONE LEE PLEASE CALL
THE I. MEMBERS SENATOR WIENER HI
WIENER AYE MCGUIRE. SKINNER
AMBERG NINE HUNDRED WILL HOLD
BOB BY J. TO ONE IT'S ALL PART
OF A ON BECAUSE NEXT ADAM FIVE
AB THREE ONE EIGHTY PLACE OVER
AT US CALL THE UP MEMBERS.
SENATOR WIENER WIENER BY THE OF
. SEARCH WITH OUT OF. THAT IS.
YEAH MCGUIRE SKINNER BURKE. FIVE
HUNDRED ALL.
FIVE ZERO PUT IT BACK ON CALL
NEXIS ITEM NUMBER EIGHTY THREE
FOUR SIX BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
QUIRK-SILVA PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS CENTER CHOKE I
TROUBLED BY MCGUIRE THERE TOO
SKINNER- BURKE- HEIBERG BY EIGHT
ZERO THREE ZERO WHAT ABOUT A
PHONE CALL AND NUMBER NINE AB
FOUR SIX A PLACE. QUIRK-SILVA
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
SENATOR KABIRU. NEVER HI MCGUIRE
HERE TO SCARE NUMBER. AMBERG BY
EIGHT ZERO EIGHT ZERO WHAT ABOUT
ON CALL IN NEXT ITEM. BEFORE FOR
FIVE MEMBER WORKS PLEASE CALL
THE OFFICE MEMBERS SENATE
MCGUIRE SKINNER BURKE THAT
NUMBER FIVE EIGHT TO ONE TO ONE
BUT OUR CALL NEXT ITEM TO AB
THREE NINE BY US MEMBER WORKS
FOR CALL THEM MEMBERS. SENATE
REQUIRE SKINNER I'M BURKE I JUST
I WILL HAVE. BY SEVENTY TWO TWO
PROVIDE ON CALL NEXIS ADAM
THIRTEEN ABC FIFTH SEVEN SOMEONE
WORKS PLEASE CALL OFFICE OF MY-
ADOBO. NO THE TROUBLE NOW
MCGUIRE THERE ARE TWO SKINNER
NUMBER. AMBER BY SEVENTY ONE THE
ONE PROVIDE FALL WHEN EXCUSE.
RESIST. WHEN I FLEW TO EITHER
NUMBER EIGHTY. AB RIGHT.
FOR IT'S FAIR. TO SKINNER NUMBER
. THIRTY ONE. FIVE FIVE THE
WOMAN FOR THE BILL ON BACK ON
CALL. WHEN I SCHOOL IN NINETEEN
EIGHTY FOUR TO NINETY FIVE BY
SOME REMEMBER ANY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR
WIENER FIVE WIENER HI. ON CARE
HI. THERE TO SKINNER NUMBER.
NUMBER FIVE SEVEN ONE SEVEN
LOCAL CALLED ITEM TWENTY ONE
EIGHTY NINE SO SIX BY SOME TING
PLEASE CALL THE UP SOME. CENTER
REQUIRES SKINNER NUMBER NUMBER I
WILL HAVE. THIS THAT IS TIED TO
THE TO PUT IT BACK ON CALL- NEXT
ITEM TWENTY IS ONE OF THREE
THREE BY SOME TEN PLEASE CALL
OUT SOME OF. SENATOR WINNER
WIENER THE TRUTH OF. REQUIRE.
SKINNER NUMBER NUMBER BOB. SIX
ONE. SIXTY ONE PUT IT BACK ON
CALL MAX IS A NUMBER TWENTY
THREE AB SIXTEEN THIRTY THREE BY
SOME OVER TO PLEASE CALL THE
OFFICE AND- SENATOR WIENER HI
WIENER I AM. SKINNER NUMBER ALL
RIGHT I WILL HAVE.
ZERO FOUR O'CLOCK ON CALL. AND
THAT IS THAT WERE CAUGHT OFF
GUARD. OKAY THANK YOU CENTER I'M
BURKE- SO MEMBER THANK YOU FOR
YOUR PATIENCE AND ARE YOU MAY
PROCEED TO PRESENT- IN SEVENTEEN
EIGHTY FIVE EIGHTY NINE. GOOD
AFTERNOON INTERMEMBRANE AB FIVE
EIGHTY NINE WOULD UPON
APPROPRIATION BY THE LEGISLATURE
ESTABLISH A THREE YEAR PILOT
PROJECT OF THE UNICORN HOMES
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING FOR
HOMELESS LGBTQ YOUTH PROGRAM IN
THE COUNTIES OF SYMBOL SAN DIEGO
AND SACRAMENTO. A G. B. T. Q.
CENTERS WITHIN EACH OF THE
COUNTIES WOULD ADMINISTER THE
PROGRAM PROVIDING CRISIS
INTERVENTION WAS TRAUMA INFORMED
APPROACH TO HOUSING ELIGIBLE
YOUTH AND LGBTQ AFFIRMING HOST
HOMES. WHO IDENTIFIES- AND ARE
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS HAVE
GREATER DIFFICULTY FINDING
SHELTERS THAT ACCEPT AND RESPECT
FROM. OFTENTIMES LGBTQ
COMMUNITIES AT GREATER RISK OF
ASSAULT TRAUMA AND EARLY DEATH
COMPARED TO THEIR HETEROSEXUAL
PEERS. ADDRESSING THE HOUSING
CRISIS IS A KEY PRIORITY FOR THE
STATE BUT THERE'S NO STATE
HOUSING PROGRAM TARGETED
DIRECTLY AT LGBTQ YOUTH
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS. OR
UNICORN HOMES IS A PROGRAM
WITHIN THE NORTH COUNTY LGBTQ
RESOURCE CENTER THAT AIMS TO
PROVIDE CRISIS INTERVENTION AND
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING TO LGBTQ
YOUTH. EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
TO THE FAMILY REJECTION WITH AN
ULTIMATE GOAL TO REUNITE
FAMILIES WHEN POSSIBLE SIMILAR
PROGRAMS CALLED HOST HOMES EXIST
IN DOWNTOWN SAN DIEGO LGBTQ
COMMUNITY CENTER AND SACRAMENTO
LGBT COMMUNITY CENTER THAT HOPE
HOUSE LGBTQ YOUTH EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS. AND LGBTQ
AFFIRMING HOMES UNFORTUNATELY
DUE TO CHALLENGES ATTRIBUTED TO
THE PANDEMIC THE HOST OF THIS
PROGRAM HERE IN SACRAMENTO AT
THE LGBTQ CENTER HAD TO END ITS
OPERATIONS A FEW MONTHS AGO THEY
MADE THE DIFFICULT CHOICE TO
DIVERT THE FUNDS FROM HUD HOMES
PROGRAM. TO CONTINUE OPERATING
THEIR YOUTH SHELTER.
ESTABLISHING A UNICORN'S HOME
PILOT PROJECT WILL NOT ONLY
PROVIDE STABLE HOUSING FOR LGBTQ
YOUTH EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS.
BUT ALSO PROVIDE A PATH TO
MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES JOB
READINESS AND INDEPENDENT LIVING
SKILLS THROUGH THE L. G. B. T.
Q. CENTERS. THE CARD HOMES
PROGRAM DOES NOT REQUIRE THE
DEVELOPMENT OF NEW BUILT
INFRASTRUCTURE MAKING A LOW COST
FLEXIBLE INVALUABLE STEPPING
STONE WELL YOUTH WAIT FOR MORE
PERMANENT SOLUTIONS. WITH SO
MUCH INTOLERANCE AND HOSTILITY
TOWARD THE LGBTQ COMMUNITY THIS
PRIDE MONTH IT IS IMPERATIVE
THAT WE HAVE THE SAFETY NET FOR
POPULATION OF YOUTH. THAT
EXPERIENCES FAMILY REJECTION AT
A HIGHER RATE THAN THOSE OUTSIDE
THE L. G. B. T. Q. SPECTRUM. I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FROM AYE VOTE
IN MY WITNESS MASTERS THE POLICY
FOR WHO IS THE EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR OF THE NORTH COUNTY
LGBTQ RESOURCE CENTER WAS HERE
EARLIER BUT HE HAD TO CATCH A
FLIGHT BACK TO SAN DIEGO.
ALTHOUGH LATER FLIGHTS WERE
BOOKED OUT SO- I HAVE THIS
TESTIMONY. WITH ME HERE TODAY
AND ASKED FOR TWO WEEKS ENTERED
INTO THE RECORD SO THANK YOU
FOR- IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL
ANY- SO- TESTIMONY PLEASE COME
FOR. HYLA HE GETS ON BEHALF OF
THE- ACADEMY OF CHILD AND
ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. CRIPPLES FROM BEHALF
OF A QUALITY CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT. ANY
OPPOSITION IN THE HEARING ROOM.
OKAY WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
. IT FOR ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
TO THIS BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE HAVE
AT LEAST ONE KOLU SIGNALED THAT
THEY WISH TO SPEAK JUST A MOMENT
PLACE.
WELL NOW GO TO LINE SEVENTY FOR
YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN. THANK YOU
MR CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MORE TOP
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SAN
DIEGO IN SUPPORT. MISTER CHAIR
THERE IS NO ONE ELSE. YOU VERY
MUCH OF A BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
AND COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. OUR
MOTION BY CENTER PRETTY- I WANT
TO THANK THE AUTHOR- FOR DOING
THIS BILL ANDERSON IS VERY
PERSONAL FOR ME AND I SEE SOME
RESERVE- IS GONNA USE THAT TOO I
KNOW IT'S PERSONAL FOR HIM- YOU
KNOW WE HAVE- ALSO BE TWO TO.
FIVE YEARS ARE HEAVILY OVER. IN
THE HOMELESS POPULATION- IT WAS
ONLY ABOUT SEVEN OR EIGHT YEARS
AGO THE CALIFORNIA INVESTED
ALMOST NOTHING ABOUT A MILLION
DOLLARS A YEAR FOR THE WHOLE
STATE FOR LGBTQ YOUTH. TWO
THIRDS OF CALIFORNIA COUNTIES AS
OF A FEW YEARS AGO HAD NO USE
FOR SUFFOLK ALMOST PROGRAMS-
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO GET THE
MONEY. PUT ASIDE ANY NEARLY- ONE
IN THE CITY- A FEW YEARS AGO I
WAS IMPRESSED FRESNO FOR PRIDE-
THERE WAS A GUY WHO WAS TELLING
ME THAT HE HAD OPENED UP ABOUT
HIS GROUP IT OPENED UP. FRESNO'S
FIRST- YOU SPECIFIC SHELTER WITH
TWENTY FIVE BEDS AND ON THE
FIRST NIGHT WAS OPEN THREE
HUNDRED KIDS SHOWED UP FOR
THOSE. FOR THOSE TWENTY FIVE BUT
IT'S REALLY HEARTBREAKING
UNFORTUNATELY WE SAW EARLIER-
TODAY OVER IN THE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE AND WE SAW IT TODAY IN
THE ASSEMBLY. HUMAN SERVICES
COMMITTEE- WE SAW LAST WEEK IN
JUDICIARY- BILLS TO TRY TO
SUPPORT- YOUTH IN PARTICULAR
LGBTQ. YOUTH WHETHER- ALLOWING
THEM GREATER ACCESS TO MENTAL
HEALTH CARE BILL BY SOME MEMBER
CARILLO- A BILL THAT I AUTHORED
ON IT WASN'T SOMEBODY IN
SERVICES TODAY TO MAKE SURE THAT
LGBTQ FOSTER YOUTH. ARE PLACED
IN HOMES THAT ARE NOT GOING TO
REJECT THEM AND KICK THEM OUT
INTO THE STREETS. AND SO ON AND
SO OR MAKING SURE. THAT WHEN YOU
HAVE- A DIVORCE- THAT THE KIDS
ARE BEING PLACED IN A WAY THAT'S
NOT GOING TO RESULT FROM GETTING
KICKED OUT PLACED ON TO THE
STREETS AND UNFORTUNATELY WE
HAD. TO SET UP ALLOWED TO REALLY
VILE DISGUSTING- OPPOSITION.
FULL OPPOSITION. THE OF THOSE
PEOPLE HERE SO THIS BILL TO HELP
WHO ARE THE STREET. INSTEAD
THERE FOLK ON. KEEPING KIDS IN
HOSTILE HOMES THAT IN THEM BE
AND STREETS ARE WANNA SAY THAT
BECAUSE I THINK IT'S A- AND- AND
OF. COLLEAGUES ON WHY REALLY
GOING ON HERE THAT THERE ARE
PEOPLE WHO DON'T NECESSARILY.
CARE VERY MUCH ABOUT THESE KIDS
IT'S MORE ABOUT- THERE ARE-
WHATEVER IT IS THAT THEY'RE
READING ON SOCIAL MEDIA- THAT
DAY AND I JUST THINK IT'S VERY
VERY HARMFUL AND I'M JUST VERY
GRATEFUL THAT YOU'RE ACTUALLY
DOING SOMETHING. TO HELP THESE
KIDS THANK YOU. YOU MAY CLOSE
WELL THAT WAS MY CLOTHES SO.
ASSEMBLY FOR. I JUST WANT TO SAY
THAT- COMING FROM SAN DIEGO I
KNOW UNICORN HOMES AND IT'S
REALLY GREAT I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE
DOING THIS BILL AND I COMPLETELY
SUPPORT THANK YOU. PERFECT PLACE
FOR A VOTE. THANK YOU WILL CALL
THE ROLL. THE MOTION IS TO PASS
IN RE REFER THE COMMITTEE AND
HUMAN SERVICES SENATOR WINNER.
WINNER HI THE TROUBLES. LAKE
SUPERIOR FIVE WEEKS HERE HI.
CAROL KEMMERER. COURTESY BECAUSE
THE BY MCGUIRE. VIDEA ALL RIGHT
VIDEO ZERO. SKINNER AMBERG. BOB
HI BY. THE ZERO SIX PUT THAT ON
CALL THANK YOU SO NUMBERS. OKAY
SOME MEMBER CARILLO. THANK YOU
YOUR PATIENCE. YOUR TWO BILLS.
AS A FOOT OF SNOW WHICH WILL YOU
LIKE TO TAKE UP FIRST. THANKS TO
A TOP FIFTEEN OKAY I AM TWENTY
FOUR AB TOP FIFTEEN THE RIVER
CITY. THANK YOU MISTER KAREN
MEMBERS I AM PROUD 2% ASSEMBLY
BILL TWELVE THIRTEEN THE
PEGASYSTEMS SUPPORT OR POTS
PROGRAM AB TWELVE FIFTEEN WILL
REESTABLISH THE POTS PROGRAM TO
ADMINISTER AN AWARD GRANTS TO
HOMELESS AND DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
SHELTERS. ADDITIONALLY THIS BILL
WILL PROVIDE FOOD AND BASIC
VETERINARIAN SERVICES FOR PETS
AND ALLOW A PATHWAY FOR
PERMANENT HOUSING PLACEMENT
STUDIES SHOW THAT PETS PROVIDE
COMFORT AND HELP A TRAUMA AND
ABUSE WHEN PETS ARE SURRENDERED
LESS THAN 15% ARE REUNITED
REUNITED FURTHERING DEPRESSION
AND ANXIETY AMONGST THEIR
OWNERS. AROUND 10% OF IN HOUSE
CALIFORNIANS ON A PET A BELOVED
SOURCE OF DIGNITY SELF
RESPONSIBILITY SAFETY AND
COMFORT AT A TIME WHEN IT IS.
NEEDED THE MOST. AT THE SAME
TIME WHEN THE SHELTER COULD NOT
ACCOMMODATE AND ON HOUSE
INDIVIDUALS PET THE INDIVIDUAL
IS FAR MORE LIKELY TO REFUSE AN
OFFER OF SHELTER AND REMAIN
OUTSIDE. THAN THEY ARE TO
SURRENDER THEIR PET IN LOS
ANGELES FOR INSTANCE STUDIES
FOUND THAT NEARLY HALF OF PET
OWNERS EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
WERE TURNED AWAY. FROM SHELTERS
AFTER REFUSING TO SURRENDER
THEIR PETS. INTEREST IN
EXTENDING SHELTER SERVICES TO A
COP TO ACCOMMODATE PETS IS
GROWING. MORE SHELTERS ARE
UNDERSTANDING THE IMPORTANCE OF
THE HUMAN ANIMAL BOND AND ARE
WORKING TOWARDS ACCOMMODATING
PETS THE WORK OF AB TEL FIFTEEN
AS A WORTH THE USE OF RESOURCES.
AND WILL CREATE EXCELLENT
OPPORTUNITIES TO BUILD IN OUR
COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS TO BETTER
SERVICE CALIFORNIA'S OWNERS AND
THEIR PETS. BILL HAS RECEIVED
UNANIMOUS SUPPORT IN THE
ASSEMBLY AND HAS NO OPPOSITION
HERE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS
JENNY BURR THE CALIFORNIA STATE
DIRECTOR OF STATE AFFAIRS. FOR
THE HUMANE SOCIETY OF THE UNITED
STATES AND- SEKI SOUND OF A
POLICY MANAGER FOR THE PEOPLE
ASSISTING THE HOMELESSNESS
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
. THANK YOU CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS JENNY
BURKE AND I'M THE CALIFORNIA
STATE DIRECTOR FOR THE HUMANE
SOCIETY OF THE UNITED STATES. I
AM PROUD TO WORK ALONGSIDE THE
LOS ANGELES HOMELESS. SERVICES
AUTHORITY AND PEOPLE ASSISTING
HOMELESS AND ESPECIALLY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CARILLO TO CO SPONSOR AB
TWELVE FIFTEEN. TO HELP ADDRESS
CALIFORNIA'S ON GOING HOME
HOUSING AND HOMELESS CRISIS WE
NEED COMPREHENSIVE AND INCLUSIVE
SOLUTIONS WHICH IT MEANS MAKING
ACCOMMODATIONS FOR PAT. WE KNOW
AN OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF
AMERICANS INCLUDING MYSELF
CONSIDER THEIR PETS TO BE A PART
OF THEIR FAMILY. BUT FOR PEOPLE
IN AN ABUSIVE RELATIONSHIP ARE
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS THAT
BOND CAN BE EXPRESSIONIST WRONG.
CONTINUING CARE PROGRAMS AND
NONPROFIT SERVING THESE
POPULATIONS HAVE LEARNED IS THAT
PEOPLE WILL FORGO OR AVOID
SHELTERS BECAUSE THEY DON'T
ACCEPT THEIR PATHS. FOR MANY AT
THE PATH TO SEE FOR SHELTER
STARTS WITH THEIR COMPANION
ANIMALS SADLY IN CASES OF
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE VICTIMS WILL
DELETE DELAY LEAVING IN FEAR OF
DANGER AND FEAR OF THEIR-
SAFETY. PROVIDERS SEE FIRSTHAND
THEY KNOW THERE IS A NEED BUT
UNFORTUNATELY ALL TOO OFTEN
FINANCIAL CONSTRAINTS LIMIT THE
ABILITY TO WELCOME PAT. AB
TWELVE FIFTEEN WILL HELP
ADDRESSES GAP BY REESTABLISHING
THE PAST ASSISTANCE AND SUPPORT
PROGRAM. THIS PROGRAM IS
IMPORTANT GRANT RECIPIENTS TO
BOOST SUPPORT FOR THOSE THAT
THEY SERVE AND PROVIDE MUCH
NEEDED SERVICES THE TICKET
TYPICAL GRANT AND CONTRACT
DOLLARS DON'T COVER. THANK YOU
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION OF THIS
LEGISLATION AND WE URGE AND I
FELL ON AB TWELVE FIFTEEN. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH NEXT SPEAKER. GOOD
AFTERNOON TO REMEMBER AS IN THE
SALE OF YOUR NAILS THANK YOU FOR
THE OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY TODAY
MY NAME IS THE EXTENT OF ALL ON
THE PUBLIC POLICY MANAGER FOR
PATH. PATH AS ONE OF
CALIFORNIA'S LARGEST AND MOST
IMPACTFUL NONPROFIT HOMELESS
SERVICE PROVIDERS AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPERS ARE PROUD TO
BE HERE TODAY AS A CO SPONSOR OF
THE PAWS ACT. AND ABLE TO OUR
OTHER CO SPONSORS OF THE MAN'S
SOCIETY AND THE ONLY HOMELESS
SERVICES AUTHORITY. ALMOST THIS
IS A DRAMATIC EXPERIENCE STREET
OUTREACH TEAMS LIKE THE ONES WE
OPERATE A PATH TO SUCCEED WHEN
OUR APPROACH RECOGNIZES
SOMEONE'S TRAUMA. AND OFFERS
RESOURCES THAT MEET THAT
PERSON'S INDIVIDUAL NEEDS FOR
PET OWNERS THAT ALMOST ALWAYS
MEANS A PLACE TO STAY WHERE THEY
CAN KEEP THEIR ANIMAL
COMPANIONS. OWNERS EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS GENERALLY WON'T
ACCEPT A SHELTER ARRANGEMENT
THAT FORCES SURRENDERING ONE OF
THE ONLY LIVING BEINGS GIVING
THAT PERSON UNCONDITIONAL
SUPPORT. WHEN OUR SHELTERS CAN
ACCOMMODATE PETS I CAN TELL YOU
THE ENVIRONMENT IS MUCH MORE
WELCOMING AND THE HEALTHY AND
HAPPY ANIMALS HELP DE ESCALATE
CONFLICTS AND PANIC ATTACKS. AND
EVEN IF PEOPLE OF DEPRESSIVE
EPISODES OF COURSE ANY PET OWNER
KNOWS PETS COST MONEY OUR
OPERATING BUDGETS ARE STRETCHED
THIN AS IT IS. THAT'S WHY THE
ONE TIME PAD ASSISTANCE GRANTS
WERE SO HELPFUL FOR OUR STAFF
AND RESIDENTS AND WEBER CO
SPONSORING THE CONTACT TO MAKE
THESE PROGRAMS AN ONGOING
OPPORTUNITY FOR THE STATE'S
ALMOST RESPONSE SYSTEM. BETTER
SHELTER FOR SINGLE ADULTS AND AS
A MEMBER COULD USE DISTRICT IN
LOS ANGELES FOR EXAMPLE. WE
PURCHASED COLLARS LEASHES FLEA
AND TICK MEDICINE. ANOTHER
IMPORTANT ITEMS FOR ANY PET
OWNER. WE'VE ALSO BEEN ABLE TO
COVER VETERINARY SERVICES SO
EVERYONE IN THE SHELTER HUMAN
AND ANIMAL. STAYS HEALTHY. I
WANT TO CLOSE THE STORY ABOUT
ONE OF OUR RESIDENTS IN ORANGE
COUNTY NAME RICHARD AND HIS DOG
PRINCESS. RICHARD CAME TO OUR
SHELTER IN TWENTY TWENTY AFTER
PRINCESS WAS HIT BY A CAR. AND
HE MADE IT VERY CLEAR THAT HE
COULDN'T DO ANYTHING WITHOUT
PRINCESS BY HIS SIDE. PROCESS
COULD BARELY WALK BUT HE'D CARRY
HER EVERYWHERE HE COULDN'T.
SITTING ON THE PHONE WITH HER
AND BRING HER ON HALTING LIMPING
LOCKS. FACE THE ONETIME BEST
SYSTEMS GRANT WE RECEIVED THE-
WE WERE ABLE TO COVER PRINCESS
MEDICAL PROCEDURES. AND IS NOW
BACK TO BROWN ACROSS OUR SHELTER
GROUNDS READY TO PLAY FETCH.
RICHARD TOLD US SEEING PRINCESS
RECOVER. GAVE HIM THE STRENGTH
TO FIGHT FOR HIS OWN RECOVERY.
HE'S RECEIVING TREATMENT FOR IT
IS A- HE- AND IS HONEST TO
PERMANENT HOUSING. WITH PRINCESS
OF COURSE. THE PROJECT WILL
MOORE SHOW. OP LIKE OURS SO CAL.
LIKE AND- DON'T HAVE TO YEARS
OUR STREETS FOR HELP. IT'S A
SMART INVESTMENT THAT LETS US
MAKE THE MOST OF OUR SHELTER AND
OUTREACH PROGRAMS. RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
ZERO MUCH OKAY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENT HAS COME
FORWARD AND SAY YOUR NAME. AND
AFFILIATION IF ANY. GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS I'M BARBARA SCHMITZ. I
WORK WITH THE SAN FRANCISCO SPCA
AND WE'RE IN SUPPORT. SURE
WINNER AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE RAFI RATE BECAUSE
PRESIDENT OF THE YOUNG LEADERS
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE. ON
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA STUDENTS IN
SUPPORT. HI FOR MANY DAYS IS
THAT RIGHT HAS PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF OF UNITED WAY GREATER LOS
ANGELES IN SUPPORT. WITH THE
KIDS ON A HERE ON BEHALF OF CAL
ANIMALS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
RESEARCHER MEMBERS MADISON TO
ONLY BECAUSE A WITH POLITICAL
SOLUTIONS ON BEHALF OF ROVER
.COM IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE ROOM.
SITTING NINE IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINES. FOR THOSE
WHO WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN
ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE'RE GOING
TO GO TO LINE SEVENTY NINE YOUR
LINE IS NOW OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON
REBEKAH CONSULTANT FOR THE
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF. SOCIAL
WORKERS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN
SUPPORT. WE'RE GONNA GO TO LINE
EIGHTY TWO YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN
. HELLO MY NAME IS DONNA TANK ON
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE LOS
ANGELES HOMELESS SERVICES
AUTHORITY. HOW FILED SPONSORED.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO LINE FIFTY
EIGHT LINE FIFTY YOUR LINE IS
NOW OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON
ELIZABETH ORRICK CALIFORNIA
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR BEST FRIENDS
ANIMAL SOCIETY IN STRONG SUPPORT
. NOW MOVE ON TO LINE FIFTY
THREE YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE- ACTIVE AND REYES THE
FROM THE ASPCA SUPPORT AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST OPPORTUNITY
ONE BRIEF COMMON UNTIL AS A
POSSIBLE- MAYBE LIKE TEN SECONDS
. YEAH I DID WANTED TO MAKE
AMENDMENT MADE IN THE BILLION
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE PET
GIRL. SO FOR THE VILLAGE OF
USERS. WHILE BILL YOU'RE
BARRIERS TO ACCESSING HOW IN THE
HOPE THE COVER OFFICE BOTH
PEOPLE AND PETS FOR LONGER TERMS
MOVIE TO PERMIT HOUSING. AT THE
NUMBER LIVE INDOORS THIS
BEHAVIORAL SUPPORT NEEDS
CRITICAL TO ENSURING THAT THERE
COULD TWENTY THOUSAND THE DOW- I
YOU THANK YOU STATION THANK.
THANK YOU BRING BACK THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS SUNDERLAND. THE BILL
FOR BREAD BUT I ALSO HANDLE BILL
ON HAVE FULL SUPPORT- GOOD WORK
THANK YOU FOR. YES CENTER WORKS
HI I SEE THAT THIS SIMILAR BILL
FROM HERTZBERG DIDN'T MAKE IT
OUT OF APPROPRIATIONS AND
ASSEMBLY FOR THE PREVIOUS THREE
YEARS AND I WAS JUST WONDERING
IF- WHAT IS THE PRICE TAG ON
THIS I DIDN'T SEE THAT. WELL
PART OF OUR SUCCESS IS BEING
ABLE TO NEGOTIATE SENATOR THERE
IS A THIRTY MILLION DOLLAR
BUDGET ALLOCATION THAT WE ARE
WORKING PARALLEL AT THE SAME
TIME. BEING IN THE CHAIR OF A
OUR ASSEMBLY BUDGET COMMITTEE ON
STATE ADMINISTRATION WHICH WE
OVERSEE HOUSING AND HOMELESSNESS
ALSO PLAYS A ROLE IN ENSURING
THAT WE ARE ABLE TO ALLOCATE THE
FUNDING NECESSARY WHICH IS
SELLING CONVERSATION AT THIS
MOMENT BUT MOVING THIS PIECE OF
POLICY FORWARD- IS A STEP IN THE
RIGHT DIRECTION AND ENSURING
THAT WE ARE. LOOKING AT ALL
POSSIBLE AVENUES TO HELP OUR OWN
HOUSE COMMUNITIES- IT DOESN'T
SOLVE HOMELESSNESS BUT IT'S
CERTAINLY- MOVES THE NEEDLE IN
THE RIGHT DIRECTION. THANKS. IT
SOUNDS LIKE A GREAT CLOSE. THANK
YOU FOR YOU YOU MAY YOU MAY
CLOSE. I DON'T KNOW IF YOU'RE
GONNA TALK ABOUT BUT HE FELL
CONTRACT YOU KNOW BECAUSE SHE'S
CONCERNED- I JUST REALLY JUST
WANT TO THANK OUR SPONSORS AS
WELL AS A SPECIAL RECOGNITION TO
THE SILVERLAKE ECHO PARK LOS
FELIS ATWATER VILLAGE HOLLYWOOD
SELA. NEIGHBORHOOD HOMELESSNESS
COALITION WHICH ENGAGES IN MY
DISTRICT- EVERY WEEK EVERY MONTH
TO ENSURE THAT FOLKS KNOW WHAT
THOSE RESOURCES ARE AVAILABLE TO
THEM. AND IN PARTICULAR IN LOS
FELIS THANKS TO PASSED THE LOSS
AND OUR SPONSORS. WE HAVE ANY-
ANY. A SHELTER THAT ALLOWS FOR
PETS THAT I RECENTLY HAD THE
OPPORTUNITY TO VISIT VISIT WITH
THE RESIDENTS. AND REALLY TRY TO
SEE FIRSTHAND HOW THIS ACTUALLY
CAN CHANGE LIVES AND SO WITH
THAT I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU THANK YOU-
AND WE HAVE A MOTION. BY SENATOR
WAHAD. AND THAT WOULD BE TO PASS
THE BILL TO APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE I WILL CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR WINNER. WINNER BY THE
TROUBLED LIKE SPEAR I PLEASE
VERIFY CABALLERO. BECAUSE HE.
PARTISI HI MCGUIRE VIDEA. VIDEA
I HERE TO HI SARAH BUY SKY-
BURKE WILL HELP. BOB THANKS TO
THE- SIX ZERO PUT ON. AND NOW WE
WILL GO- I DON'T FOR FIVE AB
SIXTY- SO. ASSEMBLY MEMBER. IF
YOU. WELCOME TO THE OF. I
THOUGHT I WAS. THE MOST
IMPORTANT BILL. THE FORTY K.
THANK YOU AGAIN MR TO AND MEMBER
SAME PER TO ENTER A SIXTY L.
SEVEN WITCHES FOLLOW UP. TO SB
SIX SEVEN NINE BY OUR- CALL NOW
CA COM LONGER FROM LAST YEAR IS
SOUTH THE LAW ANGELES COUNTY FOR
HOUSE. SOLUTIONS OTHER KNOWN AS
LUKASZ. HOUSING FOR LOW INCOME
PEOPLE ACROSS LOS ANGELES COUNTY
SEVERELY OVERCROWDED RACIALLY
SEGREGATED AND OFTEN NOT LINKED
TO HIGH QUALITY RESOURCES LIKE
TRANSIT JOB SCHOOLS OR PARKS AS
A RESULT 79% OF EXTREMELY LOW
INCOME HOUSEHOLDS IN LOS ANGELES
COUNTY YOU'RE PAYING MORE THAN
HALF OF THEIR INCOME. ON HOUSING
COSTS COMPARED TO JUST 3% OF
MODERATE INCOME HOUSEHOLDS
ACOSTA WAS CREATED FOR THE
PURPOSE OF ADDRESSING THIS
HOUSING CRISIS BY FACILITATING
THE PRESERVATION AND
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING ACROSS L. A. COUNTY THE
AGENCY WAS ALSO GIVEN THE
AUTHORITY TO ACQUIRE LAND. FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AB SIXTEEN OH
SEVEN EXPEDITES THE CONSTRUCTION
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN L. A.
COUNTY BY EXEMPTING LAND
TRANSFER TO PURCHASE BUY OR
LEASE BY. FOR CASA FOR
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING. FOR USE CONSISTENT WITH
THE SURPLUS LAND ACT IT ALSO
CLARIFIES THE SELECTION PROCESS
FOR CHOOSING THE ELIGIBLE SMALL
CITY REPRESENT REPRESENTATIVE.
TO THE TWENTY ONE MEMBER BOARD
OF DIRECTORS. AB SIXTEEN OH
SEVEN WILL FURTHER THE GOALS AND
MISSIONS OF THE COST OF
CONSTRUCTION OF CONSTRUCTING AN
- SERVE AFFORDABLE HOW. IN OUR
REGION THE BILL PASSED THE
ASSEMBLY POLICY COMMITTEES WITH
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. AND HAS NO
OPPOSITION IT IS A REGIONAL BILL
TO L. A. COUNTY. AND HERE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS HOLLY FROM
MEDIA. FROM INDY I'M SORRY IT'S
TAKEN ME UNDER HIS COMPANY. HIS
ON BEHALF OF UNITED WAY LA WHO'S
A SPONSOR OF OUR BILL. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR- JUST REALLY HERE
FOR TECHNICAL SUPPORT- AND JUST
A REMINDER THAT LACROSSE IS ONLY
ONE OF TWO REGIONAL AGENCIES
THAT HAVE BEEN CREATED IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND IS THE
ONLY ONE THAT ISN'T. TRULY AN
INDEPENDENT AGENCY WITH THE
AUTHORITY TO PURCHASE LAND SO
IT'S FURTHERING THE SURPLUS
LANDS ACT- IT IS JUST THAT IT'S
ONLY SUPPORTING THE AGENCY'S
LAND AND MONEY IS ONLY
SUPPORTING 1100% AFFORDABLE
HOUSING PROJECTS IN THE FUTURE
SO THAT ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS
I CAN HELP WITH AND I- DRIVE
OUT. THANK YOU THANK YOU ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE
HEARING ROOM. SEEING NONE IS
THERE ANY OPPOSITION. IN ORDER
TO THE PHONE LINES. PLEASE PRESS
ONE THEN ZERO IF YOU WISH TO
COMMENT IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
TO THIS BILL. THE SECURE THERE
IS NO ONE'S WILL BRING BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. MOTION BY SENATOR
CORTEZ THE AND YOU MAY CLOSE.
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
MISTER KAREN MEMBERS. OKAY THANK
YOU- WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
CORTEZ THE- CUT TO PASS THE BILL
TO THE GOVERNMENT'S FINANCE
COMMITTEE AND WILL CALL THE ROLL
. SENATOR WINNER. WINNER HI THE
TROUBLED LAKE SUPERIOR. PLEASE
VERIFY CABALLERO CORTESE. THE
REQUIRED FOR THE- WITH THE- ICE
HERE TO. HERE TO BUY SKY. I'M
BIRTH HUB. FIVE ZERO. THREE FIVE
ZERO PUT A LOCAL THING YOU- OKAY
- WE'VE TWO BILLS LAST. NEXT
CALL MISTER SUPER. TWENTY EIGHT
THIRD THIRTY FIVE AND MEMBER YOU
MAY PRESS.
MISTER MEMBERS SO IS WHY OF MY-
BILLS- I WOULD LIKE TO STAY BY.
THE COME STAFF FOR THEIR HARD
WORK ON THE AMENDMENTS- THAT I
BELIEVE ADDRESS CONCERNS BY THE
REMAINING OPPOSITION- I'M PROUD
TO PRESENT AB THIRTEEN THIRTY
FIVE LEGISLATION SPONSORED BY
BONDED HOUSING LOS ANGELES WHICH
STRENGTHENS THE SUSTAINABLE
COMMITTEES STRATEGIES PROGRAM OR
S. C. S. A LOCAL PLANNING
PROCESS THAT ENCOURAGES. MORE
HOUSING NEAR TRANSIT TO REDUCE
OUR RELIANCE ON CARS AND ADDRESS
OUR HOUSING AND CLIMATE CRISIS.
AB THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE ALIGN
CSCS PROGRAM WITH THE REGIONAL
HOUSING NEEDS ALLOCATION OR
READING A PROCESS AND MAKES IT
EASIER FOR CITIES AND COUNTIES
TO MEET THEIR HOUSING NEEDS IN A
MORE SUSTAINABLE WAY. CURRENTLY
THE ASSUMPTIONS AND INFORMATION
USED TO DEVELOP THE A CS ARE
DIFFERENT THAN THE ASSUMPTIONS
THAT CITIES AND COUNTIES USE FOR
THE RENO PROCESS AS A RESULT
THIS DISCREPANCY HAS LED TO AN
UNDER ESTIMATION OF HOUSING
NEEDS FOR CERTAIN AREAS IN THE
SCS PROCESS. WHEN SCS HOUSING
NUMBERS ARE LESS THAN THE RECENT
RENO HOUSING NUMBERS MUCH NEEDED
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS ARE UNABLE
TO ACCESS INCENTIVES LIKE SECRET
STREAMLINING AND SCS RELATED
GRANTS. AB THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE
ADDRESSES THIS PROBLEM BY
REQUIRING THAT SCS HOUSING
NUMBERS ARE NOT LOW AT LOWER
THAN RENO HOUSING NUMBERS THIS
BILL WILL MAKE IT EASIER FOR
CITIES AND COUNTIES. TO
IMPLEMENT SCS AND CREATE MORE
HOUSING NEAR TRANSIT. AB
THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE WILL ALSO
RESULT IN VALUABLE INFORMATION
ABOUT THE EFFICACY OF THE FCS
PROGRAM AND CREATES TRANSPARENCY
AROUND LOCAL PROGRESS TOWARDS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT. WITH ME
TODAY IS ANY HÌNH SHAKE ON
BEHALF OF ABUNDANT HOUSING LA
THE SPONSOR OF THE BILL TO
PROVIDE ADDITIONAL. INFORMATION
AND ASSIST WITH QUESTIONS. THANK
YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK YOU
HONORABLE WIENER AND THIS MEMBER
MANY IS AMY SHY I'M OR- A-
HOUSING LA THIS. OF ASSEMBLY
BILL ONE THREE THREE FIVE
ABUNDANT HOUSING LA BELIEVES IN
HOUSING FOR ALL GUIDED BY THE
VALUES OF RACIAL JUSTICE AND
EQUITY. THERE'S A LOT OF PARTS
OF MY STATEMENT THAT MR THE FOR
HAVE ALREADY STATED SO TRYING TO
SKIP TO THE FACT THAT AB ONE
THREE THREE FIVE IS ALSO KNOWN
AS THE STRENGTHENING THE
SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITY STRATEGIES
ACT. AS THERE ARE TWO PROCESSES
TO PLAN FOR HOUSING AT THE
REGIONAL LEVEL THE HOUSING-
NEEDS ASSESSMENT ARENA AND OUR
GPS YES THESE TWO PROCESSES ARE
FREQUENTLY MISALIGNED AND WHILE
CERTAINLY NOT ISOLATED TO ANY
ONE GEOGRAPHICAL AREA THIS LACK
OF ALIGNMENT BECAUSE LOGISTICAL
CHALLENGES AT THE SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
GOVERNMENTS WHICH- ULTIMATELY
CAUSED A SIX MONTH DELAY AND
HALVED. THE AMOUNT OF TIME THE
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CITIES HAD
TO COMPLETE THEIR HOUSING
ELEMENTS IN THE SIX AYE KARINA.
THE STATE EXTENDED THE CCAC
REGION'S DEADLINE FOR A COMPLAIN
HOUSING ELEMENT BY PASSING S. B.
ONE NINETY SEVEN IN TWENTY
TWENTY TWO. ASSEMBLY BILL ONE
THREE THREE FIVE ADDRESSES TWO
ASPECTS OF THE PROBLEM FIRST IT
REQUIRES THAT HOUSING TARGETS
FOR SHORT TERM PLANNING AN S. U.
S. B. DIRECTLY ALIGNED WITH THE
REGIONAL HOUSING NEEDS A
TERMINATION AND IT ALSO REQUIRES
THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS REPORT ON
THEIR PROGRESS TOWARD PRODUCING
HOUSING IN THE MOST CLIMATE
FRIENDLY LOCATIONS. IN THEIR
GENERAL PLAN ANNUAL PROGRESS
REPORT THIS WILL ENABLE LOCAL
CITIZENS WERE INTERESTED IN THE
TOPIC TO ENGAGE WITH THE
TRANSPARENT INFORMATION THANK
YOU ALL VERY MUCH AND WE
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST HER AYE
VOTE. THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT. IN THE HEARING ROOM. I
THINK SOMEONE COME FORWARD. A
DIFFERENT. THANKS VERY MUCH THE
CAMERA BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT AND THANK YOU TO THE
AUTHOR AND SPONSORS FOR WORKING
WITH US THANK YOU. THANK YOU ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT. THIRTY NINE
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
HEARING ROOM. HELLO SABRINA
BRADBURY WITH THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF COUNCILS OF
GOVERNMENTS. AS I WANT TO THANK
THE AUTHOR FOR COMING TO OUR
LEGISLATIVE DAY RECENTLY. WELL
WE'RE NOT ON RECORD AS OPPOSING
THE BILL WE HAVE BEEN
TRANSPARENT ABOUT. OUR CONCERNS
WITH THE LEGISLATION. AND
APOLOGIES FOR MISSING THE
DEADLINE ON GETTING THE LETTER
AND- BUT WE DO NEED TO EXPRESS
OUR OPPOSITION FOR A COUPLE OF
REASONS. THAT ALL HIGHLIGHT
TODAY FIRST- CURRENT LAW UNDER.
GOVERNMENT CODE SIX FIVE OH
EIGHT FOUR POINT OH FOUR M.
ALREADY REQUIRES CONSISTENCY
BETWEEN THE SCS AND RINA AND TO
OUR KNOWLEDGE NO SCS HAS BEEN
CHALLENGED ON THE GROUNDS OF NOT
BEING CONSISTENT WITH RITA. SO
WE ARE. OUR QUESTION IS THERE A
NEED FOR THIS ADDITIONAL
REQUIREMENT. WE ARE ALSO
CONCERNED ABOUT THE TIMING
ASSOCIATED WITH ADOPTING AN R.
T. PSCS AND WHEN YOU HAVE TO
HAVE A FINAL RINA ALLOCATION
DETERMINATION. AT THIS POINT THE
PROCESS- EACH CITY'S FINAL
DETERMINATION OF THE RENOWNED
FOR REGION OCCURS EIGHT MONTHS
AFTER THE ADOPTION OF AN ARTY
PSCS. AND SO THIS IS A VERY
TIGHT TIME LINE TO HAVE THOSE
NUMBERS MATCH EXACTLY. FINALLY
WE JUST WANT TO SAY THAT THE
FORECAST THAT WE USE IS TO MAKE
RESPONSIBLE TRANSPORTATION
INVESTMENTS AND IT'S AN
ITERATIVE PROCESS WE ARE ON
RECORD AS SUPPORTING AT GREATER
INVESTMENT IN TRANSIT. AND AT TO
HELP ADDRESS THAT FISCAL CLIFF
IF THOSE FUNDS DON'T MATERIALIZE
THEN THE HOMES MAY NOT
MATERIALIZE OR WON'T HAVE THE
MOBILITY OPTIONS THAT THEY NEED.
AND SO WE SUPPORT THE RENEWAL
PROCESS WE WANT TO PLAN FOR
THOSE HOMES WHO WANT THEM TO BE
BUILT. AND M. IF THOSE HOMES ARE
AREN'T CONSTRUCTED WE NEED A WAY
TO LOOK AT THAT IN OUR S. YES
GROWTH FORECAST AND ACCOMMODATE
FOR THAT SO WHEN- WE ASSUME THAT
THE HOUSES WILL BE THERE AT THIS
THAT YOU KNOW RAIN AS A PLANNING
AND ZONING EXERCISE AND WE NEED
TO. ACCOMMODATE THAT MUCH
HOUSING TO OCCUR BUT IF THAT
MUCH HOUSING DOESN'T OCCUR- WE
NEED A WAY TO ACCOUNT FOR THAT
AND WE UPDATE THIS PLAN EVERY
FOUR YEARS. SO WITH THAT WE
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE THE BILL AT
THIS TIME THANK YOU. THANK YOU
NEXT SPEAKER. SURE MEMBERS NICK
GRAHAM ON BEHALF OF THE SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
GOVERNMENTS THAT WE DO REMAIN
OPPOSED. TO THIS MEASURE WE
APPRECIATE- THE WORKING
COMMITTEE IS DONE THE AUTHORS
STAFF ON THE RECENT AMENDMENTS
BUT WE'RE STILL CONCERNED- AS
HIGHLIGHTED IN THE ANALYSIS. OF
THAT THE BILL MAY BE PREMATURE-
A CD IS CURRENTLY UNDERGOING A
WORKING GROUP TO REVIEW EVERY
NOW AND HOW TO IMPROVE IT- THAT
WORK IS DO I BELIEVE I CAN THIS
YEAR. I WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE TO
LOOK BACK AND THINK ABOUT HOW TO
A LYING OUR WORK- WITH- A CD'S-
RECOMMENDATIONS AND THE WORK OF
THIS POLICE BODY. SO WE DO
REMAIN OPPOSED TO LOOK FORWARD
TO WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR. I
WOULD ALSO LIKE TO SEE THE
AMENDMENTS THEY'RE GONNA COME
OUT OF THE COMMITTEE AND WE CAN
DISCUSS THIS FURTHER. THANK YOU
. BUT YOU NEXT FIGURE. AND I
APOLOGIZE I MISSED THE SUPPORT
QUEUES ARE NOT IN OPPOSITION
HIGH FOR MANY DAY HAS SEUSS WITH
LIGHT HOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS HERE
IN STRONG SUPPORT TODAY ON
BEHALF IS FOR. CIVIC WELL AND
AGREE UNITED WAY GREATER LOS
ANGELES THANK YOU. THANK YOU ANY
ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION. IN THE
ROOM. WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE
LINES. PLEASE PRESS ONE TO ZERO
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
WE'RE GOING TO GO TO LINE EIGHTY
FIVE YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
AFTERNOON SURE MEMBERS BEYOND
TURNER WITH ENERGY LAWCENTER IN
SUPPORT. WELL NOW GO TO LINE
SEVENTY THREE. GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CARE LUIS MONTERO BEHALF BURY
COUNCIL IN SUPPORT ALIGN OUR
COMMENTS WITH THOSE OF THE
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION.
BLIND. EIGHTY YES BAKER PIERCE
OF ABUNDANT HOUSING LA HERE IN
SUPPORT A GREAT WAY TO ALIGN OUR
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING PLANNING
THANK YOU SO MUCH. WELL NOW GO
ON TO LINE. SIXTY THREE. GOOD
AFTERNOON NATASHA GLASS GONE ON
BEHALF OF ABANDONED HOUSE IN LOS
ANGELES IN SUPPORT OF. MISTER
CHAIR WE HAVE ONE ADDITIONAL
PERSON IS SIGNALED THEY WISH TO
SPEAK JUST A MOMENT PLEASE. WILL
NOW GO ON TO LINE. EIGHTY FOUR.
HELLO THIS IS KIND OF SIGNED
POLICY AND RESEARCH DIRECTOR
WITH FUND HOUSING LOS ANGELES
PRODUCT SPONSORS THIS BILL THANK
YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
MISTER CHAIR THERE IS NO ONE
ELSE. OKAY WILL BRING BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. MOTION BY
SENATOR WILL HOG. OKAY AND- YOU
USE IT YOU ACCEPTED THE
AMENDMENTS CORRECT YES I DID
THANK YOU SORRY FOR MISSING
THAT- OKAY- THANKS FOR BRINGING
THIS BILL THANK YOU FOR WORKING
WITH THE COMMITTEE I THINK IT'S
A REALLY NOBLE GOAL TO TRY TO
ALIGN THESE TWO PROCESSES USED.
HAVING GONE THROUGH BOTH OF THEM
AND WHEN I WAS A LOCAL
GOVERNMENT- IT'S PROBABLY LONG
OVERDUE I DON'T KNOW YOU'LL
CONTINUE TO DIALOGUE WITH CITY.
COUNCILS OF GOVERNMENT- SO. WITH
THAT YOU MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- THINK YOU FOR
CONSIDERING THIS BILL- YOU KNOW
IN ADDITION THIS BILL SUPPORTED
BY THE BERRIER COUNCIL
CALIFORNIA BY MENTAL VOTERS
CIVIC WELL A CALIFORNIA BUILDING
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION CLIMATE
ACTION CAMPAIGN A FIFTY OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS. THAT KNOW HOW
IMPORTANT IT IS FOR US TO ALIGN
OUR HOUSING NEAR TRANSIT- THE
REALITY AND YOU CAN LOOK IN YOUR
STAFF REPORT IS THAT THESE TWO
PROGRAMS ARE NOT ALIGNED- AND SO
IT ISN'T PREMATURE BECAUSE THESE
AGENCIES. HAVE NOT BEEN ASKED TO
ALIGN THE PROGRAMS AND THIS BILL
REQUIRES THAT THEY BE ALIGNED
AND GO THROUGH A PROCESS TO
ALIGN THEM- THE FAILURE TO DO
THAT WE WILL BE RESULTS IN THE
SCS NUMBERS. BEING TOO LOW- AND
SO- IT'S- THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
DOESN'T. HURT ANYONE- IT ONLY
REQUIRES IT RESULTS IN MORE
HOUSING IN THE SCS AREAS AND
MAKES THOSE. THOSE THOSE THAT
HOUSING- INCENTIVES AND PROGRAMS
TIPS TO SPUR THEM MOVE FORWARD
IT DOESN'T CHANGE THE RINGER
NUMBERS AT ALL- IT MOVES IF THE
RAIN AND NUMBERS ARE. OF LOWER
THAN THE SCS NUMBERS IT REQUIRES
THE- I'M SORRY. IT IT'S THE
OTHER WAY AROUND THE BASICALLY
BE IT WILL BUT YOU INCREASE SCS
NUMBERS RATHER THAN. EVER
LOWERING THE MARINA NUMBERS- SO
THIS IS A PRO HOUSING BILL AND
IT'S A HAVE BILL THAT BASICALLY
ALIGNS HOUSING THE TRANSIT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF A MOTION
BY SENATOR LOG TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO THE TRANSPORTATION
COMMITTEE. OVERALL THE ROLE.
SENATOR WINNER. WINNER I WOULD.
NO PHOTOBOOK NOW CLICKS HERE
CLICKS THERE I COVER YOUR-
COURTESY. CORTESE I'M A CO.
VIDEO VIDEA FISER TO SERVE OF NO
SKINNER- BURKE BOB. BOB BY. FIVE
TO FIVE TWO ON CALL THANK YOU
SUMMER. OKAY- WE'VE TO LIKE AND
I SOME MEMBER TOM HERE FIRST
HELLO MONTHS. THE SERVICE YOUR
BLOCKS BY THE CALL SO. THIS
GARCIA YOU MAY COME ITS ARE
SOMEONE- THAT YOU COULDN'T SEEM
BEHIND COLUMN IT. I HAVE A
PROBLEM USERS ARE ABLE TO POINT
OKAY SO THAT IS AB FOURTEEN NINE
AND YOU CAN THAT TIME BOTH MY-
IN OUR WITNESS BE BRIEF YOUR NOW
DIED. REALLY TO WHAT THE BILL
INTO ON DO AND IT'S- A MUCH MORE
COME PRICE. FOR FAR MORE HOUSING
IN THE STATE OF. LOOKING AT A
SPECIFIC PROGRAM AND IT'S
CRITERIAS AND SO WITH THAT
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
THANK YOU- WOOD WITNESSES MAY
COME FORWARD. OUR RESEARCH HERE
HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS MICHAEL
SAYS CENTER DECIDER AND I'M THE
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
CORPORATE A FEW ACCOMPLISHING
TELEPORTING. R. AS OF FORMER
CRIPPLED THAT ARE FOR FEDERAL.
THE SERVER THE FOR. OF THE STATE
OF. I'M HERE TODAY. TO EXPRESS
SUPPORT FOR A BI FOURTEEN THIRTY
NINE PASS AMENDED THIS BILL
WOULD AT AGE IN DEVELOPMENT OF
AFFORDABLE HIGH LOW INCOME
FARMWORKER HOUSING IN RURAL
AREAS FOR MANY YEARS FARMWORKERS
IN CALIFORNIA CONFIRMED SALAK
AFFORDABLE HOUSING OPTIONS OFTEN
LIVING IN CRAMPED SPACES OR IN
SUBSTANDARD LIVING CONDITIONS.
THE RECENT TRAGEDY IN HALF MOON
BAY FOR SURVIVORS WERE FOUND
LIVING IN SHAPING SHIPPING
CONTAINERS WITHOUT INSULATION.
HIGHLIGHTS THE DIRE NEED FOR
CHANGE. AB FOUR THIRTY NINE AIMS
TO ADDRESS THIS ISSUE BY. THE
CALIFORNIA TAX CREDIT ALLOCATION
COMMITTEE TO CONSIDER AMENDING
THE SCORING SYSTEM FOR THE LOW
INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT BY
GRANTING INCREASED CONSIDERATION
FOR FARMWORKER HOUSING PROJECTS.
THE TAX CREDIT COMMITTEE
ALLOCATES FEDERAL AND STATE TAX
CREDITS TO DEVELOPERS FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE
RENTAL HOUSING FOR LOW INCOME
CALIFORNIA'S HOWEVER. THE RULE
COMMUNITIES ARE OFTEN PENALIZED
FOR THEIR LACK OF ACCESS. TO
AMENITIES SUCH AS PUBLIC
TRANSFERS TRANSPORTATION PARKS
AND GROCERY STORES AB FOURTEEN
THIRTY NINTH GOAL IS TO
ULTIMATELY ALLOW. SKEWS ME
FARMWORKER HOUSING PROJECTS TO
BETTER COMPETE FOR TAX CREDITS
AND INCENTIVIZE THE DEVELOPMENT
. OF FARMWORKER HOUSING AND
RURAL AREAS. ALL EMPLOYERS EIGHT
THOUSAND FARMWORKERS IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. FOR ABOUT
SEVEN POINT 3% OF THE PRIVATE
SECTOR EMPLOYMENT IN THE STATE.
IN AGRICULTURE INDUSTRY THAT
PRODUCED FOR OVER FIFTY BILLION
DOLLARS IN REVENUE IN TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN I THINK IT'S
TIME TO PRIORITIZE THE WELL
BEING OF THE CENTRAL WORKERS. BY
ADDRESSING THEIR DIRE HOUSING
SITUATION. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AND I BUILT. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU FOR ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT OF PUBLIC
COMMENT IN THE ROOM. THIRTY NINE
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION. THREE
NINE WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
. TO GO TO LINE EIGHTY SIX. LINE
IS NOW OPEN. HELLO DANIEL
SANCHEZ ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT CENTER FOR
EMPLOYMENT TRAINING CENTRAL
VALLEY OPPORTUNITY CENTER FIELD
WITH ME WITH A TWENTY NINE
PROTEUS AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
MISTER CHAIR THERE IS NO ONE
ELSE. RATES OF WILL BRING BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE- IS THERE ROOM
MOTION A MOTION BY CENTER
WAFFLING AB FOURTEEN THIRTY NINE
ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS CALL
EIGHT. CASEY NINE. YOU MAY CLOSE
THANK YOU AT THE END OF YOUR
NELSON PAGE FIVE THERE'S A
QUESTION RAISE ABOUT SOME
AMBIGUITY WITH SOME OF THE
LANGUAGE. IN THE BILL OUR OFFICE
WILL BE TAKING A LOOK AT THAT
AND THE HOPE THAT WE ARE ABLE TO
CLARIFY THAT WITH THAT SPECTER
ASKED RIVAL. OKAY THANK YOU AND
THAT IS A MOTION TO PASS TO THE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE AND
WILL CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER WIENER I WOULD SHOW I
WHICH HI LOOKS. LIKE YOU'RE ON A
CONVEYER. HAS A- PRETENDS HE
REQUIRE VIDEO EXPEDIA I THERE TO
ZERO BY SKINNER- BURKE BOB. BOB
I. SEVEN ZERO OKAY SEVEN IS PUT
IT ON CALL- I'M GONNA SAY- FOR
THE- AND PROP SERGEANTS AND
OFFICERS WERE ALL HOUSING MEMBER
WHO. HAVE PLEASE- COME TO THE
ROOM WE ARE ON OUR LAST. BILL
THANK YOU. SOMEONE WITH WITH HIM
FOR WALKING THE HOUSING- YOU'LL
BE PER TO. FIFTY THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR I'M HERE AFTERNOON
OUR TO PROCESS AB FOURTEEN FIFTY
EIGHT D. THIS BILL. SICK TO CALL
A BECOME PROP IN OWNERS AS SUCH
BOARD ELECTION WHAT I'VE GOT A
FOUR HOME I IN IN. DEVELOP ON SO
NO LAST. I ALL AWAY THESE.
SPECIAL WAY I AS THE CHAU GOLEM
IN. REGULATING THEIR CA. ELECT
FOR A- PLAY B. AS AND MEET OUR
PARTY TO. CALIFORNIA A- LAW
SPELL OUT HOW A- ELECTION ADD TO
CAN. INCLUDING CALL.
REQUIREMENTS UNFORTUNATELY MY
ENJOY A NAY BOTH HOLD ELECTION
TO AND IN THE- TO MEET THEIR
MINIMUM. KALRA REQUIRED THIS
OFTEN READ IN BO MAN SAYING FOR
MANY YEARS. BECAUSE I A NAY VOTE
TO HAVE AND IT. IT IS ON THE-
AND EAST NOT HOW PUBLIC ALLOW
NOW. CONDUCTED FOR INSTANT NOTED
AT A MINIMUM WHAT NUMBER A PHOTO
. MUST PARTICIPATE BE FOR
SOMEONE CAN BE A TO THE LET'S
JUST LAY. THIS BIÂU CONTEND THAT
THE HIGH LEVEL OF THE CITY IN
THE ENJOY MORE UP. CORRECT TO
ELECT IS A GOAL HOWEVER IT A
CALIFORNIA STATE SAN AND STUDY
SENATE OPERATE UNDER ELECTIONS.
THAT ISSUE A MORE FOR. MANY MEN
WERE NOT BE AT LIKE. FOR DURING
THAT. TWENTY TWO PRIMARY ONLY
FORTY. FORTY FORTY FIVE BUT OF
PRICES VOTE. IN LA. SAUDI BUT
THIS OF IN THE ELECTION. AB
FORTY FEET EIGHT. SIX TO REMEDY
IT IS. A PROBLEM BY LOWING THE
CORN REQUIREMENT 220% OF
HOMEOWNERS IN THE EVENT THAT A
HIGH A QUORUM NOT MET. AND FOR
ELECTION TO BE PLACED ON HOLD
ELECTION MUST BE HELD TO ELECT A
BOARD. THIS BILL DOES NOT MAKE
ANY. CHANGES TO CORE REQUIREMENT
FOR ELECTION TO CHEN AND- ZHOU A
GO OPENING DOCUMENT OUGHT TO
RAISE FREE. I HAVE- TWO
WITNESSES. HE ARE TODAY WHO ARE
. SUPPORTING THE BILL AND I
HUMBLY ASK FOR YOUR BILL GREAT-
YOU'RE THE WITNESS CAN COME
FORWARD. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
AND MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SUPPORT AB
FOURTEEN FIFTY EIGHT. THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS LISA TRIPLET AND I'VE
BEEN- BOARD OF DIRECTORS ON MY
CONDOMINIUM FOR MANY YEARS I
ALSO WORK IN THE INDUSTRY AT A
MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION. BUT IT'S
REGARDING- QUORUM REDUCTION IT'S
CHALLENGING AND COSTLY TO HOLD
ELECTIONS BASED ON OUTDATED
GOVERNING DOCUMENTS ELECTIONS
THAT YIELD NO RESULTS BUT DRAIN
HOMEOWNER FINDS BECAUSE OF OUR
INABILITY TO OBTAIN A QUORUM. IN
FACT A STUDY BY THE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS IN
TWENTY TWENTY ONE STATED THAT
55% OF HOME BUYERS ARE
TRADITIONALISTS BOOMERS AND GEN
X. AND ONE OF THE ISSUES WITH
THAT IS THAT MANY OF THEM ARE
LIVING ON FIXED INCOMES SO THESE
ADDITIONAL COSTS CAN REALLY
IMPACT PEOPLE'S ABILITY TO STAY
IN THEIR HOMES. IT'S ALSO
HELPFUL TO UNDERSTAND THE EFFORT
THAT GOES INTO ATTEMPTING TO GET
A QUORUM- THERE'S A LOT OF
NOTICES THAT HAVE TO BE SENT
OUT- WITH WITHIN STATUTORY
TIMELINES- THE H. AND M. OUT THE
H. AWAY NOW MUST CONTRACT WITH-
AN INSPECTOR OF ELECTIONS WHICH
IS AN ADDITIONAL COST- THE H.
AWAY MUST MAIL OUT THE BALLOT
PACKAGE WHICH HAS VERY STRICT
REQUIREMENTS THAT END UP COSTING
HOMEOWNERS MONEY. ALL OF THAT
JUST TO GET US TO THE ANNUAL
MEETING. NOW WE HAVE MANY
ASSOCIATIONS THAT HAVE NEVER
ONCE COMPLETED AN ELECTION I
MYSELF SERVED FOR MANY YEARS
BECAUSE WE COULD NOT GET
ELECTIONS- WE COULD NOT GET THE
QUORUM REQUIREMENT- AND I'M
WORKING WITH AN H. AWAY NOW THAT
HAS A HOMEOWNER THAT'S ACTUALLY
SUING THE ASSOCIATION- BECAUSE
THAT H. AWAY HAD NOT BEEN ABLE
TO SECURE THE QUORUM. ODD THAT
THEY HAVE NEVER BEEN ABLE TO- IN
ORDER TO OPEN BALLOTS BECAUSE
THEY'RE QUORUM IS THIRTY THREE
AND A THIRD. OUT OF EIGHTY FOUR
HOMES THAT'S JUST TWENTY EIGHT
BALLOTS THAT AFTER SEVERAL YEARS
OF TRYING TO INCENTIVIZE RAFFLE
THEY'VE NOT BEEN ABLE TO DO BUT
THAT'S AT AN ADDITIONAL COST TO
THE ASSOCIATION TO MEET THOSE
GUIDELINES. IF THIS COMMUNITY
AND OTHER COMMUNITIES LIKE THIS
IN THE INDUSTRY WERE ABLE TO
ADJOURN THE MEETING AND
RECONVENE WITH A QUORUM AMOUNT
OF 10% WOULD BE ABLE TO FILL
VACANCIES ON THE BOARD AND BE
ABLE TO CONDUCT BUSINESS IN A
RESPONSIBLE. LEGAL AND
TRANSPARENT MANNER. HOAS MAY BE
ABLE TO GET MORE OWNERS
INTERESTED IN SERVING WHICH
WOULD BE FABULOUS. IF THE
COMMUNITY CAN SEE THAT EVERY
ANNUAL ELECTION RESULTS IN
ACTION THAT SAME YEAR. CURRENTLY
REQUIRES THAT OWNERS BE
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS OR
LACK OF ACTIONS. WE NEED TO
CONSIDER LAWS WITH THE INTENT
THAT PEOPLE. NEED TO BE
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR OWN
ACTIONS AND CHOICES IF YOU OWN
AN H. AWAY THEN THAT COMES WITH
THE OBLIGATION TO ENGAGE. IN A
PARTICIPATION OF COMMUNITY RULES
MA'AM. IF YOU IF YOU COULD WRAP
UP A CATEGORY ASKED. IF NOTED
DOES NOT USED TO ENGAGE- THEN WE
DON'T WANT TO SILENCE OR IGNORE
THOSE. BECAUSE OF HIGHER COSTS
SO. I'M ASKING THAT YOU DO
SUPPORT A. B. AT FOURTEEN FIFTY
EIGHT FOR THESE REASONS AS A
HOMEOWNER AND MAN MANAGER. I
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
BECOME BEHALF OF THE BILL. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MISTER BROWN.
MISTER CHAIRMAN FOR THE
COMMITTEE LOUIS BROWN HERE TODAY
ON BEHALF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS
INSTITUTE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE
ACTION COMMITTEE COSPONSORED THE
BILL. AVAILABLE ANSWER ANY
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS IF YOU HAVE
ASKING FOR NIGHT OF THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT. JENNIFER WHAT ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
COMMUNITY MANAGERS AND SUPPORT.
THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT- SEEING NINE. WE WILL GO
TO OPPOSITION IS OR ANY
OPPOSITION IN THE ROOM. SO
PLEASE COME FORWARD. OKAY SAYING
THAT WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
. FOR THOSE WHO WISH TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE THEN ZERO. THE SECURE
THERE IS NO ONE. WHO CAN BRING
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES
ANY- QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. OUR
MOTION MOTION MY CENTER CITY AND
SENATORS WHO HAS A QUESTION.
THIS IS JUST A COMMENTED WANT TO
PROLONG THE COMMITTEE HEARING
BECAUSE OF SUPPORTING GIVEN THE
BILL A COMMITTEE TODAY. I DO
HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT WILL WANT TO
CONTINUE TO- TAKE A LOOK AT
WHICH MADE IMPACT MY FLOAT ON
THE FOR ON IN IN THAT REALLY HAS
TO DO WITH- SOME THE IDEAS WE
WERE TALKING ABOUT EARLIER WITH-
INCREASE COSTS INCREASE FEES I
KNOW THAT THE AUTHOR SAID. THIS
COURT THIS ISN'T A CHANGE A
QUORUM IN TERMS OF FEE DECISIONS
BUT THE FEWER PEOPLE THAT ARE
INVOLVED- IN SETTING A QUORUM TO
HOLD ACT FOLKS- IN THIS IS BASED
ON MY OWN EXPERIENCE- THE MORE
INSULAR DECISIONS ABOUT-
MAINTENANCE COSTS- CONTRA.
LANDSCAPING CONTRACTORS SEARCHER
WHICH WHICH IN EFFECT- AS THOSE
DECISIONS BECOME LESS
COMPETITIVE AND MORE INSULAR.
REYES COST WHICH THEREFORE RISK
PLEASE BECAUSE THE H. AWAY IS
ALWAYS GOING TO BE ABLE TO GO
BACK AND- AND COVER THOSE COSTS
SO I WORRY ABOUT THAT UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES IN AGAIN IT MAY
AFFECT MY- MY VOTE ON THE FLOOR
BUT I'M- THE SPONSORS BE
CONTACTING ME IN THE MEANWHILE
TRY TO EXPLAIN THAT SO. FOR
TODAY HOPE YOU KNOW VOTE THANK
YOU. THANK YOU ANY OTHER OR-
OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION BY CENTERS
SEYARTO TO PASS THE BILL TO THE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND YOU MAY
CLOSE- APPRECIATE THE COMMON
FROM US SENATOR FIFTY AND-
ACTUALLY VOTE. THANK YOU WILL
CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR WIENER
WIENER HI JOE OF. THE JOB BY
BLIX. LIKE THERE I CAN.
CAVALEIRO I COULD HAS A- CORTESE
I MCGUIRE VIDEO. VIDEO I SEE.
SARATOGA VICE. NUMBER BOB. BOB.
NINE ZERO ZERO WILL PUT THAT ON
CALL THANK YOU MEMBER THANK OF.
OKAY WE'VE COMPLETED ALL THE
BILL'S AND WE- TOOLS I BELIEVE
CENTER SKINNER IS COME AND SO
WAS SENT MCGUIRE- IS THIS ONE
VOTE. AND- DID YOU MISS ANY
ROADS YES HE DID HELLO. WHY
DON'T WE- AND HELP.
THIS CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
FIVE FIVE. I'M SORRY HERE KNOW
SO YEAH. WHAT THE TWENTY
DIFFERENT BECAUSE I'M A NICE.
OKAY OKAY WE DON'T EVERYONE HERE
WE'RE GONNA GO FOR AN OPEN THE
ROLE TO WE'RE GONNA START WITH
ITEM FIVE AB OH SEVEN THE PLEASE
CALL THE OUT SOME. AND THAT WAS
FIVE ZERO ZERO TOTAL I A
TROUBLED HI KEVIN. CHOIR I
MCGUIRE HI SKINNER BUT YOU CAN
HI UNDER BOB. BOB I. JUST. ZERO
NINE. OKAY NO TWENTY FIVE YES.
OKAY SO. ON ITEM. FIVE TWENTY
FIVE EIGHTY SIX ZERO SEVEN NINE
ZERO THAT BILL AS ADULTS. OKAY
ABOUT TO THE- WE'LL START WITH
ITEM A. B. FORTY TWO BY MARRANOS
PLEASE CALL THE OFFICE OF.
SENATE MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE
SKINNER SKINNER ELEVEN ZERO
SEVEN ZERO THE THOSE ARE WILL
NOW. WE HAVE SOME ON THE CONSENT
. FROM THE SIX SON CONNOR WITH
OF ITEMS TO SELL TEN FORTY
TWENTY SEVEN AND TWENTY NINE
SENATE MCGUIRE. R. I. SKINNER.
SKIN I LIVE IN IS A- ELEVEN ZERO
VICTIMS CALENDAR IS. ONE WELL NO
GOOD ITEM THREE AB THREE ON A BY
SO LEAFLETS THE OFFICE MEMBERS
THE CURRENT BONUS EXIT SENATOR
REQUIRE. REQUIRES PRICE. SKIN
ICE CITY TO THE MOTIVATED AN UP
OUT. WHEN A GOOD ITEM FOR A BI
NINETY SOMEONE LEAVE CALL THE
MEMBERS. SO THE COMPOSED EIGHT
ONCE REQUIRE. OUR BY SKINNER.
SKINNER. TEN TO ONE. THIS TIME
THE ONE THAT BILL IS A- NEXT
FIVE AB THREE ONE EIGHT FIVE
MEMBER PLEASE CALL THE OPTIMUM.
VETERANS HERBAL IS SEVEN AWAY
SENATOR BLOW. MCGUIRE I'VE
MCGUIRE AYE SKINNER FIVE SKINNER
I. THAT IS NINE TO ONE NINE ONE
BILLS OUT. NEXT SIXTY THREE ONE
NINE BY A MARC CONNELLY PLEASE
CALL THEM OF MY- BUT I DESERVES
REQUIRES.
GOOD ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AB THREE
FOUR SIX BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
QUIRK-SILVA PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS THE CURRENT BILLS
EIGHT ZERO SAN REQUIRE. MCGUIRE
VICE CHAIR TO DISCRETE IN THE
NUMBER OF CALLS ABOUT IT TODAY
SKINNER. FIVE SKINNER HI. THE
TEACHERS. TRY NOT. AT A TEN ZERO
ZERO THAT BILLS HAVE SIGN NEXT
TO IT ITEM NUMBER NINE AB FOUR
SIX EIGHT FIVE QUIRK SO PLEASE
CALL THE UP MEMBERS. THE CURRENT
VOTERS EIGHT TO ZERO SAN. FIVE
REQUIRED BY TWO ZERO TWO FIVE
SKINNER BUT SKINNER HI ELEVEN
ZERO SEVEN ZERO THAT THOSE OUT
WHEN I GO TO ITEM ELEVEN AB FOR
FORD BY SOMEONE WORKS PLEASE
CALL ABSENT MEMBERS. THE CURRENT
AS A TOOL AND WIRE. THIS IS A
ITEM NUMBER CLICK YES THANK YOU
SO MUCH I. MCGUIRE I CAN RIGHT
SKINNER HI TEND TO ONE VOTERS
THE ONE THOSE. AT A MEMBER TO A
ONE THREE ONE BY SOMEONE WORK
PLEASE CALL ABSENT MEMBERS KERN
SEVEN TWO SENECA. SKINNER BUT
ENTER HI HE TO THE BILL IS OUT.
NEXT ITEM THIRTEEN OF THE
SIXTEEN FIFTY SO BY A WORKS
PLEASE CALL THE OFFICE OF- KERN
BOTH SEVEN TO ONE SENATE
MCGUIRE- MCGUIRE AYE SARATOGA
YEAH HERE TO NO SKINNER. SKINNER
HI. NINETY TO NINETY TWO THAT
THE OUT- WE WILL NOW GO TO ITEMS
.
NINE ONE. NEITHER ONE OF THOSE
OUT- NEXT ITEM SEVENTEEN EIGHTY
FIVE EIGHT NINE BY SOME MEMBER
BURNER PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THE CURRENT BUT A SIX
ZERO THE ORIGINAL BOOKS. WHICH
WAS FOR A SEVENTEENTH. FIVE THE
TROUBLED BY MCGUIRE. OUR EYES
HERE TO. SKINNER RIGHT SKINNER.
NINE ZERO NINE ZERO THE BILL OUT
NEXT ITEM EIGHTEEN A. B. SO TWO
BY SOMEONE HE- PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT. THE CURRENT IS FIVE TWO
ONE SENATOR. MCGUIRE REQUIRE
FIVE ZERO TWO YEAH SEROTONIN
SKINNER BUT SKINNER I NUMBERS.
BUT IS SEVENTY TWO BUT IT'S TWO
THE BILL IS NOW- WHEN I GO TO
NINE SHE IS FOURTEEN EIGHTY FIVE
WEST MEMBER PLACE THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THE CURRENT VOTER SEVEN
TWO. SENATE MCGUIRE ACQUIRE HI.
CERTAIN NOW SKINNER. SKINNER HI
. THE NINE TWO HUNDRED THE BILL
ITSELF ONE OF TO A TWENTY IF
NINE SO SIX FIVE SOME TO. PLEASE
HOLD IT UP SO MEMBERS THE
CURRENT GOAL IS FIVE TO TWO
SEVEN ACQUIRE. HI SKINNER. FIVE
SKINNER I THE HOBBIT SEVENTY TWO
SEVEN TWO THE BILL ITSELF- IT
WILL NEXT CODES ITEM TWENTY TWO
EIGHTY TWO THIRTY BY REMEMBER
TING'S CALL OUT SOME. THE
CURRENT THAT IS SIX ONE RATIO
BOTH MCGUIRE. I SKINNER.
SENATE MCGUIRE. I SKINNER
SKINNER I LIVE IN ISRAEL CURTIS
LEVINS WHO ZERO THE BILL. NEXT
ITEM TWENTY FOUR AB TWELVE
FIFTEEN BY SOME MEMBER CARILLO
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
THE CURRENT THAT IS SIX ZERO
SENATE MITCHELL BOOK. FIVE
POTOMAC FIVE CAMARO. ZERO FIVE
MCGUIRE REQUIRED BY SKINNER
SKINNER AYE NUMBER TEN ZERO ZERO
THE BILL IS OUT WE ALREADY
CLOSED CELL AND TWENTY FIVE SO
WHEN I GO TO ITEM TWENTY SIX AB
TWELVE EIGHTY SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER ALVAREZ PLEASE
CALL. THE ABSENT MEMBERS. NUMBER
SEVEN ZERO SAN- CHILLED. CHOIRS
FIRE I HERE TO SEROTONIN SKIN.
FIVE SKINNER HI. NINETY ONE THE
ONE OF THOSE OUT. WILL NOW GO TO
AB THIRTEEN FIVE BY SOME. FOR
PLEASE HOLD OUTS MEMBERS THE
CURRENT VOTER SEVEN THREE FIVE.
SENATOR KABIRU. HI MCGUIRE FIRE
I SKINNER. SKINNER I NUMBER.
EIGHT TO TWO EIGHTY TWO BILL AS
ADULTS WILL NOW GO TO THIRTY
EIGHT FORTY THIRTY NINE BY
ASSEMBLY VERY. PLEASE HOLD
ABSENT MEMBERS THE CURRENT A
SEVEN ZERO SENATOR. KABIRU I
MCGUIRE. I SKINNER. BURKE THE
FILE ITEM THIRTY FIVE. SKINNER.
FIVE THE SENATE ZERO. TELL ZERO
THE BILLS OUT. AND FINALLY
THIRTY ONE FOUR OF IF I TOP
PLEASE CALL OFFICE AND ARE. THE
CURRENT BUT AS. ZERO ZERO. FIRE
I SKINNER.
FIVE AND WITH THAT WE ARE
CERTAIN.