COOL ALL RIGHT WE'RE GONNA CALL
THE COMMUTER ORDER. I WORK
CONTINUE TO WELCOME IT PUBLIC IN
PERSON BY THE TELECONFERENCE
ORVIS FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY ON
THE TELEPHONE LINES THROUGH HIS
PERSONAL NUMBER IS 877-262-6816
THREE ACCESS CODE IS. SEVEN
THREE SIX TWO EIGHT THREE FOUR.
WE'RE ASKING MEMBERS TO COME
DOWN TO BE PRESENT HERE IN ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED SO WE CAN
ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM WE'VE GOT
NINE BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA
THREE WELL TWO ACTUALLY ARE ON
THE KITCHEN COUNTER NOW THREE.
THREE I'M SORRY THREE YEAH SO I
DON'T THREE EIGHTY FIVE THIRTY
SIX AM SEVEN A. B. THREE FIFTY
SIX I AM A A. B. SIX EIGHTY TWO.
AND AS AMERICAN PEOPLE KIND OF A
QUORUM I HAVE TO GO TO PRESENT A
BILL RIGHT NOW ELECTION SOME IN
HAND OVER THE GAVEL- TO YOU MY
FRIEND AND COLLEAGUE VICE CHAIR
WHO WILL HEAR OUR FIRST BILL
WHICH I BELIEVE IS- SENATOR
RUBIO'S. BILL THIS IS A B. TWO
SEVENTY NINE. THAT I AM
PHYSICALLY SUPPORT BUT I'M
LEAVING. I WON'T BE IN ELECTIONS
WE'RE GOING TO TURN IT ON TO
HEAR YOUR BILL DOG COME BACK TO
BITE RIGHT I THIS. THANK YOU
ABOUT TERENCE FOR LONG NEEDS FOR
AB TWO SEVENTEEN THIS THIS
MORNING WHICH ENSURES THE
CONTINUED EFFECTIVE MASS OF OUR
LOCAL WATER QUALITY OF THIRTY
THE COMPLEX WATERSHEDS OF THE
SANGAMON VALLEY MOUNTAIN
PROVIDES WATER FOR NEARLY A
MILLION RESIDENTS OF THE SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY. IN MY DISTRICT
UNFORTUNATELY THE WATER QUALITY
OF THE BASIN IS COMPLICATED BY
DECADES OF DECADES OF POOR
ENVIRONMENTAL OVERSIGHT DURING
THE TWENTIETH CENTURY ORGANIC
COMPOUNDS P. FAST AND NUMEROUS
OTHER VOLATILE CONTAMINATIONS.
PLAGUE THE GROUND WATER WHICH IN
TURN DESIGNATED THE BASIN OF THE
FEDERAL SUPERFUND. THE TASK OF
ORGANIZING AND PROVIDING FUNDING
TO REMEDY THE CLEAN UP OF THE
BASIN WAS DELEGATED TO THE THANK
YOU PROVIDE THANK YOU FOR BASED
ON WATER QUALITY AT THIRTY OR W.
Q. A- ESTABLISHED BY AB TWENTY
ONE SEVENTY THREE IN NINETEEN
NINETY TWO. WKA HAS OVERSEEN
NEARLY HALF A BILLION DOLLARS IN
RIGHT REMEDIATION EFFORTS
ACCOUNTING FOR NEARLY 50% OF THE
TOTAL CONTAMINANTS REMOVED FROM
THE BASIN IN THE SINCE NINETEEN
SEVENTY NINE. UNFORMED
UNFORTUNATELY AT THIS COMMITTEE
HAS THIS COMMITTEE IS ALL TOO
FAMILIAR WITH THE EFFORTS TO
REMEDIATE GROUNDWATER POLLUTION
ARE LONG TERM AND COMPLICATED BY
NEWLY EMERGING CONTAMINANTS. AS
SUCH THE W. CREEK Q. AS MISSION
HAS BEEN EXTENDED SEVERAL TIMES
MOST RECENTLY LAST YEAR BY OUR
BY OUR MEASURES. AB TWENTY ONE
SIXTY THREE WHICH RECEIVED
UNANIMOUS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN
THIS COMMITTEE. WITH THE
AUTHORITY ACTIVELY PLANNING AND
PREPARING CONTRACTS UP TO ITS
NEXT PROPOSED SUNSET OF THE YEAR
TWENTY FIFTY EIGHTY TWO SEVENTY
NINE PROVIDE STABILITY. FOR THE
AUTHORITY BY REVISING THE
PUMPING RIGHTS ASSESSMENT CAP
FROM TEN DOLLARS TO TWENTY
DOLLARS. THIS ALLOWS THE WATER
QUALITY- AUTHORITY TO LEVERAGE
THE BREATH OF FUNDING STREAMS
AVAILABLE TO THE AUTHORITY WHILE
KEEPING COSTS DOWN FOR THE BASIS
CONSTITUENTS THAT RELY ON IT.
THE WTA HAS CONSISTENTLY
DEMONSTRATED EFFECTIVE IN
CONSERVATIVE BUDGETING TO ENSURE
THAT EVERY DOLLAR SPENT UNDER
THEIR PURVIEW BUT EFFECTIVELY
ADDRESSES ONE OF THE LARGEST
SUPERFUND SITES IN THE U. S.
THEIR WORK IS INVALUABLE. TO MY
DISTRICT AND TO THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY- BASIN WHAT WHAT THE WAY
QUALITY AT THIRTY SET THIS. FOR
A IN SPACE. THIS MEASURE HAS
UNANIMOUS UNANIMOUS SUPPORT FROM
LOCAL AND STATEWIDE WATER
ENTITIES AND NO KNOWN OPPOSITION
HERE TODAY TO. TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF AB TWO SEVENTY NINE
IS RANDY. AYE SOLOMON EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR OF THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY OB FROM SAN GABRIEL BASIN
WATER QUALITY AT THIRTY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU MR. MORNING
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
RANDY SHULMAN EXECUTIVE
DIRECTORS SAYING ABLE BASIN
WATER QUALITY AUTHORITY- OUR
AGENCY. WAS GREAT NINETEEN
NINETY TWO THE PHILLY AGENTS
FEEL THE NEED TO CLEAN UP THE
MAIN SAN GABRIEL BASIN. SINCE
OUR INCEPTION THE WA IT'S BEEN
INSTRUMENTAL IN FACILITATING
FUNDING AGREEMENTS WITH
RESPONSIBLE PARTIES TO PAY FOR
THAT CLEAN UP- XCELERATED EMPATH
ACCELERATING THE IMPLEMENTATION
OF BASIN CLEANUP PROJECTS. AND
ACQUIRING STATE AND FEDERAL
FUNDING TO FURTHER REDUCE THE
CLEANUP COST BURDEN TO LOCAL
RESIDENTS. THE W. ELSA PARTNERS
WITH STATE AND LOCAL. STATE AND
FEDERAL REGULATORY AGENCIES TO
EXPEDITE CLEANUP PLANS. AND TO
INVESTIGATE SITES THAT MAY
CONTINUE TO POSE A THREAT. TO
THE GROUNDWATER BASIN. OVERALL
THE BASIN IS A LOCAL DRINKING
WATER SOURCE OVER ONE POINT FOUR
MILLION RESIDENTS IN THE VALLEY.
THE W. IS ALSO TASKED WITH
ADDRESSING THE IMPACT OF
EMERGING- CONTAMINANTS OF
CONCERN IS AS WAS MENTIONED.
THEREFORE REQUESTING THIS
INCREASE TO THE MAXIMUM
ASSESSMENT ALLOWABLE FOR TEN TO
TWENTY DOLLARS AN ACRE FOOT
WHICH HASN'T BEEN ADDRESSED IN
OVER TWENTY YEARS. FOR THE
FUTURE NEEDS OF THE BASIN
CLEANUP IN COORDINATION WITH OUR
LOCAL REGIONAL STATE AND FEDERAL
PARTNERS. NOTE THAT THIS BILL
DOES NOT INCREASE THE ACTUAL
ASSESSMENT. IF THE IF AN
INCREASE IS EVER NEEDED FOR THE
ACTUAL CESSNAS SOME POINT THE
FUTURE THE SEVEN MEMBER WQAD
PORTE. CONSISTING OF WATER
PURVEYORS CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS.
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT BOARD
MEMBERS WILL FOLLOW THE WELL
ESTABLISHED LAW THING INCLUDES
PUBLIC NOTICES IN HEARINGS.
PRIOR TO THE ACTION BEING
CONSIDERED WHICH IS ALREADY IN
OUR ENABLING ACT. THE W. AS
BROAD SUPPORT AMONG THE BASE AND
STAKEHOLDERS AND HAS ESTABLISHED
A GOOD REPUTATION FOR EFFICIENT
USE OF ITS ASSESSMENTS.
THEREFORE WE APPRECIATE YOUR AYE
VOTE. I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS AS WELL. DO YOU HAVE
ANY OTHER THE- PRIMARY WITNESSES
NOPE. OKAY- THOSE. IN HERE IN
THE ROOM HERE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
SPEAK IN FAVOR. SEEING NONE-
WE'LL GO TO THE- OPPOSITION IS
THERE ANYONE HERE IN TWELVE
HUNDRED. IS IN OPPOSITION OF. AB
TWO SEVEN NINE C. NINE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINES. OPPOSITION
OR SUPPORT. OPERATOR THANK YOU
FOR IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION OF
AB TWO SEVENTY NINE YOU MAY
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO FOR
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. THE CHAIR
WE HAVE NO ONE IN YOU AT THIS
TIME. THANK YOU WE HAVE NO
OTHERS IN Q. WILL BRING IT BACK
TO THE DYESS OBVIOUSLY WE DON'T
HAVE A QUORUM BUT- IN THE
TESTIMONY OF THE WITNESSES THAT.
HE MENTIONED THAT THEY ALREADY
HAVE THE ABILITY IN THE ACT TO
RAISE THE RATE THROUGH THE
PROPER PROCESS SO. NO NO WHAT
WHAT WHAT HE SAID IS WE'RE EXT
WE'RE INCREASING THE ABILITY TO
OUT RIGHT NOW IT'S AT FIFTY
FIFTEEN SO. WHAT THE TEN BUT YOU
HAVE THE BILL ALLOWS THEM TO GO
TO TWENTY TO TWENTY IF NEEDED IF
NEEDED AND I THINK THAT'S THE
IMPORTANT PART OF THE
CONVERSATION IT'S IN THE HAVE
BEEN VERY VERY GOOD ABOUT NOT
RAISING IT UNLESS THEY NEEDED
AND THAT'S WHY HE MENTIONED THE
SEVEN MEMBER BOARD IF. THERE'S A
NEED THEY HAVE THE ABILITY TO
RAISE IT TO TWENTY BUT THEY IT'S
AN THIS IS NOT RAISING IT TO
TWENTY THEY WILL GO THROUGH THE
BOARD THE OLD DO YOU KNOW DO THE
PROPER- PUBLIC NOTICE AND I
HAVE. I WAS A WE- TINY WATER
BOARD MEMBER TWENTY FIVE YEARS
AGO WHEN I STARTED DATA ON MY-
WHAT A BOARD SEAT AND THEY HAVE
ALWAYS BEEN VERY VERY GOOD ABOUT
MAKING SURE THAT THEY PROVE TO
THE PUBLIC WHY THEY NEED IT AS
OPPOSED TO JUST DOING IT BECAUSE
THEY CAN. AND SO THAT'S WHY I
OFFERED TO CARRY THE BILL
BECAUSE IT WAS IMPORTANT TO MY
REGION THE- I ELEVEN BOTTOM PARK
IN THE SUPER SOME FUND SITE IS
CALLED THE PUBLIC PARKING
OPERABLE UNIT SO YOU KNOW THAT
IT'S RIGHT UNDERNEATH. MY CITY
BUT AGAIN IT'S NOT THAT THE
RAISING IT TO TWENTY AS THEY
HAVE THE ABILITY TO RAISE IT UP
TO TWENTY IF NEEDED OKAY THANK
YOU. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS NOW.
ALL RIGHT I THINK THIS IS A-
GOOD BILL WILL BE I'LL BE
SUPPORTING IT. I DON'T KNOW. BUT
THE REST I THINK IT'S GONNA DO
WELL THANK YOU. OKAY WE'LL MOVE.
TO FOR. BY C. S. M. MEMBER WOULD
IS HERE. A FIVE. ONE WELCOME.
HOW ARE YOU MY FRIEND. GOOD HOW
ARE YOU. GET GOOD MORNING THANK
YOU MR VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS- I
LIKE TO START BY THANKING THE-
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
BILL. I'M HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS TODAY. AB
FIVE FORTY ONE WOULD DIRECT THE
WATER BOARD TO REQUIRE PUBLIC
WATER SYSTEMS THAT HAVE IMPACTED
BIT BEEN IMPACTED BY MAJOR
WILDFIRE EVENTS TO TEST FOR THE
PRESENCE. OF BENZENE FOLLOWING-
FOLLOWING THE FIRE. THE SHORTLY
AFTER THE TUBBS FIRE IN TWENTY
SEVENTEEN RESIDENTS OF SANTA
ROSA REPORTED THE- WHAT THAT
WATER COMING OUT OF TAPS MOBIKE
GASOLINE. AFTER SOME TESTS WERE
DONE. IT WAS DISCOVERED THAT
BENZENE HAD LEAKED INTO THE
WATER SYSTEM. THE TEMPERATURES
OF THE FIRE WERE INCREDIBLY HIGH
IN RESULTING IN PARALYSIS.
PYROLYSIS OF THE SYSTEM'S PIPES
BELOW THE GROUND- PARDON ME.
JUST ONE YEAR LATER THE TOWN OF
PARADISE ALSO FOUND WIDESPREAD
BENZENE CONTAMINATION IN THEIR
WATER SYSTEM AS A RESULT OF THE
CAMPFIRE. BENZENE FOR THOSE WHO
MAY NOT KNOWN IS UNKNOWN MAY NOT
KNOW IS A KNOWN CARCINOGEN.
EXPOSURE TO BENZENE CAN LEAD TO
BLOOD DISEASES CANCER AND EVEN
DEATH. THE LAST THING WILDFIRES-
WELL FOR SURVIVORS SHOULD HAVE
TO WORRY ABOUT IS WHETHER OR NOT
THE DRINKING WATER IS SAFE A. B.
FORTY BY FORTY ONE IS A SIMPLE
YET CRITICAL MEASURE. ENSURES
THAT DRINKING WATER SAFETY TESTS
WILL BE CONDUCTED FOLLOWING
DISASTROUS WILDFIRE EVENTS. WITH
ME TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL IS BRETT BARROW ON BEHALF
OF THE SPONSOR EACH. OF AB FIVE
FORTY ONE BUILD STRONG
CALIFORNIA. TWO MINUTES GOOD
MORNING MISTER TURNER MEMBERS
HAVE BRED BURROWED BILL STRONG
CALIFORNIA WHERE THE CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER OF A NATIONAL COALITION
OF FIREFIGHTERS FIRST RESPONDERS
CODE SPECIALIST. CONSTRUCTION
AND INSURERS AND WE MAKE SURE
ENSURE THAT COMMUNITIES HAVE
RESILIENT INFRASTRUCTURE TO
SERVE THEIR NEEDS IN IN THE
INSTANCE OF- NATURAL DISASTERS.
AND REALLY WHEN WE TOOK A LOOK
AT THE INSTANCES OF TUBS FIRE
AND CAMPFIRE IN IN OTHER PLACES
WHERE BINS IN IT SHOWING UP WE
FOUND WAS. THAT THE TESTING
WASN'T CORRELATED TO THE
WILDFIRES THERE'S WATER BOARD
HAS THE OPPORTUNITY CALL FOR
TEST FOR BENZENE AT ANY POINT.
BUT THERE WASN'T. ANY
REQUIREMENT THAT TO BE CALLED
NEXT TO WILDFIRE OF IT IN FACT
IF IT WERE A PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM
HAD A WAIVER AND APPLIED FOR A
WAIVER BECAUSE THEY NEVER
DETECTED THAT BOC. THEY CAN GO
FOR YEARS WITHOUT HAVING TO TEST
SO REALLY WE'RE JUST CORRELATING
THE WELFARE OF IN WITH THE
BENZENE TEST FOR THE SAFETY OF
THE- THE PUBLIC SO WITH THAT IN
YOUR DRIVE OUT. THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE HERE IN. ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED WISHING TO. SPEAKING
SUPPORT. HELLO MY NAME IS SERRA
BRIDGES AND IN ON BEHALF OF
VALLEY. I'M SO SORRY SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. SINGLE OTHERS IS THERE
ANYONE HERE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING ON WILL GO TO
THE PHONE LINES THOSE AND
SPEAKING IN OPPOSITION OR IN
FAVOR. MODERATOR THANK YOU
AFFAIRS SUPPORTER OPPOSITION OF
A. B. FIVE FORTY ONE YOU MAY
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. WE'LL
GO TO LINE SIXTEEN YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. GOOD MORNING THIS IS
ANNUALLY ON BEHALF OF SIERRA
CLUB CALIFORNIA SUPPORT. THANK
YOU AND IT'S CHAIR WE HAVE NO
FURTHER SUPPORTER OPPOSITION IN
Q. THANK YOU WE WILL CLOSE
PUBLIC COMMENT BRING IT BACK TO.
DIESS ANY QUESTIONS I LIKE.
FRIEDMAN I WILL BE SUPPORTERS
BILL GREAT BILL THANK YOU- LET'S
WAIT TO GET A CORPSMAN I THINK
YOU'RE GOING TO. FLY OUT OF
HERE. HOPEFULLY NOT BUT I CLOSE
WALK BUT THAT YOU APPRECIATE
THAT- MISTER VICE CHAIR SO I
WILL WALK OUT. THANK YOU- SEEING
NO OTHER AUTHORS IN- TWELVE
HUNDRED I WOULD- URGE THOSE WHO
ARE WATCHING IF YOU ARE WATCHING
TO COME DOWN AND WILL PRESENT
YOUR BILL.
YEAH. YOUR. RT YEAH. THIS IS
GOING.
HELLO ASSEMBLY WOMAN PLEASE JOIN
US RIGHT HERE YOU CAN COME OVER
HERE IF YOU LIKE OR YOU CAN
BRING PERCENT FROM WHEREVER YOU
WANT I HAVEN'T PRESENTED IN THIS
ROOM A LITTLE CONFUSED GOOD
MORNING. SO WHICH ONE ARE YOU
GONNA START WE HAVE THREE BILLS
I HAVING TO AN AND ONE FOR LEE
YOU RIGHT I HAVE ONE BILL OF MY
OWN AND THEN TWO BILLS FOR
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LEE OKAY YOU
WHICH STOCKS ARE WITH MY BILL
BECAUSE I KNOW WHAT IT IS ALL
RIGHT FIND OUT WHAT THE OTHER
BILLS ARE WOULD BE A SURPRISED
EVERYBODY. OKAY GOOD MORNING MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS- PERSONAL CARE
PRODUCTS AND COSMETICS IN THIS
COUNTRY ARE BASICALLY
UNREGULATED IN TERMS OF THEIR
CONTENTS ASIDE FROM CALIFORNIA'S
RECENT PROHIBITIONS ON THIRTEEN
CHEMICALS AND THE CLASS OF P.
FIVE CHEMICALS FEW INGREDIENTS
ARE RESTRICTED FROM USING THIS
PRODUCTS AND REGULATORS HAVE
LIMITED ABILITY TO MAKE SURE
THAT COSMETICS ARE SAFE WE TEND
TO BE REACTIVE WHEN SOMETHING
BAD HAPPENS RATHER THAN
PROACTIVE AB FOUR NINETY SIX
WOULD PROHIBIT THE SALE OF ANY
PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS WITH IN
CALIFORNIA. THAT CONTAIN ANY ONE
OF TWENTY SIX HIGHLY TOXIC
CHEMICALS STARTING IN TWENTY
TWENTY SEVEN. THESE TWENTY SIX
CHEMICALS CONSISTS OF KNOWN
CARCINOGENS REPRODUCTIVE TOXINS
AND ENDOCRINE DISRUPTORS THAT
THE EUROPEAN UNION HAS ALREADY
BANNED. FROM PERSONAL CARE
PRODUCTS SOLD IN ITS NATION TO
BE CLEAR THESE ARE SKIN PRODUCTS
THIS IS SHAMPOO IS ARE THINGS
YOU LITERALLY PUT ON YOUR BODY.
NOW THAT BECAUSE ABOUT THE
HEALTH RISKS IN THESE CHEMICALS
ARE VERY IMMEDIATE. I AM VERY
SIGNIFICANT. AND SINCE THESE
CHEMICALS ARE NOT ESSENTIAL IN
THESE PRODUCTS I WOULD ARGUE
THAT EVEN IF THEY WERE MAYBE WE
SHOULDN'T BE USING THEM BECAUSE
A LOT OF THE PRODUCTS ARE NOT
ESSENTIAL. BUT THESE CHEMICALS
ARE DEFINITELY NOT ESSENTIAL FOR
IT THE PRODUCTS AS MANY OF THEM
DON'T CONTAIN THEM. ARE THERE
ARE ALREADY ALTERNATIVES
AVAILABLE SO WE ARE EXPOSING
PEOPLE FOR ABSOLUTELY NO REASON.
THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS DISCUSSES
THE REASONS FOR CONSISTENCY WITH
THE E. REGULATIONS ESPECIALLY
GIVEN THAT A LOT OF THESE
PRODUCTS ARE SOLD IN BOTH
COUNTRIES. THE E. U. HAS A
RIGOROUS SCIENTIFIC PROCESS TO
EVALUATE CHEMICAL INGREDIENTS IN
COSMETICS. AND IT'S IMPORTANT
THAT THE INDUSTRY NOT HAVE TO
MEET TO DIFFERENT STANDARDS IN
DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE WORLD.
THE ANALYSIS ALSO NOTES THAT
IT'S BEEN THE INTENT OF THIS
LEGISLATURE TO ALIGN
CALIFORNIA'S BANS ON COSMETIC
INGREDIENTS. WITH INGREDIENTS
THAT ARE BANNED IN THE EU. MY
OFFICE HAS MET HAVE MET WITH THE
OPPOSITION THEIR CONCERN WITH.
THE INCLUSION OF ONLY ONE
CHEMICAL THAT'S BEEN IN THIS
BILL LILY ALL- OR LILY OUT HOW
DELIGHTED. THIS IS A FRAGRANCE
COMPOUND USED IN SOME PERSONAL
CARE PRODUCTS. THE PRIMARY
HEALTH HARMS LINKED TO THIS
CHEMICAL INCLUDE AND HEARD FOR
IMPAIRED FERTILITY. AND PRENATAL
DEVELOPMENT. I'M NOT CONVINCED
THAT THE PROCESS OF THE E. U.
UNDER COOK WITH REGARDS TO LILY
ALWAYS INCOMPLETE. MY WITNESS
WILL SPEAK MORE ON THIS WE DO
HAVE EXPERT WITNESSES. I AMENDED
THE BILL IN THE ASSEMBLY TO MAKE
TWENTY TWENTY SEVEN THE
EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE BAND FOR
THESE CHEMICALS. AFTER
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE PERSONAL
CARE PRODUCTS COUNCIL THEY'RE
NEUTRAL ON THE BILL BEFORE WE
INTRODUCED WE SAT DOWN WITH THEM
AND SAID. IS THIS A PROBLEM WITH
FOR YOU THEY FELT IT WASN'T THEY
THEY DON'T DO THEIR NEUTRAL ON
THIS BILL THEY SEE THE NEED FOR
IT. THE BILL HAS GOTTEN
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AND HAS HAD
NO AND NO VOTES IN THE ASSEMBLY.
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF AB FOUR
NINETY SIX TODAY. ON BEHALF OF
OUR SPONSOR. THE ENVIRONMENTAL
WORKING GROUP IS KAYLEE BAINES
SENIOR SCIENTIST AND SUSAN
LITTLE SENIOR ADVOCATE. NEVER
TO. AND EITHER. THANK. YOU YOU
HAVE TWO MINUTES EACH. OUR WHAT
YOU SPLIT IT UP EVERYONE I'M
SORRY. THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY. MY NAME
IS KELLY BINDS AND I'M A SENIOR
SCIENTIST WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL
WORKING GROUP. I'M HERE TODAY TO
URGE THE COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT AB
FOUR NINE SIX AND CONTINUE
CALIFORNIA'S LEADERSHIP. IN
REMOVING HARMFUL INGREDIENTS AND
COSMETICS. THE CHEMICALS
IDENTIFIED IN THIS BILL POST
PERSONAL AND PUBLIC HEALTH
RISKS. AS WELL AS LONG LASTING
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS. EACH
CHEMICAL ON THIS LIST IS
ASSOCIATED WITH SERIOUS HARMS.
INCLUDING RISKS RELATED TO
CANCER. REPRODUCTIVE OUTCOMES
DEVELOPMENTAL EFFECTS AND
TOXICITY IN THE ENVIRONMENT.
WELL EACH OF THE A. BEFORE NINE
SIX CHEMICALS POSE RISKS TO
HUMAN HEALTH OR THE ENVIRONMENT.
EWG IS ESPECIALLY CONCERNED
ABOUT THE WELL DOCUMENTED HEALTH
IMPACTS FOR LILY ALDEHYDE. LILLY
L. THE HEIGHT IS A SKIN
SENSITIZER THAT CAN CAUSE
ALLERGIC SKIN REACTIONS AND MAY
INDUCE RESPIRATORY IRRITATION.
STUDIES HAVE SHOWN IT MAY IT.
AFFECT THE UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
MAY AFFECT THE ENDOCRINE SYSTEM
AND DAMAGE THE LIVER. GET THE
MOST ALARMING HEALTH IMPACTS OF
THE SYNTHETIC CHEMICAL OR ITS
EFFECTS ON FERTILITY. THE
COSMETIC INDUSTRIES OWN DATA
HAVE SHOWN THAT EXPOSURE TO THE
OUT THE HEIGHT IS ASSOCIATED
WITH MALE REPRODUCTIVE HARM. AS
WELL AS NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON
FETAL DEVELOPMENT. THESE STUDIES
DEMONSTRATE THAT MALE ANIMALS
EXPOSED TO LILY ALDEHYDE
EXPERIENCE TESTICULAR AND SPERM
DAMAGE. AT TIMES THIS DAMAGE
OCCURRED AFTER A SINGLE DOSE OF
THE CHEMICAL. IN ONE INDUSTRY
STUDY THE MISCARRIAGE RATE FOR
FEMALE RATS EXPOSED TO DIFFERENT
DOSES OF THE LEE ALDEHYDE WITH
DOUBLE. AND TRIPLE THE
MISCARRIAGE RATE FOR UNEXPOSED
RATS. WHEN THEY EXPOSED RATS DID
MANAGE TO HAVE OFFSPRING THEIR
OFFSPRING WERE SMALLER AND
GAINED LESS WEIGHT THAN THE
OFFSPRING OF THE UNEXPOSED RATS
. OTHER STUDIES REPORTED FETAL
MALFORMATIONS SUCH AS DID EXTRA
DIGITS AND MATERNAL EFFECTS SUCH
AS INSUFFICIENT WEIGHT GAIN
DURING PREGNANCY. FOR THESE
REASONS THE EUROPEAN UNION
CLASSIFIES ALLOWED TO HIDE AS A
REPRO TOXIC ONE B. SUBSTANCE OR
A QUOTE PRESUMED HUMAN
REPRODUCTIVE TOXICANT. AND
QUOTE. NOTABLY THIS ONE B.
CLASSIFICATION IS ONLY USED WHEN
THE ANIMAL DATA FOR SUBSTANCE IS
DIRECTLY RELEVANT TO HUMANS.
ACCORDING TO THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SAFE COSMETICS DATABASE
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS ARE EXPOSED
TO MORE THAN ONE THOUSAND NINE
HUNDRED COSMETIC PRODUCTS
CONTAINING LILLY L. TO HIDE.
AFTER EVALUATING THE HEALTH
EFFECTIVELY ALDEHYDE IN THE
PUBLIC'S TOTAL EXPOSURE TO IT.
THE E. U. SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE
ON CONSUMER SAFETY EUROPE SAFETY
AUTHORITY FOR PERSONAL CARE
PRODUCTS. HAS TWICE CONFIRMED
THAT LILLY L. THE HEIGHT IS NOT
SAFE. SAFER ALTERNATIVES EXIST
FOR EACH OF THE CHEMICALS
PROHIBITED BY EIGHTY FOUR NINE
SIX INCLUDING WILLIE I'LL THE
HIDE. IN FACT INDUSTRY IS
REFORMULATED PRODUCTS WITHOUT
THESE CHEMICALS TO SELL IN THE
EUROPEAN UNION AND OTHER NATIONS
. THESE PRODUCTS ARE ALREADY ON
SHELVES IN EUROPE. INDUSTRY IS
HOPING AMERICANS WILL SETTLE FOR
LESS. WE REQUEST THIS COMMITTEE
SUPPORT OF AB FOUR NINE SIX TO
SAFEGUARD THE HEALTH OF CURRENT
AND FUTURE GENERATIONS OF
CALIFORNIANS I WOULD BE HAPPY TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU
. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. GOOD
MORNING I'M SUSAN LITTLE WITH
THE ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP-
I'M JUST QUICKLY JUST TO REMIND
THE COMMITTEE THAT WHAT WE'RE
ASKING THE COMMITTEE TO DO AND
THE LEGISLATURE TO DO IS JUST.
PROHIBITS SOME CHEMICALS IN
COSMETICS IN COSMETICS THAT HAVE
ALREADY BEEN PROHIBITED IN THE
EUROPEAN MARKET PLACE. REFORM
RELATIONS HAVE ALREADY OCCURRED
THIS IS ALREADY HAPPENING IN A
LARGE PART OF THE REST OF THE
WORLD- ALSO THIS BILL WILL
ENSURE THAT THERE IS A FLOOR.
FOR THOSE BECAUSE ON THERE'S A
FLOOR OF. FOR HEALTH SAFETY FOR
COSMETICS HOLDEN IN CALIFORNIA
SO. CONSUMERS DON'T HAVE TO
PURCHASE THE MORE EXPENSIVE
PRODUCTS. THE AT THE MARKET THE
THAT. THE GREEN COSMETICS FOR
THE SPECIALTY COSMETICS
COMPANIES MARKET. TO ENSURE THAT
WOMEN DON'T HAVE OR PEOPLE DON'T
HAVE TO BUY AND USE PRODUCTS.
THAT THAT CONTAIN THESE KINDS OF
CHEMICALS PEOPLE SHOULD BE ABLE
TO BUY THESE CHEMICAL THESE HIS
ME THESE COSMETICS. AT THE
REGULAR RETAIL LOCATION WITHOUT
FEAR OF HAVING THESE CUTS THESE
TOXIC CHEMICALS IN THEIR
PRODUCTS AND THEIR PRODUCTS
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYONE
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
. GOOD MORNING REBECCA MARQUESS
AND STRONG SUPPORT REPRESENTING
CALPERS AND AS A COURTESY TO MY
COLLEAGUES AT THE SIERRA CLUB
CALIFORNIA. AND CLEAN WATER
ACTION IN SUPPORT AS WELL THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. MORNING MR CHEN
MEMBERS BECOMING WITH WHITEMAN
GROUP ON BEHALF OF CAL WATER IN
SUPPORT. SEEING OTHERS COMING TO
THE MICROPHONE HERE TWELVE
HUNDRED WE WILL GO TO OPPOSITION
. GOOD MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS AT
NO COOKING UNITS ON BEHALF OF
THE FRAGRANCE CREATORS
ASSOCIATION- WE CERTAINLY
APPRECIATE THE AUTHORS GOAL TO
LIMIT THE USE OF INGREDIENTS
THAT ARE BANNED BY THE EUROPEAN
UNION- IN COSMETIC PRODUCTS
HOWEVER WE DO HAVE AN OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION OUT SHE
NOTED- REQUESTING THE REMOVAL
OF- LILY ALL TO HIDE FROM THE
LIST OF INGREDIENTS THAT WOULD
BE BANNED BY AB FOR NINETY SIX-
WE BELIEVE THAT A- LILY OUTSIDE
WAS REALLY OUT WITH BAND IN THE
E. U. THEIR DECISION WAS A
HAZARD BASED- ACTION. AND WE ARE
ADVOCATING AT- ALWAYS ADVOCATE
FOR A RISK BASED APPROACH AS IT
RELATES TO INGREDIENTS IN
COSMETICS AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE
WE ARE HERE TODAY AS IT RELATES
TO LILY I'LL- ABSOLUTELY I'LL IS
NOT FOUND ON. ANY OF THE TWENTY
TWO AUTHORITATIVE LISTS THAT ARE
FROM YOU KNOW AT INTERNATIONAL
BODIES THAT MAKE UP THE
DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCES
CONTROLS AT CANADA CHEMICALS
LIST THAT'S USED IN THE GREEN
CHEMISTRY PROGRAM- AND IT IS NOT
LISTED AS THE PROP SIXTY FIVE
CHEMICAL WHICH IS ONE OF THE
MOST. HEALTH PROTECTIVE CONSUMER
WARNING PROGRAMS- IN THE
COUNTRY- AND ALL JUST KNOW FOR
FIFTY YEARS THE RESEARCH
INSTITUTE A FRAGRANCE MATERIALS
HAS GATHERED AND ANALYZED
SCIENTIFIC DATA- AND ENGAGE IN
TESTING AND EVALUATION. OF
FRAGRANCE MATERIALS AND I KNOW
I'M YOU KNOW THERE IS SOME
CRITICISM ABOUT A SELF
REGULATORY PROGRAM BUT I WILL
JUST NOTE- YOU KNOW THE INDUSTRY
WAS SORT OF AHEAD OF ITS TIME.
IN TERMS OF REGULATING ITSELF I
WERE IN A LOT OF INDUSTRIES-
DON'T- TAKE THAT THAT STEP-
THEIR RESEARCH- IS REVIEWED BY
AN INDEPENDENT EXPERT PANEL AT
WHICH IS AN INTERNATIONAL GROUP
OF DERMATOLOGISTS PATHOLOGISTS
TOXICOLOGIST. AND ENVIRONMENTAL
AND RESPIRATORY SCIENTISTS THAT
HAVE NO COMMERCIAL TIES TO THE
FRAGRANCE INDUSTRY- THEY HAVE
LOOKED AT LILLY L. EXTENSIVELY
AND THERE ARE A POSITION AS THAT
IT MAY BE USED SAFELY IN
COSMETIC PRODUCTS BELOW. A
CERTAIN SPECIFIC. CONCENTRATION
LIMITS THESE ARE PUBLISHED BY-
INTERNET FRAGRANCES. AND THEY
ARE ALL OF OUR MEMBERS ABIDE BY
THOSE LIMITS- AND BECAUSE THEY
ABIDE STRICTLY BY THOSE LIMITS
WHICH ARE UPDATED- OVERTIME-
THAT'S WHERE WE ARE WE ARE
REQUESTING IT BE REMOVED FROM
THE SCOPE OF THIS BILL. I DO
JUST WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT
THE ANALYSIS NOTED. THE INDUSTRY
HAS ADVOCATED FOR ALIGNMENT WITH
THE E. U. ON OTHER COSMETIC
LEGISLATION- AND YOU KNOW.
CERTAINLY IN THE FUTURE YOU
LIKELY WILL AS WELL- HOWEVER
AGAIN I'M AS IT RELATES TO
INGREDIENT LEGISLATION FRAGRANCE
CREATORS WILL ALWAYS ADVOCATE
FOR- A SOUND SCIENCE AS A
FOUNDATION- AND SO WHEN WE DO
DISAGREE WITH THE SCIENCE IN THE
YOU THAT IS. WHY YOU KNOW OMAR
IN THIS POSITION AND- SEEKING A
DIFFERENT OUTCOME HERE SOME
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MISTER
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE-
SHANE GUSMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
FRAGRANCE SCIENCE AND ADVOCACY
COUNCIL- THIS IS A GROUP OF SOME
OF THE LARGEST. A FRAGRANCE
HOUSES IN THE WORLD THAT ENGAGE
IN THE REGULATORY AND LAWMAKING
PROCESS AND A SORT OF SCIENCE
BASED AND AN EDUCATIONAL MANNER-
I. THINK I WOULD ALIGN MY
COMMENTS WITH THE PREVIOUS
SPEAKER WE ARE CONCERNED WITH
BANNING INGREDIENTS SIMPLY BASED
ON A HAZARD- OR- RISK A HAZARD.
OR A POTENTIAL HARM- THAT THIS
INGREDIENT MAY CAUSE HARM TO
HUMANS- THERE ARE MANY MANY MANY
INGREDIENTS- THINGS IN USE IN
PRODUCTS THINGS WE NEED TO LIVE.
THAT ARE POTENTIALLY HARMFUL IF
THEY'RE USED THE WRONG WAY OR A
YOU KNOW USED. INAPPROPRIATELY
SO- IN OUR VIEW LILLY L. HAS NOT
HAD THE RISK. BASED ASSESSMENT-
AND THEREFORE WE OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED THAT AMENDMENT WE WOULD
SEEK WITH THAT REMOVAL OF LILLY
L. FROM THE LIST THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. THE OTHERS WISHING
JUST IN OFFICE HERE IN ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED SEEN ON WE WILL
GO TO- THE MODERATOR FOR THOSE
WHO ONLY SPEAK IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION MODERATE. THANK YOU
FOR AS PART OF OPPOSITION OF AB
NINE SIX- BEFORE NINETY SIX
GIVES ME MY PRESS ONE AND THEN
ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS FOR SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION OF AB FOUR NINETY
SIX. WE WILL GO TO LINE
SEVENTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
HELLO I'M KYLE JOKED WITH.
BAMILEKE ADVOCATING FOR CHEMICAL
AND TOXIC SAFETY AND STRONG
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. THANK YOU I
NINETEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS PRISCILLA
CHAOS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA PRODUCT STEWARDSHIP
COUNCIL AND NATIONAL STEWARDSHIP
ACTION COUNCIL IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THANK YOU LINE
EIGHTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN. THIS
IS CATHERINE DODDERIDGE YOU'RE
NURSING A MEMBER OF THE ALLIANCE
OF NURSES FOR HEALTHY
ENVIRONMENTS IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THANK YOU LINE TWENTY
TWO YOUR LINE IS OPEN. MORNING
JIM LINDBERG ON BEHALF OF THE
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
OF CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU LINE ELEVEN YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. THIS IS JAMIE MCCONNELL
WOMEN'S VOICES FOR THE EARTH IN
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU LINE
FIFTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN. NINE
FIFTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN TO
HAVE A SUMMIT. THIS IS JIM KOCH
THE FOUNDER OF NONTOXIC
NEIGHBORHOODS AND I AM IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF AB. FOUR NINETY SIX.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE HAD NO
FOR SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION IN Q.
THANK YOU WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC
COMMENT BRING IT BACK TO. DIESS
DO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS.
SENATOR SO UP. WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM OBVIOUS YOU CAN SEE THAT
BUT I WANT TO DO- WE WORKED ON
MICROBEADS IN THE PAST AND SO
I'VE SPENT ON THE COMMITTEE FOR
LONG ENOUGH TO SEE A FEW THESE
COME THROUGH- THIS WE JUST I
SAID STOP LOOK UP THE ONE. THE
IS THAT WHAT WILL THE L. THE
HIDE THANKS I SAID- AND I WON I
HAVE A QUESTION ACTUALLY FOR THE
OPPOSITION WHO STATED THAT- YOU
KNOW. FIRST OF ALL WE DO WE USE
WHEN WE GIVE AN EXAMPLE USE
CHEMOTHERAPY FOR CANCER WHICH IS
VERY HARMFUL TO YOU BUT IT HELPS
YOU WITH CANCER IN THIS CASE-
THIS FOR IS A FRAGRANCE OF OVER
FIVE. UNDERSTANDING WHAT I'M
READING HERE SO WHAT IS THAT
WHAT IS THAT IS THERE IS OUR
HEALTH NEED FOR IT AND I DIDN'T
SEE THAT ANYWHERE IN HERE. AS
THE OPPOSITION WANTED ADDRESS
THAT ARE. THE. HELLO THERE- SO
NO I'M NOT AWARE OF A WHOLE.
NEED FOR IT AGAIN RUMORED
SPEAKING OF COSMETICS AND IT'S
IN A FRAGRANT INGREDIENTS SO IT
WOULDN'T BE. AN INGREDIENT THAT
YOU WOULD SEE BENEFITS TO THE
SKIN OF THAT SORT OF WHAT YOUR-
GETTING OUT I GUESS I WILL JUST
SEE YOU KNOW WHEN. CERTAINLY
PRODUCTS HAVE BEEN REFORMULATED
OUT OF IT IN THE EUROPEAN UNION
WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A
FRAGRANCE PALETTE THERE ISN'T A
ONE TO ONE LIKE BECAUSE SORT OF.
DROP IN IF YOU WILL- REPLACEMENT
THE WHOLE FRAGRANCE DOES NEED TO
BE SORT OF REFORMULATE REBUILT
TO GET AS CLOSE TO THE ORIGINAL
FRAGRANCE AS POSSIBLE SO. AND
YOU HAVE UNTIL TWENTY TWENTY
SEVEN TO FIGURE THAT OUT IS THAT
WHAT THE BILL SAYS. YES OKAY
THANK YOU. THERE'S NO OTHER
QUESTIONS WE WILL WAIT UNTIL WE
GET A CORPSMAN. SEE WHAT
HAPPENS. THANK YOU THANK YOU. I
WILL MOVE ON THEN TO ASSEMBLY
MEMBER LEASE BILLS. DECIDED TO
SEE WHAT THEY ARE. OKAY AND HE
IS SORRY THAT HE CAN'T BE HERE-
A FIRST UP PERCENT AB SIX SIXTY
FOUR- MISTER CHAIRMAN FIRST
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME TODAY.
INEQUITABLE ACCESS TO SAFE
DRINKING WATER IS A MAJOR
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE PROBLEM IN
CALIFORNIA AND CONTAMINATED
WELLS ARE PART OF THE ISSUE.
ACCORDING TO THE STATE'S TWENTY
TWENTY THREE DRINKING WATER
NEEDS ASSESSMENT EIGHTY TWO
THOUSAND DOMESTIC WELLS USED FOR
DRINKING WATER IN CALIFORNIA OR
AT RISK IT COULD CONTAINING
DANGEROUS CONTAMINANTS. THESE
CONTAMINANTS CAN CAUSE A RANGE
OF SERIOUS HEALTH ISSUES
INCLUDING CANCER. AREAS WITHOUT
RISK WELLS HAVE HIGHER OVERALL
POPULATION BURDENS HIGHER HIGHER
PERCENTAGES OF POVERTY I DON'T
MORE LIKELY TO BE LOCATED IN
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. TENANTS
RENTING PROPERTIES AT SOURCE
THEIR WATER FROM WELLS MAY
ESPECIALLY BE AT RISK WELL WATER
QUALITY IS NOT REGULATED BY
STATE OR FEDERAL LAW. AND
LANDLORDS ARE NOT REQUIRED TO
PROVIDE SAFE DRINKING WATER TO
TENANTS. AB SIX SIXTY FOUR HELPS
PROTECT AROUND HERS BY REQUIRING
WELL OWNERS TO ENSURE THAT THEIR
TENANTS HAVE ACCESS TO AN
ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF SAFE DRINKING
WATER. AND THAT THEY TEST THEIR
WELLS ANNUALLY FOR CONTAMINANTS
AND PROVIDE THOSE RESULTS TO
TENANTS. IMPORTANTLY THESE
REQUIREMENTS ARE ONLY TRIGGERED
IF WELL OWNERS ARE FIRST OFFERED
AND DECLINE. TO PARTICIPATE IN
THE DRINKING WATER SYSTEM
CONSOLIDATION. WHEN WELL OWNERS
PARTICIPATING CONSOLIDATION THE
STATE PROVIDES FUNDING TO COVER
THE COSTS OF CONNECTING THEIR
PROPERTIES TO OUR WATER SYSTEM.
TO RECEIVE SAFE DRINKING WATER.
WHEN WELL OWNERS DECLINE THEY
ESSENTIALLY DECLINE THIS FUNDING
AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.
DECLINING ALSO MEANS ANY TENANTS
DRINKING FROM THEIR WELLS CANNOT
BENEFIT FROM THESE RESOURCES. AB
SIX SIXTY FOUR WOULD MOVE US ONE
STEP CLOSER TO REALIZING THE
VISION. OF THE HUMAN RIGHT TO
WATER LAW WHICH RECOGNIZES THAT
EVERY HUMAN BEING HAS THE RIGHT
TO SAFE. CLEAN AFFORDABLE AND
ACCESSIBLE WATER. WELL SOUNDS
GOOD TO ME BUT I'D LIKE TO NOW
TURN TO TWO WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT. MICHAEL CLAIBORNE
DIRECTING ATTORNEY AT THE
LEADERSHIP COUNSEL FOR JUSTICE
AND ACCOUNTABILITY. ANNA JOANNA
ACT NAGA DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY
ADVOCACY. AND COMMUNITY WATER
CENTER. WELCOME GOOD MORNING TO
THE CHAIR IN THE COURT GOOD
MORNING TO A SENATOR DOLLY AND
THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS MICHAEL
CLAIBORNE- DIRECTING ATTORNEY
WITH LEADERSHIP COUNSEL FOR
JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY. TEN
YEARS AFTER THIS STATE
RECOGNIZED THE HUMAN RIGHTS TO
SAFE AND AFFORDABLE DRINKING
WATER. APPROXIMATELY ONE MILLION
PEOPLE STILL LACK ACCESS TO SAFE
AND AFFORDABLE WATER AND
DRINKING WATER IN THEIR HOMES. A
SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THE
PROBLEM IS HOUSEHOLDS SERVED BY
DOMESTIC WELLS THAT SERVE NEARLY
TWO MILLION CALIFORNIANS AN-
ARGUMENT TOO MANY MILLION
CALIFORNIANS. IF YOU TRAVEL TO
THE COMMUNITIES WE WORK
ALONGSIDE IN THE SAN JOAQUIN IN
EAST COACHELLA VALLEY'S YOU'LL
SEE AROUND SIXTEEN HUNDRED
HOUSES WITH LARGE THREE HUNDRED
GALLON. THIS IS TO ADDRESS WELLS
THAT HAVE GONE DRY DUE TO OVER
PUMPING BY LARGE WATER USERS
NEARBY. LESS VISIBLE ARE
CONTAMINANTS FOUND. IN WATER
DOMESTIC WELLS PUMPED FROM THE
GROUND ARSENIC ONE TWO THREE T.
C. P. NITRATES IN URANIUM ARE
ALL PREVALENT. BECAUSE THERE'S
NO REQUIREMENT TO TEST THE
MYSTIC WELL AS PEOPLE CAN DRINK
CONTAMINATED WATER FOR YEARS AND
DECADES WITHOUT REALIZING IT.
OFTEN THE BEST ANSWER TO PROVIDE
SUSTAINABLE SAFE AND AFFORDABLE
DRINKING WATER TO A COMMUNITY
STRUGGLING WITH FAILING AND AT
RISK DOMESTIC WELLS. IS
EXTENSION OF PUBLIC SERVICE FROM
A NEARBY CITY OR WATER DISTRICT.
THESE PROJECTS ARE STATE AND
FEDERALLY FUNDED AND AS A RESULT
HOUSEHOLDS CAN CONNECT TO SAFE
PUBLIC DRINKING WATER SERVICE
WITHOUT PAYING FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION COSTS. AND YET WE
OFTEN HAVE DIFFICULTY SECURING
CONSENT TO CONNECT TO A WATER
PROJECT FROM DOMESTIC WELL
OWNERS WHO DO NOT LIVE IN THE
COMMUNITY AND HAVE RENTED THEIR
PROPERTY TO ATTEND IT. AB SIX
SIX FOUR WOULD BOTH SPEED UP THE
PROCESS OF EXTENDING DRINKING
WATER TO DOMESTIC WELL
COMMUNITIES BY BETTER SECURING
SUPPORT FOR PROJECTS. EARLY ON
IN THE PROCESS AND ENSURE THAT
TENANTS ARE NOT LIGHT LEFT
BEHIND AS WE FUND AND IMPLEMENT
SOLUTIONS. AT THE SAME TIME THE
BILL RETAINS DOMESTIC WELL
OWNERS ABILITY TO CHOOSE HOW TO
MANAGE THE PROPERTY AS LONG AS
THEY ENSURE THAT RENTERS HAVE
ACCESS TO SAFE WATER. WE URGE
THE COMMITTEE SUPPORT THANK YOU
. NEXT WITNESS. GOOD MORNING MR
VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE THANKS SO MUCH FOR.
HEARING US TODAY MY NAME IS
JOHNNY KEY ANNIKA AND THE
DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY ADVOCACY
WITH COMMUNITY WATER CENTER. AND
ONE OF MY ROLES IS MAKING SURE
THAT THE FOR CONSOLIDATION
PROJECTS THAT WERE CURRENTLY
OVERSEEING. AND THE SEVERAL MORE
THAT ARE ON OUR HORIZON ACTUALLY
END UP. DELIVERING SAFE AND
AFFORDABLE DRINKING WATER TO
HUNDREDS OF RESIDENTS AS MANY
RESIDENTS AS POSSIBLE IN
CALIFORNIA. AND AGAIN THESE ARE
STATE AND FEDERALLY FUNDED
PROJECTS RIGHT. SO WHAT WHAT
THIS. LEGISLATION WOULD LOOK
LIKE ON THE GROUND AND IS KIND
OF WHAT I'M HERE TO TALK ABOUT
TODAY. IS FOR INSTANCE IN ONE
COMMUNITY THAT I WORK WITH A
COMMUNITY CALLED WEST GOSHEN
WHICH IS INTO A COUNTY. OUTSIDE
OF VICE ELIA. IT'S AT HOME IT'S
A RESIDENTS THE RESIDENTIAL AREA
OF APPROXIMATELY THIRTY PARCELS.
BUT IN IT OUTSIDE OF THOSE
THIRTY PARCELS THERE ABOUT SIXTY
FAMILIES SIXTY OR SEVENTY
FAMILIES LIVING IN THAT AREA SO
THAT TELLS YOU THAT THERE'S A
LOT OF PEOPLE RENTING. THOSE
HOMES AND ESPECIALLY DURING THE
HARVEST TIME THE POPULATION IN
THESE AREAS CAN DOUBLE OR TRIPLE
BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE COMING IN. TO
PICK OUR FRUITS AND VEGETABLES
SO IT IT KIND OF ENDS UP WITH
SOME ABSURD RESULTS WHEN WE HAVE
STATE AND FEDERALLY FUNDED
PROJECTS THAT DON'T END UP
GETTING THE SERVICES TO THE
PEOPLE WHO NEED THEM BECAUSE-
LANDLORDS ARE SOMETIMES. HARD TO
REACH- ARE IT IS AND SOMETIMES
THEY DON'T WANT TO NEGOTIATE OR
THEY DON'T WANT TO ACTUALLY TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THESE PROJECTS EVEN
THOUGH IT WILL RESULT IN. IN
THEIR PROPERTIES ACTUALLY
INCREASING IN VALUE SO THAT'S
SOMETHING THAT THIS LEGISLATION
WOULD ADDRESS AND- REALLY MEET
THE MEET THE MANDATE OF THE
HUMAN RIGHT TO WATER BY
ENSURING. AS MUCH ACCESS TO SAFE
AND AFFORDABLE DRINKING WATER
THROUGH THESE PROJECTS AS
POSSIBLE. AND I'M HAPPY TO TAKE
ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU ANYONE
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
. HERE. TWELVE HUNDRED. SERRA
RIDGES ON BEHALF OF SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU. MELISSA SEGUN ON BEHALF OF
THE PESTICIDE ACTION NETWORK IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK
YOU. SEEING NO OTHERS- WE WILL
GO TO OPPOSITION IS THERE ANYONE
HERE TWELVE HUNDRED WISHES TO
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF. AB. SIX
SIX FOUR. SEEING NONE WE WILL GO
TO OUR PHONE LINES. FOR THOSE
WHO WANT TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
OR SUPPORT. MODERATOR THANK YOU
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION OF EIGHTY
SIX SIX FOUR YOU MAY PRESS ONE
AND THEN ZERO. DAN THAT IS ONE
AND THEN ZERO FOR SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION OF AB SIX SIX FOUR.
WE WILL GO TO LINE TWENTY YOUR
LINE IS OPEN. ANYONE IN THE
TRUMP. I MEAN. THE ONLY CLEAR YA
I'M- THE BOARD. AB FOUR NINE
EIGHT. THANK YOU. WRONG WILL
EXECUTE SIX FIFTY YOUR LINE OPEN
. GOOD MORNING THIS IS WILL ON
BEHALF SPHERICAL CAL. THANK YOU
. THANK YOU LINE LINE IS OPEN.
GOOD MORNING RIGHT ON BEHALF OF
THE ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA WATER
AGENCIES IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
NINE FIFTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
I AM CURRENTLY FOUNDER OF NON
TAX NEIGHBORHOODS AND I'M AND
TRONG SUPPORT OF AB. SIXTY FOUR.
THANK YOU LINE SET. SEVENTEEN
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. RICHARD KYLE
CAL THAT ADVOCATE FOR AND TOXIC
SAFETY IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
YOU. MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE NO FOR
THE SUPPORT OPPOSITION IN KILL
THANK YOU WE WILL CLOSE THE
PUBLIC PORTION AND BRING IT TO
THE DIESS FOR QUESTIONS. ON AB
SIX SIX POORLY. YES MA'AM. I. I
DON'T HAVE ANY QUESTIONS BUT I
DO WITH THE BILL OKAY WELL.
WE'LL LET HER CLOTHES AND THEN
WE'LL DO WE'LL GET A CORPSMAN
THEN YOU WE CAN TAKE THAT ACTION
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE SOUNDS
LIKE A GREAT BILL I'D RECOMMEND-
OKAY WE WILL- WHICH IS A CORE.
SENATORS ALLEN. DOLLY HERE. HERE
GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ HERE HER TADO
. MENJIVAR HERE WHEN. SKINNER
HERE. OKAY WE HAVE A QUORUM.
SENATOR SKINNER YOU MAY MOVE THE
BILL I WILL MOVE THE BILL. KATE
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE. EIGHTY SIX
SIX FOR THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS ALLEN. DALLY
GONZALEZ. HI GONZALEZ I HER TADO
. MENJIVAR MANY OF OUR EYES WHEN
. SKINNER HI SKINNER I. THE BILL
HAS THREE BOATS WILL LEAVE IT ON
CALL. RESTAURANTS HERE OKAY- HOW
ABOUT. NEXT I'LL BE PRESENTING
AB SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN- CHAIRED
MEMBERS THIS BILL IS A FEDERAL
CONFORMITY BILL CONFORMING STATE
LOT OF FEDERAL REQUIREMENTS
SPECIFICALLY A. B. SIXTEEN
TWENTY SEVEN PRESERVES THE
STATE'S AUTHORITY TO IMPLEMENT
THE FEDERAL SAFE DRINKING WATER
ACT IN CALIFORNIA BY REVEALING A
PROVISION IN THE CALIFORNIA. A
DRINKING ACT THAT MAYBE
CONSTRUCT CONSTRUED TO EXEMPT
FOOD FACILITIES THAT OPERATE
PUBLIC WATER SYSTEMS FROM
REGULATION UNDER THE CALIFORNIA
S. T. W. A. ADDITIONALLY AB
SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN CONFORMS
CALIFORNIA'S DEFINITION OF A
PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM TO THE
FEDERAL DEFINITION. BY ALIGNING
THE CALIFORNIA S. D. W. A. IN
THE FEDERAL ONE AB SIXTEEN
TWENTY SEVEN ENSURES THAT STATE
LAW IS NO LESS STRINGENT THAN
FEDERAL LAW THIS PROTECTS THE
STATE'S PRIMARY AUTHORITY TO
ENFORCE THE FEDERAL S. T. W. A.
IN CALIFORNIA THERE'S NO
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU HAVE
ANYBODY SPEAKING IN SUPPORT.
SEEING NINE ANYONE. SPEAKING IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING ON WE WILL GO
TO OUR- CALL LINE IS ANYONE
SPEAKING IN OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT OF. AB SIXTEEN TWENTY
SEVEN MODERATOR THANK THANK YOU
FOR IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION OF
AB SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN YOU MAY
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO FOR
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. AND WE
HAVE NO ONE TO ENOUGH THANK YOU
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THE
QUESTION- ANY QUESTIONS BY
SORRY. I THINK THIS IS A SOBRE
SUPPORT. NO QUESTIONS WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE. SOUNDS LIKE A
GOOD BILL TO SUNSET I THINK IT
SOUNDS LIKE A RIGHT DO WE HAVE A
MOTION FOR THE BILL. HAVE A
MOTION BY IMAGE OF OUR- WHICH
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE. SENATORS
DOLLY. DALY I GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ
I HER TADO. HER TADO I MENTIONED
ARE. MANY OF OUR AYE NGUYEN
SKINNER ALL RIGHT SKINNER I.
THANK YOU ALL. FIVE ZERO
WOLSELEY THAT BELONG CALL.
SEEING NO OTHER AUTHORS WE WOULD
LIKE TO START WITH THE WE NEED A
MOTION ON AB TWO SEVEN NINE. I
HAVE A MOTION BY MENJIVAR. YEAH
WE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE. AB TWO
SEVEN NINE ALLEN. GALLEY HI
KELLY I GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ I HER
TADO. HER TADO I. MENJIVAR.
MINGE OF OUR AYE NGUYEN SKINNER
. SKINNER I. FIVE OH THAT BILLS
ON CALL. LET'S TAKE UP ITEM
NUMBER TWO ARE YOU READY. YEAH
WE NEED A MOTION ON AB FOUR NINE
SIX FRIEDMAN HAVE MOST MOMENT OF
OUR- AB FIVE EIGHTY FOUR NINE
SIX THE MOTION IS DO YOU PASS.
ALLEN GALLEY ARE DAILY AYE
GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ I HER TADO.
HER TADO I. MENJIVAR. AYE
MENJIVAR AYE WHEN. SKINNER
SKINNER HI. I NEED TO GO BACK
INTO AB. TWO THAT'S FIVE OH THAT
BILL IS ON CALL WE NEED TO GO
BACK AND GET A MOTION ON AB TWO
SEVEN NINE RUBIO. I THOUGHT SHE
MENJALANI YEAH JAMIE TO NINETY
POUNDS THE MOTION NOW THE MOTION
. AB TWO SEVEN NINE AM WAS YOU
PASS. HI THE MOVE TO FAST NOW.
OKAY WILL TAKE UP TO CONSENT
WHICH IS A FIVE THREE SIX. AB
SIX NOPE THAT WE TOOK OFF SORRY
AND AB SIXTY TWO AB THREE FIVE
SIX. EIGHTY FIVE EIGHTY SIX AB
THREE FIVE SIX. BY FIVE SIX FILE
THREE AB FIVE THREE SIX FILE
ITEM SEVEN A. B. THREE FIVE SIX
AND FILE ITEM EIGHT A. B. SIX
EIGHT TWO. AB TWO MOTIONS ONE BY
MENJIVAR ONE WAY SKINNER. OKAY
SENATORS ALAN DALLY BY DOLLY I
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I HER TADO.
HER TADO I. MENJIVAR MENGE OF
OUR AYE NGUYEN IN SKINNER.
SKINNER I. WE HAVE FIVE OH
BELIEVE THOSE BILLS ON CALL FOR
ABSENT MEMBER. NUMBER FOUR AND
THEN WE HAVE A ARE YOU READY FOR
THAT ONE THANK YOU AB FIVE FOUR
ONE WOULD BE A MOTION. MOTION BY
MENJIVAR. AB ONE PRODUCER THIS
NUMBER ITEM NUMBER FOR AB FIVE
FOUR ONE IT'S TO PASS TO FIFTY
PASSES TO THE COMEDIAN
APPROPRIATION TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS. SENATORS ALLEN.
DALLY OUR DAILY AYE GONZALEZ.
GONZALEZ I HER TADO. HER TADO I.
MENJIVAR MENGE OF OUR AYE NGUYEN
SKINNER. STE. FIVE OH WILL LEAVE
THE BILL ON CALL WE HAVE ONE
MORE THAT WE- SO. WE HAVE A WE
ONLY HAVE THERE'S MEMBERS. AND
FIVE WITH A RAZOR FURTADO OKAY I
DON'T KNOW ITEM NUMBER FIVE LIKE
LIVE THE CALL. ABC SIX FOUR LEE
. IT'S IS NOT WE'RE GETTING
EARLY WE'RE- HER DAUGHTER OF
OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE ON A FIVE.
ON EIGHTY SIX SIX THREE THEM IS
YOU PASS TO THE CAN ON A PER.
OUR OUR- HER TADO. HER TADO NOW
. WHEN WE NOW.
OKAY SO WE ARE WAITING ON
SENATOR CORTESE. DO YOU HAVE YOU
WANT TO GO TO THE ROLE. OKAY
WE'RE GONNA GO TO THE ROLE AGAIN
. YEP THE SERVICE IS AB TWO
SEVEN NINE THE MOTION IS DO YOU
PASS THE CURRENT VOTERS FIVE
ZERO VICE CHAIR IS VOTING I.
ALLEN WHEN. FIVE ZERO ZERO CALL
. AB SPORE NINE SIXTY ONE OF
HOMEOWNERS YEAH YOU CAN OKAY. K.
AB FOUR NINE SIX FRIEDMAN. AB
FOUR NINE SIX THE MOTION IS DO
YOU PASS. THE CURRENT VOTE IS
FIVE ZERO VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE
ALLEN. WHEN. OKAY K. WILL TAKE
UP ITEM THE CONSENT WHICH IS
ITEM NO. WE SHOULD BE CONCERNED
WHEN- WELL IT WILL YEAH OKAY YES
TAKE A CONSENT WHICH IS ITEM
FIVE THREE A. B. C. TWO. YEAH
SORRY. AND AB AB THREE SIX AND A
. SIXTY TWO. SENATOR ALLEN
SENATOR. WHEN I. YEAH SIX OO
BILLS ON CALL. REPUBLICANS OKAY
AB FIVE ONE WOULD. AB FIVE ONE.
MOTION IS DO YOU PASS AS AMENDED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS ALLEN. WHEN I.
SIX ZERO SIX ZERO STE BELIEVE
IRAN BILONG CALL AB SIX SIX FOUR
LEE. OKAY. EXISTENCE THAT'S IT
RIGHT- AB AB SIXTEEN TWENTY
SEVEN LEE. AND THE MOTION IS DUE
PASSED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
APPROPRIATIONS WITH THE VICE
CHAIR VOTING AYE ALLEN WHEN. ALL
RIGHT WE'RE WAITING ON CENTER
CORTESE SO IF YOU'RE HANGING OUT
SOMEWHERE. THE LAST.
ONE
WELCOME SENATOR CORTEZ EASIER UP
WITH SR. THIRTY FOUR. OKAY THANK
YOU- CHAIR AND MEMBERS- CREATURE
PATIENCE IS CAME RUNNING OUT OF
IT COMMITTEE I WANT TO-
STARBUCKS SIPPING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND I WANT TO THANK
THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE WITH THIS-
ED WE'VE GONE BACK AND FORTH TO
TRY TO MAKE SURE TO GET- THE
LANGUAGE EXACTLY RIGHT WHICH IS
SO IMPORTANT- UP WITH A
RESOLUTION LIKE THIS PARTICULAR
ON THIS TOPIC- CLIMATE
RESTORATION THAT SPECIFIC TERM
OF COURSE REFERS TO RESTORING
ATMOSPHERIC CARBON DIOXIDE
CONCENTRATIONS TO A LEVEL. THAT
IS ABOUT LONG TERM HUMAN
SURVIVAL SINCE INDUSTRIALIZATION
THE EARTH'S ATMOSPHERE SEEN A
SHARP SPIKE IN CARBON DIOXIDE
CONCENTRATIONS ARE CO TWO
RESULTING IN CLIMATE CHANGE-
THAT'S NO SECRET CLIMATE CHANGE.
OF COURSE IS DEVASTATING
CALIFORNIA WILDFIRES STORMS
DROUGHTS THESE IMPACTS ARE OFTEN
FELT BUT THE MOST VULNERABLE
COMMUNITIES. HUMANS HAVE NEVER
SURVIVED WITH THE SISTINE
ATMOSPHERIC CO TWO CONCENTRATION
ABOVE THREE HUNDRED PARTS PER
MILLION CO TWO IS NOW UP TO FOUR
HUNDRED TWENTY. PARTS PER
MILLION WHICH IS 40% HIGHER THAN
PRE INDUSTRIAL TIMES TO RETURN
TO THREE HUNDRED WE MUST REMOVE
ONE TRILLION TONS OF LEGACY CO
TWO FROM THE ATMOSPHERE.
SCIENTISTS AND TECHNOLOGISTS
HAVE DEVELOPED PROVEN METHODS OF
REMOVING CARBON FROM THE
ATMOSPHERE THIS INCLUDES
REPLICATING NATURAL PROCESSES
SUCH AS PHOTOSYNTHESIS IN THE
OCEAN S. R. THIRTY FOUR
HIGHLIGHTS THE IMPORTANCE OF
CRIME RESTORATION RECOGNIZES OUR
OBLIGATION TO FUTURE GENERATIONS
RESTORING THE SAFE CLIMATE ALONG
WITH ACHIEVING. NET ZERO AND NET
NEGATIVE CO TWO EMISSIONS. OF
THESE MUST ALL BE CLIMATE POLICY
PRIORITIES AND WITH THAT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU DO YOU HAVE ANY
WITNESSES. WE DO NOT OKAY.
ANYONE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF- S. R. THIRTY FOUR.
C. NINE YUP. TWO MINUTES. THANK
YOU JIM WILSON. ADVISOR TO NAPA
SCHOOLS FOR CLIMATE ACTION-
ADVOCATING IN STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYONE
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT. HERE IN ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED SEEING NON. ANY
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED. SEEING ON WE WILL GO
TO. OUR MODERATOR WITH
OPPOSITION AND SUPPORT MODERATOR
. THANK YOU FOR IN OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT OF THE S. R. THIRTY FOUR
YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND THEN
ZERO FOR SUPPORTER OPPOSITION.
MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE NO ONE IN
Q. OKAY WE WILL CLOSE PUBLIC
COMMENT BRING BACK TO THE DÍAS
ANY QUESTIONS FOR THE SENATOR.
DON'T HAVE A MOTION IT IS. IT IS
. DO PASSED TO BE ADOPTED AS
AMENDED. HE'S CALL THE ROLL.
SENATORS ALLEN. DOLLY GONZALEZ.
GONZALEZ I HER TADO. HER TADO
I'M- MANJA AYE WIN. SKINNER
SKINNER I. FOUR ZERO ON CALL WE
WILL LEAVE IT ON CALL FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBER. THANK YOU THANK
YOU. ALL RIGHT. YOU CAN ONLY I
AM IN A SERVICE CALL RE. UNTIL
CENTER INTEL'S ALLEN COMES BACK
ALL RIGHT WE WILL REOPEN THE
ROLE FOR THE CHAIRED AT I'M-
LET'S START WITH THE FIRST
THAT'S AB TWO SEVEN NINE. AB TWO
SEVEN NINE THE MOTION IS DO YOU
PASS. THE CURRENT VOTERS FIVE
ZERO WITH THE VICE CHAIR VOTING
AYE ALLEN ALL ALLEN AYE WHEN.
SIX ZERO CORRECT ALSO BECAUSE
THE ROLE YEAH OKAY WELL CLOSER
SIX ZERO LET'S GO TO ITEM
TUESDAY FOUR NINETY SIX AB FOUR
NINE SIX THE MOTION IS DO YOU
PASS THE CURRENT VOTE IS FIVE
ZERO WITH THE VICE CHAIR VOTING
AYE ALLEN AYE ALLEN AYE. R.
THAT'S DONE IT'S- SIX TWO ZERO
ZERO AS WELL- MORE MEXICO TO THE
CONSENT CALENDAR. ALLEN HI ALAN
I. THAT'S SEVEN ZERO CLOSER ON
THAT LET'S GO TO A SUMMER WOODS
BILL AB FIVE FORTY ONE. AB FIVE
FOUR ONE AND THE MOTION IS DO
YOU PASS AS AMENDED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS THE
CURRENT VOTE IS SIX ZERO WITH
VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE ALLEN AYE.
ALLEN AYE. THAT'S SEVEN ZERO
CLOSER ON THAT AB SIX SIXTY FOUR
SIMILARLY. AB SIX SIX FOUR WITH
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS THE
CURRENT VOTE IS THREE TWO. ALLEN
HI ALAN HI SO THAT'S FORTY TWO
WE WILL CLOSE DOWN AND WE THANK
YOU SO EVER FRIEDMAN FOR
PRESENTING A BILL IT'S GOING TO
AB SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN. I LEASE
BILL AB ONE SIX TWO SEVEN THE
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS THE
CURRENT VOTE IS FIVE ZERO WITH
THE VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE. ALLEN
ALL RIGHT ALAN HI AND THEN
FINALLY. I AM SORRY THAT'S A SIX
ZERO. AND NOW FINALLY WE'RE
GOING TO CORTES HE'S S. R.
THIRTY FOUR. SR THIRTY FOUR WITH
THE MOTION IS TO BE ADOPTED AS
AMENDED ALLEN HI. ALLEN I.
THAT'S FIVE TWO ZERO AND- WILL
CLOSE THE ROLE ON THAT ITEM.
RIDICULOUS SO WITH THAT I REALLY
APPRECIATE EVERYONE'S FOR
BERENSON WILL. WILL WILL CALL
THIS HEARING. ADJOURNED.