THIS COMMITTEE ON HOUSING WILL
COME TO ORDER ON WELCOME
EVERYONE TODAY WE CONTINUE TO
WELCOME IN PERSON- PUBLIC'S
VISION AS WELL AS OUR PUBLIC
COMMENT VIA TELECONFERENCE
ARVEST FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING
TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY-
THE PACIFIC NUMBER IS.
877-226-8581 SIX THREE IN THE
ACCESS CODE IS. SEVEN THREE SIX
TWO EIGHT THREE FOUR. SEVEN
THREE SIX TWO EIGHT THREE FOUR-
WE ARE HOLDING THIS HEARING- IN
OUR- ST- BUILDING AS OUR CAPITAL
CONTINUES TO UNDERGO SOME VERY
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES- AND I WE
ASK OUR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
TO PLEASE- COME THIS TO THE
COMMITTEE ROOM TO HELP US
ESTABLISH A QUORUM WE ARE- WORK
FOR WE NEED SEX SO WE CAN MAYBE
HAVE A BETTING POOL ON HOW LONG
IT'S GONNA TAKE FOR OUR FIFTH
AND SIX MEMBERS ARRIVED- WE HAVE
FOUR BILLS ON TODAY. TODAY'S
AGENDA TWO OF THOSE BILLS ARE ON
CONSENT- THE TO ON CONSENT OR
ITEM NUMBER TWO. THAT'S BEFORE
SEX BYE CENTER CORTESE SAID ITEM
FIVE AS BEFORE SEVENTY SEVEN- BY
THE HOUSING COMMITTEE WILL TAKE
A MOTION ON THAT ON THE CONSENT
CALENDAR ONCE WE ESTABLISH-
PERFORMS A WE'RE GONNA BEGIN AS
A SUB COMMITTEE. UNTIL QUORUM
ARRIVES- AND I WANT TO WELCOME
OUR FIRST PRESENTER OF SENATOR
RUBIO FOR ITEM NUMBER ONE. SB.
TWENTY YOU MAY PRESENT. GOOD
AFTERNOON BOB CHAIRMAN THAT CAN
TODAY PROUD TO PRESENT S. B.
TWENTY AND EMPOWER FAILED WILL
HELP CAR. A DRESS CAL OF HOUSING
SHORTAGE HOMELESSNESS CRISIS THE
IDEA FOR THE BILL CONSTRUCT
INCREDIBLE SUCCESS WE'VE HAD IN
THE SINGULAR VALUE WITH THE
HOUSING TRUST THAT I CREATED
SEVERAL YEARS BACK. IN TWENTY
NINETEEN GOVERNOR NEWSOM SIGN MY
SENATE BILL SEVEN FIFTY ONE INTO
LAW AUTHORIZING COMMUNITIES OF
THE SINGULAR VALUE TO COME
TOGETHER AND CREATE A REGIONAL
HOUSING TRUST. AND SINCE THEN IT
HAS HEALED A LOT OF SUCCESS IN A
LOT OF OPPORTUNITY IT CREATES A
FRAMEWORK FOR NEW REGIONAL
HOUSING TRUST MODELED AFTER THE
SUCCESSFUL THANK YOUR VALLEY
REGION A HOUSING TRUST I KNOW
IT'S A MOUTHFUL BUT- THAT'S THE
NAME. THIS WILL ALSO ALLOW
GOVERNMENTS TO CREATE THEIR OWN-
THE ONLY HOUSING TRUST BUT
WITHOUT NEEDING TO COME TO THE
LEGISLATURE EVERY HERE SINCE
TWENTY NINETEEN WHERE I CREATED
THAT THE OF THE ORIGINAL ONE.
THERE'S BEEN ABOUT THREE TO FOUR
THAT COMES BEFORE YOU AND SO WE
DECIDED THAT INSTEAD OF PUTTING
THE BURDEN ON YOU KNOW WE WOULD
CREATE A STATEWIDE REGIONAL
HOUSING TRUST SELL. THIS IS JUST
OPTIONAL OFTEN THAT MEANS ANY
COMMUNITY THAT WANTS TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE CANNOT. BOB BILL IS A
BY TWENTY FIVE PRO HOUSING
GROUPS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS FROM
ACROSS THE ENTIRE STATE IT ALSO
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT IN THE SENATE GOVERNANCE
AND FINANCE COMMITTEE LAST
MONTH. I WANT TO THANK THE CHAIR
IN THE COMMITTEE I KNOW THAT MY
STAFF HAS BEEN WORKING CLOSELY
WITH YOUR COMMITTEE SO JUST WANT
TO THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
TO. TO WORK WITH YOU IN AND TAKE
INPUT AND I GET TO THE RIGHT
PLACE WITH THE SPELL. AND I ALSO
WANT TO- TODAY INTRODUCED OP
SOMEONE OUT THAT SUPPORTING THE
BILL MIGHT LEAD WITNESSES JORDAN
PANAMA CARVAJAL. FROM CALIFORNIA
YIMBY AND- WHEN YOU'RE READY HE
WILL PROCEED THANK YOU VERY MUCH
YOU MAY BE SEATED THANK YOU GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS JONATHAN
AND KIND OF ODD. THAT IS THAT
ADVOCATE FOR CALIFORNIAN BE THE
CUTEST BECAUSE SPORT SB TWENTY
CALIFORNIAN BE THE STATE WHERE
ORGANIZATION OF OVER EIGHTY
THOUSAND NEIGHBORS DEDICATED TO
MAKING OUR STATE A FOR A PLACE
TO LIVE. WORK AND RAISE RAISE A
FAMILY FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS. THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF A REGIONAL
HOUSING TRUST IS A PROVEN
SOLUTION TO HELP FINANCE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT. FOR
HOMELESS AND LOW INCOME
POLLUTION. A POPULATIONS AS
EVIDENCE TO THE FINGER FINGER
BROKE VALLEY REGIONAL HOUSING
TRUST WHICH HAS BEEN A
INCREDIBLE SUCCESS STORY. IN
JUST A FEW SHORT YEARS NEARLY
TWO. DOZEN SMALL CITIES HAVE
JOINED TOGETHER AND LEVERAGE OUR
COLLECTIVE RESOURCES. TO FIND
SEVERAL AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROJECTS AND OPEN THE FIRST TINY
HOME VILLAGE FOR THE ON. HOUSING
IN THE REGION. WELL SOME CITIES
AND INCOME. NOT MEETING THE
SHARE OF HOUSE AND UNDER PUT.
PURDUE NEW SUPPLY. THE SINGER
WROTE THE BALLOT. HOUSE TRUST.
PROVE THAT THERE ARE MANY MORE
LOCAL GO. WORKING PRODUCTIVELY
TO. CALL HOUSING FOR. SB TWENTY
WOULD ALLOW OTHER REGIONS AROUND
THE STATE TO REPLICATE THE
SUCCESS OF THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY. REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST.
IT DOES THIS BY ESTABLISHING A
STATE FRAMEWORK FOR LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS THAT WANT TO.
EXPEDITE THE CREATION OF THEIR
OWN REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST
WITHOUT THE REQUIREMENT TO PASS.
IMPLEMENTING LEGISLATION PRIOR.
TO PROVIDE A LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
WITH ANOTHER TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX
AT THREE TWENTY. AS WE TRY TO
OFFER CALIFORNIA'S ANOTHER PATH
TOWARD ACHIEVING OUR SHARED GOAL
OF ADDRESSING THE HOUSING
CRISIS. CREATING A FUTURE FROM
CREATING A FUTURE WHERE EVERY
PERSON HAS IT HAS ACCESS TO SAFE
AFFORDABLE HOME. IT'S FOR THIS
REASON WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR SUPPORT FOR SB TWENTY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS
THERE ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN
THE HEARING ROOM. SEEING NONE-
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
ROOM PLEASE COME FORWARD. GOOD
AFTERNOON SENATORS IT'S A
PLEASURE TO BE HERE MY NAME IS
JOHN SCRIBNER I'M WITH THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS. AND WE RESPECTFULLY
ABBE OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED
POSITION ON. THIS BILL. OUR
CONCERN IS ABOUT. MOVING FORWARD
AND CONSTRUCTING HOUSING WITH
THE AVAILABLE FUNDS THAT YOU
HAVE. IT ISN'T ABOUT USING THOSE
FUNDS. TO DENY POTENTIAL
HOMEOWNERS. THE OPPORTUNITY TO
BUY THAT HOUSE. OR THAT DUPLEX.
THE ISSUE IS WITHOUT A CLEAR
GUARD RAIL IF YOU WILL ON
ACQUISITION. THESE GROUPS WILL
GAVE BE COMPETING. WITH THE
CALIFORNIANS FOR TRYING TO BUY A
HOME. FOR THE WANT OF THAT ONE
EVENT THAT IS OUR ONLY ISSUE
WITH THE BILL. IS TO ALLOW
CALIFORNIANS TO BUY A HOME
RATHER THAN HAVING MORE GROUPS
COMPETING AND TAKING THEM AWAY
FROM THE HOUSING STOCK FOR
PEOPLE TO PURCHASE. I MEAN JUST
LAST YEAR THIS BODY. APPROVED
AND FUNDED A MAJOR PROGRAM TO
HELP CALIFORNIANS BUY A HOME.
THE CALIFORNIA DREAM FOR ALL.
AND THIS YEAR'S PROPOSED PLAN
FROM THE SENATE DEMOCRATS EVEN
CALLS FOR CONTINUED FUNDING AND
TO MAKE IT I GUESS BASICALLY
CONTINUOUS APPROPRIATION OR SELF
SUSTAINING. BUT MY COLLEAGUE WHO
TESTIFIED LITTLE EARLIER TALKED
ABOUT THAT TOOL BOX RIGHT. WELL
WHEN I WORKED IN BOTH HOUSES
YEARS AGO WE WOULD EVALUATE
THESE BILLS BASED ON WHETHER THE
PROPOSAL WAS A NEW PROGRAM. TO
PRESENT A DIFFERENT PARADIGM OR
PHILOSOPHY. OUR WEATHER
COMPLEMENTED AN EXISTING PROGRAM
. OUR WEATHER CAUSE PROBLEMS
WITH THOSE PROGRAMS ALREADY
AVAILABLE AND WORKING. IN THIS
CASE FOR THE WANT OF THAT ONE OF
THEM. THIS BILL RUNS COUNTER TO
EVERYTHING THIS BODY HAS DONE
LAST YEAR IN THE BUDGET. I MEAN
YOU HAVE IN PAST ACTIONS AT
KNOWLEDGE BIG GROUPS BUYING UP.
HOMES ENTRY LEVEL HOMES. AND
THIS HAS THAT SAME POTENTIAL
HOWEVER LAUDABLE. IT STILL HAS
THE SAME POTENTIAL WERE SAYING
WE'RE GOING TO PUT MONEY BILL.
LET'S DEAL WITH THE SHORTAGE BY
BUILDING OUR WAY OUT OF IT.
OTHERWISE WE'RE SIMPLY
TRANSFERRING ONE SET OF STOCK
HOUSING. TO RESTRICTED HOUSING
AND THERE'S NOTHING FOR THOSE
RUNNERS WHO WANT TO MOVE UP TO
BUY. THAT'S OUR PROBLEM AND
THAT'S OUR ISSUE WE HAVE. AND AT
A TIME WHEN CALIFORNIA'S
HOMEOWNERS NEW HOMEOWNERS ARE
BEGINNING TO MORE ACCURATELY
REFLECT. THE DIVERSE CITY OF
CALIFORNIA. OUR ACTIONS ARE
BASICALLY GOING TO START SAYING
YOU KNOW HOLD OFF. WE MAY HAVE
OTHER PLANS THAT PREVENT YOU
FROM BUYING THAT IN AND IT DE
FACTO MANNER. SO I WOULD ASK YOU
PLEASE HELLO DISCUSSION ABOUT
AMENDMENT THAT LIMITS IT
EXCLUDES ONE TO FOUR. THAT'S ALL
WE ARE ASKING FOR. AND THEN WE
WILL GLADLY WHO WALK AWAY. I
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
TIME THANKS AGAIN. THANK YOU SO
MUCH IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL
OPPOSITION- COMMENT IN THE ROOM
. EMAIL WILL GO TO THE PHONE
LINES. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENTS. IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION S. B.
TWENTY THIS PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME. AND WE HAVE NO
COMMENT OKAY WILL BRING BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. I AM A
SENATOR TO VOTE THANK YOU SIR
OUR- RESEARCH HERE- THROUGH
WHICH IS LIKE AN- TO RESPOND TO
THE- THE CONCERNS OF THE
OPPOSITION. YES I WOULD THINK
HILL- AND THANK YOU FOR THIS
OPPORTUNITY- I THINK AND I'M
HAPPY TO SEE MY GOALS ARE THE
SAME AS THE REALTORS AND THAT IS
TO ENSURE THAT THERE IS AN OF
HOUSING- IT'S NOT YOU KNOW
COMBAT PUTTING AT A DISADVANTAGE
ONE GROUP OR THE OTHER. TO MAKE
SURE THAT PEOPLE MOVE UP AND SO-
I AM WORKING WITH MY STAFF AND
WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
THE REALTORS THAT'S MY INTENTION
IS NOT TO DISADVANTAGE THEM SO I
JUST WANTED TO SHARE A LITTLE
BIT WITH THE HOUSING TRUST HOUSE
DONE. THE HOUSING TRUST HAS
BUILT A HUNDRED AND FIVE TINY
HOMES FOR THE HOMELESS CONNECT
AND HAS HOUSE- AGAIN
APPROXIMATELY OVER A HUNDRED
FOLKS THAT GET FED THREE TIMES A
DAY. OFF FOR THOSE FAMILIES THAT
HAVE CHILDREN THERE IS A
COMMUNITY CENTER SO THEY CAN DO
THEIR HOMEWORK I THESE ARE
FAMILIES THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN ON
THE STREETS HAD IT NOT BEEN FOR
THAT THE HOUSING TRUST. SO I
JUST WANTED TO SHARE A LITTLE
BIT ASPECT OF THAT HOUSING TRUST
THE OTHER ASPECT IS WE ARE
COMPLETING SIX HUNDRED AND FIFTY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS THAT
WERE NOT. TAKEN FROM ANYWHERE
THESE ARE PROJECTS THAT WERE
SITTING THERE STALLED FOR YEARS.
I KNEW THAT AS A COUNCIL MEMBER
WHEN I WAS A COUNCIL MEMBER FOR
THIRTEEN YEARS WE- USED TO RUN
INTO FINANCIAL DEFICIENCIES AND
SOME OF YOU HAVE SERVE LOCALLY
YOU DON'T ALWAYS HAVE THE
FUNDING AND AGAIN WE HAVE GREAT
IDEAS GREAT PLANS AND A LOT OF
THE- IDEAS JUST. STAY ON THE
TABLE BECAUSE WE CANNOT AFFORD
TO FUND ITSELF THE SIX HUNDRED
AND FIFTY HOUSING UNITS THAT
WE'RE BUILDING. WERE PROJECTS
THAT WERE ALREADY DONE THERE
WERE SHOVEL READY. AND WENT UP
CITIES HAVE A DIFFICULT TIME
FINISHING THE PROJECT. THEY WILL
APPROACH THE REGION A HOUSING
TRUST AND WE GET ON THE FUNDING
TO COMPLETE IT. SO IN THESE
CASES THAT I'VE HIGHLIGHTED WE
HAVEN'T TAKEN ONE HOME AWAY. AND
THEN WE HAVE ANOTHER. FOUR
HUNDRED ON IN THE PIPELINE SO
THAT'S OVER AT THE- I WAS SENT
HOME THAT ARE BEING CREATED.
THAT WOULD GIVE. FOR FOLK NOT
ONLY TO BE HOW. BUT FOR THE
CHOICE TO HAVE WELL. TO SELL. I
DO UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN I JUST
WANT TO HIGHLIGHT. THAT THE
REGION HOUSING BECAUSE BECAUSE
WE'RE SO PROUD OF IT BUT I DO
WANT TO WORK AT THE REALTORS I
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
REALTORS. AND QUITE FRANKLY AS
MY COLLEAGUES KNOW IT HAS BEEN A
VERY BUSY TIME. AND SO IT WAS
JUST A MATTER OF GETTING TO THE
TABLE AND TOP. YOU KNOW THAT
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT
LOOKS LIKE STILL. WANTS TO PASS
ITS COMMITTEE I HAVE. BY THEY
HAVE MY FULL COMMITMENT THAT'LL
CONTINUE TO WORK ON IT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. SENATOR JUST. TO
FOLLOW UP SO IF I UNDERSTAND
CORRECTLY I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE
THAT I HAVE. CLEAR WHAT THE
CONCERNS ARE. WITH REGARD TO
REALTORS. YOUR CONCERN. THAT THE
TRUST WILL TAKE PROPERTIES. THAT
ARE CURRENTLY ALREADY BUILT TO.
BE REFURBISHED AND BE ABLE TO BE
ALLOCATED FOR THIS PARTICULAR
PURPOSE THAT'S YOUR CONCERN. AND
RIGHT OKAY. IN YOUR IN YOUR
PURPOSE IN WHAT YOU JUST EXPLAIN
IS THAT. THE AS- AS IT EXISTS
RIGHT NOW. NOT ONCE HAS THAT
HAPPENED. AB PRIOR TO. WELL LET
ME CORRECT. THE RECORD- AT THIS
POINT TO- THE ONLY CASE WHERE IT
HAPPENED AND I THINK WE'LL HAVE-
HABITAT FOR HUMANITY IN OUR
COMMUNITIES- THEY DO THEIR OWN
THING ON THEIR OWN TIME AND
THEY'LL CAR HOUSES. ON THEIR OWN
TIME WITH THEIR OWN NONPROFIT
FINDING SELL. BECAUSE WE HAD SO
MUCH SUCCESS AND WE HAD MONEY
THEY CAME TO US AND SAID. CAN
YOU HELP WITH HELP WITH A COUPLE
OF PROJECTS SO YES HABITAT FOR
HUMANITY. HAS BENEFITED TO
FINISH THEIR PROJECTS- SO I
DON'T WANNA YOU KNOW- IT'S NOT
THAT THE HOUSING CHOICES TAKING
THEM AWAY IT'S JUST THAT WE'RE
HELPING A NONPROFIT LIKE HABITAT
FOR HUMANITY SO. I WAS THINKING
OF SOME KIND OF MIDDLE GROUND
WHERE WE MAY EXCLUDE SOME OF
THESE NONPROFITS BECAUSE WE KNOW
THAT THE TO GO TO WORK AND- THEY
ACTUALLY PLACE OUR FAMILIES AT
HOME HOMES THAT. WOULD OTHERWISE
NEVER HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE
HOMEOWNERS SELL WE'RE NOT THERE
YET LIKE I SAID THESE ARE JUST
IDEAS BUT I DO WANT TO SIT WITH
THEM JUST KNOW THAT I'M FULLY
COMMITTED TO WORKING WITH THEM
BECAUSE I WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT. THEY'RE OKAY WITH THAT
AND- MISTER TECH. TECH JUST AS A
FOLLOW UP SO- MORE OF THEIR WAY
NOT THE- IS YOUR CA. THAT YOUR
APPLY TO HAVE A FOR. SENERE OR
IS IT COMPLETELY ASIDE FROM THE
HABITAT FOR WEEKS. AT THE ISSUE
IS. WITHOUT REGARD TO HABITAT.
OR NEW YORK REET. IT'S THE ISSUE
OF TAKING EXISTING HOUSING. AND
CONVERTING IT TO RENTAL. AND NO
LONGER HAVING IT AVAILABLE. OKAY
SOMEONE TO PURCHASE IT'S NOT
DIRECTLY WITH THOSE PARTICULAR
PRO THAT DOES NOT. IS NOT ABOUT
CHARGES WHETHER IT'S YOUR CAREER
HABITAT IT'S THE ISSUE. SUGGEST
HAVING CLARIFICATION ON THE
LANGUAGE ON AB THEY WOULD
EXCLUDE YOU IN. A UNITS FROM ONE
TO FOUR BUT NOT NECESSARILY
IMPLYING ANYTHING THAT HAS. WE
DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH
APARTMENTS ANYTHING LIKE THAT
IT'S THE ONE TO FOUR WHERE YOU
COULD HAVE A HOMEOWNER TRYING TO
GET IN. CONTACT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH I APPRECIATE YOUR FEEDBACK
AND I WILL BE SUPPORTING THE AB
THE BILL AT THIS TIME AND I'LL
BE HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL WHEN
APPROPRIATE BUT I DO WOULD LOVE
TO SEE. AB IN THE COMPETITION
AND I DON'T SEE A CONFLICT OF
INTEREST BASED ON THE EXAMPLES
THAT YOU GAVE IN YOUR GOALS. FOR
THIS PARTICULAR FAILS- AND I DO
SEE THE CONCERN AS FAR AS THE
FORMER REAL TORQUE. AND I. DO
SEE THE CONCERNS THAT THEY THEY-
CAN. THIS WITH WEEK TO TAKING
AWAY CURRENT- CURRENT INVENTOR
WHICH IS VERY LIMITED AND AT
TIMES IT BECOMES VERY VERY
LIMITED FOR OUR FIRST TIME HOME
BUYERS. ON THAT AND SO. I IN MY
LITTLE WORLD IN MY MIND I DON'T
SEE A CONFLICT OF INTEREST OF UP
BE ABLE TO FIND LANGUAGE IS A
COMEDY INTO BOTH- WOULD LOVE TO
SEE THAT AT THE ANIMAL RESERVE
MY- MY VOTE AT ME. SERGEANTS
CHANGER OR KEEP MY VOTE
DEPENDING ON THE FINAL LANGUAGE
BUT I THINK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
THIS BILL AND BRING IT TO. THE
LIGHT AND I AM HAPPY WITH THE
BILL ONE. IT COMES REMOVED FROM
MOTION MY CENTER- OR THANK YOU
FOR THIS BILL IS WELL HE'S IN.
TO STRESS THAT THIS IS A PURELY
LOCAL CONTROL. BILL THIS IS
SIMPLY AUTHORIZING BUT NOT
REQUIRING TWO OR MORE CITIES TO
COME TOGETHER AND CREATE A JOINT
POWERS AUTHORITIES- FOR AS A
HOUSING. TRUST IT'S A TOOL THAT
THEY CAN DECIDE LOCALLY. HELLO I
WANT TO DO AND I DON'T THINK WE
SHOULD- TELL THEM YOU CAN DO IT
HERE BUT NOT. BUT NOT THERE I
THINK IT MAKES SENSE TO GIVE
THEM FLEXIBILITY- AND I
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
FORWARD- AND- YOU YOU MAY HAVE
ALREADY CLOSE TO EDUCATE SOME
ELEGANT REMARKS BUT YOU'RE
WELCOME TO CLOSE OUT. A. THANK
YOU AND THANK YOU FOR POINTING
THAT OUT AS I MENTIONED I WAS A
COUNCIL MEMBER LOCALLY SO IT'S
VERY IMPORTANT FOR ME NOT TO BE
TOO PRESCRIPTIVE AND- AND THAT
IS THE POINT- YOU KNOW THERE'S
TWENTY TWO CITIES THAT HAVE NOW
JOINED. MY HOUSING TRUST THEY'RE
NOT IN MY SENATE DISTRICT BUT
THAT JUST SPEAKS TO THE SUCCESS
AND- AND HOW THEY SAW THEMSELVES
BEING- EIGHT EIGHT WHEN THEY
HAVE PROJECTS THAT WERE STALLED.
THAT'S HOW THEY GET THEIR
HOUSING DOWN AND SELL. YES I
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS
FLEXIBILITY I DON'T WANNA BE TOO
PRESCRIPTIVE BUT I DO WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT I WORK WITH THE
REALTORS. AND LET'S FIND A
MIDDLE GROUND AND SO I'M WILLING
TO DO THAT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH AND WE DO NOW HAVE A
QUORUM SO. LETS US SELVES.
QUORUM SENATOR WIENER. PRESENT
WINNER PRESENT A TROUBLE PRESENT
A SHOW PRESENT. CABALLERO CORTEZ
HE YOUR CORTES A HERE MCGUIRE.
PATEA HERE. HERE HERE SEYARTO.
C. R. TO HEAR SKINNER. HERE
SKINNER HERE BURKE. BOB THE
COURT SIX WE A QUORUM- AND WE-
ACTUALLY WILL MELT TAKEN. FOR
CENTERS OF THOSE- MY APOLOGIES
WHO- THANK YOU- SEN RUBIO FOR
BRING THIS- I HAVE A BILL THAT.
SOME THAT WOULD IN A- FOR. LOCAL
LOW GOVERNMENTS SAID TO COME. TO
CREATE. REGIONAL.
I KNOW IF- THE BASICALLY THE
SUBSIDY TO MAKE THE HOUSING
AFFORDABLE BECAUSE FOR DOUBLE
HOUSING NEEDS SUBSIDY PRIVATE
MARKET DOES NOT- IS- THIS WILL.
WHATEVER LIMITED IN WHAT THEY
WILL DO REGARDING THAT BECAUSE
OBVIOUSLY- PROFIT DEVELOPERS
NEED TO BE ABLE TO HELP THEIR
PROJECTS PENCIL OUT. AND ONE OF
THE WAYS OF COURSE THAT WE'VE
BEEN TRYING TO INCENTIVIZE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THROUGH
MARKET REDEVELOPMENT IS WITH-
DENSITY BONUSES WITH A HOLD
RATING MANY OF THE BILLS WE'VE
DONE VARIETY THINGS LIKE THAT
BUT WE STILL HAVE A SEVERE
SHOULD NOT ONLY SEVERE HOUSING
SHORTAGE BUT A SEVERE HOUSE
SEEMS AFFORDABLE HOUSING
SHORTAGE. AND SO MECHANISMS LIKE
THIS TO BE ABLE TO GET THE
FINANCING TO DO IT IS VERY
SENSUAL NOW MY POINT OF SPEAKING
IS TO THE REALTORS. I APPRECIATE
THAT THERE'S NOT A LOT OF-
INVENTORY AND THERE'S A LOT OF
REASONS NUMBER ONE BECAUSE WE
HAVEN'T BUILT ENOUGH HOUSING
NUMBER TWO BECAUSE WITH HIGHER
INTEREST RATES PEOPLE ARE- YOU
KNOW FEARFUL THAT IF THEY SELL
THEIR HOUSE THEY CAN'T AFFORD
THE NEXT HOUSE SO I APPRECIATE
THAT REALTORS NEED INVENTORY IN
ORDER TO- TO. DO THEIR JOBS
HOWEVER. TO OPPOSE THIS BECAUSE
OF THE FEAR THAT. THRUST LIKE
THIS WOULD BUY UP ALL SINGLE
FAMILY HOMES I MEAN I KNOW YOU
DIDN'T SAY ALL BUT. I JUST- WE
THE TYPE OF CHANGE THAT WE THE
LEGISLATURE HASN'T HAVE MADE
EMBARRASSED OF OUR LAND USE
POLICIES. IF THIS WOULD ENABLE
SOME TRUST TO BUY UP A SINGLE
FAMILY HOME PROPERTY AND THEN
UTILIZE IT FOR. HI AS A LARGER
MORE UNITS- THE NAC BENEFITS US
AND IT BENEFITS THAT. AND
THERE'S ALSO NOTHING IN HERE
THAT SAYS THAT THE- PROGRAM
COULDN'T. DO HOUSING FOR
OWNERSHIP THERE'S NOTHING IN IT
SO THERE COULD BE OWNERSHIP
OPPORTUNITIES WITH THIS PROGRAM.
AND WHILE I AGAIN APPRECIATE
THAT- EVERYONE WHO COMES BEFORE
US IS ALWAYS. LOOKING OUT FOR
THEIR IMPORTANT INTEREST MORE
HOMES IN THE REALTORS INTEREST
SO I JUST WANTED TO MAKE THAT
COME IS CAN I JUST SAID I'M
SORRY OPENED THE DOOR MAY I MAKE
JUST ONE COMMENT. OKAY AND I
SHOULD HAVE UPSET THAT I WAS
TRYING TO STREAMLINE IT BUT SOME
OF THE PROJECT THAT WE HAVE
BUILT. ARE NOT JUST ALL
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND SO ON I
BELIEVE THAT ACTUALLY THEY WILL
BENEFIT FROM A THOUSAND UNITS-
THAT ARE COMING UP- IN THE NEAR
FUTURE BUT IT'S JUST A SMALL
PERCENTAGE THEY'LL BE AVAILABLE
FOR MARKET RATE WHERE. IT WOULD
BENEFIT THE REALTORS BUT AGAIN
MY INTENTION IS TO WORK. WITH
THEM TO SEE WE CAN FIND A
SOLUTION. GREAT OKAY AND THE
APPLE I BELIEVE I CLOSED YES
OKAY WE HAVE A PROMOTION BY
CENTER TROUBLE ACROSS. THE
RESOLVER SHOWS BEFORE HAD A
QUORUM- AND IS TO PASS- THIS
BILL TO THE SENATE FLOOR. AT THE
CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR WINNER
RIGHT WE'RE HI- TROUBLE FIVE
CHAU FOLKS CLICKS. COVER YOUR
CORTEZ HE- CORTES HE REQUIRE
PATEA NIGHT BUT THE HI C. R. HI
THERE TELEVISED. RIGHT SKINNER
HI I'M BURKE BOB. OKAY LET US
TOTAL PUT CALL FOR THE OFFICE OF
MY- I THANK YOU CENTER. WILL NOW
GO TO THE CONSENT. AGENDA AGAIN
THERE TWO WAYS ON COULD ITEMS TO
AND FOR THAT'S AS- US. AND SPEAK
FOR SEVEN SEVEN- MAXIE'S HAVE A
MOTION ON THE CAN IS AN. MOSHE
MY CENTER SHOW BOTH AND CALL THE
ROLL. SENATOR WIENER BY WINNER
I- OSCEOLA AYE CHOKE I. COMING
CORTEZ ET FIVE FORTY HI REQUIRED
FOR THE- VIDEO FIVE ZERO. ZERO
TWO HI. RIGHT HI UMBERG. SIX
ZERO COULD AT A SIX VOTE SOME
REPUBLICANS AGENDA ON CALL- I
WILL NOT BE.
WELCOME SENATOR WIENER YOU ARE
ABOUT TO PRESENT SB FIVE NINETY
THREE. WHEN YOU'RE READY THANK
YOU VERY MUCH- MADAM CHAIR-
COLLEAGUES I'M HERE TO PRESENT-
SB FIVE NINETY THREE THE SAN
FRANCISCO REPLACEMENT HOUSING
ACT WHICH OPENS UP FUNDING TO
REPLACE MORE THAN FIFTY EIGHT
HUNDRED UNITS OF LOW AND
MODERATE INCOME. HOUSING THAT
WAS THAT WERE DEMOLISHED- AND
ARE TRULY ATROCIOUS PERIOD IN
SAN FRANCISCO HISTORY. FROM THE
FIFTIES TO THE SEVENTIES A
PERIOD KNOWN AS QUOTE UNQUOTE
URBAN RENEWAL- WHICH IS REALLY
URBAN DEMOLITION AND
DISPLACEMENT OF LARGELY
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. WE DURING
THIS PERIOD- SAN FRANCISCO
THROUGH ITS REDEVELOPMENT
AGENCIES- DEMOLISHED- A
SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THE OF
THE FILLMORE AREA IN THE WESTERN
TUITION WHICH HAD BEEN KNOWN AS
THE HARLEM OF THE WEST WAS A
TRULY ICONIC NEIGHBORHOOD AND IT
WAS LARGELY ODD DEMOLISHED
PUSHING OUT THOUSANDS OF
RESIDENTS. AND BUSINESSES- IT
WAS AN EPICENTER NATIONALLY OF
OUR BLACK COMMUNITY AND IT WAS
JUST SIMPLY- TORN DOWN- IN
ADDITION- WE SAW A JAPANTOWN-
EXPERIENCE DEMOLITION AS WELL AS
PORTIONS OF SOUTH OF MARKET THE
FILIPINO COMMUNITY. OTHER WITH
THE PLAN ACTUALLY PROPOSED TO
DEMOLISH AYE HE'D BIRD OPPOSE
TRIANGLE FOR THOSE FOLKS SERVICE
IS UNFORTUNATELY IT WAS STOP
BEFORE- THIS ADDITIONAL DAMAGE
WAS CAUSED. ON IN THE NINETEEN
THE TO HAD FIVE FEWER HOME THAT
AND I FIFTY OF THIRTY PER
DECREASE EFFORTS. BLACK POPULATE
IN NINETY SEVENTY WITH 30% TODAY
IT'S FIVE POINT PERCENT. SOME
BETWEEN TWENTY AND THIRTY PEOPLE
OVER WERE DISPLACED SIMPLY
BULLDOZED OUT OF THEIR
NEIGHBORHOODS EIGHT HUNDRED
EIGHTY THREE BUSINESSES WERE
DISPLACED FOUR THOUSAND SEVEN
HUNDRED AND TWENTY NINE
HOUSEHOLDS WERE DISPLACED AND
TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED VICTORIAN
HOMES WERE DEMOLISHED. ELEVEN
HUNDRED SENIOR CITIZENS TRUST IN
ONE'S OWN WERE DISPLACED FROM
THEIR HOMES- SB FIVE NINETY
THREE PROVIDES A NARROW AND
TAILORED FUNDING SOURCE- THROUGH
THE REDEVELOPMENT PROPERTY TAX
TRUST FUND. UNLIMITED
CONTINUATION OF EXISTING TAX
INCREMENT FINANCING THAT WILL
NOT IMPACT ANY OTHER PRIORITIES
LIKE EDUCATION NOR WILL IT HAVE
ANY IMPACT ON THE STATE I
GENERAL FUND. IS LONG OVERDUE
FOR SAN FRANCISCO TO MAKE AMENDS
FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF
AFFORDABLE HOMES AND
NEIGHBORHOODS PREDOMINANTLY
POPULATED BY PEOPLE OF COLOR.
THE BILL IS SIMPLY PUTTING
TOGETHER A PLAN- AND-
AUTHORIZING SAN FRANCISCO TO
TAKE- THIS STEP I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE. AND WITH ME
TODAY TO TESTIFY ARE MANY SCOTT
FROM FREEDOM HOMES WHAT FREEDOM
WAS TOM'S UNDOCKED VERONICA
HUNTING. FROM THE CITY ADVICE
COMMITTEE FOR THE HUNTERS POINT
SHIPYARD SHE IS THE CHAIR. WE
ALSO HAVE FOR ANY TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS AUTHORITIES LOSSKY
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF. THE SAN
FRANCISCO OFFICE OF COMMUNITY
INVESTMENT IN INFRASTRUCTURE
WHICH IS A REDEVELOPMENT
SUCCESSOR AGENCY. THANK YOU I'M
SURE. HE SAID WIENER NOW
CONTINUE THEIR LEAD WHAT DOES IN
. OF SB FIVE NINETY. WHEN YOU'RE
READY. WELL WELL GOOD AFTERNOONS
. EVERYONE FOR A MISMATCH IS
SCOTT. AND I AM A RESIDENT OF
FREEDOM WEST HOMES I'VE BEEN A
RESIDENT THERE FOR OVER FORTY
FIVE YEARS SURVEYS MY THREE
CHILDREN THERE. AND I WAS MY
FIRST TIME BY MY HOME WAS
FREEDOM WAS HOUSING COOPERATIVE.
LIVES SEE MY FAMILY'S AND A FEW
MORE COMMUNITY- HOUSES BE PICKED
UP AND MOVED TO OTHER
NEIGHBORHOODS WHEN THEY WERE
TOLD THAT DOUBLES HOW'S THIS
WAR. ALONE NOT. FIT TO LIVE IN
AND WOULD COME IN AND LIVE UP
THESE HOUSES TWITTER. ON M. THEM
TO POST HIGH ANOTHER
NEIGHBORHOOD. PUT BUTTE. THE
MUCH OF BLACK FOLKS AND
NEIGHBORHOOD THE DOLLS HOUSES
FOR. CONDEMNED AND NOT FIT FOR
LIVING. I WATCHED AS A YOUNG
CHILD GROWING UP IN THE FILLMORE
COMMUNITY BOB WAS ONE OF THOSE
PEOPLE THAT LOST HER HOME FULTON
STREET- DOWN THE STREET FROM THE
AFRICAN AMERICAN ART AND CULTURE
COMPLEX ALL WATCH MANY FAMILIES
MANY FAMILIES IN OUR COMMUNITY
JUST BE UPROOTED AND LEAVE. NO
PLACE TO GO WE DON'T WANT THAT.
FOR YOU FEEL MORE INFO FREEDOM
WAS TO HAPPEN AGAIN I'VE BEEN AN
ADVOCATE FOR FREEDOM WESTON FOR
A FEW MORE COMMUNITY ALL MY LIFE
. I RAISE MY CHILDREN THERE. WE
HAVE A BEAUTIFUL DIVERSE
COMMUNITY OF PEOPLE OF ALL
COLORS WE MAJORITY OF US CAME
HERE TO BUY OFFERS HOME WE'RE
VERY PROUD OF THAT COMMUNITY.
FOR PART OF IT. MANY OF US LOSS
OF CHILDREN IN THE COMMUNITY I
LOST MY YOUNGEST SON TO GUN
VIOLENCE IN NINETEEN NINETY SIX
AND A COMMUNITY AROUND THE
CORNER FROM MY HOUSE ALONG WITH
A LOT OF OTHER. NEIGHBORS AND WE
CONTINUE TO STAY AND TO FIGHT.
TO MAINTAIN OUR COMMUNITY
BECAUSE WE LOVE SAN FRANCISCO WE
LOVE THE CITY OF ST FRANCIS WE
ARE MY CHILDREN WENT TO SCHOOL
IN THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD I RAISE
THEM IN A COMMUNITY. I WANT TO
WORK IN THAT COMMUNITY. MY HOUSE
WAS TWENTY MINUTES AWAY FROM
CALIFORNIA PACIFIC MEDICAL
CENTER. AND NOW IS THE TIME FOR
US TO. REALLY THINK ABOUT
REPARATIONS AND THE RIGHT WAY.
AND TO GIVE. S. B. FIVE NINETY
THREE. THE GO AHEAD TO MOVE
FORWARD TO RIGHT THE WRONGS OF
THE PAST OF WHAT HAPPENED WE
KNOW WHAT HAPPENED WAS WRONG.
LET'S MAKE IT RIGHT. TO MAKE IT
RIGHT AGAIN. ASSEMBLY PEOPLE
LEAVE THE SENSE GO BECAUSE
ECONOMIC I DON'T WANT TO LEAVE
HELLO MY COMMUNITY MY NAME.
HELLO THE DIVERSITY. I LOVED THE
CHILDREN IN MY NEIGHBORHOOD I
LOVE BEING. SLOW SERVING ON THE
BOARD OF FREEDOM WES- TO HELP
OUR COMMUNITY TO BE STRONG WANT
TO BE BETTER NOT THANK YOUS
CINDERS GOT WIN FOR ALL THAT
YOU'VE DONE AND WHAT YOU'RE
DOING- FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
AND ALL OF YOU. SO ACTUALLY
TODAY TO DO THE RIGHT THING.
LET'S BUILD OUT COMMUNITIES BACK
UP WE CAN MAKE AMERICA GREAT
AGAIN WE GET PEOPLE BACK. IN
AFFORDABLE HOMES AND OFF THE
STREETS. WE DO THAT. DO WE HAVE
SERVE RIGHTEOUSLY WE CAN AND
WILL BILL AMERICA THE WAY THAT
IT WAS. BUT BETTER. STRONGER TO
GATHER. IN UNITY. IT AFFORDABLE
HOUSING. I WOULD LOVE AND WITH
JUSTICE SO ACTUALLY TODAY TO
PLEASE HONOR. THIS BILL. FOR
BOTH HOUSES THE SAN FRANCISCO
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MA'AM FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. WE'LL
CONTINUE WITH EARLY WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT OF SB FIVE ANY THREE.
THE CHAIRPERSON- OF CHOI BAO.
AND MEMBERS OF THIS ESTEEMED
HOUSING COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS DR
VERONICA HONEY CUT. I AM THE
CHAIR OF THE HUNTERS POINT
SHIPYARD CITIZENS ADVISORY
COMMITTEE AS WELL AS THE CHAIR
OF THE MILLION LEVY BOARD
COMMUNITY RECREATION COUNCIL. I
REPRESENT VARIOUS STAKEHOLDERS
INCLUDING THE BABY HUNTERS POINT
COMMUNITY. THE CITY AND COUNTY
OF SAN FRANCISCO AND COMMUNITY
ORGANIZATIONS. I HAVE WORKED ON
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. WORKFORCE
EDUCATION AND COMMUNITY
EMPOWERMENT INITIATIVES FOR OVER
FIFTY YEARS. AND I WOULD LIKE TO
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER FOR
PRESENTING THIS BILL FOR
APPROVAL. S. B. FIVE NINETY
THREE IS A LONG AWAITED ACTION.
TO CORRECT DISCRIMINATION AND
INJUSTICE THAT HAS DECIMATED
AFRICAN AMERICAN LIVES IN SAN
FRANCISCO. AND THE SUFFERING
CONTINUES TO THIS DAY. WHEN I
WAS A YOUNG GIRL MANY YEARS AGO
. IN THE FILLMORE AND WESTERN
ADDITION. AREAS I REMEMBER THE
NEIGHBORHOOD AND THE PEOPLE IN
THE NEIGHBORHOOD I REMEMBER THE
SMITHS THE BLACK COUPLE WHO OWN
THE DRY CLEANING ESTABLISHMENT
ON FILLMORE STREET. THE GERMAN
DELI WHERE MY FAMILY BOUGHT HOG
CHEESE THE REXALL DRUGSTORE AT
FILLMORE AND GARY WERE MY FAMILY
PURCHASED MEDICINE FROM BEEN A
JAPANESE PHARMACIST. THE
YUGOSLAVIAN BAKERY- WE ATE
PASTRIES HELEN'S RESTAURANT
WHERE WE PURCHASED DELICIOUS
CHINESE FOOD NEW HOUSES CLOTHING
STORE WHICH FEATURED PLUS SIZES
AND YES ONORATO WAS MEAT STORE.
WHICH FEATURED. OXTAILS PIG FEET
. FROG'S LEGS AND RABBIT FOOD.
WHICH WORKING CLASS PEOPLE. AND
FOLKS OF COLOR COULD AFFORD. ALL
OF THIS IS A DISTANT MEMORY.
REDEVELOPMENT FORCED AFRICAN
AMERICANS IN WORKING CLASS FOLKS
OUT OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD. SENATOR
WIENER HAS THROUGH THIS BILL
MITIGATED SAN FRANCISCO'S
ONGOING HOUSING CRISIS. EVERYONE
IN SAN FRANCISCO STANDS TO
BENEFIT FROM S. B. FIVE NINETY
THREE. ESPECIALLY LOW INCOME
WORKERS AFRICAN AMERICANS AT
RISK FAMILIES. THE REPLACEMENT
HOUSING FINANCING IS UNNECESSARY
AND URGENTLY NEEDED SOURCE TO
JUMPSTART TARGETED HOUSING
REPLACEMENTS. PLEASE KEEP THIS
IN MIND. YOUR YES VOTE. AND
APPROVAL OF S. B. FIVE NINETY
THREE. WE'LL KEEP HOPE ALIVE.
CAN UP HOLD JEFF THIS. PLEASE
KEEP THIS IN YOUR MIND. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MA'AM.
SIMONI WE WILL NOW CONTINUE WITH
ANY WITNESSES IN SUPPORT HERE IN
ROOM TWELVE HUNDRED FOR S. B.
FIVE NINETY THREE. GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIRWOMAN
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
NAME IS BOBBY SAYS I'M A MEMBER
OF BETHEL A. M. E. CHURCH SAN
FOR THIS GOAL WE'RE CELEBRATING
ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY ONE YEARS
AND THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN
FRANCISCO OUR CHURCH OVER FIFTY
ONE YEARS AGO BUILT IN SPONSORED
THE PROPERTIES IN WHICH THEY'RE
TALKING ABOUT TODAY FREEDOM WEST
HOMES. WE FILLED IT SOME URGENCY
NOT TO SPEND A LOT OF TIME
TRYING TO LOOK BACK SIXTY YEARS
AND DO A PROFILE TO TRY TO
CONVINCE YOU OF THE LOSSES THAT
HAVE BEEN SUSTAINED IN THAT
NEIGHBORHOOD BY THE FAMILIES AND
BY THOSE CHILDREN'S THE
DESCENDANTS OF THOSE FAMILIES
WOULD SIMPLY SAY TO YOU WE HAVE
AN OPPORTUNITY HERE. THIS IS NOT
ALL THE MONEY IN THE WORLD WHEN
YOU LOOK AT IT OVER TIME AND IF
WE GET IT REVERSED ANALYSIS WE
WOULD SEE THAT AMOUNT OF MONEY
THAT WE'RE DEALING WITH WHAT
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT FIVE SIX
THOUSAND FAMILIES. DIDN'T GO
MUCH BUT THIS DOES DO SOMETHING
TO RIGHT THE WRONGS SO AS OUR
CHURCH HAS SENT ME TO ASK YOU TO
SUPPORT THIS BILL IT'S BADLY
NEEDED AND CERTAINLY WOULD
BENEFIT PERSONS OF COLOR. THANK
YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND ATTENTION
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND JUST AS
A REMINDER AT THIS TIME WILL BE
TAKING A NEED TO- AT MOTION FOR
TESTIMONY SO JUST YOUR NAME YOUR
POSITION. ON THE BILL IN THE
ORGANIZATION THAT YOU'RE PERCENT
PLEASE THANK YOU. FOR TWO
HUNDRED MEMBERS OF THE ALASKA
GUY FOR THE CALIFORNIA AFRICAN
AMERICAN CHAMBER OF COMMERCE. IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU SIR.
AND STIVERS OF THE HOUSING. IN
SUPPORT OF THIS CREATIVE
MECHANISMS TO FINANCE A LONG
UNMET OBLIGATIONS THANK YOU
THANK YOU SIR. NICOLE DELUCA MAP
OF NONPROFIT HOUSING OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT THANKS
THANK YOU SIR. THANK YOU SENATOR
STORK IS LUCKY ON THE SECULAR
DIRECTOR OF THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY
OF SYMPTOMS GO ON BEHALF OF THE
MAYOR OF SAN FRANCISCO ON BEHALF
OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF
SAN FRANCISCO WE OFFER OUR FULL
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
SIR. DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF SB FIVE
NINETY THREE HERE MOM TALK
HUNDRED. EIGHTY NINE WILL NOW
CONTINUE WITH LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION TO SB. FIVE NINETY
THREE HERE IN ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED DO WE HAVE ANY. C. LEVEL
. CONTINUE WITH ANY. WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION TO S. B. FIVE
TWENTY THREE HERE ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED. CNN WILL KNOCK
CONTINUE- MODERATOR. MR. SIX
WATERY IF YOU WOULD PLEASE QUEUE
UP ANY WITNESSES- WAITING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION TO SB FIVE NINETY
THREE AND WILL CONTINUE. IN THIS
IS A REMINDER- TO OUR WITNESSES
IN AB WAITING IN QUEUE PLEASE
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR POSITION IN
THE ORGANIZATION THAT YOU'RE
PRESENTING THANK YOU. IF YOU
WOULD LIKE TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
COMMENT IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
TO SB FIVE NINETY THREE PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
WE HAVE NO COMMENT. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MISTER MODERATOR- WILL
BRING IT BACK TO THE- DYESS. WE
HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR BOB
SENATOR CORTESE. THANK YOU
MANAGER I AM VERY SUPPORTIVE OF
THE BILL AND- EVEN MORE SO IF
YOU'RE IN THE TESTIMONY IF
THAT'S POSSIBLE THEY HAD A
CHANCE TO- HAVE A LITTLE
EXCHANGE WITH AUTHORED AGES. BUT
IT WAS A LITTLE CONCERNED
BECAUSE OF THE OBVIOUS. I
PERHAPS MAYBE IS AN OBVIOUS BUT
THE FOR THOSE OF US THAT WERE
AROUND LOCAL GOVERNMENT WITH THE
DISSOLUTION REDEVELOPMENT. THE
OBVIOUS CONCERN IN MY MIND THAT
- ANY GOVERNOR MY LOOK AT THIS
AS SORT OF AN END RUN AROUND THE
TO SOLUTION- YOU KNOW I WOULD
LIKE TO SEE THE BILL SUCCEED. IN
A WITHOUT PEOPLE HAVING TO HAVE
THOSE KIND OF CONCERNS THAT
THERE'S GONNA BE SOME- TO
SOMEHOW GOING TO OPEN UP THE
FLOODGATES TO- MAYBE- LESS
HONORABLE SITUATIONS WHERE
PEOPLE WOULD COME IN THEY JUST
TRY TO START READING
REDEVELOPMENT ALL OVER AGAIN
WITHOUT THE GUARD RAILS- IS
THERE ANY WAY TO. TO FASHION
SOMETHING IN THE BILL THAT IS
SUCH A STRONG STATEMENT OF
INTENT THAT. IT JUST REASSURES
EVERYBODY FROM HERE ON OUT THAT
THAT'S NOT A PROBLEM. THIS FIX
BIG PICTURE WE OPINIONS ABOUT
THAT THIS THE END OF READ READ.
I THINK IT WAS. PROBLEMATIC THAT
THE STATE IS THAT OF THE ABUSES
OF READ. INSTEAD OF FIXING IT-
ST CITED TO GET RID OF IT AND
THAT IS WHAT IS IT HAPPENED- I
WISH THERE'D BEEN MORE OF LITTLE
MORE OF A SURGICAL. BUT THAT'S
NOT WHAT HAPPENED. THIS IS. IF
YOU JUST LOOKING AT THE BILL AND
LOOK AT THE HISTORY IS FAIRLY
UNIQUE- A SEVERANCE IS CUT
SERVICES TO WAS NOT THE ONLY
CITY USE THE IN GATES AND
DEMOLITION- BUT SAN FRANCISCO IS
A PARTICULARLY EXTREME- EXAMPLE
IN TERMS OF WHAT IT DID- AND-
THE AND SAN FRANCISCO FOR
DECADES HAS HAD A LEGAL
RESPONSIBILITY TO REPLACE. THE
UNITS THAT WERE IN THE HOMES ARE
LOST FOR DECADES WE'VE BEEN
LEGALLY OBLIGATED WE AND WE WERE
ON WE HAD STARTED REPLACING THEM
WE'RE ON A PATH AND THEN RE AND
ROOM REDEVELOPMENT WAS.
ELIMINATED SO IT'S SORT OF SHUT
THE GATE AND SO WHAT THIS DOES
IS IT FOR THIS- YOU SITUATION
SAN FRANCISCO ALLOWS US. TO
COMPLY WITH OUR LONG STANDING
LEGAL OBLIGATION WE HAVE FIFTEEN
FIFTY FIFTY FIVE THOUSAND EIGHT
HUNDRED HOMES TO GO- AND- THIS
WILL YOU KNOW HELP US I GET THAT
DONE SO I THINK. IT'S FAIRLY
UNIQUE- KNOX SAID NO OTHER CITY
WHAT WHATEVER COMPORTMENT CITIES
ARE ENTITLED TO COME FORWARD AND
SAY WE HAVE. A SITUATION IN THE
LEGISLATURE CAN EVALUATE THAT.
BUT THIS ON ITS MERITS- I THINK
WARRANT SUPPORT. THANK YOU IT
FOR THE RECORD I DID MEAN THAT
I'M- A- I WOULD OBJECT TO YOU
TAX INCREMENT AGAIN HOUSING.
SPECIFICALLY FOR HOW BUT A-
EIGHT BUT I DO KNOW RACES SOME
EYEBROWS ARE CONCERTS EVERYONE
OF HIM TO POINT OUT HERE IS THIS
IS NOT WHAT ONE OF THE
COMPLEXITIES OF TRYING TO PUT
READ IT ALL BACK TOGETHER AGAIN
THIS ONE SO AND THAT THE TAX
INCREMENT ALL SPREAD OUT TO THE
COMMUNITY COLLEGES AND- SCHOOL
DISTRICTS AND SO IT'S VERY VERY
HARD TO. MASTER YEAH BECAUSE YOU
HAVE A LOT OF STAKEHOLDERS COULD
NOT BE HAPPY ABOUT THAT HERE
THIS IS REALLY ABOUT SAN
FRANCISCO'S. ALLOTMENT OF IT SO
IT'S MORE MUCH MORE FOCUSED ON
TRADITIONAL REDEVELOPMENT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH THANKS. THANK YOU
SENATOR CORTESE. I'M SORRY WE
HAVEN'T CENTER SKINNER. I JUST
TO THANK THE PRIMARY WHICH-
SINCE. THEY WERE YOU ARE VERY-
WITH BOTH THE JUST. IN THE CASE
. AND APPOINTED MY- TO YOU FOR
SUPPORTING THE SENATOR SKINNER
ANY OTHER CALL. FROM THE DYESS.
SET OF SENIOR SIX I WANNA THANK
YOU THE FOR THE BILL. I THINK
THE WITNESSES FOR COMING AND
TESTIFYING. VERY COMPELLING
STORIES. THAT YOU SHARE TODAY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR SHARING
WITH THE- WITH OUR COMMITTEE AS
WELL AS WITH THE AUDIENCE THAT'S
WATCHING- SENATOR WE WOULD LIKE
TO CLOSE. I APPRECIATE THE
CONVERSATION AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AND I WILL. HAVE A
MOTION BY SENATOR WAHHAB.
MEDITECH RETURN IF YOU WOULD
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS SB
FIVE NINETY THREE THE MOTIONS TO
PASS AND RE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
CENTER WIENER. WIENER I- CHAU
BOOK BY THE TROUBLED FIVE WEEKS
. CABALLERO FOR HE- CORTEZ THE A
CHOIR FOR THE I FOR THE PRICE
THEY ARE TO HIGH. THEY ARE TOO
HIGH. SKINNER FIVE ON BURKE WHAT
. WHAT HI THAT'S. ZERO THE
MEASURE IS AT THE ZERO IT OPEN.
OUR ABSENT THANK YOU MUCH.
OKAY SO- THANK YOUR OWN WE'RE
GOING TO- OPEN THE RULES FOR US
FOR OUR- RECENTLY RIGHT MEMBERS
WILL START AT THE TOP- ITEMS
NUMBER ONE SB TWENTY. PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. CENTER
BLIX PAYER CABALLERO. I MCGUIRE
. BURKE RIGHT NUMBER FIVE WILL
HELP BOB BY. THAT IS NOT ZERO
NINE IS PUT BACK ON CALL PLEASE
. PUT THE BUG IN CULVER CENTER
MCGUIRE MEXICAN SENATOR ITEMS SB
SIX AND FILE AS WE SOME SEVEN-
PLEASE CALL ABSENT CENTER BLIX
PAYER CABALLERO. AVEIRO I
MCGUIRE SKINNER FROM SORRY I'M
BURKE ALL RIGHT NUMBER BOB. BOB
. AND THAT IS ALSO OKAY TO SIGN
THIS YEAR OPEN UP ON BECAUSE-
AND FINE ITEM SB. FIVE HUNDRED.
UNDER BLISTER. FIVE CABALLERO
MCGUIRE NUMBER RIGHT NUMBER HI
IT IS ALSO COULD NOT ZERO PUT IT
BACK ON CALL ON SO I THINK
EVERYONE IS VOTE EXCEPT MCGUIRE
AND- FOR A SURPRISE.
OKAY WILL NOW OPEN FOR THE ROLE
SORRY THERE'S LIKE THREE FINAL.
MEASURES THE NEW ROLE- ITEM
NUMBER ONE SB TWO- CALL THE
AWESOME SENATOR BLIX PAYER
MCGUIRE ACQUIRE BY TEN TEN
NOTHING ABOUT THE OUT WHEN I GO
TO THE CONCERT AS A AND TO A
BEFORE AS AND FIVE US BEFORE
SEVENTY. PLEASE HOLD UP MEMBERS
CENTER BLIX PAYER REQUIRE
REQUIRE HI TENS VOTER TEND TO
NOTHING THE CONCERT IS AND ITEM
FOR SB FIVE NINETY THREE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS LAKE
SUPERIOR MCGUIRE RIGHT MCGUIRE
HI DENNIS OKAY THAT VOTERS TEND
NOTHING AND THE BILL IS SOUTH
STE- AND WITHOUT. WE'VE COME OUR
AGENDA THE SAN COMMITTEE ON IS A
JERK.