CALL TWO OR- THE SENATE
COMMITTEE ON HOUSING- AS YOU CAN
SEE WE ARE CURRENTLY DO NOT HAVE
OR CORN THANK YOU US AND ZERO
FOR BEING HERE REALLY APPRECIATE
YOUR PARTICIPATION- WE WILL
ESTABLISH QUORUM AS SOON AS A
FEW MORE MEMBERS ARE CALM BUT WE
WILL BEGIN AS A SUB COMMITTEE-
WHEN WE CONTINUE THE SENATE
CONTINUES TO WELCOME PUBLIC IN
PERSON AND TELECONFERENCE
PARTICIPATION FOR INDIVIDUALS
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
COMMENTS TODAY THE PARTICIPANT
NUMBER IS 877-226-8163 THE
ACCESS CODE IS SEVEN THREE SIX
TWO EIGHT THREE FOUR. WE'RE OF
COURSE HOLDING A COMMITTEE
HEARING HERE IN THE- STREET
BUILDINGS- I WILL- AN OUNCE TO
TV FOR ALL STAFF COULD YOU
FIGURE MEMBERS DOWN AT LEAST A
SELFISH QUORUM- THAT WOULD BE
FANTASTIC- OWNERSHIP
ANNOUNCEMENTS- FOR OF ALL SB
THREE FIVE TWO WHICH ITEM FOR BY
PRETTY. HAS BEEN PULLED AND WE
WILL BE HERE INTO NEXT COMMITTEE
HEARINGS. NEXT WEEK- SO WE HAVE
FIFTEEN BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA
WITH ONE ON CONSENT THE CONSENT
ITEMS THIS FIGHT FILE ITEM
TWELVE SB NINETY ONE BY CENTER-
BURKE. SENATE IT'S BEFORE FIFTH
BY- SOME ATKINS A PROTON WILL BE
PRESENTING THAT ON HER BEHALF
THAT IS FILE ITEM ONE. BEFORE
YOUR PRESENTATION AS YOU KNOW WE
CAMPUS WARM- SO WILL NOW.
PROCEED AS A SUB COMMITTEE AND
THE FIRST ITEM THAT WE ARE GOING
TO HEAR- IS ITEM NUMBER FOUR SB
FOUR SIXTY NINE- BY SENATOR ALAN
CENTER WALKING THE HOUSING
COMMITTEE. THE SOURCES. FROM
WITH HIS MICROPHONE TURNED ON
AND ON BUT I KNOW. RIGHT THANK
YOU SISTER SO- AS YOU KNOW WELL
I AM CHAIR ARTICLE FOUR. OF THE
CARD. IS THE ROLE OF THE PRE
RIGHTS ERA THOUGHT LIMIT. THE
DEVELOPMENT. OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING. HI AND SERVICE DAY FOR
TO. FOR AND THEY'LL TIMES
REDUCED ABOUT THIS- TWO OF THE
FROM NATURE OF THE INTENT DEMAND
ACTIONS OR EFFORTS THAT'S WHY
WE'RE DOING AS HE TO WHICH
COURSE IS BY. EFFORT TO REMOVE
ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR FROM THE
CONSTITUTION THAT ENJOYS
WIDESPREAD SUPPORT FOR AND OF
THE P. PUTTING IT ON THE IT'S ON
THE BALLOT NEXT YEAR. I'M ONE
UNINTENDED INTERPRETATION OF
ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR HAS PLACE
THE STATE IN A LEGAL GRAY AREA
CONTINUE SUPPORT. FOR BY HOUSING
GOALS AND I KNOW ON THIS
COMMITTEE. PLEASE ANSWER DEEPLY
CATHARTIC THIRTY FOUR REQUIRES
LOCAL VOTER APPROVAL CODE EIGHTY
LOW RENT HOUSING PROJECT THAT IS
CODE DEVELOPED CONSTRUCTED OR
ACQUIRED. IN ANY MANNER BY THE
STATE BODY. BY NOW. GO BACK
ARTICLE THE RIVER WAS INTENDED
TO COVER FOR HOUSING THERE STATE
FUNDING BUT IS TO. BY PRIVATE
SUCH AS NONPROFIT FOR BY HOUSING
DEVELOPERS- AND YEAH OUT OF AN
ABUNDANCE OF CAUTION I
UNDERSTAND HOW THIS THINGS WORK.
THE STATE HAS REQUIRED
APPLICANTS FOR SOME FUNDING
SOURCES TO DEMONSTRATE ARTICLE
FOR THIRTY FOUR COMPLAINTS
BEFORE DEVELOPMENTS MAY PROCEED
. THIS IS ADDED A WHOLE SET OF
UNNECESSARY COSTS DELAYS AND
UNCERTAINTY. TO THE HOUSING
PROJECTS THE CALIFORNIA
DESPERATELY NEEDS TO ADDRESS OUR
OUR OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
CHALLENGES. SO YOU KNOW ARTICLE
THE REPORT DID GRANT THE
LEGISLATURE THE POWER TO ENACT
LAWS TO IMPLEMENT IT INTO POWER
THE LEGISLATURE IS EXERCISE
NUMEROUS TIMES OVER THE DECADES
THAT FOLLOWED. IN RECENT YEARS
AS THE STATE'S INVESTED IN
PROGRAMS ADMINISTERED BY THE CT.
LATER IN USED IT TO THE FLOOR
UNDER ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR TO
MAKE CLEAR THAT AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPERS RECEIPT OF
FUNDS FROM SOME CRUCIAL PROGRAMS
LIKE THE HOME KEEP PROGRAM-
HOUSING EXHILARATED PROGRAM
PORTFOLIO RESTRUCTURING PROGRAM-
THERE IS HOUSING AND HOMELESS
EVICTION- SORRY. THE BETTER ITS
HOUSING AND HOMELESSNESS
PREVENTION PROGRAM. I DO NOT
TRIGGER A LOCAL ARTICLE THIRTY
FOUR COLLECTION FOR EXAMPLE. SO
THIS BILL AS BEFORE SIXTY NINE
UNDERSCORES LAST YEAR'S BITES
STRONG BIPARTISAN SUPPORT FOR A
C. TO. AN EXERCISE IS THE
STATE'S AUTHORITY TO BRING
CONSISTENCY DAHLE STATE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUNDING
PROGRAMS IT CLARIFIES THAT A
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT THAT
RECEIVES A LOAN. OR A GRANT FROM
A CD OR RESERVATION OF LOW
INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDITS FOR
THE STATE'S TAX CREDIT
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE IS NOT. A
LOW RENT HOUSING PROJECT
DEVELOPED CONSTRUCTED OR
ACQUIRED IN ANY MANNER BY ANY
STATE PUBLIC BODY. AS DEFINED BY
ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR. SO MUCH HAS
HAPPENED SINCE THE PASSAGE
VERTICALLY FOR IT IS YOU KNOW
SEE BACK IN THE FORTIES. AND
WALL- YOU KNOW NO ONE PERSON-
YOU KNOW IS TO IS TO BLAME FOR
ITS IMPACT WITH THE LEGISLATURE
HAVE THE DUTY AND RESPONSIBILITY
TRY TO FIND SOME SOLUTIONS TO
OUR CURRENT HOUSING CRISIS.
USING EVERY TOOL THAT WE HAVE IN
THE BOX. IN THIS BILL- DOES JUST
THAT BY SAYING YOU KNOW- I
APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDER PERCENT
THE GOOD WORK OF THE COMMITTEE
AND ANALYZE. THE BILL AND TO ME
TO ONCE A THERE MIGHT STIVERS
FOR THE CALIFORNIA PARTNERS ALSO
PER ACOSTA. FROM THE GOVERNOR
LEGAL ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION.
SERVICE IN THE PURSUIT THANK YOU
GOOD MORNING GOOD AT CHAIRMAN
TRYING TO CAST A- ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION. ON BEHALF
OF OUR LOW INCOME CLIENTS THAT
LIVE IN RURAL AREAS. WE ARE
PLEASED TO SPONSOR THIS BILL.
YOU KNOW THE COST AND
UNCERTAINTY OF A ARTICLE THIRTY
FOUR ELECTION WHICH IS ONE
SOLUTION TO THE BARRIERS THAT
ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR PERCENT. IS
BUT AS A BARRIER IN RURAL AREAS
BECAUSE THE COST IN THE-
UNCERTAINTY OF THAT AND SO. FOR
DEVELOPMENT IN ROLLERS RAFI
NAVIGATING AROUND. THOSE
RESTRICTIONS THAT MAKE IT MORE
COMPLEX AND COSTLY TO PRODUCE.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THAT SERVES
OUR CLIENTS THIS COMMONSENSE
APPROACH. BECAUSE CONSISTENT
WITH WHAT THE LEGISLATURE IS
DONE OVER SEVERAL YEARS NOW TO
REMOVE THOSE BARRIERS. AND SO
WHILE WE WORK- AS THE AUTHOR AND
CHAIR HAVE BEEN DOING TO.
PERMANENTLY REPEAL ARTICLE
THIRTY FOUR THIS BILL WILL HELP
REMOVE THOSE BARRIERS IN THE
SHORT TERM AND FOR THOSE REASONS
WE URGENT ABOUT. MISTER SADDAM.
MARCH OF THE CALIFORNIA PARTNERS
AND- MY COLLEAGUES WORK ON THE
FINANCING ABOUT TWO HUNDRED
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS
PER YEAR WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH
THE RAMIFICATIONS OF TRYING TO
COMPLY WITH ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR
IN ALL THESE SITUATIONS WHEN
EVEN WHEN STATE FUNDING IS A
IMPROVED. I'VE BEEN IN THE
POSITION OF ADMINISTERING STATE
PROGRAMS AND I'VE ALSO SEEN THE
MENTAL GYMNASTICS THAT WE GO
THROUGH IN THE ADDED TIME IN
LAWYER COSTS THAT IS INVOLVED IN
TERMS OF. TRYING TO MAKE SURE
DEVELOPMENTS ARE COMPLYING WITH
ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR WE HAVE USED
THIS MEASURE OF EXEMPTING OUT
PROGRAMS THAT ARE JUST PROVIDING
FINANCING ON A COUPLE OCCASIONS
AS A SENATOR MENTIONED. AND IF
THEY'VE WORKED AND HAS NOT BEEN
CHALLENGED AND WE THINK THAT
THIS IS A WAY TO GO SO THANK YOU
VERY MUCH FOR SUPPORTER PARTICLE
SPONSORED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
IT SENATORS SUPPORT IN THE
HEARING ROOM. BRING A WHITE WITH
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
CONSORTIUM IN SUPPORT. BUT THE
VEGGIE WITH INNER CITY LAW
CENTER IN SUPPORT. ANYONE ELSE
PRESENT HERE. OKAY THAT IS THERE
ANY OPPOSITION- TO SB FOUR SIXTY
NINE. SENATE HEARING ROOM. SAY
NO MORE GO TO THE PHONE LINES-
WITH THE MODERATOR PLEASE QUEUE
UP ANY SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. ON
THE PHONE LINES. OF COURSE PLAYS
SEVEN IF YOU WISH TO MAKE A
COMMENT IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE. ZERO TO HEAR
TONY CAME TO GIVE BACK TO THE
QUEUE HE WILL BE GIVING YOUR
LIFE THEM. BUT WE SHOULD MAKE A
COMMON SUPPORT OR- PLEASE PRESS
ONE. ZERO WE'LL GO TO LINE
SEVENTY TWO. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
GOOD AFTERNOON- THIS IS ROB WITH
ALL OF THE OLD BOWLING IN STRONG
SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF THE N. B.
ATKINS AND ARE. OF THE NUMBER SO
CHAPTER IS AN PARTNERS AND CAL
THANK YOU. EXCELLENT ONLINE
SEVENTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES
THIS IS MICHAEL FULL OP CALLING
IN ON BEHALF SANTA MONICA
DEMOCRATIC CLUB AND SORT STRONG
WORD OF THE MEASURE. THERE'S
CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN THE
QUEUE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF AN
IMPACT TO THE MIDEAST TO THE
COMMITTEE- CENTER SERGEANTS
INVOICE FOR ANY COMMON QUESTIONS
CENTER BOOKS. A STRONGLY SUPPORT
THE SENATOR AND I'M GRATEFUL
THAT YOU BROUGHT FORWARD THANK
YOU- I JUST ALSO AS WE CENTER
OUR UNITED PARTNERS ON THIS EVER
FOR FEW YEARS NOW AND I'M- IT
WAS REALLY. EXCITING TO BE AT
THE VERY LAST NIGHT OF SESSION
LAST YEAR TO PLACE ARTICLE
THIRTY THIRTY FOUR REPEAL ON THE
BALLOT- ARTICLE THIRTY FOUR IS
AN ABSOLUTE SCAR. ON THE
CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION IT IS IT
IS HARMFUL AND HUMILIATING DIE
IN TWENTY TWENTY THREE WE HAVE
THIS PROVISION IN OUR
CONSTITUTION THAT WAS DESIGNED.
TO KEEP OUR COMMUNITIES A
SEGREGATED- AND IT'S A LONG LONG
PASSED TO STRIP IT OUT AND I
THINK IT'S FANTASTIC THAT WE
HAVE A BROAD COALITION RANGING
FROM UP. YOU KNOW THE ADVOCATE
FOR TENANTS IN AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND- THE TO THE REALTORS
AND WE OUGHT OVERWHELMING ALMOST
UNANIMOUS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
LAST YEAR OF ITS PLANES FIRING
AND I LOOK FORWARD TO GETTING IT
OUT OF THE CONSTITUTION- BUT
THIS. IS A GREAT COMPLIMENTS- TO
THAT AND- AND I REALLY
APPRECIATE YOU- I BRING THIS UP
FOR AND I'M PROUD TO BE A JOINT
AUTHOR- WE WILL OF COURSE TAKE A
MOTION ONCE WE HAVE A QUORUM
AND- YOU MAY CLOSE. BY PROCEDURE
COMMENTS A GREAT DEAL I YOU KNOW
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT. STEP BY
AND HELPING TO. DRESS THIS THIS
REALLY ADEQUACY THE BECOME SO
CLEAR UNDER THE- THE STATE'S.
CARPOOL WITH THE REST OF
INTERPRETER IS THE TO TAKING A
CAUTIOUS OF WE'RE GONNA GET AN
ADDRESS WITH THIS. BILL AND I
THINK I JUST. THAT AND I VOTE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- AND THE
ROLE OF THE MOTION WE HAVE A CO
THEY YOU. WE HAVE ANOTHER AUTHOR
MISTER- ITEM NUMBER. TWO THREE
FIFTY SIX. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. THANK YOU SO
VERY MUCH. TODAY WOULD LIKE TO.
FIRST OFF BY POINT THAT I HAVE
WILL IT. THE AMENDMENT. AND- TO
DAMPER SENATE BILL THREE FIVE
SIX TO RESTORE FUNDING. TO
MODERNIZE THE CODE ENFORCEMENT
GRANT AND INCENTIVE PROGRAM AND
THE COMMUNITY AND CODE
ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM.
TO SUPPORT HEALTHY AND SAFE
HOUSING. OVER TWENTY YEARS AGO
THE STATE IMPLEMENTED THESE TWO
PROGRAMS TO SUPPORT LOCAL
EFFORTS TO IDENTIFY AND FIX
EXISTING HOUSING BEFORE PROBLEMS
GET SO SEVERE THEY ARE LOST TO
THE MARKET. FUNDING FOR THESE
PROGRAMS WAS A VICTIM OF BUDGET
CUTS DURING THE GREAT RECESSION
. SENATE BILL THREE FIVE SIX
WOULD INCREASE THE MAXIMUM GRANT
TO A SINGLE MUNICIPALITY UNDER
THE CODE ENFORCEMENT GRANT
INCENTIVE PROGRAM FROM ONE
MILLION TO TWO MILLION. AND
REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT TO ADJUST
THAT AMOUNT FOR INFLATION AT
LEAST ONCE EVERY FIVE YEARS. THE
BILL WOULD CHANGE THE LOCAL
MATCH REQUIREMENT UNDER THIS
PROGRAM TO REQUIRE A RECIPIENT
CITY OR MUNICIPALITY. TO MATCH
35% OF THE FUNDS AWARDED OVER
THREE YEARS THIS WILL ALLOW
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO BETTER
BUDGET FOR THE GRANT YEAH UNDER
CURRENT LAW THE LOCAL MATCH GOES
FROM 25% UP TO SEVENTY FIVE
PERCENT. IN THE FINAL YEAR. THE
BILL WOULD ALSO INCREASE THE
MAXIMUM GRANT UNDER THE
COMMUNITY CODE INCENTIVE PROGRAM
WHICH IS A SECOND PROGRAM FROM
400-500-0022 MILLION AND ADJUST
FOR INFLATION. WITH THESE GRANTS
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WILL BE ABLE
TO CREATIVELY AND EFFECTIVELY
ADDRESS CODE ENFORCEMENT ISSUES
IN THEIR COMMUNITIES
CALIFORNIA'S INVESTING HUNDREDS
OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO
SUPPORT THE CONSTRUCTION OF NEW
HOUSING UNITS. TO HELP ALLEVIATE
THE HOUSING CRISIS THIS BILL
SHOULD GO HAND IN HAND HOWEVER
VERY LITTLE IS INVESTED IN
HOUSING CODE ENFORCEMENT TO
ENSURE THE STATE'S EXISTING
HOUSING STOCK IS NOT LOST DUE TO
NEGLECT AND DISREPAIR. THE LOSS
OF EXISTING HOUSING UNDERMINES
THE GAINS OF OUR MASSIVE
INVESTMENTS IN NEW CONSTRUCTION.
THIS BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION AND
IS SUPPORTED BY A BROAD
COALITION OF GROUPS WHO SUPPORT
HEALTHY AND SAFE HOUSING. AND
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY PROVIDE
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE OUR BRAND
DIDN'T GET A WAGGA IN ON BEHALF
OF REGIONAL AS MUCH AND
PREVENTION. AS WELL AS LARRY
BROOKS BEHALF FOR THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS AND I RESPECTFULLY
AFTER I VOTE AND I THINK YOU.
YOU MAY PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON-
CHAIR AND MEMBERS- MY NAME IS
BRANDON COULD I GOT ONE WITH
REGIONAL MANAGEMENT AND
PREVENTION WERE PART OF THE
PUBLIC HEALTH INSTITUTE. OUR
MISSION IS TO REDUCE THE BURDEN
OF HOUSE NOT PARTICULARLY IN
COMMUNITIES MOST IMPACTED BY THE
DISEASE. OUR WORK TO REDUCE
EXPOSURE TO ENVIRONMENTAL ASTHMA
TRIGGERS HAS LED US TO PARTNER
WITH TENANTS RIGHTS
ORGANIZATIONS- PUBLIC HEALTH
AGENCIES AND LOCAL CODE
ENFORCEMENT TO ADDRESS-
UNHEALTHY SUBSTANDARD CONDITIONS
OF SUCH AS- PEST INFESTATIONS
AND MOLD. WHICH CAN EXACERBATE
AND SOMETIMES BECAUSE ASTHMA AS
WELL AS OTHER HEALTH CONDITIONS
. UNHEALTHY HOUSING IS NOT
UNCOMMON UNFORTUNATELY IN THE
STATE ACCORDING TO TWENTY TWENTY
ONE DATA FROM THE AMERICAN
HOUSING SURVEY. OVER ONE MILLION
HOMES IN CALIFORNIA HAVE SIGNS
OF MICE. OVER ONE POINT FOUR
MILLION REPORT HAVING
COCKROACHES. ONE POINT FIVE
MILLION HAVE IDENTIFIED PLUMBING
OR OTHER WATER LEAKS WHICH
CONTRIBUTE TO OVER THREE HUNDRED
FIFTY THOUSAND HOUSEHOLDS HAVING
MOLD- THE COURT IN THE SAME DAY
OUT OF THESE CONDITIONS ARE
SUBSTANTIALLY MORE COMMON IN
RENTAL HOUSING. WITH RENTERS TWO
AND A HALF MORE TIMES LIKELY TO
HAVE COCKROACHES IN OUR HOMES OR
LIVE WITH MOLD. THESE
DISPARITIES ARE PARTICULARLY
CONCERNING GIVEN THAT THERE AND
GIVEN THEIR IMPACTS ON
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. WE'RE
SIGNIFICANT MAJORITY OF
HOUSEHOLDS ARE RENTERS. EXISTING
STATE AND LOCAL LAW REQUIRES
LANDLORDS TO ADEQUATELY MAINTAIN
THE RENTAL HOUSING WHAT DOESN'T
EIGHTEEN LOCAL CODE ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES RESPONSIBLE FOR
ENFORCING THESE HEALTH AND
SAFETY STANDARDS. IN OUR WORK
WITH CODE ENFORCEMENT WE OFTEN
SHARE MODEL POLICIES WE SEE
ACROSS THE STATE- BUT OFTEN HERE
AGENCIES SAY THAT THEY CAN'T TO
TRY THESE NEW THINGS BECAUSE
THEY DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES TO
DO IT. WE WILL LEARNED ABOUT
THESE GRANT PROGRAMS. WITHOUT IS
A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO UPDATE
THEM AND RESTORE FUNDING SO THAT
THEY CAN PROVIDE THE SEED MONEY
TO HELP JURISDICTIONS- BETTER
IMPROVE A BETTER ADDRESS THEIR
THEIR HOUSING STOCKS WE-
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR TYPE
OF. GOOD AFTERNOON HONORABLE
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME'S
LARRY BROOKS BOARD MEMBER OF
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF CODE
ENFORCEMENT. DIRECTOR OF ALAMEDA
COUNTY HEALTHY HOMES DEPARTMENT
AND PREVIOUSLY THAT THE DEPUTY
CHIEF OF CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
SACRAMENTO COUNTY AND PREVIOUS
MANAGER CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE
CITY OF WEST SACRAMENTO. I
CONTINUE TO URGE YOUR SUPPORT
FOR SENATE BILL THREE FIVE SIX
OFTEN REFERRED TO AS THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE GRANT AND
COMMUNITY CALLED FORCING PILOT
PROGRAM GRANTS. EVERY RECEIVED
ONE OF THESE GRANTS WERE WORKING
FOR SACRAMENTO COUNTY I CAN
ATTEST TO HOW EFFECTIVE THESE
GRANTS CAN BE IN HELPING CODE
ENFORCEMENT PROGRAMS. SUCCEED IN
PRESERVING SAFE AND HEALTHY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
UNFORTUNATELY IN THE TWENTY PLUS
YEARS SINCE THE LAST ROUND OF
THESE GRANTS EXISTED. DEMANDS ON
CODE ENFORCEMENT PROGRAMS ABOUT
PEACE THE RESOURCES THAT MANY
JURISDICTIONS CAN PROVIDE THEM.
WITH SOME CITIES AND COUNTIES TO
PET TO CREATE OR EXPAND
REGULATORY ACTIVITIES SUCH AS
CANNABIS MASSAGE PARLORS.
HOMELESS CAMPS DOWNTOWN
NIGHTLIFE ENTERTAINMENT VENUES
ON TOP OF THEIR TRADITIONAL CODE
ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITIES LIKE LAND
USE ILLEGAL DUMPING ANIMAL AND
VEHICLE CONTROL. MANY COLD
FORSMAN OFFICERS ARE LEFT
STRAPPED TO ADDRESS HOUSING
PRESERVATION ISSUES. THROUGH
TRAINING MODERNIZATION AND
INNOVATION JUST AS THE ORIGINAL
GRANTS BROUGHT MANY OF US FROM
USING CLIPBOARDS TO LAPTOP
COMPUTERS POLAROIDS TO
SMARTPHONES WITH DIGITAL
CAMERAS. THESE GRANTS COULD HELP
FROM CODE ENFORCEMENT PROGRAMS
LEAP FORWARD IN ADDRESSING MANY
HEALTHY HOUSING HIT ISSUES THE
STORE CLEAN OVERLOOKED BY MANY
BUILDING CODE REGULATORS SUCH AS
MOLD. AS BEST AS AN LEAD PAINT
HAZARDS THEREFORE FOR THESE AND
MANY OTHER REASONS THAT TIME
DOES NOT ALLOW ME TO EXPLAIN TO
YOU I URGE YOU TO VOTE. ON
SENATE BILL THREE FIVE SIX.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SIR ANY OF
THIS SO IN HERE ROOM PLEASE COME
FOR. GOOD AFTERNOON TURN MEMBERS
PRETTY GOOD ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS IN
TRUMP'S SUPPORTER THIS BILL
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON CINDY
GUSTY ON BEHALF OF WESTERN
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY IN
SUPPORT. SORRY OPPOSITION IN THE
HEARING ROOM. THIRTY OPPOSITION
. SEEING NONE WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES MISTER MODERATOR WE
PLEASE QUEUE UP- ANY- TELEPHONIC
TESTIMONY. OF COURSE PLEASE
NEVER ONCE AGAIN ISSUE IF YOU
WISH TO BE CAN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS. ONE
ZERO. YEAH. EIGHT THERE IS
CURRENTLY NO ONE QUEUING UP.
OKAY OVER IN FIVE THE COMMITTEE
COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
. ON A SPEECH FIFTIES. OKAY
SEEING NONE- MISTER SODIUM CLOSE
I URGE YOU- I THANK YOU FOR AND
I'VE- THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK
YOU THANK YOU ONE THREE OIL
CORPS- WILL TAKE THE MOST AND
BOTH TO THANK YOU. OKAY I SEE
MISTER PER. HERE FOR ITEM NUMBER
A B. EIGHT THREE FOUR. WHAT.
THANK YOU CHAIR AND- MEMBERS- SB
EIGHT THREE FOUR PROPOSES TO
PLACE A TWENTY FIVE BILLION
DOLLAR VOTER APPROVED GENERAL
OBLIGATION BOND ON THE NEXT
STATEWIDE GENERAL ELECTION
BALLOT TO FINANCE HOMEOWNERSHIP
OPPORTUNITIES TO PROMOTE NEW
HOME CONSTRUCTION. SENATORS
HOMEOWNERSHIP BENEFITS ARE
INDISPUTABLE AND LEAD TO
MEASURABLE IMPROVEMENTS IN
HEALTH EDUCATION AND SECURITY.
OBVIOUSLY ESCALATING HOME PRICES
SEVERE PRODUCTION SHORTAGE IN
GENERATIONAL BARRIERS CAUSED BY
SYSTEMIC ISSUES AND INEQUALITIES
ARE SQUEEZING MANY ASPIRING
HOMEOWNERS OUT OF THE MARKET
RENTERS OF ALL INCOME LEVELS BUT
ESPECIALLY THOSE OF LOW AND
MODERATE INCOME YOU
HOMEOWNERSHIP FRANKLY SOME OF
THEM VIEWED AS AN UNATTAINABLE
GOAL. WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY
TO CREATE MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
FIRST TIME AND OFTEN LEFT BEHIND
HOME BUYERS TO PURCHASE A HOME.
THRIVE IN THE MIDDLE CLASS AND
BUILD GENERATIONAL WEALTH- THIS
CANNOT BE ACCOMPLISHED WITHOUT
ADDRESSING THE SEVERE LACK OF
HOUSING PRODUCTION THAT IS
FUELING MUCH OF OUR CRISIS SB
EIGHT THIRTY FOUR WILL ADDRESS
HOUSING PRODUCTION BY INCREASED
HOME OWNERSHIP OF THE BILL USES
BOND PROCEEDS TO GENERATE BY.
GENERATED BY THE MEASURE TO
CREATE TWO UNIQUE FINANCING
PROGRAMS ONE TO PROVIDE DOWN
PAYMENT ASSISTANCE. TO HOME
BUYERS AND ANOTHER TO PROVIDE
INFRASTRUCTURE STONE LOANS FOR
UP FRONT CONSTRUCTION COSTS IN
THE SENATE AGAIN WE WILL BE
BUILDING MORE AND THEN HELPING
PEOPLE AFFORD THOSE NEW HOMES.
IMPORTANTLY S. B- THIS BILL-
CLOSES USED INVESTOR MONEY TO
BUILD NEW HOUSING NOT TAXPAYER
MONEY. AND USE THE BOND FUNDS IN
SHORT BY THE PROGRAM IS BACKED
BY THE FULL FAITH AND CREDIT OF
THE STATE- IT'LL BE. SO WE'RE
GOING TO CREATE THIS PROGRAM
WE'RE GONNA USE OUR OWN PROCEEDS
THERE'S NOTHING IN THE LAW THAT
SAYS WE HAVE TO MAKE A PROFIT SO
WE CAN USE THIS TO HELP. BUILD
MORE AND HELP MORE PEOPLE BY
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE- AND WE HAVE A
REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE STATE
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
COUNCIL THING YOU'RE GOING TO DO
WITH ME TOO. AND SO WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN I BUT WHEN
. YOU HAVE A CORPSMAN WHEN
YOU'RE READY TO DO THAT. THANK
VERY MUCH. THIRTY SUPPORT THIS
MONEY. SO IF YOU WANT TO HAVE A
STABLE CONSTRUCTION TRADE
COUNCIL APPRECIATE THE HEARING
TODAY WELL LIKE THANK THE OFF
FOR BRING BILL FOR. THIS BILL
PROVIDE MORTGAGES. YOU BECAUSE
PRE TO. WORK IN MIDDLE CLASS
WAGES AND BENEFITS SO THAT
WORKERS BILLION YOU HOUSING CAN
AFFORD TO BUY ONE. THIS BILL
WILL ALSO MAKE THE DREAM OF
OWNING A HOME MORE ATTAINABLE
FOR PEOPLE AT NO COST TO THE
STATE WILL OTHERWISE BE TRAPPED
IN A VICIOUS CYCLE OF RENTING.
FOR THESE REASONS WE ASK FOR
YOUR IPHONE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU VERY MUCH DIGITAL
SUPPORT. JENNIFER SPOKE ABOUT
THE CALIFORNIA. OF REALTORS
WE'RE HEARING ON THEM IN SUPPORT
POSITION CURRENTLY BUT WE ARE
WORKING COLLECTIVELY WITH THE
AUTHOR. AND HIS STAFF TO.
FACILITATE TECHNICAL
IMPROVEMENTS IN THE BILL TO
ENSURE THAT IT OPERATES IN THE
WAY THAT IS- BEST AVAILABLE FOR
USE WITHIN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WE LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUING OUR EFFORTS FOR THE
AUTHOR. THANK YOU. GERMANY
MEMBER SCOTT WHICH ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION
OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS A
CALIFORNIA STATE PATRONS COUNCIL
IN THE WESTERN STATES COUNCIL.
OF SHEET METAL WORKERS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. FOR YOUR ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE
HEARING ROOM. SAY NOT ANY
OPPOSITION IN THE HEARING ROOM.
OKAY- WILL NOW FOCUS. YES PLEASE
COME FORWARD IF YOU'RE- OPPOSED
. TO PLEASE TURN THE MICROPHONE
ON THANK YOU MARK STATUS OF THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
AND WE ARE POSING LESS AMENDED
TO ONE PARTICULAR PROVISION OF
THE BILL- THERE'S A COUPLE
PLACES WHERE. IT SETS A LOWER
AFFORDABILITY THRESHOLD THAN IS
CURRENTLY EXISTS IN SB THIRTY
FIVE WARREN LOCAL INCLUSIONARY
ORDINANCES. TO WOULD LIKE TO
WORK WITH THE AUTHOR ON THAT.
AND THEN JUST MORE BROADLY WE
JUST WE DO HAVE SOME CONCERNS
ABOUT DOING A TWENTY FIVE
BILLION DOLLAR HOUSING BOND THAT
IS SOLELY FOCUSED ON
HOMEOWNERSHIP WE SUPPORT
HOMEOWNERSHIP WE'D LIKE TO SEE
UPON THIS MORE BROADLY BASED. ON
HOMEOWNERSHIP AND RENTAL AS WE
HAVE DONE IN THE PAST. BECAUSE
THE ON BEHALF OF WESTERN CENTER
ALONG POVERTY RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. RIGHT
AWAY WITH THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
CONSORTIUM RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED FOR THE REASONS
STATED. THERE IS A STRONG
POSITION. SEEN ON WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES- PLEASE QUEUE UP
BOTH SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION
TELEPHONICALLY. THE FIRST ONE
WHICH TO QUEUE UP TO MAKE
SOMETHING WORK FOR OPPOSITION
THE- ONE. ZERO ONE HAS TO UP ON
THE WEATHER THE LINE.
WILL BE GOING LINE EIGHTY THE
BILL AT. POLICE ARE HERE BECAUSE
CAL FACT THE- AND SUPPORT YOU.
IT CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN THE
- OKAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH WILL
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS CENTER CABALLERO. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR-
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR PROPOSING
THIS BILL- THERE'S NO QUESTION
THAT WE NEED TO USE BOND FUNDS
IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO DO
CONSTRUCTION SEMI LET ME GIVE
YOU MY CONCERN SOMEONE TO
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY BUT I DO
HAVE SOME CONCERNS- THE- THEY'VE
BEEN MENTIONED BY SOME OF THE
OPPOSITION ONE IS THE AFFORDABLE
AFFORDABILITY PROVISIONS IN SB
THIRTY FIVE. AS WELL AS LOCAL
INCLUSIONARY ORDINANCES BUT THE
OTHER THING ABOUT IT IS THAT THE
CONCERNS ME IS THAT- WE PUT OUT.
FIVE HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS
THIS PAST YEAR IN THE BUDGET FOR
A FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS PROGRAM
THROUGH KELLY CAFE AND THEY
RELEASED THREE HUNDRED MILLION
OF IT- CLOSE TO I THINK IT'S TWO
HUNDRED EIGHTY EIGHT MILLION
AND- CHANGE AND- IT WENT WITHIN
ELEVEN DAYS AND I'VE BEEN ASKING
FOR INFORMATION AS TO WHAT
CITIES ARE WHAT REGION'S
BENEFITTED. BECAUSE WHEN WE PUT
IT IN THE BUDGET I ASKED IF CAL
HFA WOULD DO SOME- WORKSHOPS IN
MY COMMUNITIES TO ADVISE PEOPLE
HOW TO ACCESS THE MONEY. AND HOW
THEY SHOULD PREPARE THEMSELVES
TO BE ABLE TO ACCESS RESOURCES
AND- THE COMMUNITIES ARE- HAVE A
HI. A SECOND LANGUAGE RATE IN
OTHER WORDS IF ENGLISH IS NOT
THEIR FIRST LANGUAGE- THERE
MEYKHANA MEANS ARE USUALLY CASH
ECONOMIES NOT BUILT ON CREDIT
AND- MAINTAINING GOOD CREDIT.
AND AND THEY'RE THEY'RE THEY'RE
LOW AND LOW INCOME- HOUSING
STOCK IS MUCH MORE AFFORDABLE
THAN IN SOME OF THEM. URBANIZED
REGIONS AND YET THE MONEY'S GONE
POOF IT'S GONE- MY VISION IS
THAT NONE OF THE FIRST TIME HOME
BUYERS MONEY WILL EVER GET OUT
IF IT'S FIRST TIME. FIRST COME
FIRST SERVE BASIS BECAUSE
SOPHISTICATED EDUCATED
COMMUNITIES TEND TO GET IN LINE
MUCH FASTER AND TO UTILIZE THAT
SO HAVING SAID THAT I'D LIKE
THERE. TO BE A- CAR ABOUT A- IS
SET ASIDE OR SO MARKET. THAT
DISADVANTAGED HAVE A HARD TIME
ACCESSING SOME OF THIS THESE
RESOURCES NUMBER ONE AND NUMBER
TWO IS IF YOU DO IT TO A HUNDRED
AND 80% OF THEM MEDIAN INCOME.
SLAPSHOT OF MY REGION IT'S
PROBABLY BEEN FIFTEEN YEARS AGO
NOW BUT OUR MEDIAN INCOME USED
TO BE ABOUT FORTY EIGHT MINUTES
FORTY THOUSAND FIFTY THOUSAND-
AND WE WERE ALWAYS TRYING TO GET
AFFORDABILITY TO FORTY. 4260% OF
THE MEDIAN INCOME. SAN JOSE
WHICH IS ONE HOUR AWAY FROM
THAT- THIS SALINAS VALLEY- HAS
HAD A MEDIAN INCOME OF A HUNDRED
AND HAD ABOUT A HUNDRED AND TEN
THOUSAND DOLLARS SO THEY WERE
TRYING TO REACH A TWO HUNDRED
AND 20% OF THE MEDIAN INCOME AND
WOULD SUBSIDIZE UP TO A HUNDRED
AND TWENTY INCOME OF A HUNDRED
AND TWENTY. HUNDRED THIRTY
THOUSAND MY POINT ABOUT THAT IS
THAT IF YOU WERE TO IF YOU WERE
SUBSIDIZING IN MY COMMUNITY
YOU'D BE SUBSIDIZED. ONLY UP TO
ABOUT THIRTY SIX THOUSAND
DOLLARS IF YOU WERE EARNING
THIRTY SIX THOUSAND DOLLARS OR
LESS AS OPPOSED TO- INDIVIDUALS
SO YOU DON'T GET MUCH VALUE FOR
YOUR MONEY IF YOU HAVE TO
SUBSIDIZE- HOME THE COST
MULTIPLE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS I'M
NOT SAYING WE DON'T DO IT BUT I
JUST THINK THAT. THAT'S TO BE
SOME EQUITY AND I'M REALLY
CONCERNED SO MANY SUPPORT YOUR
BILL TODAY BUT I DO WANT TO
RAISE THOSE ISSUES AND- IT
WINNER WHEN IT COMES TO THE
FLOOR IF IT LOOKS EXACTLY THE
SAME I MAY NOT. SO TWO THINGS
WERE WE HAVE THE BENEFIT OF THAT
FIVE HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR
INVESTMENT TO SEE WHAT WORKED
AND WHAT DIDN'T WORK AND HOW IT
WAS IMPLEMENTED SO I THINK. THE
LESSONS THAT YOU'RE OUTLINING. I
WANT TO I WANT TO TRY TO
INCORPORATE HOW TO MAKE THIS.
BETTER THAT'S ONE SO WE HAVE WE
HAVE A BLUEPRINT OF WHAT WHAT
WORKS AND WHAT DOESN'T WORK AND
TOO OBVIOUSLY TWENTY FIVE
BILLION DOLLARS IS A LOT BIGGER
THAN. FIVE HUNDRED MILLION AND
SO WE HAVE. THE NASCENT A BIGGER
POT. TO WHERE WE CAN TRY TO
ACCOMMODATE THE DIFFERENT
REGIONS OF THE STATE- MORE
EQUITABLY SO. COMPLETELY TOTALLY
OPEN TO WORKING WITH YOU I'M
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO. TO
APPLY IT. IN A BETTER IN A
BETTER WAY BECAUSE YOU'RE RIGHT
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT FOR
HELPING. ALL OF CALIFORNIA NOT
JUST ONE PARTICULAR PART OF
CALIFORNIAN DOING IT FAIRLY.
THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THAT
ABSOLUTELY. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS SENATOR PLACE HERE.
THANK YOU. FROM I'LL BE
SUPPORTING THIS BILL TODAY AS
WELL BUT I JUST WANTED TO ASK
YOU- TWO QUESTIONS SO THE FIRST
IS THAT THIS BILL IS IDENTICAL
TO. SB FOURTEEN FIFTY SEVEN- AND
I JUST WANT FROM LAST YEAR SO I
WANTED TO HEAR WHAT YOU THINK IT
MIGHT. NEED A DIFFERENT FATE.
FOR THE RISK OF INSULTING MISTER
HERTZBERG BETTER AUTHOR. OKAY
THAT'S BUT THAT'S IT'S NOT THE
ANSWER THEN I ACCEPT THAT ANSWER
OKAY. ANY OTHER SUBSTANCES. OKAY
I'M ALSO I KNEW THAT WOULD GO
OVER WELL- I'M ALSO CONCERNED
ABOUT THE LACK OF RENTAL HOUSING
AND THE REALITY THAT SUCH A
LARGE BOND WOULD CROWD OUT OTHER
TYPES OF BONDS FOR RENTAL
HOUSING- AND- I JUST WANTED TO
HEAR ANY RESPONSE TO THE- THAT'S
A PHILOSOPHICAL QUESTION WHICH
OBVIOUSLY. YOU KNOW. TAKING THE
INPUT OF THE COMMITTEE AND OTHER
SERIOUSLY I MEAN WE'VE DONE SO
MUCH OVER THE PAST DECADE ON.
RENTAL HOUSING BUT NOT A LOT ON
FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS AND I
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT THE
SOCIOLOGY OF CALIFORNIA. I MEAN
WHEN I TALK TO YOUNG- FAMILIES
FIRST GENERATION CALIFORNIANS.
YOU KNOW THEY HAVE THIS DREAM OF
HOMEOWNERSHIP AND I WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT WE HAVE POLICIES IN
PLACE THAT HELP US MEET THAT
DREAM AND SO- I HEAR THAT
CRITICISM AND OBVIOUSLY I KNOW
THE CHAIR. HAS WORKED
SIGNIFICANTLY ON ON NUMEROUS
BILLS. TO CREATE MORE HOUSING
STOCK OF ALL TYPES- BUT I JUST
WANTED TO REALLY EMPHASIZE THE
IMPORTANCE OF THIS. HOME
OWNERSHIP PEACE AND MAKE SURE
THAT IN THE SOCIOLOGY OF HOUSING
WE GIVE IT. AS MUCH FOCUS AS
POSSIBLE. OKAY THANK YOU AND
THEN JUST MY LAST POINT IS ON I
AM SUPPORTIVE OF. THE VARIETY OF
INCLUSIONARY ORDINANCE
PERCENTAGES THAT LEAD TO MORE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND I THINK
CITIES THERE ARE SOME CITIES HE
MIGHT TRY TO SET THEM TOO HIGH
TO PREVENT ANY TYPE OF HOUSING
TO BE BUILT. BUT IN REALITY THAT
IS CHALLENGED AT THE AT THE H.
C. D. LEVEL- AND ALSO
POTENTIALLY IN COURT AND SO
HIGHER INCLUSION PERCENTAGES DO
RESULT IN MORE DETAIL STRICT
AFFORDABLE UNITS WHICH I THINK
IS A GOOD THING. SO JUST THE
FACT THAT YOUR BILL WOULD
OVERRIDE LOCAL ORDINANCES THAT
ARE THAT ARE. THAT HIGHER
INCLUSION OR PERCENTAGES THAT
WAS A BIT OF A CONCERN TO ME AS
WELL JUST WANT TO FIND OUT AND
WE WILL CERTAINLY BE BEAT THAT'S
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WILL BE
DISCUSSING AS THE BILL MOVES
FORWARD. OKAY THANK YOU. HAS THE
BETTER OFF THE- ANY OTHER. OR
COME. OKAY SO IT'S ONLY A FEW
COMMONSENSE. THE TODAY WITH WITH
SOME RESERVATIONS- IN THE STILL
OF COURSE WAS OPPOSED BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG. LAST YEAR THE YEAR
BEFORE WHATEVER WAS EIGHTY TWO
YEARS AGO I THINK IT WAS TWO
YEARS I THINK IT WAS A TWO YEAH-
AND- FIFTY I'D BY DOING SOME
CONCERNS ABOUT- ABOUT- USING
BOND MONEY AND I AM. FOR
HOMEOWNERSHIP- NOT OBVIOUS I'M
NOT. CATEGORY POST WHAT I WANTED
BE SUPPORTING BILL IF I WERE BUT
IT DOES RAISE. QUESTIONS FOR ME
AND I THINK THAT'S THIS MOVES
FORWARD WITH SOMETHING TO BE
CONSIDERED- WE TYPICALLY ARE
HOUSING SUBSIDIES HAVE- REALLY
FOCUSED MORE ON RENTAL AND ON
FOLKS WHO. MAY NOT BE IN A
POSITION TO BE IN A
HOMEOWNERSHIP SITUATION BUT NEW
HOUSING- ALSO IT WHILE I WANNA
THANK YOU FOR KEEPING ALL OF THE
WE WORKED WITH CENTER HERTZBERG
ON TO MAKE A NUMBER OF
AMENDMENTS TO THE BILL TO MAKE
IT. MORE CONSISTENT CALIFORNIA
HOUSING POLICY- TO PUT STRONG
ANTI SPRAWL LIMITATIONS AND THE
BILL- TO MAKE SURE THAT IT-
INCLUDE SUCH AS SINGLE FAMILY
HOMES BUT TOWN HOMES. AND CONDOS
BECAUSE THERE A LOT OF DIFFERENT
FORMS OF HOME OWNERSHIP- AND
ALSO- AND THIS IS NOT MY MOMENT
CENTER HERTZBERG ON ITS OWN AND
YOU KEPT THIS. INCLUDES SB
THIRTY FIVE STREAMLINING- IN.
THE BILL I WANT TO- THANK YOU
FOR EMBRACING- SB THIRTY- WHICH-
I THINK- MAKE BOND IF IT IS THE-
MUCH MORE SIX BY. READY WANT
THIS- HOUSE TO BE BUILT QUICKLY
AS WHY THIS PASS- AND WILL HELP
. AS IN THE EMAIL- YOU I DO HAVE
A CONCERN- THAT I THINK- OTHER
SHARE ABOUT- I'M FOR THE FIRST
TIME EVER AS FAR AS I'M AWARE
THIS WOULD- TOUCH SKILLED WORK
FORCE. TO PUBLIC HOUSING MONEY
THAT'S TO MY KNOWLEDGE NOT BEEN
DONE BEFORE PREVAILING WAGE HAS
LONG BEEN ATTACHED TO CERTAIN
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUNDING
STREAMS BUT NEVER SKILLED
WORKFORCE- FORCES THE BROADER
CONVERSATION WE'RE HAVING IN THE
CAPITAL BECAUSE- UNFORTUNATELY I
WOULD LOVE FOR THE ENTIRE
RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION WORK
FORCE TO BE UNIONIZED. IT'S NOT-
NOT EVEN 10% IS LESS THAN 10%
THE VAST MAJORITY OF RESIDENTIAL
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS ARE NOT IN
UNIONS I WANT THAT TO CHANGE
SOMEONE BUT NOT THAT 9% TO
BECOME. IF NOT A 100% AND THEN
CLOSE TO IT BUT WE'RE NOT THERE-
AND SO. I DO HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
THIS PROVISION- REVOKE EXPLAINED
IN THE ANALYSIS WHY AND WHAT WE
RECOMMEND HOWEVER I TYPICALLY IN
THIS COMMITTEE TO NOT. TRY TO
DICTATE TO AUTHORS WHAT LABOR
PROTECTIONS PUT IN THEIR
LEGISLATION SO I DEFER TO YOU IN
MAKING THAT CHOICE- WALTERS
EXPRESSING THAT. POINT SO
WITHOUT I'LL BE VOTING FOR THIS
TODAY WE DO NOT YET HAVE. A
QUORUM- AND WHEN WE DO WE WILL
ENTERTAIN A MOTION TO TAKE A
VOTE. THANK. YOU AND YOU MAY
CLOSE A FEW. WHEN APPROPRIATE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR THE THANK
YOU MUCH SIR PORTANTINO.
HOPELESS YES- CENTER BUT FOR
WOULD YOU LIKE TO. WE WILL CALL
ITEM NUMBER. YOU CERTAINLY HAS A
TO- ITEM EIGHT SB SO WHILST WITH
. AND THEN FROM THERE GO TO ITEM
NOT AS HE. TWO THANK YOU. CHAIR
AND CO. AND THE CAN FOR THEIR
WORK ON THE- AND A MAY
SUGGESTIONS- I JUST WANNA- SAY
THAT I'M HAPPY TO BE HERE AT MY
FIRST COMMITTEE ON SB SEVEN THE
HOUSING COMMITTEE- AND THIS BILL
IS. WAS ON THE GENESIS OF IT WAS
MY EXPERIENCE AND LOCAL
GOVERNMENT AS THE MAYOR OF THE
CITY AND ALSO RUNNING. ON THE
SUBCOMMITTEE FOR THE COG THAT
DISTRIBUTED THE RENOWNED
ALLOCATIONS TO CITIES AND
WATCHING THAT PROCESS OVER
MULTIPLE YEARS. SO I WILL START
BY SAYING I HAVE ACCEPTED THE
AMENDMENTS THAT ARE PROPOSED AS
DESCRIBED ON PAGE NINE COMMENT
TEN OF THE ANALYSIS. AND MY
STAFF AND I ARE CONTINUING TO
EXPLORE THE IMPLICATIONS OF THE
REMAINING PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
WITH OUR SPONSORS. SO SB SEVEN
ESSENTIALLY SEEKS TO MANDATE THE
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS MEET THE
HOUSING NEEDS OF THEIR HOMELESS
POPULATIONS. THIS BILL ADDS THE
CATEGORY OF HOMELESSNESS TO
RENO. THE PREMISE OF RINA IS
THAT EVERY CITY AND COUNTY IS
OBLIGATED TO PLAN FOR HOUSING AT
ALL INCOME LEVELS. ARE CURRENTLY
FIVE INCOME CATEGORIES WHICH
START AT ABOVE MODERATE INCOME
AND GO TO EXTREMELY LOW INCOME
BUT CRITICALLY THERE IS NO
REQUIREMENT FOR CITIES AND
COUNTIES TO PLAN FOR THE HOUSING
OF THE HOMELESS POPULATION
SPECIFICALLY. WELL WE HAVE MANY
MANY FEDERAL STATE AND
PHILANTHROPIC PHILANTHROPIC LEE
FUNDED PROGRAMS THAT HELP OUR
UNSHELTERED NEIGHBORS WE ALSO
HAVE THE COLD HARD FACTS THAT
HOMELESSNESS CONTINUES TO GET
WORSE IN THE STATE. EVERY MONTH
INCLUDING WITHIN THE SHADOW OF
THE CAPITOL OF THE FOURTH
LARGEST ECONOMY IN THE WORLD
RIGHT HERE IN SACRAMENTO. SO WE
ARE SIMPLY STATED NOT KEEPING UP
WITH THE NEED AND WE ARE NOT
WORKING SYSTEMICALLY TOWARD
GETTING PEOPLE OUT OF
ENCAMPMENTS AND INTO HOMES. AND
THE STATE HAS NOT PROVIDED AN
OBLIGATION FOR CITIES AND
COUNTIES TO DO THIS. SO IT IS
CURRENTLY DISCRETIONARY AND JUST
AS AN EXAMPLE IN THE SAN DIEGO
UNION TRIBUNE NEWSPAPER TODAY AN
ARTICLE ABOVE THE FOLD ON THE
FIRST PAGE. STATES THAT IN NORTH
SAN DIEGO COUNTY WHICH IS THE
AREA THAT I REPRESENT. THE POINT
IN TIME COUNT- INDICATED THAT
AND THEN POINT TIME COUNT IS A
WELL. UNDER OF HOMELESSNESS- BUT
INDICATED THAT THERE ARE TWO
THOUSAND UNSHELTERED PEOPLE IN
NORTH SAN DIEGO COUNTY. AND
THERE ARE A TOTAL OF ONE HUNDRED
AND FIFTY SHELTER BEDS. NO THIS
IS NOT A STATISTIC THAT'S
CHANGING TWO THOUSAND HOMELESS
PEOPLE A HUNDRED AND FIFTY
SHELTER BEDS. SO CANDIDLY EVERY
CITY WANTS ANOTHER CITY OR
BETTER YET THE COUNTY TO MANAGE
THE HOMELESSNESS PROBLEM. A
CITY'S DECISION TO BUILD A
SHELTER OR TO FIND A LOCATION
FOR A SAFE PARKING OR SAFE
CAMPING PROGRAM OR TO PROVIDE
RAPID RE HOUSING OR TO PERMIT A
SINGLE ROOM OCCUPANCY HOTEL. IS
1100% DISCRETIONARY. THIS BILL
WOULD ADD HOMELESS HOUSING
PLANNING TO THE RENEWAL PROCESS.
SO THAT PROVIDING FOR HOMELESS
RESIDENTS IS NOT DISCRETIONARY.
THE BILL WOULD ALSO ESTABLISH
THE HOMELESS HOUSING OBLIGATION
FUND WHICH MAY BE RENAMED. AND
MAY ALSO BE SUBSUMED UNDER A
DIFFERENT FUND. THAT WOULD
ENABLE LOCAL PUBLIC AGENCIES AND
NONPROFITS TO ACCESS THE FUNDING
TO MEET THEIR OBLIGATIONS. TO
ROCK WIDE RANGE OF ACTIVITIES
INCLUDING A MOTEL AND HOTEL
CONVERSIONS AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PRESERVATION PERMANENT HOUSING
CONSTRUCTION RENTAL ASSISTANCE
AND RAPID RE HOUSING AMONG
OTHERS. THIS BILL IS STILL A
WORK IN PROGRESS AS MY STAFF
SPONSORS AND I CONTINUE TO REACH
RESEARCH AND REFINE THIS BILL TO
ACHIEVE THE GOALS. AND I WOULD
LIKE TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
AGAIN FOR THE RESEARCH
ASSISTANTS AND ANALYSIS THAT HAS
BEEN PROVIDED TO HELP US
STRENGTHEN THIS LEGISLATION. I
HOPE THIS BILL PROCEEDS TODAY
AND SHOULD IT I WILL CONTINUE TO
WORK WITH THE COMMITTEE AND ALL
OF YOU INDIVIDUALLY TO AMENDED
INTO ITS BEST POSSIBLE FORM. SO
WITH ME IN SUPPORT R. MADHI MON
G. AND D. ON TURNER FROM THE
INNER CITY LAWCENTER. WELCOME IF
. GOOD AFTERNOON SURE MEMBERS MY
NAME IS DIONNE TURNER WITH
INDUSTRY LAWCENTER WE'RE PROUD
TO SPONSOR SENATE BILL SEVEN.
ENERGY LAWCENTER SKID ROW'S PRO
BONO LEGAL SERVICES PROVIDER
EVERY DAY WE HELP PEOPLE WHO ARE
HOMELESS OR AT THE PRECIPICE OF
BECOMING HOMELESS. FINDING
SECURE HOUSING TO LEAF THROUGH
FREE LEGAL SERVICES. SB SEVEN
WILL ENSURE THAT EVERY LOCALITY
IS REQUIRED TO BUILD HOUSING FOR
RESIDENTS EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS WITHIN THEIR TRYST
WITH INTEREST. THEIR
JURISDICTIONS. OKAY INCOME. IS A
HOME OR A PLACE OF WORK FOR LOW
INCOME CALIFORNIANS. OF ENDEMIC
HAS SHOWN US THAT OUR ESSENTIAL
WORKERS ARE THE HEART OF
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY. NEVER THE
LESS LOW INCOME CALIFORNIANS ARE
THE MOST LIKELY TO BE RENT
BURDEN AND FALL TO THE
HOMELESSNESS CRACKS. TWENTY
TWENTY TWO REPORT FROM THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOUND
THAT WE NEED TO BUILD A ONE
POINT TWO MILLION AFFORDABLE
HOMES OVER THE NEXT DECADE. TO
MEET OUR HOUSING GOALS. L. A.
COUNTY ALONE IS SHORT OVER FIVE
HUNDRED THOUSAND HOMES THAT ARE
AFFORDABLE TO LOWER INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS. AND ECONOMIC
ROUNDTABLE STUDY TWENTY EIGHTEEN
FATHER ALMOST SIX HUNDRED
THOUSAND L. A. COUNTY RESIDENTS
ARE POVERTY AND SPEND 90% OR
MORE OF THEIR INCOME ON HOUSING.
WHEN FOLKS ARE SPENDING DRASTIC
AMOUNT OF INCOME ON HOUSING
THERE ARE ONE PARKING TICKET
AWAY ONE MEDICAL BILLER MISHAP
FROM FALLING INTO THE SPIRAL OF
HOMELESSNESS. BUT TWENTY TWENTY
USC STUDY FOUND THAT THREE
FOURTHS OF ELLIE HOUSEHOLDS ARE
RENT BURDENED SPENDING OVER
FIFTY SPENDING OVER 30% OF
HOUSEHOLD INCOME. ON RENT AND
UTILITIES AND A HALF BEING
SEVERELY BURDENED. SPENDING OVER
50% OF THEIR INCOME ON RENT
UTILITIES ALMOST. ALMOST HALF
DELAYED OR BILL PAYMENTS OR TAKE
ON ADDITIONAL DEBT JUST TO MAKE
RENT. ANY HOLES WILL REQUIRE
CALIFORNIA TO SIGNIFICANTLY
SCALE THE PRODUCTION. AND
FUNDING FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
WE MUST MOVE RAPIDLY TO PROVIDE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO OUR OWN
HOUSE NEIGHBORS LIVING ON THE
STREET AND STRUGGLING FAMILIES
ALIKE. SB SEVEN REQUIRES
LOCALITIES TO PROVIDE SUFFICIENT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO MEET THE
NEEDS OF ALL THEIR OWN HOUSE
RESIDENTS. SB SEVEN INTRODUCES A
VARIETY OF MEANS TO ACCOMPLISH
AFFORDABLE HOUSING GOALS
INCLUDING MASTER LEASING. THE
PROVISION OF RENTAL SUBSIDIES
HOTEL AND MOTEL CONVERSIONS AND
BUILDING NEW AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
IN ADDITION SB SEVEN CREE SELF
FUNDED TO SUPPORT CITIES AND
MEETING THE NEEDS OF THEIR OWN
HOUSE RESIDENTS. TO LOCALITY
FAILED TO MEET THE PUBLIC
SCHOOLS SB SEVEN ALLOWS A
DIVERSE RANGE OF HOUSING
MODALITIES TO BE DEVELOPED A
STREAMLINED PROCESS. FOR THESE
REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY URGE AN
AYE VOTE ON SB SEVEN THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- IS THERE ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PUBLIC
COMMENT IN THE ROOM HERE. PLEASE
COME FORWARD. EDITAS IN WITH
THAT COMPANY HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
IN SUPPORT. WELCOME BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE. I'M AMBERLEY LESLIE
WITH HOUSING CALIFORNIA AND ALSO
ON BEHALF OF C. S. H. WE SUPPORT
CONCEPT AND REALLY APPRECIATE
THE AUTHOR AND STUFF- FOR
WORKING THROUGH SOME ADDITIONAL
MOMENTS THINKING. ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENTS. MAY BE
NO SO- OKAY- ANY OPPOSITION IN
THE HEARING ROOM. PLEASE COME
FORWARD. ELIZABETH ELLIOTT
NORTHERN CIRCLE INDIAN HOUSING
AUTHORITY. AND WE STAND IN
OPPOSITION. IN LIFE THERE IS AN
AMENDMENT TO INCLUDE TRIBAL
NATIONS AND SPELL. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
SILVIO FOR ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
AND PAULA JEEZ WE ARE LATE
OPPOSITION AS EARLY AS YESTERDAY
AND WE COMMUNICATE THAT WITH THE
AUTHOR- WE DO HAVE A MEETING
COMING UP SO WE'RE LOOKING
FORWARD TO THAT I THINK OUR VIEW
RIGHT NOW IS THAT THERE ARE
AMPLE OPPORTUNITIES IN EXISTING
LAW TO DO THE ANALYSIS AND
BETTER PLAN SO. WE'RE THAT'S
DEFICIENT WE'RE LOOKING FORWARD
TO HAVING THAT CONVERSATION
THANK YOU. THANKS FOR YOUR-
VENTURE FOTOLIA CALIFORNIA
CITIES WE HAVE SOME CONCERNS
WITH THE MOST RECENT AMENDMENTS
TO SP SEVEN HOWEVER WE
APPRECIATE THE RECOGNITION FOR
THE NEED FOR ONGOING FUNDING TO
ADDRESS HOUSING HOMELESSNESS
CRISIS WHAT WORKING AT THEIR
OFFICE THANK YOU. THANK YOU ANY
OF THIS OPPOSITION IN A ROOM
SIGNAL TO THE PHONE LINES OF THE
MODERATOR PLEASE CLOSE AND
OPPOSITION. OF COURSE IN LATE IN
A MINUTE ACCURACY WHAT ARE
OPPOSITION THE ONE. GOING TO
SEVEN FEW BUT. SEVENTY TWO YOUR
LINE IS OPEN. BOB THIS IS WHAT
THE BOTTOM FELL TO CALLING ON
BEHALF OF THE LAW AND THE ACTION
IN SUPPORT OF. IT. CURRENTLY NO
ONE ELSE IN THE GIVES. OKAY WILL
BRING ABOUT THE COMMITTEE-
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FOR CENTER BOOKS YES
CENTERS THEY ARE NO. THANK YOU.
I- I'M KIND OF CURIOUS ABOUT A
YEAR THE CITY'S V. REPRESENTED I
REPRESENT. ALL OF US HAVE THE
CITY'S. EIGHT I KEEP READING NO
REGISTERED OPPOSITION. BUT ALL I
HEAR FROM THE CITIES IS THAT
THEY OPPOSE THIS HAVE YOU HAD
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
COMMUNITIES THAT YOU REPRESENT
REGARDING THIS BILL AND WHERE
THEY STAND ON IT. BECAUSE I KNOW
THEY ALL HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
LOCAL CONTROL- I KNOW THERE'S
ISSUES ABOUT THE POINT TIME
COUNTS- IF WE DO A PREVIOUSLY
THE POINT TIME COUNTS WERE WERE
MEANT AS A TOOL FOR CITIES TO
DEVELOP- OKAY TO KIND OF KNOW
WHERE THEY'RE AT. AS FAR AS THAT
IS THE HOMELESS POPULATIONS
THEY'RE IN THEIR COMMUNITIES IF
WE TURN IT INTO. SOMETHING THAT
REQUIRES THEM. TO DO UNFUNDED
MANDATES TO. EIGHT THEN IT TURNS
INTO SOMETHING THAT NEEDS TO BE
YOU KNOW IS RIGHT FOR
MANIPULATION- EITHER BY PHYSICAL
MANIPULATION NOT HAVING ANYBODY
WHEN YOU'RE DOING YOUR TOWN
POINT IN TIME COUNT- YOU KNOW
ALL THE SENATE MASS MIGRATION
FROM ONE CITY TO ANOTHER WITH
HOMELESS PEOPLE. AND AND SO ONE
CITY WINDS UP WITH NONE AND THE
OTHER CITY WINDS UP WITH TOO
MANY. SO I'M I'M KIND OF CURIOUS
HOW THIS BILL. PROPOSES TO
CONTROL THAT- AND I THINK THAT'S
A LOT THERE'S A LOT OF CITIES
THAT HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT THIS AS
SOME OF THEM ARE PROBABLY MORE
ABLE TO- ARE MORE SUSCEPTIBLE
SHOULD I SAY TO THAT KIND OF.
MOVEMENT OF POPULATIONS THAN
OTHERS ARE. YES WELL THANK YOU
FOR THE QUESTIONS SO THE POINT
IN TIME COUNT NUMBERS ARE AN
OBJECTIVE WAY OF ACTUALLY
LOOKING AT THE HOMELESS COUNT IN
OUR STATE AND SO IF YOU ARE
THINKING ABOUT TRYING TO FIGURE
OUT HOW TO. DISTRIBUTE SOLVING
THE HOMELESS PROBLEM IN A WAY
THAT'S BASED UPON SOMETHING THAT
IS. DONE AT A STATEWIDE LEVEL
AND ISN'T JUST SELF REPORTED BY
A CITY I THINK THE POINT IN TIME
COUNT NUMBER IS THE NUMBER
THAT'S THE CLEAREST IT'S
DEFINITELY AN UNDERCOUNT
ACCORDING TO NEARLY EVERY
SOURCE. BUT IF THERE'S A
JURISDICTION THAT REPORTS THAT
THEY HAVE TWENTY HOMELESS PEOPLE
AND THEN THEY HAVE AN OBLIGATION
TO FIND HOUSING FOR TWENTY
PEOPLE THAT'S ACTUALLY MORE THAN
THEY'RE CURRENTLY DOING. SO I
SEE THAT AS A START AND MAYBE
THE POINT IN TIME COUNT. PROCESS
WILL CHANGE OVER TIME OR THERE
WILL BE ADDITIONAL- AMENDMENTS
AROUND POINT TIME COUNT NUMBERS.
BUT I THINK THAT IT'S PREMATURE
REALLY TO BE TO BE TRYING TO
WORK IN THAT AREA. SO AND THEN
TO YOUR FIRST POINT WHICH WAS
ABOUT CITIES YOU KNOW YOU YOU
HEARD LEAGUE OF CITIES AND- THE
OPPOSITION IT WAS HERE TODAY TO
SPEAK MEAN THIS IS THE FIRST
COMMITTEE HEARING. SO IT WAS
INTRODUCED AND IT'S GOING TO
COME IN FIVE AFTER THIS SO I
EXPECT THAT THERE WILL BE QUITE
A BIT OF ENGAGEMENT ON THIS. I
JUST WANT TO SAY THAT DESPITE
THE FACT THAT. THERE IS A
WIDESPREAD BELIEF THAT. THAT THE
RENEWAL PROCESS IS FORCING
CITIES TO DO THINGS A SENSUALLY
THE RENO PROCESS IS ROOTED IN
LOCAL CONTROL BECAUSE THERE'S A
NUMBER THAT'S GIVEN TO THE CITY.
BUT THE CITY FIGURES OUT HOW TO
MEET AND A CITY COULD CHOOSE TO
BUILD A 100% AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROJECT THAT WOULD IMMEDIATELY
MEET ALL OF THE NEEDS OF THE
LOWER INCOME CATEGORIES OR IT
COULD CHOOSE TO UPS OWN.
PROPERTIES THAT HAVE A 10%
INCLUSIONARY ORDINANCE AND THEN
THEY WOULD HAVE A LOT OF MARKET
RATE HOUSING AND 10%
INCLUSIONARY. AND SO AND THERE'S
A NO NET LOSS PROCESS THAT
RESULTS IN CITIES HAVING TO WORK
TOWARD THAT GOAL. SO TO ME THE
REALITY IS THAT IF WE'RE GOING
TO WORK WITH OUR CURRENT SYSTEM
WHICH IS THAT CITIES AND
COUNTIES. CONCEPTUALLY ARE
FORCED TO BECAUSE OF STATE LAWS
ARE FOR WE THINK OF HOUSING IS
BEING THE OBLIGATION OF EVERY
CITY AND COUNTY TO DO THEIR
PART. FOR LOW INCOME RESIDENTS
THESE AREN'T ALLOWED TO OPT OUT
OF THAT. THAT WE SHOULD HAVE THE
SAME CONCEPT FOR HOMELESSNESS
WHICH IS CITIES AND COUNTIES
SHOULD NOT BE ABLE TO OPT OUT OF
PROVIDING FOR HOMELESS
RESIDENTS. RIGHT NOW ALL DAY
ESSENTIALLY ARE AND SO WE HAVE
HOW FUNDING IN LARGE CITIES OR
ACCESSING FUNDING SOURCES TO DO
THINGS THERE ARE THINGS
HAPPENING. BUT WE'RE ACTUALLY
NOT REDUCING HOMELESS NUMBERS IN
THE STATE AND IF WE WANT TO IF
WE SEE THAT AS A GOAL AND WE
DON'T WANT TO HAVE ENCAMPMENTS
IN PUBLIC SPACES. WHICH I DON'T
WANT I DON'T THINK. ANY
RESIDENTS WANT- THEN WE HAVE TO
SAY HOW ARE WE GETTING THERE.
AND SO DISTRIBUTING THE
OBLIGATION AMONG THE FIVE
HUNDRED AND A LITTLE BIT LESS
THAN THAT. CITIES AND COUNTIES
IN THIS STATE SEEMS. TO BE A
REASONABLE WAY TO GO ABOUT THAT.
OKAY THANK YOU FOR THE ACTUAL. I
OF JUST A WITH YOU BIT ON RAIN
AND- IT SAID TO THE- TEN TO TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY RENOWNED ARENA
NUMBERS. A LOT OF CITIES DID NOT
MAKE THEIR NUMBER. AND THE
BIGGEST REASON FOR THAT IS
BECAUSE WE HAD A RECESSION IN
THE FRONT HALF OF THAT WHEN
NOBODY WAS BUILDING. AND THEN
THE SECOND HALF OF IT. PEOPLE
THAT WERE BRAVE ENOUGH TO START
BUILDING- CAME FORWARD- STARTED
THEIR PROCESS THAT THEY HAVE TO
GO THROUGH WITH THAT PROCESS
BEFORE THEY CAN GET BUILDING
PERMITS TAKES ABOUT. FIVE TO SIX
OR SEVEN YEARS AS A PUSHED HIM
INTO THE TWO THOUSAND. TWENTY TO
TWO THOUSAND THIRTY RANGE. AND
BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T MAKE THEIR
NUMBERS PREVIOUSLY THE THAT. A
BUNCH OF THEIR LOCAL CONTROL WAS
TAKEN AWAY. VIA ALL THIS. OUT OF
MANY OF OUR BILLS. THAT ACTUALLY
WE HAVEN'T EVEN ALLOWED TO COME
TO SEE HOW THEY'RE WORKING WE
SPENT TWENTY TWO BILLION
DOLLARS. FOR HOMELESS- ISSUES IN
IN HOUSING. AND YET. WE'RE GOING
BACKWARDS STILL. AND WE'VE WE'VE
INTRODUCED AND ENACTED A LOT OF
BILLS IN THE LAST TWO YEARS- AND
THREE YEARS AND WE JUST SEEM TO
BE PILING MORE. BILLS ON THAT
ACTUALLY STRIP LOCAL CONTROL
AWAY AND FORCE MANDATES THAT
COST MONEY ON TO LOCAL AGENCIES.
AND THEN EVERYONE OF THESE BILLS
HAS IN. THE AFTER PASSING A
LITTLE BIT VOTERS PASSED THING
IS THAT WHEN WE DO ENFORCE
MANDATES. THE STATE NEEDS TO
REIMBURSE CITIES WELL ALL OF
THESE NOW HAVE A CLOSET SAYS
THIS IS NOT REIMBURSABLE BY THE
STATE. SO THAT'S HOW THEY GET
AROUND THAT- SO THE CITIES ARE
REALLY FRUSTRATED WITH THIS
ISSUE. OF BEING TOLD YOU'RE
GOING TO HAVE TO DO THIS YOU
HAVE TO DO THAT OTHERWISE. WE'RE
GONNA TAKE AWAY EVEN MORE
CONTROL. WHEN THEY HAVEN'T EVEN
ALLOW THIS THE- THE MEASURES
THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO TAKE
ALREADY THAT HAVE BEEN PASSED
INTO LAW. TO BE ABLE TO BE
STUDIED TO SEE. IF THEY'RE
EFFECTIVE IF THEY'RE EVEN NEEDED
TO BE IN LINE ANYMORE OR
ANYTHING SO. SO THAT'S MY
CONCERN. IS WE SEEM TO BE PILING
ON A LOT. AND I WOULD LIKE IT
FUND ON A LOT OF BILLS. JUST
TAKE THE COMMENTS I JUST SAID
AND APPLY THEM TO ALL OF THOSE
OTHER BILLS SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO
HEAR ME AGAIN OVER AND OVER- SO
ANYWAY APPRECIATE IT AND
APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS. TO TRY
TO WORK IN THIS I JUST I JUST
WISH WE WOULD LET SOME OF OUR
BILLS- YOU WORK A LITTLE BIT
BEFORE WE ADD ON TO OTHER ONES
THANK YOU. AND JUSTICE BRIEFLY
TO RESPOND TO SOME OF THE THINGS
YOU JUST SAID. SO THIS IS NOT AN
UNFUNDED MANDATE BECAUSE IT IT
HAS THIS HOMELESS HOUSING
OBLIGATION FUND ATTACHED TO IT
WHICH WOULD ALLOW. CITIES TO
ACCESS FUNDS FOR THESE PROJECTS-
AND ALSO DESPITE THE FACT THAT
RENO MAY HAVE PROBLEMS. IT
ACTUALLY HAS RESULTED IN.
HOUSING THAT WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN
BILLED OTHERWISE AND THAT'S
BECAUSE OF RESTRICTIVE ZONING
THAT PROHIBITED HIGHER DENSITY
HOUSING THAT IS. NATURALLY MORE
AFFORDABLE WHEN THOSE TYPES OF
PROJECTS CAN'T BE DEVELOPED.
THEN IT'S ESSENTIALLY A STAGNANT
HOUSING MARKET WHICH HAS CREATED
THE SYSTEMIC PROBLEMS OVER
MULTIPLE DECADES THAT WE HAVE IN
CALIFORNIA. SO I KNOW THAT RINA
GETS A REALLY BAD RAP AND SODAS
EIGHT CD AND I WAS ON THE OTHER
SIDE AS A MAYOR WHO IS IN
LITIGATION WITH EACH CD AND
REALLY. EXPERIENCES FIRST HAND
BUT WHEN YOU RISE UP A LITTLE
BIT AND LOOKED DOWN AT IT YOU
REALIZE THAT. THERE IS HOUSING
BEING BUILT BECAUSE OF THIS IT
IS AN EFFECTIVE PROCESS IT IS
THE PROCESS WE HAVE AND I'M NOT
TRYING TO CREATE. A WHOLE NOTHER
AGENCY OR OVERSIGHT- MECHANISM
HERE IT'S LEANING INTO THE ACT
AND RENO PROCESS WE HAVE TO TRY
TO. CREATE THE OPPORTUNITIES FOR
OUR OWN HOUSE NEIGHBORS TO BE
HOUSED AND TO HAVE THAT BE AN
OBLIGATION THAT SITS AT SOME
LEVEL OF GOVERNMENT AND
CURRENTLY IT DOESN'T ACTUALLY
SIT. ANYWHERE SO THIS. THIS
MOVES THAT FORWARD. ANY
ADDITIONAL THIS. CENTER FOR
THOSE IF. THANK YOU MISTER
SHEARER- I I'M SUPPORTIVE OF THE
BILL AND- THE NO NEED FOR THE
AUTHOR TO RESPOND UNLESS YOU
WANT TO. CLOSE WITH IT UNLESS
YOU'RE WATCHING TOO. AS WELL IN
A TRAINED. TEACHER HERE BUT I
JUST WANTED TO SAY INDICATE WHY
I'M SUPPORTIVE- HAVING PRESIDED
OVER. THE RENEWAL PROCESS- ONCE
AND PARTICIPATED IN IT AT THE
REGIONAL LEVEL A NUMBER OF
TIMES- AS- WELL AS- AS DID
ARCHER- THE ONE TIME- IN THE BAY
AREA. A VERSION OF THE PROCESS.
I THINK OF THE FOUR THINGS THAT
OR- SERVE HIGHLIGHTED IN IN IN
THE DIGEST- PARAGRAPH ABOUT THE
BILL OR DISK- ALL OF THEM. YOU
KNOW TO ME ARE REALLY KIND OF NO
BRAINER THINGS- I DO THINK
THOUGH THAT. THE BILL- ADDS-
SOMETHING THAT'S THAT'S SORT OF
MISSING- I THINK THE MODELING
TRADITIONALLY HAS BEEN DONE
BASED ON WHAT THE CITIES AND
COUNTIES. PUSH UP TO THE REGION
IN TERMS OF WHAT THEY INDICATE
IS THE CULPABLE IN THEIR GENERAL
PLANS SO THEIR THEIR NUMBERS
BASICALLY THIS IS A LIST OF ALL
POSSIBLE. THE REGION TAKES- IT
DOES MODELING TO SEE HOW THAT'S
GOING TO MATCH UP WITH JOB
GROWTH. BASICALLY AND THEN MOVES
IT I'M OVER SIMPLIFYING A LITTLE
BIT AND THEN MOVES AROUND EIGHT
C. D. BUT- THE FACT MATTER IS.
NOT SEEN IN THE MODELING IN OUR
REGION- HOMELESS OR UNDER HOUSED
POPULATION CALLED OUT IN WE KNOW
FROM POINT TIME CENSUS SAID AT
LEAST IN OUR AREA NINETY SEVEN
PERCENT. OF THE FOLKS ACCOUNT I
SELF IDENTIFY WITH THAT SAME
COUNTY- OFTEN TIMES WITH THE
SAME CITY WHERE THEY'RE LOCATED
SO WHY WOULDN'T WE BE INCLUDING
IN OUR NEEDS ANALYSIS THE
HOUSING FOR THEM AS WELL.
BECAUSE THEY'RE ON HOW THE
APPOINTMENTS ALMOST
COUNTERINTUITIVE TO EXCLUDE
THEM- I DON'T KNOW. ON THE PIECE
OF IT THAT CALLS FOR THE
HOMELESS HOUSING OBLIGATION ACT
REQUIREMENTS- YOU KNOW WHETHER
THAT'S GOING TO BE- TO BE TO
BURN FOR ALL GOVERNMENT AS THE
BILL. MOVES ALONG- BUT FOR MY
AND- I THINK IT'S A FASCINATING
CONVERSATION AND ANYTHING THAT-
TRIES TO- BETTER THIS RENEWAL
PROCESS- WITH FUNDAMENTALS LIKE
THIS I THINK IS A GOOD THING SO
I I'M SUPPORTIVE. THANK YOU
MISTER. CAN I JUST BRIEFLY
RESPOND TO WHAT HE SAID THERE.
WILL BE QUICK OKAY SO- THE
RENEWAL PROCESS USED TO INVOLVE
THE LOCALS PUSHING UP WHAT IS IT
THEIR GENERAL PLANS REFLECT BUT
H. CD IS BECOME MUCH MORE
PRESCRIPTIVE. AND NOW FOR
EXAMPLE WHEN WE JUST WENT
THROUGH IT TWO YEARS AGO IN SAN
DIEGO COUNTY WE HAD A JOBS AND
TRANSIT ANALYSIS THAT LED TO THE
DISTRIBUTION OF HOUSING UNITS
SO. SO WHAT WHAT TYPE OF TRANSIT
STOPS ARE THERE IN THE CITY OR
COUNTY AND THEN WHAT WHAT ARE
THE WHAT IS THE JOB PICTURE LOOK
LIKE AND THAT DROVE WHAT THE
HOUSING NEED TO BE. SO I THINK
THE- THE ANALYSIS OF HOW RIVAS
DISTRIBUTED HAS CHANGED OVER
TIME- BUT ALSO WHEN YOU THINK
ABOUT IT IT IS A NOTABLE LACK
THAT RENO DOESN'T INCLUDE
HOMELESSNESS. BECAUSE
ESSENTIALLY CITIES CAN BE ZONING
FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE ONLY
PREVIOUSLY HOUSED LIKE THERE
ACTUALLY IS NOT A CONSIDERATION
WITHIN ARENA NOW THAT IS DEALING
WITH HOMELESSNESS. IN A WAY THAT
THAT HAS ANY TYPE OF PRODUCTION
REQUIREMENTS SO THERE THERE ARE
STUDY THERE ARE STATEMENTS THAT
NEED TO BE MADE AND BARRIERS
THAT NEED TO BE IDENTIFIED. BUT
ALL OF THAT IS JUST WORDS I MEAN
WHAT I'M REALLY LOOKING FOR IS
THE ACTION IS TO SAY WHAT IS IT
THAT THE CITY AND COUNTY IS
GOING TO DO TO PROVIDE FOR A
CERTAIN SPECIFIC NUMBER OF
PEOPLE. NOT JUST TO TALK ABOUT
IDENTIFICATION OF BARRIERS AND
DOING ADDITIONAL STUDIES BECAUSE
I DON'T SEE THAT AS SUBSTANTIVE
WORK AND I THINK IT'S VERY EASY
FOR CITIES. TO SAY WE'RE GONNA
DO HOMELESS ACTION PLAN AND
THAT'S THE END OF WHAT THEY DO.
DOING ALMOST ACTUAL PLAN
ACTUALLY ISN'T ACTUALLY HELPING
ANY HOMELESS PERSON. TO THIS
CONTRIVED TO GET TO THAT NEXT
LEVEL. OKAY ANY OTHER THE ELSE-
THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU MAY
CLOSE. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU GREAT THANK
YOU AND- WE SHOULD HOPEFULLY
MOMENTARILY. I HAVE A SIX MEMBER
IN THE SOUTHEAST CORNER AND
WHAT'S MORE TAKE A MOTION- I'M
ACTUALLY GONNA- CODE. OVER NOT
THE CALL CENTRE LIMÓN WILLS- YOU
CAN PRESENT YOUR SECOND A LITTLE
LATER. OKAY THANK YOU CENTER
LIKE FOR. HIM FOR A- COMING OUT
OF ORDER. OF COURSE. ASK FEDERAL
. AND THIS IS. ITEM NUMBER FIVE
SB FIVE. EIGHTY THE- YOU. IN
SENATORS. FIRST I WANT TO OFF
WITH. THE STAFF FOR THEIR WORK
ON THIS. AND I'D LIKE TO
CONTINUE TO COMMIT. TO WORK WITH
THIS COMMITTEE- ON THIS BILL.
CALIFORNIA HAS STRUGGLED TO GET
ALL THE LOW INCOME HOUSING THAT
WE NEED TO ADDRESS THE HOUSING
CRISIS. IN ADDITION TO ALL THAT
CALIFORNIA HAS DONE TO ADDRESS
THE HOUSING CRISIS IT'S
IMPORTANT THAT WE ALSO CONSIDER
MODEL IN WHICH- THE GOVERNMENT
PLAYS A GREATER ROLE IN BUILDING
AND REHABILITATING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING PROJECTS THAT ARE
PUBLICLY OWNED AND FINANCE. I'VE
HEARD REPEATEDLY FROM MY LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS FOR YEARS THAT WE
NEED AN ONGOING FUNDING SOURCE
TO ME OUR HOUSING GOALS
ESPECIALLY FOR AFFORDABLE
HOUSING. THIS BILL CREATES A
STATEWIDE ASSESSMENT ON THE
COMMERCIAL USE OF RESIDENTIAL
HOMES AND APARTMENTS FOR
TRANSIENT OCCUPANCY. FOR SHORT
TERM RENTALS. THIS WILL PROVIDE
A BUDGET PROOF SOURCE OF INCOME
FOR MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT
CALIFORNIA DESPERATELY NEEDS.
WITH ME TODAY I HAVE- BEVERLY
YOU FROM THE STATE BUILDING AND
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL OF
CALIFORNIA AND ON THE
ASTRONOMERS FROM PROBABLY OUGHT
ADVOCATES TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL. THANK YOU MAY BE
SEATED. MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
THAT REALLY ON BEHALF THE STATE
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TRADES
COUNCIL REPRESENTING HALF A
MILLION CONSTRUCTION WORKERS
STATEWIDE WE'RE PROUD SPONSOR OF
SB FIVE EIGHTY FOUR LIKE TO
THINK THE OFFER HER STAFF FOR
THE WORK ON THIS BILL. THAT'S
YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA IS IN A
SEVERE HOUSING CRISIS AND ONE OF
THE MANY REASONS WHY AFFORDABLE
HOUSING ISN'T BEING BILL IS
BECAUSE THERE ISN'T A DEDICATED
BUDGET PROOF FUNDING STREAM- IN
THE LAST DECADE. CALIFORNIA'S
POPULATION HAS GROWN OVER TWO
AND A HALF MILLION UNFORTUNATELY
THE CREATION OF HOUSING UNITS
HAS NOT KEPT UP SO UNFORTUNATELY
WE'RE SEEING A HOUSING SHORTAGE-
FOR BOTH RENTERS AND HOMEBUYERS
ALIKE- IN THE PAST THREE YEARS
THERE HAS BEEN STRIDES TOGETHER
FOR BOTH HOUSING BUILT- BUT- WE
ARE STILL. YOU KNOW FUNDING ONLY
16% OF WHAT IS NEEDED- TO GET
THESE PROJECTS OFF THE. GROUND
S. B- I WANNA MAKE SURE I GET
THE BILL RIGHT FIVE EIGHTY FOUR.
SKEWS ME SB FIVE EIGHTY FOUR
WOULD CREATE ASSESSMENT- ON
SHORT TERM RENTALS AND IT IS
IMPORTANT- TO HAVE THIS TO MAKE
SURE THAT THIS ASSESSMENT IS
THERE- TO FILL IN FOR THE
PORTION OF- HOUSING UNITS THAT
ARE AVAILABLE FOR PERMANENT
OCCUPANCY PURPOSES. OF THE
DEPARTMENT HOUSING COMMITTEE
DEVELOPMENT WILL BE- COLLECTING-
IT THE ASSESSMENT IT WILL BE
DISTRIBUTING A PROPORTIONATE TO
WHAT WAS COLLECTED TO THE LOCAL
JURISDICTION. AND THIS WILL GO
TO FUNDING LABOR FORCE HOUSING-
FOR THE CONSTRUCTION AND
REHABILITATION OF THESE HOUSING
UNITS- THIS BILL ALSO INCLUDES
STRONG LABOR PROTECTIONS. AS
WELL SB FIVE EIGHTY FOUR
PRESENTS A REAL SOLUTION TO OUR
STATE'S HOUSING NEEDS TAKING THE
PROFIT MOTIVE OUT OF KEEPING
PEOPLE HOUSE. OF ALLOWING
FAMILIES TO GROW THEIR SAVINGS
AND STABILIZING COMMUNITIES. WE
ARE DRIVE UP THANK YOU. THANK
YOU THANK SPEAKER. GOOD
AFTERNOON SHERMAN ON FROM
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL WITH PUBLIC
ADVOCATES FOR A LAW FIRM IN.
ADVOCACY ORGANIZATION THAT
REPRESENTS THE INTERESTS AND
NEEDS OF LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
AND COMMUNITIES OF COLOR.
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA VIXENS AND
HOMELESSNESS ARE ON THE RISE
BECAUSE CORPORATE LANDLORDS AND
PRIVATE EQUITY OR DRIVING COSTS
UP. EXCUSE ME THREE SPECULATION
WORSENING OUR HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS. SHORT TERM
RENTALS HAVE CONTRIBUTED TO THIS
CRISIS BY REMOVING NEEDED
HOUSING FROM THE RENTAL MARKET
AND THEY'RE BY PUSHING RENTS
HIGHER. WE NEED TO CREATE A
LARGE SECTOR OF HOUSING
SHELTERED FROM THE SPECULATIVE
MARKET BUT AS PERMANENTLY
AFFORDABLE FOR PEOPLE OF ALL
INCOME LEVELS WHO CAN'T AFFORD
MARKET RENTS. THAT'S WHAT THIS
BILL CALLS LABOR FORCE HOUSING
ALSO SOMETIMES CALLED SOCIAL
HOUSING. VICE PUBLIC ENTITIES
AND MISSION DRIVEN NONPROFITS
LIKE COMMUNITY LAND TRUSTS WITH
A NEW SOURCE OF REVENUE TO
PROVIDE THAT HOUSING. THAT
REVENUE WILL SUPPLEMENT LOCAL
FUNDING SOURCES FOR SOCIAL
HOUSING LIKE MEASURE YOU LA IN
LOS ANGELES COUNTY- THAT ARE
LIKELY TO CONTINUE TO RISE
ACROSS THE STATE. SPECIFICALLY
SB FIVE EIGHTY FOUR CREATES A
NEW REVENUE SOURCE TO BOTH
BUILDING LABOR FORCE HOUSING AND
TAKE EXISTING HOUSING OFF THE
SPECULATIVE MARKET. BY STRONGER
A STRONG RENTER PROTECTIONS TO
KEEP FAMILIES IN THEIR HOMES. IT
WILL TEST THE DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT. DEVELOPING
GUIDELINES ON THE SPECIFICS
IMPLEMENTATION- INCLUDING ON THE
MIX OF HOUSEHOLD INCOMES IN
LABOR FORCE HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTS. FOR THESE REASONS
WE RESPECTFULLY URGE AN AYE VOTE
ON SB FIVE BEFORE. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE
HEARING ROOM PLEASE COME FORWARD
. MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS SERRA.
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION IN
SUPPORT. THE FIGURE. COMMENTS ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
PIPE TRADES COUNCIL THE WESTERN
STATES COUNCIL A FEW METAL
WORKERS IN THE STATE
ASSOCIATION. ALEXCO WORKERS IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU BYE G. ON
BEHALF INNER CITY LAW CENTER AND
SO FORTH. KATHY MANZI ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
SUPPORT. DIGITAL SUPPORT COMMENT
IN THE HEARING ROOM SITTING NINE
AS ARE ANY OPPOSITION. IN THE
HEARING ROOM PLEASE COME FORWARD
. MARCH THERE'S THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AGAIN AND WE
ARE VERY SYMPATHETIC WITH THE
AUTHORS GOAL OF INCREASING
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SUPPLY WE'RE
ALSO VERY SYMPATHETIC TO THE
IDEA OF INCREASING REVENUES TO
HELP FUND THAT. WE HAVE AN
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED POSITION-
WE DO HAVE AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
FINANCE SYSTEM THAT WORKS WE
JUST NEED MORE DEFINING TO TAKE
IT TO SCALE AND THIS BILL WOULD
CREATE A KIND OF A COMPLETELY
NEW PARADIGM THAT COMPETES WITH
THAT EXISTING SYSTEM THAT WITH
THAT WORKS WELL SO. WE THINK-
AND THEN SECONDARILY WE'VE HAD
MANY CONVERSATIONS AS COMMITTEE
ABOUT SKILLED AND TRAINED LABOR
REQUIREMENTS BUT WE THINK THAT
WILL BE UNBEATABLE IN VARIOUS
PARTS OF THE STATE AND- WOULD
ALSO MAKE IT UNDERMINE THE GOAL
AND ENFORCE THE STATE EVEN WHERE
WE CAN FIND UNION LABOR SO. ARE
POSING AS AMENDED IS THAT WE
WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE REVENUES
DIRECTED TOWARDS EXISTING
PROGRAMS AND THAT WE USE AB
TWENTY ELEVEN LABOR STANDARDS A
MOVE SKILLED AND TRAINED BUT WE
WILL HAVE TO HAVE MORE
CONVERSATIONS WITH YOU THANK YOU
. WITH ONE. MORE IN LINE WITH
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
CONSORTIUM WE SUBMITTED A LETTER
OF CONCERNS I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S
A PER MONTH BASIS OKAY- SO WE
STRONGLY SUPPORT THE ADDITION OF
NEW FUNDING SOURCES TO BOTH
LEVERAGE EXISTING PRIVATE
CAPITAL AND EXPAND THE TYPES OF
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THE STATE
NEEDS TO MEET ITS DIVERSE
HOUSING NEEDS. HOWEVER WHAT WE
HAVE CONCERNS THAT AS WRITTEN
THIS BILL WILL NOT BE AS
IMPACTFUL AS IT COULD BE FOR THE
FOLLOWING REASONS. FIRST THE
BILL UNNECESSARILY LIMITS THE
TYPES OF ENTITIES THAT CAN
DEVELOP PRODUCE AND MANAGE LABOR
FORCE HOUSING WHICH WILL
DRASTICALLY LIMIT THE ABILITY TO
LEVERAGE OTHER PUBLIC PRIVATE
AND PHILANTHROPIC. RESOURCES THE
DEED RESTRICTIONS WILL ALSO BE
CHALLENGING TO EXECUTE FOR LEGAL
UNDERWRITING REASONS AND THE
BILL LACKS ANY SPECIFIC
AFFORDABILITY REQUIREMENTS
ENSURE THAT THE PUBLIC FUNDS ARE
BEING USED TO SUPPORT HOUSING
THAT THE MARKET IS NOT ALREADY
PRODUCING. AND THIRD- AGAIN THAT
THE SKILLED AND TRAINED
WORKFORCE REQUIREMENT FOR KELLY
REQUIREMENTS WILL LIMIT WHERE
THE HOUSING CAN BE BUILT BECAUSE
THERE'S MANY PARTS TO SAY BUT
YOU KNOW I HAVE A WORK FORCE
THAT CAN MEET THOSE
REQUIREMENTS. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU ANY ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION
TESTIMONY IN THE HEARING ROOM.
THREE NINE WILL GO THE PHONE
LINE- WITH MY- PLEASE QUEUE UP-
SUPPORT ENOUGH IS. TELEFONICA.
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN IF YOU
WOULD WISH TO COMMENT IN SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION. THE FIRST ONE
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. PLEASE
ONLY BE FELT. A ONE MOM. FILE
FOR COMIC CON FROM A LINE EIGHTY
TWO. EIGHTY TWO YOUR LONG. IS
OPEN. THE HE UNION OF EDUCATOR
IN CLASS I PREFER. WHO ARE PROUD
TO SUPPORT. ONE POINT EIGHTY
FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD- YES-
DIDN'T- GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS- QUEEN GREASY
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS IN
OPPOSITION FOR THE REASONS
STATED IN OUR LETTER BE
RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING OF A-
THANK YOU. AT THE FINAL NOBODY
ELSE TO THE- THANK YOU VERY MUCH
WE WILL BRING BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. CENTER
CORTESE. SEVEN CENTERS ZERO
CENTER CABALLERO THANK WE SHOULD
. SUPPORT THE BILL- A QUESTION
ON THE MECHANICS OF IT IF YOU
WILL- WE WERE TRYING TO. DO A
LITTLE RESEARCH ON THAT- OFFICE
TO OFFICE BEFORE HAND AT WHAT
POINT WILL WE HAVE A BETTER
UNDERSTANDING AS TO. ACTUAL
COSTS IMMEDIATE TALKS BUT
UNSPECIFIED PERCENTAGE OF THE
RENT AND- WHETHER NOT THAT'LL BE
TIERED IN ANY WAY FOR MOM AND
POP- OPERATIONS WHICH OF COURSE
IS SOME SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE
OF THIS MARKET FROM WHAT I
UNDERSTAND I DON'T. DEAL WITH
THIS MARKET RIGHT IT'S A LOT BUT
A I KNOW ENOUGH ABOUT IT TO KNOW
THAT THERE'S- YOU KNOW DIFFERENT
LEVELS OF INVESTMENT OUT THERE
IN SUMMER. NEIGHBORHOOD PEOPLE
AND SUCH SO WE ARE ACTUALLY IN
CONVERSATIONS RIGHT NOW WITH THE
SHORT TERM RENTAL ADVOCATES
TRYING TO DETERMINE WHAT A
PERCENTAGE WOULD BE AND THAT'S
WHY IT IS NOT INCLUDED IN THIS
VERSION OF THE BILL THIS BILL IS
DOUBLE REFERRED- AND SO WE HOPE
THAT WE WOULD BE ABLE TO- EITHER
COME TO AN AGREEMENT- MOVE
FORWARD WITH SETTING- YOU KNOW.
OR CLEAR LANGUAGE AND OF WHAT
PERCENTAGE WOULD BE. OKAY IN
WITHOUT WITHOUT PERMIT GIVING UP
I'M NOT ASKING FOR ANY SO WE
STARTED NEGOTIATING POSITION BUT
ON IT THAT THE MECHANICS OF IT
HAS TO. PASS THROUGH TO
CONSUMERS- IS THIS SOMETHING
THAT YOU'RE USED TO WORKING ON
WHETHER IT'S BASICALLY BECOMES A
PROPERTY OWNER- COST. OR WHAT
YES WE ARE STILL WORKING ON THAT
BUT THE THOUGHT WAS TO E.
SENSUALLY MODEL SOME OF WHAT
WE'VE SEEN STRUCTURE THROUGH TOT
LOCALLY AND SO THAT WAS. WHERE
OUR STARTING POINT I'M NOT SURE
THAT THAT'S WHERE WE WILL BE BUT
THAT WAS OUR STARTING POINT TO
MODEL A TOT. SO IT'S A GOOD
STARTING POINT THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN. THERE ARE. THANK YOU I
HAD QUESTIONS AS SIMILAR TO MY
COLLEAGUE OVER THERE ESPECIALLY
FOR THE YOU KNOW MOM AND POP.
YOU KNOW THEY HAVE A- VACATION
HOME THE TRYING TO KEEP- THIS
OFFERS THEM A WAY OF DOING THAT
THEY'RE ALREADY PAYING 10212% T.
O. T. AND IN ADDITION TO OTHER
FEES- FOR LOCAL AND COUNTY- SO
IF THIS IS A SIMILAR. TAX TO
THAT ANOTHER TOT ON TOP OF THE
10% THEY ALREADY PAY NOW YOU'RE
GETTING THE TWENTY TO TWENTY
FIVE PERCENT. TAXES FOR
OPERATING. A SINGLE FAMILY HOME
PART TIME BASICALLY. BECAUSE
THAT'S WHAT THEY DO. MOST MOST
AIRBNB FOLKS THAT ARE IN OF THAT
NATURE AND I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT
THE CORPORATIONS AGO BY. YOU
KNOW FIFTEEN OR TWENTY AIRBNB IS
I KNOW ONE GUY HAD LIKE A
HUNDRED- WELL IF YOU WANTED TO
FOCUS ON THOSE MAYBE. THE MOM
AND POP THEY NEED TO BE LEFT
ALONE. THEY PAY ENOUGH TAXES THE
COUNTY CAN DO THIS IF THEY WANT.
THAT SO THEY CAN USE THEIR 10%
T. O. T. FOR- BUT IT'S
ESSENTIALLY THE MOST OF THESE
FOLKS TRY TO. GET TO A POINT
WHERE THEY CAN BREAK EVEN. ON ON
THAT BEING ABLE TO KEEP THEIR
THEIR PLACE AND- AND SO THAT IT
DOES THAT SAY I CONCERNED NOT
KNOWING THAT THAT NUMBER IS. IS
A BIG FACTOR FOR ME AND- AND
ALSO- WE NEED TO EXCLUDE THESE
SINGLE FAN ARE SINGLE OPERATORS.
FROM THIS BECAUSE YOU ARE ACTION
THAT THAT IS. THIS WILL HURT
THEM. THIS WILL MAKE SOME PEOPLE
EVEN LOSE THEIR PROPERTY. AND I
AM WHOLLY AGAINST THAT. YOU KNOW
PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE
THEIR VACATION HOMES THEY WANT.
AND MOVING INTO THAT SPACE I
THINK IT'S A- I THINK. I'M NOT A
BIG FAN OF THAT APPROACH SO
THANK YOU. THANK YOU CENTER
CABALLERO AND THEN CENTER. X.
HERE. WHO THINK THANK YOU THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR I
GUESS HAVE TO TALK FOR A LONG
TIME TILL SENATOR BREAKS OR GETS
BACK. BUT- I JUST WANT TO THANK
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD IT I'M AYE AYE MA. THIS
IS GOING TO COME TO GOVERNANCE
AND FINANCE OBVIOUSLY WILL HAVE
AN OPPORTUNITY TO TALK ABOUT
WHAT COMES NEXT- BECAUSE THERE'S
SOME QUESTIONS I THINK THAT NEED
TO BE ANSWERED. SUCH AS- AND
RIGHT NOW IT'S EACH CD IS A
COLLECTION AGENCY THIS IS NOT IN
A REAL HOUSE AND SO PROBABLY
MAKES MORE SENSE TO HAVE IT
SOMEWHERE ELSE. AND THEN- THE
ABILITY TO CREATE A VARIETY OF I
MEAN THERE IS A MISSING MIDDLE
BUT THEY'RE STILL OF A VARIETY
OF HOW HOUSING NEEDS- AND
THEY'LL BE DIFFERENT IN
DIFFERENT COMMUNITY SAME WANT TO
MAKE SURE WE CAN MEET. MEET
THOSE BUT- BUT I AM. I WANNA BE
EVEN I THINK LITTLE BIT MORE
PROVOCATIVE BECAUSE- BUT YOU
KNOW BACK IN THE DAY- SENATOR I
THINK THAT PEOPLE USED TO OWN A
SECOND HOME IS A VACATION HOME
AND YOU KNOW IT DESTINATION AND
THEY GRANTED OUT TO FAMILY AND
THAT KIND OF STUFF. I THINK
THAT'S THE CASE ANYMORE I THINK
PEOPLE ARE USING. LAND
SPECULATION AS A WAY TO- SHELTER
SHELTER IN INVESTMENT PUT MONEY
INTO. BUYING UP LAND AND WHAT I
THINK WHAT I'VE SEEN IS THAT-
THAT- IT ESPECIALLY IN TOURIST
DESTINATION SITES. YOU SEE THAT
MOST OF THE HOUSES AND I SAY
THIS BECAUSE THERE WAS A PROJECT
DEVELOPED IN MONTEREY COUNTY
CLOSE TO- CLOSE TO THE CITY OF
MONTEREY. THAT THAT I HAD
FRIENDS THAT MOVED INTO AROUND A
GOLF COURSE AND 70% OF THE UNITS
WERE BOUGHT A SECOND HOMES FOR
SOMEONE ELSE- AND MAYBE A SECOND
OR THIRD HOME THEIR VACANT. MOST
OF THE YEAR ROUND SO THEY'RE
NOT. CREATING AN OPPORTUNITY TO
INVEST IN THE LOCAL COMMUNITY.
AND THEY'RE USING UP LAND THAT
WOULD OTHERWISE BE USED FOR
HOUSING THE LOCAL WORK FORCE AND
SO- I REALLY THINK THAT THERE
OUGHT TO BE LIMITS ON HOW MANY
UNITS IN A IN A COMMUNITY AND
THAT. ONCE IT GOES BEYOND A
CERTAIN AMOUNT THAT MAY BE. THAT
THE- THE OTHER UNITS GET. TAXED
AT A HIGHER LEVEL I'M- I'M SPIT
BALLING TO A CERTAIN EXTENT BUT
I'VE IT'S BECOME REALLY CLEAR TO
ME THAT ONE OF THE CHALLENGES IN
OUR HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA IS
THAT. ALL LOCATIONS ARE REALLY
ATTRACTIVE FOR PEOPLE TO COME IN
AND HAVE A SECOND OR THIRD OR
FOURTH HOME AND IF WE'RE GONNA
ALLOW IT WHICH IS FINE. THEN
THERE OUGHT TO BE AT- SOME KIND
OF REMUNERATION THAT RECOGNIZES
THAT BEN WERE CROWDING OUT THE
WORK FORCE. THEY CAN AFFORD TO-
TO BUY THEIR OWN HOME AND SO-
I'M JUST BY PUTTING THAT OUT
THERE BECAUSE I THINK THAT- THAT
THE IDEA IS A REALLY GOOD IDEA-
THERE ARE SOME- SOME. I THINK
THAT WE NEED ANSWER AND THAT
THAT T. O. T. MODEL IS- IT'S ONE
THAT. THAT THAT SUBTRACTIVE IN
THAT AND I ALSO THINK WE HAVE TO
MAKE SURE WE'RE BUILDING
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS AS
WELL. SO WITH THAT I LOOK
FORWARD TO IT. EGGMAN SUPPORTED
TODAY EXPECTED TO GET OUT AND
WE'LL SEE YOU AT GOVERNMENT SOME
FINITE. THANK YOU US AND A COVER
OKAY SEN. WE WOULD HAVE HAD A
SIX FOOT BUT NOW. SURE IT TURNS
OUT REALLY APPRECIATE THAT SO.
LEAD THE WAY FOR LIGHTNING TO
STRIKE- INCIDENTS. WITH- OKAY-
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
OKAY BOB THE CEREMONY YOUR SPOKE
EXTENDS. ABOUT THIS FILLED TAX
ISSUES. THAT'LL BE HANDLED IT
ANYTHING AND- BUT WE'RE NOT
ASSEMBLY WILL WORK- ON I'M SURE
THERE WILL BE A ROBOT DISCUSS.
ON NEXT FIND. WERE FOLKS HERE ON
THE- IS. FIRST OF THE STRONG SO
. OF FOR THE HOUSE. AND SOCIAL
HOUSING AND- OKAY. TO RURAL
SCARY THE CHAIR ON. FOSTER
WELCOME WELCOME TO WORLD. AND A
PRE SHOULD YOUR YOUR WORK ON
THIS- AS I EXPRESSED TO YOU AND
AS IN THE- IN THE TO AND
ANALYSIS- TO THE CENTER
PORTANTINO'S BILL. THIS BILL
WOULD SET A NEW. THE FOR THE
FIRST EVER THEIR CAL LAW SKILLED
WORK FOR WHAT IT TO AFFORDABLE
HOUSING WE NOT TO MY KNOWLEDGE
NEVER DONE THAT BEFORE AND I
WOULD A SEAT. IN AFFORDABLE.
FUNDING WOULD SET PRESS- I
INDICATED IN THE. IN THE CENTER
PORTANTINO'S BILL.
IT'S BAD AND I KNOW THERE ARE A
LOT OF PEOPLE WORKING IN TWO
CHAINS- AND I SUPPORT THOSE
EFFORTS WHOLEHEARTEDLY- BUT MOMS
WHO SKILLED WORKFORCE LANGUAGES
THIS LIMITING IN TERMS OF WHAT
CONTRACTORS CAN BID. AND EVEN IN
PLACES LIKE. THAT WE WOULD
EXPECT IT TO BE EASY IT MAY NOT
BE IN THEIR PARTS OF THE STATE
WHERE THERE WOULD NOT BE. THERE
MAY NOT BE ANY BIDS ON A
PROJECT- AND SO. YOU KNOW WE
LOOK AT SB THIRTY FIVE WHICH ARE
TRYING TO RENEW THIS YEAR- THE
PREVAILING WAGE PART OF THAT
BILL IS GOING GANGBUSTERS THE
SKILLED WORKFORCE PART OF THE
BILL HAS NOT- AND SO- I SAIL
THIS JUST TO REPEAT WHAT I'VE
WITHIN AN HOUR SO SOMEONE I SAID
TO YOU. AS I INDICATED EARLIER I
AM NOT IN THE PRACTICE OF.
DEMANDING THAT AUTHOR-
PARTICULAR RELY ARTS ME THAT'S
AUTHORS- AND SO I DEFER TO YOUR
YOUR CHOICE HERE AND I'LL BE
SUPPORTING THE BILL- TODAY
CONCERT PREVIEW YOUR WORK. I
THOUGHT WE COULD TAKE A MOTION
YOUR BILL WE CANNOT YET-
HOPEFULLY SOON BUT AS SOON AS WE
CAN WE WILL AND- YOU'RE WELCOME
CLOSE THANK YOU AND I APPRECIATE
THE ROBUST DISCUSSION AND I
THINK THAT THAT IS REALLY THE
INTENTION OF THIS BILL. TO HAVE
A ROBUST DISCUSSION AFTER. STEPS
THAT YOU KNOW SEVEN YEARS OF
REPRESENTING THE DISTRICT AND
CERTAINLY BEING A DISTRICT THAT
HAS A HIGH PERCENTAGE OF THE
SHORT TERM RENTALS AND HAVE SEEN
JUST THE IMPACT THE DIALOGUE THE
CONVERSATION THAT IT GENERATES
IN COMMUNITIES- YOU KNOW IT WAS
NOT EASY JUST TO SAY HEY LET'S
LET'S BRING THIS FORWARD BUT I
THINK IT WAS NEEDED. AND I WENT
FROM JUST SOMETHING THAT FELT
COMFORTABLE TO SOMETHING THAT
WAS NEEDED IN A DISTRICT THAT
WAS NEEDED I THINK ACROSS THE
STATE SO- YOU KNOW AND THAT NEED
IS TO HAVE A ROBUST DISCUSSION-
JUST A YOU KNOW A COUPLE THINGS-
THAT I WANTED TO CLARIFY IS THE
ONE YOU KNOW. THROUGH TOT MODELS
IT IS THE CONSUMER RIGHT SO IF I
DECIDE TO GO TO A HOTEL IF I
DECIDED TO DO A SHORT TERM
RENTAL IT IS THE CONSUMER- THAT
TO YOU KNOW BEARS THAT
INVESTMENT THAT IS MADE- AND
SECONDLY. THIS BILL IT DOES
ALLOW FOR PROJECT LABOR
AGREEMENT OR IF YOU KNOW SKILLED
IN TRAIN SO IT'S ONE OR THE
OTHER. I LIVE AND I REPRESENT A
DISTRICT- THAT WHETHER IT'S THE
RURAL PARTS OF MY DISTRICT TO-
THAT YOU KNOW ARE HARDER TO GET
TO A LITTLE BIT FURTHER AWAY
FROM SOME OF THE JOBS. OR
WHETHER IT'S IT AT THE PART OF
THE DISTRICT. THAT HAS A WHOLE
LOT. OF THE TIME YOU KNOW
TOURIST- AND- YOU KNOW IT IS
VERY HEALTHY THERE AND BECOMES A
MORE EXPENSIVE TO LIVE IN. I
UNDERSTAND SOME OF THE REAL
CHALLENGES- WITH THE LABOR
MARKET- IN WITH PEOPLE NOT BEING
ABLE TO LIVE. IN THE COMMUNITIES
THAT THEY WORK IN. AND SO I YOU
KNOW I THINK IT THAT AS A AS A
AS A COMMUNITY THAT HAS
STRUGGLED WITH THIS IN REALLY.
ALL SECTORS I'M ALL SECTORS
WHERE PEOPLE CAN'T ALWAYS AFFORD
TO LIVE IN THE CITY. OF SANTA
BARBARA RATE- OR IN THE BROADER
CARE. COUNTY INTER OR SANTA
BARBARA CAN- I ALSO. NOTE YOU
KNOW LOOKING AT HOW ARC LOCAL
COMMUNITIES HAVE MODELED- AT THE
PIECE ABOUT ENSURING. THAT WE
THAT WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO HAVE
THE WORK FORCE- REALLY THE KEY
LA OR THE SKILLED- YOU KNOW AND
TRAIN SYSTEM HAS EVEN WORKED IN
SOME OF THESE COMMUNITIES WHERE
EVERYONE CAN AFFORD TO LIVE
THERE SO I THINK THAT THAT WAS.
YOU KNOW PART OF WHY WE FELT
THAT THIS WAS SOMETHING THAT CAN
BE DONE. BUT CERTAINLY- YOU KNOW
I EAT YOU ARE A THOUGHT LEADER
IN THIS SPACE AS IS YOU KNOW
THIS COMMITTEE THAT WORKS DAY IN
AND DAY OUT TO TRY TO HELP SHAPE
US. AND SO I WILL CONTINUE TO BE
WORKING WITH FOLKS BUT I WANTED
TO EXPLAIN WHY I FELT THAT IT
THIS PIECE WAS IMPORTANT. AND
WHY. YOU KNOW WE HAVE EXAMPLES
IN THE STATE WHERE WE CAN. ALLOW
FOR ONE OR THE OTHER TO WORK ON
AND THEY WERE STILL SEE SOME OF
THE DESIRED OUTCOMES. SO FOR ME
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT BUILT IT'S
A IT'S A BILL THAT I'M GOING TO
QUOTE AT OURS SENATOR AT YOU
KNOW FROM UP. A CENTRAL VALLEY
AND THAT IT IS PROVOCATIVE BUT I
THINK WE NEED THAT TYPE OF
CONVERSATION RIGHT NOW. SO WITH
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AND I DO SINCE I PRETTY AND I
VERY MUCH APPRECIATE YOUR
CLOTHES I WANT TO. ALSO TO
STRESS THAT LAST YEAR I CARRIED-
TO BILLS OF SKILLED WORKFORCE
CENTER AND THE PUBLIC WORKS
CONTRACTS SO. MY CONCERN IS IN
THE RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION.
SECTOR I'M NOT IN COMMERCIAL NOT
AND- NOT NOT AND MADE PUBLIC
WORKS SO IT'S A NEW ONCE
CONVERSATION AND- AND I WELCOME
YOU TO THE CONVERSATION SENATOR
I THINK IT'S LIKE SAILLY.
COMMAND AND I DO WANT TO
INCREASE SHE- THE- YOU KNOW THAT
AND NOW. I WILL SAY THE I KNOW
HE- WHERE YOU SAY IT'S A PAGE
THAT. EIGHT OF THE IN. WHERE YOU
LAY AN- THIS FOR. KIND I JUST
WANT. THE TEAM TO KNOW THAT IT'S
BEEN READ. AND NOTED THAT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. WE WERE TAKE
EMOTIONAL WERE ARE. WERE WE'RE
SLIDING BACK FOR DOWN THE-
FRIEDMAN. S. OKAY WHEN OUR
DOCTOR. TO FOUR. YOU MIGHT HAVE
IT- CENTER. YOU KNOW WE NEED.
GOT MY GOT EVERYONE HERE OKAY.
IT IS A- MEAN I I'M JEWISH. I
CAN SAY THIS IS YOU IT'S A- MORE
- OKAY WE WILL ESTABLISH A CORE.
NOW SENATOR WIENER PRESENT
WIENER PRESENT THE TROUBLED BLIX
BEER. THANKS FOR PRESENT KERO.
CAVALEIRO PRESENT COULD.
COURTESY PRESENT MY- ACQUIRE
PRESENT VIDEO THERE ARE TWO.
THERE ARE TWO PRESENTS. AMBERG
BOB SIX. WE HAVE A QUORUM SO I
WOULD LIKE TO ENTER A MOTION BY
SO CORTES ON. SB FIVE EIGHTY FOR
A 5% OR LIMÓN AND WE WILL THE
SENATE BILL 584% OF THEM ON THE
MOTION TO PASS AND REFER THE
COMMITTEE. UNDER AND FINANCE
SENATOR WINNER FIVE WIENER HI
TROUBLE. LIKE SPEAR. LIKE SPEAR
CARRIER. SORRY WE WILL BECAUSE
THE LIMÓN. FIVE CAMARO FIVE
COURTESY. AS THE MCGUIRE.
ACQUIRE VIDEO THERE ARE TWO ZERO
TWO NOW SKINNER AMBERG BOB. IT
WILL PUT THE BILL ON CALL ZERO
SIX SIX BOTH A SIR WORKING BE
ALL THE BECAUSE YOU WANT TO CALL
YOU OUT FOR A MAY HAVE MOTIONS
EVERYTHING IN YOU DON'T TO SAY
YOU DON'T BUT IF YOU'D LIKE TO
VOTE ANNOUNCED.
HOLE IN SECONDS- AND THERE ARE
AMENDMENTS ON THE BILL SO CAN I
GET A MOTION ON ITEM TO- TO. AND
I AM ACTUALLY BEFORE FOR SEVERAL
OF ON THAT MOTION IS SET AND
STILL TO GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
- AS FOR THE MOTION ON ITEM TO
ARTS A LOT I WOULD BE A MOTION
TO PASS AS AMENDED. TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS FOR
CANCER MOTIONS ALMOST MOTIONLESS
CENTER CORTEZ C. WE WILL CALL
THE ROLL. SENATOR WIENER WIENER
HI THE TROUBLED SIX YEAR. THANK
BYE CABALLERO CAMARO ICRA.
COURTESY MCGUIRE. ACQUIRE BY
DEAR THERE ARE TWO. ZERO TWO
FIVE SKINNER. NUMBER. IT WILL
PUT THAT BILL CALL. R. ONE EXTRA
ITEM THREE S. B. C. THIRTY FOUR
BY SEVEN PORTENT. AND I WILL
ENTERTAIN A MOTION. TO PAY. THIS
BILL TO THE GOVERNOR TO
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE. STOCK THE MOTION. BY
SENATOR. BUT LACKS INTERNAL I'M
- CENTER CABALLERO- WILL CALL
THE- SENATOR WIENER. WIENER HI
THE CHAU BOOK LOOKS. CLICKS
THERE HI CAMARO. AVEIRO OCCURRED
AS HE PRETENDS HE HI MCGUIRE.
ACQUIRE HI MEDINA THERE ARE TWO.
ZERO TWO NOW SKINNER NUMBER
COOPER OKAY WE'LL PUT THE BILL
ON CALL. MEXICO TO ARE YOU
NUMBER. SB FOUR SIXTY NINE. BY
AL- AND THE IS MOTION TO A BILL
THE CAN ON APPROPRIATION- BY
CENTER EAT AND WE WILL CALL THE
ROLL. SENATOR WIENER WIENER HI
UNTIL LIKE SEVERE LIKE SPEAR I
CARRIER. CABRERO RETURN HE
BECAUSE HE HI MCGUIRE MCGUIRE US
TO THE THEIR TO THEIR TÔI
SKINNER NUMBER BOB. OKAY WE'LL
PUT UP ON AND IN THE FINAL BILL
WE HEARD BUT THE VOTER ON IS- S.
B. SORRY TO BE ITEM. EIGHT SB
SIX BY SENATOR BLOW SEVERE AND
BECAUSE I HAVE A THE AMENDMENT
WILL NOT BE TO THIS OVERTAKEN
GOVERNMENT BY SO THOSE FOR UP
MOTION TO PASS THE BILL TO THE
COMMITTEE ON COMEY OF FINE.
ROLES PLEASE ENTER THE RULES
FOR. HELLO. OKAY MY UP- THIS
WILL BE SEND OF THE TO RULES
COMMITTEE WHICH WILL RE REFER.
FOCUS ON THOSE. TO PASS THIS
BILL. AND SEND IT THE RULES
COMMITTEE. BY SEN COURT HE WILL
CALL THE ROLL SENATOR HI WIENER
AYE TROUBLES SIX YEAR. THANKS
FOR HI KEVIN. CARRIER I BECAUSE
HE BECAUSE HE MCGUIRE. ACQUIRE
FIVE. THERE ARE TWO ZERO TWO NO
SKINNER. BOB OKAY WHAT THE PHONE
CALL THE FINAL WE'RE GOING TO
THE CONCERT CALENDAR. ITEMS
WHICH IS WHY ITEM ITEM NUMBER
TWO S. B. NINETY BY SEN. NUMBER
SIR MO ON THE CA CALENDAR. OKAY
BY SEN CABALLERO THE ROLL. ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR CONSISTS OF
ITEMS SENATOR WIENER WIENER I
BOOK FLICKS BEER FIVE PLEASE A
DAY. COMMITTEE I COULD HE COULD
HE HI MICHAEL. ACQUIRE HI MEDINA
THERE ARE TWO THEIR TWO BY
SKINNER NUMBER CLUB. OKAY- FOR
THE IS ON THE ALL. CALL OKAY ARE
CAUGHT UP FROM EXCITED-
THUNDERCRACKER WELCOME THANK YOU
FOR YOUR PATIENCE. AND OUT OF
THE CITY ITEM SEVEN SB. SIX
THIRTY FOUR. THANK YOU AFTER TO
SECURE AN MEMBERS. I THINK IF BY
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE. OUTLINE
THE NAILS IN THANK YOU FOR STAFF
TO CLEAR ISSUES FOR WORKING WITH
ME IN MY STAFF ON THIS BILL. SB
SIX FOUR WILL DEFINE HOUSE IT
STATUTE AND THE STATE. ADDRESS
HOMELESSNESS CRISIS WHILE WE
WAIT FOR PERMITS HOUSING TO BE.
I AM VERY CLEAR THAT SUPPORT OF
EFFORT TO AND DIVERT HERMAN
HOUSING. WHICH IS A PRIMARY OF
SOLVING LONG TERM. CALIFORNIA
LACK OF ADEQUATE. CONTRIBUTES TO
CALIFORNIA'S HIGHEST IN THE
NATION UNSHELTERED RATE. WITH
67% OF CALIFORNIANS EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS SLEEPING ON THE
STREETS WITHOUT ACCESS TO
SHELTER OR SANITATION. IN FACT
HALF OF ALL UNSHELTERED HOMELESS
AMERICANS LIVE IN CALIFORNIA. AT
THE SAME TIME THE STATE AND
LOCAL AGENCIES SEVERAL LARGE
SWATHS OF VACANT LAND. IT IS NOT
CURRENTLY BEING DEVELOPED THAT
COULD BE UTILIZED TO HOUSE. OUR
HOMELESS POPULATION. CALIFORNIA
NEEDS A SOLUTION THAT ALLOWS
PEOPLE EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
TO HAVE A ROOF OVER THEIR HEADS
WHILE WE WAIT FOR PERMANENT
SUPPORTIVE HOUSING TO BE
CONSTRUCTED. SB SIX THIRTY FOUR
HELPS ADDRESS THESE PROBLEMS BY
DOING THE FOLLOWING NUMBER ONE.
DEFINING OPPORTUNITY HOUSING IN
STATUTE AS A LOW BARRIER
NAVIGATION CENTER THAT IS NOT
CONGREGATE RELOCATABLE. RESERVE
FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE HOMELESS OR
AT RISK OF EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS AND ON LAND WITH NO
DEMONSTRABLE USE WITHIN THE NEXT
FIVE YEARS. NUMBER TWO REQUIRES
LOCAL AGENCIES TO RESPOND TO
REQUESTS TO DEVELOP THE LAND FOR
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING. NUMBER
THREE QUITTING A STREAMLINED
APPROVAL PROCESS TO DEVELOP
THESE KINDS OF UNITS QUICKLY.
AND FINALLY TASKING H. E. D.
WITH REVIEWING BUILDING CODES TO
EXPEDITE AND REDUCE CONSTRUCTION
COSTS OF OPPORTUNITY HOUSING
WHILE MAINTAINING HEALTH AND
SAFETY AND SAFETY STANDARDS AND
MAKING SURE THEY'RE HIGH QUALITY
. BY DOING SO THIS BILL WILL BE
IT WILL BE ABLE TO RAPIDLY SCALE
IN EXPENSIVE HOUSING. TO HELP
HOUSE OR ON HOUSE NEIGHBORS.
WITH ME HERE TODAY HAVE TWO
WITNESSES WITH THE FUNK FROM
TURKEY MOVES AND ADRIN COVERED
FOR THE BAY AREA COUNCIL. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH PLEASE COME
FORWARD WITH. ZERO OKAY. K. YEAH
HI ELIZABETH PUNK THE AND- OF
DIGNITY MOVES THE MOVE IS. TO BE
A SPA. OF S. B. C. THIRTY FOR.
AS SAID ABOUT HER MENTION MORE
PERMANENT HOUSING IS THE OLD
LONG TO GOAL BUT BECAUSE IT
TAKES LONG. IT IS SO EXPENSIVE
PEOPLE ARE LANGUISHING ON THE
STREETS THE ONLY ALTERNATIVE IS
GROUP SHELTERS WHERE THEY DON'T
WANT TO GO UNDERSTANDABLY THERE
SAFE AND QUITE FRANKLY THERE
STILL AREN'T EVEN ENOUGH OF THEM
. THIS MODEL ALLOWS US TO BUILD
FAST SCALABLE SOLUTIONS TO GET
PEOPLE INDOORS IMMEDIATELY WHERE
THEY CAN THEN HOW THE SERVICES
THAT THEY NEED TO REBUILD THEIR
LIVES. PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO
ACCEPT GROUP SHELTER BEDS
BECAUSE THEY WANT THEIR OWN
SPACE WHEN THEY HAVE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE THEIR OWN
ROOM WITH A DOOR THAT LOCKS IS A
GAME CHANGER. THE ABILITY TO
TAKE A DEEP BREATH AND START TO
THINK FORWARD ABOUT REBUILDING
THEIR LIVES. DID YOU MOVES BUILT
A COUPLE OF COMMUNITIES THE
FOLLOWS OPPORTUNITY HOUSING
MODEL WE USE VACANT LAND THAT WE
BORROW BECAUSE ALL. ALL THE IT
THIS IS ALL OBVIOUSLY AN INTERIM
USE. THAT WE SET UP RELOCATABLE
CABINS THAT ARE EASY. FAST AND
SCALABLE WE'RE PEOPLE- THE
RESIDENTS FOR LOVING THEM. THEY
CAN TAKE A DEEP BREATH THE HAVE
THE BOTH THE COMBINATION OF
PRIVACY BUT ALSO THE SENSE OF
COMMUNITY THAT HAS BEEN SO
IMPORTANT FOR THEM. BUT THEY'VE
LEARNED IS WHAT KEEPS THEM ALIVE
IN THE END- OUT ON THE STREETS.
THE THESE ARE BIT SORRY EXCUSE
ME- AS YOU KNOW THIS IS BECOME A
VERY POPULAR MODEL. THERE BEEN
LOTS OF CITIES THAT HAVE BEEN
CURIOUS THAT HAVE COME WALKING
THROUGH AND TOURED AN- AHA
MOMENT WHEN THEY SEE WHAT THIS
COULD BE. THERE ARE WE'RE NOW
STARTING TO SEE INTEREST ALL
ACROSS THE STATE AND YET THERE
ARE THINGS THAT STAND IN THE WAY
FOR BEING ABLE TO DO THIS AT
SCALE. ABOUT DRIVING UP HERE
TODAY I HAD A CONVERSATION WITH
THE SUPERVISOR IN SANTA CRUZ
COUNTY WHO SAID HE'S WRITING AN
ORDINANCE THAT WOULD ALLOW. TINY
HOME COMMUNITIES BEING MORE
ZONES THAT I'M DOING THAT JOB
FOR YOU TODAY I HOPE. AT A AND
MAY HAVE ON IN SAN JOSE SAID
THAT HE'S TRYING TO GET PUBLIC
UTILITIES THE LAND LAND. FOR
THEIR HOUSING AND HAVING THEM
DROP DRAG THEIR FEET. IF WE
COULD PAVE THE WAY TO DO A LOT
MORE OF THIS HOUSING FAST AND
SCALABLE YOU WERE PEOPLE CAN
COME INDOORS. WE MAY ULTIMATELY
NEED A LOT LESS OF THAT
PERMANENT HOUSING. BUT IT KEEPS
PEOPLE SAFE WHILE THEY'RE
WAITING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MY
NAME'S ADRIAN COVERTS I'M WITH
THE BAY AREA COUNCIL. HOUSING IS
A BASIC HUMAN NEED IS BASIC AS
FOOD WATER OR CLOTHING. WITHOUT
HOUSING HUMAN HEALTH DECLINES
RAPIDLY AND PARISHES MUCH MORE
SWIFTLY THAN THEIR HOUSE
COUNTERPARTS. BY ANY GIVEN DAY
IN CALIFORNIA THEY'RE ABOUT A
HUNDRED SEVENTY THOUSAND PEOPLE
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS. TWO
THIRDS OF THEM ABOUT A HUNDRED
FIFTEEN THOUSAND PEOPLE ARE
WITHOUT ACCESS TO BASIC SHELTER
WHICH PUTS THEM AT EXTREMELY
HIGH RISK. FOR DEVELOPING
CHRONIC DISEASE INFECTIOUS
DISEASE SUFFERING FROM ASSAULT
HOMICIDE AND ACCIDENTAL DEATHS.
OMITS THIS URGENT HUMANITARIAN
CRISIS THE NEW SOME
ADMINISTRATION ESTIMATES ARE
ABOUT FORTY FIVE THOUSAND
CALIFORNIANS WITH HOUSING
VOUCHERS. THAT REMAIN HOUSE
HOMELESS OR HOUSING INSECURE
BECAUSE THERE'S A SHORTAGE OF
PLACES FOR THEM TO GO WE NEED
MORE PLACES FOR PEOPLE TO GO.
PERMANENT HOUSING IS THE GOLD
STANDARD. IT IS THE GOLD
STANDARD FOR A HOW TO STABLY
HOUSE SOMEONE. WHO'S BEEN ON THE
STREETS BUT SIX HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS A UNIT ON AVERAGE. BEST
ESTIMATES ARE THAT SCALING THAT
TO MEET THE NEED WOULD COST
ABOUT SEVENTY BILLION DOLLARS.
CURRENTLY THE STATE'S WERE
FACING A TWENTY THREE BILLION
DOLLAR DEFICIT. THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT IS NOT ANYWHERE TO BE
SEEN AT THAT KIND OF LEVEL
MAGNITUDE. OF INVESTMENT
MEANWHILE CALIFORNIA IS A
HUNDRED FIFTEEN THOUSAND
HOMELESS RESIDENTS WHO ARE
UNSHELTERED CANNOT WAIT YEARS OR
DECADES FOR SOLUTIONS WHEN
THEY'RE ON THE STREETS.
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING CONSISTS OF
NON CONGREGATE HOUSING. THAT CAN
TAKE MONTHS TO BUILD AND INSTALL
NOT YEARS AND WE'RE RESIDENTS
CAN STAY YEARS NOT MONTHS IF. NO
PERMANENT HOUSING IS AVAILABLE
AND UNTIL CURRENT HOUSING
BECOMES AVAILABLE THIS IS THE
MISSING RUNG ON THE LADDER
BETWEEN THE STREETS AND PERMIT
HOUSING THAT WE CAN SCALE
QUICKLY. AND AFFORDABLY IT'S THE
MOST EXCITING OPTION THAT I'VE
SEEN FOR YEARS SO THAT'S ONE OF
THE REASONS WHY WE'RE REALLY
EXCITED ABOUT SUPPORTING THIS
BILL SO SB SIX THIRTY FOUR WOULD
ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING WHILE
PERMANENT HOUSING. IS UNDER
CONSTRUCTION BY DEFINING
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING IN STATUTE
BY REQUIRING OLD LOCAL AGENCIES
TO RESPOND TO A QUEST TO
DEVELOP. THE LAND FOR THIS
HOUSING TYPE AND BY CREATING A
STREAMLINED APPROVAL PROCESS BY
ASKING A CD TO DEVELOP- AND
REVIEW BUILDING CODES TO
EXPEDITE THE CONSTRUCTION OF
THESE UNITS. FOR THESE REASONS
THE BARE COUNCILS A PROUD CO
SPONSOR THE BILL AND WE
RESPECTFULLY. ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU. THANKS BAKER.
GOOD AFTERNOON ROSS BUCKLEY ON
BEHALF OF SACRAMENTO- DALE
STAMBERG IN SUPPORT. MY CLAIM
WAS BURKE CO SPONSOR IN STRONG
SUPPORT. STEVEN CENTER WITH
BROWN SEEN ON BEHALF OF THE
HOUSING ACTION COALITION IN
SUPPORT. OKAY ADDITIONAL-
SUPPORT IN THE ROOM. THIRTY NINE
ANY OPPOSITION IN THE ROOM
PLEASE COMPORT. SERVER CONFIGURE
THE OWN DISCOVER ONE THING THANK
YOU. THANK YOU FOR WORKING WITH
US ON AMENDMENTS SOME TRULY
APPRECIATE OF THE COLLABORATION
HE'LL BE TAKING THOSE AMENDMENTS
IN THE NEXT COMMITTEE OF IN
FINANCE YEAH. I JUST WANT TO
CLARIFY. EXPERTS THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS- STANDING
HERE SHOT JOHNSON- REPRESENTING
PALETTE SHELTERS- SPECTRALLY IN
REGRETTABLY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
BILL SB SIX THIRTY FOUR- IN
THROUGH THIS BILL WOULD NORMALLY
BE SOMETHING THAT A COMPANY LIKE
POUT WHICH SUPPORT- BECAUSE WE
STAND TO BENEFIT FROM SUCH A
BILL IN ITS LANGUAGE. BY RIGHT
ACCESS TO SURPLUS LAND FOR THE
INTENT OF INCREASING SHELTER AND
NON CONGREGATE NAVIGATION CENTER
STOCK WOULD BE AN INVALUABLE
RESOURCE AND COMBATING
HOMELESSNESS. WE HAVE BUILT OVER
ONE HUNDRED NINE CONGREGATE
EMERGENCY SHELTER AND
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING SITES OVER
FORTY OF THOSE ARE IN CALIFORNIA
WE HAVE A DEEP UNDERSTANDING OF
WHAT IS WORKING AND WHAT'S NOT
IN RESPONDING TO THIS CRISIS AS
WELL AS WERE THE BEST INVEST
RESOURCES TO ENSURE WE
EFFECTIVELY. AND RAPIDLY GET TO
THE APPROPRIATE GOAL MORE
PERMANENT AFFORDABLE HOUSING
THAT IS ACCESSIBLE TO ALL.
PHYSICS IN MIND POT CANNOT
SUPPORT SB SIX THIRTY FOR THE
SIGNIFICANTLY AMENDED TO INCLUDE
GUARDRAILS FOR THE FOLLOWING
ISSUES. FURTHER CLARIFICATION OF
THE PROCESS FOR SURPLUS LAND
IDENTIFICATION UTILIZATION OF
THESE PUBLIC RESOURCES FAIR
PROCESSES FOR ACCESS AND
ULTIMATE LONG TERM STRATEGY.
PACIFICATION LANGUAGE THAT
PREVENTS DEVELOPERS FROM BEING
ABLE TO CHARGE RENT OPPORTUNITY
HOUSING PROJECTS. REQUIREMENT OF
DETAILED RELOCATION PLAN FOR
RESIDENTS THAT MAY BE ASKED TO
RELOCATE FROM ONE THESE SITES.
SHOULD THE OPPORTUNITY HOUSING
PROJECT NEED TO BE RECALL
RELOCATED FOR ANY REASON.
REQUIREMENT OF DETAILED PLAN FOR
COLLABORATION WITH LOCAL
STAKEHOLDERS TO ENSURE COMMUNITY
ADOPTION AND ENGAGEMENT WITH
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING SITES WITH
THE ATTEMPT TO PRIORITIZE
PLACEMENT OF RESIDENTS INTO
PERMANENT HOUSING. HOW DOES NOT
A SUBSTITUTE FOR PERMANENT
HOUSING. THIS BILL AS CURRENTLY
WRITTEN PROVIDES TOO MANY
LOOPHOLES FOR DEVELOPERS TO
AGGRESSIVELY ACCESS LAN FOR
DESIRED MODELS WITHOUT FOUGHT TO
ENFORCEABILITY AND
IMPLEMENTATION PROVISIONS. THAT
ENSURE EFFECTIVE REHABILITATION
RESIDENTS THAT WOULD BE LIVING
IN THE SITES ADDITIONALLY
INTERMENT TRANSITIONAL HOUSING
FACTS SHOULD BE LOW COST EASY TO
DEPLOY AND MINIMIZE RESOURCE
DISTRACTION. FROM INCREASING
PERMIT HOUSING SUPPLY. HOW WILL
BE OPEN TO SUPPORTING SB SIX
THIRTY FOUR SHOULD SIGNIFICANT
AMENDMENTS TO BE TO ADDRESS
THESE ISSUES AND CONCERNS. IN
TERM SOLUTIONS TO SERVE AS A
STARTING POINT ALLOWING SOMEONE
THE ABILITY TO STABILIZE WHILE
THEY WAIT FOR PERMANENT HOUSING
TO BECOME AVAILABLE. WE MUST
EMBRACE ALTERNATIVE INTERMODAL
SO FAR STREETS NOT CONTINUE TO
SERVICE WAITING ROOMS FOR
HOUSING. WE MUST ALSO BE VERY
CAREFUL TO PROVIDE THESE
INTERMODAL WITH THE APPROPRIATE
OVERSIGHT TO ENSURE THE SAFETY
IN CARE OF THE RESIDENTS WHO
BENEFIT FROM THIS MODEL. IN THIS
SPIRIT PLEASE CONSIDER THESE
AMENDMENTS I RESPECTFULLY URGE A
NO VOTE UNLESS AMENDED. THANKS
FOR YOUR- GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRMAN REYES ON A LAWLER HERE
TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN THE
PUBLIC INTEREST LAW PROJECT BOTH
STATEWIDE LEGAL SERVICE
ORGANIZATIONS. THAT REPRESENT
THE INTERESTS OF LOOK VERY LOW
INCOME CALIFORNIANS INCLUDING
THOSE EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
. ALL THE WORK THAT'S BEEN DONE
ON THE BILL THUS FAR-
REGRETTABLY THOUGH WE MUST
REMAIN OPPOSED UNTIL A NUMBER OF
OUTSTANDING ISSUES HAVE BEEN
ADDRESSED WE HAVE NO. ISSUE WITH
THIS MODEL OF HOUSING IN GENERAL
TINY HOME TYPE DEVELOPMENTS THAT
PROVIDE NON CONGREGATE SHELTER
ON AN INTERIM BASIS. OFFERING
SERVICES AND OTHER SUPPORTS CAN
BE AN IMPORTANT COMPONENT OF A
COMMUNITY'S EFFORTS TO
TRANSITION HOUSE TO INDIVIDUALS
TO STABLE PERMANENT HOUSING.
UNFORTUNATELY WE'VE SEEN
NUMEROUS EXAMPLES OF THIS TYPE
OF DEVELOPMENT LOCATED IN FAR
FLUNG AREAS THAT ARE
INACCESSIBLE TO PUBLIC
TRANSPORTATION DAILY NECESSITIES
AND JOBS. MORE ALARMINGLY WE'VE
SEEN INSTANCES WHERE THESE
DEVELOPMENTS HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED
RAPIDLY NOT BECAUSE OF ANY
URGENCY TO PROVIDE HUMANE
SERVICE NIGHT SHELTER FOR THE
RESIDENTS. BUT AS A WAY TO
JUSTIFY SWEEPS. CONDITIONS AND
SOME OF HIS DEVELOPMENTS WHICH
ARE NONE THAT ARE OPERATED BY
THE SPONSOR I SHOULD NOTE. EVERY
SIGNIFICANT FAIR HOUSING AND
HUMANITARIAN CONCERNS STATE LAW
ALREADY PROVIDES A NUMBER OF
OPPORTUNITIES FOR BY RIGHT
APPROVAL OF THIS TYPE OF
HOUSING- IF IT'S LOW BARRIER AND
CONSISTENT WITH HOUSING FIRST
PRINCIPLES INAPPROPRIATELY
LOCATED. HOUSING ON A LAW
REQUIRES ALL JURISDICTIONS TO DO
AN IN DEPTH ANALYSIS OF THEIR
NEED FOR INCOME HOUSING TYPES IN
PERMANENT HOUSING TYPES FOR
PEOPLE EXPERIENCING
HOMELESSNESS. AND THEY HAVE TO
DESIGNATE AS OWNERS OWNS WHERE
THESE TYPES OF USES CAN. CAN BE
LOCATED BY RIGHT HAND. THAT
THOSE DON'T HAVE SUFFICIENT
ADEQUATE SITES TO ACCOMMODATE
THE JURISDICTIONS ENTIRE NEED
FOR THAT TYPE OF HOUSING.
ADDITIONALLY THANKS TO YOUR WORK
MISTER CHAIR- LITERARY
NAVIGATION CENTERS ARE ALSO USED
BY RIGHT A IN VARIOUS TOWNS- IN
HOUSING CAN UTILIZE THESE TOOLS
ALREADY. BUT IF THE BILL'S
PROPONENTS BELIEVE THAT'S
UNCLEAR WE HAVE NO OBJECTION TO
CLARIFYING THAT HOWEVER. IF THE
GOAL IS TO EXPAND BY RIGHT
OPPORTUNITIES TO ADDITIONAL
LOCATIONS IT MUST BE CLEAR THAT
THE SAME STANDARDS APPLY BOTH IN
TERMS OF LOCATION AND TREATMENT
OF RESIDENTS. WE PROVIDED THE
AUTHOR WAS SPECIFIC STATUTORY
LANGUAGE ADDRESS THESE CONCERNS
AS WELL AS TO CLARIFY. THAT
OPPORTUNITY HOUSING IS NOT
PERMANENT HOUSING. AND TO ENSURE
THAT OPPORTUNITY HOUSING
PROPONENTS PROACTIVELY DEVELOP
RELOCATION. PLANS TO MINIMIZE
DISRUPTIONS RESIDENTS GIVEN THE
LIKELIHOOD. THAT THESE TEMP
HOUSING PROJECTS WILL
EVENTUALLY. SHOULD THE MOMENT
FOR TODAY WE LOOK FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR AND
SPONSORS TO MAKE THESE NEEDED
CHANGES THANK YOU. THANKS FOR
YOUR- I. THINK BECAUSE THE ON
BEHALF WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
POVERTY WOULD LIKE TO LEARN OUR
COMMENTS WITH. SALLY F. AND
PALETTE THANK YOU. THANKS FOR
YOUR- CHRIS MARTIN ON BEHALF OF
HOUSING CALIFORNIA RESPECTFUL
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED FOR THE
REASON SAID ABOUT THE PREVIOUS
SPEAKERS THANKS. THANK YOU FOR
ANY ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION
COMMENT IN THE HEARING ROOM.
SITTING DOWN WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES WITH A MODERATOR
PLEASE QUEUE UP ALL TELEPHONIC-
TESTIMONY BOTH SUPPORT AND
OPPOSE. PARTS PLEASE AND ONCE
AGAIN. WE SHOULD MAKE A COMMENT
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION THE PRESS
ONE IF YOU'RE A- BILL WITH THE
LINE SEVENTY SEVEN. PLEASE GO
AHEAD. YES HI THIS IS BLOOD LEE
ENG AND I HEALTH MEMBER. THE
FIFTY UP BY ALSO IN AT. WHAT
ELSE. SB. SIX THIRTY THIRTY. CAN
YOU HEAR ME WHAT EXIT ON THE
WIND. TWO GOOD AFTERNOON PROP UP
ON THE FIELD ON BEHALF OF THE A
B. AND SEVENTEEN FAIRLY.
CHAPTERS AND- PART ACROSS THE
STATE IN SUPPORT OF THIS MARKET
. THAT COULD BE ON THE LINE
NINETY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
MEMBERS OF THE LEAD SHOT HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF THE LEADER
AND ALSO ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA FACULTY ASSOCIATION
BOARD. THANK YOU. WITH ON THE
LINE NINETY SEVEN PLEASE GO
AHEAD. BY THE CONTROL MORE
NUMBER. ASIAN ARMIES THE GOAL
AND WE SUPPORT SB SIX THIRTY
FOUR THANK YOU. ACTUALLY ON THE
LINE NINETY FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD
. FILE GANDHI CALLING FROM
CONNECT HOME WE ARE IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL AND LOOKING FOR A
COPY. IT'LL BOOKIE REGION THAT
WE PROVIDE. ACTUALLY GOING TO
BLIND ONE HUNDRED PLEASE GO
AHEAD. AFTERNOON REPORTER THE
CORPORATION FOR SUPPORTIVE
HOUSING- AND WE RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSE THE BILL ONLINE AT.
ACTUALLY ON THE LINE NINETY
EIGHT THOUGH AT. HELLO MY NAME
IS AROUND ME NOT THAT THE FORTY
FIVE PRESIDENT OF PROGRAMS OUR
COMMUNITY FORWARD AT AT AND I AM
HERE TO SUPPORT THE BILL IN THE
INDIAN HOME FOR WOMEN ACROSS
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU. EXPERT ON
THE LINE NINETY SIX PLEASE GO
AHEAD. HI KELLY MAKER HI THIS IS
KELLY TONIGHT- I'M A PROFESSOR
AT TENNESSEE STATE UNIVERSITY
AND I'M ALSO A MISSING MIDDLE
HOUSING DEVELOPER I AM STRONGLY
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK
YOU. THAT COULD BE GOING TO LINE
ONE OH TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE
OF TO YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HELLO
THIS IS ALL PRETTY CLOSE BY MHE
ASSISTANT DISTRICT ATTORNEY
RETIRED FOR SANTA BARBARA
COUNTY. AND I AM STRONGLY IN
FAVOR OF THIS BUILT. ACTUALLY ON
THE LINE NINETY FOUR PLEASE GO
AHEAD. THIS IS YOUR BAPTIZING
BURKE I AM DIRECTOR AND IT'S SIX
SEVEN OF THE ETHICS THAT ALLEY
WATER DISTRICT. SANTA CLARA
COUNTY I THINK MY OWN BEHALF.
THANK YOU KNOW THAT ARE HARD
WORK HE ABOUT HAVING AN OUT AND
I QUIT THE BILL YEAH. ON THE
LINE FIFTIES PLEASE AHEAD. YEAH
I WANTED TO MAKE SURE YOU
REGISTER MY THE PARTS OF THE
BILL THE NETMEETING. CITY OF FOX
THANK YOU. THERE'S CURRENTLY NO
ONE ELSE IN THE QUEUE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH AROUND BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS COLLEAGUES CENTER LOOKS
FOR AN ANGLOPHONE OR- THANK YOU-
I APPRECIATE THIS BILL SENATOR
THANK YOU FOR INTRODUCING IT I
THINK THAT IT'S QUITE CREATIVE
AND THE REALITY IS THAT WE RUN
INTO SO MUCH RIGIDITY AROUND OUR
CODES OR TRYING TO SOLVE THE
HOMELESSNESS PROBLEM- THAT I
THINK. FIGURING OUT WAYS TO
BUILD MORE HOUSING MORE QUICKLY
AT ALL LEVELS IS JUST CRITICAL
AND I KNOW THAT IN MY ROLE IN
LOCAL GOVERNMENT I RAN DOWN THE
RABBIT HOLE OF TRYING TO FIGURE
OUT HOW TO DO TINY HOMES AND YOU
RUN INTO THERE ARE FEES AND WHAT
ABOUT THE VEHICLE CODE AND WHAT
ABOUT ALL THESE OTHER
REQUIREMENTS AND IN THE END.
THERE SO YOU'RE SO BOXED INTO
WHAT YOU CAN DO THAT YOU DON'T
END UP DOING ANYTHING AND SO YOU
KNOW I AM IT'S OKAY WITH ME IF
WE CONSIDER DIFFERENT WAYS OF
EVEN CHARGING RIGHT LIKE WE HAVE
FARM STANDS AT SAY PAY WHAT YOU
CAN. WE HAVE DIFFERENT WAYS OF
THINKING ABOUT HOW HOW ARE
PEOPLE PARTICIPATING IN LIVING
HERE MAYBE THERE ARE WAYS THEY
CAN WORK MAYBE THERE ARE
DIFFERENT THINGS THAT. THAT THAT
I'M NOT OPPOSED TO SOMETHING TO
DO WITH RENT. AND ALSO I JUST
WANT TO SAY THAT IN MY MIND I
ALWAYS THINK WHAT IS THE
ALTERNATIVE. AND SO WHEN WE'RE
CONCERNED ABOUT. THINGS YOU
THINK ABOUT ENCAMPMENTS LIKE
WHAT WHAT HAPPENED THERE THERE
ARE SO MANY ISSUES AROUND.
SAFETY AND SANITATION AND
STAFFED AND ENVIRONMENTAL
DEGRADATION AND HUMAN
TRAFFICKING. ALL OF THESE
PROBLEMS THAT ARE PRINT THAT ARE
IN OUR EXISTING ENCAMPMENTS.
THAT HAVING SOMETHING NOT HAPPEN
BECAUSE FOR EXAMPLE THERE ARE
PROTECTIONS THAT ENSURE
RESIDENTS DO NOT EXIT BACK INTO
HOMELESSNESS OR TEMPORARY
SHELTER. I MEAN THAT'S LIKE SUCH
A HIGH BARRIER THAT IT JUST
SEEMS COMPLETELY UNREASONABLE TO
ME SO I DO VERY MUCH HOPE THAT
THIS BILL. MAKES IT ALL THE WAY
THROUGH AND THAT IT'S NOT SO
CONSTRAINED THAT IT ACTUALLY
ENDS UP RESULTING IN NOTHING
BEING BUILT. BECAUSE THERE'S
REALLY GREAT OPPORTUNITY HERE
AND I'M REALLY EXCITED TO SEE
WHAT SOME OF THESE CREATIVE.
THINGS COME PROVIDE OUR STATE
THANK YOU. THANK YOU CENTER
COULD IT. THANK YOU. THE THANK
YOU FOR BRINGING FORWARD TO. A
COULD BE IN. IT'S A BOLD BILL I
THINK IT'S SENSE BUT- I WANT TO
NOTE. IN IT I DIDN'T SEE IT IN
THE IN THE LEGISLATIVE HISTORY
MAYBE JUST BECAUSE- ONE OF THE
REFER TO OUR DISTRICT BILLS AT
THE TIME BUT- SOMEONE THAT YOU
KNOW WELL FROM. THE SANTA CLARA
VALLEY FROM SILICON VALLEY-
FORMER ASSEMBLYMEMBER NOR
COUPLES TODAY. A DISTRICT BILL
THAT- ALLOWED CITY OF SAN JOSE
BY RIGHT- TO DO THIS WORK. OVER
THREE YEAR PERIOD AND- THERE
WERE THERE WAS THERE WAS NO
THERE WERE NO NEGATIVE
REPERCUSSIONS FOR- THAT I KNOW
OF- IN IN FACT TO THE EXTENT
THAT THE COUNTY THEN. AND I
DON'T REMEMBER THE AUTHOR. MIMIC
THAT BILL- SO THE SANTA CLARA
COUNTY WOULD HAVE A BY RIGHT
OPTION- IS WELL- I THINK- IT
DOESN'T GET RID OF SOME OF THE
ISSUES THAT. ARE OUT THERE THANK
YOU TO WHERE YOU ACTUALLY COME
UP WITH WITH THE SITES AND SO
FORTH- BUT- I'M GLAD YOU'RE HERE
PUSHING FORWARD WITH THIS AND- I
HOPE TO SEE IT AGAIN IN THE
FUTURE IT SOUNDS LIKE. FROM WHAT
I'VE READ THE REPORT VERY
CLOSELY WITH THE COMMITTEE TO
TRY TO- GET THE BILL IN BETTER-
BUT I DID WANT YOU TO KNOW- IT
MAY BE WORTH GOING BACK LOOKING
AT THE LEGISLATIVE HISTORY TO-
TO HELP PITCH THE BILL IN THE
FUTURE BECAUSE- AS I SAID- THERE
WAS REALLY NO DOWNSIDE TO THOSE
PROGRAMS I WAS A COUNTY
SUPERVISOR AT THE TIME AND- YOU
KNOW AND I HAPPEN TO KNOW THAT.
FROM THE A PETITION WAS NOT A
PROBLEM. THANK YOU. THANK MISTER
. OKAY- SO I DON'T WANT I WANT
TO THANK YOU IN FOR WORKING WITH
THE COMMITTEES AND WAYS I THINK
THE CRITICISM GOOD- AMENDMENTS-
YOU'RE ONE OF ONE OF THE- ISSUES
OF EXPRESSED TO HIS DIGNITY
MOVES IS A SUPERB ORGANIZATIONAL
STUDIES JUST FANTASTIC WORK- IN
THE BAY AREA AND SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA. BUT OF COURSE WE
HAVE TO DESIGN A BILL IT'S GOING
TO PLAY ALL OPERATORS NOT ALL
OPERATORS ARE OF THE SAME
CALIBER- SICKENING MOVES I WISH
THEY ALL. WERE BUT WERE LIVING.
IN IN A WORLD WHERE THERE'S
VARIETY OF- QUALITY- BUT I THINK
THIS IS A STRONG- BILLS I.
COMMUTERS HEADING HEADING IN A
POSITIVE DIRECTION I KNOW YOU'LL
CONTINUE. TO ENGAGE WITH THE
OPPONENTS AND- WE CAN DO. I MEAN
HAVE MY SO- AND I PRETTY YOU
WORK WITH US- SO IT'S- YOU CLOSE
. THANK YOU I. ALL THE COMMENTS
HE ON- WE'VE HAD PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATIONS WITH MOST FOLKS
SPOKE HERE TODAY SOME OF THE-
RECENT COMMENTS CAME IN MORE
RECENTLY BUT I'M HAPPY TO LOOK
AT THEM AS WELL AND- AND-
CONSIDER THOSE- AS WELL BUT-
YEAH I THINK IS KNOWN HE'S
REMINDED HERE YOU KNOW PEOPLE
ARE. ARE LIVING ON THE STREETS
AND DYING ON THE STREETS NOW
EVERY DAY AND WE NEED TO DO
MORE. THAT WE DON'T LET THE
PERFECT BE THE ENEMY GOOD ON
THEIR HAND WE DO YOU WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT. WE ARE PUTTING
GUARDRAILS UP AND YOU SAID MAKE
SURE THAT- WE ARE ACCOUNTING FOR
THE FACT THAT YEAH THAT BE YOU
KNOW WITH ALL OPERATORS- IN THE
FUTURE. WHO MAY WANT TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THIS. THANK YOU
TARGETED YOUR FOR YOUR REMINDER
WE'LL LOOK INTO THAT HISTORY- AS
WELL- AREA AND- THE- YEAH JUST
AT THE I THINK. ALL WHO CALLED
IN REALLY EXCITED. ABOUT THE
POTENTIAL FOR THIS TO BOTH SCALE
UP FAST. AND INEXPENSIVE BUT
ALSO HIGH QUALITY. AND THAT'S
WHAT DREW ME TO THIS WHAT I AM
REALLY EXCITED ABOUT THIS IN OUR
STRIDE FOR STRIDE VOTE. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH- CAN I HAVE A-
MOTION TO- THIS BILL PASSED TO
THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE SOME OF THIS MOVE BY
CENTER PLACE. WILL CALL THE ROLL
. SENATOR WIENER. WIENER HI THE
TROUBLED LAKE SUPERIOR. PLEASE
VERIFY CARRERO CORTEZ HE-
PRETENDS HE BY REQUIRE PADILLA
SEYARTO SKINNER AABERG WILL HELP
. OKAY WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL
THANK VERY MUCH AND- OKAY- I DO
SEE OTHER- AUTHOR TO ON THE
COMMITTEE SO CENTER BLAKE'S
PAYER HEALTH BUT WE- AND A YEAR
SECOND BILL THIS WILL BE ITEM
NINE. THAT'S. FOUR EIGHTY TWO.
OKAY THANK YOU THIS ONE SHOULD
BE SHORTER THAN THE FIRST ONE-
SO THANK YOU TO THE CHAIR AND
COLLEAGUES AND STAFF. TODAY I
PRESENT SB FOUR EIGHTY TWO WHICH
REQUIRES EACH CD TO OFFER
CAPITALIZED OPERATING SUBSIDY
RESERVES OTHERWISE CALLED
COASTERS TO SPECIAL NEEDS UNIT
IT'S FUNDED THROUGH THE MULTI
FAMILY HOUSING PROGRAM. COASTERS
ARE IMPORTANT BECAUSE IF GRANTED
THEY SET ASIDE UP FRONT MONEY TO
COVER FIFTEEN TO TWENTY YEARS
WORTH OF DEFICITS IN ANNUAL
OPERATING REVENUES FOR HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTS MAKING EASIER FOR
THE DEVELOPMENTS TO GET FINANCED
AND BUILT. SB FOUR EIGHTY TWO
EXTENDS COASTERS WHICH ARE USED
BY EIGHT CD AND OTHER STATE
AGENCIES FOR HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTS TO SPECIAL NEEDS
UNITS FUNDED THROUGH AN H. P. BY
DOING SO AND ENSURE THAT
DEVELOPMENT SERVING ANNOUNCED
INDIVIDUALS WITH LITTLE OR NO
INCOME AND THE GREATEST NEEDS.
CAN MORE EASILY BE BUILT. STILL
NEEDS UNITS ARE CRUCIAL IN
HELPING PEOPLE WHO ARE HOMELESS
ADDRESS PERSONAL HEALTH OR
SUBSTANCE ABUSE PROBLEMS WHERE
TO GET OTHER HELP THEY NEED.
THESE UNITS OFTEN OFFER CASE
MANAGEMENT MEDICAL AND MENTAL
HEALTH CARE SUBSTANCE ABUSE
TREATMENT AND EMPLOYMENT
SERVICES AMONG OTHER RESOURCES
THIS IS AN ESSENTIAL ELEMENT AND
HELPING TO TRANSITION SOME OF
THE MOST VULNERABLE CALIFORNIANS
OUT OF HOMELESSNESS. BY SIMPLY
PROVIDING COASTERS FOR SPECIAL
NEEDS UNITS SB FOUR EIGHTY TWO
ENSURES THAT THE MULTI FAMILY
HOUSING PROGRAM CAN MORE
ADEQUATELY FUND HOUSING
DEVELOPMENTS THAT SERVE HOMELESS
INDIVIDUALS WITH THE LEAST
INCOME AND THE GREATEST NEED.
WITH ME HERE TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT IS ANDREW DAWSON FROM
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
PARTNERSHIP AND AMBERLEY LESLIE
FROM HOUSING CALIFORNIA. HELLO
I'M ANDREW DAWSON THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP THE
PARTNERSHIP IS A PRIVATE
NONPROFIT THOSE ACTUALLY CREATED
BY THE STATE IN NINETEEN EIGHTY
EIGHT- FOR THE PRESERVATION AND
CREATION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
FOR LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS. I'M
HERE TO TESTIFY ON SB FOUR
EIGHTY TO. A BILL THAT REQUIRES
A CITY TO OFFER CLOSER SIR
CAPITALIZE OFFERING SUBSIDY
RESERVES. FOR IN THE IMAGE P.
PROGRAM M. S. P. PROGRAM IS THE
STATE'S FLAGSHIP RENTAL HOUSING
PROGRAM THAT LAST YEAR HAS.
ALLOCATED HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS
OF DOLLARS FOR AFFORDABLE
HOUSING- SERIES ON. TOOL IN OUR
TOOL KIT. TO CREATE SUPPORTIVE
HOUSING WHICH CAN BE WITH SOME
OF THE MOST DIFFICULT HOUSING TO
FINANCE AND BUILD. THIS IS
BECAUSE IT PAIRS HOUSING WITH
SERVICES FOR SOME OF US MOST
VIABLE POPULATIONS LIKE ELI
COMMUNITIES EXTREMELY LOW
INCOME. AS WELL AS FORMALLY
HOMELESS HOUSEHOLDS. THIS IS
HARD BECAUSE WE HAVE LIMITED
RENTAL INCOME DUE TO SERVING
THESE COMMUNITIES. AS WELL AS
HIGHER OPERATING COSTS BECAUSE
YOU WANT TO PROVIDE THE SERVICES
FOR THESE COMMUNITIES TO THRIVE
. COASTERS ARE IMPORTANT TOOL
THAT ALLOWED DEVELOPERS TO. DRAW
MONEY FROM. WITH A CD APPROVAL
IN ORDER TO FILL IN GAPS FOR
OPERATING EXPENSES THE BILL
ANALYSIS HAS A GREAT EXAMPLE OF
ONE IN ONE OF THE COMMENTS- WE
WANT TO ENSURE THAT THIS TOOL IS
MAINTAINED RIGHT NOW IT CITY
DOES PROVIDE CO SUSAN THE NO
PLACE LIKE HOME. AND VETERANS
HOUSING HOMELESS PREVENTION
PROGRAM HOWEVER THE THIS FUNDING
IS RUNNING OUT. AND TO ENSURE
THIS TOOL IS AVAILABLE AND THESE
PEOPLE- GRAHAM WHICH THE
FLAGSHIP PROGRAM. WITH THIS I'D
LIKE TO URGE IN HIGH VOTE- AND
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THIS SUPPORT. THANK YOU MISS
CHAIRMAN SENATOR BLIX- I WON'T
ELABORATE TOO MUCH ON THE
COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE AGAIN
I'M AMBERLEY LESLIE WITH HOUSING
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE ADVOCATE.
WE SUPPORT THIS BILL- BUT WE
WORK AT THE INTERSECTION OF
HOUSING AND HOMELESSNESS AND A
LOT OF THE PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE
HOUSING PROVIDERS THAT WE WORK
WITH ARE. VERY CONCERNED ABOUT
THE INCREASING COSTS JUST TO
OPERATE IN GENERAL- AND SO THIS
PROVIDE SOME FLEXIBILITY UP
FRONT FOR THEM TO PROVIDE THOSE
CRITICAL SERVICES TO. SOME OF
THE MOST VULNERABLE POPULATIONS
THAT HOUSING PROVIDERS SERVE SO-
WITH THAT WE ALSO RESPECTFULLY
URGE RIVAL THANK YOU. NICOLO DA
OKAY HERE BEHALF OF NONPROFIT
HOUSING OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
SUPPORT THANK YOU. AMBER
MEDICINE FROM THE CALIFORNIA
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
. BRING A LIGHT WITH THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM IN
SUPPORT. VERY VISUAL SUPPORT
COMMENT IN THE HEARING ROOM.
SITTING NINE IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION IN THE HEARING ROOM.
EMAIL WILL GO TO THE PHONE
LINES- THE MODERATOR PLEASE
QUEUE UP BOTH SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION. FIRST IN GERMAN
WHICH IS COMMON IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION PLEASE PRESS ONE
ZERO. WE GOING TO LINE SEVENTY
TWO PLEASE GO AT. NEW MEMBERS
WELCOME HELD THE PMB ACTION.
GOING IN THE- OR- ON BEHALF OF
THE ACTION AND ARE IN JAIL AT
HAND PARTNER THE TRUMP WITH THE
THANK YOU FOR. SEE. CURRENTLY NO
ONE ELSE IN THE QUEUE. THANK YOU
RESIST COMMENTING THAT I- ALWAYS
AUTOMATICALLY LOOK UP WHEN I
ASKED THE MODERN OPERATOR TO
KEEP PEOPLE OFF I DON'T KNOW WHY
I LOOK OUT TODAY I LOOK UP. OKAY
WILL BE ABOUT TO COMMIT ANY OR-
OKAY SO OKAY MOTIONS- BY SENATOR
CORTEZ THE TO PASS A BILL TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS- YOU
MAY CLOSE. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR ANOTHER THANK YOU OKAY OUR
MOTION AND WE WILL CALL THE ROLL
. ANOTHER WINNER WINNER I HAVE A
TROUBLED FLICKS HERE HI THANKS
FOR KABIRU CORTEZ HE- IT HAS A
HI MCGUIRE THE DEUS HERE TO
SKINNER ON BERGEN WILL HOLD.
STRICKLAND WE'LL PUT THAT ON ALL
- AND I WILL NOW AS CENTER COURT
. TO ITEM FOR A. SEVEN FORTY
FIVE. PRESIDENT. THE YOU MISTER
MEMBERS- I'M HERE TO PRESENT SB
SEVEN FOUR FIVE THE DROP.
BUILDINGS ACT. A TWO PROJECT
WATER SHORTAGES IN CALIFORNIA
THE GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE JUST
BE SOME FORTY FIVE DIRECTS THE
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT HOUSING AND
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT IN THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING STANDARDS
COMMISSION. TO RESEARCH DEVELOP
ADOPT APPROVED CODIFIED AND
PUBLISHED VOLUNTARY MANDATORY
BUILDING STANDARDS TO REDUCE
POTABLE WATER USE IN NEW
NONRESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS. THE
BILL ALSO REQUIRES BOTH THE CITY
AND THE BUILDING STANDARDS
COMMISSION TO REVIEW AND UPDATE
THE WATER EFFICIENCY IN WATER
REUSE STANDARDS IN THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING STANDARDS
CODE EVERY THREE YEARS. THE
SCIENCES PROJECT THE AVERAGE
WATER SUPPLY FROM SNOW PACK WILL
DECLINE TO TWO THIRDS OF
HISTORICAL LEVELS BY TWENTY
FIFTY. A BECAUSE BUILDING STAY
IN USE FOR THIRTY TWO ONE
HUNDRED YEARS BEFORE THE
REPLACED- IT'S VERY VERY
IMPORTANT TO CALIFORNIA THE
PREPARE FOR THE REALITIES OF
CLIMATE CHANGE BY REDUCING. THE
DESIGN POTABLE WATER DEMAND OF
NEW BUILDINGS NOW. THE VERSION
BEFORE YOU TODAY INCLUDES
AMENDMENT SO WE NEGOTIATED WITH
THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION IN ORDER TO ENSURE
THAT WE HAVE A BILL DO SUPPORT
THIS BILL IN KEY TO THOSE
MEMBERS FOR MAKING SURE THAT ANY
NEW VOLUNTARY MANDATORY
STANDARDS ARE DEVELOPED. THROUGH
THE NORMAL STATE BUILDING
STANDARDS CODE ADOPTION PROCESS
WHICH PROVIDES ALL STAKEHOLDERS
AN OPPORTUNITY PARTICIPATE IN
PROVIDE THEIR EXPERTISE. I'M
HERE TO TELL IN SUPPORT AND ANY
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS SO WE HAVE
SCOTT WHICH IS COMMON SENSE WILL
FROM CALPERS THE PIPE TRADES
COUNCIL. THANK YOU THANK YOU AND
CENTER I APOLOGIZE IF I IF I
MISSED THIS BUT ARE YOU YOU'RE
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEES
AMENDMENTS YES OKAY THANK YOU
FOR WORKING WITH US IN THAT
REGARD. THANK YOU FOR WORKING
WITH ME APPRECIATE IT SO.
OFFICERS THANK YOU .COM MENTAL.
ALSO HERE TODAY BEHALF OF THE
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
PLUMBING AND MECHANICAL
OFFICIALS AYE AT MALL WHICH
REPRESENT ALL THE PLUMBING
OFFICIALS. IN CALIFORNIA AS WELL
AS PUBLISHERS THE COMPANY
PLUMBING CODE. CALIFORNIA IS
EXPECTED TO GROUP POPULATION IS
EXPECTED TO GROW FROM FORTY
MILLION TO SIXTY MILLION BY
TWENTY FIFTY WHAT THE SAME TIME
THE BILL THE WATERS PROJECTED TO
DECREASE BY FIFTEEN PERCENT.
THIS COMING WATER SHORTAGE NEEDS
TO BE ADDRESSED AND MULTIPLE
LEVELS BOTH YOU KNOW THROUGH
URBAN WATER USE OBJECTIVES FOR
YOU TO EXISTING USERS THAT WATER
DISTRICTS. ARE ALREADY REQUIRED
TO ESTABLISH BUT ALSO BY
REDUCING NEW WATER DEMAND FROM
NEW BUILDINGS WHICH IS WHAT THIS
LEGISLATION ADDRESSES. WERE
REACHING THE LIMIT OF WATER
SAVING TO RECONNECT IT CHEAP FOR
MORE EFFICIENT APPLIANCES. BUT
MANDATORY WATER RE USE
REQUIREMENTS. CAN SUBSTANTIALLY
REDUCED ADDITIONAL DEMAND THAT
NEW BUILDINGS CREATE. A RECENT
STUDY BY THE SAN FRANCISCO
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION THE
SIMPSONS BECAUSE ALREADY ADOPTED
SOME MANDATORY WATER REUSE
STANDARDS. THE PHONE THAT
POTABLE WATER USE CAN BE REDUCED
BY BETWEEN FIFTEEN TO THIRTY
EIGHT PERCENT. JUST TO THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF ONSITE
GREYWATER RECYCLING. IN
BUILDINGS FOR THAT MAKES SENSE.
THIS ACTUALLY SUPPORT SERVING
WATER OBJECTIVE REQUIREMENTS
IMPOSED IN WATER DISTRICTS%
BECAUSE IT REDUCES DEMAND FROM
NEW BUILDINGS MAKING IT EASIER
FOR WATER UTILITIES TO MEET
THEIR WATER USE OBJECTIVES.
BECAUSE THIS MEANS THERE'S LESS
NEW WATER TO TONY TIED DOWN A
FIGHT AND PURCHASE. SOME
OPPONENTS HAVE ALSO INACCURATELY
CLAIMED THAT SB SEVEN FORTY FIVE
IS PREMATURE BECAUSE THE STATE
WATER RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD IS
IN THE PROCESS OF UPDATING.
REGULATIONS FOR WATER QUALITY
STANDARDS FOR ONSITE TREATMENT
AND REDUCE OF NON POTABLE WATER.
HOWEVER THIS IS JUST AN UPDATE
TO EXISTING STANDARDS IT'S GOING
TO BE COMPLETED BY THE END OF
THIS YEAR. BUT THE PROCESS FOR
ADOPTING NEW VOLUNTARY MANDATORY
STANDARDS HAS TO FOLLOW THE
BUILDING STANDARDS CODE PROCESS
WHICH IS A THREE YEAR CYCLE. THE
SOONEST AT NEW MANDATORY
STANDARDS. REQUIRED UNDER THIS
BILL COULD BE. DEVELOPED AND
EFFECTIVE WOULD BE JANUARY OF
TWENTY TWENTY SIX THREE YEARS
FROM NOW BUT UNDER THIS PROCESS
THE STANDARDS HAVE TO START
BEING DEVELOPED BY NEXT YEAR. WE
DON'T PASS A BILL THIS YEAR WE
DON'T HAVE STANDARDS IN PLACE TO
ADDRESS THESE ISSUES UNTIL
TWENTY TWENTY NINE. WE NEED. TO
START THIS PROCESS NOW WHAT
WOULD YOU ASK THE AYE VOTE THANK
YOU. THANK YOU RESEARCH. MISTER
CHAIRMAN MEMBER SCOTT WHICH ON
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA STATE PIPE
TRADES COUNCIL. I'M HERE ON B.
THE BRITISH COUNCIL'S WILL IT
PROBABLY ONE OF THE SPONSORS
LEGISLATION SB SEVEN FORTY FIVE
ADDRESSES. THE BRIDGE THAT
PROJECTED WATER SHORTAGES THAT
THE AUTHOR MENTIONED DUE TO
CLIMATE CHANGE BY REQUIRING THE
ADOPTION BUILDING STANDARDS TO
REDUCE THE DESIGN POTABLE WATER
DEMAND OF NEW BUILDINGS. WE'VE
WORKED WITH THE BUILDING
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION IS BEYOND
ME THAT ANYBODY OUTSIDE THE
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY. IT
OPPOSE. HAVING THE BUILDING
STANDARDS COMMISSION MAKE
BUILDINGS MORE WATER EFFICIENT-
STILL AND WRAP MY HEAD AROUND
THAT. ALSO DIRECTS THE BUILDING
STANDARDS COMMISSION DEVELOP
MODEL ORDINANCE LANGUAGE AND
GUIDANCE TO STREAMLINE LOCAL
IMPLEMENTATION. OF WATER CODE
SECTION THIRTEEN FIVE FIVE EIGHT
WHICH ALLOWS BUILDERS TO INSTALL
ONSITE TREATED NON POTABLE WATER
SYSTEMS FOR INDOOR BUILDING
WATER USE. WE'RE A LOCAL PROVE
APPROVAL PROGRAM HAS BEEN TO
ADOPTED. LET ME USE THIS EXAMPLE
SAN FRANCISCO'S DONE THIS.
SACRAMENTO HAS ADOPTED AN
ORDINANCE IF THIS BUILDING THAT
WE STAND IN TODAY. I HAD BEEN
BUILT IN SAN FRANCISCO. RATHER
THAN IN SACRAMENTO AND THE STATE
HAD CHOSEN TO FOLLOW THE SAN
FRANCISCO. BUILDING ORDINANCE.
EVERY DROP OF WATER THAT WE USE
WASHING OUR HANDS IN THE SINK
BASINS. WOULD BE. RECYCLED IN
THIS BUILDING. IN THE WATER
CLOSETS IN THE URINALS IN THE
TOILETS. JUST THAT SIMPLE.
PROCESS COULD SAVE MILLIONS OF
GALLONS OF WATER JUST IN THE
STATE CAPITOL BUILDING.
AUSTRALIA HAS BEEN DOING THIS
FOR DECADES IT'S TIME TO
CALIFORNIA CUT UP AND LEAD THE
WAY IN THE COUNTRY AND WE'D URGE
AND I'VE- THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OUR NEXT SPEAKER IN SUPPORT-
YEAH FIRST NAME ORGANIZATION OF
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS DENNIS
O'CONNOR- VOLUNTEER WITH THE
MONO LAKE COMMITTEE- ALSO AS OF
. LAST SEPTEMBER RECENTLY
RETIRED CHIEF CONSULTANT OF THE
SENATE NATURAL RESOURCES AND
WATER COMMITTEE WE NEED TO
BECOME MORE FRUGAL WITH OUR
WATER MODEL X. COMMITTEE
SUPPORTS WELCOME BACK. MISTER
CHAIR MEMBERS STILL HERE FOR
ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION WHERE AT
THE MOMENT WITH THE LANGUAGE
IMPRINTS SORTED IN BETWEEN BUT
BASED ON THE AMENDMENTS AND THE
GREAT WORK WITH THE SPONSORS ME
OFF THEIR WORK OPENED- TO GET
THEIR MOVING TO SUPPORT IN THE
NEAR FUTURE. THANK YOU THANK YOU
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT COMMON.
CREDIT SCORE WE HAVE MULTIPLE-
FORMER- COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS
AND STAFF BACK TODAY TESTIFYING
IS GREAT- WELL NOT A GOOD
OPPOSITION. GOOD AFTERNOON MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS- BETH A LOSS ON
BEHALF OF WATER REUSE CALIFORNIA
WHERE THE ASSOCIATION OF WATER
RECYCLERS IN THE STATE- THERE'S
A COALITION LETTER OF ALL THE
MAJOR WATER ASSOCIATIONS-
CIRCULATING IN OPPOSITION OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED- VERY CLEARLY WE
ARE. VERY SUPPORTIVE OF ON SITE
REVIEWS WE ARE SUPPORTIVE OF
YOUR SB NINE SIX SIX- FROM
TWENTY EIGHTEEN WE WORKED ON
THAT. ARE OUR PROBLEM IS
MANDATED ANY ONE TYPE OF WATER
USE- THAT IS OUR OUR MAJOR
CONCERN WITH THIS PIECE OF
LEGISLATION- THE STATE THROUGH
THE LEGISLATION THROUGH THE
LEGISLATURE- PAST SB SIX OF SIX
AB SIXTY SIXTY EIGHT. AND SB
ELEVEN FIFTY SEVEN TO REQUIRE
COMMUNITIES TO ESTABLISH AND
URBAN WATER USE OBJECTIVE- THAT
ALLOWS THEM TO USE THE DIFFERENT
TOOLS IN THEIR TOOLBOX WHAT
MAKES SENSE FOR THE HYDROLOGY IN
A LOCAL COMMUNITY- TO HIT THAT
URBAN WATER USE OBJECTIVE.
COMMUNITIES HAVE INVESTED
SIGNIFICANTLY- FROM SAN DIEGO-
UP TO SACRAMENTO IN CENTRALIZED
WATER RECYCLING AND IF THAT'S
THE BEST USE OF RATEPAYER FUNDS
THE NAPS YOU KNOW WHAT THEY
SHOULD BE ABLE TO DO THE TOOL
THEY SHOULD BE ABLE TO USE TO
MEET THAT URBAN WATER USE
OBJECTIVE- WE DO HAVE SOME
CONCERNS WITH THE- PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS- IT TALKS ABOUT.
BLACKWATER I DON'T THINK ANY-
HOME SHOULD BE. RECYCLING THEIR
OWN SEWAGE- THAT IS JUST WILDLY
OUT OF THE SCOPE OF SOMETHING
THAT A HOMEOWNER CAN DO- SO
THERE ARE JUST SOME TECHNICAL
THINGS THAT WE ARE. CONCERNED
WITH ON THAT SIDE BECAUSE IT'S
NOT JUST LIMITED TO COMMERCIAL I
HAVEN'T SEEN OUR AND WE'VE JUST
GOTTEN A WORD DOCUMENT OF WHAT
WE THINK THE AMENDMENTS ARE. BUT
EVERYTHING I HAVE IT SAYS BLACK
WATER MULTIPLE TIMES SO- THAT'S
A BIG CONCERN- FINALLY I MEAN WE
REALLY JUST. WANT TO FOCUS THE
COMMITTEE ON WHERE THE STATE IS
GOING WITH THIS URBAN WATER USE
OBJECTIVE AND LET THE LOCAL
COMMUNITIES IT MAKES SENSE AND
SAN FRANCISCO TO DO ON SITE
REVIEWS. IT MIGHT NOT IN SAN
DIEGO OR THE INLAND EMPIRE- AND
LET IT BE A TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX
WE ARE HAPPY WE HAVE. PUT
SIGNIFICANT FUNDING TO DEVELOP
TO DEVELOPING A MODEL ORDINANCE
WE'RE HAPPY TO DICK DEDICATE
MORE IF THERE'S THINGS THAT NEED
TO HAPPEN- TO. ALLOW LOCAL
COMMUNITIES TO DEVELOP THEIR OWN
ORDINANCES AND REGULATIONS AFTER
THE WATER BOARD DOES THEIR
PROCESS OF. ON THE WATER QUALITY
STANDARDS THANK YOU. THANK YOU-
NAME ORGANIZATION. ACTUALLY A
WHOLE WITH THE ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA WATER AGENCIES ALSO
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED LINER COMMENTS WITH BETH
FROM WATER FROM WATER USE THANK
YOU FOR YOUR- SPENCER SACKS OF
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
SANITATION AGENCIES I
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED. THANK YOU. IN A FREE
WITH THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED ALIGN MY COMMENTS WITH
WATER USE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
ANY ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION IN THE
ROOM. THREE NINE WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. BEIJING LET'S GIVE
YOU WISH TO PAY COMMON IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. ONE ZERO.
WILL BE GOING TO LINE UP ONE OH
SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD. IN THE
FUTURE MEMBERS. THAT ARE ACTIVE
CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL LABORS-
DON'T HAVE A HEART CONDITION
WELL- WE HAVE HAD THEM REALLY
WELL BUT THE PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR.
WE COULD HAVE A COUPLE OF
CONCERNS AS FAR AS THEY PERTAIN
TO- GREEN WATER CATCHMENT
SYSTEMS BUT WE LOOK FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH YOU OUT THERE AND
FIGURING THAT OUT. THANK YOU. MY
CURRENT BOOK ONE PERSON HAS JUST
QUEUE UP TO ONE ON WATER LINE.
NEXT WE'RE GOING TO LINE ONE OH
THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON ANDREA ADAMS ON THE
CALIFORNIA WILL. YOU CAN.
VERSION ON MY COMMENT. UP ONE
COMMITTEE ON THE GREAT.
CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN THE
QUEUE. OKAY WILL BRING BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS. ONE
ONE SEVEN OR ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS OKAY GREAT SENATE- I
WANT TO THANK YOU FOR WORKING
WITH US AND FOR ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEES- MEMBERS I THINK THIS
IS A- IMPORTANT BILL. IT'LL BE
CONSUMED CONTINUING
CONVERSATIONS BUT WE HAVE TO
MOVE THE DIAL ON WATER RE USE
AND- I. AM NOT INCLUDE
BLACKWATER INCLUDES EVERYTHING
AND I THINK SOMETIMES WITH WATER
RECYCLING POLICY THERE IS THIS
X. FACTOR THAT PEOPLE HAVE. WE
HAVE TO MOVE PAST THAT WE HAVE
REALLY GOOD TECHNOLOGY TO PURIFY
WATER AND THE RECYCLE AND WE'VE
DONE SO MUCH- WASTE WATER INTO
THE OCEAN AND WE NEED TO MOVE
AWAY FROM THAT- AND SO I KNOW
THAT THERE'S YOU KNOW YOU'LL
CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION WITH
THE WATER AGENCIES- BUT THIS IS
A AN IMPORTANT STEP IN
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS FOR
AND I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT AS
AMENDED- SO I CENTER BLIX FOR.
THAT COULD I JUST WANNA GO THAT
I THINK IT'S REALLY TRUE THAT WE
HAVE IT'S A GREAT SOURCE OF
WATER IS THE RECYCLING OF THE
WATER WE ALREADY HAVE INSTEAD OF
TRYING TO FIND NEW SOURCES AND
WE TREAT WATER AND PUT. NEARLY
TWO POTABLE WATER BACK INTO THE
OCEAN IN THE MILLIONS OF GALLONS
A DAY AND SO THIS IS. REALLY
IMPORTANT AND I AM GRATEFUL FOR
THE BILL. IT'LL MOVE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH- YOU MAKE. I JUST TO
THANK YOU AGAIN FOR YOUR- IN THE
COMMITTEE HELP DO THINK THE A
MEMBER SO. CLEAR IN A
RESPECTFULLY I YOUR ABOVE. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH- THE ANSWER DID
YOU MOVE THE SAID BOOKS ARE
CONCERNS MOTION TO MOVE THE BILL
AS AMENDED AND PASSED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
WILL CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WINNER. WINNER BY PATROL BOOK.
THIS IS. PERFECT A PUBLIC. THANK
CLICK HERE HI CABALLERO CORTEZ
HE- CRITTER. I IT HAS THE HI.
REQUIRE FIFTY HERE SKINNER. WILL
HOLD OKAY WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON
- ONE ELKS I SEE CENTER. IS HERE
. SO WE WILL A NUMBER. SB FIVE
NINETY SO. AND I'M GONNA HAVE TO
GO OVER TO POP SAFETY TO VOTE SO
I'M GOING TO HAND THE GOBBLED TO
CENTER TO A BOAT. BEFORE BEFORE
NO I WOULDN'T DO THIS PERSON'S
WON'T BE HERE. I'M CENTER GLAZER
AM SUPPORTING YOUR BILL AS WE
DISCUSSED AND I KNOW- THE LABORS
CAME IN WITH SOMEBODY CONCERNS
AND- I APPRECIATE YOU ENGAGE IN
THAT DIALOGUE BUT I JUST WANT
TO. INSURE THAT YOU'RE COMMITTED
TO CONTINUING DIALOGUE WITH THE
LABORS I AM OKAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH SORRY TO INTERJECT THAT
BEFORE YOU EVEN OPEN I WILL BE
BACK. SHOULD BE AN- OKAY HI THIS
IS ALICIA MAY START BY THANKING
SURE WINNER FOODS OFFERS- IN HIS
SUPPORT OF COURSE IN HIS HELP IS
AS STAFFERS. IN PRESENTING THIS
BILL TOO TODAY AT. SB FIVE
NINETY SEVEN WOULD REQUIRE THAT
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT TO CONDUCT RESEARCH.
AND PROPOSE STANDARDS TO THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING STANDARDS
COMMISSION. FOR THE MANDATORY
INSTALLATION OF RAIN WATER
CAPTURE SYSTEM A NEW HOMES. AS
CALIFORNIA CONTINUES TO DEAL
WITH THE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE
CHANGE. THE STATE MUST LOOK FOR
WAYS TO MITIGATE THE STRESS IT
HAS ON OUR WATER RESOURCES I
KNOW IT'S SOMETHING WE ALL KNOW.
A ONE STUDY RECENT STUDY BY PP I
SEE THE PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE
FOUND THAT WHILE RECREATIONAL
URBAN WATER USAGE HAS FALLEN
OVER THE PAST TWO DECADES.
LANDSCAPE WATERING MAKES UP
ROUGHLY HALF OF ALL RESIDENTIAL
AND URBAN WATER USE. ALLOWING
FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF STANDARDS
FOR THESE TYPES OF DEVICES CAN
INCREASE THE STATE'S CAPTURE
ABILITY DURING PERIODS OF HIGH
PERSON. PRECIPITATION BY WHAT
WE'VE SEEN THIS WINTER AND
DECREASE RELIANCE ON EXISTING
WATER RESOURCES DURING PERIODS
OF DROUGHT. THERE OTHER CITIES
IN THE UNITED STATES SUCH AS
TUCSON ARIZONA AND SANTA FE NEW
MEXICO THAT ALREADY HAVE
MANDATES FOR RAIN WATER CAPTURE
SYSTEMS. IN SELECT CONSTRUCTION.
RESEARCH ON THESE PROGRAMS SHOW
AN AVERAGE DECREASE IN WATER
DEMAND FOR RESIDENTS TO
IMPLEMENT THIS TECHNOLOGY. UNDER
THIS BILL HCD WOULD EVALUATE THE
ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY OF RAIN
WATER CAPTURE SYSTEM. AND THEIR
ABILITY TO REDUCE RELIANCE ON
IMPORTED WATER. THEY WOULD ALSO
ASSESS POTENTIAL INCENTIVES OR
SUBSIDIES TO ENCOURAGE ADOPTION
WITH INPUT FROM. ALL THE
STAKEHOLDERS LOCAL WATER
AGENCIES PUBLIC WATER SYSTEMS.
PRODUCT MANUFACTURERS LOCAL
OFFICIALS AND OTHER
STAKEHOLDERS. THROUGH THIS
PROCESS CALIFORNIA WILL HAVE THE
ABILITY TO AUGMENT ITS WATER
STORAGE CAPACITY. AND THE
DECREASE RELIANCE ON MUNICIPAL
WATER SYSTEMS WITH ME DAD DENNIS
O'CONNOR. OF THE MODEL A
COMMITTEE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
AT THE PERFECT. TIME
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
. THANK YOU THE TERM MEMBERS
DENNIS O'CONNOR AGAIN A
VOLUNTEER WITH MONO LAKE
COMMITTEE- THE MODEL A COMMITTEE
AS A NON PROFIT CITIZENS GROUP
DEDICATED TO PROTECTING AND
RESTORING THE MONO BASIN ECO
SYSTEM. EDUCATING THE PUBLIC
ABOUT MONA LAKE IN THE IMPACTS
OF ENVIRONMENTAL LIKE THOUGHT ON
THE ENVIRONMENT OF EXCESS WATER
USE. AND IMPORTANT FOR THIS
COMMITTEE- PROMOTING COOPERATIVE
SOLUTIONS TO PROTECT MONO LAKE
AND MEET REAL WATER NEEDS
WITHOUT TRANSFERRING
ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS TO OTHER.
AREAS OF THE STATE- THE- THE
AUTHOR MENTIONED- TWO SONS SANTA
FE ACTUALLY RAIN WATER CAPTURE
SYSTEMS ARE WORLDWIDE- AUSTRALIA
AND NEW ZEALAND BERMUDA- THE U.
S. VIRGIN ISLANDS- AS AN ASIDE
IF YOU'D LIKE ME TO COME BACK AS
A RETIRED ANNUITANT GIVE UNITE
WITNESS ACCOUNTING OF ALL THOSE
THINGS I'D BE WILLING TO DO
THAT- IT DOESN'T. THE TECHNOLOGY
VIEWS WIDELY USED AND I'VE
TOURED SOME RAIN WATER SYSTEM.
SUCH AS THE RAIN WATER CAPTURE
SYSTEM- AT- EVERGREEN LODGE NEAR
YOU SOMEBODY IT'S ON THE ROAD TO
HETCH HETCHY IF YOU'RE LOOKING
FOR A ROAD TRIP- WHAT'S
INTERESTING ABOUT THIS IS THEY
REQUIRE LITTLE OR NO ENERGY TO
OPERATE- AND LESS ENERGY MEANS
LESS GREENHOUSE GASES EMITTED AS
PART OF MOVING THAT WATER. ONE
INCH OF RAIN ON THE TYPICAL
SIXTEEN HUNDRED SQUARE FOOT ROOF
GENERATES ABOUT A THOUSAND
GALLONS OF WATER. THE CITY OF
LOS ANGELES DURING A DROUGHT
YEAR GETS FOUR INCHES OF WATER A
YEAR. AND IF YOU WERE TO
MULTIPLY THAT BY ALL THE HOUSES
IN LA WE'RE TALKING A REAL
QUANTITIES OF WATER AND THEN IF
YOU CONSIDER A YEAR LIKE THIS
YEAR. WE'D LITERALLY BE AWASH-
AND EVERY GALLON OF WATER THAT
WE CAPTURE OFFSETS HE- GALLAGHER
MUNICIPALES SUPPLIED WATER- MY
FORMER CHAIR SENATOR PADLEY USED
TO SAY THAT REGIONAL. WATER
SOLUTIONS SUCH AS RAIN WATER CAN
AFTER PROMOTE INCREASED REGION
WATER- I WOULD ALSO ADD FROM
AMONG THE LAKE PERSPECTIVE
INCREASED REGIONAL RELIABILITY
REDUCES PRESSURE. TO IMPORT
WATER FROM OTHER WATERSHEDS
WHICH IS WHY THE MONO LAKE
COMMITTEE- SUPPORTS THIS BILL
THANK YOU THANK YOU SIR. THE
MANAGER MEMBER SCOTT WHICH ON
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
PATRIOTS COUNCIL AND THE
INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
PLUMBING AND MECHANICAL
OFFICIALS. GENERALLY VERY
SUPPORTIVE OF WATER CATCHMENT
CAPTURE WE HAVE A VERY ROBUST
PROVISION WITHIN THE CALIFORNIA
PLUMBING CODE WHICH I APPLE
PUBLISHES. AND SO WE'RE
GENERALLY SUPPORTIVE OF THE BILL
I DO NEED TO SAY THOUGH. ANY
MOVEMENT TOWARDS ADDING OTHER
STANDARDS OTHER THAN I AT MOST
STANDARDS WHICH ARE CALIFORNIA'S
STANDARDS IN WHICH ARE IN
STATUTE WOULD LEAD US TO CHANGE
FROM SUPPORT TO A STRONG
OPPOSITION THANK YOU. SORRY NOT
ON THE- CHAIR OF MINE SAID YET I
GOT A HOSPITAL IN. SO DO WE HAVE
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
OF- S. B. FIVE NINETY SEVEN.
SEEING NONE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO
ASSIST IN OPPOSITION S. B. BY
NINETY SEVEN HE- A ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED. GOOD AFTERNOON TURN
MEMBERS PRETTY GOOD ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
OFFICIALS AND RESPECTFUL OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION FOR NOW
WE'VE HAD VERY PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATION WITH THE AUTHOR'S
OFFICE AND APPRECIATE THE
CONCERNS ARE BEING HEARD MOST OF
OUR CONCERN IS JUST FORCING
MANDATORY BUILDING STANDARDS TO
THE BANKS AND COMMISSION WHICH
WE SUPPORT. BUT DOING IT IN THAT
TIME FRAME WITHOUT THE RESEARCH
TO BACK IT UP HAS SOME CONCERNS
LOOKING AT THE LANGUAGE YOU KNOW
IT'S ONLY A COUPLE CITIES IN THE
US DOING THIS WE UNDERSTAND ITS
WORLDWIDE WE THINK WE NEED TO
MAKE SURE WE KNOW THE SAFETY
IMPLICATIONS AS WELL AS THE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR COST
REDUCTION. FOR THESE ABILITIES
AND GOING THROUGH THIS BUILDING
STANDARDS COMMISSION PROCESS IS
THE CORRECT APPROACH TO DO THAT-
WE JUST THINK THAT FORCING A
TIME LINE FOR THE NEXT CODE
CYCLE IS A LITTLE. PUTTING THE
CART BEFORE THE HORSE IF YOU
WELL AND I THINK WE NEED TO TAKE
A STEP BACK AND HAVE THEM NAY
RESEARCH AND PROPOSE AND ADOPT
THOSE MODEL CODES AT THE
NATIONAL LEVEL FIRST BEFORE
MANDATING NEW STANDARDS AND
ADDITIONALLY FOR ALL RESIDENTIAL
CONSTRUCTION WE SHOULD BE AWARE
OF THE DIFFERENT. AREAS OF
CALIFORNIA AND SOME OF THE COST
IMPLICATIONS OF THESE SYSTEMS
YOU. JUST THINGS WE NEED TO BE
AWARE OF BEFORE MANDATING IT. SO
WANTED TO BRING THOSE ATTENTION
SO WE THINK THAT. PUSHING BACK A
TIME LINE AND HAVING THAT
RESEARCH IS REALLY USEFUL AND
HELPFUL. AND THEN WE WOULD BE
HAPPY TO MOVE TO NEUTRAL WITHOUT
THAT. SPECIFIC TIME LINE SO
THANK YOU AND WILL LOOK FOR TO
CONTINUE CONVERSATIONS WITH
AUTHORS AND SPONSORS ON THE
BILL. THANK YOU HE- ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. TO HELL
WITH THE ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA WATER AGENCIES WE
RELATE TAKING A POSITION AND WE
ACTUALLY HAVE A MEETING SET TO
SPEAK WITH THE AUTHOR. TO LOOK
FORWARD TO HAVING PRODUCTIVE
CONVERSATIONS BUT JUST WANTED TO
SHARE THAT POSITION TODAY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR
MEMBERS STILL YOU FOR ABOUT THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION WERE ALSO CAN IT IN
THE IN BETWEEN- REALLY
APPRECIATE THE DIRECTION THE
BILL THE ONE THING I THINK WE
YOU KNOW WE GUARD AGAINST. YOU
KNOW PUTTING BUILDING CODE IN
STATUTE I THINK WE'RE RIGHT
THERE IN COUPLE WITH THAT THE
ONE THING WE WOULD GO BEYOND IS
TO SAY- WE DO THINK THERE SHOULD
BE LANGUAGE OUT OF THE BILL TO
MAKE SURE THAT EACH CD HAS THE
DISCRETION TO DETERMINE. WHERE
IT IS NOT APPROPRIATE. SO THEY
DO A GOOD JOB ANALYSIS OF WHERE
DOES BUT THEY ALSO NEED TO HAVE
THE FLEXIBILITY SAY YOU KNOW
WHAT IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE
THERE. SO THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH TO HAVE ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. SEE NOW
WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO WITNESSES
WAITING TO TESTIFY IDEA THE
TELECONFERENCE ORVIS. MODERATE
HE WOULD PLEASE FROM THE
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION AND WE
WILL RETURN AGAIN. BUT AGAIN
LATE. THEM IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE. ZERO IT CURRENTLY NO
ONE KEEPING UP AT THIS TIME. ALL
RIGHT- WOULD YOU MIND CHECKING
THE LINES ONE MORE TIME JUST TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE'VE GIVEN THE
OPPORTUNITY TO WITNESSES. TO
TESTIFY VIA TELECONFERENCE
ARVEST. OF COURSE AS A REMINDER
BUT AGAIN IF YOU WISH MAKE A
COMMENT OR OPPOSITION MAY PRESS
ONE THEN DEAR I'M. TO
THEY'RE STILL CURRENTLY KNOWING
QUEUING UP. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MR MODERATOR FOR YOUR TIME AND
WE WILL NOW WHAT I WANT TO ALSO
THANK OUR WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
AND OPPOSITION THE CAME TODAY TO
TESTIFY WILL NOW BRING THE
DISCUSSION BACK TO OUR MEMBERS
TO HAVE ANY COMMENTS QUESTIONS.
SORRY I WOULD BE TAKING OVER AS
CHAIR AND ONE SECOND SO THEY
WERE JUST RIPPING ME I REALLY
LIKE THIS BILL AND I'M EXCITED
BY IT SO I I'M GOING TO SUPPORT
IT THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- THANK YOU
MISTER GLAZER SENATOR GLAZERS
MYSTICALLY CENTER GREAT LEADER
FOR YOUR TIME THIS AFTERNOON IN
PRESENTING THE BILL FIVE EIGHTY
SEVEN- I ACTUALLY HAVE CONCERNS
WITH. WITH WITH THE BILL WITH
REGARDS TO- REQUIRING OUR YOU
KNOW ADDING MORE. REQUIREMENTS
TO HOUSING INDUSTRY CALIFORNIA
JUST BECAUSE OF THE COST OF.
HOUSING RIGHT NOW IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA THAT'S NOT TO SAY
THAT. WE WOULDN'T ENCOURAGE- I
WOULD ENCOURAGE. ANY BUILDER TO
PROVIDE CERTAIN AMENITIES EXTRA
IN THERE DEVELOPMENTS I THINK
THAT WOULD BE GREAT AND
WONDERFUL I AM A LITTLE BIT
HESITANT TO- TO CONTINUE DUE TO
PROMOTE- AB ADDITIONAL STANDARDS
FOR MORE BUILDING AB
REQUIREMENTS FOR HOUSING THAT
JUST ADDS TO THE COST SO ON ON
THAT FRONT. I'M GONNA LAY OFF
BECAUSE I REALLY DO THINK THAT
THEY SHOULD THIS CURRENT. I AM
VERY MUCH BE AN AMENITY THAT
BUILDERS DECIDE TO PROMOTE AND
DEPENDING ON THE AREA THAT YOUR
GRAPHICAL AREA WHICH THE
BUILDING HOMES. BUT. I'M GONNA
LEAVE IT AT THAT THANK YOU. OKAY
THE ROOM COMMENTED- PRETTY FOR
CLOTHES I AM READY FOR FLOWS.
NUMBERS A THIS IS IN MY FIRST
SAID THAT THAT TIME DEALING WITH
THESE TYPES OF ISSUES OF WATER
CAPTURE ACTUALLY CARRIED A BILL-
FOUR YEARS AGO. PUT A MEASURE ON
THE BALLOT THAT THE PEOPLE OF
CALIFORNIA PASSED WITH 85% OF
THE VOTE THAT. THAT IF YOU
INSTALL THE WATER CAPTURE SYSTEM
THAT YOU WOULDN'T INCREASE YOUR
TAX BASIS. SHE OF THE
LEGISLATURE AND THE PEOPLE
SUPPORT TO- TO HAVE THAT IN LOSS
OF THAT YOU CAN IMPROVE YOUR
PROPERTY WITH THESE WATER
CAPTURE SYSTEM TO NOT INCREASE
YOUR TAXES. BUT THE BILL IS VERY
CLEAR ON THIS ISSUE OF COST
BECAUSE I'M SENSITIVE TO IT. WE
HAVE A HOUSING CRISIS WE ALSO
HAVE A WATER. CRISIS TO SO WE
HAVE TO TRY TO DO BOTH BUT- YOU
KNOW THE INSTINCT ON THESE TYPES
OF BILLS I'M GONNA MANDATE AND
HERE'S THE STANDARDS AND I'M
GONNA DO ALL THE WORK FOR A CD
RIGHT HERE IN THIS THIS BILL.
AND I'VE PULLED BACK FROM THAT
AND DECIDED THAT UP A
STAKEHOLDER PROCESS IS THE
BETTER WAY TO DO IT. AND THAT IN
THE BILL IT SAYS THAT WE'RE
ASKING THAT AN EVALUATION OF
COSTS BENEFITS AND FEASIBILITY
BE PART OF THAT ANALYSIS. SO
IT'S NOT AT THE SWITCH IS TURNED
INTO AN A REQUIREMENT IS PUT IN
PLACE. BUT IT HAS TO BE A ROBUST
STAKEHOLDER PROCESS THAT
EVALUATES THE SAME ISSUES THAT
YOU ARE CONCERNED WITH. HOW DO
WE ENCOURAGE TO SUPPORT MORE
HOUSING BUT ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT
WE HAVE A SERIOUS WATER PROBLEM
IN OUR STATE. AND THAT WE NEED
TO DEVELOP THE RIGHT STANDARDS
TO DO BOTH AND THAT'S WHAT'S
BEFORE YOU AND WITHOUT A
RESPECTFULLY ASTRONAUT. OKAY WE
HAVE- I'M SORRY DO WE HAVE A
MOTION OKAY EMOTION THE PAST TO
THE PREPARATIONS. BY SEN- OKAY
PERCENT CLICK THROUGH EXPERIENCE
YOU. WILL CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER. WIENER HI JOE BOGUE. THE
TROUBLED NOW LOOKS. CLICK HERE
HI CABRERO. CORTEZ REQUIRE THE
DHEA C. YEAH. SEYARTO NOW
SKINNER- BURKE WILL HOUSE. WILL
FOOT THE BILL ON CALL THANK YOU
SENATOR GLAZERS. OKAY SIR NEXT I
BELIEVE CENTER PATROL. PRO COOL
GO. SHARE I WAS ABOUT TO TEAR MY
FIRST COMMITTEE HERE WHEN YOU
WERE ABSENT. AND I WAS. GOING TO
CRACK CRACK THE HAMMER AND NOT
ALLOW ANYONE TO GO OVERTIME CUT
THEM OFF. WHEN THEY DID. BUT
UNFORTUNATELY- BACK IN SO THAT
MEANS THAT YOU. YOU MIGHT BE A
LITTLE MORE LENIENT. SAMUS OFTEN
TELL A LITTLE BIT YES.
YOU MAY PROCEED CENTER TROUBLE
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER. FOR
MISTER CHAIR- APOLOGIZE. MEMBERS
I'D LIKE TO START TO THINK BY
THINKING THAT COMMITTEE FOR
THEIR WORK ON THIS BILL AND
ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS OUTLINE
IN THE ANALYSIS THAT SIMPLY
REMOVE THE OUTDATED TERM
TRANSITIONAL FROM THE BELL. IT
IS NO SECRET THAT CALIFORNIA IS
IN THE MIDST OF A HOUSING CRISIS
EVEN THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BELIEVES
THE STATE NEEDS AT LEAST SEVENTY
THOUSAND AFFORDABLE UNITS
ANNUALLY TO KEEP UP WITH DEMAND.
CALIFORNIA PRODUCE ROUGHLY
NINETEEN THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED
NEW AFFORDABLE UNITS LAST YEAR
THE LACK OF HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
HAS CONTINUED TO INCREASE THE
COST OF HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA TO
THE POINT THE VAST MAJORITY OF
HOUSING UNITS ARE NO LONGER
AFFORDABLE FOR IT TO THE AVERAGE
PERSON. IN TO THE DEPARTMENT OF
FINANCE THE MEDIAN PRICE OF A
SINGLE FAMILY HOME PETE IN MAY
OF TWENTY TWENTY TWO AT EIGHT
HUNDRED AND NINETY EIGHT
THOUSAND DOLLARS NINE HUNDRED
AND EIGHTY DOLLARS. TO AFFORD
THIS A FAMILY WOULD NEED A
COMBINATION INCOME OF A HUNDRED
AND EIGHTY THOUSAND DOLLARS MORE
THAN TWICE CALIFORNIANS MEDIAN
HOUSEHOLD INCOME AND ALMOST FIVE
TIMES THE CALIFORNIA POVERTY'S
MEASURE. MEASURES OF POVERTY
LINE UP THIRTY SIX THOUSAND NINE
HUNDRED DOLLARS. BRING SURPLUS
PROPERTY DISPOSAL LAWS. BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES
IS AUTHORIZED TO SELL STATE
SURPLUS PROPERTY TO A LOCAL
AGENCY OR NON PROFIT. OR
NONPROFIT AFFORDABLE HOUSING
SPONSOR FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PROJECTS BELOW MARKET VALUE IF
THE DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL
SERVICES DETERMINES. THAT SUCH A
DISCOUNT IS NECESSARY TO FINANCE
THE HOUSING PROJECT AND THAT THE
HOUSING WILL REMAIN AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FOR AT LEAST FORTY
YEARS. HOWEVER BUYERS RARELY
INVOKED THIS OPTION IN FACT
ACCORDING TO DGS NONE OF THE
SURPLUS PROPERTY SOLD TO LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS OR NONPROFITS FROM
TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHTEEN.
THROUGH TWO THOUSAND TWENTY TWO
WERE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
PURPOSES. SB TWO FOUR FORTY WILL
FURTHER INCENTIVIZE DEVELOPERS
TO PURCHASE SURPLUS STATE
PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSES OF
BUILDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING BY
EXTENDING THE PROPERTY FROM
SEQUEL REVIEWS. AS BY RIGHT
DEVELOPMENTS. SB TWO FORTY WILL
ALSO ADD. HOUSING PROJECTS
INTENDED FOR FORMERLY
INCARCERATED INDIVIDUALS AS A
PRIORITY IN SURPLUS HOUSING
DISPOSAL LOGS. JOIN ME JOINING
ME TO TESTIFYING SUPPORT IS
AMBERG MADISON SAY POLICY
COMPLIANCE COUNSEL FOR THE
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
. PLEASE VISIT. GET UP. GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIRED MEMBERS. AS
MENTIONED MY NAME IS AMIT
MEDICINE FOR THE CALIFORNIA
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION AND I'M
HAPPY TO EXTEND THE
ORGANIZATION'S ORGANIZATION
SUPPORT OF SB TWO FORTY. THREE
TO FORTY WOULD EXPAND OUR
STATE'S EXISTING SURPLUS
PROPERTY LOSS TO SERVE A
CRITICALLY UNDER LOOK POPULATION
FORMERLY INCARCERATED
INDIVIDUALS SB TWO FORTY IS A
NECESSARY STEP TO ADDRESS
CALIFORNIA'S HOMELESSNESS
CRISIS. MY ENSURING THAT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS DEVELOPED
FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO NEED
ASSISTANCE TRANSITIONING OUTSIDE
OF THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM
AND BACK INTO OUR COMMUNITIES.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN ICE.
THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
COMMENT IN THE ROOM THIRTY NINE
ANY OPPOSITION IN- SIGNAL GO TO
THE PHONE LINES. MAKE A COMMENT
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO. THE LINE SEVENTY
TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD. PEPPERMILL
RATHER THAN TELL THEM THEY OF
YOU'D BE ACTION IN SUPPORT. AND
WE CURRENTLY KNOWN HAVE BEEN
PRESENTED TO US A ONE ANOTHER.
GIVEN. THIS IS RYAN WITH
EIGHTEEN T. I TOLD YOU I'D GIVE
YOU MY NUMBER MY NUMBER IS ONE
ZERO SEVEN. STILL BE THE WITH
THE NEXT ONE UP I'LL GET TO
WRITE BACK AND.
IT LOOKS LIKE THEY DID JUST
REMOVED HIMSELF FROM Q.
EXCELLENT TO LINE ONE OH SEVEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CARAMON BURGERS
THANK YOU BOTH ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
COUNTIES OF THE PORT OF SB TWO
FORTY THANK YOU. THERE'S
CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE IN THE
QUEUE ON THE PROGRAM BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. OKAY SEE NONE THANK
YOU FOR THIS BILL AND THANK YOU
FOR- WORKING WITH STAKEHOLDERS
IN THE COMMITTEE AND-
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE ON THIS
BILL AND YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR THE LEGISLATURE HAS
ALREADY FOUND THAT THE PROVISION
OF DECENT HOUSING FOR ALL
CALIFORNIANS IS A STATE GOAL OF
THE HIGHEST PRIORITY. AND THAT
THE DISPOSAL OF SURPLUS STATE
REAL PROPERTY IS A DIRECT AND
SUBSTANTIAL PUBLIC PURPOSE OF
STATEWIDE CONCERN SB TWO FORTY
WILL ADDRESS THESE CONCERNS BY
ENSURING WE DO EVERYTHING WE CAN
TO INCENTIVIZE THE DEVELOPMENT
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING. A STATE
SURPLUS LAND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE. OKAY SO TO KIND
OF A MOTION TO PASS WITH A
MINUTE TO PASS AS AMENDED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
OKAY MOTIONLESS INTERPRETERS HE
WILL CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER FIGHT. WIENER BY THE
TROUBLED. A TROUBLED BY BLIX
HERE. CLICKS THERE HI CABALLERO
CORTESE. PRETENDS HE BY MCGUIRE
PADILLA THERE ARE TWO. ZERO TWO
HI SKINNER- BURKE WILL HOP. OKAY
WILL PUT THAT ON CALL I'M GOING
TO KNOW. HIM AGO WILL OVER TO-
CENTER TO A VOTE SO I CAN
PRESENT- FILE ONE SP FOUR FIFTY
ON BEHALF OF SENATOR ATKINS.
WELCOME TO OUR SENATOR WIENER
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE READY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FRONT AND
CENTER COLLEAGUES I'M I'M
PRESENTING SP FOUR FIFTY ON
BEHALF OF OUR PRO TEM CENTER
ATKINS. MANY OF YOU WILL RECALL
A BILL THAT TO PROTECT OUR
PREVIOUSLY AUTHORED SB NINE THE
HOME ACT WHICH WAS SIGNED INTO
LAW AND TWENTY TWENTY ONE. IT'S
AUTHORIZED- DUPLEXES ARE
CONSIDERED CALIFORNIA I REMAIN
PROUD IT WAS A IT WAS A PROBLEM-
WHAT THEY'RE OF THAT
LEGISLATION- AND IT IS STARTING
TO HAVE REAL IMPACTS SB NINE
SOUGHT TO WIDEN ACCESS TO
HOUSING FOR CALIFORNIA'S WORKING
FAMILIES BY STREAMLINING A
HOMEOWNER'S ABILITY TO BUILD A
DUPLEX OR SPLIT THE RESIDENTS A
LOT. ALLOWING UP TO FOUR UNITS
UNFORTUNATELY IN THE YEARS SINCE
IT BECAME LAW- WE'VE SEEN A
NUMBER OF LOCAL JURISDICTIONS-
TAKE WHAT WE MIGHT CALL CREATIVE
LICENSE IN IMPLEMENTING THIS LAW
EITHER BY IGNORING IT ENTIRELY.
OR IMPOSING- OVERLY BURDENSOME
ON REASONABLE STANDARDS SEEKING
TO DISCOURAGE ITS USE HI. THIS
BILL AS BEFORE FIFTY. INCLUDE
SOME KEY PROVISIONS. TO INCREASE
IF. OF US NINE. BY IMPROVING AND
CERTAINTY HOMEOWNER WHO WISH TO
USE A- OF THE LAW AND INCREASING
ENFORCEMENT OF EXISTING LAW
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE- HERE TO TESTIFY AS CROSS
SELLING CONSIDER CRAVINGS WITH
CALIFORNIA YIMBY. AND JENNIFER
SPECTRUM THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS. GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS MY NAME IS BETTY LEGACY-
CRANKS I AM HERE IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THE BILL AND I AM
HERE REPRESENTING CALIFORNIA
YIMBY. I'M IN INTEREST OF TIME I
WILL KEEP MY COMMENTS SHORT BUT
REALLY WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
UNDERSTAND THAT THIS IS MODELED
AFTER SOME OF THE SUCCESS THAT
WE'VE HAD WITH EIGHTY
LEGISLATION. IT TOOK A COUPLE
YEARS AND EVERY TIME WE'VE
ACTUALLY WORKED AT STANDARDIZING
FEES INCREASING THE PRODUCTIVITY
BY MAKING IT EASIER AND REMOVING
SOME OF THE RED TAPE THAT HAS
PRECLUDED. A LOT OF HOMEOWNERS
FROM ADDING EIGHTY USE AND IT IS
ONE OF THE SUSPECTS ACCESS
STORIES THAT WE HAVE HERE IN
CALIFORNIA YOU LOOK AT THE
NUMBERS THAT ARE BEING PERMITTED
IN LA AND WE BELIEVE THAT SB
NINE CAN BE BAD IMPACTFUL. CAN
PROVIDE ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
FOR HOMEOWNERS TO NOT ONLY BUILD
ADDITIONAL EQUITY BUT ALSO BUILD
MORE GENERATIONAL HEALTH WOULD
GENERATIONAL INTERGENERATIONAL
WEALTH. SO FOR THOSE REASONS WE
BELIEVE THAT THIS IS ANOTHER
STEP FORWARD TO MAKING SURE THAT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE ABLE TO
CONTINUE TO HAVE LOCAL CONTROL
WHILE ALSO BALANCING THE NEED OF
ADDITIONAL. HOUSING PRODUCTION
SO FOR THOSE REASONS WE URGE AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU. AS CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
JENNIFER SECOND HALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS. SB FOUR FIFTY SIX TO
CREATE A MORE IS A MODEST
MEASURE TO CLEAN UP
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES THAT WE'VE
EXPERIENCED WITH SB NINE. THE
MODEST CHANGES PROPOSED IN THE
MEASURE WILL HELP TO BRIDGE THE
WEALTH GAP AMONG OUR MOST
ETHNICALLY DIVERSE COMMUNITIES
THROUGHOUT THE STATE BY ENSURING
THAT HOMEOWNERS BENEFIT FROM THE
ADDITIONAL HOUSING
OPPORTUNITIES. CREATED UNDER SB
NINE SPECIFICALLY AGAIN THESE
ARE EXTRAORDINARILY TECHNICAL
AMENDMENTS TO RESOLVE CONCERNS
WITH IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
MEASURE WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
DRIVE UP. HELLO MY NAME IS BRIAN
AND- I'M- HERE ON BEHALF OF
BILLS COSTS THAT WE ARE A
COMPANY THAT HELPS HOMEOWNERS
ACROSS THE STATE. I DO SB NINE
PROJECTS. AND WE ARE STRONGLY IN
SUPPORT OF S. B. FOR FIFTY.
YEARS AND I'VE- AND WE LOOK
FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO WORK
WITH CENTER ATKINS. AND MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE. TO MOVE THIS
BILL FORWARD- STILL SORELY
NEEDED- WE ARE ON THE GROUND
ACROSS MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS
AND- THE MORE CLARITY. THE
BETTER THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THIRTEEN A STRONG GRIN VOLUNTEER
ON BEHALF OF A RP CALIFORNIA
CAPITAL RESPONSE TEAM IN SUPPORT
OF SB FOUR FIFTY THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON BRIAN STEP ON BEHALF
OF SPUR CIVIC WELL HABITAT FOR
HUMANITY CALIFORNIA ALSO SUPPORT
THANK YOU. AMBER MADISON
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE WILL NOW
MOVE ON TO WITNESS SAYS DO YOU
HAVE ANY OTHER WITH A WHICH IS
IN SUPPORT OF SB FOUR FIFTY. SEE
NOW WILL NOW MOVE ON TO
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION SB FOUR
FIFTY- ROOM TWELVE HUNDRED. YOU
SEEN NONE. WE WILL NOW MOVE ON
TO WITNESS SAYS GIVE IT TO. YOUR
TELECOM PROJECTS. NOT WILL NOW
MOVE ON TO WITNESSES AT THE AT
THE TELECONFERENCE I WAITING TO
TESTIFY FOR MR MODERATOR IF YOU
WOULD PLEASE PROMPT INDIVIDUALS
TO. TWO WERE READY TO ACT AS A
BABY AT THE TELECONFERENCE
SERVICE- EITHER IN SUPPORT OR IN
OPPOSITION OF SP. FOUR FIFTY. OF
COURSE PLAYED IN GERMAN ONCE
AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO MAKE A
COMMENT REPORT OR OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO WILL BE
GOING TO LINE ONE OH EIGHT THESE
ARE AT. GOOD AFTERNOON OR THE
EVELYN EVER THE AMERICAN
PLANNING ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA
CHAPTER AND WORK. ACTUALLY ALL
GOING TO LINE SEVENTY TWO PLEASE
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON SYMBOL
OF SADDAM HELD ON BEHALF OF THE
ACTION IN THE LAW AND- DOZENS OF
CHAPTERS. IN CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT. ACTUALLY GOING TO LINE
UP ONE TEN PLEASE GO AHEAD- THIS
IS BOB NAYLOR REPRESENTING
FIELDS THE COMPANY THAT POWER.
I'M INSINUATING YEAR ORANGE
COUNTY PHILANTHROPISTS STRONG
SUPPORT. THAT'S CURRENTLY NO ONE
ELSE THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH- THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
MONTEREY WILL WE GET BACK TO OUR
COMMITTEE FOR COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS. I HAVE A QUICK
QUESTION WHAT'S THE RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN HOAS AND SB NINE. IS
THERE ANY- BY TRYING TO REMEMBER
WHAT THE RESOLUTION WAS AROUND
H. IS. AN S. R. NINE PERHAPS
THIS FAQ CAN REFRESH OUR MEMORY
ON THAT. HOAS SEN IT'S BEEN AN
ONGOING- ISSUE BUT THAT WAS A
NEGOTIATIONS ON THE- HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATIONS AND HUNDRED OF
ELEMENTS HAVE BEEN
EXTRAORDINARILY COMPLICATED
CONSTRUCTION WITH RESPECT TO THE
LEGISLATIVE STAFF OR WITH THE
STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION- AND IT
MAKES IT ALMOST LIKE A SQUARE
PEG IN A ROUND HOLE AND IF WE
WERE TO FACILITATE SB NINE TYPE
CONVERSIONS WITHIN. H. AWAY
COMMUNITIES WE WILL PROBABLY
HAVE TO COMPLETELY CRACKED OPEN
THE STATUTE SPECIFICALLY IN
DAVIS STERLING ENABLE IN ORDER
TO DO THAT. THE QUESTION WAS-
REFRESH YOUR MEMORY ON THE
STATUS OF A CHOI I THINK THEY'RE
EXEMPTED FROM THEY ARE EXEMPTED
FROM THE BILL MY APOLOGIES I WAS
ANSWERED THE QUESTIONS OF WHY
WOULDN'T INCLUDE THEM. THEY'RE
GOING TO TELL. I WILL SAY IN
RESPONSE MISS SAKAMOTO'S THIS IS
AN ALL. DISCUSS AND SOMETIMES
DISPUTE WITHIN HOUSING POLICIES
ABOUT STATUS OF HOAS SOMEONE'S
WE DON'T AGREE AND I KNOW THERE
HAS BEEN TALK ABOUT TRYING TO DO
PERHAPS- GLOBAL. JOE A RELATED
HOUSING LAW SO FINALLY RESOLVES
THAT ISSUE BUT THAT HAS BEEN A-
BILL BY BILL- DIALOGUE. RIGHT SO
WHEN THE REPORT SAYS THAT TWO
THIRDS OR THREE FOURTHS OF THE
STATE IS SINGLE FAMILY ZONING.
HIT THAT AND THEN IT TALKS ABOUT
THE AMOUNT OF HOUSING THAT COULD
BE BUILT I MEAN WE'RE TAKING A
TWO WAY IS OFF THE TABLE IN
DISCUSSING SB NINE WITH THE
AMOUNT OF HOUSING THAT COULD BE
BUILT. RIGHT RIGHT HI. IF YOU'RE
SUGGESTING THERE IS WE SHOULD
NOT BE EXAMS I AGREE IF THAT'S
YOUR SAID I AGREE WITH- I DON'T.
AND I KNOW I'VE HAD SOME
DISAGREEMENTS IN SOME CIRCLES
AND I PERSONALLY DON'T THINK WE
SHOULD BE EXEMPT OUT IT'S ALWAYS
UP IT BECOMES A VERY-
CHALLENGING POLITICAL SITUATION.
IN THE BUILDING AND I HOPE THAT
AT SOME POINT I GET FULLY
RESOLVED. THANK YOU I KNOW THIS
ISN'T YOUR BILL. ON YOUR AND
HITTING THANK YOU. THANK VERY
MUCH ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS REMEMBER. TO HAVE
MOTION ON THE BILL. PROVED THANK
YOU SIR PARTISAN WE HAVE MOTION
AND- FROM SENATOR CORTESE.
BOTTOM COURT. CENTER AND I DON'T
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- THIS ISN'T
A BILL FOR FIFTY BUT SENATOR
ATKINS MOTIONS TO PASS AND
REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON RULES.
SENATOR WIENER. WIENER AYE THE
CHOI BOGUE. THE TROUBLED BY.
NEXT YEAR HI CABALLERO COURTESY
. PHOTO HE I MCGUIRE PATEA THERE
. ENTER A BIRD WILL. OKAY WE'LL
PUT THE BILL ON CALL. WE A RE.
BILLS ARE TO BUY SENATOR MCCALL
. WOMAN SERVICE UNITS THERE
CURRENTLY HERE THEY SHOULD BE
HERE SOON- WHY DON'T WE- OPEN
THE- RULES THAT ARE BILLS JUST
FOR ANYONE WHO MAY NOT HAVE BEEN
HERE FOR PARTICULAR VOTES- SO WE
WILL- PHONE. CONSIDER ON BURGERS
HERE SO YOU CAN VOTE ON
EVERYTHING ELSE. WELCOME CENTER
- HERE'S WHAT THE WHY I'M NOT A
JUDICIAL. OKAY WILL OPEN THE
ROLE ON STARTING WITH ITEM
NUMBER ONE AS BEFORE FIFTY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
MCGUIRE THE US AIR TO SKINNER-
BURKE. NUMBER FIVE BOB. HA BY
CENTER WILL HAVE TO TWO AWESOME
WE'LL PUT THAT ALL BACK AND CALL
THEM TO SB THREE FIFTY SIX
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
UNDER TOWBOAT BY A TROUBLED BY
THE IDEA SKINNER AMBERG. THIS IS
THAT ARE SO LET US GO AS WE
THREE FIFTY SIX. NUMBER FIVE BOB
. THE HOBBIT BY CORPORATE THAT
BACK IN CALL. THEM AND THEY'LL
ITEM NUMBER THREE SB THIRTY FOUR
BY SEVEN OR PORTANTINO PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR
JOE BOOK YEAH. PHOTOBOOK NOW
PADILLA SKINNER. BURKE BOB. BOB
HI OKAY WE'LL PUT THAT BACK ON
CALL- ITEM NUMBER FOUR SP FOUR
SIXTY NINE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. SENATOR JOE BUG
HI THE TROUBLED BY THE IDEA
SKINNER- BERG BOB. BOB HI CAN
PUT THAT BACK ON CALL FROM ZACKS
WHY DON'T WE KNOW THOSE MCGUIRE
ARE YOU READY OFF SOME OKAY OF
CIVIL FOR THE THROUGH THE ROLE
FOR YOUR- ITEM FOR SP FIVE
EIGHTY FOR. PLEASE UP SOME.
UNDER TOBA. SOME FIVE IN FIVE
LIMÓN. THE TROUBLED NOW DO
SKINNER AMBERG BOB HI BOB I. PUT
THAT **** CALL ITEM SIX SB FIVE
NINETY SO BUT SOME REPLACE
PLEASE CALL THE UP SOME.
CABALLERO QUIT. IT HAS THE HI
MCGUIRE. R. HI VIDEA SKINNER
NUMBER WHAT. THE HOBBIT PUT THAT
BACK CALL NO ITEM SEVEN SB SIX
THIRTY FOUR BUCKS A BAKER PLEASE
CALL OFFICE AND MY- SENATOR CHOI
BOGUE. SORRY YEAH. SIX HUNDRED.
SOME. YEAH LATER WILL WILL KEEP
IT ON- CAMARO MCGUIRE FIVE
REQUIRE I DO SIR R. TO. SKINNER
UMBERG WHAT. BOB HI- PUT IT BACK
ON CALL I REMEMBER EIGHT SPC BY
CENTER PLEASE CALL THE MEMBERS.
SENATOR TOLD. OKAY VIDEA SKINNER
NUMBER BOB. BOB HI. FOR THE PUT
THAT BACK ON NEXT ITEM. SB FOUR
EIGHTY TWO BY SEN PLACE PLEASE
CALL OFFICE AND ARE. SENATOR
CHOCOBO. THE TROUBLE BY
CABALLERO MCGUIRE I'M REQUIRE I
DO THEY ARE. SKINNER NUMBER BOB
. BOB PRAYER WILL PUT ABOUT CALL
NEXT- THE CONSENT CAL- WHICH IS
I FOR THAT'S NINETY ONE BY SO-
BURKE PLEASE CALL THAT SOME.
SENATOR TOLD BY THE TROUBLED BY
VIDEO SKINNER UMBERG BOB BOB BY
PUT THAT BACK ON CALL ON THE
NEXT ITEM THIRTEEN S. B. TWO BY
SEN CHOI BOTH CALL THE MEMBERS
SENATOR. MCGUIRE I OUR MEDIA
SKINNER NUMBER WHAT. BOB HI WILL
PROVIDE ON CALL AND FINAL-
NUMBER ITEMS SP SO 45% OR CORTES
HE PLEASE CALL THE OF MY- CENTER
TO. NO PHOTOBOOK NOW CAVALEIRO
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I VIDEA SEYARTO
SKINNER UMBERG BOB. BOB THERE
WILL PUT UP PHONE CALL FOR YOUR
MUCH OKAY HOUSE WHY AS BILLS.
WILL START WITH ITEM NUMBER TEN
THAT'S THE TEAM YOU MAY PROCEED
FROM- FOR SOCIAL. IN A WOMAN
TENNESSEE YOU'RE WOULD YOU LIKE
TO DO IS. EIGHTEEN PER. FOR AS
SIX TWENTY- RESEARCH SB EIGHTEEN
YES THANK YOU SO MUCH. PERCENT I
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO THE
CHAIR. FOR HAZING CLUB WHAT I
REALLY PUSHES OUT I'D SURE
WINNER IS THAT HE IS IN. EACH OF
THESE- AND MAKING SURE THAT THIS
MEETING RAN SMOOTHLY AND- HIS
COLLABORATION AND IT'S WANNA
TAKE A MOMENT AND SAY HOW MUCH I
APPRECIATE THAT. TIME MEMBERS
THE FAX FOR THIS NATIVE
AMERICANS IN CALIFORNIA ARE
DISPROPORTIONATELY REPRESENTED
AMONG THE STATE'S ALMOST
POPULATION AND HAVE HIGHER RATES
OF POVERTY OVERCROWDED
SUBSTANDARD HOMES THAN ANY OTHER
POPULATION HERE IN THE GOLDEN
STATE AND THAT'S WHY WE'VE BEEN
INTRODUCED SB EIGHTEEN THE
TRAVEL HOUSING PROGRAM BILL. THE
RATE OF TRAVEL TRAVEL POVERTY IS
MORE THAN TWICE THAT OF THE REST
OF CALIFORNIA'S POPULATION
WITHIN NATIVE AMERICAN
COMMUNITIES AND ACCORDING TO
CENSUS DATA APPROXIMATELY 10% OF
TRIBES HAVE HOMES THAT LACK
COMPLETE PLUMBING. IN SEVEN
PERCENT. LACK COMPLETE TENSION
KITCHENS HOMELESSNESS AMONG
INDIGENOUS INDIVIDUALS UP TO
DOUBLE THAT OF THE GENERAL
POPULATION HERE IN CALIFORNIA
AND ONE THIRD A TRAVEL RESIDENTS
LIVE BELOW THE FEDERAL POVERTY
RATE. DESPITE THE CLEAR NEED THE
OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF TRIBES
ARE UNABLE TO ACCESS EXISTING
HOUSING PROGRAMS HERE IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. BECAUSE THE
CONFLICT WITH TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY
. LAWS IN CULTURE. THEY'RE OFTEN
TWO RESEARCH. THOSE LAWS FOR
TRIBES TO MEET THRESHOLD
COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS FOR
THEIR MISMATCH THE NEEDS THAT
EXIST ON TRIBAL LAND. AND EVEN
WHEN THERE IS A ONE TIME
DEDICATED FUNDS FOR TRIBES
WITHIN THE CITY CALIFORNIA IT
OFTEN GOES UNSPENT IN HERE'S A
STATISTIC FROM A CD. IN TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN AND EFFORT TO
ADDRESS THESE ISSUES THE
LEGISLATURE PASSED AB TEN TEN
MAKING TRIBES ELIGIBLE FOR MOST
OF CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING PROGRAMS
AND ALLOWING HOUSING COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT TO WAIVE CERTAIN
REQUIREMENTS. FOR TRAVEL
APPLICATIONS DESPITE THIS ONLY
THIRTEEN OUT OF A HUNDRED AND
NINE TRIBES HAVE BEEN AWARDED
STATE FUNDS. THIRTEEN A HUNDRED
NINE. LET'S BE CLEAR WE KNOW
THAT WE ARE SIGNIFICANT
CHALLENGES WITHIN THE CITY
CALIFORNIA I'M GRATEFUL TO
HOUSING COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
BUT WE MUST DO BETTER. SO SB
EIGHTEEN WOULD ADDRESS THESE
CHALLENGES BY CREATING A NEW IN
SEPARATE HOUSING PROGRAMS FOR
TRAVEL GOVERNMENT'S SPECIFIC TO
TRIBAL MEMBER NEEDS WHICH WOULD
BE CREATED IN CONSULTATION WITH
TRIBES AND TAILORED TO THE VERY
SPECIFIC NEEDS THAT EXIST WITHIN
TRAVELLING AND- THIS IS SIMILAR
TO WHAT WE'VE ALREADY DONE IS A
LEGISLATURE. PERFORMER HOUSING
FOR THE JOKES ARE NO FUN FOR
MORE GREAT HOUSING GRANT PROGRAM
IS A DESIGNATED FIND EXCLUSIVELY
TO ADDRESS THE HOUSING NEEDS OF
AGRICULTURAL WORKERS ACROSS THE
STATE. WE'VE ALSO TAKEN A
SIMILAR APPROACH IN OTHER POLICY
AREAS FOR EXAMPLE I JUST TWO
YEARS AGO THIS LEGISLATURE
CREATED A SPECIFIC TRIBAL
WILDFIRE PROGRAM. FOCUS FOR
TRIBAL COMMUNITIES. THIS BILL
WILL SUPPORT THE CONSTRUCTION OF
NEW HOMES AND RENOVATION OF
EXISTING ONES IN TROUBLE
COMMUNITIES. WHO HAVE THE
GREATEST NEED THE BILL ALSO
PROVIDES TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO
ASSIST STRIDES TO NAVIGATE THE
COMPLEX WEB OF REGULATIONS THAT
WE ALL KNOW. EXIST HERE IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA TRIBAL
HOUSING PROJECTS. SIMPLY PUT SB
EIGHTEEN IS A HOUSING PROGRAM
DESIGNED BY TRIBES FOR TRIBES
CAN I WITH ME TODAY ELIZABETH
ELLIOTT BECAUSE HE EXPECTS TO
DIRECTOR OF THE NORTHERN CIRCLE
INDIAN HOUSING AUTHORITY. IN
ANALLY TRUJILLO WHO IS THE
EXECUTOR FOR PUBLIC HOUSING
RESOURCE CENTER OF THE POLITY
AND MISSION INDIANS AND GRATEFUL
FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP ON THIS.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
INTERPRET PRETEND STRUCTURE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WHEN. I GO
TO SUPPORT TESTIMONY WILL COME.
GOOD ENOUGH I HAVE MR CHERRY
COMMITTEE IN PLANNING IS
ELIZABETH- WE CURRENT SERVE
EIGHT FEB. RECOGNIZED SPANNING
OVER FOUR COUNTIES IN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA I WANNA THINK
CINNAMON SENATOR MCGUIRE FOR
SEEN IN HEARING THE HOUSING
DISPARITIES PRIZE FROM TRIBAL
NATIONS ACROSS CALIFORNIA. I
PROMISED THE FAMILIES IN MY
COMMUNITIES WHO ARE CURRENTLY
LIVING IN STORAGE CONTAINERS.
AND THE ELDERS LIVING IN SUB
STANDARD HOMES WITHOUT RUNNING
WATER OR ELECTRICITY AND HAVE
BEEN FOR THE LAST FORTY YEARS
WHY SB EIGHTEEN MATTERS. I WANT
TO CALL OUT TO THE COMMITTEE
THAT. WE MUST ACKNOWLEDGE
GOVERNOR PETER BURNETT THE FIRST
GOVERNOR OF CALIFORNIA. IN THE
STATE ADDRESS AND WHERE HE WAGED
A WAR ON THE EXTERMINATION. OF
THE CALIFORNIA TRIBAL NATIONS
AND THAT THAT HAS EXTENDED FOR
ONE HUNDRED AND SEVENTY THREE
YEARS AND A PERFECT EXAMPLE OF
HOW TO ADDRESS STILL LIVES ON.
IS THE BARRIERS STRIDES FACE IN
ACCESSING TROUBLE SET ASIDE. FOR
THE BEACH CD. MY PROGRAM NOR SIR
. WAS AWARDED EIGHT IN FOR THIS
MAY PARTNERS GRANT INTO THOUSAND
EIGHTEEN. TO DATE WE HAVE NO
SIGNS STANDARD AGREEMENT. PASSED
THE COMMITTEE FOR AN AYE VOTE
BECAUSE I'M TIRED OF WATCHING
THE ELDERS IN MY COMMUNITY DIE
WAITING FOR A FOUR PLEX THANK
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. FOR
THE SPEAKER WELCOME. THANK YOU
MR CHAIRMAN. MY NAME IS EMILY
TRUJILLO AND I'M FROM THE POLYP
AND MISSION INDIANS AND SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA- WE HAVE THIRTY TWO
TRIBES WITHIN YOU KNOW OUR AREA.
AND I JUST YOU KNOW OUR ADVOCATE
ADVOCACY FOR TROUBLE HOUSING-
THANK GOD HAS GOTTEN IS HERE
THANK YOU. AND I JUST YOU KNOW.
CALIFORNIA OUR TRIBES WERE THE
FIRST TRIBE TO BE HOMELESS BY A
STATE ACTION. WHEN YOU TALK
ABOUT HOMELESSNESS IT JUST YOU
KNOW TAKE THIS FACT TO THE
DISPLACEMENT OF ALL TRIBES-
WHETHER THE RELOCATED OR THEY
WERE TERMINATED. SO THE FIRST
HOMELESSNESS STARTED WITH TRIBES
TRIBAL NATIONS TRIBAL PEOPLE-
WITH THE PATIENT SB EIGHTEEN- IT
SIGNIFICANTLY NEEDED ACROSS THE
BOARD ON THAT WE HAVE YOU KNOW
PEOPLE THINK OKAY WELL YOU KNOW
DO WE HAVE BEEN IN TYPES AND NOT
ALL TYPES ARE GAMING AND ALL
GAMING TYPES ARE RICH. WE DON'T
HAVE THE CAPACITY- TO HOUSE ALL
OF OUR TRIBAL MEMBERS WHO WE
NEED ASSISTANCE SO WE HAVE BEEN
VERY- VOCAL IN OUR ADVOCACY AND
HOW HOSTING TRIBAL HOUSING
ROACHES ON THE RESERVATION. AND
IF YOU HAVEN'T YET VISITED ONE
OF YOUR- JUST RESERVATIONS IN
YOUR DISTRICTS I REALLY URGE YOU
TO DO SO HE CAN SEE FIRSTHAND OF
THE LACK OF HOUSING- OUR TRIBES
OF. SINCE YOU KNOW S. B. R. A.
B. TEN I'M SORRY IS THE FIRST
TIME THAT WE WERE INCLUDED WITH
THE STATE OF TO PARTICIPATE IN
THE STATE PROGRAMS PRIOR TO THAT
TRIBES HAVE NEVER BEEN INVESTED
IN AT THE STATE LEVEL. AS BUT
PARTICULARLY FOR HOUSING SAID
THIS PROGRAM IS A VERY MUCH
NEEDED THANK YOU FOR THAT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH OKAY WILL NOW GO
TO ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PUBLIC
COMMENT PLEASE JUST STATE YOUR
NAME. AND ORGANIZATION IF
ANYTHING- IF AND SO- WE WELCOME
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON ROSS BUCKLEY
ABOUT THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO IN
SUPPORT. PAMELA LOPEZ ON BEHALF
OF THE TULE RIVER TRIBE IN
SUPPORT. STEVE FRISCH ON BEHALF
OF THE SIERRA BUSINESS COUNCIL
IN SUPPORT HE'S- ENTER DUSTED ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT. SYLVIUS
ELISE SHOT HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FOR THE
COUNTY OF MENDOCINO IN STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU. GIELEN
DOBBINS ON A BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR RURAL
HOUSING IN STRONG SUPPORT. CHRIS
MARTIN WE HAVE A HOUSING
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
CRYSTALLINS FROM ONLY HALF THAT
CALIFORNIANS TRAVEL BUSINESS
ALLIANCE AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
FOR YOUR ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
IN THE ROOM. CRISTINA WE'RE GOOD
OPPOSITION IS OR ANY OPPOSITION
IN THE ROOM. EMAIL WILL GO TO
THE PHONE LINES. IT UP TO A
QUARTER OF. WHAT. THEY ARE
CURRENTLY NOT IN THE QUEUE. OKAY
TERRIFIC WILL BRING BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THIS
BILL. BUT CENTER TO A VOTE- SO I
JUST WANTED TO MAKE A COMMENT
AND- WITH REGARDS TO I WAS PRIVY
TO ATTENDING THE CONFERENCE THAT
THEY HAD WITH THE TRIBES IMPALA
AND RECOGNIZE THE SPEAKERS TODAY
AND I. I WAS REALLY SURPRISED
AND I AND I LEARNED A LOT OF THE
FACTS THE WITNESSES TODAY SHARED
ON THERE AND THEY'RE REALLY IS A
NEED AND WE'VE HAD CONVERSATIONS
IN TRYING TO HELP ME UNDERSTAND
IS I HAVE SEVERAL TRIBES IN MY
IN MY DISTRICT. I WAS REALLY
ENLIGHTENING TO SEE- THE
STRUGGLES THAT THEY HAVE DAYS
WITH NOT JUST HAVING ACCESS BUT
MORE IMPORTANTLY BEING AWARE AND
HOW TO NAVIGATE. THE PROCESS OF.
ACQUIRING A RESOURCES FOR THE
TRIBES THAT ARE AVAILABLE TO
THEM BUT BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE
. MANY MANY PEOPLE WHO
UNDERSTAND THE SYSTEM OR TRAINED
TO NAVIGATE THE SYSTEM THEY JUST
DON'T HAVE ACCESS SO I'M
GRATEFUL FOR THE EFFORT THAT YOU
ARE PUTTING FORTH IN THIS BILL
AND IF I'M NOT ALREADY A CO
AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO BE ADDED AS
A CO AUTHOR ON THIS BILL. THANK
YOU SO MUCH. PEOPLE CENTER. OKAY
SEEING YES- SHOWN BY- SENATOR
JOE BOGAN THAT IS- TO PASSED TO
THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONS. WITH THAT SAID- I
WANT TO THANK GOD FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD THIS IS WHY I DO
THIS IS A FIRST STEP IN TERMS OF
MAKING GOOD- ON OUR HUGE DEBT-
TO OUR- TRIBAL COMMUNITIES FOR
THE EXTREME HARM THAT THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. INFLICTED ON
THEM- AND- IT'S THIS IS- I
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
FIRST STEP FORWARD CERTAINLY
SHOULDN'T BE THE LAST STEP- WHEN
WE LOOK AT THE- LEVELS OF.
POVERTY AND- OTHER- PARTICULARLY
ECONOMIC CHALLENGES FACING
TRIBAL COMMUNITIES. WHICH DOT
STATE AFFAIRS EXISTS. BECAUSE OF
THE WAY THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AND THE UNITED STATES CREATED
TROUBLE COMMUNITIES- AND SO WE
NEED TO- REPAY THAT DEBT AND
THIS MOVES US IN THAT DIRECTION
AND I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR YOU
BRING THIS FORWARD- WITH THAT
WE'VE MOTION YOU MAY CLOSE
RESPECT RESTAURANT I DON'T THINK
YOU SO MUCH SECURE. THANK YOU
THANK YOU- WILL CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR WIENER WIENER FIVE THE
TROUBLED HI THE TROUBLED BY
CLICK HERE. CLICK HERE HI
CABRERO CORTEZ HE- BECAUSE HE
FIVE MCGUIRE. ACQUIRE BY VIDEO
C. R. TWO C. R. TELL HI SKINNER.
NUMBER BOB. THE HOBBIT BY OKAY
THAT HAS A VOTE FOR THE BILL ON
FOR ABSENT. WILL NOW GO TO ITEM
ELEVEN SB SIX TWENTY SENATE
MCGUIRE YOU MAY PROCEED. THANK
YOU SO MUCH MISTER CHAIR INTO
MESSENGER I JUST WANNA SAY HOW
GRATEFUL I AM ONCE AGAIN. FOR
YOUR ENGAGEMENT ON THE OUTDOOR
RECREATION FOR ALL ACT OF COURSE
WILL BE ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS TODAY. AND I CANNOT
SAY HOW MUCH I APPRECIATE YOUR
OPEN IN FEEDBACK ON ALL OF THESE
END UP BEING ABLE TO DELAY IN
THIS YEAR TODAY SO THANK YOU A
CHEERLEADER. AFTER RECREATION
HIT A RECORD HIGH IN TWENTY
TWENTY ONE WITH NINETEEN MILLION
CALIFORNIANS GETTING OUTSIDE. IN
WHEN WE TAKE A LOOK AT OUR
OUTDOOR RECREATION ECONOMY IN
THE STATE ARE AND HOW THE
RECREATION ECONOMY IT'S ACTUALLY
ONE OF OUR LARGEST ECONOMIC
DRIVERS INSTEAD CALIFORNIA'S
WORTH ABOUT FIFTY FOUR BILLION
DOLLARS. CAMPAIGN IN HIKING OUR
TOP TIERS WITHIN AN ECONOMY- IN
INTO MANY CASES THOUGH WHAT WE
KNOW IS THE EXPENSE ASSOCIATED
WITH CAMPING IS OUT OF REACH
FINANCIALLY FOR EVERY DAY
CALIFORNIANS AND NEARLY. HALF OF
ALL CAMPERS REPORT DIFFICULTY
FINDING AVAILABLE CAMPSITES AND
ESPECIALLY COMING OUT OF THE
PANDEMIC I CAMPING WAS
DISCOVERED BY MANY MORE ACROSS
THE STATE IN THE WEST. SO HERE'S
WHAT SB SIX TWENTY WILL DO
CREATE ENHANCED AND MORE
AFFORDABLE ACCESS TO CAMPING BY
STREAMLINING THE PERMITTING
PROCESS FOR SMALL LOW IMPACT
CAMPSITES ALL THE WHILE
ESTABLISHING A NEEDED FRAMEWORK
GUARD RAILS AND REGULATIONS.
GOVERNING THESE NEW SITES
INCLUDING AN IMPORTANT HEALTH
AND SAFETY RATINGS CURRENTLY THE
PROCESS OF OBTAINING A PERMIT TO
OPEN AND OPERATE A CAMPGROUND IN
CALIFORNIA. CAN LEGALLY TAKE
YEARS AND COST HUNDREDS OF
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS TO GET TO
THE APPROVAL PROCESS THE AVERAGE
AMERICAN CAMPGROUND NOW YOU'RE
GOING TO BE- TO WATCH JEOPARDY
TONIGHT. THE AVERAGE U. S.
CAMPGROUND HAS A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY FOUR CAMPSITES IN THERE
ARE SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS.
CAMPGROUNDS ARE ALSO REGULATED
BY THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
HOUSING COMMITTEE DEVELOPMENT
HERE IN THE STATE THAT'S THE
LEAD AGENCY. NACD DOESN'T
DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN A HUNDRED
TWENTY FOUR SPACE CAMPGROUND IN
THE CAMPGROUND THAT MAY HAVE.
NINE OR LESS SPACES SO HERE'S
WHAT THIS BILL WILL DO IT WILL
TAKE A CALM SENSE OF. AND FOCUS
ON THE NET AND THE NEXT.
AVAILABLE POINT. WOULD ALLOW UP
NINE LOW INCOME IMPACT CAMPS BE
TO. UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF A
LOCAL GOVERNMENT CITY OR COUNTY
NOT EACH CD. IT WOULD LIMIT I
HAVE A LIMIT OF FOURTEEN OR
FEWER CONSECUTIVE NIGHTS AT ONE
LOW IMPACT CAMPSITE. IN THAT
MUST BE ENFORCED NO SITES ARE
ALLOWED FOR PERMANENT HUMAN
OCCUPANCY NO ON STREET PARKING
AT HERONS RIGHT TO LOCAL AND
STATE FIRE CODES. ALL PORTANTINO
COOL GOVERNMENT ORDINANCES APPLY
THEY HAVE TO HAVE A POLICY FOR
TRACTION RESTROOMS- THE YOU HAVE
TO COMPLY WITH LOCAL NOISE
ORDINANCES. ALL BAY TAXES
APPLIED OF COURSE A TWENTY FOUR
HOUR PHONE NUMBER MUST BE
AVAILABLE AT LOW EACH LOW IMPACT
CAMPGROUND. SB SIX TWENTY WILL
ALSO EMPOWER LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
TO MANAGE AND OVERSEE LOW IMPACT
CAMPING SITES AND IT'S GONNA
OPEN UP NEW ECONOMIC
OPPORTUNITIES ESPECIALLY. IN
ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED RURAL
COMMUNITIES I HAVE WITH ME
TODAY. AT A- AT A WORLD THEIR
EXCUSE ME UP WITH THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES IN
OF COURSE MATT LINE WHO'S WITH
THE CALIFORNIA OUTDOOR
RECREATION PARTNERSHIP. TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT. AND RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ONE OF TO EARLY WITH A-
HELLO THANK YOU CHAIR AND MA'AM.
WE PREACH YOU OUT OFFERING US
THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME AND
SPEAK TODAY MY NAME'S EIGHT A
WELDER AND I'M A LEGISLATIVE
ADVOCATE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES
WHICH REPRESENTS ALL FIFTY EIGHT
COUNTIES IN CALIFORNIA. HERE IN
PROUD SUPPORT SB SIX TWENTY.
EXISTING STATE PERMITTING
REQUIREMENTS FOR SPECIAL
OCCUPANCY PARKS STREETS
CONFUSION AND POTENTIAL CONFLICT
WITH LOCAL RULES. SB SIX TWENTY
DEFINES AND PROVIDES STANDARDS
FOR LOW IMPACT COUNTY CAMPING
AND POWERS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
REGULATE THIS ACTIVITY IN WAYS
THAT WORK FOR THEIR COMMUNITIES.
THIS BILL WILL HELP MINIMIZE
CONFLICT BY CLARIFYING STATE AND
LOCAL AUTHORITY. ADDITIONALLY
STATEWIDE LAND USE SOLUTIONS
RELATING TO CAMPING ARE NOT ONE
SIZE FITS ALL. ZONING VARIES
WIDELY ACROSS COUNTIES AND
ALLOWING FLEXIBILITY IN THIS
AREA WILL ENSURE LAND IS USED
MOST APPROPRIATELY FOR LOCAL
NEEDS. FOR EXAMPLE PARCELS ZONED
FOR SINGLE FAMILY HOMES IN MANY
COUNTIES ARE ACTUALLY VERY
COMPATIBLE WITH LOW IMPACT
COUNTY CAMPING. AND OTHER
COUNTIES UTILIZE RESIDENTIAL
AGRICULTURAL ZONES WHICH ALLOW
FOR LOW DENSITY SINGLE FAMILY
DWELLINGS. IN ADDITION TO
RECREATIONAL TRAILS WINERIES IN
FARMING ALL OF WHICH ARE
COMPATIBLE USES WITH LOW IMPACT
CAMPING. SEE ZACKS SUPPORTS
EFFORTS LIKE SB SIX TWENTY TO
PROMOTE AGRICULTURAL HISTORIC
AND NATURAL RESOURCES TOURISM
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. ON AVERAGE
CAMPERS SPEND THREE HUNDRED
DOLLARS PER PERSON AT LOCAL
RESTAURANTS CAFES GEAR SHOPS
FARM STANDS AND MORE. THESE
TOURISM DOLLARS STIMULATE LOCAL
ECONOMIES BY PROVIDING
SUSTAINABLE REVENUE FOR SMALL
BUSINESSES AND HELPING CREATE
JOBS. LOW IMPACT CAMPING WOULD
HELP DRIVE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
INTO THESE COMMUNITIES. IN
SUMMARY SB SIX TWENTY WOULD
CLARIFY STATE AND LOCAL
AUTHORITY AND INCREASE ACCESS TO
THE OUTDOORS WHAT PROVIDING
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY TO SMALL
FARMERS RANCHERS AND OTHER SMALL
RURAL BUSINESSES. THE SEX
STRONGLY ENCOURAGES YOU TO
SUPPORT SB SIX TWENTY AND WE
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME TODAY.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO COMMENT
ON SB SIX TWENTY TODAY. MY NAME
IS MATT LYON AND I'M
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
OUTDOOR RECREATION PARTNERSHIP
FOR CORP. CORPORATE PRISONS OVER
AT CALIFORNIA COMPANIES AND
ORGANIZATIONS IN THE OUTDOOR
RECREATION INDUSTRY INCLUDING
GEAR MANUFACTURERS RETAILERS.
GUIDES AND MORE. REGISTRATION
OUT TO RECREATIONAL SKYROCKETED
DURING THE PANDEMIC IN FACT
ABOUT HALF OF ALL CALIFORNIANS
PARTICIPATED IN OUTDOOR
RECREATION LAST YEAR. AT
CAMPAIGN HAS ALSO GROWN IT'S A
GREAT EXAMPLE OF HOW THE OUTER
RECREATION INDUSTRY'S BEEN
RESPONDING TO CHIN CHANGING
CONSUMER PREFERENCES. LOW IMPACT
CAMPING AREAS OFFER A RANGE OF
ACCOMMODATION TYPES AT ALL PRICE
POINTS THAT ARE SPREAD
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. SOME
CAMPING AREAS PROVIDE TENTS AND
OTHER GEAR WHICH CAN BE
INVALUABLE FOR FOLKS WHO ARE
NEWER TO CAMPING AND WHO MAY NOT
HAVE THE MEANS OR KNOWLEDGE TO
PROVIDE THEIR OWN GEAR. HOWEVER
THERE ARE STILL TOO FEW
CAMPSITES TO ACCOMMODATE
CALIFORNIANS WHO WANT TO CAMP.
NEARLY HALF OF ALL CAMPERS
REPORT DIFFICULTY FINDING AN
AVAILABLE SITE. AS A RESULT MORE
THAN HALF OF THOSE WHO STARTED
CAMPING IN THE PAST FEW YEARS
SEPARATELY THEY WILL LIKELY CAMP
LASTS IN THE NEXT YEAR. BECAUSE
THE MAJORITY OF NEW CAMPERS ARE
PEOPLE OF COLOR BARRIERS LIKE
THESE DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACT
POPULATIONS HAVE BEEN
HISTORICALLY EXCLUDED FROM OUTER
SPACE IS. AT THE CORE OF THIS
ISSUE OR EXISTING STATE
PERMITTING REQUIREMENTS. THEY
CAN BE CONFUSING FINANCIALLY
BURDENSOME AN IMP IMPRACTICAL.
ESPECIALLY FOR PROPERTIES WITH
JUST TWO OR THREE TEMPORARY
CAMPSITES. FOR EXAMPLE EXISTING
RECRUIT RULES REQUIRE HOT
SHOWERS IN THE INSTALLATION OF
INTENSE ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING.
THESE REQUIREMENTS DON'T HELP
ENSURE THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
CAMPERS AND DON'T REFLECT
CURRENT CONSUMER PREFERENCES.
BUT THEY DO ADD TO THE CHALLENGE
FOR THE STATE IN MEETING ITS
OUTDOOR ACCESS FOR ALL GOALS. SB
SIX TWENTY DIFFERENCES BETWEEN
COMMERCIAL CAMPGROUNDS AND LOW
IMPACT CAMPING. THE PROPOSED
BILL WOULD ESTABLISH
REQUIREMENTS FOR LOW IMPACT
CAMPING. THAT ARE APPROPRIATE
AND RIGHT SIZED HIS ACTIVITY. IN
SUMMARY THIS BILL WOULD INCREASE
THE SUPPLY OF OUTER
ACCOMMODATIONS AT ALL PRICE
POINTS. TO MEET THE CURRENT AND
EXPECTED INCREASED DEMAND. LOW
IMPACT CAMPING HELPS PROVIDE THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS
TO EXPERIENCE THE BENEFITS
THEY'RE DOORS. WE RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST- YOUR VOTES FOR SB SIX
TWENTY AND I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TIME AND CONSIDERATION. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE ANY
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE ROOM.
PLEASE COME FORWARD AND PLEASE
TAKE YOUR NAME AND YOUR
ORGANIZATION IF ANY. HELLO
ALYSSA REVISI N. FOUNDER AND CEO
OF HIPPOCAMPAL ASTRO IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL THANK YOU THANK
YOU. FOR THE ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
COMMON IN THE ROOM. THREE NINE
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
ROOM. THREE NINE WILL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES. IT FOR THIS. POINT
IN FEAR. AT IT UP BEFORE. IF I'M
SORRY YOU'RE YOU'RE CUTTING OUT
A LITTLE BIT- MODERATOR. SOMEONE
HAD USED UP ONE MOMENT WHILE
THEIR FLIGHT. THANK YOU. IN FACT
IT WILL. TO BLOCK THAT OUT IT AT
. LARA FOUNDER AND CEO OF FOR
AFRO FUNK AND FUNK FORD FELL.
THERE IS CURRENTLY NO ONE ELSE
IN THE QUEUE. GREAT WE WILL-
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE-
OTHER ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
MOTION BY SENATOR JOE BOGAN
THAT'S TO PASS AS AMENDED TO THE
COMMUTER APPROPRIATIONS I WANT
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR WORKING
WITH US IS A TOTAL COMMONSENSE.
BILL WE HAVE REGULATIONS IN
PLACE FOR TRADITIONAL CAMPSITES
TO MAKE SURE THERE'S ADEQUATE
PLUMBING IT CETERA AND THAT
MAKES ALL THE SENSE IN THE WORLD
BUT FOR SMALLER- SITES IT REALLY
IS A HUGE BARRIER AND ESPECIALLY
IN THESE MORE RURAL AREAS WHERE
YOU WANT TO. YOU KNOW HAVE
ACTIVATION AND DRAW PEOPLE AND
HAS ECONOMIC BENEFITS ETCETERA
TO MAKE SENSE TO HAVE MORE
FLEXIBILITY FOR THE SMALLER
SITES SO. YOU BRING THE VOTE
FORWARD THANK YOU FOR WORKING
WITH US TO MAKE SURE THAT MORE
URBANIZED IN FILL AREAS ARE NOT-
A PART OF THIS I DON'T THINK
THERE WAS EVER YOUR INTENT AND
SO I APPRECIATE YOU- WORKING
WITH US ON AMENDMENTS. BOTTOM
HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE BILL AS
AMENDED- SO WITH THAT YOU MAY
CLOSE THE COMMISSION'S CHAIRMAN
COULD YOU WORK I THINK THAT
THERE'S SOME ADDITIONAL
TIGHTENING UP ON THE BILL THAT
WE CAN. ENHANCE MEMBERS WHO WILL
BE TOUCH THEY PUT YOU ON THAT
INIZIO MISS WILDER AT AN APOLOGY
TO BECAUSE BECAUSE I PUT YOUR
NAME SO I DO WANT TO APOLOGIZE
ABOUT THAT AND I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR IN A BOAT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WE'LL SEE WE
CAN MAKE- BLOOPER REEL OF. OF
LEGISLATORS WHO WHO MESS UP THE
NAMES. OF THEIR LEAD WITNESSES.
ALL GIVE OF THAT FROM TIME TO
TIME I TOLD. IS OKAY- WITH-
WE'VE MOTION BY CENTER OF BOGAN
WE WILL CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER HI WIENER I HOPE ROBO I
THE TROUBLE BY FLICKS FEAR.
CABALLERO CORTESE. COURTESY BY
MICHAEL. ACQUIRE BY THE DHEA
SEYARTO SKINNER. SKINNER HI
BURKE BOB HI BOB HI. AM PLEASED
. THANKS BYE. WE'LL PUT THAT ON
CALL CALL. I DON'T YOU CAN CATCH
A LATER- OKAY WE HAVE ONE FINAL
BILL HAVEN'T HEARD IS. A CENTER
SKINNER IS AS FOR FORTY WERE IS
ITEM SIXTEEN. AS YOU MAY PRESENT
BILL.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR. MEMBERS
PLEASE TO PRESENT- SB FOUR
FORTY- ARE FOR THE FIRST START
WITH I'M ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS WHICH WILL
BE TAKEN AS AUTHORS AMENDMENTS
IN SENATE GOVERNOR GOVERNMENT
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. AND
THOSE ARE THAT REQUIRE EACH A
FACE TO SHOW HOW THE FUNDS
RAISED WOULD COMPLEMENT EXISTING
HOUSING RESOURCES. AND FILL
NECESSARY GAPS IN FUNDING
REQUIRES AN ACCOUNT OF HOW
EXPENDITURES AND PROJECTS WILL
MEET SPECIFIC HOUSING NEEDS
WITHIN A HOUSING FINANCE
AUTHORITY'S JURISDICTION- AS WE
ARE ALL KEENLY AWARE CALIFORNIA
IS FACING A SEVERE HOUSING
SHORTAGE WE NEED MILLIONS OF NEW
HOMES AND- LOTS OF PUBLIC
DOLLARS. IN ORDER TO PROVIDE THE
FINANCING FOR THE NON MARKET
RATE HOUSING AND THE BIGGEST
OBSTACLE NOW TO OUR NON MARKET
RATE HOUSING IS FINANCING AND
WHAT S. BEFORE FORTY DOES IS IT
EMPOWERS THOSE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
WHO ARE WILLING TO JOIN TOGETHER
TO CREATE REGIONAL HOUSING
FINANCE AGENCIES. THAT CAN
GENERATE REVENUE TO ACQUIRE LAND
AND CONSTRUCT PRESERVE AND
MANAGE AFFORDABLE IN MISSING
MIDDLE HOUSING IN THEIR REGIONS.
SO WHAT ELSE BEFORE FORTY WILL
DO IS HELP THOSE REGIONS WHERE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND OTHER
LOCAL AUTHORITIES WANT TO
COOPERATE TOGETHER. ELIMINATING
THE NEED FOR US IN THE
LEGISLATURE TO HAVE TO DO ONE
OFF LEGISLATION EACH TIME A
LOCAL AUTHORITY WANTS TO
COOPERATE IN THIS WAY- LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO CHOOSE THIS PATH
WILL STILL HAVE TO FOLLOW
EXISTING LAWS. AND GET VOTER
APPROVAL FOR ANY FINANCING THAT
THE USE THAT REQUIRES VOTER
APPROVAL IT DOES NOT SUSPEND ANY
OF THAT AND WITH THAT I'D LIKE
ME WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF STEVE
FIRST FOR MOUNTAIN HOUSING
COUNCIL. FROM TAHOE IN THE
TURKEY AREA AND MARINO WYANT.
FROM THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
CONSORTIUM. MAY FIFTH. GOOD
AFTERNOON MR CHAIRMAN OF THE CAN
C. FRESH WITH THIS. IS COUNCIL
RIGHT INTO OF SB FOUR FORTY. OUR
REGION HAS DONE ALMOST
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO TRY TO
ADVANCE AFFORDABLE AND
ACHIEVABLE HOUSING. THE MOUNTAIN
HOUSING COUNCIL IS A COALITION
OF TWENTY NINE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
SPECIAL DISTRICTS AND NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATIONS IN THE NORTH LAKE
TAHOE TRUCKEE REGION WORKING TO
ADVANCE- HOUSING GOALS. WE HAVE
INCLUDED- RAISING LOCAL
DEDICATED TAXES ALLOCATING
PORTIONS OF GENERAL FUND
GOVERNMENT BUDGETS- GOING FOR
PRO HOUSING DESIGNATIONS FROM H.
C. D. FUNDING DEED RESTRICTION
UNITS AND PUTTING IN STRICT
SHORT TERM RENTAL LIMITS BUT
WITH ALL OF THOSE ACTIONS. WE'VE
BEEN UNABLE TO REALLY ADDRESS
OUR HOUSING CRISIS. WE SUPPORT
SB FOUR FORTY BECAUSE IT IT
ANSWERS THREE KEY QUESTIONS FOR
US NUMBER ONE WE WERE ALREADY IN
THE PROCESS OF CREATING A
REGIONAL HOUSING FINANCE
AUTHORITY. AND THIS CLARIFIES
THE PROCESS THE GOVERNANCE
STRUCTURE IN THE RULES AROUND
THAT WHICH IS MOST WELCOME.
SECOND IT ALLOWS LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS INCLUDING CITIES
COUNTIES AND SPECIAL DISTRICTS
TO WORK TOGETHER AND POOLING
FUNDS FOR HOUSING WHICH IS A
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT OBJECTIVE
IN OUR REGION. AND THIRD AND
FINALLY IT ALLOWS THE
AUTHORITIES TO ISSUE REVENUE
BONDS TO HELP SPEED THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE HOUSING
POLICIES IN THE LOCAL REGION. WE
WELCOME SB FOUR FORTY ARE STRONG
IN SUPPORT AND WELCOME THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WERE- SUBMITTED
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS RAIN
WIND WITH THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
CONSORTIUM AND A PROUD SPONSOR
OF SB FOUR FORTY- DESPITE
SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENTS IN
RECENT YEARS THE STATE CONTINUES
TO LACK COMMITTED ONGOING
FUNDING AT THE SKILL NECESSARY
TO PRODUCT MAKE PROGRESS TOWARDS
OUR ONE POINT TWO MILLION. HOME
GAP FOR OUR LOWEST INCOME
CALIFORNIANS AND AS AN EXAMPLE-
OF THAT FUNDING NEED THAT STATES
MHP PROGRAM WAS OVER SUBSCRIBED
TEN TO ONE IN THE LAST FUNDING
ROUND. MANY REGIONS ALIKE- MAKE
CHECK FOR ABOUT HOUSING NEEDS IN
THEIR COMMUNITIES AND IN
PARTICULAR TO RAISE FUNDS FOR
THE DEVELOPMENT AND ACQUISITION
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING HOWEVER
THE EXISTING TOOLS HAVE
SHORTFALLS THIS IS WHY THE BAY
AREA SPONSORED AB FOURTEEN
EIGHTY SEVEN IN TWENTY TWENTY
AND LOS ANGELES COUNTY SPONSORED
SICK SB SIX SEVENTY NINE IN
TWENTY TWENTY TWO. TO SABOTAGE A
SINGLE UNIFIED APPROACH TO
DRESSING HOUSING INSTABILITY IN
THE REGION. AS BEFORE FORTY SIX
TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF IT THIS
INNOVATIVE FUNDING MODEL FOR
HOUSING BY ALLOWING ALL REGIONS
IN CALIFORNIA TO CREATE THEIR
OWN HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY
WITHOUT NEEDING TO COME TO THE
LEGISLATURE FIRST. THE BILL WHAT
OUGHT. OF WILL AVOID RESTATING
WHAT THE AUTHORS THAT I'M HAVING
ANY QUESTIONS AND RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE TODAY.
THANK YOU ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
TESTIMONY PLEASE COME FORWARD.
ANDREW DAWSON THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AND SUPPORT
. PRESS UP ON BEHALF OF CIVIC
WELL IN SUPPORT. ANYONE ELSE.
THREE NINE ANY OPPOSITION.
PLEASE COME FORWARD. CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
JENNIFER SECOND HALF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS HERE IN OPPOSITION TO
US BEFORE FORTY. UNLESS IT IS
AMENDED TO LIMIT THE POWERS
CONVEYED TO POSE LOCAL
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AGENCIES
AUTHORIZED TO BE ESTABLISHED
WITHOUT LIMITATION THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIA. I SHOULD KNOW AS
BEFORE FORTY IS VASTLY DIFFERENT
FROM THE HOUSING AGENCIES WHICH
WERE ESTABLISHED IN THE BAY AREA
AND LOS ANGELES. AS BEFORE FORTY
WOULD AUTHORIZE TWO OR MORE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO ESTABLISH A
REGIONAL HOUSING FINANCE
AUTHORITY TO RAISE PROPERTY
TAXES TO FUND CORPORATE
PURCHASES OF SINGLE FAMILY HOMES
WHICH ARE NECESSARY TO
FACILITATE GENERATIONAL WHAT THE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR FIRST TIME
HOME BUYERS AND LOW AND MODERATE
INCOME FAMILIES. AS BEFORE FORTY
WITH GRANTS VAST UNCHECKED
BONDING AND TAXING AUTHORITY TO
AN UNELECTED AGENCY BOARD WHICH
WOULD CONSIST OF THREE APPOINTED
REPRESENTATIVES FROM TWO LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS THAT CAN IMPOSE
SPECIAL TAXES ON REAL PROPERTY.
INCLUDING A PERSONAL TAX GROSS
RECEIPTS TAX BUSINESS LICENSE
TAX SPECIAL BUSINESS TAX OR
DOCUMENTARY TRANSFER TAX SPECIAL
INTACS VALUE WHEN PAUL TAX AND
COMMERCIAL IN CLINTON COUNTRY.
THE PROPOSED AGENCY REQUIRES
REVENUES GENERATED TO ASSIST IN
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PRESERVATION
INCLUDING THE ACQUISITION
REHABILITATION ANNEKE AND
EXPANDED D. RESTRICTIONS WHICH
ENCOURAGES THE REMOVAL OF
NATURALLY OCCURRING AFFORDABLE
MARKET RATE HOUSING FROM THE
PRIVATE MARKET. IN FAVOR OF
CREATING MORE RENTAL HOUSING
WITHOUT CONSTRUCTING ANY NEW
UNITS NECESSARY. TO BRIDGE THE
STATE'S HOUSING SUPPLY SHORTAGE.
M. ARE ILL EQUIPPED TO. COMPETE
WITH ALL CASH OFFERS WHICH WOULD
FACILITATE THE STATE FURTHER
REDUCING HOMEOWNERSHIP
OPPORTUNITIES STATEWIDE. IN FACT
THE VAST UNCHECKED BONDING IN
TAXING AUTHORITY GRANTED TO THIS
AGENCY WILL NEGATIVELY IMPACT.
MARKET RATE HOMEOWNERSHIP AND
DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES BY
PUTTING THE DREAM FOR OF WATER
QUALITY. THROUGH HOMEOWNERSHIP
OUT OF REACH FOR STATES WORKING
FAMILIES. ACCORDING TO DATA
COLLECTED BY THE CALIFORNIA
STATE CONTROLLER'S OFFICE FOR
THE YEARS TWENTY NINETEEN TO
TWENTY TWENTY. AB VALOREM
PROPERTY TAXES COLLECTED FROM
PROPERTY OWNERS EQUAL SEVENTY
FOUR POINT FOUR BILLION DOLLARS
ANNUALLY. COMBINED WITH EXISTING
FIFTY TWO HUNDRED SPECIAL
DISTRICTS WHICH ALREADY COLLECT
AN ESTIMATED SEVENTY NINE POINT
SIX SEVEN BILLION DOLLARS. PAID
FOR ENTIRELY BY HOMEOWNERS TO
FIND A WIDE VARIETY OF VARIETY
OF SERVICES AND PROGRAMS. IF YOU
COULD- WRAP UP FOR THE- AS
HOMEOWNERS STRUGGLE TO FOR THE
MONTHLY MORTGAGE THEY SHOULD NOT
ALSO BE FORCED TO FROM THE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
OF DEED RESTRICTED AFFORDABLE.
RENTAL HOUSING WHICH SHOULD BE
BORNE BY SOCIETY AND DEVELOPERS
BENEFITING FROM THE ACQUISITION.
OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THESE
UNITS FOR THESE REASONS WE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR HELP. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. ANY OTHER
OPPOSITION IN THE ROOM. SITTING
THAT WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
. EIGHT OF WHICH TO MAKE A
COMMENT IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE THERE ARE. SOME
. YOU HAD SOMEONE THAT HAD
QUEUED UP ONE MOMENT WATER LINE
NUMBER IS GIVEN.
AND WE'LL BE GOING TO LINE ONE
WELL. GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
NATALIE DR THE CALIFORNIA
BUSINESS ROUNDTABLE WE ARE
OPPOSED. THERE'S CURRENTLY NO
ONE ELSE IN THE QUEUE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH FOR ME BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS CENTER BIKES HERE IN
CENTER COURTESY JUST BRIEFLY- BY
APPRECIATE THIS BILL AND I THINK
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS HAVE THE ABILITY TO
GET INVOLVED IN BUILDING BUYING
CREATING HOUSING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING- IT SEEMS VERY SIMILAR
TO THE BILL FROM HIS SENATOR
RUBIO THAT WE HEARD IN SEVEN
FIVE AND I WAS JUST WONDERING
IF. IS THERE SOME OVERLAP THERE
THAT. ARRAF FROM. I'M A THAT
BILL IS GOT LIMITATIONS ON- WHAT
ENTITIES CAN PARTICIPATED DITION
ONLY CAN ONLY BE FOR THE LOWEST
INCOME AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND
THIS IS A LITTLE BROADER-
BECAUSE AS WE KNOW SOMETIMES-
I'M A MIXED USE. PROJECT MAY END
UP BEING FIND IT MORE
FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE EVEN FOR-
FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WHO ARE
DOING THE DEVELOPMENT THEN AB
1100% SUBSIDIZED- PROPERTY. SO
THOSE ARE SOME OF THE
DIFFERENCES AND WHILE THIS BILL
DOES REQUIRE IT MUST BE MAJORITY
OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS LIKE CITIES
AND COUNTIES IT WOULD ALSO
ENABLE SAY A SCHOOL DISTRICT.
AND THE BENEFIT OF THAT IS
SCHOOL DISTRICTS CAN OWN LAND
BUT THEY HAVE NO THEY DO NOT
HAVE THE EXPERTISE FOR- FOR
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WHERE IS THE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS BUT NOT
EVERYONE BUT MORE OF THEM HAVE
THAT CAPACITY AND THAT IN HOUSE
EXPERTISE. SO IT ALLOWS.
LOCALITIES TO BE ABLE TO JOIN
TOGETHER AND THEN I JUST WANT
YOU KNOW I CAN DO THIS AND CLOSE
BUT I JUST WANT TO REFERENCE I
THINK THE- AT THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS KNOWS
FULL WELL THAT NONE OF THE
TAXING- ACTIONS THAT. DESCRIBED
IN THEIR OPPOSITION COULD BE
ENACTED WITHOUT VOTER APPROVAL
SO THIS IS NOT ELIMINATE ANY OF
THOSE VOTER APPROVAL SO IT DOES
NOT ALLOW FOR THESE LOCALITIES
THAT COME TOGETHER IN THIS
COOPERATIVE WAY. TO DO THAT
WITHOUT. VOTER APPROVAL OKAY
THANK YOU. INTERPRETERS THE- MR
TERRY JUST WANTED THANK YOU
AUTHOR FOR DOING THIS FOR BRING
THIS FORWARD AND I KNOW. BECAUSE
WE'RE BOTH FROM OF THE BAY AREA
REGION- THAT THE YOU KNOW THE
ORIGINAL ONE OFF MODEL FOR THIS
IF YOU WILL FUTURE WORDS WITH
SOME. THE SOME INFORMERS SO
MEMBER CHOOSE SEPARATE THAT- ALL
SORTS HERE WAS INVOLVED WITH-
PUSHY AT THE TIME AND I DON'T
KNOW YOU WERE- AND THEN LAST
YEAR- CENTER CALL MARKERS BILL.
UP FOR THE LOS ANGELES AREA AND
NOW WE HAVE TO BUT WE DON'T HAVE
THE ABILITY FOR EVERYONE SO. I
THINK THE OUTCOME YOU'RE LOOKING
FOR IS SMART IN EFFICIENT. AND
EFFECTIVE AND- YOU KNOW I'M I'M
HAVE TO SUPPORT THE BILL-
CLEARLY THIS IS JUST ENABLING
LEGISLATION THAT ALLOWS-
ENTITIES YOU KNOW AGENCIES OR
REGIONS TO GO FORWARD AND THINK
ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT THEY WANT
TO TRY TO CONVINCE THE VOTERS OR
SOMETHING BUT THEY CAN'T DO THAT
UNLESS. THEY FIRST HAVE- A
MAJORITY IN PLACE THAT WOULD
ACTUALLY. BE ABLE TO MOVE
FORWARD WITH WITH ANY KIND OF A
REVENUE OPPORTUNITY SO THIS THE
FIRST STEP IN THE STILL IN THE
HANDS OF THE VOTERS LIKE YOU
SAID I THINK IT'S SO. THE WHOLE
CONCEPT IS LONG OVERDUE WE HEARD
IN THE INFORMATIONAL HEARINGS
THAT HOUSING COMMITTEE- PUT
TOGETHER- I KNOW ONE OF THE
WITNESSES WHO SPOKE- FROM THE
INDUSTRY SIDE. SAID YOU KNOW THE
THING WE NEED MOST HIS HELP WITH
POIGNANT SCENE IN IN EXACTLY
THIS TYPE OF THING SO. I'M SORRY
TO GO ON BUT I'M JUST A VERY
ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THE BILL AND
I'D BE HAPPY TO COME ON AS A CO
AUTHOR THANK YOU EVEN CONSIDER
THAT THING UP SO WE WOULD.
DEFINITELY CONSIDER THAT THANK
YOU ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS OKAY SEEING NONE- THANK
YOU FOR WORKING WITH US AND I
KNOW YOU'LL BE TAKING THE
MEASUREMENTS AND GOVERNMENT
FINANCES HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE
BILL TODAY. SO WITHOUT- I WILL
HAVE- THAT'S FOR A MOTION. TO
MOVE THE BILL- TO COME IN
FINANCE. OKAY RUSSIAN WITH
INTERPRETERS IT. YOU MAY CLOSE-
SB VOTE. THANK YOU WILL CALL THE
ROLL. SENATOR WIENER RIGHT
WIENER BY THE TRUMP. THE TWO.
NOW CLICK HERE. THANKS BYE
CARREIRO CORTESE. BECAUSE THE
HIGH REGARD. FOR DHEA. THEY ARE
TO. SKINNER BY SKINNER FIVE
NUMBER. UNDER FIVE WILL HAVE.
BOB THE- WE WILL PUT THAT ON
CALL. THERE IS. A AYE. CABALLERO
HI. THE COVER. ONE GOOD FOR THE
POSITION ON COMMITTEE. AND OKAY
SO PUT ON BACK ON CALL. BUT THAT
ON CALLS OKAY SO WE'VE NOW
COMPLETED THE EVERYTHING IS ON
CALL- WE HAVE. ONE TWO THREE
FOUR FIVE SIX EIGHT NINE. A KEY
VOTER EVERYTHING. K. WE'RE
WITNESSING TO BE NOW PHOTOS
VIDEOS APPS AND SO. WE'RE JUST
WAITING FOR SAY IS. THIS COMING
BACK. AFTER THE. RESOURCE COMING
BACK IMMINENTLY. OKAY SO WAS HIS
WAY LIKE A OR TWO- SO WE DON'T
WANT TO GO THROUGH EVERYTHING
AND.
RIGHT.
CHIEF. YEAH IT'S GOING TO BE.
OKAY VETERANS HERE TO OPEN THE
IN EVERY WILL START WITH ITEM
NUMBER ONE BEFORE FIFTY BY
CENTER- PLEASE CALL THE MEMBERS
SENATE- CABALLERO CAVALEIRO HI
MCGUIRE ACQUIRE I DO THERE ARE
TWO. THERE TOTAL SNOW SKI.
SKINNER I. AMONG THE ONE. THE
VOTE IS GOING TO ONE OF THE BILL
IS OUT. NEXT ITEM NUMBER TWO SB
THREE FIFTY SIX BY SENATOR ARCH
ALETTA- PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. SENATOR PADILLA SKINNER
. SKINNER HI. THE VOTERS TEND
ZERO AND THAT BILL IS ALEX. NEXT
IS ITEM THREE SB THIRTY FOUR BY
SENATOR PORTANTINO PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR PER
DIEM SKINNER. FIVE SKINNER AM
BERG FIVE NUMBER FIVE. EIGHTY
THE VOTERS EIGHT TO TWO AND THE
BILL ITSELF. CEMEX IS ITEM FOR
AS BEFORE SIXTY NINE BY SENATOR
ALLEN PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS CENTER PADILLA SKINNER
SKINNER I AM BERG BURKE BY.
NUMBER IS TEN ZERO AND THE BILL
IS OUT. NEXT IS ITEM FIVE SP
FIVE EIGHTY FOUR BY CENTER LIMÓN
WILL CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
UNDER VIDEO SKINNER SKINNER I
NUMBER NUMBER HI EIGHTY TWO THE
ROAD IS A TO AND THAT BILL IS
OUT- NEXT IS ITEM SIX SB FIVE
NINETY SEVEN BY CENTER GLAZER
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
SENATOR CABALLERO. CAVALEIRO HI
VIDEO SKINNER. SKINNER I NUMBER.
NUMBER I. NEED TO TAKE THE
VOTERS EIGHT TO TWO AND THAT
BILL IS OUT. NEXT WE'LL GO TO
ITEM SEVEN SB SIX THIRTY FOUR BY
SENATOR PACKER PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. SENATOR TOLD
VOGUE. CABALLERO CARRERO BY THE
DHEA SEYARTO. SEYARTO NOW
SKINNER SKINNER HI NUMBER NUMBER
HI. IT TO ONE THAT BILL IS HOUSE
NEXT IS ITEM NUMBER EIGHT SB
SEVEN BY SENATOR PLACE HERE
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
SENATOR CHOI BOGUE. SB SEVEN.
INDIA ENTER. SKINNER I NUMBER.
BURKE HI. EIGHT THE VOTERS TO
ONE THE BILL IS OUT. NEXT IS
ITEM NUMBER NINE S. B. FORTY TWO
BY SENATOR PLACE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR CABALLERO
. CABALLERO HI VIDEO SEYARTO ALL
RIGHT CERAKOTE HI SKINNER
SKINNER I NUMBER. NUMBER I. THE
VOTERS TEND TO ZERO AND THE
BILL'S HOUSE. NEXT IS ITEM
NUMBER TEN S. B. EIGHTEEN BY
CENTER MCGUIRE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. SENATOR
CABALLERO CARO HI VIDEO SKINNER
. SKINNER HI NUMBER. TWO HUNDRED
FIVE. THE VOTERS TEND TO ZERO
AND THE BILL IS. FIVE NEXT ITEM
ELEVEN SB SIX TWENTY BY CENTER
MCGUIRE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. CARREIRO CAMARO HI
VIDEO. THERE ARE TWO ZERO TWO HI
I'M BURKE NUMBER I. THE VOTERS
TEND ZEROED BILL IS OUT. NEXT IS
ITEM TWELVE ASSEMBLY NEXUS THE
CONSENT AGENDA WHICH IS ITEM
TWELVE SB NINETY ONE BY CENTER-
BURKE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS- VIDEO SKINNER. SKINNER
HI NUMBER NUMBER HI. THE LOTUS
TO THE ZERO THE CONSENT AGENDA
IS APPROVED- NEXT IS ITEM
THIRTEEN S. B. TWO FORTY BY
SENATOR OCHO BOTH PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR
CABALLERO. CARREIRO HI VIDEO
SKINNER FIVE SKINNER I AM BURKE.
BURKE BY. THE VOTER TEND TO ZERO
IN THE BILL IS OUT. NEXT IS ITEM
FIFTEEN SB SEVEN FORTY FIVE BY
SENATOR CORTEZ THE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS SENATOR
CABRERO. CABRERO HI VIDEO
SEYARTO. SKINNER SKINNER BY A
BURKE ALL RIGHT NUMBER BY. ONE
OF THE VOTERS FIVE EIGHT TO ONE
AND THE BILL IS OUT AND THEN
FINALLY- ITEM SIXTEEN S. BEFORE
FORTY BY CENTER SKINNER PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS CENTER
PADILLA. THERE ARE TWO. THEY'RE
TOUGH NOW EIGHTY SEVEN WAS
EIGHTY TWO AND THAT BILL IS OUT
THE RESPONSE. OKAY SO THAT I CAN
SEARCH I WANT TO THEM. SOUTH
MEMBERS OF- AND WE ARE ADJOURNED
.