GOOD MORNING THE SENATE
EDUCATION COMMITTEE WILL COME TO
ORDER THE SENATE CONTINUES TO
WELCOME THE PUBLIC IN PERSON AND
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE AREAS FOR
INDIVIDUALS WISHING PROVIDE
PUBLIC COMMENT TODAY'S PETITION
NUMBER IS. 877-226-8216 AGAIN
THAT'S 877-226-8216 IN THE
ACCESS CODE FOR THIS COMMITTEE
HEARING IS. 621-761-6217
716-162-1716 ONE NOW WE ARE
HOLDING A COMMITTEE HEARINGS
HERE IN THE- STREET BUILDING I
ASK ALL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
TO BE PRESENT. IN ROOM TWENTY
ONE HUNDRED GOOD MORNING SIR SO
WE CAN ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM AND
BEGIN OUR HEARING WE HAVE
SIXTEEN BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA
NINE OF THOSE BILLS RUN CONSENT
THE CONSENT BILLS ARE AS FOLLOWS
ITEM NUMBER ONE SB SIXTY ONE BY
SENATOR DODD. ITEM NUMBER SIX SB
TWO TO THREE BY CENTER MENJIVAR
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AS BEFORE
SEVENTY TWO BY SENATOR TADO ITEM
NUMBER TEN BY SENATOR STERN ITEM
OR ELEVEN BY SENATOR COUPLE
EUROFIGHTER NUMBER TWELVE SB TEN
BY CENTER CORTESE ITEM NUMBER
FOURTEEN BY CENTER- CHOI BOGUE
ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN. BY SENATOR
JOE BOGUE AND ITEM NUMBER
SIXTEEN BY SENATOR NEWMAN-
BEFORE HE BE HERE PRESENTATION
ON THE BILLS LET US ESTABLISH A
QUORUM WE DO NOT HAVE A QUORUM.
WE WILL START. AS A
SUBCOMMITTEE- WE WILL SKIP OF
THAT. AND LET US START WITH THE
FIRST BILLS FIRST BILL IS SB
NINETY EIGHT FROM SENATOR
PORTANTINO GOOD MORNING CENTER
PORTANTINO- WELCOME- PLEASE
PROCEED WHEN RATES. MORNING MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. IT'S GOOD TO
BE BACK IN COMMITTEE IT'S GOOD
TO HAVE YOU HERE THANK YOU- MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS- SB NINETY
EIGHT WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
FUNDING TO LOCAL EDUCATIONAL
AGENCIES BASED ON AN AVERAGE
DAILY. ENROLLMENT INSTEAD OF
ALLEN AVERAGE DAILY ATTENDANCE
ENROLLMENT BASED FUNDING
INSURANCE QUOTES EQUITY AND HOW
OUR SCHOOLS ARE FUNDED AND ALSO
MAKES IT EASIER FOR DISTRICTS TO
PLAN THEIR BUDGETS AND
OPERATIONS. CALIFORNIA'S
CALCULATED SCHOOL FUNDING USED
USED ON A THAT TENANTS METHOD
FOR DECADES- AT AVERAGE DAILY
ATTENDANCE IS ALWAYS EQUAL. TO
OR LESS THAN ENROLLMENT. BECAUSE
STUDENTS MAY BE ABSENT WHETHER
EXCUSED OR UNEXCUSED BESIDES
CALIFORNIA IS THE ONLY OTHER
STATE THAT USES THIS ATTENDANCE
BASED FUNDING MODEL INCLUDE
IDAHO KENTUCKY MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI AND TEXAS. GOD LOVE
THOSE STATES BUT I DON'T KNOW IF
WE WANT TO BE FUNDING THE SAME
WAY THAT THEY FIND IN THE
STATE'S MOST STATES BASE SCHOOL
FUNDING ON THE AVERAGE
ENROLLMENT FOR TWO AS AVERAGE
DAILY MEMBERSHIP. WHICH IS A
MORE EQUITABLE MEMBER WAY TO DO
ATTENDANCE- TO BETTER METHOD IN
FACT SCHOOLS THAT SERVE LOW
INCOME FAMILIES ARE
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTED BY
FINANCE. FINANCIALLY PENALIZING
SCHOOLS REPORT TENANTS BASICALLY
SCHOOL HAS TO BUDGET. THEIR YEAR
BASED ON THE NUMBER OF KIDS THAT
ARE ENROLLED. AND THEN
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR AS PEOPLE
ARE TEN- ARE ABSENT WE TAKE
MONEY AWAY FROM THOSE SCHOOLS
BUT THE COSTS STAY THE SAME. SO
WHY ARE WE PENALIZING. SCHOOLS
WHEN WE SHOULD BE HELPING THEM
WE SEE. FUNDING IN OUR EDUCATION
SYSTEM THE LAST YEAR WAS A
FANTASTIC YEAR WE STILL NEED TO
DO BETTER THIS IS A BETTER WAY
TO DO IT AND THAT'S WHY MOST
STATES USE THIS METHOD. SB
NINETY EIGHT ATTEMPTS TO FIX
THIS ISSUE BY ALLOWING. SCHOOL
DISTRICTS TO RECEIVE ADDITIONAL
FUNDING. USING THE DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN THEIR FUNDING BASED ON
ATTENDANCE UNDER THE LCF BATH
AND WHAT THEY WOULD RECEIVE
BASED ON ENROLLMENT WE ALSO WANT
TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S
ACCOUNTABILITY BUILT INTO THE
BILL WHICH THERE IS WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE GO AFTER-
CHRONIC TRUE IT- ABSENCES WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
INCENTIVIZE. BEING AN IN CLASS
WHICH WE DO THE BILL THE AS- AND
SO WE THINK IT NOT ONLY AS AN-
WAY TO DO THIS. BUT ALSO MORE
CANNIBAL. TO DO THIS IT'S GOT
INCENTIVES- WITH ME TODAY WE
HAVE OUR- STATE SUPERINTENDENT.
I WHO'S GOING TO BE OUR KEY
WITNESS WE ALSO HAVE MISTER
MEYERS FROM THAT CALIFORNIA
SCHOOL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
I'M SURE A NUMBER OF OTHER
FOLKS. ARE HERE ADVOCATE SO.
MISTER SUPERINTENDENT PLEASE
COMMA AND GOOD MORNING
SUPERINTENDED PUBLIC INSTRUCTION
IS TONY THURMOND WELCOME THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS THANK
YOU CENTER PORTANTINO. I'M
PLEASED TO BE HERE AS A SPONSOR.
OF SB NINETY EIGHT AND TO SPEAK
TO WHY WE THINK IT'S IMPORTANT.
I WOULD ECHO IN PLUS ONE ALL THE
THINGS THAT YOU HEARD FROM THE
SENATOR. RIGHT NOW BUT WHY THIS
IS SO IMPORTANT TO SCHOOL
DISTRICTS I SPENT ABOUT. TEN
YEARS WORKING WITH SCHOOL
DISTRICTS AT WHERE. CHRONIC
ABSENTEEISM AS ONE OF OUR-
TOUGHEST ISSUES IT IS AN ISSUE
THAT WE CAN IMPROVE. WHAT'S
NEVER BEEN LOST ON ME IS THAT
THERE IS A BUILT IN INCENTIVE TO
HELP OUR SCHOOLS DO MORE. AROUND
REDUCING CHRONIC ABSENTEEISM
THEY SIMPLY LOSE MONEY EVERY
SINGLE TIME A STUDENT IS NOT
PRESENT. IN SCHOOL FOR WHATEVER
REASON WHETHER SICK OR THEIR
OTHER TRANSPORTATION ISSUES THEY
LOSE MONEY. AND SO SWITCHING TO
A SYSTEM THAT FOCUSES ON
ENROLLMENT- ADDRESSES THAT NEED.
FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND IT ALSO
ADDRESSES THE NEEDS TO BRING
EQUITY INTO THE CONVERSATION. OF
FOR OUR SCHOOLS- YOU KNOW HAVING
WORKED IN SCHOOL BASS- MENTAL
HEALTH AND OTHER PROGRAMS. I'VE
LEARNED THE REASON KIDS MISS
SCHOOL OFTEN HAS TO DO WITH
HELP- ASTHMA IN MANY OF OUR
COUNTY IS ONE OF THE NUMBER ONE
REASONS- IF THERE ARE ANY
DISRUPTIONS IN THE FAMILY FROM
POVERTY TO TRANSPORTATION-
ANYTHING THAT YOU CAN IMAGINE-
BECOMES AN ISSUE. EARLIER THIS
YEAR I WAS KNOCKING ON DOORS
WITH SOME SCHOOL DISTRICT
LEADERS TO FAMILIES OF KIDS WERE
CHRONICALLY ABSENT. THE NUMBER
ONE THING I HEARD. MENTAL HEALTH
NEEDS WHERE THE REASONS THAT
MANY STUDENTS WERE COMING TO
SCHOOL. WHAT I APPRECIATE ABOUT
SB NINETY EIGHT. IS THAT NOT
ONLY DOES IT CREATE A MORE
EQUITABLE WAY TO FIND ATTENDED.
BY MOVING TO ENROLLMENT. BUT BUT
THE THIRTY. OF THE FUNDS BE
USED. TO HELP DISTRICTS WITH THE
PROGRAMS THEY NEED TO DO
OUTREACH DO SUPPORT TO WORK WITH
FAMILIES TO GET THEM BACK INTO
SCHOOL. IT'S A THOUGHTFUL PIECE
OF LEGISLATION IT IS CRITICAL
FOR OUR SCHOOLS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
ON SB NINETY. THANK YOU
SUPERINTENDENT. GOOD MORNING
SURE- COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY
NAME'S CHRIS MYERS I'M
REPRESENTING AT THE CALIFORNIA
SCHOOL EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION.
WHO REPRESENTS OVER TWO HUNDRED
FIFTY THOUSAND CLASSIFIED SCHOOL
EMPLOYEES. ACROSS CALIFORNIA IN.
BOTH THE SENATOR AND THE
SUPERINTENDENT BASICALLY SAID
EVERYTHING I WAS GOING TO COVER
EXCEPT I DO WANT TO MENTION THAT
FOR US THIS IS AN EQUITY ISSUE-
YEAH WE TALK A LOT ABOUT. YOU
KNOW THE SCHOOLS NOT GETTING THE
FUNDS THAT THEY NEED BUT IT'S
REALLY THE KIDS THAT ARE IN
ATTENDANCE. AT THE SCHOOLS THAT
ARE GETTING THE PROGRAMS AND
SERVICES. THAT THEY NEED AND I
JUST WANT TO MENTION- WE DO HAVE
A LOT OF CO SPONSORS ON THE
SMALL SOME OF WHICH ARE
REFLECTED IN THE ANALYSIS AND
SOME WORK. THAT'S OF COURSE
WHERE THE SUPERINTENDENT WE HAVE
L. A. U. S. T. ASKED ME. CFT GEN
UP SEIU STATE COUNCIL AND THE
TEAMSTERS. AND I'M HERE. TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY
HAVE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
ASSEMBLY HERE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. MORNING
TURN MEMBERS SOCIAL HER WITH LOS
ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT-
WE ARE PROUD CO SPONSORS OF THIS
BILL. PASSED FOR YOUR SUPPORT
THANK YOU I'M SORRY ABOUT THAT
OTHER- WOODS IN SUPPORT. EACH.
MISTER CHAIRMAN SENATOR- ADAM K.
ONE OF THE HELP THE CALIFORNIA
CHARTER SCHOOLS ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN.
AB OUT HERE IN THE YEAH
COMMITTEE ROOM SUPPORT GOOD
MORNING. SHANNON PRIMARY SPECIAL
EDUCATION PARALEGAL WHO
REPRESENTS MENTAL HEALTH
PATIENTS THEIR KIDS I SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. ALL HAS ASKING A
TEACHER FOR HAVING UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT AND I SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU. WE ARE
GOING TO TAKE- TELECONFERENCE
WHEN THIS IS COMBINED AT THE END
SO EVERYBODY KNOWS ALL RIGHT NOW
WILL MOVE ON TO LEAD WHEN
DECISION OPPOSITION IS ANYBODY
WHO'S HERE TO SPEAK. IN
OPPOSITION TO BILL WELCOME. WHAT
YOUR MEMBERS MY NAME IS DARREN
WATERS I CURRENTLY SERVE AS THE
VICE CHAIR OF THE LEGISLATIVE
COMMITTEE- FOR THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOL BUSINESS
OFFICIALS ACCOUNTABLE. WE
REPRESENT OVER TWENTY FOUR
THOUSAND SCHOOL BUSINESS LEADERS
IN K. FOURTEEN EDUCATION AND WE
REGRETFULLY POST SENATE BILL
NINETY EIGHT. OUR CONCERN STEMS
FROM HOUSE BILL WOULD CREATE A
NEW FORMULA TO GENERATE
DISTRIBUTE RICH- RESOURCES. IN A
MANNER THAT CAN BE AND- THEY CAN
CREATE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES
REALLY AS INCLUDING WINNERS AND
LOSERS OR DISTRICTS RECEIVING
LESS FUNDING THAT ARE CURRENTLY
GETTING. THE BILL WOULD PROVIDE
ADDITIONAL FUNDING FOR UP TO
ELEAZAR LOWER TENANTS RATES
WITHOUT ANY STATE OR COUNTY
OFFICE OF EDUCATION ALICE'S
REVIEW PRIOR DISTRIBUTION OF
FUNDS DETERMINES THAT ELEAZAR.
WITH HIGH CHRONIC ABSENTEEISM
RATES HAVE MADE STRIDES REDUCING
THE CHRONIC ABSENTEEISM AND
RATES. NOR DOES A PROVIDE FOR
THE ABILITY TO REDUCE STAFF.
ACCORDING TO NEED AS A TO SCHOOL
GAINES REDUCING CHRONIC
ABSENTEEISM. THE MINUTES OF
EFFORT COMPONENT CREATES AN
AUTOPILOT EXPENDITURE PLAN WITH
NO CONSIDERATION OF NEED. AND
THEN IT AS WE ALL KNOW PROP
NINETY IS ROUGHLY 40% OF THE
BUDGET THAT REPRESENTS THE WHOLE
PIE- THERE WILL BE WINNERS THERE
WILL BE LOSERS THE QUESTION IS.
WHERE WITHIN A 40% DOES THE
EXTRA THREE BILLION DOLLARS COME
FROM. AS WE NOTE CD IS DUE TO AS
ESTIMATED THAT- THIS COST
PROXIMITY. THREE BILLION
DOLLARS- PROP NINETY EIGHT
DOLLARS. WE DO RECOGNIZE THAT
THE AUTHOR SPONSORS ARE
INTERESTED IN RESOLVING. THE
DISCREPANCY THE CAN BE CREATED
DUE TO FUNDING BASED ON AN
EIGHTY A SYSTEM. IN WHICH
ELEAZAR TO ENSURE THAT EVERY
STERN REGARDLESS OF THEIR
ATTENDANCE RECORD AS AN EDUCATOR
CLASSROOM SPACE INSTRUCTION
MATERIALS. AND EQUIPMENT TO
ATTEND SCHOOL. WE ALSO
UNDERSTAND THE CURRENT SYSTEM
DOES NOT PROVIDE FOR SUCH
RESOLUTION. INSTEAD WE RECOMMEND
THAT YOU CONDUCTED ENROLLMENT
BASED FUNDING STUDIES THAT
AMOUNT THE DISCOUNTS FOR FEDERAL
STATE PROGRAMS THAT ARE
DEPENDENT ON ADA INFORMATION.
CREATES A MINIMUM FUNDING
THRESHOLD TO PROTECT SMALL
SCHOOL DISTRICTS. THE LOAN ROMAN
NUMBERS. REVIEWS BASIC AID
DISTRICTS WOULD GENERATE FUNDS
THROUGH LOCAL PROPERTY TAXES
INSTEAD OF THE LCF. ASSESSES HOW
THESE DISTRICTS MONITOR
ESTABLISH. CREDIBILITY METRICS
FOR ATTENDANCE PURPOSES. REVIEW
OTHER GEOGRAPHICALLY AND
DEMOGRAPHICALLY SIMILAR STATES
ON THEIR ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEM
FOR ROMA BASE FUNDING. AND THIS
BILL DOES NOT ADDRESS GROWTH
DISTRICTS. THERE ARE FEW OF US
STILL OUT THERE. AND AS
CURRENTLY WRITTEN WITH A MID
YEAR. GROWTH IT DOES HAPPEN
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR ESPECIALLY
AFTER CHRISTMAS. THE DISTRICT
WOULD NOT RECEIVE THE ADDITIONAL
FUNDING NEEDED UNTIL AFTER THE
FOLLOWING FISCAL YEAR- AFTER
YOU'VE ALREADY HAD A HARSH AND
STUFF FOR. THANKS FOR TIME THIS
MORNING I'M HAPPY TO ANSWERING
QUESTIONS THANK YOU- DO WE HAVE
ANOTHER LEAD WITNESS IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE- LET US
GO TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
BOB MODERATED THANK YOU- OH I'M
SORRY I'M SORRY WE'VE GOT A LATE
ARRIVAL- PLEASE WELCOME. HI
THANK YOU SORRY I RAN OVER HERE
WILL RUNNING A LITTLE LATE. SOCI
T. AKING PART ABOUT THE
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION.
PTA DOES NOT HAVE AN OFFICIAL
POSITION ON THE BILL BUT WE DID
WANT TO JUST RAISE SOME. ISSUES
OF CONCERNS- WITH THE BILL- WE
DO APPRECIATE THE INTENT AND
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE BILL'S GOING
TO DO. I'M GOING TO RAISE A
COUPLE OF ISSUES JUST ONE AS
NOTED IN THE ANALYSIS- THE BILL
DOES NOT PROVIDE MORE FUNDING
FOR EDUCATION BUT REALLOCATE
EXISTING PROP NINETY EIGHT.
RESOURCES I WE DO HAVE SOME
QUESTION JUST AROUND- WILL THIS
ADEQUATE ADEQUATELY HOLD AND
SCHOOL DISTRICTS ACCOUNTABLE FOR
ATTENDANCE- AND THEN CONCERNS
WITH THE REDUCTION OF OVERALL
PROP NINETY EIGHT. IF WE DON'T
HOLD THEM ACCOUNTABLE- WE COULD
REDUCE THE OVERALL NOT A PROP
NINETY EIGHT SINCE THAT- HE SAID
EIGHTY EIGHT TO CALCULATE. UNTIL
PROP NINETY THANK YOU. THANK YOU
MS HARMAN. ARE THERE ANY OTHER
PEOPLE HERE THE ROOM ON A TEST.
IN OP. IF SO PLEASE COME FORWARD
STATE YOUR NAME AND ORGANIZATION
AND YOUR POSITION. A GOOD
MORNING KRISTOFF MEYER WITH THE
AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE
COUNTY MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES
APOLOGIES ALSO RUNNING LATE THIS
MORNING WE ARE PROUD CO SPONSOR
OF THIS BILL. TURN UP. THANK YOU
MR MAYOR. LOS YOU'RE COCA SAN
DIEGO UNIFIED ALSO RUNNING LATE
WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE STILL.
POINTS OFF YOUR TOES FOR BEING
LATE BUT OTHERWISE FOR MUCH
APPRECIATE ANYBODY IN OPPOSITION
. OKAY LET'S LET'S MOVE ON TO
THE TELECOMS MUCH OF A MODERATE
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROP
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
IN EITHER SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION.
TO THE BILL- THIS IS A CHANGE
FOR THE PANDEMIC AND TWO IF YOU
ARE WAITING JUST BY PLEASE. YOUR
NAME YOUR ORGANIZATION AND YOUR
POSITION ON THE BILL. AND PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
FIRST THE LINE NUMBER SIXTEEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CAN REALLY
ROSENBERGER WITH THAT YEAH YOU
UP. ON. CAN YOU JUST A MOMENT
EVERITT ONE WEREN'T YOU. AND WE
CAN GO TO LINE EIGHT PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
MEMBER SHIRLEY DOWN BEHALF
CALPERS POLITICIZATION
ACCOMPLISHMENT THAT WE LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
DOCTOR TO BE ABLE TO GET THAT
MOMENTUM THANKS SO MUCH. DO YOU
- ANY OTHER WORDS. ONE AND THEN
FURTHER AT THIS TIME MATT
PRITCHARD SAID THANK YOU TO ALL
OF OUR SUPPORT ABSENCE WOODS
WILL NOW BRING THE DISCUSSION
BACK. TO THE MEMBERS LET ME LET
ME STRUCTURE PORTANTINO SO AS
THE ANALYSIS IN THE SOME OF THE
WHIMS OF POINT OUT. WHEN I DID
THIS DOES HAVE AN IMPACT ISSUES
IT INTERSECTS WITH PROP NINETY
EIGHT WHICH IS THE DIFFERENCE.
BETWEEN CALIFORNIA MANY OTHER
STATES- SO HOW HOW DO- HOW
SHOULD WE THINK ABOUT HOW CAN WE
ADDRESS. THE SHORTFALL IN THE
FISCAL IMPACT WELL I THINK- IT'S
THE RIGHT QUESTION TO ASK-
MISTER CHAIRMAN IT'S ALWAYS BEEN
MY INTENTION TO. MAKE SURE THAT
THERE ARE NO WINNERS AND LOSERS
THAT THERE'S ONLY WINNERS- WE
HOLD SCHOOL DISTRICTS HARMLESS
WHICH WE'VE DONE OVER THE PAST
SEVERAL YEARS AS WE RECOGNIZE
THE IMPACT THAT ENROLLMENT HAS
HAD. ON SCHOOL FUNDING THE COAT-
THE PANDEMIC HAS HAS DEVASTATED
ATTENDANCE NUMBERS AND SO WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE'S A
HOLD HARMLESS PROVISION IN THE
BILL WE WANT TO BRING ADDITIONAL
FUNDING AND WE THINK. THAT
THAT'S WHAT THIS IS GOING TO
ULTIMATELY DO I MEAN LOOK AT THE
IMPACT OF LA UNIFIED THAT'S WHY
THEY'RE HERE AS A AS A CO
SPONSOR OF THIS BILL AND IT'S
GOING TO HAVE A POSITIVE
BENEFIT. WE ALSO WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT THOSE SMALLER
DISTRICTS THAT DON'T HAVE A
NEGATIVE IMPACT SO WE'RE
BUILDING THAT SAFEGUARD INTO THE
BILL. AND NOW WE LOOK FORWARD TO
HAVING THE CONVERSATION BECAUSE
THAT'S OUR INTENTION IS TO
INCREASE SCHOOL FUNDING NOT
DECREASE SCHOOL FUND. AND I
APPRECIATE THAT SO YOU KNOW
THERE'S A SEMI IMPLICATIONS
RELATES TO THE L. C. F. F. AND-
FIND A BETTER. OF DID THAT
TRICK. I CONTINUE TWEAKS THAT WE
MAKE IN THE US OF THAT SO I TRY
TO RISK THAT THE CAR PROS WITH.
AGREE MULTIPLIER WITH THE LCF OF
WHY THINK THAT'S ONE OF THE
THINGS THAT WERE GONNA WORK
THROUGH THE- YOU KNOW BOTH
THROUGH THE BUDGET COMMITTEE AND
BOTH THROUGH THE APPROPRIATIONS
PROCESS I MEAN THESE ARE THESE
ARE THE ISSUES THAT HAVE TO BE
WORKED OUT AS THIS BILL MOVES
FORWARD. I MEAN- THAT'S THE
INTENT BEHIND IT AND WE THINK.
ALSO AS MR MYERS TALKED ABOUT.
HAVING SOME ACCOUNTABILITY BUILT
INTO THE BILL THERE'S FRANKLY
SOME OF THE OPPOSITION OR SOME
OF THE CONCERN IS. PEOPLE WANT.
THERE TO BE A 100% DISCRETION
WITH IT. AND WE THINK. SOME
PIECE OF THAT SHOULD. GO
DIRECTLY. TO I WENT. EFFORTS AND
WE THINK THAT. IS YOU KNOW.
SPIRIT TECH. AS PART OF THIS AND
SO WHEN THEY GO. THOSE POINTS.
INTO WITH WE- RISK. TO THE
TRUANCY OF. AND AN I DO BRIDGE.
BOTH YOU AND- THE
SUPERINTENDENT. EMPHASIZE THE
CHALLENGES WITH FRUIT. TREES IN
CITY COMING OUT THE PANDEMIC. A
CLEARLY WAS A- OF- DRIVERS- YOU
KNOW DOES. THAT EMPHASISES THAT
THE MAIN ISSUE. EFFORT WITH
THIRTY PERCENT. I'M GOING
SPENDING REQUIREMENT ON
ABSENTEEISM AND TRUANCY. DOES
THERE'S SOME CONCERN THAT WOULD
CREATE. A NEW CATEGORY CORRECT
KARAKUL CATEGORICAL PROGRAMS WHO
HAVE HOW SHOULD WE THINK ABOUT
THAT. WELL I THINK IT'S EASY TO
CALL THAT A NEW CATEGORICAL
PROGRAM I PREFER TO CALL IT
ACCOUNTABILITY I MEAN IT'S ALL.
IT'S ALL IN THE NAME. BUT THE
EFFORT IS THE POINT IS. WE
RECOGNIZE THAT WHEN YOU CHANGE
FROM AN ATTENDANCE BASED MODEL.
TO AN ENROLLMENT BASED MODEL
THEY ARE GOING TO BE FOLKS WHO
THINK THAT THAT'S GOING TO DIS
INCENTIVIZE ATTENDANCE. AND WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT'S
NOT THE CASE WE WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT A PART OF THIS NEW
MONEY. GOES TOWARDS TRUANCY
EFFORTS WHETHER IT'S 30% OR A
DIFFERENT NUMBER THAT'S
OBVIOUSLY GOING TO BE NEGOTIATED
AS THE BILL PROGRESSES THROUGH
THE PROCESS. BUT I THINK IT'S AN
IMPORTANT POINT TO IMPORTANT
POLICY TO KEEP. AS PART OF THE
FRAMEWORK OF THIS BILL WITH THE
APPROPRIATE NUMBER IS CAN BE
DEBATED BUT THE CONCEPT I THINK
IS IMPORTANT. APPRECIATE THAT
JOINT I'M AND I'M OPEN UP TO
MEMBERS AND THEN BEFORE WE- WE
COMPLETE OR AFTER AFTER SENATOR
PORTANTINO CLOSES. WE GOT TO
ADMINISTRATIVE RIGHTS THAT WILL
COVER WE COULD COMMUNITY GET A
QUORUM ALSO VOTER ON THE
COMMITTEE RULES- BUT. OTHER
MEMBERS QUESTIONS TO THE
SENATOR. YOU DE AN EXCELLENT JOB
NO QUESTIONS. IF YOU HAVE A GOOD
QUESTION WHAT DOES IT IS THE-
THIS THAT THE. NINETY NO THAT'S
FAIR THAT'S VERY. TO SAN
WEALTHIEST MISTER WERE GET YOUR
IN LAW FAVORITE POLITICIAN. THE
THANK YOU FOR. YEAH YEAH CAN I
GET LIKE. ANGELES EVERY I GET I
. WHILE THIS IS A RECORD I AM IS
A IN LAW FAVORITE POLITICIAN IS
YOUR NOW. NOW THAT HAS BEEN
VERY. SORRY LET LET LET LET'S DO
THIS THEN LET'S LET'S JUST OF A
QUORUM. GIVEN A CHANCE TO GET OR
THE LATE AND SO- MADAM SIR.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. NEWMAN
HERE NEWMAN HERE. UNTIL BOTH.
THE CHEWABLE CARE CORTESE.
GLAZER PLEASE HERE MCGUIRE.
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HERE SMALL
CUEVAS HERE WILL. PRESENT WILL
CARE. ALL RIGHT SECOND ADMIN D.
IF WE COULD TO THE COMMITTEE.
RULES IS OUR FIRST MEETING OF
THE YEAR- WITHOUT OBJECTION ANY
OBJECTIONS TO STEPS INTO THE
RULES AS- SPECIFIED NONE OF
MEMSIC TO PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ON THE- NEWMAN. BOB YEAH I
NEWMAN EYEING A CHILL BOTH. OR
TURBO GUY CORTESE. GLAZER GLAZER
EYEING MCGUIRE. SMALLWOOD CUEVAS
. SMALL CUEVAS I WILL. WILK I'D
NIGHT LAST ME DETAIL TO THE
COMMITTEES POLICY ON CURRICULUM
AS WE DO YEAR YOUR AGE ACTIONS
TO REAFFIRMING THAT POLICY SHE
NINE MADAM SECRETARY. THANK YOU
FOR THE PLEASE CALL THE CALL THE
ROLL NEWMAN. AYE NEWMAN AYE
PHOTOBOOK. WHICH- OBERG I
QUICKLY SEE. GLAZER GLAZER AYE
MCGUIRE. SMALLWOOD CUEVAS
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS I WILL NAY. DID
YOU KNOW THAT WILL BE A WELCOME
L. AND IT'S OKAY BECAUSE WE WANT
TO THE AGE OF CONSENT WILL DO
THAT WE CAN WE DO THAT AFTER.
CENTER PORTANTINO LIVING CLOSE.
LET'S NOT DO THAT I'M SO HAVING
BLOOD. I'M CALL MOM. IT'S MOTHER
IN LAW THE RIGHT IMAGE OF THE
THAT THE DOESN'T GET YOU THE
SAME OBJECTION CHAU- ANY FROM
MEMBERS OKAY OKAY AS FORTINO IF
YOU'VE LIKE TO CALL. HOWEVER TO
CLOSE YOU MISS CHAIR OF AND
MEMBERS- THIS IS A YOU KNOW
OBVIOUSLY. IT FROM MY
PERSPECTIVE AND I KNOW THAT'S
WHY ALL OF YOU SIT ON THIS
COMMITTEE- PUBLIC EDUCATION. IS
OUR PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY I
THINK AS AS SHEPHERDS OF OUR OUR
STATE. AND WE HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO IMPROVE HOW WE
FUND PUBLIC EDUCATION I THINK WE
SHOULD TAKE THAT OPPORTUNITY AND
WE SEEN THAT MOST STATES USE
THIS MODEL AND FRANKLY
CALIFORNIA TRADITIONALLY HAS
BEEN A LEADER ON PUBLIC POLICY'S
BEEN A LEADER IN SO MANY THINGS
IN IN THIS CASE WE'RE NOT. AND I
THINK WE HAVE TO CORRECT THAT
AND I APPRECIATE THE
SUPERINTENDENT BEING HERE AGAIN
THE PERSON WHO SHOULD BE IN
CHARGE OF THE STATE SHEPHERDING
EDUCATION AND ALL OF THE
DIFFERENT. ASPECTS OF THAT.
SEIZE THE BARRETT OF IT WE HAVE
LA UNIFIED AND WE'RE ALL SEEING
WHAT'S GOING ON IN LA UNIFIED
RIGHT NOW- AND AGAIN IT COMES
DOWN TO RESOURCES AND- I
APPRECIATE THEM BEING HERE TO
MAKE THAT PERSPECTIVE BECAUSE
THIS WOULD HELP THEM- I.
RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH SOME
OF THE OPPOSITION ON WINNERS AND
LOSERS BECAUSE I DON'T THINK
THAT IS THE ULTIMATE GOAL AND-
NOT THE CASE BUT- WE HAVE TO
FIGURE OUT A WAY TO SHIFT TO
THIS MODEL IT IS JUST A BETTER
WAY OF DOING THINGS. AND WHEN WE
HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO
SOMETHING BETTER. WE SHOULD TAKE
IT AND IT'S NOT A MYSTERY THAT
IT'S BETTER BECAUSE WE SEE IT
WORKING IN OTHER STATES AND
AGAIN. PART OF INNOVATION IS TO
SEE WHAT OTHER PEOPLE ARE DOING
WELL. AND THEN DO IT AND THAT'S
WHAT WE SEE HERE OTHER STATES
ARE DOING THIS BETTER THAN US.
AND WE SHOULD USE THAT EXAMPLE
AND WE SHOULD DO IT SO I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR LIMA. AND
THANK YOU SO THIS DOES RAISE
SOME. SOME FISCAL CHALLENGES BUT
FORTUNATELY WE DO HAVE GOOD
PEOPLE ON APPROPRIATIONS RICHARD
RECOGNITION TO PAST REPARATIONS
MADAM SECRETARY- PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. DOES YOUR EMOTIONS ARE.
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER WE HAVE
A MOTION FOR SENATOR GLAZERS.
MASSACRED PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SB NINETY EIGHT BY SENATOR
PORTANTINO THE MOTION IS TO PASS
BUT FOR IS BEING REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
NEWMAN NEWMAN AYE PHOTOBOOK AYE
OR TROUBLES I'D CORTESE. GLAZER
GLAZER AYE. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I.
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS I WILK NO WILL FROM NOW.
I WILL LEAVE THAT UP WITH
SIGNIFICANT. HI TRIVAGO STRIDE
ONE LEAVE IT OPEN. I CENTER
PORTANTINO- BACKS WERE S. B. TWO
THIRTY FOUR- INTACT AS FOR THE
POLICE PURSUIT. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR TOO MANY MEMBERS SB TWO
THIRTY FOUR WOULD REQUIRE
SCHOOLS COLLEGES AND CAMPUSES.
STADIUMS CONCERT CONCERT VENUES
AMUSEMENT PARKS- IN OUR STATE TO
MAINTAIN UNEXPIRED DOSES OF OUR
NOR CAN AND VARIOUS OTHER NAMES
OF THAT THE SAME- IMPORTANT OVER
OPIOID FIGHTING- TREATMENT WE
SAW SPIKE IN ADOLESCENT DEATH
RATES FROM OPIOID OVERDOSES FROM
TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN THE TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY. NEARLY
DOUBLING- AND WE'VE CONTINUED TO
SEE THIS ALARMING INCREASE ON
ABOUT. ALL OF YOU OF RECEIVE
THOSE PAINFUL PHONE CALLS FROM
PARENTS AND FAMILY MEMBERS WHO
HAVE LOST SOMEBODY TO THIS
HORRIBLE SCOURGE- WHICH FOUND
THAT 20% OF THE FORTY TWO BAY
AREA SCHOOL DISTRICTS REPORTED
NOT HAVING NOR CAN READILY
AVAILABLE ON THEIR SCHOOL
CAMPUSES. IT'S CRUCIAL THAT WE
PLACE IN OUR CANTON SPACES
FREQUENTLY ACCESSED BY
CALIFORNIANS GIVEN THE SEVERE
RISK POSED BY OUR STATE'S
GROWING OPIOID CRISIS IT'S A
MEDICATION WITH THE POTENTIAL TO
SAVE A LIFE- IT REALLY DOES
HELP- AGAIN. THAT WE HAVE WE
HAVE THE ABILITY TO HELP WE KNOW
THAT STATES THAT HAVE
IMPLEMENTED DISTRIBUTION
PROGRAMS HAVE SEEN A REDUCTION
IN DEATH RATES- BY FOLLOWING
THIS APPROACH THIS BILL WILL
HELP. EQUIP SCHOOLS WITH THE
RESOURCES THEY NEED YOU KNOW
WE'VE ALL BEEN IN PLACES THAT
HAVE REFER BELLATOR'S WE SEEN
THAT THE STATE MANDATED THAT THE
THEY'RE AVAILABLE AND THEY SAVE
LIVES. THIS IS IT SIMILAR
CONCEPT BY HAVING IT AVAILABLE
NOT JUST ON SCHOOL SITES BUT
PLACES THAT. THAT OUR YOUNG
PEOPLE CONGREGATE- WE'RE GOING
TO SAVE LIVES TO THE SO I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
WE HAVE- ADRIAN SHELTON FROM THE
CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE OF CHINA
FAMILY SERVICES AND KIM STONE
FROM THE CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT. WELCOME TO
CHILDREN'S. PLEASE READ THANK
YOU CHAIR MEMBER A SHELTON
REPRESENT THE COLOR LIFE OF
CHILD AND FAMILY SERVICES. WE
REPRESENT ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTY
EIGHT NONPROFIT COMMUNITY BASED
ORGANIZATIONS ACROSS CALIFORNIA
WHO ARE PROVIDING SERVICES AND
SUPPORTS TO CHILDREN YOUTH AND
FAMILIES IN PUBLIC. HUMAN
SERVICES SYSTEMS AND THAT
INCLUDES BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND
CHILD WELFARE. JUVENILE JUSTICE
AND EDUCATION AND WE ARE PROUD
TO SUPPORT SB TWO THIRTY FOR
TODAY. OUR MEMBERS ARE SERVING
STUDENTS IN VARIOUS SETTINGS
ACROSS THE STATE AND RECOGNIZE
THE NEED. TO HAVE LIFESAVING
MEDICATIONS SUCH AS NALOXONE
AVAILABLE ON SCHOOL CAMPUSES.
AND WE HAVE EXISTING LAWN
CALIFORNIA THAT AUTHORIZES EACH
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE ELEMENTARY
AND SECONDARY SCHOOL. TO
DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT TO MAKE
EMERGENCY ABOUT THE LOCKS OWN.
AND TRAINED PERSONNEL AVAILABLE
ON AT SCHOOL CAMPUSES. HOWEVER
DUE TO THE AVAILABILITY OF
OPIOIDS AND THE IMPACT OF YOUTH
ACROSS THE STATE WE BELIEVE THAT
WE MUST TAKE FURTHER PRECAUTIONS
TO PREPARE FOR POTENTIAL
OVERDOSES. IN OUR COMMUNITIES.
THE OPIOID CRISIS AS HAS BEEN
STATED IT HAS BEEN HEIGHTENED
AND WE ARE SEEING DEATHS. LINKED
TO OPIOID OVERDOSES AT ALARMING
RATES. SO FOR EXAMPLE THE
CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
HEALTH HAS REPORTED A TOTAL OF
600-080-0403 DEATHS RELATED TO.
OVERDOSE IN THE PAST YEAR UP
FROM FIFTY FIVE HUNDRED AND
TWENTY TWENTY. SO WE MUST HAVE
NALOXONE MORE COMMONLY REFERRED
TO AS NOR CAN MORE READILY
AVAILABLE IN SCHOOLS AND OTHER
VENUES- TO SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE.
OPIOID RELATED OVERDOSE DEATHS.
SO SB TWO THIRTY FOUR FOUR FROM
OUR PERSPECTIVE WILL BETTER
EQUIP CALIFORNIA TO RESPOND TO
OUR OPIOID CRISIS AND WILL MAKE
CRITICAL MEDIC MEDICATION
AVAILABLE TO THOSE EXPERIENCING.
OVERDOSE SO FOR THOSE REASONS WE
ARE PROUD TO SUPPORT SB TWO
THREE FOUR TODAY THANK YOU
MICHELLE TO AND NEXT MISS STONE
WELCOME GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
MEMBERS HAVE THANK YOU- TO THE
AUTHOR FOR. LEADERSHIP THAT
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
ASSOCIATION IS IN SUPPORT OF S.
B. TWO THIRTY FOUR. OF FENNEL AS
YOU PROBABLY KNOW IS A SYNTHETIC
OPIOID FIFTY TO THREE HUNDRED
TIMES STRONGER THAN MORPHINE
POINT 0007% OF AN OUNCE CAN BE
FATAL. UP SENTINEL KILLS
CURRENTLY MORE PEOPLE AGED
EIGHTEEN TO FORTY FIVE AND CAR
CRASHES GUNSHOTS SUICIDES OR
LAST YEAR CODE NINETEEN DEATHS.
AND YOUTH DEATHS AND THAT'S AGE
ON TWENTY FOUR AND UNDER I IS
THE FASTEST GROWING- SECTION OF
A DRUG BECAUSE DEATH. PENALTY IS
CHEAPER THAN OTHER STREET DRUGS
AND IS OFTEN MIXED WITH OTHER
STREET DRUGS SO A USER PURCHASER
MAY NOT EVEN KNOW THAT THEY ARE
BUYING FENTANYL- YOU'VE PROBABLY
HEARD THE STORY OF- ZACH DDA. A
SEVENTEEN YEAR OLD TEENAGER FROM
ROCKLAND WHO BOUGHT ON SOCIAL
MEDIA PLATFORM SNAPCHAT A SINGLE
PILL HE THOUGHT WAS PERCOCET FOR
PAIN RELIEF AT THE- FOOD MET
THE- DEALER AT THE FOOD COURT AT
A LOCAL MALL. HIS PARENTS FOUND
HIM DEAD IN HIS BEDROOM TWO DAYS
AFTER CHRISTMAS- HE WAS A
STUDENT ATHLETE A SOCCER PLAYER
IN EAGLES OUT IN SCOUT IN THE
SCHOOL MUSICAL. AND A PIANO
PLAYER HAD NO IDEA HE WAS INTENT
INGESTING FENTANYL NOW NALOXONE
IS A NASAL SPRAY OPIOID
ANTAGONISTIC YOU USE LIKE. I USE
LONEY'S EVERY MORNING. AND IT
CAN RAPIDLY. FENTANYL OVER- THIS
CALL SENSE MEASURE ALTHOUGH MY
CALLING IT BELIEVES MEASURES ARE
ALSO NECESSARY TO ADDRESS THE
FEDERAL CRISIS IN CALIFORNIA WE
BELIEVE THIS IS A COMMON SENSE
HARM REDUCTION MEASURE. THAT
WILL SAVE LIVES AND WE URGE YOUR
SUPPORT. THANK YOU MISTER OWNER
ARE THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES
THE COMMITTEE HEARING LIKE TO
SPEND SUPPORT. OF THE MEASURE IF
SO ABOUT YOUR NAME OR YOUR
ORGANIZATION YOUR POSITION
PLEASE. TARGET BY EASTMAN WITH
THE CYBER INSTITUTE IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. ZACHARIA WOULDN'T
WITH THE STUDENT CENTER FOR
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU SIR. SHE
EMPIRE ON BEHALF OF MYSELF AND
TASHA HAMILTON WHO AS A CHILD
HIS USED DRUGS ON CAMPUS I AM IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. THANK YOU
. TWENTY FOUR OH ONE K. FROM THE
FACULTY ASSOCIATION THE
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU. UNDER
GOVERNOR- HAVE THE SYMPTOMS GO
FORTY NINERS IN THE FIVE
CALIFORNIA BASEBALL TEAMS WE
APOLOGIZE FOR NOT GETTING A
LETTER IN SOONER WE'RE SUPPORT
OF AMANDA WE APPRECIATE THE
SENDER WORKING WITH US ON SOME
CLARIFYING LANGUAGE. THANK YOU
THANK YOU MISTER GOVERNMENT. ALL
HAS ASKING A TEACHER FROM A
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT AND WE
SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU- SING NO MORE
WITNESSES AND SPORTING COMMITTEE
HEARING ROOM. OUT WE'LL MOVE ON
TO OPPOSITION- ELITE WITNESSES
OPPOSITION BILL. ANYONE IS IT
ALL AN UPSURGE IN ATTACKS ON.
THERE LET'S LET'S MOVE NOW TO
THE- TELECONFERENCE ON MR
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE.
PROMPT ANYBODY WISHING TO TEST I
BOTH IN SUPPORT AND IN
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL- AND
AGAIN IF YOU'RE ON THE PHONE
PLEASE JUST YOUR NAME. YOUR
ORGANIZATION A POSITION. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH AND IT'S ONE ZERO
AT THIS TIME PLEASE PRESS ONE
ZERO. FIRST QUARTER LINE NUMBER
NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
MORNING REBECCA GONZALEZ
NATIONALIST EDUCATION OF THOSE
WORKER CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. AND
CURRENTLY NONE FURTHER IN Q.
THANK YOU LET'S LET'S BRING IT
BACK TO COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM
TO ADD CENTER PORTANTINO THIS IS
A GOOD INVESTOR BILL GLAD
SUPPORTED. ANY OTHER MEMBERS
LIKE TO SPEAK ON THE BILL SEARCH
ABOVE THANK YOU. I JUST HAD A
COUPLE OF QUESTIONS FOR SENATOR
PORTANTINO. I'M IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE
THAT I. HAVE SOME QUESTIONS
ANSWERED- WITH REGARDS TO THE-
TO THE NUMBER OF DOSES FROM
BEING REQUIRED AB AT THE
DIFFERENT. VENUES WEATHERS THE
COLLEGES ORDER. THE SPORTS OR
CONCERT VENUES. WHAT WILL THE
PREVIOUS THE FIRST QUESTION.
WHAT M. WHAT IS THE TIME- AND
WHEN. WHAT IS THE TIME THAT THE-
THAT THAN ALEX- NEEDS TO BE
ADMINISTERED BY THE TIME SO IT
CAN BE A FACTOR. THE SOONER THE
AS SOON AS POSSIBLE OKAY DO WE
HAVE A TERRORISM AND THE REASON
FOR MY QUESTION IS THAT WE WERE
SPEAKING OF WITH REGARDS TO
REALLY LARGE VENUES. THERE HAS
TO BE SEVEN SEVEN TIME THAT HAS
TO BE CONSIDERED IN WHICH- IT
HAS TO REACH THE WRONG PERSON
THAT IS BEING- AT HELP SO I'M
JUST KIND OF CURIOUS AS TO SURE
WE'RE GOING. TO HAVE I'M SURE
WHAT WE BUILT INTO THE BILL IS
THAT AT ALL TIMES ON THOSE SITES
THERE HAS TO BE AT LEAST TWO
PEOPLE WHO. KNOW WHERE IT YOU
KNOW THIS THE POINT YOU'RE
MAKING IS IF THERE'S AN
EMERGENCY YOU CAN HAVE SOMEBODY
WHO DOESN'T KNOW WHERE TO GO OR
WHAT TO DO OR HOW TO GET IT. AND
SO WORK REQUIRING ON SITE AT
LEAST TWO PERSONALITY EACH OF
THOSE SITES HAS TO BE
KNOWLEDGEABLE OF HOW TO
IMPLEMENT HAS TO BE NO NO WHERE
IT IS HAS TO KNOW HOW TO GET IT
AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE SO. YOU
KNOW YOU'RE RIGHT IF IT'S ON ONE
END OF A VENUE AND- YOU KNOW.
SOME OF THE LOGISTICS ARE ARE
KEY TO THE TO THE SUCCESS. BUT
PART OF IT IS MAKING SURE THAT
THE PEOPLE ON THAT SITE KNOW
WHERE IT IS KNOW HOW TO
IMPLEMENT IT. AND KNOW HOW TO
ADMINISTER THIS QUICKLY AS
POSSIBLE THAT WAS A CONCERN THAT
I HAD RUN JUST TO MAKE SURE THAT
HE GETS TO THE CORRECT INTENDED.
WITH IN A TIMELY MANNER AND OF
COURSE THAT'S GOING TO VERY
DEPENDING ON WHERE. THE
LOGISTICAL PART OF THE AT THE
VENUE SO KEEPING THAT IN MIND-
AND. MAKING SURE THAT WE HAVE
THAT WITHIN THAT. WHEN THE BILL
IN THEN THIS- AND THEN THE COST-
MORE TOWARDS THE SCHOOLS I HAVE
NO IDEA WHAT. THIS COST. TO HAVE
A CAN IMAGINING THAT EXPENSIVE
BUT- WE PROVIDING ANY FUNDING
FOR THE SCHOOLS TO BE ABLE TO
PROVIDE THIS OR THE TRAINING. SO
THE GOVERNOR IN JANUARY PUT
SEVENTY NINE MILLION FOR
DISTRIBUTION- THERE'S ALSO THREE
POINT FIVE MILLION WAS
ALLOCATED- NINETY PROP NINETY
EIGHT MONEY ON GOING. FROM
MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOL SITES TO
MAINTAIN THE DOSES AND SO. AND
THEN THERE'S TEN MILLION WAS.
PROFESSIONAL PROGRAMS AND
ANOTHER FOUR MILLION WAS
ALLOCATED FOR SUPPORT-
APPROACHES SO. WITHIN THE
CURRENT BUDGET THERE ARE
RESOURCES- TO HELP SCHOOLS
OFFSET THE COST MANY SCHOOLS
ALREADY DOING IT- WHAT WE'RE
TRYING TO DO IS ALSO AT THOSE
OTHER. PRIVATE VENUES AS WELL.
AND SO THERE'S A LOT THAT THERE
IS MONEY IN THE BUDGET TO HELP
IMPLEMENT IT MAKE THIS OF HER
EFFICIENT ROLLOUT. WONDERFUL
WELL IF I'M NOT ALREADY A CO
AUTHOR WOULD LIKE TO BE ADDED AS
A CO AUTHOR ON THE C. HEALTHY
HAPPY TO HAVE THEM. AND I WILL
MOVE THE BILL WHEN TIME IS
APPROPRIATE WE SHOULDN'T MEMBERS
AND ANY OTHER QUESTIONS FOR SENT
WORD TO- NO SIMPLE GENERAL IF
YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE. IT JUST
IT'S A- YOU KNOW AS WE ALL KNOW
THIS IS A PROBLEM THAT. AND AS
THE DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
MENTIONED. NEEDS MULTIPLE
SOLUTIONS AND- YOU KNOW TREATING
THE EMERGENCY IS FRANKLY AN
AFTER THE FACT. TREATMENT BUT
IT'S ONE THAT'S NECESSARY WE
SHOULD BE LOOKING AT THE
UPSTREAM PROBLEMS AS WELL. AND
THEN DEALING WITH THAT THESE
CRISIS IS QUICKLY AND
EFFICIENTLY AND AS SAFELY AS
POSSIBLE SO I RESPECTFULLY
ASTRONOMICAL. PREACHER THAT
WE'VE EMOTION FROM CENTER CHOI
BOGUE MA'AM SECTOR PLEASE CALL
THE. ROLL THE MOTION IS TO PASS
BY FIRST WE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE HEALTH. NEWMAN NEWMAN
AYE OR TROUBLE I. WHICH WILL BE
I CORTESE. GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE
MCGUIRE. WITH AYE SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS. WILL HI WILL AYE- THANK
YOU WE ARE MIDWAY THROUGH THE-
SHOW. AT AND WE'LL PUT THAT BILL
A CALL FOR NOW. SO NEXT UP IS AS
BEFORE FOR FIVE UNDERSTAND THIS
BILL WILL WILL BE USING A
TRANSLATOR- AT CENTER PORTANTINO
POLICE PURSUIT. THANK YOU AYE MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO
BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AND THANKING. THE CO
AUTHORS WHO- WILL BE ADDED TO
THE BILL IN THE NEXT COMMITTEE-
I'M PRESENTING SP FOUR FOUR FIVE
WHICH REQUIRES LOCAL EDUCATION
AGENCIES TO PROVIDE A STUDENT.
PARENT WITH A COPY OF A
COMPLETED I. E. P. WITHIN THIRTY
DAYS OF BEING REQUESTED- IN
THEIR NATIVE LANGUAGE AS WELL AS
REQUIRE THE I. E. P. TO BE
TRANSLATED- THE BILL ALSO
REQUIRES CVT PROVIDES ITS NOTICE
PROCEDURES SAFEGUARDS. IN ORDER
TO INFORM PARENTS OF THEIR RIGHT
TO REQUEST THE TRANSLATION OF
THE DOCUMENT. FRANKLY JUST
IMAGINE BEING A CHILD A PARENT
WITH A CHILD THAT REQUIRES AN I
EP THAT NEEDS HELP AND YOU GET
THIS DOCUMENT. AND YOU CAN'T
READ IT- BECAUSE IT'S NOT IN
YOUR NATIVE FINE HOW DO YOU
ADVOCATE FOR YOUR CHILD HOW DO
YOU HELP THEM I MEAN IT'S TOUGH
ENOUGH TO GET THROUGH THE
SYSTEM- WHEN YOU'RE- KNOWING
WHAT'S ON THE DOCKING. WHEN YOU
HAVE AN ARMY OF FOLKS AROUND YOU
TO HELP YOU AND YOU KNOW I JUST
THINK. I JUST THINK WE SHOULD
MAKE IT AVAILABLE IN IN.
MULTIPLE LANGUAGES AS QUICKLY AS
POSSIBLE AND- HELP KIDS GET
THROUGH THE SYSTEM- ESPECIALLY
IN AND NURTURING AS POSSIBLE AND
SO THAT'S WHAT THE HEART OF THE
BILL DIES. WITH ME WE HAVE MONEY
CHAU CHAU OFF WAS A MEMBER OF
THE DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA
BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND- SHARON
PRIMER I DON'T KNOW WHICH
PRIMARY PRIMER. THAT'S MY MAD-
FROM EDUCATE ADVOCATE WHO ARE
HERE TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF THE
BILL. WELCOME VISIT SHOWN. ONE
OF THE IS THAT THOSE THE NUMBER
IS NICE WITH CHILDREN. SO LET
THE NIGHT THEY MORNING YOU'RE
GOING TO SEE THAT THIS THE
SALARIES. AND CMH ALEX. YEAH
MIDDLE SAN USER THEM YES THE
RECEIVING END OF THE QUESTION
YEAH. WE ONE OF THE HAVE HELLO
GOOD MORNING- I AM AND- AND- I
HAVE A CHILD WITH A CHILD. THE
BUT HE TALKED TO A I AM LATIN
AND I HAVE TRIED THAT WITH THE
FISH NEEDS- HIS NAME IS ALEX
HE'S TWELVE YEARS OLD AND HE'S
RECEIVING A SPECIAL EDUCATION.
COMO AMY GRANT THERE ARE SEALED
WE DID HE SAID NOW THEY GOTTA
TEACH THE MONTH IT'LL GO THE
WILL. CENTER MINDLESS ANOTHER
LESS BUSY IT'S NOT ADDRESS. THE
RIVER OF FUN UP IT I DO THAT I'M
WHOLE I'M GOING TO SAVE.
SERVICES FOR PARTS THAT THE
THREE DISCO. ASSEMBLY AS AN
IMAGE. IT'S BEEN VERY HARD TO
NAVIGATE THE SYSTEM TO. SYSTEM
BEING IN A- THIS ONE OF THE-
BARRIERS TO PUT. IT YEAH THROUGH
. TWO OF. IT'S A VERY THE HAS TO
BE. STOPPED TO BE ABLE TO HELP
MY CHILD. GET THE SERVICES FROM
THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. FULLER
RENTALS MOTHER THIS IF THEY
CONCEDE BECAUSE THAT THAT WAS
THE MOST LIKE SEE ME IN MILLING
ONE AT THAT. IN LOTS OF THE
OMINOUS. DECK IN MY YOU KNOW THE
OTHER LAST AUGUST YOU HONEST I
DEVELOPED A THAT SAID AS THE
SMITH. THE HAHNEMANN SEVEN
ELEMENTS CONSIDER THE ME COLITIS
YOU. ONE OF THE BIGGEST
CHALLENGES THAT I HAVE IS TO
GET. I KNOW YOU P. TRANSLATOR MY
LAND. INTO MY NATIVE LANGUAGE IN
WITHIN MONTH. BECAUSE OF THE
CASES- THE TAKEN A- SIX. LEAVING
ME WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT IS
REALLY HAPPENING AND WHAT KIND
OF SERVICES MY CHILD IS GOING TO
RECEIVE. EAGLES HERE'S SOME OF
WHAT IS TO BE SENT THERE
EVERYTHING WILL NOT AFFECT THE
PRESS YOUNG BUT IF YOU MAY LIKE
HE WILL GIVE A LOT OF MONEY AND
I NEED OF WHAT I SEE WE HAVE
THE- OF EACH. I THANK LOCAL
MEANT THIS DIFFERENT. OTHERWISE
MY CHILD WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO
RECEIVE- BASIC SERVICES THAT ARE
OFFERED UNTIL THE DOCUMENT IS
BEING FINE. I THINK A COMMERCIAL
. MUCH OF THIS IS THAT THE NEW
LOOK AT I. SAYS HAVE A LOOK CITY
SAY IN THE- YOUR BILL THE L. A.
OF ME I'D BE. AN MEDIO MARC
ENVELOPE SO THE ONLY. TO PUT IT
INTO. AT THE APPROACH MUST A
LOOK AT THE LOS AND ANALYSIS.
YOU MAY PRESS THAT YEAH PEOPLE
AT A LOT HOSPITAL BECAUSE TO ME
TO SEE. ASSEMBLY IT MAY KINDS OF
HAVE GOT TO FIGHT THE MY
CONTRACT WITH KNOWING IN WHAT
IT'S WHAT'S THIS. IF I COULD
READ THE I. E. P. L. ALEXIS AND
SON AND MY LANGUAGE IN WITH A
MONTH I COULD THE TIE OF PROBLEM
. IT PROBLEMS EMOTIONAL AND
MEDICAL THAT HE RESET. THEREFORE
BEING ABLE TO US OKAY FOR THE
SERVER. THE ADEQUATE FOR TO THE
HE NEEDS. NOT BE ABLE TO GET THE
ACROSS IS LAST UNITS THIS IS THE
THIRD ONE I'M OF THE YOUR THIS
BUT WHO. UP WITH THAT.
ALEX YOUR MEDICINE MOST OF IT
CAN LOOK AT THE FINANCIAL I'M
JUST GLAD I KNEW WHAT THE LAW
THEM REST AS CONSENT BEFORE
LEMME SMOKE ON THE SILICON
SLIPPERS. SEE I CAN ALSO AT THE
MONTH POINT THAT I OUT OF THE
FOR MANY MANY THE- I WAS AND I
DESERVE TO KNOW WHAT IS- IT
WAITING FOR. THROUGHOUT THIS
YEAR ON THE THAT ARE IN SAME. AS
WE ARE. IS WE DESERVE TO HAVE
THIS AND THAT IF THERE'S
SOMETHING THAT THEY'RE NOT
TAKING INTO ACCOUNT WE CAN ACT
IMMEDIATELY. SOLO HERO BABY
LET'S GET THEM YET I THINK
ALMOST IS PLANTED WHEN THEY HAVE
TO LOCAL MENTAL SKIP OUT OF
SPACE ON THE FOURTH THIS LOOMING
MUCH BUT A THE LAST FOR
MEDIASCAPE. L. LEADING MY LIST
WILL BE MADE. WHAT IS SAW WHAT
IS THE WRESTLING LIST PEOPLE WE
CAN FOR YOU KNOW FOR A- IT'S-
WHAT THE ACCORDING TO SINGLE AND
AS FOR THE BUT. I ONLY WANT TO
ASK YOU THAT IF YOU CAN READ
THE- IN YOUR LANGUAGE AND THAT.
THAT ARE IMPORTANT FOR YOUR YOUR
LANGUAGE THIS THE SAME FOR US ON
THE FAMILIES WHO DO NOT ENGLISH
AS A FIRST LANGUAGE. FOR THESE
REASONS I. ASK YOU TO PLEASE.
THE BILL OFF FOR. THANK YOU FOR
THIS SPACE FOR ME. AND THEN YOU
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN THANK
YOU FOR THE TRANSLATE NOT NAY
LEAD WITNESS. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE EDUCATION
COMPANY I AM SHANNON PRIMER OF
EDUCATE ADVOCATE WE ARE
STATEWIDE GRASSROOTS NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATION THAT SERVES
FAMILIES WITH EXCEPTIONAL NEEDS
AND A CO SPONSOR OF SB FOUR FOUR
FIVE. AS A PARENT OF THREE
STUDENTS WHO QUALIFY FOR SPECIAL
EDUCATION PROGRAMS AND WHOSE
NATIVE LANGUAGE IS ENGLISH. I
FOUND THE PROCESS VERY DIFFICULT
TO NAVIGATE. I ATTENDED THE
UNIVERSITY OF SAN DIEGO'S LAW
SCHOOL EDUCATION ADVOCACY CLASS
TO LEARN ABOUT SPECIAL EDUCATION
PARENTAL AND STUDENT RIGHTS FOR
MY CHILDREN. AS A PROFESSIONAL I
NOW FIND THE PROCESS FOR CLIENTS
WITH LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY
CONFUSING AND WITH OBSTACLES.
IMPEDING THEIR ABILITY TO
MEANINGFULLY PARTICIPATE IN
THEIR CHILD'S SPECIAL EDUCATION
PROGRAM. PROVIDING EDUCATIONAL
RECORDS AND SPECIAL EDUCATION
MATERIALS IN THEIR NATIVE
LANGUAGE IN ADDITION TO
KNOWLEDGEABLE TRANSLATORS WILL
ENABLE MORE EQUITABLE
PARTICIPATION FOR ELLIE P.
PARENTS AND SPECIAL EDUCATION
PROCESS. TIMELY TRANSLATION OF
THE DOCUMENT IS IMPERATIVE TO A
PARENT'S KNOWLEDGE AND
UNDERSTANDING OF THEIR CHILD I
REPEAT. AFFORDING THEM THE
OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE PERMANENT
INPUT AND ASK QUESTIONS RELATED
TO THE PROPOSED EDUCATIONAL
CRITERIA PROGRAMS AND SERVICES.
OFFICIALLY TRANSLATIONS OF
RECORDS SCREENPLAYS IP PROCESS
THAT ACCORDING TO THE STUDENT. A
FREE AND APPROPRIATE EDUCATION
IN A TIMELY MANNER ACCESSING
APPROPRIATE SUPPORTS AND
SERVICES PAVING THE ROAD FOR
EDUCATIONAL PROGRESS ON BEHALF
OF PARENTS AND STUDENTS WITH
LIMITED ENGLISH I RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE TO ESTABLISH A
CLEAR EDUCATIONAL STATUTE FOR
ALL DISTRICTS TO APOLLO. THANK
YOU AND THANK YOU MISS PRIMER
YEAH I ANY OTHER WITNESSES HERE
IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM WISHING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE
MEASURE. WELCOME UNION NAME YOUR
ORGANIZATION AND YOUR POSITION
PLEASE. MORNING MISTER TURNER
MEMBERS GREGORY KRAMER ON BEHALF
OF DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA
WERE A PROUD SPONSOR OF THE BILL
I'M ALSO A PARENT OF THE CHILD
AND SPECIAL EDUCATION AND I
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
JENNIFER WATER ON BEHALF OF
ADVICE AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
CHRISTIE SUPPORTED A PURCHASE ON
BEHALF OF EDUCATE ADVOCATE IN
MARIN STRONG SUPPORT IN A CO
SPONSOR THANK YOU. PAGE CLARK ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ALLIANCE OF CHILD AND FAMILY
SERVICES IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU. CLINTON OF EC ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIA HEALTH COALITION
ADVOCACY IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
PAULA'S LASKY ON BEHALF OF
EDUCATE ADVOCATE AND A PAIR OF
SPECIAL NEEDS CHILDREN I SUPPORT
THANK YOU. MISTER CHAIRMAN
SENATORS AND OKAY ONE ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA CHARTER
SCHOOLS ASSOCIATION APOLOGIES
FOR NOT GETTING A LETTER IN
TIME. FOR INSTRUCTS WORK. THANK
YOU I DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION OF LIKE TO SPEAK.
AS A LEAD WHEN HIS OPPOSITION
THE MEASURE. SEEING NO THE
COMMITTEE ROOM IS ANYBODY IN THE
GREEN ROOM LIKE TO DESTROY IN
OPPOSITION. AND ALL. THAT THREE
WELL LET'S GO TO THE
TELECONFERENCE I MISTER MODERATE
IF YOU COULD PLEASE PROMPT
ANYBODY WISHING DEATH BY EITHER
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION THE
MEASURE BY PHONE. THANK YOU
AGAIN PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT
THIS TIME. I WOULD ALIGN NUMBER
NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. REBECA
GONZALEZ NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
BLACK WORKERS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. I CAN'T
GIVE ME JUST A MOMENT HERE TO
SUPPORT BOTH. GOT ONE MORE. AND
HOLD HERE JUST A SECOND. HELLO A
LINE NUMBER NINETEEN GO AHEAD.
YOU KNOW SO SEASON OF REGIONAL
CENTER AGENCIES ALSO IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU ANYBODY ELSE IN THE
TELECONFERENCE ON. CURRENTLY
NONE THANK YOU. THANK YOU MR
MURRAY WAS BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE MEMBERS COMMITTEE
WISHING. TO SPEAK ON THE BILL.
THE VICE CHAIR CLICK FIRST. I
WISH YOU COULD FOR INSTANCE
SENATOR JOE VOTE CAST RESERVE
CHUTES. A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS ON
ON THIS- M. SO I SUPPORT THE
MEASURE WITH REGARDS TO HAVING
THEM- HAVING THE DOCUMENTS BEING
TRANSLATED. I'M LOOKING AT THE
LOGISTICAL PART OF IT FOR THE
SCHOOL DISTRICTS I WANTED TO
FIRST OF MISTER CHIRLA. AB WHAT
SCHOOL DISTRICT. DO YOU DOES
YOUR CHILD ATTEND. LODI LORD I
DISTRICT OKAY. DEPENDING ON THE
SCHOOL DISTRICT- DO WE HAVE
ENOUGH. A QUALIFIED TRANSLATORS
TO BE ABLE TO BE HIRED BY SCHOOL
DISTRICTS TO MEET THIS
REQUIREMENT. BECAUSE THAT'S ONE
OF THE BIGGEST FACTORS THAT. I
HAVE SEEN WITH PRO WAS NOT BE
ABLE TO BE IMPLEMENTED WITH
WITHIN SCHOOL DISTRICTS BECAUSE
I BELIEVE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE
REQUIRED TO TRANSLATE. DOCUMENTS
FOR PARENTS BUT I'M TRYING TO
FIGURE OUT HOW MUCH HOW MANY OF
THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS DO NOT HAVE
THE PERSONNEL TO BE ABLE TO MEET
THE NEED AND IT'S NOT WHETHER OR
NOT THEY DON'T WANT TO BUT IT'S
THE FACT THAT THEY DON'T. THEY
DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO
FULFILL THIS REQUIREMENT I
BELIEVE THERE IS ENOUGH-
RESOURCES OUT THERE TO
ADEQUATELY MEET. MANDATE LIKE
THIS- I DO THINK SCHOOL
DISTRICTS HAVE A CHALLENGE- AND
I DO THINK. UNFORTUNATELY IT
LEADS TO DELAYS AND I THINK BY
FORCING THE ISSUE. WE'RE GONNA
MAKE SURE THAT IT GETS DONE AND
I THINK THERE'S ENOUGH
TRANSLATORS OUT THERE AND WE'RE
LIMITING IT TO THE TOP EIGHT
LANGUAGES. IN A PARTICULAR
DISTRICT- AND SO WE THINK THAT'S
ALSO PRUDENT- BUT I DO THINK THE
RESOURCES ARE OUT THERE TO
ACCOMMODATE I THINK THE- IF WE
DON'T. YOU YOU NEVER GET BACK
FIRST GRADE YOU NEVER GET BACK
TO SECOND GRADE YOU KNOW WE HAVE
TO DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO MAKE
THESE TRANSLATIONS AVAILABLE IS
IT GOING TO BE EASY NOW. COM AND
I RESPECT THE QUESTION. BUT I
THINK IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE
HAVE TO. AND ARE THE SCHOOL
DISTRICTS ARE ALREADY REQUIRED
TO GET THE REQUIRED TO TRANSLATE
BUT NOT IN A TIMELY MANNER THEY
DON'T HAVE TO DO IT WITHIN
THIRTY DAYS AND OKAY AND SO THEY
DON'T. YOU KNOW AS YOU KNOW
THINGS GET PUSHED. PUSH BACK YOU
KNOW. AND ARE WE GIVING THEM
TIME TO BE ABLE TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY HAVE THE PERSONNEL TO
TRANSLATE. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE
IMPLEMENTATION DATE IS. WE KNOW
WHAT THE IMPLEMENTATION DAVIS.
THAT IS AND WHAT HAPPENS IF WE
DON'T HAVE. SOMEONE CAPABLE WE
DON'T HAVE PUNITIVE MEASURES IN
IT OKAY SO BUT WHEN A CAR. FOR
THE FOR THE MELLOW THE TEETH ARE
IF YOU REQUIRE THEY'RE GOING TO
DO IT- BUT RIGHT NOW WE'RE NOT
PENALIZING THEM FOR NOT DOING IT
BUT- WE'RE REQUIRING TO DO IT
AND AGAIN. WENCH FIRST GRADERS
OVER FIRST GRADES OVER I MEAN SO
THIS IS ONLY FOR PERSONS AND I'M
JUST SAYING YOU DON'T GET THOSE
YOUNG. OFTENTIMES IF YOU DO
THINGS IN EARLIER GRADES IT HAS
A BIGGER IMPACT AND WHAT I'M
SAYING IS WHEN THOSE IP'S FIRST
COME OUT FOR THE YOUNGER KIDS.
THAT IS A MISSED OPPORTUNITY IF
WE DON'T TAKE IT AND SO. I'M NOT
I'M NOT DEBATING THAT IT'S GOING
TO BE DIFFICULT. BUT I'M SAYING
THE BENEFIT IS WORTH THAT
DIFFICULT. AND THAT'S WHERE I
COMPLETELY AGREE WITH YOU I
BELIEVE THAT IT IS A BENEFIT IT
IS SOMETHING. BUT THE REALITY IS
WE JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE ABLE TO
IMPLEMENT THIS POLICY- IN A IN A
TIMELY MATTER AND EFFICIENT
MANNER. CAN THEY WITH THE
PRINTER BUT LET'S YOU KNOW
CHINA. AND ZERO CHAU. BECAUSE
REALLY THAT'S NOT THE UNIT- NO I
CITY BE ZEROS THE FEDEX YOU ONLY
IN SYCAMORE THAT. GIVE WITHIN
EIGHTY THAT- AT THAT AND SEE OF
THE COMMANDOS ARE. IT SHOULD BE
FOR CHIU HIS ABOUT I THINK THE
TRUE. AS THE TO UNITED THE
ANSWERS WERE RECKLESS THE
QUESTION WAS- I'M ALSO OUT.
WHETHER OR NOT CHOI. THE TO READ
OR HAVE I TO. TRANSLATING ARE
PEOPLE THAT ARE BILINGUAL THAT
CAN HELP TRANSLATED THE
TRANSLATE THESE- ACADEMIC ORDER
IT PEAS BURKE. PER CHILD IN HER
COMMUNITY. NOT NOT MATERNAL
SNUCK IN ENGLAND SAID RESEAL ON
THE WITH ENTITLES YOU DISS LOCAL
POST IN. NOW HE ABDUCTED THEM
YET- THROUGH A WHOLE IN WHICH IS
FOR ESSAY ONE AT THE THAT'S
GOING OKAY. A KNOWS NOT COMPLY
THEM AND DOING ON A LONG RUNNING
SO THAT THE AND SO BOOK VALUE
THAT THEY'LL DO THE TO SEE A
ALSO IS MUCH WAS DOWN. THE CAST
WE THAT SEVERAL STATES SEE IN
THE SQUARE. GATE NÚMERO THEIR
FIRST ONE AS SOON BILLION- IN
THE SISTERS WERE LEADING- GET A
LAP AS HE THAT A LOT OVER LIKE A
BUS THAT THEY- ARE TWO ZERO THE
WOMAN. NINE NINETY IN IN IN THE
IN THIS WAY THAT GET A WITHIN A
WITHOUT A DOUBT THIS LAST ELLIS
. LASSEN WITH LOW KISSES OF OKAY
SB THREE TWO MINUTE FUNDS HOW
THAT IT THAT I'VE TO GET ON SAN
.
SIS IS LIMÓN DOES NOT KNOW
PREVENTING ONE PEOPLE DATE THE
CLASSIC EASY MAKING OUT AN AWFUL
ALONG WITH ELSE I AS THEY-
APPARATUS. IN ENGLISH COMP.
FORGET THAT I MEAN- ARTICLES IN
WHICH IS A LITTLE SAID SYSTEM IT
DOESN'T MIND GOING THROUGH OUT
BUT A WONDERFUL MY THAT THEN THE
BUT I CANNOT TELL YOU THINK
THERE I. IF THE NETTING. I MEAN
WITHOUT THE- ONE OF THE
COMENTARIOS SAID HELLO WITH A K.
ALMOST ANIMALS LESS AS WELL AS
THE EMAIL THIS BILL HAVE ANY
THAT THAT ARE LOOSE. THE MOMENT
THOSE I YOU MAY NOT BY THE LOWER
THERE'S A OF THE EMBASSY THE
LOST BY. MIDDLE NOT LAST THREE
MONTHS GOING. IS GAY ME IS THE
LAST THE LAST THE SCHOOL LOOKING
SEE THAT THE ENCOUNTER I GET
THINGS THAT LAST AND- LAB A
LITTLE BIT I MEAN TO PROVIDE
NINETY DOUBLE THE TITLES. SIX OF
THE CUENTA HE WOULD THE LAST THE
LAST AB REQUESTED A GOOD THING
GOING YOUR IS. MAN THE MOST
COMMON THAT OKAY THE CLICK HERE
SO THERE'S A SCHOOL I WAS OUR
ONLY BE IN ELECTRIFY ADDING ON
THAT THINK IT.
AND JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE
THAT- SHE UNDERSTOOD WHAT MY
QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS WERE TO
THE AUTHOR AND THEN THE OTHER AT
QUESTION I ASKED WAS WHETHER OR
NOT. THE THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS
HAD PERSONNEL WHO HAVE SPOKE
THEY WERE BILINGUAL THAT COULD
TRANSLATE THAT SHE COULD HAVE
ACCESS TO- OTHER THAN OFFICIAL
AND THEN THE OTHER WORDS ENTER
ANSWER WAS- AND PRACTICES. SORRY
HEARD HER ANSWER WAY THAT THEY
DO HAVE IT BUT- WITH TECHNICAL-
WITH TECHNICAL- AB TWENTY
LANGUAGE IN THE I DON'T HAVE
ANYTHING UNDERSTOOD- AND THEN
YET THE LAST QUESTION THAT I
ASKED HER WAS WHETHER OR NOT THE
SCHOOL DISTRICT. FACILITATED
CLASSES TO TEACH ENGLISH TO HELP
THAT PERHAPS YOU HAVE THE
TEACHERS ABLE TO TRANSLATE A
DOCUMENT SO JUST FINDING OTHER
RESOURCES WITHIN THE COMMUNITY
TO BE ABLE TO STRESS HIGH
PRESSURE THAT WILL LET LET ME
HAVE THE AUTHOR SPEAK TO THOSE
ISSUES PLEASE. SO ONE THING-
SOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS FRANKLY.
COMPLETE THESE WITHIN TEN DAYS.
SOME DISTRICTS TAKE INORDINATELY
LONGER PERIODS OF TIME AND WHAT
WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS CREATE A
UNIFORM SYSTEM SO THEIR
CERTAINTY FOR THE FAMILIES-
OBVIOUSLY. WE HAVE A MULTI.
STATE THERE IS. NUMEROUS
PROFESSIONALS THAT SPEAK
MULTIPLE LANGUAGES I THINK WE'LL
DISTRICTS WILL ACCOMMODATE THIS
BUT WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT
IT'S REQUIRED OF THEM TO DO IT
AND SO THAT'S THAT'S WHAT WE'RE
TRYING TO DO HERE. THANK YOU
SENATOR JOB CHEN WILL DO THAT
YOUR QUESTION GOOD. NO QUESTION
JUST A COMMENT SO MY WIFE AND
THAT'S A NIGHT. ONE OF OUR
CHILDREN SPECIAL NEEDS. I
BELIEVE THAT WE ARE- EDUCATED
CONSUMERS AND EVEN WE HAD A-
PROBLEMS AT TIMES YOU KNOW NOT
NAVIGATING THE SYSTEM SO I CAN.
DON'T EVEN BEGIN TO FATHOM THEIR
HURDLES- THESE FAMILIES GO
THROUGH AND- HI SO I SALUTE YOU
FOR CONTINUING TO PUSH THIS BILL
IS RIGHT THING TO DO BECAUSE
EDUCATION ABOUT LIFTING UP.
EVERYBODY AND IT'S A LACK OF
COMPASSION ADMINISTRATION FOR
VETOING THIS TWICE SO I'M
DEFICIT PART OF IT I DID GET A
CHECK FOR MY MOTHER IN LAW WHO
WANTS ME TO ASK YOU IF I COULD
BE ADDED AS A CO AUTHOR. AND
EDITOR AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
AND THEN I PERSONALLY THINK- I
KNOW A LOT OF MEMBERS IN BOTH
HOUSES. KIND OF FELT EMASCULATED
OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS AND NOT
BEING TREATED AS A CO EQUAL
BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT. THIS IS
WHY THESE BILLS THAT I THINK IF
IT WERE TO GET VETO IT AGAIN.
THAT WE PRIORITY TAKE A LOOK AT
THE BODY. THREE FOUR FIVE NINE
OH SIX BILLS AND ACTUALLY OVER
RIGHT IF YOU GO AND KIND OF REAR
START OR STOP IN THE PROCESS BUT
THIS IS A RIGHTEOUS CAUSE AND- I
BUT I LOVE YOUR PASSION ON THIS
ISSUE AND- I HOPE YOU'RE
SUCCESSFUL THIS TIME. AND GIVEN
THE REQUEST CAME FROM YOUR
MOTHER LIVE WILL PROUDLY PUT YOU
ARTISTIC AND CAN WE TAKE THAT AS
YOUR CLOSER TO WHERE DATA. ACT
ACTUALLY SHE JUST TEXT AGAIN SHE
SAID THANK YOU SHE SAID TO BE
NICE IF. AND SHE BECAUSE YOU
ANTHONY AND SO I MEAN YOU HAVE A
PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP IF I COULD
BE PRINCIPLE CO AUTHOR SHE WANT
TO KNOW IT WAS POSSIBLE TO TELL
HER ON SHE SHOULD. MEDIA WHICH
MEANS OF COURSE IN OUR JUST
TALKED. SO NOW YOU'RE SO UP. ALL
RIGHT WE'RE SO THOUGH. AND
EVERYBODY THANK YOU
PARTICIPATING HIS FAMILY. SO ED
I'VE GOT A MOTION PRESENTED. I
ACTUALLY GIVE YOU KNOW BECAUSE
YOU WOULD LIKE TO OUR- CENTER
FOR DATA. I YOU GAVE MIKE I DID
I DON'T THIS CENTER WILL TRUMP.
I RESPECTFUL ASK FOR A PRE THAT
. TO BE CLEARED YOU KNOW THERE
ARE AMENDMENTS TO ENSURE
CONCERTS WITH EXISTING LAW
RELATED ON PRIVATE CHARTER
SCHOOLS YOU DO YOU HAVE
ACCEPTED. THOSE MEMBERS WILL
MOTION FROM CENTER GLAZER MADAM
SECTOR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED THE
FIRST. AND RE REFER TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
NEWMAN AYE NEWMAN I WOULD SHOW
BOTH AYE PATROL BOATS I'D
CORTESE. GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE
MCGUIRE. SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. WILK
I WILL GUIDE. NEXT DRIVE SB FOUR
SIXTY SEVEN I WILL BE INTERESTED
IN HOW CENTER WORKS MOTHER IN
LAW FEELS ABOUT THIS BILL.
PLEASE PROCEED. WELL I TALKED TO
YESTERDAY BUT- I'M MISTER
CHAIRMAN. TODAY I'M- SP SIXTY
SEVEN MY FINAL FOUR BILLS THIS
MORNING. WHICH YOU SHOULD CLUB
OVER THAT- WHICH WOULD PROHIBIT
A COMMUNITY COLLEGE FROM IT'D
TODAY NOT FROM DENYING A STUDENT
ACCESS TO AN INTERNSHIP OR
APPRENTICESHIP TRAINING PROGRAM
BASED ON THEIR USE OF AN
INDIVIDUAL TAX IDENTIFICATION
NUMBER FOR IT WHEN APPLYING FOR
THESE PROGRAMS. IN THE PAST
WE'VE MADE GREAT STRIDES TO
INCREASE ACCESS TO EDUCATION FOR
UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS MAKING
SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENTS THAT
INCENTIVIZE COMPLETION AND
PROMOTE JOB PLACEMENT. THE
FACULTY ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES
BROUGHT TO OUR ATTENTION THAT
SOME SCHOOLS HAVE DENIED
ADMISSION TO STUDENTS IN CERTAIN
CAREER TECHNICAL EDUCATION OR
WORKFORCE PROGRAMS BECAUSE OF
THEIR IMMIGRATION STATUS.
RESULTING IN NOT BEING ABLE TO
COMPLETE THE PROGRAM OR SECURE
THE EMPLOYMENT WE IN ESSENCE
WERE. HAVING THEM COME INTO THE
SCHOOL AND THEN HAVING CERTAIN
PROGRAMS DENIED TO THEM BASED ON
A PARTICULAR TYPE. OF
IDENTIFICATION WITH SO THIS BILL
PROVIDES PROVIDES AN IMPORTANT
STEP IN CORRECTING THIS INEQUITY
OF THE INEQUITY ENSURING THAT
IMMIGRANT STUDENTS. DO NOT
PRESENT THAT IMMIGRATION STATUS
DOES NOT PRESENT A BARRIER TO
OBTAINING A HIGHER EDUCATION FOR
ALL OF OUR STUDENTS SO WITH ME
TODAY. I HAVE WENDY BELL RING
CUTS FROM THE FACULTY
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
COMMUNITY COLLEGES AND ZACHARIAH
WOULDN'T FROM THE STUDENTS
SENATE. FOR COMMUNITY COLLEGES
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT I HOPE
YOU. LIKE. QUIET YEAH. WELL
THANK YOU- GOOD MORNING MR
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
ZACH RIGHT WOULDN'T AND I'M THE
VICE PRESIDENT LISTED AFFAIRS
WITH THE STUDENT CENTER FOR
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES WE
REPRESENT OVER ONE POINT EIGHT
MILLION STUDENTS IN THE
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGE
SYSTEM. OUR PRODUCT CO SPONSOR
S. B. FOUR SIX SEVEN- WHICH
WOULD STOP THE PRACTICES OF
CERTAIN CAREER TECHNICAL
EDUCATION PROGRAMS FROM
EXCLUDING UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS-
WHO NEED TO USE AN INDIVIDUAL
TAX IDENTIFICATION NUMBER OR AN
I. T. I. AND- FOR BACKGROUND
CHECKS OR OTHERWISE QUALIFIED TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE PROGRAM. WITH
APPROXIMATELY US WITH ESTIMATED
TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS IN THE
CALIFORNIA RECALL SYSTEM. AND
WITH COMMUNITY COLLEGES CLOSELY
LINKED TO THE CAREER AND
TECHNICAL EDUCATION PROGRAMS-
THAT THEY HOST THIS ISSUE IS
CLOSELY RELATED TO US AS
STUDENTS. I WITH THE SS TRIPLE
C. SUPPORTED EIGHTY FIVE NINE
FIVE IN TWENTY NINETEEN WE
BELIEVE THAT THIS WOULD OPEN
DOORS FOR UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS
AND HELP FILL HIGH DEMAND JOBS
WITH QUALIFIED PEOPLE. YET
THAT'S NOT WHAT HAPPENED. I
COLLEGES AND PLACEMENT PROGRAMS
HAVE USE WHICH SHOULD HAVE BEEN
A TOOL FOR ACCEPTING MORE
STUDENTS INTO THEIR PROGRAMS AS
A WAY TO BLOCK STUDENTS BASED ON
THEIR IMMIGRATION STATUS.
UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS DO EXIST
AND THEY'RE NOT GOING ANYWHERE
ENABLING THEM TO ENTER ALLIED
HEALTH NURSING BUILDING TRADE
PROGRAMS AND OTHERS REQUIRING AN
INTERVENTION- AN ADVOCATE
INDIVIDUAL TAX IDENTIFICATION
NUMBER. FOR BACKGROUND CHECK
ALLOWS THEM THE OPPORTUNITY TO
INCREASE THEIR LIFETIME EARNING
POTENTIAL BUILDING OPPORTUNITY
FOR THEMSELVES AND FOR THOSE
THAT DEPEND ON THEM. HIGHER
LIFETIME EARNINGS ALSO MEANS
PAYING TAXES AND CONTRIBUTING
EVEN MORE SIGNIFICANTLY TO
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY. ONE OF OUR
STUDENT LEADERS RECENTLY
DESCRIBED THE EXPERIENCE OF
BEING UNDOCUMENTED AS FEELING
LIKE A GHOST. YOU EXIST AND YOU
ARE THERE BUT NOBODY EVER REALLY
SEES YOU. AGAIN UNDOCUMENTED
STUDENTS ARE HERE THEY'RE
TALENTED THEY WANT EDUCATION FOR
JOBS WITH LIFE SKILLS AND THEY
WANT TO WORK. LET'S NOT PREVENT
THEM FROM THAT FROM BECAUSE OF
WHERE THEY COME FROM. SHOWING
DOCUMENTS TUNES THAT YOU CAN SEE
THEM AND SUPPORT SB FOUR SIX
SEVEN WITH AN AYE VOTE. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU DO IT NOW AND
ANOTHER LEAD WITNESS. PLEASE
PROCEED. GOOD MORE CHAIR NEWMAN
MEMBERS MY NAME IS WHEN DEEPER
ONE COULD THE PRESS. OF THE
FACULTY ASSOCIATION OF THE
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES.
FACT ALONG WITH HER COLLEAGUES
ACROSS THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
COLLEGE SYSTEM. HAS JOINED WITH
MEMBERS OF THE STATE
LEGISLATURE. FOR MANY YEARS AND
SUPPORTING THOUSANDS OF
UNDOCUMENTED STUDENTS IN OUR
STATE. THESE STUDENTS ARE OUR
NEIGHBORS OUR COLLEAGUES ARE
FRIENDS AND THEY WORK IN OUR
COMMUNITIES AND GIVE BACK
EXPONENTIALLY COMPARED TO WHAT
WE INVEST IN THEM. IN TWO
THOUSAND AND NINETEEN THE
LEGISLATURE PASSED LEGISLATION
TO ALLOW THE STUDENTS TO UTILIZE
UTILIZE. AN INDIVIDUAL TAX ID
NUMBER FOR THE PURPOSES OF A
BACKGROUND CHECK. REQUIRED BY AN
INTERNSHIP OR APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAM. AB FIVE NINETY FIVE BY
THEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER MEDINA
BROKE DOWN ONE OF THE LARGEST
BARRIERS TO ENTERING A CAREER
TECHNICAL EDUCATION PROGRAM OR
WORK FORCE INITIATIVE THAT THE
STUDENTS FACED AT THAT TIME.
THESE PROGRAMS ALLOWED STUDENTS
TO DRAMATICALLY INCREASE THEIR
EARNING POTENTIAL AND IMPROVE
THEIR OVERALL OVERALL LIVELIHOOD
THROUGH SKILLED TRADES AND
VANSON TRAINING NEEDS NEEDED TO
GROW IN THEIR CAREERS.
UNFORTUNATELY DESPITE THE
INTENTIONS OF THE LEGISLATURE
AND COUNTLESS ADVOCATES FOR THE
STUDENTS SOME COMMUNITY COLLEGE
DISTRICTS HAVE PROGRAMS THAT
DENY STUDENTS ACCESS TO CTP. AND
WORKFORCE BASED ON THEIR USE OF
I. T. I. N. NUMBER FOR THEIR
BACKGROUND CHECKS. THE RATIONALE
IS THAT STUDENTS USING AN I. T.
I. N. MAY NOT BE ABLE TO APPLY
HIS OR HER DEGREE OR CERTIFICATE
AND SECURE A JOB IN THEIR
INTENDED FIELD OF STUDY. THIS
ASSUMPTION IS UNFOUNDED AND MANY
DO GO ON TO FIND EMPLOYMENT IN
THEIR FIELDS AND UNDER AND
UNFAIR THIS CRITERION IS NOT
APPLIED TO ANY OTHER STUDENT
POPULATION APPLYING FOR THESE
TYPES OF PROGRAMS. SB FOUR SIXTY
SEVEN WOULD PROHIBIT THESE
PROGRAMS FROM UTILIZING THE USE
OF AN I. T. I. N. NUMBER OR
IMMIGRATION STATUS. AS THE BASIS
FOR DENYING AN OTHERWISE CAPABLE
STUDENT FROM A C. T. E. OR
WORKFORCE PATHWAY THAT WOULD
ULTIMATELY BE THE DEFINING
CHANGE IN THEIR LIFE WE THINK
SENATOR PORTANTINO. FOR HIS
IMPORTANT WORK IN THE SPACE AND-
JUROR I VOTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU. IT'S ANYBODY ELSE
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM.
WHO'D LIKE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF
THE BILL. WELL GOOD MORNING CHEN
MEMBERS ROAMING FOCUSING WITH
THE PRAYER IN THE KEIGHLEY ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
WORKFORCE ASSOCIATION AND THE
LOCAL THE FORTY FIVE LOCAL
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT BOARDS
ACROSS THE STATE HERE IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. CHEN MEMBERS
OFTEN WEBSTER WITH W. STRATEGIES
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION
FOR OCCUPATIONAL EDUCATION WE
ARE CHEN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU. DR
CRYSTAL NASI- FROM BARSTOW
COMMUNITY COLLEGE EXECUTIVE DEAN
OF WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT WE
SUPPORT AND URGED I VOTE THANK
YOU. THANK YOU- ANYTHING ELSE
LIKE SPEAKING SUPPORT. SEEING
NONE IS ANYBODY HERE LIKE
SPEAKING OPPOSITION. TO THE
MEASURE. ALSO SEE NOW LET'S GO
TO THE TELECONFERENCE I MISSED
MODERATE IF YOU COULD PLEASE
PROP- INDIVIDUALS ON THE
TELECOMS I SPEAK EITHER ON
BEHALF OF OR IN OPPOSITION TO
THE MEASURE. AGAIN YOUR NAME
YOUR ORGANIZATION AND YOUR
POSITION. THANK YOU AND PLEASE
PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME. HE
LOOKED YOU UP IN OPPOSITION OR
IN SUPPORT OF ONE AND ZERO AT
THIS TIME. AND WE'LL GO TO LINE
NUMBER SEVEN. NUMBER ASHLEY
WALKER WITH NINE AND THEN ON
BEHALF OF NORTH ORANGE COUNTY
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT.
MOUNT SAN ANTONIO COLLEGE AND-
COLLEGE IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
YOU. NEXT PLEASE. AND NOW WE GO
TO A LINE NUMBER NINE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING PERFECT
BECAUSE ALL OF THE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. HM. AND WITH THAT
THEY'RE NOT FOR THE LINE THANK
YOU. THANK YOU LET'S BRING IT
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE ROOM
MEMBERS. ANY THOUGHTS ON THIS
BILL CENTER JO'BURG. I'M TALKING
A LOT TODAY- SO QUESTIONS. I
KNOW LAST WAS A HE WAS EITHER
LAST YEAR OR THE YEAR PRIOR
SENATORS SKINNER HAD A SIMILAR
BILL. OR HAD SOME A BILL THAT
HAS TO DO WITH SPECIFICALLY I
BELIEVE IT WAS HAVE TO DO WITH
LAW ENFORCEMENT OR PUBLIC SAFETY
TRAINING COMMUNITY COLLEGES-
THAT LED TO I BELIEVE THE FBI
TRAINING FOUR OR CA I DON'T
QUITE REMEMBER THAT THE DETAILS
ON IT. BUT SOME OF THE CONCERNS
THAT I EXPRESSED THAT WITHIN
THAT IS THAT- WHEN YOU'RE GOING
INTO PUBLIC SAFETY WELL LET ME
LET ME. LET ME. BEFORE EXPRESSED
MY CONCERNS. CLARIFICATIONS WHAT
PROGRAMS ARE DENYING STUDENTS-
ACCESS TO THAT PRINTER PROGRAMS
OR THE CAREERS- IN COMMUNITY
COLLEGES- THAT FOR STUDENTS WHO
HAVE THE TO NUMBER. WHAT SORT OF
PROGRAMS ARE WE LOOKING AT RIGHT
THAT ARE CURRENTLY DENYING-
ACCESS. HOME AND BUILDING TRADES
I'M SORRY ALLIED HEALTH PROGRAMS
AND BUILDING TRADES- AND WHAT
WHAT'S THE REASON BEHIND THOSE.
PARTICULAR PROGRAMS THE NINE
AXIS WHAT ARE THE REQUIREMENTS
AFTER THAT THERE IS THAT
BACKGROUND REQUIREMENT FOR CHECK
FOR SOME PROGRAMS- FOR SOME
EMPLOYMENT AFTER COMPLETION OF
THOSE PROGRAMS IS MY
UNDERSTANDING AND- BASED ON THE
CONCERN. WHETHER SOMEBODY CAN
USE AN I. T. I. N. NUMBER IN A
BACKGROUND CHECK FOR THAT
EMPLOYMENT THERE STUDENTS ARE
BEING DENIED ACCESS TO EVEN THE
TRAINING PROGRAMS. IS THAT FOR
SECURE YOUR SAFETY PROGRAMS IN
IT- BE ABLE TO COME TO. DO THE
JOB. R. R. I'M TRYING TO
UNDERSTAND WHY WHY THE
BACKGROUND WHY ARE THESE CAREERS
REQUIRING A BACKGROUND CHECK.
AND I. T. NUMBER. I AM I I'M
SORRY I DON'T KNOW WHY THEY
REQUIRE AND THEY JUST BE
REQUIRED BUT BUT DETESTED THE TO
CLARIFY THERE ARE PROGRAMS
REQUIRE A SOCIAL SECURITY
NUMBER. OUT THERE WHERE THEY'RE
NOT ALLOWING THE I. TWO NUMBER I
CAN LIEU OF THAT BECAUSE THE
UNDERSTANDING IS THAT IF THOSE
PEOPLE ARE INELIGIBLE FOR FUTURE
EMPLOYMENT TRAINING IT DOES NOT
MAKES IT MAKES SENSE TO MAKE
INVESTMENT AT THIS TIME RIGHT SO
THAT'S RIGHT THAT'S FORGET
CONCEPT IT'S NOT SURE IF THE
ISSUE WITH YOUR OR OF- PEOPLE
ARE QUESTIONING WHETHER THEY CAN
GET THE EMPLOYMENT IF THEY
COMPLETE THE PROGRAM AND THAT'S-
THE- FALSE NARRATIVE THAT WE'RE
TRYING TO. THAT'S CORRECT YES SO
I AM FORMER DEAN- OF NURSING
ALLIED HEALTH AT MANY COLLEGES
AND COMMUNE IN SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA- ONE OF THE ISSUES IS
THAT PRIOR TO EVEN ENTERING INTO
THE PROGRAM THE STUDENTS WILL
NEED TO DO A LIVE SOUND AND
BACKGROUND CHECK. WHICH INCLUDES
THEIR SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER OR
TI AT. SOME PROGRAMS ARE
HESITANT TO BECAUSE THE CLINICAL
SITES OR SOMETHING OF THAT
NATURE. MAY BE HESITANT TO BRING
AN HONOR STUDENT AND SO THEY AB
HAVE UNFORTUNATELY ARONIE ASLI.
STOP THIS TI AND STUDENTS FROM
UP- ACTUALLY ENTERED INTO THE
PROGRAMS WHICH CANNOT HAPPEN
LOOKING FORWARD- IT'S NOT A
LEGAL REQUIREMENT- MOON BEFORE
IMPLEMENTED SO SHOULD NOT. STOP
STUDENT GOING INTO THE CLINICAL
SITES. IN THE FUTURE IF I COULD
COME IN A PLEASE. AND GIVEN OUR
. WORK FORCE NEEDS. WE TALKED
ABOUT EARLIER. WE SHOULDN'T BE
THIS IS A CULVER OF FOLKS WHO
CAN HELP US ON OUR WAY FORCE IN
WE SHOULD BE USING THE
IDENTIFICATION VARY TO KEEP.
THAT PIPELINE FROM SUPER BEING
SUPPLIED IF THAT MAKES SENSE
MAYOR DOOR PROVIDES WE SHOULDN'T
ALLOW THAT BARRIER RIGHT GET IN
THE WAY. RIGHT PROP WORKFORCE
MOMENT. AND SO WITH THAT IN MIND
AND THE REASON I ASKED WE HAVE A
SIMILAR BILLS THAT SORT OF
WANTED TO BREAK THE BARRIERS
WITH SENATOR SKINNER'S LIKE THEY
MENTIONED- EARLIER. I DON'T KNOW
WHAT HAPPENED TO THAT BILL- A
WITH REGARDS TO. REMOVING
BARRIERS FOR STUDENTS THAT WERE
UNDOCUMENTED. I'M GOING THROUGH
LAW ENFORCEMENT- TRAINING-
BECAUSE OF THE REQUIREMENTS
MOVING FORWARD. WHAT WOULD BE I
THINK IMPORTANT TO OUTSIDE AND
IF WE DON'T ALREADY HAVE THAT IN
THE BILL SOMETHING TO CONSIDER
WOULD BE A DISCLOSURE FOR THE
STUDENTS TO MAKE SURE THAT. THEY
KNOW THAT THERE MAY BE- SOME-
REQUIREMENTS AB THAT MIGHT
IMPEDE THEM FROM MOVING FORWARD
IN THOSE CAREERS BECAUSE- THE
SADDEST THING FOR ME WOULD BE
ONE. FOR US TO INVEST MONEY-
BECAUSE WE'RE PROVIDING FOR MANY
OF THE STUDENTS THE ABILITY TO
GO TO SCHOOL- AT NO COST. AND
KEEP PROVIDING THAT TRAINING AND
THEN. SEEING THEM NOT BE ABLE TO
PURSUE A CAREER IN THAT FIELD SO
PERHAPS AN ADVISEMENT WOULD BE
WISE TO SAY HEY YOU'RE DOING
THIS BUT JUST SO YOU KNOW MOVING
FORWARD THESE ARE SOME OF THE
OBSTACLES THAT YOU MAY FACE
BECAUSE YOU DON'T HAVE. L. S. A
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER YOU HAVE
A TWO NUMBER INSTEAD- JUST
SOMETHING THAT WE SHOULD
PROBABLY KEEP IN MIND AND MAYBE
CONSIDER ADDING ON TO THE BILL
I'M LOOKING FORWARD. ANY TO COME
TO THE COMMITTEE. I'VE GOT A
MOTIONS CENTER GLAZER UNANSWERED
PLEASE ARE YOU A CLOSE I'M SORRY
SIR BORDER I RESPECTFULLY ASK
HER ARRIVAL COULD CLOSE SHOW-
MEMSIC A PROCESS ONE YET. AS
BEFORE SIXTY SEVEN PORTANTINO
MOTION IS TO PASS NEWMAN. NEWMAN
HI PHOTOBOOK. FOR TROUBLED I'D
CORTESE. LASER GLAZER AYE
MCGUIRE. SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. WILL
I WILL BUY. ALL RIGHT LET IT LET
US MOVE ON QUICKLY TO VOTE ON
THE CONSENT CALENDAR. MEMBERS
WHO ARE WITHDRAW AND THE ITEMS
FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR. I'VE
GOT A MOTION SENATE VERSION
MOVED THE CALENDAR- MASSACRED
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ON THE
CONSENT ITEMS NEWMAN AYE NEWMAN
AYE OR TROUBLE HI WHICH- BOTH
I'D CORTESE. LASER GLAZER I'M-
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS WILK I WILL DIE
. AWESOME AND I WELCOME TO THE
PODIUM CENTER MEASURE WELCOME
YOU ARE GOING TO PRESENT S. B.
FOUR NINETY NINE- PLEASE PROCEED
IN READING. THANK YOU CHAIR
GIVEN MORNING MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE FIRST I REALLY WANT TO
TAKE A MOMENT TO THINK OF THE
COMMITTEE STAFFER WORKING WITH
MY TEAM ON THIS BELT. IN AYE
WELL I DO WANT TO KNOW THAT I
WILL BE ACCEPTING THE TECHNICAL
AMENDMENTS A STATEMENT PAGE FIVE
OF THE ANALYSIS. SO I'M GONNA
TALK ABOUT S. B. FOUR NINE NINE
MY COURSE SCHOOLS ACT WHICH
WOULD DRESS ISSUE APART GROUND
SURFACES ON SCHOOL CAMPUSES THAT
IMPACT THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
STUDENTS. SPECIFICALLY THIS BILL
IS LOOKING TO DO FOR DIFFERENT
THINGS CREATE AN EXTREME HEAT
ACTION PLAN SAVING THE BY THE
EARLIEST TIME OR THE NEXT TIME
SCHOOLS WERE SURFACE TO
RESURFACE THEY WILL OFFER A
COOLER SOLUTION. TO INSTALL
SHADE TREES AND MANY FORESTS
THAT HAVE BEEN SHOWN TO MITIGATE
THE IMPACTS OF EXTREME HEAT AND
POLLUTION. THREE IT'S GOING TO
REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL
SERVICES TRYING TO FIND A
LIAISON THAT IS TRAINED IN
EXTREME HEAT MITIGATION EFFORTS
AND LASTLY. IT IS ASKING FOR IT
IT IS REQUIRING THE DEPARTMENT
OF EDUCATION IN CONSULTATION
WITH DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL
SERVICES TO DEVELOP A PLAN THAT
WOULD SERVE AS A- MODEL PROGRAM
A GUIDE BOOK IF YOU WILL. THAT
IS MADE AVAILABLE TO SCHOOL
SITES PLEASE NOTE THIS FINAL
SECTION THE LANGUAGE OF IT IS
STILL BEING WORKED ON AS WE MOVE
THROUGH THE PROCESS. WE DON'T
KNOW CLIMATE CHANGE HAS LED TO
AVERAGE TEMPERATURES RISING IN
THE UNITED STATES
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTING OUR
BLACK INDIGENOUS PEOPLE OF COLOR
COMMUNITIES- JUST LAST YEAR THE
L. A. TIMES HIGHLIGHTED. HOW
DRASTICALLY THIS IS IMPACTING
AREAS IN PARTICULAR THE
HIGHLIGHTED AN AREA IN MY
DISTRICT. THE L. A. TIMES WENT
ON TO WRITE ABOUT ON A DAY OF
93 DEGREES WEATHER'S IN THE SAN
FERNANDO VALLEY. THE ASPHALT IN
OUR SCHOOLS REACHED A HUNDRED
AND FORTY FIVE DEGREES. READ
RESEARCH CONTINUES TO SHOW THAT
COMMUNITIES WITH THE FEWEST
RESOURCES USUALLY. HAVE THE
LEAST ACCESS TO NATURE WITHIN
AND SURROUNDING THEIR SCHOOL
GROUNDS. COUPLED WITH THE HIS
HE'D TO POLLUTION AND
ENVIRONMENTAL TOXICOLOGY LEVELS.
MANY OF THE GROUND SERVICE
MATERIALS USED ON SCHOOL
CAMPUSES ARE HARMFUL THESE
MATERIALS GENERALLY CONSISTS OF
ASPHALT CONCRETE SYNTHETIC TURF
ANOTHER PLASTIC SERVICES THE
OVERHEAT AND MELT. BURNING
STUDENTS AND STAFF FROM CONTACT
OR EVEN CATCHING ON FIRE CAN
THIS I HOPE I AM ASSUMING THAT
WE'VE SEEN PHOTOS OF LITTLE KIDS
HAVING TO SIT ON THEIR-
BACKPACKS BECAUSE HOW HOT BASS
BOAT IS. FOR PREVENTING THEM
FROM GOING OUTSIDE AND PLAYING.
A STATEWIDE COALITION OF NEARLY
FIFTY EXPERTS INCLUDING DOCTORS
MEDICAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
RESEARCHERS EDUCATORS YOUTH AND
COMMUNITY GROUPS RELEASED A CALL
TO ACTION REPORT JUST THIS PAST
MONTH. IN AMONG THE EVIDENCE
BASED RECOMMENDATIONS WAS THE
CALL FOR CREATION OF A CLIMATE
RESILIENT MASTER PLAN TO RESERVE
OF. TO SERVE AS A GUIDING LIGHT
FOR CALIFORNIA'S K. THROUGH
TWELVE SYSTEM SPECIFICALLY ON
WHAT I'M LOOKING TO ADDRESS. I
WANT STUDENTS TO BE ABLE TO
THRIVE IN SCHOOL I'M VERY MOVING
THESE HARMFUL SERVICES IN ADDING
GREEN SPACES IT'LL BE
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES STUDENTS
DAILY EXPERIENCES LEARNING
HEALTH. OUTCOMES HERE TODAY WITH
ME TO TESTIFY. ON S. FOUR NINE
NINE IS. CRISTINA HI DON'T RUN
PRESIDENT OF A VOICE CHOICE FOR
A VOICE FOR CHOICE ADVOCACY A CO
SPONSOR OF THE BILL. AND LISA
JONES WHO IS SPEAKING ON BEHALF
OF PIPER PRIMROSE DIRECTOR OF
NON TEXAS CLOSING COSPONSORED
COSPONSOR OF SB FOUR NINE NINE
AND I WELCOME THEM UP. WELCOME
MS HARMAN. HILDEBRAND I'M SORRY
FOR- THANK YOU CHEN NEWMAN AND
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE EDUCATION
COMMITTEE MY NAME'S KRISTINA
HILDEBRAND AND I AM THE
PRESIDENT AND FOUNDER OF A VOICE
FOR CHOICE ADVOCACY. I AM PROUD
SPONSOR OF SB FOUR NINE NINE.
THE GOAL OF SB FOUR NINE NINE IS
TO CREATE SCHOOL ENVIRONMENT
WHICH BENEFITS STUDENTS AND STOP
PHYSICALLY MENTALLY AND
ENVIRONMENTALLY. AND ENSURE THAT
THIS IS ACCOMPLISHED FROM A
PLACE OF EQUITY. SB FOUR NINE
NINE WILL MITIGATE BOTH EXTREME
HEAT AND AIR POLLUTION IN
CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS IN LINE WITH
THESE PRIORITIES IN OUR STATE.
AND BY THE GOVERNOR. CHILDREN
SPENDING SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF
THEIR DAY AT SCHOOL REMOVING
SYNTHETIC SURFACES THAT ABSORB
HEAT AND ADDING SHADE TREES IN
PLACES THAT ARE ACCESSIBLE TO
CHILDREN DURING THE SCHOOL DAY
WELL DIRECTLY PROTECT THEM FROM
HIGH TEMPERATURES AND TOXIC
EXPOSURE. A SENATOR MANAGER OF
OUR MENTION SYNTHETIC SURFACES
CAN RISE TO OVER A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY DEGREES. VEGETATION AND
TREE CANOPY LOWER TEMPERATURES
ON SCHOOLYARDS THREE DIRECT
SHADE AND A PROCESS KNOWN AS AND
PROPER TREND. AND EVAPORATE
TRANSPIRATION IN WHICH TREES
PULL MOISTURE FROM THE SOIL AND
RELEASE IT BY THE LEAVES. AN
AREA OF SHADE CAN BE TWENTY TO
FORTY FIVE DEGREES COOLER THAN
SERVICES IN FULL SUN ACCORDING
TO THE U. S. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY. CHILDREN IN
LOWER INCOME NEIGHBORHOODS ARE
AFFECTED DISPROPORTIONATELY AND
WITH ALARMING FREQUENCY. MAKE
GOING PUBLIC CONCERN ABOUT
ECONOMIC INEQUALITY AND
ENVIRONMENTAL INJUSTICE IT IS
ESSENTIAL TO UNRAVEL THE LINK
BETWEEN POVERTY AND POLLUTION.
AND EXTREME HEAT AND DESIGN
EFFECTIVE MEANS TO SPARE
CHILDREN THESE DETRIMENTAL
EFFECT. RESEARCH SHOWS THAT OF
ENTRY ENTRY COVER IN SCHOOLS IS
POSITIVELY ASSOCIATED WITH
ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE. AS WELL AS
A STUDENTS MENTAL AND PHYSICAL
HEALTH. THIS BILL WILL ENSURE
THAT ALL CALIFORNIA SCHOOLS NOT
JUST THOSE IN AFFLUENT
NEIGHBORHOODS PRIORITIZE NATURAL
SYSTEMS ON THEIR SCHOOL SITES
LEADING TO HEAT AND POLLUTION
MITIGATION. SB FOUR NINE NINE
WILL BE FUNDED THROUGH A NUMBER
OF EXISTING AND FUTURE GRANTS
VOICE TO TRY IS ALSO THAT YOU
COSTS. SB FOUR NINE NINE THREE
THIS COMMITTEE AND I'M HAPPY TO
AND ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU
HAVE TO THANK YOU- WELCOME TO
WATCH ME GET THIS LAST NAME
RIGHT WELCOME MS JOHNSON. GOOD
MORNING TURN THURMOND AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS
LEAH JONES I'M LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR VOICE FOR CHOICE
ADVOCACY. NONTOXIC SCHOOLS ISN'T
ISN'T AB SCA PILOT PROJECT BASED
IN THE BAY AREA AND RECENTLY
LAUNCHED AN AUTO UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT. THE GOAL OF THIS
PROJECT IS TO SUCCESSFULLY
IMPLEMENT AND ORGANIC FIELD
MAINTENANCE PROGRAM INCREASED
ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS AND
INTEREST AND EXPAND GREEN SPACES
THAT MULTIPLE SCHOOL SITES BY
WORKING WITH STUDENTS AND STAFF.
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL STUDENTS ARE
INVOLVED WITH NATIVE HABITAT
GARDENS THE MIDDLE SCHOOL HAS
ESTABLISHED THE TEACHER LED
ENVIRONMENTAL CLUB AND NONTOXIC
SCHOOLS IS PARTNERING WITH
OSBORNE ORGANICS AND BEYOND
PESTICIDES. TO TRAIN THE
DISTRICT MAINTENANCE TEAM AN
ORGANIC FIELD MAINTENANCE TO
BETTER IMPROVE FIELD HEALTH AND
INCREASED DROUGHT TOLERANCE.
ORGANIC GRASS PLAYING FIELDS ARE
THE ONLY CLIMATE FRIENDLY CHOICE
FOR SCHOOLS. THEY'RE COOL
DROUGHT TOLERANT NON TOXIC AND
IT COLLIDED ECOLOGICALLY
COMPATIBLE. THERE ARE A LARGE
NUMBER OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN
CALIFORNIA THAT HAVE ALREADY
MADE GREENING SCHOOLYARDS OF
PRIORITY AND MANY MORE ARE
RECOGNIZING THE BENEFITS OF
GETTING STARTED. DESPITE THIS
THERE'S STILL CONCERN MAJORITY
OF DISTRICTS IN HIGH MINORITY
LOW INCOME AREAS THAT HAVE YET
TO TAKE SUCH STEPS. THESE AREAS
ALSO TOP NATIONAL CHARTS WITH
HAVING THE HIGHEST AIR QUALITY
ENVIRONMENTAL TOXICOLOGY ISSUES.
CAMPUS SCREENING INCLUDING
REMOVING HOT SYNTHETIC SURFACES
AND CREATING OUTDOOR CLASSROOMS
WITH POLLINATOR FRIENDLY PLANTS
AND NATURAL TREE CANOPY SHADE IS
SUPPORTED BY STUDENTS AND STAFF
AS WELL AS COMMUNITY BUSINESSES.
INDIVIDUALS AND A LARGE NUMBER
OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND CHILDREN'S
HEALTH ORGANIZATIONS ADDING
GREEN SPACES INCLUDING TREES
SHRUBS AND NATURAL PROCESS TO
SCHOOLYARDS HAS BEEN LINKED TO
PERSISTENT POSITIVE CHANGES IN
RECESS AND CLASSROOM BEHAVIOR.
INCLUDING INCREASED PHYSICAL
ACTIVITY ATTENTION AND SOCIAL
COLLABORATION HIGHER ACADEMIC
ACHIEVEMENT AND DECREASES IN
STRESS ANXIETY AND DISRUPTIVE
BEHAVIOR. THE CHOICES. SCHOOLS
AND DISTRICTS MAKE ABOUT HOW ALL
MANAGE THEIR DIRECT INTO.
STUDENTS DAILY- MENTAL AND
PHYSICAL HEALTH AND LEARNING
OUTCOMES SYNTHETIC SERVICES
BECOME EXTREME HEAT VECTORS THAT
OVERHEAT. 102 DEGREES
TEMPERATURES HAVE BEEN RECORDED
ON ASPHALT AND SYNTHETIC TURF
TURF HAS MELTED BURNED STUDENTS
AND STAFF ON CONTACT. AND EVEN
CAUGHT ON FIRE SYNTHETIC TURF
CONTAINS TOXIC CHEMICALS LISTED
ON PROP SIXTY FIVE SUCH AS
BENZENE AND PIPAS. THESE
CHEMICALS ARE RELEASED INTO THE
AIR WATER WASTE AND SOIL
CONSTANTLY ESPECIALLY WHEN
PLAYED ON WHEN HEATED AND WHEN
RAIN ON. NATURAL SURFACES NATIVE
SHRUBS AND TREES SEQUESTER
CARBON IMPROVE SOIL HEALTH CARE
QUALITY AND INCREASE THE WATER
HOLDING CAPACITY OF SOIL MAKING
CAMPUSES AND SURROUNDING
COMMUNITIES HEALTHIER COOLER.
AND MORE RESILIENT TO EXTREME
HEAT ON BEHALF OF THE CHILDREN
OF CALIFORNIA AND ESPECIALLY
THOSE IN LOW INCOME AREAS I ASK
YOU TO PASS SB FOUR NINE NINE
THROUGH THIS COMMITTEE THANK YOU
THANK YOU MISTER JONES. ASSEMBLY
HOUSE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM LIKE
TO STAY IN BEHALF OF THE
MEASURE- AND- WE ASKED YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION AND YOUR POSITION.
THIS IS FOR THE PURCHASE ON
BEHALF OF AS BEFORE I MAY HAVE
EDUCATE ADVOCATE WE SUPPORT SB
FOUR NINE NINE THANK THANK YOU.
ALL HAS LASKY BOARD MEMBER OF
EDUCATE ADVOCATE TEACHER AND
PARENTS IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY AND
I SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
HI GOOD MORNING GABRIELLE OF
BARBOSA BEHALF OF THE CHILDREN'S
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT OF SB
FOUR NINE NINE AND RESPECTFULLY
URGING YOUR IPHONE. THANK YOU.
FORTY MICHAEL'S BEAR WITH
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. SHANNON
PRIMER BOARD MEMBER OF EDUCATE
ADVOCATE AND ADVOCATE FOR A
PARENT A CHILD WHO WAS LEFT TO
SLEEP ON. AN 80 DEGREES DAY ON
THE ASPHALT. I NEWMAN FIRMLY
ASKING YOU GUYS TO PLEASE
SUPPORT THANK YOU. NEXT MOVES.
DOES ANYBODY HERE THE COMMITTEE
HEARING LIKE TO STRIKE IN
OPPOSITION TO THE MEASURE PLEASE
. PURSUIT THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS AND STAFF- JEFF BARKER
REPRESENTING THE RIVERSIDE
COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS
AND THE TWENTY THREE SCHOOL
DISTRICTS SUPERINTENDENTS IN
RIVERSIDE COUNTY. WE ARE OPPOSED
TO THE BILL AS INTRODUCED- WE'RE
NOT OPPOSED AT ALL TO HAVING THE
CONVERSATION ABOUT ENSURING THAT
OUR SCHOOLS ARE MORE CLIMATE
RESILIENT- AS A SCENARIO CHOI
BOGUE KNOWS WELL. WE HAVE FOUR
SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND RIVERSIDE
COUNTY THAT ARE ACTUALLY IN A
DESERT- TWO OF THOSE HAVE DESERT
IN THEIR NAMES SO WE HAVE A LOT
OF EXPERIENCE AND HEAT
MITIGATION. OF TO GIVE YOU ONE
EXAMPLE DESERT SANDS UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT CLOSE TO PALM
SPRINGS HAS WORKED WITH THEIR
TEACHERS THEIR STAFF THEIR
STUDENTS AND THEIR COMMUNITY AND
THEIR PARENTS AND THEIR
COMMUNITY A TO COME UP WITH A
HEAT MITIGATION PLANS. TO MAKE
INVESTMENTS AND SHADE STRUCTURES
TO REQUIRE THAT EACH SCHOOL SITE
IN THE DISTRICT ACTUALLY REPORT
ON DAYS WHEN. TEMPERATURES REACH
A CERTAIN THRESHOLD- SO IT'S NOT
AS IF SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN THE
COUNTY AREN'T DOING ANYTHING.
BUT I THINK OUR CONCERN WITH THE
BILL REALLY GETS TO A COMMENT
THAT'S MADE IN YOUR ANALYSIS
THAT REFERENCES THE FLEXIBILITY
TO DEVELOP PLANS THAT CONSIDER
APPROPRIATE LANDSCAPE AND OTHER
FACTORS. EVEN WITHIN RIVERSIDE
COUNTY WE HAVE A VAST DIVERGENCE
OF GEOGRAPHIC CONDITIONS IN PALM
SPRINGS THE AVERAGE TEMPERATURE
IN JUNE AND AUGUST IS OVER A
HUNDRED DEGREES. INTO MACULA IN
THE SOUTH PART OF THE COUNTY
IT'S CLOSE TO EIGHTY DEGREES. SO
THAT THE NEEDS AND THE AND THE
EVEN THE CLIMACTIC CONDITIONS
FOR THE TYPES OF. OF TREES AND
OTHER GREEN EFFORTS THAT ARE
REFERENCED IN THE BILL ARE
DIFFERENT WITHIN THE COUNTY. SO
WE'D LIKE TO CONTINUE THE
CONVERSATION ABOUT WE THINK THAT
MANDATING ONE APPROACH FOR EVERY
SCHOOL DISTRICT. IS NOT THE
CORRECT ROUTE TO GO AND SO WE
WOULD ALSO AND I HATE TO ALWAYS
MENTION. AND WE HATE TO MENTION
THE FISCAL AND PACKED BUT A LOT
OF THESE. WHAT COOL TECH- THEY
ARE MARK. THAN THAN THE TYPES OF
MATERIALS THAT WOULD NORMALLY BE
USE ARE THERE ARE FUNDING
SOURCES BUT THOSE SOURCES ARE
FINITE- AND SO WE WOULD LIKE TO
CONTINUE THIS CONVERSATION AS
VARIOUS. BOND MEASURES ARE-
ADVANCING TO THE LEGISLATURE
THIS YEAR SENATOR GLAZER HAS A
BILL ASSEMBLY MEMBER MURATSUCHI
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GARCIA WHO IS IN
THE DEBT LIVES IN THE DESERT.
HAS A BILL ON CLIMATE RESILIENCY
SO FOR THE REASONS THAT I'VE
OUTLINED WE ARE OPPOSED TO THE
BILL I WOULD LIKE TO CONTINUE TO
WORK WITH THE AUTHOR AND OF
SPONSORS ON. APPROPRIATE
MEASURES APPRECIATE APPRECIATE
YOUR TESTIMONY AT NEXT WEEK'S.
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS SKEWS ME IN
TODAY WITH THE COALITION FOR
ADEQUATE SCHOOL HOUSING AND OF
COURSE I'D LIKE TO ASSOCIATE
MIGHT WE ARE ALSO OPPOSED
UNFORTUNATELY FOR MANY OF THE
REASONS THAT OF ME AYE MR BACA
STATED. I WILL GIVE YOU KIND OF
A SCHOOL FACILITIES AND
MAINTENANCE FRAME ON ON ON THIS
OF COURSE WE ARE VERY WELL AWARE
OF THE- ISSUE OF HEAT IN
SCHOOLS. IT'S NOT ONLY OUTSIDE
BUT IT'S ALSO INSIDE RIGHT
THERE'S MULTIPLE BILLS IN BOTH
HOUSES RIGHT TALKING ABOUT
TEMPERATURE INTERIOR AND THEN WE
HAVE THAT'S WHY THIS ONE SO WE
ALSO WANT TO HAVE THIS LARGER
CONVERSATION. ABOUT THIS BUT WE
DO AS INTRODUCED FEEL LIKE THIS
IS A VERY PRESCRIPTIVE. OF
SCHOOLS ARE KIND OF. YOU KNOW
WE'RE LOOKING AT SOLAR AND
STORAGE AND AIR QUALITY AND-
INTERVIEW RESILIENCE AND STORAGE
AND SO ON AND SO THIS BILL-
TOUCHES ON A LOT OF THOSE VERY
IMPORTANT ISSUES BUT AGAIN.
WE'RE CONCERNED AGAIN THE FISCAL
IMPACT BUT AS PLANNERS HOW DO
HOW DO WE WANT TO MAKE SURE AND-
OF THE LAST WILL USE THAT AS
EXAMPLE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE AT
THE LOCAL LEVEL THAT WE DON'T.
AREN'T ASKED TO DIFFERENT THINGS
RIGHT NOW KIND OF COMPETING OF
GOODS SO TO SPEAK. A WE HAVE
SHADE BUT THEN WE HAVE SOLAR
PLACEMENT AS WELL RIGHT THOSE
ARE BOTH THOSE ARE BOTH VERY
IMPORTANT SO WE JUST WANNA MAKE
SURE AS WE HAVE THIS
CONVERSATION. GOING FORWARD-
THAT OF FOLKS WHO ARE DOING THIS
WORK- HAVE WASTE IN THE PROCESS
AND SO WE ALSO LOOK FORWARD TO
WORKING WITH YOU BECAUSE THIS IS
A- AN IMPORTANT ISSUE AND IT'S
OTHER THERE AGAIN THERE'S- A LOT
OF BILLS. THAT ARE- DISCUSSING
DIFFERENT ASPECTS OF THE ISSUE
IN A IN AN EDUCATIONAL
ENVIRONMENT SO THANK YOU THANK
YOU. IS ANYONE ELSE. IN THE GREY
HERE REALLY TESTIFIED OPPOSITION
YOUR NAME. YOUR EXECUTIVES IN
PLACE GOOD MORNING MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS DOROTHY JOHNSON ON
BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATION FOR
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS
. RESPECTFULLY POST THANK YOU-
AND WILLIAMS. ALL RIGHT LET'S GO
TO THE TELECONFERENCE I MISSED
MODERATE IF YOU COULD PLEASE
FROM. ANYWHERE IN THE TELECOMS
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL WITH
THEIR NAME- THE ORGANIZATION AND
THE POSITION. M. PLEASE PRESS
ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME TO PUT
YOURSELF IN Q. AND WILL FIRST GO
TO LINE NUMBER THIRTEEN PLEASE
GO AHEAD. THE CAPTAIN DON IN
REPRESENTING FAMILIES ASKING FOR
CHEMICAL AND TOXIC SAFETY. I'M
ALSO REPRESENTING. THEIR
ORGANIZATIONS AND THE LETTER
DIDN'T GET THROUGH THE PORTAL.
THE SIERRA CLUB INDIVISIBLE ALL
HAS BEEN A- THREE FIFTY
SOUTHLANDS THAN GREAT GET I
CONSENT. VALLEY CLIMATE ACTION
CALIFORNIA. FANS WILL USE
PLASTIC THE CLIMATE REALITY
PROJECT- WE ARE IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL AND HELP
YOU OVERNIGHT IF YOU COULD SHARE
. YOUR NAME AGAIN I GOT CUT OFF
AS YOU'RE COMING UP. HI
CATHERINE. WITH SAM ADVOCATING
CHEMICAL. EXIT THANK YOU THANK
YOU MISS. NEXT WHICH- AND THAT'S
WHAT I LINE NUMBER. THREE THIS
AT. GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS THE
AND I'M A PARENT TO A SOLITARY A
LITTLE SCHOOLS DURING AND AFTER
. WHERE BOTH CAMPUSES YOU GET
BLAZING HOT FROM. SEVEN OF I
FINALLY. AT THE FOUR NINETY.
THANK YOU THANK YOU. NEXT WAS.
NEXT THE LINE TO FOUR IS WHAT.
BRIAN WALKING WITH THEY TELL
CLAIMS. FILE ITEM PROLIFIC. YOUR
YOUR NAME YOUR OR- YOUR POSITION
FOR. COURT WE ALWAYS SUPPORT THE
BILL AT WORK AB SOLD AND RECORD
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT PLEASE
. THANKS THE LINE FIVE PLEASE
CALL AT. GOOD MORNING CARTER
WITH YOUR CALL HELLO IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU. AND THAT'S WHAT TO
LINE UP EIGHT IS GOING. BY THE
VERY EVERY YEAR OPEN. I'M MOVING
ON WE HAVE LINE NUMBER TEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MNJ PURCELL
SPECIAL EDUCATION TEACHER AT
PUBLIC SCHOOL PARENT AND I'M
WITH JONAS PHILANTHROPIES IN
STRONG SUPPORT AND SAFE PLACES
FOR CHILDREN TO PLAY. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH NEXT WHICH- WE HAVE WE
HAVE A PLAN NUMBER TWENTY SEVEN
PLEASE WHAT. HELLO MY NAME IS
PIPER PRIMROSE AND WITH NONTOXIC
SCHOOLS ALSO REPRESENTING
PESTICIDE FREE ZONE AND WE
AREN'T DRUNK THE PORT OF THIS
BILL. THANK YOU NEXT. AN EXTRA
LINE NUMBER TWENTY TWO PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING THIS IS WILL
BRING HER ON BEHALF OF THREE
FIFTY SACRAMENTO AND WE ARE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU NEXT WHICH- NEXT LEVEL
I NEVER TWENTY ONE PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHUCK BILLS
WITH THREE PEOPLE LOS ANGELES
FUNDS FOR THE BILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU NECKLACE. AN ACTUAL
TRIAL I NUMBER EIGHT AGAIN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE MORNING
SURE NUMBER SURELY DOWN HAPPENS
HEALTH REFORMER DISSOCIATION IN
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU NEXTBUS.
AND WITH THAT WE HAVE NO FOR THE
LINE THANK YOU- LET'S COME BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE HEARING BUT I
HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS IMAGE
WHAT. YOU KNOW CLEARLY THIS IS.
A BIG DEAL RIGHT ISSUE IN MRS
MAY'S JONES WERE VERY ELEGANTLY
DESCRIBING THE EXTENT AND SCALE
THE PROBLEM. I THINK WITH MR
VAIKO POINTED OUT THE FISCAL
IMPACT SO WHAT ARE YOUR
THOUGHTS. ON HOW THIS WILL BE
FUNDED CLEARLY THERE'S RIGHT IN
BEGIN THANK YOU AND I'D LIKE TO
IF THE CHAIR ALLOW ME TO START
OFF WITH. ALSO RESPONDING TO THE
COMMENTS MADE ON THE OPPOSITION
SIDE. UNDER THAT IN TOGETHER-
PLEASE DO RIGHT SO I RECOGNIZE
YOU KNOW EVERY SCHOOL INSTEAD OF
CALIFORNIA IS BASED IN A VERY
DIFFERENT AREA RIGHT SO THIS
ISN'T A ONE SIZE FITS ALL
APPROACH. AND I DO COMMITTED TO
WORKING IN FURTHER HAVING
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE SCHOOL
DISTRICTS ARE REPRESENTATIVES TO
CLARIFY THIS LANGUAGE IN THE
BILL. AS IT MOVES FORWARD
BECAUSE WHAT I WANT TO ENSURE IS
THAT WE MAKE THIS A SUCCESSFUL
AS POSSIBLE AND I DO COMMEND
SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT ALREADY
HAVE A PLAN IN PLACE. THEY'RE
GOING TO BE AHEAD OF THE GAME
WHEN IT COMES TO THIS BILL IN
TERMS OF THE FISCAL IMPACT I YOU
KNOW. YOU KNOW THE LEGISLATORS
HERE BEFORE MY TIME POTS IN THE
BUDGET A HUNDRED THIRTY MILLION
DOLLARS FOR THE URBAN AND
COMMUNITY FORESTRY GRANTS WITHIN
CAL FIRE. AT THE JANUARY BUDGET
PROPOSED- THERE ARE LOOKING TO
ZERO OUT THE REMAINING THIRTY
THREE MILLION HUNDRED SEVENTEEN
MILLION WERE ALREADY INCLUDED
AND GRANTS APPLICATIONS CLOSE
APRIL THIRD. THERE IS ALSO A
FEDERAL GRANT THROUGH THE
EVENING A. P. P. A. BECAUSE THEY
RECOGNIZE HOW IMPORTANT.
IMPORTANT IS THIS WHILE
APPLICATIONS ALSO CLOSE IN APRIL
YOU ARE NOW SEEING HOW IMPORTANT
IS BOTH ON THE FEDERAL LEVEL AND
ON THE LEFT LOCAL LEVEL.
ADDITIONALLY I HAVE COLLEAGUES
BOTH IN THIS HOUSE IN THE OTHER
HOUSE WERE PUSHING LEGISLATION
TO. MAKE THIS GRANT WITHIN CAL
FIRE PERMANENT AND CONTINUE TO
FIND FUNDS FOR THIS THIS IS WHY
MY BILL WAS NOT LOOKING TO
MANDATE CHANGE RIGHT NOW. IT IS
LOOKING TO FOR THE SCHOOLS TO
HAVE A PLAN FOR ONCE WE HAVE YOU
KNOW FUNDING APPROPRIATIONS.
THEY'RE. READY TO GO BECAUSE
AGAIN THE GOAL OF THE IS FOR
THEM TO BE SO. PICTURE THAT
SHOULD SHOW TO ANOTHER MISSED
VARGAS. YOU KNOW THE KIND OF THE
YOU KNOW THE VAST DIFFERENCES
ACROSS THE STATE. BOTH IN TERMS
LANDSCAPING CLIMATE- SHOULD
SCHOOL SITES JOKER FACILITIES
HAVE GREATER FLEXIBILITY. TO
DEVELOP PLANS WHEN HE ADDED THAT
YEAH YOU KNOW AND IT'S OF THIS
THIS IDENTIFIES EACH SCHOOL SITE
AS THE KIND OF AREA. OR OR-
INTEREST FOR DEVELOPING A PLANT
YOU MIGHT MIGHT THAT BE- MIGHT
BE MORE EFFICIENT TO FOR THE
PLAN TO BE AT THE SCHOOL
DISTRICT LEVEL IN SOME DISTRICTS
. COULD YOU REPHRASE LET'S LET'S
WILL BREAK A TOOTH SO IT SO SHE
SHOULD SCHOOL SITES IN SHOCK
ABSORBS HAVE GREATER
FLEXIBILITY. TO TAKE INTO
ACCOUNT DIFFERENCES IN CLIMATE
THE DIFFERENCES IN CONFIGURATION
THERE'S ALSO THE ISSUE OF SOME
SCHOOL SITES ARE NOT OWNED BY
THE L. E. A. THEIR- THEIR OWN
SERVICES PROPERTY SO. HOW DO WE
THINK ABOUT THAT. AS RELATES TO
THE PRESCRIBED SO YOU KNOW
RECOGNIZING THAT YOU KNOW THIS
IS THE FIRST POLICY COMMITTEE
IT'S GOING THROUGH WE'RE STILL
WORKING ON THE LANGUAGE WITHIN A
DO. YOU KNOW WHAT I WANT TO
REAFFIRM THAT I DO COMPLY DO I
DO- I WILL BE CLARIFYING THE
LANGUAGE IN THERE TO ENSURE THAT
WE PUT MORE SPECIFICS AND THE
DIFFERENT TYPES OF LOCATIONS.
WHETHER THEY'RE COLOCATED OR NOT
LIKE YOU MENTIONED AND OTHER
ENTITIES THAT AREN'T UNDER THE
L. E. AS AND SO FORTH. OKAY LET
LAST QUESTION MAYES IS ABOUT
TRAINING THERE'S SOME LANGUAGE
ABOUT- TRAINING FOR PERSONAL
MAKE THE ASSESSMENTS MAKING
THOSE IMPROVEMENTS. WILL PROVIDE
THAT TRAINING AND WE'VE YOU KNOW
BEEN AGAIN MOVING TO ANOTHER
COMMITTEES TO THINK ABOUT- HOW
WILL THOSE CRITERIA WHAT
TRAINING CREATURE SHOULD BE MET.
UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF YOUR
BILL. YES RIGHT NOW THE YOU KNOW
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES
SHOULD HAVE A LIAISON- AND THEN
WITH COLLABORATION WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION. COME
TOGETHER TO PUT TOGETHER THAT
GUIDE. I'M IN TERMS OF THE CALL-
THE ELIGIBILITY OR
QUALIFICATIONS FOR THE LIAISON
WE ARE WORKING WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES TO
COME UP WITH LANGUAGE TO AND
IT'S GOING TO BE WORKED OUT. AS
WE MOVE THROUGH THE LEGISLATIVE
PROCESS. AND I APPRECIATE THAT
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS TO THE
COMMITTEE AND CHECK YOU KNOW WE
DO YOU KNOW WE DO IT WE ARE OPEN
TO MAKING THIS ON A- A SCHOOL
DISTRICT LEVEL FOR. JURISDICTION
I APPRECIATE THAT AND AGAIN THIS
IS DOUBLE REFERRED TO HUMAN
SERVICES FROM HERE CENTER CHAU
VOTE. AND SAYS YOU HEARD THERE
ARE SOME CONCERNS WITH- MY
DISTRICT- THAT SPOKE THIS
AFTERNOON OR THIS. THIS MORNING
ACTUALLY I THINK IT'S VERY SELF-
IN IN THE COMMITTEE. SO I'M
GOING TO SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY
BECAUSE I THINK THE INTENT AND I
KNOW THAT YOU'RE CURRENTLY
ENGAGE IN HAVING CONVERSATIONS.
I DO HOPE THAT YOU TAKING
CONSIDERATION. WHAT AB YOU KNOW
THE NOT ONE SIZE FITS ALL IN IN
TAKING TO. THAT YOU'RE- AREAS.
THAT WE HAVE IN THIS BEAUTIFUL
STATE. WHEN IT COMES TO THAT.
AND ALSO TAKING CONSERVE. THE
THE DISTRICTS THAT ARE ALREADY
BEING PROACTIVE IN IN THIS SPACE
SUCH AS IN MY DISTRICT- I'M
GONNA SUPPORT. THE BILL TODAY-
IN HOPES THAT. THE COMPETITION
WILL CONTINUE THE NEGOTIATIONS
WILL CONTINUE THE CONSIDERATIONS
WILL CONTINUE. I DO RESERVE MY
RIGHT TO. CHANGE MY VOTE- ONCE
THE FINAL LANGUAGE IS DRAFTED
AND SEE WHETHER OR NOT IT MEETS
THE CRITERIA FOR- MY DISTRICT.
THANK YOU HAVE MY COMMITMENT
THAT THAT WILL HAPPEN. GENERAL
THANK YOU MISTER. I GREW UP IN
WORKING CLASS NEIGHBORHOOD AND
WE AND OUR SCHOOL. SCHOOL WE HAD
ASPHALT. AND WE JUST HAD A PATCH
OF GRASS IN THE SOMETIMES A LONG
TIME COSTA BUT SOMETIME DURING
MY ELEMENTARY EDUCATION CAREER-
THE WHAT THE CITY. FORMED A JPA
AND THEY BUILD UP THE REST OF
WHICH WAS JUST. DIRT INTO A PARK
WITH TREES IN INDIGENOUS PLANTS
EVERYTHING ELSE AND- AND WHICH
REALLY MADE A DIFFERENCE IN FACT
I WENT- RECENTLY TO GO PRESENT
AN EDUCATIONAL GRANT TO MY L. MY
HOME ELEMENTARY SCHOOL. AND I
TOOK A TOUR AROUND OF IT AND IT
LOOKS GREAT YOU KNOW YOU KNOW
FIFTY YEARS LATER SO THIS IS
REALLY IS IMPORTANT ISSUE. LIKE
YOU I HAVE A VERY HIGH HEAT
AREA- AND I BUT I HAVE SOME OF
THE SAME RESERVATIONS AT SENATOR
CHOI ABOVE DOES SO I'M WE ARE
SUPPORTED TODAY. GIVE YOU EVERY
OPPORTUNITY AND I THINK YOU WILL
BE SUCCESSFUL- AND RESERVE THE
RIGHT TO VOTE NO AT A LATER DATE
BUT I DON'T THINK I'M GONNA HAVE
TO KIND OF HAPPY TO SUPPORTED
TODAY THANK YOU. SENATE RATES
YOU OR SOMEONE SUGGEST SENATOR.
WEALTHY YOU BRING HEAT
EVERYWHERE YOU GO. FREE EIGHT.
BUT WITH THAT- I'M HAPPY TO MOVE
THE BILL THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK
ON THIS PROJECT TO WORK WITH ALL
PARTIES GOING FORWARD. THE
CENTER OF THE BILL THE
PREPARATORY DEAD CENTER MEASURE
WHICH LIKE CLOSE. JUST TO BE
APPRECIATE THE FEEDBACK AGAIN I
LOOK FORWARD TO ONGOING
CONVERSATION- I DON'T WANT TO
WORK THROUGH THE SPELL AND I ASK
MY COLLEAGUES SUPPORT THE COURTS
COURTS ACT. AND THAT NGUYEN
PROVE THAT WERE MOST IMPROVE THE
WELL BEING OF OUR YOUTH THANK
YOU. I APPRECIATE THAT- MA'AM
SECOND PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SB
FOUR NINETY NINE MINS OF OUR
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED THE
FIRST AMEND AND RE REFER. TO THE
COMMITTEE ON THE HUMAN SERVICES.
NEWMAN ALL RIGHT NEWMAN I TOLD
BOTH SIDES PATROL BOAT I'D
CORTESE. GLAZER GLAZER AYE
MCGUIRE. SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. WILL
I WILL CRY. WE'LL KEEP ON HOLD.
ALL RIGHT NEXT UP THAT THANK YOU
SEE AN IMAGE WORK. WELL DONE AND
NEXT OF CENTER TADO. SHE'S HERE.
JOINT. WELCOME SENATOR TODD
SENATOR YOU WILL BE PRESENTING
SB FOUR EIGHTY SIX. THANK YOU
GOOD MORNING. MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS AS WE ALL KNOW
CALIFORNIA IS FULL OF TALENTED
INDIVIDUALS THAT MAKE OUR STATE
GREAT IN EVERY. IN EVERY WAY.
OUR SCHOOL SPORTS ARE NO
EXCEPTION. GREAT ATHLETES HAVE
STARTED THEIR INSPIRATIONAL
CAREERS HERE IN OUR VERY OWN
SCHOOL SYSTEMS OF AND HAVE GONE
TO. REPRESENT CALIFORNIA AT THE
HIGHEST LEVELS POSSIBLE.
UNFORTUNATELY THE NUMBER OF
THOSE THAT GO ON AND MAKE IT TO
THE PROFESSIONAL STAGE IS VERY
LOW. MEANING THAT THE MORE THAT
MOST OF OUR ATHLETES WILL NOT
EXPERIENCE WHAT IT IS LIKE
PLAYING THE SPORT THEY LOVE ON
THE HIGHEST STAGE POSSIBLE. FOR
THE MAJORITY OF OUR STUDENTS.
HIGH SCHOOLS WHERE THEIR
ATHLETIC CAREERS AND THEY WILL
NOT PLAY ORGANIZED SPORTS EVER
AGAIN. IN EARLY DECEMBER TWENTY
TWENTY TWO UNDER THE RULES OF
THE CALIFORNIA INTERSCHOLASTIC
FEDERATION. THIRTY HIGH SCHOOL
FOOTBALL TEAMS COMPETED IN THE
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAME WHERE
SOME ATHLETES PLAYED THEIR VERY
LAST GAME. WHAT ALL WINNING
TEAMS CAN EQUALLY CLAIM TO BE A
CALIFORNIA STATE CHAMPION. THE
CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH THE GAMES
WERE PLAYED WERE LESS THAN EQUAL
. A SELECT FEW GAMES THOSE
TYPICALLY RESERVED FOR THE
SCHOOLS FROM THE TOP DIVISIONS
THAT WILL BRING IN BIGGER CROWDS
AND DRIVE UP TICKET REVENUE WERE
PLAYED AT NEUTRAL FACILITIES
WITH TURF FIELDS. AND ALMOST
PERFECT FIELD CONDITIONS WHICH
MADE FOR A MEMORABLE AND
POSITIVE EXPERIENCE FOR THOSE
STUDENTS. THE REST OF THE CIF
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES WERE
PLAYED AT THE SCHOOL OF THE
HIGHER RANKING TEAM WITH
FACILITY AND FIELD CONDITIONS
THAT VARIED ACROSS THE BOARD. A
RECENT GAME BETWEEN SHAFTER HIGH
SCHOOL IN ORLAND HIGH SCHOOL
WHICH WAS PLAYED IN A WEEK-
WEATHERED STADIUM WITH INCHES
THICK OF MUD. BOTH TEAMS EARNED
THE RIGHT TO PLAY AT THE STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME. BUT THEY WERE
NOT ABLE TO FULLY SHOWCASE OUR
FULL CAPABILITIES AND
UNFORTUNATELY WE'RE GIVING AN
EXPERIENCE. MAR FROM THOSE OF
HIGHER DIVISIONS. FAMILIES
TRAVELED SIX PLUS HOURS TO
ATTEND THIS GAME IMPORTANT RAME
AND WHEN THEY ARRIVED THEY WERE
NOT THE THERE WAS NOT ENOUGH
SEATING TO HOST THEM AND THERE
WERE LONG LINES FOR RESTROOM
FACILITIES. SMALL TOWNS LIKE
SCHACHTER IN ORLAND ARE
OFTENTIMES THE MOST
DISADVANTAGED AND FORGOTTEN
COMMUNITIES IN OUR STATE. AND
THEIR EXPERIENCE THAT DAY WAS
NOT WHAT THEY HAD HOPED FOR. I
WILL BE THE FIRST TO SAY THAT
SMALL COMMUNITIES ARE OFTEN SOME
OF THE MOST PRIDEFUL COMMUNITIES
THAT WE HAVE. FOOTBALL IN
PARTICULAR IS A SPORT THAT
HEIGHTENS PRIDE NOT ONLY IN
ATHLETES BUT IN THE COMMUNITY AS
A WHOLE. FANS OF THE SPORT WILL
BE THE FIRST TO LET YOU KNOW
THAT IT. BRINGS COMMUNITIES
TOGETHER AS EACH YEAR ON THEIR
TEAMS. AND MAKING IT TO THE
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP IS A GREAT
ACCOMPLISHMENT THAT SHOULD
HIGHLIGHT THE STUDENTS AND THE
COMMUNITIES. WHERE THEY COME
FROM. THESE TEAMS AND
COMMUNITIES SHOULD. HAVE BEEN
CELEBRATED IN TREATED WITH THE
LEVEL OF ATTENTION THAT THEY
DESERVE. THE EDUCATIONAL AND
ATHLETIC EXPERIENCES FOR
STUDENTS IN RURAL AND
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES ACROSS
CALIFORNIA AND ARE UNFORTUNATELY
SHAPED BY THE NEIGHBORHOODS THEY
LIVE IN. IT IS FOR LOW INCOME
AND DISADVANTAGED SCHOOLS
ALREADY LACK OPPORTUNITIES AND
RESOURCES AS THEY FACE A
CHALLENGING PATH TO ACHIEVE
THEIR EDUCATIONAL AND ATHLETIC
GOALS. AND IT'S NO SECRET THAT
HIGH INCOME HIGH SCHOOLS. HAVE
ACCESS TO BETTER QUALITY SPORTS
FIELDS MODERN GEN GYMNASIUMS
STATE OF THE ART ATHLETIC
EQUIPMENT AND OVERALL BETTER
EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES.
FOLLOWING COME SCHOOLS HAVE
LIMITED OR INADEQUATE FACILITIES
FACILITIES THAT NEGATIVELY
IMPACTS STUDENT ATHLETIC
EXPERIENCES AND OPPORTUNITIES.
TO THIS VERY DAY WE CONTINUE TO
SEE AN EQUITY ISSUES. IN THE
QUALITY AND AVAILABILITY OF
OPPORTUNITIES BETWEEN HIGH
INCOME AND LOW INCOME SCHOOLS IN
CALIFORNIA INCLUDING ACCESS TO
HIGH QUALITY SPORTS FIELDS AN
EDUCATIONAL FACILITIES. SB FOUR
EIGHT SIX REQUIRES THE
CALIFORNIA INTERSCHOLASTIC
FEDERATION TO HOLD ALL STATE
FOOTBALL CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES FOR
ALL DIVISIONS AT COMPARABLE
NEUTRAL LOCATIONS. HOWEVER AS
BEFORE EIGHTY SIX DIVES INTO
MUCH DEEPER ISSUE OF INEQUITY
THAT IS SEEN THROUGHOUT OUR
EDUCATION SYSTEMS. ESPECIALLY
WHEN IT COMES TO THOSE IN OUR
ROLE AND DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES. STUDENTS WHO EARNED
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PLAY IN ANY
CIF STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAME
DESERVE. THE SAME TREATMENT. SO
THEY CAN BE SAFE SO THEY CAN
SHOWCASE THEIR TALENTS AND
SKILLS AND SO THEY CAN BE
RECOGNIZED. FOR THE HARD WORK
AND DISCIPLINE IT TOOK TO GET
THERE. FOR THOSE REASONS I
INTRODUCED SB FOUR EIGHTY SIX
WHICH AIMS AT PROVIDING AN
EQUITABLE EXPERIENCE FOR ALL
STUDENT ATHLETES WHO HAVE EARNED
THE OPPORTUNITY TO COMPETE. AND
BE FOREVER KNOWN AS A CALIFORNIA
STATE CHAMPION. I DO WANT TO
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT CAF HAS
INITIATED CONVERSATIONS WITH MY
OFFICE AND HAS EXPRESSED. THEY
ARE LOOKING INTO ADDRESSING THIS
CONCERN OF AN EQUITY AT STATE
FOOTBALL CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES.
ALSO WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
S. STAFF IN THE CONSULTANT FOR
BEING SO KNOWLEDGEABLE ON THIS
ISSUE AND I LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THEM ON
THIS. I DO HAVE TWO WITNESSES
WITH ME HERE TODAY BOTH STUDENTS
WILL BE SHARING THEIR
EXPERIENCES FROM THE RECENT
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAME. A
WITNESS ONE IS EZEKIEL OSBORNE.
SECOND RATED FRESHMAN
QUARTERBACK IN THE STATE AND
THIRD IN THE NATION. AND WITNESS
NUMBER TWO MARK MARIANE SLOAN
ALSO A FRESHMAN PHENOM. HELLO MY
NAME IS YOU ALSO BORN I'M A
FRESHMAN IN THE STARTING VARSITY
QUARTERBACK FIRST AFTER HIGH
SCHOOL IN CHAPTER CALIFORNIA.
UNDER SEVEN TENTHS OF TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY TWO MY TEAM
PLAYED IN THE DIVISION FIVE
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAME FOR THE
CIA. ANOTHER TEAM FROM AREA ALSO
MADE IT TO THE STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME FOR DIVISION
ONE AND THE TEAM'S EXPERIENCES
COULD NOT HAVE BEEN MORE
DIFFERENT. MY TEAM IS NOT A
POWERHOUSE WE ARE A YOUNG TEAM
WITH TWENTY SIX GUYS FROM A
SMALL RURAL SCHOOL. WE GREW AS A
TEAM TO THE SEASON OF STRUGGLES
AND BARELY MADE IT TO THE
PLAYOFFS OUR TEAM GREW CLOSER
AND CLOSER AND WENT ON A WIN
STREAK THAT YOU CAN WRITE A
MOVIE ABOUT. FORTY MILES SOUTH
THE TEAM FROM LIBERTY HIGH
SCHOOL WAS RETURNING TO THE
STATE GAME FOR THE SECOND YEAR
IN A ROW. THEN NINETY PLAYERS
FROM ALL OVER A MUCH BIGGER
TELL. I LIKE EVERY OTHER QB HAVE
ALWAYS DREAMT OF LEADING MY TEAM
TO STATE. THE ONLY VISION OF THE
BIG GAME I HAD WAS WHAT I SAW ON
TV AND SOCIAL MEDIA FROM LIBERTY
STATE CHAMPIONSHIP LAST YEAR.
THE HUGE BECAUSE STADIUM TURF
FIELD A DJ INSTANT REPLAY FOR
MEDIA COVERAGE AND LIVE STREAMED
BY A PROFESSIONAL MEDIA TEAM.
ALL IN A NEUTRAL FAIR SITE. I
WAS SURPRISED WHEN I FOUND THAT
WE'D BE TRAVELING SIX AND A HALF
HOURS ON A BUS TO OUR OPPONENTS
HOME FIELD. A FIELD THAT WAS
WORN WORN OUT WITH BARELY ANY
GRASS IN SO FROM ALL THE RAIN.
WE CALLED AND WERE TOLD THAT THE
VISITOR STANDS CANNOT
ACCOMMODATE. ATA SEATING FROM MY
UNCLE THAT IS IN A WHEELCHAIR.
NOR COULD THE STANDS FIT ALL OF
OUR FANS. SO MY DREAM NIGHT
TURNED INTO ONE OF THE MOST
DISAPPOINTING TIMES OF MY LIFE.
A GAME PLAYED IN THE MIDDLE OF
NOWHERE NEITHER TEAM GETTING TO
PLAY ANYTHING THAT RESEMBLED A
FOOTBALL GAME. IN ANKLE DEEP
MUD. NO SCOUTS CAME OUT TO THE
TINY TOWN TO WATCH THIS AND THE
TERRIBLE UNSAFE CONDITIONS. MY
UNCLE IN THE REST OF OUR FANS.
INSTEAD OF ATTENDING HAD TO
WATCH THIS BODY STREAM OF THE
GAME. THAT KEPT HOUSING. AND
ENOUGH TO DO NOT EVEN KNOW HOW
TO PRONOUNCE OUR TOWN'S NAME. I
RETURNED HOME TO SEE THE
INCREDIBLE DAY MY FRIENDS FROM
LIBERTY HIGH SCHOOL HAD. ON THE
FIELD WERE FIVE OTHER GAME FOR
PLAY. THEY GOT TO DISPLAY ALL
THEIR TALENTS FOR THE WORLD TO
SEE. AND FIRST CLASS STADIUM
THAT COULD SEE THOUSANDS. THE
NEWS NCIS OWN OFFICIAL WEBSITE
PER NEW PROMOTED HOW NICER
FACILITY AND GAME WAS. SO I'M
HERE TO ASK THIS WHY. WE HAVE
ALL PAY THE SAME PRICE BLOOD
SWEAT TEARS. AND TIME WAY FOR
FAMILIES. HI CAN YOU TELL ONE
GROUP OF US THAT WE ARE WORTH
LESS THEIR PEERS FROM FORTY
MILES DOWN THE ROAD. THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS MARA AND
SLOWS AND I'M A FRESHMAN AT
SHAFTER HIGH SCHOOL. FIRST ALLEN
THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR ALLOWING
ME TO SPEAK ON THE TOPIC. THAT
IS REALLY IMPORTANT TO ME. A
YOUNG BOY I'VE PLAYED TRAVEL.
FOOTBALL AND WAS. AND WAS ABLE
TO PLAY MANY NATIONAL
CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES I WAS ABLE TO
PLAY AT. STADIUMS I WILL PLAY AT
THE COWBOYS STADIUM THE NEW
ORLEANS SAINTS PRACTICE
FACILITIES. AND THE LOS ANGELES
RAMS STADIUM. AS A FRESHMAN THE
WEEK GOING TO THE STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME I WAS SUPER
EXCITED. AND WEBER VARSITY
FOOTBALL STATE CHAMPIONSHIP
GAME. I THOUGHT OF A BIG STADIUM
WITH THE NICE FILLED WITH.
HUNDREDS OR EVEN THOUSANDS OF
SELF DEFENSE READY SUPPORT THEIR
TEAM. NOT SENT OUT TO BE AN NFL
STADIUM BUT I EXPECTED TO BE
SOMETHING PRETTY NICE. WHEN WE
GOT OVER THE HIGH SCHOOL. ON
DECEMBER TENTH TWO THOUSAND
TWENTY TWO. IT WAS THE EXACT
OPPOSITE OF WHAT I EXPECTED. THE
VISITORS STANDS WEREN'T EVEN BIG
ENOUGH TO SELL ALL OF OUR FANS.
BEFORE WE EVEN CAME OUT FOR
WARMUPS THE STANDS WERE FULL
WITH PEOPLE SITTING IN. THE
STANDS THIS OF THE STAIRS. SAN
ALONG TO GET. AND STAYING ON THE
SIDE OF THE STANDS THERE EVEN
PEOPLE WHO BROUGHT THEIR HOMES
M. SIGNED THEIR OWN CHAIRS. THE
FOOD WAS FLOODED WITH PUDDLE
SPREAD OUT ACROSS DIFFERENT
AREAS OF THE FIELD. AS SOON AS
HE TOOK A STEP YOUR FOOT WOULD
SINK AND GET STUCK IN THE MUD.
MOTOR SO BAD I COULDN'T MOVE HOW
I WANTED TO I FELT LIMITED. ME
BEING A RECEIVER CATCHING THE
BALL IS A BIG PART OF MY JOB. I
COULDN'T CATCH THE BALL BECAUSE
IT WAS SO SLICK AND MUDDY. ON
DEFENSE I WAS HAVING A HARD TIME
SWITCHING DIRECTIONS AND MAKING
TACKLES BECAUSE EVERY TIME I
MAKE IMPACT WITH SOMEONE. MY FEE
WAS SLIDE OUT FROM UNDER ME. THE
MOD ALSO WAS AFFECTING THE WAY I
MOVED AND CAUGHT. IT WAS ALSO.
IN GETTING INTO MY EYES
AFFECTING MY VISION TOWARDS THE
END OF THE GAME I WAS SQUINTING
BECAUSE OF HOW BADLY BURNED.
NORMALLY A GAME. I'D BE HOT BUT
DURING THIS GAME. IT WAS VERY
COLD. AND THE WATER MIGHT GET
INTO MY JERSEY PANTS AND SHOES.
MADE MY BODY FEEL EVEN MORE
COLD. AND JUST MADE MY MUSCLES
FEEL TIGHT. HOUSE X. SORRY.
ABOUT MAKING IT TO THE CIF STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME. BUT IT WAS
NOT WHAT I DREAMED A STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP WILL ALSO LOOK
LIKE. IF I COULDN'T PERFORM AT
MY BEST IN THOSE CONDITIONS I
KNOW THAT MY TEAMMATES AND
ORLEANS PLAYERS WERE NOT. ABLE
TO PLAY AT THEIR BEST EITHER. IT
WOULD BE NICE TO GET THIS FIXED
BECAUSE IT'S NOT ONLY IMPORTANT
TO ME BUT THE NEW INCOMING HIGH
SCHOOL FOOTBALL PLAYERS. IF THEY
MAKE IT TO A STATE CHAMPIONSHIP
GAME I DON'T WANT THEM TO HAVE
THE SAME EXPERIENCE I DID. I
WOULD LIKE THEM TO PLAY A BIG
STADIUM. WITH ALL THEIR FANS
WATCHING CHEERING THEM ON. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU TO
BOTH THE WOULD IS THERE ANYBODY
ELSE. HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM
WAS TESTIFYING BEHALF. OF THE
BILL. HELLO MY NAME IS- JOURNAL
PREACH ON THAT FOOTBALL COACH
AFTER HIGH SCHOOL- YOU KNOW I'M
I'M- OBVIOUSLY IN SUPPORT.
TWELVE I TOOK A TEAM TO A STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME AND IT WAS
THAT SO FIVE STADIUM. SO I KNOW
THE EXPERIENCE THAT THE BIG
SCHOOLS GET TO HAVE I GOT TO
WITNESS IT MYSELF. YOU KNOW
FROM. A FROM THE LOCKER ROOM
THAT YOU GET. TO BE IN ON THE
FIELD IN THE TV TIME OUTS AND
THE WHOLE EXPERIENCE OF BEING IN
A IN A COLLEGE STADIUM TO. WHAT
WE HAD TO EXPERIENCE WAS A SMALL
GIRLS LOCKER ROOM WITH TWO
TOILETS AND NO HOT WATER- IT WAS
FRUSTRATING TO KNOW THAT. MY
KIDS HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO PLAY
AT THE HIGHEST LEVEL THAT A HIGH
SCHOOL ATHLETE CAN PLAY IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND THERE
WAS NOTHING SPECIAL ABOUT IT AT
ALL. AND SO- IF ANYTHING- THIS
BILL GETS THE BALL ROLLING IN
THE RIGHT DIRECTION THAT ALL
KIDS THEY MAY ARE LUCKY ENOUGH.
TO PLAY IN A IN A IN A PROGRAM
THAT GETS TO THE STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAME ARE GIVEN THE
SAME EXPERIENCE NO MATTER WHAT
SIZE SCHOOLS THEY GO TO THANK
YOU THANK YOU INSPIRATION.
ASSEMBLY ALSO LIKE JUST TRYING
TO HAVE THE BILL SO PLEASE COME
FORWARD. AS ANYBODY HERE LIKE
TESTIFIED IN OPPOSITION. TO THIS
LEGISLATION- OKAY LET LET'S GO
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE IS
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD. Q. AND
A- PARTICIPANTS SHOULD LIKE
TOUCH. ON EITHER- FOR THE BILL
OR ON YOU KNOW CAN OPPOSITION-
WITH THEIR NAME THEIR
ORGANIZATION A POSITION PLEASE.
THANK YOU TO PLEASE PRESS. ONE
ZERO AT THIS TIME SO. AGAIN IT'S
. ONE ZERO. CURRENTLY NOBODY IN
Q. OKAY LET LET'S BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE COMMISSIONER
GLAZER PLACE. YEAH THANKS
SENATOR- THANKS SHARE NEWMAN I
WANT TO THANK- SENATOR TODD- FOR
BRING IN THIS ISSUE. FORWARD I
LOVE YOUR PASSION- AND I KNOW-
IT IT'S CONSISTENT WITH YOUR
GREAT LEADERSHIP IN THE VALLEY
AND SO MANY THINGS. I WANT TO
COMMEND THE STUDENT ATHLETES
HAVE COME TO SPEAK TO US TODAY
YOU GUYS DID GREAT- CERTAINLY-
AN EASY TOUCHDOWN HERE WITH ME
ON THE COMMITTEES THANK YOU FOR.
FOR TAKING THE TIME AS WELL AS
THE COACH TO COME UP HERE AND
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS. IN SOME
WAYS- THIS GOES COUNTER TO MY
OWN PHILOSOPHY ABOUT WHAT WE DO
HERE AND GOVERNMENT WHICH IS TO
TRY TO MAKE THESE DECISIONS AT
THE LOCAL LEVEL- TRY TO HAVE
RESPONSIBLE ENTITIES. DO
RESPONSIBLE THINGS WE DON'T HAVE
TO STEP IN AND- AND BIG PUT
ISSUES LIKE THIS- BUT I RESPECT
THE AUTHOR KNOWS THAT SHE WILL
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THAT THE
CIF IS THIS BILL GOES FORWARD
HOPE IT DOES GO FORWARD- AND
HOPE THAT THAT WE CAN RESOLVE IT
MAY BE WITHOUT A STATE LAW BUT
WITH APPROPRIATE ACTIONS THAT
THEY MIGHT TAKE- IN AT
THOUGHTFUL CONSIDERATION OF THE
CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED.
WITH THAT I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE
BILL AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME AND
I APPRECIATE THAT SPENT. NEARLY
MEMBERS KNOW CHILE I CAN AYE I
SURE SENATE. TURNED KNOW BASED.
THE QUESTION A DECISION. LESS
AND I SEE MR JERRY FROM C. IF
YOU YOU WOULD MY- A CAN CAN YOU
SPEAK TO THAT I MEAN OBVIOUSLY
THAT WAS A SUB. SITUATION IN THE
GAME OR. GAMES TO WHICH- OUR
WOULDN'T REFERRED SO HOW DOES
THIS YEAR I THINK THAT THIS
MOVIE FORWARD- AND WHAT'S WERE
RESPONSE. LET THE NEED HERE.
WELL OBVIOUSLY WE ALWAYS WANT TO
HANDLE OUR ISSUES WITHIN THE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE WE HAVE
ONE THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED NINE
MEMBER SCHOOLS. WHO PUT THE
CURRENT STRUCTURE IN PLACE WITH
A VOTE- WE USED TO HAVE FIVE
STATE GAMES WE EXPANDED TO NOW
WHAT IS. FIFTEEN STATE GAMES
KNOWING THAT. THEY'LL COULD BE
AT THE SAME SITE. GIVEN THAT
THEY PASSED THAT- WE WANT TO
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH OUR
MEMBERSHIP. JUST BECAUSE
SOMETHING'S IN PLACE CURRENTLY
DOESN'T MEAN THAT THAT'S WHAT
HAS TO STAY IN PLACE
PERMANENTLY. AND SO WE ARE
COMMITTED TO CONTINUING TO WORK
WITH OUR OFFICE BUT CENTERS
OFFICE AND- LOOKING AT WAYS WE
CAN BE AT. NEUTRAL SITES FOR ALL
THE GAMES. IT DOES MEAN THAT
WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO FIND
PROBABLY SEVERAL THOUSAND
DOLLARS SOMEWHERE TO DO THIS
BECAUSE THERE IS. GREATER
EXPENSES. WE LOSE THIS YEAR AT
OUR FIVE MAIN ST GAMES. WE LOST
NINETY THOUSAND DOLLARS. SO IT'S
NOT WE'RE NOT MAKING A LOT OF
REVENUE WITH THE SPORT OF
FOOTBALL WATER STATE
CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES. BECAUSE OF
THE EXPENSES TO TRAVEL THE
TEAMS- TO THOSE GAMES- SO WE'VE
MET CURRENTLY WITH OUR FOOTBALL
ADVISORY COMMITTEE. R. TEN
SECTION COMMISSIONERS. ARE
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE. AND WILL BE
MEETING WITH OUR FEDERATED
COUNCIL ABOUT HOW WE CAN IMPROVE
THIS GOING FORWARD SO THAT. WE
DON'T HEAR EXPERIENCES LIKE THIS
BECAUSE- I CAN UNDERSTAND
ATHLETES THEY CAME AND SPOKE ARE
FEDERATED COUNSEL'S WELL. AND
DID A GREAT JOB THERE TO. ANSWER
IF YOU COULD STAY THERE FOR A
MOMENT SAY SENATOR. PER TITLE
YOU KNOW THAT THE BILL ACTUALLY
TO MY KNOWLEDGE SKILLS EXPERTISE
EXCLUSIVELY WITH FOOTBALL- AND
NOT OTHER SPORTS IS THAT CORRECT
THAT'S CORRECT. AND IT SHOWED TO
MR CHERRY IT SHOWED YET IF AT
SOME LARGER EXPENSE YOU HAVE DO
YOU DO TRY TO ACCOMMODATE THIS
LEGISLATION. WE HAD INFORMATION
HEARING EARLY IN THE YEAR BUT
I'M SPECIFIC ABOUT TITLE NINE
ARE THERE IMPLICATIONS. FOR
TITLE NINE IF YOU HAVE TO FIND
MONEY FOR. FOOTBALL AT I ASSUME.
NO NO YOU'RE SURE YOU KNOW THERE
SHOULD BE BECAUSE RIGHT NOW ALL
OVER THE STATE CHAMPIONSHIP MOST
OF OUR REGIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP
EVENTS ARE PLAYED AT HOME SITES
FOR BOTH BOYS AND GIRLS SPORTS.
OUR STATE CHAMPIONSHIP GAMES ARE
PLAYED AT NEUTRAL SITES THE ONLY
REASON FOOTBALL IS TREATED
DIFFERENTLY. IS OUR OTHER SPORTS
HAVE EITHER FIVE OR SIX
DIVISIONS- TOTAL FOOTBALL HAS
FIFTY. SO THAT'S WHY FOOTBALL IS
TREATED DIFFERENTLY THAN OTHER
SPORTS NOT BEING PLAYED A
NEUTRAL SITE FOR THE
CHAMPIONSHIPS. APPRECIATE. THEIR
INPUT MEMBERS. I WANT TO ASK-
CENTER GLAZER COMMON I TYPICALLY
ON THIS TYPE STUFF I'D I'D I
DIFFER. BUT I WATCH FRIDAY NIGHT
LIGHTS. NO I'M SICK OF. I'VE
BEEN SO INSPIRED. NO NO NO
SERIOUSLY IN IT AND I AND I
UNDERSTAND I UNDERSTAND THOSE.
THOSE YOUNG PEOPLE'S CONCERNS. I
KNOW FOR ME DURING- DURING KOBE
WHEN FOOTBALL SHUT DOWN I
REMEMBER- HAVING A- ZOOM CALL
WITH THE ENTIRE FOOTBALL TEAM.
AND THERE IS YOU KNOW YOUNG MEN
ON THEIR CRYING BECAUSE HE SAID
WE KNOW WE'RE NOT ALLOWED TO
PLAY FOOTBALL. WE THINK WE'RE
GOOD ENOUGH TO GET A COLLEGE
SCHOLARSHIP YOU KNOW WHAT'S
GOING TO KNOW BECAUSE OF THE
FACT THAT WE'RE NOT PLAYING IN
AND THE SAME THING WITH THESE
YOUNG PEOPLE SO. I'M GONNA
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY. AND WITH
THE HOPES THAT WE CAN GET ALL
ALL ALL THE IN. GET GET ALL THIS
WORKED OUT BECAUSE I WAS
INCLINED TO BE A NO GOING IN BUT
I WAS REALLY MOVED BY THEIR
TESTIMONY AND- AND- SO. I'M
HOPING WE CAN GET THAT AND I
WANT TO COMMEND THE C. A. C. I.
F. FOR EXPANDING THE OPPORTUNITY
FOR YOUNG MEN TO PLAY AS WELL
RIGHT BECAUSE YOU WENT FROM FIVE
TO FIFTEEN. SO WE SHOULD
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT AS WELL. WHEN
WE MOVE FORWARD ANYWAY NOW I
BOARD OF TODAY DO APPRECIATE AND
EDUCATION AGREES YOU MADE THE
MOTION SIR. SENATOR WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE. COLLEAGUES
THERE'S ASK FOR KNIVES. NAB OKAY
. MA'AM SERGEI PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. SB EIGHTY SIX FOR. MOTION
IS TO PASS NEW. NINE NEWMAN I'D
GO TO A BOWL AYE. PHOTOBOOK I.
GLAZER HI GLAZER AYE MCGUIRE.
SMALLWOOD WHERE. WILL HI. WILL
DIE. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU
SENATOR. IT THAT. US TO OUR NEXT
. FILL IN THAT IS AS BETWEEN.
SENATOR DO. THANK YOU FOR YOUR.
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS THANK YOU
FOR. ALLOWING ME TO- THIS THIS
IS WHAT. AT PRESENT. SB TWENTY
EIGHT WANT TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE STAFF YOUR DILIGENT
WORK. I THINK YOU NEED TO MOVE
THE MONEY JUST LOOK IT UP TO
YOU. NOT YET. THERE WE GO YEAH
THE BETTER. YES OKAY. SO I
REPEAT THANKS FOR A HEARD IT ON
A WE LET WE LET IT WOULD.
BELIEVED SHOULD GET THAT AGAIN.
YOU DON'T HAVE TO GO. SO AT THIS
OUT THE FIFTEEN FIVE. BILLION
BOND FOR THE TWENTY TWO FOUR
ABOUT. FOR HIS SAID THE INCLUDE
K. THREE TWO THROUGH IT
SPECIFICALLY NINE AND A HALF
BILLION FOR PRESCHOOL THROUGH
GRADE TWELVE. AND TWO BILLION
DOLLARS EACH FOR THE COMMUNITY
COLLEGES THE CSU AND UC- THE
LAST K. THROUGH TWELVE AND
HIGHER EDUCATION BONDS PASSED IN
TWO THOUSAND SIX- HOWEVER BY TWO
THOUSAND TWELVE ALL THOSE FUNDS
WERE ESSENTIALLY EXHAUSTED. AT
THIS BOND IS IT REALLY
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT BRING ALL
OF OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS INTO THE
TWENTY FIRST CENTURY. AND IT'S
YOUR STUDENTS HAVE A SAFE PLACE
TO LEARN. ACCORDING TO THE
PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE TWO
THIRDS OF THE STATE SCHOOL
FACILITIES FOR MORE THAN TWENTY
FIVE YEARS OLD. I RESEARCH SHOWS
THAT IT WOULD COST OVER A
HUNDRED AND SEVENTEEN BILLION
DOLLARS TO MODERNIZE THE SCHOOLS
AND COLLEGES IN THE NEXT DECADE.
YEAH WE DID HAVE A MEASURE
SIMILAR TO THIS ON THE MARCH
TWENTY TWENTY BALLOT THEY CAME
UP JUST SHORT. BUT IF YOU LOOK
AT THE RESULTS IN THIS LAST
ELECTION NOVEMBER TWENTY TWO.
VOTERS APPROVED 71% OF THE
HUNDRED AND ONE LOCAL SCHOOL
BOND MEASURES THAT WERE ON THE
BALLOT. SO THE BILL BEFORE YOU
IS AN EXTENSION OF THAT
COMPROMISE. THAT OCCURRED IN
THAT TWENTY TWENTY ELECTION.
THERE ARE STILL MANY
CONVERSATIONS AND DISCUSSION TO
HAVE WITH LEADERSHIP- WITH THE
GOVERNOR. TO FASHION THIS
MEASURE IN A WAY THAT WORKS FOR
ALL THE STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVED SO
IT'S A STARTING POINT. FOR THE
DISCUSSIONS THAT WILL OCCUR OVER
THE NEXT YEAR IF THE BILL MOVES
FORWARD- I KNOW WE NEED TO DO
BETTER FOR OUR STUDENTS
FACILITIES ARE IMPORTANT PART OF
FIVE. OF PROPER LEARNING
ENVIRONMENT THAT I RESPECTFULLY
ASTRONAUT VOTE. I DO HAVE TO OF
FOLKS HERE TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT. JASON MURPHY FROM
UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA. HANASI
TENDER VALHI FROM THE EARTH
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY.
THANK YOU MISTER MURPHY WELCOME
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS JASON MURPHY ON
BEHALF UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA
HERE IN STRONG SUPPORT TODAY. I
THANK THE SENATOR FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP ON THIS IMPORTANT
TOPIC AND BEING WILLING TO BRING
THIS ISSUE BACK AGAIN. AFTER THE
OTHER ORDER. COME IN TWENTY
TWENTY. THE AT THE UNIVERSITY
CALIFORNIA OVER 50% OF OUR
FACILITIES ARE OVER THIRTY YEARS
OLD. ARC MOST CURRENT- CAPITAL
FINANCIAL PLAN. IDENTIFIES OVER
THIRTY THREE BILLION DOLLARS IN
STATE SUPPORTED THANKS. NEED AN
EDUCATIONAL SPACE AND THOUGH WE
FEEL THAT THIS BOND WE KNOW IT'S
NOT GONNA SOLVE A WHOLE FOR
ISSUES OF COURSE. BUT REALLY-
HOPEFULLY WE GET OUR STATE BACK
ON TRACK WITH THE REGULAR-
EFFORT. WITH BONDS OF ALREADY
BASIS AGAIN STRONG SUPPORTS THEY
THINK CENTER AND THANKS FOR THE
CONVERSATION TODAY AND THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. WELCOME GOOD
MORNING MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS TO
TENDER MOLLY HERE WHAT THE CSU
CHANCELLOR'S OFFICE IT'S A
PLEASURE TO BE HERE. I JOIN WITH
ARE YOU SEE COLLEAGUES IN
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE- AS WAS
STATED EARLIER SB TWENTY EIGHT
WILL HELP FINANCE CRITICAL.
CAPITAL RENEWAL PROJECTS AT BOTH
THE CSU AND THE UC ALONG WITH
OUR CATER FOURTEEN EDUCATIONAL
FACILITIES. ARE THESE RESOURCES
WOULD ENABLE THE CSU TO BEGIN TO
ADDRESS THE CONSTRUCTION
RENOVATION AND RENEWAL OF
FACILITIES THROUGHOUT OUR TWENTY
THREE CAMPUS SYSTEM. AS OUTLINED
IN OUR FIVE YEAR CAPITAL OUTLAY
PLAN- MISTER CHAIR AS YOU WE
WILL NOW CALIFORNIA IS FACING
THE CHALLENGE OF AN AGING
INFRASTRUCTURE IN DIRE NEED OF
RENOVATION AND REPLACEMENT AND
ARE OVER A THOUSAND PLUS SCHOOL
DISTRICTS COMMUNITY COLLEGES.
AND YES ARE YOU SEASON CSU. AT
THE CSU SPECIFICALLY MORE THAN
HALF OF OUR FACILITY SPACES
FORTY YEARS OR OLDER. AND A
THIRD BEING OVER FIFTY YEARS
OLD. OUR FIVE YEAR CAPITAL
OUTLAY PLAN REFLECTS MORE THAN
TWENTY SIX ARE NEARLY TWENTY
SEVEN BILLION DOLLARS IN
ACADEMIC AND SELF SUPPORT
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS. AND
SEVEN POINT EIGHT BILLION IN
CRITICAL FACILITY RENEWAL NEEDS.
AND AS WAS RECENTLY NOTED BY THE
L. A. GO OUR BACKLOG FOR
ACADEMIC FACILITIES AND
INFRASTRUCTURE GREW BY TWO POINT
FOUR BILLION OR 60% JUST OVER
THE BAR. PAST FIVE YEARS ALONE.
SO AGAIN AS WE TWENTY EIGHT
PROVIDES CRITICAL FUNDING FOR
CAMPUSES TO EXPAND STUDENT
CAPACITY IN OUR CLASSROOMS AND
LABS. ADDRESSES CRITICAL FIRES
AND SAFETY AND SEISMIC
DEFICIENCIES. AND IT'S FOR THESE
REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR I. BOATS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH AND THANK YOU MISTER
MILLER. ANYBODY ELSE HERE. AND
MAYBE LIKE TO STRIKE AND SERVE.
OF THE MEASURE. THANK YOU CHAIR
- JEFF BARKER. THE RIVERSIDE
COUNTY SO. SCHOOLS ON THE- THREE
SCHOOL DISTRICTS SUPERINTENDENTS
RIVERSIDE COUNTY. IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL. FAMOUS ROCKER- THE
SURVEY HERE INTEGRIEREN LIKE
DESPITE OPPOSITION THE MEASURE.
OF SEEING NINE MISMATCHED
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE.
HOLD THE TELECONFERENCE LINE FOR
ANYBODY ON THE LINE YOU'D LIKE
TO TRY EITHER IN SUPPORT OF OR
OR IN OPPOSITION TO. THIS
MEASURE. THANK YOU AND IF SO
PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO AT THIS
TIME AGAIN AT. ONE ZERO. GIVE ME
JUST A MOMENT HERE. THANK YOU.
AND WE GO FIRST TO LINE NUMBER
EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
MORNING. MEMBER SHIRLEY DOWN
THEY HAVE TO CALIFORNIA TO WORK
EFFICIENTLY DON'T CURRENTLY HAVE
A COMMISSION ON THE SALE- ARE
NEEDING RAIN DIFFICULT BUT- OUT
OF QUEUE WITH. THE HEARING DATE
BUT WE PLAN TO TAKE SUPPORT-
SIMILAR TO MY WE TOOK LAST. I'M
HIM ABOUT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
NEXT WHICH AND THAT THANK YOU
FOR NUMBER. THE MORE THANK
FUTURE MEMBERS NAME FOR THE KING
TABOO HELLO. WE'RE HERE TO STAY
OUR REPORT TO MANDATE YOU SHOULD
A LETTER WE THE OFFICE THE
FOCUSING THE MAIN. HERE EQUITY
IN THE BILL THANK YOU. THANK YOU
AND. AT NO FURTHER COMMENT IN.
NO THAT LED TO A BEFORE I BRING
TO THE COMMITTEE I'M NEARLY END
OF THE AT A ANY MEMBERS WHO ARE
NOT. WHO HAVE VOTES TO OF THE
RETURN THE COMMITTEE HERE
HEARING OR- EVENT MAY WANT TO
THIS. SEEING THE- SAME CENTER
PLEASE. AS PART OF THIS LAST
TIME I IN TO SERVE IT AGAIN AS
MEMBER OF THE STATE OUT BOARD I
CAN'T WE WE'RE OF MY- AND THE
NEED IS- THIS THIS COURSE IS
KIND OF A- ON. A ISSUE. BUT I
KNOW YOU'RE YOUR CHAIR OF DELAY
CAN AND I THINK ONE OF THE WHY
WE FELL A LITTLE SHORT WAS THE
NUMBERING OF THE BILL. HAVE YOU
AND YOUR COMMITTEE TAKE A LOOK
AT MAY BE A LIMITING IN THE
FUTURE CERTAIN. PROPOSITION
NUMBERS JUST BECAUSE THEY KIND
OF TAPE SOMETHING ONE WAY OR
ANOTHER. TO THE TO THE CHAIR
THANK YOU SENATOR WELCOME IS NOT
BEEN AN ISSUE THAT WE HAVE
DISCUSSED- UP UNTIL NOW I
CERTAINLY I SHARE THAT CONCERN
THAT YOU ARE. INTIMATING ABOUT-
HOW A NUMBER THAT HAS BEEN SO
INGRAINED IN PEOPLE'S HEADS- CAN
CAN BIAS AND OBJECTIVE LOOK AT
IT AT A NEW MEASURE WHICH SEPT
HAPPENS TO HAVE THAT NUMBER. AND
HAPPY TO HAVE CONVERSATION WITH
YOU AND OTHERS ABOUT WHETHER OR
NOT THAT SHOULD BE SOMETHING WE
SHOULD CONSIDER GOING FORWARD.
AND I WILL SAVE BUT I THAT FOR
THE NUMBER WE WILL NOT NAME HERE
IN THE COMING MONTHS- SO THAT
CENTER JOB. THANK YOU S. SENATE
AT. THEREFORE THE OPPORTUNITY. I
HAVE A QUESTION WITH REGARD TO-
I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY. THAT
THIS BILL- IT'S SO THAT WE COULD
VOTE. PUT IT ON THE BALLOT FOR
THE VOTERS TO PASS ON THERE.
WOULD YOU DO HAVE A RECORD. DEAL
LET ME CONFIRM. DO YOU HAVE A
REQUIREMENT HERE AT THAT THE-
BILL PRIOR TO. PRIORITIZES
MODERNIZATION OF PROJECTS TO
DISTRICTS THAT REQUIRE. PLAAF
GRIEVANCE. WHICH THERE ARE A
NUMBER OF PROVISIONS I CAN'T
SPEAK SPECIFICALLY TO THAT THERE
A NUMBER OF PROVISIONS. THAT YOU
MIGHT SEE IN THE BILL TODAY THAT
ARE SIMPLY PLACE HOLDERS. IT
JUST RIGHT REPLICATES WHAT WAS
IN BEFORE. BECAUSE THIS IS GOING
TO BE SUBJECT TO NEGOTIATION
WITH ALL THE VARIOUS
STAKEHOLDERS. I THOUGHT THAT THE
BEST WAY TO. BEGIN THE
CONVERSATION WAS DID NOT. MAKE
ANY CHANGES JUST. MAKE IT A COME
FROM COME TO YOU IN THE SAME
FORMAT WHICH IT'D BEEN PASSED
PREVIOUSLY AND HAVE EVERYTHING
IS EVERYTHING IS OPEN EVERYTHING
IS AN OPEN CONVERSATION
INCLUDING THE ISSUE THAT YOU
RAISED. OKAY THE REASON I ASK IS
JUST YESTERDAY WE HAD A
CONVERSATION WITH REGARDS TO.
OTHER HOUSING BILLS AND THE
CONCERN IS THAT- WERE BROUGHT UP
WORD THE LIMITED AMOUNT OF.
PEOPLE WHO CAN ACTUALLY WORK ON
THESE PROJECTS I CAN ELIMINATING
THE ABILITY FOR MANY OTHER-
ORGANIZATIONS TO BE ABLE TO WORK
SO. AND. I'M GONNA SUPPORT THE
BILL TODAY. BUT I AM GOING TO BE
WATCHING A RESERVE RIGHT.
ABSTAIN OR- NOT SUPPORT THE
BILL- IN THE LATER FINANCES SO I
HOPE THAT THAT CAN OPEN THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR ALL OF
CALIFORNIA'S YOU HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO WORKING IN OUR
STATE. AND ACTUALLY HAVE THESE
PROJECTS- BE BUILT IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA THANK YOU. ANY
OTHER MEMBERS WANTED. SPEAK TO
THIS. GREAT ALL RIGHT SO WE DO
HAVE A MOTION FOR SB TWENTY
EIGHT. FROM CENTER WEALTH CENTER
GLAZER I'M SORRY WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE AT REFLECTIVE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I THOSE
WHO SHOULD AMENDED MADAM SECTOR
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SB TWENTY
EIGHT GLAZER MOTION IS TO PASS
THE FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE. NEWMAN AYE NEWMAN AYE
OR TROUBLE HI WHICH- BROKE I
CORTESE. AYE CORTESE AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE IT MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE
AYE SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS I WILL. HI WILL
DIE. AND THE BILL IS OUT SEVEN
ZERO FIVE MA'AM SIR IF YOU COULD
PLEASE REOPEN THE ROLE- AND
LET'S GO THROUGH THE VOTES THAT
MEMBERS MIGHT HAVE MISSED. JUST
GO WITH. I BELIEVE VIA OKAY IN
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA WE'RE GONNA
OPEN THE ROLE AND CLOSE. OUT
THOSE REMAINING VOTES OKAY ON
THE CONSENT ITEMS CORTESE.
CORTESE EYEING. MCGUIRE I
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS I SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS. SEVEN ZERO THAT'S THAT'S
ZERO. ON THE COMMITTEE RULES
CORTESE. FOUR DAYS THE- MCGUIRE
. HI ON THE CREW POLICY ARE THE
SETS OF ZERO TWO. PLEASE
CONSIDER ON THE CREEK POLICY.
WHAT IS THE HI MCGUIRE. WHERE I
. AND I THINK THAT THOSE THAT'S
. ONE FILE ITEM TO SB NINETY
PORTANTINO MOTION IS TO PASS THE
FIRST YEAR WE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
BROUGH IS FIVE TWO ONE WITH THE
CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR VOTING NINE
CORTESE. CORTESE I WILK I'M
SURE. WE'LL START WITH YOU KNOW
THAT THAT DOESN'T SIXTY ONE OKAY
. FILE ITEM THREE SB TWO THIRTY
FOUR PORTANTINO MOTION IS TO
PASS A FRISBEE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON HEALTH CURRENT VOTE
IS FIVE TWO ZERO. WITH THE CHAIR
ADVICE TURBO DENIED CORTESE
CORTESE I'D SMALLWOOD CUEVAS BY
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI THE BILL IS
BILL IS AT SEVEN ZERO. FILE ITEM
FOR SB FOUR FOUR FIVE PORTANTINO
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED THE
FIRST AMENDED AND WE REFERRED TO
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
CURRENT VOTE IS FORTY ZERO WITH
THE CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR VOTING
NINE. CORTESE CORTESE AYE
MCGUIRE AYE MCGUIRE AYE
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI MY WITH
MEMBERS I IN THE BILL IS AT
SEVEN ZERO. FILE ITEM FIVE SB
FOUR SIXTY SEVEN PORTANTINO
MOTION IS TO PASS CURRENT VOTE
IS FOUR ZERO WITH THE CHAIR AND
VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE CORTESE
AYE CORTESE I'M MCGUIRE. SORRY
MCGUIRE AYE SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI
MY WITH PLYMOUTH HI THE BILL IS
AT. SEVEN ZERO. FILE ITEM SEVEN
SB FOUR NINE NINE. MANAGEABLE
OUR MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
THE FIRST AMENDED AND WE
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
HUMAN SERVICES CRUMBLE IS FORTY
ZERO WITH THE- CHAIR AND VICE
CHAIR VOTING HI CORTESE. CORTESE
I'D MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI MY WOULD
QUIT WITH HI. THE VILLAGE AT
SEVEN ZERO. ON FILE ITEM NINE SB
FORTY SIX BY HER TADO MOTION IS
TO PASS CURRENT VOTE IS FOUR TWO
ZERO WITH THE CHAIR AND VICE
CHAIR VOTING HI CORTESE. CORTESE
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MCGUIRE AYE MORE
WITH CLEVERNESS HI MY WOULD
QUIBBLE HI THE BILL IS AT. SEVEN
ZERO. VERY VERY SCARED ALL RIGHT
SO THAT THAT CLOSER ROLE THANK
YOU. TO ALL THE INDIVIDUALS WHO
PROTESTED PUMP JUST NINETY THANK
YOU ESPECIALLY TO- COMMITTEE
STAFF- INTO THE MODERATOR WE
HAVE NOW CONCLUDED TODAY'S
AGENDA. THE SENATE EDUCATION
COMMITTEE IS NO INSURANCE THANKS
.
WE'RE SORRY YOUR CONFERENCE IS
ENDING NOW PLEASE HANG UP.