THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC
SAFETY WILL COME TO ORDER- GOOD
MORNING THE SENATE CONTINUES TO
WELCOME THE PUBLIC IN PERSON AND
VIA TELECOM TELECONFERENCE
SERVICE FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING
TO PROVIDE PUBLIC SAFETY
COMMENTS TODAY PARTICIPANT
NUMBER IS. 877-226-8163 AND THE
ACCESS CODE IS. SIX NINE FOUR
EIGHT NINE THREE ZERO WE ARE
HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS
HERE IN THE- STREET BUILDING I
ASK ALL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
TO BE PRESENT IN ROOM. NUMBER
TWENTY TWO HUNDRED SO WE CAN
ESTABLISH REQUIREMENT BEGIN OUR
HEARING. WE HAVE FIVE BILLS ON
TODAY'S AGENDA ONE ITEMS ON
CONSENT SB NINETEEN WAS PULLED
FROM CONSENT BEFORE WE HEAR
PRESENTATIONS ON THE BILL'S
LET'S ESTABLISH QUORUM WE ARE
WAITING FOR QUORUM AND AN
OFFICER.
DO YOU THINK WITH. SO WE WILL
START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE SENATOR
ROTH ARE YOU READY TO PRESENT.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
AND PRESENTING SENATE BILL FORTY
SIX AS YOU KNOW DRUG OVERDOSES
ARE ON THE RISE IN CALIFORNIA
ACCORDING TO THE NATIONAL CENTER
FOR DRUG ABUSE STATISTICS
CALIFORNIA EXPERIENCED AN ANNUAL
RATE INCREASE OF TEN POINT 37%
IN OVERDOSE DEATHS OVER THE LAST
THREE YEARS NOW MORE THAN EVER
THE STATE MUST ADOPT POLICIES
NECESSARY TO SUPPORT THE
REHABILITATION OF THOSE
SUFFERING FROM THIS EPIDEMIC
THIS BILL DOES JUST THAT THE
BILL REQUIRES A PERSON CONVICTED
OF A DRUG OFFENSE AND HE WAS
GRANTED PROBATION TO
SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETE A
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE EDUCATION
OR TREATMENT PROGRAM. THE BILL
ALSO OUTLINES STANDARDS FOR
THOSE FOR THESE PROGRAMS AND
REQUIRES EDUCATION AND TREATMENT
FOR DRUG DIVERSION TO INCLUDE
INFORMATION ON THE EFFECTS OF
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES ON THE
BRAIN AND BODY HOW TO RECOGNIZE
AND RESPOND TO THE SIGNS OF A
DRUG OVERDOSE AND THE DANGERS OF
USING CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES
WE'RE FACING A MAJOR OVERDOSE
EPIDEMIC AND MORE NEEDS TO BE
DONE TO ENSURE PROPER TREATMENT
AND EDUCATION. FOR INDIVIDUALS
BATTLING SUBSTANCE ABUSE
DISORDERS I WON'T REPEAT THE
STATISTICS YOU KNOW THEM AND
THEY'RE IN THE ANALYSIS WITHOUT
BETTER WITH WITH WHILE CURRENT
LAW REQUIRES PROBATIONERS AND
DIVERSITIES TO COMPLETE
EDUCATION AND TREATMENT
PROGRAMS. THE DEFINITION AND
SCOPE OF THESE PROGRAMS ARE
VAGUE AND UNDEFINED IN EXISTING
STATUTE. THE AMBIGUITY IN THE
LAW LEAVES MANY PROBATIONERS AND
DIVERT T. IS WITHOUT MUCH HELP
DUE TO A LACK OF EDUCATION AND
TREATMENT OPTIONS. ADDITIONALLY
THE LAW DOES NOT REQUIRE THE
COURTS TO RECOMMEND SIMILAR
SUBSTANCE ABUSE EDUCATION
PROGRAMS TO INMATES WHO WERE
INCARCERATED FOR RELATED
OFFENSES. YOUR FOR SERIOUS ABOUT
THE COMMITMENT TO CORRECT AND
REHABILITATE. SPECIFIC
INTENTIONAL EDUCATION AND
TREATMENT MUST BE REQUIRED TO
REDUCE RECIDIVISM AND ENSURE
LONG TERM SUCCESS. THIS BILL IS
A CRUCIAL STEP FORWARD IF WE
WISH TO MEET TO MEET THOSE
OBJECTIVES AND SAVE LIVES. I
ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS PROPOSED
BY THE COMMITTEE. AND THE DRUG
POLICY ALLIANCE WITH RESPECT TO
THE AMENDMENTS OF THE PACIFIC
JUVENILE DEFENDER CENTER THOSE
PROPOSED BY THE CENTER.
SPECIFICALLY TO DELETE THE
REFERENCES TO MINOR OFFENSES IN
PARAGRAPHS ONE A. B. AND ONE
EIGHT EIGHT EXCUSE ME A. ONE B.
AND A. ONE C. I ACCEPT THAT
AMENDMENT AS WELL. WITHOUT A
RESPECTFULLY AS FOR AN AYE VOTE
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL OR DEPUTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY ROB HIGH
TERROR OF THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AND
ERIN HILL. DIRECTOR OF HILL
RECOVERY VENTURE. THANK YOU
SENATOR WILL NOW MOVE ON TO LEAD
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT. PLEASE
STATE YOUR NAME AND- INSURE YOUR
MICHAEL'S ON. I EVERY TWO YEARS.
HI MY NAME IS ERIN HOME AND FROM
HER LOCAL AND DRUG TREATMENT
CALIFORNIA. GOOD MORNING MY
NAME'S ROB HI JEREMY DEPUTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY IN RIVERSIDE
CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU MA'AM YOU
CAN START. I AM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS THE MORNING MY NAME IS
ERIN HILL AND I'M THE DIRECTOR.
AT HILL ALCOHOL AND DRUG
TREATMENT INTO MACULA CALIFORNIA
MY REASON FOR BEING HERE TODAY
IN SUPPORT OF SB FORTY SIX. IS
ROOTED IN THE BELIEF IN PEOPLE
PROVIDED THE OPPORTUNITY. TO
CHANGE THEIR LIVES FOR THE
BETTER. THROUGH WORKING IN THE
TREATMENT FIELD FOR OVER
SEVENTEEN YEARS I PERSONALLY
WITNESSED COUNTLESS PEOPLE
WALKING INTO THE DOORS OF OUR
FACILITY. BROKEN ASHAMED SCARED
AND LOST. THEY'VE OFTEN LOST WHO
THEY ARE AND WHO THEY WANT TO BE
IN THE FACE OF THEIR ADDICTION.
FOR QUALITY TREATMENT THAT
INCORPORATES STRONG EDUCATION.
FAMILY INVOLVEMENT. NECROTIC
REPLACEMENT THERAPY IF
APPLICABLE. AND EVIDENCE BASED
PRACTICES OUR OUTCOME STUDIES
HAVE SHOWN TREMENDOUS RESULTS.
IT IS AMAZING SINGLE APPALLED
CAMANCHE AS WE CALL IT IN
TREATMENT. FAMILY SYSTEMS
REBUILT COPING SKILLS DEVELOPS.
AND A LIFE BECOMING POSSIBLE
THAT NEVER SEEM TO REALITY WHEN
THE PERSON WITH ACTIVE
INTERDICTION. THE PROGRAM SB
FORTY SIX HAS SET FORTH FOR
OFFENDERS. PARALLELS THE MODEL
FOR TREATMENT THAT WE AND OTHER
SUBSTANCE ABUSE PROVIDERS
NATIONWIDE HAVE FOUND TO BE
SUCCESSFUL. WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT
ADDICTION AND RECOVERY IS THAT
SOME KIND OF PAIN WHETHER IT BE
EMOTIONAL FINANCIAL.
RELATIONSHIP VOCATIONAL OR LEGAL
. IS GENERALLY WHAT ACTS AS THE
CATALYST TO CREATING THE NEED TO
CHANGE AND GETTING ADDICTS INTO
THE DOORS OF TREATMENT. THIS IS
WHAT WE REFER TO AS THE CARROT
AND THE STICK. THE STICK IS THE
DRIVER OF THE PAIN. AND THE
CARROT IS WHAT TREATMENT SHOULD
PROVIDE. AT THE HOPE EDUCATION
AND TOOLS FOR A BETTER LIFE. TO
KNOW BETTER AND DO BETTER. ONE
OF MY FAVORITE QUOTES IS CHANGE
OCCURS. WHEN THE PAIN OF WHERE
YOU ARE. IS GREATER THAN THE
FEAR OF MOVING FORWARD. SB FORTY
SIX LAYS THE GUIDELINES FOR THIS
CHANGE AND A PLATFORM TO IMPROVE
LIFE. FOR THE ADDICTS THEIR
FAMILIES AND SOCIETY AS A WHOLE
THANK YOU. NEXT WITNESS. GOOD
MORNING AND THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR AS WELL AS- MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE I ALSO WANT TO THANK
SENATOR RON FOR BRINGING THIS
VERY IMPORTANT LEGISLATION
BEFORE YOU HERE TODAY- I AM A
DEPUTY JUST RETURNING. SKEWS ME
IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY CALIFORNIA.
I'M OBVIOUSLY WHAT THE OF THE
THINGS THAT THIS LEGISLATION
SEEKS TO ACCOMPLISH IS TO REMOVE
DISPARITIES THAT MAY EXIST
BETWEEN THOSE WHO ARE ABLE TO
OBTAIN EDUCATION AND THOSE WERE
NOT. BUT ONE OF THE PRIMARY
PURPOSES OF THIS LEGISLATION AND
ONE OF ITS MAIN BENEFITS IS THAT
IT CLEARLY DEFINES WHAT
EDUCATION MEANS- AS WE KNOW THIS
DRUG PANDEMIC PARTICULARLY
OPIOID PANDEMIC HAS HIT EVERYONE
IN PERSONAL WAYS. I MYSELF LOST
A COUSIN TO FENNEL- LAST YEAR.
AS WE KNOW. WITH THAT NO MANY
TIMES ADDICTS ARE TAKING THINGS
THAT THEY DO NOT RECOGNIZE TO BE
FEDERAL FOR EXAMPLE I HAVE SEEN
COUNTLESS EXAMPLES OF
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE SELF
MEDICATING THROUGH XANAX NOT
REALIZING THAT IT CONTAINS
LETHAL DOSES OF FENTANYL. OUT
WITHIN THOSE SUBSTANCES
EDUCATION IS THE BEST MEANS TO
HI INSTRUCT THOSE WHO ARE
STRUGGLING WITH ADDICTION TO BE
ON THE LOOK OUT AND BE CAREFUL
OUT NGUYEN FENNEL- THAT FEDERAL
MAY EXIST. IN ADDITION ANOTHER
PIECE OF THIS LEGISLATION HAS
FIXED OUR OUTDATED THINKING-
THAT IS MORE THAN TWENTY YEARS
OLD TO MAKE SURE THAT WE NO
LONGER REQUIRE THOSE WHO ARE
OVER TO OVERCOME THEIR ADDICTION
BUT RATHER. A THAT THOSE
INDIVIDUALS ARE PROGRESSING IN
THEIR TREATMENT- AND THAT IS ALL
THAT WE CAN ASK FOR ANYONE WHO'S
RECOVERING. FOR ADDICTION WITH
THAT I ASK YOUR AYE VOTE AND I
THINK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
APPEAR BEFORE YOU TODAY. THANK
YOU WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ANY
OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES HERE IN
THE ROOM. SEEING NONE. I'M SORRY
PLEASE- APPROACH THAT MIKE OVER
THERE. STATE YOUR NAME GOOD
MORNING MY NAME IS BRANDON
FERAL. AND THE DESCRIPTION
INCLUDES THE COUNTY I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF- CALIFORNIA
DISCONTINUES ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU ANY OTHER
WITNESSES. SEEING NONE WILL NOW
MOVE ON TO LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE- WILL
ASK FOR ANY LEAD ON YOUR
OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN THE
ROOM. SEEING NONE- THANK YOU WE
WILL NOW MOVE ON TO WITNESSES
WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE PLEASE
STATE ONLY YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION AND POSITION.
MODERATOR IF YOU PLEASE- A
PROMPT INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
. WE WILL BEGIN THANK YOU MA'AM.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR- TO
COMMENT ON THIS ITEM FIRST ONE
ZERO AN OPERATOR WILL PROVIDE
YOU A LINE NUMBER WHEN YOU HEAR
MY NUMBER CALLED STATE YOUR NAME
AND AFFILIATION FOR LEGISLATIVE
RECORD ONCE AGAIN TO COMMENT
PRESS. ONE ZERO AT THIS TIME.
AND WE DO HAVE ONE IN Q. WE'RE
GOING TO LINE NUMBER SIXTEEN
PLEASE GO AHEAD. WHICH THE
MORNING THIS IS MAUREEN THE
CHECK FROM PACIFIC JIM DEFENDER
CENTER AND WE JUST WANT TO THANK
THE AUTHOR AND THE SPONSOR. FOR
TAKING OUR AMENDMENTS AND WITH
THOSE AMENDMENTS WITH THE
SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU MODERATOR
SURE. WE HAVE ONE MORE IN Q. ALL
RIGHT. WINDS I'D PLEASE GOING
TO. I MADE TO BE HEARD WITH THE
NATIONAL. OF POWERFUL CHAPTER WE
SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANK YOU
MODERATOR WE HAVE ANY ELSE ON
THE LINE. WELL SURE WE HAVEN'T
ADDITIONAL RISK IN. THANK YOU. I
THANK YOU TO ALL SUPPORTER AND-
WITNESSES- WILL NOW BRING THE
DISCUSSION BACK TO MEMBERS DO
ANY OF OUR MEMBERS HAVE
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. ONE NO
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS US SENATOR
WHICH LIKE CLOSE JUST
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
MANAGER. WHEN WE GET A QUORUM
WILL ASK FOR MOTION THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY.
WE WILL BE MOVING ON TO SB TWO
FORTY ONE SENATOR MAN YOU HAVE
THE FLOOR. THANK YOU SURE WILL
HELP GOOD MORNING TO YOU AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE I ASK
YOU TO FORTY ONE WILL REQUIRE
FIREARMS DEALERS AND EMPLOYEES
TO COMPLETE REGULAR TRAINING
THAT COVERS FEDERAL AND STATE
LAWS COVERING THE SALE AND
TRANSFER OF FIREARMS AND
AMMUNITION. INCLUDING HOW TO
RECOGNIZE INDICATORS THAT AN
INDIVIDUAL INTENDS TO USE A
FIREARM FOR FRAUDULENT ACTIVITY
UNLAWFUL PURPOSES OR SELF HARM
THEFT AND BURGLARY PREVENTION
RULES OF SAFE FIREARM HANDLING
AND STORAGES AND OTHER
REASONABLE BUSINESS PRACTICES TO
DETER GUN TRAFFICKING OR THE
UNLAWFUL USE OF FIREARMS.
ILLEGAL GUNS OFTEN BEGIN WITH A
LEGAL INITIAL FIREARM PURCHASE
THAT IS SUBSEQUENTLY FUNNELED
INTO THE LEGAL MARKET ACCORDING
TO DATA FROM THE GIFFORDS LAW
CENTER TO PREVENT GUN VIOLENCE
MORE THAN THIRTY THOUSAND STRAW
PURCHASES THAT'S WHEN SOMEONE
BUYS A GUN INTENDING TO TRANSFER
TO SOMEONE ELSE ARE TEMPTED EACH
YEAR. THEFT EGGMAN SELLERS IS
ALSO A PERSISTENT PROBLEM IN
CALIFORNIA. ANOTHER WAY IN WHICH
FIREARMS REACHES THE ILLICIT
MARKET. WHILE GUN DEALERS ARE
CONSIDER FIRST IN LINE TO
MAINTAIN THE SECURE AND LAWFUL
TRANSFER OF FIREARMS. THERE'S
CURRENTLY NO TRAINING
REQUIREMENT FOR GUN DEALERS OR
THEIR EMPLOYEES ON RESPONSIBLE
BUSINESS PRACTICES AND HOW TO
RECOGNIZE SIGNS OF ILLEGAL
ACTIVITY. MANY OTHER INDUSTRIES
REQUIRE TRAINING TO REDUCE HARM
TO THE PUBLIC AND GIVEN THE
OBVIOUS DANGERS THAT FIREARMS
POSE WE BELIEVE THE FIREARM
INDUSTRY SHOULD NOT BE AN
EXCEPTION. SB TWO FORTY ONE
WOULD ESTABLISH GUARDRAILS AT
THE POINT OF SALE AND BRING GUN
RETAILERS UNDER THE UMBRELLA OF
PROFESSIONAL TRAINING PRACTICES.
TO PROMOTE RESPONSIBLE GUN
OWNERSHIP AND PREVENT FRAUDULENT
ACTIVITY. BUT THAT I HAVE
REBEKAH MARCUS LOBBYIST ADVOCATE
FROM BRADY CAMPAIGN. AND PERHAPS
ANOTHER WITNESS. THANK YOU AS
YOUR WITH IS A- I WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT YOU KNOW THE SYSTEM
CAN PLEASE CALL ROLES WE CAN
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. TERRIBLE HOT
. HERE OCTOBER. BRADFORD
BRADFORD HERE SKINNER AND WIENER
. PRESIDENT WIENER PRESENT.
THANK YOU- YOU KNOW WE NEED TO
WE NEED TO START OFF WITH A VOTE
ON THE RULES NOW THAT WE'VE
ESTABLISHED QUORUM IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO DOCTOR THE RULES BY
UNANIMOUS CONSENT. SEEING NONE.
OKAY ALL RIGHT. RULES HAVE BEEN
ESTABLISHED WE CAN MOVE ON-
THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
ABSOLUTELY GOOD MORNING SURE
MEMBERS RECOMMEND BECAUSE
REPRESENTING THE BRADY CAMPAIGN
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF SB TWO FOUR
ONE. NEARLY IDENTICAL BILL WAS
SIGNED INTO LAW IN NEW YORK LAST
YEAR GUN DEALERS SHARE THE
RESPONSIBILITY IN PREVENTING
VIOLENCE IN OUR COMMUNITIES THEY
ACT AS GATEKEEPERS AND THEIR
CONDUCT HAS A DIRECT BEARING ON
WHETHER GUNS ARE DIVERTED TO THE
ILLEGAL MARKET. OR INTO THE
HANDS OF THOSE WHO SHOULD NOT
HAVE THEM AND YET NEITHER
DEALERS NORTHERN PLEASE-
REQUIRED TO HAVE REGULAR
SENSITIVE. TRAINING TO PREVENT
DANGEROUS SALES AND GUN
TRAFFICKING AND ON AN OUTLINE
THEIR OBLIGATION TO ENGAGE AND
BUSINESS PRACTICES AND TO COMPLY
WITH STATE AND FEDERAL LAWS. IF
MY TEENAGE DAUGHTER IS REQUIRED
BY LAW TO HAVE ONLINE TRAINING
TO SCOOP ICE CREAM IT SEEMS ONLY
TO MAKE SENSE OF INDIVIDUALS WHO
SELL LETHAL WEAPONS ARE REQUIRED
TO DO THE SAME THING. SB TWO
FOUR ONE WOULD REQUIRE THE
TRAININGS TO INCLUDE FEDERAL AND
STATE LAWS GOVERNING SALES AND
TRANSFERS OF FIREARMS AND
AMMUNITION. HOW TO RECOGNIZE AND
IDENTIFY STRIPERS TEACHER
PURCHASERS AND FRAUDULENT
ACTIVITY HOW TO RECKON RECOGNIZE
AND IDENTIFY INDICATORS THAT AN
INDIVIDUAL INTENDS TO USE A
FIREARM FOR SELF HARM. AND HOW
TO PREVENT THEFT OR BURGLARY OF
FIREARMS AND AMMUNITION NOT ONLY
IS THIS TRAINING COMMONSENSE
BECAUSE IT WILL BENEFIT PUBLIC
HEALTH AND SAFETY BUT IT WILL
ALSO PROVIDE TOOLS TO THE
DEALERS AND THEIR EMPLOYEES TO
ENSURE THAT THEY ARE ACTING
RESPONSIBLY. AND COMPLIANCE WITH
OUR LAWS THIS LEGISLATION IS
CRITICAL TO CURBING DANGEROUS
SALES PREVENTING GUNS FROM BEING
DIVERTED INTO THE CRIMINAL
MARKETS WE RESPECTED
RESPECTIVELY REQUEST YOUR
SUPPORT FOR SB TWO FOUR ONE.
I'LL JUST ADD THAT THE SECOND
WITNESS IS TESTIFYING IN-
ASSEMBLY PUBLIC SAFETY. THERE IS
A SECOND INTO SOMETHING YOU
THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
WAY. HERE IN THE ROOM. SEEING
NONE- WILL MOVE ON TO LEAD
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. SEEING
NONE DO WE HAVE ANY- OTHER
OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN THE
ROOM. I THINK YOU WILL MOVE ON
TO WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
PLEASE STATE ONLY YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION AND POSITION
MODERATOR CAN WE PUMP THE NEXT
INDIVIDUAL TO TESTIFY. IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. TO MAKE
COMMENT BY PHONE ON S. B. TWO
FORTY ONE PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO
AT THIS TIME. WELL I'M SURE WE
HAVE NO RESPONDENTS IN Q. THANK
YOU AND THANK YOU TO ALL OF THE
SUPPORT IN OPPOSITION WITNESSES
WILL NOW BRING THE DISCUSSION
BACK TO THE MEMBERS. DO ANY OF
OUR MEMBERS HAVE QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. SEEING NONE- SENATOR
WOULD YOU LIKE CLOSE- THANK YOU
HAPPY FRIDAY EVERYONE LET'S NOT
HAVE TOO MUCH CIRCULAR LOGIC I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR PART
OF AYE VOTE NOT PRIVATE. IS
THERE A MOTION ON THE BILL. TO
PASS THIS TO APPROPRIATIONS. ALL
RIGHT. MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS WAHABI. HI BOB HI
JOE ABOUT BRADFORD. SKINNER
WIENER RIGHT WIENER HIGH. SO
SENATE TWO FOUR WILL BE CALL
THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE A MOTION
ON SB FOUR SIX A TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
MOTIONS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS WILL HOP I HOP HI
BRADFORD SKINNER WINNER WIENER
AYE. THANK YOU THIS BILL WILL BE
PUT ON PLACE ON CALL.
DO WE HAVE A MOTION ON SB EIGHTY
SIX WHICH IS PLACED ON CONSENT.
THURMOND. WE'RE NOT IT'S NOT TOO
CONCERNED THE M. S. B. NINETEEN
HAVE PLAYED OPPOSITION SUMS
PULLED UP. SO HE'S ON HIS WAY
HERE I'M SORRY. BOB HI HOP I
BRADFORD SKINNER WINNER BUT
WIENER AYE. THE CONSENT
CALENDARS ON CALL. WE'RE WAITING
FOR NOW ON. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU WE HAVE OUR NEXT
AUTHOR. SENATOR SAY ARE TO A FEW
KEY YOU JOIN US- WE HAVE. SB
NINETEEN. WHICHEVER YOU PREFER.
I THANK YOU ON A WHEELCHAIR I'M
HERE TO PRESENT SB NINETEEN
FIRST I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE STAFFER WORKING WITH
MY STAFF TO REFINE INFORM THE
AMENDMENTS FOR THIS VERY
IMPORTANT BILL SB NINETEEN IS A
BIPARTISAN BILL THAT ESTABLISHES
THE CALIFORNIA FENNEL ABUSE TASK
FORCE. THIS POLICY PASSED THE
ASSEMBLY PUBLIC SAFETY AND
HEALTH COMMITTEES AND UNANIMOUS
SUPPORT LAST SESSION AND HAD
UNANIMOUS SUPPORT LAST SESSION
THIS TASK FORCE WILL COLLECT AND
ORGANIZE DATA ON THE NATURE AND
EXTENT OF THE FENNEL TO ABUSE
AND EVALUATE APPROACHES TO
INCREASE PUBLIC AWARENESS OF
SENTINEL THIS TASK FORCE'S
MEMBERSHIP IS DIVERSE INCLUDING
REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE LEGAL
SYSTEM NONPROFITS AND HEALTH
AGENCIES. OVER THE LAST TWO
DECADES CALIFORNIA AND THE REST
OF THE NATION HAVE SEEN A RISE
IN OVERDOSES RELATED TO OR OKAY
YOUR USE. AND AS WE HAVE ALL
SEEN A NEW FORM OF OPIOID CALLED
FENTANYL HAS TAKEN THIS EPIDEMIC
TO NEW HEIGHTS. THE NEW WAVE OF
DRUG DEATHS AFFECTS CALIFORNIANS
OF ALL DEMOGRAPHICS AND
COMMUNITIES COSTING THE LIVES OF
ALMOST FOUR THOUSAND
CALIFORNIANS IN TWENTY TWENTY
ALONE. IN TWENTY TWENTY ONE
FENNEL OVERDOSE BECAME
RECOGNIZED AS THE LEADING CAUSE
OF DEATH FOR AMERICANS EIGHTEEN
TO FORTY FIVE. MORE THAN SUICIDE
GUN HOMICIDE OR CAR ACCIDENTS.
FENNEL DIFFERS FROM TRADITIONAL
PRESCRIPTION. IS IT ITS POTENCY
AND AVAILABILITY ONLY TWO
MILLIGRAMS OF FENTANYL IS ENOUGH
TO CAUSE A SINGLE OVERDOSE. DATA
FROM LAW ENFORCEMENT YIELDS THAT
IN THE BAY AREA ALONE OVER SIXTY
FIVE THOUSAND GRAMS OF FENTANYL
WAS SEIZED IN TWENTY TWENTY TWO
AND THAT'S ENOUGH TO KILL EVERY
ADULT IN CALIFORNIA. IN A SINGLE
DAY THEY SEIZED TWELVE HUNDRED
AND TWO GRAMS OF FENTANYL WHICH
IS ENOUGH TO KILL SIX HUNDRED
THOUSAND PEOPLE. THE VALUE OF
BRINGING TOGETHER A STATEWIDE
TASK FORCE OF INDIVIDUALS
ALREADY TRYING TO ADDRESS THE
CRISIS CANNOT BE UNDERSTATED.
OUR HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATIONS
AND WORKERS ARE TAKING THE BRUNT
OF CARING FOR OVERDOSE VICTIMS.
OUR PUBLIC HEALTH A NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATIONS SPREAD EDUCATIONAL
SOURCES TO TRY AND BRING
AWARENESS TO THE PUBLIC. OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT HAS THE DIFFICULT
TASK OF COMBATING ILLICIT PILLS
AND THEIR DISTRIBUTION NETWORKS
THAT CONTINUE TO RAVAGE OUR
COMMUNITIES. AN EPIDEMIC OF
THESE PROPORTIONS DESERVES A
RESPONSE THAT BRINGS TOGETHER
THE BEST OF OUR STATE'S
RESOURCES SB NINETEEN WILL
ASSEMBLE THE DATA AND
INDIVIDUALS TO IDENTIFY THE
RESOURCES NECESSARY. TO RESPOND
TO THIS NEW FORM OF SYNTHETIC
OPIOID ABUSE. WITH THAT STAND BY
FOR ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU I
DO WE HAVE ANY LEAD WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT. NO I DID NOT BRING ANY
LEAD WITNESSES. OKAY I DO WE
HAVE ANY SUPPORT WITNESSES HERE
IN THE ROOM. ON BEHALF.
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
. NEXT WITNESS. BRADFORD THE
DESCRIPTION INCLUDES THE COUNTY
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ATTORNEYS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANKS
VERY MUCH THANK YOU. ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. SEEING
NONE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO LEAD
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. SEEING
NONE- WILL NOW LEAD TO ANY OTHER
OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN THE
ROOM. THANK YOU WILL NOW MOVE ON
TO WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
PLEASE STATE ONLY YOUR NAME
ORGANIZATION AND POSITION
MODERATOR DO WE HAVE ANY
WITNESSES. TO COMMENT ON THIS BE
NINETEEN PLEASE PRESS ONE ZERO
AT THIS TIME ONE MOMENT I'M SURE
WITH COLLECTION LINE NUMBERS
DEFENSE RESPONDENTS THANK YOU.
OUR FIRST COMMENT THOSE FROM
LINE NUMBER FIFTEEN YOU MAY GO
AHEAD. JOSH DUGGAR ON BEHALF OF
THE COUNTY HEALTH EXECUTIVE
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU. I
WOULD HAVE ONE MORE TO BE ONE
MOMENT. LINE TWENTY ONE GO AHEAD
PLEASE. MORNING ALLEN CHAIR AND
MEMBERS THAT THE ARMSTRONG ON
BEHALF OF THE COUNTY HEALTH
EXECUTIVE ASSOCIATION
REPRESENTING LOCAL HEALTH
DEPARTMENTS HE SUPPORT THANK YOU
. THE MANAGER WE HAVE NO
ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS IN Q.
THANK YOU TO ALL OUR SUPPORT AND
OPPOSITION WITNESSES WILL NOW
BRING THE DISCUSSION BACK TO
MEMBERS DO ANY OF OUR MEMBERS
HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. IF
SINCE I WAS WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE YEAH I JUST RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR A VOTE THANK YOU. THIS
SENATOR WIENER WE HAD A- TO PASS
A PURPOSE. THE SECRETARY WOULD
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. WHAT
HARPER I HAVE HI BRADFORD.
SKINNER HI SKINNER AYE WIENER.
AYE WIENER AYE. THANK YOU. THIS
WILL MOVE ON TO- THE
TELECONFERENCE ON CALL THANK YOU
. THANK YOU. SO SKINNER. WOULD
YOU LIKE TO PRESENT SB THIRTY
SIX. HOW ARE YOU COMFORTABLE
WITH MY PRESENTING FROM THE DICE
HERE VERSUS THE 1100% YES OKAY
GREAT. THANKS SO MUCH- CHAIR AND
MEMBERS- SB THIRTY SIX. IS
NEEDED NOW. AS WE- HAVE WATCHED
ONCE THE SUPREME COURT
OVERTURNED ROE VERSUS WADE IT
UNLEASHED STATE LAWS ACROSS THE
COUNTRY THAT HAVE NOW BEYOND OR
MADE CRIMINALIZED ESSENTIAL
HEALTH CARE SERVICES. NOW IN
CONTRAST TO CALIFORNIA'S PASSED
MULTIPLE BILLS TO MAKE
CALIFORNIA A SAFE HAVEN FOR
CLIENTS AND PROVIDERS OF
ABORTION AND GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE. BUT AS I MENTIONED AS WE
SEE MORE AND MORE LAWS
CRIMINALIZING THESE ACTIVITIES
WE RECOGNIZE THAT CALIFORNIA CAN
DO MORE SO WHAT SB THIRTY SIX
PARTICULAR SPECIFICALLY DOES
BEFORE STATE THIS'LL MAKE AN
ANALOGY I'M SURE MANY OF US HAVE
SEEN THOSE REALITY SHOOT SHOWS
ABOUT BOUNTY HUNTERS. AND YOU
KNOW THAT. I DAY THERE'S A
DOLLAR AMOUNT ON SOMEONE PICKING
UP WHEN IN FACT THE BOUNTY
HUNTER CAN MAKE MONEY OFF OF
PICKING UP SOMEONE WHO IS WANTED
SOMEWHERE WHETHER IT'S IN
CALIFORNIA OR ELSEWHERE AND THEN
THEY PICK UP THAT PERSON IN IN
THOSE SHOWS RATHER BRUTALLY AND
DELIVER THEM TO ANOTHER STATE
AND ARE PAID. SO WHAT SB THIRTY
SIX DOES IS BANDS BACK T.
HUNTERS AND BAIL AGENTS FROM
CAPTURING A PERSON IN
CALIFORNIA. WHO IS ANOTHER
STATUS TRYING TO PROSECUTE FOR
RECEIVING OR PROVIDING ABORTION
SERVICES OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE THAT IS LEGAL IN CALIFORNIA
. SB THIRTY SIX ALSO PROHIBITS-
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS FROM
ASSISTING OUT OF STATE
INVESTIGATIONS OR PROSECUTIONS
FOR ABORTION AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE AGAIN THAT IS
LEGAL IN CALIFORNIA. AND IT
ENSURES ACCESS TO CALIFORNIA'S
PUBLIC BENEFITS TO THOSE WHO MAY
BE CHARGED WITH SUCH CRIMES. WHO
AYE MATE WHO OTHERWISE- BECAUSE
OF OUR RULES AROUND SUCH THING
IF YOU. CHARGES PENDING THEN YOU
ARE DISQUALIFIED AND BECAUSE WE
ARE NOT RECOGNIZING THOSE LAWS
IN OTHER STATES WE DON'T WANT TO
DISQUALIFY PEOPLE. I'M SO AS
THAT IS THE- THE PURPOSE OF THE
BILL THAT'S WHAT THE BILL DOES
AND WITH THAT I'M HAPPY TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU
WE WILL NOW MOVE ON TO LEAD
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT. POLICIES
THAT SHOULD HAVE INTRODUCED ME
WITNESSES NO WORRIES- IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ATTEND THE- YES WE
HAVE CRAIG'S POST FOR ME QUALITY
CALIFORNIA AND- I'M RUSTY OF
PRESENTING BILLS. THANK YOU
THAT'S YOUR MEMBERS GOOD MORNING
CRAIG PULLS FROM BEHALF OF A
QUALITY CALIFORNIA PROUD CO
SPONSOR OF SB THIRTY SIX. AS YOU
ALL WELL KNOW WE'RE WITNESSING
DANGEROUS AND UNPRECEDENTED
ATTACKS ON THE TRANS COMMUNITY
IN THIS COUNTRY IN THIS YEAR
ALONE MORE THAN THREE HUNDRED
ANTI LGBTQ BILLS HAVE BEEN
INTRODUCED. THE VAST MAJORITY OF
WHICH TARGET TRANS PEOPLE AND
ESPECIALLY THEIR ACCENT THEIR
ABILITY TO ACCESS LIFESAVING
MEDICAL CARE. ALREADY AT LEAST
EIGHT STATES HAVE PASSED LAWS
THE RESTRICTION AFFIRMING CARE
FOR TRANS YOUTH AND NEARLY TWO
DOZEN STATES HAVE INTRODUCED
BILLS THAT WOULD ALSO RESTRICT
THIS KIND OF CARE FOR TRANS
YOUTH. AND NOW IN SOME CASES
EVEN ADULTS. BUT IT DOESN'T STOP
THERE STATES ARE ALSO ATTEMPTING
TO CRIMINALIZE PROVIDERS FOR
DELIVERING GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
AND EVEN PUNISH PARENTS WHO SEEK
MEDICAL CARE FOR THEIR CHILDREN.
LAST YEAR ALABAMA WAS THE FIRST
STATE TO MAKE PROVIDING GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE FELONY. AND TEXAS
IS NOW CONSIDERING THREE
SEPARATE BILLS THAT WOULD MAKE
PROVIDING GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
TO MINORS A FORM OF CHILD ABUSE.
PUNISHABLE AS A SECOND DEGREE
FELONY. THESE ATTACKS ARE
CERTAINLY NOT NEW. OR NOW
WITNESSING BLATANT ATTEMPTS TO
USE LEGISLATION AND POLICY TO
ELIMINATE THE RIGHTS AND EVEN
THE VERY EXISTENCE OF TRANS
PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTRY. IN FACT
JUST THIS MONTH YOU MAY HAVE
HEARD OF FAR RIGHT COMMENTATOR
SAY THE QUIET PART OUT LOUD.
WHEN HE DECLARED QUOTE THE
TRANSGENDERISM MUST BE
ERADICATED FROM PUBLIC LIFE
ENTIRELY. MAKE NO MISTAKE TRANS
EXISTENCE NOT UP FOR DEBATE IN
CALIFORNIA AND WILL CONTINUE
STANDING UP TO THESE HATEFUL
ATTACKS. SB THIRTY SIX WILL
BUILD ON LAST YEAR'S LANDMARK
PROTECTIONS TO ENSURE THAT THE
STATE REMAINS A SAFE HAVEN. FOR
THOSE ATTEMPTING TO ACCESS
LIFESAVING MEDICAL CARE FOR
THEMSELVES AND THEIR CHILDREN.
THE QUALITY CALIFORNIA'S PROUD
TO CO SPONSOR SB THIRTY SIX AND
WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU
KNOW DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER LEAD
WITNESSES AND YES MY OTHER LEAD
WITNESSES AARON EVANS FROM NAY
RALPH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS I'M ERIN
EVANS ON BEHALF OF NARAL PRO
CHOICE CALIFORNIA. OUR STATE
DIRECTOR WANTED TO BE HERE TODAY
BUT WAS DELAYED DUE TO WEATHER.
ADMIRAL BITES FOR REPRODUCTIVE
FREEDOM FOR EVERYBODY POWERED BY
FOUR MILLION MEMBERS NATIONWIDE.
AND THREE HUNDRED AND SEVENTY
THOUSAND MEMBERS IN CALIFORNIA.
AND WE'RE VERY PROUD TO CO
SPONSOR SB THIRTY SIX. CURRENTLY
THERE ARE SEVENTEEN STATES AND
COUNTING THAT ARE ENFORCING BANS
ON ABORTION. AND WE'RE SAYING
CATASTROPHIC CONSEQUENCES ON
REAL PEOPLE'S LIVES. THESE BANDS
AND TERMINATE PREGNANT PEOPLE.
AS WELL AS DOCTORS AND
HOSPITALS. THE STOCK CLINICIANS
FROM PROVIDING CRITICAL CARE.
AND MISCARRIAGE MANAGEMENT AND
PUT PREGNANT PEOPLE'S LIVES AND
HEALTH IN DANGER. THE THREATS
DON'T THERE. ANTI CHOICE
LAWMAKERS IN SEVERAL STATES HAVE
INTRODUCED LEGISLATION PROPOSING
HOMICIDE. AND OTHER CRIMINAL
CHARGES FOR PEOPLE SEEKING
ABORTION CARE. THESE BILLS HAVE
BEEN INTRODUCED IN STATES LIKE
TEXAS. KENTUCKY SOUTH CAROLINA
OKLAHOMA ARKANSAS AND JUST LAST
WEEK SOUTH CAROLINA. IT'S A DARK
WORLD WHERE CALIFORNIA HAS TO
CONTEMPLATE HOW TO PROTECT
PEOPLE. FROM BEING CHARGED WITH
HOMICIDE FOR ACCESSING ESSENTIAL
HEALTH CARE. BUT HERE WE ARE.
FOR CALIFORNIA TO CONTINUE
LIVING UP TO OUR DESIGNATION AS
A REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM STATE. WE
MUST PROTECT ALL PEOPLE WHO ARE
ACCESSING ABORTION AND GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE. AND THAT
INCLUDES PROTECTING ANYONE
FORCED TO SEEK REFUGE IN
CALIFORNIA. AFTER ACCESSING
THESE SERVICES IN ANOTHER STATE
. SB THIRTY SIX EXPAND
CALIFORNIA'S REPRODUCTIVE
FREEDOM STATE PROTECTIONS BY
PROHIBITING BAIL AGENTS OR
PRIVATE BOUNTY HUNTERS FROM
CAPTURING PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA.
AFTER THEY FLED THEIR HOME STATE
TO AVOID CRIMINALIZATION OF
ABORTION OR GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE. CALIFORNIA MUST CONTINUE
TO HOLD THIS IMPORTANT LINE AND
MAKE ABUNDANTLY CLEAR THAT
CRIMINALIZING WOMEN PREGNANT
PEOPLE AND TRANS PEOPLE AS A
PORN AND WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
HERE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
LEADERSHIP AND YOUR SUPPORT AND
YOUR- SUPPORT OF SB THIRTY SIX.
POUNDS FOR THE FULL SEVENTEEN
BILL FUTURE OF ABORTION COUNSEL
PACKAGE I WAS JUST ANNOUNCED
YESTERDAY WITH THE LEGISLATIVE
WOMEN'S CAUCUS. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU I DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
SUPPORT ONCE IS HERE IN THE ROOM
. YEAH GOOD AFTERNOON KEVIN AS
THEIR COALITION CALIFORNIA
WELFARE RIGHTS ORGANIZATION
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ANNOUNCER AND IS ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA TERMS JUSTICE AND
SUPPORT. THE FOOD HOLD WILL
HOUSTON FOR THE CALIFORNIA
PUBLIC DEFENDERS ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. HI THERE
KATHY VAN OSTERN ON BEHALF OF.
THE ASSIST ASSOCIATION OF
UNIVERSITY WOMEN CALIFORNIANS
PARK. DO WE NEED SO DO WE HAVE
ANY OTHER SUPPORT WHEN THIS IS
HERE IN THE ROOM. OUR RATE WILL
MOVE ON TO LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE LET'S
HEAR FROM ANY OTHER OPPOSITION
WITNESSES HERE IN THE ROOM.
SEEING NONE THANK YOU WILL NOW
MOVE ON TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
TESTIFY VIA TELECONFERENCE
SERVICE PLEASE STATE ONLY YOUR
NAME ORGANIZATION AND POSITION
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
PROMPT INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
WE WILL BEGIN. THANK YOU AND I'M
SURE IF YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY
DONE SO AND LIKE TO COMMENT
PRESS ONE ZERO ON YOUR PHONE'S
KEYPAD WE'LL GO FIRST TO LINE
NUMBER TWENTY TWO PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING
ADMINISTRATOR WITH CHRISTIANITY
ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA LATINAS
FOR REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE AND
SUPPORT. THANKS FOR GOING TO
LINE NUMBER TWENTY THREE PLEASE
GO AHEAD. MY MANAGER MEMBERS
CHRIS RESPONSES WITH THE WESTERN
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY PART
OF YOUR SPONSORED. LIKE TWENTY
FIVE GO AHEAD PLEASE. I'M MORE.
WHEN YOU'RE MODES YOU CAN WITH
LOCKED SO ON. PRODUCT SALAS WILL
BOND HEARING SUPPORT THANK YOU.
LINE TWENTY FOUR PER GO AHEAD. I
TWENTY FOUR GO HEAD TO. OKAY MY
NAME IS PA. I LIVE IN- I'M
ENABLE ME AND I. AS HE THIRTY
THIRD. M. LINE MY GO AHEAD
PLEASE. HEVIA HERNANDEZ WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER OF NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORK AND
WE SUPPORT. I'M SURE THERE ARE
NO OTHER RESPONDENTS IN Q. THANK
YOU AND THANK YOU TO OUR
WITNESSES WILL NOW BRING THE
DISCUSSION BACK TO MEMBERS TO DO
ANY OF OUR MEMBERS HAVE
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. SENATOR
WIENER I'VE- THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR- I WANT TO THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS BILL
FORWARD I FULLY SUPPORT AND I
WANT TO THANK HER FOR YA EVEN
WITHOUT BEING ASKED INCLUDING
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE SHOULD
INCREDIBLE ALLY TO THE LGBTQ
COMMUNITY- THIS. BILL ON THE
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE SIDE BY IT
IT ADDS TO AN OF THE FILLS AND
GAPS ARE TO SB ONE OF SEVEN
WHICH WE PASSED OUT LAST YEAR TO
MAKE A CALIFORNIA STATE OF. A
REFUGE FOR TRANS KIDS AND THEIR
FAMILIES AS THEY'RE BEING
CRIMINALIZED IN OTHER STATES ARE
WE NEED TO REALLY PUT THIS IN
THE REAL TERMS- WHAT'S HAPPENED
YOU HEARD FROM MR PULLS OVER A
WHITE- WHAT OTHER STATES ARE
DOING. BUT THIS IS LIKE THIS IS
LIKE REAL LIFE STUFF. WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT FAMILIES IN PLACES
LIKE ALABAMA OR TEXAS OR OR OR
GROWING LIST OF STATES WERE
LITERALLY ALL THEY'RE DOING IS
WHAT WE WHAT PARENTS SHOULD DO
TO SUPPORT THEIR KIDS HAVE KIDS
WHO ARE TRANS AND THEY ARE
THEY'RE TRYING TO BE THE BEST
PARENTS THEY CAN BE AND ARE
SUPPORTING THOSE KIDS. INSTEAD
OF STIGMATIZING ATTACKING THEM.
WHICH IS WHAT DRIVES THESE KIDS
TO HAVE A SUCH A HIGH RATE. OF
EFFORTS AT SELF HARM AND SUICIDE
HIS PARENTS ARE TRYING TO BE
GOOD PARENTS. AND THEY'RE
ALLOWING THEIR KIDS TO GET
HEALTH CARE. THAT IS WITHIN THE
STANDARD OF CARE FOR EVERY
REPUTABLE- MEDICAL ORGANIZATION-
IN OUR COUNTRY. AND THEY'RE
BEING TOLD BY THE STATE'S. BUT
IF YOU DO THAT YOU'RE CRIMINAL.
THAT THE THESE THESE HIP. AND
THE THREATS TO CALL. THAT THE
TO. PARENTAL AND THEN THE TOP.
IF YOU. AUTHORIZE YOUR KID. TO
GET HEALTH CARE. YOUR CRIMINAL
WE'RE GONNA THROW YOU IN PRISON
TAKE THE KID AWAY AND PUT THEM
IN FOSTER CARE. IT'S THE HEIGHT
OF HYPOCRISY THAT DETER THEM
CARE ABOUT PARENTAL RIGHTS.
THESE PEOPLE COULD CARE LESS
ABOUT PARENTAL RIGHTS. THEY CARE
ABOUT TRYING TO OBLITERATE IN A
RACE WELL TO BE T. Q. PEOPLE
STARTING WITH KIDS. AND WE'VE
SEEN THAT THEY'RE NOT LIMITS ALL
THEY SAY IT'S ALL ABOUT THE
CHILDREN BUT THEN THEY START
ENACTING LAWS- INCREASING THEIR
BANDS ON GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
UP TO THE AGE OF TWENTY FIVE.
THESE THESE IT IS THE MOST
HYPOCRITICAL DESPICABLE THING.
AT AND CALIFORNIA SHOULD NOT BE
A PARTY TO THAT WE SHOULD NOT BE
ENFORCING THEIR LAWS WE SHOULD
NOT BE OF ALLOWING THEIR THEIR-
THEIR YOU KNOW FOLKS TO COME IN
THE CALIFORNIA GRAB PEOPLE AND
TAKE THEM OUT- AND WE NEED TO
STAND VERY VERY VERY STRONG SO
I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT THIS BILL
AND HAPPY TO MOVE IT. THANK YOU
SENATOR SKINNER WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE THANK YOU SO MUCH
APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS OF A MY
COLLEAGUE- AND- THE POINT HE WAS
MAKING ABOUT THE- I HOPE WITH
THE FEAR. OF PROSECUTION THAT-
THE LAWS AGAINST GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE OR CAUSING ACROSS
THE COUNTRY. IS SIMILARLY
OCCURRING- IN. FOR THOSE PEOPLE
FOR PROVIDERS WHO PURSUE ANY
KIND OF. REPRODUCTIVE CARE
ABORTION SERVICES THAT ARE NOW
CRIMINALIZED AND WE JUST
RECENTLY READ I'M SURE MOST OF
US HAVE SEEN IN THE MEDIA HOW-
TEXAS IS NOW GOING TO CHARGE. A
WOMAN WHO USED- MEDICATION
ABORTION. AND FOR USING IT AND
ADDITIONALLY CHARGE THREE OF HER
FRIENDS WHO THEY ARE SAYING
ASSISTED HER. AND SO WE MAY FIND
INCREASINGLY THAT TO AVOID TO
AVOID THIS AND I HOPE THAT THIS
IS NOT THE CASE BUT- THAT PEOPLE
COME TO CALIFORNIA BECAUSE
OTHERWISE THEY- COULD. COULD
FACE. PRISON TIME. AND WE DO NOT
WANT TO HAVE BOUNTY HUNTERS ARE
BILL AGENTS THINKING THAT THEY
CAN MAKE MONEY OFF OF THIS. SO
THAT AMONG OTHER THINGS IS MY
PURPOSE AND I APPRECIATE- YOUR
AYE VOTES. THANK YOU- WE HAD A
MOTION BY SENATOR WIENER TO MOVE
THIS TO JUDICIARY I CAN WE- CALL
VOTE. BOB I WILL HAVE AYE
BRADFORD SKINNER SKINNER AYE
WIENER AYE WIENER AYE. THIS IS
BEEN PLACED ON CALL THANK YOU.
SECRETARY WOULD YOU PLEASE LIFT
THE CALL. ITEM TWO SB EIGHTY SIX
THE MOTION IS DEEP ON CONSENT
SKINNER. SKINNER HI. ITEM THREE
SB FORTY SIX MOTIONS TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
SKINNER. SKINNER I AM FOR SB TWO
FORTY ONE MOTIONS TO PASS
APPROPRIATIONS SKINNER SKINNER I
. THANK YOU SO WE'LL KEEP.
DEMOCRATS WILL KEEP THE BILL'S
ON CALL THANK YOU.
SECRETARY WOULD YOU PLEASE LIFT
THE CALLS THE ITEM ONE SB
NINETEEN SEYARTO MOTIONS TO PASS
APPROPRIATIONS BRADFORD EFFORT
HI. VOTERS FOUR ZERO BILLS OUT
THE ITEM TO SB EIGHTY SIX
WITHOUT CONSENT OF SORRY CONSENT
BRADFORD. BRADFORD HIGH I THANK
HIM THERE'S NO FOUR ZERO IS THE
VOTE BILL IS OUT. ITEM THREE SB
FORTY SIX ROTH TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
BRADFORD BRADFORD I WAS FOUR
ZERO BILL IS OUT I DON'T FOR SB
TWO FORTY ONE MAN MOTIONS TO
PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS BRADFORD
BRADFORD I. VOTERS FOUR ZERO
BILL IS OUT AND ITEM FIVE SB
THIRTY SIX SKINNER MOTIONS TO
PASS TO DO DISH BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE. FOUR ZERO AS THE
VOTE BILL IS OUT.
OUR PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE IS
ADJOURNED THANK YOU ALL.