WEBVTT
00:00:10.944 --> 00:00:12.278
THE SENATE
00:00:12.345 --> 00:00:13.646
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
00:00:13.713 --> 00:00:16.149
FINANCE WILL COME TO ORDER. GOOD
00:00:16.216 --> 00:00:17.650
MORNING AS WE CONTINUE TO TAKE
00:00:17.717 --> 00:00:18.852
PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE THE
00:00:18.918 --> 00:00:21.287
ONGOING COVID 19 RISK. THE
00:00:21.354 --> 00:00:22.989
SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE
00:00:23.056 --> 00:00:25.125
PUBLIC AND HAS PROVIDED ACCESS
00:00:25.191 --> 00:00:26.259
TO BOTH IN PERSON AND
00:00:26.326 --> 00:00:27.527
TELECONFERENCE PARTICIPATION FOR
00:00:27.594 --> 00:00:30.563
PUBLIC COMMENT. FOR INDIVIDUALS
00:00:30.630 --> 00:00:32.298
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
00:00:32.365 --> 00:00:34.467
COMMENT VIA TELECONFERENCE
00:00:34.534 --> 00:00:36.603
SERVICE THAT PARTICIPANT TOLL
00:00:36.669 --> 00:00:38.738
FREE NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:38.805 --> 00:00:40.073
POSTED ON OUR ON OUR COMMITTEE
00:00:40.140 --> 00:00:43.109
WEBSITE. AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT
00:00:43.176 --> 00:00:45.178
NOW. TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER
00:00:45.245 --> 00:00:51.217
IS 8772. AND THE ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:51.284 --> 00:00:57.690
1 TO 2. 9718. WE WELCOME YOU TO
00:00:57.757 --> 00:01:00.193
THE HEARING AND I WILL MAINTAIN
00:01:00.260 --> 00:01:01.094
DECORUM DURING THE HEARING, AS
00:01:01.161 --> 00:01:02.629
IS CUSTOMARY IN ANY INDIVIDUAL
00:01:02.695 --> 00:01:04.030
WHO IS DISRUPTIVE MAY BE REMOVED
00:01:04.097 --> 00:01:05.632
FROM THE REMOTE MEETING SERVICE
00:01:05.698 --> 00:01:08.067
OR HAVE THEIR CONNECTION MUTED.
00:01:08.134 --> 00:01:09.869
I HAVE TO SAY WE'VE NEVER HAD
00:01:09.936 --> 00:01:11.070
THAT HAPPEN BEFORE, SO I DON'T
00:01:11.137 --> 00:01:13.640
EXPECT THAT TO HAPPEN TODAY. WE
00:01:13.706 --> 00:01:14.874
ARE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
00:01:14.941 --> 00:01:17.210
HEARINGS HERE IN ROOM 2100 OF
00:01:17.277 --> 00:01:18.611
THE OLD STREET BUILDING, AND I
00:01:18.678 --> 00:01:20.280
ASK ALL MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:01:20.346 --> 00:01:21.714
TO BE PRESENT SO WE CAN
00:01:21.781 --> 00:01:22.882
ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM AND BEGIN
00:01:22.949 --> 00:01:24.117
OUR HEARING. WE'RE GOING TO
00:01:24.184 --> 00:01:25.618
BEGIN OUR HEARING AS A
00:01:25.685 --> 00:01:26.953
SUBCOMMITTEE, SO WE'LL HEAR THE
00:01:27.020 --> 00:01:28.721
BILLS AND THEN WE'LL HAVE TO
00:01:28.788 --> 00:01:30.156
WAIT IN ORDER TO HAVE MOTIONS
00:01:30.223 --> 00:01:34.561
AND, UM AND TAKE A VOTE. ITEM
00:01:34.627 --> 00:01:37.564
NUMBER EIGHT A B 23 59 BY
00:01:37.630 --> 00:01:38.998
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO HAS
00:01:39.065 --> 00:01:40.400
BEEN PULLED BY THE AUTHOR AND
00:01:40.467 --> 00:01:42.936
WILL NOT BE HEARD TODAY. THAT
00:01:43.002 --> 00:01:44.237
LEAVES 26 BILLS ON TODAY'S
00:01:44.304 --> 00:01:46.172
AGENDA WITH TWO BILLS PROPOSED
00:01:46.239 --> 00:01:48.575
FOR CONSENT. THE CONSENT ITEMS
00:01:48.641 --> 00:01:51.945
ARE ITEM NUMBER 22 A B 27 89 BY
00:01:52.011 --> 00:01:54.581
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MULLEN AND FILE
00:01:54.647 --> 00:01:56.616
ITEM NUMBER 24 A B 26 51 BY
00:01:56.683 --> 00:02:00.086
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PETRIE-NORRIS.
00:02:00.153 --> 00:02:01.855
AT 9 30. THERE WILL BE A SPECIAL
00:02:01.921 --> 00:02:04.390
ORDER A B 2021 FOR
00:02:04.457 --> 00:02:06.092
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS AND THE
00:02:06.159 --> 00:02:07.694
COMMITTEE WILL HEAR THE BILL AT
00:02:07.760 --> 00:02:09.262
THAT TIME AND THEN RESUME ITS
00:02:09.329 --> 00:02:10.797
WORK AFTER CONSIDERATION OF THE
00:02:10.864 --> 00:02:11.865
BILL THAT IS FINISHED. WE'RE
00:02:11.931 --> 00:02:13.867
TRYING TO COORDINATE WITH THE
00:02:13.933 --> 00:02:15.902
ASSEMBLY ON THE PRESENTATION OF
00:02:15.969 --> 00:02:17.937
BILLS AND MAKE SURE THAT UM THAT
00:02:18.004 --> 00:02:20.473
WE DO IT IN AN ORDERLY FASHION
00:02:20.540 --> 00:02:21.975
DURING THE SPECIAL ORDER DUE TO
00:02:22.041 --> 00:02:23.476
CONSTRAINTS REGARDING THE LENGTH
00:02:23.543 --> 00:02:24.511
OF HEARINGS AND TECHNOLOGY
00:02:24.577 --> 00:02:26.546
CONSIDERATIONS, WE ARE GOING TO
00:02:26.613 --> 00:02:27.647
INSTITUTE TIME LIMITS ON
00:02:27.714 --> 00:02:29.816
TESTIMONY. EACH SIDE WILL BE
00:02:29.883 --> 00:02:30.750
PERMITTED IN EQUAL AMOUNT OF
00:02:30.817 --> 00:02:33.019
TIME THAT WILL BE DETERMINED
00:02:33.086 --> 00:02:34.254
WHEN THE TIME COMES BEFORE WE,
00:02:34.320 --> 00:02:39.392
UM SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND WE WANT
00:02:39.459 --> 00:02:41.461
TO TAKE UP AS MANY AUTHORS AS WE
00:02:41.528 --> 00:02:43.696
CAN. BEFORE 9 30. WE HAVE
00:02:43.763 --> 00:02:45.665
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ARAMBULA HERE.
00:02:45.732 --> 00:02:47.200
SO IF YOU OWE QUIRK-SILVA IF
00:02:47.267 --> 00:02:48.935
YOU'D LIKE TO COME FORWARD.
00:02:49.002 --> 00:02:51.037
FORWARD WE CAN START WITH WITH
00:02:51.104 --> 00:02:55.408
YOUR, UM YOUR ITEMS. WE'LL START
00:02:55.475 --> 00:02:57.010
WITH VILE ITEM NUMBER THREE,
00:02:57.076 --> 00:02:58.945
WHICH IS A B 4 98. AND THE FLOOR
00:02:59.012 --> 00:03:05.485
IS YOURS. HI. GOOD MORNING,
00:03:05.552 --> 00:03:07.620
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBER. I WILL
00:03:07.687 --> 00:03:10.023
BE AS QUICK AS POSSIBLE AND LIKE
00:03:10.089 --> 00:03:11.524
TO THANK THE COMMITTEE AND
00:03:11.591 --> 00:03:13.493
ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS,
00:03:13.560 --> 00:03:15.161
UH, THAN THANK THEM FOR THEIR
00:03:15.228 --> 00:03:18.498
WORK ON THIS BILL. 84 98 WOULD
00:03:18.565 --> 00:03:20.433
ENSURE CONTINUOUS TRANSPARENCY,
00:03:20.500 --> 00:03:23.803
COLLABORATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY
00:03:23.870 --> 00:03:24.671
THAT IS VITAL TO THE ORANGE
00:03:24.737 --> 00:03:26.272
COUNTY COMMUNITY PARTNER
00:03:26.339 --> 00:03:27.807
ORGANIZATIONS AND ESPECIALLY THE
00:03:27.874 --> 00:03:29.542
PATIENTS, WHICH KELL OPTIMA WAS
00:03:29.609 --> 00:03:32.178
FOUNDED. TO SERVE. KELL OPTIMA
00:03:32.245 --> 00:03:34.447
WAS FOUNDED AS A PUBLIC PRIVATE
00:03:34.514 --> 00:03:36.549
PARTNERSHIP NEARLY 30 YEARS AGO.
00:03:36.616 --> 00:03:38.418
THEY ARE THE LARGEST HEALTH
00:03:38.484 --> 00:03:40.186
ENSURE IN ORANGE COUNTY,
00:03:40.253 --> 00:03:42.555
PROVIDING COVERAGE FOR ONE AND
00:03:42.622 --> 00:03:43.890
FOUR RESIDENTS, INCLUDING
00:03:43.957 --> 00:03:45.458
COORDINATING HEALTHCARE AND
00:03:45.525 --> 00:03:47.660
RELATED SERVICES FOR MEDICAL
00:03:47.727 --> 00:03:49.228
ENROLLEE, SERVING OUR COUNTY'S
00:03:49.295 --> 00:03:51.464
MOST VULNERABLE RESIDENTS. KILL
00:03:51.531 --> 00:03:53.700
OPTIMA, WHICH IS NOT A COUNTY
00:03:53.766 --> 00:03:55.969
AGENCY, MANAGES PROGRAMS THAT
00:03:56.035 --> 00:03:57.437
ARE FUNDED BY THE STATE AND
00:03:57.503 --> 00:03:59.005
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, BUT OPERATES
00:03:59.072 --> 00:03:59.872
INDEPENDENTLY UNDER THE
00:03:59.939 --> 00:04:00.940
LEADERSHIP OF THE BOARD OF
00:04:01.007 --> 00:04:05.545
DIRECTORS. IN 2017. SB FOUR,
00:04:05.612 --> 00:04:09.082
PASSED OVERWHELMINGLY TO PREVENT
00:04:09.148 --> 00:04:10.950
ANY ORANGE COUNTY SUPERVISOR
00:04:11.017 --> 00:04:12.318
FROM AMENDING THE LOCAL COUNTY
00:04:12.385 --> 00:04:13.386
ORGANIZED HEALTH SYSTEM
00:04:13.453 --> 00:04:15.955
ORDINANCE PROTECT THE GOVERNANCE
00:04:16.022 --> 00:04:17.624
STRUCTURE AND ENSURE CONTINUED
00:04:17.690 --> 00:04:20.526
BALANCE ON THE KILL OPTIMA BOARD
00:04:20.593 --> 00:04:22.095
. HOWEVER THE SAFEGUARDS UNDER
00:04:22.161 --> 00:04:23.730
SB FOUR ARE SET TO SUNSET AT THE
00:04:23.796 --> 00:04:27.266
END OF THIS YEAR. 84 98 WOULD
00:04:27.333 --> 00:04:29.535
NOT ONLY EXTEND SB FOUR
00:04:29.602 --> 00:04:31.070
PERMANENTLY. IT WOULD ALSO
00:04:31.137 --> 00:04:32.038
PROVIDE ADDITIONAL KEY
00:04:32.105 --> 00:04:33.773
GUARDRAILS TO ENSURE THE LONG
00:04:33.840 --> 00:04:34.874
TERM STABILITY OF KELL OPTED
00:04:34.941 --> 00:04:38.478
BÂO. THE BILL IS CO AUTHORED BY
00:04:38.544 --> 00:04:40.580
BARRY PARTISAN COALITION OF
00:04:40.647 --> 00:04:42.181
ORANGE COUNTY MEMBERS OF THE
00:04:42.248 --> 00:04:44.283
LEGISLATURE WITH ME TODAY TO
00:04:44.350 --> 00:04:46.552
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OUR DR
00:04:46.619 --> 00:04:47.086
RICHARD FRANKENSTEIN PAST
00:04:47.153 --> 00:04:50.556
PRESIDENT. OF THE ORANGE COUNTY
00:04:50.623 --> 00:04:53.292
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION PAST
00:04:53.359 --> 00:04:54.460
PRESIDENT OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:04:54.527 --> 00:04:56.896
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION AND FOUNDING
00:04:56.963 --> 00:04:58.965
MEMBER AND PAST YEAR OF THE KELL
00:04:59.032 --> 00:05:01.668
OPTIMA BOARD OF DIRECTORS. ALSO
00:05:01.734 --> 00:05:04.237
MISS RACHEL BLOCHER, SEND SENIOR
00:05:04.303 --> 00:05:05.872
COUNSEL WITH NIELSEN SOUND
00:05:05.938 --> 00:05:08.274
SIMMER. UH AND WE WOULD ASK THEM
00:05:08.341 --> 00:05:13.312
TO COME UP. WELCOME GOOD MORNING
00:05:13.379 --> 00:05:14.647
, KAREN MEMBERS. I BELIEVE DR
00:05:14.714 --> 00:05:17.050
FRANKENSTEIN IS ON THE PHONE, SO
00:05:17.116 --> 00:05:18.484
I'LL LET HIM GO FIRST. AND THEN
00:05:18.551 --> 00:05:20.253
IF YOU COULD GO AHEAD AND WE
00:05:20.319 --> 00:05:21.587
WANT TO KEEP THIS MOVING, SO GO
00:05:21.654 --> 00:05:22.789
AHEAD. ABSOLUTELY WELL. I THINK
00:05:22.855 --> 00:05:24.691
DR FRANKENSTEIN'S TESTIMONY WILL
00:05:24.757 --> 00:05:27.093
ADDRESS THE PUBLIC POLICY REASON
00:05:27.160 --> 00:05:29.228
FOR THIS, UM, BILL, I WILL JUST
00:05:29.295 --> 00:05:31.264
LIKE TO ADD THAT WE WORKED VERY
00:05:31.330 --> 00:05:32.398
CLOSELY WITH COMMITTEE STAFF TO
00:05:32.465 --> 00:05:34.200
TAKE SOME AMENDMENTS THAT WERE
00:05:34.267 --> 00:05:36.135
RESPONSIVE TO CAL OPTIMIST
00:05:36.202 --> 00:05:38.304
CONCERNS THAT ATTEMPT TO NARROW
00:05:38.371 --> 00:05:39.772
THE RESTRICTIONS, SO IT ONLY
00:05:39.839 --> 00:05:42.275
APPLIES TO SOME MEMBERS ON THE
00:05:42.341 --> 00:05:42.909
BOARD, THE BOARD OF SUPERVISOR
00:05:42.975 --> 00:05:44.577
MEMBER AND THE ATTORNEY CPA
00:05:44.644 --> 00:05:47.080
MEMBER AND ALSO MAKES CLEAR THAT
00:05:47.146 --> 00:05:49.482
ANY INDIVIDUALS CAN RETURN TO
00:05:49.549 --> 00:05:51.417
THE ROLES THAT THEY ARE SERVING
00:05:51.484 --> 00:05:52.552
IN OR CONTINUE THE ROLES THAT
00:05:52.618 --> 00:05:54.554
THEY HAVE WHEN THEY JOINED THE
00:05:54.620 --> 00:05:56.923
BOARD. WE ALSO JUST WANT TO BE
00:05:56.989 --> 00:05:58.357
HERE TO ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL
00:05:58.424 --> 00:05:59.358
QUESTIONS. SO THANK YOU VERY
00:05:59.425 --> 00:06:02.328
MUCH. THANK YOU. NOW IF WE COULD
00:06:02.395 --> 00:06:03.529
OPEN THE LINE OF DR RICHARD
00:06:03.596 --> 00:06:09.569
FRANKENSTEIN. THANK YOU. THE
00:06:09.635 --> 00:06:10.737
FLOOR IS YOURS. GOOD MORNING,
00:06:10.803 --> 00:06:15.808
SENATOR. SENATOR CHAIR CAFIERO
00:06:15.875 --> 00:06:16.876
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I AM
00:06:16.943 --> 00:06:20.179
RICHARD FRANKENSTEIN. A RETIRED
00:06:20.246 --> 00:06:22.048
PULMONARY DOCTOR FROM ORANGE
00:06:22.115 --> 00:06:23.883
COUNTY, WHERE I PRACTICED FOR 30
00:06:23.950 --> 00:06:26.552
YEARS. REMAIN ACTIVE IN MANY
00:06:26.619 --> 00:06:28.187
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, HEALTH CARE
00:06:28.254 --> 00:06:29.722
POLICY ENDEAVORS. AND IN PAST
00:06:29.789 --> 00:06:32.258
PRESIDENT AS YOU HAVE HEARD OF O
00:06:32.325 --> 00:06:33.593
C M, A IN CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
00:06:33.659 --> 00:06:37.830
ASSOCIATION. I WAS ONE OF THE
00:06:37.897 --> 00:06:38.831
FOUNDING MEMBERS OF THE CAL
00:06:38.898 --> 00:06:40.733
OFTEN BOARD OF DIRECTORS WHERE I
00:06:40.800 --> 00:06:42.268
SERVED A FULFILLING YEARS,
00:06:42.335 --> 00:06:43.069
HELPING TO BUILD THE LARGEST
00:06:43.136 --> 00:06:44.837
MEDICAID PLAN OF ITS KIND IN THE
00:06:44.904 --> 00:06:46.706
COUNTRY, AS YOU HAVE HEARD,
00:06:46.773 --> 00:06:50.309
SERVING ONE IN FOUR MY SERVICE.
00:06:50.376 --> 00:06:51.878
THERE IS THE REASON I AM HERE
00:06:51.944 --> 00:06:54.781
TODAY TO SUPPORT A B FOR 98 TO
00:06:54.847 --> 00:06:56.215
ENSURE THE CAL OPTIMIST
00:06:56.282 --> 00:06:57.416
GOVERNING BOARD AND LEADERSHIP
00:06:57.483 --> 00:06:59.152
ACT IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF
00:06:59.218 --> 00:07:00.553
ORANGE COUNTY MEDICAL MEMBERS.
00:07:00.620 --> 00:07:02.855
30 YEARS AGO, WE CAME TOGETHER
00:07:02.922 --> 00:07:03.856
TO LAUNCH CAL OPTIMISM. TRUE
00:07:03.923 --> 00:07:06.025
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP. IT
00:07:06.092 --> 00:07:08.194
IS NOT A COUNTY AGENCY. BUT THE
00:07:08.261 --> 00:07:09.195
UNIQUE ORGANIZED HEALTH SYSTEM
00:07:09.262 --> 00:07:10.196
CREATED BY THE BOARD OF
00:07:10.263 --> 00:07:13.800
SUPERVISORS. PARTNERSHIP WAS
00:07:13.866 --> 00:07:15.001
FOUNDED ON PRINCIPLES OF
00:07:15.067 --> 00:07:17.136
COLLABORATION, TRANSPARENCY AND
00:07:17.203 --> 00:07:18.638
ACTING IN THE BEST INTERESTS OF
00:07:18.704 --> 00:07:20.473
PATIENTS. UNFORTUNATELY EVENTS
00:07:20.540 --> 00:07:21.774
OVER THE PAST FEW YEARS, OF
00:07:21.841 --> 00:07:23.643
COURSE, MANY TO QUESTION WHETHER
00:07:23.709 --> 00:07:24.911
COW UP ADHERING TO THESE CORPORA
00:07:24.977 --> 00:07:29.549
SAMPLES. IN 2017. IT'S LIKE
00:07:29.615 --> 00:07:32.552
IMPORTANT STEP PASSING S BEFORE
00:07:32.618 --> 00:07:34.387
WHICH FROZE THE CURRENT BOARD
00:07:34.453 --> 00:07:35.054
STRUCTURE, BUT ONLY THROUGH THIS
00:07:35.121 --> 00:07:38.991
YEAR. NOW. THE SAME COALITION OF
00:07:39.058 --> 00:07:40.059
HOSPITALS, HEALTH SYSTEMS AND
00:07:40.126 --> 00:07:41.994
DOCTORS IS ASKING THE
00:07:42.061 --> 00:07:43.696
LEGISLATURE TO REMOVE THE SUNSET
00:07:43.763 --> 00:07:44.931
PROVISIONS AND ENACT A SERIES OF
00:07:44.997 --> 00:07:47.166
GOOD GOVERNMENT PROVISION. IT
00:07:47.233 --> 00:07:48.167
REMAINS IMPORTANT THAT WE
00:07:48.234 --> 00:07:49.035
REINFORCED THE PRINCIPLE. THE
00:07:49.101 --> 00:07:53.272
ACCOUNT PROGRAM. WILL ACT IN
00:07:53.339 --> 00:07:54.740
THEIR PATIENT'S BEST INTEREST.
00:07:54.807 --> 00:07:55.608
WE HEARD THE COMMITTEE TO
00:07:55.675 --> 00:07:57.910
SUPPORT A B FOR 98 THANK YOU FOR
00:07:57.977 --> 00:07:59.712
THE OPPORTUNITY TO EXPRESS THEIR
00:07:59.779 --> 00:08:02.715
VIEWS TODAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:08:02.782 --> 00:08:04.183
FOR YOUR FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
00:08:04.250 --> 00:08:04.784
WE'RE GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S
00:08:04.851 --> 00:08:07.420
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
00:08:07.486 --> 00:08:08.921
IN SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM 2100.
00:08:08.988 --> 00:08:11.724
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:08:11.791 --> 00:08:13.025
LINES MODERATOR IF YOU COULD
00:08:13.092 --> 00:08:18.965
QUEUE UP SUPPORT FOR A B FOR 98.
00:08:19.031 --> 00:08:20.132
I THINK, MADAM CHAIR. YEAH AND
00:08:20.199 --> 00:08:21.734
FOR THE PUBLIC COMMENT, IF YOU'D
00:08:21.801 --> 00:08:24.303
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B
00:08:24.370 --> 00:08:34.013
498 PLEASE PRESS 10 THIS TIME.
00:08:34.080 --> 00:08:36.082
AND WE HAVE NO COMMENTS. VERY
00:08:36.148 --> 00:08:38.184
GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE
00:08:38.251 --> 00:08:39.785
NOW GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:08:39.852 --> 00:08:41.721
OPPOSITION IS THERE I DO NOT
00:08:41.787 --> 00:08:43.723
HAVE ANY LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESS
00:08:43.789 --> 00:08:44.991
NOTICED, BUT IF THERE'S SOMEONE
00:08:45.057 --> 00:08:46.058
IN THE ROOM, PLEASE COME
00:08:46.125 --> 00:08:49.962
FORWARD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
00:08:50.029 --> 00:08:50.963
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I AM EUNJUNG
00:08:51.030 --> 00:08:53.099
KIM, CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER AT
00:08:53.165 --> 00:08:54.667
CAL OPTIMA. THANK YOU FOR THE
00:08:54.734 --> 00:08:56.903
CHANCE TO SPEAK WITH YOU THIS
00:08:56.969 --> 00:08:57.703
MORNING WHILE CALLUP. MY DOES
00:08:57.770 --> 00:08:58.804
NOT HAVE A POSITION ON THIS
00:08:58.871 --> 00:09:01.140
BILL. WE DO HAVE ONE SIGNIFICANT
00:09:01.207 --> 00:09:02.141
CONCERN THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO
00:09:02.208 --> 00:09:03.709
SHARE. BEFORE I STAYED ARE
00:09:03.776 --> 00:09:05.011
CONCERNED. I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
00:09:05.077 --> 00:09:06.212
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA AND
00:09:06.279 --> 00:09:06.879
THE COMMITTEE FOR THE AMENDMENTS
00:09:06.946 --> 00:09:09.148
THAT PROVIDE CLARITY ON SEVERAL
00:09:09.215 --> 00:09:10.283
PROVISIONS. HOWEVER WE REMAIN
00:09:10.349 --> 00:09:12.418
CONCERNED ABOUT ONE PROVISION IN
00:09:12.485 --> 00:09:14.053
THIS BILL WOULD BAN CERTAIN
00:09:14.120 --> 00:09:15.154
MEMBERS OF OUR BOARD FROM
00:09:15.221 --> 00:09:16.422
EMPLOYMENT WITH ANY ENTITY THAT
00:09:16.489 --> 00:09:17.857
RECEIVES FUNDS FROM CAL OPTIMA.
00:09:17.924 --> 00:09:19.859
FOR A PERIOD OF ONE YEAR AFTER
00:09:19.926 --> 00:09:22.094
LEAVING OUR BOARD. HELL OPTIMUS,
00:09:22.161 --> 00:09:23.496
THE LARGEST HEALTH PLAN IN THE
00:09:23.562 --> 00:09:25.464
COUNTY AND A LARGE EMPLOYER HAS
00:09:25.531 --> 00:09:26.032
VAST FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIPS
00:09:26.098 --> 00:09:28.968
ACROSS THE COUNTY AND BEYOND. IF
00:09:29.035 --> 00:09:30.503
ENACTED, THESE INDIVIDUALS AFTER
00:09:30.569 --> 00:09:31.904
SERVING ON OUR BOARD WOULD NOT
00:09:31.971 --> 00:09:33.773
BE ABLE TO WORK, FOR EXAMPLE,
00:09:33.839 --> 00:09:35.808
FOR A NATIONAL TELECOM PROVIDER
00:09:35.875 --> 00:09:37.743
THAT SERVICES MY PHONE OR FOR A
00:09:37.810 --> 00:09:39.078
LOCAL UNIVERSITY THAT WE FUNDED
00:09:39.145 --> 00:09:41.113
FOR A MENTAL HEALTH SYMPOSIUM.
00:09:41.180 --> 00:09:42.348
OR FOR THE LOCAL FIRE AUTHORITY
00:09:42.415 --> 00:09:44.283
THAT WE SUPPORT FOR WORK WITH
00:09:44.350 --> 00:09:46.585
OUR HOMELESS MEMBERS. APPLYING
00:09:46.652 --> 00:09:47.753
THIS EMPLOYMENT BAN TO THIS
00:09:47.820 --> 00:09:49.622
TARGET LIST OF INDIVIDUALS AND
00:09:49.689 --> 00:09:51.857
ORANGE COUNTY, ONE THAT NOT EVEN
00:09:51.924 --> 00:09:53.292
MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATURE ARE
00:09:53.359 --> 00:09:54.794
NOT SUBJECT TO, UM, APPEARS
00:09:54.860 --> 00:09:56.963
PUNITIVE AND UNWARRANTED. WE
00:09:57.029 --> 00:09:58.064
REQUEST AN AMENDMENT TO REMOVE
00:09:58.130 --> 00:10:01.701
THIS PROVISION. UM AND LOOK TO
00:10:01.767 --> 00:10:03.135
WOR WITH THE AUTHOR AND THE
00:10:03.202 --> 00:10:04.804
COMMITTEE ON FUTURE AMENDMENTS.
00:10:04.870 --> 00:10:06.439
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:10:06.505 --> 00:10:07.506
SHARE OUR CONCERNS AND REQUESTS
00:10:07.573 --> 00:10:08.808
AND AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
00:10:08.874 --> 00:10:09.875
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR BEING
00:10:09.942 --> 00:10:11.510
HERE TODAY. APPRECIATE IT. IS
00:10:11.577 --> 00:10:12.678
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN THE ROOM
00:10:12.745 --> 00:10:15.481
THAT IS AN OPPOSITION? SAYING
00:10:15.548 --> 00:10:17.016
THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
00:10:17.083 --> 00:10:18.317
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:10:18.384 --> 00:10:20.152
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
00:10:20.219 --> 00:10:22.755
IN OPPOSITION? FROM THE PHONE IF
00:10:22.822 --> 00:10:24.690
HE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:10:24.757 --> 00:10:25.858
OPPOSITION OF A B 498 PLEASE
00:10:25.925 --> 00:10:36.502
PRESS 10. INTO THE CHAIR AND NO
00:10:36.569 --> 00:10:37.937
COMMENTS COMING IN. THANK YOU
00:10:38.004 --> 00:10:39.572
VERY MUCH. I'M GOING TO BRING IT
00:10:39.638 --> 00:10:40.840
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE. ANY
00:10:40.906 --> 00:10:42.141
QUESTIONS? UM THE ONLY QUESTION
00:10:42.208 --> 00:10:43.442
I HAVE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IS THE
00:10:43.509 --> 00:10:45.411
ISSUE THAT WAS RAISED IN THE
00:10:45.478 --> 00:10:47.847
OPPOSITION. UM ASSUMING YOU'RE
00:10:47.913 --> 00:10:49.482
WILLING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION
00:10:49.548 --> 00:10:51.384
TO SEE IF THERE'S SOMETHING THAT
00:10:51.450 --> 00:10:52.485
NEEDS TO BE DONE TO, UM,
00:10:52.551 --> 00:10:54.487
SPECIFY. I THINK THERE'S
00:10:54.553 --> 00:10:55.321
CLARIFICATION THAT THERE COULD
00:10:55.388 --> 00:10:59.658
BE ADDED ADDED TO IT. WE ARE. WE
00:10:59.725 --> 00:11:02.561
ALREADY HAVE TAKEN, UM AN
00:11:02.628 --> 00:11:05.131
AMENDMENT TO NARROW THAT, SO I
00:11:05.197 --> 00:11:07.967
BELIEVE THIS WILL ONLY APPLY TO
00:11:08.034 --> 00:11:09.602
TWO OF THE BOARD MEMBERS AND SO
00:11:09.668 --> 00:11:13.706
THAT MEMBERS THAT MAY NOT BE
00:11:13.773 --> 00:11:15.741
NURSES AND SO FORTH. THIS WOULD
00:11:15.808 --> 00:11:18.577
NOT APPLY TO OKAY. WELL, THAT'S
00:11:18.644 --> 00:11:19.779
THAT'S THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENT.
00:11:19.845 --> 00:11:20.946
AND I APPRECIATE YOU TAKING THAT
00:11:21.013 --> 00:11:23.315
THAT AMENDMENT AND ITHINK
00:11:23.382 --> 00:11:24.650
CONVERSATION MIGHT BE
00:11:24.717 --> 00:11:26.552
APPROPRIATE TO SEE WHETHER THAT
00:11:26.619 --> 00:11:28.821
SATISFIES SATISFIES THEM. BUT
00:11:28.888 --> 00:11:33.192
I'LL ALLOW YOU TO CLOSE. YES. SO
00:11:33.259 --> 00:11:35.428
I'LL ALLOW YOU TO CLOSE. JUST
00:11:35.494 --> 00:11:37.763
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
00:11:37.830 --> 00:11:39.899
VERY GOOD. AS I SAID, WE NEED A
00:11:39.965 --> 00:11:41.967
QUORUM IN ORDER TO TAKE EMOTION,
00:11:42.034 --> 00:11:43.235
SO WE'LL MOVE ON TO YOUR SECOND
00:11:43.302 --> 00:11:47.506
BILL. WHICH IS, UM FILE ITEM
00:11:47.573 --> 00:11:52.511
NUMBER FOUR A B 20 TO 21. AGAIN
00:11:52.578 --> 00:11:54.980
I WANT TO THANK, UM MADAM CHAIR
00:11:55.047 --> 00:11:57.616
AND THE MEMBERS HERE AND AGAIN
00:11:57.683 --> 00:11:59.985
YOUR TEAM FOR THEM WORKING AND
00:12:00.052 --> 00:12:01.654
WE DO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
00:12:01.720 --> 00:12:03.989
AMENDMENTS. I'M HERE TO PRESENT
00:12:04.056 --> 00:12:06.859
A B 20 TO 21, WHICH WILL CLARIFY
00:12:06.926 --> 00:12:09.095
EXISTING LAW TO HELP EXPEDITE
00:12:09.161 --> 00:12:11.197
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ACCESSORY
00:12:11.263 --> 00:12:14.333
DWELLING UNITS. A D U S, UH, ONE
00:12:14.400 --> 00:12:16.635
OF THE KEY NOTES HERE IS,
00:12:16.702 --> 00:12:17.970
ALTHOUGH WE HAVE STRUGGLED IN
00:12:18.037 --> 00:12:18.938
CALIFORNIA WITH HOUSING
00:12:19.004 --> 00:12:23.109
PRODUCTION AND WE HAVE SEEN
00:12:23.175 --> 00:12:25.411
RENTS SKYROCKET. WE HAVE SEEN
00:12:25.478 --> 00:12:28.347
MORTGAGES AND HOMES. UH FOR A
00:12:28.414 --> 00:12:30.249
MEDIAN HOME BE 800,080 US ARE
00:12:30.316 --> 00:12:33.953
THE ONE I THINK A LITTLE GLIMMER
00:12:34.019 --> 00:12:36.122
OF HOPE FOR PEOPLE WHO OWN
00:12:36.188 --> 00:12:38.624
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES TO ACTUALLY
00:12:38.691 --> 00:12:40.025
USE THOSE PROPRTIES FOR AN
00:12:40.092 --> 00:12:43.129
ADDITIONAL RESIDENT. UM WE KNOW
00:12:43.195 --> 00:12:45.998
THAT HOUSING IS SOMETHING THAT
00:12:46.065 --> 00:12:47.466
IS SO IMPORTANT TO OUR WORKING
00:12:47.533 --> 00:12:51.637
FAMILIES. TO OUR. WE EDUCATE
00:12:51.704 --> 00:12:53.639
THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF INDIA
00:12:53.706 --> 00:12:56.609
BUSHELS IN OUR INCREDIBLE UCS
00:12:56.675 --> 00:12:58.911
CAL STATES AND YET FINDING A
00:12:58.978 --> 00:13:01.947
HOME IS OFTEN ELUSIVE. SO A D.
00:13:02.014 --> 00:13:04.016
U. S ARE PART OF THE SOLUTION TO
00:13:04.083 --> 00:13:05.518
OUR STATE'S HOUSING CRISIS, AND
00:13:05.584 --> 00:13:07.019
THIS MEASURE WILL HELP OWNERS
00:13:07.086 --> 00:13:08.754
GET ACCESS TO A D U. S AND SPEED
00:13:08.821 --> 00:13:10.156
THE DEVELOPMENT OF HOUSING
00:13:10.222 --> 00:13:13.592
ACROSS CALIFORNIA. WITH ME TODAY
00:13:13.659 --> 00:13:15.227
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
00:13:15.294 --> 00:13:17.696
IS JORDAN'S CARBON HALL WITH
00:13:17.763 --> 00:13:19.431
CALIFORNIA, UM B AND MARK
00:13:19.498 --> 00:13:20.032
STIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:13:20.099 --> 00:13:21.100
HOUSING PROJECT. VERY GOOD.
00:13:21.167 --> 00:13:25.337
WELCOME. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
00:13:25.404 --> 00:13:27.039
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:13:27.106 --> 00:13:27.640
MY NAME IS JORDAN PLANET GOT
00:13:27.706 --> 00:13:29.074
BEHIND LEADERSHIP ADVOCATE FOR
00:13:29.141 --> 00:13:31.944
CALIFORNIAN B AND WE ARE PROUD
00:13:32.011 --> 00:13:33.412
SPONSOR OF A B 20 TO 21
00:13:33.479 --> 00:13:35.581
CONFERENCE YOU AS A STATEWIDE
00:13:35.648 --> 00:13:36.582
ORGANIZATION OF OVER 80,000
00:13:36.649 --> 00:13:39.218
MEMBERS. DEDICATED TO MAKING A
00:13:39.285 --> 00:13:41.053
STATE THEREFORE WILL PLACE TO
00:13:41.120 --> 00:13:43.022
LIVE WORK AND RAISE A FAMILY FOR
00:13:43.088 --> 00:13:44.657
ALL CALIFORNIANS. WE'RE UNDER
00:13:44.723 --> 00:13:46.458
WAYS WE CAN COURAGE ACCOMPLISHED
00:13:46.525 --> 00:13:48.594
. THE GOAL IS BY PASSING THE
00:13:48.661 --> 00:13:50.496
REFORMS ACCELERATE 80 US
00:13:50.563 --> 00:13:51.864
PRODUCTIONS BY CLARIFYING EU
00:13:51.931 --> 00:13:53.165
RULES FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
00:13:53.232 --> 00:13:56.602
HOMEOWNERS AS WELL. SAYS
00:13:56.669 --> 00:13:58.003
CALIFORNIA ENACTED LAWS TO ALLOW
00:13:58.070 --> 00:13:59.538
80 US ON RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY
00:13:59.605 --> 00:14:01.607
AND SPURRED THE CREATION OF TENS
00:14:01.674 --> 00:14:04.009
OF THOUSANDS OF HOMES IN THE
00:14:04.076 --> 00:14:05.311
CREATION OF A MULTI BILLION
00:14:05.377 --> 00:14:06.278
DOLLAR INDUSTRY FOR A D U
00:14:06.345 --> 00:14:08.781
SPECIALISTS. OUR CURRENT TO
00:14:08.847 --> 00:14:09.748
RESEARCH FROM UC BERKELEY.
00:14:09.815 --> 00:14:11.717
ETERNAL CENTER 80 US PRODUCED
00:14:11.784 --> 00:14:13.018
MORE AFFORDABLE HOMES TYPICALLY
00:14:13.085 --> 00:14:14.887
OCCUPIED BY LOW INCOME FAMILIES
00:14:14.954 --> 00:14:17.156
AND INDIVIDUALS. MAYBE 20 TO 21
00:14:17.223 --> 00:14:19.225
TAKES US ONE STEP CULTURE TO
00:14:19.291 --> 00:14:20.492
ADDRESSING THE HOUSING SHORTAGE.
00:14:20.559 --> 00:14:21.894
BY EXPANDING AVENUES FOR
00:14:21.961 --> 00:14:23.162
HOMEOWNERS AND ACCELERATE THE
00:14:23.229 --> 00:14:25.297
PRODUCTION OF 80. US CALIFORNIA
00:14:25.364 --> 00:14:27.600
HAS A SHORTAGE OF 3.5 MILLION
00:14:27.666 --> 00:14:29.501
HOMES, AND WE BELIEVE THIS BILL
00:14:29.568 --> 00:14:31.403
COULD BE ONE OF THE SOLUTIONS TO
00:14:31.470 --> 00:14:33.372
GET US BACK ON TRACK. THING WITH
00:14:33.439 --> 00:14:33.973
THAT. I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
00:14:34.039 --> 00:14:35.541
YOUR SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 20 TO 21.
00:14:35.608 --> 00:14:40.079
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GOOD
00:14:40.145 --> 00:14:41.614
MORNING MARKS. DIVERS WITH THE
00:14:41.680 --> 00:14:42.748
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
00:14:42.815 --> 00:14:45.451
AND 80 US CAN BE A GREAT SOURCE
00:14:45.517 --> 00:14:46.085
OF NATURALLY OCCURRING
00:14:46.151 --> 00:14:48.120
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. BUT THE
00:14:48.187 --> 00:14:49.688
HOMEOWNERS WHO GO TO BUILD THEM
00:14:49.755 --> 00:14:50.789
NEED SOME CERTAINTY. AND THEY
00:14:50.856 --> 00:14:53.292
NEED TO KNOW THAT IF AN
00:14:53.359 --> 00:14:54.293
APPLICATION IS INCORRECT, WHAT
00:14:54.360 --> 00:14:54.793
IT WILL TAKE TO GET IT
00:14:54.860 --> 00:14:56.061
CORRECTED. AND THIS BILL
00:14:56.128 --> 00:14:57.029
PROVIDES THOSE TWO ITEMS. IT
00:14:57.096 --> 00:14:58.964
GIVES A TIMEFRAME, WHICH BY BY
00:14:59.031 --> 00:14:59.965
WHICH THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
00:15:00.032 --> 00:15:01.066
LACKED AND IT GIVES THE OAN
00:15:01.133 --> 00:15:02.134
HOMEOWNER FEEDBACK. IF THERE'S
00:15:02.201 --> 00:15:03.102
SOMETHING INCORRECT WITH THE
00:15:03.168 --> 00:15:03.802
APPLICATION THAT WILL GREATLY
00:15:03.869 --> 00:15:06.038
SPEED THE DEVELOPMENT OF A DUS.
00:15:06.105 --> 00:15:07.172
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
00:15:07.239 --> 00:15:08.540
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. HIRANUMA
00:15:08.607 --> 00:15:09.642
NELSON IN THE ROOM THAT WOULD
00:15:09.708 --> 00:15:12.011
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT.
00:15:12.077 --> 00:15:13.479
SEEING THEN WE'LL GO TO THE
00:15:13.545 --> 00:15:14.813
TELECONFERENCE LINE, MR.
00:15:14.880 --> 00:15:16.081
MODERATOR CAN YOU CUE UP
00:15:16.148 --> 00:15:18.117
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:15:18.183 --> 00:15:21.053
TEST TESTIFY IN SUPPORT? THANK
00:15:21.120 --> 00:15:22.554
YOU. YEP. IF THEY'D LIKE TO
00:15:22.621 --> 00:15:25.291
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A B 20 TO
00:15:25.357 --> 00:15:27.192
21, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND FIRST
00:15:27.259 --> 00:15:29.194
GO TO LINE 67. YOUR LINE IS
00:15:29.261 --> 00:15:33.732
OPEN. JACK TILTON GUILLORY CITY
00:15:33.799 --> 00:15:39.305
COUNCIL MEMBER IN SUPPORT. NEXT.
00:15:39.371 --> 00:15:40.506
WHETHER THE LINE 105 PLEASE GO
00:15:40.572 --> 00:15:44.943
AHEAD. THIS IS ADAM SOUTH. THEY
00:15:45.010 --> 00:15:46.812
ME SPORT OF MAYBE 20 TO 21.
00:15:46.879 --> 00:15:52.351
THANK YOU. NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:15:52.418 --> 00:15:56.055
38, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
00:15:56.121 --> 00:15:58.123
LISA DAN'S WITH FREMONT FOR
00:15:58.190 --> 00:15:59.258
EVERYONE, AND WE SUPPORT 22 21.
00:15:59.325 --> 00:16:03.762
THANK YOU. NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:16:03.829 --> 00:16:09.268
NUMBER EIGHT. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:16:09.335 --> 00:16:10.502
MY NAME IS BILL RAFFLE NUMBER
00:16:10.569 --> 00:16:13.272
RESIDENTS. OF SEPARATE CISCO,
00:16:13.339 --> 00:16:17.576
FORMERLY OF MORAN. I'M DRAWING
00:16:17.643 --> 00:16:19.345
AND SUPPORT OF SPORT OF THIS
00:16:19.411 --> 00:16:25.617
BILL. FOR THE FOR THE
00:16:25.684 --> 00:16:26.819
CONSERVATIVE CATION STREAMLINING
00:16:26.885 --> 00:16:30.222
UP 80 YEARS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:16:30.289 --> 00:16:31.924
OPINION. 80 YEARS. WE'RE JUST
00:16:31.990 --> 00:16:34.126
TAKING OUR JUST TAKING NAMES AND
00:16:34.193 --> 00:16:35.294
IDENTIFICATIONS AT THIS POINT.
00:16:35.361 --> 00:16:39.765
THANK YOU. NEXT. PLEASE GO TO
00:16:39.832 --> 00:16:41.667
LINE FIFTH LINE. 58, PLEASE GO
00:16:41.734 --> 00:16:45.738
AHEAD. YES THIS IS MELISSA CASEY
00:16:45.804 --> 00:16:47.673
ON FULLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS
00:16:47.740 --> 00:16:50.876
MEASURE. THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO
00:16:50.943 --> 00:16:58.317
TO LINE 14. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
00:16:58.384 --> 00:17:00.686
ALISON SHOWER CALLING FROM LOS
00:17:00.753 --> 00:17:03.689
ANGELES, UM, CALLING, UM TO
00:17:03.756 --> 00:17:04.857
HAPPEN MYSELF AND HOLLYWOOD
00:17:04.923 --> 00:17:09.962
FORWARD, A GROUP OF OVER 30.
00:17:10.028 --> 00:17:13.031
INDIVIDUALS SERVICE PROVIDERS
00:17:13.098 --> 00:17:15.801
AND CHURCHES. IT'S A BAD GROUP
00:17:15.868 --> 00:17:18.370
OF PEOPLE WERE IN SUPPORT OF THE
00:17:18.437 --> 00:17:19.538
SELF. THANKS SO MUCH. HAVE A
00:17:19.605 --> 00:17:22.674
GREAT DAY. THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO
00:17:22.741 --> 00:17:26.979
TO LINE 96. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:17:27.045 --> 00:17:28.213
SO THAT THE CALIFORNIA INDIAN
00:17:28.280 --> 00:17:32.217
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:17:32.284 --> 00:17:34.253
AND WE GO TO LINE 78. YOUR LINE
00:17:34.319 --> 00:17:37.990
IS OPEN. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
00:17:38.056 --> 00:17:39.224
MEMBERS JORDAN GRIMES ON BEHALF
00:17:39.291 --> 00:17:40.225
OF PENINSULA FOR EVERYONE AND
00:17:40.292 --> 00:17:41.260
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY
00:17:41.326 --> 00:17:45.330
MUCH. AND MADAM CHAIR. NO
00:17:45.397 --> 00:17:46.999
FURTHER COMMENTS IN Q. VERY
00:17:47.065 --> 00:17:48.700
GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:17:48.767 --> 00:17:49.601
OPPOSITION. I HAVE NO LEAD
00:17:49.668 --> 00:17:51.303
OPPOSITION WITNESS IDENTIFIED.
00:17:51.370 --> 00:17:52.504
LET'S SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN
00:17:52.571 --> 00:17:56.341
ROOM 2100. SEEING NONE WILL MOVE
00:17:56.408 --> 00:17:58.544
ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
00:17:58.610 --> 00:18:00.078
COULD YOU QUEUE UP ANY
00:18:00.145 --> 00:18:01.547
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:18:01.613 --> 00:18:03.282
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF A B 20 TO
00:18:03.348 --> 00:18:06.618
21? AND PLEASE PRESS 10 CR AND
00:18:06.685 --> 00:18:09.822
OPPOSITION OF ÁP 20 TO 21. IN
00:18:09.888 --> 00:18:11.757
ONE MOMENT, WE HAVE ONE LINE. I
00:18:11.824 --> 00:18:25.737
MEAN,
00:18:25.804 --> 00:18:27.806
AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 1 43,
00:18:27.873 --> 00:18:31.443
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR
00:18:31.510 --> 00:18:33.378
MEMBERS CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS IN
00:18:33.445 --> 00:18:38.717
OPPOSITION. NEXT WE'LL GO TO
00:18:38.784 --> 00:18:43.255
LINE AT 1 42, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:18:43.322 --> 00:18:44.490
MY NAME IS THAT TIMOTHY
00:18:44.556 --> 00:18:45.991
JEFFERIES INTERNATIONAL BROTHER
00:18:46.058 --> 00:18:48.460
OF LOCAL LARGE NINE
00:18:48.527 --> 00:18:49.995
REPRESENTATIVES IN CALIFORNIA. I
00:18:50.062 --> 00:18:51.964
STAND IN OPPOSITION WITH THE
00:18:52.030 --> 00:18:53.165
BUILDING TRADES TO A CITY BUILT
00:18:53.232 --> 00:18:58.737
2011. WRONG BILL, BUT BUT WELL,
00:18:58.804 --> 00:19:01.106
WE'LL KEEP YOU ON THE LINE. AND
00:19:01.173 --> 00:19:02.341
IF YOU'D LIKE TO TESTIFY WHEN
00:19:02.407 --> 00:19:03.609
THAT BILL COMES UP, THAT WOULD
00:19:03.675 --> 00:19:07.045
BE GREAT. THIS IS 20 TO 21. AND
00:19:07.112 --> 00:19:09.081
WE'LL GO TO LINE 1 47, PLEASE GO
00:19:09.147 --> 00:19:13.685
AHEAD. HI JAKE PRICE ON BEHALF
00:19:13.752 --> 00:19:15.454
OF THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION
00:19:15.521 --> 00:19:19.758
, CALLING IN SUPPORT OF A B 2221
00:19:19.825 --> 00:19:21.393
SORRY. I BELIEVE I MET THE TIME
00:19:21.460 --> 00:19:22.961
FOR SUPPORT EARLIER. GOT IT.
00:19:23.028 --> 00:19:26.832
NEXT, PLEASE. A MAN OF CARE. NO
00:19:26.899 --> 00:19:28.834
FURTHER COMMENTS AND QUÊ VERY
00:19:28.901 --> 00:19:30.736
GOOD. UM WHAT THAT CONCLUDES OUR
00:19:30.802 --> 00:19:35.107
OPPOSITION. THE COMMITTEE HAS NO
00:19:35.173 --> 00:19:38.110
NO QUESTIONS. SO WE WILL. WE
00:19:38.176 --> 00:19:40.045
WILL ALLOW YOU TO FINISH AND
00:19:40.112 --> 00:19:41.713
THEN WE WILL TAKE UP THE VOTE AT
00:19:41.780 --> 00:19:43.549
A LATER TIME JUST MEMBERS ARE
00:19:43.615 --> 00:19:44.816
HERE WOULD APPRECIATE EIGHT AND
00:19:44.883 --> 00:19:46.718
I VOTE. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU SO
00:19:46.785 --> 00:19:55.460
MUCH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ARAMBULA.
00:19:55.527 --> 00:19:57.462
WE'RE GOING TO TAKE UP FILE ITEM
00:19:57.529 --> 00:20:02.501
NUMBER 14, WHICH IS A B 2030.
00:20:02.568 --> 00:20:03.569
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:20:03.635 --> 00:20:08.006
SENATOR. MAYBE 2030 WILL PUT
00:20:08.073 --> 00:20:09.541
VOTERS FIRST BY REMOVING THE
00:20:09.608 --> 00:20:11.610
INHERENT CONFLICT OF INTEREST
00:20:11.677 --> 00:20:13.845
WHEN BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ARE
00:20:13.912 --> 00:20:14.880
INVOLVED IN DECISIONS IN
00:20:14.947 --> 00:20:18.317
REDRAWING POLITICAL LINES. A B
00:20:18.383 --> 00:20:20.719
2030 WILL ESTABLISH THE COUNTY
00:20:20.786 --> 00:20:22.821
OF FRESNO CITIZENS REDISTRICTING
00:20:22.888 --> 00:20:24.990
COMMISSION TO DRAW DISTRICT
00:20:25.057 --> 00:20:26.191
BOUNDARIES FOR THE FRESNO COUNTY
00:20:26.258 --> 00:20:28.727
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS.
00:20:28.794 --> 00:20:29.695
GERRYMANDERING ALLOWS ELECTED
00:20:29.761 --> 00:20:33.966
OFFICIALS. TO CHOOSE THE VOTERS
00:20:34.032 --> 00:20:36.268
IN THEIR DISTRICTS, RATHER THAN
00:20:36.335 --> 00:20:37.736
ALLOWING THE VOTERS TO ELECT
00:20:37.803 --> 00:20:39.137
THEIR REPRESENTATIVES IN FAIR
00:20:39.204 --> 00:20:42.474
AND LAWFUL ELECTIONS. THIS
00:20:42.541 --> 00:20:44.810
PRACTICE OF GERRYMANDERING HAS
00:20:44.876 --> 00:20:46.878
DISENFRANCHISED UNDERREPRESENTED
00:20:46.945 --> 00:20:49.014
COMMUNITIES, INCLUDING
00:20:49.081 --> 00:20:50.582
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR AND HAS
00:20:50.649 --> 00:20:53.719
DILUTED THEIR VOTING POWER. MAPS
00:20:53.785 --> 00:20:55.754
DRAWN BY LOCAL COMMUNITY GROUP,
00:20:55.821 --> 00:20:57.456
WHICH TOOK INTO ACCOUNT THE
00:20:57.522 --> 00:21:00.659
GROWING DEMOGRAPHICS OF LATINO
00:21:00.726 --> 00:21:02.761
COMMUNITY MEMBERS, AS REFLECTED
00:21:02.828 --> 00:21:04.863
IN THE CENSUS WAS STRUCK DOWN BY
00:21:04.930 --> 00:21:06.632
THE FRESNO COUNTY BOARD OF
00:21:06.698 --> 00:21:09.134
SUPERVISORS. THE DISTRICT MAP,
00:21:09.201 --> 00:21:10.669
WHICH WAS ADOPTED BY THE
00:21:10.736 --> 00:21:11.803
PRESIDENT COUNTY BOARD OF
00:21:11.870 --> 00:21:13.505
SUPERVISORS WAS MET WITH
00:21:13.572 --> 00:21:17.009
WIDESPREAD LOCAL OPPOSITION. A
00:21:17.075 --> 00:21:18.510
CITIZEN'S REDISTRICTING
00:21:18.577 --> 00:21:20.112
COMMISSION WILL PUT THE
00:21:20.178 --> 00:21:22.014
RESPONSIBILITY OF DRAWING
00:21:22.080 --> 00:21:24.216
POLITICAL LINES IN THE HANDS OF
00:21:24.282 --> 00:21:24.816
AN INDEPENDENT GROUP OF FRESNO
00:21:24.883 --> 00:21:29.287
COUNTY VOTERS. ENSURING THAT THE
00:21:29.354 --> 00:21:31.156
VOTE VOICES IN OUR COMMUNITY ARE
00:21:31.223 --> 00:21:33.692
HEARD. I HAVE THE FOLLOWING
00:21:33.759 --> 00:21:35.260
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT OF A B
00:21:35.327 --> 00:21:38.230
2030 TODAY. CAMILA CHAVEZ, THE
00:21:38.296 --> 00:21:39.331
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
00:21:39.398 --> 00:21:41.133
DELORES WORTH THAT FOUNDATION.
00:21:41.199 --> 00:21:45.003
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WELCOME
00:21:45.070 --> 00:21:46.238
MISS CHAVEZ, AND THE FLOOR IS
00:21:46.304 --> 00:21:51.476
YOURS. GOOD MORNING, THE LOTUS
00:21:51.543 --> 00:21:53.078
FOUNDATION ESTABLISHED THE
00:21:53.145 --> 00:21:55.147
EQUITABLE MAPS COALITION THAT
00:21:55.213 --> 00:21:56.715
EMPOWERED 5000 RESIDENTS TO
00:21:56.782 --> 00:21:57.816
ENGAGE IN THE REDISTRICTING
00:21:57.883 --> 00:21:58.784
PROCESS AT ALL LEVELS OF
00:21:58.850 --> 00:22:00.352
GOVERNMENT. DURING LAST YEAR'S
00:22:00.419 --> 00:22:03.989
REDISTRICTING PROCESS. BANKNOTE
00:22:04.056 --> 00:22:05.290
COUNTIES ADVISORY COMMISSION
00:22:05.357 --> 00:22:06.391
MEMBERS WERE APPOINTED BY
00:22:06.458 --> 00:22:09.661
SUPERVISORS PROVIDE COVER FOR
00:22:09.728 --> 00:22:11.563
THE ADOPTION OF A MAP THAT
00:22:11.630 --> 00:22:12.764
PROTECTED THEIR INTEREST. THE
00:22:12.831 --> 00:22:14.966
COMMISSION DID NOT IN ANY WAY
00:22:15.033 --> 00:22:16.468
REFLECT THE ACTUAL DEMOGRAPHICS
00:22:16.535 --> 00:22:18.637
OR POLITICAL DIVERSITY OF FRESNO
00:22:18.704 --> 00:22:21.773
COUNTY, WHICH IS OVER 70% PEOPLE
00:22:21.840 --> 00:22:24.376
OF COLOR AND DEMOCRATS HOLD A
00:22:24.443 --> 00:22:25.577
SEVEN POINT VOTER REGISTRATION
00:22:25.644 --> 00:22:28.013
ADVANTAGE. THE COMMISSION HAD
00:22:28.080 --> 00:22:31.049
NOT ONE AFRICAN AMERICAN ARAB
00:22:31.116 --> 00:22:33.919
MOM OR PUNJABI MEMBER, AND ONLY
00:22:33.985 --> 00:22:34.720
THREE LATINOS, EVEN THOUGH
00:22:34.786 --> 00:22:36.588
LATINOS ARE OVER 50% OF THE
00:22:36.655 --> 00:22:38.657
POPULATION. EIGHT OF THE 11
00:22:38.724 --> 00:22:40.625
COMMISSIONERS, WHERE REPUBLICANS
00:22:40.692 --> 00:22:43.028
, INCLUDING TWO OF THE THREE
00:22:43.095 --> 00:22:44.196
LATINO MEMBERS, A RATIO THAT IS
00:22:44.262 --> 00:22:46.264
OUT OF ALIGNMENT WITH THE
00:22:46.331 --> 00:22:47.566
PERCENTAGE OF REPUBLICAN VOTERS.
00:22:47.632 --> 00:22:48.600
THE COMMISSION'S PROCESS WAS
00:22:48.667 --> 00:22:50.969
EQUALLY UNREPRESENTATIVE.
00:22:51.036 --> 00:22:52.637
HUNDREDS OF FRESNO COUNTY
00:22:52.704 --> 00:22:54.272
RESIDENTS, INCLUDING RECORD
00:22:54.339 --> 00:22:56.374
NUMBERS OF CONSTITUTIONALLY
00:22:56.441 --> 00:22:58.510
PROTECTED CLASS MEMBERS
00:22:58.577 --> 00:23:00.078
ADVOCATED FOR EQUITABLE MAPS FOR
00:23:00.145 --> 00:23:01.713
MONTHS, WITH NO REMOTE OPTION
00:23:01.780 --> 00:23:04.616
OFFERED, PEOPLE MUST WORK.
00:23:04.683 --> 00:23:06.118
ARRANGE CHILDCARE AND
00:23:06.184 --> 00:23:08.520
TRANSPORTATION, SOME TRAVELING
00:23:08.587 --> 00:23:09.721
VERY FAR AT RISK TO THEMSELVES
00:23:09.788 --> 00:23:12.457
IN THE PANDEMIC. DURING ONE
00:23:12.524 --> 00:23:14.793
HEARING FARMWORKERS WERE OPENLY
00:23:14.860 --> 00:23:16.228
HARASSED BY WHITE SUPREMACISTS
00:23:16.294 --> 00:23:18.463
AND THE COUNTY DID NOTHING. WE
00:23:18.530 --> 00:23:19.898
EVEN HAD TO PROVIDE UR OWN
00:23:19.965 --> 00:23:20.899
SPANISH INTERPRETATIONS COULD BE
00:23:20.966 --> 00:23:23.568
HURT. THE COMMISSION COMPLETELY
00:23:23.635 --> 00:23:24.936
IGNORED THE TESTIMONIES OF
00:23:25.003 --> 00:23:26.538
HUNDREDS OF RESIDENTS AND
00:23:26.605 --> 00:23:28.006
RECOMMENDED THAT ADOPTION OF A
00:23:28.073 --> 00:23:30.275
REPUBLICAN OPERATIVE MAP A MAP
00:23:30.342 --> 00:23:32.811
THAT HADN'T EVEN BEEN VETTED.
00:23:32.878 --> 00:23:34.146
YET BY THEIR DEMOGRAPHER
00:23:34.212 --> 00:23:36.348
CONSULTANT BECAUSE BY THE
00:23:36.414 --> 00:23:38.116
AUTHOR'S OWN ADMISSION, HE HAD
00:23:38.183 --> 00:23:39.785
TO MAKE ADJUSTMENTS TO IT
00:23:39.851 --> 00:23:41.653
BECAUSE QUOTE THE DATA WAS WRONG
00:23:41.720 --> 00:23:42.888
WHEN THE PROCESS MOVED TO THE
00:23:42.954 --> 00:23:46.057
BOARD ITSELF. WE KNEW THAT THE
00:23:46.124 --> 00:23:47.626
FIX WAS IN WHEN ONLY THE CHAIR
00:23:47.692 --> 00:23:49.394
OF THE FRESNO REPUBLICAN PARTY
00:23:49.461 --> 00:23:51.396
AND ANOTHER REPUBLICANS SHOWED
00:23:51.463 --> 00:23:52.764
UP TO SUPPORT THEIR MAP. ALL
00:23:52.831 --> 00:23:53.365
OTHER SPEAKERS OVERWHELMINGLY
00:23:53.431 --> 00:23:57.068
OPPOSED THIS MAP. IN THE RECENT
00:23:57.135 --> 00:23:59.437
PRIMARY ELECTION, NO MATTER
00:23:59.504 --> 00:24:01.006
PROVED AS CORRUPT AS THE PROCESS
00:24:01.072 --> 00:24:03.141
THAT CREATED IT WHEN IT FAILED
00:24:03.208 --> 00:24:05.210
TO ELECT CANDIDATES OF CHOICE
00:24:05.277 --> 00:24:06.344
FOR PROTECTED CLASSES. IT'S TIME
00:24:06.411 --> 00:24:09.381
FOR THE PEOPLE OF FRESNO COUNTY.
00:24:09.447 --> 00:24:10.715
TO HAVE A TRULY INDEPENDENT
00:24:10.782 --> 00:24:13.084
REDISTRICTING COMMISSIONS. WE
00:24:13.151 --> 00:24:15.120
THINK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ARAMBULA
00:24:15.187 --> 00:24:16.688
AND THIS COMMITTEE FOR YOUR
00:24:16.755 --> 00:24:18.890
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE AND
00:24:18.957 --> 00:24:20.125
RESPECTFULLY ASKED FOR YOUR EYE
00:24:20.192 --> 00:24:23.061
VOTES ON A V 2030. THANK YOU
00:24:23.128 --> 00:24:24.996
VERY MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
00:24:25.063 --> 00:24:27.232
ON TO TESTIMONY AND SUPPORT. IS
00:24:27.299 --> 00:24:29.334
THERE ANYBODY IN ROOM 2100 THAT
00:24:29.401 --> 00:24:31.002
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT.
00:24:31.069 --> 00:24:33.271
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:24:33.338 --> 00:24:33.839
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IF YOU
00:24:33.905 --> 00:24:35.707
COULD PLEASE OPEN THE LINES OF
00:24:35.774 --> 00:24:36.808
INDIVIDUALS THAT WANT TO SPEAK
00:24:36.875 --> 00:24:42.480
ON BEHALF. IN SUPPORT OF 2030.
00:24:42.547 --> 00:24:44.115
CERTAINLY AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO
00:24:44.182 --> 00:24:47.219
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 2030 01
00:24:47.285 --> 00:24:58.997
MOMENT, PLEASE. AND ONCE AGAIN
00:24:59.064 --> 00:24:59.898
FOR THE PUBLIC COMMENTS. YOU'D
00:24:59.965 --> 00:25:02.500
LIKE TO SPEAK IN FAVOR OF. MAYBE
00:25:02.567 --> 00:25:04.102
2030 PLEASE PRESS 10 AND WE'LL
00:25:04.169 --> 00:25:08.139
GO TO LINE 42 YEAR LINE IS OPEN.
00:25:08.206 --> 00:25:09.741
HELLO MY NAME IS JULIE CELL
00:25:09.808 --> 00:25:11.142
RODRIGUEZ WITH THE LEAGUE OF
00:25:11.209 --> 00:25:12.844
WOMEN VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA AND
00:25:12.911 --> 00:25:13.979
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS, BILL.
00:25:14.045 --> 00:25:20.285
THANK YOU. NEXT A LITTLE LINE
00:25:20.352 --> 00:25:24.155
57, PLEASE GO AHEAD. TÌM MY NAME
00:25:24.222 --> 00:25:26.124
IS KEISHA THOMAS, TRUSTEE FOR
00:25:26.191 --> 00:25:28.526
FRESNO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
00:25:28.593 --> 00:25:30.128
I AM A RESIDENT OF FRESNO COUNTY
00:25:30.195 --> 00:25:32.664
AND I AM IN AGREEMENT WITH THIS.
00:25:32.731 --> 00:25:34.266
PLEASE MAKE A YES VOTE. THANK
00:25:34.332 --> 00:25:39.537
YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT GO TO LINE
00:25:39.604 --> 00:25:44.242
79. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
00:25:44.309 --> 00:25:45.710
MORNING. SHARON MEMBERS AND MY
00:25:45.777 --> 00:25:47.779
NAME IS JULIANA HUNNICUTT. AND
00:25:47.846 --> 00:25:49.347
I'M CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:25:49.414 --> 00:25:52.217
A B 2030 ON BEHALF OF THE LOTUS
00:25:52.284 --> 00:25:53.184
FOUNDATION. THANK YOU. THANK
00:25:53.251 --> 00:25:57.155
YOU. AND WE'LL GO THROUGH LINE
00:25:57.222 --> 00:26:01.993
OF 1 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD. AMBER
00:26:02.060 --> 00:26:03.094
SO HOW WAS TRENTON? TAKE THEM
00:26:03.161 --> 00:26:03.962
SHOPPING ON BEHALF OF
00:26:04.029 --> 00:26:04.996
CALIFORNIA. ENTIRE VOTERS
00:26:05.063 --> 00:26:10.201
SUPPORT THANK YOU. AND WE'LL GO
00:26:10.268 --> 00:26:14.706
TO LINE 63. PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE
00:26:14.773 --> 00:26:16.741
MONEY AND MY NAME IS OLGA LÀ
00:26:16.808 --> 00:26:20.478
ORGANIZED AND I'M JUST WAS A B.
00:26:20.545 --> 00:26:28.687
2030 THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO TO
00:26:28.753 --> 00:26:32.190
LINE AT 1 16, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:26:32.257 --> 00:26:33.558
HI GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:26:33.625 --> 00:26:35.660
ANGEL AND PRESIDENT AND I'M
00:26:35.727 --> 00:26:37.262
STRONGLY SUPPORTIVE OF A B 2030.
00:26:37.329 --> 00:26:42.233
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL GO TO
00:26:42.300 --> 00:26:47.605
LINES 65, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
00:26:47.672 --> 00:26:49.741
MY NAME IS PASSED THE MONTGOMERY
00:26:49.808 --> 00:26:51.142
I'M A RESIDENT OF PRESIDENT
00:26:51.209 --> 00:26:54.145
COUNTY AND I'M CALLING IN
00:26:54.212 --> 00:26:54.646
SUPPORT FROM PARENTHOOD
00:26:54.713 --> 00:26:56.982
MODERNISTIC. THANK YOU VERY
00:26:57.048 --> 00:27:02.754
MUCH. AND MADAM CHAIR. NO
00:27:02.821 --> 00:27:05.223
FURTHER LINES IN COMMENT. VERY
00:27:05.290 --> 00:27:07.292
GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:27:07.359 --> 00:27:08.727
OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO LEAD
00:27:08.793 --> 00:27:10.762
OPPOSITION IDENTIFIED SO WE'LL
00:27:10.829 --> 00:27:11.997
SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM
00:27:12.063 --> 00:27:13.765
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:27:13.832 --> 00:27:15.300
AN OPPOSITION, SAYING NONE WILL
00:27:15.367 --> 00:27:16.534
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:27:16.601 --> 00:27:18.803
LINE. IF YOU COULD OPEN ANY LINE
00:27:18.870 --> 00:27:20.138
OF AN INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUALS
00:27:20.205 --> 00:27:21.006
THAT WANT TO SPEAK IN
00:27:21.072 --> 00:27:22.807
OPPOSITION. THAT WOULD BE GREAT,
00:27:22.874 --> 00:27:24.743
MR MODERATOR. CERTAINLY AND IF
00:27:24.809 --> 00:27:27.078
YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:27:27.145 --> 00:27:28.380
OPPOSITION TO A B 2030 PLEASE
00:27:28.446 --> 00:27:31.950
PRESS 10. IN ONE MOMENT. WE HAVE
00:27:32.017 --> 00:27:39.224
ONE LINE COMING IN. AND WE WILL
00:27:39.290 --> 00:27:43.595
GO TO LINE 69, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:27:43.661 --> 00:27:45.030
GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
00:27:45.096 --> 00:27:45.864
MEMBERS, JEFF NEAL WITH THE
00:27:45.930 --> 00:27:47.032
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
00:27:47.098 --> 00:27:48.633
COUNTIES RESPECTFULLY. THANK YOU
00:27:48.700 --> 00:27:53.838
VERY MUCH. AND WE DID HAVE ONE
00:27:53.905 --> 00:27:55.807
MORE. COME IN. WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:27:55.874 --> 00:27:58.476
1 74, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:27:58.543 --> 00:27:59.744
MORNING SHARING MEMBERS. RUTH
00:27:59.811 --> 00:28:00.979
FASTENED WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:28:01.046 --> 00:28:03.048
ACTION APOLOGIES. I HAD A
00:28:03.114 --> 00:28:05.183
TECHNICAL DIFFICULTY, BUT WE ARE
00:28:05.250 --> 00:28:06.384
ALSO IN SUPPORT OF THE FILM.
00:28:06.451 --> 00:28:09.621
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND MAN OF
00:28:09.687 --> 00:28:10.688
CARE. NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND
00:28:10.755 --> 00:28:12.690
YOU VERY GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO
00:28:12.757 --> 00:28:14.225
BRING THE DISCUSSION TO THE
00:28:14.292 --> 00:28:15.260
COMMITTEE. ARE THERE ANY
00:28:15.326 --> 00:28:17.695
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS CONCERNS.
00:28:17.762 --> 00:28:20.198
SAYING NONE. WE WILL ALLOW YOU
00:28:20.265 --> 00:28:21.800
TO CONCLUDE THANK YOU FOR THE
00:28:21.866 --> 00:28:23.635
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AND WHEN
00:28:23.701 --> 00:28:25.070
THE TIME IS APPROPRIATE, I
00:28:25.136 --> 00:28:26.304
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I VOTE.
00:28:26.371 --> 00:28:27.639
THANK YOU SO MUCH. I REALLY
00:28:27.705 --> 00:28:28.640
APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU FOR
00:28:28.706 --> 00:28:31.142
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. GOING TO
00:28:31.209 --> 00:28:33.711
MOVE ON TO OUR SPECIAL ITEM OR
00:28:33.778 --> 00:28:36.648
SPECIAL ORDER. FILE ITEM NUMBER
00:28:36.714 --> 00:28:38.583
ONE, WHICH IS A B 2011 BY
00:28:38.650 --> 00:28:39.651
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WIDTHS AND WHAT
00:28:39.717 --> 00:28:44.189
WE'RE GOING TO DO. ON THIS ONE
00:28:44.255 --> 00:28:46.424
IS WE WILL TAKE THE SUPPORT IN
00:28:46.491 --> 00:28:47.892
THE ROOM AND THEN WE'LL DO THE
00:28:47.959 --> 00:28:49.727
OPPOSITION IN THE ROOM AND THEN
00:28:49.794 --> 00:28:50.728
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE PHONE
00:28:50.795 --> 00:28:52.664
TESTIMONY. I THINK IT'S A LITTLE
00:28:52.730 --> 00:28:53.731
BIT QUICKER AND WILL ALLOW
00:28:53.798 --> 00:28:55.366
INDIVIDUALS TO TESTIFY AND
00:28:55.433 --> 00:28:58.169
SUPPORT OR IN OPPOSITION, YOU
00:28:58.236 --> 00:29:00.405
KNOW, JUST GET ON THE PHONE AND
00:29:00.472 --> 00:29:01.573
LET'S SEE HOW MANY PEOPLE WE
00:29:01.639 --> 00:29:04.742
CAN. WE CAN GET THROUGH THE OUR
00:29:04.809 --> 00:29:07.112
AGENDA IS EXTREMELY FULL TODAY
00:29:07.178 --> 00:29:08.780
AND WE HAVE SESSION AT THE END
00:29:08.847 --> 00:29:10.882
OF THE DAY. AND WE'RE THE THREAT
00:29:10.949 --> 00:29:12.550
IS WE COME BACK TOMORROW TO
00:29:12.617 --> 00:29:13.952
FINISH UP IF WE DON'T GET DONE
00:29:14.018 --> 00:29:14.919
TODAY, SO I DON'T THINK
00:29:14.986 --> 00:29:16.020
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ARE GOING TO
00:29:16.087 --> 00:29:17.722
WANT TO COME BACK TOMORROW TO
00:29:17.789 --> 00:29:18.990
PRESENT THEIR BILLS. SO WE'RE
00:29:19.057 --> 00:29:20.592
TRYING TO BE REALLY EFFICIENT
00:29:20.658 --> 00:29:21.025
WITH THEIR TIME. SO
00:29:21.092 --> 00:29:21.860
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ALEX. THANK YOU
00:29:21.926 --> 00:29:24.496
SO MUCH FOR PRESENTING THIS BILL
00:29:24.562 --> 00:29:26.197
, AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO A GOOD
00:29:26.264 --> 00:29:27.332
DISCUSSION. THANK YOU, MADAM
00:29:27.398 --> 00:29:29.033
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
00:29:29.100 --> 00:29:30.368
COMMITTEE WHO'S HERE APPRECIATE
00:29:30.435 --> 00:29:31.569
YOU'RE BEING HERE. I'M HERE TO
00:29:31.636 --> 00:29:32.770
TALK ABOUT A B 2011 THE
00:29:32.837 --> 00:29:34.139
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND HIGH
00:29:34.205 --> 00:29:36.040
ROADS JOB ACT, A BILL SPONSORED
00:29:36.107 --> 00:29:37.609
BY THE CARPENTERS UNION AND
00:29:37.675 --> 00:29:39.077
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPERS
00:29:39.144 --> 00:29:40.612
AND SUPPORTED BY A WIDE ARRAY OF
00:29:40.678 --> 00:29:41.579
LABOR ORGANIZATIONS. BUSINESS
00:29:41.646 --> 00:29:43.515
GROUPS, ENVIRONMENTALISTS.
00:29:43.581 --> 00:29:45.884
TRANSPORTATION ADVOCATES PRO
00:29:45.950 --> 00:29:46.651
HOUSING ORGANIZATIONS, CIVIC
00:29:46.718 --> 00:29:47.519
GROUPS, FAITH BASED
00:29:47.585 --> 00:29:50.155
ORGANIZATIONS AND OTHERS. BEFORE
00:29:50.221 --> 00:29:51.789
I TELL YOU ABOUT THE DETAILS OF
00:29:51.856 --> 00:29:53.825
THE BILL, I WANT TO TELL YOU
00:29:53.892 --> 00:29:56.161
WHY. I THINK THIS BILL IS SO
00:29:56.227 --> 00:29:57.128
IMPORTANT. WE HAVE A HOUSING
00:29:57.195 --> 00:29:58.062
CRISIS AS WE ALL KNOW, THAT'S
00:29:58.129 --> 00:29:59.531
OUT OF CONTROL. HUNDREDS OF
00:29:59.597 --> 00:30:00.698
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE ARE SLEEPING
00:30:00.765 --> 00:30:01.799
ON OUR STREETS. 80% OF LOW
00:30:01.866 --> 00:30:04.002
INCOME TENANTS CANNOT CAN ONLY
00:30:04.068 --> 00:30:04.903
PAY FOR THEIR RENT IF THEY
00:30:04.969 --> 00:30:05.870
SACRIFICE OTHER BASIC NEEDS LIKE
00:30:05.937 --> 00:30:07.138
FOOD, EDUCATION, HEALTH CARE.
00:30:07.205 --> 00:30:09.107
THE MEDIAN PRICE OF BUYING A
00:30:09.174 --> 00:30:10.742
HOUSE IN CALIFORNIA IS NOW OVER
00:30:10.808 --> 00:30:11.809
$800,000, MEANING THE AMERICAN
00:30:11.876 --> 00:30:13.378
DREAM OF HOME OWNERSHIP. IS ONLY
00:30:13.444 --> 00:30:14.512
AVAILABLE TO THE RICHEST
00:30:14.579 --> 00:30:17.382
CALIFORNIANS. POLLING
00:30:17.448 --> 00:30:18.449
CONTINUOUSLY SHOWS THAT HOUSING
00:30:18.516 --> 00:30:20.218
AND HOMELESSNESS OR THE TOP TWO
00:30:20.285 --> 00:30:22.020
CONCERNS IN CALIFORNIA. AT THE
00:30:22.086 --> 00:30:24.155
SAME TIME, WE NEED TO BUILD OUR
00:30:24.222 --> 00:30:24.889
CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE BACK IN
00:30:24.956 --> 00:30:25.857
THE SEVENTIES, EIGHTIES AND
00:30:25.924 --> 00:30:26.925
NINETIES, WE REGULARLY BUILT
00:30:26.991 --> 00:30:29.027
MORE THAN 200,000 UNITS A YEAR.
00:30:29.093 --> 00:30:31.196
PECKED AND THOSE THOSE WERE HIGH
00:30:31.262 --> 00:30:32.297
WAGE JOBS THAT WERE AN
00:30:32.363 --> 00:30:33.364
INCREDIBLE PATHWAY TO MIDDLE
00:30:33.431 --> 00:30:35.066
CLASS LIFE. NOW WE REGULARLY
00:30:35.133 --> 00:30:36.734
BUILD FEWER THAN 100,000 UNITS A
00:30:36.801 --> 00:30:38.736
YEAR AND UNLESS YOU ARE
00:30:38.803 --> 00:30:39.804
FORTUNATE ENOUGH TO BE WORKING
00:30:39.871 --> 00:30:41.039
ON A PUBLIC WORK OR UNIONIZED
00:30:41.105 --> 00:30:42.941
CONSTRUCTION JOB IT'S LIKELY YOU
00:30:43.007 --> 00:30:44.876
ARE WORKING IN LOW WAGES AND
00:30:44.943 --> 00:30:45.376
POTENTIALLY EXPLOITATIVE
00:30:45.443 --> 00:30:46.678
CONDITIONS FRIENDLY. WE HAVE TO
00:30:46.744 --> 00:30:49.214
TALK ABOUT HOW THIS RELATES TO
00:30:49.280 --> 00:30:50.782
CLIMATE CHANGE AND IS THE MOTHER
00:30:50.848 --> 00:30:51.849
OF TWO YOUNG DAUGHTERS. I'M
00:30:51.916 --> 00:30:52.984
TERRIFIED OF WHAT THE FUTURE
00:30:53.051 --> 00:30:54.686
HOLDS FOR THEM. I NEED TO BE
00:30:54.752 --> 00:30:56.588
ABLE TO LOOK THEM IN THE EYE AND
00:30:56.654 --> 00:30:57.789
TELL THEM AS SOMEONE IN A
00:30:57.855 --> 00:30:59.924
POSITION OF LEADERSHIP THAT IS
00:30:59.991 --> 00:31:01.392
ABLE TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE THAT I
00:31:01.459 --> 00:31:03.161
DID EVERYTHING WITHIN MY POWER
00:31:03.228 --> 00:31:04.362
WHEN THERE WAS STILL TIME TO DO
00:31:04.429 --> 00:31:05.697
SO AND AS CHAIR OF HOUSING
00:31:05.763 --> 00:31:06.898
COMMITTEE, WHAT I CAN DO IS
00:31:06.965 --> 00:31:08.032
INTRODUCE BOLD LEGISLATION.
00:31:08.099 --> 00:31:08.733
FORCING NECESSARY BUT
00:31:08.800 --> 00:31:09.500
UNCOMFORTABLE CONVERSATIONS TO
00:31:09.567 --> 00:31:10.702
PROMOTE THE HOUSING OF THE
00:31:10.768 --> 00:31:11.703
FUTURE HOUSING YOUR JOBS AND
00:31:11.769 --> 00:31:13.037
TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING THAT
00:31:13.104 --> 00:31:15.039
ALLOWS US TO SLASH OUR CARBON
00:31:15.106 --> 00:31:16.174
EMISSIONS. SO I WANT TO TALK
00:31:16.241 --> 00:31:17.709
ABOUT WHAT THIS BILL DOES. THIS
00:31:17.775 --> 00:31:18.943
BILL AIMS TO ADDRESS ALL THESE
00:31:19.010 --> 00:31:20.645
PROBLEMS AND MAKING IT MUCH
00:31:20.712 --> 00:31:21.813
EASIER TO BUILD. HOUSING AT
00:31:21.879 --> 00:31:23.248
SCALE IN CLIMATE FRIENDLY
00:31:23.314 --> 00:31:25.383
LOCATIONS USING HIGH ROAD LABOR
00:31:25.450 --> 00:31:26.117
STANDARDS THAT PROTECT AND
00:31:26.184 --> 00:31:27.819
UPLIFT OUR EXISTING WORKERS,
00:31:27.885 --> 00:31:29.153
WHILE SIMULTANEOUSLY GROWING A
00:31:29.220 --> 00:31:30.421
WHOLE NEW GENERATION OF HIGHLY
00:31:30.488 --> 00:31:32.624
TRAINED MEN AND WOMEN. HOW ARE
00:31:32.690 --> 00:31:34.759
WE GOING TO DO THAT BY MAKING
00:31:34.826 --> 00:31:35.660
AFFORDABLE AND MIXED INCOME,
00:31:35.727 --> 00:31:37.095
MULTI FAMILY HOUSING A USE BY
00:31:37.161 --> 00:31:39.130
RIGHT AND AREAS THAT ARE
00:31:39.197 --> 00:31:39.731
APPROPRIATE FOR HOUSING, BUT
00:31:39.797 --> 00:31:41.065
WHERE IT IS CURRENTLY DIFFICULT
00:31:41.132 --> 00:31:43.668
OR IMPOSSIBLE TO BUILD. BY BEING
00:31:43.735 --> 00:31:44.636
BY RIGHT DEVELOPERS CAN MOVE
00:31:44.702 --> 00:31:46.037
FORWARD WITHOUT THE SUBSTANTIAL
00:31:46.104 --> 00:31:46.971
AMOUNT OF RED TAPE THAT
00:31:47.038 --> 00:31:48.806
INCREASES COSTS AND KILLS MONEY,
00:31:48.873 --> 00:31:50.875
VIABLE PROJECTS. WE'RE TAKING
00:31:50.942 --> 00:31:51.876
THE COST SAVINGS OF ALLOWING
00:31:51.943 --> 00:31:53.945
HOUSING BY RIGHT AND GIVING IT
00:31:54.012 --> 00:31:54.712
BACK IN THE FORM OF MORE
00:31:54.779 --> 00:31:55.847
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND BETTER
00:31:55.913 --> 00:31:56.914
PAY FOR THE CONSTRUCTION
00:31:56.981 --> 00:31:59.017
WORKFORCE. FOR 100% AFFORDABLE
00:31:59.083 --> 00:32:00.351
HOUSING PROJECTS. BRINGING IN
00:32:00.418 --> 00:32:02.153
THE COST MEANS MAKING OUR PUBLIC
00:32:02.220 --> 00:32:04.289
MONIES GO FARTHER. FOR ALL THE
00:32:04.355 --> 00:32:05.790
PROJECTS WERE REQUIRING THAT 15%
00:32:05.857 --> 00:32:07.825
OF THE UNITS WOULD NEED TO BE
00:32:07.892 --> 00:32:08.893
AFFORDABLE TO LOWER INCOME
00:32:08.960 --> 00:32:09.961
HOUSEHOLDS OR 30% MODERATE
00:32:10.028 --> 00:32:12.030
INCOME FOR HOMEOWNERSHIP. THIS
00:32:12.096 --> 00:32:13.998
REQUIREMENT COULD RESULT IN AN
00:32:14.065 --> 00:32:15.066
EXTRAORDINARY AMOUNT OF NEW
00:32:15.133 --> 00:32:15.566
AFFORDABLE UNITS WITHOUT
00:32:15.633 --> 00:32:18.169
REQUIRING PUBLIC SUBSIDY. AS FOR
00:32:18.236 --> 00:32:19.804
WHERE THE HOUSING CAN GO, IT
00:32:19.871 --> 00:32:20.638
WOULD NEED TO BE LOCATED IN
00:32:20.705 --> 00:32:22.073
AREAS THAT CURRENTLY ALLOW
00:32:22.140 --> 00:32:23.041
RETAIL OFFICE BUILDINGS AND
00:32:23.107 --> 00:32:24.876
PARKING LOTS. FURTHERMORE MIXED
00:32:24.942 --> 00:32:26.244
INCOME HOUSING WOULD BE LIMITED
00:32:26.311 --> 00:32:27.178
TO COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS.
00:32:27.245 --> 00:32:28.146
BASICALLY THOSE STREETS THAT IN
00:32:28.212 --> 00:32:30.882
MOST CITIES ARE LINED WITH STRIP
00:32:30.948 --> 00:32:32.684
MALLS AND LOTS OF PARKING THE
00:32:32.750 --> 00:32:34.986
PERFECT PLACE FOR MORE HOUSING.
00:32:35.053 --> 00:32:37.221
BECAUSE THE SITE NEEDS TO ALLOW
00:32:37.288 --> 00:32:38.523
COMMERCIAL USE. WE ARE DIRECTING
00:32:38.589 --> 00:32:40.258
NEW HOUSING AWAY FROM SINGLE
00:32:40.325 --> 00:32:41.059
FAMILY NEIGHBORHOODS AND BECAUSE
00:32:41.125 --> 00:32:42.593
THE BECAUSE THE ECONOMICS OF
00:32:42.660 --> 00:32:43.961
DEVELOPMENT MEAN THIS WILL ONLY
00:32:44.028 --> 00:32:45.363
WORK ON UNDERUTILIZED COMMERCIAL
00:32:45.430 --> 00:32:46.364
SITES. THE BILL WILL FACILITATE
00:32:46.431 --> 00:32:49.100
THEIR TRANSPORTATION. FROM
00:32:49.167 --> 00:32:50.735
RUNDOWN STRIP MALLS TO VIBRANT,
00:32:50.802 --> 00:32:51.302
WALKABLE NEIGHBORHOODS WHILE
00:32:51.369 --> 00:32:52.003
INCREASING TAX REVENUE FOR
00:32:52.070 --> 00:32:54.872
CITIES. FRIENDLY I WANT TO TALK
00:32:54.939 --> 00:32:56.774
ABOUT THE LABOR STANDARDS IN
00:32:56.841 --> 00:32:57.875
THIS BILL, WHICH ARE DESIGNATED
00:32:57.942 --> 00:32:58.810
TO CREATE TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:32:58.876 --> 00:33:00.278
HIGH ROAD HIGHLY PAID
00:33:00.345 --> 00:33:02.246
CONSTRUCTION JOBS. ALL WORKERS
00:33:02.313 --> 00:33:03.781
WILL BE PAID PREVAILING WAGE,
00:33:03.848 --> 00:33:04.982
ENABLING OUR HARD WORKING WOMEN
00:33:05.049 --> 00:33:06.884
AND MEN TO LEAD A MIDDLE CLASS
00:33:06.951 --> 00:33:08.052
LIFE. ALL WORKERS WILL BE
00:33:08.119 --> 00:33:10.288
PROTECTED FROM WAGE THEFT BY THE
00:33:10.355 --> 00:33:11.356
STRONGEST ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS
00:33:11.422 --> 00:33:13.791
ON RECORD NATIONALLY. IF A
00:33:13.858 --> 00:33:15.960
PROJECT IS 50 UNITS OR MORE,
00:33:16.027 --> 00:33:17.295
THEY WOULD NEED TO BRING IN
00:33:17.362 --> 00:33:19.030
APPRENTICES TO HELP BUILD THE
00:33:19.097 --> 00:33:20.131
PROJECT AND GROW THE NEXT
00:33:20.198 --> 00:33:21.032
GENERATION OF SKILLED
00:33:21.099 --> 00:33:22.567
CRAFTSPEOPLE. A RISING TIDE
00:33:22.633 --> 00:33:24.502
LIFTS ALL BOATS. MAYBE 2011 IS A
00:33:24.569 --> 00:33:26.404
BOLD BILL. BUT IT'S ALSO I
00:33:26.471 --> 00:33:29.006
BELIEVE IN VERY PRACTICAL BILL.
00:33:29.073 --> 00:33:31.509
WE NEED TO, BUT WE ALSO NEED
00:33:31.576 --> 00:33:32.610
BOLD BILLS BECAUSE WE HAVE A
00:33:32.677 --> 00:33:33.711
HOUSING CRISIS THAT MERITS BOLD
00:33:33.778 --> 00:33:35.513
ACTION. WE NEED TO DO EVERYTHING
00:33:35.580 --> 00:33:38.116
POSSIBLE TO KEEP HOUSING ARE
00:33:38.182 --> 00:33:39.751
HOMELESS, KEEP OUR TENANTS IN
00:33:39.817 --> 00:33:40.818
PLACE AND KEEP PROPERTY OWNERS
00:33:40.885 --> 00:33:42.387
FROM FORECLOSING, BUT THE ONLY
00:33:42.453 --> 00:33:43.788
WAY OUT OF THIS CRISIS IS TO
00:33:43.855 --> 00:33:44.756
ENSURE THAT THERE IS A
00:33:44.822 --> 00:33:46.057
FUNCTIONING MARKET PLACE WHERE
00:33:46.124 --> 00:33:47.425
HOUSING IS ABUNDANT AND
00:33:47.492 --> 00:33:47.992
AFFORDABLE, AND PEOPLE HAVE
00:33:48.059 --> 00:33:49.460
OPTIONS ABOUT WHERE TO LIVE,
00:33:49.527 --> 00:33:50.795
WHERE PEOPLE WITH A RANGE OF
00:33:50.862 --> 00:33:51.996
INCOMES FROM ALL KINDS OF
00:33:52.063 --> 00:33:53.731
BACKGROUNDS CAN PUT DOWN ROOTS.
00:33:53.798 --> 00:33:55.066
AND SEE THERE. WEALTH GROW. AND
00:33:55.133 --> 00:33:57.168
WHERE WE DO THIS ALL BY HELPING
00:33:57.235 --> 00:33:59.137
ADDRESS CLIMATE CHANGE. WITH ME
00:33:59.203 --> 00:34:00.571
HERE TO TESTIFY AS MARINA Y IN
00:34:00.638 --> 00:34:02.707
VP FOR GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS FOR
00:34:02.774 --> 00:34:03.541
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
00:34:03.608 --> 00:34:05.009
CONSORTIUM, AND J. BRADSHAW
00:34:05.076 --> 00:34:06.043
EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF THE
00:34:06.110 --> 00:34:06.677
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CARPENTER'S
00:34:06.744 --> 00:34:10.081
UNION. VERY GOOD. WELCOME THANK
00:34:10.148 --> 00:34:11.516
YOU. GOOD MORNING, CHAIR AND
00:34:11.582 --> 00:34:13.651
MEMBER MARINA WHITE WITH THE
00:34:13.718 --> 00:34:14.285
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM.
00:34:14.352 --> 00:34:15.653
WE ARE NONPARTISAN ADVOCATE FOR
00:34:15.720 --> 00:34:16.821
THE PRODUCTION AND PRESERVATION
00:34:16.888 --> 00:34:17.855
OF LOW AND MODERATE INCOME
00:34:17.922 --> 00:34:19.891
HOUSING. AND COMMITTED TO THE
00:34:19.957 --> 00:34:21.192
GOAL THAT EVERY CALIFORNIAN HAVE
00:34:21.259 --> 00:34:22.894
A SAFE, AFFORDABLE PLACE TO CALL
00:34:22.960 --> 00:34:24.662
HOME. OVER THE PAST TWO YEARS,
00:34:24.729 --> 00:34:26.130
CHC HAS WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH
00:34:26.197 --> 00:34:27.665
MEMBERS AND OTHER STAKEHOLDERS
00:34:27.732 --> 00:34:28.800
TO TRY TO DEVELOP SOLUTIONS THAT
00:34:28.866 --> 00:34:30.668
MATCH THE SCALE OF OUR STATE
00:34:30.735 --> 00:34:32.270
HOUSING CHALLENGES, AND WE HAVE
00:34:32.336 --> 00:34:33.404
REPEATEDLY COMMITTED TO FINDING
00:34:33.471 --> 00:34:34.539
COLLABORATIVE SOLUTIONS THAT
00:34:34.605 --> 00:34:36.174
THAT SIGNIFICANTLY EXPAND ACCESS
00:34:36.240 --> 00:34:38.109
TO WELL PAYING JOBS FOR WORKERS
00:34:38.176 --> 00:34:40.478
ALL OVER THE STATE. WELL, AT THE
00:34:40.545 --> 00:34:41.579
SAME TIME, INCREASING HOUSING
00:34:41.646 --> 00:34:42.680
PRODUCTION FOR THE STATE'S MOST
00:34:42.747 --> 00:34:44.615
VULNERABLE. AND THEN THESE
00:34:44.682 --> 00:34:45.716
CONVERSATIONS, WE HAVE NOTED TWO
00:34:45.783 --> 00:34:47.018
CRITICAL ISSUES FOR AFFORDABLE
00:34:47.084 --> 00:34:48.252
HOUSING PROVIDERS. WE BELIEVE
00:34:48.319 --> 00:34:49.821
THAT DEVELOPMENTS RECEIVING NEW
00:34:49.887 --> 00:34:51.656
LAND USE BENEFITS LIKE MAYBE
00:34:51.722 --> 00:34:53.658
2011 SHOULD CREATE STEADY, WELL
00:34:53.724 --> 00:34:55.526
PAYING JOBS AND HELP BUILD THE
00:34:55.593 --> 00:34:56.561
MIDDLE CLASS CONSTRUCTION
00:34:56.627 --> 00:34:58.296
WORKFORCE IN EVERY COMMUNITY. WE
00:34:58.362 --> 00:34:59.831
ALSO RECOGNIZE, THOUGH THE
00:34:59.897 --> 00:35:01.899
PROJECTS CAN'T MOVE FORWARD IF
00:35:01.966 --> 00:35:02.467
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS ARE NOT
00:35:02.533 --> 00:35:04.035
AVAILABLE, A GROWING CHALLENGE
00:35:04.101 --> 00:35:05.903
IN MANY PARTS OF THE STATE AND A
00:35:05.970 --> 00:35:06.971
REAL ISSUE WITH SKILL AND
00:35:07.038 --> 00:35:07.805
TRAINED WORKFORCE REQUIREMENTS.
00:35:07.872 --> 00:35:09.440
RECENT LEGISLATION WITH THESE
00:35:09.507 --> 00:35:11.609
REQUIREMENTS HAVE NOT BEEN
00:35:11.676 --> 00:35:13.110
SUCCESSFULLY UTILIZED WITHOUT
00:35:13.177 --> 00:35:14.011
BECAUSE THEY DO NOT INCLUDE THE
00:35:14.078 --> 00:35:16.347
RIGHT OFF RAMPS, UM, NECESSARY
00:35:16.414 --> 00:35:18.349
TO REMOVE THE RISK THAT AT THE
00:35:18.416 --> 00:35:20.985
TIME OF ENTITLEMENT UM, WHEN
00:35:21.052 --> 00:35:22.887
THEY ARE USING THOSE TOOLS THAT
00:35:22.954 --> 00:35:24.055
THE WORKFORCE WILL EXIST WHEN
00:35:24.121 --> 00:35:26.324
THEY COME TO CONSTRUCTION AND IN
00:35:26.390 --> 00:35:28.359
THAT, IN OUR VIEW, A B 2011
00:35:28.426 --> 00:35:29.060
FINALLY STRIKES THE RIGHT
00:35:29.126 --> 00:35:31.796
BALANCE. AND I'M HONORED TO BE
00:35:31.863 --> 00:35:33.064
HERE TODAY AS A CO SPONSOR OF
00:35:33.130 --> 00:35:34.298
THIS LEGISLATION, MAYBE 2011
00:35:34.365 --> 00:35:35.800
PAIRS THE ABILITY TO BUILD
00:35:35.867 --> 00:35:36.767
HOUSING ON UNDERLIES
00:35:36.834 --> 00:35:38.169
UNDERUTILIZED COMMERCIAL SITES
00:35:38.236 --> 00:35:39.670
WITH STRONG LABOR STANDARDS THAT
00:35:39.737 --> 00:35:41.405
ENSURE ALL CONSTRUCTION WORKERS
00:35:41.472 --> 00:35:42.406
EARN PREVAILING WAGES AND
00:35:42.473 --> 00:35:43.708
RECEIVE HEALTH BENEFITS. AND
00:35:43.774 --> 00:35:48.112
ALSO INCREASES. UM THE
00:35:48.179 --> 00:35:49.480
ACCOUNTABILITY TO ENSURE THAT
00:35:49.547 --> 00:35:50.748
THEY'RE ACTUALLY PAYING THEIR
00:35:50.815 --> 00:35:51.782
WORKERS WHAT THEY ARE SAYING
00:35:51.849 --> 00:35:53.150
THEY'RE PAYING. THE BILL ALSO
00:35:53.217 --> 00:35:54.652
INCLUDES WORKABLE OFF RAMPS. IT
00:35:54.719 --> 00:35:55.786
GIVES WORKERS IN STATE APPROVED
00:35:55.853 --> 00:35:56.854
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS, THE
00:35:56.921 --> 00:35:59.290
FIRST SHOT OF THESE JOBS, BUT IF
00:35:59.357 --> 00:36:00.725
AND WHEN THEY ARE NOT READILY
00:36:00.791 --> 00:36:02.193
AVAILABLE. IT ALLOWS THESE
00:36:02.260 --> 00:36:04.128
PROJECTS TO STILL MOVE FORWARD
00:36:04.195 --> 00:36:05.830
AND AVOID THE COMPLICATION THAT
00:36:05.897 --> 00:36:07.532
I DESCRIBED A MOMENT AGO. THIS
00:36:07.598 --> 00:36:08.900
BILL HAS THE POTENTIAL TO OPEN
00:36:08.966 --> 00:36:10.201
THOUSANDS OF NEW SITES,
00:36:10.268 --> 00:36:11.202
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND TO
00:36:11.269 --> 00:36:12.103
RAPIDLY ACCELERATE HOUSING
00:36:12.169 --> 00:36:13.938
PRODUCTION AT ALL INCOME LEVELS,
00:36:14.005 --> 00:36:14.906
BUT PARTICULARLY FOR LOWER
00:36:14.972 --> 00:36:16.974
INCOME CALIFORNIANS. IT IS
00:36:17.041 --> 00:36:17.909
CRITICAL TO HELPING HIS CLOTHES
00:36:17.975 --> 00:36:19.410
ARE TERMINUS AFFORDABILITY GAP
00:36:19.477 --> 00:36:20.845
AND ENSURE THAT LOWER INCOME
00:36:20.912 --> 00:36:22.413
CALIFORNIANS HAVE ACCESS TO SAFE
00:36:22.480 --> 00:36:23.614
, STABLE, AFFORDABLE PLACES TO
00:36:23.681 --> 00:36:24.782
CALL HOME. AND FOR THESE
00:36:24.849 --> 00:36:25.917
REASONS, WHY ARE YOUR SUPPORT
00:36:25.983 --> 00:36:35.092
TODAY? THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GOOD
00:36:35.159 --> 00:36:36.527
MORNING, MADAM CHAIR MEMBER
00:36:36.594 --> 00:36:37.828
NIELSEN. IN ORDER TO BE HERE
00:36:37.895 --> 00:36:39.263
TODAY, J. BRADSHAW EXECUTIVE
00:36:39.330 --> 00:36:40.364
OFFICER NOR CAL CARPENTER'S
00:36:40.431 --> 00:36:42.099
UNION REPRESENTED 38,000
00:36:42.166 --> 00:36:43.901
HARDWORKING MEMBERS OUT THERE
00:36:43.968 --> 00:36:45.503
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA ALSO BRING
00:36:45.570 --> 00:36:46.904
GREETINGS FROM MY COUNTERPART
00:36:46.971 --> 00:36:48.172
AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA FROM THE
00:36:48.239 --> 00:36:49.206
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL COUNCIL, PETE
00:36:49.273 --> 00:36:51.676
RODRIGUEZ. WITH NEARLY 60,000
00:36:51.742 --> 00:36:54.045
HARDWORKING MEN AND WOMEN IN THE
00:36:54.111 --> 00:36:55.413
SOUTHWEST, WERE IN STRONG
00:36:55.479 --> 00:36:57.014
SUPPORT AND PROUD TO BE A CO
00:36:57.081 --> 00:37:00.518
AUTHOR FOR A B 2011 PRIMARILY
00:37:00.585 --> 00:37:01.652
AND JUST TO ECHO SOME OF THE
00:37:01.719 --> 00:37:03.521
POINTS ALREADY MADE, BUT TO
00:37:03.588 --> 00:37:04.622
DRILL INTO IT, YOU KNOW FOR
00:37:04.689 --> 00:37:05.556
WORKING CLASS FOLKS IN
00:37:05.623 --> 00:37:07.391
CALIFORNIAWHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
00:37:07.458 --> 00:37:09.360
HOUSING CRISIS, IT IS CRUSHING I
00:37:09.427 --> 00:37:09.927
JUST STARTED MEMBERSHIP THE
00:37:09.994 --> 00:37:10.962
WORKERS OVERALL, THE LACK OF
00:37:11.028 --> 00:37:13.397
HOUSING PRODUCTION FOR A NUMBER
00:37:13.464 --> 00:37:14.031
OF YEARS REALLY DECADES HAS LED
00:37:14.098 --> 00:37:15.733
TO A CRISIS FOR THE WORKING
00:37:15.800 --> 00:37:17.969
CLASS. AH BECAUSE FOLKS HAVE TO
00:37:18.035 --> 00:37:20.171
MOVE FURTHER AND FURTHER AWAY
00:37:20.237 --> 00:37:20.972
FROM THE JOB CENTERS, AND THAT'S
00:37:21.038 --> 00:37:21.973
ALSO LED TO A TRANSPORTATION
00:37:22.039 --> 00:37:23.174
CRISIS, CHILDCARE AND
00:37:23.240 --> 00:37:24.008
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS AND
00:37:24.075 --> 00:37:25.276
THROUGHOUT THE CONSTRUCTION
00:37:25.343 --> 00:37:26.777
INDUSTRY, OVERALL, ESCALATING
00:37:26.844 --> 00:37:28.279
SUICIDE RATES AND ADDICTION
00:37:28.346 --> 00:37:30.915
PROBLEMS, SO IT'S REAL ISSUES
00:37:30.982 --> 00:37:32.116
THAT WORKERS FACE EVERYDAY
00:37:32.183 --> 00:37:33.317
ROOTED IN THE LACK OF HOUSING
00:37:33.384 --> 00:37:35.386
PRODUCTION. BOTH AFFORDABLE
00:37:35.453 --> 00:37:36.420
INCLUSIONARY AND, OF COURSE,
00:37:36.487 --> 00:37:37.054
WORKFORCE HOUSING, SO WE
00:37:37.121 --> 00:37:38.789
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS AS A
00:37:38.856 --> 00:37:41.692
SOLUTION. UM WHEN YOU LOOK AT
00:37:41.759 --> 00:37:43.995
WHAT IS NEEDED OVERALL THROUGH
00:37:44.061 --> 00:37:46.097
THE STATE BEING CONSERVATIVE,
00:37:46.163 --> 00:37:47.031
TWO MILLION MORE HOUSING UNITS
00:37:47.098 --> 00:37:49.066
ARE NEEDED IMMEDIATELY, WITH
00:37:49.133 --> 00:37:49.600
OVER HALF OF THOSE IN THE
00:37:49.667 --> 00:37:50.635
AFFORDABLE CATEGORY, AND THE
00:37:50.701 --> 00:37:51.636
PRODUCTION IS JUST NOT
00:37:51.702 --> 00:37:54.739
HAPPENING. RIGHT NOW. WE BELIEVE
00:37:54.805 --> 00:37:55.773
BY RIGHT WITH THESE CONDITIONS
00:37:55.840 --> 00:37:57.842
IS THE RIGHT WAY TO GO. WE HAVE
00:37:57.908 --> 00:37:59.043
A MOMENT IN TIME, BOTH MARKET
00:37:59.110 --> 00:38:01.078
RATE AFFORDABLE AND THE
00:38:01.145 --> 00:38:02.179
CARPENTERS UNION. OTHER LABOR
00:38:02.246 --> 00:38:03.247
ORGANIZATIONS ARE IN ALIGNMENT
00:38:03.314 --> 00:38:04.548
TOWARDS SOLUTIONS. AND WE NEED
00:38:04.615 --> 00:38:07.218
TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THAT, AND
00:38:07.284 --> 00:38:08.052
WE'RE ASKING FOR YOUR SUPPORT
00:38:08.119 --> 00:38:09.587
FOR THAT. WHEN THERE HAS BEEN A
00:38:09.654 --> 00:38:11.956
BIT OF A DEBATE, GOING BACK AND
00:38:12.023 --> 00:38:12.490
FORTH BETWEEN THESE LABOR
00:38:12.556 --> 00:38:13.457
STANDARDS AND SKILLED AND
00:38:13.524 --> 00:38:15.026
TRAINED LABOR STANDARDS, NOT
00:38:15.092 --> 00:38:16.494
HERE TO ENGAGE AND FIGHT THE
00:38:16.560 --> 00:38:17.762
TRADE UNIONS, BUT JUST TO LAY
00:38:17.828 --> 00:38:19.764
THE FACTS OUT AS WE SEE HIM. AND
00:38:19.830 --> 00:38:22.600
ARE BACKED UP BY THE DATA. IF
00:38:22.667 --> 00:38:24.101
YOU TAKE A 20 YEAR RUN OF
00:38:24.168 --> 00:38:24.769
GRADUATES OF APPRENTICESHIP
00:38:24.835 --> 00:38:27.038
PROGRAMS, LEADING 2020 OR 2000
00:38:27.104 --> 00:38:32.510
TO 2021. 122,000 GRADUATES OF
00:38:32.576 --> 00:38:33.778
FOUR OR FIVE YEAR APPRENTICESHIP
00:38:33.844 --> 00:38:35.513
PROGRAMS ACROSS TRADES IF YOU
00:38:35.579 --> 00:38:36.781
TAKE A CONSERVATIVE ESTIMATE OF
00:38:36.847 --> 00:38:38.449
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS IN
00:38:38.516 --> 00:38:41.152
CALIFORNIA AT 800,000 THE DATA
00:38:41.218 --> 00:38:42.386
SAYS IT PRETTY CLEARLY THERE'S
00:38:42.453 --> 00:38:43.387
NOT A SKILLED AND TRAINED
00:38:43.454 --> 00:38:45.356
WORKFORCE, WHICH REQUIRES FOR
00:38:45.423 --> 00:38:46.791
THE JOURNEY LEVEL TO EITHER
00:38:46.857 --> 00:38:48.292
GRADUATE OR PROGRAM OR HAVE
00:38:48.359 --> 00:38:50.261
HOURS THAT ARE TRACKABLE 5 TO
00:38:50.327 --> 00:38:51.996
8000. SO IT'S A WORKFORCE IN
00:38:52.063 --> 00:38:53.097
HOUSING. OVERALL IN CALIFORNIA,
00:38:53.164 --> 00:38:57.201
IT'S 90. THE CARBON SEEN
00:38:57.268 --> 00:38:59.236
STRONGLY SUPPORTS THIS BECAUSE
00:38:59.303 --> 00:39:00.304
THOSE WORKERS ARE HYPER
00:39:00.371 --> 00:39:01.706
EXPLOITED, DRIVEN INTO THE
00:39:01.772 --> 00:39:03.741
UNDERGROUND ECONOMY AND FRANKLY
00:39:03.808 --> 00:39:05.643
NEED TO RAISE AND LIFT UP
00:39:05.710 --> 00:39:07.211
MAJORITY OF THAT WORKFORCE RIGHT
00:39:07.278 --> 00:39:08.212
NOW. LATINO WORKFORCE IMMIGRANT
00:39:08.279 --> 00:39:11.215
WORKFORCE, IT'S HYPER EXPLOITED.
00:39:11.282 --> 00:39:12.383
AS A LABOR ORGANIZATION
00:39:12.450 --> 00:39:15.286
STATEWIDE. BOTH COUNCILS WE ARE
00:39:15.352 --> 00:39:16.420
INTERESTED IN THOSE FOLKS
00:39:16.487 --> 00:39:19.290
HELPING THEMSELVES PULL UP RIGHT
00:39:19.356 --> 00:39:21.358
AND THEN IT'S OUR JOB AS LABOR
00:39:21.425 --> 00:39:21.992
ORGANIZATIONS GOT AND ORGANIZE
00:39:22.059 --> 00:39:23.627
THOSE FOLKS AND WE WILL INTEND
00:39:23.694 --> 00:39:25.696
TO DO THAT. THE PROVISIONS HERE
00:39:25.763 --> 00:39:27.531
WE BELIEVE ATOP ACCOMPLISHED
00:39:27.598 --> 00:39:29.133
BOTH TASKS, GET HOUSING
00:39:29.200 --> 00:39:31.268
PRODUCTION GOING AND CREATE GOOD
00:39:31.335 --> 00:39:33.537
, HIGH LEVEL JOBS THAT WE WILL
00:39:33.604 --> 00:39:34.805
WELCOME THESE FOLKS IN OUR
00:39:34.872 --> 00:39:35.873
ORGANIZATION. MEANWHILE, WE HAVE
00:39:35.940 --> 00:39:37.742
TO PULL THEM OUT OF THE
00:39:37.808 --> 00:39:38.542
UNDERGROUND ECONOMY. AND YOU
00:39:38.609 --> 00:39:40.010
WERE ASKING FOR YOUR HELP TO DO
00:39:40.077 --> 00:39:43.013
THAT. TODAY WE ARE NOT ASKING
00:39:43.080 --> 00:39:44.648
FOR YOU TO RUN ORGANIZATION OR
00:39:44.715 --> 00:39:45.449
CREATE AN EXCLUSIONARY LABOR
00:39:45.516 --> 00:39:46.951
STANDARD TO DO ARE ORGANIZING
00:39:47.017 --> 00:39:48.953
FOR US. WE INTEND TO TAKE CARE
00:39:49.019 --> 00:39:51.388
OF THAT PART OF IT. UH LOOKING
00:39:51.455 --> 00:39:52.957
AT THE TRACK RECORD, WHETHER IT
00:39:53.023 --> 00:39:55.426
BE ASKED ME 35 OR A B 73 THAT
00:39:55.493 --> 00:39:56.093
HAD SKILLED AND TRAINED
00:39:56.160 --> 00:39:58.462
PROVISIONS? NO UH SKILLED AND
00:39:58.529 --> 00:40:00.765
TRAINED PROJECTS WERE BUILT.
00:40:00.831 --> 00:40:02.133
UNDER THOSE BILLS. THEY WEREN'T
00:40:02.199 --> 00:40:03.601
BAD BILLS. GREAT INTENTION. I
00:40:03.667 --> 00:40:05.736
THINK SIMILAR INTENTION TO US
00:40:05.803 --> 00:40:08.239
ATTACK ON THAT. BUT WHEN YOU
00:40:08.305 --> 00:40:09.707
HAVE A WORKFORCE THAT IS 90% NON
00:40:09.774 --> 00:40:10.975
ORGANIZED, WE DO NOT WANT TO
00:40:11.041 --> 00:40:12.777
EXCLUDE THOSE WORKERS. WE WANT
00:40:12.843 --> 00:40:14.044
TO PULL THEM UP. HELP OUR
00:40:14.111 --> 00:40:15.112
CURRENT MEMBERSHIP AND HELP THEM
00:40:15.179 --> 00:40:18.616
AS WELL. AH A COUPLE OF THINGS
00:40:18.682 --> 00:40:20.317
TO JUST LOOKING AT THE ANALYSIS.
00:40:20.384 --> 00:40:22.119
I THINK THERE MAY BE A LITTLE
00:40:22.186 --> 00:40:22.720
BIT OF CONFUSION. ONE OF THE
00:40:22.787 --> 00:40:24.688
QUOTES WAS THAT DEVELOPERS ARE
00:40:24.755 --> 00:40:26.423
LIKELY TO USE 82,011 ARABIA, SB
00:40:26.490 --> 00:40:27.625
SIX BECAUSE THE LESS COSTLY
00:40:27.691 --> 00:40:30.861
LABOR PROVISIONS PROVIDING WAGES
00:40:30.928 --> 00:40:32.196
ACROSS BOTH SKILLED AND TRAINED
00:40:32.263 --> 00:40:33.230
PROVISIONS, AND OUR LABOR
00:40:33.297 --> 00:40:35.699
PROVISIONS ARE THE SAME. IT'S
00:40:35.766 --> 00:40:37.034
REALLY A MATTER OF THE WORKFORCE
00:40:37.101 --> 00:40:38.669
AVAILABILITY. AND CAN WE
00:40:38.736 --> 00:40:39.904
ACTUALLY HELP THE CURRENT
00:40:39.970 --> 00:40:41.405
WORKFORCE COME IN AND CONTINUE
00:40:41.472 --> 00:40:43.174
TO BUILD THOSE PROJECTS ALONG
00:40:43.240 --> 00:40:45.109
WITH OUR CURRENT MEMBERSHIP? WE
00:40:45.176 --> 00:40:46.143
HAVE THE STRONGEST LABOR
00:40:46.210 --> 00:40:47.111
ENFORCEMENT STANDARDS OF ANY
00:40:47.178 --> 00:40:49.880
BILLS. NATIONWIDE BUILT INTO
00:40:49.947 --> 00:40:51.282
THIS WITH LABOR MANAGEMENT
00:40:51.348 --> 00:40:53.617
COMMITTEE WRITES TO ENFORCE, SO
00:40:53.684 --> 00:40:55.019
JUST WANT TO POINT THOSE
00:40:55.085 --> 00:40:55.853
ELEMENTS OUT THAT STRONG LABOR
00:40:55.920 --> 00:40:56.987
STANDARDS, BUT IT'S LABOR
00:40:57.054 --> 00:40:58.055
STANDARDS THAT DEVELOPERS WHO
00:40:58.122 --> 00:40:59.990
ACTUALLY USE AND GET HOUSING
00:41:00.057 --> 00:41:01.892
PRODUCTION GOING, SO WE STRONGLY
00:41:01.959 --> 00:41:04.328
URGE YOU TO SUPPORT THIS. WE
00:41:04.395 --> 00:41:05.396
APPRECIATE BEING HERE TODAY AND
00:41:05.462 --> 00:41:06.764
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK
00:41:06.831 --> 00:41:08.766
YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
00:41:08.833 --> 00:41:10.434
. NEXT, WE'RE GOING TO GO ON TO
00:41:10.501 --> 00:41:11.902
THE LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESS THAT
00:41:11.969 --> 00:41:13.838
IS LISTED ERIN LAHANE FROM THE
00:41:13.904 --> 00:41:15.039
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
00:41:15.105 --> 00:41:18.275
TRADES COUNCIL WELCOME. THANK
00:41:18.342 --> 00:41:19.343
YOU, SENATOR CABALLERO, SENATOR
00:41:19.410 --> 00:41:24.548
NIELSEN. ALL THE EMPTY SEATS. I
00:41:24.615 --> 00:41:26.016
DO HAVE TO SAY THAT THE MISSING
00:41:26.083 --> 00:41:28.052
MEMBERS WERE WITH ME LAST NIGHT
00:41:28.118 --> 00:41:30.020
UNTIL 11 O'CLOCK IN JUDICIARY,
00:41:30.087 --> 00:41:32.022
SO, UM, AND THEY'RE PRESENTING
00:41:32.089 --> 00:41:34.425
THEIR BILLS IN ASSEMBLY. SO YEAH
00:41:34.491 --> 00:41:36.660
. LAST COUPLE OF WEEKS. UM GOOD
00:41:36.727 --> 00:41:38.028
MORNING. MY NAME IS AARON LAHANE
00:41:38.095 --> 00:41:39.697
AND I PROUDLY BE APPEARED BEFORE
00:41:39.763 --> 00:41:41.465
YOU ON BEHALF OF THE NEARLY HALF
00:41:41.532 --> 00:41:42.766
A MILLION MEMBERS OF THE STATE
00:41:42.833 --> 00:41:43.934
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
00:41:44.001 --> 00:41:46.036
COUNCIL. OF CALIFORNIA AND
00:41:46.103 --> 00:41:47.104
CONTINUED OPPOSITION TO A B
00:41:47.171 --> 00:41:51.008
2011. OUR LETTER CLEARLY STATES
00:41:51.075 --> 00:41:52.643
OUT THE REASONS WHY THE BUILDING
00:41:52.710 --> 00:41:54.912
TRADES OPPOSE THIS BILL, LACK OF
00:41:54.979 --> 00:41:56.914
A SUNSET LACK OF ACTUAL
00:41:56.981 --> 00:41:57.848
HEALTHCARE PROTECTIONS THAT
00:41:57.915 --> 00:41:59.717
CAN'T BE SEVERED FROM THE BILL.
00:41:59.783 --> 00:42:00.684
ACTUAL DEFINED TERMS AS
00:42:00.751 --> 00:42:03.954
CUSTOMARY AND LEGISLATION. ALL
00:42:04.021 --> 00:42:04.755
THINGS THAT MAKE OUR TRADE
00:42:04.822 --> 00:42:06.657
SUSPICIOUS OF THE TRUE INTENT,
00:42:06.724 --> 00:42:07.625
INTERESTS AND MOTIVES BEHIND
00:42:07.691 --> 00:42:11.996
THIS BILL. AT THE STATE BUILDING
00:42:12.062 --> 00:42:13.530
TRADES, WE ENGAGE IN LITERALLY
00:42:13.597 --> 00:42:15.966
HUNDREDS OF BILLS EVERY YEAR. WE
00:42:16.033 --> 00:42:18.002
WORK WITH AUTHORS AND STAFF AND
00:42:18.068 --> 00:42:19.103
BOTH HOUSES TO ADDRESS THE
00:42:19.169 --> 00:42:21.872
CONCERNS OF OUR MEMBERS. THE
00:42:21.939 --> 00:42:24.108
OTHER BIG CONCERN WE HAVE WITH
00:42:24.174 --> 00:42:25.809
THIS BILL IS THE PROCESS OR THE
00:42:25.876 --> 00:42:28.812
OR THE LACK THEREOF. ALTHOUGH WE
00:42:28.879 --> 00:42:30.247
WERE WORKING WITH THE OFFERS
00:42:30.314 --> 00:42:31.882
AUTHORS OF THIS BILL ON MANY
00:42:31.949 --> 00:42:33.317
OTHER ISSUES, THIS BILL WAS
00:42:33.384 --> 00:42:35.152
NEVER RAISED WITH THE STATE
00:42:35.219 --> 00:42:36.220
BUILDING TRADES UNTIL THE
00:42:36.287 --> 00:42:37.221
LANGUAGE WAS SUBMITTED TO
00:42:37.288 --> 00:42:38.923
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL. THERE WAS
00:42:38.989 --> 00:42:40.758
NO ATTEMPT TO WORK WITH THE
00:42:40.824 --> 00:42:42.326
STATE BUILDING TRADES. SINCE THE
00:42:42.393 --> 00:42:43.494
BILL HAS BEEN INTRODUCED, WE
00:42:43.560 --> 00:42:44.662
WOULD HAVE HAD MULTIPLE
00:42:44.728 --> 00:42:46.230
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR.
00:42:46.297 --> 00:42:48.265
WE HAVE PROVIDED MULTIPLE
00:42:48.332 --> 00:42:49.833
AMENDMENTS TO ADDRESS THE STATED
00:42:49.900 --> 00:42:50.834
CONCERNS THAT THE DEVELOPER
00:42:50.901 --> 00:42:53.504
SPONSORS AND WE HAVE HEARD
00:42:53.570 --> 00:42:54.405
NOTHING BACK OF THESE WELL
00:42:54.471 --> 00:42:54.939
INTENTIONED AND THOUGHTFUL
00:42:55.005 --> 00:42:58.409
AMENDMENTS. IT REMINDS ME OF THE
00:42:58.475 --> 00:42:59.977
CONVERSATIONS WE HAD JUST LAST
00:43:00.044 --> 00:43:01.378
YEAR WITH THE VERY SAME
00:43:01.445 --> 00:43:03.080
DEVELOPED RESPONSES. WE WERE
00:43:03.147 --> 00:43:05.349
OFFERED SEVERAL AGAIN, WELL
00:43:05.416 --> 00:43:06.283
INTENTIONED AND THOUGHTFUL
00:43:06.350 --> 00:43:08.052
AMENDMENTS THAT AGAIN. WE GOT NO
00:43:08.118 --> 00:43:10.821
RESPONSE ON BUT WE DID GET
00:43:10.888 --> 00:43:11.889
YELLED AT BY THE DEVELOPMENT,
00:43:11.956 --> 00:43:13.324
SAME DEVELOPER SPONSORS ACCUSING
00:43:13.390 --> 00:43:16.327
US OF SEEKING A MONOPOLY AS WE
00:43:16.393 --> 00:43:16.894
MERELY ADVOCATED FOR OURHARD
00:43:16.961 --> 00:43:20.130
WORKING BLUE COLLAR MEMBERSHIP.
00:43:20.197 --> 00:43:21.632
AND SPEAKING OF MONOPOLIES AND
00:43:21.699 --> 00:43:23.133
PROFIT. WE ONLY NEED TO THINK
00:43:23.200 --> 00:43:25.102
BACK TO THE FINANCIAL CRISIS IN
00:43:25.169 --> 00:43:26.837
2000 AND EIGHT TO REMEMBER HOW
00:43:26.904 --> 00:43:29.206
MUCH MONEY IS MADE BY PROFITEERS
00:43:29.273 --> 00:43:30.341
WHENEVER THERE IS A HOUSING
00:43:30.407 --> 00:43:33.377
CRISIS. INCLUDING YOU KNOW THE
00:43:33.444 --> 00:43:34.912
SAME ORGANIZATIONS THAT HAVE
00:43:34.979 --> 00:43:37.214
TESTIFIED IN THE ASSEMBLY WHO
00:43:37.281 --> 00:43:40.217
SAW THEIR SALARIES RISE SHARPLY
00:43:40.284 --> 00:43:41.418
AS OUR MEMBERS LOST THEIR HOMES
00:43:41.485 --> 00:43:45.990
AND THEIR JOBS. A B 2011 IS
00:43:46.056 --> 00:43:48.258
FLAWED. IT WILL GENTRIFY WORKING
00:43:48.325 --> 00:43:49.159
FAMILIES, NEIGHBORHOODS ACROSS
00:43:49.226 --> 00:43:51.996
THE STATE AND ITS BY RIGHT
00:43:52.062 --> 00:43:52.930
DEVELOPMENT AND WILL NOT PROVIDE
00:43:52.997 --> 00:43:54.431
TROOPS WORKER PROTECTIONS FOR
00:43:54.498 --> 00:43:55.499
THE CONSTRUCTION WORKERS NEEDED
00:43:55.566 --> 00:43:57.901
TO BUILD IT. AND IT WILL GREATLY
00:43:57.968 --> 00:43:59.770
ENRICH THE DEVELOPERS. THE SAME
00:43:59.837 --> 00:44:01.872
DEVELOPERS WHO CASHED IN ON THE
00:44:01.939 --> 00:44:03.073
COLLAPSE OF THE HOUSING MARKETS
00:44:03.140 --> 00:44:05.542
IN A WAY AND ON A PERSONAL NOTE
00:44:05.609 --> 00:44:08.012
. I WOULD SAY THAT YOU KNOW, I
00:44:08.078 --> 00:44:08.912
TO MY DAUGHTER IS ACTUALLY HERE
00:44:08.979 --> 00:44:12.016
WITH METODAY. I TOO HAVE THAT
00:44:12.082 --> 00:44:13.250
MORAL OBLIGATION TO SEE HOUSING
00:44:13.317 --> 00:44:16.020
BUILT IN CALIFORNIA. BUT I ALSO
00:44:16.086 --> 00:44:17.955
HAVE A MORAL OBLIGATION WITH THE
00:44:18.022 --> 00:44:19.690
HALF A MILLION MEMBERS OF THE
00:44:19.757 --> 00:44:21.158
STATE BUILDING TRADES TO ENSURE
00:44:21.225 --> 00:44:22.059
THAT BLUE COLLAR WORKERS ARE
00:44:22.126 --> 00:44:25.095
LIFTED UP IN THE PROCESS. ON
00:44:25.162 --> 00:44:26.563
BEHALF OF OUR NEARLY HALF A
00:44:26.630 --> 00:44:28.632
MILLION MEMBERS, INCLUDING MOST
00:44:28.699 --> 00:44:30.134
IMPORTANTLY, ARE 73,000
00:44:30.200 --> 00:44:32.236
APPRENTICES. WE URGE A NO VOTE
00:44:32.302 --> 00:44:34.772
ON A B 2011 THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:44:34.838 --> 00:44:35.773
THANK YOU APPRECIATE YOUR
00:44:35.839 --> 00:44:38.208
COMMENTS TODAY. WE'RE GOING TO
00:44:38.275 --> 00:44:39.643
MOVE ON TO OUR TELECONFERENCE
00:44:39.710 --> 00:44:41.011
LINE. AND MR MONTEREY, WE'RE
00:44:41.078 --> 00:44:42.946
GOING TO DO THINGS A LITTLE BIT
00:44:43.013 --> 00:44:45.849
DIFFERENTLY HERE. UM WELL, I'M
00:44:45.916 --> 00:44:47.985
IS THERE A SECOND THAT WOULD
00:44:48.052 --> 00:44:48.986
LIKE TO SPEAK THAT WAS NOT
00:44:49.053 --> 00:44:51.522
LISTED ON MY THAT'S FINAL. ALLOW
00:44:51.588 --> 00:44:53.090
IT SINCE IT'S EQUAL TIME. THANK
00:44:53.157 --> 00:44:54.258
YOU, MADAM CHAIR. APPRECIATE
00:44:54.324 --> 00:44:55.826
THAT. MITCH STEIGER, WITH THE
00:44:55.893 --> 00:44:57.428
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION,
00:44:57.494 --> 00:44:58.829
STANDING IN SOLIDARITY WITH THE
00:44:58.896 --> 00:45:00.164
STATE BUILDING TRADES COUNCIL
00:45:00.230 --> 00:45:01.331
TODAY IN VERY RESPECTFUL
00:45:01.398 --> 00:45:04.034
OPPOSITION TO 2011. FOR OTHER
00:45:04.101 --> 00:45:05.502
REASONS, PREVIOUSLY STATED, WE
00:45:05.569 --> 00:45:07.204
WOULD ALSO JUST REALLY EMPHASIZE
00:45:07.271 --> 00:45:09.139
THAT OUR CONTINUED OPPOSITION
00:45:09.206 --> 00:45:11.075
STEMS FROM THE CONTINUED LACK OF
00:45:11.141 --> 00:45:12.076
SKILLED AND TRAINED WORKFORCE
00:45:12.142 --> 00:45:14.044
LANGUAGE IN THE BILL. THIS IS
00:45:14.111 --> 00:45:15.512
NOT NEW LANGUAGE. THIS IS NOT
00:45:15.579 --> 00:45:16.980
SOME EXPERIMENTAL MEASURE. THIS
00:45:17.047 --> 00:45:17.714
IS SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN IN
00:45:17.781 --> 00:45:18.816
MANY BILLS THAT HAVE COME
00:45:18.882 --> 00:45:20.751
THROUGH THE LEGISLATURE. WE KNOW
00:45:20.818 --> 00:45:22.719
WHAT IT IS. WE KNOW HOW IT
00:45:22.786 --> 00:45:23.954
WORKS. WE KNOW THAT IT WORKS. WE
00:45:24.021 --> 00:45:25.355
KNOW THAT IT SUPPORTS
00:45:25.422 --> 00:45:26.256
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS. IT
00:45:26.323 --> 00:45:27.157
GIVES WORKERS THE TOOLS THAT
00:45:27.224 --> 00:45:28.659
THEY NEED TO DO THEIR JOB SAFELY
00:45:28.725 --> 00:45:30.461
AND TO BUILD A QUALITY PRODUCT
00:45:30.527 --> 00:45:32.296
FOR THE FIRST TIME. AND SPEAKING
00:45:32.362 --> 00:45:34.398
OF THOSE MEMBERS, NO ONE NEEDS
00:45:34.465 --> 00:45:35.933
AFFORDABLE HOUSING MORE THAN
00:45:35.999 --> 00:45:37.768
THEM JUST HEARD THAT THE MEDIAN
00:45:37.835 --> 00:45:38.902
HOME PRICE IN CALIFORNIA'S CROSS
00:45:38.969 --> 00:45:42.306
$900,000 FEW IF ANY OF OUR
00:45:42.372 --> 00:45:43.440
MEMBERS CAN AFFORD A $900,000
00:45:43.507 --> 00:45:46.210
HOUSE. NO ONE REALIZES THE
00:45:46.276 --> 00:45:47.845
URGENCY AROUND THIS PROBLEM MORE
00:45:47.911 --> 00:45:49.346
THAN THE FOLKS WE REPRESENT, AND
00:45:49.413 --> 00:45:52.015
WE VERY MUCH SUPPORT BIG EFFORTS
00:45:52.082 --> 00:45:53.584
TO TRY TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM BUT
00:45:53.650 --> 00:45:55.619
TRYING TO SOLVE IT ON THE BACKS
00:45:55.686 --> 00:45:57.654
OF THOSE WHO ARE GOING TO DO THE
00:45:57.721 --> 00:45:58.689
WORK. AND WITH ALL THE RISK THAT
00:45:58.755 --> 00:46:00.657
COMES TO THEIR OWN SAFETY TO THE
00:46:00.724 --> 00:46:03.060
QUALITY OF THE PRODUCT TO ALL
00:46:03.127 --> 00:46:03.727
THE OTHER THINGS THAT WERE JUST
00:46:03.794 --> 00:46:04.728
MENTIONED. WE JUST DON'T THINK
00:46:04.795 --> 00:46:07.264
BENEFITS ANYONE EXCEPT FOR THE
00:46:07.331 --> 00:46:08.265
EXTREMELY WEALTHY DEVELOPERS
00:46:08.332 --> 00:46:09.500
THAT THEY CAN'T AFFORD $900,000
00:46:09.566 --> 00:46:11.001
HOUSES. AND WE JUST DON'T THINK
00:46:11.068 --> 00:46:11.935
THAT'S FAIR. WE THINK WE
00:46:12.002 --> 00:46:14.071
ABSOLUTELY NEED TO TAKE A BIGGER
00:46:14.138 --> 00:46:15.539
PICTURE LOOK AND MAKE SURE THAT
00:46:15.606 --> 00:46:17.241
THE WORKERS ARE PROTECTED THAT
00:46:17.307 --> 00:46:18.442
THE QUALITY OF CONSTRUCTION IS
00:46:18.509 --> 00:46:20.110
PROTECTED. AND WE THINK SKILLED
00:46:20.177 --> 00:46:21.011
AND TRAINED WORKFORCE LANGUAGE
00:46:21.078 --> 00:46:23.046
IS THE WAY TO DO THAT, AND WE
00:46:23.113 --> 00:46:24.181
URGE OUR OPPOSITION UNTIL THOSE
00:46:24.248 --> 00:46:27.251
AMENDMENTS ARE ADOPTED. THANK
00:46:27.317 --> 00:46:30.087
YOU VERY MUCH. I DO APOLOGIZE. I
00:46:30.154 --> 00:46:32.523
NEGLECTED TO MAKE SURE THAT I
00:46:32.589 --> 00:46:34.158
INCLUDED EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM
00:46:34.224 --> 00:46:36.593
THAT WANTED TO SPEAK BEFORE I
00:46:36.660 --> 00:46:37.661
WENT TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:46:37.728 --> 00:46:38.929
NIGHT, SO I'M GOING TO MOVE ON
00:46:38.996 --> 00:46:40.030
TO THOSE INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD
00:46:40.097 --> 00:46:42.132
LIKE TO ADD ON AS A ME TOO, UM,
00:46:42.199 --> 00:46:43.634
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL. PLEASE
00:46:43.700 --> 00:46:47.271
COME FORWARD AND MY APOLOGIES.
00:46:47.337 --> 00:46:48.906
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
00:46:48.972 --> 00:46:50.340
COMMITTEE SCOTT GOVERNOR ON
00:46:50.407 --> 00:46:51.441
BEHALF OF THE CONSTRUCTION
00:46:51.508 --> 00:46:52.876
EMPLOYERS ASSOCIATION, WHICH ARE
00:46:52.943 --> 00:46:54.711
THE LARGEST UNION SIGNATORY
00:46:54.778 --> 00:46:55.746
BUILDING CONTRACTORS IN THE
00:46:55.812 --> 00:46:56.847
STATE. HERE IN SUPPORT. THANK
00:46:56.914 --> 00:47:00.918
YOU. GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
00:47:00.984 --> 00:47:01.852
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:47:01.919 --> 00:47:03.320
RAFINHA'S ARIANS, AARP,
00:47:03.387 --> 00:47:05.455
CALIFORNIA ON BEHALF OF OUR 3.3
00:47:05.522 --> 00:47:06.557
MILLION MEMBERS HERE IN STRONG
00:47:06.623 --> 00:47:10.527
SUPPORT. ROOM DEALS WITH THE
00:47:10.594 --> 00:47:11.662
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION
00:47:11.728 --> 00:47:12.629
RATHER THAN CALIFORNIA STRONG
00:47:12.696 --> 00:47:16.567
SUPPORT. SCOTT LITTLE HAIL,
00:47:16.633 --> 00:47:18.068
PROUD MEMBER OF CARPENTERS,
00:47:18.135 --> 00:47:19.536
LOCAL 1 52, REPRESENTING
00:47:19.603 --> 00:47:21.805
THOUSANDS OF MEMBERS AND CONTRA
00:47:21.872 --> 00:47:23.507
COSTA, SAN JOAQUIN, STANISLAUS,
00:47:23.574 --> 00:47:24.641
CALIBERS AND AMADOR COUNTIES AND
00:47:24.708 --> 00:47:29.846
STRONG SUPPORT. TONY BOY WITH
00:47:29.913 --> 00:47:30.881
THE CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
00:47:30.948 --> 00:47:31.882
ASSOCIATION HERE IN STRONG
00:47:31.949 --> 00:47:35.018
SUPPORT AS WELL, THANKS CHRIS
00:47:35.085 --> 00:47:36.053
MEYERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:47:36.119 --> 00:47:37.054
SCHOOLEMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
00:47:37.120 --> 00:47:39.389
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:47:39.456 --> 00:47:40.857
MORNING, MICHAEL SARAGOSA ON
00:47:40.924 --> 00:47:42.025
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA FARMWORKERS
00:47:42.092 --> 00:47:46.129
FOUNDATION AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:47:46.196 --> 00:47:47.431
GOOD MORNING, DANIEL BRAMPTON,
00:47:47.497 --> 00:47:49.199
UH, PROUD MEMBER OF DRYWALL,
00:47:49.266 --> 00:47:51.468
LATTER'S LOCAL 9109. AND ALL OUR
00:47:51.535 --> 00:47:53.337
MEMBERS ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:47:53.403 --> 00:47:55.606
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. RON
00:47:55.672 --> 00:47:56.773
ROULETTE NORTH CAL CARPENTER'S
00:47:56.840 --> 00:48:00.677
UNION IN SUPPORT. DEREK MACEIO,
00:48:00.744 --> 00:48:01.612
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL COUNCIL OF
00:48:01.678 --> 00:48:05.515
CARPENTERS IN SUPPORT. MARK'S
00:48:05.582 --> 00:48:06.416
DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:48:06.483 --> 00:48:07.417
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP IN STRONG
00:48:07.484 --> 00:48:10.821
SUPPORT. MATT WAS THERE WITH STU
00:48:10.887 --> 00:48:15.125
CALIFORNIAN SUPPORT. ADAM
00:48:15.192 --> 00:48:16.059
BRIANNA'S WITH CALIFORNIA
00:48:16.126 --> 00:48:17.060
COMMUNITY BUILDERS AND STRONG
00:48:17.127 --> 00:48:21.765
SUPPORT. ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH
00:48:21.832 --> 00:48:22.699
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
00:48:22.766 --> 00:48:24.034
BEHALF OF THE BLACK LEADERSHIP
00:48:24.101 --> 00:48:25.569
COUNCIL, SOUND HILL PROPERTIES
00:48:25.636 --> 00:48:27.771
SPUR AND SUPPORT HAVE ALSO BEEN
00:48:27.838 --> 00:48:28.772
ASKED TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT ON
00:48:28.839 --> 00:48:30.774
BEHALF OF ALL HOME SV AT HOME
00:48:30.841 --> 00:48:32.843
ACTION FUND AND CIVIC WELL IS IN
00:48:32.909 --> 00:48:33.977
SUPPORT AS WELL. THANK YOU SO
00:48:34.044 --> 00:48:36.713
MUCH. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. ALEX
00:48:36.780 --> 00:48:37.914
TORRES WITH THE BARRIER COUNSEL
00:48:37.981 --> 00:48:38.949
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
00:48:39.016 --> 00:48:41.852
YOU. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR TODD
00:48:41.918 --> 00:48:43.120
BLUMSTEIN FOR THE SOUTHERN
00:48:43.186 --> 00:48:44.554
CALIFORNIA CONTRACTORS
00:48:44.621 --> 00:48:45.689
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:48:45.756 --> 00:48:48.659
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:48:48.725 --> 00:48:50.527
THANK YOU, MADAM. CHAIR SENATORS
00:48:50.594 --> 00:48:51.628
. DANNY CURTIN, CALIFORNIA
00:48:51.695 --> 00:48:53.263
CONFERENCE OF CARPENTERS. THANK
00:48:53.330 --> 00:48:54.898
YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. I MEAN,
00:48:54.965 --> 00:48:56.166
I'M SORRY. THANK YOU FOR HEARING
00:48:56.233 --> 00:48:58.035
THIS BILL AND YOUR PATIENTS ARE
00:48:58.101 --> 00:48:59.169
SURROUNDING THE CONTROVERSIES ON
00:48:59.236 --> 00:49:00.604
THIS STRONG SUPPORT. THANK THANK
00:49:00.671 --> 00:49:05.642
YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR
00:49:05.709 --> 00:49:07.744
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE, JORDAN
00:49:07.811 --> 00:49:08.812
BANANA CARBON HARD ON BEHALF OF
00:49:08.879 --> 00:49:09.813
CALIFORNIAN B AND STRONG
00:49:09.880 --> 00:49:11.748
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:49:11.815 --> 00:49:16.520
WE ARE ACCEPTING SUPPORT. OKAY?
00:49:16.586 --> 00:49:17.688
SAYING NO FURTHER SUPPORT IN
00:49:17.754 --> 00:49:18.889
ROOM 2100 WILL MOVE ON TO
00:49:18.955 --> 00:49:21.091
OPPOSITION. AND THESE ARE THE ME
00:49:21.158 --> 00:49:26.897
TOOS. THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
00:49:26.963 --> 00:49:29.132
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS SCOTT WEST
00:49:29.199 --> 00:49:29.800
ON BEHALF OF THE 100,000,
00:49:29.866 --> 00:49:30.867
MEMBERS OF THE STATE ASSOCIATION
00:49:30.934 --> 00:49:32.269
OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS. THE
00:49:32.336 --> 00:49:34.137
55,000 MEMBERS OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:49:34.204 --> 00:49:36.006
COALITION OF UTILITY EMPLOYEES,
00:49:36.073 --> 00:49:38.075
THE 39,000 MEMBERS OF THE
00:49:38.141 --> 00:49:38.909
CALIFORNIA STATE PIPE TRADES
00:49:38.975 --> 00:49:41.078
COUNCIL AND THE 35,000 MEMBERS
00:49:41.144 --> 00:49:42.045
OF THE WESTERN STATES COUNCIL OF
00:49:42.112 --> 00:49:44.348
SHEET METAL WORKERS URGED A NO
00:49:44.414 --> 00:49:45.582
VOTE TODAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:49:45.649 --> 00:49:48.985
VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
00:49:49.052 --> 00:49:50.554
OF THE COMMITTEE. MARCO PRAYER.
00:49:50.620 --> 00:49:53.023
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
00:49:53.090 --> 00:49:54.224
OF SAN CLEMENTE. REGRETTABLY WE
00:49:54.291 --> 00:49:56.326
HAVE TO ASK FOR YOUR NO VOTE.
00:49:56.393 --> 00:49:59.262
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MORNING
00:49:59.329 --> 00:50:00.764
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS AND THE
00:50:00.831 --> 00:50:01.798
REST RAMIREZ ON BEHALF OF THE
00:50:01.865 --> 00:50:03.834
TRI VALLEY CITIES OF DUBLIN,
00:50:03.900 --> 00:50:04.835
LIVERMORE, PLEASANTON CENTER MAN
00:50:04.901 --> 00:50:06.970
IN DENVILLE, AS WELL AS THE CITY
00:50:07.037 --> 00:50:08.171
OF FREMONT AND RESPECTFUL
00:50:08.238 --> 00:50:09.106
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:50:09.172 --> 00:50:11.541
VERY MUCH. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
00:50:11.608 --> 00:50:12.943
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
00:50:13.009 --> 00:50:13.744
PAULSON'S OFFICE ON BEHALF OF
00:50:13.810 --> 00:50:14.978
THE FOLLOWING CITIES BANNING
00:50:15.045 --> 00:50:17.147
CUPERTINO, ELK GROVE, FAIRFIELD
00:50:17.214 --> 00:50:19.349
FILLMORE, FONTANA, GLENDORA,
00:50:19.416 --> 00:50:20.250
INDIAN WELLS, KERMAN. LA MORADA,
00:50:20.317 --> 00:50:21.284
LAPUENTE, WE'RE GONNA HILLS
00:50:21.351 --> 00:50:24.654
LAKEWOOD. LAMEDA NORCO, PALM
00:50:24.721 --> 00:50:26.156
DESERT, PARAMOUNT, RANCHO
00:50:26.223 --> 00:50:28.258
CUCAMONGA, ROSEMEAD, SIGNAL HILL
00:50:28.325 --> 00:50:29.726
, 1000 OAKS, TORRENTS AND
00:50:29.793 --> 00:50:30.927
WHITTIER ALL IN RESPECTFUL
00:50:30.994 --> 00:50:33.430
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:50:33.497 --> 00:50:34.998
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS, MATT
00:50:35.065 --> 00:50:36.199
BROUGHT ON BEHALF OF THE
00:50:36.266 --> 00:50:37.267
TEAMSTERS MACHINISTS AND UNITE
00:50:37.334 --> 00:50:38.702
HERE AND RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION.
00:50:38.769 --> 00:50:41.138
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:50:41.204 --> 00:50:42.973
NICOLE WORD ULLMAN ON BEHALF OF
00:50:43.039 --> 00:50:44.107
THE CITY OF ONTARIO AND
00:50:44.174 --> 00:50:47.444
OPPOSITION. MADAM CHAIR AND
00:50:47.511 --> 00:50:49.379
MEMBERS, ANTHONY RESCUE SO LOCAL
00:50:49.446 --> 00:50:51.181
16 HEAT AND FROST INSULATORS AND
00:50:51.248 --> 00:50:52.249
STRONG OPPOSITION WITH ALONG
00:50:52.315 --> 00:50:53.417
WITH STATE BUILDING TRADES.
00:50:53.483 --> 00:50:55.986
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:50:56.052 --> 00:50:57.554
GOOD MORNING. HONORABLE CHAIR
00:50:57.621 --> 00:50:59.256
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
00:50:59.322 --> 00:51:00.690
CHRIS HANAN, EXECUTIVE SECRETARY
00:51:00.757 --> 00:51:02.292
OF THE LOS ANGELES ORANGE
00:51:02.359 --> 00:51:03.560
COUNTY'S BUILDING CONSTRUCTION
00:51:03.627 --> 00:51:05.128
TRADES COUNCIL, STANDING IN
00:51:05.195 --> 00:51:06.363
SOLIDARITY WITH STATE BUILDING
00:51:06.430 --> 00:51:11.735
TRADES OPPOSE 2011. GOOD MORNING
00:51:11.802 --> 00:51:12.769
, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS JAMES
00:51:12.836 --> 00:51:13.970
THURWACHTER WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:51:14.037 --> 00:51:15.405
STATE COUNCIL OF LABORERS AND
00:51:15.472 --> 00:51:16.907
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK YOU
00:51:16.973 --> 00:51:18.375
. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM
00:51:18.442 --> 00:51:19.976
CHAIR DAVID JONES ON BEHALF OF
00:51:20.043 --> 00:51:21.578
THE CITIES OF BURBANK, GLENDALE.
00:51:21.645 --> 00:51:22.145
WE'RE IN COUNTY COUNCIL OF
00:51:22.212 --> 00:51:22.913
MAYORS AND COUNCIL MEMBERS,
00:51:22.979 --> 00:51:23.947
SOLANA BEACH AND TRUCKING
00:51:24.014 --> 00:51:27.918
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:51:27.984 --> 00:51:30.153
MORNING. MY NAME IS MATT NEWTON
00:51:30.220 --> 00:51:30.654
BOOM WITH INTERNATIONAL
00:51:30.720 --> 00:51:31.188
BROTHERHOOD OF ELECTRICAL
00:51:31.254 --> 00:51:33.156
WORKERS, LOCAL 3 40. WE STAND
00:51:33.223 --> 00:51:34.524
WITH THE STATE BUILDING TRADES
00:51:34.591 --> 00:51:35.525
AND STRONG OPPOSITION. THANK
00:51:35.592 --> 00:51:38.195
YOU. THANK YOU. ZACH GOODMAN.
00:51:38.261 --> 00:51:40.664
I'M HERE REPRESENTING I BW LOCAL
00:51:40.730 --> 00:51:43.166
3 40. I STAND IN STRONG
00:51:43.233 --> 00:51:43.700
OPPOSITION WITH THE STATE
00:51:43.767 --> 00:51:44.901
BUILDING TRADES. THANK YOU.
00:51:44.968 --> 00:51:46.736
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
00:51:46.803 --> 00:51:48.972
ANYONE ELSE? SEEING NO FURTHER
00:51:49.039 --> 00:51:51.041
TESTIMONY IN THE IN THE HEARING
00:51:51.107 --> 00:51:52.442
ROOM. I WANT TO THANK EVERYBODY
00:51:52.509 --> 00:51:54.110
THAT CAME HERE THIS MORNING.
00:51:54.177 --> 00:51:54.911
REALLY APPRECIATE IT. WE'RE
00:51:54.978 --> 00:51:56.947
GOING TO MOVE ON TO THE
00:51:57.013 --> 00:51:57.881
TELECONFERENCE LINE. WE WILL
00:51:57.948 --> 00:51:59.483
TAKE TESTIMONY FOR 30 MINUTES
00:51:59.549 --> 00:52:01.084
AND IT WOULD BE IT CAN BE EITHER
00:52:01.151 --> 00:52:05.489
IN SUPPORT OR IN OPPOSITION. NO.
00:52:05.555 --> 00:52:08.992
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. AND FOR
00:52:09.059 --> 00:52:10.961
THOSE ON THE PHONE IF YOU'D LIKE
00:52:11.027 --> 00:52:12.829
TO MAKE IT, ACTUALLY, I HAVE TO.
00:52:12.896 --> 00:52:16.099
I HAVE TO AMEND THAT. UM IT WILL
00:52:16.166 --> 00:52:17.767
BE 15 MINUTES AND SUPPORT AND 15
00:52:17.834 --> 00:52:19.002
MINUTES IN OPPOSITION. SO WE'LL
00:52:19.069 --> 00:52:24.407
START WITH THE SUPPORT. THANK
00:52:24.474 --> 00:52:25.942
YOU. YEP. IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK
00:52:26.009 --> 00:52:27.444
IN SUPPORT, MAYBE 2011 PLEASE
00:52:27.511 --> 00:52:29.679
PRESS 10 AND WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:52:29.746 --> 00:52:33.250
UP. 54, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:52:33.316 --> 00:52:34.518
MORNING, MADAM SHARING MEMBERS
00:52:34.584 --> 00:52:35.919
LAUREN DE VALENCIA, REPRESENTING
00:52:35.986 --> 00:52:36.686
THE AMERICAN PLANNING
00:52:36.753 --> 00:52:37.587
ASSOCIATION, CALIFORNIA CHAPTER
00:52:37.654 --> 00:52:42.092
AND SUPPORT. NEXT. WE'RE GONNA
00:52:42.158 --> 00:52:46.630
LINE 42. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:52:46.696 --> 00:52:47.864
MORNING. MY NAME IS JULIE.
00:52:47.931 --> 00:52:50.634
SURGERY GETS WITH THE LEGAL
00:52:50.700 --> 00:52:51.301
WOMAN BORDERS OF CALIFORNIA, AND
00:52:51.368 --> 00:52:54.170
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:52:54.237 --> 00:52:55.238
LINE NUMBER. 12, PLEASE GO
00:52:55.305 --> 00:52:59.042
AHEAD. IT WAS CARL KELLEY WITH
00:52:59.109 --> 00:53:00.143
NEIGHBORLY SANTA CRUZ, CALLING
00:53:00.210 --> 00:53:04.047
HIM STRONG SUPPORT. LINE NUMBER
00:53:04.114 --> 00:53:14.724
1 26, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 24 HOURS.
00:53:14.791 --> 00:53:20.897
AND. NEXT WE GO TO LINE NUMBER
00:53:20.964 --> 00:53:26.269
14, PLEASE GO AHEAD. FROM LOS
00:53:26.336 --> 00:53:27.771
ANGELES. I'M A SINGLE FAMILY
00:53:27.837 --> 00:53:28.772
HOME OWNER, BUT I'M ALSO
00:53:28.838 --> 00:53:31.174
REPRESENTING STORIES FROM THE
00:53:31.241 --> 00:53:33.243
FRONT LINE WITH 400 MEMBERS AND
00:53:33.310 --> 00:53:33.877
HOLLYWOOD FORWARD WITH ALL THE
00:53:33.944 --> 00:53:38.014
WORDS 30 ORGANIZATION. AH STRONG
00:53:38.081 --> 00:53:39.616
SUPPORT. YOU ALL NEED TO DO
00:53:39.683 --> 00:53:41.051
EVERYTHING YOU CAN TO BUILD
00:53:41.117 --> 00:53:43.520
HOUSING ALONG CORRIDOR. THANK
00:53:43.587 --> 00:53:45.555
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NAME
00:53:45.622 --> 00:53:47.424
AND ASSOCIATION, PLEASE. I WANT
00:53:47.490 --> 00:53:50.060
TO BE ABLE TO GET THROUGH THE 52
00:53:50.126 --> 00:53:51.161
PEOPLE THAT WOULD LIKE TO BE
00:53:51.227 --> 00:53:53.897
ABLE TO TESTIFY. AND NEXT ONE IN
00:53:53.964 --> 00:53:57.434
LINE 98. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:53:57.500 --> 00:53:59.169
MORNING, JOHN BYNER, EAST BAY
00:53:59.235 --> 00:54:00.337
FOR EVERYONE. WE ARE IN STRONG
00:54:00.403 --> 00:54:02.439
SUPPORT. THANK LINE. 38, PLEASE
00:54:02.505 --> 00:54:06.776
GO AHEAD. THIS IS LISA DANCE.
00:54:06.843 --> 00:54:07.811
I'M A RESIDENT OF FREMONT AND
00:54:07.877 --> 00:54:11.314
I'M IN SUPPORT. LINE 1 84,
00:54:11.381 --> 00:54:16.252
PLEASE GO AHEAD. SUCH A NUISANCE
00:54:16.319 --> 00:54:18.755
ON BEHALF OF I B W LOCAL 56 935
00:54:18.822 --> 00:54:19.990
100. YOU KNEW ELECTRICIANS IN
00:54:20.056 --> 00:54:21.658
SAN DIEGO AND UP HERE ALL
00:54:21.725 --> 00:54:22.592
COUNTIES IN SOLIDARITY OF THE
00:54:22.659 --> 00:54:23.727
STATE BUILDING TREATMENT
00:54:23.793 --> 00:54:24.761
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. THANK
00:54:24.828 --> 00:54:31.768
YOU. LINE 1 87, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:54:31.835 --> 00:54:33.903
IS RYAN, ALSO MEMBER OF
00:54:33.970 --> 00:54:34.704
INCLUSIVE SANTA MONICA AND
00:54:34.771 --> 00:54:35.672
CALIFORNIA AND BE ITALIAN
00:54:35.739 --> 00:54:40.076
SUPPORT. LINE. 105, PLEASE GO
00:54:40.143 --> 00:54:45.248
AHEAD. PLANET FROM CAMPBELL AND
00:54:45.315 --> 00:54:46.883
SENATE-DISTRICT 15. ON BEHALF OF
00:54:46.950 --> 00:54:48.018
SATURDAY, UM B AND SUNRISE,
00:54:48.084 --> 00:54:49.119
SILICON VALLEY SUPPORTED BABY
00:54:49.185 --> 00:54:52.689
2011. THANK YOU. LINE. 56,
00:54:52.756 --> 00:54:57.527
PLEASE GO AHEAD. STAMP PUBLIC
00:54:57.594 --> 00:54:58.495
MORE CALLING FROM OAKLAND AND
00:54:58.561 --> 00:55:02.699
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE. 109,
00:55:02.766 --> 00:55:07.103
PLEASE GO AHEAD. FOREIGN WELLS
00:55:07.170 --> 00:55:08.138
MISSING METAL RENTER IN
00:55:08.204 --> 00:55:11.708
BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA. LINE. 204,
00:55:11.775 --> 00:55:17.614
PLEASE GO AHEAD. NIELSEN FROM
00:55:17.681 --> 00:55:18.848
PALO ALTO AND FOR EVERYONE IN
00:55:18.915 --> 00:55:23.153
SUPPORT. LINE. 67, PLEASE GO
00:55:23.219 --> 00:55:27.023
AHEAD. JACK COLTON DIVERSITY
00:55:27.090 --> 00:55:32.462
COUNCIL MEMBER IN SUPPORT. LINE
00:55:32.529 --> 00:55:36.533
2 10 TO 10. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:55:36.599 --> 00:55:37.934
TOBY MORRISON. OH, COME FROM LOS
00:55:38.001 --> 00:55:39.602
ANGELES ON BEHALF OF WESTSIDE
00:55:39.669 --> 00:55:43.139
FOR EVERYONE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:55:43.206 --> 00:55:44.307
LINE TWO. OH, EIGHT. PLEASE GO
00:55:44.374 --> 00:55:49.813
AHEAD. NOTHING. CAN DIEGO YANDY
00:55:49.879 --> 00:55:54.217
STRONG SUPPORT? LYING TO 20.
00:55:54.284 --> 00:55:59.689
PLEASE GO AHEAD. BROUGH
00:55:59.756 --> 00:56:00.356
MALDONADO, KHALID REPRESENTATIVE
00:56:00.423 --> 00:56:05.628
STATE SUPPORT. LINE 2 22, PLEASE
00:56:05.695 --> 00:56:10.734
GO AHEAD. BEEN REPRESENTING
00:56:10.800 --> 00:56:11.801
FRANCISCO AND BE STRONG SUPPORT.
00:56:11.868 --> 00:56:17.207
THANK YOU. LINE 2 16, PLEASE GO
00:56:17.273 --> 00:56:22.712
AHEAD. HI. JOEL COHEN CALLING IN
00:56:22.779 --> 00:56:23.947
FROM BURLINGAME, CALIFORNIA AND
00:56:24.013 --> 00:56:27.851
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE 2 30,
00:56:27.917 --> 00:56:33.156
PLEASE GO AHEAD. SO AMAZING. I'M
00:56:33.223 --> 00:56:34.991
CALLING HIM FROM DAY FOR
00:56:35.058 --> 00:56:35.992
EVERYONE, CALLING HIM STRONG
00:56:36.059 --> 00:56:39.195
SUPPORT. LINE 2 33, PLEASE GO
00:56:39.262 --> 00:56:43.867
AHEAD. ANDREWS WELCOME CALLING
00:56:43.933 --> 00:56:45.135
FROM PASADENA, CALIFORNIA,
00:56:45.201 --> 00:56:46.369
REPRESENTING TO SEE THIS
00:56:46.436 --> 00:56:48.204
ABUNDANT HOUSINGS, KALUGIN BE IN
00:56:48.271 --> 00:56:53.910
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B TWO. 011.
00:56:53.977 --> 00:56:58.882
LINE 2 35, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:56:58.948 --> 00:57:00.049
MORNING, MRS ROBINSON THEMSELVES
00:57:00.116 --> 00:57:03.620
CALLING ON BEHALF OF UM, BE
00:57:03.686 --> 00:57:05.255
ACTING AND CHAPTERS URBAN
00:57:05.321 --> 00:57:07.524
ENVIRONMENTALISTS, CARIBBEAN B B
00:57:07.590 --> 00:57:09.025
AND B MOUNTAIN VIEW. UM, BE
00:57:09.092 --> 00:57:16.232
PEOPLE FOR HOUSING. LINE. 77,
00:57:16.299 --> 00:57:22.438
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CHÁVEZ WITH THE
00:57:22.505 --> 00:57:23.439
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:57:23.506 --> 00:57:26.976
REALTORS AND SUPPORT LINE 1 90,
00:57:27.043 --> 00:57:34.784
PLEASE GO AHEAD. 91 90. YOUR
00:57:34.851 --> 00:57:39.122
LINE IS OPEN. CAR WEEKS CALLING
00:57:39.189 --> 00:57:40.590
IN BEHALF OF GENERATION HOUSING
00:57:40.657 --> 00:57:42.225
HERE IN CINEMA COUNTY, WE OFFER
00:57:42.292 --> 00:57:46.062
OUR PHOTOS OR BRAID IN 2011.
00:57:46.129 --> 00:57:52.602
LINE 2 41, PLEASE GO AHEAD. BEEN
00:57:52.669 --> 00:57:53.770
CALLING AND AS RESIDENT LOSS
00:57:53.837 --> 00:57:54.838
ANGELES AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:57:54.904 --> 00:57:59.709
THANK YOU. LINE 2 42, PLEASE GO
00:57:59.776 --> 00:58:04.414
AHEAD. MORNING ALL AND BRAD, YOU
00:58:04.480 --> 00:58:06.216
INK ON THE BEST SANTA MONICA
00:58:06.282 --> 00:58:07.984
FORD OR DO YOU NEED THE
00:58:08.051 --> 00:58:09.118
STRONGEST FOR THIS, BILL? THANK
00:58:09.185 --> 00:58:14.023
YOU. LINE. 200, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:58:14.090 --> 00:58:15.558
THIS IS RYAN O'CONNELL,
00:58:15.625 --> 00:58:17.260
REPRESENTING THAT SOLANO FOR
00:58:17.327 --> 00:58:18.361
EVERYONE IN SUPPORT OF 2011.
00:58:18.428 --> 00:58:22.699
THANK YOU. LINE 2 44, PLEASE GO
00:58:22.765 --> 00:58:27.503
AHEAD. VERONICA VIA LEVELS
00:58:27.570 --> 00:58:29.405
CRUISE ON BEHALF OF THE CALGARY
00:58:29.472 --> 00:58:31.140
AFFORD ACTION FUND IN SUPPORT.
00:58:31.207 --> 00:58:35.378
THANK YOU. LINE 2 40, PLEASE GO
00:58:35.445 --> 00:58:39.649
AHEAD. COULD EXPLAIN WITH THE
00:58:39.716 --> 00:58:41.451
TOP BRAND NURSES ASSOCIATION AND
00:58:41.517 --> 00:58:42.352
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
00:58:42.418 --> 00:58:50.260
YOU. LINE 1 92, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:58:50.326 --> 00:58:50.760
JEFFERIES INTERNATIONAL
00:58:50.827 --> 00:58:53.730
BROTHERHOOD OF BOILERMAKERS.
00:58:53.796 --> 00:58:56.566
SITTING IN OPPOSITION ABOUT 2011
00:58:56.633 --> 00:58:57.634
AND SOLIDARITY WITH SPACE
00:58:57.700 --> 00:58:58.701
BUILDING TRADES ON THIS, BILL.
00:58:58.768 --> 00:59:03.706
THANK YOU. LINE 1 45, PLEASE GO
00:59:03.773 --> 00:59:08.778
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
00:59:08.845 --> 00:59:10.780
MEMBERS. ALEX WALKER. SAN
00:59:10.847 --> 00:59:11.981
FRANCISCO BARRIER REPORT TRANSIT
00:59:12.048 --> 00:59:13.249
DISTRICT, GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS AND
00:59:13.316 --> 00:59:18.721
SUPPORT. LINE 1 35, PLEASE GO
00:59:18.788 --> 00:59:33.002
AHEAD. 91 35. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:59:33.069 --> 00:59:34.270
AND WE WILL MOVE TO LINE 78.
00:59:34.337 --> 00:59:38.408
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THERE'S JORDAN
00:59:38.474 --> 00:59:39.642
GRINDS ON BEHALF OF GREENBELT
00:59:39.709 --> 00:59:40.743
ALLIANCE AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:59:40.810 --> 00:59:46.215
2011. HOLD ON THE LINE. 96,
00:59:46.282 --> 00:59:50.320
PLEASE GO AHEAD. DUTY OR MOANER
00:59:50.386 --> 00:59:56.159
, WALNUT CREEK. STRONG SUPPORT.
00:59:56.225 --> 00:59:57.427
LINE 1 41. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:59:57.493 --> 01:00:01.030
PLEASE GO AHEAD. FANNY PANERA,
01:00:01.097 --> 01:00:02.532
MONTEREY SECTORS. COUNTY
01:00:02.598 --> 01:00:03.399
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TRADES
01:00:03.466 --> 01:00:05.034
COUNCIL. WE OPPOSE A B 2011. BUT
01:00:05.101 --> 01:00:09.739
STATE BUILDING TRADES. THANK YOU
01:00:09.806 --> 01:00:10.540
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY, BUT WE'RE
01:00:10.606 --> 01:00:12.642
STILL ON SUPPORT. SO WE WERE
01:00:12.709 --> 01:00:13.843
PRETTY CLOSE TO FINISHING UP AND
01:00:13.910 --> 01:00:14.877
THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO
01:00:14.944 --> 01:00:18.815
OPPOSITION. AND NEXT WE'RE THE
01:00:18.881 --> 01:00:22.051
LINE. 1 85, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:00:22.118 --> 01:00:23.286
MELANIE MURILLO, SOMETHING HALF
01:00:23.353 --> 01:00:24.420
OF THE GREENLINING INSTITUTE
01:00:24.487 --> 01:00:25.388
WITH THE SUPPORT AND CONCEPT
01:00:25.455 --> 01:00:30.393
POSITIONS. WE'LL GO TO LINE IT
01:00:30.460 --> 01:00:33.596
TO 11 TO 11. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:00:33.663 --> 01:00:35.131
GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR CHRIS
01:00:35.198 --> 01:00:36.632
WILSON WITH THE LOCK, HEAD OF
01:00:36.699 --> 01:00:38.001
THE COUNTY BUSINESS FEDERATION
01:00:38.067 --> 01:00:42.205
AND SUPPORT. NEXT LITTLE LINE
01:00:42.271 --> 01:00:48.778
THAT 1 29, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:00:48.845 --> 01:00:49.812
ACTUALLY IN OPPOSITION, SO I
01:00:49.879 --> 01:00:55.651
GOTTA WAIT. THANK YOU AND WE'LL
01:00:55.718 --> 01:00:56.886
GO TO LINE 1 24, PLEASE GO
01:00:56.953 --> 01:01:02.859
AHEAD. NOW. THANK YOU. LINE 1 24
01:01:02.925 --> 01:01:11.868
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. AND WE WILL
01:01:11.934 --> 01:01:13.936
MOVE ON TO LINE 1 99, PLEASE GO
01:01:14.003 --> 01:01:18.808
AHEAD. I JUST CHOSE YOU SHOULD
01:01:18.875 --> 01:01:21.344
BE BOARD MEMBER FOR SAN
01:01:21.411 --> 01:01:22.412
FRANCISCO. UM, BE CALLING IN
01:01:22.478 --> 01:01:27.850
STRONG SUPPORT. NEXT WITH A LINE
01:01:27.917 --> 01:01:32.922
THAT 1 91, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:01:32.989 --> 01:01:35.625
MORNING. SENATORS MY NAME IS
01:01:35.691 --> 01:01:37.960
MATTHEW BAKER, POLICY DIRECTOR
01:01:38.027 --> 01:01:38.561
FOR WHERE? THE PLANNING
01:01:38.628 --> 01:01:40.863
CONSERVATION LEE. WE HAVE A SORT
01:01:40.930 --> 01:01:42.031
OF SUPPORT FROM MENDED POSITION
01:01:42.098 --> 01:01:43.466
ON THIS BILL, BUT WE DO HAVE
01:01:43.533 --> 01:01:44.600
SIGNIFICANT AMENDMENTS THAT WE
01:01:44.667 --> 01:01:46.469
RECOMMENDED VERY SIMILAR TO THE
01:01:46.536 --> 01:01:48.805
CHAIRS, SD SIX, AND WE LOOK
01:01:48.871 --> 01:01:50.073
FORWARD AND HOPE THAT WE CAN
01:01:50.139 --> 01:01:51.140
CONTINUE DISCUSSING NUMBERS.
01:01:51.207 --> 01:01:54.210
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:01:54.277 --> 01:01:59.182
LINE 1 77, PLEASE GO AHEAD. CHEN
01:01:59.248 --> 01:02:01.250
WARREN WITH MULTIFAITH ACTION
01:02:01.317 --> 01:02:02.151
COALITION OF COUNTRIES STRONG
01:02:02.218 --> 01:02:07.323
SUPPORT 2011. LINE. 58, PLEASE
01:02:07.390 --> 01:02:13.062
GO AHEAD. MELISSA CASEY FROM LOS
01:02:13.129 --> 01:02:14.564
ANGELES. STRONG SUPPORT FOR A B
01:02:14.630 --> 01:02:19.602
2 2011. LINE 1 26, PLEASE GO
01:02:19.669 --> 01:02:26.809
AHEAD. LINE 1 26. YOUR LINE IS
01:02:26.876 --> 01:02:31.347
OPEN. ITS OPPOSITION, NOW
01:02:31.414 --> 01:02:33.649
CLEARLY IN OPPOSITION. WE'RE
01:02:33.716 --> 01:02:39.188
STILL ON SUPPORT. AND WE WILL GO
01:02:39.255 --> 01:02:42.792
TO LINE 59. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:02:42.859 --> 01:02:44.927
PUBLISHED HIS MAGIC OUT, CALLING
01:02:44.994 --> 01:02:45.761
THE HALF OF THE MONTH RIGHT
01:02:45.828 --> 01:02:46.929
THERE. ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AND
01:02:46.996 --> 01:02:51.767
STRONG SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2011.
01:02:51.834 --> 01:02:53.603
LINE NUMBER 202 TO 0 TO YOUR
01:02:53.669 --> 01:02:57.507
LINE IS OPEN. HI. MY NAME IS
01:02:57.573 --> 01:02:58.908
CATHERINE CHAN WITH THE
01:02:58.975 --> 01:03:00.009
APARTMENT HOUSING L A AND I
01:03:00.076 --> 01:03:04.580
SUPPORT. LINE TO 53 YEAR LINE IS
01:03:04.647 --> 01:03:10.253
OPEN. THIS IS BOB NAYLOR ORFIELD
01:03:10.319 --> 01:03:11.787
SAID IN COMPANY OWNED BY HOWARD
01:03:11.854 --> 01:03:14.257
AHMANSON JR AND ORANGE COUNTY
01:03:14.323 --> 01:03:15.324
PHILANTHROPY AND PROPOSED IN
01:03:15.391 --> 01:03:20.596
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE 1 43. YOUR
01:03:20.663 --> 01:03:28.804
LINE IS OPEN. LINE 1 43. YOUR
01:03:28.871 --> 01:03:33.709
LINE IS OPEN. MADAM CHAIR AND
01:03:33.776 --> 01:03:35.545
MEMBERS ANDREW ANTWI ON BEHALF
01:03:35.611 --> 01:03:38.014
OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS.
01:03:38.080 --> 01:03:39.215
AND THE CITY COUNTY ASSOCIATION
01:03:39.282 --> 01:03:42.518
OF GOVERNMENTS. UM SAN MATEO
01:03:42.585 --> 01:03:44.253
COUNTY AND OPPOSITION TO A B
01:03:44.320 --> 01:03:49.192
2011. THANK YOU. WE'RE ALMOST
01:03:49.258 --> 01:03:50.760
DONE WITH THE SUPPORT, SO I WANT
01:03:50.826 --> 01:03:52.695
TO MAKE SURE THEY HAVE AN
01:03:52.762 --> 01:03:53.796
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK BEFORE WE
01:03:53.863 --> 01:03:57.099
SWITCH. AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 2
01:03:57.166 --> 01:04:00.770
52, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES, IT'S
01:04:00.836 --> 01:04:01.671
MARVIN NORMAN SAMMARTINO
01:04:01.737 --> 01:04:04.073
RESIDENTS OF PLACING PRICING
01:04:04.140 --> 01:04:08.611
THINGS THAT REPORT. THAT'S WHERE
01:04:08.678 --> 01:04:12.949
THE LINE 89, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:04:13.015 --> 01:04:14.417
FIND MY NAME IS ALEXANDER WALNUT
01:04:14.483 --> 01:04:15.851
. OH, I'M OVER AND THREE LIVING
01:04:15.918 --> 01:04:17.053
IN SAN FRANCISCO TRUMP'S
01:04:17.119 --> 01:04:20.156
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 1 37,
01:04:20.223 --> 01:04:28.431
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 1 37. YOUR
01:04:28.497 --> 01:04:35.905
LINE IS OPEN. AND WE WILL GO ON
01:04:35.972 --> 01:04:40.176
TO LINE ONE. OH, 3103 IS OPEN.
01:04:40.243 --> 01:04:41.744
HI. MY NAME IS AMANDA LOCK I'M
01:04:41.811 --> 01:04:44.513
WITH AMG AND ASSOCIATES LLC. AND
01:04:44.580 --> 01:04:45.781
WE ARE STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011.
01:04:45.848 --> 01:04:50.319
THANK YOU. LINE 2 66, PLEASE GO
01:04:50.386 --> 01:04:54.590
AHEAD. HI CHRIS GREEN FROM
01:04:54.657 --> 01:04:56.792
SOLANO COUNTY. STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:04:56.859 --> 01:04:59.095
2 11. THOSE OF US WHO ABOUT HOW
01:04:59.161 --> 01:05:01.163
THANK YOU VERY MUCH CANNOT VERY
01:05:01.230 --> 01:05:02.431
MUCH. YOU'RE TAKING UP SOMEONE
01:05:02.498 --> 01:05:03.466
ELSE'S TIME. I WANT TO GET
01:05:03.532 --> 01:05:04.433
THROUGH EVERYBODY. WE'RE ALMOST
01:05:04.500 --> 01:05:07.637
THERE. LINE TWO. OH, NINE.
01:05:07.703 --> 01:05:13.542
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE TWO. OH,
01:05:13.609 --> 01:05:18.581
NINE. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HELLO
01:05:18.648 --> 01:05:19.615
THIS IS MARLENE. NOBODY SO
01:05:19.682 --> 01:05:22.852
CALLING FROM CALIFORNIA. I'M IN
01:05:22.918 --> 01:05:24.954
STRONG OPPO OPPOSED A B THE BABY
01:05:25.021 --> 01:05:28.691
GOT IT. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE
01:05:28.758 --> 01:05:30.326
WERE ALMOST GOT TO GET THROUGH
01:05:30.393 --> 01:05:34.897
THOSE. I VOTE SUPPORT, AND WE'LL
01:05:34.964 --> 01:05:36.932
GO TO LINE UP. MY APOLOGIES,
01:05:36.999 --> 01:05:38.067
MADAM CHAIR WE'LL GO TO LINE 2
01:05:38.134 --> 01:05:42.271
72, PLEASE GO AHEAD. JAKE CHRIST
01:05:42.338 --> 01:05:43.773
ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
01:05:43.839 --> 01:05:44.907
COALITION AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:05:44.974 --> 01:05:48.811
A B 2011. THANK YOU. AND WE'LL
01:05:48.878 --> 01:05:55.685
TRY 1 37, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 1 37
01:05:55.751 --> 01:06:02.792
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. AND MOVING ON
01:06:02.858 --> 01:06:07.663
TO LINE 2 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:06:07.730 --> 01:06:09.765
MY NAME'S MIKE NARDI. I HAVE NO
01:06:09.832 --> 01:06:11.400
AFFILIATION. JUST A RENTER IN
01:06:11.467 --> 01:06:13.002
LOS ANGELES COUNTY AND I AM
01:06:13.069 --> 01:06:14.704
STRONG SUPPORT OF PB 2011. THANK
01:06:14.770 --> 01:06:18.674
YOU. THANK YOU. AND MADAM CHAIR.
01:06:18.741 --> 01:06:20.543
NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND QUÊ VERY
01:06:20.609 --> 01:06:22.044
GOOD. IT WAS ALMOST EXACTLY ON
01:06:22.111 --> 01:06:24.013
THE ON THE DOT SO THAT'S GOOD.
01:06:24.080 --> 01:06:26.015
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
01:06:26.082 --> 01:06:27.416
INDIVIDUALS WHO WANT TO TESTIFY
01:06:27.483 --> 01:06:28.484
IN OPPOSITION AGAIN NAME AND
01:06:28.551 --> 01:06:33.723
AFFILIATION. AND ONCE AGAIN IF
01:06:33.789 --> 01:06:34.990
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:06:35.057 --> 01:06:37.059
OPPOSITION TO A B 2011 PLEASE
01:06:37.126 --> 01:06:40.296
PRESS 10. AND FIRST GO TO LINE 1
01:06:40.363 --> 01:06:44.200
35, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MORNING,
01:06:44.266 --> 01:06:46.102
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS JASON RYAN,
01:06:46.168 --> 01:06:46.669
LEAD CALIFORNIA CITIES WERE
01:06:46.736 --> 01:06:57.546
OPPOSED THIS MEASURE. THANK YOU.
01:06:57.613 --> 01:07:00.015
NEXT. MR MODERATOR LIKE THANK
01:07:00.082 --> 01:07:04.653
YOU LINE 45. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:07:04.720 --> 01:07:06.055
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
01:07:06.122 --> 01:07:06.889
SENATE GOVERNMENT FINANCE
01:07:06.956 --> 01:07:08.324
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS CHARLIE
01:07:08.391 --> 01:07:09.859
SUMMERS. I'M SPEAKING ON BEHALF
01:07:09.925 --> 01:07:11.460
OF PEOPLE ORGANIZING TO DEMAND
01:07:11.527 --> 01:07:12.762
ENVIRONMENTAL AND ECONOMIC
01:07:12.828 --> 01:07:14.964
RIGHTS FOR THEIR FRANCISCO. WE
01:07:15.030 --> 01:07:16.665
OPPOSE A B 2011 UNLESS AMENDED.
01:07:16.732 --> 01:07:17.099
THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:07:17.166 --> 01:07:21.837
CONSIDERATION. THANK YOU. GO TO
01:07:21.904 --> 01:07:26.008
LINE2 12 212, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:07:26.075 --> 01:07:28.277
THANK YOU. THIS IS TRACY
01:07:28.344 --> 01:07:29.378
ROSENBERG CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:07:29.445 --> 01:07:34.016
MEDIA. ALLIANCE WE HAVE CONCERNS
01:07:34.083 --> 01:07:35.851
ABOUT THE IMPACT IN FRANCISCO
01:07:35.918 --> 01:07:41.690
AND OUR AND OUR POST. THANK YOU.
01:07:41.757 --> 01:07:42.925
WE'LL GO TO LINE 47, PLEASE GO
01:07:42.992 --> 01:07:46.796
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
01:07:46.862 --> 01:07:47.596
MEMBERS, DANA HUTCHINGS,
01:07:47.663 --> 01:07:48.764
REPRESENTING THE CITIES OF
01:07:48.831 --> 01:07:50.866
CORONA VILLE, RANCHO PALOS VERDE
01:07:50.933 --> 01:07:51.934
, IS IN SANTA ROSA AND
01:07:52.001 --> 01:07:56.238
OPPOSITION IN 2011. THANK YOU.
01:07:56.305 --> 01:07:58.340
NEXT TO THE LINE AT 1 44. PLEASE
01:07:58.407 --> 01:08:03.913
GO AHEAD. LINE 1 40 FOR YOUR
01:08:03.979 --> 01:08:11.620
LINE IS OPEN. AND WE WILL MOVE
01:08:11.687 --> 01:08:13.622
ON TO LINE 1 18 118, PLEASE GO
01:08:13.689 --> 01:08:16.492
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
01:08:16.559 --> 01:08:19.695
ME LINKS DEAFEN ON BEHALF OF
01:08:19.762 --> 01:08:21.897
SUNDAY. VAIL UNITED NEIGHBORS IN
01:08:21.964 --> 01:08:23.699
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:08:23.766 --> 01:08:29.205
VERY MUCH. NEXT GO TO LINE TWO.
01:08:29.271 --> 01:08:32.842
OH, SEVEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:08:32.908 --> 01:08:33.876
MORNING SHARON MEMBERS ERIC
01:08:33.943 --> 01:08:36.212
TURNER ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
01:08:36.278 --> 01:08:37.112
DOWNEY IN TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY
01:08:37.179 --> 01:08:40.583
AND OPPOSITION. THANK THANK YOU.
01:08:40.649 --> 01:08:46.188
LINE 2 64, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:08:46.255 --> 01:08:47.590
ASTHMA WITH THE SAN DIEGO
01:08:47.656 --> 01:08:49.291
IRONWORKERS JOINING STATE
01:08:49.358 --> 01:08:50.459
BUILDING TRADES IN OPPOSITION TO
01:08:50.526 --> 01:08:54.296
A B 2011. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:08:54.363 --> 01:08:58.267
LINE TO 59. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:08:58.334 --> 01:09:00.536
GOOD MORNING. THIS IS ANESTHESIA
01:09:00.603 --> 01:09:02.137
OF ANNAPOLIS, A MEMBER OF SAN
01:09:02.204 --> 01:09:05.007
FRANCISCO TENANTS UNION CALLING
01:09:05.074 --> 01:09:07.776
TO OPPOSE A B 2011 UNLESS IT IS
01:09:07.843 --> 01:09:10.145
AMENDED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:09:10.212 --> 01:09:14.116
VERY MUCH. LINE 2 67, PLEASE GO
01:09:14.183 --> 01:09:19.421
AHEAD. THIS IS LARISSA PATRON
01:09:19.488 --> 01:09:20.823
SHELLY, WITH UNITED TO SAVE THE
01:09:20.890 --> 01:09:22.224
MISSION IN SAN FRANCISCO.
01:09:22.291 --> 01:09:23.459
OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED. THANK
01:09:23.526 --> 01:09:32.701
YOU. LINE. 91, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:09:32.768 --> 01:09:34.837
CUT AWAY WITH GUARANTEED LATINO
01:09:34.904 --> 01:09:35.804
CULTURAL DISTRICT IN SAN
01:09:35.871 --> 01:09:36.972
FRANCISCO POPES UNLESS AMENDED.
01:09:37.039 --> 01:09:41.544
THANK YOU. LINE. 32, PLEASE GO
01:09:41.610 --> 01:09:46.148
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
01:09:46.215 --> 01:09:48.050
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME
01:09:48.117 --> 01:09:49.051
IS RICK SMILES WITH THE SOUTHERN
01:09:49.118 --> 01:09:50.519
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT COUNCIL OF
01:09:50.586 --> 01:09:52.087
LABORERS AND ON BEHALF OF OUR
01:09:52.154 --> 01:09:54.189
32,000, PLUS MEMBERS, WE STAND
01:09:54.256 --> 01:09:55.457
WITH THE STATE BUILDING TRADES
01:09:55.524 --> 01:09:57.426
AND STRONG OPPOSITION OF A B
01:09:57.493 --> 01:10:01.997
2011. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND
01:10:02.064 --> 01:10:03.966
WE'LL GO TO LINE AT 203. PLEASE
01:10:04.033 --> 01:10:08.771
GO AHEAD. SEVEN PM JIN BURBANK,
01:10:08.837 --> 01:10:09.872
RESIDENT AND OPPOSITION THANK
01:10:09.939 --> 01:10:21.617
YOU. LINE 1 55, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:10:21.684 --> 01:10:22.885
LINE 1 55. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:10:22.952 --> 01:10:25.955
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING
01:10:26.021 --> 01:10:27.456
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS JOEL PICKET
01:10:27.523 --> 01:10:29.592
. I AM THE BUSINESS AGENT WITH G
01:10:29.658 --> 01:10:31.093
W. LOCAL 1 80, REPRESENTING
01:10:31.160 --> 01:10:33.462
UNION ELECTRICIANS, WORKERS IN
01:10:33.529 --> 01:10:34.663
NAPA AND SOLANO COUNTIES, AND WE
01:10:34.730 --> 01:10:37.166
STAND IN SOLIDARITY. WITH THE
01:10:37.232 --> 01:10:38.400
STATE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION
01:10:38.467 --> 01:10:40.669
TRADES IN A PROPOSITION OF A B
01:10:40.736 --> 01:10:45.908
2011 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK
01:10:45.975 --> 01:10:53.115
YOU. 1 29, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 29,
01:10:53.182 --> 01:10:55.818
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CAN YOU HEAR
01:10:55.884 --> 01:10:59.054
ME? WE CAN HEAR YOU. YES. CAN
01:10:59.121 --> 01:11:02.725
YOU HEAR ME? HELLO. WE CAN HEAR
01:11:02.791 --> 01:11:05.294
YOU. YES. MY NAME IS JOHNNY
01:11:05.361 --> 01:11:09.198
ESCOBEDO. I'M WITH THIS
01:11:09.264 --> 01:11:10.866
IRONWORKERS, LOCAL 4 16 AND I
01:11:10.933 --> 01:11:13.168
STAND IN SOLIDARITY WITH STATE
01:11:13.235 --> 01:11:14.203
BUILDING TRADES, AND I OPPOSE
01:11:14.269 --> 01:11:17.072
THIS. AH MAYBE 2011 THANK YOU SO
01:11:17.139 --> 01:11:20.309
MUCH FOR TESTIFYING TODAY. LINE
01:11:20.376 --> 01:11:23.712
1 41, PLEASE GO AHEAD. CAN YOU
01:11:23.779 --> 01:11:29.385
HEAR ME NOW? WE CAN. OKAY THIS
01:11:29.451 --> 01:11:31.420
IS MONTEREY. THANK YOU'S CABLING
01:11:31.487 --> 01:11:33.956
TRADES MANNY GENERO, AND WE
01:11:34.023 --> 01:11:35.190
OPPOSE A B 2011 WITH STATE
01:11:35.257 --> 01:11:35.958
BUILDING TRADES. THANK YOU VERY
01:11:36.025 --> 01:11:40.663
MUCH. LINE 1 78, PLEASE GO
01:11:40.729 --> 01:11:45.567
AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS LAWRENCE
01:11:45.634 --> 01:11:47.136
LEAVING. I'M A FRESHMAN AT UC
01:11:47.202 --> 01:11:48.303
BERKELEY, CALLING OPPOSITION OF
01:11:48.370 --> 01:11:53.642
A B 20. LINE 1 37, PLEASE GO
01:11:53.709 --> 01:11:58.313
AHEAD. THIS PIEDMONT BROWN
01:11:58.380 --> 01:12:00.349
REPRESENT LOCAL COURTS. 33
01:12:00.416 --> 01:12:01.750
IRONWORKERS HAVE LOST PANDAS. WE
01:12:01.817 --> 01:12:03.686
STAND WITH THE BUILDING, TRADE
01:12:03.752 --> 01:12:04.853
AND OPPOSITION OF A B 2011.
01:12:04.920 --> 01:12:09.258
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:12:09.324 --> 01:12:15.064
LINE 1 75, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:12:15.130 --> 01:12:16.965
ALOHA CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
01:12:17.032 --> 01:12:17.800
MEMBERS. THIS IS MITCHELL
01:12:17.866 --> 01:12:19.201
BACKDOOR WITH THE DISTRICT
01:12:19.268 --> 01:12:20.369
COUNCIL VIOLENT WORKERS WE STAND
01:12:20.436 --> 01:12:22.237
WITH HE STATE BUILDING TRADES
01:12:22.304 --> 01:12:25.541
AND OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. LINE
01:12:25.607 --> 01:12:31.947
1 88, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
01:12:32.014 --> 01:12:33.115
LISA, RESIDENT OF SAN DIEGO
01:12:33.182 --> 01:12:34.016
COUNTY AND RESPECTFUL
01:12:34.083 --> 01:12:38.187
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:12:38.253 --> 01:12:41.490
LINE 1 83, PLEASE GO AHEAD. CAN
01:12:41.557 --> 01:12:43.559
YOU CALL ME BACK AND LIKE FIVE
01:12:43.625 --> 01:12:47.963
MINUTES. I'M SORRY, BUT WE'RE
01:12:48.030 --> 01:12:50.532
FINISHING UP THE HEARING AND SO
01:12:50.599 --> 01:12:51.567
MAYBE YOU'RE TELLING SOMEONE
01:12:51.633 --> 01:13:00.042
ELSE. GOOD. LINE 1 83. UM HI. UH
01:13:00.109 --> 01:13:01.310
THIS IS A LITTLE BIT MEMORIES.
01:13:01.376 --> 01:13:02.911
LAFAYETTE, CALIFORNIA. ON BEHALF
01:13:02.978 --> 01:13:08.851
OF STABLE LAFAYETTE. AND I'D
01:13:08.917 --> 01:13:10.853
LIKE TO STRONGLY OPPOSE A B
01:13:10.919 --> 01:13:15.791
2011. THE DISINGENUOUS IN ITS
01:13:15.858 --> 01:13:16.792
HEAD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:13:16.859 --> 01:13:18.060
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MA'AM.
01:13:18.127 --> 01:13:20.095
WE'RE JUST TRYING TO GET NAMES
01:13:20.162 --> 01:13:21.163
AND AFFILIATION. THANK YOU SO
01:13:21.230 --> 01:13:24.266
MUCH. NEXT WOULD ALIGN THE 74
01:13:24.333 --> 01:13:28.036
PLEASE GO AHEAD. RECALL LIVABLE
01:13:28.103 --> 01:13:29.772
CALIFORNIA IN OPPOSITION. THANK
01:13:29.838 --> 01:13:39.815
YOU. LINE 1 92, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:13:39.882 --> 01:13:47.489
LINE 1 92. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:13:47.556 --> 01:13:50.325
AND WE WILL MOVE ON TO LINE 1
01:13:50.392 --> 01:13:53.162
76, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME
01:13:53.228 --> 01:13:55.197
IS LOGAN ANDREWS HIGH SCHOOL
01:13:55.264 --> 01:13:56.165
SHARE IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
01:13:56.231 --> 01:13:57.800
OPPOSITION TO A B 2011. THANK
01:13:57.866 --> 01:14:03.238
YOU VERY MUCH. LINE 1 10 110,
01:14:03.305 --> 01:14:09.711
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 1 10, YOUR
01:14:09.778 --> 01:14:13.448
LINE IS OPEN. GOOD MORNING
01:14:13.515 --> 01:14:15.083
MEMBERS AND CHAIR. MY NAME IS
01:14:15.150 --> 01:14:16.852
PATRICK DAVIDSON WITH PAINTERS.
01:14:16.919 --> 01:14:17.386
KNOWLEDGE TRADE REPRESENTS
01:14:17.452 --> 01:14:18.754
10,000 MEMBERS IN SOUTHERN
01:14:18.821 --> 01:14:20.722
CALIFORNIA WE SUPPORT STATE
01:14:20.789 --> 01:14:21.723
BUILDING TRADES ARE STRONGLY
01:14:21.790 --> 01:14:26.295
OPPOSED. A B 2011. THANK YOU.
01:14:26.361 --> 01:14:27.496
LINE NUMBER. 14 14, PLEASE GO
01:14:27.563 --> 01:14:33.168
AHEAD. LINE 14. YOUR LINE IS
01:14:33.235 --> 01:14:40.309
OPEN. AND WE WILL MOVE ON TO
01:14:40.375 --> 01:14:46.315
LINE 1 69, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE
01:14:46.381 --> 01:14:51.286
1 69, YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
01:14:51.353 --> 01:14:52.087
MORNING, MEMBERS OF THE
01:14:52.154 --> 01:14:53.522
COMMITTEE RUDY GONZALEZ, SAN
01:14:53.589 --> 01:14:54.823
FRANCISCO BUILDING AND
01:14:54.890 --> 01:14:55.757
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
01:14:55.824 --> 01:14:58.327
REPRESENTING IMPORTANTLY, 1300
01:14:58.393 --> 01:14:59.494
SKILLED AND TRAINED OUT OF WORK
01:14:59.561 --> 01:15:01.330
MEMBERS FOR NEARLY TWO YEARS
01:15:01.396 --> 01:15:05.968
OPPOSING 2011. LINE 2 79, PLEASE
01:15:06.034 --> 01:15:10.372
GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
01:15:10.439 --> 01:15:11.773
EVERYONE. MY NAME IS TONY DID
01:15:11.840 --> 01:15:12.674
THAT WITH THE PAINTERS NOW
01:15:12.741 --> 01:15:14.810
TRADES DISTRICT COUNCIL 36 ON
01:15:14.877 --> 01:15:16.178
BEHALF OF OUR MEMBERSHIP HERE IN
01:15:16.245 --> 01:15:18.213
SOUTHERN CORNEA. WE OPPOSE THIS
01:15:18.280 --> 01:15:20.949
BILL. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. LINE
01:15:21.016 --> 01:15:25.687
2 82, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:15:25.754 --> 01:15:27.155
MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS PETER
01:15:27.222 --> 01:15:28.824
PAPADOPOULOS WITH THE MISSION
01:15:28.891 --> 01:15:30.225
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
01:15:30.292 --> 01:15:32.294
SERVING 5000 LOW TO MODERATE
01:15:32.361 --> 01:15:34.396
INCOME LATINO RESIDENTS THE YEAR
01:15:34.463 --> 01:15:34.930
AND WE ARE OPPOSED UNLESS
01:15:34.997 --> 01:15:39.201
AMENDED. THANK YOU. LINE. 57,
01:15:39.268 --> 01:15:44.840
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO KEISHA
01:15:44.907 --> 01:15:47.075
THOMAS PRESIDENT UNIFIED SCHOOL
01:15:47.142 --> 01:15:48.210
DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION. I
01:15:48.277 --> 01:15:49.678
AM AN OPPOSITION OF THIS. UM,
01:15:49.745 --> 01:15:54.116
THANK YOU. LINE 1 52, PLEASE GO
01:15:54.182 --> 01:15:59.254
AHEAD. MY NAME IS MARK FELT THE
01:15:59.321 --> 01:16:00.589
HEAT AND FROST INSULATORS LOCAL
01:16:00.656 --> 01:16:02.925
16 OF NORTHERN CALIFORNIA,
01:16:02.991 --> 01:16:03.558
STANDING WITH THE STATE BUILDING
01:16:03.625 --> 01:16:05.227
TRADES AND ALL OF ITS REALLY
01:16:05.294 --> 01:16:06.995
STRONG ADDITION TO A B 2011
01:16:07.062 --> 01:16:10.933
UNLESS PROPERLY AMENDED. LINE.
01:16:10.999 --> 01:16:16.071
27, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU.
01:16:16.138 --> 01:16:17.439
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS BURRITO
01:16:17.506 --> 01:16:18.974
ROBLES WITH THE SOUTHERN
01:16:19.041 --> 01:16:19.942
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT COUNCIL OF
01:16:20.008 --> 01:16:20.809
LABORERS. AND WE RESPECTFULLY
01:16:20.876 --> 01:16:24.713
OPPOSED THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
01:16:24.780 --> 01:16:25.881
AND MADAM CHAIR, NO FURTHER
01:16:25.948 --> 01:16:27.783
COMMENTS AND QUÊ. VERY GOOD.
01:16:27.849 --> 01:16:32.821
THAT. WAS VERY WELL DONE. I WANT
01:16:32.888 --> 01:16:34.189
TO THANK EVERYBODY WHO WHO
01:16:34.256 --> 01:16:35.857
TESTIFIED ON THE PHONE AND HERE
01:16:35.924 --> 01:16:37.993
IN PERSON, APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR
01:16:38.060 --> 01:16:39.661
PATIENTS AND ALSO UNDERSTAND
01:16:39.728 --> 01:16:41.396
THERE WAS MORE TO BE SAID. BUT
01:16:41.463 --> 01:16:43.365
WE, UM WERE TIME CONSTRAINTS SO
01:16:43.432 --> 01:16:46.101
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
01:16:46.168 --> 01:16:49.171
UM AND LET ME JUST SAY HERE
01:16:49.237 --> 01:16:51.573
TODAY THAT, UM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:16:51.640 --> 01:16:52.841
WICKS. I MEAN, YOU AND I HAVE
01:16:52.908 --> 01:16:54.576
HAD A NUMBER OF CONVERSATIONS.
01:16:54.643 --> 01:16:56.945
BOTH ABOUT THIS AND ABOUT MY
01:16:57.012 --> 01:16:58.780
BILL. THAT'S IN YOUR COMMITTEE.
01:16:58.847 --> 01:17:00.682
UM, SB SIX THAT THAT TAKE
01:17:00.749 --> 01:17:03.185
DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO, UM,
01:17:03.251 --> 01:17:04.820
TRYING TO SOLVE WITH WHAT IS AN
01:17:04.886 --> 01:17:08.056
INTRACTABLE PROBLEM. UM AND I
01:17:08.123 --> 01:17:09.491
THINK WE'RE BOTH COMMITTED TO
01:17:09.558 --> 01:17:10.959
TAKING THESE UNDERUTILIZED
01:17:11.026 --> 01:17:13.061
PROPERTIES AND DOING INFILL AND
01:17:13.128 --> 01:17:14.563
DOING IT IN A WAY THAT, UM,
01:17:14.629 --> 01:17:15.731
CREATES THE GREATEST OPPORTUNITY
01:17:15.797 --> 01:17:17.232
FOR HOUSING, BUT ALSO PROTECTS
01:17:17.299 --> 01:17:22.571
AND. AH AND MAKE MAKE SURE THAT
01:17:22.637 --> 01:17:24.139
WE'RE BUILDING THE LABOR FORCE
01:17:24.206 --> 01:17:26.208
THAT WE REALLY NEED. AND IF WE
01:17:26.274 --> 01:17:28.710
DO IT RIGHT, THEN WE END UP WITH
01:17:28.777 --> 01:17:30.612
GOOD RESULTS IN TERMS OF CLIMATE
01:17:30.679 --> 01:17:32.214
CHANGE AND THE ABILITY TO
01:17:32.280 --> 01:17:33.615
ECONOMICALLY REALLY ECONOMICALLY
01:17:33.682 --> 01:17:34.583
STIMULATE AREAS THAT ARE NOT
01:17:34.649 --> 01:17:39.454
DOING VERY WELL. SO UM, MY, UM.
01:17:39.521 --> 01:17:43.225
UM RECOMMENDATION IS A DO PASS,
01:17:43.291 --> 01:17:44.960
AND BOTH OF OUR BILLS WILL GO TO
01:17:45.027 --> 01:17:45.560
APPROPRIATIONS. AND THEN WE'LL
01:17:45.627 --> 01:17:47.796
SPEND JULY DOING NOTHING BUT
01:17:47.863 --> 01:17:49.731
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT? UM
01:17:49.798 --> 01:17:52.701
WHAT A COMPROMISE IS TO SEE IF
01:17:52.768 --> 01:17:54.403
WE CAN REACH ONE, SO I REALLY
01:17:54.469 --> 01:17:57.272
APPRECIATE YOU. PRESENTING THE
01:17:57.339 --> 01:17:58.807
BILL HERE TODAY AND ALL THE WORK
01:17:58.874 --> 01:18:00.409
THAT YOU'VE DONE AND KNOW THAT
01:18:00.475 --> 01:18:01.777
WE HAVE DIFFERENT APPROACHES TO
01:18:01.843 --> 01:18:04.112
IT, AND WE'LL HOPEFULLY BE ABLE
01:18:04.179 --> 01:18:05.714
TO GET EVERYBODY TO THE TABLE TO
01:18:05.781 --> 01:18:07.115
RESOLVE THEM. SO I APPRECIATE
01:18:07.182 --> 01:18:08.884
IT. ARE THERE ANY OTHER COMMENTS
01:18:08.950 --> 01:18:12.354
OR MM. SENATOR WIENER. YEAH
01:18:12.421 --> 01:18:14.856
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND I, UM
01:18:14.923 --> 01:18:15.857
AS THE CHAIR OF THE FIRST
01:18:15.924 --> 01:18:17.893
COMMITTEE THIS WENT THROUGH AND
01:18:17.959 --> 01:18:18.593
MADAME SARAH AND I ARE, BUT
01:18:18.660 --> 01:18:20.328
WE'RE BOTH. IT'S GREAT THAT
01:18:20.395 --> 01:18:22.030
WE'RE BOTH ON BOTH COMMITTEES
01:18:22.097 --> 01:18:22.998
AND SO CAN WORK TOGETHER. AND I
01:18:23.065 --> 01:18:24.599
APPRECIATE THE CHAIRS. UM YOU
01:18:24.666 --> 01:18:26.134
KNOW, SUPPORTED MOVING THIS OUT
01:18:26.201 --> 01:18:29.004
OF COMMITTEE AND I'M A CO AUTHOR
01:18:29.071 --> 01:18:31.339
OF THIS BILL, AND I KNOW IT'S
01:18:31.406 --> 01:18:32.407
BEEN HAVING BEEN IMMERSED IN
01:18:32.474 --> 01:18:36.845
SOME OF THE UM, LABOR RELATED
01:18:36.912 --> 01:18:39.347
DISPUTES ON HOUSING BILLS FOR A
01:18:39.414 --> 01:18:41.716
NUMBER OF YEARS. NOW IT'S
01:18:41.783 --> 01:18:43.185
COMPLICATED AND IT'S GOTTEN MUCH
01:18:43.251 --> 01:18:44.719
MORE COMPLICATED THIS YEAR.
01:18:44.786 --> 01:18:46.221
THERE ARE NOW I BELIEVE FIVE
01:18:46.288 --> 01:18:48.356
DIFFERENT VERSIONS OF LABOR,
01:18:48.423 --> 01:18:49.524
LANGUAGE AND HOUSING BILLS
01:18:49.591 --> 01:18:50.959
CIRCULATING IN THE LEGISLATURE.
01:18:51.026 --> 01:18:52.861
I THINK IT'S FIVE AT THIS POINT.
01:18:52.928 --> 01:18:57.099
UM AND THAT IS HAS CREATED SOME
01:18:57.165 --> 01:18:58.767
REAL TENSIONS AND IT BECOMES A
01:18:58.834 --> 01:19:00.936
LITTLE BIT CHAOTIC. BUT AS I
01:19:01.002 --> 01:19:01.870
SAID IN HOUSING COMMITTEE OUT OF
01:19:01.937 --> 01:19:04.840
CHAOS WE HOPE COMES ORDER AND I
01:19:04.906 --> 01:19:08.577
THINK WE NOW HAVE ANOTHER.
01:19:08.643 --> 01:19:11.580
REALLY 45 DAYS TO SEE IF THERE
01:19:11.646 --> 01:19:13.882
CAN BE SOME SORT OF RESOLUTION,
01:19:13.949 --> 01:19:17.419
UM, ON THESE ISSUES, AND THAT'S
01:19:17.486 --> 01:19:18.487
LONG OVERDUE BECAUSE THE THING
01:19:18.553 --> 01:19:22.157
IS WHAT I YOU KNOW WHAT I KNOW
01:19:22.224 --> 01:19:23.959
TO BE TRUE WHEN WE TALK ABOUT
01:19:24.025 --> 01:19:26.261
HOUSING ADVOCATES AND ALL ALL OF
01:19:26.328 --> 01:19:29.764
LABOR, UM AND, UM, WE ALL BOTTOM
01:19:29.831 --> 01:19:33.502
LINE. I WANT THE SAME THING. WE
01:19:33.568 --> 01:19:35.437
WANT A LOT MORE HOUSING TO BE
01:19:35.504 --> 01:19:36.838
BUILT SO THAT YOU KNOW, PEOPLE
01:19:36.905 --> 01:19:39.241
HAVE A PLACE TO LIVE. UM, WE
01:19:39.307 --> 01:19:44.179
WANT UH, THAT TO BE GOOD WORK
01:19:44.246 --> 01:19:46.948
AND GOOD PAYING JOBS WITH, YOU
01:19:47.015 --> 01:19:48.683
KNOW FOR WORKERS SO THAT
01:19:48.750 --> 01:19:50.252
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS ARE NOT
01:19:50.318 --> 01:19:52.420
LIVING IN POVERTY. I THINK WE
01:19:52.487 --> 01:19:54.322
ALL WANT THE SAME THINGS. IN THE
01:19:54.389 --> 01:19:55.690
END. THE QUESTION IS HOW DO WE
01:19:55.757 --> 01:19:56.992
GET THERE? AND IT'S PAINFUL, BUT
01:19:57.058 --> 01:19:59.494
I MY HOPE IS THAT WE WILL GET
01:19:59.561 --> 01:20:00.662
THERE. BUT BOTTOM LINE PUTTING
01:20:00.729 --> 01:20:03.231
THE DISCUSSIONS AROUND LABOR
01:20:03.298 --> 01:20:04.366
STANDARDS, WHICH ARE IMPORTANT
01:20:04.432 --> 01:20:05.867
PUTTING THAT ASIDE FOR THE
01:20:05.934 --> 01:20:08.503
MOMENT TO FOCUS ON THE HOUSING
01:20:08.570 --> 01:20:14.009
PIECE OF IT. UM, WE I JUST I
01:20:14.075 --> 01:20:15.610
THINK SOMETIMES WE GET PEOPLE
01:20:15.677 --> 01:20:17.512
GET NAM TO THE FACT OF IT. WE
01:20:17.579 --> 01:20:18.747
HAVE A HOUSING PROCESS WITH THE
01:20:18.813 --> 01:20:20.849
HOUSING CRISIS. HOUSING CRISIS,
01:20:20.916 --> 01:20:22.484
IS IT? THOSE ARE WORDS AND WE
01:20:22.551 --> 01:20:24.986
USE THE WORD CRISIS A LOT FOR A
01:20:25.053 --> 01:20:27.856
LOT OF THINGS, BUT YOU KNOW IT
01:20:27.923 --> 01:20:29.024
IS DOING SUCH DEEP, LONG TERM
01:20:29.090 --> 01:20:30.058
DAMAGE TO THE FABRIC,
01:20:30.125 --> 01:20:33.795
CALIFORNIA. THAT THIS IS A STATE
01:20:33.862 --> 01:20:35.630
NOW WHERE WE HAVE SO MANY
01:20:35.697 --> 01:20:38.066
CALIFORNIANS WHO ARE REALLY JUST
01:20:38.133 --> 01:20:39.868
WONDERING, CAN I ACTUALLY STAY
01:20:39.935 --> 01:20:42.604
HERE? LIKE CAN I MAKE A LIFE FOR
01:20:42.671 --> 01:20:44.739
ME AND FOR MY CURRENT OR MY
01:20:44.806 --> 01:20:48.410
FUTURE? FAMILY HERE. AND DO I
01:20:48.476 --> 01:20:51.413
NEED TO MOVE SOMEWHERE ELSE, AND
01:20:51.479 --> 01:20:53.615
IT'S JUST REALLY DEVASTATING.
01:20:53.682 --> 01:20:54.916
AND YES TO THE HOMELESSNESS IS
01:20:54.983 --> 01:20:57.219
THE MOST VISIBLE ASPECT OF IT.
01:20:57.285 --> 01:21:00.822
BUT IT GOES SO FAR BEYOND THAT,
01:21:00.889 --> 01:21:02.691
UM TO YOU KNOW, THE PEOPLE WHO
01:21:02.757 --> 01:21:04.192
YOU KNOW THEIR KIDS HAVE
01:21:04.259 --> 01:21:04.793
CONSTANT TURNOVER OF TEACHERS
01:21:04.859 --> 01:21:05.927
BECAUSE TEACHERS JUST THERE'S
01:21:05.994 --> 01:21:10.999
NOWHERE. FOR THEM TO LIVE OR,
01:21:11.066 --> 01:21:13.635
YOU KNOW, SERVICE WORKERS WHO I
01:21:13.702 --> 01:21:14.970
YOU KNOW, I'M ALWAYS IN AWE WHEN
01:21:15.036 --> 01:21:17.239
I KNOW WHAT YOU KNOW AT A
01:21:17.305 --> 01:21:19.140
STARBUCKS AND YOU AND YOU KNOW,
01:21:19.207 --> 01:21:20.942
AND I KNOW THAT SOME OF THE
01:21:21.009 --> 01:21:22.544
WORKERS THAT ARE LIVING IN SAN
01:21:22.611 --> 01:21:24.212
FRANCISCO I WONDER HOW ON EARTH
01:21:24.279 --> 01:21:25.513
ARE THEY DOING? I KNOW HOW
01:21:25.580 --> 01:21:26.715
THEY'RE DOING IT. THEY PROBABLY
01:21:26.781 --> 01:21:28.250
ARE LIVING WITH A BUNCH OF
01:21:28.316 --> 01:21:29.551
ROOMMATES OR LIVING IN UNSTABLE
01:21:29.618 --> 01:21:31.019
SITUATION. AND IF WE DON'T FIX
01:21:31.086 --> 01:21:32.587
THIS AGGRESSIVELY AND STOP
01:21:32.654 --> 01:21:34.089
NIBBLING AROUND THE EDGES,
01:21:34.155 --> 01:21:35.757
AGGRESSIVELY FIX THIS BY SAYING,
01:21:35.824 --> 01:21:38.526
WE NEED MILLIONS OF NO NEW HOMES
01:21:38.593 --> 01:21:40.428
AND WE'RE GOING TO DO IT. AND
01:21:40.495 --> 01:21:42.330
WE'RE GOING TO DO IT. AS SOON AS
01:21:42.397 --> 01:21:43.565
POSSIBLE IF WE DON'T GET ALL
01:21:43.632 --> 01:21:46.234
UNITED AND COMMITTED TO SOLVING
01:21:46.301 --> 01:21:48.837
THIS PROBLEM, IT IS GOING TO DO
01:21:48.903 --> 01:21:51.339
PERMANENT DAMAGE TO CALIFORNIA'S
01:21:51.406 --> 01:21:53.141
STATUS AS A DIVERSE, INNOVATIVE
01:21:53.208 --> 01:21:55.877
ECONOMIC POWERHOUSE, NOT THE
01:21:55.944 --> 01:21:57.012
DISABILITIES, A SILVER BULLET.
01:21:57.078 --> 01:21:59.881
THIS IS ONE PIECE OF IT. BUT I'M
01:21:59.948 --> 01:22:02.050
HOPING THAT THIS BILL WILL PLAY
01:22:02.117 --> 01:22:03.084
A ROLE IN FACILITATING
01:22:03.151 --> 01:22:04.953
RESOLUTION OF THE LABOR ISSUES
01:22:05.020 --> 01:22:06.621
SO WE CAN ALL LOCK ARMS AND JUST
01:22:06.688 --> 01:22:09.124
BUILD A TON OF NEW HOUSING, AND
01:22:09.190 --> 01:22:10.292
I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL.
01:22:10.358 --> 01:22:11.926
OKAY. WE NEED TO TAKE THE ROLE
01:22:11.993 --> 01:22:14.029
FIRST. SO WE'LL TAKE A BREAK AND
01:22:14.095 --> 01:22:15.363
TAKE THE, UH, ESTABLISHED A
01:22:15.430 --> 01:22:17.132
QUORUM AND THEN I'LL ALLOW YOU
01:22:17.198 --> 01:22:18.300
TO MAKE THAT MOTION. UM SO
01:22:18.366 --> 01:22:21.970
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
01:22:22.037 --> 01:22:24.472
CABALLERO HERE CABALLERO
01:22:24.539 --> 01:22:28.576
PRESIDENT NIELSEN. NIELSEN
01:22:28.643 --> 01:22:29.144
PRESIDENT DURAZO, HERZBERG
01:22:29.210 --> 01:22:33.148
WIENER. WIENER PRESENT. YOU HAVE
01:22:33.214 --> 01:22:36.017
A QUORUM. WE DO HAVE A QUORUM.
01:22:36.084 --> 01:22:39.087
THE UH, SENATOR MOVES THE BILL
01:22:39.154 --> 01:22:40.622
SO WELL, UM, SENATOR NIELSEN.
01:22:40.689 --> 01:22:42.390
DID YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
01:22:42.457 --> 01:22:45.260
COMMENTS TO MAKE CALIFORNIA IS
01:22:45.327 --> 01:22:47.395
GETTING EXACTLY WHAT IT IS
01:22:47.462 --> 01:22:48.463
DESERVED FOR DECADES OF
01:22:48.530 --> 01:22:52.033
OVERREGULATION. THAT'S THE
01:22:52.100 --> 01:22:53.668
BIGGEST REASON WE DO NOT HAVE
01:22:53.735 --> 01:22:54.736
HOUSING SUFFICIENT IN THIS
01:22:54.803 --> 01:22:57.539
STATE. FEDERAL STATE LOCAL
01:22:57.605 --> 01:23:01.910
REGULATIONS. I LOST SOME OF MY
01:23:01.976 --> 01:23:05.480
FAMILY TO COLORADO. AND I'M
01:23:05.547 --> 01:23:06.715
CHEERFUL FOR THEM BECAUSE THEY
01:23:06.781 --> 01:23:07.916
COULD NEVER, EVER AFFORD THEY
01:23:07.982 --> 01:23:10.985
FELT AS HIGH LEVEL. US NPS
01:23:11.052 --> 01:23:12.954
RANGERS TO BUY A HOME IN MARIN
01:23:13.021 --> 01:23:16.157
COUNTY. SO CALIFORNIA'S GETTING
01:23:16.224 --> 01:23:17.659
WHAT IT DESERVES. NOW, THIS IS A
01:23:17.726 --> 01:23:20.695
STEP BACK A TURNAROUND AND I
01:23:20.762 --> 01:23:22.630
SURELY HOPE THAT WE CAN INDEED
01:23:22.697 --> 01:23:24.933
MOVE AHEAD. THERE'S MORE TO BE
01:23:24.999 --> 01:23:27.669
DONE AND FOR SURE, BUT THIS IS A
01:23:27.736 --> 01:23:28.737
BIG AND POSITIVE STEP. I'M VERY
01:23:28.803 --> 01:23:30.572
HAPPY TO SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY
01:23:30.638 --> 01:23:33.141
MUCH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WEEKS.
01:23:33.208 --> 01:23:35.677
YOU MAY CONCLUDE I WANT TO THANK
01:23:35.744 --> 01:23:37.879
YOU, MADAM CHAIR AS WELL AS THE
01:23:37.946 --> 01:23:38.780
OTHER MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY
01:23:38.847 --> 01:23:39.714
HAD EXTENSIVE CONVERSATIONS WITH
01:23:39.781 --> 01:23:41.116
EVERYONE ON THIS COMMITTEE. UM
01:23:41.182 --> 01:23:43.885
AND FRANKLY, EVERYONE IN EVERY
01:23:43.952 --> 01:23:45.854
COMMITTEE AND ALL MEMBERS OF THE
01:23:45.920 --> 01:23:47.021
LEGISLATURE AS WELL AS MANY,
01:23:47.088 --> 01:23:47.789
MANY STAKEHOLDERS. I WILL SAY
01:23:47.856 --> 01:23:49.724
THIS IS PROBABLY THE BILL. I'VE
01:23:49.791 --> 01:23:50.825
SPENT THE MOST TIME WORKING ON
01:23:50.892 --> 01:23:52.494
IN MY LEGISLATIVE CAREER,
01:23:52.560 --> 01:23:54.162
BECAUSE OF ALL THE REASONS
01:23:54.229 --> 01:23:55.330
DISCUSSED TODAY, AND I JUST WANT
01:23:55.397 --> 01:23:57.432
TO SAY THE GOAL OF THE BILL. UM
01:23:57.499 --> 01:23:59.701
REMAINS FOR WHAT YOU ALL SAID.
01:23:59.768 --> 01:24:02.203
WE HAVE GROWING ENCAMPMENTS AT
01:24:02.270 --> 01:24:03.738
ALL OF OUR FREEWAY UNDERPASSES
01:24:03.805 --> 01:24:05.340
AND OFF RAMPS. YOU KNOW, WE
01:24:05.407 --> 01:24:09.444
HAVE, UM YOU KNOW, IN THE BAY
01:24:09.511 --> 01:24:10.979
AREA REALTOR S<c.cyan> DRIVE TILL YOU</c>
01:24:11.045 --> 01:24:12.747
QUALIFY. IF YOU WANT TO BUY A
01:24:12.814 --> 01:24:15.083
HOUSE, SO IF YOU WORK IN SAN
01:24:15.150 --> 01:24:15.717
FRANCISCO, OAKLAND AND BERKELEY,
01:24:15.784 --> 01:24:16.618
YOU'RE LIVING IN TRACY OR
01:24:16.684 --> 01:24:17.786
BEYOND, AND YOU'RE SPENDING FOUR
01:24:17.852 --> 01:24:19.654
HOURS A DAY ON THE ROAD. WHICH
01:24:19.721 --> 01:24:21.623
EXACERBATES OUR HOUSING CRISIS.
01:24:21.689 --> 01:24:23.958
AS YOU ALL KNOW, UM, YOU KNOW SO
01:24:24.025 --> 01:24:25.026
MANY RENT BURDENED PEOPLE,
01:24:25.093 --> 01:24:25.827
PEOPLE GETTING EVICTED PEOPLE
01:24:25.894 --> 01:24:27.162
UNABLE TO PAY THEIR MORTGAGES
01:24:27.228 --> 01:24:28.897
ALL OF THE CHALLENGES THAT WE
01:24:28.963 --> 01:24:30.031
HAVE, AND SO THE GOAL, AS
01:24:30.098 --> 01:24:32.100
ARTICULATED BY ALL OF YOU IS TO
01:24:32.167 --> 01:24:34.002
ENSURE WE HAVE MORE NECESSARY
01:24:34.068 --> 01:24:35.103
HOUSING PRODUCTION, BUT ALSO
01:24:35.170 --> 01:24:36.671
DOING SO IN A WAY THAT REALLY
01:24:36.738 --> 01:24:38.406
HONORS OUR WORKFORCE. WE HAVE TO
01:24:38.473 --> 01:24:39.607
CRACK DOWN ON THE WAGE THEFT
01:24:39.674 --> 01:24:41.476
THAT WE KNOW EXISTS. THESE WILL
01:24:41.543 --> 01:24:42.777
BE THE STRONGEST WAGE THEFT. A
01:24:42.844 --> 01:24:44.145
MEASURES IN THE COUNTRY AND
01:24:44.212 --> 01:24:45.613
CONTINUE TO BUILD OUR UNION
01:24:45.680 --> 01:24:47.282
WORKFORCE. SO, WITH ALL OF THAT,
01:24:47.348 --> 01:24:48.650
I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
01:24:48.716 --> 01:24:50.685
VOTE AND I LOOK FORWARD TO MORE
01:24:50.752 --> 01:24:51.686
CONVERSATION. SENATOR YOU'RE A
01:24:51.753 --> 01:24:52.787
GREAT THOUGHT. PARTNER IN THIS
01:24:52.854 --> 01:24:54.923
SPACE. I REALLY I ADMIRE YOUR
01:24:54.989 --> 01:24:57.025
LEADERSHIP AND AGREE WITH YOU. I
01:24:57.091 --> 01:24:58.126
THINK WE SHARE THE SAME GOALS
01:24:58.193 --> 01:25:00.028
AND HOPEFULLY WE CAN COME TO
01:25:00.094 --> 01:25:01.229
SOME KIND OF AGREEMENT. ALSO, AS
01:25:01.296 --> 01:25:03.198
YOU SAID, MR HOUSING CHAIR TO
01:25:03.264 --> 01:25:04.165
FIGURE OUT A STANDARD THAT CAN
01:25:04.232 --> 01:25:06.167
WORK FOR EVERYONE SO THAT WE CAN
01:25:06.234 --> 01:25:08.403
LOCK ARMS AND DO THE WORK THAT
01:25:08.470 --> 01:25:10.305
WE NEED TO DO FOR THE STATE OF
01:25:10.371 --> 01:25:11.339
CALIFORNIA. SO WITH THAT,
01:25:11.406 --> 01:25:12.407
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE.
01:25:12.474 --> 01:25:13.608
VERY GOOD. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:25:13.675 --> 01:25:15.810
MOTION IS TO PASS. BUT FIRST WE
01:25:15.877 --> 01:25:17.679
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:25:17.745 --> 01:25:18.179
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
01:25:18.246 --> 01:25:22.517
CABALLERO, Hí
01:25:22.584 --> 01:25:23.785
, DURAZO, HERZBERG WIENER
01:25:23.852 --> 01:25:29.591
WIENER. AYE. 303 TO 0. WE'LL PUT
01:25:29.657 --> 01:25:30.792
THAT ON CALL FOR THE MISSING
01:25:30.859 --> 01:25:32.827
MEMBERS. UM NEXT, WE'RE GONNA
01:25:32.894 --> 01:25:34.863
TAKE UP FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO,
01:25:34.929 --> 01:25:36.865
WHICH IS A B 23 34
01:25:36.931 --> 01:25:37.932
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS. THAT IS
01:25:37.999 --> 01:25:39.300
YOUR BILL AS WELL. THANK YOU,
01:25:39.367 --> 01:25:42.437
MADAM CHAIR. AND I WANT TO THANK
01:25:42.504 --> 01:25:45.974
THE COMMITTEE STAFF. CALIFORNIA
01:25:46.040 --> 01:25:47.108
CURRENTLY HAS A GAP OF 1.2
01:25:47.175 --> 01:25:48.376
MILLION HOMES AFFORDABLE TO
01:25:48.443 --> 01:25:49.844
STRUGGLING LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS
01:25:49.911 --> 01:25:51.980
WITH ROUGHLY 160,000 PEOPLE
01:25:52.046 --> 01:25:53.147
HOMELESS ON OUR STREETS AT ANY
01:25:53.214 --> 01:25:55.016
GIVEN MOMENT, WHILE THIS MOST
01:25:55.083 --> 01:25:55.984
SIGNIFICANT BARRIER TO THE
01:25:56.050 --> 01:25:57.552
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE
01:25:57.619 --> 01:25:58.987
HOUSING IS A LACK OF PUBLIC
01:25:59.053 --> 01:25:59.621
FUNDING, LAND USE POLICY ALSO
01:25:59.687 --> 01:26:00.722
SIGNIFICANTLY LIMITS THE AMOUNT
01:26:00.788 --> 01:26:02.991
OF UNITS THAT CAN BE BUILT. IN
01:26:03.057 --> 01:26:05.960
2019 80 17 63 BY
01:26:06.027 --> 01:26:07.428
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TO AMENDED
01:26:07.495 --> 01:26:09.697
STATE BONUS STATE DENSITY BONUS
01:26:09.764 --> 01:26:11.699
SLOT TO ALLOW 100% AFFORDABLE
01:26:11.766 --> 01:26:13.201
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS UNLIMITED
01:26:13.268 --> 01:26:14.736
DENSITY FOR DEVELOPMENTS WITHIN
01:26:14.802 --> 01:26:15.770
ONE HALF MILE OF MAJOR TRANSIT
01:26:15.837 --> 01:26:17.539
STOPS OR HIGH QUALITY BUS
01:26:17.605 --> 01:26:20.508
CORRIDORS. MAYBE 23 34 BUILDS ON
01:26:20.575 --> 01:26:22.911
RECENT IMPROVEMENTS TO A B 17 63
01:26:22.977 --> 01:26:24.712
BY ALLOWING 100% AFFORDABLE
01:26:24.779 --> 01:26:26.214
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS TO RECEIVE
01:26:26.281 --> 01:26:27.715
AN ADDITIONAL INCENTIVE FROM THE
01:26:27.782 --> 01:26:28.883
LOCAL AGENCY ADDED HEIGHT AND
01:26:28.950 --> 01:26:30.752
WE'RE DENSITY OF THE PROJECT IS
01:26:30.818 --> 01:26:32.687
LOCATED IN AN URBANIZED VERY LOW
01:26:32.754 --> 01:26:34.722
V AREA. THE BILL DEFINES A VERY
01:26:34.789 --> 01:26:37.091
LOW V AREA AS AN URBANIZED AREA
01:26:37.158 --> 01:26:37.825
WHERE THE EXISTING RESIDENTIAL
01:26:37.892 --> 01:26:39.994
DEVELOPMENT GENERATES VM T PER
01:26:40.061 --> 01:26:42.130
CAPITA THAT IS BELOW 85% OF
01:26:42.196 --> 01:26:43.164
REGIONAL OF EITHER REGIONAL V
01:26:43.231 --> 01:26:46.100
PER CAPITA. OR CITY V PER CAPITA
01:26:46.167 --> 01:26:47.035
. THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF
01:26:47.101 --> 01:26:48.603
PLANNING AND RESEARCH WILL BE
01:26:48.670 --> 01:26:50.204
RELEASING MAPS WITH REGIONAL
01:26:50.271 --> 01:26:51.005
VIEW CALCULATIONS AT THE
01:26:51.072 --> 01:26:51.806
METROPOLITAN PLANNING
01:26:51.873 --> 01:26:53.841
ORGANIZATION LEVEL IN THE COMING
01:26:53.908 --> 01:26:56.044
MONTHS. THESE MAPS ARE BASED ON
01:26:56.110 --> 01:26:57.145
LOCAL TRAVEL DEMAND MODELS
01:26:57.211 --> 01:26:58.212
DEVELOPED BY JURISDICTIONS THAT
01:26:58.279 --> 01:26:59.280
HAVE PRODUCED THEIR OWN MAPS OF
01:26:59.347 --> 01:27:01.749
E M. T. OPR IS SIMPLY A
01:27:01.816 --> 01:27:03.618
CLEARINGHOUSE FOR THE LOCAL MAPS
01:27:03.685 --> 01:27:06.220
USING THE DATA BASED ON OPR IS
01:27:06.287 --> 01:27:08.189
USING THE DATABASE THAT OPR IS
01:27:08.256 --> 01:27:09.624
CREATING DEVELOPERS AND CITIES
01:27:09.691 --> 01:27:11.125
WILL BE ABLE TO CITE CHECK
01:27:11.192 --> 01:27:12.660
PARCELS IF THEY SEE IF THEY
01:27:12.727 --> 01:27:14.896
QUALIFY FOR LOW V M. T. THE
01:27:14.963 --> 01:27:16.564
ANALYSIS SUGGESTS TAKING OUT THE
01:27:16.631 --> 01:27:18.032
VM T REQUIREMENT AND RATHER
01:27:18.099 --> 01:27:19.367
APPLYING THE ADDITIONAL HEIGHT
01:27:19.434 --> 01:27:21.102
AND DENSITY AND URBANIZED AREA.
01:27:21.169 --> 01:27:22.804
THE REASON WE CHOOSE. WE CHOSE
01:27:22.870 --> 01:27:24.672
VERY LOW BMT AND URBANIZED AREAS
01:27:24.739 --> 01:27:26.708
IS THAT THOSE SITES ARE MORE
01:27:26.774 --> 01:27:28.309
LOCATION EFFICIENT AND SHOULD
01:27:28.376 --> 01:27:29.644
HELP TO REDUCE OUR GREENHOUSE
01:27:29.711 --> 01:27:30.545
GAS CONSUMPTION. ONE OF THE KEY
01:27:30.612 --> 01:27:32.847
CHALLENGES FACING OUR STATE I'D
01:27:32.914 --> 01:27:34.482
ALSO LIKE TO FLAG THE STATE
01:27:34.549 --> 01:27:35.083
BUILDING TRADES HAVE REMOVED
01:27:35.149 --> 01:27:37.085
THEIR OPPOSITION AND ARE NOW
01:27:37.151 --> 01:27:38.019
NEUTRAL ON THE BILL. THE BILL
01:27:38.086 --> 01:27:38.653
ADDRESSES THE HOUSING,
01:27:38.720 --> 01:27:40.121
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS AND FURTHER
01:27:40.188 --> 01:27:41.522
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY
01:27:41.589 --> 01:27:42.890
GOALS BY INCREASING THE UNIVERSE
01:27:42.957 --> 01:27:43.858
OF SITES AVAILABLE FOR
01:27:43.925 --> 01:27:44.792
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS
01:27:44.859 --> 01:27:45.927
THAT ARE SO DESPERATELY NEEDED.
01:27:45.994 --> 01:27:47.762
I ALSO WANT TO MENTION THAT YOU
01:27:47.829 --> 01:27:49.130
KNOW, WE'VE HAD MADAM CHAIR
01:27:49.197 --> 01:27:50.598
CONVERSATIONS AS OF THIS MORNING
01:27:50.665 --> 01:27:52.000
, SO I'M GOING TO BE MAKING
01:27:52.066 --> 01:27:54.202
AMENDMENTS TO THE BILL TO NARROW
01:27:54.268 --> 01:27:56.371
THE BILL TO APPLY ONLY TO THE
01:27:56.437 --> 01:27:58.272
NINE BARRIER COUNTIES PLUS LOS
01:27:58.339 --> 01:27:59.574
ANGELES, SANTA BARBARA VENTURA.
01:27:59.641 --> 01:28:00.842
SAN BERNARDINO, RIVERSIDE,
01:28:00.908 --> 01:28:02.110
ORANGE AND SAN DIEGO COUNTY'S
01:28:02.176 --> 01:28:03.111
ALL OTHER COUNTIES WILL BE
01:28:03.177 --> 01:28:06.214
EXCLUDED FROM THE BILL. AND WITH
01:28:06.280 --> 01:28:08.249
ME OR TO TESTIFY IS NEVADA
01:28:08.316 --> 01:28:09.550
MERRIMAN FROM MID PEN HOUSING
01:28:09.617 --> 01:28:11.552
AND MARIA WINE FROM THE HOUSE IN
01:28:11.619 --> 01:28:12.787
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM.
01:28:12.854 --> 01:28:14.322
VERY GOOD. WELCOME THANK YOU
01:28:14.389 --> 01:28:15.823
AGAIN. GOOD MORNING. WE'RE GONNA
01:28:15.890 --> 01:28:17.358
WIN WITH THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
01:28:17.425 --> 01:28:18.559
CONSORTIUM. WE JUST HAD A VERY
01:28:18.626 --> 01:28:20.161
ROBUST DISCUSSION ABOUT THE NEED
01:28:20.228 --> 01:28:21.763
FOR MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AND
01:28:21.829 --> 01:28:23.931
MAYBE 23 34 ADDRESSES THIS
01:28:23.998 --> 01:28:25.433
CRISIS FROM A DIFFERENT ANGLE AT
01:28:25.500 --> 01:28:26.834
MERELY IS ADDING AN ADDITIONAL
01:28:26.901 --> 01:28:27.969
TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX FOR
01:28:28.036 --> 01:28:30.972
AFFORDABLE DEVELOPERS. UM AND
01:28:31.039 --> 01:28:33.241
INCENTIVIZES ADDITIONAL DENSITY
01:28:33.307 --> 01:28:34.842
IN AREAS THAT ARE LOW V M T. I
01:28:34.909 --> 01:28:36.811
KNOW THERE'S ALWAYS BEEN ALSO
01:28:36.878 --> 01:28:38.212
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSIONS IN THIS
01:28:38.279 --> 01:28:40.715
LEGISLATURE ABOUT THE ROLE THE
01:28:40.782 --> 01:28:41.916
APPROPRIATE ROLE FOR BMT
01:28:41.983 --> 01:28:44.152
ANALYSIS AND THIS IS ONE THAT WE
01:28:44.218 --> 01:28:45.153
THINK IS REALLY APPROPRIATE
01:28:45.219 --> 01:28:46.287
BECAUSE IT INSTEAD OF SORT OF
01:28:46.354 --> 01:28:47.655
CREATING CONSTRAINTS TO
01:28:47.722 --> 01:28:49.190
DEVELOPMENT ACTUALLY IS REALLY
01:28:49.257 --> 01:28:50.725
JUST TRYING TO INCENTIVIZE THAT
01:28:50.792 --> 01:28:53.327
THAT ADDITIONAL DENSITY IN AREAS
01:28:53.394 --> 01:28:54.662
THAT WILL ALSO HELP REDUCE OUR
01:28:54.729 --> 01:28:58.833
STAGE G H G. EMISSIONS THAT'S
01:28:58.900 --> 01:29:00.968
WHY THIS WE THINK THIS IS A
01:29:01.035 --> 01:29:03.071
LOVELY BILL AND, UM, BUILDS ON
01:29:03.137 --> 01:29:04.172
THE IMPROVEMENTS THAT WERE
01:29:04.238 --> 01:29:06.974
ALREADY CREATED IN 17 63. NEVADA
01:29:07.041 --> 01:29:08.209
WHO'S ON THE PHONE WILL TALK A
01:29:08.276 --> 01:29:10.344
BIT ABOUT HOW THEY'VE BEEN ABLE
01:29:10.411 --> 01:29:11.579
TO WORK WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
01:29:11.646 --> 01:29:13.614
TO UTILIZE DENSITY BONUS PROGRAM
01:29:13.681 --> 01:29:15.683
, UM, AND THE AND THE ADDITIONAL
01:29:15.750 --> 01:29:17.618
DENSITY THAT WAS CREATED 17 63
01:29:17.685 --> 01:29:19.620
AND 23 3 OR FOUR MERELY BUILDS
01:29:19.687 --> 01:29:20.621
ON THOSE IMPROVEMENTS AND
01:29:20.688 --> 01:29:22.290
ENSURES THAT IN COMMUNITIES THAT
01:29:22.356 --> 01:29:23.524
MIGHT NOT YET HAVE MAJOR TRANSIT
01:29:23.591 --> 01:29:26.427
STOPS. BUT DO YOU HAVE LOCATION
01:29:26.494 --> 01:29:28.663
EFFICIENT AREAS THAT CAN BENEFIT
01:29:28.730 --> 01:29:30.231
FROM ADDITIONAL DENSITY THEY'RE
01:29:30.298 --> 01:29:32.333
ABLE TO DO SO. FOR THESE REASONS
01:29:32.400 --> 01:29:34.035
. I URGE YOUR SUPPORT TODAY.
01:29:34.102 --> 01:29:39.040
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:29:39.107 --> 01:29:40.341
DO WE? WE HAVE NEVADA MERRIMAN
01:29:40.408 --> 01:29:43.711
THAT'S ON THE PHONE. WELCOME.
01:29:43.778 --> 01:29:45.146
YES. GOOD MORNING. THANK YOU,
01:29:45.213 --> 01:29:47.081
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS. NEVADA
01:29:47.148 --> 01:29:48.316
MERRIMAN, POLICY DIRECTOR FOR
01:29:48.382 --> 01:29:49.584
MIDTOWN HOUSING CORPORATIONS TO
01:29:49.650 --> 01:29:53.588
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
01:29:53.654 --> 01:29:55.790
BILL 23 34 AT MID 10 WE OWN AND
01:29:55.857 --> 01:29:58.092
MANAGE OVER 8300 AFFORDABLE
01:29:58.159 --> 01:29:59.627
RENTAL APARTMENT AND WE HAVE A
01:29:59.694 --> 01:30:00.828
DEVELOPMENT PIPELINE OF NEARLY
01:30:00.895 --> 01:30:02.563
5000 ADDITIONAL HOMES.
01:30:02.630 --> 01:30:04.332
THROUGHOUT THE 11 COUNTS
01:30:04.398 --> 01:30:04.832
THROUGHOUT 11 COUNTIES,
01:30:04.899 --> 01:30:05.666
INCLUDING THE SAN FRANCISCO
01:30:05.733 --> 01:30:09.737
MONTEREY BAY AREAS. LAST MARCH,
01:30:09.804 --> 01:30:11.372
MID 10 BROKE GROUND ON KIKU
01:30:11.439 --> 01:30:14.375
CROSSING 225 UNITS, INNOVATIVE,
01:30:14.442 --> 01:30:15.643
AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMUNITY
01:30:15.710 --> 01:30:17.211
ENVISIONS TO SERVE LOW INCOME
01:30:17.278 --> 01:30:19.180
FAMILIES, PUBLIC EMPLOYEES AND
01:30:19.247 --> 01:30:20.414
OTHER SPECIAL NEEDS POPULATIONS
01:30:20.481 --> 01:30:21.516
, INCLUDING MEN, WOMEN AND
01:30:21.582 --> 01:30:22.350
CHILDREN EXPERIENCING
01:30:22.416 --> 01:30:25.153
HOMELESSNESS. THIS COMMUNITY WAS
01:30:25.219 --> 01:30:26.687
DEVELOPED IN DEEP PARTNERSHIP
01:30:26.754 --> 01:30:27.989
WITH THE CITY OF SAN MATEO AS
01:30:28.055 --> 01:30:30.291
IT'S ON CITY ON LAND. IN
01:30:30.358 --> 01:30:31.793
ADDITION TO PROVIDING PREVAILING
01:30:31.859 --> 01:30:32.794
WAGE JOBS FOR THE 40 SOME
01:30:32.860 --> 01:30:35.696
BUILDING TRADES A MEETING
01:30:35.763 --> 01:30:36.330
AMBITIOUS SUSTAINABILITY GOALS
01:30:36.397 --> 01:30:39.066
WITH AN ALL ELECTRIC APPROACH.
01:30:39.133 --> 01:30:40.601
IT WAS AMONG THE VERY FIRST
01:30:40.668 --> 01:30:41.936
PROJECT TO BE ENTITLED USING
01:30:42.003 --> 01:30:43.070
STATE LAWS INCREASE THE NUMBER
01:30:43.137 --> 01:30:44.105
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNIT.
01:30:44.172 --> 01:30:48.709
ASSEMBLY BILL 17 63. SANITARY
01:30:48.776 --> 01:30:50.311
WAS EXCITED TO UTILIZE THIS NEW
01:30:50.378 --> 01:30:51.813
ENHANCED DENSITY BONUSES. THEY
01:30:51.879 --> 01:30:53.314
HAVE A HUGE LOCAL NEED FOR
01:30:53.381 --> 01:30:54.182
AFFORDABLE HOMES, BUT LIMITED
01:30:54.248 --> 01:30:55.917
SITES THAT ARE UNDER CITY
01:30:55.983 --> 01:30:57.819
CONTROL TO DEVELOP. CEMETERY
01:30:57.885 --> 01:30:59.987
BROUGHT THIS OPPORTUNITY TO MID
01:31:00.054 --> 01:31:01.222
10 AND EMBRACE THE
01:31:01.289 --> 01:31:02.423
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE BILL AS A
01:31:02.490 --> 01:31:03.991
TOOL THAT WOULD HELP THEM
01:31:04.058 --> 01:31:05.726
MAXIMIZE THE SCARCE AND PRESSES
01:31:05.793 --> 01:31:07.395
RESOURCE THAT THEY HAVE THEIR
01:31:07.461 --> 01:31:09.397
LAND. THE REVISED ENTITLEMENT
01:31:09.463 --> 01:31:11.365
PACKAGE HAD A NET OUT OF 61
01:31:11.432 --> 01:31:14.268
HOMES FOR A TOTAL OF 225, AND IT
01:31:14.335 --> 01:31:15.736
WAS SUBMITTED IN PROCESS PRETTY
01:31:15.803 --> 01:31:17.371
QUICKLY, WITH THE PROCEDURE
01:31:17.438 --> 01:31:17.972
STILL REQUIRING DISCRETIONARY
01:31:18.039 --> 01:31:18.973
ACTION BY THE PLANNING
01:31:19.040 --> 01:31:21.909
COMMISSION AND CITY COUNCIL. THE
01:31:21.976 --> 01:31:23.144
COUNCIL PROVIDED THEIR UNANIMOUS
01:31:23.211 --> 01:31:25.112
SUPPORT AND WAS PROUD BEYOND
01:31:25.179 --> 01:31:26.147
MEASURE, FORMER CEMETERY MAYOR
01:31:26.214 --> 01:31:27.615
JOE GOSSEL SAID IN THE
01:31:27.682 --> 01:31:29.650
STATEMENT. WE HAVE OVER 22,000
01:31:29.717 --> 01:31:30.685
UNITS IN THE DEVELOPMENT
01:31:30.751 --> 01:31:32.787
PIPELINE AND WITH THE HOUSING
01:31:32.854 --> 01:31:33.855
COMMUNITY THAT MID TENNIS
01:31:33.921 --> 01:31:34.922
BUILDING, WE'RE PROVIDING
01:31:34.989 --> 01:31:35.923
OPPORTUNITIES FOR EVERY INCOME
01:31:35.990 --> 01:31:39.227
LEVEL. BY EXPANDING THIS DENSITY
01:31:39.293 --> 01:31:41.729
BONUS PROVISION TO LOW BMT AREAS
01:31:41.796 --> 01:31:43.264
. A B 23 34 WOULD ALLOW MORE
01:31:43.331 --> 01:31:44.732
COMMUNITIES TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
01:31:44.799 --> 01:31:46.734
THIS CRITICAL TOOL, JUST LIKE
01:31:46.801 --> 01:31:48.302
CEMETERY DID AND INCREASE THE
01:31:48.369 --> 01:31:49.971
SUPPLY OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN
01:31:50.037 --> 01:31:51.239
AREAS THAT OFFER CONVENIENT
01:31:51.305 --> 01:31:52.240
ACCESS TO JOBS, RETAIL AND
01:31:52.306 --> 01:31:53.975
SERVICES. ALLOWING OUR LOW
01:31:54.041 --> 01:31:56.344
INCOME RESIDENTS TO DRIVE LIST
01:31:56.410 --> 01:31:57.211
AND REACH THEIR DAILY
01:31:57.278 --> 01:31:58.246
DESTINATIONS AND THE STATE. TO
01:31:58.312 --> 01:32:00.581
REACH ITS CLIMATE CHANGE COURSE.
01:32:00.648 --> 01:32:02.183
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND
01:32:02.250 --> 01:32:02.917
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE MID
01:32:02.984 --> 01:32:04.218
SENSE EXPERIENCE MOVING,
01:32:04.285 --> 01:32:05.753
CONSISTENT ACTION. HAPPY TO
01:32:05.820 --> 01:32:07.255
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AS NEEDED.
01:32:07.321 --> 01:32:08.723
THANK YOU AGAIN. THANK YOU VERY
01:32:08.789 --> 01:32:10.758
MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON NOW
01:32:10.825 --> 01:32:12.293
TO SUPPORT IN ROOM 2100. IS
01:32:12.360 --> 01:32:14.228
THERE ANY INDIVIDUAL THAT WOULD
01:32:14.295 --> 01:32:16.097
LIKE TO TEST FRANCE SPORT? GOOD
01:32:16.163 --> 01:32:16.964
MORNING, RAFINHA'S VARIANTS A OR
01:32:17.031 --> 01:32:18.900
B CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. THANK
01:32:18.966 --> 01:32:23.337
YOU. BURIAL AND SHAKE CALIFORNIA
01:32:23.404 --> 01:32:24.405
ASSOCIATION OF LOCAL HOUSING
01:32:24.472 --> 01:32:28.776
FINANCE AGENCY'S STRONG SUPPORT.
01:32:28.843 --> 01:32:30.278
ANYA LAWLER ON BEHALF OF THE
01:32:30.344 --> 01:32:31.479
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
01:32:31.545 --> 01:32:32.446
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN THE
01:32:32.513 --> 01:32:33.481
PUBLIC INTEREST LAW PROJECT AND
01:32:33.547 --> 01:32:34.615
THE WESTERN CENTRAL ON POVERTY
01:32:34.682 --> 01:32:40.388
AND SUPPORT. ADRIAN MOHAMMED
01:32:40.454 --> 01:32:41.555
WITH LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS
01:32:41.622 --> 01:32:45.893
ON BEHALF OF SPUR AND SUPPORT. A
01:32:45.960 --> 01:32:47.695
ROOM DÍAS AT THE NONPROFIT
01:32:47.762 --> 01:32:48.296
HOUSING ASSOCIATION, NORTHERN
01:32:48.362 --> 01:32:51.265
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT MARK'S
01:32:51.332 --> 01:32:52.266
DIVERS THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
01:32:52.333 --> 01:32:56.504
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT. MADAM
01:32:56.570 --> 01:32:58.139
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE,
01:32:58.205 --> 01:32:59.206
JOINING PANAGORA HIGH ON BEHALF
01:32:59.273 --> 01:33:01.208
OF CALIFORNIA, MB AND SUPPORT
01:33:01.275 --> 01:33:02.810
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
01:33:02.877 --> 01:33:06.847
ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2100? SAYING
01:33:06.914 --> 01:33:07.682
NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
01:33:07.748 --> 01:33:09.150
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
01:33:09.216 --> 01:33:10.818
MODERATOR, CAN YOU CUE UP
01:33:10.885 --> 01:33:12.653
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:33:12.720 --> 01:33:17.391
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF E B 23 34.
01:33:17.458 --> 01:33:18.926
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND IF
01:33:18.993 --> 01:33:20.728
THEY WOULD LIKE THIS SPEAKING
01:33:20.795 --> 01:33:24.699
COMMENT AND FAVOR OF A B 23 34
01:33:24.765 --> 01:33:26.801
PRESS 10 AND WE'LL GO TO LINE 2
01:33:26.867 --> 01:33:29.036
35, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:33:29.103 --> 01:33:30.504
MORNING, MRS PROFITS ON HIM
01:33:30.571 --> 01:33:31.639
FELLED A MEMBER OF SANTA CRUZ MP
01:33:31.706 --> 01:33:37.945
IN SUPPORT. NEXT WOULD LINE UP
01:33:38.012 --> 01:33:42.283
54. PLEASE GO AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR
01:33:42.350 --> 01:33:43.150
AND MEMBERS LAUREN DAY VALENCIA
01:33:43.217 --> 01:33:44.185
, REPRESENTING THE AMERICAN
01:33:44.251 --> 01:33:45.386
PLANNING ASSOCIATION, CALIFORNIA
01:33:45.453 --> 01:33:49.023
CHAPTER AND SUPPORT. KLEIN TO
01:33:49.090 --> 01:33:54.128
90. PLEASE GO AHEAD. BUTTER FROM
01:33:54.195 --> 01:33:56.097
CAMPBELL AND SENATE-DISTRICT 15%
01:33:56.163 --> 01:33:58.132
BILLION BE IN SUPPORT OF A B 23
01:33:58.199 --> 01:34:01.702
34. THANK YOU. LINE 2 72, PLEASE
01:34:01.769 --> 01:34:07.508
GO AHEAD. PRICE AND A HALF OF
01:34:07.575 --> 01:34:08.876
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION IN
01:34:08.943 --> 01:34:15.316
STRONG SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2334.
01:34:15.383 --> 01:34:17.351
NEXT GO TO LINE 3 19 319, PLEASE
01:34:17.418 --> 01:34:20.321
GO AHEAD. KIERAN AGGREY
01:34:20.388 --> 01:34:22.623
DEVELOPMENT INC IN OPPOSITION OF
01:34:22.690 --> 01:34:29.397
A B 28 40. AND WE WILL GO TO
01:34:29.463 --> 01:34:33.267
LINE 14. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:34:33.334 --> 01:34:36.003
ALISON SHALLOT CALLING ON BEHALF
01:34:36.070 --> 01:34:36.871
OF STORIES FROM FRONTLINE
01:34:36.937 --> 01:34:38.172
HOLLYWOOD FORWARD ON MYSELF,
01:34:38.239 --> 01:34:40.174
SIMPLE FAMILY HOME OWNER. 32
01:34:40.241 --> 01:34:43.544
YEARS. FALLING INTO STRONG
01:34:43.611 --> 01:34:50.217
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:34:50.284 --> 01:34:51.485
AND WE'LL GO TO LINE TWO. OH,
01:34:51.552 --> 01:34:56.323
EIGHT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. READY TO
01:34:56.390 --> 01:35:03.330
GO. NEXT GO TO LINE 1 91, PLEASE
01:35:03.397 --> 01:35:09.837
GO AHEAD. LINE 1 91. YOUR LINE
01:35:09.904 --> 01:35:14.341
IS OPEN. SCUSE ME. GOOD MORNING.
01:35:14.408 --> 01:35:15.810
SELLERS AGAIN. MATTHEW BAKER
01:35:15.876 --> 01:35:17.478
PLAYING CONCERT CONSERVATION
01:35:17.545 --> 01:35:22.483
LEÓN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:35:22.550 --> 01:35:23.751
LITTLE LINE AT 2 33. PLEASE GO
01:35:23.818 --> 01:35:30.324
AHEAD. 0.2 33. YOUR LINE IS
01:35:30.391 --> 01:35:38.432
OPEN. 20 AND WE WILL MOVE TO
01:35:38.499 --> 01:35:41.969
LINE 2 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:35:42.036 --> 01:35:43.871
TIMES LIKE THE NERDY AND
01:35:43.938 --> 01:35:45.005
AFFILIATION TO SURRENDER IN L, A
01:35:45.072 --> 01:35:46.807
COUNTY AND I HAVE BEEN
01:35:46.874 --> 01:35:51.779
SUPPORTED. WE'LL GO TO LINE 78,
01:35:51.846 --> 01:35:56.517
PLEASE GO AHEAD. JORDAN GRINDS
01:35:56.584 --> 01:35:57.418
ON BEHALF OF PENINSULA FOR
01:35:57.485 --> 01:36:01.188
EVERYONE AND STRONG SUPPORT. AND
01:36:01.255 --> 01:36:02.423
MADAM CHAIR, NO FURTHER COMMENTS
01:36:02.490 --> 01:36:17.338
AND QUÊ.
01:36:17.404 --> 01:36:18.639
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE GOING
01:36:18.706 --> 01:36:22.810
TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION. HAVE
01:36:22.877 --> 01:36:26.447
WE FINISHED? I APOLOGIZE. I BEEN
01:36:26.514 --> 01:36:27.915
DISTRACTED BY PEOPLE COMING UP
01:36:27.982 --> 01:36:29.817
AND TALKING TO ME. SO UM, HAVE
01:36:29.884 --> 01:36:30.918
WE MR MODERATOR? HAVE WE
01:36:30.985 --> 01:36:34.555
FINISHED THOSE IN SUPPORT? YES
01:36:34.622 --> 01:36:36.490
WE HAVE. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
01:36:36.557 --> 01:36:37.591
APPRECIATE IT. WE'RE GOING TO
01:36:37.658 --> 01:36:39.326
MOVE ON TO, UM OPPOSITION
01:36:39.393 --> 01:36:40.895
WITNESSES. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY
01:36:40.961 --> 01:36:42.463
LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESSES
01:36:42.530 --> 01:36:43.831
IDENTIFIED. IS THERE ANYBODY
01:36:43.898 --> 01:36:45.533
HERE IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD
01:36:45.599 --> 01:36:48.669
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
01:36:48.736 --> 01:36:51.205
SEEING AND WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
01:36:51.272 --> 01:36:52.072
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASK IF
01:36:52.139 --> 01:36:54.341
THERE'S ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO
01:36:54.408 --> 01:36:57.845
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO 23 34.
01:36:57.912 --> 01:36:59.246
AND IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
01:36:59.313 --> 01:37:00.614
IN OPPOSITION TO MAYBE 2334
01:37:00.681 --> 01:37:11.559
PRESS 10. AND MADAM CHAIR. NO
01:37:11.625 --> 01:37:13.394
LINES COMING INTO QUÊ. THANK YOU
01:37:13.460 --> 01:37:16.730
VERY MUCH. WE WILL BRING THE
01:37:16.797 --> 01:37:18.532
MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
01:37:18.599 --> 01:37:21.368
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. YES,
01:37:21.435 --> 01:37:26.674
SENATOR WIENER. THANK YOU. UM,
01:37:26.740 --> 01:37:29.577
MATT. MADAM CHAIR. UM SO I
01:37:29.643 --> 01:37:31.312
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL, AND
01:37:31.378 --> 01:37:33.547
I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT. I
01:37:33.614 --> 01:37:34.682
JUST WANTED TO CLARIFY ONE
01:37:34.748 --> 01:37:37.685
THING, BECAUSE I THINK WE THE
01:37:37.751 --> 01:37:40.421
AUTHOR. WE WE'VE HAD BEEN HAVING
01:37:40.487 --> 01:37:41.822
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT WHAT COUNTY
01:37:41.889 --> 01:37:43.857
SHOULD BE INCLUDED, AND I
01:37:43.924 --> 01:37:44.758
THOUGHT, I THINK IT'S REALLY
01:37:44.825 --> 01:37:46.860
IMPORTANT THAT ESPECIALLY SOME
01:37:46.927 --> 01:37:47.895
OF THE WEALTHIER, URBANIZED
01:37:47.962 --> 01:37:54.368
COUNTIES ALSO BE INCLUDED AND SO. THE AUTHOR AT THE BEGINNING
01:37:54.435 --> 01:37:55.369
RECITED THE NINE BAY AREA
01:37:55.436 --> 01:37:58.138
COUNTIES. AND THEN BASICALLY
01:37:58.205 --> 01:37:59.206
SEVEN CALIFORNIA FROM SANTA
01:37:59.273 --> 01:38:01.408
BARBARA SOUTH TO SANTA BARBARA
01:38:01.475 --> 01:38:03.210
VENTURA L. A INLAND EMPIRE
01:38:03.277 --> 01:38:07.081
ORANGE SAN DIEGO. I THINK, UM
01:38:07.147 --> 01:38:09.283
SACRAMENTO COUNTY WAS ALSO IN
01:38:09.350 --> 01:38:10.884
THE ORIGINAL LIST THAT THE CHAIR
01:38:10.951 --> 01:38:13.988
SUGGESTED OF THE NINE LARGEST SO
01:38:14.054 --> 01:38:16.724
I WOULD SUGGEST THAT IN ADDITION
01:38:16.790 --> 01:38:17.825
TO WHAT THE AUTHOR RECITED THE
01:38:17.891 --> 01:38:18.726
BEGINNING, SACRAMENTO COUNTY
01:38:18.792 --> 01:38:23.797
ALSO, UH, BE INCLUDED. YES THAT
01:38:23.864 --> 01:38:26.500
THAT I'M PART OF THE CHALLENGE
01:38:26.567 --> 01:38:28.836
WAS SAYING WITH WITH PICKING
01:38:28.902 --> 01:38:30.070
PICKING THINGS AND THEN TRYING
01:38:30.137 --> 01:38:31.472
TO FIGURE OUT WHAT WE INCLUDED
01:38:31.538 --> 01:38:33.841
WHAT WE DIDN'T BUT SO LET ME LET
01:38:33.907 --> 01:38:34.875
ME JUST RESTATE THAT, AS I
01:38:34.942 --> 01:38:36.877
UNDERSTAND IT BECAUSE WE HAD
01:38:36.944 --> 01:38:37.745
AGREED TO THE NINE LARGEST
01:38:37.811 --> 01:38:42.149
COUNTIES AND IN ADDITION TO THAT
01:38:42.216 --> 01:38:44.318
SAN FRANCISCO BECAUSE IT IS A
01:38:44.385 --> 01:38:46.987
HIGHLY URBANIZED AREA AND, UM
01:38:47.054 --> 01:38:49.957
AND IT WAS. THE REQUEST IS THAT
01:38:50.024 --> 01:38:53.027
WE INCLUDE, UM THE ALL OF THE
01:38:53.093 --> 01:38:54.161
BAY AREA COUNTIES, WHICH WOULD
01:38:54.228 --> 01:38:59.933
ADD, UM CONTRA COSTA. SOLANO,
01:39:00.000 --> 01:39:02.569
NAPA AND MARIN. AND IN SAN
01:39:02.636 --> 01:39:07.908
MATEO. UM I'M LOOKING AT THE
01:39:07.975 --> 01:39:10.444
LIST THAT I HAVE OF THE NINE
01:39:10.511 --> 01:39:11.612
LARGEST. SO THAT CINNAMON TAN
01:39:11.679 --> 01:39:13.280
CEMETERY. OH, THAT'S CORRECT. UM
01:39:13.347 --> 01:39:18.385
OTHERWISE. MM HMM. THE. YES SO
01:39:18.452 --> 01:39:19.887
THOSE ARE THE ADDITIONS AS I
01:39:19.953 --> 01:39:22.122
UNDERSTAND IT. YES I THINK IT
01:39:22.189 --> 01:39:23.724
WOULD BE THE EXPANDING IT TO THE
01:39:23.791 --> 01:39:25.859
ENTIRE NINE BAY AREA CORRECT
01:39:25.926 --> 01:39:27.728
COUNTIES SO THAT WOULD ADD IN
01:39:27.795 --> 01:39:30.597
NOT BUST. SONOMA SOLANO. MARIN
01:39:30.664 --> 01:39:33.033
AND SAN MATEO. UM I THINK THE
01:39:33.100 --> 01:39:34.301
OTHER BARRY COUNTIES WERE
01:39:34.368 --> 01:39:36.570
ALREADY IN YOUR LIST AND THEN
01:39:36.637 --> 01:39:38.005
THE SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COUNTIES
01:39:38.072 --> 01:39:39.206
. UM WELL, IT WOULD ALSO ADD IN
01:39:39.273 --> 01:39:44.645
VENTURA. IN SANTA BARBARA, UM IN
01:39:44.712 --> 01:39:45.612
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, BECAUSE
01:39:45.679 --> 01:39:47.948
THOSE ARE NOT PART OF THE NINE
01:39:48.015 --> 01:39:50.284
AH AND SACRAMENTO WAS ALREADY IN
01:39:50.351 --> 01:39:51.452
YOUR LIST. CORRECT. IT WOULD BE
01:39:51.518 --> 01:39:55.055
THE NINE BAY AREA. UM SANTA
01:39:55.122 --> 01:39:57.391
BARBARA VENTURA, L, A SAN
01:39:57.458 --> 01:39:59.860
BERNARDINO, RIVERSIDE, ORANGE,
01:39:59.927 --> 01:40:02.830
SAN DIEGO SACRAMENTO. IF I'M
01:40:02.896 --> 01:40:04.231
THINK THAT'S RIGHT, THAT'S
01:40:04.298 --> 01:40:05.699
RIGHT. OKAY GREAT. I THINK WE
01:40:05.766 --> 01:40:07.968
HAVE THE SAME LIST. IT'S JUST
01:40:08.035 --> 01:40:08.635
THEY'RE IN DIFFERENT ORDERS, SO
01:40:08.702 --> 01:40:10.437
AND I THINK THAT COVERS LIKE IN
01:40:10.504 --> 01:40:12.339
TERMS OF THE URBANIZED AREAS.
01:40:12.406 --> 01:40:15.576
MEGA REGIONS IN THE SO NOW THAT
01:40:15.642 --> 01:40:17.311
YOU BROUGHT THIS UP, I REALLY
01:40:17.378 --> 01:40:19.079
APPRECIATE IT BECAUSE I WAS
01:40:19.146 --> 01:40:20.581
TRYING TO GET THE LIST. CLEARLY
01:40:20.647 --> 01:40:22.383
BECAUSE STAFF NEEDS TO
01:40:22.449 --> 01:40:24.318
UNDERSTAND IT IN ORDER TO
01:40:24.385 --> 01:40:25.919
PROCESS THE IMMENSE IS THAT, UM,
01:40:25.986 --> 01:40:31.225
IS. AND I REALLY APPRECIATE WHAT
01:40:31.291 --> 01:40:32.826
YOU'RE ATTEMPTING TO DO. PART OF
01:40:32.893 --> 01:40:34.228
THE CHALLENGE IS ONE SIZE
01:40:34.294 --> 01:40:35.763
DOESN'T FIT ALL AND THERE ARE
01:40:35.829 --> 01:40:36.830
ARAB REGIONS OF THE STATE THAT
01:40:36.897 --> 01:40:37.865
HAVEN'T URBANIZED TO THE EXTENT
01:40:37.931 --> 01:40:42.102
THAT OTHER REGIONS HAVE AND WHEN
01:40:42.169 --> 01:40:44.271
WE APPLY THE OVERLAYS THAT YOU
01:40:44.338 --> 01:40:48.475
SOMETIMES HAVE, UM UH, HARD TIME
01:40:48.542 --> 01:40:50.811
BECAUSE NOT ONLY HAVE THEY NOT
01:40:50.878 --> 01:40:52.613
URBANIZED, BUT THEY JUST DON'T
01:40:52.679 --> 01:40:54.548
HAVE THE BUDGETS THAT, UM AND
01:40:54.615 --> 01:40:56.383
THE PLANNING STAFF AND EVERYONE
01:40:56.450 --> 01:40:57.451
ELSE THAT YOU REQUIRE. WHEN
01:40:57.518 --> 01:40:58.585
YOU'RE DOING THESE, UM THESE
01:40:58.652 --> 01:41:00.287
KINDS OF PROJECTS. THIS IS AN
01:41:00.354 --> 01:41:05.092
EXPANSION OF THE SUPER DENSITY
01:41:05.159 --> 01:41:08.862
BONUS. UM WHICH I BELIEVE IS
01:41:08.929 --> 01:41:10.364
REALLY THOUGHTFUL, BUT IT'S GOT
01:41:10.431 --> 01:41:11.565
TO REALLY APPLY, BECAUSE
01:41:11.632 --> 01:41:13.300
OTHERWISE YOU'RE GONNA END UP
01:41:13.367 --> 01:41:14.935
WITH THESE INCONGRUENT. I WANT
01:41:15.002 --> 01:41:17.671
YOU COULD 100% AFFORDABLE
01:41:17.738 --> 01:41:19.807
PROJECTS IN COMMUNITIES THAT
01:41:19.873 --> 01:41:22.276
DON'T HAVE ANYTHING ABOVE TWO
01:41:22.342 --> 01:41:23.777
STORIES OR ABOVE OR WITH THE
01:41:23.844 --> 01:41:27.347
DENSITY. TO SUPPORT PUBLIC
01:41:27.414 --> 01:41:29.783
TRANSPORTATION IN IN THEIR AREA
01:41:29.850 --> 01:41:30.918
. I'VE BEEN ADVOCATING THAT WE
01:41:30.984 --> 01:41:33.120
SPEND A LOT MORE MONEY.
01:41:33.187 --> 01:41:35.823
CONNECTING RURAL CALIFORNIA AND
01:41:35.889 --> 01:41:37.991
SUBURBAN AREAS WITH PUBLIC
01:41:38.058 --> 01:41:39.693
TRANSPORTATION TO TAKE THE TRAIN
01:41:39.760 --> 01:41:42.095
ON A REGULAR BASIS. UM AND IT'S
01:41:42.162 --> 01:41:44.298
REALLY INCONVENIENT. UM AND
01:41:44.364 --> 01:41:46.767
UNTIL WE HAVE THAT CONNECTIONS,
01:41:46.834 --> 01:41:49.369
SOME OF THE OVERLAYS WE PUT ON
01:41:49.436 --> 01:41:50.504
OUR VERY DIFFICULT BUT I THINK
01:41:50.571 --> 01:41:54.107
THIS HAS THIS IS A UM, SO THAT'S
01:41:54.174 --> 01:41:54.775
ONE OF THE REASONS I HAVE AN
01:41:54.842 --> 01:41:57.344
ISSUE WITH SOME OF THE VM T
01:41:57.411 --> 01:41:58.812
EXPANSIONS THAT ARE GOING ON.
01:41:58.879 --> 01:42:00.347
BUT I THINK THIS THIS HANDLES
01:42:00.414 --> 01:42:02.649
THE ISSUE THAT I HAD. AND SO I
01:42:02.716 --> 01:42:04.518
WILL BE SUPPORTING IT TODAY, AND
01:42:04.585 --> 01:42:05.686
I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING
01:42:05.752 --> 01:42:07.621
IT FORWARD BY THAT. A BROKE INTO
01:42:07.688 --> 01:42:09.256
WHAT YOU WERE SAYING. SENATOR
01:42:09.323 --> 01:42:11.291
WIENER SAW LET YOU FINISH. I
01:42:11.358 --> 01:42:13.327
JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE WE WERE
01:42:13.393 --> 01:42:14.261
ON THE SAME PAGE. VERY GOOD.
01:42:14.328 --> 01:42:15.863
GOOD. I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE
01:42:15.929 --> 01:42:21.335
BILL. GREAT. AH! YES SENATOR.
01:42:21.401 --> 01:42:22.269
I'M SURE IT'S A SMALL QUESTION
01:42:22.336 --> 01:42:25.873
HERE. IS THERE A LIMITOF HOW
01:42:25.939 --> 01:42:27.407
MANY PROJECTS CAN CLAIM THE
01:42:27.474 --> 01:42:31.245
DENSITY BONUS WITHIN AN AREA? I
01:42:31.311 --> 01:42:35.315
BELIEVE SO. NO, NO, NO. AND
01:42:35.382 --> 01:42:36.950
THEY'RE IN ISN'T BEING THE OTHER
01:42:37.017 --> 01:42:39.419
ISSUE. BUT AND, YEAH, THIS ONLY
01:42:39.486 --> 01:42:40.587
APPLIES TO 100% AFFORDABLE
01:42:40.654 --> 01:42:46.994
HOUSING. YEAH, WELL, THAT'S THE. THAT'S THE SWEET PART OF THIS
01:42:47.060 --> 01:42:47.728
RIGHT IT IS. IT IS THE
01:42:47.794 --> 01:42:50.130
AFFORDABILITY. UM THE REASON I
01:42:50.197 --> 01:42:51.965
ASK IS BECAUSE IT COULD LEAD TO
01:42:52.032 --> 01:42:54.935
ISSUES WITHOUT ASSESSING, UM
01:42:55.002 --> 01:42:57.204
AVAILABILITY OF PARKING AND
01:42:57.271 --> 01:43:00.007
OTHER OTHER CONDITIONS. YOU KNOW
01:43:00.073 --> 01:43:01.942
THAT WE ALWAYS LOOK OUT FOR. SO,
01:43:02.009 --> 01:43:04.311
UM WE SHOULDN'T. MAYBE WE CAN
01:43:04.378 --> 01:43:05.112
TALK ABOUT THAT SOME MORE. BUT
01:43:05.178 --> 01:43:09.483
ON THE ONE HAND. YOU KNOW IT'S
01:43:09.550 --> 01:43:11.084
GOOD BECAUSE YOU COULD BUILD
01:43:11.151 --> 01:43:12.586
MORE HOUSING. ON THE OTHER HAND
01:43:12.653 --> 01:43:14.254
, IT WILL HAVE AN IMPACT IF YOU
01:43:14.321 --> 01:43:15.856
IF THEY'RE ALL REALLY CLUSTERED
01:43:15.923 --> 01:43:18.525
IN THE NEXT TO EACH OTHER, AND
01:43:18.592 --> 01:43:20.193
THAT'S NOT SOMETHING WE WANT
01:43:20.260 --> 01:43:21.428
EITHER. NÓI I APPRECIATE THE
01:43:21.495 --> 01:43:23.163
COMMENT. I'M HAPPY TO HAVE MORE
01:43:23.230 --> 01:43:24.097
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT IT. I THINK
01:43:24.164 --> 01:43:25.732
THE GOAL OF THE BILL IS PUTTING
01:43:25.799 --> 01:43:27.901
IT IN LOW. VM T MEANS IN THEORY,
01:43:27.968 --> 01:43:29.403
THERE'S A FAIR AMOUNT OF PUBLIC
01:43:29.469 --> 01:43:30.137
TRANSPORTATION TO HELP ADDRESS
01:43:30.203 --> 01:43:32.539
THE NEED, BUT AS YOU ALL KNOW,
01:43:32.606 --> 01:43:33.774
HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION, GO
01:43:33.840 --> 01:43:34.908
HAND IN GLOVE, AND WE CAN'T HAVE
01:43:34.975 --> 01:43:36.944
ONE CONVERSATION WITHOUT THE
01:43:37.010 --> 01:43:38.045
OTHER. SO I'M HAPPY TO ENTERTAIN
01:43:38.111 --> 01:43:38.979
MORE CONVERSATIONS WITH YOU,
01:43:39.046 --> 01:43:41.715
SENATOR. THERE'S NO MORE
01:43:41.782 --> 01:43:43.884
COMMENTS. UM WILL ALLOW YOU TO
01:43:43.951 --> 01:43:45.619
CONCLUDE. JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:43:45.686 --> 01:43:48.255
FOR MY VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:43:48.322 --> 01:43:49.423
. WE DO HAVE EMOTION BY SENATOR
01:43:49.489 --> 01:43:51.592
WEINER WILL CALL THE ROLL.
01:43:51.658 --> 01:43:53.961
MOTION IS TO PASS THIS AMENDED
01:43:54.027 --> 01:43:54.861
FOR FIRST AMOUNT, AND WE
01:43:54.928 --> 01:43:56.997
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:43:57.064 --> 01:43:57.698
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
01:43:57.764 --> 01:44:02.336
CABALLERO I. NIELSEN. NELSON
01:44:02.402 --> 01:44:05.472
DURAZO. AYE HERZBERG. WIENER
01:44:05.539 --> 01:44:11.478
WIENER. I 321. UM THAT BILL IS
01:44:11.545 --> 01:44:12.946
OUT. WE WILL WAIT. WE'LL KEEP
01:44:13.013 --> 01:44:15.215
THE ROLE OPEN FOR, UM, COMMITTEE
01:44:15.282 --> 01:44:16.817
MEMBERS THAT ARE NOT HERE. THANK
01:44:16.883 --> 01:44:18.151
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND
01:44:18.218 --> 01:44:19.920
I'M ON MY WAY OVER TO YOUR
01:44:19.987 --> 01:44:21.788
COMMITTEE, SO I WILL PASS THAT
01:44:21.855 --> 01:44:24.858
THE GAVEL. IF WE COULD. I'D LIKE
01:44:24.925 --> 01:44:25.993
TO ENTERTAIN A MOTION ON THE TWO
01:44:26.059 --> 01:44:28.261
CONSENT ITEMS THAT, UM WE'VE
01:44:28.328 --> 01:44:30.097
IDENTIFIED ITS FILE ITEM NUMBER
01:44:30.163 --> 01:44:34.001
22 A B 27 89 FILE ITEM NUMBER 24
01:44:34.067 --> 01:44:37.838
WHICH IS A B 26 61. THERE IS A
01:44:37.904 --> 01:44:41.308
MOTION PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:44:41.375 --> 01:44:42.843
MOTION IS TO ADOPT THE CONSENT
01:44:42.909 --> 01:44:44.311
CALENDAR. SENATOR SCOTT
01:44:44.378 --> 01:44:47.314
CABALLERO CABALLERO I. NILSSON
01:44:47.381 --> 01:44:50.717
NILSSON, ANDORRA. AYE HERZBERG
01:44:50.784 --> 01:44:55.922
WIENER WIENER. AYE. 40 THAT BILL
01:44:55.989 --> 01:44:58.291
HAS FOUR VOTES WILL HOLD THE
01:44:58.358 --> 01:45:00.694
ROLL OPEN. UM WE ALSO TOOK UP
01:45:00.761 --> 01:45:02.496
FILE ITEM NUMBER THREE, WHICH IS
01:45:02.562 --> 01:45:05.265
A B 4 98. WE DID NOT HAVE A
01:45:05.332 --> 01:45:06.433
QUORUM, SO I'LL ENTERTAIN A
01:45:06.500 --> 01:45:10.170
MOTION ON THAT BILL. SOME OF.
01:45:10.237 --> 01:45:11.972
MOVED BY SENATOR WIENER. PLEASE
01:45:12.039 --> 01:45:15.809
CALL THE ROLL. MACHINE IS TO
01:45:15.876 --> 01:45:17.811
PASS US AMENDED BUT FIRST CEMENT
01:45:17.878 --> 01:45:19.446
AND WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
01:45:19.513 --> 01:45:21.114
ON APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
01:45:21.181 --> 01:45:23.316
CABALLERO CABALLERO, I, NILSSON
01:45:23.383 --> 01:45:27.754
NILSSON I DORIS Ó. YOU'RE A SO
01:45:27.821 --> 01:45:31.825
I HERZBERG WIENER ER I WILL HOLD
01:45:31.892 --> 01:45:34.528
THAT OPENING CONSENT WAS ITEM 22
01:45:34.594 --> 01:45:36.196
24. JUST THAT IS CORRECT. IT'S
01:45:36.263 --> 01:45:39.900
JUST TWO BILLS. UM NEXT. I'D
01:45:39.966 --> 01:45:43.804
LIKE TO, UM, HAVE A CALL ON FILE
01:45:43.870 --> 01:45:45.839
ITEM NUMBER FOUR, WHICH IS A B
01:45:45.906 --> 01:45:48.108
20 TO 21 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:45:48.175 --> 01:45:49.142
QUIRK-SILVA. SHE PRESENTED HER
01:45:49.209 --> 01:45:49.910
BILL EARLIER. WE DID NOT HAVE A
01:45:49.976 --> 01:45:54.848
QUORUM. I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION.
01:45:54.915 --> 01:45:58.285
WHAT DAMAGES DO THAT? NO, WE DID
01:45:58.351 --> 01:45:59.853
NUMBER THREE. THIS IS NUMBER
01:45:59.920 --> 01:46:07.761
FOUR. UM SOME OF WHAT? SENATOR
01:46:07.828 --> 01:46:09.696
NELSON. DID YOU MOVE THAT BILL?
01:46:09.763 --> 01:46:11.832
OKAY WE DO HAVE A MOTION BY
01:46:11.898 --> 01:46:13.800
SENATOR NIELSEN. PLEASE CALL THE
01:46:13.867 --> 01:46:16.036
ROLL MOTION IS TO PASS US
01:46:16.103 --> 01:46:17.804
AMENDED BEFORE CEMENT AND WE
01:46:17.871 --> 01:46:18.705
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:46:18.772 --> 01:46:20.140
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
01:46:20.207 --> 01:46:22.109
CABALLERO, Hí
01:46:22.175 --> 01:46:26.847
NILSSON, ADORA, SO. H
01:46:26.913 --> 01:46:32.219
ENER WIENER? AYE. THAT HAS
01:46:32.285 --> 01:46:33.754
FOUR VOTES AND WE'LL LEAVE IT
01:46:33.820 --> 01:46:35.222
OPEN AS WELL. MOVING ON TO FILE
01:46:35.288 --> 01:46:37.724
ITEM NUMBER 14. WE DID HAVE A
01:46:37.791 --> 01:46:39.092
PRESENTATION BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:46:39.159 --> 01:46:42.896
ARAMBULA A B 2030. 14 OF THE
01:46:42.963 --> 01:46:46.199
BILL. THERE IS A MOTION BY
01:46:46.266 --> 01:46:47.234
SENATOR WIENER. POLICE CALL THE
01:46:47.300 --> 01:46:52.372
ROLL. MOTION IS TO PASS BY FOR
01:46:52.439 --> 01:46:56.209
CEMENT ARE SORRY. MOTION IS TO
01:46:56.276 --> 01:46:57.711
PASS. BUT FIRST WE REFER TO THE
01:46:57.778 --> 01:46:59.079
COMMITTEE AND APPROPRIATION
01:46:59.146 --> 01:46:59.980
SENATORS CABALLERO CABALLERO, I,
01:47:00.046 --> 01:47:04.684
NIELSEN. NELSON, EIDUR ASSO.
01:47:04.751 --> 01:47:08.221
DORIS. SO I HERTZBERG. WIENER
01:47:08.288 --> 01:47:13.193
WIENER? AYE. THAT BILL IS OUT AS
01:47:13.260 --> 01:47:15.195
WELL AND WE'LL LEAVE THE ROAD
01:47:15.262 --> 01:47:21.201
OPEN. LOW BLOOD SUGAR. I'M SORRY
01:47:21.268 --> 01:47:23.336
. WE'LL LEAVE IT ON CALL. WE'LL
01:47:23.403 --> 01:47:25.705
LEAVE THE ROLE OPEN SO THAT WE
01:47:25.772 --> 01:47:27.541
CAN ADD THE MISSING MEMBERS.
01:47:27.607 --> 01:47:32.979
OKAY, THAT MOVES US ON TO.
01:47:33.046 --> 01:47:34.614
SENATOR GREAT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:47:34.681 --> 01:47:36.383
GRAYSON. I WAS JUST ABOUT TO
01:47:36.449 --> 01:47:37.584
MAKE YOU A SENATOR, BUT I THINK
01:47:37.651 --> 01:47:41.054
IT REQUIRES A FEW MORE VOTES. UM
01:47:41.121 --> 01:47:46.526
HI. OKAY SO YOU'LL BE YOU WANT
01:47:46.593 --> 01:47:47.627
TO PRESENT MR SALEH'S BILL
01:47:47.694 --> 01:47:50.797
FIRST? OKAY SOUNDS GOOD. THAT IS
01:47:50.864 --> 01:47:53.300
FILE ITEM NUMBER 59 16, AND I'M
01:47:53.366 --> 01:47:55.435
GOING TO HAND THE GAVEL OVER TO
01:47:55.502 --> 01:47:59.306
MY WHO CHAIR. AND I WILL BE
01:47:59.372 --> 01:48:12.319
BACK. T<c.cyan>. PLEASE PROCEED. YOU'RE</c>
01:48:12.385 --> 01:48:13.386
BRINGING THE STAR ATTENTION
01:48:13.453 --> 01:48:15.522
RIGHT NOW. A B 9 16 CORRECT.
01:48:15.589 --> 01:48:22.028
THANK YOU. EMBER. THEY ARE
01:48:22.095 --> 01:48:24.264
PRESENTING A B 9 16 ON BEHALF OF
01:48:24.331 --> 01:48:26.199
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS AND WOULD
01:48:26.266 --> 01:48:27.968
LIKE TO BEGIN BY STATING THAT
01:48:28.034 --> 01:48:29.202
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS DOES
01:48:29.269 --> 01:48:30.103
ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE'S
01:48:30.170 --> 01:48:32.005
AMENDMENTS AND IS COMMITTED TO
01:48:32.072 --> 01:48:34.307
ALIGNING THIS BILL WITH SB 897.
01:48:34.374 --> 01:48:35.842
THIS BILL WILL REMOVE BARRIERS
01:48:35.909 --> 01:48:37.110
TO THE CREATION OF ACCESSORY
01:48:37.177 --> 01:48:38.612
DWELLING UNITS AND ADDITIONAL
01:48:38.678 --> 01:48:41.081
BEDROOMS. WE ARE FACING A
01:48:41.147 --> 01:48:41.982
HOUSING CRISIS IN CALIFORNIA
01:48:42.048 --> 01:48:44.317
WITH BOTH A LACK OF AFFORDABLE
01:48:44.384 --> 01:48:44.885
HOUSING AND PANDEMIC AND A
01:48:44.951 --> 01:48:49.189
PANDEMIC OF HOMELESSNESS. 80 US
01:48:49.256 --> 01:48:51.091
AND ENABLE THE CREATION OF EASY
01:48:51.157 --> 01:48:52.592
TO BUILD HOUSING ON LAND THAT IS
01:48:52.659 --> 01:48:54.327
ALREADY UTILIZED FOR HOUSING
01:48:54.394 --> 01:48:56.096
THAT'S BRINGING DOWN THE COST OF
01:48:56.162 --> 01:48:58.198
CREATING NEW HOUSING. THIS BILL
01:48:58.265 --> 01:49:00.634
WILL ALLEVIATE BURDENS TO A D U
01:49:00.700 --> 01:49:02.469
CREATION IN THE STATE AND CREATE
01:49:02.535 --> 01:49:03.536
MORE HOUSING FOR LOW INCOME
01:49:03.603 --> 01:49:06.139
RESIDENTS. TESTIFYING REMOTELY.
01:49:06.206 --> 01:49:07.274
TODAY IS CAPE BELL WITH THE
01:49:07.340 --> 01:49:08.275
CALIFORNIA RENTAL HOUSING
01:49:08.341 --> 01:49:12.345
ASSOCIATION. GOOD MORNING FELLOW
01:49:12.412 --> 01:49:13.213
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:49:13.280 --> 01:49:14.814
RENTAL HOUSING ASSOCIATION, WAS
01:49:14.881 --> 01:49:16.816
A SPONSOR OF THE BILL AND ON
01:49:16.883 --> 01:49:18.351
BEHALF OF THE DEPARTMENT
01:49:18.418 --> 01:49:19.619
ASSOCIATION OF GREATER L. A
01:49:19.686 --> 01:49:21.955
STRONG SUPPORT. WE APPRECIATE
01:49:22.022 --> 01:49:22.789
THE AUTHOR BRINGING FORTH THIS
01:49:22.856 --> 01:49:25.191
MEASURE AND REMEMBER GRAYSON FOR
01:49:25.258 --> 01:49:26.726
PRESENTING TODAY 89 16
01:49:26.793 --> 01:49:28.828
STRAIGHTFORWARD MEASURE, WHICH
01:49:28.895 --> 01:49:29.963
WOULD ALLOW OUR MEMBERS AND
01:49:30.030 --> 01:49:31.965
OTHERS TO RIDE MORE IMMEDIATE
01:49:32.032 --> 01:49:33.600
AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING THE STATE
01:49:33.667 --> 01:49:34.801
THE BILL WOULD STREAMLINE THE
01:49:34.868 --> 01:49:36.236
ADDITION OF UP TO TWO BEDROOMS
01:49:36.303 --> 01:49:37.837
WITHOUT A PUBLIC HEARING AND
01:49:37.904 --> 01:49:38.672
INCREASE THE HEIGHT LIMIT FOR
01:49:38.738 --> 01:49:40.740
AWS. IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES.
01:49:40.807 --> 01:49:42.075
WE APPRECIATE THE FEEDBACK OF
01:49:42.142 --> 01:49:44.010
THE CHAIR AND THE WORK OF THE
01:49:44.077 --> 01:49:45.045
COMMITTEE STAFF. WE LOOK FORWARD
01:49:45.111 --> 01:49:46.680
TO FUTURE CONVERSATIONS ON THE
01:49:46.746 --> 01:49:48.448
BILL OVER THE SUMMER AND
01:49:48.515 --> 01:49:49.482
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
01:49:49.549 --> 01:49:54.888
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANY OTHER
01:49:54.955 --> 01:49:56.056
SUPPORT. THAT WILL BE THE SINGLE
01:49:56.122 --> 01:49:59.426
ONE, OKAY? ANYONE HERE IN THE
01:49:59.492 --> 01:50:01.127
ROOM? UH, WISHES TO SPEAK IN
01:50:01.194 --> 01:50:05.165
SUPPORT. ONE GENTLEMAN HERE. ALL
01:50:05.231 --> 01:50:06.733
RIGHT, ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH
01:50:06.800 --> 01:50:08.034
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
01:50:08.101 --> 01:50:09.769
BEHALF OF SPUR AND SUPPORT.
01:50:09.836 --> 01:50:15.208
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ONE MORE.
01:50:15.275 --> 01:50:16.343
THANK YOU. JORDAN. PLANNING
01:50:16.409 --> 01:50:17.344
CARVAJAL ON BEHALF OF
01:50:17.410 --> 01:50:18.411
CALIFORNIAN BE STRONG SUPPORT.
01:50:18.478 --> 01:50:20.113
THANK YOU FOR THAT TESTIMONY.
01:50:20.180 --> 01:50:25.719
ANY FURTHER HERE IN THE ROOM.
01:50:25.785 --> 01:50:27.620
OKAY, MODERATOR. DO WE HAVE ANY
01:50:27.687 --> 01:50:28.621
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT WITNESSES IN
01:50:28.688 --> 01:50:34.761
QUÊ? AND WE DO HAVE. SOME IN
01:50:34.828 --> 01:50:37.097
SUPPORT. IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO
01:50:37.163 --> 01:50:38.365
QUEUE UP THE PRESS. 10 WILL GO
01:50:38.431 --> 01:50:41.868
TO LINE 47, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:50:41.935 --> 01:50:42.802
DEAN HUTCHINGS, CALLING ON
01:50:42.869 --> 01:50:45.105
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA
01:50:45.171 --> 01:50:49.509
ROSA, AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. AND
01:50:49.576 --> 01:50:51.478
WE'LL GO TO THE LINE. 14 14,
01:50:51.544 --> 01:50:54.848
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI ALISON
01:50:54.914 --> 01:50:57.283
SHELLER SINGLE FAMILY HOME OWNER
01:50:57.350 --> 01:51:00.587
IN LOSANGELES. AH REPRESENTING
01:51:00.653 --> 01:51:01.621
FROM THE FRONTLINE HOLLYWOOD
01:51:01.688 --> 01:51:04.824
FORWARD, THE I ASKED SUPPORT
01:51:04.891 --> 01:51:07.193
ITSELF. THANKS SO MUCH. THANK
01:51:07.260 --> 01:51:12.532
YOU. WE HAVE NO FURTHER COMMENTS
01:51:12.599 --> 01:51:15.568
IN Q AT THIS TIME. DO WE HAVE
01:51:15.635 --> 01:51:17.404
ANY OPPOSITION HERE IN THE ROOM
01:51:17.470 --> 01:51:20.040
WISHING TO TESTIFY? I'M AFRAID
01:51:20.106 --> 01:51:21.608
TO DO YOU HAVE ANY OPPOSITION?
01:51:21.674 --> 01:51:27.280
IN QUÊ. AND IF THEY WOULD LIKE
01:51:27.347 --> 01:51:28.915
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION, THE A B
01:51:28.982 --> 01:51:33.787
916 PRESS 10 AND WE WILL GO TO
01:51:33.853 --> 01:51:37.590
LINE 1 43, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:51:37.657 --> 01:51:39.826
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS, ANDREW
01:51:39.893 --> 01:51:41.094
HANDS WE ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
01:51:41.161 --> 01:51:47.200
OF BEVERLY HILLS AND OPPOSITION.
01:51:47.267 --> 01:51:49.102
THAT'S WHERE THE LINE 3 18 318,
01:51:49.169 --> 01:51:52.872
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE MORNING
01:51:52.939 --> 01:51:53.740
TRAIN NUMBER BECAUSE SANDRA
01:51:53.807 --> 01:51:55.909
SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
01:51:55.975 --> 01:51:56.910
RANCHO PALOS, VERDES AND
01:51:56.976 --> 01:52:00.747
OPPOSITION, THANK YOU. WE'LL GO
01:52:00.814 --> 01:52:04.584
TO LINE 77, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:52:04.651 --> 01:52:06.219
BEEN AS THE CHAVEZ WITH THE
01:52:06.286 --> 01:52:07.687
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:52:07.754 --> 01:52:09.556
FILTERS WITH AN OPPOSING
01:52:09.622 --> 01:52:10.457
RECOMMENDED POSITION ON THE
01:52:10.523 --> 01:52:15.728
BILL. WE'LL GO TO LINE 55 0,
01:52:15.795 --> 01:52:20.733
PLEASE GO AHEAD. TRACY RYAN WITH
01:52:20.800 --> 01:52:21.734
THE RURAL COUNTY REPRESENTATIVE
01:52:21.801 --> 01:52:23.736
, CALIFORNIA AND ALSO ON BEHALF
01:52:23.803 --> 01:52:24.704
OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
01:52:24.771 --> 01:52:25.839
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES, WITH AN
01:52:25.905 --> 01:52:29.742
IMPOSING LESS AMENDED POSITION.
01:52:29.809 --> 01:52:31.711
WE'LL GO TO LINE 3 51, PLEASE GO
01:52:31.778 --> 01:52:35.615
AHEAD. HI MRS. JOHNSON WANTED TO
01:52:35.682 --> 01:52:37.584
GO FROM CURSED STRATEGIES ON
01:52:37.650 --> 01:52:39.085
BEHALF OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
01:52:39.152 --> 01:52:39.886
ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNMENT AND
01:52:39.953 --> 01:52:43.723
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. AND WE
01:52:43.790 --> 01:52:44.958
HAVE NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND
01:52:45.024 --> 01:52:48.628
QUÊ. THANK YOU, ASSEMBLYMAN. ANY
01:52:48.695 --> 01:52:53.199
QUESTIONS OF THE COMMITTEE HERE?
01:52:53.266 --> 01:52:54.901
THEN WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE US A
01:52:54.968 --> 01:52:56.503
CLOSE ON THIS BILL? YES A
01:52:56.569 --> 01:52:58.271
SIMILAR MEMBER SALAS. THANKS YOU
01:52:58.338 --> 01:52:59.372
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION AND
01:52:59.439 --> 01:53:01.074
SIMPLY ASKED FOR AN I VOTE.
01:53:01.141 --> 01:53:04.310
OKAY? WOULD THE SECRETARY PLEASE
01:53:04.377 --> 01:53:11.084
CALL THE ROLL? MOTION IS TO PASS
01:53:11.151 --> 01:53:14.554
BUT FIRST OH, I THOUGHT WE HAD
01:53:14.621 --> 01:53:17.323
ONE. WOULD YOU PROFIT PROFIT
01:53:17.390 --> 01:53:21.828
PROPER EMOTION? I'M SORRY. THANK
01:53:21.895 --> 01:53:24.130
YOU, UH, MOTION IS DO PASS BY
01:53:24.197 --> 01:53:25.165
FIRST RE REFERRED TO THE
01:53:25.231 --> 01:53:27.066
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:53:27.133 --> 01:53:28.401
SENATORS CABALLERO NIELSEN
01:53:28.468 --> 01:53:35.608
DURAZO. SO I HERZBERG WINNER. 2
01:53:35.675 --> 01:53:39.946
TO 0 PUT IT ON THE CALL. DO YOU
01:53:40.013 --> 01:53:42.048
HAVE ONE MORE? I HAVE THREE MORE
01:53:42.115 --> 01:53:46.819
BILLS. THREE MORE VERY GOOD.
01:53:46.886 --> 01:53:47.921
MUCH WOULD YOU START WITH I WILL
01:53:47.987 --> 01:53:50.557
START WITH A B 1951 ITEM NUMBER
01:53:50.623 --> 01:53:52.258
10. I BELIEVE. 1951 SSEMBLYMAN
01:53:52.325 --> 01:53:58.298
AWARD. ALRIGHT AGAIN. GOOD
01:53:58.364 --> 01:54:00.633
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBER
01:54:00.700 --> 01:54:02.202
BEFORE I BEGIN THE PRESENTATION
01:54:02.268 --> 01:54:04.404
. I DO WANT TO THANK SENATOR AND
01:54:04.470 --> 01:54:06.706
CHAIR QUÊ VIETTO AND HER STAFF.
01:54:06.773 --> 01:54:08.841
BOTH MR GRENELL AND MR KEEGAN'S
01:54:08.908 --> 01:54:10.843
FOR THEIR GUIDANCE AS WE WORK TO
01:54:10.910 --> 01:54:11.911
BRING SOMETHING BEFORE THIS
01:54:11.978 --> 01:54:13.446
COMMITTEE THAT STRIKES A REAL
01:54:13.513 --> 01:54:15.782
BALANCE BETWEEN THE NEEDS OF ONE
01:54:15.848 --> 01:54:17.850
OF OUR STATE'S ECONOMIC DRIVERS
01:54:17.917 --> 01:54:19.552
, AND THEN THE NEED TO MAINTAIN
01:54:19.619 --> 01:54:20.887
FISCAL PRUDENCE AS THE ECONOMY
01:54:20.954 --> 01:54:21.888
RECOVERS FROM THE RECENT
01:54:21.955 --> 01:54:24.791
PANDEMIC. I AM HAPPY TO ACCEPT
01:54:24.857 --> 01:54:26.059
THE TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS
01:54:26.125 --> 01:54:27.794
DESCRIBED ON PAGE SIX OF THE
01:54:27.860 --> 01:54:29.095
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS THAT ADDRESS
01:54:29.162 --> 01:54:32.699
A DRAFTING ISSUE A B 1951 6 TO
01:54:32.765 --> 01:54:33.866
INCENTIVIZE LONG TERM
01:54:33.933 --> 01:54:35.134
INVESTMENTS AND FUEL EXPANSION
01:54:35.201 --> 01:54:36.502
IN CALIFORNIA'S MANUFACTURING
01:54:36.569 --> 01:54:39.572
INDUSTRY. BY PROVIDING A FULL
01:54:39.639 --> 01:54:41.307
SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTION UP
01:54:41.374 --> 01:54:44.110
TO 200 MILLION IN PURCHASES PER
01:54:44.177 --> 01:54:45.111
QUALIFIED COMPANY FOR THE
01:54:45.178 --> 01:54:46.212
PURCHASE OF MANUFACTURING
01:54:46.279 --> 01:54:47.413
EQUIPMENT WITH A FIVE YEAR
01:54:47.480 --> 01:54:50.817
SUNSET. THE BILL WOULD ALSO
01:54:50.883 --> 01:54:52.252
REQUIRE A REPORT BY THE
01:54:52.318 --> 01:54:54.120
DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND FEE
01:54:54.187 --> 01:54:56.990
ADMINISTRATION IN ORDER TO GAUGE
01:54:57.056 --> 01:54:58.891
THE EFFECTS OF A FULL TAX
01:54:58.958 --> 01:55:00.693
EXEMPTION ON THE STATE. THIS
01:55:00.760 --> 01:55:02.095
WILL FACILITATE THE GROWTH,
01:55:02.161 --> 01:55:04.731
HIRING AND TRAINING OF SKILLED
01:55:04.797 --> 01:55:06.599
WORKFORCES FOR THE FUTURE AND
01:55:06.666 --> 01:55:07.834
PROVIDE HIGH WAGE JOBS FOR
01:55:07.900 --> 01:55:09.502
CALIFORNIANS. PRE PANDEMIC
01:55:09.569 --> 01:55:10.370
CALIFORNIANS MANUFACTURING
01:55:10.436 --> 01:55:13.973
SECTOR HAD ONLY FACED A DECLINE
01:55:14.040 --> 01:55:16.976
IN TOTAL EMPLOYMENT HAD ALREADY
01:55:17.043 --> 01:55:18.444
FACED THAT SO MUCH OF THIS
01:55:18.511 --> 01:55:20.179
DECLINE HAS BEEN A RESULT OF
01:55:20.246 --> 01:55:21.814
CALIFORNIA STEEP COST OF DOING
01:55:21.881 --> 01:55:23.716
BUSINESS, WHICH IS ONE OF THE
01:55:23.783 --> 01:55:25.585
HIGHEST IN THE NATION. THE COVID
01:55:25.652 --> 01:55:26.719
19 PANDEMIC HAS FURTHER
01:55:26.786 --> 01:55:27.720
CHALLENGED CALIFORNIA'S
01:55:27.787 --> 01:55:30.089
MANUFACTURING SECTOR SINCE MARCH
01:55:30.156 --> 01:55:32.258
OF 2020 MANUFACTURING JOBS IN
01:55:32.325 --> 01:55:35.194
CALIFORNIA HAVE DECREASED 4%
01:55:35.261 --> 01:55:36.696
OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS,
01:55:36.763 --> 01:55:38.231
CALIFORNIA HAS ATTRACTED LESS
01:55:38.298 --> 01:55:40.033
THAN 1% OF THE COUNTRY'S
01:55:40.099 --> 01:55:42.135
MANUFACTURING INVESTMENTS WITH
01:55:42.201 --> 01:55:43.369
OTHER STATES AGGRESSIVELY
01:55:43.436 --> 01:55:45.438
ATTEMPTING TO LURE OUR STATES.
01:55:45.505 --> 01:55:47.206
MANUFACTURERS WITH ATTRACTIVE
01:55:47.273 --> 01:55:49.609
LOWER BUSINESS COSTS AND
01:55:49.676 --> 01:55:51.411
LOCATION AND CENTERS. THIS BILL
01:55:51.477 --> 01:55:53.780
WILL HELP TO RESERVE OR TO
01:55:53.846 --> 01:55:55.448
ACTUALLY REVERSE THESE TRENDS
01:55:55.515 --> 01:55:56.482
AND MAKE CALIFORNIA MORE
01:55:56.549 --> 01:55:59.118
ATTRACTIVE TO INVESTMENT.
01:55:59.185 --> 01:56:00.553
ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF THIS
01:56:00.620 --> 01:56:03.122
STATISTIC, THE FACT THAT 38
01:56:03.189 --> 01:56:05.558
STATES ALREADY HAVE A FULL SALES
01:56:05.625 --> 01:56:07.427
AND USE TAX EXEMPTION FOR
01:56:07.493 --> 01:56:07.927
MANUFACTURING EQUIPMENT
01:56:07.994 --> 01:56:10.396
PURCHASES. AND ANOTHER FIVE
01:56:10.463 --> 01:56:13.299
STATES HAVE NO SALES TAX,
01:56:13.366 --> 01:56:14.834
MEANING THAT WE ARE NOT
01:56:14.901 --> 01:56:17.770
COMPETING, AND NOT EVEN IN IN
01:56:17.837 --> 01:56:19.839
THE SAME FIELD WITH 43 OTHER
01:56:19.906 --> 01:56:21.140
STATES, IT IS IMPERATIVE THAT
01:56:21.207 --> 01:56:22.575
THE STATE FOUND WAYS TO MITIGATE
01:56:22.642 --> 01:56:24.577
FINANCIAL BURDENS, PROMOTE
01:56:24.644 --> 01:56:26.713
INCREASED PRODUCTION AND ENSURE
01:56:26.779 --> 01:56:28.281
THE GROWTH OF HIGH WAGE JOBS FOR
01:56:28.348 --> 01:56:30.116
A VARIETY OF SKILL LEVELSAND
01:56:30.183 --> 01:56:31.484
BACKGROUNDS IN ONE OF THE
01:56:31.551 --> 01:56:33.619
STATE'S ESSENTIAL INDUSTRIES. A
01:56:33.686 --> 01:56:36.322
START. MANUFACTURING JOB BASE IS
01:56:36.389 --> 01:56:37.824
KEY TO THE GLOBAL AND DOMESTIC
01:56:37.890 --> 01:56:39.625
COMPETITIVENESS OF OUR ECONOMY,
01:56:39.692 --> 01:56:41.728
BECAUSE IT'S BECAUSE OF ITS
01:56:41.794 --> 01:56:43.830
BREATH AND ALSO VARIETY. THERE
01:56:43.896 --> 01:56:44.964
IS A MISCONCEPTION THAT ALL
01:56:45.031 --> 01:56:46.099
MANUFACTURING IS DONE ON LARGE
01:56:46.165 --> 01:56:49.335
INDUSTRIAL SCALES. BUT OVER 70%
01:56:49.402 --> 01:56:50.937
OF MANUFACTURERS HAVE LESS THAN
01:56:51.003 --> 01:56:53.740
20 EMPLOYEES, SMALL AND MEDIUM
01:56:53.806 --> 01:56:55.341
SIZED MANUFACTURERS FACE A
01:56:55.408 --> 01:56:56.909
DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE OF
01:56:56.976 --> 01:56:58.711
ECONOMIC BURDENS. INCREASED
01:56:58.778 --> 01:57:00.213
CAPITAL COSTS DUE TO THE
01:57:00.279 --> 01:57:02.482
PANDEMIC AND ONE OF THE HIGHEST
01:57:02.548 --> 01:57:03.649
STATE AND LOCAL SALES TAX RATES
01:57:03.716 --> 01:57:06.185
IN THE NATION. A B 1951 WOULD
01:57:06.252 --> 01:57:07.954
HELP EASE SOME OF THOSE ECONOMIC
01:57:08.020 --> 01:57:10.022
BURDENS. CALIFORNIA HAS
01:57:10.089 --> 01:57:12.091
COMPARATIVE MANUFACTURING
01:57:12.158 --> 01:57:13.659
ADVANTAGES TO OTHER REGIONS OF
01:57:13.726 --> 01:57:14.961
THE WORLD DUE TO THE STRENGTH
01:57:15.027 --> 01:57:17.196
AND THE DEPTH OF ITS INNOVATION
01:57:17.263 --> 01:57:19.432
IN TECHNOLOGY. NOT ONLY DOES THE
01:57:19.499 --> 01:57:21.100
INDUSTRY EMPLOY 1.3 MILLION
01:57:21.167 --> 01:57:22.835
PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA IT ALSO
01:57:22.902 --> 01:57:25.438
PLAYS A KEY ROLE IN CREATING NEW
01:57:25.505 --> 01:57:27.106
JOBS, WITH ITS MULTIPLIER EFFECT
01:57:27.173 --> 01:57:28.174
SUPPORTING 2.5 JOBS FOR EVERYONE
01:57:28.241 --> 01:57:31.310
MANUFACTURING JOBS.
01:57:31.377 --> 01:57:32.845
MANUFACTURING PLAYS A CRUCIAL
01:57:32.912 --> 01:57:35.081
AND ITS CENTRAL ROLE WITHIN OUR
01:57:35.148 --> 01:57:35.882
STATE'S ECONOMY, SUPPORTING HIGH
01:57:35.948 --> 01:57:38.718
WAGE JOBS AND SMALL BUSINESSES
01:57:38.785 --> 01:57:41.053
WITH ROOM FOR GROWTH. IT IS IT
01:57:41.120 --> 01:57:44.123
IS MY HOPE THAT A B 1951 CAN BE
01:57:44.190 --> 01:57:46.125
A TIPPING POINT TO ENCOURAGE A
01:57:46.192 --> 01:57:47.860
NEW INVENT HERE. MANUFACTURER
01:57:47.927 --> 01:57:48.861
HERE REALITY BY INCENTIVIZING
01:57:48.928 --> 01:57:52.365
COMPANIES. TO PLANT ROOTS IN OUR
01:57:52.432 --> 01:57:54.634
STATE AND TO GROW AND BEFORE I
01:57:54.700 --> 01:57:56.803
CLOSE, I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE
01:57:56.869 --> 01:57:58.237
CONCERNS OF THE COUNTIES AND
01:57:58.304 --> 01:57:59.839
CITIES AS I SHARED WITH THE
01:57:59.906 --> 01:58:01.040
CHAIR WHEN WE MET TO DISCUSS
01:58:01.107 --> 01:58:03.209
THIS BILL. WE HAVE HAD POSITIVE
01:58:03.276 --> 01:58:04.310
CONVERSATIONS WITH
01:58:04.377 --> 01:58:05.711
REPRESENTATIVES FROM LOCAL
01:58:05.778 --> 01:58:07.213
GOVERNMENTS AND HAVE ALREADY
01:58:07.280 --> 01:58:08.781
STARTED THE PROCESS OF
01:58:08.848 --> 01:58:10.283
COORDINATING OUR EFFORTS WITH
01:58:10.349 --> 01:58:11.484
THEM AND THE SPONSORS OF THIS
01:58:11.551 --> 01:58:13.786
MEASURE. TO LOOK FOR WAYS TO
01:58:13.853 --> 01:58:14.954
MINIMIZE ANY FISCAL IMPACTS.
01:58:15.021 --> 01:58:17.457
THIS BILL MAY HAVE COMING FROM
01:58:17.523 --> 01:58:18.958
LOCAL GOVERNMENT, HAVING SERVED
01:58:19.025 --> 01:58:21.127
AS A COUNCIL MEMBER AND ALSO A
01:58:21.194 --> 01:58:22.728
MAYOR OF ONE OF THE LARGEST
01:58:22.795 --> 01:58:23.696
CITIES IN THE BAY AREA. I
01:58:23.763 --> 01:58:25.598
UNDERSTAND THE CHALLENGES FACED
01:58:25.665 --> 01:58:27.233
BY MY COLLEAGUES SERVING ON CITY
01:58:27.300 --> 01:58:28.935
COUNCILS AND COUNTY BOARD OF
01:58:29.001 --> 01:58:31.337
SUPERVISORS, AS I HAVE SHARED IN
01:58:31.404 --> 01:58:32.371
MY MEETINGS WITH LOCAL
01:58:32.438 --> 01:58:34.240
GOVERNMENT LOBBYISTS. MY INTENT
01:58:34.307 --> 01:58:35.908
HERE IS TO PROVIDE A CATALYST
01:58:35.975 --> 01:58:37.810
FOR JOBS AND ECONOMIC
01:58:37.877 --> 01:58:39.912
DEVELOPMENT AT A TIME WHEN ALL
01:58:39.979 --> 01:58:40.947
LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT COULD
01:58:41.013 --> 01:58:43.182
CERTAINLY USE MORE OF BOTH. I
01:58:43.249 --> 01:58:44.383
COMMIT TO CONTINUE WORKING WITH
01:58:44.450 --> 01:58:46.419
THEM IN THE COMING MONTHS. TO
01:58:46.486 --> 01:58:47.820
FIND A MUTUALLY AGREEABLE
01:58:47.887 --> 01:58:50.590
OUTCOME THAT LIVES UP BOTH OUR
01:58:50.656 --> 01:58:51.657
STATE'S MANUFACTURERS AND
01:58:51.724 --> 01:58:53.593
PARTNERS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT
01:58:53.659 --> 01:58:55.628
WITH THAT, UH, WHEN THE TIME
01:58:55.695 --> 01:58:56.796
COMES, I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:58:56.863 --> 01:58:58.731
AND I VOTE WITH ME HERE TO
01:58:58.798 --> 01:59:00.600
TESTIFY. OR LENGTH HATE. LANCE
01:59:00.666 --> 01:59:02.368
HASTINGS, PRESIDENT, CEO OF
01:59:02.435 --> 01:59:04.170
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS AND
01:59:04.237 --> 01:59:06.205
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION VIA
01:59:06.272 --> 01:59:07.840
TELECONFERENCE, AS WELL AS MARK
01:59:07.907 --> 01:59:08.841
TAYLOR, DIRECTOR OF GOVERNMENT
01:59:08.908 --> 01:59:11.210
OPERATIONS FROM BOEING. OKAY.
01:59:11.277 --> 01:59:12.712
MR. HASTINGS, ARE YOU AND ON THE
01:59:12.778 --> 01:59:17.550
LINE. PAYMENT I AM ON THE LINE,
01:59:17.617 --> 01:59:19.185
SIR. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MR
01:59:19.252 --> 01:59:21.187
CHAIRMAN, MR GRAYSON APPRECIATE
01:59:21.254 --> 01:59:22.054
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN
01:59:22.121 --> 01:59:24.490
SUPPORT OF A B 1951 AND ON
01:59:24.557 --> 01:59:25.124
BEHALF OF THE ENTIRE
01:59:25.191 --> 01:59:26.158
MANUFACTURING SECTOR, WE
01:59:26.225 --> 01:59:28.227
APPRECIATE MR GRAYSON'S EFFORT.
01:59:28.294 --> 01:59:29.762
TO BRING THIS ISSUE FORWARD AT A
01:59:29.829 --> 01:59:31.864
CRITICAL TIME IN THE STATE'S
01:59:31.931 --> 01:59:33.866
HISTORY AND ECONOMIC SITUATION.
01:59:33.933 --> 01:59:35.501
I AM IN WASHINGTON, D. C RIGHT
01:59:35.568 --> 01:59:37.937
NOW SELECT USA CONFERENCE OR
01:59:38.004 --> 01:59:39.138
I'VE BEEN REPRESENTING
01:59:39.205 --> 01:59:40.139
CALIFORNIA WITH THE DELEGATION
01:59:40.206 --> 01:59:42.275
OF ABOUT 30, OTHERS. TRYING TO
01:59:42.341 --> 01:59:43.042
APPEAL TO FOREIGN DIRECT
01:59:43.109 --> 01:59:45.144
INVESTMENT IN OUR STATE AND
01:59:45.211 --> 01:59:46.312
HAVING A TOUGH TIME BECAUSE THE
01:59:46.379 --> 01:59:47.380
OTHER STATE HAS MR GRAYSON
01:59:47.446 --> 01:59:50.783
STATED, HAVE THE TAX EXEMPTION
01:59:50.850 --> 01:59:52.518
THAT WE DO NOT, AND I DID SAY
01:59:52.585 --> 01:59:54.654
THAT WE ARE PURSUING LEGISLATION
01:59:54.720 --> 01:59:56.622
TO MAKE THAT A REALITY AND THE
01:59:56.689 --> 01:59:57.423
RESPONSE I GOT FROM EVERY
01:59:57.490 --> 01:59:58.524
BUSINESS INTEREST AND I SPOKE
01:59:58.591 --> 02:00:00.259
WITH WAS VERY FAVORABLE. WE DO
02:00:00.326 --> 02:00:01.861
BELIEVE THAT THERE IS A STRONG
02:00:01.928 --> 02:00:03.296
ECONOMIC INCENTIVE TO PASS THE
02:00:03.362 --> 02:00:05.765
BILL GENERATING AT LEAST $123
02:00:05.831 --> 02:00:08.100
BILLION OF NEW ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
02:00:08.167 --> 02:00:09.135
AND INCREASE IN THE
02:00:09.201 --> 02:00:10.236
MANUFACTURING JOB BASED BY OVER
02:00:10.303 --> 02:00:12.672
10. AND LIKE MR GRAYSON, WE
02:00:12.738 --> 02:00:15.007
REMAIN COMMITTED TO WORKING WITH
02:00:15.074 --> 02:00:15.908
LOCAL GOVERNMENT TO MAKE SURE
02:00:15.975 --> 02:00:18.311
THEY ARE KEPT AS FULL AS
02:00:18.377 --> 02:00:19.045
POSSIBLE. AND IN FACT THAT THAT
02:00:19.111 --> 02:00:20.146
ADDITIONAL ECONOMIC ACTIVITY WE
02:00:20.212 --> 02:00:23.816
FEEL THAT STATE LOCAL BUDGETS
02:00:23.883 --> 02:00:25.418
AND FISCUS IS GOING TO IMPROVE
02:00:25.484 --> 02:00:26.485
AS A RESULT OF THIS BILL IS
02:00:26.552 --> 02:00:27.520
APPROVED, AND WE ALSO
02:00:27.587 --> 02:00:28.588
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR EYE
02:00:28.654 --> 02:00:31.223
BOAT. THANK YOU, MR HASTINGS,
02:00:31.290 --> 02:00:36.662
AND WE HAVE ONE OTHER PERSON.
02:00:36.729 --> 02:00:37.830
MODERATOR. DO WE HAVE ONE OTHER
02:00:37.897 --> 02:00:44.337
PERSON IN Q THERE? AND WHAT IS
02:00:44.403 --> 02:00:48.708
THAT WITNESSES? NAME, PLEASE.
02:00:48.774 --> 02:00:49.909
MARTIN IT'S MARK TAYLOR FROM THE
02:00:49.976 --> 02:00:56.849
BOEING COMPANY. AND I DO LIKE
02:00:56.916 --> 02:01:00.953
THE LINE DIALED IN. NOT IN WELL,
02:01:01.020 --> 02:01:02.722
IF HE SHOWS UP, WE WILL
02:01:02.788 --> 02:01:03.723
ENTERTAIN HIS TESTIMONY WHERE HE
02:01:03.789 --> 02:01:06.359
WILL HAVE TO BE SHORTLY. DO WE
02:01:06.425 --> 02:01:07.360
HAVE ANY OPPOSITION HERE
02:01:07.426 --> 02:01:13.933
PRESENT? YOUR SPORT. YEAH DO WE
02:01:14.000 --> 02:01:15.735
HAVE ANY SUPPORT IN THE ROOM
02:01:15.801 --> 02:01:17.169
SUPPORTING THE ROOM? YEAH I'M
02:01:17.236 --> 02:01:18.270
SORRY. MICROBES IN HERE ON
02:01:18.337 --> 02:01:19.805
BEHALF OF THE GLASS PACKAGING IS
02:01:19.872 --> 02:01:21.507
TO THE TRADE ASSOCIATION OF
02:01:21.574 --> 02:01:22.108
GLASS BOTTLE MANUFACTURERS IN
02:01:22.174 --> 02:01:22.642
CALIFORNIA. THERE'S THREE
02:01:22.708 --> 02:01:25.077
PLANTS. UNIONIZED WORKFORCE AND
02:01:25.144 --> 02:01:29.081
SUPPORTED THE BILL. THANK YOU.
02:01:29.148 --> 02:01:31.217
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
02:01:31.283 --> 02:01:32.718
MICHAEL PIMENTEL WITH SHOWER
02:01:32.785 --> 02:01:33.886
DRAIN, WHICH SMELTER AND LYING
02:01:33.953 --> 02:01:35.054
ON BEHALF OF THE SPECIALTY
02:01:35.121 --> 02:01:36.155
EQUIPMENT MARKET ASSOCIATION AND
02:01:36.222 --> 02:01:40.493
SUPPORT. MR CHAIR MEMBERS, CHRIS
02:01:40.559 --> 02:01:41.961
MAKELELE, ON BEHALF OF THE
02:01:42.028 --> 02:01:43.029
HOLLYWOOD CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
02:01:43.095 --> 02:01:44.163
AND NIAGARA BOTTLING AND SUPPORT
02:01:44.230 --> 02:01:46.666
OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. GOOD
02:01:46.732 --> 02:01:47.667
MORNING, COLLECTING WITH THE
02:01:47.733 --> 02:01:48.701
SILICON VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP
02:01:48.768 --> 02:01:52.738
AND SUPPORT. IN THAT ROOM WITH
02:01:52.805 --> 02:01:53.939
NORMAL OF ABSENCES. HE GETS HERE
02:01:54.006 --> 02:01:55.074
FOR BLUE DIAMOND GROWERS AND
02:01:55.141 --> 02:01:57.610
SUPPORT MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. REX
02:01:57.677 --> 02:01:59.845
W. HEIM ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
02:01:59.912 --> 02:02:00.479
BUSINESS PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION
02:02:00.546 --> 02:02:01.947
NAP, CALIFORNIA BUILDING OWNERS
02:02:02.014 --> 02:02:02.882
AND MANAGERS ASSOCIATION,
02:02:02.948 --> 02:02:03.883
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
02:02:03.949 --> 02:02:07.720
YOU. MR VICE CHAIR MEMBERS,
02:02:07.787 --> 02:02:08.954
LEWIS MERANTI SPEAKING ON BEHALF
02:02:09.021 --> 02:02:10.089
OF THE BAY AREA COUNCIL AND
02:02:10.156 --> 02:02:13.826
SUPPORT THANKS MR VICE CHAIR AND
02:02:13.893 --> 02:02:15.161
MEMBERS LARA FITZGERALD ON
02:02:15.227 --> 02:02:16.195
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA LIFE
02:02:16.262 --> 02:02:17.196
SCIENCES AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:02:17.263 --> 02:02:19.699
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WE DON'T
02:02:19.765 --> 02:02:20.866
NORMALLY HAVE SO MANY IN THE
02:02:20.933 --> 02:02:24.937
ROOM. DO YOU HAVE ANYONE
02:02:25.004 --> 02:02:28.874
MODERATOR IN Q. IN ADDITION, TO
02:02:28.941 --> 02:02:31.177
SPEAK. YES AND IF THEY WOULD
02:02:31.243 --> 02:02:32.611
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B
02:02:32.678 --> 02:02:34.847
1951 PRESS 10 AND THE LITTLE
02:02:34.914 --> 02:02:39.085
LINE AT 3 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:02:39.151 --> 02:02:40.619
THANK YOU. CHERRY MEMBERS.
02:02:40.686 --> 02:02:42.822
BALLON BEHALF OF RYAN LLC
02:02:42.888 --> 02:02:43.823
ATTACKED CONSULTING FIRM AND
02:02:43.889 --> 02:02:47.827
STRONG SUPPORT. NEXT A LITTLE
02:02:47.893 --> 02:02:52.331
LINE 3 67, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:02:52.398 --> 02:02:53.265
MORNING. THIS IS TRUDY HUGE, OR
02:02:53.332 --> 02:02:54.734
THE CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF FOOD
02:02:54.800 --> 02:02:55.935
PRODUCERS REPRESENTING FOOD
02:02:56.001 --> 02:02:57.103
PROCESSING ACROSS THE STATE OF
02:02:57.169 --> 02:02:58.671
CALIFORNIA VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT
02:02:58.738 --> 02:03:01.140
OF THE BILL, AND I JUST THINK OF
02:03:01.207 --> 02:03:02.174
SOMETHING MEMBER PRECINCT
02:03:02.241 --> 02:03:04.543
INTERVIEW THING. LINE. 3 48,
02:03:04.610 --> 02:03:09.849
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
02:03:09.915 --> 02:03:12.218
AUDRA HARTMAN WITH PUBLIC POLICY
02:03:12.284 --> 02:03:13.719
AVERAGES ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
02:03:13.786 --> 02:03:14.954
STEEL INDUSTRIES, A COMPANY
02:03:15.020 --> 02:03:16.455
LOCATED IN FONTANA, CALIFORNIA,
02:03:16.522 --> 02:03:18.224
WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
02:03:18.290 --> 02:03:21.393
THANK YOU. LINE 1 40, PLEASE GO
02:03:21.460 --> 02:03:25.798
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MR VICE
02:03:25.865 --> 02:03:27.333
CHAIR MEMBERS, DAVE BUTLER ON
02:03:27.399 --> 02:03:28.267
BEHALF OF UNITED CHAMBER
02:03:28.334 --> 02:03:30.302
ADVOCACY NETWORK AND COALITION
02:03:30.369 --> 02:03:32.338
OF NINE LOCAL CHAMBERS OF
02:03:32.404 --> 02:03:33.606
COMMERCE ACROSS FOR NORTHERN
02:03:33.672 --> 02:03:38.077
CALIFORNIA COUNTIES IN SUPPORT.
02:03:38.144 --> 02:03:39.278
BLIND 1071. OH, SEVEN. PLEASE GO
02:03:39.345 --> 02:03:44.550
AHEAD. HI ASSAULT THE CHECKER
02:03:44.617 --> 02:03:46.385
WITH THE LAW AREA CHAMBER OF
02:03:46.452 --> 02:03:49.088
COMMERCE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:03:49.155 --> 02:03:53.692
LINE. 3 64, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:03:53.759 --> 02:03:54.860
GOOD MORNING. SARAH NUMBERS.
02:03:54.927 --> 02:03:56.495
THIS IS CONOR MEDINA ON BEHALF
02:03:56.562 --> 02:03:58.164
OF THE ORANGE COUNTY BUSINESS
02:03:58.230 --> 02:04:01.600
COUNCIL IN SUPPORT OF A B 1951.
02:04:01.667 --> 02:04:05.838
LINE. 3 57, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:04:05.905 --> 02:04:06.972
THANK YOU. PRESTON YOUNG FROM
02:04:07.039 --> 02:04:07.940
THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
02:04:08.007 --> 02:04:11.343
COMMERCE HERE IN SUPPORT. LINE 2
02:04:11.410 --> 02:04:17.049
46, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 2 46
02:04:17.116 --> 02:04:22.488
LINE IS OPEN. PARENT MEMBERS,
02:04:22.555 --> 02:04:23.622
PARTICULARLY ER WITH
02:04:23.689 --> 02:04:24.590
AGRICULTURAL COUNCIL OF
02:04:24.657 --> 02:04:28.327
CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:04:28.394 --> 02:04:29.495
LINE THREE. OH, THREE. PLEASE GO
02:04:29.562 --> 02:04:34.033
AHEAD. JOEL BACK THROUGH WITH
02:04:34.099 --> 02:04:35.100
WEST DROP, DEFYING STRONG
02:04:35.167 --> 02:04:40.206
SUPPORT. LINE. 3 55, PLEASE GO
02:04:40.272 --> 02:04:44.476
AHEAD. MOTHER PROBABLY GO HOME
02:04:44.543 --> 02:04:52.718
AND SUPPORT. AND NEXT WITH THE
02:04:52.785 --> 02:04:56.622
LINE 3 77, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:04:56.689 --> 02:04:58.657
STUDENT GROUPS OF BIO COMMON
02:04:58.724 --> 02:04:59.658
CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:04:59.725 --> 02:05:03.229
THANK YOU. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
02:05:03.295 --> 02:05:08.200
COMMENTS IN QUÊ. THANK YOU.
02:05:08.267 --> 02:05:10.302
OPPOSITION ANY ONE IN THE ROOM
02:05:10.369 --> 02:05:16.609
IN A POST POSITION. SEEING NONE
02:05:16.675 --> 02:05:17.776
. MODERATOR CAN YOU AND HERE WE
02:05:17.843 --> 02:05:22.348
GO. THANK YOU, SENATOR JEFF NEAL
02:05:22.414 --> 02:05:23.115
WITH THE CALIFORNIA STATE
02:05:23.182 --> 02:05:24.617
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES
02:05:24.683 --> 02:05:26.819
RESPECTFULLY IN A POSITION OF
02:05:26.886 --> 02:05:29.788
OPPOSING LESS AMENDED. UM UM IT
02:05:29.855 --> 02:05:31.857
WAS A LONG LINE OF PEOPLE IN
02:05:31.924 --> 02:05:33.492
SUPPORT. WHO KNEW THAT PEOPLE
02:05:33.559 --> 02:05:34.660
LIKE PAYING LOWER TAXES, BUT WE
02:05:34.727 --> 02:05:35.861
DO HAVE TO FUND GOVERNMENT
02:05:35.928 --> 02:05:39.531
SOMEHOW. AND IN THIS CASE WE
02:05:39.598 --> 02:05:41.967
HAVE FOR THIS EQUIPMENT RIGHT
02:05:42.034 --> 02:05:42.701
NOW. IT'S ABOUT HALF OF THE
02:05:42.768 --> 02:05:45.571
USUAL SALES TAX THAT THEY PAY,
02:05:45.638 --> 02:05:47.239
AND THAT FUNDS NOT ONLY COUNTY
02:05:47.306 --> 02:05:50.276
AND CITY GENERAL FUNDS, BUT ALSO
02:05:50.342 --> 02:05:53.879
A NUMBER OF OTHER OF OTHER ITEMS
02:05:53.946 --> 02:05:55.214
. PROBLEM 72 FOR PUBLIC SAFETY
02:05:55.281 --> 02:05:57.416
TRANSPORTATION FUNDS. AND
02:05:57.483 --> 02:05:58.651
IMPORTANTLY, ALSO THE
02:05:58.717 --> 02:06:01.220
REALIGNMENT FUNDS THAT ARE PAID
02:06:01.287 --> 02:06:02.621
FOR BY SALES TAX SERVICES THAT
02:06:02.688 --> 02:06:04.490
INCLUDE THE HEALTH AND HUMAN
02:06:04.556 --> 02:06:05.557
SERVICE PROGRAMS AND IMPORTANTLY
02:06:05.624 --> 02:06:07.293
, FOR A LOT OF DISCUSSIONS THIS
02:06:07.359 --> 02:06:07.893
YEAR, ALSO BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:06:07.960 --> 02:06:09.528
SERVICES AND SO YOU KNOW,
02:06:09.595 --> 02:06:12.097
THROUGH BILLS THAT ARE MÀ
02:06:12.164 --> 02:06:13.766
MATRICULATING THROUGH OTHER
02:06:13.832 --> 02:06:15.100
COMMITTEES. A LOT OF DISCUSSION
02:06:15.167 --> 02:06:16.068
ABOUT THE BEHAVIOR, HEALTH
02:06:16.135 --> 02:06:19.071
SERVICES AND WHETHER TO INCREASE
02:06:19.138 --> 02:06:20.172
FUNDING FOR THEM. UNFORTUNATELY
02:06:20.239 --> 02:06:21.740
THIS BILL WOULD HAVE THE
02:06:21.807 --> 02:06:22.808
OPPOSITE EFFECT AND CUT THAT
02:06:22.875 --> 02:06:25.711
FUNDING. HOWEVER WE HAVE HAD
02:06:25.778 --> 02:06:26.545
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR'S
02:06:26.612 --> 02:06:28.781
OFFICE AND WHAT WE HOPE WE CAN
02:06:28.847 --> 02:06:29.815
DO WITH THIS WITH WITH
02:06:29.882 --> 02:06:31.951
AMENDMENTS THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO
02:06:32.017 --> 02:06:33.919
SEE IS MAKE A MODEL. OF THIS
02:06:33.986 --> 02:06:36.288
BILL IF WE CAN GET IT SO THAT
02:06:36.355 --> 02:06:39.291
THE SO THAT THE STATE AT LEAST
02:06:39.358 --> 02:06:40.759
REIMBURSES THE LOSSES TO LOCAL
02:06:40.826 --> 02:06:43.662
AGENCIES, SINCE IF THERE IS A IF
02:06:43.729 --> 02:06:45.931
THERE IS AN ECONOMIC IMPACT OF
02:06:45.998 --> 02:06:48.133
THIS BILL, A POSITIVE ECONOMIC
02:06:48.200 --> 02:06:49.702
IMPACT HE TAX REVENUES IN
02:06:49.768 --> 02:06:51.303
GENERAL WON'T ACTUALLY FLOW TO
02:06:51.370 --> 02:06:52.571
THE TO THE COUNTIES AND CITIES
02:06:52.638 --> 02:06:55.207
THAT ARE LOSING THIS REVENUE. BE
02:06:55.274 --> 02:06:56.709
MUCH MORE LIKELY TO FLOW THROUGH
02:06:56.775 --> 02:06:58.844
THE INCOME TAXES AND CORPORATE
02:06:58.911 --> 02:07:00.646
TAXES THAT THE STATE RECEIVES.
02:07:00.713 --> 02:07:02.848
AND AS A FEW MEMBERS OF THIS
02:07:02.915 --> 02:07:04.917
COMMITTEE HEARD ME, SAY, 14 OR
02:07:04.984 --> 02:07:06.852
15 HOURS AGO IN THIS ROOM, THREE
02:07:06.919 --> 02:07:08.854
OUT OF FOUR COUNTIES HAVE LESS
02:07:08.921 --> 02:07:10.255
GENERAL FUND REVENUE PER CAPITA
02:07:10.322 --> 02:07:11.857
NOW THAN THEY HAD 15 YEARS AGO.
02:07:11.924 --> 02:07:14.360
SO IF WE CAN MAKE A MODEL OF
02:07:14.426 --> 02:07:15.594
THIS BILL AND INCLUDE EITHER A
02:07:15.661 --> 02:07:17.129
REIMBURSEMENT OR MAKE THE EFFECT
02:07:17.196 --> 02:07:19.898
OF THE BILL. CONTINGENT UPON AN
02:07:19.965 --> 02:07:21.600
APPROPRIATION, REIMBURSING
02:07:21.667 --> 02:07:23.002
COUNTIES AND CITIES FOR THEIR
02:07:23.068 --> 02:07:26.238
LOSSES, THEN WE WOULD BE HAPPY
02:07:26.305 --> 02:07:27.339
TO SUPPORT THIS BECAUSE LOCAL
02:07:27.406 --> 02:07:30.743
AGENCIES DO UM, I DO APPRECIATE
02:07:30.809 --> 02:07:31.710
THE MANUFACTURERS AND THEIR
02:07:31.777 --> 02:07:33.779
COMMUNITIES, BUT TAKING THE
02:07:33.846 --> 02:07:36.081
MONEY. UH THE OTHER THING I'D
02:07:36.148 --> 02:07:37.850
LIKE TO POINT OUT IS THAT IT
02:07:37.916 --> 02:07:39.852
WOULD TAKE THE MONEY BECAUSE OF
02:07:39.918 --> 02:07:41.220
THE WAY THESE REALIGNMENT
02:07:41.286 --> 02:07:42.421
FORMULAS WORK, TAKE THE MONEY
02:07:42.488 --> 02:07:43.555
FROM ALL COUNTIES IN THE STATE,
02:07:43.622 --> 02:07:45.758
NOT ONLY THE AREAS WHERE THE
02:07:45.824 --> 02:07:48.827
MANUFACTURING ACTIVITY WILL WILL
02:07:48.894 --> 02:07:51.797
OCCUR, AND SO YOU KNOW, EVEN IN
02:07:51.864 --> 02:07:54.099
SMALL COUNTIES, SENATOR IT LIKE
02:07:54.166 --> 02:07:55.634
IN MUCH OF YOUR DISTRICT, THEY
02:07:55.701 --> 02:07:56.735
WILL SEE THE REVENUE LOSSES AS
02:07:56.802 --> 02:07:58.737
WELL. SO WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE A
02:07:58.804 --> 02:08:00.773
REIMBURSEMENT OR CONTINGENT UPON
02:08:00.839 --> 02:08:01.673
APPROPRIATION. ADDED TO THE
02:08:01.740 --> 02:08:03.509
BILL. IF THAT HAPPENS, WE'D BE
02:08:03.575 --> 02:08:05.844
HAPPY TO SUPPORT BUT AS THE BILL
02:08:05.911 --> 02:08:07.413
STANDS RIGHT NOW WE ARE
02:08:07.479 --> 02:08:08.347
RESPECTFULLY AND OPPOSITION.
02:08:08.414 --> 02:08:11.116
THANK YOU. I UNDERSTAND, SIR,
02:08:11.183 --> 02:08:12.718
AND I PROBABLY DON'T RUN AROUND
02:08:12.785 --> 02:08:14.820
HERE THAT REMEMBERS, BUT THE
02:08:14.887 --> 02:08:18.090
INFAMOUS SB 90 DISCLAIMERS.
02:08:18.157 --> 02:08:20.225
WHEREBY THE STATE HAD AN
02:08:20.292 --> 02:08:21.326
OBLIGATION TO REIMBURSE AND JUST
02:08:21.393 --> 02:08:24.096
JUST MADE A STATEMENT TO CLEAR
02:08:24.163 --> 02:08:26.865
THE AIR FOR THEM. OR THEIR
02:08:26.932 --> 02:08:27.933
LIABILITY THAT JUST DID NOT
02:08:28.000 --> 02:08:32.237
REPRESENT. A MANDATE. SB 90
02:08:32.304 --> 02:08:34.039
DISCLAIMERS. WE OFTEN FORGET
02:08:34.106 --> 02:08:35.974
THAT I CERTAINLY AM SYMPATHY
02:08:36.041 --> 02:08:37.443
WITH THE PLIGHT OF COUNTIES. BUT
02:08:37.509 --> 02:08:38.977
I'M ALSO VERY SYMPATHY IN
02:08:39.044 --> 02:08:42.581
SYMPATHY WITH THIS BILL SER.
02:08:42.648 --> 02:08:44.016
THANK YOU CHAIR AND NICK ROMAN
02:08:44.083 --> 02:08:45.350
BEHALF OF LEGAL CALIFORNIA CITY
02:08:45.417 --> 02:08:46.685
, JOINING C SACKING OPPOSITION
02:08:46.752 --> 02:08:48.620
UNLESS AMENDED. I'D LIKE TO TAKE
02:08:48.687 --> 02:08:50.055
A MOMENT TO THANK THE AUTHOR,
02:08:50.122 --> 02:08:51.623
HIS STAFF AND THE SPONSORS FOR
02:08:51.690 --> 02:08:53.425
WORKING WITH US, AND I LOOK
02:08:53.492 --> 02:08:54.293
FORWARD TO FURTHER
02:08:54.359 --> 02:08:55.227
CONVERSATIONS. THANK YOU SO
02:08:55.294 --> 02:08:59.098
MUCH. ONE MORE SORRY I AM
02:08:59.164 --> 02:09:00.399
ON THE SUPPORT SIDE, SO I
02:09:00.466 --> 02:09:02.568
APOLOGIZE AHEAD. DENNIS DENNIS
02:09:02.634 --> 02:09:03.735
ALBION E WITH THE FAMILY
02:09:03.802 --> 02:09:04.937
BUSINESS ASSOCIATION OF
02:09:05.003 --> 02:09:06.672
CALIFORNIA, ALSO WITH THE CAN
02:09:06.738 --> 02:09:07.940
MAN FACTORING INSTITUTE. THEY
02:09:08.006 --> 02:09:10.943
ASKED ME TO. TO ME, TOO, AS
02:09:11.009 --> 02:09:12.244
WELL. AND THEN I HAVE SEVERAL
02:09:12.311 --> 02:09:13.245
CLIENTS THAT SUPPORT THIS AS
02:09:13.312 --> 02:09:15.814
WELL. THANK YOU. NÓ ASSEMBLYMAN
02:09:15.881 --> 02:09:17.316
. THERE ARE AN AWFUL LOT OF
02:09:17.382 --> 02:09:18.650
SMALLER AND MEDIUM SIZED
02:09:18.717 --> 02:09:19.785
BUSINESSES, THAT'S FOR SURE. AND
02:09:19.852 --> 02:09:23.088
WE OFTEN FORGET THEM. ALRIGHT
02:09:23.155 --> 02:09:25.724
WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE US WELL?
02:09:25.791 --> 02:09:26.859
ANY ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE
02:09:26.925 --> 02:09:29.795
COMMITTEE? YES, SENATOR ROSS Ó.
02:09:29.862 --> 02:09:34.633
THE. ONE DID WE? I THOUGHT I
02:09:34.700 --> 02:09:38.003
DID. OKAY. MODERATOR YOU CALL UP
02:09:38.070 --> 02:09:43.175
ANYONE ON IN QUÊ. RECENTLY YEP.
02:09:43.242 --> 02:09:45.210
IF THEY'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:09:45.277 --> 02:09:46.411
OPPOSITION, THE A B 1951 PRESS
02:09:46.478 --> 02:09:48.147
10. AND LITTLE LINE. 3 60,
02:09:48.213 --> 02:09:51.950
PLEASE GO AHEAD. KAREN MEMBERS
02:09:52.017 --> 02:09:53.452
CATALINA SANCHEZ WITH CORBETT
02:09:53.519 --> 02:09:54.953
AND KAISER ON BEHALF OF THE
02:09:55.020 --> 02:09:55.787
CALIFORNIA TAX REFORM
02:09:55.854 --> 02:09:56.822
ASSOCIATION AND OPPOSITION.
02:09:56.889 --> 02:10:01.760
THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO TO LINE 3
02:10:01.827 --> 02:10:05.764
81, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THREE
02:10:05.831 --> 02:10:10.903
AFTERNOON. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS
02:10:10.969 --> 02:10:12.571
IS ACTUALLY MARK TAYLOR. I WAS
02:10:12.638 --> 02:10:13.839
ORIGINALLY SCHEDULED TO BE ONE
02:10:13.906 --> 02:10:15.307
OF THE SPEAKERS AD SUPPORT OF
02:10:15.374 --> 02:10:17.209
THIS. UM I'M NOT QUITE SURE HOW
02:10:17.276 --> 02:10:20.479
ENDED UP IN THIS QUÊ. AH. I
02:10:20.546 --> 02:10:22.347
DON'T KNOW IF YOU STILL WANT ME
02:10:22.414 --> 02:10:24.249
TO TAKE MY TWO MINUTES OR JUST
02:10:24.316 --> 02:10:26.084
TO MEET YOU AT THIS PROCEDURE,
02:10:26.151 --> 02:10:27.619
SIR. GO AHEAD. GO AHEAD. THANK
02:10:27.686 --> 02:10:29.121
YOU TO THE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
02:10:29.188 --> 02:10:30.289
MEMBERS AND THANK YOU
02:10:30.355 --> 02:10:30.856
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON FOR
02:10:30.923 --> 02:10:31.723
BRINGING THIS IMPORTANT BILL
02:10:31.790 --> 02:10:33.659
FORWARD. MY NAME IS MARK TAYLOR
02:10:33.725 --> 02:10:34.793
AND I CURRENTLY SERVED THE CHAIR
02:10:34.860 --> 02:10:36.028
OF THE AEROSPACE AND DEFENSE
02:10:36.094 --> 02:10:38.463
ALLIANCE FOR CALIFORNIA. ALSO
02:10:38.530 --> 02:10:40.232
KNOWN AS A DECK APPEARED TODAY
02:10:40.299 --> 02:10:41.600
TO REQUEST YOUR SUPPORT FOR A B
02:10:41.667 --> 02:10:43.802
1951 HELP MAINTAIN AND IMPROVE
02:10:43.869 --> 02:10:45.304
THE COMPETITIVENESS OF
02:10:45.370 --> 02:10:45.971
CALIFORNIA'S AEROSPACE
02:10:46.038 --> 02:10:48.540
MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY. OUR
02:10:48.607 --> 02:10:49.841
INDUSTRY DIRECTLY EMPLOYS MORE
02:10:49.908 --> 02:10:51.944
THAN HALF A MILLION CALIFORNIANS
02:10:52.010 --> 02:10:53.545
AND EARN AN AVERAGE INCOME OF
02:10:53.612 --> 02:10:55.347
MORE THAN $109,000 PER YEAR WITH
02:10:55.414 --> 02:10:58.183
GENEROUS BENEFITS. THE AEROSPACE
02:10:58.250 --> 02:10:59.685
INDUSTRIES. ANNUAL ECONOMIC
02:10:59.751 --> 02:11:01.954
IMPACT IN CALIFORNIA IS LARGER
02:11:02.020 --> 02:11:03.021
THAN THE COMBINED IMPACT OF
02:11:03.088 --> 02:11:06.291
AGRICULTURE AND ENTERTAINMENT. A
02:11:06.358 --> 02:11:08.460
B 1951 WERE REDUCED THE COST OF
02:11:08.527 --> 02:11:09.328
EXPANDING MANUFACTURING
02:11:09.394 --> 02:11:10.762
FACILITIES IN CALIFORNIA AND
02:11:10.829 --> 02:11:12.631
HELP TO LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD
02:11:12.698 --> 02:11:14.700
WITH OTHER LOW COST STATES.
02:11:14.766 --> 02:11:15.601
INCREASED PRODUCTION WILL LEAD
02:11:15.667 --> 02:11:17.703
TO INCREASED UTILITY USER TAXES
02:11:17.769 --> 02:11:18.904
, SALES TAXES FOR AH, MATERIALS
02:11:18.971 --> 02:11:20.739
THAT WILL HELP OFFSET SOME OF
02:11:20.806 --> 02:11:22.641
THE REVENUE WAS LOST. GOING
02:11:22.708 --> 02:11:23.275
RECENTLY EXPANDED OUR
02:11:23.342 --> 02:11:25.644
MANUFACTURING CAPACITY AND R L.
02:11:25.711 --> 02:11:27.079
FERNANDO AND SOME ARE FACILITIES
02:11:27.145 --> 02:11:28.180
, AND THIS MEASURE WOULD PROVIDE
02:11:28.247 --> 02:11:29.281
AN INCENTIVE FOR ADDITIONAL
02:11:29.348 --> 02:11:32.484
EXPANSION AND FUTURE. MAYBE 1951
02:11:32.551 --> 02:11:33.986
WOULD HELP REVERSE THE INVENT
02:11:34.052 --> 02:11:35.887
HERE. DESIGN IT HERE AND BUILD.
02:11:35.954 --> 02:11:38.357
IT S ELSEWHERE. TREND WE'VE SEEN
02:11:38.423 --> 02:11:39.725
FAR TOO OFTEN IN CALIFORNIA.
02:11:39.791 --> 02:11:41.026
INCREASING MANUFACTURING
02:11:41.093 --> 02:11:42.494
CALIFORNIA WILL HELP INCREASE
02:11:42.561 --> 02:11:44.763
THE NUMBER OF HIGH WAGE JOBS
02:11:44.830 --> 02:11:45.864
GOING AND ARE MORE THAN 2000
02:11:45.931 --> 02:11:46.832
LOCAL SUPPLIERS HAVE IN
02:11:46.898 --> 02:11:49.234
CALIFORNIA. EVERY MANUFACTURING
02:11:49.301 --> 02:11:51.069
JOB SUPPORTS ADDITIONAL 2.5 JOBS
02:11:51.136 --> 02:11:52.104
IN OTHER INDUSTRIES THROUGH
02:11:52.170 --> 02:11:54.606
INDIRECT AND INDUCED JOB.
02:11:54.673 --> 02:11:57.509
FINALLY WE THINK 1951 WILL HELP
02:11:57.576 --> 02:11:58.744
PROVIDE LIES CALIFORNIA'S
02:11:58.810 --> 02:11:59.678
COMPETITIVENESS, PUTTING US IN
02:11:59.745 --> 02:12:01.880
LINE WITH OTHER STATES WHO
02:12:01.947 --> 02:12:02.614
ALREADY FULLY SET MANUFACTURING
02:12:02.681 --> 02:12:04.816
EQUIPMENT THAT IS PURCHASED AND
02:12:04.883 --> 02:12:06.752
USE THEIR SO ON BEHALF OF A DOC.
02:12:06.818 --> 02:12:09.388
I URGE YOUR I VOTE TO SUPPORT
02:12:09.454 --> 02:12:10.289
CALIFORNIA'S CONTINUED ROLE AS A
02:12:10.355 --> 02:12:11.423
NATIONAL LEADER IN AEROSPACE
02:12:11.490 --> 02:12:12.324
MANUFACTURING. THANK YOU. THANK
02:12:12.391 --> 02:12:16.995
YOU. MODERATOR ANY ADDITIONAL.
02:12:17.062 --> 02:12:19.331
TESTIMONY YES, WE'RE GOING TO
02:12:19.398 --> 02:12:21.333
LINE UP. WE'LL GO TO LINE 3 69,
02:12:21.400 --> 02:12:23.869
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI GOOD MORNING
02:12:23.935 --> 02:12:24.903
. MY NAME IS SARA DEL ANTHONY
02:12:24.970 --> 02:12:26.938
CHEE AND I'M, AN OWNER OF STILL
02:12:27.005 --> 02:12:27.973
GROUP REAL ESTATE AND MORTGAGE
02:12:28.040 --> 02:12:29.875
PROGRAMMED AND I'M GOING TO ASK
02:12:29.941 --> 02:12:31.343
YOU GUYS TO GREENFIELD NO 80
02:12:31.410 --> 02:12:34.346
2040 BECAUSE IT ENDS LOCAL JOBS
02:12:34.413 --> 02:12:35.881
FOR VETERANS RIGHT AWAY, AND
02:12:35.947 --> 02:12:37.382
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WE
02:12:37.449 --> 02:12:38.450
MAKE SURE OUR VETERANS HAVE GOOD
02:12:38.517 --> 02:12:40.786
JOB. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE
02:12:40.852 --> 02:12:42.387
WERE ON SUPPORT, BUT WE'LL
02:12:42.454 --> 02:12:43.722
CERTAINLY ACCEPT YOUR TESTIMONY
02:12:43.789 --> 02:12:45.457
, AND IT IS ON RECORD MODERATOR
02:12:45.524 --> 02:12:46.258
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
02:12:46.325 --> 02:12:50.495
WITNESSES. NO FURTHER.
02:12:50.562 --> 02:12:52.597
PARTICIPANTS IN Q. OKAY DO YOU
02:12:52.664 --> 02:12:54.199
HAVE ANY AND QUÊ ADDITIONAL TO
02:12:54.266 --> 02:12:55.267
THIS YOUNG WOMAN WOULD WOULD
02:12:55.334 --> 02:13:02.374
OPPOSITION. I DO NOT OKAY, WOULD
02:13:02.441 --> 02:13:03.742
YOU? NOT ANY QUESTIONS OF
02:13:03.809 --> 02:13:05.911
MEMBERS? SENATOR ROSS? OH, THANK
02:13:05.977 --> 02:13:07.979
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
02:13:08.046 --> 02:13:10.849
CHAIR. UM I DID WANT TO RAISE AN
02:13:10.916 --> 02:13:14.586
ISSUE. I HAVE BEEN WORKING. UM
02:13:14.653 --> 02:13:15.821
REALLY HARD ON THE ISSUE OF HIGH
02:13:15.887 --> 02:13:21.059
ROAD. LABOR STANDARDS OVER THE
02:13:21.126 --> 02:13:24.596
LAST FEW YEARS, AND PARTICULARLY
02:13:24.663 --> 02:13:25.630
AROUND MANUFACTURING, BECAUSE A
02:13:25.697 --> 02:13:29.434
LOT OF THE CONSTRUCTION WORK.
02:13:29.501 --> 02:13:33.972
WE'VE BECOME. UM A LITTLE BIT
02:13:34.039 --> 02:13:36.675
MORE ACCEPTABLE OF GOOD
02:13:36.742 --> 02:13:38.744
STANDARDS IN THE CONSTRUCTION
02:13:38.810 --> 02:13:41.446
INDUSTRY, SO THAT IS WELL ON ITS
02:13:41.513 --> 02:13:43.348
WAY TO PROVIDING THE GOOD GOOD
02:13:43.415 --> 02:13:44.383
HIGH LABOR STANDARDS THAT WE
02:13:44.449 --> 02:13:46.985
WANT. UM HOWEVER, IN
02:13:47.052 --> 02:13:52.924
MANUFACTURING. IT'S NOT THERE
02:13:52.991 --> 02:13:54.192
AND I APPRECIATE THERE WERE SOME
02:13:54.259 --> 02:13:56.628
OF THE SUPPORTERS THAT MENTIONED
02:13:56.695 --> 02:13:58.964
THE YOU KNOW, HIGH ROAD OR THEY
02:13:59.030 --> 02:14:01.233
MENTIONED UNION JOBS. UM BUT
02:14:01.299 --> 02:14:05.237
IT'S REALLY NOT A PART OF OUR UM
02:14:05.303 --> 02:14:06.805
, THE WAY THAT WE DO BUSINESS AS
02:14:06.872 --> 02:14:09.441
A STATE. UM AND SO I WOULD LIKE
02:14:09.508 --> 02:14:12.944
FOR YOU TO, UH TO WORK WITH YOU.
02:14:13.011 --> 02:14:15.280
I WOULD LIKE TO WORK WITH YOU ON
02:14:15.347 --> 02:14:16.415
HIGH ROAD LABOR STANDARDS,
02:14:16.481 --> 02:14:19.885
LANGUAGE. UH UM, WE'RE GETTING
02:14:19.951 --> 02:14:21.653
SOME. VERY WE'VE GOTTEN SOME
02:14:21.720 --> 02:14:25.590
VERSION OF THAT, UM IN THE
02:14:25.657 --> 02:14:26.625
UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE CODE. UM
02:14:26.691 --> 02:14:30.595
AND WE'RE PERFECTING IT AS WE GO
02:14:30.662 --> 02:14:32.564
ALONG, BUT THE PROCUREMENT
02:14:32.631 --> 02:14:35.634
PROCESS SHOULD CREATE MORE JOBS
02:14:35.700 --> 02:14:37.135
. MORE GOOD. YOU UH, HIGH ROAD
02:14:37.202 --> 02:14:40.539
STANDARD JOBS. THEN WHAT IS DONE
02:14:40.605 --> 02:14:42.340
RIGHT NOW? RIGHT NOW IT'S SORT
02:14:42.407 --> 02:14:44.342
OF HIT AND MISS. MAYBE SOMETIMES
02:14:44.409 --> 02:14:46.845
AND I REALLY WANT TO, UM,
02:14:46.912 --> 02:14:48.880
MANUFACTURING TO GROW IN
02:14:48.947 --> 02:14:49.981
CALIFORNIA, BUT USING OUR TAX
02:14:50.048 --> 02:14:53.585
DOLLARS SHOULD MEAN IT SHOULDN'T
02:14:53.652 --> 02:14:56.621
MEAN HIT AND MISS OR, YOU KNOW,
02:14:56.688 --> 02:14:58.290
TRICKLE DOWN THEORIES. IT SHOULD
02:14:58.356 --> 02:15:00.058
REALLY USE OUR TAX DOLLARS TO
02:15:00.125 --> 02:15:01.993
THE MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF WORKERS.
02:15:02.060 --> 02:15:06.465
SO UM, I WANT YOU TO CONSIDER
02:15:06.531 --> 02:15:08.300
THAT AND I WILL GLADLY WORK WITH
02:15:08.366 --> 02:15:10.101
YOU ON THAT. THANK YOU, SENATOR
02:15:10.168 --> 02:15:11.136
FOR YOUR OBSERVATION, AND IN
02:15:11.203 --> 02:15:14.139
THIS PARTICULAR CASE, UH, BY THE
02:15:14.206 --> 02:15:16.341
WAY, I HEAR EXACTLY WHAT YOU'RE
02:15:16.408 --> 02:15:17.709
SAYING, AND ALWAYS TRYING TO
02:15:17.776 --> 02:15:18.877
RAISE THE STANDARD, ESPECIALLY
02:15:18.944 --> 02:15:21.079
IF SOMEONE IS GETTING A BENEFIT.
02:15:21.146 --> 02:15:22.614
FROM THE TAX DOLLAR. THIS
02:15:22.681 --> 02:15:24.349
PARTICULAR BILL WAS DRAFTED
02:15:24.416 --> 02:15:26.318
USING PARTIAL SALES AND USE TAX
02:15:26.384 --> 02:15:29.187
EXEMPTION THAT IS IN CURRENT
02:15:29.254 --> 02:15:32.190
STATUTE. SO OUT OF THE UTMOST
02:15:32.257 --> 02:15:32.858
PRUDENCE AND REALLY AT THE
02:15:32.924 --> 02:15:34.659
ADVICE OF THE REVEREND TAX
02:15:34.726 --> 02:15:38.196
COMMITTEE. WE WERE WE WERE
02:15:38.263 --> 02:15:40.198
INSTRUCTED AND DID SO KEPT THE
02:15:40.265 --> 02:15:41.967
BILL AS CLEAN AS POSSIBLE IN AN
02:15:42.033 --> 02:15:43.602
EFFORT TO MAINTAIN CONSISTENCY
02:15:43.668 --> 02:15:44.669
WITH WHAT CURRENTLY IS TAX
02:15:44.736 --> 02:15:48.139
POLICY. SO THE QUESTION THAT THE
02:15:48.206 --> 02:15:50.008
BILL ACTUALLY ASK IS SIMPLY
02:15:50.075 --> 02:15:52.210
WHETHER OR NOT TO EXPAND CURRENT
02:15:52.277 --> 02:15:54.145
LAW BECAUSE IT'S ALREADY AT 50%
02:15:54.212 --> 02:15:55.847
WERE RAISING IT TO 100%
02:15:55.914 --> 02:15:59.818
EXEMPTION. SO THE BUILD ITSELF
02:15:59.885 --> 02:16:01.820
DOES NOT ACTUALLY ADDRESS THE
02:16:01.887 --> 02:16:04.256
CURRENT LAWS POLICY AS FAR AS
02:16:04.322 --> 02:16:07.192
WHAT'S IN IT, BUT JUST ARE WE
02:16:07.259 --> 02:16:08.860
GOING TO EXPAND IT TO 100% AND
02:16:08.927 --> 02:16:12.564
SO I WOULD I WOULD SAY THAT YOUR
02:16:12.631 --> 02:16:13.765
OBSERVATION IS A GREAT
02:16:13.832 --> 02:16:15.467
OBSERVATION, SOMETHING THAT IS
02:16:15.534 --> 02:16:17.035
DEFINITELY WORTHY OF
02:16:17.102 --> 02:16:18.537
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT PARTNERSHIP
02:16:18.603 --> 02:16:19.604
IN, UH, AN ADDITIONAL BILL
02:16:19.671 --> 02:16:23.041
MOVING FORWARD. THE THAT I THINK
02:16:23.108 --> 02:16:24.376
WE COULD. WE COULD WORK ON
02:16:24.442 --> 02:16:26.077
TOGETHER. I DO WANT TO STATE,
02:16:26.144 --> 02:16:27.812
THOUGH, THAT THE THING ABOUT
02:16:27.879 --> 02:16:29.247
MANUFACTURING AND THE IMPORTANT
02:16:29.314 --> 02:16:31.049
PART OF THAT, MAKING THAT BAR
02:16:31.116 --> 02:16:33.718
WHERE IT IS. IS THAT IT HAS
02:16:33.785 --> 02:16:35.887
BECOME AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE
02:16:35.954 --> 02:16:37.022
GRADUATING FROM HIGH SCHOOL THAT
02:16:37.088 --> 02:16:39.791
DON'T HAVE THAT PATHWAY. TO
02:16:39.858 --> 02:16:42.694
COLLEGE BUT STILL NEED THE
02:16:42.761 --> 02:16:44.195
OPPORTUNITY FOR LIVABLE WAGE
02:16:44.262 --> 02:16:45.830
JOBS. AND AS YOU HEARD FROM
02:16:45.897 --> 02:16:47.632
TESTIMONY THESE ARE A NUMBER OF
02:16:47.699 --> 02:16:48.767
THESE JOBS ARE UNION JOBS,
02:16:48.833 --> 02:16:51.536
PAYING LIVABLE WAGES. AND OFFER
02:16:51.603 --> 02:16:54.072
CAREER LIFELONG CAREERS WHERE
02:16:54.139 --> 02:16:55.774
FOLKS CAN RETIRE AND AGE WITH
02:16:55.840 --> 02:16:58.109
DIGNITY IN OUR COMMUNITIES, SO I
02:16:58.176 --> 02:17:01.413
WOULD I. I HEAR WHAT YOU HAVE TO
02:17:01.479 --> 02:17:03.281
SAY ABOUT PUTTING THAT BAR AT A
02:17:03.348 --> 02:17:04.282
HIGH ENOUGH PLACE. WITH HIGH
02:17:04.349 --> 02:17:06.318
WITH HIGH ROAD LANGUAGE AS WELL
02:17:06.384 --> 02:17:08.853
AS THE RIGHT STANDARDS TO MAKE
02:17:08.920 --> 02:17:12.490
SURE THAT WE HAVE PROTECTIONS
02:17:12.557 --> 02:17:14.859
AND STANDARDS FOR WORKERS THAT
02:17:14.926 --> 02:17:17.228
MEET OUR VALUES IN CALIFORNIA,
02:17:17.295 --> 02:17:18.830
SO WITH THAT I WOULD LOOK
02:17:18.897 --> 02:17:19.998
FORWARD TO US HAVING
02:17:20.065 --> 02:17:21.266
CONVERSATIONS AND FINDING
02:17:21.333 --> 02:17:23.168
PATHWAYS FORWARD TO BE ABLE TO
02:17:23.234 --> 02:17:23.802
MOVE SOMETHING LIKE THAT. UM IN
02:17:23.868 --> 02:17:29.708
THE FUTURE AS WELL. CENTER. DO
02:17:29.774 --> 02:17:30.809
WE KNOW ANY QUESTIONS OR
02:17:30.875 --> 02:17:35.480
COMMENTS? TEACHER. HOW THAT. HE
02:17:35.547 --> 02:17:36.915
HAS WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
02:17:36.982 --> 02:17:39.117
SENATOR WIENER. WOULD YOU LIKE
02:17:39.184 --> 02:17:39.985
TO CLOSE? PLEASE? I RESPECTFULLY
02:17:40.051 --> 02:17:41.720
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
02:17:41.786 --> 02:17:42.654
CONSIDERATION. AND SENATOR.
02:17:42.721 --> 02:17:43.788
THANK YOU. SO FOR YOUR
02:17:43.855 --> 02:17:44.923
OBSERVATIONS, AND I TAKE THAT TO
02:17:44.990 --> 02:17:47.125
HEART SO WITH THAT, I
02:17:47.192 --> 02:17:48.226
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHENEVER
02:17:48.293 --> 02:17:49.027
SENATOR WEINER HAS MOVED THE
02:17:49.094 --> 02:17:50.862
BILL. WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE
02:17:50.929 --> 02:17:53.798
ROLL? MOTION IS TO PASS AS
02:17:53.865 --> 02:17:55.367
AMENDED, BUT FIRST CEMENT AND WE
02:17:55.433 --> 02:17:56.835
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:17:56.901 --> 02:17:58.236
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
02:17:58.303 --> 02:17:59.070
CABALLERO, NILSSON, NILSSON
02:17:59.137 --> 02:18:05.076
DURAZO. SO I HERZBERG WIENER
02:18:05.143 --> 02:18:08.780
WIENER. I 3 TO 0 TO ZERO. WE'LL
02:18:08.847 --> 02:18:10.782
PLACE THE BILL ON CALL NOW WOULD
02:18:10.849 --> 02:18:12.784
HAVE 21 86. THANK YOU, SIR. GO
02:18:12.851 --> 02:18:15.887
AHEAD. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
02:18:15.954 --> 02:18:17.355
MEMBERS. THANK YOU TO THE
02:18:17.422 --> 02:18:18.823
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
02:18:18.890 --> 02:18:19.858
BILL. I WILL BE ACCEPTING
02:18:19.924 --> 02:18:21.726
COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND I AM
02:18:21.793 --> 02:18:23.495
PLEASED TO PRESENT A B 21 86
02:18:23.561 --> 02:18:26.331
WHICH WILL INCENTIVIZE LOCAL
02:18:26.398 --> 02:18:27.899
JURISDICTIONS TO REDUCE IMPACT
02:18:27.966 --> 02:18:29.467
FEES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:18:29.534 --> 02:18:31.703
PROJECTS. DESPITE MONUMENTAL
02:18:31.770 --> 02:18:32.904
EFFORTS FROM THE LEGISLATURE, IT
02:18:32.971 --> 02:18:34.673
CONTINUES TO BE TOO EXPENSIVE TO
02:18:34.739 --> 02:18:36.975
BUILD HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA.
02:18:37.042 --> 02:18:39.411
IMPACT FEES CAN REPRESENT UP TO
02:18:39.477 --> 02:18:41.212
18% OF THE COST ASSOCIATED WITH
02:18:41.279 --> 02:18:43.615
BUILDING NEW HOUSING. THAT COST
02:18:43.682 --> 02:18:45.383
IS ADDED DIRECTLY ONTO THE COST
02:18:45.450 --> 02:18:46.818
OF THE UNIT, OFTEN MAKING IT
02:18:46.885 --> 02:18:47.986
DIFFICULT OR IMPOSSIBLE TO BUILD
02:18:48.053 --> 02:18:51.222
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. MAYBE 21 86
02:18:51.289 --> 02:18:52.757
PROVIDES TO INCENTIVES TO
02:18:52.824 --> 02:18:55.160
ADDRESS THIS PROBLEM FIRST,
02:18:55.226 --> 02:18:57.228
MAYBE 21 86 WILL PROVIDE LOCAL
02:18:57.295 --> 02:18:59.364
JURISDICTIONS WITH 50% OF THE
02:18:59.431 --> 02:19:00.632
VALUE OF THE FEET REDUCTION
02:19:00.699 --> 02:19:03.702
GRANTED TO THE PROJECT. SECOND A
02:19:03.768 --> 02:19:06.171
B 21 86 ALLOWS JURISDICTIONS TO
02:19:06.237 --> 02:19:07.605
DEFER FEES UNTIL THE HOUSING
02:19:07.672 --> 02:19:08.673
PROJECT IS CONVERTED TO
02:19:08.740 --> 02:19:10.608
PERMANENT FINANCING WHILE
02:19:10.675 --> 02:19:12.243
CHARGING INTEREST. THE STATE
02:19:12.310 --> 02:19:14.245
WILL THEN BACKFILL THAT INTEREST
02:19:14.312 --> 02:19:14.746
, EFFECTIVELY PROVIDING
02:19:14.813 --> 02:19:16.314
DEVELOPERS WITH ZERO INTEREST
02:19:16.381 --> 02:19:17.716
LOAN AND ENSURING LOCAL
02:19:17.782 --> 02:19:19.718
JURISDICTIONS ARE MADE WHOLE.
02:19:19.784 --> 02:19:21.853
THIS VOLUNTARY PROGRAMWILL
02:19:21.920 --> 02:19:23.588
SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE THE COST OF
02:19:23.655 --> 02:19:25.490
BUILDING HOUSING, AND I DO HAVE
02:19:25.557 --> 02:19:26.991
WITNESSED THROUGH THE CHAIR, MR
02:19:27.058 --> 02:19:28.493
. MARK STIVERS WITH CALIFORNIA
02:19:28.560 --> 02:19:30.161
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. WELCOME,
02:19:30.228 --> 02:19:30.962
SIR. PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
02:19:31.029 --> 02:19:32.063
MORNING MARKS. DIVERS WITH THE
02:19:32.130 --> 02:19:34.132
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP.
02:19:34.199 --> 02:19:35.800
WE HAD THE PARTNERSHIP ARE
02:19:35.867 --> 02:19:37.435
ALWAYS LOOKING FOR WAYS TO
02:19:37.502 --> 02:19:39.237
REDUCE THE COST OF DEVELOPING
02:19:39.304 --> 02:19:39.904
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THIS BILL IS
02:19:39.971 --> 02:19:42.273
A WIN WIN WIN IN THAT REGARD.
02:19:42.340 --> 02:19:43.508
FIRST OF ALL, IT REDUCES THE
02:19:43.575 --> 02:19:45.310
COST OF IMPACT FEES TO THE
02:19:45.376 --> 02:19:47.078
DEVELOPMENT. SECOND IT ALLOWS
02:19:47.145 --> 02:19:48.646
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT TO CONTINUE
02:19:48.713 --> 02:19:50.749
RECEIVING INCOME TO BE ABLE TO
02:19:50.815 --> 02:19:51.683
MEET THE INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDS IN
02:19:51.750 --> 02:19:52.984
THE COMMUNITY AND THIRD IT
02:19:53.051 --> 02:19:54.786
ACTUALLY REDUCES COST TO THE
02:19:54.853 --> 02:19:57.455
STATE. THE STATE ENDS UP NOW
02:19:57.522 --> 02:19:58.990
PAYING FOR MOST OF THESE IMPACT
02:19:59.057 --> 02:20:00.658
FEES, EITHER THROUGH THE LOW
02:20:00.725 --> 02:20:01.559
INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDIT
02:20:01.626 --> 02:20:02.827
PROGRAM OR THROUGH THE
02:20:02.894 --> 02:20:04.829
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING PROGRAMS
02:20:04.896 --> 02:20:05.830
AND IF WE CAN GET LOCAL
02:20:05.897 --> 02:20:07.298
GOVERNMENTS TO HELP CONTRIBUTE
02:20:07.365 --> 02:20:08.833
TO THAT, BY REDUCING THE FEES
02:20:08.900 --> 02:20:11.770
AND SHARING THE COST BETWEEN THE
02:20:11.836 --> 02:20:12.704
STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS, THE
02:20:12.771 --> 02:20:14.639
STATE WILL COME OUT AHEAD. SO
02:20:14.706 --> 02:20:15.840
IT'S A THREE WAY WIN FOR ALL
02:20:15.907 --> 02:20:16.975
INVOLVED. WE APPRECIATE YOUR
02:20:17.041 --> 02:20:19.110
SUPPORT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:20:19.177 --> 02:20:20.845
TESTIMONY. ANY OTHER WITNESSES
02:20:20.912 --> 02:20:22.080
IN THE ROOM HERE WISHING TO
02:20:22.147 --> 02:20:24.282
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT? PLEASE COME
02:20:24.349 --> 02:20:33.024
FORWARD. ABRAM DIAZ AT THE
02:20:33.091 --> 02:20:34.225
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION
02:20:34.292 --> 02:20:35.693
ROLE IN CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT
02:20:35.760 --> 02:20:40.298
THANK YOU. JENNIFER MENTAL WITH
02:20:40.365 --> 02:20:41.266
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
02:20:41.332 --> 02:20:42.333
CONSORTIUM AND SUPPORT OF THIS
02:20:42.400 --> 02:20:47.338
BILL. QUÊ. IN ANY FURTHER AND
02:20:47.405 --> 02:20:51.976
QUÊ MODERATOR. AND IF THERE ARE
02:20:52.043 --> 02:20:53.978
PARTICIPANTS THAT ARE WOULD LIKE
02:20:54.045 --> 02:20:55.213
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. BABY 21 86
02:20:55.280 --> 02:20:59.317
PRESS 10. AND GO TO LINE 2 72,
02:20:59.384 --> 02:21:04.556
PLEASE GO AHEAD. JAKE CRAZE ON
02:21:04.622 --> 02:21:05.790
BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
02:21:05.857 --> 02:21:10.995
COALITION AND SUPPORT. MÁS RICE
02:21:11.062 --> 02:21:12.764
CHAIR AND NO FURTHER COMMENTS IN
02:21:12.831 --> 02:21:17.068
QUÊ. DO YOU HAVE ANY OPPOSITION?
02:21:17.135 --> 02:21:22.574
IN CUBA. COULD YOU SOLICIT THAT?
02:21:22.640 --> 02:21:25.410
YES AND THEY'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:21:25.476 --> 02:21:26.444
OPPOSITION. MAYBE 21 86 PRESS
02:21:26.511 --> 02:21:28.847
10. AND WE DO HAVE SOME LINES
02:21:28.913 --> 02:21:35.920
COMING IN JUST ONE MOMENT. AS WE
02:21:35.987 --> 02:21:38.156
PROCEED. I SAW NO ONE STAND UP
02:21:38.223 --> 02:21:39.924
IN OPPOSITION HERE PRESENT. IS
02:21:39.991 --> 02:21:41.192
THERE ANYONE HERE PRESENT WANTS
02:21:41.259 --> 02:21:43.928
TO SPEAK. IN OPPOSITION. TAPE
02:21:43.995 --> 02:21:44.963
MODERATED. PROCEED AS YOU GET
02:21:45.029 --> 02:21:48.433
THEM INTO YOU. THANK YOU AND
02:21:48.500 --> 02:21:50.468
WE'LL GO TO LINE 3 88, PLEASE GO
02:21:50.535 --> 02:21:54.172
AHEAD. KENYA I'M, A RESIDENT OF
02:21:54.239 --> 02:21:57.342
FONTANA, CALIFORNIA. I'VE LIVED
02:21:57.408 --> 02:22:00.879
IN MONTANA FOR ABOUT 25 YEARS.
02:22:00.945 --> 02:22:03.014
AND I'M JUST WATCHING THE GROWTH
02:22:03.081 --> 02:22:03.882
OF THE WAREHOUSES HERE IN
02:22:03.948 --> 02:22:08.186
MONTANA. AND. YOU KNOW, WE WERE
02:22:08.253 --> 02:22:11.623
PROMISED WHEN I MOVED HERE THAT
02:22:11.689 --> 02:22:13.625
WE WILL BE A MOVING FORWARD
02:22:13.691 --> 02:22:17.095
COMMUNITY AND STEADY. BUT THE
02:22:17.161 --> 02:22:19.664
RECENT GROWTH OF WAREHOUSES
02:22:19.731 --> 02:22:20.865
ISN'T MOVING FORWARD AS ACTUALLY
02:22:20.932 --> 02:22:24.369
BLAMED MAUDE AND POLLUTION THAT
02:22:24.435 --> 02:22:28.106
WE GOT AWAY FROM THAT IN THE 19.
02:22:28.172 --> 02:22:30.842
I'M GONNA FAVOR OF PUTTING
02:22:30.909 --> 02:22:31.776
REGULATIONS IN PLACE TO
02:22:31.843 --> 02:22:34.545
MITIGATE. GROWTH BY WAREHOUSES
02:22:34.612 --> 02:22:40.618
AND ALL UM, HAVING. YOU KNOW,
02:22:40.685 --> 02:22:41.586
SAFEGUARDS FOR COMMUNITIES AND
02:22:41.653 --> 02:22:45.857
CHILDREN. THAT COULDN'T SCHOOL.
02:22:45.924 --> 02:22:46.958
UH WAREHOUSE WAS RIGHT NEXT TO
02:22:47.025 --> 02:22:49.928
SCHOOLS, WHICH MAKES NO SENSE.
02:22:49.994 --> 02:22:53.865
AND I OBSERVED. MANY ACCIDENTS
02:22:53.932 --> 02:22:58.202
AND MANY ISSUES THAT UH, ARISE
02:22:58.269 --> 02:22:59.304
FROM, YOU KNOW THE EXTRA
02:22:59.370 --> 02:23:04.142
TRAFFIC. NOT ONLY THAT IT'S ALSO
02:23:04.208 --> 02:23:05.310
THE FACILITY. BUT MOMENTS AGO,
02:23:05.376 --> 02:23:07.612
ONE OF THE SENATORS SPOKE TO
02:23:07.679 --> 02:23:11.883
HAVING A SAFE WORK ENVIRONMENT.
02:23:11.950 --> 02:23:14.085
THERE'S A BUNCH OF WAREHOUSING
02:23:14.152 --> 02:23:17.722
ADOPTED FACILITIES MORE NÓ. NO
02:23:17.789 --> 02:23:20.224
CONCESSIONS, NO SHOPPING, LIKE
02:23:20.291 --> 02:23:26.097
70,000. NEW EMPLOYEES. EXCUSE ME
02:23:26.164 --> 02:23:28.466
. I'VE BEEN REMINDED YOU ARE ON
02:23:28.533 --> 02:23:32.103
28 40. THAT BILL IS NOT BEFORE
02:23:32.170 --> 02:23:33.705
US RIGHT NOW WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
02:23:33.771 --> 02:23:37.308
A B 21 86 21 86. DO YOU HAVE
02:23:37.375 --> 02:23:44.215
COMMENTS ON THAT BILL? WE'LL
02:23:44.282 --> 02:23:46.784
JUST STAY ONLINE. WHEN IF YOU
02:23:46.851 --> 02:23:48.319
WOULDN'T BE HERE, THE BILL THAT
02:23:48.386 --> 02:23:49.821
YOU CARE ABOUT THEN COMES
02:23:49.887 --> 02:23:50.321
FORWARD ANY ADDITIONAL
02:23:50.388 --> 02:23:54.692
OPPOSITION. YES TO LINE UP FOUR.
02:23:54.759 --> 02:23:58.429
OH, ONE, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS
02:23:58.496 --> 02:24:00.198
IS WHEN THE STEVENS I'M RETIRED
02:24:00.264 --> 02:24:01.399
, AND I'M A VOLUNTEER WITH
02:24:01.466 --> 02:24:05.603
VETERANS. I AM REQUESTING NO ON
02:24:05.670 --> 02:24:08.006
A B 28 40 IT WILL END JOBS FOR
02:24:08.072 --> 02:24:10.208
VETERANS WERE ON 21 86 RIGHT
02:24:10.274 --> 02:24:14.612
NOW, PLEASE. AND WE'LL GO TO THE
02:24:14.679 --> 02:24:19.250
LINE. 3 85, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:24:19.317 --> 02:24:20.351
GETS MY NAME IS ALEX SANCHEZ
02:24:20.418 --> 02:24:22.120
ABOUT ORGANIZER. WE'VE WOKEN IN
02:24:22.186 --> 02:24:23.521
LABOR UNION AND WE HAVE OPPOSED
02:24:23.588 --> 02:24:26.858
THIS PROJECT. THANK YOU. AND MR
02:24:26.924 --> 02:24:29.360
VICE CHAIR. NO FURTHER COMMENTS.
02:24:29.427 --> 02:24:29.994
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. COME BACK
02:24:30.061 --> 02:24:34.298
HERE TO THE COMMITTEE. ANY WE
02:24:34.365 --> 02:24:35.133
HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR WEINER
02:24:35.199 --> 02:24:36.834
AND THE OTHER COMMENTS OR
02:24:36.901 --> 02:24:40.405
QUESTIONS. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
02:24:40.471 --> 02:24:41.205
CLOSE SIMILAR IMMIGRATION.
02:24:41.272 --> 02:24:42.073
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
02:24:42.140 --> 02:24:44.008
OKAY, VERY SIMPLE. WOULD YOU
02:24:44.075 --> 02:24:48.179
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL? 21 86.
02:24:48.246 --> 02:24:49.847
MOTION IS TO PASS THIS AMENDED
02:24:49.914 --> 02:24:51.215
BUT FIRST AMEND AND WE REFERRED
02:24:51.282 --> 02:24:52.116
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:24:52.183 --> 02:24:53.317
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
02:24:53.384 --> 02:24:56.954
CABALLERO NIELSEN, I. AYE
02:24:57.021 --> 02:25:01.793
HERZBERG WIENER. WIENER? AYE.
02:25:01.859 --> 02:25:04.829
320 WE WILL PUT THE CALL ON THAT
02:25:04.896 --> 02:25:05.963
BILL. ASSEMBLYMAN GRAYSON, YOU
02:25:06.030 --> 02:25:07.231
HAVE ONE ADDITIONAL BILL.
02:25:07.298 --> 02:25:10.368
CORRECT. 26 68. THAT IS CORRECT.
02:25:10.435 --> 02:25:11.536
MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU
02:25:11.602 --> 02:25:13.304
TO THE COMMITTEE. FOR YOUR WORK
02:25:13.371 --> 02:25:14.939
ON THIS BILL. I AM PLEASED TO
02:25:15.006 --> 02:25:17.308
PRESENT TWENTIES A B 26 68. IT
02:25:17.375 --> 02:25:18.743
IS A FIX IT BILL TO ENSURE
02:25:18.810 --> 02:25:19.944
QUALIFIED HOUSING PROJECTS ARE
02:25:20.011 --> 02:25:21.512
STREAMLINED AS INTENDED UNDER
02:25:21.579 --> 02:25:24.315
CURRENT LAW, SB 35. WAS A
02:25:24.382 --> 02:25:25.850
LANDMARK EFFORT TO INCREASE OUR
02:25:25.917 --> 02:25:28.853
HOUSING SUPPLY UNDER SP 35 LOCAL
02:25:28.920 --> 02:25:30.354
JURISDICTIONS MUST ESTABLISH
02:25:30.421 --> 02:25:31.923
OBJECTIVE STANDARDS AND
02:25:31.989 --> 02:25:32.890
STREAMLINE APPROVALS FOR
02:25:32.957 --> 02:25:33.891
DEVELOPMENTS THAT MEET THOSE
02:25:33.958 --> 02:25:36.627
STANDARDS. HOWEVER AMBIGUITIES
02:25:36.694 --> 02:25:38.696
IN THE LAW HAVE BEEN EXPLOITED
02:25:38.763 --> 02:25:39.697
TO DERAIL DESPERATELY NEEDED
02:25:39.764 --> 02:25:41.032
HOUSING PROJECTS ACROSS THE
02:25:41.099 --> 02:25:42.900
STATE. MAYBE 26 68 SIMPLY
02:25:42.967 --> 02:25:44.001
CLARIFIES THAT A PROJECT SHALL
02:25:44.068 --> 02:25:46.904
BE APPROVED. IF IT MEETS
02:25:46.971 --> 02:25:48.272
OBJECTIVE STANDARDS, AND THAT
02:25:48.339 --> 02:25:50.308
THE TOTAL PROJECT UNITS ARE
02:25:50.374 --> 02:25:52.743
COUNTED PRIOR TO DENSITY BONUS.
02:25:52.810 --> 02:25:53.744
THIS WILL HELP ENSURE THE LAW
02:25:53.811 --> 02:25:55.713
FUNCTIONS AS INTENDED TO BUILD
02:25:55.780 --> 02:25:57.381
THE HOUSING WE SO DESPERATELY
02:25:57.448 --> 02:25:59.016
NEED. I DO HAVE THROUGH THE
02:25:59.083 --> 02:26:00.051
CHAIR WITNESS PRESIDENT, MR
02:26:00.118 --> 02:26:02.954
MICHAEL LANE WHISPER. WOULD YOU
02:26:03.020 --> 02:26:04.489
PLEASE PROCEED, SIR? WELCOME
02:26:04.555 --> 02:26:06.124
THANK YOU, MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
02:26:06.190 --> 02:26:07.191
MICHAEL AND WHISPER, A PUBLIC
02:26:07.258 --> 02:26:09.026
POLICY THINK TANK IN THE SAN
02:26:09.093 --> 02:26:10.161
FRANCISCO BAY AREA. SP 35
02:26:10.228 --> 02:26:11.629
HOUSING APPROVALS STREAMLINE HAS
02:26:11.696 --> 02:26:12.630
BEEN A TREMENDOUS BOOM TO THE
02:26:12.697 --> 02:26:14.966
PRODUCTION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:26:15.032 --> 02:26:15.533
AND IS HELPING TO BRING NEW
02:26:15.600 --> 02:26:17.001
HOMES ONLINE MORE QUICKLY AND
02:26:17.068 --> 02:26:18.836
EFFICIENTLY WHILE RESPECTING
02:26:18.903 --> 02:26:19.871
LOCAL ZONING AND OBJECTIVE
02:26:19.937 --> 02:26:20.338
DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT
02:26:20.404 --> 02:26:23.808
STANDARDS. AS DETAILED IN THE
02:26:23.875 --> 02:26:25.076
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS. 26 68
02:26:25.143 --> 02:26:26.244
PROVIDES ADDITIONAL TECHNICAL
02:26:26.310 --> 02:26:28.112
CLEANUP AND CLARIFYING LANGUAGE
02:26:28.179 --> 02:26:29.280
CONSISTENT WITH LEGISLATIVE
02:26:29.347 --> 02:26:31.782
INTENT IN HZDS SP 35 GUIDELINES
02:26:31.849 --> 02:26:32.617
. THESE CLARIFICATIONS WILL
02:26:32.683 --> 02:26:35.186
FURTHER PERFECT THE LAW. AND
02:26:35.253 --> 02:26:36.087
ENSURE IT FUNCTIONS AS INTENDED
02:26:36.154 --> 02:26:37.455
, AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
02:26:37.522 --> 02:26:40.791
AND I VOTE. ANY OTHER WITNESSES
02:26:40.858 --> 02:26:42.693
HERE IN SUPPORT. LOOKS LIKE WE
02:26:42.760 --> 02:26:43.828
HAVE A COUPLE. PLEASE COME
02:26:43.895 --> 02:26:49.133
FORWARD. GOOD MORNING, MR
02:26:49.200 --> 02:26:50.268
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS, DEBORAH
02:26:50.334 --> 02:26:51.302
CARLSON WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:26:51.369 --> 02:26:52.103
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION AND
02:26:52.170 --> 02:26:56.340
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ADRIAN
02:26:56.407 --> 02:26:57.441
MOHAMMED WITH LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC
02:26:57.508 --> 02:26:59.210
AFFAIRS HERE IN SUPPORT ON
02:26:59.277 --> 02:27:00.945
BEHALF OF SANDHILL PROPERTIES
02:27:01.012 --> 02:27:01.979
AND HABITAT FOR HUMANITY,
02:27:02.046 --> 02:27:07.585
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:27:07.652 --> 02:27:08.853
JOHN BRENNAN CARVAJAL ON BEHALF
02:27:08.920 --> 02:27:09.954
OF CALIFORNIA B AND SUPPORT.
02:27:10.021 --> 02:27:13.191
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:27:13.257 --> 02:27:15.193
I HAVE SEEN NO MORE PRESENT HERE
02:27:15.259 --> 02:27:19.697
IN THE IN QUÊ MODERATOR. THANK
02:27:19.764 --> 02:27:21.832
YOU, AND THEY'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:27:21.899 --> 02:27:25.136
SUPPORT OF A B 2668 PRESS 10.
02:27:25.203 --> 02:27:26.237
AND ALTHOUGH THE LINE 3 63,
02:27:26.304 --> 02:27:29.874
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, MR
02:27:29.941 --> 02:27:31.542
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS ON BEHALF
02:27:31.609 --> 02:27:32.843
OF THE CALIFORNIA RENTAL HOUSING
02:27:32.910 --> 02:27:34.145
ASSOCIATION AND THE APARTMENT
02:27:34.212 --> 02:27:34.712
ASSOCIATION OF GREATER LOS
02:27:34.779 --> 02:27:35.880
ANGELES AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:27:35.947 --> 02:27:39.684
THANK YOU. NEXT WITH ALIGNMENT
02:27:39.750 --> 02:27:44.989
TO 72. PLEASE GO AHEAD. FIRST ON
02:27:45.056 --> 02:27:47.091
BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
02:27:47.158 --> 02:27:48.159
COALITION IN SUPPORT OF A B
02:27:48.226 --> 02:27:54.365
2668. AND WE'LL GO TO LINE UP
02:27:54.432 --> 02:27:57.969
FOR FOUR. PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS
02:27:58.035 --> 02:27:59.537
IS BAD NAYLOR, REPRESENTING
02:27:59.604 --> 02:28:02.273
FIELDS DEAD COMPANY, UH, IN
02:28:02.340 --> 02:28:03.808
ORDER TO COUNTY COMPANY OWNED BY
02:28:03.875 --> 02:28:04.875
HOWARD AHMANSON JR. STRONG
02:28:04.942 --> 02:28:10.648
SUPPORT. QUÊ. MR BRYCE, JERRY?
02:28:10.715 --> 02:28:12.817
NO FURTHER COMMENTS. THANK YOU.
02:28:12.884 --> 02:28:15.586
ANY OPPOSITION? HER PRESENT.
02:28:15.653 --> 02:28:21.826
INDOOR AND QUÊ. ON THE PHONE IF
02:28:21.892 --> 02:28:22.660
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:28:22.727 --> 02:28:32.637
OPPOSITION TO A B 26 68 PRESS 10. UM MR RICE JOURNAL COMMENTS IN
02:28:32.703 --> 02:28:34.805
Q COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
02:28:34.872 --> 02:28:35.673
ANY COMMENTS QUESTIONS BY
02:28:35.740 --> 02:28:42.380
MEMBERS? BILL HAS MOVED BY
02:28:42.446 --> 02:28:44.081
SENATOR WIENER. WOULD YOU LIKE
02:28:44.148 --> 02:28:45.883
TO CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A
02:28:45.950 --> 02:28:47.852
VOTE. THANK YOU, SENATOR. POLICE
02:28:47.918 --> 02:28:49.820
CALL HER ALL WE HAVE A MOTION TO
02:28:49.887 --> 02:28:52.890
PASS AS AMENDED. MOTION IS TO
02:28:52.957 --> 02:28:54.091
PASS TO THE SENATE FLOOR.
02:28:54.158 --> 02:28:56.227
SENATORS CABALLERO NILSSON,
02:28:56.294 --> 02:29:00.564
NILSSON DURAZO. YOU'RE A SO I
02:29:00.631 --> 02:29:02.466
HERZBERG WIENER WIENER I THREE
02:29:02.533 --> 02:29:06.704
OR ZERO THANK YOU DON'T CALL.
02:29:06.771 --> 02:29:07.905
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU,
02:29:07.972 --> 02:29:08.939
ASSEMBLYMAN. IN. PLEASE COME
02:29:09.006 --> 02:29:20.584
FORWARD. AND WHAT IS YOUR BILL?
02:29:20.651 --> 02:29:25.823
UM GRAB 99, OKAY? 18 45,
02:29:25.890 --> 02:29:27.558
SENATOR, ASSEMBLYMAN. WOMAN
02:29:27.625 --> 02:29:33.497
CALDERON. NUMBER NINE. GOOD
02:29:33.564 --> 02:29:35.866
MORNING, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS A
02:29:35.933 --> 02:29:38.002
B 14 18 45 WOULD AUTHORIZE THE
02:29:38.069 --> 02:29:39.036
METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF
02:29:39.103 --> 02:29:41.339
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. TO USE
02:29:41.405 --> 02:29:42.340
THREE ALTERNATIVE PROJECT
02:29:42.406 --> 02:29:45.343
DELIVERY METHODS. AS CLIMATE
02:29:45.409 --> 02:29:46.877
CHANGE INTENSIFIES DROUGHT
02:29:46.944 --> 02:29:48.446
CONDITIONS IN OUR STATE. THIS
02:29:48.512 --> 02:29:49.780
LEGISLATION WILL EXPEDITE THE
02:29:49.847 --> 02:29:51.849
CONSTRUCTION OF A REGIONAL
02:29:51.916 --> 02:29:54.118
RECYCLED WATER PROJECT AND A SET
02:29:54.185 --> 02:29:55.186
OF DROUGHT RESPONSE PROJECTS IN
02:29:55.252 --> 02:29:56.921
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. THESE
02:29:56.987 --> 02:29:58.556
PROJECTS ARE TIME SENSITIVE AND
02:29:58.622 --> 02:30:01.058
CRUCIAL FOR THE REGION, SINCE WE
02:30:01.125 --> 02:30:02.093
ARE CURRENTLY EXPERIENCING TOO
02:30:02.159 --> 02:30:03.194
SEVERE DROUGHTS IN SOUTHERN
02:30:03.260 --> 02:30:05.596
CALIFORNIA. WITH ME IN SUPPORT
02:30:05.663 --> 02:30:08.199
OF A B 18 45 IS ADELE. HOW'D YOU
02:30:08.265 --> 02:30:09.633
KHALIL, GENERAL MANAGER OF
02:30:09.700 --> 02:30:11.135
METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF
02:30:11.202 --> 02:30:13.104
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, AND ALAN
02:30:13.170 --> 02:30:14.605
SHANAHAN, PRESIDENT OF ASKED ME
02:30:14.672 --> 02:30:17.908
LOCAL 19. OH, TWO. RIGHT? YOU
02:30:17.975 --> 02:30:21.078
HAVE YOUR WITNESSES, ARE THEY
02:30:21.145 --> 02:30:22.780
ONLINE. HERE WE ARE. PLEASE GO
02:30:22.847 --> 02:30:24.782
AHEAD, SIR. GOOD MORNING, MR
02:30:24.849 --> 02:30:26.350
CHAIR, HONORABLE CHAIR AND
02:30:26.417 --> 02:30:27.852
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
02:30:27.918 --> 02:30:29.153
NAME IS A DOLL HOSPITAL GENERAL
02:30:29.220 --> 02:30:30.354
MANAGER OF METROPOLITAN WATER
02:30:30.421 --> 02:30:32.156
DISTRICT, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.
02:30:32.223 --> 02:30:35.459
WE ARE RESPONSES OF A B 18 45.
02:30:35.526 --> 02:30:36.727
THIS BILL IS CRITICAL FOR OUR
02:30:36.794 --> 02:30:39.130
WATER SUPPLY IN SOUTHERN
02:30:39.196 --> 02:30:39.797
CALIFORNIA, OUR MAIN TWO SOURCES
02:30:39.864 --> 02:30:41.365
OF IMPORTED WATER, THE STATE
02:30:41.432 --> 02:30:42.967
WATER PROJECT AND THE COLORADO
02:30:43.033 --> 02:30:44.268
RIVER ARE EXPERIENCING DRUG
02:30:44.335 --> 02:30:45.903
CONDITIONS LIKE WE HAVE NEVER
02:30:45.970 --> 02:30:48.572
SEEN BEFORE. THIS CLIMATE CHANGE
02:30:48.639 --> 02:30:50.508
AND WE NEED TO DO EVERYTHING
02:30:50.574 --> 02:30:51.842
POSSIBLE TO ACCELERATE NEW WATER
02:30:51.909 --> 02:30:54.178
SUPPLIES AND PROJECTS IN OUR
02:30:54.245 --> 02:30:56.947
REGION. THIS IS WHAT A B 18 45
02:30:57.014 --> 02:30:58.949
DOES. AS A PUBLIC AGENCY. WE ARE
02:30:59.016 --> 02:31:00.151
LIMITED BY THE TRADITIONAL
02:31:00.217 --> 02:31:02.153
DESIGN BID BUILD MODEL. FOR
02:31:02.219 --> 02:31:03.587
PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS WHICH CAN
02:31:03.654 --> 02:31:06.323
BE INEFFICIENT AND INFLEXIBLE.
02:31:06.390 --> 02:31:07.925
WITH A NEW DELIVERY METHODS. WE
02:31:07.992 --> 02:31:09.727
CAN AVOID DELAYS AND REDUCE THE
02:31:09.794 --> 02:31:12.229
RISK AND COST OUR TAXPAYERS OUR
02:31:12.296 --> 02:31:14.965
URGENT. DROUGHT MITIGATION
02:31:15.032 --> 02:31:17.301
PROJECTS TO MOVE WATER TO AREAS
02:31:17.368 --> 02:31:18.502
THAT LACK SUFFICIENT WATER
02:31:18.569 --> 02:31:20.971
SUPPLIES WILL BE SERVED BY THIS
02:31:21.038 --> 02:31:22.106
EFFORT, ALONG WITH BUILDING THE
02:31:22.173 --> 02:31:25.042
LARGEST PURE WATER. SOUTHERN
02:31:25.109 --> 02:31:27.011
CALIFORNIA RECYCLED PROJECT IN
02:31:27.077 --> 02:31:29.980
CARSON IN THE WHOLE NATION WILL
02:31:30.047 --> 02:31:31.582
HELP PROVIDE NEEDED SUPPLIES FOR
02:31:31.649 --> 02:31:32.583
OVER 1.5 MILLION PEOPLE IN
02:31:32.650 --> 02:31:35.486
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. AT THIS
02:31:35.553 --> 02:31:37.054
MOMENT, WE MUST ACT TO ADDRESS
02:31:37.121 --> 02:31:39.223
THIS DROUGHT AND CLIMATE CRISIS
02:31:39.290 --> 02:31:40.491
AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THAT
02:31:40.558 --> 02:31:42.827
YOU VOTE YES, ON THIS BILL. MY
02:31:42.893 --> 02:31:44.995
GREAT APPRECIATION, ALSO TO THE
02:31:45.062 --> 02:31:45.930
AUTHOR OF THE BILL
02:31:45.996 --> 02:31:46.530
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CALDERON AND
02:31:46.597 --> 02:31:47.798
HER STAFF FOR THEIR HARD WORK.
02:31:47.865 --> 02:31:50.401
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.
02:31:50.468 --> 02:31:54.972
PRIEST. ONE MORE. HURRY UP. GOOD
02:31:55.039 --> 02:31:56.440
MORNING, ALMOST AFTERNOON, MR
02:31:56.507 --> 02:31:58.175
CHAIR. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
02:31:58.242 --> 02:31:58.943
ALLEN SHANAHAN. PRESIDENT ASKED
02:31:59.009 --> 02:32:01.045
ME LOCAL 19 OH, TWO, ALSO THE
02:32:01.111 --> 02:32:02.112
INTERNATIONAL VICE PRESIDENT FOR
02:32:02.179 --> 02:32:03.214
CALIFORNIA FOR ASKED ME.
02:32:03.280 --> 02:32:05.216
REPRESENT CHEMISTS, ENGINEERS
02:32:05.282 --> 02:32:06.317
ALL THE WAY TO TRADES AND EVEN
02:32:06.383 --> 02:32:08.385
COOKS AT METROPOLITAN TOTALING
02:32:08.452 --> 02:32:09.720
ABOUT 80% OF THE WORKFORCE THERE
02:32:09.787 --> 02:32:10.654
IS OTHERWISE AS WELL AS OTHER
02:32:10.721 --> 02:32:14.058
WATER AGENCIES. UM JUST KEEP MY
02:32:14.124 --> 02:32:15.493
COMMENTS QUICK OR UNION ARE
02:32:15.559 --> 02:32:18.462
MEMBERS STRONGLY SUPPORT 18 45.
02:32:18.529 --> 02:32:20.898
WE'VE BEEN WATCHING CLOSELY TO
02:32:20.965 --> 02:32:22.833
BUILD AND WE TRULY APPRECIATE
02:32:22.900 --> 02:32:24.335
THE AMENDMENTS AND THE MEMBER
02:32:24.401 --> 02:32:25.536
CALDERON FOR WORKING WITH US
02:32:25.603 --> 02:32:28.506
VERY CLOSELY ON THIS BILL. AS
02:32:28.572 --> 02:32:29.607
WELL AS THE STAFF OF THIS
02:32:29.673 --> 02:32:30.774
COMMITTEE, WHO ALSO EXPRESSED
02:32:30.841 --> 02:32:33.777
SOME OF THEIR CONCERNS TO US AND
02:32:33.844 --> 02:32:35.412
THE CURRENT FORM. AFSCME IS
02:32:35.479 --> 02:32:36.180
COMPLETELY SUPPORTING THIS
02:32:36.247 --> 02:32:38.749
LEGISLATION. UM AND WE'VE SEEN A
02:32:38.816 --> 02:32:40.351
NEW ERA OF COLLABORATION BETWEEN
02:32:40.417 --> 02:32:41.585
LABOR AND MANAGEMENT AND
02:32:41.652 --> 02:32:42.720
METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT THAT
02:32:42.786 --> 02:32:44.388
WE HAVEN'T SEEN BEFORE. THANK
02:32:44.455 --> 02:32:45.556
YOU. THANKS TO OUR NEW GENERAL
02:32:45.623 --> 02:32:48.526
MANAGER, ADELE HAJJ CLEAR. 18 45
02:32:48.592 --> 02:32:50.561
WILL HELP OUR MEMBERS IN MWD
02:32:50.628 --> 02:32:52.096
MORE QUICKLY AND EFFICIENTLY
02:32:52.162 --> 02:32:53.597
MOVE ON INFRASTRUCTURE, WHICH
02:32:53.664 --> 02:32:55.132
WILL ALLOW MWD TO ADDRESS THE
02:32:55.199 --> 02:32:56.767
NEW REALITY WE FACE WITH THE
02:32:56.834 --> 02:32:58.168
WORSENING DROUGHT CONDITIONS,
02:32:58.235 --> 02:32:59.670
WHICH HAVE ONLY BECOME WORSE AND
02:32:59.737 --> 02:33:01.906
WILL CONTINUE TO GET WORSE. OUR
02:33:01.972 --> 02:33:04.074
MEMBERS ARE FULLY AWARE OF THIS
02:33:04.141 --> 02:33:04.708
AS WE WATCHED THE WATER LEVELS
02:33:04.775 --> 02:33:06.477
DROPPED ALL ACROSS OUR IMPORTED
02:33:06.544 --> 02:33:09.313
WATER SUPPLIES. SUPPORT OF 18 45
02:33:09.380 --> 02:33:10.848
WILL HELP OUR MEMBERS RAPIDLY
02:33:10.915 --> 02:33:12.883
MOVE ON INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
02:33:12.950 --> 02:33:14.952
SUCH AS PURE WATER IN THE RECENT
02:33:15.019 --> 02:33:16.053
REGIONAL RECYCLED WATER PLANT
02:33:16.120 --> 02:33:17.087
AND ADAPT AND INCREASE OUR
02:33:17.154 --> 02:33:20.157
RELIABILITY. AS WE STRIVE TO
02:33:20.224 --> 02:33:21.559
MEET THE NEEDS OF 19 MILLION
02:33:21.625 --> 02:33:23.227
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
02:33:23.294 --> 02:33:24.562
AND WITH THAT, RESPECTFULLY
02:33:24.628 --> 02:33:25.563
REQUEST YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU
02:33:25.629 --> 02:33:27.865
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. WE HAVE
02:33:27.932 --> 02:33:28.899
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES IN FAVOR.
02:33:28.966 --> 02:33:32.970
PLEASE COME FORWARD. MHM. MR
02:33:33.037 --> 02:33:34.538
TARYN MEMBERS DON GILBERT ON
02:33:34.605 --> 02:33:35.906
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:33:35.973 --> 02:33:38.108
MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSOCIATION
02:33:38.175 --> 02:33:39.777
, AND SUPPORT AS WELL AS LOS
02:33:39.843 --> 02:33:41.345
ANGELES COUNTY SANITATION
02:33:41.412 --> 02:33:42.346
DISTICT SUPPORTING THANK YOU.
02:33:42.413 --> 02:33:46.050
THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING, MR
02:33:46.116 --> 02:33:47.484
CHAIR AND MEMBERS ERIN AVERY
02:33:47.551 --> 02:33:48.519
WITH THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
02:33:48.586 --> 02:33:49.053
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION AND
02:33:49.119 --> 02:33:53.724
SUPPORT THANK YOU. MR CHAIR
02:33:53.791 --> 02:33:55.359
MEMBERS MIKE MONEGAN AND BEHALF
02:33:55.426 --> 02:33:56.360
THE CALIFORNIA STATE BUILDING
02:33:56.427 --> 02:33:57.661
AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
02:33:57.728 --> 02:34:00.698
IN SUPPORT. THANK THANK YOU.
02:34:00.764 --> 02:34:02.466
MORNING MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS BOB
02:34:02.533 --> 02:34:03.701
READ WITH REED GOVERNMENT
02:34:03.767 --> 02:34:05.536
RELATIONS ON BEHALF OF THE WATER
02:34:05.603 --> 02:34:07.237
REPLENISHMENT DISTRICT OF
02:34:07.304 --> 02:34:08.272
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
02:34:08.339 --> 02:34:10.674
THANK YOU. ANY OTHER ADDITIONAL
02:34:10.741 --> 02:34:14.678
WITNESSES HERE IN SUPPORT.
02:34:14.745 --> 02:34:19.216
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION. MODERATE
02:34:19.283 --> 02:34:22.586
OR ANYONE. OPPOSED IN Q. WOULD
02:34:22.653 --> 02:34:28.726
YOU INQUIRE? THIS IS MY SISTER
02:34:28.792 --> 02:34:29.927
DIDN'T WANT TO TAKE THOSE IN
02:34:29.994 --> 02:34:31.161
SUPPORT FIRST. DO WE HAVE
02:34:31.228 --> 02:34:36.233
ADDITIONAL INGEST? YES FOR THOSE
02:34:36.300 --> 02:34:38.102
ON THE FRONT OF HERE IN SUPPORT
02:34:38.168 --> 02:34:40.037
OF A B 18 45 PRESS 10 AND LITTLE
02:34:40.104 --> 02:34:45.609
LINE. 1 43, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR
02:34:45.676 --> 02:34:46.810
CHAIR AND MEMBERS ANDREW ANTWI
02:34:46.877 --> 02:34:48.746
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY
02:34:48.812 --> 02:34:53.517
HILLS AND SUPPORT. NEXT WE GO TO
02:34:53.584 --> 02:34:57.321
LINE UP 407, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:34:57.388 --> 02:34:58.789
GOOD MORNING, JAMIE MINOR ON
02:34:58.856 --> 02:35:00.991
BEHALF OF WEST BASIN MUNICIPAL
02:35:01.058 --> 02:35:01.992
WATER DISTRICT, IN ADDITION TO
02:35:02.059 --> 02:35:03.127
THAT EASTERN MUNICIPAL ATER
02:35:03.193 --> 02:35:04.662
DISTRICT AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:35:04.728 --> 02:35:08.832
OKAY? NEXT ABOUT A 408. PLEASE
02:35:08.899 --> 02:35:12.703
GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, CHRIS
02:35:12.770 --> 02:35:13.971
ANDERSON ON BEHALF OF THE
02:35:14.038 --> 02:35:15.139
ASSOCIATIONOF CALIFORNIA WATER
02:35:15.205 --> 02:35:20.611
AGENCIES IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:35:20.678 --> 02:35:21.712
NEXT LITTLE LINE LINE. 4. 10
02:35:21.779 --> 02:35:25.649
410, PLEASE GO AHEAD. BEST LASSO
02:35:25.716 --> 02:35:27.217
ON BEHALF OF THE INLAND EMPIRE
02:35:27.284 --> 02:35:28.485
UTILITIES, AGENCY AND WATER
02:35:28.552 --> 02:35:29.720
REUSE CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
02:35:29.787 --> 02:35:34.224
THANK YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE ONE.
02:35:34.291 --> 02:35:38.696
OH, SEVEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
02:35:38.762 --> 02:35:40.731
SHANKAR WITH LAW, THIS AREA
02:35:40.798 --> 02:35:41.865
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND STRONG
02:35:41.932 --> 02:35:45.836
SUPPORT. AND GO TO LINE 4 12,
02:35:45.903 --> 02:35:49.907
PLEASE GO AHEAD. ANTONIO VINA,
02:35:49.973 --> 02:35:55.813
RESIDENT OF MONTANA IN SUPPORT.
02:35:55.879 --> 02:35:56.980
AND NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND QUÊ
02:35:57.047 --> 02:36:00.684
ALRIGHT, VERY GOOD. LITTLE
02:36:00.751 --> 02:36:05.389
HISTORICAL OBSERVATION. YEARS
02:36:05.456 --> 02:36:06.623
AGO, THERE WAS SOMETHING CALLED
02:36:06.690 --> 02:36:08.892
THE PERIPHERAL CANAL AND THE
02:36:08.959 --> 02:36:10.828
WATERSHED REGIONS OF CALIFORNIA
02:36:10.894 --> 02:36:12.663
HAD SOME DIFFICULTY WITH IT, AND
02:36:12.730 --> 02:36:15.099
THAT'S AN OLD BATTLE. BUT THIS
02:36:15.165 --> 02:36:17.935
SPEAKS TO THE HISTORY WITH M. W.
02:36:18.001 --> 02:36:23.474
D I GOT A CALL FROM THE
02:36:23.540 --> 02:36:24.942
GOVERNOR'S CHIEF OF STAFF, THEN
02:36:25.008 --> 02:36:27.177
DUKE NATION, AND THEY ASKED IF I
02:36:27.244 --> 02:36:28.512
WOULD BE SUPPORTIVE OF DAVID
02:36:28.579 --> 02:36:31.482
KENNEDY. WHO WAS THEN THE
02:36:31.548 --> 02:36:35.152
MANAGER OF. METROPOLITAN WATER
02:36:35.219 --> 02:36:38.655
DISTRICT AS THE DIRECTOR OF
02:36:38.722 --> 02:36:39.723
DEPARTMENT OF WATER STATE OF
02:36:39.790 --> 02:36:43.360
CALIFORNIA. AND, UH I DIDN'T
02:36:43.427 --> 02:36:47.698
YELL. NO, BUT HE SAID. PLAINTIFF
02:36:47.765 --> 02:36:49.733
WE WOULD YOU LEAST MEET WITH MR
02:36:49.800 --> 02:36:53.003
KENNEDY. WHICH I DID. HE PROVED
02:36:53.070 --> 02:36:57.107
TO BE OF SUPERB. LEADER IN
02:36:57.174 --> 02:36:58.308
CALIFORNIA AS WE MOVED TO THE
02:36:58.375 --> 02:37:00.677
FUTURE AND WATER. AND I WANT TO
02:37:00.744 --> 02:37:06.283
PARTICULARLY THANKS. MWD NOW FOR
02:37:06.350 --> 02:37:08.852
THEIR SUPPORT, THE DEVELOPMENT
02:37:08.919 --> 02:37:10.053
AND THE WATER BOND THAT PASSED
02:37:10.120 --> 02:37:13.357
PROPOSITION ONE. THAT INCLUDES
02:37:13.423 --> 02:37:15.225
LARGE SURFACE STORAGE IN THIS
02:37:15.292 --> 02:37:17.928
CASE SITES RESERVOIR. THE POINT
02:37:17.995 --> 02:37:19.763
I MAKE HERE AND WHY IT'S
02:37:19.830 --> 02:37:22.332
IMPORTANT. FOR DECADES. OUR
02:37:22.399 --> 02:37:24.434
POLICIES IN CALIFORNIA WERE
02:37:24.501 --> 02:37:25.536
PREDICATED ON THE SHARING OF
02:37:25.602 --> 02:37:27.571
SCARCITY. SAME THING. AS WITH
02:37:27.638 --> 02:37:31.341
ENERGY. THAT IS NOT THE PATHWAY
02:37:31.408 --> 02:37:32.342
TO THE FUTURE FOR OUR
02:37:32.409 --> 02:37:34.478
GRANDCHILDREN. IT'S ONLY A SMALL
02:37:34.545 --> 02:37:37.247
PART. IT'S A RATHER THAT'S A
02:37:37.314 --> 02:37:43.086
LARGE PART OF IT.AND IN THE.
02:37:43.153 --> 02:37:45.255
AROUND 2000 AND 10. WE CRAFTED A
02:37:45.322 --> 02:37:48.492
NEW WATER PLAN FOR THE STATE OF
02:37:48.559 --> 02:37:52.729
CALIFORNIA. A NUMBER OF ELEMENTS
02:37:52.796 --> 02:37:55.299
OF IT WERE VERY SIGNIFICANT ONE
02:37:55.365 --> 02:37:59.303
ASSERTING A HUMAN WATER, RIGHT?
02:37:59.369 --> 02:38:01.438
FOR CALIFORNIA'S, WHICH INCLUDED
02:38:01.505 --> 02:38:02.372
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION, NOT
02:38:02.439 --> 02:38:05.342
JUST HUMAN CONSUMPTION. AND
02:38:05.409 --> 02:38:09.680
ARGUES, BUT AGRICULTURE AS WELL.
02:38:09.746 --> 02:38:12.216
AND ANOTHER THING THAT WAS VERY
02:38:12.282 --> 02:38:13.951
SIGNIFICANT FOR DECADES WATER
02:38:14.017 --> 02:38:15.619
POLICY IN CALIFORNIA HAD BECOME
02:38:15.686 --> 02:38:18.388
WHAT I CALL DELTA CENTRIC. AND I
02:38:18.455 --> 02:38:20.324
WAS A DELTA CENTER FROM NUMBER
02:38:20.390 --> 02:38:23.727
OF YEARS. BUT EVERYTHING WE WERE
02:38:23.794 --> 02:38:25.762
DOING AND WATER AND INCLUDING
02:38:25.829 --> 02:38:27.397
SOMETHING THAT RATHER GOT
02:38:27.464 --> 02:38:28.799
CORRUPTED. CAL FED WAS ABOUT THE
02:38:28.866 --> 02:38:33.070
DELTA. WE HAVE NOW ACCEPTED.
02:38:33.136 --> 02:38:36.540
THAT IT'S HOLISTIC. THAT THERE'S
02:38:36.607 --> 02:38:38.342
A NORTH THERE'S A SOUTH, THERE'S
02:38:38.408 --> 02:38:41.912
A CENTRAL AND THERE IS AN EAST
02:38:41.979 --> 02:38:44.181
AND WEST TO WATER IN CALIFORNIA.
02:38:44.248 --> 02:38:46.683
IT'S A MUCH BETTER DIRECTION.
02:38:46.750 --> 02:38:47.818
AND WE ARE MOVING IN THAT
02:38:47.885 --> 02:38:52.155
DIRECTION. AND I WANT TO THANK
02:38:52.222 --> 02:38:53.690
MWD FOR THEIR ASSISTANCE AND
02:38:53.757 --> 02:38:54.825
SUPPORT OF HELPING SECURE MORE
02:38:54.892 --> 02:38:58.962
SUPPLIES. DO YOU LIKE TO CLOSE?
02:38:59.029 --> 02:39:04.835
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CALDERON. PARDON?
02:39:04.902 --> 02:39:07.371
I THOUGHT I ASKED, YOU KNOW. DO
02:39:07.437 --> 02:39:09.139
WE HAVE ANY? I DIDN'T THINK I
02:39:09.206 --> 02:39:11.041
SAW ANY HERE. BUT DO WE HAVE ANY
02:39:11.108 --> 02:39:15.579
IN Q IN OPPOSITION? AND IF THERE
02:39:15.646 --> 02:39:17.581
ARE ANY OPPOSITION TO A B 18 45
02:39:17.648 --> 02:39:24.288
PRESS 10. MÁS VICE CHAIR. NO
02:39:24.354 --> 02:39:26.323
LINES COMING IN. VERY GOOD.
02:39:26.390 --> 02:39:28.992
THANK YOU, PLEASE. THANK YOU,
02:39:29.059 --> 02:39:30.193
SENATOR. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
02:39:30.260 --> 02:39:32.095
A KNIFE VOTE GOOD. WE HAVE
02:39:32.162 --> 02:39:33.263
EMOTION. WOULD YOU CALL HER
02:39:33.330 --> 02:39:41.738
OPERATION? MOTION IS TO PASS.
02:39:41.805 --> 02:39:43.941
BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO THE
02:39:44.007 --> 02:39:44.541
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
02:39:44.608 --> 02:39:47.844
SENATORS CABALLERO NIELSEN
02:39:47.911 --> 02:39:53.250
DURAZO. SO I HERTZBERG WIENER.
02:39:53.317 --> 02:39:56.586
WIENER I 30 MOVE A CALL. THANK
02:39:56.653 --> 02:39:58.422
YOU FOR YOUR PRESENTATION. THANK
02:39:58.488 --> 02:39:59.423
YOU, SENATOR. PLEASE COME
02:39:59.489 --> 02:40:07.965
FORWARD. WELCOME THANK YOU, MR
02:40:08.031 --> 02:40:09.733
CHAIR, AND SENATORS. I'M HERE TO
02:40:09.800 --> 02:40:12.369
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL 18 50.
02:40:12.436 --> 02:40:13.804
THIS WILL BE A BENEFICIAL TOOL
02:40:13.870 --> 02:40:14.771
TO INCREASE THE SUPPLY OF
02:40:14.838 --> 02:40:15.939
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND PROVIDE
02:40:16.006 --> 02:40:17.240
PUBLIC BENEFIT COMMENSURATE WITH
02:40:17.307 --> 02:40:20.444
THE PUBLIC SUBSIDY. V<c.cyan> 18 50</c>
02:40:20.510 --> 02:40:21.945
SETS MINIMUM STANDARDS OF
02:40:22.012 --> 02:40:23.080
OWNERSHIP FOR WHEN PUBLIC
02:40:23.146 --> 02:40:24.448
ENTITIES ACQUIRE MIDDLE INCOME
02:40:24.514 --> 02:40:26.717
HOUSING TO ENSURE THAT FUTURE
02:40:26.783 --> 02:40:28.051
TRANSACTIONS ARE EQUITABLE FOR
02:40:28.118 --> 02:40:29.853
TENANTS, THE LOCAL JURISDICTION
02:40:29.920 --> 02:40:31.421
AND OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WHO
02:40:31.488 --> 02:40:32.422
ARE FOREGOING PROPERTY TAX
02:40:32.489 --> 02:40:35.192
REVENUES. THIS ALLOWS GPS AND
02:40:35.258 --> 02:40:36.693
FOR PROFIT INTEREST TO ENTER
02:40:36.760 --> 02:40:37.828
INTO MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL
02:40:37.894 --> 02:40:39.563
AGREEMENTS THAT WILL SECURE
02:40:39.629 --> 02:40:40.831
AFFORDABLE AND MIDDLE INCOME
02:40:40.897 --> 02:40:42.032
HOUSING FOR THE RESPECTIVE
02:40:42.099 --> 02:40:43.100
COMMUNITIES WHILE PROTECTING OUR
02:40:43.166 --> 02:40:46.470
CITIES. THIS WEEK SPUR AND THE
02:40:46.536 --> 02:40:47.971
<c.cyan>/C BERKELEY CENTER. TURNER</c>
02:40:48.038 --> 02:40:49.406
CENTER FOR HOUSING INNOVATION
02:40:49.473 --> 02:40:50.974
RELEASED A STUDY THAT STRESSES
02:40:51.041 --> 02:40:53.210
THE NEED FOR POLICIES IN A B 18
02:40:53.276 --> 02:40:54.845
50 TO MAKE THIS MODEL OF
02:40:54.911 --> 02:40:56.046
BENEFICIAL TOOL FOR COMMUNITIES
02:40:56.113 --> 02:40:58.482
ACROSS CALIFORNIA. WHILE MAKING
02:40:58.548 --> 02:41:00.050
SURE THAT THESE PROJECTS WORK
02:41:00.117 --> 02:41:01.685
AND AT LOCAL GOVERNMENT RECEIVES
02:41:01.752 --> 02:41:03.086
THE ASSURANCES THAT THEY WILL BE
02:41:03.153 --> 02:41:05.088
DELIVERED MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING
02:41:05.155 --> 02:41:06.256
. I'D LIKE TO PRESENT WITNESSES
02:41:06.323 --> 02:41:07.557
AND SUPPORTED THE BILL FRANK
02:41:07.624 --> 02:41:09.026
MARTINEZ, REPRESENTING THE
02:41:09.092 --> 02:41:10.494
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
02:41:10.560 --> 02:41:12.029
OF NON PROFIT HOUSING, AND MARK
02:41:12.095 --> 02:41:12.963
STIVERS, REPRESENTING THE
02:41:13.030 --> 02:41:15.465
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP.
02:41:15.532 --> 02:41:16.933
SOMEONE AWARD APPEARS YOU DO
02:41:17.000 --> 02:41:18.802
HAVE A NUMBER OF WITNESSES HERE
02:41:18.869 --> 02:41:20.037
WITH YOUR FIRST ONE. PLEASE COME
02:41:20.103 --> 02:41:23.173
FORWARD AND SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
02:41:23.240 --> 02:41:24.408
HE'S ON THE PHONE, SIR. OKAY,
02:41:24.474 --> 02:41:30.614
QUÊ. MODERATOR. YES. MY NAME IS
02:41:30.680 --> 02:41:33.550
FRANK MARTINEZ ALREADY. YES.
02:41:33.617 --> 02:41:37.354
PLEASE PROCEED, MR MARTINEZ. YES
02:41:37.421 --> 02:41:38.822
THANK YOU. YES, THANK YOU. MY
02:41:38.889 --> 02:41:39.556
NAME IS FRANK MARTINEZ, UM,
02:41:39.623 --> 02:41:41.391
POLICY DIRECTOR CALIFORNIA
02:41:41.458 --> 02:41:42.092
ASSOCIATION OF HOUSING. ALSO
02:41:42.159 --> 02:41:46.029
KNOWN AS CAMP. WE REPRESENT THE
02:41:46.096 --> 02:41:47.297
NONPROFIT, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:41:47.364 --> 02:41:48.365
BUILDERS, PEOPLE WHO BUILD
02:41:48.432 --> 02:41:51.835
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE LOWER
02:41:51.902 --> 02:41:53.336
INCOME PEOPLE IN THE STATE
02:41:53.403 --> 02:41:54.438
THROUGHOUT THE REGION OF
02:41:54.504 --> 02:41:56.206
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, WHICH IS
02:41:56.273 --> 02:41:57.808
LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY RIVERSIDE
02:41:57.874 --> 02:42:00.243
ADVENTURE FOR ANYTHING COUNTY.
02:42:00.310 --> 02:42:01.478
NOW WE HAVE HUNDREDS OF MEMBERS
02:42:01.545 --> 02:42:03.713
OF THE CORE OF OUR MEMBERSHIP.
02:42:03.780 --> 02:42:07.117
IS ABOUT 55 MAJOR NON DEVELOPERS
02:42:07.184 --> 02:42:08.752
WHO WORKED ON HUNDREDS OF
02:42:08.819 --> 02:42:10.787
AFFORDABLE BUILDING TEACHER OR
02:42:10.854 --> 02:42:11.822
NORTHERN MEMBERS FIND THE
02:42:11.888 --> 02:42:12.989
GUARDRAILS IN 80 18 50.
02:42:13.056 --> 02:42:16.626
REASONABLE AND WORKABLE. WE
02:42:16.693 --> 02:42:17.928
APPRECIATE INNOVATION IN
02:42:17.994 --> 02:42:18.862
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, INCLUDING
02:42:18.929 --> 02:42:22.299
COMPELLING BUT NOW IT MEANS
02:42:22.365 --> 02:42:24.234
CUTTING CORNERS OF THE EXTENT OF
02:42:24.301 --> 02:42:24.935
TENANTS IN THE LONG TERM
02:42:25.001 --> 02:42:25.836
VIABILITY. HAMAD FIFTIES
02:42:25.902 --> 02:42:29.840
INCLUDES FOLLOWING GODDARD RAILS
02:42:29.906 --> 02:42:30.941
THAT ARE STANDARD IN AFFORDABLE
02:42:31.007 --> 02:42:32.843
HOUSING WORLD AND APPROPRIATE AT
02:42:32.909 --> 02:42:35.846
ALL. TV AGENT 50 REQUIRES
02:42:35.912 --> 02:42:37.080
REGULATORY AGREEMENTS ENSURE FOR
02:42:37.147 --> 02:42:38.248
ABILITY FOR 55 YEARS STANDARDS.
02:42:38.315 --> 02:42:40.917
PERIOD. THE AGREEMENT SIMPLY
02:42:40.984 --> 02:42:45.088
REQUIRED. THE PROJECT MINISTERS
02:42:45.155 --> 02:42:47.691
MAKE QUOTE EFFORTS FROM QUOTE TO
02:42:47.757 --> 02:42:48.425
ACHIEVE THE DESIRED
02:42:48.492 --> 02:42:49.759
AFFORDABILITY AND ALLOW THE
02:42:49.826 --> 02:42:50.994
PROJECT CONVERT TO MARKET RATE
02:42:51.061 --> 02:42:52.896
AT ANY TIME REPUBLICANS, WHICH
02:42:52.963 --> 02:42:55.132
IS HIMSELF UNFORTUNATELY, THIS
02:42:55.198 --> 02:42:56.566
IS NOT ADEQUATE GUARANTEES OF
02:42:56.633 --> 02:42:58.969
THE PUBLIC BENEFIT OF AFFORDABLE
02:42:59.035 --> 02:43:02.906
HOUSING. YEAH, FUTURE. THE BILL
02:43:02.973 --> 02:43:04.608
REQUIRES THAT RENT CALCULATED
02:43:04.674 --> 02:43:06.776
UNDER TKS STANDARD USING 30% I
02:43:06.843 --> 02:43:08.445
THINK FROM THAT TARGETING FROM
02:43:08.512 --> 02:43:10.747
LEVEL B J P. A TRANSACTIONS
02:43:10.814 --> 02:43:12.249
ASSUME 35% OF INCOME WITH
02:43:12.315 --> 02:43:15.385
RAZORS, FRIENDS TECHNICALLY. 50
02:43:15.452 --> 02:43:16.920
11 HOST CITIES HONESTLY, JPS
02:43:16.987 --> 02:43:18.121
MONITOR EFFORTS THINKING DOCTOR
02:43:18.188 --> 02:43:20.757
ADDITIONAL MIND IT IS A
02:43:20.824 --> 02:43:22.893
COMPETENT INTEREST IN THE DECADE
02:43:22.959 --> 02:43:23.927
MONITOR DEVELOPMENTS. OWNERS AND
02:43:23.994 --> 02:43:25.529
DILIGENT MONITORING IS NECESSARY
02:43:25.595 --> 02:43:26.997
TO ENSURE THE PUBLIC BUT FOR
02:43:27.063 --> 02:43:29.065
WHICH THE TAX A BILLION IN HIS
02:43:29.132 --> 02:43:31.268
GIVEN ACTUALLY ACHIEVED. THIS
02:43:31.334 --> 02:43:33.336
BILL ALSO ENSURES THAT TENANTS
02:43:33.403 --> 02:43:34.638
AND THE HOST CITY AND THE
02:43:34.704 --> 02:43:35.672
ABILITY TO ENFORCE THE
02:43:35.739 --> 02:43:36.673
REGULATORY RESTRICTIONS ON THE
02:43:36.740 --> 02:43:39.643
PROPERTY IN SUMMARY, 88 50
02:43:39.709 --> 02:43:41.044
YOURSELF, WHICH IS REASONABLE
02:43:41.111 --> 02:43:42.779
AND APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS TO
02:43:42.846 --> 02:43:44.748
REPEAT AND TO ENSURE THAT
02:43:44.814 --> 02:43:46.950
CALIFORNIA TAX DOLLARS ARE USED
02:43:47.017 --> 02:43:48.118
WIDELY ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE.
02:43:48.185 --> 02:43:49.186
YES. UNDERSTOOD. THANK YOU VERY
02:43:49.252 --> 02:43:53.190
MUCH. THANK YOU. PLEASE WE HAVE
02:43:53.256 --> 02:43:54.191
A WITNESS, CALIFORNIA HOUSING
02:43:54.257 --> 02:43:56.593
PARTNERSHIP. WE ALL SHARE AN
02:43:56.660 --> 02:43:58.161
INTEREST IN MEETING AFFORDABLE
02:43:58.228 --> 02:43:58.862
HOUSING NEEDS AT ALL INCOME
02:43:58.929 --> 02:44:01.031
LEVELS UPON IT TO THIS BILL WILL
02:44:01.097 --> 02:44:02.499
SAY THAT WE ARE PROVIDED THAT
02:44:02.566 --> 02:44:04.067
THEY ARE PROVIDING AFFORDABLE
02:44:04.134 --> 02:44:04.601
HOUSING TO MIDDLE INCOME
02:44:04.668 --> 02:44:05.602
HOUSEHOLDS WITH NO PUBLIC
02:44:05.669 --> 02:44:06.236
SUBSIDY. UNFORTUNATELY, NEITHER
02:44:06.303 --> 02:44:09.039
IS TRUE. FIRST LET'S TALK ABOUT
02:44:09.105 --> 02:44:10.840
THE SUBSIDY IDENTIFIED JP
02:44:10.907 --> 02:44:12.209
OWNERSHIP. THESE DEVELOPMENTS
02:44:12.275 --> 02:44:13.210
RECEIVED PROPERTY TAX BREAKS AND
02:44:13.276 --> 02:44:15.345
THE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS PER YEAR
02:44:15.412 --> 02:44:16.680
WITH MOST OF THE HIT TAKEN BY
02:44:16.746 --> 02:44:17.981
COUNTY SCHOOLS AND INTERACT WITH
02:44:18.048 --> 02:44:19.783
THE STATE WHO HAVE NO STAY IN
02:44:19.849 --> 02:44:21.785
THE MATTER. IN ADDITION, THE
02:44:21.851 --> 02:44:23.787
BUYERS OF THE BONDS, FINANCING
02:44:23.853 --> 02:44:25.021
THE PURCHASE OR NOT PAYING TAXES
02:44:25.088 --> 02:44:26.523
ON THE INTEREST EARNINGS. AS FOR
02:44:26.590 --> 02:44:27.824
AFFORDABILITY IN THE LARGE
02:44:27.891 --> 02:44:29.826
MAJORITY OF CASES, THE RENTS
02:44:29.893 --> 02:44:30.594
THESE DEVELOPMENTS CHARGE REMAIN
02:44:30.660 --> 02:44:32.262
WELL ABOVE THE HUD DETERMINED
02:44:32.329 --> 02:44:33.096
FAIR MARKET RENT FOR THE AREA,
02:44:33.163 --> 02:44:34.998
KNOWN AS A SMALL AREA FAIR
02:44:35.065 --> 02:44:36.099
MARKET RENT, WHICH CONSIDERS ALL
02:44:36.166 --> 02:44:38.602
RENTAL UNITS. OF THE 21 JP
02:44:38.668 --> 02:44:41.338
DEVELOPMENTS FOR WHICH WE HAVE
02:44:41.404 --> 02:44:41.938
RENT DATA. THE 80% RENTS WERE
02:44:42.005 --> 02:44:44.074
BELOW THIS HUD BENCHMARK IN ONLY
02:44:44.140 --> 02:44:46.243
EIGHT CASES. 100% OF MY RENTS
02:44:46.309 --> 02:44:47.477
WERE BELOW THE HUT BENCHMARK AND
02:44:47.544 --> 02:44:50.280
ONLY FIVE CASES. AND ONLY THREE
02:44:50.347 --> 02:44:52.315
OUT OF 21 WITH 120% AM I RENTS
02:44:52.382 --> 02:44:54.451
BELOW THE BENCHMARK THE RENT
02:44:54.517 --> 02:44:56.019
CALCULATION SHEET I HANDED OUT
02:44:56.086 --> 02:44:57.354
ILLUSTRATES THE UN AFFORDABILITY
02:44:57.420 --> 02:44:58.221
FOR A PARTICULAR DEVELOPMENT IN
02:44:58.288 --> 02:45:00.023
SANTA ROSA. THE RENT SAVINGS THE
02:45:00.090 --> 02:45:01.324
OPPONENTS CLAIM ARE IN
02:45:01.391 --> 02:45:02.826
COMPARISON TO CLASS. A LUXURY
02:45:02.892 --> 02:45:04.461
APARTMENTS ARE VERY SMALL SUBSET
02:45:04.527 --> 02:45:06.696
OF THE OVERALL OVERALL MARKET.
02:45:06.763 --> 02:45:08.198
WHEREAS WORKING FAMILIES NEED A
02:45:08.265 --> 02:45:10.233
SOLID CAMERA TO GET TO WORK.
02:45:10.300 --> 02:45:11.301
THEY ARE OFFERING DISCOUNTS ON
02:45:11.368 --> 02:45:13.570
FERRARIS. MOREOVER THE FOR
02:45:13.637 --> 02:45:15.038
PROFIT ADMINISTRATORS ARE
02:45:15.105 --> 02:45:16.439
RECEIVING EXCESSIVE COMPENSATION
02:45:16.506 --> 02:45:17.974
, ESPECIALLY WHEN ONE CONSIDERS
02:45:18.041 --> 02:45:18.942
THAT THEY ARE MERELY BUYING AND
02:45:19.009 --> 02:45:20.010
MANAGING AN EXISTING DEVELOPMENT
02:45:20.076 --> 02:45:21.278
, NOT DEVELOPING SORELY NEEDED
02:45:21.344 --> 02:45:24.080
NEW HOUSING. THEY'RE THEY'RE
02:45:24.147 --> 02:45:27.817
RECEIVING UPFRONT FEES. ANNUAL
02:45:27.884 --> 02:45:30.020
ASSET MANAGER FEES, AND THEY ARE
02:45:30.086 --> 02:45:31.554
THE BENEFICIARIES OF A B BOND, A
02:45:31.621 --> 02:45:34.357
DEBT TO THE PROPERTY OFTEN OF $5
02:45:34.424 --> 02:45:36.026
MILLION AND ACCRUING INTEREST AT
02:45:36.092 --> 02:45:38.461
10% PER YEAR. THE SECOND
02:45:38.528 --> 02:45:39.596
DOCUMENT I HANDED OUT SHOWS
02:45:39.663 --> 02:45:40.664
EXAMPLE AN EXAMPLE OF THESE
02:45:40.730 --> 02:45:43.300
FEES. LASTLY THE OPPONENTS WHO
02:45:43.366 --> 02:45:45.302
BENEFIT GREATLY FROM THE STATUS
02:45:45.368 --> 02:45:45.935
QUO WILL ARGUE THAT THIS BILL
02:45:46.002 --> 02:45:48.038
WILL UNDER THIS BILL, THE SKY
02:45:48.104 --> 02:45:49.339
WILL FALL. HOWEVER THE LARGE
02:45:49.406 --> 02:45:50.974
MAJORITY OF STAKEHOLDERS
02:45:51.041 --> 02:45:52.342
INCLUDING NON PROFIT DEVELOPERS
02:45:52.409 --> 02:45:53.476
, LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND THE
02:45:53.543 --> 02:45:54.711
TURNER CENTER AT UC BERKELEY AND
02:45:54.778 --> 02:45:55.745
SPUR WHO TOGETHER CONVENED A
02:45:55.812 --> 02:45:57.580
WORKING GROUP. OF PARTNERS
02:45:57.647 --> 02:45:58.481
INTERESTED IN MIDDLE INCOME
02:45:58.548 --> 02:46:00.183
HOUSING, FIND THE BILL BOTH
02:46:00.250 --> 02:46:02.652
WORKABLE AND REASONABLE. THE
02:46:02.719 --> 02:46:04.187
MAJORITY BELIEVES THIS BILL HITS
02:46:04.254 --> 02:46:06.089
THE SWEET SPOT AND THAT THE SKY
02:46:06.156 --> 02:46:08.091
WILL NOT IN FACT FALL. I WOULD
02:46:08.158 --> 02:46:08.892
ALSO LIKE TO CLARIFY THAT THE
02:46:08.958 --> 02:46:10.994
BUILDERS NOT APPLY TO NEW
02:46:11.061 --> 02:46:11.561
CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS ONLY
02:46:11.628 --> 02:46:13.029
APPLIES TO THE ACQUISITION OF
02:46:13.096 --> 02:46:15.699
EXISTING HOUSING. IN SOME OF THE
02:46:15.765 --> 02:46:16.700
PUBLIC IS GOING TO PROVIDE A
02:46:16.766 --> 02:46:17.834
SUBSIDY, THE PUBLIC SHOULD
02:46:17.901 --> 02:46:18.868
RECEIVE A COMMENSURATE PUBLIC
02:46:18.935 --> 02:46:21.971
BENEFIT. A B 18 50 ENSURES AN
02:46:22.038 --> 02:46:22.872
APPROPRIATE BALANCE AND ALSO
02:46:22.939 --> 02:46:24.074
ENSURES THE LONG TERM
02:46:24.140 --> 02:46:25.308
FEASIBILITY OF THESE
02:46:25.375 --> 02:46:26.643
DEVELOPMENTS TO PROTECT AGAINST
02:46:26.710 --> 02:46:28.611
FUTURE DISPLACEMENT OF TENANTS.
02:46:28.678 --> 02:46:29.746
THE BILL SUPPORTS THE PROVISION
02:46:29.813 --> 02:46:31.381
OF MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING WITH
02:46:31.448 --> 02:46:32.682
APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS TO ENSURE
02:46:32.749 --> 02:46:34.117
THAT TENANTS NOT JUST THE
02:46:34.184 --> 02:46:35.318
PROGRAM ADMINISTRATORS RECEIVE
02:46:35.385 --> 02:46:37.087
ADEQUATE BENEFITS. THANK YOU.
02:46:37.153 --> 02:46:38.688
APPRECIATE YOU, SIR. I
02:46:38.755 --> 02:46:40.190
APPRECIATE YOUR REFERENCE HERE
02:46:40.256 --> 02:46:42.392
TO AN ADELE TO HAD LONG AGO,
02:46:42.459 --> 02:46:44.094
REPRESENTATIVE THAT COUNTY. I'M
02:46:44.160 --> 02:46:44.961
QUITE FAMILIAR WITH THOSE
02:46:45.028 --> 02:46:46.863
CIRCUMSTANCES AND WASN'T JUST AN
02:46:46.930 --> 02:46:47.964
ADELE THAT WAS AFFECTED. IT'S A
02:46:48.031 --> 02:46:52.302
BROAD AND DEEP ISSUE HERE. OKAY?
02:46:52.369 --> 02:46:54.003
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
02:46:54.070 --> 02:47:02.112
PLEASE. HELLO JENNIFER MENTAL
02:47:02.178 --> 02:47:03.613
WITH THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
02:47:03.680 --> 02:47:04.647
CONSORTIUM AND SUPPORT OF THIS
02:47:04.714 --> 02:47:09.619
BILL. ANYA LAWLER ON BEHALF OF
02:47:09.686 --> 02:47:10.954
THE CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
02:47:11.020 --> 02:47:12.355
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION, THE
02:47:12.422 --> 02:47:13.490
PUBLIC INTEREST LAW PROJECT, THE
02:47:13.556 --> 02:47:15.525
NATIONAL HOUSING LAW PROJECT IN
02:47:15.592 --> 02:47:16.659
THE WESTERN CENTRAL ON POVERTY
02:47:16.726 --> 02:47:19.095
ON SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ABRAM
02:47:19.162 --> 02:47:20.430
DEALS WITH THE NONPROFIT HOUSING
02:47:20.497 --> 02:47:21.097
ASSOCIATION, NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
02:47:21.164 --> 02:47:24.501
AND SUPPORT OKAY. THANK YOU.
02:47:24.567 --> 02:47:26.302
QUITE A COALITION IN THE SUPPORT
02:47:26.369 --> 02:47:27.337
ASSEMBLYMAN. THANK YOU, SIR.
02:47:27.404 --> 02:47:30.440
GOOD WORK, OKAY? ANY ANY FURTHER
02:47:30.507 --> 02:47:33.343
QUESTIONS COMMITTEE NÓ. DO WE
02:47:33.410 --> 02:47:40.617
HAVE ANY IN QUÊ. AND IF THEY'D
02:47:40.683 --> 02:47:42.652
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B
02:47:42.719 --> 02:47:49.859
18 50, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND WE
02:47:49.926 --> 02:47:53.163
HAVE NO LINES COMING IN. WOULD
02:47:53.229 --> 02:48:00.537
DO POLE. ANY OPPOSITION. AND
02:48:00.603 --> 02:48:02.572
AGAIN IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:48:02.639 --> 02:48:04.974
OPPOSITION A B 18 50 PRESS 10 WE
02:48:05.041 --> 02:48:06.176
HAVE ONE PERSON HAS JUST STOOD
02:48:06.242 --> 02:48:08.211
UP HERE IN COMMITTEE, PLEASE.
02:48:08.278 --> 02:48:09.779
HONORABLE MEMBERS OF THE
02:48:09.846 --> 02:48:11.247
COMMITTEE. I'M JOHN STOKER,
02:48:11.314 --> 02:48:12.115
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
02:48:12.182 --> 02:48:13.116
MUNICIPAL FINANCE AUTHORITY, OR
02:48:13.183 --> 02:48:15.952
SAME IF A WE ARE A JOINT
02:48:16.019 --> 02:48:17.854
EXERCISE WITH POWERS AUTHORITY
02:48:17.921 --> 02:48:19.355
CREATED PRIVATE PUBLIC BENEFITS
02:48:19.422 --> 02:48:20.323
THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND,
02:48:20.390 --> 02:48:21.324
REGARDLESS TO AFFORDABLE
02:48:21.391 --> 02:48:23.693
HOUSING. WE'VE BEEN WORKING FOR
02:48:23.760 --> 02:48:25.094
THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS
02:48:25.161 --> 02:48:26.663
FOR YEARS. LAST YEAR LONG WE
02:48:26.729 --> 02:48:27.931
SUBMITTED MORE APPLICATIONS THE
02:48:27.997 --> 02:48:29.666
SEDLAK THAN EVERY OTHER ISSUE OR
02:48:29.732 --> 02:48:32.035
IN THE STATE COMBINED, SAY THAT
02:48:32.101 --> 02:48:33.336
ONLY TO SAY THAT WE ARE WORKING
02:48:33.403 --> 02:48:34.471
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO FIX THE
02:48:34.537 --> 02:48:36.773
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS. IN
02:48:36.840 --> 02:48:38.842
REGARDS TO MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING
02:48:38.908 --> 02:48:40.844
. THERE ARE ARE NOT THE PROGRAMS
02:48:40.910 --> 02:48:42.579
THAT ARE AVAILABLE TO THE
02:48:42.645 --> 02:48:43.112
NORMAL, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:48:43.179 --> 02:48:44.247
PROGRAM WITH TAX CREDIT AND
02:48:44.314 --> 02:48:45.849
OTHERS, AND THAT'S WHY THIS
02:48:45.915 --> 02:48:46.749
PROGRAM, THE MIDDLE INCOME OR
02:48:46.816 --> 02:48:48.418
CENTRAL HOUSING PROGRAM HAS BEEN
02:48:48.485 --> 02:48:53.089
CREATED. THE ESSENTIAL HOUSING
02:48:53.156 --> 02:48:55.091
PROGRAM WORKS WITHOUT TAX
02:48:55.158 --> 02:48:58.094
CREDITS THAT PROVIDES 30 TO 70%
02:48:58.161 --> 02:48:59.629
EQUITY MONEY, ESSENTIALLY A
02:48:59.696 --> 02:49:02.031
GRANT TO TAX CREDIT PROJECTS. WE
02:49:02.098 --> 02:49:03.266
DON'T HAVE THAT ABILITY. ALL WE
02:49:03.333 --> 02:49:05.001
HAVE IS THE PROPERTY TAX
02:49:05.068 --> 02:49:07.003
EXEMPTION. TO WORK WITH AND
02:49:07.070 --> 02:49:08.605
THAT'S INTENTIONAL SO THAT WE
02:49:08.671 --> 02:49:10.707
DON'T AFFECT THE NORMAL TAX
02:49:10.773 --> 02:49:14.310
CREDIT PROJECTS. UM I THINK THIS
02:49:14.377 --> 02:49:16.613
THIS BILL VERY WELL THOUGHT OUT
02:49:16.679 --> 02:49:18.381
IN THE SENSE THAT YES, WE LOVE
02:49:18.448 --> 02:49:20.517
GUARDRAILS WITH WE LIKE STANDARD
02:49:20.583 --> 02:49:22.085
AFFORDABILITY. OTHER THINGS, I
02:49:22.151 --> 02:49:23.620
THINK IF YOU LOOK AT THESE
02:49:23.686 --> 02:49:25.121
DOCUMENTS, ALL OF THESE BONDS
02:49:25.188 --> 02:49:26.122
HAVE BEEN OFFERED IN PUBLIC
02:49:26.189 --> 02:49:27.323
DOCUMENTS. HUNDREDS OF PAGES
02:49:27.390 --> 02:49:29.692
LONG THERE ARE GUARDRAILS. THERE
02:49:29.759 --> 02:49:31.060
ARE A NUMBER OF THE REQUIREMENTS
02:49:31.127 --> 02:49:33.229
THAT WE THINK THIS BILL
02:49:33.296 --> 02:49:34.430
INTRODUCES ITEMS THAT AREN'T IN
02:49:34.497 --> 02:49:35.632
NORMAL IF YOU WILL, OR
02:49:35.698 --> 02:49:37.433
TRADITIONAL, AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
02:49:37.500 --> 02:49:39.435
I THINK THE BIGGEST THING THAT
02:49:39.502 --> 02:49:40.737
WE'RE MISSING IS THAT THIS IS
02:49:40.803 --> 02:49:43.339
GOVERNMENTAL OWNERSHIP AT ALL
02:49:43.406 --> 02:49:45.041
AND ORDERS IT BENEFITS TO LOCAL
02:49:45.108 --> 02:49:46.576
GOVERNMENT TO THE TUNE OF
02:49:46.643 --> 02:49:47.644
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS, WHICH IS
02:49:47.710 --> 02:49:49.445
DIFFERENT THAN THE TAX CREDIT
02:49:49.512 --> 02:49:51.047
TRANSACTIONS THAT ALL GO TO A
02:49:51.114 --> 02:49:53.182
PRIVATE DEVELOPER THAT THEY TAKE
02:49:53.249 --> 02:49:54.350
THE PROPERTY OFF THE TABLE AT
02:49:54.417 --> 02:49:57.253
SOME POINT FINALLY TREASURER MÀ
02:49:57.320 --> 02:49:59.455
HAS COME TO AN OPEN HOUSE ON ONE
02:49:59.522 --> 02:50:00.990
OF OUR PROPERTIES AND PARAMOUNT
02:50:01.057 --> 02:50:02.959
AND GOT TO SEE FIRSTHAND WITH
02:50:03.026 --> 02:50:03.960
THE CITY COUNCIL AND RESIDENTS
02:50:04.027 --> 02:50:06.062
THE TREMENDOUS IMPACT THAT THE
02:50:06.129 --> 02:50:07.096
MIDDLE INCOME PROGRAM HAS
02:50:07.163 --> 02:50:10.099
PROVIDED. AND SEEN FIRSTHAND AND
02:50:10.166 --> 02:50:11.668
CONSIDERABLE RENT REDUCTIONS.
02:50:11.734 --> 02:50:13.703
PEOPLE ARE BENEFITING THE TURN
02:50:13.770 --> 02:50:15.939
OF $1000 A MONTH AND WHEN YOU
02:50:16.005 --> 02:50:16.839
LOOK AT THAT THAT IS VERY
02:50:16.906 --> 02:50:18.341
MEANINGFUL IN TODAY'S
02:50:18.408 --> 02:50:19.142
INFLATIONARY ENVIRONMENT.
02:50:19.208 --> 02:50:20.677
BECAUSE OF THAT, AND OTHER
02:50:20.743 --> 02:50:21.644
REASONS, WE MUST REGARD FELI
02:50:21.711 --> 02:50:22.645
OPPOSE LEGISLATION BUT
02:50:22.712 --> 02:50:23.246
APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION.
02:50:23.313 --> 02:50:27.083
THANK YOU, SIR. I'M INFORMED
02:50:27.150 --> 02:50:30.086
THERE IS A WADE NORRIS ALSO VIA
02:50:30.153 --> 02:50:34.123
PHONE MODERATOR, MR NORRIS IN. Q
02:50:34.190 --> 02:50:36.593
UH, YES, THANK YOU. CHEER
02:50:36.659 --> 02:50:37.460
CABALLERO, VICE CHAIR, NIELSEN
02:50:37.527 --> 02:50:40.330
AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
02:50:40.396 --> 02:50:41.531
NAME IS WADE NORTH, AND I'M
02:50:41.598 --> 02:50:42.799
SPEAKING IN OPPOSITION TO A B.
02:50:42.865 --> 02:50:45.802
18 50, THE MANAGING MEMBER OF
02:50:45.868 --> 02:50:47.170
NORRIS, GEORGIA AND AUSTRO AT
02:50:47.236 --> 02:50:49.339
WASHINGTON, D C BASED LAW FIRM
02:50:49.405 --> 02:50:50.707
THAT SPECIALIZES IN TACTICS THEM
02:50:50.773 --> 02:50:51.941
UP THE FAMILY HOUSING BIND
02:50:52.008 --> 02:50:52.875
FINANCE THROUGHOUT THE UNITED
02:50:52.942 --> 02:50:56.245
STATES. SINCE 1974. I'VE CLOSED
02:50:56.312 --> 02:50:57.213
MANY BILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF
02:50:57.280 --> 02:50:59.048
THESE FINANCING IN ALL 50
02:50:59.115 --> 02:51:02.352
STATES. THE JP WORKFORCE HOUSING
02:51:02.418 --> 02:51:03.753
PROGRAM IS ONE OF THE MOST
02:51:03.820 --> 02:51:05.188
REMARKABLE BAND FINANCING
02:51:05.254 --> 02:51:08.157
PROGRAMS HAVE SEEN IN MY CAREER.
02:51:08.224 --> 02:51:10.660
IT IS PROVIDED A BILLION OF 100%
02:51:10.727 --> 02:51:14.097
DEBT FINANCING TO MOVE 14,000.
02:51:14.163 --> 02:51:15.798
TOP QUALITY APARTMENT UNITS FROM
02:51:15.865 --> 02:51:17.734
PRIVATE TO PUBLIC GOVERNMENTAL
02:51:17.800 --> 02:51:20.136
OWNERSHIP AND NO OUT OF POCKET
02:51:20.203 --> 02:51:21.838
COST OR RISK TO THE GOVERNMENTAL
02:51:21.904 --> 02:51:23.840
PARTICIPANTS. THIS IS THE ONLY
02:51:23.906 --> 02:51:25.742
PROGRAM THAT PROVIDES MATERIAL
02:51:25.808 --> 02:51:26.909
RENT RELIEF TO THE TEACHERS,
02:51:26.976 --> 02:51:29.612
FIRST RESPONDERS. AND OTHER
02:51:29.679 --> 02:51:31.014
MIDDLE INCOME CALIFORNIANS WHO
02:51:31.080 --> 02:51:33.983
ARE DESPERATE TO LIVE WHERE THEY
02:51:34.050 --> 02:51:35.685
WERE. CITIZENS HAVE NO ACCESS TO
02:51:35.752 --> 02:51:36.819
THE HUGE FEDERAL AND STATE
02:51:36.886 --> 02:51:38.087
SUBSIDIES, WHICH FUND HALF THE
02:51:38.154 --> 02:51:40.556
COST OF HOUSING. FOR RENTERS AT
02:51:40.623 --> 02:51:42.425
60% VOLUME OUR BLOWS, JOHN
02:51:42.492 --> 02:51:48.364
STOKER JUST INDICATED. THANK YOU
02:51:48.431 --> 02:51:57.273
VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. UM. WE ARE GOING TO ASKED FOR
02:51:57.340 --> 02:51:58.741
OPPOSITION IN IN THE COMMITTEE
02:51:58.808 --> 02:52:01.177
ROOM. UM IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE
02:52:01.244 --> 02:52:01.844
COMMITTEE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
02:52:01.911 --> 02:52:03.246
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
02:52:03.312 --> 02:52:06.582
BILL? WELCOME. THANK YOU, MADAM
02:52:06.649 --> 02:52:07.617
CHAIR AND MEMBERS DEBORAH
02:52:07.684 --> 02:52:09.152
CARLSON WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:52:09.218 --> 02:52:09.686
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION IN
02:52:09.752 --> 02:52:13.356
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:52:13.423 --> 02:52:14.290
. BEN BARKER AT THE CALIFORNIA
02:52:14.357 --> 02:52:15.625
MUNICIPAL FINANCE AUTHORITY,
02:52:15.692 --> 02:52:16.559
WHERE THE LARGEST AFFORDABLE
02:52:16.626 --> 02:52:17.627
HOUSING ISSUE IN THIS STATE AND
02:52:17.694 --> 02:52:21.431
WE OPPOSED THE BILL. THANK YOU.
02:52:21.497 --> 02:52:22.632
ELECTING WITH THE SILICON VALLEY
02:52:22.699 --> 02:52:23.700
LEADERSHIP GROUP IN RESPECTFUL
02:52:23.766 --> 02:52:27.203
OPPOSITION. SEAN ROSIN WITH
02:52:27.270 --> 02:52:28.738
WATERFORD PROPERTY COMPANY AND
02:52:28.805 --> 02:52:29.872
OPPOSITION MAYBE 18 50. THANK
02:52:29.939 --> 02:52:33.576
YOU. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE HERE
02:52:33.643 --> 02:52:35.211
IN THE ROOM, SEEING NONE WILL
02:52:35.278 --> 02:52:36.612
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
02:52:36.679 --> 02:52:38.948
LINE. IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE
02:52:39.015 --> 02:52:39.949
TELECONFERENCE LINE THAT WOULD
02:52:40.016 --> 02:52:50.359
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION?
02:52:50.426 --> 02:52:51.494
MR MODERATOR, YOU CAN YOU CUE
02:52:51.561 --> 02:52:54.197
UP? PUBLIC TESTIMONY AND
02:52:54.263 --> 02:53:03.039
OPPOSITION. ARE YOU THERE? MR
02:53:03.106 --> 02:53:12.315
MODERATOR. CHECKING IN TO SEE IF
02:53:12.381 --> 02:53:25.595
WE'VE LOST OUR CONNECTION.
02:53:25.661 --> 02:53:26.829
MR MODERATOR, CAN YOU CHECK IF
02:53:26.896 --> 02:53:44.147
YOU'RE MUTED? MM HMM.
02:53:44.213 --> 02:53:50.553
SHE SAID. HE'S THERE BUT. DO WE
02:53:50.620 --> 02:53:52.522
NEED TO TAKE A LITTLE BREAK TO
02:53:52.588 --> 02:53:56.559
SEE IF THERE ARE ISSUES WITH THE
02:53:56.626 --> 02:54:12.708
LINE.
02:54:12.775 --> 02:54:16.913
WE ARE CHECKING TO SEE THAT. TO
02:54:16.979 --> 02:54:19.248
SEE THAT THE LINE IS WORKING AND
02:54:19.315 --> 02:54:20.383
THAT THE MODERATOR IS ABLE TO
02:54:20.449 --> 02:54:29.625
COMMUNICATE WITH US. RIGHT, MHM.
02:54:29.692 --> 02:54:30.927
YES WE'RE GONNA WE'RE GOING TO
02:54:30.993 --> 02:54:33.362
TAKE A TWO MINUTE RECESS. UM AND
02:54:33.429 --> 02:54:35.264
THEN WE'LL COME BACK. WE'LL MAKE
02:54:35.331 --> 02:54:52.381
SURE THE LINE IS WORKING.
02:55:11.200 --> 02:55:12.435
LOT, A LOT OF BUSINESS IN FRONT
02:55:12.501 --> 02:55:26.148
OF US.
02:55:26.215 --> 02:55:32.755
AND THIS IS JOHN WITH A T AND T.
02:55:32.822 --> 02:55:33.923
HI, JOHN. THANK YOU FOR RE
02:55:33.990 --> 02:55:35.258
ESTABLISHING CONNECTION. OKAY,
02:55:35.324 --> 02:55:46.369
PLACES THROUGH NOW. THANK YOU.
02:55:46.435 --> 02:55:47.370
IN YOUR RECONNECTED. PLEASE
02:55:47.436 --> 02:55:58.481
CONTINUE. VERY GOOD WHERE WE ARE
02:55:58.547 --> 02:55:59.649
NOW ON OPPOSITION ON THE
02:55:59.715 --> 02:56:01.817
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
02:56:01.884 --> 02:56:04.253
MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE QUEUE
02:56:04.320 --> 02:56:08.224
UP OPPOSITION TO A B 18 50?
02:56:08.291 --> 02:56:09.992
CERTAINLY THANK YOU AND WE'LL GO
02:56:10.059 --> 02:56:15.264
TO LINE 86, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES
02:56:15.331 --> 02:56:16.732
HELLO. MY NAME IS RACHEL MANNER
02:56:16.799 --> 02:56:18.267
AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT ESSENTIAL
02:56:18.334 --> 02:56:19.936
HOUSING. I LIVE IN THE ROMAN
02:56:20.002 --> 02:56:21.971
APARTMENT IN ESCONDIDO. AND SO I
02:56:22.038 --> 02:56:27.376
OPPOSED A B 18 50. THANK YOU.
02:56:27.443 --> 02:56:28.611
NEXT GO TO LINE 55, PLEASE GO
02:56:28.678 --> 02:56:33.149
AHEAD. ARMANDO SANCHEZ, HOUSING
02:56:33.215 --> 02:56:34.684
ENDOWMENT AND REGIONAL TRUST OF
02:56:34.750 --> 02:56:36.752
DAMAGE. COUNTY STRONGLY OPPOSED
02:56:36.819 --> 02:56:38.321
THIS BILL UNLESS AMENDED TO
02:56:38.387 --> 02:56:39.822
ALLOW OUR COUNTY TO TRY AND
02:56:39.889 --> 02:56:41.424
MODEL THAT SOLVES THESE ISSUES
02:56:41.490 --> 02:56:42.224
WITHOUT KILLING THESE TYPES OF
02:56:42.291 --> 02:56:45.995
DEALS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:56:46.062 --> 02:56:50.833
LINE. 84, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HOW
02:56:50.900 --> 02:56:52.201
YOU DOING? ALISON ARNOLD FROM
02:56:52.268 --> 02:56:54.370
CATALYST HOUSING GROUP IN STRONG
02:56:54.437 --> 02:56:55.004
OPPOSITION TO A B 18 50. THANK
02:56:55.071 --> 02:56:59.308
YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 4 23,
02:56:59.375 --> 02:57:04.747
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THURMAN AND A
02:57:04.814 --> 02:57:06.449
MEMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA FOR
02:57:06.515 --> 02:57:07.383
ESSENTIAL HOUSING COALITION, AND
02:57:07.450 --> 02:57:12.221
I STRONGLY OPPOSED AVIATION 50.
02:57:12.288 --> 02:57:18.627
LINE 4 33, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE
02:57:18.694 --> 02:57:26.535
FOR 33. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. AND
02:57:26.602 --> 02:57:28.504
WE'LL MOVE ON TO LINE 29. PLEASE
02:57:28.571 --> 02:57:31.407
GO AHEAD. HI. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
02:57:31.474 --> 02:57:34.710
NAME IS CRISTINA FREE. AND
02:57:34.777 --> 02:57:36.312
THAT'S A PARALLEL APARTMENTS IN
02:57:36.379 --> 02:57:37.747
ANAHEIM, AND I'M A STRONG
02:57:37.813 --> 02:57:38.814
SUPPORTER OF THE CENTRAL HOUSING
02:57:38.881 --> 02:57:39.682
IN CALIFORNIA. I STRONGLY
02:57:39.749 --> 02:57:44.887
OPPOSED A B 18 50. THANK YOU.
02:57:44.954 --> 02:57:49.692
LINE 2 68, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:57:49.759 --> 02:57:51.761
MADAM CHAIRWOMAN MEMBERS MATTHEW
02:57:51.827 --> 02:57:52.762
JACOBS HERE FROM BILL, DID YOU
02:57:52.828 --> 02:57:54.830
PARTNERS IN STRONG OPPOSITION OF
02:57:54.897 --> 02:57:56.332
THE PROGRAM HAS IT EXISTS HAS
02:57:56.399 --> 02:57:57.533
SOME PROBLEMS, BUT IT'S
02:57:57.600 --> 02:57:58.067
EFFICIENT AND IT DELIVERS
02:57:58.134 --> 02:58:01.070
ESSENTIAL HOUSING. UM AND AS
02:58:01.137 --> 02:58:02.838
WRITTEN, THIS BILL IS GOING TO
02:58:02.905 --> 02:58:03.839
REALLY KILL THIS INNOVATIVE
02:58:03.906 --> 02:58:06.976
PROGRAM THANK YOU. LINE 4 22,
02:58:07.043 --> 02:58:12.715
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:58:12.782 --> 02:58:14.917
TOM MAYS. I AM A MEMBER OF THE
02:58:14.984 --> 02:58:16.852
ESSENTIAL HOUSING COALITION. AND
02:58:16.919 --> 02:58:21.657
I STRONGLY OPPOSED MAYBE 18 50.
02:58:21.724 --> 02:58:26.028
LINE. 1 30, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY
02:58:26.095 --> 02:58:28.130
NAME IS MARGARITA ROCHA RESIDENT
02:58:28.197 --> 02:58:29.665
AT FEEL APARTMENTS IN PASADENA
02:58:29.732 --> 02:58:31.400
MANAGED BY GREAT STORY AND I
02:58:31.467 --> 02:58:35.304
OPPOSED A B 18 50. LINE 4 27,
02:58:35.371 --> 02:58:40.242
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS COLE
02:58:40.309 --> 02:58:41.744
TATE AND A MEMBER OF THE
02:58:41.811 --> 02:58:43.279
CALIFORNIA FOR ESSENTIAL HOUSING
02:58:43.345 --> 02:58:44.513
COALITION, AND I STRONGLY
02:58:44.580 --> 02:58:48.818
OPPOSED A B 18 50. LINE 2 83,
02:58:48.884 --> 02:58:53.622
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
02:58:53.689 --> 02:58:55.458
LAUREN FEVER, WITH CITY HOUSING
02:58:55.524 --> 02:58:56.692
GROUPS BEING STRONG OPPOSITION
02:58:56.759 --> 02:59:01.730
TO A V 18 50. LINE 4194 19,
02:59:01.797 --> 02:59:10.139
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS MATT
02:59:10.206 --> 02:59:12.141
A BEETLE WITH ASCENDENT CAPITAL
02:59:12.208 --> 02:59:13.008
. WE ARE PROJECT ADMINISTERING
02:59:13.075 --> 02:59:15.144
FOR LATITUDE 33 DEPARTMENTS,
02:59:15.211 --> 02:59:17.413
ANDINO AND WE STRONGLY OPPOSED
02:59:17.480 --> 02:59:19.615
18 50. WE'VE SEEN THIS. UM THIS
02:59:19.682 --> 02:59:20.616
PROGRAM SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACT THE
02:59:20.683 --> 02:59:24.086
LIVES OF MANY FAMILIES BY
02:59:24.153 --> 02:59:25.488
REDUCING THEIR RENT AND OFFERING
02:59:25.554 --> 02:59:27.223
THEM SIGNIFICANTLY LESS RENT
02:59:27.289 --> 02:59:29.358
THAN THE REST OF THE MARKET, AND
02:59:29.425 --> 02:59:35.064
WE STRONGLY OPPOSE THE BILL. IN
02:59:35.131 --> 02:59:37.032
THE GOLD LINE. 4 41, PLEASE GO
02:59:37.099 --> 02:59:42.638
AHEAD. MY NAME IS JEREMY BORDEN
02:59:42.705 --> 02:59:45.374
AND A MEMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:59:45.441 --> 02:59:46.509
FOR A CENTRAL HOUSING COALITION
02:59:46.575 --> 02:59:47.610
. AND I STRONGLY OPPOSED MAYBE
02:59:47.676 --> 02:59:53.115
1850. WE'LL GO TO LINE 4 28,
02:59:53.182 --> 02:59:57.553
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD EVENING.
02:59:57.620 --> 02:59:59.622
MY NAME IS THAT ENQUIST? I LIVE
02:59:59.688 --> 03:00:01.824
IN, UH, ORANGE PANIC. CALIFORNIA
03:00:01.891 --> 03:00:03.859
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE A V 18 50.
03:00:03.926 --> 03:00:08.631
THANK YOU. BLIND FOR 13, PLEASE
03:00:08.697 --> 03:00:13.068
GO AHEAD. SAMUEL KOONJUL WOULD
03:00:13.135 --> 03:00:14.403
BLDG PARTNERS CALLING TO OPPOSE
03:00:14.470 --> 03:00:22.678
A B 18 50. LINE 4 40, PLEASE GO
03:00:22.745 --> 03:00:27.883
AHEAD. THIS IS BRENDAN MASSEY
03:00:27.950 --> 03:00:28.951
WITH CINDY CAPITAL AND I
03:00:29.018 --> 03:00:32.721
STRONGLY OPPOSE A B 18 50. LINE.
03:00:32.788 --> 03:00:38.327
93, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
03:00:38.394 --> 03:00:39.929
EVERYONE. MY NAME IS GALICIA,
03:00:39.995 --> 03:00:42.231
GRACE ISRAEL AND I LIVE AS THE
03:00:42.298 --> 03:00:45.034
WESTGATE APARTMENT IN PASADENA
03:00:45.100 --> 03:00:46.969
AND I AM A SUPPORTER OF THE
03:00:47.036 --> 03:00:49.605
SEXUAL HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA AND
03:00:49.672 --> 03:00:51.707
I STRONGLY OPPOSED A B 18. THANK
03:00:51.774 --> 03:00:59.515
YOU. LINE 4 47, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:00:59.582 --> 03:01:01.617
HI. MY NAME IS BRAD GRIGGS. I'M
03:01:01.684 --> 03:01:03.219
A 40 YEAR VETERAN IN THIS
03:01:03.285 --> 03:01:06.121
INDUSTRY PROVIDER OF UNWELCOME
03:01:06.188 --> 03:01:07.623
HOUSING AND THIS PROGRAM, THERE
03:01:07.690 --> 03:01:08.857
ARE GUARD RAILS IN PLACE. THIS
03:01:08.924 --> 03:01:10.025
IS A COMPLETE ALIGNMENT OF
03:01:10.092 --> 03:01:11.660
INTEREST. STRONGLY OPPOSED A B
03:01:11.727 --> 03:01:16.398
18 50. FLYING CORPS 02, PLEASE
03:01:16.465 --> 03:01:22.004
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. KAREN
03:01:22.071 --> 03:01:23.672
ESPARZA WOULD BLDG PARTNERS AND
03:01:23.739 --> 03:01:28.644
I STRONGLY OPPOSE MAYBE. LINE 2
03:01:28.711 --> 03:01:32.715
19, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:01:32.781 --> 03:01:33.749
AFTERNOON, SHAWN BRADLEY WITH
03:01:33.816 --> 03:01:34.650
HOMESTEAD CORPORATION. STRONGLY
03:01:34.717 --> 03:01:40.122
OPPOSE 18TH. LINE 1 83. PLEASE
03:01:40.189 --> 03:01:46.095
GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS ELIZABETH
03:01:46.161 --> 03:01:48.230
HENRY FROM STATE, LAFAYETTE AND
03:01:48.297 --> 03:01:52.101
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA. AND IN
03:01:52.167 --> 03:01:53.836
STRONG OPPOSITION TO BUILD THAT
03:01:53.902 --> 03:01:55.771
IT'S ALSO DISINGENUOUS IN ITS
03:01:55.838 --> 03:02:00.409
INTENT AND MOTHER. LINE 4 57,
03:02:00.476 --> 03:02:07.549
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE WORK, 57.
03:02:07.616 --> 03:02:15.057
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. AND MADAM
03:02:15.124 --> 03:02:16.892
CHAIR AND NO FURTHER COMMENTS IN
03:02:16.959 --> 03:02:20.329
QUÊ. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT
03:02:20.396 --> 03:02:22.398
CONCLUDES OUR OPPOSITION BRING
03:02:22.464 --> 03:02:24.133
THE MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
03:02:24.199 --> 03:02:27.002
FOR COMMENTS AND SENATOR WIENER
03:02:27.069 --> 03:02:29.772
. UH EXCUSE ME. THANK YOU VERY
03:02:29.838 --> 03:02:30.906
MUCH, MADAM CHAIR AS AS YOU
03:02:30.973 --> 03:02:34.643
KNOW, WE HEARD THIS IN HOUSING
03:02:34.710 --> 03:02:36.812
COMMITTEE AS WELL. I KNOW THE
03:02:36.879 --> 03:02:38.047
AUTHOR AND HIS SPONSORS HAVE
03:02:38.113 --> 03:02:41.483
BEEN WORKING PRETTY INTENSIVELY
03:02:41.550 --> 03:02:44.486
AND TAKEN SIGNIFICANT AMENDMENTS
03:02:44.553 --> 03:02:46.588
TO TRY TO RESPOND TO SOME OF THE
03:02:46.655 --> 03:02:49.058
OBJECTIONS BY THE OPPONENTS. I
03:02:49.124 --> 03:02:51.560
THINK THIS MODEL IS IT CAN HAVE
03:02:51.627 --> 03:02:53.228
REAL BENEFITS. BUT THERE ARE
03:02:53.295 --> 03:02:58.334
ALSO SOME REAL CHALLENGES AROUND
03:02:58.400 --> 03:03:00.102
IT. I THINK THE BILL DOES A
03:03:00.169 --> 03:03:03.772
REASONABLE JOB OF, UM OF
03:03:03.839 --> 03:03:05.174
ADDRESSING SOME OF THOSE
03:03:05.240 --> 03:03:06.275
CHALLENGES AND MAKING SURE THAT
03:03:06.342 --> 03:03:08.444
THIS MODEL ACTUALLY DOES WHAT?
03:03:08.510 --> 03:03:12.247
IT UM IS SUPPOSED TO BE DOING.
03:03:12.314 --> 03:03:14.249
THIS IS A MODEL THAT IS
03:03:14.316 --> 03:03:15.751
RECEIVING PUBLIC SUBSIDIES
03:03:15.818 --> 03:03:17.386
BECAUSE HE'S J P IS THE ONLY
03:03:17.453 --> 03:03:20.122
REASON THAT A J P A IS THE MODEL
03:03:20.189 --> 03:03:21.623
IS SO THAT THEY DON'T PAY
03:03:21.690 --> 03:03:23.325
PROPERTY TAXES AND I'M NOT
03:03:23.392 --> 03:03:26.195
OPPOSED TO USING A PROPERTY TAX
03:03:26.261 --> 03:03:27.863
SUBSIDY, UM, TO IMPROVE
03:03:27.930 --> 03:03:28.831
AFFORDABILITY. THAT'S HOW A LOT
03:03:28.897 --> 03:03:32.334
OF MIDDLE CLASS HOUSING GOT
03:03:32.401 --> 03:03:34.002
BUILT IN NEW YORK CITY AFTER
03:03:34.069 --> 03:03:36.138
WORLD WAR TWO IF I AM
03:03:36.205 --> 03:03:36.972
UNDERSTANDING MY HISTORY
03:03:37.039 --> 03:03:38.140
CORRECTLY, SO I'M NOT
03:03:38.207 --> 03:03:39.475
PHILOSOPHICALLY OPPOSED TO THAT.
03:03:39.541 --> 03:03:41.343
BUT I DO THINK THAT IF YOU'RE
03:03:41.410 --> 03:03:42.745
DOING THAT THERE HAVE TO BE
03:03:42.811 --> 03:03:44.546
OTHER CARD RAILS IN PLACE, AND I
03:03:44.613 --> 03:03:45.981
THINK THIS BILL IS A GOOD FAITH
03:03:46.048 --> 03:03:47.783
EFFORT TO DO THAT. I'M CONFIDENT
03:03:47.850 --> 03:03:49.218
THERE WILL BE CONTINUED DIALOGUE
03:03:49.284 --> 03:03:51.153
AND CONTINUE TO WORK ON THIS
03:03:51.220 --> 03:03:53.322
BILL. UM BUT I AS I DID IN
03:03:53.389 --> 03:03:54.089
HOUSING COMMITTEE, I'LL CONTINUE
03:03:54.156 --> 03:03:55.824
TO SUPPORT IT AND I'M HAPPY TO
03:03:55.891 --> 03:03:58.327
MOVE THE BILL. OKAY. THERE IS A
03:03:58.394 --> 03:03:59.495
MOTION BY SENATOR WIENER. OTHER
03:03:59.561 --> 03:04:03.699
COMMENTS. WELL ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:04:03.766 --> 03:04:05.667
I WILL BE. UM I WILL NOT BE
03:04:05.734 --> 03:04:08.103
SUPPORTING THE BILL TODAY. UM
03:04:08.170 --> 03:04:09.104
THE CONCERN I HAVE IS, UM WE
03:04:09.171 --> 03:04:12.841
DESPERATELY NEED HOUSING AND ANY
03:04:12.908 --> 03:04:15.110
TOOL IN OUR TOOLBOX BOX THAT
03:04:15.177 --> 03:04:16.478
PROVIDES US WITH AN OPPORTUNITY
03:04:16.545 --> 03:04:19.114
TO DO THAT IS REALLY IMPORTANT.
03:04:19.181 --> 03:04:22.851
AND AS I WAS, UM, SPEAKING WITH
03:04:22.918 --> 03:04:24.019
EVERYBODY ABOUT THE BILL, IT
03:04:24.086 --> 03:04:25.921
WASN'T CLEAR TO ME EXACTLY WHERE
03:04:25.988 --> 03:04:30.359
THE EXACTLY EXACTLY WHAT THE
03:04:30.426 --> 03:04:31.960
CHANGES ARE THAT NEEDED TO BE
03:04:32.027 --> 03:04:33.562
MADE THAT WOULD ALLOW THE
03:04:33.629 --> 03:04:35.764
PROGRAM TO CONTINUE, BUT ALSO,
03:04:35.831 --> 03:04:39.768
UM, UM, MAKE SURE THAT UM, THAT
03:04:39.835 --> 03:04:41.069
THE GOALS ARE MET THAT THE
03:04:41.136 --> 03:04:43.138
PROGRAM WAS SET UP OR DESIGNED
03:04:43.205 --> 03:04:46.508
TO AH, TO PROVIDE AND SO, UM,
03:04:46.575 --> 03:04:49.044
I'M NOT IN A POSITION TO BE ABLE
03:04:49.111 --> 03:04:50.979
TO SUPPORT IT TODAY. AND SO I,
03:04:51.046 --> 03:04:52.981
UH, I JUST, UH APPRECIATE YOUR
03:04:53.048 --> 03:04:54.349
HARD WORK ON IT AND APPRECIATE
03:04:54.416 --> 03:04:56.151
YOUR COMMUNICATION WITH THE
03:04:56.218 --> 03:05:00.022
COMMITTEE AND, UM, STAFF. BUT
03:05:00.088 --> 03:05:02.124
WHEN? WHENEVER THERE ARE TWO
03:05:02.191 --> 03:05:03.292
SIDES THAT ARE ABSOLUTELY
03:05:03.358 --> 03:05:07.596
OPPOSED AND. AND THERE'S A SWEET
03:05:07.663 --> 03:05:09.131
SPOT IN THE MIDDLE. IT'S
03:05:09.198 --> 03:05:10.632
IMPORTANT TO ME TO UNDERSTAND
03:05:10.699 --> 03:05:12.868
WHERE THAT SWEET SPOT IS, AND I
03:05:12.935 --> 03:05:13.769
COULDN'T I COULDN'T GET THERE AT
03:05:13.836 --> 03:05:15.504
ALL, TO BE ABLE TO HELP TO
03:05:15.571 --> 03:05:16.738
FIGURE OUT HOW TO MAKE IT MAKE
03:05:16.805 --> 03:05:18.507
IT BETTER SO HOPEFULLY HOPEFULLY
03:05:18.574 --> 03:05:20.175
YOU FOUND IT AND IN YOUR
03:05:20.242 --> 03:05:22.311
CONTINUED DISCUSSIONS WITH THE
03:05:22.377 --> 03:05:24.112
OPPOSITION, THERE'S A PLACE FOR
03:05:24.179 --> 03:05:26.114
THAT. BUT RIGHT NOW, IN TERMS OF
03:05:26.181 --> 03:05:32.054
BOTH BOTH SIDES SITE. ERECT
03:05:32.120 --> 03:05:33.889
IRREPARABLE DAMAGE. AND WHENEVER
03:05:33.956 --> 03:05:35.691
THAT'S THE CASE, THEN IT IS IT
03:05:35.757 --> 03:05:37.359
IS. IT BEHOOVES US TO LOOK
03:05:37.426 --> 03:05:39.194
TOWARDS THE MIDDLE, AND LIKE I
03:05:39.261 --> 03:05:39.795
SAID, I'M NOT SURE WHERE THAT
03:05:39.862 --> 03:05:41.597
IS, SO APPRECIATE IT. ANY OTHER
03:05:41.663 --> 03:05:44.733
COMMENTS. I'M ALLOWING YOU TO
03:05:44.800 --> 03:05:45.667
CONCLUDE. THANK YOU, MADAM
03:05:45.734 --> 03:05:47.236
CHAIR, APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS.
03:05:47.302 --> 03:05:47.970
I APPRECIATE ALL THE DISCUSSION
03:05:48.036 --> 03:05:49.705
HERE TODAY. THANK YOU, SENATOR
03:05:49.771 --> 03:05:52.407
WIENER AS WELL FOR RECAPPED,
03:05:52.474 --> 03:05:53.876
RECAPTURING WHAT WE HAD TALKED
03:05:53.942 --> 03:05:55.143
ABOUT IT AND HOUSING COMMITTEE
03:05:55.210 --> 03:05:57.479
AS WELL. UM, I'LL JUST MAYBE
03:05:57.546 --> 03:05:59.748
CLARIFY AND BUILD OFF OF ONE OF
03:05:59.815 --> 03:06:00.649
YOUR COMMENTS THAT THIS PROGRAM
03:06:00.716 --> 03:06:02.584
IT'S NOT THAT IT CAN HAVE REAL
03:06:02.651 --> 03:06:04.353
BENEFITS THAT IS HAVING REAL
03:06:04.419 --> 03:06:05.254
BENEFITS. THERE ARE EXISTING
03:06:05.320 --> 03:06:06.755
PROJECTS RIGHT NOW. THAT WERE
03:06:06.822 --> 03:06:08.323
THEY BUILT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF
03:06:08.390 --> 03:06:10.726
18 50 GUIDELINES WOULD ACTUALLY
03:06:10.792 --> 03:06:14.263
BE, UM, ALIVE AND WELL TODAY, UM
03:06:14.329 --> 03:06:15.564
, BUT THERE HAVE BEEN INSTANCES
03:06:15.631 --> 03:06:17.332
AND THE REASON THIS CAME BEFORE
03:06:17.399 --> 03:06:18.333
US FOR CONSIDERATION FOR
03:06:18.400 --> 03:06:19.301
LEGISLATION. IS BECAUSE THE
03:06:19.368 --> 03:06:21.670
ABUSE BY SOME FOR PROFIT
03:06:21.737 --> 03:06:23.138
DEVELOPERS HAS EXTRACTED
03:06:23.205 --> 03:06:24.306
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF
03:06:24.373 --> 03:06:26.141
ADMINISTRATIVE FEES HAS NOT
03:06:26.208 --> 03:06:27.576
DELIVERED ON THE MIDDLE INCOME
03:06:27.643 --> 03:06:29.878
HOUSING THAT THEY PROMISED CITY
03:06:29.945 --> 03:06:31.380
COUNCIL MEMBERS. LOCAL CITY
03:06:31.446 --> 03:06:31.980
COUNCIL MEMBERS, SMALL CITIES
03:06:32.047 --> 03:06:35.751
WITH MAYBE, UM LESSER THAN
03:06:35.817 --> 03:06:37.185
AVERAGE. I'M CITY OF SAN DIEGO.
03:06:37.252 --> 03:06:39.254
WE'VE GOT STAFF. WE'VE GOT GREAT
03:06:39.321 --> 03:06:41.023
CITY ATTORNEYS AS WELL. THEY CAN
03:06:41.089 --> 03:06:42.558
REALLY VET THIS AND SOMETIMES
03:06:42.624 --> 03:06:44.693
CITIES HAVE BEEN SNOOKERED INTO
03:06:44.760 --> 03:06:45.794
DEALS THAT IS NOT DELIVERING ON
03:06:45.861 --> 03:06:47.162
WHAT THEIR PROMISED. MEANWHILE,
03:06:47.229 --> 03:06:47.996
THEY'RE LEFT HOLDING THE BAG
03:06:48.063 --> 03:06:49.064
PROPERTY THAT THEY CAN'T
03:06:49.131 --> 03:06:51.533
ACTUALLY DEDICATE. TOWARDS
03:06:51.600 --> 03:06:53.068
MIDDLE INCOME GRANTS BECAUSE IT
03:06:53.135 --> 03:06:53.835
WON'T PENCIL OUT ANYMORE AND
03:06:53.902 --> 03:06:55.370
THEY'RE NOT GETTING THE PROPERTY
03:06:55.437 --> 03:06:56.939
TAX REVENUE BECAUSE THEY HAD
03:06:57.005 --> 03:06:58.440
ALREADY SEEN INK THE DEAL AND
03:06:58.507 --> 03:06:59.875
GONE AWAY WITH THAT PROPERTY TAX
03:06:59.942 --> 03:07:02.177
BASE AS WELL. SO UM, WE BELIEVE
03:07:02.244 --> 03:07:03.545
THAT TURNER CENTER AND SPURS
03:07:03.612 --> 03:07:05.080
REPORT THAT CAME OUT THIS WEEK
03:07:05.147 --> 03:07:07.182
DOES UNDERSCORE BOTH THE NEED
03:07:07.249 --> 03:07:08.850
FOR THE GUARDRAILS BUT AS WELL
03:07:08.917 --> 03:07:09.818
THE TESTIMONY HERE TODAY FROM
03:07:09.885 --> 03:07:11.820
SOME OF THOSE SAME FOR PROFIT
03:07:11.887 --> 03:07:12.921
DEVELOPERS THAT DO BELIEVE THAT
03:07:12.988 --> 03:07:14.122
THEY CAN MAKE EVERYTHING PENCIL
03:07:14.189 --> 03:07:15.624
OUT. I THINK PROVIDES THAT SWEET
03:07:15.691 --> 03:07:17.025
SPOT AND THAT GUARANTEE THAT
03:07:17.092 --> 03:07:18.660
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT'S REALLY
03:07:18.727 --> 03:07:19.995
HELPFUL. SO I APPRECIATE OUR
03:07:20.062 --> 03:07:21.430
ONGOING CONVERSATION THAT THIS
03:07:21.496 --> 03:07:22.931
DOES HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE
03:07:22.998 --> 03:07:24.700
IT OUT OF COMMITTEE HERE TODAY
03:07:24.766 --> 03:07:26.001
AND FURTHER WORK ON AS IT, UH,
03:07:26.068 --> 03:07:27.769
THAT WILL HAVE OTHER BOATS TO
03:07:27.836 --> 03:07:29.471
COME IN THE SENATE. I LOOK
03:07:29.538 --> 03:07:30.806
FORWARD TO BEING ABLE TO WORK ON
03:07:30.872 --> 03:07:32.708
THAT. WELL, BECAUSE WE WANT TO
03:07:32.774 --> 03:07:34.876
BE ABLE TO GET THIS RIGHT. IT
03:07:34.943 --> 03:07:35.711
DOES PRESERVE AND ESPECIALLY NOT
03:07:35.777 --> 03:07:37.479
ONLY PRESERVES LOCAL CONTROL BUT
03:07:37.546 --> 03:07:38.580
IS ABLE TO HELP ASSIST LOCAL
03:07:38.647 --> 03:07:39.648
GOVERNMENTS TO MY EARLIER POINT.
03:07:39.715 --> 03:07:41.683
I WOULD NEVER BE ABLE TO AFFORD
03:07:41.750 --> 03:07:42.918
ON A BILL THAT IS GOING TO
03:07:42.985 --> 03:07:44.753
AFFECT PRODUCTION. WE WANT TO
03:07:44.820 --> 03:07:45.921
MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE ALL TOOLS
03:07:45.988 --> 03:07:48.290
IN OUR TOOLBOX AND ALL HOUSING
03:07:48.357 --> 03:07:49.358
OPPORTUNITIES. BUT THIS IS
03:07:49.424 --> 03:07:50.525
ALREADY SOMETHING THAT IS GOING
03:07:50.592 --> 03:07:52.394
TO BE ABLE TO HELP EXISTING
03:07:52.461 --> 03:07:53.295
HOUSING HOUSING STOCK. LUXURY
03:07:53.362 --> 03:07:54.763
HOUSING STOCK THAT WE ARE TRYING
03:07:54.830 --> 03:07:56.231
TO TRANSFORM INTO MIDDLE INCOME
03:07:56.298 --> 03:07:57.966
HOUSING. UM SO WITH THAT I
03:07:58.033 --> 03:07:59.334
APPRECIATE ALL THE COMMENTS HERE
03:07:59.401 --> 03:08:00.535
TODAY AND YOUR AND YOUR WISE
03:08:00.602 --> 03:08:01.670
ADVICE AND WOULD RESPECTFULLY
03:08:01.737 --> 03:08:02.771
REQUEST THE COMMITTEE'S I VOTE.
03:08:02.838 --> 03:08:08.343
QUÊ PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MOTION
03:08:08.410 --> 03:08:09.811
IS TO PASS TO THE SENATE FLOOR.
03:08:09.878 --> 03:08:14.249
SENATORS CABALLERO ONO NILSSON
03:08:14.316 --> 03:08:16.051
NILSSON, NO, DURAZO, HERZBERG
03:08:16.118 --> 03:08:23.659
WIENER. HI, WIENER. I 222. WE
03:08:23.725 --> 03:08:25.360
WILL LEAVE THAT ON CALL FOR THE
03:08:25.427 --> 03:08:27.129
ABSENT MEMBER. THANK YOU. THANK
03:08:27.195 --> 03:08:29.631
YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
03:08:29.698 --> 03:08:32.701
ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER 15. WHICH
03:08:32.768 --> 03:08:35.237
IS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEE'S BILL.
03:08:35.303 --> 03:08:39.908
A B 2053. THANK YOU, MADAM
03:08:39.975 --> 03:08:41.209
CHAIR. I HAVE TWO BILLS, SO I'LL
03:08:41.276 --> 03:08:42.944
START WITH THE ASSEMBLY BILL
03:08:43.011 --> 03:08:44.813
2053. AH BEFORE YOU TODAY I'M
03:08:44.880 --> 03:08:46.281
PRESENTING THIS SOCIAL HOUSING
03:08:46.348 --> 03:08:48.517
ACT OF CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL
03:08:48.583 --> 03:08:50.252
WILL ENABLE US TO HAVE A NEW
03:08:50.318 --> 03:08:51.820
TOOL IN TOOLBOX OF PRESERVING
03:08:51.887 --> 03:08:52.821
AND PRODUCING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:08:52.888 --> 03:08:54.790
ACROSS CALIFORNIA. THROUGH THIS
03:08:54.856 --> 03:08:55.957
MODEL HOUSING WOULD BE
03:08:56.024 --> 03:08:57.192
AFFORDABLE FOR ALL INCOME LEVELS
03:08:57.259 --> 03:08:58.760
BE COLLECTIVELY OWNED UNION
03:08:58.827 --> 03:09:00.262
BUILT IN FINANCIALLY SELF
03:09:00.328 --> 03:09:01.797
SUSTAINING HOUSING FOR PEOPLE
03:09:01.863 --> 03:09:03.231
WITH HIGHER INCOMES WILL CROSS
03:09:03.298 --> 03:09:04.800
SUBSIDIZE LOW INCOME UNITS, THE
03:09:04.866 --> 03:09:06.668
RENT SOLIDARITY AND ALLOWING
03:09:06.735 --> 03:09:07.736
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS TO BE
03:09:07.803 --> 03:09:08.837
REVENUE NEUTRAL OVER THE LONG
03:09:08.904 --> 03:09:10.806
TERM. THE MODEL HAS BEEN
03:09:10.872 --> 03:09:12.541
SUCCESSFUL BOTH INTERNATIONALLY
03:09:12.607 --> 03:09:13.175
AND OTHER PARTS OF THE COUNTRY
03:09:13.241 --> 03:09:14.609
FOR AS LONG AS THE U. S. IS
03:09:14.676 --> 03:09:16.845
TRYING TO CHOOSE THIS. ONE OF
03:09:16.912 --> 03:09:18.380
THE PICTURES YOU HAVE TODAY IS
03:09:18.447 --> 03:09:20.782
OF ALL AIRLINES IN VIENNA,
03:09:20.849 --> 03:09:22.984
AUSTRIA. 60% OF VIENNA'S
03:09:23.051 --> 03:09:24.519
RESIDENTS LIVE IN SOCIAL HOUSING
03:09:24.586 --> 03:09:26.555
AND PAY AND MOST PAY 300 TO $800
03:09:26.621 --> 03:09:30.292
PER MONTH. THIS DEVELOPMENT IS
03:09:30.358 --> 03:09:32.360
IN HIGH DEMAND, AND IT IS ONE OF
03:09:32.427 --> 03:09:33.495
THE GOLD STANDARD OF SOCIAL
03:09:33.562 --> 03:09:34.162
HOUSING ACROSS THE WORLD. AND IN
03:09:34.229 --> 03:09:35.764
THE U. S MONTGOMERY, THE
03:09:35.831 --> 03:09:37.399
MONTGOMERY COUNTY HOUSING
03:09:37.466 --> 03:09:38.767
OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION, MARYLAND
03:09:38.834 --> 03:09:39.768
HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY BUILDING
03:09:39.835 --> 03:09:41.069
HOUSING INSPIRED BY SOCIAL
03:09:41.136 --> 03:09:42.771
HOUSING IN VIENNA AND ELSEWHERE
03:09:42.838 --> 03:09:44.239
. AND THIS IS THE PICTURE OF
03:09:44.306 --> 03:09:45.373
MONTGOMERY COUNTY IN MARYLAND.
03:09:45.440 --> 03:09:46.708
SO MUCH MORE TYPICAL AMERICAN
03:09:46.775 --> 03:09:50.912
DESIGN. THEY PLAN TO BUILD OVER
03:09:50.979 --> 03:09:51.680
5000 UNITS, USING A SIMILAR
03:09:51.747 --> 03:09:53.281
APPROACH TO WHAT IS PROPOSED IN
03:09:53.348 --> 03:09:54.683
THIS BILL AND CALIFORNIA OVER
03:09:54.750 --> 03:09:57.018
97% OF CITIES AND COUNTIES HAVE
03:09:57.085 --> 03:09:57.753
NOT PRODUCED ENOUGH AFFORDABLE
03:09:57.819 --> 03:09:59.087
HOUSING, AND MANY CALIFORNIANS,
03:09:59.154 --> 03:10:01.289
OF COURSE, ARE BURDENED BY
03:10:01.356 --> 03:10:02.390
HOUSING COSTS OF 15 SPENDING
03:10:02.457 --> 03:10:03.492
OVER HALF OF THEIR INCOME ON
03:10:03.558 --> 03:10:04.826
HOUSING. SO IT'S CLEAR THAT
03:10:04.893 --> 03:10:05.660
CALIFORNIA NEEDS ADDITIONAL
03:10:05.727 --> 03:10:07.229
TOOLS TO HELP SOLVE THE HOUSING
03:10:07.295 --> 03:10:08.730
SHORTAGE AND SOCIAL HOUSING IS A
03:10:08.797 --> 03:10:10.799
CRITICAL MISSING PIECE. I'VE
03:10:10.866 --> 03:10:12.200
HEARD UP AND DOWN THE STATE FROM
03:10:12.267 --> 03:10:13.835
LOCAL ELECTED SO WHETHER THEY BE
03:10:13.902 --> 03:10:14.836
SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS, CANCER
03:10:14.903 --> 03:10:15.804
VISORS OR CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
03:10:15.871 --> 03:10:17.739
IS THEY WANT TO DO THEIR PART TO
03:10:17.806 --> 03:10:19.474
SOLVE THE HOUSING CRISIS. BUT
03:10:19.541 --> 03:10:21.276
THE STATE RIGHT NOW REALLY
03:10:21.343 --> 03:10:21.877
ENGAGES ONLY INTO ACTIVITIES.
03:10:21.943 --> 03:10:23.044
THERE ARE REGULATORS OR THEIR
03:10:23.111 --> 03:10:25.914
MONEY. WHAT THIS BILL ENABLES US
03:10:25.981 --> 03:10:27.048
TO DO IS CREATE THE FOUNDATION
03:10:27.115 --> 03:10:28.917
TO BE A PUBLIC DEVELOPED TO
03:10:28.984 --> 03:10:29.918
CREATE THE HOUSING OURSELVES,
03:10:29.985 --> 03:10:31.953
AND NOT ONLY TO SIMPLY RELY ON
03:10:32.020 --> 03:10:33.288
THE FOR PROFIT DEVELOPMENT
03:10:33.355 --> 03:10:35.090
SECTOR SO WELL TODAY I'LL BE
03:10:35.157 --> 03:10:36.458
RESPECTFULLY ASKING HER I VOTE,
03:10:36.525 --> 03:10:37.826
BUT WITH ME TESTIFYING SUPPORT
03:10:37.893 --> 03:10:38.927
WILL BE SCOTT, WHICH WAS
03:10:38.994 --> 03:10:39.861
REPRESENTATIVE CALIFORNIA STATE
03:10:39.928 --> 03:10:40.762
ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL
03:10:40.829 --> 03:10:41.763
WORKERS. THE CALIFORNIA STATE
03:10:41.830 --> 03:10:43.265
PIPE TRADES COUNCIL, THE WESTERN
03:10:43.331 --> 03:10:44.666
STATES COUNCIL OF SHEET METAL
03:10:44.733 --> 03:10:46.234
WORKERS AND A COALITION OF
03:10:46.301 --> 03:10:47.669
CALIFORNIA OF UTILITY EMPLOYEES
03:10:47.736 --> 03:10:49.271
IN PERSON AND DAVID BARBOSA.
03:10:49.337 --> 03:10:50.405
PROPOSE A FROM ABUNDANT HOUSING
03:10:50.472 --> 03:10:53.975
L A WILL BE ON THE PHONE. GOOD
03:10:54.042 --> 03:10:56.044
MORNING. GOOD AFTERNOON. WE'VE
03:10:56.111 --> 03:10:58.313
SHIFTED, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
03:10:58.380 --> 03:10:59.281
YES. SCOTT WEST ON BEHALF OF ALL
03:10:59.347 --> 03:11:01.116
THE GROUPS THAT THE AUTHOR JUST
03:11:01.183 --> 03:11:02.050
MENTIONED. UM WE SUPPORT THIS
03:11:02.117 --> 03:11:03.952
BILL FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS.
03:11:04.019 --> 03:11:06.254
FIRST. WE NEED TO MOVE THE BALL
03:11:06.321 --> 03:11:09.758
ON HOUSING. SECONDLY UM, WE
03:11:09.825 --> 03:11:10.725
SUPPORT THE BILL WITH THE
03:11:10.792 --> 03:11:11.927
SKILLED AND TRAINED LANGUAGE
03:11:11.993 --> 03:11:12.994
WITH THE INCLUSION OF TWO BITTER
03:11:13.061 --> 03:11:17.232
REQUIREMENT. FOR A NUMBER OF
03:11:17.299 --> 03:11:19.301
REASONS. ONE LEADERSHIP AND THE
03:11:19.367 --> 03:11:21.770
ADMINISTRATION HAS EXPRESSED
03:11:21.837 --> 03:11:23.939
THAT WITH SKILLED AND TRAINED,
03:11:24.005 --> 03:11:25.273
WANTING TO HAVE SOME INSURE
03:11:25.340 --> 03:11:26.608
ASSURANCES THAT THERE'LL BE A
03:11:26.675 --> 03:11:29.444
ROBUST CONTRACTOR POOL. FOR
03:11:29.511 --> 03:11:30.579
PROJECTS THAT ARE COVERED BY
03:11:30.645 --> 03:11:35.016
SKILLED AND TRAIN. SECONDLY, WE
03:11:35.083 --> 03:11:36.151
HAVE BITTER LANGUAGE, THREE
03:11:36.218 --> 03:11:40.121
BITTER LANGUAGE. IN COUNTLESS
03:11:40.188 --> 03:11:41.223
PROJECT LABOR AGREEMENTS IN L.
03:11:41.289 --> 03:11:44.759
A. 30 DIFFERENT PROJECT LABOR
03:11:44.826 --> 03:11:46.127
AGREEMENTS. IT WOULD BE
03:11:46.194 --> 03:11:47.829
DISINGENUOUS FOR ME TO STAND
03:11:47.896 --> 03:11:49.431
HERE AND OPPOSED TO BITTER
03:11:49.497 --> 03:11:50.765
LANGUAGE WHEN WE HAVE
03:11:50.832 --> 03:11:52.033
INCORPORATED THAT INTO OUR VERY
03:11:52.100 --> 03:11:53.168
OWN COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
03:11:53.235 --> 03:11:55.837
AGREEMENTS, AND THEN LASTLY, AH
03:11:55.904 --> 03:11:58.773
, MY UNIONS AND MY BELIEVE THAT
03:11:58.840 --> 03:12:01.810
IF THE PROJECT COMES ALONG, AND
03:12:01.877 --> 03:12:03.812
THEY CAN'T GUARD AND THEY CAN'T
03:12:03.879 --> 03:12:05.747
GARNER THE INTEREST OF AT LEAST
03:12:05.814 --> 03:12:09.384
TWO REPUTABLE QUALIFIED BIDDERS
03:12:09.451 --> 03:12:10.852
TO BID ON A PROJECT AND WE
03:12:10.919 --> 03:12:12.787
SHOULDN'T BE DOING THE WORK. AND
03:12:12.854 --> 03:12:13.955
FOR ALL THOSE REASONS, WE THINK
03:12:14.022 --> 03:12:16.024
THAT THIS IS A VERY REASONABLE
03:12:16.091 --> 03:12:18.293
AND RESPONSIBLE APPROACH. AND
03:12:18.360 --> 03:12:19.861
WOULD URGE YOUR I VOTE. THANK
03:12:19.928 --> 03:12:21.763
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE
03:12:21.830 --> 03:12:24.466
HAVE A LEAD SUPPORT WITNESS ON
03:12:24.532 --> 03:12:25.066
THE PHONE DAVID BARBOSA FROM
03:12:25.133 --> 03:12:32.374
ABUNDANT HOUSING L A. THE FLOOR
03:12:32.440 --> 03:12:37.012
IS YOURS. CHECK. GET AFTERNOON
03:12:37.078 --> 03:12:38.313
CHAIR COUPLE OF YOUR OWN MEMBERS
03:12:38.380 --> 03:12:39.481
OF THE SENATE GOVERNANCE OF
03:12:39.547 --> 03:12:41.216
FINANCE COMMITTEE. HOW CAN THE
03:12:41.283 --> 03:12:42.651
STATE ENSURE THAT ENOUGH HOUSING
03:12:42.717 --> 03:12:44.119
IS BUILT EVERY AFFORDABILITY
03:12:44.185 --> 03:12:45.687
LEVEL AND GUARANTEE PERMANENT
03:12:45.754 --> 03:12:47.122
AFFORDABILITY OF THOSE BADLY
03:12:47.188 --> 03:12:49.524
NEEDED HOMES? I'M DAVID BARBOZA
03:12:49.591 --> 03:12:50.725
, DIRECTOR OF POLICY AND
03:12:50.792 --> 03:12:52.560
RESEARCH FOR ABUNDANT HOUSING LÀ
03:12:52.627 --> 03:12:54.162
, AND WE'RE PROUD TO SUPPORT A B
03:12:54.229 --> 03:12:57.766
2053 SOCIAL HOUSING. FORMED THE
03:12:57.832 --> 03:13:00.001
CALIFORNIA HOUSING AUTHORITY OR
03:13:00.068 --> 03:13:01.136
TO CREATE SOCIAL HOUSING BASED
03:13:01.202 --> 03:13:02.370
ON SUCCESSFUL GLOBAL MODELS.
03:13:02.437 --> 03:13:03.438
THROUGH NEW CONSTRUCTION AND
03:13:03.505 --> 03:13:06.408
ACQUISITION. THE HOUSING
03:13:06.474 --> 03:13:08.510
SHORTAGE IS CAUSING OUR HOUSING
03:13:08.576 --> 03:13:10.946
COSTS ARISE THE PAINFUL LEVELS
03:13:11.012 --> 03:13:13.348
AND YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE GREAT
03:13:13.415 --> 03:13:14.649
THINGS ABOUT THIS BILLS WOULD
03:13:14.716 --> 03:13:15.483
PRODUCE HOUSING AT A RANGE OF
03:13:15.550 --> 03:13:16.551
AFFORDABILITY. AFFORDABILITY
03:13:16.618 --> 03:13:18.320
LEVELS TO UNDO PATTERNS OF
03:13:18.386 --> 03:13:20.488
SEGREGATION. IT WOULD ALSO
03:13:20.555 --> 03:13:21.990
PROVIDE FOR PERMANENT
03:13:22.057 --> 03:13:23.491
AFFORDABILITY WITH NO NEED TO
03:13:23.558 --> 03:13:25.427
RENEW EXPIRING AFFORDABILITY
03:13:25.493 --> 03:13:26.561
COVENANTS JUST AN ISSUE LOCAL
03:13:26.628 --> 03:13:27.829
GOVERNMENTS OFTEN STRUGGLE WITH
03:13:27.896 --> 03:13:29.731
ASSUMING THEY HAVE MONEY TO DO
03:13:29.798 --> 03:13:32.701
THAT, WITH RESIDENTS WOULD ALSO
03:13:32.767 --> 03:13:34.636
HAVE A RIGHT TO BE INVOLVED IN
03:13:34.703 --> 03:13:36.071
THE MANAGEMENT OF THEIR HOUSING.
03:13:36.137 --> 03:13:38.139
THE BILL USE OF CROSS SUBSIDIZE
03:13:38.206 --> 03:13:40.141
CROSS SUBSIDIES, SO ON
03:13:40.208 --> 03:13:42.043
SUBSIDIZED CAN HELP PAY FOR THE
03:13:42.110 --> 03:13:44.779
AFFORDABLE HOMES. AND WELL, IT
03:13:44.846 --> 03:13:46.314
HAS REVENUE NEUTRALITY OF THE
03:13:46.381 --> 03:13:48.717
GOAL. IT ALSO PRESERVES THE
03:13:48.783 --> 03:13:50.318
FLEXIBILITY FOR THE STATE TO
03:13:50.385 --> 03:13:50.852
INJECT SUBSIDIES INTO THE
03:13:50.919 --> 03:13:55.023
PROGRAM TO CELEBRATE PROGRESS.
03:13:55.090 --> 03:13:56.458
TO ENSURE THAT MORE AFFORDABLE
03:13:56.524 --> 03:13:57.492
HOMES ARE BUILT AT PEOPLE,
03:13:57.559 --> 03:13:59.761
DEEPER LEVELS OF AFFORDABILITY.
03:13:59.828 --> 03:14:01.262
THE FLEXIBLE FINANCING ALSO
03:14:01.329 --> 03:14:02.697
HELPS ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF
03:14:02.764 --> 03:14:04.232
PROPERTY MAINTENANCE, AND WE'RE
03:14:04.299 --> 03:14:05.800
HAPPY TO SEE THAT, UM, YOU KNOW
03:14:05.867 --> 03:14:07.402
CONCERNS AROUND GENTRIFICATION
03:14:07.469 --> 03:14:08.036
OR ADDRESSED REQUIREMENT FOR AN
03:14:08.103 --> 03:14:12.007
ANNUAL REPORT. OAN PUBLIC INPUT
03:14:12.073 --> 03:14:13.708
, WHICH WOULD FEED INTO THE
03:14:13.775 --> 03:14:15.677
AGENCY'S PLANNING. AND THE
03:14:15.744 --> 03:14:16.711
CLOTHES. YOU KNOW, WE THINK THAT
03:14:16.778 --> 03:14:18.780
HOUSING IS A HUMAN RIGHT AND THE
03:14:18.847 --> 03:14:20.648
PUBLIC SECTOR REALLY HAS TO DO
03:14:20.715 --> 03:14:22.317
MORE. THAN JUST CREATE THE
03:14:22.384 --> 03:14:24.019
CONDITIONS FOR HOUSING TO BE
03:14:24.085 --> 03:14:26.187
BUILT AND FUNDING. WHAT IS
03:14:26.254 --> 03:14:27.756
IMPORTANT AS THOSE THINGS ARE.
03:14:27.822 --> 03:14:29.124
WE THINK THE PUBLIC SECTOR ALSO
03:14:29.190 --> 03:14:31.126
HAS TO GET INVOLVED IN
03:14:31.192 --> 03:14:32.727
CONSTRUCTION AS WELL. SO WITH
03:14:32.794 --> 03:14:33.862
THAT. THANK YOU, AND WE
03:14:33.928 --> 03:14:36.398
RESPECTFULLY URGE AND I VOTE.
03:14:36.464 --> 03:14:37.832
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NOW WE'RE
03:14:37.899 --> 03:14:40.235
GOING TO MOVE ON TO MEMBERS OF
03:14:40.301 --> 03:14:41.770
THE PUBLIC HERE IN THE ROOM THAT
03:14:41.836 --> 03:14:43.438
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY AND
03:14:43.505 --> 03:14:44.639
SUPPORT WOULD LIKE TO INVITE YOU
03:14:44.706 --> 03:14:45.774
TO PLEASE COME FORWARD STATE
03:14:45.840 --> 03:14:47.876
YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD. GOOD
03:14:47.942 --> 03:14:49.411
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
03:14:49.477 --> 03:14:50.478
MEMBERS, DEBORAH CARLSON WITH
03:14:50.545 --> 03:14:51.379
THE CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
03:14:51.446 --> 03:14:56.151
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT.MADAM
03:14:56.217 --> 03:14:57.752
CHAIR MEMBERS RANT MARTIN ON
03:14:57.819 --> 03:14:59.154
BEHALF OF THE AIDS HEALTHCARE
03:14:59.220 --> 03:15:00.321
FOUNDATION, WHOSE HEALTHY
03:15:00.388 --> 03:15:01.456
HOUSING FOUNDATION IS ALREADY
03:15:01.523 --> 03:15:03.291
DEVELOPED MORE THAN 1400
03:15:03.358 --> 03:15:04.893
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS IN LOS
03:15:04.959 --> 03:15:07.328
ANGELES FOR EXTREMELY AND VERY
03:15:07.395 --> 03:15:07.962
LOW INCOME WERE VERY STRONGLY IN
03:15:08.029 --> 03:15:12.667
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
03:15:12.734 --> 03:15:13.835
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
03:15:13.902 --> 03:15:14.769
COMMITTEE. JORDAN'S BANANA
03:15:14.836 --> 03:15:15.970
CARVAJAL ON BEHALF OF COLOR FOR,
03:15:16.037 --> 03:15:17.872
UM, BE PROUD CON SPONSOR IN
03:15:17.939 --> 03:15:19.808
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY
03:15:19.874 --> 03:15:21.676
MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE IN
03:15:21.743 --> 03:15:24.345
ROOM 2100? SEEING THEN WE'LL
03:15:24.412 --> 03:15:25.747
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
03:15:25.814 --> 03:15:26.948
LINE. AND MR MODERATOR IF YOU
03:15:27.015 --> 03:15:32.821
COULD T UP MEMBERS IN SUPPORT.
03:15:32.887 --> 03:15:34.155
CERTAINLY AND IF THEY'D LIKE TO
03:15:34.222 --> 03:15:36.057
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 2053
03:15:36.124 --> 03:15:38.960
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND WE'LL GO TO
03:15:39.027 --> 03:15:42.630
LINE 4 39, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:15:42.697 --> 03:15:44.766
HELLO MY NAME IS JOSHUA HAKKEN,
03:15:44.833 --> 03:15:45.333
REPRESENTING COMMON GROUND,
03:15:45.400 --> 03:15:46.634
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT OF 80
03:15:46.701 --> 03:15:51.940
2053. THANK YOU. NEXT GO TO LYON
03:15:52.006 --> 03:15:55.243
AT 1 23. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI.
03:15:55.310 --> 03:15:56.811
THIS IS AN WILLIAM BEHALF OF
03:15:56.878 --> 03:15:57.912
SIERRA CLUB, CALIFORNIA IN
03:15:57.979 --> 03:16:02.083
SUPPORT OF 2053. LINE 4 37,
03:16:02.150 --> 03:16:07.422
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO. THIS IS
03:16:07.489 --> 03:16:09.324
JOHN MADE IT WITH THE STAY FOR
03:16:09.390 --> 03:16:10.425
EVERYONE. WE ARE IN FERVENT
03:16:10.492 --> 03:16:13.094
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 2 90,
03:16:13.161 --> 03:16:18.366
PLEASE GO AHEAD. ADAM BOOK
03:16:18.433 --> 03:16:19.868
FIGHTER FROM CAMPBELL AND CENSUS
03:16:19.934 --> 03:16:21.836
15 FOR SELF FAGAN B AND SUNRISE
03:16:21.903 --> 03:16:23.705
SILICON VALLEY AND SUPPORT OF A
03:16:23.771 --> 03:16:26.908
B 2053. THANK YOU. LINE 4 76,
03:16:26.975 --> 03:16:31.546
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
03:16:31.613 --> 03:16:34.048
ROBERT BROCKMAN ON BEHALF OF SAN
03:16:34.115 --> 03:16:35.183
FRANCISCO. UM, BE IN STRONG
03:16:35.250 --> 03:16:40.688
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 4 75,
03:16:40.755 --> 03:16:42.991
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS TOBY
03:16:43.057 --> 03:16:44.592
MORE SHINE A COLUMN FROM US
03:16:44.659 --> 03:16:45.927
ANGELES ON BEHALF OF WEBSITE FOR
03:16:45.994 --> 03:16:47.028
EVERYONE INSTRUCTS SUPPORT.
03:16:47.095 --> 03:16:51.199
THANK YOU. LINE 4 74, PLEASE GO
03:16:51.266 --> 03:16:57.038
AHEAD. I TOLD YOU AND STEIN FROM
03:16:57.105 --> 03:16:58.740
BERKELEY AND CMB AND PAY FOR
03:16:58.806 --> 03:17:00.341
EVERYONE IN STRONG SUPPORT.
03:17:00.408 --> 03:17:03.978
THANK YOU. LINE 4 30, PLEASE GO
03:17:04.045 --> 03:17:09.817
AHEAD. YES, THIS IS ROBINSON
03:17:09.884 --> 03:17:11.686
IMPELLED CALLING ON BEHALF OF
03:17:11.753 --> 03:17:13.688
THE SPONSOR CAN BE ACTION AND
03:17:13.755 --> 03:17:14.856
ALL ASSOCIATED CHAPTERS IN FRONT
03:17:14.923 --> 03:17:19.427
SUPPORT. LINE 1 67, PLEASE GO
03:17:19.494 --> 03:17:23.598
AHEAD. YES MY NAME IS FRANCESCA
03:17:23.665 --> 03:17:25.767
WANDER. I AM A NUMBER OF
03:17:25.833 --> 03:17:29.704
CALIFORNIA COALITION 80 PLUS
03:17:29.771 --> 03:17:32.407
INVISIBLE ORGANIZATIONS.
03:17:32.473 --> 03:17:36.311
CALIFORNIA REMEMBER MENTAL
03:17:36.377 --> 03:17:38.379
INDIVISIBILITY, YOLO AND
03:17:38.446 --> 03:17:40.448
INDIVISIBLE FRANCISCO ALL IN
03:17:40.515 --> 03:17:42.517
STRONG SYMPTOMS OF 82. OH, +53.
03:17:42.584 --> 03:17:47.455
THANK YOU. LINE 2 72, PLEASE GO
03:17:47.522 --> 03:17:52.994
AHEAD. JAKE PRICE CALLING IN ON
03:17:53.061 --> 03:17:55.129
BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
03:17:55.196 --> 03:17:56.664
COALITION IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
03:17:56.731 --> 03:18:00.835
B 2053. THANK YOU. LINE 4 71,
03:18:00.902 --> 03:18:05.306
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS LISA
03:18:05.373 --> 03:18:07.342
DANCE ON BEHALF OF FREMONT FOR
03:18:07.408 --> 03:18:11.079
EVERYONE IN SUPPORT. FLYING 4
03:18:11.145 --> 03:18:14.382
92, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES. HELLO.
03:18:14.449 --> 03:18:18.219
MY NAME IS SARAH. AND I'M A
03:18:18.286 --> 03:18:20.288
MEMBER OF PEACE. THEY, UM BE
03:18:20.355 --> 03:18:21.956
CHAPTER OF THE N B ACTION IN
03:18:22.023 --> 03:18:23.491
STRONG SUPPORT OF 2053. THANK
03:18:23.558 --> 03:18:28.796
YOU. LINE FOR 88, PLEASE GO
03:18:28.863 --> 03:18:34.902
AHEAD. MORE THAN OTHER KHALID
03:18:34.969 --> 03:18:37.538
WITHIN EAST BAY AND BE STRONG
03:18:37.605 --> 03:18:42.644
SUPPORT. VB 053. THANK YOU. LINE
03:18:42.710 --> 03:18:45.480
2 70, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES.
03:18:45.546 --> 03:18:46.581
THANK YOU. OPERATOR. THANK YOU.
03:18:46.648 --> 03:18:50.418
CHAIR. I'M RIGHT ON BEHALF OF
03:18:50.485 --> 03:18:52.020
CHANGE BEGINS WITH ME. WE'RE
03:18:52.086 --> 03:18:53.054
INSTRUCT SUPPORT AND A B 2053.
03:18:53.121 --> 03:18:57.792
THANK YOU. FLYING 96, PLEASE GO
03:18:57.859 --> 03:19:03.298
AHEAD. CALIFORNIA, INDIA AND
03:19:03.364 --> 03:19:04.299
INDIVISIBLE, STRONG STATE IN
03:19:04.365 --> 03:19:09.237
STRONG SUPPORT. BLIND FOR 48
03:19:09.304 --> 03:19:14.642
448, PLEASE GO AHEAD. COMMITTEE
03:19:14.709 --> 03:19:16.344
AND CHAIR. MY NAME IS VINCENT
03:19:16.411 --> 03:19:17.845
CASTELLANA ON BEHALF OF THE
03:19:17.912 --> 03:19:18.946
AMERICAN FEDERATION FOR STATE,
03:19:19.013 --> 03:19:21.115
COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES.
03:19:21.182 --> 03:19:23.818
WE JOIN IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
03:19:23.885 --> 03:19:28.890
BILL 2053. LINE. 12, PLEASE GO
03:19:28.956 --> 03:19:34.228
AHEAD. HEY THIS IS CARL KELLEY.
03:19:34.295 --> 03:19:35.330
WITH REALLY SANTA CRUZ CALLING
03:19:35.396 --> 03:19:38.099
AND STRONG SUPPORT. LINE 4 90,
03:19:38.166 --> 03:19:42.303
PLEASE GO AHEAD. WARREN WELLS,
03:19:42.370 --> 03:19:47.542
BERKELEY RENTER AND SUPPORT.
03:19:47.608 --> 03:19:51.879
LINE 4 81, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:19:51.946 --> 03:19:53.648
DAVID WATSON, A MEMBER OF
03:19:53.715 --> 03:19:54.716
MOUNTAIN VIEW, UM, BE IN
03:19:54.782 --> 03:20:05.827
SUPPORT. AND GO TO LINE FOR 80.
03:20:05.893 --> 03:20:09.364
PLEASE GO AHEAD. SYSTEMS YEAH.
03:20:09.430 --> 03:20:10.898
FAGAN THE BERGRIN INSTITUTE IN
03:20:10.965 --> 03:20:16.804
STRONG SUPPORT. WE'LL GO TO LINE
03:20:16.871 --> 03:20:21.342
FOR 79, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS
03:20:21.409 --> 03:20:23.644
IS ADRIANA RIZZO FROM COMMON
03:20:23.711 --> 03:20:25.046
GROUND, CALIFORNIA AND RIVERSIDE
03:20:25.113 --> 03:20:30.651
RENTER AND STRONG IMPORTANCE.
03:20:30.718 --> 03:20:36.023
LINE 4 78, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:20:36.090 --> 03:20:37.625
JOHNSON A RENTER IN OAKLAND,
03:20:37.692 --> 03:20:42.563
STRONGLY SUPPORTED. LINE 4 77,
03:20:42.630 --> 03:20:48.836
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MAZEL. I'M IN
03:20:48.903 --> 03:20:49.971
OAKLAND, AND I'M CALLING AND
03:20:50.037 --> 03:20:54.208
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE 4 83,
03:20:54.275 --> 03:20:59.514
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:20:59.580 --> 03:21:00.982
. HENRY HOOKER REPRESENTING
03:21:01.048 --> 03:21:01.916
SANTA CRUZ. UM, BE STRONG
03:21:01.983 --> 03:21:07.321
SUPPORT. LINE 1 77, PLEASE GO
03:21:07.388 --> 03:21:12.393
AHEAD. CHEN WARREN WITH MULTI
03:21:12.460 --> 03:21:14.495
FACE ACTION COALITION TO COUNTY
03:21:14.562 --> 03:21:19.834
SUPPORT. LINE FOR 84, PLEASE GO
03:21:19.901 --> 03:21:26.240
AHEAD. QUÊ MY NAME IS SHANE
03:21:26.307 --> 03:21:26.874
LABOR CALLING FROM SAN DIEGO.
03:21:26.941 --> 03:21:30.978
UM, BE URGING STRONG SUPPORT.
03:21:31.045 --> 03:21:37.385
LINE FOUR. 55, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:21:37.452 --> 03:21:38.886
HELLO THIS IS DAVID KING,
03:21:38.953 --> 03:21:40.822
PRESIDENT OF SENATE-DISTRICT PEN
03:21:40.888 --> 03:21:41.856
WITH COMMON GROUND, CALIFORNIA
03:21:41.923 --> 03:21:42.824
AND EVERYONE'S CALLING IN
03:21:42.890 --> 03:21:46.828
SUPPORT. FIND 4 86, PLEASE GO
03:21:46.894 --> 03:21:52.366
AHEAD. KILLERS WHO WRITE IN
03:21:52.433 --> 03:21:53.768
SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA AND
03:21:53.835 --> 03:21:54.936
INDIVIDUAL EAST PAID ONLY STRONG
03:21:55.002 --> 03:21:59.807
SUPPORT. LINE 4 85, PLEASE GO
03:21:59.874 --> 03:22:05.012
AHEAD. CLUE MY NAME IS CONNOR
03:22:05.079 --> 03:22:07.849
FINNING. I'M CALLING WITH COMMON
03:22:07.915 --> 03:22:09.517
GROUND, CALIFORNIA JUST A
03:22:09.584 --> 03:22:11.085
SACRAMENTO RENDER AND CALLING IN
03:22:11.152 --> 03:22:15.056
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. LINE FOR
03:22:15.122 --> 03:22:20.127
82, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
03:22:20.194 --> 03:22:22.230
DEREK'S H ONE FROM OAKLAND WITH
03:22:22.296 --> 03:22:23.464
FOR EVERYONE AND COMMON GROUND,
03:22:23.531 --> 03:22:27.101
CALIFORNIA CONTENT SUPPORT LINE
03:22:27.168 --> 03:22:32.206
4 67, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. THIS
03:22:32.273 --> 03:22:35.643
IS WILL GO. I'M A RENTER IN SAN
03:22:35.710 --> 03:22:36.711
FRANCISCO, AND I'M CALLING IT
03:22:36.777 --> 03:22:40.348
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE 4 72,
03:22:40.414 --> 03:22:45.853
PLEASE GO AHEAD. EVERYONE THIS
03:22:45.920 --> 03:22:47.755
IS POPAYAN. POSTGRADUATE
03:22:47.822 --> 03:22:49.757
STUDENTS FROM EVERY SIDE AND
03:22:49.824 --> 03:22:53.094
RENTER IN RIVERSIDE, CALIFORNIA
03:22:53.160 --> 03:22:58.199
FOR 2030. LINE 4 94, PLEASE GO
03:22:58.266 --> 03:23:04.539
AHEAD. I'M CALLING AS AN
03:23:04.605 --> 03:23:07.208
INDIVIDUAL, NOT A RENTER AND
03:23:07.275 --> 03:23:10.411
ALSO REPRESENTING CWW,
03:23:10.478 --> 03:23:14.448
INDIVISIBLE LOS COTTO'S AND. OH,
03:23:14.515 --> 03:23:17.018
SEE I ORCHARD CITY INDIVISIBLE
03:23:17.084 --> 03:23:18.953
IN SAN JOSE WITH STRONG STRONG
03:23:19.020 --> 03:23:24.325
SUPPORT. LINE 4 96. PLEASE GO
03:23:24.392 --> 03:23:30.665
AHEAD. HI THERE. MY NAME IS BRAD
03:23:30.731 --> 03:23:32.099
EWING. I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
03:23:32.166 --> 03:23:33.601
SANTA MONICA FORD AND COMMON
03:23:33.668 --> 03:23:34.702
GROUND. CALIFORNIA VIRGINIA TO
03:23:34.769 --> 03:23:36.304
SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANK YOU
03:23:36.370 --> 03:23:37.338
HAVE A GREAT DAY. LINE FIVE. OH,
03:23:37.405 --> 03:23:41.542
ONE, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
03:23:41.609 --> 03:23:43.844
KEVIN BURKEWITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:23:43.911 --> 03:23:44.879
ASSOCIATION OF LONGTIME
03:23:44.946 --> 03:23:45.980
LISTENERS. FIRST TIME CALLERS IN
03:23:46.047 --> 03:23:49.650
SUPPORT. WIND 500, PLEASE GO
03:23:49.717 --> 03:23:58.392
AHEAD. HI. THIS IS CAROLINE WITH
03:23:58.459 --> 03:24:00.595
CALIFORNIA, MD. AND EVERYONE
03:24:00.661 --> 03:24:05.299
VERY STRONG TO PUSH. LINE. 305,
03:24:05.366 --> 03:24:12.506
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 305. YOUR
03:24:12.573 --> 03:24:19.981
LINE IS OPEN. AND WE WILL MOVE
03:24:20.047 --> 03:24:24.018
TO LINE 507. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:24:24.085 --> 03:24:25.286
THIS IS RYAN O'CONNELL,
03:24:25.353 --> 03:24:26.287
REPRESENTING NAPA, SOLANO FOR
03:24:26.354 --> 03:24:31.258
EVERYONE AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
03:24:31.325 --> 03:24:35.830
LINE. 508, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:24:35.896 --> 03:24:37.732
VICTOR FLORES OPEN DATA CALLING
03:24:37.798 --> 03:24:39.533
FOR EAST BAY FOR EVERYONE IN
03:24:39.600 --> 03:24:42.937
STRONG SUPPORT. LINE. 509,
03:24:43.004 --> 03:24:48.943
PLEASE GO AHEAD. SAM AL FORN,
03:24:49.010 --> 03:24:50.144
RUNNER FROM LOS ANGELES COUNTY
03:24:50.211 --> 03:24:54.849
AND STRONG SUPPORT. LINE. 5 10,
03:24:54.915 --> 03:24:59.720
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
03:24:59.787 --> 03:25:01.922
MIKE HARDY HAVE NO AFFILIATION.
03:25:01.989 --> 03:25:03.124
JUST THE RENTER AND ANGELES AND
03:25:03.190 --> 03:25:07.228
I AM IN STRONG SUPPORT. LINE.
03:25:07.294 --> 03:25:11.632
502, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES
03:25:11.699 --> 03:25:12.633
MARGARET NORMAN'S RESTAURANT AND
03:25:12.700 --> 03:25:17.371
SHOP SUPPORT. LINE 4 87, PLEASE
03:25:17.438 --> 03:25:23.811
GO AHEAD. LINE 47 YEAR LINE IS
03:25:23.878 --> 03:25:27.348
OPEN. HELLO. YOU HEAR ME? YES.
03:25:27.415 --> 03:25:36.691
PLEASE GO AHEAD. ALSO ONE OF THE
03:25:36.757 --> 03:25:37.725
INDIVIDUAL REPORTS STILL DON'T
03:25:37.792 --> 03:25:41.262
WORK. THANK YOU. LINE 5 21,
03:25:41.328 --> 03:25:46.901
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS IS
03:25:46.967 --> 03:25:48.402
NATASHA PEOPLE AND THEY RENT HER
03:25:48.469 --> 03:25:50.204
AND A CAR OWNER IN SAN FRANCISCO
03:25:50.271 --> 03:25:51.338
AND I'M CALLING A STRONG
03:25:51.405 --> 03:25:56.944
SUPPORT. AND MADAM CHAIR. WE
03:25:57.011 --> 03:25:58.112
HAVE ONE MORE LINE COMING IN
03:25:58.179 --> 03:26:03.617
JUST ONE MOMENT. ALRIGHT? AND WE
03:26:03.684 --> 03:26:05.486
WOULD ALIGN 5 18, PLEASE GO
03:26:05.553 --> 03:26:10.725
AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS WILL BUYER
03:26:10.791 --> 03:26:12.626
CITIZEN OF LOS ANGELES,
03:26:12.693 --> 03:26:13.627
CALIFORNIA, FORCING MY VERY
03:26:13.694 --> 03:26:16.831
STRONG SUPPORT YOURSELF. MADAM
03:26:16.897 --> 03:26:17.965
CHAIR, NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND
03:26:18.032 --> 03:26:20.901
QUÊ. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE
03:26:20.968 --> 03:26:23.137
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION.
03:26:23.204 --> 03:26:25.740
THERE IS NO LEAD. OPPOSITION
03:26:25.806 --> 03:26:28.275
WITNESS IDENTIFIED WENT TO SEE
03:26:28.342 --> 03:26:29.744
IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM 2100
03:26:29.810 --> 03:26:30.911
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
03:26:30.978 --> 03:26:34.582
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL
03:26:34.648 --> 03:26:35.716
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
03:26:35.783 --> 03:26:37.551
LINE. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
03:26:37.618 --> 03:26:41.322
T UP OPPOSITION WITNESSES
03:26:41.388 --> 03:26:42.723
CERTAINLY IF THEY'D LIKE TO
03:26:42.790 --> 03:26:44.525
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO A B 2053
03:26:44.592 --> 03:26:49.130
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND WE WILL GO
03:26:49.196 --> 03:26:52.199
TO LINE 77. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:26:52.266 --> 03:26:54.735
VANESSA CHÁVEZ ON BEHALF OF THE
03:26:54.802 --> 03:26:55.669
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
03:26:55.736 --> 03:27:03.844
REALTORS IN OPPOSITION. AND NEXT
03:27:03.911 --> 03:27:05.713
ONE LINE AT 404. PLEASE GO
03:27:05.780 --> 03:27:10.217
AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR. THIS IS BOB
03:27:10.284 --> 03:27:11.452
NAYLOR, REPRESENTING FUELED
03:27:11.519 --> 03:27:12.720
SETTING COMPANY THAT'S HOWARD
03:27:12.787 --> 03:27:14.488
AHMANSON JR AND ORANGE COUNTY
03:27:14.555 --> 03:27:18.192
PHILANTHROPISTS. UH WE HAVE BEEN
03:27:18.259 --> 03:27:21.061
OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED. THEY
03:27:21.128 --> 03:27:22.229
SEND OUR CONCERNS ABOUT EMINENT
03:27:22.296 --> 03:27:26.300
DOMAIN. UM AND IF THE AUTHOR
03:27:26.367 --> 03:27:30.471
WOULD COMMIT TO NOT MM. GIVING
03:27:30.538 --> 03:27:31.372
THIS AUTHORITY EMINENT DOMAIN
03:27:31.438 --> 03:27:34.575
POWER, WE WOULD GO TO NEUTRAL.
03:27:34.642 --> 03:27:38.312
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU. LINE 4 70,
03:27:38.379 --> 03:27:43.584
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:27:43.651 --> 03:27:44.518
. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. JASON
03:27:44.585 --> 03:27:46.587
RYAN LEE, CALIFORNIA CITIES. WE
03:27:46.654 --> 03:27:47.388
HAVE AN OPPOSABLE SUBMITTED
03:27:47.454 --> 03:27:49.657
POSITION ON THIS MEASURE. UM ARE
03:27:49.723 --> 03:27:51.192
OUR BIGGEST CONCERN IS WITH
03:27:51.258 --> 03:27:53.227
REGARD TO THE AUTHORITY OVER
03:27:53.294 --> 03:27:54.895
LAND USE PROVISIONS. THIS NEW
03:27:54.962 --> 03:27:56.230
HOUSING AUTHORITY WOULD BE ABLE
03:27:56.297 --> 03:27:57.698
TO OVERRIDE OFF THE SCIENCE
03:27:57.765 --> 03:27:58.299
STANDARDS DENSITY REQUIREMENT
03:27:58.365 --> 03:28:00.701
TYPE LIMITATION. PARKING
03:28:00.768 --> 03:28:02.837
STANDARDS, ETCETERA, SO WE'RE
03:28:02.903 --> 03:28:03.637
HOPING TO WORK WITH THE AUTHOR
03:28:03.704 --> 03:28:05.506
TO LIMIT THE SCOPE OF THOSE
03:28:05.573 --> 03:28:08.642
PROVISIONS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
03:28:08.709 --> 03:28:10.711
VERY MUCH. 1 89 1 83, PLEASE GO
03:28:10.778 --> 03:28:15.716
AHEAD. MY NAME IS ELIZABETH
03:28:15.783 --> 03:28:17.351
HENRY LEFT CALIFORNIA FOR STATE
03:28:17.418 --> 03:28:21.388
LATVIA. AND THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE
03:28:21.455 --> 03:28:22.523
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
03:28:22.590 --> 03:28:26.393
CALIFORNIA A B 2053 IS ANOTHER
03:28:26.460 --> 03:28:30.197
DISINGENUOUS BILL. THAT IT
03:28:30.264 --> 03:28:31.932
PRETENDS TO BE ABOUT SOCIAL
03:28:31.999 --> 03:28:34.301
HOUSING, BUT CONTENT INTENT AND
03:28:34.368 --> 03:28:35.169
MOTIVE OF THIS BILL. IT IS
03:28:35.236 --> 03:28:38.272
TOTALLY NOT ABOUT SOCIAL
03:28:38.339 --> 03:28:41.742
HOUSING. VERY MUCH OPPOSED TO
03:28:41.809 --> 03:28:42.977
THIS BILL. THANK YOU NEXT,
03:28:43.043 --> 03:28:47.281
PLEASE. LINE 5 33, PLEASE GO
03:28:47.348 --> 03:28:53.654
AHEAD. I'M SO SORRY. I'M. BRO
03:28:53.721 --> 03:28:56.590
I'M SO SORRY IF I MESSED UP
03:28:56.657 --> 03:28:57.691
ALLISON CHARLOTTE FROM LOS
03:28:57.758 --> 03:29:00.561
ANGELES SINGLE FAMILY OWNER
03:29:00.628 --> 03:29:07.735
SUPPORTING, UM, THE TWO OF 533.
03:29:07.801 --> 03:29:08.869
AND MADAM KAREN. NO FURTHER
03:29:08.936 --> 03:29:11.906
COMMENTS AND QUÊ. I'M SORRY I
03:29:11.972 --> 03:29:17.111
MISSED THAT. NO FURTHER FURTHER
03:29:17.177 --> 03:29:19.146
COMMENTS AND QUÊ VERY GOOD. I
03:29:19.213 --> 03:29:20.681
UNDERSTAND THERE'S SOMEONE ELSE
03:29:20.748 --> 03:29:21.782
IN OPPOSITION. THAT'S IN THE
03:29:21.849 --> 03:29:25.686
ROOM, SO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
03:29:25.753 --> 03:29:27.521
FLIPPED OVER SO TO OPPOSITION OF
03:29:27.588 --> 03:29:28.956
JEREMY SMITH, HERE ON BEHALF OF
03:29:29.023 --> 03:29:30.057
THE STATE BUILDING AND
03:29:30.124 --> 03:29:31.225
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL. WE
03:29:31.292 --> 03:29:33.160
ARE IN AN OPPOSING LESSON MINUTE
03:29:33.227 --> 03:29:33.761
POSITION. WE'VE COMMUNICATED
03:29:33.827 --> 03:29:36.497
THAT TO THE AUTHOR AND REMOVE
03:29:36.563 --> 03:29:37.097
THEIR SUPPORT LAST COMMITTEE
03:29:37.164 --> 03:29:38.165
WERE STILL NEEDED. OPPOSING LESS
03:29:38.232 --> 03:29:39.533
ADMITTED STANCE. THANK YOU.
03:29:39.600 --> 03:29:42.269
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
03:29:42.336 --> 03:29:44.204
ANYONE HERE THAT I MISSED? WANT
03:29:44.271 --> 03:29:47.574
TO MAKE SURE I CAUGHT EVERYBODY.
03:29:47.641 --> 03:29:49.209
SEEING WE FINISHED THE
03:29:49.276 --> 03:29:50.344
OPPOSITION AND BRING IT BACK TO
03:29:50.411 --> 03:29:53.314
COMMITTEE. SENATOR WIENER. THANK
03:29:53.380 --> 03:29:54.982
YOU, MADAM CHAIR. UM YOU KNOW, I
03:29:55.049 --> 03:29:56.951
WANT TO THANK THE, UH, THE
03:29:57.017 --> 03:29:57.885
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS BILL
03:29:57.952 --> 03:29:59.653
FORWARD. I'M PROUD TO BE A CO
03:29:59.720 --> 03:30:01.655
AUTHOR OF THE BILL, AND WE SAW
03:30:01.722 --> 03:30:03.857
THIS BILL IN HOUSING COMMITTEE
03:30:03.924 --> 03:30:05.926
AND PASSED IT OUT. AS I
03:30:05.993 --> 03:30:07.528
MENTIONED AND HOUSING COMMITTEE.
03:30:07.594 --> 03:30:09.730
THE UH THE AUTHOR WAS PUTTING IT
03:30:09.797 --> 03:30:11.932
IN A PRECARIOUS SITUATION SINCE
03:30:11.999 --> 03:30:13.167
HE, UH WHEN HE INTRODUCED THE
03:30:13.233 --> 03:30:16.303
BILL. WITH THE BUILDING TRADES
03:30:16.370 --> 03:30:17.972
THAT SPONSORS AND WITH SKILLED
03:30:18.038 --> 03:30:19.707
WORKFORCE IN THE BILL THE BILL
03:30:19.773 --> 03:30:21.108
AS AMENDED AND ASSEMBLY
03:30:21.175 --> 03:30:22.409
APPROPRIATIONS WITHOUT THE
03:30:22.476 --> 03:30:24.778
PARTICIPATION OR CONSENT OF THE
03:30:24.845 --> 03:30:27.114
AUTHOR, UH AND SO THE AUTHOR, I
03:30:27.181 --> 03:30:28.449
THINK IS DOING HIS BEST DID HIS
03:30:28.515 --> 03:30:31.986
BEST TO PIVOT WITH THIS MODIFIED
03:30:32.052 --> 03:30:34.989
SKILLED WORKFORCE, UM, LANGUAGE
03:30:35.055 --> 03:30:36.523
, AND I AGAIN AS WITH THE
03:30:36.590 --> 03:30:38.158
PREVIOUS BILL, HOPEFULLY THIS
03:30:38.225 --> 03:30:39.727
WILL ALL GET WORKED OUT OVER THE
03:30:39.793 --> 03:30:41.095
SUMMER. BUT PUTTING ASIDE THAT
03:30:41.161 --> 03:30:43.797
PARTICULAR ISSUE, UM BIG PICTURE
03:30:43.864 --> 03:30:44.932
SOCIAL HOUSING WHAT WE USED TO
03:30:44.999 --> 03:30:48.736
CALL PUBLIC HOUSING. IS SO I
03:30:48.802 --> 03:30:50.204
THINK ESSENTIAL FOR THE FUTURE
03:30:50.270 --> 03:30:52.940
OF HOUSING, AND WE LOOK ABOUT
03:30:53.007 --> 03:30:54.742
LOOK AT WHEN HOMELESSNESS
03:30:54.808 --> 03:30:56.243
STARTED RAMPING UP IN THIS
03:30:56.310 --> 03:30:58.312
COUNTRY LIKE IN THE EARLY TO MID
03:30:58.379 --> 03:31:00.948
EIGHTIES. THERE WASN'T ONE JUST
03:31:01.015 --> 03:31:02.316
ONE FACTOR. THERE WERE VARIOUS
03:31:02.383 --> 03:31:04.852
IN TERMS OF LIKE, YOU KNOW,
03:31:04.918 --> 03:31:06.320
MENTAL HEALTH, ETCETERA AND LACK
03:31:06.387 --> 03:31:08.489
OF MENTAL TREATMENT. BUT ONE OF
03:31:08.555 --> 03:31:10.724
THE FACTORS WAS THAT RONALD
03:31:10.791 --> 03:31:12.226
REAGAN PUT A STAKE IN THE HEART
03:31:12.292 --> 03:31:13.694
OF PUBLIC HOUSING IN THE 19
03:31:13.761 --> 03:31:17.097
EIGHTIES AND SO WE STOPPED. YOU
03:31:17.164 --> 03:31:18.665
KNOW, WE HAD ALREADY DECELERATED
03:31:18.732 --> 03:31:20.100
OUR PRODUCTION OF PUBLIC
03:31:20.167 --> 03:31:21.535
HOUSING. BUT IT'S JUST STOPPED
03:31:21.602 --> 03:31:22.803
AND THE PUBLIC HOUSING WE HAD
03:31:22.870 --> 03:31:26.106
STARTED TO FALL APART. UH, AND
03:31:26.173 --> 03:31:27.775
THAT WAS ONE FACTOR BECAUSE
03:31:27.841 --> 03:31:30.144
PUBLIC HOUSING IS IT'S NOT JUST
03:31:30.210 --> 03:31:31.478
A SAFETY NET FOR THE POOREST OF
03:31:31.545 --> 03:31:33.313
THE POOR. IT'S ALSO FOR WORKING
03:31:33.380 --> 03:31:34.715
CLASS PEOPLE. IT IS, UH, IT WAS
03:31:34.782 --> 03:31:37.084
JUST A STRUCTURAL FOUNDATION. SO
03:31:37.151 --> 03:31:39.286
THAT, UH, PEOPLE WHO MIGHT
03:31:39.353 --> 03:31:41.221
STRUGGLE TO AFFORD HOUSING HAVE
03:31:41.288 --> 03:31:43.223
HAVE AN OPTION AND WE NEED TO
03:31:43.290 --> 03:31:47.327
GET BACK ON TRACK OF WITH WITH
03:31:47.394 --> 03:31:48.862
NOW WHAT WE NOW CALL SOCIAL
03:31:48.929 --> 03:31:51.098
HOUSING. IT'S NOT THE ONLY PART
03:31:51.165 --> 03:31:51.732
OF THE SOLUTION. WE NEED MARKET
03:31:51.799 --> 03:31:53.233
RATE HOUSING. WE TRADITIONAL NON
03:31:53.300 --> 03:31:54.068
PROFIT SUBSIDIZED, AFFORDABLE
03:31:54.134 --> 03:31:57.604
HOUSING, ETCETERA, ETCETERA. BUT
03:31:57.671 --> 03:31:58.672
IT'S ONE PIECE OF THE PUZZLE.
03:31:58.739 --> 03:32:01.108
THIS BILL IS NOT GOING TO
03:32:01.175 --> 03:32:02.409
OVERNIGHT SNAP INTO EXISTENCE. A
03:32:02.476 --> 03:32:03.811
BUNCH OF SOCIAL HOUSING THIS
03:32:03.877 --> 03:32:05.879
BILL IS A FIRST STOP LAYING A
03:32:05.946 --> 03:32:07.114
STRUCTURAL FOUNDATION. SO WE
03:32:07.181 --> 03:32:09.216
HAVE SOMETHING TO BUILD ON. IN
03:32:09.283 --> 03:32:12.119
THE FUTURE. THERE IS NO WAY BUT
03:32:12.186 --> 03:32:13.220
ONE BILL IS GOING TO LIKE SOLVE
03:32:13.287 --> 03:32:15.122
EVERY ISSUE TO GET US SOCIAL
03:32:15.189 --> 03:32:16.423
HOUSING. BUT THIS IS A STEP
03:32:16.490 --> 03:32:17.524
FORWARD. AND I SUPPORT THIS
03:32:17.591 --> 03:32:21.695
BILL. UM UH, BECAUSE IT'S A GOOD
03:32:21.762 --> 03:32:22.796
BILL. AND ALSO IT WOULD BE A
03:32:22.863 --> 03:32:24.998
SHAME. IF WE DIDN'T TAKE THAT
03:32:25.065 --> 03:32:26.733
STEP FORWARD. IT WOULD SEND THE
03:32:26.800 --> 03:32:28.469
MESSAGE THAT CALIFORNIA IS NOT
03:32:28.535 --> 03:32:30.304
MOVING IN THAT DIRECTION, AND I
03:32:30.370 --> 03:32:32.239
REALLY THINK WE NEED TO. SO I'M
03:32:32.306 --> 03:32:34.141
HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL. THERE IS
03:32:34.208 --> 03:32:36.043
A MOTION BY SENATOR WEINER IN
03:32:36.110 --> 03:32:37.411
THE OTHER COMMENTS, SENATOR
03:32:37.478 --> 03:32:38.545
RIZZO. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
03:32:38.612 --> 03:32:42.549
UM I THINK THIS IS ONE OF THOSE
03:32:42.616 --> 03:32:45.886
TIMES WHEN AND IT'S NOT JUST IN
03:32:45.953 --> 03:32:47.721
HOUSING, BUT IT'S ON A NUMBER OF
03:32:47.788 --> 03:32:50.324
THE NUMBER OF CRISIS AREAS IN
03:32:50.390 --> 03:32:52.025
OUR STATE AND COUNTRY IS ONE OF
03:32:52.092 --> 03:32:54.862
THOSE WHERE YOU HAVE TO TAKE A
03:32:54.928 --> 03:32:56.396
BIG STEP, EVEN THOUGH YOU DON'T
03:32:56.463 --> 03:32:57.965
HAVE ALL THE ANSWERS, EVEN
03:32:58.031 --> 03:32:59.166
THOUGH YOU DON'T HAVE EVERYTHING
03:32:59.233 --> 03:33:01.602
FILLED IN BUT JUST THE IDEA THAT
03:33:01.668 --> 03:33:04.705
WE COULD RECREATE PUBLIC. UM
03:33:04.771 --> 03:33:07.107
PUBLICLY OWNED HOUSING. I THINK
03:33:07.174 --> 03:33:10.811
IS REALLY IMPORTANT. UM
03:33:10.878 --> 03:33:11.879
UNFORTUNATELY, BECAUSE OF THE
03:33:11.945 --> 03:33:15.582
WAY PUBLIC HOUSING WAS ALLOWED
03:33:15.649 --> 03:33:18.018
TO DETERIORATE IN THE PAST. IT
03:33:18.085 --> 03:33:22.122
KIND OF HAS A STIGMA ON IT THAT
03:33:22.189 --> 03:33:23.824
WE ALL SHOULD BE VERY CAREFUL
03:33:23.891 --> 03:33:25.092
ABOUT. UM AND I HOPE THAT THE
03:33:25.159 --> 03:33:28.629
WAY THAT THIS THE STEPS ARE
03:33:28.695 --> 03:33:32.332
TAKEN IS TO GIVE A DIFFERENT
03:33:32.399 --> 03:33:36.770
VISION OF PUBLIC HOUSING. UM IN
03:33:36.837 --> 03:33:38.005
THIS COUNTRY AND WE COULD START
03:33:38.071 --> 03:33:42.976
IN CALIFORNIA. UM THERE ARE MANY
03:33:43.043 --> 03:33:45.179
PROJECTS AND IN MY DISTRICT SOME
03:33:45.245 --> 03:33:47.781
OF PUBLIC PUBLICLY OWNED AND
03:33:47.848 --> 03:33:49.783
SOME WERE JUST BEAUTIFUL. WELL
03:33:49.850 --> 03:33:54.588
MAINTAINED. HEALTHY CLEAN
03:33:54.655 --> 03:33:56.223
NEIGHBORHOODS. AND THEN THERE'S
03:33:56.290 --> 03:34:00.093
OTHERS WHO JUST WENT TO POT AND
03:34:00.160 --> 03:34:01.595
THEY DIDN'T KEEP THEM UP AND
03:34:01.662 --> 03:34:04.198
GIVES THAT AGAIN THAT STIGMA, SO
03:34:04.264 --> 03:34:07.267
I REALLY HOPE THAT I'D RATHER
03:34:07.334 --> 03:34:08.769
HAVE SOLID STEPS TAKING AND DO
03:34:08.835 --> 03:34:13.340
IT RIGHT. THEN. YOU KNOW, JUST A
03:34:13.407 --> 03:34:18.212
LOT OF FANFARE. AND END UP WITH
03:34:18.278 --> 03:34:21.215
, YOU KNOW, UH, SOMETHING THAT
03:34:21.281 --> 03:34:24.618
DOESN'T, UM, MEET OUR NEEDS, SO
03:34:24.685 --> 03:34:26.153
I'D LIKE TO SEE THE INVESTMENT.
03:34:26.220 --> 03:34:28.222
THERE IS A NUMBER OF THINGS
03:34:28.288 --> 03:34:29.289
FLOATING AROUND THAT WE DON'T
03:34:29.356 --> 03:34:31.191
HAVE PERFECT ANSWERS TO WE HAVE
03:34:31.258 --> 03:34:33.193
OUR CHARACTER CHORDS. WE HAVE
03:34:33.260 --> 03:34:34.761
PUBLIC BANKING. WE HAVE ALL
03:34:34.828 --> 03:34:37.030
THESE. WE HAVE SEVERAL AREAS IN
03:34:37.097 --> 03:34:38.599
WHICH WE'RE SAYING LET'S TAKE
03:34:38.665 --> 03:34:40.701
THE CHANCE WILL FILL IN WILL
03:34:40.767 --> 03:34:42.703
FILL IT IN. SO UM, I'M READY TO
03:34:42.769 --> 03:34:46.974
SUPPORT YOU. VERY GOOD. VERY
03:34:47.040 --> 03:34:51.178
GOOD. SO I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT
03:34:51.245 --> 03:34:53.013
THAT THAT I WON'T BE SUPPORTING
03:34:53.080 --> 03:34:54.481
YOUR BILL TODAY, BUT LET ME TELL
03:34:54.548 --> 03:34:55.882
YOU, I MEAN, WHO CAN NOT
03:34:55.949 --> 03:34:59.019
APPRECIATE THE PROMISES THAT ARE
03:34:59.086 --> 03:35:00.721
THAT ARE MADE IN THE BILL, AND
03:35:00.787 --> 03:35:03.290
THAT'S WHAT WHAT CONCERNS ME IS
03:35:03.357 --> 03:35:07.461
THAT I THINK THERE IS, UM THERE
03:35:07.527 --> 03:35:09.463
IS A LOT THAT'S NOT IN IT AS AS
03:35:09.529 --> 03:35:13.100
SENATOR, DURAZO SAID. UM AND IT
03:35:13.166 --> 03:35:15.602
THE ANALOGY SHE DREW WAS TO THE
03:35:15.669 --> 03:35:18.605
STATE OWNED BANK. AND AFTER MANY
03:35:18.672 --> 03:35:20.607
FAILURES, WE FINALLY DECIDED WE
03:35:20.674 --> 03:35:22.109
NEEDED TO STUDY THE ISSUE SO
03:35:22.175 --> 03:35:23.910
THAT WE KNOW WHAT IT IS. WE'RE
03:35:23.977 --> 03:35:25.946
GOING TO NEED IN ORDER TO BE
03:35:26.013 --> 03:35:27.881
ABLE TO PUT TOGETHER A BANK AND
03:35:27.948 --> 03:35:28.915
WHAT IT'S GOING TO COST US SO
03:35:28.982 --> 03:35:31.184
LET ME JUST TELL YOU WHY I LOVE
03:35:31.251 --> 03:35:32.986
THE IDEA OF DOING THIS, BUT WE
03:35:33.053 --> 03:35:37.357
ALREADY HAVE PUBLIC HOUSING ANDTHE PUBLIC HOUSING IS BUILT AND
03:35:37.424 --> 03:35:40.027
MANAGED BY OUR HOUSING
03:35:40.093 --> 03:35:41.561
AUTHORITIES IN EACH ONE OF OUR
03:35:41.628 --> 03:35:42.429
JURISDICTIONS AND THE
03:35:42.496 --> 03:35:45.332
JURISDICTION OF THIS COMMITTEE.
03:35:45.399 --> 03:35:47.534
IS LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
03:35:47.601 --> 03:35:50.604
FINANCING AND, UM, AS A FORMER
03:35:50.671 --> 03:35:52.339
SECRETARY OF BUSINESS, CONSUMER
03:35:52.406 --> 03:35:53.607
SERVICES AND HOUSING. I'VE HAD
03:35:53.674 --> 03:35:58.211
AN OPPORTUNITY. TO SEE WHAT THE
03:35:58.278 --> 03:35:59.846
STATE DOES REALLY WELL, UM AND
03:35:59.913 --> 03:36:01.214
THE STATE EMPLOYEES ARE TERRIFIC
03:36:01.281 --> 03:36:03.216
. THAT'S THE BOTTOM LINE. BUT
03:36:03.283 --> 03:36:05.252
WHEN THE STATE GETS INVOLVED IN
03:36:05.319 --> 03:36:08.221
DOING WHAT THE PRIVATE SECTOR
03:36:08.288 --> 03:36:13.794
DOES. AND UM THEN THEN YOU GOT
03:36:13.860 --> 03:36:15.862
YOU HAVE TO BE CAREFUL BECAUSE
03:36:15.929 --> 03:36:16.930
WHAT WE WOULD BE DOING IS
03:36:16.997 --> 03:36:18.965
SETTING UP A WHOLE NEW AGENCY.
03:36:19.032 --> 03:36:22.169
AND THAT AGENCY WOULD HAVE TO
03:36:22.235 --> 03:36:24.738
HIRE FROM THE PUBLIC SECTOR. AND
03:36:24.805 --> 03:36:26.173
WOULD HAVE TO SET UP THE
03:36:26.239 --> 03:36:28.141
INFRASTRUCTURE IN ORDER TO BE
03:36:28.208 --> 03:36:29.343
ABLE TO DO ANY OF THE WORK
03:36:29.409 --> 03:36:33.714
THAT'S BEEN IDENTIFIED. AND UM.
03:36:33.780 --> 03:36:35.015
AND THAT THAT THE JURISDICTION
03:36:35.082 --> 03:36:39.453
THAT'S THIS COMMITTEE IS IT
03:36:39.519 --> 03:36:40.987
WOULD ROLL LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
03:36:41.054 --> 03:36:44.725
THE THAT THE BILL, UM, ALLOWS
03:36:44.791 --> 03:36:48.662
THAT PROCESS TO HAPPEN AND UM,
03:36:48.729 --> 03:36:50.731
IT MAYBE AT SOME POINT THAT THAT
03:36:50.797 --> 03:36:52.232
THAT'S A GOOD IDEA. I DON'T KNOW
03:36:52.299 --> 03:36:53.834
. BUT UM I'VE BEEN VERY
03:36:53.900 --> 03:36:56.336
PROTECTIVE OF MAKING SURE THAT
03:36:56.403 --> 03:36:57.404
WE RESPECT THE ROLE THAT LOCAL
03:36:57.471 --> 03:37:01.308
GOVERNMENT PLAYS IN. UM LAND USE
03:37:01.375 --> 03:37:02.576
DECISIONS AND THEN JUST
03:37:02.642 --> 03:37:05.712
DETERMINING WHAT? UM WHAT? WHAT
03:37:05.779 --> 03:37:07.147
THE COMMUNITY SHOULD LOOK LIKE
03:37:07.214 --> 03:37:08.815
AND HOW IT SHOULD HAPPEN, AND
03:37:08.882 --> 03:37:10.183
I'VE BEEN VERY CRITICAL OF THOSE
03:37:10.250 --> 03:37:11.618
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVEN'T BUILT
03:37:11.685 --> 03:37:13.487
OR AFFORDABLE HOUSING BECAUSE IN
03:37:13.553 --> 03:37:14.588
MY COMMUNITIES, WE BUILT THE
03:37:14.654 --> 03:37:20.327
HOUSING FOR A WIDE, UM. SECTOR
03:37:20.394 --> 03:37:21.862
OF THE POPULATION THAT DIDN'T
03:37:21.928 --> 03:37:23.964
EVEN LIVE IN OUR COMMUNITY. BUT
03:37:24.030 --> 03:37:26.333
BUT, UM BUT, UM, COULDN'T FIND
03:37:26.400 --> 03:37:27.267
HOUSING ANYWHERE ELSE AND WE'RE
03:37:27.334 --> 03:37:28.969
MOVING IN AND DRIVING UP THE
03:37:29.035 --> 03:37:30.904
COST OF HOUSING, SO I'M REAL
03:37:30.971 --> 03:37:31.805
SENSITIVE TO THAT. UM, AND TO
03:37:31.872 --> 03:37:36.309
MAKING SURE WE PROTECT THE. THE
03:37:36.376 --> 03:37:38.044
HOUSING THAT WE HAVE, AND FOR
03:37:38.111 --> 03:37:39.413
THE FOR THE LOCAL RESIDENTS SO
03:37:39.479 --> 03:37:41.248
THAT THEY DON'T HAVE TO TRAVEL
03:37:41.314 --> 03:37:42.649
SO FAR, BUT, UM, I SUGGESTED,
03:37:42.716 --> 03:37:44.151
AND IT WAS REJECTED AND THAT'S
03:37:44.217 --> 03:37:45.786
FINE. IT'S PART OF THE GIVE AND
03:37:45.852 --> 03:37:47.754
TAKE A PILOT PROJECT WHERE WE
03:37:47.821 --> 03:37:49.122
START, START OFF SMALL AND
03:37:49.189 --> 03:37:50.424
DEVELOP A PROOF OF CONCEPT SO
03:37:50.490 --> 03:37:53.126
THAT WE KNOW EXACTLY WHAT WHAT?
03:37:53.193 --> 03:37:55.195
UM WHAT THE OPTION. THE
03:37:55.262 --> 03:37:56.963
OPPORTUNITIES ARE GOING TO BE. I
03:37:57.030 --> 03:38:00.600
JUST WORRY ABOUT ABOUT THIS BIG
03:38:00.667 --> 03:38:02.702
, BOLD RIGHT? BUT WE SPEND A
03:38:02.769 --> 03:38:05.205
BUNCH OF MONEY AND THEN WE DON'T
03:38:05.272 --> 03:38:07.207
GET THERE AND UM OR OR WE SPEND
03:38:07.274 --> 03:38:08.775
A BUNCH OF MONEY. AND THEN THE
03:38:08.842 --> 03:38:11.077
ECONOMY IS NOT WHAT IT SHOULD BE
03:38:11.144 --> 03:38:12.612
, AND IT'S ONE OF THE NEW
03:38:12.679 --> 03:38:13.713
PROGRAMS WE STARTED AND WE CAN'T
03:38:13.780 --> 03:38:15.849
AFFORD TO CONTINUE IT. SO UM SO
03:38:15.916 --> 03:38:20.787
I NEED TO KNOW. YOU KNOW WHAT IS
03:38:20.854 --> 03:38:22.722
THE IMPACT GOING TO BE ON LOCAL
03:38:22.789 --> 03:38:23.890
GOVERNMENT? AND HOW ARE WE
03:38:23.957 --> 03:38:25.725
GONNA, UM, STRUCTURE IT SO WE'RE
03:38:25.792 --> 03:38:27.828
WORKING IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
03:38:27.894 --> 03:38:29.262
LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND WE'RE DOING
03:38:29.329 --> 03:38:33.700
IT IN A WAY THAT THAT FITS. UM
03:38:33.767 --> 03:38:35.368
YOU KNOW WHAT PEOPLE THINK IS
03:38:35.435 --> 03:38:36.303
BEAUTIFUL ABOUT CALIFORNIA
03:38:36.369 --> 03:38:38.205
BECAUSE WE HAVE SOME INCREDIBLE
03:38:38.271 --> 03:38:39.739
, UM, ASSETS IN OUR COMMUNITY
03:38:39.806 --> 03:38:41.675
AND I DON'T WANT TO LOSE THAT AS
03:38:41.741 --> 03:38:44.244
WELL. AND I HAVE NOT NOT SEEN
03:38:44.311 --> 03:38:47.214
ANY ANY EXAMPLE OF SOCIAL
03:38:47.280 --> 03:38:48.582
HOUSING IN THE US THAT CAN GIVE
03:38:48.648 --> 03:38:51.618
US A ROAD MAP. UM IF YOU'VE GOT
03:38:51.685 --> 03:38:52.719
EXAMPLES OF THAT, I'D I'D
03:38:52.786 --> 03:38:55.722
APPRECIATE IT. BUT, UM BUT TODAY
03:38:55.789 --> 03:38:57.991
I JUST WON'T BE SUPPORTING AND I
03:38:58.058 --> 03:38:59.493
LOOK FORWARD TO HAVING RESOLVING
03:38:59.559 --> 03:39:00.660
THE ISSUE ABOUT LOCAL GOVERNMENT
03:39:00.727 --> 03:39:04.097
AND WHAT YOU KNOW HOW WE GET
03:39:04.164 --> 03:39:05.665
THERE SO THAT WE CAN GET THE
03:39:05.732 --> 03:39:07.133
SUPPORT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
03:39:07.200 --> 03:39:08.735
HAVE THEM FEEL LIKE IT'S A GOOD
03:39:08.802 --> 03:39:11.171
THING TO HAVE THE STATE COME IN
03:39:11.238 --> 03:39:12.472
WITH AN AGENCY THAT'S GOING TO
03:39:12.539 --> 03:39:13.340
BUILD HOUSING IN THEIR
03:39:13.406 --> 03:39:14.441
COMMUNITY, AND THEY DON'T HAVE
03:39:14.508 --> 03:39:15.809
ANY SAY ABOUT IT. SO WITH THAT.
03:39:15.876 --> 03:39:17.744
UM I'LL IF THERE'S NO MORE
03:39:17.811 --> 03:39:18.879
COMMENTS ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE.
03:39:18.945 --> 03:39:20.213
THANK YOU. CHAIR CABALLERO. I
03:39:20.280 --> 03:39:21.915
JUST WANT TO NOTE A COUPLE OF
03:39:21.982 --> 03:39:22.949
THINGS IN RESPONSE TO WHAT YOU
03:39:23.016 --> 03:39:25.552
SAID IS, YOU KNOW, THIS BILL IS
03:39:25.619 --> 03:39:26.620
AN AMBITIOUS FIRST STEP IN MANY
03:39:26.686 --> 03:39:28.088
WAYS. AND WE FIND OURSELVES AT A
03:39:28.154 --> 03:39:30.056
CROSSROADS IN MANY WAYS IN THIS
03:39:30.123 --> 03:39:31.124
COUNTRY, AND I AM REMINDED MUCH
03:39:31.191 --> 03:39:32.759
MUCH BEFORE MY TIME, BUT WHEN IF
03:39:32.826 --> 03:39:34.794
THEY ARE CALLED THE NEW DEAL AND
03:39:34.861 --> 03:39:35.929
CREATED PUBLIC HOUSING, CREATED
03:39:35.996 --> 03:39:37.230
SOCIAL SECURITY CREATED ALL THE
03:39:37.297 --> 03:39:38.798
THINGS THAT WE HAVE TAKEN FOR
03:39:38.865 --> 03:39:39.933
GRANTED, AND THEN DURING THE
03:39:40.000 --> 03:39:41.067
REAGAN ERA DISMANTLED AND NOW
03:39:41.134 --> 03:39:43.370
WE'RE IN THE SAME ECONOMIC
03:39:43.436 --> 03:39:45.672
THROWS IS THIS IS IMPORTANT TO
03:39:45.739 --> 03:39:47.007
TAKE THAT FIRST STEP. AND IT'S
03:39:47.073 --> 03:39:48.808
BECAUSE, AS EXAMPLE ASSURED YOU
03:39:48.875 --> 03:39:49.910
WITH LIKE, SAY, AUSTRIA HERE.
03:39:49.976 --> 03:39:52.279
THEY HAVE BEEN DOING IT SINCE 19
03:39:52.345 --> 03:39:53.880
TWENTIES, WE START EMBARKED ON
03:39:53.947 --> 03:39:55.348
OUR PUBLIC HOUSING ENDEAVORS IN
03:39:55.415 --> 03:39:56.816
THE THIRTIES AND FORTIES. BUT
03:39:56.883 --> 03:39:58.251
THE REASON WHY THERE ARE
03:39:58.318 --> 03:39:59.753
COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD IN ASIA
03:39:59.819 --> 03:40:00.820
AND IN EUROPE. THEY HAVE BEEN
03:40:00.887 --> 03:40:03.323
DOING IT LONGER, IF NOT, JUST AS
03:40:03.390 --> 03:40:04.457
LONG AS US THAT HAVE SUCCEEDED
03:40:04.524 --> 03:40:06.092
IS BECAUSE THEY MADE POLICY
03:40:06.159 --> 03:40:06.760
CHOICE ALONG THE WAY. WE IN THE
03:40:06.826 --> 03:40:07.994
US, UNFORTUNATELY MADE SOME
03:40:08.061 --> 03:40:08.895
REALLY TERRIBLE POLICY CHOICES
03:40:08.962 --> 03:40:10.697
THAT MADE THINGS REALLY BAD, BUT
03:40:10.764 --> 03:40:11.798
WE CAN LEARN FROM MISTAKES OF
03:40:11.865 --> 03:40:13.733
OUR COUNTRY AND ALSO LEARN FROM
03:40:13.800 --> 03:40:15.335
SUCCESSES AND ADAPT THOSE FROM
03:40:15.402 --> 03:40:16.803
ASIA AND EUROPE. AND THE SAME
03:40:16.870 --> 03:40:18.371
TIME. ALSO WANT TO POINT TO THIS
03:40:18.438 --> 03:40:19.639
PICTURE I SHOWED IS FROM
03:40:19.706 --> 03:40:21.241
MARYLAND AND MARYLAND IS THE
03:40:21.308 --> 03:40:21.875
ONLY STATE RIGHT NOW, WHICH IS
03:40:21.942 --> 03:40:23.543
ADOPTING SOCIAL HOUSING AND IS
03:40:23.610 --> 03:40:24.711
FIRST AND FOREMOST AND I KNOW IN
03:40:24.778 --> 03:40:26.046
CALIFORNIA. WE PRIDE OURSELVES
03:40:26.112 --> 03:40:28.048
ON BEING FIRST, BUT I WOULD
03:40:28.114 --> 03:40:28.949
REALLY LIKE US TO BE BEATING
03:40:29.015 --> 03:40:30.517
MARYLAND AND THEY'RE TRYING IT
03:40:30.584 --> 03:40:31.851
RIGHT NOW, OBVIOUSLY THEIR STATE
03:40:31.918 --> 03:40:32.786
AND COUNTY LEVEL, WHICH IS
03:40:32.852 --> 03:40:34.120
SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT, BUT I THINK
03:40:34.187 --> 03:40:35.555
THERE'S A LOT OF SUCCESS IN THIS
03:40:35.622 --> 03:40:37.157
AND THE BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
03:40:37.223 --> 03:40:38.858
PUBLIC HOUSING AS WE UNDERSTAND
03:40:38.925 --> 03:40:39.960
IT IN THE UNITED STATES AND
03:40:40.026 --> 03:40:41.595
SOCIAL HOUSING. IS THAT IT IS
03:40:41.661 --> 03:40:42.829
UNIVERSAL. GOOD MEETING PEOPLE
03:40:42.896 --> 03:40:44.297
FROM ALL WALKS OF LIFE, ROCK
03:40:44.364 --> 03:40:45.699
STARS, POLITICIANS AND PEOPLE ON
03:40:45.765 --> 03:40:47.400
WELFARE AND ALL OVER THE SAME
03:40:47.467 --> 03:40:48.168
PLACE AND I'LL PAY APPROPRIATE
03:40:48.234 --> 03:40:50.704
RENTS FOR THAT IN THE U. S WHAT
03:40:50.770 --> 03:40:51.972
WE'VE KIND OF CRETED IS A
03:40:52.038 --> 03:40:53.640
SYSTEM WHERE IT'S HOUSING AS
03:40:53.707 --> 03:40:55.108
WELFARE IF WE TREATED OUR SAME
03:40:55.175 --> 03:40:56.042
UNIVERSE, UNIVERSAL GOODS AT THE
03:40:56.109 --> 03:40:57.944
SAME WAY YOU THINK OF, YOU KNOW
03:40:58.011 --> 03:40:59.713
ROADS FOR POOR PEOPLE, ROADS FOR
03:40:59.779 --> 03:41:01.247
EVERYONE ELSE OR SCHOOLS OR
03:41:01.314 --> 03:41:02.215
PEOPLE SCHOOLS FOR EVERYONE
03:41:02.282 --> 03:41:03.717
ELSE. WE DID THAT ON A HOUSING,
03:41:03.783 --> 03:41:04.985
BUT WE DIDN'T DO THAT WITH OTHER
03:41:05.051 --> 03:41:06.720
MUNICIPAL GOODS, AND THAT'S WHAT
03:41:06.786 --> 03:41:07.821
EUROPEAN AND ASIAN COUNTRIES
03:41:07.887 --> 03:41:08.622
DECIDED IS A UNIVERSAL MENTAL
03:41:08.688 --> 03:41:11.491
GOOD AND WE MEET PEOPLE WHERE
03:41:11.558 --> 03:41:12.392
THEY'RE NEEDED, AND THAT'S WHY
03:41:12.459 --> 03:41:13.460
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO DO
03:41:13.526 --> 03:41:14.995
THAT. AND AS FOR, UM THE IDEA
03:41:15.061 --> 03:41:15.996
ABOUT LOCAL GOVERNMENT DECISIONS
03:41:16.062 --> 03:41:16.596
. YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT CERTAINLY
03:41:16.663 --> 03:41:18.131
SOMETHING WE DON'T WANT TO
03:41:18.198 --> 03:41:19.499
REPEAT THE MISTAKES OF IN THIS
03:41:19.566 --> 03:41:21.334
COUNTRY TO WE DON'T WANT TO
03:41:21.401 --> 03:41:22.235
FORCE COMMUNITIES TO FEEL LIKE
03:41:22.302 --> 03:41:24.270
THERE ARE TOWERS IN THE PARK
03:41:24.337 --> 03:41:25.338
THAT DON'T FIT THEIR NEEDS OR
03:41:25.405 --> 03:41:26.673
THINGS THAT THAT DON'T WORK WITH
03:41:26.740 --> 03:41:27.874
IT. LEGAL CITIES DID HAVE THEIR
03:41:27.941 --> 03:41:29.609
OPPOSITION COMING IN THE SENATE,
03:41:29.676 --> 03:41:30.810
AND WE DO WANT TO HOPEFULLY WORK
03:41:30.877 --> 03:41:32.712
WITH THEM. HAND IN HAND TO
03:41:32.779 --> 03:41:34.447
FIGURE OUT HOW CAN WE MAKE THIS
03:41:34.514 --> 03:41:35.749
A TOOL FOR THEM RIGHT BECAUSE AT
03:41:35.815 --> 03:41:37.751
THE END DAY AS WE TALKED ABOUT
03:41:37.817 --> 03:41:39.386
SOME OF THOSE COMMUNITIES THAT
03:41:39.452 --> 03:41:40.487
DON'T MEET THEIR HOUSING GOALS,
03:41:40.553 --> 03:41:40.987
SOME OTHER IMPEDIMENTS.
03:41:41.054 --> 03:41:42.322
SOMETIMES THERE'S A HUGE
03:41:42.389 --> 03:41:43.456
SKEPTICISM OF THE PRIVATE MARKET
03:41:43.523 --> 03:41:45.025
RIGHT AND SOME OF THEIR
03:41:45.091 --> 03:41:46.059
CONSTITUENTS HAVE THE SAME
03:41:46.126 --> 03:41:46.893
SKEPTICISM. I UNDERSTAND THAT,
03:41:46.960 --> 03:41:48.128
SO THAT'S WHY WE'RE PROVIDING AN
03:41:48.194 --> 03:41:49.963
OPTION NOW SO YOU CAN EITHER
03:41:50.030 --> 03:41:51.064
HAVE A FOR PROFIT DEVELOPMENT.
03:41:51.131 --> 03:41:51.998
OR THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
03:41:52.065 --> 03:41:53.066
AUTHORITY DEVELOPMENT TO COME IN
03:41:53.133 --> 03:41:55.301
AND HELP YOU MEET THOSE RINA
03:41:55.368 --> 03:41:57.303
GOALS. THERE ARE A LOT EVEN IN
03:41:57.370 --> 03:41:58.304
MY COMMUNITY WHERE WE HAVE
03:41:58.371 --> 03:41:58.872
DEFUNCT ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
03:41:58.938 --> 03:41:59.472
BECAUSE DECLINING ENROLLMENT
03:41:59.539 --> 03:42:00.674
IT'S TOO EXPENSIVE TO LIVE IN,
03:42:00.740 --> 03:42:01.875
OR PARKING LOTS OWNED BY TRANS
03:42:01.941 --> 03:42:03.610
AUTHORITIES. THEY WOULD LOVE TO
03:42:03.677 --> 03:42:04.611
BUILD WORKFORCE HOUSING THERE,
03:42:04.678 --> 03:42:05.945
BUT THEY DON'T WANT TO SELL THE
03:42:06.012 --> 03:42:07.647
ASSETS TO A PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT
03:42:07.714 --> 03:42:08.915
IN THE COMMUNITY IS ALSO NOT
03:42:08.982 --> 03:42:10.650
PRO, SELLING THE ASSET OF PUBLIC
03:42:10.717 --> 03:42:11.985
LAND TO A PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT.
03:42:12.052 --> 03:42:12.919
SO I'M TRYING TO PROVIDE MORE
03:42:12.986 --> 03:42:14.888
OPTIONS IN THAT SENSE, AND I DO
03:42:14.954 --> 03:42:16.189
WANT TO ALSO THANK YOUR
03:42:16.256 --> 03:42:17.257
COMMITTEE STAFFER WORKING WITH
03:42:17.323 --> 03:42:18.625
MY STAFF ON SOME POSSIBLE
03:42:18.692 --> 03:42:19.659
AMENDMENTS, AND YOU KNOW IF
03:42:19.726 --> 03:42:20.927
THERE'S A BILL TO CONTINUE
03:42:20.994 --> 03:42:22.529
MOVING FORWARD, I STILL WANT TO
03:42:22.595 --> 03:42:23.963
TALK ABOUT SOME OF THOSE THINGS
03:42:24.030 --> 03:42:25.665
AND WHILE I MAY NOT BE THERE ON
03:42:25.732 --> 03:42:28.168
A PILOT PROGRAM YET I DO ALSO
03:42:28.234 --> 03:42:29.436
UNDERSTAND GIVING YOURSELF YOUR
03:42:29.502 --> 03:42:30.003
EXPERIENCES SECRETARY ABOUT
03:42:30.070 --> 03:42:31.137
REORGANIZATION. I'M VERY MUCH
03:42:31.204 --> 03:42:31.805
COMMITTED TO IF THAT'S THE PATH
03:42:31.871 --> 03:42:34.407
WE WANT TO GO TOWARDS IS PUTTING
03:42:34.474 --> 03:42:36.209
INTO HCG THAT WORKS FOR ME. I'VE
03:42:36.276 --> 03:42:36.810
ALWAYS BEEN KIND OF AGNOSTIC
03:42:36.876 --> 03:42:37.811
ABOUT BUREAUCRATIC ORGANIZATION.
03:42:37.877 --> 03:42:38.878
BUT I DO SHARE THAT. YOU KNOW,
03:42:38.945 --> 03:42:41.381
WE HAVE TO DO IT RIGHT? AND I
03:42:41.448 --> 03:42:42.716
THINK WE HAVE TO TAKE THAT BOLD,
03:42:42.782 --> 03:42:44.050
FIRST LEAP FORWARD AND
03:42:44.117 --> 03:42:45.518
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE SO
03:42:45.585 --> 03:42:46.853
WE CAN CONTINUE WORKING ON
03:42:46.920 --> 03:42:47.654
SUPPORTING BILL. THANK YOU SO
03:42:47.721 --> 03:42:49.589
MUCH, AND I APPRECIATE THAT I
03:42:49.656 --> 03:42:50.857
WON'T VOTE NO TO THE I'LL JUST,
03:42:50.924 --> 03:42:53.059
UH, NOT VOTE, AND THEN WE CAN
03:42:53.126 --> 03:42:54.094
CONTINUE OUR CONVERSATIONS. I DO
03:42:54.160 --> 03:42:55.762
APPRECIATE THAT. THANK YOU.
03:42:55.829 --> 03:42:56.896
THANK YOU. SO THERE IS A MOTION.
03:42:56.963 --> 03:42:58.698
UM PLEASE TAKE THE ROLL. MOTION
03:42:58.765 --> 03:43:00.767
IS TO PASS THE FIRST REROUTE BE
03:43:00.834 --> 03:43:01.768
RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:43:01.835 --> 03:43:02.268
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS,
03:43:02.335 --> 03:43:03.570
CABALLERO NILSSON NILSSON, NO,
03:43:03.636 --> 03:43:08.708
DURAZO. LARA SO I HERZBERG
03:43:08.775 --> 03:43:14.080
WIENER WIENER, I 2 TO 1. WELL
03:43:14.147 --> 03:43:16.216
WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON CALL AND
03:43:16.282 --> 03:43:17.984
PICK UP THE ABSENT MEMBER.
03:43:18.051 --> 03:43:21.955
LATER. WE'RE GONNA OKAY. I'M
03:43:22.021 --> 03:43:25.225
GOING TO MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM
03:43:25.291 --> 03:43:27.694
NUMBER 16, WHICH IS A B 27 21.
03:43:27.761 --> 03:43:29.229
THANK YOU, BUT I'M SURE I HOPE
03:43:29.295 --> 03:43:30.830
THIS BILL WILL BE A LITTLE BIT
03:43:30.897 --> 03:43:32.599
MORE BRIEF. THAT'S A THANK YOU.
03:43:32.665 --> 03:43:33.767
I WILL BE ACCEPTING THE
03:43:33.833 --> 03:43:34.868
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS TO DEFINE
03:43:34.934 --> 03:43:35.802
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION AND LIKE
03:43:35.869 --> 03:43:37.070
TO THANK THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
03:43:37.137 --> 03:43:38.738
THEIR WORK ON THIS BILL, HB 27
03:43:38.805 --> 03:43:40.707
21 WILL ALLOW THE BAY AREA AIR
03:43:40.774 --> 03:43:41.608
QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
03:43:41.674 --> 03:43:42.976
BOARD AND THE COMMITTEE MEETING
03:43:43.042 --> 03:43:44.077
SCHEDULED TO BECOME MORE
03:43:44.144 --> 03:43:45.578
EFFCIENT AND AUTHORIZED THE
03:43:45.645 --> 03:43:46.513
BOARD TO START ACTIVE
03:43:46.579 --> 03:43:47.347
TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM. UNDER
03:43:47.413 --> 03:43:48.982
EXISTING LAW BOARD MEMBERS CAN
03:43:49.048 --> 03:43:51.251
ONLY BE REIMBURSED FOR TRAVELING
03:43:51.317 --> 03:43:51.885
BY MEETINGS BY CAR RIDE SHARE
03:43:51.951 --> 03:43:53.186
PUBLIC TRANSIT, BUT NOT BY
03:43:53.253 --> 03:43:54.821
BIKING OR WALKING. THIS BILL
03:43:54.888 --> 03:43:56.089
ALLOWS THE BOARD TO CREATE
03:43:56.156 --> 03:43:57.390
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM
03:43:57.457 --> 03:43:58.558
THAT COMPENSATES MEMBERS FOR
03:43:58.625 --> 03:43:59.993
BIKING, WALKING TO MEETINGS,
03:44:00.059 --> 03:44:01.094
WHICH, OF COURSE, IS IN LINE
03:44:01.161 --> 03:44:02.228
WITH CALIFORNIA EMISSION
03:44:02.295 --> 03:44:04.264
REDUCTION GOALS. THIS BILL WILL
03:44:04.330 --> 03:44:05.465
CHANGE THE COMPENSATION FOR BACK
03:44:05.532 --> 03:44:07.200
MED BOARD MEETINGS ATTENDING
03:44:07.267 --> 03:44:09.302
MEETINGS FROM $100 A DAY $200
03:44:09.369 --> 03:44:10.603
PER MEETING WITHOUT CHANGING THE
03:44:10.670 --> 03:44:12.338
YEARLY COMPENSATION LIMIT. I
03:44:12.405 --> 03:44:13.907
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE
03:44:13.973 --> 03:44:15.575
TODAY. TESTIFYING WITH ME WILL
03:44:15.642 --> 03:44:16.843
BE ALAN ABS WITH BACK MED. VERY
03:44:16.910 --> 03:44:20.180
GOOD WELCOME. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
03:44:20.246 --> 03:44:21.648
CABALLERO AND MEMBERS OF THE
03:44:21.714 --> 03:44:22.715
COMMITTEE. I'M ALAN ABS. I'M THE
03:44:22.782 --> 03:44:24.617
LEGISLATIVE OFFICER FOR THE BAY
03:44:24.684 --> 03:44:25.485
AREA AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT
03:44:25.552 --> 03:44:26.820
DISTRICT, THE SPONSOR OF MAYBE
03:44:26.886 --> 03:44:28.888
27 21 IN THE LOCAL AIR REGULATOR
03:44:28.955 --> 03:44:30.023
FOR THE NINE COUNTIES
03:44:30.089 --> 03:44:30.990
SURROUNDING THE SAN FRANCISCO
03:44:31.057 --> 03:44:33.793
BAY. THE BOARD IS COMPRISED OF
03:44:33.860 --> 03:44:35.995
24 ELECTED OFFICIALS THAT ALSO
03:44:36.062 --> 03:44:38.164
SIT ON EIGHT COMMITTEES, AS WELL
03:44:38.231 --> 03:44:39.599
AS REPRESENTING THE DISTRICT AND
03:44:39.666 --> 03:44:41.868
OTHER AGENCY IN PUBLIC MEETINGS
03:44:41.935 --> 03:44:43.570
SINCE THE SECTION OF THE HEALTH
03:44:43.636 --> 03:44:44.604
AND SAFETY CODE WAS LAST
03:44:44.671 --> 03:44:47.640
AMENDED. AMENDED IN 1986 THE
03:44:47.707 --> 03:44:49.075
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD
03:44:49.142 --> 03:44:51.077
AND PUBLIC INTEREST IN
03:44:51.144 --> 03:44:52.111
PARTICIPATION IN AIR QUALITY
03:44:52.178 --> 03:44:55.114
POLICY HAVE SKYROCKETED. A B 27
03:44:55.181 --> 03:44:56.683
21 ACKNOWLEDGES THIS BY
03:44:56.749 --> 03:44:57.984
INCREASING THE TOTAL DAILY
03:44:58.051 --> 03:44:59.185
MEETING COMPENSATION BY $100 PER
03:44:59.252 --> 03:45:02.522
DAY. FROM LOCAL REVENUES TO
03:45:02.589 --> 03:45:03.990
ENCOURAGE HOLDING MULTIPLE
03:45:04.057 --> 03:45:05.491
COMMITTEE MEETINGS PER DAY,
03:45:05.558 --> 03:45:06.593
WHICH ALSO ALLOWS FOR MORE
03:45:06.659 --> 03:45:09.329
ACCESSIBLE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
03:45:09.395 --> 03:45:10.230
. IT ALSO PROVIDES A MINOR
03:45:10.296 --> 03:45:11.931
MONETARY BOOST TO BOARD MEMBERS
03:45:11.998 --> 03:45:14.000
, MANY OF WHOM ARE UNPAID CITY
03:45:14.067 --> 03:45:15.702
ELECTED OFFICIALS. THAT TAKE
03:45:15.768 --> 03:45:17.203
TIME OFF FROM THEIR PRIMARY JOBS
03:45:17.270 --> 03:45:19.138
AND FAMILIAL RESPONSIBILITIES TO
03:45:19.205 --> 03:45:20.840
REPRESENT THEIR COMMUNITIES AT
03:45:20.907 --> 03:45:23.843
UMD MEETINGS. MAYBE 27 21 ALSO
03:45:23.910 --> 03:45:24.878
ALLOWS THE BOARD TO CREATE A
03:45:24.944 --> 03:45:26.846
COMPENSATION POLICY, ENCOURAGING
03:45:26.913 --> 03:45:28.181
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION, SUCH AS
03:45:28.248 --> 03:45:29.849
WALKING AND BICYCLING WHEN
03:45:29.916 --> 03:45:31.451
REPRESENTING THE DISTRICT. THIS
03:45:31.517 --> 03:45:32.852
AMENDMENT ALIGNS WITH REGIONAL
03:45:32.919 --> 03:45:34.354
REQUIREMENTS FOR EMPLOYEE
03:45:34.420 --> 03:45:34.988
COMMUTE BENEFIT PROGRAMS IN THE
03:45:35.054 --> 03:45:39.092
BAY AREA UNDER EXISTING LAW. I'M
03:45:39.158 --> 03:45:40.226
HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
03:45:40.293 --> 03:45:42.195
YOU HAVE, AND I'D ALSO LIKE TO
03:45:42.262 --> 03:45:43.162
THANK THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
03:45:43.229 --> 03:45:44.497
WORKING WITH US ON CLARIFYING
03:45:44.564 --> 03:45:46.566
AMENDMENTS TO THE BILL. THANK
03:45:46.633 --> 03:45:48.468
YOU AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
03:45:48.534 --> 03:45:49.702
YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:45:49.769 --> 03:45:54.974
I LOST MY NOTES. DID YOU HAVE A
03:45:55.041 --> 03:45:55.708
SECOND SUPPORT WITNESS? I'M
03:45:55.775 --> 03:45:57.243
SORRY. JUST OKAY. VERY GOOD.
03:45:57.310 --> 03:46:00.213
THAT MAKES IT SIMPLER. UM IS
03:46:00.280 --> 03:46:01.915
THERE ANYONE HERE IN THE ROOM
03:46:01.981 --> 03:46:03.149
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
03:46:03.216 --> 03:46:07.220
AND SUPPORT. SAYING NONE. WE'LL
03:46:07.287 --> 03:46:09.322
GO OUT. WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
03:46:09.389 --> 03:46:10.356
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
03:46:10.423 --> 03:46:11.524
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
03:46:11.591 --> 03:46:13.726
LINE? AND IF THEY'D LIKE TO
03:46:13.793 --> 03:46:15.828
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 27 21,
03:46:15.895 --> 03:46:22.135
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
03:46:22.201 --> 03:46:25.204
CHAIR. NO LINES COMING IN. VERY
03:46:25.271 --> 03:46:27.307
GOOD. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY LEAD
03:46:27.373 --> 03:46:28.942
OPPOSITION WITNESSES, SO WE'RE
03:46:29.008 --> 03:46:30.043
GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY
03:46:30.109 --> 03:46:31.911
IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
03:46:31.978 --> 03:46:33.813
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. SEEING THEN
03:46:33.880 --> 03:46:35.648
WE'LL GO TO THE TELECONFERENCE
03:46:35.715 --> 03:46:36.516
LINE IF YOU COULD CHECK AND SEE
03:46:36.582 --> 03:46:38.384
IF THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION ON THE
03:46:38.451 --> 03:46:40.954
LINE. CERTAINLY AND SAY, LIKE
03:46:41.020 --> 03:46:43.089
SPEAKING OPPOSITION TO A B 27
03:46:43.156 --> 03:46:53.800
21, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
03:46:53.866 --> 03:46:55.601
CHAIR. NO LINES ARE COMING IN
03:46:55.668 --> 03:46:56.903
VERY GOOD THAT WILL BRING THE
03:46:56.970 --> 03:46:59.038
MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE. UH
03:46:59.105 --> 03:47:00.606
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? THERE
03:47:00.673 --> 03:47:05.712
ARE NONE. UM, WE JUST LOST OUR.
03:47:05.778 --> 03:47:08.348
OUR QUORUM, BUT WHEN THEY RETURN
03:47:08.414 --> 03:47:09.782
WILL TAKE UP THE BILL, AND
03:47:09.849 --> 03:47:11.651
ACTUALLY, I CAN MOVE THE BILL
03:47:11.718 --> 03:47:13.853
AND I WELL, I WILL WAIT. WE'LL
03:47:13.920 --> 03:47:15.755
WAIT TILL THEY COME BACK. IT'S A
03:47:15.822 --> 03:47:18.157
LOT CLEANER. BUT I HAVE NO
03:47:18.224 --> 03:47:19.592
CONCERNS. I REALLY APPRECIATE
03:47:19.659 --> 03:47:21.728
HOW YOU'VE DONE THIS BILL, AND
03:47:21.794 --> 03:47:24.097
SO WILL ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE.
03:47:24.163 --> 03:47:25.765
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS AND
03:47:25.832 --> 03:47:27.033
THANK THE COMMITTEE SET FOR
03:47:27.100 --> 03:47:28.735
THEIR WORK. SO WHEN THE QUORUM
03:47:28.801 --> 03:47:29.769
RETURNS VIA ACTIVE
03:47:29.836 --> 03:47:30.303
TRANSPORTATION VIA WALKING
03:47:30.370 --> 03:47:32.372
LIMITS, RIGHT DRIVER THANK YOU
03:47:32.438 --> 03:47:36.242
SO MUCH. ALRIGHTY. WE'LL MOVE ON
03:47:36.309 --> 03:47:40.613
TO. SENATOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:47:40.680 --> 03:47:45.952
TEAM. THANK YOU, SENATOR. FIRST
03:47:46.019 --> 03:47:47.220
LET ME THANK YOU APPRECIATE OUR
03:47:47.286 --> 03:47:48.121
DISCUSSION YESTERDAY. LET ME
03:47:48.187 --> 03:47:50.723
ALSO THANK THE COMMITTEE. AH
03:47:50.790 --> 03:47:52.158
YOUR STAFF FOR THEIR AMENDMENTS
03:47:52.225 --> 03:47:53.226
WERE HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE
03:47:53.292 --> 03:47:55.361
AMENDMENTS THAT CLARIFY WHEN A
03:47:55.428 --> 03:47:56.696
COMPLAINT CAN BE FILED UNDER
03:47:56.763 --> 03:47:58.631
THIS BILL. THE AMENDMENTS ALSO
03:47:58.698 --> 03:48:00.333
ENSURE THAT COURT FEES AND BE
03:48:00.400 --> 03:48:01.334
AWARDED TO A PLAINTIFF THE LOCAL
03:48:01.401 --> 03:48:03.302
AGENCY ACTED IN GOOD FAITH AND
03:48:03.369 --> 03:48:04.470
HAD REASONABLE CAUSE TO REQUIRE
03:48:04.537 --> 03:48:06.205
MORE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. UM
03:48:06.272 --> 03:48:08.174
THIS THIS BILL IS ABOUT JUST
03:48:08.241 --> 03:48:09.242
FURTHER CLARIFY THE HOUSING
03:48:09.308 --> 03:48:11.077
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT, WHICH AGAIN?
03:48:11.144 --> 03:48:12.979
WAS A TOOL TO LIMIT THE ABILITY
03:48:13.046 --> 03:48:14.714
OF LOCAL AGENCIES TO DENY
03:48:14.781 --> 03:48:16.082
QUALIFYING HOUSING PROJECTS FROM
03:48:16.149 --> 03:48:16.883
BEING BUILT IN THEIR
03:48:16.949 --> 03:48:19.052
JURISDICTION. WHAT WE DON'T WANT
03:48:19.118 --> 03:48:20.586
IT TO TURN INTO WHICH IS WHAT
03:48:20.653 --> 03:48:23.389
YOU AND I TALKED INTO IS, YOU
03:48:23.456 --> 03:48:24.524
KNOW A SMORGASBORD FOR LAWYERS
03:48:24.590 --> 03:48:25.958
TO SUE CITIES SO WE APPRECIATE
03:48:26.025 --> 03:48:27.660
THE WORK TO FIND THIS
03:48:27.727 --> 03:48:29.429
COMPROMISED. WE THINK THIS IS A
03:48:29.495 --> 03:48:30.830
VERY USEFUL TOOL WE SEE.
03:48:30.897 --> 03:48:33.132
UNFORTUNATELY UH, TOO MANY
03:48:33.199 --> 03:48:34.200
JURISDICTIONS MY CITY ALONE,
03:48:34.267 --> 03:48:37.170
WHICH IS DENIED. HOUSING PROJECT
03:48:37.236 --> 03:48:39.072
KEPT IT TO HOUSING PROJECTS KEPT
03:48:39.138 --> 03:48:40.940
IN LIMBO. SO WE WANT TO MAKE
03:48:41.007 --> 03:48:43.076
SURE THAT UNDER THIS BILL
03:48:43.142 --> 03:48:44.510
PROJECTS THAT HAVE DENIED SECRET
03:48:44.577 --> 03:48:45.411
CLEARANCE, EVEN THOUGH THE
03:48:45.478 --> 03:48:47.346
PROJECT ISN'T IS IN AN URBANIZED
03:48:47.413 --> 03:48:48.381
ZONE HAS MINIMUM ENSITY
03:48:48.448 --> 03:48:49.415
REQUIREMENTS OF 15 UNITS PER
03:48:49.482 --> 03:48:51.784
ACRE. AS MITT REQUIREMENTS FOR
03:48:51.851 --> 03:48:52.952
AN EXEMPTION OR HAS GONE THROUGH
03:48:53.019 --> 03:48:54.020
LEGALLY SUFFICIENT ENVIRONMENTAL
03:48:54.087 --> 03:48:58.791
VIEW IS NOT ALLOWED, AND WE WANT-TO MAKE SURE THAT THESE CRITICAL
03:48:58.858 --> 03:49:00.927
HOUSING PROJECTS, UH, ARE GOING
03:49:00.993 --> 03:49:02.095
THROUGH NOW. THIS DOES NOT
03:49:02.161 --> 03:49:03.262
PRECLUDE A PROJECT FROM GOING
03:49:03.329 --> 03:49:04.964
THROUGH. THE ENVIRONMENTAL
03:49:05.031 --> 03:49:07.366
PROCESS, AND IT DOES NOT EXPAND
03:49:07.433 --> 03:49:09.469
A SECRET EXEMPTION AT ALL. SO
03:49:09.535 --> 03:49:11.137
WITH THAT, RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
03:49:11.204 --> 03:49:14.107
I VOTE ON A B 26 56. WE HAVE TWO
03:49:14.173 --> 03:49:15.208
WITNESSES, MR MICHAEL LANE AND
03:49:15.274 --> 03:49:17.343
CORNELIUS BURKE. VERY GOOD.
03:49:17.410 --> 03:49:19.245
WELCOME THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR,
03:49:19.312 --> 03:49:21.180
MR VICE CHAIR. MICHAEL NAME WAS
03:49:21.247 --> 03:49:23.349
SPUR OF PUBLIC POLICY THINK TANK
03:49:23.416 --> 03:49:24.517
IN THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA.
03:49:24.584 --> 03:49:27.320
26 56 DOES NOT TOUCH SEQUA IN
03:49:27.386 --> 03:49:28.754
ANY WAY, NOR DOES IT ALTER ANY
03:49:28.821 --> 03:49:29.789
EXISTING RIGHTS OR
03:49:29.856 --> 03:49:30.756
RESPONSIBILITIES THAT EXIST IN
03:49:30.823 --> 03:49:31.891
CURRENT LAW WITH REGARD TO THAT
03:49:31.958 --> 03:49:33.893
STATUTE. THIS BILL IN NO WAY
03:49:33.960 --> 03:49:35.495
ELIMINATES OR LIMITS LAWFUL AND
03:49:35.561 --> 03:49:37.096
LEGITIMATE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
03:49:37.163 --> 03:49:38.264
, NOR DOES IT CHANGE SECRET
03:49:38.331 --> 03:49:39.165
TIMELINES OR TRUNCATE THE
03:49:39.232 --> 03:49:41.167
PROCESS. THE FINDINGS AND
03:49:41.234 --> 03:49:42.068
DECLARATIONS WERE INCLUDED IN
03:49:42.135 --> 03:49:43.536
THE BILL TO EXPLICITLY CONVEY
03:49:43.603 --> 03:49:44.971
ITS INTENT TO CLARIFY EXISTING
03:49:45.037 --> 03:49:47.106
LAW AND CODIFY HZDS
03:49:47.173 --> 03:49:47.974
INTERPRETATION OF THE HOUSING
03:49:48.040 --> 03:49:48.975
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT AND ITS
03:49:49.041 --> 03:49:51.577
INTERACTION WITH SEQUA. THE BILL
03:49:51.644 --> 03:49:53.079
DOES NOT EXPAND THE DEFINITION
03:49:53.146 --> 03:49:54.480
OF DISAPPROVAL UNDER THE WHICH
03:49:54.547 --> 03:49:56.616
BOTH THE LEGISLATURE AND THE
03:49:56.682 --> 03:49:58.117
COURTS HAVE FOUND AND RECOGNIZE
03:49:58.184 --> 03:49:59.785
, ALREADY BROADLY INCLUDES THE
03:49:59.852 --> 03:50:01.020
REQUIRED LAND USE APPROVALS OR
03:50:01.087 --> 03:50:01.988
ENTITLEMENTS NECESSARY. FOR THE
03:50:02.054 --> 03:50:05.091
ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING PERMIT.
03:50:05.158 --> 03:50:06.592
WHILE THE DOES NOT EXEMPT
03:50:06.659 --> 03:50:08.194
PROJECT FROM SEQUA. IT ALSO DOES
03:50:08.261 --> 03:50:09.629
NOT AUTHORIZED CITIES TO DENY A
03:50:09.695 --> 03:50:10.930
SECRET CLEARANCE TO WHICH A
03:50:10.997 --> 03:50:12.598
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT IS LEGALLY
03:50:12.665 --> 03:50:14.534
ENTITLED. A B 26 56 MILLION
03:50:14.600 --> 03:50:15.701
REQUIRES THAT A SEQUEL EXEMPTION
03:50:15.768 --> 03:50:17.737
ALREADY ON THE BOOKS. THAT A
03:50:17.803 --> 03:50:19.539
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT IS LEGALLY
03:50:19.605 --> 03:50:20.640
ENTITLED TO BASED ON THE RECORD
03:50:20.706 --> 03:50:23.075
BEFORE THE AGENCY BE GRANTED, OR
03:50:23.142 --> 03:50:25.144
THAT AN E I R OR NEG DECK WITH
03:50:25.211 --> 03:50:26.112
ILLEGALLY SUFFICIENT BASIS IN
03:50:26.179 --> 03:50:28.214
THE RECORD BE ADOPTED. THIS IN
03:50:28.281 --> 03:50:29.248
NO WAY PRECLUDES ADDITIONAL
03:50:29.315 --> 03:50:31.684
STUDY IF THE NEED IS IDENTIFIED.
03:50:31.751 --> 03:50:34.353
THE FACT IS A B 26 56 ONLYSEEKS
03:50:34.420 --> 03:50:35.254
TO ENFORCE THE LAW AROUND
03:50:35.321 --> 03:50:36.355
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW THAT IS
03:50:36.422 --> 03:50:38.157
ALREADY IN STATUTE AND WE
03:50:38.224 --> 03:50:38.791
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I VOTE.
03:50:38.858 --> 03:50:43.329
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GOOD
03:50:43.396 --> 03:50:43.963
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
03:50:44.030 --> 03:50:44.797
THE SENATE GOVERNANCE AND
03:50:44.864 --> 03:50:47.533
FINANCE COMMITTEE. CORNELIS
03:50:47.600 --> 03:50:48.968
BURKE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:50:49.035 --> 03:50:50.403
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION.
03:50:50.469 --> 03:50:52.605
WE ARE THE VOICE OF THE HOME
03:50:52.672 --> 03:50:53.372
BUILDING INDUSTRY WE BUILT ABOUT
03:50:53.439 --> 03:50:55.208
80% OF THE HOMES IN THE STATE.
03:50:55.274 --> 03:50:57.977
WE ARE PROUD TO SUPPORT A B 26
03:50:58.044 --> 03:50:59.478
56, WHICH WE HAVE LABELED THIS
03:50:59.545 --> 03:51:00.680
YEAR AS A HOUSING CREATOR. THIS
03:51:00.746 --> 03:51:05.218
IS A GREAT BILL. A B 26 56 CLUE
03:51:05.284 --> 03:51:06.986
CLOSE A LOOPHOLE IN THE HOUSING
03:51:07.053 --> 03:51:08.221
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT RECENTLY
03:51:08.287 --> 03:51:08.955
CREATED BY SOME TO ADD
03:51:09.021 --> 03:51:10.590
ADDITIONAL STEPS TO CALIFORNIA'S
03:51:10.656 --> 03:51:11.991
ALREADY LENGTHY AND COMPLICATED
03:51:12.058 --> 03:51:15.261
HOUSING APPROVAL PROCESS. IN AN
03:51:15.328 --> 03:51:16.529
EFFORT TO SCUTTLE ADDITIONAL
03:51:16.596 --> 03:51:18.197
HOUSING. SOME JURISDICTIONS HAVE
03:51:18.264 --> 03:51:19.532
REQUIRED FURTHER ENVIRONMENTAL
03:51:19.599 --> 03:51:21.234
STUDY. IN ADDITION TO COMPLYING
03:51:21.300 --> 03:51:23.402
WITH SIKA, WHERE THERE IS NOT A
03:51:23.469 --> 03:51:24.437
LEGALLY SUFFICIENT BASIS FOR
03:51:24.503 --> 03:51:26.372
DOING SO. ALTERNATIVELY SOME
03:51:26.439 --> 03:51:27.707
JURISDICTIONS HAVE DENIED
03:51:27.773 --> 03:51:29.809
EXEMPTION FOR SEQUA, WHERE
03:51:29.875 --> 03:51:31.477
HOUSING PROJECT WAS ELIGIBLE FOR
03:51:31.544 --> 03:51:33.746
AN EXEMPTION. MAYBE 26 26 CLOSES
03:51:33.813 --> 03:51:37.717
THIS ABUSIVE PROCESS. IT IS NOT
03:51:37.783 --> 03:51:39.719
EXEMPT PRODUCTS EQUAL. IT IS NOT
03:51:39.785 --> 03:51:41.487
GET RID OF SEQUA. IT'S A GREAT
03:51:41.554 --> 03:51:42.622
BILL TO STRENGTHEN HOUSING
03:51:42.688 --> 03:51:43.723
ACCOUNTABILITY. FOR THESE
03:51:43.789 --> 03:51:46.325
REASONS AND MORE A B 26 36 IS A
03:51:46.392 --> 03:51:48.327
HOUSING CREATOR. AND WE URGE
03:51:48.394 --> 03:51:49.662
YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
03:51:49.729 --> 03:51:53.399
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MARK'S
03:51:53.466 --> 03:51:54.467
DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:51:54.533 --> 03:51:59.272
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT.
03:51:59.338 --> 03:52:00.773
ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH LIGHTHOUSE
03:52:00.840 --> 03:52:03.109
PUBLIC AFFAIRS HERE ON BEHALF OF
03:52:03.175 --> 03:52:05.278
HABITAT FOR HUMANITY, CALIFORNIA
03:52:05.344 --> 03:52:06.412
CIVIC WELL AND FILLED SAID IN
03:52:06.479 --> 03:52:07.780
COMPANY AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
03:52:07.847 --> 03:52:12.285
VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
03:52:12.351 --> 03:52:13.719
OF THE COMMITTEE JONATHAN AND
03:52:13.786 --> 03:52:15.488
CARVE A HARD ON BEHALF OF COLOR
03:52:15.554 --> 03:52:16.656
FOR INDIAN BE STRONG SUPPORT.
03:52:16.722 --> 03:52:19.592
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MITCH.
03:52:19.659 --> 03:52:21.394
SEEING NO OTHER WITNESSES IN THE
03:52:21.460 --> 03:52:22.862
ROOM WILL MOVE ON TO THE
03:52:22.928 --> 03:52:23.829
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
03:52:23.896 --> 03:52:25.431
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD QUEUE UP
03:52:25.498 --> 03:52:29.335
TESTIMONY. CERTAINLY IF THEY'D
03:52:29.402 --> 03:52:30.836
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B
03:52:30.903 --> 03:52:34.073
26 56, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
03:52:34.140 --> 03:52:36.075
WE'LL GO TO LINE 2 90, PLEASE GO
03:52:36.142 --> 03:52:39.078
AHEAD. THIS IS ADAM BOOK,
03:52:39.145 --> 03:52:39.812
LEONARD FROM CAMPBELL AND
03:52:39.879 --> 03:52:41.747
SENATOR TRICK 15 FOR SOMETHING
03:52:41.814 --> 03:52:42.948
IN B AND SUPPORTIVE. MAYBE 26
03:52:43.015 --> 03:52:47.586
56. THANK YOU. NEXT GO TO LINE
03:52:47.653 --> 03:52:51.324
OR 30, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:52:51.390 --> 03:52:52.792
AFTERNOON. WELCOME HIMSELF,
03:52:52.858 --> 03:52:54.660
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE NBA
03:52:54.727 --> 03:52:55.428
ACTION AND ALL AFFILIATED
03:52:55.494 --> 03:53:00.166
CHAPTERS AND STRONG SUPPORT.
03:53:00.232 --> 03:53:02.234
WE'LL GO TO LINE 5 33, PLEASE GO
03:53:02.301 --> 03:53:05.571
AHEAD. ALL RIGHT. ALISON SHALLOT
03:53:05.638 --> 03:53:06.706
FROM LOS ANGELES FAMILY HOME
03:53:06.772 --> 03:53:08.708
OWNER. STORIES FROM THE FRONT
03:53:08.774 --> 03:53:12.645
LINE. HOLLYWOOD FORWARD AND
03:53:12.712 --> 03:53:14.313
STRONG SUPPORT. PLEASE DO
03:53:14.380 --> 03:53:16.182
EVERYTHING YOU CAN. THANK YOU.
03:53:16.248 --> 03:53:17.350
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT,
03:53:17.416 --> 03:53:22.321
PLEASE. NEXT GO TO LINE UP TO
03:53:22.388 --> 03:53:26.325
72. PLEASE GO AHEAD. CHECKPOSTS
03:53:26.392 --> 03:53:28.327
ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
03:53:28.394 --> 03:53:28.961
COALITION, CALLING IN SUPPORT OF
03:53:29.028 --> 03:53:34.800
INDEED. HE SAID. LINE 5 39,
03:53:34.867 --> 03:53:41.107
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI DEBBIE.
03:53:41.173 --> 03:53:42.108
DEBBIE NELSON WAS SENDING
03:53:42.174 --> 03:53:48.347
VALIUM. THINK. LINE 5 59, PLEASE
03:53:48.414 --> 03:53:54.120
GO AHEAD. HI TECH WITH THE LOS
03:53:54.186 --> 03:53:55.287
ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
03:53:55.354 --> 03:53:58.391
IN SUPPORT. APPLYING FOR 83.
03:53:58.457 --> 03:54:02.728
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HENRY HOOKER,
03:54:02.795 --> 03:54:08.167
SANTA CRUZ, CMB AND SUPPORT. AND
03:54:08.234 --> 03:54:09.735
MADAM CHAIR. NO FURTHER COMMENTS
03:54:09.802 --> 03:54:12.138
IN Q. VERY GOOD. UM I
03:54:12.204 --> 03:54:12.772
UNDERSTAND. THERE'S SOMEONE WHO
03:54:12.838 --> 03:54:15.508
MISSED THE OPPORTUNITY IN THE
03:54:15.574 --> 03:54:16.509
ROOM. SO IF YOU COULD PLEASE
03:54:16.575 --> 03:54:17.610
COME FORWARD. STATE YOUR NAME
03:54:17.676 --> 03:54:20.079
FOR THE RECORD. JENNIFER MENTO
03:54:20.146 --> 03:54:21.247
WITH THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
03:54:21.313 --> 03:54:23.149
CONSORTIUM AND STRONG SUPPORT.
03:54:23.215 --> 03:54:24.817
THANK YOU SO MUCH. APPRECIATE IT
03:54:24.884 --> 03:54:26.018
. NOW WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
03:54:26.085 --> 03:54:30.623
THE OPPOSITION. I HAVE TO. AND
03:54:30.689 --> 03:54:32.625
LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
03:54:32.691 --> 03:54:34.727
KRISTINA KARO FROM THE STATE
03:54:34.794 --> 03:54:36.462
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
03:54:36.529 --> 03:54:37.763
AND JP ROSE FROM THE CENTER FOR
03:54:37.830 --> 03:54:44.069
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY. WELCOME.
03:54:44.136 --> 03:54:45.971
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR. CABALLERO
03:54:46.038 --> 03:54:48.107
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
03:54:48.174 --> 03:54:48.874
NAME IS CRISTINA CARO. I'M HERE
03:54:48.941 --> 03:54:50.743
ON BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING
03:54:50.810 --> 03:54:51.811
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL IN
03:54:51.877 --> 03:54:55.915
OPPOSITION TO A B. 26 56 FOR
03:54:55.981 --> 03:54:58.150
SEVERAL REASONS, AND I WOULD
03:54:58.217 --> 03:55:00.085
ALSO NOTE THAT A CLOSE READING
03:55:00.152 --> 03:55:01.620
OF THE BILL ITSELF ACTUALLY
03:55:01.687 --> 03:55:02.621
DEMONSTRATES THAT MANY OF THE
03:55:02.688 --> 03:55:04.990
STATEMENTS YOU JUST HEARD IN
03:55:05.057 --> 03:55:07.359
SUPPORT ARE ACTUALLY INCORRECT.
03:55:07.426 --> 03:55:09.061
UM, SO FIRST, THIS BILL WOULD
03:55:09.128 --> 03:55:10.563
ACTUALLY REDEFINED LAND USE LOG
03:55:10.629 --> 03:55:13.332
BY CREATING A NEW DEFINITION OF
03:55:13.399 --> 03:55:15.034
PROJECT DISAPPROVAL THAT OCCURS
03:55:15.100 --> 03:55:17.069
SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE OF A
03:55:17.136 --> 03:55:18.037
MANDATORY ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
03:55:18.103 --> 03:55:20.739
PROCESS. SO UNDER THIS BILL,
03:55:20.806 --> 03:55:22.274
AGENCIES WHO MOVE FORWARD WITH
03:55:22.341 --> 03:55:23.709
ADDITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
03:55:23.776 --> 03:55:25.377
FOR HOUSING PROJECT WHEN THEY
03:55:25.444 --> 03:55:27.012
ACTUALLY REASONABLY BELIEVED
03:55:27.079 --> 03:55:29.181
BASED ON THE EVIDENCE, IN THE
03:55:29.248 --> 03:55:31.350
RECORD THAT A PROJECT IS NOT
03:55:31.417 --> 03:55:32.551
EXEMPT FROM SEQUA, OR ADDITIONAL
03:55:32.618 --> 03:55:33.586
MITIGATION IS REQUIRED. WOULD BE
03:55:33.652 --> 03:55:36.322
SUBJECT TO IMMEDIATE LITIGATION
03:55:36.388 --> 03:55:39.425
. FINES OF $10,000 PER UNIT OF
03:55:39.492 --> 03:55:40.793
THE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT AND
03:55:40.860 --> 03:55:42.628
EXPOSURE TO ATTORNEY'S FEES AND
03:55:42.695 --> 03:55:43.729
COSTS SIMPLY FOR COMPLYING WITH
03:55:43.796 --> 03:55:46.398
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. THAT'S AN
03:55:46.465 --> 03:55:47.533
ABSURD RESULT FOR A BILL
03:55:47.600 --> 03:55:51.136
INTENDED TO PROMOTE HOUSING AND
03:55:51.203 --> 03:55:52.171
PURPORTEDLY PROTECT THE
03:55:52.238 --> 03:55:54.306
ENVIRONMENT SO SECOND, THIS BILL
03:55:54.373 --> 03:55:55.608
IS INCONSISTENT WITH EXISTING
03:55:55.674 --> 03:55:58.277
LAW, BOTH SEQUA AND THE HOUSING
03:55:58.344 --> 03:55:59.245
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT PROHIBIT
03:55:59.311 --> 03:55:59.745
AGENCIES FROM APPROVING
03:55:59.812 --> 03:56:02.748
PROJECTS. BEFORE THEY MITIGATE
03:56:02.815 --> 03:56:04.683
THE IMPACTS AND DISCLOSE THOSE
03:56:04.750 --> 03:56:06.552
TO THE PUBLIC. THIS BILL DOES
03:56:06.619 --> 03:56:07.586
THE OPPOSITE. IT ACTUALLY
03:56:07.653 --> 03:56:09.955
REQUIRES IT. STATE LAW ALSO
03:56:10.022 --> 03:56:12.057
REQUIRES ANY LITIGANTS TO
03:56:12.124 --> 03:56:13.859
EXHAUST LOCAL REMEDIES BEFORE
03:56:13.926 --> 03:56:15.961
FILING A LAWSUIT. THIS BILL
03:56:16.028 --> 03:56:17.396
ELEVATES DEVELOPERS OVER THAT
03:56:17.463 --> 03:56:19.265
REQUIREMENT AND ALLOWS THEM TO
03:56:19.331 --> 03:56:21.800
FILE SUIT RIGHT AWAY. UM STATE
03:56:21.867 --> 03:56:22.935
LAW AND THE AMENDMENTS,
03:56:23.002 --> 03:56:25.804
ACTUALLY, UM A NEW LEGAL
03:56:25.871 --> 03:56:27.840
STANDARDS THEY ACTUALLY DO ADD
03:56:27.907 --> 03:56:28.741
EXPRESSED NEW ENVIRONMENTAL
03:56:28.807 --> 03:56:31.110
EXEMPTIONS, AND THEY ADD ERRATIC
03:56:31.176 --> 03:56:33.345
NEW TIMELINES THAT ARE
03:56:33.412 --> 03:56:35.447
CONTRADICTORY TO THE TIMELINES
03:56:35.514 --> 03:56:37.283
AND THE PROCEDURES SET FORTH IN
03:56:37.349 --> 03:56:39.585
BOTH SEQUEL AND OTHER STATE
03:56:39.652 --> 03:56:41.820
LAWS. THIRD THIS BILL ELEVATES
03:56:41.887 --> 03:56:43.222
THE RIGHTS OF DEVELOPERS OVER
03:56:43.289 --> 03:56:45.324
OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC BY
03:56:45.391 --> 03:56:46.859
ALLOWING THE DEVELOPER TO DECIDE
03:56:46.926 --> 03:56:48.460
WHEN ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW SHOULD
03:56:48.527 --> 03:56:50.129
BE COMPLETE, RATHER THAN THE
03:56:50.195 --> 03:56:51.230
AGENCY THAT HAS THE
03:56:51.297 --> 03:56:52.231
RESPONSIBILITY TO APPROVE THE
03:56:52.298 --> 03:56:54.967
PROJECT. THERE'S ALSO THREATENS
03:56:55.034 --> 03:56:56.569
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION BECAUSE IT
03:56:56.635 --> 03:56:58.137
WOULD MAKE IT ILLEGAL FOR AN
03:56:58.203 --> 03:57:00.005
AGENCY TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
03:57:00.072 --> 03:57:01.840
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW IN RESPONSE
03:57:01.907 --> 03:57:03.609
TO PUBLIC COMMENTS, WHICH IS A
03:57:03.676 --> 03:57:05.611
PROCEDURE MANDATED BY SEQUA.
03:57:05.678 --> 03:57:10.249
FINALLY, UH. AND ALSO, I WOULD
03:57:10.316 --> 03:57:11.584
WANT TO NOTE THAT LITIGATION
03:57:11.650 --> 03:57:13.252
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE
03:57:13.319 --> 03:57:16.422
SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF NEW
03:57:16.488 --> 03:57:17.856
LITIGATION THAT WILL BE FILED.
03:57:17.923 --> 03:57:19.592
WE'LL PUT A BURDEN ON STATE
03:57:19.658 --> 03:57:22.294
FUNDED COURT RESOURCES. UM AND
03:57:22.361 --> 03:57:23.829
AS A LAST POINT, YOU KNOW,
03:57:23.896 --> 03:57:25.230
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IS A
03:57:25.297 --> 03:57:26.231
REQUIREMENT. ENVIRONMENTAL
03:57:26.298 --> 03:57:27.333
REVIEW IS A REQUIREMENT. IT'S
03:57:27.399 --> 03:57:30.169
NOT A PROBLEM. WE HAVE 40 YEARS
03:57:30.235 --> 03:57:31.704
OF CALIFORNIA HISTORY, WHICH
03:57:31.770 --> 03:57:32.805
DEMONSTRATE THAT PROJECTS THAT
03:57:32.871 --> 03:57:35.641
COMPLY WITH SEQUA ARE SAFER,
03:57:35.708 --> 03:57:37.409
CLEANER, MORE SUSTAINABLE AND
03:57:37.476 --> 03:57:38.644
THEY MITIGATE ENVIRONMENTAL AND
03:57:38.711 --> 03:57:41.180
PUBLIC HEALTH EFFECTS. THOUSANDS
03:57:41.246 --> 03:57:43.315
OF PROJECTS ARE APPROVED AFTER
03:57:43.382 --> 03:57:44.717
ADDITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
03:57:44.783 --> 03:57:46.518
AND THEN THEY'RE BUILT. THAT'S
03:57:46.585 --> 03:57:48.687
STANDARD PRACTICE IN THE STATE.
03:57:48.754 --> 03:57:50.823
THIS BILL IDENTIFIES AN UNLIKELY
03:57:50.889 --> 03:57:52.992
SITUATION WHERE AN AGENCY WOULD
03:57:53.058 --> 03:57:54.560
DELIBERATELY DELAY A PROJECT
03:57:54.627 --> 03:57:56.962
WITHOUT ANY EVIDENCE ON WHICH TO
03:57:57.029 --> 03:57:58.464
DO SO. AND THERE ARE EXISTING
03:57:58.530 --> 03:58:00.232
REMEDIES IN THE LAW FOR THAT.
03:58:00.299 --> 03:58:02.835
UNDER DUE PROCESS LAW, SO THIS
03:58:02.901 --> 03:58:04.236
BILL IS UNNECESSARY AND IT
03:58:04.303 --> 03:58:05.104
THREATENS ENVIRONMENTAL
03:58:05.170 --> 03:58:07.506
PROTECTION. EXCUSE ME. WE URGE
03:58:07.573 --> 03:58:08.774
YOU TO VOTE NOW. THANK YOU VERY
03:58:08.841 --> 03:58:11.710
MUCH. IS THIS AFTERNOON, MADAM
03:58:11.777 --> 03:58:15.047
CHAIR. GO AHEAD. I'M SORRY. I
03:58:15.114 --> 03:58:16.949
DIDN'T. YES, I MISSED. YOU WERE
03:58:17.016 --> 03:58:18.684
ON THE PHONE APOLOGIZE.
03:58:18.751 --> 03:58:21.220
WONDERFUL MY NAME IS J. P. ROSE
03:58:21.286 --> 03:58:22.755
SENIOR ATTORNEY AND POLICY
03:58:22.821 --> 03:58:23.789
DIRECTOR AT THE CENTER FOR
03:58:23.856 --> 03:58:25.724
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY AND FIRST
03:58:25.791 --> 03:58:27.693
OFF. I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT WE
03:58:27.760 --> 03:58:29.395
STRONGLY SUPPORT IN THE FIELD
03:58:29.461 --> 03:58:30.362
DEVELOPMENT THAT ADDRESSES THE
03:58:30.429 --> 03:58:31.296
STATE'S AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:58:31.363 --> 03:58:33.032
CRISIS. HOWEVER, WE OPPOSE THIS
03:58:33.098 --> 03:58:34.166
BILL BECAUSE THEY WILL UNDERMINE
03:58:34.233 --> 03:58:36.001
COMMUNITY'S ABILITY TO HAVE A
03:58:36.068 --> 03:58:37.403
VOICE IN DECISION MAKING, AND IT
03:58:37.469 --> 03:58:38.971
WILL DRIVE TO THESE TO APPROVE
03:58:39.038 --> 03:58:39.471
HARMFUL PROJECTS WITHOUT
03:58:39.538 --> 03:58:42.441
ENVIRONMENT WITH MITIGATION.
03:58:42.508 --> 03:58:44.977
PRIMARY PROBLEM WITH THIS BILL
03:58:45.044 --> 03:58:45.544
IS IT WOULD RHETORIC, CITY
03:58:45.611 --> 03:58:48.013
COMPLIANCE OR ATTEMPTS TO COMPLY
03:58:48.080 --> 03:58:48.580
WITH THE STATE'S KEY
03:58:48.647 --> 03:58:50.282
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW AS NON
03:58:50.349 --> 03:58:51.583
COMPLIANCE WITH THE STATE'S KEY
03:58:51.650 --> 03:58:53.252
HOUSING LAW, IT WOULD GIVE
03:58:53.318 --> 03:58:55.320
DEVELOPERS THE ABILITY TO SUE
03:58:55.387 --> 03:58:56.388
CITIES SIMPLY FOR TRYING TO
03:58:56.455 --> 03:58:58.223
COMPLY WITH EQUAL. OR SOME OF
03:58:58.290 --> 03:58:59.892
THESE CASES WILL END UP CLOGGING
03:58:59.958 --> 03:59:01.260
THE COURTS. THE BILL WOULD ALSO
03:59:01.326 --> 03:59:03.095
HAVE A CHILLING EFFECT ON UNDER
03:59:03.162 --> 03:59:04.963
RESOURCED CITIES. WHEN FACED
03:59:05.030 --> 03:59:05.798
WITH A DECISION WHETHER TO
03:59:05.864 --> 03:59:07.966
UNDERGO NECESSARY ENVIRONMENTAL
03:59:08.033 --> 03:59:09.501
REVIEW OR RISK POTENTIAL
03:59:09.568 --> 03:59:11.270
LITIGATION BY DEEP POCKETED
03:59:11.336 --> 03:59:12.905
DEVELOPERS. MANY CITIES WILL
03:59:12.971 --> 03:59:14.306
BUCKLE UNDER THE PRESSURE IS
03:59:14.373 --> 03:59:16.308
SKIP ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. THE
03:59:16.375 --> 03:59:17.743
PUBLIC WILL LOSE OUT ON A
03:59:17.810 --> 03:59:19.778
TRANSPARENT PROCESS AND
03:59:19.845 --> 03:59:20.779
IMPORTANT PUBLIC HEALTH AND
03:59:20.846 --> 03:59:22.214
SAFETY ISSUES THAT SECRETLY
03:59:22.281 --> 03:59:23.348
DESIGNED TO ADDRESS THE SWEPT
03:59:23.415 --> 03:59:26.185
UNDER THE RUG. THE BILL HAVE
03:59:26.251 --> 03:59:28.620
OTHER UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES,
03:59:28.687 --> 03:59:29.621
INCLUDING INCREASED APPROVAL OF
03:59:29.688 --> 03:59:31.957
DEVELOPMENT IN WILDFIRES. AN.
03:59:32.024 --> 03:59:33.192
AS OUTLINED IN THE CENTER'S
03:59:33.258 --> 03:59:35.594
REPORT BUILT TO BURN DEVELOPMENT
03:59:35.661 --> 03:59:37.129
AND HIGH FIRE RISK, WILDLANDS
03:59:37.196 --> 03:59:38.997
AND CALIFORNIA IS GETTING
03:59:39.064 --> 03:59:40.299
PUTTING MORE PEOPLE IN HARM'S
03:59:40.365 --> 03:59:41.300
WAY AND DRIVING UP FIRE
03:59:41.366 --> 03:59:42.568
SUPPRESSION COSTS. THE BILL
03:59:42.634 --> 03:59:44.970
ANALYSIS CORRECTLY NOTES HUMANS
03:59:45.037 --> 03:59:46.038
DO NOT MEANINGFULLY EXCLUDED
03:59:46.105 --> 03:59:48.974
PROJECTS IN FAR ZONES. CITIES
03:59:49.041 --> 03:59:50.375
MUST BE ALLOWED TO STUDY AND
03:59:50.442 --> 03:59:51.977
DISCLOSE THE RISKS OF SUCH
03:59:52.044 --> 03:59:53.378
DEVELOPMENT, AS REQUIRED BY
03:59:53.445 --> 03:59:55.347
SEQUA WITHOUT FEAR OF BEING SUED
03:59:55.414 --> 03:59:57.583
BY DEVELOPERS FOR UNDUE DELAY. I
03:59:57.649 --> 03:59:59.651
DON'T KNOW, LIKE TO KNOW THAT
03:59:59.718 --> 04:00:01.286
THE BILL IS A SOLUTION IN SEARCH
04:00:01.353 --> 04:00:02.588
OF A PROBLEM. A SINGLE CASE IN
04:00:02.654 --> 04:00:04.757
SAN FRANCISCO DOES NOT WARRANT
04:00:04.823 --> 04:00:05.758
DISRUPTING THE BALANCE BETWEEN
04:00:05.824 --> 04:00:06.792
THE STATE'S HOUSING AND
04:00:06.859 --> 04:00:07.993
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS THAT HAS BEEN
04:00:08.060 --> 04:00:10.262
IN PLACE FOR MANY YEARS. PLUS A
04:00:10.329 --> 04:00:12.231
RECENT REPORT COMMENTS SECRET IS
04:00:12.297 --> 04:00:13.298
NOT A MAJOR BARRIER TEAM
04:00:13.365 --> 04:00:14.900
DEVELOPMENT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
04:00:14.967 --> 04:00:16.468
TIME. I RESPECTFULLY
04:00:16.535 --> 04:00:17.402
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOU DON'T
04:00:17.469 --> 04:00:19.905
DO IT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
04:00:19.972 --> 04:00:22.141
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2100
04:00:22.207 --> 04:00:23.308
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:00:23.375 --> 04:00:26.712
OPPOSITION. MR MODERATOR, CAN
04:00:26.779 --> 04:00:29.248
YOU CUE UP ANYBODY ON THE LINE
04:00:29.314 --> 04:00:30.415
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:00:30.482 --> 04:00:32.184
OPPOSITION? CERTAINLY AND IF
04:00:32.251 --> 04:00:33.619
THEY LIKE SPEAKING OPPOSITION TO
04:00:33.685 --> 04:00:36.789
A B 26 56, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
04:00:36.855 --> 04:00:37.956
DOUBLE THE LINE. 50, PLEASE GO
04:00:38.023 --> 04:00:43.195
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, TRACY
04:00:43.262 --> 04:00:44.229
RYAN WITH THE RURAL COUNTY
04:00:44.296 --> 04:00:46.198
REPRESENTATIVE CALIFORNIA, ALSO
04:00:46.265 --> 04:00:47.232
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
04:00:47.299 --> 04:00:48.667
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES IN
04:00:48.734 --> 04:00:50.702
THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES
04:00:50.769 --> 04:00:52.304
. WE HAVE NO FORMAL POSITION ON
04:00:52.371 --> 04:00:55.140
A B 26 56. HOWEVER I WOULD LIKE
04:00:55.207 --> 04:00:56.208
TO CONVEY OUR APPRECIATION TO
04:00:56.275 --> 04:00:58.210
THE AUTHOR. HIS STAFF BILL
04:00:58.277 --> 04:01:00.179
SPONSORS AND COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
04:01:00.245 --> 04:01:01.613
THE MANY HOURS OF COLLABORATION
04:01:01.680 --> 04:01:03.115
WITH OUR ORGANIZATIONS TO TRY TO
04:01:03.182 --> 04:01:04.616
FIND A COMPROMISE THAT WOULD
04:01:04.683 --> 04:01:05.150
ADDRESS LOCAL GOVERNMENT
04:01:05.217 --> 04:01:07.019
CONCERNS THAT THIS BILL MOVES
04:01:07.085 --> 04:01:08.353
FORWARD TODAY. WE WOULD JUST
04:01:08.420 --> 04:01:09.354
LIKE TO CONTINUE THOSE
04:01:09.421 --> 04:01:10.622
CONVERSATIONS. THANK YOU. THANK
04:01:10.689 --> 04:01:14.259
YOU VERY MUCH. AND GO TO LINE 5
04:01:14.326 --> 04:01:18.697
68, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
04:01:18.764 --> 04:01:21.700
AFTERNOON, SENATORS AGAIN.
04:01:21.767 --> 04:01:22.201
MATTHEW BAKER SPENDING
04:01:22.267 --> 04:01:23.602
CONSERVATION LEÓN OPPOSITION.
04:01:23.669 --> 04:01:28.473
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND MADAM
04:01:28.540 --> 04:01:30.042
CHAIR. NO FURTHER COMMENTS AND
04:01:30.108 --> 04:01:31.577
QUÊ. THANK YOU. SO WE'RE GOING
04:01:31.643 --> 04:01:33.579
TO BRING THE MATTER BACK TO THE
04:01:33.645 --> 04:01:34.580
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS OR
04:01:34.646 --> 04:01:37.149
CONCERNS? UM AS ASSEMBLY MEMBER,
04:01:37.216 --> 04:01:43.689
THE THEM. MOCK UP SO WELL. I
04:01:43.755 --> 04:01:45.057
APPRECIATE ALL THE TESTIMONY
04:01:45.123 --> 04:01:47.993
HERE TODAY, AND I THINK WHAT WE
04:01:48.060 --> 04:01:49.027
WERE. THERE WERE SOME GOALS THAT
04:01:49.094 --> 04:01:51.029
WE WERE TRYING TO ACHIEVE. MAKE
04:01:51.096 --> 04:01:54.032
SURE THAT, UM THAT THAT IF AN
04:01:54.099 --> 04:01:56.335
ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT IS DOES
04:01:56.401 --> 04:01:57.803
NOT HAVE SUFFICIENT INFORMATION
04:01:57.870 --> 04:01:59.972
THAT THERE WAS THE ABILITY TO GO
04:02:00.038 --> 04:02:02.207
BACK AND DO MORE WORK ON IT, AND
04:02:02.274 --> 04:02:03.442
THE COUNCIL HAD THAT, UH, THAT
04:02:03.508 --> 04:02:07.746
OPPORTUNITY. AS WELL AS, UM,
04:02:07.813 --> 04:02:10.048
MAKING SURE THAT THERE THIS DOES
04:02:10.115 --> 04:02:12.317
NOT SET UP A LITIGATION CHAIN
04:02:12.384 --> 04:02:13.886
WHERE THE ONLY PEOPLE MAKING
04:02:13.952 --> 04:02:15.053
MONEY ARE ATTORNEYS. UM AND THE
04:02:15.120 --> 04:02:21.960
AGREED. UM PROVISIONS. UM AND
04:02:22.027 --> 04:02:23.629
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG, WOULD
04:02:23.695 --> 04:02:25.597
EXCLUDE VERY HIGH FIRE HAZARD
04:02:25.664 --> 04:02:28.200
SEVERITY ZONES WOULD NARROW THE
04:02:28.267 --> 04:02:31.069
URBANIZED AREA DEFINITION. ALLOW
04:02:31.136 --> 04:02:32.704
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. AS I SAID, TO
04:02:32.771 --> 04:02:33.605
REQUIRE MY MORE STUDY. IF
04:02:33.672 --> 04:02:35.107
THERE'S A FAIR ARGUMENT THAT
04:02:35.173 --> 04:02:36.975
IT'S NECESSARY TO IDENTIFY
04:02:37.042 --> 04:02:39.311
SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS, CLARIFY
04:02:39.378 --> 04:02:41.413
THAT AND YOU USUAL CIRCUMSTANCES
04:02:41.480 --> 04:02:43.382
CAN STILL APPLY TO CATEGORY
04:02:43.448 --> 04:02:46.218
CATEGORICAL EXEMPTIONS. UM
04:02:46.285 --> 04:02:47.386
DELETE NEW STANDARDS FOR
04:02:47.452 --> 04:02:49.187
REASONABLE CONSTRUCTION OF
04:02:49.254 --> 04:02:50.722
APPLICABLE LAW LIMITED
04:02:50.789 --> 04:02:52.224
ATTORNEY'S FEES WHEN THE LOCAL
04:02:52.291 --> 04:02:54.259
GOVERNMENT DESIGN DENIES A
04:02:54.326 --> 04:02:55.661
CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION IN GOOD
04:02:55.727 --> 04:02:56.662
FAIT AND OTHER TECHNICAL AND
04:02:56.728 --> 04:03:00.098
CLARIFYING AMENDMENTS. UM SO I
04:03:00.165 --> 04:03:04.636
GUESS I LET YOU ASK YOU TO, UM,
04:03:04.703 --> 04:03:07.005
UM, TO ADDRESS THE ISSUES THAT
04:03:07.072 --> 04:03:08.473
HAVE BEEN RAISED, IF YOU WOULD
04:03:08.540 --> 04:03:10.676
LIKE TO IN CONCLUSION, AND THEN
04:03:10.742 --> 04:03:12.477
WHEN WE GET MEMBERS BACK, WE CAN
04:03:12.544 --> 04:03:14.579
, UH, TAKE UP EMOTION OR AND
04:03:14.646 --> 04:03:16.081
VOTE ON IT. IF THAT'S
04:03:16.148 --> 04:03:18.350
APPROPRIATE, HAVE HAPPY TO, UM
04:03:18.417 --> 04:03:20.819
AH, THOSE AMENDMENTS ARE EXACTLY
04:03:20.886 --> 04:03:22.087
WHAT YOU AND I DISCUSSED. WE
04:03:22.154 --> 04:03:23.956
THINK IT REALLY ADDRESSES. UH
04:03:24.022 --> 04:03:25.557
YOUR CONCERN TO ENSURE THAT
04:03:25.624 --> 04:03:26.792
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN CONTINUE
04:03:26.858 --> 04:03:28.727
TO DO THEIR ENVIRONMENTAL WORK.
04:03:28.794 --> 04:03:30.829
BUT ALSO NOT HAVE THE RISK OF
04:03:30.896 --> 04:03:31.930
BEING SUED, WHICH I THINK IS
04:03:31.997 --> 04:03:33.298
EXACTLY WHERE WE'RE GOING WITH
04:03:33.365 --> 04:03:34.733
THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION WITH
04:03:34.800 --> 04:03:36.201
THE LEGISLATION DOES IS ENSURE
04:03:36.268 --> 04:03:38.337
THAT WE COMPLY WITH SICKLE. WE
04:03:38.403 --> 04:03:39.571
IMPLY WITH ALL THE ENVIRONMENTAL
04:03:39.638 --> 04:03:41.440
REGULATIONS, BUT THAT HOUSING
04:03:41.506 --> 04:03:42.474
PROJECTS DON'T GET STUCK IN
04:03:42.541 --> 04:03:45.344
BUREAUCRATIC PURGATORY. WE WANT
04:03:45.410 --> 04:03:47.112
TO MAKE SURE THAT HOUSING
04:03:47.179 --> 04:03:47.813
HOUSING PROJECTS ARE ASKED TO
04:03:47.879 --> 04:03:50.082
COMPLY WITH SECRET DO ALL THEIR
04:03:50.148 --> 04:03:50.716
ENVIRONMENTAL WORK. BUT AGAIN,
04:03:50.782 --> 04:03:52.884
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WHEN
04:03:52.951 --> 04:03:55.153
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE ASKING
04:03:55.220 --> 04:03:56.088
FOR THAT WORK THAT IT REALLY HAS
04:03:56.154 --> 04:03:57.322
TO DO WITH SEQUENCE THAT SOME
04:03:57.389 --> 04:03:57.889
ULTERIOR MOTIVE OR ULTERIOR
04:03:57.956 --> 04:04:00.592
POLITICAL AGENDA. SO AGAIN VERY
04:04:00.659 --> 04:04:02.094
MUCH APPRECIATE YOUR HELP YOUR
04:04:02.160 --> 04:04:03.628
COMMITTEE'S HELP HAPPY TO TAKE
04:04:03.695 --> 04:04:05.397
THOSE AMENDMENTS AS YOU STATED,
04:04:05.464 --> 04:04:06.698
AND WE RESPECT FOR US RIVAL AND
04:04:06.765 --> 04:04:07.866
MAYBE 26 56. THANK YOU VERY
04:04:07.933 --> 04:04:10.602
MUCH. AND WE'LL TAKE IT UP. WHEN
04:04:10.669 --> 04:04:12.137
THEY RETURNING MEMBERS. THEY'RE
04:04:12.204 --> 04:04:13.205
VOTING IN ANOTHER COMMITTEE, SO
04:04:13.271 --> 04:04:14.139
IT'S NOT THAT IT'S NOTHING
04:04:14.206 --> 04:04:15.073
PERSONAL. NOTHING PERSONAL.
04:04:15.140 --> 04:04:19.711
PRETTY GOOD. ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
04:04:19.778 --> 04:04:28.820
EDUARDO GARCIA. WELCOME. GOOD
04:04:28.887 --> 04:04:32.591
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR. UM FILE
04:04:32.657 --> 04:04:35.994
ITEM NUMBER 27. MAYBE 28 87.
04:04:36.061 --> 04:04:37.162
THANK YOU. THIS BILL WOULD
04:04:37.229 --> 04:04:39.031
INCREASE THE LIMIT OF THE SALES
04:04:39.097 --> 04:04:40.065
TAX EXCLUSION PROGRAM.
04:04:40.132 --> 04:04:41.533
ADMINISTER BY THE TREASURER'S
04:04:41.600 --> 04:04:43.268
OFFICE FROM 100 MILLION TO 150
04:04:43.335 --> 04:04:46.705
MILLION DOLLARS. RECOGNIZING
04:04:46.772 --> 04:04:47.806
THIS OPPORTUNITY I ALONG WITH
04:04:47.873 --> 04:04:50.709
SENATOR WEST SO ADMINISTRATION
04:04:50.776 --> 04:04:53.078
COMMUNITIES AROUND OUR REGION
04:04:53.145 --> 04:04:56.081
HAVE FOCUSED, UM, THIS PROGRAM
04:04:56.148 --> 04:04:58.016
IN AND AROUND THE CONVERSATIONS
04:04:58.083 --> 04:04:59.251
TAKING PLACE AS IT RELATES TO
04:04:59.317 --> 04:05:01.086
LITHIUM. AND LITHIUM ECONOMIC
04:05:01.153 --> 04:05:02.020
DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR
04:05:02.087 --> 04:05:04.856
THE STATE. RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
04:05:04.923 --> 04:05:06.725
YOUR EYEBALL ON THIS BILL. VERY
04:05:06.792 --> 04:05:08.326
GOOD. YOU HAVE HIS ELITE SUPPORT
04:05:08.393 --> 04:05:10.095
. WITNESS V<c.cyan>. JOHN WHITE FROM</c>
04:05:10.162 --> 04:05:11.997
CLEAN POWER CAMPAIGN WHO IS HERE
04:05:12.064 --> 04:05:14.332
IN PERSON? WELCOME WHITE MADAM
04:05:14.399 --> 04:05:15.767
CHAIR FROM CLINT POWER CAMPAIGN
04:05:15.834 --> 04:05:16.868
. WE SUPPORT THIS BILL BECAUSE
04:05:16.935 --> 04:05:18.503
WE THINK THAT THE DEVELOPMENT OF
04:05:18.570 --> 04:05:19.771
A DOMESTIC CALIFORNIA LITHIUM
04:05:19.838 --> 04:05:20.872
INDUSTRY IS AN EXTRAORDINARY
04:05:20.939 --> 04:05:24.076
OPPORTUNITY. AND THIS INCENTIVE
04:05:24.142 --> 04:05:26.445
BY EXPANDING IT, AND ASSUMING
04:05:26.511 --> 04:05:28.213
THAT THE PROJECTS CAN MEET THE
04:05:28.280 --> 04:05:31.016
CONDITIONS IN THE EXISTING LAW,
04:05:31.083 --> 04:05:32.350
PROVIDING SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC
04:05:32.417 --> 04:05:34.352
AND EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AS
04:05:34.419 --> 04:05:35.687
JUSTIFICATION FOR THIS EXEMPTION
04:05:35.754 --> 04:05:36.855
, SO WE SUPPORT THE EXPANSION
04:05:36.922 --> 04:05:38.723
WITH ASKED FOR AND I VOTE. VERY
04:05:38.790 --> 04:05:42.194
GOOD. IS THERE ANYBODY IN THIS
04:05:42.260 --> 04:05:43.395
ROOM ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE
04:05:43.462 --> 04:05:46.565
TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT. CHAIR
04:05:46.631 --> 04:05:48.400
MEMBERS DAN CHOI ON BEHALF OF
04:05:48.467 --> 04:05:50.202
ARRIVAL. AUTOMOTIVE INSTRUCTION.
04:05:50.268 --> 04:05:52.170
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
04:05:52.237 --> 04:05:56.074
ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2100? SEEING
04:05:56.141 --> 04:05:58.110
NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
04:05:58.176 --> 04:05:59.111
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR MODERATE
04:05:59.177 --> 04:05:59.744
IF YOU COULD PROMPT ANYONE WHO
04:05:59.811 --> 04:06:03.982
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY. CERTAINLY
04:06:04.049 --> 04:06:05.717
IT SEEMS LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:06:05.784 --> 04:06:06.985
SUPPORT OF A B 28 87 PLEASE
04:06:07.052 --> 04:06:15.260
PRESS 10. AND THE ONE MOMENT
04:06:15.327 --> 04:06:16.394
MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE A LINE
04:06:16.461 --> 04:06:29.074
COMING IN.
04:06:29.141 --> 04:06:31.176
AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 5 76,
04:06:31.243 --> 04:06:34.479
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
04:06:34.546 --> 04:06:35.981
ANESTHESIA CABAL TRICK WITH
04:06:36.047 --> 04:06:37.549
CALIFORNIA ADVISORS BEHALF OF
04:06:37.616 --> 04:06:39.017
BIOENERGY ASSOCIATION OF
04:06:39.084 --> 04:06:40.652
CALIFORNIA ENERGY SOURCE
04:06:40.719 --> 04:06:41.987
MINERALS AND SUPPORTIVE, MAYBE
04:06:42.053 --> 04:06:42.854
2087. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
04:06:42.921 --> 04:06:48.160
MUCH. AND MADAM CHAIR. NO
04:06:48.226 --> 04:06:50.095
FURTHER COMMENTS IN Q. VERY
04:06:50.162 --> 04:06:51.196
GOOD. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
04:06:51.263 --> 04:06:52.731
OPPOSITION. WE HAVE NO LEAD
04:06:52.797 --> 04:06:55.033
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IDENTIFIED
04:06:55.100 --> 04:06:56.201
. LET'S SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY
04:06:56.268 --> 04:06:58.336
IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
04:06:58.403 --> 04:07:00.572
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. SAYING
04:07:00.639 --> 04:07:01.773
NONE. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
04:07:01.840 --> 04:07:05.310
QUEUE UP PEOPLE WHO WOULD LIKE
04:07:05.377 --> 04:07:06.411
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION ON THE
04:07:06.478 --> 04:07:08.880
TELECONFERENCE LINE. AND IF
04:07:08.947 --> 04:07:10.549
THEY'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:07:10.615 --> 04:07:12.651
OPPOSITION OF A B 28 87, PLEASE
04:07:12.717 --> 04:07:23.562
PRESS 10. AND MADAM CHAIR. WE
04:07:23.628 --> 04:07:24.696
HAVE ONE LINE COMING INTO ME
04:07:24.763 --> 04:07:39.578
JUST ONE MOMENT.
04:07:39.644 --> 04:07:41.646
AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 4 29,
04:07:41.713 --> 04:07:44.683
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU,
04:07:44.749 --> 04:07:45.984
MADAM. CHAIR MEMBERS JUMPING
04:07:46.051 --> 04:07:46.618
OVER THE CALIFORNIA STATUS
04:07:46.685 --> 04:07:47.619
VISITATION ACCOMPANIES
04:07:47.686 --> 04:07:48.753
RESPECTFULLY IN OPPOSED UNLESS
04:07:48.820 --> 04:07:54.593
AMENDED POSITION. VERY GOOD.
04:07:54.659 --> 04:07:55.961
MADAME PIERRE NO FOR NO FURTHER
04:07:56.027 --> 04:07:58.296
COMMENTS IN Q. VERY GOOD. UM,
04:07:58.363 --> 04:08:01.766
THAT CONCLUDES OUR TESTIMONY AND
04:08:01.833 --> 04:08:03.635
OPPOSITION WILL BRING IT BACK TO
04:08:03.702 --> 04:08:05.003
THE COMMITTEE. THERE ARE NO
04:08:05.070 --> 04:08:06.605
QUESTIONS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WOULD
04:08:06.671 --> 04:08:09.407
YOU LIKE TO CONCLUDE? THANK YOU
04:08:09.474 --> 04:08:10.408
AGAIN FOR YOUR COMMITTEE
04:08:10.475 --> 04:08:12.277
ANALYSIS AND THE RIGHT TIME
04:08:12.344 --> 04:08:14.179
ASKED FOR NAVAL. THANK YOU SO
04:08:14.246 --> 04:08:21.353
MUCH. APPRECIATE IT. WE ARE
04:08:21.419 --> 04:08:28.760
GOING. WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A 10
04:08:28.827 --> 04:08:29.794
MINUTE RECESS. GIVE EVERYBODY A
04:08:29.861 --> 04:08:32.364
CHANCE TO CATCH THEIR BREATH AND
04:08:32.430 --> 04:08:32.998
USUALLY UTILITIES AND WE'LL BE
04:08:33.064 --> 04:08:40.905
BACK. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:08:42.507 --> 04:08:44.242
WELL GOOD AFTERNOON,
04:08:44.309 --> 04:08:46.411
EVERYBODY. WE TOOK A BREAK TO
04:08:46.478 --> 04:08:48.980
WAIT FOR AUTHORS AND, UM, THAT
04:08:49.047 --> 04:08:50.882
GAVE US A CHANCE TO USE ALL OF
04:08:50.949 --> 04:08:53.251
THE SERVICES. UM I DID PROMISE
04:08:53.318 --> 04:08:55.387
SINCE I PASSED ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:08:55.453 --> 04:08:56.988
LEVIN ON THE WAY OUT, AND HE
04:08:57.055 --> 04:08:58.156
ASSURED ME HIS BILL WAS VERY
04:08:58.223 --> 04:09:00.659
QUICK. THAT I WOULD TAKE HIM UP
04:09:00.725 --> 04:09:03.061
OUT OF ORDER. SO I WILL DO THAT
04:09:03.128 --> 04:09:05.030
AND WE'LL WE'LL GET GOING. WE
04:09:05.096 --> 04:09:06.164
STARTED THIS MORNING AT NINE
04:09:06.231 --> 04:09:09.834
O'CLOCK, SO UM, WE ARE. WE ARE
04:09:09.901 --> 04:09:12.003
INTERESTED IN BREVITY. SO
04:09:12.070 --> 04:09:13.538
WELCOME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:09:13.605 --> 04:09:15.140
MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU. SENATORS
04:09:15.206 --> 04:09:16.474
THIS IS A BROWN ACT BILL AND A
04:09:16.541 --> 04:09:17.776
RECENT COURT CASE IN PLASTIC
04:09:17.842 --> 04:09:18.677
COUNTY COUNTY CHALLENGE THE
04:09:18.743 --> 04:09:19.577
COUNTY'S AUTHORITY TO MAKE
04:09:19.644 --> 04:09:21.146
SUPPLEMENTAL DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE
04:09:21.212 --> 04:09:22.547
TO THE PUBLIC. THIS DECISION HAS
04:09:22.614 --> 04:09:24.215
BEEN FISCALLY AND PRACTICAL AND
04:09:24.282 --> 04:09:25.684
DIFFICULT TO COMPLY WITH DURING
04:09:25.750 --> 04:09:27.719
THE PANDEMIC, AND SO THIS BILL
04:09:27.786 --> 04:09:28.787
OFFERS FLEXIBILITY TO LOCAL
04:09:28.853 --> 04:09:29.287
GOVERNMENTS BY ALLOWING
04:09:29.354 --> 04:09:32.324
DISTRIBUTION ONLINE. UM AS LONG
04:09:32.390 --> 04:09:33.825
AS THEY MAKE AVAILABLE IN PERSON
04:09:33.892 --> 04:09:35.026
AT A LOCAL GOVERNMENT OFFICE THE
04:09:35.093 --> 04:09:36.861
NEXT BUSINESS DAY. THE MEASURE
04:09:36.928 --> 04:09:38.363
IS NO OPPOSITION, AND THIS IS
04:09:38.430 --> 04:09:39.864
SUPPORTED BY A LARGE COALITION
04:09:39.931 --> 04:09:40.865
OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT GROUPS WITH
04:09:40.932 --> 04:09:42.534
ME TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT IS
04:09:42.600 --> 04:09:43.802
SARAH DUCAT FROM THE RURAL
04:09:43.868 --> 04:09:44.869
COUNTIES. REPRESENTATIVES OF
04:09:44.936 --> 04:09:45.837
CALIFORNIA I RESPECT LAST ONE. I
04:09:45.904 --> 04:09:50.008
VOTE VERY GOOD. UM IT SARAH DECK
04:09:50.075 --> 04:09:51.242
. IT IS ON THE LINE. UM, THE
04:09:51.309 --> 04:09:55.914
FLOOR IS YOURS. GOOD GOOD
04:09:55.980 --> 04:09:56.881
AFTERNOON SHARING COMMITTEE
04:09:56.948 --> 04:09:58.183
MEMBERS PARODY KET ON BEHALF OF
04:09:58.249 --> 04:09:59.517
THE RURAL COUNTY REPRESENTATIVES
04:09:59.584 --> 04:10:02.587
OF CALIFORNIA. IN SUPPORT OF A B
04:10:02.654 --> 04:10:05.590
26 47. THIS BILL WOULD ALLEVIATE
04:10:05.657 --> 04:10:06.124
ADMINISTRATIVE DELAYS BY
04:10:06.191 --> 04:10:07.892
ALLOWING DOCUMENTS TO BE SHARED
04:10:07.959 --> 04:10:08.893
ONLINE WITH THE LEGACY OF BODY
04:10:08.960 --> 04:10:11.529
AND THE PUBLIC AS LONG AS THE
04:10:11.596 --> 04:10:12.697
DOCUMENTS ARE MADE AVAILABLE IN
04:10:12.764 --> 04:10:14.733
PERSON. RECENTLY THE DISTRICT
04:10:14.799 --> 04:10:17.502
COURT OF APPEALS POSTING MEETING
04:10:17.569 --> 04:10:18.303
DOCUMENTS ONLINE DOES NOT
04:10:18.370 --> 04:10:20.071
SATISFY THIS REQUIREMENT OF THE
04:10:20.138 --> 04:10:21.439
BALANCE, BROWN EYES. AND THE
04:10:21.506 --> 04:10:22.674
LOCAL GOVERNMENT MUST PLACE
04:10:22.741 --> 04:10:24.409
PHYSICAL COPIES OF THE DOCUMENTS
04:10:24.476 --> 04:10:26.111
AND DESIGNATED OFFICES OPEN TO
04:10:26.177 --> 04:10:27.278
THE PUBLIC. ACQUIRING PHYSICAL
04:10:27.345 --> 04:10:29.214
ACCESS AT THE PUBLIC LOCATION AS
04:10:29.280 --> 04:10:30.548
THE ONLY WAY TO SATISFY THE
04:10:30.615 --> 04:10:31.716
BROWNER COULD IMPAIR THE CONDUCT
04:10:31.783 --> 04:10:33.451
OF THE PEOPLE'S BUSINESS.
04:10:33.518 --> 04:10:34.986
WITHOUT A LEGISLATIVE SOLUTION.
04:10:35.053 --> 04:10:36.521
THE COURT'S DECISION REQUIRES
04:10:36.588 --> 04:10:38.156
LOCAL AGENCIES TO KEEP AN OFFICE
04:10:38.223 --> 04:10:39.691
OPEN TO THE PUBLIC DURING THE
04:10:39.758 --> 04:10:41.926
EVENINGS AND OR THE WEEKENDS
04:10:41.993 --> 04:10:42.861
WHEN WRITTEN MATERIAL IS
04:10:42.927 --> 04:10:44.295
DISTRIBUTED. LATE BREAKING
04:10:44.362 --> 04:10:45.630
INFORMATION WOULD BE WITH HEALTH
04:10:45.697 --> 04:10:46.765
AND THE LEGISLATIVE BODY AND THE
04:10:46.831 --> 04:10:49.267
PUBLIC. UNTIL AN OFFICE IS OPEN
04:10:49.334 --> 04:10:50.969
, WHICH CAN IMPACT THE ABILITY
04:10:51.035 --> 04:10:52.670
OF THE LEGISLATIVE BODY AND THE
04:10:52.737 --> 04:10:54.072
PEOPLE TO BE INFORMED, GIVEN THE
04:10:54.139 --> 04:10:55.106
REDUCED TIME TO CONSIDER
04:10:55.173 --> 04:10:57.108
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. THIS
04:10:57.175 --> 04:10:58.343
MEASURE WITH COMMITTEE
04:10:58.410 --> 04:10:59.611
AMENDMENTS WOULD CLARIFY THAT
04:10:59.677 --> 04:11:00.879
WRITING IS DISTRIBUTED TO THE
04:11:00.945 --> 04:11:01.880
MAJORITY OFTHE LOCAL
04:11:01.946 --> 04:11:03.848
LEGISLATIVE BODY LESS THAN 72
04:11:03.915 --> 04:11:04.883
HOURS BEFORE A MEETING CAN BE
04:11:04.949 --> 04:11:06.951
POSTED ONLINE TO SOUTH SIDE OF
04:11:07.018 --> 04:11:08.286
BROWN EX IF THERE'S LITTLE
04:11:08.353 --> 04:11:09.154
COPIES ARE MADE AVAILABLE FOR
04:11:09.220 --> 04:11:10.588
THE PUBLIC INSPECTION 24 HOURS
04:11:10.655 --> 04:11:12.190
PRIOR TO THE MEETING, AND THAT
04:11:12.257 --> 04:11:13.491
DISTRIBUTED MATERIALS ARE
04:11:13.558 --> 04:11:14.759
SUPPLEMENTAL DOCUMENTS TO AN
04:11:14.826 --> 04:11:16.494
AGENDA ITEM WITH A STAFF REPORT
04:11:16.561 --> 04:11:18.263
OR EXECUTIVE SUMMARY BY REDUCING
04:11:18.329 --> 04:11:19.864
DELAYS, THE PUBLIC COMMUNITY AND
04:11:19.931 --> 04:11:21.199
THE LEGISLATIVE BODY WILL BE
04:11:21.266 --> 04:11:23.034
BETTER INFORMED TO ENGAGE IN THE
04:11:23.101 --> 04:11:24.169
MEETING. WITH THE FLEXIBILITY
04:11:24.235 --> 04:11:25.837
AND TRANSPARENCY THIS MEASURE
04:11:25.904 --> 04:11:28.173
PROVIDES FOR THESE REASONS ARE
04:11:28.239 --> 04:11:29.174
CRC. RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
04:11:29.240 --> 04:11:32.410
I'M OUT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
04:11:32.477 --> 04:11:34.245
THERE ANYBODY HERE IN THE ROOM
04:11:34.312 --> 04:11:35.413
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:11:35.480 --> 04:11:39.818
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL? HELLO
04:11:39.884 --> 04:11:41.786
DENNIS ALBION ON BEHALF OF THE
04:11:41.853 --> 04:11:42.787
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION JOINT
04:11:42.854 --> 04:11:44.355
POWERS AUTHORITIES WE SUPPORT
04:11:44.422 --> 04:11:48.326
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE?
04:11:48.393 --> 04:11:49.961
SEEING THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
04:11:50.028 --> 04:11:51.396
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
04:11:51.463 --> 04:11:52.564
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
04:11:52.630 --> 04:11:54.365
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:11:54.432 --> 04:11:56.701
SUPPORT? AND IF THEY WOULD LIKE
04:11:56.768 --> 04:11:59.871
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 26
04:11:59.938 --> 04:12:08.713
47, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
04:12:08.780 --> 04:12:10.315
CHAIR. NO LINES COMING IN. THANK
04:12:10.381 --> 04:12:11.783
YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
04:12:11.850 --> 04:12:13.218
OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO LEAD
04:12:13.284 --> 04:12:14.919
OPPOSITION IDENTIFIED WE'LL SEE
04:12:14.986 --> 04:12:17.422
IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM 2100
04:12:17.489 --> 04:12:18.590
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:12:18.656 --> 04:12:20.358
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL GO
04:12:20.425 --> 04:12:21.759
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS
04:12:21.826 --> 04:12:23.394
THERE ANYBODY ON THE LINE, MR
04:12:23.461 --> 04:12:25.830
MODERATOR? AND IF THEY'D LIKE TO
04:12:25.897 --> 04:12:27.499
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO A B 2647
04:12:27.565 --> 04:12:37.609
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
04:12:37.675 --> 04:12:39.811
CHAIR. NO COMMENTS IN. Q THANK
04:12:39.878 --> 04:12:41.346
YOU VERY MUCH WILL BRING THE
04:12:41.412 --> 04:12:42.947
MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
04:12:43.014 --> 04:12:46.751
ANY COMMENTS CONCERNS. DURAZO
04:12:46.818 --> 04:12:49.220
YES, JUST A QUESTION FOR THE
04:12:49.287 --> 04:12:52.824
AUTHOR IS, UM YOU KNOW, THERE'S
04:12:52.891 --> 04:12:55.693
BEEN A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT UM
04:12:55.760 --> 04:12:56.895
BILLS THAT HAVE BEEN INTRODUCED
04:12:56.961 --> 04:12:59.764
ABOUT ESPECIALLY SINCE THE
04:12:59.831 --> 04:13:02.867
PANDEMIC BECAUSE IT HAD SUCH AN
04:13:02.934 --> 04:13:05.069
IMPACT ON OUR ABILITY TO DO
04:13:05.136 --> 04:13:06.938
CONDUCT BUSINESS AS USUAL, YOU
04:13:07.005 --> 04:13:08.873
KNOW, GOVERNMENT BODIES,
04:13:08.940 --> 04:13:11.042
LEGISLATIVE BODIES. SO UM, IF
04:13:11.109 --> 04:13:14.345
YOU COULD JUST EXPLAIN WHY YOU
04:13:14.412 --> 04:13:16.447
FEEL LIKE THIS IS SUCH A AN
04:13:16.514 --> 04:13:20.685
IMPORTANT PIECE OF TO ADDRESS IN
04:13:20.752 --> 04:13:23.821
THE MIDDLE OF ALL OF ALL OF THE,
04:13:23.888 --> 04:13:25.757
UM, POSSIBILITY POSSIBLE CHANGES
04:13:25.823 --> 04:13:27.659
RIGHT THAT WE COULD BE MAKING
04:13:27.725 --> 04:13:29.193
TWO MEETINGS AND, YOU KNOW,
04:13:29.260 --> 04:13:31.429
DISCLOSURE OF WHERE THE
04:13:31.496 --> 04:13:34.365
LEGISLATORS ARE WHEN THEY DO A
04:13:34.432 --> 04:13:35.466
MEETING REMOTE, ALL THOSE SORTS
04:13:35.533 --> 04:13:39.404
OF THINGS SO WHY THIS IT WAS AN
04:13:39.470 --> 04:13:43.474
ISSUE WAS A PROBLEM. WHAT MADE.
04:13:43.541 --> 04:13:45.143
THIS SUCH AN IMPORTANT THING TO
04:13:45.209 --> 04:13:46.644
DO. WELL, THANK YOU FOR THE
04:13:46.711 --> 04:13:48.212
THOUGHTFULNESS OF THE QUESTION.
04:13:48.279 --> 04:13:49.814
AND IN THE INTEREST OF BREVITY,
04:13:49.881 --> 04:13:51.849
I SKIPPED OVER SOMETHING THAT I
04:13:51.916 --> 04:13:52.650
THINK IS IMPORTANT FOR ME TO
04:13:52.717 --> 04:13:55.386
SAY. AND I WANT TO SAY WITH
04:13:55.453 --> 04:13:56.554
GRATITUDE TO THE CHAIR AND THE
04:13:56.621 --> 04:13:58.423
STAFF THAT I DO ACCEPT THE
04:13:58.489 --> 04:13:58.990
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS, AS
04:13:59.057 --> 04:14:01.359
OUTLINED IN THE ANALYSIS, UM
04:14:01.426 --> 04:14:02.594
THIS IS AN ISSUE. I'M A FORMER
04:14:02.660 --> 04:14:05.897
CITY COUNCIL MEMBER. AND UM, YOU
04:14:05.964 --> 04:14:07.966
KNOW, I THINK THAT BROWN ACT IS
04:14:08.032 --> 04:14:10.835
PRETTY DARN FUNDAMENTAL TO
04:14:10.902 --> 04:14:12.437
GOVERNMENT AND HOW IT WORKS AND
04:14:12.503 --> 04:14:14.372
MAKING SURE IT WORKS FOR
04:14:14.439 --> 04:14:16.841
EVERYBODY. AND THAT EVERYONE HAS
04:14:16.908 --> 04:14:19.344
ALL OF THE INFORMATION THEY NEED
04:14:19.410 --> 04:14:20.445
TO UNDERSTAND HOW GOVERNMENT IS
04:14:20.511 --> 04:14:23.414
MAKING CHOICES FOR THEM. AND HOW
04:14:23.481 --> 04:14:24.716
IT'S GOING TO IMPACT THEM RIGHT
04:14:24.782 --> 04:14:26.751
SO THAT IT CAN BE AS INCLUSIVE
04:14:26.818 --> 04:14:28.620
AS POSSIBLE AND THAT WE GET
04:14:28.686 --> 04:14:29.754
INFORMATION OUT TO PEOPLE AS
04:14:29.821 --> 04:14:32.123
QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE. AND I KNOW
04:14:32.190 --> 04:14:33.591
THAT THERE ARE LOTS AND LOTS OF
04:14:33.658 --> 04:14:36.728
BILLS, SOME OF WHICH ARE NOT
04:14:36.794 --> 04:14:37.862
GOING TO BE SUCCESSFUL THIS
04:14:37.929 --> 04:14:41.099
YEAR. THAT ATTEMPT TO TINKER
04:14:41.165 --> 04:14:43.701
WITH ALL OF THIS, UM AND I'VE
04:14:43.768 --> 04:14:45.203
REALLY PUSHED ON THIS BILL, AND
04:14:45.269 --> 04:14:46.671
I'M JUST GRATEFUL. SO MUCH TO
04:14:46.738 --> 04:14:47.872
ALL THE MEMBERS IN THE
04:14:47.939 --> 04:14:49.607
LEGISLATURE WHO WORKED WITH ME
04:14:49.674 --> 04:14:51.676
TO GET IT TO THIS POINT. I THINK
04:14:51.743 --> 04:14:52.877
THERE'S MORE WORK TO BE DONE ON
04:14:52.944 --> 04:14:54.746
THIS. BUT THIS IS ABOUT HOW DO
04:14:54.812 --> 04:14:56.848
WE MAKE SURE WITH THE TECHNOLOGY
04:14:56.914 --> 04:14:57.882
THAT IS OUT THERE THAT WE'RE NOT
04:14:57.949 --> 04:14:58.983
HOLDING INFORMATION BACK FROM
04:14:59.050 --> 04:15:01.519
PEOPLE. SO WITH THE BROWN ACT,
04:15:01.586 --> 04:15:04.522
THE AGENDAS UM YOU KNOW, AND E I
04:15:04.589 --> 04:15:07.191
R SOMETHING LIKE THAT THAT HAS
04:15:07.258 --> 04:15:07.825
TO BE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC.
04:15:07.892 --> 04:15:12.997
THIS BILL. IS MERELY IMPACTING
04:15:13.064 --> 04:15:15.199
OR AFFECTING WHAT IS CALLED, UM,
04:15:15.266 --> 04:15:19.137
SUPPLEMENTARY DOCUMENTATION. SO
04:15:19.203 --> 04:15:21.272
IF A STAFF REPORT HAS AN
04:15:21.339 --> 04:15:23.007
AMENDMENT OR NOT AN AMENDMENT
04:15:23.074 --> 04:15:23.908
BUT YOU KNOW AN UPDATE AND ERROR
04:15:23.975 --> 04:15:25.643
TYPOS. THEY WANTED TO UPDATE
04:15:25.710 --> 04:15:26.778
WHAT THAT PRESENTATION MAY HAVE
04:15:26.844 --> 04:15:29.614
BEEN TO SUPPORT. THE AGENDA
04:15:29.681 --> 04:15:31.749
AGENDA IS TO ITEMS THAT WE WANT
04:15:31.816 --> 04:15:33.551
TO GET THAT TO THE PUBLIC AS
04:15:33.618 --> 04:15:35.286
MUCH AS POSSIBLE AND ACTUALLY
04:15:35.353 --> 04:15:36.821
GET THAT OUT. AND ACTUALLY MAKE
04:15:36.888 --> 04:15:38.389
CHANGES RATHER THAN STOPPING
04:15:38.456 --> 04:15:42.226
THAT FROM EVER OCCURRING. SO UM
04:15:42.293 --> 04:15:44.862
, THIS BILL IS TO MAKE SURE THAT
04:15:44.929 --> 04:15:45.930
THAT INFORMATION IS PUSHED OUT
04:15:45.997 --> 04:15:48.199
RATHER THAN NOT SHARED. UM AND
04:15:48.266 --> 04:15:50.068
THAT'S I THINK A DIFFERENCE IN A
04:15:50.134 --> 04:15:51.335
LOT OF THE OTHER THINGS THAT YOU
04:15:51.402 --> 04:15:55.073
HAD. MENTIONED THAT ARE CHANGES
04:15:55.139 --> 04:15:56.374
TO THE BROWN ACT BECAUSE OF THE
04:15:56.441 --> 04:16:00.645
PANDEMIC. UM, YOU KNOW, I THINK
04:16:00.712 --> 04:16:01.913
NOT TO SAY THAT MY BILL ISN'T
04:16:01.979 --> 04:16:03.881
AMAZING, BUT MAYBE MORE
04:16:03.948 --> 04:16:05.149
SUBSTANTIVE WAYS THAT THOSE
04:16:05.216 --> 04:16:07.218
BILLS DO WHERE WE'RE JUST TRYING
04:16:07.285 --> 04:16:07.985
TO, UM, MAKE SURE THAT
04:16:08.052 --> 04:16:09.087
SUPPLEMENTARY DOCUMENTATION IS
04:16:09.153 --> 04:16:11.723
AVAILABLE TO PEOPLE. IT'S BASED
04:16:11.789 --> 04:16:13.891
ON A LAWSUIT THAT I'LL WATCH A
04:16:13.958 --> 04:16:15.359
DECADE. A LAWSUIT THAT WAS
04:16:15.426 --> 04:16:17.061
FILED. YEAH THAT WAS A SHORTER
04:16:17.128 --> 04:16:19.230
WELL IT YES, BUT THE OTHER THING
04:16:19.297 --> 04:16:21.032
IS THAT IS IT. THE CITY COUNCIL
04:16:21.099 --> 04:16:24.102
HAS TO GET THE REPORTS WITH 72
04:16:24.168 --> 04:16:26.104
HOURS BEFORE THE COUNCIL MEETING
04:16:26.170 --> 04:16:28.706
AND WHATEVER A COUNCIL GETS THE
04:16:28.773 --> 04:16:30.641
PUB, THE PUBLIC GETS A COPY OF
04:16:30.708 --> 04:16:31.843
THAT AS WELL. WELL THERE MAY BE
04:16:31.909 --> 04:16:33.511
SOMETHING THAT CAN BE SENT
04:16:33.578 --> 04:16:34.812
ELEKTRONIK LEE TO A COUNCIL
04:16:34.879 --> 04:16:37.348
MEMBER THAT UPDATES A REPORT. UM
04:16:37.415 --> 04:16:39.884
IT COULD BE LIKE AN EMAIL FROM A
04:16:39.951 --> 04:16:40.985
CONSTITUENT, UM, THAT YOU WOULD
04:16:41.052 --> 04:16:43.621
WANT TO INCLUDING THE COUNCIL
04:16:43.688 --> 04:16:45.123
MEMBER TO KNOW ABOUT RATHER THAN
04:16:45.189 --> 04:16:46.924
KEEP IT FROM THE COUNCIL MEMBER
04:16:46.991 --> 04:16:48.126
OR THE PUBLIC. YOU PUSH IT OUT
04:16:48.192 --> 04:16:50.795
ONLINE. OKAY MAYBE I WAS JUST
04:16:50.862 --> 04:16:52.630
THROWN OFF BECAUSE IT SAYS
04:16:52.697 --> 04:16:53.698
EXEMPTS LOCAL AGENCY. FROM
04:16:53.765 --> 04:16:54.832
MAKING MATERIALS. AVAILABLE TO
04:16:54.899 --> 04:17:00.838
THE PUBLIC. DID I READ THAT
04:17:00.905 --> 04:17:03.841
WRONG? I DON'T THAT IS NOT THE
04:17:03.908 --> 04:17:05.510
INTENT OF THE BILL. THE BILL IS
04:17:05.576 --> 04:17:07.145
TO ACTUALLY GET THE INFORMATION
04:17:07.211 --> 04:17:07.979
OUT AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE. BUT
04:17:08.045 --> 04:17:09.113
IF THAT EMAIL IS SHARED
04:17:09.180 --> 04:17:10.481
ELECTRONICALLY, SÜ CONSTITUENT,
04:17:10.548 --> 04:17:13.284
WRITES AN EMAIL. UM YOU WANT TO
04:17:13.351 --> 04:17:14.719
GET THAT TO A COUNCIL MEMBER,
04:17:14.786 --> 04:17:16.120
YOU HAVE TO HAVE A PHYSICAL
04:17:16.187 --> 04:17:17.889
PRODUCT AVAILABLE, BUT IT MIGHT
04:17:17.955 --> 04:17:20.091
BE A WEEKEND OR AT NIGHT THAT
04:17:20.158 --> 04:17:21.592
THAT IS GETTING PUSHED OUT. AND
04:17:21.659 --> 04:17:24.162
SO THIS SAYS, AS SOON AS THE
04:17:24.228 --> 04:17:25.263
OFFICES OPEN, IT NEEDS TO BE
04:17:25.329 --> 04:17:27.365
THERE. IF YOU'RE GOING TO LIVE
04:17:27.431 --> 04:17:28.432
IN, LET'S JUST SAY SAN
04:17:28.499 --> 04:17:29.500
BERNARDINO COUNTY. I'LL PICK A
04:17:29.567 --> 04:17:30.568
VERY LARGE COUNTY. IT'S VERY
04:17:30.635 --> 04:17:32.603
HARD FOR PEOPLE TO GET TO THAT
04:17:32.670 --> 04:17:33.538
GOVERNMENT OFFICE BUILDING TO
04:17:33.604 --> 04:17:36.274
FIND OUT WHETHER A CONSTITUENT
04:17:36.340 --> 04:17:36.874
LETTER WAS THERE. IT'S A LOT
04:17:36.941 --> 04:17:38.810
EASIER FOR THEM TO FIND IT
04:17:38.876 --> 04:17:41.579
ONLINE. SO WE'RE BRINGING THAT
04:17:41.646 --> 04:17:42.914
INFORMATION OUT WHEN WE
04:17:42.980 --> 04:17:44.415
RECOGNIZE THAT BROADBAND'S NOT
04:17:44.482 --> 04:17:45.850
EVERYWHERE. SO WE STILL SAY
04:17:45.917 --> 04:17:46.818
PHYSICALLY, IT NEEDS TO BE
04:17:46.884 --> 04:17:48.386
AVAILABLE WHEN THE OFFICE OPENS
04:17:48.452 --> 04:17:50.388
, BUT WE DON'T WANT TO HOLD THAT
04:17:50.454 --> 04:17:51.355
INFORMATION BACK FROM THE
04:17:51.422 --> 04:17:52.490
PUBLIC. BECAUSE OF THAT
04:17:52.557 --> 04:17:54.025
LIMITATION, AND THAT'S WHAT THE
04:17:54.091 --> 04:17:56.260
COURT CASE WAS SAYING WAS THAT
04:17:56.327 --> 04:17:58.863
IT WAS CHALLENGING OFFICES THAT
04:17:58.930 --> 04:18:00.231
MAY NOT BE STAFFED DURING THE
04:18:00.298 --> 04:18:02.900
PANDEMIC. BUT ALSO MIGHT NOT BE
04:18:02.967 --> 04:18:04.902
OPEN AT NIGHT OR ON A WEEKEND OR
04:18:04.969 --> 04:18:10.107
HOLIDAY. GOOD. OKAY UM, SEEING
04:18:10.174 --> 04:18:11.676
NO FURTHER QUESTIONS WILL ALLOW
04:18:11.742 --> 04:18:13.845
YOU TO CONCLUDE THAT WOULD BE
04:18:13.911 --> 04:18:15.613
GRATEFUL FOR AN I VOTE VERY
04:18:15.680 --> 04:18:16.747
GRATEFUL FOR THE WORK OF THE
04:18:16.814 --> 04:18:18.349
COMMITTEE AND THE MEMBERS. THANK
04:18:18.416 --> 04:18:20.084
YOU, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU VERY
04:18:20.151 --> 04:18:21.452
MUCH. IS THERE A MOTION? SENATOR
04:18:21.519 --> 04:18:27.525
DORR ASO, UM. MOVES AND, UH THE
04:18:27.592 --> 04:18:28.659
MOTION WOULD BE DO PASSES
04:18:28.726 --> 04:18:30.561
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR. PLEASE
04:18:30.628 --> 04:18:34.165
CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
04:18:34.232 --> 04:18:36.500
CABALLERO CABALLERO HIGH NIELSEN
04:18:36.567 --> 04:18:40.371
NIELSEN, I DURAZO. YOU'RE A SO I
04:18:40.438 --> 04:18:44.141
HERZBERG WIENER THROUGH ZERO.
04:18:44.208 --> 04:18:46.477
THE BILL IS OUT, BUT WE'RE GONNA
04:18:46.544 --> 04:18:48.212
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN FOR ABSENT
04:18:48.279 --> 04:18:49.847
MEMBERS. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
04:18:49.914 --> 04:18:50.748
YOUR PATIENTS APPRECIATE IT VERY
04:18:50.815 --> 04:18:54.585
MUCH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MULLEN.
04:18:54.652 --> 04:18:56.287
WELL, WE'LL TAKE UP FILE ITEM
04:18:56.354 --> 04:19:04.395
NUMBER 21. MAYBE 26 22. THANK
04:19:04.462 --> 04:19:07.164
YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR AND
04:19:07.231 --> 04:19:11.469
MEMBERS. THIS BILL SIMPLY
04:19:11.535 --> 04:19:13.271
EXTENDS AN EXISTING PARTIAL
04:19:13.337 --> 04:19:15.072
SALES TAX EXEMPTION AUTHORED IN
04:19:15.139 --> 04:19:17.742
2019 FOR OUR PUBLIC TRANSIT
04:19:17.808 --> 04:19:19.610
AGENCIES TO PURCHASE ZERO
04:19:19.677 --> 04:19:21.846
EMISSION BUSSES. PUBLIC TRANSIT
04:19:21.913 --> 04:19:23.447
AGENCIES ARE OFTEN CASH STRAPPED
04:19:23.514 --> 04:19:24.548
EVEN MORE SO TODAY WITH
04:19:24.615 --> 04:19:25.616
RIDERSHIP LOSSES DUE TO COVID
04:19:25.683 --> 04:19:28.319
19. EXTENDING THE EXCEPTION OF
04:19:28.386 --> 04:19:30.755
THE STATE PORTION OF THE SALES
04:19:30.821 --> 04:19:32.223
TAX FOR ZERO EMISSION BUSSES,
04:19:32.290 --> 04:19:34.258
AND THEIR PURCHASES WILL REDUCE
04:19:34.325 --> 04:19:35.893
THE UPFRONT CAPITAL COSTS AND
04:19:35.960 --> 04:19:36.427
INCREMENTAL COSTS BETWEEN
04:19:36.494 --> 04:19:39.397
TECHNOLOGIES. THUS DECREASING
04:19:39.463 --> 04:19:40.898
THE BURDEN ON TRANSIT AGENCIES
04:19:40.965 --> 04:19:42.566
AND ENCOURAGING EARLY COMPLIANCE
04:19:42.633 --> 04:19:43.901
WITH THE INNOVATIVE CLEAN
04:19:43.968 --> 04:19:45.503
TRANSIT REGULATION, LEADING TO
04:19:45.569 --> 04:19:46.504
IMMEDIATE EMISSION REDUCTIONS
04:19:46.570 --> 04:19:47.872
AND BENEFITING CALIFORNIANS IN
04:19:47.939 --> 04:19:51.676
ALL PARTS OF THE STATE. THE BILL
04:19:51.742 --> 04:19:53.110
IS BEING PURSUED THIS YEAR SO
04:19:53.177 --> 04:19:53.811
THAT TRANSIT AGENCIES HAVE
04:19:53.878 --> 04:19:56.047
CLARITY ON THE SALES AND USE
04:19:56.113 --> 04:19:57.548
TAXES THAT WOULD APPLY TO
04:19:57.615 --> 04:19:59.917
PURCHASES BEGINNING IN 2024 AS
04:19:59.984 --> 04:20:01.052
THEY BEGIN THEIR PROCUREMENT
04:20:01.118 --> 04:20:03.854
PROCESSES. THESE PROCUREMENT
04:20:03.921 --> 04:20:05.623
PROCESSES ARE OFTEN LENGTHY AND
04:20:05.690 --> 04:20:08.159
BEGIN 18 TO 24 MONTHS PRIOR TO
04:20:08.225 --> 04:20:09.293
THE ISSUANCE OF A PURCHASE
04:20:09.360 --> 04:20:11.996
ORDER. THANK YOU. MEMBERS ASKED
04:20:12.063 --> 04:20:14.165
FOR IT. I VOTED WITH ME TWO
04:20:14.231 --> 04:20:15.700
WITNESSES. MICHAEL MENTAL WITH
04:20:15.766 --> 04:20:16.467
THE CALIFORNIA TRANSIT
04:20:16.534 --> 04:20:18.703
ASSOCIATION, AS WELL AS STEPHEN
04:20:18.769 --> 04:20:20.705
JONES. EXTERNAL AFFAIRS REP WITH
04:20:20.771 --> 04:20:21.572
ALAMEDA CONTRA COSTA TRANSIT
04:20:21.639 --> 04:20:22.606
DISTRICT WHO WILL BE ON THE
04:20:22.673 --> 04:20:25.910
PHONE, I BELIEVE WELCOME. THANK
04:20:25.977 --> 04:20:26.744
YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
04:20:26.811 --> 04:20:27.611
MICHAEL PIMENTEL, EXECUTIVE
04:20:27.678 --> 04:20:28.846
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
04:20:28.913 --> 04:20:29.747
TRANSIT ASSOCIATION,
04:20:29.814 --> 04:20:32.049
REPRESENTING 85 TRANSIT AGENCIES
04:20:32.116 --> 04:20:33.384
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
04:20:33.451 --> 04:20:34.352
220 MEMBER ORGANIZATIONS
04:20:34.418 --> 04:20:37.121
NATIONWIDE. YOU'RE TO VOICE OUR
04:20:37.188 --> 04:20:39.991
SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 26 22 WILL BE
04:20:40.057 --> 04:20:41.759
SUPER BRIEF AND JUST EMPHASIZE
04:20:41.826 --> 04:20:43.427
OR INDUSTRY IS COMMITTED TO
04:20:43.494 --> 04:20:44.795
MAKING A TRANSITION TO 100% 0
04:20:44.862 --> 04:20:46.998
EMISSION TECHNOLOGIES BY 2040.
04:20:47.064 --> 04:20:49.166
ONE OF THE CHALLENGING ASPECTS
04:20:49.233 --> 04:20:50.468
OF THIS TRANSITION HAS BEEN THE
04:20:50.534 --> 04:20:53.004
HIGH COST OF THE ZERO EMISSION
04:20:53.070 --> 04:20:55.272
BUSSES. AND SO THIS BILL WOULD
04:20:55.339 --> 04:20:56.707
HELP BY DOWN THE COST OF THESE
04:20:56.774 --> 04:20:58.576
BUSSES AT AGENCIES LOOK TO MOVE
04:20:58.642 --> 04:21:00.644
AGGRESSIVELY. INTO THIS ZERO
04:21:00.711 --> 04:21:02.546
MISSION FUTURE AND WITH THAT,
04:21:02.613 --> 04:21:03.647
JUST ENCOURAGE, DRIVE OUT. THANK
04:21:03.714 --> 04:21:06.650
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT.
04:21:06.717 --> 04:21:08.519
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO STEVE
04:21:08.586 --> 04:21:09.754
JONES, WHO'S ON THE PHONE. HE'S
04:21:09.820 --> 04:21:14.558
FROM TRANSIT. I AM. THANK YOU.
04:21:14.625 --> 04:21:16.093
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
04:21:16.160 --> 04:21:17.328
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
04:21:17.395 --> 04:21:18.696
STEPHEN JONES, EXTERNAL AFFAIRS
04:21:18.763 --> 04:21:19.663
REPRESENTATIVE AT THE ALAMEDA
04:21:19.730 --> 04:21:21.532
CONTRA TALKED TO THE TRANSIT
04:21:21.599 --> 04:21:23.100
DISTRICT IN OAKLAND, SPEAKING IN
04:21:23.167 --> 04:21:25.936
SUPPORT OF A B TO 6 TO 2. I JUST
04:21:26.003 --> 04:21:27.605
WANT TO APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE
04:21:27.671 --> 04:21:29.407
FOR CONSIDERING THIS BILL TODAY
04:21:29.473 --> 04:21:30.107
AND ALSO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:21:30.174 --> 04:21:32.877
BOWLING FOR INTRODUCING SINCE 8
04:21:32.943 --> 04:21:34.712
2006 HAS BEEN BUILDING THE MOST
04:21:34.779 --> 04:21:36.213
COMPREHENSIVE ZERO EMISSION BUS
04:21:36.280 --> 04:21:38.616
PROGRAM IN THE NATION. CURRENTLY
04:21:38.682 --> 04:21:42.086
OPERATE. 46 ROMA SCHLUSS SEVEN
04:21:42.153 --> 04:21:44.088
BATTERY ELECTRIC BOXES 39 FUEL
04:21:44.155 --> 04:21:45.956
CELL ELECTRIC, BUT WE HAVE 21
04:21:46.023 --> 04:21:47.058
MORE BATTERY ELECTRIC BUSSES
04:21:47.124 --> 04:21:50.361
ARRIVING THIS YEAR. MY EARLY
04:21:50.428 --> 04:21:54.131
2023 C TRANSIT HAS 67 0 EMISSION
04:21:54.198 --> 04:21:55.399
BUSSES SERVICE CONSTITUTING MORE
04:21:55.466 --> 04:21:59.070
THAN 10% OF OUR ENTIRE FLEET.
04:21:59.136 --> 04:22:00.104
THANKS TO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:22:00.171 --> 04:22:01.906
BOLAN'S ORIGINAL BILL, MAYBE 7
04:22:01.972 --> 04:22:04.708
80 FOR TRANSIT IS REALIZING OVER
04:22:04.775 --> 04:22:06.911
$43,000 TAX SAVINGS ON EACH
04:22:06.977 --> 04:22:10.081
HYDROGEN FUEL CELL BUS PURCHASE.
04:22:10.147 --> 04:22:12.483
AND MORE THAN $34,000 ON THE
04:22:12.550 --> 04:22:13.951
PURCHASE OF EACH BATTERY
04:22:14.018 --> 04:22:15.686
ELECTRIC PLUS, AND AS A RESULT,
04:22:15.753 --> 04:22:16.787
THEY'VE ALREADY REALIZED ABOUT
04:22:16.854 --> 04:22:19.090
$2 MILLION IN TAX SAVINGS. AND
04:22:19.156 --> 04:22:19.957
WE'RE USING THE SAVINGS TO
04:22:20.024 --> 04:22:21.025
PURCHASE EVEN MORE. THEIR
04:22:21.092 --> 04:22:23.360
OMISSION BUSTED. AND TO BUILD
04:22:23.427 --> 04:22:24.562
THE INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WILL
04:22:24.628 --> 04:22:27.031
THAT WILL POWER THEM. BUT MORE
04:22:27.098 --> 04:22:28.732
FUNDING IS NEEDED. IT WILL COST
04:22:28.799 --> 04:22:32.136
BC TRANSIT AND ESTIMATED $1.3
04:22:32.203 --> 04:22:33.637
BILLION TO MEET THE STATE
04:22:33.704 --> 04:22:35.306
MANDATES THAT REQUIRES TRANSIT
04:22:35.372 --> 04:22:36.874
PROVIDERS OPERATE 100% 0 MISSION
04:22:36.941 --> 04:22:41.679
FLEET. BY 2040. MAYBE 26 22 WILL
04:22:41.745 --> 04:22:42.847
HELP. THERE WERE SOME OF THESE
04:22:42.913 --> 04:22:45.549
FUNDS. STILL IN THE CURRENT
04:22:45.616 --> 04:22:46.951
TEXT, THE CURRENT TAX EXEMPTION
04:22:47.017 --> 04:22:49.687
FOR ANOTHER TWO YEARS AND STILL
04:22:49.753 --> 04:22:51.355
IS AN IMPORTANT TOOL IN HELPING
04:22:51.422 --> 04:22:52.723
US ANOTHER TRANSIT OPERATORS
04:22:52.790 --> 04:22:54.959
MEET THE STATE MANDATE OF 100% 0
04:22:55.025 --> 04:22:58.229
EMISSIONS BY 2040. ADD AND
04:22:58.295 --> 04:22:59.163
ACHIEVING THE STATE'S AMBITIOUS
04:22:59.230 --> 04:23:01.098
CLIMATE THOUGHTS, TRANSIT REALLY
04:23:01.165 --> 04:23:03.100
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME AND URGES
04:23:03.167 --> 04:23:05.269
YOUR SUPPORT FOR 80 26 22. THANK
04:23:05.336 --> 04:23:07.838
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT.
04:23:07.905 --> 04:23:08.906
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
04:23:08.973 --> 04:23:10.708
SUPPORTERS IN ROOM. 2100. PLEASE
04:23:10.774 --> 04:23:12.977
COME FORWARD. GOOD AFTERNOON,
04:23:13.043 --> 04:23:14.979
STEVE BULLOCK ON BEHALF OF THE
04:23:15.045 --> 04:23:15.513
NAPA VALLEY TRANSPORTATION
04:23:15.579 --> 04:23:16.881
AUTHORITY AND THE CALIFORNIA
04:23:16.947 --> 04:23:17.448
ASSOCIATION FOR COORDINATED
04:23:17.515 --> 04:23:18.115
TRANSPORTATION AND SUPPORT.
04:23:18.182 --> 04:23:19.483
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
04:23:19.550 --> 04:23:22.386
ANYONE ELSE? SEEING THEN WE'LL
04:23:22.453 --> 04:23:24.088
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
04:23:24.155 --> 04:23:26.957
LINE. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
04:23:27.024 --> 04:23:28.492
CHECK TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY
04:23:28.559 --> 04:23:29.793
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
04:23:29.860 --> 04:23:34.365
SUPPORT OF A B 26 22. AND IF
04:23:34.431 --> 04:23:35.633
THEY WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:23:35.699 --> 04:23:37.434
SUPPORT THESE PRESS 10 AND LOAD
04:23:37.501 --> 04:23:41.639
LINE TO 91, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
04:23:41.705 --> 04:23:42.940
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
04:23:43.007 --> 04:23:45.009
MEMBERS CANDYGRAM ON BEHALF OF
04:23:45.075 --> 04:23:46.210
MONTEREY SALINAS TRANSIT. SEEN
04:23:46.277 --> 04:23:48.812
REGIONAL TRADE DISTRICT. SAN
04:23:48.879 --> 04:23:52.249
MATEO COUNTY DISTRICT. CITY
04:23:52.316 --> 04:23:53.651
COUNTY ASSOCIATION OF THAT
04:23:53.717 --> 04:23:55.119
GOVERNMENT STILL ON THE
04:23:55.186 --> 04:23:56.820
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY IN CITY
04:23:56.887 --> 04:23:59.356
OF KHALIDIYA IN SUPPORT OF MAYBE
04:23:59.423 --> 04:24:00.591
26 22. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
04:24:00.658 --> 04:24:03.627
MUCH. WE'LL GO TO LINE 6 35,
04:24:03.694 --> 04:24:09.934
PLEASE GO AHEAD. 6 35. YOUR LINE
04:24:10.000 --> 04:24:20.277
IS OPEN. AND WE. 6 35 YOU PRESS
04:24:20.344 --> 04:24:23.681
THE 10 AGAIN? AND WE'LL GO TO
04:24:23.747 --> 04:24:24.915
LINE 6 36 IN THE MEANTIME,
04:24:24.982 --> 04:24:28.552
PLEASE GO AHEAD. PILLOW CHAIR
04:24:28.619 --> 04:24:30.154
MEMBERS. AMBER CELL WITH TRENTON
04:24:30.221 --> 04:24:31.889
PRESENT INSULTING ON BEHALF OF
04:24:31.956 --> 04:24:38.395
ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND IN
04:24:38.462 --> 04:24:40.531
GO BACK TO, UH, 6 35, PLEASE GO
04:24:40.598 --> 04:24:43.767
AHEAD. SMELL GERMAN NEGRO ON
04:24:43.834 --> 04:24:45.002
BEHALF OF LEGAL CALIFORNIA
04:24:45.069 --> 04:24:49.106
CITIES AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
04:24:49.173 --> 04:24:50.608
AND MADAM CHAIR, A NO FURTHER
04:24:50.674 --> 04:24:52.109
COMMENTS IN Q. VERY GOOD. WE'RE
04:24:52.176 --> 04:24:54.445
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION.
04:24:54.511 --> 04:24:55.713
THERE ARE NO LEAD OPPOSITION
04:24:55.779 --> 04:24:57.448
WITNESSES IDENTIFIED. IS THERE
04:24:57.514 --> 04:24:58.482
ANYBODY IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD
04:24:58.549 --> 04:25:01.185
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
04:25:01.252 --> 04:25:03.020
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
04:25:03.087 --> 04:25:06.590
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND INQUIRE.
04:25:06.657 --> 04:25:09.126
WHETHER THERE ARE INDIVIDUALS
04:25:09.193 --> 04:25:10.427
THAT WANT TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
04:25:10.494 --> 04:25:14.565
TO A B 26 22. AND IF THEY WOULD
04:25:14.632 --> 04:25:15.799
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION,
04:25:15.866 --> 04:25:25.609
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM KAREN
04:25:25.676 --> 04:25:27.211
. NO COMMENTS COMING IN VERY
04:25:27.278 --> 04:25:28.679
GOOD. WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
04:25:28.746 --> 04:25:29.413
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS?
04:25:29.480 --> 04:25:31.615
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? SENATOR
04:25:31.682 --> 04:25:33.050
DRIESELL. THANK YOU, MADAM
04:25:33.117 --> 04:25:36.186
CHAIR. UH JUST TO RAISE TO THE
04:25:36.253 --> 04:25:38.722
AUTHOR, UM, I HAVE WORKED WITH
04:25:38.789 --> 04:25:42.459
MY COLLEAGUES IN THE SENATE. UH
04:25:42.526 --> 04:25:46.830
TO ADD LABOR STANDARDS ON YOU
04:25:46.897 --> 04:25:49.266
KNOW THE CONTRACTS THAT WE AWARD
04:25:49.333 --> 04:25:51.568
OR THE PROCUREMENT PROCESS?
04:25:51.635 --> 04:25:52.636
BECAUSE THESE ARE OUR TAX
04:25:52.703 --> 04:25:55.472
DOLLARS AT WORK. THESE ARE THE
04:25:55.539 --> 04:25:57.875
PEOPLE'S MONEY, SO WE WANT TO
04:25:57.941 --> 04:25:59.710
MAKE SURE THAT WHAT'S BEING
04:25:59.777 --> 04:26:00.878
CREATED THE KINDS OF JOBS THAT
04:26:00.944 --> 04:26:02.479
ARE BEING CREATED OR QUALITY
04:26:02.546 --> 04:26:03.447
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS,
04:26:03.514 --> 04:26:07.518
OUTREACH TO ALL COMMUNITIES. UM
04:26:07.584 --> 04:26:13.457
AND GOOD PAIN JOBS. UM SO, UH, I
04:26:13.524 --> 04:26:16.927
WOULD LIKE TO WORK WITH YOU, UH
04:26:16.994 --> 04:26:18.595
, TO LOOK AT THESE HIGH ROAD
04:26:18.662 --> 04:26:20.631
STANDARDS. THEY ARE ALREADY, UM
04:26:20.698 --> 04:26:21.699
, CODIFIED IN THE UNEMPLOYMENT
04:26:21.765 --> 04:26:24.535
INSURANCE CODE, SO THERE'S A WAY
04:26:24.601 --> 04:26:26.270
TO JUST MAKE SIMPLE REFERENCE
04:26:26.337 --> 04:26:28.238
WITHOUT, YOU KNOW, HAVING A
04:26:28.305 --> 04:26:30.174
WHOLE BOOK WRITTEN ON IT. SO
04:26:30.240 --> 04:26:31.342
WITH THAT IN MIND, I WOULD
04:26:31.408 --> 04:26:35.946
COURSE LOVE TO SUPPORT YOU. THAT
04:26:36.013 --> 04:26:37.815
EMOTION. THANK YOU, SENATOR. AND
04:26:37.881 --> 04:26:39.650
MORE THAN HAPPY TO LOOK AT THAT
04:26:39.717 --> 04:26:41.285
ISSUE, AND YOU KNOW, THESE ARE
04:26:41.352 --> 04:26:42.653
PUBLIC AGENCIES WERE DEALING
04:26:42.720 --> 04:26:44.021
WITH WHO GOT HIT PRETTY HARD
04:26:44.088 --> 04:26:45.089
DURING COVID ARE STILL
04:26:45.155 --> 04:26:48.692
RECOVERING. BUT MORE THAN HAPPY
04:26:48.759 --> 04:26:50.961
TO LOOK AT A WAY TO DO A CROSS
04:26:51.028 --> 04:26:51.795
REFERENCE THERE AND MAKE SURE
04:26:51.862 --> 04:26:53.564
THAT THOSE STANDARDS ARE ARE IN
04:26:53.630 --> 04:26:54.998
PLACE ON THE LEGISLATION. MORE
04:26:55.065 --> 04:26:57.067
THAN HAPPY TO LOOK AT THAT
04:26:57.134 --> 04:26:57.901
ISSUE. GREAT. THANK YOU. I MOVED
04:26:57.968 --> 04:26:59.837
THE BILL. THERE IS A MOTION BY
04:26:59.903 --> 04:27:02.873
SENATOR DURAZO. SENATOR NELSON
04:27:02.940 --> 04:27:04.441
WERE ON FILE ITEM NUMBER 21 A B
04:27:04.508 --> 04:27:08.045
26 22. AND THERE IS A MOTION.
04:27:08.112 --> 04:27:11.815
UM, YOU MAY CONCLUDE. JUST ASK
04:27:11.882 --> 04:27:13.250
FOR MY VOTE. THANK YOU, MADAM
04:27:13.317 --> 04:27:14.151
CHAIR FOR ENTERTAINING IT AND
04:27:14.218 --> 04:27:17.388
STAFF FOR THEIR WORK ON THE
04:27:17.454 --> 04:27:19.823
CONTINUATION OF THIS POLICY AND
04:27:19.890 --> 04:27:22.359
FISCAL APPROACH WILL HELP OUR
04:27:22.426 --> 04:27:23.594
AGENCIES MAKE THAT CONVERSION.
04:27:23.660 --> 04:27:26.029
APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU SO MUCH
04:27:26.096 --> 04:27:27.231
, AND I APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING
04:27:27.297 --> 04:27:30.401
THIS BILL FORWARD AND ONE OF
04:27:30.467 --> 04:27:32.002
THESE DAYS. WE'RE GOING TO START
04:27:32.069 --> 04:27:34.972
PRODUCING THEM HERE BECAUSE WE
04:27:35.038 --> 04:27:37.975
INVEST ALL THESE TAX DOLLARS, UM
04:27:38.041 --> 04:27:41.011
IN RENEWABLE ENERGY, BUT THEN BY
04:27:41.078 --> 04:27:42.946
A SOLAR PANELS FROM GERMANY AND
04:27:43.013 --> 04:27:45.349
CHINA AND DON'T PRODUCE THEM
04:27:45.416 --> 04:27:47.618
RIGHT RIGHT IN OUR OWN STATE,
04:27:47.684 --> 04:27:49.119
WHICH IS KIND OF ONE OF MY
04:27:49.186 --> 04:27:50.721
FRUSTRATIONS. IF I COULD JUST
04:27:50.788 --> 04:27:52.856
HAVE VERY QUICKLY YES, ONE OF
04:27:52.923 --> 04:27:54.425
THE ONE OF THE MAIN COMPANIES IS
04:27:54.491 --> 04:27:56.226
RIGHT BY MY HOME DISTRICT, AND
04:27:56.293 --> 04:27:57.194
I'VE HAD THE BENEFIT OF TOURING
04:27:57.261 --> 04:27:59.229
THAT FACILITY WAS VERY IMPRESSED
04:27:59.296 --> 04:28:00.731
. SO THERE ARE THERE IS JOB
04:28:00.798 --> 04:28:02.266
CREATION HAPPENING RIGHT HERE IN
04:28:02.332 --> 04:28:03.801
OUR STATE. THAT'S GREAT. THANK
04:28:03.867 --> 04:28:04.968
YOU. FOR THAT. APPRECIATE IT.
04:28:05.035 --> 04:28:06.236
THERE IS A MOTION. PLEASE CALL
04:28:06.303 --> 04:28:09.573
THE ROLL. MOTION IS TO PASS BUT
04:28:09.640 --> 04:28:11.475
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
04:28:11.542 --> 04:28:12.342
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
04:28:12.409 --> 04:28:16.146
SENATORS CABALLERO, Hí
04:28:16.213 --> 04:28:19.082
, NILSSON, DORIS OH OH, I
04:28:19.149 --> 04:28:20.083
HERTZBERG WIENER THROUGH THE
04:28:20.150 --> 04:28:24.054
ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT, AND WE
04:28:24.121 --> 04:28:25.856
WILL PUT IT ON CALL FOR THE
04:28:25.923 --> 04:28:28.258
ABSENT MEMBERS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:28:28.325 --> 04:28:35.699
SANTIAGO WELCOME. WE'D LIKE TO
04:28:35.766 --> 04:28:37.835
PICK UP FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX,
04:28:37.901 --> 04:28:40.137
WHICH IS A B 15 15 IF THAT'S
04:28:40.204 --> 04:28:41.805
OKAY WITH YOU. ABSOLUTELY THANK
04:28:41.872 --> 04:28:42.706
YOU, MADAM SHERIFF, ALLOWING ME
04:28:42.773 --> 04:28:44.842
TO PRESENT AND WE WANT TO ACCEPT
04:28:44.908 --> 04:28:45.676
THE COMMITTEE COMMITTEE'S
04:28:45.742 --> 04:28:47.611
AMENDMENTS AND CONTINUE WORKING.
04:28:47.678 --> 04:28:48.679
TO MAKE SURE THAT THE GRANTEE
04:28:48.745 --> 04:28:50.147
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS WHICH,
04:28:50.214 --> 04:28:51.548
WITH YOUR COMMITTEE AND THE
04:28:51.615 --> 04:28:53.083
COMMITTEE STAFF AND THE FRENCH
04:28:53.150 --> 04:28:54.351
TAX SITE SIDEBOARD APPRECIATE
04:28:54.418 --> 04:28:55.419
THAT IT'S ACTUALLY MEANINGFUL TO
04:28:55.486 --> 04:28:58.956
DO THAT. UM PLAN. THIS IS
04:28:59.022 --> 04:29:00.357
STRAIGHTFORWARD BILL THAT WOULD
04:29:00.424 --> 04:29:01.492
CODIFY THE OUTREACH, EDUCATION
04:29:01.558 --> 04:29:03.393
AND FREE TAX ASSISTANCE GRANT
04:29:03.460 --> 04:29:04.761
PROGRAMS SO THEY CAN MILLIONS OF
04:29:04.828 --> 04:29:05.729
FOUNDERS COULD CONTINUE APPLYING
04:29:05.796 --> 04:29:06.697
FOR THE DIFFERENT TRACKS
04:29:06.763 --> 04:29:08.999
CREDITS. THAT ARE AVAILABLE. FOR
04:29:09.066 --> 04:29:09.766
EXAMPLE, WE'RE NOW PUSHING FOR
04:29:09.833 --> 04:29:11.702
THE BETTER FOR FAMILIES REBATE
04:29:11.768 --> 04:29:12.970
THE GOLDEN STATE STIMULUS. THE
04:29:13.036 --> 04:29:15.105
STATE AND FEDERAL INCOME TAXES
04:29:15.172 --> 04:29:15.939
ON CHILD TAX CREDIT IN THE
04:29:16.006 --> 04:29:19.042
FASTER YOU TAX PROGRAM. IT'S
04:29:19.109 --> 04:29:20.277
FUNDED IN THE BUDGET. WE WANT TO
04:29:20.344 --> 04:29:22.446
CODIFY IT, AND THERE'S A
04:29:22.513 --> 04:29:25.382
SIGNIFICANT PUBLIC GOOD TO ALL
04:29:25.449 --> 04:29:26.550
CALIFORNIANS. WE HAVE TWO
04:29:26.617 --> 04:29:27.217
WITNESSES WHO WILL BE TESTIFYING
04:29:27.284 --> 04:29:29.853
BY PHONE. MARGARITA ALVAREZ
04:29:29.920 --> 04:29:30.854
GOMEZ FROM CENTRAL CITY
04:29:30.921 --> 04:29:33.724
NEIGHBORHOOD PARTNERS. AND
04:29:33.790 --> 04:29:35.859
DEBORAH LINDER, HOME FROM THE
04:29:35.926 --> 04:29:36.960
UNITED WAY. CALIFORNIA CAPITAL
04:29:37.027 --> 04:29:40.364
REGION. THANK YOU VERY GOOD.
04:29:40.430 --> 04:29:41.398
LET'S START WITH MARGARITA
04:29:41.465 --> 04:29:42.766
ALVAREZ GÓMEZ. THE FLOOR IS
04:29:42.833 --> 04:29:51.642
YOURS. YES. GOOD AFTERNOON. UM
04:29:51.708 --> 04:29:53.877
GOOD. GOOD AFTERNOON. CARE ABOUT
04:29:53.944 --> 04:29:55.412
YOUR OWN MEMBERS OF THE
04:29:55.479 --> 04:29:56.313
COMMITTEE? THANK YOU FOR
04:29:56.380 --> 04:29:57.347
INVITING ME HERE TODAY. MY NAME
04:29:57.414 --> 04:29:59.149
IS MARGARITA ALVAREZ GOMEZ AND
04:29:59.216 --> 04:30:01.385
I'M, THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
04:30:01.451 --> 04:30:03.954
CENTRAL CITY PARTNERS. ANGELES
04:30:04.021 --> 04:30:05.422
BASED ON PROFIT THAT ADVANCES
04:30:05.489 --> 04:30:06.757
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES OF LOW
04:30:06.823 --> 04:30:07.958
INCOME FAMILIES BY FULL STREAM
04:30:08.025 --> 04:30:11.161
PARTNERSHIP. AND SUPPORTING
04:30:11.228 --> 04:30:12.763
POSITIVE COMMUNITY CHANGE. I AM
04:30:12.829 --> 04:30:15.899
HERE TODAY AND SUPPORT OF BABY.
04:30:15.966 --> 04:30:18.669
15155 GRAND FUNDING FOR
04:30:18.735 --> 04:30:20.938
COMMUNITY BASED TAX CREDIT HAVE
04:30:21.004 --> 04:30:23.473
REACHED EDUCATION AND FREE TAX
04:30:23.540 --> 04:30:26.143
PREPARATION SERVICES TO CMP HAS
04:30:26.209 --> 04:30:27.277
PROVIDED TAX CREDIT, EDUCATION
04:30:27.344 --> 04:30:29.246
OF REACH AND PRETEXT SEPARATION
04:30:29.313 --> 04:30:31.982
SERVICES. IN ENGLISH AND SPANISH
04:30:32.049 --> 04:30:33.584
FOR OVER 10 YEARS BELOW AND
04:30:33.650 --> 04:30:35.118
MOTHERING FROM TAXPAYERS,
04:30:35.185 --> 04:30:35.652
INCLUDING INDIVIDUALS AND
04:30:35.719 --> 04:30:39.523
FAMILIES. THE FAMILIES THAT WE
04:30:39.590 --> 04:30:42.159
SORT OF ON AVERAGE 17,000 PER
04:30:42.225 --> 04:30:43.794
YEAR AND CANNOT AFFORD THE HIGH
04:30:43.860 --> 04:30:47.464
COST OF FOR PROFIT TAX PREPARERS
04:30:47.531 --> 04:30:49.566
. THEY ARE FAMILIES AND RELY ON
04:30:49.633 --> 04:30:50.801
THE EARNING CONTACTS, CREDIT AND
04:30:50.867 --> 04:30:53.704
CHILDHOODS CREDIT. ANOTHER
04:30:53.770 --> 04:30:56.440
CREDITS TO MAINTAIN THE HOUSING
04:30:56.506 --> 04:30:58.842
FOR ON THE TABLE AND MEET THE
04:30:58.909 --> 04:30:59.710
BASIC NEEDS OF THEIR CHILDREN.
04:30:59.776 --> 04:31:01.945
THE STATE FUNDING WILL RECEIVE
04:31:02.012 --> 04:31:03.447
THE RAISE AWARENESS AND TAX
04:31:03.513 --> 04:31:04.581
BENEFITS AND NOT COMMUNITY HELPS
04:31:04.648 --> 04:31:08.051
ENSURE THAT ALL TAX PLAYERS HAVE
04:31:08.118 --> 04:31:10.554
EQUAL ACCESS TO ACCURATE TAX
04:31:10.621 --> 04:31:12.956
INFORMATION AND NON PREDATORY
04:31:13.023 --> 04:31:14.992
TAX PREPARATION SERVICES,
04:31:15.058 --> 04:31:16.059
REGARDLESS IF THEY ARE
04:31:16.126 --> 04:31:17.894
TRADITIONAL TAXPAYER OR FILE US
04:31:17.961 --> 04:31:20.731
AND I THINK HOLDER AS SURVIVORS
04:31:20.797 --> 04:31:23.066
SIDE CCMP HELD THOUSANDS OF
04:31:23.133 --> 04:31:25.836
TAXPAYERS SMILED TAXES EVERY
04:31:25.902 --> 04:31:27.604
YEAR, INCLUDING. I THINK HOLDERS
04:31:27.671 --> 04:31:28.939
WHO OFTEN HAVE LIMITED
04:31:29.006 --> 04:31:31.208
EXPERIENCE WAS ATTACKED, FILING
04:31:31.274 --> 04:31:31.942
AND REQUIRED ADDITIONAL
04:31:32.009 --> 04:31:32.676
ASSISTANCE NAVIGATING THE
04:31:32.743 --> 04:31:36.480
PROCESS. THIS BILL WILL ENSURE
04:31:36.546 --> 04:31:39.182
THAT STATE FUNDING FOR FREE TAX
04:31:39.249 --> 04:31:40.784
PREPARATION SERVICES IS PROVIDED
04:31:40.851 --> 04:31:42.719
YEAR ROUND. ORGANIZATIONS LIKE
04:31:42.786 --> 04:31:43.854
THE CMP CAN MAINTAIN OUR
04:31:43.920 --> 04:31:47.457
SERVICES. WITH THAT INTERRUPTION
04:31:47.524 --> 04:31:48.959
. THIS FUNDING WILL HELP OUR
04:31:49.026 --> 04:31:50.460
FAMILIES BE MORE FINANCIALLY
04:31:50.527 --> 04:31:52.663
SECURE AND HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO
04:31:52.729 --> 04:31:54.631
INCREASE HOUSES, ABILITY AND
04:31:54.698 --> 04:31:56.466
REDUCED WOULD INSECURITY ON
04:31:56.533 --> 04:31:58.135
BEHALF OF THE THOUSANDS OF
04:31:58.201 --> 04:32:01.038
TAXPAYERS CCMP EACH YEAR AND THE
04:32:01.104 --> 04:32:02.606
DAWSONS OF OTHER VITALS,
04:32:02.673 --> 04:32:03.440
ORGANIZATIONS AND THE COMMUNITY,
04:32:03.507 --> 04:32:07.644
A LARGE FUNGAL IT AND COURAGE
04:32:07.711 --> 04:32:08.912
YOU TO VOTE? YES OR MAYBE 151
04:32:08.979 --> 04:32:12.416
SIDE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
04:32:12.482 --> 04:32:14.317
MUCH. NEXT, WE'LL GO TO DEBRA
04:32:14.384 --> 04:32:20.457
LINDER HOME. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
04:32:20.524 --> 04:32:21.958
NAME IS DEBORAH LINDER, HOME
04:32:22.025 --> 04:32:23.493
WITH UNITED WAY CALIFORNIA
04:32:23.560 --> 04:32:24.227
CAPITAL REGION AND REPRESENTING
04:32:24.294 --> 04:32:27.330
THE CALI COALITION. I AM PROUD
04:32:27.397 --> 04:32:28.865
TO TESTIFY AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
04:32:28.932 --> 04:32:30.867
ABBY 15 15 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:32:30.934 --> 04:32:33.236
SANTIAGO AS I KNOW FIRSTHAND
04:32:33.303 --> 04:32:34.538
POWER THAT COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
04:32:34.604 --> 04:32:35.772
AT FREE TAX PREP SERVICES HAVE
04:32:35.839 --> 04:32:38.775
IN MY COMMUNITY. THE COVID 19
04:32:38.842 --> 04:32:40.610
PANDEMIC HAS HAD DEVASTATING
04:32:40.677 --> 04:32:42.179
HEALTH AND ECONOMIC IMPACT ON
04:32:42.245 --> 04:32:44.181
OUR MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES
04:32:44.247 --> 04:32:45.315
, INCLUDING LOW INCOME AND
04:32:45.382 --> 04:32:47.517
UNDOCUMENTED CALIFORNIANS DURING
04:32:47.584 --> 04:32:49.319
THIS TIME UNITED WAY, CALIFORNIA
04:32:49.386 --> 04:32:50.754
CAPITAL REGION HAS CONTINUED TO
04:32:50.821 --> 04:32:51.755
PROVIDE CRITICAL FINANCIAL
04:32:51.822 --> 04:32:54.324
EMPOWERMENT TOOLS. INCLUDING
04:32:54.391 --> 04:32:55.992
VOLUNTEER INCOME TAX ASSISTANCE
04:32:56.059 --> 04:32:59.062
, OR VADA IN 2022 UNITED WAY
04:32:59.129 --> 04:33:01.231
VOLUNTEERS HELPED OVER 5000
04:33:01.298 --> 04:33:02.432
INDIVIDUALS WITH FREE FREE TAX
04:33:02.499 --> 04:33:05.769
PREPARATION. SAVING OVER $1
04:33:05.836 --> 04:33:07.637
MILLION IN TAX PREPARATION FEES
04:33:07.704 --> 04:33:10.340
MORE THAN $9.6 MILLION IN
04:33:10.407 --> 04:33:11.375
CREDIT, HAVE ALREADY BEEN
04:33:11.441 --> 04:33:13.343
CLAIMED ACROSS THE SACRAMENTO
04:33:13.410 --> 04:33:14.845
REGION ALONE WITH THESE EFFORTS
04:33:14.911 --> 04:33:16.513
, WE ARE INCREDIBLY PROUD OF
04:33:16.580 --> 04:33:18.949
THIS WORK AND KNOW THAT WE CAN
04:33:19.015 --> 04:33:19.883
REACH MORE ELIGIBLE TAX FILERS
04:33:19.950 --> 04:33:21.585
WITH YEAR ROUND SERVICES AS
04:33:21.651 --> 04:33:23.854
ENVISIONED IN A B 15 15. THE
04:33:23.920 --> 04:33:25.255
MAJORITY OF CALIFORNIANS
04:33:25.322 --> 04:33:26.990
BENEFITING FROM THE CALI, HPC
04:33:27.057 --> 04:33:28.859
AND YOUNG CHILD TAX CREDIT,
04:33:28.925 --> 04:33:31.194
PARTICULARLY AMONG ITIN FILERS
04:33:31.261 --> 04:33:33.063
PAY COMMERCIAL TAX PREPARER TO
04:33:33.130 --> 04:33:34.164
RECLAIM THESE CREDITS, EVEN
04:33:34.231 --> 04:33:35.932
THOUGH THEY ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
04:33:35.999 --> 04:33:38.935
FREE TAX SERVICES. MAYBE 15 15
04:33:39.002 --> 04:33:40.337
WILL ENSURE THE STATE PROVIDES
04:33:40.403 --> 04:33:41.805
ADEQUATE ASSISTANCE AND
04:33:41.872 --> 04:33:43.740
EDUCATION FILERS AND WILL ENSURE
04:33:43.807 --> 04:33:45.442
TRUSTED CBO PARTNERS ARE FUNDED
04:33:45.509 --> 04:33:47.344
MORE ADEQUATELY ADEQUATELY SO
04:33:47.411 --> 04:33:48.912
THAT FAMILIES ELIGIBLE FOR TAX
04:33:48.979 --> 04:33:50.614
CREDITS CAN FILE AND RECEIVE
04:33:50.680 --> 04:33:52.849
LIGHT FALTERING FINANCIAL AID.
04:33:52.916 --> 04:33:54.484
IT TAKES YEAR ROUND EFFORT FROM
04:33:54.551 --> 04:33:56.453
DEDICATED AND PASSIONATE PEOPLE
04:33:56.520 --> 04:33:58.054
TO CONTINUE TO BUILD AND PERFECT
04:33:58.121 --> 04:33:59.890
OUR SERVICES AT A TIME OF
04:33:59.956 --> 04:34:00.924
CONTINUED ECONOMIC INSECURITY
04:34:00.991 --> 04:34:03.093
AND UNPRECEDENTED TAX CREDIT THE
04:34:03.160 --> 04:34:03.827
NEED FOR CLEAR OUTREACH,
04:34:03.894 --> 04:34:04.728
EDUCATION AND FREE TAX
04:34:04.795 --> 04:34:08.331
ASSISTANCE. FROM TRUSTED SOURCES
04:34:08.398 --> 04:34:09.733
HAD DRAMATICALLY INCREASED
04:34:09.800 --> 04:34:11.368
ACROSS OUR STATE. THIS BILL WILL
04:34:11.434 --> 04:34:12.903
ENSURE THAT MORE LOW INCOME
04:34:12.969 --> 04:34:14.604
CALIFORNIANS AND FAMILIES ARE
04:34:14.671 --> 04:34:16.106
BETTER ABLE TO GAIN ACCESS TO
04:34:16.173 --> 04:34:17.507
EQUITABLE TAX CREDITS AT NO
04:34:17.574 --> 04:34:19.709
ADDITIONAL COST TO THEM. FOR
04:34:19.776 --> 04:34:21.278
THESE REASONS, I RESPECTFULLY
04:34:21.344 --> 04:34:23.613
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE ON A B 15 15.
04:34:23.680 --> 04:34:26.917
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:34:26.983 --> 04:34:28.051
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. WE'RE GOING
04:34:28.118 --> 04:34:32.289
TO MOVE ON TO THE HAVE.
04:34:32.355 --> 04:34:33.824
INDIVIDUALS THAT WANT TO SPEAK
04:34:33.890 --> 04:34:35.158
IN SUPPORT IN ROOM. 2100 IS
04:34:35.225 --> 04:34:37.127
THERE ANYONE HERE WHO WOULD LIKE
04:34:37.194 --> 04:34:39.296
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT? SEEING NONE
04:34:39.362 --> 04:34:40.297
WILL MOVE ON TO THE
04:34:40.363 --> 04:34:41.398
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
04:34:41.465 --> 04:34:43.066
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD QUEUE UP
04:34:43.133 --> 04:34:44.167
GOT INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE
04:34:44.234 --> 04:34:48.104
TO SPEAK. CERTAINLY IF THEY'D
04:34:48.171 --> 04:34:49.506
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT, MAYBE
04:34:49.573 --> 04:34:52.475
15 15, PLEASE PRESS 10 AND YOU
04:34:52.542 --> 04:34:54.511
KNOW THE LINE AT 6 31, PLEASE GO
04:34:54.578 --> 04:34:58.048
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, REBECA
04:34:58.114 --> 04:34:58.815
GONZALEZ FOR THE NATIONAL
04:34:58.882 --> 04:35:00.217
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS,
04:35:00.283 --> 04:35:00.817
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
04:35:00.884 --> 04:35:06.823
THANK YOU. NEXT GO TO LINE 1.
04:35:06.890 --> 04:35:12.796
60, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU,
04:35:12.863 --> 04:35:14.731
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
04:35:14.798 --> 04:35:16.533
COMMITTEE. THIS IS TERRY OLI
04:35:16.600 --> 04:35:17.534
WITH ECONOMIC SECURITY PROJECT
04:35:17.601 --> 04:35:18.635
ACTION IN STRONG SUPPORT OF 15
04:35:18.702 --> 04:35:23.473
15 THINK IT NEXT GO TO LINE 607,
04:35:23.540 --> 04:35:27.744
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
04:35:27.811 --> 04:35:29.279
. INTERESTING CHAN WITH GRACE
04:35:29.346 --> 04:35:30.914
AND CHILD POVERTY IN CALIFORNIA
04:35:30.981 --> 04:35:32.716
AND TRUMP SUPPORT OF MAYBE 15
04:35:32.782 --> 04:35:36.987
15. THANK YOU. WE'LL GO TO LINE
04:35:37.053 --> 04:35:41.558
5 48, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
04:35:41.625 --> 04:35:43.059
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS JACKSON
04:35:43.126 --> 04:35:45.195
NGUYEN UNITED WAYS OF CALIFORNIA
04:35:45.262 --> 04:35:46.630
, CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
04:35:46.696 --> 04:35:51.234
MAYBE 15 15. THANK YOU. WE WILL
04:35:51.301 --> 04:35:53.169
GO TO LINE 6 29, PLEASE GO
04:35:53.236 --> 04:35:56.539
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME
04:35:56.606 --> 04:35:57.741
IS MONICA LASSO WITH GOLDEN
04:35:57.807 --> 04:35:59.476
STATE OPPORTUNITY AND CALLING
04:35:59.542 --> 04:36:01.278
AND STRONG SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 15
04:36:01.344 --> 04:36:05.749
15. WE WILL GO TO LINE 2 13 213,
04:36:05.815 --> 04:36:09.019
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
04:36:09.085 --> 04:36:10.487
, MADAM TERRY MEMBERS. MY NAME
04:36:10.554 --> 04:36:11.888
IS MADDIE RIPPED FROM THE
04:36:11.955 --> 04:36:12.756
CHILDREN'S DEFENSE FUND
04:36:12.822 --> 04:36:14.157
CALIFORNIA CALLING IN STRONG
04:36:14.224 --> 04:36:15.992
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 15 15. THANK
04:36:16.059 --> 04:36:19.029
YOU. MADAM CHAIR, NO FURTHER
04:36:19.095 --> 04:36:21.831
COMMENT AND QUÊ. THANK YOU VERY
04:36:21.898 --> 04:36:23.500
MUCH. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
04:36:23.566 --> 04:36:25.001
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. THERE ARE
04:36:25.068 --> 04:36:28.238
NONE LISTED IN, UM AS LEAD
04:36:28.305 --> 04:36:29.339
WITNESSES. IS THERE ANYBODY IN
04:36:29.406 --> 04:36:31.374
ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
04:36:31.441 --> 04:36:32.876
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. SEEING THEN
04:36:32.943 --> 04:36:33.843
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
04:36:33.910 --> 04:36:36.579
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IF YOU
04:36:36.646 --> 04:36:40.917
COULD CURE UP OPPOSITION. EARLY
04:36:40.984 --> 04:36:42.585
AND SAVE TO, UH, SPEAKING
04:36:42.652 --> 04:36:44.354
OPPOSITION TO MAYBE 15 15,
04:36:44.421 --> 04:36:52.429
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
04:36:52.495 --> 04:36:53.797
CHAIR. NO COMMENTS COMING IN
04:36:53.863 --> 04:36:56.933
VERY GOOD. BRING THEM THE MATTER
04:36:57.000 --> 04:36:58.802
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE AND THE
04:36:58.868 --> 04:37:02.739
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS. YOU MAY
04:37:02.806 --> 04:37:05.308
CONCLUDE. I JUST WANNA THANK YOU
04:37:05.375 --> 04:37:07.477
ENOUGH FOR THE LONGEST TO GET
04:37:07.544 --> 04:37:09.145
THIS AND PRESENT BECAUSE IT'S
04:37:09.212 --> 04:37:10.747
INCREDIBLY PAINFUL AND TALK A
04:37:10.814 --> 04:37:12.015
LOT, BUT I FEEL VERY PASSIONATE
04:37:12.082 --> 04:37:13.917
ABOUT THIS. BECAUSE IT'S A
04:37:13.984 --> 04:37:17.120
SIMPLE STEP. BUT TO THE OTHER
04:37:17.187 --> 04:37:18.588
FAMILIES THAT BENEFIT FROM THE
04:37:18.655 --> 04:37:19.656
PROGRAM, WHO OTHERWISE NOT
04:37:19.723 --> 04:37:20.657
BENEFIT IF THESE PROGRAMS
04:37:20.724 --> 04:37:22.258
WEREN'T IN PLACE. IN AND
04:37:22.325 --> 04:37:24.627
SOMETIMES THAT IMPACTS NOT SEEN.
04:37:24.694 --> 04:37:27.364
UM CCMP, WHO? THE ORGANIZATION
04:37:27.430 --> 04:37:29.366
WHO PRESENTED IT IS IN DISTRICT
04:37:29.432 --> 04:37:31.868
THAT THE GOOD SENATOR AND I
04:37:31.935 --> 04:37:33.236
OVERLAP. IT WOULD HAVE LINES AND
04:37:33.303 --> 04:37:36.673
LINES OF PEOPLE WHO KNOW HOW TO
04:37:36.740 --> 04:37:38.141
BECAUSE OF THE TIN NUMBER
04:37:38.208 --> 04:37:39.643
BECAUSE THESE PROGRAMS THAT
04:37:39.709 --> 04:37:41.011
EXISTED THEY RECEIVING THOUSANDS
04:37:41.077 --> 04:37:42.245
AND THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS AND
04:37:42.312 --> 04:37:44.147
THESE ARE HARD HIT PROBABLY
04:37:44.214 --> 04:37:45.715
STRICKEN AREAS, SO I CAN'T THANK
04:37:45.782 --> 04:37:48.351
YOU ENOUGH FOR HELPING US. THANK
04:37:48.418 --> 04:37:49.886
YOU FOR AN I VOTED IMPORTANT
04:37:49.953 --> 04:37:51.388
BILL, I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION.
04:37:51.454 --> 04:37:52.822
AT THE MOTION BY SENATOR DURAZO.
04:37:52.889 --> 04:37:58.061
THIS CULTURAL. MOTION IS TO PASS
04:37:58.128 --> 04:37:59.896
THIS AMENDED BUT FIRST CEMENT
04:37:59.963 --> 04:38:01.398
EVERY REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
04:38:01.464 --> 04:38:02.832
ON APPROPRIATIONS. SENATOR SCOTT
04:38:02.899 --> 04:38:06.102
HI, ERO. I NILSSON NILSSON. I DO
04:38:06.169 --> 04:38:07.904
RUSSELL H
04:38:07.971 --> 04:38:12.308
ROUGH ZERO. THAT BILL IS OUT.
04:38:12.375 --> 04:38:14.778
WE'LL LEAVE THE, UM OPEN FOR THE
04:38:14.844 --> 04:38:16.679
ABSENT MEMBERS. THANK YOU VERY
04:38:16.746 --> 04:38:18.681
MUCH FOR THAT. MOVING ON TO FILE
04:38:18.748 --> 04:38:24.120
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN A. B 1925.
04:38:24.187 --> 04:38:26.823
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I WANT
04:38:26.890 --> 04:38:27.957
TO THANK FIRST BEGIN BY
04:38:28.024 --> 04:38:28.958
ACCEPTING THE COMEDIAN
04:38:29.025 --> 04:38:31.694
AMENDMENTS. AND THIS THIS BILL
04:38:31.761 --> 04:38:32.996
IS GOING TO HAVE A HUGE IMPACT
04:38:33.063 --> 04:38:35.965
ON A POPULATION PEOPLE WHO ARE
04:38:36.032 --> 04:38:37.300
DOCUMENTED NONCITIZENS WHO WILL
04:38:37.367 --> 04:38:39.002
NOW BE ELIGIBLE FOR COUNTY BOARD
04:38:39.069 --> 04:38:40.136
APPOINTED POSITION BY REMOVING
04:38:40.203 --> 04:38:41.771
AN OUTDATED REFERENCE TO VOTER
04:38:41.838 --> 04:38:46.910
REGISTRATION REQUIREMENT. UM THE
04:38:46.976 --> 04:38:48.278
AND, FOR EXAMPLE, DACA
04:38:48.344 --> 04:38:49.579
RECIPIENTS AND LEGAL PERMANENT
04:38:49.646 --> 04:38:51.081
RESIDENTS. RESIDENTS WOULD NOT
04:38:51.147 --> 04:38:52.749
BE ABLE TO HAVE MEANINGFUL WORK
04:38:52.816 --> 04:38:54.117
IN THEIR COMMUNITIES. AND YOU
04:38:54.184 --> 04:38:55.652
KNOW, WE REALLY GOT THE IDEA
04:38:55.718 --> 04:38:57.754
WHEN L A COUNTY DID IT, AND I
04:38:57.821 --> 04:38:58.755
REMEMBER TALKING TO THE
04:38:58.822 --> 04:39:00.523
SUPERVISOR AT THE TIME. SOLUTION
04:39:00.590 --> 04:39:02.258
AND I WALKED UP AND SAID, YOU
04:39:02.325 --> 04:39:03.226
KNOW WHAT? WHAT IS IT THAT YOU
04:39:03.293 --> 04:39:05.395
DID? AND THEY FOUND AN OLD
04:39:05.462 --> 04:39:06.429
OUTDATED REFERENCE TO VOTER
04:39:06.496 --> 04:39:09.365
REGISTRATION. AH TO GIVE CERTAIN
04:39:09.432 --> 04:39:13.369
APPOINTED POSITIONS. A POINT OF
04:39:13.436 --> 04:39:15.138
POSITIONS LIKE A CPA LIKE A
04:39:15.205 --> 04:39:16.840
ALREADY WAS A NUMBER OF THEM,
04:39:16.906 --> 04:39:18.875
AND WHEN THEY TOOK THAT OUT,
04:39:18.942 --> 04:39:20.743
THEY WERE ABLE TO OPEN IT UP.
04:39:20.810 --> 04:39:21.878
THE OTHER PEOPLE WHO ARE
04:39:21.945 --> 04:39:22.612
QUALIFIED WHO COULD APPLY, BUT
04:39:22.679 --> 04:39:24.814
JUST 10 GOT THEIR CITIZENSHIP
04:39:24.881 --> 04:39:25.448
BECAUSE THE FEDERAL COURTS HAVE
04:39:25.515 --> 04:39:27.317
BEEN TIED UP OR FOR WHATEVER
04:39:27.383 --> 04:39:28.952
REASON. AND WE FOUND A NECESSITY
04:39:29.018 --> 04:39:30.053
TO DO THIS ACROSS THE STATE
04:39:30.120 --> 04:39:31.121
BECAUSE THEY'RE VERY QUALIFIED
04:39:31.187 --> 04:39:32.889
PEOPLE WHO JUST HAVEN'T BEEN
04:39:32.956 --> 04:39:33.490
ABLE TO GET THEIR CITIZENSHIP
04:39:33.556 --> 04:39:35.758
WHO SHOULD BE WORKING AND SOME
04:39:35.825 --> 04:39:36.392
OF THESE APPOINTED POSITIONS SO
04:39:36.459 --> 04:39:37.160
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE.
04:39:37.227 --> 04:39:40.096
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, UM, LEAD
04:39:40.163 --> 04:39:41.731
WITNESSES. RITA MEDINA FROM THE
04:39:41.798 --> 04:39:43.700
COALITION OF HUMANE IMMIGRANT
04:39:43.766 --> 04:39:47.137
RIGHTS AND SHE'S OH, SHE'S HERE.
04:39:47.203 --> 04:39:49.672
WELCOME CRAZY DAYS, SO I CAME IN
04:39:49.739 --> 04:39:52.242
PERSON. THANK YOU, MADAM. TO SEE
04:39:52.308 --> 04:39:55.145
THE CRAZY DAYS. I WENT TO THIS
04:39:55.211 --> 04:39:56.679
EXACTLY, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU
04:39:56.746 --> 04:39:58.314
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS RITA MEDINA
04:39:58.381 --> 04:39:59.682
. I'M DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF STATE
04:39:59.749 --> 04:40:01.351
POLICY AND ADVOCACY AT SHE WOULD
04:40:01.417 --> 04:40:03.219
LÀ AND WE'RE HERE IN PROUD
04:40:03.286 --> 04:40:05.221
SUPPORT, AND MAYBE 1925 IS JUST
04:40:05.288 --> 04:40:07.023
SO ESSENTIAL TO ASSURING THAT
04:40:07.090 --> 04:40:09.325
NON CITIZENS IN CALIFORNIA ARE
04:40:09.392 --> 04:40:10.760
AFFORDED THE SAME OPPORTUNITIES
04:40:10.827 --> 04:40:13.129
AS THEIR CITIZEN COMMUNITY
04:40:13.196 --> 04:40:14.464
MEMBERS AND THAT WE'RE WORKING
04:40:14.531 --> 04:40:16.132
TO CREATE SYSTEMS WHERE ALL
04:40:16.199 --> 04:40:16.733
RESIDENTS CAN PARTICIPATE IN
04:40:16.799 --> 04:40:17.700
THEIR COMMUNITIES. THIS WAS JUST
04:40:17.767 --> 04:40:18.768
MENTIONED BY THE ASSEMBLY
04:40:18.835 --> 04:40:22.071
MEMBER. CALIFORNIA IS HOME TO 11
04:40:22.138 --> 04:40:22.972
MILLION IMMIGRANTS, AND OVER
04:40:23.039 --> 04:40:25.074
HALF OF THEM ARE DOCUMENTED
04:40:25.141 --> 04:40:27.177
RESIDENTS. BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY
04:40:27.243 --> 04:40:28.978
, MOST OF THESE FOLKS HAVE BEEN
04:40:29.045 --> 04:40:30.513
HERE FOR SEVERAL YEARS, AND IN
04:40:30.580 --> 04:40:32.749
SOME CASES DECADES, RESIDENTS OF
04:40:32.815 --> 04:40:34.117
THEIR STATES RESIDENTS OF THE
04:40:34.184 --> 04:40:35.785
SAME COUNTY YEAR AFTER YEAR, AND
04:40:35.852 --> 04:40:37.253
THESE COMMUNITY MEMBERS HOLD
04:40:37.320 --> 04:40:39.222
VALUABLE KNOWLEDGE EXPERIENCE
04:40:39.289 --> 04:40:41.391
THAT CAN HELP STRENGTHEN OUR
04:40:41.457 --> 04:40:42.392
LOCAL LEADERSHIP AND ADD
04:40:42.458 --> 04:40:44.227
IMPORTANT VOICES. AND IN VIEW
04:40:44.294 --> 04:40:45.628
POINTS TO THESE CONVERSATIONS,
04:40:45.695 --> 04:40:47.230
SOMEONE'S PLACE OF BIRTH SHOULD
04:40:47.297 --> 04:40:49.265
NOT EXCLUDE THEM FROM HOLDING
04:40:49.332 --> 04:40:50.733
PUBLIC OFFICE WHERE THEY CAN DO
04:40:50.800 --> 04:40:51.834
MEANINGFUL WORK FOR THEIR
04:40:51.901 --> 04:40:52.802
COMMUNITIES WHERE THEY WANT TO
04:40:52.869 --> 04:40:54.871
DO MEANINGFUL WORK AND WE WORK
04:40:54.938 --> 04:40:56.739
WITH OUR FOLKS EVERY DAY AND SEE
04:40:56.806 --> 04:40:59.475
THE EXCITEMENT WHEN, AS YOU KNOW
04:40:59.542 --> 04:41:00.376
THEY COME AND ENGAGE WITH THEIR
04:41:00.443 --> 04:41:01.211
GOVERNMENT. LAWCENTER THIS
04:41:01.277 --> 04:41:02.679
COUNTY IS THE ONLY COUNTY IN THE
04:41:02.745 --> 04:41:04.847
STATE TO HAVE ADDRESSED THIS
04:41:04.914 --> 04:41:05.481
ISSUE BY UNANIMOUSLY PASSING A
04:41:05.548 --> 04:41:06.549
MOTON TO WAIVE THE VOTER
04:41:06.616 --> 04:41:08.151
REGISTRATION REQUIREMENT FOR
04:41:08.218 --> 04:41:09.118
MOST APPOINTED COUNTY POSITION,
04:41:09.185 --> 04:41:11.054
SO A STEP CLOSER TO EQUITY AND
04:41:11.120 --> 04:41:13.189
PARTICIPATION. IT'S TIME FOR
04:41:13.256 --> 04:41:15.625
CALIFORNIA TO STEP UP AND TO
04:41:15.692 --> 04:41:18.228
ISSUE TO STEP UP AND ACT ON THIS
04:41:18.294 --> 04:41:20.029
ISSUE AND WAVE THE OUTDATED
04:41:20.096 --> 04:41:21.264
VOTER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENT
04:41:21.331 --> 04:41:24.267
FOR BOARD APPOINTED POSITIONS.
04:41:24.334 --> 04:41:25.768
THIS WILL OPEN UP OPPORTUNITIES
04:41:25.835 --> 04:41:26.769
FOR IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES. AND,
04:41:26.836 --> 04:41:28.204
OF COURSE, CHEERLESS IS
04:41:28.271 --> 04:41:28.972
ABSOLUTELY GOING TO STAND BY
04:41:29.038 --> 04:41:32.208
THAT. SO WE THINK THE ASSEMBLY
04:41:32.275 --> 04:41:33.209
MEMBER AND WE ASK FOR A VOTE.
04:41:33.276 --> 04:41:34.644
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:41:34.711 --> 04:41:36.012
IS THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM
04:41:36.079 --> 04:41:37.880
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:41:37.947 --> 04:41:41.985
SUPPORT OF A B 1925? SEEING NONE
04:41:42.051 --> 04:41:43.353
WILL MOVE ON TO THE
04:41:43.419 --> 04:41:44.954
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASKED
04:41:45.021 --> 04:41:46.155
THE MODERATOR TO POLICE QUÊ UP.
04:41:46.222 --> 04:41:49.792
UH, COMMENTS. CERTAINLY AND
04:41:49.859 --> 04:41:51.427
THEY'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
04:41:51.494 --> 04:42:00.136
OF A B 1925 PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
04:42:00.203 --> 04:42:01.604
MADAM CHAIR. NO COMMENTS COMING
04:42:01.671 --> 04:42:03.673
IN VERY GOOD. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
04:42:03.740 --> 04:42:05.742
THE OPPOSITION AND THERE ARE NO
04:42:05.808 --> 04:42:07.143
LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESSES
04:42:07.210 --> 04:42:08.478
IDENTIFIED IS THERE ANYONE HERE
04:42:08.544 --> 04:42:11.648
IN THE ROOM THAT WOULD LIKE TO
04:42:11.714 --> 04:42:13.683
TESTIFYING OPPOSITION, SAYING
04:42:13.750 --> 04:42:15.018
NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
04:42:15.084 --> 04:42:16.085
TELECONFERENCE LINE. AND IF YOU
04:42:16.152 --> 04:42:17.253
COULD QUEUE UP OPPOSITION,
04:42:17.320 --> 04:42:20.256
PLEASE CERTAINLY IF THEY'D LIKE
04:42:20.323 --> 04:42:22.158
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. THE A B
04:42:22.225 --> 04:42:31.000
1925 PLEASE PRESS 10. AND MADAM
04:42:31.067 --> 04:42:32.869
CARANO COMMENTS COMING IN VERY
04:42:32.935 --> 04:42:34.037
GOOD. WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
04:42:34.103 --> 04:42:37.273
COMMITTEE. UM SENATOR DURAZO
04:42:37.340 --> 04:42:38.908
LIKE TO MOVE THE BILL AND JUST
04:42:38.975 --> 04:42:40.877
MAKE A COMMENT YES. MOTION BY
04:42:40.943 --> 04:42:43.112
SENATOR DURAZO. THANK YOU. UM I
04:42:43.179 --> 04:42:47.016
WANT TO COMMEND THE AUTHOR. MY
04:42:47.083 --> 04:42:49.519
FIRST YEAR HERE IN SACRAMENTO, I
04:42:49.585 --> 04:42:53.022
TOOK UP A BILL FOR APPOINTMENTS
04:42:53.089 --> 04:42:54.791
AND COMMISSIONS, STATE
04:42:54.857 --> 04:42:58.161
COMMISSIONS AND STATE BOARDS.
04:42:58.227 --> 04:43:01.798
AND IT WAS THE SIMILAR IDEA WAS
04:43:01.864 --> 04:43:03.366
. IF YOU'RE NOT A CITIZEN, THEN
04:43:03.433 --> 04:43:04.867
YOU WERE BLOCKED FROM
04:43:04.934 --> 04:43:06.969
PARTICIPATING IN SO MANY I THINK
04:43:07.036 --> 04:43:09.439
WE HAVE THOUSANDS OF BOARDS HAVE
04:43:09.505 --> 04:43:11.307
TO DO WITH EDUCATION OR
04:43:11.374 --> 04:43:12.175
ENTERTAINMENT MUSIC. YOU NAME
04:43:12.241 --> 04:43:14.077
IT. WE HAVE A BOARD AND A
04:43:14.143 --> 04:43:17.580
COMMISSION. UM SO I REMEMBER
04:43:17.647 --> 04:43:19.849
TALKING TO SO MANY TALENTED
04:43:19.916 --> 04:43:22.418
YOUNG PEOPLE THAT JUST REALLY
04:43:22.485 --> 04:43:24.120
WANTED, AS SOMEONE SAID BETTER,
04:43:24.187 --> 04:43:27.123
MORE SERVED. PROVIDE MORE
04:43:27.190 --> 04:43:29.392
SERVICE TO OUR STATE, SO I'M
04:43:29.459 --> 04:43:31.594
GLAD IT'S SOMETHING SIMILAR,
04:43:31.661 --> 04:43:33.796
WHICH OPENS THE DOORS TO SO MANY
04:43:33.863 --> 04:43:34.864
PEOPLE THAT REALLY WANT TO SHARE
04:43:34.931 --> 04:43:38.334
THEIR TALENTS. SO THANK YOU. I
04:43:38.401 --> 04:43:40.436
AGREE. I THINK THIS IS IT'S A
04:43:40.503 --> 04:43:41.804
SIMPLE WORDING THAT CHANGES
04:43:41.871 --> 04:43:44.040
THINGS TOTALLY. AND SO IT'S A
04:43:44.107 --> 04:43:45.708
GOOD CATCH. AND I APPRECIATE THE
04:43:45.775 --> 04:43:47.744
WORK THAT YOU DID ON IT AND MUCH
04:43:47.810 --> 04:43:50.513
APPRECIATED. UM IF THERE'S NO
04:43:50.580 --> 04:43:52.281
FURTHER COMMENTS, WE DO HAVE
04:43:52.348 --> 04:43:54.317
EMOTION AND WILL ALLOW YOU TO
04:43:54.384 --> 04:43:55.351
CONCLUDE RESPECTFULLY WOULD ASK
04:43:55.418 --> 04:43:56.619
FOR AN I BOTH. THANK YOU. VERY
04:43:56.686 --> 04:43:58.788
GOOD. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THE
04:43:58.855 --> 04:44:00.390
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED,
04:44:00.456 --> 04:44:01.691
BUT FIRST AMENDED RE REFERRED TO
04:44:01.758 --> 04:44:04.360
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
04:44:04.427 --> 04:44:05.161
SENATORS CABALLERO CABALLERO
04:44:05.228 --> 04:44:12.368
NIELSEN. SO SO I HEARD HERZBERG
04:44:12.435 --> 04:44:16.072
WIENER 2 TO 0. WE ARE GOING TO
04:44:16.139 --> 04:44:17.974
LEAVE THAT BILL AND CALL. THANK
04:44:18.040 --> 04:44:34.223
YOU SO MUCH.
04:45:05.388 --> 04:45:06.689
WE ARE WAITING FOR AUTHORS AND
04:45:06.756 --> 04:45:10.593
BEEN TOLD THAT THERE AT LEAST
04:45:10.660 --> 04:45:13.129
ONE OF THEM IS ON THEIR WAY. SO
04:45:13.196 --> 04:45:14.464
WE'LL WE'LL TAKE A FIVE MINUTE
04:45:14.530 --> 04:45:16.532
RECESS AND WILL BE BACK. WHEN
04:45:16.599 --> 04:45:25.775
ONE OF THE AUTHORS GETS HERE.
04:45:25.842 --> 04:45:44.427
WHICH. ONE THEN. RIGHT? WORLD.
04:45:44.494 --> 04:46:00.543
YES.
04:46:01.244 --> 04:46:20.162
HAS.
04:47:01.871 --> 04:47:03.940
SO WE'LL TAKE UP SOME BUSINESS
04:47:04.006 --> 04:47:04.874
WHILE WE'RE WAITING FOR AN
04:47:04.941 --> 04:47:06.943
AUTHOR. UM WE HAVE FILE ITEM
04:47:07.009 --> 04:47:11.514
NUMBER 16, WHICH IS A B 27 21.
04:47:11.581 --> 04:47:12.682
WE HEARD THE BILL BUT DID NOT
04:47:12.748 --> 04:47:16.052
HAVE EMOTION. IS THERE A MOTION
04:47:16.118 --> 04:47:24.160
ON FILE ITEM NUMBER 6 16. MM HMM
04:47:24.226 --> 04:47:25.895
. SENATOR DURAZO. THIS IS UM
04:47:25.962 --> 04:47:32.568
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY UM. MOVED
04:47:32.635 --> 04:47:38.307
BY ASSEMBLY SENATOR DURAZO. UH
04:47:38.374 --> 04:47:39.542
YES, AND THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
04:47:39.609 --> 04:47:40.843
AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR. PLEASE
04:47:40.910 --> 04:47:45.948
CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
04:47:46.015 --> 04:47:49.685
CABALLERO, Hí
04:47:49.752 --> 04:47:51.387
, NO, DURAZO. SO I HERZBERG
04:47:51.454 --> 04:47:57.360
WIENER. 321. WILL PUT THAT ON
04:47:57.426 --> 04:47:59.729
CALL WILL TAKE UP FILE ITEM
04:47:59.795 --> 04:48:07.269
NUMBER 25. WHICH IS A B 26 56 BY
04:48:07.336 --> 04:48:17.480
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CUTTING SOME OF. I, UM I THOUGHT WE DID. BUT I
04:48:17.546 --> 04:48:19.515
AM TOLD WE DID NOT SO WE NEEDED
04:48:19.582 --> 04:48:23.519
A MOTION. AND MOTION BY SENATOR
04:48:23.586 --> 04:48:25.221
DRAWS. OH, DO PASS AS AMENDED
04:48:25.287 --> 04:48:27.323
BUT FIRST AMEND AND RE REFERRED
04:48:27.390 --> 04:48:28.224
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:48:28.290 --> 04:48:29.425
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
04:48:29.492 --> 04:48:34.664
ROLL. SENATORS CABALLERO, I KNOW
04:48:34.730 --> 04:48:38.634
I NEED TO HOLD HIM TO ROT Ó.
04:48:38.701 --> 04:48:42.872
GRASSO I HERZBERG WIENER 2 TO 0.
04:48:42.938 --> 04:48:44.573
WE'LL PUT THAT BACK ON CALL FOR
04:48:44.640 --> 04:48:45.975
THE MISSING MEMBERS, AND THEN WE
04:48:46.042 --> 04:48:49.412
NEED A MOTION ON FILE NUMBER.
04:48:49.478 --> 04:48:54.617
YEAH. 27 WHICH IS A B 28 87 BY A
04:48:54.684 --> 04:48:56.585
MEMBER, EDUARDO GARCIA,
04:48:56.652 --> 04:49:04.627
ENTERTAIN A MOTION. MOTION. YES.
04:49:04.694 --> 04:49:06.562
TO PASS AND RE REFER TO MEDIA ON
04:49:06.629 --> 04:49:07.563
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
04:49:07.630 --> 04:49:15.104
ROLL. SENATORS CABALLERO NIELSEN
04:49:15.171 --> 04:49:17.573
, SO I HERZBERG WIENER THROUGH
04:49:17.640 --> 04:49:21.544
20. THAT IS OUT. WE'LL PUT IT
04:49:21.610 --> 04:49:23.079
BACK ON CALL FOR THE MISSING
04:49:23.145 --> 04:49:27.983
MEMBERS. OKAY, DOPE NOW. TWO YES
04:49:28.050 --> 04:49:33.956
, ITEM 19. IT'S NOT. IT'S NOT
04:49:34.023 --> 04:49:44.400
OKAY. WE HAVE. TO 34 25. I GUESS
04:49:44.467 --> 04:49:48.637
1 26 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WANT TO
04:49:48.704 --> 04:49:57.713
WELCOME. THE FILE ITEM. 2018 25
04:49:57.780 --> 04:50:02.384
60 AFTERNOON MANAGER AND MEMBERS
04:50:02.451 --> 04:50:03.986
START BY SAYING THE COMMITTEE
04:50:04.053 --> 04:50:06.856
AND EXPRESSING MY PATIENT STAFF.
04:50:06.922 --> 04:50:10.659
FOR THEIR HELP AMENDED A 25 60
04:50:10.726 --> 04:50:12.995
ESTABLISHES A PILOT QUALIFIED
04:50:13.062 --> 04:50:15.097
JURISDICTIONS WITHIN THE ALAMEDA
04:50:15.164 --> 04:50:17.433
AND CONTRA COUNTIES AND CITIES
04:50:17.500 --> 04:50:19.068
WITHIN THOSE COUNTIES TO TURN
04:50:19.135 --> 04:50:19.835
BLOOD PROPERTIES INTO
04:50:19.902 --> 04:50:20.836
OPPORTUNITIES FOR FIRST TIME
04:50:20.903 --> 04:50:24.907
MARKERS. A B 25 60 ACCOMPLISHES
04:50:24.974 --> 04:50:27.476
THIS BY AFFECTING THE SPECIFIC
04:50:27.543 --> 04:50:29.812
JURISDICTIONS TO IDENTIFY THEIR
04:50:29.879 --> 04:50:32.181
BLIND DEVELOP A PLAN AND
04:50:32.248 --> 04:50:33.415
CONGESTION PROFIT DEVELOPERS
04:50:33.482 --> 04:50:36.585
COMMUNITY. STATIONS AND FINANCE
04:50:36.652 --> 04:50:39.488
AND POSITIONS THREE PROPERTIES
04:50:39.555 --> 04:50:41.357
AND RETURN THEM TO THE HANDS OF
04:50:41.423 --> 04:50:43.425
COMMUNITY. ADDITIONALLY LOCAL
04:50:43.492 --> 04:50:44.560
GOVERNMENTS ARE ASKED TO
04:50:44.627 --> 04:50:47.396
IDENTIFY BARRIERS TO IMPLEMENT
04:50:47.463 --> 04:50:50.599
AND WORKED THEM PROGRAM STRING
04:50:50.666 --> 04:50:52.535
FROM A VERY SPECIAL PILOT AND
04:50:52.601 --> 04:50:56.238
FRIEND TIME WHERE THIS
04:50:56.305 --> 04:50:57.740
TRANSFORMED BLIGHTED PROPERTIES
04:50:57.807 --> 04:51:00.009
INTO NEW HOMES FOR FIRST TIME
04:51:00.075 --> 04:51:00.743
HOMEBUYERS AND IN THE PROCESS,
04:51:00.810 --> 04:51:03.946
REDUCE CRIME, THIS PIECE FOR
04:51:04.013 --> 04:51:05.347
AFFECTED NEIGHBORHOODS YOU
04:51:05.414 --> 04:51:07.149
WITNESSES WITH THE DAY JONES
04:51:07.216 --> 04:51:11.320
AUDIO OF THE COMMUNITY BUILT AND
04:51:11.387 --> 04:51:13.989
YOU NO DIRECT RICHMOND HOUSING
04:51:14.056 --> 04:51:20.362
SERVICES. SUCH WALK UP. GOOD
04:51:20.429 --> 04:51:23.866
AFTERNOON AGAIN, OBVIOUSLY RICH
04:51:23.933 --> 04:51:25.000
PUT HOUSING SERVICES. WE
04:51:25.067 --> 04:51:26.669
APPRECIATE HER OFFICE WELL AS
04:51:26.735 --> 04:51:33.742
THE KIDS. MORE ABOUT IT. 25 6.
04:51:33.809 --> 04:51:39.381
COORDINATION THAT 25 6. IT'S
04:51:39.448 --> 04:51:41.150
PROBLEM, SIR. TO ADDRESS NEEDS
04:51:41.217 --> 04:51:42.818
CUTE FOR HOMEOWNER OPPORTUNITIES
04:51:42.885 --> 04:51:47.122
FOR FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS AS WE
04:51:47.189 --> 04:51:49.859
ARE PALETTE, EASE STATE
04:51:49.925 --> 04:51:53.395
GOVERNMENT AND A LOT OF FUN
04:51:53.462 --> 04:51:55.197
PERHAPS CAME IN THIS INSTANCE
04:51:55.264 --> 04:51:59.435
OTHER THAN IT IS. THERE'S NOT
04:51:59.501 --> 04:52:09.912
TIME ON HER. I AM BEFORE POCKET
04:52:09.979 --> 04:52:11.847
. WE EXPERIENCE OR TAPE I'M OUT
04:52:11.914 --> 04:52:14.650
HAVING YOU CAN SEE WHAT WE'RE
04:52:14.717 --> 04:52:17.219
BIG JOB. PEOPLE WILL BUY
04:52:17.286 --> 04:52:21.290
ANYTHING IN THE YES EFFORTS
04:52:21.357 --> 04:52:24.360
TRYING TO QUICKLY BY PHOENIX
04:52:24.426 --> 04:52:28.931
FEEL MADE POSSIBLE WHETHER
04:52:28.998 --> 04:52:36.472
YOU'RE. APRIL. BELIEVE THAT
04:52:36.538 --> 04:52:44.546
MONTH. MHM I MEAN IT. AND THIRD.
04:52:44.613 --> 04:52:50.486
THURMOND. LEVERAGING THEY FOUND
04:52:50.552 --> 04:52:55.658
WAS THERE AND THEIR TOMORROW
04:52:55.724 --> 04:53:00.429
STATIONED TEST POSITION. HANDS
04:53:00.496 --> 04:53:03.465
AT HOME. AWESOME THAT THERE'S
04:53:03.532 --> 04:53:06.535
LITTLE OR NO OPPORTUNITY
04:53:06.602 --> 04:53:08.837
AVAILABLE THAT MORE THAN A
04:53:08.904 --> 04:53:13.842
PERCENT. SO THIS IS A BALL TO BE
04:53:13.909 --> 04:53:17.479
ABLE TO THINK OWNERSHIP INTO THE
04:53:17.546 --> 04:53:20.749
ENTITIES IMPACT BY STRIPPING, UM
04:53:20.816 --> 04:53:24.186
LINING AND OTHER ISSUES. THAT
04:53:24.253 --> 04:53:29.124
CAUSED FRANCHISE IN AREAS WE
04:53:29.191 --> 04:53:31.126
DON'T KNOW THAT THIS IS ANY NEW
04:53:31.193 --> 04:53:32.594
MUNICIPAL. THERE'S ALREADY A
04:53:32.661 --> 04:53:37.933
TOOL. BRING EVIDENCES SECTION
04:53:38.000 --> 04:53:40.302
AND LEVERAGING FUNDS THAT THEY
04:53:40.369 --> 04:53:41.337
HAVE AVAILABLE COMMUNITY
04:53:41.403 --> 04:53:44.606
INVESTMENT. DID IT FOR THE
04:53:44.673 --> 04:53:48.310
COMMITTEE MENTIONED. YOU HAVE TO
04:53:48.377 --> 04:53:58.821
SAY IS THAT. GOOD ALL THEY NEED.
04:53:58.887 --> 04:54:05.361
YES THAT'S A PILOT. TO BE
04:54:05.427 --> 04:54:10.199
BEAUTIFUL DRESS. HIS DORMANT
04:54:10.265 --> 04:54:19.675
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. MHM. TOÀN
04:54:19.742 --> 04:54:24.713
COMMUNITY. COMMITTEE, BRINGING
04:54:24.780 --> 04:54:30.419
BUILT OFFERING A. IT WAS VERY
04:54:30.486 --> 04:54:34.456
CREDIBLE ISSUE SIX. SAMPLE
04:54:34.523 --> 04:54:36.825
POSSIBLE WE DID NOT ACCEPT COME
04:54:36.892 --> 04:54:40.696
TOGETHER. I'M STILL IN TROUBLE.
04:54:40.763 --> 04:54:42.898
THIS IS THE SAME OPPORTUNITY TO
04:54:42.965 --> 04:54:45.300
TEST PILOT AND WE'RE PATIENT,
04:54:45.367 --> 04:54:49.238
PRIVATE LEWIS TO CREATE WAS VERY
04:54:49.304 --> 04:54:51.407
REALLY NON EXISTENT FINANCING
04:54:51.473 --> 04:54:52.441
FOR SMALL INFILL HOUSING
04:54:52.508 --> 04:54:53.609
PRODUCTION THAT WILL BE SALE IN
04:54:53.675 --> 04:54:58.580
MARCH. FAMILIES. 5 $60 FROM THE
04:54:58.647 --> 04:55:00.516
VERY SUCCESSFUL RENOVATION PILOT
04:55:00.582 --> 04:55:02.184
PROGRAM THAT BROUGHT HER
04:55:02.251 --> 04:55:05.921
COMMUNITY STATION, SOCIAL
04:55:05.988 --> 04:55:06.588
INVESTOR AND A LOCAL
04:55:06.655 --> 04:55:07.222
JURISDICTION ESSENTIAL PARTNER.
04:55:07.289 --> 04:55:11.627
YEAH. PART OF THE RICHMOND
04:55:11.693 --> 04:55:14.196
PALETTE. THERE WERE OVER 200 IN
04:55:14.263 --> 04:55:15.397
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES. COSTUME
04:55:15.464 --> 04:55:17.599
CITY HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
04:55:17.666 --> 04:55:20.602
JUST TO KEEP THEM BOARD ON
04:55:20.669 --> 04:55:23.372
FRIDAY ON AN ACT TO BLOOD BAND
04:55:23.439 --> 04:55:24.440
AT HOME SO THE PROGRAM COULD
04:55:24.506 --> 04:55:25.908
EVALUATE ACQUIRE REHAB AND FELT
04:55:25.974 --> 04:55:27.776
TO GRADUATE LOCAL SORT OF FIRST
04:55:27.843 --> 04:55:31.447
TIME HOMEBUYER PROGRAMS. AS THE
04:55:31.513 --> 04:55:33.482
ASSEMBLY ANALYSIS, TOTAL COST
04:55:33.549 --> 04:55:35.617
AND A B 26 YEARS, ALL
04:55:35.684 --> 04:55:39.521
JURISDICTIONS LESS THAN $150,000
04:55:39.588 --> 04:55:41.457
IS IMPORTANT TO COMPARE. COMPARE
04:55:41.523 --> 04:55:44.660
THAT TO THE ALMOST $5 MILLION.
04:55:44.726 --> 04:55:46.361
BENEFITS SEEN BY THE CITY OF
04:55:46.428 --> 04:55:49.064
RICHMOND FIVE YEAR PILOT PROGRAM
04:55:49.131 --> 04:55:50.732
AND THAT INCLUDES 6.5 AND IN
04:55:50.799 --> 04:55:52.201
LOCAL SPENDING GENERATED THROUGH
04:55:52.267 --> 04:55:55.404
THE CONSTRUCTION WORK $800,000
04:55:55.471 --> 04:55:56.872
TO THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PAST
04:55:56.939 --> 04:55:58.707
DUE TAX CODE ENFORCEMENT LEANS
04:55:58.774 --> 04:56:01.176
$700,000 PER YEAR LOCAL ECONOMIC
04:56:01.243 --> 04:56:02.377
SPENDING GENERATED BY NEW
04:56:02.444 --> 04:56:05.013
HOMEOWNERS AND $350,000 PER YEAR
04:56:05.080 --> 04:56:07.716
IN REDUCED CODE ENFORCEMENT. BUS
04:56:07.783 --> 04:56:09.852
CCB IS PROUD TO SUPPORT THIS
04:56:09.918 --> 04:56:11.120
INNOVATIVE LEGISLATION TO
04:56:11.186 --> 04:56:12.354
ADDRESS LONGSTANDING BLIGHT AND
04:56:12.421 --> 04:56:14.223
ALAMEDA AND COST OF COST MONIES
04:56:14.289 --> 04:56:16.024
AS WELL AS CREATING A NEW FILE
04:56:16.091 --> 04:56:17.226
MECHANISM FOR MUCH NEW
04:56:17.292 --> 04:56:17.726
AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP
04:56:17.793 --> 04:56:20.129
PRODUCTION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
04:56:20.195 --> 04:56:21.463
VERY MUCH. ANYONE ELSE THAT
04:56:21.530 --> 04:56:23.298
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
04:56:23.365 --> 04:56:24.399
OF THIS BILL, PLEASE COME
04:56:24.466 --> 04:56:29.238
FORWARD. ADRIAN MOM. IT WAS
04:56:29.304 --> 04:56:30.472
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
04:56:30.539 --> 04:56:32.007
BEHALF OF HABITAT FOR HUMANITY,
04:56:32.074 --> 04:56:33.075
CALIFORNIA AND VERY STRONG
04:56:33.142 --> 04:56:39.648
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:56:39.715 --> 04:56:40.883
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
04:56:40.949 --> 04:56:41.917
COMMITTEE. JORDAN PLAN TO CARVE
04:56:41.984 --> 04:56:43.986
A HARD ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
04:56:44.052 --> 04:56:45.287
AND BE STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
04:56:45.354 --> 04:56:46.388
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
04:56:46.455 --> 04:56:49.291
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2100?
04:56:49.358 --> 04:56:50.859
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE OVER TO
04:56:50.926 --> 04:56:51.927
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
04:56:51.994 --> 04:56:53.996
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD QUEUE UP
04:56:54.062 --> 04:56:56.198
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
04:56:56.265 --> 04:57:00.102
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 25 60.
04:57:00.169 --> 04:57:01.737
AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:57:01.803 --> 04:57:05.040
SUPPORT OF A B 25 60 AT THE TIME
04:57:05.107 --> 04:57:06.108
, PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
04:57:06.175 --> 04:57:08.177
THE ZERO TOUCHED ON PHONE. AND
04:57:08.243 --> 04:57:09.478
IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:57:09.545 --> 04:57:11.280
SUPPORT OF PLEASE PRESS 10 ON
04:57:11.346 --> 04:57:13.182
YOUR TOUCH TONE PHONE AT THIS
04:57:13.248 --> 04:57:17.519
TIME. AND WE CURRENTLY HAVE NO
04:57:17.586 --> 04:57:20.589
LINES OF QUÊ. THANK YOU VERY
04:57:20.656 --> 04:57:22.558
MUCH. WE'LL MOVE ON TO, UM,
04:57:22.624 --> 04:57:23.559
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. THERE
04:57:23.625 --> 04:57:26.461
ARE NO LEAD. OPPOSITION
04:57:26.528 --> 04:57:28.697
WITNESSES NOTED. SO WE'LL SEE IF
04:57:28.764 --> 04:57:29.898
THERE'S ANYONE IN ROOM 2100 THAT
04:57:29.965 --> 04:57:30.933
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:57:30.999 --> 04:57:33.635
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL
04:57:33.702 --> 04:57:35.270
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
04:57:35.337 --> 04:57:36.171
LINE IS THERE COULD YOU PLEASE
04:57:36.238 --> 04:57:37.372
QUEUE UP OPPOSITION WITNESSES,
04:57:37.439 --> 04:57:41.810
PLEASE. COURSE. AND IF THERE IS
04:57:41.877 --> 04:57:43.345
ANYONE THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
04:57:43.412 --> 04:57:44.680
IN OPPOSITION TO A B 25 60,
04:57:44.746 --> 04:57:46.515
PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
04:57:46.582 --> 04:57:49.751
THE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AGAIN IF
04:57:49.818 --> 04:57:51.053
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
04:57:51.119 --> 04:57:52.888
OPPOSITION TO PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
04:57:52.955 --> 04:57:57.726
THIS TIME. AND WE CURRENTLY HAVE
04:57:57.793 --> 04:57:59.294
NO ALLIANCE IN Q. VERY GOOD.
04:57:59.361 --> 04:58:00.963
WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
04:58:01.029 --> 04:58:01.964
COMMITTEE FOR COMMENTS OR
04:58:02.030 --> 04:58:04.666
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS. THERE IS
04:58:04.733 --> 04:58:06.201
A MOTION BY SENATOR DURAZO.
04:58:06.268 --> 04:58:07.769
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
04:58:07.836 --> 04:58:09.371
FORWARD. UM, THIS IS REALLY
04:58:09.438 --> 04:58:11.506
INNOVATIVE AND WHAT WE KNOW IS
04:58:11.573 --> 04:58:13.141
THAT IT'S A LOT CHEAPER TO MIGHT
04:58:13.208 --> 04:58:17.713
AND FASTER. TO UM TO REALLY MAKE
04:58:17.779 --> 04:58:19.948
THE INVESTMENT TO BUY UP WHAT'S
04:58:20.015 --> 04:58:21.083
AFFORDABLE AND TO GET FAMILIES
04:58:21.149 --> 04:58:24.853
INTO THEM. UM BUT BUT I REALLY
04:58:24.920 --> 04:58:26.855
APPRECIATE THE FINANCIAL
04:58:26.922 --> 04:58:28.757
EDUCATION BECAUSE WITHOUT THAT
04:58:28.824 --> 04:58:30.892
FINANCIAL EDUCATION, WHAT WE
04:58:30.959 --> 04:58:31.860
FIND IS THAT YOU DO ALL THIS
04:58:31.927 --> 04:58:33.962
WORK AND THEN THEY DON'T QUALIFY
04:58:34.029 --> 04:58:35.597
FOR THE LOAN. SO I REALLY
04:58:35.664 --> 04:58:37.399
APPRECIATE THAT. AND SO WITH
04:58:37.466 --> 04:58:38.734
THAT THERE IS A MOTION AND WE'D
04:58:38.800 --> 04:58:40.469
ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE THANK YOU
04:58:40.535 --> 04:58:42.537
SO MUCH WITH THIS BILL. WE ARE
04:58:42.604 --> 04:58:44.139
RECLAIMING ABANDONED NEGLECTED
04:58:44.206 --> 04:58:45.540
HOMES AND REDLINED NEIGHBORHOODS
04:58:45.607 --> 04:58:46.441
FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE
04:58:46.508 --> 04:58:49.077
COMMUNITY. TO KEEP OUR STREETS
04:58:49.144 --> 04:58:50.646
SAFE AND TO START BUILDING AND
04:58:50.712 --> 04:58:52.014
REBUILDING BACK BLACK AND BROWN
04:58:52.080 --> 04:58:53.448
WEALTH IN PARTICULAR FOR
04:58:53.515 --> 04:58:54.850
OURSELVES AND OUR CHILDREN WITH
04:58:54.916 --> 04:58:55.851
THAT, I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
04:58:55.917 --> 04:58:57.419
YOUR RIVAL. VERY GOOD. PLEASE
04:58:57.486 --> 04:59:01.123
CALL THE ROLL. MOTION IS TO PASS
04:59:01.189 --> 04:59:02.924
THIS AMENDED BUT FIRST CEMENT
04:59:02.991 --> 04:59:05.227
AND REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:59:05.294 --> 04:59:05.727
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS
04:59:05.794 --> 04:59:09.931
CABALLERO, NILSSON, NILSSON,
04:59:09.998 --> 04:59:11.400
EIDUR ASO, Hí
04:59:11.466 --> 04:59:15.270
3 TO 0. BILL IS OUT. WE'LL LEAVE
04:59:15.337 --> 04:59:19.474
THE ROLL OPEN FOR THE MEMBERS
04:59:19.541 --> 04:59:20.575
THAT ARE MISSING. SO THANK YOU
04:59:20.642 --> 04:59:27.783
SO MUCH. JUST CHUGGING ALONG. WE
04:59:27.849 --> 04:59:32.454
ARE CHUGGING ON. I HAVE TO GO
04:59:32.521 --> 04:59:35.891
TESTIFY IN I MEAN, I HAVE TO GO
04:59:35.957 --> 04:59:37.459
PRESENT BILLS, SO I'M TRYING TO
04:59:37.526 --> 04:59:39.528
GET DONE AND I'M NOT GONNA BE
04:59:39.594 --> 04:59:41.296
ABLE TO DO IT. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:59:41.363 --> 04:59:49.137
RISK. YEAH. WELCOME. THANK YOU,
04:59:49.204 --> 04:59:51.640
SENATOR. MADAM CHAIR. AND
04:59:51.707 --> 04:59:57.112
MEMBERS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S I
04:59:57.179 --> 04:59:59.047
UNDERSTAND THAT YOU'RE ASKING
04:59:59.114 --> 05:00:00.182
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT
05:00:00.248 --> 05:00:02.784
YOUR BILL. AND WITH NO VOTE. IS
05:00:02.851 --> 05:00:03.985
THAT CORRECT? CORRECT VERY GOOD.
05:00:04.052 --> 05:00:05.120
WELL, WELCOME. WE'RE HAPPY TO
05:00:05.187 --> 05:00:08.790
SEE YOU HERE. THANK YOU. THANK
05:00:08.857 --> 05:00:10.726
YOU SO VERY MUCH. IT'S A VERY
05:00:10.792 --> 05:00:11.827
IMPORTANT ISSUE. AND I HAVE
05:00:11.893 --> 05:00:17.466
WORKED. TIRELESSLY ON. AND MY
05:00:17.532 --> 05:00:19.701
WITNESSES HAVE DONE A TREMENDOUS
05:00:19.768 --> 05:00:22.304
JOB OF MAKING SURE THAT WE GET
05:00:22.371 --> 05:00:23.305
INFORMATION TO THE COMMUNITY
05:00:23.372 --> 05:00:26.141
THAT IS THAT IS BASED ON THE
05:00:26.208 --> 05:00:29.945
FACTS. AND BASED ON WHAT REALLY
05:00:30.011 --> 05:00:30.812
HAPPENS TO HUMAN BEINGS BECAUSE
05:00:30.879 --> 05:00:36.284
OF THIS. SO A B 28 40
05:00:36.351 --> 05:00:38.453
ESTABLISHES A GOOD NEIGHBOR
05:00:38.520 --> 05:00:39.421
POLICY FOR LOGISTICS
05:00:39.488 --> 05:00:40.922
DEVELOPMENTS IMPACTING SAN
05:00:40.989 --> 05:00:41.857
BERNARDINO AND RIVERSIDE
05:00:41.923 --> 05:00:46.528
COUNTIES. SPECIFICALLY A B 28 40
05:00:46.595 --> 05:00:48.930
, AS WRITTEN WOULD REQUIRE THAT
05:00:48.997 --> 05:00:51.166
WAREHOUSES, 100,000 SQUARE FEET
05:00:51.233 --> 05:00:52.901
OR LARGER, BE BUILT AT LEAST
05:00:52.968 --> 05:00:56.438
1000 FT. OR FURTHER FROM
05:00:56.505 --> 05:00:57.439
SENSITIVE RECEPTORS SUCH AS
05:00:57.506 --> 05:00:59.875
SCHOOLS. RESIDENCES AND
05:00:59.941 --> 05:01:03.478
DAYCARES. THE BILL ALSO OFFERS
05:01:03.545 --> 05:01:05.647
DEVELOPERS SINCE THE AMENDMENT
05:01:05.714 --> 05:01:11.386
WAS TAKEN. AH AN OPPORTUNITY TO
05:01:11.453 --> 05:01:12.954
MEET THE REQUIREMENT BY PUTTING
05:01:13.021 --> 05:01:14.456
IN PLACE ALTERNATIVE MEASURES
05:01:14.523 --> 05:01:16.091
THAT PROVED SIMILAR PUBLIC
05:01:16.158 --> 05:01:17.192
HEALTH AND SAFETY BENEFITS TO
05:01:17.259 --> 05:01:17.759
COUNTER THE IMPACT. OF THE
05:01:17.826 --> 05:01:23.398
HEALTH. TO COUNTER THE NEGATIVE
05:01:23.465 --> 05:01:26.368
HEALTH IMPACT ON THE COMMUNITY.
05:01:26.435 --> 05:01:27.903
I BROUGHT THIS BILL FORWARD
05:01:27.969 --> 05:01:29.438
BECAUSE OF SIGNIFICANT CHANGES
05:01:29.504 --> 05:01:31.206
THAT HAVE OCCURRED OVER THE LAST
05:01:31.273 --> 05:01:33.875
DECADE IN THE INLAND EMPIRE.
05:01:33.942 --> 05:01:35.110
CHANGES THAT HAVE IMPACTED THE
05:01:35.177 --> 05:01:36.244
LIVES OF PEOPLE LIVING IN THE
05:01:36.311 --> 05:01:39.681
COMMUNITY. SINCE 2010. THERE
05:01:39.748 --> 05:01:43.318
HAVE BEEN MORE THAN 174 MILLION
05:01:43.385 --> 05:01:45.754
SQUARE FEET OF LOGISTICS
05:01:45.821 --> 05:01:46.822
INDUSTRIAL SPACE DEVELOPED IN
05:01:46.888 --> 05:01:49.858
THE COMMUNITY. WITH THE MAJORITY
05:01:49.925 --> 05:01:50.826
OF THIS BEING DEVELOPED IN SAN
05:01:50.892 --> 05:01:51.927
BERNARDINO AND RIVERSIDE
05:01:51.993 --> 05:01:55.630
COUNTIES. DURING THE SAME TIME.
05:01:55.697 --> 05:01:57.432
THE INLAND EMPIRE EXPERIENCE THE
05:01:57.499 --> 05:01:59.734
FIFTH LARGEST POPULATION GROWTH
05:01:59.801 --> 05:02:01.269
IN THE UNITED STATES. THIS
05:02:01.336 --> 05:02:02.237
INCLUDED NEARLY 400,000
05:02:02.304 --> 05:02:05.207
RESIDENTS. ADDED IN SAN
05:02:05.273 --> 05:02:06.308
BERNARDINO AND RIVERSIDE
05:02:06.374 --> 05:02:10.378
COUNTIES. THIS HAS CALLED
05:02:10.445 --> 05:02:11.379
SIGNIFICANT PLANNING ISSUES THAT
05:02:11.446 --> 05:02:12.447
WOULD HAVE BEEN HARD TO
05:02:12.514 --> 05:02:15.150
ANTICIPATE. WITH OVER 10 YEARS
05:02:15.217 --> 05:02:17.352
AGO, AND NOW COMMUNITY IS
05:02:17.419 --> 05:02:19.087
FUNDING WHERE HOUSES ARE BEING
05:02:19.154 --> 05:02:23.492
BUILT. RIGHT NEXT DOOR. NEXT TO
05:02:23.558 --> 05:02:26.862
SCHOOLS, WAREHOUSES THEM TRUCKS
05:02:26.928 --> 05:02:28.463
PRODUCING DIESEL PARTICULATE
05:02:28.530 --> 05:02:30.365
MATTER THE PRIMARY REASON WHY
05:02:30.432 --> 05:02:32.000
THE TWO PARTIES RANKED IN THE
05:02:32.067 --> 05:02:37.572
TOP 10. FOR THE WORST ANNUAL
05:02:37.639 --> 05:02:39.341
POLLUTION NATIONALLY TO THE
05:02:39.407 --> 05:02:43.879
AMERICAN NEGOTIATION. THIS POINT
05:02:43.945 --> 05:02:45.213
IS A DRIVING FACTOR AND
05:02:45.280 --> 05:02:48.316
RESPIRATORY ILLNESSES AS LEAD TO
05:02:48.383 --> 05:02:49.484
LONG TERM ISSUES. IT'S HEART
05:02:49.551 --> 05:02:55.857
DISEASE CANCER. 1000 FT THIS
05:02:55.924 --> 05:02:58.760
BILL IS ON A RECOMMENDATION.
05:02:58.827 --> 05:03:04.833
CALIFORNIA RESOURCES BOARD MEMO.
05:03:04.900 --> 05:03:06.401
WITH THE RECOMMENDATIONS.
05:03:06.468 --> 05:03:10.906
CALIFORNIA WRONG, IT'S FINE.
05:03:10.972 --> 05:03:23.752
PETE. DIESEL EMISSIONS. IMPACT
05:03:23.818 --> 05:03:28.590
RESEARCHERS. UM, WHEN YOU READ
05:03:28.657 --> 05:03:32.294
THE PARTICULAR MAN, YOU REALLY
05:03:32.360 --> 05:03:36.698
ARE GOING TO SEE A DROP IN THE
05:03:36.765 --> 05:03:38.700
HEALTH OF THE COMMUNITY. EXAMPLE
05:03:38.767 --> 05:03:45.907
IN MY DISTRICT IN THE COMMUNITY. SIX OUT OF THE SCHOOLS ARE
05:03:45.974 --> 05:03:51.379
HATED LOCATED. WITHIN AN APP 250
05:03:51.446 --> 05:04:01.556
FT. SOME CLOSEST 20 FT. ALSO
05:04:01.623 --> 05:04:06.795
RECENTLY HAD WENT THROUGH IT.
05:04:06.861 --> 05:04:13.001
THIS FIRE WHERE PROJECT WAS IT?
05:04:13.068 --> 05:04:18.607
RIGHT TO PUBLIC SCHOOL. UM
05:04:18.673 --> 05:04:24.746
HELLO, GOOD. I WANT TO CLEAR.
05:04:24.813 --> 05:04:43.732
NEVER.
05:10:30.044 --> 05:10:30.078
TOO
05:10:30.144 --> 05:10:32.046
TOILET SCRUBBING TREES LIKE
05:10:32.113 --> 05:10:34.148
CYPRUS TREES, FOR EXAMPLE, WHO
05:10:34.215 --> 05:10:36.117
ACCORDING TO A WIND TUNNEL STUDY
05:10:36.184 --> 05:10:39.654
HAVE 20% REDUCTION IN PM 2.5.
05:10:39.721 --> 05:10:42.190
THE RECOMMENDATION FROM ANY
05:10:42.256 --> 05:10:45.126
REGULATORY AGENCY IS 1000 FT
05:10:45.193 --> 05:10:46.361
BECAUSE IT HAS TO DO WITH THE
05:10:46.427 --> 05:10:49.964
SPAN OF 2.5. WITH COVID. WE
05:10:50.031 --> 05:10:52.367
STOOD SIX FT APART BECAUSE OF
05:10:52.433 --> 05:10:53.768
THE PARTICULAR PARTICULAR
05:10:53.835 --> 05:10:56.838
MATTER. THIS IS PM 2.5. IF THE
05:10:56.904 --> 05:10:58.806
REGULATORY AGENCIES ARE SAYING
05:10:58.873 --> 05:11:00.008
1000 FT, THERE IS A REASON
05:11:00.074 --> 05:11:02.944
BEHIND IT. WE APPRECIATE OUR
05:11:03.011 --> 05:11:06.014
REPRE REPRESENTATIVES AND
05:11:06.080 --> 05:11:07.782
LEADERS WORKING TOGETHER TO FIND
05:11:07.849 --> 05:11:09.917
COMMON GROUND, BUT WE MUST
05:11:09.984 --> 05:11:12.286
REENTER TO REITERATE THE IMPACT
05:11:12.353 --> 05:11:13.755
OF PARTICULAR IS NOT A FUTURE
05:11:13.821 --> 05:11:17.992
STATE. IT'S HAPPENING NOW. WITH
05:11:18.059 --> 05:11:19.460
CHILDREN THAT ARE STRUGGLING TO
05:11:19.527 --> 05:11:21.629
BREATHE BLOODY NOSES. LOW BIRTH
05:11:21.696 --> 05:11:23.231
RATES, IRREVERSIBLE NEUROLOGICAL
05:11:23.297 --> 05:11:29.070
IMPACTS. WE ARE GETTING SICK OUT
05:11:29.137 --> 05:11:31.873
OF RATE THAT OUTPACES HEALTH
05:11:31.939 --> 05:11:34.375
INSURANCE COVERAGE, SIXTIES
05:11:34.442 --> 05:11:36.177
RESPIRATORY ILLNESSES.
05:11:36.244 --> 05:11:36.744
EXACERBATIONS OVERCROWDED,
05:11:36.811 --> 05:11:40.948
URGENT CARES. AH EMERGENCY ROOMS
05:11:41.015 --> 05:11:47.889
AND HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS BECAUSE. INEVITABLY WE ARE LEAVING THE
05:11:47.955 --> 05:11:49.023
TRUE COST OF WAREHOUSE
05:11:49.090 --> 05:11:51.993
DEVELOPMENT TO THE STATE. THIS
05:11:52.060 --> 05:11:54.729
IS ABOUT HEALTH STANDARDS, WHICH
05:11:54.796 --> 05:11:56.764
, WITHOUT THIS BILL CANNOT
05:11:56.831 --> 05:11:59.567
REALISTICALLY EVER EXIST OR COME
05:11:59.634 --> 05:12:00.635
TO COME BACK CHILDHOOD ASTHMA
05:12:00.701 --> 05:12:03.237
RATE AND MANY OTHER CHRONIC
05:12:03.304 --> 05:12:05.106
PULMONARY CONDITIONS DUE TO POOR
05:12:05.173 --> 05:12:06.507
AIR QUALITY THAT RESULTS FROM
05:12:06.574 --> 05:12:07.442
INDISCRIMINATE OF WAREHOUSE
05:12:07.508 --> 05:12:11.112
DEVELOPMENT. IN SHORT, NOT
05:12:11.179 --> 05:12:13.648
PASSING BILL 28 40. YOU'RE
05:12:13.714 --> 05:12:15.183
ALLOWING THESE DEVELOPERS TO
05:12:15.249 --> 05:12:17.118
OFFSET THEIR COST TO THE STATE
05:12:17.185 --> 05:12:19.320
IN A RATIO OF $50 PER TON. OF
05:12:19.387 --> 05:12:24.292
POLLUTION. TO BE CLEAR. WE'RE
05:12:24.358 --> 05:12:27.328
NOT SAYING DON'T BUILD, AS UM,
05:12:27.395 --> 05:12:29.864
UM, ASSEMBLY MEMBER ELOISE REYES
05:12:29.931 --> 05:12:31.199
SAID WHAT WE'RE SAYING AND
05:12:31.265 --> 05:12:34.635
ASKING US TO BUILD RESPONSIBLY.
05:12:34.702 --> 05:12:36.270
WE'RE NOT SAYING DON'T BRING
05:12:36.337 --> 05:12:37.772
JOBS WERE SAYING BRING GOOD PING
05:12:37.839 --> 05:12:41.576
JOBS. I ENCOURAGE YOU TO REALLY
05:12:41.642 --> 05:12:44.011
LOOK AT THIS BILL FOR WHAT IT IS
05:12:44.078 --> 05:12:46.681
SAYING AND WHAT IT IS OFFERING
05:12:46.747 --> 05:12:48.382
AND SILENCE THAT FALSE
05:12:48.449 --> 05:12:49.450
NARRATIVES THAT ARE WILDLY BEING
05:12:49.517 --> 05:12:53.588
SPREAD. I GOT TO ASK YOU TO WRAP
05:12:53.654 --> 05:12:57.225
UP BECAUSE I LET MY LAST. OKAY
05:12:57.291 --> 05:12:57.859
APPRECIATE IT. SO I WROTE THIS
05:12:57.925 --> 05:13:00.094
TESTIMONY. BEFORE THE DECISION
05:13:00.161 --> 05:13:01.996
TO PRESENT WAS MADE, AND I WAS
05:13:02.063 --> 05:13:04.732
GOING TO ASK YOU TO PLEASE ALLOW
05:13:04.799 --> 05:13:06.734
ME THE HONOR AND THE PRIVILEGE
05:13:06.801 --> 05:13:08.903
TO GO BACK HOME WITH SOME GOOD
05:13:08.970 --> 05:13:09.904
NEWS AND SOME PROTECTIVE
05:13:09.971 --> 05:13:15.476
MEASURES. UM I DON'T. I DON'T
05:13:15.543 --> 05:13:17.311
KNOW WHERE THAT FITS NOW IN
05:13:17.378 --> 05:13:20.414
TODAY. THANK YOU FOR THE
05:13:20.481 --> 05:13:21.749
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK. THANK YOU
05:13:21.816 --> 05:13:23.518
VERY MUCH FOR BEING HERE. NOW WE
05:13:23.584 --> 05:13:24.685
HAVE JUST SENIOR GONZALES WAS ON
05:13:24.752 --> 05:13:28.222
THE PHONE. HI. CAN YOU HEAR ME?
05:13:28.289 --> 05:13:32.527
WE CAN GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND
05:13:32.593 --> 05:13:34.128
MEMBERS. MY A MOVIE. SONIA
05:13:34.195 --> 05:13:35.696
GONZALEZ. I'M THE ORGANIZING
05:13:35.763 --> 05:13:36.697
DIRECTOR WITH THE UNITED FOOD
05:13:36.764 --> 05:13:38.099
AND COMMERCIAL WORKERS UNION,
05:13:38.166 --> 05:13:40.902
LOCAL 11 57. I'M HERE ON BEHALF
05:13:40.968 --> 05:13:43.237
OF 19,000 MEMBERS IN THE
05:13:43.304 --> 05:13:44.505
COUNTY'S RIVERSIDE, SOME
05:13:44.572 --> 05:13:46.007
BERNARDINO AND PARTS OF L, A AND
05:13:46.073 --> 05:13:47.975
IMPERIAL AND 100 AND 80,000
05:13:48.042 --> 05:13:50.478
MEMBERS STATEWIDE. UFCW IS PROUD
05:13:50.545 --> 05:13:52.180
TO SUPPORT AND THANKS, MAJORITY
05:13:52.246 --> 05:13:53.981
LEADER REYES FOR AUTHORING A B
05:13:54.048 --> 05:13:56.350
28 40 LOCAL HAS WATCHED
05:13:56.417 --> 05:13:57.451
FIRSTHAND THE RAPIDITY OF
05:13:57.518 --> 05:14:00.421
INDUSTRIAL WAREHOUSING. FILLIED
05:14:00.488 --> 05:14:01.956
OVER INTO AREAS WHERE OUR LIVE
05:14:02.023 --> 05:14:03.124
WHERE THEIR CHILDREN TO SCHOOL
05:14:03.191 --> 05:14:05.493
WHERE THEY GO TO WORSHIP. HAS
05:14:05.560 --> 05:14:07.695
BEEN IT HAS HAD A SUBSTANTIAL
05:14:07.762 --> 05:14:09.430
IMPACT ON OUR MEMBERS. IF YOU
05:14:09.497 --> 05:14:10.698
SPEND JUST ONE DAY IN THE INLAND
05:14:10.765 --> 05:14:12.500
EMPIRE, YOU WILL NOTICE THE
05:14:12.567 --> 05:14:14.101
LARGE AND NUMEROUS BORDERING
05:14:14.168 --> 05:14:15.870
RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD AND AS
05:14:15.937 --> 05:14:17.305
YOU DRIVE THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY
05:14:17.371 --> 05:14:18.506
, YOU WILL EXPERIENCE TRAFFIC
05:14:18.573 --> 05:14:20.007
CONGESTION AND EXHAUST FROM
05:14:20.074 --> 05:14:21.509
TRUCKS DRIVING PAST SCHOOLS AND
05:14:21.576 --> 05:14:22.677
CHURCHES, LEAVING LAYERS OF SMOG
05:14:22.743 --> 05:14:25.846
AND POLLUTION BEHIND. FOUR
05:14:25.913 --> 05:14:27.215
MEMBERS. THESE UNFORTUNATE
05:14:27.281 --> 05:14:29.250
CONDITIONS HAVE BECOME THE NORM
05:14:29.317 --> 05:14:30.751
AND THESE CONDITIONS WOULD NOT
05:14:30.818 --> 05:14:32.620
BE ACCEPTED AS NORMAL IN ANY
05:14:32.687 --> 05:14:33.888
AFFLUENT AREAS OF THE STATE.
05:14:33.955 --> 05:14:35.623
RAPID WAREHOUSING EXPANSION HAS
05:14:35.690 --> 05:14:37.625
HAD NEGATIVE ENVIRONMENTAL AND
05:14:37.692 --> 05:14:39.193
HEALTH IMPACT ON OUR MEMBERS AND
05:14:39.260 --> 05:14:40.595
THEIR FAMILIES. HOW STUDIES HAVE
05:14:40.661 --> 05:14:42.363
SHOWN THAT THE EXPOSURE TO
05:14:42.430 --> 05:14:43.631
DIESEL EXHAUST FROM TRUCKS
05:14:43.698 --> 05:14:44.665
MOVING GOODS CAN AFFECT THE
05:14:44.732 --> 05:14:46.133
RESPIRATORY SYSTEM. SUCH AS
05:14:46.200 --> 05:14:48.002
WORSEN ASTHMA, ALLERGIES,
05:14:48.069 --> 05:14:49.403
BRONCHITIS AND LUNG FUNCTION.
05:14:49.470 --> 05:14:51.138
OUR MEMBERS HAVE SHARED PERSONAL
05:14:51.205 --> 05:14:52.406
STORIES ABOUT THEIR CHILDREN
05:14:52.473 --> 05:14:54.108
HAVING ASTHMA WITH NO KNOWN
05:14:54.175 --> 05:14:56.210
FAMILY HISTORY OF THE CONDITION
05:14:56.277 --> 05:14:57.645
, THEIR CHILDREN HAVING THEIR
05:14:57.712 --> 05:14:59.213
PHYSICAL EDUCATION CLASSES
05:14:59.280 --> 05:15:00.581
ACROSS THE STREET FROM NEWLY
05:15:00.648 --> 05:15:02.149
BUILT WAREHOUSES AND WAREHOUSES
05:15:02.216 --> 05:15:04.619
BEING BUILT NEAR THEIR HOMES.
05:15:04.685 --> 05:15:06.153
OUR MEMBERS AND THEIR FAMILIES
05:15:06.220 --> 05:15:07.688
SHOULD NOT HAVE TO EXPERIENCE
05:15:07.755 --> 05:15:09.557
THE PHYSICAL AND MONETARY HEALTH
05:15:09.624 --> 05:15:11.192
CONSEQUENCES JUST MERELY
05:15:11.259 --> 05:15:13.461
EXISTING IN THEIR COMMUNITIES,
05:15:13.527 --> 05:15:14.929
AND ITS CURRENT WAREHOUSE
05:15:14.996 --> 05:15:16.063
EXPANSION CONTINUES, OUR MEMBERS
05:15:16.130 --> 05:15:17.932
WILL HAVE TO LIVE IN HAZARDOUS
05:15:17.999 --> 05:15:19.100
CONDITIONS OR BE FORCED TO MOVE.
05:15:19.166 --> 05:15:21.736
FURTHER AWAY FROM THEIR JOB,
05:15:21.802 --> 05:15:22.837
WHICH WOULD BE DEVASTATING TO
05:15:22.903 --> 05:15:23.904
WORKERS WHO ARE ALREADY
05:15:23.971 --> 05:15:24.972
STRUGGLING TO MAKE ENDS MEET.
05:15:25.039 --> 05:15:27.375
UFCW STRONGLY BELIEVED THAT 80
05:15:27.441 --> 05:15:29.243
28 40 OFFERS A PRACTICAL
05:15:29.310 --> 05:15:30.344
SOLUTION TO PROTECT THE
05:15:30.411 --> 05:15:32.780
RESIDENTS ARE MEMBERS IN
05:15:32.847 --> 05:15:33.914
RIVERSIDE AND SAN BERNARDINO
05:15:33.981 --> 05:15:35.283
COUNTIES, WHILE ALSO SUPPORTING
05:15:35.349 --> 05:15:36.517
THE LOGISTICS CENTER SECTOR AND
05:15:36.584 --> 05:15:39.553
OUR STATES SUPPLY CHAIN.
05:15:39.620 --> 05:15:41.088
WAREHOUSE DEVELOPMENT AND
05:15:41.155 --> 05:15:43.357
EXPANSION SHOULD NOT COME AT THE
05:15:43.424 --> 05:15:44.925
EXPENSE OF REMEMBERS, AND THEIR
05:15:44.992 --> 05:15:45.493
AND THEIR FAMILY'S HELP AND
05:15:45.559 --> 05:15:47.862
ABILITY TO LIVE IN THEIR
05:15:47.928 --> 05:15:48.996
COMMUNITIES. IT'S FOR THESE
05:15:49.063 --> 05:15:49.730
REASONS AND MORE THAT WE
05:15:49.797 --> 05:15:51.699
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I VOTE
05:15:51.766 --> 05:15:53.901
TODAY ON A B 28 40 THANK YOU FOR
05:15:53.968 --> 05:15:55.770
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK ON THIS
05:15:55.836 --> 05:15:58.339
IMPORTANT MATTER. THANK YOU VERY
05:15:58.406 --> 05:16:00.207
MUCH FOR YOUR TESTIMONY GOING TO
05:16:00.274 --> 05:16:01.976
SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE ELSE IN IN
05:16:02.043 --> 05:16:03.177
ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
05:16:03.244 --> 05:16:07.882
SPEAK TODAY. SAYING YES, PLEASE.
05:16:07.948 --> 05:16:12.453
I'M SORRY. NO WORRIES. WE'RE ON
05:16:12.520 --> 05:16:15.156
SUPPORT. I'M SORRY. YES. IF
05:16:15.222 --> 05:16:17.091
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT,
05:16:17.158 --> 05:16:18.292
LIKE TO INVITE YOU TO COME TO
05:16:18.359 --> 05:16:20.594
THE MIC. DO I HAVE A TIMELY
05:16:20.661 --> 05:16:22.463
MARRIAGES? ACTUALLY RIGHT NOW,
05:16:22.530 --> 05:16:24.165
WHAT WE'RE DOING IS JUST HAVING
05:16:24.231 --> 05:16:26.567
YOU IDENTIFY WHO YOU ARE AND WHO
05:16:26.634 --> 05:16:28.235
YOU REPRESENT. AND THAT YOU'RE
05:16:28.302 --> 05:16:30.438
IN SUPPORT. OKAY. THANK YOU. UM,
05:16:30.504 --> 05:16:31.005
WELL, GOOD. GOOD AFTERNOON,
05:16:31.072 --> 05:16:31.872
EVERYONE. MY NAME'S SANTA
05:16:31.939 --> 05:16:34.875
GONZALES. I AM A REALTOR
05:16:34.942 --> 05:16:37.745
RESIDENT AND A MOM OF SUN HAD
05:16:37.812 --> 05:16:40.281
HAS DEVELOPED ASPE DUE TO THE
05:16:40.348 --> 05:16:41.615
INFLUX OF WAREHOUSING. I ALSO
05:16:41.682 --> 05:16:43.217
REPRESENT THE CENTER FOR
05:16:43.284 --> 05:16:43.984
COMMUNITY ACTION AND
05:16:44.051 --> 05:16:45.886
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE AND
05:16:45.953 --> 05:16:47.221
MILLIONS OF COMMUNITY MEMBERS
05:16:47.288 --> 05:16:48.122
BEING AFFECTED BY THIS AND I
05:16:48.189 --> 05:16:49.990
STRUGGLE TO SUPPORT THE LITTLE
05:16:50.057 --> 05:16:51.325
THINGS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
05:16:51.392 --> 05:16:52.226
THESE ARE ANYONE'S YES. PLEASE
05:16:52.293 --> 05:16:55.896
GO BORING. HELLO MY NAME IS
05:16:55.963 --> 05:16:57.832
MARLENE GERSH. YEAH, I AM A
05:16:57.898 --> 05:16:59.300
CURRENT GRADUATE FROM THE
05:16:59.367 --> 05:17:01.769
DIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA DAVIS
05:17:01.836 --> 05:17:02.837
FROM COLLEGE OF ENVIRONMENTAL
05:17:02.903 --> 05:17:05.406
SCIENCES AND AGRICULTURE. I
05:17:05.473 --> 05:17:07.375
PRESIDENT OF FONTANA. DIFFERENT
05:17:07.441 --> 05:17:08.843
TEAMS, AND I STRONGLY THERE THE
05:17:08.909 --> 05:17:11.479
COUNTLESS RESEARCH THAT I'VE
05:17:11.545 --> 05:17:14.048
IMPACTS OF WAREHOUSES I STRUCK.
05:17:14.115 --> 05:17:15.049
CONGRATULATIONS THANK YOU SO
05:17:15.116 --> 05:17:21.689
MUCH ENOUGH. SEEN NOTHING.
05:17:21.756 --> 05:17:23.524
THEY'RE TESTED HERE IN THE, UM
05:17:23.591 --> 05:17:26.227
I'D LIKE TO OPEN THE LINE WHEN
05:17:26.293 --> 05:17:31.699
THE LINE WANTS TO FIND SUPPORT.
05:17:31.766 --> 05:17:36.337
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL THEM
05:17:36.404 --> 05:17:40.941
AGAIN. AND SUPPORT HIS FIRST TWO
05:17:41.008 --> 05:17:57.091
LINE.
05:17:58.192 --> 05:18:17.144
BUT.
05:22:52.886 --> 05:23:13.107
WITH SMILES. THREE YEAR OLD DÍAS. 23-14. THE NEXT SEVEN. FULLER.
05:23:13.173 --> 05:23:19.980
UH HUH. AYE. WHAT NATIONAL
05:23:20.047 --> 05:23:22.983
CABINET NIGHT SO I ASKED FOR AND
05:23:23.050 --> 05:23:35.062
I VOTE NO. YEAH. MUCH. OF LYING.
05:23:35.129 --> 05:23:43.270
HOLD OUT. MHM. PLEASE. THAT IS
05:23:43.337 --> 05:23:59.453
ALL.
05:24:08.495 --> 05:24:25.245
I OWE YOU. THE ROLE OF AND.
05:24:25.312 --> 05:24:49.970
QUIET. ABOUT MY.
05:26:32.940 --> 05:27:03.170
TOMORROW. RIGHT? RIGHT? LIKE.
05:27:03.236 --> 05:27:08.842
AMANDA. I LEFT MESSAGES. AND I
05:27:08.909 --> 05:27:17.751
THANK YOU. AND THE FLYING. IN
05:27:17.818 --> 05:27:23.890
19. HI. MY NAME IS SHANNON AND
05:27:23.957 --> 05:27:25.826
GIVEN THE CITY OF LEWINGTON AND
05:27:25.892 --> 05:27:28.395
I'M CALLING A FAVOR, MAYBE 28
05:27:28.462 --> 05:27:36.870
40. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND
05:27:36.937 --> 05:27:38.071
THIS TIME THERE ARE NO FURTHER
05:27:38.138 --> 05:27:40.907
LINES IN QUÊ. VERY GOOD. THAT
05:27:40.974 --> 05:27:44.478
CONCLUDES OUR SUPPORT TESTIMONY
05:27:44.544 --> 05:27:46.213
. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
05:27:46.279 --> 05:27:48.415
OPPOSITION. UM WANT TO INVITE
05:27:48.482 --> 05:27:50.250
THE THERE ARE TWO, UM, LEAD
05:27:50.317 --> 05:27:54.354
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. JAMES
05:27:54.421 --> 05:27:55.355
WALKER AND COUNCIL MEMBER DEBRA
05:27:55.422 --> 05:28:01.695
DORST THAT UM AND WE WITHIN
05:28:01.762 --> 05:28:02.796
PERSON, SO PLEASE, LIKE LIKE,
05:28:02.863 --> 05:28:12.239
COME FORWARD. PLEASE. WELCOME.
05:28:12.305 --> 05:28:13.874
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS
05:28:13.940 --> 05:28:14.841
JAMES THURWACHTER TO THE
05:28:14.908 --> 05:28:16.109
CALIFORNIA STATE COUNCIL OF
05:28:16.176 --> 05:28:18.545
LABORERS. PLEASURE TO BE HERE.
05:28:18.612 --> 05:28:19.980
ONE AT FIRST EXTEND OUR DEEPEST
05:28:20.047 --> 05:28:21.014
GRATITUDE TOO MUCH TO THE
05:28:21.081 --> 05:28:22.849
MAJORITY LEADER AND HER TEAM.
05:28:22.916 --> 05:28:24.551
WE'VE HAD VERY POSITIVE AND
05:28:24.618 --> 05:28:25.152
PRODUCTIVE CONVERSATIONS
05:28:25.218 --> 05:28:26.987
THROUGHOUT THIS PROCESS, AND WE
05:28:27.054 --> 05:28:28.221
LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE.
05:28:28.288 --> 05:28:29.089
CONTINUE THAT PATH IN THE
05:28:29.156 --> 05:28:32.626
FUTURE. THANK YOU. REMEMBER IS
05:28:32.692 --> 05:28:34.294
OUR ORGANIZATION IS COMPRISED OF
05:28:34.361 --> 05:28:36.329
CLOSE TO 70,000 MEN AND WOMEN
05:28:36.396 --> 05:28:38.365
STATEWIDE WHO WORK IN THE HEAVY
05:28:38.432 --> 05:28:38.999
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY. WE BUILD
05:28:39.066 --> 05:28:42.602
CALIFORNIA'S INFRASTRUCTURE. WE
05:28:42.669 --> 05:28:44.004
ENSURE THAT OUR ROADS AND
05:28:44.071 --> 05:28:45.839
HIGHWAYS ARE SAFE FOR US TO
05:28:45.906 --> 05:28:48.141
DRIVE ON. AND YES, WE ASSEMBLE
05:28:48.208 --> 05:28:49.009
CRITICAL FACILITIES SUCH AS
05:28:49.076 --> 05:28:49.943
LOGISTICS CENTERS AND
05:28:50.010 --> 05:28:54.614
WAREHOUSES. 80% OF OUR OF OUR
05:28:54.681 --> 05:28:56.450
MEMBERS ARE PEOPLE OF COLOR.
05:28:56.516 --> 05:28:57.484
MANY HAVE COME DIRECTLY FROM THE
05:28:57.551 --> 05:28:58.618
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM. WE'RE
05:28:58.685 --> 05:29:03.924
PROUD TO PROVIDE. PRISON PROJECT
05:29:03.990 --> 05:29:06.393
PATHWAYS AS WE LIKE TO SAY, AND
05:29:06.460 --> 05:29:07.060
REAL OPPORTUNITIES FOR OUR
05:29:07.127 --> 05:29:08.228
MEMBERS TO WORK IN THE VERY
05:29:08.295 --> 05:29:10.697
COMMUNITIES IN WHICH THEY LIVE.
05:29:10.764 --> 05:29:11.898
THIS BILL AS AMENDED THREATENS
05:29:11.965 --> 05:29:16.169
THE LIVELIHOODS. OF THESE
05:29:16.236 --> 05:29:19.940
MEMBERS. WE UNDERSTAND AND WE'RE
05:29:20.006 --> 05:29:20.774
THANKFUL FOR THE RECENT
05:29:20.841 --> 05:29:22.642
AMENDMENTS TO NARROW THE SCOPE
05:29:22.709 --> 05:29:23.910
TO ONLY RIVERSIDE AND SAN
05:29:23.977 --> 05:29:25.745
BERNARDINO COUNTIES. HOWEVER THE
05:29:25.812 --> 05:29:28.415
FACT IS, IS THAT THERE IS STILL
05:29:28.482 --> 05:29:29.316
A SUBSCRIPTION CRISIS WITHIN OUR
05:29:29.382 --> 05:29:31.685
STATE. IN THE I IV. INLAND
05:29:31.751 --> 05:29:32.652
EMPIRE HAS CRITICAL STRATEGIC
05:29:32.719 --> 05:29:36.323
REGION. FOR LOGISTICS CENTERS TO
05:29:36.389 --> 05:29:37.257
STORE AND MOVE GOODS THROUGH THE
05:29:37.324 --> 05:29:41.128
PORTS OF L, A AND LONG BEACH.
05:29:41.194 --> 05:29:42.863
BUT ALSO INCLUDING A BROAD
05:29:42.929 --> 05:29:44.631
CATEGORY OF LOCATIONS UNDER THE
05:29:44.698 --> 05:29:46.833
TERMS SENSITIVE RECEPTORS, OFTEN
05:29:46.900 --> 05:29:49.236
ASKING OURSELVES WHERE IN
05:29:49.302 --> 05:29:50.537
REALITY CAN WE BUILD OR AND
05:29:50.604 --> 05:29:54.608
THESE CRITICAL CENTERS? MAYBE 28
05:29:54.674 --> 05:29:55.842
46 TO MITIGATE AIR QUALITY
05:29:55.909 --> 05:29:57.878
ISSUES. ASSOCIATED WITH THE
05:29:57.944 --> 05:29:59.613
TRUCKS TRAVELING TO AND FROM THE
05:29:59.679 --> 05:30:03.283
CENTERS. BUT THE WAY THAT THE
05:30:03.350 --> 05:30:04.618
BILL IS DRAFTED, IT PRESUMES
05:30:04.684 --> 05:30:06.219
THAT STATE ENTITIES LIKE CARB
05:30:06.286 --> 05:30:08.388
AND THE OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY
05:30:08.455 --> 05:30:09.022
GENERAL AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
05:30:09.089 --> 05:30:14.227
MHM. SORRY HERE. MY ECHO. LOCAL
05:30:14.294 --> 05:30:15.629
GOVERNMENTS AND LOCAL AIR
05:30:15.695 --> 05:30:17.464
QUALITY BOARDS ARE NOT DOING
05:30:17.531 --> 05:30:19.366
THEIR JOB AND WE THINK THAT THEY
05:30:19.432 --> 05:30:21.701
ARE A DIRECT CONSEQUENCE OF THIS
05:30:21.768 --> 05:30:22.736
BILL. WHETHER INTENDED OR NOT,
05:30:22.802 --> 05:30:24.871
IS THAT CENTERS WILL MOVE
05:30:24.938 --> 05:30:28.208
FURTHER AWAY FROM PORTS. AND
05:30:28.275 --> 05:30:29.409
WITH THAT THEY'LL BE TAKING THE
05:30:29.476 --> 05:30:31.144
JOBS AND ECONOMIC ACTIVITY WITH
05:30:31.211 --> 05:30:33.680
THEM. THE INCONVENIENT TRUTH IS
05:30:33.747 --> 05:30:34.981
THAT THIS WILL INCREASE BMT
05:30:35.048 --> 05:30:36.583
SIGNIFICANTLY AS BOTH WORKERS
05:30:36.650 --> 05:30:38.385
AND COMMERCIAL TRUCKS WILL BE
05:30:38.451 --> 05:30:39.619
TRAVELING LONGER DISTANCES TO
05:30:39.686 --> 05:30:42.255
REACH THEIR DESTINATIONS. AND
05:30:42.322 --> 05:30:43.657
CLOSING. I JUST WANT TO LEAVE
05:30:43.723 --> 05:30:46.126
YOU ALL WITH, UH, SOME DATA FROM
05:30:46.193 --> 05:30:47.160
THE BUREAU OF LABOR. IN 2012
05:30:47.227 --> 05:30:50.430
JUST 10 YEARS AGO. THE
05:30:50.497 --> 05:30:52.265
UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IN THE III WAS
05:30:52.332 --> 05:30:55.101
AROUND 12% JUST UNDER 12. THAT
05:30:55.168 --> 05:30:56.970
WAS THE HIGHESTIN THE NATION
05:30:57.037 --> 05:30:57.938
FOR COUNTIES WITH POPULATIONS
05:30:58.004 --> 05:31:01.541
OVER A MILLION. TODAY THAT
05:31:01.608 --> 05:31:02.809
NUMBER IS JUST UNDER FOUR. NOW.
05:31:02.876 --> 05:31:04.644
I'M NOT GOING TO GO ON RECORD
05:31:04.711 --> 05:31:06.713
SAYING THAT THAT CHANGES SLOWLY
05:31:06.780 --> 05:31:07.714
DUE TO THE E COMMERCE AND
05:31:07.781 --> 05:31:08.548
LOGISTICS INDUSTRY. HOWEVER, WE
05:31:08.615 --> 05:31:12.519
WOULD BE REMISS AH, TONIGHT
05:31:12.586 --> 05:31:14.387
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THEY THAT
05:31:14.454 --> 05:31:16.423
INDUSTRY HAS BEEN INSTRUMENTAL
05:31:16.489 --> 05:31:16.990
IN LIFTING FAMILIES IN THE
05:31:17.057 --> 05:31:19.059
APARTMENT. FOR ITS FINE, THANK
05:31:19.125 --> 05:31:26.066
YOU VERY MUCH. WELCOME GOOD.
05:31:26.132 --> 05:31:27.367
YEAH, GOOD. ACTUALLY CHAIRMAN
05:31:27.434 --> 05:31:30.870
CALDERON MEMBERS OF SOMETHING
05:31:30.937 --> 05:31:31.972
FOR THE ZOOM CALL THE TRULY
05:31:32.038 --> 05:31:35.175
APPRECIATED THE INFORMATION. MY
05:31:35.242 --> 05:31:37.477
NAME IS DEBBIE ENDORSE PERATA.
05:31:37.544 --> 05:31:39.346
14 YEARS REMEMBER IN THE CITY OF
05:31:39.412 --> 05:31:41.114
ONTARIO. I'VE BEEN A REGISTERED
05:31:41.181 --> 05:31:43.183
NURSE YEARS, THE LAST 15 OF
05:31:43.250 --> 05:31:45.151
THOSE YEARS SERVING AS A PUBLIC
05:31:45.218 --> 05:31:46.486
HEALTH NURSE OF THE L. A COUNTY.
05:31:46.553 --> 05:31:48.488
THE APARTMENT. THANK YOU. I'M
05:31:48.555 --> 05:31:50.390
REPRESENTING THE CITY OF SAN
05:31:50.457 --> 05:31:52.058
BERNARDINO, RIVERSIDE COUNTY TO
05:31:52.125 --> 05:31:53.693
IVE YOU A ROOF OVER TWO OF
05:31:53.760 --> 05:31:55.495
WHAT'S COUNTY SAID COME OVER THE
05:31:55.562 --> 05:31:58.331
LAST 100 YEARS AND THE 1920 17
05:31:58.398 --> 05:32:01.268
60. WE WERE BASIC CONTROL
05:32:01.334 --> 05:32:03.003
COMMUNITY WHERE WE GREW ORANGES
05:32:03.069 --> 05:32:06.640
, GRAPES AND HAD DAIRY FROM
05:32:06.706 --> 05:32:09.042
WORLD WAR TWO, THE 19 SEVENTIES
05:32:09.109 --> 05:32:10.010
WAS LIKE WE'RE STILL JUST
05:32:10.076 --> 05:32:11.745
ELECTRIC GENERAL. AND I'M JUST
05:32:11.811 --> 05:32:14.481
LIKE CAME TO THE TOWNS AND WE
05:32:14.547 --> 05:32:16.416
NEEDED. HOW DOES THE THOUSANDS
05:32:16.483 --> 05:32:18.318
OF HOMES BUILT TO FACILITATE A
05:32:18.385 --> 05:32:22.022
PLACE FOR PEOPLE TO LOVE? NOW
05:32:22.088 --> 05:32:24.824
THAT WE NEEDED TO FIND OUR NEXT
05:32:24.891 --> 05:32:27.227
AND THE NEXT IS LOGISTICS.
05:32:27.294 --> 05:32:29.462
LOGISTICS IS, UM WHAT WE NEED TO
05:32:29.529 --> 05:32:34.434
KEEP PEOPLE WORKING. UM. WHAT WE
05:32:34.501 --> 05:32:36.670
HAVE FOUND IN THE STATE OF
05:32:36.736 --> 05:32:38.672
CALIFORNIA HAS NO PROVIDED US
05:32:38.738 --> 05:32:40.473
WITH A WONDERFUL FRAMEWORK
05:32:40.540 --> 05:32:44.377
SYSTEM HAVE THE 15TH 10. WE ALSO
05:32:44.444 --> 05:32:47.113
HAVE TWO WONDERFUL AIRPORTS. UM
05:32:47.180 --> 05:32:48.815
SAMBERG, YOU KNOW, AND ONTARIO
05:32:48.882 --> 05:32:50.116
ALONG WITH TWO RED ROSE. I CARRY
05:32:50.183 --> 05:32:53.753
CARGO IN AND OUT. WHAT TO DO,
05:32:53.820 --> 05:32:55.822
BUT ONLY MAKES SENSE THAT LIES
05:32:55.889 --> 05:32:58.325
ON THESE WONDERFUL ASSETS, EVEN
05:32:58.391 --> 05:33:00.827
WITH HOUSES NOW MOVING
05:33:00.894 --> 05:33:02.429
UNDERSTANDING BECOME A LITTLE
05:33:02.495 --> 05:33:14.074
GOOD. PRINCE. JUST SIX TAX
05:33:14.140 --> 05:33:16.476
TRUCKS HELPING PLEASE FIRE
05:33:16.543 --> 05:33:25.752
STREET TRUE. THE EARTH. ONE I
05:33:25.819 --> 05:33:27.520
LOVED IT. I LOVED ALL MY LIFE.
05:33:27.587 --> 05:33:29.656
AND WHEN I WAS LITTLE AND GO
05:33:29.723 --> 05:33:31.424
BACK IN THE 19 SIXTIES AND
05:33:31.491 --> 05:33:37.263
SEVENTIES LOOKS LIKE MOUNTAINS
05:33:37.330 --> 05:33:38.198
FROM ELEMENTARY SCHOOL COULDN'T
05:33:38.264 --> 05:33:48.308
BE I MEAN. TO IS THEN. TOTALLY
05:33:48.375 --> 05:34:03.390
THAT, UM. FUNNY POINT. KEEP
05:34:03.456 --> 05:34:11.731
LATER. LET US SCHOOL. JUST
05:34:11.798 --> 05:34:21.074
REALLY REQUIRED. JUST SO OKAY?
05:34:21.141 --> 05:34:37.524
COACHES. TO ACCESS THE 31ST. FOR
05:34:37.590 --> 05:34:53.673
HELP.
05:37:27.760 --> 05:37:43.910
POSITION.
05:37:47.180 --> 05:37:58.591
OPEN.
05:37:58.658 --> 05:38:18.978
LINE. BUT OKAY OH, EXCUSE ME.
05:38:19.045 --> 05:38:26.452
AH, MOVING ON. WE HAVE 6 71.
05:38:26.519 --> 05:38:33.626
ASSEMBLED. COLOR AND RED.
05:38:33.693 --> 05:38:42.568
BUSINESS OWNER. THANK YOU. AND
05:38:42.635 --> 05:38:43.836
NEXT WE HAVE LINES 6 73, PLEASE
05:38:43.903 --> 05:38:46.572
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
05:38:46.639 --> 05:38:51.878
NAME IS QUISENBERRY. I'M CALLING
05:38:51.944 --> 05:38:52.679
FROM THE LABOR SPECIFIC
05:38:52.745 --> 05:38:53.713
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL ORGANIZING
05:38:53.780 --> 05:38:56.182
COALITION. AND I'LL BE HALF OF
05:38:56.249 --> 05:38:58.451
OUR ENTIRE STAFF. WE
05:38:58.518 --> 05:39:01.354
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED A B 28 40.
05:39:01.421 --> 05:39:06.225
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
05:39:06.292 --> 05:39:08.628
AND NEXT WE HAVE LINES 6 43,
05:39:08.695 --> 05:39:12.165
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH THIS IS
05:39:12.231 --> 05:39:12.565
CHRISTIAN COCKBURN
05:39:12.632 --> 05:39:14.634
REPRESENTATIVE REALITY WE
05:39:14.701 --> 05:39:22.041
OPPOSED A B 28 40. AND NEXT WE
05:39:22.108 --> 05:39:25.478
HAVE LINED 6 65, PLEASE GO
05:39:25.545 --> 05:39:30.249
AHEAD. CHAIR AND MEMBERS, LUIS
05:39:30.316 --> 05:39:31.918
SANCHEZ WITH MILLER SAID THIS
05:39:31.984 --> 05:39:33.653
AND ASSOCIATES ON BEHALF OF THE
05:39:33.720 --> 05:39:34.854
CALIFORNIA FAMILY BEER
05:39:34.921 --> 05:39:35.888
DISTRIBUTORS IN OPPOSITION.
05:39:35.955 --> 05:39:43.463
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
05:39:43.529 --> 05:39:44.764
NEXT. WE HAVE LINES 5 80, PLEASE
05:39:44.831 --> 05:39:49.302
GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS APOLLO.
05:39:49.368 --> 05:39:51.904
LOCAL 3 45 LABOR. AND I
05:39:51.971 --> 05:39:53.740
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED TO MAYBE 28
05:39:53.806 --> 05:40:03.116
40. NEXT WE PUT A LINE OF 1 40,
05:40:03.182 --> 05:40:11.023
PLEASE GO AHEAD. FIND 140. YOUR
05:40:11.090 --> 05:40:22.802
LINE IS OPEN. MOVING ON. WE HAVE
05:40:22.869 --> 05:40:29.876
LINES. 6 89. HI GOOD MORNING.
05:40:29.942 --> 05:40:32.078
THIS IS ED LEARNED BUSINESS
05:40:32.145 --> 05:40:34.947
MANAGER FROM LABOUR'S LOCAL 3 45
05:40:35.014 --> 05:40:36.249
ON BEHALF OF OUR 500 MEMBERS. WE
05:40:36.315 --> 05:40:38.885
RESPECT ACTUALLY OPPOSED A B
05:40:38.951 --> 05:40:50.096
284. NEXT. WE HAVE LINES. 6 94,
05:40:50.163 --> 05:40:55.268
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
05:40:55.334 --> 05:40:56.969
. MY NAME IS SEARCH FOR MERITS
05:40:57.036 --> 05:40:58.137
AND PROBLEMS LIKE IN THE LOCAL
05:40:58.204 --> 05:41:01.707
TO 20. APRIL 2000 MEMBERS FROM
05:41:01.774 --> 05:41:03.476
SANTA BARBARA OPPOSED TO THIS
05:41:03.543 --> 05:41:04.010
ONE CURRENT TALLY THAT WE
05:41:04.076 --> 05:41:06.145
STRONGLY OPPOSED A B 28 40.
05:41:06.212 --> 05:41:12.618
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT WE
05:41:12.685 --> 05:41:13.553
HAVE LINES 6 58, PLEASE GO
05:41:13.619 --> 05:41:17.323
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS
05:41:17.390 --> 05:41:19.258
RYAN ELAINE, WITH THE CALIFORNIA
05:41:19.325 --> 05:41:19.792
RETAILERS ASSOCIATION AND
05:41:19.859 --> 05:41:27.667
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. NEXT WE
05:41:27.733 --> 05:41:28.835
HAVE LINES 6 18, PLEASE GO
05:41:28.901 --> 05:41:33.739
AHEAD. TÌM NAME IS MARIO SALINAS
05:41:33.806 --> 05:41:34.941
AND WITH THE NEIGHBORS, LOCAL 3
05:41:35.007 --> 05:41:37.577
20. ON BEHALF OF MYSELF AND OUR
05:41:37.643 --> 05:41:41.180
2000 MEMBERS. WE OPPOSE A B 2840
05:41:41.247 --> 05:41:42.348
. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
05:41:42.415 --> 05:41:48.521
MUCH. AND NEXT WE GO TO LINE 6
05:41:48.588 --> 05:41:52.925
24, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
05:41:52.992 --> 05:41:54.694
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS ERNESTO
05:41:54.760 --> 05:41:56.863
KANSEN BEHALF OF LEVERS. LOCAL
05:41:56.929 --> 05:42:00.132
300 ARE OVER 8000 MEMBERS IN THE
05:42:00.199 --> 05:42:01.934
COUNTYOF LOS ANGELES, AND WE
05:42:02.001 --> 05:42:10.376
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED E B 28 40.
05:42:10.443 --> 05:42:11.711
NEXT WE GO TO LINE 6 75, PLEASE
05:42:11.777 --> 05:42:16.015
GO AHEAD. HI GOOD AFTERNOON.
05:42:16.082 --> 05:42:16.983
ATTORNEY HUGHES AT THE
05:42:17.049 --> 05:42:18.050
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE PRODUCERS
05:42:18.117 --> 05:42:19.752
REPRESENTING FOOD PROCESSING
05:42:19.819 --> 05:42:20.786
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
05:42:20.853 --> 05:42:21.754
AND RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
05:42:21.821 --> 05:42:28.027
YOU. AND THEY GOT A LINE. 43,
05:42:28.094 --> 05:42:32.231
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
05:42:32.298 --> 05:42:34.200
, JAMES HAMMOND, LABOUR'S LOCAL
05:42:34.267 --> 05:42:37.637
TO 94, PRESENTING 1900 MEMBERS.
05:42:37.703 --> 05:42:39.405
WE RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED A B 28
05:42:39.472 --> 05:42:47.480
40. THANK YOU. THE NEXT LITTLE
05:42:47.546 --> 05:42:51.784
LINES 65 AHEAD. MET HIM
05:42:51.851 --> 05:42:54.053
CHEERFULLY ON BEHALF OF THE
05:42:54.120 --> 05:42:54.954
ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS
05:42:55.021 --> 05:43:04.697
CALIFORNIA IN OPPOSITION. NEXT.
05:43:04.764 --> 05:43:05.831
WE'RE GOING TO LINE 6 40,
05:43:05.898 --> 05:43:11.203
PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON MANAGER
05:43:11.270 --> 05:43:12.405
REMEMBERS 20 FARM BUREAU IN
05:43:12.471 --> 05:43:23.950
OPPOSITION. AND LEFT. 6 79.
05:43:24.016 --> 05:43:25.117
THANK YOU. THIS IS GAIL
05:43:25.184 --> 05:43:27.119
DELAHANTY WITH WESTERN GROWERS
05:43:27.186 --> 05:43:29.021
ASSOCIATION AND WE ARE IN
05:43:29.088 --> 05:43:35.995
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE
05:43:36.062 --> 05:43:40.466
HAVE 49. PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH
05:43:40.533 --> 05:43:42.969
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS I'M
05:43:43.035 --> 05:43:45.104
CALLING FOR, YOU KNOW, LABORS
05:43:45.171 --> 05:43:48.040
LOCAL 5 35 923 MINUTES, WE WOULD
05:43:48.107 --> 05:43:58.417
BE A FOLK. 28 40 THINGS. NEXT
05:43:58.484 --> 05:44:04.023
YEAR. 7 13 WAS GOOD AFTERNOON
05:44:04.090 --> 05:44:04.757
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
05:44:04.824 --> 05:44:05.725
JONATHAN CHARLO, RIVERSIDE
05:44:05.791 --> 05:44:07.193
COUNTY RESIDENT. I'M CALLING IN
05:44:07.259 --> 05:44:09.261
STRONG OPPOSITION TO A B 2040.
05:44:09.328 --> 05:44:17.003
THANK YOU. GO TO LINE 6 91 GO
05:44:17.069 --> 05:44:22.441
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF
05:44:22.508 --> 05:44:24.143
MEDINA WITH THE ORANGE COUNTY
05:44:24.210 --> 05:44:24.877
BUSINESS LOOKS LIKE TO THE BILL
05:44:24.944 --> 05:44:33.119
. IT IS. NEXT WE HAVE 6 61,
05:44:33.185 --> 05:44:37.256
PLEASE GO AHEAD. AFTERNOON
05:44:37.323 --> 05:44:38.891
TURNED MEMBER. THIS IS CHRIS
05:44:38.958 --> 05:44:40.726
WILSON COUNTY BUSINESS
05:44:40.793 --> 05:44:42.495
FEDERATION. WE ARE STRONGLY
05:44:42.561 --> 05:44:49.602
OPPOSED TO A B 28 40. THANK YOU.
05:44:49.668 --> 05:44:50.870
NEXT WE HAVE LINES 6 82, PLEASE
05:44:50.936 --> 05:44:55.674
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
05:44:55.741 --> 05:44:56.742
MEMBERS DEREK TURNAROUND BEHALF
05:44:56.809 --> 05:44:57.943
OF THE TOWN OF APPLE VALLEY,
05:44:58.010 --> 05:45:04.850
RESPECTIVELY OPPOSED. THANK YOU.
05:45:04.917 --> 05:45:06.852
NEXT WE GO TO LINE 7 26, PLEASE
05:45:06.919 --> 05:45:11.290
GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
05:45:11.357 --> 05:45:13.125
MEMBERS, TODD STEIN FOR THE
05:45:13.192 --> 05:45:14.326
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA CONTRACTORS
05:45:14.393 --> 05:45:16.896
ASSOCIATION OPPOSED TO MAYBE 28
05:45:16.962 --> 05:45:21.000
40. THANK YOU. MR MURDOCH.
05:45:21.067 --> 05:45:23.035
MODERATOR CAN YOU TELL US HOW
05:45:23.102 --> 05:45:24.170
MANY MORE PEOPLE ARE ON THE
05:45:24.236 --> 05:45:29.542
LINE? AH IN QUÊ. CURRENTLY WE
05:45:29.608 --> 05:45:33.846
HAVE 29 MORE LINES. UM LET'S SEE
05:45:33.913 --> 05:45:36.082
IF WE CAN SPEED IT UP A LITTLE
05:45:36.148 --> 05:45:38.250
BIT MORE OF THIS REALLY IS FOR
05:45:38.317 --> 05:45:41.053
AND HEARING PURPOSES ONLY. I
05:45:41.120 --> 05:45:42.188
RESPECT EVERYBODY THAT'S CALLED
05:45:42.254 --> 05:45:45.191
IN AND TALK TODAY, BUT, UM WE'VE
05:45:45.257 --> 05:45:47.326
GOTTA COUPLE MORE BILLS TO DO,
05:45:47.393 --> 05:45:49.161
AND WE'D LIKE TO GET FINISHED
05:45:49.228 --> 05:45:52.565
BEFORE WE HAVE SESSION. ONE
05:45:52.631 --> 05:45:53.732
MOMENT HERE. WE'LL SPEED IT UP.
05:45:53.799 --> 05:45:55.668
WE HAVE LINED BY 95, PLEASE GO
05:45:55.734 --> 05:45:58.637
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS
05:45:58.704 --> 05:45:59.839
KIMBERLY DAVIDSON WITH THE CITY
05:45:59.905 --> 05:46:01.640
OF WILLIAM ARE LOCATED IN
05:46:01.707 --> 05:46:02.741
RIVERSIDE COUNTY. AND WE ARE
05:46:02.808 --> 05:46:03.976
VERY MUCH IN OPPOSITION. THANK
05:46:04.043 --> 05:46:11.517
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 39. GOOD
05:46:11.584 --> 05:46:13.719
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS VINCENT ON
05:46:13.786 --> 05:46:15.488
BEHALF OF THE PLASTIC TENDERS OF
05:46:15.554 --> 05:46:17.623
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA LOCAL 14 14.
05:46:17.690 --> 05:46:19.825
WE'RE STRONGLY OPPOSING A B 28
05:46:19.892 --> 05:46:24.263
40. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT
05:46:24.330 --> 05:46:25.397
LEVEL LINE. 4 42, PLEASE GO
05:46:25.464 --> 05:46:30.302
AHEAD. YES THIS IS RIVERSIDE
05:46:30.369 --> 05:46:32.638
COUNTY SUPERVISOR KAREN SPIEGEL
05:46:32.705 --> 05:46:34.807
AND I SUBMITTED A LETTER TO THE
05:46:34.874 --> 05:46:36.408
COMMITTEE OPPOSING A B 28
05:46:36.475 --> 05:46:37.776
FORTIES OR RESPECTFULLY WANT TO
05:46:37.843 --> 05:46:38.744
CONTINUE OUR OPPOSITION. THANK
05:46:38.811 --> 05:46:47.586
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINES 6 62.
05:46:47.653 --> 05:46:55.127
FIND 6 62 YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
05:46:55.194 --> 05:46:57.062
WITH ME GONE. WE HAVE LINED 35.
05:46:57.129 --> 05:47:02.234
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON.
05:47:02.301 --> 05:47:06.672
BUT AND OCAMPO'S LABOUR'S 3 24.
05:47:06.739 --> 05:47:07.873
AND ON BEHALF OF OUR 4500
05:47:07.940 --> 05:47:10.042
NUMBERS AND THEIR FAMILIES. WE
05:47:10.109 --> 05:47:11.911
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED 80 2040.
05:47:11.977 --> 05:47:13.112
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK
05:47:13.179 --> 05:47:17.950
YOU. NEXT WE HAVE LINE 28,
05:47:18.017 --> 05:47:20.486
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON.
05:47:20.553 --> 05:47:21.787
MY NAME IS BELLA DOOR AND I'M
05:47:21.854 --> 05:47:23.455
CALLING ON BEHALF OF LABOUR'S
05:47:23.522 --> 05:47:25.624
LOCAL 11 84, REPRESENTING 5800
05:47:25.691 --> 05:47:27.593
MEMBERS AND WE RESPECT THE POSE
05:47:27.660 --> 05:47:32.031
A B 2040 NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 6 96
05:47:32.097 --> 05:47:37.136
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
05:47:37.203 --> 05:47:38.404
NAME IS JASON CORN GOLD,
05:47:38.470 --> 05:47:40.272
PRESIDENT OF AN EMPIRE CHAPTER
05:47:40.339 --> 05:47:42.308
OF NEW YORK AND I'LL BE HAPPY
05:47:42.374 --> 05:47:43.342
FOR 350 MEMBERS, WHICH OPPOSED A
05:47:43.409 --> 05:47:48.480
B 28 POINT. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE
05:47:48.547 --> 05:47:53.452
HAVE LINES OF FIVE. MADAM CHAIR
05:47:53.519 --> 05:47:54.820
ANDREW SAUL, ON BEHALF OF THE
05:47:54.887 --> 05:47:55.921
GREATER RIVERSIDE CHAMBERS OF
05:47:55.988 --> 05:47:56.922
COMMERCE AND RESPECTFUL
05:47:56.989 --> 05:48:01.360
OPPOSITION. NEXT. WE HAVE LINES
05:48:01.427 --> 05:48:05.030
6 80. AFTERNOON. THIS IS WITH
05:48:05.097 --> 05:48:08.834
PROPERTIES. RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED
05:48:08.901 --> 05:48:17.309
A B 2040. NEXT DAY. THE LINE 40
05:48:17.376 --> 05:48:18.811
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR.
05:48:18.877 --> 05:48:20.512
THIS IS DAVID DRY ON BEHALF OF
05:48:20.579 --> 05:48:21.480
THE SOUTHWEST CALIFORNIA,
05:48:21.547 --> 05:48:21.981
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL AND
05:48:22.047 --> 05:48:29.321
OPPOSITION. NEXT RED LINE, 37.
05:48:29.388 --> 05:48:30.889
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
05:48:30.956 --> 05:48:31.890
MEMBERS CARLOS GUTIERREZ ON
05:48:31.957 --> 05:48:33.158
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA FRESH
05:48:33.225 --> 05:48:34.927
FRUIT ASSOCIATION, CALIFORNIA
05:48:34.994 --> 05:48:36.295
GROCERS ASSOCIATION AND THE
05:48:36.362 --> 05:48:37.263
CALIFORNIA CON GENDERS AND
05:48:37.329 --> 05:48:41.467
GROWERS ASSOCIATION. NEXT. WE
05:48:41.533 --> 05:48:46.805
HAVE LIONS 6 77. HI MY NAME IS
05:48:46.872 --> 05:48:48.374
ROBERT MARIE'S AND I'M CALLING
05:48:48.440 --> 05:48:50.776
FROM LABORERS LOCAL SIX TYPE IN
05:48:50.843 --> 05:48:52.011
ORANGE COUNTY ON BEHALF OF OUR
05:48:52.077 --> 05:48:53.379
4000 MEMBERS. WE RESPECTFULLY
05:48:53.445 --> 05:48:56.682
OPPOSED. THANKS. NEXT. WE HAVE
05:48:56.749 --> 05:49:04.123
LINE 24. LINE 24. YOUR LINE IS
05:49:04.189 --> 05:49:14.933
OPEN. NEXT WE HAVE LINES 7 27,
05:49:15.000 --> 05:49:18.971
PLEASE GO AHEAD. TWO BIG DEAL ON
05:49:19.038 --> 05:49:20.339
BEHALF OF THE SEMI VALLEY
05:49:20.406 --> 05:49:21.073
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE IN
05:49:21.140 --> 05:49:26.045
OPPOSITION. NEXT WE HAVE LINE
05:49:26.111 --> 05:49:29.982
27, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU.
05:49:30.049 --> 05:49:31.650
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAME CARRON
05:49:31.717 --> 05:49:33.852
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS BUBBLES
05:49:33.919 --> 05:49:35.154
FILLED REPRESENTATIVE FOR
05:49:35.220 --> 05:49:36.255
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA DISTRICT
05:49:36.322 --> 05:49:39.091
COUNCIL OF LABORERS. WE HAVE
05:49:39.158 --> 05:49:39.992
EVEN MEMBERSHIP OF MORE THAN
05:49:40.059 --> 05:49:42.528
3000 CONSTRUCTION CRAFT LABORERS
05:49:42.594 --> 05:49:44.530
, MANY OF THE INDIAN EMPIRE AND
05:49:44.596 --> 05:49:46.031
RUNNING COMMUNITIES AND WE
05:49:46.098 --> 05:49:47.166
RESPECTFULLY OF COURSE, 2040.
05:49:47.232 --> 05:49:54.373
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANKS. WE
05:49:54.440 --> 05:49:58.911
HAVE LINE 7 23, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
05:49:58.977 --> 05:50:00.479
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS BILL
05:50:00.546 --> 05:50:01.880
BLANKENSHIP, REPRESENTING NAP
05:50:01.947 --> 05:50:03.015
INLAND EMPIRE CHAPTER
05:50:03.082 --> 05:50:04.983
REPRESENTING OVER 300 MEMBER
05:50:05.050 --> 05:50:06.385
COMPANIES IN THE LOGISTICS
05:50:06.452 --> 05:50:08.987
INDUSTRY. THANK YOU FOR THE
05:50:09.054 --> 05:50:09.955
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY AND
05:50:10.022 --> 05:50:15.294
OPPOSITION AT 24 80. NEXT. WE
05:50:15.361 --> 05:50:19.498
HAVE LINE 7 24, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
05:50:19.565 --> 05:50:21.133
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR
05:50:21.200 --> 05:50:22.935
CARLOS RODRIGUEZ ON BEHALF OF
05:50:23.001 --> 05:50:24.203
THE BUILDING INDUSTRY
05:50:24.269 --> 05:50:25.104
ASSOCIATIONS. SOUTHERN
05:50:25.170 --> 05:50:27.272
CALIFORNIA EXPRESS OUR STRONG
05:50:27.339 --> 05:50:29.475
OPPOSITION TO A B 28 40. THANK
05:50:29.541 --> 05:50:37.149
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 7 20.
05:50:37.216 --> 05:50:38.884
GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS MAYOR A
05:50:38.951 --> 05:50:40.552
QUINTET A WARRANT FROM THE CITY
05:50:40.619 --> 05:50:42.621
OF FONTANA THAT SETTLED WITH THE
05:50:42.688 --> 05:50:43.689
ATTORNEY GENERAL AFTER
05:50:43.756 --> 05:50:46.392
DEVELOPING AN INDUSTRIAL
05:50:46.458 --> 05:50:49.261
QUALITY OF LIFE. INCLUDING
05:50:49.328 --> 05:50:51.497
ENVIRONMENTAL TOMORROW AND THIS
05:50:51.563 --> 05:50:53.732
PARTICULAR BILL WAS COMPLETELY
05:50:53.799 --> 05:50:54.867
GUT OUR COMMUNITY OF OUR
05:50:54.933 --> 05:50:57.970
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. I
05:50:58.036 --> 05:51:00.072
REPRESENT OVER 200. THANK YOU
05:51:00.139 --> 05:51:01.673
VERY MUCH. WE'RE JUST WE'RE JUST
05:51:01.740 --> 05:51:05.444
RIGHT NOW ON, UH, WHETHER YOU'RE
05:51:05.511 --> 05:51:06.812
IN SUPPORTER OPPOSED AND YOUR
05:51:06.879 --> 05:51:11.450
NAME AND AFFILIATION. I'M SORRY.
05:51:11.517 --> 05:51:14.052
AND BASICALLY, THIS BILL IS JUST
05:51:14.119 --> 05:51:16.789
THIS VILLAGE JUST BE BEING HEARD
05:51:16.855 --> 05:51:18.023
TODAY. THERE WOULD BE NO ACTION
05:51:18.090 --> 05:51:19.158
TAKEN, SO I APPRECIATE YOUR
05:51:19.224 --> 05:51:24.329
COMMENTS. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE
05:51:24.396 --> 05:51:28.600
HAVE LINE 6 59, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
05:51:28.667 --> 05:51:30.436
GOOD AFTERNOON PACHECO WITH THE
05:51:30.502 --> 05:51:32.371
AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE IN
05:51:32.438 --> 05:51:40.245
OPPOSITION. IN LINE 6 67. THANK
05:51:40.312 --> 05:51:41.680
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON. I'M GARY
05:51:41.747 --> 05:51:44.216
GARDNER PRO TEM OF THE CITY OF
05:51:44.283 --> 05:51:45.551
DESERT HOT SPRINGS AND ALSO
05:51:45.617 --> 05:51:47.586
EXECUTIVE BOARD MEMBER OF THE
05:51:47.653 --> 05:51:49.221
RIVERSIDE DIVISION OF THE LEGAL
05:51:49.288 --> 05:51:50.589
CALIFORNIA CITIES. WE ARE
05:51:50.656 --> 05:51:52.791
OPPOSED TO A B 28 40 IS
05:51:52.858 --> 05:51:56.495
CURRENTLY WRITTEN. THANK YOU.
05:51:56.562 --> 05:52:01.967
AND LINE 7 35. SCENARIO SMALL
05:52:02.034 --> 05:52:02.868
BUSINESS OWNER CORONA MOBILE
05:52:02.935 --> 05:52:04.937
SLEEPERS I STRONGLY OPPOSED A B
05:52:05.003 --> 05:52:12.344
28 40. IN LINE 5 87. GOOD
05:52:12.411 --> 05:52:14.446
AFTERNOON, BOBBY SPIEGEL.
05:52:14.513 --> 05:52:15.714
PROFOUNDLY CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
05:52:15.781 --> 05:52:17.583
WERE IN OPPOSITION OF A B 2840.
05:52:17.649 --> 05:52:26.792
THANK YOU. CLIENTS. 7 17. HI MY
05:52:26.859 --> 05:52:29.061
NAME IS TONY. NEGOTIATION I'M AN
05:52:29.127 --> 05:52:31.196
M ON EMPIRE CALLING ON BEHALF OF
05:52:31.263 --> 05:52:32.231
NOW DEVELOPING LEADERS IN
05:52:32.297 --> 05:52:35.567
CALIFORNIA. ER SEXUALLY POSED A
05:52:35.634 --> 05:52:44.476
B 28 40. THANK YOU. FIND 7 37.
05:52:44.543 --> 05:52:45.844
JEFF GIBSON ASSOCIATION OF
05:52:45.911 --> 05:52:46.879
WESTERN EMPLOYERS RESPECTFULLY
05:52:46.945 --> 05:52:54.953
OPPOSED. BUYING 7 39. GOOD
05:52:55.020 --> 05:52:56.188
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
05:52:56.255 --> 05:52:57.389
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. THIS IS
05:52:57.456 --> 05:52:57.956
BENJAMIN LOPEZ WITH THE NEW
05:52:58.023 --> 05:52:58.824
LONDON PAR ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP
05:52:58.891 --> 05:52:59.725
. WE RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED MAYBE
05:52:59.791 --> 05:53:07.266
28 40. BY 7 43. GOOD AFTERNOON
05:53:07.332 --> 05:53:08.901
MANAGER MEMBERS CARLY SHELBY,
05:53:08.967 --> 05:53:11.003
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
05:53:11.069 --> 05:53:11.503
TEMECULA AND RESPECTFUL
05:53:11.570 --> 05:53:13.805
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. CLIENTS.
05:53:13.872 --> 05:53:18.810
7 33. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND
05:53:18.877 --> 05:53:20.312
MEMBERS. THIS IS MANUAL RENDON,
05:53:20.379 --> 05:53:22.314
RESIDENT OF FONTANA ON BEHALF OF
05:53:22.381 --> 05:53:23.782
ALL RESIDENTS WHOSE HEALTH IS
05:53:23.849 --> 05:53:24.283
NEGATIVELY AFFECTED BY
05:53:24.349 --> 05:53:26.285
WAREHOUSES. WE SUPPORT A B 2 80.
05:53:26.351 --> 05:53:33.392
284. AND NEXT WE HAVE LINES. 7
05:53:33.458 --> 05:53:37.796
47, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LUCY LOCKET
05:53:37.863 --> 05:53:39.264
PHILLIPS FROM THE CITY OF
05:53:39.331 --> 05:53:41.333
MARIETTA, AND WE STRONGLY OPPOSE
05:53:41.400 --> 05:53:45.704
A B 28 40. NEXT. WE HAVE LINES 6
05:53:45.771 --> 05:53:51.710
16. MY APOLOGIES. WE HAVE LINE 7
05:53:51.777 --> 05:54:09.061
49. OF THE 49 YEAR LINE IS OPEN.
05:54:09.127 --> 05:54:11.763
MOVING ON. WE HAVE LINED 7 50,
05:54:11.830 --> 05:54:16.568
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
05:54:16.635 --> 05:54:18.136
. THIS IS AARON SAFTEY ON BEHALF
05:54:18.203 --> 05:54:21.073
OF THE 27 MEMBER CITIES IN THE
05:54:21.139 --> 05:54:22.741
RIVERSIDE COUNTY DIVISION OF THE
05:54:22.808 --> 05:54:25.344
LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES AND
05:54:25.410 --> 05:54:26.211
WE ARE IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU
05:54:26.278 --> 05:54:32.751
VERY MUCH. AND WITH THAT THERE
05:54:32.818 --> 05:54:37.222
ARE NO FURTHER LINE. THANK YOU.
05:54:37.289 --> 05:54:39.925
THANK YOU. SQUEEZE DOWN HAVE NOW
05:54:39.992 --> 05:54:41.760
COMPLETED THE OPPOSITION WE CAN
05:54:41.827 --> 05:54:45.764
BACK TO COMMITTEE. ANY.
05:54:45.831 --> 05:54:47.265
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. SENATOR
05:54:47.332 --> 05:54:49.334
ROSSA? YES UM THANK YOU, MR
05:54:49.401 --> 05:54:54.640
CHAIR. UM I WANT TO STAND UP AND
05:54:54.706 --> 05:54:56.541
THANK THE WOMEN WHO ARE HERE
05:54:56.608 --> 05:55:01.413
TODAY. I WANT TO THANK YOU
05:55:01.480 --> 05:55:03.115
BECAUSE AS LATINA WOMEN, YOU'RE
05:55:03.181 --> 05:55:04.783
FIGHTING FOR YOUR FAMILIES.
05:55:04.850 --> 05:55:05.817
YOU'RE FIGHTING FOR OUR
05:55:05.884 --> 05:55:08.787
COMMUNITIES. NEED VOICE AND NEED
05:55:08.854 --> 05:55:10.522
REPRESENTATION. I WANT TO THANK
05:55:10.589 --> 05:55:14.893
THE AUTHOR. FOR BEING AN EQUALLY
05:55:14.960 --> 05:55:15.927
STRONG WOMAN, EQUALLY STRONG
05:55:15.994 --> 05:55:19.398
LATINA. AND WITHOUT WOMEN LIKE
05:55:19.464 --> 05:55:22.768
YOURSELVES. FIGHTING FOR THE
05:55:22.834 --> 05:55:24.536
KIDS FIGHTING FOR POOR
05:55:24.603 --> 05:55:26.638
COMMUNITIES. WE WOULD REALLY,
05:55:26.705 --> 05:55:29.107
REALLY BE IN WORSE CONDITIONS
05:55:29.174 --> 05:55:30.275
THAN MANY OF OUR COMMUNITIES ARE
05:55:30.342 --> 05:55:33.845
TODAY. WHEN CESAR CHAVEZ AND
05:55:33.912 --> 05:55:34.846
DOLORES HUERTA STARTED THE
05:55:34.913 --> 05:55:37.783
FARMWORKER MOVEMENT. EVERYBODY
05:55:37.849 --> 05:55:39.151
TOLD HIM YOU'RE POOR. YOU'RE
05:55:39.217 --> 05:55:42.954
LATINO IMMIGRANT. YOU HAVE NO
05:55:43.021 --> 05:55:44.756
WAY OF GETTING YOUR VOICE
05:55:44.823 --> 05:55:49.027
ACROSS. UM, BUT THEY WERE WRONG.
05:55:49.094 --> 05:55:52.330
AND WHEN THE FARM WORKERS UNION
05:55:52.397 --> 05:55:55.033
BAND, THE FIRST PESTICIDE THAT
05:55:55.100 --> 05:55:56.802
WAS SPRAYED OVER FARM WORKERS,
05:55:56.868 --> 05:56:00.405
IT WAS BECAUSE OF THEM. IT WAS
05:56:00.472 --> 05:56:02.074
BECAUSE WHEN AND EVEN THOUGH
05:56:02.140 --> 05:56:04.042
EVERYBODY TOLD HIM YOU HAVE NO
05:56:04.109 --> 05:56:07.212
POWER. THEY STILL MOVE FORWARD,
05:56:07.279 --> 05:56:09.481
AND THEY STARTED TO ADDRESS THE
05:56:09.548 --> 05:56:10.582
HEALTH AND SAFETY OF THOSE FARM
05:56:10.649 --> 05:56:13.418
WORKERS OUT IN THE FIELDS. IF IT
05:56:13.485 --> 05:56:16.188
WASN'T FOR WOMEN, STRONG LATINA
05:56:16.254 --> 05:56:19.424
WOMEN LIKE YOURSELVES AGAIN, OUR
05:56:19.491 --> 05:56:21.259
COMMUNITIES WOULD BE SO MUCH
05:56:21.326 --> 05:56:23.361
WORTH WORSE OFF. SO THAT'S THE
05:56:23.428 --> 05:56:25.030
FIRST THING I WANT TO TELL YOU,
05:56:25.097 --> 05:56:26.998
AND I WANT TO TELL YOU NOT TO
05:56:27.065 --> 05:56:29.034
GIVE UP. I WANT TO TELL YOU TO
05:56:29.101 --> 05:56:30.902
KEEP ON DOING WHAT YOU'RE DOING,
05:56:30.969 --> 05:56:31.970
BECAUSE YOU'RE DOING THE RIGHT
05:56:32.037 --> 05:56:34.606
THING. UM AND YOU NEED TO BE
05:56:34.673 --> 05:56:36.541
ACKNOWLEDGED. YOU NEED TO BE
05:56:36.608 --> 05:56:40.045
ACKNOWLEDGED. FOR BEING THE
05:56:40.112 --> 05:56:41.313
FIGHTERS FOR OUR COMMUNITY.
05:56:41.379 --> 05:56:44.382
YOU'RE NOT OUT TO DESTROY JOBS.
05:56:44.449 --> 05:56:45.884
YOU'RE NOT OUT TO HURT ECONOMIC
05:56:45.951 --> 05:56:47.986
DEVELOPMENT. YOU'RE NOT OUT TO
05:56:48.053 --> 05:56:49.087
TAKE ANYBODY'S JOB AWAY FROM
05:56:49.154 --> 05:56:52.858
THEM. YOU'RE OUT TO DEFEND THE
05:56:52.924 --> 05:56:54.626
HEALTH AND SAFETY OF YOUR
05:56:54.693 --> 05:56:58.463
COMMUNITY. SO THAT TO ME IS MY
05:56:58.530 --> 05:57:01.166
THE BEST THAT I CAN DO RIGHT NOW
05:57:01.233 --> 05:57:04.569
AND ENCOURAGE YOU TO KEEP ON WE
05:57:04.636 --> 05:57:06.938
ARE PUT INTO THIS FALSE
05:57:07.005 --> 05:57:09.908
NARRATIVE OF THINKING THAT WE
05:57:09.975 --> 05:57:11.243
CAN ONLY PICK BETWEEN HEALTH AND
05:57:11.309 --> 05:57:13.712
SAFETY AND GOOD JOBS. AND THAT'S
05:57:13.779 --> 05:57:17.215
JUST NOT TRUE. IT'S NOT TRUE,
05:57:17.282 --> 05:57:19.684
BUT IT DEPENDS ON ALL OF US. IF
05:57:19.751 --> 05:57:21.286
WE FALL INTO THAT. THE COMMUNITY
05:57:21.353 --> 05:57:25.190
WILL LOOK AT AH LABOR AND UNIONS
05:57:25.257 --> 05:57:30.862
AS THE BAD GUYS. OR. UNIONS WILL
05:57:30.929 --> 05:57:32.030
LOOK AT COMMUNITY ACTIVIST LIKE
05:57:32.097 --> 05:57:36.234
YOURSELF. AS THE BAD GUYS. AND
05:57:36.301 --> 05:57:38.170
IT CANNOT BE THAT WAY. IT CANNOT
05:57:38.236 --> 05:57:40.605
BE THAT WAY. SOME OF THE SAME
05:57:40.672 --> 05:57:42.440
PEOPLE WHO TESTIFIED AGAINST
05:57:42.507 --> 05:57:44.109
THIS BILL TODAY ARE THE SAME
05:57:44.176 --> 05:57:46.978
ONES WHO TESTIFY AGAINST RAISING
05:57:47.045 --> 05:57:48.780
OUR MINIMUM WAGE THAT THE SAME
05:57:48.847 --> 05:57:50.348
ONES WHO TESTIFY AGAINST OTHER
05:57:50.415 --> 05:57:51.683
THINGS THAT ARE GOOD. FOR OUR
05:57:51.750 --> 05:57:57.322
COMMUNITY. SO JUST. BE CLEAR.
05:57:57.389 --> 05:57:58.690
KEEP ON MOVING FORWARD. JUST
05:57:58.757 --> 05:58:00.592
KNOW THAT MANY OF US ARE VERY
05:58:00.659 --> 05:58:03.295
PROUD OF YOU. AND WE'RE ALSO
05:58:03.361 --> 05:58:04.462
PROUD. I'M ALSO PROUD OF CAN
05:58:04.529 --> 05:58:07.532
SPEAK FOR MYSELF. THAT THERE ARE
05:58:07.599 --> 05:58:10.936
UNIONS FIGHTING FOR GOOD JOBS.
05:58:11.002 --> 05:58:13.205
AND THE TWO TOGETHER ARE VERY
05:58:13.271 --> 05:58:15.640
POWERFUL FORCE. WHEN WE GET
05:58:15.707 --> 05:58:18.076
SPLIT ACROSS AWAY FROM EACH
05:58:18.143 --> 05:58:21.713
OTHER. THEN WE'RE WEAKER. UM AND
05:58:21.780 --> 05:58:23.481
I, FOR ONE, AM NOT GOING TO FALL
05:58:23.548 --> 05:58:25.150
INTO THE NARRATIVE OF ONE OR THE
05:58:25.217 --> 05:58:27.085
OTHER. I KNOW THE AUTHOR MADE
05:58:27.152 --> 05:58:29.221
SURE SHE INCLUDED. THE ISSUE OF
05:58:29.287 --> 05:58:32.324
JOB STANDARDS IN IN THE BILL,
05:58:32.390 --> 05:58:34.693
AND SO LET'S KEEP ON DOING THAT.
05:58:34.759 --> 05:58:35.827
LET'S KEEP ON, UH, TRYING TO
05:58:35.894 --> 05:58:40.332
MOVE FORWARD. BUT DON'T GIVE UP.
05:58:40.398 --> 05:58:41.466
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. SENATOR
05:58:41.533 --> 05:58:42.968
ROSCOE, DID YOU MAKE A MOTION
05:58:43.034 --> 05:58:44.469
EARLIER WHEN I WAS OUT? WELL
05:58:44.536 --> 05:58:46.705
MAYBE WE COULD GO BACK TO THE
05:58:46.771 --> 05:58:48.006
MOTION YET. OKAY, PLEASE. WOULD
05:58:48.073 --> 05:58:52.010
YOU LIKE TO GIVE US A CLOSER?
05:58:52.077 --> 05:58:55.313
URGING AND THOSE ARE IMPORTANT
05:58:55.380 --> 05:58:57.282
WORDS FOR MY WITNESSES TO HEAR.
05:58:57.349 --> 05:58:58.450
BECAUSE THEY HAVE BEEN THE
05:58:58.516 --> 05:59:05.724
FIGHTERS. NOBODY MAKES ME CRY.
05:59:05.790 --> 05:59:07.826
EXCEPT FOR LIZ. NOW YOU'RE
05:59:07.893 --> 05:59:11.696
MAKING ME CRY. AND WITH THE
05:59:11.763 --> 05:59:12.697
OPPOSITION. I APPRECIATE THAT,
05:59:12.764 --> 05:59:15.100
THEY SAY, RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION.
05:59:15.166 --> 05:59:16.701
BECAUSE WE NEED TO RESPECT EACH
05:59:16.768 --> 05:59:19.504
OTHER'S POSITIONS HERE. I THINK
05:59:19.571 --> 05:59:22.974
IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT
05:59:23.041 --> 05:59:24.209
FROM THE MOMENT WE STARTED THIS
05:59:24.276 --> 05:59:29.347
BILL. IT WAS NEVER THE INTENT.
05:59:29.414 --> 05:59:31.516
OUR INTENT WAS NEVER TO STOP
05:59:31.583 --> 05:59:33.585
DEVELOPMENT. NEVER IT WAS NEVER
05:59:33.652 --> 05:59:35.587
TO TAKE AWAY THE GOOD JOBS, GOOD
05:59:35.654 --> 05:59:38.323
PAYING JOBS. BUT IT WAS TO MAKE
05:59:38.390 --> 05:59:52.003
SURE.
05:59:52.070 --> 05:59:53.605
I DON'T THINK I'VE EVER CRIED
05:59:53.672 --> 05:59:56.474
WHEN I PRESENTED A BILL. BUT IT
05:59:56.541 --> 06:00:01.179
IS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HEAR THE
06:00:01.246 --> 06:00:03.048
VOICE OF THOSE WHO ARE MOST
06:00:03.114 --> 06:00:05.150
HARMED. AND THE ONES WHO ARE
06:00:05.216 --> 06:00:06.685
HARMED ARE THE ONES WHO ARE THE
06:00:06.751 --> 06:00:08.753
MOTHERS WHO HAVE TO TAKE THEIR
06:00:08.820 --> 06:00:09.554
CHILDREN TO DOCTOR'S
06:00:09.621 --> 06:00:11.289
APPOINTMENTS. WE HAVE TO TAKE
06:00:11.356 --> 06:00:13.191
TIME OFF FROM WORK BECAUSE THEIR
06:00:13.258 --> 06:00:14.392
CHILDREN ARE ASTHMATIC. THAT'S
06:00:14.459 --> 06:00:16.194
WHAT WE NEED TO TAKE CARE OF. IN
06:00:16.261 --> 06:00:20.765
OUR COMMUNITY. SEVEN IN 10,
06:00:20.832 --> 06:00:25.503
CHILDREN HAVE ASTHMA. DOESN'T
06:00:25.570 --> 06:00:27.005
JUST HAPPEN. THERE'S SOMETHING
06:00:27.072 --> 06:00:28.139
HAPPENING IN OUR COMMUNITY THAT
06:00:28.206 --> 06:00:30.175
IS CAUSING THIS. THERE WAS A
06:00:30.241 --> 06:00:31.176
COMMENT MADE ABOUT THE SUPPLY
06:00:31.242 --> 06:00:33.745
CHAIN CRISIS. WE HAVE A HEALTH
06:00:33.812 --> 06:00:37.215
CRISIS. THAT HAS TO TAKE
06:00:37.282 --> 06:00:38.383
PRECEDENCE OVER ANYTHING ELSE
06:00:38.450 --> 06:00:42.253
THAT WE TALKED ABOUT. IN SOME OF
06:00:42.320 --> 06:00:43.722
THE COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE NOT
06:00:43.788 --> 06:00:45.557
TODAY. BUT IN THE LITERATURE
06:00:45.623 --> 06:00:48.360
THAT WAS THAT WAS DISSEMINATED.
06:00:48.426 --> 06:00:49.561
IT TALKED ABOUT THIS BILL BEING
06:00:49.627 --> 06:00:52.564
A JOB KILLER. IMMEDIATELY GOT
06:00:52.630 --> 06:00:54.632
CALLS FROM THE COMMUNITY,
06:00:54.699 --> 06:00:56.234
SAYING, ELOISE. HOW CAN THEY SAY
06:00:56.301 --> 06:00:57.435
THIS IS A JOB KILLER? IT'S
06:00:57.502 --> 06:00:59.104
KILLING OUR CHILDREN. THAT BE
06:00:59.170 --> 06:01:01.006
THE SHOULDN'T THAT BE WHAT WE
06:01:01.072 --> 06:01:08.980
TALKED ABOUT INSTEAD? THE.
06:01:09.047 --> 06:01:12.684
AMENDMENT THAT WAS OFFERED AND I
06:01:12.751 --> 06:01:13.752
SINCERELY APPRECIATE. I'M SORRY
06:01:13.818 --> 06:01:15.820
THAT THE CHAIR IS NOT HERE. I
06:01:15.887 --> 06:01:16.755
SINCERELY APPRECIATED THAT SHE
06:01:16.821 --> 06:01:18.723
WAS WILLING TO WORK WITH US THAT
06:01:18.790 --> 06:01:21.659
THE COMMITTEE UM MEMBERS WERE
06:01:21.726 --> 06:01:23.161
ALSO WILLING TO WORK WITH US.
06:01:23.228 --> 06:01:24.429
THE STAKEHOLDERS. MORE
06:01:24.496 --> 06:01:31.603
IMPORTANTLY, MY COMMUNITY. BUT
06:01:31.669 --> 06:01:35.673
TO PUT A MORATORIUM ON ALL THE
06:01:35.740 --> 06:01:37.809
DEVELOPMENT OF WAREHOUSES. IS
06:01:37.876 --> 06:01:41.413
NOT WHERE WE WANT TO GO. THAT
06:01:41.479 --> 06:01:44.315
ISN'T WHAT I INTENDED TO DO WHEN
06:01:44.382 --> 06:01:45.583
I STARTED AND I'M NOT GOING TO
06:01:45.650 --> 06:01:47.352
ACCEPT THAT AS AN AMENDMENT
06:01:47.419 --> 06:01:48.753
TODAY. I APPRECIATE THE OFFER OF
06:01:48.820 --> 06:01:52.023
A STUDY STUDIES HAVE BEEN DONE.
06:01:52.090 --> 06:01:54.492
CARB HAS ALREADY COMPLETED THEIR
06:01:54.559 --> 06:01:56.728
STUDY. THEY DID IT IN 2000 AND
06:01:56.795 --> 06:01:58.863
FIVE. THEY REDID IT JUST A FEW
06:01:58.930 --> 06:01:59.931
YEARS AGO AND SAID, I THINK EVEN
06:01:59.998 --> 06:02:01.800
MORE THAN 1000 FT IS WHAT WE
06:02:01.866 --> 06:02:04.035
NEED TO DO. 1000 FT ISN'T
06:02:04.102 --> 06:02:07.705
ENOUGH. WE ARE SAYING. BUILD
06:02:07.772 --> 06:02:09.707
YOUR WAREHOUSES JUST DON'T BUILD
06:02:09.774 --> 06:02:12.010
THEM NEXT TO THE HOMES. BUILD
06:02:12.077 --> 06:02:13.411
YOUR WAREHOUSES JUST DON'T BUILD
06:02:13.478 --> 06:02:15.780
THEM NEXT TO THE SCHOOLS WHERE
06:02:15.847 --> 06:02:18.216
THE CHILDREN ARE PLAYING. THERE
06:02:18.283 --> 06:02:20.118
IS A NEW WAREHOUSE THAT HAS JUST
06:02:20.185 --> 06:02:21.820
BEEN APPROVED. THAT WILL BE 15
06:02:21.886 --> 06:02:25.156
FT. FROM THE FENCE WHERE
06:02:25.223 --> 06:02:26.191
PRESCHOOLERS ARE GOING TO BE
06:02:26.257 --> 06:02:29.227
PLAYING. THERE'S SOMETHING WRONG
06:02:29.294 --> 06:02:33.932
WITH THIS. AND I RECOGNIZE THAT
06:02:33.998 --> 06:02:35.834
ONE OF OUR MAYORS CALLED IN TO
06:02:35.900 --> 06:02:38.736
SAY THAT THEY HAD, UM THEY HAD
06:02:38.803 --> 06:02:40.205
RESOLVED AN ISSUE WITH WITH THE
06:02:40.271 --> 06:02:42.841
ATTORNEY GENERAL TO BE CLEAR.
06:02:42.907 --> 06:02:47.479
THERE WAS A 205. 1000 SQUARE
06:02:47.545 --> 06:02:49.714
FOOT WAREHOUSE. IT WAS GOING TO
06:02:49.781 --> 06:02:51.916
BE ABLE TO BE BUILT IN THE CITY
06:02:51.983 --> 06:02:53.985
OF FONTANA SEQUA. WAS FOLLOWED.
06:02:54.052 --> 06:02:56.087
BUT AS IS ALLOWED UNDER SEQUA.
06:02:56.154 --> 06:03:02.127
IF THE CITY. WANTS THEY CAN SIGN
06:03:02.193 --> 06:03:03.962
A STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING
06:03:04.028 --> 06:03:06.030
CONSIDERATIONS, WHICH THEY DID.
06:03:06.097 --> 06:03:09.667
AND THE WAREHOUSE WAS APPROVED.
06:03:09.734 --> 06:03:11.402
AND I'M SO GRATEFUL TO THE
06:03:11.469 --> 06:03:12.637
COMMUNITY WHO THEN CONTACTED THE
06:03:12.704 --> 06:03:14.072
ATTORNEY GENERAL AND SAID HOW
06:03:14.139 --> 06:03:16.407
CAN THIS HAPPEN? IF THE
06:03:16.474 --> 06:03:18.743
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT SAYS
06:03:18.810 --> 06:03:20.879
THAT SHOULDN'T BE BUILT HERE,
06:03:20.945 --> 06:03:21.913
BECAUSE IT'S IMPACTING US. WHY
06:03:21.980 --> 06:03:24.682
IS THIS BEING APPROVED? AND I'M
06:03:24.749 --> 06:03:25.817
VERY GRATEFUL TO OUR ATTORNEY
06:03:25.884 --> 06:03:28.486
GENERAL ROB BONTA. WHO DID THE
06:03:28.553 --> 06:03:31.356
INVESTIGATION AND AS A RESULT OF
06:03:31.422 --> 06:03:32.390
THAT, THEN THERE WAS AN
06:03:32.457 --> 06:03:34.792
AGREEMENT. BUT IT WASN'T A
06:03:34.859 --> 06:03:36.294
VOLUNTARY AGREEMENT. IT CAME AS
06:03:36.361 --> 06:03:38.363
A RESULT OF A LAWSUIT. LET'S BE
06:03:38.429 --> 06:03:41.766
CLEAR ABOUT THAT. A MORATORIUM
06:03:41.833 --> 06:03:46.137
TODAY. COULD TAKE CARE OF MY
06:03:46.204 --> 06:03:48.273
COMMUNITY FOR A YEAR. THAT WAS
06:03:48.339 --> 06:03:49.841
THE OFFER THE, UM OFFERED
06:03:49.908 --> 06:03:54.078
AMENDMENT. THAT IS NOT WHAT
06:03:54.145 --> 06:03:55.780
WE'RE SEEKING. WE ARE SEEKING
06:03:55.847 --> 06:03:57.715
REAL SOLUTIONS. WE ARE SEEKING
06:03:57.782 --> 06:03:59.717
REAL SOLUTIONS THAT WILL PROVIDE
06:03:59.784 --> 06:04:00.985
A BENEFIT TO THE COMMUNITY SO
06:04:01.052 --> 06:04:05.190
THAT WE NOT ONLY HAVE WAREHOUSES
06:04:05.256 --> 06:04:07.625
AS NEIGHBORS, WE WANT THEM AS
06:04:07.692 --> 06:04:09.827
GOOD NEIGHBORS. LET'S FIND WAYS
06:04:09.894 --> 06:04:12.096
THAT ARE ALTERNATIVE MEASURES
06:04:12.163 --> 06:04:12.664
THAT WILL PROVIDE THE SAME
06:04:12.730 --> 06:04:16.267
BENEFITS AS 1000 FT BUFFER. SO
06:04:16.334 --> 06:04:17.635
IT ISN'T JUST 1000 FT BUFFER.
06:04:17.702 --> 06:04:20.205
IT'S SAYING IF YOU CAN THINK OF
06:04:20.271 --> 06:04:21.673
OTHER WAYS THAT WILL HAVE THE
06:04:21.739 --> 06:04:23.174
SAME PROTECTION TO THE HEALTH OF
06:04:23.241 --> 06:04:24.242
THE COMMUNITY. OFFER IT. THE
06:04:24.309 --> 06:04:26.611
CITY CAN APPROVE IT. THAT
06:04:26.678 --> 06:04:28.413
PROVIDES THAT LOCAL CONTROL THAT
06:04:28.479 --> 06:04:30.915
THE CITIES SO MUCH WANT. BUT
06:04:30.982 --> 06:04:32.784
IT'S STILL MAKES THEM BE
06:04:32.850 --> 06:04:33.818
INTENTIONAL ABOUT PROTECTING THE
06:04:33.885 --> 06:04:36.821
COMMUNITY. THEY HAVE TO BE
06:04:36.888 --> 06:04:38.223
INTENTIONAL ABOUT SAYING
06:04:38.289 --> 06:04:39.657
ALRIGHT, DEVELOPER YOU WANT TO
06:04:39.724 --> 06:04:40.858
BUILD A WAREHOUSE? WE DON'T HAVE
06:04:40.925 --> 06:04:44.362
1000 FT. WHAT CAN YOU OFFER SO
06:04:44.429 --> 06:04:45.863
THAT WE'RE SURE THAT WE TAKE
06:04:45.930 --> 06:04:48.366
CARE OF THE COMMUNITY'S HEALTH?
06:04:48.433 --> 06:04:49.400
BECAUSE THOSE DIESEL TRUCKS
06:04:49.467 --> 06:04:51.202
COMING IN AND OUT, THEY'RE GOING
06:04:51.269 --> 06:04:52.904
TO AFFECT THEIR HEALTH. AND THAT
06:04:52.971 --> 06:04:56.874
IS WHAT WE ARE SEEKING. WE WANT
06:04:56.941 --> 06:04:58.343
THERE TO BE SOMETHING THAT IS
06:04:58.409 --> 06:05:00.778
INTENTIONAL WHERE THE WAREHOUSES
06:05:00.845 --> 06:05:02.046
CAN BE BUILT, BUT THE
06:05:02.113 --> 06:05:03.848
COMMUNITY'S HEALTH WILL BE AN
06:05:03.915 --> 06:05:06.751
OVERRIDING FACTOR. NOT THE
06:05:06.818 --> 06:05:10.288
ECONOMIC BENEFIT OF A WAREHOUSE.
06:05:10.355 --> 06:05:11.556
AND WITH THAT, I SINCERELY
06:05:11.623 --> 06:05:13.024
APPRECIATE WE ARE NOT DONE. WE
06:05:13.091 --> 06:05:14.926
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK ON THIS
06:05:14.993 --> 06:05:17.862
ISSUE. THAT IS A PROMISE. AND I
06:05:17.929 --> 06:05:19.897
APPRECIATE THE HELP FROM THOSE
06:05:19.964 --> 06:05:21.899
OF YOU WHO HAVE PLEDGED YOUR
06:05:21.966 --> 06:05:24.302
YOUR ASSISTANCE AND YOUR SUPPORT
06:05:24.369 --> 06:05:27.138
ON THIS MATTER. AND WITH THAT I
06:05:27.205 --> 06:05:28.506
THANK THE CHAIR FOR ALLOWING ME
06:05:28.573 --> 06:05:29.907
TO PRESENT THIS. FOR TESTIMONY
06:05:29.974 --> 06:05:35.913
ONLY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
06:05:35.980 --> 06:05:37.915
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EMOTION IS A
06:05:37.982 --> 06:05:39.083
SIGN OF STRENGTH, NOT A
06:05:39.150 --> 06:05:40.585
WEAKNESS. THANK YOU FOR SAYING
06:05:40.652 --> 06:05:44.088
THAT. OKAY? THANK YOU FOR ALL
06:05:44.155 --> 06:05:46.124
WHO HAVE PARTICIPATED TODAY.
06:05:46.190 --> 06:05:47.191
VERY THOROUGH HEARING. WHAT IS
06:05:47.258 --> 06:05:49.560
OUR NEXT ITEM? PLEASE COME
06:05:49.627 --> 06:06:03.007
FORWARD. AS YOU WILL PROCEED,
06:06:03.074 --> 06:06:04.575
SIR. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
06:06:04.642 --> 06:06:06.210
CHAIR. YOU KNOW, MR CHAIR WITH
06:06:06.277 --> 06:06:08.379
YOUR PERMISSION. I HAVE A VERY
06:06:08.446 --> 06:06:10.782
THINK QUICK BILL THAT IT'S THINK
06:06:10.848 --> 06:06:13.384
MAKES MORE SENSE TO TAKE OUT OF
06:06:13.451 --> 06:06:15.286
ORDER. THAT'S A B 24 53. THAT'S
06:06:15.353 --> 06:06:17.055
VENTURA TAX CAP. DO IT AND WE
06:06:17.121 --> 06:06:18.656
COULD GET INTO THE LONGER BILL.
06:06:18.723 --> 06:06:22.026
THAT'S UH 24 53. GREAT. THANK
06:06:22.093 --> 06:06:25.296
YOU VERY MUCH 24 53 UNDER
06:06:25.363 --> 06:06:26.331
EXISTING LAW, CITIES AND
06:06:26.397 --> 06:06:27.632
COUNTIES ARE AUTHORIZED TO
06:06:27.699 --> 06:06:30.401
IMPOSE TRANSITION TAXES. AND USE
06:06:30.468 --> 06:06:31.369
TAXES AND QUARTER CENT
06:06:31.436 --> 06:06:32.837
INCREMENTS AS LONG AS THE
06:06:32.904 --> 06:06:35.073
COMBINED RATE FOR THE COUNTY
06:06:35.139 --> 06:06:36.474
DOESN'T EXCEED 2% VENTURA COUNTY
06:06:36.541 --> 06:06:38.543
HIT THAT CAP WHEN ONE CITY
06:06:38.609 --> 06:06:40.244
RECENTLY PASSED A SALES TAX
06:06:40.311 --> 06:06:41.312
INCREASE. THIS BILL SIMPLY
06:06:41.379 --> 06:06:42.313
RAISES THE CAP. BY HALF A
06:06:42.380 --> 06:06:45.416
PERCENTAGE POINT. THANK YOU.
06:06:45.483 --> 06:06:47.785
THANK YOU. BILL DOESN'T INCREASE
06:06:47.852 --> 06:06:49.954
ATTACKS ITSELF. ANY WITNESSES
06:06:50.021 --> 06:06:51.456
YOU WISH TO BRING FORWARD WITH
06:06:51.522 --> 06:06:53.224
ME TODAY IS ANDY FIELDS FROM
06:06:53.291 --> 06:06:54.125
REBUILD SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. HE
06:06:54.192 --> 06:06:56.227
WAS HERE, BUT HE HAD TO LEAVE
06:06:56.294 --> 06:06:57.362
AND HE'S GOING TO TESTIFY BY
06:06:57.428 --> 06:06:59.564
PHONE. OKAY WE WOULD ARE WE AS
06:06:59.630 --> 06:07:03.935
HE PATCHED IN NOW, MODERATOR.
06:07:04.001 --> 06:07:05.203
NOT ON THE LINE MOMENT. LET ME
06:07:05.269 --> 06:07:14.145
SEE HERE. I DON'T SEE HIM
06:07:14.212 --> 06:07:16.214
CONNECTED AT THE MOMENT. YOU'RE
06:07:16.280 --> 06:07:18.549
ONLY UH, LEADING WITNESS THAT
06:07:18.616 --> 06:07:20.918
THAT WAS MY ONLY WITNESS FOR
06:07:20.985 --> 06:07:22.353
FOUR FOR TODAY. UM HE
06:07:22.420 --> 06:07:24.322
REPRESENTED THE ORGANIZATION
06:07:24.389 --> 06:07:25.690
TRYING TO DO A TRANSPORTATION
06:07:25.757 --> 06:07:29.060
SALES TAX IN THE COUNTY. WE ALSO
06:07:29.127 --> 06:07:31.028
HAD REPRESENTATION FROM THE
06:07:31.095 --> 06:07:32.163
LOCAL TRADE UNIONS, ALSO IN
06:07:32.230 --> 06:07:34.699
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. WELL
06:07:34.766 --> 06:07:35.666
CERTAINLY CONNECTED ANYBODY,
06:07:35.733 --> 06:07:45.810
PLEASE PRESS STAR ZERO. AND I'M
06:07:45.877 --> 06:07:47.378
NOT SEEING ANYONE QUEUE UP AT
06:07:47.445 --> 06:07:48.746
THIS TIME. NOBODY OKAY? IT WOULD
06:07:48.813 --> 06:07:49.914
BE SUFFICIENT FOR YOU TO PROCEED
06:07:49.981 --> 06:07:51.048
WITHOUT THAT TESTIMONY.
06:07:51.115 --> 06:07:51.916
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
06:07:51.983 --> 06:07:55.953
OKAY, VERY GOOD. YEAH. NOW DO WE
06:07:56.020 --> 06:08:01.092
HAVE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE ROOM?
06:08:01.159 --> 06:08:02.326
AND OR MODERATOR ON THE LINE
06:08:02.393 --> 06:08:07.999
OPPOSITION. IF WE WOULD LIKE TO
06:08:08.065 --> 06:08:08.933
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL
06:08:09.000 --> 06:08:10.768
, PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
06:08:10.835 --> 06:08:15.706
THE ZERO AT THIS TIME. AGAIN IF
06:08:15.773 --> 06:08:16.808
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
06:08:16.874 --> 06:08:17.842
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
06:08:17.909 --> 06:08:20.011
THIS TIME. ONE MOMENT, PLEASE.
06:08:20.077 --> 06:08:24.081
WE HAVE ONE LINE THE QUÊ. AND WE
06:08:24.148 --> 06:08:28.352
HAVE LINE 5 72, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
06:08:28.419 --> 06:08:34.759
15 TO GO AHEAD. WELL, I'M SORRY.
06:08:34.826 --> 06:08:43.668
5 72 7 TO GO AHEAD. THANK YOU.
06:08:43.734 --> 06:08:48.406
PLEASE GO AHEAD LINE 5 72. MY
06:08:48.473 --> 06:08:50.641
NAME IS JAN DIETRICH WITH THE 3
06:08:50.708 --> 06:08:52.710
50 VENTURA COUNTY CLIMATE HUB
06:08:52.777 --> 06:08:54.245
THAT HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN TWO
06:08:54.312 --> 06:08:55.813
PRIOR EFFORTS TO HAVE A
06:08:55.880 --> 06:08:57.715
TRANSPORTATION SALES TAX AND OUR
06:08:57.782 --> 06:09:00.184
COUNTY. UH WE'RE REALLY STRONGLY
06:09:00.251 --> 06:09:01.786
SUPPORTING THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
06:09:01.853 --> 06:09:10.962
THANK YOU. AND ANY OPPOSITION.
06:09:11.028 --> 06:09:13.264
AND THERE ARE NO FURTHER LINE.
06:09:13.331 --> 06:09:14.398
THANK YOU. OKAY, WE WILL SOON
06:09:14.465 --> 06:09:18.970
NOT SO PARDON? PLEASE PUT THEM
06:09:19.036 --> 06:09:22.373
ON. GO AHEAD WITH YOUR
06:09:22.440 --> 06:09:29.347
TESTIMONY. THANK YOU, MR VICE
06:09:29.413 --> 06:09:30.848
CHAIR. I APOLOGIZE. I WAS
06:09:30.915 --> 06:09:32.350
LISTENING TO THE, UH, THE LIVE
06:09:32.416 --> 06:09:33.851
TESTIMONY AND APPARENTLY IT WAS
06:09:33.918 --> 06:09:35.386
A LITTLE BIT BEHIND. SO I
06:09:35.453 --> 06:09:36.120
APOLOGIZE IN MY TARDINESS AND
06:09:36.187 --> 06:09:38.389
GETTING ON. UM QUICKLY, MR VICE
06:09:38.456 --> 06:09:39.957
CHAIR MEMBERS. MY NAME IS ANDREW
06:09:40.024 --> 06:09:41.025
FIELDS AND I REPRESENTED THE
06:09:41.092 --> 06:09:42.860
TOUR COUNTY FIRST. FUNDING
06:09:42.927 --> 06:09:43.728
INNOVATIVE, RELIABLE AND SAFE
06:09:43.794 --> 06:09:45.830
TRANSPORTATION WERE GRASSROOTS
06:09:45.897 --> 06:09:46.731
COALITION THAT INCLUDES
06:09:46.797 --> 06:09:47.932
ORGANIZED LABOR, LOCAL
06:09:47.999 --> 06:09:49.500
BUSINESSES. CHAMBERS OF
06:09:49.567 --> 06:09:50.535
COMMERCE, ECONOMIC GROUPS,
06:09:50.601 --> 06:09:51.135
ENVIRONMENTALISTS, ENGINEERS,
06:09:51.202 --> 06:09:52.203
CITY MANAGERS AND LOCAL ELECTED
06:09:52.270 --> 06:09:55.706
OFFICIALS. SINCE 2015 OVER
06:09:55.773 --> 06:09:57.275
VARIOUS ITERATIONS. WE'VE
06:09:57.341 --> 06:09:58.609
SUPPORTED AN INCREASE IN FUNDING
06:09:58.676 --> 06:09:59.710
FOR CRUMBLING INFRASTRUCTURE
06:09:59.777 --> 06:10:01.612
SYSTEM AND OUR OVERBURDENED
06:10:01.679 --> 06:10:03.447
TRANSIT AGENCIES. I'M ONLY HERE
06:10:03.514 --> 06:10:05.016
TO ASK YOU TO ALLOW US TO
06:10:05.082 --> 06:10:07.318
PRESENT TO THE VOTERS OF INTER A
06:10:07.385 --> 06:10:08.486
COUNTY THE CHOICE OF WHETHER
06:10:08.553 --> 06:10:09.554
THEY'RE WILLING TO IMPOSE A TAX
06:10:09.620 --> 06:10:11.355
ON THEMSELVES. IN EXCHANGE FOR
06:10:11.422 --> 06:10:12.256
WHOLESALE TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM
06:10:12.323 --> 06:10:14.158
AND SAFETY IMPROVEMENT. I'M SURE
06:10:14.225 --> 06:10:14.992
STAFF HAS MADE YOU MADE SURE
06:10:15.059 --> 06:10:16.661
THAT YOU ARE ALL FAMILIAR WITH
06:10:16.727 --> 06:10:18.029
THE PREDICAMENT IN THE COUNTY
06:10:18.095 --> 06:10:19.330
WHEN ONE JURISDICTION REACHES
06:10:19.397 --> 06:10:20.831
THE 2% LOCAL SALES TAX CAP,
06:10:20.898 --> 06:10:22.099
THERE IS NO MORE ABILITY TO
06:10:22.166 --> 06:10:23.167
COLLECT FUNDING FOR OTHER AREAS
06:10:23.234 --> 06:10:25.403
OF IMPORTANCE. WE'RE NOT ASKING
06:10:25.469 --> 06:10:26.704
YOU TO RAISE TAXES, JUST AS WE
06:10:26.771 --> 06:10:28.706
DID NOT ASK THE BOARD OF
06:10:28.773 --> 06:10:31.075
SUPERVISORS TO RAISE TAXES WHEN
06:10:31.142 --> 06:10:31.542
THEY VOTED TO REQUEST
06:10:31.609 --> 06:10:32.176
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BENNETT KERRY A
06:10:32.243 --> 06:10:35.179
V 24 53, WHICH THEY DID WITH
06:10:35.246 --> 06:10:37.448
OVERWHELMING BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
06:10:37.515 --> 06:10:39.083
AND WITH GUSTO. WE'RE SIMPLY
06:10:39.150 --> 06:10:40.451
ASKING YOU TODAY TO AUTHORIZE
06:10:40.518 --> 06:10:42.186
THE CITIZENS TO VOTE ON THIS ONE
06:10:42.253 --> 06:10:44.121
VERY SPECIFIC ISSUE WITH A VERY
06:10:44.188 --> 06:10:45.189
SPECIFIC CAPITAL LEAF NUMBER OF
06:10:45.256 --> 06:10:47.558
ONE HALF OF 1. TO BE USED SOLELY
06:10:47.625 --> 06:10:49.260
FOR THE PURPOSES SET FORWARD AND
06:10:49.327 --> 06:10:50.561
PUBLICLY CREATED AND VETTED
06:10:50.628 --> 06:10:51.429
TRANSPORTATION EXPENDITURE
06:10:51.495 --> 06:10:53.965
PLANS. AS YOU WELL KNOW, THIS
06:10:54.031 --> 06:10:55.633
TYPE OF CAP RELIEF HAS BEEN DONE
06:10:55.700 --> 06:10:57.435
A NUMBER OF TIMES IN THE PAST,
06:10:57.501 --> 06:10:58.169
ALWAYS WITH THE UNDERSTANDING
06:10:58.235 --> 06:10:59.971
THAT IF THE COUNTY SUPPORTS THE
06:11:00.037 --> 06:11:01.439
ITEM, IT CAN BE LEFT TO THE
06:11:01.505 --> 06:11:02.974
COUNTY TO IMPLEMENT IT, BUT
06:11:03.040 --> 06:11:04.241
ALWAYS ALLOWS THE CITIZENS OF
06:11:04.308 --> 06:11:05.142
THE COUNTY TO MAKE THE
06:11:05.209 --> 06:11:06.210
DETERMINATION FOR THEMSELVES.
06:11:06.277 --> 06:11:07.411
AND THAT'S CERTAINLY THE CASE
06:11:07.478 --> 06:11:08.446
HERE. OUR COMMITTEE HAS
06:11:08.512 --> 06:11:09.180
PERFORMED PUBLIC OPINION
06:11:09.246 --> 06:11:10.748
RESEARCH TWICE OVER THE LAST 12
06:11:10.815 --> 06:11:13.084
MONTHS AND AS RECENTLY AS TWO
06:11:13.150 --> 06:11:13.751
MONTHS AGO AMIDST NEWS OF
06:11:13.818 --> 06:11:16.287
SOARING GAS PRICES AND RAMPANT
06:11:16.354 --> 06:11:16.854
INFLATION, THAT PEOPLE HAVE
06:11:16.921 --> 06:11:18.022
INTERCOUNTY OVERWHELMINGLY
06:11:18.089 --> 06:11:19.290
SUPPORT MOVING FORWARD WITH THE
06:11:19.357 --> 06:11:20.524
MEANS TO FIX OUR TRANSPORTATION
06:11:20.591 --> 06:11:22.927
SYSTEM. IN ADDITION TO THE
06:11:22.994 --> 06:11:23.995
CITIZENS OF INTER ACCOUNT WOULD
06:11:24.061 --> 06:11:25.096
LIKE TO REITERATE THE AMOUNT OF
06:11:25.162 --> 06:11:26.497
PROMINENT ORGANIZATIONAL SUPPORT
06:11:26.564 --> 06:11:29.000
. WE HAVE MAYBE 24 53 TO NAME A
06:11:29.066 --> 06:11:30.568
FEW. THIS INCLUDES ORGANIZED
06:11:30.635 --> 06:11:31.535
LABOR, SUCH AS THE LABORERS,
06:11:31.602 --> 06:11:33.638
OPERATING ENGINEERS, CARPENTERS
06:11:33.704 --> 06:11:34.705
, THE REBUILD SOCIAL PARTNERSHIP
06:11:34.772 --> 06:11:35.873
. LOCAL BUSINESSES SUCH AS MINOR
06:11:35.940 --> 06:11:37.942
FILTRATION FOR RECONSTRUCTION.
06:11:38.009 --> 06:11:39.176
BOYS CONSTRUCTION MNS
06:11:39.243 --> 06:11:41.178
ENGINEERING W SP, THE 2020
06:11:41.245 --> 06:11:42.747
NETWORK, THE COUNTY BOARD OF
06:11:42.813 --> 06:11:43.881
SUPERVISORS, AS WELL AS THE
06:11:43.948 --> 06:11:45.349
NUMBER OF OTHER LOCAL ELECTED
06:11:45.416 --> 06:11:47.685
OFFICIALS. WE WANT TO THANK
06:11:47.752 --> 06:11:48.419
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BRANDED
06:11:48.486 --> 06:11:50.354
PROFUSELY FOR CARRYING THIS BILL
06:11:50.421 --> 06:11:52.056
THAT WILL ALLOW US THE
06:11:52.123 --> 06:11:52.757
OPPORTUNITY TO BRING TO THE
06:11:52.823 --> 06:11:53.924
VOTERS A CHOICE AND TO PRACTICE
06:11:53.991 --> 06:11:55.626
THE ULTIMATE FORM OF DEMOCRACY
06:11:55.693 --> 06:11:56.694
AND LET THEM DECIDE. THANK YOU
06:11:56.761 --> 06:11:57.795
VERY MUCH BIGGER AND AGAIN, WE
06:11:57.862 --> 06:11:59.730
URGE A VOTE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
06:11:59.797 --> 06:12:04.168
TESTIMONY. DO WE HAVE ANYONE
06:12:04.235 --> 06:12:05.970
ADDITIONAL ON ON CUE FOR
06:12:06.037 --> 06:12:06.771
SUPPORTIVE TESTIMONY. MODERATOR,
06:12:06.837 --> 06:12:11.609
NONE. OKAY DO WE HAVE ANY
06:12:11.676 --> 06:12:15.613
OPPOSITION AND QUÊ? FURTHER.
06:12:15.680 --> 06:12:20.618
HEARING NUTS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
06:12:20.685 --> 06:12:23.220
WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE US A
06:12:23.287 --> 06:12:24.188
CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY ASKED FOR AN
06:12:24.255 --> 06:12:26.090
I VOTE. OKAY, VERY GOOD.
06:12:26.157 --> 06:12:28.426
ANYTHING SENATOR ROSCOE, JUST
06:12:28.492 --> 06:12:30.361
MOVE THE BILL. OKAY? I THOUGHT
06:12:30.428 --> 06:12:31.729
WE ALREADY HAD THE MOTION, BUT
06:12:31.796 --> 06:12:33.864
WE HAVE THE BILL MOVED AND WE
06:12:33.931 --> 06:12:36.300
WILL PROCEED WITH THE ROLL CALL.
06:12:36.367 --> 06:12:37.902
MOTION IS TO PASSTO THE SENATE
06:12:37.968 --> 06:12:40.538
FLOOR. SENATORS CABALLERO
06:12:40.604 --> 06:12:42.907
NILSSON, NILSSON, NO, DURAZO.
06:12:42.973 --> 06:12:50.147
AYE, HERTZBERG WIENER. 2211.
06:12:50.214 --> 06:12:51.649
WE'VE GOT A LOT OF MEMBERS IN
06:12:51.716 --> 06:12:53.017
AND OUT, BUT THEY'LL ALL BE HERE
06:12:53.084 --> 06:12:53.984
EVENTUALLY. I'M SURE
06:12:54.051 --> 06:12:55.419
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S DO YOU NOT TO
06:12:55.486 --> 06:12:58.322
WANT TO BRING UP THE 21. IF I
06:12:58.389 --> 06:13:00.257
COULD. I HAVE THREE BILLS I'M
06:13:00.324 --> 06:13:02.193
SUPPOSED TO PRESENT YOU NAME
06:13:02.259 --> 06:13:02.993
OTHER BILL I'M SUPPOSED TO
06:13:03.060 --> 06:13:05.262
PRESENT IS THE ROBERT REVIS BILL
06:13:05.329 --> 06:13:08.966
A B 24 42. THAT IS ALSO QUICKER
06:13:09.033 --> 06:13:10.901
BILL. IF I COULD DO THAT, BILL,
06:13:10.968 --> 06:13:12.269
PLEASE, OF COURSE, RIGHT. THANK
06:13:12.336 --> 06:13:14.905
YOU VERY MUCH, MR CHAIR AND
06:13:14.972 --> 06:13:17.374
MEMBERS AND PRESENTING A B 24 42
06:13:17.441 --> 06:13:18.809
ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
06:13:18.876 --> 06:13:20.978
ROBERT REVIS BEFORE WE AGAIN I
06:13:21.045 --> 06:13:21.846
JUST WANT TO NOTE THAT
06:13:21.912 --> 06:13:22.947
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S REVIS WILL BE
06:13:23.013 --> 06:13:25.049
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEES.
06:13:25.116 --> 06:13:27.351
RECOMMENDATIONS TO DELETE
06:13:27.418 --> 06:13:29.320
SECTION THREE OF THE BILL. MAYBE
06:13:29.386 --> 06:13:31.622
24 42 SEEKS TO CLEARLY DEFINE
06:13:31.689 --> 06:13:33.424
CLIMATE CHANGE AS A DISASTER
06:13:33.491 --> 06:13:34.425
UNDER THE CALIFORNIA DISASTER
06:13:34.492 --> 06:13:36.193
ASSISTANCE ACT. THIS ENABLES
06:13:36.260 --> 06:13:38.129
BETTER INTEGRATION OF CLIMATE
06:13:38.195 --> 06:13:39.230
MITIGATION AND ADAPTION PLANNING
06:13:39.296 --> 06:13:40.131
AT BOTH THE STATE AND LOCAL
06:13:40.197 --> 06:13:42.233
LEVELS. CURRENT LAWS
06:13:42.299 --> 06:13:43.100
INCONSISTENT AS TO WHETHER
06:13:43.167 --> 06:13:44.635
CLIMATE CHANGE IS A DISASTER
06:13:44.702 --> 06:13:46.103
UNTO ITSELF, OR SIMPLY A
06:13:46.170 --> 06:13:47.271
MODIFIER OF EXISTING HAZARDS
06:13:47.338 --> 06:13:50.641
LIKE FIRES AND FLOODS. A B 24 42
06:13:50.708 --> 06:13:52.443
CLARIFIES THAT CLIMATE CHANGE IS
06:13:52.510 --> 06:13:54.044
ITSELF A DISASTER AS WELL AS A
06:13:54.111 --> 06:13:56.213
HAZARD MODIFIER AND MAKES IT
06:13:56.280 --> 06:13:57.548
EASIER FOR STATE AND LOCAL
06:13:57.615 --> 06:13:58.816
GOVERNMENTS TO TAKE A MORE
06:13:58.883 --> 06:13:59.884
HOLISTIC APPROACH TO REDUCING
06:13:59.950 --> 06:14:00.751
CLIMATE RISK. RATHER THAN
06:14:00.818 --> 06:14:01.786
TACKLING CLIMATE IMPACTS, ONE AT
06:14:01.852 --> 06:14:04.488
A TIME. THIS APPROACH COULD
06:14:04.555 --> 06:14:06.056
INCLUDE NATURE BASED SOLUTIONS
06:14:06.123 --> 06:14:07.558
THAT PROVIDE MULTIPLE ADAPTIONS
06:14:07.625 --> 06:14:09.493
BENEFITS WHILE ALSO SEQUESTERING
06:14:09.560 --> 06:14:11.195
CARBON. THIS LEGISLATION COULD
06:14:11.262 --> 06:14:12.563
ALSO OPEN UP NEW DISASTER
06:14:12.630 --> 06:14:14.632
PREPAREDNESS FUNDING TO CAL O ES
06:14:14.698 --> 06:14:16.867
AND OUR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. AS
06:14:16.934 --> 06:14:18.969
WE KNOW CLIMATE CHANGE, AND AS
06:14:19.036 --> 06:14:19.937
MANY IMPACTS ARE THE GREATER
06:14:20.004 --> 06:14:21.338
GREATEST DISASTER WE'RE
06:14:21.405 --> 06:14:23.541
EXPERIENCING RIGHT NOW. MAYBE 24
06:14:23.607 --> 06:14:25.709
40 TO ALLOW STATE AND LOCAL
06:14:25.776 --> 06:14:27.144
GOVERNMENTS TO INCREASE THEIR
06:14:27.211 --> 06:14:28.179
CLIMATE RESILIENCE IN A MORE
06:14:28.245 --> 06:14:31.282
HOLISTIC WAY. WITH US TODAY TO
06:14:31.348 --> 06:14:34.285
TESTIFY IS LUCAS FREDERICKS OF
06:14:34.351 --> 06:14:35.986
THE NATURE CONSERVANCY.
06:14:36.053 --> 06:14:37.421
FREDERICKS WOULD YOU LIKE TO
06:14:37.488 --> 06:14:38.856
PROCEED WITH THE TESTIMONY?
06:14:38.923 --> 06:14:40.224
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND SENATORS
06:14:40.291 --> 06:14:41.759
THAT LUCAS FOREX I'M HALF THE
06:14:41.826 --> 06:14:43.260
NATURE CONSERVANCY. APPRECIATE
06:14:43.327 --> 06:14:44.962
YOUR CONSIDERATION OF A B 24 42
06:14:45.029 --> 06:14:46.063
BY SOME OF THEM WERE
06:14:46.130 --> 06:14:48.465
ROBERT RIVAS. AS SOME MEMBER,
06:14:48.532 --> 06:14:49.967
BENNETT STATED IT WOULD DEFINE
06:14:50.034 --> 06:14:50.968
CLIMATE CHANGE AS A STANDALONE,
06:14:51.035 --> 06:14:53.003
HAZARDOUS PART OF STATE HAZARD
06:14:53.070 --> 06:14:54.104
MITIGATION POLICY. BETTER
06:14:54.171 --> 06:14:55.606
ENABLING INTEGRATION OF CLIMATE
06:14:55.673 --> 06:14:56.540
MITIGATION ADAPTATION, PLANNING
06:14:56.607 --> 06:14:57.741
AT THE STATE AND LOCAL LEVELS
06:14:57.808 --> 06:14:58.843
INSTEAD OF THE CURRENT SILENT
06:14:58.909 --> 06:15:01.111
PROCESS. IT WOULD ALSO ELEVATE
06:15:01.178 --> 06:15:02.780
AND INCENTIVIZE NATURE BASED
06:15:02.847 --> 06:15:04.148
SOLUTIONS THAT BOTH REDUCE
06:15:04.215 --> 06:15:06.016
EMISSIONS AND RISK AND COULD
06:15:06.083 --> 06:15:06.450
RESULT IN ADDITIONAL
06:15:06.517 --> 06:15:07.117
OPPORTUNITIES FOR FEDERAL
06:15:07.184 --> 06:15:08.085
FUNDING TO SUPPORT THESE
06:15:08.152 --> 06:15:09.854
ACTIVITIES AT THE PROPOSED
06:15:09.920 --> 06:15:11.922
CHANGES IN 24 42 ARE IN LINE
06:15:11.989 --> 06:15:12.890
WITH THIS GROWING TREND AMONG
06:15:12.957 --> 06:15:14.124
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. BOTH SANTA
06:15:14.191 --> 06:15:15.226
CRUZ COUNTY AND SAN FRANCISCO
06:15:15.292 --> 06:15:16.927
HAVE DONE THIS ALREADY. AND IT
06:15:16.994 --> 06:15:17.795
WOULD ENCOURAGE CONSISTENCY
06:15:17.862 --> 06:15:19.096
ACROSS THE STATE, AND IT COULD
06:15:19.163 --> 06:15:20.531
LEAD TO ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
06:15:20.598 --> 06:15:21.498
FROM THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
06:15:21.565 --> 06:15:22.900
SOURCES FORLOCAL COMMUNITIES
06:15:22.967 --> 06:15:23.634
FOR THEIR CLIMATE ADAPTATION
06:15:23.701 --> 06:15:24.235
MEASURES. RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
06:15:24.301 --> 06:15:25.870
YOUR VOTE ON A B 24 42. THANK
06:15:25.936 --> 06:15:29.039
YOU. THANK YOU. DO YOU HAVE A
06:15:29.106 --> 06:15:29.540
NETWORK? OTHER PRINCIPAL
06:15:29.607 --> 06:15:31.175
WITNESSES. WE SEE ANOTHER
06:15:31.242 --> 06:15:32.509
GENTLEMAN COMING FORWARD,
06:15:32.576 --> 06:15:34.178
PLEASE. OH, I KNOW THAT MAN. MR
06:15:34.245 --> 06:15:35.512
VICE CHAIR SENATOR ROGER
06:15:35.579 --> 06:15:37.381
DICKINSON ON BEHALF OF CIVIC
06:15:37.448 --> 06:15:38.515
WELL IN SUPPORT, THANKS. THANK
06:15:38.582 --> 06:15:41.185
YOU, SIR. AND THE OTHER
06:15:41.252 --> 06:15:48.993
SUPPORTIVE TESTIMONY BEFORE US.
06:15:49.059 --> 06:15:50.327
MODERATE OR ANY SUPPORT CALL IN
06:15:50.394 --> 06:15:55.900
TESTIMONY. IF YOU LATER SUPPORT
06:15:55.966 --> 06:15:57.735
THE BILL AT THIS TIME, PLEASE
06:15:57.801 --> 06:16:06.277
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY THE ZERO. AND WE DO HAVE LINE 5 70 TO 1
06:16:06.343 --> 06:16:10.147
MOMENT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. CN
06:16:10.214 --> 06:16:12.549
DIETRICH WITH 3 52 INTEREST
06:16:12.616 --> 06:16:14.285
COUNTY CLIMATE HUB AND VERY,
06:16:14.351 --> 06:16:15.519
VERY, VERY STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
06:16:15.586 --> 06:16:22.092
BILL. THANK YOU. QUÊ. THANK YOU.
06:16:22.159 --> 06:16:30.167
GO AHEAD. THERE ARE NO FURTHER
06:16:30.234 --> 06:16:31.769
LINES IN. Q ALL RIGHT. DO YOU
06:16:31.835 --> 06:16:33.570
HAVE ANY OPPOSITION WOULDN'T
06:16:33.637 --> 06:16:34.071
WANNA CALL TO OPPOSITION
06:16:34.138 --> 06:16:39.109
TESTIMONY. AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO
06:16:39.176 --> 06:16:40.511
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION, DEPRESSED
06:16:40.577 --> 06:16:46.583
ONE THAT ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE
06:16:46.650 --> 06:16:47.751
DO HAVE ONE QUEUED UP ONE
06:16:47.818 --> 06:17:03.934
MOMENT.
06:17:06.270 --> 06:17:10.708
AND THAT ONE IS FLYING. 7 59,
06:17:10.774 --> 06:17:15.312
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CHAIRMAN AND
06:17:15.379 --> 06:17:17.548
MEMBERS OF THE WESTERN STATES
06:17:17.614 --> 06:17:19.683
PETROLEUM ASSOCIATION. WE HAVE
06:17:19.750 --> 06:17:21.352
AN OPPOSING LESS AMENDED
06:17:21.418 --> 06:17:21.952
POSITION. WE LOOK FORWARD TO
06:17:22.019 --> 06:17:23.287
REVIEWING THE AMENDMENTS AND
06:17:23.354 --> 06:17:24.388
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THE
06:17:24.455 --> 06:17:26.590
AUTHOR. THANK YOU. OKAY AND IS
06:17:26.657 --> 06:17:28.559
THAT ALL WE HAVE IN QUÊ
06:17:28.625 --> 06:17:31.962
MODERATOR? THAT WAS THE ONLY ONE
06:17:32.029 --> 06:17:33.564
WE HAD ACCUSED. YES ALRIGHT,
06:17:33.630 --> 06:17:35.366
THEN, ON BEHALF OF SIMILAR
06:17:35.432 --> 06:17:36.800
MEMBER REVIS, WOULD YOU LIKE TO
06:17:36.867 --> 06:17:39.136
GIVE US A CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY
06:17:39.203 --> 06:17:40.471
ASTRONAUT VOTE, OKAY, WE HAVE
06:17:40.537 --> 06:17:43.974
EMOTION. SO HAS MOVED THE BILL.
06:17:44.041 --> 06:17:45.142
AND WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE
06:17:45.209 --> 06:17:48.579
ROLL? IS TO PASS THIS AMENDED,
06:17:48.645 --> 06:17:50.848
BUT FIRST MEANT AND WE REFER TO
06:17:50.914 --> 06:17:52.149
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
06:17:52.216 --> 06:17:54.785
SENATORS CABALLERO NILSSON,
06:17:54.852 --> 06:17:56.053
NILSSON, NO, DURAZO, SO I'M
06:17:56.120 --> 06:18:00.190
HERTZBERG. WIENER 11. THANK YOU.
06:18:00.257 --> 06:18:03.360
WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON.
06:18:03.427 --> 06:18:04.995
SOMEWHERE INVENT IT. WHICH WOULD
06:18:05.062 --> 06:18:07.031
BE THE NEXT YOU CHOOSE MY LAST
06:18:07.097 --> 06:18:08.832
BILL, AND IT'S THE LAST BILL FOR
06:18:08.899 --> 06:18:10.567
THE COMMITTEE. I THINK,
06:18:10.634 --> 06:18:11.568
HOPEFULLY BE DONE ENTIRE YEAR
06:18:11.635 --> 06:18:16.006
SENATE SESSION IS A B 22 OPEN.
06:18:16.073 --> 06:18:17.674
AND IT MAKES COMMON SENSE. UM
06:18:17.741 --> 06:18:21.078
CALIFORNIA TO ALLOW LOCAL AGENCY
06:18:21.145 --> 06:18:22.212
RESPONSIBLE FOR STOPPING OVER
06:18:22.279 --> 06:18:26.016
DRAFTING OF A BASIN. TO BE ABLE
06:18:26.083 --> 06:18:28.385
TO SIGN OFF ON NEW WELLS THAT
06:18:28.452 --> 06:18:30.254
COULD POTENTIALLY INCREASE THE
06:18:30.320 --> 06:18:32.222
OVER DRAFTING IN THAT BASIN AND
06:18:32.289 --> 06:18:34.691
HURT THE EXISTENCE AS WELL AND
06:18:34.758 --> 06:18:35.826
PARTICULARLY THE DISADVANTAGED,
06:18:35.893 --> 06:18:38.695
LOW IN PEACE. WHO HAVE
06:18:38.762 --> 06:18:40.564
VULNERABLE GIRLS WITH CLASS
06:18:40.631 --> 06:18:42.266
CHANGE AND WARMING TEMPERATURES
06:18:42.332 --> 06:18:44.368
FOR IN THIS WATER CRISIS IS
06:18:44.435 --> 06:18:45.836
LIKELY TO GET MORE SERIOUS AND
06:18:45.903 --> 06:18:47.671
MORE CHALLENGING IN THE FUTURE,
06:18:47.738 --> 06:18:49.339
NOT LESS SERIOUS AND LEFT
06:18:49.406 --> 06:18:51.775
CHALLENGING. DOING NOTHING IS
06:18:51.842 --> 06:18:53.444
SIMPLY NOT THE APPROPRIATE STEP
06:18:53.510 --> 06:18:55.746
FOR US TO TAKE AT THIS TIME.
06:18:55.813 --> 06:18:57.548
CALIFORNIA'S GROUND PROBATION
06:18:57.614 --> 06:18:58.882
HAVE UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS.
06:18:58.949 --> 06:19:00.517
THEY HOLD PRECIOUS WATER
06:19:00.584 --> 06:19:02.686
RESERVES THAT HAVE OFTEN BUILT
06:19:02.753 --> 06:19:04.121
UP OVER CENTURIES. THEY
06:19:04.188 --> 06:19:05.489
GENERALLY DO NOT CHARGE AS
06:19:05.556 --> 06:19:06.457
QUICKLY AS OUR SURFACE WATER
06:19:06.523 --> 06:19:10.527
FIRST. THE PUBLIC SITE, AND THEY
06:19:10.594 --> 06:19:14.298
HAVE FAR LESS THAN AND FAR LESS
06:19:14.364 --> 06:19:15.799
RARE, MANAGED OUR SURFACE WATER
06:19:15.866 --> 06:19:18.035
FLOWS THIS AMAZING VISION. WHY
06:19:18.102 --> 06:19:20.504
MANY OF OUR BASES SERIOUSLY OVER
06:19:20.571 --> 06:19:24.408
DRIFTED FOR YOU. THIS OVERDRAFT
06:19:24.475 --> 06:19:25.876
A PARADISE LONG VALUE OF THE
06:19:25.943 --> 06:19:30.447
BASINS. IN THE LONG TERM SYSTEM,
06:19:30.514 --> 06:19:32.049
AGRICULTURE AND THE LIVELIHOOD.
06:19:32.116 --> 06:19:34.751
VANTAGE FANS ARE EXTRACTING
06:19:34.818 --> 06:19:38.722
WATER FAR FASTER THAN IT IS. IN
06:19:38.789 --> 06:19:41.158
TWO SINCE IT'S LITERALLY A CASE
06:19:41.225 --> 06:19:44.027
OF A RACE TO THE BOTTOM. THE
06:19:44.094 --> 06:19:45.662
IMPACTS NEW WELLS AND OVER
06:19:45.729 --> 06:19:48.031
DRAFTED BASINS ONE THEY SIMPLY
06:19:48.098 --> 06:19:49.867
DRAW MORE WATER OUT OF A BASIN
06:19:49.933 --> 06:19:51.768
THAT'S ALREADY OVER DRAFTED.
06:19:51.835 --> 06:19:53.637
THEY POTENTIALLY HAVE NEGATIVE
06:19:53.704 --> 06:19:55.139
IMPACTS FOR NEIGHBORING WELLS,
06:19:55.205 --> 06:19:57.941
PARTICULARLY SHALLOW WELLS OF
06:19:58.008 --> 06:19:59.343
THESE DOMESTIC FARM WORKER
06:19:59.409 --> 06:20:00.577
COMMUNITIES THAT WERE WE'VE SEEN
06:20:00.644 --> 06:20:03.380
A NUMBER OF PROBLEMS WITH AND
06:20:03.447 --> 06:20:07.484
THESE NEW WELLS ONCE PERMITTED,
06:20:07.551 --> 06:20:10.254
UM ACQUIRE VESTED RIGHTS, AND
06:20:10.320 --> 06:20:12.156
THAT COMPLICATES ABILITY OF A G
06:20:12.222 --> 06:20:15.359
S A TO LEGALLY REGULATE THE WELL
06:20:15.425 --> 06:20:17.094
RATHER THAN JUST NOT HAVING THE
06:20:17.161 --> 06:20:19.363
WELCOME IN IN THE FIRST PLACE.
06:20:19.429 --> 06:20:22.566
GF PSAS ARE RESPONSIBLE TO END
06:20:22.633 --> 06:20:25.235
THE OVER DRAFTING OF BASINS THEY
06:20:25.302 --> 06:20:26.837
MUST FIND A DECREASED AMOUNT
06:20:26.904 --> 06:20:32.209
PUMPING. NO ABILITY TO STOP A
06:20:32.276 --> 06:20:34.811
GROUP OF PRIVATE YEARS. BANK.
06:20:34.878 --> 06:20:38.282
OUTSIDE THE AREA. DECISION BASED
06:20:38.348 --> 06:20:45.923
SO OR T<c.cyan>. HUNDREDS AND THIRSTY</c>
06:20:45.989 --> 06:20:50.527
SINK, DUST SPELLS AND PUMP IT,
06:20:50.594 --> 06:20:51.995
THAT'S WHAT THEY CAN VISION
06:20:52.062 --> 06:20:58.936
PLANE MAKING. INVESTMENT. DRY
06:20:59.002 --> 06:21:08.679
PART. ALL OF. SUFFER. IF WE WERE
06:21:08.745 --> 06:21:22.626
TO SAY TO EXPAND. THE OVER.
06:21:22.693 --> 06:21:27.598
MAYOREDLEE TO DO AND COUNT FOR
06:21:27.664 --> 06:21:37.441
TO THE WATER. AND. AND HERE.
06:21:37.507 --> 06:21:40.944
I'LL REMEMBER THAT. POWERFUL
06:21:41.011 --> 06:21:45.482
COURSE ONES THAT PROFIT FROM
06:21:45.549 --> 06:21:49.720
OVERDRAFT OF THE GROUND. THEY
06:21:49.786 --> 06:21:52.189
HAVE THE RESOURCES FROM THEIR
06:21:52.256 --> 06:21:53.590
PROFITS TO HIRE. GREAT
06:21:53.657 --> 06:21:56.026
REPRESENTATION BE HERE. AND A
06:21:56.093 --> 06:21:59.730
LOT OF STATE LEGISLATURE, WHICH
06:21:59.796 --> 06:22:01.965
IS WHY IT'S SO DIFFICULT TO GET
06:22:02.032 --> 06:22:03.433
WATER BILLS PASSED. TO REMEMBER
06:22:03.500 --> 06:22:05.769
THAT THE FARM WORKER COULD SEIZE
06:22:05.836 --> 06:22:07.070
, WHOSE WELLS HAVE RUN DRY
06:22:07.137 --> 06:22:10.007
NEARLY A FOUNTAIN WELLS AND DRY
06:22:10.073 --> 06:22:11.808
IN 2021 ALONE IN THE SAN JOAQUIN
06:22:11.875 --> 06:22:15.979
VALLEY. THOSE COMMUNITIES DON'T
06:22:16.046 --> 06:22:17.914
HAVE HIGH POWERED LOBBYISTS TO
06:22:17.981 --> 06:22:20.651
COME IN LOBBY YESTERDAY. THE
06:22:20.717 --> 06:22:22.753
SMALL FARMERS, THE FUTURE
06:22:22.819 --> 06:22:25.355
GENERATIONS THAT RELY ON US TO
06:22:25.422 --> 06:22:26.590
ADDRESS THIS OVER DRAFTING
06:22:26.657 --> 06:22:28.825
PROBLEM. THEY DON'T HAVE
06:22:28.892 --> 06:22:29.526
LOBBYISTS AND SACRAMENTO TO
06:22:29.593 --> 06:22:33.397
MATCH THE POWERFUL VOICE VOICES.
06:22:33.463 --> 06:22:36.033
POSITION. SO AS THIS BILL HAS
06:22:36.099 --> 06:22:39.069
MOVED, I REMAINED OPEN TO EVERY
06:22:39.136 --> 06:22:41.438
REASONABLE SUGGESTION. TRY TO
06:22:41.505 --> 06:22:42.773
MAKE SURE THAT THE PERATIONAL
06:22:42.839 --> 06:22:48.011
PACKS OF THIS BILL. HAVE TAKEN
06:22:48.078 --> 06:22:50.314
AND WE ARE STILL OPEN TO TAKING
06:22:50.380 --> 06:22:52.149
MANY AMENDMENTS THAT IMPROVE THE
06:22:52.215 --> 06:22:53.150
OPERATIONAL ASPECTS OF THIS
06:22:53.216 --> 06:22:57.187
BILL. BUT THE ARGUMENT FROM
06:22:57.254 --> 06:22:59.956
THOSE WHO SIMPLY SAY WE WANT TO
06:23:00.023 --> 06:23:02.492
GUT THIS BILL WE DON'T WANT TO
06:23:02.559 --> 06:23:03.827
DO ANYTHING IS JUST NOT LOGICAL.
06:23:03.894 --> 06:23:07.197
YOU CAN'T FIND THE STRENGTH OF
06:23:07.264 --> 06:23:09.299
THEIR LOGIC IN THEIR ARGUMENT.
06:23:09.366 --> 06:23:11.335
UM THERE ARE ORIGINAL ARGUMENT
06:23:11.401 --> 06:23:12.703
WAS JUST FIXED AWAY LOCAL
06:23:12.769 --> 06:23:16.106
CONTROL AND IN FACT, THIS
06:23:16.173 --> 06:23:17.174
INCREASES LOCAL CONTROL IT, SAYS
06:23:17.240 --> 06:23:19.910
THE LOCAL GROUNDWATER AGENCY CAN
06:23:19.976 --> 06:23:21.745
SET ITS OWN RULES AND ITS OWN
06:23:21.812 --> 06:23:24.314
PLAN FOR DOING THIS. THEY HAVE
06:23:24.381 --> 06:23:25.649
NOW DROPPED THAT ARGUMENT, BUT
06:23:25.716 --> 06:23:26.983
THERE IS AN ATTEMPT TO THROW A
06:23:27.050 --> 06:23:28.618
LOTS OF OTHER CONFUSION AT THIS
06:23:28.685 --> 06:23:29.886
BILL AGAIN. WE'RE WILLING TO
06:23:29.953 --> 06:23:32.422
TAKE THOSE AMENDMENTS. THE
06:23:32.489 --> 06:23:33.990
AMENDMENTS THAT WE HAVE TAKEN
06:23:34.057 --> 06:23:36.727
HAVE ACTUALLY INCREASED THE
06:23:36.793 --> 06:23:38.829
SUPPORT SMALL FARMERS AND FROM
06:23:38.895 --> 06:23:41.398
SOME JEEPS ACE IN THE STATE OF
06:23:41.465 --> 06:23:44.201
IT WAS PEOPLE THOUGHT. WAS FIRST
06:23:44.267 --> 06:23:45.936
STARTED WITH THE BILL IN THE
06:23:46.002 --> 06:23:47.471
SENATE NATURAL RESOURCES
06:23:47.537 --> 06:23:50.607
COMMITTEE. THE BILL WAS AMENDED
06:23:50.674 --> 06:23:53.443
TO SHIFT THE RESPONSIBILITY FOR
06:23:53.510 --> 06:23:55.445
DOING THIS IS GOING TO IMPACT
06:23:55.512 --> 06:23:59.383
NEIGHBORHOOD OIL YES, A TWO
06:23:59.449 --> 06:24:01.551
PUTTING THE GOOD AMENDMENT AND
06:24:01.618 --> 06:24:06.123
G. APPRECIATED THAT I WANTED TO
06:24:06.189 --> 06:24:09.092
TAKE FULLY EXEMPT THE SHALLOWEST
06:24:09.159 --> 06:24:10.227
WELL, BECAUSE THE ARGUMENT WAS
06:24:10.293 --> 06:24:11.962
REALLY THAT MONTH AND OTHERS
06:24:12.028 --> 06:24:14.965
SIMPLY DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES.
06:24:15.031 --> 06:24:17.134
TO DO THAT KIND OF ANALYSIS, AND
06:24:17.200 --> 06:24:18.668
THAT ANALYSIS IS NOT AS
06:24:18.735 --> 06:24:20.504
IMPORTANT IF IT IS A SHALLOW
06:24:20.570 --> 06:24:21.905
WELL, THAT'S NOT LIKELY TO
06:24:21.972 --> 06:24:23.707
AFFECT THE BASIN LIKE THESE
06:24:23.774 --> 06:24:25.609
SUPER DEEP WELLS THAT HAVE BEEN
06:24:25.675 --> 06:24:26.676
DONE BY THESE BANKERS AND
06:24:26.743 --> 06:24:30.113
OTHERS. FIND THEM COMMITTED TO
06:24:30.180 --> 06:24:31.681
WORKING TO CLARIFY THE IMPACT OF
06:24:31.748 --> 06:24:33.683
EQUAL AND THAT THIS BILL'S
06:24:33.750 --> 06:24:36.553
INTENTION IS NOT TO TRIGGER A
06:24:36.620 --> 06:24:37.154
SEQUENCE SEQUENCE ANALYSIS OF
06:24:37.220 --> 06:24:42.893
THE BILL. YOU WILL. HEAR TODAY
06:24:42.959 --> 06:24:45.495
THAT WE DON'T NEED THIS BILL
06:24:45.562 --> 06:24:46.263
BECAUSE WE HAVE AN EXECUTIVE
06:24:46.329 --> 06:24:48.298
ORDER. STOP THE EXAM. IS PROOF
06:24:48.365 --> 06:24:57.374
IS STILL WE. AND. FOUR OF THAT
06:24:57.441 --> 06:25:00.610
WAS TO STOP RUN ON NEW WELLS AS
06:25:00.677 --> 06:25:02.412
THIS BILL WOULD BE MORE WORKING
06:25:02.479 --> 06:25:04.080
ITS WAY THROUGH THE LEGISLATIVE
06:25:04.147 --> 06:25:05.315
PROCESS AND NOT TAKE EFFECT
06:25:05.382 --> 06:25:06.917
UNTIL JANUARY OF 2023. WE COULD
06:25:06.983 --> 06:25:10.487
HAVE SEEN A HUGE INCREASE IN THE
06:25:10.554 --> 06:25:11.855
NUMBER OF WELL PERMITS TRYING TO
06:25:11.922 --> 06:25:14.658
GET IN BEFORE THIS. THIS BILL
06:25:14.724 --> 06:25:16.726
PASSED, SO THE GOVERNOR'S ORDER
06:25:16.793 --> 06:25:18.195
ACTUALLY COMPLEMENTS THIS BILL,
06:25:18.261 --> 06:25:20.263
BUT WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE IT IS
06:25:20.330 --> 06:25:23.700
TEMPORARY. IT IS NOT NUANCED. IT
06:25:23.767 --> 06:25:25.202
DIDN'T GO THROUGH THE PROCESS.
06:25:25.268 --> 06:25:26.002
THEY CAN'T KEEP TAKING THESE
06:25:26.069 --> 06:25:27.070
AMENDMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN
06:25:27.137 --> 06:25:28.905
OFFERED BY THE SOUS AND SOME
06:25:28.972 --> 06:25:30.407
OTHERS, AND IT WOULD BE A
06:25:30.474 --> 06:25:34.544
TRAGEDY. FOR US TO RELY ON A
06:25:34.611 --> 06:25:36.746
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER THAT
06:25:36.813 --> 06:25:37.714
MANY OF THE PEOPLE THAT ARE
06:25:37.781 --> 06:25:39.816
TRYING TO KILL THIS BILL HAVE
06:25:39.883 --> 06:25:41.651
INDICATED THAT IF THEY KILL THIS
06:25:41.718 --> 06:25:43.653
BILL, THE NEXT THING THEY'LL DO
06:25:43.720 --> 06:25:45.555
IS GO TO COURT TO TRY TO KILL
06:25:45.622 --> 06:25:47.023
THE EXECUTIVE ORDER. IF THEY
06:25:47.090 --> 06:25:47.924
CAN'T KILL THE EXECUTIVE WORD,
06:25:47.991 --> 06:25:49.926
THEY'LL WAIT. AND AS SOON AS WE
06:25:49.993 --> 06:25:51.027
HAVE SOME HEAVY RAIN, THEY WILL
06:25:51.094 --> 06:25:52.529
SAY THE DROUGHT IS OVER AND THE
06:25:52.596 --> 06:25:54.197
EXECUTIVE ORDER IT SHOULD BE
06:25:54.264 --> 06:25:57.934
LIFTED. AND IF THAT HAPPENS AND
06:25:58.001 --> 06:25:59.436
WE DON'T HAVE THIS BILL IN PLACE
06:25:59.503 --> 06:26:01.304
. YOU WE WILL BE BACK IN THE
06:26:01.371 --> 06:26:03.974
AREA OF HAVING A RUN ON THE NEW
06:26:04.040 --> 06:26:05.542
BILLS. SO FINALLY, I'D LIKE TO
06:26:05.609 --> 06:26:08.078
ASK YOU TO IMAGINE WHAT WOULD BE
06:26:08.144 --> 06:26:09.212
HAPPENING IF THIS WAS SURFACE
06:26:09.279 --> 06:26:12.015
WATER. IF THIS WAS A LOCAL
06:26:12.082 --> 06:26:14.384
RESERVOIR IF THIS WAS LAKE
06:26:14.451 --> 06:26:16.953
OROVILLE, RIGHT, AND INVESTMENT
06:26:17.020 --> 06:26:19.189
BANKERS WERE COMING IN AND
06:26:19.256 --> 06:26:20.690
DROPPING NEW PUMPS INTO A
06:26:20.757 --> 06:26:21.958
RESERVOIR THAT WAS AT HISTORIC
06:26:22.025 --> 06:26:25.061
LOWS. AND SAYING, WE WANT TO
06:26:25.128 --> 06:26:27.264
TAKE SOME MORE WATER. THERE
06:26:27.330 --> 06:26:28.131
WOULD BE ENORMOUS OUTRAGE IF IT
06:26:28.198 --> 06:26:29.533
WAS SURFACE WATER, AND EVERYONE
06:26:29.599 --> 06:26:31.835
COULD SEE THAT, UM, THAT IS
06:26:31.902 --> 06:26:33.069
WHAT'S HAPPENING WITH THESE
06:26:33.136 --> 06:26:36.673
GROUNDWATER WATER BASINS. SO I
06:26:36.740 --> 06:26:40.944
IMPLORE YOU TO, UM, TAKE THIS
06:26:41.011 --> 06:26:42.812
OPPORTUNITY TO STEP UP AND
06:26:42.879 --> 06:26:44.915
PROTECT CALIFORNIA FROM A REALLY
06:26:44.981 --> 06:26:46.616
SERIOUS PROBLEM THAT CAN'T
06:26:46.683 --> 06:26:48.919
AFFORD TO BE DELAYED IN TERMS OF
06:26:48.985 --> 06:26:50.220
US TAKING APPROPRIATE
06:26:50.287 --> 06:26:51.121
LEGISLATIVE ACTION. THANK YOU
06:26:51.187 --> 06:26:54.624
VERY MUCH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TEST
06:26:54.691 --> 06:26:57.227
HIM WITH ME TO TESTIFY. I HAVE
06:26:57.294 --> 06:26:58.595
FORMER ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ROGER
06:26:58.662 --> 06:27:02.098
DICKINSON, WHO WAS PART OF THE
06:27:02.165 --> 06:27:04.434
SEQUEL ANALYSIS FOR THIS BILL.
06:27:04.501 --> 06:27:12.042
AND, UH, AND MR DICKINSON. NOW
06:27:12.108 --> 06:27:13.577
LEAVE IT TO YOU HERE. WELCOME
06:27:13.643 --> 06:27:14.477
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S DICKINSON.
06:27:14.544 --> 06:27:16.646
WELCOME BACK. THANK YOU, MR VICE
06:27:16.713 --> 06:27:18.982
VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I'M
06:27:19.049 --> 06:27:20.750
ROGER DICKINSON, POLICY DIRECTOR
06:27:20.817 --> 06:27:21.885
FOR CIVIC WELL, FORMERLY THE
06:27:21.952 --> 06:27:24.821
LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMISSION. AND
06:27:24.888 --> 06:27:26.456
WE'RE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A B
06:27:26.523 --> 06:27:28.425
22 OH, ONE FAMILY MEMBER.
06:27:28.491 --> 06:27:29.659
BENNETT HAS DESCRIBED THE
06:27:29.726 --> 06:27:31.494
CIRCUMSTANCES AS WELL. AND I
06:27:31.561 --> 06:27:34.297
WANT TO THANK HIM FOR HIS HIS
06:27:34.364 --> 06:27:34.931
LEADERSHIP AND FOLLOWING ON OUR
06:27:34.998 --> 06:27:37.334
LEGISLATION OF 2014. AS ONE OF
06:27:37.400 --> 06:27:41.171
THE AUTHORS OF SIGMA. I HOPE
06:27:41.237 --> 06:27:42.872
THAT LOCAL WELL PERMITTING
06:27:42.939 --> 06:27:44.941
AUTHORITIES AND THE ESAS WOULD
06:27:45.008 --> 06:27:47.277
WORK TOGETHER TO ENSURE THE
06:27:47.344 --> 06:27:49.346
PERMITS WERE ISSUED CONSISTENT
06:27:49.412 --> 06:27:50.580
WITH THE IMPLEMENTATION OF G SPS
06:27:50.647 --> 06:27:51.481
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:27:51.548 --> 06:27:55.352
PLANS. UNFORTUNATELY THAT HAS
06:27:55.418 --> 06:27:56.953
MOSTLY NOT HAPPENED AND THE
06:27:57.020 --> 06:27:59.189
PROLIFERATION OF NEW WELLS HAS
06:27:59.255 --> 06:28:01.191
CONTINUED TO SAP OUR GROUNDWATER
06:28:01.257 --> 06:28:02.392
AND IMPERIL ACHIEVING
06:28:02.459 --> 06:28:05.695
SUSTAINABILITY. A B 22 OH, ONE
06:28:05.762 --> 06:28:09.165
FILLS A GAP. IN MAKING SURE THAT
06:28:09.232 --> 06:28:10.166
JESUS WHICH HAVE THE
06:28:10.233 --> 06:28:12.035
RESPONSIBILITY OF IMPLEMENTING
06:28:12.102 --> 06:28:14.471
SIGMA AND CITIES AND COUNTIES
06:28:14.537 --> 06:28:16.272
ARE NOT WORKING AT CROSS
06:28:16.339 --> 06:28:17.907
PURPOSES TO THE DETRIMENT OF
06:28:17.974 --> 06:28:19.042
BOTH RESIDENTS. AND THE
06:28:19.109 --> 06:28:23.413
ENVIRONMENT. WE NEED TO MAKE
06:28:23.480 --> 06:28:23.913
GREATER COORDINATION AND
06:28:23.980 --> 06:28:26.316
ACCOUNTABILITY PERMANENT. SIGMA
06:28:26.383 --> 06:28:28.418
HAS A 20 YEAR IMPLEMENTATION
06:28:28.485 --> 06:28:29.619
TIMEFRAME TO REACH
06:28:29.686 --> 06:28:30.687
SUSTAINABILITY AND IT WILL BE
06:28:30.754 --> 06:28:34.057
CRUCIAL. TO MAINTAIN LINKAGE
06:28:34.124 --> 06:28:36.526
BETWEEN THE APPLICATION OF G S,
06:28:36.593 --> 06:28:38.728
P S AND THE ISSUANCE OF WELL
06:28:38.795 --> 06:28:40.363
PERMITS OVER THAT PERIOD AND
06:28:40.430 --> 06:28:41.898
BEYOND. HOPEFULLY OUR CURRENT
06:28:41.965 --> 06:28:44.567
DROUGHT WILL END. AND THE
06:28:44.634 --> 06:28:47.637
<c.blue>XECUTIVE ORDERWILL EXPIRE. BUT</c>
06:28:47.704 --> 06:28:49.506
THE CRITICAL NECESSITY TO
06:28:49.572 --> 06:28:50.173
CONNECT REACHING AND MAINTAINING
06:28:50.240 --> 06:28:52.976
SUSTAINABILITY. WITH THE
06:28:53.043 --> 06:28:54.144
ISSUANCE OF NEW WELL PERMITS
06:28:54.210 --> 06:28:58.114
WILL ENDURE. A B 22. OH, ONE
06:28:58.181 --> 06:29:00.216
DOES NOT CHANGE WHICH AGENCY
06:29:00.283 --> 06:29:01.951
MAKES DECISION. THE DECISION
06:29:02.018 --> 06:29:03.219
WHETHER TO ISSUE A WELL PERMIT,
06:29:03.286 --> 06:29:05.555
IT DOES NOT INTRUDE. ON THE
06:29:05.622 --> 06:29:06.990
AUTHORITY OR DISCRETION OF
06:29:07.057 --> 06:29:08.558
CITIES AND COUNTIES, WHICH GRANT
06:29:08.625 --> 06:29:11.561
PERMITS ONLY ENSURES THAT SUCH
06:29:11.628 --> 06:29:12.796
DECISIONS WILL BE MADE WITH MORE
06:29:12.862 --> 06:29:14.631
COMPLETE AND THOROUGH.
06:29:14.698 --> 06:29:16.032
INFORMATION INDISPENSABLE
06:29:16.099 --> 06:29:17.967
INFORMATION, I WOULD ARGUE. WE
06:29:18.034 --> 06:29:22.639
CANNOT AFFORD. TO FAIL TO ATTAIN
06:29:22.706 --> 06:29:23.239
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY FOR
06:29:23.306 --> 06:29:26.109
THE HEALTH OF OUR ENVIRONMENT.
06:29:26.176 --> 06:29:27.143
PERHAPS MORE IMPORTANTLY, FOR
06:29:27.210 --> 06:29:29.946
GENERATIONS TO COME. BUT WE
06:29:30.013 --> 06:29:32.048
CANNOT EXPECT THE ESAS WHICH
06:29:32.115 --> 06:29:32.849
HAVE BEEN GIVEN THE
06:29:32.916 --> 06:29:34.451
RESPONSIBILITY TO ACHIEVE
06:29:34.517 --> 06:29:37.854
SUSTAINABILITY TO SUCCEED. IF
06:29:37.921 --> 06:29:39.856
THEY HAVE LITTLE CONTROL OVER OR
06:29:39.923 --> 06:29:41.691
ABILITY TO INFLUENCE THE NUMBER
06:29:41.758 --> 06:29:42.692
AND LOCATION OF WELLS,
06:29:42.759 --> 06:29:45.895
EXTRACTING GROUNDWATER. A B 22.
06:29:45.962 --> 06:29:47.897
OH, ONE TAKES AN IMPORTANT STEP
06:29:47.964 --> 06:29:49.432
IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. AND I
06:29:49.499 --> 06:29:50.500
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND URGE
06:29:50.567 --> 06:29:53.036
YOUR I VOTE. THANKS. MAY I ASK A
06:29:53.103 --> 06:29:55.271
QUESTION ON THAT POINT? THE
06:29:55.338 --> 06:29:56.806
ORIGINAL LEGISLATION BY SENATOR
06:29:56.873 --> 06:30:02.178
PAVLE. IT. REMANDED THE
06:30:02.245 --> 06:30:04.280
DECISIONS TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT
06:30:04.347 --> 06:30:04.914
FOR THE SUSTAINABLE GROUNDWATER
06:30:04.981 --> 06:30:07.617
MANAGEMENT PLANTS, HOWEVER, ONE
06:30:07.684 --> 06:30:10.353
OF THE CAVEATS AT THAT TIME THAT
06:30:10.420 --> 06:30:11.888
I OBJECTED TO WAS THAT IF TH
06:30:11.955 --> 06:30:13.223
STATE DID NOT THROUGH THE BOARDS
06:30:13.289 --> 06:30:15.225
LIKE THE LOCAL PLAN, THEY COULD
06:30:15.291 --> 06:30:16.593
THEN ASSERT THE STATE AUTHORITY
06:30:16.659 --> 06:30:19.729
SUPERSEDING. AND NOW WE HAVE
06:30:19.796 --> 06:30:23.166
GOVERNORS AND I SAY GENERALLY,
06:30:23.233 --> 06:30:24.000
GOVERNORS AND PRESIDENTS
06:30:24.067 --> 06:30:28.471
GRIEVOUSLY. OVER UTILIZING
06:30:28.538 --> 06:30:29.773
EXECUTIVE ORDERS. SO WHAT'S
06:30:29.839 --> 06:30:33.810
LOCAL ABOUT THIS? WHAT IS A
06:30:33.877 --> 06:30:35.879
GRIEVOUS NEED AND DEFICIENCY AND
06:30:35.945 --> 06:30:38.214
EXISTING LEGISLATION AND
06:30:38.281 --> 06:30:39.048
SUSTAINABLE GROUNDWATER
06:30:39.115 --> 06:30:41.284
MANAGEMENT PLANS AND THE
06:30:41.351 --> 06:30:42.752
INVOLVEMENT OF THE STATE BOARD.
06:30:42.819 --> 06:30:44.821
WELL, RESPECTFULLY. THIS BILL
06:30:44.888 --> 06:30:45.855
ACTUALLY ADDRESSES WHAT'S
06:30:45.922 --> 06:30:47.891
HAPPENING AT THE LOCAL LEVEL AND
06:30:47.957 --> 06:30:48.992
LEAVES THE AUTHORITY TO MAKE
06:30:49.058 --> 06:30:51.861
DECISIONS. ABOUT WHETHER AND
06:30:51.928 --> 06:30:53.163
WHEN TO GRANT WELL PERMITS WITH
06:30:53.229 --> 06:30:56.299
LOCAL AUTHORITIES. SO WHAT IT'S
06:30:56.366 --> 06:30:57.801
SIMPLY DOES IT SAYS THAT
06:30:57.867 --> 06:30:58.802
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:30:58.868 --> 06:31:01.838
AGENCIES WILL BE ABLE TO HAVE
06:31:01.905 --> 06:31:04.574
THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW
06:31:04.641 --> 06:31:06.576
PERMITS TO COMMENT ON PERMITS TO
06:31:06.643 --> 06:31:09.479
THE PERMIT ISSUING AGENCY, WHICH
06:31:09.546 --> 06:31:11.080
IS GENERALLY GOING TO BE A
06:31:11.147 --> 06:31:12.315
COUNTY COULD BE A CITY IN SOME
06:31:12.382 --> 06:31:14.551
IN IN SOME CASES. SO IT REALLY
06:31:14.617 --> 06:31:17.287
IS ACTUALLY A WAY IN WHICH ONCE
06:31:17.353 --> 06:31:18.922
THE GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER
06:31:18.988 --> 06:31:21.858
EXPIRES, WHICH PRESUMABLY WILL
06:31:21.925 --> 06:31:25.395
HAPPEN SOMEDAY. THEN IT IT
06:31:25.461 --> 06:31:27.030
DEVOLVES AGAIN TO THE LOCAL
06:31:27.096 --> 06:31:29.232
LEVEL TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS IN
06:31:29.299 --> 06:31:30.967
THE BEST INTEREST AND WITH
06:31:31.034 --> 06:31:32.302
RESPECT TO THE CONDITIONS AND
06:31:32.368 --> 06:31:33.336
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT APPLY IN THE
06:31:33.403 --> 06:31:36.840
LOCAL AREA. BUT THE STATE BOARD
06:31:36.906 --> 06:31:38.808
IS NOT PRECLUDED NOW OR WOULD BE
06:31:38.875 --> 06:31:40.844
IN THE FUTURE OF THEN ASSERTING
06:31:40.910 --> 06:31:44.714
THEIR AUTHORITY. STATE THE STEP
06:31:44.781 --> 06:31:46.349
RESPECTFULLY, SENATOR THE STATE
06:31:46.416 --> 06:31:48.618
BOARD, THE STATE WATER BOARD CAN
06:31:48.685 --> 06:31:51.654
ONLY STEP IN TO, UH, LOCAL
06:31:51.721 --> 06:31:53.790
JURISDICTION. IF THERE'S A
06:31:53.857 --> 06:31:55.225
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:31:55.291 --> 06:31:56.826
AGENCY, WHICH DOES NOT COME UP
06:31:56.893 --> 06:31:58.261
WITH AN ADEQUATE PLAN, AS
06:31:58.328 --> 06:31:59.796
DETERMINED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF
06:31:59.863 --> 06:32:01.331
WATER RESOURCES, OR IF THEY
06:32:01.397 --> 06:32:06.002
SIMPLY REFUSE. NO I DON'T KNOW
06:32:06.069 --> 06:32:07.270
THAT WE'VE HAD ANY CASES OF
06:32:07.337 --> 06:32:09.038
REFUSALS WE'VE HAD. WE'VE HAD
06:32:09.105 --> 06:32:09.973
CASES WHERE THE DEPARTMENT OF
06:32:10.039 --> 06:32:12.141
WATER RESOURCES HAS SAID TO A
06:32:12.208 --> 06:32:13.543
LOCAL GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:32:13.610 --> 06:32:15.111
AGENCY. WE THINK THERE ARE
06:32:15.178 --> 06:32:15.778
THINGS YOU NEED TO ADDRESS THAT
06:32:15.845 --> 06:32:17.614
YOU HAVEN'T DONE SO SUFFICIENTLY
06:32:17.680 --> 06:32:20.149
YET IN YOUR PLAN. BUT BUT PLANS
06:32:20.216 --> 06:32:21.684
HAVE NOT YET BEEN DENIED OR
06:32:21.751 --> 06:32:23.553
TURNED DOWN AND IT'S ONLY IF
06:32:23.620 --> 06:32:26.723
THERE'S A FAILURE. AT THE LOCAL
06:32:26.789 --> 06:32:28.524
LEVEL THAT YOU COULD POTENTIALLY
06:32:28.591 --> 06:32:30.260
HAVE THE STATE WATER BOARD COME
06:32:30.326 --> 06:32:31.895
INTO PLAY, AND THAT WAS VERY
06:32:31.961 --> 06:32:34.030
INTENTIONAL. ON THE PART OF
06:32:34.097 --> 06:32:34.931
SENATOR PAVLE AND ME AND
06:32:34.998 --> 06:32:35.965
CRAFTING THE LEGISLATION AS WELL
06:32:36.032 --> 06:32:37.634
AS THOSE WHO SUPPORTED THE
06:32:37.700 --> 06:32:38.902
LEGISLATION. THAT THERE WAS A
06:32:38.968 --> 06:32:42.572
BACKSTOP. BUT WE WANTED WE
06:32:42.639 --> 06:32:44.941
WANTED LOCAL AGENCIES AND LOCAL
06:32:45.008 --> 06:32:46.976
COMMUNITIES TO TAKE THE
06:32:47.043 --> 06:32:48.044
RESPONSIBILITY AND MAKE THE
06:32:48.111 --> 06:32:49.579
DETERMINATIONS FOR THEIR OWN
06:32:49.646 --> 06:32:50.647
THEIR OWN CIRCUMSTANCES AND
06:32:50.713 --> 06:32:53.583
TERRITORY. I THANK YOU. THANK
06:32:53.650 --> 06:32:59.822
YOU. SUPPORTED WITNESSES. I SEE.
06:32:59.889 --> 06:33:02.225
AND MY SECOND MY SECOND WITNESS
06:33:02.292 --> 06:33:04.193
IS KYLE JONES FROM COMMUNITY
06:33:04.260 --> 06:33:06.663
WATER CENTER, PLEASE, MR JONES.
06:33:06.729 --> 06:33:07.931
GOOD AFTERNOON. KYLE JONES,
06:33:07.997 --> 06:33:08.831
POLICY DIRECTOR WITH COMMUNITY
06:33:08.898 --> 06:33:10.967
WATER CENTER IN STRONG SUPPORT
06:33:11.034 --> 06:33:13.369
OF ASSEMBLY BILL 201, SINCE
06:33:13.436 --> 06:33:14.504
SIGMA HAS PASSED 6200 WELLS HAVE
06:33:14.570 --> 06:33:18.341
BEEN DRILLED. IN THE STATE. AT
06:33:18.408 --> 06:33:21.277
THE SAME TIME, 4293 DRY WELLS
06:33:21.344 --> 06:33:22.345
HAVE GONE DRY, INCLUDING 462
06:33:22.412 --> 06:33:25.548
WELLS THIS YEAR ALONE. PART OF
06:33:25.615 --> 06:33:26.649
THE PROBLEM IS THAT THERE
06:33:26.716 --> 06:33:27.750
CONTINUES TO BE A RUBBER
06:33:27.817 --> 06:33:29.619
STAMPING OF PERMITS FOR NEW
06:33:29.686 --> 06:33:30.853
WELLS WITHOUT CONSIDERATION OF
06:33:30.920 --> 06:33:32.355
HOW THEY IMPACT SUSTAINABILITY
06:33:32.422 --> 06:33:34.657
OR OTHER USERS OF GROUNDWATER.
06:33:34.724 --> 06:33:35.858
ONE COMMUNITY FACING THIS THREAT
06:33:35.925 --> 06:33:37.894
RIGHT NOW IS THE COMMUNITY OF D
06:33:37.961 --> 06:33:38.995
QUARANTA, LARRY COUNTY. WE HAVE
06:33:39.062 --> 06:33:40.897
WORKED WITH THIS COMMUNITY FOR
06:33:40.964 --> 06:33:41.631
YEARS BECAUSE IT CONSISTENTLY
06:33:41.698 --> 06:33:42.765
STRUGGLED WITH ARSENIC AND
06:33:42.832 --> 06:33:44.901
NITRATE CONTAMINATION AND WORK
06:33:44.968 --> 06:33:46.369
TO GET AT $1.8 MILLION GRANT
06:33:46.436 --> 06:33:47.837
FROM PROP 50 TO GET THEM A NEW
06:33:47.904 --> 06:33:50.974
DEEPER WELL. THAT WAS DRILLED A
06:33:51.040 --> 06:33:52.542
COUPLE OF YEARS BACK. THAT WAS A
06:33:52.608 --> 06:33:54.711
2000 FT. WELL, I NOT A SHALLOW
06:33:54.777 --> 06:33:57.547
WELL AT ALL. AS OF RIGHT NOW, WE
06:33:57.613 --> 06:33:59.515
TALKED ON HOW TO CALL WITH THE
06:33:59.582 --> 06:34:00.683
PRESIDENT ON MONDAY THAT
06:34:00.750 --> 06:34:01.851
COMMUNITY WELL, HAS ALREADY
06:34:01.918 --> 06:34:02.852
STARTING TO LOSE PRESSURE
06:34:02.919 --> 06:34:04.454
BECAUSE THE COUNTY APPROVED A
06:34:04.520 --> 06:34:06.422
NEW AGRICULTURAL WELL ACROSS THE
06:34:06.489 --> 06:34:08.992
STREET. THAT WAS ALSO 2000 FT,
06:34:09.058 --> 06:34:10.360
DEEP, CAUSING ACCOUNT OF
06:34:10.426 --> 06:34:11.828
DEPRESSION THAT IS CAUSING THE
06:34:11.894 --> 06:34:14.630
COMMUNITIES WELL OF 600 PEOPLE
06:34:14.697 --> 06:34:16.299
TO LOSE ACCESS TO WATER, AND
06:34:16.366 --> 06:34:17.400
WE'VE SEEN WHAT HAPPENS WHEN
06:34:17.467 --> 06:34:17.967
COMMUNITIES LOSE ACCESS TO
06:34:18.034 --> 06:34:20.069
WATER. WE HAVE TO HAUL IN WATER
06:34:20.136 --> 06:34:22.405
TANKS FOR RESIDENTS. WE HAVE TO
06:34:22.472 --> 06:34:23.072
SET UP MOBILE SHOWERS AND PEOPLE
06:34:23.139 --> 06:34:24.340
LIVE IN CONDITIONS THAT FRANKLY,
06:34:24.407 --> 06:34:26.009
THEY SHOULDN'T BE LIVING IN THIS
06:34:26.075 --> 06:34:27.910
STATE. AND I WOULD NOTE THAT
06:34:27.977 --> 06:34:29.412
THAT ALL OF THESE EFFORTS HAPPEN
06:34:29.479 --> 06:34:31.748
ON STATE EXPENSE. SO ANY WORK
06:34:31.814 --> 06:34:33.883
THAT WE DO TO PASS THE SAFE AND
06:34:33.950 --> 06:34:34.784
AFFORDABLE DRINKING WATER FUND
06:34:34.851 --> 06:34:35.952
OR MOVE TOWARDS FULFILLING THE
06:34:36.019 --> 06:34:37.487
HUMAN RIGHT TO WATER CAN'T BE
06:34:37.553 --> 06:34:38.888
MADE IF WE CONTINUALLY PULLING
06:34:38.955 --> 06:34:39.822
THE RUG OUT FROM UNDER
06:34:39.889 --> 06:34:41.824
COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE VALLEY.
06:34:41.891 --> 06:34:43.993
MAYBE 2201 FIXES THIS PROBLEM
06:34:44.060 --> 06:34:45.028
REQUIRING ANALYSIS BEFORE HARM
06:34:45.094 --> 06:34:48.398
IS DONE. TO ENSURE THAT THOSE
06:34:48.464 --> 06:34:50.066
WHO ARE ACTUALLY CAUSING IMPACTS
06:34:50.133 --> 06:34:53.069
CAN BE HELD RESPONSIBLE. AND NOT
06:34:53.136 --> 06:34:54.070
THE COMMUNITIES AND IT'S IT
06:34:54.137 --> 06:34:56.606
WON'T BE THE JOB OF THE STATE TO
06:34:56.672 --> 06:34:58.608
HAVE TO COME IN AND PAY FOR THIS
06:34:58.674 --> 06:35:01.044
DAMAGE. WE WANT TO THANK THE
06:35:01.110 --> 06:35:02.612
WORK OF THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER ON
06:35:02.678 --> 06:35:03.713
GETTING THIS. MOVING THIS BILL
06:35:03.780 --> 06:35:05.648
AND CHAMPION THIS ISSUE AND
06:35:05.715 --> 06:35:07.383
REALLY WORKING TO MAKE SURE THAT
06:35:07.450 --> 06:35:09.118
WE HAVE SOMETHING THAT INCLUDES
06:35:09.185 --> 06:35:09.585
PUBLIC OVERSIGHT. AND
06:35:09.652 --> 06:35:12.155
ENFORCEMENT. WE BELIEVE THIS IS
06:35:12.221 --> 06:35:13.689
A STRONG BILL THAT WILL FILL THE
06:35:13.756 --> 06:35:15.591
GAP BETWEEN LAND USE AND SIGMA
06:35:15.658 --> 06:35:18.294
AND PREVENT SOME OF THE WORST
06:35:18.361 --> 06:35:19.429
IMPACTS THAT WE'RE SEEING ON THE
06:35:19.495 --> 06:35:20.830
GROUND. AND WE ARE DRIVE OUT
06:35:20.897 --> 06:35:21.964
TODAY. THANK YOU. HAVE ANOTHER
06:35:22.031 --> 06:35:24.700
WITNESS PRESENT. YOU ARE
06:35:24.767 --> 06:35:26.769
SUPPORTER. CORRECT I AM. I
06:35:26.836 --> 06:35:28.771
ACTUALLY AM A CHANGE OF
06:35:28.838 --> 06:35:29.739
POSITION. MICHAEL JARED ON
06:35:29.806 --> 06:35:31.507
BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY ALLIANCE
06:35:31.574 --> 06:35:32.842
WITH FAMILY FARMERS, UM WE WERE
06:35:32.909 --> 06:35:34.911
OPPOSING LESS AMENDMENT MENDED.
06:35:34.977 --> 06:35:37.380
BUT THANKS TO THE AUTHOR WHO IS
06:35:37.447 --> 06:35:38.147
COMMITTED TO TAKE AMENDMENTS TO
06:35:38.214 --> 06:35:39.449
PROTECT SMALL FARMERS WITH SHALL
06:35:39.515 --> 06:35:40.650
EXISTING WELLS. WE ARE NOW IN
06:35:40.716 --> 06:35:42.852
FULL SUPPORT OF THE BILL. UM,
06:35:42.919 --> 06:35:44.954
CALF REPRESENTS OVER 8000 SMALL
06:35:45.021 --> 06:35:46.889
MID SCALE FARMERS AND WE
06:35:46.956 --> 06:35:47.957
APPRECIATE THE AUTHORS
06:35:48.024 --> 06:35:50.059
WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH US AND
06:35:50.126 --> 06:35:51.160
HIS STAFF AND WE'RE NOW IN
06:35:51.227 --> 06:35:53.062
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. THANK YOU
06:35:53.129 --> 06:35:54.230
FOR YOUR TIME. TELL ME, SIR.
06:35:54.297 --> 06:35:56.199
WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE
06:35:56.265 --> 06:35:57.433
AMENDMENT THAT WOULD PROTECT
06:35:57.500 --> 06:35:57.967
SMALL FARMERS TO A HIGHER
06:35:58.034 --> 06:35:59.702
DEGREE. UM THE AMENDMENTS WOULD
06:35:59.769 --> 06:36:02.205
EXEMPT MAINTENANCE OF A WHILE IT
06:36:02.271 --> 06:36:03.739
WOULD EXEMPT MAINTENANCE OR
06:36:03.806 --> 06:36:06.275
REPLACEMENT OF A PUMP. IT WOULD
06:36:06.342 --> 06:36:08.010
, UH, ALSO EXCLUDE FROM THE NEED
06:36:08.077 --> 06:36:09.879
TO GET A PERMIT LOWERING THE
06:36:09.946 --> 06:36:12.682
CASING. OR EXTENDING OR
06:36:12.748 --> 06:36:15.451
REPLACING AN EXISTING WHILE THAT
06:36:15.518 --> 06:36:17.687
IS AT THE 15TH PERCENTILE OF
06:36:17.753 --> 06:36:19.822
DEPTH, SO THE SHALLOW WELLS THAT
06:36:19.889 --> 06:36:21.991
MANY OF OUR MEMBERS OWN THAT
06:36:22.058 --> 06:36:23.559
THEY PUT IN A LONG TIME AGO AND
06:36:23.626 --> 06:36:25.561
HAVE BEEN USING CONSISTENTLY FOR
06:36:25.628 --> 06:36:27.630
DECADES THAT WHEN THE GROUND
06:36:27.697 --> 06:36:29.866
WATER LEVEL GOES DOWN BELOW THAT
06:36:29.932 --> 06:36:31.100
THEY CAN EXTEND THEIR CASING TO
06:36:31.167 --> 06:36:34.470
KEEP FARMING. UM AND SO WE
06:36:34.537 --> 06:36:36.873
BELIEVE THAT SINCE NONE OF OUR
06:36:36.939 --> 06:36:37.940
MEMBERS ARE PUTTING IN NEW WELLS
06:36:38.007 --> 06:36:39.142
AND ARE ACTUALLY NEGATIVELY
06:36:39.208 --> 06:36:40.977
IMPACTED BY THE NEW WELLS THAT
06:36:41.043 --> 06:36:42.778
ARE OFTEN PUT AROUND THEM THAT
06:36:42.845 --> 06:36:44.447
THIS BILL WILL NOW STRIKE A GOOD
06:36:44.514 --> 06:36:45.715
BALANCE TO PROTECT SMALL FARMERS
06:36:45.781 --> 06:36:47.049
WHILE STOPPING BAD DRILLING
06:36:47.116 --> 06:36:48.918
PRACTICES. THANK YOU. YOU'RE
06:36:48.985 --> 06:36:50.019
WELCOME GENTLEMAN COMING
06:36:50.086 --> 06:36:54.657
FORWARD. HI BRIAN. THEY'RE
06:36:54.724 --> 06:36:55.758
JACKING WITH THE REGIONAL WATER
06:36:55.825 --> 06:36:58.127
AUTHORITY. UM REGIONAL WATER
06:36:58.194 --> 06:36:59.629
AUTHORITY IS ONE OF THOSE GS
06:36:59.695 --> 06:37:01.697
ASSESS THAT IS NOW IN SUPPORT
06:37:01.764 --> 06:37:04.033
CENTRAL VALLEY OR NO SACRAMENTO
06:37:04.100 --> 06:37:06.202
AREA. GREATER SACRAMENTO AREA.
06:37:06.269 --> 06:37:08.037
WE PROVIDE DRINKING WATER TO TWO
06:37:08.104 --> 06:37:09.172
MILLION PEOPLE IN THE GREATER
06:37:09.238 --> 06:37:11.073
SACRAMENTO AREA, SO PROBABLY
06:37:11.140 --> 06:37:12.542
MOST OF THE PEOPLE IN THE ROOM.
06:37:12.608 --> 06:37:15.545
UH WE'RE NOW IN SUPPORT OF THE
06:37:15.611 --> 06:37:17.346
BILL BECAUSE WE THINK THAT THE
06:37:17.413 --> 06:37:19.081
STRUCTURE IN THE BILL PUTS THE
06:37:19.148 --> 06:37:19.682
RESPONSIBILITIES IN THE RIGHT
06:37:19.749 --> 06:37:22.418
PLACES OBVIOUSLY WOULD LIKETO
06:37:22.485 --> 06:37:24.086
SEE THE BILL MOVE FORWARD
06:37:24.153 --> 06:37:24.820
BECAUSE OF THOSE REASONS AND
06:37:24.887 --> 06:37:26.022
LOOK FORWARD TO FURTHER
06:37:26.088 --> 06:37:26.956
DEVELOPMENTS WITH THE BILL.
06:37:27.023 --> 06:37:30.226
THANK YOU. MODERATOR DO WE HAVE
06:37:30.293 --> 06:37:32.395
ANY? WOULD YOU INVITE PEOPLE TO
06:37:32.461 --> 06:37:35.031
GET ANOTHER ONE? PLEASE COME ON.
06:37:35.097 --> 06:37:37.300
HIGH CALIBER ON BEHALF OF THE
06:37:37.366 --> 06:37:38.467
WATER FOUNDATION, FORMER STATE
06:37:38.534 --> 06:37:41.003
SENATOR AND SIGMA AUTHOR FRAN
06:37:41.070 --> 06:37:41.804
PAVLEY MONAURAL A COMMITTEE
06:37:41.871 --> 06:37:44.073
AMERICAN RIVERS, THE UNION OF
06:37:44.140 --> 06:37:45.908
CONCERNED SCIENTISTS, CALIFORNIA
06:37:45.975 --> 06:37:47.777
AND NRDC IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
06:37:47.843 --> 06:37:51.480
B 2201. THANK YOU. MODERATOR CAN
06:37:51.547 --> 06:37:53.216
YOU INVITE ANY CALLING
06:37:53.282 --> 06:37:57.787
PARTICIPANTS IN SUPPORT? SURE IF
06:37:57.853 --> 06:37:59.555
YOU WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
06:37:59.622 --> 06:38:00.690
SUPPORT OF THE BILL, PLEASE
06:38:00.756 --> 06:38:02.491
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY THE ZERO
06:38:02.558 --> 06:38:04.293
AT THIS TIME. F FIRST FORWARD
06:38:04.360 --> 06:38:09.365
ALLIANCE. 7 65, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
06:38:09.432 --> 06:38:10.733
HELLO. TURN MEMBERS. AMBER WAS
06:38:10.800 --> 06:38:12.368
THREATENED PRICE CONSULTED ON
06:38:12.435 --> 06:38:13.603
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
06:38:13.669 --> 06:38:14.637
ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS IN SUPPORT
06:38:14.704 --> 06:38:19.542
OF 82 2. OH, ONE. THANK YOU.
06:38:19.609 --> 06:38:20.843
NEXT WE HAVE LINE 5 72, PLEASE
06:38:20.910 --> 06:38:25.581
GO AHEAD. STAND. DIETRICH OUR
06:38:25.648 --> 06:38:28.184
1200 MEMBERS OF THE 3 54
06:38:28.251 --> 06:38:30.486
COUNTIES HAVE JOINED THOSE DEREK
06:38:30.553 --> 06:38:33.422
CLUB AND SUPPORT OF A B 20. NO.
06:38:33.489 --> 06:38:34.590
ONE IT'S OBVIOUS THAT GSA'S NEED
06:38:34.657 --> 06:38:36.359
THIS TO MAKE SICK MY WORK. THANK
06:38:36.425 --> 06:38:45.201
YOU. NEXT WE GO TO LINE 7 56.
06:38:45.268 --> 06:38:47.169
THANK YOU. THIS IS BRIAN SHOW ON
06:38:47.236 --> 06:38:48.371
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CLIMATE
06:38:48.437 --> 06:38:49.705
AND AGRICULTURE NETWORK AND
06:38:49.772 --> 06:38:51.340
SEVEN COALITION MEMBERS. WE ARE
06:38:51.407 --> 06:38:52.508
NOW WITH THE AMENDMENTS. THE
06:38:52.575 --> 06:38:54.176
AUTHORS AGREED TO THANK YOU.
06:38:54.243 --> 06:39:05.087
THANK YOU. IN LINE 7 32. FIND 7
06:39:05.154 --> 06:39:09.859
30 TO YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
06:39:09.925 --> 06:39:11.327
AFTERNOON. THIS IS MICHAEL
06:39:11.394 --> 06:39:12.061
CLAIBORNE WITH LEADERSHIP
06:39:12.128 --> 06:39:13.496
ACCOUNT COUNCIL FOR JUSTICE AND
06:39:13.562 --> 06:39:14.063
ACCOUNTABILITY AND SUPPORT.
06:39:14.130 --> 06:39:18.801
THANK YOU. AND WITH THAT WE HAVE
06:39:18.868 --> 06:39:20.703
NO FURTHER LINE. THANK YOU.
06:39:20.770 --> 06:39:21.771
RIGHT. WOULD YOU INVITE ANY
06:39:21.837 --> 06:39:25.474
OPPOSITION? TO PRESENT THEIR
06:39:25.541 --> 06:39:27.043
POINT OF VIEW. YOU WON. WE WON
06:39:27.109 --> 06:39:30.813
ONE SPEAKER HERE IN PRESENT. UM
06:39:30.880 --> 06:39:32.581
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
06:39:32.648 --> 06:39:34.450
BOB RIEBE WITH REED GOVERNMENT
06:39:34.517 --> 06:39:36.085
RELATIONS, TESTIFYING TODAY ON
06:39:36.152 --> 06:39:37.486
BEHALF OF THE VALLEY OG WATER
06:39:37.553 --> 06:39:39.989
COALITION, WHICH CONSISTS OF 43
06:39:40.056 --> 06:39:41.457
, AGRICULTURAL WATER SUPPLIERS
06:39:41.524 --> 06:39:43.559
AND THE SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY, ALL
06:39:43.626 --> 06:39:44.527
OF WHOM ARE MEMBERS OF
06:39:44.593 --> 06:39:45.528
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:39:45.594 --> 06:39:47.330
AGENCIES AND WHO ARE OPPOSED TO
06:39:47.396 --> 06:39:51.500
THIS LEGISLATION. BY MEANS OF
06:39:51.567 --> 06:39:53.469
CONTEXT. MR CHAIRMAN, WE'RE IN
06:39:53.536 --> 06:39:55.805
THE MIDST OF A SEVERE DROUGHT.
06:39:55.871 --> 06:39:57.340
AND IT'S WELL ESTABLISHED FACT
06:39:57.406 --> 06:39:59.475
IN CALIFORNIA THAT WHEN WE HAVE
06:39:59.542 --> 06:40:01.210
A SEVERE DROUGHT IN CALIFORNIA,
06:40:01.277 --> 06:40:02.645
WE RELY MORE HEAVILY ON
06:40:02.712 --> 06:40:04.480
GROUNDWATER AND THAT GROUNDWATER
06:40:04.547 --> 06:40:07.717
TENDS THOSE LEVELS TEND TO DROP
06:40:07.783 --> 06:40:09.051
AND RECOVER WHEN WE GET INTO THE
06:40:09.118 --> 06:40:12.154
MORE WETTER PERIODS. SO WE HAVE,
06:40:12.221 --> 06:40:13.789
AS HAS BEEN BEEN MENTIONED THE
06:40:13.856 --> 06:40:15.825
GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER WHICH
06:40:15.891 --> 06:40:16.359
SUBSTANTIALLY MIRRORS THE
06:40:16.425 --> 06:40:19.295
PROVISIONS OF THIS BILL. BUT
06:40:19.362 --> 06:40:21.330
LET'S BE CLEAR THE EXECUTIVE
06:40:21.397 --> 06:40:22.832
ORDER WHICH IS ISSUED WITHOUT
06:40:22.898 --> 06:40:24.967
STAKEHOLDER INPUT OR THE PROCESS
06:40:25.034 --> 06:40:25.935
, THE LEGISLATURE'S UNDERTAKING
06:40:26.001 --> 06:40:27.002
NOW HAS CREATED SIGNIFICANT
06:40:27.069 --> 06:40:30.706
CONFUSION. CONCERNED ABOUT
06:40:30.773 --> 06:40:32.508
LIABILITY EXPOSURE FOR THE
06:40:32.575 --> 06:40:33.976
PROFESSIONALS. ENGINEERS THAT
06:40:34.043 --> 06:40:36.212
LOOK AT THESE FOR THE JEEP DAYS
06:40:36.278 --> 06:40:38.280
AND FOR THE COUNTIES, AND IT
06:40:38.347 --> 06:40:39.582
REMINDS ME OF THE CHILDHOOD GAME
06:40:39.648 --> 06:40:40.683
THAT WE PLAYED CALLED HOT
06:40:40.750 --> 06:40:43.352
POTATO. AND SOME OF THESE
06:40:43.419 --> 06:40:43.986
COUNTIES. THERE HASN'T BEEN A
06:40:44.053 --> 06:40:46.088
NEW WELL APPROVED SINCE APRIL,
06:40:46.155 --> 06:40:48.924
WHEN THIS ORDER WAS ISSUED. NOW,
06:40:48.991 --> 06:40:50.760
LET ME JUST SAY THAT THE
06:40:50.826 --> 06:40:52.828
LEGISLATURE AND ADMINISTRATION
06:40:52.895 --> 06:40:54.730
THANKFULLY ADMINISTRATION THE
06:40:54.797 --> 06:40:55.965
BROWN ADMINISTRATION BEFORE IT
06:40:56.031 --> 06:40:57.767
HAS BEEN APPROPRIATING FUNDING
06:40:57.833 --> 06:40:59.935
TO ASSIST WITH THE SHALLOW WELLS
06:41:00.002 --> 06:41:01.270
ANDWITH THE COMMUNITY, SMALL
06:41:01.337 --> 06:41:03.706
COMMUNITY SYSTEMS. WITH
06:41:03.773 --> 06:41:05.007
CONNECTING THEM WITH LARGER
06:41:05.074 --> 06:41:06.175
SYSTEMS WITH DEEPENING WEALTH.
06:41:06.242 --> 06:41:09.011
AND WHAT HAVE YOU BUT WHAT WE
06:41:09.078 --> 06:41:10.813
HAVE HERE IS A MEASURE THAT IS
06:41:10.880 --> 06:41:12.681
AT BEST, UNTIMELY, GIVEN THE
06:41:12.748 --> 06:41:14.717
EFFECTS OF THE DROUGHT AND THE
06:41:14.784 --> 06:41:16.285
GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER, BUT
06:41:16.352 --> 06:41:17.353
MY CLIENTS WOULD ARGUE IS
06:41:17.420 --> 06:41:19.889
UNNECESSARY. LET'S BE CLEAR AND
06:41:19.955 --> 06:41:21.957
I WAS INVOLVED IN THE IN THE
06:41:22.024 --> 06:41:22.725
DRAFTING AND THE NEGOTIATIONS
06:41:22.792 --> 06:41:26.462
OVER SIGMA BACK IN 2014.
06:41:26.529 --> 06:41:28.364
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY.
06:41:28.431 --> 06:41:29.432
AGENCIES UNDER SIGMA HAVE
06:41:29.498 --> 06:41:31.834
AUTHORITY TO REGULATE
06:41:31.901 --> 06:41:33.369
GROUNDWATER WELLS. THEY CAN
06:41:33.436 --> 06:41:35.504
REGULATE SPACING THEY CAN
06:41:35.571 --> 06:41:36.639
REGULATE THE AMOUNT OF
06:41:36.705 --> 06:41:38.474
EXTRACTIONS THEY CAN EVEN
06:41:38.541 --> 06:41:40.543
REGULATE THE HOURS IN WHICH TO
06:41:40.609 --> 06:41:42.344
GROUNDWATER WELL IS OPERATED.
06:41:42.411 --> 06:41:45.414
THERE IS NO NEW NEED FOR
06:41:45.481 --> 06:41:47.183
AUTHORITY FOR JESUS TO DO THEIR
06:41:47.249 --> 06:41:49.318
JOB IN ORDER TO SEE THE
06:41:49.385 --> 06:41:50.119
SUSTAINABILITY GOAL AND FURTHER
06:41:50.186 --> 06:41:50.886
SIGMA SPECIFICALLY RECOGNIZES
06:41:50.953 --> 06:41:55.324
THAT. THERE WILL BE CHALLENGES
06:41:55.391 --> 06:41:57.159
AND ACHIEVING MAKING PROGRESS OF
06:41:57.226 --> 06:41:58.427
THE WAR, THE ACHIEVING THE
06:41:58.494 --> 06:42:00.463
SUSTAINABILITY GOAL IN TIMES OF
06:42:00.529 --> 06:42:01.697
DROUGHT, THE VERY TYPE OF TIMES
06:42:01.764 --> 06:42:05.968
WE'RE IN RIGHT NOW. LET ME SAY
06:42:06.035 --> 06:42:09.038
THAT THE BILL CURRENTLY WILL
06:42:09.104 --> 06:42:11.140
APPLY TO THE REPLACEMENT OF AN
06:42:11.207 --> 06:42:12.708
EXISTING WILL AND THE ALTERING
06:42:12.775 --> 06:42:15.110
EXISTING WELL, SO EVEN IF YOU
06:42:15.177 --> 06:42:17.079
HAVE A WELL THAT NEEDS TO BE
06:42:17.146 --> 06:42:18.814
DEEPENED, IF YOU'RE NOT, UM, EX
06:42:18.881 --> 06:42:19.648
, EXPANDING THE EXISTING
06:42:19.715 --> 06:42:22.818
SPECIFIC CAPACITY THAT WELL THIS
06:42:22.885 --> 06:42:24.854
BILL COVERS THAT, IN SOME AREAS
06:42:24.920 --> 06:42:26.455
OF CALIFORNIA HIGH SPEED RAIL
06:42:26.522 --> 06:42:27.756
AUTHORITY HAS BEEN PURCHASING
06:42:27.823 --> 06:42:30.059
LAND FOR THE RAIL LINE. SOME OF
06:42:30.125 --> 06:42:31.460
THOSE AG PROPERTIES HAVE
06:42:31.527 --> 06:42:32.695
EXISTING WELLS. WELL, WE'VE LOST
06:42:32.761 --> 06:42:35.998
THOSE WELLS. WE NEED TO REPLACE
06:42:36.065 --> 06:42:36.866
THOSE WELLS. THIS BILL WILL
06:42:36.932 --> 06:42:39.869
COMPLICATE THAT UNNECESSARILY.
06:42:39.935 --> 06:42:42.471
THIS BILL REQUIRES PROFESSIONAL
06:42:42.538 --> 06:42:45.040
TO PROVIDE A REPORT AS TO
06:42:45.107 --> 06:42:46.609
WHETHER PROPOSED NEW WELL WILL
06:42:46.675 --> 06:42:48.878
INTERFERE WITH EXISTING WELL OR
06:42:48.944 --> 06:42:50.479
LEAD TO SUBSIDENCE THAT WOULD
06:42:50.546 --> 06:42:53.082
IMPACT INFRASTRUCTURE. I'LL
06:42:53.148 --> 06:42:54.483
REMIND THE COMMITTEE THAT WE'VE
06:42:54.550 --> 06:42:56.619
HAD IN THE SAND, JOAQUIN VALLEY
06:42:56.685 --> 06:42:59.088
AND MANY AREAS SUBSIDENCE THAT'S
06:42:59.154 --> 06:43:01.757
BEEN OCCURRING FOR OVER 70 YEARS
06:43:01.824 --> 06:43:03.259
. HOW DOES ONE PROFESSIONAL
06:43:03.325 --> 06:43:05.728
DETERMINE WHETHER A NEW WELL A
06:43:05.794 --> 06:43:07.363
PROPOSED NEW? WELL NOT AN
06:43:07.429 --> 06:43:08.697
EXISTING? WELL, I PROPOSED NEW
06:43:08.764 --> 06:43:10.432
WELL WILL CAUSE DAMAGED FROM
06:43:10.499 --> 06:43:11.467
SOME SCIENCE TO EXISTING
06:43:11.534 --> 06:43:13.269
INFRASTRUCTURE. WHEN WE ALREADY
06:43:13.335 --> 06:43:17.139
HAVE THAT TODAY. HOW DOES A
06:43:17.206 --> 06:43:18.741
PROFESSIONAL DETERMINE WHETHER
06:43:18.807 --> 06:43:20.776
THERE WILL BE WELL INTERFERENCE
06:43:20.843 --> 06:43:22.545
FOR A WELL PERMIT? THAT'S NOT IN
06:43:22.611 --> 06:43:25.848
EXISTENCE. WE'RE HEARING FROM
06:43:25.915 --> 06:43:27.383
THE ENGINEERS DOWN THE SAN
06:43:27.449 --> 06:43:28.183
JOAQUIN VALLEY THAT THEY'RE
06:43:28.250 --> 06:43:29.451
CONCERNED WITH THEIR INSURANCE
06:43:29.518 --> 06:43:32.154
COMPANIES WON'T BE ABLE TO
06:43:32.221 --> 06:43:33.255
PROVIDE LIABILITY COVERAGE FOR
06:43:33.322 --> 06:43:35.491
THEM FOR THESE REPORTS. WE'RE
06:43:35.558 --> 06:43:36.492
HEARING THAT IT'S NEARLY
06:43:36.559 --> 06:43:37.760
IMPOSSIBLE TO MAKE THOSE
06:43:37.826 --> 06:43:39.695
DETERMINATIONS. AND SO UNDER THE
06:43:39.762 --> 06:43:41.797
CURRENT OPERATIONS, THE BILL, WE
06:43:41.864 --> 06:43:43.999
DON'T THINK THAT IT WILL ALLOW
06:43:44.066 --> 06:43:45.868
FOR ANY NEW WELLS TO BE DRILLED.
06:43:45.935 --> 06:43:50.139
LET ME CLOSE BY SAYING THAT. WE
06:43:50.205 --> 06:43:52.808
BELIEVE THAT THE COUNTIES AND
06:43:52.875 --> 06:43:54.476
THE JESUS ARE JUST NOW GETTING
06:43:54.543 --> 06:43:57.513
UNDERWAY AND IMPLEMENTING SIGMA
06:43:57.580 --> 06:43:59.648
. IN FACT, A LOT OF THE OF THE
06:43:59.715 --> 06:44:01.283
INITIAL REPORTS ARE STILL BEING
06:44:01.350 --> 06:44:03.085
REVIEWED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF
06:44:03.152 --> 06:44:05.220
WATER RESOURCES. THERE'S A LOT
06:44:05.287 --> 06:44:07.523
OF LAND FOLLOWING GOING ON.
06:44:07.590 --> 06:44:09.391
THERE'S A LOT OF WELLS THAT
06:44:09.458 --> 06:44:10.526
OBVIOUSLY HAVE BEEN IMPACTED,
06:44:10.593 --> 06:44:13.429
BUT WE HAVE TIME TO GET THIS
06:44:13.495 --> 06:44:15.364
SUSTAINABILITY GOAL UNDERWAY AND
06:44:15.431 --> 06:44:18.567
IT'S NOT THE STATE BOARD. YES
06:44:18.634 --> 06:44:19.568
THEY CAN INTERVENE IF A
06:44:19.635 --> 06:44:21.270
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABLY PLAN IS
06:44:21.337 --> 06:44:23.973
NOT ADOPTED, BUT THEY ALSO CAN
06:44:24.039 --> 06:44:25.874
INTERVENE IF EVERY FIVE YEARS
06:44:25.941 --> 06:44:27.977
THAT AGENCY IS NOT ABLE TO PROVE
06:44:28.043 --> 06:44:28.911
THAT IT'S MAKING PROGRESS
06:44:28.978 --> 06:44:31.480
TOWARDS ACHIEVING THE
06:44:31.547 --> 06:44:33.816
SUSTAINABILITY GOAL, SO THERE IS
06:44:33.882 --> 06:44:35.918
A BACKSTOP, AND IT'S ONE THAT
06:44:35.985 --> 06:44:37.686
NONE OF MY AGENCIES WHEN I EVER
06:44:37.753 --> 06:44:39.722
EXPERIENCED. THEY DON'T WANT THE
06:44:39.788 --> 06:44:40.889
STATE BOARD COMING IN MANAGING
06:44:40.956 --> 06:44:43.292
THE GROUNDWATER BASIN. SO UM,
06:44:43.359 --> 06:44:45.628
LIKE I SAID, I DON'T REPRESENT
06:44:45.694 --> 06:44:46.629
THE INVESTMENT BANKERS IN NEW
06:44:46.695 --> 06:44:49.264
YORK. I REPRESENT LOCAL AGENCIES
06:44:49.331 --> 06:44:50.432
THAT ARE STRUGGLING TO PROVIDE
06:44:50.499 --> 06:44:54.136
FARM WATER. AND TO ALSO ACHIEVE
06:44:54.203 --> 06:44:56.338
THE SUSTAINABILITY. GOLDER SIGMA
06:44:56.405 --> 06:44:57.840
, WE'D ASK RESPECTFULLY FOR A NO
06:44:57.906 --> 06:45:00.209
VOTE, MR REID, LET ME ADD
06:45:00.275 --> 06:45:04.313
ANOTHER QUESTION, THEN. ANYTHING
06:45:04.380 --> 06:45:06.649
HISTORICALLY PREVIOUS TWO OR
06:45:06.715 --> 06:45:08.217
SUBSEQUENT TO THAT LEGISLATION,
06:45:08.283 --> 06:45:10.119
BY SENATOR PAVLE. IN OUR AUTHOR
06:45:10.185 --> 06:45:16.792
HERE. THAT PRECLUDES GROUNDWATER
06:45:16.859 --> 06:45:22.164
pTO YES, SIR? NO UM, SOME NOBODY
06:45:22.231 --> 06:45:23.666
WANTS TO TALK ABOUT THAT. WE DO
06:45:23.732 --> 06:45:24.900
A LOT OF THAT IN CALIFORNIA. DO
06:45:24.967 --> 06:45:27.269
WE? NOT YES. IN FACT, THE PLAN
06:45:27.336 --> 06:45:28.537
CONTENTS THAT ARE IN THE
06:45:28.604 --> 06:45:29.204
SUSTAINABLE GROUND MONITOR WATER
06:45:29.271 --> 06:45:32.508
MANAGEMENT ACT. LARGELY COME
06:45:32.574 --> 06:45:35.911
FROM MAYBE 30 30, WHICH WAS THEN
06:45:35.978 --> 06:45:36.612
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HELEN
06:45:36.679 --> 06:45:38.480
THOMPSON'S LEGISLATION BACK IN
06:45:38.547 --> 06:45:39.081
THE EARLY 19 NINETIES. THE
06:45:39.148 --> 06:45:43.018
PROBLEM WITH A B 30 30 WAS THAT
06:45:43.085 --> 06:45:45.087
THE FINANCING AUTHORITY THE
06:45:45.154 --> 06:45:47.890
LEGISLATURE PUT INTO THAT LAW
06:45:47.956 --> 06:45:49.024
WAS BASED ON THE WATER
06:45:49.091 --> 06:45:49.558
REPLENISHMENT DISTRICT OF
06:45:49.625 --> 06:45:50.959
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA LAW THAT
06:45:51.026 --> 06:45:51.927
DISTRICT OVER LIES AND
06:45:51.994 --> 06:45:54.730
ADJUDICATED BASIN. AND THEIR
06:45:54.797 --> 06:45:56.231
AUTHORITY WAS LIMITED TO
06:45:56.298 --> 06:45:58.467
IMPOSINGUNIFORM RATES FOR WATER
06:45:58.534 --> 06:46:01.503
REPLENISHMENT, AND YOU CAN'T DO
06:46:01.570 --> 06:46:04.540
THAT, UNDER MOST AUTHORITY THAT
06:46:04.606 --> 06:46:06.108
THE IRRIGATION DISTRICTS AND
06:46:06.175 --> 06:46:07.109
OTHERS DIDN'T HAVE THAT
06:46:07.176 --> 06:46:09.178
AUTHORITY SO SIGMA
06:46:09.244 --> 06:46:10.779
REPRESENTATIVE. SIGNIFICANT
06:46:10.846 --> 06:46:13.782
IMPROVEMENT IN THE ABILITY FOR
06:46:13.849 --> 06:46:15.851
JESUS TO IMPOSE FEES ON WELLS,
06:46:15.918 --> 06:46:17.586
BOTH REGULATORY AND
06:46:17.653 --> 06:46:19.254
REPLENISHMENT ASSESSMENT IN
06:46:19.321 --> 06:46:20.689
ORDER TO GET THE FUNDING TO DO
06:46:20.756 --> 06:46:22.891
THE RECHARGE PROJECTS AND THE
06:46:22.958 --> 06:46:23.726
TYPES OF THINGS THAT THAT ARE
06:46:23.792 --> 06:46:25.461
AUTHORIZED INTO THE PLANS. THANK
06:46:25.527 --> 06:46:27.730
YOU. WE HAVE MORE OF
06:46:27.796 --> 06:46:30.165
WESTMINSTER'S HERE PRESENT.
06:46:30.232 --> 06:46:31.567
THANK YOU. CATHERINE FREEMAN ON
06:46:31.633 --> 06:46:33.168
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
06:46:33.235 --> 06:46:34.403
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES, THE
06:46:34.470 --> 06:46:35.804
RURAL COUNTY REPRESENTATIVES OF
06:46:35.871 --> 06:46:37.339
CALIFORNIA AND THE CALIFORNIA
06:46:37.406 --> 06:46:38.674
ASSOCIATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
06:46:38.741 --> 06:46:39.208
HEALTH ADMINISTRATORS AND
06:46:39.274 --> 06:46:39.908
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THE
06:46:39.975 --> 06:46:43.011
BILL IN PRINT. SIGMA WAS
06:46:43.078 --> 06:46:44.480
FUNDAMENTALLY A LOCAL GOVERNMENT
06:46:44.546 --> 06:46:46.048
ISSUE. WE'VE HEARD THAT TODAY
06:46:46.115 --> 06:46:47.549
AND WHEN WE NEGOTIATED SIGMA AND
06:46:47.616 --> 06:46:49.952
I WAS IN THE IN THOSE ROOMS, WE
06:46:50.018 --> 06:46:51.153
CAREFULLY PRESERVED THE ROLE OF
06:46:51.220 --> 06:46:53.655
THE COUNTY AND PERMITTING THIS
06:46:53.722 --> 06:46:55.023
BILL WITH RECENT AMENDMENTS
06:46:55.090 --> 06:46:57.159
APPENDS THAT ROLE FIRST. I WANT
06:46:57.226 --> 06:46:58.093
TO JUST QUICKLY SAY, AND
06:46:58.160 --> 06:47:00.162
APPRECIATION TO THE COUNT OF THE
06:47:00.229 --> 06:47:01.063
COMMITTEE STAFF. THEY'VE BEEN
06:47:01.130 --> 06:47:02.631
WORKING VERY HARD ON THIS.
06:47:02.698 --> 06:47:04.433
THEY'VE BEEN INVOLVED WITH ALL
06:47:04.500 --> 06:47:05.100
OF THE AMENDMENTS. BUT THE
06:47:05.167 --> 06:47:06.535
AMENDMENT ADDED BY THE AUTHOR
06:47:06.602 --> 06:47:07.936
AFTER THE MOST RECENT HEARING
06:47:08.003 --> 06:47:09.304
CONFUSES THE BILL BY REQUIRING
06:47:09.371 --> 06:47:10.939
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO CONSIDER
06:47:11.006 --> 06:47:12.141
AND ACCEPT THE FINDINGS OF A
06:47:12.207 --> 06:47:13.208
WRITTEN REPORT TO CONSIDER
06:47:13.275 --> 06:47:15.410
PUBLIC COMMENT. THIS CAN CREATE
06:47:15.477 --> 06:47:17.412
SOME SIGNIFICANT NEW COSTS TO
06:47:17.479 --> 06:47:18.547
LOCAL AGENCIES BUT ARGUABLY
06:47:18.614 --> 06:47:20.415
SHIFTS THE PROCESS AND
06:47:20.482 --> 06:47:21.416
DISCRETION. DISCRETIONARY
06:47:21.483 --> 06:47:22.584
PERMITTING TO, UM TO THE LOCAL
06:47:22.651 --> 06:47:26.955
GOVERNMENT. UH WE THINK OF THIS
06:47:27.022 --> 06:47:28.991
MAY ADD TO SOME LEGAL CHALLENGES
06:47:29.057 --> 06:47:30.192
. WHAT I WANT TO ADD, THOUGH
06:47:30.259 --> 06:47:32.194
JUST ON BEHALF OF COUNTIES IS
06:47:32.261 --> 06:47:33.495
THAT WE ARE WORKING EVERY SINGLE
06:47:33.562 --> 06:47:35.063
DAY. ON GROUNDWATER. WE ARE
06:47:35.130 --> 06:47:38.300
WORKING ON RECHARGE FLOOD MARK.
06:47:38.367 --> 06:47:40.402
AND OTHER PROJECTS. WE BELIEVE
06:47:40.469 --> 06:47:42.437
IN THE G S A. SO WE BELIEVE IN
06:47:42.504 --> 06:47:44.039
THE ROLE OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
06:47:44.106 --> 06:47:46.475
WITH THE SOUS, AND SO AS WE WORK
06:47:46.542 --> 06:47:47.643
TOGETHER, SIGMA IS A VERY LONG
06:47:47.709 --> 06:47:49.444
TERM PROJECT. BUT IT'S GOING TO
06:47:49.511 --> 06:47:53.015
WORK. WE JUST HAVE TO ACTUALLY
06:47:53.081 --> 06:47:54.149
GO THROUGH THE PROCESS OF HAVING
06:47:54.216 --> 06:47:55.951
AT WORK. AND I AGREE WITH MY
06:47:56.018 --> 06:47:59.321
COLLEAGUE, MR REID. IS HAVE A
06:47:59.388 --> 06:48:01.623
LOT OF POWER RIGHT NOW. THEY CAN
06:48:01.690 --> 06:48:03.091
DO ANYTHING THEY WANT. THEY CAN
06:48:03.158 --> 06:48:05.060
ADD A FEE. THEY CAN LIMIT WATER.
06:48:05.127 --> 06:48:06.895
SO THE QUESTION IS. IS THIS THE
06:48:06.962 --> 06:48:08.564
RIGHT TIME FOR THIS BILL, OR
06:48:08.630 --> 06:48:09.798
SHOULD WE LET THE PROCESSES WORK
06:48:09.865 --> 06:48:11.400
SO ON BEHALF OF COUNTIES WE
06:48:11.466 --> 06:48:13.335
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR NO
06:48:13.402 --> 06:48:18.006
VOTE. THANK YOU. VERY RECENTLY
06:48:18.073 --> 06:48:19.274
BEEN FORMED, AND SOME HAVEN'T
06:48:19.341 --> 06:48:21.109
EVEN BEEN FORMED YET. IS THAT
06:48:21.176 --> 06:48:21.910
CORRECT? THAT'S CORRECT AND MANY
06:48:21.977 --> 06:48:23.645
OF THEM HAVE ALREADY IMPLEMENTED
06:48:23.712 --> 06:48:24.479
SOME OF THE STRONGEST
06:48:24.546 --> 06:48:26.215
RESTRICTIONS ON NEW WELLS, WELL,
06:48:26.281 --> 06:48:29.818
DRILLING AND PUMPING. IN ORDER
06:48:29.885 --> 06:48:31.720
TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS SHARED
06:48:31.787 --> 06:48:32.855
RESOURCE IS IN THE GROUND. ARE
06:48:32.921 --> 06:48:35.691
SHARED ACROSS THE ENTIRE BASIN.
06:48:35.757 --> 06:48:37.593
THAT IS WHAT SIGMA ASKED FOR,
06:48:37.659 --> 06:48:39.228
AND THAT'S WHAT THEY ASKED LOCAL
06:48:39.294 --> 06:48:40.996
GOVERNMENTS TO PARTICIPATE IN
06:48:41.063 --> 06:48:41.964
BEHALF OF COUNTIES. THAT'S WHAT
06:48:42.030 --> 06:48:43.165
WE'RE LOOKING FOR. FROM OUR
06:48:43.232 --> 06:48:44.333
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:48:44.399 --> 06:48:45.567
AGENCIES. THANK YOU. WE HAVE
06:48:45.634 --> 06:48:46.134
ANOTHER OLD FRIEND, PLEASE.
06:48:46.201 --> 06:48:50.105
EXCELLENT. ROBERT CORE FROM THE
06:48:50.172 --> 06:48:51.840
GUANACO GROUP ON BEHALF OF
06:48:51.907 --> 06:48:54.343
MODESTO. IRRIGATION CURRENT
06:48:54.409 --> 06:48:55.944
COUNTY WATER AND KINGS RIVER
06:48:56.011 --> 06:48:57.479
CONSERVATION DISTRICT, WHICH
06:48:57.546 --> 06:48:58.513
INCLUDES 4000, FAMILY FARMERS,
06:48:58.580 --> 06:49:01.350
100 DISADVANTAGED. COMMUNITIES
06:49:01.416 --> 06:49:03.518
AND NO INVESTMENT BANKERS. WE
06:49:03.585 --> 06:49:05.954
URGE A NO VOTE ON THIS ON THIS
06:49:06.021 --> 06:49:06.855
BILL, AND WE ASSOCIATE OURSELVES
06:49:06.922 --> 06:49:08.523
WITH THE COMMENTS FROM MISS
06:49:08.590 --> 06:49:10.392
FREEMAN AND MR REID. THANK YOU.
06:49:10.459 --> 06:49:13.462
THANK YOU. NEXT WITNESS. MR
06:49:13.528 --> 06:49:14.830
CHAIRMAN OF MEMBERS, POLYESTER
06:49:14.897 --> 06:49:16.865
ME HALF OF THE EIGHT COUNTIES IN
06:49:16.932 --> 06:49:17.900
CALIFORNIA'S CENTRAL VALLEY.
06:49:17.966 --> 06:49:18.967
THEY'RE ALL IN OPPOSITION. THE
06:49:19.034 --> 06:49:21.370
BILL. SINCE THE SUPPORTERS
06:49:21.436 --> 06:49:22.371
TALKED ABOUT ONE COUNTY IN
06:49:22.437 --> 06:49:23.805
PARTICULAR, TILLERY COUNTY. I
06:49:23.872 --> 06:49:26.041
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE UH, THE
06:49:26.108 --> 06:49:27.743
COMMITTEE AND THE MEMBER MEMBER
06:49:27.809 --> 06:49:30.979
BENNETT UNDERSTANDS. INTO LARRY
06:49:31.046 --> 06:49:32.915
COUNTY. I WORKED. I WORKED MY
06:49:32.981 --> 06:49:34.316
TAIL OFF TO GET EAST PORTER
06:49:34.383 --> 06:49:36.118
VILLE CONNECTED TO THE PORT OF
06:49:36.184 --> 06:49:37.586
ILL MUNICIPAL SYSTEM. TV ESTÁN
06:49:37.653 --> 06:49:39.087
TO LEAVE ILL EASTER ROSIE OTHER
06:49:39.154 --> 06:49:40.355
COMMUNITIES INTO LARRY COUNTY
06:49:40.422 --> 06:49:42.991
AND IN THE VALLEY. FOR $456
06:49:43.058 --> 06:49:47.095
MILLION APIECE. THEY CAN BE
06:49:47.162 --> 06:49:48.563
CONNECTED TO MEAN THIS IP ALS
06:49:48.630 --> 06:49:51.500
WATER SYSTEMS. WHEN MR DICKINSON
06:49:51.566 --> 06:49:53.902
TALKS ABOUT SUSTAINABILITY THAT
06:49:53.969 --> 06:49:56.038
IS THE ULTIMATE SUSTAINABILITY.
06:49:56.104 --> 06:49:57.739
WE WANT OUR RESIDENTS TO HAVE
06:49:57.806 --> 06:50:02.010
CLEAN, RELIABLE WATER. WE NEED
06:50:02.077 --> 06:50:03.512
TO HOOK THEM UP TO MUNICIPAL
06:50:03.578 --> 06:50:05.614
SYSTEMS AS MUCH AS WE POSSIBLY
06:50:05.681 --> 06:50:07.416
CAN. THAT'S SOMETHING I WOULD BE
06:50:07.482 --> 06:50:08.951
REALLY EXCITED TO WORK WITH
06:50:09.017 --> 06:50:11.420
EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM ON IF WE
06:50:11.486 --> 06:50:13.322
CAN DO THAT. THANK YOU. THANK
06:50:13.388 --> 06:50:15.624
YOU, MR YODER. GONNA SALVI ON
06:50:15.691 --> 06:50:17.492
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA GRAIN
06:50:17.559 --> 06:50:18.794
AND FEED CALIFORNIA'S SEED
06:50:18.860 --> 06:50:19.695
COVERED A PAIR OF GROWER
06:50:19.761 --> 06:50:20.429
ASSOCIATION AND WE CURRENTLY
06:50:20.495 --> 06:50:24.933
OPPOSE. THANK YOU. FRIEND OF
06:50:25.000 --> 06:50:26.401
VAST WITH THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
06:50:26.468 --> 06:50:28.603
OF COMMERCE, A CONSORTIUM OF
06:50:28.670 --> 06:50:30.939
BUSINESSES BOTH LARGE AND SMALL
06:50:31.006 --> 06:50:31.974
, AND WE RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED
06:50:32.040 --> 06:50:36.111
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. GOOD
06:50:36.178 --> 06:50:37.579
AFTERNOON FOR TRIGGERING ER WITH
06:50:37.646 --> 06:50:38.947
AGRICULTURAL COUNCIL OF
06:50:39.014 --> 06:50:40.282
CALIFORNIA RPRESENTING 15,000
06:50:40.349 --> 06:50:42.017
FARMERS ALL THROUGHOUT THE STATE
06:50:42.084 --> 06:50:43.652
OF ALL SIZES ALSO RESPECTFULLY
06:50:43.719 --> 06:50:44.753
AND OPPOSITION. DO WE HAVE
06:50:44.820 --> 06:50:47.289
WITNESSES HERE? THAT WOULD
06:50:47.356 --> 06:50:53.362
SPEAK. ADDITIONALLY, IN FAVOR OF
06:50:53.428 --> 06:50:59.167
THINK WE. THROUGH THE REMOTE.
06:50:59.234 --> 06:51:00.469
WE'VE GOT EVERYBODY, DIDN'T WE?
06:51:00.535 --> 06:51:02.337
THAT WE DID ALL OF THE WE DIDN'T
06:51:02.404 --> 06:51:05.440
WANT TO LEAVE ANY OUT. NOW IT'S
06:51:05.507 --> 06:51:08.610
JUST BY BY PHONE OPPOSITION.
06:51:08.677 --> 06:51:09.945
OKAY WE'VE GOT IT COVERED, THEN.
06:51:10.012 --> 06:51:19.021
VERY GOOD. OKAY? YEAH. PEACE. DO
06:51:19.087 --> 06:51:22.257
WE HAVE ANYONE HERE?
06:51:22.324 --> 06:51:23.191
ADDITIONALLY TO SPEAK IN
06:51:23.258 --> 06:51:27.863
OPPOSITION AND OR ON THE LINE.
06:51:27.929 --> 06:51:29.197
IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
06:51:29.264 --> 06:51:30.232
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS ONE,
06:51:30.298 --> 06:51:32.000
FOLLOWED BY THE ZERO AT THE
06:51:32.067 --> 06:51:33.368
TIME. AND WE DO HAVE LINES. 7
06:51:33.435 --> 06:51:45.213
41, PLEASE GO AHEAD. FLIGHT 41.
06:51:45.280 --> 06:51:46.515
GOOD AFTERNOON, CHRIS ANDERSON
06:51:46.581 --> 06:51:48.250
ON BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATION OF
06:51:48.316 --> 06:51:49.551
CALIFORNIA WATER AGENCIES
06:51:49.618 --> 06:51:51.953
OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED, BUT WE
06:51:52.020 --> 06:51:52.954
DO APPRECIATE THE CONTINUED
06:51:53.021 --> 06:51:53.955
DIALOGUE WITH ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
06:51:54.022 --> 06:51:54.923
BENNETT AND HIS STAFF. THANK
06:51:54.990 --> 06:52:03.632
YOU. QUÊ GO AHEAD. LINE 7 64.
06:52:03.698 --> 06:52:04.800
GOOD AFTERNOON. REBECCA BASKINS
06:52:04.866 --> 06:52:06.601
ON THE HOUSE, CALIFORNIA CITRUS
06:52:06.668 --> 06:52:08.070
MUTUAL, CALIFORNIA FRESH FRUIT
06:52:08.136 --> 06:52:10.272
ASSOCIATION, CALIFORNIA COTTON
06:52:10.338 --> 06:52:11.640
JENNERS AND GO WITH ASSOCIATION
06:52:11.706 --> 06:52:13.141
AND OTHER I ORGANIZATIONS AND
06:52:13.208 --> 06:52:14.076
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
06:52:14.142 --> 06:52:20.615
YOU. CLIENTS. 7 71. GOOD
06:52:20.682 --> 06:52:27.122
AFTERNOON. DOOR ROSE, CALIFORNIA
06:52:27.189 --> 06:52:28.857
I APOLOGIZE. I HAD SOME TROUBLE
06:52:28.924 --> 06:52:30.725
WITH ITS OWN SYSTEM. WE ARE IN
06:52:30.792 --> 06:52:32.527
STRONG SUPPORT. WHAT IS THE NAME
06:52:32.594 --> 06:52:34.896
OF YOUR ORGANIZATION AGAIN? IT'S
06:52:34.963 --> 06:52:36.098
THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS OF
06:52:36.164 --> 06:52:42.104
CALIFORNIA. OKAY, SUPPORT. AND
06:52:42.170 --> 06:52:47.008
WE HAVE LINED 6 75. HI GOOD
06:52:47.075 --> 06:52:48.677
AFTERNOON TRUDY HUES OF THE
06:52:48.743 --> 06:52:49.911
CALIFORNIA LEAGUE OF FOOD
06:52:49.978 --> 06:52:50.479
PRODUCERS REPRESENTING THIS
06:52:50.545 --> 06:52:51.213
PROCESSORS AND RESPECTFUL
06:52:51.279 --> 06:52:54.683
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. WE HAVE
06:52:54.749 --> 06:53:00.622
LINES 7 69. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
06:53:00.689 --> 06:53:02.457
VICE CHAIR AND OWNERS ROSANNA
06:53:02.524 --> 06:53:03.959
CARPACCIO, ELIOT COHEN ON BEHALF
06:53:04.025 --> 06:53:05.193
OF THE CALIFORNIA BROWN WATER
06:53:05.260 --> 06:53:06.995
COALITION. WE WERE IN AN
06:53:07.062 --> 06:53:07.863
OPPOSING LESS ADMITTED POSITION
06:53:07.929 --> 06:53:09.631
WHEN THERE STILL IS TURNING OUT
06:53:09.698 --> 06:53:11.933
TO RESOURCE. WATER AND
06:53:12.000 --> 06:53:13.535
APPRECIATED THE AMENDMENT TAKEN
06:53:13.602 --> 06:53:16.104
IN THAT COMMITTEE. WE ARE STILL
06:53:16.171 --> 06:53:16.905
A LITTLE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
06:53:16.972 --> 06:53:19.241
LIABILITY PROVISIONS FOR ESA'S
06:53:19.307 --> 06:53:20.775
AND LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
06:53:20.842 --> 06:53:21.943
TO WORK WITH THE AUTHOR TO
06:53:22.010 --> 06:53:24.446
ENSURE ARE TAKEN CARE OF. THANK
06:53:24.513 --> 06:53:26.781
YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.
06:53:26.848 --> 06:53:29.050
MODERATE OR ANY OTHER SEVEN. WE
06:53:29.117 --> 06:53:34.489
HAVE LINED 7 73. YES THANK YOU
06:53:34.556 --> 06:53:35.824
VERY MUCH. THIS IS GAIL
06:53:35.891 --> 06:53:37.325
DELAHANTY WITH WESTERN GROWERS
06:53:37.392 --> 06:53:39.094
ASSOCIATION AND WE ARE IN
06:53:39.161 --> 06:53:49.204
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU, 6 47.
06:53:49.271 --> 06:53:50.138
CLOSES MICHAEL MILLER WITH THE
06:53:50.205 --> 06:53:51.406
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION BUYING
06:53:51.473 --> 06:53:52.507
GRAPE GROWERS. RESPECTFUL
06:53:52.574 --> 06:53:55.310
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. WE HAVE
06:53:55.377 --> 06:54:01.216
LINED 26. THANK YOU. CHAIR
06:54:01.283 --> 06:54:03.285
NIELSEN OR VICE CHAIR. PILSEN
06:54:03.351 --> 06:54:04.686
DANNY MERCURY WITH CALIFORNIA
06:54:04.753 --> 06:54:07.055
FARM GIRL REPRESENTING MORE THAN
06:54:07.122 --> 06:54:08.757
30,000, SMALL FAMILY, FARMERS
06:54:08.823 --> 06:54:09.591
AND RANCHERS RESPECTFULLY
06:54:09.658 --> 06:54:14.596
OPPOSED. THANK YOU, MR BERKELEY.
06:54:14.663 --> 06:54:15.764
WE HAVE LINED 40, PLEASE GO
06:54:15.830 --> 06:54:23.638
AHEAD. FIND 40. YOUR LINE IS
06:54:23.705 --> 06:54:28.210
OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. THIS
06:54:28.276 --> 06:54:30.278
IS DAVID DRY ON BEHALF OF THE
06:54:30.345 --> 06:54:31.413
TRI COUNTY CHAMBER ALLIANCE IN
06:54:31.479 --> 06:54:34.216
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. AND WE
06:54:34.282 --> 06:54:39.721
HAVE LINED 62. GOOD AFTERNOON,
06:54:39.788 --> 06:54:41.189
MR VICE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
06:54:41.256 --> 06:54:42.824
MEMBERS, DAVID MERRITT WITH
06:54:42.891 --> 06:54:44.359
KINGS RIVER CONSERVATION
06:54:44.426 --> 06:54:44.960
DISTRICT RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED
06:54:45.026 --> 06:54:48.763
UNLESS THURMOND THANK YOU. AND
06:54:48.830 --> 06:54:55.837
LINE 3 90. YES GOOD AFTERNOON.
06:54:55.904 --> 06:54:57.339
KATHY KAHAN, NORTH KINGS
06:54:57.405 --> 06:54:58.206
GROUNDWATER SUSTAINABILITY
06:54:58.273 --> 06:55:00.375
AGENCY RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED
06:55:00.442 --> 06:55:02.177
UNLESS AMENDED AND APPRECIATE AS
06:55:02.244 --> 06:55:03.311
ASSEMBLYMAN BENNETT STAFF ON
06:55:03.378 --> 06:55:08.984
WORKING WITH US. QUÊ. AND AT
06:55:09.050 --> 06:55:11.286
THIS TIME THERE WERE NO FURTHER
06:55:11.353 --> 06:55:12.454
LINE. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
06:55:12.520 --> 06:55:13.622
THANK YOU. WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH
06:55:13.688 --> 06:55:14.756
THE OPPOSITION. YOU GIVE US A
06:55:14.823 --> 06:55:17.792
CLOSER QUESTIONS FROM THE
06:55:17.859 --> 06:55:18.827
COMMITTEE. WELL, THAT'S RIGHT,
06:55:18.893 --> 06:55:24.866
PLEASE. SENATOR RASO. NO
06:55:24.933 --> 06:55:30.005
QUESTIONS. HAD THAT DOWN, TOO.
06:55:30.071 --> 06:55:39.781
WE HAVE THE CHAIRMAN. QUESTION
06:55:39.848 --> 06:55:41.716
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS ARE WE
06:55:41.783 --> 06:55:43.351
ON FILE ADAM NUMBER 18. 17 OKAY,
06:55:43.418 --> 06:55:49.357
GREAT. ANY COMMITTEE QUESTIONS.
06:55:49.424 --> 06:55:52.594
NO MYSTERIES. SEVERAL COMMENTS I
06:55:52.661 --> 06:55:57.565
RAISED. LAST COMMITTEE ISSUES
06:55:57.632 --> 06:55:58.700
RELATING TO ENFORCEMENT. I THINK
06:55:58.767 --> 06:56:02.070
THE LIABILITY ISSUES UM, SEQUEL
06:56:02.137 --> 06:56:04.005
AND THE LIKE, YOU KNOW, I'M I'M
06:56:04.072 --> 06:56:05.874
IN A SITUATION WHERE I VOTED FOR
06:56:05.940 --> 06:56:07.509
THIS BILL. WE'VE HAD MANY
06:56:07.575 --> 06:56:08.677
CONVERSATIONS, MR SALOMON ABOUT
06:56:08.743 --> 06:56:12.047
THIS. AND THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT
06:56:12.113 --> 06:56:14.282
TO YOU. IT'S ABUNDANTLY CLEAR.
06:56:14.349 --> 06:56:15.650
SINCE LEARNED A LOT FROM A LOT
06:56:15.717 --> 06:56:18.119
OF OTHER FOLKS ABOUT OPPOSITION
06:56:18.186 --> 06:56:19.321
AND I ALSO IN A TERRIBLE
06:56:19.387 --> 06:56:21.556
POSITION BECAUSE THE CHAIR'S NOT
06:56:21.623 --> 06:56:24.292
IN SUPPORT, AND I DON'T LIKE I
06:56:24.359 --> 06:56:25.160
DON'T LIKE VOTING AGAINST THE
06:56:25.226 --> 06:56:29.497
CHAIR. BUT I VOTED FOR IT. YOU
06:56:29.564 --> 06:56:31.166
KNOW, I'M PRETTY STRAIGHT UP
06:56:31.232 --> 06:56:32.500
PERSON AROUND AWHILE. I KNOW WHO
06:56:32.567 --> 06:56:34.402
I AM COMFORTABLE IN MY SKIN AND
06:56:34.469 --> 06:56:35.704
I, YOU KNOW, I HAVE A LOT OF
06:56:35.770 --> 06:56:37.706
ISSUES THAT HAVE COME TO MY
06:56:37.772 --> 06:56:40.008
ATTENTION, BUT I THINK WITH THE
06:56:40.075 --> 06:56:41.276
APPROPRIATE THING TO DO HERE
06:56:41.343 --> 06:56:42.310
UNDER THE CIRCUMSTANCES, SUPPORT
06:56:42.377 --> 06:56:47.048
SURE. VOTE TODAY BECAUSE. MY
06:56:47.115 --> 06:56:48.650
VOTE'S HERE TO GET THIS OUT IF I
06:56:48.717 --> 06:56:51.086
HAD TO GUESS I WANT TO CONTINUE
06:56:51.152 --> 06:56:51.820
DISCUSSIONS. THERE'S BEEN SOME
06:56:51.886 --> 06:56:54.389
DISCUSSIONS ABOUT AMENDMENTS. UM
06:56:54.456 --> 06:56:55.623
WHETHER WE CAN DO SOMETHING OR
06:56:55.690 --> 06:56:58.393
NOT, I DON'T KNOW. I'VE BEEN SO
06:56:58.460 --> 06:57:00.495
BUSY ON OTHER THINGS. I HAVEN'T
06:57:00.562 --> 06:57:01.062
HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEND
06:57:01.129 --> 06:57:02.964
ENOUGH TIME WITH THE CHAIR TO
06:57:03.031 --> 06:57:04.432
DISCUSS HER VIEW ON THIS AND I
06:57:04.499 --> 06:57:05.934
OVER THAT RESPECT, AND THEY HAVE
06:57:06.000 --> 06:57:07.769
A LOT OF OTHER FOLKS THAT
06:57:07.836 --> 06:57:10.939
RESPECT TO BUT I THINK THERE'S
06:57:11.005 --> 06:57:12.240
STILL TIME IN THE PROCESS TO
06:57:12.307 --> 06:57:14.743
CONTINUE TO DISCUSS THIS, BUT
06:57:14.809 --> 06:57:15.710
APPROPRIATE THING IS TO ALLOW
06:57:15.777 --> 06:57:17.612
THIS DIFFERENCE TO THE CHAIR TO
06:57:17.679 --> 06:57:18.880
LET IT MOVE ON, BUT ALSO IN
06:57:18.947 --> 06:57:21.015
DEFERENCE TO THE CHAIR TO
06:57:21.082 --> 06:57:22.617
CONTINUE TO EMPLOY YOUR
06:57:22.684 --> 06:57:25.253
ATTENTION AND BRAINS AND SEEING
06:57:25.320 --> 06:57:26.988
IF WE CAN TRY TO MAKE THIS WORK
06:57:27.055 --> 06:57:29.090
IF IT'S POSSIBLE, SO I WILL BE
06:57:29.157 --> 06:57:30.525
SUPPORTING IT. I DO HAVE A LOT
06:57:30.592 --> 06:57:31.559
OF QUESTIONS ABOUT IT. I
06:57:31.626 --> 06:57:32.794
APOLOGIZE BECAUSE I'VE BEEN SO
06:57:32.861 --> 06:57:33.962
OTHERWISE DISPOSED AND WORKING
06:57:34.028 --> 06:57:37.899
ON A LOT OF OTHER ISSUES THAT
06:57:37.966 --> 06:57:38.733
TOOK MY ATTENTION AND WASN'T
06:57:38.800 --> 06:57:40.702
ABLE TO PUT IT IN THAT TIME AND
06:57:40.769 --> 06:57:42.771
ATTENTION INTO IT. BUT I THINK I
06:57:42.837 --> 06:57:45.006
OWE YOU THAT. AND I ALSO THE
06:57:45.073 --> 06:57:46.207
CHAIR AND I TOLD YOU WHAT MY
06:57:46.274 --> 06:57:48.042
PREDICAMENT WAS. AND I JUST WANT
06:57:48.109 --> 06:57:49.477
YOU TO KNOW THAT ALLOW YOU TO
06:57:49.544 --> 06:57:51.579
MOVE IT ON. BUT I IT'S NOT A
06:57:51.646 --> 06:57:52.781
COMMITMENT TO VOTE FOR IT ON THE
06:57:52.847 --> 06:57:54.849
FLOOR, BUT IT IS A COMMITMENT
06:57:54.916 --> 06:57:56.251
THAT WILL CONTINUE TO WORK TO
06:57:56.317 --> 06:57:57.786
SEE IF WE CAN GET THROUGH SOME
06:57:57.852 --> 06:58:00.422
OF THE ISSUES THAT WE NEED TO
06:58:00.488 --> 06:58:01.489
GET THROUGH WITH THE CHAIR. OKAY
06:58:01.556 --> 06:58:02.757
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WITH GREAT
06:58:02.824 --> 06:58:03.992
RESPECT TO THE AUTHOR. I WILL
06:58:04.058 --> 06:58:05.693
VIGOROUSLY OPPOSE THIS. AND I'LL%
06:58:05.760 --> 06:58:07.729
MAKE A NOTE THAT THIS COULD HAVE
06:58:07.796 --> 06:58:08.630
A DEVASTATING IMPACT. TO THE
06:58:08.696 --> 06:58:09.631
AGRICULTURAL ECONOMY OF THE
06:58:09.697 --> 06:58:10.064
STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
06:58:10.131 --> 06:58:12.267
DEVASTATING. AT THE TIME OF THE
06:58:12.333 --> 06:58:14.102
ORIGINAL LEGISLATION. I
06:58:14.169 --> 06:58:15.270
PREDICTED THIS WOULD NOT SEE THE
06:58:15.336 --> 06:58:18.239
END. OF SUCH MORE PRESCRIPTIVE.
06:58:18.306 --> 06:58:20.942
LEGISLATION. THAT HAS INDEED
06:58:21.009 --> 06:58:25.213
BEEN THE CASE. AND IT'S A
06:58:25.280 --> 06:58:27.115
FEARSOME STRIP THAT WE'RE NOW
06:58:27.182 --> 06:58:28.817
HEADED DOWN. AND WHEN THERE ARE
06:58:28.883 --> 06:58:33.188
SOLUTIONS. AND I PARTICULARLY
06:58:33.254 --> 06:58:35.356
HAVE OBJECTED OVER THE YEARS TO
06:58:35.423 --> 06:58:36.491
THE COMPLAINTS ABOUT THE
06:58:36.558 --> 06:58:37.492
AGRICULTURAL INDUSTRY. USING TOO
06:58:37.559 --> 06:58:41.996
MUCH WATER. I DON'T THINK ANY
06:58:42.063 --> 06:58:43.665
INDUSTRY HAS DONE MORE TO
06:58:43.731 --> 06:58:44.999
CONSERVE WATER. THE AGRICULTURAL
06:58:45.066 --> 06:58:48.970
INDUSTRY. I CAN TELL YOU
06:58:49.037 --> 06:58:50.104
SPECIFICALLY HOW AND WHY AND
06:58:50.171 --> 06:58:51.739
WHAT I MYSELF DONE. AND I THINK
06:58:51.806 --> 06:58:55.176
THEY DESERVE CREDIT FOR THAT.
06:58:55.243 --> 06:58:56.177
AND THEY DON'T DESERVE DISCREDIT
06:58:56.244 --> 06:58:57.946
AND BEING PUT OUT OF BUSINESS.
06:58:58.012 --> 06:58:59.714
AND CONSTRAINED FOR THAT. I
06:58:59.781 --> 06:59:05.019
WOULD URGE A NO VOTE. THANK YOU
06:59:05.086 --> 06:59:08.423
VERY MUCH. GO FIRST SINGLE. WELL
06:59:08.490 --> 06:59:10.024
LET ME JUST MAKE AND I
06:59:10.091 --> 06:59:11.426
APOLOGIZE. I MISSED I WAS IN
06:59:11.493 --> 06:59:12.961
YOUR COMMITTEE PRESENTING A BILL
06:59:13.027 --> 06:59:14.529
OR THE COMMITTEE. YOU SIT ON
06:59:14.596 --> 06:59:17.565
PRESENTING A BILL MISSED IT
06:59:17.632 --> 06:59:19.567
CONVINCING. I'M SURE I'M SURE
06:59:19.634 --> 06:59:21.302
THAT'S TRUE. WELL LET ME JUST
06:59:21.369 --> 06:59:22.704
SAY I REALLY APPRECIATED OUR
06:59:22.770 --> 06:59:26.441
CONVERSATIONS. AND I REALLY AYE.
06:59:26.508 --> 06:59:28.977
I ACTUALLY AND I TOLD YOU THIS I
06:59:29.043 --> 06:59:31.112
SUPPORT WHAT YOU TOLD ME WAS THE
06:59:31.179 --> 06:59:33.748
INTENTION, WHICH IS THE CONCERN
06:59:33.815 --> 06:59:40.889
TO NOT ALLOW. NEW WELLS FOR OUT
06:59:40.955 --> 06:59:42.090
OF STATE INVESTORS THAT ARE
06:59:42.156 --> 06:59:44.292
COMING IN AND BUYING UP EITHER
06:59:44.359 --> 06:59:46.828
LAND OR WATER. UM AND THEY GO
06:59:46.895 --> 06:59:49.597
TOGETHER, SO, UM, TO THE
06:59:49.664 --> 06:59:51.032
DETRIMENT OF OUR LOCAL ECONOMIES
06:59:51.099 --> 06:59:54.068
AND TO THE DETRIMENT OF FARMING.
06:59:54.135 --> 06:59:56.304
LONGSTANDING FARMING IN IN THE
06:59:56.371 --> 06:59:58.573
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. UM I'M NOT
06:59:58.640 --> 06:59:59.908
GOING TO BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
06:59:59.974 --> 07:00:02.277
TODAY BECAUSE THE BILL DOESN'T
07:00:02.343 --> 07:00:03.778
DO THAT. AND SO THAT'S MY
07:00:03.845 --> 07:00:05.713
CHALLENGE THAT I HAVE IS THAT IT
07:00:05.780 --> 07:00:06.881
DOESN'T DO THAT. WE HAVE THE
07:00:06.948 --> 07:00:07.815
GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER ON
07:00:07.882 --> 07:00:10.685
THIS EXACT SAME SUBJECT THAT IS
07:00:10.752 --> 07:00:13.888
BARELY THREE MONTHS OLD. AND UM
07:00:13.955 --> 07:00:16.691
, I'M HEARING FROM, UM PEOPLE
07:00:16.758 --> 07:00:19.127
ALL OVER MY DISTRICT AND THEN UP
07:00:19.193 --> 07:00:19.994
AND DOWN THE VALLEY THAT ARE
07:00:20.061 --> 07:00:21.563
VERY CONCERNED. GS ASSESS
07:00:21.629 --> 07:00:26.267
FARMERS. UM CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
07:00:26.334 --> 07:00:27.835
THAT ARE REALLY CONCERNED WITH
07:00:27.902 --> 07:00:30.805
WITH THE EXECUTIVE ORDER AND HOW
07:00:30.872 --> 07:00:31.940
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW IT'S
07:00:32.006 --> 07:00:34.709
SUPPOSED TO WORK. AND UM, THAT
07:00:34.776 --> 07:00:36.344
EXECUTIVE RDER ISN'T GOING AWAY
07:00:36.411 --> 07:00:37.579
ANYTIME SOON. THIS DROUGHT ISN'T
07:00:37.645 --> 07:00:41.549
GOING AWAY ANYTIME SOON. UM AND
07:00:41.616 --> 07:00:44.419
, UM IT ON TOP OF EVERYTHING
07:00:44.485 --> 07:00:46.220
ELSE THAT THAT'S HAPPENED IN THE
07:00:46.287 --> 07:00:50.658
REGION. UM. TO IMPOSE UNTESTED
07:00:50.725 --> 07:00:53.394
MEASURES WHEN WATER SUPPLIES ARE
07:00:53.461 --> 07:00:54.963
SO LOW AND FUEL PRICES ARE
07:00:55.029 --> 07:00:56.698
THROUGH THE ROOF. UM IT JUST
07:00:56.764 --> 07:00:59.400
DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE TO ME SO
07:00:59.467 --> 07:01:01.803
I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU TO VISIT
07:01:01.869 --> 07:01:04.105
REVISIT THE ISSUE EVER AFTER
07:01:04.172 --> 07:01:05.239
WE'VE HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO
07:01:05.306 --> 07:01:06.307
UNDERSTAND THE EFFECTS OF THE
07:01:06.374 --> 07:01:10.645
EXECUTIVE ORDER AND, UM. AND
07:01:10.712 --> 07:01:11.746
WE'RE NOT DONE WITH THIS. AND I
07:01:11.813 --> 07:01:14.449
WANT TO. I WANT TO AGREE WITH MY
07:01:14.515 --> 07:01:15.550
COLLEAGUE, SENATOR NIELSEN. IS
07:01:15.617 --> 07:01:18.086
THAT, UM IS THAT WE SET UP THESE
07:01:18.152 --> 07:01:19.454
THESE PROGRAMS ARE HEAVILY
07:01:19.520 --> 07:01:23.391
NEGOTIATED, AND THEN BEFORE THE
07:01:23.458 --> 07:01:24.559
INK IS EVEN DRY ON IT.
07:01:24.626 --> 07:01:25.493
SOMEBODY'S GOT A PROPOSAL TO
07:01:25.560 --> 07:01:31.032
CHANGE IT AND TO, UM. CHANGED
07:01:31.099 --> 07:01:33.568
THE ELEMENTS OF THE OF THE ISSUE
07:01:33.635 --> 07:01:35.770
THAT WAS HEAVILY NEGOTIATED. AND
07:01:35.837 --> 07:01:37.772
SO I THINK THIS HAS TO BE DONE.
07:01:37.839 --> 07:01:39.173
AT SOME POINT. THE QUESTION IS
07:01:39.240 --> 07:01:41.342
WHEN AND HOW DO WE GO ABOUT IT?
07:01:41.409 --> 07:01:44.212
SO I APPRECIATE UM ALL OF YOUR
07:01:44.278 --> 07:01:46.447
WORK ON THIS, BUT TODAY I WON'T
07:01:46.514 --> 07:01:48.316
BE SUPPORTING YOUR BILL. SO I
07:01:48.383 --> 07:01:50.051
APPRECIATE IT SO SENATOR DURAZO.
07:01:50.118 --> 07:01:51.919
THANK YOU, MAN CHAIR AND THANK
07:01:51.986 --> 07:01:54.055
YOU TO THE AUTHOR, AND I REALLY
07:01:54.122 --> 07:01:54.589
APPRECIATE MY COLLEAGUE'S
07:01:54.656 --> 07:01:58.059
COMMENTS AS WELL BECAUSE THERE
07:01:58.126 --> 07:01:59.694
ARE VERY FEW OF US IN THE
07:01:59.761 --> 07:02:01.129
LEGISLATIVE VERY FEW IN THE
07:02:01.195 --> 07:02:03.164
LEGISLATURE, THAT ACTUAL EXPERTS
07:02:03.231 --> 07:02:06.267
, UM IN ALL ASPECTS OF WATER.
07:02:06.334 --> 07:02:07.301
I'VE BEEN TRYING TO LEARN MORE
07:02:07.368 --> 07:02:11.539
MEETING WITH WATER EXPERTS. UM
07:02:11.606 --> 07:02:12.740
AND JUST SOME THINGS JUST HIT
07:02:12.807 --> 07:02:17.445
YOU HIT YOUR REALLY HARD, UM,
07:02:17.512 --> 07:02:18.579
ABOUT THE NUMBER OF WELLS IN THE
07:02:18.646 --> 07:02:23.851
STATE. AH, THAT THOUSANDS AND
07:02:23.918 --> 07:02:24.986
THOUSANDS JUST DOESN'T SEEM TO
07:02:25.053 --> 07:02:28.856
BE KIND OF LIKE A WILD WEST IN
07:02:28.923 --> 07:02:30.792
TERMS OF WHO GETS WATER AND WHEN
07:02:30.858 --> 07:02:32.093
THEY GET WATER, SO, UM, I
07:02:32.160 --> 07:02:36.798
APPRECIATE THAT YOU'VE WHATEVER
07:02:36.864 --> 07:02:38.499
, UM, AMENDMENT. THE AMENDMENTS
07:02:38.566 --> 07:02:41.269
THAT YOU PUT TOGETHER ONE OVER
07:02:41.335 --> 07:02:43.871
SMALL FARMERS AND OTHERS. AND SO
07:02:43.938 --> 07:02:44.872
YOU'RE BUILDING QUITE A
07:02:44.939 --> 07:02:47.542
COALITION HERE. QUITE A UNITED
07:02:47.608 --> 07:02:49.310
FRONT AND I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU
07:02:49.377 --> 07:02:50.712
TO KEEP DOING THAT BECAUSE
07:02:50.778 --> 07:02:51.779
THAT'S THE ONLY WAY WE'RE GOING
07:02:51.846 --> 07:02:53.748
TO COME UP WITH SOMETHING WHEN
07:02:53.815 --> 07:02:55.383
MOST OF THE STAKEHOLDERS ARE ARE
07:02:55.450 --> 07:03:00.688
THERE, UM SO I, UH I HOPE TO
07:03:00.755 --> 07:03:02.590
HEAR MORE FROM FROM THE CHAIR
07:03:02.657 --> 07:03:04.859
TODAY. I WILL BE SUPPORTING. UM
07:03:04.926 --> 07:03:06.527
AND I HOPE THAT EITHER THROUGH
07:03:06.594 --> 07:03:10.598
THE CHAIR. HER. ARGUMENTS OR
07:03:10.665 --> 07:03:15.002
YOURS. UM ONE OF YOU WILL WIN US
07:03:15.069 --> 07:03:17.338
MORE OF US OVER WHEN THIS COMES
07:03:17.405 --> 07:03:18.940
UP TO A NEXT ANOTHER VOTE, SO
07:03:19.006 --> 07:03:24.145
THANK YOU. YES. FIRST OF ALL, I
07:03:24.212 --> 07:03:28.716
WANT TO COMPLIMENT THE AUTHOR.
07:03:28.783 --> 07:03:30.651
ABOUT THREE WEEKS AGO,
07:03:30.718 --> 07:03:31.753
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IN IT CAME UP
07:03:31.819 --> 07:03:34.522
SEVERAL MILES NORTH OF HERE. WE
07:03:34.589 --> 07:03:37.225
HAD DINNER AT A RICE FARM. AND
07:03:37.291 --> 07:03:38.459
WHEN WE WERE LOOKING OUT OVER
07:03:38.526 --> 07:03:40.962
THE BUT THE WINDOW WE WERE
07:03:41.028 --> 07:03:44.465
LOOKING TO RICE FIELDS. SO HE
07:03:44.532 --> 07:03:46.000
CERTAINLY IS DEVOTED SOME
07:03:46.067 --> 07:03:48.136
ATTENTION TO TAKING A LOOK.
07:03:48.202 --> 07:03:51.439
ANOTHER IMPORTANT ASPECT OF THIS
07:03:51.506 --> 07:03:52.740
COULD BE EVEN MORE IMPORTANT TO
07:03:52.807 --> 07:03:55.276
IMPACT ON AGRICULTURE. AND AT
07:03:55.343 --> 07:03:57.111
THE TIME OF THE ORIGINAL
07:03:57.178 --> 07:03:58.279
LEGISLATION THAT DISMAYED ME
07:03:58.346 --> 07:04:00.882
THAT THE LEGAL CALIFORNIA CITIES
07:04:00.948 --> 07:04:01.883
AND THE COUNTY SUPERVISORS
07:04:01.949 --> 07:04:04.619
ASSOCIATION. TOOK NO INTEREST IN
07:04:04.685 --> 07:04:09.123
THIS LEGISLATION. AND I SAID,
07:04:09.190 --> 07:04:10.224
DON'T YOU THINK MUNICIPAL WELLS
07:04:10.291 --> 07:04:13.327
ARE GOING TO BE AFFECTED? DON'T
07:04:13.394 --> 07:04:14.562
YOU THINK DOMESTIC WELLS ARE
07:04:14.629 --> 07:04:15.863
GOING TO BE AFFECTED? OH, NO.
07:04:15.930 --> 07:04:17.331
WELL, GUESS WHAT? DOMESTIC
07:04:17.398 --> 07:04:22.303
WELLS. ARE EFFECTIVE. AND
07:04:22.370 --> 07:04:25.306
MUNICIPAL WELLS ARE AFFECTED, SO
07:04:25.373 --> 07:04:27.008
DON'T THINK THAT THIS IS SIMPLY
07:04:27.074 --> 07:04:28.075
ABOUT AGRICULTURE IS FAR MORE
07:04:28.142 --> 07:04:31.145
EXPANSIVE. AND OF GREATER IMPACT
07:04:31.212 --> 07:04:36.250
THAN JUST THAT. WELL AND I TO
07:04:36.317 --> 07:04:39.587
ADD TO MAKE IT EVEN MURKIER. UM
07:04:39.654 --> 07:04:40.788
I'VE BEEN WORKING FOR THE PAST
07:04:40.855 --> 07:04:45.359
FOUR YEARS. TO DO TO TRY TO GET
07:04:45.426 --> 07:04:48.729
A BILL TO STUDY AND TO DO WATER
07:04:48.796 --> 07:04:51.098
INNOVATION BY BY REGION SO THAT
07:04:51.165 --> 07:04:51.899
WE START LOOKING AT EVERY REGION
07:04:51.966 --> 07:04:54.335
IF WE MADE SOME CHANGES, AND IF
07:04:54.402 --> 07:04:55.670
WE PUT SOME MONEY INTO THE
07:04:55.736 --> 07:04:57.238
SYSTEM UM, COULD WE BECOME
07:04:57.305 --> 07:04:59.841
DROUGHT RESISTANCE RESISTANT OR
07:04:59.907 --> 07:05:02.877
RESILIENT? UM AND THERE'S NO
07:05:02.944 --> 07:05:04.011
SUPPORT FOR THAT. WELL, THERE'S
07:05:04.078 --> 07:05:05.880
NOT NONE, BUT IT'S EVERY YEAR IT
07:05:05.947 --> 07:05:08.449
GETS CAUGHT. CAUGHT UP IN
07:05:08.516 --> 07:05:10.351
APPROPRIATIONS, WHICH IS THE
07:05:10.418 --> 07:05:12.587
BLACK HOLE, AND WHAT THAT TELLS
07:05:12.653 --> 07:05:14.555
ME IS, THERE'S JUST NOT ENOUGH
07:05:14.622 --> 07:05:15.790
SUPPORT FOR LOOKING AT. HOW CAN
07:05:15.857 --> 07:05:18.392
WE DO? HOW CAN WE DO WATER A
07:05:18.459 --> 07:05:19.727
LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY AND WHAT
07:05:19.794 --> 07:05:23.931
KINDS OF SOLUTIONS ARE THERE OUT
07:05:23.998 --> 07:05:25.199
THERE IN THE WORLD THAT WOULD
07:05:25.266 --> 07:05:28.469
WORK IN CALIFORNIA. AND THAT
07:05:28.536 --> 07:05:30.338
WOULD HELP US TO STABILIZE OUR
07:05:30.404 --> 07:05:31.606
WATER USAGE AND IN OUR WATER
07:05:31.672 --> 07:05:34.609
SUPPLY, AND SO WE'RE CONSTANTLY
07:05:34.675 --> 07:05:38.012
DEALING WITH THIS, UM LACK OF
07:05:38.079 --> 07:05:40.581
WATER AND A DROUGHT SITUATION
07:05:40.648 --> 07:05:44.218
AND SHORTAGES AND, UM I
07:05:44.285 --> 07:05:45.853
PREDICTED SOME POINT. THE
07:05:45.920 --> 07:05:46.787
SHORTAGES ARE GOING TO BE SUCH
07:05:46.854 --> 07:05:48.723
THAT YOU'LL HAVE PEOPLE FROM ONE
07:05:48.789 --> 07:05:50.725
REGION OF THE STATE. THAT DON'T
07:05:50.791 --> 07:05:52.727
HAVE ENOUGH TO MEET THEIR BASIC
07:05:52.793 --> 07:05:54.428
NEEDS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE
07:05:54.495 --> 07:05:56.864
STATE WHERE THEY'RE WATERING, UM
07:05:56.931 --> 07:05:57.732
, GOLF COURSES. I'M NOT WITH
07:05:57.798 --> 07:06:00.134
RECYCLED WATER, BUT, UM, WITH
07:06:00.201 --> 07:06:01.402
WATER THAT PEOPLE CAN CONSUME
07:06:01.469 --> 07:06:04.739
PORTABLE PORTABLE WATER. AND UM
07:06:04.805 --> 07:06:07.174
AND IT'LL BE IT'LL BE. IT'LL BE
07:06:07.241 --> 07:06:09.510
A DISASTER FOR THE STATE OF
07:06:09.577 --> 07:06:10.845
CALIFORNIA. SO ANYWAY, WE'LL
07:06:10.912 --> 07:06:12.146
ALLOW YOU TO CONCLUDE THAT'S ALL
07:06:12.213 --> 07:06:14.081
WE'VE DUMPED A LOT ON YOUR PLATE
07:06:14.148 --> 07:06:16.183
HERE AND SO UM, THANK YOU FOR
07:06:16.250 --> 07:06:19.120
YOUR INDULGENCE. I WANT TO THANK
07:06:19.186 --> 07:06:19.754
ALL FIVE OF YOU FOR YOUR
07:06:19.820 --> 07:06:22.857
ATTENTION. AND YOUR COMMENTS. UM
07:06:22.924 --> 07:06:24.725
I REALLY DO APPRECIATE IT. THE
07:06:24.792 --> 07:06:26.761
FIRST THING I JUST WOULD LIKE TO
07:06:26.827 --> 07:06:29.163
SAY IS LIKE MANY OF YOU KNOW,
07:06:29.230 --> 07:06:30.831
SOME OF YOU HAVE REALLY CUT YOUR
07:06:30.898 --> 07:06:32.800
TEETH ON WATER AND HAVE WORKED
07:06:32.867 --> 07:06:34.669
ON THIS ISSUE. I WOULD JUST LIKE
07:06:34.735 --> 07:06:35.836
TO RESPECTFULLY REQUESTS THE
07:06:35.903 --> 07:06:37.838
OPPORTUNITY TO JOIN WITH YOU.
07:06:37.905 --> 07:06:39.674
AND TRY TO MOVE WATER BECAUSE,
07:06:39.740 --> 07:06:43.010
AS I SAID, YOU MISSED THE THOSE
07:06:43.077 --> 07:06:46.047
COMMENTS CHAIR, BUT I SAID THE
07:06:46.113 --> 07:06:46.681
HARDEST THING TO DO IN
07:06:46.747 --> 07:06:47.748
CALIFORNIA IN THE CALIFORNIA
07:06:47.815 --> 07:06:49.650
LEGISLATURE IS TO MOVE THE WATER
07:06:49.717 --> 07:06:50.718
BILL REALLY TRY. IT'S REALLY
07:06:50.785 --> 07:06:52.853
TRUE. THERE IS SO MUCH FEAR THAT
07:06:52.920 --> 07:06:54.588
IS IMMEDIATELY GENERATED PEOPLE
07:06:54.655 --> 07:06:56.290
THINK. OH, THIS CHANGE IS GOING
07:06:56.357 --> 07:06:58.225
TO AND SO IT'S THE EASIEST THING
07:06:58.292 --> 07:07:00.828
TO DO WAS TO BLOCK CHANGE AND IN
07:07:00.895 --> 07:07:01.829
A DEMOCRATIC SYSTEM, LIKE WE
07:07:01.896 --> 07:07:03.898
HAVE A CHEESY TO BLOCK CHANGE,
07:07:03.965 --> 07:07:05.866
SO I WOULD WELCOME THE
07:07:05.933 --> 07:07:08.469
OPPORTUNITY TO TRY TO WORK WITH
07:07:08.536 --> 07:07:09.971
WORK WITH YOU AND COME UP WITH
07:07:10.037 --> 07:07:12.640
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS, AND I WILL
07:07:12.707 --> 07:07:14.208
. I WILL CERTAINLY REACH OUT
07:07:14.275 --> 07:07:15.743
SENATOR HIRSCHBERG. YOUR
07:07:15.810 --> 07:07:17.645
COMMENTS ABOUT YOU HAVE CONCERNS
07:07:17.712 --> 07:07:20.614
WE HAVEN'T HAD I DEFINITELY
07:07:20.681 --> 07:07:22.850
WOULD LIKE TO HEAR AND I HAVE
07:07:22.917 --> 07:07:25.152
BEEN COMPLETELY OPEN TO TRY TO
07:07:25.219 --> 07:07:27.288
HEAR IMPROVEMENTS AS LONG AS
07:07:27.355 --> 07:07:29.323
THEY CAPTURE THE ESSENCE OF WHAT
07:07:29.390 --> 07:07:32.159
THE BILL IS TRYING TO DO. AND IF
07:07:32.226 --> 07:07:35.162
I COULD GO TO THAT THEREIS A
07:07:35.229 --> 07:07:37.198
SIGNIFICANT FRUSTRATION WITH THE
07:07:37.264 --> 07:07:38.866
EXECUTIVE ORDER OUT THERE. THE
07:07:38.933 --> 07:07:40.601
EXECUTIVE ORDER, AS WAS POINTED
07:07:40.668 --> 07:07:42.069
OUT TALKS ABOUT SUBSIDENCE AND
07:07:42.136 --> 07:07:44.071
HOW DIFFICULT IT IS TO TRY TO
07:07:44.138 --> 07:07:46.173
SAY WHETHER THIS WELL IS GOING
07:07:46.240 --> 07:07:47.608
TO LEAD TO SUBSIDENCE OR NOT,
07:07:47.675 --> 07:07:49.143
ETCETERA. I WOULD POINT OUT
07:07:49.210 --> 07:07:50.644
THAT'S ONE OF THE BENEFITS OF
07:07:50.711 --> 07:07:52.179
MOVING FORWARD WITH THIS BILL.
07:07:52.246 --> 07:07:53.647
THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD. YOU
07:07:53.714 --> 07:07:54.982
DON'T NEED THE EXECUTIVE ORDER
07:07:55.049 --> 07:07:57.151
AND THIS BILL WILL BE BETTER.
07:07:57.218 --> 07:07:58.686
THAN THE EXECUTIVE ORDER. IT
07:07:58.753 --> 07:08:00.755
DOESN'T DEAL WITH SUBSIDENCE
07:08:00.821 --> 07:08:02.156
WILLING TO HAVE ONE OF THE
07:08:02.223 --> 07:08:04.158
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'RE WILLING TO
07:08:04.225 --> 07:08:04.692
TAKE. WE WON'T DEAL WITH
07:08:04.759 --> 07:08:06.227
SUBSIDENCE WILL ONLY DEAL WITH
07:08:06.293 --> 07:08:08.162
THE IMPACT ON NEIGHBORING WELSH,
07:08:08.229 --> 07:08:10.131
FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE STUDY. THERE
07:08:10.197 --> 07:08:11.632
ARE ALL KINDS OF THINGS ABOUT
07:08:11.699 --> 07:08:13.734
THIS BILL THAT I THINK YOU WOULD
07:08:13.801 --> 07:08:14.802
FIND BETTER THAN THE EXECUTIVE
07:08:14.869 --> 07:08:16.904
ORDER ALL OF THESE THINGS THAT
07:08:16.971 --> 07:08:17.805
WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO NEGOTIATE
07:08:17.872 --> 07:08:19.673
WITH THE PSAS AND THE SMALL
07:08:19.740 --> 07:08:21.609
FARMERS. ARE NOT IN THE
07:08:21.675 --> 07:08:23.077
EXECUTIVE ORDER, BUT THEY'RE IN
07:08:23.144 --> 07:08:25.246
THIS BILL. THEY WOULD BE BETTER
07:08:25.312 --> 07:08:27.548
OFF IF WE MOVE THIS BILL THAN IF
07:08:27.615 --> 07:08:29.617
WE LIVE WITH THE EXECUTIVE
07:08:29.683 --> 07:08:31.552
ORDER. SO I DO WANT TO SAY THAT.
07:08:31.619 --> 07:08:34.488
I APPRECIATE YOUR CONCERN, AND I
07:08:34.555 --> 07:08:37.425
PROBABLY AND I WOULD ADMIT I
07:08:37.491 --> 07:08:40.361
PROBABLY OVEREMPHASIZED THE OUT
07:08:40.428 --> 07:08:43.130
OF STATE ASPECT OF THE BUT THERE
07:08:43.197 --> 07:08:44.565
ARE OUT OF STATE INVESTMENT
07:08:44.632 --> 07:08:46.634
BANKERS THAT HAVE COME IN AND
07:08:46.700 --> 07:08:49.236
THIS HAS BEEN GIVEN TO ME BY
07:08:49.303 --> 07:08:50.738
SOME OF THE MEMBERS OF THE
07:08:50.805 --> 07:08:51.739
VARIOUS ORGANIZATIONS THAT HAVE
07:08:51.806 --> 07:08:52.940
TALKING ABOUT BEING OPPOSED THIS
07:08:53.007 --> 07:08:54.642
AND THEY'RE REALLY FRUSTRATED BY
07:08:54.708 --> 07:08:56.444
THIS SO THERE ARE OUT OF STATE,
07:08:56.510 --> 07:08:57.778
BUT MIGHT THE INTENTION OF THE
07:08:57.845 --> 07:08:59.480
BILL TO BE VERY CLEAR AND
07:08:59.547 --> 07:09:01.615
HONEST. HERE IS ALL NEW
07:09:01.682 --> 07:09:03.784
EXTRACTIONS FROM THE AQUIFER
07:09:03.851 --> 07:09:05.519
OUGHT TO BE REVIEWED BY THE
07:09:05.586 --> 07:09:06.821
GSA'S. IN OTHER WORDS, IF
07:09:06.887 --> 07:09:08.622
SOMEBODY WANTS TO COME IN
07:09:08.689 --> 07:09:10.491
WHETHER THEY'RE FROM OUT OF
07:09:10.558 --> 07:09:11.926
STATE OR IN STATE, AND THEY WANT
07:09:11.992 --> 07:09:13.727
TO SAY, YOU KNOW, WE'RE GOING TO
07:09:13.794 --> 07:09:16.130
BUY THIS PROPERTY RIGHT NEXT TO
07:09:16.197 --> 07:09:17.832
THIS THIS OPERATION. IT HASN'T
07:09:17.898 --> 07:09:19.567
HAD ANY ANY AGRICULTURE ON IT
07:09:19.633 --> 07:09:21.569
YET, AND WE'RE GOING TO SINK THE
07:09:21.635 --> 07:09:22.770
DOZENS OF NEW WELLS AND PUT IN
07:09:22.837 --> 07:09:24.805
ALMOND TREES. THERE SHOULD BE
07:09:24.872 --> 07:09:26.807
THE G S A. THAT'S IN CHARGE OF
07:09:26.874 --> 07:09:29.343
THAT BASIN. DOES NOT HAVE THE
07:09:29.410 --> 07:09:31.712
TOOLS TO SAY NO RIGHT NOW. AND
07:09:31.779 --> 07:09:33.848
THE PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING TO BE
07:09:33.914 --> 07:09:36.150
HURT FROM THAT NEED THE TO HAVE
07:09:36.217 --> 07:09:38.552
THAT TOOL, WHETHER THEY USE IT
07:09:38.619 --> 07:09:40.387
AND HOW ALL THAT THAT'S THAT'S
07:09:40.454 --> 07:09:42.423
THAT'S LEFT TO THE LOCALS. SO I
07:09:42.490 --> 07:09:43.891
HOPE THAT THAT'S A CLARIFICATION
07:09:43.958 --> 07:09:47.361
AND IN MY WE WERE IN THE HALLWAY
07:09:47.428 --> 07:09:48.696
. WE DIDN'T HAVE MUCH TIME TO
07:09:48.762 --> 07:09:50.531
TALK, SO I JUST WANTED TO USE
07:09:50.598 --> 07:09:52.399
THAT AS AN EXAMPLE. RIGHT NOW,
07:09:52.466 --> 07:09:53.601
THE GSA'S CAN'T STOP THE OUT OF
07:09:53.667 --> 07:09:54.702
STATE OR THE IN STATE.
07:09:54.768 --> 07:09:57.571
INAPPROPRIATE EXPANSION OF WELL
07:09:57.638 --> 07:10:00.107
ACTIVITY. AND IF I IF I COULD
07:10:00.174 --> 07:10:02.076
POINT OUT THAT, YOU KNOW THE
07:10:02.143 --> 07:10:04.011
COMMENT WAS MADE, YOU KNOW RIGHT
07:10:04.078 --> 07:10:05.246
AWAY. THERE'S ALWAYS A CHANGE.
07:10:05.312 --> 07:10:08.115
THIS IS EIGHT YEARS AFTER SEQUA.
07:10:08.182 --> 07:10:09.783
THAT THIS IS CERTAINLY THE MOST
07:10:09.850 --> 07:10:11.318
SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN SEQUA IN
07:10:11.385 --> 07:10:12.853
IN THE EIGHT YEARS AND IT'S NOT
07:10:12.920 --> 07:10:14.755
THAT SIGNIFICANT. IT'S SIMPLY
07:10:14.822 --> 07:10:16.824
SAYS THAT THE WELL PERMITTING
07:10:16.891 --> 07:10:17.958
THAT HAS BEEN DONE BY THE
07:10:18.025 --> 07:10:19.727
COUNTIES. IF YOU LOOK AT THE
07:10:19.793 --> 07:10:21.629
DATA, I THINK YOU CAN MAKE A
07:10:21.695 --> 07:10:24.398
STRONG CASE THAT IT HAS NOT BEEN
07:10:24.465 --> 07:10:26.333
SUFFICIENTLY STRINGENT ENOUGH TO
07:10:26.400 --> 07:10:28.002
STOP THE VERY THINGS THAT I JUST
07:10:28.068 --> 07:10:32.239
MENTIONED. OUT THERE. AND SO
07:10:32.306 --> 07:10:33.841
THIS IS A COMMON SENSE FIXED.
07:10:33.908 --> 07:10:34.975
IT'S STILL ALLOWS THE COUNTIES
07:10:35.042 --> 07:10:37.978
TO DO THE PERMIT. IT JUST SAYS
07:10:38.045 --> 07:10:40.147
THE COUNTY'S CHECK WITH THE CIA
07:10:40.214 --> 07:10:41.582
AS THEY'RE GETTING READY TO MOVE
07:10:41.649 --> 07:10:42.650
FORWARD. AND THE FINAL THING I
07:10:42.716 --> 07:10:44.485
WOULD I WOULD JUST LEAVE YOU
07:10:44.552 --> 07:10:46.954
WITH AND A QUICK EXAMPLE IN THE
07:10:47.021 --> 07:10:49.290
COUNTY OF VENTURA THAT WE HAD A
07:10:49.356 --> 07:10:50.357
GROUNDWATER AGENCY THAT WAS
07:10:50.424 --> 07:10:52.593
ESTABLISHED BEFORE SIX. AND WHEN
07:10:52.660 --> 07:10:54.195
SIGMA WAS PASSED, ALL OF A
07:10:54.261 --> 07:10:55.629
SUDDEN THERE WAS A RUSH OF NEW
07:10:55.696 --> 07:10:57.298
WELL PERMITS. EVERYBODY WANTED
07:10:57.364 --> 07:10:58.599
TO GET THEIR PERMIT IN BECAUSE
07:10:58.666 --> 07:10:59.733
SIGMA WAS COMING. THEY DIDN'T
07:10:59.800 --> 07:11:01.869
KNOW WHAT IT WAS GOING TO MEAN.
07:11:01.936 --> 07:11:05.839
WE WE, THE GROUNDWATER AGENCY
07:11:05.906 --> 07:11:07.041
THOSE OF UNDERGROUND ASKED THE
07:11:07.107 --> 07:11:09.243
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS TO
07:11:09.310 --> 07:11:10.844
DO A WELL MORATORIUM JUST UNTIL
07:11:10.911 --> 07:11:13.714
WE GOT THE PLAN READY. BECAUSE
07:11:13.781 --> 07:11:15.883
WHAT WE RECOGNIZED AND WHAT I
07:11:15.950 --> 07:11:16.984
HOPE THAT YOU WOULD RECOGNIZE IS
07:11:17.051 --> 07:11:19.853
THAT, UM IF THERE AND THERE HAVE
07:11:19.920 --> 07:11:23.757
BEEN 6000 NEW WELLS PUT INTO THE
07:11:23.824 --> 07:11:24.892
OVER DRAFTED BASINS IN SAN
07:11:24.959 --> 07:11:27.728
JOAQUIN VALLEY SINCE SIX NOW.
07:11:27.795 --> 07:11:31.298
THAT'S 6000 COMPLICATIONS. 6000
07:11:31.365 --> 07:11:34.268
PROBLEMS BECAUSE WE SAY THAT THE
07:11:34.335 --> 07:11:35.135
GSS CAN DO WHATEVER THEY WANT,
07:11:35.202 --> 07:11:37.838
BUT WE ALL KNOW THERE IS 11
07:11:37.905 --> 07:11:38.906
LAWSUIT AFTER ANOTHER AFTER
07:11:38.973 --> 07:11:39.907
ANOTHER WATER LAWSUITS OUT
07:11:39.974 --> 07:11:42.710
THERE. AND A LAWSUIT IS
07:11:42.776 --> 07:11:44.878
STRONGER. IF YOU CAN SAY LOOK, I
07:11:44.945 --> 07:11:45.946
GOT MY WELL PERMITTED FOUR YEARS
07:11:46.013 --> 07:11:47.581
AGO FIVE YEARS AGO, AND WE'VE
07:11:47.648 --> 07:11:49.550
HAD THIS WELL IN THERE AND THE
07:11:49.617 --> 07:11:51.719
GS ASAR STRUGGLING TO SORT OF
07:11:51.785 --> 07:11:52.987
GET ALL OF THEIR RULES AND STUFF
07:11:53.053 --> 07:11:55.189
IN PLACE. THIS GIVES THEM THE
07:11:55.256 --> 07:11:57.658
FLEXIBILITY TO SAY, YOU KNOW,
07:11:57.725 --> 07:11:59.293
OUR POLICY IS WE'RE NOT GOING TO
07:11:59.360 --> 07:12:00.728
DO ANYTHING FOR A WHILE, OR
07:12:00.794 --> 07:12:02.196
WELLS THAT HAVE A CERTAIN AMOUNT
07:12:02.263 --> 07:12:04.531
OF EXPANSION. BUT THIS IS NOT A
07:12:04.598 --> 07:12:06.467
ONE SIZE FIX. ALL SOLUTION. THIS
07:12:06.533 --> 07:12:09.703
IS EVERY LOCAL GSA. CAN COME UP
07:12:09.770 --> 07:12:11.538
WITH ITS OWN SOLUTION WITH THE
07:12:11.605 --> 07:12:13.741
WAY THIS BILL IS WORDED JUST TO
07:12:13.807 --> 07:12:15.943
MEET THEIR PARTICULAR NEEDS, AND
07:12:16.010 --> 07:12:17.411
I THINK THAT THAT'S IMPORTANT
07:12:17.478 --> 07:12:19.713
FOR ME TO END ON THAT. SO I
07:12:19.780 --> 07:12:21.081
APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS. I
07:12:21.148 --> 07:12:22.483
APPRECIATE THE WILLINGNESS TO
07:12:22.549 --> 07:12:25.853
LET THIS BILL STAY ALIVE. AND IN
07:12:25.919 --> 07:12:28.188
WITH AS GOOD A FAITH AS I CAN
07:12:28.255 --> 07:12:29.056
POSSIBLY PLEDGED YOU. I WILL DO
07:12:29.123 --> 07:12:30.691
EVERYTHING I CAN TO TRY TO BOTH
07:12:30.758 --> 07:12:32.860
HOLD ON TO THE ESSENCE OF THE
07:12:32.926 --> 07:12:34.161
BILL AND MAKE IT OPERATIONALLY
07:12:34.228 --> 07:12:36.163
AS FUNCTIONAL AS POSSIBLE. I
07:12:36.230 --> 07:12:37.598
WANT TO THANK YOU. THANK YOUR
07:12:37.665 --> 07:12:39.800
STAFF, WHO IN A SHORT PERIOD OF
07:12:39.867 --> 07:12:41.835
TIME GOT BOMBARDED WITH AN AWFUL
07:12:41.902 --> 07:12:43.570
LOT. I ALSO WANT TO THANK BOTH
07:12:43.637 --> 07:12:44.571
THE SUPPORTERS AND THE
07:12:44.638 --> 07:12:47.207
OPPOSITION OUT THERE. WE'VE HAD
07:12:47.274 --> 07:12:48.709
GOOD CONVERSATIONS WITH LOTS OF
07:12:48.776 --> 07:12:51.478
PEOPLE, AND YOU SAW A NUMBER OF
07:12:51.545 --> 07:12:52.346
ORGANIZATIONS SWITCH FROM
07:12:52.413 --> 07:12:54.448
OPPOSITION TO SUPPORT AND I
07:12:54.515 --> 07:12:56.250
INVITE THOSE PEOPLE THAT HAVE
07:12:56.317 --> 07:12:57.818
NOT COME UP WITH SPECIFIC AND,
07:12:57.885 --> 07:13:00.120
YOU KNOW, SUGGESTED CHANGES.
07:13:00.187 --> 07:13:02.122
THAT WE ARE OPEN TO ALL OF THOSE
07:13:02.189 --> 07:13:03.857
ORGANIZATIONS AS WE GO FORWARD.
07:13:03.924 --> 07:13:05.693
THE FINAL THING I WOULD OFFER
07:13:05.759 --> 07:13:08.362
WHEN WE HAD THE VOTE AND THE
07:13:08.429 --> 07:13:10.898
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ROOM. FOR
07:13:10.964 --> 07:13:12.966
THE WELL MORATORIUM THE NIGHT
07:13:13.033 --> 07:13:14.802
BEFORE THE VOTE. I HAD A NUMBER
07:13:14.868 --> 07:13:16.870
OF PEOPLE IN THE EGG INDUSTRY,
07:13:16.937 --> 07:13:18.305
LARGE FORM, BUT LARGE GROWERS,
07:13:18.372 --> 07:13:19.606
LANDOWNERS, ETCETERA, CONTACT ME
07:13:19.673 --> 07:13:23.110
AND SAY THERE'S AN ALL POINTS
07:13:23.177 --> 07:13:23.877
BULLETIN. WE'RE ALL SUPPOSED TO
07:13:23.944 --> 07:13:24.878
BE IN THE BOARDROOM AND
07:13:24.945 --> 07:13:26.714
OPPOSITION TO YOUR BILL. I'M
07:13:26.780 --> 07:13:28.282
GOING TO BE THERE, BUT I WANT
07:13:28.349 --> 07:13:30.250
YOU TO KNOW I'M NOT GOING TO SAY
07:13:30.317 --> 07:13:32.386
ANYTHING, BUT I'M ACTUALLY NOT
07:13:32.453 --> 07:13:33.554
IN OPPOSITION TO YOUR BILL, BUT
07:13:33.620 --> 07:13:34.755
I CAN'T BE PUBLIC ABOUT THAT.
07:13:34.822 --> 07:13:37.691
AND I HAVE HEARD FROM PEOPLE IN
07:13:37.758 --> 07:13:39.226
SOME OF THE ORGANIZATIONS THAT
07:13:39.293 --> 07:13:40.561
HAVE TOLD YOU TODAY THEY'RE
07:13:40.627 --> 07:13:42.129
OPPOSED. I'VE HEARD FROM THEIR
07:13:42.196 --> 07:13:44.531
MEMBERS WHO SAY YOU KNOW WHAT
07:13:44.598 --> 07:13:46.934
THIS BILL IS REALLY GOING TO BE
07:13:47.000 --> 07:13:48.001
HELPED SOLVE SOME OF THE
07:13:48.068 --> 07:13:49.603
PROBLEMS THAT WE HAVE. OF THESE
07:13:49.670 --> 07:13:51.271
NEW WELLS IMPACTING OUR EXISTING
07:13:51.338 --> 07:13:52.673
OPERATIONS. THOSE RICE FARMERS
07:13:52.740 --> 07:13:56.477
NEED TO BE PROTECTED. AND THAT
07:13:56.543 --> 07:13:58.645
TOOL HAS TO BE GIVEN TO THE G S
07:13:58.712 --> 07:13:59.980
A. C FOR THAT PROTECTION TAKE
07:14:00.047 --> 07:14:01.915
PLACE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
07:14:01.982 --> 07:14:02.950
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
07:14:03.016 --> 07:14:04.551
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE
07:14:04.618 --> 07:14:10.591
HAVE EMOTION. DO WE HAVE? DON'T
07:14:10.657 --> 07:14:13.360
I DON'T BELIEVE SO. SO SENATOR
07:14:13.427 --> 07:14:15.629
GERARDO DURAZO MAKES THE MOTION.
07:14:15.696 --> 07:14:24.671
UM THE MOTION IS. WHERE IS HE
07:14:24.738 --> 07:14:26.607
NEED TO FIND OUT WHERE IT'S
07:14:26.673 --> 07:14:31.945
GOING TO. K<c.cyan>. THE MOTION WOULD</c>
07:14:32.012 --> 07:14:34.481
BE DO PASS AND WE REFER TO THE
07:14:34.548 --> 07:14:35.616
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
07:14:35.682 --> 07:14:36.784
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
07:14:36.850 --> 07:14:42.089
CABALLERO VOTING NIELSEN.
07:14:42.156 --> 07:14:46.260
NIELSEN NO, DURAZO. AYE HERZBERG
07:14:46.326 --> 07:14:50.164
HERZBERG. AYE WIENER. WIENER I 3
07:14:50.230 --> 07:14:55.302
TO 1. THAT BILL IS OUT 321. OKAY
07:14:55.369 --> 07:14:57.337
SO IT LOOKS LIKE WHAT WE SHOULD
07:14:57.404 --> 07:15:03.444
DO IS UM. GO THROUGH THE ENTIRE
07:15:03.510 --> 07:15:04.745
LIST? YES, AND THAT WAS OUR LAST
07:15:04.812 --> 07:15:08.949
HEARING. MM. SO WE'LL START WITH
07:15:09.016 --> 07:15:12.286
FILE ITEM NUMBER ONE A. B 2011
07:15:12.352 --> 07:15:14.221
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS.
07:15:14.288 --> 07:15:19.993
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
07:15:20.060 --> 07:15:33.740
OKAY?
07:15:33.807 --> 07:15:35.609
WAS THERE. OH, YES. YOU WANTED
07:15:35.676 --> 07:15:37.644
TO MAKE A COMMENT ON THIS. SO MY
07:15:37.711 --> 07:15:39.112
APOLOGIES. I TOTALLY FORGOT.
07:15:39.179 --> 07:15:40.414
THANK THANK YOU, I BECAUSE WE'RE
07:15:40.481 --> 07:15:42.115
ALL IN DIFFERENT PLACES AT THE
07:15:42.182 --> 07:15:44.218
SAME TIME WAS UNABLE TO BE HERE
07:15:44.284 --> 07:15:47.354
DURING THE PRESENTATION AND
07:15:47.421 --> 07:15:52.125
EARLIER VOTE ON A B 2011 AND I
07:15:52.192 --> 07:15:54.328
JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT, UM UH,
07:15:54.394 --> 07:15:57.831
TODAY I'LL BE SUPPORTIVE. AH OF
07:15:57.898 --> 07:15:58.699
THE MEASURE, BUT I AM VERY
07:15:58.765 --> 07:16:01.802
SERIOUSLY CONCERNED ABOUT TWO
07:16:01.869 --> 07:16:04.004
AREAS, AFFORDABILITY AND THE
07:16:04.071 --> 07:16:06.874
LABOR STANDARDS. UM AND I WILL
07:16:06.940 --> 07:16:08.509
WITHDRAW MY SUPPORT IF SUCH
07:16:08.575 --> 07:16:10.377
ISSUES ARE NOT ADDRESSED THINGS
07:16:10.444 --> 07:16:14.314
LIKE, UH, GENTRIFICATION AND
07:16:14.381 --> 07:16:16.683
COMMUTE, DISPLACING BYE BYE,
07:16:16.750 --> 07:16:18.952
RIGHT DEVELOPMENT. WE'RE NOT. I
07:16:19.019 --> 07:16:21.755
DON'T THINK WE'RE GETTING ENOUGH
07:16:21.822 --> 07:16:23.290
FOR THE BENEFITS THAT WERE, UH
07:16:23.357 --> 07:16:25.259
GRANTING TO DEVELOPERS 15% TO
07:16:25.325 --> 07:16:28.095
ME. DOES NOT MEET WHAT WE SHOULD
07:16:28.161 --> 07:16:30.831
BE GETTING OUT OF THIS. UM AND
07:16:30.898 --> 07:16:32.499
OF COURSE, I THINK LIKE MOST
07:16:32.566 --> 07:16:34.635
PEOPLE, I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE
07:16:34.701 --> 07:16:36.770
LABOR BECOME MUCH MORE UNIFIED
07:16:36.837 --> 07:16:39.172
ON ON THE ISSUES OF LABOR
07:16:39.239 --> 07:16:40.240
STANDARDS. I APPRECIATE ALL THE
07:16:40.307 --> 07:16:42.976
WORK. THAT THEY ARE ALL DOING ON
07:16:43.043 --> 07:16:45.812
THIS. UM AH. SO I JUST WANTED TO
07:16:45.879 --> 07:16:48.215
MAKE THAT SINCE I WAS UNABLE TO
07:16:48.282 --> 07:16:49.816
BE HERE AT THE TIME OF THE VOTE.
07:16:49.883 --> 07:16:51.485
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. VERY
07:16:51.552 --> 07:16:54.154
GOOD. SO WE'LL MAKE A STATEMENT
07:16:54.221 --> 07:16:56.189
TO SURE YOU MIGHT AS WELL BUT WE
07:16:56.256 --> 07:16:58.458
HAVE TO BE DONE IN AN HOUR
07:16:58.525 --> 07:17:00.127
BECAUSE WE GO BACK TO SESSIONS.
07:17:00.193 --> 07:17:01.762
YEAH MY UNDERSTANDING THAT NEEDS
07:17:01.828 --> 07:17:04.131
TO FOLLOW ON TO DRAW ALSO SAID
07:17:04.197 --> 07:17:05.732
THAT THE DISCUSSION RESTRICTION
07:17:05.799 --> 07:17:07.568
LABOR STANDARDS, UM, THAT THE
07:17:07.634 --> 07:17:09.236
BILL OF WHICH YOUR MEASURE THAT
07:17:09.303 --> 07:17:11.438
WAS IN HOUSING, THE LANGUAGE HAS
07:17:11.505 --> 07:17:13.040
BEEN PUT BACK IN ITS MOVED TO
07:17:13.106 --> 07:17:14.174
ASSEMBLY APPROACH. THIS MEASURE
07:17:14.241 --> 07:17:15.242
IS BEING MOVED TO SENATOR
07:17:15.309 --> 07:17:17.044
PROBES. AND THAT DURING THE
07:17:17.110 --> 07:17:19.346
BREAK, WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE
07:17:19.413 --> 07:17:20.013
TO HAVE THOSE DISCUSSIONS AND IT
07:17:20.080 --> 07:17:22.115
THIS IS AN ACCOMMODATION TO
07:17:22.182 --> 07:17:22.983
ALLOW THAT TO OCCUR, BUT THAT'S
07:17:23.050 --> 07:17:26.253
ALL IT MEANS. THAT IS CORRECT.
07:17:26.320 --> 07:17:27.421
VERY GOOD, SO WE'LL CALL THE
07:17:27.487 --> 07:17:32.359
ABSENT MEMBERS. FIRE ITEM NUMBER
07:17:32.426 --> 07:17:36.163
ONE A B 2011 MOTION IS TO PASS.
07:17:36.229 --> 07:17:37.598
BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO THE
07:17:37.664 --> 07:17:39.032
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
07:17:39.099 --> 07:17:43.036
CHAIR VOTING. I SO I HERZBERG
07:17:43.103 --> 07:17:45.706
HERZBERG. I FIGHT A ZERO THAT
07:17:45.772 --> 07:17:51.612
BILL IS OUT. UM VILE ITEM NUMBER
07:17:51.678 --> 07:17:53.413
TWO A B 23 34 BY
07:17:53.480 --> 07:17:56.650
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS. MOTION
07:17:56.717 --> 07:17:58.719
IS TO PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST
07:17:58.785 --> 07:18:00.120
AMENDMENT AND WE REFERRED TO THE
07:18:00.187 --> 07:18:01.822
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
07:18:01.888 --> 07:18:03.490
CHAIR VOTING. I HERZBERG
07:18:03.557 --> 07:18:08.829
HERZBERG, I 41 THAT BILL IS OUT.
07:18:08.895 --> 07:18:10.764
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
07:18:10.831 --> 07:18:12.399
THREE. MAYBE 4 98. BY
07:18:12.466 --> 07:18:16.470
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA.
07:18:16.536 --> 07:18:18.271
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
07:18:18.338 --> 07:18:20.841
AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMEND AND WE
07:18:20.907 --> 07:18:22.042
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:18:22.109 --> 07:18:23.010
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
07:18:23.076 --> 07:18:28.382
ROLL. CURRENT VOTE IS FOR THIS
07:18:28.448 --> 07:18:31.685
ZERO CHAIR VOTING. I HERTZBERG
07:18:31.752 --> 07:18:34.287
AYE, HERZBERG. I FIND WITH ZERO
07:18:34.354 --> 07:18:37.457
THAT BILL IS OUT. MOVING ON TO
07:18:37.524 --> 07:18:40.827
FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR A B 20 TO
07:18:40.894 --> 07:18:41.795
21 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
07:18:41.862 --> 07:18:45.632
QUIRK-SILVA. THE MOTION WAS DUE
07:18:45.699 --> 07:18:46.833
PAST AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST
07:18:46.900 --> 07:18:48.702
AMENDMENT AND WE REFER TO THE
07:18:48.769 --> 07:18:49.369
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
07:18:49.436 --> 07:18:53.240
CURRENT VOTE IS 4 TO 0. CHAIR
07:18:53.306 --> 07:18:56.309
VOTING. I HERZBERG HERZBERG. I 5
07:18:56.376 --> 07:18:59.980
TO 0. THAT BILL IS OUT BEGAN TO
07:19:00.047 --> 07:19:01.415
FILE ITEM NUMBER FIVE. MAYBE 9
07:19:01.481 --> 07:19:05.018
16 BY SALAS. THE MOTION WAS DO
07:19:05.085 --> 07:19:06.953
PASS AND RE REFERRED TO THE
07:19:07.020 --> 07:19:09.256
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
07:19:09.322 --> 07:19:11.391
CURRENT VOTE IS 2 TO 0 CHAIR,
07:19:11.458 --> 07:19:15.529
NOT VOTING. OR. NO VOTE
07:19:15.595 --> 07:19:19.132
RECORDED. CABALLERO AYE.
07:19:19.199 --> 07:19:20.834
CABALLERO I HERZBERG HERZBERG.
07:19:20.901 --> 07:19:25.138
AYE, WIENER. WINNER. I'M 5 TO 0.
07:19:25.205 --> 07:19:29.576
THAT GOES OUT. WHEN WE GOT INTO
07:19:29.643 --> 07:19:31.878
FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX A. B 15 15
07:19:31.945 --> 07:19:36.183
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO.
07:19:36.249 --> 07:19:37.784
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
07:19:37.851 --> 07:19:39.886
AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMEND AND WE
07:19:39.953 --> 07:19:41.588
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:19:41.655 --> 07:19:42.522
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
07:19:42.589 --> 07:19:45.859
ROLL. CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0
07:19:45.926 --> 07:19:47.894
CHAIR VOTING. I HERZBERG
07:19:47.961 --> 07:19:50.497
HERZBERG. AYE WIENER WIENER. I
07:19:50.564 --> 07:19:54.468
FIGHT A ZERO BILL IS OUT. FILE
07:19:54.534 --> 07:19:56.036
ITEM NUMBER 79 A B 1925 BY
07:19:56.103 --> 07:19:59.740
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO. D<c.cyan></c>
07:19:59.806 --> 07:20:01.274
PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMEND
07:20:01.341 --> 07:20:03.176
AND RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
07:20:03.243 --> 07:20:05.312
ON APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE
07:20:05.378 --> 07:20:07.180
IS 2 TO 0 CHAIR VOTING. I'M
07:20:07.247 --> 07:20:11.752
NIELSEN. NIELSEN NO. HERZBERG
07:20:11.818 --> 07:20:15.956
HERZBERG. AYE, WIENER. SEVEN.
07:20:16.022 --> 07:20:24.731
1925. WIENER. I'M 41. THAT BILL
07:20:24.798 --> 07:20:26.933
IS OUT, MOVING UNDER FILE ITEM
07:20:27.000 --> 07:20:30.871
NUMBER NINE. A B 18 45 BY
07:20:30.937 --> 07:20:34.441
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CALLED IRAN.
07:20:34.508 --> 07:20:36.443
THE MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
07:20:36.510 --> 07:20:38.245
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:20:38.311 --> 07:20:39.379
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
07:20:39.446 --> 07:20:45.018
3 TO 0. NO CURRENT VOTE FOR THE
07:20:45.085 --> 07:20:47.854
CHAIR. CABALLERO I CABALLERO I
07:20:47.921 --> 07:20:52.392
HERTZBERG. 18.5 HERZBERG. I
07:20:52.459 --> 07:20:57.864
FIGHT A ZERO. MOVING ON TO FILE
07:20:57.931 --> 07:21:00.867
ITEM NUMBER 10 A B 18 50 BY
07:21:00.934 --> 07:21:05.839
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD. AH! THE
07:21:05.906 --> 07:21:08.375
MOTION. WELL, I THE MOTION WAS
07:21:08.441 --> 07:21:12.779
DUE PASSED TO THE SENATE FLOOR.
07:21:12.846 --> 07:21:16.883
YES SO CURRENT VOTE IS 2 TO 2.
07:21:16.950 --> 07:21:26.593
CHAIR VOTING. NO HERTZBERG. TO
07:21:26.660 --> 07:21:29.296
THE MOTION. THE NEW OUR
07:21:29.362 --> 07:21:37.037
ANNOUNCER. THE BILL IS FAILS. UM
07:21:37.103 --> 07:21:40.407
AND AT IF THERE IS NO OBJECTION
07:21:40.473 --> 07:21:44.511
, WE WILL GRANT RECONSIDERATION.
07:21:44.578 --> 07:21:45.846
THAT SEEING NO OBJECTION WILL
07:21:45.912 --> 07:21:46.913
GRANT RECONSIDERATION AND
07:21:46.980 --> 07:21:50.150
ANOTHER TIME. MOVING ON TO FILE
07:21:50.217 --> 07:21:52.319
ITEM. MADAM CHAIRMAN, SIR WHAT
07:21:52.385 --> 07:21:53.587
WAS THE VOTE? I DIDN'T HEAR TOO
07:21:53.653 --> 07:21:56.756
TOO, OKAY. UM FILE ITEM NUMBER
07:21:56.823 --> 07:22:01.261
11 A B 1951 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
07:22:01.328 --> 07:22:04.898
GREAT GRAYSON. THE MOTION IS DUE
07:22:04.965 --> 07:22:05.665
PASSES AMENDED, BUT FIRST
07:22:05.732 --> 07:22:06.833
AMENDED AND RE REFERRED TO THE
07:22:06.900 --> 07:22:09.169
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
07:22:09.236 --> 07:22:13.006
CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0. NO VOTE
07:22:13.073 --> 07:22:14.574
RECORDED FOR THE CHAIR.
07:22:14.641 --> 07:22:18.745
CABALLERO HERZBERG. HERZBERG I
07:22:18.812 --> 07:22:22.749
FIGHT A ZERO BILL IS OUT. FILE
07:22:22.816 --> 07:22:26.152
ITEM NUMBER 12 21 86. BY
07:22:26.219 --> 07:22:28.321
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON. THAT
07:22:28.388 --> 07:22:30.323
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED,
07:22:30.390 --> 07:22:31.558
BUT FIRST AMEND AND WE REFER TO
07:22:31.625 --> 07:22:34.527
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATION.
07:22:34.594 --> 07:22:36.663
CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0. NO
07:22:36.730 --> 07:22:38.198
CURRENT VOTE FOR THE CHAIR.
07:22:38.265 --> 07:22:41.868
CAVALLERO H
07:22:41.935 --> 07:22:43.136
I FIGHT A ZERO THAT BILL IS
07:22:43.203 --> 07:22:47.707
OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 13 A B 26
07:22:47.774 --> 07:22:50.810
68 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON.
07:22:50.877 --> 07:22:51.945
THE MOTION WAS PASSED TO THE
07:22:52.012 --> 07:22:57.350
FLOOR. CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0.
07:22:57.417 --> 07:22:59.452
NO CURRENT VOTE FOR THE CHAIR.
07:22:59.519 --> 07:23:01.721
CAVALLERO H
07:23:01.788 --> 07:23:05.725
5 TO 0. THAT BILL IS OUT. FILE
07:23:05.792 --> 07:23:09.796
ITEM NUMBER 14. A B 2030 BY
07:23:09.863 --> 07:23:13.099
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ARAMBULA. THE
07:23:13.166 --> 07:23:15.201
MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE REFER
07:23:15.268 --> 07:23:16.269
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:23:16.336 --> 07:23:19.139
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
07:23:19.205 --> 07:23:21.541
FOR 20 CHAIR VOTING. I HERZBERG
07:23:21.608 --> 07:23:25.745
. I'M SORRY, 14. HERTZBERG I 50
07:23:25.812 --> 07:23:29.816
THAT BUILT THAT BUILT RIGHT? ON
07:23:29.883 --> 07:23:42.262
14. NIELSEN. NO. 41. OH, THAT
07:23:42.329 --> 07:23:46.733
FILE ITEM NUMBER 15. AND A B
07:23:46.800 --> 07:23:50.036
2053 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY.
07:23:50.103 --> 07:23:52.272
THE MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
07:23:52.339 --> 07:23:54.307
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:23:54.374 --> 07:23:55.342
APPROPRIATIONS. CAN I MAKE A
07:23:55.408 --> 07:23:56.876
STATEMENT ON THAT, MADAM? SURE
07:23:56.943 --> 07:23:58.044
THANK YOU. SO KINDLY APOLOGIZE.
07:23:58.111 --> 07:23:59.312
I WASN'T HERE FOR THE COMMITTEE
07:23:59.379 --> 07:24:01.314
HEARING AND A VERY PRODUCTIVE
07:24:01.381 --> 07:24:01.982
CONVERSATION WITH THE AUTHOR OF
07:24:02.048 --> 07:24:03.750
THIS MEASURE. I WILL NOT BE
07:24:03.817 --> 07:24:06.353
VOTING FOR THIS TODAY. BUT I
07:24:06.419 --> 07:24:07.954
THINK THAT IF WE CAN DEAL WITH
07:24:08.021 --> 07:24:09.456
THE LABOR STANDARDS, WHICH WE
07:24:09.522 --> 07:24:10.857
CAN PROBABLY DO IN REGARD TO
07:24:10.924 --> 07:24:12.659
SOME OTHER BILLS THAT ARE ALSO
07:24:12.726 --> 07:24:13.927
PENDING. SECONDLY I HAD A COUPLE
07:24:13.994 --> 07:24:14.828
OF ISSUES THAT UNFORTUNATELY
07:24:14.894 --> 07:24:15.929
AGAIN BECAUSE I WAS SO OTHERWISE
07:24:15.996 --> 07:24:16.863
PREOCCUPIED WORKING OTHER
07:24:16.930 --> 07:24:19.132
MATTERS. I DIDN'T GET A CHANCE
07:24:19.199 --> 07:24:21.101
TO WORK OUT WITH THE AUTHOR, SO
07:24:21.167 --> 07:24:23.236
I WON'T BE VOTING FOR TODAY BUT
07:24:23.303 --> 07:24:25.171
WILL HELP HIM IF WE CAN WORK
07:24:25.238 --> 07:24:25.772
PAST THESE COUPLE OF THINGS,
07:24:25.839 --> 07:24:27.007
WHETHER IT'S GOTTEN, AMEND OR
07:24:27.073 --> 07:24:28.608
OTHER PROCEDURES TO MAKE IT
07:24:28.675 --> 07:24:29.943
HAPPEN AND HELP THEM TO THE
07:24:30.010 --> 07:24:31.811
PROCESS OF ELEMENTS IS THAT WORK
07:24:31.878 --> 07:24:32.645
AND THAT ARE GOOD. WE JUST
07:24:32.712 --> 07:24:33.747
COULDN'T GET THERE AND I
07:24:33.813 --> 07:24:36.216
COULDN'T GET THERE FOR PURPOSE
07:24:36.282 --> 07:24:37.250
OF TODAY, SO I WILL NOT BE
07:24:37.317 --> 07:24:38.985
VOTING, BUT I COMMIT TO HIM TO
07:24:39.052 --> 07:24:44.457
WORK WITH HIM, OKAY? MOTION IS
07:24:44.524 --> 07:24:45.959
TO PASS BY FIRST WE REFERRED TO
07:24:46.026 --> 07:24:48.028
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
07:24:48.094 --> 07:24:49.863
CURRENT VOTE 2 TO 1. NO CURRENT
07:24:49.929 --> 07:24:51.664
VOTE FOR THE CHAIR, CABALLERO.
07:24:51.731 --> 07:24:57.771
HERTZBERG. 2 TO 1. THE BILL
07:24:57.837 --> 07:25:00.106
FAILS, BUT, UM WE WILL GRANT
07:25:00.173 --> 07:25:01.141
RECONSIDERATION IF THERE'S NO
07:25:01.207 --> 07:25:03.076
OBJECTION. SAYING NONE
07:25:03.143 --> 07:25:06.479
RECONSIDERATION IS GRANTED.
07:25:06.546 --> 07:25:10.183
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER 16
07:25:10.250 --> 07:25:12.052
A B 27 21 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
07:25:12.118 --> 07:25:16.322
EARLY. THE MOTION WAS DO PASS AS
07:25:16.389 --> 07:25:20.260
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR. CURRENT
07:25:20.326 --> 07:25:23.263
BOAT IS 2 TO 1 CHAIR VOTING I
07:25:23.329 --> 07:25:26.332
HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE, WIENER.
07:25:26.399 --> 07:25:30.036
WIENER I 41 THAT BILL IS OUT.
07:25:30.103 --> 07:25:31.971
FILE ITEM NUMBER 17 A B 22 OH,
07:25:32.038 --> 07:25:34.007
ONE. BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
07:25:34.074 --> 07:25:40.280
BENNETT. UH, THAT IS OUT. MOVING
07:25:40.346 --> 07:25:44.084
ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER 18 A B 24
07:25:44.150 --> 07:25:47.187
53 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BENNETT.
07:25:47.253 --> 07:25:49.422
THE MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
07:25:49.489 --> 07:25:50.590
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:25:50.657 --> 07:25:53.426
APPROPRIATIONS. OH, THIS IS
07:25:53.493 --> 07:25:54.627
STRAIGHT TO THE FLOOR. VERY
07:25:54.694 --> 07:26:00.400
GOOD. MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
07:26:00.467 --> 07:26:03.269
REFER TO THE TO THE FLOOR.
07:26:03.336 --> 07:26:05.805
CURRAN VOTE IS 1 TO 1 A CURRENT
07:26:05.872 --> 07:26:08.675
VOTE FOR THE CHAIR CABALLERO
07:26:08.741 --> 07:26:11.478
CABALLERO, I HERZBERG HERZBERG.
07:26:11.544 --> 07:26:13.880
AYE, WIENER WIENER. I 4 TO 1.
07:26:13.947 --> 07:26:17.550
THAT BILL IS OUT. FILE I ITEM
07:26:17.617 --> 07:26:23.056
NUMBER 19. A B 24 42 BY
07:26:23.123 --> 07:26:25.291
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ROBERT RIVAS.
07:26:25.358 --> 07:26:26.559
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
07:26:26.626 --> 07:26:28.895
AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND RE
07:26:28.962 --> 07:26:30.063
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:26:30.130 --> 07:26:32.665
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
07:26:32.732 --> 07:26:34.901
1 TO 1. NO CURRENT VOTE FOR THE
07:26:34.968 --> 07:26:37.203
CHAIR CABALLERO CABALLERO,
07:26:37.270 --> 07:26:39.305
HERZBERG. HERZBERG WIENER
07:26:39.372 --> 07:26:44.177
WIENER. I 41 THAT BILL IS OUT.
07:26:44.244 --> 07:26:47.280
FILE ITEM NUMBER 20 A B 25 60 BY
07:26:47.347 --> 07:26:54.154
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BONTA. THE
07:26:54.220 --> 07:26:55.822
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED,
07:26:55.889 --> 07:26:57.824
BUT FIRST AMENDED AND RE REFER
07:26:57.891 --> 07:26:59.092
TO THE COMMUNITY COMMITTEE ON
07:26:59.159 --> 07:27:00.894
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT BEAU IS
07:27:00.960 --> 07:27:04.731
3 TO 0 CHAIR VOTING I HERZBERG
07:27:04.797 --> 07:27:06.533
HERZBERG. AYE WIENER WIENER. I'M
07:27:06.599 --> 07:27:11.404
FIDO ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT. WELL
07:27:11.471 --> 07:27:14.474
ITEM NUMBER 21 A B 26 22 BY
07:27:14.541 --> 07:27:17.410
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MULLEN THE
07:27:17.477 --> 07:27:19.579
MOTION IS DO PASS, AND WE REFER
07:27:19.646 --> 07:27:21.047
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:27:21.114 --> 07:27:22.649
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
07:27:22.715 --> 07:27:25.251
3 TO 0 CHAIR VOTING I HERZBERG
07:27:25.318 --> 07:27:28.521
HERZBERG. AYE, WIENER. WIENER
07:27:28.588 --> 07:27:32.792
FIGHTER ZERO BILL IS OUT. FILE
07:27:32.859 --> 07:27:34.327
ITEM NUMBER 22 27 89 BY
07:27:34.394 --> 07:27:39.899
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MULLEN. THIS
07:27:39.966 --> 07:27:41.134
WAS PART OF THE CONSENT. I'M
07:27:41.201 --> 07:27:44.337
SORRY. MY APOLOGY. ODD AND WE
07:27:44.404 --> 07:27:46.339
SHOULD TAKE UP CONSENT. IT'S TWO
07:27:46.406 --> 07:27:49.275
ITEMS FILE ITEM NUMBER 22 A B 27
07:27:49.342 --> 07:27:55.515
89 FILE ITEM NUMBER 24 A B 26 51
07:27:55.582 --> 07:27:57.417
AND THAT'S TO ADOPT THE CONSENT
07:27:57.483 --> 07:28:02.021
CALENDAR IS EMOTION. CURRENT
07:28:02.088 --> 07:28:03.256
ALREADY HAD EMOTION. YEAH
07:28:03.323 --> 07:28:07.193
CURRENT VOTE IS 4 TO 0. CHAIR
07:28:07.260 --> 07:28:08.795
VOTING I HERZBERG HERZBERG 5 TO
07:28:08.861 --> 07:28:14.300
0. THAT CONSENT CALENDARS OUT.
07:28:14.367 --> 07:28:17.770
FILE ITEM NUMBER 23 WHICH IS A B
07:28:17.837 --> 07:28:18.805
26 47 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
07:28:18.871 --> 07:28:22.809
LEVINE. THAT MOTION IS DUE PASS
07:28:22.875 --> 07:28:26.179
AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR. CURRENT
07:28:26.246 --> 07:28:28.081
VOTE IS 3 TO 0 CHAIR VOTING I
07:28:28.147 --> 07:28:30.383
HERZBERG HERZBERG, I WINNER
07:28:30.450 --> 07:28:35.555
WINNER ZERO. THAT BILL IS OUT.
07:28:35.622 --> 07:28:37.790
FILE ITEM NUMBER 25, WHICH IS A
07:28:37.857 --> 07:28:41.527
B 26 56 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING
07:28:41.594 --> 07:28:42.929
. THAT MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
07:28:42.996 --> 07:28:44.831
AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND
07:28:44.897 --> 07:28:45.865
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
07:28:45.932 --> 07:28:48.268
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT BOAT IS
07:28:48.334 --> 07:28:51.504
2 TO 0 CHAIR VOTING I NIELSEN.
07:28:51.571 --> 07:28:56.009
HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG AYE, WIENER
07:28:56.075 --> 07:28:58.878
. WIENER. I 4 TO 0. THAT BILL IS
07:28:58.945 --> 07:29:06.653
OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 26. MAYBE
07:29:06.719 --> 07:29:11.524
2020 THAT ONE WAS ON, UM
07:29:11.591 --> 07:29:13.593
PRESENTATION ONLY FILE ITEM
07:29:13.660 --> 07:29:18.865
NUMBER 27 A B 28 87 BY UM
07:29:18.931 --> 07:29:19.399
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BORRADOR
07:29:19.465 --> 07:29:25.705
GARCIA. THAT MOTION? YES. DO
07:29:25.772 --> 07:29:27.040
PASS AND RE REFERRED TO THE
07:29:27.106 --> 07:29:29.175
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
07:29:29.242 --> 07:29:31.277
CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0 CHAIR
07:29:31.344 --> 07:29:33.880
VOTING I HERZBERG HERZBERG I
07:29:33.946 --> 07:29:35.748
WINNER WINNER I 5 TO 0. THAT
07:29:35.815 --> 07:29:49.262
BILL IS OUT. YES. IS THE NEXT TO
07:29:49.329 --> 07:30:05.445
HELP YOU. RIGHT AND. SO I WANT
07:30:05.511 --> 07:30:07.413
TO THANK ALL THE INDIVIDUALS WHO
07:30:07.480 --> 07:30:08.481
PARTICIPATED IN OUR PUBLIC
07:30:08.548 --> 07:30:10.650
TESTIMONY TODAY. IF YOU WERE NOT
07:30:10.717 --> 07:30:12.185
ABLE TO TESTIFY, PLEASE SUBMIT
07:30:12.251 --> 07:30:14.287
YOUR COMMENTS OR SUGGESTIONS IN
07:30:14.354 --> 07:30:15.855
WRITING TO THE GOVERNANCE AND
07:30:15.922 --> 07:30:16.923
FINANCE COMMITTEE OR VISIT OUR
07:30:16.989 --> 07:30:18.858
WEBSITE. YOUR COMMENTS AND
07:30:18.925 --> 07:30:21.160
SUGGESTIONS ARE VERY IMPORTANT
07:30:21.227 --> 07:30:22.595
TO US, AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE
07:30:22.662 --> 07:30:24.163
YOUR TESTIMONY IN THE OFFICIAL
07:30:24.230 --> 07:30:25.732
HEARING RECORDS. THANK YOU, AND
07:30:25.798 --> 07:30:27.800
WE APPRECIATE YOUR PARTICIPATION
07:30:27.867 --> 07:30:29.569
. AND IF THE MODERATOR IS STILL
07:30:29.635 --> 07:30:30.837
ON THE LINE, THANK YOU. SO MUCH
07:30:30.903 --> 07:30:33.740
FOR YOUR PATIENTS AND ALL OF
07:30:33.806 --> 07:30:36.008
YOUR HARD WORK. UM TODAY WE
07:30:36.075 --> 07:30:38.177
REALLY APPRECIATE IT. THANK
07:30:38.244 --> 07:30:40.179
EVERYONE FOR YOUR PATIENCE AND
07:30:40.246 --> 07:30:41.180
COOPERATION. WE HAVE CONCLUDED
07:30:41.247 --> 07:30:43.082
THE AGENDA AND THE SENATE
07:30:43.149 --> 07:30:44.183
COMMITTEE AND GOVERNANCE AND
07:30:44.250 --> 07:31:01.033
FINANCE IS ADJOURNED.