WEBVTT
00:00:08.808 --> 00:00:10.810
THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON
00:00:10.877 --> 00:00:12.479
TRANSPORTATION. WILL COME TO
00:00:12.545 --> 00:00:18.852
ORDER. AS YOU CAN SEE, WE HAVE
00:00:18.918 --> 00:00:20.286
MADE A TEMPORARY CHANGE IN THE
00:00:20.353 --> 00:00:22.856
COMMITTEE. I AM FILLING IN FOR
00:00:22.922 --> 00:00:24.457
SENATOR GONZALEZ TODAY. MY NAME
00:00:24.524 --> 00:00:27.193
IS JOSH NEWMAN. SHE IS UNDER THE
00:00:27.260 --> 00:00:28.294
WEATHER, AND WE WISH HER A
00:00:28.361 --> 00:00:30.363
SPEEDY RECOVERY AND TEMPORARILY
00:00:30.430 --> 00:00:34.467
TEMPORARILY. WE MAY FEEL SOME
00:00:34.534 --> 00:00:35.969
OTHER AGENCIES, DEPENDING ON
00:00:36.035 --> 00:00:37.003
OTHER COMMITTEE MEMBERS BEING
00:00:37.070 --> 00:00:38.138
ABSENT. SO WITH THAT, LET'S
00:00:38.204 --> 00:00:39.139
START THE HEARING. GOOD
00:00:39.205 --> 00:00:41.074
AFTERNOON. AS WE CONTINUE TO
00:00:41.141 --> 00:00:42.575
TAKE SOME PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE
00:00:42.642 --> 00:00:44.511
ONGOING COVID 19 RISKS. THE
00:00:44.577 --> 00:00:45.612
SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE
00:00:45.678 --> 00:00:46.913
PUBLIC AND HAS PROVIDED ACCESS
00:00:46.980 --> 00:00:48.481
TO BOTH IN PERSON AND
00:00:48.548 --> 00:00:49.949
TELECONFERENCE. PARTICIPATION
00:00:50.016 --> 00:00:50.950
FOR PUBLIC COMMENT FOR
00:00:51.017 --> 00:00:52.285
INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO PROVIDE
00:00:52.352 --> 00:00:52.952
PUBLIC COMMENT VIEW THE
00:00:53.019 --> 00:00:54.220
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE. THE
00:00:54.287 --> 00:00:55.622
PARTICIPANT. TOLL FREE NUMBER
00:00:55.688 --> 00:00:57.323
AND ACCESS CODE IS POSTED ON OUR
00:00:57.390 --> 00:00:59.392
COMMITTEE WEBSITE ON THE LINK
00:00:59.459 --> 00:01:00.360
TODAY'S HEARING AND I WILL
00:01:00.427 --> 00:01:01.528
ANNOUNCE IT NOW, TODAY'S
00:01:01.594 --> 00:01:09.068
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS 844291.
00:01:09.135 --> 00:01:13.473
2914185 AND THE ACCESS CODE FOR
00:01:13.540 --> 00:01:15.775
THIS HEARING IS 984113 AGAIN.
00:01:15.842 --> 00:01:19.612
THAT EXCESS CODE IS 984113. AS
00:01:19.679 --> 00:01:21.147
THE CHAIR. I WILL MAINTAIN
00:01:21.214 --> 00:01:22.649
DECORUM DURING THE HEARING, AS
00:01:22.715 --> 00:01:23.817
IS CUSTOMARY IN MY ANY
00:01:23.883 --> 00:01:25.485
INDIVIDUALS DISRUPTED MAY BE
00:01:25.552 --> 00:01:26.886
REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE MEETING
00:01:26.953 --> 00:01:28.321
SERVICE OR HAVE THEIR
00:01:28.388 --> 00:01:29.289
CONNECTIONS MUTED. WE ARE
00:01:29.355 --> 00:01:31.124
HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE. HEARING
00:01:31.191 --> 00:01:32.192
THIS AFTERNOON HERE IN THE
00:01:32.258 --> 00:01:33.593
SENATE CHAMBERS. I ASK ALL
00:01:33.660 --> 00:01:35.228
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE TO COME
00:01:35.295 --> 00:01:36.029
TO THE CHAMBER SO WE CAN
00:01:36.095 --> 00:01:38.298
ESTABLISH A QUORUM AT THE
00:01:38.364 --> 00:01:38.932
EARLIEST POSSIBLE OPPORTUNITY.
00:01:38.998 --> 00:01:41.634
WE DO NOT CURRENTLY HAVE A
00:01:41.701 --> 00:01:43.036
QUORUM WILL BE STARTING AS A
00:01:43.102 --> 00:01:45.138
SUBCOMMITTEE. WE HAVE 45
00:01:45.205 --> 00:01:47.273
MEASURES ON TODAY'S AGENDA DUE
00:01:47.340 --> 00:01:48.141
TO CONSTRAINTS REGARDING THE
00:01:48.208 --> 00:01:49.242
LENGTH OF HEARINGS IN TECHNOLOGY
00:01:49.309 --> 00:01:51.177
CONSIDERATIONS. I AM GOING TO
00:01:51.244 --> 00:01:52.645
INSTITUTE TIME LIMITS ON
00:01:52.712 --> 00:01:53.513
TESTIMONY. PRIMARY WITNESSES
00:01:53.580 --> 00:01:54.747
WILL EACH BE PROVIDED TWO
00:01:54.814 --> 00:01:55.982
MINUTES FOR THEIR TESTIMONY.
00:01:56.049 --> 00:01:57.884
EACH SIDE WILL BE PERMITTED. AN
00:01:57.951 --> 00:01:59.986
EQUAL AMOUNT OF TIME ACROSS ALL
00:02:00.053 --> 00:02:01.054
OF THE TESTIMONY, ALL OTHERS
00:02:01.120 --> 00:02:03.122
WISHING TO TESTIFY MUST LIMIT
00:02:03.189 --> 00:02:04.090
THEIR COMMENTS TO THEIR NAME,
00:02:04.157 --> 00:02:06.092
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
00:02:06.159 --> 00:02:08.027
MEASURES. WE HAVE A BIG AGENDA
00:02:08.094 --> 00:02:09.596
TODAY. THANKFULLY THE MAJORITY
00:02:09.662 --> 00:02:12.131
OF BILLS ARE ON CONSENT. I'M
00:02:12.198 --> 00:02:13.566
GOING TO LIMIT THE TIME FOR
00:02:13.633 --> 00:02:14.734
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES TO 10
00:02:14.801 --> 00:02:16.970
MINUTES FOR EACH SIDE SO THAT WE
00:02:17.036 --> 00:02:19.339
CAN GET OUR WORK DONE HERE THIS
00:02:19.405 --> 00:02:20.807
AFTERNOON IN A TIMELY MANNER
00:02:20.874 --> 00:02:21.808
BEFORE WE HEAR PRESENTATION ON
00:02:21.875 --> 00:02:24.110
THE BILLS. LET US LOOK NGUYEN
00:02:24.177 --> 00:02:26.045
SKIN FOR QUORUM. WE DO NOT HAVE
00:02:26.112 --> 00:02:28.748
IT. WE WILL START AS A
00:02:28.815 --> 00:02:30.383
SUBCOMMITTEE. I THANK THE OTHER
00:02:30.450 --> 00:02:31.384
MEMBERS FOR BEING HERE AND WE
00:02:31.451 --> 00:02:33.686
WILL START THE FIRST BILL THAT
00:02:33.753 --> 00:02:35.054
SLIGHTLY OUT OF ORDER. FOR
00:02:35.121 --> 00:02:36.890
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S KING. I BELIEVE
00:02:36.956 --> 00:02:39.759
THAT IS ITEM NUMBER 16 AND I AM
00:02:39.826 --> 00:02:47.000
GOING TO IT. GIVE ME ONE SECOND.
00:02:47.066 --> 00:02:49.569
AND I JUST WANT TO SAY MANY OF
00:02:49.636 --> 00:02:50.970
YOU HAVE SEEN ME IN OTHER
00:02:51.037 --> 00:02:52.472
COMMITTEES. I AM LIKE THE
00:02:52.539 --> 00:02:53.373
SUBSTITUTE TEACHER THAT YOU GET
00:02:53.439 --> 00:02:55.275
IN VARIOUS CLASSES AT YOUR
00:02:55.341 --> 00:02:56.209
SCHOOL. SO MAY I MAY BE NEW TO
00:02:56.276 --> 00:02:58.378
THIS CLASS. BUT I KNOW ALL YOU
00:02:58.444 --> 00:02:59.546
KIDS FROM OTHER CLASSES, SO
00:02:59.612 --> 00:03:01.381
LET'S ALL BEHAVE. UM HAS ANYBODY
00:03:01.447 --> 00:03:03.516
EVER SEEN THE KEY AND PEELE SKIT
00:03:03.583 --> 00:03:04.517
AND SUBSTITUTE TEACHERS MOVING
00:03:04.584 --> 00:03:10.323
ALONG? MHM. LET ME GO TO ONE OF
00:03:10.390 --> 00:03:12.191
THE PIECE OF PAPER SO ASSEMBLY
00:03:12.258 --> 00:03:14.627
ROOTING FOR FURTHER ADO YOU WILL
00:03:14.694 --> 00:03:16.262
BE PRESENTING ITEM NUMBER 16 18
00:03:16.329 --> 00:03:19.666
25 94 PLEASE PURSUE. THANK YOU,
00:03:19.732 --> 00:03:21.100
MR CHAIR. I WAS ALWAYS AN
00:03:21.167 --> 00:03:22.535
EXEMPLARY STUDENTS HAVE NO
00:03:22.602 --> 00:03:24.604
ISSUES WITH ME TODAY IN CLASS.
00:03:24.671 --> 00:03:27.674
SO A B 25 94 DEALS WITH THE
00:03:27.740 --> 00:03:29.142
INEQUITIES IN OUR CALIFORNIA
00:03:29.208 --> 00:03:31.511
TALL SYSTEM AS WE HAVE MOVED
00:03:31.578 --> 00:03:33.780
AWAY FROM TOLL TAKERS AND MOVED
00:03:33.846 --> 00:03:36.983
MORE TOWARDS ELEKTRONIK. I TOLD
00:03:37.050 --> 00:03:38.818
TAKING LIKE FAST TRACKS. THIS
00:03:38.885 --> 00:03:41.154
HAS POTENTIALLY LEFT MANY PEOPLE
00:03:41.220 --> 00:03:43.256
BEHIND PEOPLE WHO DON'T HAVE
00:03:43.323 --> 00:03:44.057
ACCESS TO BANK ACCOUNTS. CREDIT
00:03:44.123 --> 00:03:45.024
CARDS, PEOPLE WHO TRADITIONALLY
00:03:45.091 --> 00:03:49.462
PAY WITH CASH. HAVE STRUGGLED TO
00:03:49.529 --> 00:03:51.230
PAY THEIR BILLS BECAUSE THEY
00:03:51.297 --> 00:03:52.765
DIDN'T KNOW THAT THEY HAD THEM
00:03:52.832 --> 00:03:54.267
AND THEY ALSO END UP INCURRING
00:03:54.334 --> 00:03:56.269
SIGNIFICANT FINES AND SO WORKING
00:03:56.336 --> 00:03:57.537
IN CONCERT WITH ALL THE VARIOUS
00:03:57.604 --> 00:03:59.973
TOLL AGENCIES WE'VE WORKED TO
00:04:00.039 --> 00:04:01.107
REALLY ADDRESS MANY OF THESE
00:04:01.174 --> 00:04:03.876
INEQUITIES. ONE THE BILL
00:04:03.943 --> 00:04:05.645
REQUIRES DMV TONIGHT IF I PEOPLE
00:04:05.712 --> 00:04:06.479
TO UPDATE THEIR VEHICLE
00:04:06.546 --> 00:04:08.648
REGISTRATION, THAT'S OFTENTIMES
00:04:08.715 --> 00:04:09.916
HOW IF YOU DON'T HAVE A FAST
00:04:09.983 --> 00:04:13.219
TRACK OR A TAG SYSTEM. THE TOLL
00:04:13.286 --> 00:04:15.021
AGENCIES NOTIFY YOU OF THE
00:04:15.088 --> 00:04:17.724
MONETARY OBLIGATION. WE REQUIRE
00:04:17.790 --> 00:04:19.258
RENTAL AGENCIES TO NOTIFY PEOPLE
00:04:19.325 --> 00:04:20.126
OF INFORMATION ABOUT THE
00:04:20.193 --> 00:04:21.728
CALIFORNIA TOLLING SYSTEM, SO
00:04:21.794 --> 00:04:23.262
THEY KNOW THERE IS A CHRGE THEY
00:04:23.329 --> 00:04:25.498
HAVE OPTIONS. IT ALSO SETS A CAP
00:04:25.565 --> 00:04:26.666
ON THE FINES AGENCIES CAN
00:04:26.733 --> 00:04:29.102
OPPOSE. IT ALSO MAKES SURE THAT
00:04:29.168 --> 00:04:31.404
PAYMENT PLANS ARE ALL AGENCIES.
00:04:31.471 --> 00:04:32.238
SO IF YOU FALL BEHIND, GIVEN
00:04:32.305 --> 00:04:33.139
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A PAYMENT
00:04:33.206 --> 00:04:35.675
PLAN AND ALSO MANDATES CASH
00:04:35.742 --> 00:04:36.843
PAYMENTS BECAUSE WE SHOULDN'T
00:04:36.909 --> 00:04:39.879
DISALLOW CASH AS A PAYMENT.
00:04:39.946 --> 00:04:41.114
UNFORTUNATELY FOR MANY PEOPLE
00:04:41.180 --> 00:04:43.616
WHO DO RELY ON CASH, THEY SEEM
00:04:43.683 --> 00:04:45.618
TO BE SHUT OUT OF CURRENT TOLL
00:04:45.685 --> 00:04:48.221
TAKERS TAKING AT THIS TIME ALSO
00:04:48.287 --> 00:04:49.055
PROVIDES CUSTOMER SERVICE
00:04:49.122 --> 00:04:49.956
ACCESS, MAKING SURE THAT AS A
00:04:50.023 --> 00:04:53.126
CUSTOMER YOU HAVE ACCESS, YOU
00:04:53.192 --> 00:04:54.694
CAN GO SOMEWHERE DURING BUSINESS
00:04:54.761 --> 00:04:56.195
HOURS. THAT'S NOT THE CASE WITH
00:04:56.262 --> 00:04:58.164
ALL THE TOLERANCES RIGHT NOW AND
00:04:58.231 --> 00:04:59.465
IN PARTICULAR AROUND BRIDGES, WE
00:04:59.532 --> 00:05:01.267
KNOW BRIDGES ARE A LITTLE BIT
00:05:01.334 --> 00:05:02.368
DIFFERENT REQUIRES THE BAY AREA
00:05:02.435 --> 00:05:04.137
BRIDGES TO PROVIDE A ONE X
00:05:04.203 --> 00:05:06.572
PENALTY. WIPE OUT A ONE TIME
00:05:06.639 --> 00:05:09.509
PENALTY WIPE OUT FOR DRIVERS. SO
00:05:09.575 --> 00:05:11.010
WITH THAT WE HAVE TWO WITNESSES
00:05:11.077 --> 00:05:12.178
. AMY WORTH WHO'S CHAIR OF THE
00:05:12.245 --> 00:05:13.513
BAY AREA TOLL AUTHORITY
00:05:13.579 --> 00:05:15.014
OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE, IN THE PAST
00:05:15.081 --> 00:05:16.149
, CHAIR OF THE METROPOLITAN
00:05:16.215 --> 00:05:17.383
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE, AND
00:05:17.450 --> 00:05:18.551
MICHAEL HAROLD, WITH THE WESTERN
00:05:18.618 --> 00:05:21.688
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY. MS
00:05:21.754 --> 00:05:22.889
WORD, MAYOR WORD. IT'S NICE TO
00:05:22.955 --> 00:05:25.858
HAVE YOU HERE, PLEASE PURSUIT.
00:05:25.925 --> 00:05:29.128
HELLO THERE. PLEASE PROCEED.
00:05:29.195 --> 00:05:31.030
OKAY GOOD. GOOD AFTERNOON,
00:05:31.097 --> 00:05:32.999
SENATOR NEWMAN. VICE YOUR BAITS
00:05:33.066 --> 00:05:34.467
AND MEMBERS OF MY NAME IS AMY
00:05:34.534 --> 00:05:36.369
WORTH AND I'M VERY HONORED TO BE
00:05:36.436 --> 00:05:38.104
HERE REPRESENTING THE VARIOUS
00:05:38.171 --> 00:05:39.639
TOLL AUTHORITY, ALSO KNOWN AS
00:05:39.706 --> 00:05:40.740
THE METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION
00:05:40.807 --> 00:05:41.674
COMMISSION, WHERE I'VE SERVED
00:05:41.741 --> 00:05:44.043
FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS. AND I'M
00:05:44.110 --> 00:05:46.112
SPEAKING HERE ON BEHALF OF MTC
00:05:46.179 --> 00:05:48.347
BATTER WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT
00:05:48.414 --> 00:05:50.016
LAST WEEK, MTC ENTHUSIASTICALLY
00:05:50.083 --> 00:05:52.285
ENDORSED ASSEMBLY BILL 25 94. I
00:05:52.351 --> 00:05:55.254
WANT TO COMMEND AND THINK
00:05:55.321 --> 00:05:56.789
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING AND HIS
00:05:56.856 --> 00:05:57.657
STAFF FOR THEIR COLLABORATIVE
00:05:57.724 --> 00:06:00.159
APPROACH TO DRAFTING THIS BILL.
00:06:00.226 --> 00:06:02.128
THEY'VE SPENT MANY HOURS TALKING
00:06:02.195 --> 00:06:03.329
TO TOLL AGENCY STAFF AROUND THE
00:06:03.396 --> 00:06:06.566
STATE. AND BOARD MEMBERS TO
00:06:06.632 --> 00:06:07.567
UNDERSTAND AND ADDRESS OUR
00:06:07.633 --> 00:06:09.535
CONCERNS WHILE ALSO TRYING TO
00:06:09.602 --> 00:06:10.536
ADVANCE THE BILLS. COMMENDABLE
00:06:10.603 --> 00:06:11.871
GOALS. WHICH WE WHOLEHEARTEDLY
00:06:11.938 --> 00:06:17.076
SUPPORT. MAYBE 25 94 AIMS TO
00:06:17.143 --> 00:06:18.711
ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIA'S TOLL
00:06:18.778 --> 00:06:19.912
FACILITIES CONDUCT OUR BUSINESS
00:06:19.979 --> 00:06:22.615
IN AN EQUITABLE MANNER. THIS
00:06:22.682 --> 00:06:23.783
MAKES TREMENDOUS SENSE AND IS
00:06:23.850 --> 00:06:26.285
THE RIGHT THING TO DO. AT THE
00:06:26.352 --> 00:06:28.387
BARRIER TOLD AUTHORITY. WE ARE
00:06:28.454 --> 00:06:29.122
CURRENTLY IMPLEMENTING A TOLL
00:06:29.188 --> 00:06:31.390
EQUITY PLAN AND THE FIRST MAJOR
00:06:31.457 --> 00:06:32.792
STEP WAS REDUCING OUR PENALTIES
00:06:32.859 --> 00:06:35.995
BY 80% EARLIER THIS YEAR. WE
00:06:36.062 --> 00:06:37.663
HAVE ALSO BEEN WORKING HARD TO
00:06:37.730 --> 00:06:39.866
HELP PEOPLE AVOID ACCUMULATING
00:06:39.932 --> 00:06:40.733
PENALTIES IN THE FIRST PLACE.
00:06:40.800 --> 00:06:42.635
DUE TO SAFETY CONCERNS RELATED
00:06:42.702 --> 00:06:44.670
TO COVID 19. CALTRANS TOOK A
00:06:44.737 --> 00:06:46.806
QUICK AND WISE DECISION TO
00:06:46.873 --> 00:06:48.374
REMOVE CASH PAYMENTS FROM THE
00:06:48.441 --> 00:06:49.442
BRIDGES RECOGNIZING HOW ABRUPT
00:06:49.509 --> 00:06:51.744
THIS CHANGE WAS FOR MOTORISTS.
00:06:51.811 --> 00:06:53.246
WHO ARE USED TO HANDING OVER
00:06:53.312 --> 00:06:54.981
CASH WHEN THEY CROSS THE BRIDGE
00:06:55.047 --> 00:06:57.250
. WE SUSPENDED PENALTIES THROUGH
00:06:57.316 --> 00:07:00.253
2021 SHIFTED TO A SYSTEM WHERE
00:07:00.319 --> 00:07:01.420
THE FIRST NOTICE OF PERSON
00:07:01.487 --> 00:07:02.522
RECEIVES ISN'T A VIOLATION AT
00:07:02.588 --> 00:07:06.359
ALL. IT'S AN INVOICE A B 25 94
00:07:06.425 --> 00:07:08.294
REQUIRES THAT WE CONTINUE THIS
00:07:08.361 --> 00:07:11.697
APPROACH. A B 25 94 WOULD ALSO
00:07:11.764 --> 00:07:14.066
MANDATE PAYMENT PLANS FOR UNPAID
00:07:14.133 --> 00:07:16.002
PENALTIES AND REQUIRE THAT WE
00:07:16.068 --> 00:07:17.670
WAIVE OUTSTANDING TOLL BRIDGE
00:07:17.737 --> 00:07:20.807
PENALTIES THAT WERE ACCRUED-DURING THE PANDEMIC FOR THOSE
00:07:20.873 --> 00:07:23.910
WITH AN INCOME AT OR BELOW. 200%
00:07:23.976 --> 00:07:26.245
OF THE FEDERAL POVERTY LEVEL IF
00:07:26.312 --> 00:07:28.881
TOLLS ARE PAID UP FRONT ONCE
00:07:28.948 --> 00:07:30.950
AGAIN, I WOULD LIKE TO EXTEND MY
00:07:31.017 --> 00:07:32.819
DEEP APPRECIATION ON BEHALF OF
00:07:32.885 --> 00:07:34.453
THE COMMISSION TO
00:07:34.520 --> 00:07:36.022
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING AND HIS
00:07:36.088 --> 00:07:37.123
STAFF FOR THEIR ATTENTION TO
00:07:37.190 --> 00:07:39.725
THIS VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE. AND
00:07:39.792 --> 00:07:41.027
FOR LISTENING TO OUR CONCERNS TO
00:07:41.093 --> 00:07:43.229
ADDRESS THE PROVISION. AND
00:07:43.296 --> 00:07:45.364
ENSURE THAT THEY ARE WORKABLE
00:07:45.431 --> 00:07:46.432
FROM BOTH OF FINANCIAL AND
00:07:46.499 --> 00:07:49.502
PRACTICAL STANDPOINT. IT'S THIS
00:07:49.569 --> 00:07:51.370
KIND OF COLLABORATION WITH STATE
00:07:51.437 --> 00:07:53.105
LEGISLATORS AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT
00:07:53.172 --> 00:07:54.941
THAT IS SO IMPORTANT FOR
00:07:55.007 --> 00:07:57.109
CALIFORNIA'S SUCCESS. SO I WANT
00:07:57.176 --> 00:07:58.277
TO THANK YOU AND RESPECTFULLY
00:07:58.344 --> 00:08:00.580
ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU
00:08:00.646 --> 00:08:02.415
VERY MUCH. AND THANK YOU MISS
00:08:02.481 --> 00:08:05.218
WORTH NEXT IN SUPPORT. WE HAVE
00:08:05.284 --> 00:08:06.385
MICHAEL HAROLD FROM THE WESTERN
00:08:06.452 --> 00:08:07.453
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY
00:08:07.520 --> 00:08:10.523
WELCOME. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
00:08:10.590 --> 00:08:11.591
MEMBERS. YES MIKE CARROLL WITH
00:08:11.657 --> 00:08:13.593
THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
00:08:13.659 --> 00:08:15.161
POVERTY. FOR MANY YEARS, OUR
00:08:15.228 --> 00:08:17.029
LEGAL SERVICE PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN
00:08:17.096 --> 00:08:18.698
WORKING HARD TO TRY TO GET A
00:08:18.764 --> 00:08:20.833
FAIR AND EQUITABLE. UM FINES AND
00:08:20.900 --> 00:08:22.068
FEES AND PAYMENT PLANS FOR OUR
00:08:22.134 --> 00:08:24.737
LOW INCOME CLIENTS. TOTAL
00:08:24.804 --> 00:08:28.007
AGENCIES ACTUALLY ISSUE MILLIONS
00:08:28.074 --> 00:08:29.375
OF TOLL VIOLATIONS EVERY YEAR.
00:08:29.442 --> 00:08:32.245
THEY ALSO PUT UM SOMEWHERE CLOSE
00:08:32.311 --> 00:08:36.649
TO A MILLION HOLES ON DMV.
00:08:36.716 --> 00:08:38.184
NEGATIVE IMPACT FOR OUR CLIENTS.
00:08:38.251 --> 00:08:40.152
THEY OFTEN GET PULLED OVER. THEY
00:08:40.219 --> 00:08:41.120
GET ADDITIONAL TICKETS AND FINES
00:08:41.187 --> 00:08:42.188
AND THEY CAN EVEN HAVE THEIR
00:08:42.255 --> 00:08:44.357
CARS TOWED. UM SO WE'RE REALLY
00:08:44.423 --> 00:08:46.425
APPRECIATIVE OF THE WORK OF
00:08:46.492 --> 00:08:47.260
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING AND HIS
00:08:47.326 --> 00:08:49.428
STAFF AND THE AND THE TALL
00:08:49.495 --> 00:08:50.196
AGENCIES TO ALL COME TOGETHER
00:08:50.263 --> 00:08:51.230
AND COLLABORATE AND FIND A
00:08:51.297 --> 00:08:53.733
SOLUTION FOR THIS. WHAT WE WERE
00:08:53.799 --> 00:08:55.868
SEEKING. HERE WAS A STATEWIDE
00:08:55.935 --> 00:08:57.470
STANDARD THAT APPLIED ACROSS THE
00:08:57.536 --> 00:09:00.539
STATE SO THAT OUR CLIENTS AND
00:09:00.606 --> 00:09:01.440
OUR LOCAL LEGAL SERVICE PROVINCE
00:09:01.507 --> 00:09:02.775
WOULD KNOW SO TO SPEAK, THE
00:09:02.842 --> 00:09:04.744
RULES OF THE ROAD AND HOW WE
00:09:04.810 --> 00:09:06.579
COULD RESOLVE THESE KIND OF
00:09:06.646 --> 00:09:07.580
PROBLEMS. LEGAL ISSUES GOING
00:09:07.647 --> 00:09:10.249
FORWARD. UM SO THESE THIS BILL
00:09:10.316 --> 00:09:12.118
IS VERY SIMILAR TO WHAT WE'VE
00:09:12.184 --> 00:09:14.553
SEEN IN TRAFFIC COURT AND IN
00:09:14.620 --> 00:09:16.155
PARKING VIOLATIONS WHERE WE NOW
00:09:16.222 --> 00:09:17.156
HAVE UNIFORM STANDARDS. $25
00:09:17.223 --> 00:09:20.793
PAYMENT PLANS. AND ABILITY FOR
00:09:20.860 --> 00:09:21.894
PEOPLE TO GET THEIR CAR
00:09:21.961 --> 00:09:23.829
REGISTERED ONCE THEY MAKE THAT
00:09:23.896 --> 00:09:25.364
FIRST PAYMENT, SO THIS GETS
00:09:25.431 --> 00:09:26.766
PEOPLE ON THE ROAD GETS THEM
00:09:26.832 --> 00:09:28.501
LEGAL AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT 25
00:09:28.567 --> 00:09:33.839
94. ED THANK YOU VERY MUCH. LET
00:09:33.906 --> 00:09:35.975
LET US TURN TO THE HEARING ROOM
00:09:36.042 --> 00:09:37.643
HERE, THE CHAMBER OR ANY WITNESS
00:09:37.710 --> 00:09:39.211
HERE LIKE TESTIFIED IN SUPPORT
00:09:39.278 --> 00:09:43.115
OF A B 25 94. AND IF YOU COULD
00:09:43.182 --> 00:09:44.283
YOUR NAME AFFILIATION YOUR
00:09:44.350 --> 00:09:47.253
POSITION ON THE BILL. GOOD
00:09:47.320 --> 00:09:48.187
AFTERNOON, STEVE BULLOCK ON
00:09:48.254 --> 00:09:49.322
BEHALF OF THE GOLDEN GATE,
00:09:49.388 --> 00:09:50.423
BRIDGE, HIGHWAY AND
00:09:50.489 --> 00:09:51.257
TRANSPORTATION DISTRICT AND
00:09:51.324 --> 00:09:52.959
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE
00:09:53.025 --> 00:09:55.995
WISHING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
00:09:56.062 --> 00:09:57.163
LET'S NOW GO TO THE
00:09:57.229 --> 00:09:59.065
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MR
00:09:59.131 --> 00:10:00.132
MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
00:10:00.199 --> 00:10:01.634
PROMPT THE INDIVIDUALS WAITING
00:10:01.701 --> 00:10:04.270
TEST RANGE SUPPORT OF A B 25 94
00:10:04.337 --> 00:10:05.371
. WE CAN BEGIN WITH THE
00:10:05.438 --> 00:10:10.042
CONFERENCE LINE. OF COURSE,
00:10:10.109 --> 00:10:11.310
LADIES. AND THEN IF YOU ARE IN
00:10:11.377 --> 00:10:16.682
SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS 10. IF YOU
00:10:16.749 --> 00:10:18.150
HAVE QUEUED UP ONE MOMENT WHILE
00:10:18.217 --> 00:10:19.251
THEY'RE GIVING THEIR LINE NUMBER
00:10:19.318 --> 00:10:30.629
THANK YOU. AND WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:10:30.696 --> 00:10:34.200
53. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GEORGE FOR
00:10:34.266 --> 00:10:36.068
EMPATHY ON BEHALF OF HIâU,
00:10:36.135 --> 00:10:37.603
CALIFORNIA ACTION AND SUPPORT.
00:10:37.670 --> 00:10:44.443
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT. ONE
00:10:44.510 --> 00:10:45.544
MOMENT THERE'S LINE NUMBER IS
00:10:45.611 --> 00:11:01.794
BEING GIVEN.
00:11:02.061 --> 00:11:04.330
AND NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE 50,
00:11:04.397 --> 00:11:08.300
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CHAIR AND
00:11:08.367 --> 00:11:11.103
MEMBERS NEITZEL UP ON BEHALF OF
00:11:11.170 --> 00:11:12.004
TRANSPORTATION CORRIDORS,
00:11:12.071 --> 00:11:13.506
AGENCIES THAT ORANGE COUNTY TOLL
00:11:13.572 --> 00:11:15.541
ROADS. WE REALLY APPRECIATE
00:11:15.608 --> 00:11:16.542
SOMETHING MEMBER TAKING ALL THE
00:11:16.609 --> 00:11:18.077
GREAT WORK THAT HE AND HIS STAFF
00:11:18.144 --> 00:11:19.912
HAVE DONE. WE APPRECIATE YOU
00:11:19.979 --> 00:11:21.113
MEETING WITH US DIRECTLY. WE
00:11:21.180 --> 00:11:25.484
SHARED HIS GOAL. FOR MAKING TOP
00:11:25.551 --> 00:11:26.685
PAYMENTS EASIER IN THE STATE OF
00:11:26.752 --> 00:11:29.488
CALIFORNIA. WE ARE ON THE VERGE
00:11:29.555 --> 00:11:31.023
OF REMOVING OUR OPPOSITION.
00:11:31.090 --> 00:11:32.558
THERE ARE JUST TWO REMAINING
00:11:32.625 --> 00:11:33.125
TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS THAT WE
00:11:33.192 --> 00:11:35.461
HOPE TO BE MADE IN THE NEXT
00:11:35.528 --> 00:11:36.562
COMMITTEE AND SO WE'LL BE
00:11:36.629 --> 00:11:37.997
LOOKING FORWARD TO REMOVING OUR
00:11:38.064 --> 00:11:38.964
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:11:39.031 --> 00:11:42.601
THANK YOU NEXT. AND THEY'RE
00:11:42.668 --> 00:11:45.504
CURRENTLY NONE OTHER IN QUÊ.
00:11:45.571 --> 00:11:48.074
THANK YOU. LET'S COME BACK TO
00:11:48.140 --> 00:11:49.909
THE CHAMBER. IS ANYBODY IN THE
00:11:49.975 --> 00:11:51.110
CHAMBER WISHING TO TESTIFY IN
00:11:51.177 --> 00:11:52.711
PERSON IN OPPOSITION TO BE 25
00:11:52.778 --> 00:11:57.249
94? WE SHOW NO PRIMARY WITNESS.
00:11:57.316 --> 00:11:58.684
SEEING NONE. MR MODERATOR, IF
00:11:58.751 --> 00:11:59.652
YOU COULD PLEASE QUERY THE
00:11:59.718 --> 00:12:00.820
TELECONFERENCE LINE FOR ANYBODY
00:12:00.886 --> 00:12:02.655
WISHING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
00:12:02.721 --> 00:12:07.193
TO A B 25 94. OF COURSE, IF
00:12:07.259 --> 00:12:08.794
THERE ARE ANY IN OPPOSITION,
00:12:08.861 --> 00:12:18.137
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND THEY'RE
00:12:18.204 --> 00:12:20.239
CURRENTLY NONE IN OPPOSITION.
00:12:20.306 --> 00:12:21.774
VERY GOOD. LET'S COME BACK TO
00:12:21.841 --> 00:12:23.075
THE CHAMBER TO THE MEMBERS. DO
00:12:23.142 --> 00:12:24.110
ANY OF THE MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE
00:12:24.176 --> 00:12:25.978
WISH TO MAKE A COMMENT OR ASK A
00:12:26.045 --> 00:12:29.048
QUESTION. SAYING NONE. MR TING,
00:12:29.115 --> 00:12:31.383
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? THANK
00:12:31.450 --> 00:12:32.952
YOU, MR CHAIR. I WOULD REALLY
00:12:33.018 --> 00:12:34.120
APPRECIATE ALL THE COMMENTS
00:12:34.186 --> 00:12:36.522
APPRECIATE THEIR WORTH AND
00:12:36.589 --> 00:12:38.657
MIRROR. MR HERALDS COMMENTS.
00:12:38.724 --> 00:12:39.758
WE'VE WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH
00:12:39.825 --> 00:12:40.893
THE TOLL AGENCIES. WE THINK THIS
00:12:40.960 --> 00:12:43.596
IS A BILL THAT REALLY WILL HELP
00:12:43.662 --> 00:12:46.432
MANY WORKING PEOPLE JUST TRYING
00:12:46.499 --> 00:12:48.000
TO GET TO WORK. HELP THEM WITH
00:12:48.067 --> 00:12:49.668
THEIR TOLLS. WE ULTIMATELY
00:12:49.735 --> 00:12:51.504
BELIEVE THAT NOBODY SHOULD GET
00:12:51.570 --> 00:12:54.006
FINED FOR DRIVING TO WORK. AND
00:12:54.073 --> 00:12:56.208
WE RESPECT FOR S FIVE OR ON A B.
00:12:56.275 --> 00:12:58.410
25 94 APPRECIATE THAT. SO AS WE
00:12:58.477 --> 00:13:00.212
DON'T YET HAVE A QUORUM. WE WILL
00:13:00.279 --> 00:13:02.281
TAKE THAT UP AS SOON AS WE DO,
00:13:02.348 --> 00:13:03.382
BUT THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:13:03.449 --> 00:13:05.284
TESTIMONY, AND WE WILL LET YOU
00:13:05.351 --> 00:13:08.721
KNOW. PRE. SHE ATE. THANK YOU.
00:13:08.787 --> 00:13:11.757
VERY GOOD. NEXT UP. WE HAVE
00:13:11.824 --> 00:13:13.225
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLDING. I SHOW
00:13:13.292 --> 00:13:15.828
YOU WITH THREE BILLS. I ASSUME
00:13:15.895 --> 00:13:17.029
YOU'LL BE STARTING WITHOUT A
00:13:17.096 --> 00:13:18.797
NUMBER. 1 85 12. WELCOME, MR
00:13:18.864 --> 00:13:23.235
HOLDEN. THANK YOU, MR CHAIRMAN.
00:13:23.302 --> 00:13:24.737
PLEASE PROCEED AT YOUR LEISURE.
00:13:24.803 --> 00:13:28.841
THANK YOU. FIRST I'D LIKE TO
00:13:28.908 --> 00:13:31.043
THANK THE CHAIR AND THE
00:13:31.110 --> 00:13:32.411
CONSULTANT FOR WORKING WITH MY
00:13:32.478 --> 00:13:34.079
STAFF ON THIS BILL AND THAT I
00:13:34.146 --> 00:13:35.281
WILL ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
00:13:35.347 --> 00:13:38.350
AMENDMENTS. TODAY I WOULD LIKE
00:13:38.417 --> 00:13:40.252
TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL 5 12
00:13:40.319 --> 00:13:41.187
BILL THAT AUTHORIZES THE
00:13:41.253 --> 00:13:42.655
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
00:13:42.721 --> 00:13:44.190
COMMISSION TO RELINQUISH A
00:13:44.256 --> 00:13:45.958
PORTION OF THE STATE HIGHWAY
00:13:46.025 --> 00:13:46.926
THAT CONTAINS AN INFRASTRUCTURE
00:13:46.992 --> 00:13:49.395
BARRIER. AS DEFINED TO A CITY OR
00:13:49.461 --> 00:13:52.898
COUNTY. IF THE DEPARTMENT AND
00:13:52.965 --> 00:13:54.466
THE APPLICABLE CITY OR COUNTY
00:13:54.533 --> 00:13:55.901
HAVE ENTERED INTO AN AGREEMENT
00:13:55.968 --> 00:13:57.670
PROVIDING FOR THE RELINQUISHMENT
00:13:57.736 --> 00:13:58.837
OF THE PORTION OF THE STATE
00:13:58.904 --> 00:14:01.540
HIGHWAY. AS MANY OF YOU KNOW
00:14:01.607 --> 00:14:04.043
DIVISIONS. THE DIVISION HAS BEEN
00:14:04.109 --> 00:14:06.245
AT THE CENTER OF SO MUCH UNREST.
00:14:06.312 --> 00:14:07.479
NOT ONLY IN CALIFORNIA BUT ALSO
00:14:07.546 --> 00:14:09.648
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY. THIS
00:14:09.715 --> 00:14:11.884
BILL METAPHORICALLY AND IN
00:14:11.951 --> 00:14:13.886
ACTUALITY SEEKS TO REMOVE
00:14:13.953 --> 00:14:15.721
INFRASTRUCTURAL BARRIERS THAT
00:14:15.788 --> 00:14:16.889
HAVE UPROOTED AND DIVIDED
00:14:16.956 --> 00:14:18.624
COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
00:14:18.691 --> 00:14:20.059
BY ESTABLISHING A SET OF
00:14:20.125 --> 00:14:21.760
CRITERIA FOR RELINQUISHMENT
00:14:21.827 --> 00:14:22.795
DESIGNED TO ENHANCE COMMUNITY
00:14:22.861 --> 00:14:26.465
CONNECTIVITY. IT ALSO TAKES A
00:14:26.532 --> 00:14:28.601
STEP TOWARDS ALLOWING THE STATE
00:14:28.667 --> 00:14:30.803
AND THE CITY TO WRITE HISTORIC
00:14:30.869 --> 00:14:33.572
WRONGS. SPECIFICALLY MAYBE 5 12
00:14:33.639 --> 00:14:36.809
ALLOWS THE CITY'S CTC. TO
00:14:36.875 --> 00:14:38.978
RELINQUISH A PORTION OF A STATE
00:14:39.044 --> 00:14:40.512
HIGHWAY TO A CITY OR COUNTY OF
00:14:40.579 --> 00:14:41.280
THE PURPOSE OF THE
00:14:41.347 --> 00:14:42.881
RELINQUISHMENT IS FOR
00:14:42.948 --> 00:14:44.216
RESTORATIVE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL
00:14:44.283 --> 00:14:45.484
JUSTICE, INCLUDING BUT NOT
00:14:45.551 --> 00:14:48.220
LIMITED TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
00:14:48.287 --> 00:14:49.722
TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT AND
00:14:49.788 --> 00:14:52.424
GREEN SPACE. ONE OF THE
00:14:52.491 --> 00:14:53.559
CLARIFYING AMENDMENTS THAT I
00:14:53.626 --> 00:14:56.228
WOULD LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT. THAT IS
00:14:56.295 --> 00:14:57.196
MENTIONED IN THE ANALYSIS IS
00:14:57.263 --> 00:14:59.698
THAT THIS BILL DOES NOT IMPACT A
00:14:59.765 --> 00:15:00.332
RELINQUISHMENT PROCESS THAT HAS
00:15:00.399 --> 00:15:04.236
COMMENCED. TWO PRIOR TO JANUARY,
00:15:04.303 --> 00:15:08.607
1ST 2023 I ASKED FOR YOUR IBOOK.
00:15:08.674 --> 00:15:11.710
THANK YOU. I UNDERSTAND ON THE
00:15:11.777 --> 00:15:13.846
CO HOST LINE. WE HAVE A WITNESS
00:15:13.912 --> 00:15:21.854
FROM THE CITY OF PASADENA. OH IN
00:15:21.920 --> 00:15:24.023
PERSON WILL WELCOME
00:15:24.089 --> 00:15:25.991
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE CITY OF
00:15:26.058 --> 00:15:27.793
ROSES, PLEASE PURSUIT. I'M NOT
00:15:27.860 --> 00:15:29.161
FROM PASADENA, DEBORAH CARLSON
00:15:29.228 --> 00:15:29.928
WITH A CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
00:15:29.995 --> 00:15:32.798
ASSOCIATION. FIRST WE WANT TO
00:15:32.865 --> 00:15:34.333
THANK THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR
00:15:34.400 --> 00:15:35.768
HIS DILIGENT WORK ON THIS BILL
00:15:35.834 --> 00:15:36.802
YOU KNOW, DECADES AGO,
00:15:36.869 --> 00:15:38.137
CALIFORNIA'S HIGHWAYS WERE BUILT
00:15:38.203 --> 00:15:40.339
TO IMPROVE MOBILITY. DESPITE THE
00:15:40.406 --> 00:15:41.874
INPUT IMPACT THEY WOULD HAVE ON
00:15:41.940 --> 00:15:44.877
ADJACENT COMMUNITIES. MAYBE 512
00:15:44.943 --> 00:15:47.012
REMEDIES THAT PRIOR OVERSIGHT BY
00:15:47.079 --> 00:15:49.948
PROVIDING A STATEWIDE PROCESS TO
00:15:50.015 --> 00:15:51.450
RECONNECT THESE COMMUNITIES ONCE
00:15:51.517 --> 00:15:52.951
THE HIGHWAY IS NO LONGER OF
00:15:53.018 --> 00:15:55.321
SERVICE. FOR THESE REASONS, WE
00:15:55.387 --> 00:15:56.889
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE
00:15:56.955 --> 00:15:58.657
TODAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:15:58.724 --> 00:16:01.560
THANK YOU. IS ANYBODY ELSE YOU'D
00:16:01.627 --> 00:16:02.761
LIKE TO TESTIFY AS YOU DO? WE
00:16:02.828 --> 00:16:03.996
HAVE ANOTHER PRIMARY WITNESS.
00:16:04.063 --> 00:16:05.798
I'M ASSUMING NOT DO WE HAVE A
00:16:05.864 --> 00:16:07.800
WITNESS ON THE PHONE? MY RECORDS
00:16:07.866 --> 00:16:12.404
INDICATE WE THEN I GUESS WE DO
00:16:12.471 --> 00:16:13.772
NOT. UM, IS THERE ANYBODY IN THE
00:16:13.839 --> 00:16:14.907
CHAMBER LIKE TESTIFY IN PERSON
00:16:14.973 --> 00:16:16.075
WITH YOUR NAME? YOUR AFFILIATION
00:16:16.141 --> 00:16:19.645
YOUR POSITION. HI KIRA ROSS ON
00:16:19.712 --> 00:16:20.913
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF PASADENA,
00:16:20.979 --> 00:16:22.314
AND I'M ACTUALLY A TWEENER, SO I
00:16:22.381 --> 00:16:25.851
WANTED TO AH! PLEASE YOU WANT TO
00:16:25.918 --> 00:16:29.254
GO NOW? PLEASE TWEEN AT YOUR
00:16:29.321 --> 00:16:30.823
GOOD AFTERNOON, SHERIFF ROSS
00:16:30.889 --> 00:16:32.424
AGAIN ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
00:16:32.491 --> 00:16:35.427
PASADENA REALLY THANKFUL THE FOR
00:16:35.494 --> 00:16:36.362
THE AMENDMENTS THAT THE AUTHORS
00:16:36.428 --> 00:16:37.930
TAKEN, AND WITH THOSE
00:16:37.996 --> 00:16:38.931
AMENDMENTS, WE ARE ABLE TO
00:16:38.997 --> 00:16:40.733
REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION. HOWEVER
00:16:40.799 --> 00:16:42.801
THE COUNCIL HAS YET TO BE ABLE
00:16:42.868 --> 00:16:44.536
TO REALLY TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE
00:16:44.603 --> 00:16:45.871
AMENDMENTS. SO FOR TODAY, WE'RE
00:16:45.938 --> 00:16:47.072
JUST GOING TO BE REMOVING OUR
00:16:47.139 --> 00:16:49.241
OPPOSITION AND REMAIN THANKFUL.
00:16:49.308 --> 00:16:50.242
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYBODY IN
00:16:50.309 --> 00:16:51.643
THE CHAMBER LIKE TEST RIGHT? IN
00:16:51.710 --> 00:16:53.612
SUPPORT WOULD NAME AFFILIATION
00:16:53.679 --> 00:16:55.714
AND YOUR POSITION ON BEHALF OF
00:16:55.781 --> 00:16:58.117
THE 5 12 SEEING NONE. MISS
00:16:58.183 --> 00:16:59.551
MODERATOR, LET'S GO TO THE
00:16:59.618 --> 00:17:00.652
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:17:00.719 --> 00:17:01.453
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
00:17:01.520 --> 00:17:02.488
ONLY LIKE TESTIFY AND SUPPORT.
00:17:02.554 --> 00:17:18.370
OF 85 12. MR MODERATE. HAVE WE
00:17:18.437 --> 00:17:35.387
LOST THE MODERATOR?
00:17:35.921 --> 00:17:39.091
I UNDERSTAND. WE'RE HAVING SOME
00:17:39.158 --> 00:17:40.125
TECHNICAL DIFFICULTIES NOW WITH
00:17:40.192 --> 00:17:43.495
THE AUDIO DEEP SIDE FROM THE
00:17:43.562 --> 00:17:59.745
CONSULTANT.
00:18:02.681 --> 00:18:04.149
IS WHAT? WELL WHILE WE'RE
00:18:04.216 --> 00:18:05.617
WAITING IS ANYBODY LIKE
00:18:05.684 --> 00:18:06.685
TESTIFYING OPPOSITION IN PERSON
00:18:06.752 --> 00:18:25.404
TO A B 5 12. SEE NONE.
00:19:19.992 --> 00:19:22.160
TO THE T V STEP. WE'RE GOING TO
00:19:22.227 --> 00:19:23.629
TAKE A BRIEF RECESS. YOU CAN GO
00:19:23.695 --> 00:19:25.163
TO THE RECESS IMAGE FOR THE
00:19:25.230 --> 00:19:26.999
COMMITTEE HEARING WHILE WE WORK
00:19:27.065 --> 00:19:28.667
OUT THE AUDIO TECHNICAL PROBLEMS
00:19:28.734 --> 00:19:29.868
SO THIS COMMITTEE WILL RECESS
00:19:29.935 --> 00:19:42.548
FOR THE TIME BEING.
00:19:42.614 --> 00:19:44.917
LOST THE AUDIO. WE WERE GOING TO
00:19:44.983 --> 00:19:46.785
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE FOR
00:19:46.852 --> 00:19:49.321
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF 85 12.
00:19:49.388 --> 00:19:51.690
WITH NAME AFFILIATION. AND
00:19:51.757 --> 00:19:52.724
POSITION. GO AHEAD, MISS
00:19:52.791 --> 00:19:57.896
MONAHAN. IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT,
00:19:57.963 --> 00:20:00.499
PLEASE PRESS 10 1ST GOT A LINE
00:20:00.566 --> 00:20:15.581
73. 73 YEAR LINE IS OPEN. WELL
00:20:15.647 --> 00:20:17.549
NEXT, THEN GO TO LINE 48. PLEASE
00:20:17.616 --> 00:20:30.295
GO AHEAD. 9 48 YEARS OPEN. WITH
00:20:30.362 --> 00:20:36.335
ME. YES, AS YOU, SIR. I JUST
00:20:36.401 --> 00:20:38.136
STOOD UP TO LET YOU KNOW THERE
00:20:38.203 --> 00:20:39.705
WAS AN AUDIO ISSUE. THEY HAVE
00:20:39.771 --> 00:20:40.906
NOTHING TO SAY ON THIS, BILL.
00:20:40.973 --> 00:20:44.810
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT,
00:20:44.876 --> 00:20:49.414
PLEASE ANY PARLIAMENT, MR CHAIR.
00:20:49.481 --> 00:20:50.649
ALL RIGHT. GO AHEAD, PLEASE. QUÊ
00:20:50.716 --> 00:20:55.287
IT AGAIN. ONCE AGAIN IF THERE IS
00:20:55.354 --> 00:20:56.555
ANYONE THAT IS IN SUPPORT,
00:20:56.622 --> 00:21:06.264
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND THERE IS
00:21:06.331 --> 00:21:08.367
CURRENTLY NO ONE IN THE QUEUE.
00:21:08.433 --> 00:21:10.602
THANK YOU. COME BACK TO THE
00:21:10.669 --> 00:21:13.105
CHAMBER. UH I DON'T SEE ANYBODY
00:21:13.171 --> 00:21:14.373
ONE MORE TIME. IS ANYBODY HERE
00:21:14.439 --> 00:21:15.474
LIKE TEST RIGHT OPPOSITION 85
00:21:15.540 --> 00:21:18.043
12. AGAINST MS MODERATE. LET'S
00:21:18.110 --> 00:21:19.344
GO BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:21:19.411 --> 00:21:21.647
LINE. IF YOU COULD PLEASE ASK IF
00:21:21.713 --> 00:21:22.247
ANYBODY ON THE LINE WOULD LIKE
00:21:22.314 --> 00:21:23.749
TEST RIGHT OPPOSITION TO BE 5
00:21:23.815 --> 00:21:28.387
12. OF COURSE. THERE'S ANYONE IN
00:21:28.453 --> 00:21:40.732
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10.
00:21:40.799 --> 00:21:42.034
THERE'S CURRENTLY NO ONE QUEUING
00:21:42.100 --> 00:21:43.735
UP AS WELL. VERY GOOD. LET'S
00:21:43.802 --> 00:21:45.303
COME BACK TO THE CHAMBER, ANY
00:21:45.370 --> 00:21:46.371
MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE WITH
00:21:46.438 --> 00:21:47.372
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THE
00:21:47.439 --> 00:21:50.275
BILL. SAYING NONE. MR. HOLDEN
00:21:50.342 --> 00:21:51.810
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I
00:21:51.877 --> 00:21:52.878
APPRECIATE YOUR PATIENCE WITH
00:21:52.944 --> 00:21:54.846
ALL THIS. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
00:21:54.913 --> 00:21:56.348
IT IS MY PLEASURE TO PRESENT
00:21:56.415 --> 00:21:57.683
THIS BILL AND AS WE FOLLOWED,
00:21:57.749 --> 00:21:59.484
AND SO MANY INSTANCES AROUND THE
00:21:59.551 --> 00:22:02.287
COUNTRY WHERE FREEWAYS WERE
00:22:02.354 --> 00:22:03.822
BUILT, AT TIMES THAT ACTUALLY
00:22:03.889 --> 00:22:06.892
DISPLACED A LOT OF FOLKS,
00:22:06.958 --> 00:22:09.561
HARDWORKING COMMUNITIES. AND NOW
00:22:09.628 --> 00:22:11.063
THAT WHEN WE SEE THAT THESE
00:22:11.129 --> 00:22:12.030
FREEWAYS OR MAYBE BECOMING OR
00:22:12.097 --> 00:22:15.100
SURPLUS LAND THAT IS CONNECTED
00:22:15.167 --> 00:22:16.268
TWO PROJECTS THAT ARE NO LONGER
00:22:16.334 --> 00:22:19.037
NEEDED. THIS IS A GREAT
00:22:19.104 --> 00:22:20.172
OPPORTUNITY TO TRANSITION INTO
00:22:20.238 --> 00:22:23.442
PROJECTS THAT ARE OUR PRIORITIES
00:22:23.508 --> 00:22:25.143
FOR THE STATE, AND SO WHEN YOU
00:22:25.210 --> 00:22:27.345
HAVE YOUR QUORUM, I RESPECTFULLY
00:22:27.412 --> 00:22:29.081
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE. I APPRECIATE
00:22:29.147 --> 00:22:31.383
THAT. THE BILL HAS A DO PASS AS
00:22:31.450 --> 00:22:32.684
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS
00:22:32.751 --> 00:22:34.453
RECOMMENDATION FROM THE CHAIR.
00:22:34.519 --> 00:22:36.121
WE WILL TAKE THAT UP WHEN WE
00:22:36.188 --> 00:22:37.823
HAVE A QUORUM. THANK YOU VERY
00:22:37.889 --> 00:22:39.057
MUCH. LET'S MOVE TO YOUR NEXT
00:22:39.124 --> 00:22:40.892
BILL, WHICH I BELIEVE YOU CAN
00:22:40.959 --> 00:22:43.228
PRESENT A B 1919. THANK YOU, MR
00:22:43.295 --> 00:22:44.096
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
00:22:44.162 --> 00:22:44.930
COMMITTEE FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:22:44.996 --> 00:22:47.099
PRESENT A B 1919. THIS BILL
00:22:47.165 --> 00:22:48.600
ESTABLISHES THE YOUTH TRANSIT
00:22:48.667 --> 00:22:50.202
PAST PILOT PROGRAM, A GRANT
00:22:50.268 --> 00:22:51.937
PROGRAM FOR TRANSIT AGENCIES
00:22:52.003 --> 00:22:53.405
DESIGNED TO FIND FAIR FREE
00:22:53.472 --> 00:22:54.573
TRANSIT PASSES FOR CALIFORNIA
00:22:54.639 --> 00:22:59.711
STUDENTS. UNDER A B 1919 TRANSIT
00:22:59.778 --> 00:23:00.846
AGENCIES ARE ENCOURAGED TO
00:23:00.912 --> 00:23:01.847
COLLABORATE WITH EDUCATIONAL
00:23:01.913 --> 00:23:03.348
INSTITUTIONS ON THE GRANT
00:23:03.415 --> 00:23:05.350
APPLICATION AND USE THE FUNDS
00:23:05.417 --> 00:23:06.551
WORKING TOGETHER. THESE PUBLIC
00:23:06.618 --> 00:23:08.787
AGENCIES ARE BEST POSITION. TO
00:23:08.854 --> 00:23:10.822
CREATE ROBUST TRANSIT STUDENT
00:23:10.889 --> 00:23:12.491
TRANSIT PAST PROGRAMS FOR
00:23:12.557 --> 00:23:14.960
STUDENTS AND THE SERVICE AREA.
00:23:15.026 --> 00:23:16.561
FOR STUDENTS. ACCESS TO TRANSIT
00:23:16.628 --> 00:23:18.797
IS INSEPARABLE FROM THEIR
00:23:18.864 --> 00:23:20.332
CAPACITY TO PURSUE THEIR
00:23:20.398 --> 00:23:22.267
EDUCATION, SUPPORT THEMSELVES
00:23:22.334 --> 00:23:23.568
AND THEIR FAMILIES AND OBTAIN
00:23:23.635 --> 00:23:26.071
THE CALIFORNIA DREAM. STUDY
00:23:26.138 --> 00:23:28.073
AFTER STUDY HAS SHOWN THE
00:23:28.140 --> 00:23:28.974
POSITIVE BENEFITS OF EXPANDING
00:23:29.040 --> 00:23:31.076
FAIR FREE TRANSIT PROGRAMS FOR
00:23:31.143 --> 00:23:31.843
BOTH STUDENTS AND THE TRANSIT
00:23:31.910 --> 00:23:34.212
AGENCIES. THAT SERVED THEM.
00:23:34.279 --> 00:23:36.882
TODAY IS THE TIME TO ACT BECAUSE
00:23:36.948 --> 00:23:38.950
MAYBE 1919 IS A WIN FOR OUR
00:23:39.017 --> 00:23:40.519
STUDENTS, OUR CLIMATE AND OUR
00:23:40.585 --> 00:23:43.388
TRANSIT AGENCIES. HERE WITH ME
00:23:43.455 --> 00:23:46.792
TODAY IS MICHAEL PIMENTAL. THE
00:23:46.858 --> 00:23:48.293
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
00:23:48.360 --> 00:23:49.628
CALIFORNIA TRANSIT ASSOCIATION,
00:23:49.694 --> 00:23:52.831
AND JOSHUA ELIZONDO. THE
00:23:52.898 --> 00:23:54.166
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:23:54.232 --> 00:23:55.901
STUDENT PRESIDENT TO TESTIFY AND
00:23:55.967 --> 00:23:58.403
SUPPORT. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:23:58.470 --> 00:23:59.604
YOUR ADVICE. THANK YOU, SIR. MR
00:23:59.671 --> 00:24:01.606
PIMENTO WELCOME. PLEASE RECEIPT.
00:24:01.673 --> 00:24:03.708
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:24:03.775 --> 00:24:04.309
. MICHAEL PIMENTEL, EXECUTIVE
00:24:04.376 --> 00:24:05.777
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:24:05.844 --> 00:24:07.212
TRANSIT ASSOCIATION, AND I'M
00:24:07.279 --> 00:24:08.480
PLEASED TO JOIN YOU THIS
00:24:08.547 --> 00:24:10.048
AFTERNOON TO VOICE MY
00:24:10.115 --> 00:24:11.917
ASSOCIATION SUPPORT FOR A B 1919
00:24:11.983 --> 00:24:15.053
AS AMENDED. JUNE 14TH. AS I
00:24:15.120 --> 00:24:16.521
BEGIN MY REMARKS, I WANT TO
00:24:16.588 --> 00:24:17.656
FIRST THINK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:24:17.722 --> 00:24:18.924
HOLDIN HIS STAFF AND THE POLICY
00:24:18.990 --> 00:24:21.159
COMMITTEES IN BOTH HOUSES FOR
00:24:21.226 --> 00:24:22.460
WORKING COLLABORATIVELY WITH MY
00:24:22.527 --> 00:24:24.062
ASSOCIATION AND OUR MEMBERS TO
00:24:24.129 --> 00:24:25.597
ADDRESS THE VARIOUS TECHNICAL
00:24:25.664 --> 00:24:26.765
AND SUBSTANTIVE CONCERNS. WE
00:24:26.832 --> 00:24:27.933
RAISED THE BILL AS ORIGINALLY
00:24:27.999 --> 00:24:29.901
INTRODUCED. THEIR WILLINGNESS TO
00:24:29.968 --> 00:24:31.336
WORK WITH US TO DEVELOP A
00:24:31.403 --> 00:24:32.370
STATUTORY AND FUNDING FRAMEWORK
00:24:32.437 --> 00:24:33.772
THAT WILL DELIVER OPERATIONAL
00:24:33.839 --> 00:24:35.106
BENEFITS TO CALIFORNIA'S TRANSIT
00:24:35.173 --> 00:24:36.608
AGENCIES. AND OUR WRITERS
00:24:36.675 --> 00:24:38.410
ALLOWED US TO REMOVE OUR
00:24:38.476 --> 00:24:39.911
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL. AS THE
00:24:39.978 --> 00:24:41.246
COMMITTEE'S ANALYSIS. DETAILS.
00:24:41.313 --> 00:24:43.448
18 1919 ADVANCES IN EVIDENCE
00:24:43.515 --> 00:24:45.050
BASED FISCALLY RESPONSIBLE AND
00:24:45.116 --> 00:24:46.351
ELECTIVE FRAMEWORK FOR EXPANDING
00:24:46.418 --> 00:24:47.385
FAIR FREE TRANSIT PROGRAM
00:24:47.452 --> 00:24:50.088
STATEWIDE. THE BILL ACKNOWLEDGES
00:24:50.155 --> 00:24:52.457
THAT FOR DECADES THE MOST
00:24:52.524 --> 00:24:53.725
SUCCESSFUL FINANCIALLY DURABLE
00:24:53.792 --> 00:24:55.393
AND EFFECTIVE FAIR FREE PROGRAMS
00:24:55.460 --> 00:24:56.494
HAVE OPERATED HIS PARTNERSHIP
00:24:56.561 --> 00:24:57.729
BETWEEN TRANSIT AGENCIES AND
00:24:57.796 --> 00:25:00.832
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS. SO TO
00:25:00.899 --> 00:25:02.567
BUILD ON THIS PROVEN MODEL. THE
00:25:02.634 --> 00:25:03.735
BILL PROVIDES NEW FUNDING TO
00:25:03.802 --> 00:25:05.237
INCENTIVIZE TRANSIT AGENCIES AND
00:25:05.303 --> 00:25:06.972
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS TO
00:25:07.038 --> 00:25:08.974
ENTER INTO NEW PARTNERSHIPS THAT
00:25:09.040 --> 00:25:09.541
EXPAND ACCESS TO FAIR FREE
00:25:09.608 --> 00:25:10.175
TRANSIT PROGRAMS COVERING, FOR
00:25:10.242 --> 00:25:11.176
EXAMPLE, NEW COLLEGES NEW
00:25:11.243 --> 00:25:15.313
SCHOOLS. OR NEW AGE DEMOGRAPHICS
00:25:15.380 --> 00:25:15.881
. THE BILL ALSO PROVIDES NEW
00:25:15.947 --> 00:25:17.382
FUNDING TO STRENGTHEN EXISTING
00:25:17.449 --> 00:25:18.984
PARTNERSHIPS, RECOGNIZING THAT
00:25:19.050 --> 00:25:20.552
THE COST OF MAINTAINING FAIR
00:25:20.619 --> 00:25:21.820
FREE TRANSIT PROGRAMS CAN BE
00:25:21.887 --> 00:25:23.121
CHALLENGING FOR TRANSIT AGENCIES
00:25:23.188 --> 00:25:24.055
AND EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
00:25:24.122 --> 00:25:26.324
ALIKE. AND THAT AT TIMES
00:25:26.391 --> 00:25:27.492
EXISTING PARTNERSHIPS CAN BE
00:25:27.559 --> 00:25:29.027
STRENGTHENED BY BEING COUPLED
00:25:29.094 --> 00:25:30.328
WITH INVESTMENTS AT ENHANCED
00:25:30.395 --> 00:25:32.430
TRANSIT SERVICE. FINALLY THE
00:25:32.497 --> 00:25:34.132
BILL RECOGNIZES THAT SEVERAL OF
00:25:34.199 --> 00:25:35.200
OUR LARGEST AGENCIES IN METRO
00:25:35.267 --> 00:25:37.602
AREAS LIKE L. A SAN FRANCISCO,
00:25:37.669 --> 00:25:39.237
SAN DIEGO, ORANGE COUNTY,
00:25:39.304 --> 00:25:39.971
RIVERSIDE AND SACRAMENTO
00:25:40.038 --> 00:25:41.806
CURRENTLY OVERSEE FAIR FREE
00:25:41.873 --> 00:25:42.941
TRANSIT PROGRAMS FOR INDIVIDUALS
00:25:43.008 --> 00:25:45.844
AGED 18 AND UNDER TO REWARD
00:25:45.911 --> 00:25:47.212
THESE AGENCIES FOR THEIR
00:25:47.279 --> 00:25:48.346
LEADERSHIP AND INCENTIVIZE
00:25:48.413 --> 00:25:49.381
OTHERS TO ADOPT SIMILAR
00:25:49.447 --> 00:25:51.283
UNIVERSAL FAIR FREE PROGRAMS.
00:25:51.349 --> 00:25:52.751
THE BILL OFFERS NEW FUNDING WITH
00:25:52.817 --> 00:25:54.119
MORE FLEXIBLE TERMS. WE BELIEVE
00:25:54.185 --> 00:25:56.821
THAT SHOULD BE 1919 BECOME LAW.
00:25:56.888 --> 00:25:57.923
IT WILL MAKE SIGNIFICANT
00:25:57.989 --> 00:25:59.357
PROGRESS TOWARD EXPANDING ACCESS
00:25:59.424 --> 00:26:00.725
TO FAIR FREE TRANSIT PROGRAM
00:26:00.792 --> 00:26:02.227
STATEWIDE ESTABLISHED
00:26:02.294 --> 00:26:03.728
PARTNERSHIPS THAT CAN OUTLIVE
00:26:03.795 --> 00:26:05.830
THE FUNDING PROVIDED BY THE BILL
00:26:05.897 --> 00:26:06.831
AND SUBSTANTIALLY INCREASE
00:26:06.898 --> 00:26:08.233
TRANSIT RIDERSHIP. AND FOR THESE
00:26:08.300 --> 00:26:09.467
REASONS, I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:26:09.534 --> 00:26:12.337
YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU. AND THANK
00:26:12.404 --> 00:26:13.605
YOU ON THE LINE. MR ELIZONDO,
00:26:13.672 --> 00:26:18.710
PLEASE PURSUED. HELLO GOOD
00:26:18.777 --> 00:26:19.811
AFTERNOON CHAIR. HONORABLE
00:26:19.878 --> 00:26:21.079
MEMBERS OF THE TRANSPORTATION
00:26:21.146 --> 00:26:21.913
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS JOSHUA
00:26:21.980 --> 00:26:24.115
ELIZONDO. I'M A STUDENT MEMBER
00:26:24.182 --> 00:26:24.916
OF THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
00:26:24.983 --> 00:26:26.217
COLLEGE BOARD OF GOVERNORS
00:26:26.284 --> 00:26:28.687
COUNTY
00:26:28.753 --> 00:26:29.955
WELL AS THE STUDENT GOVERNMENT
00:26:30.021 --> 00:26:30.855
PRESIDENT AND SANTA MONICA
00:26:30.922 --> 00:26:33.325
COLLEGE. MY COMMENTS TODAY AND
00:26:33.391 --> 00:26:34.592
MY PERSONAL OPINION, BUT A
00:26:34.659 --> 00:26:36.261
REFLECTION OF THE WORK THAT I DO
00:26:36.328 --> 00:26:37.462
AND THE THOUSANDS OF STUDENTS
00:26:37.529 --> 00:26:39.130
THAT I HAVE INTERACTED WITH MY
00:26:39.197 --> 00:26:40.532
TIME IN OFFICE AND ON AN
00:26:40.598 --> 00:26:41.800
ADJACENT NOTES. SANTA MONICA
00:26:41.866 --> 00:26:43.468
COLLEGE STUDENT BODY VOTED TO
00:26:43.535 --> 00:26:44.002
SUPPORT THIS BILL AS WELL.
00:26:44.069 --> 00:26:46.071
ASSEMBLY BILL 1919 AS A PIVOTAL
00:26:46.137 --> 00:26:47.639
STEP FORWARD TO PROVIDING ACCESS
00:26:47.706 --> 00:26:48.940
TO TRANSPORTATION FOR STUDENTS
00:26:49.007 --> 00:26:50.842
THAT WILL TRANSFORM THE WAY OUR
00:26:50.909 --> 00:26:51.376
COMMUNITIES NAVIGATE THEIR
00:26:51.443 --> 00:26:52.911
EDUCATION AND THEIR TIME OUTSIDE
00:26:52.978 --> 00:26:54.846
THE CLASSROOM. WHEN I FIRST
00:26:54.913 --> 00:26:55.880
HEARD OF THIS BILL, I WAS
00:26:55.947 --> 00:26:57.882
EXTREMELY EXCITED AS I HAD BEEN
00:26:57.949 --> 00:26:59.918
A PART OF THE INITIATIVE PASSED
00:26:59.985 --> 00:27:00.585
THE PILOT PROGRAM IN PARTNERSHIP
00:27:00.652 --> 00:27:02.754
WITH MOVE ELLIE IN HERE IN L, A
00:27:02.821 --> 00:27:04.522
COUNTY THAT TOOK EFFECT THIS
00:27:04.589 --> 00:27:05.757
PAST FALL FOR LOW INCOME AND
00:27:05.824 --> 00:27:07.225
COLLEGE STUDENT. I'M EQUALLY
00:27:07.292 --> 00:27:08.460
EXCITED TO LEARN THAT RECENTLY,
00:27:08.526 --> 00:27:09.294
COLLEGE STUDENTS WERE
00:27:09.361 --> 00:27:10.829
REINTRODUCED INTO THE BILL. AS A
00:27:10.895 --> 00:27:12.197
STUDENT WHO HAS STRUGGLED WITH
00:27:12.263 --> 00:27:13.365
FINANCES NAVIGATING ADULTHOOD AS
00:27:13.431 --> 00:27:15.834
A FORMER PROSTITUTE. PUBLIC
00:27:15.900 --> 00:27:17.268
TRANSPORTATION HAS BEEN PIVOTAL
00:27:17.335 --> 00:27:18.136
IN ALLOWING ME TO HAVE ACCESS TO
00:27:18.203 --> 00:27:20.305
MY COMMUNITY. THIS PASSING OF
00:27:20.372 --> 00:27:23.241
THE PAST PROGRAM HERE IN L. A. I
00:27:23.308 --> 00:27:24.009
HAVE CHOSEN TO FOREGO USING MY
00:27:24.075 --> 00:27:25.610
PERSONAL TRANSPORTATION AND HAVE
00:27:25.677 --> 00:27:27.445
WRITTEN THE METRO FOR THE FIRST
00:27:27.512 --> 00:27:28.580
TIME IN SEVERAL YEARS. BESIDES
00:27:28.646 --> 00:27:29.914
MY OWN STORY, THOSE THAT HAVE
00:27:29.981 --> 00:27:31.983
ACCESS TO THESE TRANSPORTATION
00:27:32.050 --> 00:27:33.184
SERVICES MAY NOT HAVE CARS AND
00:27:33.251 --> 00:27:34.953
WILL BE ABLE TO GO TO SCHOOL TO
00:27:35.020 --> 00:27:36.321
WORK TO RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES
00:27:36.388 --> 00:27:38.189
TO FAMILY TO FRIENDS. THEY'LL BE
00:27:38.256 --> 00:27:39.624
ACTIVELY CONTRIBUTING TO BUILD
00:27:39.691 --> 00:27:40.725
MORE VIBRANT COMMUNITY AND
00:27:40.792 --> 00:27:42.293
HEALTHIER ECONOMY WHEN THEY HAVE
00:27:42.360 --> 00:27:43.728
THE ABILITY TO RIDE THROUGHOUT
00:27:43.795 --> 00:27:45.397
THEIR CITIES WITH REDUCED OR
00:27:45.463 --> 00:27:47.432
WAIVED FARES. ISABELLE REED WILL
00:27:47.499 --> 00:27:49.167
RECREATE OUR EXPERIENCE AND IN
00:27:49.234 --> 00:27:50.769
THE NEXT STEP TO TRANSFORM THE
00:27:50.835 --> 00:27:52.737
LIVES ACROSS OF STUDENTS ACROSS
00:27:52.804 --> 00:27:54.406
OUR STATE, LASTLY BY PROVIDING
00:27:54.472 --> 00:27:55.273
FUNDING TO LOCAL MUNICIPALITIES
00:27:55.340 --> 00:27:56.207
SEEKING TO EXPAND THEIR
00:27:56.274 --> 00:27:58.343
TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM. THIS
00:27:58.410 --> 00:27:59.744
BILL, REDUCE GREENHOUSE
00:27:59.811 --> 00:28:01.246
EMISSIONS FROM CARS ON THE ROAD
00:28:01.312 --> 00:28:02.113
AND PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY
00:28:02.180 --> 00:28:03.381
INCREASED RIDERSHIP BY ALLOWING
00:28:03.448 --> 00:28:04.849
CRUCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE TO BE
00:28:04.916 --> 00:28:06.518
BUILT AND PUT CALIFORNIA ON THE
00:28:06.584 --> 00:28:07.886
FOREFRONT OF THE LARGEST
00:28:07.952 --> 00:28:08.787
INITIATIVE OF PUBLIC
00:28:08.853 --> 00:28:10.121
TRANSPORTATION ACROSS THIS
00:28:10.188 --> 00:28:11.756
COUNTRY AT A TIME WHEN WE ARE IN
00:28:11.823 --> 00:28:12.824
DESPERATE NEED OF LEADERS ON
00:28:12.891 --> 00:28:13.892
CLIMATE CHANGE AND EQUITY.
00:28:13.958 --> 00:28:15.226
HOPEFULLY ONE DAY WE CAN BUILD
00:28:15.293 --> 00:28:17.862
UPON A B 1919. SO THAT THE
00:28:17.929 --> 00:28:18.997
CITIZENS OF OUR GREAT STATE CAN
00:28:19.064 --> 00:28:20.632
RIDE ANYWHERE. ANYTIME HAVE THE
00:28:20.698 --> 00:28:22.600
ABILITY TO EXPERIENCE ALL THAT
00:28:22.667 --> 00:28:23.435
CALIFORNIA HAS OFFERED. PLEASE
00:28:23.501 --> 00:28:26.838
BOOK I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
00:28:26.905 --> 00:28:29.340
THANK YOU. LET'S STAY HERE IN
00:28:29.407 --> 00:28:30.275
THE COMMITTEE ROOM FOR WITNESSES
00:28:30.341 --> 00:28:34.579
IN SUPPORT. POLICE PURSUE. GOOD
00:28:34.646 --> 00:28:35.480
AFTERNOON, STEVE. WELCOME BACK
00:28:35.547 --> 00:28:36.915
AFTER THE ALAMEDA CONTRA CONTRA
00:28:36.981 --> 00:28:38.483
TRANSIT DISTRICT AS THE BILL HAS
00:28:38.550 --> 00:28:40.051
BEEN AMENDED, THEY SUPPORT AND
00:28:40.118 --> 00:28:41.653
THEN ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:28:41.719 --> 00:28:42.687
ASSOCIATION OF COORDINATED
00:28:42.754 --> 00:28:43.621
TRANSIT, THEY REMOVED OUR
00:28:43.688 --> 00:28:45.590
POSITION TO THE BILL. MR WALLY
00:28:45.657 --> 00:28:49.828
NEXT THANK YOU, MR CHAIRMAN AND
00:28:49.894 --> 00:28:51.796
MEMBERS MORE ATOP ON BEHALF OF
00:28:51.863 --> 00:28:52.430
THE ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION
00:28:52.497 --> 00:28:55.366
AUTHORITY IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
00:28:55.433 --> 00:28:57.135
ANY OTHER WITNESSES SUPPORT,
00:28:57.202 --> 00:28:59.304
SAYING NONE. LET'S GO TO THE
00:28:59.370 --> 00:28:59.971
TELECONFERENCE. I'M MR
00:29:00.038 --> 00:29:00.905
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:29:00.972 --> 00:29:02.006
QUERY THE LINE FOR ANY WITNESSES
00:29:02.073 --> 00:29:06.911
IN SUPPORT OF A B 1919. OF
00:29:06.978 --> 00:29:08.113
COURSE, IF YOU'RE IN SUPPORT OF
00:29:08.179 --> 00:29:12.383
A B 1919 POLICE PRESS 10 WE'LL
00:29:12.450 --> 00:29:16.087
GO TO LINE 73, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:29:16.154 --> 00:29:18.490
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, MATT
00:29:18.556 --> 00:29:19.257
ROBINSON. CELLULAR ANTENNAE
00:29:19.324 --> 00:29:20.525
SMELLS ARE IN LANG ON BEHALF OF
00:29:20.592 --> 00:29:21.659
THE MONTEREY SALINAS TRANSIT
00:29:21.726 --> 00:29:22.760
DISTRICT IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU,
00:29:22.827 --> 00:29:27.031
MR ROBINSON NEXT. WE'LL GO TO
00:29:27.098 --> 00:29:31.736
LINE 48, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:29:31.803 --> 00:29:33.438
WILLIAMS MARK BOOKS REPRESENTING
00:29:33.505 --> 00:29:34.572
STREETS FOR ALL AND WE'RE PROUD
00:29:34.639 --> 00:29:36.174
TO SUPPORT THIS BILL. THANK YOU.
00:29:36.241 --> 00:29:40.278
THANK YOU NEXT. THE LITTLE LINE.
00:29:40.345 --> 00:29:44.582
85, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:29:44.649 --> 00:29:45.984
AFTERNOON, DANIEL BROUGHT ON
00:29:46.050 --> 00:29:47.352
BEHALF OF THEIR CLUBS,
00:29:47.418 --> 00:29:48.353
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. THANK
00:29:48.419 --> 00:29:50.421
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT. WE'LL GO TO
00:29:50.488 --> 00:29:56.427
LINE 86. PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS
00:29:56.494 --> 00:29:57.862
IS SANTIAGO RODRIGUEZ,
00:29:57.929 --> 00:29:58.496
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS
00:29:58.563 --> 00:30:04.302
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT. GOT
00:30:04.369 --> 00:30:09.307
A LINE 33, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS
00:30:09.374 --> 00:30:11.309
IS AMY THOMPSON WAS TRANSFORMED
00:30:11.376 --> 00:30:12.510
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:30:12.577 --> 00:30:16.147
NEXT. NUMBER WINE 78, PLEASE GO
00:30:16.214 --> 00:30:20.485
AHEAD. ON BEHALF OF THE GREEN
00:30:20.552 --> 00:30:21.319
LIGHTING INSTITUTE SUPPORT THANK
00:30:21.386 --> 00:30:27.525
YOU NEXT. WE'LL GO TO LINE 87,
00:30:27.592 --> 00:30:31.963
PLEASE GO AHEAD. JONES ON BEHALF
00:30:32.030 --> 00:30:33.431
OF USE FOR CLIMATE JUSTICE AND
00:30:33.498 --> 00:30:34.499
THE SANTA CRUZ CLIMATE
00:30:34.566 --> 00:30:35.533
COALITION. WE ARE IN SUPPORT.
00:30:35.600 --> 00:30:38.369
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. RELYING
00:30:38.436 --> 00:30:49.214
66. PLEASE GO AHEAD. 66 YOUR
00:30:49.280 --> 00:30:55.220
LINE IS OPEN. MY NAME IS GLORIA
00:30:55.286 --> 00:30:57.121
ISLAND AND REPRESENTING MOVE L.
00:30:57.188 --> 00:30:58.223
A. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:30:58.289 --> 00:31:01.326
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLDING. 1919
00:31:01.392 --> 00:31:06.364
THANK YOU NEXT. LITTLE LINE. 15,
00:31:06.431 --> 00:31:12.704
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:31:12.770 --> 00:31:14.839
CHAIR. MY NAME IS SANDY AND RON
00:31:14.906 --> 00:31:16.574
KHÓ POLICY ADVOCATE WITH CLIMATE
00:31:16.641 --> 00:31:18.243
PLAN, CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT
00:31:18.309 --> 00:31:19.877
OF GIVING 1919 THANK YOU. THANK
00:31:19.944 --> 00:31:24.349
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. OR GO TO LINE
00:31:24.415 --> 00:31:31.856
NINE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. CATHERINE
00:31:31.923 --> 00:31:33.758
AND MY NAME IS MATTHEW BAKER,
00:31:33.825 --> 00:31:34.792
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR PLANNING
00:31:34.859 --> 00:31:35.827
CONSERVATION THAT YOU CAN STRONG
00:31:35.893 --> 00:31:41.432
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
00:31:41.499 --> 00:31:46.437
LINE 67, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:31:46.504 --> 00:31:49.240
AFTERNOON. THIS IS NOT A CRICK
00:31:49.307 --> 00:31:50.375
IN CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE
00:31:50.441 --> 00:31:51.142
COMMUNITY COLLEGE LEAGUE OF
00:31:51.209 --> 00:31:52.577
CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT.
00:31:52.644 --> 00:31:54.312
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT,
00:31:54.379 --> 00:31:57.749
PLEASE. AND WE'LL GO TO LINE 70.
00:31:57.815 --> 00:32:02.453
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:32:02.520 --> 00:32:04.489
WEST RUDERMAN WITH ACTIVE SAN
00:32:04.555 --> 00:32:05.490
GABRIEL VALLEY, CALLING STRONG
00:32:05.556 --> 00:32:10.862
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
00:32:10.928 --> 00:32:11.996
AND THERE ARE CURRENTLY NO ONE
00:32:12.063 --> 00:32:14.732
ELSE IN QUÊ. VERY GOOD. LET'S
00:32:14.799 --> 00:32:15.767
RETURN TO THE COMMITTEE
00:32:15.833 --> 00:32:18.469
HEARINGS. WE HAVE NO PRIMARY
00:32:18.536 --> 00:32:20.171
WITNESS IN OPPOSITION TO ANYBODY
00:32:20.238 --> 00:32:21.973
IN THE CHAMBER LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:32:22.040 --> 00:32:24.275
IN OPPOSITION TO THE MEASURE.
00:32:24.342 --> 00:32:25.410
SEEING NONE. MR. MODERATOR IF
00:32:25.476 --> 00:32:26.844
YOU COULD PLEASE QUERY THE
00:32:26.911 --> 00:32:27.979
TELECONFERENCE, AND IF THERE'S
00:32:28.046 --> 00:32:29.480
ANYBODY IN OPPOSITION TO A B
00:32:29.547 --> 00:32:35.320
1919. IF THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION
00:32:35.386 --> 00:32:45.196
, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND THEY'RE
00:32:45.263 --> 00:32:47.332
CURRENTLY NONE OF THE Q. VERY
00:32:47.398 --> 00:32:48.099
GOOD. LET'S COME BACK TO THE
00:32:48.166 --> 00:32:49.167
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM, UH,
00:32:49.233 --> 00:32:50.201
MEMBERS ANY QUESTIONS OR
00:32:50.268 --> 00:32:52.537
COMMENTS ON THE BILL? SENATOR
00:32:52.603 --> 00:32:56.574
MEN THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. I JUST
00:32:56.641 --> 00:32:57.909
WANT TO APPLAUD THE AUTHOR FOR
00:32:57.975 --> 00:32:59.677
THIS BILL. I REMEMBER TAKING THE
00:32:59.744 --> 00:33:01.346
BUS AS A KID. AND I THINK, JUST
00:33:01.412 --> 00:33:03.014
OPENING THIS UP TO YOUNG PEOPLE
00:33:03.081 --> 00:33:04.515
OPENING UP OUR PUBLIC TRANSIT,
00:33:04.582 --> 00:33:05.983
YOUNG PEOPLE SUCH A IMPORTANT
00:33:06.050 --> 00:33:07.852
AND LAUDABLE GOAL. WE SPEND SO
00:33:07.919 --> 00:33:10.688
MUCH IN SUBSIDIES. ON PRIVATE
00:33:10.755 --> 00:33:12.156
TRANSPORT ON SINGLE PASSENGER
00:33:12.223 --> 00:33:14.158
CARS, OR, UM, OR MULTI PASSENGER
00:33:14.225 --> 00:33:16.494
CARS. JUST THINK THIS IS GREAT,
00:33:16.561 --> 00:33:17.228
AND IT WOULD RESPECT
00:33:17.295 --> 00:33:18.730
RESPECTFULLY LOVE TO BE A CO
00:33:18.796 --> 00:33:19.731
AUTHOR AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME
00:33:19.797 --> 00:33:20.898
AND WOULD MOVE THE BILL WHEN
00:33:20.965 --> 00:33:22.700
APPROPRIATE. APPRECIATE THAT.
00:33:22.767 --> 00:33:24.836
AND WE ALSO KNOW FROM MY PART.
00:33:24.902 --> 00:33:26.938
MR HOLDEN COMMEND YOU ON THE
00:33:27.004 --> 00:33:30.108
BILL WITH SIMILAR BILL SB 9 42,
00:33:30.174 --> 00:33:31.943
WHICH WOULD ALLOW FOR THE USE OF
00:33:32.009 --> 00:33:33.044
LOW CARBON TRANSFER OPERATION
00:33:33.111 --> 00:33:34.178
PROGRAM FUNDS FOR A SIMILAR
00:33:34.245 --> 00:33:37.582
PURPOSE. GLAD TO SUPPORT IT. UH
00:33:37.648 --> 00:33:39.317
THE CHAIR HAS A DO PASS THROUGH
00:33:39.384 --> 00:33:41.152
APPROACH RECOMMENDATION, AND WE
00:33:41.219 --> 00:33:43.054
WILL VOTE ON IT WHEN WE HAVE A
00:33:43.121 --> 00:33:44.922
QUORUM. IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE,
00:33:44.989 --> 00:33:46.057
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, MR
00:33:46.124 --> 00:33:47.892
CHAIR AND FIRST SENATOR MAN, I
00:33:47.959 --> 00:33:50.628
WOULD LOVE TO HAVE YOU AS A AS A
00:33:50.695 --> 00:33:52.997
CO AUTHOR. I WOULD ALSO JUST SAY
00:33:53.064 --> 00:33:56.567
THAT THIS IS CERTAINLY BEEN A
00:33:56.634 --> 00:34:00.905
TOUGH HAUL. UH NEVER LET IT BE
00:34:00.972 --> 00:34:03.274
SAID THAT I TAKE NO FOR AN
00:34:03.341 --> 00:34:04.776
ANSWER. SINCE I WAS LOOKING AT
00:34:04.842 --> 00:34:07.245
THE ANALYSIS AND UNDER RELATED
00:34:07.311 --> 00:34:08.312
LEGISLATION, I'VE INTRODUCED
00:34:08.379 --> 00:34:11.949
TRANSIT FREE. REDUCED FARE
00:34:12.016 --> 00:34:14.185
TRANSIT PASS FROM 2016 EVERY
00:34:14.252 --> 00:34:18.790
YEAR ALL THE WAY TO 2020. SO I'M
00:34:18.856 --> 00:34:19.991
GLAD THAT AND THEN THEY'VE
00:34:20.057 --> 00:34:23.628
EITHER. NOT GOT OUT OF A
00:34:23.694 --> 00:34:24.162
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
00:34:24.228 --> 00:34:27.665
COMMITTEE. IN THE ASSEMBLY. THE
00:34:27.732 --> 00:34:29.000
SENATE ONE GOT TO THE GOVERNOR'S
00:34:29.067 --> 00:34:30.835
DESK AND HE VETOED IT, SO WE'RE
00:34:30.902 --> 00:34:34.238
VERY HOPEFUL. THAT THIS YEAR IN
00:34:34.305 --> 00:34:36.140
2022 THAT WILL SEE THIS BILL
00:34:36.207 --> 00:34:39.243
MAKE IT ALL THE WAY BECAUSE
00:34:39.310 --> 00:34:41.078
THAT'S THE POINT WAS MADE. IT'S
00:34:41.145 --> 00:34:42.146
TO BENEFIT THE YOUNG PEOPLE AND
00:34:42.213 --> 00:34:43.448
TURN THEM INTO PUBLIC
00:34:43.514 --> 00:34:45.316
TRANSPORTATION PARTICIPANTS AS
00:34:45.383 --> 00:34:46.384
THEY GO FORWARD, AND I
00:34:46.451 --> 00:34:48.352
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
00:34:48.419 --> 00:34:50.388
THANK YOU AND APPRECIATE YOUR
00:34:50.455 --> 00:34:51.155
PERSISTENCE. I APPRECIATE THE
00:34:51.222 --> 00:34:53.057
BILL. AND SINCE YOU'RE ON A ROLL
00:34:53.124 --> 00:34:54.892
HAVE ABOUT DOING ANOTHER, BUT I
00:34:54.959 --> 00:34:57.328
SEE YOU HAVE A THIRD BALLET B 27
00:34:57.395 --> 00:34:59.697
73, PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU.
00:34:59.764 --> 00:35:01.232
TODAY I'M PRESENTING ASSEMBLY
00:35:01.299 --> 00:35:03.801
BILL 27 73 A BILL THAT WOULD
00:35:03.868 --> 00:35:04.902
REQUIRE A PEACE OFFICER MAKING A
00:35:04.969 --> 00:35:07.038
TRAFFIC OR PEDESTRIAN STOP TO
00:35:07.104 --> 00:35:08.739
STATE THE REASON FOR THE STOP
00:35:08.806 --> 00:35:09.907
BEFORE ENGAGING IN QUESTIONING
00:35:09.974 --> 00:35:12.710
RELATED TO A CRIME INVESTIGATION
00:35:12.777 --> 00:35:14.812
OR TRAFFIC VIOLATION UNLESS THE
00:35:14.879 --> 00:35:16.948
OFFICER REASONABLY BELIEVES THAT
00:35:17.014 --> 00:35:18.749
WITHHOLDING THE REASON FOR THE
00:35:18.816 --> 00:35:20.818
STOP IS NECESSARY TO PROTECT
00:35:20.885 --> 00:35:21.953
LIFE OR PROPERTY FROM IMMINENT.
00:35:22.019 --> 00:35:25.022
THREAT. FOR NEARLY A YEAR. MY
00:35:25.089 --> 00:35:26.023
OFFICE HAS WORKED WITH LAW
00:35:26.090 --> 00:35:27.625
ENFORCEMENT POSTS, VARIOUS
00:35:27.692 --> 00:35:29.060
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS TO PUT
00:35:29.126 --> 00:35:30.161
FORWARD THOUGHTFUL LEGISLATION
00:35:30.228 --> 00:35:31.929
SURROUNDING TRAFFIC AND
00:35:31.996 --> 00:35:33.998
PEDESTRIAN STOPS. OVER THE PAST
00:35:34.065 --> 00:35:35.466
YEAR. THERE HAVE BEEN NUMEROUS
00:35:35.533 --> 00:35:36.968
IN DEPTH REPORTS SURROUNDING
00:35:37.034 --> 00:35:38.169
TRAFFIC STOPS TO INCLUDE
00:35:38.236 --> 00:35:39.237
INVESTIGATIONS FROM THE NEW YORK
00:35:39.303 --> 00:35:41.172
TIMES THE TIMES. AND REPORT FROM
00:35:41.239 --> 00:35:44.742
THE PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE. THE
00:35:44.809 --> 00:35:45.943
COMMON THEME SURROUNDING THESE
00:35:46.010 --> 00:35:48.079
REPORTS, IS THAT PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:35:48.145 --> 00:35:49.780
MORE SO FOR AFRICAN AMERICANS
00:35:49.847 --> 00:35:51.782
ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE STOPPED,
00:35:51.849 --> 00:35:53.651
THEN WHITE INDIVIDUALS. WHAT IS
00:35:53.718 --> 00:35:54.785
MORE TROUBLING IS THAT,
00:35:54.852 --> 00:35:55.953
ACCORDING TO THE PUBLIC POLICY
00:35:56.020 --> 00:35:58.222
INSTITUTE, STOPS OF AFRICAN
00:35:58.289 --> 00:36:00.091
AMERICANS ARE THREE TIMES MORE
00:36:00.157 --> 00:36:02.126
LIKELY TO INVOLVE A WEAPON, THEN
00:36:02.193 --> 00:36:04.929
STOPS OF WHITE INDIVIDUALS. A B
00:36:04.996 --> 00:36:08.299
27 73 REQUIRES EACH STATE AND
00:36:08.366 --> 00:36:10.601
LOCAL AGENCY THAT EMPLOYS PEACE
00:36:10.668 --> 00:36:12.003
OFFICERS TO INCLUDE IN ITS
00:36:12.069 --> 00:36:13.404
ANNUAL REPORT TO THE ATTORNEY
00:36:13.471 --> 00:36:15.673
GENERAL. THE REASONS GIVEN TO
00:36:15.740 --> 00:36:16.841
THE PERSON STOPPED AT THE TIME
00:36:16.908 --> 00:36:18.910
OF THE START. IN TERMS OF
00:36:18.976 --> 00:36:20.444
EDUCATING THE PUBLIC. THIS BILL
00:36:20.511 --> 00:36:22.380
REQUIRES THE DMV TO INCLUDE
00:36:22.446 --> 00:36:23.648
INFORMATION REGARDING THE DUTY
00:36:23.714 --> 00:36:25.249
OF A PEACE OFFICER TO STATE THE
00:36:25.316 --> 00:36:27.652
REASON FOR THE STOP AND THE D. M
00:36:27.718 --> 00:36:28.819
V HANDBOOK AT THE EARLIEST
00:36:28.886 --> 00:36:32.056
OPPORTUNITY. AS YOU MAY RECALL,
00:36:32.123 --> 00:36:35.226
THE LEGISLATURE APPROVED AND
00:36:35.293 --> 00:36:42.366
GOVERNOR-BROWN-SIGNS-MOORLACH-DATE-SEPARATION-BILL. GUARDING A PERSON CIVIL RIGHTS
00:36:42.433 --> 00:36:44.969
DURING THE STOP INCLUDING THE
00:36:45.036 --> 00:36:46.070
RIGHT TO FILE A COMPLAINT
00:36:46.137 --> 00:36:48.205
AGAINST A PEACE OFFICER. AND
00:36:48.272 --> 00:36:50.841
CLOSING. AS I HAVE MENTIONED
00:36:50.908 --> 00:36:51.909
BEFORE. I BELIEVE THAT THE
00:36:51.976 --> 00:36:52.810
CONFRONTATION BETWEEN LAW
00:36:52.877 --> 00:36:54.011
ENFORCEMENT AND THE PUBLIC
00:36:54.078 --> 00:36:55.346
BEGINS BECAUSE PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:36:55.413 --> 00:36:56.981
ARE BEING ASKED TO SURRENDER
00:36:57.048 --> 00:36:58.149
THEIR CIVIL RIGHTS AND THEY
00:36:58.215 --> 00:37:00.451
DON'T KNOW WHY THEY ARE BEING
00:37:00.518 --> 00:37:01.752
STOPPED, BUT THEY ARE FORCED TO
00:37:01.819 --> 00:37:03.921
COMPLY. SURELY THIS BODY CAN
00:37:03.988 --> 00:37:05.356
FIND A SOLUTION TO THIS DILEMMA
00:37:05.423 --> 00:37:07.325
. THIS BILL IS A STEP IN THE
00:37:07.391 --> 00:37:08.459
RIGHT DIRECTION. I RESPECTFULLY
00:37:08.526 --> 00:37:10.895
ASK FOR RIFLE. THANK YOU AND LET
00:37:10.962 --> 00:37:12.063
US PROCEED. WITNESSES IN
00:37:12.129 --> 00:37:16.400
SUPPORT. I SEE YOU HAVE GEORGE
00:37:16.467 --> 00:37:18.703
PARENT PARENT PART TWO FROM THE
00:37:18.769 --> 00:37:20.705
ISSUE OF CALIFORNIA ON THE CO
00:37:20.771 --> 00:37:21.906
HOST LINE, MR PARENT PATO. IF
00:37:21.973 --> 00:37:25.876
YOU COULD PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
00:37:25.943 --> 00:37:27.345
AFTERNOON, SIR AND MEMBERS.
00:37:27.411 --> 00:37:28.946
GEORGE GRANDPA DO LEGISLATIVE
00:37:29.013 --> 00:37:30.247
INTERN WITH DETAIL YOU
00:37:30.314 --> 00:37:31.983
CALIFORNIA ACTION IN SUPPORT OF
00:37:32.049 --> 00:37:36.454
ASSEMBLY BILL 27 73. JANUARY
00:37:36.520 --> 00:37:38.089
2022 THE RACIAL AND IDENTITY
00:37:38.155 --> 00:37:40.257
PROFILING ADVISORY BORN RELEASED
00:37:40.324 --> 00:37:41.158
A REPORT ANALYZING STOP DATA
00:37:41.225 --> 00:37:45.696
FROM 18 LAUNCH. SORRY MR MR
00:37:45.763 --> 00:37:47.098
PEREMPTORY, HAVING TROUBLE
00:37:47.164 --> 00:37:48.899
HEARING YOU IF YOU COULD SPEAK
00:37:48.966 --> 00:37:50.735
IT ALOUD OR CLOSER TO YOUR
00:37:50.801 --> 00:37:55.439
MICROPHONE. UM. IN 2020, THE
00:37:55.506 --> 00:37:56.574
AGENCY'S MADE OVER 2.9 BILLION
00:37:56.641 --> 00:38:00.711
STUFF. TO APPOINT FOUND THAT
00:38:00.778 --> 00:38:02.146
BLACK PEOPLE WERE STOPPED FOR
00:38:02.213 --> 00:38:03.214
REASONABLE SUSPICION MORE THAN
00:38:03.280 --> 00:38:05.750
ANY OTHER RACIAL IDENTITY GROUP.
00:38:05.816 --> 00:38:07.118
OFFICERS SEARCHED, DETAINED,
00:38:07.184 --> 00:38:07.985
HANDCUFFED AND REMOVED FROM
00:38:08.052 --> 00:38:11.155
VEHICLES. FOR INDIVIDUALS. THEY
00:38:11.222 --> 00:38:12.356
PROCEED AS BLACK AND INDIVIDUALS
00:38:12.423 --> 00:38:15.726
PERCEIVED AS WHITE. BLACK AND
00:38:15.793 --> 00:38:17.395
LATINO INDIVIDUALS ARE MORE
00:38:17.461 --> 00:38:19.096
LIKELY TO ASK FORCE USED AGAINST
00:38:19.163 --> 00:38:19.997
THEM AS COMPARED TO WHITE
00:38:20.064 --> 00:38:21.065
INDIVIDUALS. THESE FINDINGS ARE
00:38:21.132 --> 00:38:23.934
TROUBLING. BUT UNFORTUNATELY
00:38:24.001 --> 00:38:25.403
THEY ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE
00:38:25.469 --> 00:38:27.605
BOARDS HIGHER REPORT AS WELL AS
00:38:27.672 --> 00:38:29.040
REPORTS FROM THE STANFORD OPEN
00:38:29.106 --> 00:38:31.242
POLICING PROJECT. THE NEW YORK
00:38:31.308 --> 00:38:32.343
TIMES THE SAN DIEGO UNION
00:38:32.410 --> 00:38:35.579
TRIBUNE. AND STUDY AFTER STUDY.
00:38:35.646 --> 00:38:37.581
IN THOSE CASES, THESE
00:38:37.648 --> 00:38:38.115
CONFRONTATIONS BETWEEN LAW
00:38:38.182 --> 00:38:39.583
ENFORCEMENT AND PEOPLE OF COLOR.
00:38:39.650 --> 00:38:43.254
BEGAN WHEN PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:38:43.320 --> 00:38:44.722
DENIED THE PRIVILEGE OF KNOWING
00:38:44.789 --> 00:38:45.890
WHY THEY WERE PULLED OVER OR
00:38:45.956 --> 00:38:48.292
STOPPED IN THE FIRST PLACE.
00:38:48.359 --> 00:38:50.895
WITHOUT KNOWING WHY THEY WERE
00:38:50.961 --> 00:38:51.962
STOPPED. PEOPLE ARE COLOR PEOPLE
00:38:52.029 --> 00:38:53.230
OF COLOR ARE DEMANDED TO COMPLY
00:38:53.297 --> 00:38:54.465
WITH THE SITUATION CAN QUICKLY
00:38:54.532 --> 00:38:57.435
ESCALATE. SEND YOUR BLAND,
00:38:57.501 --> 00:39:00.571
GLENDA CASTILLO, WALTER SCOTT.
00:39:00.638 --> 00:39:01.672
DANTE RIGHT, RASHARD WERE ALL
00:39:01.739 --> 00:39:05.710
BLACK. AND POLICE KILLED HER.
00:39:05.776 --> 00:39:07.244
CHERIE. ORDINARY TRAFFIC STOPS
00:39:07.311 --> 00:39:08.112
FOR VIOLATIONS THAT DID NOT
00:39:08.179 --> 00:39:12.416
THREATEN PUBLIC SAFETY. IT IS NO
00:39:12.483 --> 00:39:12.950
WONDER THAT PEOPLE CAN BE
00:39:13.017 --> 00:39:14.819
NERVOUS WHEN BEING STOPPED BY AN
00:39:14.885 --> 00:39:16.787
OFFICER WHO CAN DEPRIVE THEM OF
00:39:16.854 --> 00:39:19.056
LIFE AND LIBERTY. REQUIRING
00:39:19.123 --> 00:39:20.958
POLICE OFFICERS TO STATE THE
00:39:21.025 --> 00:39:22.159
REASON FOR TRAFFIC OR PEDESTRIAN
00:39:22.226 --> 00:39:24.295
STOCK. AT THE TIME OF THE STOP
00:39:24.361 --> 00:39:25.563
AND BEFORE ASKING ANY QUESTIONS.
00:39:25.629 --> 00:39:28.833
CAN LITERALLY SAVE LIVES. THIS
00:39:28.899 --> 00:39:30.768
BILL IS A COMMON SENSE MEASURE
00:39:30.835 --> 00:39:32.837
AND ONE THAT IS LONG OVERDUE.
00:39:32.903 --> 00:39:34.739
RESPECTFULLY THAT YOU TO SUPPORT
00:39:34.805 --> 00:39:35.539
MAYBE 27 73. THANK YOU. THANK
00:39:35.606 --> 00:39:41.078
YOU. IS ANYBODY ELSE HERE IN THE
00:39:41.145 --> 00:39:43.080
CHAMBER WOULD LIKE TEST FIND
00:39:43.147 --> 00:39:45.716
SUPPORT OF 27 73 POLICE PURSUIT.
00:39:45.783 --> 00:39:46.784
CHAIR AND MEMBERS, CHRISTOPHER
00:39:46.851 --> 00:39:48.152
SANDINO FROM THE CALIFORNIA
00:39:48.219 --> 00:39:49.954
HAWAII AND KEEP HERE IN PROUD
00:39:50.020 --> 00:39:52.256
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE
00:39:52.323 --> 00:39:55.092
WISH TESTIFY IN PERSON? IN
00:39:55.159 --> 00:39:57.027
SUPPORTING NONE. LET'S GO TO THE
00:39:57.094 --> 00:39:58.729
TELECONFERENCE ON MR MODERATOR.
00:39:58.796 --> 00:39:59.764
IF THERE'S ANYBODY WHO LIKE
00:39:59.830 --> 00:40:01.665
TESTIFYING ON THE LINE INTO WHAT
00:40:01.732 --> 00:40:05.002
MAYBE 27 73. OF COURSE, LADIES
00:40:05.069 --> 00:40:06.303
AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU ANYONE IN
00:40:06.370 --> 00:40:16.747
SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS 10.
00:40:16.814 --> 00:40:17.915
THEY'RE CURRENTLY NONE OF THE
00:40:17.982 --> 00:40:20.384
CUE. THANK YOU BACK TO THE
00:40:20.451 --> 00:40:21.519
CHAMBER HERE. IS THERE ANYBODY
00:40:21.585 --> 00:40:23.420
HERE WHO'D LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:40:23.487 --> 00:40:24.488
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL? I'LL BE
00:40:24.555 --> 00:40:26.390
27 73. SAYING NONE. MR MODERATOR
00:40:26.457 --> 00:40:27.992
BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE
00:40:28.058 --> 00:40:28.959
. IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE LINE
00:40:29.026 --> 00:40:30.828
LIKE TEST RIGHT OPPOSITION? 27
00:40:30.895 --> 00:40:34.532
73. OF COURSE. IF THERE WAS
00:40:34.598 --> 00:40:35.566
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION, PLEASE
00:40:35.633 --> 00:40:45.242
PRESS 10. AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY
00:40:45.309 --> 00:40:49.046
NONE QUEUING UP. GRAVERT THANK
00:40:49.113 --> 00:40:50.714
YOU. LET'S COME BACK TO THE
00:40:50.781 --> 00:40:51.348
CHAMBER. ANY MEMBERS COMMITTEE
00:40:51.415 --> 00:40:52.883
WITH QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON
00:40:52.950 --> 00:40:56.654
THE BILL? KING. NONE MR. HOLDEN.
00:40:56.720 --> 00:40:58.689
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? THANK
00:40:58.756 --> 00:41:00.257
YOU. I RESPECT ME. LAST YEAR I
00:41:00.324 --> 00:41:01.759
VOTE WHEN YOU HAVE YOUR CORE.
00:41:01.826 --> 00:41:03.327
THANK YOU THAT THAT DOES HAVE A
00:41:03.394 --> 00:41:04.762
RECOMMENDATION FROM THE CHAIR OF
00:41:04.829 --> 00:41:06.263
DO PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
00:41:06.330 --> 00:41:07.097
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WILL
00:41:07.164 --> 00:41:08.866
TAKE THAT UP AT THE APPROPRIATE
00:41:08.933 --> 00:41:10.034
TIME. THANK YOU. AND THANK YOU
00:41:10.100 --> 00:41:13.070
FOR YOUR PATIENCE. LET ME NOTE
00:41:13.137 --> 00:41:14.738
BEFORE WE GET TO OUR NEXT ITEM
00:41:14.805 --> 00:41:16.273
THAT IF YOU'RE ON THE LINE,
00:41:16.340 --> 00:41:19.076
WAITING TO TESTIFY ON ITEM 14
00:41:19.143 --> 00:41:21.879
2039 HAS BEEN PULLED BY THE
00:41:21.946 --> 00:41:22.780
AUTHOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:41:22.847 --> 00:41:25.716
THREE OF US AGAIN. THAT'S 2039
00:41:25.783 --> 00:41:28.152
HAS BEEN PULLED NEXT UP. I
00:41:28.219 --> 00:41:29.420
BELIEVE WE HAVE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:41:29.486 --> 00:41:32.690
BOERNER HORVATH. WELCOME YOU'LL
00:41:32.756 --> 00:41:41.332
BE PRESENTING A B 17 13. YES
00:41:41.398 --> 00:41:43.167
THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS.
00:41:43.234 --> 00:41:44.702
A B 17 13 WOULD MAKE
00:41:44.768 --> 00:41:45.402
INTERSECTIONS SAFER FOR
00:41:45.469 --> 00:41:46.837
BICYCLISTS, DRIVERS AND
00:41:46.904 --> 00:41:48.072
PEDESTRIANS BY ALLOWING
00:41:48.138 --> 00:41:49.139
BICYCLISTS TO TREAT STOP
00:41:49.206 --> 00:41:51.342
SCIENCES YIELD SIGNS. NGUYEN
00:41:51.408 --> 00:41:53.444
APPROACHING THE INTERSECTION
00:41:53.510 --> 00:41:54.044
SPECIFICALLY, YOU'LL REMEMBER
00:41:54.111 --> 00:41:57.047
THIS BILL AS A B 1 22. LAST YEAR
00:41:57.114 --> 00:41:58.749
, WE MADE SOME MODIFICATIONS AND
00:41:58.816 --> 00:41:59.917
SO SPECIFICALLY, 17 13 WILL
00:41:59.984 --> 00:42:01.752
ALLOW INDIVIDUALS, 18 YEARS AND
00:42:01.819 --> 00:42:03.854
OLDER. TO YIELD WHEN APPROACHING
00:42:03.921 --> 00:42:04.922
THE STOP SIGN IN AN
00:42:04.989 --> 00:42:07.858
INTERSECTION. MAKE IT A SIX YEAR
00:42:07.925 --> 00:42:09.660
PILOT INSTEAD OF A THREE YEAR
00:42:09.727 --> 00:42:10.427
PILOT HAS INTRODUCED AND THAT'S
00:42:10.494 --> 00:42:11.896
REALLY BECAUSE CHP REALLY NEEDS
00:42:11.962 --> 00:42:13.931
ENOUGH DATA TO EVALUATE THE
00:42:13.998 --> 00:42:15.933
PROGRAM TO SEE IF IT SHOULD
00:42:16.000 --> 00:42:16.967
CONTINUE LIMIT THE STOPPERS
00:42:17.034 --> 00:42:19.169
YIELD TO TWO LANE ROADS AT
00:42:19.236 --> 00:42:20.804
COMPLETELY STOP SIGN CONTROLLED
00:42:20.871 --> 00:42:22.473
INTERSECTIONS AND ADD THAT
00:42:22.539 --> 00:42:23.908
MINERS WHO FAILED TO STOP AT A
00:42:23.974 --> 00:42:25.709
STOP SIGN WILL GET A WARNING
00:42:25.776 --> 00:42:27.845
TICKET IN THE FIRST OFFENSE.
00:42:27.912 --> 00:42:30.080
VEHICLE CODE. 21 804 ALREADY
00:42:30.147 --> 00:42:31.582
PROVIDES A CLEAR LEGAL
00:42:31.649 --> 00:42:33.951
DEFINITION AND EXPECTATION FOR
00:42:34.018 --> 00:42:35.286
THOSE REQUIRED TO YIELD AT
00:42:35.352 --> 00:42:36.153
INTERSECTIONS UNDER THIS CODE
00:42:36.220 --> 00:42:37.922
SECTION, THE DRIVER OF ANY
00:42:37.988 --> 00:42:40.991
VEHICLE INCLUDING BIKES
00:42:41.058 --> 00:42:42.226
APPROACHING AN INTERSECTION WITH
00:42:42.293 --> 00:42:43.861
THE YIELD SIGN MUST YIELD TO THE
00:42:43.928 --> 00:42:45.729
RIGHT OF WAY OF ANY VEHICLES AND
00:42:45.796 --> 00:42:46.630
PEDESTRIANS THAT HAVE ALREADY
00:42:46.697 --> 00:42:48.299
ENTERED THE INTERSECTION. 80 TO
00:42:48.365 --> 00:42:49.566
17 13 YEARS IS THIS COMMON
00:42:49.633 --> 00:42:51.635
UNDERSTANDING OF THE YIELD SIGN?
00:42:51.702 --> 00:42:53.270
TO ALLOW BICYCLISTS APPROACHING
00:42:53.337 --> 00:42:54.238
THE INTERSECTION WITH A STOP
00:42:54.305 --> 00:42:58.075
SIGN TO SLOW DOWN. LOOK AND
00:42:58.142 --> 00:42:59.376
YIELD TO ANY CARS OF PRODUCTION
00:42:59.443 --> 00:43:00.244
PEDESTRIANS ALREADY IN THE
00:43:00.311 --> 00:43:02.379
INTERSECTION. IF IT IS SAFE TO
00:43:02.446 --> 00:43:04.481
DO SO, THE BICYCLES AND THEN
00:43:04.548 --> 00:43:05.115
PROCEED THROUGH THE INTERSECTION
00:43:05.182 --> 00:43:07.251
WITHOUT MAKING A FULL AND
00:43:07.318 --> 00:43:08.752
COMPLETE STOP. I WANT TO BE
00:43:08.819 --> 00:43:11.221
CLEAR THAT A B 17 13 IS NOT A
00:43:11.288 --> 00:43:12.089
BILL TO AUTHORIZE THE BICYCLES
00:43:12.156 --> 00:43:13.891
TO DO A ROLLING STOP, BLOW
00:43:13.958 --> 00:43:14.959
THROUGH A STOP SIGN OR DO
00:43:15.025 --> 00:43:17.227
ANYTHING ELSE. THOSE ARE ILLEGAL
00:43:17.294 --> 00:43:18.796
NOW AND THEY WILL BE ILLEGAL IF
00:43:18.862 --> 00:43:20.798
17 13 IS SIGNED BY THE GOVERNOR
00:43:20.864 --> 00:43:23.434
AND MADE INTO LAW. THE GOAL OF A
00:43:23.500 --> 00:43:24.902
B 17 13 IS TO MAKE BICYCLES
00:43:24.969 --> 00:43:27.738
BEHAVIOR PREDICTABLE FOR DRIVERS
00:43:27.805 --> 00:43:29.239
WHEN THEY APPROACH IT.
00:43:29.306 --> 00:43:30.107
INTERSECTION ALL ROSE TO THE
00:43:30.174 --> 00:43:32.376
MEAT NEED TO BE SAFE FOR ALL
00:43:32.443 --> 00:43:33.877
ROAD USERS. I DO WANT TO MENTION
00:43:33.944 --> 00:43:35.346
THE ADMINISTRATION, CALISTA IS
00:43:35.412 --> 00:43:37.047
PROPOSING AMENDMENTS TO LIMIT
00:43:37.114 --> 00:43:38.949
THE PILOT THIS TO A PILOT
00:43:39.016 --> 00:43:40.317
REGIONAL PILOT PROGRAM. I'M
00:43:40.384 --> 00:43:41.752
MEETING WITH THEM THIS WEEK,
00:43:41.819 --> 00:43:43.354
ACTUALLY, AFTER I PRESENT THIS
00:43:43.420 --> 00:43:45.255
BILL, AND WE'LL BE SURE TO SHARE
00:43:45.322 --> 00:43:46.924
ANY AGREED UPON AMENDMENTS WITH
00:43:46.991 --> 00:43:47.992
THE CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE
00:43:48.058 --> 00:43:49.893
MEMBERS AND YOUR STAFF. I
00:43:49.960 --> 00:43:51.729
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE AND
00:43:51.795 --> 00:43:53.063
WITH ME ON THE LINE. HAVE ALLAN
00:43:53.130 --> 00:43:55.299
WACHTEL, LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR OF
00:43:55.366 --> 00:43:56.333
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:43:56.400 --> 00:43:58.569
BICYCLE ORGANIZATIONS. THANK
00:43:58.635 --> 00:44:00.938
YOU, MR WALKER. PLEASE PURSUIT.
00:44:01.005 --> 00:44:05.809
THANK YOU. MR CHAIR MEMBERS OF
00:44:05.876 --> 00:44:08.078
THE COMMITTEE. I'M A LEGISLATIVE
00:44:08.145 --> 00:44:09.146
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:44:09.213 --> 00:44:10.080
ASSOCIATION OF BICYCLE
00:44:10.147 --> 00:44:13.283
ORGANIZATIONS. AND I'VE BEEN A
00:44:13.350 --> 00:44:14.351
TRANSPORTATION CONSULTANT FOR
00:44:14.418 --> 00:44:17.488
MORE THAN 20 YEARS. AND A HALF
00:44:17.554 --> 00:44:19.590
OF OUR BOARD AND OUR MEMBERS AND
00:44:19.656 --> 00:44:20.557
PROVIDING THIS COMMENT IN
00:44:20.624 --> 00:44:24.828
SUPPORT OF A B 17. THIS CHANGE
00:44:24.895 --> 00:44:25.929
TO THE CALIFORNIA VEHICLE CODE
00:44:25.996 --> 00:44:28.999
IS AN IMPORTANT STEP. SELF BUDDY
00:44:29.066 --> 00:44:31.235
SICKLING IN CALIFORNIA. SAFER
00:44:31.301 --> 00:44:32.569
MORE CONVENIENT AND MORE
00:44:32.636 --> 00:44:33.370
ATTRACTIVE CHOICE FOR TRAVEL.
00:44:33.437 --> 00:44:40.110
THANK THANK YOU. IS ANYBODY ELSE
00:44:40.177 --> 00:44:42.246
IN THE HEARING ROOM WAS LIKE
00:44:42.312 --> 00:44:43.380
TESTIFIED PERSON. I SEE A FEW,
00:44:43.447 --> 00:44:46.784
PLEASE PURSUIT. RIGHT STEVE
00:44:46.850 --> 00:44:48.385
WALLER COUNTY HAVE THE ALAMEDA
00:44:48.452 --> 00:44:49.253
COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
00:44:49.319 --> 00:44:53.057
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. GUSTATORY
00:44:53.123 --> 00:44:54.124
ON BEHALF OF THE TRANSPORTATION
00:44:54.191 --> 00:44:55.459
AGENCY FROM MONTEREY COUNTY AND
00:44:55.526 --> 00:44:57.795
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ANYBODY ELSE
00:44:57.861 --> 00:44:59.263
KNOW, MISS MODERATE? LET'S GO
00:44:59.329 --> 00:45:01.465
BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE
00:45:01.532 --> 00:45:02.399
FOR ANYBODY WISHING TO TESTIFY
00:45:02.466 --> 00:45:06.303
IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 13. IF
00:45:06.370 --> 00:45:07.971
THERE'S ANY IN SUPPORT, PLEASE
00:45:08.038 --> 00:45:14.144
PRESS 10. IF YOU HAVE QUEUED UP,
00:45:14.211 --> 00:45:15.279
AMONG OTHER LINE NUMBERS ARE
00:45:15.345 --> 00:45:17.948
GIVEN WELL, FIRST GO TO THE
00:45:18.015 --> 00:45:21.985
LINE. 48, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE
00:45:22.052 --> 00:45:24.321
AFTERNOON CHAIR. MY NAME IS MARK
00:45:24.388 --> 00:45:25.089
BOOK CEVICHE REPRESENTING
00:45:25.155 --> 00:45:27.424
STREETS FOR ALL AND WE'RE PROUD
00:45:27.491 --> 00:45:28.292
TO SUPPORT THIS PROVEN SAFETY,
00:45:28.358 --> 00:45:29.293
INDIFFERENT DECRIMINALIZATION
00:45:29.359 --> 00:45:30.360
MEASURE PROVEN THROUGHOUT THE
00:45:30.427 --> 00:45:31.895
COUNTRY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:45:31.962 --> 00:45:37.868
NEXT, PLEASE. WELL, NEXT TO THE
00:45:37.935 --> 00:45:41.071
LINE. 97, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR
00:45:41.138 --> 00:45:43.240
CHAIR. THIS IS ROGER DICKINSON
00:45:43.307 --> 00:45:44.074
ON BEHALF OF CIVIC WELL,
00:45:44.141 --> 00:45:45.876
FORMERLY THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
00:45:45.943 --> 00:45:48.212
COMMISSION IN SUPPORT. THANKS
00:45:48.278 --> 00:45:49.313
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. NEXT,
00:45:49.379 --> 00:45:52.816
PLEASE. WELL, NEXT GO TO LINE
00:45:52.883 --> 00:45:56.687
70. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:45:56.753 --> 00:45:57.988
AFTERNOON CHAIR WEST RUDERMAN
00:45:58.055 --> 00:45:59.323
WITH ACTIVE SAYING GABRIEL
00:45:59.389 --> 00:46:00.991
VALLEY AND STRONG SUPPORT OF ÁP
00:46:01.058 --> 00:46:06.330
17 13. THANK YOU NEXT. LINE 96.
00:46:06.396 --> 00:46:12.569
PLEASE GO AHEAD. I'VE BEEN FULLY
00:46:12.636 --> 00:46:13.370
USED ON BEHALF OF PREVENTION
00:46:13.437 --> 00:46:14.671
INSTITUTE IN STRONG SUPPORT.
00:46:14.738 --> 00:46:18.742
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT WEEK.
00:46:18.809 --> 00:46:19.843
AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY NONE OTHER
00:46:19.910 --> 00:46:23.447
THAN QUÊ. THANK YOU. LET'S COME
00:46:23.514 --> 00:46:24.915
BACK TO THE CHAMBERS. ANYBODY
00:46:24.982 --> 00:46:25.916
HERE IN THE CHAMBER IN WHICH
00:46:25.983 --> 00:46:27.718
WHICH IS TESTIFIED IN OPPOSITION
00:46:27.784 --> 00:46:31.889
TO THE BILL TO A B 17 13. SEEING
00:46:31.955 --> 00:46:32.923
NONE. MR. MODERATOR IF YOU COULD
00:46:32.990 --> 00:46:34.591
PLEASE QUERY THE LINE FOR
00:46:34.658 --> 00:46:36.393
ANYBODY WISHING TO TEST RIGHT
00:46:36.460 --> 00:46:39.096
OPPOSITION TO A B 17 13. OF
00:46:39.163 --> 00:46:40.697
COURSE, IF THERE ARE ANY IN
00:46:40.764 --> 00:46:47.404
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
00:46:47.471 --> 00:46:48.472
THEY'RE CURRENTLY DONE IN THE
00:46:48.539 --> 00:46:51.975
QUEUE. LET'S COME BACK TO THE
00:46:52.042 --> 00:46:54.011
CHAMBER MEMBERS WITH CAMERAS OF
00:46:54.077 --> 00:46:55.045
QUESTIONS WILL START WITH
00:46:55.112 --> 00:46:58.916
SENATOR WILK. THANK YOU, MR
00:46:58.982 --> 00:47:00.450
CHAIR. ACTUALLY DON'T HAVE A
00:47:00.517 --> 00:47:02.219
QUESTION. JUST HAVE A COMMENT. I
00:47:02.286 --> 00:47:03.720
WAS DISAPPOINTED THAT THIS GUY
00:47:03.787 --> 00:47:05.255
VETOED LAST YEAR. THIS IS JUST A
00:47:05.322 --> 00:47:07.524
COMMON SENSE SOLUTION. I WANT TO
00:47:07.591 --> 00:47:08.592
COMMEND THE AUTHOR FOR
00:47:08.659 --> 00:47:11.895
PERSEVERING. AND BEING AS
00:47:11.962 --> 00:47:14.364
FLEXIBLE AS YOU HAVE BEEN, AND I
00:47:14.431 --> 00:47:15.832
GUESS ONCE WE GET THE DATA, THEN
00:47:15.899 --> 00:47:17.868
WE'LL BE ABLE TO PUT PRESS IT
00:47:17.935 --> 00:47:19.002
OUT. I JUST CAN'T HELP BUT THINK
00:47:19.069 --> 00:47:21.104
THAT IF THIS LAW WERE HAD BEEN
00:47:21.171 --> 00:47:23.240
IN PLACE IN DELAWARE THAT MAYBE
00:47:23.307 --> 00:47:24.141
PRESIDENT BIDEN WOULD NOT HAVE
00:47:24.208 --> 00:47:25.976
FALLEN DOWN A COUPLE OF WEEKENDS
00:47:26.043 --> 00:47:27.711
AGO, SO I THINK THIS IS REALLY
00:47:27.778 --> 00:47:28.845
IMPORTANT MEASURE FOR THE SAFETY
00:47:28.912 --> 00:47:31.748
OF ALL. WITHOUT A KIND OF OWED.
00:47:31.815 --> 00:47:34.885
I APPRECIATE THAT, AND FROM MY
00:47:34.952 --> 00:47:36.720
PART SEEMS LIKE JUST YESTERDAY
00:47:36.787 --> 00:47:37.988
WE WERE HAVING A VERY SPIRITED
00:47:38.055 --> 00:47:39.122
DEBATE ABOUT YOUR PRECURSOR TO
00:47:39.189 --> 00:47:42.926
THIS BILL. FOR WHICH I VOTED
00:47:42.993 --> 00:47:44.194
LAST TIME PLANNING ON VOTING
00:47:44.261 --> 00:47:46.396
THIS TIME, SO THANK YOU FOR
00:47:46.463 --> 00:47:47.831
STICKING WITH IT. I WILL BE
00:47:47.898 --> 00:47:49.032
SUPPORTING THE BILL AS WELL ANY
00:47:49.099 --> 00:47:50.334
ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE
00:47:50.400 --> 00:47:53.737
COMMITTEE? SENATOR ALLEN. OUR
00:47:53.804 --> 00:47:55.472
FOREMOST BICYCLIST HAS ARRIVED,
00:47:55.539 --> 00:47:58.809
DOES NOT HAVE A COMMENT. WE'RE
00:47:58.875 --> 00:48:00.611
ON BIKES. YOU'RE GOOD. SO
00:48:00.677 --> 00:48:01.778
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IF YOU'D LIKE
00:48:01.845 --> 00:48:05.282
TO CLOSE. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:48:05.349 --> 00:48:07.651
MY VOTE. THANK YOU. AND SO THE
00:48:07.718 --> 00:48:10.587
RECOMMENDATION IS DO PASS AND
00:48:10.654 --> 00:48:11.555
REFER TO APPROPRIATIONS. WE WILL
00:48:11.622 --> 00:48:13.624
VOTE ON THAT. IF AND WHEN I
00:48:13.690 --> 00:48:15.626
SHOULD SAY WHEN WE HAVE A
00:48:15.692 --> 00:48:16.793
QUORUM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:48:16.860 --> 00:48:20.097
THANK YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:48:20.163 --> 00:48:22.199
FRIEDMAN WELCOME AND THANK YOU
00:48:22.266 --> 00:48:23.800
FOR YOUR PATIENCE. I UNDERSTAND
00:48:23.867 --> 00:48:26.036
YOU'RE GOING TO START WITH A B
00:48:26.103 --> 00:48:27.204
1938. I WOULD LIKE TO SAY,
00:48:27.271 --> 00:48:29.206
PLEASE TAKE AS MUCH TIME AND
00:48:29.273 --> 00:48:31.074
SPEAK AS SLOWLY AS YOU'D LIKE. I
00:48:31.141 --> 00:48:32.075
REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR NOT
00:48:32.142 --> 00:48:35.212
RUSHING ME. I HAVE A POWER
00:48:35.279 --> 00:48:38.048
POINT. WE HAVE NO FACILITY FOR A
00:48:38.115 --> 00:48:39.383
POWER POINT. PLEASE PROCEED.
00:48:39.449 --> 00:48:41.251
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
00:48:41.318 --> 00:48:42.352
LAST YEAR, THE LEGISLATURE
00:48:42.419 --> 00:48:44.721
PASSED A B 43 TO GIVE CITIES
00:48:44.788 --> 00:48:46.657
MORE FLEXIBILITY TO LOWER SPEED
00:48:46.723 --> 00:48:50.160
LIMITS. AND TO NOT HAVE TO BE
00:48:50.227 --> 00:48:51.962
FORCED TO RAISE THE SPEED LIMITS
00:48:52.029 --> 00:48:53.997
BASED ON THEIR SPEED SURVEYS
00:48:54.064 --> 00:48:56.266
THAT THEY DO. THIS BILL WAS
00:48:56.333 --> 00:48:57.134
LIMITED TO AREAS WITH HIGH
00:48:57.200 --> 00:48:59.102
INJURY AND FATALITY RATES AND
00:48:59.169 --> 00:49:00.203
AREAS WITH HIGH CONCENTRATIONS
00:49:00.270 --> 00:49:01.271
OF BICYCLES, PEDESTRIANS AND
00:49:01.338 --> 00:49:03.573
OTHER VULNERABLE POPULATIONS.
00:49:03.640 --> 00:49:05.075
DURING THE IMPLEMENTATION PAYS
00:49:05.142 --> 00:49:06.576
OF REWRITING THE MANUAL ON
00:49:06.643 --> 00:49:08.712
TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES. THERE
00:49:08.779 --> 00:49:10.113
WAS A DISAGREEMENT ON WHETHER A
00:49:10.180 --> 00:49:12.282
B 43 WAS MEANT TO GRANT
00:49:12.349 --> 00:49:13.116
ADDITIONAL FLEXIBILITY TO LOWER
00:49:13.183 --> 00:49:14.418
SPEED LIMITS OR TO REPLACE
00:49:14.484 --> 00:49:15.419
EXISTING PRACTICES ON SETTING
00:49:15.485 --> 00:49:17.721
SPEED LIMITS. THIS AGREEMENT LED
00:49:17.788 --> 00:49:19.056
TO A DRAFT THAT ACTUALLY MADE IT
00:49:19.122 --> 00:49:21.158
HARDER, NOT EASIER FOR CITIES TO
00:49:21.224 --> 00:49:22.993
LOWER SPEED LIMITS, AND THEY
00:49:23.060 --> 00:49:24.728
HAVE ACTUALLY REQUIRED IN SOME
00:49:24.795 --> 00:49:25.295
CASES CITIES TO RAISE SPEED
00:49:25.362 --> 00:49:28.932
LIMITS NOW. NOT TO BELABOR THE
00:49:28.999 --> 00:49:30.133
POINT, BUT OUR CITIES WERE NOT
00:49:30.200 --> 00:49:32.202
HAPPY ABOUT THIS. THEY WERE VERY
00:49:32.269 --> 00:49:33.670
MUCH LOOKING FORWARD TO HAVING
00:49:33.737 --> 00:49:34.304
THE FLEXIBILITY TO PROTECT AND
00:49:34.371 --> 00:49:35.772
PRIORITIZE PUBLIC SAFETY. THIS
00:49:35.839 --> 00:49:37.841
BILL IF BEFORE YOU TODAY
00:49:37.908 --> 00:49:39.643
CODIFIES THE EXISTING PRACTICE
00:49:39.710 --> 00:49:40.811
ON SETTING SPEED LIMITS THAT HAS
00:49:40.877 --> 00:49:42.846
EXISTED FOR DECADES. CALTRANS
00:49:42.913 --> 00:49:44.314
AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE WITHIN THE
00:49:44.381 --> 00:49:46.350
TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES CONTROL
00:49:46.416 --> 00:49:47.984
DEVICES COMMITTEE TO IMPLEMENT A
00:49:48.051 --> 00:49:49.152
B 43 AGREED WITH THIS
00:49:49.219 --> 00:49:52.789
INTERPRETATION. OF THE 43. THIS
00:49:52.856 --> 00:49:54.224
BILL CLARIFIES THE INTENT TO
00:49:54.291 --> 00:49:56.493
MAYBE 43. IT'S ACTUALLY A LOWER
00:49:56.560 --> 00:49:58.495
SPEED LIMIT CHANGE FROM THE 85TH
00:49:58.562 --> 00:49:59.429
PERCENTILE THANTHE OPPONENTS OF
00:49:59.496 --> 00:50:01.198
A B 43 ARGUED, WOULD HAVE
00:50:01.264 --> 00:50:02.366
HAPPENED WHEN WE PASSED THE BILL
00:50:02.432 --> 00:50:04.901
LAST YEAR. THIS CLARIFICATION
00:50:04.968 --> 00:50:05.869
STILL WOULD ONLY PERMIT POSTED
00:50:05.936 --> 00:50:07.804
SPEED LIMITS TO BE REDUCED BY
00:50:07.871 --> 00:50:08.972
FIVE MILES AN HOUR FROM WHAT
00:50:09.039 --> 00:50:10.974
THEY ARE SET AT TODAY. AS AN
00:50:11.041 --> 00:50:12.442
ENGINEERING AND TRAFFIC STUDY
00:50:12.509 --> 00:50:15.245
ALREADY PERMITS AT 7.4 MPH
00:50:15.312 --> 00:50:16.113
REDUCTION FROM THE 85TH
00:50:16.179 --> 00:50:17.614
PERCENTILE UNDER CERTAIN
00:50:17.681 --> 00:50:19.182
CONDITIONS. REDUCING SPEED
00:50:19.249 --> 00:50:20.951
LIMITS HAS SHOWN TO REDUCE POST
00:50:21.017 --> 00:50:22.686
INJURIES AND FATALITIES ON THE
00:50:22.753 --> 00:50:24.254
ROAD. AND A RANGE OF RESEARCH
00:50:24.321 --> 00:50:25.455
ALSO SUGGESTS SLOWING SPEED
00:50:25.522 --> 00:50:26.957
LIMIT MAY RESULT IN THE NUMBER
00:50:27.023 --> 00:50:29.626
OF FATALITIES DROPPING BY 10 TO
00:50:29.693 --> 00:50:31.128
30% WITH ONE OUTLIER STUDY
00:50:31.194 --> 00:50:32.729
SHOWING AN 80% REDUCTION IN
00:50:32.796 --> 00:50:34.364
FATALITIES WITH ME HERE TODAY IS
00:50:34.431 --> 00:50:35.799
DAN MITCHELL, THE CHIEF ENGINEER
00:50:35.866 --> 00:50:37.334
AT L. A DEPARTMENT OF
00:50:37.401 --> 00:50:38.335
TRANSPORTATION. THANK YOU, MR
00:50:38.402 --> 00:50:38.835
MITCHELL. WELCOME POLICE
00:50:38.902 --> 00:50:42.439
PURSUIT. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
00:50:42.506 --> 00:50:44.040
MEMBERS DAMAGE AGAIN CHIEF
00:50:44.107 --> 00:50:45.041
ENGINEER WITH THE CITY OF LOS
00:50:45.108 --> 00:50:46.143
ANGELES DEPARTMENT OF
00:50:46.209 --> 00:50:47.844
TRANSPORTATION AND STRONG
00:50:47.911 --> 00:50:50.881
SUPPORT OF A B 1938. NEARLY 4000
00:50:50.947 --> 00:50:52.249
CALIFORNIANS ARE KILLED IN
00:50:52.315 --> 00:50:54.484
CRASHES EVERY YEAR. THREE TIMES
00:50:54.551 --> 00:50:56.720
THAT AMOUNT OR SEVERELY INJURED
00:50:56.787 --> 00:50:57.454
. THIS DISPROPORTIONATELY
00:50:57.521 --> 00:50:58.889
AFFECTS THE MOST VULNERABLE
00:50:58.955 --> 00:51:00.991
AMONG US CHILDREN, SENIORS AND
00:51:01.057 --> 00:51:02.125
PEOPLE WALKING IN LOW INCOME
00:51:02.192 --> 00:51:05.061
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. SPEED
00:51:05.128 --> 00:51:06.630
KILLS AND ROBS COMMUNITIES OF
00:51:06.696 --> 00:51:08.565
THEIR QUALITY OF LIFE. SPEED
00:51:08.632 --> 00:51:09.699
DETERMINES THE SEVERITY OF A
00:51:09.766 --> 00:51:12.202
CRASH JUST FIVE MILES AN HOUR
00:51:12.269 --> 00:51:13.336
CAN MEAN THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
00:51:13.403 --> 00:51:15.539
LIFE AND DEATH. LAST YEAR, THE
00:51:15.605 --> 00:51:16.239
GOVERNOR SIGNED LIFESAVING
00:51:16.306 --> 00:51:18.742
LEGISLATION, MAYBE 43 THE LAW.
00:51:18.809 --> 00:51:20.444
MAYBE 43 WAS WRITTEN TO PUT AN
00:51:20.510 --> 00:51:21.845
END TO SENSELESS SPEED LIMIT
00:51:21.912 --> 00:51:23.413
INCREASES. IT CREATED REASONABLE
00:51:23.480 --> 00:51:25.649
FLEXIBILITY FOR CITIES TO SET
00:51:25.715 --> 00:51:26.850
SPEED LIMITS IN LINE WITH SAFETY
00:51:26.917 --> 00:51:29.453
GOALS. ROADWAY CONDITIONS AND
00:51:29.519 --> 00:51:31.555
THE LAW. IT PROTECTS OUR MOST
00:51:31.621 --> 00:51:33.256
VULNERABLE AND GIVE CITIES A
00:51:33.323 --> 00:51:34.791
BETTER WAY TO SET SAFE SPEED
00:51:34.858 --> 00:51:36.493
LIMITS ON OUR DEADLIEST STREETS
00:51:36.560 --> 00:51:37.661
AND WHERE MORE PEOPLE WALK AND
00:51:37.727 --> 00:51:40.163
CONGREGATE. UNFORTUNATELY SOME
00:51:40.230 --> 00:51:42.499
NOW INTERPRET MAYBE 43 TO REMOVE
00:51:42.566 --> 00:51:43.900
EXISTING AUTHORITY TO LOWER
00:51:43.967 --> 00:51:45.469
SPEED LIMITS, NEGATING THE
00:51:45.535 --> 00:51:46.403
POSITIVE EFFECTS OF THIS
00:51:46.470 --> 00:51:49.739
CRITICAL LEGISLATION. 1938
00:51:49.806 --> 00:51:51.508
ADDRESSES THAT BY CODIFYING THE
00:51:51.575 --> 00:51:52.876
CALIFORNIA MANUAL OF UNIFORM
00:51:52.943 --> 00:51:54.811
TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES AS IT
00:51:54.878 --> 00:51:57.614
READ LAST YEAR ON MARCH 31ST
00:51:57.681 --> 00:51:59.082
2021 TO ENSURE THAT CITIES
00:51:59.149 --> 00:52:01.418
MAINTAIN THE AUTHORITY THEY HAD
00:52:01.485 --> 00:52:02.652
TO LOWER SPEED LIMITS PRIOR TO
00:52:02.719 --> 00:52:05.789
THE PASSAGE OF A B 43. THANKS TO
00:52:05.856 --> 00:52:07.858
A B 43, THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES
00:52:07.924 --> 00:52:08.859
RECENTLY REDUCED SPEEDS BY FIVE
00:52:08.925 --> 00:52:11.795
MILES AN HOUR ON 177 MILES OF
00:52:11.862 --> 00:52:13.530
OUR STREETS, THE SPEED LIMIT
00:52:13.597 --> 00:52:15.699
REDUCTIONS WILL SAVE LIVES.
00:52:15.765 --> 00:52:18.335
WITHOUT A B 1938 CITIES WILL
00:52:18.401 --> 00:52:19.870
INSTEAD BE FORCED TO IMPLEMENT
00:52:19.936 --> 00:52:20.971
HIGHER SPEED LIMITS THAN MAYBE
00:52:21.037 --> 00:52:22.873
43 INTENDED. IN FACT, EVEN
00:52:22.939 --> 00:52:24.708
HIGHER THAN BEFORE THE 43 WAS
00:52:24.774 --> 00:52:27.244
PASSED IN 1938 IS A CRITICAL AND
00:52:27.310 --> 00:52:28.311
NECESSARY MEASURE TO ENSURE
00:52:28.378 --> 00:52:30.680
CITIES IN CALIFORNIA. CAN
00:52:30.747 --> 00:52:31.748
CONTINUE TO SET SAFE SPEED
00:52:31.815 --> 00:52:34.150
LIMITS IN LINE WITH THE 43. I
00:52:34.217 --> 00:52:36.119
STRONGLY URGE A YES VOTE AND I'M
00:52:36.186 --> 00:52:37.120
AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY
00:52:37.187 --> 00:52:38.755
QUESTIONS. THANK YOU, MR
00:52:38.822 --> 00:52:40.323
MITCHELL. IS ANYBODY ELSE HERE
00:52:40.390 --> 00:52:41.324
LIKE TESTIFYING? SUPPORTED THE
00:52:41.391 --> 00:52:43.827
BILL. PLEASE PURSUIT. MR CHAIR
00:52:43.894 --> 00:52:45.395
MEMBERS, JOSH SHAW FOR THE
00:52:45.462 --> 00:52:47.230
CALIFORNIA CITY TRANSPORTATION
00:52:47.297 --> 00:52:49.099
AND YESTERDAY TIVE, A COALITION
00:52:49.165 --> 00:52:51.868
OF AID OF DAN'S COLLEAGUES
00:52:51.935 --> 00:52:53.737
FELLOW CDOT DIRECTORS AT EIGHT
00:52:53.803 --> 00:52:56.406
OF THE 10 LARGEST CITY D. O. T S
00:52:56.473 --> 00:52:58.408
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL. I THINK
00:52:58.475 --> 00:52:59.876
MR SHOW ANYBODY ELSE WHICH
00:52:59.943 --> 00:53:00.977
TESTIFYING SUPPORT IN PERSON
00:53:01.044 --> 00:53:02.712
SAYING NONE. MR MODERATOR,
00:53:02.779 --> 00:53:04.047
PLEASE QUERY THE LINE FOR
00:53:04.114 --> 00:53:05.315
ANYBODY WISHING TO TESTIFY IN
00:53:05.382 --> 00:53:11.421
SUPPORT OF A B 1938. OF COURSE,
00:53:11.488 --> 00:53:12.222
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU ARE
00:53:12.289 --> 00:53:15.825
IN SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS 10.
00:53:15.892 --> 00:53:16.993
WE'LL GO AHEAD AND GO TO THE
00:53:17.060 --> 00:53:30.707
LINE 89. 98 APOLOGY. I BELIEVE
00:53:30.774 --> 00:53:32.976
YEAH, I'M THE WRONG ON THE WRONG
00:53:33.043 --> 00:53:40.183
LINE. SORRY. THANK YOU NEXT. OUR
00:53:40.250 --> 00:53:42.185
NEXT LINE WILL BE 61. PLEASE GO
00:53:42.252 --> 00:53:46.356
AHEAD. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:53:46.423 --> 00:53:48.825
, CHAIRMAN MEMBERS GREEN HERE
00:53:48.892 --> 00:53:50.460
TODAY WITH THE SAN FRANCISCO
00:53:50.527 --> 00:53:51.394
MUNICIPAL TRANSPORTATION AGENCY
00:53:51.461 --> 00:53:52.429
IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU
00:53:52.495 --> 00:53:57.867
NEXT, PLEASE. THE LINE ONE. OH,
00:53:57.934 --> 00:54:01.972
THREE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR CHAIR
00:54:02.038 --> 00:54:03.974
AND MEMBER SYLVIA SO LEAST SHAW
00:54:04.040 --> 00:54:06.276
ON BEHALF OF CITY OF LOS ANGELES
00:54:06.343 --> 00:54:07.444
MAYOR ERIC GARCETTI AND STRONG
00:54:07.510 --> 00:54:09.646
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:54:09.713 --> 00:54:12.148
NEXT, PLEASE. WHEN I SORT OF
00:54:12.215 --> 00:54:16.953
LINE 100, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HE
00:54:17.020 --> 00:54:18.054
REMEMBERS ROSS BUCKLEY ON BEHALF
00:54:18.121 --> 00:54:20.590
OF THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO AND
00:54:20.657 --> 00:54:22.392
SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT. NEXT
00:54:22.459 --> 00:54:27.263
LITTLE LINE 48, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:54:27.330 --> 00:54:28.765
WHICH IS, HE REMEMBERS MY NAME
00:54:28.832 --> 00:54:30.166
IS MARK HABITUAL, PRESENTING
00:54:30.233 --> 00:54:31.901
STREETS FOR ALL SUPPORTED A B
00:54:31.968 --> 00:54:33.803
43. WE'RE SUPPORTING A B 1919 38
00:54:33.870 --> 00:54:34.971
. THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
00:54:35.038 --> 00:54:39.009
PLEASE. NEXT TO THE LINE ONE.
00:54:39.075 --> 00:54:43.046
OH, ONE, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI.
00:54:43.113 --> 00:54:45.515
THIS IS AMY TRUMP'S UNWIN.
00:54:45.582 --> 00:54:46.483
TRANSFORM AND SUPPORT. THANK
00:54:46.549 --> 00:54:49.819
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. OR
00:54:49.886 --> 00:54:50.920
NECESSARY LINE. 99, PLEASE GO
00:54:50.987 --> 00:54:55.592
AHEAD. THANK YOU. CHAIR MEMBERS
00:54:55.659 --> 00:54:57.627
. MAX VERY ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
00:54:57.694 --> 00:54:58.261
OF LONG BEACH ALSO SUPPORT THANK
00:54:58.328 --> 00:55:01.431
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. ALL NEXT
00:55:01.498 --> 00:55:10.874
LITTLE WINE 66. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:55:10.940 --> 00:55:19.616
PLACES, SIX YEAR LINE IS OPEN.
00:55:19.683 --> 00:55:20.950
WHEN I GO TO LINE ONE. OH, FIVE.
00:55:21.017 --> 00:55:26.089
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:55:26.156 --> 00:55:28.291
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
00:55:28.358 --> 00:55:29.759
NICOLE FERRARA CALLING FROM THE
00:55:29.826 --> 00:55:30.593
CITY OF OAKLAND AND STRONG
00:55:30.660 --> 00:55:34.464
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
00:55:34.531 --> 00:55:35.665
WELL NEXT TO THE LINE. 70,
00:55:35.732 --> 00:55:40.837
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THROUGH THEM IN
00:55:40.904 --> 00:55:42.472
ON BEHALF OF ACTIVE THINK
00:55:42.539 --> 00:55:43.373
GABRIEL VALLEY AND STRONG
00:55:43.440 --> 00:55:48.578
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
00:55:48.645 --> 00:55:50.246
AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY NO OTHERS
00:55:50.313 --> 00:55:51.347
IN THE QUEUE. VERY GOOD. LET'S
00:55:51.414 --> 00:55:53.216
COME BACK TO THE HEARING ROOM.
00:55:53.283 --> 00:55:54.684
IS ANYBODY HERE IN THE HEARING
00:55:54.751 --> 00:55:56.586
ROOM WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY. AN
00:55:56.653 --> 00:55:59.889
OPPOSITION IN 1938. SEEING NONE.
00:55:59.956 --> 00:56:01.691
MR MODERATOR ON THE
00:56:01.758 --> 00:56:02.492
TELECONFERENCING IS THERE
00:56:02.559 --> 00:56:03.693
ANYBODY WOULD LIKE TESTIFY IN
00:56:03.760 --> 00:56:05.428
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL? MAYBE
00:56:05.495 --> 00:56:08.198
1938. IF THERE ARE ANY IN
00:56:08.264 --> 00:56:13.403
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10. DO
00:56:13.470 --> 00:56:14.604
YOU HAVE? SOMETHING HAS QUEUED
00:56:14.671 --> 00:56:16.372
UP ONE MOMENT? LOOKS LIKE THE
00:56:16.439 --> 00:56:22.979
ELECTRIC YOU NEVER MIND. THEY'RE
00:56:23.046 --> 00:56:24.981
CURRENTLY NONE OF THE QUÊ NOW
00:56:25.048 --> 00:56:27.183
VERY GOOD. LET'S COME BACK TO
00:56:27.250 --> 00:56:28.051
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. IS
00:56:28.118 --> 00:56:29.686
THERE ANYBODY IN THE HEARING
00:56:29.753 --> 00:56:31.688
ROOM OR ANY OF THE MEMBERS SORRY
00:56:31.755 --> 00:56:32.756
WITH QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ABOUT
00:56:32.822 --> 00:56:35.458
THE BILL. SEEING NONE. I WILL
00:56:35.525 --> 00:56:36.493
SAY FROM MY PART
00:56:36.559 --> 00:56:38.194
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN, THIS
00:56:38.261 --> 00:56:39.963
IS A GOOD BILL. I COMMEND YOU ON
00:56:40.029 --> 00:56:41.531
YOUR WORK LAST YEAR. I'M
00:56:41.598 --> 00:56:42.732
CERTAINLY HAVE SUPPORT THIS YEAR
00:56:42.799 --> 00:56:45.468
IT THERE'S A NOTE HERE. THAT
00:56:45.535 --> 00:56:47.270
THERE ARE AMENDMENTS THAT YOU
00:56:47.337 --> 00:56:48.972
ARE WILLING TO ACCEPT IF YOU
00:56:49.038 --> 00:56:50.306
EXPLICIT COMMITTED TO ACCEPTING
00:56:50.373 --> 00:56:52.475
THE AMENDMENTS. YES VERY GOOD.
00:56:52.542 --> 00:56:53.676
HAVING LAID THAT OUT. WOULD YOU
00:56:53.743 --> 00:56:55.345
LIKE TO CLOSE, PLEASE?
00:56:55.411 --> 00:56:56.346
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK
00:56:56.412 --> 00:57:01.251
YOU. THANK YOU. WE DO NOT YET
00:57:01.317 --> 00:57:03.119
HAVE A QUORUM. LET'S MOVE TO
00:57:03.186 --> 00:57:06.756
YOUR NEXT. BILL AND WHICH IS A B
00:57:06.823 --> 00:57:09.125
24 38, PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU
00:57:09.192 --> 00:57:12.162
, UM, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I
00:57:12.228 --> 00:57:14.564
BECAME TERROR OF THE ASSEMBLY
00:57:14.631 --> 00:57:15.131
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE TO
00:57:15.198 --> 00:57:16.633
PRIORITIZE TRAFFIC SAFETY, LAND
00:57:16.699 --> 00:57:18.301
USE AND ALTERNATIVE MODALITIES
00:57:18.368 --> 00:57:20.436
AND ORDER TO MEET OUR STATE'S
00:57:20.503 --> 00:57:21.571
CLIMATE GOALS AND, OF COURSE TO
00:57:21.638 --> 00:57:22.672
PROTECT LIFE AND LIMB. IN
00:57:22.739 --> 00:57:23.973
FEBRUARY, THE STRATEGIC GROWTH
00:57:24.040 --> 00:57:25.241
COUNCIL PUBLISHED THE CALIFORNIA
00:57:25.308 --> 00:57:26.743
TRANSPORTATION ASSESSMENT
00:57:26.810 --> 00:57:28.645
PURSUANT TO MY BILL FROM 19 2080
00:57:28.711 --> 00:57:31.981
TO 85. THE REPORT OFFERS AN
00:57:32.048 --> 00:57:33.449
ASSESSMENT, INCLUDING FIVE WHITE
00:57:33.516 --> 00:57:35.151
PAPERS AND OVER 80 STAKEHOLDER
00:57:35.218 --> 00:57:36.853
INTERVIEWS OF HOW TRANSPORTATION
00:57:36.920 --> 00:57:38.054
PLANNING AND FUNDING IN
00:57:38.121 --> 00:57:39.956
CALIFORNIA SUPPORTS OR DOESN'T
00:57:40.023 --> 00:57:41.090
SUPPORT BUILDING AND MAINTAINING
00:57:41.157 --> 00:57:42.959
A TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM. THAT
00:57:43.026 --> 00:57:45.094
ADVANCES STATE CLIMATE GOALS AND
00:57:45.161 --> 00:57:45.995
MEETS THE STATE'S TRANSPORTATION
00:57:46.062 --> 00:57:48.231
NEEDS. HE FINDINGS FROM THIS
00:57:48.298 --> 00:57:50.233
REPORT IDENTIFY A GAP BETWEEN
00:57:50.300 --> 00:57:51.301
THE STATES VISION FOR A MORE
00:57:51.367 --> 00:57:52.569
CLIMATE FRIENDLY EQUITABLE
00:57:52.635 --> 00:57:53.770
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM AND OUR
00:57:53.837 --> 00:57:56.706
SPENDING DECISIONS. THE REPORT
00:57:56.773 --> 00:57:58.274
ALSO HIGHLIGHTS THAT PROJECTS IN
00:57:58.341 --> 00:57:59.709
THE PIPELINE ARE RARELY RE
00:57:59.776 --> 00:58:00.844
EVALUATED TO ASSESS THEIR
00:58:00.910 --> 00:58:02.745
ALIGNMENT WITH CURRENT STATE
00:58:02.812 --> 00:58:05.081
PRIORITIZE OUR PRIORITIES. THIS
00:58:05.148 --> 00:58:06.549
BILL AND THE COMPLEMENTARY BILL
00:58:06.616 --> 00:58:07.817
, WHICH IS NOW BEING HELD IN
00:58:07.884 --> 00:58:09.485
THIS COMMITTEE WORK TO CODIFY
00:58:09.552 --> 00:58:12.255
RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE 2 85
00:58:12.322 --> 00:58:13.723
REPORT AND THE ADMINISTRATION'S
00:58:13.790 --> 00:58:15.391
CLIMATE ACTION ON TRANSPORTATION
00:58:15.458 --> 00:58:16.426
INFRASTRUCTURE, KNOWN AS CAPT.
00:58:16.492 --> 00:58:19.295
E. THIS BILL REQUIRES THE
00:58:19.362 --> 00:58:20.396
GUIDELINES AND PROJECT
00:58:20.463 --> 00:58:21.464
NOMINATION PROCESS FOR THE
00:58:21.531 --> 00:58:23.233
STATE'S LARGEST TRANSPORTATION
00:58:23.299 --> 00:58:25.435
FUNDING PROGRAMS TO CLEARLY AND
00:58:25.501 --> 00:58:26.669
TRANSPARENTLY INCLUDE THE
00:58:26.736 --> 00:58:27.537
APPLICABLE STRATEGIES OF
00:58:27.604 --> 00:58:30.440
CAPITAL. CAPITAL IS DESIGNED TO
00:58:30.506 --> 00:58:31.941
BE A HOLISTIC FRAMEWORK FOR
00:58:32.008 --> 00:58:33.643
ALIGNING STATE TRANSPORTATION
00:58:33.710 --> 00:58:34.878
INVESTMENTS WITH THE STATE'S
00:58:34.944 --> 00:58:35.745
CLIMATE, HEALTH AND SOCIAL
00:58:35.812 --> 00:58:38.214
EQUITY GOALS. THIS DOCUMENT WAS
00:58:38.281 --> 00:58:39.349
DEVELOPED WITH THE STATE OF
00:58:39.415 --> 00:58:40.183
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
00:58:40.250 --> 00:58:42.986
COMMITTEE. IN ALIGNMENT WITH THE
00:58:43.052 --> 00:58:45.121
CURRENT GOVERNORS ADMINISTRATION
00:58:45.188 --> 00:58:46.522
AND IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S
00:58:46.589 --> 00:58:48.191
SUPPOSED TO BE A GUIDING
00:58:48.258 --> 00:58:49.359
FRAMEWORK FOR ALL OF OUR STATE
00:58:49.425 --> 00:58:50.360
AGENCIES. I APPRECIATE THE
00:58:50.426 --> 00:58:52.128
OPPOSITION'S WORK WITH MY STAFF,
00:58:52.195 --> 00:58:53.196
AND I LOOK FORWARD TO
00:58:53.263 --> 00:58:54.631
INCORPORATING TECHNICAL
00:58:54.697 --> 00:58:56.099
AMENDMENTS THAT CLARIFY PROGRAMS
00:58:56.165 --> 00:58:56.966
MENTIONED IN SECTIONS ONE
00:58:57.033 --> 00:58:59.202
THROUGH THREE OF THE BILL AND
00:58:59.269 --> 00:59:00.570
SPECIFY THE COMPETITIVE PORTION
00:59:00.637 --> 00:59:01.638
OF THE LOCAL PARTNERSHIP
00:59:01.704 --> 00:59:03.873
PROGRAM. WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF
00:59:03.940 --> 00:59:06.109
TIME TO ADDRESS CLIMATE CHANGE.
00:59:06.175 --> 00:59:08.278
MAYBE 24 38 WORKS TO INCORPORATE
00:59:08.344 --> 00:59:09.812
OUR EXISTING GOALS INTO THE
00:59:09.879 --> 00:59:11.281
STATE'S LARGEST FUNDING,
00:59:11.347 --> 00:59:11.881
TRANSPORTATION TRANSPORTATION
00:59:11.948 --> 00:59:14.350
FUNDING PROGRAMS. IN SUPPORT ON
00:59:14.417 --> 00:59:15.785
THE PHONE IS CLIMATE PLAN
00:59:15.852 --> 00:59:17.353
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR NELIA POPE
00:59:17.420 --> 00:59:19.822
HARDEN AND EILEEN MESA VICE
00:59:19.889 --> 00:59:21.457
MAYOR JACK SHOE AND I WOULD
00:59:21.524 --> 00:59:22.959
RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED I VOTE SO
00:59:23.026 --> 00:59:24.127
WE CAN CONTINUE THIS IMPORTANT
00:59:24.193 --> 00:59:26.396
DISCUSSION. THANK YOU, MS POPE
00:59:26.462 --> 00:59:27.463
HARDEN. IF YOU'D LIKE TO
00:59:27.530 --> 00:59:30.433
PROCEED, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK
00:59:30.500 --> 00:59:32.602
YOU SO MUCH AVAILABLE GARDEN
00:59:32.669 --> 00:59:35.638
WITH CLIMATE PLAN. A B 24 38 IS
00:59:35.705 --> 00:59:36.940
LONG OVERDUE AND NECESSARY
00:59:37.006 --> 00:59:38.841
POLICY TO MOVE US CLOSER TO A
00:59:38.908 --> 00:59:39.976
HEALTHIER AND BETTER CONNECTED
00:59:40.043 --> 00:59:42.145
STATE. ON ONE HAND, WE HAVE THE
00:59:42.211 --> 00:59:43.913
MOST AMBITIOUS CLIMATE POLICIES
00:59:43.980 --> 00:59:46.182
IN THE NATION, AND THIS BODY HAS
00:59:46.249 --> 00:59:47.750
DONE A LOT TO SET TARGETS,
00:59:47.817 --> 00:59:48.685
MANDATES AND CREATE POLICIES
00:59:48.751 --> 00:59:49.919
THAT WORK TO REDUCE OUR MISSIONS
00:59:49.986 --> 00:59:52.288
AND CLEAN OUR COMMUNITIES. AND
00:59:52.355 --> 00:59:53.556
WE ALSO HAVE THE CLIMATE ACTION
00:59:53.623 --> 00:59:54.958
PLAN FOR TRANSPORTATION
00:59:55.024 --> 00:59:56.225
INFRASTRUCTURE THAT IS A
00:59:56.292 --> 00:59:57.260
FRAMEWORK TO LEAD US INTO THE
00:59:57.327 --> 00:59:59.562
FUTURE. ALL OF THESE ARE REALLY
00:59:59.629 --> 01:00:00.630
PROGRESSIVE AND MAKE US THE
01:00:00.697 --> 01:00:02.565
LEADER IN THE STATE ON CLIMATE
01:00:02.632 --> 01:00:04.233
POLICIES. BUT ON THE OTHER HAND
01:00:04.300 --> 01:00:04.901
, WE HAVE A TRANSPORTATION
01:00:04.968 --> 01:00:07.236
SECTOR THAT HAS 40% EMISSIONS
01:00:07.303 --> 01:00:08.771
AND TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS THAT
01:00:08.838 --> 01:00:09.973
ARE MISALIGNED FROM OUR CLIMATE
01:00:10.039 --> 01:00:11.607
GOALS. THE 80 TO 85 REPORTS
01:00:11.674 --> 01:00:13.743
INDICATE THAT WE NEED ACTION.
01:00:13.810 --> 01:00:16.312
AND MAYBE 24 38 IS REALLY WHAT
01:00:16.379 --> 01:00:18.481
WE NEED TO TIE THE BOW BETWEEN
01:00:18.548 --> 01:00:19.549
OUR CLIMATE GOALS AND OUR
01:00:19.615 --> 01:00:21.150
CURRENT TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM.
01:00:21.217 --> 01:00:22.085
I RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED VIDEOS.
01:00:22.151 --> 01:00:26.322
I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK
01:00:26.389 --> 01:00:29.993
YOU, MR XU. PLEASE PURSUE THANK
01:00:30.059 --> 01:00:34.330
YOU. CHAIR NEWMAN. MY NAME IS
01:00:34.397 --> 01:00:35.498
JACKSON, A LIFELONG ADVOCATE FOR
01:00:35.565 --> 01:00:36.499
THE ENVIRONMENT, ENVIRONMENTAL
01:00:36.566 --> 01:00:39.469
JUSTICE. IN OVER 15 YEARS HAVE
01:00:39.535 --> 01:00:41.037
BEEN LOOKING AT REGIONAL
01:00:41.104 --> 01:00:42.071
TRANSPORTATION PLANS AND TRYING
01:00:42.138 --> 01:00:44.974
TO IMPROVE OUR CLIMATE. NOW THE
01:00:45.041 --> 01:00:46.542
CITY COUNCIL MEMBER BACK VICE
01:00:46.609 --> 01:00:50.279
MAYOR ON OUR LOCAL M P O SANDBAG
01:00:50.346 --> 01:00:52.048
AND ON THE MTS BOARD, OUR
01:00:52.115 --> 01:00:53.116
TRANSPORTATION AGENCY AS WELL AS
01:00:53.182 --> 01:00:54.317
THE EVOLUTION CONTROLS ISSUE. WE
01:00:54.384 --> 01:01:01.391
NEED A B. 24 38. BUT IT. COMES
01:01:01.457 --> 01:01:02.258
TO REDUCING GREENHOUSE GAS
01:01:02.325 --> 01:01:04.027
EMISSIONS MUST TRAVELED AIR
01:01:04.093 --> 01:01:05.028
POLLUTION OR COMMUNITIES.
01:01:05.094 --> 01:01:08.231
THERE'S NO TIME LEFT. WE CAN
01:01:08.297 --> 01:01:09.966
ASPIRE TO HAVE A BETTER PLAN. WE
01:01:10.033 --> 01:01:12.268
CAN HAVE A BETTER PLAN. BUT
01:01:12.335 --> 01:01:14.837
THESE ARE JUST PLANS. WE NEED
01:01:14.904 --> 01:01:16.039
THE FUNDING ASPECT TO ALIGN WITH
01:01:16.105 --> 01:01:17.974
OUR GOALS. SO LET ME GIVE YOU A
01:01:18.041 --> 01:01:21.878
QUICK EXAMPLE. IF YOU GO TO THE
01:01:21.944 --> 01:01:24.547
DOCTOR AND THE DOCTOR SAYS, YOU
01:01:24.614 --> 01:01:25.782
KNOW YOU HAVE LIVER DISEASE, AND
01:01:25.848 --> 01:01:26.916
YOU REALLY SHOULD STOP DRINKING.
01:01:26.983 --> 01:01:28.084
WELL, NO ONE IN RIGHT MIND WOULD
01:01:28.151 --> 01:01:31.387
THINK TAKING TO CONTINUE TO
01:01:31.454 --> 01:01:33.322
SPEND THE SAME KIND OF MONEY AND
01:01:33.389 --> 01:01:35.625
ON BUYING DRINK. YOU HAVE TO
01:01:35.691 --> 01:01:36.759
CHANGE THE BUDGET, YOU HAVE TO
01:01:36.826 --> 01:01:39.962
CHANGE THE EXPENDITURES. WE KNOW
01:01:40.029 --> 01:01:42.198
EXPANDING ROADWAYS. IN THIS
01:01:42.265 --> 01:01:46.869
SYSTEM AND. AND THEN A SHORT
01:01:46.936 --> 01:01:48.037
TIME WE END UP WITH MORE
01:01:48.104 --> 01:01:49.839
CONGESTION AND MORE POLLUTION.
01:01:49.906 --> 01:01:50.740
WE HAVE TO CHANGE
01:01:50.807 --> 01:01:54.577
TRANSPORTATION. AS AS NOT ONLY
01:01:54.644 --> 01:01:55.378
PLANNING DIFFERENTLY, BUT ALSO
01:01:55.445 --> 01:01:56.012
SPENDING DIFFERENTLY. PLANNERS
01:01:56.079 --> 01:01:57.346
KNOW HOW TO LEAVE IT. BUT THEY
01:01:57.413 --> 01:02:01.984
CAN'T. IF THE PROJECTS THAT ARE
01:02:02.051 --> 01:02:03.820
FUNDED ARE STILL LIKE THE
01:02:03.886 --> 01:02:05.621
WEDNESDAY THAT WE HAVE FUNDED IN
01:02:05.688 --> 01:02:06.789
THE PAST. THAT'S DIRECTLY
01:02:06.856 --> 01:02:07.723
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
01:02:07.790 --> 01:02:08.791
COMMISSION TO SUPPORT SCIENCE.
01:02:08.858 --> 01:02:12.128
AND SUPPORT. CLIMATE CODE IN THE
01:02:12.195 --> 01:02:15.965
STATE. LET'S HAVE OUR PROJECTS
01:02:16.032 --> 01:02:17.133
ALIGNED WITH TARGETS, SO THAT IN
01:02:17.200 --> 01:02:20.670
THE NEAR TERM WILL WE CAN DO
01:02:20.736 --> 01:02:22.138
BETTER IN TERMS OF REDUCING
01:02:22.205 --> 01:02:24.006
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS ACROSS
01:02:24.073 --> 01:02:25.141
MARCH. TRAVEL AND POLLUTION THAT
01:02:25.208 --> 01:02:28.377
AFFECTS OUR COMMUNITY. THANK YOU
01:02:28.444 --> 01:02:30.279
. AND I HEARD YOUR SUPPORT FOR
01:02:30.346 --> 01:02:33.282
THE POINTS FOR 38. THANK YOU, MR
01:02:33.349 --> 01:02:35.751
XU. IS THERE ANYBODY HERE IN THE
01:02:35.818 --> 01:02:36.919
CHAMBER LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
01:02:36.986 --> 01:02:38.454
SUPPORT OF A B 24 38? PLEASE
01:02:38.521 --> 01:02:41.757
PURSUE. CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:02:41.824 --> 01:02:42.959
ALEJANDRA AND REPRESENTING NEXT
01:02:43.025 --> 01:02:45.094
IN CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT THANK
01:02:45.161 --> 01:02:47.130
YOU. ANYONE ELSE WOULD LIKE TO
01:02:47.196 --> 01:02:48.264
TRY AND SUPPORTED THE BILL IN
01:02:48.331 --> 01:02:50.366
THE CHAMBERS. MR MODERATOR, CAN
01:02:50.433 --> 01:02:52.335
WE GO TO THE TELECONFERENCE AND
01:02:52.401 --> 01:02:53.669
PLAYS ANYBODY WISHING TO SUPPORT
01:02:53.736 --> 01:02:55.338
TO TEST AND SUPPORT OF 24 38
01:02:55.404 --> 01:02:56.606
WITH THEIR NAME, AFFILIATION AND
01:02:56.672 --> 01:03:00.810
POSITION, PLEASE? OF COURSE.
01:03:00.877 --> 01:03:01.744
ONCE AGAIN, LADIES AND
01:03:01.811 --> 01:03:03.045
GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO ASK A
01:03:03.112 --> 01:03:04.847
QUESTION OR IF YOU ARE IN
01:03:04.914 --> 01:03:06.382
SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS 10 WILL
01:03:06.449 --> 01:03:08.384
FIRST GO TO LINE 109, PLEASE GO
01:03:08.451 --> 01:03:12.255
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON STEPHANIE
01:03:12.321 --> 01:03:13.823
SHADOW WITH CRUZ STRATEGIES ON
01:03:13.890 --> 01:03:16.092
BEHALF OF THIS TODAY, SAN JOSE
01:03:16.159 --> 01:03:16.759
ACTUALLY MISSED THE BILL
01:03:16.826 --> 01:03:18.561
BEFOREHAND, BUT WE'RE IN SUPPORT
01:03:18.628 --> 01:03:20.062
OF 1938. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
01:03:20.129 --> 01:03:23.366
YOUR PATIENCE. THANK YOU NEXT.
01:03:23.432 --> 01:03:24.600
WE'LL GO TO LINE 48, PLEASE GO
01:03:24.667 --> 01:03:29.805
AHEAD. IN SHARE MARKET THAT'S
01:03:29.872 --> 01:03:31.374
REPRESENTING THE STREETS FOR ALL
01:03:31.440 --> 01:03:32.975
AND THE CHRISTMAS ALLIANCE FOR
01:03:33.042 --> 01:03:34.010
BETTER STREETS IN SUPPORT OF
01:03:34.076 --> 01:03:35.878
THIS, BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:03:35.945 --> 01:03:38.881
NEXT, PLEASE. LINE. 94, PLEASE
01:03:38.948 --> 01:03:44.220
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. ELENA
01:03:44.287 --> 01:03:47.323
ORTIZ ON BEHALF OF NRDC ACTION
01:03:47.390 --> 01:03:48.558
FUND AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:03:48.624 --> 01:03:51.160
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. WELL,
01:03:51.227 --> 01:03:53.362
NEXT GO TO LINE ONE. OH, ONE.
01:03:53.429 --> 01:03:58.201
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. THIS IS AMY
01:03:58.267 --> 01:03:59.368
THOMPSON WAS TRANSFORMED IN
01:03:59.435 --> 01:03:59.969
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:04:00.036 --> 01:04:04.740
NEXT, PLEASE. AND I'VE GOT A
01:04:04.807 --> 01:04:08.344
LINE. 102, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:04:08.411 --> 01:04:10.513
AFTERNOON. THIS IS AT LEAST PHÊN
01:04:10.580 --> 01:04:11.847
DRINK WITH CALIFORNIA
01:04:11.914 --> 01:04:13.449
ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS CALLING IN
01:04:13.516 --> 01:04:14.617
SUPPORT. I'M ALSO CALLING AND
01:04:14.684 --> 01:04:15.718
SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF SIERRA
01:04:15.785 --> 01:04:19.822
CLUB. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:04:19.889 --> 01:04:21.123
NEXT TO THE LINE ONE. OH, SEVEN.
01:04:21.190 --> 01:04:24.594
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:04:24.660 --> 01:04:26.062
, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS ROGER
01:04:26.128 --> 01:04:27.763
DICKINSON ON BEHALF OF CIVIC
01:04:27.830 --> 01:04:28.798
WELL IN SUPPORT, THANKS VERY
01:04:28.864 --> 01:04:32.335
MUCH. NEXT, PLEASE. LET'S GO TO
01:04:32.401 --> 01:04:40.209
LINE. 20, PLEASE GO AHEAD. PERU.
01:04:40.276 --> 01:04:42.645
PLEASE PURSUED GOOD AFTERNOON
01:04:42.712 --> 01:04:44.880
CHAIR MEMBERS. MY NAME IS KIM
01:04:44.947 --> 01:04:46.482
LOOK SILLY AND REPRESENTING
01:04:46.549 --> 01:04:47.917
SCREW SAFETY BAY AREA AND I
01:04:47.984 --> 01:04:49.752
STRONGLY SUPPORT 24 38. THANK
01:04:49.819 --> 01:04:54.890
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:04:54.957 --> 01:04:56.125
NEXT TO THE LINE. 59, PLEASE GO
01:04:56.192 --> 01:05:00.963
AHEAD. CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES.
01:05:01.030 --> 01:05:06.836
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU.
01:05:06.902 --> 01:05:08.771
MATTHEW BAKER, POLICY DIRECTOR
01:05:08.838 --> 01:05:09.805
FOR PLANNING AND CONSERVATION,
01:05:09.872 --> 01:05:10.706
LEGAL, STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU
01:05:10.773 --> 01:05:15.778
NEXT, PLEASE. WELL, NEXT TO THE
01:05:15.845 --> 01:05:19.348
LINE. 70, PLEASE GO AHEAD. QUITE
01:05:19.415 --> 01:05:21.317
THROUGH THEM IN WITH EFFECTIVE.
01:05:21.384 --> 01:05:21.951
THANK GABRIEL VALLEY AND STRONG
01:05:22.018 --> 01:05:23.052
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:05:23.119 --> 01:05:26.956
NEXT. WHEN I STARTED LINED 15,
01:05:27.023 --> 01:05:32.361
PLEASE GO AHEAD. 15 YEARS LINE
01:05:32.428 --> 01:05:40.736
IS OPEN. GO TO LINE 82, PLEASE
01:05:40.803 --> 01:05:44.907
GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS IS STEVE.
01:05:44.974 --> 01:05:47.843
GUILT FROM SAN DIEGO. 3 50. I
01:05:47.910 --> 01:05:50.313
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 24 38.
01:05:50.379 --> 01:05:51.414
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:05:51.480 --> 01:05:55.017
PLEASE. WHEN THEY GO TO LINE 32
01:05:55.084 --> 01:06:00.423
, PLEASE GO AHEAD. WELL MY NAME
01:06:00.489 --> 01:06:02.325
IS BEING MR MILLER FROM SAN
01:06:02.391 --> 01:06:05.361
DIEGO. 3 50. I ALSO STRONGLY
01:06:05.428 --> 01:06:07.630
SUPPORT A B 24 30 GAMES. THANK
01:06:07.697 --> 01:06:12.368
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:06:12.435 --> 01:06:13.536
WELL, NEXT LINE. 40, PLEASE GO
01:06:13.602 --> 01:06:18.874
AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS MUSTAFA
01:06:18.941 --> 01:06:21.210
PATTON. I'M WITH SAN DIEGO. 3
01:06:21.277 --> 01:06:22.411
50. I STRONGLY SUPPORT MAYBE 24
01:06:22.478 --> 01:06:27.850
38. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. NEXT
01:06:27.917 --> 01:06:32.121
GO TO LINE 68, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:06:32.188 --> 01:06:33.389
THANK YOU. THIS IS OLIVIA
01:06:33.456 --> 01:06:34.390
SIDEMEN WITH LEADERSHIP COUNCIL
01:06:34.457 --> 01:06:35.558
FOR JUSTICE, JUSTICE AND
01:06:35.624 --> 01:06:36.659
ACCOUNTABILITY AND SUPPORT.
01:06:36.726 --> 01:06:40.229
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. UNLESS
01:06:40.296 --> 01:06:41.364
THEY'RE A LINE. 81, PLEASE GO
01:06:41.430 --> 01:06:46.469
AHEAD. HI GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS
01:06:46.535 --> 01:06:48.738
IS PETER SLOAN. ALSO WITH SAN
01:06:48.804 --> 01:06:50.439
DIEGO 3 50. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
01:06:50.506 --> 01:06:52.007
A B 2438. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:06:52.074 --> 01:06:56.879
NEXT, PLEASE. NEXT GO TO LINE.
01:06:56.946 --> 01:07:03.119
30, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS
01:07:03.185 --> 01:07:04.487
IS MATTHEW BOSS LOCKETS WITH
01:07:04.553 --> 01:07:06.756
CLIMATE ACTION CAMPAIGN. STRONG
01:07:06.822 --> 01:07:07.923
SUPPORT FOR THE MEASURE. THANK
01:07:07.990 --> 01:07:10.559
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. AND
01:07:10.626 --> 01:07:11.660
THEY'RE CURRENTLY NONE OTHER IN
01:07:11.727 --> 01:07:15.231
THE QUEUE. LET'S COME BACK TO
01:07:15.297 --> 01:07:17.600
THE CHAMBER SHOW A LEAD
01:07:17.666 --> 01:07:19.135
OPPOSITION WITNESS, MR KEITH,
01:07:19.201 --> 01:07:20.770
DOWN FROM THE SHELF UP COUNTIES
01:07:20.836 --> 01:07:21.771
COALITION, MR DUNN. WELCOME.
01:07:21.837 --> 01:07:23.906
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU, MR
01:07:23.973 --> 01:07:25.508
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE
01:07:25.574 --> 01:07:27.476
COMMITTEE AND CHAIRMAN FRIEDMAN
01:07:27.543 --> 01:07:29.378
, KEITH DOWN EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
01:07:29.445 --> 01:07:31.447
OF THE SELF HELP COUNTIES
01:07:31.514 --> 01:07:33.215
COALITION, THE 25. LOCAL
01:07:33.282 --> 01:07:34.784
COUNTIES THAT HAVE PASSED BY TWO
01:07:34.850 --> 01:07:36.485
THIRDS VOTE OF THEIR CITIZENS
01:07:36.552 --> 01:07:37.486
AND YOUR CONSTITUENTS
01:07:37.553 --> 01:07:39.288
EXPENDITURE PLANS TO FIX AN
01:07:39.355 --> 01:07:41.257
ADDRESS AND FUND INFRASTRUCTURE
01:07:41.323 --> 01:07:42.992
THROUGHOUT THEIR COUNTIES. I'M
01:07:43.058 --> 01:07:44.927
HERE TODAY. IN FIRST I'D LIKE TO
01:07:44.994 --> 01:07:47.963
SAY IN SUPPORT OF AH, THE EFFORT
01:07:48.030 --> 01:07:50.065
TO DELIVER EQUITABLE CLIMATE
01:07:50.132 --> 01:07:50.966
RESILIENT FUTURE. IT'S A GOAL
01:07:51.033 --> 01:07:53.269
NOT ONLY OF MYSELF, BUT ALSO OF
01:07:53.335 --> 01:07:55.337
ALL THE SELF HELP COUNTIES TO
01:07:55.404 --> 01:07:56.071
ENSURE THAT THE CITIZENS OF
01:07:56.138 --> 01:07:57.139
CALIFORNIA HAVE A SAFE AND
01:07:57.206 --> 01:08:00.075
EQUITABLE ENVIRONMENT THAT ALSO
01:08:00.142 --> 01:08:00.976
DELIVERS THEM TO HOMEWORK AND
01:08:01.043 --> 01:08:02.378
SCHOOL AND GET SOME HOME SAFELY
01:08:02.445 --> 01:08:03.512
AND THEIR TRANSPORTATION
01:08:03.579 --> 01:08:05.948
SYSTEMS. I'M HERE TODAY IN
01:08:06.015 --> 01:08:09.452
OPPOSITION TO 24 38 AS CURRENTLY
01:08:09.518 --> 01:08:11.320
WRITTEN. WE HAVE CONCERNS THAT
01:08:11.387 --> 01:08:14.223
REMAIN, UH, IN THE
01:08:14.290 --> 01:08:15.724
IMPLEMENTATION OF ADDITIONAL
01:08:15.791 --> 01:08:18.194
GUIDELINES TOMORROW IS CALLED
01:08:18.260 --> 01:08:19.295
OUT IN THE ANALYSIS. THE
01:08:19.361 --> 01:08:19.829
CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
01:08:19.895 --> 01:08:21.697
COMMISSION WE'LL DO A
01:08:21.764 --> 01:08:23.999
PRESENTATION ON A 10 MONTH 23
01:08:24.066 --> 01:08:25.134
PUBLIC WORKSHOP PROCESS THAT'S
01:08:25.201 --> 01:08:27.970
HAPPENED TO DATE. ESTABLISHING
01:08:28.037 --> 01:08:30.072
GUIDELINES THAT DO THE VERY
01:08:30.139 --> 01:08:31.674
THING THAT 24 38 IS SUPPOSED TO
01:08:31.740 --> 01:08:33.142
DO. SO WE DO STAND IN
01:08:33.209 --> 01:08:35.010
PARTNERSHIP WITH THE STATE AS A
01:08:35.077 --> 01:08:36.412
FUNDING PARTNER, AND THAT'S THE
01:08:36.479 --> 01:08:38.581
KEY DIFFERENCE THAT COME HERE
01:08:38.647 --> 01:08:40.082
TODAY WITH YOU, AS IS THE SELF
01:08:40.149 --> 01:08:41.617
HELP COUNTIES FUND $5 BILLION
01:08:41.684 --> 01:08:44.587
ANNUALLY. AS PARTNERS IN THE
01:08:44.653 --> 01:08:45.955
FUNDING AND BUILDING OF OUR
01:08:46.021 --> 01:08:47.056
INFRASTRUCTURE. NOW THE
01:08:47.122 --> 01:08:49.058
DIFFERENCE THERE IN 24 38 IS
01:08:49.125 --> 01:08:50.860
WE'RE CONCERNED THAT AND WHILE
01:08:50.926 --> 01:08:52.995
THERE'S A STIPULATION THAT THERE
01:08:53.062 --> 01:08:54.129
SHOULD BE NO CONFLICT WITH
01:08:54.196 --> 01:08:55.364
MULTIPLE GUIDELINES AS THEY'RE
01:08:55.431 --> 01:08:57.333
DEVELOPED, WE ALL KNOW THAT.
01:08:57.399 --> 01:08:58.868
MULTIPLE GUIDELINES, WILCOCK
01:08:58.934 --> 01:09:01.003
CAUSE CONFUSION AND DELAYS AND
01:09:01.070 --> 01:09:02.705
HOW THOSE INTERACT AND HOW THEY
01:09:02.771 --> 01:09:04.273
ARE MERGED TOGETHER. IF THERE
01:09:04.340 --> 01:09:07.676
NEEDED TO BE SO WERE CONTINUED
01:09:07.743 --> 01:09:09.111
TO OPPOSE THIS BILL. WE THINK
01:09:09.178 --> 01:09:10.646
IT'S NOT NEEDED. WE DO SUPPORT
01:09:10.713 --> 01:09:12.681
THE GOALS WE HAVE BEEN WORKING
01:09:12.748 --> 01:09:13.816
AGAIN. 10 MONTHS 23 PUBLIC
01:09:13.883 --> 01:09:16.118
WORKSHOPS. THERE WILL BE MORE.
01:09:16.185 --> 01:09:17.987
WE'VE BEEN ACTIVE PARTICIPANTS.
01:09:18.053 --> 01:09:20.623
WE ARE SUPPORTIVE OF RESILIENT
01:09:20.689 --> 01:09:22.458
CLIMATE FUTURE FOR OUR CITIZENS
01:09:22.525 --> 01:09:24.093
. WE ALSO KNOW THAT WE HAVE TO
01:09:24.159 --> 01:09:25.227
DELIVER PROGRAMS ON THE PROMISES
01:09:25.294 --> 01:09:27.630
THAT WE MADE TO OUR TAXPAYERS.
01:09:27.696 --> 01:09:30.399
IN EACH COUNTY THAT HAS VOTED TO
01:09:30.466 --> 01:09:31.667
TAX THEMSELVES TO FUND THESE
01:09:31.734 --> 01:09:32.935
PRIORITY PROJECTS. IT CAN BE
01:09:33.002 --> 01:09:35.404
DONE IN AN EQUITABLE FASHION. IT
01:09:35.471 --> 01:09:36.005
CAN BE DONE WITH THE CLIMATE
01:09:36.071 --> 01:09:38.007
RESILIENT FUTURE IN MIND. WE
01:09:38.073 --> 01:09:40.242
MOVED TO DO THOSE PROJECTS USING
01:09:40.309 --> 01:09:41.176
URBAN QUARRIES AND DIFFERENT
01:09:41.243 --> 01:09:42.311
TECHNIQUES THAT CHANGE HOW WE
01:09:42.378 --> 01:09:44.079
CONSTRUCT A PROGRAM IN THE
01:09:44.146 --> 01:09:45.814
PROJECT. SO AGAIN APPRECIATE THE
01:09:45.881 --> 01:09:48.384
AUTHORS SENTIMENTS WE CONSIDER
01:09:48.450 --> 01:09:50.286
HER GOOD FRIEND, BUT
01:09:50.352 --> 01:09:51.921
UNFORTUNATELY HAVE TO OPPOSE
01:09:51.987 --> 01:09:53.389
THIS BILL STILL, THANK YOU FOR
01:09:53.455 --> 01:09:54.523
YOUR TIME. THANK YOU, SIR.
01:09:54.590 --> 01:09:55.991
ANYBODY ELSE? IN THE CHAMBER
01:09:56.058 --> 01:09:57.693
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
01:09:57.760 --> 01:09:58.460
OPPOSITION WITH YOUR NAME,
01:09:58.527 --> 01:09:59.995
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
01:10:00.062 --> 01:10:01.497
BILL, PLEASE MR CHAIR MEMBERS,
01:10:01.564 --> 01:10:03.566
MIKE MONEGAN'S ON BEHALF OF THE
01:10:03.632 --> 01:10:04.767
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
01:10:04.833 --> 01:10:08.637
TRADES IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
01:10:08.704 --> 01:10:09.972
MR CHAIR MEMBERS, GUS CORN
01:10:10.039 --> 01:10:11.707
BEHALF OF THE 13 COUNTIES ALONG
01:10:11.774 --> 01:10:13.142
THE CENTRAL COAST AND SAN
01:10:13.208 --> 01:10:15.110
JOAQUIN VALLEY. WE HAVE AN
01:10:15.177 --> 01:10:16.111
OPPOSING LESS SUBMITTED
01:10:16.178 --> 01:10:16.912
POSITION. WE BELIEVE THAT THE
01:10:16.979 --> 01:10:18.547
BILL IS DUPLICATIVE, BUT WE'RE
01:10:18.614 --> 01:10:20.316
HAPPY TO WORK WITH THE AUTHOR ON
01:10:20.382 --> 01:10:21.817
IMPLEMENTING STRATEGIES IN ORDER
01:10:21.884 --> 01:10:24.353
TO HELP COMPEL ACCELERATING OUR
01:10:24.420 --> 01:10:25.487
RESPONSE TO MEETING CLIMATE
01:10:25.554 --> 01:10:28.357
CHANGE OBJECTIVES. THANK YOU
01:10:28.424 --> 01:10:30.392
NEXT, PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON. MR
01:10:30.459 --> 01:10:32.161
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS SILVIO FERRARI
01:10:32.227 --> 01:10:33.429
ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA BUILDING
01:10:33.495 --> 01:10:34.563
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION, WE ARE
01:10:34.630 --> 01:10:35.764
OPPOSED. THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT,
01:10:35.831 --> 01:10:39.768
PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR
01:10:39.835 --> 01:10:41.437
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE CHIANA
01:10:41.503 --> 01:10:42.538
VALENTINE, ON BEHALF OF THE
01:10:42.605 --> 01:10:44.239
COACHELLA VALLEY ASSOCIATION OF
01:10:44.306 --> 01:10:45.307
GOVERNMENTS AND OPPOSITION.
01:10:45.374 --> 01:10:47.910
THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. MR
01:10:47.977 --> 01:10:49.111
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS, MARK WATTS
01:10:49.178 --> 01:10:50.112
TODAY REPRESENTING
01:10:50.179 --> 01:10:51.647
TRANSPORTATION, CALIFORNIA.
01:10:51.714 --> 01:10:53.749
REVEREND TO THAT REPRESENTS THE
01:10:53.816 --> 01:10:54.316
TRANSPORTATION INDUSTRY AND
01:10:54.383 --> 01:10:55.618
WORKFORCE THAT BUILDS REPAIRS
01:10:55.684 --> 01:10:57.753
AND MAINTAINS OUR MULTIMODAL
01:10:57.820 --> 01:10:58.854
SYSTEM. WE ARE OPPOSING THIS
01:10:58.921 --> 01:11:02.091
AMENDED AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO
01:11:02.157 --> 01:11:04.927
SEEING THE NEXT SEVEN AMENDMENTS
01:11:04.994 --> 01:11:06.061
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
01:11:06.128 --> 01:11:07.796
THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. MR
01:11:07.863 --> 01:11:08.864
CHAIR MEMBERS, JOHN MARTIN ON
01:11:08.931 --> 01:11:10.733
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA ALIGNED
01:11:10.799 --> 01:11:12.401
WITH TRANSPORTATION, CALIFORNIA
01:11:12.468 --> 01:11:13.268
CURRENTLY IN OPPOSING UNLESS
01:11:13.335 --> 01:11:15.404
AMENDED, BUT LOOK FORWARD TO
01:11:15.471 --> 01:11:16.505
SEEING THE AMENDMENTS COMMITTED
01:11:16.572 --> 01:11:17.673
TO TODAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:11:17.740 --> 01:11:20.442
NEXT, PLEASE. THANK YOU, MR
01:11:20.509 --> 01:11:22.011
CHAIR AND MEMBERS MOIRA TOP ON
01:11:22.077 --> 01:11:23.112
BEHALF OF THE ORANGE COUNTY
01:11:23.178 --> 01:11:24.880
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY. WE
01:11:24.947 --> 01:11:26.315
TOO, HAVE A POSITION OF OPPOSED,
01:11:26.382 --> 01:11:27.983
BUT I DO APPRECIATE THE
01:11:28.050 --> 01:11:28.917
CONVERSATIONS WE'VE HAD WITH THE
01:11:28.984 --> 01:11:30.185
AUTHOR AND LOOK FORWARD TO THE
01:11:30.252 --> 01:11:31.920
NEXT SET OF AMENDMENTS TO
01:11:31.987 --> 01:11:33.622
REEVALUATE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:11:33.689 --> 01:11:35.157
NEXT, PLEASE. CHRIS LEE ON
01:11:35.224 --> 01:11:36.358
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
01:11:36.425 --> 01:11:37.760
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES, ALSO
01:11:37.826 --> 01:11:39.061
TODAY WITH AN IMPOSING LESS
01:11:39.128 --> 01:11:40.462
AMENDED POSITION, BUT LOOK
01:11:40.529 --> 01:11:41.296
FORWARD TO REMOVING OUR
01:11:41.363 --> 01:11:43.632
OPPOSITION UPON THE AMENDMENTS.
01:11:43.699 --> 01:11:46.235
APPRECIATE THAT, SEEING NOBODY
01:11:46.301 --> 01:11:47.269
ELSE IN THE CHAMBER. LET'S MOVE
01:11:47.336 --> 01:11:49.938
THE TELECOMS. I'M MR MODERATOR.
01:11:50.005 --> 01:11:51.373
HE COULD PLEASE QUERY THE LINE
01:11:51.440 --> 01:11:52.107
FOR ANYBODY LIKE TESTIFYING
01:11:52.174 --> 01:11:56.945
OPPOSITION TO A B 24 38. OF
01:11:57.012 --> 01:11:59.548
COURSE, IF YOU WERE IN
01:11:59.615 --> 01:12:03.285
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10.
01:12:03.352 --> 01:12:04.486
WELL, FIRST OF LINES 74, PLEASE
01:12:04.553 --> 01:12:07.856
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
01:12:07.923 --> 01:12:08.957
CHAIRMAN, MEMBERS ELICIT STILL
01:12:09.024 --> 01:12:10.759
HIGH ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
01:12:10.826 --> 01:12:11.827
CORONA RESPECTING OPPOSITION AS
01:12:11.894 --> 01:12:13.128
CURRENTLY DRAFTED. THANK YOU.
01:12:13.195 --> 01:12:16.265
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. WILL
01:12:16.331 --> 01:12:18.167
NEXT GO TO LINE 100, PLEASE GO
01:12:18.233 --> 01:12:22.304
AHEAD. MR CHAIR MEMBERS. ROSS
01:12:22.371 --> 01:12:24.206
BUCKLEY ON BEHALF OF THE SAME
01:12:24.273 --> 01:12:24.740
BIRTHDAY, OKAY, TRANSITION
01:12:24.807 --> 01:12:25.307
AUTHORITIES. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:12:25.374 --> 01:12:29.178
PLEASE. THE LINE 88. PLEASE GO
01:12:29.244 --> 01:12:34.116
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
01:12:34.183 --> 01:12:35.384
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS JAMES THROW
01:12:35.451 --> 01:12:36.919
ACTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
01:12:36.985 --> 01:12:38.020
COUNCIL OF LABORERS. THANK YOU.
01:12:38.087 --> 01:12:41.290
NEXT QUESTION. THE NEXT LINE.
01:12:41.356 --> 01:12:46.161
89, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
01:12:46.228 --> 01:12:47.463
NATALIE ABOUT SOMEBODY ELSE'S
01:12:47.529 --> 01:12:48.397
THE CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
01:12:48.464 --> 01:12:49.031
ROUNDTABLE RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED.
01:12:49.098 --> 01:12:53.235
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. AND I'VE
01:12:53.302 --> 01:12:57.039
GOT A LINE. 42, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:12:57.106 --> 01:12:59.174
YES TYLER MCGARY WITH THE
01:12:59.241 --> 01:13:00.275
RIVERSIDE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION
01:13:00.342 --> 01:13:01.877
COMMISSION AND OPPOSITION TO A B
01:13:01.944 --> 01:13:03.212
24 38. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:13:03.278 --> 01:13:06.548
NEXT, PLEASE. MASTER ALIGNED 1
01:13:06.615 --> 01:13:10.652
15, PLEASE GO AHEAD. DAMON
01:13:10.719 --> 01:13:12.054
CONKLIN, WITH THE LEAGUE OF
01:13:12.121 --> 01:13:13.255
CALIFORNIA CITIES OPPOSED MUSLIM
01:13:13.322 --> 01:13:15.724
ENDED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:13:15.791 --> 01:13:17.259
NEXT, PLEASE. AND THEY'RE
01:13:17.326 --> 01:13:21.864
CURRENTLY NONE OF THE QUÊ. THANK
01:13:21.930 --> 01:13:23.899
YOU. LET'S LET'S COME BACK TO
01:13:23.966 --> 01:13:24.900
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. ANY
01:13:24.967 --> 01:13:25.968
MEMBERS WITH QUESTIONS OR
01:13:26.034 --> 01:13:27.703
COMMENTS ON THE BILL? MAYBE 24
01:13:27.770 --> 01:13:31.673
38. SEEING NONE SHALL REMEMBER.
01:13:31.740 --> 01:13:34.810
FRIEDMAN. I DO APPRECIATE YOUR
01:13:34.877 --> 01:13:36.945
EFFORTS. YOU AND I BOTH SERVE AS
01:13:37.012 --> 01:13:38.280
EX OFFICIAL REPRESENTATIVE TO
01:13:38.347 --> 01:13:39.047
THE CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTATION
01:13:39.114 --> 01:13:41.316
COMMISSION. I ALSO APPRECIATE
01:13:41.383 --> 01:13:42.518
HOW COMPLICATED THIS IS AND THE
01:13:42.584 --> 01:13:45.487
CONCERN AROUND. UNINTENDED
01:13:45.554 --> 01:13:47.523
CONSEQUENCES OR DUPLICATIVE
01:13:47.589 --> 01:13:51.460
PROGRAMS. UM THE I HAVE A NOTE
01:13:51.527 --> 01:13:52.961
HERE THAT YOU AND YOUR SPONSOR
01:13:53.028 --> 01:13:54.296
HAVE AGREED TO TAKE AMENDMENTS
01:13:54.363 --> 01:13:55.464
IN APPROPRIATIONS TO CLARIFY THE
01:13:55.531 --> 01:13:56.598
EXACT PROGRAMS. THE NEW
01:13:56.665 --> 01:13:57.733
GUIDELINES WOULD IMPACT IS THAT
01:13:57.800 --> 01:14:00.536
CORRECT? CORRECT WE'RE HOPING TO
01:14:00.602 --> 01:14:02.504
KEEP WORKING WITH THE FRIENDS OF
01:14:02.571 --> 01:14:04.273
OURS, WHO STILL HAVE CONCERNS
01:14:04.339 --> 01:14:06.008
AND TO TAKE THOSE AMENDMENTS AND
01:14:06.074 --> 01:14:07.576
HOPEFULLY REMOVE A LOT OF THE
01:14:07.643 --> 01:14:08.677
OPPOSITION AND I APPRECIATE
01:14:08.744 --> 01:14:10.212
THAT. WOULD THAT WOULD YOU LIKE
01:14:10.279 --> 01:14:12.214
TO CLOSE? JUST THAT RIGHT NOW WE
01:14:12.281 --> 01:14:13.215
HAVE GOALS THAT ARE NOT IN
01:14:13.282 --> 01:14:14.183
ALIGNMENT WITH SOME OF OUR
01:14:14.249 --> 01:14:15.617
GUIDELINES. WE'VE ALREADY TALKED
01:14:15.684 --> 01:14:17.186
TO CTC ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT
01:14:17.252 --> 01:14:18.320
WE'RE IN HARMONY WITH THEIR
01:14:18.387 --> 01:14:20.155
GUIDELINES. AND WE DO THINK THAT
01:14:20.222 --> 01:14:22.191
THE AMENDMENTS ARE GOING TO
01:14:22.257 --> 01:14:24.092
ADDRESS A LOT OF THE CONCERNS
01:14:24.159 --> 01:14:24.960
AND WILL CONTINUE TO WORK SO
01:14:25.027 --> 01:14:26.094
THAT WE MAKE SURE THAT WE DON'T
01:14:26.161 --> 01:14:28.831
HAVE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES.
01:14:28.897 --> 01:14:30.098
PROCEED TO YOUR NEXT PIECE OF
01:14:30.165 --> 01:14:33.702
LEGISLATION IN 23 44. THANK YOU
01:14:33.769 --> 01:14:34.870
VERY MUCH. I'M VERY PLEASED TO
01:14:34.937 --> 01:14:36.939
BE ABLE TO PRESENT A B 23 44.
01:14:37.005 --> 01:14:39.107
THAT HELPS THE STATE AVOID TWO
01:14:39.174 --> 01:14:40.475
VERY BAD OUTCOMES THAT WE SEE
01:14:40.542 --> 01:14:42.244
HAPPENING WAY TOO OFTEN, AND
01:14:42.311 --> 01:14:43.679
THOSE ARE COLLISIONS WITH LARGE
01:14:43.745 --> 01:14:45.914
WILDLIFE ON OUR ROADS. FIRST OF
01:14:45.981 --> 01:14:48.016
ALL, THEY ARE NOT ONLY
01:14:48.083 --> 01:14:49.051
DESTRUCTIVE, OF COURSE TO THE
01:14:49.117 --> 01:14:50.252
MIGRATING WILDLIFE AND IN MY
01:14:50.319 --> 01:14:51.420
AREA, MY I'M ALMOST MY MOST
01:14:51.486 --> 01:14:52.487
FAMOUS CONSTITUENT. MY MOST
01:14:52.554 --> 01:14:53.589
BELOVED CONSTITUENT IN MY
01:14:53.655 --> 01:14:56.091
DISTRICT IS NAMED P 22. AND HE
01:14:56.158 --> 01:14:57.092
HAS A MOUNTAIN LION WHO LIVES IN
01:14:57.159 --> 01:14:59.094
GRIFFITH PARK, AND SEVERAL OF
01:14:59.161 --> 01:15:00.462
HIS BRETHREN HAVE RECENTLY BEEN
01:15:00.529 --> 01:15:01.830
KILLED IN OUR HIGHWAYS TRYING TO
01:15:01.897 --> 01:15:03.198
MIGRATE, WHICH IS WHAT ANIMALS
01:15:03.265 --> 01:15:05.734
DO NATURALLY, AND EVERY TIME IT
01:15:05.801 --> 01:15:06.602
HAPPENS, WE'RE ALL TERRIFIED
01:15:06.668 --> 01:15:09.204
THAT IT'S OUR BELOVED P 22. BUT
01:15:09.271 --> 01:15:11.006
WE NEED TO HELP OUR WILDLIFE AND
01:15:11.073 --> 01:15:12.541
ALSO TO PREVENT THE INJURIES AND
01:15:12.608 --> 01:15:14.643
DEATHS THAT OCCUR WHEN DEER AND
01:15:14.710 --> 01:15:16.111
OTHER LARGE WILDLIFE HIT
01:15:16.178 --> 01:15:19.147
VEHICLES, AND WE ALSO KNOW THAT
01:15:19.214 --> 01:15:20.616
IT'S NOT. IT IS POSSIBLE TO
01:15:20.682 --> 01:15:22.851
IDENTIFY THE MIGRATORY PATHS.
01:15:22.918 --> 01:15:25.554
AND TO MAKE SURE THAT WE DO OUR
01:15:25.621 --> 01:15:26.989
INFRASTRUCTURE IN SUCH A WAY%
01:15:27.055 --> 01:15:28.523
THAT WE CAN GIVE THAT MIGRATING
01:15:28.590 --> 01:15:30.225
WILDLIFE ANOTHER WAY TO SAFELY
01:15:30.292 --> 01:15:31.927
CROSS OUR ROADS WITH ROAD WAYS
01:15:31.994 --> 01:15:33.629
THAT ARE SAFE FOR THEM WILDLIFE.
01:15:33.695 --> 01:15:36.031
AND SAFE FOR HUMANS. AND BY THE
01:15:36.098 --> 01:15:37.733
WAY, THE LAST TIME WE DID THIS
01:15:37.799 --> 01:15:39.134
BILL, ONE OF MY FRIENDS ACROSS
01:15:39.201 --> 01:15:41.103
THE AISLE WHO REPRESENTS A RURAL
01:15:41.169 --> 01:15:42.838
AREA, SPOKE ON IN FAVOR OF THE
01:15:42.905 --> 01:15:45.540
BILL. HOW MUCH HE SUPPORTED IT
01:15:45.607 --> 01:15:46.341
BECAUSE COLLISIONS WITH DEER
01:15:46.408 --> 01:15:47.442
HAVE CAUSED A LOT OF TERRIBLE
01:15:47.509 --> 01:15:48.810
CRASHES IN HIS DISTRICT, AND WE
01:15:48.877 --> 01:15:50.646
KNOW HOW TO SOLVE THIS THROUGH
01:15:50.712 --> 01:15:51.914
WILDLIFE CROSSINGS TO MAKING
01:15:51.980 --> 01:15:53.649
SURE THAT WHEN WE DO BUILD NEW,
01:15:53.715 --> 01:15:54.249
LARGE INFRASTRUCTURE THAT WE
01:15:54.316 --> 01:15:56.218
LOOK AT WHERE THE WILDLIFE IS
01:15:56.285 --> 01:15:58.487
CROSSING AND DEAL WITH THAT SO
01:15:58.553 --> 01:15:59.922
WE KNOW THAT THAT BETTER
01:15:59.988 --> 01:16:02.024
PLANNING WORKS AND NOT ONLY
01:16:02.090 --> 01:16:03.358
THAT, BUT THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
01:16:03.425 --> 01:16:05.127
HAS PUT A LOT OF MONEY UP
01:16:05.193 --> 01:16:05.694
TOWARDS WILDLIFE CROSSINGS
01:16:05.761 --> 01:16:07.262
ACROSS THE NATION IN CALIFORNIA
01:16:07.329 --> 01:16:09.431
WILL BE IN A MUCH BETTER PLACE
01:16:09.498 --> 01:16:10.565
TO COMPETE FOR THAT FEDERAL
01:16:10.632 --> 01:16:12.067
MONEY IF WE ALREADY HAVE ARE
01:16:12.134 --> 01:16:13.368
PLANNING WORK DONE. THIS BILL
01:16:13.435 --> 01:16:14.937
HAS ENJOYED WHILE WIDE
01:16:15.003 --> 01:16:16.505
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT, AND I WOULD
01:16:16.571 --> 01:16:17.906
ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT TODAY.
01:16:17.973 --> 01:16:20.008
TESTIFYING AND SUPPORT TODAY IS
01:16:20.075 --> 01:16:21.410
JULIE ANDERSON WITH THE MID
01:16:21.476 --> 01:16:22.544
PENINSULA REGIONAL OPEN SPACE
01:16:22.611 --> 01:16:25.113
DISTRICT BY PHONE. AND CHRIS
01:16:25.180 --> 01:16:26.148
WILMERS, WHO IS A WILDLIFE
01:16:26.214 --> 01:16:27.816
BIOLOGIST AND PROFESSOR AT UC
01:16:27.883 --> 01:16:31.320
SANTA CRUZ, ALSO BY PHONE. I
01:16:31.386 --> 01:16:32.654
GUESS, MRS ANDERSON, IF YOU'D
01:16:32.721 --> 01:16:33.822
LIKE TO PROCEED, PLEASE GO AHEAD
01:16:33.889 --> 01:16:37.259
ON THE CONFERENCE LINE. YES HI.
01:16:37.326 --> 01:16:38.694
THANK YOU. JULIE ANDERSON
01:16:38.760 --> 01:16:40.395
WILDLIFE PROGRAM LEAD WITH MID
01:16:40.462 --> 01:16:41.663
PENINSULA REGIONAL OPEN SPACE
01:16:41.730 --> 01:16:45.100
DISTRICT IN SUPPORT OF THIS ACT.
01:16:45.167 --> 01:16:46.702
MY AGENCY WORKS ON CONNECTIVITY
01:16:46.768 --> 01:16:49.137
FOR WILDLIFE FROM NEWTS. FROGS
01:16:49.204 --> 01:16:51.173
SNAKES, BADGERS, DEER AND
01:16:51.239 --> 01:16:52.441
MOUNTAIN LIONS AND ALL SPECIES
01:16:52.507 --> 01:16:55.310
NEED CONNECTIVITY. THE PROJECT
01:16:55.377 --> 01:16:57.446
MANAGER FOR THE HIGHWAY 17
01:16:57.512 --> 01:16:59.214
CROSSING PROJECTS WITH CALTRANS
01:16:59.281 --> 01:17:01.283
DISTRICT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF
01:17:01.350 --> 01:17:03.251
FISH AND WILDLIFE AND A HOT SPOT
01:17:03.318 --> 01:17:05.520
WHERE THE WILDLIFE THEIR INCOMES
01:17:05.587 --> 01:17:07.522
ARE BEING RUN OVER AND IT'S SO
01:17:07.589 --> 01:17:10.225
CLEARLY NEEDED, POSING A THREAT
01:17:10.292 --> 01:17:11.526
TO MOTORISTS ON THIS WINDING
01:17:11.593 --> 01:17:14.363
MOUNTAIN ROAD. IT'S A LOCAL
01:17:14.429 --> 01:17:15.964
ASSISTANCE PROJECT, MEANING THAT
01:17:16.031 --> 01:17:18.066
MY AGENCY, A LOCAL AGENCY,
01:17:18.133 --> 01:17:19.601
SPONSORING THE PROJECT, EVEN
01:17:19.668 --> 01:17:21.670
THOUGH THE BARRIER IS THE STATE
01:17:21.737 --> 01:17:23.271
HIGHWAY. CULTURE AND STAFF KNOWS
01:17:23.338 --> 01:17:25.007
HOW TO IMPROVE AND UPGRADE THEIR
01:17:25.073 --> 01:17:26.241
FACILITIES. THEY'RE EXCELLENT.
01:17:26.308 --> 01:17:27.809
THEY HAVE DESIGN STANDARDS AND
01:17:27.876 --> 01:17:30.145
MANUALS. AND YET IT'S CURRENTLY
01:17:30.212 --> 01:17:32.080
UP TO OUR AGENCY TO MAKE THESE
01:17:32.147 --> 01:17:33.181
IMPROVEMENTS ON THE STATE ROAD
01:17:33.248 --> 01:17:35.617
SYSTEM. THIS CURRENT PROCESSES
01:17:35.684 --> 01:17:37.586
INEFFICIENT OUTSIDE AGENCIES ARE
01:17:37.652 --> 01:17:39.121
NOT ALWAYS ABLE TO RECEIVE THOSE
01:17:39.187 --> 01:17:40.822
FEDERAL FUNDS, OFTEN THEIR
01:17:40.889 --> 01:17:41.757
DESIGNATED FOR TRANSPORTATION
01:17:41.823 --> 01:17:44.426
AGENCIES SUCH AS CALTRANS. THE
01:17:44.493 --> 01:17:46.094
CALTRANS PROCESS IS NOT ALWAYS
01:17:46.161 --> 01:17:48.063
KNOWN TO THESE OUTSIDE AGENCIES
01:17:48.130 --> 01:17:49.865
, WHICH AS TIME TO IMPLEMENT THE
01:17:49.931 --> 01:17:50.832
PROJECTS AND LEARN THOSE
01:17:50.899 --> 01:17:53.201
PROCESSES. THE ROAD DESIGNERS
01:17:53.268 --> 01:17:54.236
SHOULD BE THE ONES DOING THE
01:17:54.302 --> 01:17:56.038
ROAD DESIGN. CALTRANS HAS THE
01:17:56.104 --> 01:17:57.806
EXPERTISE THAT QUALIFIED THEY'RE
01:17:57.873 --> 01:17:59.775
ABLE TO LEAD. HOWEVER THEY NEED
01:17:59.841 --> 01:18:00.709
A MANDATE SO THAT THESE WILDLIFE
01:18:00.776 --> 01:18:02.811
CROSSINGS ARE PRIORITIZED.
01:18:02.878 --> 01:18:05.781
FUNDED AND IMPLEMENTED ROUTINELY
01:18:05.847 --> 01:18:07.682
NOT JUST OPPORTUNISTICALLY, OR
01:18:07.749 --> 01:18:08.917
ONLY IN AREAS WITH A WELL FUNDED
01:18:08.984 --> 01:18:11.286
PARTNER. CULTURES IS ALREADY
01:18:11.353 --> 01:18:12.387
REQUIRED TO DO THIS FOR FISH
01:18:12.454 --> 01:18:16.124
PASSAGE UNDER SP 8 57, IT ONLY
01:18:16.191 --> 01:18:18.160
MAKES SENSE TO DO IT FOR LAND
01:18:18.226 --> 01:18:19.528
BASED ANIMALS AS WELL. WE HAVE
01:18:19.594 --> 01:18:22.064
AN OPPORTUNITY TO LEAD SO THAT
01:18:22.130 --> 01:18:24.199
WE VIEW WILDLIFE CROSSINGS AS WE
01:18:24.266 --> 01:18:24.833
DRIVE ACROSS THE LANDSCAPE
01:18:24.900 --> 01:18:26.034
INSTEAD OF BEING DEAD ANIMALS ON
01:18:26.101 --> 01:18:28.670
THE ROADWAY SHOULDER. WHEN I
01:18:28.737 --> 01:18:30.639
ASKED MY 8.5 YEAR OLD WHY WE
01:18:30.705 --> 01:18:31.773
SHOULD SUPPORT CONNECTIVITY. SHE
01:18:31.840 --> 01:18:33.909
SUMMED IT UP PERFECTLY. WE DON'T
01:18:33.975 --> 01:18:35.377
WANT TRAFFIC OR CAR CRASHES AND
01:18:35.444 --> 01:18:36.511
WILDLIFE IS IMPORTANT TO THE
01:18:36.578 --> 01:18:39.848
WORLD. PLEASE SUPPORT THIS
01:18:39.915 --> 01:18:41.249
EFFORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:18:41.316 --> 01:18:42.150
PROFESSOR WILMERS, PLEASE
01:18:42.217 --> 01:18:48.890
PURSUIT. YEAH. THANK YOU, CHRIS
01:18:48.957 --> 01:18:50.092
WILMERS. I'M A PROFESSOR OF
01:18:50.158 --> 01:18:51.226
WILDLIFE. HE CALLED YOU AND
01:18:51.293 --> 01:18:52.294
CONSERVATION IN SANTA CRUZ. AS
01:18:52.360 --> 01:18:56.531
IN STUDYING LARGE CARNIVORES
01:18:56.598 --> 01:18:58.100
LIKE MOUNTAIN LIONS AND ANGULAR
01:18:58.166 --> 01:19:02.270
LIKE HERE FOR 25 YEARS NOW. UM
01:19:02.337 --> 01:19:05.040
AND CONNECTIVITY IS REALLY A
01:19:05.107 --> 01:19:07.409
STATEWIDE ISSUE THAT REQUIRES A
01:19:07.476 --> 01:19:09.177
STATEWIDE COMMITMENT TO
01:19:09.244 --> 01:19:09.778
IMPROVING AND ENHANCING
01:19:09.845 --> 01:19:11.079
CONNECTIVITY. IT EXISTING
01:19:11.146 --> 01:19:12.814
BARRIERS THAT EXIST BECAUSE OF
01:19:12.881 --> 01:19:16.418
THE STATE'S ROAD SYSTEM. THIS IS
01:19:16.485 --> 01:19:17.252
PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT FOR WIDE
01:19:17.319 --> 01:19:20.956
RANGING SPECIES LIKE LARGE
01:19:21.022 --> 01:19:21.890
CARNIVORES SUCH AS MOUNTAIN
01:19:21.957 --> 01:19:24.159
LIONS AND WOLVES, WHICH HAVE
01:19:24.226 --> 01:19:26.094
RECENTLY COME INTO THE STATE AS
01:19:26.161 --> 01:19:27.596
WELL AS FOR UNGULATES AND
01:19:27.662 --> 01:19:28.964
PARTICULARLY MIGRATORY ARGUMENTS
01:19:29.030 --> 01:19:32.400
BY DEER AND ELK. UM WHICH RELY
01:19:32.467 --> 01:19:33.468
ON THE CONNECTIVITY OF
01:19:33.535 --> 01:19:35.303
LANDSCAPES FOR THEIR SURVIVAL
01:19:35.370 --> 01:19:36.404
AND ALSO FOR THEIR GENETIC
01:19:36.471 --> 01:19:39.608
CONNECTIVITY AMONG POPULATIONS.
01:19:39.674 --> 01:19:41.443
UM IN THE SANTA CRUZ MOUNTAINS
01:19:41.510 --> 01:19:43.812
WHERE, AS IN STUDYING THAT
01:19:43.879 --> 01:19:47.215
ALLIANCE FOR ABOUT 15 YEARS NOW
01:19:47.282 --> 01:19:48.350
WE'VE DISCOVERED THAT THEY HAVE
01:19:48.416 --> 01:19:52.120
INCREDIBLY LOW GENETIC DIVERSITY
01:19:52.187 --> 01:19:54.156
DUE TO ROADS AND DEVELOPMENT,
01:19:54.222 --> 01:19:56.391
WHICH PREVENTS THEM FROM
01:19:56.458 --> 01:19:57.759
CONNECTING TO ADJACENT MOUNTAIN
01:19:57.826 --> 01:19:59.394
RANGES. AND THIS IS A PROBLEM
01:19:59.461 --> 01:20:01.396
THAT IS NOW YOU KNOW, REPLICATED
01:20:01.463 --> 01:20:04.199
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. UM THAT
01:20:04.266 --> 01:20:06.268
CURRENT ACTIONS AVAILABLE TO
01:20:06.334 --> 01:20:07.235
IMPROVE CONNECTIVITY THERE TOO
01:20:07.302 --> 01:20:09.204
FEW AND TOO SLOW. THERE ARE A
01:20:09.271 --> 01:20:12.974
COUPLE HIGH PROFILE. ROAD
01:20:13.041 --> 01:20:16.211
CROSSINGS THAT ARE UNDERWAY NOW
01:20:16.278 --> 01:20:17.712
ONE IN HIGHWAY 17 AND THE SANTA
01:20:17.779 --> 01:20:19.414
CRUZ MOUNTAINS AND THE OTHER BUT
01:20:19.481 --> 01:20:20.482
WALLIS ANNENBERG PROJECT AND
01:20:20.549 --> 01:20:24.719
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. BOTH. MANY
01:20:24.786 --> 01:20:27.222
YEARS, TWO DECADES AND, YOU KNOW
01:20:27.289 --> 01:20:29.324
IMMENSE POLITICAL PRESSURE TO
01:20:29.391 --> 01:20:31.660
MAKE HAPPEN. WE NEED A MORE
01:20:31.726 --> 01:20:32.561
PROACTIVE STATE MANDATE THAT
01:20:32.627 --> 01:20:35.797
MAKE THESE EFFORTS MORE EASILY
01:20:35.864 --> 01:20:39.201
REPLICABLE THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
01:20:39.267 --> 01:20:41.269
AND THEN MY FAIR. JUST WANT TO
01:20:41.336 --> 01:20:42.971
SAY THAT, UM, YOU KNOW, EVEN
01:20:43.038 --> 01:20:44.372
WHEN CALTRANS, UH, WANTS TO
01:20:44.439 --> 01:20:48.009
ENGAGE ON THESE PROJECTS UM,
01:20:48.076 --> 01:20:49.511
THEY OFTEN LACK THE PLANNING
01:20:49.578 --> 01:20:50.745
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION THAT MAKES
01:20:50.812 --> 01:20:53.415
IT DIFFICULT FOR THEM TO DO SO.
01:20:53.481 --> 01:20:55.584
AND TO PROACTIVELY ADDRESS THESE
01:20:55.650 --> 01:20:56.985
IMPEDIMENTS TO WILDLIFE
01:20:57.052 --> 01:20:58.420
MOVEMENT, IN CONTRAST, AS JULIE
01:20:58.486 --> 01:21:01.723
POINTED OUT AS THE 8 57
01:21:01.790 --> 01:21:03.291
CLARIFIES CULTURE AND DUTY TO
01:21:03.358 --> 01:21:05.260
LOCATE A STEPS AND REMEDIATE
01:21:05.327 --> 01:21:06.928
BARRIERS FOR FISH PASSAGE. IT
01:21:06.995 --> 01:21:08.997
WOULD BE GREAT TO DO THE SAME
01:21:09.064 --> 01:21:10.098
THING AFTER WILDLIFE. THAT'S
01:21:10.165 --> 01:21:14.369
THAT. YOU KNOW CALTRANS. HAS A
01:21:14.436 --> 01:21:16.638
DUTY TO REMEDIATE BARRIERS, BOTH
01:21:16.705 --> 01:21:18.273
FISH AND TO WILDLIFE AS WE'RE
01:21:18.340 --> 01:21:19.674
PROPOSING, AND THIS NEW BILL.
01:21:19.741 --> 01:21:24.312
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.
01:21:24.379 --> 01:21:25.914
LET'S UH, STANDING COMMITTEE
01:21:25.981 --> 01:21:27.515
HEARING ROOM. IS THERE ANYBODY
01:21:27.582 --> 01:21:28.550
HERE LIKE TESTIFYING SUPPORT OF
01:21:28.617 --> 01:21:32.153
THE MEASURE? 23 44. SEEING NONE.
01:21:32.220 --> 01:21:38.426
SEEING. ONE MR. CHAIR JOHN
01:21:38.493 --> 01:21:39.794
MOFFITT ON BEHALF OF A CC,
01:21:39.861 --> 01:21:41.796
CALIFORNIA WE'RE KIND OF AN IN
01:21:41.863 --> 01:21:43.632
BETWEEN HER SUPPORTIVE AMENDED
01:21:43.698 --> 01:21:45.166
AND I DON'T KNOW IF NOW IS THE
01:21:45.233 --> 01:21:47.068
APPROPRIATE TIME OR IF I SHOULD
01:21:47.135 --> 01:21:50.372
WAIT. UM LET'S DO IT NOW. YOU
01:21:50.438 --> 01:21:52.974
KNOW, THE BILL REQUIRES THAT NEW
01:21:53.041 --> 01:21:56.044
PROJECTS NOT BE CONSTRUCTED OR
01:21:56.111 --> 01:21:57.712
MUST BE CONSTRUCTED SO THEY
01:21:57.779 --> 01:21:59.581
DON'T PRESENT A BARRIER OF FISH
01:21:59.648 --> 01:22:00.615
AND WILDLIFE MOVEMENT. OUR
01:22:00.682 --> 01:22:02.651
CONCERN IS WHAT ABOUT THE
01:22:02.717 --> 01:22:04.219
INSTANCE WHERE IT IS IMPOSSIBLE
01:22:04.286 --> 01:22:05.553
TO DESIGN OR CONSTRUCTIVE
01:22:05.620 --> 01:22:07.255
PROJECT THAT WAY. WE BELIEVE THE
01:22:07.322 --> 01:22:09.658
BILL SHOULD HAVE, UH OUT OR AN
01:22:09.724 --> 01:22:11.593
EXEMPTION IN SOME MANNER FOR
01:22:11.660 --> 01:22:13.695
THOSE TYPES OF PROJECTS. AND
01:22:13.762 --> 01:22:15.030
AGAIN WE HAVE A SPORT
01:22:15.096 --> 01:22:16.197
SUPPORTIVE, AMENDED POSITION ON
01:22:16.264 --> 01:22:18.667
THE BILL. APPRECIATE THAT. LET'S
01:22:18.733 --> 01:22:20.201
GO TO THE TELECONFERENCE, MR
01:22:20.268 --> 01:22:21.102
MODERATOR OF THIS INTEGRATING
01:22:21.169 --> 01:22:22.737
THE LINE. YOU'D LIKE TESTIFYING
01:22:22.804 --> 01:22:23.371
SUPPORT WITH THE NAME
01:22:23.438 --> 01:22:24.539
AFFILIATION AND THEIR POSITION.
01:22:24.606 --> 01:22:28.243
UNABLE 23-14 FOUR, PLEASE. OF
01:22:28.310 --> 01:22:30.345
COURSE, IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT,
01:22:30.412 --> 01:22:34.049
PLEASE PRESS 10. WE'LL GO TO
01:22:34.115 --> 01:22:38.386
LINE 1 11, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:22:38.453 --> 01:22:39.921
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS KIM
01:22:39.988 --> 01:22:41.990
DELFINO AND I'M REPRESENTING THE
01:22:42.057 --> 01:22:43.558
FUTURE DOUBLE TRUST CALIFORNIA
01:22:43.625 --> 01:22:44.659
NEED TO PLANT SOCIETY, DEFENDERS
01:22:44.726 --> 01:22:46.828
OF WILDLIFE AND THE SONOMA LAND
01:22:46.895 --> 01:22:48.930
TRUST IN SUPPORT OF A B 23 44.
01:22:48.997 --> 01:22:50.031
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:22:50.098 --> 01:22:54.469
PLEASE. WELL NEXT TO THE LINE. 1
01:22:54.536 --> 01:22:57.305
12, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
01:22:57.372 --> 01:22:58.006
JENNIFER HAGUE WITH THE ANIMAL
01:22:58.073 --> 01:23:00.375
LEGAL DEFENSE FUND IN SUPPORT.
01:23:00.442 --> 01:23:03.945
THANK YOU NEXT WEEK. NEXT GO TO
01:23:04.012 --> 01:23:08.116
LINE 1 10, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:23:08.183 --> 01:23:09.884
AFTERNOON. CHRISTINA'S ORANGE
01:23:09.951 --> 01:23:10.352
WITH ANIMAL DEFENDERS
01:23:10.418 --> 01:23:11.720
INTERNATIONAL OUT OF LOS ANGELES
01:23:11.786 --> 01:23:12.821
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:23:12.887 --> 01:23:17.125
PLEASE. NEXT LINE. 94, PLEASE GO
01:23:17.192 --> 01:23:30.105
AHEAD. 94 YEARS. LINE IT UP.
01:23:30.171 --> 01:23:31.840
GOOD AFTERNOON, ELENA ORTIZ ON
01:23:31.906 --> 01:23:33.274
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA STATE PARKS
01:23:33.341 --> 01:23:34.376
FOUNDATION AND RDP ACTION
01:23:34.442 --> 01:23:35.744
FINDING SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT,
01:23:35.810 --> 01:23:41.516
PLEASE. NEXT GO TO LINE 1 17,
01:23:41.583 --> 01:23:45.286
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
01:23:45.353 --> 01:23:46.521
SANTIAGO RODRIGUEZ WITH
01:23:46.588 --> 01:23:47.455
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS
01:23:47.522 --> 01:23:54.763
AND SUPPORT YEAH. NEXT, PLEASE.
01:23:54.829 --> 01:23:55.864
AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY NONE OTHER
01:23:55.930 --> 01:23:59.300
IN THE KETO. VERY GOOD. LET'S
01:23:59.367 --> 01:24:01.069
COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:24:01.136 --> 01:24:02.003
HEARING. WAS ANYBODY HERE LIKE
01:24:02.070 --> 01:24:03.772
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
01:24:03.838 --> 01:24:10.278
BILL 23-14 FOR PLEASE, MR WATTS.
01:24:10.345 --> 01:24:11.413
NEED A MICROPHONE FOR THEM.
01:24:11.479 --> 01:24:21.623
GALLERY, PLEASE. HELLO. TRY TRY
01:24:21.689 --> 01:24:26.761
AGAIN, MR MARSHALL. UH, PARDON
01:24:26.828 --> 01:24:31.199
ME CHAIR. AND MEMBERS THAT MY
01:24:31.266 --> 01:24:32.467
NAME IS MARK WATTS. I'M HERE
01:24:32.534 --> 01:24:33.435
TODAY REPRESENTING
01:24:33.501 --> 01:24:34.636
TRANSPORTATION, CALIFORNIA. AND
01:24:34.702 --> 01:24:36.204
INDUSTRY GROUP THAT WORKS WITH
01:24:36.271 --> 01:24:38.206
THAT IS ALLIED WITH THE INDUSTRY
01:24:38.273 --> 01:24:39.207
AND WORKFORCE THAT BUILDS AND
01:24:39.274 --> 01:24:40.208
MAINTAINS CALIFORNIA'S
01:24:40.275 --> 01:24:42.343
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM. WE ARE IN
01:24:42.410 --> 01:24:44.279
A POSITION OF OPPOSING LIST
01:24:44.345 --> 01:24:46.481
AMENDED. WE ARE LOOKING AT THE
01:24:46.548 --> 01:24:47.882
SAME CODE SECTION THAT THE
01:24:47.949 --> 01:24:51.252
PREVIOUS TWITTER WAS LOOKING AT.
01:24:51.319 --> 01:24:52.854
AND WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE
01:24:52.921 --> 01:24:55.089
MANDATE THAT HAS BEEN EXPANDED
01:24:55.156 --> 01:24:57.125
THERE WILL NOW COVER NEW
01:24:57.192 --> 01:24:58.593
PROJECTS FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO
01:24:58.660 --> 01:25:00.562
EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE. WOULD
01:25:00.628 --> 01:25:03.064
RESULT IN ADDITIONAL MANDATED
01:25:03.131 --> 01:25:05.233
COSTS ON THE DEPARTMENT WITHOUT
01:25:05.300 --> 01:25:06.801
UNDERSTANDING WHAT THE LONG
01:25:06.868 --> 01:25:08.369
RANGE COSTS ARE COST
01:25:08.436 --> 01:25:09.304
IMPLICATIONS ARE FOR PROVIDING
01:25:09.370 --> 01:25:11.840
ALL THE CONNECTIVITY CORRIDORS.
01:25:11.906 --> 01:25:13.341
WE THINK THAT CONNECTIVITY
01:25:13.408 --> 01:25:15.376
PLANNING PROCESS THAT'S THE
01:25:15.443 --> 01:25:17.712
BASIC PART OF THIS BILL SHOULD
01:25:17.779 --> 01:25:18.947
BE COMPLETED FIRST AND THEN AT
01:25:19.013 --> 01:25:21.149
SOME FUTURE DATE, COME BCK WHEN
01:25:21.216 --> 01:25:21.983
WITH MANDATES WHEN WE KNOW HOW
01:25:22.050 --> 01:25:24.452
MUCH IT'S GOING TO COST US. SO
01:25:24.519 --> 01:25:25.620
FOR THOSE REASONS, WE'RE ASKING
01:25:25.687 --> 01:25:26.688
THAT THAT SECTION BE DELETED.
01:25:26.754 --> 01:25:28.122
AND THE REST OF THE BILL. MOVE
01:25:28.189 --> 01:25:30.291
ON AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:25:30.358 --> 01:25:30.925
AFTERNOON FOR YOUR ATTENTION.
01:25:30.992 --> 01:25:33.294
SEVEN. THANK YOU. THAT'S RIGHT.
01:25:33.361 --> 01:25:35.463
I'M TOLD THAT WE HAVE A QUORUM
01:25:35.530 --> 01:25:38.566
IN THE HEARING ROOM, SO LET US
01:25:38.633 --> 01:25:40.502
CALL THE ROLL AND ESTABLISH A
01:25:40.568 --> 01:25:44.105
QUORUM. MISS WHITE IF YOU COULD
01:25:44.172 --> 01:25:44.839
SENATORS. NEWMAN NEWMAN,
01:25:44.906 --> 01:25:47.175
PRESIDENT BATES BATES PRESENT,
01:25:47.242 --> 01:25:50.378
ALAN. ALLEN PRESIDENT
01:25:50.445 --> 01:25:54.449
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. BECKER,
01:25:54.516 --> 01:26:00.488
PRESIDENT CORTEZ. SALLY. DAD.
01:26:00.555 --> 01:26:03.491
DATA HERE. HERZBERG LIMÓN. LIMÓN
01:26:03.558 --> 01:26:06.794
HERE, ACQUIRE. MELINDA'S
01:26:06.861 --> 01:26:08.930
MELINDA'S HERE, MEN. MEN HERE,
01:26:08.997 --> 01:26:15.270
RUBIO. SKINNER. WIECKOWSKI. WILK
01:26:15.336 --> 01:26:17.572
PRESIDENT PRESIDENT SO WE DO
01:26:17.639 --> 01:26:19.841
HAVE A QUORUM PRESENT. LET'S GO
01:26:19.908 --> 01:26:21.876
BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE,
01:26:21.943 --> 01:26:23.044
MR MODERATOR, IF THERE'S ANYBODY
01:26:23.111 --> 01:26:25.079
IN THE TELECONFERENCE ON WISHING
01:26:25.146 --> 01:26:26.214
JUST WRITE IN OPPOSITION TO THE
01:26:26.281 --> 01:26:31.452
BILL. OF COURSE, THERE ARE ANY
01:26:31.519 --> 01:26:35.490
IN OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10.
01:26:35.557 --> 01:26:42.430
AND THAT IS YOUR BABY 23-14 FOR. WE'VE GOT A LINE 59. PLEASE GO
01:26:42.497 --> 01:26:48.069
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON AGAIN.
01:26:48.136 --> 01:26:50.004
THIS IS MATTHEW BAKER, WHO WAS
01:26:50.071 --> 01:26:51.205
PLAYING CONSERVATION LEAGUE. I
01:26:51.272 --> 01:26:53.007
APOLOGIZE. I DID NOT
01:26:53.074 --> 01:26:54.909
SUCCESSFULLY GET IN THE LAST FEW
01:26:54.976 --> 01:26:56.844
WERE IN SUPPORT AT 23 44. THANK
01:26:56.911 --> 01:26:59.147
YOU. IS ANYBODY WISHING TO TRY
01:26:59.213 --> 01:27:06.120
AND OPPOSITION? THEY'RE
01:27:06.187 --> 01:27:09.524
CURRENTLY DONE IN THE QUEUE.
01:27:09.591 --> 01:27:11.192
OKAY LET'S COME BACK TO THE
01:27:11.259 --> 01:27:13.494
COMMITTEE ROOM MEMBERS ANY
01:27:13.561 --> 01:27:14.729
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THE
01:27:14.796 --> 01:27:20.635
BILL? SAYING NONE. THE BILL HAS
01:27:20.702 --> 01:27:22.103
A RECOMMENDATION FROM THE CHAIR
01:27:22.170 --> 01:27:24.172
OF D<c.cyan>PAST APPROPRIATIONS</c>
01:27:24.238 --> 01:27:25.673
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDS THAT THE
01:27:25.740 --> 01:27:26.741
AUTHOR CONTINUES TO DISCUSS
01:27:26.808 --> 01:27:28.076
AMENDMENTS WITH THE OPPOSITION
01:27:28.142 --> 01:27:30.345
AND CAL TRANSFERRED TO ADDRESS
01:27:30.411 --> 01:27:31.312
SOME OF THE CONCERNS RAISED WITH
01:27:31.379 --> 01:27:33.114
THE LAST PROVISIONS OF BILL.
01:27:33.181 --> 01:27:35.249
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN. UM
01:27:35.316 --> 01:27:37.218
ARE YOU COMMITTED TO FURTHER
01:27:37.285 --> 01:27:38.286
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE OPPOSITION
01:27:38.353 --> 01:27:41.522
AND WITH CALTRANS? YES WE ARE
01:27:41.589 --> 01:27:43.124
GOOD TO HEAR IF YOU'D LIKE TO
01:27:43.191 --> 01:27:45.593
CLOSE, PLEASE, JUST TO CLARIFY
01:27:45.660 --> 01:27:48.062
THAT THIS BILL DOES NOT PANED.
01:27:48.129 --> 01:27:49.998
ANY FUNDING OR HIGHWAYS. THIS
01:27:50.064 --> 01:27:51.566
IS A SET UP AN ADDITIONAL
01:27:51.633 --> 01:27:53.301
PROGRAM TO GIVE MONEY TO
01:27:53.368 --> 01:27:54.936
PROJECTS FOR WILDLIFE MITIGATION
01:27:55.003 --> 01:27:56.671
, SO IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT'S
01:27:56.738 --> 01:27:58.006
GOING TO BLOCK CONSTRUCTION OF
01:27:58.072 --> 01:27:59.974
NEW PROJECTS AND IT'S ALREADY IN
01:28:00.041 --> 01:28:01.009
CALTRANS MANDATE. WE'RE TRYING
01:28:01.075 --> 01:28:03.978
TO HAVE A MORE FORMALIZED WAY OF
01:28:04.045 --> 01:28:05.146
LOOKING AT THE PLACES WHERE WE
01:28:05.213 --> 01:28:06.447
REALLY NEED TO DO THIS,
01:28:06.514 --> 01:28:07.248
OBVIOUSLY NOT EVERY ROAD, BUT
01:28:07.315 --> 01:28:09.017
THERE ARE CERTAIN PLACES THAT
01:28:09.083 --> 01:28:10.184
ARE MIGRATORY. PATHS FOR
01:28:10.251 --> 01:28:11.519
ANIMALS, AND THE IDEA HERE IS
01:28:11.586 --> 01:28:14.589
JUST TO GET TO CALTRANS LIST
01:28:14.656 --> 01:28:15.490
THOSE ACROSS THE STATE AND THEN
01:28:15.556 --> 01:28:17.692
TO HAVE RESOURCES SET UP TO HELP
01:28:17.759 --> 01:28:19.394
MITIGATE, UM, CONSTRUCTION THAT
01:28:19.460 --> 01:28:21.029
IMPACTS THE ABILITY OF THOSE
01:28:21.095 --> 01:28:21.863
MIGRATING ANIMALS TO MIGRATE
01:28:21.929 --> 01:28:23.931
AGAIN. NOT JUST FOR THE HEALTH
01:28:23.998 --> 01:28:25.433
OF OUR WILDLIFE, WHICH WE CARE
01:28:25.500 --> 01:28:27.235
DEEPLY ABOUT IN CALIFORNIA, BUT
01:28:27.301 --> 01:28:28.436
ALSO TO PROTECT HUMAN LIFE FROM
01:28:28.503 --> 01:28:29.604
COLLISIONS ON THE HIGHWAYS,
01:28:29.671 --> 01:28:31.506
WHICH WE SEE FAR TOO OFTEN
01:28:31.572 --> 01:28:33.007
ACROSS THE STATE. AND OF COURSE,
01:28:33.074 --> 01:28:34.609
WE WILL CONTINUE TO TALK WITH
01:28:34.676 --> 01:28:35.943
THE OPPOSITION TO ADDRESS THEIR
01:28:36.010 --> 01:28:36.811
CONCERNS. AND WE'RE COMMITTED TO
01:28:36.878 --> 01:28:38.579
DOING THAT. AND I WOULD REQUEST
01:28:38.646 --> 01:28:40.415
AN AYE. VOTE THANK YOU. THANK
01:28:40.481 --> 01:28:41.616
YOU. AND WITH THAT, MISS WHITE
01:28:41.683 --> 01:28:43.451
IF YOU COULD CALL THE ROLL. THE
01:28:43.518 --> 01:28:44.218
CHAIRS, RECOMMENDATION IS DO
01:28:44.285 --> 01:28:46.020
PASS AND REFER TO THE COMMITTEE
01:28:46.087 --> 01:28:47.121
AND APPROPRIATION. DO WE HAVE
01:28:47.188 --> 01:28:49.090
EMOTIONAL APOLOGIZE? I'VE GOT A
01:28:49.157 --> 01:28:50.324
MOTION FROM SENATOR DOT
01:28:50.391 --> 01:28:55.129
APPRECIATE. FILE ITEM NUMBER 10
01:28:55.196 --> 01:28:58.800
A B 2344 SENATORS NEWMAN HI, I
01:28:58.866 --> 01:29:03.604
BATES BATES, I, ALAN. ALAN I
01:29:03.671 --> 01:29:07.508
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. BECKER. I
01:29:07.575 --> 01:29:13.881
ORTEZ. SALLY. DODD. THAT I
01:29:13.948 --> 01:29:18.152
HERZBERG LIMÓN. LIMÓN, AYE
01:29:18.219 --> 01:29:21.823
MCGUIRE, MELINDA'S MEN. MOMENT.
01:29:21.889 --> 01:29:25.393
I RUBIO SKINNER. WIECKOWSKI
01:29:25.460 --> 01:29:34.669
WILK. THEIR OWN. THAT CURRENTLY
01:29:34.736 --> 01:29:36.504
SEVEN VOTES TO ZERO WILL KEEP
01:29:36.571 --> 01:29:39.307
THAT OPEN. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WE
01:29:39.373 --> 01:29:40.975
SEEM TO BE ON A ROLL. LET'S TAKE
01:29:41.042 --> 01:29:42.176
ADVANTAGE OF THIS MOMENTUM.
01:29:42.243 --> 01:29:43.911
PLEASE PROCEED WITH 27 46. THANK
01:29:43.978 --> 01:29:45.213
YOU. ALAS, IT'S MY LAST BILL
01:29:45.279 --> 01:29:47.548
TODAY WITH YOU HERE AND PLEASED
01:29:47.615 --> 01:29:50.017
TO PRESENT 27 46, WHICH WILL
01:29:50.084 --> 01:29:51.586
REDUCE RACIAL AND WEALTH BASED
01:29:51.652 --> 01:29:53.121
DISPARITIES. IN FACT,
01:29:53.187 --> 01:29:54.555
ENFORCEMENT OF MINOR TRAFFIC
01:29:54.622 --> 01:29:55.656
LAWS WHILE MAINTAINING ROAD
01:29:55.723 --> 01:29:57.658
SAFETY BY MAKING THE FOLLOWING
01:29:57.725 --> 01:29:58.659
POLICY CHANGES BEGINNING IN
01:29:58.726 --> 01:30:01.729
2027. ELIMINATING LICENSE
01:30:01.796 --> 01:30:02.730
SUSPENSIONS BASED ONLY ON
01:30:02.797 --> 01:30:06.100
FAILURE TO APPEAR IN COURT. AND
01:30:06.167 --> 01:30:07.335
MAKING THE FIRST TWO OFFENSES
01:30:07.401 --> 01:30:08.302
AND INFRACTION FOR DRIVING
01:30:08.369 --> 01:30:10.371
WITHOUT A LICENSE. THESE
01:30:10.438 --> 01:30:11.706
RECOMMENDATIONS COME FROM THE
01:30:11.773 --> 01:30:13.107
COMMITTEE ON REVISION OF THE
01:30:13.174 --> 01:30:14.709
PENAL CODE. THESE OFFENSES ARE
01:30:14.776 --> 01:30:16.277
PRIMARILY FINANCIAL IN NATURE
01:30:16.344 --> 01:30:18.312
AND ARE NOT CONNECTED TO UNSAFE
01:30:18.379 --> 01:30:19.947
DRIVING. SO TO BE CLEAR THIS IS
01:30:20.014 --> 01:30:21.482
NOT AFFECT PEOPLE WHOSE LICENSES
01:30:21.549 --> 01:30:23.151
WERE SUSPENDED FOR RECKLESS
01:30:23.217 --> 01:30:25.019
DRIVING D<c.cyan>!I ANY OF THOSE TYPES</c>
01:30:25.086 --> 01:30:26.988
OF OFFENSES. TESTIFYING AND
01:30:27.054 --> 01:30:28.689
SUPPORT THIS AFTERNOON, IT'S
01:30:28.756 --> 01:30:29.924
DISTRICT ATTORNEY DIANA BECKTON
01:30:29.991 --> 01:30:31.726
OF CONTRA COSTA AND THAILAND.
01:30:31.793 --> 01:30:32.927
NICOLE SMITH WITH LEGAL AID
01:30:32.994 --> 01:30:34.662
FOUNDATION OF LOS ANGELES TO BE
01:30:34.729 --> 01:30:36.564
CLEAR THIS BILL HAS RECEIVED
01:30:36.631 --> 01:30:37.632
BROAD SUPPORT FROM SOCIAL AND
01:30:37.698 --> 01:30:39.634
CRIMINAL JUSTICE GROUPS AND HAS
01:30:39.700 --> 01:30:41.102
NO REGISTERED OPPOSITION. AND
01:30:41.169 --> 01:30:43.471
THIS IS TO MAKE SURE THAT PEOPLE
01:30:43.538 --> 01:30:44.005
WHO DON'T APPEAR IN COURT
01:30:44.071 --> 01:30:45.606
BECAUSE MANY TIMES THEY ACTUALLY
01:30:45.673 --> 01:30:47.141
DON'T REALIZE THAT THAT'S A
01:30:47.208 --> 01:30:48.709
REQUIREMENT. THEY THINK ALL JUST
01:30:48.776 --> 01:30:49.977
PAY A TICKET WHEN IT COMES SO
01:30:50.044 --> 01:30:52.413
THEY DON'T SHOW UP OR THEY'RE
01:30:52.480 --> 01:30:53.080
WORKING OR CAN'T FIND CHILDCARE
01:30:53.147 --> 01:30:55.283
OR SOME OTHER REASON THEY DON'T
01:30:55.349 --> 01:30:56.484
APPEAR IN COURT, EVEN IF THEY
01:30:56.551 --> 01:30:59.187
ARE VERY WILLING TO DO THAT. UM
01:30:59.253 --> 01:31:01.189
TO PAY THE TICKET AND THEN, AS A
01:31:01.255 --> 01:31:02.323
RESULT, THEY GET THEIR LICENSE
01:31:02.390 --> 01:31:03.691
SUSPENDED AND OFTEN DON'T EVEN
01:31:03.758 --> 01:31:05.259
KNOW THAT THEIR LICENSE WAS
01:31:05.326 --> 01:31:06.194
SUSPENDED. AND AFTER THAT, THEY
01:31:06.260 --> 01:31:08.229
GET PULLED OVER AND THINGS
01:31:08.296 --> 01:31:08.830
ESCALATE. THE NEXT THING YOU
01:31:08.896 --> 01:31:09.897
KNOW, THEY'RE IN A FINANCIAL
01:31:09.964 --> 01:31:11.766
DEEP FINANCIAL HOLE BECAUSE OF
01:31:11.833 --> 01:31:13.034
THEIR INABILITY TO PAY AND THIS
01:31:13.100 --> 01:31:14.936
HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH KEEPING
01:31:15.002 --> 01:31:16.037
OUR ROADS SAFE. IT'S PURELY
01:31:16.103 --> 01:31:17.505
PUNITIVE. SO I WOULD APPRECIATE
01:31:17.572 --> 01:31:18.606
YOUR THOUGHTFUL CONSIDERATION OF
01:31:18.673 --> 01:31:19.774
THIS BILL AND I WOULD EMPLOY YOU
01:31:19.841 --> 01:31:21.475
TO VOTE I TODAY. THANK YOU.
01:31:21.542 --> 01:31:23.077
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MISS
01:31:23.144 --> 01:31:25.246
BECKTON. UH IF I THINK SHE'S
01:31:25.313 --> 01:31:26.380
WENT ON THE LINE, PLEASE
01:31:26.447 --> 01:31:31.285
PROCEED. YES. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:31:31.352 --> 01:31:32.720
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. DINA BECKTON
01:31:32.787 --> 01:31:34.322
HERE, DISTRICT ATTORNEY FOR
01:31:34.388 --> 01:31:35.923
CONTRA CLASSIC COUNTY AND FORMER
01:31:35.990 --> 01:31:37.225
PRESIDING JUDGE OF THE CONTRA
01:31:37.291 --> 01:31:39.427
COSTA COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT HERE
01:31:39.493 --> 01:31:43.197
IN SUPPORT OF A B 27 46. WHICH
01:31:43.264 --> 01:31:45.299
WILL REQUIRE DRIVING WITHOUT
01:31:45.366 --> 01:31:47.168
POSSESSION OF A LICENSE TO BE
01:31:47.235 --> 01:31:49.370
CHARGED AS AN INFRACTION FOR THE
01:31:49.437 --> 01:31:51.439
FIRST TWO VIOLATIONS. AND IN
01:31:51.505 --> 01:31:52.440
LICENSE SUSPENSIONS FOR FAILURE
01:31:52.506 --> 01:31:55.610
TO APPEAR IN COURT. UNDER THE
01:31:55.676 --> 01:31:57.778
CURRENT LAW, PERSONS LICENSED TO
01:31:57.845 --> 01:32:00.348
DRIVE CAN BE SUSPENDED SIMPLY
01:32:00.414 --> 01:32:01.716
BECAUSE THEY FEEL TO APPEAR.
01:32:01.782 --> 01:32:03.885
THIS IS COUNTERPRODUCTIVE AND
01:32:03.951 --> 01:32:05.753
INEFFECTIVE WAY TO GET PEOPLE TO
01:32:05.820 --> 01:32:08.589
SHOW UP FOR COURT. WHEN WE TAKE
01:32:08.656 --> 01:32:10.091
AWAY THEIR ABILITY TO LEGALLY
01:32:10.157 --> 01:32:13.127
DRIVE, WE MAKE IT MORE DIFFICULT
01:32:13.194 --> 01:32:14.896
FOR THEM TO COME TO COURT, AND
01:32:14.962 --> 01:32:15.930
THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO EVIDENCE
01:32:15.997 --> 01:32:17.131
THAT THE THREAT OF LICENSE
01:32:17.198 --> 01:32:19.200
SUSPENSION WORKS TO GET PEOPLE
01:32:19.267 --> 01:32:23.204
TO COURT. THE PRACTICE IS JUST
01:32:23.271 --> 01:32:24.472
INEFFECTIVE AND IT ENDANGERS
01:32:24.538 --> 01:32:27.275
PUBLIC SAFETY. WHEN WE SUSPEND A
01:32:27.341 --> 01:32:29.243
LICENSE FOR TECHNICAL REASONS,
01:32:29.310 --> 01:32:30.978
LIKE FAILURE TO APPEAR MANY
01:32:31.045 --> 01:32:33.748
PEOPLE CONTINUE TO DRIVE ANYWAY
01:32:33.814 --> 01:32:35.416
, BUT THEY LOSE THEIR INSURANCE
01:32:35.483 --> 01:32:36.884
COVERAGE AS A RESULT OF THIS
01:32:36.951 --> 01:32:38.052
SUSPENSION, AND THIS MAKES
01:32:38.119 --> 01:32:39.987
PEOPLE MORE LIKELY TO FEED THE
01:32:40.054 --> 01:32:42.290
SCENE OF AN SO IT'S IN THE
01:32:42.356 --> 01:32:44.425
INTEREST OF HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
01:32:44.492 --> 01:32:45.693
THE COMMUNITY THAT EVERYONE WHO
01:32:45.760 --> 01:32:49.964
DRIVES THE LIFE AND ENSURE. A B
01:32:50.031 --> 01:32:52.366
27 46 WILL ALSO MAKE THE FIRST
01:32:52.433 --> 01:32:53.634
TWO VIOLATIONS FOR DRIVING
01:32:53.701 --> 01:32:54.969
WITHOUT POSSESSION OF A LICENSE
01:32:55.036 --> 01:32:56.704
AND INFRACTION RATHER THAN AN
01:32:56.771 --> 01:32:58.739
OFFENSE THAT CAN BE CHARGED AS A
01:32:58.806 --> 01:33:00.675
MISDEMEANOR. THE REASON MANY
01:33:00.741 --> 01:33:02.376
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S LIKE MYSELF
01:33:02.443 --> 01:33:04.211
NOW CHARGED, DRIVING WITHOUT
01:33:04.278 --> 01:33:05.212
POSSESSION OF A LICENSE AS
01:33:05.279 --> 01:33:07.214
INFRACTIONS IS THAT THIS
01:33:07.281 --> 01:33:08.983
BEHAVIOR IS NOT ASSOCIATED WITH
01:33:09.050 --> 01:33:10.451
DANGEROUS DRIVING OR EVEN PUBLIC
01:33:10.518 --> 01:33:14.088
SAFETY. MORE BROADLY, IT IS
01:33:14.155 --> 01:33:15.790
ASSOCIATED WITH POVERTY AND
01:33:15.856 --> 01:33:16.757
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTS BLACK
01:33:16.824 --> 01:33:19.827
AND LATINO PEOPLE. THE COMMITTEE
01:33:19.894 --> 01:33:21.562
ON REVISION OF THE PENAL CODE
01:33:21.629 --> 01:33:22.964
RECOMMENDS THIS CHANGE IN THE
01:33:23.030 --> 01:33:24.966
LAW BECAUSE OF THE NEGATIVE
01:33:25.032 --> 01:33:26.667
IMPACTS THAT MISDEMEANOR CHARGES
01:33:26.734 --> 01:33:28.035
HAVE ON SUCH A LARGE NUMBER OF
01:33:28.102 --> 01:33:30.304
PEOPLE. THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR
01:33:30.371 --> 01:33:32.373
TIME THIS AFTERNOON AND I ASKED
01:33:32.440 --> 01:33:35.109
FOR YOUR A VOTE. ON A B 27 46.
01:33:35.176 --> 01:33:38.646
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
01:33:38.713 --> 01:33:40.748
WITNESS IS MISS SMITH FROM LEGAL
01:33:40.815 --> 01:33:42.083
OUTFIT ILLEGAL AID FOUNDATION.
01:33:42.149 --> 01:33:43.284
LOS ANGELES. PLEASE PURSUE. YOU
01:33:43.351 --> 01:33:47.154
HAVE TWO MINUTES. THANK YOU.
01:33:47.221 --> 01:33:48.489
GOOD AFTERNOON COMMITTEE MEMBERS
01:33:48.556 --> 01:33:50.157
. MY NAME IS NICOLE, MANAGING
01:33:50.224 --> 01:33:51.993
ATTORNEY AT THE LEGAL AID
01:33:52.059 --> 01:33:53.761
OUNDATION OF LOS ANGELES FOCUS
01:33:53.828 --> 01:33:55.229
PRIMARILY ON TRAFFIC AND POST
01:33:55.296 --> 01:33:56.931
CONVICTION RELIEF. AND I M HERE
01:33:56.998 --> 01:34:00.134
TODAY IN SUPPORT A BABY 27 46.
01:34:00.201 --> 01:34:03.537
UM PREVIOUSLY STATUS. MOST OF
01:34:03.604 --> 01:34:05.539
THE FOLKS WHO THIS CURRENT LAW
01:34:05.606 --> 01:34:08.476
IMPACT THE MOST HAPPENED TO BE
01:34:08.542 --> 01:34:09.944
THOSE WHO ARE A LITTLE INCOME,
01:34:10.011 --> 01:34:11.312
MANY OF WHOM ARE BLACK AND
01:34:11.379 --> 01:34:12.413
BROWN, WHO HAVE STRUGGLED TO
01:34:12.480 --> 01:34:13.547
OVERCOME THE COLLATERAL
01:34:13.614 --> 01:34:15.182
CONSEQUENCES AND TRAUMA THAT ARE
01:34:15.249 --> 01:34:16.784
ASSOCIATED WITH A CRIMINAL
01:34:16.851 --> 01:34:17.785
CONVICTION AND THE LICENSE
01:34:17.852 --> 01:34:19.520
SUSPENSION. THESE INDIVIDUALS
01:34:19.587 --> 01:34:21.789
ARE NOT FOLKS WHO ARE A DANGER
01:34:21.856 --> 01:34:23.090
OR RISK THEIR COMMUNITIES OR
01:34:23.157 --> 01:34:24.925
SOCIETY AT LARGE. THEY ARE
01:34:24.992 --> 01:34:26.227
REGULAR, HARDWORKING PEOPLE
01:34:26.293 --> 01:34:28.562
TRYING TO DO WHAT THEY NEED TO
01:34:28.629 --> 01:34:29.163
DO TO SURVIVE ACTIONS LIKE A
01:34:29.230 --> 01:34:30.331
CRIMINAL CONVICTION AND OUR
01:34:30.398 --> 01:34:33.067
LICENSE SUSPENSION. CANNOT AN
01:34:33.134 --> 01:34:35.202
ALREADY UNSTABLE INDIVIDUAL AND
01:34:35.269 --> 01:34:37.238
FAMILY FURTHER OUT OF BLACK AND
01:34:37.304 --> 01:34:38.339
SWITCH THEM FARTHER AWAY FROM
01:34:38.406 --> 01:34:41.575
CIVILITY. WHERE LICENSES ARE
01:34:41.642 --> 01:34:43.411
CONCERNS AS PREVIOUSLY STATED
01:34:43.477 --> 01:34:44.779
THE SUSPENSION OF A LICENSE
01:34:44.845 --> 01:34:47.114
PLACES EVEN MORE CONSTRAINTS ON
01:34:47.181 --> 01:34:48.616
ALREADY STRAPPED PERSON OR
01:34:48.682 --> 01:34:50.151
FAMILY AS THE LICENSE HOLDER MAY
01:34:50.217 --> 01:34:51.352
BE THE PRIMARY SOURCE OF
01:34:51.419 --> 01:34:53.821
TRANSPORTATION. FOR THEMSELVES
01:34:53.888 --> 01:34:55.990
OR THEIR FAMILIES AND MAKE IT
01:34:56.057 --> 01:34:57.358
IMPOSSIBLE FOR THEM TO FILL
01:34:57.425 --> 01:34:58.726
THEIR OBLIGATIONS. UM FOR THEIR
01:34:58.793 --> 01:35:00.661
FAMILIES AND FOR THEIR OWN WELL
01:35:00.728 --> 01:35:02.563
BEING. ADDITIONALLY, AS STATED.
01:35:02.630 --> 01:35:03.998
IN MOST CASES, MANY INDIVIDUALS
01:35:04.065 --> 01:35:05.533
ARE UNAWARE OF THEIR LICENSE
01:35:05.599 --> 01:35:06.467
SUSPENSION UNTIL THEY ARE
01:35:06.534 --> 01:35:09.270
STOPPED BY LAW ENFORCEMENT DUE
01:35:09.336 --> 01:35:10.704
TO THE DEMS IN COURT NOTICES,
01:35:10.771 --> 01:35:12.373
NEVER EVEN REACHING THEM IN RARE
01:35:12.440 --> 01:35:14.542
CASES WHERE INDIVIDUAL MAY EVEN
01:35:14.608 --> 01:35:15.709
BE AWARE THAT THEIR LICENSES
01:35:15.776 --> 01:35:17.545
FUNDED THEY'RE UNAWARE OF WHAT
01:35:17.611 --> 01:35:20.748
MAY HAPPEN NEXT. OR WHEN THEY
01:35:20.815 --> 01:35:22.950
ARE TO APPEAR IN COURT AND ARE
01:35:23.017 --> 01:35:24.752
AFRAID THAT AN APPEARANCE MAY
01:35:24.819 --> 01:35:25.820
WORSEN ALREADY PRETTY BAD
01:35:25.886 --> 01:35:30.558
SITUATION. UNDER THE CURRENT LAW
01:35:30.624 --> 01:35:31.725
, THE COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES
01:35:31.792 --> 01:35:33.027
THAT COME WITH THOSE IN THIS
01:35:33.094 --> 01:35:34.528
CONTAINER CONVICTION AND THE
01:35:34.595 --> 01:35:35.129
LICENSE SUSPENSION CAN SPEND
01:35:35.196 --> 01:35:37.531
EVEN YEARS AFTER THE INITIAL
01:35:37.598 --> 01:35:38.866
INCIDENT, WHILE HASN'T ALWAYS
01:35:38.933 --> 01:35:40.167
BEEN PERPETUATED. CONVICTION IS
01:35:40.234 --> 01:35:43.704
LESS SERIOUS THAN A FELONY. MR
01:35:43.771 --> 01:35:45.039
NEW YORK. CONVICTION IS A NO WAY
01:35:45.106 --> 01:35:48.209
LESS HARMLESS OR NO WAY HARMLESS
01:35:48.275 --> 01:35:49.710
TO THE INDIVIDUAL WHO RECEIVED
01:35:49.777 --> 01:35:51.345
ONE A CONVICTION. WHETHER
01:35:51.412 --> 01:35:52.546
MISDEMEANOR OR FELONY OR EVEN AN
01:35:52.613 --> 01:35:54.715
INFRACTION ISN'T PERMANENT MARK.
01:35:54.782 --> 01:35:56.484
ON A RECORD AND EVEN IF EXPUNGE,
01:35:56.550 --> 01:35:59.286
CAN NEVER BE ERASED OR REMOVED.
01:35:59.353 --> 01:36:01.555
AND BECAUSE OF THAT, IT
01:36:01.622 --> 01:36:03.791
PERPETUATES FURTHER, UM,
01:36:03.858 --> 01:36:06.694
COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES THROUGH
01:36:06.760 --> 01:36:07.294
PUBLIC BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR
01:36:07.361 --> 01:36:08.329
HOUSING, EMPLOYMENT AND LICENSE
01:36:08.395 --> 01:36:13.200
YOURS. UM THAT'S FURTHER PUSH AS
01:36:13.267 --> 01:36:15.769
STATED ALREADY UNSTABLE
01:36:15.836 --> 01:36:16.904
HOUSEHOLD PERSON FARTHER OUT OF
01:36:16.971 --> 01:36:21.642
BLACK, UM WE ASK THAT YOU CAN
01:36:21.709 --> 01:36:24.078
PREVENT YOUR SUPPORT TO A B 27
01:36:24.145 --> 01:36:25.846
46 TODAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:36:25.913 --> 01:36:27.047
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. IS ANYBODY
01:36:27.114 --> 01:36:28.849
HERE IN THE IN THE HEARING OF
01:36:28.916 --> 01:36:29.984
LIKE TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:36:30.050 --> 01:36:31.785
BILL, PLEASE PROCEED. NATASHA
01:36:31.852 --> 01:36:33.754
MINSTER ON BEHALF OF THE
01:36:33.821 --> 01:36:34.288
PROSECUTOR'S ALLIANCE OF
01:36:34.355 --> 01:36:36.090
CALIFORNIA. PROUD TO SPONSOR A B
01:36:36.157 --> 01:36:39.727
27 46. THANK YOU, MISS MINSTER.
01:36:39.793 --> 01:36:40.828
IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE
01:36:40.895 --> 01:36:42.229
TELECONFERENCE LINE WOULD LIKE
01:36:42.296 --> 01:36:44.632
TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF THE
01:36:44.698 --> 01:36:50.437
BILL A B 27 46. IF THERE ARE ANY
01:36:50.504 --> 01:36:51.639
IN SUPPORT THE BILL, PLEASE
01:36:51.705 --> 01:36:59.313
PRESS 10. THEY'RE CURRENTLY NONE
01:36:59.380 --> 01:37:03.017
IN THE QUEUE. THANK YOU. LET'S
01:37:03.083 --> 01:37:05.586
COME BACK TO THE HEARING. WAS
01:37:05.653 --> 01:37:06.720
ANYBODY LIKE TESTIFY IN PERSON
01:37:06.787 --> 01:37:07.721
IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL?
01:37:07.788 --> 01:37:10.691
SEEING NONE. MISS MODERATOR QUÊ
01:37:10.758 --> 01:37:12.193
CONFERENCES. ANYBODY WISHING
01:37:12.259 --> 01:37:13.194
TESTIMONY OPPOSITION TO THIS
01:37:13.260 --> 01:37:17.498
BILL A B 27 46 THERE ANY
01:37:17.565 --> 01:37:29.376
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
01:37:29.443 --> 01:37:30.544
THEY ARE CURRENTLY NONE IN THE
01:37:30.611 --> 01:37:32.046
QUEUE. VERY GOOD. LET'S COME
01:37:32.112 --> 01:37:33.948
BACK TO THE HEARING ROOM MEMBERS
01:37:34.014 --> 01:37:35.182
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THE
01:37:35.249 --> 01:37:39.853
BILL 27 46. BUT I DO HAVE
01:37:39.920 --> 01:37:41.288
SENATOR MILLENDER. SORRY SORRY
01:37:41.355 --> 01:37:42.790
TO SEE YOU THROUGH THIS GLASS.
01:37:42.856 --> 01:37:44.024
THANK YOU. UM WELL, THERE'S THE
01:37:44.091 --> 01:37:46.660
AUTHOR SEATED IN THE BACK, OKAY?
01:37:46.727 --> 01:37:50.030
UM SO I'M A LITTLE CONFUSED BY
01:37:50.097 --> 01:37:52.533
THIS BILL. UM, I UNDERSTAND WHAT
01:37:52.600 --> 01:37:55.135
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO. BUT I'M
01:37:55.202 --> 01:37:57.805
LOOKING AT THE TEXT, WHICH SAYS
01:37:57.871 --> 01:38:00.374
EXISTING LAW MAKES IT A
01:38:00.441 --> 01:38:03.244
MISDEMEANOR FOR A PERSON WHO
01:38:03.310 --> 01:38:03.877
WILLFULLY VIOLATE THEIR WRITTEN
01:38:03.944 --> 01:38:04.945
PROMISE TO APPEAR IN COURT. IN
01:38:05.012 --> 01:38:07.648
OTHER WORDS, YOU SAY, YOU KNOW,
01:38:07.715 --> 01:38:09.550
YOU HAVE A COURT DATE. YOU SAY
01:38:09.617 --> 01:38:10.651
I'M NOT GOING THAT'S A
01:38:10.718 --> 01:38:11.452
MISDEMEANOR. THIS BILL WOULD
01:38:11.518 --> 01:38:12.853
REPEAL THAT REQUIREMENT OF THE
01:38:12.920 --> 01:38:14.488
DMV HAVING TO SUSPEND THE
01:38:14.555 --> 01:38:15.222
PERSON'S DRIVING DRIVING
01:38:15.289 --> 01:38:18.459
PRIVILEGES BECAUSE YOU WILLFULLY
01:38:18.525 --> 01:38:20.828
DID NOT GO TO COURT WHEN YOU
01:38:20.894 --> 01:38:25.666
WERE ASSIGNED TO SO. I DON'T SEE
01:38:25.733 --> 01:38:27.401
IN HERE WHERE IT'S SPECIFIES FOR
01:38:27.468 --> 01:38:31.472
WHAT TYPES OF AND VIOLATIONS
01:38:31.538 --> 01:38:32.573
THAT WOULD GO INTO EFFECT IS
01:38:32.640 --> 01:38:37.077
THIS FOR NIGHT. PAYING YOUR
01:38:37.144 --> 01:38:38.746
PARKING TICKETS. IS THIS ALSO
01:38:38.812 --> 01:38:43.417
FOR, UM. YOU KNOW, A HIT AND RUN
01:38:43.484 --> 01:38:46.387
DRIVING NEGLIGENTLY. WHAT OLD
01:38:46.453 --> 01:38:48.255
DOES THIS COVER BECAUSE IT'S NOT
01:38:48.322 --> 01:38:50.591
CLEAR IN THE BILL. SO THE WAY
01:38:50.658 --> 01:38:52.660
THAT IT WOULD WORK IS IF YOU'RE
01:38:52.726 --> 01:38:53.927
LIKE IF YOU HAVE TO HIT AND RUN
01:38:53.994 --> 01:38:56.096
AND YOUR LICENSE IS SUSPENDED.
01:38:56.163 --> 01:38:57.865
YOUR LICENSE IS SUSPENDED. AND
01:38:57.931 --> 01:38:59.266
YOU STILL YOU IF YOU DRIVE
01:38:59.333 --> 01:39:01.302
WITHOUT A LICENSE, YOU STILL WE
01:39:01.368 --> 01:39:02.903
DON'T AFFECT ANY OF THE
01:39:02.970 --> 01:39:05.105
PENALTIES FOR DRIVING WITHOUT A
01:39:05.172 --> 01:39:06.006
LICENSE THAT'S BEEN SUSPENDED
01:39:06.073 --> 01:39:07.608
FOR ANY OF THOSE REASONS. THIS
01:39:07.675 --> 01:39:09.243
IS ONLY YEAH, YOU HAVEN'T. BUT
01:39:09.310 --> 01:39:10.377
YOU HAVEN'T GOTTEN TO THE POINT
01:39:10.444 --> 01:39:12.546
THAT HE DID A HIT AND RUN. YOU
01:39:12.613 --> 01:39:13.614
HAVEN'T ACTUALLY GONE TO COURT
01:39:13.681 --> 01:39:14.915
YET. SO YOU STILL HAVE YOUR
01:39:14.982 --> 01:39:17.084
LICENSE? SO IF YOU WILLFULLY
01:39:17.151 --> 01:39:18.352
DEFY THAT REQUIREMENT TO APPEAR
01:39:18.419 --> 01:39:21.355
IN COURT THERE WHEN EXACTLY DOES
01:39:21.422 --> 01:39:34.068
ONE'S LICENSE GET REVOKED?
01:39:34.134 --> 01:39:39.840
OKAY? THANK YOU. HAVE A ONE OF
01:39:39.907 --> 01:39:41.842
MY STAFFERS IS A TRAFFIC LAW
01:39:41.909 --> 01:39:43.477
EXPERT, SO YOU WOULD STILL HAVE
01:39:43.544 --> 01:39:44.244
A MISDEMEANOR FOR NOT APPEARING
01:39:44.311 --> 01:39:45.879
IN COURT. SO WE DON'T AFFECT
01:39:45.946 --> 01:39:48.349
THAT. BUT YOUR LICENSE THEN
01:39:48.415 --> 01:39:49.917
WOULDN'T BE OFFENDED. WOULDN'T
01:39:49.983 --> 01:39:51.418
BE SUSPENDED FOR THAT OFFENSE.
01:39:51.485 --> 01:39:53.320
YOU WOULD STILL HAVE A CRIMINAL
01:39:53.387 --> 01:39:54.388
MISDEMEANOR AT THAT POINT FOR
01:39:54.455 --> 01:39:55.622
NOT APPEARING. BUT YOU WOULDN'T
01:39:55.689 --> 01:39:57.057
HAVE THAT AUTOMATIC TRIGGER OF
01:39:57.124 --> 01:39:58.459
YOUR LICENSE ALSO BEING
01:39:58.525 --> 01:39:59.960
SUSPENDED, RIGHT? BUT SO IF YOU
01:40:00.027 --> 01:40:02.162
IF YOU COMMITTED CONVICTED OF
01:40:02.229 --> 01:40:03.931
THE OFFENSE, WHICH YOU WOULD BE
01:40:03.997 --> 01:40:05.866
CONVICTED OF THE OFFENSE IF YOU
01:40:05.933 --> 01:40:07.000
WOULD HAVE YOUR LICENSE
01:40:07.067 --> 01:40:09.870
SUSPENDED RIGHT, BUT THAT'S IF
01:40:09.937 --> 01:40:11.772
YOU ACTUALLY GO TO COURT. BUT IF
01:40:11.839 --> 01:40:13.807
YOU ARE NOT IF YOU'RE REFUSING
01:40:13.874 --> 01:40:16.243
TO GO TO COURT AND EVADING THE
01:40:16.310 --> 01:40:17.444
LAW. THEN YOUR LICENSE NEVER GET
01:40:17.511 --> 01:40:18.545
SUSPENDED BECAUSE YOU NEVER GO
01:40:18.612 --> 01:40:21.115
TO COURT. EVENTUALLY THEY WOULD
01:40:21.181 --> 01:40:22.850
STILL CONVICT YOU. IF YOU THEY
01:40:22.916 --> 01:40:24.284
COULD STILL CONVICT YOU. I
01:40:24.351 --> 01:40:25.753
BELIEVE IF YOU'RE THERE OR NOT
01:40:25.819 --> 01:40:27.621
THERE, I MEAN, THEY WOULD. STILL
01:40:27.688 --> 01:40:28.789
THEY COULD STILL CONVICT YOU OF
01:40:28.856 --> 01:40:30.290
THE OFFENSE YOU WOULD HAVE. I
01:40:30.357 --> 01:40:31.492
MEAN, YOU COULD ACTUALLY BE
01:40:31.558 --> 01:40:33.293
ARRESTED FOR JUST NOT SHOWING
01:40:33.360 --> 01:40:34.194
UP, ESPECIALLY FOR SOMETHING
01:40:34.261 --> 01:40:37.664
THAT'S LIKE A CRIMINAL OFFENSE
01:40:37.731 --> 01:40:38.899
AND RUN COULD BE A CRIMINAL
01:40:38.966 --> 01:40:40.634
OFFENSE. NO, I UNDERSTAND THAT I
01:40:40.701 --> 01:40:43.470
DO. AGAIN IF YOU DON'T EVER GO
01:40:43.537 --> 01:40:45.038
TO COURT AND YOU EVADE THE LAW,
01:40:45.105 --> 01:40:46.807
AND YOU MADE YOURCOURT DATE,
01:40:46.874 --> 01:40:47.941
THEY CAN'T EVER REVOKE YOUR
01:40:48.008 --> 01:40:48.976
LICENSE. THEY CAN NEVER NOTIFY
01:40:49.042 --> 01:40:50.110
YOU. YOUR LICENSE HAS BEEN
01:40:50.177 --> 01:40:52.746
REVOKED. YOU MAY NOT. OPERATE A
01:40:52.813 --> 01:40:55.549
MOTOR VEHICLE. SO THEN YOU ARE
01:40:55.616 --> 01:40:56.617
FREE TO GO ON AND PERHAPS
01:40:56.683 --> 01:40:58.152
COMMIT. ANOTHER HIT AND RUN OR,
01:40:58.218 --> 01:40:59.653
YOU KNOW, WHATEVER IT IS. I
01:40:59.720 --> 01:41:00.687
UNDERSTAND. I UNDERSTAND WHAT
01:41:00.754 --> 01:41:02.656
YOU'RE SAYING. BUT IF YOU HAVE A
01:41:02.723 --> 01:41:04.324
WARRANT OUT BECAUSE YOU FAILED
01:41:04.391 --> 01:41:06.193
TO APPEAR IN COURT FOR CRIMINAL
01:41:06.260 --> 01:41:07.594
TRIAL, LIKE A HIT AND RUN AND
01:41:07.661 --> 01:41:08.929
YOU GET PULLED OVER FOR
01:41:08.996 --> 01:41:09.963
SOMETHING. I THINK THAT WHETHER
01:41:10.030 --> 01:41:11.865
OR NOT YOUR LICENSE IS SUSPENDED
01:41:11.932 --> 01:41:13.033
IS KIND OF THE LEAST OF YOUR
01:41:13.100 --> 01:41:14.134
WORRIES. BECAUSE THEY COULD
01:41:14.201 --> 01:41:16.470
ACTUALLY TAKE YOU TO JAIL. YOU
01:41:16.537 --> 01:41:18.405
CAN HAVE ALL KINDS OF YOU KNOW
01:41:18.472 --> 01:41:18.939
THAT THEY DON'T THEY DON'T
01:41:19.006 --> 01:41:20.174
TYPICALLY GET PEOPLE. TO SHOW UP
01:41:20.240 --> 01:41:21.742
IN COURT BECAUSE OF LICENSE
01:41:21.809 --> 01:41:23.076
SUSPENSION. IT'S GOING TO BE A
01:41:23.143 --> 01:41:24.778
WHOLE HOST OF OTHER CRIMINAL
01:41:24.845 --> 01:41:25.879
CHARGES THAT YOU WOULD HAVE FOR
01:41:25.946 --> 01:41:27.147
EVADING THAT ORDER TO APPEAR IN
01:41:27.214 --> 01:41:28.982
COURT. I CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND
01:41:29.049 --> 01:41:30.551
THAT, BUT I'M TALKING ABOUT JUST
01:41:30.617 --> 01:41:32.152
WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THIS BILL.
01:41:32.219 --> 01:41:34.488
NICE. LET ME SORRY I'VE GOT MS
01:41:34.555 --> 01:41:35.989
MINSKY FROM THE BLUE IS WISHING
01:41:36.056 --> 01:41:38.759
TO CLARIFY. I BELIEVE ACTUALLY
01:41:38.826 --> 01:41:40.727
NOT HATCHING INSTAGRAM BUT HALF
01:41:40.794 --> 01:41:41.361
OF THE PROSECUTOR'S ALLIANCE OF
01:41:41.428 --> 01:41:43.864
CALIFORNIA FAIR ENOUGH, PLEASE
01:41:43.931 --> 01:41:46.266
IN ABSENTIA, SO IF A PERSON
01:41:46.333 --> 01:41:47.968
RECEIVES A DEFENSE THAT IS AN
01:41:48.035 --> 01:41:49.002
INFRACTION, LIKE A SPEEDING
01:41:49.069 --> 01:41:52.306
TICKET OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT,
01:41:52.372 --> 01:41:54.608
AND THEY'VE ASKED FOR A TRIAL
01:41:54.675 --> 01:41:56.109
AND THEY FAILED TO SHOW UP AT
01:41:56.176 --> 01:41:57.044
THEIR COURT DATE THAN THE COURT
01:41:57.110 --> 01:41:59.379
CAN PROCEED WITH THE TRIAL IN
01:41:59.446 --> 01:42:01.648
THEIR ABSENCE TRIAL IN ABSENTIA
01:42:01.715 --> 01:42:03.317
AND CAN FIND THEM GUILTY AND CAN
01:42:03.383 --> 01:42:05.185
TAKE FURTHER ACTION, INCLUDING
01:42:05.252 --> 01:42:07.454
SUSPENDING THEIR LICENSE FOR THE
01:42:07.521 --> 01:42:08.722
ACTUAL OFFENSE. IF YOU'RE
01:42:08.789 --> 01:42:10.357
CHARGED WITH A MISDEMEANOR OR A
01:42:10.424 --> 01:42:12.526
FELONY, THEN THEY WILL ISSUE A
01:42:12.593 --> 01:42:13.694
BENCH WARRANT IF YOU FAIL TO
01:42:13.760 --> 01:42:15.429
APPEAR IN COURT. AND THEN WHEN
01:42:15.496 --> 01:42:17.164
YOU ARE STOPPED, THEY WILL BRING
01:42:17.231 --> 01:42:19.066
YOU INTO COURT UNDER THE
01:42:19.132 --> 01:42:21.368
AUTHORITY OF LAW, AND SO IT'S
01:42:21.435 --> 01:42:22.269
REALLY CRITICAL TO EMPHASIZE
01:42:22.336 --> 01:42:25.305
THAT ALL THIS VILLA DRESSES IS
01:42:25.372 --> 01:42:27.941
THE SIMPLE FAILURE TO SHOW UP IN
01:42:28.008 --> 01:42:29.443
COURT. THAT SHOULDN'T BE
01:42:29.510 --> 01:42:31.278
SUFFICIENT FOR YOU TO LOSE YOUR
01:42:31.345 --> 01:42:33.247
LICENSE. WE SHOULD TAKE PEOPLE'S
01:42:33.313 --> 01:42:35.415
LICENSES AND SUSPEND THEM BASED
01:42:35.482 --> 01:42:37.351
ON THE ACTUAL CONDUCT WHEN THAT
01:42:37.417 --> 01:42:38.585
CONDUCT THREATENS PUBLIC SAFETY
01:42:38.652 --> 01:42:47.060
OR TRAFFIC SAFETY. OKAY, SO. SO
01:42:47.127 --> 01:42:49.096
YOU'RE TELLING ME THAT IF
01:42:49.162 --> 01:42:53.033
SOMEONE IS SAYING ENGAGING IN.
01:42:53.100 --> 01:42:55.469
STREET RACING, WHICH WE'VE HAD
01:42:55.536 --> 01:42:56.770
BILLS GO THROUGH THE LEGISLATURE
01:42:56.837 --> 01:42:58.338
THIS YEAR. JUST ABOUT THAT. YEAH
01:42:58.405 --> 01:43:00.541
SO SOMEONE IS ENGAGED IN STREET
01:43:00.607 --> 01:43:01.608
RACING OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT,
01:43:01.675 --> 01:43:04.912
UM AND THEY DON'T APPEAR IN
01:43:04.978 --> 01:43:07.848
COURT. THEIR LICENSE WOULD STILL
01:43:07.915 --> 01:43:14.254
BE REVOKED. BUT FOR MISDEMEANOR. INFRACTIONS LIKE NOT PAYING
01:43:14.321 --> 01:43:17.858
PARKING TICKETS OR I DON'T KNOW.
01:43:17.925 --> 01:43:19.159
PLANET SPEEDING TICKETS OR
01:43:19.226 --> 01:43:20.260
SOMETHING, THEN THEIR LICENSE
01:43:20.327 --> 01:43:23.297
WOULD NOT BE REVOKED. SPORT, NOT
01:43:23.363 --> 01:43:24.831
SHOWING UP IN THE COURT. AND SO
01:43:24.898 --> 01:43:26.867
IN OTHER WORDS, IF THEY ASKED
01:43:26.934 --> 01:43:28.368
FOR A TRIAL FOR THE STREET
01:43:28.435 --> 01:43:29.503
RACING, AND THEY DON'T SHOW UP
01:43:29.570 --> 01:43:31.838
THE COURT AS YOU JUST HEARD FROM
01:43:31.905 --> 01:43:32.472
THE PROSECUTORS, THE COURT CAN
01:43:32.539 --> 01:43:34.041
STILL SAY WE'RE CONVICTING THEM.
01:43:34.107 --> 01:43:35.208
THEY DIDN'T SHOW UP TO OFFER
01:43:35.275 --> 01:43:37.010
DEFENSE. WE'VE GOT THE TESTIMONY
01:43:37.077 --> 01:43:38.712
FROM THE OFFICERS. AND THEN
01:43:38.779 --> 01:43:39.846
THEIR LICENSE CAN BE SUSPENDED
01:43:39.913 --> 01:43:43.116
AND THEN FOR THAT REASON THEIR
01:43:43.183 --> 01:43:43.750
LICENSE WILL BE SUSPENDED. BUT
01:43:43.817 --> 01:43:45.319
WE DON'T WANT TO SUSPEND
01:43:45.385 --> 01:43:46.386
PEOPLE'S LICENSE. THE PERSON WHO
01:43:46.453 --> 01:43:47.921
GOT A COUPLE PARKING TICKETS,
01:43:47.988 --> 01:43:49.356
THEY GET A NOTICE TO APPEAR.
01:43:49.423 --> 01:43:50.090
THEY MAYBE DON'T EVEN REALLY
01:43:50.157 --> 01:43:52.025
LIKE. HEY, I'M GOING TO PAY IT.
01:43:52.092 --> 01:43:54.628
I'M NOT GOING TO SHOW UP IN
01:43:54.695 --> 01:43:55.729
COURT. NEXT THING YOU KNOW,
01:43:55.796 --> 01:43:56.730
THEY'RE LICENSE HAS BEEN
01:43:56.797 --> 01:43:57.364
SUSPENDED. THEY PROBABLY DON'T
01:43:57.431 --> 01:43:58.332
EVEN REALIZE IT. THAT'S WHAT
01:43:58.398 --> 01:44:00.634
WE'RE TRYING TO STOP. AND SO
01:44:00.701 --> 01:44:01.835
YOU'VE SAID TWICE NOW IF THEY
01:44:01.902 --> 01:44:03.103
ASK FOR A TRIAL. AND I JUST WHAT
01:44:03.170 --> 01:44:05.539
DO YOU MEAN BY THAT? I'M GOING
01:44:05.606 --> 01:44:07.074
TO ASK THE PROSECUTORS TO SPEAK
01:44:07.140 --> 01:44:08.075
BECAUSE THEY KNOW MORE ABOUT
01:44:08.141 --> 01:44:09.876
WHEN PEOPLE GET TRIALS AND WHEN
01:44:09.943 --> 01:44:12.446
THEY DON'T THANK YOU SO IF YOU
01:44:12.512 --> 01:44:14.414
RECEIVE A TICKET FOR AN
01:44:14.481 --> 01:44:15.749
INFRACTION, SO LET'S SAY, FOR
01:44:15.816 --> 01:44:16.950
EXAMPLE, YOUR TYPICAL SPEEDING
01:44:17.017 --> 01:44:18.552
TICKET YOU HAVE THE OPTION OF
01:44:18.619 --> 01:44:19.953
SIMPLY SIMPLY PAYING THAT TICKET
01:44:20.020 --> 01:44:21.054
, WHICH IS EFFECTIVELY YOU
01:44:21.121 --> 01:44:23.857
PLEADING GUILTY. IF YOU WANT TO
01:44:23.924 --> 01:44:25.792
CONTEST THAT TICKET, THEN YOU
01:44:25.859 --> 01:44:28.228
CAN REQUEST A TRIAL ON THAT
01:44:28.295 --> 01:44:29.062
INFRACTION. YOU CAN TELL THE
01:44:29.129 --> 01:44:31.665
COURT CONTESTING THIS TICKET AND
01:44:31.732 --> 01:44:34.067
I'M GOING TO APPEAR IN COURT.
01:44:34.134 --> 01:44:36.069
ONCE YOU'VE REQUESTED THAT TRIAL
01:44:36.136 --> 01:44:38.505
, YOU HAVE TO SHOW UP AND IF YOU
01:44:38.572 --> 01:44:39.906
DON'T, THEN THEY CAN PROCEED
01:44:39.973 --> 01:44:42.109
WITH THE TRIAL IN ABSENTIA AND
01:44:42.175 --> 01:44:43.143
ACTUALLY FIND YOU GUILTY BASED
01:44:43.210 --> 01:44:44.945
ON THE OFFICER'S TESTIMONY AND
01:44:45.012 --> 01:44:47.280
PRESENTATION. THAT'S DIFFERENT.
01:44:47.347 --> 01:44:48.582
THAT'S ONLY FOR INFRACTIONS
01:44:48.649 --> 01:44:50.384
RIGHT THAT WE HAVE THAT PROCESS
01:44:50.450 --> 01:44:51.385
THAT'S DIFFERENT FROM
01:44:51.451 --> 01:44:53.520
MISDEMEANORS OR FELONIES. YOU
01:44:53.587 --> 01:44:54.921
MUST APPEAR IN COURT AND YOU
01:44:54.988 --> 01:44:56.490
CAN'T BE CONVICTED OF A
01:44:56.556 --> 01:44:57.658
MISDEMEANOR OR FELONY UNLESS
01:44:57.724 --> 01:44:59.393
YOU'VE ACTUALLY PLED GUILTY OR
01:44:59.459 --> 01:45:01.028
BEEN THROUGH A TRIAL AND IN
01:45:01.094 --> 01:45:02.796
THOSE CASES, IF YOU MISSED YOUR
01:45:02.863 --> 01:45:04.364
COURT DATE, THEY WILL ISSUE A
01:45:04.431 --> 01:45:06.566
WARRANT FOR YOUR ARREST. AND
01:45:06.633 --> 01:45:08.402
THAT IS HOW MOST PEOPLE WHO
01:45:08.468 --> 01:45:09.536
FAILED TO APPEAR OR IN FACT
01:45:09.603 --> 01:45:11.672
BROUGHT INTO COURT. OKAY THANK
01:45:11.738 --> 01:45:14.675
YOU FOR CLARIFYING THAT, UM, I
01:45:14.741 --> 01:45:17.611
WILL SAY JUST AS A AS A FINAL
01:45:17.678 --> 01:45:19.546
COMMENT. I APPRECIATE THE
01:45:19.613 --> 01:45:20.681
CLARIFICATION BECAUSE THAT WAS
01:45:20.747 --> 01:45:23.617
VERY CONCERNING TO ME. UM
01:45:23.684 --> 01:45:25.619
HOWEVER, DO YOU HAVE ANY
01:45:25.686 --> 01:45:28.255
CONCERNS THAT BECAUSE YOU KNOW
01:45:28.321 --> 01:45:31.158
THE LICENSE REVOCATION CAN BE,
01:45:31.224 --> 01:45:32.726
UM, THE STICK AND THE CARROT AND
01:45:32.793 --> 01:45:35.495
STICK SCENARIO, RIGHT? SO DO YOU
01:45:35.562 --> 01:45:37.497
HAVE CONCERNS THAT WHEN YOU TAKE
01:45:37.564 --> 01:45:39.900
AWAY THAT INCENTIVE TO TAKE CARE
01:45:39.966 --> 01:45:41.968
OF BUSINESS AND MAKE SURE YOU GO
01:45:42.035 --> 01:45:43.170
TO YOUR COURT DATE IF YOU'VE
01:45:43.236 --> 01:45:44.738
REQUESTED IT, UM, THAT PEOPLE
01:45:44.805 --> 01:45:48.208
WILL JUST CONTINUE TO SAY I'M
01:45:48.275 --> 01:45:50.010
JUST NOT GOING TO DEAL WITH THIS
01:45:50.077 --> 01:45:52.245
AND NOT PAY THEIR TICKET OR SHOW
01:45:52.312 --> 01:45:54.114
UP IN COURT, OR I MEAN, IF YOU
01:45:54.181 --> 01:45:57.718
TAKE AWAY THE PUNISHMENT. I
01:45:57.784 --> 01:45:58.919
GUESS IF YOU WANT TO CALL IT
01:45:58.985 --> 01:46:00.120
THAT, THEN WHAT'S YOU KNOW?
01:46:00.187 --> 01:46:01.221
WHAT'S THE INCENTIVE TO DO?
01:46:01.288 --> 01:46:02.456
WHAT'S RIGHT. FROM MY
01:46:02.522 --> 01:46:03.857
UNDERSTANDING, TALKING TO THE
01:46:03.924 --> 01:46:05.459
ADVOCATES, THE BEST MAJORITY OF
01:46:05.525 --> 01:46:06.927
PEOPLE THAT HAVE THIS HAPPEN TO
01:46:06.993 --> 01:46:08.929
THEM ACTUALLY DON'T REALIZE THAT
01:46:08.995 --> 01:46:10.564
THIS IS WHERE THEM NOT SHOWING
01:46:10.630 --> 01:46:12.365
UP IS GOING TO GO AND SOMETIMES
01:46:12.432 --> 01:46:13.433
THEY DON'T EVEN REALIZE THEY
01:46:13.500 --> 01:46:15.669
WERE SUPPOSED TO SHOW UP. AND IN
01:46:15.736 --> 01:46:16.503
SOME JURISDICTIONS, PEOPLE
01:46:16.570 --> 01:46:17.471
ROUTINELY HAVE TO SHOW UP AND
01:46:17.537 --> 01:46:18.739
OTHER JURISDICTIONS. THEY
01:46:18.805 --> 01:46:20.107
ACTUALLY DON'T. THEY CAN JUST
01:46:20.173 --> 01:46:21.174
PAY A TICKET. SOME PLACES YOU
01:46:21.241 --> 01:46:23.510
ACTUALLY HAVE TO PAY THE TICKET
01:46:23.577 --> 01:46:24.745
IN PERSON OR SHOW UP IN PERSON
01:46:24.811 --> 01:46:26.146
IS MY UNDERSTANDING. SO WE DON'T
01:46:26.213 --> 01:46:27.581
THINK THAT THIS IS ACTUALLY
01:46:27.647 --> 01:46:29.683
LEADING TO ANYBODY BEHAVING ANY
01:46:29.750 --> 01:46:31.351
DIFFERENT. ALL IT'S DOING IS
01:46:31.418 --> 01:46:33.386
FURTHER PUNISHING PEOPLE WHO
01:46:33.453 --> 01:46:35.155
OFTEN DON'T SHOW UP FOR VERY
01:46:35.222 --> 01:46:36.156
LEGITIMATE REASONS. LIKE HAVING
01:46:36.223 --> 01:46:39.760
A JOB. HAVING LACK OF CHILDCARE
01:46:39.826 --> 01:46:41.895
OR A LOT OF TIMES SIMPLY NOT
01:46:41.962 --> 01:46:43.563
KNOWING WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN
01:46:43.630 --> 01:46:44.698
IF THEY DON'T SHOW UP. OKAY,
01:46:44.765 --> 01:46:46.600
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ANY OTHER
01:46:46.666 --> 01:46:51.738
MEMBERS. SEEING NONE. UM WOULD
01:46:51.805 --> 01:46:53.774
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? THIS IS
01:46:53.840 --> 01:46:55.275
SOMETHING THAT ACTUALLY COMES
01:46:55.342 --> 01:46:56.810
FROM THE AGENCIES THEMSELVES,
01:46:56.877 --> 01:46:58.278
SAYING THAT THEY DON'T WANT THIS
01:46:58.345 --> 01:47:00.380
TO CONTINUE HAPPENING THAT THEY
01:47:00.447 --> 01:47:02.315
THINK THAT THIS IS NOT A PROPER
01:47:02.382 --> 01:47:04.551
PUNISHMENT FOR INFRACTIONS THAT
01:47:04.618 --> 01:47:05.719
WOULDN'T ACTUALLY LEAD TO A
01:47:05.786 --> 01:47:06.820
LICENSE SUSPENSIONS. THINGS LIKE
01:47:06.887 --> 01:47:08.488
NOT PAYING A TICKET. SO WITH
01:47:08.555 --> 01:47:10.090
THAT I WOULD ASK YOU TO SORT OF
01:47:10.157 --> 01:47:12.058
CLOSE. WHAT I THINK IS AN
01:47:12.125 --> 01:47:12.993
UNINTENDED LOOPHOLE IN THE LAW
01:47:13.059 --> 01:47:14.461
AND STOP DRIVING PEOPLE INTO
01:47:14.528 --> 01:47:16.429
FURTHER CYCLES OF POVERTY AND
01:47:16.496 --> 01:47:17.697
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY. THANK
01:47:17.764 --> 01:47:19.699
YOU. DO WE HAVE A MOTION ON THE
01:47:19.766 --> 01:47:22.969
BILL? SENATOR COURTESY IN THE
01:47:23.036 --> 01:47:24.838
NICK OF TIME WE DO HAVE A MOTION
01:47:24.905 --> 01:47:26.006
FROM SENATOR CORTEZ HAS MOVED
01:47:26.072 --> 01:47:27.140
THE BILL. MISS WHITE. IF YOU
01:47:27.207 --> 01:47:29.609
COULD PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FILE
01:47:29.676 --> 01:47:32.312
ITEM 11 A B 2746. THE MOTION IS
01:47:32.379 --> 01:47:34.147
DO PASS THE FIRST BE REFERRED TO
01:47:34.214 --> 01:47:35.348
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:47:35.415 --> 01:47:37.517
SENATORS NEWMAN BATES. BATES?
01:47:37.584 --> 01:47:40.720
NO, ALAN ALAN I ARCHULETTA.
01:47:40.787 --> 01:47:44.691
BECKER. CORTEZ. PRETTY EASY. I
01:47:44.758 --> 01:47:49.996
DOLLY. SADLY, NO DODD. THAT I
01:47:50.063 --> 01:47:52.499
HERZBERG LIMÓN. LIMÓN. AYE
01:47:52.566 --> 01:47:57.637
MCGUIRE. MELINDA'S. MEN. MOMENT.
01:47:57.704 --> 01:48:02.108
I RUBIO RUBIO SKINNER.
01:48:02.175 --> 01:48:07.047
WIECKOWSKI WILK. THAT'S SEVEN
01:48:07.113 --> 01:48:14.688
CORRECT. 72. THE VOTE IS
01:48:14.754 --> 01:48:16.356
CURRENTLY SEVEN TO, UM SHE HAS
01:48:16.423 --> 01:48:19.192
GONE LIKE THE WIND. SO NEXT UP
01:48:19.259 --> 01:48:24.898
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SURGERY WELCOME
01:48:24.965 --> 01:48:26.099
YOUR PATIENCE. YOU WILL BE
01:48:26.166 --> 01:48:27.634
PRESENTING A B 27 03 PLEASE
01:48:27.701 --> 01:48:29.236
PROCEED. YES THANK YOU VERY
01:48:29.302 --> 01:48:32.606
MUCH, MR CHAIRMAN AND SENATORS.
01:48:32.672 --> 01:48:35.175
I AM HERE TO PRESENT A B 2703,
01:48:35.242 --> 01:48:36.376
WHICH WOULD REQUIRE THE
01:48:36.443 --> 01:48:38.345
CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION TO
01:48:38.411 --> 01:48:40.146
DEVELOP A PROGRAM TO PROVIDE
01:48:40.213 --> 01:48:41.348
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR
01:48:41.414 --> 01:48:42.582
ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING TO LOW
01:48:42.649 --> 01:48:46.486
INCOME DRIVERS. AS WELL AS TO
01:48:46.553 --> 01:48:49.155
ESTABLISH RELIABILITY STANDARDS
01:48:49.222 --> 01:48:51.625
FOR E. V. CHARGERS THAT RECEIVE
01:48:51.691 --> 01:48:52.826
STATE FUNDS. I THINK ALL OF US
01:48:52.893 --> 01:48:57.364
WHO UM, I HAVE THE PRIVILEGE OF
01:48:57.430 --> 01:48:59.299
DRIVING ELECTRIC VEHICLE KNOW
01:48:59.366 --> 01:49:01.134
THAT HAVING THE RELIABILITY
01:49:01.201 --> 01:49:03.370
STANDARDS IS GOING TO BE
01:49:03.436 --> 01:49:04.137
ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY TO INSPIRE
01:49:04.204 --> 01:49:05.705
THE CONFIDENCE AND THE RELIANCE
01:49:05.772 --> 01:49:10.277
NECESSARY FOR CALIFORNIA TO
01:49:10.343 --> 01:49:14.414
REACH OUR GOAL OF, UH GETTING
01:49:14.481 --> 01:49:15.916
FIVE MILLION ZERO MISSION
01:49:15.982 --> 01:49:17.117
VEHICLES ON OUR ROADS BY 2030 AS
01:49:17.183 --> 01:49:22.555
WELL AS TO HAVE ALL OBSERVES ALL
01:49:22.622 --> 01:49:24.357
VEHICLES LIKE TO THE VEHICLES TO
01:49:24.424 --> 01:49:26.359
RESERVES BY IN TERMS OF SALES BY
01:49:26.426 --> 01:49:31.031
2035. WITH ME HERE TODAY AND TO
01:49:31.097 --> 01:49:32.399
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT. THE BILL IS
01:49:32.465 --> 01:49:34.301
MARKET PRAIA WITH CHARGE POINT
01:49:34.367 --> 01:49:36.169
AS WELL AS GARZON CESSNA WITH
01:49:36.236 --> 01:49:37.304
THE MAKE MAKING HOPE HAPPEN
01:49:37.370 --> 01:49:40.674
FOUNDATION. THAT'S YOUR PRAYER.
01:49:40.740 --> 01:49:42.442
WELCOME PLEASE PROCEED. MR
01:49:42.509 --> 01:49:43.643
CHAIR. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:49:43.710 --> 01:49:45.578
MARK A PRAYER WITH A PRAYER.
01:49:45.645 --> 01:49:46.613
MAKELELE ON BEHALF OF CHARGE
01:49:46.680 --> 01:49:48.915
POINT. FIRST WE WANT TO THANK
01:49:48.982 --> 01:49:50.850
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MERITS UCI FOR
01:49:50.917 --> 01:49:53.987
AUTHORING THIS MEASURE AND FOR
01:49:54.054 --> 01:49:55.255
THE CO AUTHORS, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:49:55.322 --> 01:49:56.323
BENNETT BLOOM AND THREE OF US.
01:49:56.389 --> 01:49:59.659
WORK. OH, AUTHORING THE MEASURE.
01:49:59.726 --> 01:50:00.794
I'M HERE TODAY BECAUSE WE ALL
01:50:00.860 --> 01:50:02.462
SHARE A COMMON GOAL OF MAKING
01:50:02.529 --> 01:50:05.432
CALIFORNIA'S TRANSITION TO A
01:50:05.498 --> 01:50:06.833
ZERO EMISSION TRANSFERS
01:50:06.900 --> 01:50:07.334
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM OF
01:50:07.400 --> 01:50:11.671
SUCCESS. EVIE, CHARGING
01:50:11.738 --> 01:50:12.906
INFRASTRUCTURE MUST BE
01:50:12.973 --> 01:50:15.442
CONVENIENT, RELIABLE, EASY TO
01:50:15.508 --> 01:50:17.477
USE AND ACCESSIBLE IN ALL
01:50:17.544 --> 01:50:19.379
NEIGHBORHOODS FOR ALL DRIVERS.
01:50:19.446 --> 01:50:21.348
WHAT BROUGHT THIS MEASURE ABOUT
01:50:21.414 --> 01:50:24.250
WAS UH, A DIFFICULTY IN
01:50:24.317 --> 01:50:28.555
CONVINCING. MULTI UNIT DWELLINGS
01:50:28.621 --> 01:50:31.925
TO INSTALL EVIE INFRASTRUCTURE.
01:50:31.992 --> 01:50:34.194
PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN APARTMENT
01:50:34.260 --> 01:50:34.861
BUILDINGS HAVE DIFFICULTY
01:50:34.928 --> 01:50:36.463
BECAUSE I HAVE A LACK OF
01:50:36.529 --> 01:50:38.064
INFRASTRUCTURE, MAKING THE
01:50:38.131 --> 01:50:40.967
CONVENIENCE OF CHARGING AT HOME
01:50:41.034 --> 01:50:42.736
. NOT THERE AND TWO BECAUSE WHEN
01:50:42.802 --> 01:50:46.606
THEY PAY FOR EVIE, CHARGING IN
01:50:46.673 --> 01:50:48.575
THE PUBLIC DOMAIN. IT IS MORE
01:50:48.641 --> 01:50:50.977
EXPENSIVE. I ALSO WANT TO POINT
01:50:51.044 --> 01:50:53.213
OUT DATA THAT SHOWS THAT THE
01:50:53.279 --> 01:50:55.215
THAT THERE ARE FOLKS WHO WILL
01:50:55.281 --> 01:50:58.918
DISCONTINUE USING THEIR THEIR PV
01:50:58.985 --> 01:51:02.389
OR E. V FOR AMONG THE REASONS IS
01:51:02.455 --> 01:51:04.758
A DISSATISFACTION WITH THE
01:51:04.824 --> 01:51:06.026
CONVENIENCE OF CHARGING AND NOT
01:51:06.092 --> 01:51:07.160
HAVING LEVEL TWO CHARGING AT
01:51:07.227 --> 01:51:11.464
HOME. THE DATA SHOWS THAT 18% OF
01:51:11.531 --> 01:51:13.600
BATTERY ELECTRIC VEHICLE OWNERS
01:51:13.666 --> 01:51:16.503
DISCONTINUE THE USE OF THEIR E V
01:51:16.569 --> 01:51:18.938
WITHIN THE 1ST 12 MONTHS. E V S
01:51:19.005 --> 01:51:21.808
INFRASTRUCTURE ECOSYSTEM.
01:51:21.875 --> 01:51:25.011
EXPANDS WE NEED TO ENSURE THAT
01:51:25.078 --> 01:51:28.548
FOR THOSE WHO NEED AN INCENTIVE
01:51:28.615 --> 01:51:30.550
PARTICULARLY LOW INCOME AND
01:51:30.617 --> 01:51:32.018
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES THAT
01:51:32.085 --> 01:51:35.021
THAT IS AVAILABLE TO THEM AND TO
01:51:35.088 --> 01:51:36.089
THAT E INFRASTRUCTURE LIVES UP
01:51:36.156 --> 01:51:37.357
TO A PERFORMANCE STANDARD. SO
01:51:37.424 --> 01:51:42.996
THAT BOTH DRIVERS AND POTENTIAL
01:51:43.063 --> 01:51:44.297
BUYERS KNOW THAT EVIE
01:51:44.364 --> 01:51:46.533
INFRASTRUCTURE IS RELIABLE WITH
01:51:46.599 --> 01:51:48.401
THAT. WE ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE.
01:51:48.468 --> 01:51:52.338
THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND THE
01:51:52.405 --> 01:51:54.274
NEXT WITNESS AND SUPPORTERS IN
01:51:54.340 --> 01:51:55.341
THE COASTLINE. KAREN SUAREZ,
01:51:55.408 --> 01:52:00.947
PLEASE. PLEASE RECEIPT. CHAIR
01:52:01.014 --> 01:52:02.148
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE COMMITTEE.
01:52:02.215 --> 01:52:04.584
MY NAME'S SENIOR PROGRAM MANAGER
01:52:04.651 --> 01:52:06.553
AT THE MAKE NO DONATION HERE IN
01:52:06.619 --> 01:52:08.054
PLACE OF TERRENCE JUAREZ. I'D
01:52:08.121 --> 01:52:09.856
LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:52:09.923 --> 01:52:11.825
OR SUSHI AND ALL THE CO AUTHORS
01:52:11.891 --> 01:52:14.627
OF A B 27 03. I RESPECTFULLY
01:52:14.694 --> 01:52:15.662
REQUEST YOUR VOTE ON THIS
01:52:15.728 --> 01:52:19.432
MEASURE. EXISTING E V
01:52:19.499 --> 01:52:20.100
INFRASTRUCTURE IS LESS
01:52:20.166 --> 01:52:21.067
SUCCESSFUL FOR DISADVANTAGED
01:52:21.134 --> 01:52:22.335
COMMUNITIES OR WE CALL PRIORITY
01:52:22.402 --> 01:52:25.305
POPULATION. THIS IS ESPECIALLY
01:52:25.371 --> 01:52:26.406
TRUE IN THIS INVESTED
01:52:26.473 --> 01:52:28.408
NEIGHBORHOODS IN SAN BERNARDINO
01:52:28.475 --> 01:52:30.977
RESIDENTS OLDER AND OLDER, MULTI
01:52:31.044 --> 01:52:32.378
FAMILY DWELLINGS DO NOT HAVE
01:52:32.445 --> 01:52:33.012
ACCESS CHARGING, AND THOSE THAT
01:52:33.079 --> 01:52:34.814
HAVE LIVED HERE FOR GENERATIONS
01:52:34.881 --> 01:52:37.450
THAT MADE OWNER RENTS A HOME
01:52:37.517 --> 01:52:39.152
HALF OLDER HOUSING STOCK THAT
01:52:39.219 --> 01:52:40.220
WOULD REQUIRE COSTLY UPDATES AND
01:52:40.286 --> 01:52:42.088
REPAIRS. AS A RESULT,
01:52:42.155 --> 01:52:44.157
INDIVIDUALS WHO WANT AND HAVE
01:52:44.224 --> 01:52:46.092
TVS MUST RELY MORE ON PUBLIC
01:52:46.159 --> 01:52:47.794
CHARGING AT RETAIL LOCATION.
01:52:47.861 --> 01:52:49.362
BALDER PROGRAMS PROVIDE
01:52:49.429 --> 01:52:50.096
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO LOW
01:52:50.163 --> 01:52:51.664
INCOME INDIVIDUALS FOR EVIE,
01:52:51.731 --> 01:52:53.133
CHARGING THAT FINANCIAL AID IS
01:52:53.199 --> 01:52:54.267
LIMITED TO CERTAIN PARTS OF THE
01:52:54.334 --> 01:52:56.002
STATE. OVERSUBSCRIBED AND
01:52:56.069 --> 01:52:56.970
DELIVERED ON ONE E V CHARGING
01:52:57.036 --> 01:52:59.572
NETWORK. THE VITAL
01:52:59.639 --> 01:53:01.074
DIFFERENTIATOR IN THIS BILL IS
01:53:01.141 --> 01:53:02.041
THAT THE PROGRAM WILL MAKE
01:53:02.108 --> 01:53:03.643
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE AVAILABLE
01:53:03.710 --> 01:53:04.210
THROUGH A RELOADABLE PAYMENT
01:53:04.277 --> 01:53:06.779
CARD THAT HAS BOTH TÌM V<c.cyan>AND</c>
01:53:06.846 --> 01:53:09.082
CONTACT WITH CAPABILITIES. THAT
01:53:09.149 --> 01:53:10.650
MEANS THAT THE INDIVIDUAL CAN
01:53:10.717 --> 01:53:11.818
USE THIS PAYMENT CARD ANYWHERE,
01:53:11.885 --> 01:53:13.987
NOT JUST THAT ONE E V CHARGING
01:53:14.053 --> 01:53:14.988
COMPANIES TIME THAT IS
01:53:15.054 --> 01:53:16.256
PARTICIPATING IN THE PROGRAM.
01:53:16.322 --> 01:53:17.724
LOW INCOME FAMILIES ARE
01:53:17.790 --> 01:53:18.925
CREATIVELY ACCESSING EAVES AND
01:53:18.992 --> 01:53:20.860
SAN MARTINO AND NEED MORE ACCESS
01:53:20.927 --> 01:53:22.962
TO PUBLIC CHARGE. THIS MEASURE
01:53:23.029 --> 01:53:24.464
WILL BENEFIT. THIS IS
01:53:24.531 --> 01:53:25.365
NEIGHBORHOODS THROUGHOUT
01:53:25.431 --> 01:53:26.799
CALIFORNIA, ESPECIALLY LOWER
01:53:26.866 --> 01:53:28.101
INCOME RESIDENTS THAT COMMUTE
01:53:28.168 --> 01:53:29.903
HUNDREDS OF MILES EACH WEEK OUT
01:53:29.969 --> 01:53:32.405
OF OUR CITY FOR WORK AND PROVIDE
01:53:32.472 --> 01:53:33.573
THEM AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE
01:53:33.640 --> 01:53:34.707
TO PUT FUEL AND ELECTRIC
01:53:34.774 --> 01:53:36.476
VEHICLE. WE THEREFORE
01:53:36.543 --> 01:53:37.477
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR VOTE
01:53:37.544 --> 01:53:40.914
ON A B 27 03. THANK YOU VERY
01:53:40.980 --> 01:53:42.081
MUCH. ANYBODY IN THE CHAMBER
01:53:42.148 --> 01:53:44.050
WOULD LIKE TEST RIGHT SUPPORT.
01:53:44.117 --> 01:53:47.587
HAVE A B 27 3. PLEASE PURSUE.
01:53:47.654 --> 01:53:48.888
COLLECTING WITH THE SILICON
01:53:48.955 --> 01:53:49.756
VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP AND
01:53:49.822 --> 01:53:52.825
SUPPORT THANK YOU ANYBODY ELSE?
01:53:52.892 --> 01:53:54.394
SEEING NONE. MR. MODERATOR IF
01:53:54.460 --> 01:53:56.196
YOU COULD PLEASE QUERY THE
01:53:56.262 --> 01:53:57.530
CONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
01:53:57.597 --> 01:53:59.799
ANYBODY ON THE LINE YOU'D LIKE
01:53:59.866 --> 01:54:00.900
TO TEST FOR AND SUPPORT OF 27 3.
01:54:00.967 --> 01:54:02.735
IF YOU'D LIKE TO EXPRESS
01:54:02.802 --> 01:54:03.870
SUPPORT. PLEASE PRESS 10 AT THIS
01:54:03.937 --> 01:54:13.079
TIME. AND WE DO HAVE SEVERAL
01:54:13.146 --> 01:54:19.052
LINING UP HERE. THE FIRST. MINE
01:54:19.118 --> 01:54:20.987
IS LINE 117. YOUR LINE IS NOW
01:54:21.054 --> 01:54:24.991
OPEN. THIS IS SANTIAGO RODRIGUEZ
01:54:25.058 --> 01:54:25.858
WITH CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL
01:54:25.925 --> 01:54:30.196
VOTERS IN SUPPORT. NEXT, PLEASE.
01:54:30.263 --> 01:54:35.168
OKAY? WE'RE WAITING TO GET THE
01:54:35.235 --> 01:54:36.336
NUMBER LINE HERE. THANK YOU, MR
01:54:36.402 --> 01:54:46.913
CHAIR. KATE. THE NEXT COMMENT IS
01:54:46.980 --> 01:54:48.915
FROM LINE 1 24. YOUR LINE IS NOW
01:54:48.982 --> 01:54:51.351
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON, ELAINE
01:54:51.417 --> 01:54:53.620
ORTIZ ON BEHALF OF THE ELECTRIC
01:54:53.686 --> 01:54:54.254
VEHICLE CHARGING ASSOCIATION AND
01:54:54.320 --> 01:55:00.226
SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:55:00.293 --> 01:55:02.095
THE NEXT COVET IS LYING FROM
01:55:02.161 --> 01:55:05.865
LINE 123 OR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
01:55:05.932 --> 01:55:07.967
THINK CHAIR MEMBERS MAX CARRY ON
01:55:08.034 --> 01:55:09.202
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF LONG BEACH
01:55:09.269 --> 01:55:11.004
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT,
01:55:11.070 --> 01:55:14.040
PLEASE. AND THERE ARE ENOUGH
01:55:14.107 --> 01:55:15.008
FURTHER COMMENTS. MR CHAIR.
01:55:15.074 --> 01:55:16.009
ALRIGHT, LET'S COME BACK TO THE
01:55:16.075 --> 01:55:17.343
HEARING ROOM. IS ANYBODY HERE
01:55:17.410 --> 01:55:19.045
LIKE TESTIFYING IN PERSON IN
01:55:19.112 --> 01:55:22.015
OPPOSITION TO A B 27 3 SEEING
01:55:22.081 --> 01:55:23.249
NINE. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU
01:55:23.316 --> 01:55:24.417
PLEASE QUERY THE CONFERENCE
01:55:24.484 --> 01:55:25.385
LINE, IS THERE ANYBODY WISHING
01:55:25.451 --> 01:55:27.153
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO 27
01:55:27.220 --> 01:55:30.923
03. IF YOU'D LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
01:55:30.990 --> 01:55:31.991
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
01:55:32.058 --> 01:55:40.867
THIS TIME. AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO
01:55:40.933 --> 01:55:42.035
EXPRESS OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS
01:55:42.101 --> 01:55:45.104
ONE THROUGH AT THIS TIME. AND
01:55:45.171 --> 01:55:47.373
THERE IS NO ONE QUEUED UP. MR.
01:55:47.440 --> 01:55:48.074
CHAIR. THANK YOU. LET'S COME
01:55:48.141 --> 01:55:50.576
BACK TO THE HEARING ROOM MEMBERS
01:55:50.643 --> 01:55:51.711
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THE
01:55:51.778 --> 01:55:56.549
BILL? I WILL, MR. MURATSUCHI YOU
01:55:56.616 --> 01:55:58.117
AND I HAD A CONVERSATION ABOUT A
01:55:58.184 --> 01:55:59.419
RELATED SUBJECT ON A DIFFERENT
01:55:59.485 --> 01:56:00.987
BILL AND A DIFFERENT HEARING
01:56:01.054 --> 01:56:02.288
ROOM. I THINK IT WAS YESTERDAY
01:56:02.355 --> 01:56:04.057
AT ALL KINDS OF BLURS TOGETHER,
01:56:04.123 --> 01:56:06.492
I WOULD BE REMISS. IN MY ROLE AS
01:56:06.559 --> 01:56:07.627
A SELF APPOINTED CHAIR OF THE
01:56:07.694 --> 01:56:08.895
HOUSE IN CORK CAUCUS. TO POINT
01:56:08.961 --> 01:56:09.896
OUT THAT FOR DISADVANTAGED
01:56:09.962 --> 01:56:10.830
COMMUNITIES. LET LET US NOT
01:56:10.897 --> 01:56:12.131
FORGET THAT FUEL CELL ELECTRIC
01:56:12.198 --> 01:56:14.400
VEHICLES ARE SHOULD BE. I WOULD
01:56:14.467 --> 01:56:16.336
ARGUE PART OF THE SOLUTION, BUT
01:56:16.402 --> 01:56:17.503
I WOULD ALSO ALLOW THEY SHOULD
01:56:17.570 --> 01:56:19.405
NOT BE AT THE EXPENSE. OF MAKING
01:56:19.472 --> 01:56:20.640
THOSE INVESTMENTS IN ELECTRIC
01:56:20.707 --> 01:56:22.308
INFRASTRUCTURE. HAVING SAID THAT
01:56:22.375 --> 01:56:26.012
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? POINT.
01:56:26.079 --> 01:56:27.280
WELL TAKEN. MR CHAIRMAN. I
01:56:27.347 --> 01:56:28.781
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I VOTE.
01:56:28.848 --> 01:56:31.317
THANK YOU AND I LET LET ME MAKE
01:56:31.384 --> 01:56:33.086
CLEAR YOU. DO YOU HAVE SOME
01:56:33.152 --> 01:56:34.754
MINOR MEMBERS COMING OUT OF THE
01:56:34.821 --> 01:56:35.922
LAST HEARING ANY QUÊ? YOU'RE
01:56:35.988 --> 01:56:36.889
COMMITTED TO TAKING THESE
01:56:36.956 --> 01:56:41.027
AMENDMENTS. THANK YOU. I M UM
01:56:41.094 --> 01:56:44.130
SUBMITTED A SET OF AMENDMENTS TO
01:56:44.197 --> 01:56:45.298
THE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
01:56:45.365 --> 01:56:47.834
STAFF TO PROVIDE MORE DETAIL IN
01:56:47.900 --> 01:56:49.435
TERMS OF THE FINANCIAL
01:56:49.502 --> 01:56:50.203
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM. THAT WAS THE
01:56:50.269 --> 01:56:52.472
REQUEST OF BOTH THE ENERGY
01:56:52.538 --> 01:56:53.406
COMMITTEE AS WELL AS
01:56:53.473 --> 01:56:56.476
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE, THE
01:56:56.542 --> 01:56:57.243
UNDERSTANDING THAT YOUR
01:56:57.310 --> 01:56:58.745
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE'S STAFF
01:56:58.811 --> 01:57:01.781
HAS AGREED TO WITH MY COMMITMENT
01:57:01.848 --> 01:57:03.816
TO WORK WITH THIS COMMITTEE TO
01:57:03.883 --> 01:57:07.353
FLUSH OUT THE DETAILS. TO BE
01:57:07.420 --> 01:57:08.888
FINALIZED, THAT THAT IS THE
01:57:08.955 --> 01:57:10.223
UNDERSTANDING. VERY GOOD. THANK
01:57:10.289 --> 01:57:12.291
YOU FOR THAT. DO I HAVE A
01:57:12.358 --> 01:57:13.960
MOTION? SENATOR CORTEZ MAKES THE
01:57:14.026 --> 01:57:15.128
MOTION MISS WHITE. IF YOU COULD
01:57:15.194 --> 01:57:17.997
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FILE ITEM
01:57:18.064 --> 01:57:21.033
23 A B 2703. THE MOTIONS DO PASS
01:57:21.100 --> 01:57:23.403
AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST MEN AND
01:57:23.469 --> 01:57:24.971
YOUR RE REFERRED TO THE
01:57:25.037 --> 01:57:26.639
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:57:26.706 --> 01:57:28.474
SENATORS NEWMAN, I, BATES. ALAN
01:57:28.541 --> 01:57:33.780
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. CORTEZ.
01:57:33.846 --> 01:57:39.285
COURTESY I DOLLY. DODD. THAT I
01:57:39.352 --> 01:57:42.155
HERZBERG LIMÓN. MCGUIRE
01:57:42.221 --> 01:57:48.060
MELINDA'S. MEN. RUBIO. RUBIO I
01:57:48.127 --> 01:57:54.233
SKINNER. WIECKOWSKI WELL. THAT
01:57:54.300 --> 01:57:57.170
BILL HAS FOUR VOTES. NO KNOWS
01:57:57.236 --> 01:57:58.337
WE'RE LEAVING ON CALL. THANK YOU
01:57:58.404 --> 01:58:02.442
VERY MUCH. AND IF YOU SEE
01:58:02.508 --> 01:58:03.443
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GARCIA ON YOUR
01:58:03.509 --> 01:58:07.046
WAY OUT WELL, SHE'S WHERE IS
01:58:07.113 --> 01:58:08.314
SHE? WHERE IS SHE? ALRIGHT
01:58:08.381 --> 01:58:09.348
WELCOME. WELCOME TO
01:58:09.415 --> 01:58:15.388
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GARCIA. I THINK
01:58:15.455 --> 01:58:25.698
I SEE GIBSON. AYE. ONE SECOND,
01:58:25.765 --> 01:58:37.343
PLEASE. YEAH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:58:37.410 --> 01:58:40.246
GARCIA, ARE YOU GOING TO GOING
01:58:40.313 --> 01:58:43.416
TO DEFER TO SOME MEMBER GIBSON.
01:58:43.483 --> 01:58:44.650
VERY GOOD. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:58:44.717 --> 01:58:47.220
REMEMBER GIBSON WELCOME. YOU ARE
01:58:47.286 --> 01:58:49.188
HERE TO PRESENT A B 22 71,
01:58:49.255 --> 01:58:50.923
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU VERY
01:58:50.990 --> 01:58:53.059
MUCH. MR CHAIRMAN AND I WANT TO
01:58:53.125 --> 01:58:54.694
THANK THE GENTLE LADY FROM BELL
01:58:54.760 --> 01:58:56.629
GUARDS. ALLOW ME TO GO AHEAD OF
01:58:56.696 --> 01:58:59.765
HER. I WANT TO THANK YOU VERY
01:58:59.832 --> 01:59:01.467
MUCH FOR ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT
01:59:01.534 --> 01:59:03.903
ASSEMBLY BUILT 22 71, WHICH
01:59:03.970 --> 01:59:05.438
SEEKS TO PERMIT LOS ANGELES
01:59:05.505 --> 01:59:07.273
COUNTY METROPOLITAN TRANSIT
01:59:07.340 --> 01:59:09.208
AUTHORITY L. A METRO TO OFFER A
01:59:09.275 --> 01:59:12.578
CONTRACT INCENTIVE. WITH LOCAL
01:59:12.645 --> 01:59:14.413
SMALL BUSINESSES, BUSINESSES
01:59:14.480 --> 01:59:16.749
SPECIFICALLY, THIS BUSINESS
01:59:16.816 --> 01:59:19.252
WOULD BE ELIGIBLE FOR A 5%
01:59:19.318 --> 01:59:20.286
PREFERENCE DISCOUNT WHEN BIDDING
01:59:20.353 --> 01:59:24.390
ON CONTRACTS. AS A WAY TO
01:59:24.457 --> 01:59:28.528
PROVIDE MORE EQUITY. ARE
01:59:28.594 --> 01:59:29.996
MANY SMALL BUSINESSES THAT WOULD
01:59:30.062 --> 01:59:33.566
NORMALLY NOT BE ABLE TO AFFORD A
01:59:33.633 --> 01:59:35.868
SEAT AT THE TABLE IN AND PREMIUM
01:59:35.935 --> 01:59:40.006
TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS. SINCE
01:59:40.072 --> 01:59:45.044
2019 CURRENT LAW MAYBE. 12 05
01:59:45.111 --> 01:59:48.548
JOAN SAWYER HAS AUTHORIZED METRO
01:59:48.614 --> 01:59:51.050
TO DO MORE FOR BUSINESSES WITH A
01:59:51.117 --> 01:59:53.786
MEDIUM SIZED BUSINESS, SMALL
01:59:53.853 --> 01:59:56.956
BUSINESS AS WELL AS DISABLED
01:59:57.023 --> 01:59:57.423
VETERANS BUSINESS, UM
01:59:57.490 --> 02:00:00.393
ENTREPRENEURS OR ENTERPRISE.
02:00:00.459 --> 02:00:03.563
THIS POLICY HAS LED TO MORE
02:00:03.629 --> 02:00:06.165
DIVERSE CONTRACTS WITH ONE OF
02:00:06.232 --> 02:00:07.767
THE LARGEST TRANSPORTATION
02:00:07.833 --> 02:00:10.069
AUTHORITY IN THE STATE AND
02:00:10.136 --> 02:00:12.171
NATION. BUT THERE IS CURRENTLY
02:00:12.238 --> 02:00:13.940
VERY LITTLE INCENTIVE TO KEEP
02:00:14.006 --> 02:00:17.510
LOCAL BUSINESS IN MIND FOR THESE
02:00:17.577 --> 02:00:18.644
CONTRACTS. LOCAL SMALL
02:00:18.711 --> 02:00:21.881
BUSINESSES CONTRIBUTE A LOT OF
02:00:21.948 --> 02:00:23.783
TAX DOLLARS TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT
02:00:23.849 --> 02:00:27.019
, AND THEY PROVIDE LONG TERM
02:00:27.086 --> 02:00:28.387
BENEFITS FOR A VARIETY OF
02:00:28.454 --> 02:00:31.290
POPULATIONS. THEY EMPLOY
02:00:31.357 --> 02:00:32.892
APPROXIMATELY ONE THIRD OF
02:00:32.959 --> 02:00:35.861
CALIFORNIA'S WORKERS AND THE
02:00:35.928 --> 02:00:37.129
OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF THOSE
02:00:37.196 --> 02:00:40.633
WORKERS ARE PEOPLE OF COLOR. IT
02:00:40.700 --> 02:00:42.535
IS WIDELY KNOWN THAT LOW INCOME
02:00:42.602 --> 02:00:44.570
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR HAVE BEEN
02:00:44.637 --> 02:00:46.305
HIT THE HARDEST DURING THIS
02:00:46.372 --> 02:00:49.308
PANDEMIC. IT IS ALSO KNOWN THAT
02:00:49.375 --> 02:00:51.944
OUR LOCAL GOVERNMENT NEEDS
02:00:52.011 --> 02:00:53.679
TANGIBLE SOLUTIONS TO PROVIDE
02:00:53.746 --> 02:00:58.551
MORE LOCAL JOBS. UM AND BUILD
02:00:58.618 --> 02:01:00.052
OUR LOCAL ECONOMY BOOSTING
02:01:00.119 --> 02:01:02.855
CONTRACTING OPPORTUNITIES FOR
02:01:02.922 --> 02:01:05.191
LOCAL SMALL BUSINESSES IS A
02:01:05.257 --> 02:01:07.526
TREMENDOUS STEP, AND I WANT TO
02:01:07.593 --> 02:01:08.461
UNDERSCORE TREMENDOUS STEP
02:01:08.527 --> 02:01:13.299
FORWARD. ASSEMBLY BILL 22 71 6
02:01:13.366 --> 02:01:15.701
TO PROMOTE A STRONG AND MORE
02:01:15.768 --> 02:01:18.471
INCLUSIVE MARKETPLACE TO BEST
02:01:18.537 --> 02:01:20.840
SERVE OUR COMMUNITY, PROVIDING,
02:01:20.906 --> 02:01:23.009
UM, JOINING ME TODAY BY PHONE.
02:01:23.075 --> 02:01:25.344
UM IS MICHAEL TURNER WITH LOS
02:01:25.411 --> 02:01:27.480
ANGELES METRO WHO IS A SPONSOR
02:01:27.546 --> 02:01:30.983
OF 22 71? THANK YOU. MR GIBSON.
02:01:31.050 --> 02:01:34.053
MR. TURNER, PLEASE PROCEED.
02:01:34.120 --> 02:01:36.489
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
02:01:36.555 --> 02:01:37.323
THIS IS MICHAEL TURNER ON BEHALF
02:01:37.390 --> 02:01:39.325
OF THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
02:01:39.392 --> 02:01:40.092
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION
02:01:40.159 --> 02:01:41.527
AUTHORITY BOARD OF DIRECTORS,
02:01:41.594 --> 02:01:43.295
AND WE'D LIKE TO THANK
02:01:43.362 --> 02:01:43.863
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GIBSON FOR
02:01:43.929 --> 02:01:45.464
WORKING WITH US TO ADVANCE THESE
02:01:45.531 --> 02:01:48.868
MEASURES. AS METRO PROCEEDS IN
02:01:48.934 --> 02:01:50.302
EXPANDING OUR TRANSIT SYSTEM
02:01:50.369 --> 02:01:52.438
WERE ENGAGED IN THE LARGEST
02:01:52.505 --> 02:01:54.073
EXPANSION OF A TRANSIT CAPITAL
02:01:54.140 --> 02:01:56.976
PROGRAM IN THE COUNTRY AS A PART
02:01:57.043 --> 02:01:58.177
OF THAT INVESTMENT. WE WANT TO
02:01:58.244 --> 02:02:00.346
MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE PROVIDING
02:02:00.413 --> 02:02:02.782
OPPORTUNITIES. FOR LOCAL SMALL
02:02:02.848 --> 02:02:05.518
BUSINESSES TO BENEFIT FROM THAT
02:02:05.584 --> 02:02:06.786
CONSTRUCTION AND THOSE
02:02:06.852 --> 02:02:08.387
EXPENDITURES WE HAVE ON THE
02:02:08.454 --> 02:02:09.855
STREET RIGHT NOW, SOMETHING ON
02:02:09.922 --> 02:02:11.123
THE ORDER OF ABOUT $20 BILLION
02:02:11.190 --> 02:02:13.259
IN CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS. AND
02:02:13.325 --> 02:02:15.061
WE WANTED TO ENSURE THAT WE ARE
02:02:15.127 --> 02:02:18.097
DOING OUR BEST. TO MAKE SURE
02:02:18.164 --> 02:02:19.799
THAT THE JOBS THAT ARE AVAILABLE
02:02:19.865 --> 02:02:21.600
FROM THOSE CONTRACTS ARE
02:02:21.667 --> 02:02:24.036
AVAILABLE FOLKS IN THE AREA TO
02:02:24.103 --> 02:02:25.004
THE EXTENT ALLOWED BY FEDERAL
02:02:25.071 --> 02:02:28.641
LAW, BUT ALSO TO THE EXTENT THAT
02:02:28.708 --> 02:02:29.875
WE CAN ENSURE THAT LOCAL SMALL
02:02:29.942 --> 02:02:31.977
BUSINESSES ALSO HAVE AN
02:02:32.044 --> 02:02:34.914
OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN
02:02:34.980 --> 02:02:36.949
THAT ECONOMIC ACTIVITY. WE'VE
02:02:37.016 --> 02:02:39.318
SEEN A LOT OF SUCCESS IN GROWING
02:02:39.385 --> 02:02:41.320
OUR LOCAL SMALL BUSINESS PROGRAM
02:02:41.387 --> 02:02:42.888
. IN FACT, DUE TO THE SUCCESS OF
02:02:42.955 --> 02:02:44.056
THAT WE'VE CREATED A MEDIUM
02:02:44.123 --> 02:02:46.125
SIZED BUSINESS PROGRAM. TO
02:02:46.192 --> 02:02:47.626
CONTINUE TO SUPPORT THOSE
02:02:47.693 --> 02:02:50.296
BUSINESSES. THIS BILL WILL HELP
02:02:50.362 --> 02:02:51.797
US TO ENSURE THAT THOSE BENEFITS
02:02:51.864 --> 02:02:53.399
REMAIN LOCAL AND THAT WE ARE
02:02:53.466 --> 02:02:55.267
ABLE TO REWARD THE TAXPAYERS OF
02:02:55.334 --> 02:02:57.069
LOS ANGELES COUNTY. BY HELPING
02:02:57.136 --> 02:02:58.604
TO SUPPORT BUSINESSES IN LOS
02:02:58.671 --> 02:03:00.039
ANGELES COUNTY. THANK YOU AGAIN
02:03:00.106 --> 02:03:01.140
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, AND WE
02:03:01.207 --> 02:03:03.409
URGE YOU TO SUPPORT THE MEASURE.
02:03:03.476 --> 02:03:04.710
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYBODY HERE
02:03:04.777 --> 02:03:07.646
IN THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM
02:03:07.713 --> 02:03:09.582
WOULD LIKE TO TRY AND SUPPORT OF
02:03:09.648 --> 02:03:12.551
A B 22 71. SAYING MISTER
02:03:12.618 --> 02:03:14.053
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE
02:03:14.120 --> 02:03:14.920
QUERY THE TELECONFERENCE NIGHT
02:03:14.987 --> 02:03:15.955
FOR ANYBODY WISHING TO TESTIFY
02:03:16.021 --> 02:03:20.359
IN SUPPORT OF A B 22 71. IF YOU
02:03:20.426 --> 02:03:22.661
WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS SUPPORT
02:03:22.728 --> 02:03:23.796
FOR A B 22 71, PLEASE PRESS 10
02:03:23.863 --> 02:03:29.802
AT THIS TIME. IN JUST A MOMENT,
02:03:29.869 --> 02:03:52.725
MR CHAIR. THANK YOU.
02:03:52.792 --> 02:03:53.959
OKAY. WE HAVE A COMMENT FROM
02:03:54.026 --> 02:03:56.662
LINE 80. YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
02:03:56.729 --> 02:03:58.697
DECLAN ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
02:03:58.764 --> 02:04:00.533
LOS ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF
02:04:00.599 --> 02:04:01.300
COMMERCE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:04:01.367 --> 02:04:02.501
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AS ANYBODY
02:04:02.568 --> 02:04:06.472
ELSE. AND THERE ARE NO FURTHER
02:04:06.539 --> 02:04:08.641
COMMENTS. MR. CHAIR THANK YOU.
02:04:08.707 --> 02:04:09.875
LET'S COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:04:09.942 --> 02:04:10.910
HEARING ROOMS. ANYBODY HERE LIKE
02:04:10.976 --> 02:04:13.579
TESTIFY? IN OPPOSITION TO A B 22
02:04:13.646 --> 02:04:15.080
71 SAYING NONE. MR MODERATOR,
02:04:15.147 --> 02:04:16.749
PLEASE QUERY THE LIVE FOR
02:04:16.816 --> 02:04:17.983
ANYBODY WISHING TEST RYAN
02:04:18.050 --> 02:04:19.752
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. HB 22
02:04:19.819 --> 02:04:22.888
71. AND IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
02:04:22.955 --> 02:04:23.956
COMMENT ON OPPOSED OPPOSITION TO
02:04:24.023 --> 02:04:26.826
LINE UM TO BUILD A B 2071 PLEASE
02:04:26.892 --> 02:04:30.029
PRESS WINDSOR AT THIS TIME. FOR
02:04:30.095 --> 02:04:31.063
OPPOSITION. PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
02:04:31.130 --> 02:04:39.205
THIS TIME. AND THERE WERE NO
02:04:39.271 --> 02:04:40.739
COMMENTS. MR CHAIR. VERY GOOD.
02:04:40.806 --> 02:04:43.475
THE RECOMMENDATION BY THE CHAIRS
02:04:43.542 --> 02:04:45.144
DO PASS. MR GIBBS. I DO HAVE A
02:04:45.211 --> 02:04:49.081
COMMENT. BILL SENATOR DOLLY
02:04:49.148 --> 02:04:51.250
MAKES THE MOTION. THANK YOU, MR
02:04:51.317 --> 02:04:53.652
GIBSON. IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE,
02:04:53.719 --> 02:04:54.720
I'LL USE THAT AS MY CLOTHES AND
02:04:54.787 --> 02:04:55.788
THANK THE COMMITTEE AND THE
02:04:55.855 --> 02:04:57.223
CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU MISS WHITE.
02:04:57.289 --> 02:04:59.458
IF YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:04:59.525 --> 02:05:02.962
FILE. ADAM 25 A B 2271 SENATORS
02:05:03.028 --> 02:05:06.565
NEWMAN BATES BATES, I, ALAN.
02:05:06.632 --> 02:05:11.370
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. CORTEZ.
02:05:11.437 --> 02:05:15.841
ORTEZ EI DOLLY! I DOT THAT I
02:05:15.908 --> 02:05:20.179
HERTZBERG LIMÓN MCGUIRE
02:05:20.246 --> 02:05:26.452
MELINDA'S. MEN. RUBIO. SKINNER.
02:05:26.518 --> 02:05:35.160
WIECKOWSKI WILK. THANK YOU.
02:05:35.227 --> 02:05:36.495
THERE'S OKAY AND IS CURRENTLY
02:05:36.562 --> 02:05:37.630
50. WE'LL LEAVE THAT OPEN. THANK
02:05:37.696 --> 02:05:39.064
YOU VERY MUCH. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:05:39.131 --> 02:05:42.034
GARCIA. AH WELCOME PURSUED AT
02:05:42.101 --> 02:05:50.075
YOUR LEISURE. QUÊ. AND YOU WILL
02:05:50.142 --> 02:05:53.979
BE PRESENTING A B 17 78, PLEASE
02:05:54.046 --> 02:05:55.481
PROCEED. YES THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:05:55.547 --> 02:05:56.615
PATIENCE WITH ME, MR SENATOR
02:05:56.682 --> 02:06:01.553
NEWMAN. I'M HERE TO PRESENT A B
02:06:01.620 --> 02:06:06.558
17 48. I HAVE SIX FREEWAYS THAT
02:06:06.625 --> 02:06:10.362
CHUCK MY DISTRICT 17 78 17 78.
02:06:10.429 --> 02:06:12.564
THANK YOU. YES I HAVE SIX
02:06:12.631 --> 02:06:13.999
FREEWAYS THAT CHUCK MY DISTRICT
02:06:14.066 --> 02:06:15.000
AND FOR THE LAST 10 YEARS I'VE
02:06:15.067 --> 02:06:16.902
BEEN TALKING ABOUT THAT IN THE
02:06:16.969 --> 02:06:18.237
IMPACTS IN MY COMMUNITY. IRAN
02:06:18.304 --> 02:06:21.073
AIR POLLUTION BUT THOSE THREE
02:06:21.140 --> 02:06:22.574
WAYS ALSO THROUGH IT AND TO
02:06:22.641 --> 02:06:24.610
DISLOCATE THOUSANDS OF COMMUNITY
02:06:24.677 --> 02:06:27.012
MEMBERS AS WE LOOK AT FREEWAY
02:06:27.079 --> 02:06:29.381
WIDENING AND EXPANSIONS. A
02:06:29.448 --> 02:06:31.583
COUPLE OF EXPANSIONS THAT ARE
02:06:31.650 --> 02:06:32.985
PLANNED AND HAVE BEEN PLANNED
02:06:33.052 --> 02:06:34.153
MOST OF MY LIFE, ACTUALLY,
02:06:34.219 --> 02:06:35.387
THEY'RE NOT NEW PLANS. INCLUDE
02:06:35.454 --> 02:06:37.289
THE WIDENING OF THE SEVENTH TERM
02:06:37.356 --> 02:06:40.125
FREEWAY. IN SOUTH EAST L. A
02:06:40.192 --> 02:06:41.760
INCLUDES THE WIDENING OF THE
02:06:41.827 --> 02:06:43.429
FIRE FREEWAY AND DOWNEY AND
02:06:43.495 --> 02:06:48.033
SOUTHEASTERLY AS WELL. IT LOOKS
02:06:48.100 --> 02:06:49.268
AT A COUPLE OF THEIR PROJECTS
02:06:49.335 --> 02:06:51.203
AND ON FREEWAYS AROUND MY AREA.
02:06:51.270 --> 02:06:54.006
AND AS WE LOOKED AT RESEARCH,
02:06:54.073 --> 02:06:55.040
THE IDEA THAT THIS VERY WIDE
02:06:55.107 --> 02:06:56.308
IDIOTS HELP WITH CONGESTIONS HAS
02:06:56.375 --> 02:07:01.447
HAS HAS NOT. PAST MUSTARD. UM
02:07:01.513 --> 02:07:04.049
AND SO MY GOAL IS TO BE ABLE TO
02:07:04.116 --> 02:07:05.484
SAY LET'S LET'S LEARN FROM THE
02:07:05.551 --> 02:07:07.519
PAST AND LET'S DO BETTER THAT
02:07:07.586 --> 02:07:09.021
STOP SACRIFICING COMMUNITIES
02:07:09.088 --> 02:07:10.756
LIKE MINE AND LET'S START
02:07:10.823 --> 02:07:11.824
PRIORITIZING THEM AND MAKING
02:07:11.890 --> 02:07:13.592
THEM HEALTHIER OUT THERE.
02:07:13.659 --> 02:07:16.228
WITHOUT SACRIFICING PROJECTS
02:07:16.295 --> 02:07:16.996
THAT ARE NEEDED FOR SAFETY
02:07:17.062 --> 02:07:18.297
WITHOUT SACRIFICING PROJECTS
02:07:18.364 --> 02:07:20.499
THAT ARE GOING TO BE ADVANCING
02:07:20.566 --> 02:07:22.634
NEW TECHNOLOGIES ARE INTER MODAL
02:07:22.701 --> 02:07:24.536
AND HELPING TO GET FOLKS OUT OF
02:07:24.603 --> 02:07:25.704
THEIR CARS AND INTO PUBLISH
02:07:25.771 --> 02:07:28.173
INTERPRETATION. OUT THERE. AND
02:07:28.240 --> 02:07:30.542
SO TODAY'S BILL IS INCOMPLETE
02:07:30.609 --> 02:07:32.111
AND SAD TO SEE THAT THE
02:07:32.177 --> 02:07:32.978
CHAIRWOMAN IS SICK, AND I WISH
02:07:33.045 --> 02:07:35.314
HER A FAST RECOVERY. BUT IN OUR
02:07:35.381 --> 02:07:36.548
DISCUSSIONS DURING THE WEEKEND
02:07:36.615 --> 02:07:38.384
AND UP THROUGH YESTERDAY EARLY
02:07:38.450 --> 02:07:40.452
AFTERNOON I TALKED ABOUT
02:07:40.519 --> 02:07:41.854
WIDENING THEIR FREEWAY. THAT'S
02:07:41.920 --> 02:07:44.056
RIGHT. A NAME. I MEAN, NARROWING
02:07:44.123 --> 02:07:45.190
ABILITY THAT IS STATEWIDE TO
02:07:45.257 --> 02:07:48.494
JUST A COUNTY OF L. A. I TALKED
02:07:48.560 --> 02:07:50.662
ABOUT NARROWING IT TO
02:07:50.729 --> 02:07:51.697
COMMUNITIES WHERE THEY'RE THE
02:07:51.764 --> 02:07:53.599
MOST IMPACTED BY POLLUTION AND
02:07:53.665 --> 02:07:54.533
TRAFFIC. THERE'S THREE METRICS
02:07:54.600 --> 02:07:55.834
AND THE CALEN VIRAL SCREENER
02:07:55.901 --> 02:07:57.870
THAT ALLOW YOU TO DO THAT ONE IS
02:07:57.936 --> 02:08:02.474
PM 2.5. ONE IS DIESEL PARTICULAR
02:08:02.541 --> 02:08:03.842
MATTER, AND ONE IS TRAFFIC
02:08:03.909 --> 02:08:07.679
CONGESTION OUT THERE. AND SO
02:08:07.746 --> 02:08:09.181
WHEN I LOOKED AT L, A COUNTY AND
02:08:09.248 --> 02:08:11.450
I OVERLAPPED THOSE THREE, UH,
02:08:11.517 --> 02:08:13.519
SCREENERS FROM CALLEN BORROW
02:08:13.585 --> 02:08:16.055
FROM ABOUT 2500 TONS OF TRACKS
02:08:16.121 --> 02:08:18.123
IT CAME DOWN TO ABOUT 300 CENSUS
02:08:18.190 --> 02:08:22.327
TRACTS. AND SO MY PROPOSAL IN MY
02:08:22.394 --> 02:08:23.495
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE CHAIR WHERE
02:08:23.562 --> 02:08:25.130
LIFTOFF BUT DOESN'T SPILL WOULD
02:08:25.197 --> 02:08:27.866
BE LIMITED TO JUST A LA COUNTY.
02:08:27.933 --> 02:08:29.201
IT IS THE PORTIONS OF L, A
02:08:29.268 --> 02:08:32.071
COUNTY THAT ARE IN THE 75% PLUS
02:08:32.137 --> 02:08:35.974
MOST POLLUTED COMMUNITIES. AH
02:08:36.041 --> 02:08:38.010
AND THAT IT WOULD STILL ACCEPT
02:08:38.077 --> 02:08:40.512
PROJECTS THAT ARE NEEDED FOR
02:08:40.579 --> 02:08:41.146
SECURITY PROJECTS THAT HAVE NEW
02:08:41.213 --> 02:08:42.614
TECHNOLOGIES PROJECTS THAT ARE
02:08:42.681 --> 02:08:44.516
INTERMODAL LIKE YOU SEE IN THIS
02:08:44.583 --> 02:08:48.053
BILL. THAT'S AN R CHAIRWOMAN GOT
02:08:48.120 --> 02:08:50.222
SICK AND I DIDN'T GET TO FINISH
02:08:50.289 --> 02:08:50.889
THOSE DISCUSSIONS. MY COMMITMENT
02:08:50.956 --> 02:08:53.025
IS STILL THAT TO ME, THAT'S THE
02:08:53.092 --> 02:08:54.660
FLOOR OF NARROWING THIS. I MIGHT
02:08:54.726 --> 02:08:56.628
HAVE TO NARROW IT FURTHER IF
02:08:56.695 --> 02:08:58.030
THIS BILL WERE TO MOVE FORWARD.
02:08:58.097 --> 02:09:00.132
AND I WOULD WANT TO BE ABLE TO
02:09:00.199 --> 02:09:00.833
CONTINUE TO TALK TO THE
02:09:00.899 --> 02:09:01.934
CHAIRWOMAN AND USE THEIR
02:09:02.000 --> 02:09:03.669
EXPERTISE IN HER STAFF'S
02:09:03.735 --> 02:09:04.903
EXPERTISE IN FIGURING OUT HOW TO
02:09:04.970 --> 02:09:08.941
GET TO MY ULTIMATE GOAL HERE.
02:09:09.007 --> 02:09:10.642
AND SO THAT'S WHERE I'M AT TODAY
02:09:10.709 --> 02:09:12.611
. I'M I'M FIGHTING FOR
02:09:12.678 --> 02:09:14.646
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE BEEN
02:09:14.713 --> 02:09:15.747
CHOKED BY FREEWAYS THAT HAVE
02:09:15.814 --> 02:09:17.483
BEEN DISPLACED BY FREEWAYS AND
02:09:17.549 --> 02:09:18.650
TRYING TO DO BETTER BY THOSE
02:09:18.717 --> 02:09:21.887
COMMUNITIES IN MY BACKYARD.
02:09:21.954 --> 02:09:23.188
THANK YOU. I UNDERSTAND IS YOUR
02:09:23.255 --> 02:09:26.125
SUPPORT AS WE HAVE TWO ON THE
02:09:26.191 --> 02:09:27.326
LINE WITH THE MAYOR OR RALLY
02:09:27.392 --> 02:09:29.795
AROUND BOYO OF COMMERCE, AND
02:09:29.862 --> 02:09:31.463
MICHAEL DIDN'T FROM CREATIVE
02:09:31.530 --> 02:09:32.131
HOUSING HOUSING ASSOCIATES NEAR
02:09:32.197 --> 02:09:33.332
REBEL IF YOU'D LIKE TO PROCEED,
02:09:33.398 --> 02:09:42.875
PLEASE. IS A RALLY Ó WE'RE ON
02:09:42.941 --> 02:09:50.782
THE LINE. I HAVE THE RUN. I HAVE
02:09:50.849 --> 02:09:51.817
INTERACTED MELISSA ROMERO, WHO'S
02:09:51.884 --> 02:09:56.822
ON THE LINE. YES THANK YOU.
02:09:56.889 --> 02:09:58.290
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. A
02:09:58.357 --> 02:09:59.958
LIST OF ROMERO WITH CALIFORNIA
02:10:00.025 --> 02:10:02.227
ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS. HERE TO
02:10:02.294 --> 02:10:05.030
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 78 BY
02:10:05.097 --> 02:10:06.431
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CRISTINA GARCIA
02:10:06.498 --> 02:10:09.201
, WHICH WILL PROHIBIT STATE
02:10:09.268 --> 02:10:10.669
FUNDING OR COMMITTING A FREEWAY
02:10:10.736 --> 02:10:11.570
EXPANSION IN ENVIRONMENTAL
02:10:11.637 --> 02:10:12.204
JUSTICE COMMUNITIES. HISTORY OF
02:10:12.271 --> 02:10:13.472
LAND USE, PLANNING, AND
02:10:13.539 --> 02:10:14.940
PARTICULARLY THE PLANNING OF
02:10:15.007 --> 02:10:15.440
FREEWAYS IS MARRED WITH
02:10:15.507 --> 02:10:17.709
ENVIRONMENTAL RATED THEM.
02:10:17.776 --> 02:10:19.378
RESEARCH SHOWS US THAT WIDENING
02:10:19.444 --> 02:10:20.812
AND EXPANDING FREEWAYS DIVIDES
02:10:20.879 --> 02:10:23.115
PRESIDENTS DIVIDES COMMUNITIES
02:10:23.182 --> 02:10:24.383
SUPPRESSES GENERATIONAL WEALTH
02:10:24.449 --> 02:10:26.218
FROM OCCURRING IN EXACTLY EIGHT
02:10:26.285 --> 02:10:28.253
HOUSING INSTABILITY, AND THAT
02:10:28.320 --> 02:10:29.855
REALITY IS ALL TOO OBVIOUS FOR
02:10:29.922 --> 02:10:31.223
MANY LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES OF
02:10:31.290 --> 02:10:32.291
COLOR AND CALIFORNIA WHO ARE
02:10:32.357 --> 02:10:34.960
SURROUNDED BY FREEWAYS. ALSO
02:10:35.027 --> 02:10:38.463
SHOWS I SAID BUILDING MORE LANES
02:10:38.530 --> 02:10:40.432
MORE CONGESTION AND MORE VEHICLE
02:10:40.499 --> 02:10:41.700
EMISSIONS WHILE NOT REDUCING
02:10:41.767 --> 02:10:43.936
CONDUCT CONGESTION AND IN A
02:10:44.002 --> 02:10:45.003
STATE WHERE SOME OF THE WORST
02:10:45.070 --> 02:10:47.773
AIR QUALITY IN THE NATION WHERE
02:10:47.839 --> 02:10:48.974
WE HAVE SOME OF THE WORST AIR
02:10:49.041 --> 02:10:50.342
QUALITY IN THE NATION. IT'S THE
02:10:50.409 --> 02:10:51.443
STATE'S RESPONSIBILITY TO ENSURE
02:10:51.510 --> 02:10:52.844
THAT STATE FUNDS ARE NOT BEING
02:10:52.911 --> 02:10:54.446
USED IN A MATTER THAT IS COUNTER
02:10:54.513 --> 02:10:56.114
TO OUR AIR QUALITY, PUBLIC
02:10:56.181 --> 02:10:58.116
HEALTH AND CLIMATE GOALS, AND
02:10:58.183 --> 02:10:58.984
PARTICULARLY WITH THE BILLS
02:10:59.051 --> 02:11:00.852
FOCUS ON COMMUNITIES THAT ARE
02:11:00.919 --> 02:11:02.521
SUFFERING THE MOST. SOME TOXIC
02:11:02.588 --> 02:11:03.622
AIR QUALITY AND HOUSING AND
02:11:03.689 --> 02:11:05.791
SECURITY. IT'S TIME TO
02:11:05.857 --> 02:11:07.593
CALIFORNIA TO END THE PRACTICE
02:11:07.659 --> 02:11:08.860
OF EXACERBATING THESE ISSUES OF
02:11:08.927 --> 02:11:10.862
TOXIC AIR POLLUTION AND HOUSING
02:11:10.929 --> 02:11:12.598
INSTABILITY IN THE COMMUNITIES
02:11:12.664 --> 02:11:13.966
THAT ARE SUFFERING THE MOST OF
02:11:14.032 --> 02:11:15.901
THE BILL COVERS WHEN WE KNOW FOR
02:11:15.968 --> 02:11:17.636
A FACT THAT THESE PROJECTS WILL
02:11:17.703 --> 02:11:18.604
NOT ONLY MAKE, WE'LL ACTUALLY
02:11:18.670 --> 02:11:19.571
MAKE THOSE PROBLEMS FOR
02:11:19.638 --> 02:11:20.973
EXTENDING FREEWAYS ONLY FURTHER
02:11:21.039 --> 02:11:22.808
INCREASES THE SOCIAL AND HEALTH
02:11:22.874 --> 02:11:23.709
COSTS FOR PEOPLE ALREADY LIVING
02:11:23.775 --> 02:11:25.711
WITH HIGH POLLUTION LEVELS. HE
02:11:25.777 --> 02:11:28.080
URGED YOUR VOTE ON A B 17 78 TO
02:11:28.146 --> 02:11:29.581
PROTECT COMMUNITIES THAT ARE
02:11:29.648 --> 02:11:31.483
OVERBURDENED WITH POLLUTION, AND
02:11:31.550 --> 02:11:32.985
WE COMMEND THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:11:33.051 --> 02:11:34.820
FOR CONTINUING TO PUSH FOR A
02:11:34.886 --> 02:11:36.054
BETTER WAY ON THIS ISSUE. THANK
02:11:36.121 --> 02:11:39.224
YOU. THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE ANY
02:11:39.291 --> 02:11:41.126
OTHER WITNESSES ON THE LINE IN
02:11:41.193 --> 02:11:43.128
SUPPORT AS PRIMARY WITNESSES? I
02:11:43.195 --> 02:11:44.529
SHOW HIM, MICHAEL, DIDN YES,
02:11:44.596 --> 02:11:46.765
CORRECT ABOUT THAT. AWESOME. MR.
02:11:46.832 --> 02:11:51.737
DAYTON. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
02:11:51.803 --> 02:11:55.107
YOU, MR CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS, UM
02:11:55.173 --> 02:11:58.010
I AM THE FOUNDER AND SHARE OF
02:11:58.076 --> 02:12:01.079
CREATIVE HOUSING ASSOCIATES. WE
02:12:01.146 --> 02:12:03.548
DO TRANSIT INTEGRATED
02:12:03.615 --> 02:12:04.816
NEIGHBORHOODS AROUND THE STATE
02:12:04.883 --> 02:12:07.619
OF CALIFORNIA WORKING WITH LOCAL
02:12:07.686 --> 02:12:11.857
CITY TRANSIT AUTHORITIES. TWO.
02:12:11.923 --> 02:12:15.661
SPEED. THE RIDERSHIP OF PUBLIC
02:12:15.727 --> 02:12:18.797
TRANS. MOST OF OUR WORK.
02:12:18.864 --> 02:12:24.269
FEELING. OF COMMUNITY THAT I'VE
02:12:24.336 --> 02:12:24.736
BEEN, UH INTERRUPTED,
02:12:24.803 --> 02:12:29.107
DEVASTATED. CALLED BY FREEWAYS
02:12:29.174 --> 02:12:34.079
CUTTING THROUGH VERY PREVIOUS,
02:12:34.146 --> 02:12:37.482
LOVELY 12-1 AND THEY
02:12:37.549 --> 02:12:40.686
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BILL IS SPOT ON
02:12:40.752 --> 02:12:46.992
GREATLY. SAID UM ZERO COURAGEOUS
02:12:47.059 --> 02:12:48.894
. I UNDERSTAND THERE'S A LOT OF
02:12:48.960 --> 02:12:51.196
OPPOSITION. DO THIS PARTICULAR
02:12:51.263 --> 02:12:58.637
BILL FOR FUTURE. WHAT THREE WAYS
02:12:58.704 --> 02:13:00.639
THAT IS, UH, THANK YOU VERY
02:13:00.706 --> 02:13:04.176
MUCH. BUILDING ANYMORE. ALL OF
02:13:04.242 --> 02:13:11.049
US DOLLARS. PUBLIC. THANK YOU
02:13:11.116 --> 02:13:12.317
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE
02:13:12.384 --> 02:13:17.222
POURED. IMPORTANT LEGISLATION.
02:13:17.289 --> 02:13:19.458
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
02:13:19.524 --> 02:13:20.058
ANYBODY HERE IN THE COMMUNITY
02:13:20.125 --> 02:13:22.094
ROOM WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
02:13:22.160 --> 02:13:23.228
SUPPORT OF THE MEASURE A B 17
02:13:23.295 --> 02:13:27.332
78. SEEING NONE. LET'S GO BACK
02:13:27.399 --> 02:13:28.266
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE, MR
02:13:28.333 --> 02:13:29.634
MODERATOR, POLICE QUEER ANYBODY.
02:13:29.701 --> 02:13:31.370
I'M SORRY WE DO SOMEBODY'S
02:13:31.436 --> 02:13:40.579
SUPPORT. WELCOME GOOD AFTERNOON
02:13:40.645 --> 02:13:41.780
. DAVID ACEVEDA WITH AARP, AARP,
02:13:41.847 --> 02:13:44.583
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
02:13:44.649 --> 02:13:45.617
. ANYBODY ELSE IN SUPPORT? WHO
02:13:45.684 --> 02:13:47.619
IS PRESENT? NO MR MODERATOR,
02:13:47.686 --> 02:13:49.187
PLEASE GO TO THE TELECOMS AND
02:13:49.254 --> 02:13:51.456
EVERYBODY ON THE LINE WOULD WISH
02:13:51.523 --> 02:13:52.090
TO TESTIFY WITH THEIR NAME, THE
02:13:52.157 --> 02:13:54.292
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON A B
02:13:54.359 --> 02:13:55.527
17 78. WE'RE GONNA LIMIT
02:13:55.594 --> 02:13:58.630
TESTIMONY TO 10 MINUTES. OKAY.
02:13:58.697 --> 02:14:02.534
IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK TO A B 17
02:14:02.601 --> 02:14:06.204
78 PLEASE PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME
02:14:06.271 --> 02:14:07.572
, AND THE FIRST COMMENT IS FROM
02:14:07.639 --> 02:14:12.677
LINE 126. YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
02:14:12.744 --> 02:14:14.212
GREETINGS SHARE MY NAME IS
02:14:14.279 --> 02:14:15.714
STANDING AROUND. KHÓ POLICY
02:14:15.781 --> 02:14:17.082
ADVOCATES CLIMATE PLAN CALLING
02:14:17.149 --> 02:14:19.351
IN AND SUPPORT A B 17 78. THANK
02:14:19.418 --> 02:14:21.920
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
02:14:21.987 --> 02:14:23.121
MIND WENT 35. YOUR LINE IS NOW
02:14:23.188 --> 02:14:28.093
OPEN. AMBER SAY HOW WOULD
02:14:28.160 --> 02:14:29.795
THREATEN PRICE CONSULTING ON
02:14:29.861 --> 02:14:30.896
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
02:14:30.962 --> 02:14:31.530
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE, ALLIANCE
02:14:31.596 --> 02:14:32.364
AND SUPPORT? THANK YOU NEXT,
02:14:32.431 --> 02:14:35.567
PLEASE. MINE WENT 36. YOUR LINE
02:14:35.634 --> 02:14:39.571
IS NOW OPEN. HI MY NAME IS
02:14:39.638 --> 02:14:41.273
DOUGLAS FISH FROM STREETS FOR
02:14:41.339 --> 02:14:44.075
ALL IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 17
02:14:44.142 --> 02:14:46.678
78. THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
02:14:46.745 --> 02:14:47.946
PLEASE. LINE 1 29. YOUR LINE IS
02:14:48.013 --> 02:14:51.082
NOW OPEN. ELENA ORTIZ ON BEHALF
02:14:51.149 --> 02:14:54.186
OF NRDC ACTION FUNDING SUPPORT.
02:14:54.252 --> 02:14:58.023
THANK YOU. NEXT PLEASE LINE WENT
02:14:58.089 --> 02:15:00.358
33, OR LINE IS NOW OPEN. HI
02:15:00.425 --> 02:15:01.526
WESTERN WOMEN ON BEHALF OF
02:15:01.593 --> 02:15:02.260
ACTIVE STAYING GABRIEL VALLEY
02:15:02.327 --> 02:15:04.362
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU
02:15:04.429 --> 02:15:07.766
NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 40, OR LINE
02:15:07.833 --> 02:15:10.869
IS NOW OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON.
02:15:10.936 --> 02:15:12.904
ADRIANA CHAMPAGNE WITH THE
02:15:12.971 --> 02:15:14.139
LEAGUE OF WOMEN, VOTERS OF
02:15:14.206 --> 02:15:15.173
CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:15:15.240 --> 02:15:19.177
THANK YOU. OKAY. 1, 30 OR LINE
02:15:19.244 --> 02:15:23.548
IS NOW OPEN. NOT ANYMORE. ILO'S
02:15:23.615 --> 02:15:24.216
ON BEHALF OF THE GREEN MONEY
02:15:24.282 --> 02:15:25.383
INTO PEOPLE'S SUPPORT, GOOD
02:15:25.450 --> 02:15:27.252
SHAPE AND EVERYTHING. 1 34 YEAR
02:15:27.319 --> 02:15:31.523
LINE IS NOW OPEN. HELLO VINCE
02:15:31.590 --> 02:15:33.492
VALUES ON BEHALF OF PREVENTION
02:15:33.558 --> 02:15:35.360
INSTITUTE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
02:15:35.427 --> 02:15:38.263
B 1778. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
02:15:38.330 --> 02:15:43.869
9 59. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
02:15:43.935 --> 02:15:45.303
AFTERNOON AGAIN. SENATORS MY
02:15:45.370 --> 02:15:46.972
NAME IS MATTHEW BAKER, POLICY
02:15:47.038 --> 02:15:48.073
DIRECTOR FOR PLAYING
02:15:48.139 --> 02:15:49.441
CONSERVATION MADE IN STRONG
02:15:49.508 --> 02:15:51.243
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
02:15:51.309 --> 02:15:58.884
LINE 68 YEAR, LINUS NOW OPEN.
02:15:58.950 --> 02:16:03.154
1968. YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
02:16:03.221 --> 02:16:05.156
SORRY. THIS IS OLIVIA SIDEMEN
02:16:05.223 --> 02:16:06.992
WITH LEADERSHIP COUNCIL FOR
02:16:07.058 --> 02:16:08.894
JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY,
02:16:08.960 --> 02:16:09.928
TAKING THE SUPPORT OF THE MEN
02:16:09.995 --> 02:16:11.329
POSITION ALONGSIDE WESTERN
02:16:11.396 --> 02:16:12.564
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY.
02:16:12.631 --> 02:16:13.498
CALIFORNIA WALK CLIMATE RESOLVED
02:16:13.565 --> 02:16:14.299
COMMUNITIES FOR A BETTER
02:16:14.366 --> 02:16:15.400
ENVIRONMENT PARTNERSHIP IN
02:16:15.467 --> 02:16:16.268
CENTER FOR COMMUNITY ACTION AND
02:16:16.334 --> 02:16:17.936
ENVIRONMENTAL AND GET THANK YOU
02:16:18.003 --> 02:16:22.207
NEXT, PLEASE. AND THERE ARE NO
02:16:22.274 --> 02:16:23.441
FURTHER COMMENTS. MR. CHAIR
02:16:23.508 --> 02:16:25.343
THANK YOU. LET'S COME BACK TO
02:16:25.410 --> 02:16:27.512
THE HEARING ROOM. I SHOW MR
02:16:27.579 --> 02:16:28.813
WATSON OPPOSITION, MR WATTS.
02:16:28.880 --> 02:16:31.516
WELCOME. PLEASE PURSUIT. THANK
02:16:31.583 --> 02:16:32.651
YOU, MR CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS.
02:16:32.717 --> 02:16:33.818
I'M HERE ON BEHALF TODAY AND OF
02:16:33.885 --> 02:16:35.820
TRANSPORTATION, CALIFORNIA.
02:16:35.887 --> 02:16:37.255
REPRESENTING THE TRANSPORTATION
02:16:37.322 --> 02:16:39.357
INDUSTRY AND WITH OUR ALLIED
02:16:39.424 --> 02:16:41.259
LABOR FORCES THAT BUILD AND WORK
02:16:41.326 --> 02:16:43.328
ON THE SYSTEM. WE REMAIN OPPOSED
02:16:43.395 --> 02:16:45.697
TO THE BILL ON THE AS AS WRITTEN
02:16:45.764 --> 02:16:49.401
ON JUNE 20TH. WE ARE VERY
02:16:49.467 --> 02:16:51.169
CONCERNED THAT THERE ARE OTHER
02:16:51.236 --> 02:16:52.304
TOOLS AVAILABLE. THE SEQUEL
02:16:52.370 --> 02:16:55.507
PROCESS. REQUIRES LEAD AGENCIES
02:16:55.574 --> 02:16:56.675
TO ANALYZE TRANSPORTATION
02:16:56.741 --> 02:16:57.776
PROJECTS FOR A LOT OF IMPACTS,
02:16:57.842 --> 02:16:59.511
INCLUDING AIR QUALITY.
02:16:59.578 --> 02:17:01.813
CONVENIENT IN FACT, SPECIFICALLY
02:17:01.880 --> 02:17:04.916
, SP 7 43 REQUIRES PROJECTS TO
02:17:04.983 --> 02:17:07.018
EVALUATE IMPACTS ON VM T RATHER
02:17:07.085 --> 02:17:09.754
THAN CONGESTION. AND WE'VE SEEN
02:17:09.821 --> 02:17:11.623
A SWEEPING CHANGES TO HOW THE
02:17:11.690 --> 02:17:13.592
STATE AND REGIONAL AGENCIES AND
02:17:13.658 --> 02:17:14.960
CITIES AND COUNTIES ARE NOW
02:17:15.026 --> 02:17:15.927
APPROACHING TRANSPORTATION
02:17:15.994 --> 02:17:19.531
PROJECTS UNDER SP 7 43, AND FOR
02:17:19.598 --> 02:17:21.333
THAT REASON WE MADE OPPOSED, BUT
02:17:21.399 --> 02:17:23.234
WE WOULD BE PLEASED TO TAKE A
02:17:23.301 --> 02:17:24.436
LOOK AT THE AMENDMENTS. IN
02:17:24.502 --> 02:17:26.504
ADDITION, I'VE BEEN ASKED BY THE
02:17:26.571 --> 02:17:27.305
RIVERSIDE CAN I TRANSPORTATION
02:17:27.372 --> 02:17:30.175
COMMISSION WHOSE LEADERSHIP HAD
02:17:30.241 --> 02:17:32.477
MEETINGS WITH THE AUTHOR AND
02:17:32.544 --> 02:17:33.244
OTHER REPRESENTATIVES OF THE
02:17:33.311 --> 02:17:35.347
LEGISLATURE, AND THEY REMAIN
02:17:35.413 --> 02:17:36.748
OPPOSED AS WRITTEN, BUT ARE VERY
02:17:36.815 --> 02:17:38.550
GRATEFUL FOR THE AUTHORS TÌM.
02:17:38.617 --> 02:17:40.118
AND ALSO LOOK FORWARD TO
02:17:40.185 --> 02:17:41.720
REVIEWING AMENDMENTS. SO
02:17:41.786 --> 02:17:43.321
APPRECIATE THIS AND THANK YOU
02:17:43.388 --> 02:17:44.823
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
02:17:44.889 --> 02:17:46.124
ANY OTHER WITNESSES AND
02:17:46.191 --> 02:17:47.292
OPPOSITION WITH YOUR NAME AND
02:17:47.359 --> 02:17:48.360
AFFILIATION YOUR POSITION. THANK
02:17:48.426 --> 02:17:50.829
YOU. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS SILVIO
02:17:50.895 --> 02:17:52.297
FERRARI ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
02:17:52.364 --> 02:17:53.632
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION,
02:17:53.698 --> 02:17:55.367
HERE IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL
02:17:55.433 --> 02:17:57.502
HAS ALSO BEEN TAGGED AS A
02:17:57.569 --> 02:17:58.470
HOUSING KILLER BY THE CBI
02:17:58.536 --> 02:17:59.971
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS COMMITTEE.
02:18:00.038 --> 02:18:02.741
AND EVEN AND THAT IS TO THE BILL
02:18:02.807 --> 02:18:04.109
IN PRINT. AS FAR AS THE
02:18:04.175 --> 02:18:05.143
AMENDMENTS. I DON'T THINK OUR
02:18:05.210 --> 02:18:06.678
TOP TWO PRIORITY CONCERNS ARE
02:18:06.745 --> 02:18:07.712
ADDRESSED EVEN WITH AMENDMENTS
02:18:07.779 --> 02:18:10.582
SO JUST TO GIVE YOU A SENSE, YOU
02:18:10.649 --> 02:18:12.584
KNOW, RIGHT NOW, WHEN OUR
02:18:12.651 --> 02:18:14.085
MEMBERS PROPOSED A PROJECT
02:18:14.152 --> 02:18:17.188
WITHIN 10 MILES OF A FREEWAY, UM
02:18:17.255 --> 02:18:18.156
WE ARE GOING TO ULTIMATELY BE
02:18:18.223 --> 02:18:19.891
PAYING CALTRANS TO MITIGATE OUR
02:18:19.958 --> 02:18:22.594
PROJECT'S IMPACTS. THAT IS
02:18:22.661 --> 02:18:24.963
TODAY. THAT'S THE WAY OF THE
02:18:25.030 --> 02:18:27.132
THAT MEANS WE'RE GOING TO PAY
02:18:27.198 --> 02:18:28.033
FOR IMPROVEMENTS AS PART OF OUR
02:18:28.099 --> 02:18:29.701
HOUSING PROJECTS, THEN THAT CAN
02:18:29.768 --> 02:18:30.969
BE CAPACITY. IMPROVEMENTS,
02:18:31.036 --> 02:18:32.737
INTERCHANGES, WHATEVER MIGHT BE
02:18:32.804 --> 02:18:34.205
BUT IF THIS BILL WERE TO PASS,
02:18:34.272 --> 02:18:37.008
AS IS, THAT MEANS FUTURE HOUSING
02:18:37.075 --> 02:18:39.411
PROJECTS WILL BE PAYING CALTRANS
02:18:39.477 --> 02:18:41.079
FOR THOSE PROJECTS THAT IMPROVE
02:18:41.146 --> 02:18:42.313
TRANSPORTATION AND THEY CANNOT
02:18:42.380 --> 02:18:45.250
BE BUILT UNDER THIS BILL. SO
02:18:45.316 --> 02:18:46.317
FUTURE HOMEBUYERS ARE GOING TO
02:18:46.384 --> 02:18:48.319
BE SADDLED WITH THAT COST, YET
02:18:48.386 --> 02:18:49.854
THEY'RE NOT GOING TO RECEIVE THE
02:18:49.921 --> 02:18:52.023
BENEFIT OF THOSE PROJECTS THAT
02:18:52.090 --> 02:18:53.224
THEY NEED TO IMPROVE THEIR
02:18:53.291 --> 02:18:54.492
COMMUNITIES. NUMBER TWO THIS
02:18:54.559 --> 02:18:58.229
BILL IS SPRAWL INDUCING. THAT'S
02:18:58.296 --> 02:18:59.798
THAT'S THE PERVERSE IMPACT OF
02:18:59.864 --> 02:19:02.200
THIS BILL. IT IS GOING TO PUT US
02:19:02.267 --> 02:19:04.335
IN A POSITION OR LARGELY ARE
02:19:04.402 --> 02:19:07.539
INFILL PROJECTS CANNOT GET THOSE
02:19:07.605 --> 02:19:08.106
TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENTS
02:19:08.173 --> 02:19:09.774
BUILT THAT ARE NEEDED. SO WHAT'S
02:19:09.841 --> 02:19:11.276
GOING TO HAPPEN? WE'RE GOING TO
02:19:11.342 --> 02:19:14.813
GO FURTHER OUT. WE'RE GOING TO
02:19:14.879 --> 02:19:16.247
GO FURTHER OUT WHERE WE DON'T
02:19:16.314 --> 02:19:18.016
HAVE NIMBYISM, AND WE DON'T HAVE
02:19:18.083 --> 02:19:20.051
THE RULE OF LAW OF A BILL LIKE
02:19:20.118 --> 02:19:20.985
THIS, AND WE'RE GOING TO GO
02:19:21.052 --> 02:19:23.588
BUILD IT OUT WHERE ONE IT'S
02:19:23.655 --> 02:19:24.589
AFFORDABLE AND TWO. WE CAN GET
02:19:24.656 --> 02:19:25.757
THE INFRASTRUCTURE AND
02:19:25.824 --> 02:19:26.324
TRANSPORTATION BUILT THAT IS
02:19:26.391 --> 02:19:27.926
NEEDED. SO THIS IS THIS IS A BAD
02:19:27.992 --> 02:19:30.228
BILL FOR ALL HOUSING. IT HURTS
02:19:30.295 --> 02:19:32.197
INFILL. IT ENCOURAGES SPRAWL.
02:19:32.263 --> 02:19:33.865
AND JUST EARLIER, THIS COMMITTEE
02:19:33.932 --> 02:19:36.868
HEARD A B 5 12 HOLDING THAT IS A
02:19:36.935 --> 02:19:38.169
MUCH BETTER APPROACH SO WE WOULD
02:19:38.236 --> 02:19:40.972
URGE A NO VOTE. THANK YOU VERY
02:19:41.039 --> 02:19:42.540
MUCH. OTHER WITNESSES IN
02:19:42.607 --> 02:19:45.276
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
02:19:45.343 --> 02:19:46.177
KEITH DONE, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
02:19:46.244 --> 02:19:47.479
THE SELF HELP COUNTIES COALITION
02:19:47.545 --> 02:19:48.980
I'D ADD ON TO THE COMMENTS MADE
02:19:49.047 --> 02:19:51.449
BY SILVIO FOR C B. A. YOU'RE
02:19:51.516 --> 02:19:52.817
GOING TO HAVE AND I LOOK FORWARD
02:19:52.884 --> 02:19:54.385
TO LOOKING AND SEEING WHAT THE
02:19:54.452 --> 02:19:55.453
AMENDMENTS ARE IN PRINT. BUT
02:19:55.520 --> 02:19:57.822
TALKING TO THE BILL, AS IT IS WE
02:19:57.889 --> 02:19:59.657
HAVE CITIZENS IN ALL 25 LOCAL
02:19:59.724 --> 02:20:00.959
SALES TAX COUNTIES THAT ARE
02:20:01.025 --> 02:20:03.294
PAYING TO HAVE IMPROVEMENTS TO
02:20:03.361 --> 02:20:04.996
THEIR SYSTEMS MADE WHETHER OR
02:20:05.063 --> 02:20:06.865
NOT IT'S JUST IN LOS ANGELES
02:20:06.931 --> 02:20:07.999
THAT HAS THREE ADDITIONAL SALES
02:20:08.066 --> 02:20:09.067
TAX MEASURES. THOSE INDIVIDUALS
02:20:09.134 --> 02:20:11.069
WILL BE PAYING THAT FREIGHT PLUS
02:20:11.136 --> 02:20:13.404
UNDER SB ONE, A GAS TAX INCREASE
02:20:13.471 --> 02:20:14.005
TO IMPROVEMENTS TO THEIR ROAD
02:20:14.072 --> 02:20:16.274
SYSTEM. WE THINK IT'S A BAD
02:20:16.341 --> 02:20:18.777
APPROACH TO BUILDING AND MEETING
02:20:18.843 --> 02:20:19.844
OUR NEEDS FOR INFRASTRUCTURE WE
02:20:19.911 --> 02:20:22.280
SUPPORT EQUITABLE, UH,
02:20:22.347 --> 02:20:23.548
TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS HAVE
02:20:23.615 --> 02:20:24.949
TAKEN TO ACCOUNT FOR CLIMATE
02:20:25.016 --> 02:20:26.518
CHANGE AND FOLLOW ALL THE LAWS
02:20:26.584 --> 02:20:28.186
AND GUIDANCE OF THE STATE OF
02:20:28.253 --> 02:20:29.487
CALIFORNIA AND LOCAL ZONING. SO
02:20:29.554 --> 02:20:31.089
AGAIN LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING THE
02:20:31.156 --> 02:20:32.824
BILL THAT'S BEEN PROPOSED TODAY
02:20:32.891 --> 02:20:35.260
IN COMMITTEE IN PRINT AT SOME
02:20:35.326 --> 02:20:39.464
POINT IF IT MOVES FORWARD, BUT
02:20:39.531 --> 02:20:40.064
WERE OPPOSED AS IT'S WRITTEN.
02:20:40.131 --> 02:20:41.332
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR DUNN.
02:20:41.399 --> 02:20:42.500
ANYBODY ELSE? BRIEFLY OPPOSITION
02:20:42.567 --> 02:20:44.602
TO THE BILL. THANK YOU, MR
02:20:44.669 --> 02:20:46.104
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MOIRA TAP
02:20:46.171 --> 02:20:47.672
HERE ON BEHALF OF BOTH THE
02:20:47.739 --> 02:20:48.573
ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION
02:20:48.640 --> 02:20:50.642
AUTHORITY AND THE ORANGE COUNTY
02:20:50.708 --> 02:20:52.343
BUSINESS COUNCIL, AND I WAS ALSO
02:20:52.410 --> 02:20:54.212
ASKED IF I COULD NOTE THE
02:20:54.279 --> 02:20:55.313
OPPOSITION FROM THE SOUTHERN
02:20:55.380 --> 02:20:56.781
CALIFORNIA. COALITION MOBILITY,
02:20:56.848 --> 02:20:58.683
21. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT,
02:20:58.750 --> 02:21:03.188
PLEASE. THE CHAIR MEMBERS MIKE
02:21:03.254 --> 02:21:06.691
MONEGAN AND I WILL BE SHORT. ON
02:21:06.758 --> 02:21:08.426
BEHALF OF THE BUILDING AND
02:21:08.493 --> 02:21:08.993
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
02:21:09.060 --> 02:21:14.032
PROPOSED MR MARK. MR CHAIR JOHN
02:21:14.098 --> 02:21:15.700
MOFFITT ON BEHALF OF A
02:21:15.767 --> 02:21:16.801
CALIFORNIA ALSO IN OPPOSITION.
02:21:16.868 --> 02:21:21.005
THANK YOU, SIR. MR CHAIR, GUS
02:21:21.072 --> 02:21:22.006
CORE ON BEHALF OF THE SAN
02:21:22.073 --> 02:21:23.274
JOAQUIN VALLEY REGIONAL POLICY
02:21:23.341 --> 02:21:26.477
COUNCIL AND CENTRAL COAST. JUST
02:21:26.544 --> 02:21:28.279
TRYING TO DIGEST THE INFORMATION
02:21:28.346 --> 02:21:29.814
JUST PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR. UM
02:21:29.881 --> 02:21:31.616
WE'RE OPPOSED TO THE CURRENT
02:21:31.683 --> 02:21:33.885
BUILDING PRINT CONTINGENT UPON A
02:21:33.952 --> 02:21:36.354
MOTION MADE BY THE BODY IF
02:21:36.421 --> 02:21:37.422
AMENDMENTS ARE TAKEN TO MAKE IT
02:21:37.488 --> 02:21:39.190
A DISTRICT BILL. I THINK WE
02:21:39.257 --> 02:21:40.091
WOULD BE INCLINED TO CHANGE OUR
02:21:40.158 --> 02:21:41.960
POSITION FROM AN OPPOSED TO A
02:21:42.026 --> 02:21:44.495
NEUTRAL POSITION. BUT I DEFERRED
02:21:44.562 --> 02:21:45.897
TO THE COMMITTEE ON THAT MR.
02:21:45.964 --> 02:21:47.532
CHAIR. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:21:47.599 --> 02:21:48.867
ANYBODY ELSE? WE SHOULD JUST
02:21:48.933 --> 02:21:50.268
TRYING PERSON SEEING NONE. MISS
02:21:50.335 --> 02:21:51.369
MARJORIE, LET'S GO TO THE PHONE
02:21:51.436 --> 02:21:53.338
LINES. IS THERE ANYBODY WISH TO
02:21:53.404 --> 02:21:55.006
TESTIFY IN OUR POSITION? TO A B
02:21:55.073 --> 02:21:59.878
17 78. OF COURSE, LADIES AND
02:21:59.944 --> 02:22:00.879
GENTLEMEN, IF YOU'RE AN
02:22:00.945 --> 02:22:04.716
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10.
02:22:04.782 --> 02:22:08.920
CAROLINE 1 38, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:22:08.987 --> 02:22:10.588
GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR MEMBERS
02:22:10.655 --> 02:22:11.689
OF THE COMMITTEE, SHARON CAN
02:22:11.756 --> 02:22:15.593
SOLVE IT ON BEHALF OF THE CITIES
02:22:15.660 --> 02:22:16.494
OF BAKERSFIELD IN CORONA AND
02:22:16.561 --> 02:22:18.630
CONDITIONS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:22:18.696 --> 02:22:20.899
NEXT, PLEASE. NEXT WE'LL GO TO
02:22:20.965 --> 02:22:25.703
LINE 100, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK
02:22:25.770 --> 02:22:27.138
YOU. MR CHAIR MEMBERS WASN'T
02:22:27.205 --> 02:22:28.773
BADLY ON BEHALF OF STEM
02:22:28.840 --> 02:22:29.908
BERNARDINO COUNTY TRANSITION
02:22:29.974 --> 02:22:31.175
AUTHORITY WERE POSTED IN PRINT,
02:22:31.242 --> 02:22:33.378
BUT LOOK FORWARD TO DOING ANY
02:22:33.444 --> 02:22:36.514
AMENDMENT. THANK YOU NEXT WEEK.
02:22:36.581 --> 02:22:38.383
THE NEXT GIRL LINE. 1 28, PLEASE
02:22:38.449 --> 02:22:42.120
GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR,
02:22:42.186 --> 02:22:44.088
FELIPE WENT IS CALLING ON BEHALF
02:22:44.155 --> 02:22:45.523
OF THE ASSOCIATED GENERAL
02:22:45.590 --> 02:22:46.591
CONTRACTORS OF CALIFORNIA IN
02:22:46.658 --> 02:22:47.592
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU NEXT,
02:22:47.659 --> 02:22:51.029
PLEASE. NEXT TO THE LINE. 1 32,
02:22:51.095 --> 02:22:54.866
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS NATALIE
02:22:54.933 --> 02:22:55.967
BOAST ON BEHALF OF THE
02:22:56.034 --> 02:22:57.035
CALIFORNIA BUSINESS ROUNDTABLE,
02:22:57.101 --> 02:22:57.936
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED. THANK YOU
02:22:58.002 --> 02:23:02.974
NEXT WEEK. THE NEXT LINE. 1 39,
02:23:03.041 --> 02:23:07.612
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, MR
02:23:07.679 --> 02:23:09.914
CHAIR MEMBERS. TODD BLOOM STEIN
02:23:09.981 --> 02:23:11.382
ON BEHALF OF THE SOUTHERN
02:23:11.449 --> 02:23:12.317
CALIFORNIA CONTRACTORS
02:23:12.383 --> 02:23:14.585
ASSOCIATION, OPPOSED TO A B 17
02:23:14.652 --> 02:23:17.689
78. THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
02:23:17.755 --> 02:23:22.627
PLEASE. DON'T GO TO LINE 1 21,
02:23:22.694 --> 02:23:26.764
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:23:26.831 --> 02:23:28.466
, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
02:23:28.533 --> 02:23:29.867
COMMITTEE CHIANA VALENTINE ON
02:23:29.934 --> 02:23:31.269
BEHALF OF TWO ORGANIZATIONS AND
02:23:31.336 --> 02:23:32.370
OPPOSITION THIS AFTERNOON, THE
02:23:32.437 --> 02:23:35.740
UNITED CONTRACTORS IN THE
02:23:35.807 --> 02:23:36.674
COACHELLA VALLEY ASSOCIATION OF
02:23:36.741 --> 02:23:37.742
GOVERNMENTS. THANK YOU. THANK
02:23:37.809 --> 02:23:42.547
YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. AND THERE ARE
02:23:42.613 --> 02:23:45.550
CURRENTLY NONE IN THE KILL.
02:23:45.616 --> 02:23:48.586
LET'S BRING IT BACK TO THE
02:23:48.653 --> 02:23:50.588
HEARING ROOM MEMBERS, QUESTIONS
02:23:50.655 --> 02:23:52.523
COMMENTS AND ON THE BILL A B 70
02:23:52.590 --> 02:23:56.194
78. OKAY, SENATOR DODD, PLEASE.
02:23:56.260 --> 02:24:01.799
YEAH. I GUESS I HAVE SOME
02:24:01.866 --> 02:24:04.302
SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS WITH, YOU
02:24:04.369 --> 02:24:07.071
KNOW, WITH THIS BILL AND THE
02:24:07.138 --> 02:24:09.440
APPROACH I UNDERSTAND THE AUTHOR
02:24:09.507 --> 02:24:10.375
IS GOOD AT SOME POINT TIME TAKES
02:24:10.441 --> 02:24:12.076
SOME AMENDMENTS, BUT WE DON'T
02:24:12.143 --> 02:24:13.244
HAVE AMENDMENTS TODAY. YOU KNOW
02:24:13.311 --> 02:24:15.880
FOR US. JUST HEARING THE
02:24:15.947 --> 02:24:21.019
OPPOSITION HERE. I. YEAH, I WANT
02:24:21.085 --> 02:24:22.453
TO HEAR WHAT SOME OTHER MY
02:24:22.520 --> 02:24:23.521
COLLEAGUES SAY BEFORE I GET
02:24:23.588 --> 02:24:25.123
APPLYING WHAT? I'M GOING TO DO
02:24:25.189 --> 02:24:26.991
TODAY, BUT I GOT SOME SERIOUS
02:24:27.058 --> 02:24:28.092
RESERVATIONS ABOUT LETTING THIS
02:24:28.159 --> 02:24:30.495
BILL OUT OF COMMITTEE TODAY.
02:24:30.561 --> 02:24:31.662
BASED ON WHAT I'VE HEARD THIS
02:24:31.729 --> 02:24:34.065
FAR. ANY OTHER MEMBERS. SENATOR
02:24:34.132 --> 02:24:38.169
RUBIO, PLEASE. THANK YOU. MR
02:24:38.236 --> 02:24:41.272
CHAIR AT I HAVE TO COMMEND THE
02:24:41.339 --> 02:24:43.441
OUT THERE. I UNDERSTAND HER
02:24:43.508 --> 02:24:44.909
INTENT, AND WE SHARE LOCAL
02:24:44.976 --> 02:24:46.244
COMMUNITY, SO I DO UNDERSTAND
02:24:46.310 --> 02:24:48.312
WHERE YOU KNOW HER HEART IS AND
02:24:48.379 --> 02:24:51.349
WHY SHE'S TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH
02:24:51.416 --> 02:24:52.250
THIS. I ALSO DON'T DISAGREE WITH
02:24:52.316 --> 02:24:53.818
SOME OF THE COMMENTS OF THE
02:24:53.885 --> 02:24:56.687
SUPPORTERS AND SUPPORT BUT I
02:24:56.754 --> 02:24:58.222
ALSO HAVE VERY SERIOUS CONCERNS
02:24:58.289 --> 02:25:00.158
AS I YOU KNOW, SPOKE EARLIER
02:25:00.224 --> 02:25:02.727
WITH THE AUTHOR, UM THE
02:25:02.794 --> 02:25:04.228
UNFORTUNATE PART THAT I'M
02:25:04.295 --> 02:25:05.730
STRUGGLING WITH IS THAT YOU ARE
02:25:05.797 --> 02:25:08.366
OUR CHAIR IS ABSENT. AND FROM
02:25:08.433 --> 02:25:10.201
WHAT I UNDERSTAND. INITIALLY SHE
02:25:10.268 --> 02:25:11.969
WAS IN OPPOSITION. THEN WE GOT A
02:25:12.036 --> 02:25:13.171
MESSAGE THAT SHE'S NO LONGER AN
02:25:13.237 --> 02:25:15.807
OPPOSITION. BUT REALLY DIDN'T
02:25:15.873 --> 02:25:16.908
GET TO A PLACE DUE TO HER
02:25:16.974 --> 02:25:20.445
ILLNESS, AND SO I FEEL A LITTLE
02:25:20.511 --> 02:25:22.046
CONFLICTED BECAUSE THERE'S SO
02:25:22.113 --> 02:25:23.948
MANY ISSUES THAT I HAVE, BUT
02:25:24.015 --> 02:25:25.183
AGAIN, THIS IS JUST SOMETHING
02:25:25.249 --> 02:25:26.751
THAT'S BEYOND I GUESS THE CHAIR
02:25:26.818 --> 02:25:29.587
AND THE AUTHORS CONTROL BUT I DO
02:25:29.654 --> 02:25:31.656
WANT TO EXPRESS A COUPLE ISSUES
02:25:31.722 --> 02:25:34.292
THAT I HAVE AND AS A FORMER
02:25:34.358 --> 02:25:35.726
COUNCIL MEMBER. UM YOU KNOW,
02:25:35.793 --> 02:25:36.594
I'VE ALWAYS BEEN VERY VOCAL
02:25:36.661 --> 02:25:39.630
ABOUT WANTING LOCAL CONTROL, AND
02:25:39.697 --> 02:25:42.967
I BELIEVE THAT THE WAY THE BILLS
02:25:43.034 --> 02:25:44.669
WRITTEN, IT MAY IMPACT SOME OF
02:25:44.735 --> 02:25:45.269
THE PROJECTS AND CONSTRUCTION
02:25:45.336 --> 02:25:48.206
THAT'S IN THE PIPELINE. ALSO
02:25:48.272 --> 02:25:49.907
I'VE BEEN FIGHTING FOR HOUSING
02:25:49.974 --> 02:25:52.610
AT THE LAST THREE YEARS. YOU
02:25:52.677 --> 02:25:53.578
KNOW, WE BUILT OVER 500 UNITS,
02:25:53.644 --> 02:25:55.279
YOU KNOW IN MY DISTRICT AND I
02:25:55.346 --> 02:25:58.516
FEEL THAT THIS MAY ALSO ARE
02:25:58.583 --> 02:26:00.918
SLOWED DOWN THAT PROGRESS AND
02:26:00.985 --> 02:26:02.253
GET IN THE WAY OF, UH, MEETING.
02:26:02.320 --> 02:26:04.722
YOU KNOW, SOME OF OUR ARENA
02:26:04.789 --> 02:26:06.257
GOALS AND MANDATES FROM THE
02:26:06.324 --> 02:26:08.726
STATE. UM AND STIFLE JUST THE
02:26:08.793 --> 02:26:10.194
CREATIVITY OF OUR LOCAL LEADERS
02:26:10.261 --> 02:26:13.197
. UM AND THIRD, UH, THE JOB.
02:26:13.264 --> 02:26:16.734
FACTOR I KNOW THAT YOU KNOW
02:26:16.801 --> 02:26:17.768
WE'RE COMING OUT OF A PANDEMIC
02:26:17.835 --> 02:26:19.470
WHERE IT'S JUST REALLY IMPACTED
02:26:19.537 --> 02:26:25.243
A LOT OF OUR LOCALS, NOT ONLY
02:26:25.309 --> 02:26:26.511
JUST INDIVIDUALS, BUT BUSINESSES
02:26:26.577 --> 02:26:29.113
ARE CITIES WERE OFF STRUGGLING
02:26:29.180 --> 02:26:34.785
AND RIGHT NOW.
02:26:34.852 --> 02:26:36.521
MISSION AND THE TRAITS AND
02:26:36.587 --> 02:26:39.090
EVERYONE SPEAK ABOUT HOW THEY
02:26:39.157 --> 02:26:41.459
FEEL THAT THIS IS GOING TO
02:26:41.526 --> 02:26:44.996
IMPACT THAT SO AGAIN. UM, I
02:26:45.062 --> 02:26:46.497
UNFORTUNATE THAT WE DO HAVE
02:26:46.564 --> 02:26:49.567
THIS. RAP. UP. ITS WE CAN HAVE
02:26:49.634 --> 02:26:51.636
ALL THE INFORMATION THAT ARE,
02:26:51.702 --> 02:27:02.480
BUT, UM DID. SPEAK TO THE ABOUT. IS GOING TO CONTINUE THE
02:27:02.547 --> 02:27:03.848
CONVERSATION WITH THE CHAIR,
02:27:03.915 --> 02:27:05.883
WHICH I APPRECIATE. UM SHE
02:27:05.950 --> 02:27:08.019
EXPRESSED WANTING TO DO A MORE
02:27:08.085 --> 02:27:11.322
RESTRICTIVE BILL AND TAILOR IT
02:27:11.389 --> 02:27:14.525
TO HER DISTRICT. BUT AYE ALSO
02:27:14.592 --> 02:27:16.561
TO. I HEARD LAKE COUNTY BUT I AM
02:27:16.627 --> 02:27:19.564
L. A COUNTY SO THAT PRESENTS
02:27:19.630 --> 02:27:21.499
PROBLEM FOR ME. I WISH IT WOULD
02:27:21.566 --> 02:27:24.402
BE TIGHTER AND SO AGAIN. I'M
02:27:24.468 --> 02:27:25.002
EXPRESSING ALL THESE CONCERNS.
02:27:25.069 --> 02:27:27.205
BECAUSE I'M NOT THERE. YET. BUT
02:27:27.271 --> 02:27:29.740
I WILL. OFFER THAT CURVE. JUST
02:27:29.807 --> 02:27:31.142
BASED ON THE ABSENCE. OF ARCHER.
02:27:31.209 --> 02:27:37.048
AND. UPON US THE DEADLINES UPON
02:27:37.114 --> 02:27:39.250
US SO I WOULD OFFER THAT
02:27:39.317 --> 02:27:43.087
COURTESY BUT VERY CLEAR THAT I
02:27:43.154 --> 02:27:44.355
RESERVE THE RIGHT TO NOT SUPPORT
02:27:44.422 --> 02:27:47.124
IT. IF THIS IS NOT A ENOUGH FORM
02:27:47.191 --> 02:27:51.696
THAT I CAN BECOME, THANK YOU. I
02:27:51.762 --> 02:27:54.732
WANT TO. FIRST OF ALL, LET ME
02:27:54.799 --> 02:27:56.300
JUST ASSOCIATE MY COMMENTS IN
02:27:56.367 --> 02:27:58.603
THE INTEREST OF TIME WITH THE
02:27:58.669 --> 02:28:00.137
TWO SENATORS WHO SPOKE BEFORE
02:28:00.204 --> 02:28:01.639
ME, UM SIMILAR HAVE SIMILAR
02:28:01.706 --> 02:28:05.509
CONCERNS. UM FUNDAMENTALLY WHERE
02:28:05.576 --> 02:28:08.145
I LEFT OFF ON THIS BILL WAS THAT
02:28:08.212 --> 02:28:10.314
IF THE AUTHOR WOULD TAKE THE
02:28:10.381 --> 02:28:11.082
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS, THEN I
02:28:11.148 --> 02:28:14.952
WOULD BE SUPPORTIVE. UM, IT'S
02:28:15.019 --> 02:28:18.389
DIFFICULT. UM AND IN FACT, IT IS
02:28:18.456 --> 02:28:23.160
A PROBLEM FOR ME, GIVEN, UM THAT
02:28:23.227 --> 02:28:25.263
WE DON'T HAVE AMENDMENTS WITH
02:28:25.329 --> 02:28:26.564
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS ON THEM
02:28:26.631 --> 02:28:30.601
BEFORE US, UM DESPITE WHAT I
02:28:30.668 --> 02:28:32.770
TAKE AS VERY GOOD EFFORTS, AND
02:28:32.837 --> 02:28:34.572
DESPITE THE FACT THAT I'VE
02:28:34.639 --> 02:28:35.906
WORKED WITH THIS AUTHOR BEFORE
02:28:35.973 --> 02:28:37.141
OF CO AUTHORED LEGISLATION WITH
02:28:37.208 --> 02:28:38.709
HER, SHE'S A PERSON OF HIGH
02:28:38.776 --> 02:28:41.078
CHARACTER AND CREDIBILITY. WHEN
02:28:41.145 --> 02:28:43.214
SHE SAYS SHE'S GOING TO DO
02:28:43.281 --> 02:28:44.348
SOMETHING. SHE DOES IT. I JUST
02:28:44.415 --> 02:28:45.049
DON'T ACTUALLY UNDERSTAND
02:28:45.116 --> 02:28:46.417
COMPLETELY. WHAT THAT SOMETHING
02:28:46.484 --> 02:28:50.488
IS. AND I'M PART OF HIS. I'M A
02:28:50.554 --> 02:28:51.122
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA SENATOR. AND
02:28:51.188 --> 02:28:56.460
HONESTLY. YOU KNOW, UM HE I KNOW
02:28:56.527 --> 02:28:57.862
ENOUGH TO BE DANGEROUS AS THEY
02:28:57.928 --> 02:28:59.130
SAY ON THIS BILL WHEN YOU APPLY
02:28:59.196 --> 02:29:00.998
IN VIRUS SCREEN, FOR EXAMPLE TO
02:29:01.065 --> 02:29:02.700
NARROW THINGS DOWN. SOMETIMES
02:29:02.767 --> 02:29:05.102
THAT WORKS VERY POORLY FOR US IN
02:29:05.169 --> 02:29:07.071
THE BAY AREA, AND SO I DON'T
02:29:07.138 --> 02:29:08.572
KNOW WHAT ENDS UP HAPPENING IN
02:29:08.639 --> 02:29:11.008
TERMS OF AN OUTCOME, AND IT IT'S
02:29:11.075 --> 02:29:12.777
NOT AGAIN NOT THE AUTHOR'S
02:29:12.843 --> 02:29:15.546
CREDIBILITY, BUT MY OWN CONCERN
02:29:15.613 --> 02:29:18.382
THAT WE DON'T GET A GET THE KIND
02:29:18.449 --> 02:29:20.618
OF OUTCOME THAT IS THE AUTHOR'S
02:29:20.685 --> 02:29:23.087
INTENT. IF WE SEND THIS FORWARD
02:29:23.154 --> 02:29:25.356
RIGHT NOW, SO I'M GONNA HAVE TO
02:29:25.423 --> 02:29:29.660
STAY OFF APOLOGIZE. YOU KNOW TO
02:29:29.727 --> 02:29:30.294
ALL CONCERNED. APPARENTLY A LOT
02:29:30.361 --> 02:29:31.829
OF WORK HAS GONE INTO THIS AND
02:29:31.896 --> 02:29:34.565
THERE'S BEEN SOME UM, MITIGATING
02:29:34.632 --> 02:29:36.300
CIRCUMSTANCES. OBVIOUSLY YOU
02:29:36.367 --> 02:29:37.335
KNOW, IN TERMS OF ABSENCES AND
02:29:37.401 --> 02:29:41.272
SO FORTH, BUT UM BUT THAT'S
02:29:41.339 --> 02:29:43.574
WHERE I'M AT ON THE BILL. THANK
02:29:43.641 --> 02:29:45.643
YOU. I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS
02:29:45.710 --> 02:29:47.378
OF BOTH SENATE COURTESY AND
02:29:47.445 --> 02:29:48.713
SENATOR RUBIO. I FIND MYSELF IN
02:29:48.779 --> 02:29:50.715
AN ODDS SPOT. UM YOU AS THE
02:29:50.781 --> 02:29:54.819
ACTING CHAIR. UM, I. FEEL
02:29:54.885 --> 02:29:57.822
OBLIGATED TO DEFER TO THE CHAIR
02:29:57.888 --> 02:29:59.623
AND SORT OF THE CONVERSATIONS
02:29:59.690 --> 02:30:01.625
THAT ASSEMBLY MEMBER YOU'VE BEEN
02:30:01.692 --> 02:30:02.960
HAVING WITH THE CHAIR AND YOUR
02:30:03.027 --> 02:30:04.395
EFFORT TO FIND COMMON GROUND AND
02:30:04.462 --> 02:30:06.397
MOVE THIS FORWARD. SO BECAUSE OF
02:30:06.464 --> 02:30:09.133
THAT, I WILL SUPPORT THE BILL
02:30:09.200 --> 02:30:12.103
TODAY. AS I TOLD YOU, HOWEVER,
02:30:12.169 --> 02:30:14.372
AS CHAIR I CAN'T MAKE THE MOTION
02:30:14.438 --> 02:30:16.607
AND SO AT THIS POINT, AND I ALSO
02:30:16.674 --> 02:30:18.542
WANT TO CLEAR THAT I'LL RESERVE
02:30:18.609 --> 02:30:20.010
THE RIGHT. TO CASUALLY DIFFERENT
02:30:20.077 --> 02:30:22.213
VOTE MOVING FORWARD. I DO SHARE
02:30:22.279 --> 02:30:23.781
A LOT OF THE CONCERNS OF THE
02:30:23.848 --> 02:30:25.383
OPPOSITION, AS THEY HAVE
02:30:25.449 --> 02:30:27.385
EXPRESSED THEM. SO HAVING SAID
02:30:27.451 --> 02:30:28.686
THAT GIVE YOU AN OPPORTUNITY TO
02:30:28.753 --> 02:30:31.922
CLOSE YES, THANK YOU. LET ME SAY
02:30:31.989 --> 02:30:33.791
THIS. I'VE BEEN HERE 10 YEARS
02:30:33.858 --> 02:30:36.327
AND THIS IS THE FIRST TIME IN 10
02:30:36.394 --> 02:30:37.261
YEARS I SHOW UP TO COMMITTEE
02:30:37.328 --> 02:30:39.363
WHERE I HAVEN'T GOTTEN INTO A
02:30:39.430 --> 02:30:39.930
BETTER PLACE WITH THE
02:30:39.997 --> 02:30:41.098
CHAIRPERSON, BECAUSE IT'S NOT
02:30:41.165 --> 02:30:42.600
WHERE I WANT TO BE. IS THAT
02:30:42.666 --> 02:30:44.235
WHERE ANY OF US WANT TO BE? IT'S
02:30:44.301 --> 02:30:46.203
NOT WHERE I WANT TO PUT MEMBERS
02:30:46.270 --> 02:30:48.205
IN, UH I'VE BEEN ON YOUR SIDE.
02:30:48.272 --> 02:30:49.774
OF THINGS, AND IT'S AND IT'S
02:30:49.840 --> 02:30:52.576
HARD, UM AND UNTIL YOU KNOW THAT
02:30:52.643 --> 02:30:53.744
I'M HERE. UH UNCOMFORTABLE
02:30:53.811 --> 02:30:56.947
BECAUSE I WANT TO HAVE IDEAL.
02:30:57.014 --> 02:31:01.218
AH, WITH US AND. I HAVE BEEN
02:31:01.285 --> 02:31:02.219
TALKING TO THE CHAIR, AND
02:31:02.286 --> 02:31:04.088
UNFORTUNATELY SHE GOT TAKEN. WE
02:31:04.155 --> 02:31:05.356
DIDN'T GET TO AN AGREEMENT. SHE
02:31:05.423 --> 02:31:07.191
WE STARTED OFF BY THE FIRST
02:31:07.258 --> 02:31:08.592
AGREEMENT WE DID COME TO IS THAT
02:31:08.659 --> 02:31:09.994
THIS WOULD ONLY AFFECT THE
02:31:10.060 --> 02:31:11.128
COUNTY AND PARTS OF VALLEY
02:31:11.195 --> 02:31:13.097
COUNTY. NOT ALL OF L. A COUNTY.
02:31:13.164 --> 02:31:15.533
AND SO IN THAT IS THIS PROPOSAL
02:31:15.599 --> 02:31:18.469
THAT I HAVE, AND IT'S JUST THE
02:31:18.536 --> 02:31:19.336
FLOOR. MY COMMITMENT AND MY HOPE
02:31:19.403 --> 02:31:21.105
IS THAT HER AND I CAN CONTINUE
02:31:21.172 --> 02:31:22.773
TO TALK ABOUT OUR COMMON GOALS.
02:31:22.840 --> 02:31:23.908
WE BOTH REPRESENT SOUTH EAST L,
02:31:23.974 --> 02:31:26.143
A COUNTY WE BOTH HAVE A DISTRICT
02:31:26.210 --> 02:31:27.178
THAT'S SOAKED BY A LOT OF
02:31:27.244 --> 02:31:30.981
FREEWAYS. IN A LOT OF FAMILIES
02:31:31.048 --> 02:31:31.515
THAT COULD BE POTENTIALLY
02:31:31.582 --> 02:31:32.917
DISPLACED OUT THERE, AND SO WE
02:31:32.983 --> 02:31:33.350
WERE HAVING POSITIVE
02:31:33.417 --> 02:31:35.152
CONVERSATIONS, BUT WE COULDN'T
02:31:35.219 --> 02:31:37.087
GET THERE. WE RAN OUT OF TIME
02:31:37.154 --> 02:31:40.491
AND IT'S UNFORTUNATE. AH FOR US
02:31:40.558 --> 02:31:42.493
. I DO NOTWANT TO HAVE A I DID
02:31:42.560 --> 02:31:44.895
NOT WANT TO BRING A BILL TO YOUR
02:31:44.962 --> 02:31:46.063
FLOOR. THERE'S THAT DOES NOT
02:31:46.130 --> 02:31:48.032
HAVE HER SUPPORT. LET ME SAY
02:31:48.098 --> 02:31:50.868
THAT. AND SO MY COMMITMENT IS
02:31:50.935 --> 02:31:52.603
THAT I WILL WORK WITH THEIR TO
02:31:52.670 --> 02:31:54.338
GET TO A BETTER PLACE. AND IF
02:31:54.405 --> 02:31:56.307
THIS COMES UP ON THE FLOOR
02:31:56.373 --> 02:31:57.408
SHOULD THIS MOVE TODAY? IT'S
02:31:57.475 --> 02:31:59.577
GOING TO BE WITH SOMETHING THAT
02:31:59.643 --> 02:32:00.244
SHE'S COMFORTABLE WITH, BECAUSE
02:32:00.311 --> 02:32:02.146
WE'VE HAD THE TIME WHEN SHE GETS
02:32:02.213 --> 02:32:04.515
BETTER TO FIGURE THAT OUT. AH!
02:32:04.582 --> 02:32:06.050
INTO THAT'S WHERE I'M AT TODAY
02:32:06.116 --> 02:32:07.251
TO THEM, ASKING THAT YOU ALLOW
02:32:07.318 --> 02:32:08.319
ME TO CONTINUE THOSE
02:32:08.385 --> 02:32:09.920
CONVERSATIONS. THINGS ARE, YOU
02:32:09.987 --> 02:32:12.990
KNOW A LITTLE HECTIC AND I DON'T
02:32:13.057 --> 02:32:15.125
MAKE CONTROL, BUT BECAUSE OF THE
02:32:15.192 --> 02:32:16.193
LINES, I AM ASKING THE COURTESY
02:32:16.260 --> 02:32:18.262
THAT WE MOVED THIS BILL TO THE
02:32:18.329 --> 02:32:19.730
NEXT COMMITTEE. SECOND HAVE THAT
02:32:19.797 --> 02:32:20.798
TIME WITH THE CHAIRWOMAN TO GET
02:32:20.865 --> 02:32:22.066
SOMETHING TO A BETTER PLACE, AND
02:32:22.132 --> 02:32:23.934
IF IT DOESN'T GET TO A BETTER
02:32:24.001 --> 02:32:25.002
PLACE WHERE SHE CAN BE
02:32:25.069 --> 02:32:26.804
SUPPORTIVE. I WILL NOT BE
02:32:26.871 --> 02:32:28.005
BRINGING THIS UP ON THE FLOOR.
02:32:28.072 --> 02:32:30.241
IT'S NOT THE TYPE OF WORK THAT I
02:32:30.307 --> 02:32:32.376
DO. IT'S NOT WHERE I WANT MY
02:32:32.443 --> 02:32:34.311
LEGACY TO END UP HERE AFTER 10
02:32:34.378 --> 02:32:35.379
YEARS IN THE IN THE LEGISLATURE
02:32:35.446 --> 02:32:37.781
AND SO I WOULD REQUEST THAT
02:32:37.848 --> 02:32:38.916
SOMEONE MOVED THE BILL AND THEN
02:32:38.983 --> 02:32:40.317
THAT WE HAD HE GAVE ME AND I
02:32:40.384 --> 02:32:42.987
VOTE TODAY TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT
02:32:43.053 --> 02:32:44.455
A GOOD SPOT FOR MY DISTRICT
02:32:44.522 --> 02:32:46.490
THAT'S TOOK BY 63 WAYS, AND
02:32:46.557 --> 02:32:47.625
WE'RE CONSTANTLY IN THE THREAT
02:32:47.691 --> 02:32:49.093
OF BEING THIS PLACE. WITH
02:32:49.159 --> 02:32:51.562
FREEWAY EXPANSIONS THAT ARE JUST
02:32:51.629 --> 02:32:53.697
FOR THE SAKE OF I DO WANT TO
02:32:53.764 --> 02:32:55.599
ADDRESS THE JOBS ISSUE. I WANT
02:32:55.666 --> 02:32:57.201
JOBS. I WANT THESE DOLLARS TO GO
02:32:57.268 --> 02:32:58.235
TO THINGS LIKE BUILDING THE
02:32:58.302 --> 02:33:00.204
WESTERN AND A BRANCH SOONER THAN
02:33:00.271 --> 02:33:03.207
LATER. I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:33:03.274 --> 02:33:05.409
WE ARE DOING INTERMODAL, UH,
02:33:05.476 --> 02:33:07.845
IDEAS AND THAT YOU KNOW, WE ARE
02:33:07.912 --> 02:33:09.747
LOOKING AT DIFFERENT WAYS TO
02:33:09.813 --> 02:33:11.615
MOVE PEOPLE AND MOVE GOODS AND
02:33:11.682 --> 02:33:13.918
THAT WE ARE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF
02:33:13.984 --> 02:33:15.786
TECHNOLOGY OUT THERE AND SO I
02:33:15.853 --> 02:33:17.488
WANT TO PUT THESE RESOURCES TO
02:33:17.555 --> 02:33:19.557
GOOD THAT ALSO PRODUCES JOBS IN
02:33:19.623 --> 02:33:20.991
A DIFFERENT WAY, AND A LITTLE
02:33:21.058 --> 02:33:22.493
CONCERNED OR CONFUSED ABOUT THE
02:33:22.560 --> 02:33:25.296
HOUSING DISCUSSION. OUT THERE. I
02:33:25.362 --> 02:33:26.797
HAVE A DIFFERENT BILL THAT I
02:33:26.864 --> 02:33:28.832
THINK THAT SOME OF THOSE
02:33:28.899 --> 02:33:30.501
ARGUMENTS ARE FAIR CRITICISMS OF
02:33:30.568 --> 02:33:31.435
A DIFFERENT BILL THAT THAT ISN'T
02:33:31.502 --> 02:33:33.237
MOVING. AND SO THE HOUSING PIECE
02:33:33.304 --> 02:33:35.539
HERE IS A LITTLE BIT CONFUSING.
02:33:35.606 --> 02:33:37.107
TO ME BECAUSE I ACTUALLY AM
02:33:37.174 --> 02:33:39.310
TRYING TO KEEP PEOPLE IN THEIR
02:33:39.376 --> 02:33:40.945
HOUSES INSTEAD OF DISPLACING
02:33:41.011 --> 02:33:43.514
THEM OUT THERE. AND SO WITH
02:33:43.581 --> 02:33:44.648
THAT, I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND
02:33:44.715 --> 02:33:46.517
I VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I
02:33:46.584 --> 02:33:48.919
SAID, DO WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
02:33:48.986 --> 02:33:51.522
ANY MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE ON A
02:33:51.589 --> 02:33:55.192
B 17 78? I'LL MAKE THE MOTION
02:33:55.259 --> 02:33:57.294
THE MOTIONS FROM SENATOR RUBIO
02:33:57.361 --> 02:33:58.929
AND THE CHAIR HAS NO
02:33:58.996 --> 02:33:59.930
RECOMMENDATION AGAIN. THE CHAIR
02:33:59.997 --> 02:34:03.067
HAD COMMITTED TO CONTINUE THE
02:34:03.133 --> 02:34:04.935
CONVERSATION IN THE EVENT. THIS
02:34:05.002 --> 02:34:06.437
BILL MOVES FORWARD WITH THE
02:34:06.503 --> 02:34:08.005
AUTHOR WITH A GOAL OF FINDING
02:34:08.072 --> 02:34:11.041
AMENDMENTS THAT THERE WOULD BE
02:34:11.108 --> 02:34:12.109
SATISFACTORY TO THE CHAIR IF AND
02:34:12.176 --> 02:34:14.178
WHEN IT REACHES THE FLOOR TO THE
02:34:14.244 --> 02:34:15.145
MOTIONS DO PASS. TO THE
02:34:15.212 --> 02:34:16.180
COMMITTEE APPROPRIATIONS. MISS
02:34:16.246 --> 02:34:17.748
WHITE. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:34:17.815 --> 02:34:21.685
FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX A. B 1778
02:34:21.752 --> 02:34:24.088
SENATORS NEWMAN I. BATES. BATES?
02:34:24.154 --> 02:34:27.958
NO, ALAN ARCHULETTA. BECKER.
02:34:28.025 --> 02:34:32.096
CORTEZ. SALLY. START.
02:34:32.162 --> 02:34:36.700
PITTSBURGH. LIMÓN MCGUIRE
02:34:36.767 --> 02:34:40.938
GALINDEZ MEN. RUBIO. RUBIO? AYE.
02:34:41.005 --> 02:34:50.814
SKINNER. WIECKOWSKI WILK. THAT
02:34:50.881 --> 02:34:53.851
BILL HAS TWO VOTES. UH WE WILL
02:34:53.917 --> 02:34:55.853
LEAVE IT ON CALL AND THANK YOU
02:34:55.919 --> 02:35:00.958
SHOULD REMEMBER. AND NOW.
02:35:01.025 --> 02:35:02.393
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PETRIE-NORRIS
02:35:02.459 --> 02:35:05.462
WELCOME AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:35:05.529 --> 02:35:06.230
PATIENTS. YOU WERE HERE TO
02:35:06.296 --> 02:35:08.732
PRESENT A B 24 96, PLEASE
02:35:08.799 --> 02:35:12.970
PROCEED AT YOUR LEISURE. THANK
02:35:13.037 --> 02:35:16.006
YOU, MR CHAIR AND GOOD AFTERNOON
02:35:16.073 --> 02:35:19.043
MEMBERS. SENATORS I AM HERE TO
02:35:19.109 --> 02:35:22.146
PRESENT A B 2496, WHICH PROVIDES
02:35:22.212 --> 02:35:23.147
OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES WITH A
02:35:23.213 --> 02:35:26.283
MUCH NEEDED TOOL. TO CURB
02:35:26.350 --> 02:35:27.651
HARMFUL NOISE POLLUTION FROM
02:35:27.718 --> 02:35:29.620
INTENTIONALLY AND ILLEGALLY
02:35:29.687 --> 02:35:31.355
MODIFIED VEHICLES. AT FIRST, I
02:35:31.422 --> 02:35:33.223
WOULD LIKE TO START BY THINKING
02:35:33.290 --> 02:35:35.259
YOUR STAFF FOR THEIR HARD WORK
02:35:35.325 --> 02:35:36.493
ON THIS BILL, AND I AM PLEASED
02:35:36.560 --> 02:35:38.128
TO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
02:35:38.195 --> 02:35:39.863
AMENDMENTS TODAY AND NOISE
02:35:39.930 --> 02:35:41.732
POLLUTION HAS BECOME A
02:35:41.799 --> 02:35:43.233
SIGNIFICANT PROBLEM FOR OUR
02:35:43.300 --> 02:35:44.802
LOCAL COMMUNITIES. CONSISTENT
02:35:44.868 --> 02:35:46.270
EXPOSURE TO NOISE CAN HAVE
02:35:46.336 --> 02:35:47.271
NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON HUMAN
02:35:47.337 --> 02:35:49.973
HEALTH. INCLUDING STRESS,
02:35:50.040 --> 02:35:51.108
ANXIETY, DEPRESSION, HIGH BLOOD
02:35:51.175 --> 02:35:53.077
PRESSURE AND HEART DISEASE,
02:35:53.143 --> 02:35:54.445
ACCORDING TO LOCAL LAW
02:35:54.511 --> 02:35:56.447
ENFORCEMENT NOISE POLLUTION IS
02:35:56.513 --> 02:35:57.815
OFTEN AND INCREASINGLY CAUSED BY
02:35:57.881 --> 02:35:58.982
VEHICLES THAT ARE INTENTIONALLY
02:35:59.049 --> 02:36:03.387
MODIFIED. EXCEED NOISE LIMITS.
02:36:03.454 --> 02:36:05.055
UNDER CURRENT LAW DRIVERS WHO
02:36:05.122 --> 02:36:07.024
ARE TICKETED FOR ILLEGALLY
02:36:07.091 --> 02:36:09.259
MODIFIED VEHICLES AND EXHAUSTS
02:36:09.326 --> 02:36:11.562
CAN PAY A FINE RATHER THAN FIX
02:36:11.628 --> 02:36:13.397
THE PROBLEM. AND SO THAT
02:36:13.464 --> 02:36:15.599
OBVIOUSLY ALLOWS THE PROBLEM TO
02:36:15.666 --> 02:36:18.769
CONTINUE A B 24 96 WOULD SIMPLY
02:36:18.836 --> 02:36:19.937
REQUIRE THAT DRIVERS WHO ARE
02:36:20.003 --> 02:36:24.374
TICKETED. MADE TO FIX THE
02:36:24.441 --> 02:36:25.609
ILLEGAL MODIFICATION WITHIN
02:36:25.676 --> 02:36:27.344
THREE MONTHS OR FACE A HOLD ON
02:36:27.411 --> 02:36:29.346
THEIR REGISTRATION. THIS WILL
02:36:29.413 --> 02:36:30.180
PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH AND
02:36:30.247 --> 02:36:31.815
IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE IN
02:36:31.882 --> 02:36:33.217
OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES. THAT BILL
02:36:33.283 --> 02:36:35.652
HAS ENJOYED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
02:36:35.719 --> 02:36:39.389
AND RECEIVED NO NO VOTES. AH, I
02:36:39.456 --> 02:36:41.225
AM NOW PLEASED TO WELCOME. I
02:36:41.291 --> 02:36:43.293
THINK TWO WITNESSES JOINING US
02:36:43.360 --> 02:36:45.295
TO TESTIFY ON THE PHONE IS BABA
02:36:45.362 --> 02:36:48.165
FISH. OF STREETS FOR ALL AS WELL
02:36:48.232 --> 02:36:50.567
AS LIEUTENANT TIM KLEISER OF THE
02:36:50.634 --> 02:36:53.237
LAGUNA BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT.
02:36:53.303 --> 02:36:54.471
AND THANK YOU, MR FISH. PLEASE
02:36:54.538 --> 02:36:59.743
PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
02:36:59.810 --> 02:37:01.378
AND COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS
02:37:01.445 --> 02:37:02.746
PUBLICATION AND THE LEGISLATIVE
02:37:02.813 --> 02:37:04.081
ADVOCATE WITH STREETS FOR ALL IN
02:37:04.148 --> 02:37:06.083
L, A COUNTY NONPROFIT,
02:37:06.150 --> 02:37:07.084
ADVOCATING FOR SAFE, SUSTAINABLE
02:37:07.151 --> 02:37:09.386
AND EQUITABLE TRANSPORTATION. WE
02:37:09.453 --> 02:37:11.355
WANT TO THANK TEACHER NEUROSES
02:37:11.421 --> 02:37:12.422
AND CO AUTHOR SENATOR
02:37:12.489 --> 02:37:14.792
PORTANTINO'S OFFICES AND I'M
02:37:14.858 --> 02:37:16.226
HERE TODAY AS A PROUD SPONSOR OF
02:37:16.293 --> 02:37:18.929
A B 24 96, SPEAKING IN SUPPORT
02:37:18.996 --> 02:37:21.365
NOISE POLLUTION IS NOT MERELY A
02:37:21.431 --> 02:37:22.766
NUISANCE. IT'S A GROWING PUBLIC
02:37:22.833 --> 02:37:24.301
HEALTH CRISIS. CONSISTENT
02:37:24.368 --> 02:37:26.303
EXPOSURE TO LOUD NOISES PROVEN
02:37:26.370 --> 02:37:27.037
TO INCREASE RISK OF HYPERTENSION
02:37:27.104 --> 02:37:28.038
HEARING LOSS, DIFFICULTY
02:37:28.105 --> 02:37:31.742
SLEEPING. STRESS LEVELS AND
02:37:31.809 --> 02:37:34.011
CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE, ONE
02:37:34.077 --> 02:37:36.246
RECENT STUDY DOWN THAT EXPOSURE
02:37:36.313 --> 02:37:37.581
TO NOISE POLLUTION SIGNIFICANTLY
02:37:37.648 --> 02:37:39.049
NEGATIVELY IMPACTED THE HEALTH,
02:37:39.116 --> 02:37:39.983
WELLNESS AND ACADEMIC
02:37:40.050 --> 02:37:40.984
PERFORMANCE OF SCHOOL CHILDREN
02:37:41.051 --> 02:37:43.153
EXPOSED TO IT. CURRENTLY DRIVERS
02:37:43.220 --> 02:37:44.221
TICKETED FOR ILLEGALLY MODIFIED
02:37:44.288 --> 02:37:47.958
EXHAUST. CAN OPT TO PAY A FINE
02:37:48.025 --> 02:37:49.092
RATHER THAN FIXED AMOUNT OF
02:37:49.159 --> 02:37:50.160
VACATION. AS THE
02:37:50.227 --> 02:37:52.930
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JUST JUST SAID
02:37:52.996 --> 02:37:54.898
, BUT WITHOUT REQUIRING DRIVERS
02:37:54.965 --> 02:37:56.834
TO FIX THE PROBLEM, COMMUNITIES
02:37:56.900 --> 02:37:57.968
ARE LEFT TO SUFFER FROM HARMFUL
02:37:58.035 --> 02:37:59.102
NOISE POLLUTION WITHOUT ANY
02:37:59.169 --> 02:38:01.205
TOOLS TO RESOLVE IT. SO A B 24
02:38:01.271 --> 02:38:03.607
96 WOULD ADDRESS THIS BY
02:38:03.674 --> 02:38:04.608
REQUIRING DRIVERS TICKETED FOR
02:38:04.675 --> 02:38:06.143
AN ILLEGALLY MODIFIED EXHAUST.
02:38:06.210 --> 02:38:08.178
TO EARN A CERTIFICATION THAT
02:38:08.245 --> 02:38:09.580
THEY FIX THIS MODIFICATION
02:38:09.646 --> 02:38:10.180
WITHIN THREE MONTHS OR FACE A
02:38:10.247 --> 02:38:11.081
HOLE IN THEIR VEHICLE
02:38:11.148 --> 02:38:13.550
REGISTRATION. ACQUIRING
02:38:13.617 --> 02:38:15.152
VIOLATORS TO ACTUALLY FIX
02:38:15.219 --> 02:38:16.720
ILLEGALLY MODIFIED EQUIPMENT
02:38:16.787 --> 02:38:18.722
PROVIDES US AN IMPORTANT TOOL TO
02:38:18.789 --> 02:38:19.323
PREVENT NOISE POLLUTION FROM
02:38:19.389 --> 02:38:21.959
INTENTIONALLY MODIFIED VEHICLES
02:38:22.025 --> 02:38:23.493
. AND YOU KNOW, THESE ARE
02:38:23.560 --> 02:38:24.695
VEHICLES THAT ARE VERY EXPENSIVE
02:38:24.761 --> 02:38:28.765
TO MODIFY. AND ON AVERAGE, AND,
02:38:28.832 --> 02:38:30.500
YOU KNOW, IT'S A SPECIFIC CHOICE
02:38:30.567 --> 02:38:32.169
TO BE MADE, SO THIS WILL PROTECT
02:38:32.236 --> 02:38:34.304
PUBLIC HEALTH AND ENSURE A
02:38:34.371 --> 02:38:36.173
HIGHER QUALITY OF LIFE IN OUR
02:38:36.240 --> 02:38:37.241
LOCAL COMMUNITIES. WITHOUT
02:38:37.307 --> 02:38:38.108
RELYING FURTHER ON TRAFFIC
02:38:38.175 --> 02:38:39.376
STOPS. FROM ARMED LAW
02:38:39.443 --> 02:38:42.246
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. AND MAYBE
02:38:42.312 --> 02:38:45.616
24 96 WILL TAKE, UM ONE MAJOR
02:38:45.682 --> 02:38:47.184
FIRST STEP TOWARDS ADDRESSING
02:38:47.251 --> 02:38:48.452
THE RAMPANT PROBLEM WITH NOISE
02:38:48.518 --> 02:38:49.920
POLLUTION IN OUR CITIES,
02:38:49.987 --> 02:38:50.921
IMPROVING THE HEALTH AND QUALITY
02:38:50.988 --> 02:38:52.656
OF LIFE FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS. SO
02:38:52.723 --> 02:38:54.691
I DO RESPECTFULLY URGE FOR AN I
02:38:54.758 --> 02:38:57.427
VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH. UM AND
02:38:57.494 --> 02:38:58.862
THANK YOU AND LIEUTENANT
02:38:58.929 --> 02:39:00.364
PLEASURE. BEFORE YOU BEGIN. LET
02:39:00.430 --> 02:39:03.467
LET ME JUST ASK THAT THIS IS
02:39:03.533 --> 02:39:04.902
THIS WILL BE THE LAST BILL WE
02:39:04.968 --> 02:39:06.803
DO, AND WE STILL HAVE A CONSENT
02:39:06.870 --> 02:39:08.605
COUNTER ANY MEMBERS COMMITTEE OR
02:39:08.672 --> 02:39:10.173
THEIR STAFFS WHO CAN TRACK THEM
02:39:10.240 --> 02:39:11.508
DOWN IF WE WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR
02:39:11.575 --> 02:39:14.478
ATTENDANCE. HERE IN THE CHAMBER
02:39:14.544 --> 02:39:15.545
FOR THE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE
02:39:15.612 --> 02:39:16.647
HEARINGS, LIEUTENANT PLEASURE.
02:39:16.713 --> 02:39:18.916
PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON,
02:39:18.982 --> 02:39:19.917
MR CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
02:39:19.983 --> 02:39:23.253
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS LIEUTENANT
02:39:23.320 --> 02:39:24.388
TIM, QUASI, WITH CITY WAS GOING
02:39:24.454 --> 02:39:25.122
TO BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT ON
02:39:25.188 --> 02:39:26.957
BEHALF OF THE CITY. LAGUNA
02:39:27.024 --> 02:39:27.958
BEACH. I LIKE TO EXPRESS OUR
02:39:28.025 --> 02:39:29.927
STEADFAST SUPPORT FOR A B 24 96,
02:39:29.993 --> 02:39:31.094
WHICH WILL ADDRESS LOUD VEHICLE
02:39:31.161 --> 02:39:33.797
NOISE. THE CITY OF LAGUNA BEACH
02:39:33.864 --> 02:39:35.699
IS A SMALL COASTAL COMMUNITY IN
02:39:35.766 --> 02:39:36.600
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, THE CITY
02:39:36.667 --> 02:39:37.367
COUNCIL AND THE POLICE
02:39:37.434 --> 02:39:38.468
DEPARTMENT RECEIVED NUMEROUS
02:39:38.535 --> 02:39:39.536
COMPLAINTS FROM RESIDENTS WEEKLY
02:39:39.603 --> 02:39:42.272
ABOUT LOUD VEHICLE NOISE.
02:39:42.339 --> 02:39:43.507
VEHICLE NOISE IS PERSISTENT
02:39:43.573 --> 02:39:44.908
PROBLEM IN OUR COMMUNITY HAS
02:39:44.975 --> 02:39:46.043
BEEN A CONSISTENT BURDEN ON OUR
02:39:46.109 --> 02:39:46.944
LAW ENFORCEMENT ILLEGALLY
02:39:47.010 --> 02:39:48.378
ILLEGALLY MODIFIED VEHICLES AS
02:39:48.445 --> 02:39:49.913
WELL AS BRAND NEW SUPERCARS AND
02:39:49.980 --> 02:39:51.381
MODIFIED MOTORCYCLES,
02:39:51.448 --> 02:39:52.616
MOTORCYCLES ROOM THE STREETS OF
02:39:52.683 --> 02:39:53.784
LAGUNA BEACH AND PACIFIC COAST
02:39:53.850 --> 02:39:55.552
HIGHWAY. THAT CAUSED SIGNIFICANT
02:39:55.619 --> 02:39:57.521
QUALITY OF LIFE CONCERNS FOR THE
02:39:57.587 --> 02:39:59.289
RESIDENTS OF THE ENTIRE REGION.
02:39:59.356 --> 02:40:01.091
THAT VEHICLE NOISE ROUTINELY
02:40:01.158 --> 02:40:02.259
DISRUPT DAILY LIVES OF OUR
02:40:02.326 --> 02:40:03.961
RESIDENTS AND CAN EVEN HAVE LONG
02:40:04.027 --> 02:40:06.596
TERM EFFECTS ON MENTAL HEALTH AS
02:40:06.663 --> 02:40:07.597
WELL AS SERIOUS IMPACTS
02:40:07.664 --> 02:40:08.165
ENVIRONMENT ENVIRONMENTALLY
02:40:08.231 --> 02:40:10.200
SENSITIVE AREAS. THE CITY OF
02:40:10.267 --> 02:40:11.401
LAGUNA BEACH, HAS BEEN A
02:40:11.468 --> 02:40:12.769
REGIONAL LEADER AND ADDRESSING
02:40:12.836 --> 02:40:13.537
LOUD VEHICLE NOISE IN ORANGE
02:40:13.603 --> 02:40:15.172
COUNTY. ALONG WITH THE CITIES OF
02:40:15.238 --> 02:40:15.739
HUNTINGTON'S BEACHES, SEAL
02:40:15.806 --> 02:40:17.307
BEACH, NEWPORT BEACH AND THE
02:40:17.374 --> 02:40:18.675
ORANGE COUNTY SHERIFF'S
02:40:18.742 --> 02:40:19.309
DEPARTMENT. WE HAVE ESTABLISHED
02:40:19.376 --> 02:40:21.278
JOINT TASK FORCES AND MAJOR
02:40:21.345 --> 02:40:22.312
MAJOR COMBINED OPERATIONS THAT
02:40:22.379 --> 02:40:23.780
INCLUDE EDUCATIONAL CAMPAIGNS.
02:40:23.847 --> 02:40:27.384
AND MESSAGE BOARDS TO MOTORISTS.
02:40:27.451 --> 02:40:29.686
WE BELIEVE THAT THE BILL IS THE
02:40:29.753 --> 02:40:30.587
RIGHT APPROACH TO ADDRESSING THE
02:40:30.654 --> 02:40:31.722
PROBLEM. UNDER CURRENT LAW
02:40:31.788 --> 02:40:32.956
CITATIONS ALLOWED VEHICLE
02:40:33.023 --> 02:40:33.924
KNOWLEDGE AND CONSIDERED
02:40:33.991 --> 02:40:34.591
CORRECTABLE EQUIPMENT VIOLATIONS
02:40:34.658 --> 02:40:36.126
AND THEREFORE NOT REQUIRED TO BE
02:40:36.193 --> 02:40:39.096
FIXED. WE BELIEVE THE SPIRIT OF
02:40:39.162 --> 02:40:40.130
THE LAW SHOULD BE ENCOURAGED
02:40:40.197 --> 02:40:41.631
SHOULD ENCOURAGE VIOLATORS TO
02:40:41.698 --> 02:40:42.366
REPLACE ILLEGAL EXHAUSTED
02:40:42.432 --> 02:40:44.568
EQUIPMENT IN ORDER TO BRING THEM
02:40:44.634 --> 02:40:45.602
INTO COMPLIANCE WITH CURRENT
02:40:45.669 --> 02:40:47.371
EMISSIONS AND NOISE WALLS. MAYBE
02:40:47.437 --> 02:40:49.573
2024 96 WILL SIMPLY REQUIRE
02:40:49.639 --> 02:40:50.474
PROOF OF CORRECTION FOR
02:40:50.540 --> 02:40:51.875
VIOLATIONS OF THE VEHICLE CODE
02:40:51.942 --> 02:40:53.577
RELATED TO VEHICLE NOISE ENSURE
02:40:53.643 --> 02:40:54.978
THAT VIOLATORS ARE NOT PAYING
02:40:55.045 --> 02:40:56.680
THEIR WAY OUT OF TICKETS AND
02:40:56.747 --> 02:40:58.448
THAT QUALITY OF LIFE CAN BE
02:40:58.515 --> 02:40:58.982
MAINTAINED. THANK YOU FOR
02:40:59.049 --> 02:41:03.153
CONSIDERATION OF A B 24 96. AND
02:41:03.220 --> 02:41:05.522
THANK YOU THERE ANY WITNESSES
02:41:05.589 --> 02:41:06.156
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM? WE'D
02:41:06.223 --> 02:41:07.724
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF
02:41:07.791 --> 02:41:11.728
THE BILL. SEEING NONE. LET'S GO
02:41:11.795 --> 02:41:13.363
TO THE CONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
02:41:13.430 --> 02:41:14.765
ANY ANY ANY GOOD IN THE
02:41:14.831 --> 02:41:16.666
CONFERENCE LINE LIKE TESTIFYING
02:41:16.733 --> 02:41:17.801
IN SUPPORT OF A B 24 96, MR
02:41:17.868 --> 02:41:22.205
MODERATOR? IF THERE ARE ANY IN
02:41:22.272 --> 02:41:27.611
SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS 10. WILL
02:41:27.677 --> 02:41:29.646
GO TO LINE 1 33, PLEASE GO
02:41:29.713 --> 02:41:33.817
AHEAD. WESTWARD ADMIN ON BEHALF
02:41:33.884 --> 02:41:35.652
OF ACTIVE THING, YOU REAL VALLEY
02:41:35.719 --> 02:41:40.590
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
02:41:40.657 --> 02:41:41.992
WE DO HAVE A FEW OTHER THAT HAVE
02:41:42.059 --> 02:41:43.794
QUEUED UP ONE MOMENT WHILE THEIR
02:41:43.860 --> 02:41:45.362
LINE NUMBERS TAKEN. AND AGAIN
02:41:45.429 --> 02:41:46.730
WHILE WE'RE WAITING. IF YOU'RE A
02:41:46.797 --> 02:41:48.298
MEMBER OF THE SENATE COMMITTEE
02:41:48.365 --> 02:41:49.032
ON TRANSPORTATION, WE WOULD
02:41:49.099 --> 02:41:50.901
APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENCE AT THE
02:41:50.967 --> 02:41:52.202
SOONEST POSSIBLE OPPORTUNITY IN
02:41:52.269 --> 02:41:53.937
THE HEARING ROOM, WHICH IS IN
02:41:54.004 --> 02:42:04.247
THE CHAMBER. NEXT WE'LL GO TO
02:42:04.314 --> 02:42:07.884
LINE 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD. QUARRY
02:42:07.951 --> 02:42:09.453
TALKING IN WITH TOWNS AND PUBLIC
02:42:09.519 --> 02:42:12.089
AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF TE CITIES
02:42:12.155 --> 02:42:13.890
OF HUNTINGTON'S BEACH, IRVINE,
02:42:13.957 --> 02:42:15.992
NEWPORT BEACH, HAYWARD, CHINO
02:42:16.059 --> 02:42:17.294
HILLS AND OCEAN SIDE AND SUPPORT
02:42:17.360 --> 02:42:19.763
OF 24 96. THANK YOU NEXT,
02:42:19.830 --> 02:42:24.734
PLEASE. AND THEY'RE CURRENTLY
02:42:24.801 --> 02:42:27.804
NONE OTHER IN THE QUEUE.
02:42:27.871 --> 02:42:29.372
ALRIGHT, LET'S LET US COME BACK
02:42:29.439 --> 02:42:31.975
TO THE HEARING ROOM. I SHOW A
02:42:32.042 --> 02:42:33.110
WITNESS IN OUR POSITION. AND MR
02:42:33.176 --> 02:42:34.244
JAMES LOMBARDO. MR LOMBARDO,
02:42:34.311 --> 02:42:37.848
WELCOME. PLEASE PROCEED. MR
02:42:37.914 --> 02:42:39.116
CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
02:42:39.182 --> 02:42:40.150
COMMITTEE. JAMES LOMBARDO,
02:42:40.217 --> 02:42:41.118
SENIOR ON BEHALF OF THE DATA,
02:42:41.184 --> 02:42:43.520
CALIFORNIA MOTORCYCLE RIGHTS AND
02:42:43.587 --> 02:42:47.958
WRITERS ORGANIZATION. UM WHILE
02:42:48.024 --> 02:42:49.860
WE DO NOT CONDONE OR SUPPORT
02:42:49.926 --> 02:42:51.027
LOUD PIPES ON MOTORCYCLES OR
02:42:51.094 --> 02:42:54.831
AUTOMOBILES. I THINK THERE'S
02:42:54.898 --> 02:42:56.433
SOME TECHNICAL PROBLEMS IN THE
02:42:56.500 --> 02:42:58.034
ENFORCEMENT OF THIS BILL ISN'T
02:42:58.101 --> 02:43:04.007
FAIR AT ALL. IN 2012. SB 4 35 BY
02:43:04.074 --> 02:43:07.777
SENATOR PAVLE WAS PASSED AND WE
02:43:07.844 --> 02:43:09.746
REMOVED OUR OPPOSITION WHEN SHE
02:43:09.813 --> 02:43:12.682
INSERTED THAT ALL MOTORCYCLE
02:43:12.749 --> 02:43:15.752
EXHAUST PIPES WOULD HAVE TO HAVE
02:43:15.819 --> 02:43:19.789
THE FEDERAL APPROVED. A STAMP ON
02:43:19.856 --> 02:43:22.959
THEIR MOTORCYCLE PIPES. AND IF
02:43:23.026 --> 02:43:25.028
SO, THAT THEY WERE, THEY WERE,
02:43:25.095 --> 02:43:29.432
THEY WOULD PASS. THE NOISE. TEST
02:43:29.499 --> 02:43:30.634
BECAUSE IT MET THE FEDERAL
02:43:30.700 --> 02:43:32.969
STANDARD AND THE STATE STANDARD.
02:43:33.036 --> 02:43:35.906
THOSE OTHER MOTORCYCLE PIPES,
02:43:35.972 --> 02:43:38.775
UH, SAY FOR OFF ROAD USE ONLY.
02:43:38.842 --> 02:43:40.644
AND SO CURRENTLY FOR THE LAST
02:43:40.710 --> 02:43:43.680
EIGHT YEARS, LAW ENFORCEMENT OF
02:43:43.747 --> 02:43:44.714
THESE PEOPLE THAT TESTIFIED
02:43:44.781 --> 02:43:46.917
SUPPORT HAVE HAD A TOOL TO GO
02:43:46.983 --> 02:43:48.385
OUT AND SITE MOTORCYCLES IF
02:43:48.451 --> 02:43:53.857
THEY'VE BEEN TOO LOUD. THAT THAT
02:43:53.924 --> 02:43:57.027
LAW ALLOWS ANYTIME MORE, UH
02:43:57.093 --> 02:43:59.396
OFFICER AS A LEGAL STOP OR IF A
02:43:59.462 --> 02:44:02.599
MOTORCYCLE IS PULLED ON PUBLIC
02:44:02.666 --> 02:44:04.534
ROAD PUBLIC PARKING LOT. THEY
02:44:04.601 --> 02:44:06.903
HAVE THE RIGHT TO PUT A MIRROR
02:44:06.970 --> 02:44:07.971
UNDER THE EXHAUSTED IF IT
02:44:08.038 --> 02:44:09.239
DOESN'T HAVE THAT STICKER THEY
02:44:09.306 --> 02:44:11.141
CAN GIVE THEM A CITATION AS
02:44:11.208 --> 02:44:13.944
WELL. SO THE OTHER PART OF THE
02:44:14.010 --> 02:44:15.879
BILL CALLS FOR CLEARING THIS
02:44:15.946 --> 02:44:17.581
THROUGH THE BEER OF AUTOMOTIVE
02:44:17.647 --> 02:44:19.649
REPAIR. THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT IT
02:44:19.716 --> 02:44:21.718
IS THAT BUREAU OF AUTOMOTIVE
02:44:21.785 --> 02:44:24.721
REPAIR THE OUT BEER B. A. R. HAS
02:44:24.788 --> 02:44:26.856
NO AUTHORITY NOR ANY EQUIPMENT
02:44:26.923 --> 02:44:28.058
TO CHECK AND VERIFY MOTORCYCLE
02:44:28.124 --> 02:44:31.428
EQUIPPED MOTORCYCLE EXHAUST
02:44:31.494 --> 02:44:34.531
PIPES, SO I'M NOT TOO SURE IF
02:44:34.598 --> 02:44:36.066
THESE VEHICLES GET A TICKET, HOW
02:44:36.132 --> 02:44:37.167
THEY'RE GOING TO GET THEM
02:44:37.234 --> 02:44:40.904
CLEARED. THE OTHER PART IS
02:44:40.971 --> 02:44:43.073
SENATOR PORTANTINO, AND THIS
02:44:43.139 --> 02:44:45.609
HOUSE PASSED SB 10 79, WHICH
02:44:45.675 --> 02:44:46.676
ALLOWED FOR ROADSIDE NOISE
02:44:46.743 --> 02:44:50.914
TESTING. THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN A
02:44:50.981 --> 02:44:52.515
MUCH FAIRER WAY OF FINDING OUT
02:44:52.582 --> 02:44:54.751
WHAT VEHICLES ACTUALLY BREAK THE
02:44:54.818 --> 02:44:57.587
DECIBEL BARRIER RATHER THAN JUST
02:44:57.654 --> 02:44:58.788
THE RANDOM HERE OF A POLICE
02:44:58.855 --> 02:45:02.125
OFFICER. THAT BILL IN THE
02:45:02.192 --> 02:45:06.563
ASSEMBLY BECAUSE THAT EQUIPMENT
02:45:06.630 --> 02:45:08.064
HAS ONLY BEEN USED IN NASHVILLE
02:45:08.131 --> 02:45:11.201
, TENNESSEE AND NEW YORK. BOTH
02:45:11.268 --> 02:45:12.602
OF THOSE ARE PILOT STUDIES WHERE
02:45:12.669 --> 02:45:13.737
THEY'RE TRYING TO EVALUATE HOW
02:45:13.803 --> 02:45:17.040
YOU PICK UP WHAT VEHICLE GOING
02:45:17.107 --> 02:45:18.808
DOWN THE ROAD HAS THE HAS
02:45:18.875 --> 02:45:19.943
ALLOWED NOISE. AND HOW DO YOU
02:45:20.010 --> 02:45:21.911
TICKET SO THAT'S AN ONGOING
02:45:21.978 --> 02:45:25.282
STUDY. THE BILL WAS AMENDED TO
02:45:25.348 --> 02:45:26.449
HAVE THE CALIFORNIA HIGHWAY
02:45:26.516 --> 02:45:30.186
PATROL. EVALUATE THIS EQUIPMENT
02:45:30.253 --> 02:45:32.489
AND COME BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE
02:45:32.555 --> 02:45:33.490
WITH THEIR RECOMMENDATIONS,
02:45:33.556 --> 02:45:35.225
WHETHER THIS STUFF WILL WORK OR
02:45:35.292 --> 02:45:38.328
NOT. SO I WOULD SUGGEST THAT THE
02:45:38.395 --> 02:45:40.430
BILL BE HELD IN COMMITTEE SINCE
02:45:40.497 --> 02:45:41.965
IT DOESN'T EVEN GO INTO EFFECT
02:45:42.032 --> 02:45:43.767
UNTIL 2027 AT THE DEPARTMENT OF
02:45:43.833 --> 02:45:47.103
MOTOR VEHICLES. SO FOR THOSE
02:45:47.170 --> 02:45:48.471
REASONS WERE OPPOSED THE BILL.
02:45:48.538 --> 02:45:50.307
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK
02:45:50.373 --> 02:45:51.775
YOU, SIR, AS ANYBODY ELSE HERE
02:45:51.841 --> 02:45:53.443
WHO WOULD LIKE TO TEST JOIN
02:45:53.510 --> 02:45:55.478
OPPOSITION HERE IN THE CHAMBER
02:45:55.545 --> 02:45:56.846
TO THE BILL? MAYBE 24 96 SEEING
02:45:56.913 --> 02:46:00.150
NONE. LET'S GO TO THE
02:46:00.216 --> 02:46:01.584
TELECONFERENCING. MR MODERATOR.
02:46:01.651 --> 02:46:02.619
IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE
02:46:02.686 --> 02:46:03.753
TELECONFERENCE? I'D LIKE TO
02:46:03.820 --> 02:46:05.588
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO BE 24
02:46:05.655 --> 02:46:10.994
96. OF COURSE. AND IF YOU ARE IN
02:46:11.061 --> 02:46:17.367
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10.
02:46:17.434 --> 02:46:18.435
THAT'S CURRENTLY NONE IN THE
02:46:18.501 --> 02:46:22.439
QUEUE. THANK YOU AND BRING IT
02:46:22.505 --> 02:46:24.674
BACK TO THE HEARING ROOM MEMBERS
02:46:24.741 --> 02:46:25.875
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THE
02:46:25.942 --> 02:46:33.450
BILL? LET ME ASK A QUESTION OF
02:46:33.516 --> 02:46:35.218
THE AUTHOR. SO THE OPPOSITION
02:46:35.285 --> 02:46:36.920
RAISED TWO POINTS. ONE IS ABOUT
02:46:36.986 --> 02:46:38.254
SUBJECTIVITY AT THE INABILITY
02:46:38.321 --> 02:46:40.890
FOR, UM SOMEBODY WITH AUTHORITY
02:46:40.957 --> 02:46:42.826
TO IDENTIFY THE MOTOR SECOND
02:46:42.892 --> 02:46:45.628
QUESTION AND THE OTHER WAS ABOUT
02:46:45.695 --> 02:46:46.863
OPPORTUNITIES FOR CURE. SO IF
02:46:46.930 --> 02:46:49.332
YOU COULD SPEAK TO THAT GRATEFUL
02:46:49.399 --> 02:46:51.568
, CERTAINLY, UM SO I THINK THE
02:46:51.634 --> 02:46:54.304
FIRST QUESTION AROUND THESE
02:46:54.371 --> 02:46:55.405
TICKETS BEING ISSUED
02:46:55.472 --> 02:46:58.541
SUBJECTIVELY. THAT'S JUST
02:46:58.608 --> 02:47:00.744
INACCURATE. THESE TICKETS ARE
02:47:00.810 --> 02:47:02.345
ISSUED BY LAW ENFORCEMENT AND MY
02:47:02.412 --> 02:47:03.947
COMMUNITIES AND COMMUNITIES
02:47:04.013 --> 02:47:06.182
ACROSS THE STATE ONCE THERE IS
02:47:06.249 --> 02:47:07.183
EVIDENCE OF AN ILLEGAL
02:47:07.250 --> 02:47:12.122
MODIFICATION. IN TERMS OF THE.
02:47:12.188 --> 02:47:14.357
THE QUESTION AROUND ABILITY TO
02:47:14.424 --> 02:47:17.694
CURE. UM I THINK WE HAVE A
02:47:17.761 --> 02:47:18.962
DIFFERENT INTERPRETATION OF THE
02:47:19.028 --> 02:47:20.063
LIE, AS DO THE CONSULTANTS FOR
02:47:20.130 --> 02:47:23.333
THE TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE AND
02:47:23.400 --> 02:47:26.236
IT IS MY BELIEF AND THE BELIEF
02:47:26.302 --> 02:47:27.971
OF THE COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS AND
02:47:28.037 --> 02:47:31.441
STAFF THAT THE MEASURE AS
02:47:31.508 --> 02:47:34.577
DETAILED IN THE BILL, IN FACT,
02:47:34.644 --> 02:47:35.779
DOES ALLOW A RIGHT TO QUOTE TO
02:47:35.845 --> 02:47:38.248
CURE. BOTH FOR AUTOMOBILE
02:47:38.314 --> 02:47:40.850
VIOLATORS, AS WELL AS MOTORCYCLE
02:47:40.917 --> 02:47:41.951
OWNERS, MEMBERS. ANY OTHER
02:47:42.018 --> 02:47:45.588
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS NÓ
02:47:45.655 --> 02:47:46.389
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. WOULD YOU LIKE
02:47:46.456 --> 02:47:49.426
TO CLOSE WILL SIMPLY CLOSED BY
02:47:49.492 --> 02:47:51.127
RESPECTFULLY ASKING, AND I VOTE
02:47:51.194 --> 02:47:53.430
. THANK YOU. AND DO WE HAVE A
02:47:53.496 --> 02:48:00.970
MOTION FOR A B 24 96? THE SECRET
02:48:01.037 --> 02:48:03.039
TO SEE WITH THE MOTION. SO WE DO
02:48:03.106 --> 02:48:04.207
HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
02:48:04.274 --> 02:48:05.275
COURTESY. MISS WHITE. IF YOU
02:48:05.341 --> 02:48:07.544
COULD PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FOR
02:48:07.610 --> 02:48:10.513
FAT ITEM 28 A B 2496. THE MOTION
02:48:10.580 --> 02:48:12.215
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED, BUT
02:48:12.282 --> 02:48:13.516
FIRST AMENDMENT BE REFERRED TO
02:48:13.583 --> 02:48:14.851
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
02:48:14.918 --> 02:48:17.220
SENATORS. NEWMAN NEWMAN BATES
02:48:17.287 --> 02:48:19.656
BATES, I, ALAN. ARCHULETTA.
02:48:19.722 --> 02:48:23.259
BECKER. COURTESY. ORTEZ EI
02:48:23.326 --> 02:48:28.231
DOLLY! DODD. THOUGHT I HERZBERG
02:48:28.298 --> 02:48:32.602
LIMÓN. MCGUIRE MELINDA'S. MEN.
02:48:32.669 --> 02:48:37.340
RUBIO. RUBIO I SKINNER.
02:48:37.407 --> 02:48:48.585
WIECKOWSKI WILK. WILK? AYE. THAT
02:48:48.651 --> 02:48:52.021
IS SIX VOTES FOR ZERO AGAINST.
02:48:52.088 --> 02:48:53.656
WE'LL KEEP THE ROLE OPEN. THANKS
02:48:53.723 --> 02:48:54.824
FOR YOUR PATIENCE. THANK YOU,
02:48:54.891 --> 02:48:57.060
SENATORS. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
02:48:57.126 --> 02:49:00.663
UM, NOW IS STILL AWAITING A
02:49:00.730 --> 02:49:03.199
NUMBER OF OUR COLLEAGUES, UH,
02:49:03.266 --> 02:49:04.534
BUT IN THE ABSENCE OF THEIR
02:49:04.601 --> 02:49:07.670
ARRIVAL, LET US VOTE NOW ON THE
02:49:07.737 --> 02:49:08.571
CONSENT CALENDARS PLURAL. TODAY
02:49:08.638 --> 02:49:10.006
WE ACTUALLY HAVE TWO SEPARATE
02:49:10.073 --> 02:49:10.507
CONSENT CALENDARS. THIS
02:49:10.573 --> 02:49:14.978
AFTERNOON. UM THIS EVENING,
02:49:15.044 --> 02:49:16.446
ALMOST SO CONSENT CALENDAR. ONE
02:49:16.513 --> 02:49:17.947
WILL HAVE THE INDIVIDUAL BILLS
02:49:18.014 --> 02:49:19.849
THAT ARE LISTED ON CONSENT. I'M
02:49:19.916 --> 02:49:21.117
GOING TO LIST THEM OUT. THESE
02:49:21.184 --> 02:49:23.786
ARE ITEMS FOR A B 10 37 FROM
02:49:23.853 --> 02:49:25.488
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON. ITEM
02:49:25.555 --> 02:49:26.322
SEVEN A. B 1800 FROM
02:49:26.389 --> 02:49:29.158
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LOW ITEM 12
02:49:29.225 --> 02:49:31.528
1983 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FONG
02:49:31.594 --> 02:49:33.763
ITEM. 13 A B 21 25 ALSO FROM
02:49:33.830 --> 02:49:36.032
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S VINCE PHÊN.
02:49:36.099 --> 02:49:38.034
ITEM. 15 A B 2061 FROM
02:49:38.101 --> 02:49:39.602
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING ITEM. 17
02:49:39.669 --> 02:49:41.070
2071 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:49:41.137 --> 02:49:44.207
PATTERSON ITEM 21 A B 21 74 FROM
02:49:44.274 --> 02:49:47.310
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CHEN ITEM 22 A
02:49:47.377 --> 02:49:49.479
B 22 54 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:49:49.546 --> 02:49:53.917
MURATSUCHI 24 A B 20 TO 64 FROM
02:49:53.983 --> 02:49:55.251
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM OUT OF
02:49:55.318 --> 02:49:56.352
26, MAYBE 23 50 FROM
02:49:56.419 --> 02:49:59.055
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WILSON. ITEM 27
02:49:59.122 --> 02:50:00.590
24 15 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:50:00.657 --> 02:50:03.593
LACKEY ITEM 2019 25 10 FROM
02:50:03.660 --> 02:50:05.094
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BENEDICT ITEM
02:50:05.161 --> 02:50:06.829
30 OF 25 14 FROM
02:50:06.896 --> 02:50:07.864
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S DOLLY ITEM 33
02:50:07.931 --> 02:50:11.568
27 63. FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:50:11.634 --> 02:50:15.071
KALRA ITEM, 34, WHICH IS A B 29
02:50:15.138 --> 02:50:16.306
56 FROM THE ASSEMBLY
02:50:16.372 --> 02:50:19.075
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE. UM
02:50:19.142 --> 02:50:20.944
MADAM CONSULTANT. IF YOU COULD
02:50:21.010 --> 02:50:22.178
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON THE
02:50:22.245 --> 02:50:23.313
FIRST OF THE TWO CONSENT
02:50:23.379 --> 02:50:26.115
CALENDARS. SENATORS NEWMAN, I
02:50:26.182 --> 02:50:30.753
BATES. BATES, I, ALAN. ALAN I
02:50:30.820 --> 02:50:35.625
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. ORTEZ.
02:50:35.692 --> 02:50:40.463
CORTEZ, EI DOLLY! SALLY, I DODD.
02:50:40.530 --> 02:50:44.701
DOT I HERTZBERG LIMÓN MCGUIRE
02:50:44.767 --> 02:50:48.705
MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S I MEN.
02:50:48.771 --> 02:50:54.577
MEANT I RUBIO RUBIO I SKINNER.
02:50:54.644 --> 02:50:57.046
SKINNER I WIECKOWSKI WILK. WILK?
02:50:57.113 --> 02:51:10.627
AYE. THAT HOUSE 11 VOTES FOR IT
02:51:10.693 --> 02:51:12.195
WILL GET I WILL LEAVE IT ON
02:51:12.261 --> 02:51:14.097
CALL. SECOND CONCERN CALENDAR
02:51:14.163 --> 02:51:15.531
INCLUDES THE VARIOUS NAMING
02:51:15.598 --> 02:51:16.532
RESOLUTIONS THAT ARE PENDING
02:51:16.599 --> 02:51:19.102
BEFORE THIS COMMITTEE. THESE ARE
02:51:19.168 --> 02:51:22.238
AS FOLLOWS ITEM 18 OR 1 30 FROM
02:51:22.305 --> 02:51:23.606
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PATTERSON ITEM
02:51:23.673 --> 02:51:26.542
. 1980 YEAR 1 42 ALSO FROM
02:51:26.609 --> 02:51:27.176
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PATTERSON ITEM
02:51:27.243 --> 02:51:29.145
, 20 A CR 1 64 FROM
02:51:29.212 --> 02:51:30.713
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PATTERSON ITEM.
02:51:30.780 --> 02:51:32.915
32 SCR 79 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:51:32.982 --> 02:51:35.985
NAZARIAN ITEM. 35 GR 74 FROM
02:51:36.052 --> 02:51:36.986
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALIS ITEM 36 A
02:51:37.053 --> 02:51:40.590
CR 1 57 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:51:40.657 --> 02:51:43.726
SALIS ITEM. 37 HCR 89 FROM
02:51:43.793 --> 02:51:44.827
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BIGELOW ITEM.
02:51:44.894 --> 02:51:47.697
38 1 26 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:51:47.764 --> 02:51:50.400
CUNNINGHAM ITEM 39 1 38 FROM
02:51:50.466 --> 02:51:52.468
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORA ITEM. 40
02:51:52.535 --> 02:51:53.870
IS HERE. 1 39 FROM
02:51:53.936 --> 02:51:55.605
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RAMOS ITEM 41.
02:51:55.672 --> 02:51:57.206
THIS YEAR. 1 44 FROM
02:51:57.273 --> 02:51:59.609
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAY ITEM. 42
02:51:59.676 --> 02:52:00.977
CR 1 48 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:52:01.044 --> 02:52:04.213
O'DONNELL ITEM. 43 HDR 151 FROM
02:52:04.280 --> 02:52:05.615
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BERMAN ITEM. 44
02:52:05.682 --> 02:52:06.716
ISSUE ARE 1 62 FROM
02:52:06.783 --> 02:52:09.252
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WENT AN ITEM.
02:52:09.318 --> 02:52:12.321
45 SCR 1 11 FROM OUR VERY OWN
02:52:12.388 --> 02:52:14.290
SENATOR DONE A MATTER RESULTING.
02:52:14.357 --> 02:52:17.060
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. THE
02:52:17.126 --> 02:52:19.762
SENATORS NEWMAN, I, BATES.
02:52:19.829 --> 02:52:22.265
BATES, I, ALAN. ALAN I
02:52:22.331 --> 02:52:26.502
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. ORTEZ.
02:52:26.569 --> 02:52:28.638
FORTESE? AYE, DOLLY. SALLY, I
02:52:28.705 --> 02:52:34.410
DODD. THOUGHT I HERTZBERG LIMÓN
02:52:34.477 --> 02:52:38.881
LIMÓN. AYE MCGUIRE. MELINDA'S.
02:52:38.948 --> 02:52:44.153
AYE. MELINDA'S, AYE. MEN. MEN. I
02:52:44.220 --> 02:52:47.757
RUBIO RUBIO I SKINNER.
02:52:47.824 --> 02:52:53.763
WIECKOWSKI WILK. WILK? AYE. VERY
02:52:53.830 --> 02:52:58.901
GOOD. UM. I ASSUME THAT'S ALSO
02:52:58.968 --> 02:53:00.970
11 0. THERE THAT IS 11 0 WILL
02:53:01.037 --> 02:53:02.839
HOLD THAT OPEN. THERE WILL BE
02:53:02.905 --> 02:53:05.842
OUT. LET'S GO BACK AND OPEN THE
02:53:05.908 --> 02:53:08.010
ROLL ON THE OTHER ITEMS AND WORK
02:53:08.077 --> 02:53:10.346
OUR WAY THROUGH IT. LET'S START
02:53:10.413 --> 02:53:11.481
WITH ITEM NUMBER 1 85 12.
02:53:11.547 --> 02:53:14.550
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLDING ME FIND
02:53:14.617 --> 02:53:16.352
THE RECOMMENDATION. APOLOGIES
02:53:16.419 --> 02:53:17.720
THE RECOMMENDATIONS DO PASS AS
02:53:17.787 --> 02:53:18.454
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS. MISS
02:53:18.521 --> 02:53:22.125
WHITE IF YOU COULD PLEASE ALWAYS
02:53:22.191 --> 02:53:23.059
. I'M SORRY. WE DON'T HAVE
02:53:23.126 --> 02:53:24.393
EMOTIONS BEFORE WE HAD CORN. I
02:53:24.460 --> 02:53:27.196
NEED A MOTION ON A B 5 12 FROM
02:53:27.263 --> 02:53:28.064
SENATOR MEN. THANK YOU, SIR.
02:53:28.131 --> 02:53:29.432
WITH MOTION, SENATOR. MEN,
02:53:29.499 --> 02:53:32.802
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
02:53:32.869 --> 02:53:38.674
NEWMAN, I BATES. A B 5 12. ITEM
02:53:38.741 --> 02:53:42.011
NUMBER ONE. START OVER SENATORS
02:53:42.078 --> 02:53:47.350
NEWMAN AYE, BATES. ALAN
02:53:47.416 --> 02:53:52.588
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. ORTEZ.
02:53:52.655 --> 02:53:56.859
CORTEZ, EI DOLLY! DAD. START I
02:53:56.926 --> 02:54:01.030
HERTZBERG LIMÓN LIMÓN. AYE
02:54:01.097 --> 02:54:05.701
MCGUIRE. MELINDA'S. MEN. MOMENT.
02:54:05.768 --> 02:54:11.307
I RUBIO RUBIO ICE SKINNER.
02:54:11.374 --> 02:54:14.577
SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI WILK.
02:54:14.644 --> 02:54:16.779
VOIGTS PROGRAMS THAT HERTZBERG?
02:54:16.846 --> 02:54:22.318
AYE. LET'S RECALL THAT ROLE
02:54:22.385 --> 02:54:23.486
CENTER WEST COAST YOU JUST GOT
02:54:23.553 --> 02:54:24.821
HERE. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
02:54:24.887 --> 02:54:31.060
MEMBERS. FILE ITEM. 1 85 12.
02:54:31.127 --> 02:54:34.130
NEWMAN. JUST ABSOLUTE RESULTS.
02:54:34.197 --> 02:54:40.203
THANK YOU. SENATORS BATES ALAN
02:54:40.269 --> 02:54:42.972
ALAN I ARCHULETTA. BECKER.
02:54:43.039 --> 02:54:47.810
SALLY. MCGUIRE MELINDA'S.
02:54:47.877 --> 02:54:53.850
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE.
02:54:53.916 --> 02:54:55.384
LET'S MOVE TO REMEMBER TO EVERY
02:54:55.451 --> 02:54:56.819
1919 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:54:56.886 --> 02:54:59.088
HOLDING. WE STILL NEED EMOTION,
02:54:59.155 --> 02:55:01.224
THE MOTION OR THE RECOMMENDATION
02:55:01.290 --> 02:55:03.426
WAS DUE PAST TWO APPROPRIATIONS
02:55:03.492 --> 02:55:04.460
. YOU WOULDN'T EVEN LIKE TO
02:55:04.527 --> 02:55:05.261
MOVE, SENATOR WELCOME MOVES THE
02:55:05.328 --> 02:55:07.663
BILL MISS WHITE, PLEASE CALL THE
02:55:07.730 --> 02:55:10.466
ROLL ON ITEM NUMBER TWO. PILE
02:55:10.533 --> 02:55:12.501
ITEM TO A B 1919 SENATORS.
02:55:12.568 --> 02:55:14.670
NEWMAN NEWMAN, I BATES BATES, I,
02:55:14.737 --> 02:55:20.142
ALAN. ALAN I ARCHULETTA. BECKER.
02:55:20.209 --> 02:55:25.114
ORTEZ. COURTESY, AYE. SALLY.
02:55:25.181 --> 02:55:30.786
SALLY, I DODD. DOT I HERZBERG
02:55:30.853 --> 02:55:33.089
HERZBERG. AYE, LIMÓN. LIMÓN. AYE
02:55:33.155 --> 02:55:36.325
MCGUIRE. MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S. I
02:55:36.392 --> 02:55:40.696
MEANT MEN. I RUBIO RUBIO I
02:55:40.763 --> 02:55:45.301
SKINNER. SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
02:55:45.368 --> 02:55:57.079
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK.
02:55:57.146 --> 02:55:59.215
THAT'S FOUR. THAT'S 14 0. THAT
02:55:59.282 --> 02:56:00.783
BILL IS OUT. LET'S GO TO ITEM
02:56:00.850 --> 02:56:03.519
RIVER THREE A. B 27 73 FROM
02:56:03.586 --> 02:56:07.089
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLD IN THE
02:56:07.156 --> 02:56:09.859
MOTION APOLOGIZE. WHAT'S THE
02:56:09.926 --> 02:56:16.866
MOTION? VIEW FOR THE. DO PASS
02:56:16.933 --> 02:56:18.834
AND BE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
02:56:18.901 --> 02:56:20.503
ON APPROPRIATIONS. AND DO WE
02:56:20.569 --> 02:56:24.373
HAVE A MOTION ON A B? 27 73?
02:56:24.440 --> 02:56:25.374
THANK YOU, SENATOR. COURTESY.
02:56:25.441 --> 02:56:30.313
PLEASE CALL THE ROOM. FILE ITEM
02:56:30.379 --> 02:56:34.016
NUMBER THREE A B 2773. SENATORS
02:56:34.083 --> 02:56:37.653
NEWMAN, I BATES. ALAN ALAN I
02:56:37.720 --> 02:56:42.692
ARCHULETTA. BECKER. CORTEZ.
02:56:42.758 --> 02:56:47.430
CORTEZ, EI DOLLY! SALLY NO DOT
02:56:47.496 --> 02:56:50.333
START I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG?
02:56:50.399 --> 02:56:55.705
AYE, LIMÓN. LIMÓN. AYE MCGUIRE.
02:56:55.771 --> 02:56:58.207
MELINDA'S MELINDA'S NO MEN. MEN.
02:56:58.274 --> 02:57:03.212
I RUBIO RUBIO I SKINNER.
02:57:03.279 --> 02:57:05.748
SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
02:57:05.815 --> 02:57:14.724
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK. NO.
02:57:14.790 --> 02:57:19.962
AND. THREE THE COUNTESS 10 3
02:57:20.029 --> 02:57:22.231
WILL WILL LEAVE THAT OPEN. LET'S
02:57:22.298 --> 02:57:24.300
MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER FIVE. THAT'S
02:57:24.367 --> 02:57:26.669
A B 17 13 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:57:26.736 --> 02:57:29.705
BOERNER HORVATH AND EMOTION
02:57:29.772 --> 02:57:30.873
THERE IS TO PASS TO THE
02:57:30.940 --> 02:57:34.510
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS. WE
02:57:34.577 --> 02:57:36.545
DID NOT HAVE EMOTION YET FOR
02:57:36.612 --> 02:57:38.514
THAT. THAT WAS BEFORE WE HAD A
02:57:38.581 --> 02:57:39.281
QUARREL. CAN I GET A MOTION ON
02:57:39.348 --> 02:57:41.317
THAT? UH SENATOR COURTESY
02:57:41.384 --> 02:57:42.351
RECOGNIZING YOUR HAND. PLEASE
02:57:42.418 --> 02:57:47.256
CALL HER UP. FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:57:47.323 --> 02:57:49.558
FIVE A. B 1713 SENATORS NEWMAN
02:57:49.625 --> 02:57:54.296
NEWMAN BATES BATES, I, ALAN.
02:57:54.363 --> 02:57:56.932
ALAN I ARCHULETTA. BECKER.
02:57:56.999 --> 02:58:01.537
CORTEZ. CORTEZ, EI DOLLY! SALLY
02:58:01.604 --> 02:58:06.308
NO, DODD. DOT I HERTZBERG
02:58:06.375 --> 02:58:09.178
PITTSBURGH. I LIMÓN LIMÓN. AYE
02:58:09.245 --> 02:58:13.049
MCGUIRE. MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S NO
02:58:13.115 --> 02:58:17.753
MEN. MOMENT. I RUBIO RUBIO ICE
02:58:17.820 --> 02:58:22.725
SKINNER. SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
02:58:22.792 --> 02:58:25.928
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK?
02:58:25.995 --> 02:58:39.075
AYE. THAT BILL IS HAS IS
02:58:39.141 --> 02:58:41.877
CURRENTLY AS 12 VOTES TO TWO.
02:58:41.944 --> 02:58:43.846
LET'S MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER SIX.
02:58:43.913 --> 02:58:45.047
THAT'S A B 17 78 FROM
02:58:45.114 --> 02:58:46.048
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CRISTINA
02:58:46.115 --> 02:58:48.984
GARCIA. THE CHAIR, HAD NO
02:58:49.051 --> 02:58:50.119
RECOMMENDATION BUT WANTED TO
02:58:50.186 --> 02:58:52.088
GIVE THE MEMBER TIME TO WORK OUT
02:58:52.154 --> 02:58:53.856
A SOLUTION. IF YOU COULD PLEASE
02:58:53.923 --> 02:58:57.860
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. FILE
02:58:57.927 --> 02:59:01.163
ITEM. 6 81 778. THE CURRENT VOTE
02:59:01.230 --> 02:59:03.866
IS 21 WITH THE CHAIR, VOTING
02:59:03.933 --> 02:59:05.067
VICE CHAIR, VOTING NO SENATORS
02:59:05.134 --> 02:59:11.941
ALLEN ALAN I ARCHULETTA. BECKER.
02:59:12.007 --> 02:59:18.848
HERZBERG, WHICH ONE IMAGE. LIMÓN
02:59:18.914 --> 02:59:23.319
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE, MELINDA'S.
02:59:23.385 --> 02:59:28.424
MEN. SKINNER. SKINNER. I
02:59:28.491 --> 02:59:33.729
WIECKOWSKI WILK. WIECKOWSKI I
02:59:33.796 --> 02:59:43.739
WILL KNOW. OKAY? I HEARD I
02:59:43.806 --> 02:59:57.319
SORRY. PRETTY MUCH ACCOUNT.
02:59:57.386 --> 02:59:59.121
CURRENT COUNTER 7 TO 2 WILL
02:59:59.188 --> 03:00:01.624
LEAVE THAT VOTE OPEN. LET'S MOVE
03:00:01.690 --> 03:00:03.726
NOW TO ITEM NUMBER EIGHT A. B
03:00:03.792 --> 03:00:04.927
1938 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:00:04.994 --> 03:00:07.763
FRIEDMAN IF YOU COULD PLEASE
03:00:07.830 --> 03:00:10.032
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. STORY
03:00:10.099 --> 03:00:11.934
AND WAS THAT BEFORE WE HAD A
03:00:12.001 --> 03:00:15.137
QUORUM? OKAY WE STILL NEED A
03:00:15.204 --> 03:00:16.438
MOTION ON EVERY 1938 FROM
03:00:16.505 --> 03:00:18.040
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN.
03:00:18.107 --> 03:00:19.341
SENATOR BECKER MOVES THE BILL.
03:00:19.408 --> 03:00:23.312
UH PLEASE CALL THE ROOM NUMBER
03:00:23.379 --> 03:00:25.848
EIGHT. A B 1938. THE MOTION IS
03:00:25.915 --> 03:00:27.049
DUE PASSES AMENDED, BUT FIRST WE
03:00:27.116 --> 03:00:28.984
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:00:29.051 --> 03:00:29.618
APPROPRIATIONS SENATORS NEWMAN.
03:00:29.685 --> 03:00:31.587
ALRIGHT, I BATES BATES EYES
03:00:31.654 --> 03:00:34.990
ALLEN. ALAN I ARCHULETTA.
03:00:35.057 --> 03:00:39.862
BECKER. BECKER. I ORTEZ. CORTEZ,
03:00:39.929 --> 03:00:47.069
EI DOLLY! DODD. DOT I HERZBERG
03:00:47.136 --> 03:00:49.438
HERZBERG. AYE, LIMÓN. LEMON, I
03:00:49.505 --> 03:00:55.311
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I. MELINDA'S
03:00:55.377 --> 03:00:59.281
MELINDA'S NO MEN. MEN. I RUBIO
03:00:59.348 --> 03:01:03.986
SKINNER. SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
03:01:04.053 --> 03:01:12.494
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK.
03:01:12.561 --> 03:01:26.108
RUBIO? AYE. YOU GET THAT? BILL
03:01:26.175 --> 03:01:28.377
HAS 14 VOTES TO ZERO. WE'LL
03:01:28.444 --> 03:01:30.746
WE'LL KEEP IT ON CALL. NEXT ITEM
03:01:30.813 --> 03:01:33.716
IS ITEM NUMBER NINE A. B 24 38
03:01:33.782 --> 03:01:35.851
FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN
03:01:35.918 --> 03:01:37.620
CHAIRS RECOMMENDATION WAS TO
03:01:37.686 --> 03:01:39.154
PASS AND REFER TO THE COMMITTEE
03:01:39.221 --> 03:01:42.925
ON APPROPRIATIONS. MATT AND I
03:01:42.992 --> 03:01:44.994
THINK WE STILL NEED A MOTION ON
03:01:45.060 --> 03:01:46.128
THAT BILL. IS THAT CORRECT? TO
03:01:46.195 --> 03:01:49.465
HAVE A MOTION FOR A B 24 38 FROM
03:01:49.531 --> 03:01:50.699
SENATOR BECKER? PLEASE CALL THE
03:01:50.766 --> 03:01:54.336
ROME FILE ITEM NINE. A. B 2438.
03:01:54.403 --> 03:01:55.604
THE MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST
03:01:55.671 --> 03:01:57.439
BE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:01:57.506 --> 03:01:58.374
APPROPRIATIONS. SENATORS, NEWMAN
03:01:58.440 --> 03:01:59.742
NOT VOTING. NO MAN THAT VOTING
03:01:59.808 --> 03:02:04.046
BATES BATES NOW, ALAN. ALAN I
03:02:04.113 --> 03:02:06.348
ARCHULETTA. ARCHULETTA. AYE,
03:02:06.415 --> 03:02:11.920
BECKER. BECKER. I ORTEZ. KURT,
03:02:11.987 --> 03:02:15.024
EASING UP VOTING DOLLY SALLY NO,
03:02:15.090 --> 03:02:20.195
DODD. DOT I HERTZBERG VOTING.
03:02:20.262 --> 03:02:24.266
HERTZBERG LIMÓN LIMÓN. AYE
03:02:24.333 --> 03:02:29.838
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I. MELINDA'S
03:02:29.905 --> 03:02:35.344
MELINDA'S NO MEN. MEN. I RUBIO
03:02:35.411 --> 03:02:38.047
RUBIO NOT VOTING SKINNER.
03:02:38.113 --> 03:02:41.116
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE,
03:02:41.183 --> 03:02:52.961
WILK. WELCOME NOW. NEED TO KNOW.
03:02:53.028 --> 03:02:56.932
NINE VOTES TO GET OUT. THEIR
03:02:56.999 --> 03:02:58.334
VOTE IS CURRENTLY 84 WILL LEAVE
03:02:58.400 --> 03:03:01.403
THEIR ON CALL. LET'S MOVE TO
03:03:01.470 --> 03:03:03.005
ITEM NUMBER 10, ALSO FROM
03:03:03.072 --> 03:03:05.074
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN, THE
03:03:05.140 --> 03:03:07.476
MOTION WAS DO PASS AND REFER TO
03:03:07.543 --> 03:03:08.477
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
03:03:08.544 --> 03:03:10.913
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:03:10.979 --> 03:03:13.649
FIRE ITEM 10 A B 2344. THE
03:03:13.716 --> 03:03:16.819
CURRENT VOTE IS 70 WITH THE
03:03:16.885 --> 03:03:19.488
CHAIR AND THE VICE CHAIR. BOTH
03:03:19.555 --> 03:03:21.490
VOTING I SENATORS, ARCHULETTA
03:03:21.557 --> 03:03:27.296
ARCHULETTA. I'M SORRY, BRITNEY.
03:03:27.363 --> 03:03:29.431
SENATOR SCARED CAN'T HEAR. I'M
03:03:29.498 --> 03:03:32.368
SORRY. YOU ANNOUNCED THAT A B 24
03:03:32.434 --> 03:03:35.337
38 ONLY HAD FOUR VOTES ACTUALLY
03:03:35.404 --> 03:03:39.341
HAD EIGHT IF I COUNT 8 TO 4
03:03:39.408 --> 03:03:41.243
CURRENT VOTE WAS 8 TO 4. OKAY, I
03:03:41.310 --> 03:03:45.314
APOLOGIZE. YOU CAN RECORD ME AS
03:03:45.381 --> 03:03:51.620
I ON A B 24 38. LET LET WILL
03:03:51.687 --> 03:03:53.188
COME BACK TO IT AND WE'LL BE
03:03:53.255 --> 03:03:56.358
QUICK. I'M SORRY. CONFUSING
03:03:56.425 --> 03:03:57.926
LET'S CONTINUE ON WHAT WE'LL
03:03:57.993 --> 03:03:59.495
REOPEN THE ROLE ON REMEMBER NINE
03:03:59.561 --> 03:04:01.230
WE'LL COME BACK TO IT. I DON'T
03:04:01.296 --> 03:04:02.931
NUMBER 10 MAYBE 2030 40 23 44
03:04:02.998 --> 03:04:05.167
FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN.
03:04:05.234 --> 03:04:06.335
UH, MISS WHITE. PLEASE CALL THE
03:04:06.402 --> 03:04:14.009
ROLL. WE'RE ON. WE'RE ON 23 44
03:04:14.076 --> 03:04:15.778
WILDLIFE CONNECTIVITY. REMEMBER
03:04:15.844 --> 03:04:25.387
10. FILE ITEM 10 A B 2344
03:04:25.454 --> 03:04:27.956
CURRENT VOTE IS 70 THE CHAIR AND
03:04:28.023 --> 03:04:29.391
THE VICE CHAIR. VOTING I
03:04:29.458 --> 03:04:30.859
SENATORS ARCHULETTA. ARCHULETTA.
03:04:30.926 --> 03:04:34.763
AYE, ORTEZ. CORTEZ, EI DOLLY!
03:04:34.830 --> 03:04:40.369
HERTZBERG. MCGUIRE MELINDA'S.
03:04:40.436 --> 03:04:46.775
RUBIO. RUBIO I SKINNER. SKINNER.
03:04:46.842 --> 03:04:49.945
I WIECKOWSKI. WIECKOWSKI. AYE,
03:04:50.012 --> 03:04:55.417
WILK. WELL. HERTZBERG. AYE,
03:04:55.484 --> 03:05:08.030
HERZBERG. AYE. MCGUIRE. THAT
03:05:08.096 --> 03:05:10.165
COUNT IS 14 0. WE'LL LEAVE THAT
03:05:10.232 --> 03:05:11.733
OVER THE TIME BEING, LET'S MOVE
03:05:11.800 --> 03:05:14.303
TO ITEM NUMBER 11 A B 27 46 46
03:05:14.369 --> 03:05:17.506
FROM CELLULAR FRIEDMAN. THE
03:05:17.573 --> 03:05:19.575
MOTION WAS DO PASS, AND I
03:05:19.641 --> 03:05:20.742
BELIEVE REFERRED TO THE
03:05:20.809 --> 03:05:22.511
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS. MR
03:05:22.578 --> 03:05:25.914
WHITE. IF YOU COULD CALL THAT
03:05:25.981 --> 03:05:28.650
FILE ITEM 11 A B 2746. THE
03:05:28.717 --> 03:05:30.652
CURRENT VOTE IS SEVEN TO THE
03:05:30.719 --> 03:05:32.154
CHAIR, VOTING VICE CHAIR VOTING
03:05:32.221 --> 03:05:34.456
NO. SENATORS ARCHULETTA
03:05:34.523 --> 03:05:37.226
ARCHULETTA. AYE, BECKER. BECKER.
03:05:37.292 --> 03:05:39.695
I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG? AYE,
03:05:39.761 --> 03:05:44.399
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I. SKINNER
03:05:44.466 --> 03:05:47.069
SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
03:05:47.135 --> 03:05:56.912
WIECKOWSKI. I WILL. WILK. NO.
03:05:56.979 --> 03:06:00.449
THAT'S CORRECT. THERE WAS 11.
03:06:00.516 --> 03:06:01.149
ASSEMBLY 27 46 FROM
03:06:01.216 --> 03:06:04.520
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN. YES.
03:06:04.586 --> 03:06:10.659
MALENA'S. THE RECALL YOU LIKING
03:06:10.726 --> 03:06:12.094
THAT BILL? ISN'T THAT CORRECT?
03:06:12.160 --> 03:06:14.062
THAT'S NOT CORRECT. IT DOES NOT
03:06:14.129 --> 03:06:16.732
VOTING SECRETLY LIKING IT, BILL.
03:06:16.798 --> 03:06:27.042
WHAT. THAT'S THE COUNT IS 33 13
03:06:27.109 --> 03:06:29.978
TO 3? THAT BILL IS OUT. LET US
03:06:30.045 --> 03:06:33.949
GO NOW TO ITEM NUMBER 16. THERE
03:06:34.016 --> 03:06:35.117
IS A B 25 94 FROM
03:06:35.183 --> 03:06:38.987
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING. AND THE
03:06:39.054 --> 03:06:40.088
RECOMMENDATION THERE WAS TO PASS
03:06:40.155 --> 03:06:41.189
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:06:41.256 --> 03:06:42.391
APPROPRIATIONS. DOING THE
03:06:42.457 --> 03:06:43.258
MOTIONS, RIGHT? PLEASE CALL THE
03:06:43.325 --> 03:06:54.002
ABSENT MEMBERS. WE DID NOT HAVE
03:06:54.069 --> 03:06:55.938
A MOTION THAT THERE WAS OUR
03:06:56.004 --> 03:06:57.339
FIRST BILL. SO SENATOR DODD
03:06:57.406 --> 03:06:58.674
MOVES THE BILL. APPRECIATE IT.
03:06:58.740 --> 03:07:00.008
SO THE DO PASS REFERRED TO THE
03:07:00.075 --> 03:07:01.043
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
03:07:01.109 --> 03:07:04.146
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FAR OUT
03:07:04.212 --> 03:07:07.716
AND 16 A B 2594 SENATORS NEWMAN
03:07:07.783 --> 03:07:13.221
I BATES ALAN ALAN I ARCHULETTA.
03:07:13.288 --> 03:07:16.158
ARCHILA TÔI BECKER. BECKER. I
03:07:16.224 --> 03:07:21.363
ORTEZ. CORTEZ, EI DOLLY! SALLY,
03:07:21.430 --> 03:07:27.202
I DODD. START I HERTZBERG
03:07:27.269 --> 03:07:30.138
HERTZBERG? AYE, LIMÓN. LIMÓN.
03:07:30.205 --> 03:07:32.708
AYE MCGUIRE. ACQUIRE AYE.
03:07:32.774 --> 03:07:37.179
MELINDA'S MELINDA'S. I MEANT
03:07:37.245 --> 03:07:42.684
MOMENT. I RUBIO RUBIO I SCANNER.
03:07:42.751 --> 03:07:45.821
SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI
03:07:45.887 --> 03:07:50.492
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK.
03:07:50.559 --> 03:08:12.948
BATES? AYE. THAT THE. THE COUNTY
03:08:13.015 --> 03:08:15.250
17 0 THAT VILLAGE OUT, UM LET'S
03:08:15.317 --> 03:08:20.722
MOVE NOW. TO ITEM NUMBER 23 27
03:08:20.789 --> 03:08:22.124
03 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:08:22.190 --> 03:08:24.559
MURATSUCHI RECOMMENDATION WAS
03:08:24.626 --> 03:08:26.561
THE MOTION WAS DUE PAST AS
03:08:26.628 --> 03:08:30.132
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS. FILE
03:08:30.198 --> 03:08:34.803
ADAM 23 A B 2703. THE CURRENT
03:08:34.870 --> 03:08:37.673
VOTE IS 40 THE CHAIR VOTING I
03:08:37.739 --> 03:08:39.608
VICE CHAIRMAN HAS NOT VOTED.
03:08:39.675 --> 03:08:43.645
SENATORS BATES ALAN ALAN I
03:08:43.712 --> 03:08:56.658
ARCHULETTA. ARCHULETA. I BECKER. BECKER. AYE. SALLY. HERTZBERG.
03:08:56.725 --> 03:09:01.730
DOLLY! NO! HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG?
03:09:01.797 --> 03:09:07.035
AYE. LIMÓN LIMÓN. AYE. MCGUIRE
03:09:07.102 --> 03:09:10.005
MCGUIRE? AYE. MELINDA'S.
03:09:10.072 --> 03:09:14.710
MELINDA'S NO. MEN. MAN. I
03:09:14.776 --> 03:09:21.316
SKINNER. SKINNER. I WIECKOWSKI.
03:09:21.383 --> 03:09:33.729
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WILK. WILK. 32
03:09:33.795 --> 03:09:39.801
14 WHAT DO YOU. THEIR ACCOUNT IS
03:09:39.868 --> 03:09:42.037
14 TO THAT BILL IS OUT. LET'S
03:09:42.104 --> 03:09:44.806
NOW MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER 25 A B
03:09:44.873 --> 03:09:46.141
22 71 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:09:46.208 --> 03:09:51.513
GIBSON THE MOTION WAS DO PASS.
03:09:51.580 --> 03:09:54.616
SPOT ITEM. 25 A B 2271. THE
03:09:54.683 --> 03:09:56.785
CURRENT VOTE IS 50 WITH THE
03:09:56.852 --> 03:09:58.653
CHAIR AND THE VICE CHAIR. BOTH
03:09:58.720 --> 03:10:00.722
VOTING I SENATORS, ALLEN ALAN I
03:10:00.789 --> 03:10:05.026
ARCHULETTA. ARCHILA T<c.cyan> BECKER.</c>
03:10:05.093 --> 03:10:08.163
BECKER. AYE. HERTZBERG.
03:10:08.230 --> 03:10:12.567
HERTZBERG? AYE. LIMÓN. LIMÓN.
03:10:12.634 --> 03:10:15.237
AYE MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE? AYE.
03:10:15.303 --> 03:10:24.913
MELINDA'S. MEN. MEN. I SKINNER.
03:10:24.980 --> 03:10:29.684
SKINNER. AYE. RUBIO. RUBIO. I
03:10:29.751 --> 03:10:33.655
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I WELCOME
03:10:33.722 --> 03:10:46.134
WILK.
03:10:46.201 --> 03:10:48.069
AND THE VARIOUS 16 0. THAT BILL
03:10:48.136 --> 03:10:50.071
IS OUT AND LET'S MOVE TO ITEM
03:10:50.138 --> 03:10:52.440
NUMBER 28 24 96 FROM
03:10:52.507 --> 03:10:54.609
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PETRIE-NORRIS.
03:10:54.676 --> 03:10:55.944
THE MOTION WAS DO PASS AS
03:10:56.011 --> 03:10:57.145
AMENDED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:10:57.212 --> 03:11:04.286
APPROPRIATIONS. ABOUT ADAM 28 82
03:11:04.352 --> 03:11:07.222
496. THE CURRENT VOTE IS 60, THE
03:11:07.289 --> 03:11:09.291
CHAIR AND THE VICE CHAIR. BOTH
03:11:09.357 --> 03:11:10.725
VOTING I SENATORS, ALLEN. ALAN I
03:11:10.792 --> 03:11:13.495
ARCHULETTA. ARCHULETTA. AYE,
03:11:13.562 --> 03:11:20.068
BECKER. BECKER. AYE. DOLLY!
03:11:20.135 --> 03:11:24.306
HERTZBERG. PITTSBURGH. I LIMÓN
03:11:24.372 --> 03:11:28.143
LIMÓN. AYE. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE
03:11:28.210 --> 03:11:35.951
MELINDA'S. MEN. MAN. I SKINNER.
03:11:36.017 --> 03:11:39.654
SKINNER. AYE. WIECKOWSKI
03:11:39.721 --> 03:11:53.935
WIECKOWSKI. AYE.
03:11:54.002 --> 03:11:55.203
THAT BILL HAS 15 VOTES TO ZERO
03:11:55.270 --> 03:11:59.140
THAT VILLAGE OUT. THAT FINISHES
03:11:59.207 --> 03:12:00.342
THE LIST THAT WILL GO BACK
03:12:00.408 --> 03:12:02.544
THROUGH FOR ANYWHERE. MEMBERS
03:12:02.611 --> 03:12:04.246
WERE NOT PRESIDENT. THE ROLE IS
03:12:04.312 --> 03:12:06.181
STILL OPEN. AND LET'S GO BACK
03:12:06.248 --> 03:12:10.652
THROUGH IT. JUST ONE SECOND.
03:12:10.719 --> 03:12:12.654
YEAH GIVE THIS ONE A SECOND TO
03:12:12.721 --> 03:12:28.203
GET HER. INFORMATION TOGETHER.
03:12:28.270 --> 03:12:30.338
SO ONE OF THE BILL'S LIST YOU
03:12:30.405 --> 03:12:32.774
MAY HAVE IS I DON'T KNOW 31 24
03:12:32.841 --> 03:12:35.076
25 46 FROM HIS AREA AND THAT DID
03:12:35.143 --> 03:12:37.245
NOT MAKE IT TO THE COMMITTEE. WE
03:12:37.312 --> 03:12:39.314
DID NOT HEAR THAT BILL. SO THE
03:12:39.381 --> 03:12:40.715
TOTAL NUMBER OF BILLS WE HEARD
03:12:40.782 --> 03:12:45.053
TODAY. WE'RE 31 INCLUSIVELY.
03:12:45.120 --> 03:12:46.254
ALRIGHT WE'RE GONNA GO THROUGH
03:12:46.321 --> 03:12:49.891
THIS ONE MORE TIME. SO UH, MISS
03:12:49.958 --> 03:12:51.126
WHITE? LET'S START WITH THAT.
03:12:51.192 --> 03:12:53.161
AND NO ONE A B 5 12 FROM MR
03:12:53.228 --> 03:12:59.834
HOLDEN. ITEM ONE A. B 5 12
03:12:59.901 --> 03:13:01.303
MOTIONS DO PASSES AMENDED BUT
03:13:01.369 --> 03:13:02.537
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
03:13:02.604 --> 03:13:03.505
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
03:13:03.571 --> 03:13:08.276
SENATORS BATES ARCHULETTA.
03:13:08.343 --> 03:13:10.512
ARCHULETTA. AYE, BECKER. BECKER.
03:13:10.578 --> 03:13:18.520
AYE. STALIN. MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I.
03:13:18.586 --> 03:13:37.305
MELINDA'S.
03:13:40.675 --> 03:13:54.255
NO.
03:13:54.322 --> 03:14:02.731
QUÊ. YEAH CARRIES 13 0 FOR 85 12
03:14:02.797 --> 03:14:04.866
. THAT BILL IS OUT. REMEMBER TO
03:14:04.933 --> 03:14:14.376
A B 1919. ITEM TWO A B 1919. THE
03:14:14.442 --> 03:14:16.311
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST WE
03:14:16.378 --> 03:14:17.379
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:14:17.445 --> 03:14:19.781
APPROPRIATIONS. THE CURRENT VOTE
03:14:19.848 --> 03:14:21.883
IS 14 0, BOTH THE CHAIR AND THE
03:14:21.950 --> 03:14:22.684
VICE CHAIR. VOTING EYES.
03:14:22.751 --> 03:14:25.120
SENATORS ARCHULETTA ARCHULETTA.
03:14:25.186 --> 03:14:30.825
AYE, BECKER. REMEMBER TO A B
03:14:30.892 --> 03:14:44.406
1919. BECKER. I MCGUIRE MCGUIRE. 17 THAT BILL HAS 17 VOTES THAT
03:14:44.472 --> 03:14:45.807
VILLAGE ELDERS REMEMBER 3 80 27
03:14:45.874 --> 03:14:50.178
73 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLDEN.
03:14:50.245 --> 03:14:53.348
FILE ITEM THREE A B 2773. THE
03:14:53.415 --> 03:14:54.315
MOTIONS DO PASS. THE FIRST
03:14:54.382 --> 03:14:56.217
THEORY REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
03:14:56.284 --> 03:14:57.152
ON APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE
03:14:57.218 --> 03:14:58.953
IS 10 3 WITH THE CHAIR, VOTING I
03:14:59.020 --> 03:15:00.088
VICE CHAIR, NOT VOTING. SENATORS
03:15:00.155 --> 03:15:05.026
BATES ARCHULETTA. ACTUALLY, I
03:15:05.093 --> 03:15:09.898
BECKER BECKER. AYE. MCGUIRE
03:15:09.964 --> 03:15:14.903
MCGUIRE? AYE. THAT COUNT IS 13
03:15:14.969 --> 03:15:16.971
TO 3. THAT BILL IS OUT. LET'S GO
03:15:17.038 --> 03:15:19.941
TO ITEM NUMBER. FIVE MAYBE 17 13
03:15:20.008 --> 03:15:20.308
FROM ASSEMBLYMAN
03:15:20.375 --> 03:15:25.447
BOERNER HORVATH. ITEM FIVE A B
03:15:25.513 --> 03:15:29.084
1713. THE CURRENT VOTE IS 12 TO
03:15:29.150 --> 03:15:30.351
WITH THE CHAIR AND THE VICE
03:15:30.418 --> 03:15:31.086
CHAIR, BOTH VOTING EYES,
03:15:31.152 --> 03:15:32.887
SENATORS ARCHULETTA ARCHULETTA.
03:15:32.954 --> 03:15:39.227
AYE, BECKER. BECKER. I MCGUIRE.
03:15:39.294 --> 03:15:42.097
MCGUIRE I COUNT IS 15 TO THAT
03:15:42.163 --> 03:15:43.798
VILLAGE OUT. LET'S MOVE TO THE
03:15:43.865 --> 03:15:46.534
NEXT BILL A B 17 78 ITEM NUMBER
03:15:46.601 --> 03:15:47.068
SIX FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:15:47.135 --> 03:15:50.705
CRISTINA GARCIA. FOR ADAM, SIX A
03:15:50.772 --> 03:15:52.474
B 1778. THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED
03:15:52.540 --> 03:15:53.908
WITH FIRST YOU REFERRED TO THE
03:15:53.975 --> 03:15:55.844
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS. THE
03:15:55.910 --> 03:16:00.315
CURRENT VOTE IS 72. WITH THE
03:16:00.381 --> 03:16:01.616
CHAIR. VOTING I VICE CHAIR
03:16:01.683 --> 03:16:03.284
VOTING NO SENATORS ARCHULETTA.
03:16:03.351 --> 03:16:09.324
ARCHULETTA. AYE, BECKER. CORTEZ.
03:16:09.390 --> 03:16:19.734
SALLY. STUD. HERTZBERG. FILE
03:16:19.801 --> 03:16:21.803
ITEM SIX A B 1778 BY CRISTINA
03:16:21.870 --> 03:16:28.877
GARCIA. HERTZBERG, NOT VOTING.
03:16:28.943 --> 03:16:43.324
OKAY. MELINDA'S MEN.
03:16:43.391 --> 03:16:45.693
THAT COUNT AS A TWO AND THE BILL
03:16:45.760 --> 03:16:55.103
FAILS. LET'S MOVE TO THE NEXT
03:16:55.170 --> 03:16:57.238
ITEM. NEXT ITEM IS REMEMBER 88
03:16:57.305 --> 03:17:01.276
1938 AS SOME MEMBER FRIEDMAN.
03:17:01.342 --> 03:17:03.978
FOLLOW. ADAM ATE A B 1938
03:17:04.045 --> 03:17:05.346
MOTIONS DO PASS AS AMENDED. BUT
03:17:05.413 --> 03:17:07.582
FIRST WE REFERRED TO THE
03:17:07.649 --> 03:17:08.149
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:17:08.216 --> 03:17:09.117
SENATORS ARCHULETTA ARCHULETTA.
03:17:09.184 --> 03:17:24.399
AYE, DOLLY.
03:17:24.465 --> 03:17:27.368
THAT BILL HAS 15 15 0. THE BILLS
03:17:27.435 --> 03:17:29.837
OUT NEXT IS REMEMBER NINE A. B
03:17:29.904 --> 03:17:30.805
24 38 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:17:30.872 --> 03:17:36.878
FRIEDMAN. ITEM NINE A. B 2438.
03:17:36.945 --> 03:17:38.513
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST
03:17:38.580 --> 03:17:40.348
BE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:17:40.415 --> 03:17:41.182
APPROPRIATIONS. THE CURRENT VOTE
03:17:41.249 --> 03:17:43.885
IS 84 THE CHAIR, NOT VOTING,
03:17:43.952 --> 03:17:45.386
VICE CHAIR, VOTING NO SENATORS.
03:17:45.453 --> 03:17:52.360
ORTEZ. SENATOR NEWMAN. CORTEZ.
03:17:52.427 --> 03:17:58.666
HERTZBERG. SKINNER. SKINNER.
03:17:58.733 --> 03:18:14.782
AYE.
03:18:22.991 --> 03:18:24.158
KERRY'S NIGHT FOR THAT BUILDS
03:18:24.225 --> 03:18:26.494
OUT, UM, LAST ANNOUNCING THE
03:18:26.561 --> 03:18:29.931
NEXT ITEM IS NUMBER 10 A B 23 44
03:18:29.998 --> 03:18:34.469
FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN.
03:18:34.535 --> 03:18:37.472
SPOT ITEM 10 A B 2344 OF THE
03:18:37.538 --> 03:18:39.574
MOTIONS DO PASS. BUT FIRST HE
03:18:39.641 --> 03:18:40.174
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:18:40.241 --> 03:18:43.011
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
03:18:43.077 --> 03:18:44.879
14 0 BOTH THE CHAIR AND THE VICE
03:18:44.946 --> 03:18:46.047
CHAIR OF VOTING. AYE. SENATORS
03:18:46.114 --> 03:18:54.656
DAILY. MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE? AYE.
03:18:54.722 --> 03:19:10.938
READ ABOUT IT.
03:19:19.080 --> 03:19:21.849
THE VOTE IS 15 0 THAT BUILDS OUT
03:19:21.916 --> 03:19:22.850
THANK YOU. SENATOR SKINNER
03:19:22.917 --> 03:19:26.888
STARTED INCONVENIENCE YOU. HE
03:19:26.954 --> 03:19:29.590
JUST MISSED THAT ONE VOTE BY
03:19:29.657 --> 03:19:31.326
LIKE A HERE. I'M SORRY. YEAH.
03:19:31.392 --> 03:19:34.128
NEXT IS IT 11 WHERE THE NEXT
03:19:34.195 --> 03:19:37.432
STEP. THIS IS 16. I THINK.
03:19:37.498 --> 03:19:39.734
ALRIGHT SINGLE ITEM NUMBER 16 18
03:19:39.801 --> 03:19:48.042
25 94 WAS AROUND. THAT'S IT. THE
03:19:48.109 --> 03:19:49.143
CONSENT COUNTER, SO THERE ARE
03:19:49.210 --> 03:19:51.946
TWO CONSENT COUNTERS. THAT'S WHY
03:19:52.013 --> 03:19:52.847
IT'S AN IMPORTANT TOPIC IN
03:19:52.914 --> 03:19:54.349
CALIFORNIA FIRST CONSENT
03:19:54.415 --> 03:19:55.883
CALENDAR, WHICH IS THE
03:19:55.950 --> 03:19:58.052
LEGISLATION, THE SECOND CONSENT
03:19:58.119 --> 03:19:58.986
CALENDAR WILL BE THE NAMING
03:19:59.053 --> 03:20:00.555
RESOLUTIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
03:20:00.621 --> 03:20:01.723
ROLL AND THE FIRST CONSENT
03:20:01.789 --> 03:20:04.992
COUNTER. ALRIGHT FIRST CONSENT.
03:20:05.059 --> 03:20:06.861
SALANDER SHARE VOTING. I'VE VICE
03:20:06.928 --> 03:20:08.363
CHAIR VOTING AYE. SENATORS
03:20:08.429 --> 03:20:10.131
ARCHULETTA ARCHULETTA. AYE,
03:20:10.198 --> 03:20:15.203
BECKER. BECKER. I'M HERZBERG
03:20:15.269 --> 03:20:17.105
HERZBERG. AYE, LIMÓN. LIMÓN. AYE
03:20:17.171 --> 03:20:22.877
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE? AYE.
03:20:22.944 --> 03:20:32.086
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE. 17.
03:20:32.153 --> 03:20:34.522
MHM 17 NOTHING THAT THE FIRST
03:20:34.589 --> 03:20:36.457
CONSENT CALENDARS OUT. PLEASE
03:20:36.524 --> 03:20:37.859
CALL THE ROLL ON THE SECOND
03:20:37.925 --> 03:20:39.594
CONSENT COUNTER, WHICH INCLUDES
03:20:39.660 --> 03:20:40.595
THE LEGISLATION FOR NAMING
03:20:40.661 --> 03:20:41.162
HIGHWAYS, ETCETERA. CONSENT
03:20:41.229 --> 03:20:44.365
CALENDAR, TOO. BOTH CHAIR AND
03:20:44.432 --> 03:20:46.033
VICE CHAIR. VOTING AYE. SENATORS
03:20:46.100 --> 03:20:49.137
ARCHULETTA ARCHULETTA. AYE,
03:20:49.203 --> 03:20:53.574
BECKER. BECKER. I HERTZBERG
03:20:53.641 --> 03:20:56.778
PITTSBURGH. I MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE?
03:20:56.844 --> 03:21:01.082
AYE. SKINNER. WIECKOWSKI
03:21:01.149 --> 03:21:05.820
WIECKOWSKI. AYE. THE SECOND
03:21:05.887 --> 03:21:08.790
CONSENT COUNTER IS OUT 17 TO 0
03:21:08.856 --> 03:21:11.759
16 0 APOLOGIZE THAT CONCLUDES
03:21:11.826 --> 03:21:14.462
ALL OF OUR ITEMS. UH THANK YOU
03:21:14.529 --> 03:21:15.797
TO ALL THE INDIVIDUALS WHO
03:21:15.863 --> 03:21:16.798
PARTICIPATED IN PUBLIC TESTIMONY
03:21:16.864 --> 03:21:19.066
TODAY. IF YOU'RE NOT ABLE TO
03:21:19.133 --> 03:21:20.034
TESTIFY TODAY, PLEASE SUBMIT
03:21:20.101 --> 03:21:21.803
YOUR COMMENTS OR SUGGESTIONS IN
03:21:21.869 --> 03:21:22.437
WRITING TO THE SENATE
03:21:22.503 --> 03:21:23.371
TRANSPORTATION COMMITTEE OR
03:21:23.438 --> 03:21:25.173
VISIT OUR WEBSITE. YOUR COMMENTS
03:21:25.239 --> 03:21:26.974
AND SUGGESTIONS ARE IMPORTANT TO
03:21:27.041 --> 03:21:29.510
US, AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE YOUR
03:21:29.577 --> 03:21:30.478
TESTIMONY IN THE OFFICIAL
03:21:30.545 --> 03:21:31.312
HEARING RECORDS. THANK YOU. AND
03:21:31.379 --> 03:21:32.713
WE APPRECIATE YOUR PARTICIPATION
03:21:32.780 --> 03:21:34.415
. THANK YOU TO COMMITTEE STAFF
03:21:34.482 --> 03:21:35.149
FOR PUTTING UP WITH ME. THANK
03:21:35.216 --> 03:21:36.884
YOU, EVERYONE FOR YOUR PATIENTS
03:21:36.951 --> 03:21:37.852
IN COOPERATION, WE HAVE
03:21:37.919 --> 03:21:39.120
CONCLUDED THE AGENDA. THE SENATE
03:21:39.187 --> 03:21:40.054
COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION IS
03:21:40.121 --> 03:21:56.337
NOW ADJOURNED.