WEBVTT
00:00:44.043 --> 00:00:47.147
GOOD MORNING, THE SENATE
00:00:47.213 --> 00:00:48.515
COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND
00:00:48.581 --> 00:00:49.416
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS WILL
00:00:49.482 --> 00:00:52.452
COME TO ORDER. GOOD MORNING. AS
00:00:52.519 --> 00:00:53.319
WE CONTINUE TO TAKE SOME
00:00:53.386 --> 00:00:54.821
PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE ONGOING
00:00:54.888 --> 00:00:56.956
COVID 19 RISKS. SENATE CONTINUES
00:00:57.023 --> 00:00:57.857
TO WELCOME THE PUBLICAN IS
00:00:57.924 --> 00:00:59.993
PROVIDED ACCESS TO BOTH IN
00:01:00.059 --> 00:01:00.560
PERSON AND TELECONFERENCE.
00:01:00.627 --> 00:01:02.295
PARTICIPATION FOR PUBLIC COMMENT
00:01:02.362 --> 00:01:03.663
FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
00:01:03.730 --> 00:01:04.697
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT FOR THE
00:01:04.764 --> 00:01:06.699
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE. THE
00:01:06.766 --> 00:01:07.834
PARTICIPANT TOLL FREE NUMBER AND
00:01:07.901 --> 00:01:08.968
ACCESS CODE IS POSTED OUR
00:01:09.035 --> 00:01:11.271
COMMITTEE WEBSITE. IT WILL BE
00:01:11.337 --> 00:01:12.705
DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN AS WELL
00:01:12.772 --> 00:01:13.673
. LET ME ANNOUNCE IT NOW.
00:01:13.740 --> 00:01:15.008
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
00:01:15.074 --> 00:01:20.814
8772. AGAIN. THAT'S 8772268163
00:01:20.880 --> 00:01:25.418
AND THE ACCESS CODE IS 648. 862
00:01:25.485 --> 00:01:29.289
AGAIN. THAT'S 648862. I AM
00:01:29.355 --> 00:01:30.824
CHEERING. MY NAME IS SENATOR
00:01:30.890 --> 00:01:32.692
NEWMAN. I AM CHEERING TODAY'S
00:01:32.759 --> 00:01:35.662
COMMITTEE IN LIEU OF THAT SHARE
00:01:35.728 --> 00:01:36.563
SENATOR GLASER, WHO
00:01:36.629 --> 00:01:37.997
UNFORTUNATELY HAS TAKEN ILL
00:01:38.064 --> 00:01:41.100
TODAY, AND I HAVE BEEN APPOINTED
00:01:41.167 --> 00:01:43.837
UNDER SENATE RULES TO CHAIR
00:01:43.903 --> 00:01:46.239
TODAY'S HEARING. I WILL MAINTAIN
00:01:46.306 --> 00:01:47.907
DECORUM DURING THE HEARING IS
00:01:47.974 --> 00:01:49.642
NECESSARY AND HIS CUSTOMARY ANY
00:01:49.709 --> 00:01:51.778
ANY INDIVIDUAL HAS DISRUPTIVE.
00:01:51.845 --> 00:01:54.247
MAY BE REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE
00:01:54.314 --> 00:01:55.048
HEARING SERVICE, REMOTE SERVICE
00:01:55.114 --> 00:01:56.316
OR HAVE THEIR CONNECTIONS MUTED
00:01:56.382 --> 00:01:57.183
. WE'RE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
00:01:57.250 --> 00:01:58.818
HEARINGS HERE IN THE STREET
00:01:58.885 --> 00:02:00.119
BUILDING. I ASK ALL MEMBERS THE
00:02:00.186 --> 00:02:02.789
COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT IN 2100.
00:02:02.856 --> 00:02:05.191
SO WE CAN ESTABLISH OUR CORMAN
00:02:05.258 --> 00:02:07.327
BEGIN OUR HEARING. AS OF RIGHT
00:02:07.393 --> 00:02:11.164
NOW WE DO NOT YET HAVE A QUORUM.
00:02:11.231 --> 00:02:12.599
AND I GUESS WE WILL START AS A
00:02:12.665 --> 00:02:14.701
SUBCOMMITTEE. WE HAVE 12 BILLS
00:02:14.767 --> 00:02:16.269
ON TODAY'S AGENDA. WE HAVE THREE
00:02:16.336 --> 00:02:18.605
MEASURES ON OUR CONSENT CALENDAR
00:02:18.671 --> 00:02:20.507
, WHICH WE WILL TAKE UP ONCE WE
00:02:20.573 --> 00:02:21.708
HAVE A QUORUM. THOSE THREE OR A
00:02:21.774 --> 00:02:23.877
B 16 19 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:02:23.943 --> 00:02:24.611
CERVANTES, WHICH IS VIOLENT
00:02:24.677 --> 00:02:26.279
NUMBER FOUR A B 17 98 BY
00:02:26.346 --> 00:02:27.480
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BRIAN, WHICH IS
00:02:27.547 --> 00:02:29.516
FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT. AND
00:02:29.582 --> 00:02:31.618
FINALLY, A B 25 77 BY
00:02:31.684 --> 00:02:33.052
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BIGELOW, WHICH
00:02:33.119 --> 00:02:35.388
IS FILE ITEM 11 AGAIN. WE DO NOT
00:02:35.455 --> 00:02:36.923
YET HAVE A QUORUM, SO LET US
00:02:36.990 --> 00:02:41.461
START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE. UM AND
00:02:41.528 --> 00:02:43.196
IF THERE'S NO OBJECTION, LET'S
00:02:43.263 --> 00:02:45.965
GET STARTED, BUT TWO STAR LET'S
00:02:46.032 --> 00:02:47.033
LET'S PLEASE SECTOR PLEASE DO
00:02:47.100 --> 00:02:48.434
CALL THE ROLE JUST FOR THE
00:02:48.501 --> 00:02:54.774
RECORD. NEWMAN HERE IN HERE.
00:02:54.841 --> 00:03:01.681
GLASER. NIELSEN. NIELSEN HERE,
00:03:01.748 --> 00:03:08.555
HERTZBERG. LEVER. VERY GOOD
00:03:08.621 --> 00:03:11.224
AGAIN. WE DO NOT YET HAVE A
00:03:11.291 --> 00:03:12.659
QUORUM. WE'RE STARTING AS A
00:03:12.725 --> 00:03:14.460
SUBCOMMITTEE. WE DO, THANKFULLY
00:03:14.527 --> 00:03:17.030
, HAVE AN AUTHOR. SO WE'RE GOING
00:03:17.096 --> 00:03:19.032
TO START WITH ITEM FILE ON
00:03:19.098 --> 00:03:21.668
NUMBER TWO. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:03:21.734 --> 00:03:23.236
REVIS WELCOME. YOU'LL BE
00:03:23.303 --> 00:03:29.709
PRESENTING A B 9 75. AT THE
00:03:29.776 --> 00:03:34.581
PODIUM. OKAY. I WAS GOING TO GO.
00:03:34.647 --> 00:03:35.682
JUST STARTING THE COMMITTEE HERE
00:03:35.748 --> 00:03:40.954
AND I'LL CALL YOU BACK.
00:03:41.020 --> 00:03:41.688
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S REVIS. WELCOME.
00:03:41.754 --> 00:03:45.625
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU, MR
00:03:45.692 --> 00:03:48.161
CHAIR AND GOOD MORNING. UM FIRST
00:03:48.227 --> 00:03:50.129
, I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
00:03:50.196 --> 00:03:52.131
CHAIR STAFF FOR WORKING WITH MY
00:03:52.198 --> 00:03:55.668
TEAM ON THIS BILL. SECOND I WILL
00:03:55.735 --> 00:03:56.736
BE ACCEPTING THE SUGGESTED
00:03:56.803 --> 00:03:58.204
AMENDMENTS, AS LISTED ON PAGE
00:03:58.271 --> 00:04:01.274
EIGHT OF THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS.
00:04:01.341 --> 00:04:05.178
89 75 DOES A NUMBER OF THINGS
00:04:05.244 --> 00:04:08.314
FIRST A B 9 75 REQUIRES PUBLIC
00:04:08.381 --> 00:04:10.149
OFFICIALS AND CANDIDATES FOR
00:04:10.216 --> 00:04:11.284
WHOM THE FAIR POLITICAL
00:04:11.351 --> 00:04:14.687
PRACTICES COMMISSION THE F PPC
00:04:14.754 --> 00:04:16.422
IS THE FILING OFFICER TO FILE
00:04:16.489 --> 00:04:19.192
THEIR STATEMENTS OF ECONOMIC
00:04:19.258 --> 00:04:23.062
INTEREST FORM 702ND THIS BILL
00:04:23.129 --> 00:04:24.664
PERMITS OF FILING OFFICER TO
00:04:24.731 --> 00:04:26.633
DESTROY THE PAPER ORIGINAL ONCE
00:04:26.699 --> 00:04:28.167
AN ELECTRONIC COPY HAS BEEN MADE
00:04:28.234 --> 00:04:31.304
AND KEPT ON FILE. LASTLY THIS
00:04:31.371 --> 00:04:32.739
BILL ALSO RECONCILES THE
00:04:32.805 --> 00:04:34.641
TIMELINE FOR A PUBLIC OFFICIAL
00:04:34.707 --> 00:04:37.176
TO REIMBURSE THE GIFTS. THESE
00:04:37.243 --> 00:04:38.544
CHANGES WILL RESULT IN GREATER
00:04:38.611 --> 00:04:41.581
TRANSPARENCY, STREAMLINE RECORDS
00:04:41.648 --> 00:04:43.082
RETENTION AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
00:04:43.149 --> 00:04:46.753
REDUCE IN REDUCTION IN PPC
00:04:46.819 --> 00:04:48.254
RESOURCES DEVOTED TO FORM 700
00:04:48.321 --> 00:04:50.123
FILING. AND ENSURE PRIVACY
00:04:50.189 --> 00:04:53.926
PROTECTIONS. PROMOTING PUBLIC
00:04:53.993 --> 00:04:56.162
TRUST IN THE WAKE OF COVID 19
00:04:56.229 --> 00:04:59.065
MUST BE A PRIORITY FOR OUR STATE
00:04:59.132 --> 00:05:00.466
WHEN THERE IS A RARE OPPORTUNITY
00:05:00.533 --> 00:05:02.001
TO PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY,
00:05:02.068 --> 00:05:03.436
INCREASE THE PROGRAM'S
00:05:03.503 --> 00:05:04.971
EFFICIENCY AND SAVE VALUABLE
00:05:05.038 --> 00:05:06.072
STATE RESOURCES. WE MUST PURSUE
00:05:06.139 --> 00:05:09.942
IT. EACH YEAR THE F PPC RECEIVES
00:05:10.009 --> 00:05:12.545
AND PROCESSES APPROXIMATELY
00:05:12.612 --> 00:05:15.548
APPROXIMATELY 24,000 FINANCIAL
00:05:15.615 --> 00:05:17.216
DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS COMMONLY
00:05:17.283 --> 00:05:18.284
REFERRED TO AS FORM SEVEN
00:05:18.351 --> 00:05:21.788
HUNDREDS. FROM HIGH LEVEL STATE
00:05:21.854 --> 00:05:23.556
, COUNTY AND CITY OFFICIALS
00:05:23.623 --> 00:05:25.558
DESPITE HAVING ACCESS TO THE F P
00:05:25.625 --> 00:05:28.227
PCS ONLINE PLATFORM MINORITY OF
00:05:28.294 --> 00:05:29.529
OFFICIALS STILL FILE THEIR FORMS
00:05:29.595 --> 00:05:32.899
IN HARD COPY. PROCESSING THESE
00:05:32.965 --> 00:05:35.101
HARD COPY FILINGS TAKES UP
00:05:35.168 --> 00:05:37.303
VALUABLE STAFF TIME AND REQUIRES
00:05:37.370 --> 00:05:40.173
THE F PPC TO LEASE SPACE
00:05:40.239 --> 00:05:41.374
SUFFICIENT TO STORE ALL OF THESE
00:05:41.441 --> 00:05:45.178
HARD COPIES. IN FACT, ACCORDING
00:05:45.244 --> 00:05:46.679
TO THE F PPC, IT EXPANDS OVER
00:05:46.746 --> 00:05:49.749
105 HOURS IN STAFF, TIME AND
00:05:49.816 --> 00:05:51.951
$10,000 ANNUALLY ON THE
00:05:52.018 --> 00:05:53.619
PROCESSING OF HARD COPY FORM
00:05:53.686 --> 00:05:56.689
SEVEN HUNDREDS. UNIVERSAL E
00:05:56.756 --> 00:05:59.058
FILING WILL ELIMINATE THIS
00:05:59.125 --> 00:06:00.827
UNNECESSARY ADMINISTRATIVE
00:06:00.893 --> 00:06:02.662
BURDEN AND WASTE OF PUBLIC
00:06:02.729 --> 00:06:05.098
RESOURCES. AS WITH ANY PUBLIC
00:06:05.164 --> 00:06:07.967
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE. IT IS OF
00:06:08.034 --> 00:06:10.069
PARAMOUNT IMPORTANCE THAT THE
00:06:10.136 --> 00:06:10.770
INFORMATION DSPLAYED IS
00:06:10.837 --> 00:06:14.173
ACCURATE AND NOT MISLEADING. THE
00:06:14.240 --> 00:06:16.809
ACT RECOGNIZES THIS BY EXEMPTING
00:06:16.876 --> 00:06:18.578
FROM THE GIFT RULES, A GIFT
00:06:18.644 --> 00:06:20.813
RECEIVED BY A PUBLIC OFFICIAL
00:06:20.880 --> 00:06:22.882
THAT IS REIMBURSED WITHIN 30
00:06:22.949 --> 00:06:23.950
DAYS OF RECEIPT, HOWEVER, TO
00:06:24.016 --> 00:06:26.853
EXERCISE THIS EXCEPTION. THE
00:06:26.919 --> 00:06:28.621
OFFICIAL MUST KNOW THE VALUE AND
00:06:28.688 --> 00:06:31.390
SOURCE OF THEIR GIFT. IT CAN BE
00:06:31.457 --> 00:06:33.960
DIFFICULT FOR AN OFFICIAL TO
00:06:34.026 --> 00:06:35.061
TRACK DOWN AND DETERMINE THE
00:06:35.128 --> 00:06:37.063
VALUE AND THE SOURCE OF A GIFT.
00:06:37.130 --> 00:06:38.998
CURRENT LAW DOES NOT REQUIRE
00:06:39.065 --> 00:06:41.067
THAT THE SOURCE OF A GIFT
00:06:41.134 --> 00:06:42.568
PROVIDE THE RECEIVING OFFICIAL
00:06:42.635 --> 00:06:44.504
WITH THE GIFTS VALUE UNTIL 30
00:06:44.570 --> 00:06:46.706
DAYS AFTER THE CALENDAR QUARTER
00:06:46.773 --> 00:06:47.940
, IN WHICH THE OFFICIAL RECEIVED
00:06:48.007 --> 00:06:51.444
THE GIFT, IF AT ALL. AS A RESULT
00:06:51.511 --> 00:06:52.945
, OFFICIALS OFTEN DO NOT RECEIVE
00:06:53.012 --> 00:06:55.648
NOTICE OF THE VALUE OR SOURCE OF
00:06:55.715 --> 00:06:57.583
THE GIFT AFTER THE 30 DAY PERIOD
00:06:57.650 --> 00:07:01.287
TO REIMBURSE THIS HAS RESULTED
00:07:01.354 --> 00:07:03.156
IN OFFICIALS VIOLATING THE
00:07:03.222 --> 00:07:05.858
ANNUAL GIFT LIMIT AND HAVING TO
00:07:05.925 --> 00:07:07.727
REPORT GIFTS FROM PERSONS THEY
00:07:07.794 --> 00:07:09.962
WISH NOT TO ASSOCIATE WITH. A B
00:07:10.029 --> 00:07:13.432
9 75 WILL FREE UP PPC STAFF
00:07:13.499 --> 00:07:15.701
RESOURCES TO IMPROVE EFFICIENCY
00:07:15.768 --> 00:07:16.669
IN GOVERNMENT AND INCREASED
00:07:16.736 --> 00:07:20.273
TRANSPARENCY. TODAY I HAVE EDDIE
00:07:20.339 --> 00:07:22.608
YEN LEGISLATIVE CHAIR OF THE
00:07:22.675 --> 00:07:24.677
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF CLERKS
00:07:24.744 --> 00:07:25.945
AND ELECTION OFFICIALS
00:07:26.012 --> 00:07:27.079
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF THE
00:07:27.146 --> 00:07:31.184
BILL OVER THE PHONE. UM THANK
00:07:31.250 --> 00:07:32.985
YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MR YEN. IF
00:07:33.052 --> 00:07:39.192
YOU COULD PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
00:07:39.258 --> 00:07:41.360
YOU. GOOD MORNING, MR CHAIR. AND
00:07:41.427 --> 00:07:42.829
MY NAME IS EDWARD CHEN. I AM
00:07:42.895 --> 00:07:44.297
INTERESTED EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF
00:07:44.363 --> 00:07:46.232
THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD OF
00:07:46.299 --> 00:07:47.333
SUPERVISORS. I'M HERE ON BEHALF
00:07:47.400 --> 00:07:49.435
OF THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:07:49.502 --> 00:07:50.436
CLERKS AND ELECTION OFFICIALS,
00:07:50.503 --> 00:07:52.205
CLERK OF THE BOARD. LEGISLATIVE
00:07:52.271 --> 00:07:53.806
COMMITTEE. I WANT TO THANK
00:07:53.873 --> 00:07:54.740
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RIVAS FOR
00:07:54.807 --> 00:07:55.942
AUTHORING THE BILL AND ACCEPTING
00:07:56.008 --> 00:07:57.944
THE ADJUSTED AMENDMENT. WE
00:07:58.010 --> 00:08:00.546
SUPPORT A B 9 75 BECAUSE IT WILL
00:08:00.613 --> 00:08:02.081
ALLEVIATE THE BURDEN. TOO MANY
00:08:02.148 --> 00:08:03.549
COUNTIES EXPERIENCE FROM STORING
00:08:03.616 --> 00:08:05.251
PAPER DOCUMENTS, BUT ALSO
00:08:05.318 --> 00:08:06.352
ENCOURAGING JURISDICTION TO
00:08:06.419 --> 00:08:07.320
ENHANCE THEIR TECHNOLOGY
00:08:07.386 --> 00:08:10.289
PLATFORMS. THE STORE DIGITAL
00:08:10.356 --> 00:08:11.424
COPIES OF RECORDS RATHER THAN
00:08:11.490 --> 00:08:13.492
RELY ON PAPER DOCUMENT.
00:08:13.559 --> 00:08:15.561
CURRENTLY FILING OFFICERS STORE
00:08:15.628 --> 00:08:17.496
PAPER COPIES OF FORM 700 FOR
00:08:17.563 --> 00:08:19.665
SEVERAL YEARS OF ALL THE LAW
00:08:19.732 --> 00:08:21.067
ALREADY ALLOWS FOR ELECTRONIC
00:08:21.133 --> 00:08:22.835
STORAGE OF THESE RECORDS, FILING
00:08:22.902 --> 00:08:24.470
OFFICERS ACCEPTING PAPER COPIES
00:08:24.537 --> 00:08:25.471
OF REQUIRED PHYSICALLY STORE
00:08:25.538 --> 00:08:27.740
THEM. EVEN THOUGH ELECTRONIC
00:08:27.807 --> 00:08:29.475
DATA STORAGE IS AVAILABLE AND
00:08:29.542 --> 00:08:32.078
MORE CONVENIENT. EVERY 1975
00:08:32.144 --> 00:08:33.546
ALLEVIATE THE BURDEN OF STORAGE
00:08:33.613 --> 00:08:35.214
SPACE COST ASSOCIATED WITH
00:08:35.281 --> 00:08:37.416
STORING PAPER AND STAFF TIME AND
00:08:37.483 --> 00:08:38.417
MANAGING THE ACCESSING PAPER
00:08:38.484 --> 00:08:40.586
RECORDS. LASTLY FOR THOSE
00:08:40.653 --> 00:08:42.221
FINALLY, OFFICERS THAT DO NOT
00:08:42.288 --> 00:08:43.122
CURRENTLY HAVE THE ABILITY THAT
00:08:43.189 --> 00:08:44.190
IMMEDIATELY SCANNED PAPER
00:08:44.257 --> 00:08:46.993
VERSIONS OF FORM 700 STORES
00:08:47.059 --> 00:08:48.828
ELECTRONIC DATA. IT IS IMPORTANT
00:08:48.895 --> 00:08:49.829
TO NOTE THAT OUR AMENDMENTS
00:08:49.896 --> 00:08:50.863
GOVERNMENT CODE 81009 WOULD BE
00:08:50.930 --> 00:08:54.667
PERMITTED. PERMISSIVE SO AS TO
00:08:54.734 --> 00:08:55.968
ALLOW JURISDICTIONS TIME TO
00:08:56.035 --> 00:08:58.070
TRANSITION AT THEIR OWN PACE. I
00:08:58.137 --> 00:08:59.071
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOUR
00:08:59.138 --> 00:09:00.673
COMMUNITY GIVE A B 9 25 ITS
00:09:00.740 --> 00:09:02.575
APPROVAL, AND I WOULD BE HAPPY
00:09:02.642 --> 00:09:03.643
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU
00:09:03.709 --> 00:09:06.646
MIGHT HAVE. THANK YOU, MR YAN.
00:09:06.712 --> 00:09:08.948
NOW LET'S BRING IT BACK TO THE
00:09:09.015 --> 00:09:09.749
HEARING OVER HERE. ARE THERE ANY
00:09:09.815 --> 00:09:12.919
WITNESSES HERE IN ROOM 2100, WHO
00:09:12.985 --> 00:09:14.820
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
00:09:14.887 --> 00:09:19.592
OF A B 9 75? SEEING NONE. LET'S
00:09:19.659 --> 00:09:21.227
GO BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:09:21.294 --> 00:09:22.862
SERVICE, MISS MODERATOR IF
00:09:22.929 --> 00:09:23.663
THERE'S ANYBODY ON THE
00:09:23.729 --> 00:09:25.631
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE WANTED TO
00:09:25.698 --> 00:09:27.667
WRITE IN SUPPORT OF A B 9 75,
00:09:27.733 --> 00:09:35.875
PLEASE GO AHEAD. PARDON ME TO
00:09:35.942 --> 00:09:37.143
SPEAK IN SUPPORT. PRESS ONE,
00:09:37.209 --> 00:09:39.845
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. UH,
00:09:39.912 --> 00:09:42.048
POLAND, INDICATING THEN ENTERED
00:09:42.114 --> 00:09:44.050
INTO Q AND IN 18 D SPECIALISTS
00:09:44.116 --> 00:09:45.117
WILL PROVIDE YOU WITH YOUR LINE
00:09:45.184 --> 00:09:50.957
NUMBER. MR CHAIRMAN, WE HAVE NO
00:09:51.023 --> 00:09:52.391
ONE KILLING UP AT THIS TIME.
00:09:52.458 --> 00:09:54.226
THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR. LET US
00:09:54.293 --> 00:09:55.561
COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE ROOM
00:09:55.628 --> 00:09:57.630
IF THERE'S ANYBODY HERE IN THE
00:09:57.697 --> 00:10:00.032
COMMITTEE ROOM WHO WOULD LIKE TO
00:10:00.099 --> 00:10:00.700
TEST RIGHT IN OPPOSITION OF 89
00:10:00.766 --> 00:10:02.435
75. PLEASE COME TO THE PODIUM
00:10:02.501 --> 00:10:05.938
WITH A MICROPHONE. SEEING NONE
00:10:06.005 --> 00:10:06.973
BACK TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:10:07.039 --> 00:10:08.040
SERVICE. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU
00:10:08.107 --> 00:10:10.776
COULD PLEASE QUÊ THE LINE. SEE
00:10:10.843 --> 00:10:12.011
IF THERE'S ANY WITNESS WAITING,
00:10:12.078 --> 00:10:15.014
TOUCHED RIGHT? IN OPPOSITION TO
00:10:15.081 --> 00:10:16.983
A B 79 75 ON THE TELECONFERENCE
00:10:17.049 --> 00:10:20.152
SERVICE. TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
00:10:20.219 --> 00:10:21.954
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:10:22.021 --> 00:10:29.261
TIME. MR CHAIRMAN, WE HAVE NO
00:10:29.328 --> 00:10:30.696
LINES QUEUED UP. APPRECIATE THAT
00:10:30.763 --> 00:10:34.300
SIGN OF A GOOD BILL. LET US COME
00:10:34.367 --> 00:10:35.868
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE ROOM, AND
00:10:35.935 --> 00:10:36.936
BEFORE WE GET STARTED WITH
00:10:37.003 --> 00:10:37.803
COMMITTEE MEMBERS, LET'S PLEASE
00:10:37.870 --> 00:10:39.672
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. MADAM
00:10:39.739 --> 00:10:40.673
SECRETARY. IF YOU PLEASE CALL
00:10:40.740 --> 00:10:43.042
THE ROLL, NEWMAN NEWMAN HERE.
00:10:43.109 --> 00:10:47.913
LASER. NILSSON NILSSON HERE,
00:10:47.980 --> 00:10:54.553
HERTZBERG LABOR LABOR HERE.
00:10:54.620 --> 00:10:56.055
HEADQUARTERS IS NOW PRESENT
00:10:56.122 --> 00:10:57.823
THERE. ANY MEMBERS OF THE
00:10:57.890 --> 00:11:00.459
COMMITTEE WHO WISH TO UH, BILL,
00:11:00.526 --> 00:11:02.028
WE'VE GOT EMOTION FROM SENATOR
00:11:02.094 --> 00:11:04.797
LEYVA ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S REVIS
00:11:04.864 --> 00:11:07.166
JUST TO REITERATE YOU HAVE
00:11:07.233 --> 00:11:08.701
INDEED ACCEPTED THE RECOMMEND
00:11:08.768 --> 00:11:11.137
AMENDMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
00:11:11.203 --> 00:11:12.738
AND IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE THANK
00:11:12.805 --> 00:11:13.873
YOU, AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:11:13.939 --> 00:11:18.778
MY VOTE. AND SO THE MOTION IS.
00:11:18.844 --> 00:11:21.280
D PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST
00:11:21.347 --> 00:11:22.882
AMEND AND REEF REFER TO THE
00:11:22.948 --> 00:11:26.085
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
00:11:26.152 --> 00:11:27.153
MADAM SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL THE
00:11:27.219 --> 00:11:32.558
ROLL. A B 9 75 ASSEMBLYWOMAN
00:11:32.625 --> 00:11:34.560
THREE OF US MOTION IS DUE PASS
00:11:34.627 --> 00:11:36.195
AS AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND
00:11:36.262 --> 00:11:37.730
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:11:37.797 --> 00:11:38.364
APPROPRIATIONS. NEWMAN NEWMAN.
00:11:38.431 --> 00:11:43.169
AYE. NILSSON NILSSON, I LASER
00:11:43.235 --> 00:11:49.308
HERTZBERG. LABOR LABOR. AYE.
00:11:49.375 --> 00:11:50.976
CURRENT VOTERS, 30, WE WILL
00:11:51.043 --> 00:11:53.479
LEAVE THAT OPEN FOR THE TIME
00:11:53.546 --> 00:11:54.580
BEING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
00:11:54.647 --> 00:11:57.450
SAM. REMEMBER RIVAS. ACTUALLY
00:11:57.516 --> 00:11:58.884
LET'S DO THAT. LET'S LET'S GO TO
00:11:58.951 --> 00:12:00.186
THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THERE ARE
00:12:00.252 --> 00:12:04.423
THREE ITEMS ON CONSENT. LET ME
00:12:04.490 --> 00:12:06.792
READ THEM AGAIN THAT THE 1ST 16
00:12:06.859 --> 00:12:10.062
19 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES.
00:12:10.129 --> 00:12:11.564
SECOND IS A B 17 98
00:12:11.630 --> 00:12:14.300
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BRIAN. THIRD IS
00:12:14.366 --> 00:12:16.102
ASSEMBLY A B 25 77. IT'S
00:12:16.168 --> 00:12:18.204
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BIGELOW. MADAM
00:12:18.270 --> 00:12:19.472
SECRETARY. IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:12:19.538 --> 00:12:21.173
CALL THE ROLL ON THE CONSENT
00:12:21.240 --> 00:12:24.510
CALENDAR. NEWMAN NEWMAN. AYE.
00:12:24.577 --> 00:12:28.547
NILSSON NILSSON, I LASER.
00:12:28.614 --> 00:12:34.053
HERTZBERG LEVER LEVER? AYE. THE
00:12:34.120 --> 00:12:36.122
THAT CURRENTLY STANDS AT 30.
00:12:36.188 --> 00:12:37.790
WE'LL LEAVE THAT OPEN AND
00:12:37.857 --> 00:12:39.091
WELCOME ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:12:39.158 --> 00:12:40.593
CERVANTES. I UNDERSTAND YOU HAVE
00:12:40.659 --> 00:12:42.661
YOUR OWN BILLS. YOU'LL ALSO BE
00:12:42.728 --> 00:12:43.662
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF
00:12:43.729 --> 00:12:45.564
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS. WELCOME
00:12:45.631 --> 00:12:47.233
IN WHICH WHICH WE'RE GOING TO
00:12:47.299 --> 00:12:50.169
START YOU WITH. MAYBE 13 7 IS MY
00:12:50.236 --> 00:12:51.637
UNDERSTANDING. IS IT POSSIBLE TO
00:12:51.704 --> 00:12:55.241
START WITH 21 72 FOR YOU? YES I
00:12:55.307 --> 00:12:57.309
THINK THAT MR CHAIR IT IS
00:12:57.376 --> 00:12:58.444
MONDAY. THAT'S THE LEAST WE CAN
00:12:58.511 --> 00:13:00.846
DO FOR YOU. SO PLEASE PROCEED.
00:13:00.913 --> 00:13:02.948
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND SENATORS
00:13:03.015 --> 00:13:03.949
FOR ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT
00:13:04.016 --> 00:13:05.951
ASSEMBLY BILL 21 72 TODAY I WANT
00:13:06.018 --> 00:13:06.886
TO BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE
00:13:06.952 --> 00:13:08.320
SECRETARY OF STATE SUGGESTED
00:13:08.387 --> 00:13:10.890
AMENDMENTS AS LAID OUT IN PAGE
00:13:10.956 --> 00:13:12.124
FIVE AND SIX OF THE COMMITTEE
00:13:12.191 --> 00:13:14.293
ANALYSIS. I DO WANT TO THANK THE
00:13:14.360 --> 00:13:15.361
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
00:13:15.427 --> 00:13:16.428
DILIGENT ASSISTANCE ON THIS
00:13:16.495 --> 00:13:19.465
BILL. THE PURPOSE OF A B 21 72
00:13:19.532 --> 00:13:20.966
IS TO MODERNIZE THE POLITICAL
00:13:21.033 --> 00:13:23.269
REFORM ACT OF 1974 TO REFLECT
00:13:23.335 --> 00:13:25.337
THE 21ST CENTURY REALITIES SINCE
00:13:25.404 --> 00:13:27.206
THE ENACTMENT OF THE POLITICAL
00:13:27.273 --> 00:13:29.808
REFORM ACT. 1974 ELECTED
00:13:29.875 --> 00:13:31.377
OFFICIALS AND OTHER ENTITIES ARE
00:13:31.443 --> 00:13:33.078
REQUIRED TO FILE A PERIODIC
00:13:33.145 --> 00:13:34.813
CAMPAIGN STATEMENTS AND REPORTS
00:13:34.880 --> 00:13:36.715
REGARDING CAMPAIGN FINANCES.
00:13:36.782 --> 00:13:38.450
UNDER CURRENT LAW, THE CAMPAIGN
00:13:38.517 --> 00:13:40.052
STATEMENTS THAT ARE FILED WITH
00:13:40.119 --> 00:13:42.354
THE SECRETARY OF STATE ON PAPER
00:13:42.421 --> 00:13:43.522
ALSO REQUIRED TO HAVE HENREDON
00:13:43.589 --> 00:13:45.424
SIGNATURE. IN RESPONSE TO THE
00:13:45.491 --> 00:13:47.560
ONGOING COVID 19 PANDEMIC, THE
00:13:47.626 --> 00:13:49.962
VOLUME OF REQUEST FOR ONLINE AND
00:13:50.029 --> 00:13:51.397
ELECTRONIC FILING OPTIONS HAVE
00:13:51.463 --> 00:13:53.065
RAPIDLY INCREASED AS MORE AND
00:13:53.132 --> 00:13:54.300
MORE BUSINESSES TRANSITION TO
00:13:54.366 --> 00:13:58.304
ELECTRONIC PROCESSES. TO REFLECT
00:13:58.370 --> 00:13:59.805
THE ELECTRONIC REALITIES OF THE
00:13:59.872 --> 00:14:02.808
21ST CENTURY. 21 72 ELIMINATES
00:14:02.875 --> 00:14:04.310
THE NEED FOR HENREDON SIGNATURES
00:14:04.376 --> 00:14:06.445
AND INSTEAD AUTHORIZES A PERSON
00:14:06.512 --> 00:14:08.814
TO FILE BY A VALID EMAIL ADDRESS
00:14:08.881 --> 00:14:10.983
OR BY OTHER DIGITAL MEANS, AS
00:14:11.050 --> 00:14:12.518
PRESCRIBED BY THE SECRETARY OF
00:14:12.585 --> 00:14:14.220
STATE AND REQUIRES THE FILING TO
00:14:14.286 --> 00:14:15.321
BE SIGNED WITH A DIGITAL
00:14:15.387 --> 00:14:17.156
SIGNATURE. THAT CONFORMS WITH
00:14:17.223 --> 00:14:18.157
THE SECRETARY OF STATE'S
00:14:18.224 --> 00:14:20.125
REQUIREMENTS DURING THE INTERIM
00:14:20.192 --> 00:14:21.694
PERIOD BEFORE THEY KILL ACCESS
00:14:21.760 --> 00:14:23.796
REPLACEMENT SYSTEM IS COMPLETED.
00:14:23.862 --> 00:14:26.232
I HAVE WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN
00:14:26.298 --> 00:14:27.032
SUPPORT OF THE BILL LINDSAY
00:14:27.099 --> 00:14:29.101
MCCONNELL WITH A FAIR POLITICAL
00:14:29.168 --> 00:14:29.635
PRACTICES COMMISSION, THE
00:14:29.702 --> 00:14:33.172
SPONSOR OF THE BILL. THANK YOU
00:14:33.239 --> 00:14:35.774
BELIEVE MR CONNORS ON THE PHONE
00:14:35.841 --> 00:14:36.942
LINE, MR. CONOVER, IF YOU'RE
00:14:37.009 --> 00:14:41.213
THERE, PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU
00:14:41.280 --> 00:14:41.981
. GOOD MORNING, MR CHAIR AND
00:14:42.047 --> 00:14:44.316
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS BRENDAN
00:14:44.383 --> 00:14:44.883
CONNOR, SENIOR LEGISLATIVE
00:14:44.950 --> 00:14:46.485
COUNSEL WITH THE FAIR POLITICAL
00:14:46.552 --> 00:14:48.287
PRACTICES COMMISSION. MISSION IS
00:14:48.354 --> 00:14:50.256
TO SPONSOR A B 21 72 BY
00:14:50.322 --> 00:14:52.458
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES. AND
00:14:52.524 --> 00:14:53.826
EXISTING LAW. THE POLITICAL
00:14:53.892 --> 00:14:55.327
REFORM ACT REQUIRES CERTAIN
00:14:55.394 --> 00:14:57.029
STATEMENTS AND REPORTS TO BE
00:14:57.096 --> 00:14:59.398
FILED WITH THE SECRETARY OF
00:14:59.465 --> 00:15:00.299
STATE'S OFFICE IN PAPER FORMAT.
00:15:00.366 --> 00:15:02.001
OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS AND
00:15:02.067 --> 00:15:03.068
OVER THE PAST TWO YEARS,
00:15:03.135 --> 00:15:05.170
ESPECIALLY, WE HAVE SEEN
00:15:05.237 --> 00:15:05.871
BUSINESS INCREASINGLY MOVE
00:15:05.938 --> 00:15:08.007
ONLINE AND TO REMOTE PROCESSES,
00:15:08.073 --> 00:15:09.008
AND AS A RESULT, WE'VE SEEN
00:15:09.074 --> 00:15:10.142
INCREASED REQUESTS FOR
00:15:10.209 --> 00:15:12.578
ELECTRONIC FILING OPTIONS. THE
00:15:12.645 --> 00:15:14.146
GOLD IS BUILT TO MODERNIZE THE
00:15:14.213 --> 00:15:15.814
POLITICAL REFORM ACT AND RELIEVE
00:15:15.881 --> 00:15:17.249
SOME OF THE BURDEN OF PAPER
00:15:17.316 --> 00:15:18.817
FILINGS AND THE NEED TOGETHER
00:15:18.884 --> 00:15:20.252
HANDWRITTEN SIGNATURES FOR THOSE
00:15:20.319 --> 00:15:21.787
FILINGS, AND WE THINK THE BILL
00:15:21.854 --> 00:15:22.688
EFFECTIVELY ACCOMPLISHES THE
00:15:22.755 --> 00:15:24.890
GOAL. BY AUTHORIZING EMAIL
00:15:24.957 --> 00:15:25.958
FILING WITH THE U. S WITH
00:15:26.025 --> 00:15:28.861
DIGITAL SIGNATURE. THANK YOU TO
00:15:28.927 --> 00:15:29.928
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES, YOUR
00:15:29.995 --> 00:15:32.031
LEADERSHIP AND COLLABORATION ON
00:15:32.097 --> 00:15:33.332
THIS ISSUE AND THANK YOU FOR THE
00:15:33.399 --> 00:15:34.333
COMMITTEE FOR CONSIDERING THIS
00:15:34.400 --> 00:15:36.035
BILL ESPECIALLY ASKED FOR YOUR
00:15:36.101 --> 00:15:38.871
EYES. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:15:38.937 --> 00:15:40.572
TESTIMONY. LET'S COME BACK TO
00:15:40.639 --> 00:15:41.940
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. IS
00:15:42.007 --> 00:15:43.609
ANYBODY IN THE HEARING ROOM WHO
00:15:43.676 --> 00:15:44.710
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY ON BEHALF
00:15:44.777 --> 00:15:48.380
OF A B 21 72? SHAME THAT MR
00:15:48.447 --> 00:15:49.782
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD, PLEASE
00:15:49.848 --> 00:15:51.583
, HUGH, THE TELECONFERENCE NOW
00:15:51.650 --> 00:15:52.951
IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE LINE
00:15:53.018 --> 00:15:53.919
WHO'D LIKE TO TESTIFY ON BEHALF
00:15:53.986 --> 00:15:58.757
OF A B 21 72? TO SPEAK IN
00:15:58.824 --> 00:16:00.626
SUPPORT PRESS ONE THAN ZERO AT
00:16:00.693 --> 00:16:08.367
THIS TIME. MR CHAIRMAN, WE HAVE
00:16:08.434 --> 00:16:10.402
NO IN QUEUED UP. THANK YOU.
00:16:10.469 --> 00:16:11.804
MOVING TO OPPOSITIONS OR ANYBODY
00:16:11.870 --> 00:16:12.871
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD
00:16:12.938 --> 00:16:14.506
LIKE SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
00:16:14.573 --> 00:16:18.043
ASSEMBLY BILL 21 72. SAYING NONE
00:16:18.110 --> 00:16:18.811
. MR MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
00:16:18.877 --> 00:16:20.346
PLEASE PULL THE TELECONFERENCE
00:16:20.412 --> 00:16:22.014
SIDE FOR ANYBODY WISHING TO
00:16:22.081 --> 00:16:24.149
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
00:16:24.216 --> 00:16:25.284
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION PRESS
00:16:25.351 --> 00:16:32.224
ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
00:16:32.291 --> 00:16:33.425
ONCE AGAIN, MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
00:16:33.492 --> 00:16:37.062
ONE QUEUED UP. THANK YOU COMING
00:16:37.129 --> 00:16:38.197
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE HEARING
00:16:38.263 --> 00:16:41.200
ROOM TO MEMBERS. MY COLLEAGUES
00:16:41.266 --> 00:16:43.402
AND INPUT ON THE BILL GOT A
00:16:43.469 --> 00:16:45.104
MOTION FROM CINDER LIVER
00:16:45.170 --> 00:16:46.472
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S STRATEGY. WOULD
00:16:46.538 --> 00:16:47.806
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY
00:16:47.873 --> 00:16:49.541
ASK FOR I VOTE. JUST BE CLEAR.
00:16:49.608 --> 00:16:51.043
YOU ARE ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS
00:16:51.110 --> 00:16:52.010
FROM THE COMMITTEE. THAT IS
00:16:52.077 --> 00:16:53.779
CORRECT. I AM OKAY. MADAM
00:16:53.846 --> 00:16:56.682
SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:16:56.749 --> 00:16:59.118
A B 21 72 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:16:59.184 --> 00:17:01.186
CERVANTES MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
00:17:01.253 --> 00:17:02.888
AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMENDMENT AND
00:17:02.955 --> 00:17:05.190
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:17:05.257 --> 00:17:05.824
APPROPRIATIONS. NEWMAN NEWMAN.
00:17:05.891 --> 00:17:09.561
AYE. NILSSON NILSSON, I LASER
00:17:09.628 --> 00:17:16.802
HERTZBERG. LABOR LABOR. AYE. THE
00:17:16.869 --> 00:17:18.637
THAT VOTE CURRENTLY SENDS HIS 30
00:17:18.704 --> 00:17:22.174
. WE'LL LEAVE THAT ON CALL.
00:17:22.241 --> 00:17:24.309
EXCELLENT SO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:17:24.376 --> 00:17:25.844
CERVANTES. WHAT'S YOUR CHOICE?
00:17:25.911 --> 00:17:27.980
WHAT'S YOUR NEXT BILL? IF I MAY
00:17:28.046 --> 00:17:31.250
, MR CHAIR A B 16 31 VERY GOOD.
00:17:31.316 --> 00:17:32.718
PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU FOR
00:17:32.785 --> 00:17:35.487
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT A B 16 31
00:17:35.554 --> 00:17:36.922
. UNDER EXISTING LAW, COUNTY
00:17:36.989 --> 00:17:37.990
REGISTERS ARE REQUIRED TO
00:17:38.056 --> 00:17:39.958
PUBLICIZE A LIST OF PRECINCTS.
00:17:40.025 --> 00:17:41.427
IN WHICH MULTILINGUAL POLLING
00:17:41.493 --> 00:17:42.961
PLACE WORKERS WILL BE OPERATING
00:17:43.028 --> 00:17:44.663
AS WELL AS LANGUAGES THAT THOSE
00:17:44.730 --> 00:17:46.465
WORKERS SPEAK FOR EACH ELECTION.
00:17:46.532 --> 00:17:48.233
THEY ADMINISTER. THE STATUTE
00:17:48.300 --> 00:17:49.401
CURRENTLY DOES NOT SAY THAT
00:17:49.468 --> 00:17:52.805
WHICH MEDIA THIS IMPORTANT
00:17:52.871 --> 00:17:54.173
INFORMATION SHOULD BE PUBLICIZED
00:17:54.239 --> 00:17:55.474
. THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT, FOR
00:17:55.541 --> 00:17:56.775
EXAMPLE, THAT THIS BE MADE
00:17:56.842 --> 00:17:58.844
PUBLIC ON THE INTERNET. AS A
00:17:58.911 --> 00:17:59.845
RESULT, THIS INFORMATION IS NOT
00:17:59.912 --> 00:18:01.547
CONSISTENTLY POSTED ONLINE BY
00:18:01.613 --> 00:18:02.815
OLIVER COUNTY REGISTRARS WHICH
00:18:02.881 --> 00:18:06.318
LEADS TOO SERIOUS ACCESSIBILITY
00:18:06.385 --> 00:18:07.886
ISSUES. FOR INSTANCE, DURING THE
00:18:07.953 --> 00:18:09.822
APRIL 5TH ELECTION SPECIAL
00:18:09.888 --> 00:18:11.223
ELECTION FOR THE CALIFORNIA'S
00:18:11.290 --> 00:18:13.692
22ND DISTRICT FOR THE HOUSE OF
00:18:13.759 --> 00:18:14.593
REPRESENTATIVES, THE FRESNO
00:18:14.660 --> 00:18:16.028
COUNTY REGISTRAR DID NOT PROVIDE
00:18:16.094 --> 00:18:17.996
INFORMATION ON THEIR WEBSITE
00:18:18.063 --> 00:18:19.264
ABOUT WHICH PRECINCTS WOULD
00:18:19.331 --> 00:18:20.265
EMPLOY MULTI LINGUAL POLLING
00:18:20.332 --> 00:18:22.835
PLACE WORKERS. IN 2022.
00:18:22.901 --> 00:18:23.735
PROVIDING THIS KIND OF
00:18:23.802 --> 00:18:25.170
INFORMATION ONLINE IS NO LONGER
00:18:25.237 --> 00:18:27.406
OPTIONAL. IT IS EXPECTED WHEN
00:18:27.473 --> 00:18:28.874
RESTAURANTS PROVIDE MENUS OR
00:18:28.941 --> 00:18:30.309
MOVIE THEATERS PROVIDE SHOWTIMES
00:18:30.375 --> 00:18:31.677
ONLINE. WE SHOULD EXPECT
00:18:31.743 --> 00:18:32.778
GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE BASIC
00:18:32.845 --> 00:18:33.846
INFORMATION LIKE THIS ON THE
00:18:33.912 --> 00:18:36.415
INTERNET. THE PURPOSE OF A B 13
00:18:36.482 --> 00:18:40.252
16 31. IS TO BRING THIS PART OF
00:18:40.319 --> 00:18:41.687
OUR ELECTION SYSTEMS IN LINE
00:18:41.753 --> 00:18:43.589
WITH THE REALITIES OF THE 21ST
00:18:43.655 --> 00:18:46.291
CENTURY. THIS BILL SIMPLY
00:18:46.358 --> 00:18:48.260
REQUIRES COUNTY REGISTRARS TO
00:18:48.327 --> 00:18:49.795
PUBLISH THIS INFORMATION ONLINE
00:18:49.862 --> 00:18:51.196
EACH OF THEIR RESPECTIVE
00:18:51.263 --> 00:18:54.199
WEBSITES. I DO WANT TO NOTE THAT
00:18:54.266 --> 00:18:55.701
THE ISSUES OF HOW NON ENGLISH
00:18:55.767 --> 00:18:56.902
SPEAKERS ARE ABLE TO INTERACT
00:18:56.969 --> 00:18:59.638
WITH OUR ELECTION SYSTEM. IS ONE
00:18:59.705 --> 00:19:01.273
THAT REQUIRES SERIOUS ATTENTION.
00:19:01.340 --> 00:19:03.242
I DO LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING ON
00:19:03.308 --> 00:19:04.676
MAKING OUR ELECTIONS MORE
00:19:04.743 --> 00:19:06.478
ACCESSIBLE TO LAWFULLY
00:19:06.545 --> 00:19:07.479
REGISTERED VOTERS WHO SPEAK
00:19:07.546 --> 00:19:09.348
LANGUAGES OTHER THAN ENGLISH IN
00:19:09.414 --> 00:19:11.617
COMING YEARS. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:19:11.683 --> 00:19:13.151
FOR MY VOTE. THANK YOU. MY
00:19:13.218 --> 00:19:14.052
UNDERSTANDING. THERE ARE THERE
00:19:14.119 --> 00:19:16.455
IS NO LEAD WITNESS AND
00:19:16.522 --> 00:19:19.057
SUPPORTERS ARE CORRECT. AND SO
00:19:19.124 --> 00:19:20.092
THERE IS THERE. ANYBODY HERE IN
00:19:20.158 --> 00:19:22.094
THE HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
00:19:22.160 --> 00:19:23.662
TEST RIGHT ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
00:19:23.729 --> 00:19:27.266
BILL 16 31. SEEING NONE. MR.
00:19:27.332 --> 00:19:30.035
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD PULL THE
00:19:30.102 --> 00:19:31.236
TELECONFERENCE LINE TO SEE IF%
00:19:31.303 --> 00:19:32.504
THERE'S ANYBODY SPEAKING ON
00:19:32.571 --> 00:19:37.242
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY BILL 16 31 TO
00:19:37.309 --> 00:19:38.410
SPEAK IN SUPPORT. PRESS ONE,
00:19:38.477 --> 00:19:47.219
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. THERE
00:19:47.286 --> 00:19:48.854
ARE NOT LINED UP, MR CHAIRMAN.
00:19:48.921 --> 00:19:50.489
THANK YOU, SIR. IS THERE ANYBODY
00:19:50.556 --> 00:19:51.857
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD
00:19:51.924 --> 00:19:53.559
LIKE TO TEST RIGHT IN OPPOSITION
00:19:53.625 --> 00:19:56.929
TO A B 16 31. SAYING THAT MR
00:19:56.995 --> 00:19:58.297
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:19:58.363 --> 00:20:00.265
PULL THE TELECONFERENCE LINE FOR
00:20:00.332 --> 00:20:02.167
ANYBODY WHO WANTED TO SPEAK IN
00:20:02.234 --> 00:20:05.203
OPPOSITION TV 16 31. THANK YOU
00:20:05.270 --> 00:20:06.371
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. PLEASE
00:20:06.438 --> 00:20:16.515
PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME. THERE ARE
00:20:16.582 --> 00:20:18.584
NO LINES QUEUED UP, MR CHAIRMAN
00:20:18.650 --> 00:20:20.686
. THANK YOU BACK TO MY
00:20:20.752 --> 00:20:23.822
COLLEAGUES DID ANY GOT EMOTION
00:20:23.889 --> 00:20:25.190
FROM SENATOR LIVA
00:20:25.257 --> 00:20:26.425
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES?
00:20:26.491 --> 00:20:27.526
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I
00:20:27.593 --> 00:20:28.660
RESPECTFULLY ASK TONIGHT BEFORE
00:20:28.727 --> 00:20:29.795
I VOTE. THANK YOU, MADAM
00:20:29.861 --> 00:20:33.031
SECRETARY. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:20:33.098 --> 00:20:34.600
MAYBE 16 31 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:20:34.666 --> 00:20:37.436
CERVANTES MOTION IS DUE PAST
00:20:37.502 --> 00:20:39.538
FIRST BE WE REFERRED TO THE
00:20:39.605 --> 00:20:40.572
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
00:20:40.639 --> 00:20:43.542
NEWMAN ALRIGHT, I NILSSON
00:20:43.609 --> 00:20:48.180
NILSSON, I GLASER HERTZBERG.
00:20:48.246 --> 00:20:53.785
LABOR LABOR. AYE. VERY GOOD, UM
00:20:53.852 --> 00:20:55.187
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SURVIVORS AND
00:20:55.253 --> 00:20:56.955
AN ADVENTURE A GUESS THAT THE
00:20:57.022 --> 00:20:59.291
NEXT BILLION PRESENT IS A B 13.
00:20:59.358 --> 00:21:00.092
OH, SEVEN. IS THAT CORRECT? THAT
00:21:00.158 --> 00:21:02.194
IS CORRECT. MR CHAIR. THANK YOU
00:21:02.260 --> 00:21:03.328
. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU FOR
00:21:03.395 --> 00:21:05.330
THE OPPORTUNITY HERE TO PRESENT
00:21:05.397 --> 00:21:07.366
MY RE INDEPENDENT REDISTRICTING
00:21:07.432 --> 00:21:09.201
COMMISSION BILL FOR RIVERSIDE
00:21:09.267 --> 00:21:10.268
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS,
00:21:10.335 --> 00:21:12.237
BEGINNING WITH THE 2030 ROUND OF
00:21:12.304 --> 00:21:14.239
REDISTRICTING. WE AS MEMBERS OF
00:21:14.306 --> 00:21:15.707
THE LEGISLATURE DO NOT GET TO
00:21:15.774 --> 00:21:17.542
DRAW OUR OWN DISTRICT. WHY
00:21:17.609 --> 00:21:18.577
SHOULD THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY
00:21:18.644 --> 00:21:19.645
BORDER SUPERVISORS BE ANY
00:21:19.711 --> 00:21:21.079
DIFFERENT? IN EARLY DECEMBER
00:21:21.146 --> 00:21:22.614
LAST YEAR, THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY
00:21:22.681 --> 00:21:24.282
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS VOTED 4 TO
00:21:24.349 --> 00:21:25.917
1 TO ADOPT A SUPERVISORIAL
00:21:25.984 --> 00:21:27.953
DISTRICT MAPS. WITH THE 2020
00:21:28.020 --> 00:21:29.421
ROUND OF REDISTRICTING THAT
00:21:29.488 --> 00:21:30.822
FRACTURES THE LATINO COMMUNITY
00:21:30.889 --> 00:21:32.357
IN THE COUNTY, DILUTING THE
00:21:32.424 --> 00:21:33.925
COMMUNITY'S VOTING POWER IN
00:21:33.992 --> 00:21:35.360
THEIR CAPACITY TO ELECT A
00:21:35.427 --> 00:21:36.962
REPRESENTATIVE OF THEIR CHOICE,
00:21:37.029 --> 00:21:38.030
THIS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH
00:21:38.096 --> 00:21:40.198
STATE AND FEDERAL LAW. CLEARLY
00:21:40.265 --> 00:21:42.200
ILLUSTRATES WHY AN INDEPENDENT
00:21:42.267 --> 00:21:43.201
CITIZENS REDISTRICTING
00:21:43.268 --> 00:21:45.103
COMMISSION IS NEEDED TO DRAW
00:21:45.170 --> 00:21:47.506
FAIR MAPS FOR RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
00:21:47.572 --> 00:21:48.974
MAYBE 13. OH, SEVEN WILL CREATE
00:21:49.041 --> 00:21:51.176
SUCH A COMMISSION, AND BY DOING
00:21:51.243 --> 00:21:52.711
SO RETURN THE POWER TO DRAW
00:21:52.778 --> 00:21:54.713
DISTRICT LINES WERE IT BELONGS
00:21:54.780 --> 00:21:56.281
WITH THE CITIZENS OF RIVERSIDE
00:21:56.348 --> 00:21:57.215
COUNTY. THE COMMISSION WOULD
00:21:57.282 --> 00:21:59.184
FIRST SPEAK. CONSTITUTED FOR THE
00:21:59.251 --> 00:22:01.186
2030 ROUND OF REDISTRICTING.
00:22:01.253 --> 00:22:02.754
THIS BILL'S MODELED AFTER THE
00:22:02.821 --> 00:22:04.256
COMMISSION'S IN LOS ANGELES AND
00:22:04.322 --> 00:22:05.757
SAN DIEGO COUNTY'S CREATED BY
00:22:05.824 --> 00:22:07.492
SENATE BILL 958 AND ASSEMBLY
00:22:07.559 --> 00:22:10.662
BILL 801. THIS COMMITTEE DID A
00:22:10.729 --> 00:22:12.664
GREAT DEAL OF GOOD WORK AND
00:22:12.731 --> 00:22:13.799
HELPING ENACT THOSE TWO BILLS IN
00:22:13.865 --> 00:22:15.834
RECENT YEARS, MUCH LIKE L. A AND
00:22:15.901 --> 00:22:17.302
SAN DIEGO COMMISSIONS, THE
00:22:17.369 --> 00:22:18.704
PARTISAN MAKEUP OF THIS
00:22:18.770 --> 00:22:20.205
COMMISSION WILL BE PROPORTIONAL
00:22:20.272 --> 00:22:21.139
TO THE PARTISAN MAKEUP OF
00:22:21.206 --> 00:22:22.340
RIVERSIDE COUNTY VOTERS,
00:22:22.407 --> 00:22:23.442
INCLUDING VOTERS WITH NO PARTY
00:22:23.508 --> 00:22:25.911
PREFERENCE. SIMILAR TO THE
00:22:25.977 --> 00:22:27.579
COMMISSION'S CREATED BY THE
00:22:27.646 --> 00:22:29.481
PREVIOUS TWO BILLS, AS STATED
00:22:29.548 --> 00:22:30.949
THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY COMMISSION
00:22:31.016 --> 00:22:32.184
WOULD HAVE ELIGIBILITY
00:22:32.250 --> 00:22:34.486
REQUIREMENTS AND PROHIBITIONS
00:22:34.553 --> 00:22:35.987
MOST BASED ON CURRENT EMPLOYMENT
00:22:36.054 --> 00:22:38.924
OR PREVIOUS EMPLOYMENT HISTORY.
00:22:38.990 --> 00:22:40.659
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE SERVED AS
00:22:40.726 --> 00:22:42.828
PUBLIC OFFICIALS OR CANDIDATES
00:22:42.894 --> 00:22:44.296
FOR OFFICE IN THE PAST 10 YEARS
00:22:44.362 --> 00:22:45.797
, AS WELL AS THEIR IMMEDIATE
00:22:45.864 --> 00:22:47.999
FAMILIES WOULD BE INELIGIBLE TO
00:22:48.066 --> 00:22:49.468
SERVE ON THE COMMISSION. THE
00:22:49.534 --> 00:22:51.536
SAME WOULD BE TRUE FOR POLITICAL
00:22:51.603 --> 00:22:52.604
CONSULTANTS AT THE LOCAL, STATE
00:22:52.671 --> 00:22:53.138
OR FEDERAL LEVEL THEY ARE
00:22:53.205 --> 00:22:57.008
LOBBYISTS. THE GUIDELINES IN
00:22:57.075 --> 00:22:58.677
THIS BILL, HELP ENSURE THAT
00:22:58.744 --> 00:23:00.479
TRULY INDEPENDENT AND UNBIASED
00:23:00.545 --> 00:23:01.947
CITIZENS ARE EMPOWERED TO DRAW
00:23:02.013 --> 00:23:03.181
SUPERVISORIAL DISTRICTS FOR
00:23:03.248 --> 00:23:04.950
RIVERSIDE COUNTY IF OUR TWO MOST
00:23:05.016 --> 00:23:07.786
POPULOUS COUNTIES IN OUR STATE
00:23:07.853 --> 00:23:09.788
CAN USE INDEPENDENT COMMISSION
00:23:09.855 --> 00:23:11.123
FOR DISTRICTING. IT IS TIME FOR
00:23:11.189 --> 00:23:12.257
RIVERSIDE, OUR FOURTH LARGEST TO
00:23:12.324 --> 00:23:16.895
JOIN THEM. THANK YOU. MY
00:23:16.962 --> 00:23:17.896
UNDERSTANDING IS THERE IS NO
00:23:17.963 --> 00:23:19.397
LEAD WITNESS ON THIS BILL.
00:23:19.464 --> 00:23:22.434
CORRECT IS THERE ANYBODY HERE IN
00:23:22.501 --> 00:23:23.602
THE HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
00:23:23.668 --> 00:23:24.770
TRY ON BEHALF. OF A B 13 OH,
00:23:24.836 --> 00:23:26.438
SEVEN. SITTING DOWN, MR
00:23:26.505 --> 00:23:29.941
MODERATOR, IF YOU PLEASE. PAUL
00:23:30.008 --> 00:23:31.743
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE FOR
00:23:31.810 --> 00:23:33.111
ANYBODY WISHING TO SPEAK IN
00:23:33.178 --> 00:23:36.248
SUPPORT OF A B 13 OH, SEVEN. TO
00:23:36.314 --> 00:23:37.816
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF MAYBE 13. OH
00:23:37.883 --> 00:23:39.818
SEVEN EXPRESS, ONE THAN ZERO AT
00:23:39.885 --> 00:23:46.091
THIS TIME. TO GO TO LINE 19.
00:23:46.158 --> 00:23:47.826
GOOD MORNING. THIS IS DORA ROSE
00:23:47.893 --> 00:23:49.561
FOR THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN. VOTERS
00:23:49.628 --> 00:23:51.196
OF CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT
00:23:51.263 --> 00:23:52.430
OF ABC. 13. OH, SEVEN. THANK
00:23:52.497 --> 00:23:55.000
YOU. THANK YOU, MR MURRAY. IS
00:23:55.066 --> 00:23:57.235
THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON THE
00:23:57.302 --> 00:23:59.571
TELECOM? FURTHER LINES QUEUED UP
00:23:59.638 --> 00:24:01.773
. THANK YOU FOR BRINGING IT BACK
00:24:01.840 --> 00:24:03.475
TO THE HEARING ROOMS. ANYBODY
00:24:03.542 --> 00:24:04.676
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD
00:24:04.743 --> 00:24:05.744
LIKE TO TEST RIGHT IN
00:24:05.811 --> 00:24:09.181
OPPOSITION. TO A B 13 OH, SEVEN.
00:24:09.247 --> 00:24:11.116
SEEING NONE. LET US GO BACK TO
00:24:11.183 --> 00:24:16.188
THE TELECONFERENCE ON MR MORROW.
00:24:16.254 --> 00:24:17.856
THERE'S ANYBODY ON THE LINE WILL
00:24:17.923 --> 00:24:19.591
WISHING TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION,
00:24:19.658 --> 00:24:25.697
MAYBE 13 OR SOON. MR CHAIRMAN,
00:24:25.764 --> 00:24:27.599
WE HAVE NO ONE QUEUED UP AT THIS
00:24:27.666 --> 00:24:31.036
TIME. THANK YOU COMING BACK TO
00:24:31.102 --> 00:24:33.305
MY COLLEAGUES HERE. GOT EMOTION.
00:24:33.371 --> 00:24:35.473
MOVE THE BILL. LIKE I WILL SAY
00:24:35.540 --> 00:24:37.709
PRIOR TO CALLING THE ROLL. I
00:24:37.776 --> 00:24:38.944
UNDERSTAND THIS IS A DISTRICT
00:24:39.010 --> 00:24:40.145
BILL. I UNDERSTAND IT'S MODELED
00:24:40.212 --> 00:24:42.647
ON OTHER PREVIOUS BILLS THAT
00:24:42.714 --> 00:24:44.115
PERTAIN TO COUNTIES BUT IN TERMS
00:24:44.182 --> 00:24:47.018
OF THE BROADER PRINCIPLE AND THE
00:24:47.085 --> 00:24:48.486
GOALS, I'M FULLY SUPPORTIVE,
00:24:48.553 --> 00:24:49.821
HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE BILL. AND
00:24:49.888 --> 00:24:50.989
WITH THAT, MADAM SECRETARY,
00:24:51.056 --> 00:24:56.728
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MAYBE 13
00:24:56.795 --> 00:24:57.896
OH, SEVEN, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:24:57.963 --> 00:25:01.266
CERVANTES. MOTION IS DUE PAST
00:25:01.333 --> 00:25:02.434
BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO THE
00:25:02.500 --> 00:25:03.568
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
00:25:03.635 --> 00:25:07.172
FINANCE. NEWMAN NEWMAN, I
00:25:07.239 --> 00:25:08.907
NILSSON NILSSON, NO LASER
00:25:08.974 --> 00:25:16.314
HERTZBERG. LABOR LEVER. AYE.
00:25:16.381 --> 00:25:19.651
THANK YOU SO THAT THAT BILL IS
00:25:19.718 --> 00:25:20.986
HAS TWO VOTES FOR ONE AGAINST TO
00:25:21.052 --> 00:25:23.922
LEAVE THAT ON CALL. AND SINCE
00:25:23.989 --> 00:25:25.423
YOU ARE ON A ROLL,
00:25:25.490 --> 00:25:26.224
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES LET'S
00:25:26.291 --> 00:25:28.493
HAVE YOU DO SOME OTHER PEOPLE'S
00:25:28.560 --> 00:25:30.128
BILLS. SO I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE
00:25:30.195 --> 00:25:31.029
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF
00:25:31.096 --> 00:25:33.465
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS TODAY A B
00:25:33.531 --> 00:25:35.834
24 94, PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU
00:25:35.901 --> 00:25:38.069
, MR CHAIR AND SENATORS. I AM
00:25:38.136 --> 00:25:40.972
PRESENTING A B 24 94 ON BEHALF
00:25:41.039 --> 00:25:42.507
OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RUDY SALIS.
00:25:42.574 --> 00:25:44.109
THIS BILL IS VERY SIMILAR TO MY
00:25:44.175 --> 00:25:45.810
OWN ASSEMBLY BUILT 13 7, WHICH
00:25:45.877 --> 00:25:48.079
THIS COMMITTEE JUST HEARD. EVERY
00:25:48.146 --> 00:25:50.282
24 90 TO CREATE AN INDEPENDENT
00:25:50.348 --> 00:25:51.016
CITIZENS REDISTRICTING
00:25:51.082 --> 00:25:53.184
COMMISSION FOR CURRENT COUNTY
00:25:53.251 --> 00:25:54.753
THE COMMISSION WOULD BE MADE UP
00:25:54.819 --> 00:25:56.121
OF REPUBLICAN DEMOCRATS AND
00:25:56.187 --> 00:25:57.289
DECLINING STATE VOTERS WHO LIVE
00:25:57.355 --> 00:25:59.958
IN KERN COUNTY. THIS INDEPENDENT
00:26:00.025 --> 00:26:00.926
COMMISSION WILL PROTECT
00:26:00.992 --> 00:26:03.561
TAXPAYERS FROM HAVING THEIR HARD
00:26:03.628 --> 00:26:05.063
EARNED DOLLARS WASTED ON
00:26:05.130 --> 00:26:06.998
LAWSUITS LIKE THE ONE IN 2018,
00:26:07.065 --> 00:26:08.400
IN WHICH CURRENT COUNTY WAS SUED
00:26:08.466 --> 00:26:10.435
FOR NOT DRAWING FAIR MAPS.
00:26:10.502 --> 00:26:11.970
INDEPENDENT CITIZENS.
00:26:12.037 --> 00:26:12.938
REDISTRICTING COMMISSIONS HAVE
00:26:13.004 --> 00:26:14.940
ALREADY BEEN SUCCESSFUL IN OTHER
00:26:15.006 --> 00:26:15.874
COUNTIES LIKE LOS ANGELES AND
00:26:15.941 --> 00:26:17.976
SAN DIEGO, ESTABLISHING A
00:26:18.043 --> 00:26:18.810
SIMILAR INDEPENDENT
00:26:18.877 --> 00:26:20.312
REDISTRICTING COMMISSION IN
00:26:20.378 --> 00:26:21.880
CURRENT COUNTY WILL AID IN THE
00:26:21.947 --> 00:26:24.049
CREATION OF A MORE FAIR MAPS. SO
00:26:24.115 --> 00:26:25.550
MORE VOICES AND CURRENT COUNTY
00:26:25.617 --> 00:26:27.085
COMMUNITY WILL BE HEARD AND
00:26:27.152 --> 00:26:29.387
RESPECTED WITH ME TO TESTIFY BY
00:26:29.454 --> 00:26:31.289
PHONE TODAY IS LAURIE PISSANT, A
00:26:31.356 --> 00:26:32.357
WITH THE DELORES WORTH A
00:26:32.424 --> 00:26:34.659
FOUNDATION. THANK YOU, MISS
00:26:34.726 --> 00:26:39.531
PERCENT. PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
00:26:39.597 --> 00:26:41.433
MORNING, SENATOR NEWMAN. MEMBERS
00:26:41.499 --> 00:26:43.101
OF THE COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS
00:26:43.168 --> 00:26:44.002
LAURIE ASANTE AND I'M THE
00:26:44.069 --> 00:26:46.004
DIRECTOR OF CIVIC ENGAGEMENT,
00:26:46.071 --> 00:26:48.073
WORDS OF FOUNDATION AND THE
00:26:48.139 --> 00:26:48.840
FACILITATOR OF THE GRASSROOTS
00:26:48.907 --> 00:26:50.008
GROUP KNOWN AS THE EXCITABLE
00:26:50.075 --> 00:26:53.545
MAPS COALITION. IN THE 2021
00:26:53.611 --> 00:26:55.113
REDISTRICTING CYCLE. WE
00:26:55.180 --> 00:26:56.948
COLLECTED THOUSANDS OF COMMUNITY
00:26:57.015 --> 00:26:58.583
OF INTEREST SURVEYS, THREE
00:26:58.650 --> 00:27:00.485
MARKET COVID OUTREACH EVENTS AND
00:27:00.552 --> 00:27:01.453
FOOD BANKS THROUGHOUT THE
00:27:01.519 --> 00:27:02.954
CENTRAL VALLEY AND HIGH DESERT
00:27:03.021 --> 00:27:04.956
HELD COMMUNITY MAPPING SESSIONS
00:27:05.023 --> 00:27:07.125
EACH WEEK FOR OVER A YEAR,
00:27:07.192 --> 00:27:08.126
ULTIMATELY ENGAGING OVER 5000
00:27:08.193 --> 00:27:11.196
PEOPLE. WE PROPOSED MAPS FOR THE
00:27:11.262 --> 00:27:12.731
CURRENT QUARTER SUPERVISORS THAT
00:27:12.797 --> 00:27:14.966
EASILY DREW THREE EFFECTIVE
00:27:15.033 --> 00:27:17.035
VOTING RIGHT BACK DISTRICT, BUT
00:27:17.102 --> 00:27:18.103
UNFORTUNATELY, THE BOARD OF
00:27:18.169 --> 00:27:19.204
SUPERVISORS DID WHAT THEY HAVE
00:27:19.270 --> 00:27:21.806
ALWAYS DONE. THEY PAID HUGE
00:27:21.873 --> 00:27:23.241
AMOUNTS OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO
00:27:23.308 --> 00:27:24.743
ATTORNEYS AND DEMOGRAPHERS TO
00:27:24.809 --> 00:27:25.777
DRAW THEM A MAP THAT
00:27:25.844 --> 00:27:27.879
CONCENTRATES POWER IN THE HANDS
00:27:27.946 --> 00:27:29.247
OF WHITE, AFFLUENT RESIDENTS TO
00:27:29.314 --> 00:27:30.348
THE PROFOUND DETRIMENT OF
00:27:30.415 --> 00:27:32.017
CURRENT RURAL AND LOW INCOME
00:27:32.083 --> 00:27:35.987
RESIDENTS. AND THE 78.6% OF THE
00:27:36.054 --> 00:27:37.789
COUNTY WHO ARE PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:27:37.856 --> 00:27:40.892
REFUSED TO RECOGNIZE THIRD VR. A
00:27:40.959 --> 00:27:42.794
DISTRICT IN THE CENTRAL DISTRICT
00:27:42.861 --> 00:27:44.529
CONTAINS REDLINING DISTRICT AND
00:27:44.596 --> 00:27:45.563
OTHER AREAS OF HISTORICAL
00:27:45.630 --> 00:27:48.666
DISCRIMINATION. IN LAST
00:27:48.733 --> 00:27:50.168
TUESDAY'S PRIMARY ELECTION
00:27:50.235 --> 00:27:52.604
CENTRAL DISTRICT FAILED TO
00:27:52.670 --> 00:27:53.605
PROTECT THOSE CONSTITUTIONALLY
00:27:53.671 --> 00:27:55.807
PROTECTED CLASSES IN THAT AREA.
00:27:55.874 --> 00:27:57.709
CURRENT COUNTY HAS NEVER DRAWN A
00:27:57.776 --> 00:27:59.044
VOTING RIGHTS ACT DISTRICT
00:27:59.110 --> 00:28:00.678
WITHOUT BEING LEGALLY COMPELLED
00:28:00.745 --> 00:28:02.013
TO DO SO. THEY HAD TO BE SUED TO
00:28:02.080 --> 00:28:03.848
CREATE THE FIRST THEY HAD TO BE
00:28:03.915 --> 00:28:05.683
SUED TO CREATE THE SECOND AND
00:28:05.750 --> 00:28:07.185
NOW IT'S VERY CLEAR THAT THERE
00:28:07.252 --> 00:28:09.320
MAY EVEN BE A THIRD LOSS BECAUSE
00:28:09.387 --> 00:28:10.922
THEY FAILED TO DRAW THAT THIRD
00:28:10.989 --> 00:28:12.824
BR RATE WITH WELL OVER 50% OF
00:28:12.891 --> 00:28:14.759
LATINOS IN CURRENT COUNTY. IT IS
00:28:14.826 --> 00:28:18.630
ALSO THE CASE THAT WHEN THAT
00:28:18.696 --> 00:28:22.067
SECOND ER, A DISTRICT WAS DRAWN.
00:28:22.133 --> 00:28:24.502
DAY MANIPULATED THE PROCESS TO
00:28:24.569 --> 00:28:26.538
ENSURE THAT WHITE AFFLUENT
00:28:26.604 --> 00:28:28.239
VOTERS IN THE RICHEST PART OF
00:28:28.306 --> 00:28:31.076
THE CITY OF BAKERSFIELD WITH 98%
00:28:31.142 --> 00:28:32.577
VOTER TURNOUT, THEY LITERALLY
00:28:32.644 --> 00:28:34.279
HAVE OUT VOTED EVERY RURAL FARM
00:28:34.345 --> 00:28:35.613
WORKER COMMUNITY IN THE COUNTY
00:28:35.680 --> 00:28:36.681
EVERY TIME THEY'VE HAD AN
00:28:36.748 --> 00:28:39.284
ELECTION. BY COMPARISON, THE
00:28:39.350 --> 00:28:42.187
STATE HAS SHOWN THAT BE THEY CAN
00:28:42.253 --> 00:28:43.188
DRAW USING INDEPENDENT
00:28:43.254 --> 00:28:45.190
REDISTRICTING COMMISSION, STATE
00:28:45.256 --> 00:28:46.291
AND CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT THAT
00:28:46.357 --> 00:28:48.193
PERFORMED BEAUTIFULLY LAST
00:28:48.259 --> 00:28:49.794
TUESDAY, TOTALLY IN ALIGNMENT
00:28:49.861 --> 00:28:50.995
WITH THE DEMOGRAPHIC STARE AND
00:28:51.062 --> 00:28:52.864
THE HISTORY THAT WE'RE TRYING TO
00:28:52.931 --> 00:28:56.501
RESOLVE. I ASK THIS COMMITTEE TO
00:28:56.568 --> 00:28:58.536
HELP US FINALLY GET THE FAIR
00:28:58.603 --> 00:29:00.205
MAPS WE DESERVE IN CURRENT
00:29:00.271 --> 00:29:01.573
COUNTY BECAUSE THEY SEEM HELL
00:29:01.639 --> 00:29:03.741
BENT ON MAKING SURE THAT YOUR
00:29:03.808 --> 00:29:05.777
POLICIES AND BUDGET ALLOCATIONS
00:29:05.844 --> 00:29:08.179
DON'T EVER MAKE IT TO THE PEOPLE
00:29:08.246 --> 00:29:09.280
THAT YOU'RE INTENDING THEM TO
00:29:09.347 --> 00:29:11.282
SERVE. I RESPECTFULLY ASK THIS
00:29:11.349 --> 00:29:14.319
COMMITTEE FOR A VOTE ON A B 24
00:29:14.385 --> 00:29:15.753
94. WE KNOW INDEPENDENTLY
00:29:15.820 --> 00:29:17.422
DISTRICTING COMMISSIONS WORK.
00:29:17.489 --> 00:29:19.157
AND WE REALLY WANT ONE HERE IN
00:29:19.224 --> 00:29:20.758
KERN COUNTY. THANK YOU. AND
00:29:20.825 --> 00:29:23.428
THANK YOU MISS PERCENT TO IS
00:29:23.495 --> 00:29:24.662
THERE. ANYBODY HERE IN THE
00:29:24.729 --> 00:29:26.464
HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
00:29:26.531 --> 00:29:30.602
TESTIFY ON BEHALF. OF 24 94.
00:29:30.668 --> 00:29:36.174
OKAY? AND I'M SEEING NONE. LET
00:29:36.241 --> 00:29:38.476
US MOVE TO POSITION FOLLOWING
00:29:38.543 --> 00:29:39.844
THE SAME PROCESS, UNDERSTANDING
00:29:39.911 --> 00:29:41.079
THAT THERE IS NO LEAD WITNESS.
00:29:41.146 --> 00:29:42.247
ARE YOU THE LEAD WITNESS HERE?
00:29:42.313 --> 00:29:47.585
YEAH, HE SAYS. OKAY SO PLEASE,
00:29:47.652 --> 00:29:49.921
WE DO HAVE OPPOSITION HERE IN
00:29:49.988 --> 00:29:52.223
THE HEARING ROOM. MR YODER,
00:29:52.290 --> 00:29:52.891
PLEASE PROCEED. CHAIRMAN OF
00:29:52.957 --> 00:29:54.192
MEMBERS. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING
00:29:54.259 --> 00:29:56.394
. EVERY MONDAY, UM, ON BEHALF OF
00:29:56.461 --> 00:29:57.929
THE CURRENT COUNTY BOARD OF
00:29:57.996 --> 00:29:59.030
SUPERVISORS, THEY ARE OPPOSED TO
00:29:59.097 --> 00:30:03.134
24 94. AND. I APPRECIATE THE
00:30:03.201 --> 00:30:04.802
COMMITTEE, INCLUDING SOME OF THE
00:30:04.869 --> 00:30:06.938
LANGUAGE FROM THE BOARDS LETTER.
00:30:07.005 --> 00:30:09.274
WHICH NOTES THAT WE'RE TURNING A
00:30:09.340 --> 00:30:10.942
NONPARTISAN REDISTRICTING
00:30:11.009 --> 00:30:11.976
PRACTICE INTO A PARTISAN,
00:30:12.043 --> 00:30:15.547
CLEARLY PARTISAN IN EVERY SINGLE
00:30:15.613 --> 00:30:17.315
ONE OF THESE REDISTRICTING BILLS
00:30:17.382 --> 00:30:18.917
. THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT IS
00:30:18.983 --> 00:30:20.118
HAPPENING. AND THEN THE SECOND
00:30:20.185 --> 00:30:22.020
POINT I WANT TO MAKE TODAY IS
00:30:22.086 --> 00:30:23.254
THAT THE REDISTRICTING
00:30:23.321 --> 00:30:24.189
COMMISSIONS ARE HELD OUT AS
00:30:24.255 --> 00:30:28.426
BEING PERFECT. AND THEY'RE NOT.
00:30:28.493 --> 00:30:30.995
THE L. A COMMISSION THE SORT OF
00:30:31.062 --> 00:30:34.098
THE BASIS OF THESE OTHER BILLS.
00:30:34.165 --> 00:30:35.366
THERE WAS GREAT ACRIMONY. IN
00:30:35.433 --> 00:30:37.435
THIS LATEST PROCESS. THERE WERE
00:30:37.502 --> 00:30:39.470
CULTURAL ASSETS ALL OVER L. A
00:30:39.537 --> 00:30:41.906
THERE WERE TAKEN OUT OF WHAT WAS
00:30:41.973 --> 00:30:43.308
HISTORICALLY THEIR DISTRICTS.
00:30:43.374 --> 00:30:44.909
THE PROCESS, THERE HAS BECOME
00:30:44.976 --> 00:30:46.277
MORE PARTISAN. THE CURRENT BOARD
00:30:46.344 --> 00:30:48.079
ONCE THE PROCESS TO BE LESS
00:30:48.146 --> 00:30:52.183
PARTISAN. THIRD POINT I WANT TO
00:30:52.250 --> 00:30:54.485
MAKE IS THAT ESPECIALLY SINCE WE
00:30:54.552 --> 00:30:56.321
HAVE A SUBSTITUTE AUTHOR TODAY,
00:30:56.387 --> 00:30:58.156
UM I BELIEVE SHE HAD ACTUALLY
00:30:58.223 --> 00:31:02.060
THE, UM THE FORESIGHT THE
00:31:02.126 --> 00:31:04.062
COURTESY OF GETTING A MILLION
00:31:04.128 --> 00:31:05.697
DOLLARS IN THE STATE BUDGET FOR
00:31:05.763 --> 00:31:07.232
RIVERSIDE. I DON'T WANNA IF
00:31:07.298 --> 00:31:08.833
CREDIT IS DUE THERE. I WANT TO
00:31:08.900 --> 00:31:11.703
MAKE SURE I GIVE IT. I BELIEVE
00:31:11.769 --> 00:31:12.370
THERE'S A MILLION DOLLARS IN THE
00:31:12.437 --> 00:31:14.038
STATE BUDGET FOR THE CITY, THE
00:31:14.105 --> 00:31:15.006
RIVERSIDE COUNTY INDEPENDENT
00:31:15.073 --> 00:31:18.977
REDISTRICTING COMMISSION. AND AS
00:31:19.043 --> 00:31:20.812
FAR AS I KNOW, THERE ISN'T ANY
00:31:20.878 --> 00:31:21.779
MONEY PROPOSED IN THE STATE
00:31:21.846 --> 00:31:23.214
BUDGET SIMILARLY FOR THE CURRENT
00:31:23.281 --> 00:31:24.949
COUNTY, AND SO I WOULD SAY TO
00:31:25.016 --> 00:31:27.018
THE AUTHOR, I KNOW WE HAVE THE
00:31:27.085 --> 00:31:28.052
SUBSTITUTE AUTHOR HERE, BUT I
00:31:28.119 --> 00:31:29.854
WOULD SAY TO THE AUTHOR UM, YOU
00:31:29.921 --> 00:31:33.324
KNOW, UM, MAYBE RESPECTFULLY GET
00:31:33.391 --> 00:31:35.460
ON THAT, AS AS THE SUBSTITUTE
00:31:35.526 --> 00:31:37.161
AUTHOR HAS FOR HER DISTRICT AND
00:31:37.228 --> 00:31:39.163
THEN LAST, BUT NOT LEAST I HAD
00:31:39.230 --> 00:31:41.065
THE I GUESS. GOOD FORTUNE. OF
00:31:41.132 --> 00:31:43.268
WATCHING A LOT OF THIS STATE
00:31:43.334 --> 00:31:44.002
REDISTRICTING COMMISSION
00:31:44.068 --> 00:31:46.237
PROCEEDINGS AND I WANT TO GO
00:31:46.304 --> 00:31:47.705
BACK TO JUST THIS. THIS HOLDING
00:31:47.772 --> 00:31:49.474
OUT OF THESE COMMISSIONS AS
00:31:49.540 --> 00:31:52.777
BEING PERFECT. THREE OR FOUR
00:31:52.844 --> 00:31:54.879
COMMISSIONERS AT THE END OF THE
00:31:54.946 --> 00:31:55.780
STATE PROCESS BASICALLY BROKE
00:31:55.847 --> 00:31:57.815
DOWN IN TEARS BECAUSE OF THE
00:31:57.882 --> 00:31:58.883
IMPERFECTIONS THAT THEY KNEW
00:31:58.950 --> 00:32:01.019
THEY HAD CREATED. THE ARMENIAN
00:32:01.085 --> 00:32:04.989
COMMUNITY IN L. A. EVEN WENT SO
00:32:05.056 --> 00:32:07.592
FAR AS TO CALL INTO THE BUSINESS
00:32:07.659 --> 00:32:08.559
MEETINGS OF THE CITIZENS
00:32:08.626 --> 00:32:09.627
REDISTRICTING COMMISSION TO
00:32:09.694 --> 00:32:12.797
CONTINUE TO AIR THEIR VIEWS. AND
00:32:12.864 --> 00:32:14.332
THE EXTENT TO WHICH THEY
00:32:14.399 --> 00:32:15.300
BELIEVED THEY WERE BEING
00:32:15.366 --> 00:32:16.301
DISENFRANCHISED IN THE STATES
00:32:16.367 --> 00:32:21.939
REDISH INNING COMMISSION PROCESS. THIS IS THE COMMISSION'S
00:32:22.006 --> 00:32:22.974
AREN'T PERFECT. THEY SHOULDN'T
00:32:23.041 --> 00:32:25.476
BE HELD OUT AS SUCH THE CURRENT
00:32:25.543 --> 00:32:27.045
BOARD AS OPPOSED. THANK YOU.
00:32:27.111 --> 00:32:28.880
THANK YOU, MR YODER. IS ANYBODY
00:32:28.946 --> 00:32:30.048
ELSE HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:32:30.114 --> 00:32:31.983
LIKE TO TESTIFY? UH BRIEFLY IN
00:32:32.050 --> 00:32:36.554
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. 24 94
00:32:36.621 --> 00:32:38.956
SAYING NONE. LET'S GO BACK TO
00:32:39.023 --> 00:32:39.557
THE TELECONFERENCE. MR
00:32:39.624 --> 00:32:41.059
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:32:41.125 --> 00:32:42.627
PAUL, THE TELECONFERENCE. IS
00:32:42.694 --> 00:32:43.861
THERE ANYBODY ON THE LINE WHO'D
00:32:43.928 --> 00:32:46.297
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION?
00:32:46.364 --> 00:32:49.534
TO A B 24 94. SPEAKING
00:32:49.600 --> 00:32:50.635
OPPOSITION PRESS ONE THAT IS
00:32:50.702 --> 00:32:53.504
ZERO AT THIS TIME. WELL, FIRST
00:32:53.571 --> 00:32:58.976
GO TO LIVE 19. TOURIST LEAGUE OF
00:32:59.043 --> 00:33:00.812
WOMEN VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA
00:33:00.878 --> 00:33:02.547
CERTAINLY NOT IN OPPOSITION IN
00:33:02.613 --> 00:33:05.917
STRONG SUPPORT, BUT I WAS CUTE.
00:33:05.983 --> 00:33:08.920
LET ME IN, UH, FULLY ENDORSED
00:33:08.986 --> 00:33:10.955
DELORES HUERTA. ARGUMENTS THANK
00:33:11.022 --> 00:33:12.990
YOU. DULY NOTED. HAS ANYBODY ON
00:33:13.057 --> 00:33:14.692
THE LINE MISS MODERATOR IN
00:33:14.759 --> 00:33:18.463
OPPOSITION? OF A B 24 94. I
00:33:18.529 --> 00:33:21.265
CERTAINLY DON'T ASK IF THERE IS
00:33:21.332 --> 00:33:23.167
IN FAVOR OPPOSITION WHEN WE GIVE
00:33:23.234 --> 00:33:25.603
THEM THEIR LINE NUMBER TO THE
00:33:25.670 --> 00:33:27.839
PHONE LINES FOR, UH FOR SUPPORT
00:33:27.905 --> 00:33:29.340
, AND I THINK THAT THAT'S WHAT
00:33:29.407 --> 00:33:30.575
THERE IS MY MISTAKE. I
00:33:30.641 --> 00:33:34.846
APOLOGIZE. UM APPRECIATE THAT.
00:33:34.912 --> 00:33:36.948
SO LET'S ACTUALLY IF YOU DON'T
00:33:37.014 --> 00:33:38.015
MIND PULLING, LET'S I'M SORRY
00:33:38.082 --> 00:33:40.952
ABOUT THAT. DISCONNECT HERE. SO
00:33:41.018 --> 00:33:43.254
PAUL AT FIRST IS ANYBODY ON THE
00:33:43.321 --> 00:33:46.290
LINE? IN ADDITION T<c.cyan> THE LEGAL</c>
00:33:46.357 --> 00:33:48.259
AND VOTERS IN SUPPORT. LET'S GET
00:33:48.326 --> 00:33:50.962
THAT ON THE RECORD. ALSO WE HAVE
00:33:51.028 --> 00:33:52.029
TWO LINES QUEUED UP RIGHT NOW.
00:33:52.096 --> 00:33:54.031
WE DON'T KNOW THE STATUS OF
00:33:54.098 --> 00:33:54.899
WHETHER THERE IS A REPORTER AND
00:33:54.966 --> 00:33:57.201
SEE WHAT THE FUTURE HOLDS. THEN
00:33:57.268 --> 00:33:58.636
GO AHEAD. THANK YOU, SIR. LINE
00:33:58.703 --> 00:34:03.941
82. GOOD MORNING RESPONSIBLE
00:34:04.008 --> 00:34:05.243
WITH THE HULU CALIFORNIA ACTION
00:34:05.309 --> 00:34:06.310
IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
00:34:06.377 --> 00:34:14.919
THANK YOU. LINE 84. AND THIS IS
00:34:14.986 --> 00:34:16.387
SANTIAGO RODRIGUEZ, CALIFORNIA
00:34:16.454 --> 00:34:17.355
ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS IN SUPPORT
00:34:17.422 --> 00:34:21.392
OF THIS STUFF. OKAY AND AGAIN.
00:34:21.459 --> 00:34:23.661
MY APOLOGIES FOR MAKING THIS
00:34:23.728 --> 00:34:26.097
LESS THAN SEAMLESS. IS ANYBODY
00:34:26.164 --> 00:34:28.699
ELSE ON THE LINE WANTS TO SPEAK
00:34:28.766 --> 00:34:29.901
, UH, WITH WITH RESPECT TO A B
00:34:29.967 --> 00:34:40.778
24 94. YES. PLEASE. FOR SYRIAN.
00:34:40.845 --> 00:34:44.949
CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES. WE CAN
00:34:45.016 --> 00:34:47.518
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR MY NAME IS
00:34:47.585 --> 00:34:48.753
ILEANA ANIKA. I AM A RESIDENT OF
00:34:48.820 --> 00:34:51.556
THE COUNTY. CALLING AND STRONG
00:34:51.622 --> 00:34:53.658
SUPPORT OF A B 24 94 ON BEHALF
00:34:53.724 --> 00:34:55.827
OF THE BUILDING FOUNDATION.
00:34:55.893 --> 00:34:57.628
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MS
00:34:57.695 --> 00:34:59.931
MODERATE ANYBODY ELSE SPEAKING
00:34:59.997 --> 00:35:01.232
ON THE TIME WE HAVE NO FURTHER
00:35:01.299 --> 00:35:04.469
LINES IN QUÊ. ALRIGHT APPRECIATE
00:35:04.535 --> 00:35:06.070
THAT AGAIN. APOLOGIES BRING IT
00:35:06.137 --> 00:35:07.972
BACK TO COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES
00:35:08.039 --> 00:35:10.074
HAVE THE MOTION FROM SENATOR
00:35:10.141 --> 00:35:12.176
LEYVA UH, AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:35:12.243 --> 00:35:13.678
CERVANTES. THANK YOU FOR
00:35:13.744 --> 00:35:14.879
PRESENTING THIS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:35:14.946 --> 00:35:16.714
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IF YOU'D LIKE TO
00:35:16.781 --> 00:35:18.249
CLOSE YES, THANK YOU. I
00:35:18.316 --> 00:35:19.984
CERTAINLY JUST WANT TO ADD THAT
00:35:20.051 --> 00:35:21.285
NO BILL IS PERFECT. NOT THIS
00:35:21.352 --> 00:35:23.321
ONE. NOR MY OWN. HOWEVER WHAT I
00:35:23.387 --> 00:35:25.156
DO KNOW IS THAT PLACING THE
00:35:25.223 --> 00:35:27.225
POWER TO DRAW MAPS IN THE HANDS
00:35:27.291 --> 00:35:29.694
OF THE ACTUAL COUNTY SUPERVISORS
00:35:29.760 --> 00:35:30.628
WHO WOULD RUN FOR ELECTION IN
00:35:30.695 --> 00:35:31.929
THOSE MAPS HAVE A VESTED
00:35:31.996 --> 00:35:32.930
INTEREST IN DRAWING MAPS IN
00:35:32.997 --> 00:35:34.932
THEIR FAVOR. THAT DOES NOT WORK
00:35:34.999 --> 00:35:36.467
. IT HAS NOT WORKED IN MY OWN
00:35:36.534 --> 00:35:38.169
COUNTY IN RIVERSIDE AND BASED ON
00:35:38.236 --> 00:35:39.537
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS
00:35:39.604 --> 00:35:40.705
EXPERIENCE, IT DOES NOT WORK IN
00:35:40.771 --> 00:35:44.141
CURRENT COUNTY. CURRAN COUNTY IS
00:35:44.208 --> 00:35:45.576
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL BECAUSE
00:35:45.643 --> 00:35:47.311
THEY DO NOT WANT TO SEE THEIR
00:35:47.378 --> 00:35:49.046
POWER BEING TRANSFERRED TO THE
00:35:49.113 --> 00:35:50.147
PEOPLE. I SUPPOSE THAT IS
00:35:50.214 --> 00:35:51.349
UNDERSTANDABLE, BUT THIS
00:35:51.415 --> 00:35:53.217
ATTITUDE IS NOT IN THE BEST
00:35:53.284 --> 00:35:55.353
INTEREST OF GOVERNMENT. FOR THE
00:35:55.419 --> 00:35:57.221
VOTERS OF CURRENT COUNTY AND I
00:35:57.288 --> 00:35:58.556
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I VOTE.
00:35:58.623 --> 00:35:59.957
THANK YOU, MADAM SECRETARY. IF
00:36:00.024 --> 00:36:03.261
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MAYBE
00:36:03.327 --> 00:36:06.297
24 94 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS.
00:36:06.364 --> 00:36:08.499
MOTION IS DUE PASSPORTS FIRST BE
00:36:08.566 --> 00:36:09.667
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:36:09.734 --> 00:36:11.068
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. NEWMAN
00:36:11.135 --> 00:36:14.739
NEWMAN. AYE. NILSSON NILSSON, NO
00:36:14.805 --> 00:36:22.547
LASER HERTZBERG. LABOR? AYE.
00:36:22.613 --> 00:36:25.082
THAT VOTE CURRENTLY STANDS AS 2
00:36:25.149 --> 00:36:28.920
TO 1 WILL LEAVE THAT ON CALL. AH
00:36:28.986 --> 00:36:30.054
LOOKING FORWARD. WE ARE LOOKING
00:36:30.121 --> 00:36:36.861
FOR ARTHUR'S. I'M SORRY. WE HAVE
00:36:36.928 --> 00:36:37.395
AN AUTHOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:36:37.461 --> 00:36:40.765
LEVIN. YOU WERE BEHIND SOMEBODY
00:36:40.831 --> 00:36:41.365
. WELCOME TO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:36:41.432 --> 00:36:45.303
LEVINE. YOU WILL BE PRESENTING A
00:36:45.369 --> 00:36:47.939
B 17 83. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
00:36:48.005 --> 00:36:49.240
YOU SO MUCH. MEMBERS BROKE HER
00:36:49.307 --> 00:36:52.810
TOE OF MR CHAIR AND CHAIR AND
00:36:52.877 --> 00:36:53.744
SENATORS, MERGERS AND
00:36:53.811 --> 00:36:54.946
ACQUISITIONS OF INSURANCE
00:36:55.012 --> 00:36:56.147
COMPANIES ARE UNIQUELY IMPORTANT
00:36:56.213 --> 00:36:59.016
TO CONSUMERS. AND CHANGES IN
00:36:59.083 --> 00:37:00.451
CONTROL OF INSURANCE COMPANIES
00:37:00.518 --> 00:37:02.086
CAN HAVE DRAMATIC IMPLICATIONS.
00:37:02.153 --> 00:37:04.288
IMPLICATIONS FOR CALIFORNIANS A
00:37:04.355 --> 00:37:05.823
B 17 83 INSURERS, GOVERNMENT
00:37:05.890 --> 00:37:06.657
TRANSPARENCY BY APPLYING
00:37:06.724 --> 00:37:10.061
EXISTING LOBBYING, REGISTRATION
00:37:10.127 --> 00:37:11.629
AND REPORTING REQUIREMENTS TO
00:37:11.696 --> 00:37:14.565
INDIVIDUALS OR LOBBYING FIRMS
00:37:14.632 --> 00:37:16.067
SEEKING TO INFLUENCE ENSURE
00:37:16.133 --> 00:37:19.437
MERGER DECISIONS. THIS BILL
00:37:19.503 --> 00:37:21.005
REMEDIES AN ONGOING PROBLEM
00:37:21.072 --> 00:37:21.973
RECENTLY REPORTED IN THE
00:37:22.039 --> 00:37:23.207
SACRAMENTO BEE, WHERE
00:37:23.274 --> 00:37:25.443
CONSULTANTS WERE TO BE PAID $2
00:37:25.509 --> 00:37:28.512
MILLION CONTINGENCY FEE TO
00:37:28.579 --> 00:37:29.947
INFLUENCE THE APPROVAL OF AN
00:37:30.014 --> 00:37:31.482
INSURANCE COMPANY ACQUISITION
00:37:31.549 --> 00:37:32.450
WHILE EVADING PUBLIC DISCLOSURE
00:37:32.516 --> 00:37:35.553
LAWS FOR LOBBYING ACTIVITY.
00:37:35.620 --> 00:37:36.854
WHILE THE POLITICAL REFORM ACT
00:37:36.921 --> 00:37:37.722
HAS TIGHT REGULATIONS,
00:37:37.788 --> 00:37:39.256
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS AND
00:37:39.323 --> 00:37:41.192
LOBBYING RESTRICTIONS, MANY OF
00:37:41.258 --> 00:37:43.160
THESE RESTRICTIONS ONLY APPLY TO
00:37:43.227 --> 00:37:45.129
LOBBYING ON LEGISLATIVE ACTIVITY
00:37:45.196 --> 00:37:46.497
AND DID NOT CAPTURE BROAD SWATHS
00:37:46.564 --> 00:37:49.333
OF ACTIVITY. THAT LOBBYISTS AND
00:37:49.400 --> 00:37:50.668
CONSULTANTS MAY ENGAGE IN TO
00:37:50.735 --> 00:37:52.737
INFLUENCE POLICY IN WAYS THAT
00:37:52.803 --> 00:37:54.071
WILL AFFECT THEIR CLIENTS AND
00:37:54.138 --> 00:37:55.072
CALIFORNIANS IN SIGNIFICANT
00:37:55.139 --> 00:37:59.176
WAYS. A B 17 83 WILL CLOSE A
00:37:59.243 --> 00:38:00.811
DISTURBING LOOPHOLE IN OUR
00:38:00.878 --> 00:38:02.913
POLITICAL PRACTICES LAWS THAT
00:38:02.980 --> 00:38:04.315
ALLOW A PERSON TO CIRCUMVENT
00:38:04.382 --> 00:38:05.583
LOBBYING RULES AND PROHIBITIONS
00:38:05.650 --> 00:38:08.653
WITH ME HERE TODAY TO TESTIFY.
00:38:08.719 --> 00:38:10.521
IS JERRY FLANAGAN, CHIEF TRIAL
00:38:10.588 --> 00:38:13.824
COUNSEL FOR CONSUMER WATCHDOG.
00:38:13.891 --> 00:38:15.626
UM HENRY, SEAMUS FLANAGAN IS ON
00:38:15.693 --> 00:38:18.329
THE LINE OR HE'S ON THE LINE.
00:38:18.396 --> 00:38:18.863
MR. FLANAGAN, IF YOU COULD
00:38:18.929 --> 00:38:19.897
PLEASE PROCEED. SPIRITUALLY WITH
00:38:19.964 --> 00:38:22.566
ME TODAY. IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:38:22.633 --> 00:38:27.805
PROCEED. VIRTUALLY. AND SO WE
00:38:27.872 --> 00:38:29.573
DON'T SEE HIM ON THE LINE AT THE
00:38:29.640 --> 00:38:30.941
MOMENT, MR MODERATOR, IF YOU IF
00:38:31.008 --> 00:38:33.544
YOU COULD CHECK, SEE IF THERE'S
00:38:33.611 --> 00:38:34.779
A JERRY FLANAGAN ON THE LINE AS
00:38:34.845 --> 00:38:37.014
THE LEAD SPORT WITNESS. ONE
00:38:37.081 --> 00:38:46.624
MOMENT, PLEASE. WE DON'T APPEAR
00:38:46.691 --> 00:38:50.027
TO HAVE MR FLANAGAN WITH US.
00:38:50.094 --> 00:38:53.698
OKAY? SURE, AS WE CAN. ADD SOME
00:38:53.764 --> 00:38:56.300
COLOR TO YOUR CLOSES. IS ANYBODY
00:38:56.367 --> 00:38:57.601
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM WOULD
00:38:57.668 --> 00:38:58.736
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. OF A
00:38:58.803 --> 00:39:05.142
B 17 83. ASSUME DONE. LET'S GO
00:39:05.209 --> 00:39:06.577
BACK TO THE PHONE LINES. MR.
00:39:06.644 --> 00:39:07.945
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:39:08.012 --> 00:39:09.313
QUÊ TELECONFERENCE PARTICIPANTS
00:39:09.380 --> 00:39:10.848
. ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE TO
00:39:10.915 --> 00:39:12.850
WRITE IN SUPPORT OF A PH SEVEN
00:39:12.917 --> 00:39:17.188
A. B 17 83. TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
00:39:17.254 --> 00:39:18.322
. PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:39:18.389 --> 00:39:22.760
TIME. WE DO HAVE A LINE QUEUING
00:39:22.827 --> 00:39:23.928
UP ONE MOMENT WHILE WE PROVIDE
00:39:23.994 --> 00:39:31.702
THE LINE NUMBER. WE WILL FIRST
00:39:31.769 --> 00:39:39.043
GO TO LINE 53. AH! HELLO MR
00:39:39.110 --> 00:39:40.578
CHAIRMAN. MEMBERS AT TRENT LANG
00:39:40.644 --> 00:39:41.545
, CALIFORNIA CLEAN MONEY
00:39:41.612 --> 00:39:43.547
CAMPAIGN NOT PREPARED TO TESTIFY
00:39:43.614 --> 00:39:45.549
AND SUPPORT TESTIFIED. BUT WE
00:39:45.616 --> 00:39:47.051
ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT. YOU THINK
00:39:47.118 --> 00:39:48.853
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT BILL AND
00:39:48.919 --> 00:39:49.720
URGED THE COMMITTEE TO PASS IT.
00:39:49.787 --> 00:39:51.555
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR LANG.
00:39:51.622 --> 00:39:57.061
NEXT, PLEASE. WE'LL GO TO LINE
00:39:57.128 --> 00:40:02.533
77. HI LINDSAY MCCONNELL WITH
00:40:02.600 --> 00:40:03.167
THE POLITICAL PRACTICES
00:40:03.234 --> 00:40:04.335
COMMISSION IN SUPPORT OF 80 17
00:40:04.401 --> 00:40:08.806
83. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYBODY
00:40:08.873 --> 00:40:10.074
ELSE ON THAT? I WOULD LIKE TO
00:40:10.141 --> 00:40:11.909
FIND SUPPORT OF A B. 17 83
00:40:11.976 --> 00:40:13.911
CHAIRMAN. PARDON ME, MR.
00:40:13.978 --> 00:40:15.513
CHAIRMAN WE HAVE NO OTHER LINES
00:40:15.579 --> 00:40:17.882
IN. Q THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
00:40:17.948 --> 00:40:19.316
LET'S LET'S RETURN TO THE
00:40:19.383 --> 00:40:20.618
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. IS THERE
00:40:20.684 --> 00:40:22.219
ANYBODY HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:40:22.286 --> 00:40:23.754
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:40:23.821 --> 00:40:24.889
OPPOSITION TO A B 17 83. ARE YOU
00:40:24.955 --> 00:40:28.959
GETTING ME IN QUÊ? SEEING NOT
00:40:29.026 --> 00:40:30.694
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE HEARING
00:40:30.761 --> 00:40:32.329
ROOM. IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE
00:40:32.396 --> 00:40:33.798
LINE? WHO'D LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:40:33.864 --> 00:40:39.069
OPPOSITION? A. B 17 83. AND
00:40:39.136 --> 00:40:41.172
SPEAKING OF OPPOSITION ONE, THEN
00:40:41.238 --> 00:40:43.440
ZERO AT THIS TIME, I'M SUPPOSED
00:40:43.507 --> 00:40:44.542
TO BE THE LEADER LEAD WITNESS
00:40:44.608 --> 00:40:45.876
HERE. I'M WAITING TO GO ON THE
00:40:45.943 --> 00:40:49.313
HOLDING. UH OKAY. LEAD WITNESS
00:40:49.380 --> 00:40:51.115
AND SUPPORT. UNDERSTOOD THAT, MR
00:40:51.182 --> 00:40:53.083
FLANAGAN, WE DID NOT SEE YOU ON
00:40:53.150 --> 00:40:55.419
THE LINE. WHY DON'T YOU GO AHEAD
00:40:55.486 --> 00:40:56.520
AND PURSUIT? YOU HAVE TWO
00:40:56.587 --> 00:41:03.294
MINUTES. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
00:41:03.360 --> 00:41:05.429
YOU. SORRY ABOUT THAT. MR
00:41:05.496 --> 00:41:06.931
CHAIRMAN, MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE
00:41:06.997 --> 00:41:09.066
WAS LOST IN HOLD LAND. APOLOGIES
00:41:09.133 --> 00:41:10.868
WOULD LIKE TO BE THERE, BUT I
00:41:10.935 --> 00:41:12.203
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:41:12.269 --> 00:41:13.838
TESTIFY ON THE PHONE POLITICAL
00:41:13.904 --> 00:41:15.339
REFORM ACT AS THE KITTY MEDIA IS
00:41:15.406 --> 00:41:16.974
AWARE WAS ADOPTED IN THE WAKE OF
00:41:17.041 --> 00:41:18.976
WATERGATE TO RESTORE PUBLIC
00:41:19.043 --> 00:41:19.910
CONFIDENCE BY REQUIRING THE
00:41:19.977 --> 00:41:20.945
PUBLIC'S BUSINESS TO BE
00:41:21.011 --> 00:41:22.947
CONDUCTED OPENLY FOR ALL TO SEE.
00:41:23.013 --> 00:41:24.448
AND THE RECENT SEGMENT OF THE
00:41:24.515 --> 00:41:25.950
ARTICLE THAT WE SUBMITTED TO
00:41:26.016 --> 00:41:26.884
COMMITTEE PERFECTLY CAPTURES THE
00:41:26.951 --> 00:41:28.319
ISSUE OF THE SO CALLED
00:41:28.385 --> 00:41:29.820
CONSULTANTS INFLUENCING
00:41:29.887 --> 00:41:30.754
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS OF
00:41:30.821 --> 00:41:32.489
AGENCIES WHILE AVOIDING PUBLIC
00:41:32.556 --> 00:41:33.490
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS OF THE
00:41:33.557 --> 00:41:36.427
POLITICAL REFORM ACT. THERE ARE
00:41:36.493 --> 00:41:37.962
TWO FORMER LAWMAKERS WERE HIRED
00:41:38.028 --> 00:41:38.929
BY A WORKERS COMPENSATION
00:41:38.996 --> 00:41:40.097
INSURER TO INFLUENCE THE
00:41:40.164 --> 00:41:41.298
INSURANCE COMMISSIONER'S
00:41:41.365 --> 00:41:43.033
DECISION REGARDING A MERGER AND
00:41:43.100 --> 00:41:44.835
ACQUISITION AT STAKE WERE
00:41:44.902 --> 00:41:46.604
POTENTIALLY HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS
00:41:46.670 --> 00:41:47.705
OF DOLLARS IN OVERCHARGES TO
00:41:47.771 --> 00:41:49.006
SMALL BUSINESSES. AND THE
00:41:49.073 --> 00:41:50.641
CONSULTANTS WERE TO BE PAID $2
00:41:50.708 --> 00:41:53.077
MILLION CONTINGENCY FEE CONTRACT
00:41:53.143 --> 00:41:54.545
. THIS WAS ALL ACCOMPANIED BY
00:41:54.612 --> 00:41:56.146
CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS TO
00:41:56.213 --> 00:41:56.847
CONCEAL THEIR TRUE SOURCE.
00:41:56.914 --> 00:41:57.848
OBVIOUSLY, THESE EFFORTS HAVE
00:41:57.915 --> 00:42:01.185
ALL THE HALLMARKS. OF LOBBYING.
00:42:01.252 --> 00:42:04.021
A B 17 83 WOULD NOT CREATE ANY
00:42:04.088 --> 00:42:05.256
NEW SUBSTANTIVE PROHIBITIONS. IT
00:42:05.322 --> 00:42:07.224
WOULD SIMPLY APPLY EXISTING
00:42:07.291 --> 00:42:08.926
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS TO THESE
00:42:08.993 --> 00:42:10.060
TYPE OF MINISTER ADMINISTRATIVE
00:42:10.127 --> 00:42:13.297
DECISIONS. A B 17 83 IS A
00:42:13.364 --> 00:42:14.865
MEASURED APPROACH. STATE LAW
00:42:14.932 --> 00:42:16.834
ALREADY DEFINED THE LOBBYISTS AS
00:42:16.901 --> 00:42:19.203
ANYONE BEING PAID INFLUENCE
00:42:19.270 --> 00:42:20.404
DECISIONS REGARDING AN
00:42:20.471 --> 00:42:22.172
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION. HOWEVER
00:42:22.239 --> 00:42:23.807
ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS HAVE BEEN
00:42:23.874 --> 00:42:25.576
NARROWLY INTERPRETED TO EXCLUDE
00:42:25.643 --> 00:42:26.944
EFFORTS TO INFLUENCE AGENCY
00:42:27.011 --> 00:42:27.912
DECISIONS ON MERGERS AND
00:42:27.978 --> 00:42:30.281
ACQUISITIONS. AND THIS BILL
00:42:30.347 --> 00:42:31.348
WOULD SIMPLY UPDATE THAT THE
00:42:31.415 --> 00:42:35.853
DEFINITION. A B 17 83 IS ALSO
00:42:35.920 --> 00:42:37.187
CONSISTENT WITH THIS COMMITTEE'S
00:42:37.254 --> 00:42:38.355
PRIOR INCREMENTAL AND TARGETED
00:42:38.422 --> 00:42:39.957
CHANGES TO THE POLITICAL REFORM
00:42:40.024 --> 00:42:43.661
ACT. FOR EXAMPLE, A 2010
00:42:43.727 --> 00:42:45.663
LEGISLATIVE LEGISLATIVE BILL, UH
00:42:45.729 --> 00:42:46.697
, THAT WERE ADOPTED BY THE
00:42:46.764 --> 00:42:48.866
GOVERNOR. UM UH, CHANGE THE
00:42:48.933 --> 00:42:50.167
DEFINITION OF ADMINISTRATIVE
00:42:50.234 --> 00:42:53.304
ACTION IN WAKE OF A SEPARATE
00:42:53.370 --> 00:42:54.939
POLITICAL CONTROVERSY AT THE
00:42:55.005 --> 00:42:56.941
HELPERS TO ADDRESS INVESTMENTS
00:42:57.007 --> 00:43:00.678
IN PUBLIC RETIREMENT ASSETS.
00:43:00.744 --> 00:43:01.779
FINALLY I JUST WANT TO NOTE THAT
00:43:01.845 --> 00:43:03.781
THE ANALYSIS FOCUSED ON A KIND
00:43:03.847 --> 00:43:04.782
OF A TECHNICAL DIFFERENCE
00:43:04.848 --> 00:43:06.317
BETWEEN QUALITATIVE LEGISLATIVE
00:43:06.383 --> 00:43:06.817
AND QUALITATIVE JUDICIAL
00:43:06.884 --> 00:43:10.154
PROCEEDINGS. THE IMPORTANT ISSUE
00:43:10.220 --> 00:43:11.789
HERE IS THAT THE TYPE OF
00:43:11.855 --> 00:43:13.324
LOBBYING ADDRESSING HERE ARE
00:43:13.390 --> 00:43:14.792
VERY MUCH IN LINE WITH WHAT THE
00:43:14.858 --> 00:43:16.961
POLITICAL REFORM ACT WAS MEANT
00:43:17.027 --> 00:43:18.495
TO COVER. AND MORE IMPORTANTLY,
00:43:18.562 --> 00:43:19.797
THE FAIR POLITICAL PRACTICES
00:43:19.863 --> 00:43:20.898
COMMISSION, WHICH WILL NOW
00:43:20.965 --> 00:43:21.966
ADMINISTER THE BILL IS IN
00:43:22.032 --> 00:43:24.668
SUPPORT. THERE IS NO OPPOSITION
00:43:24.735 --> 00:43:26.236
ON RECORD. WE URGED THE
00:43:26.303 --> 00:43:27.738
COMMITTEE TO ALLOW VOTERS TO
00:43:27.805 --> 00:43:29.673
DECIDE WHETHER TO APPLY THE
00:43:29.740 --> 00:43:30.774
POLITICAL REFORM ACT ETHICS AND
00:43:30.841 --> 00:43:32.443
REPORTING REQUIREMENT. TO THESE
00:43:32.509 --> 00:43:33.377
TYPES OF INSURANCE COMPANY
00:43:33.444 --> 00:43:34.712
MERGERS, AND I WANT TO THANK THE
00:43:34.778 --> 00:43:36.146
COMEDIAN AGAIN. APOLOGIZE FOR
00:43:36.213 --> 00:43:37.982
THE STAFF. YOU WITH THE PHONE
00:43:38.048 --> 00:43:38.983
ALSO WANT TO THANK
00:43:39.049 --> 00:43:41.518
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WITHIN. THANK
00:43:41.585 --> 00:43:43.020
YOU, MR MR FLAGON APOLOGIZED TO
00:43:43.087 --> 00:43:44.488
YOUR FRIEND ANY INCONVENIENCE.
00:43:44.555 --> 00:43:45.756
SO, HAVING NOW HEARD YOUR
00:43:45.823 --> 00:43:47.424
TESTIMONY? IS THERE ANYBODY HERE
00:43:47.491 --> 00:43:49.960
IN THE HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE
00:43:50.027 --> 00:43:51.095
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
00:43:51.161 --> 00:43:54.465
BILL. STILL KNOWN, MR MODERATOR
00:43:54.531 --> 00:43:56.233
, IF WE COULD RETURN TO THE
00:43:56.300 --> 00:43:57.267
TELECONFERENCE LINE, IS THERE
00:43:57.334 --> 00:43:59.236
ANYBODY ON THE LINE WHO'D LIKE
00:43:59.303 --> 00:44:00.337
TO STRIKE IN OPPOSITION TO A B
00:44:00.404 --> 00:44:04.375
17 83? TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION,
00:44:04.441 --> 00:44:05.442
PLEASE, PERHAPS ONE, THEN ZERO
00:44:05.509 --> 00:44:11.949
AT THIS TIME. HAVE KNOWN MR
00:44:12.016 --> 00:44:16.954
CHAIR. OKAY LET'S BRING IT BACK
00:44:17.021 --> 00:44:18.155
TO THE COMMITTEE GOT EMOTION
00:44:18.222 --> 00:44:19.289
FROM SOONER, LEYVA. MADAM
00:44:19.356 --> 00:44:23.827
SECRETARY, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:44:23.894 --> 00:44:26.063
I'M SORRY. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:44:26.130 --> 00:44:27.564
CLOSE? WELL THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:44:27.631 --> 00:44:31.201
MR CHAIR AS THE WITNESS TESTIFY
00:44:31.268 --> 00:44:32.803
, THERE IS NO OPPOSITION. I'D
00:44:32.870 --> 00:44:33.804
LIKE TO SAY THANK YOU TO THE
00:44:33.871 --> 00:44:35.806
COMMITTEE OF THE STAFF WHO WROTE
00:44:35.873 --> 00:44:36.640
THE ANALYSIS. EVERYONE WHO
00:44:36.707 --> 00:44:38.575
TESTIFIED IN SUPPORT, ALSO THE
00:44:38.642 --> 00:44:39.076
BRILLIANT INVESTIGATIVE
00:44:39.143 --> 00:44:41.545
REPORTING BY THE B. THAT HELPED
00:44:41.612 --> 00:44:43.347
SHINE LIGHT ON THESE PRACTICES
00:44:43.414 --> 00:44:46.383
THAT WE'RE LOOKING TO PUT SOME
00:44:46.450 --> 00:44:48.252
RULES AROUND. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:44:48.318 --> 00:44:50.020
FOR MY VOTE. THAT WAS VERY
00:44:50.087 --> 00:44:51.722
STRONG CLOSE. SO GLAD I GIVE YOU
00:44:51.789 --> 00:44:52.790
THAT OPPORTUNITY. SO, MADAM
00:44:52.856 --> 00:44:53.924
SECRETARY, IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:44:53.991 --> 00:44:57.361
NOW CALL THE RULE. A B 17 83 BY
00:44:57.428 --> 00:44:59.163
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LIVING MOTION
00:44:59.229 --> 00:45:01.365
IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST WE
00:45:01.432 --> 00:45:02.533
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:45:02.599 --> 00:45:06.036
APPROPRIATIONS. NEWMAN NEWMAN, I
00:45:06.103 --> 00:45:07.771
NILSSON NILSSON. I LASER
00:45:07.838 --> 00:45:14.678
HERTZBERG. LABOR LABOR. AYE. SO
00:45:14.745 --> 00:45:17.748
THAT BILL NOW HAS THREE VOTES TO
00:45:17.815 --> 00:45:20.017
ZERO. WE WILL KEEP IT ON HOLD,
00:45:20.084 --> 00:45:21.218
BUT IT WILL PASS. THANK YOU.
00:45:21.285 --> 00:45:25.055
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EVENT.
00:45:25.122 --> 00:45:26.557
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORIDA THANK
00:45:26.623 --> 00:45:30.060
YOU FOR BEING HERE. WELCOME
00:45:30.127 --> 00:45:31.328
YOU'RE GOING TO PRESENTING BE
00:45:31.395 --> 00:45:35.232
PRESENTING A B 2037. WHEN YOU
00:45:35.299 --> 00:45:37.167
ARE READY, PLEASE PROCEED. RIGHT
00:45:37.234 --> 00:45:38.602
WELL, GOOD MORNING, SENATORS.
00:45:38.669 --> 00:45:39.670
HAPPY MONDAY. I'M HERE TO
00:45:39.736 --> 00:45:42.539
PRESENT A B 2037. WITH PROFILE
00:45:42.606 --> 00:45:44.441
WILL PROVIDE ADDITIONAL VOTING
00:45:44.508 --> 00:45:45.476
LOCATIONS TO CALIFORNIA VOTERS
00:45:45.542 --> 00:45:46.477
BY GIVING COUNTY ELECTION
00:45:46.543 --> 00:45:48.579
OFFICIALS THE OPTION OF USING
00:45:48.645 --> 00:45:50.581
VENUES LIKE VÀ HALLS AS POLLING
00:45:50.647 --> 00:45:52.516
LOCATIONS. UNDER EXISTING LAW
00:45:52.583 --> 00:45:54.518
VENUES THAT HAVE BARS OR SERVE
00:45:54.585 --> 00:45:56.787
ALCOHOL CANNOT SERVE AS POLLING
00:45:56.854 --> 00:45:58.288
LOCATIONS. THERE WERE EXEMPTIONS
00:45:58.355 --> 00:45:59.957
MADE IN THE 2020 GENERAL
00:46:00.023 --> 00:46:01.725
ELECTION, AS WELL AS A 2021
00:46:01.792 --> 00:46:02.826
RECALL ELECTION TO ALLOW THESE
00:46:02.893 --> 00:46:04.928
TYPES OF VENUES BE UTILIZED.
00:46:04.995 --> 00:46:07.698
THROUGH A B 2037 COUNTY ELECTION
00:46:07.764 --> 00:46:09.466
OFFICIALS WILL HAVE MORE POLLING
00:46:09.533 --> 00:46:11.568
LOCATION OPTIONS, WHICH WILL
00:46:11.635 --> 00:46:13.504
HELP VOTERS PERFORM THEIR CIVIC
00:46:13.570 --> 00:46:14.138
DUTY WITHOUT OBSTACLES FOR MANY
00:46:14.204 --> 00:46:15.439
YEARS TO COME. WITH ME ON THE
00:46:15.506 --> 00:46:17.774
PHONE. WE HAVE RYAN RONCO WITH
00:46:17.841 --> 00:46:19.009
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:46:19.076 --> 00:46:20.177
CLERKS IN ELECTION OFFICIALS. MR
00:46:20.244 --> 00:46:23.814
RANKO, WELCOME. PLEASE PROCEED.
00:46:23.881 --> 00:46:25.949
THANK YOU AND GOOD MORNING,
00:46:26.016 --> 00:46:27.017
CHAIRMAN NEWMAN AND MEMBERS OF
00:46:27.084 --> 00:46:28.118
COMMITTEE. CAN YOU HEAR ME?
00:46:28.185 --> 00:46:29.953
OKAY. WE CAN GREAT. THANK YOU.
00:46:30.020 --> 00:46:30.954
I'M RYAN RONCO, PLASTIC COUNTY
00:46:31.021 --> 00:46:32.356
CLERK RECORDER, REGISTRAR OF
00:46:32.422 --> 00:46:33.824
VOTERS AND CO CHAIR OF THE
00:46:33.891 --> 00:46:34.525
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATIONS OF
00:46:34.591 --> 00:46:35.392
CLERKS AND ELECTIONS OFFICIALS.
00:46:35.459 --> 00:46:36.994
LEGISLATIVE COMMITTEE. PLEASED
00:46:37.060 --> 00:46:38.962
TO SPONSOR AND SUPPORT A B 2037
00:46:39.029 --> 00:46:39.663
. I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
00:46:39.730 --> 00:46:40.731
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORA AND HIS
00:46:40.797 --> 00:46:41.832
STAFF FOR THEIR IMPORTANT WORK
00:46:41.899 --> 00:46:43.634
ON THIS BILL. DURING THE
00:46:43.700 --> 00:46:44.501
NOVEMBER 2020 PRESIDENTIAL
00:46:44.568 --> 00:46:47.471
ELECTION AND FOR ALL OF LAST
00:46:47.538 --> 00:46:48.071
YEAR, INCLUDING THE SEPTEMBER
00:46:48.138 --> 00:46:48.972
GUBERNATORIAL RECALL ELECTION
00:46:49.039 --> 00:46:50.207
COUNTIES WERE ALLOWED BY YOUR
00:46:50.274 --> 00:46:51.408
LEGISLATURE. THE TEMPORARY
00:46:51.475 --> 00:46:52.109
ABILITY TO USE COMMUNITY
00:46:52.176 --> 00:46:53.377
CENTERS, VETERANS HALLS, BANQUET
00:46:53.443 --> 00:46:56.079
ROOMS AND LODGES. LOCATIONS
00:46:56.146 --> 00:46:56.547
WHERE WE HAVE AVOIDED
00:46:56.613 --> 00:46:57.948
APPROACHING IN THE PAST BECAUSE
00:46:58.015 --> 00:46:59.316
THERE WERE ALSO PLACES WHERE
00:46:59.383 --> 00:47:00.717
ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES ARE SOLD.
00:47:00.784 --> 00:47:02.252
MAYBE 2037 WOULD MAKE THIS
00:47:02.319 --> 00:47:03.587
TEMPORARY CHANGE PERMANENT,
00:47:03.654 --> 00:47:04.621
ALLOWING COUNTIES TO CONTINUE
00:47:04.688 --> 00:47:05.622
USING THESE LOCATIONS GOING
00:47:05.689 --> 00:47:08.592
FORWARD. FOR THE COUNTIES THAT
00:47:08.659 --> 00:47:09.860
WERE ABLE TO UTILIZE THE
00:47:09.927 --> 00:47:10.794
TEMPORARY LIFTING OF THESE
00:47:10.861 --> 00:47:11.895
RESTRICTIONS. THEY FOUND THAT
00:47:11.962 --> 00:47:13.931
THEY WERE BETTER ABLE TO HELP
00:47:13.997 --> 00:47:14.565
THEIR HISTORICALLY UNDERSERVED
00:47:14.631 --> 00:47:15.465
COMMUNITIES WHERE POLLING PLACE
00:47:15.532 --> 00:47:15.999
FACILITY OPTIONS ARE OFTEN
00:47:16.066 --> 00:47:17.401
LIMITED. IT'S SURPRISING TO
00:47:17.467 --> 00:47:19.102
THINK IN THE YEAR 2020 THAT IS
00:47:19.169 --> 00:47:21.238
ACTUALLY 2022 THAT IT'S ACTUALLY
00:47:21.305 --> 00:47:22.806
BECOMING HARDER AND EASIER FOR
00:47:22.873 --> 00:47:24.508
ELECTIONS OFFICIALS POINT
00:47:24.575 --> 00:47:25.576
SUITABLE FLOWING AT PLACES OR
00:47:25.642 --> 00:47:27.477
VOTE CENTERS. FOR THEIR VOTERS.
00:47:27.544 --> 00:47:29.112
HOWEVER, SADLY, IT IS. SCHOOLS
00:47:29.179 --> 00:47:30.514
ARE LESS INCLINED SERVICE
00:47:30.581 --> 00:47:31.048
POLLING PLACES BECAUSE OF
00:47:31.114 --> 00:47:32.482
SECURITY CONCERNS THAT STRANGERS
00:47:32.549 --> 00:47:34.218
ON CAMPUS CHURCHES ARE REFUSING
00:47:34.284 --> 00:47:35.886
TO OPEN UP HIS VOTE CENTERS IN
00:47:35.953 --> 00:47:37.054
RECORD NUMBERS BECAUSE THEY
00:47:37.120 --> 00:47:38.622
DON'T WANT TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH
00:47:38.689 --> 00:47:39.389
POLARIZING POLITICAL CLIMATE OF
00:47:39.456 --> 00:47:40.991
THE DAY. SENIOR CENTERS ARE
00:47:41.058 --> 00:47:41.825
SAYING NO BECAUSE WITHOUT
00:47:41.892 --> 00:47:43.227
BETTERS, BRINGING IN GERMS
00:47:43.293 --> 00:47:44.561
ENDANGERING THE HEALTH OF THEIR
00:47:44.628 --> 00:47:46.363
COMMUNITIES. PROPER VOTING
00:47:46.430 --> 00:47:47.598
CENTER LOCATIONS IS PARTICULARLY
00:47:47.664 --> 00:47:49.299
DIFFICULT FOR VOTERS. CHOICE ACT
00:47:49.366 --> 00:47:50.300
COUNTIES MUST HAVE FACILITIES
00:47:50.367 --> 00:47:52.169
OPEN FOR FOUR OR 11 DAYS IN A
00:47:52.236 --> 00:47:54.204
ROW. HAVING THESE HOLES IN LARGE
00:47:54.271 --> 00:47:56.240
IS AVAILABLE CENTERS SITES HAS
00:47:56.306 --> 00:47:57.641
BEEN THE PERFECT ALTERNATIVE TO
00:47:57.708 --> 00:47:59.643
THOSE FACILITIES WHO ARE NOW
00:47:59.710 --> 00:48:01.445
TELLING US NO, YOU'RE NOT WERE
00:48:01.511 --> 00:48:02.412
NOT AVAILABLE TO SERVE YOU.
00:48:02.479 --> 00:48:03.146
COUNTIES TO GO THROUGH AN
00:48:03.213 --> 00:48:04.147
EXTENSIVE CHECKLIST OF PARKING
00:48:04.214 --> 00:48:06.016
ACCESSIBILITY, PROXIMITY TO
00:48:06.083 --> 00:48:07.517
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION, 88
00:48:07.584 --> 00:48:09.419
COMPLIANCE AND MORE IN ORDER TO
00:48:09.486 --> 00:48:11.255
PICK THE RIGHT FACILITY FOR
00:48:11.321 --> 00:48:12.422
COMMUNITY AS A POINT PLACE OR
00:48:12.489 --> 00:48:13.957
VOTE CENTER. MAYBE 2037 WILL
00:48:14.024 --> 00:48:15.659
ALLOW US TO CONTINUE TO USE SOME
00:48:15.726 --> 00:48:16.893
OF THESE FACILITIES THAT OUR
00:48:16.960 --> 00:48:17.928
COMMUNITIES HAVE ENJOYED USING
00:48:17.995 --> 00:48:19.563
FOR TWO YEARS NOW, ESPECIALLY IN
00:48:19.630 --> 00:48:20.797
A TIME WHEN FINDING WILLING
00:48:20.864 --> 00:48:21.298
FACILITIES ARE BECOMING
00:48:21.365 --> 00:48:22.866
INCREASINGLY MORE DIFFICULT.
00:48:22.933 --> 00:48:24.201
THANK YOU. WE RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:48:24.268 --> 00:48:25.602
FOR YOUR VOTE,AND I'M AVAILABLE
00:48:25.669 --> 00:48:27.304
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU
00:48:27.371 --> 00:48:29.306
MIGHT HAVE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
00:48:29.373 --> 00:48:33.310
MR RONCO. IS ANYBODY HERE IN THE
00:48:33.377 --> 00:48:34.845
HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO
00:48:34.911 --> 00:48:38.915
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A B 2037?
00:48:38.982 --> 00:48:40.984
SEEN DONE. LET'S RETURN TO THE
00:48:41.051 --> 00:48:43.186
TELECOMS AND MR MODERATOR, IF
00:48:43.253 --> 00:48:45.322
YOU COULD FALL FOR ANYBODY ON
00:48:45.389 --> 00:48:46.590
THE LINE WHO WOULD LIKE TO TEST
00:48:46.657 --> 00:48:49.960
RIGHT IN SUPPORT OF EVERY 2037?
00:48:50.027 --> 00:48:51.128
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT, PRESSED
00:48:51.194 --> 00:48:58.802
ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. MR
00:48:58.869 --> 00:49:00.137
CHAIRMAN, WE HAVE NO IN CUBA.
00:49:00.203 --> 00:49:02.472
PARDON ME. WOULD YOU HAVE THE
00:49:02.539 --> 00:49:03.707
LION QUEUING UP ONE MOMENT WHILE
00:49:03.774 --> 00:49:20.757
WE PROVIDE THEIR LINE NUMBER?
00:49:26.630 --> 00:49:27.798
WE WILL OFTEN LINE 96 GO AHEAD,
00:49:27.864 --> 00:49:32.969
PLEASE. YES, IT IS. JERRY. DON
00:49:33.036 --> 00:49:37.240
PROBLEM IS. WE DIDN'T CATCH IT.
00:49:37.307 --> 00:49:40.811
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GARY JOHNSON,
00:49:40.877 --> 00:49:45.182
PARLIAMENT SUPPORTER. OKAY I
00:49:45.248 --> 00:49:47.617
APPRECIATE YOUR TESTIMONY. THANK
00:49:47.684 --> 00:49:48.885
YOU, AS ANYBODY ELSE WOULD LIKE
00:49:48.952 --> 00:49:52.689
TO TEST RIGHT SUPPORT. OF 2037
00:49:52.756 --> 00:49:55.192
OTHER LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME,
00:49:55.258 --> 00:49:56.026
MS MARGARITA LET'S COME BACK TO
00:49:56.093 --> 00:49:58.061
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. IS
00:49:58.128 --> 00:49:59.296
ANYBODY HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:49:59.363 --> 00:50:01.064
WOULD LIKE TO FIND OPPOSITION TO
00:50:01.131 --> 00:50:02.666
BE 2037. SEEING NONE. MR.
00:50:02.733 --> 00:50:03.734
MODERATOR BACK TO THE
00:50:03.800 --> 00:50:05.102
TELECONFERENCE LINES. ANYBODY ON
00:50:05.168 --> 00:50:06.703
THE LINE AND LIKE JUST WRITING
00:50:06.770 --> 00:50:10.340
OPPOSITION TO HB 2037. TO SPEAK
00:50:10.407 --> 00:50:12.209
IN OPPOSITION PRESS ONE AND ZERO
00:50:12.275 --> 00:50:20.384
AT THIS TIME. GUIDELINES IN QUÊ,
00:50:20.450 --> 00:50:21.952
MR. CHAIR. THANK YOU, MR
00:50:22.018 --> 00:50:24.054
MODERATOR BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES
00:50:24.121 --> 00:50:25.422
, COLLEAGUES EMOTION FROM
00:50:25.489 --> 00:50:26.523
SENATOR LABOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:50:26.590 --> 00:50:29.960
FLORA. I COMMEND YOU ON THE BILL
00:50:30.026 --> 00:50:32.229
SEEMS LIKE A REASONABLE AND VERY
00:50:32.295 --> 00:50:33.730
COMMON SENSE APPROACH TO
00:50:33.797 --> 00:50:35.165
CREATING OPPORTUNITIES FOR
00:50:35.232 --> 00:50:37.200
VOTING CENTERS. UM WITH THAT
00:50:37.267 --> 00:50:38.668
GLADYS SUPPORTED AMOUNT OF
00:50:38.735 --> 00:50:39.803
SECRETARY IF YOU COULD PLEASE
00:50:39.870 --> 00:50:42.873
CALL THE WRONG WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:50:42.939 --> 00:50:44.341
CLOSE DISRESPECTFULLY ASTRAY? I
00:50:44.408 --> 00:50:46.777
VOTE THAT'S THAT'S A SOLID CLOSE
00:50:46.843 --> 00:50:48.678
. NOW THAT ON SECRETARY IF YOU
00:50:48.745 --> 00:50:53.550
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. A B 2037
00:50:53.617 --> 00:50:55.619
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORA MOTION IS
00:50:55.685 --> 00:50:58.321
DUE PAST BUT FRISBEE WE REFERRED
00:50:58.388 --> 00:50:59.556
TO THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL
00:50:59.623 --> 00:51:03.427
ORGANIZATION. NEWMAN I NIELSEN.
00:51:03.493 --> 00:51:07.664
NIELSEN. I GLASER. HERTZBERG.
00:51:07.731 --> 00:51:13.069
LABOR LABOR. AYE. UM THERE WAS
00:51:13.136 --> 00:51:14.971
30 AND SUPPORT IS THAT CORRECT?
00:51:15.038 --> 00:51:17.307
SO THAT WILL MOVE. WE'LL LEAVE
00:51:17.374 --> 00:51:18.975
THAT ON CALL FOR SENATOR
00:51:19.042 --> 00:51:20.277
HERZBERG WHEN HE ARRIVES, BUT
00:51:20.343 --> 00:51:24.281
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND THE
00:51:24.347 --> 00:51:27.551
LAST OF THE ASSEMBLY BILLS TODAY
00:51:27.617 --> 00:51:28.585
AND THEN WE HAVE A
00:51:28.652 --> 00:51:30.053
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. WE'VE
00:51:30.120 --> 00:51:31.321
GOT 89 72 FROM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:51:31.388 --> 00:51:33.223
BERMAN. WELCOME, SIR. UM, GOOD
00:51:33.290 --> 00:51:39.496
TO SEE YOU. THANK YOU. CHAIR AND
00:51:39.563 --> 00:51:40.897
COLLEAGUES GREAT TO SEE ALL OF
00:51:40.964 --> 00:51:41.898
YOU AS WELL. THIS IS AN
00:51:41.965 --> 00:51:43.800
INTERESTING ANGLE IS MY FIRST
00:51:43.867 --> 00:51:44.935
TIME IN THIS IN THIS HEARING
00:51:45.001 --> 00:51:46.837
ROOM. DEEPFAKES ARE EXTREMELY
00:51:46.903 --> 00:51:48.338
CONVINCING, FABRICATED PHOTOS,
00:51:48.405 --> 00:51:50.073
VIDEOS AND AUDIO RECORDINGS OF
00:51:50.140 --> 00:51:51.975
SOMEONE APPEARING TO SAY OR DO
00:51:52.042 --> 00:51:54.277
SOMETHING THAT THEY DID NOT. THE
00:51:54.344 --> 00:51:55.846
ABILITY TO ATTRIBUTE SPEECH AND
00:51:55.912 --> 00:51:57.380
CONDUCT TO A POLITICAL CANDIDATE
00:51:57.447 --> 00:51:58.915
. THAT IS FALSE. THAT NEVER
00:51:58.982 --> 00:52:00.984
HAPPENED MAKES DEEPFAKES A
00:52:01.051 --> 00:52:02.519
POWERFUL AND DANGEROUS TOOL IN
00:52:02.586 --> 00:52:04.120
THE ARSENAL OF THOSE THAT WANT
00:52:04.187 --> 00:52:05.388
TO WAGE MIS AND DISINFORMATION
00:52:05.455 --> 00:52:08.091
CAMPAIGNS. WHICH IS WHY IN 2019
00:52:08.158 --> 00:52:09.559
, THE LEGISLATURE PASSED MY A B
00:52:09.626 --> 00:52:12.395
7 30 NEARLY CRAFTED BILL TO
00:52:12.462 --> 00:52:13.497
PROHIBIT THE DISTRIBUTION OF
00:52:13.563 --> 00:52:14.097
DEEP FACE ANOTHER MANIPULATED
00:52:14.164 --> 00:52:16.099
MEDIA WITHIN 60 DAYS OF AN
00:52:16.166 --> 00:52:18.301
ELECTION. UNLESS THE IMAGE OF
00:52:18.368 --> 00:52:19.769
RECORDING INCLUDES A DISCLOSURE
00:52:19.836 --> 00:52:22.939
STATING THAT IT IS MANIPULATED.
00:52:23.006 --> 00:52:24.808
NOTABLY THE BILL INCLUDED A
00:52:24.875 --> 00:52:26.810
JANUARY 1ST 2023 SUNSET
00:52:26.877 --> 00:52:29.212
PROVISION. THIS BILL, MAYBE 9 72
00:52:29.279 --> 00:52:30.514
WOULD EXTEND THE SUNSET TO
00:52:30.580 --> 00:52:32.048
JANUARY. 1ST 2027, KEEPING THE
00:52:32.115 --> 00:52:33.116
LAW INTACT FOR AN ADDITIONAL
00:52:33.183 --> 00:52:35.819
FOUR YEARS. DOING SO WILL
00:52:35.886 --> 00:52:37.354
PROTECT THE INTEGRITY OF OUR
00:52:37.420 --> 00:52:39.222
ELECTIONS IN THE COMING YEARS AS
00:52:39.289 --> 00:52:40.323
DEEPFAKE TECHNOLOGY ADVANCES AND
00:52:40.390 --> 00:52:42.492
BECOMES EVEN MORE MAINSTREAM.
00:52:42.559 --> 00:52:43.560
MAYBE 7 30 RECEIVED WIDESPREAD
00:52:43.627 --> 00:52:46.463
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN 2019.
00:52:46.530 --> 00:52:48.131
VOTERS HAVE A RIGHT TO KNOW
00:52:48.198 --> 00:52:49.065
WHETHER OR NOT THE MEDIA THEY
00:52:49.132 --> 00:52:51.401
ARE BEING SHOWN IS REAL OR FAKE.
00:52:51.468 --> 00:52:52.669
SO I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
00:52:52.736 --> 00:52:56.439
VOTE. THANK YOU, MR BERMAN. UM
00:52:56.506 --> 00:52:58.575
DO WE HAVE WE DO NOT HAVE A
00:52:58.642 --> 00:52:59.776
PRIMARY WITNESSES, MY AESTHETIC.
00:52:59.843 --> 00:53:01.745
NOT THAT I'M AWARE OF THAT YOU
00:53:01.811 --> 00:53:02.979
ARE AWARE OF, SO PROBABLY NOT.
00:53:03.046 --> 00:53:04.948
IS ANYBODY HERE IN THE IN THE
00:53:05.015 --> 00:53:06.116
HEARING ROOM WOULD LIKE TO TEST
00:53:06.182 --> 00:53:08.385
FIVE AND SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
00:53:08.451 --> 00:53:10.186
BILL NYE 72. WE DO HAVE SOMEBODY
00:53:10.253 --> 00:53:12.989
WELCOME. GOOD MORNING, JOHN ON
00:53:13.056 --> 00:53:14.457
BEHALF OF SILICON VALLEY
00:53:14.524 --> 00:53:16.026
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT
00:53:16.092 --> 00:53:17.761
OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. THANK
00:53:17.827 --> 00:53:19.262
YOU. ANYBODY ELSE IN THE HEARING
00:53:19.329 --> 00:53:20.330
ROOM LIKE TEST DRIVE AND
00:53:20.397 --> 00:53:22.532
SUPPORTED THE BILL. SEEING MR
00:53:22.599 --> 00:53:24.034
MODERATED. WE COULD GO TO THE
00:53:24.100 --> 00:53:25.101
TELECONFERENCE LINE IS ANYBODY
00:53:25.168 --> 00:53:27.037
ON THE LINE WOULD LIKE TO TRY
00:53:27.103 --> 00:53:29.406
AND SUPPORT OF 89 72. TO SPEAK
00:53:29.472 --> 00:53:38.415
IN SUPPORT 110 AT THIS TIME.
00:53:38.481 --> 00:53:39.950
THERE ARE NO LINES STUDIO, MR
00:53:40.016 --> 00:53:42.319
CHAIRMAN. OKAY LET'S BRING IT
00:53:42.385 --> 00:53:44.387
BACK TO THE HEARING WAS ANYBODY
00:53:44.454 --> 00:53:45.889
HERE AND THE HEARING WOULD LIKE
00:53:45.956 --> 00:53:47.891
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE 9
00:53:47.958 --> 00:53:52.062
72. SAYING THAT MS MODERATOR, IS
00:53:52.128 --> 00:53:53.296
THERE ANYBODY ON THE LINE? WHO'D
00:53:53.363 --> 00:53:54.464
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION?
00:53:54.531 --> 00:53:56.499
MAYBE 9 72. TO SPEAK IN
00:53:56.566 --> 00:53:58.435
OPPOSITION PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO
00:53:58.501 --> 00:54:05.308
AT THIS TIME. MR CHAIRMAN, THERE
00:54:05.375 --> 00:54:09.613
ARE NO LINES GET UP. ALL RIGHT,
00:54:09.679 --> 00:54:11.314
COMING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE TO
00:54:11.381 --> 00:54:13.216
MY COLLEAGUES AND THE INPUT ON
00:54:13.283 --> 00:54:14.284
THE BILL. EMOTIONS TO SENATOR
00:54:14.351 --> 00:54:16.319
LIVER, MR. BERMAN WOULD YOU LIKE
00:54:16.386 --> 00:54:17.287
TO CLOSE? RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:54:17.354 --> 00:54:19.823
BROUGH. VERY GOOD. SO, UM, THANK
00:54:19.889 --> 00:54:21.257
YOU FOR THAT. MADAM SECRETARY,
00:54:21.324 --> 00:54:28.932
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MAYBE 9 72
00:54:28.999 --> 00:54:30.600
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BERMAN MOTION
00:54:30.667 --> 00:54:31.735
IS DUE PASS, BUT FIRST BE WE
00:54:31.801 --> 00:54:33.970
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON G
00:54:34.037 --> 00:54:38.541
H. JUDICIARY. NEWMAN I NIELSEN.
00:54:38.608 --> 00:54:43.279
NIELSEN KNOWN LASER. HERTZBERG.
00:54:43.346 --> 00:54:48.018
LEVER LEVER. AYE. THAT VOTE
00:54:48.084 --> 00:54:50.186
STANDS IS 2 TO 1 OR KEEP THAT ON
00:54:50.253 --> 00:54:52.055
CALL. THANK YOU SHOULDN'T BE
00:54:52.122 --> 00:54:54.557
GOVERNMENT. AND LAST, BUT
00:54:54.624 --> 00:54:56.926
CERTAINLY NOT LEAST. WELCOME
00:54:56.993 --> 00:54:58.595
SENATOR KAMLAGER. WE HAVE THE
00:54:58.662 --> 00:55:00.430
CURIOUS SITUATION, THE CENTER
00:55:00.497 --> 00:55:01.498
PRESENTING AN ASSEMBLY
00:55:01.564 --> 00:55:02.599
CONSTITUTIONAL MOMENT, I'M SURE
00:55:02.666 --> 00:55:03.900
YOU'LL EXPLAIN. WELCOME. PLEASE
00:55:03.967 --> 00:55:07.671
PROCEED. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
00:55:07.737 --> 00:55:10.573
MEMBERS. YES THIS IS A REMNANT
00:55:10.640 --> 00:55:13.309
FROM MY TIME IN THE ASSEMBLY AND
00:55:13.376 --> 00:55:15.111
DELAYED BECAUSE OF COVID. BUT
00:55:15.178 --> 00:55:17.280
TODAY I AM HERE PRESENTING.
00:55:17.347 --> 00:55:18.915
ASSEMBLY CONSTITUTIONAL
00:55:18.982 --> 00:55:19.949
AMENDMENT THREE, THE CALIFORNIA
00:55:20.016 --> 00:55:23.420
ABOLITION ACT. THE CALIFORNIA
00:55:23.486 --> 00:55:26.823
CONSTITUTION PROHIBITS SLAVERY,
00:55:26.890 --> 00:55:28.491
BUT INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE IS
00:55:28.558 --> 00:55:29.959
ALSO PROHIBITED, WITH ONE
00:55:30.026 --> 00:55:33.329
EXCEPTION TO PUNISH CRIME. SO A
00:55:33.396 --> 00:55:35.532
C A THREE SEEKS TO AMEND THE
00:55:35.598 --> 00:55:37.033
CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION TO
00:55:37.100 --> 00:55:38.935
REMOVE SUCH CONDITIONAL LANGUAGE
00:55:39.002 --> 00:55:40.804
, ABOLISHING SLAVERY AND
00:55:40.870 --> 00:55:42.238
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE WITHOUT
00:55:42.305 --> 00:55:45.041
EXCEPTION AND WITHOUT LOOPHOLES.
00:55:45.108 --> 00:55:48.178
THIS AMENDMENT IS LONG OVERDUE.
00:55:48.244 --> 00:55:50.213
TODAY 12 STATES PROHIBIT
00:55:50.280 --> 00:55:52.182
ENSLAVEMENT AND INVOLUNTARY
00:55:52.248 --> 00:55:54.718
SERVITUDE. NINE STATES PERMIT
00:55:54.784 --> 00:55:56.720
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE AS A
00:55:56.786 --> 00:55:58.455
CRIMINAL PUNISHMENT, AND
00:55:58.521 --> 00:55:59.556
CALIFORNIA IS ONE OF THOSE
00:55:59.622 --> 00:56:01.624
STATES. SO DISSOLVING THE
00:56:01.691 --> 00:56:04.027
VESTIGES OF SLAVERY IS MORE
00:56:04.094 --> 00:56:06.963
IMPORTANT NOW THAN EVER BEFORE.
00:56:07.030 --> 00:56:09.566
IN 2021, US SENATOR JEFF MERKLEY
00:56:09.632 --> 00:56:11.101
OF OREGON INTRODUCED THE
00:56:11.167 --> 00:56:12.435
ABOLITION AMENDMENT ALONG WITH
00:56:12.502 --> 00:56:13.603
CONGRESSWOMAN NIKI MO WILLIAMS
00:56:13.670 --> 00:56:16.239
OF GEORGIA. TO REMOVE
00:56:16.306 --> 00:56:17.841
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE AS A
00:56:17.907 --> 00:56:20.076
PUNISHMENT FOR CRIME FRM THE U.
00:56:20.143 --> 00:56:22.378
S CONSTITUTION. VOTERS IN
00:56:22.445 --> 00:56:24.814
COLORADO, NEBRASKA AND UTAH
00:56:24.881 --> 00:56:26.549
VOTED TO REMOVE EXCEPTION
00:56:26.616 --> 00:56:27.550
CLAUSES FROM THEIR STATE
00:56:27.617 --> 00:56:31.287
CONSTITUTION. CALIFORNIA VOTERS
00:56:31.354 --> 00:56:32.622
SHOULD BE GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY
00:56:32.689 --> 00:56:35.525
TO DO THE SAME THIS NOVEMBER.
00:56:35.592 --> 00:56:37.927
OUR CONSTITUTION IS A DOCUMENT
00:56:37.994 --> 00:56:40.263
OF PRINCIPLES SERVING AS A GUIDE
00:56:40.330 --> 00:56:41.865
FOR ALL OTHER OPERATIONAL STATE
00:56:41.931 --> 00:56:44.134
LAWS. AS A MATTER OF PRINCIPLE,
00:56:44.200 --> 00:56:46.936
THERE IS NO PLACE FOR SLAVERY.
00:56:47.003 --> 00:56:49.606
FORCED LABOR OR INVOLUNTARY
00:56:49.672 --> 00:56:52.575
SERVITUDE ON OUR BOOKS WITH ME
00:56:52.642 --> 00:56:54.811
HERE IN SUPPORT IS JAMELIA LAND
00:56:54.878 --> 00:56:57.080
AND SAMUEL BROWN. OH, FOUNDERS
00:56:57.147 --> 00:56:58.314
OF THE ANTI VIOLENCE SAFETY AND
00:56:58.381 --> 00:57:00.350
ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT. A
00:57:00.416 --> 00:57:03.086
SPONSOR, ORGANIZATION OF A C A
00:57:03.153 --> 00:57:04.287
THREE AND AT THE APPROPRIATE
00:57:04.354 --> 00:57:05.989
TIME, I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:57:06.055 --> 00:57:08.725
FOR YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU VERY
00:57:08.792 --> 00:57:10.894
MUCH TO THE WITNESSES HERE OR IS
00:57:10.960 --> 00:57:12.195
HERE VERSUS TO WELCOME. WELCOME,
00:57:12.262 --> 00:57:18.468
SIR. PLEASE PURSUED. MORNING,
00:57:18.535 --> 00:57:22.438
SENATORS. MORNING MY NAME IS
00:57:22.505 --> 00:57:25.074
SAMUEL NATHANIEL BROWN. I AM THE
00:57:25.141 --> 00:57:27.210
CO FOUNDER OF THE ANTI VIOLENCE
00:57:27.277 --> 00:57:27.877
SAFETY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
00:57:27.944 --> 00:57:28.978
PROJECT, ALONG WITH MY WIFE,
00:57:29.045 --> 00:57:30.947
JAMELIA LAND. THE CULTURE OF THE
00:57:31.014 --> 00:57:31.447
CALIFORNIA ABOLITION ACT
00:57:31.514 --> 00:57:36.052
COALITION. I AM. UM. I HAVE AN
00:57:36.119 --> 00:57:38.221
ASSOCIATE TO ARTS AND SOCIAL
00:57:38.288 --> 00:57:39.088
SCIENCE AND ASSOCIATES OF ARTS
00:57:39.155 --> 00:57:41.191
TRANSFER DEGREE IN SOCIOLOGY
00:57:41.257 --> 00:57:43.593
ABOUT 14 DAYS AGO, I WALKED THE
00:57:43.660 --> 00:57:45.094
STAGE OF CALIFORNIA STATE
00:57:45.161 --> 00:57:47.197
UNIVERSITY, LOS ANGELES, AND I
00:57:47.263 --> 00:57:48.364
GRADUATED MAGNA CUM LAUDE WITH
00:57:48.431 --> 00:57:49.532
MY BACHELOR'S IN COMMUNICATIONS
00:57:49.599 --> 00:57:52.068
STUDIES. I'M ALSO THE ORIGINAL
00:57:52.135 --> 00:57:53.203
ART OF THE LANGUAGE THAT
00:57:53.269 --> 00:57:55.538
EVENTUALLY BECAME A C A THREE. I
00:57:55.605 --> 00:57:58.474
AM THE PART THAT MOST DON'T KNOW
00:57:58.541 --> 00:58:00.443
IS I'M ONLY 175 DAYS REMOVED
00:58:00.510 --> 00:58:02.545
FROM PRISON. AND I SERVED 24
00:58:02.612 --> 00:58:06.416
YEARS. AND SO WHEN I SPEAK TO
00:58:06.482 --> 00:58:08.251
YOU, I SPEAK FROM A VERY
00:58:08.318 --> 00:58:09.385
INTIMATE PLACE. AND I CAN TELL
00:58:09.452 --> 00:58:10.954
YOU FIRST AND FOREMOST, THAT
00:58:11.020 --> 00:58:14.490
SLAVERY HAS NO PLACE IN 2022.
00:58:14.557 --> 00:58:16.125
THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR US
00:58:16.192 --> 00:58:17.827
ALL TO EVOLVE IN OUR SHARED
00:58:17.894 --> 00:58:19.095
HUMANITY AND CLOSE A LOOPHOLE
00:58:19.162 --> 00:58:20.163
THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN CLOSED A
00:58:20.230 --> 00:58:22.232
LONG TIME AGO. THE FACT THAT THE
00:58:22.298 --> 00:58:24.067
MATTER IS, DESPITE ALL THE
00:58:24.133 --> 00:58:25.368
ACCOLADES THAT I JUST SHARED
00:58:25.435 --> 00:58:26.569
WITH YOU, I'VE ALSO TAKEN
00:58:26.636 --> 00:58:28.504
THOUSANDS OF HOURS OF SELF HELP
00:58:28.571 --> 00:58:29.606
PROGRAMMING COGNITIVE BEHAVIORAL
00:58:29.672 --> 00:58:30.373
THERAPY. ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS
00:58:30.440 --> 00:58:34.244
NARCOTICS ANONYMOUS. VICTIMS
00:58:34.310 --> 00:58:35.278
SENSITIVITY VICTIM AWARENESS 10
00:58:35.345 --> 00:58:38.348
P PROGRAM ALL OF THAT. WOULD
00:58:38.414 --> 00:58:39.816
HAVE BEEN IRRELEVANT. IT ALL
00:58:39.883 --> 00:58:42.552
WOULD HAVE BEEN MOOT IF I WOULD
00:58:42.619 --> 00:58:43.686
HAVE MISSED ONE DAY OF WORK.
00:58:43.753 --> 00:58:45.121
BECAUSE THEY ARE ABLE TO
00:58:45.188 --> 00:58:46.189
DETERMINE THAT I WAS AN
00:58:46.256 --> 00:58:48.658
UNREASONABLE RISK OF SOCIETY.
00:58:48.725 --> 00:58:49.959
BECAUSE I RECEIVED THE 1 15 FOR
00:58:50.026 --> 00:58:51.694
NOT REPORTING TO WORK ONE DAY,
00:58:51.761 --> 00:58:54.831
NO MATTER WHAT IT WAS, AND THEN
00:58:54.898 --> 00:58:56.132
I WOULD HAVE RECEIVED A 15 YEAR
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:57.934
DENIAL FROM THE BOARD OF PAROLE
00:58:58.001 --> 00:58:58.868
HEARINGS. AND IF THERE WAS
00:58:58.935 --> 00:58:59.669
MITIGATING EVIDENCE, IT WOULD
00:58:59.736 --> 00:59:02.205
HAVE BEEN WALKED DOWN TO A 10
00:59:02.272 --> 00:59:03.840
YEARS NOW THAN A SEVEN YEAR TO
00:59:03.907 --> 00:59:04.941
NOW THAN FIVE YEARS AND NOW THAN
00:59:05.008 --> 00:59:06.643
THREE YEARS NOW, AND SO THE
00:59:06.709 --> 00:59:08.578
POINT THAT I'M MAKING IS AS LONG
00:59:08.645 --> 00:59:10.546
AS FORCED LABOR TAKES PRECEDENCE
00:59:10.613 --> 00:59:11.481
OVER REHABILITATION IN PUBLIC
00:59:11.547 --> 00:59:14.317
SAFETY. THEN WE WILL BE STUCK AT
00:59:14.384 --> 00:59:15.084
A STANDSTILL AND WE WOULD NEVER
00:59:15.151 --> 00:59:16.953
BE ABLE TO PROVIDE THE
00:59:17.020 --> 00:59:18.021
OPPORTUNITIES AND THE HEALTH OF
00:59:18.087 --> 00:59:19.555
PEOPLE WHO FIND THEMSELVES IN
00:59:19.622 --> 00:59:20.156
CORRECTIONAL SETTINGS THAT WE
00:59:20.223 --> 00:59:21.024
STRIKE WE TRULY STRIVE TO
00:59:21.090 --> 00:59:24.127
PROVIDE AS A SOCIETY. SO I'M
00:59:24.193 --> 00:59:27.430
HERE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A
00:59:27.497 --> 00:59:28.765
THREE. AND I ASK THAT YOU PLEASE
00:59:28.831 --> 00:59:31.467
GIVE US A YES VOTE. THANK YOU.
00:59:31.534 --> 00:59:33.536
AND THANK YOU, MR BROWN.
00:59:33.603 --> 00:59:34.037
CONGRATULATIONS ON YOUR
00:59:34.103 --> 00:59:36.105
GRADUATION. IS THERE ANYBODY
00:59:36.172 --> 00:59:38.007
ELSE HERE IN THE HEARING LIKE TO
00:59:38.074 --> 00:59:40.410
TESTIFY? AND SUPPORT OF THE
00:59:40.476 --> 00:59:41.611
SECOND WITNESS. I'M SORRY, VERY
00:59:41.678 --> 00:59:46.115
GOOD. GOOD MORNING. I'M A TAD
00:59:46.182 --> 00:59:48.184
BIT VERTICALLY CHALLENGED. SO
00:59:48.251 --> 00:59:49.218
MICROPHONE IS PICKING YOU UP
00:59:49.285 --> 00:59:51.220
PERFECTLY. OK THAT'S WONDERFUL.
00:59:51.287 --> 00:59:52.655
I NEEDED IN THE HOUSE TO HOLLER
00:59:52.722 --> 00:59:53.756
AT THE CHILDREN. GOOD MORNING.
00:59:53.823 --> 00:59:55.758
MY NAME IS JIMMY LELAND S.
00:59:55.825 --> 00:59:57.293
SAMUEL STATED EARLIER. NOT ONLY
00:59:57.360 --> 01:00:00.296
AM I HIS WIFE, BUT I AM ALSO THE
01:00:00.363 --> 01:00:01.531
CO FOUNDER OF THE ANTI VIOLENCE
01:00:01.597 --> 01:00:02.065
SAFETY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
01:00:02.131 --> 01:00:03.666
PROJECT. UM SAMUEL STATED HE WAS
01:00:03.733 --> 01:00:05.802
INCARCERATED FOR 24 YEARS.
01:00:05.868 --> 01:00:07.603
DURING THE COURSE OF THAT TIME,
01:00:07.670 --> 01:00:09.706
UM SAMUEL WORKED AS A HEALTH
01:00:09.772 --> 01:00:10.573
CARE FACILITY MAINTENANCE
01:00:10.640 --> 01:00:13.409
WORKER. ESSENTIALLY THAT IS A
01:00:13.476 --> 01:00:15.345
HOSPITAL JANITOR INSIDE OF THE
01:00:15.411 --> 01:00:17.313
CORRECTIONAL FACILITY. AT THE
01:00:17.380 --> 01:00:19.849
ONSET OF COVID 19 PANDEMIC.
01:00:19.916 --> 01:00:22.819
SAMUEL WAS TASKED WITH GOING
01:00:22.885 --> 01:00:24.387
INTO THE SALE OF THE FIRST
01:00:24.454 --> 01:00:26.122
PERSON IN CALIFORNIA
01:00:26.189 --> 01:00:27.190
CORRECTIONAL FACILITY OF THE HIP
01:00:27.256 --> 01:00:29.926
TESTED POSITIVE FOR COVID. WHILE
01:00:29.993 --> 01:00:31.794
THE WORLD IS WATCHING, AND WE DO
01:00:31.861 --> 01:00:34.497
NOT KNOW WHAT THIS IS GOING TO
01:00:34.564 --> 01:00:35.932
BRING SAMUEL ASSES FORCED TO GO
01:00:35.999 --> 01:00:38.401
TO WORK. NOT ONLY IS HE FORCED
01:00:38.468 --> 01:00:39.936
TO GO TO WORK, BUT HE HAS
01:00:40.003 --> 01:00:41.637
THREATENED THAT IF HE DOES NOT
01:00:41.704 --> 01:00:43.806
GO TO WORK, HE WILL GET HIT WITH
01:00:43.873 --> 01:00:45.742
A 1 15, WHICH IS A RULES
01:00:45.808 --> 01:00:47.677
VIOLATION. WE'RE CALLING 1 15.
01:00:47.744 --> 01:00:49.679
THE MODERN DAY WHIP, BECAUSE IT
01:00:49.746 --> 01:00:51.881
IS SOMETHING THAT IS FORCING YOU
01:00:51.948 --> 01:00:53.883
TO WORK. I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE
01:00:53.950 --> 01:00:55.952
TO BRIEF THINGS WITH YOU.
01:00:56.019 --> 01:00:57.453
CALIFORNIA PENAL CODE SECTION
01:00:57.520 --> 01:00:59.389
2700 STATES THAT THE CALIFORNIA
01:00:59.455 --> 01:01:00.056
DEPARTMENT OF CORRCTIONS AND
01:01:00.123 --> 01:01:02.291
REHABILITATION QUOTE SHALL
01:01:02.358 --> 01:01:04.460
REQUIRE EVERY ABLE BODIED
01:01:04.527 --> 01:01:06.362
PRISONER IMPRISONED IN ANY STATE
01:01:06.429 --> 01:01:09.298
IN ANY STATE PRISON. AS MANY
01:01:09.365 --> 01:01:11.434
HOURS OF FAITHFUL LABOR IN EACH
01:01:11.501 --> 01:01:13.803
DAY ND EVERY DAY DURING HIS OR
01:01:13.870 --> 01:01:15.638
HER TERM OF IMPRISONMENT, AS
01:01:15.705 --> 01:01:16.939
SHALL BE PRESCRIBED BY THE RULES
01:01:17.006 --> 01:01:19.042
AND REGULATIONS OF THE DIRECTOR.
01:01:19.108 --> 01:01:21.244
OF CORRECTIONS. THAT SOUNDS LIKE
01:01:21.310 --> 01:01:23.613
FORCED LABOR TO ME. THAT SOUNDS
01:01:23.679 --> 01:01:25.648
LIKE SLAVERY TO ME. IN ADDITION
01:01:25.715 --> 01:01:30.253
TO THAT, AND THIS AND I WANT TO
01:01:30.319 --> 01:01:31.821
BE VERY CLEAR. THIS IS NOT ABOUT
01:01:31.888 --> 01:01:33.689
WAGES, BUT I NEED YOU ALL TO
01:01:33.756 --> 01:01:34.690
UNDERSTAND THE MAGNITUDE OF
01:01:34.757 --> 01:01:36.426
THESE THINGS. SAMUEL WAS WAS
01:01:36.492 --> 01:01:38.895
CONSIDERED A HIGH EARNER. WHERE
01:01:38.961 --> 01:01:42.698
HE MADE 75 CENTS PER HOUR. THE
01:01:42.765 --> 01:01:44.267
STATE OF CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT
01:01:44.333 --> 01:01:46.169
OF CORRECTIONS TOOK 55. OF 75
01:01:46.235 --> 01:01:48.871
CENTS PER HOUR. YES, MA'AM. YOU
01:01:48.938 --> 01:01:52.442
HEARD THAT CORRECTLY? WE JUST
01:01:52.508 --> 01:01:54.310
RECENTLY RECEIVED A BILL IN THE
01:01:54.377 --> 01:01:55.778
MAIL. FROM THE CALIFORNIA
01:01:55.845 --> 01:01:57.980
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD. FOR
01:01:58.047 --> 01:02:01.317
$35,000. WHERE THEY ARE GOING TO
01:02:01.384 --> 01:02:04.787
LEVY. GARNISH ANY MONEY THAT HE
01:02:04.854 --> 01:02:07.557
MAKES. WHILE HE WAS INSIDE.
01:02:07.623 --> 01:02:11.828
WORKING FOR 75 CENTS AN HOUR.
01:02:11.894 --> 01:02:15.965
THIS IS THE MAGNITUDE OF WHAT?
01:02:16.032 --> 01:02:20.736
FORCED LABOR CAN DO. ON THE
01:02:20.803 --> 01:02:22.171
MORNING OF FRIDAY, AUGUST 9TH
01:02:22.238 --> 01:02:24.607
2019 BETWEEN NINE AND 10 WHILE I
01:02:24.674 --> 01:02:25.908
WAS PERFORMING MY DUTIES AS A
01:02:25.975 --> 01:02:28.010
STUDY CUSTODIAN ONE AND THE
01:02:28.077 --> 01:02:29.212
CORRECTIONAL TREATMENT CENTER AT
01:02:29.278 --> 01:02:30.179
CALIFORNIA STATE PRISON, LOS
01:02:30.246 --> 01:02:33.516
ANGELES COUNTY H F M CUSTODIAN
01:02:33.583 --> 01:02:35.051
ONE WENDY WEST IN FRONT OF ME
01:02:35.118 --> 01:02:37.086
AND TOLD ME THAT I QUOTE BETTER
01:02:37.153 --> 01:02:38.254
TELL INMATE BROWN TO TAKE OFF
01:02:38.321 --> 01:02:40.022
HIS NECKLACE. I WAS AWARE OF THE
01:02:40.089 --> 01:02:42.058
CUSTODIAN WEST. IT HAD SEVERAL
01:02:42.125 --> 01:02:43.059
UNNECESSARY CONFRONTATIONS WITH
01:02:43.126 --> 01:02:44.260
INMATE BROWN IN THE PAST, AND I
01:02:44.327 --> 01:02:45.962
KNEW THAT THE NECKLACE SHE WAS
01:02:46.028 --> 01:02:46.729
REFERRING TO WAS RELATED TO HIS
01:02:46.796 --> 01:02:49.532
RELIGION AND REFUSED TO ISSUE AN
01:02:49.599 --> 01:02:50.666
ORDER ON HER BEHALF THAT I
01:02:50.733 --> 01:02:51.801
DIDN'T AGREE WITH. AT THIS POINT
01:02:51.868 --> 01:02:52.869
IT MAY BROWN WALKED INTO THE
01:02:52.935 --> 01:02:54.904
ROOM AND I TOLD HER HE'S RIGHT
01:02:54.971 --> 01:02:56.072
BEHIND YOU. WHY DON'T YOU TELL
01:02:56.139 --> 01:02:57.807
HIM YOURSELF? HE THEN BEGAN
01:02:57.874 --> 01:02:58.708
ANGRILY YELLING AT BROWN WITH
01:02:58.774 --> 01:03:00.076
HER FINGER IN HIS FACE AND
01:03:00.143 --> 01:03:01.844
DEMANDING THAT HE WROTE HIS
01:03:01.911 --> 01:03:02.979
NECKLACE. BROWN CALI INFORMED
01:03:03.045 --> 01:03:03.946
CUSTODIAN WEST THAT HE HAD A
01:03:04.013 --> 01:03:04.947
RIGHT TO WEAR HIS RELIGIOUS
01:03:05.014 --> 01:03:06.849
NECKLACE, AND IF SHE CONTINUED
01:03:06.916 --> 01:03:08.518
TO INSIST HE REMOVED IT, HE
01:03:08.584 --> 01:03:10.319
COULD FILE HE COULD FILE A
01:03:10.386 --> 01:03:11.320
LAWSUIT AGAINST HER FOR
01:03:11.387 --> 01:03:12.288
DISCRIMINATION. SHE SAID, QUOTE.
01:03:12.355 --> 01:03:13.856
OH, WE'LL SEE ABOUT THAT. BROWN
01:03:13.923 --> 01:03:15.791
THEN ANGER THEN OUT. BROWN THEN
01:03:15.858 --> 01:03:17.293
WALKED AWAY. A FEW MINUTES
01:03:17.360 --> 01:03:18.227
LATER, BROWN APPROACHED ME AND
01:03:18.294 --> 01:03:19.929
ASKED IF I HAD DEALT WITH IF HE
01:03:19.996 --> 01:03:21.197
HAD DEALT WITH THE SITUATION
01:03:21.264 --> 01:03:22.098
APPROPRIATELY. I ASSURED HIM
01:03:22.165 --> 01:03:23.866
THAT HE HAD A FEW HOURS LATER
01:03:23.933 --> 01:03:25.535
WITHOUT WARNING AND WITHOUT
01:03:25.601 --> 01:03:26.669
PERMISSION FROM THE CUSTODIAN
01:03:26.736 --> 01:03:28.204
SUPERVISOR, ONE OF HF M
01:03:28.271 --> 01:03:30.239
CUSTODIAN WEST USED HER FAMILIAL
01:03:30.306 --> 01:03:31.974
CONNECTIONS WITH CUSTODY STAFF
01:03:32.041 --> 01:03:33.075
TO HAVE BROWN HANDCUFFED,
01:03:33.142 --> 01:03:34.243
REMOVED FROM CTC AND RETURNED TO
01:03:34.310 --> 01:03:36.445
HIS CELL. FURTHERMORE WITH THE
01:03:36.512 --> 01:03:37.813
HELP OF THE SAME CUSTODY STAFF
01:03:37.880 --> 01:03:39.382
SHE HAD TURNED TO PREVIOUSLY
01:03:39.448 --> 01:03:41.117
CUSTODIAN WEST DRAFTED A RULES
01:03:41.184 --> 01:03:42.818
VIOLATION REPORT, WHICH WAS
01:03:42.885 --> 01:03:44.687
ISSUED TO INMATE BROWN. HE THEN
01:03:44.754 --> 01:03:46.656
CONFRONTED ME AND TOLD ME THAT I
01:03:46.722 --> 01:03:47.857
QUOTE BETTER BACK UP HER VERSION
01:03:47.924 --> 01:03:49.659
OF EVENTS. HE ALSO USED THOSE
01:03:49.725 --> 01:03:51.093
SAME CONNECTIONS TO ISSUE A 1 28
01:03:51.160 --> 01:03:52.562
DROPPED PRONTO TO HAVE INMATE
01:03:52.628 --> 01:03:54.330
BROWN REMOVED FROM HIS
01:03:54.397 --> 01:03:55.531
ASSIGNMENT AS AN H FM OFFENDER
01:03:55.598 --> 01:03:58.067
CUSTODIAN. WHEN OUR SUPERVISORS
01:03:58.134 --> 01:03:59.035
DISCOVERED WHAT SHE HAD DONE,
01:03:59.101 --> 01:04:01.003
CUSTODIAN WEST WAS REPRIMANDED,
01:04:01.070 --> 01:04:02.138
REASSIGNED TO A NEW POST AND
01:04:02.205 --> 01:04:03.272
INSTRUCTED TO FOLLOW THE PROPER
01:04:03.339 --> 01:04:05.041
CHAIN OF COMMAND. BROWN WAS THEN
01:04:05.107 --> 01:04:06.442
REASSIGNED AS ONE OF OUR WORKERS
01:04:06.509 --> 01:04:08.578
CUSTODIAN WEST AGAIN TURN TO HER
01:04:08.644 --> 01:04:10.313
CONNECTIONS TO HAVE INMATE BROWN
01:04:10.379 --> 01:04:11.447
AND ASSIGNED AGAIN. THIS WAS
01:04:11.514 --> 01:04:12.448
AGAIN OVERTURNED BY OUR
01:04:12.515 --> 01:04:14.617
SUPERVISORS. THE RVR THAT SHE
01:04:14.684 --> 01:04:15.918
HAD ISSUED TO INMATE BROWN WAS
01:04:15.985 --> 01:04:17.687
ADJUDICATED AND HE WAS FOUND NOT
01:04:17.753 --> 01:04:19.188
GUILTY. STUDY IN WEST THEN
01:04:19.255 --> 01:04:20.790
TURNED TO HER CONNECTIONS AGAIN
01:04:20.856 --> 01:04:21.958
TO HAVE SOME INFORMATION PLACED
01:04:22.024 --> 01:04:23.993
INTO HIS FILE TO GET HER WAY. IT
01:04:24.060 --> 01:04:25.695
IS CLEAR TO ME THAT CUSTODIAN
01:04:25.761 --> 01:04:27.029
WEST HAS A PROBLEM WITH INMATE
01:04:27.096 --> 01:04:28.164
BROWN AND HIS VINDICTIVELY
01:04:28.231 --> 01:04:29.932
ATTEMPTING TO HAVE HIM PUNISHED.
01:04:29.999 --> 01:04:32.201
THIS COME TO MY ATTENTION THAT
01:04:32.268 --> 01:04:33.936
THIS INCIDENT WAS IN FACT USED
01:04:34.003 --> 01:04:35.271
AS A WAY TO DENY INMATE BROWN
01:04:35.338 --> 01:04:38.808
PAROLE. I BELIEVE THAT IT IS
01:04:38.874 --> 01:04:40.176
UNFAIR AS I WAS PRESENT WHEN
01:04:40.243 --> 01:04:41.377
THESE THINGS HAPPEN, AND
01:04:41.444 --> 01:04:43.479
CUSTODIAN WEST TRIED TO FORCE ME
01:04:43.546 --> 01:04:45.581
TO GO AGAIN TO GO ALONG WITH HER
01:04:45.648 --> 01:04:46.716
VERSION OF EVENTS THAT I KNEW
01:04:46.782 --> 01:04:51.420
WERE INCORRECT. THIS IS SIGNED.
01:04:51.487 --> 01:04:54.223
BUY A COW PIA EMPLOYEE WHO WORKS
01:04:54.290 --> 01:04:58.361
INSIDE OF CDCR. THE WOMAN WENDY
01:04:58.427 --> 01:05:00.429
WEST BECAUSE OF THIS LOOPHOLE.
01:05:00.496 --> 01:05:03.065
IS ACTING AS A PLANTATION
01:05:03.132 --> 01:05:08.771
DRIVER. SHE'S WIELDING THE WHIP.
01:05:08.838 --> 01:05:12.008
TO KEEP HIM INCARCERATED.
01:05:12.074 --> 01:05:14.443
BECAUSE THIS LOOPHOLE ALLOWS FOR
01:05:14.510 --> 01:05:16.846
THAT TYPE OF BEHAVIOR. AND
01:05:16.912 --> 01:05:19.615
UNLESS WE COME TO YOU, AND WE
01:05:19.682 --> 01:05:21.217
TELL YOU THAT THIS IS WHAT'S
01:05:21.284 --> 01:05:22.285
HAPPENING IN THIS CULTURAL
01:05:22.351 --> 01:05:23.319
SETTING. YOU'LL NEVER KNOW. AND
01:05:23.386 --> 01:05:24.787
PEOPLE CONTINUE TO GET AWAY WITH
01:05:24.854 --> 01:05:26.389
THIS TYPE OF BEHAVIOR. FOR
01:05:26.455 --> 01:05:29.025
TODAY. AND A CLIMATE THAT IS SO
01:05:29.091 --> 01:05:32.361
CHARGED. BUT WE HAVE A YOUNG MAN
01:05:32.428 --> 01:05:34.563
THAT WALKS INTO A SCHOOL. WHEN
01:05:34.630 --> 01:05:36.465
WE HAVE A YOUNG MAN THAT WALKS
01:05:36.532 --> 01:05:38.034
INTO A GROCERY STORE. AND HAS
01:05:38.100 --> 01:05:39.835
REPARATIONS AND WRITTEN ON HIS
01:05:39.902 --> 01:05:43.239
GUN. AND GUNS DOWN PEOPLE WHO
01:05:43.306 --> 01:05:48.144
LOOK LIKE ME. I ASK YOU. TO
01:05:48.210 --> 01:05:49.312
STAND ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF
01:05:49.378 --> 01:05:52.214
HISTORY TODAY. AND LET'S WRITE
01:05:52.281 --> 01:05:54.150
SOME OF THE BRONX IN THIS
01:05:54.216 --> 01:05:57.720
COUNTRY. IN 2022. AS PROGRESSIVE
01:05:57.787 --> 01:06:00.256
AS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IS WE
01:06:00.323 --> 01:06:02.425
SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF OURSELVES.
01:06:02.491 --> 01:06:04.593
THAT OUR CONSTITUTION POSSESSES
01:06:04.660 --> 01:06:07.930
LANGUAGE. THAT IS A DIRECT
01:06:07.997 --> 01:06:09.965
VESTIGE OF SLAVERY. I ASK YOU
01:06:10.032 --> 01:06:12.435
RESPECTFULLY TODAY. FOR YOUR I
01:06:12.501 --> 01:06:17.840
VOTE. THANK YOU. MISS LIN, IS
01:06:17.907 --> 01:06:21.510
ANYBODY ELSE HERE? IN THE
01:06:21.577 --> 01:06:23.446
HEARING WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:06:23.512 --> 01:06:27.683
SUPPORT BRIEFLY. HAVE THE THANKS
01:06:27.750 --> 01:06:29.085
CHAIR AND SENATORS. I DON'T CARE
01:06:29.151 --> 01:06:30.753
WHEN, WITH ACT, UM, HERE ON
01:06:30.820 --> 01:06:31.821
BEHALF OF THE YOUNG WOMAN'S
01:06:31.887 --> 01:06:33.489
FREEDOM CENTER, AND THE SISTER
01:06:33.556 --> 01:06:34.623
WARRIORS, FREEDOM, COALITION AND
01:06:34.690 --> 01:06:37.059
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:06:37.126 --> 01:06:38.561
THANK YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:06:38.627 --> 01:06:40.529
RESPOND. NUNEZ WITH THE ANTI
01:06:40.596 --> 01:06:41.564
RECIDIVISM COALITION, PROUD CO
01:06:41.630 --> 01:06:42.198
SPONSOR OF THE MEASURE, AND HERE
01:06:42.264 --> 01:06:43.799
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:06:43.866 --> 01:06:47.069
YOU. THANK YOU. CHAIR AND
01:06:47.136 --> 01:06:48.371
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS AARON FISHER
01:06:48.437 --> 01:06:49.004
ORGANIZED, INDIVISIBLE AS ACROSS
01:06:49.071 --> 01:06:51.207
THE STATE AND ALSO WITH THE ANTI
01:06:51.273 --> 01:06:51.941
VIOLENCE, AGENT ACCOUNTABILITY
01:06:52.007 --> 01:06:53.743
PROJECT, AND I URGE YOU TO PASS
01:06:53.809 --> 01:06:56.746
THREE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:06:56.812 --> 01:06:57.813
ANYBODY ELSE IN THE HEARING ROOM
01:06:57.880 --> 01:06:59.749
SEEING NONE. MISS MODERATOR. IF
01:06:59.815 --> 01:07:01.417
WE COULD PLEASE GO TO THE
01:07:01.484 --> 01:07:02.017
TELECONFERENCE LINE, ANYBODY'S
01:07:02.084 --> 01:07:04.253
WISHING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
01:07:04.320 --> 01:07:09.024
THE E EIGHT. THANK YOU TO SPEAK
01:07:09.091 --> 01:07:10.926
IN SUPPORT. PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO
01:07:10.993 --> 01:07:12.094
AT THIS TIME. WE'LL START WITH
01:07:12.161 --> 01:07:17.800
LINE 102. GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS
01:07:17.867 --> 01:07:21.904
MINISTER KING. AND I'M HERE ON
01:07:21.971 --> 01:07:23.973
BEHALF. L S P C ALL OF US OR
01:07:24.039 --> 01:07:26.509
NONE. CALIFORNIA PRISON FOCUS IS
01:07:26.575 --> 01:07:28.811
PAID UIVERSAL AND SUPPORT OF
01:07:28.878 --> 01:07:30.579
ABC AND STRONG SUPPORT OF ABC.
01:07:30.646 --> 01:07:46.195
THANK YOU. BLIND 58. FIND 58.
01:07:46.262 --> 01:07:47.396
WE'LL MOVE ON TO LINE ONE OR
01:07:47.463 --> 01:07:53.903
FIVE. YES. VERY HARD. AND ONE OF
01:07:53.969 --> 01:07:58.140
FIVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HELLO
01:07:58.207 --> 01:08:03.779
THIS IS. I'M CALLING ON BEHALF
01:08:03.846 --> 01:08:05.147
OF ALL OF US ARE NONE COMMUNITY
01:08:05.214 --> 01:08:09.418
HEALER. AND I AM IN VERY STRONG
01:08:09.485 --> 01:08:10.753
, OF COURSE FROM MY COMMUNITY
01:08:10.820 --> 01:08:12.688
AND EVERYBODY ELSE IN FOR A
01:08:12.755 --> 01:08:16.158
PRIEST. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:08:16.225 --> 01:08:23.666
LINE 107. GOOD MORNING. SHARON
01:08:23.732 --> 01:08:25.568
THE NUMBERS ALYONA SINGER ON
01:08:25.634 --> 01:08:27.503
BEHALF BY IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
01:08:27.570 --> 01:08:38.080
BAKERY. THANK YOU. FIND 1 17.
01:08:38.147 --> 01:08:39.381
THE LINE IS TAKING THEMSELVES
01:08:39.448 --> 01:08:43.552
OUT OF A FEW LINE 1 19. GOOD
01:08:43.619 --> 01:08:44.787
MORNING, MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
01:08:44.854 --> 01:08:45.754
CURTIS, PLAYING WITH THE
01:08:45.821 --> 01:08:47.656
CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION
01:08:47.723 --> 01:08:48.224
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF THREE
01:08:48.290 --> 01:08:55.297
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 1 11.
01:08:55.364 --> 01:08:56.866
PEACE AND BLESSINGS TO ALL MY
01:08:56.932 --> 01:08:58.400
NAME IS TALK. WALT BONNER, THE
01:08:58.467 --> 01:09:00.703
HOUSING ADVOCATE FOR ALL OF US
01:09:00.769 --> 01:09:02.204
OR NOT, WHICH IS A PROJECT OF
01:09:02.271 --> 01:09:05.007
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS-WITH CHILDREN, AND I'M STRONG
01:09:05.074 --> 01:09:06.041
SUPPORT OF A C A THREE. THANK
01:09:06.108 --> 01:09:13.716
YOU, SIR. FIND 1 24. YES. MY
01:09:13.782 --> 01:09:18.487
NAME IS TROY WILLIAMS. AM
01:09:18.554 --> 01:09:20.556
COMMUNICATIONS MANAGER FOR LEGAL
01:09:20.623 --> 01:09:21.857
SERVICES FOR BUSINESS WITH
01:09:21.924 --> 01:09:23.692
CHILDREN, PROUD MEMBER OF ALL OF
01:09:23.759 --> 01:09:25.327
US TO NONE. ANY ABOLISHED,
01:09:25.394 --> 01:09:27.930
ABUNDANCE COLLECTIVELY. CALLING
01:09:27.997 --> 01:09:29.098
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF THREE
01:09:29.164 --> 01:09:35.905
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 80.
01:09:35.971 --> 01:09:37.306
HELLO GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
01:09:37.373 --> 01:09:39.275
MARVIN. GALLED AMIS, UM, FROM
01:09:39.341 --> 01:09:41.076
PRESIDENT, LEGAL SERVICES
01:09:41.143 --> 01:09:42.978
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN, AND I'M
01:09:43.045 --> 01:09:45.514
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A
01:09:45.581 --> 01:09:47.416
THREE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:09:47.483 --> 01:09:53.989
LINE 25. OH, MY GOD. HELLO, THIS
01:09:54.056 --> 01:09:57.693
IS ALYSSA. MORE FROM L S P C. M
01:09:57.760 --> 01:09:59.828
2022 POLICIES AND I'M CALLING IN
01:09:59.895 --> 01:10:03.165
STRONG SUPPORT OF 83. THANK YOU.
01:10:03.232 --> 01:10:09.438
LINE 59. THAT MORNING, MR
01:10:09.505 --> 01:10:10.539
TAYLOR'S UNDER AN EXECUTIVE
01:10:10.606 --> 01:10:15.177
DIRECTOR FROM INSIDE OUT. A C A
01:10:15.244 --> 01:10:16.412
STATE CALLING AND STRONG
01:10:16.478 --> 01:10:18.047
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:10:18.113 --> 01:10:24.553
NEXT. LINE 36. THAT WILL BE
01:10:24.620 --> 01:10:27.656
CURTIS HOWARD, LEAD ORGANIZER
01:10:27.723 --> 01:10:28.958
FOR THE SAN DIEGO CHAPTER OF ALL
01:10:29.024 --> 01:10:31.961
OF US ARE NONE. TOTALLY IN
01:10:32.027 --> 01:10:34.063
SUPPORT OF A C A C. THANK YOU.
01:10:34.129 --> 01:10:40.202
THANK YOU, SIR. 9 15. UH THIS IS
01:10:40.269 --> 01:10:41.971
MICHAEL DORADO CALLING FOR
01:10:42.037 --> 01:10:43.672
STARTING OVER INK AND RIVERSIDE
01:10:43.739 --> 01:10:46.041
COUNTY. WE'RE IN STRONG SUPPORT
01:10:46.108 --> 01:10:48.077
OF A C A THREE. THANK YOU. THANK
01:10:48.143 --> 01:10:55.551
YOU. BLIND 50. GOOD MORNING
01:10:55.618 --> 01:10:57.987
CHAIRMAN. NAME IS <c.cyan>/C. DRAZI I</c>
01:10:58.053 --> 01:11:00.222
AM CALLING FROM ALL OF US ARE
01:11:00.289 --> 01:11:02.358
THEN BAKERS STILL IN STRONG
01:11:02.424 --> 01:11:03.058
SUPPORT OF A C A THREE. THANK
01:11:03.125 --> 01:11:06.395
YOU, MA'AM. MR MODERATE BEFORE
01:11:06.462 --> 01:11:08.230
WE GO FORWARD. HOW MANY IF YOU
01:11:08.297 --> 01:11:09.865
COULD PLEASE? GIVE US AN IDEA
01:11:09.932 --> 01:11:11.800
HOW MANY MORE COLORS OTHER THAN
01:11:11.867 --> 01:11:14.603
THE QUÊ WE HAVE 42 LINES IN QUÊ
01:11:14.670 --> 01:11:16.905
SER. VERY GOOD. PLEASE PROCEED.
01:11:16.972 --> 01:11:22.211
LINE 38. HELLO HOW ARE YOU
01:11:22.277 --> 01:11:23.846
DOING? THIS IS CHOPPED BUT
01:11:23.912 --> 01:11:25.648
CALLING ON BEHALF OF RIVERSIDE.
01:11:25.714 --> 01:11:28.884
ALL OF US ARE KNOWN LSC. IN THE
01:11:28.951 --> 01:11:30.085
BONDAGE BONDAGE, COLLECTIVELY
01:11:30.152 --> 01:11:34.423
STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A PRETTY.
01:11:34.490 --> 01:11:40.062
LINE 28. HELLO THIS IS JACOB
01:11:40.129 --> 01:11:41.964
TRUCK IT I'M AN ETHICS PROFESSOR
01:11:42.031 --> 01:11:44.533
AT SCC AND FOUNDER OF SPECTRUM.
01:11:44.600 --> 01:11:45.768
THANK YOU TO DJAMILA HAND. THANK
01:11:45.834 --> 01:11:47.403
YOU. TO SAMUEL THE ANNUAL BROWN
01:11:47.469 --> 01:11:49.004
AM AND STRONG SUPPORT. THEY SAY
01:11:49.071 --> 01:11:55.678
THREE. THANK YOU. NEXT 9 86.
01:11:55.744 --> 01:11:58.514
HELLO THIS IS ALMA ROBINSON AND
01:11:58.580 --> 01:11:59.648
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
01:11:59.715 --> 01:12:01.684
CALIFORNIA LAWYERS FOR THE ARTS.
01:12:01.750 --> 01:12:04.520
I'M ALSO A MEMBER OF THE SOCIAL
01:12:04.586 --> 01:12:05.587
JUSTICE WORKING GROUP THAT GREAT
01:12:05.654 --> 01:12:07.356
CATHEDRAL. BOTH OF THESE
01:12:07.423 --> 01:12:09.692
ORGANIZATIONS, AS WELL AS THE
01:12:09.758 --> 01:12:11.393
DIOCESE OF CALIFORNIA OR IN
01:12:11.460 --> 01:12:13.729
STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A THREE.
01:12:13.796 --> 01:12:15.397
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT. LINE
01:12:15.464 --> 01:12:22.304
39. HELLO MY NAME IS DIANE
01:12:22.371 --> 01:12:25.474
FIGUEROA, CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:12:25.541 --> 01:12:27.810
ALL OF US ARE NONE LEFT ANGELUS.
01:12:27.876 --> 01:12:29.545
AND WE ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:12:29.611 --> 01:12:31.947
A C A THREE. THANK YOU. THANK
01:12:32.014 --> 01:12:38.787
YOU NEXT. LINE 108. GOOD
01:12:38.854 --> 01:12:39.722
MORNING. MY NAME IS JOSIAH
01:12:39.788 --> 01:12:41.156
WILLIAMS AND WITH THE COALITION
01:12:41.223 --> 01:12:42.057
FOR ADJUSTMENT, EQUITABLE
01:12:42.124 --> 01:12:43.659
CALIFORNIA SUBJECT AND ALSO THE
01:12:43.726 --> 01:12:44.960
AMERICAN REDRESS COALITION TO
01:12:45.027 --> 01:12:46.495
CALIFORNIA BAY AREA AND SHOWING
01:12:46.562 --> 01:12:48.163
SUPPORT OF AC THREE. PLEASE
01:12:48.230 --> 01:12:49.331
VOTE. YES, THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:12:49.398 --> 01:12:56.505
NEXT. FIND 57. GOOD MORNING. MY
01:12:56.572 --> 01:12:57.840
NAME IS CHRIS PAUL COBB. AND I
01:12:57.906 --> 01:13:00.042
LIVE IN SACRAMENTO. I'M CALLING
01:13:00.109 --> 01:13:02.544
IN SUPPORT OF A THREE AND I'M
01:13:02.611 --> 01:13:03.746
ASKING THE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
01:13:03.812 --> 01:13:05.347
TO SUPPORT IT AS WELL. THANK YOU
01:13:05.414 --> 01:13:07.916
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. NEXT. LOOK
01:13:07.983 --> 01:13:17.159
LINE 1 13. LINE 1 13. YOUR LINE
01:13:17.226 --> 01:13:20.295
IS OPEN. GO AHEAD, PLEASE. MY
01:13:20.362 --> 01:13:21.230
NAME IS DORSEY NON ON THE
01:13:21.296 --> 01:13:22.698
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF LEGAL
01:13:22.765 --> 01:13:24.333
SERVICES FOR PRISONS, WITH
01:13:24.399 --> 01:13:25.768
CHILDREN AND PRAVACHOL FOUND OF
01:13:25.834 --> 01:13:27.836
ALL OF US FOR NINE AND I'M
01:13:27.903 --> 01:13:29.037
CALLING IN THE STRONG WERE URGED
01:13:29.104 --> 01:13:31.306
TO SUPPORT THIS. THIS
01:13:31.373 --> 01:13:34.076
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. UM AND
01:13:34.143 --> 01:13:36.211
I AM IN SUPPORT OF IT. THANK
01:13:36.278 --> 01:13:41.950
YOU. THANK YOU. NICE. LINE 94.
01:13:42.017 --> 01:13:44.052
MARTIN PERLMUTTER FROM
01:13:44.119 --> 01:13:45.788
INDIVISIBLE MEDIA CITY, BURBANK
01:13:45.854 --> 01:13:47.055
AND A LONG TIME MATH TEACHER.
01:13:47.122 --> 01:13:49.792
QUENTIN PRISON. AYE. SPEAKING
01:13:49.858 --> 01:13:50.859
STRONG SUPPORT OF THREE AND
01:13:50.926 --> 01:13:55.397
SLAVERY. THANK YOU NEXT. LINE
01:13:55.464 --> 01:14:07.142
46. 9 46. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:14:07.209 --> 01:14:08.811
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS KEVIN
01:14:08.877 --> 01:14:12.014
SANCHEZ. I'M FROM MARIN COUNTY.
01:14:12.080 --> 01:14:15.184
AND I AM AS STRONG AS A BULL
01:14:15.250 --> 01:14:17.319
WEEK. THREE WE NEED A AND THIS
01:14:17.386 --> 01:14:18.453
STATEMENT. VERY THANK YOU. THANK
01:14:18.520 --> 01:14:24.526
YOU, SIR. NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 32.
01:14:24.593 --> 01:14:26.061
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
01:14:26.128 --> 01:14:27.229
SAMANTHA HAMMER. I'M CALLING ON
01:14:27.296 --> 01:14:29.131
BEHALF OF LEGAL SERVICES FOR
01:14:29.198 --> 01:14:30.532
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN, ALL OF
01:14:30.599 --> 01:14:32.201
US OR NONE IN THE BAY AREA, AND
01:14:32.267 --> 01:14:34.570
I STRONGLY SUPPORT YOU TO THREE.
01:14:34.636 --> 01:14:35.671
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT. LINE
01:14:35.737 --> 01:14:41.977
93. GOOD MORNING COMMITTEE
01:14:42.044 --> 01:14:43.245
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LINDA
01:14:43.312 --> 01:14:44.012
PRESSURE AND I'M CALLING ON
01:14:44.079 --> 01:14:46.849
BEHALF OF RACIAL JUSTICE AREA
01:14:46.915 --> 01:14:47.316
AND ABOLISHED, FUNDED
01:14:47.382 --> 01:14:48.217
SELECTIVELY AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:14:48.283 --> 01:14:49.952
THREE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:14:50.018 --> 01:14:56.992
NEXT. LINE 64. THE MORNING SHARE
01:14:57.059 --> 01:14:59.394
REMEMBERS. MY NAME IS NAGOYA AND
01:14:59.461 --> 01:15:01.964
I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF LITTLE
01:15:02.030 --> 01:15:04.600
PILL, RIVERSIDE, ALL OF US OR
01:15:04.666 --> 01:15:05.901
NONE, ABC AND WE ARE IN STRONG
01:15:05.968 --> 01:15:07.836
SUPPORT OF THREE THANK YOU.
01:15:07.903 --> 01:15:15.310
THANK YOU NEXT. LINE 71. HI MY
01:15:15.377 --> 01:15:18.313
NAME IS A J UNDERSTAND THAT THEY
01:15:18.380 --> 01:15:20.649
I SAY A I I'M CALLING ON BEHALF
01:15:20.716 --> 01:15:24.286
OF THE AND ENTRY COUNCIL OF
01:15:24.353 --> 01:15:26.521
CALIFORNIA AS WELL AS
01:15:26.588 --> 01:15:28.590
TRANSFORMING YOUNG MINDS, FUTURE
01:15:28.657 --> 01:15:31.460
SOLUTIONS AS WELL AS ABOLISHED
01:15:31.526 --> 01:15:34.963
BONDAGE COLLECTIVELY. AS WELL AS
01:15:35.030 --> 01:15:37.432
ALL OF US ARE MOM AND I AM IN
01:15:37.499 --> 01:15:39.701
STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A THREE.
01:15:39.768 --> 01:15:41.603
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:15:41.670 --> 01:15:50.746
PLEASE. LINE 1 16. LYON WON 16
01:15:50.812 --> 01:15:59.054
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. WE'LL MOVE ON
01:15:59.121 --> 01:16:04.660
TO LINE 61. HELLO GOOD MORNING.
01:16:04.726 --> 01:16:06.495
CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES. PLEASE
01:16:06.561 --> 01:16:09.498
PROCEED. WONDERFUL THANK YOU.
01:16:09.564 --> 01:16:10.999
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS LIU BEI
01:16:11.066 --> 01:16:12.868
BROWN. UM I AM A NEW
01:16:12.935 --> 01:16:14.569
ABOLITIONISTS AND THE EDITOR OF
01:16:14.636 --> 01:16:15.904
FRANCISCO BABY NATIONAL BLACK
01:16:15.971 --> 01:16:18.807
NEWSPAPER, UM, AS WELL AS PART
01:16:18.874 --> 01:16:20.509
OF THE PRISONER HUMAN RIGHTS
01:16:20.575 --> 01:16:21.543
MOVEMENT, AND I STRONGLY
01:16:21.610 --> 01:16:22.778
ENTHUSIASTICALLY SUPPORT THE
01:16:22.844 --> 01:16:24.813
PASSING OF A THREE AND LEGAL
01:16:24.880 --> 01:16:27.316
SLAVERY NOW, THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:16:27.382 --> 01:16:28.483
FOR ALL THE BEAUTIFUL WORK
01:16:28.550 --> 01:16:29.651
PEOPLE HAVE DONE. THANK YOU. AND
01:16:29.718 --> 01:16:36.124
NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 47. HELLO MY
01:16:36.191 --> 01:16:38.160
NAME IS SHARON TO YOU FROM THE
01:16:38.226 --> 01:16:42.097
POLLS. CENTER IN SOME STUFF LONG
01:16:42.164 --> 01:16:46.468
ENOUGH. MAMA SPEAKING ON BEHALF
01:16:46.535 --> 01:16:47.836
OF, UH, SOUTHERN APPALACHIAN,
01:16:47.903 --> 01:16:48.570
QUICKER, UPLIFTING RACIAL
01:16:48.637 --> 01:16:51.940
JUSTICE. I AM IN STRONG SUPPORT
01:16:52.007 --> 01:16:54.076
OF A PS THREE. THANK YOU VERY
01:16:54.142 --> 01:17:00.482
MUCH NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 32.
01:17:00.549 --> 01:17:02.918
GOOD MORNING, THIS EVERY WONDER
01:17:02.985 --> 01:17:04.519
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE YOUNG
01:17:04.586 --> 01:17:06.121
WOMEN'S FREEDOM CENTER IN STRONG
01:17:06.188 --> 01:17:07.990
SUPPORT THE BASIC GREEN. THANK
01:17:08.056 --> 01:17:09.124
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:17:09.191 --> 01:17:15.097
LINE 68. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME
01:17:15.163 --> 01:17:16.965
IS SAVANNAH ELDER DRUM CALLING
01:17:17.032 --> 01:17:19.101
FROM THE STATE OF TEXAS AND THE
01:17:19.167 --> 01:17:20.569
STANDARD OF THE COALITION TO
01:17:20.635 --> 01:17:22.971
ABOLISH SLAVERY, TEXTURES AND
01:17:23.038 --> 01:17:24.573
DIRECTOR STATE OPERATIONS FOR
01:17:24.639 --> 01:17:25.640
THE POLISH SLAVERY NATIONAL
01:17:25.707 --> 01:17:27.943
NETWORK. I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT
01:17:28.010 --> 01:17:29.444
OF FAMILIAR LAND AND SAMUEL
01:17:29.511 --> 01:17:32.781
BROWN AND IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
01:17:32.848 --> 01:17:33.982
C THREE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:17:34.049 --> 01:17:41.189
NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 31. YES
01:17:41.256 --> 01:17:43.158
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS DARLING
01:17:43.225 --> 01:17:45.060
COMEDY AND I AM A MEMBER OF THE
01:17:45.127 --> 01:17:47.796
COALITION FOR JUST AND EQUITABLE
01:17:47.863 --> 01:17:49.831
. CALIFORNIA AND AUSTIN ALSO THE
01:17:49.898 --> 01:17:53.135
AMERICAN REDRESS. COALITION OF
01:17:53.201 --> 01:17:56.405
CALIFORNIA URGE YOU TODAY TO
01:17:56.471 --> 01:17:59.608
PASS AND VOTE FOR A C A THREE.
01:17:59.674 --> 01:18:00.742
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:18:00.809 --> 01:18:10.652
PLEASE. LINE 37. HI MY NAME IS
01:18:10.719 --> 01:18:12.487
JOHN DARLING. I WORKED WITH
01:18:12.554 --> 01:18:13.622
ABOLISHED, LEAVING NATIONAL
01:18:13.688 --> 01:18:17.192
NETWORK AND STRONG SUPPORTING
01:18:17.259 --> 01:18:18.593
THREE AND THE WORK OF
01:18:18.660 --> 01:18:21.196
ENGINEERING SONS, THE PRESENCE
01:18:21.263 --> 01:18:21.997
OF TRANSITIONAL SLAVERY AND
01:18:22.064 --> 01:18:26.835
SEVERAL, UM STATE CONSTITUTIONS
01:18:26.902 --> 01:18:28.804
AND THE NATIONAL CONSTITUTION IS
01:18:28.870 --> 01:18:30.772
A CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS. WE JUST
01:18:30.839 --> 01:18:33.809
, UM ACKNOWLEDGE AND NEEDS TO BE
01:18:33.875 --> 01:18:35.010
BUT THE FOREFRONT AND IT'S ALSO
01:18:35.077 --> 01:18:40.215
A HUMAN RIGHTS MATTERS, RIGHT
01:18:40.282 --> 01:18:42.117
VIOLATION, SO I URGE YOU TO
01:18:42.184 --> 01:18:45.987
SUPPORT A C STREET TO, UM AND
01:18:46.054 --> 01:18:47.956
HE'S COMING. RIGHT THANK YOU.
01:18:48.023 --> 01:18:49.591
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1
01:18:49.658 --> 01:18:56.465
33. TREAT THAT AFTERNOON CHAIR
01:18:56.531 --> 01:18:57.866
AND MEMBERS I WOULD LIKE TO
01:18:57.933 --> 01:18:59.067
THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING. AND
01:18:59.134 --> 01:19:00.168
THIS IS YOLANDA NEVER ALREADY
01:19:00.235 --> 01:19:02.604
WITH FAMILIES UNITED TO END L
01:19:02.671 --> 01:19:04.106
WALK AND STRONG SUPPORTER
01:19:04.172 --> 01:19:05.140
VITIATE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:19:05.207 --> 01:19:14.449
NEXT, PLEASE. FIND 74. HELLO. HI
01:19:14.516 --> 01:19:15.951
MY NAME IS KIMBERLY. I'M WITH A
01:19:16.017 --> 01:19:18.520
NEW WAY OF LIFE AND ALL OF US
01:19:18.587 --> 01:19:19.554
ARE NÀN FELLOW, AND WE ARE IN
01:19:19.621 --> 01:19:21.756
STRONG SUPPORT OF AC THREE.
01:19:21.823 --> 01:19:31.066
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 42.
01:19:31.133 --> 01:19:33.435
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS TATYANA
01:19:33.502 --> 01:19:35.737
LEWIS. I AM A POLICY FELLOW AT
01:19:35.804 --> 01:19:36.872
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS,
01:19:36.938 --> 01:19:40.041
WITH CHILDREN CALLING ON I'M
01:19:40.108 --> 01:19:41.676
ALSO PROUD MEMBER OF ALL OF US
01:19:41.743 --> 01:19:43.578
ARE NONE AS WELL AS ABOLISHED
01:19:43.645 --> 01:19:45.814
BONDAGE COLLECTIVELY IN STRONG
01:19:45.881 --> 01:19:47.916
SUPPORT OF A CREEK. THANK YOU,
01:19:47.983 --> 01:19:48.984
PLEASE, AND INVOLUNTARY SERVICE
01:19:49.050 --> 01:19:52.154
TO NOW. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:19:52.220 --> 01:19:55.857
FIND 109. BUT WORSE SPENDING
01:19:55.924 --> 01:19:59.995
MORE. TO HOUSE THEM. YEAH, FEED
01:20:00.061 --> 01:20:07.502
THEM. WHAT'S FACING SURE IF YOU
01:20:07.569 --> 01:20:09.371
COULD, WE'D WE'D LIKE YOUR NAME
01:20:09.437 --> 01:20:10.338
YOUR AFFILIATION IN YOUR
01:20:10.405 --> 01:20:14.543
POSITION ON THE BILL. HELLO.
01:20:14.609 --> 01:20:16.611
FIND 109. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. OH,
01:20:16.678 --> 01:20:19.214
YOU CAN HEAR ME. WE CAN PLEASE
01:20:19.281 --> 01:20:24.753
PROCEED. OKAY MY NAME IS
01:20:24.819 --> 01:20:26.588
SYLVESTER ANNIE JUNIOR FOUNDER
01:20:26.655 --> 01:20:27.822
OF THE LOVE WE DON'T SEE AND I'M
01:20:27.889 --> 01:20:30.392
CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A C
01:20:30.458 --> 01:20:33.161
83. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE
01:20:33.228 --> 01:20:37.499
PARDON ME LINE 1 20. GOOD
01:20:37.566 --> 01:20:38.800
MORNING. MY NAME IS CHRIS LARSON
01:20:38.867 --> 01:20:40.402
WITH THE COALITION FOR JUSTIN
01:20:40.468 --> 01:20:42.070
EQUITABLE, CALIFORNIA, ALSO WITH
01:20:42.137 --> 01:20:43.371
THE AMERICAN REDRESS COALITION
01:20:43.438 --> 01:20:45.006
OF CALIFORNIA IN SACRAMENTO,
01:20:45.073 --> 01:20:46.474
CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A C
01:20:46.541 --> 01:20:48.043
A THREE. PLEASE VOTE YES. THANK
01:20:48.109 --> 01:20:55.784
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 10. MY
01:20:55.850 --> 01:20:57.819
NAME IS MISS BINGO. BRITAIN AND
01:20:57.886 --> 01:21:01.690
I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT OF A C A
01:21:01.756 --> 01:21:03.625
THREE. I ENCOURAGE YOU TO VOTE
01:21:03.692 --> 01:21:05.560
YES, IN SLAVERY AND THANK YOU SO
01:21:05.627 --> 01:21:06.695
MUCH TO THE GROUNDS FOR THEIR
01:21:06.761 --> 01:21:07.963
TESTIMONY IN THEIR COURAGE.
01:21:08.029 --> 01:21:14.736
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. 9 78.
01:21:14.803 --> 01:21:18.506
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS THAT'S
01:21:18.573 --> 01:21:20.642
WONDERFUL NEEDLES AND MICHAEL
01:21:20.709 --> 01:21:22.444
RESPONSE SUPPORT OF THE THREE
01:21:22.510 --> 01:21:24.079
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:21:24.145 --> 01:21:34.990
PLEASE. BY 96. THE PRESIDENT.
01:21:35.056 --> 01:21:36.258
YOUR LINE IS UP. WE'LL GO AHEAD,
01:21:36.324 --> 01:21:43.531
PLEASE. RIGHT? YES, LINE 96.
01:21:43.598 --> 01:21:50.405
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. 15 ME? YES.
01:21:50.472 --> 01:21:55.944
PLEASE PROCEED. YES I WILL PUMP
01:21:56.011 --> 01:22:00.181
DURING. MR GARY JOHN, SPEAKING
01:22:00.248 --> 01:22:05.153
FOR US. A DELICATE AS TIME FOR
01:22:05.220 --> 01:22:08.123
TIME DONE HIS THIRD SYSTEM I
01:22:08.189 --> 01:22:10.625
HEREBY ENFORCED BEFORE, AS WELL
01:22:10.692 --> 01:22:12.627
AS THE MEMBERS OF TIME. DON'T
01:22:12.694 --> 01:22:14.029
FULLY SUPPORT H B. A GOOD. THANK
01:22:14.095 --> 01:22:17.165
YOU. THANK YOU, MR JOHN. NEXT
01:22:17.232 --> 01:22:26.107
PLEASE BY LINE, 45. BLIND 45.
01:22:26.174 --> 01:22:34.783
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. WE'LL MOVE ON
01:22:34.849 --> 01:22:40.588
TO LINE 33. YES GOOD MORNING. MY
01:22:40.655 --> 01:22:43.692
NAME IS YUSUF ASAN. I'M CALLING
01:22:43.758 --> 01:22:44.659
FROM THE A POLISH. WE RE
01:22:44.726 --> 01:22:46.795
NATIONAL NETWORK AND I'M ALSO
01:22:46.861 --> 01:22:48.463
THE CO HOST OF THE ABOLITION
01:22:48.530 --> 01:22:50.231
TODAY, PODCAST CALLING AND
01:22:50.298 --> 01:22:53.568
SUPPORT SUPPORT OF A C A THREE.
01:22:53.635 --> 01:22:55.003
LOVE YOU VERY MUCH TO MERELY A
01:22:55.070 --> 01:22:57.439
LAND SAMUEL BROWN AND SENATOR
01:22:57.505 --> 01:22:59.474
COMMON LAGER URGED THE ASSEMBLY
01:22:59.541 --> 01:23:01.643
TO VOTE. YES, ON A CH THREE.
01:23:01.710 --> 01:23:02.811
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
01:23:02.877 --> 01:23:10.785
PLEASE. LINE 1 26. HELLO MY NAME
01:23:10.852 --> 01:23:12.687
IS TONY MCGILL ARE COMMON ON
01:23:12.754 --> 01:23:15.156
BEHALF OF LEGAL SERVICES FOR
01:23:15.223 --> 01:23:16.858
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN, ALSO A
01:23:16.925 --> 01:23:18.593
PROUD MEMBER OF ALL OF US OR
01:23:18.660 --> 01:23:20.695
NONE AND ALSO MEMBER OF THE
01:23:20.762 --> 01:23:21.830
ABOLISHED BONDAGE COLLECTIVELY
01:23:21.896 --> 01:23:25.567
COALITION. IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:23:25.633 --> 01:23:28.603
88 3 AND ALSO JUST WOULD LIKE TO
01:23:28.670 --> 01:23:30.839
EXTEND MY GRATITUDE TO THE
01:23:30.905 --> 01:23:33.074
VISION OF THE O. G S IN THIS
01:23:33.141 --> 01:23:34.109
MOVEMENT FROM CRITICAL
01:23:34.175 --> 01:23:35.944
RESISTANCE TO YOU KNOW, COMRADE
01:23:36.010 --> 01:23:38.246
GEORGE JACKSON TOWARDS ME? NONE
01:23:38.313 --> 01:23:40.448
ANGELA DAVIS, ALL OF THE GIANTS
01:23:40.515 --> 01:23:41.950
, THAT THE SHOULDERS THAT WE
01:23:42.016 --> 01:23:43.551
STAND UPON FOLKS THAT HAVE BEEN
01:23:43.618 --> 01:23:44.786
WORKING TO END SLAVERY FOR A
01:23:44.853 --> 01:23:46.721
VERY LONG TIME. SO PLEASE VOTE
01:23:46.788 --> 01:23:48.356
YES, ON 88 3. THANK YOU. THANK
01:23:48.423 --> 01:23:53.928
YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. 91 18. GOOD
01:23:53.995 --> 01:23:56.931
MORNING. MY NAME IS PAUL BRILEY.
01:23:56.998 --> 01:23:59.367
I AM WITH LEGAL SERVICES FOR
01:23:59.434 --> 01:24:01.102
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN AND
01:24:01.169 --> 01:24:03.104
PROUD CO FOUNDER OF ALL OF US
01:24:03.171 --> 01:24:04.873
ARE NINE, CALLING STRONG SUPPORT
01:24:04.939 --> 01:24:07.075
OF THREE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:24:07.142 --> 01:24:12.881
NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 44. GOOD
01:24:12.947 --> 01:24:17.485
MORNING. MY NEXT NEED A WATSON.
01:24:17.552 --> 01:24:19.454
I'M THE PRESIDENT OF FREE
01:24:19.521 --> 01:24:21.556
INDEED. REENTRY PROJECT. BASED
01:24:21.623 --> 01:24:23.158
HERE IN THE ANTELOPE VALLEY, AND
01:24:23.224 --> 01:24:25.393
I'M ALSO A PROUD MEMBER OF THE
01:24:25.460 --> 01:24:26.861
JETS, THE COALITION FOR JUSTIN,
01:24:26.928 --> 01:24:28.963
EQUITABLE, CALIFORNIA AND
01:24:29.030 --> 01:24:30.165
CALLING TO EMPLOY YOU TO VOTE
01:24:30.231 --> 01:24:34.636
YES, ON A P A THREE. THE ACT IN
01:24:34.702 --> 01:24:37.939
SLAVERY. INVOLUNTARY SORRY.
01:24:38.006 --> 01:24:38.473
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE AS
01:24:38.540 --> 01:24:41.309
PUNISHMENT FOR A CRIME. THE
01:24:41.376 --> 01:24:44.179
SAYING GOES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:24:44.245 --> 01:24:45.613
. WE'RE JUST TAKING YOUR NAME,
01:24:45.680 --> 01:24:47.115
YOUR AFFILIATION AND YOUR
01:24:47.182 --> 01:24:48.116
POSITION. APPRECIATE IT. THANK
01:24:48.183 --> 01:24:54.155
YOU, MODERATOR NEXT LINE 11.
01:24:54.222 --> 01:24:57.192
HELLO AND HAPPY MONDAY TO ALL MY
01:24:57.258 --> 01:24:59.027
NAME IS IRIS PEOPLE AND I'M
01:24:59.093 --> 01:25:01.696
CALLING IN SUPPORT OF THE JET,
01:25:01.763 --> 01:25:03.264
THE COALITION FOR A JUST AND
01:25:03.331 --> 01:25:05.567
EQUITABLE CALIFORNIA URGING NEW
01:25:05.633 --> 01:25:06.801
. YES. VOTES ON A C A THREE.
01:25:06.868 --> 01:25:08.670
THANK YOU ALL VERY MUCH. THANK
01:25:08.736 --> 01:25:13.274
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 79. BUT
01:25:13.341 --> 01:25:16.277
ONE MOMENT, PLEASE. YOUR LINE IS
01:25:16.344 --> 01:25:21.683
OPEN. GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS
01:25:21.749 --> 01:25:23.451
CHANTELLE WATERHOUSE. AND I'M
01:25:23.518 --> 01:25:25.854
CALLING ON BEHALF OF ABC AND I
01:25:25.920 --> 01:25:27.589
AM IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE A
01:25:27.655 --> 01:25:28.723
THREE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:25:28.790 --> 01:25:45.840
NEXT, PLEASE. SMARTER IN NEXT.
01:25:45.907 --> 01:25:50.778
EVER AND WE LOST THE MODERATE.
01:25:50.845 --> 01:25:53.181
SENATOR KAMLAGER ABLE TO HEAR ME
01:25:53.248 --> 01:25:54.816
. WE CAN HEAR YOU. THANKS YOU'RE
01:25:54.883 --> 01:25:56.150
BACK. OKAY ONE MOMENT. PLEASE
01:25:56.217 --> 01:25:59.454
PURSUED LINE 18. HELLO. CAN YOU
01:25:59.521 --> 01:26:04.993
HEAR ME? YES. GREETINGS MAX
01:26:05.059 --> 01:26:07.061
PARTNERS AND THE NATIONAL
01:26:07.128 --> 01:26:08.696
CAMPAIGN DIRECTOR FOR THE
01:26:08.763 --> 01:26:10.665
ABOLISHED SLAVERY NATIONAL
01:26:10.732 --> 01:26:13.701
NETWORK ORGANIZATION INCLUDES
01:26:13.768 --> 01:26:15.069
LEAD ORGANIZER'S THAT ABOLISHED
01:26:15.136 --> 01:26:16.204
SLAVERY IN COLORADO AND NEBRASKA
01:26:16.271 --> 01:26:19.607
AND UTAH. AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO
01:26:19.674 --> 01:26:21.676
CALIFORNIA BEING THE SIXTH STATE
01:26:21.743 --> 01:26:23.912
THIS YEAR ON THE BALLOT TO DO
01:26:23.978 --> 01:26:25.647
THE EXACT SAME THING. WE ARE
01:26:25.713 --> 01:26:28.716
FIRMLY IN SUPPORT OF A CH THREE
01:26:28.783 --> 01:26:30.385
AND MUCH LOVE TO THE ORGANIZED
01:26:30.451 --> 01:26:32.487
BEHIND YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU,
01:26:32.554 --> 01:26:41.563
SIR. NEXT, PLEASE. MR MODERATOR
01:26:41.629 --> 01:26:45.533
. NEXT 75. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:26:45.600 --> 01:26:47.135
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
01:26:47.201 --> 01:26:48.069
STEPHANIE JEFF CALLING ON BEHALF
01:26:48.136 --> 01:26:53.675
OF ALL OF US, AND THEN. THANK
01:26:53.741 --> 01:27:03.084
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 40.
01:27:03.151 --> 01:27:10.558
FIND 1 40 YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:27:10.625 --> 01:27:19.534
WE'LL MOVE ON TO LINE 97. LINE.
01:27:19.601 --> 01:27:28.943
97 GO AHEAD, PLEASE. ONCE YOU
01:27:29.010 --> 01:27:30.878
GET IN LINE, 97, YOUR LINE IS
01:27:30.945 --> 01:27:32.647
OPEN. WE CAN HEAR YOU. GOOD
01:27:32.714 --> 01:27:33.748
MORNING. IS THAT ME? IS YOU
01:27:33.815 --> 01:27:37.819
PLEASE PROCEED. OH THANK YOU.
01:27:37.885 --> 01:27:39.153
THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME
01:27:39.220 --> 01:27:40.822
IS KATIE. I'M CALLING ON BEHALF
01:27:40.888 --> 01:27:43.157
FOR ALL OF US OR NONE OF THE 40
01:27:43.224 --> 01:27:44.959
. 88. 3 THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK
01:27:45.026 --> 01:27:51.299
YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. LIKE LINE 87.
01:27:51.366 --> 01:27:53.201
GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING,
01:27:53.267 --> 01:27:55.303
CHAIR MEMBERS, WITNESSES AND
01:27:55.370 --> 01:27:56.838
FELLOW CALLERS. I AM RATIO.
01:27:56.904 --> 01:27:58.673
PLUNKETT IS DIAMOND BAR AND I'M
01:27:58.740 --> 01:28:00.208
CALLING HIM SUPPORT OF REJECT
01:28:00.274 --> 01:28:01.342
THE COALITION FOR JUST AND
01:28:01.409 --> 01:28:04.045
EQUITABLE CALIFORNIA. I AM
01:28:04.112 --> 01:28:07.048
URGING YOUR YES. VOTE ON A C
01:28:07.115 --> 01:28:08.816
THREE. PLEASE END INVOLUNTARY
01:28:08.883 --> 01:28:10.218
SERVITUDE IN CALIFORNIA. THANK
01:28:10.284 --> 01:28:12.086
YOU TO SENATOR KAMLAGER
01:28:12.153 --> 01:28:13.254
PARTICULAR. THANK YOU TO THE
01:28:13.321 --> 01:28:14.422
BROWNS FOR YOUR POWERFUL
01:28:14.489 --> 01:28:15.490
TESTIMONY, PEACE AND BLESSINGS.
01:28:15.556 --> 01:28:16.658
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT,
01:28:16.724 --> 01:28:23.598
PLEASE. LINE 1 50. OKAY HELLO.
01:28:23.665 --> 01:28:26.000
MY NAME IS ALEXIAMOYER. I'M
01:28:26.067 --> 01:28:26.734
CALLING ON BEHALF OF LEGAL
01:28:26.801 --> 01:28:28.536
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS OF
01:28:28.603 --> 01:28:29.637
CHILDREN AND I'M CALLING HIM
01:28:29.704 --> 01:28:30.805
STRONG SUPPORT OF FREE. THANK
01:28:30.872 --> 01:28:32.907
YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE.
01:28:32.974 --> 01:28:41.049
LINE 60. GOOD MORNING SHARE AND
01:28:41.115 --> 01:28:42.483
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
01:28:42.550 --> 01:28:44.719
CHRISTINE AWAY AND WHAT YOU'RE
01:28:44.786 --> 01:28:46.988
SEEING COALITION. WE'RE TOAST,
01:28:47.055 --> 01:28:50.224
SPONSORS THREE AND CALLING IN
01:28:50.291 --> 01:28:51.159
THE STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:28:51.225 --> 01:28:53.594
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1
01:28:53.661 --> 01:28:59.967
56. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
01:29:00.034 --> 01:29:01.002
ANGEL RICE AND I'M CALLING ON
01:29:01.069 --> 01:29:02.503
BEHALF OF EMPOWERING WOMEN
01:29:02.570 --> 01:29:04.005
IMPACTED BY INCARCERATION IN
01:29:04.072 --> 01:29:05.273
STRONG SUPPORT OF THREE THANK
01:29:05.339 --> 01:29:12.447
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LION 1 60.
01:29:12.513 --> 01:29:15.850
HELLO MY NAME IS NOAH SANCHEZ SR
01:29:15.917 --> 01:29:17.719
JESUIT HIGH SCHOOL AND I'M
01:29:17.785 --> 01:29:18.786
CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF HD
01:29:18.853 --> 01:29:21.189
83. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT,
01:29:21.255 --> 01:29:29.530
PLEASE. LINE 1 61. HELLO MY NAME
01:29:29.597 --> 01:29:31.299
IS JASMINE GARCIA CALLING ON
01:29:31.365 --> 01:29:34.001
BEHALF OF L S P. C RIVERSIDE,
01:29:34.068 --> 01:29:36.504
ALL OF US OR NONE. ABC IN STRONG
01:29:36.571 --> 01:29:39.006
SUPPORT OF DAY THREE. THANK YOU.
01:29:39.073 --> 01:29:41.209
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LEIDEN,
01:29:41.275 --> 01:29:47.448
1 67. HI MY NAME IS SANDRA
01:29:47.515 --> 01:29:48.649
ORTIZ. UM I MEAN, EMPLOYED WITH
01:29:48.716 --> 01:29:50.218
LEGAL SERVICES FOR PRISONERS
01:29:50.284 --> 01:29:51.152
WITH CHILDREN IN THE CHAPTER
01:29:51.219 --> 01:29:52.653
ORGANIZED WITH THE SACRAMENT,
01:29:52.720 --> 01:29:55.323
ALL OF US NONE AND ON BEHALF OF
01:29:55.389 --> 01:29:56.390
ALL THE SLAVES INSIDE THE
01:29:56.457 --> 01:29:58.526
INSTITUTION. RETIRED RESPECT
01:29:58.593 --> 01:30:01.095
MYSELF AND ON BEHALF OF ALL MY
01:30:01.162 --> 01:30:02.029
ELDERS, THEY'VE BEEN TALKING
01:30:02.096 --> 01:30:04.799
ABOUT THIS 1003 STRONG SUPPORT
01:30:04.866 --> 01:30:06.367
OF 88 3. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:30:06.434 --> 01:30:10.605
NEXT, PLEASE. MR CHAIR. WE HAVE
01:30:10.671 --> 01:30:12.073
NORTH. FURTHER LINES IN QUÊ
01:30:12.140 --> 01:30:17.945
APPRECIATE THAT. LET US NOW COME
01:30:18.012 --> 01:30:18.880
ROOM. THANKS FOR EVERYBODY WHO
01:30:18.946 --> 01:30:21.015
DID CALL IN IS ANYBODY HERE IN
01:30:21.082 --> 01:30:22.717
OPPOSITION TO SEE A THREE AND
01:30:22.784 --> 01:30:25.286
LIKE TO SPEAK IN PERSON.SEEING
01:30:25.353 --> 01:30:27.488
NONE. MISS MODERATOR, IF YOU
01:30:27.555 --> 01:30:28.956
COULD PLEASE PULL THE TELECOMS
01:30:29.023 --> 01:30:30.992
FOR ANYBODY WHO WISHES TO SPEAK
01:30:31.058 --> 01:30:34.295
IN OPPOSITION TO A C A THREE.
01:30:34.362 --> 01:30:35.429
SPEAKING OPPOSITION, PLEASE
01:30:35.496 --> 01:30:37.098
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS
01:30:37.165 --> 01:30:45.873
TIME. WILL OPEN LINE 29. LINE 29
01:30:45.940 --> 01:30:47.809
HAS DROPPED OUT. WE DO HAVE A
01:30:47.875 --> 01:30:49.911
COUPLE LINES QUEUING UP. FOR ONE
01:30:49.977 --> 01:30:51.813
MOMENT LINE. 29 HAS RICK YOU'D
01:30:51.879 --> 01:30:55.116
GO AHEAD, PLEASE. DID MORNING.
01:30:55.183 --> 01:30:57.351
MY NAME IS GILANI SHADE FROM THE
01:30:57.418 --> 01:30:58.953
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL
01:30:59.020 --> 01:31:01.722
WORK CALIFORNIA CHAPTER AND I'M
01:31:01.789 --> 01:31:02.990
CALLING IN STRENGTH. SUPPORT OF
01:31:03.057 --> 01:31:05.693
ISSUE THREE. ALL RIGHT. THANK
01:31:05.760 --> 01:31:07.662
YOU. OKAY MISS MODERATOR, PLEASE
01:31:07.728 --> 01:31:11.199
PURSUED. WE'LL GO NEXT TO LINE 1
01:31:11.265 --> 01:31:16.437
28. UH, MY NAME IS WILLIAM
01:31:16.504 --> 01:31:19.941
PALMER. I THINK THE BPH TO THE
01:31:20.007 --> 01:31:21.375
CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT AND
01:31:21.442 --> 01:31:23.077
EVERY FARMER ON CONSTITUTION
01:31:23.144 --> 01:31:24.478
ACCEPTED PUNISHMENT TO GIVE
01:31:24.545 --> 01:31:25.913
YOUTH OFFENDERS HEARING FOR
01:31:25.980 --> 01:31:27.048
FREEDOM. I'M CALLING ON BEHALF
01:31:27.114 --> 01:31:29.817
OF LIFE AFTER THAT. AND
01:31:29.884 --> 01:31:31.185
DIFFICULT QUESTION IN STRONG
01:31:31.252 --> 01:31:33.521
SUPPORT OF A C A THREE. I WAS
01:31:33.588 --> 01:31:35.690
TAKEN OUT OF THE Q FOUR SUPPORT
01:31:35.756 --> 01:31:37.592
AND MANY OF MY OTHER FOLLOWERS
01:31:37.658 --> 01:31:39.493
THAT THAT IS ON THIS CALL, SO I
01:31:39.560 --> 01:31:40.728
HOPE YOU GIVE THEM ANOTHER
01:31:40.795 --> 01:31:43.064
CHANCE. AGAIN MY NAME IS WILLIAM
01:31:43.130 --> 01:31:43.831
PALMER OF LIFE AFTER MEXICAN
01:31:43.898 --> 01:31:46.167
EXODUS COALITION WE WE'VE BEEN
01:31:46.234 --> 01:31:48.035
STRUGGLING FOR 31 YEARS OVER 31
01:31:48.102 --> 01:31:49.871
YEARS BEING SLAVERY, AT LEAST
01:31:49.937 --> 01:31:51.439
ARE USED OFFENDERS, PLEASE AND
01:31:51.505 --> 01:31:52.907
SUPPORT ABOUT CHILDREN. THANK
01:31:52.974 --> 01:31:54.809
YOU. THANK YOU, MR GRAVERT. I'M
01:31:54.876 --> 01:31:56.777
SORRY ABOUT ANY INCONVENIENCE IF
01:31:56.844 --> 01:31:58.045
YOU FELL OUT OF THE QUEUE NEXT,
01:31:58.112 --> 01:32:04.852
PLEASE. 1 58. GOOD MORNING. MY
01:32:04.919 --> 01:32:07.688
NAME IS KEITH WATTS. I APOLOGIZE
01:32:07.755 --> 01:32:09.557
FOR NOT GETTING IN LINE EARLIER,
01:32:09.624 --> 01:32:11.325
BUT I'M THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
01:32:11.392 --> 01:32:14.028
OF UN COMMON LAW CALL IN STRONG
01:32:14.095 --> 01:32:17.298
pSUPPORT OF SENATOR KAMLAGER.
01:32:17.365 --> 01:32:20.301
DORSEY JAMELIA, SAM AND A C A
01:32:20.368 --> 01:32:21.569
THREE. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
01:32:21.636 --> 01:32:24.505
THANK YOU. I WE WERE HOPING TO
01:32:24.572 --> 01:32:27.041
HEAR FROM OPPOSITION. BUT MISS
01:32:27.108 --> 01:32:28.776
MODERATOR, IF WE CAN PLEASE,
01:32:28.843 --> 01:32:29.911
LET'S JUST CLEAR THE Q ONE OR
01:32:29.977 --> 01:32:34.515
THE OTHER. GO AHEAD. ANYBODY ON
01:32:34.582 --> 01:32:39.186
THE LINE. WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
01:32:39.253 --> 01:32:44.292
YES. GOOD 1 47 GO AHEAD, PLEASE.
01:32:44.358 --> 01:32:46.427
AMONG THE CALLING OUT OF
01:32:46.494 --> 01:32:49.297
SACRAMENTO, UM, COMMUNITY
01:32:49.363 --> 01:32:51.766
ADVOCATE AND, UH, ALSO FORMERLY
01:32:51.832 --> 01:32:53.401
INCARCERATED. I'M STRONGLY
01:32:53.467 --> 01:32:56.437
SUPPORTED THREE. THANK YOU FOR
01:32:56.504 --> 01:32:58.372
YOUR CIVIC DUTIES AND MAKING OUR
01:32:58.439 --> 01:32:59.473
COMMUNITY A BETTER PLACE TO
01:32:59.540 --> 01:33:03.144
LIVE. IN ABOLISHED. THANK YOU.
01:33:03.210 --> 01:33:05.780
BYE THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE.
01:33:05.846 --> 01:33:13.421
LINE 1 54. HI THIS IS KARI.
01:33:13.487 --> 01:33:15.957
SYSTEM IMPACTED, CALLING THEM
01:33:16.023 --> 01:33:18.125
STRONG SUPPORT OF A C THREE AND
01:33:18.192 --> 01:33:19.193
THE FAMILY STATEWIDE OF
01:33:19.260 --> 01:33:20.962
CALIFORNIA AND BEHALF OF HIGH
01:33:21.028 --> 01:33:22.063
DESERT FAMILIES AS WELL. THANK
01:33:22.129 --> 01:33:24.732
YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU
01:33:24.799 --> 01:33:32.506
NEXT, PLEASE. LION ONCE 1 53 GO
01:33:32.573 --> 01:33:39.447
AHEAD. HI CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES.
01:33:39.513 --> 01:33:41.949
MY NAME IS SANDRA JOHNSON AND I
01:33:42.016 --> 01:33:44.285
AM CALLING ON BEHALF OF LEGAL
01:33:44.352 --> 01:33:46.954
AID AT WORK AND ALL OF A SUDDEN
01:33:47.021 --> 01:33:48.823
NONE AND I'M IN STRONG AND WE
01:33:48.889 --> 01:33:50.624
ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A C
01:33:50.691 --> 01:33:53.127
THREE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:33:53.194 --> 01:33:55.096
THANK YOU FOR CALLING. MR
01:33:55.162 --> 01:33:57.164
MODERATE. HOW MANY COLLEGE WE
01:33:57.231 --> 01:33:58.165
STILL HAVE IN THE QUEUE? I
01:33:58.232 --> 01:33:59.333
SUSPECT THEY ARE PREDOMINANTLY
01:33:59.400 --> 01:34:01.936
SUPPORT. FOUR MORE LINES, SIR.
01:34:02.003 --> 01:34:03.671
ALRIGHT, LET'S PROCEED. LINE 1
01:34:03.738 --> 01:34:09.944
17. HI MY NAME IS IVANA
01:34:10.011 --> 01:34:11.445
GONZALEZ. I AM CALLING ON BEHALF
01:34:11.512 --> 01:34:12.947
OF LEGAL SERVICES REPRESENTS
01:34:13.014 --> 01:34:15.449
WITH CHILDREN, MR. NONE AND THE
01:34:15.516 --> 01:34:16.517
COALITION FOR FAMILY UNITY IN
01:34:16.584 --> 01:34:17.785
STRONG SUPPORT OF ENDING SLAVERY
01:34:17.852 --> 01:34:19.220
IN CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU. THANK
01:34:19.286 --> 01:34:25.159
YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1 64.
01:34:25.226 --> 01:34:28.295
HELLO. MY NAME IS JEAN MOSES.
01:34:28.362 --> 01:34:30.064
AND CALLING AS A MEMBER OF FAITH
01:34:30.131 --> 01:34:32.466
AND ACTION, EAST BAY AND
01:34:32.533 --> 01:34:34.568
CALIFORNIA TO EXPRESS MY STRONG
01:34:34.635 --> 01:34:37.538
SUPPORT FOR A THREE THANK YOU.
01:34:37.605 --> 01:34:39.306
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1
01:34:39.373 --> 01:34:46.180
57. PIPING HEAR ME? YES, PLEASE
01:34:46.247 --> 01:34:49.550
PURSUED. HI MY NAME IS JAN
01:34:49.617 --> 01:34:52.586
WILLIAMS. I'M CALLING WITH, UM,
01:34:52.653 --> 01:34:54.989
WITH THE ORGANIZATION NATIONAL
01:34:55.056 --> 01:34:56.524
ASSEMBLY FOR AMERICAN SLAVE
01:34:56.590 --> 01:34:58.059
DESCENDANTS OF LOS ANGELES AND
01:34:58.125 --> 01:35:02.296
CALIFORNIA. FOR JUST. ECONOMIC
01:35:02.363 --> 01:35:04.298
CALIFORNIA AND I'M CALLING IT
01:35:04.365 --> 01:35:06.233
STRONG SUPPORT OF A C A THREE.
01:35:06.300 --> 01:35:08.936
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. LINE 1
01:35:09.003 --> 01:35:15.076
73. HI MY NAME IS RANDY CARTER
01:35:15.142 --> 01:35:16.310
AND I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:35:16.377 --> 01:35:19.180
LIFE AFTER NEXT AND EXODUS
01:35:19.246 --> 01:35:21.215
COALITION AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:35:21.282 --> 01:35:23.751
THREE THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR
01:35:23.818 --> 01:35:25.619
MATTER. IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE ON
01:35:25.686 --> 01:35:29.557
THE LINE? WE HAVE ONE LINE
01:35:29.623 --> 01:35:31.525
QUEUING UP. WE HAVE TO PROVIDE
01:35:31.592 --> 01:35:32.593
THEM THEIR LINE NUMBER ONE
01:35:32.660 --> 01:35:49.410
MOMENT, PLEASE.
01:35:57.351 --> 01:36:03.290
PLANE. FIND 1 63 GO AHEAD.
01:36:03.357 --> 01:36:12.566
ALONE. LOAN 1 63 REMOVE
01:36:12.633 --> 01:36:13.667
THEMSELVES FROM QUÊ. LET'S TAKE
01:36:13.734 --> 01:36:18.305
LINE 1 79. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME
01:36:18.372 --> 01:36:19.874
IS ANGELIQUE. I'M PROUD CO
01:36:19.940 --> 01:36:21.442
FOUNDING MEMBER OF THE WARRIOR
01:36:21.509 --> 01:36:23.577
FRAME COALITION, AND WE ARE AS
01:36:23.644 --> 01:36:25.246
WRONG SUPPORTERS AS A C A THREE
01:36:25.312 --> 01:36:27.548
AND SEXUALLY ASKED, I VOTE THEIR
01:36:27.615 --> 01:36:28.782
JOB GODPARENTS AND SAMUEL. THANK
01:36:28.849 --> 01:36:32.386
YOU. THANK YOU, MR MODERATE. IS
01:36:32.453 --> 01:36:33.754
THERE ANYBODY ELSE YOU'D LIKE TO
01:36:33.821 --> 01:36:35.022
SPEAK ON THE ISSUE? THREE MORE
01:36:35.089 --> 01:36:38.626
LINES. 1 63 IS RICK. YOU'D GO
01:36:38.692 --> 01:36:42.129
AHEAD, PLEASE. HELLO MY NAME IS
01:36:42.196 --> 01:36:44.098
MARIA RIOSGARCIA, WITH
01:36:44.165 --> 01:36:45.799
ORGANIZATION CALLING IN STRONG
01:36:45.866 --> 01:36:46.934
SUPPORT OF 88. 3. THANK YOU.
01:36:47.001 --> 01:36:52.806
THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE 1 74. HI
01:36:52.873 --> 01:36:54.808
MY NAME IS SHERRY PALMER AND I'M
01:36:54.875 --> 01:36:56.710
CALLING ON BEHALF OF LIFE AFTER
01:36:56.777 --> 01:36:59.480
NET. AND UM, AFTER THIS
01:36:59.547 --> 01:37:02.316
COALITION, I'M IN STRONG SUPPORT
01:37:02.383 --> 01:37:05.386
OF THE A THREE AND ALSO FOR
01:37:05.452 --> 01:37:06.287
PERSONAL SUPPORT OF WILLIAM
01:37:06.353 --> 01:37:09.290
PALMER ON BEHALF OF THE YOUTH.
01:37:09.356 --> 01:37:11.258
THANK YOU SO MUCH, AND GOD BLESS
01:37:11.325 --> 01:37:12.393
YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT,
01:37:12.459 --> 01:37:16.997
PLEASE. LINE 1 80. HELLO I'M
01:37:17.064 --> 01:37:18.299
SERIOUS. ROTONDO, CALLING FROM
01:37:18.365 --> 01:37:24.572
UM. BERKELEY UNIVERSITY STUDENT
01:37:24.638 --> 01:37:25.839
HERE AND IN STRONG SUPPORT OF 88
01:37:25.906 --> 01:37:31.645
3. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR. IS
01:37:31.712 --> 01:37:37.351
ANYBODY ELSE IS 68. MY NAME'S
01:37:37.418 --> 01:37:40.821
JOSE MOTOR FORMALLY APPROACHED.
01:37:40.888 --> 01:37:45.793
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, SIR. WE
01:37:45.859 --> 01:37:47.795
HAVE NO FURTHER LINES IN CUBA.
01:37:47.861 --> 01:37:49.563
THAT SEEMS HARD TO BELIEVE. SO
01:37:49.630 --> 01:37:50.998
THANK YOU. AND AGAIN. THANK YOU.
01:37:51.065 --> 01:37:52.333
EVERYBODY CALLING IT SORRY IF
01:37:52.399 --> 01:37:53.968
THEY WERE ANY CHALLENGES GETTING
01:37:54.034 --> 01:37:55.970
IN FOR SUPPORT, SO LET US TRY
01:37:56.036 --> 01:37:58.372
ONE MORE TIME TO PULL THE LINE
01:37:58.439 --> 01:37:59.306
TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY WHO'D
01:37:59.373 --> 01:38:01.175
LIKE TO SPEAK ONLY IN OPPOSITION
01:38:01.242 --> 01:38:02.243
IN OPPOSITION TO ACTUALLY A
01:38:02.309 --> 01:38:04.111
THREE. I THINK THE SUPPORTERS
01:38:04.178 --> 01:38:05.045
HAVE BEEN FAIRLY WELL
01:38:05.112 --> 01:38:05.746
REPRESENTED. ANYBODY IN
01:38:05.813 --> 01:38:10.618
OPPOSITION. TO SPEAK IN
01:38:10.684 --> 01:38:12.453
OPPOSITION PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO
01:38:12.519 --> 01:38:19.760
AT THIS TIME. MR CHAIRMAN, WE
01:38:19.827 --> 01:38:21.962
HAVE NO LINES QUEUING. I
01:38:22.029 --> 01:38:22.596
APPRECIATE THAT. APPRECIATE YOUR
01:38:22.663 --> 01:38:24.231
WORK. LET US BRING IT BACK TO
01:38:24.298 --> 01:38:26.500
THE COMMITTEE. SENATOR LAILA.
01:38:26.567 --> 01:38:27.968
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, SENATOR
01:38:28.035 --> 01:38:30.204
KAMLAGER. I JUST WANT TO THANK
01:38:30.271 --> 01:38:31.572
YOU VERY MUCH FOR BRINGING THIS
01:38:31.639 --> 01:38:33.907
FORWARD AND IT'S A SMALL STEP IN
01:38:33.974 --> 01:38:36.810
THE RIGHT DIRECTION. INTO THE
01:38:36.877 --> 01:38:38.379
BROWN FAMILY. I JUST WANT TO SAY
01:38:38.445 --> 01:38:39.880
THANK YOU FOR YOUR COURAGE AND
01:38:39.947 --> 01:38:42.316
YOUR TENACITY. I REPRESENT CHINO
01:38:42.383 --> 01:38:43.784
MEN'S PRISON AND SHEENA WOMEN'S
01:38:43.851 --> 01:38:45.386
PRISON, SO I AM FAMILIAR WITH
01:38:45.452 --> 01:38:47.221
SOME OF THE BS THAT GOES ON IN
01:38:47.288 --> 01:38:48.756
THERE. SO AGAIN. THANK YOU FOR
01:38:48.822 --> 01:38:50.557
YOUR COURAGE AND YOUR TENACITY.
01:38:50.624 --> 01:38:52.593
I KNOW THAT IT HAS NOT BEEN EASY
01:38:52.660 --> 01:38:54.094
, BUT WHAT YOU'RE DOING AND WHAT
01:38:54.161 --> 01:38:55.596
YOU'RE DOING TODAY IS GOING TO
01:38:55.663 --> 01:38:57.531
MAKE A DIFFERENCE IN LIVES ALL
01:38:57.598 --> 01:38:58.632
ACROSS CALIFORNIA AND ACROSS THE
01:38:58.699 --> 01:39:01.068
COUNTRY. SO THANK YOU. I WOULD
01:39:01.135 --> 01:39:04.071
LIKE TO MOVE THE MOVE A CIA
01:39:04.138 --> 01:39:05.806
THREE WHEN IT IS APPROPRIATE, MR
01:39:05.873 --> 01:39:06.807
. CHAIR THANK YOU, SENATOR
01:39:06.874 --> 01:39:09.877
LEVITT ANYBODY ELSE? SO IT'S SO
01:39:09.943 --> 01:39:11.945
I WANT ALSO COMMEND THE BROWNS
01:39:12.012 --> 01:39:13.547
FOR BEING HERE. SO THANK YOU.
01:39:13.614 --> 01:39:14.948
THANK YOU. VERY VERY POWERFUL
01:39:15.015 --> 01:39:17.318
TESTIMONY. SO I'M ONLY THE
01:39:17.384 --> 01:39:18.385
STANDING CHAIR TODAY. SO I'M
01:39:18.452 --> 01:39:20.354
SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF SOME OF
01:39:20.421 --> 01:39:24.658
THE UM. CONSTITUENCIES THAT
01:39:24.725 --> 01:39:26.927
ACTUALLY DO HAVE CONCERN SENATOR
01:39:26.994 --> 01:39:29.129
KAMLAGER SPECIFICALLY ABOUT THE
01:39:29.196 --> 01:39:31.231
FUTURE OF WORK WITHIN THE
01:39:31.298 --> 01:39:32.866
CORRECTIONAL SYSTEM. RIGHT SO
01:39:32.933 --> 01:39:34.001
STIPULATING THAT YOU KNOW THIS
01:39:34.068 --> 01:39:36.970
IS A VERY WORTHY EFFORT. HOW HOW
01:39:37.037 --> 01:39:38.138
? WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS? HOW
01:39:38.205 --> 01:39:42.142
DOES THIS AFFECT THE ROLE OR THE
01:39:42.209 --> 01:39:44.945
PLACE OF WORK AND EMPLOYMENT
01:39:45.012 --> 01:39:46.513
WITHIN THE CORRECTIONAL SYSTEM
01:39:46.580 --> 01:39:47.448
IS PART OF SOMEBODY'S
01:39:47.514 --> 01:39:50.351
REHABILITATIVE PROCESS. AND I
01:39:50.417 --> 01:39:51.852
WANT TO THANK YOU FOR THE
01:39:51.919 --> 01:39:53.287
QUESTION BECAUSE IT IS SOMETHING
01:39:53.354 --> 01:39:56.056
THAT COMES UP QUITE REGULARLY.
01:39:56.123 --> 01:39:59.059
UM FIRST, IT IS IMPORTANT TO
01:39:59.126 --> 01:40:01.462
RESTATE THAT THE CONSTITUTION IS
01:40:01.528 --> 01:40:03.664
A VALUES DOCUMENT. IT IS NOT A
01:40:03.731 --> 01:40:05.999
POLICY DOCUMENT. THE LEGISLATURE
01:40:06.066 --> 01:40:09.803
IS THE ONE THAT CRAFTS IN WORKS
01:40:09.870 --> 01:40:11.438
TO ENSURE APPROPRIATE
01:40:11.505 --> 01:40:14.641
OPERATIONAL IZING OF POLICY. AND
01:40:14.708 --> 01:40:15.843
SO THIS IS A STATEMENT OF
01:40:15.909 --> 01:40:21.048
VALUES. FOR OUR CONSTITUTION AS
01:40:21.115 --> 01:40:22.282
IT RELATES TO BOTH SLAVERY AND
01:40:22.349 --> 01:40:25.052
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE. WITH
01:40:25.119 --> 01:40:26.754
REGARDS TO WORK IN OUR CAR,
01:40:26.820 --> 01:40:32.025
SEVERAL SETTINGS. I ALSO WANT TO
01:40:32.092 --> 01:40:36.463
STATE THAT INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE
01:40:36.530 --> 01:40:38.565
IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU ARE
01:40:38.632 --> 01:40:40.968
FORCED TO WORK. AND WHEN YOU ARE
01:40:41.034 --> 01:40:43.971
WHEN THAT IS ENFORCED BY THE USE
01:40:44.037 --> 01:40:46.373
OR THREATENED USE OF PHYSICAL OR
01:40:46.440 --> 01:40:50.544
LEGAL COERCION. SERVITUDE IS
01:40:50.611 --> 01:40:53.380
ABOUT WORKING OR INVOLVED IN
01:40:53.447 --> 01:40:55.849
SOME KIND OF LABOR THAT IS NOT
01:40:55.916 --> 01:40:58.085
REHABILITATIVE. AND AS WE
01:40:58.152 --> 01:41:01.221
CONTINUE TO TALK ABOUT WHAT CDCR
01:41:01.288 --> 01:41:03.357
SHOULD LOOK LIKE, AND REALLY,
01:41:03.424 --> 01:41:05.692
QUITE FRANKLY, HOW CAN A SHOULD
01:41:05.759 --> 01:41:09.496
OPERATE? IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE
01:41:09.563 --> 01:41:12.866
PUSH THESE AGENCIES. TO LOOK AT
01:41:12.933 --> 01:41:15.903
HOW YOU INCENTIVIZE WORK. OFTEN
01:41:15.969 --> 01:41:18.405
TIMES MANY FOLKS ARE WANTING ARE
01:41:18.472 --> 01:41:21.074
VOLUNTEERING FOR WORK. UM THEY
01:41:21.141 --> 01:41:22.342
WANT TO WORK. WE WANT FOLKS TO
01:41:22.409 --> 01:41:26.747
WORK. BUT THIS IS ABOUT NOT
01:41:26.814 --> 01:41:29.583
PUNISHING SOMEONE WHO MAY HAVE A
01:41:29.650 --> 01:41:32.553
LEGITIMATE REASON. MEDICAL
01:41:32.619 --> 01:41:36.190
ISSUES AND INJURY, A DESIRE TO
01:41:36.256 --> 01:41:39.326
LEARN A DIFFERENT KIND OF SKILL
01:41:39.393 --> 01:41:40.561
FROM BEING PUNISHED WITH
01:41:40.627 --> 01:41:40.994
VOLUNTEERS, SOLITARY
01:41:41.061 --> 01:41:46.433
CONFINEMENT. WITH THE REVOCATION
01:41:46.500 --> 01:41:48.302
OF PRIVILEGES SUCH AS FAMILY
01:41:48.368 --> 01:41:51.438
VISITATION, UH WITHOUT RETAIL,
01:41:51.505 --> 01:41:55.142
FEAR OF RETALIATION OR ABUSE AND
01:41:55.209 --> 01:41:56.343
WITHOUT THE TAKING AWAY OF GOOD
01:41:56.410 --> 01:42:00.547
CREDITS. AND WITHOUT THE LEVYING
01:42:00.614 --> 01:42:03.550
OF ADDITIONAL TIME ON SOMEONE'S
01:42:03.617 --> 01:42:05.986
SENTENCE. AND SO THAT IS REALLY
01:42:06.053 --> 01:42:08.555
WHAT IS AT THE HEART. IT IS NOT
01:42:08.622 --> 01:42:12.259
ABOUT PEOPLE. INCARCERATED FOLKS
01:42:12.326 --> 01:42:13.460
WAKING UP AND SAYING, I'M NOT
01:42:13.527 --> 01:42:16.930
GOING TO WORK. IT IS ABOUT HOW
01:42:16.997 --> 01:42:19.433
YOU LOOK AT THE DEFINITION OF
01:42:19.500 --> 01:42:22.469
WORK. HOW YOU ASSIGN WORK. HOW
01:42:22.536 --> 01:42:26.940
YOU INCENTIVIZE HOW YOU HUMANIZE
01:42:27.007 --> 01:42:29.009
THE PROCESS OF WORKING AND
01:42:29.076 --> 01:42:31.445
POSSIBLY EVEN WHAT CORRECTIVE
01:42:31.512 --> 01:42:33.247
ACTION. LOOKS LIKE. WE CERTAINLY
01:42:33.313 --> 01:42:36.383
DON'T WHIP PEOPLE. OR TAKE AWAY
01:42:36.450 --> 01:42:38.452
THEIR RIGHTS IF THEY'RE NOT
01:42:38.519 --> 01:42:40.721
INTERESTED IN DOING A WORK OR A
01:42:40.787 --> 01:42:43.790
PARTICULAR DUTY ON THE OUTSIDE.
01:42:43.857 --> 01:42:46.793
AND AT SOME POINT SYSTEMS HAVE
01:42:46.860 --> 01:42:49.630
TO DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE
01:42:49.696 --> 01:42:50.631
INCARCERATED PERSON AND THE
01:42:50.697 --> 01:42:53.800
WORKER. AND WHEN YOU ARE
01:42:53.867 --> 01:42:55.869
RETALIATING AGAINST THE
01:42:55.936 --> 01:42:58.372
INCARCERATED WORKER BECAUSE YOU
01:42:58.438 --> 01:43:01.375
HAVE THAT AUTHORITY AND POWER TO
01:43:01.441 --> 01:43:03.510
DO SO, THEN IT COMPLICATES YOUR
01:43:03.577 --> 01:43:07.180
ABILITY. TO REALLY HAVE A
01:43:07.247 --> 01:43:10.551
HUMANIZED WORKFORCE. AND
01:43:10.617 --> 01:43:13.387
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES THAT ARE
01:43:13.453 --> 01:43:17.357
IN THAT SPACE. SO AT THE END OF
01:43:17.424 --> 01:43:18.125
THE DAY, THIS IS ABOUT PUTTING
01:43:18.191 --> 01:43:20.427
SOMETHING ON THE BALLOT FOR
01:43:20.494 --> 01:43:22.429
VOTERS TO DECIDE. AND IF IT
01:43:22.496 --> 01:43:25.532
PASSES AND I HOPE IT DOES, THEN
01:43:25.599 --> 01:43:29.002
IT WOULD REQUIRE CDCR AND CAL P
01:43:29.069 --> 01:43:30.971
I A TO LOOK AT THOSE THINGS. BUT
01:43:31.038 --> 01:43:37.044
TODAY WE ARE TALKING ABOUT. HOW
01:43:37.110 --> 01:43:39.346
YOU TREAT PEOPLE AND TAKING
01:43:39.413 --> 01:43:44.151
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE. OUT OF
01:43:44.217 --> 01:43:45.452
OUR DOCUMENT OF VALUES FOR THE
01:43:45.519 --> 01:43:49.456
STATE. AND I APPRECIATE ALL
01:43:49.523 --> 01:43:50.591
THAT. SO HOW? HOW WOULD YOU
01:43:50.657 --> 01:43:53.594
RESPOND? TO THE ASSERTION THAT
01:43:53.660 --> 01:43:56.296
IT SHOULD BE POSSIBLE TO ADDRESS
01:43:56.363 --> 01:43:57.831
ISSUES AROUND RETALIATION AND
01:43:57.898 --> 01:43:59.466
ABUSE OF AUTHORITY WAS SOMETHING
01:43:59.533 --> 01:44:00.434
SHORT OF A CONSTITUTIONAL
01:44:00.500 --> 01:44:06.173
AMENDMENT. SO ONCE AGAIN, UM. I
01:44:06.239 --> 01:44:09.109
WOULD HOPE THAT THOSE KINDS OF
01:44:09.176 --> 01:44:13.447
DISCUSSIONS UM AND POLICY IDEAS
01:44:13.513 --> 01:44:14.948
WOULD FIND THEIR WAY TO OUR
01:44:15.015 --> 01:44:16.550
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEES WHERE
01:44:16.617 --> 01:44:17.951
WE COULD HAVE A DEEPER
01:44:18.018 --> 01:44:19.620
DISCUSSIONS WITH CDCR AND OTHER
01:44:19.686 --> 01:44:24.524
AGENCIES. UM. TO TALK ABOUT WHAT
01:44:24.591 --> 01:44:26.693
THAT COULD LOOK LIKE, UM, I DO
01:44:26.760 --> 01:44:28.395
THINK PERSONALLY, I THINK THERE
01:44:28.462 --> 01:44:30.397
IS A WAY TO INCENTIVIZE FOLKS TO
01:44:30.464 --> 01:44:32.232
WORK. I THINK THERE IS A WAY TO
01:44:32.299 --> 01:44:34.434
LOOK AT WHAT KINDS OF DUTIES YOU
01:44:34.501 --> 01:44:37.004
HAVE. IN YOUR VARIOUS PRISONS
01:44:37.070 --> 01:44:39.206
AND HOW TO HOLD FOLKS YOU KNOW,
01:44:39.272 --> 01:44:43.744
ACCOUNTABLE TO THE WORK. THAT I
01:44:43.810 --> 01:44:46.079
THINK IS QUITE DIFFERENT FROM
01:44:46.146 --> 01:44:48.448
PUNISHING PEOPLE AND TAKING AWAY
01:44:48.515 --> 01:44:49.983
THEIR CREDITS AND TAKING AWAY
01:44:50.050 --> 01:44:51.718
THE LIBERTIES THAT YOU STILL
01:44:51.785 --> 01:44:54.454
HAVE. EVEN WHILE YOU ARE
01:44:54.521 --> 01:44:56.923
INCARCERATED. WE KNOW THAT
01:44:56.990 --> 01:44:59.459
NEBRASKA. WE KNOW THAT UTAH WE
01:44:59.526 --> 01:45:02.062
KNOW THAT COLORADO HAVE ALL
01:45:02.129 --> 01:45:03.096
PASSED THESE KINDS OF
01:45:03.163 --> 01:45:07.934
AMENDMENTS. AND HAVE BEGUN TO
01:45:08.001 --> 01:45:10.537
REDESIGN SOME OF THE ASPECTS
01:45:10.604 --> 01:45:14.007
WITHIN THEIR PRISON SYSTEM TO
01:45:14.074 --> 01:45:16.410
MAKE SURE THAT FOLKS STILL HAVE
01:45:16.476 --> 01:45:17.711
THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK TO GET
01:45:17.778 --> 01:45:18.612
TRAINED TO LEARN SKILLS. TO
01:45:18.679 --> 01:45:23.617
REHABILITATE. SHOW APPRECIATE,
01:45:23.684 --> 01:45:25.452
SO IT'S SO IT'S YOUR POSITION
01:45:25.519 --> 01:45:26.553
THAT IT CONSTITUTIONAL IS
01:45:26.620 --> 01:45:28.955
REQUIRED TO INSTIGATE THAT
01:45:29.022 --> 01:45:30.424
CONVERSATION. THOSE THOSE, UM,
01:45:30.490 --> 01:45:34.961
SOLUTIONS AROUND I DO THINK
01:45:35.028 --> 01:45:36.530
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE, AND I
01:45:36.596 --> 01:45:38.065
THINK SLAVERY DESERVE TO BE
01:45:38.131 --> 01:45:41.568
ELEVATED. UM TO A DISCUSSION
01:45:41.635 --> 01:45:43.437
ABOUT OUR CONSTITUTION, BECAUSE,
01:45:43.503 --> 01:45:44.971
AS WE KNOW YOU CAN CREATE A
01:45:45.038 --> 01:45:47.174
POLICY THAT SAYS A WHOLE BUNCH
01:45:47.240 --> 01:45:48.575
OF THINGS AND THE NEXT SESSION
01:45:48.642 --> 01:45:50.777
YOU CAN CHIP AWAY AT IT. YOU CAN
01:45:50.844 --> 01:45:53.080
SHIP AWAY A IT. YOU CAN CHIP
01:45:53.146 --> 01:45:55.215
AWAY AT IT. AND IF THE LANDSCAPE
01:45:55.282 --> 01:45:57.617
OF THIS BODY WERE TO CHANGE,
01:45:57.684 --> 01:45:58.685
THEN THAT POLICY COULD
01:45:58.752 --> 01:45:59.720
POTENTIALLY CHANGE. AND I
01:45:59.786 --> 01:46:02.789
CERTAINLY BELIEVE THAT
01:46:02.856 --> 01:46:04.357
PROHIBITING SLAVERY AND
01:46:04.424 --> 01:46:06.693
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE ARE FAR
01:46:06.760 --> 01:46:07.828
MORE IMPORTANT THAN A POLICY
01:46:07.894 --> 01:46:11.164
BILL. APPRECIATE THAT. UH, MY
01:46:11.231 --> 01:46:12.165
COLLEAGUE, SENATOR, SENATOR
01:46:12.232 --> 01:46:17.471
NIELSEN. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR,
01:46:17.537 --> 01:46:18.538
AND THERE'S AN IMPORTANT
01:46:18.605 --> 01:46:19.606
DISTINCTION HERE, THOUGH, THAT
01:46:19.673 --> 01:46:22.943
HAS BEEN I'VE SEEN NO ONE FROM
01:46:23.009 --> 01:46:26.546
SEE SACK. HERE TESTIFYING. THIS
01:46:26.613 --> 01:46:32.352
HAS POTENTIAL HUGE BEARING. AND
01:46:32.419 --> 01:46:35.288
OUR COUNTY JAILS, COUNTY
01:46:35.355 --> 01:46:35.856
GOVERNMENT BUDGETS, THEY'RE
01:46:35.922 --> 01:46:39.559
ABSENT FROM THE HEARING. AND
01:46:39.626 --> 01:46:41.561
PROBABLY NOT SURPRISED THAT THEY
01:46:41.628 --> 01:46:43.497
ARE THEY LIKE TO DUCK A LOT OF
01:46:43.563 --> 01:46:44.598
THINGS. BUT THIS IS VERY
01:46:44.664 --> 01:46:46.333
IMPORTANT. AND VERY DEMANDING OF
01:46:46.399 --> 01:46:50.036
THEIR INPUT. THE IMPACT ON THOSE
01:46:50.103 --> 01:46:52.038
LOCAL INSTITUTIONS. WHAT WILL BE
01:46:52.105 --> 01:46:56.510
REQUIRED OF THEM. ONE OF THE
01:46:56.576 --> 01:46:58.311
THINGS THAT THEY HAVE ALREADY
01:46:58.378 --> 01:47:01.481
EXPERIENCED. WITH REALIGNMENT
01:47:01.548 --> 01:47:03.283
AND SOME OF THE CHANGES THAT
01:47:03.350 --> 01:47:04.284
HAVE BEEN AFFECTED. INMATE
01:47:04.351 --> 01:47:07.254
LAWSUITS. THAT HAD AFFLICTED
01:47:07.320 --> 01:47:11.191
CDCR. MARCHED OUT INTO THE
01:47:11.258 --> 01:47:14.928
COUNTY JAILS. AND ALREADY HAVE
01:47:14.995 --> 01:47:16.797
HAD SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON COUNTY
01:47:16.863 --> 01:47:19.633
BUDGETS. THAT AT LEAST NEEDS TO
01:47:19.699 --> 01:47:23.804
BE DISCUSSED. AND HAS TO BE MADE
01:47:23.870 --> 01:47:25.071
AWARE OF THAT HAS NOT HAPPENED
01:47:25.138 --> 01:47:31.211
HERE TODAY. FURTHER AN ISSUE. IS
01:47:31.278 --> 01:47:34.781
INSTITUTIONAL SECURITY. HOW DO
01:47:34.848 --> 01:47:35.916
YOU MAINTAIN INSTITUTIONAL
01:47:35.982 --> 01:47:39.519
SECURITY? THERE ARE WAYS TO DO
01:47:39.586 --> 01:47:41.388
IT. THERE ARE WAYS PROBABLY NOT
01:47:41.454 --> 01:47:43.323
TO DO IT. I THINK I'M REASONABLY
01:47:43.390 --> 01:47:46.226
FAMILIAR. WITH IT FROM MY
01:47:46.293 --> 01:47:49.196
HISTORY. IN FACT, I'VE WORKED
01:47:49.262 --> 01:47:50.664
VERY EXTENSIVELY WITH
01:47:50.730 --> 01:47:52.499
INDIVIDUALS WITHIN CDCR, AND
01:47:52.566 --> 01:47:54.534
I'VE PROBABLY BEEN ONE OF THE
01:47:54.601 --> 01:47:59.039
GREATEST CRITICS OUT MY CAREER.
01:47:59.105 --> 01:48:00.307
I'M IN THE BLACK CORRECTIONAL
01:48:00.373 --> 01:48:03.276
WORKERS HALL OF FAME. FOR MY
01:48:03.343 --> 01:48:04.311
WORK WITH BLACK CORRECTIONAL
01:48:04.377 --> 01:48:07.547
WORKERS. IN THE PLIGHT THAT THEY
01:48:07.614 --> 01:48:09.382
HAVE IN THEIR INSTITUTIONS. SO
01:48:09.449 --> 01:48:13.353
I'M NOT UNFAMILIAR. BUT KEEP IN
01:48:13.420 --> 01:48:15.155
MIND AS WE COME UP WITH NOBLE
01:48:15.222 --> 01:48:18.925
IDEAS AND NOBLE WORDS. WHAT DOES
01:48:18.992 --> 01:48:20.327
THAT ALSO MEAN FOR INSTITUTIONAL
01:48:20.393 --> 01:48:24.464
SECURITY FOR FREE STAFF? AS FAR
01:48:24.531 --> 01:48:25.699
AS THEIR WELL BEING IN THE
01:48:25.765 --> 01:48:28.602
INSTITUTION. OF MAINTAINING
01:48:28.668 --> 01:48:32.372
CONTROL OF THE INSTITUTION. IT
01:48:32.439 --> 01:48:33.139
WAS MENTIONED THE SECURED
01:48:33.206 --> 01:48:35.308
HOUSING UNITS. THOSE ARE NOT
01:48:35.375 --> 01:48:38.645
PLEASANT PLACES. BUT SOMETIMES
01:48:38.712 --> 01:48:39.412
THEY'RE EXTRAORDINARILY
01:48:39.479 --> 01:48:42.148
NECESSARY. AND IF WE'RE GOING TO
01:48:42.215 --> 01:48:46.486
GO ON A PATHWAY TO JUST TO
01:48:46.553 --> 01:48:47.821
ABOLISH A LOT OF THESE
01:48:47.888 --> 01:48:49.556
INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS TO
01:48:49.623 --> 01:48:53.994
MAINTAIN SECURITY. I FEAR WE'RE
01:48:54.060 --> 01:48:55.896
GOING TO BE DOWN A VERY SORRY
01:48:55.962 --> 01:48:59.366
PATH. SO MY QUESTION. MR
01:48:59.432 --> 01:49:00.500
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS IS JUST TO
01:49:00.567 --> 01:49:04.571
BE WARY. SENSITIVE. BUT ALSO
01:49:04.638 --> 01:49:05.605
WARY BECAUSE THERE ARE
01:49:05.672 --> 01:49:09.042
CONSEQUENCES. AND I WORK
01:49:09.109 --> 01:49:11.177
COMPLEMENT MR JONES BACK THERE.
01:49:11.244 --> 01:49:12.512
HE IS A TREMENDOUS EXAMPLE. IF
01:49:12.579 --> 01:49:15.649
SOMEBODY WHO GOT PROMISE YOU
01:49:15.715 --> 01:49:17.951
BROWN. EXCUSE ME, MR BROWN. MANY
01:49:18.018 --> 01:49:22.289
DO NOT. AND MR BROWN. IT'S BEEN
01:49:22.355 --> 01:49:26.026
MY EXPERIENCE. THAT IN THE PLANT
01:49:26.092 --> 01:49:29.296
PLIGHT OF MOST INCARCERATED
01:49:29.362 --> 01:49:33.533
THEY'RE CONSTANTS. BUT IT ALL
01:49:33.600 --> 01:49:38.104
STARTS WITH A BROKEN HEART. THE
01:49:38.171 --> 01:49:39.272
LACK OF NOURISHMENT AND LOVE AND
01:49:39.339 --> 01:49:43.877
SUPPORT. THAT YOUNG CHILD. FROM
01:49:43.944 --> 01:49:44.878
WHATEVER THE SYSTEM WAS
01:49:44.945 --> 01:49:49.049
PARTICULARLY THEIR PARENTS.
01:49:49.115 --> 01:49:50.684
THERE ARE MANY OCCASIONS WHEN I
01:49:50.750 --> 01:49:53.019
WOULD OPT TO PUT A PARENT IN
01:49:53.086 --> 01:49:55.055
CUSTODY. AND SEND THEIR CHILD
01:49:55.121 --> 01:49:59.225
HOME. IF THAT WAS POSSIBLE
01:49:59.292 --> 01:50:00.260
BECAUSE THEY WERE DIRECTLY
01:50:00.327 --> 01:50:04.431
RESPONSIBLE. AND OFTEN I HAVE
01:50:04.497 --> 01:50:06.166
WEPT IN MY HEART FOR THE CHILD.
01:50:06.232 --> 01:50:06.866
THESE INDIVIDUALS WERE THEY
01:50:06.933 --> 01:50:11.538
DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE. IN LIFE.
01:50:11.604 --> 01:50:15.475
THAT IS SO INCREDIBLY SAD.
01:50:15.542 --> 01:50:17.310
BETTER DOES THE JOB OF PARENTS
01:50:17.377 --> 01:50:19.646
TO DO ALSO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY?
01:50:19.713 --> 01:50:21.548
AND THE JOB OF SOCIETY AND THE
01:50:21.614 --> 01:50:24.751
LEGISLATURE. TO ENSURE THAT
01:50:24.818 --> 01:50:26.453
PARENTAL RESPONSIBILITY IS NOT
01:50:26.519 --> 01:50:28.755
UNDERMINED, AND QUITE OFTEN HERE
01:50:28.822 --> 01:50:30.590
IN THIS INSTITUTION, WE DO THAT
01:50:30.657 --> 01:50:31.758
VERY THING. JUST SOME THOUGHTS
01:50:31.825 --> 01:50:35.528
TO OFFER. IT'S A MERITORIOUS
01:50:35.595 --> 01:50:37.297
ARGUMENT. THERE'S MERIT IN THE
01:50:37.364 --> 01:50:41.101
BILL. BUT THERE ARE ALSO
01:50:41.167 --> 01:50:42.702
QUESTIONS AND LONG TERM
01:50:42.769 --> 01:50:43.803
CONSEQUENCES THAT HAVE TO BE
01:50:43.870 --> 01:50:47.807
ADDRESSED. AND I DO LOOK FORWARD
01:50:47.874 --> 01:50:49.376
TO SEE SACKS SPEAKING UP ON THIS
01:50:49.442 --> 01:50:51.211
MATTER OF GREAT IMPORTANCE TO
01:50:51.277 --> 01:50:55.382
THEM. THE THEY DON'T THINK THEY
01:50:55.448 --> 01:50:57.117
NEED TO COMMENT, THEN THEY
01:50:57.183 --> 01:50:58.618
BETTER COME FORWARD AND SAY THAT
01:50:58.685 --> 01:51:00.320
AND NOT COME TO THE LEGISLATURE
01:51:00.387 --> 01:51:02.322
AND ASK FOR HELP WHEN THEY GET
01:51:02.389 --> 01:51:04.257
INTO THE MESS THAT THEY'RE GOING
01:51:04.324 --> 01:51:06.259
TO GET INTO. THANK YOU, MR JOE.
01:51:06.326 --> 01:51:07.027
IN REHEARSAL. THANK YOU, MR
01:51:07.093 --> 01:51:12.465
CHAIRMAN. THE OTHERS, PROBABLY
01:51:12.532 --> 01:51:15.068
THE SHORTEST EVER READ. ALL OF
01:51:15.135 --> 01:51:17.337
MY TIME IN THIS BUSINESS. THE
01:51:17.404 --> 01:51:22.742
LAW SAID. THE LAW SAYS NOW IN
01:51:22.809 --> 01:51:24.711
THE STATE CONSTITUTION, SLAVERY
01:51:24.778 --> 01:51:27.814
IS PROHIBITED. THREE WORDS.
01:51:27.881 --> 01:51:30.550
INVOLUNTARY SERVICES. SERVITUDE
01:51:30.617 --> 01:51:31.718
IS PROHIBITED EXCEPT TO PUNISH
01:51:31.785 --> 01:51:33.153
CRIME PERIOD. THAT'S THE CURRENT
01:51:33.219 --> 01:51:36.923
CONSTITUTION. THE AMENDMENT
01:51:36.990 --> 01:51:39.793
SIMPLY SAYS SLAVERY AND
01:51:39.859 --> 01:51:42.062
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE ARE
01:51:42.128 --> 01:51:47.434
PROHIBITED 123456 WORDS. BUT IT
01:51:47.500 --> 01:51:48.568
IS INDEED WHEN YOU DRAFT
01:51:48.635 --> 01:51:52.138
CONSTITUTIONS. UM STATEMENT OF
01:51:52.205 --> 01:51:54.140
PRINCIPLES ABOUT WHO WE ARE AS A
01:51:54.207 --> 01:51:54.908
PEOPLE ABOUT WHAT WE ARE AS
01:51:54.974 --> 01:51:57.143
DEMOCRACY. PLACES OF A LOT OF
01:51:57.210 --> 01:52:01.047
WORDS AND THE 200. 77,000
01:52:01.114 --> 01:52:02.182
STATUTES OR SOMETHING THAT WE
01:52:02.248 --> 01:52:03.383
JUST HEARD ABOUT THIS WEEK THAT
01:52:03.450 --> 01:52:05.018
WE HAVE IN THE BOOKS. THAT'S FOR
01:52:05.085 --> 01:52:08.354
US AS ARTICULATED TO WORK OUT.
01:52:08.421 --> 01:52:09.823
UH, IT MIGHT NOT BE EASY. THERE
01:52:09.889 --> 01:52:11.524
MIGHT BE CHALLENGES. THERE MIGHT
01:52:11.591 --> 01:52:13.393
BE WAYS TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO
01:52:13.460 --> 01:52:14.060
MAKE IT HAPPEN. BUT THE QUESTION
01:52:14.127 --> 01:52:18.932
BEFORE US, I THINK. IS WHO ARE
01:52:18.998 --> 01:52:20.366
WE AS A PEOPLE IS OUR SOCIETAL
01:52:20.433 --> 01:52:24.437
VALUES. AND WILL IT BE
01:52:24.504 --> 01:52:26.573
DIFFICULT? MAYBE. I DON'T KNOW.
01:52:26.639 --> 01:52:28.575
WHO IS TO PARTICIPATE IN THAT
01:52:28.641 --> 01:52:31.010
PROCESS. I DON'T KNOW. BUT IT
01:52:31.077 --> 01:52:33.613
SURE SEEMS TO ME THAT THIS IS A
01:52:33.680 --> 01:52:35.482
STATEMENT OF VALUES THAT I
01:52:35.548 --> 01:52:36.649
SUPPORT AND WILL BE SUPPORTING
01:52:36.716 --> 01:52:38.818
THIS BILL. THE SIX WORDS THAT WE
01:52:38.885 --> 01:52:40.053
THINK WE NEED TO BRING BEFORE
01:52:40.120 --> 01:52:42.455
THE PEOPLE. TO BE ABLE TO MAKE
01:52:42.522 --> 01:52:44.057
THAT DETERMINATION. I SUSPECT
01:52:44.124 --> 01:52:45.325
YOU'RE GOING TO SEE OVERWHELMING
01:52:45.391 --> 01:52:47.127
SUPPORT BECAUSE IT IS AT THE
01:52:47.193 --> 01:52:51.297
CORE RAP RESOUNDING COMMON SENSE
01:52:51.364 --> 01:52:53.366
AND I THINK IS INFORMED BY THE
01:52:53.433 --> 01:52:54.801
CORE VALUES OF WHO WE ARE. AS
01:52:54.868 --> 01:52:56.269
AMERICANS. AND SO FOR THAT I
01:52:56.336 --> 01:52:57.637
WOULD BE HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE
01:52:57.704 --> 01:52:59.305
BILL TODAY AND I WOULD HAVE
01:52:59.372 --> 01:53:01.174
MOVED IT AND NOT SENATOR LEVER
01:53:01.241 --> 01:53:03.443
MOVED THE BILL. THANK YOU,
01:53:03.510 --> 01:53:04.978
SENATOR HERZBERG. SO, UM WITH
01:53:05.044 --> 01:53:07.947
THAT, SENATOR KAMLAGER. I'M SURE
01:53:08.014 --> 01:53:10.183
YOU WILL SPEAK TO THE ISSUE
01:53:10.250 --> 01:53:11.551
RAISED ABOUT THE ABSENCE OF
01:53:11.618 --> 01:53:12.819
SEASICK AND OTHER CONSTITUENCIES
01:53:12.886 --> 01:53:13.987
HERE. THIS BILL IS OBVIOUSLY
01:53:14.053 --> 01:53:16.189
BEEN IN PROCESS FOR A LONG TIME.
01:53:16.256 --> 01:53:17.323
IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE,
01:53:17.390 --> 01:53:19.392
PLEASE. WELL YOU KNOW, I AGREE.
01:53:19.459 --> 01:53:20.693
UM I WISH THEY WOULD HAVE COME
01:53:20.760 --> 01:53:23.329
TO THE TABLE TO, UM, BUT
01:53:23.396 --> 01:53:24.898
SOMETIMES THE TRUTH CAN MAKE YOU
01:53:24.964 --> 01:53:30.503
AFRAID. UM. AND MAYBE THESE ARE
01:53:30.570 --> 01:53:32.438
GROUPS THAT DON'T WANT TO HAVE
01:53:32.505 --> 01:53:37.277
DAYLIGHT SHINED ONTO WHAT IS
01:53:37.343 --> 01:53:38.545
REALLY GOING ON IN OUR CARCERANO
01:53:38.611 --> 01:53:42.081
SETTINGS? UM AND I WOULD
01:53:42.148 --> 01:53:43.950
CERTAINLY WELCOME SOMEONE COMING
01:53:44.017 --> 01:53:46.486
TO THE TABLE AND TRYING TO ARGUE
01:53:46.553 --> 01:53:49.756
TO ME AS TO WHY WE SHOULD KEEP
01:53:49.822 --> 01:53:50.657
INVOLUNTARY SERVITUDE ON THE
01:53:50.723 --> 01:53:53.259
BOOKS. I WANT TO KNOW ALL OF THE
01:53:53.326 --> 01:53:56.329
ARGUMENTS, UH, THAT YOU WOULD
01:53:56.396 --> 01:53:59.065
LOVE ME BEFORE ME TO SUPPORT
01:53:59.132 --> 01:54:01.534
KEEPING THIS ON THE BOOKS. I
01:54:01.601 --> 01:54:02.535
THINK SENATOR HERZBERG FOR
01:54:02.602 --> 01:54:06.406
SHARING HIS COMMENTS. AND ALSO
01:54:06.472 --> 01:54:07.707
FOR THE STATEMENTS YOU MADE
01:54:07.774 --> 01:54:09.709
SENATOR NIELSEN. UM I THINK THIS
01:54:09.776 --> 01:54:12.445
IS REALLY ABOUT ABOLISHING.
01:54:12.512 --> 01:54:14.814
CULTURE WITHIN OUR CAR SAROS
01:54:14.881 --> 01:54:16.149
CITY SETTINGS RATHER THAN
01:54:16.216 --> 01:54:20.787
ABOLISHING WORK. THERE MIGHT BE
01:54:20.853 --> 01:54:22.922
A NUMBER OF DISCUSSIONS THAT CAN
01:54:22.989 --> 01:54:24.457
BE HAD AROUND INSTITUTIONAL
01:54:24.524 --> 01:54:26.059
SECURITY. BUT ONCE AGAIN WE'RE
01:54:26.125 --> 01:54:26.926
TALKING ABOUT WORK. WE'RE
01:54:26.993 --> 01:54:30.463
TALKING ABOUT WORKERS WITHIN OUR
01:54:30.530 --> 01:54:31.397
CARS TO ROLL SETTINGS. WE ARE
01:54:31.464 --> 01:54:32.265
NOT TALKING ABOUT INCARCERATED
01:54:32.332 --> 01:54:35.935
PEOPLE LIVING. AND THE CULTURE
01:54:36.002 --> 01:54:38.938
AROUND SURVIVING AND LIVING
01:54:39.005 --> 01:54:40.907
WHILE INCARCERATED. TRULY THIS
01:54:40.974 --> 01:54:45.545
IS SPECIFIC. TO HOW PEOPLE ARE
01:54:45.612 --> 01:54:48.648
TREATED AS WORKERS WITHIN OUR
01:54:48.715 --> 01:54:50.783
CAR, SURREAL SETTINGS WHERE THEY
01:54:50.850 --> 01:54:53.319
ARE EARNING AS LITTLE AS EIGHT
01:54:53.386 --> 01:54:57.156
CENTS. AN HOUR. AND IF, FOR
01:54:57.223 --> 01:54:59.192
WHATEVER REASON, THEY ARE NOT
01:54:59.259 --> 01:55:01.661
INCLINED TO WORK BECAUSE THEY
01:55:01.728 --> 01:55:03.663
ARE SICK FOR HEALTH REASONS
01:55:03.730 --> 01:55:05.431
BECAUSE THEY ARE INTERESTED IN
01:55:05.498 --> 01:55:06.633
EARNINGS AND CREDITS DOING
01:55:06.699 --> 01:55:10.003
SOMEPLACE ELSE. THEY CAN BE
01:55:10.069 --> 01:55:12.438
PUNISHED AND RETALIATED AGAINST
01:55:12.505 --> 01:55:13.906
AND THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS CAN BE
01:55:13.973 --> 01:55:17.143
PUNISHED AND RETALIATED AGAINST.
01:55:17.210 --> 01:55:20.280
AND THIS IS ASKING US TO SHIFT
01:55:20.346 --> 01:55:21.781
THE PRINCIPLES OF THE
01:55:21.848 --> 01:55:23.750
CONSTITUTION AND OUR OWN
01:55:23.816 --> 01:55:24.917
NARRATIVE ABOUT OUR CAR, SURREAL
01:55:24.984 --> 01:55:28.454
SYSTEMS. AND TO LEAN INTO
01:55:28.521 --> 01:55:31.157
SOMETHING THAT IS MORE HUMANE
01:55:31.224 --> 01:55:33.293
AND CERTAINLY CLEAR ABOUT HOW WE
01:55:33.359 --> 01:55:34.761
SEE OUR FELLOW MEN AND WOMEN. SO
01:55:34.827 --> 01:55:39.299
WITH THAT. I ASK THAT YOU SEE
01:55:39.365 --> 01:55:40.600
THAT AS MY CLOTHES AND I
01:55:40.667 --> 01:55:42.135
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR THANK
01:55:42.201 --> 01:55:43.970
YOU WITH THAT. LET'S CALL THE
01:55:44.037 --> 01:55:48.308
ROLL. A C A THREE. SENATOR
01:55:48.374 --> 01:55:51.444
KAMLAGER. THE MOTION IS BE
01:55:51.511 --> 01:55:52.578
ADOPTED. BUT FIRST BE WE
01:55:52.645 --> 01:55:53.646
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:55:53.713 --> 01:55:58.084
APPROPRIATIONS. NEWMAN I,
01:55:58.151 --> 01:56:01.287
NILSSON NILSSON. I LASER.
01:56:01.354 --> 01:56:06.893
HERTZBERG I LABOR LABOR? AYE.
01:56:06.959 --> 01:56:08.061
EXCELLENT SO THAT THAT BILL IS
01:56:08.127 --> 01:56:11.798
OUT. CONGRATULATIONS SENATOR
01:56:11.864 --> 01:56:15.068
KAMLAGER LET US NOW GO BACK
01:56:15.134 --> 01:56:18.104
REOPENED THE ROLE ON THOSE VOTES
01:56:18.171 --> 01:56:18.871
FOR WHICH WE DID NOT HAVE A
01:56:18.938 --> 01:56:21.607
COMPLETE RECORD AND PROCEED.
01:56:21.674 --> 01:56:27.680
THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE. FILE
01:56:27.747 --> 01:56:29.282
ITEM ONE A. B 9 72
01:56:29.349 --> 01:56:30.683
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BERMAN MOTION
01:56:30.750 --> 01:56:32.585
IS DO PASS THE FURTHER WE
01:56:32.652 --> 01:56:33.653
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:56:33.720 --> 01:56:37.156
JUDICIARY. CRAM VOTE IS TWO EYES
01:56:37.223 --> 01:56:39.092
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I AND THE
01:56:39.158 --> 01:56:41.828
CHAIR VOTING. NO. GLASER.
01:56:41.894 --> 01:56:46.032
HERTZBERG HERZBERG? AYE. 3 TO 1
01:56:46.099 --> 01:56:49.535
. THAT BILL IS OUT. THANK YOU.
01:56:49.602 --> 01:56:51.938
FILE ITEM TO A B 9 75
01:56:52.004 --> 01:56:53.439
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THREE OF US
01:56:53.506 --> 01:56:55.641
MOTION IS DUE PASSES AMENDED BUT
01:56:55.708 --> 01:56:57.343
FIRST AMEND AND BE REFERRED TO
01:56:57.410 --> 01:56:58.978
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:56:59.045 --> 01:57:00.847
. CURRENT VOTE IS THREE EYES TO
01:57:00.913 --> 01:57:02.715
KNOW KNOWS WHAT THE CHAIR AND
01:57:02.782 --> 01:57:05.685
VICE CHAIR VOTING AYE. LASER
01:57:05.752 --> 01:57:07.620
HERZBERG. HERZBERG I BILL IS OUT
01:57:07.687 --> 01:57:14.293
40 NOTHING. MAYBE. 13 OH, SEVEN.
01:57:14.360 --> 01:57:18.064
CURRENT VOTE IS TO RISE WITH THE
01:57:18.131 --> 01:57:20.299
CHAIR VOTING I AND ONE NOTE WITH
01:57:20.366 --> 01:57:23.202
THE VICE CHAIR VOTING. NO MOTION
01:57:23.269 --> 01:57:24.904
IS DO DO PASS. BUT FRISBEE WE
01:57:24.971 --> 01:57:26.406
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:57:26.472 --> 01:57:28.441
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE LASER.
01:57:28.508 --> 01:57:31.778
HERTZBERG HERZBERG I, THAT BOAT
01:57:31.844 --> 01:57:36.315
IS OUT 3 TO 1 A B 16 1916 19
01:57:36.382 --> 01:57:38.317
THIS PART OF THE CONSENT TALENT
01:57:38.384 --> 01:57:42.054
, MAYBE 16 31 A B 16 31 BY
01:57:42.121 --> 01:57:43.456
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CERVANTES
01:57:43.523 --> 01:57:45.091
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FOR HIS
01:57:45.158 --> 01:57:46.893
BE WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
01:57:46.959 --> 01:57:47.894
ON APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE
01:57:47.960 --> 01:57:50.096
IS THREE EYES. AND NO NOSE WITH
01:57:50.163 --> 01:57:51.531
THE CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. VOTING
01:57:51.597 --> 01:57:55.935
I LASER HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE.
01:57:56.002 --> 01:57:58.271
THAT BILL IS OUT. THANK YOU. A B
01:57:58.337 --> 01:58:02.408
21 72. A B 21 72 BY
01:58:02.475 --> 01:58:03.943
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EVENT IS MOTION
01:58:04.010 --> 01:58:05.678
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED, BUT
01:58:05.745 --> 01:58:07.079
FIRST AMEND AND WE REFERRED TO
01:58:07.146 --> 01:58:08.581
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:58:08.648 --> 01:58:11.384
CRIME VOTE IS THREE EYES AND NO
01:58:11.451 --> 01:58:12.552
NOSE WITH THE CHAIR AND VICE
01:58:12.618 --> 01:58:14.954
CHAIR. VOTING. AYE. LASER
01:58:15.021 --> 01:58:17.657
HERZBERG HERZBERG. I 40 NOTHING
01:58:17.723 --> 01:58:23.796
A B 17 83 A B 17 83 BY
01:58:23.863 --> 01:58:25.298
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVIN MOTION IS
01:58:25.364 --> 01:58:26.799
DUE PAST BUT FOR HIS BE WE
01:58:26.866 --> 01:58:27.767
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:58:27.834 --> 01:58:29.969
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
01:58:30.036 --> 01:58:31.237
THREE EYES AND NO NOSE WITH THE
01:58:31.304 --> 01:58:33.172
CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. VOTING.
01:58:33.239 --> 01:58:36.242
AYE. LASER, HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
01:58:36.309 --> 01:58:41.647
I BILL IS OUT FOR 20 A B 2037.
01:58:41.714 --> 01:58:43.282
MAYBE 2037 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:58:43.349 --> 01:58:46.052
FLORA. THE MOTION IS DUE PAST
01:58:46.118 --> 01:58:46.953
BUT FRISBEE WE REFERRED TO THE
01:58:47.019 --> 01:58:48.554
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL
01:58:48.621 --> 01:58:50.289
ORGANIZATION. CURRENT VOTE IS
01:58:50.356 --> 01:58:52.358
THREE EYES AND NO NOSE WITH THE
01:58:52.425 --> 01:58:53.493
CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. VOTING.
01:58:53.559 --> 01:58:56.496
AYE. LASER HERZBERG, HER SPRING
01:58:56.562 --> 01:58:59.332
I WAS OUT FOR TWO. NOTHING A B
01:58:59.398 --> 01:59:05.371
24 94. MAYBE 24 94
01:59:05.438 --> 01:59:06.873
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CELL IS THE
01:59:06.939 --> 01:59:08.374
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FRISBEE
01:59:08.441 --> 01:59:10.409
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:59:10.476 --> 01:59:11.210
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE CRUMBLE
01:59:11.277 --> 01:59:15.047
IS TWO EYES. AND ONE NO WITH THE
01:59:15.114 --> 01:59:16.249
CHAIR VOTING. I AM THE VICE
01:59:16.315 --> 01:59:18.451
CHAIR, VOTING NO LASER. NIELSEN.
01:59:18.518 --> 01:59:22.288
EXCUSE ME, HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG
01:59:22.355 --> 01:59:24.757
I THAT BILL IS OUT ON A VOTE OF
01:59:24.824 --> 01:59:27.527
3 TO 1. LET'S MOVE THE CONSENT
01:59:27.593 --> 01:59:28.961
CALENDAR. THOSE BILLS ARE
01:59:29.028 --> 01:59:29.962
THERE'S THREE BILLS UNCONSENTED
01:59:30.029 --> 01:59:32.331
BE 16 19 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:59:32.398 --> 01:59:33.900
CERVANTES A B 17 98
01:59:33.966 --> 01:59:36.068
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CRY IN A B 25
01:59:36.135 --> 01:59:37.470
77 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BIGELOW.
01:59:37.537 --> 01:59:40.006
POLICE CALL THE ROLL. ON THE
01:59:40.072 --> 01:59:41.541
CONSENT CALENDAR. GLASER
01:59:41.607 --> 01:59:46.445
HERZBERG, CHRISTOPHER GUY. THE
01:59:46.512 --> 01:59:48.514
CONSENT CALENDAR IS ALSO OUT FOR
01:59:48.581 --> 01:59:51.484
20. THANK YOU. THANK YOU COLLEGE
01:59:51.551 --> 01:59:56.055
WITH THAT THIS HEARING OF THE
01:59:56.122 --> 01:59:57.089
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
01:59:57.156 --> 01:59:58.090
AND CONSTITUTIONAL MOMENTS IS
01:59:58.157 --> 02:00:14.507
ADJOURNED. THANK YOU.