WEBVTT
00:00:07.774 --> 00:00:09.442
SENATE COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS
00:00:09.509 --> 00:00:09.909
PROFESSIONS, ECONOMIC
00:00:09.976 --> 00:00:10.710
DEVELOPMENT WILL COME TO ORDER
00:00:10.777 --> 00:00:13.947
GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE. THANK
00:00:14.013 --> 00:00:16.149
YOU FOR BEING HERE AS WE
00:00:16.216 --> 00:00:16.783
CONTINUE TO TAKE SOME
00:00:16.850 --> 00:00:17.717
PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE ONGOING
00:00:17.784 --> 00:00:19.018
COVID 19 RISKS. THE SENATE
00:00:19.085 --> 00:00:20.754
CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC
00:00:20.820 --> 00:00:22.322
AND HAS PROVIDED ACCESS. TO BOTH
00:00:22.389 --> 00:00:23.690
IN PERSON UNTIL THE CONFERENCE
00:00:23.757 --> 00:00:24.190
PARTICIPATION FOR PUBLIC
00:00:24.257 --> 00:00:26.826
COMMENT. FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS
00:00:26.893 --> 00:00:27.761
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
00:00:27.827 --> 00:00:29.062
COMMENT. THE PARTICIPANT TOLL
00:00:29.129 --> 00:00:30.530
FREE NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:30.597 --> 00:00:33.233
POSTED ON OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE.
00:00:33.299 --> 00:00:34.234
IT WILL BE DISPLAYED ON THE
00:00:34.300 --> 00:00:35.402
SCREEN AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT
00:00:35.468 --> 00:00:36.703
NOW. TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER
00:00:36.770 --> 00:00:41.441
IS 84429163. AND THE ACCESS CODE
00:00:41.508 --> 00:00:49.482
IS 14111401. 40 MAINTAIN DECORUM
00:00:49.549 --> 00:00:50.917
DURING THIS HEARING, AS WE
00:00:50.984 --> 00:00:52.352
CUSTOMARILY DO, AND ANY
00:00:52.419 --> 00:00:53.853
INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE MAY
00:00:53.920 --> 00:00:55.021
BE REMOVED FROM REMOTE MEETING
00:00:55.088 --> 00:00:55.989
SERVICE OR HAVE THEIR
00:00:56.055 --> 00:00:59.893
CONNECTIONS MUTED. AS YOU SEE,
00:00:59.959 --> 00:01:00.693
WE'RE HOLDING TODAY'S COMMITTEE
00:01:00.760 --> 00:01:02.896
HEARING IN OUR 10 21. OH STREET
00:01:02.962 --> 00:01:04.531
LOCATION. I ASK ALL MEMBERS OF
00:01:04.597 --> 00:01:06.232
THE COMMITTEE WHO ARE PRESENT IN
00:01:06.299 --> 00:01:07.801
THE BUILDING TO REPORT TO ROOM
00:01:07.867 --> 00:01:09.068
1200, SO WE MAY ESTABLISH OUR
00:01:09.135 --> 00:01:12.338
QUORUM. AND CONTINUE WITH THIS
00:01:12.405 --> 00:01:14.774
HEARING. WE HAVE 18 BILLS ON
00:01:14.841 --> 00:01:16.376
TODAY'S AGENDA. THAT MAY BE
00:01:16.443 --> 00:01:20.346
ADJUSTED SOMEWHAT. FILE ITEM
00:01:20.413 --> 00:01:24.117
ITEMS NUMBER 11 SEMI BUILT 2224
00:01:24.184 --> 00:01:25.518
AND FILE ITEM NUMBER 12 ASSEMBLY
00:01:25.585 --> 00:01:28.455
BILL 24 7 HAVE BEEN REMOVED FROM
00:01:28.521 --> 00:01:30.457
OUR FILE AND WILL NOT BE
00:01:30.523 --> 00:01:33.193
CONSIDERED TODAY. THERE ARE
00:01:33.259 --> 00:01:34.694
THREE BILLS PROPOSED FOR CONSENT
00:01:34.761 --> 00:01:37.163
FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR A B 27 45
00:01:37.230 --> 00:01:40.099
FILE ITM NUMBER NINE A B 18 13
00:01:40.166 --> 00:01:44.437
AND FILE ON NUMBER 18 A B 29 72
00:01:44.504 --> 00:01:46.206
WHEN WE HAVE ENOUGH MEMBERS DOWN
00:01:46.272 --> 00:01:47.874
HERE, WE WILL ESTABLISH A
00:01:47.941 --> 00:01:52.145
QUORUM. AND IN THE ABSENCE OF
00:01:52.212 --> 00:01:53.313
THAT, WE WILL PROCEED AS A
00:01:53.379 --> 00:01:54.647
SUBCOMMITTEE TO TAKE UP BILLS
00:01:54.714 --> 00:01:56.583
AND I SEE SOME REMEMBER GARCIA
00:01:56.649 --> 00:01:58.985
HERE. FILE ITEM NUMBER ONE
00:01:59.052 --> 00:02:02.155
ASSEMBLY BILL 3 51. SO REMEMBER,
00:02:02.222 --> 00:02:03.189
GARCIA. POLICE PROCEED WHEN
00:02:03.256 --> 00:02:08.695
READY. THANK YOU THAT AFTERNOON
00:02:08.761 --> 00:02:10.763
. MAYBE 3 51 WILL PROVIDE AN
00:02:10.830 --> 00:02:12.866
ADDITIONAL OPTION FOR CALIFORNIA
00:02:12.932 --> 00:02:13.967
RESIDENTS THAT IS
00:02:14.033 --> 00:02:15.268
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY AND
00:02:15.335 --> 00:02:16.536
GIVES ANOTHER CHOICE FOR THIS
00:02:16.603 --> 00:02:19.706
POSITION OF OUR REMAINS. THE
00:02:19.772 --> 00:02:20.840
MEASURE WOULD ALLOW INDIVIDUALS
00:02:20.907 --> 00:02:22.542
TO BE ORGANICALLY THEY COMPOSED
00:02:22.609 --> 00:02:23.810
ALSO REFERS TO AS REDUCTION OF
00:02:23.877 --> 00:02:26.880
HUMAN REMAINS. AFTER THIS
00:02:26.946 --> 00:02:27.714
NATURAL PROCESS IS COMPLETE.
00:02:27.780 --> 00:02:29.849
FAMILY AND LOVED ONES OF DISEASE
00:02:29.916 --> 00:02:30.783
MAY INTEGRATE THE REMAINS AS
00:02:30.850 --> 00:02:32.685
SOIL WHEN PLANTING A TREE OR A
00:02:32.752 --> 00:02:33.987
GARDEN AND REMEMBRANCE OF THEIR
00:02:34.053 --> 00:02:38.024
LOVED ONE. THE STATE OF
00:02:38.091 --> 00:02:39.526
WASHINGTON, COLORADO, OREGON AND
00:02:39.592 --> 00:02:40.960
VERMONT HAVE ALREADY SIGNED
00:02:41.027 --> 00:02:41.828
SIMILAR LEGISLATION. OTHER
00:02:41.895 --> 00:02:43.062
STATES ARE ALSO CONSIDERING
00:02:43.129 --> 00:02:45.064
SIMILAR LEGISLATION AS WELL TO
00:02:45.131 --> 00:02:47.100
STILL HAS BEEN BEFORE YOU TODAY
00:02:47.166 --> 00:02:49.035
AND HOPEFULLY THIS WILL BE THE
00:02:49.102 --> 00:02:49.802
YEAR THAT WE FINALLY GIVE
00:02:49.869 --> 00:02:51.437
CONSTITUENTS ANOTHER ENVIRONMENT
00:02:51.504 --> 00:02:54.107
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY OPTION
00:02:54.173 --> 00:02:55.275
FOR THE DISPOSITION OF THE
00:02:55.341 --> 00:02:56.543
REMAINS, AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:02:56.609 --> 00:02:58.378
FOR AN I VOTE WHEN YOU HAVE A
00:02:58.444 --> 00:03:00.346
QUORUM. THANK YOU. REMEMBER
00:03:00.413 --> 00:03:01.915
GARCIA WILL NOW MOVE ON TO
00:03:01.981 --> 00:03:04.017
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY AND
00:03:04.083 --> 00:03:05.451
SUPPORT DUE TO CONSTRAINTS
00:03:05.518 --> 00:03:06.886
REGARDING THE LENGTH OF
00:03:06.953 --> 00:03:07.353
HEARINGS, TECHNOLOGY
00:03:07.420 --> 00:03:08.054
CONSIDERATIONS IN CLEANING
00:03:08.121 --> 00:03:10.023
PROTOCOLS. COMMITTEE CHAIRS MAY
00:03:10.089 --> 00:03:10.990
INSTITUTE TIME LIMITS ON
00:03:11.057 --> 00:03:13.927
TESTIMONY. AND IN THIS CASE,
00:03:13.993 --> 00:03:15.328
EACH SIDE WILL ONLY BE PERMITTED
00:03:15.395 --> 00:03:16.930
A TOTAL OF THREE MINUTES. ALL
00:03:16.996 --> 00:03:18.331
OTHERS WISHING TO TESTIFY MUST
00:03:18.398 --> 00:03:19.832
LIMIT THEIR COMMENTS TO THEIR
00:03:19.899 --> 00:03:20.833
NAME, AFFILIATION AND POSITION
00:03:20.900 --> 00:03:24.571
ON THE MEASURE. AND I UNDERSTAND
00:03:24.637 --> 00:03:26.539
THAT KATRINA SPADE, FOUNDER AND
00:03:26.606 --> 00:03:28.374
CEO OF RECOMPOSED IS ON THE
00:03:28.441 --> 00:03:29.809
LINE. IS THAT CORRECT? ALONG
00:03:29.876 --> 00:03:35.181
WITH ALEX AND DRINA, ALEX
00:03:35.248 --> 00:03:36.783
ALEXANDRINA. CHAVEZ WITH
00:03:36.849 --> 00:03:38.418
CALIFORNIA'S AGAINST WASTE, WHO
00:03:38.484 --> 00:03:40.286
IS HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM IF I
00:03:40.353 --> 00:03:41.487
PRONOUNCED THAT CORRECTLY? THEN
00:03:41.554 --> 00:03:42.722
WE'LL START WITH YOU. PLEASE
00:03:42.789 --> 00:03:45.191
PROCEED MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:03:45.258 --> 00:03:46.759
ALEXA CHAVEZ ON BEHALF OF
00:03:46.826 --> 00:03:48.361
CALIFORNIA'S AGAINST WASTE.
00:03:48.428 --> 00:03:49.028
SPEAKING TODAY IN STRONG SUPPORT
00:03:49.095 --> 00:03:51.264
OF SENATE, BILL 3 51, A
00:03:51.331 --> 00:03:52.799
CEMETERIES BEGIN TO FILL UP AND
00:03:52.865 --> 00:03:54.734
LAND UNLESS AVAILABLE FOR BURIAL
00:03:54.801 --> 00:03:56.369
PLOTS. CALIFORNIANS ARE LOOKING
00:03:56.436 --> 00:03:57.770
FOR MORE SUSTAINABLE DEATH CARE
00:03:57.837 --> 00:03:59.672
PRACTICES OF EVERY CALIFORNIA.
00:03:59.739 --> 00:04:01.341
RESIDENT CHOSE NATURAL REDUCTION
00:04:01.407 --> 00:04:02.942
AS THERE AFTER DEATH PREFERENCE
00:04:03.009 --> 00:04:04.711
, WE WOULD SAVE NEARLY 2.5
00:04:04.777 --> 00:04:06.012
MILLION METRIC TONS OF CO. TWO
00:04:06.079 --> 00:04:08.247
IN JUST 10 YEARS FOR EVERY
00:04:08.314 --> 00:04:09.048
INDIVIDUAL THAT SHOWS
00:04:09.115 --> 00:04:10.917
TRADITIONAL BURIAL OR CREMATION
00:04:10.984 --> 00:04:12.151
. ONE METRIC TON OF CARBON IS
00:04:12.218 --> 00:04:14.087
EMITTED INTO THE ATMOSPHERE.
00:04:14.153 --> 00:04:17.090
OVER 66% OF AFTER DEATH CHOICES
00:04:17.156 --> 00:04:18.091
OPT FOR CREMATION IN CALIFORNIA
00:04:18.157 --> 00:04:19.692
, BUT THE PRACTICE REQUIRES
00:04:19.759 --> 00:04:20.860
FOSSIL FUELS AND, UM, IT'S 02
00:04:20.927 --> 00:04:22.829
INTO THE ATMOSPHERE.
00:04:22.895 --> 00:04:24.464
ADDITIONALLY TRADITIONAL CASKET
00:04:24.530 --> 00:04:25.932
BURIALS LEACHES CHEMICALS INTO
00:04:25.999 --> 00:04:27.367
THE GROUND FROM TREATMENT,
00:04:27.433 --> 00:04:28.835
CASKET, WOOD AND EMBALMING
00:04:28.901 --> 00:04:30.536
CHEMICALS. COMPOST HOWEVER, IS
00:04:30.603 --> 00:04:31.771
CREATED THROUGH A NATURAL
00:04:31.838 --> 00:04:33.506
PROCESS BY WHICH ORGANICS, WHICH
00:04:33.573 --> 00:04:35.108
INCLUDE HUMAN REMAINS. ARE
00:04:35.174 --> 00:04:35.975
ALLOWED TO DECOMPOSE INTO A
00:04:36.042 --> 00:04:38.378
NUTRIENT RICH SOIL OR HUMMUS.
00:04:38.444 --> 00:04:39.846
THIS RICH MATERIAL MAY BE USED
00:04:39.912 --> 00:04:41.614
BY GARDENERS AS SOIL AMENDMENTS
00:04:41.681 --> 00:04:43.416
TO IMPROVE SOIL HEALTH AND
00:04:43.483 --> 00:04:45.051
PERHAPS EVEN TO SUPPORT MEMORIAL
00:04:45.118 --> 00:04:48.821
GARDENS. MAYBE FIVE. OH, 3 51
00:04:48.888 --> 00:04:49.689
WOULD CREATE AN ADDITIONAL
00:04:49.756 --> 00:04:50.757
OPTION FOR DEATH CARE PRACTICE
00:04:50.823 --> 00:04:52.125
THAT IS MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY
00:04:52.191 --> 00:04:52.992
FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE. THANK
00:04:53.059 --> 00:04:54.293
YOU. AND I RESPECTFULLY URGE
00:04:54.360 --> 00:04:55.728
YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU, MA'AM.
00:04:55.795 --> 00:05:01.334
IS KATRINA SPADE ON THE LINE?
00:05:01.401 --> 00:05:03.736
OKAY LET'S HEAR FROM ANY OTHER
00:05:03.803 --> 00:05:05.405
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT IN THE
00:05:05.471 --> 00:05:06.439
HEARING ROOM. PLEASE STEP
00:05:06.506 --> 00:05:07.674
FORWARD. IDENTIFY YOURSELF.
00:05:07.740 --> 00:05:09.709
POSITION ON THE MEASURE AND
00:05:09.776 --> 00:05:14.580
AFFILIATION, PLEASE. THAT MR
00:05:14.647 --> 00:05:16.249
CHAIR AND MEMBERS PETE
00:05:16.315 --> 00:05:16.883
MONTGOMERY ON BEHALF OF BETTER
00:05:16.949 --> 00:05:18.317
PLACE FORESTS IN STRONG SUPPORT
00:05:18.384 --> 00:05:19.986
OF 83 51. THANK YOU, SIR. ANY
00:05:20.053 --> 00:05:21.320
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT HERE
00:05:21.387 --> 00:05:23.589
IN THE HEARING ROOM, LET'S MOVE
00:05:23.656 --> 00:05:24.624
TO WITNESSES WILLING TO TESTIFY
00:05:24.691 --> 00:05:25.591
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
00:05:25.658 --> 00:05:26.793
MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
00:05:26.859 --> 00:05:28.928
PROMPT ANY SUCH WITNESSES.
00:05:28.995 --> 00:05:30.463
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND
00:05:30.530 --> 00:05:32.198
SUPPORTIVE ASSEMBLY BILL 3 51.
00:05:32.265 --> 00:05:34.467
WE WILL BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK
00:05:34.534 --> 00:05:36.569
YOU TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS
00:05:36.636 --> 00:05:38.137
BILL. PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
00:05:38.204 --> 00:05:39.706
ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD
00:05:39.772 --> 00:05:40.907
AGAIN. THAT'S ONE AND THEN ZERO,
00:05:40.973 --> 00:05:49.849
PLEASE. WE DO HAVE A LINE WITH
00:05:49.916 --> 00:05:50.717
AN OPERATOR. IT'D BE JUST A
00:05:50.783 --> 00:06:05.832
MOMENT. THANK YOU.
00:06:05.898 --> 00:06:07.400
IN OUR PUBLIC COMMENT COMES FROM
00:06:07.467 --> 00:06:09.168
LINE 28, PLEASE GO AHEAD TO
00:06:09.235 --> 00:06:13.339
EIGHT. HI THIS IS CAROLINE MAYS
00:06:13.406 --> 00:06:14.941
IS I'M CO FOUNDER AND CHIEF
00:06:15.007 --> 00:06:16.342
OPERATING OFFICER OF EARTH
00:06:16.409 --> 00:06:17.844
FUNERAL GROUP, A LARGE SCALE
00:06:17.910 --> 00:06:18.845
PROVIDER OF NATURAL ORGANIC
00:06:18.911 --> 00:06:19.846
REDUCTION IN WASHINGTON STATE,
00:06:19.912 --> 00:06:21.714
AND I AM STRONGLY IN FAVOR OF
00:06:21.781 --> 00:06:23.116
THIS BILL. THANK YOU, MA'AM.
00:06:23.182 --> 00:06:27.186
NEXT, PLEASE. THANK YOU. THERE
00:06:27.253 --> 00:06:28.755
ARE NO OTHER LINES IN CUBA AT
00:06:28.821 --> 00:06:30.256
THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
00:06:30.323 --> 00:06:31.390
MODERATOR. LET'S FOLLOW THE SAME
00:06:31.457 --> 00:06:33.126
PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
00:06:33.192 --> 00:06:34.327
OPPOSITION FIRST. MOVING TO
00:06:34.393 --> 00:06:35.394
OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN THE
00:06:35.461 --> 00:06:38.931
HEARING ROOM. SAYING NONE LET'S
00:06:38.998 --> 00:06:40.399
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
00:06:40.466 --> 00:06:41.968
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION VIA THE
00:06:42.034 --> 00:06:43.369
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
00:06:43.436 --> 00:06:44.504
, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
00:06:44.570 --> 00:06:45.638
SUCH INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
00:06:45.705 --> 00:06:47.707
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. T<c.cyan></c>
00:06:47.774 --> 00:06:48.808
ASSEMBLY BILL 3 51. WE WILL
00:06:48.875 --> 00:06:52.278
CONTINUE WITH THEM. THANK YOU TO
00:06:52.345 --> 00:06:53.713
EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL
00:06:53.780 --> 00:06:55.348
TO BE IMPRESSED. ONE AND THEN
00:06:55.414 --> 00:06:57.383
ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE. THAT'S
00:06:57.450 --> 00:07:04.357
ONE FOLLOWED BY ZERO, PLEASE.
00:07:04.423 --> 00:07:05.591
AND AT THIS TIME THERE ARE NO
00:07:05.658 --> 00:07:08.394
LINES IN QUÊ. THANK YOU, MR
00:07:08.461 --> 00:07:09.829
MODERATOR. LET'S BRING THE
00:07:09.896 --> 00:07:11.330
DISCUSSION BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES
00:07:11.397 --> 00:07:13.332
IN THE HEARING ROOM COLLEAGUES
00:07:13.399 --> 00:07:14.333
ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
00:07:14.400 --> 00:07:18.938
CONCERNS? NO SEEING NONE. UM
00:07:19.005 --> 00:07:21.274
THAT'S WHEN WE GET WILL NOTE
00:07:21.340 --> 00:07:23.042
THAT SENATOR NEWMAN WHEN WE HAVE
00:07:23.109 --> 00:07:24.977
A QUORUM, SO MANY MEMBER WOULD
00:07:25.044 --> 00:07:26.078
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? JUST
00:07:26.145 --> 00:07:27.713
RESPECTFULLY ASKED WHEN I VOTE
00:07:27.780 --> 00:07:28.815
AND THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR THE
00:07:28.881 --> 00:07:30.716
HELP THANK YOU AGAIN. WE'LL VOTE
00:07:30.783 --> 00:07:41.327
WHEN WE HAVE A QUORUM.
00:07:41.394 --> 00:07:45.198
OKAY MR. KIRK YOU'RE HERE ON TWO
00:07:45.264 --> 00:07:47.533
ITEMS NUMBER SEVEN A. B 17 47
00:07:47.600 --> 00:07:51.737
AND NUMBER EIGHT. A B 1954.
00:07:51.804 --> 00:08:02.048
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN READY. OKAY
00:08:02.114 --> 00:08:05.852
SO WE'LL START WITH 17 47. THANK
00:08:05.918 --> 00:08:08.688
YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS. A B 17
00:08:08.754 --> 00:08:10.289
47 STRENGTHENS THE STATE'S
00:08:10.356 --> 00:08:13.092
ABILITY TO DISCIPLINE LICENSED
00:08:13.159 --> 00:08:14.460
CONTRACTORS WHO FAILED TO COMPLY
00:08:14.527 --> 00:08:15.361
WITH BUILDING PERMIT
00:08:15.428 --> 00:08:17.797
REQUIREMENTS, STRENGTHENING THE
00:08:17.864 --> 00:08:19.332
STATE'S ABILITY TO DISCIPLINE
00:08:19.398 --> 00:08:20.466
LICENSED CONTRACTORS WHO FAILED
00:08:20.533 --> 00:08:22.268
TO COMPLY WITH BUILDING PERMIT
00:08:22.335 --> 00:08:24.837
REQUIREMENTS. WILL BE SERVED THE
00:08:24.904 --> 00:08:25.805
HEALTH AND SAFETY OF OUR
00:08:25.872 --> 00:08:26.739
COMMUNITIES HERE TO TESTIFY AND
00:08:26.806 --> 00:08:30.243
SUPPORT. IS MICHAEL GEM NET SKI
00:08:30.309 --> 00:08:31.978
CHIEF OF LEGISLATION FOR THE
00:08:32.044 --> 00:08:34.447
CONTRACTORS STATE LICENSE BOARD.
00:08:34.513 --> 00:08:38.684
SURE, SIR. PLEASE PROCEED.
00:08:38.751 --> 00:08:40.286
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS MIGHT
00:08:40.353 --> 00:08:41.721
JIM NETSCAPE WITH THE CONTRACTOR
00:08:41.787 --> 00:08:43.389
STATE LICENSE BOARD. THE BOARD
00:08:43.456 --> 00:08:44.757
IS PLEASED TO BE THE SOURCE OF
00:08:44.824 --> 00:08:47.126
THIS BILL, WHICH AROSE OUT OF A
00:08:47.193 --> 00:08:47.894
CONSULTATION WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:08:47.960 --> 00:08:49.428
ENERGY COMMISSION ON THE ISSUE
00:08:49.495 --> 00:08:51.130
OF CONTRACTORS COMPLYING WITH
00:08:51.197 --> 00:08:52.265
TITLE 24 H FACT REQUIREMENT
00:08:52.331 --> 00:08:55.034
STANDARDS. SO THE BILL DOES
00:08:55.101 --> 00:08:58.037
CLARIFY THAT'S A REQUIREMENT FOR
00:08:58.104 --> 00:08:59.505
CONTRACTORS TO PULL A PERMIT,
00:08:59.572 --> 00:09:01.140
WHICH IS ALREADY IN THE LAW. BUT
00:09:01.207 --> 00:09:02.475
THIS CLARIFIES THAT REQUIREMENT
00:09:02.541 --> 00:09:04.543
AND INCREASES THE VIOLATIONS FOR
00:09:04.610 --> 00:09:06.379
THE PERMIT REQUIREMENTS
00:09:06.445 --> 00:09:09.348
VIOLATION FINES AS WELL AS FIND
00:09:09.415 --> 00:09:10.049
FOR OTHER SERIOUS HEALTH AND
00:09:10.116 --> 00:09:11.817
SAFETY VIOLATIONS. WE ARE VERY
00:09:11.884 --> 00:09:13.019
APPRECIATIVE OF THE ARTHUR'S
00:09:13.085 --> 00:09:14.520
OFFICE FOR TAKING THIS ON AND
00:09:14.587 --> 00:09:15.855
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
00:09:15.922 --> 00:09:17.156
THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU,
00:09:17.223 --> 00:09:18.257
SIR. LET'S HEAR FROM ANY
00:09:18.324 --> 00:09:19.292
ADDITIONAL WITNESSES AND
00:09:19.358 --> 00:09:21.360
SUPPORTING HEARING ROOM. SEEING
00:09:21.427 --> 00:09:22.795
NONE. LET'S MOVE TO WITNESSES
00:09:22.862 --> 00:09:24.730
WAITING TO TEST FIVE YEARS, THE
00:09:24.797 --> 00:09:25.364
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
00:09:25.431 --> 00:09:27.533
, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
00:09:27.600 --> 00:09:28.634
SUCH WITNESSES WAITING TO
00:09:28.701 --> 00:09:30.603
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
00:09:30.670 --> 00:09:32.505
BILL 17 47, WE WILL BEGIN WITH
00:09:32.571 --> 00:09:35.341
THEM. THANK YOU TO EXPRESS
00:09:35.408 --> 00:09:36.876
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL, PRESS ONE
00:09:36.943 --> 00:09:38.711
AND THEN ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE
00:09:38.778 --> 00:09:41.447
KEYPAD. THAT'S ONE FOLLOWED BY
00:09:41.514 --> 00:09:49.255
ZERO OR SUPPORT OF A B 17 47. WE
00:09:49.322 --> 00:09:50.423
DO HAVE ONE LINE WITH AN
00:09:50.489 --> 00:09:57.229
OPERATOR. THAT THAT COMMENT
00:09:57.296 --> 00:09:58.497
COMES FROM LINE. 39 39, PLEASE
00:09:58.564 --> 00:10:09.875
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THE
00:10:09.942 --> 00:10:10.977
LINE WAS INTERRUPTED TO BE,
00:10:11.043 --> 00:10:19.251
THEY'LL BE BACK MOMENTARILY. 39
00:10:19.318 --> 00:10:20.386
PLEASE RESUME OR START OVER,
00:10:20.453 --> 00:10:24.457
RATHER. GOOD AFTERNOON TURN
00:10:24.523 --> 00:10:26.025
MEMBERS REALLY GOOD ON BEHALF OF
00:10:26.092 --> 00:10:27.059
THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING.
00:10:27.126 --> 00:10:28.427
OFFICIALS INSTRUCT SUPPORT OF
00:10:28.494 --> 00:10:30.062
THE A B 17 47. THANK YOU. THANK
00:10:30.129 --> 00:10:33.532
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. NO OTHER LINES
00:10:33.599 --> 00:10:35.134
IN CUBA AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU,
00:10:35.201 --> 00:10:35.935
MR MODERATOR, HAVING HEARD FROM
00:10:36.002 --> 00:10:37.937
THE SUPPORTERS LESS FOLLOW THE
00:10:38.004 --> 00:10:39.171
SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
00:10:39.238 --> 00:10:40.339
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION FIRST
00:10:40.406 --> 00:10:41.307
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
00:10:41.374 --> 00:10:44.477
HEARING ROOM. SEEING NONE. LET'S
00:10:44.543 --> 00:10:45.811
MOVE TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:10:45.878 --> 00:10:47.580
SERVICE MODERATOR. IF YOU WOULD
00:10:47.646 --> 00:10:48.848
PLEASE PROMPT ANY INDIVIDUALS
00:10:48.914 --> 00:10:50.716
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
00:10:50.783 --> 00:10:51.951
TO ASSEMBLY BILL 17 47. WE WILL
00:10:52.018 --> 00:10:55.621
CONTINUE WITH THEM. THANK YOU TO
00:10:55.688 --> 00:10:56.956
EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THE BILL.
00:10:57.023 --> 00:10:58.724
YOU MAY PRESS 10 ON YOUR
00:10:58.791 --> 00:11:01.494
TELEPHONE USING YOUR TELEPHONE
00:11:01.560 --> 00:11:02.561
KEYPAD. YOU MAY PRESS ONE,
00:11:02.628 --> 00:11:09.101
FOLLOWED BY ZERO. THINK MR
00:11:09.168 --> 00:11:09.935
CHAIR. THERE ARE NO LINES IN
00:11:10.002 --> 00:11:11.604
CUBA AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
00:11:11.670 --> 00:11:13.539
MODERATOR. LET'S BRING THE
00:11:13.606 --> 00:11:14.040
CONVERSATION BACK TO MY
00:11:14.106 --> 00:11:14.840
COLLEAGUES IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:11:14.907 --> 00:11:15.741
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS,
00:11:15.808 --> 00:11:17.309
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? SEEING
00:11:17.376 --> 00:11:19.178
NONE REMEMBER? WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:11:19.245 --> 00:11:23.082
CLOSE? YES I ASKED. VERY YOUR I
00:11:23.149 --> 00:11:24.116
VOTED THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
00:11:24.183 --> 00:11:26.085
THERE IS NO OPPOSITION AND WE
00:11:26.152 --> 00:11:27.586
HAVE INDUSTRY SUPPORT. THANK YOU
00:11:27.653 --> 00:11:29.388
. THANK YOU, SIR. YOUR NEXT
00:11:29.455 --> 00:11:31.157
BILL, ITEM NUMBER EIGHT. YES,
00:11:31.223 --> 00:11:34.060
THANK YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
00:11:34.126 --> 00:11:35.928
RESEARCH SUGGESTS THAT MEDICAL
00:11:35.995 --> 00:11:38.531
CANNABIS USE CAN REDUCE OPIOID
00:11:38.597 --> 00:11:40.299
TREATMENT DOSE AND OPIOID BRUCE
00:11:40.366 --> 00:11:43.702
ABUSE. THIS CAN RESULT IN
00:11:43.769 --> 00:11:44.570
IMPROVED QUALITY OF LIFE FOR
00:11:44.637 --> 00:11:48.808
PATIENTS. MAYBE 1954 PROHIBIT
00:11:48.874 --> 00:11:50.409
PHYSICIANS, PHYSICIANS AND
00:11:50.476 --> 00:11:51.844
SURGEONS FROM DENYING TREATMENT
00:11:51.911 --> 00:11:54.914
AND MEDICATION BASED SOLELY. IN
00:11:54.980 --> 00:11:57.650
A POSITIVE THC TEST. WE HAVE
00:11:57.716 --> 00:11:59.985
WORKED WITH THE C M A VERY
00:12:00.052 --> 00:12:05.458
CLOSELY THE ONCE THE PHYSICIAN.
00:12:05.524 --> 00:12:07.827
LOOKS AT THE INDIVIDUAL PATIENT
00:12:07.893 --> 00:12:09.962
AND LOOKS AT WHETHER OR NOT THEY
00:12:10.029 --> 00:12:12.765
THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE FOR THAT
00:12:12.832 --> 00:12:15.367
PERSON TO BE ON ON CANNABIS,
00:12:15.434 --> 00:12:17.736
THEN THEY CAN IF THEY DECIDED TO
00:12:17.803 --> 00:12:19.538
NOT HAVE COMPLETE DISCRETION TO
00:12:19.605 --> 00:12:21.974
SAY NO. YOU HAVE TO GET OFF
00:12:22.041 --> 00:12:23.576
CANNABIS. IF YOU'RE GOING TO GO
00:12:23.642 --> 00:12:25.311
X Y OR Z IN PARTICULAR TAKE
00:12:25.377 --> 00:12:27.379
OPIOIDS IS THE STANDARD CONCERN,
00:12:27.446 --> 00:12:30.049
BUT AGAIN. WE'VE WORKED WITH
00:12:30.116 --> 00:12:33.085
CMA. I KNOW DR PAN HAS QUESTIONS
00:12:33.152 --> 00:12:36.088
AND I'M GLAD TO TAKE ANY OF
00:12:36.155 --> 00:12:37.556
THEM. BUT AGAIN, IT'S WORKED OUT
00:12:37.623 --> 00:12:39.692
WITH CMA. HERE TO TESTIFY AND
00:12:39.758 --> 00:12:43.696
SUPPORT OF A B 1954, R. DR LARRY
00:12:43.762 --> 00:12:46.732
BEDARD AND RICHARD MILLER, CHAIR
00:12:46.799 --> 00:12:47.933
OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS FOR
00:12:48.000 --> 00:12:49.068
THE MARINE HEALTHCARE DISTRICT
00:12:49.135 --> 00:12:52.138
AND AN IMPACTED PATIENT. THANK
00:12:52.204 --> 00:12:53.239
YOU, SIR. GENTLEMEN. UH, THREE
00:12:53.305 --> 00:12:57.810
MINUTES. WHO WANTS TO SPEAK.
00:12:57.877 --> 00:13:02.448
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:13:02.515 --> 00:13:03.549
RICHARD MILLER NAMED THE PATIENT
00:13:03.616 --> 00:13:05.518
TO SUFFERS FROM EUROPE,
00:13:05.584 --> 00:13:07.987
NEUROPATHY, SPINAL STENOSIS AND
00:13:08.053 --> 00:13:08.787
CHRONIC FLARE UPS. ASIATIC PAIN
00:13:08.854 --> 00:13:11.724
DUE TO A SERIES OF ACCIDENTS. I
00:13:11.790 --> 00:13:14.059
AM ALSO MEDICAL CANNABIS PATIENT
00:13:14.126 --> 00:13:16.595
HAS BEEN DENIED ACCESS BY THREE
00:13:16.662 --> 00:13:17.796
DIFFERENT DOCTORS ON THREE
00:13:17.863 --> 00:13:18.564
DIFFERENT OCCASIONS TO PAIN
00:13:18.631 --> 00:13:20.099
RELIEVING MEDICATION, EVEN
00:13:20.166 --> 00:13:21.867
THOUGH BY USING CANNABIS. I WAS
00:13:21.934 --> 00:13:23.769
ABLE TO REDUCE MY OPIOID UPDATE
00:13:23.836 --> 00:13:27.773
BY 75. HOWEVER WHEN IT COMES TO
00:13:27.840 --> 00:13:28.874
INTERMEDIATE, INTERMEDIATE,
00:13:28.941 --> 00:13:30.743
INTER TRACTABLE NERVE PAIN.
00:13:30.809 --> 00:13:32.444
SOMETIMES I THINK THAT WORKS AS
00:13:32.511 --> 00:13:34.246
A PHARMACEUTICAL, SUCH AS AN
00:13:34.313 --> 00:13:35.848
OPIOID PAIN RELIEVER. OR A
00:13:35.915 --> 00:13:37.483
MUSCLE RELAXER, WHICH I HAVE
00:13:37.550 --> 00:13:39.818
BEEN DENIED REPEATEDLY. OF MY
00:13:39.885 --> 00:13:41.020
USE OF BECAUSE OF MEDICAL
00:13:41.086 --> 00:13:44.490
CANNABIS. IT IS IN MY OPINION,
00:13:44.557 --> 00:13:46.592
THE 1954 WHAT OPENED THE DOOR
00:13:46.659 --> 00:13:47.760
FOR COMMUNICATION BETWEEN A
00:13:47.826 --> 00:13:50.196
DOCTOR AND A PATIENT. TO MAKE
00:13:50.262 --> 00:13:52.131
SAFE INFORMED DECISIONS FOR
00:13:52.198 --> 00:13:53.465
SENSIBLE, RESPONSIBLE MEDICATING
00:13:53.532 --> 00:13:54.200
PRACTICE PRACTICES WITH
00:13:54.266 --> 00:14:00.873
OVERSIGHT. HAVING WORKED AS A
00:14:00.940 --> 00:14:02.708
CANNABIS COUNSELOR AT ONE OF THE
00:14:02.775 --> 00:14:03.175
MOST REPUTABLE MEDICAL
00:14:03.242 --> 00:14:05.344
DISPENSARIES HERE IN SACRAMENTO
00:14:05.411 --> 00:14:06.979
FOR NINE YEARS, ENCOUNTERED MANY
00:14:07.046 --> 00:14:08.581
PATIENTS COMING IN ON A REGULAR
00:14:08.647 --> 00:14:09.748
BASIS STAY AND THEY'VE BEEN CUT
00:14:09.815 --> 00:14:11.016
OFF FROM THEIR MEDICATIONS BY
00:14:11.083 --> 00:14:13.052
THE PRIMARY CARE PHYSICIAN.
00:14:13.118 --> 00:14:15.087
SIMPLY BECAUSE OF USING MEDICAL
00:14:15.154 --> 00:14:16.088
CANNABIS IS AN ALTERNATIVE
00:14:16.155 --> 00:14:22.328
MEDICINE. I'VE. SEEN IN THE LAST
00:14:22.394 --> 00:14:23.529
FIVE YEARS HAS SIGNIFICANT
00:14:23.596 --> 00:14:25.431
INCREASE OF 3 TO 5 PATIENTS PER
00:14:25.497 --> 00:14:27.833
WEEK. AS A SUBJECT TO THIS
00:14:27.900 --> 00:14:29.435
DISCRIMINATION AND FORCED TO
00:14:29.501 --> 00:14:30.803
ENDURE UNNECESSARY PAIN. WITH NO
00:14:30.869 --> 00:14:33.205
REMEDY OR RECOURSE. TO THESE
00:14:33.272 --> 00:14:36.809
DOCTORS FOR THEIR ACTIONS. THE
00:14:36.875 --> 00:14:38.477
TIME HAS COME WHEN WE MUST
00:14:38.544 --> 00:14:40.379
CHANGE THE PERIOD. I'M JUST AS
00:14:40.446 --> 00:14:41.747
WE DID WITH A B 2 58. THE
00:14:41.814 --> 00:14:44.350
CANNABIS ORGAN TRANSPLANT BILL
00:14:44.416 --> 00:14:44.850
TO REMOVE THE STIGMA AND
00:14:44.917 --> 00:14:45.851
DISCRIMINATION FOR THOSE
00:14:45.918 --> 00:14:48.587
PATIENTS MOST IN NEED. IT IS THE
00:14:48.654 --> 00:14:52.224
ONLY HUMANITARIAN THING TO DO. I
00:14:52.291 --> 00:14:54.393
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. AND FOR
00:14:54.460 --> 00:14:56.262
THE REASONS I HAVE STATED I AM
00:14:56.328 --> 00:14:58.230
ASKING FOR YOUR I VOTE ON A B
00:14:58.297 --> 00:14:59.531
1954. THANK YOU AND I AM
00:14:59.598 --> 00:15:00.132
AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS.
00:15:00.199 --> 00:15:01.900
THANK YOU, SIR. THE DOCTOR
00:15:01.967 --> 00:15:07.139
ORDERED. PAM LOPEZ ON BEHALF OF
00:15:07.206 --> 00:15:09.074
CALIFORNIA. NORMAL. I APOLOGIZE
00:15:09.141 --> 00:15:10.976
THAT DR BEDARD IS NOT AVAILABLE
00:15:11.043 --> 00:15:12.678
TO BE WITH US TODAY, BUT I'LL DO
00:15:12.745 --> 00:15:15.447
MY BEST TO FILL IN ON HIS BEHALF
00:15:15.514 --> 00:15:17.850
. THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION WAS
00:15:17.916 --> 00:15:20.386
INSPIRED FOR CALIFORNIA NORMAL
00:15:20.452 --> 00:15:23.489
BY A RESOLUTION ADOPTED IN 2019.
00:15:23.555 --> 00:15:25.057
BY THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
00:15:25.124 --> 00:15:27.426
ASSOCIATION, WHICH ENCOURAGED
00:15:27.493 --> 00:15:29.728
DOCTORS TO USE THEIR OWN AND
00:15:29.795 --> 00:15:31.130
BEST MEDICAL DISCRETION IN
00:15:31.196 --> 00:15:32.898
DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT TO
00:15:32.965 --> 00:15:34.366
PRESCRIBE MEDICATIONS, INCLUDING
00:15:34.433 --> 00:15:36.535
OPIOID BASED PAIN MEDICATIONS TO
00:15:36.602 --> 00:15:38.537
PATIENTS WHO ARE ALSO, UM,
00:15:38.604 --> 00:15:41.840
CANNABIS USERS. WE HOPE THAT
00:15:41.907 --> 00:15:42.908
THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION DOES
00:15:42.975 --> 00:15:44.843
NOT FORCE THE HAND OF DOCTORS
00:15:44.910 --> 00:15:46.712
BUT CLARIFIES FOR THEM THAT THEY
00:15:46.779 --> 00:15:47.946
SHOULD USE THEIR OWN BEST
00:15:48.013 --> 00:15:49.415
MEDICAL DISCRETION IN
00:15:49.481 --> 00:15:50.949
DETERMINING WHETHER OR NOT IT'S
00:15:51.016 --> 00:15:52.351
APPROPRIATE TO PRESCRIBE
00:15:52.418 --> 00:15:53.752
MEDICATIONS FOR PATIENTS WHO ARE
00:15:53.819 --> 00:15:57.323
ALSO CANNABIS USERS. AS MR
00:15:57.389 --> 00:15:59.191
MILLER STATED. BASED ON OUR
00:15:59.258 --> 00:16:01.960
RESEARCH, WE FIND THAT A NUMBER
00:16:02.027 --> 00:16:03.529
OF DOCTORS SEEM TO HAVE THE
00:16:03.595 --> 00:16:04.496
MISIMPRESSION OR BE UNDER
00:16:04.563 --> 00:16:08.067
MISINFORMATION. THAT IT'S NOT
00:16:08.133 --> 00:16:10.636
LEGAL OR NOT ALLOWABLE TO TREAT
00:16:10.703 --> 00:16:12.237
PATIENTS WHO ARE ALSO CANNABIS
00:16:12.304 --> 00:16:14.606
USERS. HENCE THE 2019 CM, A
00:16:14.673 --> 00:16:15.808
RESOLUTION THAT WAS AUTHORED BY
00:16:15.874 --> 00:16:19.411
DR BERNARD AND I WILL JUST ADD
00:16:19.478 --> 00:16:20.846
THAT CALIFORNIA NORMAL HAS DONE
00:16:20.913 --> 00:16:23.082
A SURVEY ON THIS ISSUE. WE'VE
00:16:23.148 --> 00:16:25.084
RECEIVED A RESPONSE FROM 600
00:16:25.150 --> 00:16:29.054
PATIENTS THAT SHOW THAT 18.5% OF
00:16:29.121 --> 00:16:31.223
PATIENTS OF OUR VERSE 600
00:16:31.290 --> 00:16:33.459
RESPONDENTS HAVE BEEN DENIED
00:16:33.525 --> 00:16:35.327
TREATMENT BY THEIR DOCTOR
00:16:35.394 --> 00:16:36.528
BECAUSE THEY ARE ALSO CANNABIS
00:16:36.595 --> 00:16:39.832
USERS. WE BELIEVE THAT DOCTORS
00:16:39.898 --> 00:16:41.500
CERTAINLY ARE NOT BAD ACTORS,
00:16:41.567 --> 00:16:43.702
BUT THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO GIVE
00:16:43.769 --> 00:16:45.070
THEM MORE GUIDANCE SO THAT THEY
00:16:45.137 --> 00:16:46.772
UNDERSTAND THAT THEY CAN USE
00:16:46.839 --> 00:16:48.807
THEIR BEST DISCRETION IN TERMS
00:16:48.874 --> 00:16:50.042
OF CARING FOR THESE PATIENTS.
00:16:50.109 --> 00:16:51.777
THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR TIME
00:16:51.844 --> 00:16:53.245
TODAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NOW
00:16:53.312 --> 00:16:54.413
LET'S HEAR FROM ANY OTHER
00:16:54.480 --> 00:16:56.148
WITNESSES IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:16:56.215 --> 00:16:56.849
AND SUPPORT. NAME AFFILIATION
00:16:56.915 --> 00:16:57.850
AND POSITION ON THE MEASURE,
00:16:57.916 --> 00:17:01.854
PLEASE. MR CHAIR MEMBERS, RANDOM
00:17:01.920 --> 00:17:03.088
MARTIN ON BEHALF OF THE PARENT
00:17:03.155 --> 00:17:04.857
COMPANY BETTER KNOWN AROUND HERE
00:17:04.923 --> 00:17:06.058
AS KHALIFA IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:17:06.125 --> 00:17:07.726
THIS GIRL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
00:17:07.793 --> 00:17:08.861
SIR. ANY OTHER WITNESSES HERE IN
00:17:08.927 --> 00:17:10.362
THE HEARING ROOM IN SUPPORT?
00:17:10.429 --> 00:17:11.430
SEEING NONE. LET'S MOVED
00:17:11.497 --> 00:17:12.765
WITNESSES WILLING TO TESTIFY VIA
00:17:12.831 --> 00:17:14.199
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
00:17:14.266 --> 00:17:15.267
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
00:17:15.334 --> 00:17:16.769
SUCH INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
00:17:16.835 --> 00:17:18.203
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
00:17:18.270 --> 00:17:19.738
BILL 1954. WE WILL BEGIN WITH
00:17:19.805 --> 00:17:24.443
THEM. THANK YOU TO EXPRESS
00:17:24.510 --> 00:17:25.811
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL, PLEASE
00:17:25.878 --> 00:17:26.945
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO
00:17:27.012 --> 00:17:28.280
USING YOUR TELEPHONE. THE
00:17:28.347 --> 00:17:33.452
COMMANDERS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:17:33.519 --> 00:17:34.686
WILL GO TO LINE 43. PLEASE GO
00:17:34.753 --> 00:17:40.592
AHEAD. YES HI. GOOD AFTERNOON.
00:17:40.659 --> 00:17:42.694
SURE AND MEMBERS. THIS IS EDWIN
00:17:42.761 --> 00:17:44.329
BARBONE N BEHALF OF THE
00:17:44.396 --> 00:17:45.697
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
00:17:45.764 --> 00:17:47.399
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT THANK
00:17:47.466 --> 00:17:49.334
YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU, SIR.
00:17:49.401 --> 00:17:50.803
NEXT, PLEASE. THANK YOU. NO
00:17:50.869 --> 00:17:54.440
FURTHER LINES IN QUÊ. THANK YOU,
00:17:54.506 --> 00:17:55.874
MR MODERATOR. LET'S FOLLOW THE
00:17:55.941 --> 00:17:58.010
SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
00:17:58.076 --> 00:17:59.545
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION FIRST
00:17:59.611 --> 00:18:00.546
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
00:18:00.612 --> 00:18:03.916
HEARING ROOM. SAYING NONE LET'S
00:18:03.982 --> 00:18:05.250
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
00:18:05.317 --> 00:18:06.518
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION VIA
00:18:06.585 --> 00:18:07.052
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE. MR
00:18:07.119 --> 00:18:07.786
MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
00:18:07.853 --> 00:18:11.323
PROMPT ANY SUCH INDIVIDUALS
00:18:11.390 --> 00:18:13.091
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
00:18:13.158 --> 00:18:14.226
TO ASSEMBLY BILL 1954. WE WILL
00:18:14.293 --> 00:18:19.398
CONTINUE WITH THEM. THANK YOU TO
00:18:19.465 --> 00:18:21.266
EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL,
00:18:21.333 --> 00:18:22.401
PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
00:18:22.468 --> 00:18:23.836
ZERO AND YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD.
00:18:23.902 --> 00:18:25.070
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME,
00:18:25.137 --> 00:18:34.146
PLEASE. THANK YOU. THERE ARE NO
00:18:34.213 --> 00:18:35.214
LINES IN CUBA AT THIS TIME.
00:18:35.280 --> 00:18:37.382
THANK YOU, MR MARGARITO. LET'S
00:18:37.449 --> 00:18:38.684
BRING IT BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES
00:18:38.750 --> 00:18:39.818
IN THE HEARING ROOM COLLEAGUES.
00:18:39.885 --> 00:18:40.752
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS CONCERNS. DR
00:18:40.819 --> 00:18:43.755
PAN. ACTUALLY UM SO I DO HAVE A
00:18:43.822 --> 00:18:44.790
FEW QUESTIONS. I KNOW WHAT THEY
00:18:44.857 --> 00:18:46.892
WANT TO ESTABLISH QUORUM. I
00:18:46.959 --> 00:18:49.094
THINK WE HAVE A QUORUM. WE'LL
00:18:49.161 --> 00:18:49.728
TAKE YOUR QUESTIONS. SURE. NO,
00:18:49.795 --> 00:18:52.097
THANKS. THANK YOU. CHAIR SO
00:18:52.164 --> 00:18:53.465
FIRST OF ALL, SENATOR CORK
00:18:53.532 --> 00:18:55.734
APPRECIATE YOUR WORK WITH CMA.
00:18:55.801 --> 00:18:59.004
UM UM AND THE PURPOSE OF THE
00:18:59.071 --> 00:19:00.873
BILL. I GUESS THE QUESTION I
00:19:00.939 --> 00:19:02.841
WANT TO CLARIFY BECAUSE THE WAY
00:19:02.908 --> 00:19:04.943
THE BILLS PHRASED IS THAT IT'S
00:19:05.010 --> 00:19:05.911
ABOUT ANY TREATMENT. SO, FOR
00:19:05.978 --> 00:19:07.880
EXAMPLE, THERE ARE CERTAIN DRUGS
00:19:07.946 --> 00:19:08.647
THAT THERE ARE DRUG DRUG
00:19:08.714 --> 00:19:10.349
INTERACTIONS WITH YOUR WHO HAS
00:19:10.415 --> 00:19:13.318
THC. YOURS IS TAKING TAKING
00:19:13.385 --> 00:19:15.821
MEDICAL MARIJUANA. AND SO I WANT
00:19:15.888 --> 00:19:17.923
TO BE SURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE
00:19:17.990 --> 00:19:18.824
POSITIONS BEING DINGED BECAUSE
00:19:18.891 --> 00:19:21.159
THEY DECIDED NOT TO PRESCRIBE
00:19:21.226 --> 00:19:23.896
WARFARIN RIGHT FOR WHICH IS A
00:19:23.962 --> 00:19:25.163
ANTI CLOTTING AGENT, WHICH DOES
00:19:25.230 --> 00:19:27.099
HAVE AN INTERACTION WITH WITH
00:19:27.165 --> 00:19:30.636
THC. SO I JUST WANTED TO. SO I
00:19:30.702 --> 00:19:32.437
THINK ONE OF THE THINGS BECAUSE
00:19:32.504 --> 00:19:33.005
BECAUSE THIS THING DOESN'T
00:19:33.071 --> 00:19:35.073
SPECIFY IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT
00:19:35.140 --> 00:19:35.874
PAIN. IT'S PROBABLY ANY SORT OF
00:19:35.941 --> 00:19:37.442
MEDICATION. SO CAN YOU JUST
00:19:37.509 --> 00:19:38.744
ADDRESS WHAT'S THE YOU KNOW? HOW
00:19:38.810 --> 00:19:41.847
DO WE BE SURE THAT PHYSICIANS
00:19:41.914 --> 00:19:43.582
WHO REALLY ARE ACTING IN GOOD
00:19:43.649 --> 00:19:44.983
FAITH. THEY'RE NOT TRYING TO NOT
00:19:45.050 --> 00:19:46.518
CARE TO SOMEONE WHO'S ON MEDICAL
00:19:46.585 --> 00:19:47.920
CANNABIS, BUT OF COURSE, ARE
00:19:47.986 --> 00:19:49.555
EXERCISING CLINICAL JUDGMENT NOT
00:19:49.621 --> 00:19:51.423
AND ACTUALLY TRYING TO AVOID A
00:19:51.490 --> 00:19:53.559
DRUG DRUG INTERACTION. YOU KNOW,
00:19:53.625 --> 00:19:54.526
AND THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME
00:19:54.593 --> 00:19:55.928
KNOW AHEAD OF TIME ABOUT THAT
00:19:55.994 --> 00:19:58.063
QUESTION. UM MY STAFF AND THE
00:19:58.130 --> 00:19:59.698
SPONSOR, OF COURSE, WORKED WITH
00:19:59.765 --> 00:20:02.401
C M A AND OFTEN IN THE PROCESS
00:20:02.467 --> 00:20:09.274
THAT A B HUSING. A B 1954 DOES
00:20:09.341 --> 00:20:12.177
NOT LIMIT MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS
00:20:12.244 --> 00:20:13.178
FROM EXERCISING THEIR BEST
00:20:13.245 --> 00:20:14.646
JUDGMENT, SO CERTAINLY IF THEY
00:20:14.713 --> 00:20:16.515
SEE WAR, OFTEN AS GOOD COUNTER
00:20:16.582 --> 00:20:19.551
EDUCATED HOWEVER, IF YOU'RE
00:20:19.618 --> 00:20:20.919
CONCERNED ABOUT THE LANGUAGE, WE
00:20:20.986 --> 00:20:23.388
CAN SIT DOWN. YOU ME, CMA OR
00:20:23.455 --> 00:20:25.624
STAFFS WHOEVER AND JUST MAKE
00:20:25.691 --> 00:20:27.593
ABSOLUTELY SURE THAT THAT IS THE
00:20:27.659 --> 00:20:29.962
CASE AND I'M GLAD TO SET UP A
00:20:30.028 --> 00:20:32.030
MEETING ANYTIME. BECAUSE THAT IS
00:20:32.097 --> 00:20:33.198
OUR INTENTION AND I WOULDN'T
00:20:33.265 --> 00:20:35.000
WANT SOMEONE TAKING WARFARE AND
00:20:35.067 --> 00:20:36.735
WHO WAS TAKING ANY DRUG, BUT TH
00:20:36.802 --> 00:20:41.873
BUT. ONLY THC, BUT THERE ARE A
00:20:41.940 --> 00:20:43.809
HOST OF DIFFERENT CHEMICALS IN
00:20:43.875 --> 00:20:46.278
CANNABIS THAT POTENTIALLY COULD
00:20:46.345 --> 00:20:47.679
INTERACT POORLY WITH ANOTHER
00:20:47.746 --> 00:20:50.682
DRUG. NOW, I APPRECIATE THAT AND
00:20:50.749 --> 00:20:53.852
, FRANKLY, HAVEN'T HAD TIME TO,
00:20:53.919 --> 00:20:55.454
YOU KNOW, JUST ALL THE RED
00:20:55.520 --> 00:20:57.356
ANALYSIS SO FORTH AND JUST HAD
00:20:57.422 --> 00:20:57.990
THESE QUESTIONS SO I LOOK
00:20:58.056 --> 00:20:59.291
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU.
00:20:59.358 --> 00:21:00.926
IT'S PROBABLY FINE. I THINK THE
00:21:00.993 --> 00:21:04.062
MAIN THING IS TO ENSURE THAT
00:21:04.129 --> 00:21:06.264
THAT IT'S REALLY ABOUT HOW DO
00:21:06.331 --> 00:21:07.332
YOU ENFORCE THIS RIGHT? AND SO
00:21:07.399 --> 00:21:08.567
IT'S A MEDICAL BOARD SEES THIS
00:21:08.634 --> 00:21:10.135
IF THIS BECOMES LAW, WHICH I
00:21:10.202 --> 00:21:12.537
THINK YOU KNOW HOW THE MEDICAL
00:21:12.604 --> 00:21:14.406
BOARD OR A PROSECUTOR D A OR,
00:21:14.473 --> 00:21:15.974
YOU KNOW LOOKS AT THIS AND SAID,
00:21:16.041 --> 00:21:18.343
OH, LOOK, YOU DENIED TREATMENT
00:21:18.410 --> 00:21:20.445
TO A PERSON ON MEDICAL CANNABIS
00:21:20.512 --> 00:21:21.947
. IS THAT WELL ACTUALLY DIDN'T
00:21:22.014 --> 00:21:23.048
DENY THEM TREATMENT. WHAT I WAS
00:21:23.115 --> 00:21:24.950
DOING IS THAT THIS? I WAS
00:21:25.017 --> 00:21:25.951
DENYING THEM PARTICULAR
00:21:26.018 --> 00:21:26.985
MEDICATION, WHICH WOULD HAVE A
00:21:27.052 --> 00:21:29.187
DRUG DRUG INTERACTION. AND SO
00:21:29.254 --> 00:21:30.689
THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN GOOD
00:21:30.756 --> 00:21:32.691
MEDICAL CARE. AND EVEN IF THEY
00:21:32.758 --> 00:21:34.559
EVENTUALLY WON, YOU KNOW TO GO
00:21:34.626 --> 00:21:35.994
HAVE TO GO THROUGH ALL THAT
00:21:36.061 --> 00:21:38.163
EVERY TIME WE WOULD. IT
00:21:38.230 --> 00:21:39.164
CERTAINLY WOULD BE VERY
00:21:39.231 --> 00:21:40.298
CHALLENGING, SO I KNOW THAT'S
00:21:40.365 --> 00:21:41.299
NOT YOUR INTENT. BUT I
00:21:41.366 --> 00:21:43.602
APPRECIATE, UM ENSURE THAT THAT
00:21:43.669 --> 00:21:45.904
DOESN'T HAPPEN. MY GUESS IS THAT
00:21:45.971 --> 00:21:47.472
THERE'LL BE VERY LITTLE
00:21:47.539 --> 00:21:48.707
ENFORCEMENT ABOUT HIS. IT'S
00:21:48.774 --> 00:21:50.308
MAINLY SENDING A MESSAGE. YOU
00:21:50.375 --> 00:21:51.076
HAVE COMPLETE DISCRETION. IF YOU
00:21:51.143 --> 00:21:55.447
THINK. THAT IT'S JUST NOT GOOD
00:21:55.514 --> 00:21:57.082
TO TAKE FOR THIS PERSON TO TAKE
00:21:57.149 --> 00:21:59.518
CANNABIS AND OPIOIDS. YOU ARE
00:21:59.584 --> 00:22:01.486
ENTITLED TO SAY THAT OKAY? AND
00:22:01.553 --> 00:22:03.188
ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY IN YOUR
00:22:03.255 --> 00:22:05.691
DEFENSE IS THIS WAS MY BEST
00:22:05.757 --> 00:22:07.426
MEDICAL JUDGMENT. I DIDN'T BASE
00:22:07.492 --> 00:22:09.695
IT SOLELY ON A TEST THAT THEY
00:22:09.761 --> 00:22:12.364
HAD THC. I LOOK AT EACH PATIENT
00:22:12.431 --> 00:22:13.365
INDIVIDUALLY THAT WON'T TAKE
00:22:13.432 --> 00:22:15.934
LONG. AND THEY WILL BE FINE.
00:22:16.001 --> 00:22:17.803
WE'VE ALSO OF COURSE WORK WITH
00:22:17.869 --> 00:22:20.005
THE MEDICAL BOARD. THEY ASKED US
00:22:20.072 --> 00:22:21.506
TO TAKE AN AMENDMENT. I FORGOT
00:22:21.573 --> 00:22:23.575
WHICH ONE BUT AGAIN AS YOU LOOK
00:22:23.642 --> 00:22:25.210
IN THIS ANY QUESTIONS, YOUR
00:22:25.277 --> 00:22:27.045
STAFF, MY STAFF, YOU AND ME, SEE
00:22:27.112 --> 00:22:29.748
M A MEDICAL BOARD. WE CAN GET
00:22:29.815 --> 00:22:31.216
TOGETHER. WE'LL WORK IT OUT.
00:22:31.283 --> 00:22:33.351
THANK YOU ANY OTHER QUESTIONS,
00:22:33.418 --> 00:22:35.087
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? SEEING
00:22:35.153 --> 00:22:36.021
NONE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WOULD YOU
00:22:36.088 --> 00:22:39.024
LIKE TO CLOSE? UM I ASKED FOR
00:22:39.091 --> 00:22:41.460
YOUR I VOTE. THIS HAS BEEN A
00:22:41.526 --> 00:22:44.696
BIPARTISAN SUPPORTED MEASURE AND
00:22:44.763 --> 00:22:46.698
DR PAN AND I HAVE THE SAME GOAL
00:22:46.765 --> 00:22:47.933
IN MIND. THANK YOU, SIR. LET'S
00:22:47.999 --> 00:22:48.834
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. PLEASE CALL
00:22:48.900 --> 00:22:53.772
THE ROLL. SENATOR DRY HERE HERE
00:22:53.839 --> 00:22:56.808
, MELINDA'S OR CHILE TO BATES
00:22:56.875 --> 00:23:00.345
BATES HERE. BECKER HERE, DODD.
00:23:00.412 --> 00:23:02.481
THOUGHT HERE, EGGMAN EGGMAN.
00:23:02.547 --> 00:23:03.482
HEAR HER! TATO TATO HERE, JONES.
00:23:03.548 --> 00:23:08.653
LABOR. LABOR HERE, MEN MEN HERE.
00:23:08.720 --> 00:23:11.723
NEWMAN HERO KOBO. PAN IN HERE.
00:23:11.790 --> 00:23:16.461
WE HAVE A QUORUM. IS THERE A
00:23:16.528 --> 00:23:20.332
MOTION ON ASSEMBLY BILL 1954.
00:23:20.398 --> 00:23:22.300
BUT BY SENATOR NEWMAN, THE
00:23:22.367 --> 00:23:23.869
MOTION IS DUE PASS RE REFER THE
00:23:23.935 --> 00:23:25.170
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
00:23:25.237 --> 00:23:26.471
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON ASSEMBLY
00:23:26.538 --> 00:23:28.807
BILL 1954 PASS AND REFERRED TO
00:23:28.874 --> 00:23:33.745
ON APPROPRIATIONS. RIGHT? I AM
00:23:33.812 --> 00:23:37.449
MELINDA'S STILETTO BATES BATES,
00:23:37.516 --> 00:23:40.552
I BECKER DODD DOT I EGGMAN.
00:23:40.619 --> 00:23:46.291
EGGMAN. I HURTADO. TÔI JONES.
00:23:46.358 --> 00:23:49.361
LEVA LEVA AYMAN, THEN I NEWMAN
00:23:49.427 --> 00:23:54.366
KOBO. PAN, AND I THANK YOU FOR
00:23:54.432 --> 00:24:03.141
YOUR VOTE COUNT. SCUSE ME. 10 10
00:24:03.208 --> 00:24:05.210
VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLL OPEN
00:24:05.277 --> 00:24:06.311
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS. LET'S TAKE
00:24:06.378 --> 00:24:09.848
THE TAKE A MOTION ON ASSEMBLY
00:24:09.915 --> 00:24:15.220
BILL. 17 47. I BELIEVE THAT
00:24:15.287 --> 00:24:19.591
SENATOR NEWTON SENATOR NEWMAN
00:24:19.658 --> 00:24:22.060
ALSO MOVED THAT THE MOTION IS
00:24:22.127 --> 00:24:23.929
DUE PASS. WE REFER THE COMMITTEE
00:24:23.995 --> 00:24:24.963
ON APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL
00:24:25.030 --> 00:24:29.534
THE ROLL. A B 17 47 MOTION IS DO
00:24:29.601 --> 00:24:30.702
PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
00:24:30.769 --> 00:24:32.304
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS ROCK
00:24:32.370 --> 00:24:33.438
HIGH. MELINDA'S ARCHULETTA
00:24:33.505 --> 00:24:38.577
BATES. HI I BECKER DODD. GOD, I
00:24:38.643 --> 00:24:42.180
EGGMAN. EDMUND. I HURTADO. TÔI
00:24:42.247 --> 00:24:48.854
JONES. LABOR. LABOR AMEN. MEN I
00:24:48.920 --> 00:24:54.593
NEWMAN KOBO PAN AND I VOTES WILL
00:24:54.659 --> 00:24:56.361
HOLD THE ROAD OPEN FOR ABSENT
00:24:56.428 --> 00:25:03.335
MEMBERS. LET'S TURN BACK TO, UM. ITEM NUMBER ONE ASSEMBLY BILL
00:25:03.401 --> 00:25:08.540
351. THIS BILL WAS ALSO MOVED BY
00:25:08.607 --> 00:25:12.110
SENATOR NEWMAN MOTION. IS DO
00:25:12.177 --> 00:25:13.545
PASS RE REFER THE COMMITTEE ON
00:25:13.612 --> 00:25:16.882
HEALTH. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:25:16.948 --> 00:25:18.250
351 MOTION IS DO PASS AND
00:25:18.316 --> 00:25:20.452
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:25:20.518 --> 00:25:21.820
HEALTH. MELINDA'S ARCHULETTA.
00:25:21.887 --> 00:25:30.195
BATES. BECKER DODD EGGMAN.
00:25:30.262 --> 00:25:32.564
EDMUND. I HURTADO. HER DAUGHTER
00:25:32.631 --> 00:25:39.437
I. JONES. LABOR. AMEN. NEWMAN
00:25:39.504 --> 00:25:46.511
KOBO. CAN I. BILL HAS SEVEN
00:25:46.578 --> 00:25:47.679
VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROAD OPEN
00:25:47.746 --> 00:25:48.813
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS. AND WHILE
00:25:48.880 --> 00:25:51.349
WE'RE AT IT DO THE CONSENT
00:25:51.416 --> 00:25:55.387
CALENDAR. OR THREE BILLS
00:25:55.453 --> 00:25:57.422
PROPOSED FOR CONSENT. FILE ITEM
00:25:57.489 --> 00:26:00.325
NUMBER FOUR A B 27 45 FILE ITEM
00:26:00.392 --> 00:26:03.561
NUMBER NINE A B 18 13 AND FILE
00:26:03.628 --> 00:26:08.533
ITEM NUMBER 18. A B 29 72. IS
00:26:08.600 --> 00:26:13.171
THERE A MOTION? DR PAN MOVED BY
00:26:13.238 --> 00:26:16.841
DR PAN. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:26:16.908 --> 00:26:22.714
ROTH MELINDA'S ARCHULETTA. BATES
00:26:22.781 --> 00:26:26.151
I BECKER I DODD DOT I IGMAN.
00:26:26.217 --> 00:26:29.187
EDMUND. I HURTADO. HER TARGET. I
00:26:29.254 --> 00:26:34.759
JONES LABOR. BELIEVE THAT I'M IN
00:26:34.826 --> 00:26:40.198
MY NEWMAN. ALRIGHT, KOBO. PAM
00:26:40.265 --> 00:26:41.333
CONSENT CALENDAR HAS 10 VOTES
00:26:41.399 --> 00:26:42.500
HOLD THE ROLL OPEN FOR ABSENT
00:26:42.567 --> 00:26:45.370
MEMBERS. LET'S NOW MOVE TO A I
00:26:45.437 --> 00:26:47.973
SEE A SILLY MEMBER IRWIN IS HERE
00:26:48.039 --> 00:26:49.107
. ITEM NUMBER THREE AND ITEM
00:26:49.174 --> 00:26:53.678
NUMBER FOUR A B 11 20 A B 27 45
00:26:53.745 --> 00:27:01.353
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN READY. I WAS
00:27:01.419 --> 00:27:04.322
THINKING THAT, UH, I THINK I'M
00:27:04.389 --> 00:27:05.724
ONLY PRESENTING ONE BILL, RIGHT?
00:27:05.790 --> 00:27:07.359
ISN'T THE OTHER ONE IS
00:27:07.425 --> 00:27:08.493
UNCONCERNED? JUST MAKE SURE NO
00:27:08.560 --> 00:27:11.830
NOTES FOR THAT HERE. UM A B 11
00:27:11.896 --> 00:27:13.231
20 WOULD ALLOW HEALTH FACILITIES
00:27:13.298 --> 00:27:14.899
AND HOSPITALS TO AUTHORIZE THE
00:27:14.966 --> 00:27:16.601
USE OF NEW BLOOD COLLECTION
00:27:16.668 --> 00:27:19.571
METHODS AND DEVICES. CALIFORNIA
00:27:19.637 --> 00:27:21.706
IS THE ONLY STATE THAT REQUIRES
00:27:21.773 --> 00:27:23.942
PHLEBOTOMIST TO USE NEEDLES TO
00:27:24.009 --> 00:27:24.809
DRAW BLOOD, EVEN THOUGH NEW,
00:27:24.876 --> 00:27:25.844
NEEDLESS BLOOD COLLECTION
00:27:25.910 --> 00:27:29.247
METHODS EXIST. THESE METHODS ARE
00:27:29.314 --> 00:27:31.883
SAFE AND EFFECTIVE, HAS NOTED IN
00:27:31.950 --> 00:27:34.052
THE ANALYSIS, THERE HAVE BEEN
00:27:34.119 --> 00:27:36.855
FIVE PEER REVIEWED STUDIES. UM
00:27:36.921 --> 00:27:37.856
UH, PUBLISHED DETAILING THEIR
00:27:37.922 --> 00:27:41.426
EFFICIENCY. VIEWS DEVICES HAVE
00:27:41.493 --> 00:27:42.894
BEEN USED OVER THREE MILLION
00:27:42.961 --> 00:27:46.097
TIMES WITH NO ADVERSE EFFECTS
00:27:46.164 --> 00:27:48.500
AND HALF OF THOSE THREE MILLION
00:27:48.566 --> 00:27:51.836
TIMES WERE BY PLAY BOTTOM ISTS.
00:27:51.903 --> 00:27:55.073
THIS IS PERSONAL TO ME. LAST OF
00:27:55.140 --> 00:27:57.208
FALL. MY DAUGHTER IN LAW WAS IN
00:27:57.275 --> 00:27:59.477
THE HOSPITAL FOR TWO WEEKS AND
00:27:59.544 --> 00:28:02.247
TWICE A DAY. THE FLAT BOTTOM IST
00:28:02.313 --> 00:28:03.381
CAME IN TO STICKER WITH A
00:28:03.448 --> 00:28:05.950
NEEDLE. WHEN ONE OF THESE
00:28:06.017 --> 00:28:07.185
DEVICES COULD HAVE BEEN USED.
00:28:07.252 --> 00:28:09.087
SHE SENT US PICTURES AT THE END
00:28:09.154 --> 00:28:11.222
OF HER HOSPITAL STAY. BOTH OF
00:28:11.289 --> 00:28:12.323
HER ARMS WERE COMPLETELY BLACK
00:28:12.390 --> 00:28:15.060
AND BLUE. CALIFORNIA PATIENTS
00:28:15.126 --> 00:28:18.930
DESERVE ACCESS TO NEW MEDICAL
00:28:18.997 --> 00:28:20.632
PRACTICES THAT ARE SAFE AND
00:28:20.698 --> 00:28:22.567
EFFECTIVE AND MORE COMFORTABLE
00:28:22.634 --> 00:28:25.570
WITH ME. HERE TO SUPPORT IS DR P
00:28:25.637 --> 00:28:27.972
. TWO DEV GONE OF VILLANO
00:28:28.039 --> 00:28:30.241
VASCULAR AND THEN FOR QUESTIONS
00:28:30.308 --> 00:28:31.242
, RYAN SPENCER, WHO REPRESENTS
00:28:31.309 --> 00:28:33.178
THE COMPANY. OKAY. PLEASE
00:28:33.244 --> 00:28:38.349
PROCEED. THREE MINUTES. THANK
00:28:38.416 --> 00:28:39.851
YOU, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S OR NGUYEN.
00:28:39.918 --> 00:28:41.853
MY NAME IS DR P SHOULD'VE GONE
00:28:41.920 --> 00:28:43.922
AND I AM THE INVENTOR OF THE FDA
00:28:43.988 --> 00:28:45.023
CLEARED NEEDLE FREE BLOOD DROP
00:28:45.090 --> 00:28:46.825
TECHNOLOGY CALLED TIVO. WITH A
00:28:46.891 --> 00:28:47.692
SINGLE USE DISPOSABLE DEVICE
00:28:47.759 --> 00:28:49.327
THAT TEMPORARILY CONNECT TO
00:28:49.394 --> 00:28:50.695
HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS PERIPHERAL
00:28:50.762 --> 00:28:51.729
I'D CATHETER THE NEIGHBORHOOD
00:28:51.796 --> 00:28:52.464
VIRTUALLY PAINLESS AND RELIABLE
00:28:52.530 --> 00:28:55.300
BLOOD COLLECTION. MUSCLES AROUND
00:28:55.366 --> 00:28:56.367
THE COUNTRY, INCLUDING IN
00:28:56.434 --> 00:28:57.769
CALIFORNIA ARE ADOPTING I V
00:28:57.836 --> 00:28:59.471
CATHETER BLOOD COLLECTION WITH
00:28:59.537 --> 00:29:01.573
PEOPLE TO IMPROVE THE PATIENT'S
00:29:01.639 --> 00:29:02.407
EXPERIENCE BY ELIMINATING
00:29:02.474 --> 00:29:03.741
PAINFUL NEEDLES REDUCE THE RISK
00:29:03.808 --> 00:29:04.776
OF ACCIDENTAL NEEDLE INJURIES
00:29:04.843 --> 00:29:07.412
FOR THEIR STAFF. AND APPROVED
00:29:07.479 --> 00:29:08.713
LAB EFFICIENCY BY REDUCING
00:29:08.780 --> 00:29:09.814
REJECTED SAMPLE RATE THAT MOST
00:29:09.881 --> 00:29:12.117
LABS ARE PLAYED WITH. THE
00:29:12.183 --> 00:29:13.184
REQUEST. EVIDENCE SUPPORTING
00:29:13.251 --> 00:29:14.953
BLOOD DRAWS FROM IVY CATHETERS
00:29:15.019 --> 00:29:16.221
WITH PIVO, INCLUDING MULTIPLE
00:29:16.287 --> 00:29:18.089
PURE REVIEW JOURNAL PUBLICATIONS
00:29:18.156 --> 00:29:19.557
AND WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THE MOST
00:29:19.624 --> 00:29:20.992
RECENTLY PUBLISHED THIS IS LAST
00:29:21.059 --> 00:29:22.327
YEAR, THE LARGEST REAL WORLD
00:29:22.393 --> 00:29:24.395
STUDY OF A LITTLE BLOOD DROP
00:29:24.462 --> 00:29:25.296
CONDUCTED BY INTERMOUNTAIN
00:29:25.363 --> 00:29:27.832
HEALTHCARE. INTERMOUNTAIN IS THE
00:29:27.899 --> 00:29:29.400
LARGEST HOSPITAL SYSTEM IN UTAH,
00:29:29.467 --> 00:29:30.902
THE CAPITAL OF 50% OF ALL THE
00:29:30.969 --> 00:29:32.804
BEDS AND THEIR STATE, AND LIKE
00:29:32.871 --> 00:29:34.205
MOST LARGE HEALTH SYSTEMS, THEY
00:29:34.272 --> 00:29:35.173
RELY ON PHLEBOTOMIST TO COLLECT
00:29:35.240 --> 00:29:36.808
THE MAJORITY OF THEIR IMPATIENT
00:29:36.875 --> 00:29:39.077
BLOOD SAMPLES. A TRACTOR
00:29:39.144 --> 00:29:40.545
PHLEBOTOMIST USING PIVO ACROSS
00:29:40.612 --> 00:29:42.714
22 HOSPITALS OVER TWO YEARS,
00:29:42.780 --> 00:29:43.248
WHICH ENCOMPASSED 210,000
00:29:43.314 --> 00:29:46.818
PATIENTS ADMISSION. WE BELIEVE
00:29:46.885 --> 00:29:49.087
THIS IS THE LARGEST STUDY OF THE
00:29:49.154 --> 00:29:50.054
BLOOD COLLECTION DEVICE EVER
00:29:50.121 --> 00:29:51.122
PERFORMED. THE KEY FINDINGS OF
00:29:51.189 --> 00:29:54.692
THE STUDY. ONE OR THE 56%
00:29:54.759 --> 00:29:56.361
REDUCTION IN THE BLOOD SAMPLE
00:29:56.427 --> 00:29:57.428
REJECTED SAMPLE RIGHT SO
00:29:57.495 --> 00:29:59.531
BASICALLY 6 56% REDUCTION IN
00:29:59.597 --> 00:30:01.065
ERRORS AND BLOOD COLLECTION
00:30:01.132 --> 00:30:03.201
USING THE DEVICE AND A 19%
00:30:03.268 --> 00:30:05.570
REDUCTION. IN THE CATHETER
00:30:05.637 --> 00:30:06.571
REPLACEMENT LEFT. I V CATHETER
00:30:06.638 --> 00:30:09.407
COMPLICATION. SUMMARIZE THE
00:30:09.474 --> 00:30:10.241
BOTTOM. IT'S SAFELY AND
00:30:10.308 --> 00:30:12.443
EFFICIENTLY PERFORM NEEDLE FREE
00:30:12.510 --> 00:30:13.178
BLOOD DRAWS AND ACTUALLY
00:30:13.244 --> 00:30:14.812
IMPROVED CATHETER OUTCOME
00:30:14.879 --> 00:30:17.949
SIMULTANEOUSLY AT MATTERS SCALE.
00:30:18.016 --> 00:30:19.083
IN ADDITION TO THE PUBLIC
00:30:19.150 --> 00:30:22.453
STUDIES, PIVO IS NOW BEING USED
00:30:22.520 --> 00:30:24.455
MORE THAN 343 MILLION TIMES. UM
00:30:24.522 --> 00:30:25.557
OVER THE LAST 67 YEARS SINCE RFD
00:30:25.623 --> 00:30:28.326
ORIGINAL CLEARANCE. THE MAJORITY
00:30:28.393 --> 00:30:30.195
OF THOSE DRAWS WORK BY TRAIN,
00:30:30.261 --> 00:30:31.462
PHLEBOTOMIST AND OTHER STATES.
00:30:31.529 --> 00:30:33.097
AND LIKE THE WOMAN, HERMAN
00:30:33.164 --> 00:30:34.132
MENTIONED THERE'S BEEN ZERO
00:30:34.199 --> 00:30:36.568
PATIENT ADVERSE EVENT. PATIENT
00:30:36.634 --> 00:30:38.102
SAFETY IS PARAMOUNT. AND THIS
00:30:38.169 --> 00:30:39.370
NEW PROCEDURE STILL HAS NURSING
00:30:39.437 --> 00:30:40.872
IN FULL CONTROL OF THE PATIENT'S
00:30:40.939 --> 00:30:42.607
I V THERAPY AT THE BOTTOM, IT'S
00:30:42.674 --> 00:30:44.709
WILL NEVER START. STOP OR PAUSE
00:30:44.776 --> 00:30:46.744
. ANY RUNNING. I V INFUSION.
00:30:46.811 --> 00:30:48.012
THEY WERE NOT INSERT OR REMOVE
00:30:48.079 --> 00:30:49.113
ANY CATHETERS, AND THIS IS
00:30:49.180 --> 00:30:51.049
ACTUALLY IN THE BILL LANGUAGE.
00:30:51.115 --> 00:30:52.517
LAPSLEY ALSO A BOTANIST AND
00:30:52.584 --> 00:30:54.085
NURSES, COMPLETE IN PERSON
00:30:54.152 --> 00:30:55.320
TRAINING AND DEMONSTRATE
00:30:55.386 --> 00:30:56.521
COMPETENCY TO PERFORM THE
00:30:56.588 --> 00:30:57.488
PROCEDURE SAFELY AND EFFECTIVELY
00:30:57.555 --> 00:30:59.190
. THAT'S THE WAY IT ALWAYS IS
00:30:59.257 --> 00:31:01.259
DONE. IN CALIFORNIA TODAY. THE
00:31:01.326 --> 00:31:02.527
MAJORITY OF BLOOD DRAWS ARE
00:31:02.594 --> 00:31:04.095
CONDUCTED BY PHLEBOTOMIST AND IT
00:31:04.162 --> 00:31:05.463
STILL ENABLE THEM AND
00:31:05.530 --> 00:31:06.965
COLLABORATION WITH THEIR NURSE
00:31:07.031 --> 00:31:07.699
COLLEAGUES TO UTILIZE THE SAFER
00:31:07.765 --> 00:31:09.467
AND MORE HUMANE PROCEDURE FOR
00:31:09.534 --> 00:31:10.301
THEIR JOB, URGED THE COMMITTEE
00:31:10.368 --> 00:31:13.571
TO VOTE. I THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:31:13.638 --> 00:31:15.473
THANK YOU, SIR. LET'S HEAR NOW
00:31:15.540 --> 00:31:16.741
FROM ANY OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES
00:31:16.808 --> 00:31:18.176
IN THE HEARING ROOM. STEP
00:31:18.243 --> 00:31:22.747
FORWARD. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
00:31:22.814 --> 00:31:24.882
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MOIRA TAP
00:31:24.949 --> 00:31:26.150
ON BEHALF OF BIO COM CALIFORNIA
00:31:26.217 --> 00:31:28.353
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:31:28.419 --> 00:31:29.454
ANY OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES HERE
00:31:29.520 --> 00:31:31.456
IN THE HEARING ROOM? SEEING NONE
00:31:31.522 --> 00:31:32.290
THAT'S MOVED TO WITNESSES
00:31:32.357 --> 00:31:33.691
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
00:31:33.758 --> 00:31:35.193
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
00:31:35.260 --> 00:31:36.561
MODERATOR. IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
00:31:36.628 --> 00:31:37.662
PROMPT ANY SUCH INDIVIDUALS
00:31:37.729 --> 00:31:39.330
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT.
00:31:39.397 --> 00:31:40.698
ASSEMBLY BILL 11 20. WE WILL
00:31:40.765 --> 00:31:46.070
BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK YOU WOULD
00:31:46.137 --> 00:31:47.105
LIKE TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS
00:31:47.171 --> 00:31:49.307
BILL HAVE NOT ALREADY DONE SO
00:31:49.374 --> 00:31:50.875
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO.
00:31:50.942 --> 00:31:52.010
AGAIN. THAT'S ONE AND THEN ZERO
00:31:52.076 --> 00:31:54.245
ON YOUR TELEPHONE. WE'LL GO
00:31:54.312 --> 00:31:59.851
FIRST IN LINE NUMBER 53. MR
00:31:59.917 --> 00:32:01.452
CHAIR MEMBERS, JOHN WINGER ON
00:32:01.519 --> 00:32:03.087
BEHALF OF THE ADVANCED MEDICAL
00:32:03.154 --> 00:32:03.955
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION AND
00:32:04.022 --> 00:32:05.523
SUPPORT THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT,
00:32:05.590 --> 00:32:11.696
PLEASE. HER LINE 33 0. GOOD
00:32:11.763 --> 00:32:14.165
AFTERNOON, REPRESENTING THE
00:32:14.232 --> 00:32:15.400
CALIFORNIA SOCIETY OF HEALTH
00:32:15.466 --> 00:32:16.868
SYSTEM, PHARMACISTS AND SUPPORT
00:32:16.934 --> 00:32:17.969
. THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
00:32:18.036 --> 00:32:20.872
PLEASE. THANK YOU. NO FURTHER
00:32:20.938 --> 00:32:23.441
LINES IN QUEUE FOR SUPPORT. HIS
00:32:23.508 --> 00:32:25.343
FATHER, SAME PROCESS AND HEAR
00:32:25.410 --> 00:32:26.544
FROM ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
00:32:26.611 --> 00:32:28.980
FIRST. OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
00:32:29.047 --> 00:32:30.815
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT
00:32:30.882 --> 00:32:32.083
CURTIS LANG WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:32:32.150 --> 00:32:35.186
NURSES ASSOCIATION. WILL TESTIFY
00:32:35.253 --> 00:32:36.254
IN OPPOSITION, EITHER IN THE
00:32:36.321 --> 00:32:39.824
HEARING ROOM OR ON THE LINE.
00:32:39.891 --> 00:32:40.925
GOOD AFTERNOON, MR TERRA. I'M
00:32:40.992 --> 00:32:42.193
HERE ON THE LINE. OKAY, PLEASE
00:32:42.260 --> 00:32:44.696
PROCEED. YES I'M CURTIS, ALONG
00:32:44.762 --> 00:32:45.697
WITH THE CALIFORNIA NURSES
00:32:45.763 --> 00:32:47.231
ASSOCIATION, REPRESENTING OVER
00:32:47.298 --> 00:32:48.366
100,000 REGISTERED NURSES IN
00:32:48.433 --> 00:32:49.467
CALIFORNIA AND WERE STRONGLY
00:32:49.534 --> 00:32:51.703
OPPOSED TO BE 11 20. PATIENT
00:32:51.769 --> 00:32:53.838
ADVOCATES. SIENNA IS NOT OPPOSED
00:32:53.905 --> 00:32:55.907
TO THE ADVANCEMENT IN TECHNOLOGY
00:32:55.973 --> 00:32:56.974
THAT MINIMIZE PATIENT NEEDLE
00:32:57.041 --> 00:32:58.876
STICKS. QUITE THE CONTRARY,
00:32:58.943 --> 00:32:59.877
NURSES ARE VERY COMPASSIONATE
00:32:59.944 --> 00:33:00.978
ABOUT THEIR PATIENTS AND THE
00:33:01.045 --> 00:33:02.413
CARE THEY PROVIDE. AND WE'LL DO
00:33:02.480 --> 00:33:03.781
ALL THEY CAN TO MINIMIZE PAIN
00:33:03.848 --> 00:33:05.516
AND TRAUMA EXPERIENCED BY THEIR
00:33:05.583 --> 00:33:08.052
PATIENT. HOWEVER NURSES DO
00:33:08.119 --> 00:33:09.987
OPPOSE THE USE OF UNLICENSED AND
00:33:10.054 --> 00:33:12.123
INACTIVITY EDUCATED LOBOTOMY.
00:33:12.190 --> 00:33:14.058
USE THIS TECHNOLOGY ACCESS
00:33:14.125 --> 00:33:15.159
PERIPHERAL VENUS CAPITALS FOR
00:33:15.226 --> 00:33:16.294
THE PURPOSE OF THE DRAWING
00:33:16.361 --> 00:33:18.196
BLOOD. PATIENTS RECEIVING
00:33:18.262 --> 00:33:20.331
INFUSION THERAPY. THIS PROCEDURE
00:33:20.398 --> 00:33:21.899
IS BEYOND THE SCOPE OF THE
00:33:21.966 --> 00:33:22.834
BOTANIST AND POSSESS A THREAT TO
00:33:22.900 --> 00:33:23.735
HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
00:33:23.801 --> 00:33:26.771
HOSPITALIZED. POSSESSING THE
00:33:26.838 --> 00:33:28.806
EDUCATION AND EXPERIENCE TO CARE
00:33:28.873 --> 00:33:29.841
FOR AND TO MANAGE AN I V
00:33:29.907 --> 00:33:31.809
CATHETER IS AN ESSENTIAL
00:33:31.876 --> 00:33:32.944
REQUIREMENT TO DRAW BLOOD SAFELY
00:33:33.010 --> 00:33:35.713
FROM CATTLE. CURRENT EDUCATION
00:33:35.780 --> 00:33:36.914
REQUIREMENTS DID NOT PREPARE FOR
00:33:36.981 --> 00:33:38.683
THE BOTTOM IS HERE AND
00:33:38.750 --> 00:33:40.184
MANAGEMENT OF PERIPHERALLY AND
00:33:40.251 --> 00:33:42.320
STARTED INTRAVENOUS CATHETERS.
00:33:42.387 --> 00:33:44.889
AND A FACILITY OFFERED TECHNICAL
00:33:44.956 --> 00:33:48.459
TRAINING IS SIMPLY NOT ENOUGH TO
00:33:48.526 --> 00:33:49.026
SAFELY USE AN APPARATUS TO
00:33:49.093 --> 00:33:51.829
WITHDRAW BLOOD FROM IVY CAP.
00:33:51.896 --> 00:33:53.931
INSERTION OF I'VE CATHETERS,
00:33:53.998 --> 00:33:56.033
POST INSERTION CARE THE I THE,
00:33:56.100 --> 00:33:58.202
UM, SITE. THE MANAGEMENT OF I V
00:33:58.269 --> 00:34:00.071
INFUSION IS A PROFESSIONAL
00:34:00.138 --> 00:34:00.872
RESPONSIBILITY. DIRECT CARE
00:34:00.938 --> 00:34:03.441
REGISTERED NERVES. CANNOT BE
00:34:03.508 --> 00:34:04.842
DELEGATED TO UNLICENSED
00:34:04.909 --> 00:34:07.979
PERSONNEL INSERTION OF AN I V
00:34:08.045 --> 00:34:09.480
CATHETER INTO A PATIENT CREATES
00:34:09.547 --> 00:34:11.082
A PATHWAY DIRECTLY INTO THE
00:34:11.149 --> 00:34:11.582
BLOODSTREAM. IT REQUIRES
00:34:11.649 --> 00:34:15.486
EXCELLENT TECHNIQUE. SPOKE FOR
00:34:15.553 --> 00:34:16.120
THE INSERTION AND FOR THE POST
00:34:16.187 --> 00:34:18.189
INSERTS AND MANAGEMENT OF THE
00:34:18.256 --> 00:34:19.924
CATHETER CATHETER INSERTION SITE
00:34:19.991 --> 00:34:21.759
IN ORDER TO MINIMIZE THE
00:34:21.826 --> 00:34:22.860
LIKELIHOOD OF INFECTION OR THE
00:34:22.927 --> 00:34:24.328
INTRODUCTION OF BACTERIA.
00:34:24.395 --> 00:34:26.764
DIRECTLY INTO THE BLOOD. THAT IS
00:34:26.831 --> 00:34:28.900
WHY IT IS THE GOAL OF EVERY RN
00:34:28.966 --> 00:34:30.935
TO PRESERVE AND PROTECT EVERY
00:34:31.002 --> 00:34:33.404
PERIPHERALLY INSERTED CAPITA IN
00:34:33.471 --> 00:34:35.106
ORDER TO BE ABLE TO ADMINISTER
00:34:35.173 --> 00:34:36.407
PHYSICIAN ORDERED I V THERAPY,
00:34:36.474 --> 00:34:38.376
INCLUDING THE MEDICATION AND TO
00:34:38.443 --> 00:34:41.145
AVOID HAVING TO REPLACE THE I V
00:34:41.212 --> 00:34:42.313
CATHETER, CAUSING THE PATIENT
00:34:42.380 --> 00:34:44.449
ADDITIONAL PAIN AND DISCOMFORT.
00:34:44.515 --> 00:34:45.650
FOR THAT REASON, THE MANAGEMENT
00:34:45.716 --> 00:34:49.153
OF THE IVY SITE AND ACCESS THE I
00:34:49.220 --> 00:34:50.521
V CATHETER SHOULD BE LIMITED TO
00:34:50.588 --> 00:34:51.556
POSITIONS IN LICENSED NURSES IN
00:34:51.622 --> 00:34:53.958
THE HOSPITAL SETTING. SO THE
00:34:54.025 --> 00:34:56.194
QUESTION IS, WHY DO WE NEED THIS
00:34:56.260 --> 00:34:56.994
LEGISLATION? NURSES ARE ALREADY
00:34:57.061 --> 00:34:58.262
USING THIS TECHNOLOGY IN
00:34:58.329 --> 00:34:59.831
CALIFORNIA TO MINIMIZE PATIENT
00:34:59.897 --> 00:35:01.866
NEEDLE STICKS ARE MEMBERS LIKE
00:35:01.933 --> 00:35:03.201
THE DEVICE AND CURRENTLY USE IT
00:35:03.267 --> 00:35:04.302
TO MINIMIZE PATIENT NEEDLE
00:35:04.368 --> 00:35:07.505
STICK. IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE TO
00:35:07.572 --> 00:35:08.739
HAVE A REGISTERED NURSE.
00:35:08.806 --> 00:35:10.508
STARTING I V EVALUATE THE I V
00:35:10.575 --> 00:35:12.543
LINES STOP AND FLUSH. THE LINE
00:35:12.610 --> 00:35:14.245
DIDN'T HAVE IT. OBAMA'S ATTACHED
00:35:14.312 --> 00:35:15.947
TO A CATHETER TO THE LINE HAVE A
00:35:16.013 --> 00:35:17.048
BLOCK OBAMA'S DRUG DROP OF
00:35:17.114 --> 00:35:18.950
BLOOD. DIDN'T HAVE THE
00:35:19.016 --> 00:35:19.951
REGISTERED NURSE FLUSH AND WE
00:35:20.017 --> 00:35:21.953
START THE LINE. THIS IS A
00:35:22.019 --> 00:35:23.454
DISRUPTION OF WORKFLOW, WHICH
00:35:23.521 --> 00:35:24.355
PULLED THE NURSE AWAY FROM OTHER
00:35:24.422 --> 00:35:26.324
PATIENTS THAT NEED NURSING CARE
00:35:26.390 --> 00:35:28.526
WHEN THE NURSE CAN JUST USE THE
00:35:28.593 --> 00:35:29.894
DEVICE, HER OR HIMSELF. FOR
00:35:29.961 --> 00:35:31.696
THESE REASONS, WE ASKED NO ON A
00:35:31.762 --> 00:35:34.799
B 11 20 TODAY. THANK THANK YOU.
00:35:34.866 --> 00:35:35.900
LET'S MOVE TO ANY OTHER
00:35:35.967 --> 00:35:36.868
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
00:35:36.934 --> 00:35:38.903
HEARING ROOM. STEP FORWARD NAME
00:35:38.970 --> 00:35:39.837
AFFILIATION POSITION ON THE
00:35:39.904 --> 00:35:45.676
MEASURE, PLEASE. MR CHAIRMAN
00:35:45.743 --> 00:35:47.278
MEMBERS RAN BARTON ON BEHALF OF
00:35:47.345 --> 00:35:49.180
THE AIDS HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION
00:35:49.247 --> 00:35:50.882
IN VERY STRONG BUT RESPECTFUL
00:35:50.948 --> 00:35:52.717
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL ALIGNED
00:35:52.783 --> 00:35:53.818
WITH THE COMMENTS FROM THE
00:35:53.885 --> 00:35:54.785
CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION.
00:35:54.852 --> 00:35:57.455
THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT, PLEASE.
00:35:57.522 --> 00:35:57.989
LOW CHAIR MEMBERS. JANICE
00:35:58.055 --> 00:36:04.529
COULDN'T SKIP THIS. SOMALI WITH
00:36:04.595 --> 00:36:05.730
THE AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE
00:36:05.796 --> 00:36:06.797
COUNTY MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES AND
00:36:06.864 --> 00:36:07.665
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
00:36:07.732 --> 00:36:11.969
YOU. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR,
00:36:12.036 --> 00:36:12.703
EDUARDO MARTINEZ WITH THE
00:36:12.770 --> 00:36:14.338
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION IN
00:36:14.405 --> 00:36:14.906
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
00:36:14.972 --> 00:36:17.441
YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. MATTLAGE DAY
00:36:17.508 --> 00:36:18.342
WITH STU, CALIFORNIA AND
00:36:18.409 --> 00:36:20.144
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK YOU
00:36:20.211 --> 00:36:21.979
ANY OTHER WITNESSES HERE IN THE
00:36:22.046 --> 00:36:23.047
HEARING ROOM IN OPPOSITION TO
00:36:23.114 --> 00:36:25.249
THE MEASURE? NOW LET'S MOVE TO
00:36:25.316 --> 00:36:26.684
WITNESSES WILLING TO TESTIFY IN
00:36:26.751 --> 00:36:27.518
OPPOSITION VIEW THE
00:36:27.585 --> 00:36:28.853
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
00:36:28.920 --> 00:36:29.887
, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
00:36:29.954 --> 00:36:31.255
SUCH INDIVIDUALS WAITING,
00:36:31.322 --> 00:36:32.256
TESTIFYING, OPPOSITION TO
00:36:32.323 --> 00:36:33.724
ASSEMBLY BUILT 11 20. WE WILL
00:36:33.791 --> 00:36:37.528
CONTINUE WITH THEM. THANK YOU TO
00:36:37.595 --> 00:36:39.263
EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
00:36:39.330 --> 00:36:40.464
PRESS 10 ON YOUR TELEPHONE
00:36:40.531 --> 00:36:42.934
KEYPAD. AGAIN THE INSTRUCTIONS
00:36:43.000 --> 00:36:50.608
ARE ONE FOLLOWED BY ZERO. THANK
00:36:50.675 --> 00:36:52.510
YOU. THERE ARE NO LINES IN CUBA
00:36:52.577 --> 00:36:54.679
AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
00:36:54.745 --> 00:36:56.814
MODERATOR. UM LET'S NOW BRING
00:36:56.881 --> 00:36:58.449
THE CONVERSATION BACK TO MY
00:36:58.516 --> 00:37:00.217
COLLEAGUES HERE IN THE HEARING
00:37:00.284 --> 00:37:01.452
ROOM. BUT BEFORE I DO THAT, LET
00:37:01.519 --> 00:37:03.354
ME JUST ASK. ONE OR TWO QUICK
00:37:03.421 --> 00:37:06.190
QUESTIONS OF THE AUTHOR. IS
00:37:06.257 --> 00:37:07.024
THERE. ARE THERE ANY OTHER
00:37:07.091 --> 00:37:08.826
DEVICE MANUFACTURERS? BESIDES
00:37:08.893 --> 00:37:10.194
THE ONE THAT PROVIDES EVIL
00:37:10.261 --> 00:37:12.229
REFERENCED IN THE ANALYSIS?
00:37:12.296 --> 00:37:14.565
THERE'S UM AT LEAST TWO OR THREE
00:37:14.632 --> 00:37:16.267
OTHERS, BUT I THINK, DR UM DEV.
00:37:16.334 --> 00:37:19.670
GONE WOULD BE ABLE TO GIVE THE
00:37:19.737 --> 00:37:25.009
EXACT NUMBER. SURE HI. THIS IS
00:37:25.076 --> 00:37:26.944
DOCTOR. DO YOU MEAN OTHER OTHER
00:37:27.011 --> 00:37:27.912
TECHNOLOGIES THAT ARE SIMILAR OR
00:37:27.979 --> 00:37:30.081
THAT THE BILL IS DESIGNED TO BE
00:37:30.147 --> 00:37:31.749
AGNOSTIC TO THE TECHNOLOGY. IT
00:37:31.816 --> 00:37:32.750
DOES NOT MENTION PEOPLE
00:37:32.817 --> 00:37:34.719
SPECIFICALLY AT ALL. IT WAS JUST
00:37:34.785 --> 00:37:36.854
MENTIONED IN OUR ANALYSIS IS THE
00:37:36.921 --> 00:37:38.089
ONLY REASON I ASKED SO THERE ARE
00:37:38.155 --> 00:37:40.091
OTHER MANUFACTURERS THAT ARE OUT
00:37:40.157 --> 00:37:40.658
THERE. MANUFACTURING SIMILAR
00:37:40.725 --> 00:37:41.459
TECHNOLOGIES TO ACCOMPLISH THIS.
00:37:41.525 --> 00:37:47.064
BLOOD DROP. WE HAD THE FIRST
00:37:47.131 --> 00:37:48.265
WERE THE FIRST TO MARKET WE WERE
00:37:48.332 --> 00:37:49.700
THAT WE WERE THE EARLY ADOPTERS
00:37:49.767 --> 00:37:51.435
OF VENTURE BACKED COMPANY THAT
00:37:51.502 --> 00:37:52.570
WAS DEPARTED BY BD LAST YEAR, SO
00:37:52.637 --> 00:37:54.672
AS FAR AS WE KNOW, WE ARE THE
00:37:54.739 --> 00:37:55.773
FIRST THERE ARE NEW TECHNOLOGIES
00:37:55.840 --> 00:37:57.308
THAT ARE COMING OUT FROM
00:37:57.375 --> 00:37:58.476
COMPETITORS. I'M NOT SURE WHAT
00:37:58.542 --> 00:37:59.777
THEY WILL BE THERE MICRO NEEDLE
00:37:59.844 --> 00:38:01.579
ARRAYS AND OTHERS THAT ARE OUT
00:38:01.646 --> 00:38:02.680
THERE, BUT I CAN'T SPEAK
00:38:02.747 --> 00:38:04.448
DIRECTLY TO THE COMPETITION.
00:38:04.515 --> 00:38:06.484
OKAY THANK YOU. WE NORMALLY
00:38:06.550 --> 00:38:08.352
INTERESTED IN WHETHER IT'S A
00:38:08.419 --> 00:38:09.920
SINGLE SOURCE BILL OR NOT, AND
00:38:09.987 --> 00:38:11.856
THEN MY I WOULD ADD, THOUGH THE
00:38:11.922 --> 00:38:13.491
BILL DOES AUTHORIZES FACILITIES
00:38:13.557 --> 00:38:15.159
TO BE ABLE TO GET THIS DEVICE.
00:38:15.226 --> 00:38:16.594
IT DOES NOT REQUIRE SPECIFIC TO
00:38:16.661 --> 00:38:17.795
DIE DEVICE BE USED. THIS BILL
00:38:17.862 --> 00:38:19.964
COULD GO INTO THE LAW. AT THE
00:38:20.031 --> 00:38:21.932
START OF NEXT YEAR. AND YOU
00:38:21.999 --> 00:38:22.833
KNOW, THEORETICALLY, NOTHING CAN
00:38:22.900 --> 00:38:24.235
HAPPEN. IT'S JUST RIGHT NOW. IF
00:38:24.301 --> 00:38:25.202
A FACILITY JUST WANTS TO
00:38:25.269 --> 00:38:26.470
IMPLEMENT THIS DEVICE THEY
00:38:26.537 --> 00:38:28.005
CANNOT SO IT DOESN'T MANDATE ONE
00:38:28.072 --> 00:38:29.106
PARTICULAR DEVICE OR ANY DEVICE,
00:38:29.173 --> 00:38:30.808
FOR THAT MATTER. I SEE. AND IN
00:38:30.875 --> 00:38:34.311
MY LAST QUESTION, MA'AM, IS THE
00:38:34.378 --> 00:38:35.279
BILL REFERENCES TRAINING FOR
00:38:35.346 --> 00:38:38.082
PHLEBOTOMIST BUT DOESN'T SPECIFY
00:38:38.149 --> 00:38:39.450
WHAT THAT TRAINING MIGHT LOOK
00:38:39.517 --> 00:38:41.152
LIKE WHERE THEY GET IT. HOW IT
00:38:41.218 --> 00:38:42.386
HAPPENS. IS THAT SOMETHING THAT
00:38:42.453 --> 00:38:44.088
YOU ANTICIPATE BEING WORKED OUT
00:38:44.155 --> 00:38:49.760
LATER OR UH UM. THE FACILITIES
00:38:49.827 --> 00:38:51.062
DETERMINE WHETHER THEY WOULD
00:38:51.128 --> 00:38:52.997
LIKE TO HAVE A FLAT BOTTOM
00:38:53.064 --> 00:38:54.699
ISSUES. THESE DEVICES IN THE
00:38:54.765 --> 00:38:56.033
FACILITIES WILL BE RESPONSIBLE
00:38:56.100 --> 00:38:59.804
FOR THE TRAINING. OKAY? THANK
00:38:59.870 --> 00:39:00.838
YOU COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS,
00:39:00.905 --> 00:39:04.241
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? SENATOR.
00:39:04.308 --> 00:39:06.477
DONE YEAH, I'VE LOOKED AT THIS
00:39:06.544 --> 00:39:07.878
BILL A LOT, AND IT'S JUST IT'S
00:39:07.945 --> 00:39:10.581
JUST, FRANKLY, MIND BOGGLING T
00:39:10.648 --> 00:39:11.749
ME. THE OPPOSITION THAT'S ON
00:39:11.816 --> 00:39:15.352
THIS BILL. TO ALLOW PHLEBOTOMIST
00:39:15.419 --> 00:39:18.322
THAT CURRENTLY ARE DRAWING A LOT
00:39:18.389 --> 00:39:20.224
OF BLOOD NOT TO BE ABLE TO USE
00:39:20.291 --> 00:39:21.392
THE BEST TECHNOLOGY THAT'S
00:39:21.459 --> 00:39:25.930
AVAILABLE. THAT KEEPS PATIENTS
00:39:25.996 --> 00:39:28.733
MORE COMFORTABLE, LESS TRAUMA.
00:39:28.799 --> 00:39:30.434
YOU'RE THROUGH THIS THING. I'M
00:39:30.501 --> 00:39:31.802
GOING TO SUPPORT THIS BILL TODAY
00:39:31.869 --> 00:39:33.471
BECAUSE I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT
00:39:33.537 --> 00:39:35.539
THAT EVERYBODY SHOULD BE ALLOWED
00:39:35.606 --> 00:39:37.541
TO BE ABLE TO USE AND WE CAN GET
00:39:37.608 --> 00:39:39.844
OVER THE I THINK YOU YOU JUST
00:39:39.910 --> 00:39:40.911
ANSWERED THE QUESTION THAT WAS
00:39:40.978 --> 00:39:42.980
IN MY MIND WAS, YOU KNOW YOU'RE
00:39:43.047 --> 00:39:44.982
NOT FORCING ANYBODY TO USE THIS
00:39:45.049 --> 00:39:45.916
. THIS JUST GIVES THE
00:39:45.983 --> 00:39:47.818
OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE TO USE IT
00:39:47.885 --> 00:39:50.087
WHEN, IF AND WHEN THEY WANT TO.
00:39:50.154 --> 00:39:52.356
THANK YOU. I THINK IT'S A GOOD
00:39:52.423 --> 00:39:53.424
BILL. THANKS SENATOR. ANY OTHER
00:39:53.491 --> 00:39:54.492
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS?
00:39:54.558 --> 00:39:58.963
SAYING NONE. DR PAN. OF COURSE.
00:39:59.029 --> 00:40:01.966
THANK YOU AND APPRECIATE YOUR
00:40:02.032 --> 00:40:04.368
BROUGHT THE SPILL BACK BASIC
00:40:04.435 --> 00:40:06.737
QUESTION FOR THE OPPOSITION MADE
00:40:06.804 --> 00:40:07.738
FOR THE CALIFORNIA NURSES
00:40:07.805 --> 00:40:10.474
ASSOCIATION AND I CERTAINLY AM
00:40:10.541 --> 00:40:12.076
VERY SYMPATHETIC TO YOUR
00:40:12.143 --> 00:40:14.178
CONCERNS ABOUT THE I V LINE HAS
00:40:14.245 --> 00:40:15.212
SOMEONE WHO'S BEEN IN THE
00:40:15.279 --> 00:40:17.481
HOSPITAL. PEDIATRICIAN SO THOSE
00:40:17.548 --> 00:40:19.583
I V S REALLY HARD TO GET,
00:40:19.650 --> 00:40:20.985
ALTHOUGH GETTING BLOOD IS REALLY
00:40:21.051 --> 00:40:22.987
HARD TO GET TO, AND SOMEONE HAS
00:40:23.053 --> 00:40:24.655
EITHER SMALL VEINS OR, UH, RFD
00:40:24.722 --> 00:40:25.790
HAVE CHRONIC IF THEY'RE IN THE
00:40:25.856 --> 00:40:28.826
HOSPITAL A LOT. ALL TIMES THE
00:40:28.893 --> 00:40:31.829
VEINS GIVE OUT AS WELL. THE
00:40:31.896 --> 00:40:35.766
PROPONENTS. MADE REFERENCE TO
00:40:35.833 --> 00:40:38.035
THE SEVERAL STUDIES THAT WERE
00:40:38.102 --> 00:40:38.969
CONDUCTED BY PEER REVIEWED
00:40:39.036 --> 00:40:44.208
STUDIES. UM AND I UNDERSTAND
00:40:44.275 --> 00:40:46.076
THAT THIS DEVICE HAS BEEN USED
00:40:46.143 --> 00:40:48.078
IN OTHER OTHER AREAS IS THEIR
00:40:48.145 --> 00:40:49.680
DATA FROM THAT THE CALIFORNIA
00:40:49.747 --> 00:40:53.450
ASSOCIATION HAS THAT, UM SHOWS
00:40:53.517 --> 00:40:55.286
THAT THERE I MEAN, I KNOW YOU
00:40:55.352 --> 00:40:56.987
TALKED ABOUT DIFFERENT CONCERNS
00:40:57.054 --> 00:40:58.022
ABOUT CONTAMINATION IN THE LINE,
00:40:58.088 --> 00:41:01.725
POTENTIALLY BLOWING OUT I V S
00:41:01.792 --> 00:41:02.760
OTHER TYPES OF THINGS, WHICH, OF
00:41:02.827 --> 00:41:04.728
COURSE, WOULD BE CHALLENGING FOR
00:41:04.795 --> 00:41:06.497
THE NURSES AND THE AND CERTAINLY
00:41:06.564 --> 00:41:07.798
HAVING I V ACCESS IS VITAL AS
00:41:07.865 --> 00:41:09.233
YOU MENTIONED IN YOUR TESTIMONY,
00:41:09.300 --> 00:41:10.801
ASSURING THAT PATIENTS HAVE IVY
00:41:10.868 --> 00:41:12.503
ACCESS. BUT DO YOU HAVE SOME
00:41:12.570 --> 00:41:14.305
DATA THAT SHOWS THAT THERE'S A
00:41:14.371 --> 00:41:17.274
THAT THERE WERE MHM, WHERE DOES
00:41:17.341 --> 00:41:18.309
DEVICE WAS USED? AND WHETHER
00:41:18.375 --> 00:41:20.444
OTHER STATES ARE THE PLACES THAT
00:41:20.511 --> 00:41:21.278
ACTUALLY CAUSED AN INCREASE IN
00:41:21.345 --> 00:41:23.447
PROBLEMS. SO THE PROPONENTS SAID
00:41:23.514 --> 00:41:24.715
THEY HAVE THESE PIPES BY PERIOD
00:41:24.782 --> 00:41:25.783
STUDIES, BUT I WOULD BE
00:41:25.850 --> 00:41:28.285
INTERESTED IN HEARING IF THERE
00:41:28.352 --> 00:41:30.421
WAS DATA GOING THE OTHER WAY
00:41:30.487 --> 00:41:34.325
THAT, UH ALONG THE LINES OF THE
00:41:34.391 --> 00:41:35.459
CONCERNS THAT YOU RAISE IN YOUR
00:41:35.526 --> 00:41:41.131
TESTIMONY. IF I MAY? YES, MR
00:41:41.198 --> 00:41:44.201
CHAIR. GETS HIS CORRESPONDENT,
00:41:44.268 --> 00:41:46.704
JIM I DON'T KNOW THAT WE HAVE
00:41:46.770 --> 00:41:48.038
DATA ON THAT, BUT I THINK WE
00:41:48.105 --> 00:41:49.707
HAVE QUESTIONS AROUND THE PERIOD
00:41:49.773 --> 00:41:51.041
VIEW DATA BECAUSE IT'S NOT HERE.
00:41:51.108 --> 00:41:53.344
IT'S NOT CLEAR AS TO THE DATA
00:41:53.410 --> 00:41:55.045
THAT WAS PRESENTED BY THE PONY
00:41:55.112 --> 00:41:57.214
IN AS TO THE CONDITION OF THE
00:41:57.281 --> 00:41:58.816
PATIENTS. MANY OF OUR
00:41:58.883 --> 00:41:59.550
HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS ARE
00:41:59.617 --> 00:42:01.752
CRITICALLY ILL ELDERLY HAVE
00:42:01.819 --> 00:42:03.087
FRAGILE GAINS AS YOU MENTIONED
00:42:03.153 --> 00:42:05.022
OR MAYBE OBESE AND HAVE LIMITED
00:42:05.089 --> 00:42:06.957
ACCESS TO GOOD SITE FOR STARTING
00:42:07.024 --> 00:42:08.859
AND SO WE DON'T KNOW IF THOSE
00:42:08.926 --> 00:42:10.361
STUDIES ARE THOSE PEER REVIEWED
00:42:10.427 --> 00:42:11.795
STUDIES INCLUDED ANY OF THOSE
00:42:11.862 --> 00:42:13.831
PATIENTS IN THAT IN THOSE
00:42:13.898 --> 00:42:14.999
STUDIES, AND THAT'S ONE OF OUR
00:42:15.065 --> 00:42:17.835
CONCERNS. HOPE THAT HELPS. OKAY
00:42:17.902 --> 00:42:18.836
I APPRECIATE THAT. I BELIEVE
00:42:18.903 --> 00:42:19.904
THEY WERE PERFORMED IN
00:42:19.970 --> 00:42:20.871
HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS, SO I
00:42:20.938 --> 00:42:22.840
DON'T KNOW. AND I KNOW WHETHER
00:42:22.907 --> 00:42:26.877
THE PROPONENTS WANT TO SPEAKABOUT THEIR STUDY. BUT I DO
00:42:26.944 --> 00:42:27.344
UNDERSTAND WE'RE DONE
00:42:27.411 --> 00:42:31.682
HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS. UM AND I
00:42:31.749 --> 00:42:32.750
UNDERSTAND THAT ONE OF THE
00:42:32.816 --> 00:42:34.051
FINDINGS WAS THAT THEY DIDN'T
00:42:34.118 --> 00:42:35.786
YOU KNOW, IN TERMS OF I WAS
00:42:35.853 --> 00:42:36.987
CERTAINLY CONCERNED ABOUT PEOPLE
00:42:37.054 --> 00:42:37.888
LOSING THEIR LIVES, RIGHT? IF
00:42:37.955 --> 00:42:39.223
FOR BIO MISS UNKNOWINGLY WOULD
00:42:39.290 --> 00:42:41.125
SOMEHOW CAUSE A PROBLEM AND
00:42:41.191 --> 00:42:42.459
CAUSED THE I'VE TO BE
00:42:42.526 --> 00:42:45.062
ESSENTIALLY DESTROYED OR WHAT?
00:42:45.129 --> 00:42:47.064
THE STORY IS NOT THE RIGHT WORD.
00:42:47.131 --> 00:42:48.065
BUT ESSENTIALLY, UM, YOU KNOW,
00:42:48.132 --> 00:42:49.566
DAMAGE THE I V IN ANY WAY THAT
00:42:49.633 --> 00:42:50.834
THAT WOULD CERTAINLY I WOULD
00:42:50.901 --> 00:42:52.002
UNDERSTAND THAT CONCERN, BUT I
00:42:52.069 --> 00:42:54.071
UNDERSTAND THE STUDY DID NOT
00:42:54.138 --> 00:42:59.543
SHOW THAT AS AN ISSUE. TOÀN.
00:42:59.610 --> 00:43:02.046
OKAY ALRIGHT, WELL AND NO OTHER
00:43:02.112 --> 00:43:03.647
PROPONENTS WANT TO SPEAK TO
00:43:03.714 --> 00:43:05.115
WHETHER DEBT THEIR STUDIES
00:43:05.182 --> 00:43:07.384
ADDRESSED. SURE THANK YOU. SORRY
00:43:07.451 --> 00:43:08.786
I JUST WAITED WITH HARD ON THE
00:43:08.852 --> 00:43:10.087
PHONE. SORRY ABOUT THAT.
00:43:10.154 --> 00:43:12.489
APOLOGISTS YES, MULTIPLE
00:43:12.556 --> 00:43:13.590
CLINICAL STUDIES. ALL OF THEM
00:43:13.657 --> 00:43:14.758
WERE GOING ON IN PATIENT
00:43:14.825 --> 00:43:15.826
POPULATIONS IN IN LARGE ACADEMIC
00:43:15.893 --> 00:43:17.761
MEDICAL CENTERS. THE LAST ONE
00:43:17.828 --> 00:43:18.696
THAT I MENTIONED INTERMOUNTAIN
00:43:18.762 --> 00:43:20.097
WAS DONE ACROSS AN ENTIRE HEALTH
00:43:20.164 --> 00:43:22.199
SYSTEM OVER TWO YEARS AND
00:43:22.266 --> 00:43:24.268
210,000 INPATIENT. WE'RE ALL
00:43:24.335 --> 00:43:26.370
THEIR 22 HOSPITALS, SO 100%
00:43:26.437 --> 00:43:27.604
INPATIENT ACROSS ALL UNITS, I
00:43:27.671 --> 00:43:31.842
SEE YOU. PRS MED SURGICAL FLOORS
00:43:31.909 --> 00:43:34.244
. THE WORKS. IT WAS, IT WAS, IT
00:43:34.311 --> 00:43:35.713
WAS THEIR STANDARD OF CARE FOR
00:43:35.779 --> 00:43:37.281
ALL FIRST ATTEMPT. BLOOD DRAWS
00:43:37.348 --> 00:43:39.183
ACROSS THE ENTIRE SYSTEM. OKAY?
00:43:39.249 --> 00:43:40.884
ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. IS THERE
00:43:40.951 --> 00:43:42.820
ANY ANY FINAL RESPONSE FROM
00:43:42.886 --> 00:43:43.787
CALIFORNIA CITY ASSOCIATION TO
00:43:43.854 --> 00:43:47.157
THAT? I JUST SAY THAT YOU KNOW,
00:43:47.224 --> 00:43:50.661
IN THE THEY MAY HAVE DONE. IT'S
00:43:50.728 --> 00:43:52.329
JUST NOT CLEAR ON WHAT THOSE
00:43:52.396 --> 00:43:53.731
PATIENTS LOOK LIKE. WE KNOW THAT
00:43:53.797 --> 00:43:55.232
WE HAVE CONFUSED PATIENTS THAT
00:43:55.299 --> 00:43:56.166
CAN MOVE UNEXPECTEDLY AND
00:43:56.233 --> 00:43:58.102
DISLODGE AND CATHOLIC AND BLOOD
00:43:58.168 --> 00:44:00.037
WITHDRAWAL PROFITS IF THE FULL
00:44:00.104 --> 00:44:01.605
BOTTOMS IS NOT AWARE OF THE
00:44:01.672 --> 00:44:02.740
PATIENT'S CONDITION. IN MOST
00:44:02.806 --> 00:44:04.675
CASES, THE BOTTOM IS ARE NOT
00:44:04.742 --> 00:44:05.642
AWARE OF THE PATIENT'S
00:44:05.709 --> 00:44:07.244
CONDITION. THEY'RE JUST THERE TO
00:44:07.311 --> 00:44:09.046
DRAW BLOOD, SO WE THINK IT'S
00:44:09.113 --> 00:44:10.547
IMPORTANT TO ALSO HAVE THE
00:44:10.614 --> 00:44:12.049
APPROPRIATE SYSTEM TO ENSURE THE
00:44:12.116 --> 00:44:12.916
PATIENT SAFETY DURING THE
00:44:12.983 --> 00:44:14.418
PROCEDURE AND THAT THESE
00:44:14.485 --> 00:44:16.086
JUDGMENTS SHOULD NOT BE A
00:44:16.153 --> 00:44:17.388
PROPERLY MADE BY THE THESE
00:44:17.454 --> 00:44:19.590
JUDGMENTS SHOULD BE MADE. ONLY
00:44:19.656 --> 00:44:20.991
BY THE DIRECT CARE NURSE WHO
00:44:21.058 --> 00:44:22.593
KNOWS THE PATIENT AND HAS THE
00:44:22.659 --> 00:44:23.927
TRAIN TO DEAL WITH THESE
00:44:23.994 --> 00:44:25.062
UNEXPECTED SITUATIONS. OKAY, I
00:44:25.129 --> 00:44:26.530
APPRECIATE AND MAYBE JUST ONE
00:44:26.597 --> 00:44:27.798
LAST QUESTION FOR THE AUTHOR AND
00:44:27.865 --> 00:44:28.966
AGAIN APPRECIATE YOUR PATIENTS
00:44:29.033 --> 00:44:32.136
TO SHARE. IN THIS BILL IF THE
00:44:32.202 --> 00:44:33.971
NURSE WHO'S ACTUALLY TAKING CARE
00:44:34.038 --> 00:44:36.106
OF THE PATIENT SAYS. WELL I
00:44:36.173 --> 00:44:37.708
ACTUALLY YOU KNOW, IT TOOK ME IT
00:44:37.775 --> 00:44:39.810
WAS REALLY HARD TO GET THIS I'VE
00:44:39.877 --> 00:44:41.478
OR EITHER I OR MY OTHER ETCETERA
00:44:41.545 --> 00:44:42.980
CAN. THE NURSE BASICALLY TOLD
00:44:43.047 --> 00:44:44.415
BALANCE YOU CANNOT DRAW BLOOD
00:44:44.481 --> 00:44:47.217
OUT OF THIS? I V BECAUSE IT WAS
00:44:47.284 --> 00:44:48.118
, YOU KNOW, IT WAS REALLY HARD
00:44:48.185 --> 00:44:49.787
TO GET AND ETCETERA AND WE
00:44:49.853 --> 00:44:51.155
NEEDED TO PRESERVE ACCESS.
00:44:51.221 --> 00:44:52.656
ABSOLUTELY THE IVY IS COMPLETELY
00:44:52.723 --> 00:44:53.657
UNDER CONTROL OF THE NURSE.
00:44:53.724 --> 00:44:55.192
OKAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU.
00:44:55.259 --> 00:44:57.061
THANK YOU, SENATOR PAN. I DON'T
00:44:57.127 --> 00:44:59.196
SEE ANY OTHER HANDS UP. SO SOME
00:44:59.263 --> 00:45:00.264
REMEMBER, IRWIN, WOULD YOU LIKE
00:45:00.330 --> 00:45:02.266
TO CLOSE? JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:45:02.332 --> 00:45:04.201
FOR I VOTE. THANK YOU, MA'AM. DO
00:45:04.268 --> 00:45:05.469
WE HAVE A MOTION ON ASSEMBLY
00:45:05.536 --> 00:45:07.871
BILL 11 20. SENATOR EDMUND, I
00:45:07.938 --> 00:45:11.842
THINK MOVED IT THE MOTION IS DUE
00:45:11.909 --> 00:45:13.710
PASS TO THE SENATE FLOOR. PLEASE
00:45:13.777 --> 00:45:16.280
CALL THE ROLL. MAYBE 11 20
00:45:16.346 --> 00:45:17.815
MOTION IS PASSED TO THE SENATE
00:45:17.881 --> 00:45:20.484
FLOOR. ROTH I MELINDA'S
00:45:20.551 --> 00:45:25.989
ARCHULETTA BATES. BECKER I DODD
00:45:26.056 --> 00:45:27.991
GOD, I EGGMAN. EGGMAN. I
00:45:28.058 --> 00:45:32.463
HURTADO. HER TITLE. I JONES
00:45:32.529 --> 00:45:33.597
JONES, I LEVA. BELIEVE THAT I'M
00:45:33.664 --> 00:45:38.902
IN. MOMENT I NEWMAN DIACO BOTH.
00:45:38.969 --> 00:45:46.176
PAN. BILL HAS NINE VOTES. WILL
00:45:46.243 --> 00:45:47.377
HOLD THE ROLL OPEN FOR ABSENT
00:45:47.444 --> 00:45:50.214
MEMBERS. THANK YOU, MA'AM
00:45:50.280 --> 00:45:56.920
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GARCIA. HAVE
00:45:56.987 --> 00:45:59.389
ONE ITEM ASSEMBLY BILL 710.
00:45:59.456 --> 00:46:01.558
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:46:01.625 --> 00:46:05.596
OF THIS COMMITTEE. THE RECENT
00:46:05.662 --> 00:46:07.064
YEARS OF LEGISLATURE HAS TAKEN
00:46:07.131 --> 00:46:08.031
ACTION TO GUARANTEE THE HEALTH
00:46:08.098 --> 00:46:09.333
AND SAFETY OF CALIFORNIA
00:46:09.399 --> 00:46:11.101
CONSUMERS AND AGRICULTURAL FIELD
00:46:11.168 --> 00:46:12.903
WORKERS BY ENSURING THE USE OF
00:46:12.970 --> 00:46:14.171
SAFE CHEMICALS AND PROVIDING
00:46:14.238 --> 00:46:17.074
ECONOMIC FREEDOM. BY ASSURING
00:46:17.141 --> 00:46:17.941
THE RIGHT TO A LIVING WAGE THAT
00:46:18.008 --> 00:46:20.477
MEETS BASIC HOUSEHOLD NEEDS.
00:46:20.544 --> 00:46:22.079
FARMERS IN THE STATE PRODUCED
00:46:22.146 --> 00:46:23.647
FRUITS, VEGETABLES, NUTS, MEATS
00:46:23.714 --> 00:46:25.215
FROM ANIMAL LIVESTOCK IN
00:46:25.282 --> 00:46:26.216
ACCORDANCE TO THE STATES
00:46:26.283 --> 00:46:27.451
PESTICIDE. LABOR AND MINIMUM
00:46:27.518 --> 00:46:30.521
WAGE LAWS. COMPLYING WITH THE
00:46:30.587 --> 00:46:31.722
STATE LAWS INCREASES COSTS BUT
00:46:31.788 --> 00:46:32.856
PROVIDES REAL BENEFITS TO THE
00:46:32.923 --> 00:46:35.325
HEALTH OF CONSUMERS. TO THE
00:46:35.392 --> 00:46:36.960
ENVIRONMENT AND TO THE WORKERS
00:46:37.027 --> 00:46:39.196
WHO PRODUCED THESE GOODS. A B 7
00:46:39.263 --> 00:46:40.097
10 WOULD REQUIRE CERTAIN
00:46:40.164 --> 00:46:41.532
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS SOLD TO
00:46:41.598 --> 00:46:42.799
THE PUBLIC TO BE PRODUCED IN
00:46:42.866 --> 00:46:43.834
COMPLIANCE WITH OUR STATE'S
00:46:43.901 --> 00:46:47.304
REGULATIONS. THIS BILL WOULD
00:46:47.371 --> 00:46:49.273
PLACE OUR PESTICIDE REGULATIONS
00:46:49.339 --> 00:46:50.874
ON THE LISTED OUT OF STATE
00:46:50.941 --> 00:46:52.809
PRODUCE AND OUR LABOR
00:46:52.876 --> 00:46:53.977
REGULATIONS ON THE LISTED OUT OF
00:46:54.044 --> 00:46:56.747
COUNTRY PRODUCE. I WANT TO
00:46:56.813 --> 00:46:57.781
CLARIFY THAT THE LABOR
00:46:57.848 --> 00:47:00.184
PROVISIONS IN THIS BILL WOULD
00:47:00.250 --> 00:47:01.385
NOT BE PLACED ON ANY OTHER
00:47:01.451 --> 00:47:04.087
STATES IN OUR COUNTRY. THIS BILL
00:47:04.154 --> 00:47:05.255
WOULD APPLY TO THE FOLLOWING
00:47:05.322 --> 00:47:06.390
PRODUCE APPLES, ASPARAGUS BELL
00:47:06.456 --> 00:47:09.560
PEPPERS. BLUEBERRIES DATES,
00:47:09.626 --> 00:47:11.094
HONEY DEW, MELONS, LEMONS,
00:47:11.161 --> 00:47:13.163
NECTARINES, OLIVES AND TABLE
00:47:13.230 --> 00:47:15.165
GRAPES. I UNDERSTAND THERE HAVE
00:47:15.232 --> 00:47:16.800
BEEN SOME CONCERNS WITH THE
00:47:16.867 --> 00:47:18.001
ABILITY FOR GROCERY STORES TO
00:47:18.068 --> 00:47:19.036
SOURCE THESE PRODUCTS YEAR
00:47:19.102 --> 00:47:21.071
ROUND. OUR MOST RECENT
00:47:21.138 --> 00:47:23.240
AMENDMENTS ADDRESS THE INVENTORY
00:47:23.307 --> 00:47:25.209
CONCERNS BY HAVING THE BILL ONLY
00:47:25.275 --> 00:47:26.944
APPLY TO EACH LISTED
00:47:27.010 --> 00:47:28.178
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT DURING
00:47:28.245 --> 00:47:29.313
THEIR INDIVIDUAL CALIFORNIA
00:47:29.379 --> 00:47:32.449
GROWING SEASON. THE OPPOSITION
00:47:32.516 --> 00:47:35.118
USES APPLES AS AN EXAMPLE FOR
00:47:35.185 --> 00:47:36.286
EMPTY SHELVES, BUT WE BELIEVE
00:47:36.353 --> 00:47:39.056
THE MARKET WILL ADJUST. AN APPLE
00:47:39.122 --> 00:47:40.123
FARMER IN THE STATE OF
00:47:40.190 --> 00:47:42.159
WASHINGTON OR CHILI CAN TAP INTO
00:47:42.226 --> 00:47:44.294
OUR MARKET. ALL THEY WOULD HAVE
00:47:44.361 --> 00:47:45.829
TO DO IS ENSURE THE HEALTH AND
00:47:45.896 --> 00:47:47.598
SAFETY OF OUR CONSUMERS HERE IN
00:47:47.664 --> 00:47:50.334
OUR STATE. I ALSO UNDERSTAND THE
00:47:50.400 --> 00:47:50.734
CONCERNS REGARDING
00:47:50.801 --> 00:47:52.669
IMPLEMENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT.
00:47:52.736 --> 00:47:54.171
TO ADDRESS THESE CONCERNS. OUR
00:47:54.238 --> 00:47:56.273
TEAM HAS COME UP WITH AMENDMENTS
00:47:56.340 --> 00:47:57.274
TO EASE THE BURDEN OF
00:47:57.341 --> 00:47:58.175
IMPLEMENTATION ON THE
00:47:58.242 --> 00:48:00.844
DEPARTMENT. WE CAME UP WITH THE
00:48:00.911 --> 00:48:01.812
IDEA OF A FORM THAT HE
00:48:01.878 --> 00:48:04.081
DISTRIBUTOR WOULD PROVIDE TO A
00:48:04.147 --> 00:48:05.716
GROWER FOR THAT FARMER TO SELF
00:48:05.782 --> 00:48:07.718
ATTEST THAT THEIR PRODUCE IS IN
00:48:07.784 --> 00:48:09.419
COMPLIANCE. THAT FORM WOULD THEN
00:48:09.486 --> 00:48:11.455
BE SHARED WITH THE RETAILER AND
00:48:11.521 --> 00:48:13.557
BE AUDITED BY THE DEPARTMENT.
00:48:13.624 --> 00:48:15.125
THE EXPECTATION OF A HEALTHY AND
00:48:15.192 --> 00:48:17.961
SAFE SOCIETY IS A HUMAN RIGHT
00:48:18.028 --> 00:48:18.962
AND THE LEGISLATURE CAN SHOW ITS
00:48:19.029 --> 00:48:20.130
COMMITMENT TO SAFEGUARDING THAT
00:48:20.197 --> 00:48:22.866
IDEAL. BY ENSURING THAT THE
00:48:22.933 --> 00:48:24.768
PROTEST SOLD IN THE STATE MEETS
00:48:24.835 --> 00:48:25.936
THOSE EXPECTATIONS. QUESTION. WE
00:48:26.003 --> 00:48:29.373
MUST ASK OURSELVES. WHY HAS THE
00:48:29.439 --> 00:48:31.208
STATE PUT THESE REGULATIONS ON
00:48:31.275 --> 00:48:34.511
OUR OWN FARMERS? WHAT WAS IT TO
00:48:34.578 --> 00:48:35.946
ENSURE THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
00:48:36.013 --> 00:48:38.115
OUR FIELD WORKERS AND CONSUMERS
00:48:38.181 --> 00:48:39.316
? OR WAS IT JUST TO HURT OUR
00:48:39.383 --> 00:48:41.518
FARMERS? IF WE TRULY DID THOSE
00:48:41.585 --> 00:48:43.654
THINGS FOR THE HEALTH AND SAFETY
00:48:43.720 --> 00:48:44.521
OF BENEFITS TO OUR STATE THAN
00:48:44.588 --> 00:48:46.857
THIS BILL IS A NO BRAINER. WITH
00:48:46.923 --> 00:48:48.892
ME AS A CALIFORNIA FARMER TO
00:48:48.959 --> 00:48:50.994
TESTIFY. ANTHONY BIANCO
00:48:51.061 --> 00:48:52.396
HERNANDEZ, CALIFORNIA FARM
00:48:52.462 --> 00:48:54.031
WORKER FOUNDATION AND GLENN
00:48:54.097 --> 00:48:56.433
PHARAOH IS HERE WITH ME TO
00:48:56.500 --> 00:48:58.935
ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL QUESTIONS.
00:48:59.002 --> 00:48:59.469
PLEASE PROCEED. GENTLEMEN.
00:48:59.536 --> 00:49:05.042
REMEMBER THREE MINUTES. GOOD
00:49:05.108 --> 00:49:06.076
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIRMAN AND
00:49:06.143 --> 00:49:08.478
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
00:49:08.545 --> 00:49:09.980
NAME IS ANTHONY BIANCO CORNER OF
00:49:10.047 --> 00:49:11.248
ANTHONY VINEYARDS SUNDAY AND
00:49:11.315 --> 00:49:12.549
VICE PRESIDENT OF GROWING
00:49:12.616 --> 00:49:13.083
COACHELLA VALLEY AND THE
00:49:13.150 --> 00:49:14.384
COACHELLA VALLEY AND SAN JOAQUIN
00:49:14.451 --> 00:49:16.953
VALLEY. A B 7 10 IS A CALIFORNIA
00:49:17.020 --> 00:49:17.988
FARM WORKER BILL AND
00:49:18.055 --> 00:49:20.557
ENVIRONMENTAL BILL. AND A FARMER
00:49:20.624 --> 00:49:22.225
BILL. MAYBE THE FIRST TIME IN
00:49:22.292 --> 00:49:23.694
CALIFORNIA HISTORY THAT THESE
00:49:23.760 --> 00:49:24.861
THREE GROUPS HAVE JOINED FORCES
00:49:24.928 --> 00:49:27.164
TO GET BEHIND ONE BILL.
00:49:27.230 --> 00:49:28.865
LEGISLATURE HAS MADE IMPORTANT
00:49:28.932 --> 00:49:31.068
POLICY DECISIONS OVER THE LAST
00:49:31.134 --> 00:49:31.635
DECADE TO ENSURE CALIFORNIA
00:49:31.702 --> 00:49:33.570
AGRICULTURE IS A WORLDWIDE
00:49:33.637 --> 00:49:34.938
LEADER IN CONSUMER PROTECTION,
00:49:35.005 --> 00:49:37.140
FARMWORKER PROTECTION, FOOD AND
00:49:37.207 --> 00:49:39.209
HATE, HEALTH SAFETY PROTECTIONS
00:49:39.276 --> 00:49:40.277
, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS AND
00:49:40.344 --> 00:49:41.611
WAGE AND BENEFITS THAT ENSURE
00:49:41.678 --> 00:49:43.814
THAT CALIFORNIA FARM WORKERS ARE
00:49:43.880 --> 00:49:45.349
RECEIVING A LIVING WAGE WITH
00:49:45.415 --> 00:49:46.850
OVERTIME. CALIFORNIA
00:49:46.917 --> 00:49:48.051
AGRICULTURAL BUSINESS MUST
00:49:48.118 --> 00:49:50.220
COMPLY WITH THESE LAWS AND
00:49:50.287 --> 00:49:51.288
REGULATIONS AS PART OF OUR
00:49:51.355 --> 00:49:53.757
BUSINESS OPERATION. HOWEVER THE
00:49:53.824 --> 00:49:55.325
PROTECTION STANDARDS THAT HAVE
00:49:55.392 --> 00:49:56.626
BEEN DEVELOPED OVER THE YEARS
00:49:56.693 --> 00:49:57.694
ONLY APPLY TO CALIFORNIA
00:49:57.761 --> 00:49:59.196
GROWERS. EVEN THOUGH IT'S
00:49:59.262 --> 00:50:00.263
SUBSTANTIAL PORTION OF
00:50:00.330 --> 00:50:01.331
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS
00:50:01.398 --> 00:50:02.332
DISTRIBUTED AND SOLD IN
00:50:02.399 --> 00:50:04.334
CALIFORNIA ARE IMPORTED FROM
00:50:04.401 --> 00:50:06.203
OTHER STATES AND COUNTRIES
00:50:06.269 --> 00:50:08.205
CREATES AN UNLEVEL PLAYING FIELD
00:50:08.271 --> 00:50:09.840
THAT SIGNIFICANTLY DISADVANTAGES
00:50:09.906 --> 00:50:11.274
. CALIFORNIA FARMERS AND
00:50:11.341 --> 00:50:13.343
PRODUCERS, CREATING UNFAIR
00:50:13.410 --> 00:50:14.878
DISPARITIES AND ACCESS TO
00:50:14.945 --> 00:50:16.079
COMMODITY MARKETS AND CALIFORNIA
00:50:16.146 --> 00:50:18.749
FOR IN STATE GROWERS. AS THE
00:50:18.815 --> 00:50:20.350
STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS ENSURED
00:50:20.417 --> 00:50:22.319
THAT FARM WORKERS RECEIVE A
00:50:22.386 --> 00:50:23.820
LIVING WAGE WITH OVERTIME AND
00:50:23.887 --> 00:50:25.355
THEN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
00:50:25.422 --> 00:50:26.857
ENVIRONMENT IS PROTECTED.
00:50:26.923 --> 00:50:27.691
GROWERS COSTS HAVE GONE UP
00:50:27.758 --> 00:50:29.993
DRAMATICALLY, AND WE HAVE SEEN
00:50:30.060 --> 00:50:31.094
HIGHER LABOR CROPS LIKE THESE
00:50:31.161 --> 00:50:32.129
LISTED IN THIS BILL. BEING
00:50:32.195 --> 00:50:33.730
PULLED OUT AND ABANDONED IN OUR
00:50:33.797 --> 00:50:35.966
STATE. IF WE DON'T ACT ON THIS
00:50:36.032 --> 00:50:37.701
BILL, THIS PRODUCTS THESE
00:50:37.768 --> 00:50:38.935
PRODUCTS MAY ONE DAY NOT BE
00:50:39.002 --> 00:50:41.204
PRODUCED IN THE US THIS WILL
00:50:41.271 --> 00:50:43.273
LEAD TO A LOSS IN FARM WORKER
00:50:43.340 --> 00:50:44.574
JOBS AND LOSS AND CROP DIVERSITY
00:50:44.641 --> 00:50:46.076
FOR OUR STATE, ULTIMATELY
00:50:46.143 --> 00:50:48.211
LEADING TO CALIFORNIA AND THE US
00:50:48.278 --> 00:50:49.846
BEING RELIANT ON THESE FRUITS
00:50:49.913 --> 00:50:51.314
AND VEGETABLES FROM OTHER
00:50:51.381 --> 00:50:51.948
COUNTRIES LIKE MEXICO, CHINA,
00:50:52.015 --> 00:50:55.085
ARGENTINA, CHILE. PERU AND SO ON
00:50:55.152 --> 00:50:58.488
TO FEED US. THIS BILL DOES NOT
00:50:58.555 --> 00:51:00.157
SAVE ALL CALIFORNIA FARM WORKER
00:51:00.223 --> 00:51:02.058
JOBS AND IT WILL NOT SAVE ALL
00:51:02.125 --> 00:51:03.960
CALIFORNIA FARM. IT WILL ENSURE
00:51:04.027 --> 00:51:06.196
THAT MANY CALIFORNIA FARMWORKERS
00:51:06.263 --> 00:51:07.197
AND GROWERS WILL CONTINUE
00:51:07.264 --> 00:51:08.298
SUPPLYING OUR STATE WITH THESE
00:51:08.365 --> 00:51:10.100
PRODUCTS. MORE IMPORTANTLY, THAT
00:51:10.167 --> 00:51:11.101
THESE PRODUCTS WILL REPRESENT
00:51:11.168 --> 00:51:13.837
CALIFORNIA VALUES. WE REALLY
00:51:13.904 --> 00:51:14.771
APPRECIATE THE LEADERSHIP OF
00:51:14.838 --> 00:51:16.907
ASSEMBLYMAN GARCIA MAZE AND
00:51:16.973 --> 00:51:19.075
REVIS AND INVESTING 7 10 TO HELP
00:51:19.142 --> 00:51:20.010
LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD AND
00:51:20.076 --> 00:51:21.144
ENSURE AT LEAST DURING THE
00:51:21.211 --> 00:51:22.879
CALIFORNIA GROWING SEASON FOR AN
00:51:22.946 --> 00:51:24.815
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCT. THERE IS
00:51:24.881 --> 00:51:26.316
SOME SEMBLANCE OF COMPETITIVE
00:51:26.383 --> 00:51:28.185
BALANCE FOR IN STATE GROWERS TO
00:51:28.251 --> 00:51:29.252
COMPETE WITH THE IMPORTED
00:51:29.319 --> 00:51:31.555
PRODUCTS. CALIFORNIA GROWERS CAN
00:51:31.621 --> 00:51:33.256
MEET THE NEEDS OF CALIFORNIA
00:51:33.323 --> 00:51:34.558
CONSUMERS WERE THE LARGEST
00:51:34.624 --> 00:51:36.960
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCER IN THE U.
00:51:37.027 --> 00:51:39.129
S AND A B 7. 10 PROVIDES THE
00:51:39.196 --> 00:51:39.930
RIGHT STRUCTURE AND THE
00:51:39.996 --> 00:51:41.064
APPROPRIATE OFF RAMPS TO ENSURE
00:51:41.131 --> 00:51:43.200
THAT CALIFORNIA SUPPLY MEETS
00:51:43.266 --> 00:51:45.335
CALIFORNIA FOR NYA DEMAND FOR
00:51:45.402 --> 00:51:47.571
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS PRODUCED
00:51:47.637 --> 00:51:49.339
WE HAVE WORKED. WE HAVE WORKED
00:51:49.406 --> 00:51:52.142
TIRELESSLY FOR OVER TWO YEARS ON
00:51:52.209 --> 00:51:53.043
THIS BILL, CHANGING IT
00:51:53.109 --> 00:51:53.677
DRAMATICALLY WITH THE COMMENTS
00:51:53.743 --> 00:51:55.879
AND CONCERNS THAT MANY OF YOU
00:51:55.946 --> 00:51:56.913
AND OTHERS HAVE HAD,
00:51:56.980 --> 00:51:58.782
RESPECTIVELY REQUEST. A YES VOTE
00:51:58.849 --> 00:52:08.825
ON ABC, 7 10. NEXT, PLEASE. GOOD
00:52:08.892 --> 00:52:10.260
AFTERNOON, MR TANNER. I'M GOING.
00:52:10.327 --> 00:52:12.429
I'M GOING TO LIMIT YOU TO ABOUT
00:52:12.496 --> 00:52:14.097
WHAT? HELLO I'M GOING TO LIMIT
00:52:14.164 --> 00:52:15.365
YOU TO ABOUT ONE MINUTE BECAUSE
00:52:15.432 --> 00:52:18.435
I THINK YOU'RE COMPATRIOT TOOK
00:52:18.502 --> 00:52:20.437
THE REST, SO PLEASE TRY TO BE
00:52:20.504 --> 00:52:22.906
BRIEF, OKAY? ALRIGHT THANKS FOR
00:52:22.973 --> 00:52:23.773
LONDON AND THE EXECUTIVE
00:52:23.840 --> 00:52:25.575
DIRECTOR OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:52:25.642 --> 00:52:26.576
FARMWORKERS FOUNDATION. A FIVE
00:52:26.643 --> 00:52:28.078
WANTED THE ORGANIZATION THAT
00:52:28.144 --> 00:52:29.312
THERE'S FARMWORKERS. LOTS OF
00:52:29.379 --> 00:52:31.314
STATE LAST YEAR LONG WE START
00:52:31.381 --> 00:52:32.682
OVER 300,000 FARM WORKERS. I'M
00:52:32.749 --> 00:52:34.050
HERE TODAY IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:52:34.117 --> 00:52:36.286
A B 17 A B 17 SHINES THE
00:52:36.353 --> 00:52:37.220
SPOTLIGHT ON THE GROWING CRISIS
00:52:37.287 --> 00:52:38.855
OF CALIFORNIA FOOD SUPPLY CRISIS
00:52:38.922 --> 00:52:39.856
THAT HAD LED TO A LOT OF
00:52:39.923 --> 00:52:41.024
THOUSANDS OF FARMERS, THEIR
00:52:41.091 --> 00:52:42.893
JOBS, KALEVALA AND BROAD. THE
00:52:42.959 --> 00:52:44.394
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
00:52:44.461 --> 00:52:45.896
COUNTRIES WHO DO NOT HAVE THE
00:52:45.962 --> 00:52:46.763
SAME SAFETY, ENVIRONMENTAL
00:52:46.830 --> 00:52:48.231
PROTECTION, WORKING CONDITIONS
00:52:48.298 --> 00:52:50.133
AND WAGES AND BENEFITS. MAYBE 7
00:52:50.200 --> 00:52:51.201
10 ALSO HIGHLIGHTS THE INEQUITY
00:52:51.268 --> 00:52:52.702
OF NON CALIFORNIA AGRICULTURAL
00:52:52.769 --> 00:52:53.837
BUSINESSES THAT DO NOT MEET THE
00:52:53.904 --> 00:52:55.105
SAME LEVEL 50 AND LABOR
00:52:55.171 --> 00:52:57.207
STANDARDS AS CALIFORNIA FARMERS.
00:52:57.274 --> 00:52:58.441
AND PLACE THEM AT A COMPETITIVE
00:52:58.508 --> 00:52:59.543
DISADVANTAGE. THE COMPETITIVE
00:52:59.609 --> 00:53:01.511
DISADVANTAGE HAS ALREADY LED TO
00:53:01.578 --> 00:53:03.280
THOUSANDS OF FARM WORKERS LOSING
00:53:03.346 --> 00:53:04.414
THEIR JOBS, AND WE DO SEE
00:53:04.481 --> 00:53:05.415
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY IN THE STATE.
00:53:05.482 --> 00:53:07.684
A B 7 10 6 TO LEVEL THE PLAYING
00:53:07.751 --> 00:53:09.252
FIELD FOR CALIFORNIA FARMERS AND
00:53:09.319 --> 00:53:10.720
PROTECT FARMWORKERSOUTSIDE OF
00:53:10.787 --> 00:53:12.222
THE STATE. WE RESPECTFULLY
00:53:12.289 --> 00:53:14.491
REQUEST A YES GO ON A B 7 10.
00:53:14.558 --> 00:53:15.692
THANK YOU. NOW LET'S HEAR FROM
00:53:15.759 --> 00:53:16.893
ANY OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES IN
00:53:16.960 --> 00:53:18.929
THE HEARING ROOM. AND HE
00:53:18.995 --> 00:53:19.930
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. NAME
00:53:19.996 --> 00:53:20.931
AFFILIATION POSITION ON THE
00:53:20.997 --> 00:53:26.770
MEASURE, PLEASE. CHRIS KAHN,
00:53:26.836 --> 00:53:27.304
REPRESENTING THE COACHELLA
00:53:27.370 --> 00:53:28.271
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT AND
00:53:28.338 --> 00:53:30.373
SUPPORT THANKS, SIR. LET'S MOVE
00:53:30.440 --> 00:53:31.741
TO WITNESSES WAITING, TESTIFY
00:53:31.808 --> 00:53:33.143
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE AND
00:53:33.209 --> 00:53:34.411
SUPPORT MODERATOR. IF YOU WOULD
00:53:34.477 --> 00:53:35.478
PLEASE PROMPT ANY SUCH
00:53:35.545 --> 00:53:37.447
INDIVIDUALS WILLING TO TESTIFY.
00:53:37.514 --> 00:53:39.282
IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY BILL 710.
00:53:39.349 --> 00:53:42.452
WE WILL BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK
00:53:42.519 --> 00:53:44.087
YOU TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS
00:53:44.154 --> 00:53:46.089
BILL, PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
00:53:46.156 --> 00:53:47.023
ZERO AND YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD
00:53:47.090 --> 00:53:47.991
AGAIN. THAT'S ONE. AND THEN
00:53:48.058 --> 00:53:56.967
THERE ARE. WE DO HAVE TWO LINES
00:53:57.033 --> 00:53:58.068
WITH OPERATORS. ONE MOMENT,
00:53:58.134 --> 00:54:09.813
PLEASE. THANK YOU.
00:54:09.879 --> 00:54:11.281
OUR FIRST COMMENT COMES FROM
00:54:11.348 --> 00:54:16.419
LINE 29 TO 9, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:54:16.486 --> 00:54:18.154
HI GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:54:18.221 --> 00:54:20.323
GEORGE TUTOR FROM TUTOR RANCH
00:54:20.390 --> 00:54:21.524
AND GROWING COACHELLA VALLEY AND
00:54:21.591 --> 00:54:22.959
I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT OF A B
00:54:23.026 --> 00:54:24.194
778. THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT,
00:54:24.260 --> 00:54:27.330
PLEASE. AIRLINE 21, PLEASE GO
00:54:27.397 --> 00:54:35.338
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. I AM
00:54:35.405 --> 00:54:36.539
CHANCE. KIRK WITH SOME LIGHT
00:54:36.606 --> 00:54:38.341
INTERNATIONAL COLUMN AND SUPPORT
00:54:38.408 --> 00:54:40.043
OF A B 7 10. THANK YOU. THANK
00:54:40.110 --> 00:54:43.747
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. THANK YOU. NO
00:54:43.813 --> 00:54:45.815
FURTHER LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME
00:54:45.882 --> 00:54:46.950
, OKAY. LET'S FOLLOW THE SAME
00:54:47.017 --> 00:54:48.818
PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
00:54:48.885 --> 00:54:49.819
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. FIRST
00:54:49.886 --> 00:54:50.854
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
00:54:50.920 --> 00:54:53.823
HEARING ROOM. SEEING NONE. LET'S
00:54:53.890 --> 00:54:56.459
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
00:54:56.526 --> 00:54:57.594
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
00:54:57.661 --> 00:54:58.695
ONCE AGAIN, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
00:54:58.762 --> 00:55:02.065
PROMPT ANY INDIVIDUALS. WAITING
00:55:02.132 --> 00:55:04.200
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION OF
00:55:04.267 --> 00:55:05.869
ASSEMBLY BILL 710. WE WILL
00:55:05.935 --> 00:55:07.637
CONTINUE WITH THEM, BUT FIRST I
00:55:07.704 --> 00:55:08.605
SEE A TAKER UP AT THE
00:55:08.672 --> 00:55:11.207
MICROPHONE. NAME AFFILIATION
00:55:11.274 --> 00:55:13.076
POSITION, PLEASE. MY NAME IS
00:55:13.143 --> 00:55:15.078
RYAN ELAINE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:55:15.145 --> 00:55:15.845
RETAILERS ASSOCIATION. I WAS
00:55:15.912 --> 00:55:18.214
WONDERING IF I COULD JUST BE THE
00:55:18.281 --> 00:55:19.416
MAIN OPPOSITION FOR A QUICK SET.
00:55:19.482 --> 00:55:21.117
OKAY, PLEASE. SO MY NAME IS RYAN
00:55:21.184 --> 00:55:21.951
WITH THE CALIFORNIA RETAILERS
00:55:22.018 --> 00:55:23.953
ASSOCIATION AND ARE CONCERNED
00:55:24.020 --> 00:55:25.855
WITH A B 7 10 IS CONSUMER DEMAND
00:55:25.922 --> 00:55:27.223
AND THE ABILITY TO KEEP FRESH
00:55:27.290 --> 00:55:29.125
PRODUCE STOCKED IN OUR STORES.
00:55:29.192 --> 00:55:30.694
WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THE WE DO
00:55:30.760 --> 00:55:32.095
NOT BELIEVE THERE IS ADEQUATE
00:55:32.162 --> 00:55:34.030
SUPPLY WITHIN CALIFORNIA TO MEET
00:55:34.097 --> 00:55:35.098
PRODUCED DEMANDS ALL TIMES OF
00:55:35.165 --> 00:55:37.167
THE YEAR. BUYING PRODUCE
00:55:37.233 --> 00:55:38.802
REQUIRES FLEXIBILITY AND THESE
00:55:38.868 --> 00:55:40.203
PURCHASES CAN COME FROM MULTIPLE
00:55:40.270 --> 00:55:41.738
SOURCES AT ANY GIVEN TIME IN
00:55:41.805 --> 00:55:42.772
THIS BILL COMPLICATES THE
00:55:42.839 --> 00:55:44.808
ABILITY TO MAKE THOSE PURCHASES.
00:55:44.874 --> 00:55:46.476
SIGNIFICANTLY LIMITING CHOICE
00:55:46.543 --> 00:55:47.544
COULD RAISE PRICES AND RESULTED
00:55:47.610 --> 00:55:50.880
IN STOCKED SHELVES. UM AND FOR
00:55:50.947 --> 00:55:52.549
THE BILL ILL ALSO PROHIBIT OUR
00:55:52.615 --> 00:55:54.684
ABILITY TO IMPORT MANY ITEMS
00:55:54.751 --> 00:55:56.352
INTERNATIONALLY, AND FOR THESE
00:55:56.419 --> 00:55:57.754
REASONS, LET'S SIT ABOVE THE
00:55:57.821 --> 00:55:58.822
RETAILER'S ASSOCIATION ASKED YOU
00:55:58.888 --> 00:56:01.024
VOTE NO ON A B 7 10. THANK YOU,
00:56:01.091 --> 00:56:03.426
SIR. THANKS FOR STEPPING UP. NOW
00:56:03.493 --> 00:56:04.728
LET'S RETURN TO THE MODERATOR.
00:56:04.794 --> 00:56:06.296
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
00:56:06.362 --> 00:56:07.263
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
00:56:07.330 --> 00:56:09.699
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL 7
00:56:09.766 --> 00:56:10.834
10, WE WILL CONTINUE WITH THEM.
00:56:10.900 --> 00:56:14.838
MODERATOR. THANK YOU. THE STATE
00:56:14.904 --> 00:56:16.339
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. PRESS
00:56:16.406 --> 00:56:18.074
ONE AND THEN ZERO ON YOUR
00:56:18.141 --> 00:56:18.842
TELEPHONE, AND THAT'S ONE
00:56:18.908 --> 00:56:20.944
FOLLOWED BY ZERO, PLEASE. WE'LL
00:56:21.010 --> 00:56:26.549
GO TO LINE 34. THANK YOU TURNED
00:56:26.616 --> 00:56:27.450
MEMBERS, TIM JAMES, WITH THE
00:56:27.517 --> 00:56:29.586
CALIFORNIA GROCERS ASSOCIATION
00:56:29.652 --> 00:56:31.688
WITH EXPANDED COMMENTS. WE
00:56:31.755 --> 00:56:32.722
PROCEED THE AUTHOR'S RECENT
00:56:32.789 --> 00:56:34.824
AMENDMENTS TO REMOVE THE BURDEN
00:56:34.891 --> 00:56:35.892
OFF GROCERY RETAILERS WHEN
00:56:35.959 --> 00:56:36.926
PURCHASING THE LISTED PRODUCTS
00:56:36.993 --> 00:56:40.196
IN THE BILL. HOWEVER WE STILL
00:56:40.263 --> 00:56:41.364
HAVE CONCERNS OVER THE IMPACT
00:56:41.431 --> 00:56:42.432
THIS BILL WILL HAVE ON OUR
00:56:42.499 --> 00:56:44.334
GROCERIES. WE WANT THE ACTUAL
00:56:44.400 --> 00:56:45.835
THE COMMENTS MADE BY THE
00:56:45.902 --> 00:56:47.403
CALIFORNIA RETAILERS AND ADD TO
00:56:47.470 --> 00:56:49.472
THE ISSUE OF AVAILABILITY.
00:56:49.539 --> 00:56:51.174
CALIFORNIA REQUIRES THE MAJORITY
00:56:51.241 --> 00:56:52.509
OF STATE OWNED OR STATE RUN
00:56:52.575 --> 00:56:53.009
INSTITUTIONS TO PURCHASE
00:56:53.076 --> 00:56:56.079
CALIFORNIA GROWN PRODUCTS. WE
00:56:56.146 --> 00:56:58.248
HAVE YET TO SEE DATA THAT WE
00:56:58.314 --> 00:56:59.749
ASSURE GROCERS THAT THERE IS
00:56:59.816 --> 00:57:00.984
ENOUGH OF THE CALIFORNIA GROWN
00:57:01.050 --> 00:57:03.586
LISTED PRODUCE. TO SUSTAIN A
00:57:03.653 --> 00:57:05.288
MARKET THAT FEEDS 40 MILLION
00:57:05.355 --> 00:57:06.923
PEOPLE AND SELLS TO STATE RUN
00:57:06.990 --> 00:57:08.925
AND OWN INSTITUTIONS.
00:57:08.992 --> 00:57:10.493
ADDITIONALLY CALIFORNIA GROCERS
00:57:10.560 --> 00:57:12.262
AS PART OF AN ONGOING EFFORT TO
00:57:12.328 --> 00:57:14.397
EXPAND A PILOT PROGRAM TO
00:57:14.464 --> 00:57:16.566
INCREASE ACCESS TO FRESH FRUITS
00:57:16.633 --> 00:57:17.600
AND VEGETABLES, HEALTH RATION
00:57:17.667 --> 00:57:20.503
HEALTH FRESH RECIPIENT. WE WORRY
00:57:20.570 --> 00:57:21.938
THAT REQUIREMENTS HAS BILL WOULD
00:57:22.005 --> 00:57:23.940
HINDER THOSE EFFORTS WHILE WELL
00:57:24.007 --> 00:57:26.843
INTENTIONED ABC 7 10 WILL HAVE
00:57:26.910 --> 00:57:28.311
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES ON THE
00:57:28.378 --> 00:57:29.445
AVAILABILITY OF THE LISTED
00:57:29.512 --> 00:57:32.415
FRUITS AND VEGETABLES. FOR THESE
00:57:32.482 --> 00:57:34.717
REASONS, G P A IS IT IS OPPOSED
00:57:34.784 --> 00:57:36.686
TO A B 7 10. THANK YOU. THANK
00:57:36.753 --> 00:57:39.823
YOU, SIR. NEXT, PLEASE. THANK
00:57:39.889 --> 00:57:41.724
YOU. NO OTHER LINES IN CUBA AT
00:57:41.791 --> 00:57:43.693
THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
00:57:43.760 --> 00:57:44.861
MODERATOR. LET'S NOW BRING THE
00:57:44.928 --> 00:57:46.029
CONVERSATION BACK TO MY
00:57:46.095 --> 00:57:47.564
COLLEAGUES IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:57:47.630 --> 00:57:49.098
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS,
00:57:49.165 --> 00:57:50.099
COMMENTS AND CONCERNS, STARTING
00:57:50.166 --> 00:57:52.635
WITH SENATOR BECKER. THANK YOU.
00:57:52.702 --> 00:57:55.805
UM YEAH, I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT
00:57:55.872 --> 00:57:58.174
DO YOU HEAR THE OPPOSITION'S
00:57:58.241 --> 00:57:59.709
QUESTIONS AROUND THE DATA PIECE
00:57:59.776 --> 00:58:01.644
AND IN TERMS OF AVAILABILITY, SO
00:58:01.711 --> 00:58:02.679
I THINK THAT'D BE INTERESTING TO
00:58:02.745 --> 00:58:05.315
SEE. I DO KNOW THAT THIS BILL IS
00:58:05.381 --> 00:58:06.482
GOING TO GO TO AGRICULTURE NEXT.
00:58:06.549 --> 00:58:07.917
UM AND I JUST WANT AS A GENERAL
00:58:07.984 --> 00:58:09.519
STATEMENT. I'M SYMPATHETIC TO
00:58:09.586 --> 00:58:11.020
THE NOTION THAT WE SHOULD ASK
00:58:11.087 --> 00:58:12.622
OTHER STATES AND IMPORTS TO MEET
00:58:12.689 --> 00:58:14.591
THE SAME CONDITIONS THAT WE MEET
00:58:14.657 --> 00:58:16.926
HERE. SAME THING WE'RE DOING IN
00:58:16.993 --> 00:58:18.061
CARBON ARE CEMENT BILL, I THINK
00:58:18.127 --> 00:58:19.996
WE SHOULD DO NATIONALLY. UM FOR
00:58:20.063 --> 00:58:21.464
IMPORTS. IF WE HAVE STANDARDS,
00:58:21.531 --> 00:58:23.199
WE DON'T WANT TO DISADVANTAGE
00:58:23.266 --> 00:58:25.101
OUR OWN SUPPLIERS, SO I JUST
00:58:25.168 --> 00:58:26.836
WANT TO SAY THAT I'M VERY
00:58:26.903 --> 00:58:27.670
SYMPATHETIC TO, UM WHAT YOU'RE
00:58:27.737 --> 00:58:29.839
TRYING TO DO HERE TO MAKE SURE
00:58:29.906 --> 00:58:31.107
THAT WE DON'T DISADVANTAGE OUR
00:58:31.174 --> 00:58:32.809
OWN FARMS AND OUR OWN FARM
00:58:32.876 --> 00:58:33.843
WORKERS. THROUGH THE STANDARDS
00:58:33.910 --> 00:58:35.078
THAT WE ARE CREATING HERE IN
00:58:35.144 --> 00:58:36.713
CALIFORNIA, SO THEREFORE I WILL
00:58:36.779 --> 00:58:38.982
BE VOTING TO MOVE THIS FORWARD
00:58:39.048 --> 00:58:40.416
AND BUT WOULD LIKE TO SEE AS IT
00:58:40.483 --> 00:58:41.784
GOES FORWARD. SOME OF THAT
00:58:41.851 --> 00:58:43.419
ADDITIONAL DATA, UH, IN TERMS OF
00:58:43.486 --> 00:58:45.421
THE FEELING THAT WITH THE
00:58:45.488 --> 00:58:46.556
ABILITY TO MEET SOME OF THE
00:58:46.623 --> 00:58:47.857
CAPACITY THANK YOU, SIR. SENATOR
00:58:47.924 --> 00:58:50.693
NEWMAN. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR
00:58:50.760 --> 00:58:52.896
THROUGH THE CHAIR. QUESTION FOR
00:58:52.962 --> 00:58:54.931
THE AUTHOR SOMEBODY ELSE? HOW TO
00:58:54.998 --> 00:58:56.132
THIS QUESTION ABOUT DEMAND AND
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:58.835
WHETHER OR NOT, UM YOUR
00:58:58.902 --> 00:59:00.536
PRODUCERS CAN CAN FILL DEMAND
00:59:00.603 --> 00:59:01.704
ACROSS THE STATE EVEN DURING THE
00:59:01.771 --> 00:59:05.041
GROWING SEASON. SO IS THAT WHAT
00:59:05.108 --> 00:59:06.509
WHAT'S THE DATA THERE IS, YOU
00:59:06.576 --> 00:59:08.011
UNDERSTAND IT AND THEN TO THE
00:59:08.077 --> 00:59:09.879
EXTENT THAT THEN MAYBE THE CASE
00:59:09.946 --> 00:59:11.414
WHAT DOES THE BILL AND WHAT
00:59:11.481 --> 00:59:12.949
PROVISIONS DOES IT MAKE IN THE
00:59:13.016 --> 00:59:14.484
EVENT THAT YOU CANNOT FEEL
00:59:14.550 --> 00:59:16.953
DEMANDS? HOW DO WE ACCOUNT FOR
00:59:17.020 --> 00:59:18.154
ACCESS TO MITT? I'M GOING TO ASK
00:59:18.221 --> 00:59:20.056
OUR FARMER THAT'S ON THE LINE TO
00:59:20.123 --> 00:59:21.391
ADDRESS THAT QUESTION, BASED ON
00:59:21.457 --> 00:59:22.325
THE COMMODITIES THAT WERE
00:59:22.392 --> 00:59:25.194
SELECTED AND THE THOUGHT BEHIND,
00:59:25.261 --> 00:59:26.296
UM, SUPPLY AND DEMAND. SO
00:59:26.362 --> 00:59:30.333
PLEASE, MR BIANCO. SO DO THESE.
00:59:30.400 --> 00:59:33.269
THESE COMMODITIES WERE WERE
00:59:33.336 --> 00:59:34.837
PICKED OUT BECAUSE THEY'RE
00:59:34.904 --> 00:59:36.940
ALREADY PRODUCED ALMOST YEAR
00:59:37.006 --> 00:59:38.641
ROUND IN CALIFORNIA WHEN IT
00:59:38.708 --> 00:59:40.843
COMES TO ASPARAGUS, BELL PEPPERS
00:59:40.910 --> 00:59:41.911
, BLUEBERRIES DATES, HONEY DEW,
00:59:41.978 --> 00:59:45.515
MELONS, LEMONS. OLIVES THOSE ARE
00:59:45.581 --> 00:59:47.183
YEAR ROUND PRODUCTS. THERE WILL
00:59:47.250 --> 00:59:49.852
BE NO PROBLEM WITH I MEAN A LOT
00:59:49.919 --> 00:59:50.853
OF THESE PRODUCTS THEY'RE
00:59:50.920 --> 00:59:52.355
SUPPLIED THROUGHOUT THE UNITED
00:59:52.422 --> 00:59:52.989
STATES AND THE WORLD. SUPPLYING
00:59:53.056 --> 00:59:56.292
CALIFORNIA IS NOT A PROBLEM.
00:59:56.359 --> 00:59:57.760
WHEN IT COMES TO APPLES AND
00:59:57.827 --> 01:00:00.797
NECTARINES, THOSE WILL BE WILL
01:00:00.863 --> 01:00:03.433
BE SUPPLIED ON THE OFF SEASONS
01:00:03.499 --> 01:00:05.835
BY OTHER STATES THAT ALREADY
01:00:05.902 --> 01:00:08.104
MEET OUR STANDARDS WITH ALREADY
01:00:08.171 --> 01:00:10.473
WORK OR MEET OUR CHEMICAL
01:00:10.540 --> 01:00:11.441
STANDARDS AND OUR WORKER
01:00:11.507 --> 01:00:12.675
PROTECTION STANDARDS. THOSE
01:00:12.742 --> 01:00:15.445
STATES WILL NOT HAVE TO PAY OUR
01:00:15.511 --> 01:00:16.779
MINIMUM WAGE. NOW THAT'S
01:00:16.846 --> 01:00:18.915
ACTUALLY THAT'S ACTUALLY MY
01:00:18.982 --> 01:00:20.850
QUESTION.THE QUESTION IS WITHIN
01:00:20.917 --> 01:00:22.452
THE GROWING SEASON. CAN YOUR
01:00:22.518 --> 01:00:23.019
PRODUCERS AS IDENTIFIED? CAN
01:00:23.086 --> 01:00:25.655
THEY MEET CALIFORNIA'S DEMAND?
01:00:25.722 --> 01:00:28.891
UM WITHOUT THE TO THE POINT MADE
01:00:28.958 --> 01:00:31.227
BY, I THINK THE GROCERS WITHOUT
01:00:31.294 --> 01:00:33.196
HAVING TO FILL, YOU KNOW A GAP
01:00:33.262 --> 01:00:36.933
FROM OTHER PRODUCERS. YES THEY
01:00:37.000 --> 01:00:38.534
CAN MORE THAN MEET THE DEMAND
01:00:38.601 --> 01:00:39.836
RIGHT NOW. CALIFORNIA PRODUCERS
01:00:39.902 --> 01:00:41.371
ARE NOT ONLY MEETING THE
01:00:41.437 --> 01:00:42.372
CALIFORNIA DEMAND, BUT THE
01:00:42.438 --> 01:00:44.440
UNITED STATES DEMAND AT THIS
01:00:44.507 --> 01:00:46.843
TIME. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU.
01:00:46.909 --> 01:00:49.312
WELL, THEN I GUESS I HAVE A
01:00:49.379 --> 01:00:50.346
QUESTION. I'M TRYING TO
01:00:50.413 --> 01:00:51.447
UNDERSTAND THIS BILL. I WASN'T
01:00:51.514 --> 01:00:52.515
GONNA ASK ANY WHAT'S THE
01:00:52.582 --> 01:00:54.650
BUSINESS LOSS TODAY THAT
01:00:54.717 --> 01:00:56.986
COMMANDS A BILL OF THIS NATURE?
01:00:57.053 --> 01:00:58.721
OBVIOUSLY I THINK MY RECORD
01:00:58.788 --> 01:01:01.557
SUPPORTING FARMWORKERS STANDS.
01:01:01.624 --> 01:01:03.059
CAN STAND BY ITSELF. BUT WHAT'S
01:01:03.126 --> 01:01:05.261
THE BUSINESS CASE FOR THIS
01:01:05.328 --> 01:01:06.629
PARTICULAR? BLL HOW MUCH
01:01:06.696 --> 01:01:08.231
BUSINESS HAVE YOU LOST IN THE
01:01:08.297 --> 01:01:10.433
LAST YEAR AS A RESULT OF THIS
01:01:10.500 --> 01:01:15.171
BILL NOT BEING IN PLACE? SO FOR,
01:01:15.238 --> 01:01:16.839
YOU KNOW, 10 YEARS AGO, JUST IF
01:01:16.906 --> 01:01:18.241
YOU JUST TAKE THE COACHELLA
01:01:18.307 --> 01:01:18.808
VALLEY, THERE'S POCKETS IN
01:01:18.875 --> 01:01:19.976
CALIFORNIA THAT USED TO HIT
01:01:20.043 --> 01:01:24.347
MARKET. AND YOU KNOW, JUST TO
01:01:24.414 --> 01:01:25.148
SEE IF YOU TAKE CALIFORNIA
01:01:25.214 --> 01:01:26.549
GRAPES IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY.
01:01:26.616 --> 01:01:28.351
IT USED TO BE 12 MILLION BOXES
01:01:28.418 --> 01:01:30.987
OF GRAPES HERE NOW WE HAVE A
01:01:31.054 --> 01:01:31.621
MILLION AND A HALF. MEXICO HAS
01:01:31.687 --> 01:01:34.824
25 MILLION OF THOSE BOXES. THERE
01:01:34.891 --> 01:01:36.359
ARE ALSO THOSE, THOUGH, IF YOU
01:01:36.426 --> 01:01:37.994
TALK TABLE GRAPES FOR THE SAN
01:01:38.061 --> 01:01:40.129
JOAQUIN VALLEY FOR THE MONTH OF
01:01:40.196 --> 01:01:40.863
JUNE, JULY AND AUGUST, THEY'RE
01:01:40.930 --> 01:01:43.399
CREEPING UP INTO THOSE MARKETS.
01:01:43.466 --> 01:01:45.435
WE HAVE PERU. THAT'S THAT'S UM
01:01:45.501 --> 01:01:47.937
THAT'S DEVELOPING GRAPES THAT
01:01:48.004 --> 01:01:49.338
HAS MILLIONS OF BOXES THAT IS
01:01:49.405 --> 01:01:50.940
COMING IN. WE HAVE LEMONS FROM
01:01:51.007 --> 01:01:53.076
ARGENTINA, PERU THAT ARE COMING
01:01:53.142 --> 01:01:54.877
IN OUR MARKETS AND WHAT'S
01:01:54.944 --> 01:01:57.313
HAPPENING IS THAT WE ARE
01:01:57.380 --> 01:01:59.849
ABANDONING AND GETTING RID OF
01:01:59.916 --> 01:02:01.350
THESE PRODUCTS IN CALIFORNIA
01:02:01.417 --> 01:02:03.453
BECAUSE THEIR HIGH LABOR AND THE
01:02:03.519 --> 01:02:05.188
OTHER COUNTRIES ARE TAKING OVER
01:02:05.254 --> 01:02:07.156
. UM AND IT'S. YOU KNOW, IT
01:02:07.223 --> 01:02:08.825
WON'T BE LONG BEFORE BEFORE IT'S
01:02:08.891 --> 01:02:11.394
LITTLE BY LITTLE. IT'S GONE. SO
01:02:11.461 --> 01:02:14.430
IF THE BILL GOES INTO EFFECT
01:02:14.497 --> 01:02:16.299
JANUARY. ONE OF 2024. I DON'T
01:02:16.365 --> 01:02:19.402
REMEMBER THE EFFECTIVE DATE. ARE
01:02:19.469 --> 01:02:21.571
YOU ABLE TO RAMP UP AND SUPPLY
01:02:21.637 --> 01:02:23.473
13 MILLION? WHAT DID YOU SAY?
01:02:23.539 --> 01:02:25.408
£13 MILLION OF GRAPES. WHAT WAS
01:02:25.475 --> 01:02:28.978
THE BOXES? WHAT WHAT? YOU GOT TO
01:02:29.045 --> 01:02:31.848
REMEMBER THAT £13 MILLION WITH
01:02:31.914 --> 01:02:34.417
SUPPLYING THE UNITED STATES AND
01:02:34.484 --> 01:02:36.452
OTHER COUNTRIES WERE JUST
01:02:36.519 --> 01:02:37.053
TALKING ABOUT CALIFORNIA. WE
01:02:37.120 --> 01:02:41.224
HAVE. GOT A MILLION AND A HALF
01:02:41.290 --> 01:02:42.758
TO TWO MILLION BOXES. WE CAN
01:02:42.825 --> 01:02:45.128
SUPPLY THOSE THAT SUPPLY IS
01:02:45.194 --> 01:02:48.698
SUFFICIENT TO SUPPLY CALIFORNIA
01:02:48.764 --> 01:02:50.466
THAT MEXICO WILL SUPPLY THE REST
01:02:50.533 --> 01:02:52.568
OF THE UNITED STATES. WE'RE JUST
01:02:52.635 --> 01:02:56.072
ASKING FOR CALIFORNIA TO SUPPORT
01:02:56.139 --> 01:02:57.874
CALIFORNIA FARMWORKERS AND
01:02:57.940 --> 01:02:59.408
CALIFORNIA GROWERS. THAT'S ALL
01:02:59.475 --> 01:03:01.477
NOT THAT WE NEED TO SUPPLY THE
01:03:01.544 --> 01:03:03.880
WHOLE WORLD. JUST CALIFORNIA. SO
01:03:03.946 --> 01:03:05.681
ARE YOU SUPPLYING 1 TO 2 MILLION
01:03:05.748 --> 01:03:06.682
BOXES OF GRAPES TO CALIFORNIANS
01:03:06.749 --> 01:03:12.188
NOW? NO NO, WE'RE NOT. WE'RE
01:03:12.255 --> 01:03:14.557
EXPORTING OUR GRAPES ALL OVER
01:03:14.624 --> 01:03:18.261
THE WORLD AND SENDING THEM TO
01:03:18.327 --> 01:03:19.529
OTHER PLACES BECAUSE CALIFORNIA
01:03:19.595 --> 01:03:21.364
ISN'T BUYING OUR FRUITS AND
01:03:21.430 --> 01:03:23.332
VEGETABLES BECAUSE BECAUSE
01:03:23.399 --> 01:03:24.233
THEY'RE ALL THEY'RE GOING TO
01:03:24.300 --> 01:03:27.069
MEXICO, YOU KNOW, AND THE AND
01:03:27.136 --> 01:03:27.637
THE AND THE DIFFERENCE IS
01:03:27.703 --> 01:03:28.738
PENNIES A POUND IT'S PENNIES A
01:03:28.804 --> 01:03:31.641
POUND TO KNOW THAT YOUR FRUITS
01:03:31.707 --> 01:03:33.376
AND VEGETABLES WERE WERE
01:03:33.442 --> 01:03:36.112
PRODUCED BY A CALIFORNIA FARM
01:03:36.179 --> 01:03:37.079
WORKER THAT GOT A CALIFORNIA
01:03:37.146 --> 01:03:39.448
LIVING WAGE AND THAT WAS AND HAD
01:03:39.515 --> 01:03:41.017
THE HIGHEST STANDARDS. THAT'S
01:03:41.083 --> 01:03:42.919
ALL WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. OKAY I
01:03:42.985 --> 01:03:45.087
UNDERSTAND. I MEAN, I CERTAINLY
01:03:45.154 --> 01:03:45.888
UNDERSTAND AND SUPPORT
01:03:45.955 --> 01:03:47.390
ENVIRONMENTAL COMPLIANCE AND
01:03:47.456 --> 01:03:48.558
PESTICIDE USE AND THIS THAT AND
01:03:48.624 --> 01:03:51.827
THE OTHER AND CERTAINLY SUPPORT
01:03:51.894 --> 01:03:54.063
FARM WORKERS. I'M JUST TRYING TO
01:03:54.130 --> 01:03:54.830
UNDERSTAND THE BUSINESS REASON
01:03:54.897 --> 01:03:57.466
FOR THE BILL COULD MYSTERY. SO
01:03:57.533 --> 01:03:58.634
AS I'M UNDERSTANDING OF THE
01:03:58.701 --> 01:04:00.336
DIFFERENCE HERE IS THAT THAT
01:04:00.403 --> 01:04:01.470
CALIFORNIA PRODUCERS ARE LOSING
01:04:01.537 --> 01:04:03.706
OUT. T<c.cyan> OUTSIDE PRODUCERS</c>
01:04:03.773 --> 01:04:05.474
BECAUSE OF PRICE BECAUSE OF THE
01:04:05.541 --> 01:04:06.976
PRICE DIFFERENCE OR ADVANTAGE
01:04:07.043 --> 01:04:08.878
THAT THEY'RE THEY'RE YOU KNOW,
01:04:08.945 --> 01:04:09.412
THEY'RE THEY'RE DIFFERENT
01:04:09.478 --> 01:04:10.179
WORKING CONDITIONS, LABOR
01:04:10.246 --> 01:04:11.347
CONDITIONS. DICTATORS THAT
01:04:11.414 --> 01:04:15.952
CORRECT. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THAT'S
01:04:16.018 --> 01:04:18.187
CORRECT. THAT'S CORRECT. I MEAN
01:04:18.254 --> 01:04:19.689
, SOME OF US ARE HANGING IN
01:04:19.755 --> 01:04:21.857
THERE WITH WITH WITH WITH LOSSES
01:04:21.924 --> 01:04:23.726
. UM YOU KNOW, LIKE, YOU KNOW,
01:04:23.793 --> 01:04:25.161
THERE USED TO BE 12 MILLION
01:04:25.228 --> 01:04:27.430
BOXES. NOW THERE'S NOW NOW
01:04:27.496 --> 01:04:28.397
THERE'S TWO. IT'S GOING TO
01:04:28.464 --> 01:04:29.832
DISAPPEAR. WHEN IT COMES TO A
01:04:29.899 --> 01:04:30.833
LOT OF THESE PROJECTS IF WE
01:04:30.900 --> 01:04:33.703
DON'T DO SOMETHING NOW, UM YOU
01:04:33.769 --> 01:04:34.770
KNOW, WE'LL BE WHERE RELIANT ON
01:04:34.837 --> 01:04:36.672
OTHER COUNTRIES TO FEED US THESE
01:04:36.739 --> 01:04:37.740
PRODUCTS AND THEY WON'T COME
01:04:37.807 --> 01:04:40.476
BACK. UM YOU KNOW, THE WAGES
01:04:40.543 --> 01:04:42.645
WILL GO UP. YOU KNOW, THINGS ARE
01:04:42.712 --> 01:04:44.847
NOT GOING TO STAY AT $15 AN
01:04:44.914 --> 01:04:46.649
HOUR. WE SEE THE WRITING ON THE
01:04:46.716 --> 01:04:47.783
WALL. AND IF WE DON'T ACT NOW,
01:04:47.850 --> 01:04:49.852
UM THERE'LL BE LOST FOREVER. I
01:04:49.919 --> 01:04:51.621
MEAN, ASPARAGUS IS ALREADY ONE
01:04:51.687 --> 01:04:53.189
CROP ON THERE. THAT'S PRETTY
01:04:53.256 --> 01:04:55.858
MUCH GONE. YOU KNOW, ASPARAGUS,
01:04:55.925 --> 01:04:57.526
UM YOU KNOW, YOU CAN PRODUCE
01:04:57.593 --> 01:04:58.494
ASPARAGUS PRETTY MUCH ANYWHERE
01:04:58.561 --> 01:05:01.330
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THAT
01:05:01.397 --> 01:05:03.432
THAT THAT GROWS BUT BUT IT'S
01:05:03.499 --> 01:05:06.502
BEEN LOST BECAUSE OF WAGES.
01:05:06.569 --> 01:05:09.839
ASPARAGUS WILL COME BACK AND IN
01:05:09.905 --> 01:05:11.841
THE MEANTIME, IN THE SHORT TERM
01:05:11.907 --> 01:05:14.110
ASPARAGUS WILL BE SUPPLIED BY
01:05:14.176 --> 01:05:15.177
OTHER COUNTRIES. THEY WILL NOT
01:05:15.244 --> 01:05:18.080
HAVE TO MEET. ARE PROTECTIONS
01:05:18.147 --> 01:05:21.117
AND OUR WAGES UNTIL THE GAP IS
01:05:21.183 --> 01:05:23.085
MEAN. THAT'S THAT'S HOW WE'VE
01:05:23.152 --> 01:05:23.719
CHANGED THE BILL. WE'VE MADE IT
01:05:23.786 --> 01:05:26.188
TO WHERE IT DOESN'T HAPPEN RIGHT
01:05:26.255 --> 01:05:28.090
AWAY. SO THE RETAILERS CONCERNED
01:05:28.157 --> 01:05:29.825
ABOUT NOT HAVING PRODUCT IN THE
01:05:29.892 --> 01:05:31.427
IN THE GROCERY STORES ARE
01:05:31.494 --> 01:05:33.496
WARRANTED BECAUSE IN THE IN THE
01:05:33.562 --> 01:05:35.965
SHORT TERM THE THOSE PRODUCTS
01:05:36.032 --> 01:05:38.567
WILL STILL BE IMPORTED TO MEET
01:05:38.634 --> 01:05:40.870
THE DEMAND AND AS CALIFORNIA
01:05:40.936 --> 01:05:42.004
CHANGES THAT WILL, THEY WILL
01:05:42.071 --> 01:05:46.809
FILL THAT GAP. I'M GOOD. THANK
01:05:46.876 --> 01:05:48.210
YOU. THANK YOU, SENATOR NEWMAN.
01:05:48.277 --> 01:05:50.079
WELL, I GUESS THE EFFECT OF THIS
01:05:50.146 --> 01:05:51.681
SINCE IT'S UNLIKELY THAT COUNTRY
01:05:51.747 --> 01:05:53.449
OF MEXICO IS GOING TO ADOPT OUR
01:05:53.516 --> 01:05:55.418
CALIFORNIA LABOR CODE. I GUESS
01:05:55.484 --> 01:05:56.552
THIS EFFECTIVELY WILL SHUT THE
01:05:56.619 --> 01:06:00.823
BORDER. TO IMPORTS OF THESE
01:06:00.890 --> 01:06:02.024
PRODUCTS, AND I'LL LET SOMEBODY
01:06:02.091 --> 01:06:04.060
ELSE FIGURE THAT ONE OUT. UM
01:06:04.126 --> 01:06:06.195
DURING DURING OUR SEASON DURING
01:06:06.262 --> 01:06:07.263
OUR SEASON, THAT'S THE MOST
01:06:07.330 --> 01:06:09.398
IMPORTANT. OKAY THANK YOU, SIR.
01:06:09.465 --> 01:06:11.067
SENATOR TAYLOR HAS A QUESTION OR
01:06:11.133 --> 01:06:13.803
COMMENT. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. SO
01:06:13.869 --> 01:06:16.772
TODAY, I RISE. UH, TO URGE THAT
01:06:16.839 --> 01:06:18.841
YOU SUPPORT THIS BILL. OBVIOUSLY
01:06:18.908 --> 01:06:20.943
I THINK THAT THE PROBLEM HERE IS
01:06:21.010 --> 01:06:22.912
MUCH LARGER AND I AND I BELIEVE
01:06:22.978 --> 01:06:24.113
THAT THE AUTHOR IS REALLY, UM
01:06:24.180 --> 01:06:30.920
WORKING TO YOU KNOW? SOLVE ONE
01:06:30.986 --> 01:06:33.222
PIECE OF A LOT OF THE ISSUES
01:06:33.289 --> 01:06:33.989
THAT THAT ARE OCCURRING WITHIN
01:06:34.056 --> 01:06:37.059
OUR OUR FOOD SYSTEM. BUT
01:06:37.126 --> 01:06:39.195
SPECIFICALLY, MY CONCERN IS FOOD
01:06:39.261 --> 01:06:42.865
SAFETY. BECAUSE WE ARE SEEING A
01:06:42.932 --> 01:06:45.201
SIGNIFICANT INCREASE OF IMPORTS
01:06:45.267 --> 01:06:48.204
INTO THE US, UH, THAT I WOULD
01:06:48.270 --> 01:06:49.805
SAY IS FOR SEVERAL REASONS, BUT
01:06:49.872 --> 01:06:51.974
I THINK THAT IF WE HAVE SOME OF
01:06:52.041 --> 01:06:53.042
THE HIGHEST STANDARDS IN THE
01:06:53.109 --> 01:06:56.212
STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR ALL GOOD
01:06:56.278 --> 01:06:59.081
REASONS FOR HEALTH REASONS AND
01:06:59.148 --> 01:07:01.851
PROTECTING OUR CONSUMERS. WE
01:07:01.917 --> 01:07:03.452
SHOULD HAVE. WE SHOULD BENEFIT
01:07:03.519 --> 01:07:05.187
FROM FROM THOSE FROM THOSE
01:07:05.254 --> 01:07:08.090
POLICIES. UM AND I THINK THAT
01:07:08.157 --> 01:07:11.127
WILL HAVE TO DO A LOT MORE WORK
01:07:11.193 --> 01:07:13.162
IN THIS SPACE TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:07:13.229 --> 01:07:16.298
UM, THAT ANY FOOD THAT IS BEING
01:07:16.365 --> 01:07:18.901
IMPORTED THAT THEY ARE HELD TO
01:07:18.968 --> 01:07:20.102
THE SAME STANDARDS THAT WE HOLD
01:07:20.169 --> 01:07:22.304
HERE BECAUSE IT BECOMES FOOD
01:07:22.371 --> 01:07:24.240
SAFETY ISSUE AND IT BECOMES A
01:07:24.306 --> 01:07:26.409
HEALTH ISSUE AND I KNOW NOT TOO
01:07:26.475 --> 01:07:28.711
LONG AGO WE HEARD ABOUT THE BABY
01:07:28.778 --> 01:07:31.080
FORMULA SHORTAGE AND HOW
01:07:31.147 --> 01:07:32.248
CRONOBACTER WAS A PATHOGEN THAT
01:07:32.314 --> 01:07:35.217
WAS FOUND IN THE AND THE BABY
01:07:35.284 --> 01:07:36.185
FORMULA AND CREATED THIS
01:07:36.252 --> 01:07:37.553
SHORTAGE. WELL, THAT'S THAT'S
01:07:37.620 --> 01:07:38.754
WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. IN
01:07:38.821 --> 01:07:39.789
TERMS OF THE FUTURE OF FOOD
01:07:39.855 --> 01:07:42.158
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT, UM YOU
01:07:42.224 --> 01:07:46.095
KNOW, RELY, YOU KNOW NATIONS,
01:07:46.162 --> 01:07:47.596
RELYING ON ONE ANOTHER,
01:07:47.663 --> 01:07:49.899
INCREASINGLY FOR DIFFERENT TYPES
01:07:49.965 --> 01:07:53.569
OF FOODS. UM BUT BUT COUNTERFEIT
01:07:53.636 --> 01:07:55.171
FOODS ARE BECOMING INCREASINGLY
01:07:55.237 --> 01:07:59.308
AN ISSUE AROUND THE WORLD. AND
01:07:59.375 --> 01:08:03.412
THAT CREATES A HEALTH ISSUE FOR
01:08:03.479 --> 01:08:04.680
ALL OF US, AND SO WE WANT TO
01:08:04.747 --> 01:08:06.649
MAKE SURE THAT WE CREATE SOME
01:08:06.715 --> 01:08:09.318
SORT OF STANDARD OR THAT WE HOPE
01:08:09.385 --> 01:08:10.453
THAT THAT WERE, UH, HOLDING
01:08:10.519 --> 01:08:12.054
OTHERS ACCOUNTABLE TO THE SAME
01:08:12.121 --> 01:08:14.490
STANDARD THAT WE HOLD OUR OWN.
01:08:14.557 --> 01:08:14.990
SO FOR THOSE REASONS, I
01:08:15.057 --> 01:08:16.492
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU AND URGE
01:08:16.559 --> 01:08:18.360
YOU ALL TO SUPPORT THIS BILL.
01:08:18.427 --> 01:08:19.728
THANK YOU, SENATOR TATO, SENATOR
01:08:19.795 --> 01:08:24.099
EDMUND. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. UM
01:08:24.166 --> 01:08:25.568
I THINK THE ONLY MEMBER FOR
01:08:25.634 --> 01:08:28.838
BRINGING THIS FORWARD UM INTER
01:08:28.904 --> 01:08:30.539
INTERESTING CONCEPT. MY ISSUE
01:08:30.606 --> 01:08:32.208
WITH IT IS MORE LIKE I DON'T
01:08:32.274 --> 01:08:33.409
KNOW HOW YOU IMPLEMENT IT. I
01:08:33.476 --> 01:08:34.677
DON'T KNOW HOW YOU ENFORCE IT. I
01:08:34.743 --> 01:08:36.579
DON'T KNOW HOW YOU IMPLEMENT IT.
01:08:36.645 --> 01:08:39.181
AND I SO I, YOU KNOW, AND IT
01:08:39.248 --> 01:08:40.382
WOULD HAVE BEEN NICE TO HEAR
01:08:40.449 --> 01:08:42.184
FROM ME. I HAVEN'T HEARD FROM
01:08:42.251 --> 01:08:43.185
ANYBODY ON THIS EXCEPT UM, JUST
01:08:43.252 --> 01:08:44.119
, YOU KNOW, IN ANALYZING THE
01:08:44.186 --> 01:08:45.621
BILL, THAT WAS OUR QUESTION.
01:08:45.688 --> 01:08:47.690
LIKE HOW HOW DO YOU ENFORCE IT?
01:08:47.756 --> 01:08:49.792
HOW DO YOU IMPLEMENT THIS? AND
01:08:49.859 --> 01:08:50.726
I'VE CERTAINLY TRIED TO WORK IN
01:08:50.793 --> 01:08:52.361
THIS SPACE TO HAVE MORE OF
01:08:52.428 --> 01:08:53.529
CALIFORNIA'S STUFF, ESPECIALLY
01:08:53.596 --> 01:08:54.363
IN OUR SCHOOLS, EATING AND
01:08:54.430 --> 01:08:55.764
CONSUMED BY US. BUT I DON'T SEE
01:08:55.831 --> 01:08:58.400
THE ABILITY TO ENFORCE AND SOME
01:08:58.467 --> 01:08:59.168
OF THE CROPS YOU'RE TALKING
01:08:59.235 --> 01:09:00.269
ABOUT ASPARAGUS. I MEAN, I
01:09:00.336 --> 01:09:01.537
REPRESENT THE HOME OF THE
01:09:01.604 --> 01:09:03.272
ASPARAGUS. THERE'S NO MORE WE
01:09:03.339 --> 01:09:06.308
ARE. WE ARE OUT OF BUSINESS. UM
01:09:06.375 --> 01:09:07.843
YOU KNOW, WE WENT THROUGH THE
01:09:07.910 --> 01:09:08.811
FORMING, I THINK 60,000 ACRES
01:09:08.878 --> 01:09:10.813
DOWN TO NOTHING. SO THE IDEA
01:09:10.880 --> 01:09:12.548
THAT WE'RE STILL GROWING
01:09:12.615 --> 01:09:15.484
ASPARAGUS AND IN CALIFORNIA'S UM
01:09:15.551 --> 01:09:17.019
, YOU KNOW, MAYBE DOWN IN
01:09:17.086 --> 01:09:17.853
COACHELLA VALLEY. I DON'T KNOW.
01:09:17.920 --> 01:09:19.955
BECAUSE IT TAKES IT TAKES A
01:09:20.022 --> 01:09:21.624
CERTAIN AREA ANYWAY. UH I MEAN,
01:09:21.690 --> 01:09:23.592
I LOVE THE IDEA. I THINK WE'RE
01:09:23.659 --> 01:09:26.228
ALL INVESTED AS MUCH AS WE CAN
01:09:26.295 --> 01:09:27.429
AND GETTING OUR CALIFORNIA STUFF
01:09:27.496 --> 01:09:28.030
AND CALIFORNIA MARKETS AND WE
01:09:28.097 --> 01:09:29.798
LIVE IN A GLOBAL ECONOMY. WHEN I
01:09:29.865 --> 01:09:32.034
WAS A CHAIR OF AGONY, I WENT ON.
01:09:32.101 --> 01:09:33.869
I WAS ABLE TO GO ON A TRADE
01:09:33.936 --> 01:09:35.905
MICHIGAN GO THROUGH SOME OF THE
01:09:35.971 --> 01:09:36.939
MARKETS IN MEXICO. AND CERTAINLY
01:09:37.006 --> 01:09:38.607
I MEAN, OUR FRUITS AND
01:09:38.674 --> 01:09:39.742
VEGETABLES ARE EVERYWHERE THERE.
01:09:39.808 --> 01:09:40.809
I MEAN, WE EXPORT MORE THAN AS
01:09:40.876 --> 01:09:42.077
WE'VE SAID. IT'S MORE THAN WE
01:09:42.144 --> 01:09:43.779
IMPORT. IT'S A GLOBAL WORLD WE
01:09:43.846 --> 01:09:45.915
LIVE IN. SO UM, I THINK IT'S AN
01:09:45.981 --> 01:09:47.449
INTERESTING IDEA, AND I'M WOULD
01:09:47.516 --> 01:09:48.884
BE WILLING TO WORK FOR SOMETHING
01:09:48.951 --> 01:09:50.152
THAT I WOULD SEE IN ENFORCEMENT
01:09:50.219 --> 01:09:52.021
PATH TO, BUT I DON'T I DON'T I
01:09:52.087 --> 01:09:53.622
DON'T SEE THAT IN THIS BILL. SO
01:09:53.689 --> 01:09:55.491
THANK YOU. SER MELINDA'S. THANK
01:09:55.558 --> 01:10:00.062
YOU, MR CHAIRMAN. SO. I THINK
01:10:00.129 --> 01:10:01.797
YOU NEED TO SPEAK TO A COUPLE OF
01:10:01.864 --> 01:10:03.799
THE ISSUES THAT WERE RAISED FROM
01:10:03.866 --> 01:10:06.235
THE OPPOSITION. I'M GUESSING YOU
01:10:06.302 --> 01:10:07.603
TOOK SOME NOTES AS TO WHAT THOSE
01:10:07.670 --> 01:10:09.338
WORDS ALREADY FAMILIAR WITH THEM
01:10:09.405 --> 01:10:10.639
. SO IF YOU WOULD MIND
01:10:10.706 --> 01:10:13.242
SPECIFICALLY TALK ABOUT THE
01:10:13.309 --> 01:10:19.915
ENFORCEMENT SIDE OF THIS AND THE. PRODUCTION SIDE OF THIS HOW
01:10:19.982 --> 01:10:21.350
YOU MAKE SURE THAT CALIFORNIANS
01:10:21.417 --> 01:10:23.719
HAVE TO PRODUCE THAT THEY EXPECT
01:10:23.786 --> 01:10:24.853
AND DEMAND IN THE GROCERY
01:10:24.920 --> 01:10:26.121
STORES. YOU CAN START WITH THIS.
01:10:26.188 --> 01:10:27.957
THAT WOULD BE GREAT. HAPPY TO
01:10:28.023 --> 01:10:29.959
YOU KNOW, I THINK YOU HEARD FROM
01:10:30.025 --> 01:10:30.793
OUR CALIFORNIA FARMER, MR BIANCO
01:10:30.859 --> 01:10:32.461
THAT 10 COMMODITIES THAT WERE
01:10:32.528 --> 01:10:33.862
SELECTED WERE ON THE BASIS THAT
01:10:33.929 --> 01:10:37.266
THEY WOULD BE AVAILABLE. MOST
01:10:37.333 --> 01:10:40.169
LIKELY ON A YEAR ROUND BASIS. UH
01:10:40.235 --> 01:10:41.537
I THINK THE COMMENT THAT MS
01:10:41.604 --> 01:10:42.972
HAGEMAN SENATOR MEGAN SIGMUND
01:10:43.038 --> 01:10:44.406
MAKES ALIGNS WITH WHAT MR BIANCO
01:10:44.473 --> 01:10:45.541
HAS SAID ASPARAGUS TO SOME
01:10:45.608 --> 01:10:48.844
EXTENT. IN SOME AREAS OF STATE
01:10:48.911 --> 01:10:50.846
ARE GONE RIGHT TO THE POINT OF
01:10:50.913 --> 01:10:53.082
WHY A BILL LIKE THIS IS CRITICAL
01:10:53.148 --> 01:10:53.582
, RIGHT? SOMEONE ELSE'S
01:10:53.649 --> 01:10:57.119
PRODUCING THAT CAN I CAN I STOP
01:10:57.186 --> 01:10:58.153
YOU THERE? SINCE WE'RE TALKING
01:10:58.220 --> 01:10:59.722
ABOUT ASPARAGUS SO MUCH WHICH I
01:10:59.788 --> 01:11:02.958
LOVE. UM SO IT SOUNDS LIKE
01:11:03.025 --> 01:11:03.926
THERE'S NOT A WHOLE LOT OF
01:11:03.993 --> 01:11:05.861
PEOPLE WHO ARE FARMING ASPARAGUS
01:11:05.928 --> 01:11:07.930
RIGHT NOW. SO IF WE PUT THAT IN
01:11:07.997 --> 01:11:10.366
THE BILL, IT SAYS, YOU CAN ONLY
01:11:10.432 --> 01:11:11.567
GET THIS IN CALIFORNIA UNLESS
01:11:11.634 --> 01:11:12.701
IT'S COMING FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE.
01:11:12.768 --> 01:11:13.602
YOU'RE FOLLOWING OUR
01:11:13.669 --> 01:11:16.338
REGULATIONS. THEN WHAT HAPPENS
01:11:16.405 --> 01:11:18.140
TO THE SUPPLY OF ASPARAGUS IN
01:11:18.207 --> 01:11:19.441
CALIFORNIA? THEY WERE NOT
01:11:19.508 --> 01:11:20.843
FARMING IT. THESE COMMODITIES
01:11:20.909 --> 01:11:22.578
THAT WERE SELECTED WERE SELECTED
01:11:22.645 --> 01:11:25.481
AND PUT FORWARD BY INDUSTRY.
01:11:25.547 --> 01:11:29.418
FARMERS UH, THEY THEY DECIDED TO
01:11:29.485 --> 01:11:30.919
BE PART OF THIS 10 LIST OF
01:11:30.986 --> 01:11:32.454
COMMODITIES THAT DOESN'T THAT
01:11:32.521 --> 01:11:34.223
DOESN'T SOLVE THE PROBLEM OF
01:11:34.289 --> 01:11:36.191
SUPPLY. YOUR QUESTION WAS IF WE
01:11:36.258 --> 01:11:40.095
DON'T HAVE ASPARAGUS, RIGHT? HOW
01:11:40.162 --> 01:11:41.697
ARE WE GOING TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:11:41.764 --> 01:11:42.765
THESE GROCERY STORES HAVE THEM
01:11:42.831 --> 01:11:45.200
ON THE SHELVES? RESPONSE TO YOU
01:11:45.267 --> 01:11:47.703
IS THAT ASPARAGUS GROWERS SAID
01:11:47.770 --> 01:11:48.771
THAT THEY CAN PRODUCE THESE.
01:11:48.837 --> 01:11:50.639
THEY'VE ASKED TO BE PART OF THE
01:11:50.706 --> 01:11:52.641
10 COMMODITIES. AND THAT'S WHY
01:11:52.708 --> 01:11:53.942
THEY'RE LISTED HERE IF THEY FELT
01:11:54.009 --> 01:11:58.080
THAT THEY COULD NOT. PRODUCED
01:11:58.147 --> 01:12:00.015
THESE THEN THEY WOULD NOT BE ON
01:12:00.082 --> 01:12:01.650
THE LIST OF 10 COMMODITIES.
01:12:01.717 --> 01:12:03.419
THESE COMMODITIES WERE SELECTED
01:12:03.485 --> 01:12:05.621
AGAIN BY THE INDUSTRY IS COMING
01:12:05.688 --> 01:12:06.622
FORWARD, NOT BY US PULLING THEM
01:12:06.689 --> 01:12:09.591
OUT OF A HAT. AND SAYING, THESE
01:12:09.658 --> 01:12:11.060
ARE THE 10 COMMODITIES THAT WE
01:12:11.126 --> 01:12:13.195
HOPE WILL BE IN THE GROCERY
01:12:13.262 --> 01:12:15.964
STORES. AND SO I'D LIKE FOR MR
01:12:16.031 --> 01:12:17.166
BIANCO, MAYBE TO ELABORATE ON
01:12:17.232 --> 01:12:20.736
THE IDEA OF THESE COMMODITIES
01:12:20.803 --> 01:12:22.271
AND ASPARAGUS AND THEN IN
01:12:22.337 --> 01:12:23.238
REGARDS TO ENFORCEMENT, GLENN
01:12:23.305 --> 01:12:25.007
FARRELL WILL WILL TOUCH ON THAT
01:12:25.074 --> 01:12:29.144
AS WELL. I JUST WANT EVERYONE TO
01:12:29.211 --> 01:12:32.081
BE TO BE CLEAR THAT IN THE SHORT
01:12:32.147 --> 01:12:34.450
TERM THAT THERE WILL NOW THERE
01:12:34.516 --> 01:12:35.951
WON'T BE ANY. ANY SHORTAGE OF
01:12:36.018 --> 01:12:39.688
ASPARAGUS, OKAY? ASPARAGUS IN
01:12:39.755 --> 01:12:41.323
THE SHORT TERM UNTIL THE GROWERS
01:12:41.390 --> 01:12:43.959
OF CALIFORNIA PLANT A SPIRIT
01:12:44.026 --> 01:12:45.494
PLANT BACK ASPARAGUS THERE USED
01:12:45.561 --> 01:12:47.396
TO BE ASPARAGUS HERE YEAR ROUND
01:12:47.463 --> 01:12:50.132
ALL THE TIME. PRODUCED IN
01:12:50.199 --> 01:12:51.834
CALIFORNIA, SUPPLYING THE UNITED
01:12:51.900 --> 01:12:54.436
STATES YEAR ROUND, RIGHT IN
01:12:54.503 --> 01:12:57.439
CALIFORNIA AND YOU'RE RIGHT MOST
01:12:57.506 --> 01:12:58.040
OF THAT HAS DISAPPEARED THAT
01:12:58.107 --> 01:13:02.077
WILL COME BACK. BUT IN THE SHORT
01:13:02.144 --> 01:13:03.645
TERM, YOU WILL. STILL THE
01:13:03.712 --> 01:13:06.381
RETAILERS WILL STILL BE ABLE TO
01:13:06.448 --> 01:13:08.183
IMPORT ASPARAGUS FROM OTHER
01:13:08.250 --> 01:13:11.120
COUNTRIES AND THEY WILL NOT BE
01:13:11.186 --> 01:13:12.321
ABLE TO THEY WILL NOT HAVE TO
01:13:12.387 --> 01:13:15.457
PAY. BE THE STATE'S MINIMUM WAGE
01:13:15.524 --> 01:13:16.058
OR MEET THOSE PROTECTIONS IF
01:13:16.125 --> 01:13:25.167
IT'S NOT IN SEASON. OKAY, UM.
01:13:25.234 --> 01:13:26.168
YOU HAD A QUESTION ABOUT
01:13:26.235 --> 01:13:27.770
ENFORCEMENT, BECAUSE IF WE'RE
01:13:27.836 --> 01:13:30.672
TALKING ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT
01:13:30.739 --> 01:13:33.075
THOSE OTHER STATES OR COUNTRIES
01:13:33.142 --> 01:13:35.177
, FRANKLY, THAT ARE IMPORTING
01:13:35.244 --> 01:13:37.045
FOODS INTO CALIFORNIA THAT THEY
01:13:37.112 --> 01:13:38.213
ARE FOLLOWING THE SAME
01:13:38.280 --> 01:13:39.915
REGULATORY SCHEME THAT WE HAVE
01:13:39.982 --> 01:13:42.818
SET UP. HOW DO WE ENFORCE THAT?
01:13:42.885 --> 01:13:44.319
BECAUSE I THINK YOU PROBABLY SAW
01:13:44.386 --> 01:13:46.221
IN THE ANALYSIS WHERE THERE IS
01:13:46.288 --> 01:13:48.056
DISCUSSION ABOUT THE
01:13:48.123 --> 01:13:50.325
FLUCTUATIONS IN THE LABOR MARKET
01:13:50.392 --> 01:13:53.629
AND SPECIFICALLY IN, UM UM, YOU
01:13:53.695 --> 01:13:55.063
KNOW HOW MUCH PEOPLE ARE
01:13:55.130 --> 01:13:57.099
ACTUALLY PAID. SO IF THERE ARE
01:13:57.166 --> 01:13:58.700
FLUCTUATIONS, AND I JUST I'M
01:13:58.767 --> 01:14:00.102
REALLY STRUGGLING TO UNDERSTAND
01:14:00.169 --> 01:14:01.270
THE ENFORCEMENT OF REFERRED TO
01:14:01.336 --> 01:14:04.873
GLENN. THANK YOU. FOR AGREE.
01:14:04.940 --> 01:14:06.275
AFTERNOON MR. CHAIR GLENN
01:14:06.341 --> 01:14:09.077
FARRELL, UH, ON BEHALF OF THE
01:14:09.144 --> 01:14:10.078
SPONSORS GROWING COACHELLA
01:14:10.145 --> 01:14:11.847
VALLEY, SO A COUPLE OF QUESTIONS
01:14:11.914 --> 01:14:13.081
, SENATOR MELINDA'S THAT YOU'VE
01:14:13.148 --> 01:14:14.183
ASKED, AND OTHERS HAVE ASKED AS
01:14:14.249 --> 01:14:16.084
WELL. SENATOR EDMUND INCLUDED. I
01:14:16.151 --> 01:14:17.586
CAN START. I GUESS WITH THE
01:14:17.653 --> 01:14:19.154
ENFORCEMENT PIECE AND JUST THE
01:14:19.221 --> 01:14:19.788
IMPLEMENTATION. I MEAN, IT'S A
01:14:19.855 --> 01:14:22.157
IT'S A MAJOR CONSTRUCT HERE AND
01:14:22.224 --> 01:14:22.758
TRYING TO UNDERSTAND HOW THIS
01:14:22.825 --> 01:14:23.992
KIND OF PROGRAM WOULD WOULD
01:14:24.059 --> 01:14:26.528
DEVELOP. AND I GUESS I WOULD SAY
01:14:26.595 --> 01:14:29.298
A COUPLE OF THINGS. UM YOU KNOW
01:14:29.364 --> 01:14:33.569
THE BILL INTENTIONALLY. UM
01:14:33.635 --> 01:14:35.070
PANTS. A LOT OF THE PROGRAM
01:14:35.137 --> 01:14:36.572
DEVELOPMENT TO CDF A WHEN
01:14:36.638 --> 01:14:37.706
ACKNOWLEDGING IN OUR
01:14:37.773 --> 01:14:39.575
CONVERSATIONS WITH CDF A THAT
01:14:39.641 --> 01:14:40.742
THIS IS A PROGRAM THAT THEY'RE
01:14:40.809 --> 01:14:41.877
GONNA HAVE TO DEVELOP. THEY
01:14:41.944 --> 01:14:44.446
DON'T HAVE THIS SORT OF
01:14:44.513 --> 01:14:45.547
STRUCTURE IN PLACE. THEY HAVE
01:14:45.614 --> 01:14:46.682
SOME ELEMENTS OF IT. I'LL TALK
01:14:46.748 --> 01:14:47.916
ABOUT THAT. BUT GENERALLY THE
01:14:47.983 --> 01:14:49.651
PROGRAM YOU KNOW MUCH OF THE
01:14:49.718 --> 01:14:51.486
IMPLEMENTATION THAT DEVELOPMENT
01:14:51.553 --> 01:14:52.454
THE STRUCTURE OF THE FRAMEWORKS
01:14:52.521 --> 01:14:54.089
. THE SIDEBOARDS ARE IN THIS
01:14:54.156 --> 01:14:55.390
BILL, BUT YOU KNOW, WE'VE ASKED
01:14:55.457 --> 01:14:57.826
THEM TO DEVELOP THE THROUGH
01:14:57.893 --> 01:14:59.928
REGULATION UPON APPROPRIATION BY
01:14:59.995 --> 01:15:02.064
THE LEGISLATURE. SO YOU KNOW WE
01:15:02.130 --> 01:15:03.031
HAVE ALL THIS KIND OF DELAY
01:15:03.098 --> 01:15:03.632
IMPLEMENTATION IS WILLING TO
01:15:03.699 --> 01:15:05.868
TAKE EFFECT UNTIL THEY DEVELOP
01:15:05.934 --> 01:15:06.802
THE REGULATIONS AND THEY CAN'T
01:15:06.869 --> 01:15:08.003
DEVELOP THE REGULATIONS UNTIL
01:15:08.070 --> 01:15:09.671
THEY GET SOME APPROPRIATION FROM
01:15:09.738 --> 01:15:11.506
THE LEGISLATURE TO DO SO. SO YOU
01:15:11.573 --> 01:15:12.841
KNOW THAT A LOT OF THE
01:15:12.908 --> 01:15:14.343
REGULATION PROGRAM STRUCTURES
01:15:14.409 --> 01:15:16.812
DEFERRED TO CDFA TO CREATE THAT
01:15:16.879 --> 01:15:18.480
PROGRAM, BUT THERE ARE ELEMENTS
01:15:18.547 --> 01:15:20.082
THAT THEY ALREADY THAT THEY
01:15:20.148 --> 01:15:21.049
ALREADY UNDERTAKE. TODAY, FOR
01:15:21.116 --> 01:15:23.452
INSTANCE. THEY ALREADY HAVE A
01:15:23.518 --> 01:15:25.153
PRETTY ROBUST STRUCTURE FOR
01:15:25.220 --> 01:15:26.955
THIRD PARTY AGENTS WHERE THEY
01:15:27.022 --> 01:15:28.657
CONTRACT WITH ENTITIES AND
01:15:28.724 --> 01:15:30.292
PARTIES AND OTHER STATES AND
01:15:30.359 --> 01:15:32.060
OTHER COUNTRIES TO DO AUDITING
01:15:32.127 --> 01:15:33.028
AND INSPECTIONS ALREADY, THEY
01:15:33.095 --> 01:15:35.964
HAVE THIRD PARTY ARRANGEMENTS
01:15:36.031 --> 01:15:37.065
WITH THE COOPERATIVE
01:15:37.132 --> 01:15:38.166
AGRICULTURAL SUPPORT SERVICES%
01:15:38.233 --> 01:15:39.301
PROGRAM TO PROVIDE INSPECTION
01:15:39.368 --> 01:15:41.637
AND AUDITING. TO HANDLE STATE
01:15:41.703 --> 01:15:42.704
AND FEDERAL FOOD SAFETY
01:15:42.771 --> 01:15:44.907
STANDARDS. THEY HAVE
01:15:44.973 --> 01:15:46.942
COMPREHENSIVE THIRD PARTY AGENT
01:15:47.009 --> 01:15:48.944
ARRANGEMENTS FOR PREVENTIVE
01:15:49.011 --> 01:15:49.845
CONTROLS FOR HUMAN FOOD
01:15:49.912 --> 01:15:51.980
REGULATION, FOREIGN SUPPLIER
01:15:52.047 --> 01:15:53.949
VERIFICATION PROGRAMS. THEY
01:15:54.016 --> 01:15:55.217
ALREADY HAVE A LOT OF THE
01:15:55.284 --> 01:15:56.618
STRUCTURE IN PLACE. OKAY I'M
01:15:56.685 --> 01:15:58.687
GOING TO STOP YOU RIGHT THERE
01:15:58.754 --> 01:15:59.288
BECAUSE YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT
01:15:59.354 --> 01:16:02.257
SOME THINGS THAT ARE EASY. TO
01:16:02.324 --> 01:16:04.426
AUDIT IN OUR WELL NOT EASY TO
01:16:04.493 --> 01:16:05.360
AUDIT THAT ARE ALREADY BEING
01:16:05.427 --> 01:16:07.329
DONE. BUT WHAT THEY ARE NOT
01:16:07.396 --> 01:16:09.698
DOING IS LOOKING INTO THE LABOR
01:16:09.765 --> 01:16:11.566
PRACTICES OR THE COMPENSATION
01:16:11.633 --> 01:16:12.501
PRACTICES OF THESE OTHER
01:16:12.567 --> 01:16:15.470
ENTITIES. CORRECT. YOU'RE RIGHT,
01:16:15.537 --> 01:16:17.072
SENATOR MELINDA, AND THAT'S WHAT
01:16:17.139 --> 01:16:17.639
THE WHOLE PROGRAM STRUCTURES
01:16:17.706 --> 01:16:19.074
INTENDED TO DO. WHAT I'M TRYING
01:16:19.141 --> 01:16:20.509
TO DEMONSTRATORS. THEY DON'T
01:16:20.575 --> 01:16:22.077
NEED TO HIRE AN ARMYOF PEOPLE.
01:16:22.144 --> 01:16:23.745
THEY HAVE PEOPLE OUT THERE. THEY
01:16:23.812 --> 01:16:24.980
WILL NEED TO TRAIN UP TO
01:16:25.047 --> 01:16:26.248
UNDERSTAND HOW TO IMPLEMENT THIS
01:16:26.315 --> 01:16:27.983
AND ENFORCES PROGRAM. BUT THEY
01:16:28.050 --> 01:16:29.151
ALREADY HAVE THE PEOPLE OUT
01:16:29.217 --> 01:16:30.252
THERE. THEY ALREADY HAVE THE
01:16:30.319 --> 01:16:31.286
ARRANGEMENTS IN THE IN THE
01:16:31.353 --> 01:16:33.388
AGREEMENTS. IN TERMS OF SUPPLY
01:16:33.455 --> 01:16:35.424
DEMAND ISSUE. UM I THINK THE
01:16:35.490 --> 01:16:36.258
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AND ANTHONY
01:16:36.325 --> 01:16:37.459
BIANCO HAVE ADDRESSED THIS
01:16:37.526 --> 01:16:39.962
LARGEST BACKED BUT IT ALSO GETS
01:16:40.028 --> 01:16:40.963
TO CENTER. NEWMAN'S QUESTION
01:16:41.029 --> 01:16:43.665
ABOUT HOW DO WE UNDERSTAND THIS,
01:16:43.732 --> 01:16:45.467
LIKE KIND OF REAL TIME BASIS OF
01:16:45.534 --> 01:16:46.935
SUPPLY DEMAND, AND I WOULD SAY,
01:16:47.002 --> 01:16:49.237
YOU KNOW, WE LOOK AT WHAT IS
01:16:49.304 --> 01:16:50.672
ALREADY IN EXISTENCE. THERE ARE
01:16:50.739 --> 01:16:52.541
MARKETING ORDERS AND AGREEMENTS.
01:16:52.607 --> 01:16:54.009
THEY'RE ALREADY IN EXISTENCE,
01:16:54.076 --> 01:16:55.644
AND THESE MARKETING ORDERS ARE
01:16:55.711 --> 01:16:57.245
REALLY IMPORTANT FOR VARIETY OF
01:16:57.312 --> 01:16:59.414
PURPOSES FOR MAINTAINING THE
01:16:59.481 --> 01:16:59.915
QUALITY OF PRODUCE FOR
01:16:59.982 --> 01:17:03.051
STANDARDIZING PACKAGING. BUT
01:17:03.118 --> 01:17:04.386
IMPORTANTLY, REGULATING THE FLOW
01:17:04.453 --> 01:17:07.356
OF PRODUCT TO MARKET.
01:17:07.422 --> 01:17:09.324
ESTABLISHING RESERVE PROGRAMS
01:17:09.391 --> 01:17:12.728
FOR STORING ALL COMMODITIES. SO
01:17:12.794 --> 01:17:14.196
THERE'S MARKETING ORDERS ALREADY
01:17:14.262 --> 01:17:17.199
EXISTENCE CDF, A AND IN THE
01:17:17.265 --> 01:17:19.101
FEDERAL USDA HAVE THE ABILITY
01:17:19.167 --> 01:17:21.370
SORT OF ON A REAL TIME BASIS TO
01:17:21.436 --> 01:17:23.238
ASSESS THE SUPPLY DEMAND AND TO
01:17:23.305 --> 01:17:24.239
MAKE ADJUSTMENTS SO PERHAPS
01:17:24.306 --> 01:17:25.240
THERE'S AN OPPORTUNITY HERE TO
01:17:25.307 --> 01:17:28.143
LOOK AT. YOU KNOW IF THERE'S A
01:17:28.210 --> 01:17:29.711
TRIGGER TO SUSPEND THE PROGRAM
01:17:29.778 --> 01:17:31.179
THE APPLICATION OF THE PROGRAM
01:17:31.246 --> 01:17:33.181
IF IT'S IF THE MARKETING ORDER
01:17:33.248 --> 01:17:34.583
AND ANNOUNCED BY CDFA SUGGESTED
01:17:34.649 --> 01:17:37.319
SUPPLY DEMAND IS GOING TO BE
01:17:37.386 --> 01:17:38.320
IMBALANCE, PERHAPS THERE'S AN
01:17:38.387 --> 01:17:39.321
OPPORTUNITY TO REVISIT SOMETHING
01:17:39.388 --> 01:17:41.923
LIKE THAT AS WELL. OKAY SO I
01:17:41.990 --> 01:17:46.261
APPRECIATE YOUR. WILLINGNESS TO
01:17:46.328 --> 01:17:48.430
TRY TO ANSWER SOME OF THE
01:17:48.497 --> 01:17:49.498
CONCERNS THAT I HAVE THAT I
01:17:49.564 --> 01:17:50.665
DON'T THINK YOU WERE ABLE TO.
01:17:50.732 --> 01:17:53.869
REALLY UM, GET TO MOST OF THEM.
01:17:53.935 --> 01:17:56.071
UM ASSEMBLYMAN GARCIA, DO YOU
01:17:56.138 --> 01:17:58.373
HAVE ANYTHING TO ADD WITH? I
01:17:58.440 --> 01:18:00.108
THINK I THINK IT'S SUMMARY. WHAT
01:18:00.175 --> 01:18:01.376
HE SAID WAS AND I'LL REITERATE,
01:18:01.443 --> 01:18:03.745
IS THAT WE'RE ASKING CD EFFECT
01:18:03.812 --> 01:18:05.614
TO TELL US HOW WE IMPLEMENT
01:18:05.680 --> 01:18:08.183
THIS. AS WE DO WITH MANY OTHER
01:18:08.250 --> 01:18:10.519
BILLS THAT COME BEFORE US. WE
01:18:10.585 --> 01:18:12.754
ASKED THE AGENCY THE EXPERTS
01:18:12.821 --> 01:18:15.323
THAT WORK ON THIS TO FIGURE OUT
01:18:15.390 --> 01:18:16.525
THE MECHANICS OF GETTING FROM A
01:18:16.591 --> 01:18:18.126
THROUGH Z. AND HOPEFULLY THE
01:18:18.193 --> 01:18:20.162
OUTCOME THAT WE'RE ACHIEVING. UH
01:18:20.228 --> 01:18:23.198
WE ATTEMPTED TO TRY TO DEVELOP
01:18:23.265 --> 01:18:25.667
THE ACTUAL MECHANICAL, YOU KNOW,
01:18:25.734 --> 01:18:28.437
PROCESS OF HOW WE IMPLEMENT THIS
01:18:28.503 --> 01:18:29.638
. WE WENT BACK AND FORTH WITH
01:18:29.704 --> 01:18:30.539
COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS ON MANY
01:18:30.605 --> 01:18:32.841
OTHER QUESTIONS THAT REMAIN
01:18:32.908 --> 01:18:33.842
UNANSWERED. AND WE'RE SAYING
01:18:33.909 --> 01:18:35.944
LOOK, CDF A IS THE AGENCY THAT
01:18:36.011 --> 01:18:38.213
CAN ACTUALLY ASSIST US WITH
01:18:38.280 --> 01:18:39.614
PUTTING THIS TOGETHER. GLENN
01:18:39.681 --> 01:18:42.551
JUST DESCRIBED A SERIES OF OTHER
01:18:42.617 --> 01:18:45.454
PROGRAMS THAT ARE ALREADY WITHIN
01:18:45.520 --> 01:18:46.688
THE WHEELHOUSE OF WHAT WE'RE
01:18:46.755 --> 01:18:48.490
TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH AND PLACE
01:18:48.557 --> 01:18:50.358
AND BELIEVE THAT THEY HAVE THE
01:18:50.425 --> 01:18:51.460
EXPERTISE. NONE OF THIS WILL
01:18:51.526 --> 01:18:53.228
HAPPEN UNTIL THERE'S AN ACTUAL
01:18:53.295 --> 01:18:54.429
APPROPRIATION, OF COURSE. IN
01:18:54.496 --> 01:18:55.297
ORDER TO IMPLEMENT THIS PROGRAM,
01:18:55.363 --> 01:18:59.267
AND YOU ARE CERTAIN THAT CDFA
01:18:59.334 --> 01:19:01.369
HAS ENOUGH RESOURCES, UM, TO
01:19:01.436 --> 01:19:05.841
INCLUDE PERSONNEL. TO TAKE ON A
01:19:05.907 --> 01:19:07.075
TASK LIKE THIS. I'M CERTAIN THAT
01:19:07.142 --> 01:19:08.577
WE NEED ADDITIONAL RESOURCES IN
01:19:08.643 --> 01:19:11.913
AND CERTIFY THAT YOU KNOW THE
01:19:11.980 --> 01:19:13.548
PRACTICES THAT ARE THAT ARE
01:19:13.615 --> 01:19:15.250
TAKING PLACE IN OTHER COUNTRIES
01:19:15.317 --> 01:19:17.385
. OTHER STATES THAT CDF A WOULD
01:19:17.452 --> 01:19:19.054
BE ABLE TO REGULATE THAT, OR AT
01:19:19.121 --> 01:19:20.956
LEAST MAKE SURE THAT THEY ARE
01:19:21.022 --> 01:19:21.890
FOLLOWING OUR REGULATIONS
01:19:21.957 --> 01:19:22.757
COMMITTED TO GETTING THE
01:19:22.824 --> 01:19:24.326
RESOURCES NECESSARY TO ENSURE
01:19:24.392 --> 01:19:25.527
THAT CDFA HAS THE TOOLS TO DO
01:19:25.594 --> 01:19:29.197
THIS. SENATOR MELINDA'S. CAN I
01:19:29.264 --> 01:19:30.632
SPEAK TO THIS? CAN I SAY
01:19:30.699 --> 01:19:33.401
SOMETHING THAT WOULD BE YOU
01:19:33.468 --> 01:19:34.569
KNOW, HOLD ON. THAT HAS TO GO
01:19:34.636 --> 01:19:35.537
THROUGH THE CHAIRMAN, PLEASE.
01:19:35.604 --> 01:19:41.610
BRIEF. UM SO LET ME TELL YOU
01:19:41.676 --> 01:19:43.812
THAT IF YOU JUST TAKE ORGANIC,
01:19:43.879 --> 01:19:45.480
OKAY, ORGANIC THAT COMES INTO
01:19:45.547 --> 01:19:48.850
CALIFORNIA. C D. F A DOES NOT
01:19:48.917 --> 01:19:51.186
DOES NOT CHECK TO THAT. THAT
01:19:51.253 --> 01:19:52.721
THAT THAT THE ORGANIC COMING
01:19:52.787 --> 01:19:54.089
ACROSS THE BORDER FROM OTHER
01:19:54.156 --> 01:19:56.324
COUNTRIES IS ORGANIC. THEY'RE
01:19:56.391 --> 01:19:59.161
ALL THEY DO IF THEY SET UP A
01:19:59.227 --> 01:20:02.063
SYSTEM THAT A THIRD PARTY
01:20:02.130 --> 01:20:04.566
FOLLOWS, LIKE A C. C O F
01:20:04.633 --> 01:20:05.133
CALIFORNIA CERTIFIED ORGANIC
01:20:05.200 --> 01:20:08.570
FARMERS THAT THEY FOLLOW. AND
01:20:08.637 --> 01:20:10.906
THEY ARE THE THEY GO OUT AND
01:20:10.972 --> 01:20:13.241
MAKE SURE THAT IT IS FOLLOWED.
01:20:13.308 --> 01:20:16.077
SO THE CALIFORNIA CDF DOESN'T
01:20:16.144 --> 01:20:18.213
DOESN'T ACTUALLY ENFORCE THAT ON
01:20:18.280 --> 01:20:19.814
ANY OF THESE THINGS ON FOOD
01:20:19.881 --> 01:20:20.749
SAFETY, THEY DON'T DO ANY OF
01:20:20.815 --> 01:20:23.318
THAT. IT'S ALL DONE BY A THIRD
01:20:23.385 --> 01:20:25.520
PARTY SYSTEM. SO THEY WILL JUST
01:20:25.587 --> 01:20:27.556
ADD THAT ONTO THE LIST OF THINGS
01:20:27.622 --> 01:20:29.691
THAT THEY'RE CHECKING. OKAY
01:20:29.758 --> 01:20:32.160
THANK YOU FOR THAT. MY FINAL
01:20:32.227 --> 01:20:34.529
COMMENT WILL JUST BE THAT I YOU
01:20:34.596 --> 01:20:36.498
KNOW, I CAN'T HELP BUT NOTE THE
01:20:36.565 --> 01:20:40.468
IRONY. IN A BILL LIKE THIS,
01:20:40.535 --> 01:20:41.636
BECAUSE IT THAT THE COMMENT WAS
01:20:41.703 --> 01:20:42.971
MADE THAT WE DON'T WANT TO
01:20:43.038 --> 01:20:45.273
DISADVANTAGE OUR OWN GROWERS AND
01:20:45.340 --> 01:20:46.875
FARMERS. WELL, WE HAVE ALREADY
01:20:46.942 --> 01:20:48.577
DONE THAT WITH THE POLICIES OF
01:20:48.643 --> 01:20:52.681
CALIFORNIA HAS PUT IN PLACE. SO
01:20:52.747 --> 01:20:53.915
THIS IS A PROBLEM OF OUR OWN
01:20:53.982 --> 01:20:57.485
MAKING. AND I HOPE THAT PEOPLE
01:20:57.552 --> 01:20:59.120
RECOGNIZE THAT AND SEE THAT
01:20:59.187 --> 01:21:02.724
BECAUSE THIS DID NOT JUST HAPPEN
01:21:02.791 --> 01:21:04.192
ACCIDENTALLY. THIS WAS
01:21:04.259 --> 01:21:06.361
PURPOSEFULLY DONE TO THE FARMERS
01:21:06.428 --> 01:21:09.931
IN THIS STATE AND NOW WE ARE.
01:21:09.998 --> 01:21:12.267
PRESENTED WITH A BILL THAT IS
01:21:12.334 --> 01:21:14.102
TRYING TO FIX WHAT THE STATE HAS
01:21:14.169 --> 01:21:19.341
DONE. UM SO I THANK YOU FOR ALL
01:21:19.407 --> 01:21:20.909
YOU'VE BEEN WORKING ON THIS FOR
01:21:20.976 --> 01:21:23.411
A WHILE, AND I KNOW THIS IS NOT
01:21:23.478 --> 01:21:24.679
AN EASY CONCEPT TO FLESH OUT AND
01:21:24.746 --> 01:21:25.880
TO GET PEOPLE ON BOARD WITH.
01:21:25.947 --> 01:21:28.316
IT'S GOT A LOT OF UM, LEGAL
01:21:28.383 --> 01:21:29.951
RAMIFICATIONS IN HERE THAT ARE
01:21:30.018 --> 01:21:32.320
HARD TO NAVIGATE. BUT I THANK
01:21:32.387 --> 01:21:35.357
YOU FOR DOING YOUR BEST WORK.
01:21:35.423 --> 01:21:37.492
THANK YOU. LET ME I JUST HAVE
01:21:37.559 --> 01:21:38.460
ONE QUICK ONE. I'M JUST CURIOUS,
01:21:38.526 --> 01:21:41.930
REMEMBER, UM GIVEN THE FACT THAT
01:21:41.997 --> 01:21:43.064
WE'RE GOING TO BE PLACING
01:21:43.131 --> 01:21:44.132
RESTRICTIONS ON IMPORTS COMING
01:21:44.199 --> 01:21:46.768
INTO THE STATE. AND FROM MY
01:21:46.835 --> 01:21:48.069
PERSPECTIVE, ANYWAY, THE
01:21:48.136 --> 01:21:48.970
UNLIKELY EVENT THAT WE'RE GOING
01:21:49.037 --> 01:21:50.739
TO CONVINCE THE COUNTRY OF
01:21:50.805 --> 01:21:52.073
MEXICO, TOO, AS THEY SAID, ADOPT
01:21:52.140 --> 01:21:54.309
THE CALIFORNIA LABOR CODE.
01:21:54.376 --> 01:21:55.443
DURING THE GROWING SEASON. WHAT
01:21:55.510 --> 01:21:59.080
HAPPENS IF FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE
01:21:59.147 --> 01:22:00.682
COACHELLA VALLEY OR WELL, WHERE
01:22:00.749 --> 01:22:01.816
ELSE THEY WHEREVER ELSE THEY
01:22:01.883 --> 01:22:04.319
GROW ASPARAGUS THESE DAYS. THE
01:22:04.386 --> 01:22:06.154
GROWERS LOSE ALL OR
01:22:06.221 --> 01:22:07.622
SUBSTANTIALLY ALL OF THE CROP
01:22:07.689 --> 01:22:13.428
DURING THE GROWING SEASON. HOW
01:22:13.495 --> 01:22:16.064
THIS BILL, IF IT BECOMES LAW
01:22:16.131 --> 01:22:17.666
STATUTE, I THINK THAT'S AN
01:22:17.732 --> 01:22:18.566
EXCELLENT QUESTION FOR
01:22:18.633 --> 01:22:20.602
CALIFORNIA. COACHELLA VALLEY
01:22:20.669 --> 01:22:22.070
FARMER DANCER WELL TO PROVIDE TO
01:22:22.137 --> 01:22:24.072
ENSURE THAT WE HAVE
01:22:24.139 --> 01:22:25.640
APPROPRIATELY SUPPLY APPROPRIATE
01:22:25.707 --> 01:22:29.678
LEVELS OF SUPPLY. IN THE GROCERY
01:22:29.744 --> 01:22:30.912
STORES AND OTHER LOCATIONS FOR
01:22:30.979 --> 01:22:38.253
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS, MR BIANCO. SO YOU CAN. YOU CAN NEVER MAKE
01:22:38.320 --> 01:22:41.189
MAKE THAT ASSURANCE EVEN TODAY.
01:22:41.256 --> 01:22:44.059
BECAUSE THERE ARE TIMES OF THE
01:22:44.125 --> 01:22:45.827
YEAR WHERE WHEN YOU GO TO THE
01:22:45.894 --> 01:22:47.195
GROCERY STORE, THERE ARE ONLY
01:22:47.262 --> 01:22:49.331
LEMONS THAT COME FOR THAT ARE
01:22:49.397 --> 01:22:50.665
ONLY GROWN. NO, THEY'RE NOT
01:22:50.732 --> 01:22:51.866
GOING ANYWHERE ELSE IN THE
01:22:51.933 --> 01:22:52.901
WORLD. EXCEPT FOR CALIFORNIA.
01:22:52.967 --> 01:22:54.669
THERE ARE TIMES WHEN THERE ARE
01:22:54.736 --> 01:22:56.671
TABLE GRAPES. THAT ARE GROWN
01:22:56.738 --> 01:23:00.075
ONLY IN CALIFORNIA IN THE WORLD
01:23:00.141 --> 01:23:02.444
, SO IF THAT SUPPLY CHAIN WAS
01:23:02.510 --> 01:23:04.179
AWARE THERE WAS A WEATHER EVENT
01:23:04.245 --> 01:23:05.447
OR THERE WAS A DISRUPTION, THEN
01:23:05.513 --> 01:23:08.016
YOU WOULDN'T HAVE THE TYPE OF
01:23:08.083 --> 01:23:10.251
SUPPLIES SO THAT WOULD THAT
01:23:10.318 --> 01:23:12.020
THAT'S NOT GOING TO CHANGE
01:23:12.087 --> 01:23:13.355
WHETHER WE PASS THIS BILL, OR WE
01:23:13.421 --> 01:23:15.090
DON'T WELL, THE DIFFERENCE IS,
01:23:15.156 --> 01:23:16.257
OF COURSE, IF THE ONLY PLACE YOU
01:23:16.324 --> 01:23:17.859
GROW LEMONS IS THE COACHELLA
01:23:17.926 --> 01:23:19.894
VALLEY, AND THE CROP IS LOST.
01:23:19.961 --> 01:23:21.363
THEN I THINK CONSUMERS PROBABLY
01:23:21.429 --> 01:23:23.331
UNDERSTAND THAT THAT'S WHY
01:23:23.398 --> 01:23:24.699
THERE'S NO LEMONS ON THE
01:23:24.766 --> 01:23:26.334
SHELVES. BUT IF ASPARAGUS IS
01:23:26.401 --> 01:23:27.936
GROWN IN OTHER PARTS IN OTHER
01:23:28.002 --> 01:23:29.037
STATES AND OTHER PARTS OF THE
01:23:29.104 --> 01:23:31.773
WORLD. IN THE PAST THAT
01:23:31.840 --> 01:23:32.974
ASPARAGUS HAS BEEN SHIPPED INTO
01:23:33.041 --> 01:23:33.942
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
01:23:34.008 --> 01:23:37.312
OBVIOUSLY CAUSING. APPARENTLY
01:23:37.379 --> 01:23:38.346
CAUSING PROBLEMS FOR GROWERS IN
01:23:38.413 --> 01:23:42.450
COACHELLA. AND OTHERWISE. UM
01:23:42.517 --> 01:23:43.985
THERE'S THAT'S A DIFFERENCE,
01:23:44.052 --> 01:23:45.987
ISN'T IT? SO MY QUESTION IS IF
01:23:46.054 --> 01:23:47.355
ASPARAGUS IS GROWN IN OTHER
01:23:47.422 --> 01:23:49.157
STATES AND OTHER PARTS OF THE
01:23:49.224 --> 01:23:50.592
WORLD AND IN THE COACHELLA
01:23:50.658 --> 01:23:51.760
VALLEY, WHICH IS THE ONLY
01:23:51.826 --> 01:23:53.128
APPARENTLY THE ONLY PLACE IN
01:23:53.194 --> 01:23:54.662
CALIFORNIA WHERE IT'S GROWN. YOU
01:23:54.729 --> 01:23:56.297
LOSE YOUR CROP OR SUBSTANTIALLY
01:23:56.364 --> 01:23:58.199
ALL OF YOUR CROP. HOW DO WE
01:23:58.266 --> 01:23:59.701
PIVOT UNDER THIS BILL? IS THERE
01:23:59.768 --> 01:24:00.969
A RELIEF VALVE? IS THERE AN
01:24:01.035 --> 01:24:02.904
OFFERING UP? CAN WE IMPORT FROM
01:24:02.971 --> 01:24:05.840
MEXICO? CAN WE PULL FROM ALABAMA
01:24:05.907 --> 01:24:06.975
OR WHEREVER ELSE THEY GROW
01:24:07.041 --> 01:24:10.044
ASPARAGUS TO FILL THE SHELVES.
01:24:10.111 --> 01:24:11.246
IN THE GROCERY STORES THAT ARE
01:24:11.312 --> 01:24:15.784
CONSTITUENTS SHOPPING. I'M SURE
01:24:15.850 --> 01:24:16.885
THAT THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CAN
01:24:16.951 --> 01:24:17.952
WORK THIS OUT. I'M JUST
01:24:18.019 --> 01:24:21.189
WONDERING IF THAT CURRENT PIVOT
01:24:21.256 --> 01:24:22.390
OR OFF RAMP CURRENTLY EXISTS IN
01:24:22.457 --> 01:24:26.461
THE BILL. I DIDN'T SEE IT. BUT
01:24:26.528 --> 01:24:27.695
WE'RE NOT. WE'RE NOT MAKING
01:24:27.762 --> 01:24:31.099
OTHER STATES PAY. WE CANNOT MAKE
01:24:31.166 --> 01:24:33.968
OTHER STATES PAY OUR MINIMUM
01:24:34.035 --> 01:24:35.170
WAGE. SO YOU KNOW OUR CHEMICAL
01:24:35.236 --> 01:24:38.573
STANDARDS. ARE WHAT WE'RE
01:24:38.640 --> 01:24:40.208
TALKING ABOUT, AND OUR WORKER
01:24:40.275 --> 01:24:41.309
PROTECTIONS IS WHAT WE'RE
01:24:41.376 --> 01:24:43.144
TALKING ABOUT. BUT WHAT I'M
01:24:43.211 --> 01:24:45.346
TRYING TO SAY IS THESE PRODUCTS
01:24:45.413 --> 01:24:47.315
RIGHT RIGHT NOW OR ALREADY
01:24:47.382 --> 01:24:49.117
PRODUCED WHEN THERE ARE NOTHING
01:24:49.184 --> 01:24:51.219
ELSE PRODUCED IN THE WORLD AT
01:24:51.286 --> 01:24:53.555
THAT TIME, SO IF THERE WAS A
01:24:53.621 --> 01:24:56.357
SUPPLY CHAIN, IT'S THAT THAT'S
01:24:56.424 --> 01:24:57.859
THAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN. WHETHER
01:24:57.926 --> 01:25:00.161
WE PASSED THE BILL OR NOT YOU I
01:25:00.228 --> 01:25:01.529
MEAN, YOU SEE WHAT I MEAN. BUT
01:25:01.596 --> 01:25:03.465
BUT YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO GET
01:25:03.531 --> 01:25:05.166
PRODUCTS FROM OTHER STATES. AND
01:25:05.233 --> 01:25:07.101
DON'T YOU THINK THAT OHER
01:25:07.168 --> 01:25:08.770
STATES WOULD FILL THAT? IF
01:25:08.837 --> 01:25:09.771
THERE'S A MARKET HERE TO BE
01:25:09.838 --> 01:25:11.940
FILLED? I BELIEVE SOMEONE IS
01:25:12.006 --> 01:25:13.241
GOING TO FILL IT. THEY'RE JUST
01:25:13.308 --> 01:25:15.009
GOING TO FILL IT UNDER OUR
01:25:15.076 --> 01:25:17.479
STANDARDS. OKAY WELL, THAT WAS
01:25:17.545 --> 01:25:18.913
JUST WAS JUST CURIOUS. WANTED TO
01:25:18.980 --> 01:25:19.814
MAKE SURE SOMEBODY THOUGHT
01:25:19.881 --> 01:25:21.850
THROUGH WHAT HAPPENS IF YOU KNOW
01:25:21.916 --> 01:25:23.184
BECAUSE WE'VE HAD PROBLEMS WITH
01:25:23.251 --> 01:25:24.552
WINE GRAPES. IN THE PAST. WE'VE
01:25:24.619 --> 01:25:26.788
HAD PROBLEMS WITH OTHER
01:25:26.855 --> 01:25:28.323
AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTS WERE A
01:25:28.389 --> 01:25:29.691
PREDATOR COMES IN. WE
01:25:29.757 --> 01:25:31.159
POTENTIALLY HAD PROBLEMS WITH
01:25:31.226 --> 01:25:32.427
THE CITRUS INDUSTRY. WE'VE HAD
01:25:32.494 --> 01:25:34.128
PROBLEMS WHERE PREDATORS COME IN
01:25:34.195 --> 01:25:35.330
AND TAKE OUT ALL OR A WHOLE
01:25:35.396 --> 01:25:37.098
BUNCH OF CROP AND WE NEED TO
01:25:37.165 --> 01:25:39.667
HAVE A PLAN FOR THAT. COLLEAGUES
01:25:39.734 --> 01:25:40.768
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
01:25:40.835 --> 01:25:44.672
CONCERNS I SEE. NONE. SO
01:25:44.739 --> 01:25:46.074
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GARCIA. WOULD
01:25:46.140 --> 01:25:47.408
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE CHAIRMAN?
01:25:47.475 --> 01:25:50.645
THANK YOU AND YOUR TEAM? UH, FOR
01:25:50.712 --> 01:25:52.714
THE WORK THAT HAS TAKEN PLACE
01:25:52.780 --> 01:25:54.716
OVER THE LAST YEAR AND A HALF OR
01:25:54.782 --> 01:25:56.551
SO WITH WITH OUR TEAM WITH OUR
01:25:56.618 --> 01:25:57.852
SPONSORS, AND WHAT I'M ASKING OF
01:25:57.919 --> 01:25:59.654
YOU AND THE OTHER COLLEAGUES
01:25:59.721 --> 01:26:02.423
HERE TODAY IS YOUR SUPPORT TO
01:26:02.490 --> 01:26:03.725
KEEP THIS CONVERSATION GOING.
01:26:03.791 --> 01:26:04.692
YOU'VE RAISED SOME GOOD
01:26:04.759 --> 01:26:07.328
QUESTIONS. UM SOME GOOD CONCERNS
01:26:07.395 --> 01:26:10.265
HAVE BEEN BROUGHT FORWARD. AND
01:26:10.331 --> 01:26:12.634
WE'RE I THINK IN A POSITION TO
01:26:12.700 --> 01:26:14.702
BE ABLE TO CONTINUE TO ATTEMPT
01:26:14.769 --> 01:26:16.304
TO ADDRESS THOSE, UM WHAT WE'RE
01:26:16.371 --> 01:26:17.472
TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH YEARS
01:26:17.539 --> 01:26:19.173
PROTECT THE HEALTH AND SAFETY
01:26:19.240 --> 01:26:20.375
AND WELL BEING OF CALIFORNIA
01:26:20.441 --> 01:26:22.544
CONSUMERS. WHEN IT COMES TO
01:26:22.610 --> 01:26:24.078
CALIFORNIA GROWN PRODUCTS AND
01:26:24.145 --> 01:26:25.346
OTHER PRODUCTS COMING FROM OTHER
01:26:25.413 --> 01:26:26.614
PARTS OF THE COUNTRY AND THE
01:26:26.681 --> 01:26:28.182
WORLD SO RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:26:28.249 --> 01:26:29.517
YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU, SIR. NICE
01:26:29.584 --> 01:26:30.518
PRESENTATION. THANKS FOR YOUR
01:26:30.585 --> 01:26:32.353
PATIENCE WITH THE QUESTIONS. DO
01:26:32.420 --> 01:26:33.488
WE HAVE A MOTION ON ASSEMBLY
01:26:33.555 --> 01:26:35.456
BILL 710. SENATOR BECKER HAS
01:26:35.523 --> 01:26:38.359
MOVED THE BILL. THE MOTION IS
01:26:38.426 --> 01:26:39.961
DUE PASS RE REFER THE COMMITTEE
01:26:40.028 --> 01:26:40.995
ON AGRICULTURE PLEASE CALL THE
01:26:41.062 --> 01:26:44.933
ROLL. MAYBE 7 10. EMOTIONS DO
01:26:44.999 --> 01:26:46.634
PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
01:26:46.701 --> 01:26:48.336
COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE BROTH.
01:26:48.403 --> 01:26:51.673
MELINDA'S. ARCHULETTA PROCEED
01:26:51.739 --> 01:26:56.210
FATES. NO RATES. NO BECKER.
01:26:56.277 --> 01:27:05.286
SPEAKER I DODD. THOUGHT I EGGMAN. POTATO H
01:27:05.353 --> 01:27:09.457
NO MEN. MOMENT. I NEWMAN
01:27:09.524 --> 01:27:15.863
NEWMAN. I A TROVE, OKAY? PAN.
01:27:15.930 --> 01:27:17.098
COULD YOU GIVE ME THE VOTE CAM,
01:27:17.165 --> 01:27:21.869
PLEASE? 5 TO 2. 522 WILL HOLD
01:27:21.936 --> 01:27:23.004
THE ROLL OPEN FOR ABSENT
01:27:23.071 --> 01:27:25.607
MEMBERS. THANK YOU, SIR. NOW,
01:27:25.673 --> 01:27:27.475
LET'S GIVE ME ONE MINUTE. WE
01:27:27.542 --> 01:27:29.344
NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT WE'RE
01:27:29.410 --> 01:27:31.779
GOING TO DO. LADIES AND
01:27:31.846 --> 01:27:32.880
GENTLEMEN, WE HAVE SENATE
01:27:32.947 --> 01:27:35.249
SESSION THAT CONVENES AT TWO PM
01:27:35.316 --> 01:27:37.051
AND WE HAVE TO HAVE TIME TO GET
01:27:37.118 --> 01:27:38.920
OVER THERE. SO GIVE ME ONE
01:27:38.987 --> 01:27:47.195
SECOND. AND REMEMBER, GIBSON
01:27:47.261 --> 01:27:57.205
WILL TRY YOU. THIS IS ITEM
01:27:57.271 --> 01:28:00.842
NUMBER FIVE ASSEMBLY BILL 16 62.
01:28:00.908 --> 01:28:02.477
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MR CHAIRMAN
01:28:02.543 --> 01:28:03.645
AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR
01:28:03.711 --> 01:28:05.380
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY
01:28:05.446 --> 01:28:08.149
BILL. UH 16 62, WHICH SEEKS TO
01:28:08.216 --> 01:28:11.085
PROVIDE EARLY NOTICE ON WHETHER
01:28:11.152 --> 01:28:12.587
AN INDIVIDUAL CRIMINAL RECORD
01:28:12.654 --> 01:28:15.089
WILL DISQUALIFY THEM FROM
01:28:15.156 --> 01:28:16.491
OBTAINING AN OCCUPATIONAL
01:28:16.557 --> 01:28:19.193
LICENSE BEFORE THE INVEST IN
01:28:19.260 --> 01:28:20.228
EXPENSIVE TRAINING AND
01:28:20.294 --> 01:28:22.296
EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS. HAVING
01:28:22.363 --> 01:28:26.134
A CRIMINAL RECORD. CAN MAKE IT
01:28:26.200 --> 01:28:29.203
DIFFICULT OR IMPOSSIBLE FOR AN
01:28:29.270 --> 01:28:30.772
INDIVIDUAL TO ENTER INTO THE
01:28:30.838 --> 01:28:33.641
WORKFORCE, EXPECIALLY IN A FIELD
01:28:33.708 --> 01:28:34.809
THAT REQUIRES AN OCCUPATIONAL
01:28:34.876 --> 01:28:39.180
LICENSE. WHEN EXAMINING OTHER
01:28:39.247 --> 01:28:41.582
STATES THAT REQUIRE, UH, THE
01:28:41.649 --> 01:28:43.818
OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE. CALIFORNIA
01:28:43.885 --> 01:28:45.753
RANKS AMONG THE HIGHEST IN THE
01:28:45.820 --> 01:28:47.522
COUNTRY, HOWEVER, OVER 500
01:28:47.588 --> 01:28:52.060
PROVISIONS OF STATE LAW LIMITS
01:28:52.126 --> 01:28:54.262
ACCESS TO LICENSOR FOR PEOPLE
01:28:54.328 --> 01:28:57.098
WITH CRIMINAL RECORDS, ACCORDING
01:28:57.165 --> 01:28:58.633
TO THE REPORT, PUBLISHED BY THE
01:28:58.700 --> 01:29:01.102
INSTITUTE FOR JUSTICE REQUIRES
01:29:01.169 --> 01:29:03.104
REQUIREMENTS TO OBTAIN A
01:29:03.171 --> 01:29:04.906
LICENSOR ARE AMONG THE MOST
01:29:04.972 --> 01:29:09.343
RIGOROUS BASED UM ON HIGH COSTS
01:29:09.410 --> 01:29:11.646
AND LENGTHY EDUCATION IN
01:29:11.713 --> 01:29:13.848
CALIFORNIA WITH A CAREER
01:29:13.915 --> 01:29:16.851
CRIMINAL RECORD, UM, OFTEN FACE
01:29:16.918 --> 01:29:19.087
ADDITIONAL BARRIERS THAT
01:29:19.153 --> 01:29:21.355
DISCOURAGE AND EXCLUDE THEM FROM
01:29:21.422 --> 01:29:23.725
A GOOD PAYING JOB THAT REQUIRES
01:29:23.791 --> 01:29:25.927
A LICENSE PEOPLE THAT ARE
01:29:25.993 --> 01:29:27.295
REJECTED FROM EMPLOYMENT
01:29:27.361 --> 01:29:29.664
OPPORTUNITIES ARE MORE LIKELY.
01:29:29.731 --> 01:29:33.234
TO FALL INTO A CYCLE OF CRIME,
01:29:33.301 --> 01:29:35.336
ACCORDING TO THE MULTIYEAR STUDY
01:29:35.403 --> 01:29:36.838
FROM THE BROOKINGS INSTITUTE
01:29:36.904 --> 01:29:40.475
ABOUT 45% OF FORMERLY
01:29:40.541 --> 01:29:41.442
INCARCERATED AMERICANS WERE
01:29:41.509 --> 01:29:46.447
UNEMPLOYED. ONE YEAR AFTER AFTER
01:29:46.514 --> 01:29:48.316
UNDERSCORE LEAVING PRISON
01:29:48.382 --> 01:29:50.451
MEMBERS. I REPRESENT A POOR
01:29:50.518 --> 01:29:51.519
DISTRICT IN THE STATE OF
01:29:51.586 --> 01:29:54.288
CALIFORNIA. AND ONE OF THOSE
01:29:54.355 --> 01:29:57.191
MAIN BARRIERS THAT PEOPLE WITH
01:29:57.258 --> 01:29:58.793
CRIMINAL RECORDS FACE WHEN
01:29:58.860 --> 01:30:01.562
TRYING TO OBTAIN TRYING TO APPLY
01:30:01.629 --> 01:30:02.697
FOR A LICENSE. PROFESSION IS
01:30:02.764 --> 01:30:05.767
EXPENSIVE TUITION. THAT COMES
01:30:05.833 --> 01:30:07.835
WITH AN EXPENSIVE TRAINING AND
01:30:07.902 --> 01:30:09.537
COURSE THIS MEANS TIME AND
01:30:09.604 --> 01:30:13.841
MONEY. WHICH COSTS WHICH WHICH
01:30:13.908 --> 01:30:16.911
EXCUSE ME, WHICH IS COSTLY AND
01:30:16.978 --> 01:30:19.213
MONEY THAT THEY DON'T HAVE. UM
01:30:19.280 --> 01:30:21.415
WE ARE TALKING ABOUT HUNDREDS OF
01:30:21.482 --> 01:30:23.451
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS ON PROGRAMS
01:30:23.518 --> 01:30:25.153
THAT COULD TAKE MONTHS AND ALSO
01:30:25.219 --> 01:30:28.523
YEARS IN ORDER TO COMPLETE JUST
01:30:28.589 --> 01:30:31.058
TO FIND OUT THAT THE END OF THE
01:30:31.125 --> 01:30:32.827
DAY. UM WITH HIM GOING THROUGH
01:30:32.894 --> 01:30:34.829
THIS TRAINING, UM AND EXPENSIVE
01:30:34.896 --> 01:30:36.464
AND PUTTING MONEY THAT THEY HAVE
01:30:36.531 --> 01:30:37.965
BEEN DENIED BASED ON THEIR
01:30:38.032 --> 01:30:39.500
CRIMINAL RECORD, AND I MIGHT
01:30:39.567 --> 01:30:40.601
UNDERSCORE THEY PAID THEIR DEBT
01:30:40.668 --> 01:30:44.305
TO SOCIETY. THIS CAUSE OF THEM
01:30:44.372 --> 01:30:45.773
TO BE, UM, YOU KNOW,
01:30:45.840 --> 01:30:48.176
DISENCHANTED AND ALSO FEEL
01:30:48.242 --> 01:30:50.478
HOPELESS AT THE SAME TIME, THIS
01:30:50.545 --> 01:30:54.048
PROCESS OF THIS BILL IS SIMPLE.
01:30:54.115 --> 01:30:55.817
UM A PERSPECTIVE, APPLICANT
01:30:55.883 --> 01:30:57.418
APPLICANT WILL HAVE AN
01:30:57.485 --> 01:31:00.087
OPPORTUNITY TO SUBMIT A CRIMINAL
01:31:00.154 --> 01:31:01.455
OR TO SUBMIT THEIR CRIMINAL
01:31:01.522 --> 01:31:04.458
RECORD TO A BOARD AND SEEKING
01:31:04.525 --> 01:31:06.194
SEEKING FOR THEIR LICENSE. THE
01:31:06.260 --> 01:31:07.895
BOARD WILL THEN BE ABLE TO
01:31:07.962 --> 01:31:10.131
REVIEW INFORMATION AND GET BACK
01:31:10.198 --> 01:31:12.934
WITH INDIVIDUAL WHETHER OR NOT
01:31:13.000 --> 01:31:16.137
UM, THEY CAN BE A GRANTED OR
01:31:16.204 --> 01:31:19.207
DENIED, BUT BEFORE THEY EXPEND
01:31:19.273 --> 01:31:20.641
THE KIND OF MONEY THAT THEY
01:31:20.708 --> 01:31:22.877
REALLY DON'T HAVE IN ORDER TO
01:31:22.944 --> 01:31:23.811
OBTAIN THIS LICENSE, THIS IS AN
01:31:23.878 --> 01:31:25.279
OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE WHO'VE
01:31:25.346 --> 01:31:26.581
BEEN RECENTLY INCARCERATED WHO
01:31:26.647 --> 01:31:28.015
PAID THEIR DEBT TO SOCIETY
01:31:28.082 --> 01:31:29.884
RIDING NEW NARRATIVE AND ALL
01:31:29.951 --> 01:31:31.185
WE'RE ASKING THIS BILL IS THE
01:31:31.252 --> 01:31:33.120
ONE THERE'S A PROCESS PUT IN
01:31:33.187 --> 01:31:34.755
PLACE TO WHETHER OR NOT THEY
01:31:34.822 --> 01:31:36.991
WILL BE GRANTED PASSAGE FOR THE
01:31:37.058 --> 01:31:38.426
OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE OR BE
01:31:38.492 --> 01:31:39.994
DENIED. THAT'S ALL THIS BILL
01:31:40.061 --> 01:31:42.430
REQUIRES, AND THIS BILL IS
01:31:42.496 --> 01:31:44.332
STRONGLY SUPPORTED BY ANTI
01:31:44.398 --> 01:31:45.967
RECIDIVIST COALITION, THE
01:31:46.033 --> 01:31:47.468
CALIFORNIA CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE
01:31:47.535 --> 01:31:49.070
, THE U. S CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:31:49.136 --> 01:31:51.272
AND MANY, MANY OTHERS JOINING ME
01:31:51.339 --> 01:31:53.341
TO PROVIDE SUPPORTING TESTIMONY
01:31:53.407 --> 01:31:57.545
VIA ONLINE IS MISS JOHNSON. FROM
01:31:57.612 --> 01:31:59.380
THE COUNCIL OF STATE GOVERNMENT.
01:31:59.447 --> 01:32:02.283
CSG WEST. MISS JOHNSON. I'M
01:32:02.350 --> 01:32:03.851
GOING TO ASK YOU TO TRY TO LIMIT
01:32:03.918 --> 01:32:05.953
IT TO TWO MINUTES. IF YOU CAN.
01:32:06.020 --> 01:32:08.155
WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE A
01:32:08.222 --> 01:32:11.592
RECESS AT ABOUT 1 45 OR SO. AND
01:32:11.659 --> 01:32:12.827
I'D LIKE TO FINISH THIS BILL. IF
01:32:12.894 --> 01:32:14.595
I CAN, MISS JOHNSON, PLEASE
01:32:14.662 --> 01:32:16.464
PROCEED. YES, SIR. GOOD
01:32:16.530 --> 01:32:18.566
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR MEMBERS OF
01:32:18.633 --> 01:32:20.268
THE COMMITTEE FOR US. I WOULD
01:32:20.334 --> 01:32:21.469
LIKE TO THINK OF SOMETHING
01:32:21.535 --> 01:32:23.104
MEMBER, DIFFERENT PRINTS PRIMARY
01:32:23.170 --> 01:32:24.005
LEGISLATION. MY NAME IS COREY
01:32:24.071 --> 01:32:24.872
JOHNSON AND I'M MISSING A POLICY
01:32:24.939 --> 01:32:26.474
AND ELECTED COUNCILS. THE
01:32:26.540 --> 01:32:28.109
GOVERNMENT THAT'S THE CENTER.
01:32:28.175 --> 01:32:29.210
UM, WE HAVE ENGAGED IN A
01:32:29.277 --> 01:32:30.278
NATIONAL CARE TRANCELIKE LOOKING
01:32:30.344 --> 01:32:31.545
INITIATIVE, WHICH SUPPORTS
01:32:31.612 --> 01:32:33.915
ECONOMIC GROWTH. THEN
01:32:33.981 --> 01:32:35.950
OPPORTUNITY AND MAINTAIN PUBLIC
01:32:36.017 --> 01:32:38.119
SAFETY BY INCREASING ACCESS TO
01:32:38.185 --> 01:32:39.887
LICENSED OCCUPATIONS, QUALIFIED
01:32:39.954 --> 01:32:42.590
WORKERS WITH CRIMINAL HISTORY AS
01:32:42.657 --> 01:32:45.126
MR POTATO. UM CRIME IS A DIRECT
01:32:45.192 --> 01:32:47.061
CONSEQUENCE AND CAUSE OF POVERTY
01:32:47.128 --> 01:32:48.930
OF COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCES THAT
01:32:48.996 --> 01:32:50.131
ARE PLACED ON EMPLOYMENT
01:32:50.197 --> 01:32:51.699
STANDARDS OFTEN CREATE
01:32:51.766 --> 01:32:53.100
INSURMOUNTABLE BARRIERS TO
01:32:53.167 --> 01:32:55.069
SECURING ECONOMIC SECURITY.
01:32:55.136 --> 01:32:56.537
PERFORMING THE INCARCERATED
01:32:56.604 --> 01:32:59.073
INDIVIDUALS. WE CAN ALL AGREE
01:32:59.140 --> 01:32:59.974
THAT A CRIMINAL RECORD SHOULD
01:33:00.041 --> 01:33:02.243
NOT BE A DEATH SENTENCE. WHAT WE
01:33:02.310 --> 01:33:04.378
LOCKED UP PROTECTED IMPACTED
01:33:04.445 --> 01:33:06.480
INDIVIDUALS INTO A REVOLVING
01:33:06.547 --> 01:33:08.783
DOOR, UM INSTITUTE OF JUSTICE
01:33:08.849 --> 01:33:11.619
FOUND THAT 70% OF INDIVIDUALS
01:33:11.686 --> 01:33:12.987
WHO WERE RECENTLY INCARCERATED
01:33:13.054 --> 01:33:14.255
FOR UNEMPLOYED ONE YEAR AFTER
01:33:14.322 --> 01:33:15.356
RELEASE THEM WHEN THEY WEREN'T
01:33:15.423 --> 01:33:17.425
RELEASED. FORMERLY INCARCERATED
01:33:17.491 --> 01:33:20.461
INDIVIDUALS, 40% LESS ON AVERAGE
01:33:20.528 --> 01:33:21.696
THAN THEY DID BEFORE GOING TO
01:33:21.762 --> 01:33:23.831
JAIL. ALTERNATELY THE I J FOUND
01:33:23.898 --> 01:33:25.333
THAT RECIDIVISM RATES DECREASED
01:33:25.399 --> 01:33:27.068
BY NEARLY 15% WHEN WE GET FOLKS
01:33:27.134 --> 01:33:31.439
JOB. AND SO IN 2018 WITH PAT
01:33:31.505 --> 01:33:33.541
WHEN CALIFORNIA PASSED ITS
01:33:33.607 --> 01:33:35.142
CURRENT FAIR CHANCE LIFE IF YOU
01:33:35.209 --> 01:33:37.979
LAW ALLOWS FOR VARIOUS DIFFERENT
01:33:38.045 --> 01:33:39.714
INDIVIDUAL RECONSIDERATION OF AN
01:33:39.780 --> 01:33:41.849
APPLICANT APPLICANT, CRIMINAL
01:33:41.916 --> 01:33:43.818
HISTORY, UM WE THINK THAT WE
01:33:43.884 --> 01:33:45.686
SHOULD GO A STEP FURTHER IN 20
01:33:45.753 --> 01:33:48.089
STATES. UM THAT HAVE FOLLOWED IN
01:33:48.155 --> 01:33:48.856
THIS FASHION HAVE DONE THE SAME
01:33:48.923 --> 01:33:51.192
THING. THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE A
01:33:51.258 --> 01:33:53.194
PRE APPLICATION DETERMINATION
01:33:53.260 --> 01:33:55.062
FOR LICENSURE BOARDS BECAUSE
01:33:55.129 --> 01:33:57.198
CURRENTLY, AS MR GIBSON STATED,
01:33:57.264 --> 01:33:59.200
JUSTICE IMPACTED INDIVIDUALS WHO
01:33:59.266 --> 01:34:00.701
ARE SEEKING AN OCCUPATIONAL
01:34:00.768 --> 01:34:02.303
LICENSE ARE ONLY MADE AWARE OF
01:34:02.370 --> 01:34:03.971
THEIR DISQUALIFICATIONS FOR
01:34:04.038 --> 01:34:05.072
REASONS RELATED TO THEIR
01:34:05.139 --> 01:34:07.842
CRIMINAL RECORD RECORDS. AFTER
01:34:07.908 --> 01:34:08.676
THE SUBMISSION OF THE
01:34:08.743 --> 01:34:11.012
APPLICATION MATERIALS FOR THEIR
01:34:11.078 --> 01:34:12.947
LICENSE. THIS MEANS INDIVIDUALS
01:34:13.014 --> 01:34:15.349
WITH CRIMINAL RECORDS MUCH STILL
01:34:15.416 --> 01:34:17.018
ALL EDUCATIONAL AND TRAINING
01:34:17.084 --> 01:34:19.854
REQUIREMENTS WITH UNCERTAINTY AS
01:34:19.920 --> 01:34:21.989
TO THEIR ABILITY TO RECEIVE THE
01:34:22.056 --> 01:34:22.857
LICENSE WITH THEIR CRIMINAL
01:34:22.923 --> 01:34:25.059
HISTORY, OFTEN DISCOURAGED AS
01:34:25.126 --> 01:34:26.794
MANY INDIVIDUALS FROM SEEKING AN
01:34:26.861 --> 01:34:29.063
OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE AS THEY ARE
01:34:29.130 --> 01:34:31.298
FORCED TO COMPLETE YEARS OF
01:34:31.365 --> 01:34:31.832
EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS.
01:34:31.899 --> 01:34:33.034
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF
01:34:33.100 --> 01:34:34.201
EDUCATION, ALL OF US BEING ON
01:34:34.268 --> 01:34:38.372
THE BACK. UNCERTAINTY A B 16 60
01:34:38.439 --> 01:34:39.840
TO ALLOW THOSE PERSPECTIVE
01:34:39.907 --> 01:34:41.308
LICENSEES TO RECEIVE A
01:34:41.375 --> 01:34:42.576
DETERMINATION ABOUT THAT
01:34:42.643 --> 01:34:43.811
CRIMINAL HISTORY BEFORE
01:34:43.878 --> 01:34:45.012
INVESTING ALL OF THE TIME AND
01:34:45.079 --> 01:34:48.682
RESOURCES. PURSUING THE LICENSE
01:34:48.749 --> 01:34:51.786
. THIS WILL ONLY MISS JOHNSON AS
01:34:51.852 --> 01:34:53.921
I'VE STATED BEFORE. SORRY SIR.
01:34:53.988 --> 01:34:56.357
AND NOW, UM, THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:34:56.424 --> 01:34:59.160
TIME. THANK YOU. LET'S HEAR FROM
01:34:59.226 --> 01:35:00.261
ANY OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES IN
01:35:00.327 --> 01:35:02.063
THE HEARING ROOM, SEEING NONE.
01:35:02.129 --> 01:35:06.333
PLEASE STEP FORWARD. NAME.
01:35:06.400 --> 01:35:07.968
AFFILIATION POSITION ON THE
01:35:08.035 --> 01:35:10.171
MEASURE. THANK YOU. CHAIR AND
01:35:10.237 --> 01:35:11.005
MEMBERS BRENDA BASS, CALIFORNIA
01:35:11.072 --> 01:35:12.106
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND SUPPORT.
01:35:12.173 --> 01:35:14.875
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AUTHORS IN
01:35:14.942 --> 01:35:16.744
THE ROOM. WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO
01:35:16.811 --> 01:35:18.712
ADJOURN THIS HEARING, EITHER IT
01:35:18.779 --> 01:35:22.416
WELL 1 45 OR 1 50. WE ARE NOT
01:35:22.483 --> 01:35:23.184
PERMITTED TO BE LATE TO THE
01:35:23.250 --> 01:35:24.685
SENATE CHAMBER, SO I DON'T WANT
01:35:24.752 --> 01:35:26.754
TO KEEP YOU SITTING HERE IF YOU
01:35:26.821 --> 01:35:29.156
HAVE OTHER THINGS TO DO. WE WILL
01:35:29.223 --> 01:35:29.790
RECONVENE AFTER SENATE SESSION
01:35:29.857 --> 01:35:31.559
ENDS. SO IF YOU'D HAVE STAFF
01:35:31.625 --> 01:35:35.062
MEMBERS WATCH FOR THE GAVEL DOWN
01:35:35.129 --> 01:35:36.464
, SO TO SPEAK IN THE SENATE
01:35:36.530 --> 01:35:37.798
CHAMBER WILL COME BACK HERE,
01:35:37.865 --> 01:35:38.899
PROBABLY IN 10 MINUTES. THANK
01:35:38.966 --> 01:35:41.802
YOU ALL VERY MUCH. LET'S NOW
01:35:41.869 --> 01:35:43.037
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
01:35:43.104 --> 01:35:44.405
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT VIA
01:35:44.472 --> 01:35:46.006
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
01:35:46.073 --> 01:35:47.408
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
01:35:47.475 --> 01:35:48.776
SUCH INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
01:35:48.843 --> 01:35:52.079
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A B 16 62.
01:35:52.146 --> 01:35:54.281
WE WILL PROCEED. THANK YOU. MHM
01:35:54.348 --> 01:35:55.883
TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS
01:35:55.950 --> 01:35:57.418
BELONGING TO IMPRESS ONE
01:35:57.485 --> 01:35:58.285
FOLLOWED BY ZERO AGAIN. THAT'S
01:35:58.352 --> 01:36:00.121
ONE AND THEN ZERO ON YOUR
01:36:00.187 --> 01:36:08.863
TELEPHONE KEYPAD. WE DO HAVE ONE
01:36:08.929 --> 01:36:10.030
LINE WITH AN OPERATOR IN JUST A
01:36:10.097 --> 01:36:19.073
MOMENT. THANK YOU. PUBLIC
01:36:19.140 --> 01:36:20.141
COMMENT COMES FROM LINE 24,
01:36:20.207 --> 01:36:24.445
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:36:24.512 --> 01:36:25.312
MEMBERS AARON BONE WITH THE
01:36:25.379 --> 01:36:27.481
MEDICAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA. WE
01:36:27.548 --> 01:36:28.315
HAVE A SUPPORT IF AMENDED
01:36:28.382 --> 01:36:29.984
POSITION ON THE BILL SEEKING
01:36:30.050 --> 01:36:30.951
ADDITIONAL FEE AUTHORITY TO
01:36:31.018 --> 01:36:32.086
COVER OUR COSTS. THANK YOU.
01:36:32.153 --> 01:36:33.254
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT,
01:36:33.320 --> 01:36:35.923
PLEASE. NO OTHER LINES IN QUEUE
01:36:35.990 --> 01:36:39.326
FOR SUPPORT. NOW LET'S FOLLOW
01:36:39.393 --> 01:36:40.694
THE SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM
01:36:40.761 --> 01:36:41.962
ANY WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION
01:36:42.029 --> 01:36:42.997
FIRST WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION
01:36:43.063 --> 01:36:46.467
IN THE HEARING ROOM. SEEING NONE
01:36:46.534 --> 01:36:48.068
. LET'S MOVE TO WITNESSES
01:36:48.135 --> 01:36:49.036
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:36:49.103 --> 01:36:50.337
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
01:36:50.404 --> 01:36:51.839
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
01:36:51.906 --> 01:36:52.873
PROMPT ANY SUCH INDIVIDUALS
01:36:52.940 --> 01:36:53.874
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
01:36:53.941 --> 01:36:55.843
OPPOSITION. T<c.cyan> ASSEMBLY BILL 16</c>
01:36:55.910 --> 01:37:00.114
62, WE WILL CONTINUE WITH THEM.
01:37:00.181 --> 01:37:01.682
THANK YOU. WE PRESS ONE,
01:37:01.749 --> 01:37:03.851
FOLLOWED BY ZERO FOR OPPOSITION
01:37:03.918 --> 01:37:05.119
TO THIS BILL PRESS ONE THAN ZERO
01:37:05.186 --> 01:37:14.929
USING YOUR TELEPHONE. WE DO HAVE
01:37:14.995 --> 01:37:16.931
A LINE WITH AN OPERATOR AND BE A
01:37:16.997 --> 01:37:34.014
MOMENT, PLEASE. THANK YOU.
01:37:43.891 --> 01:37:45.159
OUR PUBLIC COMMENT COMES FROM
01:37:45.226 --> 01:37:49.463
LINE. 63 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:37:49.530 --> 01:37:50.698
GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS SUZIE
01:37:50.764 --> 01:37:51.699
COSTELLO WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:37:51.765 --> 01:37:53.801
BOARD OF PSYCHOLOGY. WE HAVE
01:37:53.867 --> 01:37:56.203
SUBMITTED AND OPPOSED LETTER AND
01:37:56.270 --> 01:37:58.205
I'M CALLING TO ENOUGH OPPOSITION
01:37:58.272 --> 01:38:00.341
TO A B 16 62. THANK YOU. THANK
01:38:00.407 --> 01:38:03.377
YOU, MA'AM. NEXT, PLEASE. THANK
01:38:03.444 --> 01:38:04.979
YOU. NO OTHER LINES IN Q AT THIS
01:38:05.045 --> 01:38:06.413
TIME. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
01:38:06.480 --> 01:38:07.748
LET'S BRING THE CONVERSATION
01:38:07.815 --> 01:38:09.383
BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES IN THE
01:38:09.450 --> 01:38:10.484
HEARING ROOM COLLEAGUES ANY
01:38:10.551 --> 01:38:12.820
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS?
01:38:12.886 --> 01:38:13.988
IT'S BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR
01:38:14.054 --> 01:38:15.022
LEYVA, BUT DR PAN HAS A
01:38:15.089 --> 01:38:19.193
QUESTION. SO UH, DEBORAH GIBSON
01:38:19.260 --> 01:38:21.328
. UM SO I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE
01:38:21.395 --> 01:38:22.863
TRYING TO TACKLE WITH THE BILL,
01:38:22.930 --> 01:38:23.831
I GUESS FUNCTIONALLY. I'M TRYING
01:38:23.897 --> 01:38:25.432
TO UNDERSTAND HOW THIS WORKS
01:38:25.499 --> 01:38:26.333
BECAUSE, FOR EXAMPLE, LET'S JUST
01:38:26.400 --> 01:38:28.168
TAKE THE MEDICAL BOARD AND THEN
01:38:28.235 --> 01:38:29.270
EVERYTHING IS LIKE THE MEDICAL
01:38:29.336 --> 01:38:30.871
BOARD, RIGHT? SO IF YOU GO AND
01:38:30.938 --> 01:38:32.139
YOU DO THE PRE CERTIFICATION,
01:38:32.206 --> 01:38:33.207
RIGHT, YOU SUBMIT YOUR CRIMINAL
01:38:33.274 --> 01:38:38.078
RECORD. UM IT LITERALLY WILL BE
01:38:38.145 --> 01:38:39.213
SEVEN OR EIGHT YEARS BEFORE
01:38:39.280 --> 01:38:39.980
YOU'D BE IN A POSITION TO
01:38:40.047 --> 01:38:41.482
ACTUALLY EVEN APPLY FOR MEDICAL
01:38:41.548 --> 01:38:42.916
LICENSE. YOU HAVE TO GET THROUGH
01:38:42.983 --> 01:38:44.585
MEDICAL SCHOOL. YOU'D GET
01:38:44.652 --> 01:38:45.486
THROUGH RESIDENCY THOSE
01:38:45.552 --> 01:38:46.587
REQUIREMENTS IN ORDER TO GET THE
01:38:46.654 --> 01:38:49.623
LICENSE. IS THE BOARD HELD TO
01:38:49.690 --> 01:38:52.593
THE DECISION THEY MADE SEVEN OR
01:38:52.660 --> 01:38:53.894
EIGHT YEARS AGO. MAYBE THE
01:38:53.961 --> 01:38:55.129
DIFFERENT BOARD AT THAT POINT IN
01:38:55.195 --> 01:38:56.864
TIME, SO THAT'S I GUESS.
01:38:56.930 --> 01:38:58.565
QUESTION NUMBER ONE. SO EXACTLY
01:38:58.632 --> 01:39:00.100
ARE THEY HELD TO THE SAME
01:39:00.167 --> 01:39:01.468
DECISION RIGHT? BECAUSE SOMEONE
01:39:01.535 --> 01:39:02.870
NOW MADE THE COMMITMENT RIGHT?
01:39:02.936 --> 01:39:06.407
AND THEN THE I GUESS THE OTHER
01:39:06.473 --> 01:39:07.608
QUESTION IS THAT I KNOW YOU'RE
01:39:07.675 --> 01:39:08.876
TRYING TO KEEP THE PHYLLO BUT
01:39:08.942 --> 01:39:10.811
YEAH, WELL, I GUESS THERE'S SOME
01:39:10.878 --> 01:39:12.579
ISSUES IN TERMS OF YOU KNOW IS
01:39:12.646 --> 01:39:13.681
THIS REALLY COST EFFECTIVE WAY
01:39:13.747 --> 01:39:16.450
OF DOING THINGS? UM AS WELL
01:39:16.517 --> 01:39:18.686
BECAUSE FIRST OF ALL, THE BOARD
01:39:18.752 --> 01:39:19.553
MAY CHANGE THE STANDARDS MAY
01:39:19.620 --> 01:39:20.754
HAVE A CHANGE IN FAVOR, RIGHT?
01:39:20.821 --> 01:39:22.456
MAY ACTUALLY SOMEONE MAY BE
01:39:22.523 --> 01:39:24.091
DISCOURAGED. THEY'RE TOLD THEY
01:39:24.158 --> 01:39:24.958
CAME BY THE WAY THIS NO. BUT
01:39:25.025 --> 01:39:26.927
ACTUALLY IF YOU WAITED A FEW
01:39:26.994 --> 01:39:28.195
YEARS AND THE CHANGE OF POLICIES
01:39:28.262 --> 01:39:29.863
MAYBE THROUGH YOUR EFFORTS, IN
01:39:29.930 --> 01:39:30.798
FACT, GIBSON THEY OPENED THEIR
01:39:30.864 --> 01:39:32.866
MINDS. THEY MAY SO, SO I JUST
01:39:32.933 --> 01:39:33.867
WANT TO BE SURE WE'RE NOT
01:39:33.934 --> 01:39:35.369
ACTUALLY SENDING MIXED MESSAGES
01:39:35.436 --> 01:39:36.837
OR THE WRONG MESSAGES TO PEOPLE
01:39:36.904 --> 01:39:38.105
WHO ARE APPLYING. SO I GET WHAT
01:39:38.172 --> 01:39:40.074
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO IT. BUT I'M
01:39:40.140 --> 01:39:41.475
ALSO CONCERNED THAT UM, THAT
01:39:41.542 --> 01:39:43.410
THIS MAY NOT NECESSARILY SORT OF
01:39:43.477 --> 01:39:44.812
FUNCTION. YOU'RE HOPING IT DOES.
01:39:44.878 --> 01:39:46.246
SURE THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
01:39:46.313 --> 01:39:48.449
YOUR QUESTION AND SO WERE
01:39:48.515 --> 01:39:50.451
EXPLORED, AND WE'VE WORKED AND
01:39:50.517 --> 01:39:51.452
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:39:51.518 --> 01:39:52.386
OPPOSITIONS, AS WELL AS
01:39:52.453 --> 01:39:54.355
CONSULTANTS HAVE ONE TO TRY AND
01:39:54.421 --> 01:39:56.824
LOOK AT THE FEE. TO MAKING SURE
01:39:56.890 --> 01:39:57.758
THAT IT'S A REASONABLE FEE
01:39:57.825 --> 01:39:59.927
MOVING FORWARD. WE'RE JUST THIS
01:39:59.993 --> 01:40:01.695
BILL IS TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:40:01.762 --> 01:40:02.963
THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN RECENT
01:40:03.030 --> 01:40:04.865
INCARCERATED, UM HAVE AN
01:40:04.932 --> 01:40:07.801
OPPORTUNITY TO EITHER TO KNOW.
01:40:07.868 --> 01:40:09.636
OR NOT KNOW SO THEY CAN MOVE
01:40:09.703 --> 01:40:11.805
FORWARD. AND WHAT HAS TAKEN
01:40:11.872 --> 01:40:14.708
PLACE IS THAT DAVID? THEY'VE PUT
01:40:14.775 --> 01:40:16.310
OUT A LOT OF MONEY, AND THEY
01:40:16.377 --> 01:40:17.845
HAVE NOT GOTTEN THAT MONEY BACK
01:40:17.911 --> 01:40:18.979
OR CAN'T GET THAT MONEY BACK.
01:40:19.046 --> 01:40:20.914
AND WHAT THIS BILL IS TRYING TO
01:40:20.981 --> 01:40:22.883
DO IS MAKING SURE THAT YOU
01:40:22.950 --> 01:40:23.917
EITHER KNOW OR YOU DON'T KNOW
01:40:23.984 --> 01:40:25.686
WHETHER OR NOT WHERE YOU STAND
01:40:25.753 --> 01:40:26.887
IS RELATES TO THIS PARTICULAR
01:40:26.954 --> 01:40:29.189
LICENSE. THAT YOU'RE TRYING TO.
01:40:29.256 --> 01:40:30.924
I APPRECIATE. I GUESS I'M MY
01:40:30.991 --> 01:40:33.260
CONCERN IS THAT I'M NOT SURE THE
01:40:33.327 --> 01:40:33.861
PRE CERTIFICATION GIVES MORE
01:40:33.927 --> 01:40:35.929
CERTAINTY THAN LET'S SAY WE I
01:40:35.996 --> 01:40:37.131
THINK WE SAW OTHER LEGISLATION
01:40:37.197 --> 01:40:38.132
WHERE THEY ACTUALLY PUT A LIST
01:40:38.198 --> 01:40:40.701
OF CRIMINAL ISSUES THAT WOULD
01:40:40.768 --> 01:40:42.202
THEN POTENTIALLY DENY LICENSE
01:40:42.269 --> 01:40:45.205
SURE, AND THAT WOULDN'T AND
01:40:45.272 --> 01:40:45.939
WHETHER YOU'D ACTUALLY HAVE
01:40:46.006 --> 01:40:47.608
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION THAT WAS
01:40:47.674 --> 01:40:48.909
ACTUALLY MORE USEFUL AND MAKING
01:40:48.976 --> 01:40:50.844
THAT KIND OF DECISION, BUT I
01:40:50.911 --> 01:40:52.379
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
01:40:52.446 --> 01:40:53.647
DO. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK
01:40:53.714 --> 01:40:55.449
YOU, SENATOR. PAN SENATOR MEN.
01:40:55.516 --> 01:40:57.851
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. UM I
01:40:57.918 --> 01:40:58.852
UNDERSTAND THAT ALLOW THE BOARDS
01:40:58.919 --> 01:41:00.487
HERE ARE POSTED THIS BILL AND
01:41:00.554 --> 01:41:03.390
UNDERSTAND. PRESUMABLY WISE, THE
01:41:03.457 --> 01:41:04.825
COSTS AND THE ADDED BURDEN OF
01:41:04.892 --> 01:41:06.927
TAKING PROCEDURES. BU I THINK
01:41:06.994 --> 01:41:08.829
WHEN WE TAKE A STEP BACK AS
01:41:08.896 --> 01:41:10.564
POLICYMAKERS, AND WE THINK ABOUT
01:41:10.631 --> 01:41:12.199
HOW THE COSTS ARE DIVIDED, THIS
01:41:12.266 --> 01:41:14.001
BILL MAKES EMINENT SENSE IS VERY
01:41:14.067 --> 01:41:16.837
REASONABLE. BECAUSE FOR A VERY
01:41:16.904 --> 01:41:18.739
MODEST COSTS, WE ARE ALLOWING A
01:41:18.806 --> 01:41:20.841
LOT OF THE LABOR POOL, DECIDE
01:41:20.908 --> 01:41:21.909
WHETHER OR NOT THEY WANT TO GO
01:41:21.975 --> 01:41:23.043
INTO THESE PROFESSIONS. WHERE
01:41:23.110 --> 01:41:23.911
PRESUMABLY RIGHT NOW SOMEBODY
01:41:23.977 --> 01:41:25.612
MIGHT INVEST SEVEN OR EIGHT
01:41:25.679 --> 01:41:26.713
YEARS IN EDUCATION AND TRAINING.
01:41:26.780 --> 01:41:28.949
AND THEN REALIZE THEY CAN'T EVEN
01:41:29.016 --> 01:41:29.616
QUALIFY FOR A LICENSE. OR
01:41:29.683 --> 01:41:31.251
ALTERNATIVELY, SOMEONE MIGHT BE
01:41:31.318 --> 01:41:32.386
DISCOURAGED FROM EVEN EVER
01:41:32.453 --> 01:41:33.587
ENTERING THIS FIELD, LOSING A
01:41:33.654 --> 01:41:35.522
LOT OF POTENTIAL TALENTED
01:41:35.589 --> 01:41:36.523
WORKERS IF WE BELIEVE AS A
01:41:36.590 --> 01:41:38.625
SOCIETY AS A GOVERNMENT THAT
01:41:38.692 --> 01:41:40.360
THOSE WHO REPAID THEIR DEBT TO
01:41:40.427 --> 01:41:41.762
SOCIETY SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO
01:41:41.829 --> 01:41:43.197
FIND GAINFUL EMPLOYMENT. I THINK
01:41:43.263 --> 01:41:44.331
THIS TYPE OF BILL, WHICH
01:41:44.398 --> 01:41:45.065
PROVIDES SIMPLY PROVIDES
01:41:45.132 --> 01:41:47.201
INFORMATION FOR CRIMINAL
01:41:47.267 --> 01:41:47.901
CONVICTS, OR THOSE WITH THE
01:41:47.968 --> 01:41:49.570
CRIMINAL ISTORY. WE HAVE TO
01:41:49.636 --> 01:41:51.572
START WITH THIS STEP, SO I WOULD
01:41:51.638 --> 01:41:52.840
URGE MY COLLEAGUES TO VOTE FOR
01:41:52.906 --> 01:41:54.274
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:41:54.341 --> 01:41:55.008
SIR. COLLEAGUES. ANY OTHER
01:41:55.075 --> 01:41:55.909
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS AND
01:41:55.976 --> 01:41:57.110
CONCERNS. THANK YOU.
01:41:57.177 --> 01:41:58.512
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:41:58.579 --> 01:42:00.848
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, JUST ONCE.
01:42:00.914 --> 01:42:01.648
ONE QUICK SENTENCE. A CRIMINAL
01:42:01.715 --> 01:42:03.250
RECORD SHOULD NOT BE A LIFE
01:42:03.317 --> 01:42:04.751
SENTENCE FOR UNEMPLOYMENT AND
01:42:04.818 --> 01:42:06.253
POVERTY. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:42:06.320 --> 01:42:07.621
MY VOTE FOR THE BILL HAS BEEN
01:42:07.688 --> 01:42:09.356
MOVED BY SENATOR LABOR. THE
01:42:09.423 --> 01:42:11.258
MOTION IS DO PASS AND WE REFER
01:42:11.325 --> 01:42:12.426
THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY.
01:42:12.493 --> 01:42:15.429
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. 16 62
01:42:15.496 --> 01:42:16.964
MOTIONS DO PASS AND WE REFERRED
01:42:17.030 --> 01:42:18.031
TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC
01:42:18.098 --> 01:42:19.566
SAFETY ROTH I MELINDA'S
01:42:19.633 --> 01:42:25.472
ARCHULETTA BATES. BATES I BECKER
01:42:25.539 --> 01:42:27.674
DODD GOD, I ADMINOR TATO.
01:42:27.741 --> 01:42:34.381
JONES. LEVER. THE THAT I MEN.
01:42:34.448 --> 01:42:36.316
AND I, NEWMAN. THANK YOU, OBO.
01:42:36.383 --> 01:42:42.756
FAN. BILL HAS SEVEN VOTES WILL
01:42:42.823 --> 01:42:44.525
HOLD THE ROLL OPEN FOREVER AND
01:42:44.591 --> 01:42:45.993
MEMBERS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:42:46.059 --> 01:42:49.429
VERY MUCH. WE ARE NOW IN RECESS
01:42:49.496 --> 01:42:51.265
UNTIL 15 MINUTES AFTER THE
01:42:51.331 --> 01:42:55.936
SENATE. ADJOURNS OR RECESSES
01:42:56.003 --> 01:42:59.139
TODAY.
01:43:07.147 --> 01:43:08.582
THE SENATE BUSINESS PROFESSIONS
01:43:08.649 --> 01:43:09.082
IN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
01:43:09.149 --> 01:43:11.952
COMMITTEE IS NOW RECONVENE. AS
01:43:12.019 --> 01:43:13.587
AN ADMINISTRATIVE NOTE ON
01:43:13.654 --> 01:43:15.088
TODAY'S AGENDA. FILE ITEM NUMBER
01:43:15.155 --> 01:43:19.459
15 ASSEMBLY BUILT 268 TO 26 82.
01:43:19.526 --> 01:43:20.661
GRAY WILL NOT BE CONSIDERED
01:43:20.727 --> 01:43:25.799
TODAY. WE WILL CONTINUE WITH THE
01:43:25.866 --> 01:43:28.869
LINEUP OF MEASURES ON THE AGENDA
01:43:28.936 --> 01:43:30.304
FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
01:43:30.370 --> 01:43:31.738
PROVIDE GOVERNMENT PUBLIC
01:43:31.805 --> 01:43:33.240
COMMENT THIS AFTERNOON, THE
01:43:33.307 --> 01:43:34.908
PARTICIPANT TOLL FREE NUMBER AND
01:43:34.975 --> 01:43:37.544
ACCESS CODE. AGAIN IS POSTED ON
01:43:37.611 --> 01:43:38.779
OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE. IT WILL
01:43:38.845 --> 01:43:40.714
BE DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN AND I
01:43:40.781 --> 01:43:41.982
WILL AGAIN ANNOUNCE IT NOW.
01:43:42.049 --> 01:43:43.317
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
01:43:43.383 --> 01:43:47.788
844291. IN THE ACCESS CODE IS
01:43:47.854 --> 01:43:57.197
141. 114014. MOVING AHEAD WITH
01:43:57.264 --> 01:43:58.932
THE AGENDA. WE HAVE ITEM NUMBER
01:43:58.999 --> 01:44:01.835
SIX ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MURATSUCHI.
01:44:01.902 --> 01:44:04.338
SOME WE BUILT 17 40 CATALYTIC
01:44:04.404 --> 01:44:05.372
CONVERTERS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S.
01:44:05.439 --> 01:44:11.678
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN READY. THANK
01:44:11.745 --> 01:44:14.581
YOU, MR CHAIRMAN AND SENATORS.
01:44:14.648 --> 01:44:17.284
I'M HERE TO PRESENT A B 17 40,
01:44:17.351 --> 01:44:19.653
WHICH IS ANOTHER BILL. TO
01:44:19.720 --> 01:44:22.422
ATTEMPT TO CORRECT DOWN ON THE
01:44:22.489 --> 01:44:23.624
DRAMATIC INCREASE IN THE RISE OF
01:44:23.690 --> 01:44:27.361
CATALYTIC CONVERTER THEFTS. THIS
01:44:27.427 --> 01:44:29.429
BILL IS ATTEMPTING TO ACHIEVE
01:44:29.496 --> 01:44:31.231
THIS GOAL BY MAKING IT MORE
01:44:31.298 --> 01:44:33.834
DIFFICULT. TO SELL STOLEN
01:44:33.900 --> 01:44:35.469
CONVERTERS AND PROFIT FROM THEIR
01:44:35.535 --> 01:44:38.872
STOLEN GOODS. THIS BILL
01:44:38.939 --> 01:44:40.340
PROHIBITS CORE RECYCLER FROM
01:44:40.407 --> 01:44:42.009
PURCHASING A CATALYTIC CONVERTER
01:44:42.075 --> 01:44:43.610
FROM ANYONE OTHER THAN A
01:44:43.677 --> 01:44:46.847
LICENSED COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE.
01:44:46.913 --> 01:44:49.082
OR THE VERIFIABLE OWNER OF THE
01:44:49.149 --> 01:44:50.984
VEHICLE FROM WHICH THE CATALYTIC
01:44:51.051 --> 01:44:54.221
CONVERTER HAS BEEN REMOVED.
01:44:54.287 --> 01:44:56.189
NEEDLESS TO SAY, I THINK THIS
01:44:56.256 --> 01:44:57.624
COMMITTEE HAS ALREADY HEARD AN
01:44:57.691 --> 01:44:59.259
ABUNDANCE OF EVIDENCE IN TERMS
01:44:59.326 --> 01:45:04.231
OF THE NEED FOR AH AS TO ADDRESS
01:45:04.297 --> 01:45:06.900
THIS ISSUE, THERE HAS BEEN A
01:45:06.967 --> 01:45:07.868
DRAMATIC RISE IN CATHOLIC
01:45:07.934 --> 01:45:09.770
CONVERTED THEFTS, ESPECIALLY IN
01:45:09.836 --> 01:45:11.538
THE IN RECENT YEARS SINCE THE
01:45:11.605 --> 01:45:13.807
PANDEMIC. AND SO WITH THAT I'D
01:45:13.874 --> 01:45:17.611
LIKE TO CALL ANTHONY SAMPSON,
01:45:17.678 --> 01:45:18.912
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA NEW
01:45:18.979 --> 01:45:20.580
CAR DEALERS ASSOCIATION, IN
01:45:20.647 --> 01:45:22.749
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL, AS WELL AS
01:45:22.816 --> 01:45:24.184
BY PHONE TRAVIS AUSTIN FROM THE
01:45:24.251 --> 01:45:25.419
LOS ANGELES CITY ATTORNEY'S
01:45:25.485 --> 01:45:28.088
OFFICE. THANK YOU, SIR. MR.
01:45:28.155 --> 01:45:29.056
SAMPSON UH, REMEMBER THREE
01:45:29.122 --> 01:45:32.793
MINUTES TOTAL. I WON'T TAKE THAT
01:45:32.859 --> 01:45:34.227
MUCH TIME. I PROMISED GOOD
01:45:34.294 --> 01:45:35.796
AFTERNOON MR CHAIR MEMBERS,
01:45:35.862 --> 01:45:37.197
ANTHONY SAMPSON ON BEHALF OF THE
01:45:37.264 --> 01:45:38.131
CALIFORNIA NEW CAR DEALERS
01:45:38.198 --> 01:45:40.300
ASSOCIATION. UH PLEASED TO
01:45:40.367 --> 01:45:41.768
SUPPORT THIS MEASURE. I KNOW
01:45:41.835 --> 01:45:43.637
WE'VE SEEN A BROAD RANGE OF
01:45:43.704 --> 01:45:44.671
CATALYTIC CONVERTER MEASURES
01:45:44.738 --> 01:45:48.208
THIS YEAR. THERE'S CERTAINLY NO
01:45:48.275 --> 01:45:50.477
SILVER BULLET TO ADDRESSING THIS
01:45:50.544 --> 01:45:52.612
ISSUE, BUT WE'RE VERY SUPPORTIVE
01:45:52.679 --> 01:45:55.115
OF MEASURES THAT TAKE A STEP IN
01:45:55.182 --> 01:45:55.782
THE RIGHT DIRECTION. UM YOU KNOW
01:45:55.849 --> 01:45:58.485
THE CALIFORNIA NEW CAR DEALERS
01:45:58.552 --> 01:46:00.320
ARE ALSO VICTIMS OF CATALYTIC
01:46:00.387 --> 01:46:01.788
CONVERTER OF THEFT AND HAS SEEN
01:46:01.855 --> 01:46:04.491
A SIGNIFICANT RISE ON THEIR LOTS
01:46:04.558 --> 01:46:05.559
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
01:46:05.625 --> 01:46:07.561
CALIFORNIA. UM AND IN ADDITION,
01:46:07.627 --> 01:46:08.695
WE ARE SEEING AN INCREASING
01:46:08.762 --> 01:46:09.763
NUMBER. OF CATALYTIC CONVERTERS
01:46:09.830 --> 01:46:14.801
REPLACEMENT. UM COMING IN DUE TO
01:46:14.868 --> 01:46:16.670
THEFT THAT HAVE OCCURRED FOR
01:46:16.737 --> 01:46:18.705
CONSUMERS THROUGHOUT THE STATE
01:46:18.772 --> 01:46:20.474
AND AGAIN, WE THINK THIS IS A
01:46:20.540 --> 01:46:21.975
STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. AND
01:46:22.042 --> 01:46:24.010
YOU KNOW, COMBINED WITH SOME OF
01:46:24.077 --> 01:46:25.112
THE OTHER EFFORTS THAT WE'RE
01:46:25.178 --> 01:46:26.680
SEEING. IN THE LEGISLATURE THIS
01:46:26.747 --> 01:46:28.515
YEAR. HOPEFULLY WE CAN MAKE A
01:46:28.582 --> 01:46:29.883
POSITIVE IMPACT ON THE
01:46:29.950 --> 01:46:30.984
INCREASING NUMBERS THAT WE'RE
01:46:31.051 --> 01:46:32.052
SEEING. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:46:32.119 --> 01:46:37.724
SIR. TRAVIS AUSTIN. HI THANK YOU
01:46:37.791 --> 01:46:40.127
. MR CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE
01:46:40.193 --> 01:46:41.595
COMMITTEE, UH, FOR GIVING ME THE
01:46:41.661 --> 01:46:42.696
OPPORTUNITY TO BE IN SUPPORT OF
01:46:42.763 --> 01:46:45.499
A B 17 40 AS WE ALL KNOW, IN
01:46:45.565 --> 01:46:47.067
RECENT YEARS, THERE'S BEEN AN
01:46:47.134 --> 01:46:48.001
ASTRONOMICAL INCREASE IN
01:46:48.068 --> 01:46:50.437
CATALYTIC CONVERTER THEFT. ONE
01:46:50.504 --> 01:46:51.772
OF THE REASONS FOR THIS
01:46:51.838 --> 01:46:54.141
INCREASES THE EATS AND WHICH
01:46:54.207 --> 01:46:54.775
STOLEN CATALYTIC CONVERTERS CAN
01:46:54.841 --> 01:46:56.977
BE SOLD THAT POOR RECYCLERS
01:46:57.043 --> 01:46:58.512
KNOWING THAT THE CURRENT RECORD
01:46:58.578 --> 01:46:59.746
KEEPING REQUIREMENTS ARE
01:46:59.813 --> 01:47:00.781
INSUFFICIENT TO IDENTIFY THE
01:47:00.847 --> 01:47:03.283
ORIGINAL SOURCE. AT THE
01:47:03.350 --> 01:47:05.952
CATALYTIC CONVERTER CAME FROM
01:47:06.019 --> 01:47:07.487
STRENGTHENING THE RECORD KEEPING
01:47:07.554 --> 01:47:08.488
REQUIREMENTS, OF COURSE,
01:47:08.555 --> 01:47:10.724
RECYCLERS AND LIMITING WHO
01:47:10.791 --> 01:47:11.992
KORVER CYCLERS MAY PURCHASE
01:47:12.058 --> 01:47:13.727
CATALYTIC CONVERTERS FROM A B 17
01:47:13.794 --> 01:47:17.330
40 HELPS US SOLVE THIS PROBLEM.
01:47:17.397 --> 01:47:19.499
THIS BILL PERMITS OR RECYCLERS
01:47:19.566 --> 01:47:21.234
TO PURCHASE CATALYTIC CONVERTERS
01:47:21.301 --> 01:47:23.503
FROM TWO SOURCES. ONE THE
01:47:23.570 --> 01:47:24.971
BAREFOOT, BACK, VERIFIABLE OWNER
01:47:25.038 --> 01:47:26.173
OF THE VEHICLE OR A COMMERCIAL
01:47:26.239 --> 01:47:29.176
ENTERPRISE. IN REGARDS TO A
01:47:29.242 --> 01:47:30.610
VERIFIED OWNER OF THE CORE
01:47:30.677 --> 01:47:32.112
RECYCLERS REQUIRED TO VERIFY
01:47:32.179 --> 01:47:33.747
THAT THE VIN NUMBER IS MARKED ON
01:47:33.814 --> 01:47:35.215
THE CATALYTIC CONVERTER AND THAT
01:47:35.282 --> 01:47:36.316
HAS BEEN ON THE CATALYTIC
01:47:36.383 --> 01:47:38.185
CONVERTER MATCHES HAVE BEEN ON
01:47:38.251 --> 01:47:40.253
THE TITLE. THIS WOULD ENSURE
01:47:40.320 --> 01:47:42.455
THAT THE SELLER IS IN FACT, THE
01:47:42.522 --> 01:47:44.057
TRUE OWNER. IN REGARDS TO A
01:47:44.124 --> 01:47:46.459
COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE 17 40
01:47:46.526 --> 01:47:48.662
IMPROVES UPON EXISTING LAW BY
01:47:48.728 --> 01:47:50.831
CLARIFYING AND DEFINING TERMS
01:47:50.897 --> 01:47:51.898
SUCH AS BUSINESSES OR RENT
01:47:51.965 --> 01:47:55.468
AGREEMENT. THAT MADE VIOLATIONS
01:47:55.535 --> 01:47:56.736
OF CURRENT LAW VERY DIFFICULT TO
01:47:56.803 --> 01:47:59.039
ENFORCE AND PROSECUTE. FOR
01:47:59.105 --> 01:48:00.540
EXAMPLE, THIS BILL DEFINES A
01:48:00.607 --> 01:48:01.975
COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE AND
01:48:02.042 --> 01:48:03.777
REQUIRES THE CORE RECYCLER TO
01:48:03.844 --> 01:48:07.247
RECORD MAINTAINED. THE PHYSICAL
01:48:07.314 --> 01:48:08.949
BUSINESS ADDRESS. BUSINESS
01:48:09.015 --> 01:48:10.217
LICENSE NUMBER OR TAX I D NUMBER
01:48:10.283 --> 01:48:13.220
THE COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISE. THESE
01:48:13.286 --> 01:48:15.088
REVISIONS TAKEN TOGETHER WILL
01:48:15.155 --> 01:48:15.789
ALLOW LAW ENFORCEMENT TO
01:48:15.856 --> 01:48:18.425
ESTABLISH A CHAIN OF CUSTODY AND
01:48:18.491 --> 01:48:19.860
TRACE ANY CATALYTIC CONVERTER
01:48:19.926 --> 01:48:22.596
AND A CORE RECYCLERS INVENTORY.
01:48:22.662 --> 01:48:24.231
BACK TO THE COMMERCIAL
01:48:24.297 --> 01:48:25.599
ENTERPRISE OR VERIFIABLE OWNER
01:48:25.665 --> 01:48:28.969
THAT PROVIDED IT IN CONCLUSION
01:48:29.035 --> 01:48:31.571
BY LIMITING WHO IS ABLE TO SELL
01:48:31.638 --> 01:48:33.073
CATALYTIC CONVERTERS, CORE
01:48:33.139 --> 01:48:34.841
RECYCLERS AND STRENGTHENING THE
01:48:34.908 --> 01:48:37.878
RECORD KEEPING REQUIREMENTS.
01:48:37.944 --> 01:48:40.080
MAYBE 17 40 WILL MAKE IT MORE
01:48:40.146 --> 01:48:41.982
DIFFICULT FOR THIEVES TO PROFIT
01:48:42.048 --> 01:48:43.984
AND MORE IMPORTANTLY, IT WILL
01:48:44.050 --> 01:48:46.052
DETER THIS TYPE OF THEFT IN THE
01:48:46.119 --> 01:48:47.654
FUTURE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:48:47.721 --> 01:48:48.822
SIR. NOW LET'S HEAR FROM ANY
01:48:48.889 --> 01:48:50.590
OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES IN THE
01:48:50.657 --> 01:48:52.459
HEARING ROOM. PLEASE STEP
01:48:52.525 --> 01:48:53.493
FORWARD NAME, AFFILIATION AND
01:48:53.560 --> 01:48:54.594
POSITION ON THE MEASURE ONLY
01:48:54.661 --> 01:48:57.130
PLEASE. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIRMAN
01:48:57.197 --> 01:48:59.099
ROTH COMMITTEE MEMBERS RUSTY
01:48:59.165 --> 01:49:00.367
KANOUTE'S AND ON BEHALF OF THE
01:49:00.433 --> 01:49:01.034
AUTOMOBILE CLUB OF SOUTHERN
01:49:01.101 --> 01:49:03.270
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT OF THE
01:49:03.336 --> 01:49:04.371
EASURE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:49:04.437 --> 01:49:06.806
SIR. NEXT, PLEASE. MR CHAIR JOHN
01:49:06.873 --> 01:49:08.875
MOFFITT ON BEHALF OF THE
01:49:08.942 --> 01:49:09.743
ALLIANCE FOR AUTOMOTIVE IN
01:49:09.809 --> 01:49:11.211
INNOVATION AND SUPPORT. THANK
01:49:11.278 --> 01:49:12.379
YOU ANY OTHER SUPPORT WITNESSES
01:49:12.445 --> 01:49:15.215
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM? SEEING
01:49:15.282 --> 01:49:16.082
NONE. LET'S MOVE TO WITNESSES
01:49:16.149 --> 01:49:17.250
WILLING TO TESTIFY VIA
01:49:17.317 --> 01:49:18.852
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
01:49:18.919 --> 01:49:19.953
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
01:49:20.020 --> 01:49:21.922
SUCH WITNESSES WILLING TO
01:49:21.988 --> 01:49:22.589
TESTIFY AND SUPPORTIVE ASSEMBLY
01:49:22.656 --> 01:49:24.491
BILL 17 40. WE WILL BEGIN WITH
01:49:24.557 --> 01:49:28.929
THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND
01:49:28.995 --> 01:49:29.863
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
01:49:29.930 --> 01:49:32.399
WISH TO COMMENT AND SUPPORT OF A
01:49:32.465 --> 01:49:34.467
B 17 40 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
01:49:34.534 --> 01:49:36.369
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. ONCE
01:49:36.436 --> 01:49:38.672
AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
01:49:38.738 --> 01:49:40.106
SUPPORT OF A B 17 40 YOU MAY
01:49:40.173 --> 01:49:43.310
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. FIRST
01:49:43.376 --> 01:49:46.112
COMMENT COMES FROM LINE 1 49.
01:49:46.179 --> 01:49:47.280
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
01:49:47.347 --> 01:49:56.856
AHEAD. 91 49. YOU MAY BE A MUTE,
01:49:56.923 --> 01:50:03.663
PLEASE GO AHEAD. I WANTED TO
01:50:03.730 --> 01:50:05.598
COMMENT ON 2 57, SO I'LL WAIT
01:50:05.665 --> 01:50:08.435
FOR THAT. THANK YOU AND LINE TO
01:50:08.501 --> 01:50:10.437
60. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
01:50:10.503 --> 01:50:18.611
AHEAD. AND WE'LL MOVE ON TO LINE
01:50:18.678 --> 01:50:20.647
2 63. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE
01:50:20.714 --> 01:50:23.717
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON SHARING
01:50:23.783 --> 01:50:25.318
MEMBERS. ELISA ARE SEVERE KONA
01:50:25.385 --> 01:50:26.453
WITH THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA
01:50:26.519 --> 01:50:27.754
CITIES IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
01:50:27.821 --> 01:50:30.824
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:50:30.890 --> 01:50:32.092
FLYING TO 65. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:50:32.158 --> 01:50:35.628
PLEASE GO AHEAD. IT UP IN THE
01:50:35.695 --> 01:50:36.896
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS SERGEANT
01:50:36.963 --> 01:50:37.964
JULIO DELEON ON BEHALF OF THE
01:50:38.031 --> 01:50:39.632
RIVERS. THAT KIND OF SHERIFF'S
01:50:39.699 --> 01:50:41.201
DEPARTMENT. THE SHERIFF CHAD
01:50:41.267 --> 01:50:43.203
BIANCO. WE ARE IN FULL SUPPORT
01:50:43.269 --> 01:50:43.803
OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. THANK
01:50:43.870 --> 01:50:44.637
YOU, SIR. NEXT, PLEASE. WE HAVE
01:50:44.704 --> 01:50:45.939
NO FURTHER COMMENTS IN SUPPORT
01:50:46.006 --> 01:50:48.475
OF A B 17 40. OKAY LET'S NOT
01:50:48.541 --> 01:50:49.709
FOLLOW THE SAME PROCESS AND HEAR
01:50:49.776 --> 01:50:51.144
FROM ANY OPPOSITION WITNESSES.
01:50:51.211 --> 01:50:53.380
FIRST WITNESSES HERE IN THE
01:50:53.446 --> 01:50:54.447
HEARING ROOM IN OPPOSITION TO
01:50:54.514 --> 01:50:57.050
THIS MEASURE. SEEING NONE. LET'S
01:50:57.117 --> 01:50:58.551
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
01:50:58.618 --> 01:50:59.619
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION VIA THE
01:50:59.686 --> 01:51:01.855
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE.
01:51:01.921 --> 01:51:04.090
MODERATOR ONCE AGAIN, IF YOU
01:51:04.157 --> 01:51:04.591
WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
01:51:04.657 --> 01:51:05.492
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
01:51:05.558 --> 01:51:07.961
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BUILD
01:51:08.028 --> 01:51:09.229
17 40, WE WILL CONTINUE WITH
01:51:09.295 --> 01:51:13.900
THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND
01:51:13.967 --> 01:51:14.868
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
01:51:14.934 --> 01:51:16.870
WISH TO COMMENT IN OPPOSITION OF
01:51:16.936 --> 01:51:19.372
A B 17 40 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
01:51:19.439 --> 01:51:20.807
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME AGAIN IF
01:51:20.874 --> 01:51:21.875
YOU WISH TO COMMENT IN
01:51:21.941 --> 01:51:26.780
OPPOSITION FS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
01:51:26.846 --> 01:51:27.981
ONE MOMENT WHILE WE GATHER THE
01:51:28.048 --> 01:51:46.733
LINE NUMBER.
01:51:48.134 --> 01:51:49.335
CLIMB TO 81. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:51:49.402 --> 01:51:52.772
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR CHAIRMAN,
01:51:52.839 --> 01:51:54.307
MEMBERS GATHERING MCCUE ON
01:51:54.374 --> 01:51:54.908
BEHALF OF THE STATE OF
01:51:54.974 --> 01:51:56.209
CALIFORNIA TO DISMANTLE
01:51:56.276 --> 01:51:57.811
ASSOCIATION SCATTERS THE
01:51:57.877 --> 01:51:59.245
STATEWIDE ASSOCIATION
01:51:59.312 --> 01:52:00.747
REPRESENTING LICENSED AND
01:52:00.814 --> 01:52:02.248
REGULATED AUTOMOBILE DISMANTLE
01:52:02.315 --> 01:52:04.150
EAR'S SCATTER VERY MUCH SUPPORTS
01:52:04.217 --> 01:52:05.785
EFFORTS BY THE AUTHOR AND OTHER
01:52:05.852 --> 01:52:06.986
MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATURE TO
01:52:07.053 --> 01:52:08.288
ADDRESS THE VERY SERIOUS PROBLEM
01:52:08.354 --> 01:52:09.322
OF CALIPH CONVERTER THEFT,
01:52:09.389 --> 01:52:11.124
HOWEVER, MY CLIENT DOES HAVE
01:52:11.191 --> 01:52:13.259
SOME SIGNIFICANT CONCERNS WITH
01:52:13.326 --> 01:52:14.694
SOME OF THE PROVISIONS THAT WERE
01:52:14.761 --> 01:52:15.995
AMENDED INTO THE BILL LATE LAST
01:52:16.062 --> 01:52:17.864
WEEK THAT WILL ADD POTENTIALLY
01:52:17.931 --> 01:52:18.364
UNNECESSARY AND COSTLY
01:52:18.431 --> 01:52:22.602
REQUIREMENTS. FOR THESE LICENSED
01:52:22.669 --> 01:52:23.603
, REGULATED AND LEGITIMATE
01:52:23.670 --> 01:52:24.571
BUSINESSES THAT ARE NOT
01:52:24.637 --> 01:52:25.538
CONTRIBUTING TO THE PROBLEM OF
01:52:25.605 --> 01:52:27.607
CATHOLIC INVERTER SAFETY. SINCE
01:52:27.674 --> 01:52:28.942
THEN, WE'VE HAD SOME GOOD
01:52:29.008 --> 01:52:30.577
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR'S
01:52:30.643 --> 01:52:32.212
OFFICE AND LOOK FORWARD TO
01:52:32.278 --> 01:52:33.446
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THEM TO
01:52:33.513 --> 01:52:34.981
ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS AS THE BILL
01:52:35.048 --> 01:52:36.216
MOVES ALONG AND THANK YOU FOR
01:52:36.282 --> 01:52:38.218
YOUR TIME. THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT,
01:52:38.284 --> 01:52:42.622
PLEASE. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
01:52:42.689 --> 01:52:44.190
COMMENT FROM QUÊ AT THIS TIME.
01:52:44.257 --> 01:52:44.958
THANK YOU, MODERATOR. LET'S
01:52:45.024 --> 01:52:46.826
BRING THE MATTER BACK TO MY
01:52:46.893 --> 01:52:47.994
COLLEAGUES IN THE HEARING ROOM
01:52:48.061 --> 01:52:48.962
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS,
01:52:49.028 --> 01:52:49.629
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? BEEN MOVED
01:52:49.696 --> 01:52:54.000
BY SENATOR LEYVA. SOME OF THEM
01:52:54.067 --> 01:52:55.902
REMEMBER SUKI, WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:52:55.969 --> 01:52:57.070
CLOSE? I WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR I
01:52:57.137 --> 01:52:59.639
VOTE. WE HAVE A MOTION AND IT'S
01:52:59.706 --> 01:53:00.707
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR LEYVA. THE
01:53:00.773 --> 01:53:02.742
MOTION IS DUE PASS. WE REFER TO
01:53:02.809 --> 01:53:03.743
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
01:53:03.810 --> 01:53:06.980
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. 17 40
01:53:07.046 --> 01:53:08.348
MOTIONS DO PASS AND WE REFERRED
01:53:08.414 --> 01:53:09.382
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:53:09.449 --> 01:53:09.883
APPROPRIATIONS ROCK. HI.
01:53:09.949 --> 01:53:13.586
MELINDA'S. ARCHULETTA BATES
01:53:13.653 --> 01:53:19.659
ALRIGHT BECKER. DIED. EGGMAN.
01:53:19.726 --> 01:53:23.997
EGGMAN I HER TATO JONES FLAVOR.
01:53:24.063 --> 01:53:26.900
AMEN THEN I NEWMAN I PATROL
01:53:26.966 --> 01:53:30.803
BOGEY, MAN. LITTLE HAS SIX VOTES
01:53:30.870 --> 01:53:32.639
WILL HOLD THE ROLL OPEN FOR
01:53:32.705 --> 01:53:37.477
ABSENT MEMBERS. THANK YOU.
01:53:37.544 --> 01:53:39.579
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORA ASSEMBLY
01:53:39.646 --> 01:53:42.482
BILL 21. OH 7 21 07. PLEASE
01:53:42.549 --> 01:53:48.021
PROCEED WHEN READY. ALRIGHT,
01:53:48.087 --> 01:53:49.989
THANK YOU. CHAIR AND PROMISES
01:53:50.056 --> 01:53:50.990
DOES NOT HAVE TO DO WITH
01:53:51.057 --> 01:53:52.725
PRODUCE, SO SHOULD BE A LITTLE
01:53:52.792 --> 01:53:53.927
BIT QUICKER CONVERTERS OR
01:53:53.993 --> 01:53:57.197
ASPARAGUS. BUT I'M HERE TO
01:53:57.263 --> 01:54:00.466
PRESENT A B 21. OH, SEVEN. WHICH
01:54:00.533 --> 01:54:01.868
WILL PERMIT THOSE WHO ARE
01:54:01.935 --> 01:54:03.102
LICENSED TO CONDUCT MOLECULAR
01:54:03.169 --> 01:54:05.071
TESTING FOR HUMAN GENETICS TO
01:54:05.138 --> 01:54:06.372
ALSO TEST FOR INFECTIOUS
01:54:06.439 --> 01:54:07.707
DISEASES. RECENT AMENDMENTS
01:54:07.774 --> 01:54:09.409
ADDED AN URGENCY CLAUSE AND FOR
01:54:09.475 --> 01:54:11.277
THAT SAKE, ENSURING AND FOR THAT
01:54:11.344 --> 01:54:12.879
OF ENSURING THE WORKPLACE IS
01:54:12.946 --> 01:54:13.580
CURRENTLY IN PLACE UNDER
01:54:13.646 --> 01:54:15.281
EMERGENCY OR TO REMAIN IN PLACE
01:54:15.348 --> 01:54:18.151
. IF THAT WERE TO EXPIRE, 21 7
01:54:18.218 --> 01:54:19.219
WILL ENSURE CALIFORNIA HAS THE
01:54:19.285 --> 01:54:20.920
APPROPRIATE WORKFORCE. TO
01:54:20.987 --> 01:54:22.488
PREPARE FOR IT DETECTS SPIKES
01:54:22.555 --> 01:54:24.624
AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES WITH ME
01:54:24.691 --> 01:54:26.492
TODAY ON THE PHONE LINE IS KELLY
01:54:26.559 --> 01:54:27.660
HIKES FROM HALIFAX AND DR LIN
01:54:27.727 --> 01:54:29.128
SILVERS HERE IN THE ROOM, AND
01:54:29.195 --> 01:54:30.697
SHE IS A SENIOR ADVISOR TO
01:54:30.763 --> 01:54:31.531
PUBLIC HEALTH INSTITUTION
01:54:31.598 --> 01:54:33.199
TESTIFY AND ANSWER ANY FURTHER
01:54:33.266 --> 01:54:34.167
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS. THANK YOU,
01:54:34.234 --> 01:54:42.075
SIR. WITNESSES, PLEASE PROCEED.
01:54:42.141 --> 01:54:44.611
MR CHAIR. UM MEMBERS OF THE
01:54:44.677 --> 01:54:46.246
COMMITTEE. I'M DR LYNN SILVER
01:54:46.312 --> 01:54:48.281
PEDIATRICIAN AND DIRECTOR OF THE
01:54:48.348 --> 01:54:49.249
SAFETY OF SAFELY OPENING SCHOOLS
01:54:49.315 --> 01:54:50.650
PROJECT AT THE PUBLIC HEALTH
01:54:50.717 --> 01:54:53.486
INSTITUTE. UM I'LL BE BRIEF OUR
01:54:53.553 --> 01:54:55.121
PROJECT HIS WORK WITH SCHOOLS
01:54:55.188 --> 01:54:55.822
ACROSS THE STATE ON TRAINING
01:54:55.888 --> 01:54:57.257
STAFF AND EDUCATING ABOUT
01:54:57.323 --> 01:54:58.691
ROLLING OUT COVID 19 RAPID
01:54:58.758 --> 01:55:01.461
TESTING AND VACCINATION. I'M
01:55:01.527 --> 01:55:02.762
GOING TO SPEAK TO THE CLEAR
01:55:02.829 --> 01:55:05.231
WAIVER PORTION OF THIS BILL. UM
01:55:05.298 --> 01:55:06.866
BASICALLY WITH THAT WOULD DO
01:55:06.933 --> 01:55:07.734
WOULD ALLOW APPROPRIATELY
01:55:07.800 --> 01:55:10.103
TRAINED AND SUPERVISED NON
01:55:10.169 --> 01:55:11.671
HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS TO
01:55:11.738 --> 01:55:13.473
CARRY OUT, FOR EXAMPLE, THE TYPE
01:55:13.539 --> 01:55:14.641
OF RAPID TESTING THAT I SAW
01:55:14.707 --> 01:55:15.775
BEING IMPLEMENTED ON THE SIXTH
01:55:15.842 --> 01:55:19.612
FLOOR. THIS MORNING, UM, USING
01:55:19.679 --> 01:55:21.447
COVID RAPID TESTS. THESE ARE
01:55:21.514 --> 01:55:23.583
MANY CASES THE SAME TEST THAT
01:55:23.650 --> 01:55:24.717
MANY OF YOU HAVE PROBABLY USED
01:55:24.784 --> 01:55:26.619
AT HOME AND WHICH THE FDA
01:55:26.686 --> 01:55:28.221
RECOGNIZED COULD BE SAFELY
01:55:28.288 --> 01:55:29.422
PERFORMED BY A NON HEALTHCARE
01:55:29.489 --> 01:55:31.958
PROFESSIONAL. HOWEVER UNDER
01:55:32.025 --> 01:55:34.093
CURRENT LAW, UM IT IS REQUIRED
01:55:34.160 --> 01:55:36.029
THAT IF YOU'RE DOING THIS ON A
01:55:36.095 --> 01:55:37.997
LARGER SCALE UNDER CLEAR WAIVER,
01:55:38.064 --> 01:55:39.098
IT HAS TO BE A HEALTHCARE
01:55:39.165 --> 01:55:40.266
PROFESSIONAL THAT HAS PROVED
01:55:40.333 --> 01:55:42.869
DIFFICULT IN SCHOOL SETTINGS. UM
01:55:42.935 --> 01:55:45.605
AND WE ARE, UM IN THE FUTURE. WE
01:55:45.672 --> 01:55:46.739
WANT TO BE ABLE TO TRAIN
01:55:46.806 --> 01:55:47.907
COMMUNITY MEMBERS, PARENT
01:55:47.974 --> 01:55:49.609
VOLUNTEERS OR NON HEALTH
01:55:49.676 --> 01:55:52.345
PROFESSIONALS TO DO THIS TYPE OF
01:55:52.412 --> 01:55:53.446
SCREENING. IF IT PROVES
01:55:53.513 --> 01:55:55.415
NECESSARY. WE HOPE IT WON'T UM,
01:55:55.481 --> 01:55:56.849
BUT IT MAY AND IF IT'S NECESSARY
01:55:56.916 --> 01:55:59.052
TO KEEP OUR KIDS SAFE AND IN
01:55:59.118 --> 01:56:00.119
SCHOOL NEXT YEAR, WE'D LIKE TO
01:56:00.186 --> 01:56:01.654
BE ABLE TO MOBILIZE A BROADER
01:56:01.721 --> 01:56:03.523
ARRAY OF PEOPLE TO DO WHAT
01:56:03.589 --> 01:56:05.158
THEY'RE DOING ON THE SIXTH
01:56:05.224 --> 01:56:06.392
FLOOR. SO IF YOU HAVE ANY
01:56:06.459 --> 01:56:08.227
QUESTIONS, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER
01:56:08.294 --> 01:56:09.329
THEM. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:56:09.395 --> 01:56:12.265
MA'AM. NEXT, PLEASE. AND ROSS
01:56:12.332 --> 01:56:13.566
AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
01:56:13.633 --> 01:56:15.335
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. 80
01:56:15.401 --> 01:56:17.470
21. OH SEVEN. MY NAME IS KELLY
01:56:17.537 --> 01:56:18.738
HIKES AND I LEAVE GOVERNMENT
01:56:18.805 --> 01:56:19.939
RELATIONS FOR HELIX AT
01:56:20.006 --> 01:56:20.540
CALIFORNIA BASED POPULATION.
01:56:20.606 --> 01:56:22.542
GENOMICS COMPANIES, PINNACLES
01:56:22.608 --> 01:56:23.109
GENETICS, MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
01:56:23.176 --> 01:56:26.479
SCIENTISTS WHOSE MOLECULAR PAST
01:56:26.546 --> 01:56:28.181
THE SAME WAY THAT COVID
01:56:28.247 --> 01:56:28.815
DIAGNOSTICS AND OTHER MOLECULAR
01:56:28.881 --> 01:56:30.216
INFECTIOUS WITH THESE TESTS
01:56:30.283 --> 01:56:32.485
PERFORMED THE SAME ACADEMIC
01:56:32.552 --> 01:56:34.320
CREDENTIALS AND ARE HIGHLY
01:56:34.387 --> 01:56:35.388
TRAINED IN ALL ASPECTS OF
01:56:35.455 --> 01:56:36.656
CLINICAL MOLECULAR TESTING.
01:56:36.723 --> 01:56:38.858
ESPECIALLY IN THEIR ABILITY TO
01:56:38.925 --> 01:56:40.393
DESIGN DONE AND CONFORM ALIKE
01:56:40.460 --> 01:56:41.961
HARASSES WHICH IS NECESSARY FOR
01:56:42.028 --> 01:56:43.496
CORE WORKING HUMAN GENETICS AND
01:56:43.563 --> 01:56:44.497
CAN BE APPLIED THE MOLECULAR
01:56:44.564 --> 01:56:45.565
TESTING IN OTHER DISCIPLINES
01:56:45.631 --> 01:56:48.601
LIKE INFECTIOUS DISEASES. THANKS
01:56:48.668 --> 01:56:50.002
TO THE EXECUTIVE ORDER AS
01:56:50.069 --> 01:56:51.037
SCIENTISTS THAT ARE LICENSED TO
01:56:51.104 --> 01:56:52.672
DO HIGH COMPLEXITY. TEST GRANTED
01:56:52.739 --> 01:56:53.473
AUTHORITY. DID YOU COVID TEST
01:56:53.539 --> 01:56:55.875
UNDER THESE THINGS LICENSE?
01:56:55.942 --> 01:56:57.610
CALIFORNIA WE LICENSED CLINICAL
01:56:57.677 --> 01:56:59.245
LAB SCIENTISTS BASED ON BROAD
01:56:59.312 --> 01:57:00.546
CATEGORIES INSTEAD OF THEIR
01:57:00.613 --> 01:57:03.349
EXPERTISE IN THE TYPE OF STUFF
01:57:03.416 --> 01:57:05.251
THAT MUCH OF THE COUNTRY SIMPLY
01:57:05.318 --> 01:57:06.152
ADDING MOLECULAR INFECTIOUS
01:57:06.219 --> 01:57:09.856
DISEASE PASSING THE LICENSE IS
01:57:09.922 --> 01:57:11.724
CLOSER TO OUR TEARS AND SUPPORT
01:57:11.791 --> 01:57:13.025
LABS, LIKE HE LIKES THE PURPLE
01:57:13.092 --> 01:57:15.294
AND COVID TAPS AT THE WAY THE
01:57:15.361 --> 01:57:15.995
SEQUENCE THOSE SAMPLES WITH
01:57:16.062 --> 01:57:18.664
VARIANTS WERE USED BY THE CBC
01:57:18.731 --> 01:57:20.433
AND I H AND RESEARCHERS THAT ARE
01:57:20.500 --> 01:57:21.467
DEVELOPING NEXT GENERATION
01:57:21.534 --> 01:57:23.469
VACCINES AND TREATMENT. GLASS
01:57:23.536 --> 01:57:25.605
MOVED BACK TO PRE PANDEMIC
01:57:25.671 --> 01:57:26.639
OPERATIONS WORKFORCE THAT CAN
01:57:26.706 --> 01:57:28.608
HELP MAINTAIN BASELINE TESTING
01:57:28.674 --> 01:57:30.009
AND ONE THAT IS READY TO PIVOT
01:57:30.076 --> 01:57:31.677
AWAY FROM THEIR CORE WORK TO
01:57:31.744 --> 01:57:33.079
RESPOND TO OUTBREAKS, GETTING
01:57:33.146 --> 01:57:33.780
THIS CODE TO INCLUDE MOLECULAR
01:57:33.846 --> 01:57:35.081
TESTING. FOR INFECTIOUS DISEASE.
01:57:35.148 --> 01:57:39.952
IS IT SIMPLE. SIGNIFICANT STEPS
01:57:40.019 --> 01:57:41.254
TO KEEP US PREPARED AND REFLECT
01:57:41.320 --> 01:57:42.989
THE WAY MODERN LAB TESTING IS
01:57:43.055 --> 01:57:44.690
CONDUCTED THOSE REASONS FOR
01:57:44.757 --> 01:57:47.160
PASSAGE OF HB 21 OH, SEVEN, AND
01:57:47.226 --> 01:57:48.227
I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
01:57:48.294 --> 01:57:50.062
QUESTIONS. THANK YOU, MA'AM. NOW
01:57:50.129 --> 01:57:50.763
LET'S HEAR FROM ANY OTHER
01:57:50.830 --> 01:57:51.831
SUPPORT. WITNESSES IN THE
01:57:51.898 --> 01:57:53.533
HEARING ROOM SUPPORT WITNESSES.
01:57:53.599 --> 01:57:55.868
NAME AFFILIATION POSITION. GOOD
01:57:55.935 --> 01:57:56.869
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR, JUSTIN
01:57:56.936 --> 01:57:59.005
BENDS ON BEHALF OF HELIX AND TO
01:57:59.071 --> 01:58:01.741
PROTECT US COALITION. ASK FOR-YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:58:01.808 --> 01:58:02.909
YOU. ANY OTHER SPORT WITNESSES
01:58:02.975 --> 01:58:04.477
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM? LET'S
01:58:04.544 --> 01:58:06.045
MOVE INTO WITNESSES WILLING TO
01:58:06.112 --> 01:58:07.647
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT VIA
01:58:07.713 --> 01:58:08.648
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MODERATOR
01:58:08.714 --> 01:58:11.083
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY
01:58:11.150 --> 01:58:12.251
SUCH INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
01:58:12.318 --> 01:58:13.886
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
01:58:13.953 --> 01:58:16.722
BILL 21 07, WE WILL BEGIN WITH
01:58:16.789 --> 01:58:21.360
THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND
01:58:21.427 --> 01:58:22.361
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
01:58:22.428 --> 01:58:24.397
WISH TO COMMENT IN SUPPORT OF A
01:58:24.464 --> 01:58:25.631
B 21 OH, SEVEN. YOU MAY PRESS
01:58:25.698 --> 01:58:27.867
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
01:58:27.934 --> 01:58:29.802
AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
01:58:29.869 --> 01:58:31.971
SUPPORT OF A B 21 7. THAT'S ONE
01:58:32.038 --> 01:58:36.209
AND THEN HERE, UM. PLANE TO 73.
01:58:36.275 --> 01:58:38.077
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
01:58:38.144 --> 01:58:42.482
AHEAD. THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN
01:58:42.548 --> 01:58:44.417
AND MEMBERS WERE TOP ON BEHALF
01:58:44.484 --> 01:58:45.451
OF STYLE. COM CALIFORNIA AND
01:58:45.518 --> 01:58:49.088
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE.
01:58:49.155 --> 01:58:51.123
PLANE TO 66. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:58:51.190 --> 01:58:54.894
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR CHAIRMAN,
01:58:54.961 --> 01:58:57.530
MEMBERS ADAM CABLE WITH THEM, UM
01:58:57.597 --> 01:58:59.232
, CALLING ON BEHALF OF PRIMARY
01:58:59.298 --> 01:59:00.600
HEALTH AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:59:00.666 --> 01:59:03.102
THANK YOU. NEXT, PLEASE. WE HAVE
01:59:03.169 --> 01:59:04.570
NO FURTHER COMMENTS IN. Q THANK
01:59:04.637 --> 01:59:05.838
YOU, MODERATOR. NOW LET'S FOLLOW
01:59:05.905 --> 01:59:08.007
THE SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM
01:59:08.074 --> 01:59:09.141
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
01:59:09.208 --> 01:59:10.142
FIRST OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE
01:59:10.209 --> 01:59:14.013
IN THE HEARING ROOM. SAYING NONE
01:59:14.080 --> 01:59:15.481
LET'S NOW MOVE TO WITNESSES
01:59:15.548 --> 01:59:18.084
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:59:18.150 --> 01:59:19.151
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
01:59:19.218 --> 01:59:20.253
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD ONCE
01:59:20.319 --> 01:59:22.355
AGAIN PROMPT ANY SUCH
01:59:22.421 --> 01:59:23.389
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
01:59:23.456 --> 01:59:25.491
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL
01:59:25.558 --> 01:59:29.962
21 07, WE WILL BEGIN WITH THEM.
01:59:30.029 --> 01:59:31.697
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND LADIES
01:59:31.764 --> 01:59:34.000
AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO
01:59:34.066 --> 01:59:34.867
COMMENT AND OPPOSITION OF THE 21
01:59:34.934 --> 01:59:36.836
OH, SEVEN. YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
01:59:36.903 --> 01:59:39.805
THEN BUT AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO
01:59:39.872 --> 01:59:42.375
COMMENT AND OPPOSITION OF A B 21
01:59:42.441 --> 01:59:43.576
OH SEVEN, PRESS ONE AND THEN
01:59:43.643 --> 01:59:46.979
ZERO. WE HAVE NO COMMENT. SIMPLY
01:59:47.046 --> 01:59:48.180
THANK YOU, MODERATOR. NOW LET'S
01:59:48.247 --> 01:59:49.615
BRING THE MATTER BACK TO THE
01:59:49.682 --> 01:59:50.917
HEARING ROOM AND MY COLLEAGUES
01:59:50.983 --> 01:59:52.018
ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
01:59:52.084 --> 01:59:55.421
CONCERNS? SIGNAL QUESTIONS,
01:59:55.488 --> 01:59:56.989
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS. THE BILL
01:59:57.056 --> 01:59:58.124
HAS BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR
01:59:58.190 --> 02:00:00.359
NEWMAN. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FLORA.
02:00:00.426 --> 02:00:01.527
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
02:00:01.594 --> 02:00:02.528
DISRESPECTFULLY? AZZOPARDI VOTE
02:00:02.595 --> 02:00:04.630
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, SIR. THE
02:00:04.697 --> 02:00:07.033
MOTION IS DUE PASS. WE REFER TO
02:00:07.099 --> 02:00:08.234
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
02:00:08.301 --> 02:00:10.136
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. A B 21.
02:00:10.202 --> 02:00:11.938
OH, SEVEN MOTIONS DO PASS, AND
02:00:12.004 --> 02:00:12.872
WE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:00:12.939 --> 02:00:16.242
APPROPRIATIONS. ROTH I MELINDA'S
02:00:16.309 --> 02:00:19.111
ARCHULETTA BATES. BATES, I
02:00:19.178 --> 02:00:22.982
BECKER. BECKER. I DODD. I GOT I
02:00:23.049 --> 02:00:28.254
EGGMAN. EDMUND I. HURTADO JONES.
02:00:28.321 --> 02:00:31.991
LLEVA LIVER. I'M IN. MOMENT. I
02:00:32.058 --> 02:00:37.763
NEWMAN KOBO. TÌM. BILL HAS EIGHT
02:00:37.830 --> 02:00:39.665
VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLL OPEN
02:00:39.732 --> 02:00:42.234
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS. THANKS.
02:00:42.301 --> 02:00:44.470
REMEMBER DAILY ITEM NUMBER 13
02:00:44.537 --> 02:00:51.978
ASSEMBLY BILL 26 11. THANK YOU.
02:00:52.044 --> 02:00:54.447
MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. THIS BILL
02:00:54.513 --> 02:00:56.449
PROVIDES A STANDARD DEFINITION
02:00:56.515 --> 02:00:57.650
FOR A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS IN
02:00:57.717 --> 02:01:00.886
CALIFORNIA STATUTE. CREATING A
02:01:00.953 --> 02:01:02.355
STANDARD DEFINITION WILL PROVIDE
02:01:02.421 --> 02:01:05.024
CLARITY FOR US POLICYMAKERS WHEN
02:01:05.091 --> 02:01:06.859
MAKING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
02:01:06.926 --> 02:01:09.228
DECISIONS, SUCH AS TAX POLICY,
02:01:09.295 --> 02:01:10.296
COMMIT PROGRAMS AND EMPLOYEE
02:01:10.363 --> 02:01:13.399
TRAINING INCENTIVES. HERE TO
02:01:13.466 --> 02:01:15.034
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT IS DENNIS
02:01:15.101 --> 02:01:16.402
ALBION E, REPRESENTING THE
02:01:16.469 --> 02:01:18.638
SPONSOR OF THE BILL, THE FAMILY
02:01:18.704 --> 02:01:22.008
BUSINESS ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU,
02:01:22.074 --> 02:01:24.010
SIR. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK YOU
02:01:24.076 --> 02:01:25.044
VERY MUCH AS HE MENTIONED DENNIS
02:01:25.111 --> 02:01:26.979
ALBION E. ON BEHALF OF THE
02:01:27.046 --> 02:01:27.546
CALIFORNIA FAMILY BUSINESS
02:01:27.613 --> 02:01:29.081
ASSOCIATION. FAMILY BUSINESSES
02:01:29.148 --> 02:01:30.683
ARE KEY STRUCTURE OF OUR ECONOMY
02:01:30.750 --> 02:01:33.019
HERE IN CALIFORNIA. THERE ARE
02:01:33.085 --> 02:01:35.054
1.7 MILLION FAMILY BUSINESS OF
02:01:35.121 --> 02:01:37.156
CALIFORNIA. THE DEFINITION OF
02:01:37.223 --> 02:01:38.658
CALIFORNIA FAMILY BUSINESS IS
02:01:38.724 --> 02:01:40.092
IMPORTANT FOR THE TAX
02:01:40.159 --> 02:01:41.327
DISCUSSIONS CONSISTENT
02:01:41.394 --> 02:01:43.462
DEFINITION ACROSS LARGE STATE.
02:01:43.529 --> 02:01:44.897
IS GOOD FOR LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
02:01:44.964 --> 02:01:46.666
, AND THEY WANT TO DO IT LIKE A
02:01:46.732 --> 02:01:49.235
BY LOCAL OR BY FAMILY. THE
02:01:49.301 --> 02:01:50.202
REQUIREMENTS ARE YOU HAVE TO
02:01:50.269 --> 02:01:51.737
HAVE BEEN IN BUSINESS 10 YEARS
02:01:51.804 --> 02:01:53.205
BEEN THROUGH SUCCESSION OR
02:01:53.272 --> 02:01:53.773
DEVELOPED AN ACCESSION PLAN
02:01:53.839 --> 02:01:54.707
DOMICILED AND HEADQUARTERED IN
02:01:54.774 --> 02:01:58.711
CALIFORNIA. UM AND JUST F Y I SO
02:01:58.778 --> 02:02:00.613
THIS BILL HAS ALREADY PASSED THE
02:02:00.680 --> 02:02:02.782
THIS HOUSE AS WE KNOW PREVIOUSLY
02:02:02.848 --> 02:02:04.383
, BUT IT WAS VERY BAD FORMER
02:02:04.450 --> 02:02:07.753
ADMINISTRATION. WE HAVE BEEN, UH
02:02:07.820 --> 02:02:09.255
, HAVING DISCUSSIONS WITH THE GO
02:02:09.321 --> 02:02:11.157
BIZ AND THE ADMINISTRATION AND
02:02:11.223 --> 02:02:12.191
HAVE GOTTEN FAVORABLE FEEDBACK
02:02:12.258 --> 02:02:15.094
AND SO WELL, YOU KNOW, NOTHINGS.
02:02:15.161 --> 02:02:17.096
FOR CERTAIN. WE HAVE ADDRESSED
02:02:17.163 --> 02:02:19.165
SEVERAL OF THEIR CONCERNS AND
02:02:19.231 --> 02:02:20.266
ARE CONTINUING TO WORK WITH
02:02:20.332 --> 02:02:21.467
THEM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK
02:02:21.534 --> 02:02:23.235
YOU, SIR. NOW LET'S HEAR FROM
02:02:23.302 --> 02:02:24.336
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
02:02:24.403 --> 02:02:27.106
IN THE HEARING ROOM. SEEING
02:02:27.173 --> 02:02:27.940
NONE. LET'S MOVE TO WITNESSES
02:02:28.007 --> 02:02:29.475
WILLING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
02:02:29.542 --> 02:02:30.876
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
02:02:30.943 --> 02:02:32.611
MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
02:02:32.678 --> 02:02:34.213
PROMPT ANY SUCH INDIVIDUALS.
02:02:34.280 --> 02:02:35.214
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND
02:02:35.281 --> 02:02:37.349
SUPPORTIVE ASSEMBLY BILL. 2611,
02:02:37.416 --> 02:02:42.221
WE WILL BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK
02:02:42.288 --> 02:02:43.756
YOU, MR CHAIR, AND LADIES AND
02:02:43.823 --> 02:02:45.858
GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO
02:02:45.925 --> 02:02:46.826
COMMENT AND SUPPORT OF 26 11,
02:02:46.892 --> 02:02:48.761
YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
02:02:48.828 --> 02:02:51.197
AT THIS TIME. ONCE AGAIN IF YOU
02:02:51.263 --> 02:02:54.366
WISH TO COME IN AND SUPPORTED A
02:02:54.433 --> 02:02:55.501
B 26 11, YOU MAY 1ST ONE AND
02:02:55.568 --> 02:02:57.670
THEN GERALD. WE HAVE NO COMMENTS
02:02:57.737 --> 02:03:01.607
ON CUE AT THIS. THANK YOU,
02:03:01.674 --> 02:03:03.976
MODERATOR. LET'S NOW FOLLOW THE
02:03:04.043 --> 02:03:04.744
SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
02:03:04.810 --> 02:03:06.579
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION FIRST
02:03:06.645 --> 02:03:07.480
OPPOSITION WITNESSES HERE IN THE
02:03:07.546 --> 02:03:09.849
HEARING ROOM. SAYING NONE LET'S
02:03:09.915 --> 02:03:11.283
MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
02:03:11.350 --> 02:03:12.251
TESTIFY VIA TELECONFERENCE
02:03:12.318 --> 02:03:13.352
SERVICE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
02:03:13.419 --> 02:03:15.888
MEASURE. MODERATOR ONCE AGAIN,
02:03:15.955 --> 02:03:17.256
IF YOU WOULD PROMPT ANY SUCH
02:03:17.323 --> 02:03:18.858
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:03:18.924 --> 02:03:21.227
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY, BILL
02:03:21.293 --> 02:03:22.361
2611, WE WILL CONTINUE WITH
02:03:22.428 --> 02:03:26.966
THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND
02:03:27.032 --> 02:03:28.434
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
02:03:28.501 --> 02:03:29.702
WISH TO COME AND THEN OPPOSITION
02:03:29.769 --> 02:03:31.704
OF A B 26 11, YOU MAY PRESS ONE
02:03:31.771 --> 02:03:33.939
AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:03:34.006 --> 02:03:37.209
AGAIN. YOU WISH TO COMMENT IN
02:03:37.276 --> 02:03:38.377
OPPOSITION OF 26 11, YOU MAY
02:03:38.444 --> 02:03:42.748
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. WE HAVE
02:03:42.815 --> 02:03:44.350
NO COMMENT INTO IT. THANK YOU,
02:03:44.416 --> 02:03:45.117
MODERATOR. LET'S NOT BRING THE
02:03:45.184 --> 02:03:47.052
MATTER BACK TO THE HEARING ROOM.
02:03:47.119 --> 02:03:48.053
ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
02:03:48.120 --> 02:03:50.856
CONCERNS FROM MY COLLEAGUES. AND
02:03:50.923 --> 02:03:53.859
MOVED BY SENATOR LEYVA SAYING.
02:03:53.926 --> 02:03:56.328
SENATOR PANDYA QUESTION? NO JUST
02:03:56.395 --> 02:03:57.863
JUST BRIEFLY. I WANT TO THANK
02:03:57.930 --> 02:03:59.231
SENATOR DAILY BRINGING THIS BILL
02:03:59.298 --> 02:04:00.166
FORWARD. I WAS THE PREVIOUS
02:04:00.232 --> 02:04:02.268
AFTER THE OF A DIFFERENT VERSION
02:04:02.334 --> 02:04:03.769
OF THE BILL AND GRATEFUL THAT
02:04:03.836 --> 02:04:05.404
HE'S CONTINUED TO BRING MOVING.
02:04:05.471 --> 02:04:06.172
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, DOCTOR PAN
02:04:06.238 --> 02:04:08.307
. THANK YOU, SENATOR PAN. NO
02:04:08.374 --> 02:04:09.308
OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
02:04:09.375 --> 02:04:12.411
CONCERNS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:04:12.478 --> 02:04:15.447
DAILY. WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE?
02:04:15.514 --> 02:04:17.149
I APPRECIATE DR PANTS, COMMENTS
02:04:17.216 --> 02:04:18.851
AND RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I
02:04:18.918 --> 02:04:22.822
VOTE. OKAY THE BILL HAS BEEN
02:04:22.888 --> 02:04:24.056
MOVED BY SENATOR LEVIN. THE
02:04:24.123 --> 02:04:25.558
MOTION IS DUE PASS TO THE SENATE
02:04:25.624 --> 02:04:27.026
FLOOR. THIS. PLEASE CALL THE
02:04:27.092 --> 02:04:31.597
ROLL. MAYBE 26 11 MOTIONS DO
02:04:31.664 --> 02:04:33.866
PASS TO THE SENATE FLOOR. ROTH
02:04:33.933 --> 02:04:36.802
ROTH. I, MELINDA'S, UM, DAILY.
02:04:36.869 --> 02:04:40.706
WHO'S THIS DAILY? AYE. MELINDA'S
02:04:40.773 --> 02:04:43.676
AYE, ARCHULETTA BATES SIDE
02:04:43.742 --> 02:04:45.444
BECKER BECKER. I DODD. GOD, I
02:04:45.511 --> 02:04:48.714
EGGMAN. EDMUND. I HURTADO.
02:04:48.781 --> 02:04:53.953
JONES. LEVER. BELIEVE THAT I'M
02:04:54.019 --> 02:04:58.057
IN WHEN I NEWMAN PETROVO PETROVO
02:04:58.123 --> 02:05:02.628
GUY PUT. HE HAS 11 VOTES WILL
02:05:02.695 --> 02:05:03.762
HOLD THEM OUT MATTER OPEN FOR
02:05:03.829 --> 02:05:05.731
OPEN MATTER OPEN FOR ABSENT
02:05:05.798 --> 02:05:11.971
MEMBERS. THANKS OKAY? YES.
02:05:12.037 --> 02:05:20.579
WAITING FOR AUTHORS.
02:05:20.646 --> 02:05:21.981
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CALDERON ITEM
02:05:22.047 --> 02:05:23.983
NUMBER 14 ASSEMBLY BUILT 26 26,
02:05:24.049 --> 02:05:33.158
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN READY. THANK
02:05:33.225 --> 02:05:39.064
YOU, MR CHAIR. A B 26 26 WILL
02:05:39.131 --> 02:05:39.965
PROHIBIT PROHIBIT PROFESSIONAL
02:05:40.032 --> 02:05:43.068
BOARDS IN CALIFORNIA. FROM
02:05:43.135 --> 02:05:44.536
REVOKING OR SUSPENDING THE
02:05:44.603 --> 02:05:45.738
LICENSE OF A MEDICAL
02:05:45.804 --> 02:05:48.107
PROFESSIONAL FOR PROVIDING SAFE
02:05:48.173 --> 02:05:49.275
AND LEGAL ABORTION CARE TO
02:05:49.341 --> 02:05:50.576
PATIENTS IN CALIFORNIA OR IN
02:05:50.643 --> 02:05:54.113
OTHER STATES. WITH 26 STATES
02:05:54.179 --> 02:05:55.848
ACTIVELY SEEKING TO BAN ABORTION
02:05:55.915 --> 02:05:57.383
AND IN ANTICIPATION OF THE
02:05:57.449 --> 02:06:00.352
POSSIBLE OVERTURN OF ROE V. WADE
02:06:00.419 --> 02:06:02.488
MANY STATES ARE OFFERING
02:06:02.554 --> 02:06:03.722
PROFESSIONAL BOARDS TO TAKE
02:06:03.789 --> 02:06:04.290
DISCIPLINARY ACTION AGAINST
02:06:04.356 --> 02:06:07.559
ABORTION PROVIDERS. AS A
02:06:07.626 --> 02:06:09.495
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM STATE,
02:06:09.561 --> 02:06:11.997
CALIFORNIA IS LIKELY TO BE A
02:06:12.064 --> 02:06:13.966
DESTINATION FOR MILLIONS OF OUT
02:06:14.033 --> 02:06:14.867
OF STATE. PREGNANT PEOPLE
02:06:14.934 --> 02:06:16.502
SEEKING ABORTION CARE THAT THEY
02:06:16.568 --> 02:06:21.206
CANNOT GET IN THEIR OWN STATE. A
02:06:21.273 --> 02:06:23.776
B 26 26 IS ONE OF THE
02:06:23.842 --> 02:06:25.477
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE PRIORITIES
02:06:25.544 --> 02:06:27.279
OF THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE
02:06:27.346 --> 02:06:29.348
WOMEN'S CAUCUS AND A LEGISLATIVE
02:06:29.415 --> 02:06:30.416
PRIORITY OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:06:30.482 --> 02:06:32.184
COMMISSION ON THE STATUS OF
02:06:32.251 --> 02:06:34.086
WOMEN AND GIRLS. WITH ME IN
02:06:34.153 --> 02:06:37.957
SUPPORT OF A B 26 26 IS DR
02:06:38.023 --> 02:06:40.225
DANIEL GROSSMAN, A PROFESSOR OF
02:06:40.292 --> 02:06:41.627
OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY AT THE
02:06:41.694 --> 02:06:44.563
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA. SAN
02:06:44.630 --> 02:06:46.398
FRANCISCO, WHERE HE DIRECTS A
02:06:46.465 --> 02:06:47.466
RESEARCH PROGRAM CALLED
02:06:47.533 --> 02:06:48.467
ADVANCING NEW STANDARDS AND
02:06:48.534 --> 02:06:49.735
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH. GROSSMAN
02:06:49.802 --> 02:06:53.672
WELCOME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:06:53.739 --> 02:06:54.840
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:06:54.907 --> 02:06:56.575
SPEAK AS A PRACTICING
02:06:56.642 --> 02:06:58.210
OBSTETRICIAN GYNECOLOGIST. I'VE
02:06:58.277 --> 02:06:59.778
LIVED AND WORKED IN LATIN
02:06:59.845 --> 02:07:01.747
AMERICA AND SUBSEQUENT AFRICA
02:07:01.814 --> 02:07:03.282
AND COUNTRIES WHERE ABORTION IS
02:07:03.349 --> 02:07:04.650
ILLEGAL OR HIGHLY RESTRICTED.
02:07:04.717 --> 02:07:07.353
AND I'VE SEEN FIRST HAND IN
02:07:07.419 --> 02:07:08.721
THESE CONTEXTS HOW PEOPLE OFTEN
02:07:08.787 --> 02:07:10.589
TURN TO UNSAFE PRACTICES TO
02:07:10.656 --> 02:07:12.491
TERMINATE THEIR PREGNANCIES. AND
02:07:12.558 --> 02:07:13.993
I'VE SEEN HOW PREGNANT PEOPLE
02:07:14.059 --> 02:07:14.827
SUFFER THE CONSEQUENCES OF
02:07:14.893 --> 02:07:16.328
UNSAFE ABORTION. SOMETIMES WITH
02:07:16.395 --> 02:07:18.964
THEIR LIVES. I NEVER THOUGHT THE
02:07:19.031 --> 02:07:20.165
DAY WOULD COME WHEN I WOULD SEE
02:07:20.232 --> 02:07:22.468
THAT HAPPEN HERE. IN A STATE IN
02:07:22.534 --> 02:07:23.669
THE US WHEN ABORTION WOULD BE
02:07:23.736 --> 02:07:25.204
ILLEGAL. BUT THAT'S HAPPENED IN
02:07:25.270 --> 02:07:27.272
TEXAS AND OKLAHOMA NOW AND IF
02:07:27.339 --> 02:07:28.574
THE LEAKED RULING FROM THE
02:07:28.640 --> 02:07:30.275
SUPREME COURT IN THE DOBBS
02:07:30.342 --> 02:07:31.410
VERSUS JACKSON WOMEN'S HEALTH
02:07:31.477 --> 02:07:32.277
ORGANIZATION CASE IS ANY
02:07:32.344 --> 02:07:34.913
INDICATION, IT SEEMS THAT ROE
02:07:34.980 --> 02:07:35.848
VERSUS WADE WILL SOON BE
02:07:35.914 --> 02:07:37.449
OVERTURNED, LEADING TO SEVERE
02:07:37.516 --> 02:07:39.151
RESTRICTIONS IN ABOUT HALF THE
02:07:39.218 --> 02:07:40.953
STATES. AS A REPRODUCTIVE
02:07:41.020 --> 02:07:42.621
FREEDOM STATE. WE HAVE A
02:07:42.688 --> 02:07:44.056
RESPONSIBILITY HERE IN
02:07:44.123 --> 02:07:45.624
CALIFORNIA TO BE PART OF THE
02:07:45.691 --> 02:07:47.159
SOLUTION, AND THAT'S A
02:07:47.226 --> 02:07:48.861
RESPONSIBILITY THAT MY
02:07:48.927 --> 02:07:50.062
COLLEAGUES AND MYSELF TAKE VERY
02:07:50.129 --> 02:07:54.466
SERIOUSLY. WE CANNOT SIT BY IDLY
02:07:54.533 --> 02:07:56.201
AS WE SEE PEOPLE'S RIGHTS TAKEN
02:07:56.268 --> 02:07:57.469
AWAY IN OTHER STATES, PUTTING
02:07:57.536 --> 02:07:59.271
THEIR HEALTH AT RISK WHEN WE
02:07:59.338 --> 02:08:01.006
HAVE THE SKILLS AND TOOLS HERE
02:08:01.073 --> 02:08:03.509
TO HELP THEM. SO IF A PATIENT IN
02:08:03.575 --> 02:08:05.277
A STATE WITH SEVERE RESTRICTIONS
02:08:05.344 --> 02:08:07.046
SEEKS OUT MY HELP TO ATTEND SAFE
02:08:07.112 --> 02:08:08.080
ABORTION CARE. I WOULD FEEL
02:08:08.147 --> 02:08:10.349
COMPELLED TO HELP THEM. UM THEY
02:08:10.416 --> 02:08:11.884
MAY, FOR EXAMPLE, TRAVEL HERE TO
02:08:11.950 --> 02:08:14.086
OBTAIN CARE HERE. THEY MAKE COME
02:08:14.153 --> 02:08:15.821
HERE TO OBTAIN MEDICATIONS TO
02:08:15.888 --> 02:08:16.955
START THE ABORTION AND THEN GO
02:08:17.022 --> 02:08:18.724
BACK TO THEIR HOME STATE. OR
02:08:18.791 --> 02:08:20.426
THEY MAY SEEK OUT TELEHEALTH
02:08:20.492 --> 02:08:21.927
SERVICES TO OBTAIN A MEDICATION
02:08:21.994 --> 02:08:23.228
ABORTION FROM A CALIFORNIA
02:08:23.295 --> 02:08:25.264
PROVIDER. ALL OF THESE SERVICES
02:08:25.330 --> 02:08:26.198
ARE SAFE, EFFECTIVE AND
02:08:26.265 --> 02:08:27.166
CONSISTENT WITH MEDICAL
02:08:27.232 --> 02:08:30.069
STANDARDS OF CARE. THEIR LEGAL
02:08:30.135 --> 02:08:31.537
FOR CALIFORNIA PATIENTS AND
02:08:31.603 --> 02:08:33.138
SHOULD BE AVAILABLE TO OUT OF
02:08:33.205 --> 02:08:34.306
STATE RESIDENTS AS WELL,
02:08:34.373 --> 02:08:35.407
ESPECIALLY THOSE FACING BARRIERS
02:08:35.474 --> 02:08:37.476
IN THE STATES WHERE THEY LIVE.
02:08:37.543 --> 02:08:38.710
IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER THAT
02:08:38.777 --> 02:08:39.912
THE MAJORITY OF PATIENTS WHO ARE
02:08:39.978 --> 02:08:41.880
SEEKING ABORTION CARE ARE BLACK
02:08:41.947 --> 02:08:42.681
, INDIGENOUS OR OTHER PEOPLE OF
02:08:42.748 --> 02:08:44.683
COLOR AND 3/4 ARE LIVING AT OR
02:08:44.750 --> 02:08:46.318
BELOW 200% OF THE FEDERAL
02:08:46.385 --> 02:08:48.020
POVERTY LEVEL. THESE ARE THE
02:08:48.087 --> 02:08:49.721
PEOPLE WHO WILL BE MOST GRAVELY
02:08:49.788 --> 02:08:50.889
AFFECTED BY THE ABORTION BANS IN
02:08:50.956 --> 02:08:53.725
OTHER STATES. DESPITE MY GOOD
02:08:53.792 --> 02:08:55.094
INTENTIONS TO HELP PEOPLE
02:08:55.160 --> 02:08:56.595
NEEDING ABORTION CARE IN OTHER
02:08:56.662 --> 02:08:58.097
STATES, I UNDERSTAND THAT I
02:08:58.163 --> 02:08:59.698
WOULD FACE A NUMBER OF LEGAL
02:08:59.765 --> 02:09:01.200
RISKS BY PROVIDING THE CARE THAT
02:09:01.266 --> 02:09:03.502
I'VE OUTLINED TO A PATIENT FROM
02:09:03.569 --> 02:09:05.304
A STATE THAT IS BANNED ABORTION,
02:09:05.370 --> 02:09:06.572
INCLUDING BOTH CIVIL AND
02:09:06.638 --> 02:09:07.906
CRIMINAL PENALTIES, AS WELL AS
02:09:07.973 --> 02:09:08.974
THE POSSIBILITY OF LOSING MY
02:09:09.041 --> 02:09:11.977
MEDICAL LICENSE. A B 26 26 WOULD
02:09:12.044 --> 02:09:13.078
HELP TO ADDRESS THIS LAST
02:09:13.145 --> 02:09:14.746
CONCERN BY ENSURING THAT MY
02:09:14.813 --> 02:09:16.115
MEDICAL LICENSE WOULD NOT BE
02:09:16.181 --> 02:09:17.182
SUSPENDED OR REVOKED SIMPLY
02:09:17.249 --> 02:09:18.617
BECAUSE I PROVIDE ABORTION CARE
02:09:18.684 --> 02:09:20.285
THAT IS OTHERWISE LEGAL AND SAFE
02:09:20.352 --> 02:09:23.489
HERE IN CALIFORNIA. WE MUST
02:09:23.555 --> 02:09:25.324
STAND FIRM AGAINST THE CHILLING
02:09:25.390 --> 02:09:27.126
EFFECT THAT THESE RESTRICTIVE
02:09:27.192 --> 02:09:29.495
LAWS WILL HAVE AND STATE CLEARLY
02:09:29.561 --> 02:09:30.996
THAT A CALIFORNIA CLINICIAN WHO
02:09:31.063 --> 02:09:32.097
PROVIDES SAFE ABORTION CARE THAT
02:09:32.164 --> 02:09:33.899
IS LEGAL HERE. WILL NOT BE
02:09:33.966 --> 02:09:36.034
PUNISHED EVEN IF THE PATIENT IS
02:09:36.101 --> 02:09:37.469
A RESIDENT OF A STATE WITH
02:09:37.536 --> 02:09:38.003
SEVERE RESTRICTIONS. A KEY
02:09:38.070 --> 02:09:39.872
COMPONENT OF THIS PROTECTION IS
02:09:39.938 --> 02:09:40.672
SAFEGUARDING OUR MEDICAL
02:09:40.739 --> 02:09:43.375
LICENSES. I URGE YOU TO SUPPORT
02:09:43.442 --> 02:09:49.081
A B 26 26. THANK YOU. LET'S NOW
02:09:49.148 --> 02:09:50.983
MOVE TO ANY ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
02:09:51.049 --> 02:09:51.984
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM IN
02:09:52.050 --> 02:09:55.954
SUPPORT. ANY WITNESSES. SEEING
02:09:56.021 --> 02:09:56.855
NONE. LET'S MOVE TO WITNESSES
02:09:56.922 --> 02:09:58.557
WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
02:09:58.624 --> 02:09:59.491
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE AND
02:09:59.558 --> 02:10:00.592
SUPPORT MODERATOR. IF YOU WOULD
02:10:00.659 --> 02:10:02.461
PLEASE PROMPT. ANY INDIVIDUALS
02:10:02.528 --> 02:10:04.229
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
02:10:04.296 --> 02:10:05.697
OF ASSEMBLY BILL 26 26. WE WILL
02:10:05.764 --> 02:10:10.102
BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK YOU, MR
02:10:10.169 --> 02:10:11.870
CHAIR, AND LADIES AND GENTLEMEN
02:10:11.937 --> 02:10:13.105
, IF YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
02:10:13.172 --> 02:10:14.806
SUPPORT OF A B 26 26 MAY PRESS
02:10:14.873 --> 02:10:17.876
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:10:17.943 --> 02:10:19.978
ONCE AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO
02:10:20.045 --> 02:10:22.247
COMMENT AND SUPPORT OF A B 26 26
02:10:22.314 --> 02:10:25.350
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. LINE 2
02:10:25.417 --> 02:10:27.319
34. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:10:27.386 --> 02:10:31.089
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. JUSTIN
02:10:31.156 --> 02:10:32.858
ROUSER, DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR THE
02:10:32.925 --> 02:10:34.960
OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL. ROB
02:10:35.027 --> 02:10:35.827
BONTA, CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
02:10:35.894 --> 02:10:36.862
JUSTICE SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:10:36.929 --> 02:10:42.234
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. APPLYING
02:10:42.301 --> 02:10:44.102
TO 64. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE
02:10:44.169 --> 02:10:47.839
GO AHEAD. ISABELLA ORQUERA ON
02:10:47.906 --> 02:10:49.274
BEHALF OF NEAR APPROACH
02:10:49.341 --> 02:10:50.742
CALIFORNIA AND THE CALIFORNIA
02:10:50.809 --> 02:10:51.877
NEAR SAN WIFE. DESTINATION AND
02:10:51.944 --> 02:10:53.478
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:10:53.545 --> 02:10:57.616
NEXT, PLEASE. BLAME TO 62. YOUR
02:10:57.683 --> 02:11:00.619
LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:11:00.686 --> 02:11:02.287
GOOD AFTERNOON, CHAIRMAN AND
02:11:02.354 --> 02:11:03.121
MEMBERS. DENNIS CLOSE PALMETTO
02:11:03.188 --> 02:11:04.223
WITH THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
02:11:04.289 --> 02:11:05.090
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT THANK
02:11:05.157 --> 02:11:09.394
YOU NEXT, PLEASE. WE HAVE NO
02:11:09.461 --> 02:11:10.629
FURTHER COMMENTS AND SUPPORT OF
02:11:10.696 --> 02:11:13.632
A B 26 26. THANK YOU, MODERATOR
02:11:13.699 --> 02:11:14.967
. LET'S NOW FOLLOW THE SAME
02:11:15.033 --> 02:11:16.068
PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
02:11:16.134 --> 02:11:17.369
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION, MOVING
02:11:17.436 --> 02:11:18.637
TO WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION HERE
02:11:18.704 --> 02:11:20.405
IN THE HEARING ROOM, PLEASE STEP
02:11:20.472 --> 02:11:21.974
UP. NAME AFFILIATION AND
02:11:22.040 --> 02:11:23.141
POSITION ON THE MEASURE.
02:11:23.208 --> 02:11:24.610
APOLOGIES I'M ACTUALLY HERE IN
02:11:24.676 --> 02:11:26.211
SUPPORT GENESIS GONZALEZ ON
02:11:26.278 --> 02:11:27.512
BEHALF OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR.
02:11:27.579 --> 02:11:29.081
ELENI KALLAKIS IN SUPPORT. THANK
02:11:29.147 --> 02:11:32.251
YOU. THANK YOU FOR COMING. ANY
02:11:32.317 --> 02:11:33.785
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
02:11:33.852 --> 02:11:35.454
HEARING ROOM, SEEING NONE. LET'S
02:11:35.520 --> 02:11:37.823
NOW MOVE TO WITNESSES WAITING TO
02:11:37.889 --> 02:11:39.124
TESTIFY THE OTHER TELECONFERENCE
02:11:39.191 --> 02:11:40.359
SERVICE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
02:11:40.425 --> 02:11:42.127
MEASURE, MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD
02:11:42.194 --> 02:11:43.495
PLEASE PROMPT ANY SUCH
02:11:43.562 --> 02:11:45.197
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:11:45.264 --> 02:11:46.331
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL
02:11:46.398 --> 02:11:51.370
26 26. WILL CONTINUE WITH THEM.
02:11:51.436 --> 02:11:52.804
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND LADIES
02:11:52.871 --> 02:11:55.007
AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO
02:11:55.073 --> 02:11:56.174
COMMENT AND OPPOSITION OF A B 26
02:11:56.241 --> 02:11:58.210
26 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
02:11:58.277 --> 02:12:00.746
ZERO AT THIS TIME. AGAIN IF YOU
02:12:00.812 --> 02:12:02.948
WISH TO COME AND OPPOSITION OF A
02:12:03.015 --> 02:12:08.587
B 26 26 PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
02:12:08.654 --> 02:12:10.055
WE HAVE NO COMMENTS IN THE QS
02:12:10.122 --> 02:12:11.556
EXCHANGE. THANK YOU, MODERATOR.
02:12:11.623 --> 02:12:11.990
NOW, LET'S BRING THE
02:12:12.057 --> 02:12:13.058
CONVERSATION BACK TO MY
02:12:13.125 --> 02:12:14.526
COLLEAGUES HERE. IN THE HEARING
02:12:14.593 --> 02:12:15.927
ROOM. COLLEAGUES COMMENTS,
02:12:15.994 --> 02:12:16.762
QUESTIONS CONCERNS, STARTING
02:12:16.828 --> 02:12:20.399
WITH SENATOR MEN. I'D JUST LIKE
02:12:20.465 --> 02:12:22.434
TO ASK TO BE A CO AUTHOR. THE
02:12:22.501 --> 02:12:24.002
APPROPRIATE TIME. THANK YOU.
02:12:24.069 --> 02:12:25.504
OKAY ANY OTHER COMMENTS?
02:12:25.570 --> 02:12:26.638
QUESTIONS YOUR CONCERNS, SENATOR
02:12:26.705 --> 02:12:29.474
NEWMAN. THANK YOU, THE AUTHOR. I
02:12:29.541 --> 02:12:31.476
WOULD ALSO LIKE TO BE ADDED AS A
02:12:31.543 --> 02:12:32.711
CO AUTHOR. IF AND WHEN THAT'S
02:12:32.778 --> 02:12:33.945
POSSIBLE. THANK YOU. CENTER
02:12:34.012 --> 02:12:35.881
MELINDA'S THANK YOU SO MUCH, MR
02:12:35.947 --> 02:12:38.583
CHAIRMAN, ASSEMBLYWOMAN, SO YOUR
02:12:38.650 --> 02:12:42.220
CONCERN IS THAT SOME DISCIPLINE
02:12:42.287 --> 02:12:43.855
RING IT. SOME DISCIPLINARY
02:12:43.922 --> 02:12:45.223
ACTION MIGHT BE TAKEN AGAINST
02:12:45.290 --> 02:12:46.792
CALIFORNIA PROVIDERS IN LIGHT OF
02:12:46.858 --> 02:12:48.960
WHAT'S HAPPENED IN OTHER STATES,
02:12:49.027 --> 02:12:49.961
WHERE THERE'S DUAL LICENSURE.
02:12:50.028 --> 02:12:52.497
RIGHT? OKAY, SO TYPICALLY, UM,
02:12:52.564 --> 02:12:55.334
THE STATE LICENSING BOARD WOULD
02:12:55.400 --> 02:13:00.972
NOT. TAKE ANY ACTION UNLESS
02:13:01.039 --> 02:13:02.708
SOMETHING WAS DONE NOT IN
02:13:02.774 --> 02:13:04.509
ACCORDANCE WITH CALIFORNIA LAW,
02:13:04.576 --> 02:13:06.345
AND I'M TRYING TO UNDERSTAND
02:13:06.411 --> 02:13:08.480
WHAT CIRCUMSTANCE ONE WHO IS
02:13:08.547 --> 02:13:10.849
DUAL LICENSED, MIGHT BE ACTING
02:13:10.916 --> 02:13:12.584
NOT IN ACCORDANCE WITH
02:13:12.651 --> 02:13:14.486
CALIFORNIA LAW BECAUSE ABORTION
02:13:14.553 --> 02:13:16.088
IS LEGAL IN CALIFORNIA AND WILL
02:13:16.154 --> 02:13:18.990
REMAIN SO. SO IN WHAT
02:13:19.057 --> 02:13:20.225
CIRCUMSTANCES MIGHT THAT TAKE
02:13:20.292 --> 02:13:22.527
PLACE? SO I'M GOING TO ASK DR
02:13:22.594 --> 02:13:24.363
GROSSMAN TO COME UP? UM BECAUSE
02:13:24.429 --> 02:13:26.131
I THINK YOU CLOSER TO THAT
02:13:26.198 --> 02:13:29.201
SITUATION WOULD BE THANK YOU.
02:13:29.267 --> 02:13:35.240
MAY I PROCEED? YES PLEASE. THANK
02:13:35.307 --> 02:13:38.610
YOU. UM SO IT MAY ALSO BE A
02:13:38.677 --> 02:13:40.312
SITUATION WHERE SOMEONE IN'T
02:13:40.379 --> 02:13:40.979
DUAL LICENSED. SO, FOR EXAMPLE,
02:13:41.046 --> 02:13:42.647
A PATIENT MAY TRAVEL HERE TO
02:13:42.714 --> 02:13:43.815
CALIFORNIA AND IT IS POSSIBLE
02:13:43.882 --> 02:13:46.084
THAT SOMEONE IN, FOR EXAMPLE,
02:13:46.151 --> 02:13:48.854
TEXAS COULD STILL BRING A CIVIL
02:13:48.920 --> 02:13:51.056
CLAIM. UNDER THE SB EIGHT LAW,
02:13:51.123 --> 02:13:53.859
THE BILL THAT ALLOWS ESSENTIALLY
02:13:53.925 --> 02:13:55.994
ANYBODY TO SUE ANYBODY WHO HAS
02:13:56.061 --> 02:13:57.329
PROVIDED AN ABORTION OR AIDED OR
02:13:57.396 --> 02:14:00.365
ABETTED AND ABORTION. AND AS
02:14:00.432 --> 02:14:02.033
PART OF THAT COULD ALSO BRING A
02:14:02.100 --> 02:14:03.268
COMPLAINT TO THE MEDICAL BOARD.
02:14:03.335 --> 02:14:05.437
UM, AND THAT COMPLAINT. COULD
02:14:05.504 --> 02:14:07.472
POTENTIALLY BE INVESTIGATED AND
02:14:07.539 --> 02:14:09.875
SANCTIONS COULD BE TAKEN. OKAY
02:14:09.941 --> 02:14:11.143
SO ARE YOU SUGGESTING THAT THE
02:14:11.209 --> 02:14:13.612
STATE LICENSING BOARD WOULD TAKE
02:14:13.678 --> 02:14:15.180
ACTION ON SOMETHING LIKE THAT,
02:14:15.247 --> 02:14:17.215
GIVEN THE POSTURE THAT THE STATE
02:14:17.282 --> 02:14:18.283
OF CALIFORNIA HAS TAKEN ON
02:14:18.350 --> 02:14:20.852
ABORTION RATES? IS THAT LIKELY?
02:14:20.919 --> 02:14:22.954
I DON'T KNOW HOW LIKELY IT IS,
02:14:23.021 --> 02:14:24.423
BUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT THAT
02:14:24.489 --> 02:14:25.957
THERE IS A CHILLING EFFECT
02:14:26.024 --> 02:14:27.492
ALREADY HAPPENING THAT THAT, UM
02:14:27.559 --> 02:14:28.660
THAT PROVIDERS HERE IN
02:14:28.727 --> 02:14:29.861
CALIFORNIA DON'T KNOW IF THEY
02:14:29.928 --> 02:14:31.963
COULD SUB BE SUBJECT TO THESE.
02:14:32.030 --> 02:14:33.498
THESE LAWS THAT HAVE ALREADY
02:14:33.565 --> 02:14:35.033
BEEN PASSED N TEXAS AND IN
02:14:35.100 --> 02:14:37.135
OKLAHOMA AND ARE LIKELY TO PASS
02:14:37.202 --> 02:14:38.670
IN OTHER TATES WITH THE FALL OF
02:14:38.737 --> 02:14:40.605
ROW AND THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT
02:14:40.672 --> 02:14:42.641
CIVIL OR CRIMINAL PENALTIES THEY
02:14:42.707 --> 02:14:43.942
MAY BE SUBJECT TO, AS WELL AS
02:14:44.009 --> 02:14:45.744
WHAT SANCTIONS MAY BE TAKEN
02:14:45.811 --> 02:14:46.678
AGAINST THEIR LICENSE. AND IT'S
02:14:46.745 --> 02:14:48.747
I THINK IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE BE
02:14:48.814 --> 02:14:50.282
VERY CLEAR HERE IN CALIFORNIA
02:14:50.348 --> 02:14:51.516
THAT THEY ARE PROTECTED FROM
02:14:51.583 --> 02:14:53.251
THOSE KINDS OF THE EXTRA
02:14:53.318 --> 02:14:54.953
TERRITORIAL REACH OF THOSE OTHER
02:14:55.020 --> 02:14:56.688
STATES. THANK YOU, DOCTOR FOR
02:14:56.755 --> 02:14:58.190
YOUR COMMENTS. I APPRECIATE
02:14:58.256 --> 02:15:00.091
THAT. SO I WILL JUST SAY THAT I
02:15:00.158 --> 02:15:06.832
AM I DON'T I DON'T SEE. WHERE
02:15:06.898 --> 02:15:08.900
THIS WOULD EVER BE NECESSARY TO
02:15:08.967 --> 02:15:10.035
BE PERFECTLY HONEST WITH YOU
02:15:10.101 --> 02:15:11.937
BECAUSE CALIFORNIA HAS MADE IT
02:15:12.003 --> 02:15:12.971
VERY CLEAR. THE STATE
02:15:13.038 --> 02:15:14.573
LEGISLATURE IS MADE VERY CLEAR
02:15:14.639 --> 02:15:15.841
WHERE THEY STAND ON ABORTION
02:15:15.907 --> 02:15:16.808
RIGHTS THAT IS UNLIKELY TO
02:15:16.875 --> 02:15:19.211
CHANGE EVEN IF THE SUPREME COURT
02:15:19.277 --> 02:15:21.112
WERE TO OVERTURN ROE V. WADE AND
02:15:21.179 --> 02:15:21.947
PUSH IT BACK TO THE STATES,
02:15:22.013 --> 02:15:24.115
WHICH IS WHAT WOULD ACTUALLY
02:15:24.182 --> 02:15:26.117
HAPPEN THEN IT'S UNLIKELY THAT
02:15:26.184 --> 02:15:27.118
CALIFORNIA WOULD CHANGE ITS
02:15:27.185 --> 02:15:30.522
POSTURE ON THAT. SO SOMEONE
02:15:30.589 --> 02:15:32.190
COMING HERE FROM ANOTHER STATE
02:15:32.257 --> 02:15:36.194
WOULD BE SUBJECT TO THE LIES
02:15:36.261 --> 02:15:38.096
THAT ARE HERE IN CALIFORNIA. UM
02:15:38.163 --> 02:15:40.899
SO I JUST I DON'T SEE WHERE THIS
02:15:40.966 --> 02:15:44.469
THIS BILL WHATEVER. BE NECESSARY
02:15:44.536 --> 02:15:46.972
TO BE PERFECTLY BUT THANK YOU
02:15:47.038 --> 02:15:48.573
FOR YOUR WITNESS'S TESTIMONY AND
02:15:48.640 --> 02:15:49.708
FOR YOUR ASSISTANCE IN
02:15:49.774 --> 02:15:53.411
CLARIFYING QUÊ MOVE THE BILL.
02:15:53.478 --> 02:15:57.015
THANK YOU, DOCTOR PEN. THANK YOU
02:15:57.082 --> 02:15:59.451
AND CALDERON APPRECIATE YOU
02:15:59.518 --> 02:16:01.486
BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD. I
02:16:01.553 --> 02:16:03.455
TOO AM A PHYSICIAN AND ONE OF
02:16:03.522 --> 02:16:05.490
THE THINGS THAT PROBABLY I
02:16:05.557 --> 02:16:07.492
REALLY THOUGHT ABOUT SO, UM, I
02:16:07.559 --> 02:16:09.494
DON'T KNOW IF PEOPLE ARE AWARE
02:16:09.561 --> 02:16:12.998
IF YOU ARE SANCTIONED YOU'RE
02:16:13.064 --> 02:16:13.565
SANCTIONED IN ANY WAY YOUR
02:16:13.632 --> 02:16:15.033
MEDICAL STAFF TAKES AWAY TO
02:16:15.100 --> 02:16:18.336
PRIVILEGES. A MEDICAL BOARD GOES
02:16:18.403 --> 02:16:20.438
AND TAKES AWAY AND PUTS YOU ON
02:16:20.505 --> 02:16:22.841
PROBATION. THE LICENSE. YOU ARE
02:16:22.908 --> 02:16:26.011
PROSECUTED FOR A CRIME. UM THAT
02:16:26.077 --> 02:16:27.045
GOES INTO THINGS LIKE THE
02:16:27.112 --> 02:16:28.880
NATIONAL PRACTITIONER DATABANK.
02:16:28.947 --> 02:16:31.249
UM WE ACTUALLY HAVE PASSED LAWS
02:16:31.316 --> 02:16:32.017
HERE, SAYING THAT THAT
02:16:32.083 --> 02:16:34.419
INFORMATION NOW NEEDS TO BE
02:16:34.486 --> 02:16:35.420
DISSEMINATED TO THE MEDICAL
02:16:35.487 --> 02:16:36.955
BOARD AND OTHER ENTITIES. SO
02:16:37.022 --> 02:16:38.990
THAT WE CAN ALL BE AWARE THAT
02:16:39.057 --> 02:16:40.091
THAT POSITION HAS NOW BEEN
02:16:40.158 --> 02:16:43.962
SANCTIONED. SO WE'VE SO NOW I
02:16:44.029 --> 02:16:45.463
DON'T THINK WHEN WE PASS THOSE
02:16:45.530 --> 02:16:46.765
LAWS WE WERE THINKING ABOUT THE
02:16:46.831 --> 02:16:47.966
SITUATION THAT WE'RE CONFRONTING
02:16:48.033 --> 02:16:50.936
HERE. AND SO I THINK THE
02:16:51.002 --> 02:16:52.938
CHALLENGE IS, IS THAT WELL, WE
02:16:53.004 --> 02:16:54.339
CAN RAISE THE QUESTION WHETHER
02:16:54.406 --> 02:16:56.241
WE THINK THE MEDICAL BOARD OF
02:16:56.308 --> 02:16:57.208
CALIFORNIA WHATEVER SANCTION A
02:16:57.275 --> 02:17:00.679
PHYSICIAN WHO PERFORMED AN
02:17:00.745 --> 02:17:02.380
ABORTION, BUT CERTAINLY THEY
02:17:02.447 --> 02:17:03.615
WOULD HAVE ON THE RECORD
02:17:03.682 --> 02:17:05.283
POTENTIALLY THAT THEY WERE
02:17:05.350 --> 02:17:06.384
PROSECUTED AND MAYBE EVEN FOUND
02:17:06.451 --> 02:17:08.987
GUILTY. OF A CRIME IN ANOTHER
02:17:09.054 --> 02:17:11.222
STATE THAT WOULD CERTAINLY BE
02:17:11.289 --> 02:17:11.790
INTERNATIONAL PRACTITIONER
02:17:11.856 --> 02:17:15.093
DATABANK THAT COULD BE USED AS A
02:17:15.160 --> 02:17:17.395
REASON, DEPENDING ON THE MEDICAL
02:17:17.462 --> 02:17:18.630
BOARD. AND WHO'S YOU KNOW,
02:17:18.697 --> 02:17:19.831
RUNNING THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA?
02:17:19.898 --> 02:17:21.199
EVEN IF THERE WASN'T A WELL
02:17:21.266 --> 02:17:24.002
POLITICAL WILL TO ACTUALLY UM,
02:17:24.069 --> 02:17:25.537
REMOVE ABORTION RIGHTS HERE IN
02:17:25.604 --> 02:17:27.072
THE STATE TO ACTUALLY GO AFTER
02:17:27.138 --> 02:17:29.474
PHYSICIANS WHO MAY HAVE HAD
02:17:29.541 --> 02:17:31.509
PROVIDED PERFORMED AS ABORTIONS
02:17:31.576 --> 02:17:35.046
. SO UM, WELL, WELL MAY SEEM TO
02:17:35.113 --> 02:17:37.248
BE A LITTLE WHILE SOME MAY THINK
02:17:37.315 --> 02:17:38.383
IT'S A LITTLE FAR FETCHED.
02:17:38.450 --> 02:17:40.986
ACTUALLY ANYONE WHO'S HIS
02:17:41.052 --> 02:17:42.153
ACTUALLY FAMILIAR WITH THE
02:17:42.220 --> 02:17:43.655
VARIOUS REPORTING SYSTEMS ARE IN
02:17:43.722 --> 02:17:45.357
PLACE THAT ACTUALLY, YOU KNOW,
02:17:45.423 --> 02:17:47.158
WE PUT IN PLACE TO PROTECT
02:17:47.225 --> 02:17:48.093
PATIENT SAFETY. YOU KNOW, WE'VE
02:17:48.159 --> 02:17:49.961
PASSED LAWS HERE, EVEN COMING
02:17:50.028 --> 02:17:51.029
RIGHT THROUGH THIS COMMITTEE,
02:17:51.096 --> 02:17:52.230
SAYING THAT IF THE PHYSICIAN YOU
02:17:52.297 --> 02:17:54.065
KNOW, COMMITTED SOME, YOU KNOW,
02:17:54.132 --> 02:17:56.034
HAS SOME SANCTIONS THAT THAT
02:17:56.101 --> 02:17:57.168
INFORMATION NEEDS TO BE SPREAD
02:17:57.235 --> 02:17:59.337
AROUND THAT. ESSENTIALLY, WE'RE
02:17:59.404 --> 02:18:00.472
GONNA SEE PHYSICIANS WHO ARE
02:18:00.538 --> 02:18:01.573
SANCTIONED IN OTHER STATES FOR
02:18:01.640 --> 02:18:05.110
PERFORMING ABORTIONS. OR EVEN
02:18:05.176 --> 02:18:06.711
MAKING THEMSELVES OPEN TO DO
02:18:06.778 --> 02:18:08.513
THAT, AND THEN DEPENDING ON WHAT
02:18:08.580 --> 02:18:09.914
LAWS OTHER STATES PASSED, AND WE
02:18:09.981 --> 02:18:10.915
HAVE RECIPROCATED, YOU KNOW,
02:18:10.982 --> 02:18:12.717
REPRESENT PROSPERITY, ISSUES AND
02:18:12.784 --> 02:18:15.220
SO FORTH AS WELL AS OF THEIR
02:18:15.286 --> 02:18:16.688
SANCTIONS. AND YOU KNOW, THE
02:18:16.755 --> 02:18:18.590
STATE OF TEXAS THAT INFORMATION
02:18:18.657 --> 02:18:19.624
GETS SENT TO THE STATE OF
02:18:19.691 --> 02:18:20.759
CALIFORNIA TO THE MEDICAL BOARD,
02:18:20.825 --> 02:18:22.994
ETCETERA. AND SO I THINK THERE
02:18:23.061 --> 02:18:23.895
IS SOME THERE IS CONCERN AND
02:18:23.962 --> 02:18:26.631
THAT TO HAVE A LAW IN PLACE OR
02:18:26.698 --> 02:18:28.199
THE LIKE THIS. WHAT'S BEING
02:18:28.266 --> 02:18:31.136
PROPOSED HERE IS TO SAY THAT
02:18:31.202 --> 02:18:32.170
UNFORTUNATELY, UNDER THIS, THIS
02:18:32.237 --> 02:18:33.171
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT LOOKS LIKE
02:18:33.238 --> 02:18:35.273
WE'RE FACING THAT A PHYSICIAN
02:18:35.340 --> 02:18:38.543
SHOULD NOT BE PUNISHED. FOR
02:18:38.610 --> 02:18:40.078
ACTUALLY PERFORMING, YOU KNOW,
02:18:40.145 --> 02:18:41.780
PRACTICING THE STANDARD OF CARE
02:18:41.846 --> 02:18:43.081
. THAT'S THE STANDARD OF CARE
02:18:43.148 --> 02:18:43.748
HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED BY MEDICAL
02:18:43.815 --> 02:18:45.417
PROFESSIONAL SOCIETIES. UH AND
02:18:45.483 --> 02:18:49.421
THAT BY AND JUST BECAUSE SOME
02:18:49.487 --> 02:18:51.056
STATES HAVE DECIDED TO
02:18:51.122 --> 02:18:52.991
CRIMINALIZE IT. THAT PHYSICIANS
02:18:53.058 --> 02:18:54.859
CERTAINLY SHOULD NOT BE, UH, PUT
02:18:54.926 --> 02:18:57.062
AT RISK IN THIS STATEFOR
02:18:57.128 --> 02:18:57.696
ESSENTIALLY PROVIDING ESSENTIAL
02:18:57.762 --> 02:19:00.231
HEALTH CARE. THANK YOU. AND
02:19:00.298 --> 02:19:01.599
CERTAINLY PEOPLE EARNING FOR
02:19:01.666 --> 02:19:05.437
THIS BILL. THANK YOU, SENATOR
02:19:05.503 --> 02:19:07.305
PAN. ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? COME
02:19:07.372 --> 02:19:08.606
AND SEE OUR CONCERNS COLLEAGUES.
02:19:08.673 --> 02:19:10.341
I'LL JUST SAY THIS. I'M
02:19:10.408 --> 02:19:11.476
CERTAINLY I CERTAINLY APPRECIATE
02:19:11.543 --> 02:19:13.211
THE VALUE OF PROPHYLACTIC
02:19:13.278 --> 02:19:14.212
MEASURES, WHICH I VIEW THIS TO
02:19:14.279 --> 02:19:18.583
BE. THERE'S CERTAINLY SOME
02:19:18.650 --> 02:19:19.551
INTERESTING LEGAL QUESTIONS. I
02:19:19.617 --> 02:19:20.752
DON'T KNOW THAT I'M A LAWYER
02:19:20.819 --> 02:19:23.988
ANYMORE. BUT SEEMS TO ME THAT IF
02:19:24.055 --> 02:19:25.056
ALL THE ACTS OCCURRED IN
02:19:25.123 --> 02:19:27.225
CALIFORNIA, BY A CALIFORNIA
02:19:27.292 --> 02:19:31.996
LAWYER QUESTION. THE MEAN BY
02:19:32.063 --> 02:19:32.630
CALIFORNIA DOCTOR THINKS SENATOR
02:19:32.697 --> 02:19:35.667
MAN I QUESTIONED THE
02:19:35.734 --> 02:19:36.801
APPLICABILITY OF TEXAS LAW ON
02:19:36.868 --> 02:19:40.105
ANYTHING. AND IF THERE'S SOME
02:19:40.171 --> 02:19:41.706
ACTS THAT DID OCCUR IN TEXAS, I
02:19:41.773 --> 02:19:43.541
COULD CERTAINLY SEE THE BASIS
02:19:43.608 --> 02:19:44.709
FOR A CIVIL CLAIM OR CRIMINAL
02:19:44.776 --> 02:19:47.712
JURISDICTION. BUT NOT IF ALL THE
02:19:47.779 --> 02:19:49.981
ACTS OCCURRED IN CALIFORNIA BY
02:19:50.048 --> 02:19:52.117
CALIFORNIA PHYSICIAN ON THE
02:19:52.183 --> 02:19:54.152
OTHER HAND, I GUESS IF WE
02:19:54.219 --> 02:19:55.019
PROVIDE IMMUNITY HERE FOR X THAT
02:19:55.086 --> 02:19:57.689
ARE CONDUCTED BY CALIFORNIA
02:19:57.756 --> 02:20:01.726
PHYSICIANS IN THE. MAIN ACTIONS
02:20:01.793 --> 02:20:03.528
. MAIN ACTION IS IN TEXAS. I
02:20:03.595 --> 02:20:06.297
QUESTION THE EFFICACY OF THE
02:20:06.364 --> 02:20:07.932
IMMUNITY PROVISIONS. BUT I'M
02:20:07.999 --> 02:20:09.300
GOING TO SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY
02:20:09.367 --> 02:20:11.469
. AND IF IT MAKES FOLKS FEEL
02:20:11.536 --> 02:20:12.804
BETTER, I DO THINK THAT THE
02:20:12.871 --> 02:20:13.905
PHYSICIAN GROUPS SHOULD PROBABLY
02:20:13.972 --> 02:20:15.707
SEEK OUT A LEGAL OPINION. AS TO
02:20:15.774 --> 02:20:16.908
THE NATURE AND EXTENT IN THIS
02:20:16.975 --> 02:20:18.977
FULL SCOPE OF BY THE
02:20:19.043 --> 02:20:20.111
CONSEQUENCES OF THEIR ACTIONS
02:20:20.178 --> 02:20:22.614
HERE IN CALIFORNIA AS CALIFORNIA
02:20:22.680 --> 02:20:23.681
PHYSICS PHYSICIANS PROVIDED THAT
02:20:23.748 --> 02:20:25.617
THE ACCENT ALL OCCUR. INSIDE THE
02:20:25.683 --> 02:20:26.684
BORDERS OF THE STATE OF
02:20:26.751 --> 02:20:31.022
CALIFORNIA.HAVING SAID ALL THAT
02:20:31.089 --> 02:20:31.790
WE DO HAVE EMOTION. SOME
02:20:31.856 --> 02:20:33.491
REMEMBER CAULDRON WOULD YOU LIKE
02:20:33.558 --> 02:20:37.028
TO CLOSE? YES THANK YOU, SENATOR
02:20:37.095 --> 02:20:38.797
. FIRST OF ALL, I'D LIKE TO
02:20:38.863 --> 02:20:40.698
THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTIONS AND
02:20:40.765 --> 02:20:43.134
ALSO DEFINITELY WOULD LOVE TO
02:20:43.201 --> 02:20:44.903
HAVE THE CO AUTHORS. I
02:20:44.969 --> 02:20:47.071
APPRECIATE THAT. I APPRECIATE
02:20:47.138 --> 02:20:48.273
APPRECIATEYOUR QUESTION,
02:20:48.339 --> 02:20:50.208
SENATOR MELENDEZ, THANK YOU, AND
02:20:50.275 --> 02:20:52.644
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
02:20:52.710 --> 02:20:54.212
OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION. IT'S BEEN
02:20:54.279 --> 02:20:55.947
MOVED BY SENATOR EDMUND. THE
02:20:56.014 --> 02:20:57.115
MOTION IS DUE PASS REFER THE
02:20:57.182 --> 02:20:58.983
COMMITTEE ON HEALTH. PLEASE CALL
02:20:59.050 --> 02:21:02.253
THE ROLL. 26 26 MOTION IS DO
02:21:02.320 --> 02:21:02.954
PASS AND REFERRED TO THE
02:21:03.021 --> 02:21:05.957
COMMITTEE ON HEALTH BROTH,
02:21:06.024 --> 02:21:06.457
MELINDA'S MELINDA'S NO
02:21:06.524 --> 02:21:09.761
ARCHULETTA. BATES BATES SNOW,
02:21:09.828 --> 02:21:13.198
BECKER. TUCKER. I DODD. DODD.
02:21:13.264 --> 02:21:17.468
AYE, EGGMAN. POTATO. JONES.
02:21:17.535 --> 02:21:23.241
LABOR. THAT I'M IN. MOMENT I
02:21:23.308 --> 02:21:28.913
NEWMAN PHð BOG. CAN CAN I THE
02:21:28.980 --> 02:21:34.519
BILL HAS. SEVEN I VOTES AND TWO
02:21:34.586 --> 02:21:36.554
NO VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLE AND
02:21:36.621 --> 02:21:42.894
PERHAPS SOME MEMBERS. THANK YOU.
02:21:42.961 --> 02:21:46.164
SIMILAR MEMBER BARK. OH, MR
02:21:46.231 --> 02:21:49.767
HOLDEN OVER THERE. I REMEMBER
02:21:49.834 --> 02:21:56.307
HOLDING DIDN'T MEAN TO SKIP YOU.
02:21:56.374 --> 02:21:58.376
THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 16 ASSEMBLY
02:21:58.443 --> 02:22:00.311
BILL 2723, PLEASE PROCEED WHEN
02:22:00.378 --> 02:22:08.786
READY, SIR. THANK YOU, MR
02:22:08.853 --> 02:22:10.288
CHAIRMAN AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS
02:22:10.355 --> 02:22:12.523
TODAY I'M PRESENTING ASSEMBLY
02:22:12.590 --> 02:22:15.360
BILL 27 73 A BILL THAT SEEKS TO
02:22:15.426 --> 02:22:16.661
UPDATE OUR STATE'S INSUFFICIENT
02:22:16.728 --> 02:22:21.366
PET MICROCHIPPING LAWS. MAYBE 27
02:22:21.432 --> 02:22:23.601
23 UPDATES, PET ADOPTION AND
02:22:23.668 --> 02:22:25.136
MICRO TRIP STANDARDS BY BAR
02:22:25.203 --> 02:22:27.438
BORING ALL SHELTERS AND RESCUE
02:22:27.505 --> 02:22:29.674
GROUPS FROM BEING PLACED AS THE
02:22:29.741 --> 02:22:31.242
PRIMARY CONTACTS ON A MICROCHIP
02:22:31.309 --> 02:22:35.380
IN PLACED IN A PET. MAYBE 27 23
02:22:35.446 --> 02:22:37.515
WILL ALSO REQUIRE GOING FORWARD
02:22:37.582 --> 02:22:39.517
THAT ALL PUBLIC SHELTERS AND
02:22:39.584 --> 02:22:40.618
RESCUE GROUPS PROVIDE PET
02:22:40.685 --> 02:22:43.187
ADOPTERS THE PROPER RESOURCES TO
02:22:43.254 --> 02:22:44.255
IN PLACE THEMSELVES AS THE
02:22:44.322 --> 02:22:45.423
PRIMARY CONTACT. ON THEIR PET
02:22:45.490 --> 02:22:49.394
MICROCHIP. THESE MEASURES ARE
02:22:49.460 --> 02:22:50.962
CRITICAL TO ENSURING THAT EVERY
02:22:51.029 --> 02:22:52.430
NEWLY ADOPTED PET BE
02:22:52.497 --> 02:22:54.399
MICROCHIPPED BY INFORMATION, IF
02:22:54.465 --> 02:22:56.267
REFLECTIVE OF THEIR TRUE OWNER
02:22:56.334 --> 02:22:58.636
RATHER THAN THE INFO. OF THE
02:22:58.703 --> 02:23:00.638
SHELTER OR RESCUE GROUP, WHICH
02:23:00.705 --> 02:23:02.006
MERELY HELD THEM UNTIL THEY WERE
02:23:02.073 --> 02:23:06.210
FOUND THEIR NEW HOME. THE BILL
02:23:06.277 --> 02:23:08.146
WAS ALSO STANDARDIZED, IMPORTANT
02:23:08.212 --> 02:23:10.114
CUSTODIAL DUE DILIGENCE FOR ALL
02:23:10.181 --> 02:23:12.250
PET ADOPTIONS, SHELTERS AND
02:23:12.317 --> 02:23:14.052
RESCUE GROUPS WILL BE REQUIRED
02:23:14.118 --> 02:23:15.019
TO MEET THE STANDARDS HAVE
02:23:15.086 --> 02:23:16.120
ALREADY GOOD ACTING
02:23:16.187 --> 02:23:17.088
ORGANIZATIONS BY DOCUMENTING THE
02:23:17.155 --> 02:23:19.757
PROOF. AND RATIONALE THAT LEADS
02:23:19.824 --> 02:23:22.593
TO A RECLAIMED PETS RELEASE FOR
02:23:22.660 --> 02:23:23.928
THE SAKE OF GOOD BOOKKEEPING AND
02:23:23.995 --> 02:23:27.765
ACCOUNTABILITY. WITH ME TODAY ON
02:23:27.832 --> 02:23:29.267
THE LINE TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
02:23:29.334 --> 02:23:32.971
OF A B 27 23 IS CHIARA TOLLINI,
02:23:33.037 --> 02:23:34.672
A CONSTITUENT OF MINE FROM
02:23:34.739 --> 02:23:37.442
PASADENA. AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
02:23:37.508 --> 02:23:38.910
FOR YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU, SIR.
02:23:38.977 --> 02:23:43.781
MR. LENNY, PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
02:23:43.848 --> 02:23:45.316
MORNING, SHERROD. HONORABLE
02:23:45.383 --> 02:23:46.851
MEMBERS. IT IS AN HONOR TO SPEAK
02:23:46.918 --> 02:23:48.786
TO YOU TODAY. MY NAME IS CHIARA
02:23:48.853 --> 02:23:49.754
TOLLINI. I LISTED
02:23:49.821 --> 02:23:51.155
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLDINGSUPPORT
02:23:51.222 --> 02:23:52.957
FOR ABBY TO 7 TO 3 TO PREVENT
02:23:53.024 --> 02:23:55.893
THE THEFT OF DOGS AND CATS. MANY
02:23:55.960 --> 02:23:57.161
PET OWNERS. I LOST MY DOG AND
02:23:57.228 --> 02:23:58.963
DID EVERYTHING POSSIBLE TO GET
02:23:59.030 --> 02:24:00.198
HER BACK. THE RESCUE THAT I
02:24:00.264 --> 02:24:01.566
BOUGHT HER FROM THOUGHT THAT MY
02:24:01.632 --> 02:24:03.067
DOG GETTING OUT ONE TIME THAT I
02:24:03.134 --> 02:24:04.736
WAS UNFIT TO KEEP THIS PART OF
02:24:04.802 --> 02:24:06.838
MY FAMILY. I TRIED TO DO MY PART
02:24:06.904 --> 02:24:07.905
TO REDUCE EUTHANASIA BY GETTING
02:24:07.972 --> 02:24:09.707
A DOG FROM A SHELTER INSTEAD OF
02:24:09.774 --> 02:24:11.643
A BREEDER. AFTER MEETING NEARLY
02:24:11.709 --> 02:24:13.311
$60. THEY FOUND THE RIGHT MATCH
02:24:13.378 --> 02:24:15.013
AT A LOCAL RESCUE. I PURCHASED
02:24:15.079 --> 02:24:16.581
THE ONE YEAR OLD PITBULL THAT I
02:24:16.647 --> 02:24:18.783
NAMED AKIRA TO SEE RECEIVED HER
02:24:18.850 --> 02:24:20.485
SEAT, SIGNED A CONTRACT. AND
02:24:20.551 --> 02:24:21.586
WHAT ABOUT INTEGRATING THE CARRY
02:24:21.652 --> 02:24:22.854
INTO MY WORLD? IT WAS A
02:24:22.920 --> 02:24:24.422
RESPONSIBLE OWNER WHO VACCINATED
02:24:24.489 --> 02:24:26.357
TRAINS THAT SOCIALIZED AND
02:24:26.424 --> 02:24:28.526
EXERCISE. MY DOG DAILY. CAROL
02:24:28.593 --> 02:24:30.061
WAS A MEMBER OF MY FAMILY FOR
02:24:30.128 --> 02:24:32.296
ALMOST FOUR YEARS AND NO SALT
02:24:32.363 --> 02:24:33.531
AMOUNT ABLE TO ESCAPE MY YARD.
02:24:33.598 --> 02:24:35.333
FIRST THE PERSON WHO FOUND THE
02:24:35.400 --> 02:24:36.667
CARE OF CALLED THE REST. AND I
02:24:36.734 --> 02:24:38.069
NOTIFIED THEM WITH WITHIN A
02:24:38.136 --> 02:24:40.171
COUPLE OF HOURS OF OUR ESCAPE A
02:24:40.238 --> 02:24:41.239
LONG, COSTLY A VERY PUBLIC
02:24:41.305 --> 02:24:43.241
SEARCH OVER SEVERAL MONTHS, AND
02:24:43.307 --> 02:24:44.142
ULTIMATELY I HAVE NO CLUE TO HER
02:24:44.208 --> 02:24:45.943
WHEREABOUTS. IT WAS TWO YEARS
02:24:46.010 --> 02:24:48.246
LATER. WHEN I WAS NOTED BY THE
02:24:48.312 --> 02:24:49.580
VIQUEIRA WAS STILL ALIVE.
02:24:49.647 --> 02:24:51.382
IDENTITY UNCOVERED THE FACT THAT
02:24:51.449 --> 02:24:52.750
THE RESCUE I PURCHASED HER FROM
02:24:52.817 --> 02:24:54.786
HAD HIDDEN HER THIS ENTIRE TIME.
02:24:54.852 --> 02:24:55.720
HENRY HUNGER THROUGH A SECOND
02:24:55.787 --> 02:24:57.722
RESCUE. I TRIED TO NEGOTIATE THE
02:24:57.789 --> 02:24:59.457
RETURN OF MY DOG THROUGH ALL
02:24:59.524 --> 02:25:01.025
THREE PARTIES, INCLUDING THE NEW
02:25:01.092 --> 02:25:02.260
ADOPTERS. AFTER THE REJECTION OF
02:25:02.326 --> 02:25:03.761
ALL OFFERS, I WAS FORCED TO
02:25:03.828 --> 02:25:05.229
ENGAGE IN EXTREMELY EXPENSIVE,
02:25:05.296 --> 02:25:06.364
LENGTHY AND STRESSFUL CIVIL
02:25:06.431 --> 02:25:07.665
LAWSUIT TO PROVE NOT ONLY THAT I
02:25:07.732 --> 02:25:10.668
WAS THE OWNER OF MY DOG. THAT I
02:25:10.735 --> 02:25:11.836
WAS NEVER GOING TO GIVE UP ON
02:25:11.903 --> 02:25:13.671
RECOVERING HER. THE RESCUE WAS
02:25:13.738 --> 02:25:15.740
ABLE TO STEAL MY DOG BECAUSE THE
02:25:15.807 --> 02:25:16.941
OWNER OF THE RESCUE, NEVER
02:25:17.008 --> 02:25:18.042
RELINQUISHED THE FIRST POSITION
02:25:18.109 --> 02:25:19.010
ON THE MICROCHIPS, INSTEAD
02:25:19.077 --> 02:25:19.977
DECEIVING BOTH MYSELF AND THE
02:25:20.044 --> 02:25:21.446
MICROCHIP COMPANY OF WHO
02:25:21.512 --> 02:25:22.313
ACTUALLY OWNED UP. CARS
02:25:22.380 --> 02:25:27.051
REPRESENT. THIRD NOTICE AND AN
02:25:27.118 --> 02:25:27.685
OPPORTUNITY ROOM MEDIATE
02:25:27.752 --> 02:25:29.220
CHALLENGE TAKEN FROM THE HOME.
02:25:29.287 --> 02:25:30.721
THERE'S A LEGAL PROCESS FOR THE
02:25:30.788 --> 02:25:31.823
PARENT OR GUARDIAN TO BE HEARD,
02:25:31.889 --> 02:25:33.724
EDUCATED AND WORK TO REGAIN
02:25:33.791 --> 02:25:35.159
CUSTODY. ANIMAL CONTROL HAS BEEN
02:25:35.226 --> 02:25:37.228
CAPPED SEASON CUT TO OUR LOST,
02:25:37.295 --> 02:25:38.463
NEGLECTED, ABUSED OR DANGEROUS.
02:25:38.529 --> 02:25:39.931
AND CERTAIN LEGAL STANDARDS
02:25:39.997 --> 02:25:41.833
BEFORE SEIZING AN ANIMAL. THERE
02:25:41.899 --> 02:25:44.035
SHOULD NOT VARY BY THE TYPE OF
02:25:44.102 --> 02:25:44.702
ORGANIZATIONS SEEKING TO FULFILL
02:25:44.769 --> 02:25:46.804
A SIMILAR ROLE IN PRIVATE
02:25:46.871 --> 02:25:48.272
RESCUES. RECLAIM ANIMALS THAT
02:25:48.339 --> 02:25:49.607
ARE PUBLIC ANIMAL CONTROL WOULD
02:25:49.674 --> 02:25:51.309
NOT HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO CEASE.
02:25:51.375 --> 02:25:53.044
THEY ARE YOU SERVING THE
02:25:53.111 --> 02:25:54.145
AUTHORITY OF THE LEGISLATURE HAS
02:25:54.212 --> 02:25:55.213
INTERESTED, TOO. PUBLIC ANIMAL
02:25:55.279 --> 02:25:57.148
CONTROL OFFICIALS. MAKING
02:25:57.215 --> 02:25:58.583
OWNERSHIP CLEAR BY REFLECTING
02:25:58.649 --> 02:26:00.785
THE REAL OWNER OF THE DOG OR CAT
02:26:00.852 --> 02:26:02.186
ON THE MICROCHIP CAN ALLEVIATE
02:26:02.253 --> 02:26:03.387
THE PAIN AND AGONY PEOPLE GO
02:26:03.454 --> 02:26:04.522
THROUGH WHEN THEY CAN'T RECOVER
02:26:04.589 --> 02:26:07.258
THEIR ANIMALS DUE TO BAD ACTORS.
02:26:07.325 --> 02:26:08.659
PROPERTY HUMBLE THE TITLE, BUT
02:26:08.726 --> 02:26:10.928
NOT OUR DOGS ARE CAPPED, AND
02:26:10.995 --> 02:26:11.796
BOTH ARE FINANCIAL AND EMOTIONAL
02:26:11.863 --> 02:26:13.998
INVESTMENT IN THEM. IT IS
02:26:14.065 --> 02:26:14.832
UNACCEPTABLE THAT AT ANY POINT
02:26:14.899 --> 02:26:16.234
SOMEONE ELSE CAN CLAIM OWNERSHIP
02:26:16.300 --> 02:26:17.869
OF THEM IMPOSE THEIR OWN
02:26:17.935 --> 02:26:19.070
JUDGMENT AND ARBITRARY STANDARDS
02:26:19.137 --> 02:26:20.805
WITHOUT ANY REDRESS WHATSOEVER.
02:26:20.872 --> 02:26:22.573
SPEAKING TO YOU TODAY BECAUSE
02:26:22.640 --> 02:26:24.142
MOST PEOPLE DON'T HAVE THE MEANS
02:26:24.208 --> 02:26:25.576
OR THE CONSTITUTION TO FIGHT FOR
02:26:25.643 --> 02:26:26.978
THEIR PETS IN SITUATIONS LIKE
02:26:27.044 --> 02:26:28.646
MINE JUST TAKE OF THOSE LIKE ME
02:26:28.713 --> 02:26:30.114
AND FOR INNOCENT ANIMALS TURNED
02:26:30.181 --> 02:26:32.116
FAMILY MEMBERS. I URGE YOU TO
02:26:32.183 --> 02:26:33.284
PLEASE VOTE. YES, ON A B 2723.
02:26:33.351 --> 02:26:36.320
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MA'AM. NOW
02:26:36.387 --> 02:26:37.455
LET'S TURN TO ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
02:26:37.522 --> 02:26:38.523
WITNESSES HERE IN THE HEARING
02:26:38.589 --> 02:26:41.025
ROOM. SAYING NONE LET'S MOVE TO
02:26:41.092 --> 02:26:41.926
WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
02:26:41.993 --> 02:26:42.727
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE AND
02:26:42.793 --> 02:26:43.794
SUPPORT MODERATOR. IF YOU WOULD
02:26:43.861 --> 02:26:46.898
PLEASE PROMPT ANY SUCH
02:26:46.964 --> 02:26:48.166
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:26:48.232 --> 02:26:49.834
AND SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY BILL 27
02:26:49.901 --> 02:26:54.305
23. WE WILL BEGIN WITH THEM.
02:26:54.372 --> 02:26:55.973
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND LADIES
02:26:56.040 --> 02:26:57.942
AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO
02:26:58.009 --> 02:26:59.810
COMMENT AND SUPPORT OF MAYBE 27
02:26:59.877 --> 02:27:01.112
23 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
02:27:01.179 --> 02:27:04.482
ZERO AT THIS TIME. ONCE AGAIN IF
02:27:04.549 --> 02:27:06.584
YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND SUPPORT
02:27:06.651 --> 02:27:07.885
OF A B 27 23 YOU MAY PRESS ONE
02:27:07.952 --> 02:27:12.156
AND THEN ZERO. WE HAVE NO
02:27:12.223 --> 02:27:13.791
COMMENTS IN CUBA AT THIS TIME.
02:27:13.858 --> 02:27:14.725
THANK YOU, MODERATOR. LET'S
02:27:14.792 --> 02:27:16.194
FOLLOW THE SAME PROCESS AND HEAR
02:27:16.260 --> 02:27:17.361
FROM ANY WITNESSES AND
02:27:17.428 --> 02:27:18.629
OPPOSITION FIRST OPPOSITION
02:27:18.696 --> 02:27:20.932
WITNESSES IN THE HEARING ROOM.
02:27:20.998 --> 02:27:22.166
SAYING NONE. LET'S MOVE TO
02:27:22.233 --> 02:27:23.000
WITNESSES WAITING, TESTIFYING
02:27:23.067 --> 02:27:23.935
OPPOSITION VIA TELECONFERENCE
02:27:24.001 --> 02:27:27.238
SERVICE MODERATOR ONCE AGAIN, IF
02:27:27.305 --> 02:27:29.140
YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT ANY SUCH
02:27:29.207 --> 02:27:30.208
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:27:30.274 --> 02:27:32.276
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL
02:27:32.343 --> 02:27:33.578
27 23 WILL. WE WILL CONTINUE
02:27:33.644 --> 02:27:38.249
WITH THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR,
02:27:38.316 --> 02:27:39.517
AND LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
02:27:39.584 --> 02:27:41.552
WISH TO COMMENT IN OPPOSITION OF
02:27:41.619 --> 02:27:43.588
27 23 MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
02:27:43.654 --> 02:27:46.557
ZERO AT THIS TIME. WORKED AGAIN
02:27:46.624 --> 02:27:47.725
IF YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
02:27:47.792 --> 02:27:49.727
OPPOSITION OF A B 27 23 MAY
02:27:49.794 --> 02:27:54.799
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. WE HAVE
02:27:54.865 --> 02:27:56.667
NO COMMENT ON THE CUE. THANK
02:27:56.734 --> 02:27:57.668
YOU, MODERATOR, BRINGING THE
02:27:57.735 --> 02:27:59.203
MATTER BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES
02:27:59.270 --> 02:28:00.271
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM,
02:28:00.338 --> 02:28:01.205
COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS, COMMENTS
02:28:01.272 --> 02:28:01.739
OR CONCERNS. BEEN MOVED BY
02:28:01.806 --> 02:28:06.043
SENATOR LABO. WITH THE COMMON.
02:28:06.110 --> 02:28:08.112
SENATOR MAN, MR HOLDEN. DON'T
02:28:08.179 --> 02:28:10.147
THANK YOU ON BEHALF OF FOUR OF
02:28:10.214 --> 02:28:13.150
MY CONSTITUENTS. HOMER WALLY,
02:28:13.217 --> 02:28:14.485
HUGO AND SIMON FOR RESCUE
02:28:14.552 --> 02:28:16.787
CHIHUAHUAS LIVE IN MY HOUSE, ALL
02:28:16.854 --> 02:28:18.222
MICROCHIPS, SO THANK YOU FOR
02:28:18.289 --> 02:28:18.889
BRINGING THIS. I CAN ONLY
02:28:18.956 --> 02:28:22.393
IMAGINE THE PAIN AND THE HASSLE.
02:28:22.460 --> 02:28:23.661
THAT YOUR CONSTITUENT WENT
02:28:23.728 --> 02:28:26.197
THROUGH AND SO GLAD TO SUPPORT
02:28:26.264 --> 02:28:26.964
THE BILL LOVE BEAT ANALYST AND
02:28:27.031 --> 02:28:28.799
CO AUTHOR IF ONLY TO IMPRESS MY
02:28:28.866 --> 02:28:30.868
WIFE. WHEN I COME HOME THIS
02:28:30.935 --> 02:28:31.969
WEEK, I'VE DONE SOMETHING GOOD,
02:28:32.036 --> 02:28:34.538
BUT DONE DEAL. THANKS FOR DOING
02:28:34.605 --> 02:28:36.941
THIS BY. THANK YOU. BYE. THANK
02:28:37.008 --> 02:28:40.311
YOU. HIM ON THE PHONE, THE OTHER
02:28:40.378 --> 02:28:41.712
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS AND CONCERNS
02:28:41.779 --> 02:28:43.714
COLLEAGUES SAYING THAT THE BILL
02:28:43.781 --> 02:28:46.150
HAS BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR LATER
02:28:46.217 --> 02:28:47.451
THE MOVE. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
02:28:47.518 --> 02:28:49.320
TO THE SENATE FOR PLEASE CALL
02:28:49.387 --> 02:28:52.223
THE ROLL. MAYBE 27 23 MOTIONS DO
02:28:52.290 --> 02:28:54.692
PASS TO THE SENATE FLOOR BROTH.
02:28:54.759 --> 02:28:55.926
MELINDA'S MELINDA'S, AYE
02:28:55.993 --> 02:28:59.764
ARCHULETTA BATES BECKER. DONE
02:28:59.830 --> 02:29:06.604
DOT I EGGMAN. POTATO. JONES.
02:29:06.671 --> 02:29:09.106
LEYVA LABOR. I'M IN AN EYE
02:29:09.173 --> 02:29:12.076
NEWMAN PHOTOVOGUE TRAVELED I PAN
02:29:12.143 --> 02:29:15.913
AND I BILL HAS NINE VOTES WILL
02:29:15.980 --> 02:29:16.914
HOLD THE MATTER OPEN FOR ABSENT
02:29:16.981 --> 02:29:26.324
MEMBERS. THANK YOU, SIR.
02:29:26.390 --> 02:29:27.725
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ER I DON'T
02:29:27.792 --> 02:29:31.662
REMEMBER 17 ASSEMBLY BUILT 2754.
02:29:31.729 --> 02:29:34.065
PROCEED WHEN READY. THANK YOU,
02:29:34.131 --> 02:29:36.267
MR CHAIR AND SENATORS TODAY I'M
02:29:36.334 --> 02:29:38.736
PRESENTING A B 27 54 A BILL THAT
02:29:38.803 --> 02:29:40.071
ENSURES THAT TRAINEES IN THE
02:29:40.137 --> 02:29:41.572
FIELD OF PSYCHOLOGY RECEIVED
02:29:41.639 --> 02:29:43.708
NECESSARY TRAINING IN A SAFE AND
02:29:43.774 --> 02:29:44.575
TIMELY MANNER BY EXTENDING
02:29:44.642 --> 02:29:45.743
SUPERVISION, TRAININGS TO AUDIO
02:29:45.810 --> 02:29:46.777
AND HIPAA COMPLIANT
02:29:46.844 --> 02:29:49.680
VIDEOCONFERENCING. CALIFORNIA'S
02:29:49.747 --> 02:29:51.382
EXPERIENCING A DIRE SHORTAGE OF
02:29:51.449 --> 02:29:52.750
MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSIONALS AND
02:29:52.817 --> 02:29:54.218
GRAPPLING WITH MEETING THIS NEED
02:29:54.285 --> 02:29:55.720
, ACCORDING TO THE HEALTH FORCE
02:29:55.786 --> 02:29:57.221
CENTER. CALIFORNIA IS ON TRACK
02:29:57.288 --> 02:29:58.689
TO LOSE 41% OF ITS PSYCHIATRISTS
02:29:58.756 --> 02:30:00.291
AND 11% OF ITS PSYCHOLOGISTS IN
02:30:00.358 --> 02:30:03.928
THE NEXT DECADE. THIS IS ON TOP
02:30:03.994 --> 02:30:05.096
OF THE ALREADY EXISTING SCARCITY
02:30:05.162 --> 02:30:06.263
UNDER CURRENT LAW, PSYCHOLOGY
02:30:06.330 --> 02:30:07.998
TRAINEES IN CALIFORNIA ARE
02:30:08.065 --> 02:30:10.067
REQUIRED TO RECEIVE 3000 HOURS
02:30:10.134 --> 02:30:10.935
OF SUPERVISED PROFESSIONAL
02:30:11.001 --> 02:30:12.303
EXPERIENCE AS A CONDITION
02:30:12.370 --> 02:30:13.938
CONDITION TO RECEIVE THEIR
02:30:14.004 --> 02:30:15.973
LICENSES. AS PART OF THOSE
02:30:16.040 --> 02:30:17.007
HOURS, TRAINEES ARE REQUIRED TO
02:30:17.074 --> 02:30:18.976
BE SUPERVISED FOR 10% OF THE
02:30:19.043 --> 02:30:20.544
TOTAL TIME EACH WEEK AND HAVE AT
02:30:20.611 --> 02:30:23.314
LEAST ONE HOUR PER WEEK OF FACE
02:30:23.381 --> 02:30:24.315
TO FACE DIRECT INDIVIDUAL
02:30:24.382 --> 02:30:25.316
SUPERVISION WITH THEIR PRIMARY
02:30:25.383 --> 02:30:27.318
SUPERVISOR. DURING THE PANDEMIC
02:30:27.385 --> 02:30:29.854
SUPERVISION WAS ALLOWED TO BE
02:30:29.920 --> 02:30:31.322
DONE REMOTELY VIA HIPAA
02:30:31.389 --> 02:30:33.657
COMPLIANT VIDEO THAT HAS NOW
02:30:33.724 --> 02:30:36.794
EXPIRED. 27 54 SEEKS TO REMEDY
02:30:36.861 --> 02:30:37.828
THIS BY IMMEDIATELY CODIFYING
02:30:37.895 --> 02:30:39.029
THE FACE TO FACE SUPERVISION
02:30:39.096 --> 02:30:40.831
WAIVER. THIS WILL PRESERVE
02:30:40.898 --> 02:30:42.833
ACCESS AND CONTINUITY TO CYCLE,
02:30:42.900 --> 02:30:45.336
LOGICAL CARE AND ENSURE THAT WE
02:30:45.403 --> 02:30:46.137
HAVE PROVIDERS ABLE TO RECEIVE
02:30:46.203 --> 02:30:47.538
THEIR LICENSES AND CONTINUE TO
02:30:47.605 --> 02:30:48.939
ENTER THE PROFESSION. IN
02:30:49.006 --> 02:30:50.107
ADDITION AS THE COVID PANDEMIC
02:30:50.174 --> 02:30:52.610
CONTINUES TO BE A PROBLEM. IT
02:30:52.676 --> 02:30:54.245
WILL ALLOW PEOPLE TO HAVE THE
02:30:54.311 --> 02:30:55.613
SUPERVISION IN A SAFE MANNER IF
02:30:55.679 --> 02:30:57.248
NECESSARY WITH ME TODAY AND
02:30:57.314 --> 02:30:58.582
SUPPORT OVER THE PHONE IS
02:30:58.649 --> 02:31:00.117
COLLINS SAURUS, DIRECTOR OF
02:31:00.184 --> 02:31:01.051
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS OF THE
02:31:01.118 --> 02:31:01.552
CALIFORNIA PSYCHOLOGICAL
02:31:01.619 --> 02:31:03.988
ASSOCIATION, AND AMARA SHE'D
02:31:04.054 --> 02:31:04.955
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCATE FOR THE
02:31:05.022 --> 02:31:06.190
COUNTY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:31:06.257 --> 02:31:07.057
DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION. BOTH ARE
02:31:07.124 --> 02:31:08.592
ON THE PHONE. THANK YOU
02:31:08.659 --> 02:31:13.164
WITNESSES. PLEASE PROCEED. GOOD
02:31:13.230 --> 02:31:14.932
AFTERNOON MEMBERS. THIS IS
02:31:14.999 --> 02:31:16.133
PHONES, WHEREAS WITH THE
02:31:16.200 --> 02:31:17.168
TELEVISION PSYCHOLOGICAL
02:31:17.234 --> 02:31:19.303
ASSOCIATION, THE SPONSOR, WE
02:31:19.370 --> 02:31:20.638
ALSO LIKE TO THANK YOU AND WE
02:31:20.704 --> 02:31:21.939
WILL BARRICADE FOR WORK. IT'S
02:31:22.006 --> 02:31:23.974
IMPORTANT LEGISLATION. WE
02:31:24.041 --> 02:31:26.610
RESPONSE TO NEED TO BE 27 54 TO
02:31:26.677 --> 02:31:28.446
EXPAND ACCESS PSYCHOLOGICAL
02:31:28.512 --> 02:31:29.580
SERVICES, ALLOWING THE REMOTE
02:31:29.647 --> 02:31:31.148
SUPERVISION TRAINEES IN OUR
02:31:31.215 --> 02:31:33.951
FIELD. CARDIFF I THE WAIVER
02:31:34.018 --> 02:31:35.052
GRANTED DURING THE PANDEMIC THAT
02:31:35.119 --> 02:31:36.320
HAS PROVEN HIGHLY SUCCESSFUL. AS
02:31:36.387 --> 02:31:37.421
YOU HEARD PSYCHOLOGICAL
02:31:37.488 --> 02:31:39.390
PSYCHOLOGY TRAINEES MUST RECEIVE
02:31:39.457 --> 02:31:40.925
3000 HOURS OF SUPERVISED
02:31:40.991 --> 02:31:42.226
PROFESSIONAL EXERIENCE AS A
02:31:42.293 --> 02:31:43.561
CONDITION TO RECEIVE THEIR
02:31:43.627 --> 02:31:45.429
LICENSE WITH AT LEAST ONE HOUR
02:31:45.496 --> 02:31:47.331
EACH WEEK BEING FACE TO FACE
02:31:47.398 --> 02:31:48.766
INDIVIDUAL SUPERVISION. THAT
02:31:48.833 --> 02:31:49.934
MEANS THE TRAINEES HAVE TO
02:31:50.000 --> 02:31:51.268
SCHEDULE THEIR ENTIRE WEEK
02:31:51.335 --> 02:31:53.070
TRAVEL IN ATTENDING COSTS AROUND
02:31:53.137 --> 02:31:55.172
SINGLE HOUR DURING THE PANDEMIC
02:31:55.239 --> 02:31:56.841
EXECUTIVE ORDER ALONG THE FACE
02:31:56.907 --> 02:31:57.808
TO FACE REQUIREMENT TO BE
02:31:57.875 --> 02:31:59.076
WEIGHED, AND TRAINERS AND
02:31:59.143 --> 02:32:00.044
SUPERVISORS TOOK ADVANTAGE OF
02:32:00.110 --> 02:32:01.111
WIDELY AVAILABLE CONFERENCING
02:32:01.178 --> 02:32:04.515
TECHNOLOGY. CONTINUE THEIR
02:32:04.582 --> 02:32:05.115
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT SAFE
02:32:05.182 --> 02:32:07.651
AND SIMPLE MANNER. HOWEVER WHEN
02:32:07.718 --> 02:32:09.186
THE PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY HAS
02:32:09.253 --> 02:32:11.021
LIFTED THAT WOULD IMMEDIATELY
02:32:11.088 --> 02:32:12.656
END THE WAIVER IN ANYTHING, OF
02:32:12.723 --> 02:32:14.592
COURSE SOLUTION WOULD NOT COMING
02:32:14.658 --> 02:32:17.194
FOR MANY YEARS AT ALL. BOTH
02:32:17.261 --> 02:32:18.796
TRAINEES AND SUPERVISORS HAVE
02:32:18.863 --> 02:32:19.997
REPORTED VRTUAL SUPERVISION TO
02:32:20.064 --> 02:32:21.432
BE HIGHLY EFFECTIVE AND
02:32:21.499 --> 02:32:22.700
EFFICIENT AT A DEGREE
02:32:22.766 --> 02:32:23.968
EQUIVALENCY IN PERSON
02:32:24.034 --> 02:32:25.236
SUPERVISION. NUMEROUS BENEFITS
02:32:25.302 --> 02:32:26.070
BEYOND THOSE HAVE JUST
02:32:26.136 --> 02:32:28.072
PROTECTING PUBLIC HEALTH.
02:32:28.138 --> 02:32:29.707
SYRIANS WERE INTERACT WITH A
02:32:29.773 --> 02:32:31.408
LARGER POOL OF SUPERVISORS NO
02:32:31.475 --> 02:32:33.577
LONGER RESTRICTED BY ACCESS TO A
02:32:33.644 --> 02:32:35.479
VEHICLE OR TRANSIT TRAINEES,
02:32:35.546 --> 02:32:37.147
MOST OF THEM FACING SIGNIFICANT
02:32:37.214 --> 02:32:38.315
EDUCATIONAL LOANS AND DEBTS WERE
02:32:38.382 --> 02:32:40.484
ABLE TO SAVE MY OWN TIME ALSO
02:32:40.551 --> 02:32:41.719
RECEIVING DIRECTIVE PROVISIONS.
02:32:41.785 --> 02:32:43.320
SUPERVISORS CAN MORE READILY
02:32:43.387 --> 02:32:44.722
SCHEDULED TRAININGS FOR SESSIONS
02:32:44.788 --> 02:32:46.857
AND STREAMLINED AROUND SCHEDULED
02:32:46.924 --> 02:32:48.559
AND BOTH TRAINEES HAVE REPORTED
02:32:48.626 --> 02:32:50.227
AN INCREASE IN THE NUMBER OF
02:32:50.294 --> 02:32:51.295
PATIENTS ARE ABLE TO SERVE
02:32:51.362 --> 02:32:52.563
SUFFICIENCY. SINCE TRAINEES
02:32:52.630 --> 02:32:53.564
BOOSTER PATIENTS DURING THEIR
02:32:53.631 --> 02:32:56.567
CLINICAL TRAINING. LIKEWISE THE
02:32:56.634 --> 02:32:58.068
BORDER PSYCHOLOGY SUPPORTIVE OF
02:32:58.135 --> 02:32:59.837
THIS LEGISLATION, AND EITHER
02:32:59.904 --> 02:33:01.071
CDVA NORTH BOARD HAVE RECEIVED
02:33:01.138 --> 02:33:02.039
ANY COMPLAINTS ABOUT VIRTUAL
02:33:02.106 --> 02:33:03.874
SUPERVISION. FURTHER OUR BILL
02:33:03.941 --> 02:33:05.209
WOULD NOT OBLIGATE SUPERVISORS
02:33:05.276 --> 02:33:06.377
AND TRAINEES TO COMPLETELY
02:33:06.443 --> 02:33:08.279
ELIMINATE PLACE SUPERVISION IN
02:33:08.345 --> 02:33:09.880
THE FUTURE. IF THE TRAINING
02:33:09.947 --> 02:33:10.948
SUPERVISORS SEE THE VALUE, THEN
02:33:11.015 --> 02:33:13.617
THEY WOULD BE ABLE TO DO SO. C P
02:33:13.684 --> 02:33:14.852
A BELIEVES THAT THIS BILL IS
02:33:14.919 --> 02:33:16.020
BOOKED TIMELY AND NECESSARY TO
02:33:16.086 --> 02:33:18.222
EXPAND ACCESS TO MENTAL HEALTH
02:33:18.289 --> 02:33:19.123
SERVICES AND IMPROVE THE
02:33:19.189 --> 02:33:20.391
DELIVERY OF TRAINING TO FUTURE
02:33:20.457 --> 02:33:21.425
LICENSED PSYCHOLOGIST. THANK
02:33:21.492 --> 02:33:23.360
YOU, AND I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
02:33:23.427 --> 02:33:25.229
QUESTIONS THE COMMITTEE MAY HAVE
02:33:25.296 --> 02:33:26.363
THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT WITNESS
02:33:26.430 --> 02:33:31.335
BRIEF, PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:33:31.402 --> 02:33:33.070
SENATORS AND SHARE FOR THE
02:33:33.137 --> 02:33:34.338
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY HERE
02:33:34.405 --> 02:33:35.839
TODAY. MY NAME IS EMMA SHE
02:33:35.906 --> 02:33:37.041
REPRESENTING THE COUNTY BEHAVIOR
02:33:37.107 --> 02:33:38.409
HEALTH DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION OF
02:33:38.475 --> 02:33:41.045
CALIFORNIA. UM THE EXECUTIVE
02:33:41.111 --> 02:33:43.314
ORDER AND 39 20 WAVED FACE TO
02:33:43.380 --> 02:33:45.549
FACE THE PROVISION REQUIREMENTS.
02:33:45.616 --> 02:33:47.017
WHICH ALLOWS FOR SUPERVISION TO
02:33:47.084 --> 02:33:48.185
OCCUR VIA AUDIOTAPE COMPLIANT
02:33:48.252 --> 02:33:51.255
VIDEO CONFERENCE. AND HAPPY TO
02:33:51.322 --> 02:33:52.189
PROVIDE FAVOR GAY PRACTITIONERS
02:33:52.256 --> 02:33:54.224
THE ABILITY TO EXPAND CAPACITY
02:33:54.291 --> 02:33:55.960
AND PROTECT THEIR HEALTH ABOUT
02:33:56.026 --> 02:33:57.261
ANY NEGATIVE IMPACT ON PATIENTS
02:33:57.328 --> 02:33:59.229
, SUPERVISORS OR TRAINEES. AND
02:33:59.296 --> 02:34:00.631
ALTHOUGH THIS IS MEANT TO
02:34:00.698 --> 02:34:01.799
INITIALLY BE TEMPORARY, NUMEROUS
02:34:01.865 --> 02:34:02.866
BENEFITS OF THIS WAIVER HAVE
02:34:02.933 --> 02:34:04.401
EMERGED OVER THE PAST YEAR AND
02:34:04.468 --> 02:34:05.235
THE FLEXIBILITY PROVIDED
02:34:05.302 --> 02:34:06.570
IMPROVED SAFETY AND EXTENDED
02:34:06.637 --> 02:34:08.739
PRACTITIONERS AVAILABILITY.
02:34:08.806 --> 02:34:09.974
ADDITIONALLY THE FAITH WAVER,
02:34:10.040 --> 02:34:11.308
ALLEVIATED PUBLIC HEALTH
02:34:11.375 --> 02:34:12.876
CONSTRAINTS AND REDUCED CARS TO
02:34:12.943 --> 02:34:14.478
TRAINEES AND SUPERVISORS FOR
02:34:14.545 --> 02:34:15.913
TRAINING AND SUPERVISORS, LOSING
02:34:15.980 --> 02:34:16.947
THE ABILITY TO SPEAK IN THE
02:34:17.014 --> 02:34:18.315
SUPERVISION REMOTELY, BUT AN
02:34:18.382 --> 02:34:20.284
UNDUE BURDEN ON THEIR SAFETY AS
02:34:20.351 --> 02:34:22.119
WELL AS THEIR TIME. ADDRESSING
02:34:22.186 --> 02:34:22.853
THE CURRENT BEHAVIOR, HEALTH
02:34:22.920 --> 02:34:24.521
WORKFORCE CRISIS REQUIRES
02:34:24.588 --> 02:34:26.123
MAINTAINING AND EXPANDING
02:34:26.190 --> 02:34:28.158
TRAINING FLEXIBILITIES, NOT
02:34:28.225 --> 02:34:29.760
RESCINDING OR LIMITING THEM. FOR
02:34:29.827 --> 02:34:31.161
THESE REASONS, VÀ IS GRATEFUL.
02:34:31.228 --> 02:34:32.129
CERTAINLY ABOUT MEMBER OF
02:34:32.196 --> 02:34:34.231
BAUER-KAHAN WORK ON THIS THEY'RE
02:34:34.298 --> 02:34:36.233
SEXUALLY URGES URIBE. OH THANK
02:34:36.300 --> 02:34:37.801
YOU. THANK YOU. NOW, LET'S HEAR
02:34:37.868 --> 02:34:38.802
FROM ANY ADDITIONAL WITNESSES
02:34:38.869 --> 02:34:40.337
AND SUPPORTING HEARING ROOM.
02:34:40.404 --> 02:34:42.106
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT, SAYING
02:34:42.172 --> 02:34:43.574
NONE LET'S TURN TO WITNESSES
02:34:43.641 --> 02:34:45.376
WAITING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
02:34:45.442 --> 02:34:46.276
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
02:34:46.343 --> 02:34:48.879
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
02:34:48.946 --> 02:34:50.214
PROMPT ANY SUCH INDIVIDUALS
02:34:50.280 --> 02:34:52.016
WAITING, TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF
02:34:52.082 --> 02:34:54.385
ASSEMBLY BUILD 27 54, WE WILL
02:34:54.451 --> 02:34:58.622
BEGIN WITH THEM. THANK YOU, MR
02:34:58.689 --> 02:34:59.857
CHAIR, AND LADIES AND GENTLEMEN,
02:34:59.923 --> 02:35:01.659
IF YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
02:35:01.725 --> 02:35:03.560
SUPPORT OF 27 54 YOU MAY PRESS
02:35:03.627 --> 02:35:04.962
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:35:05.029 --> 02:35:08.932
ONCE AGAIN. WE WISH TO COMMENT
02:35:08.999 --> 02:35:11.502
AND SUPPORT OF A B 27 54. YOU
02:35:11.568 --> 02:35:13.170
MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. ONE
02:35:13.237 --> 02:35:17.574
MOMENT FOR FIRSTCOMMENT. TIME
02:35:17.641 --> 02:35:19.510
TO 68. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE
02:35:19.576 --> 02:35:23.480
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS
02:35:23.547 --> 02:35:24.548
IS JENNIFER ALI WITH THE
02:35:24.615 --> 02:35:25.249
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
02:35:25.315 --> 02:35:26.316
MARRIAGE AND FAMILY THERAPIST
02:35:26.383 --> 02:35:27.284
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU NEXT,
02:35:27.351 --> 02:35:32.856
PLEASE. LINE 3 13. YOUR LINE IS
02:35:32.923 --> 02:35:37.061
OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. JACOB CAN
02:35:37.127 --> 02:35:38.729
YOU KNOW WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:35:38.796 --> 02:35:40.330
ALLIANCE OF CHILD AND FAMILY
02:35:40.397 --> 02:35:40.931
SERVICES AND STRONG SUPPORT?
02:35:40.998 --> 02:35:43.767
THANK YOU NEXT, PLEASE. WE HAVE
02:35:43.834 --> 02:35:45.736
NO FURTHER COMMENTS IN Q AT THIS
02:35:45.803 --> 02:35:47.805
TIME. THANK YOU. NOW, LET'S
02:35:47.871 --> 02:35:50.040
FOLLOW THE SAME PROCESS AND HEAR
02:35:50.107 --> 02:35:50.941
FROM ANY WITNESSES AND
02:35:51.008 --> 02:35:51.508
OPPOSITION FIRST OPPOSITION
02:35:51.575 --> 02:35:53.010
WITNESSES IN THE HEARING ROOM.
02:35:53.077 --> 02:35:54.712
SAYING NONE LET'S TURN TO
02:35:54.778 --> 02:35:56.213
WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
02:35:56.280 --> 02:35:57.848
THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE IN
02:35:57.915 --> 02:35:59.283
OPPOSITION TO THE MEASURE.
02:35:59.349 --> 02:36:00.784
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD AGAIN,
02:36:00.851 --> 02:36:01.785
PLEASE PROMPT ANY SUCH
02:36:01.852 --> 02:36:04.388
INDIVIDUALS. WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:36:04.455 --> 02:36:05.856
IN OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL
02:36:05.923 --> 02:36:07.624
27 54. WE WILL CONTINUE WITH
02:36:07.691 --> 02:36:12.830
THEM. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, AND
02:36:12.896 --> 02:36:13.897
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
02:36:13.964 --> 02:36:15.833
WISH TO COMMENT IN OPPOSITION OF
02:36:15.899 --> 02:36:17.901
A B 27 54 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
02:36:17.968 --> 02:36:21.705
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. AGAIN IF
02:36:21.772 --> 02:36:22.940
YOU WISH TO COMMENT AND
02:36:23.006 --> 02:36:25.309
OPPOSITION OF A B 27 54 YOU MAY
02:36:25.375 --> 02:36:28.746
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. LINE 2
02:36:28.812 --> 02:36:30.748
74. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:36:30.814 --> 02:36:35.619
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, CHAIRMAN
02:36:35.686 --> 02:36:37.287
ROTH AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. THIS
02:36:37.354 --> 02:36:40.457
IS ACTUALLY IN SUPPORT. I MESSED
02:36:40.524 --> 02:36:42.626
UP ON THE QUEUE THERE. UM
02:36:42.693 --> 02:36:44.328
ANTOINETTE'S ORIC FROM THE BOARD
02:36:44.394 --> 02:36:45.763
OF PSYCHOLOGY AND SUPPORT OF
02:36:45.829 --> 02:36:47.698
THIS BILL AND APPRECIATE THE
02:36:47.765 --> 02:36:48.699
CALIFORNIA PSYCHOLOGICAL
02:36:48.766 --> 02:36:50.868
ASSOCIATION FOR SPONSORING THIS
02:36:50.934 --> 02:36:52.002
BILL AND CONTINUE WITH THE
02:36:52.069 --> 02:36:53.303
BOARDS WAIVER. THANK YOU NEXT,
02:36:53.370 --> 02:36:57.674
PLEASE. THERE ARE NO FURTHER
02:36:57.741 --> 02:37:00.878
COMMENTS IN QUÊ. THANK YOU,
02:37:00.944 --> 02:37:01.979
MODERATOR. NOW LET'S BRING THE
02:37:02.045 --> 02:37:03.814
MATTER BACK TO MY COLLEAGUES IN
02:37:03.881 --> 02:37:04.848
THE HEARING ROOM FOR QUESTIONS,
02:37:04.915 --> 02:37:05.883
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS MOVE THE
02:37:05.949 --> 02:37:09.386
BILL. UNANIMOUS MOVED. HEARD
02:37:09.453 --> 02:37:10.187
SENATOR LEYVA FIRST, BUT ANY
02:37:10.254 --> 02:37:11.488
OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
02:37:11.555 --> 02:37:15.292
CONCERNS? I SEE NONE SO
02:37:15.359 --> 02:37:16.927
REMEMBER, WOULD YOU LIKE TO
02:37:16.994 --> 02:37:18.428
CLOSE? TAKE MY FOUR MOTIONS IS A
02:37:18.495 --> 02:37:21.031
CLOSE. THANK YOU. THE BILL HAS
02:37:21.098 --> 02:37:22.766
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR LABOR. THE
02:37:22.833 --> 02:37:24.468
MOTION IS DUE PASS. REFER THE
02:37:24.535 --> 02:37:25.035
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
02:37:25.102 --> 02:37:27.137
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MAYBE 27
02:37:27.204 --> 02:37:28.705
54 MOTION IS DO PASS AND WE
02:37:28.772 --> 02:37:29.840
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:37:29.907 --> 02:37:32.176
APPROPRIATIONS RAW. BREATH I
02:37:32.242 --> 02:37:33.177
MELINDA'S MELINDA'S AYE,
02:37:33.243 --> 02:37:37.648
ARCHULETTA. BATES. BATES I
02:37:37.714 --> 02:37:42.119
BECKER DODD DODD. I SIGMUND.
02:37:42.186 --> 02:37:48.158
POTATO PIE. JONES LABOR. MY MEN
02:37:48.225 --> 02:37:50.527
, MAN. I NEWMAN KOBO. A TURBO
02:37:50.594 --> 02:37:57.234
GUY PAN. CN AYE. BILL HAS 11
02:37:57.301 --> 02:37:59.503
VOTES WILL HOLD THE MATTER OPEN
02:37:59.570 --> 02:38:00.704
FOR ANY ABSENT MEMBERS. AT THIS
02:38:00.771 --> 02:38:01.672
POINT, THANK YOU.
02:38:01.738 --> 02:38:20.557
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S.
02:39:16.947 --> 02:39:18.148
FOR MEMBERS OF THE BUSINESS
02:39:18.215 --> 02:39:19.650
PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC
02:39:19.716 --> 02:39:20.584
DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE. WE ARE
02:39:20.651 --> 02:39:22.286
GOING TO OPEN THE ROLE FOR
02:39:22.352 --> 02:39:23.720
ABSENT MEMBERS. SO IF YOU'RE NOT
02:39:23.787 --> 02:39:25.689
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM AND YOU
02:39:25.756 --> 02:39:27.157
HAVE NOT VOTED ON ALL THE
02:39:27.224 --> 02:39:28.225
MEASURES START MOVING THIS
02:39:28.292 --> 02:39:36.433
DIRECTION. LET'S OPEN THE ROLE
02:39:36.500 --> 02:39:37.567
STARTING ON WITH THE CONSENT
02:39:37.634 --> 02:39:43.874
CALENDAR. SITTING AND AFTER
02:39:43.941 --> 02:39:45.108
THIS, I DON'T KNOW IT DEPENDS.
02:39:45.175 --> 02:39:47.511
CALENDAR ITEMS NUMBER FOUR NINE
02:39:47.577 --> 02:39:49.012
AND 18 CURRENT VOTES 10 TO 0.
02:39:49.079 --> 02:39:53.450
MELINDA'S. LINDA'S I. JONES. NOT
02:39:53.517 --> 02:40:00.524
SURE ABOUT. YOU'RE A BIG GUY.
02:40:00.590 --> 02:40:03.427
THE VOTE IS 12 0. THE MATTER IS
02:40:03.493 --> 02:40:20.477
THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS OUT.
02:41:02.786 --> 02:41:04.121
WHEN I ASKED THE SENATE
02:41:04.187 --> 02:41:06.323
SERGEANTS TO CALL, UM THE ABSENT
02:41:06.390 --> 02:41:07.391
MEMBERS, STARTING WITH SENATOR
02:41:07.457 --> 02:41:26.143
MEN.
02:42:04.748 --> 02:42:07.717
HE'S NOT COMING BACK. FOLDERS.
02:42:07.784 --> 02:42:22.399
WELL, LET'S GO AHEAD AND START.
02:42:22.466 --> 02:42:24.134
LET'S GO AHEAD AND START WITH
02:42:24.201 --> 02:42:25.669
THE ITEMS AFTER THE CONSENT
02:42:25.735 --> 02:42:27.504
CALENDAR. YOU JUST CALL THEM
02:42:27.571 --> 02:42:29.406
OUT, AND I'LL TRY TO TRACK WITH
02:42:29.473 --> 02:42:31.074
YOU. UNLESS YOU WANT TO DO THEM
02:42:31.141 --> 02:42:33.009
AND FILE ORDER, WHICH WORKS FOR
02:42:33.076 --> 02:42:36.213
ME. OKAY. LETS DO PILE ORDER. HE
02:42:36.279 --> 02:42:39.549
FELL. ITEM NUMBER ONE. ASSEMBLY
02:42:39.616 --> 02:42:43.620
BILL 351. AND VOTED 70.
02:42:43.687 --> 02:42:47.357
MELINDA'S. LINDA'S AYE, BATES
02:42:47.424 --> 02:42:56.133
DODD. JONES DODD AYE. OH, NO.
02:42:56.199 --> 02:43:02.472
SORRY. YOU CAN'T. YOU CAN GO
02:43:02.539 --> 02:43:07.244
NOW. YOU CAN SAY NO. HE SAID. I
02:43:07.310 --> 02:43:12.115
MEAN, KILL IT. WHAT DID YOU
02:43:12.182 --> 02:43:13.283
RECORD MA'AM? DID YOU RECORD A
02:43:13.350 --> 02:43:20.123
VOTE? OKAY SO YOU ARE WHAT YOU
02:43:20.190 --> 02:43:25.228
ARE, OKAY? OKAY. JONES. AYE.
02:43:25.295 --> 02:43:33.136
JONES. I MEN. MATURE BUG.
02:43:33.203 --> 02:43:37.240
TROUBLED I 6789 10. OKAY.
02:43:37.307 --> 02:43:39.142
CURRENT VOTE IS 10 0 THE MATTERS
02:43:39.209 --> 02:43:43.747
OUT. OKAY, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
02:43:43.813 --> 02:43:46.183
WE'RE VOTING, SO LET'S ALL PAY
02:43:46.249 --> 02:43:47.350
ATTENTION SO WE DON'T MESS THIS
02:43:47.417 --> 02:43:49.386
THING UP. FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO.
02:43:49.452 --> 02:43:55.192
WE GOT. BYLINE NUMBER TWO WHO IS
02:43:55.258 --> 02:43:58.094
ASSEMBLY BILL 710? CURRENT VOTES
02:43:58.161 --> 02:44:04.134
5 TO 2. RUSSIA. MELINDA'S
02:44:04.201 --> 02:44:06.136
MELINDA'S. I DID NOT VOTE.
02:44:06.203 --> 02:44:15.011
THAT'S RIGHT. YEAH. EGGMAN. BÀN
02:44:15.078 --> 02:44:26.656
JONES. PHð BO. TROUBLED I PAN.
02:44:26.723 --> 02:44:27.924
WHAT IS THE FINAL VOTE COUNT
02:44:27.991 --> 02:44:32.629
WHEN YOU GET IT, TOO? HOLD ON.
02:44:32.696 --> 02:44:34.297
WHAT'S WRONG? WHAT'S WRONG,
02:44:34.364 --> 02:44:39.502
1234567? 772 TO THE MATTER OF
02:44:39.569 --> 02:44:48.812
FAILS. OKAY? IF I LET HIM NUMBER
02:44:48.878 --> 02:44:57.787
THREE SIMPLY BUILT 11 20.
02:44:57.854 --> 02:45:00.290
HURTING VOTE IS 9 TO 0
02:45:00.357 --> 02:45:02.125
MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S, AYE.
02:45:02.192 --> 02:45:08.164
BATES. PHð BO. TO VOTE I PAN.
02:45:08.231 --> 02:45:15.872
RIGHT? PAN. AYE. VOTE IS 12 0,
02:45:15.939 --> 02:45:21.344
THE MATTER IS OUT. FILE ITEM
02:45:21.411 --> 02:45:24.881
NUMBER FIVE SOMEONE BUILT 16 62.
02:45:24.948 --> 02:45:30.520
OPEN ROAD IS 70. MELINDA'S.
02:45:30.587 --> 02:45:37.294
EGGMAN. SEGMENT ARE HURTADO.
02:45:37.360 --> 02:45:41.031
PHOTO T<c.cyan> JONES JONES, I TROUBLE</c>
02:45:41.097 --> 02:45:47.003
BUGGED I PAN. CURRENT VOTE IS 11
02:45:47.070 --> 02:45:52.142
0, THE MATTER IS OUT. FILE ITEM
02:45:52.208 --> 02:45:54.044
NUMBER SIX FILE ITEMS SOMEBODY
02:45:54.110 --> 02:45:59.115
BUILD 17 40. CURRENT BOAT IS 60.
02:45:59.182 --> 02:46:02.419
MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S, AYE,
02:46:02.485 --> 02:46:06.556
BECKER. BECKER. I DODD. DOT I
02:46:06.623 --> 02:46:12.896
HEARD TATO. POTATO I JONES? YES.
02:46:12.962 --> 02:46:16.866
JONES. I PETROVO. HER BOOK I
02:46:16.933 --> 02:46:25.275
PAN. CAN I. YOUR VOTE COUNT 13 0
02:46:25.342 --> 02:46:29.379
13 0, THE MATTER IS OUT. FOLLOW
02:46:29.446 --> 02:46:31.614
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN ASSEMBLY BUILD
02:46:31.681 --> 02:46:37.120
17 47 CURRENT VOTE COUNT 10 0.
02:46:37.187 --> 02:46:40.890
MELINDA'S LINDA'S I. JONES.
02:46:40.957 --> 02:46:52.268
PATROL BOAT. TURBO. TURBO GUY.
02:46:52.335 --> 02:46:55.638
FORD COUNT 12 0 MATTER IS OUT.
02:46:55.705 --> 02:46:57.774
FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT SEMI
02:46:57.841 --> 02:47:01.978
BUILT 1954. RODA'S 10 0.
02:47:02.045 --> 02:47:06.483
MELINDA'S. MELINDA'S I. JONES.
02:47:06.549 --> 02:47:10.954
JONES I WHICH OBOE? YES. THE
02:47:11.020 --> 02:47:16.726
TURBO GUY. VOTE COUNT 13 0, THE
02:47:16.793 --> 02:47:18.862
MATTER IS OUT.FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:47:18.928 --> 02:47:22.665
10 ASSEMBLY BILL 21 OH 7 21 07
02:47:22.732 --> 02:47:26.403
VOTE IS 80. MELINDA'S.
02:47:26.469 --> 02:47:30.340
MELINDA'S. I HEARD TATO. FOR
02:47:30.407 --> 02:47:34.077
TITLE II. JONES JONES, I COBURG
02:47:34.144 --> 02:47:37.647
COBURG, I PAN PAN. AYE. VOTE 13
02:47:37.714 --> 02:47:42.886
0, THE MATTER IS OUT. NUMBER 13.
02:47:42.952 --> 02:47:45.321
SEMI MEMBER DAILY ASSEMBLY BILL
02:47:45.388 --> 02:47:47.991
26 11. CURRENT VOTES 11 TO 0
02:47:48.057 --> 02:47:54.464
POTATO. TÔI JONES. JONES. I.
02:47:54.531 --> 02:47:57.133
CALLED COUNT 13. 0 MATTER IS OUT
02:47:57.200 --> 02:47:59.803
FINE NUMBER 14 ASSEMBLY BILL 26
02:47:59.869 --> 02:48:06.609
26. FRENCH VOTERS, 7 TO 2.
02:48:06.676 --> 02:48:10.513
POTATO. EXCUSE ME, ARCHULETTA.
02:48:10.580 --> 02:48:16.352
EGGMAN. HER TAITO. POTATO? AYE.
02:48:16.419 --> 02:48:21.090
EGGMAN. BIG MONEY. JONES JONES.
02:48:21.157 --> 02:48:40.243
NO. PETROVO. EXPLAINED IT. 93.
02:48:40.310 --> 02:48:42.011
VOTE COUNT 9 TO 3, THE MATTER IS
02:48:42.078 --> 02:48:45.048
OUT. THE FOLLOWING MEMBER 15
02:48:45.114 --> 02:48:50.520
ASSEMBLY BILL 26 82. I'LL BE
02:48:50.587 --> 02:48:52.188
PAST THAT. EXCUSE ME. FOLLOW,
02:48:52.255 --> 02:48:56.526
REMEMBER 16, SO WE BUILT 27 23.
02:48:56.593 --> 02:49:01.631
SPORT, COUNT 90. STILETTO BAKER
02:49:01.698 --> 02:49:06.436
BECKER ER, I EGGMAN. PIGMENT. I
02:49:06.503 --> 02:49:11.841
ROTATE Ó TÔI JONES. ACCOUNT 12
02:49:11.908 --> 02:49:16.212
0 MATTER IS OUT. FILE AND NUMBER
02:49:16.279 --> 02:49:21.351
17 ASSEMBLY BILL 27 54. CURRENT
02:49:21.417 --> 02:49:24.554
VOTE COUNT IS 11 0. ARCHULETTA
02:49:24.621 --> 02:49:28.024
EGGMAN. SEGMENT I JONES. JOHN'S,
02:49:28.091 --> 02:49:31.794
AYE. VOTE COUNT 13 0 MATTERS
02:49:31.861 --> 02:49:38.067
OUT. OKAY VERY GOOD PRINCIPLE.
02:49:38.134 --> 02:49:54.217
THREE.
02:49:55.385 --> 02:50:09.632
RAIMES.
02:50:09.699 --> 02:50:15.138
SIZE. CATCH ON. I WE CLOSED THEM
02:50:15.204 --> 02:50:21.778
SO ONE SORRY ABOUT THAT. WE HAVE
02:50:21.844 --> 02:50:23.846
CONCLUDED OUR AGENDA TODAY. I
02:50:23.913 --> 02:50:25.281
WANT TO THANK ALL THE
02:50:25.348 --> 02:50:26.149
INDIVIDUALS WHO PARTICIPATED VIA
02:50:26.215 --> 02:50:28.318
PUBLIC TESTIMONY. IF YOU WERE
02:50:28.384 --> 02:50:29.786
NOT ABLE TO TESTIFY, PLEASE
02:50:29.852 --> 02:50:30.653
SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS OR
02:50:30.720 --> 02:50:31.821
SUGGESTIONS IN WRITING TO THE
02:50:31.888 --> 02:50:32.922
SENATE COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS
02:50:32.989 --> 02:50:33.890
PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC
02:50:33.957 --> 02:50:35.925
DEVELOPMENT. OR VISIT OUR
02:50:35.992 --> 02:50:37.460
WEBSITE. YOUR COMMENTS AND
02:50:37.527 --> 02:50:39.395
SUGGESTIONS ARE IMPORTANT TO US,
02:50:39.462 --> 02:50:40.630
AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE YOUR
02:50:40.697 --> 02:50:41.531
TESTIMONY. IN THE OFFICIAL
02:50:41.598 --> 02:50:43.266
HEARING RECORDS IF AT ALL
02:50:43.333 --> 02:50:45.768
POSSIBLE. AND THANK YOU TO
02:50:45.835 --> 02:50:46.836
EVERYONE FOR YOUR PATIENCE AND
02:50:46.903 --> 02:50:48.338
COOPERATION. WE'VE CONCLUDED THE
02:50:48.404 --> 02:50:49.572
AGENDA AS I INDICATED. WE ARE
02:50:49.639 --> 02:51:05.788
ADJOURNED.