WEBVTT
00:00:11.945 --> 00:00:16.850
WILL COME TO ORDER. IN RESPONSE
00:00:16.916 --> 00:00:18.251
TO THE COVERT NINETEEN
00:00:18.318 --> 00:00:19.719
EMERGENCY AND TO PROTECT THE
00:00:19.786 --> 00:00:21.154
PUBLIC LEGISLATORS AND
00:00:21.221 --> 00:00:23.690
EMPLOYEES. WE MUST LIMIT
00:00:23.757 --> 00:00:25.859
NONESSENTIAL GATHERINGS AND IT
00:00:25.925 --> 00:00:27.761
HERE TO SOCIAL DISTANCING AND
00:00:27.827 --> 00:00:30.096
FACE COVERING GUIDELINES IN
00:00:30.163 --> 00:00:31.631
COMPLIANCE WITH THOSE ORDERS
00:00:31.698 --> 00:00:33.366
THE SENATE HAS MADE.
00:00:33.433 --> 00:00:35.835
EXTRAORDINARY BUT NECESSARY
00:00:35.902 --> 00:00:38.338
ADJUSTMENTS TO NORMAL PRACTICES
00:00:38.405 --> 00:00:40.507
IN ORDER TO ENSURE. THAT THE
00:00:40.573 --> 00:00:42.542
PUBLIC CONTINUES TO HAVE ACCESS
00:00:42.609 --> 00:00:44.711
TO THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS WE
00:00:44.778 --> 00:00:45.845
ARE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
00:00:45.912 --> 00:00:47.881
HEARINGS HERE IN THE CAPITAL.
00:00:47.947 --> 00:00:48.882
WITH SOME OF OUR COMMITTEE
00:00:48.948 --> 00:00:51.684
MEMBERS PARTICIPATING REMOTELY
00:00:51.751 --> 00:00:53.453
FAR MEMBERS ATTENDING REMOTELY
00:00:53.520 --> 00:00:57.090
TODAY ARE SENATOR STERN. AND WE
00:00:57.157 --> 00:00:59.058
ASK IF YOU HAVE A STAFF PERSON
00:00:59.125 --> 00:01:01.027
WITH YOU SENATOR TO PLEASE
00:01:01.094 --> 00:01:03.863
IDENTIFY THAT STAFF FOR NOW
00:01:03.930 --> 00:01:05.999
GOOD MORNING SENATOR STERN.
00:01:06.065 --> 00:01:07.567
MORNING YEAH I'M HERE AND I
00:01:07.634 --> 00:01:08.902
HAVE- JEREMY WILL CURE MY
00:01:08.968 --> 00:01:10.770
DISTRICT DIRECTOR THANK YOU
00:01:10.837 --> 00:01:14.107
VERY MUCH RIGHT. SENATORS AS A
00:01:14.174 --> 00:01:16.376
REMINDER PLEASE FOR OUR MUTUAL
00:01:16.443 --> 00:01:18.745
PHONES OR COMPUTERS THIS WILL
00:01:18.812 --> 00:01:20.780
GREATLY AID IN ELIMINATING ANY
00:01:20.847 --> 00:01:23.216
ACOUSTIC FEEDBACK. AND I ASK
00:01:23.283 --> 00:01:24.517
THAT EVERY TIME YOU WISH TO BE
00:01:24.584 --> 00:01:27.821
RECOGNIZED TO SPEAK A POP UP
00:01:27.887 --> 00:01:30.290
WINDOW WILL APPEAR ASKING IF
00:01:30.356 --> 00:01:32.192
YOU WOULD LIKE TO ON MUTE.
00:01:32.258 --> 00:01:33.793
PLEASE SELECT ON MUTE BEFORE
00:01:33.860 --> 00:01:36.863
YOU BEGIN SPEAKING. ARE IT
00:01:36.930 --> 00:01:39.866
PERSONNEL WILL PUT YOU BACK ON
00:01:39.933 --> 00:01:41.234
MUTE WHEN YOU ARE DONE. AND
00:01:41.301 --> 00:01:43.470
ONCE RECOGNIZE. PLEASE MAKE
00:01:43.536 --> 00:01:45.238
SURE YOU CAN BE SEEN ON THE
00:01:45.305 --> 00:01:48.875
SCREEN THEN STATE YOUR NAME AND
00:01:48.942 --> 00:01:50.176
THEN YOU ARE READY TO ADDRESS
00:01:50.243 --> 00:01:53.179
THE COMMITTEE. TO ALLOW PUBLIC
00:01:53.246 --> 00:01:55.515
ACCESS WE HAVE ADMITTED MEMBERS
00:01:55.582 --> 00:01:56.749
OF THE PUBLIC TO TWO HEARING
00:01:56.816 --> 00:01:59.719
ROOMS TO THE EXTENT THAT SOCIAL
00:01:59.786 --> 00:02:01.754
DISTANCING REQUIREMENTS ALLOW.
00:02:01.821 --> 00:02:03.289
AND WILL USE A TELECONFERENCE
00:02:03.356 --> 00:02:06.526
SERVICE FOR THOSE INDIVIDUALS
00:02:06.593 --> 00:02:08.661
WHO WISH TO TESTIFY TODAY. FOR
00:02:08.728 --> 00:02:09.996
ALL INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
00:02:10.063 --> 00:02:11.965
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT THE
00:02:12.031 --> 00:02:13.833
PARTICIPANT TOLL FREE NUMBER
00:02:13.900 --> 00:02:16.102
AND ACCESSCODE IS POSTED ON
00:02:16.169 --> 00:02:18.705
OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE IT WILL
00:02:18.771 --> 00:02:25.845
BE DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN. AND.
00:02:25.912 --> 00:02:28.414
I WILL ANNOUNCE IT NOW. TODAY'S
00:02:28.481 --> 00:02:33.887
PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS ONE.
00:02:33.953 --> 00:02:39.425
EIGHT FOUR FOUR. TWO NINE ONE.
00:02:39.492 --> 00:02:40.059
SIX THREE SIX FOUR I'LL REPEAT
00:02:40.126 --> 00:02:41.895
THAT NUMBER THE PARTICIPANT
00:02:41.961 --> 00:02:46.533
NUMBER IS ONE EIGHT FOUR FOUR.
00:02:46.599 --> 00:02:51.838
TWO NINE ONE. SIX THREE SIX
00:02:51.905 --> 00:02:57.043
FOUR AND THE ACCESS CODE IS.
00:02:57.110 --> 00:02:58.144
SIX ONE ONE ONE. ONE SEVEN NINE
00:02:58.211 --> 00:03:06.319
AGAIN. THE ACCESS CODE IS. SIX
00:03:06.386 --> 00:03:06.920
ONE ONE ONE ONE SEVEN NINE FOR
00:03:06.986 --> 00:03:08.321
DETAILED INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW
00:03:08.388 --> 00:03:11.124
THE TELECONFERENCES TEAM WORKS
00:03:11.190 --> 00:03:11.724
PLEASE REFER TO OUR COMMITTEE
00:03:11.791 --> 00:03:13.826
WEBSITE. WHEN WE MOVED TO
00:03:13.893 --> 00:03:15.128
PUBLIC COMMENT YOU WILL BE
00:03:15.194 --> 00:03:17.497
PROMPTED BY A MODERATOR TO DIAL
00:03:17.564 --> 00:03:21.067
ONE. AND THEN ZERO FOUR SUPPORT
00:03:21.134 --> 00:03:23.636
AND OPPOSITION. PLEASE
00:03:23.703 --> 00:03:25.538
PRESSURES ONLY ONE TIME AND
00:03:25.605 --> 00:03:28.308
WAIT PATIENTLY FOR AN OPERATOR
00:03:28.374 --> 00:03:30.276
TO ASSIGN YOU A LINE NUMBER
00:03:30.343 --> 00:03:32.512
THIS CAN BE A SHORT WAIT ONCE
00:03:32.579 --> 00:03:34.480
YOU RECEIVE YOUR LINE NUMBER
00:03:34.547 --> 00:03:36.549
YOU WILL WAIT IN THE QUEUE FOR
00:03:36.616 --> 00:03:37.750
THE MODERATOR TO CALL YOUR LINE
00:03:37.817 --> 00:03:40.453
NUMBER. AT THAT TIME YOU WILL
00:03:40.520 --> 00:03:42.989
BE AND MUTED AND YOU ARE NOW
00:03:43.056 --> 00:03:44.958
READY TO ADDRESS THE COMMITTEE.
00:03:45.024 --> 00:03:46.492
PLEASE NOTE THAT IN ORDER FOR
00:03:46.559 --> 00:03:48.595
US TO HEAR YOU CLEARLY AND TO
00:03:48.661 --> 00:03:51.230
AVOID ACOUSTIC FEEDBACK. YOU
00:03:51.297 --> 00:03:53.433
MUST MUTE THE DEVICE YOU ARE
00:03:53.499 --> 00:03:56.302
WATCHING THE HEARING ON. PRIOR
00:03:56.369 --> 00:03:56.869
TO GIVING TESTIMONY OVER THE
00:03:56.936 --> 00:03:59.472
PHONE. IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WE
00:03:59.539 --> 00:04:01.808
HEAR FROM YOU AND WE THANK YOU
00:04:01.874 --> 00:04:04.177
FOR YOUR PATIENCE. I WILL
00:04:04.243 --> 00:04:06.412
HOWEVER INSIST THAT WE MAINTAIN
00:04:06.479 --> 00:04:08.381
DECORUM DURING OUR HEARINGS AS
00:04:08.448 --> 00:04:10.750
IS CUSTOMARY. AND ANY
00:04:10.817 --> 00:04:12.385
INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE
00:04:12.452 --> 00:04:13.820
MAY BE REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE
00:04:13.886 --> 00:04:15.955
MEETING SERVICES OR HAVE THEIR
00:04:16.022 --> 00:04:18.424
CONNECTIONS MUTED. WHILE EVERY
00:04:18.491 --> 00:04:19.626
EFFORT HAS BEEN MADE TO
00:04:19.692 --> 00:04:21.260
STREAMLINE THE HEARING PROCESS
00:04:21.327 --> 00:04:22.495
AND CONDUCT OUR HEARINGS IN AS
00:04:22.562 --> 00:04:24.998
CLOSE TO THE SAME MANNER AS IS
00:04:25.064 --> 00:04:26.966
CUSTOMARY. THERE MAY BE SOME
00:04:27.033 --> 00:04:29.235
LAG TIME FOR PARTICIPANTS WHO
00:04:29.302 --> 00:04:30.803
ARE ADJUSTING TO THE NEW USE OF
00:04:30.870 --> 00:04:34.273
ONLINE TOOLS AND TECHNOLOGIES.
00:04:34.340 --> 00:04:35.308
PLEASE BE RESPECTFUL AND
00:04:35.375 --> 00:04:37.377
PATIENT OKAY ARE THE MICROPHONE
00:04:37.443 --> 00:04:39.812
MUTE AND UNMUTE MYSELF WHAT. TO
00:04:39.879 --> 00:04:44.884
TALK. THAT'S TRUE BECAUSE THEY
00:04:44.951 --> 00:04:46.853
DIDN'T THEY ALL RIGHT. HERE ALL
00:04:46.919 --> 00:04:49.822
RIGHT. ALL RIGHT WELL. THAT WAS
00:04:49.889 --> 00:04:51.958
INTERESTING OKAY THIS IS
00:04:52.025 --> 00:04:54.594
PROBABLY NOT GONNA BE DAHLE.
00:04:54.661 --> 00:04:55.862
AND THEY'LL PROBABLY BE SOME
00:04:55.928 --> 00:04:59.365
GLITCHES BUT- AGAIN I ASK YOU
00:04:59.432 --> 00:05:01.534
FOR YOUR PATIENCE AND YOUR OF
00:05:01.601 --> 00:05:03.569
RESPECTFUL UNDERSTANDING-
00:05:03.636 --> 00:05:05.538
BECAUSE THIS IS NEW TO MOST
00:05:05.605 --> 00:05:08.875
PEOPLE AND- CERTAINLY NEW TO ME.
00:05:08.941 --> 00:05:10.910
ALL RIGHT BEFORE WE BEGIN I
00:05:10.977 --> 00:05:12.679
WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME SENATOR
00:05:12.745 --> 00:05:14.480
MELENDEZ WHO IS SITTING TO MY
00:05:14.547 --> 00:05:15.982
LEFT BUT THAT'S PROBABLY THE
00:05:16.049 --> 00:05:19.485
ONLY TIME. SHALL EVER BE
00:05:19.552 --> 00:05:20.553
DESCRIBED AS BEING TO MY LEFT.
00:05:20.620 --> 00:05:22.088
BUT WE ARE HAPPY THANK YOU AND
00:05:22.155 --> 00:05:23.089
WELCOME TO OUR COMMITTEE
00:05:23.156 --> 00:05:25.825
SENATOR MELINDA'S. WE HAVE
00:05:25.892 --> 00:05:27.660
NINETEEN BILLS ON OUR AGENDA
00:05:27.727 --> 00:05:32.065
pCONSENT AND I APPRECIATE THE
00:05:32.131 --> 00:05:32.799
WORK OF THE AUTHORS AND
00:05:32.865 --> 00:05:36.936
COMMITTEE- AND STAFF- TO PUT
00:05:37.003 --> 00:05:38.771
THOSE ITEMS IN THE FORM WHERE
00:05:38.838 --> 00:05:41.574
THEY CAN BE CONSENT ITEMS TODAY.
00:05:41.641 --> 00:05:43.843
BUT BEFORE WE HEAR PRESENTATION
00:05:43.910 --> 00:05:45.578
ON THOSE BILLS SO I WOULD LIKE
00:05:45.645 --> 00:05:47.113
TO ESTABLISH A QUORUM. AND
00:05:47.180 --> 00:05:49.716
CONSULTANT PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
00:05:49.782 --> 00:05:57.757
WHEN. I MEAN FACT SEND HERE
00:05:57.824 --> 00:06:01.928
JACKSON HERE FOR JESS. AND IT
00:06:01.994 --> 00:06:03.996
MAY I ADMIRE ASKED THAT WE MAKE
00:06:04.063 --> 00:06:05.631
SURE BECAUSE THIS HAS TO BE
00:06:05.698 --> 00:06:07.533
CLEAR TO EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM
00:06:07.600 --> 00:06:10.036
AND WATCHING. FOR YOU SPEAK
00:06:10.103 --> 00:06:12.071
PLEASE TURN ON YOUR MICROPHONE
00:06:12.138 --> 00:06:13.840
SO THAT WE CAN IDENTIFY YOU
00:06:13.906 --> 00:06:15.842
SPECIFICALLY PRESIDENT. THANK
00:06:15.908 --> 00:06:17.677
YOU CENTER BORCHERS LARGEST
00:06:17.744 --> 00:06:21.114
PRESENT DO WRESTLED HERE. WITH
00:06:21.180 --> 00:06:26.252
US SO HERE. GONZALEZ MICRON
00:06:26.319 --> 00:06:30.656
HERE ONE SALAS HERE MELENDEZ
00:06:30.723 --> 00:06:34.861
HERE MELENDEZ HERE MORNING HERE
00:06:34.927 --> 00:06:41.834
MONEY HERE STERN. PRESIDENT
00:06:41.901 --> 00:06:47.073
HASN'T REMOTELY I'M BURKE. WHY
00:06:47.140 --> 00:06:51.811
CAL SKINNER WAY CASKEY HERE-
00:06:51.878 --> 00:06:55.081
MADAM CHAIR YOU HAVE A QUORUM.
00:06:55.148 --> 00:06:57.850
THANK YOU MADAM CONSULTANT.
00:06:57.917 --> 00:06:59.585
MADAM CHAIR I WOULD LIKE TO
00:06:59.652 --> 00:07:00.486
MOVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR VERY
00:07:00.553 --> 00:07:02.622
GOOD- WE HAVE THE CONSENT
00:07:02.688 --> 00:07:05.358
CALENDAR BEFORE US THE
00:07:05.424 --> 00:07:05.892
FOLLOWING BILLS ARE ON THE
00:07:05.958 --> 00:07:09.962
CALENDAR. FOR CONSENT. FILE
00:07:10.029 --> 00:07:12.865
ITEM NUMBER ONE AB SEVENTEEN
00:07:12.932 --> 00:07:14.300
NOT A NINETY SIX BY
00:07:14.367 --> 00:07:16.536
ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEVINE. FILE
00:07:16.602 --> 00:07:20.072
ITEM THREE AB NINETEEN EIGHTY
00:07:20.139 --> 00:07:20.573
FOUR BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:07:20.640 --> 00:07:24.610
MAANSHAN. FILE ITEM FOR AB
00:07:24.677 --> 00:07:25.178
TWENTY FORTY SIX BY ASSEMBLY
00:07:25.244 --> 00:07:28.114
MEMBER VOEPEL. FILE NUMBER ITEM
00:07:28.181 --> 00:07:32.718
NUMBER FIVE. AB TWENTY ONE
00:07:32.785 --> 00:07:33.319
SIXTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:07:33.386 --> 00:07:38.257
ROBERT RIVAS FILE ITEM SIX AB
00:07:38.324 --> 00:07:38.791
TWENTY ONE NINETY EIGHT BY
00:07:38.858 --> 00:07:41.427
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TANG FILE ITEM
00:07:41.494 --> 00:07:44.831
TEN. AB TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE
00:07:44.897 --> 00:07:47.333
AB TWENTY FOUR SEVENTY ONE BY
00:07:47.400 --> 00:07:48.768
ASSEMBLYMEMBER MIND TRYING.
00:07:48.835 --> 00:07:51.971
FILE ITEM ELEVEN AB TWENTY FIVE
00:07:52.038 --> 00:07:52.572
SEVENTEEN BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:07:52.638 --> 00:07:57.910
GLORIA. FILE ITEM TWELVE AB
00:07:57.977 --> 00:07:58.444
TWENTY SEVEN SEVENTEEN BY
00:07:58.511 --> 00:08:02.014
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHAU. FILE ITEM
00:08:02.081 --> 00:08:04.684
THIRTEEN AB TWENTY EIGHT OH
00:08:04.750 --> 00:08:06.619
FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER EGGMAN.
00:08:06.686 --> 00:08:10.556
FILE ITEM FOURTEEN AB TWENTY
00:08:10.623 --> 00:08:11.123
EIGHT FORTY FOUR BY ASSEMBLY
00:08:11.190 --> 00:08:12.758
MEMBER OBERNOLTE OBERNOLTE WITH
00:08:12.825 --> 00:08:16.829
AMENDMENTS. AND FILE ITEM
00:08:16.896 --> 00:08:19.198
SIXTEEN AB THIRTY EIGHTY EIGHT
00:08:19.265 --> 00:08:21.167
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHIU WITH
00:08:21.234 --> 00:08:23.069
AMENDMENTS WE HAVE A MOTION ON
00:08:23.135 --> 00:08:25.438
THAT CALENDAR MADE BY SENATOR
00:08:25.504 --> 00:08:28.474
MELENDEZ. MADAM CONSULTANT TO
00:08:28.541 --> 00:08:30.009
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON THE
00:08:30.076 --> 00:08:31.744
CONSENT CALENDAR SENATORS
00:08:31.811 --> 00:08:34.046
PLEASE TURN YOUR MICROPHONES ON
00:08:34.113 --> 00:08:36.482
THE MOTION IS TO PASS THE
00:08:36.549 --> 00:08:39.852
CONSENT CALENDAR. JACKSON HI
00:08:39.919 --> 00:08:45.057
JACKSON BY FOR JESS BY FORGES I
00:08:45.124 --> 00:08:50.162
DID AWESOME. GONZALEZ HI
00:08:50.229 --> 00:08:55.668
GONZALEZ I MELENDEZ. MELENDEZ I
00:08:55.735 --> 00:09:02.275
MONNING AYE MONNING AYE STERN.
00:09:02.341 --> 00:09:07.980
NINE STERN I BURKE HI I'M BURKE
00:09:08.047 --> 00:09:11.751
I WHY CAL SKENEIDAE Y. HOUSE
00:09:11.817 --> 00:09:16.989
SKI I TO OUR SIX YOU HAVE EIGHT
00:09:17.056 --> 00:09:19.525
VOTES AND LEAVE THAT OPEN FOR
00:09:19.592 --> 00:09:21.460
INDEED WE WILL LEAVE THE ROLE
00:09:21.527 --> 00:09:23.863
OPENED FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
00:09:23.930 --> 00:09:25.665
THE VOTE IS EIGHT TWO ZERO AT
00:09:25.731 --> 00:09:27.233
THIS POINT IN TIME AND NOW WE
00:09:27.300 --> 00:09:28.668
WILL START WITH OUR FIRST
00:09:28.734 --> 00:09:31.671
AUTHOR. IS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:09:31.737 --> 00:09:42.648
KALRA WITH US TODAY. ALL RIGHT
00:09:42.715 --> 00:09:46.319
WE HAVE ON HIS BEHALF OUR
00:09:46.385 --> 00:09:48.754
MEMBER THE SENATOR CAN SOLVE
00:09:48.821 --> 00:09:50.389
THIS GONZALEZ WHO WILL BE
00:09:50.456 --> 00:09:52.458
PRESENTING FOR HIM GOOD MORNING
00:09:52.525 --> 00:09:55.127
SENATOR GONZALEZ THIS IS FILE
00:09:55.194 --> 00:09:57.396
ITEM ONE A. B. EXCUSE ME FILE
00:09:57.463 --> 00:10:01.000
ITEM TO A. B. NINETEEN FORTY
00:10:01.067 --> 00:10:02.535
SEVEN YOU ARE PRESENTING ON
00:10:02.601 --> 00:10:03.402
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA.
00:10:03.469 --> 00:10:06.739
AND TO FEEL FREE TO PROCEED
00:10:06.806 --> 00:10:08.040
GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR AND
00:10:08.107 --> 00:10:09.942
SENATORS ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
00:10:10.009 --> 00:10:13.546
MEMBER KALRA AB NINETEEN FORTY
00:10:13.612 --> 00:10:14.680
SEVEN EXTENDS THE FILING
00:10:14.747 --> 00:10:16.015
DEADLINE FOR RETALIATION CLAIMS
00:10:16.082 --> 00:10:16.983
FOR THE DIVISION OF LABOR
00:10:17.049 --> 00:10:18.718
STANDARDS ENFORCEMENT DLS SEE
00:10:18.784 --> 00:10:21.053
FROM SIX MONTHS TO ONE YEAR NOW
00:10:21.120 --> 00:10:23.422
OUT FROM LAST YEAR'S AB FOUR OH
00:10:23.489 --> 00:10:24.890
THREE FROM TWO YEARS TO ADDRESS
00:10:24.957 --> 00:10:26.559
THE GOVERNOR'S VETO MESSAGE
00:10:26.625 --> 00:10:27.893
ALLOWS RECOVERY OF ATTORNEYS
00:10:27.960 --> 00:10:29.495
FEES TO PREVAILING EMPLOYEES
00:10:29.562 --> 00:10:30.696
AND ONLY APPLIES FOR WHISTLE
00:10:30.763 --> 00:10:32.365
BLOWER RETALIATION CLAIMS
00:10:32.431 --> 00:10:34.033
RETALIATION IS NOT ONLY
00:10:34.100 --> 00:10:35.534
PERVASIVE BUT ALSO A GROWING
00:10:35.601 --> 00:10:36.936
PROBLEM. DUE TO THE CURRENT
00:10:37.003 --> 00:10:38.537
POLITICAL CLIMATE SURROUNDING
00:10:38.604 --> 00:10:40.740
IMMIGRATION AND THE LAST FOUR
00:10:40.806 --> 00:10:43.676
YEARS OF AVAILABLE DATA FROM
00:10:43.743 --> 00:10:44.176
TWENTY FIFTEEN TO TWENTY
00:10:44.243 --> 00:10:45.077
EIGHTEEN IMMIGRATION RELATED
00:10:45.144 --> 00:10:46.379
RETALIATION CLAIMS FILED WITH
00:10:46.445 --> 00:10:48.681
THE T. L. S. E. INCREASED BY
00:10:48.748 --> 00:10:51.684
NEARLY 2000% AMID THE PANDEMIC
00:10:51.751 --> 00:10:54.553
ADVOCATES REPORT AN INCREASE IN
00:10:54.620 --> 00:10:55.354
CALLS REGARDING HEALTH AND
00:10:55.421 --> 00:10:58.391
SAFETY ISSUES AND WE JUST UP
00:10:58.457 --> 00:10:59.025
AND MISS CLASSIFICATION. IT IS
00:10:59.091 --> 00:11:00.259
IMPORTANT NOW THAN EVER THAT WE
00:11:00.326 --> 00:11:01.660
INSURE ALL LEGAL AND- AVENUES
00:11:01.727 --> 00:11:03.129
ARE AVAILABLE FOR WORKERS WHO
00:11:03.195 --> 00:11:04.864
COME FORWARD. THE TWO MAIN
00:11:04.930 --> 00:11:07.099
BARRIERS WORKERS SPACE TO
00:11:07.166 --> 00:11:07.700
FILING A CLAIM ARE DRESSED IN
00:11:07.767 --> 00:11:09.635
THIS BILL. FIRST WORKERS WHO
00:11:09.702 --> 00:11:11.337
HAVE FACED RETALIATION
00:11:11.404 --> 00:11:12.338
ESPECIALLY IN EXTREME FORMS OF
00:11:12.405 --> 00:11:13.773
TERMINATION OR VIOLENCE NEED
00:11:13.839 --> 00:11:15.074
MORE TIME TO GATHER THE
00:11:15.141 --> 00:11:16.776
RESOURCES AND SEEK ASSISTANCE.
00:11:16.842 --> 00:11:18.711
A SIMPLE SIX MONTH EXTENSION
00:11:18.778 --> 00:11:19.779
FOR FILING A WORKER RETALIATION
00:11:19.845 --> 00:11:20.780
CLAIM WILL GIVE PEOPLE THE
00:11:20.846 --> 00:11:22.181
OPPORTUNITY TO CONSIDER THEIR
00:11:22.248 --> 00:11:24.083
LIVELIHOOD AND THEN. THEIR NEXT
00:11:24.150 --> 00:11:26.952
STEPS FOR RECOURSE. AB NINETEEN
00:11:27.019 --> 00:11:27.520
FORTY SEVEN ALSO BUILD UPON
00:11:27.586 --> 00:11:28.954
EXISTING ABILITIES FOR COURTS
00:11:29.021 --> 00:11:30.656
TO WORK REASONABLE ATTORNEY'S
00:11:30.723 --> 00:11:32.558
FEES TO ATTORNEYS WHO TAKE
00:11:32.625 --> 00:11:33.459
THESE CASES ON BEHALF OF
00:11:33.526 --> 00:11:35.728
WORKERS. THIS IS NOT A BILL
00:11:35.795 --> 00:11:37.630
INTENDED TO INCREASE LITIGATION
00:11:37.696 --> 00:11:40.132
AS THE OPPOSITION ARGUES RATHER
00:11:40.199 --> 00:11:42.134
IT IS. IT PROVIDES AN
00:11:42.201 --> 00:11:43.536
ADDITIONAL SENSIBLE AND
00:11:43.602 --> 00:11:45.971
REASONABLE WAY FOR LOW WAGE
00:11:46.038 --> 00:11:47.073
WORKERS TO PURSUE RECOURSE WHEN
00:11:47.139 --> 00:11:48.407
IT UNFAIRLY TALLY IT AGAINST
00:11:48.474 --> 00:11:49.642
FOR INVOKING THE RIGHTS UNDER
00:11:49.708 --> 00:11:52.078
STATE LAW. WITH TO PROVIDE
00:11:52.144 --> 00:11:53.145
SUPPORT TESTIMONY IS
00:11:53.212 --> 00:11:54.613
CHRISTOPHER SANCHEZ FROM CHIRLA
00:11:54.680 --> 00:11:57.450
AND MEDICAL SO HE HADA WITH.
00:11:57.516 --> 00:11:59.118
THE CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT
00:11:59.185 --> 00:12:01.554
LAWYERS ASSOCIATION AND I
00:12:01.620 --> 00:12:02.121
RESPECTFULLY ASK FERNANDO.
00:12:02.188 --> 00:12:06.325
THANK YOU ARE. SENATOR WE HAVE.
00:12:06.392 --> 00:12:09.762
I BELIEVE TWO WITNESSES- AND
00:12:09.829 --> 00:12:11.630
ARE THEY BOTH INTENDED TO BE ON
00:12:11.697 --> 00:12:13.666
THE LINE TALKING REMOTELY YES
00:12:13.732 --> 00:12:18.237
AND ARE THEY AVAILABLE. AFTER
00:12:18.304 --> 00:12:20.339
YES HELLO AND THANK YOU MADAM
00:12:20.406 --> 00:12:22.575
CHAIR AND MEMBERS THIS IS MERRY
00:12:22.641 --> 00:12:23.709
GO YOSHI HARDEN THE POLICY
00:12:23.776 --> 00:12:25.611
DIRECTOR FOR THE CALIFORNIA
00:12:25.678 --> 00:12:27.446
EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS ASSOCIATION.
00:12:27.513 --> 00:12:28.914
I'M ARE LAWYERS LIKE MANY OF
00:12:28.981 --> 00:12:30.850
YOU I'M SURE- ARE HEARING FROM
00:12:30.916 --> 00:12:32.518
SO MANY WORKERS ACROSS THE
00:12:32.585 --> 00:12:35.254
STATE WHO FEEL UNSAFE AT WORK
00:12:35.321 --> 00:12:36.155
BECAUSE THEIR EMPLOYERS NOT
00:12:36.222 --> 00:12:37.790
TAKING PROPER PRECAUTIONS TO
00:12:37.857 --> 00:12:39.225
PROTECT THEM FROM BECAUSE THE
00:12:39.291 --> 00:12:41.060
NINETEEN. AND THE LEGISLATURE
00:12:41.127 --> 00:12:42.495
IS WORKING ON ANY OF THE BILL
00:12:42.561 --> 00:12:44.530
TO ADDRESS THE SITUATION THAT
00:12:44.597 --> 00:12:45.898
HELPS STRENGTHEN PROTECTIONS
00:12:45.965 --> 00:12:47.266
FOR OUR ITS CENTRAL WORKERS IN
00:12:47.333 --> 00:12:49.135
CALIFORNIA BUT THE RIGHT ACTION
00:12:49.201 --> 00:12:50.369
THAT WE PUT IN PLACE FOR
00:12:50.436 --> 00:12:52.138
WORKERS REALLY MEAN NOTHING IF
00:12:52.204 --> 00:12:54.039
THEY CAN BE FIRED RETALIATED
00:12:54.106 --> 00:12:55.608
AGAINST FOR TRYING TO A THIRD
00:12:55.674 --> 00:12:57.576
THOSE RIGHT OR ASK FOR THOSE
00:12:57.643 --> 00:12:59.912
PROTECTION. THE REALITY OF MANY
00:12:59.979 --> 00:13:01.046
WORKERS. SPEAK OUT BECAUSE WE
00:13:01.113 --> 00:13:02.515
SIMPLY CANNOT AFFORD TO LOSE
00:13:02.581 --> 00:13:04.683
THEIR JOB ESPECIALLY IN THIS
00:13:04.750 --> 00:13:06.318
ECONOMY. I REMEMBER THOSE
00:13:06.385 --> 00:13:08.087
WORKERS WHO DO SPEAK OUT AND DO
00:13:08.154 --> 00:13:10.322
FACE RETALIATION SIX MONTHS
00:13:10.389 --> 00:13:11.991
DOES NOT ENOUGH TIME FOR THEM
00:13:12.057 --> 00:13:17.796
FILE CLAIMS LABOR. THAT. WILL
00:13:17.863 --> 00:13:19.298
HELP INSURE THAT THESE WERE
00:13:19.365 --> 00:13:20.866
DON'T LOSE THEIR- BY GIVING
00:13:20.933 --> 00:13:22.835
THEM AND SIX. OF THEIR CAR. ON
00:13:22.902 --> 00:13:23.469
EIGHTEEN FORTY SEVEN WILL. HELP
00:13:23.536 --> 00:13:25.504
WORKER THE TICKET. LOW WAY.
00:13:25.571 --> 00:13:26.172
IMMIGRANT WORK TO GET
00:13:26.238 --> 00:13:28.274
ASSISTANCE. FOR WHAT THE LOWER
00:13:28.340 --> 00:13:29.975
RETALIATION CLAIM BECAUSE IT
00:13:30.042 --> 00:13:32.278
WILL ALLOW THOSE RECOVERS
00:13:32.344 --> 00:13:34.713
WORKERS TO RECOVER THEIR
00:13:34.780 --> 00:13:36.549
ATTORNEY. THE NEXT. RIGHT NOW
00:13:36.615 --> 00:13:38.717
I'M LIKE MOST THE END FEDERAL
00:13:38.784 --> 00:13:40.286
WHISTLEBLOWER STATUTE THERE IS
00:13:40.352 --> 00:13:41.787
NO ATTORNEY P. PROVISION WHICH
00:13:41.854 --> 00:13:43.389
MEANS THE WORKER HALF THE PAY
00:13:43.455 --> 00:13:44.590
THEIR LEGAL FEES THROUGH A
00:13:44.657 --> 00:13:46.559
PORTION OF THEIR RECOVERY. OR
00:13:46.625 --> 00:13:48.027
ELSE FIND AN ATTORNEY TO TAKE
00:13:48.093 --> 00:13:49.695
THE CASE FOR FREE. I'M AT THE
00:13:49.762 --> 00:13:51.830
RECENT NEW YORK TIMES EDITORIAL
00:13:51.897 --> 00:13:53.966
POINTED OUT ALLOWING WORKERS TO
00:13:54.033 --> 00:13:55.467
RECOVER THEIR ATTORNEY FEES IF
00:13:55.534 --> 00:13:57.136
THEY PREVAILED DOES NOT
00:13:57.203 --> 00:13:58.037
INCENTIVIZE FRIVOLOUS
00:13:58.103 --> 00:14:00.206
LITIGATION BECAUSE OF COURSE
00:14:00.272 --> 00:14:02.541
THE LAWYER GET NOTHING I'M NOT
00:14:02.608 --> 00:14:03.809
THEY WENT. MICHAEL WILL LOSE
00:14:03.876 --> 00:14:05.044
ALL THE THEY PUT INTO A INTO
00:14:05.110 --> 00:14:06.478
WORKING ON A CASE IF THE CLAIM
00:14:06.545 --> 00:14:08.447
HAS NO MERIT IN REALITY
00:14:08.514 --> 00:14:09.582
ALLOWING THE RECOVERY OF
00:14:09.648 --> 00:14:11.317
ATTORNEY FEES REALLY PROVIDES
00:14:11.383 --> 00:14:13.752
MORE EQUITABLE ACCESS TO
00:14:13.819 --> 00:14:14.320
JUSTICE BECAUSE LOWER WAGE
00:14:14.386 --> 00:14:15.888
WORKERS CAN PAY THEIR LEGAL
00:14:15.955 --> 00:14:17.856
FEES REGARDLESS OF WHAT THEY
00:14:17.923 --> 00:14:18.390
END UP RECOVERY. AND THEIR
00:14:18.457 --> 00:14:20.859
AWARD WHICH IS OFTEN TIED TO
00:14:20.926 --> 00:14:23.329
THE WAGES. THIS BILL. WILL HELP
00:14:23.395 --> 00:14:24.964
INSURE MORE WORKERS ABLE TO
00:14:25.030 --> 00:14:26.165
ENFORCE THEIR RIGHTS UNDER THE
00:14:26.232 --> 00:14:27.533
LABOR CODE WHICH WE KNOW IT'S
00:14:27.600 --> 00:14:29.068
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT SO MANY
00:14:29.134 --> 00:14:30.469
WORKERS ARE RISKING THEIR LIVES
00:14:30.536 --> 00:14:31.904
DURING AND THAT MAKE. THE FOR
00:14:31.971 --> 00:14:33.739
ALL THESE REASONS WE STRONGLY
00:14:33.806 --> 00:14:35.307
URGE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK YOU
00:14:35.374 --> 00:14:40.145
VERY MUCH THE IS. THE SECOND
00:14:40.212 --> 00:14:40.746
WITNESS AVAILABLE AND I AND I
00:14:40.813 --> 00:14:41.347
APOLOGIZE FOR NOT RE OF. THE
00:14:41.413 --> 00:14:43.015
RULES WE ARE GIVING THREE
00:14:43.082 --> 00:14:45.818
MINUTES TO EACH SIDE THAT WAS
00:14:45.884 --> 00:14:47.953
TWO MINUTES SO IF WE HAVE A
00:14:48.020 --> 00:14:51.890
WITH US THE- OTHER WITNESS
00:14:51.957 --> 00:14:53.392
MISTER SANCHEZ. ON THE LINE
00:14:53.459 --> 00:14:55.594
WE'LL GIVE YOU A MINUTE TO-
00:14:55.661 --> 00:14:58.664
PRESENT YOUR REMARKS ARE YOU
00:14:58.731 --> 00:15:01.333
WITH US MISTER SANCHEZ. MADAM
00:15:01.400 --> 00:15:03.569
CHAIR THANK YOU MY APOLOGIES
00:15:03.636 --> 00:15:05.404
BUT I WANT TO BE CONSISTENT SO
00:15:05.471 --> 00:15:07.406
WE'RE GONNA GO AHEAD AND ASK
00:15:07.473 --> 00:15:09.174
YOU IF YOU COULD PRESENT IN A
00:15:09.241 --> 00:15:12.044
MINUTE. MEANING NOW BUT I FOR
00:15:12.111 --> 00:15:15.547
ONE MINUTE. CHRIS RESPONSIBLE
00:15:15.614 --> 00:15:16.949
CHIRLA THE COALITION FOR HUMANE
00:15:17.016 --> 00:15:18.250
IMMIGRANT RIGHTS CALIFORNIA'S
00:15:18.317 --> 00:15:19.985
BUDGET DEMERITS ORGANIZATION
00:15:20.052 --> 00:15:21.387
DIRECTORY PREVENTING IMMIGRANT
00:15:21.453 --> 00:15:23.122
FAMILIES DURING SOME WORKERS I
00:15:23.188 --> 00:15:24.290
WILL TRY TO BE A SPONSOR OF
00:15:24.356 --> 00:15:26.358
THIS BILL AND- I'VE ALREADY
00:15:26.425 --> 00:15:28.160
STATED WE KNOW THAT THIS BILL
00:15:28.227 --> 00:15:28.994
MORE IMPORTANT NOW THAN EVER
00:15:29.061 --> 00:15:30.396
ESPECIALLY WITH THE PANDEMIC.
00:15:30.462 --> 00:15:31.930
BOB IS A RECEIVED REPORTS OF
00:15:31.997 --> 00:15:33.465
WORKERS WHOSE WRITING DID
00:15:33.532 --> 00:15:35.968
COMPROMISED AND PLAYERS A MENU
00:15:36.035 --> 00:15:37.036
BUT THEY WORKING ON IT
00:15:37.102 --> 00:15:38.771
CONDITION THE STORES ARE NO
00:15:38.837 --> 00:15:40.506
DIFFERENT THAN THE ONES WE WERE
00:15:40.572 --> 00:15:41.707
PART OF THE PANDEMIC THE ONLY
00:15:41.774 --> 00:15:42.908
DIFFERENCE ABOUT THE WORK FORCE
00:15:42.975 --> 00:15:44.176
OF THE CREATES A REPORTS
00:15:44.243 --> 00:15:45.844
RETALIATION AND OTHER EMPLOYER
00:15:45.911 --> 00:15:47.913
BECAUSE I MEAN CREWS. ARE FOR
00:15:47.980 --> 00:15:49.448
TO THE WORKING WITH WHO ARE
00:15:49.515 --> 00:15:52.151
WORKERS- NOTE WE KNOW THAT OUR
00:15:52.217 --> 00:15:53.719
SIX MONTH IS NOT ENOUGH AND A
00:15:53.786 --> 00:15:55.187
YEAR WOULD ABSOLUTELY BE A LOT
00:15:55.254 --> 00:15:56.655
MORE BENEFICIAL TO IMMIGRANT
00:15:56.722 --> 00:15:58.424
WORKERS ESPECIALLY TO COME
00:15:58.490 --> 00:16:00.025
FORWARD ARMS TO TRUSTED
00:16:00.092 --> 00:16:03.362
SOURCES. IF ARE- IT IS
00:16:03.429 --> 00:16:04.763
IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT SOME
00:16:04.830 --> 00:16:06.231
CASES FROM DOCTOR ARE WORKERS
00:16:06.298 --> 00:16:07.833
THAT WILL BE FILED WITH THE
00:16:07.900 --> 00:16:09.735
LABOR AND ALLOW BURDEN DOCUMENT
00:16:09.802 --> 00:16:10.703
WORKERS INSURANCE ARE
00:16:10.769 --> 00:16:13.172
JUSTIFIABLY BE SAID ON THE
00:16:13.238 --> 00:16:15.140
DETAILS WERE CASE. BOTTOM RIGHT
00:16:15.207 --> 00:16:16.709
I'M AND WHICH WAS SO THE
00:16:16.775 --> 00:16:18.477
PROTECTION SUCH AS SUPPORT OF
00:16:18.544 --> 00:16:27.619
THIS TOP SPONSOR. THANK YOU
00:16:27.686 --> 00:16:29.521
VERY MUCH EXACTLY MINUTE WELL
00:16:29.588 --> 00:16:30.456
TO. ARE NOW WE ARE GOING TO ON
00:16:30.522 --> 00:16:32.958
TO ANYONE. WHO WISHES TO. OUR
00:16:33.025 --> 00:16:34.226
AND WE ASK THE AT THE IN TIME
00:16:34.293 --> 00:16:36.929
FOR THEIR- NAME AFFILIATION AND
00:16:36.995 --> 00:16:39.164
POSITION. IN SUPPORT OR
00:16:39.231 --> 00:16:41.834
OPPOSITION. WITHOUT FURTHER
00:16:41.900 --> 00:16:43.635
EXPOSITION ON THAT POSITION
00:16:43.702 --> 00:16:45.504
WE'VE HEARD TWO WITNESSES WILL
00:16:45.571 --> 00:16:47.272
HAVE TO WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
00:16:47.339 --> 00:16:49.041
AND AN EQUALLY TWO WITNESSES IN
00:16:49.108 --> 00:16:51.610
OPPOSITION ABLE TO PRESENTED
00:16:51.677 --> 00:16:53.345
WITH FOR A TOTAL OF THREE
00:16:53.412 --> 00:16:55.514
MINUTES. SO WHAT WE WILL DO
00:16:55.581 --> 00:17:00.519
NOW. IS WE WILL MAKE SURE THAT
00:17:00.586 --> 00:17:02.654
OF ALL THOSE WHO ARE WISHING TO
00:17:02.721 --> 00:17:04.723
TESTIFY ARE IN THE QUEUE
00:17:04.790 --> 00:17:06.692
WISHING TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT
00:17:06.759 --> 00:17:08.727
AGAIN LIMITING THEIR NAME THEIR
00:17:08.794 --> 00:17:09.962
COMMENTS TO THEIR NAME
00:17:10.028 --> 00:17:12.297
AFFILIATION AND THEIR POSITION
00:17:12.364 --> 00:17:13.899
ON THE MEASURE EITHER IN
00:17:13.966 --> 00:17:15.801
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. OR WE
00:17:15.868 --> 00:17:18.303
HAVE AN OCCASIONAL WITNESS WHO
00:17:18.370 --> 00:17:20.105
COMES IN ITS STRONG NEUTRALITY
00:17:20.172 --> 00:17:23.375
SO AGAIN WE WILL ALLOW YOU TO
00:17:23.442 --> 00:17:26.678
GIVE US THAT INFORMATION AND-
00:17:26.745 --> 00:17:28.147
LET'S GO TO SEE IF THERE ARE
00:17:28.213 --> 00:17:30.949
ANY WITNESSES IN ROME FORTY TWO
00:17:31.016 --> 00:17:32.384
OR THREE WHO WISH TO STAND UP
00:17:32.451 --> 00:17:34.653
AT THE MICROPHONE. IDENTIFY
00:17:34.720 --> 00:17:36.455
THEMSELVES OR AFFILIATION- AND
00:17:36.522 --> 00:17:38.557
THEIR POSITION BY CHOOSING NONE
00:17:38.624 --> 00:17:41.927
IN FORTY TWO OR THREE ARE THERE
00:17:41.994 --> 00:17:43.061
ANY WITNESSES IN ROOM TWENTY
00:17:43.128 --> 00:17:47.466
FORTY. APPEARING TO BE NONE-
00:17:47.533 --> 00:17:48.801
WILL MOVE ON TO WITNESSES
00:17:48.867 --> 00:17:50.269
WAITING TO TESTIFY BE THE
00:17:50.335 --> 00:17:52.905
TELECONFERENCE ORVIS- MODERATOR
00:17:52.971 --> 00:17:54.573
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE PROMPT THE
00:17:54.640 --> 00:17:57.009
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY.
00:17:57.075 --> 00:18:00.479
IN SUPPORT OF AB NINETEEN FORTY
00:18:00.546 --> 00:18:04.349
SEVEN WE WILL BEGIN. THANK YOU
00:18:04.416 --> 00:18:05.984
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
00:18:06.051 --> 00:18:08.921
OF AB IN NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN
00:18:08.987 --> 00:18:11.256
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
00:18:11.323 --> 00:18:14.660
AT THIS TIME. AND WE'LL WAIT
00:18:14.726 --> 00:18:17.129
ONE MINUTE TO SEE WHO LINES UP
00:18:17.196 --> 00:18:18.630
AND THEN I WILL ASK YOU MATTER
00:18:18.697 --> 00:18:21.266
MODERATOR IF YOU COULD. IN
00:18:21.333 --> 00:18:22.968
ABOUT THIRTY SECONDS OR SO GIVE
00:18:23.035 --> 00:18:24.570
ME THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PEOPLE
00:18:24.636 --> 00:18:26.271
WHO ARE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
00:18:26.338 --> 00:18:44.957
SUPPORT. THIRTY SECONDS IS A
00:18:45.023 --> 00:18:46.725
LONG TIME IS SENATE ALL RIGHT
00:18:46.792 --> 00:18:48.594
DO YOU HAVE ANY INDICATION NOW
00:18:48.660 --> 00:18:51.096
MADAME MODERATOR OF HOW MANY
00:18:51.163 --> 00:18:52.898
PEOPLE THERE ARE WAITING TO
00:18:52.965 --> 00:18:56.068
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
00:18:56.134 --> 00:18:58.303
WE HAVE FIVE IN Q. VERY GOOD IF
00:18:58.370 --> 00:18:59.938
YOU PLEASE OPEN THE LINES AND
00:19:00.005 --> 00:19:01.773
CALL THE SUPPORT WITNESSES
00:19:01.840 --> 00:19:05.344
INDIVIDUALLY WILL CONTINUE.
00:19:05.410 --> 00:19:07.079
THANK YOU LINE ONE ZERO NINE
00:19:07.145 --> 00:19:09.648
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING
00:19:09.715 --> 00:19:11.083
JESSICA CENTER ON BEHALF OF
00:19:11.149 --> 00:19:12.751
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES AND THE
00:19:12.818 --> 00:19:14.586
STRONGER CALIFORNIA ADVOCATES
00:19:14.653 --> 00:19:16.455
NETWORK AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:19:16.522 --> 00:19:19.458
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
00:19:19.525 --> 00:19:21.226
YOU RIDE A ONE HUNDRED AND
00:19:21.293 --> 00:19:24.263
FOURTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD. I AM
00:19:24.329 --> 00:19:25.631
NOT ACOSTA ON BEHALF OF THE
00:19:25.697 --> 00:19:27.432
ACLU OF CALIFORNIA AND THE
00:19:27.499 --> 00:19:31.670
COURT. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
00:19:31.737 --> 00:19:33.005
THANK YOU BYE NINETY SIX PLEASE
00:19:33.071 --> 00:19:36.742
GO AHEAD. DANIEL GUTIERREZ ON
00:19:36.808 --> 00:19:38.010
BEHALF OF THE COMMUNICATIONS
00:19:38.076 --> 00:19:40.045
WORKERS OF AMERICA DISTRICT
00:19:40.112 --> 00:19:42.080
NINE IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT
00:19:42.147 --> 00:19:46.919
WITNESS. THANK YOU ITEM ONE
00:19:46.985 --> 00:19:49.354
EIGHTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:19:49.421 --> 00:19:50.689
JACKIE TURN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:19:50.756 --> 00:19:52.157
CONSUMER TRADE THE CALIFORNIA
00:19:52.224 --> 00:19:54.326
AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT
00:19:54.393 --> 00:19:58.597
WITNESS. THANK YOU I ONE ZERO
00:19:58.664 --> 00:20:01.800
FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD. KATHLEEN
00:20:01.867 --> 00:20:03.168
BACK IT TOOK TO BUY IN MY
00:20:03.235 --> 00:20:04.937
PERSONAL CAPACITY ALTHOUGH I AM
00:20:05.003 --> 00:20:06.538
ON THE ADVISORY BOARD FOR CLEAN
00:20:06.605 --> 00:20:10.375
CAR WASH IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
00:20:10.442 --> 00:20:13.445
ARE THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES
00:20:13.512 --> 00:20:18.116
IN SUPPORT MADAME MODERATOR. I
00:20:18.183 --> 00:20:20.352
HAVE NO FOR THEIR LINES IN Q.
00:20:20.419 --> 00:20:23.689
AT THIS TIME VERY GOOD. SO ARE.
00:20:23.755 --> 00:20:27.225
WE WILL NOW HEAR FROM WITNESSES
00:20:27.292 --> 00:20:31.997
IN OPPOSITION I BELIEVE WE HAVE
00:20:32.064 --> 00:20:33.332
TO OUR OR CHOOSE ME ONE WITNESS
00:20:33.398 --> 00:20:35.334
IN OPPOSITION PREPARED TO SPEAK
00:20:35.400 --> 00:20:37.903
BàN THE BANK WITH THE
00:20:37.970 --> 00:20:40.472
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
00:20:40.539 --> 00:20:43.108
IS ON THE LINE IN OPPOSITION IS
00:20:43.175 --> 00:20:45.811
THAT CORRECT MYSTERY BACK. YES
00:20:45.877 --> 00:20:47.879
MADAM CHAIR THANK YOU IDENTITY
00:20:47.946 --> 00:20:48.847
COME OUT FOR THE CALIFORNIA
00:20:48.914 --> 00:20:50.082
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND WE'RE
00:20:50.148 --> 00:20:52.117
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED TO AB
00:20:52.184 --> 00:20:53.418
NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN. I WILL
00:20:53.485 --> 00:20:55.020
NOT BELABOR THE POINT WE'VE HAD
00:20:55.087 --> 00:20:56.655
THAT OPPOSED TO PREVIOUS
00:20:56.722 --> 00:20:58.023
VERSIONS OF THIS BILL IN RECENT
00:20:58.090 --> 00:20:59.725
YEARS AND TO BE BRIEF WE HAVE
00:20:59.791 --> 00:21:01.426
NO OBJECTION TO INCREASE IN THE
00:21:01.493 --> 00:21:02.728
STATURE LIMITATIONS FOR SUCH
00:21:02.794 --> 00:21:04.896
CLAIMS. BUT WE CONTINUE TO BE
00:21:04.963 --> 00:21:05.964
TO BE OPPOSED TO THE PROVISION
00:21:06.031 --> 00:21:07.599
OF THE BILL THAT CREATES A ONE
00:21:07.666 --> 00:21:08.967
SIDED ATTORNEY FEE PROVISION OF
00:21:09.034 --> 00:21:09.668
THESE CLAIMS ARE FILED IN
00:21:09.735 --> 00:21:11.837
COURT- UNLIKE THE NEW YORK
00:21:11.903 --> 00:21:12.938
TIMES EDITORIAL WE DO THINK
00:21:13.005 --> 00:21:14.873
THIS INCENTIVE WILL DRIVE MORE
00:21:14.940 --> 00:21:15.707
CLAIMS TO BE FILED IN COURT
00:21:15.774 --> 00:21:17.843
WHICH IS MORE COSTLY AN
00:21:17.909 --> 00:21:19.177
ADVERSARIAL. IN THE LABOR
00:21:19.244 --> 00:21:20.679
COMMISSIONER PROCESS AND RAISES
00:21:20.746 --> 00:21:22.414
THE COSTS FOR ALL SIDES FOR
00:21:22.481 --> 00:21:23.949
THESE REASONS RECOUP WE REMAIN
00:21:24.016 --> 00:21:25.217
OPPOSED TO THIS PROPOSAL AND
00:21:25.283 --> 00:21:27.386
ASK FOR A NO VOTE ON A. B.
00:21:27.452 --> 00:21:28.186
NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN THANK YOU.
00:21:28.253 --> 00:21:30.122
THANK YOU SIR ARE THERE ANY
00:21:30.188 --> 00:21:31.857
OTHER WITNESSES WHO WISH TO
00:21:31.923 --> 00:21:34.459
TESTIFY OR WHO ARE ONLINE TO
00:21:34.526 --> 00:21:38.530
TEST FIVE WITH ABOUT A- MINUTE.
00:21:38.597 --> 00:21:40.899
AND IT'S ACTUALLY OF TIME A
00:21:40.966 --> 00:21:44.503
COUPLE OR ANY OTHER WITNESS IN
00:21:44.569 --> 00:21:46.038
OPPOSITION. HI TING NONE WILL
00:21:46.104 --> 00:21:50.108
NOW OPEN THE- NINE TO AT ANY
00:21:50.175 --> 00:21:50.676
OTHER WAY. WHO WERE TO GIVE
00:21:50.742 --> 00:21:52.077
THEIR NAME AFFILIATION AND
00:21:52.144 --> 00:21:55.147
POSITION. MADAME MODERATOR
00:21:55.213 --> 00:21:57.549
COULD YOU. PLEASE CHECK THE
00:21:57.616 --> 00:22:01.053
LINE AND- ASK FOR WITNESSES IN
00:22:01.119 --> 00:22:05.190
OPPOSITION TO. SIGN ON AND TO
00:22:05.257 --> 00:22:08.727
BE HEARD. THANK YOU IF YOU WISH
00:22:08.794 --> 00:22:10.062
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OUT OF
00:22:10.128 --> 00:22:12.931
AB ONE NINE FOUR SEVEN PLEASE
00:22:12.998 --> 00:22:14.866
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:22:14.933 --> 00:22:18.737
TIME AND EXCUSE ME MY MISTAKE I
00:22:18.804 --> 00:22:20.272
NEED TO ASK IF THERE ANY
00:22:20.338 --> 00:22:22.174
WITNESSES ACTUALLY PRESENT IN
00:22:22.240 --> 00:22:23.942
ROOM FORTY TWO OH THREE WHO
00:22:24.009 --> 00:22:25.310
WOULD LIKE TO. TESTIFY IN
00:22:25.377 --> 00:22:27.045
OPPOSITION ANYWAY WITNESSES
00:22:27.112 --> 00:22:29.314
HERE WHO WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:22:29.381 --> 00:22:31.416
IN OPPOSITION. RIGHT SEEING NON
00:22:31.483 --> 00:22:33.452
ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES IN ROOM
00:22:33.518 --> 00:22:35.020
TWENTY FORTY. WHO WISH TO
00:22:35.087 --> 00:22:38.957
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO AB
00:22:39.024 --> 00:22:39.691
NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN. SEEING
00:22:39.758 --> 00:22:42.494
NONE. OF MADAME MODERATOR TO
00:22:42.561 --> 00:22:43.862
LET'S GO TO YOU AND SEE IF
00:22:43.929 --> 00:22:44.463
THERE ANY PEOPLE ON THE LINE
00:22:44.529 --> 00:22:46.031
WHO WISH TO TESTIFY IN
00:22:46.098 --> 00:22:48.533
OPPOSITION AND IF SO COULD YOU
00:22:48.600 --> 00:22:51.570
TELL US HOW MANY THERE ARE. YOU
00:22:51.636 --> 00:22:53.638
ARE FOR IN Q. VERY GOOD LET'S
00:22:53.705 --> 00:22:58.477
PROCEED. THANK YOU OVER TO LINE
00:22:58.543 --> 00:23:01.780
ONE LINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:23:01.847 --> 00:23:03.115
MORNING MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS THE
00:23:03.181 --> 00:23:04.883
CALL RIGHT CALIFORNIA
00:23:04.950 --> 00:23:05.784
MANUFACTURES AND TECHNOLOGY
00:23:05.851 --> 00:23:08.353
ASSOCIATION AND REACH YOUR
00:23:08.420 --> 00:23:10.422
RESPECTFULLY ACCOUNT THANK YOU.
00:23:10.489 --> 00:23:13.158
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE.
00:23:13.225 --> 00:23:14.993
THANK YOU LINE ONE HUNDRED AND
00:23:15.060 --> 00:23:17.896
SEVENTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:23:17.963 --> 00:23:18.930
MORNING MEMBERS OF THE
00:23:18.997 --> 00:23:20.132
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE RICHARD
00:23:20.198 --> 00:23:21.800
MARCUSSEN FOR THE WESTERN
00:23:21.867 --> 00:23:23.802
ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS
00:23:23.869 --> 00:23:27.506
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION. NEXT
00:23:27.572 --> 00:23:30.609
WITNESS PLEASE THANK YOU SIR.
00:23:30.675 --> 00:23:32.244
THANK YOU LINE ONE HUNDRED AND
00:23:32.310 --> 00:23:35.914
TWELVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:23:35.981 --> 00:23:37.415
MORNING KATIE HANSON WITH THE
00:23:37.482 --> 00:23:40.485
CALIFORNIA RESTAURANT
00:23:40.552 --> 00:23:41.119
ASSOCIATION WE ARE RESPECTFULLY
00:23:41.186 --> 00:23:43.522
OPPOSED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:23:43.588 --> 00:23:45.757
ANY OTHER WITNESSES ON THE LINE
00:23:45.824 --> 00:23:47.058
MATTER MODERATOR WHO WOULD LIKE
00:23:47.125 --> 00:23:48.593
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO
00:23:48.660 --> 00:23:52.364
THIS MEASURE. NINE ONE OH SIX
00:23:52.430 --> 00:23:55.400
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU
00:23:55.467 --> 00:23:56.635
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS CHECKS
00:23:56.701 --> 00:23:58.370
IS NOT FROM THE FACT THAT
00:23:58.436 --> 00:24:00.405
INSURANCE WITH ALREADY OPPOSED
00:24:00.472 --> 00:24:01.173
TO THE BILL THANK YOU. THANK
00:24:01.239 --> 00:24:05.544
YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM A
00:24:05.610 --> 00:24:06.144
MODERATOR ARE THERE ANY OTHER
00:24:06.211 --> 00:24:09.014
WITNESSES. I HAVE A BROTHER
00:24:09.080 --> 00:24:11.316
LIVES IN Q. AT THIS TIME ALL
00:24:11.383 --> 00:24:15.253
RIGHT SO- NOW WE WILL BRING THE
00:24:15.320 --> 00:24:18.256
MATTER BACK TO DISCUSSION OF
00:24:18.323 --> 00:24:19.791
WITHIN THE DYE IS HERE AND
00:24:19.858 --> 00:24:22.961
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. AND
00:24:23.028 --> 00:24:25.397
LET'S GO AHEAD AND- I BELIEVE A
00:24:25.463 --> 00:24:26.998
SENATOR BORCHERS SHE WANTED TO
00:24:27.065 --> 00:24:30.368
SPEAK. THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
00:24:30.435 --> 00:24:33.705
I'D LIKE TO ALSO- EXPRESS A
00:24:33.772 --> 00:24:36.274
HEARTY- CONGRATULATIONS TO OUR
00:24:36.341 --> 00:24:38.243
NEWEST MEMBER- SENT FORMER
00:24:38.310 --> 00:24:40.212
ASSEMBLY WOMAN MELINDA'S NOW
00:24:40.278 --> 00:24:42.414
SENATOR MELINDA'S TO OUR FIND
00:24:42.480 --> 00:24:45.650
COMMITTEE. I HAVE A QUESTION
00:24:45.717 --> 00:24:47.485
AND I'M NOT CERTAIN TO WHOM I
00:24:47.552 --> 00:24:52.691
SUPPOSE IT IS. IT'S. IF A PARTY
00:24:52.757 --> 00:24:56.494
INITIATES SUIT OR A GRIEVANCE
00:24:56.561 --> 00:24:58.496
ON TO THE LABOR COMMISSIONER.
00:24:58.563 --> 00:25:02.634
CAN AT THAT- GRIEVANCE BE
00:25:02.701 --> 00:25:04.469
WITHDRAWN IF THE PARTIES
00:25:04.536 --> 00:25:06.872
SETTLED THE MATTER OUTSIDE OF
00:25:06.938 --> 00:25:10.642
THE COMMISSION SETTING. TWO WE
00:25:10.709 --> 00:25:13.945
ED IT MADAM PRESENTER FOOD LIKE
00:25:14.012 --> 00:25:15.947
TO SPEAK OR WE DO HAVE TO I
00:25:16.014 --> 00:25:17.983
BELIEVE THE TO- WITNESSES
00:25:18.049 --> 00:25:20.919
EXPERTS ON THE LINE WHO MAY BE
00:25:20.986 --> 00:25:22.053
ABLE TO ASSIST IN ANSWERING
00:25:22.120 --> 00:25:24.623
THAT QUESTION THE STANDARD ARE
00:25:24.689 --> 00:25:31.763
YOU STILL ON THE LINE. SORRY.
00:25:31.830 --> 00:25:34.299
TO HAVE MR OFF. YES MERRY GO
00:25:34.366 --> 00:25:36.501
MERRY WHICH USED MY UNDER IS
00:25:36.568 --> 00:25:38.904
YEAH AND IF THE IF THE MATTER
00:25:38.970 --> 00:25:40.805
IS SETTLED THAT BIN AND THEN IT
00:25:40.872 --> 00:25:42.540
WILL BE WITHDRAWN FROM THE
00:25:42.607 --> 00:25:44.910
LABOR COMMISSIONER'S PROCESS TO
00:25:44.976 --> 00:25:46.544
A FINANCIAL SETTLEMENT BETWEEN
00:25:46.611 --> 00:25:49.748
THE PARTIES THAT'S REACHED-
00:25:49.814 --> 00:25:51.082
COULD CRITICIZE TO ASIAN WHERE
00:25:51.149 --> 00:25:53.518
THE GRIEVANCES WITHDRAWN FROM
00:25:53.585 --> 00:25:54.786
THE LABOR COMMISSION. THAT'S
00:25:54.853 --> 00:26:00.258
CORRECT. MY UNDERSTANDING THE
00:26:00.325 --> 00:26:01.893
REASON THE REASON WHY I ASK
00:26:01.960 --> 00:26:05.697
AUTO BUT IT. I'M SORRY GO AHEAD.
00:26:05.764 --> 00:26:08.733
I KNOW GO AHEAD. THE REASON WHY
00:26:08.800 --> 00:26:10.869
I ASK IS IN THE COURSE OF
00:26:10.936 --> 00:26:13.438
BUSINESS I THINK WHAT IS LIKELY
00:26:13.505 --> 00:26:15.941
TO HAPPEN. AND I WITH ALL DUE
00:26:16.007 --> 00:26:17.676
RESPECT THE FOLKS THAT DON'T
00:26:17.742 --> 00:26:20.145
THINK THAT PLAINTIFFS ATTORNEYS
00:26:20.211 --> 00:26:21.613
FOR CONSUMER ATTORNEYS WHO
00:26:21.680 --> 00:26:23.081
WOULD TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS
00:26:23.148 --> 00:26:25.250
OPPORTUNITY. IS THAT IF IT'S
00:26:25.317 --> 00:26:27.886
THE CASE THE ATTORNEYS FEES
00:26:27.953 --> 00:26:30.021
COULD BE COLLECTED AND IT IS A
00:26:30.088 --> 00:26:34.292
ONE SIDED- AS OPPOSED TO WHAT
00:26:34.359 --> 00:26:36.061
WE LEARNED IN LAW SCHOOL THE
00:26:36.127 --> 00:26:39.197
BRITISH RULE AND- BY WAY OF
00:26:39.264 --> 00:26:42.033
BACKGROUND. THE BRITISH RULE IS
00:26:42.100 --> 00:26:45.070
THAT THE PREVAILING PARTY IS
00:26:45.136 --> 00:26:49.140
ABLE TO COLLECT NOT JUST. ON
00:26:49.207 --> 00:26:51.142
ONE SIDE A SITUATION LIKE THIS
00:26:51.209 --> 00:26:52.978
SO I THINK IN TERMS OF EQUITY I
00:26:53.044 --> 00:26:54.546
UNDERSTAND THAT THERE WILL
00:26:54.612 --> 00:26:56.214
LIKELY BE AN IMBALANCE OF
00:26:56.281 --> 00:26:59.117
RESOURCES BETWEEN A LOW WAGE
00:26:59.184 --> 00:27:01.419
EMPLOYEE VERSES EIGHT
00:27:01.486 --> 00:27:03.888
CORPORATION I UNDERSTAND THAT
00:27:03.955 --> 00:27:06.358
BUT FOR PURPOSES OF EQUITY. IF
00:27:06.424 --> 00:27:06.858
YOU'RE GOING TO MAKE FOR
00:27:06.925 --> 00:27:10.061
ATTORNEYS FEES- ON THE TABLE I
00:27:10.128 --> 00:27:12.130
THINK WE'VE HEARD FROM FOLKS IN
00:27:12.197 --> 00:27:13.898
THE BUSINESS COMMUNITY THAT ON
00:27:13.965 --> 00:27:15.300
THEY DON'T HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
00:27:15.367 --> 00:27:18.303
THE EXTENSION OF THE- STATURE
00:27:18.370 --> 00:27:20.705
THE LIMITATIONS THEY HAVE ISSUE
00:27:20.772 --> 00:27:22.607
WITH THE ATTORNEYS FEES AS TO
00:27:22.674 --> 00:27:25.443
WHY SO I THINK. IF EQUITY IS
00:27:25.510 --> 00:27:27.312
GUIDING THIS THEN I THINK IT
00:27:27.379 --> 00:27:29.681
WOULD BE APPROPRIATE TO I'LL-
00:27:29.748 --> 00:27:31.716
BOTH PARTIES THE ABILITY TO
00:27:31.783 --> 00:27:34.252
COLLECT BUT HERE'S REALLY WHERE
00:27:34.319 --> 00:27:35.487
IT'S GONNA GO I SUSPECT. IS
00:27:35.553 --> 00:27:40.091
THAT. ONE DO WE HAVE A DEFINITE
00:27:40.158 --> 00:27:41.626
DO WE HAVE A DEFINITION OF THE
00:27:41.693 --> 00:27:43.294
PREVAILING PARTY IN A CIVIL
00:27:43.361 --> 00:27:45.897
ACTION. I'M NOT CERTAIN ABOUT
00:27:45.964 --> 00:27:48.133
LABOR CIRCUMSTANCE BUT A CIVIL
00:27:48.199 --> 00:27:51.503
ACTION. IT COULD BE A PARTIAL
00:27:51.569 --> 00:27:53.505
VICTORY. LAW WOULD ALLOW AN
00:27:53.571 --> 00:27:54.606
INDIVIDUAL TO DECLARE
00:27:54.672 --> 00:27:56.107
THEMSELVES A PREVAILING PARTY
00:27:56.174 --> 00:27:59.277
IT COULD BE 51% OF THE ACTIONS
00:27:59.344 --> 00:28:00.845
OR DETERMINATIONS IN ONES
00:28:00.912 --> 00:28:04.282
FAVOR- WHATEVER THE GUIDING
00:28:04.349 --> 00:28:06.251
PRINCIPLE IS SO I DON'T KNOW
00:28:06.317 --> 00:28:08.286
HOW IT PERTAINS IN A LABOR-
00:28:08.353 --> 00:28:10.789
CONTEXT OF RETALIATION WHETHER
00:28:10.855 --> 00:28:12.490
TO ONE DETERMINED OF. JUDGMENT
00:28:12.557 --> 00:28:14.626
ON THE ISSUE OR THURSDAY
00:28:14.692 --> 00:28:16.761
ASSEMBLY OF DIFFERENT ISSUES SO
00:28:16.828 --> 00:28:18.763
I'M CONCERNED ABOUT HOW YOU
00:28:18.830 --> 00:28:19.931
WOULD COME ABOUT WITH A
00:28:19.998 --> 00:28:21.399
PREVAILING DETERMINATION THE
00:28:21.466 --> 00:28:23.902
PREVAILING PARTY BUT MORE
00:28:23.968 --> 00:28:25.804
REALISTICALLY. IF WE CAN IF WE
00:28:25.870 --> 00:28:28.173
CAN APPRECIATE THAT THESE
00:28:28.239 --> 00:28:30.542
THINGS ARE GOING TO BE SETTLED
00:28:30.608 --> 00:28:32.744
BY VIRTUE OF THE ELIGIBILITY
00:28:32.811 --> 00:28:36.247
FOR- FOR THE FOR THE
00:28:36.314 --> 00:28:38.349
ELIGIBILITY OF ATTORNEYS FEES.
00:28:38.416 --> 00:28:41.386
I CAN EASILY SEE. ATTORNEYS
00:28:41.453 --> 00:28:44.022
RACKING UP RETALIATION
00:28:44.089 --> 00:28:46.091
ALLEGATIONS AGAINST AN EMPLOYER.
00:28:46.157 --> 00:28:48.059
EMPLOYER CALCULATING THE COST
00:28:48.126 --> 00:28:50.962
OF GOING TO TRIAL OR GOING TO A
00:28:51.029 --> 00:28:52.997
REGULATORY BODY IN DEFENDING
00:28:53.064 --> 00:28:56.468
ITSELF IN SIMPLY SAYING I WILL
00:28:56.534 --> 00:28:58.436
OFFER YOU THIS TO WITHDRAW YOUR
00:28:58.503 --> 00:29:01.539
COMPLAINT. AND THAT I THINK IS
00:29:01.606 --> 00:29:03.808
A TERRIBLE DISINCENTIVE IN THE
00:29:03.875 --> 00:29:06.244
WORK FORCE BECAUSE THE
00:29:06.311 --> 00:29:07.545
CORPORATION OR THE BUSINESS
00:29:07.612 --> 00:29:09.080
WILL SIPLYLOOK AT THE
00:29:09.147 --> 00:29:10.849
OVERHEAD OF WHAT IT TAKES TO GO
00:29:10.915 --> 00:29:13.118
THROUGH A REGULATORY REVIEW
00:29:13.184 --> 00:29:15.153
WORD MINISTRY TO REVIEW. AND
00:29:15.220 --> 00:29:18.857
JUST PAY IT OUT SO BY VOLUME
00:29:18.923 --> 00:29:19.357
YOU COULD BE LOOKING AT
00:29:19.424 --> 00:29:23.361
ATTORNEYS. ASSEMBLING A NUMBER
00:29:23.428 --> 00:29:25.096
OF INDIVIDUALS AND HAVE THIS
00:29:25.163 --> 00:29:27.732
BEING A CASH COW SO- I THINK I
00:29:27.799 --> 00:29:29.567
WOULD CERTAINLY SUPPORT THE
00:29:29.634 --> 00:29:31.870
FIRST PART OF IT. I WOULD ASK
00:29:31.936 --> 00:29:35.039
THE AUTHOR OR THE PERSON
00:29:35.106 --> 00:29:37.175
REPRESENTING THE AUTHOR. CAN'T
00:29:37.242 --> 00:29:38.810
WE JUST LEAVE THE FIRST PART
00:29:38.877 --> 00:29:40.979
THERE FOR THE EXTENSION. AND
00:29:41.045 --> 00:29:42.714
WITHDRAW THE ATTORNEY'S FEES
00:29:42.780 --> 00:29:44.048
PORTION THAT I THINK WOULD MAKE
00:29:44.115 --> 00:29:46.918
THIS. A BI PARTISAN IN
00:29:46.985 --> 00:29:47.952
CERTAINLY AN ACCEPTABLE BILL IN
00:29:48.019 --> 00:29:49.721
MY OPINION THANK YOU CENTER
00:29:49.787 --> 00:29:50.889
PORCHES BEFORE I GO TO SENATOR
00:29:50.955 --> 00:29:53.391
MORNING LET ME OBSERVE WE DON'T
00:29:53.458 --> 00:29:54.959
USE THE BRITISH SYSTEM- AND
00:29:55.026 --> 00:29:56.127
THERE'S A GOOD REASON WE DON'T
00:29:56.194 --> 00:29:57.829
WE HAVE VERY DIFFERENT SYSTEMS
00:29:57.896 --> 00:30:00.865
OF JUSTICE. AND IN TERMS OF THE
00:30:00.932 --> 00:30:03.768
BALANCE OF POWER. THERE'S NO
00:30:03.835 --> 00:30:05.570
QUESTION THAT CORPORATIONS.
00:30:05.637 --> 00:30:08.439
HAVE MUCH GREATER RESOURCES AND
00:30:08.506 --> 00:30:10.108
WITHOUT THE ABILITY TO HAVE AN
00:30:10.175 --> 00:30:11.209
ATTORNEY'S FEES PRISON
00:30:11.276 --> 00:30:13.811
PREVENTION. MANY PARTICULAR OF
00:30:13.878 --> 00:30:15.713
OUR LOW WAGE WORKERS HAVE NO
00:30:15.780 --> 00:30:17.682
RESOURCES I DON'T KNOW TOO MANY
00:30:17.749 --> 00:30:19.517
ATTORNEYS WHO ARE WILLING TO
00:30:19.584 --> 00:30:21.586
WORK FOR FREE THESE DAYS. AND
00:30:21.653 --> 00:30:23.321
WE CERTAINLY PULL THE PLUG ON A
00:30:23.388 --> 00:30:25.790
LOT OF OUR LEGAL AID PROGRAMS
00:30:25.857 --> 00:30:26.991
THE PEOPLE WHO WOULD DO THAT
00:30:27.058 --> 00:30:30.428
SO- I THINK THAT TO. YOU'D LIKE
00:30:30.495 --> 00:30:32.163
TO BRING A BILL PERHAPS PICTURE
00:30:32.230 --> 00:30:33.665
THAT PUSHED MOVES US INTO THE
00:30:33.731 --> 00:30:35.633
BRITISH SYSTEM I'M SURE THAT
00:30:35.700 --> 00:30:37.902
THAT WOULD TO. BE SOMETHING
00:30:37.969 --> 00:30:40.505
THAT- YOU COULD TO- I THINK THE
00:30:40.572 --> 00:30:42.106
SYSTEM WE HAVE HERE WORKS WELL
00:30:42.173 --> 00:30:44.576
AND THESE DIRE PREDICTIONS JUST
00:30:44.642 --> 00:30:46.844
DON'T EVER SEEM TO HAPPEN- SO.
00:30:46.911 --> 00:30:49.080
THE WORST CASE SCENARIO IS MORE
00:30:49.147 --> 00:30:51.549
FICTIONAL THAN FACT AND- I
00:30:51.616 --> 00:30:54.485
THINK WE- WE REALLY NEED TO.
00:30:54.552 --> 00:30:57.855
RECOGNIZE THAT. LAWSUIT AND-
00:30:57.922 --> 00:30:59.857
THE OPPORTUNITY TO EQUALIZE THE
00:30:59.924 --> 00:31:02.060
PLAYING FIELD JUST SIMPLY DON'T
00:31:02.126 --> 00:31:04.529
HAPPEN IF. PLAINTIFFS WHO ARE
00:31:04.596 --> 00:31:06.297
MOST OF THEM. WITHOUT THE
00:31:06.364 --> 00:31:08.433
RESOURCES ARE FIGHTING THE
00:31:08.499 --> 00:31:11.803
GOLIATH OF CORPORATE AMERICA
00:31:11.869 --> 00:31:12.303
WE'RE MANY OF THEM HAVE
00:31:12.370 --> 00:31:15.840
STABLES. ALL FOR A- UP ON ON
00:31:15.907 --> 00:31:21.246
SITE COUNCIL. THE RARE IN TO GO
00:31:21.312 --> 00:31:22.280
AND VERY HAPPY TO. AND THESE
00:31:22.347 --> 00:31:23.648
CLAIMS AND OF COURSE IF IT'S A
00:31:23.715 --> 00:31:25.116
FRIVOLOUS LAWSUIT AGAINST
00:31:25.183 --> 00:31:26.150
THROWN OUT AND THERE ARE
00:31:26.217 --> 00:31:27.952
ATTORNEYS FEES PROVISIONS LET'S
00:31:28.019 --> 00:31:29.621
NOT FORGET. THAT THERE IS AN
00:31:29.687 --> 00:31:31.155
INHERENT BALANCE THAT IS
00:31:31.222 --> 00:31:32.523
CREATED WHEN YOU HAVE A
00:31:32.590 --> 00:31:34.459
FRIVOLOUS LAWSUIT. LAWYERS
00:31:34.525 --> 00:31:36.094
GENERALLY WON'T TAKE A CASE
00:31:36.160 --> 00:31:37.895
UNLESS THEY BELIEVE THAT THERE
00:31:37.962 --> 00:31:38.997
IS MERIT TO IT BECAUSE THEY
00:31:39.063 --> 00:31:41.032
WON'T GET PAID. AND AS SOMEONE
00:31:41.099 --> 00:31:43.334
WHO HAS PRACTICED LAW- YOU
00:31:43.401 --> 00:31:45.803
DON'T. WANT TO TAKE THOSE CASES
00:31:45.870 --> 00:31:47.639
BECAUSE THERE'S USUALLY NOT
00:31:47.705 --> 00:31:49.574
ONLY YOUR TIME THAT IS NOT
00:31:49.641 --> 00:31:51.709
COMPENSATED BUT OUT OF POCKET
00:31:51.776 --> 00:31:54.379
EXPENSES AS WELL. AND OF COURSE
00:31:54.445 --> 00:31:55.980
IF A SETTLEMENT IS REACHED- THE
00:31:56.047 --> 00:31:58.383
CASE IS RESOLVED AND- THAT'S
00:31:58.449 --> 00:32:00.752
WHAT WE'RE HOPING TO HAVE
00:32:00.818 --> 00:32:02.920
HAPPEN AND FRANKLY SOME OF US
00:32:02.987 --> 00:32:04.188
ARE HOPING THAT WE DON'T HAVE
00:32:04.255 --> 00:32:06.924
TO EVEN. UP THE SHOULD BE. COMP
00:32:06.991 --> 00:32:09.027
WILL COMPLY. AND THAT'S THE
00:32:09.093 --> 00:32:10.461
ULTIMATE GOAL IN IF YOU HAVE A
00:32:10.528 --> 00:32:11.629
HEAVY CAMERA THAT'S THE
00:32:11.696 --> 00:32:17.302
INCENTIVE. OFFER COMPLIANCE AND
00:32:17.368 --> 00:32:20.905
CHANGED THE WORKING WELL SO
00:32:20.972 --> 00:32:24.542
WITH THAT SENATOR MONNING. I
00:32:24.609 --> 00:32:26.711
JUST WANTED ALSO MY WELCOMING.
00:32:26.778 --> 00:32:28.246
MELINDA'S TO THE COMMITTEE
00:32:28.313 --> 00:32:31.382
WELCOME- THIS IS WHERE WE GET
00:32:31.449 --> 00:32:32.784
TO HAMMER OUT ALL KINDS OF
00:32:32.850 --> 00:32:35.486
EXCITING LEGAL ISSUES IF YOU
00:32:35.553 --> 00:32:37.155
WANT A LAWYER COMING IN YOU'LL
00:32:37.221 --> 00:32:39.824
BE A- LAWYER LEAVING- FOR
00:32:39.891 --> 00:32:42.493
BETTER OR WORSE IN A- COUPLE OF
00:32:42.560 --> 00:32:44.295
COMMENTS THE CHAIR ADDRESS SOME
00:32:44.362 --> 00:32:47.565
OF THIS. IT'S MY EXPERIENCE
00:32:47.632 --> 00:32:49.600
THAT IF THERE'S AN OUT OF COURT
00:32:49.667 --> 00:32:50.868
SETTLEMENT BETWEEN AN EMPLOYEE
00:32:50.935 --> 00:32:53.104
AND EMPLOYER. PART OF THAT
00:32:53.171 --> 00:32:54.372
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT IS THE
00:32:54.439 --> 00:32:55.973
WITHDRAWAL OF THE CHARGE FROM
00:32:56.040 --> 00:32:58.076
THE LABOR COMMISSIONER IT'S
00:32:58.142 --> 00:33:00.378
NEGOTIATED IT'S PART OF THE
00:33:00.445 --> 00:33:01.946
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT. THERE'S
00:33:02.013 --> 00:33:04.048
NOTHING IN THIS THAT PREVENTS.
00:33:04.115 --> 00:33:05.583
THAT BEING A COMPONENT OF A
00:33:05.650 --> 00:33:09.120
SETTLED CASE. ON THE ATTORNEY'S
00:33:09.187 --> 00:33:11.889
FEES ISSUE WE'VE ACTUALLY HAD
00:33:11.956 --> 00:33:14.258
LEGISLATION PROPOSED. TO
00:33:14.325 --> 00:33:21.299
REQUIRE- LOSING. PLAINTIFF WHO
00:33:21.366 --> 00:33:22.533
ALLEGES RETALIATION HAVE TO
00:33:22.600 --> 00:33:24.769
SHOULDER ATTORNEYS FEES AND
00:33:24.836 --> 00:33:26.537
THAT'S NEVER MADE IT THROUGH
00:33:26.604 --> 00:33:30.441
THE LEGISLATURE AND IN TWO.
00:33:30.508 --> 00:33:31.542
WELL YOU CAN LOOK AT THE
00:33:31.609 --> 00:33:32.377
BALANCE OF POWER IN THE
00:33:32.443 --> 00:33:34.846
LEGISLATURE OR YOU CAN LOOK AT
00:33:34.912 --> 00:33:35.747
THE EQUITY QUESTION OF WHAT ARE
00:33:35.813 --> 00:33:38.549
WE TO PUTS THE PUBLIC POLICY.
00:33:38.616 --> 00:33:41.352
OF ANALYZING AN EMPLOYER WHO
00:33:41.419 --> 00:33:44.589
RETALIATES ILLEGALLY AGAINST AN
00:33:44.655 --> 00:33:46.491
EMPLOYEE. WHO COMPLAINS THAT
00:33:46.557 --> 00:33:48.192
SAY ABOUT AN UNSAFE WORKING
00:33:48.259 --> 00:33:49.794
CONDITION. BUT SAY WORKING
00:33:49.861 --> 00:33:51.896
CONDITION THAT COULD COULD
00:33:51.963 --> 00:33:53.831
SERIOUSLY INJURE OR KILL OTHER
00:33:53.898 --> 00:33:56.100
WORKERS. A WORKER BRINGS THAT
00:33:56.167 --> 00:33:56.901
TO THE ATTENTION OF
00:33:56.968 --> 00:33:59.170
AUTHORITIES. AND IS TERMINATED
00:33:59.237 --> 00:34:03.274
FOR THAT. IF THERE'S THE THREAT
00:34:03.341 --> 00:34:05.109
OF HAVING TO SHOULDER.
00:34:05.176 --> 00:34:07.745
EXTRAORDINARY ATTORNEY'S FEES
00:34:07.812 --> 00:34:10.448
IF YOU DON'T PREVAIL. IN THAT
00:34:10.515 --> 00:34:13.518
CASE. EIGHT THE PUBLIC POLICY
00:34:13.584 --> 00:34:15.953
IMPACT IS A CHILLING IMPACT ON
00:34:16.020 --> 00:34:20.658
BRINGING TO THE. FOR REPORTS
00:34:20.725 --> 00:34:24.829
EXERCISING EXISTING ENFORCEMENT
00:34:24.896 --> 00:34:26.364
MECHANISMS WHETHER THAT'S TO
00:34:26.431 --> 00:34:27.732
CAL OSHA OR THE LABOR
00:34:27.799 --> 00:34:29.233
COMMISSIONER ON WAGE CLAIMS
00:34:29.300 --> 00:34:31.035
THAT CENTURY SO THE PUBLIC
00:34:31.102 --> 00:34:34.639
POLICY DIVIDE IN IN WHAT MAY
00:34:34.705 --> 00:34:36.040
LOOK LIKE AN IMBALANCE OF WHO'S
00:34:36.107 --> 00:34:40.211
ELIGIBLE FOR ATTORNEYS FEES IT
00:34:40.278 --> 00:34:42.146
THAT THAT IMBALANCE IN
00:34:42.213 --> 00:34:44.582
APPEARANCE IS BALANCED TERMS OF
00:34:44.649 --> 00:34:47.118
THE PUBLIC POLICY ENCOURAGED
00:34:47.185 --> 00:34:50.154
YOU DON'T WANNA CHILL AFFECT ON
00:34:50.221 --> 00:34:51.322
SOME MISSING. SOME THAT BUT IF
00:34:51.389 --> 00:34:54.358
CLEAN IN PURSUE A CASE AND
00:34:54.425 --> 00:34:56.994
DON'T PREVAIL MY FAMILY I'M
00:34:57.061 --> 00:34:57.995
WORKING FOR MINIMUM WAGE I
00:34:58.062 --> 00:34:59.497
CAN'T AFFORD TO PAY THE
00:34:59.564 --> 00:35:01.065
ATTORNEY'S FEES. OF A
00:35:01.132 --> 00:35:03.434
CORPORATION- SO THAT'S WHY I
00:35:03.501 --> 00:35:06.537
THINK THERE'S- UNNECESSARY
00:35:06.604 --> 00:35:08.272
DISTINCTION BETWEEN WHO'S
00:35:08.339 --> 00:35:11.476
ELIGIBLE ON AND IS THIS BILL
00:35:11.542 --> 00:35:12.677
BOTH EXTENDS A STATUE
00:35:12.743 --> 00:35:14.745
LIMITATIONS AND REAFFIRMS THAT
00:35:14.812 --> 00:35:16.547
PRINCIPLE I'LL BE SUPPORTING
00:35:16.614 --> 00:35:18.382
THE BILL TODAY IN MADAME SHARED
00:35:18.449 --> 00:35:20.618
LIKE TO MOVE THE BILL AT THE
00:35:20.685 --> 00:35:22.253
APPROPRIATE TIME. VERY GOOD-
00:35:22.320 --> 00:35:25.590
CENTER I CAL SKI. AND HIGH I
00:35:25.656 --> 00:35:27.425
DON'T SEE ANY OTHER HAND UP
00:35:27.492 --> 00:35:28.960
SENATOR STERN CHOICE IN WHAT
00:35:29.026 --> 00:35:31.229
YOU'RE GOOD BUT WILL END WITH
00:35:31.295 --> 00:35:32.497
THE OBSERVATION BY CENTER Y.
00:35:32.563 --> 00:35:34.031
CASKEY I'M ON PAGE SIX OF THE
00:35:34.098 --> 00:35:35.500
STAFF AND ALL SUS UNDER PRE
00:35:35.566 --> 00:35:37.235
EXISTING CLAIMS THE AUTHOR
00:35:37.301 --> 00:35:40.538
AGREES WITH THE- THE FLAPS. ARE
00:35:40.605 --> 00:35:41.839
CLAIMS THAT THERE'S NO REVIVAL
00:35:41.906 --> 00:35:45.176
SINCE THE BILL SIMON ON IT
00:35:45.243 --> 00:35:48.012
JUST. DOUBLE CHECKING. AND I
00:35:48.079 --> 00:35:49.680
WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME CENTER
00:35:49.747 --> 00:35:52.450
MELENDEZ TO THE COMMITTEE ALSO.
00:35:52.517 --> 00:35:54.986
HE SAID I SING THAT THAT'S- THE
00:35:55.052 --> 00:35:57.054
ANALYSIS THEY HAVE IN YEARS.
00:35:57.121 --> 00:35:58.422
I'M SURE WOULD YOU REPEAT THAT
00:35:58.489 --> 00:36:00.858
GET THE HIT THEY TALK ABOUT PRE
00:36:00.925 --> 00:36:01.993
SIXTEEN CLAIMS THAT THERE'S THE
00:36:02.059 --> 00:36:04.762
BILL SILENT ON ARE REVIVING ANY
00:36:04.829 --> 00:36:06.264
LAPSE CLAIMS THAT THERE IT'S
00:36:06.330 --> 00:36:08.266
ONLY GOING FORWARD A
00:36:08.332 --> 00:36:10.434
PROSPECTIVE CLAIMS THE DO A
00:36:10.501 --> 00:36:12.436
NICE ANALYSIS OF THE SUPREME
00:36:12.503 --> 00:36:14.939
COURT DECISION ON THIS SO I
00:36:15.006 --> 00:36:17.375
ASSUME THAT THAT'S- THE AUTHOR
00:36:17.441 --> 00:36:21.379
AGREES. THERE'S NO TRICKS HERE.
00:36:21.445 --> 00:36:22.613
IT LOOKS LIKE THAT IS THE CASE
00:36:22.680 --> 00:36:24.348
BUT ALL DEFERRED OF MARIE GO AS
00:36:24.415 --> 00:36:25.850
WELL AS SHE HAS ADDITIONAL OR
00:36:25.917 --> 00:36:27.151
CHRISTOPHER FOR ADDITIONAL
00:36:27.218 --> 00:36:29.053
INFORMATION ON THAT I BELIEVE
00:36:29.120 --> 00:36:29.854
THAT'S CORRECT BUT LET'S GO
00:36:29.921 --> 00:36:32.590
AHEAD AND GET CONFIRMATION- ARE
00:36:32.657 --> 00:36:35.192
ONE OF THE TWO OF YOU MISS-
00:36:35.259 --> 00:36:36.427
MISTER LET'S SEE I HAVE
00:36:36.494 --> 00:36:37.595
CHRISTOPHER AMERICAL I
00:36:37.662 --> 00:36:40.064
APOLOGIZE I DON'T LAST NAMES
00:36:40.131 --> 00:36:42.466
ARE. NOT AS QUICK TO OF TO MY
00:36:42.533 --> 00:36:45.036
MIND BUT IF EITHER OF YOU- HAS
00:36:45.102 --> 00:36:47.638
A COMMENT TO CONFIRM OR REJECT
00:36:47.705 --> 00:36:50.741
THAT I'D APPRECIATE YOUR
00:36:50.808 --> 00:36:53.978
EXPRESSING THAT TO US. YES FEET
00:36:54.045 --> 00:36:55.913
THE INTENDED NOT TO REVISE
00:36:55.980 --> 00:36:58.649
BLOCKED CLAIMS THAT IT'S FOR-
00:36:58.716 --> 00:37:01.052
EXISTING CLAIM TO EXPAND. THAT
00:37:01.118 --> 00:37:03.421
THE TIME PERIOD. FOR THOSE
00:37:03.487 --> 00:37:05.723
EXISTING CLAIM NOT TO REVISE
00:37:05.790 --> 00:37:07.758
ONES THAT HAVE ALREADY LOCKED.
00:37:07.825 --> 00:37:09.927
THANK YOU SO EXTINGUISH CLAIMS-
00:37:09.994 --> 00:37:13.798
REMAIN EXTINGUISHED. VERY GOOD.
00:37:13.864 --> 00:37:15.299
WHERE WOULD I BE ABLE TO
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:18.369
COMMENT VERY BRIEFLY WHO WHO IS
00:37:18.436 --> 00:37:18.970
THIS IF YOU IDENTIFY YOURSELF
00:37:19.036 --> 00:37:22.940
PLEASE. DYNAMIC ON BEHALF OF
00:37:23.007 --> 00:37:23.474
THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
00:37:23.541 --> 00:37:25.409
COMMERCE. IT BRIEFLY PLEASE
00:37:25.476 --> 00:37:29.714
THANK YOU. I AGREE WITH THE
00:37:29.780 --> 00:37:31.449
COMMITTEE ANNOUNCES I DID WANT
00:37:31.515 --> 00:37:34.452
TO POINT OUT ASSEMBLY BILL LINE
00:37:34.518 --> 00:37:35.019
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER RACE LAST
00:37:35.086 --> 00:37:35.920
YEAR WHICH EXTENDED THE
00:37:35.987 --> 00:37:37.521
STRUCTURE LIMITATIONS FOR
00:37:37.588 --> 00:37:39.423
CLAIMS EXPLICITLY PROVIDEDTHAT
00:37:39.490 --> 00:37:40.691
IT DID NOT REVIVED LAPSED
00:37:40.758 --> 00:37:42.627
CLAIMS SO WE THINK IT WOULD BE
00:37:42.693 --> 00:37:43.861
CONSISTENT WITH THAT STATUTE
00:37:43.928 --> 00:37:45.963
AND MORE CLEAR IF THAT'S THE
00:37:46.030 --> 00:37:47.698
INTENT TO EXPLICITLY PROVIDE SO
00:37:47.765 --> 00:37:49.667
IN THIS LEGISLATION THANK YOU.
00:37:49.734 --> 00:37:51.702
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF THAT WE
00:37:51.769 --> 00:37:54.438
DON'T HAVE OUR- CONSULTANT WITH
00:37:54.505 --> 00:37:56.674
US IN THE ROOM TO RAISE THAT
00:37:56.741 --> 00:37:59.377
ISSUE BUT CERTAINLY WE WILL.
00:37:59.443 --> 00:38:01.045
HAVE FURTHER DISCUSSIONS ALONG
00:38:01.112 --> 00:38:04.682
THAT LINE WITHOUT ANY PROMISES
00:38:04.749 --> 00:38:06.717
JUST CAN'T DO. OUR THE TO HAVE
00:38:06.784 --> 00:38:08.653
THAT ONE ON ONE BUT I DO
00:38:08.719 --> 00:38:10.888
BELIEVE THAT WAS THE INTENT AND-
00:38:10.955 --> 00:38:12.323
IF THE AUTHOR IS WILLING TO
00:38:12.390 --> 00:38:13.891
TAKE FURTHER CLARIFICATION THAT
00:38:13.958 --> 00:38:16.761
CERTAINLY- WOULD MAKE SENSE-
00:38:16.827 --> 00:38:18.829
BUT WE ARE NOW THIS BILL IS
00:38:18.896 --> 00:38:21.465
BEEN MOVED AGAIN THE MOTION. IS
00:38:21.532 --> 00:38:24.402
TO PASS. A TO APPROPRIATIONS
00:38:24.468 --> 00:38:26.103
BEFORE THAT DID YOU WISH TO SAY
00:38:26.170 --> 00:38:28.305
SOMETHING I DID- MANAGER I
00:38:28.372 --> 00:38:33.210
APOLOGIZE BUT- CHRISTOPHER AND
00:38:33.277 --> 00:38:35.146
MARIE CAL IS IT. COULD YOU
00:38:35.212 --> 00:38:36.747
REPEAT FOR ME- WHO THEY
00:38:36.814 --> 00:38:38.049
REPRESENT I DIDN'T CATCH IT AT
00:38:38.115 --> 00:38:39.917
THE BEGINNING I'M JUST TRYING
00:38:39.984 --> 00:38:40.951
TO UNDERSTAND WHO IS PROVIDING
00:38:41.018 --> 00:38:42.219
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS ON THIS
00:38:42.286 --> 00:38:46.624
BILL WE HAVE. WITH US- FASTER
00:38:46.691 --> 00:38:48.159
FOR SANCHEZ POLICY ADVOCATE
00:38:48.225 --> 00:38:49.827
WITH CHIRLA AND THEN MERRY GO
00:38:49.894 --> 00:38:51.696
YOSHIHARA. LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL
00:38:51.762 --> 00:38:52.830
POLICY DIRECTOR WITH THE
00:38:52.897 --> 00:38:54.732
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT LAWYERS
00:38:54.799 --> 00:38:57.468
ASSOCIATION OKAY SO THEY- THEY
00:38:57.535 --> 00:38:58.703
DON'T REPRESENT ORGANIZATIONS
00:38:58.769 --> 00:39:00.671
THAT OUR SPONSORS OF THIS BILL
00:39:00.738 --> 00:39:03.908
AND DO THEY. ARE THEY JUST HERE
00:39:03.974 --> 00:39:04.508
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF THE
00:39:04.575 --> 00:39:06.911
BILL. ARE THEY SPONSORS I
00:39:06.977 --> 00:39:08.179
BELIEVE THEY'RE ALSO SPONSORS
00:39:08.245 --> 00:39:11.382
OF THE BILL. AND YOU WILL YOU
00:39:11.449 --> 00:39:13.084
WILL FIND IT BOTH OF THEM.
00:39:13.150 --> 00:39:14.452
WHITE REGULARLY THE EMPLOYMENT
00:39:14.518 --> 00:39:18.055
LAW LAW. OF FOLKS AS WELL AS A
00:39:18.122 --> 00:39:21.425
CHIRLA- ARE VERY ACTIVE
00:39:21.492 --> 00:39:23.060
PARTICIPATE BUT THEY CERTAINLY
00:39:23.127 --> 00:39:25.196
SOUND LIKE- AND THEIR WELL
00:39:25.262 --> 00:39:26.697
VERSED ON THE SUBJECT I'M JUST
00:39:26.764 --> 00:39:27.598
TRYING TO UNDERSTAND BECAUSE
00:39:27.665 --> 00:39:28.799
THE AUTHOR IS IN HERE I'M NOT
00:39:28.866 --> 00:39:31.335
SURE WHY THE ARTERIES IN HERE
00:39:31.402 --> 00:39:34.105
AND SO. IT SEEMS LIKE WE HAVE
00:39:34.171 --> 00:39:35.673
OUTSIDE FOLKS ANSWERING
00:39:35.740 --> 00:39:38.609
QUESTIONS ON ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:39:38.676 --> 00:39:40.544
TOM KALRA IS BILL. WELL IT'S
00:39:40.611 --> 00:39:42.480
NOT JUST THAT UNCOMMON TO HAVE
00:39:42.546 --> 00:39:44.381
EXPERTS WHO ARE ABLE TO GIVE US
00:39:44.448 --> 00:39:47.718
FURTHER ASSISTANCE- SO. I THINK
00:39:47.785 --> 00:39:49.520
THAT WE WILL HAVE FURTHER
00:39:49.587 --> 00:39:51.789
TESTIMONY I KNOW THAT THE- RICO
00:39:51.856 --> 00:39:54.291
HAD A DOES A NUMBER. OF
00:39:54.358 --> 00:39:57.128
ANALYSES AND EFFORTS ON BEHALF
00:39:57.194 --> 00:39:59.897
OF. THE EMPLOYMENT LAW SECTION
00:39:59.964 --> 00:40:01.031
OF THE BAR AND THEY ARE THE
00:40:01.098 --> 00:40:02.032
ONES THAT ACTUALLY WERE IN THE
00:40:02.099 --> 00:40:05.236
TRENCHES THERE CONTROL IS ALSO
00:40:05.302 --> 00:40:06.570
VERY ACTIVELY INVOLVED. AND I
00:40:06.637 --> 00:40:08.405
WILL INDICATE TO THAT ONE OF
00:40:08.472 --> 00:40:10.207
THE COURTESIES THAT HAS BEEN
00:40:10.274 --> 00:40:11.742
EXTENDED AND I THINK HAVE BEEN
00:40:11.809 --> 00:40:13.978
EXTENDED TO BOTH HOUSES. IS IN
00:40:14.044 --> 00:40:16.881
ORDER TO KEEP AS FEW PEOPLE IN
00:40:16.947 --> 00:40:18.816
A CONFINED SPACE AS POSSIBLE
00:40:18.883 --> 00:40:21.118
THAT WE ARE OFFERING AND THE
00:40:21.185 --> 00:40:22.653
ASSEMBLY IS ALSO REST
00:40:22.720 --> 00:40:24.221
RECIPROCATING AND OFFERING
00:40:24.288 --> 00:40:26.323
THERE. ARE COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO
00:40:26.390 --> 00:40:27.992
PRESENT BILLS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:40:28.058 --> 00:40:30.961
AUTHORS. UNUSUAL COUNTING BUT
00:40:31.028 --> 00:40:32.563
THAT'S ONE OF THINGS WE'RE
00:40:32.630 --> 00:40:35.065
DOING SO WITH THAT THERE IS A
00:40:35.132 --> 00:40:38.068
MOTION TO PASS TO ASSEMBLY TO
00:40:38.135 --> 00:40:39.870
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS ON THIS
00:40:39.937 --> 00:40:41.639
MEASURE WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
00:40:41.705 --> 00:40:42.940
AND I'M CHAIR JUST WOULD LIKE
00:40:43.007 --> 00:40:44.408
TO SAY- I THINK ON BEHALF OF
00:40:44.475 --> 00:40:46.010
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA I THINK
00:40:46.076 --> 00:40:48.712
THE WITNESSES AND I ALSO
00:40:48.779 --> 00:40:49.313
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:40:49.380 --> 00:40:51.782
ABOUT. THANK YOU WITH THAT-
00:40:51.849 --> 00:40:53.150
MATTER IN CONSULTANT WOULD YOU
00:40:53.217 --> 00:40:54.885
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. IF THE
00:40:54.952 --> 00:40:57.321
SENATORS COULD PLEASE TURN YOUR
00:40:57.388 --> 00:40:59.857
MICROPHONES ON. THIS IS FILE
00:40:59.924 --> 00:41:03.694
ITEM TO A. B. NINETEEN FORTY
00:41:03.761 --> 00:41:05.696
SEVEN KALRA. THE MOTION IS D.
00:41:05.763 --> 00:41:06.330
PASSED THE SENATE
00:41:06.397 --> 00:41:08.866
APPROPRIATIONS. COMMITTEE
00:41:08.933 --> 00:41:13.003
JACKSON. HI JACKSON I BOARD YES
00:41:13.070 --> 00:41:17.708
NO. BORDERS NO DID ASAL.
00:41:17.775 --> 00:41:21.779
GONZALEZ GONZALEZ HI MELENDEZ
00:41:21.846 --> 00:41:25.749
NOW MELENDEZ NARROW MINING HI
00:41:25.816 --> 00:41:33.390
MY NAME AYE STERN. STERN I AM
00:41:33.457 --> 00:41:36.293
BURKE HI AMBERG I WAKE HOUSE
00:41:36.360 --> 00:41:42.233
KEY HI WHITE HOUSE SKI I. SIX
00:41:42.299 --> 00:41:44.101
BUT SIXTY TWO WITH A MEMBER
00:41:44.168 --> 00:41:45.870
MISSING CORRECT SO THE VOTE
00:41:45.936 --> 00:41:47.671
COUNT AS SIX TO TWO WILL PLACE
00:41:47.738 --> 00:41:49.173
THAT MATTER ON CALL FOR THE
00:41:49.240 --> 00:41:51.942
ABSENT MEMBERS. THANK YOU SO
00:41:52.009 --> 00:41:54.378
MUCH OF THE CENTER GONZALEZ AND
00:41:54.445 --> 00:41:57.014
NOW WE WILL MOVE TO FILE ITEM
00:41:57.081 --> 00:41:59.383
SEVEN AB TWENTY TWO EIGHT BY.
00:41:59.450 --> 00:42:01.452
SENATOR PER WHEN EXCUSE ME
00:42:01.518 --> 00:42:03.654
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN. THIS IS
00:42:03.721 --> 00:42:05.623
A CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS
00:42:05.689 --> 00:42:06.490
CHARITABLE FUNDRAISING
00:42:06.557 --> 00:42:08.959
PLATFORMS AND PLATFORM
00:42:09.026 --> 00:42:11.228
CHARITIES ARE WELCOME ASSEMBLY
00:42:11.295 --> 00:42:13.264
MEMBER WHEN THE FLOOR SHORES.
00:42:13.330 --> 00:42:15.966
THANK YOU VERY MUCH CHAIR AND
00:42:16.033 --> 00:42:17.735
SENATORS I'M HERE TODAY TO
00:42:17.801 --> 00:42:20.237
PRESENT AB TWENTY TWO OO EIGHT
00:42:20.304 --> 00:42:21.438
A BILL THAT WILL UPDATE OUR
00:42:21.505 --> 00:42:23.140
STATE LAWS ON CHARITABLE GIVING
00:42:23.207 --> 00:42:24.842
TO ACCOUNT FOR OUR NEW ONLINE
00:42:24.909 --> 00:42:26.744
METHODS OF DONATING. WHILE
00:42:26.810 --> 00:42:28.279
PROVIDING CONSUMER PROTECTION
00:42:28.345 --> 00:42:31.115
SUPPOSED DONORS AND CHARITIES.
00:42:31.181 --> 00:42:33.350
THIS BILL IS THE ONGOING WORK
00:42:33.417 --> 00:42:34.885
PRODUCT OF LITERALLY YEARS OF
00:42:34.952 --> 00:42:36.887
EFFORT BY MY OFFICE TO UPDATE
00:42:36.954 --> 00:42:38.322
CALIFORNIA LAW FOR THE NEW
00:42:38.389 --> 00:42:40.758
REALITY OF ONLINE CHARITABLE
00:42:40.824 --> 00:42:43.227
SOLICITATION. AND STAKEHOLDER
00:42:43.294 --> 00:42:44.929
NEGOTIATIONS HAVE BEEN LED BY
00:42:44.995 --> 00:42:46.997
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL THAT BEGAN
00:42:47.064 --> 00:42:52.636
LAST FALL. OUR STATE AND LOCAL
00:42:52.703 --> 00:42:53.971
COMMUNITIES MANY OF OUR
00:42:54.038 --> 00:42:55.572
CONSTITUENTS HAVE TURNED TO
00:42:55.639 --> 00:42:56.974
INTERNET TO THE INTERNET TO
00:42:57.041 --> 00:42:57.942
PROVIDE SUPPORT TO LOCAL
00:42:58.008 --> 00:42:59.910
CHARITIES. THERE ARE VARIOUS
00:42:59.977 --> 00:43:01.378
WAYS TO GIVE ONLINE INCLUDING
00:43:01.445 --> 00:43:03.480
DIRECTLY TO A CHARITY AND
00:43:03.547 --> 00:43:05.382
INDIRECTLY TO VARIOUS CHARITIES
00:43:05.449 --> 00:43:06.951
THROUGH ONLINE PLATFORMS THAT
00:43:07.017 --> 00:43:08.752
LIST ALL CHARITIES REGISTERED
00:43:08.819 --> 00:43:11.388
WITH THE IRS. THE BENEFITS AND
00:43:11.455 --> 00:43:12.356
EFFICIENCIES OF TODAY'S
00:43:12.423 --> 00:43:13.390
TECHNOLOGY ALLOWING
00:43:13.457 --> 00:43:14.792
CALIFORNIANS TO DONATE TO
00:43:14.858 --> 00:43:16.460
VIRTUALLY ANY CHARITY DO NOT
00:43:16.527 --> 00:43:18.762
FIT EASILY WITHIN THE CURRENT
00:43:18.829 --> 00:43:21.165
LETTER OF THE LAW. AT WHICH
00:43:21.231 --> 00:43:22.833
NEVER CONTEMPLATED A PERSON OR
00:43:22.900 --> 00:43:24.535
COMPANY WOULD HAVE THE CAPACITY
00:43:24.601 --> 00:43:25.703
TO SOLICIT FOR MORE THAN A
00:43:25.769 --> 00:43:27.571
HANDFUL OF PARTNER CHARITIES.
00:43:27.638 --> 00:43:29.573
AB TWENTY TWO AWAY WILL ALLOW
00:43:29.640 --> 00:43:30.741
FOR CHARITABLE FUNDRAISING
00:43:30.808 --> 00:43:32.476
PLATFORMS TO PROVIDE THE
00:43:32.543 --> 00:43:34.278
OPPORTUNITY TO EVERY CHARITY.
00:43:34.345 --> 00:43:35.446
TO REACH FAR BEYOND THEIR
00:43:35.512 --> 00:43:36.647
TRADITIONAL DONOR BASEBALL
00:43:36.714 --> 00:43:38.315
PROVIDING KEY OVERSIGHT
00:43:38.382 --> 00:43:40.384
CAPABILITIES. TO THE ATTORNEY
00:43:40.451 --> 00:43:41.618
GENERAL TO ENSURE A LEVEL
00:43:41.685 --> 00:43:43.554
PLAYING FIELD. WHAT
00:43:43.620 --> 00:43:45.089
CONVERSATIONS ARE STILL ONGOING
00:43:45.155 --> 00:43:46.323
WITH STAKEHOLDERS ON ELEMENTS
00:43:46.390 --> 00:43:48.359
OF THIS BILL. I COMMIT TO
00:43:48.425 --> 00:43:49.460
CONTINUING TO WORK WITH THIS
00:43:49.526 --> 00:43:50.894
COMMITTEE ON ANY FURTHER
00:43:50.961 --> 00:43:52.529
AMENDMENTS THAT COME FROM THE
00:43:52.596 --> 00:43:54.264
STAKEHOLDER PROCESS. TODAY I
00:43:54.331 --> 00:43:55.966
HAVE TWO WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
00:43:56.033 --> 00:43:57.368
FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
00:43:57.434 --> 00:44:00.204
ANTHONY LOU AND BRIAN ARMSTRONG.
00:44:00.270 --> 00:44:01.872
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND AGAIN
00:44:01.939 --> 00:44:03.540
DUE TO CONSTRAINTS REGARDING
00:44:03.607 --> 00:44:04.942
THE LENGTH OF HEARINGS
00:44:05.009 --> 00:44:07.011
TECHNOLOGY CONSIDERATIONS AND
00:44:07.077 --> 00:44:08.779
ARE CLEANING PROTOCOLS.
00:44:08.846 --> 00:44:11.215
COMMITTEES ARE INSTITUTING A
00:44:11.281 --> 00:44:15.019
TIME LIMIT. SO WE ARE SADLY-
00:44:15.085 --> 00:44:16.920
LIMITING A TOTAL OF THREE
00:44:16.987 --> 00:44:19.456
MINUTES PER SIDE AND ALL OTHERS
00:44:19.523 --> 00:44:21.058
WISHING TO TESTIFY. HAVE TO
00:44:21.125 --> 00:44:22.493
LIMIT THEIR COMMENTS TO NAME
00:44:22.559 --> 00:44:25.162
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
00:44:25.229 --> 00:44:29.767
MEASURES AND WITH THAT- WE HAVE
00:44:29.833 --> 00:44:30.334
VISIT THE- ADOBE ATTORNEY.
00:44:30.401 --> 00:44:32.903
ANTHONY LOU AND- DEPUTY
00:44:32.970 --> 00:44:34.304
ATTORNEY GENERAL BRIAN
00:44:34.371 --> 00:44:37.975
ARMSTRONG ON THE PHONE- WHICH
00:44:38.042 --> 00:44:39.710
ONE OF YOU WOULD LIKE TO START
00:44:39.777 --> 00:44:40.677
AND WE'LL GIVE YOU. EACH A
00:44:40.744 --> 00:44:43.680
MINUTE AND A HALF OF FOR YOUR
00:44:43.747 --> 00:44:46.083
PRESENTATIONS. GOOD MORNING HI
00:44:46.150 --> 00:44:47.584
GOOD MORNING THIS IS ANTHONY
00:44:47.651 --> 00:44:48.852
FROM THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
00:44:48.919 --> 00:44:51.255
OFFICE- I'M GONNA MAKE MOST OF
00:44:51.321 --> 00:44:52.990
THE COMMENTS AND THEN BRIAN
00:44:53.057 --> 00:44:55.225
WILL INTRODUCE THEMSELVES- AT
00:44:55.292 --> 00:44:59.329
THE END. EIJI BUT SERRA IS
00:44:59.396 --> 00:45:01.498
PLEASE THE SPOTS EIGHTEEN
00:45:01.565 --> 00:45:02.132
TWENTY TWO ZERO EIGHT THE BILL
00:45:02.199 --> 00:45:03.801
THAT WOULD PROVIDE MUCH NEEDED
00:45:03.867 --> 00:45:05.469
OVERSIGHT OF CHARITABLE FUND
00:45:05.536 --> 00:45:09.173
RATE. INTERNET PLATFORMS. WHAT
00:45:09.239 --> 00:45:10.641
ALSO ENSURE TRANSPARENCY AND
00:45:10.707 --> 00:45:12.176
PROTECT CALIFORNIA DONORS AND
00:45:12.242 --> 00:45:14.244
DECEPTIVE AND MISLEADING
00:45:14.311 --> 00:45:16.380
CHARITABLE SOLICITATIONS.
00:45:16.447 --> 00:45:18.215
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN
00:45:18.282 --> 00:45:19.416
HIGHLIGHTED THERE ARE MANY NEW
00:45:19.483 --> 00:45:22.786
WAYS THROUGH WHICH INDIVIDUALS
00:45:22.853 --> 00:45:25.055
CAN DONATE TO USING WEB OUTLOOK
00:45:25.122 --> 00:45:27.458
PUNISHED PHONE. AND EVEN OF
00:45:27.524 --> 00:45:29.059
DON'T THEIR EVENT CHARITABLE
00:45:29.126 --> 00:45:31.929
FUNDRAISING CLASS. THE CURRENT
00:45:31.995 --> 00:45:33.797
SOLICITATION WHICH WERE ADOPTED
00:45:33.864 --> 00:45:36.100
BEFORE THE INTERNET AGE IT'S
00:45:36.166 --> 00:45:37.401
NOT SPECIFICALLY REACH SHOULD
00:45:37.468 --> 00:45:40.904
BE ABLE PLATFORM. TO ENSURE
00:45:40.971 --> 00:45:42.306
THAT. CHARITABLE THE
00:45:42.372 --> 00:45:45.409
PROVISIONAL IS OUT DAY. IN
00:45:45.476 --> 00:45:46.510
ORDER TO ENSURE THE AGING
00:45:46.577 --> 00:45:48.412
CONTINUED ABILITY TO PROTECT
00:45:48.479 --> 00:45:50.581
THE PUBLIC OUR OFFICE NEEDS TO
00:45:50.647 --> 00:45:51.415
BE IN A POSITION TO OVERSEE
00:45:51.482 --> 00:45:52.783
CHARITABLE FUNDRAISING
00:45:52.850 --> 00:45:54.918
PRACTICES. THAT OCCUR INTERNET
00:45:54.985 --> 00:45:57.521
PLATFORMS AND FIND NIMBLY TO
00:45:57.588 --> 00:45:59.056
NEW CONCERNS WHATEVER THEY
00:45:59.123 --> 00:46:01.325
ARRIVE. AS POINTED OUT IN THE
00:46:01.391 --> 00:46:03.427
COMMITTEE ANNOUNCEMENTS IN TIME
00:46:03.494 --> 00:46:04.895
OF NATURAL DISASTER WE SEE AN
00:46:04.962 --> 00:46:06.263
INCREASE ONLINE SHOWING
00:46:06.330 --> 00:46:08.632
RAISING. THE COVE IN NINETEEN
00:46:08.699 --> 00:46:10.834
CRISIS IS NO DIFFERENT. BUT FOR
00:46:10.901 --> 00:46:11.835
THAT REASON WE AGREE OF THE
00:46:11.902 --> 00:46:13.604
COMMITTEE THAT NOW WITH THE
00:46:13.670 --> 00:46:15.539
RIGHT TIME TO UPDATE THE LONG.
00:46:15.606 --> 00:46:17.774
ESTABLISH A BASIC FRAMEWORK TO
00:46:17.841 --> 00:46:19.309
ENABLE THE AG'S OFFICE THE
00:46:19.376 --> 00:46:21.712
EXERCISE PROPER SUPERVISION
00:46:21.778 --> 00:46:24.815
OVER THAT FAST GROWING STATE.
00:46:24.882 --> 00:46:26.850
BUT STILL RESULT ROBOTS COURT
00:46:26.917 --> 00:46:29.286
PROCESS TO FILL IT BY AG AND
00:46:29.353 --> 00:46:33.757
ASSEMBLY WOMAN IRWIN. STARTED
00:46:33.824 --> 00:46:34.291
OVER EIGHT MONTHS AGO AND
00:46:34.358 --> 00:46:36.693
CONTINUE TO BE FOR. WE BELIEVE
00:46:36.760 --> 00:46:37.261
THAT THE FEEDBACK WITH EVEN
00:46:37.327 --> 00:46:38.629
THIS PROCESS AS YOU KNOW THE
00:46:38.695 --> 00:46:41.465
BOW PROPOSAL BEFORE YOU TODAY.
00:46:41.532 --> 00:46:42.699
AND WE ARE STILL COMMITTED TO
00:46:42.766 --> 00:46:44.234
CONTINUE DISCUSSING WHAT THEY
00:46:44.301 --> 00:46:45.536
QUOTED GOING FORWARD SHOULD THE
00:46:45.602 --> 00:46:48.639
BILL PASSED TODAY. WE THANK
00:46:48.705 --> 00:46:49.840
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN FOR HER
00:46:49.907 --> 00:46:50.774
LEADERSHIP ON THIS IMPORTANT
00:46:50.841 --> 00:46:53.310
ISSUE FOR CALIFORNIA DONOR AND
00:46:53.377 --> 00:46:55.279
CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION. AGING
00:46:55.345 --> 00:46:57.247
IS PROUD TO SPONSOR THIS BILL
00:46:57.314 --> 00:46:59.283
AND REAFFIRM HIS COMMITMENT TO
00:46:59.349 --> 00:47:01.051
PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY GUARD THE
00:47:01.118 --> 00:47:02.019
PUBLIC FROM FRAUD OR
00:47:02.085 --> 00:47:05.789
MISREPRESENTATION. AND ENSURE A
00:47:05.856 --> 00:47:06.757
LEVEL PLAYING FIELD. I
00:47:06.823 --> 00:47:09.126
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU TO VOTE I
00:47:09.193 --> 00:47:11.094
AB TWENTY TWO OH EIGHT TODAY.
00:47:11.161 --> 00:47:13.463
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER LOU-
00:47:13.530 --> 00:47:16.400
MISTER ARMSTRONG IF YOU'D LIKE
00:47:16.466 --> 00:47:19.136
TO GIVE IT A OF THIRTY SECONDS.
00:47:19.203 --> 00:47:21.471
SURE THIS IS RIAN ARMSTRONG
00:47:21.538 --> 00:47:23.774
I'M A DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL-
00:47:23.840 --> 00:47:25.375
AND ATTORNEY GENERAL THE FERRIS
00:47:25.442 --> 00:47:27.611
CHARITABLE TRUST SECTION I WILL
00:47:27.678 --> 00:47:28.712
BE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY
00:47:28.779 --> 00:47:30.581
QUESTIONS ABOUT A COMMITTEE MAY
00:47:30.647 --> 00:47:32.482
HAVE ABOUT ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY
00:47:32.549 --> 00:47:34.151
TWO AWAY THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:47:34.218 --> 00:47:36.486
THANK YOU AND WITH THAT- YOU
00:47:36.553 --> 00:47:37.854
WILL STAY ON THE LINE IN CASE
00:47:37.921 --> 00:47:39.623
THERE ARE ANY QUESTIONS HERE
00:47:39.690 --> 00:47:42.059
THIS IS SO. OBVIOUSLY SORT OF A
00:47:42.125 --> 00:47:43.927
IN THE WEEDS KIND OF ISSUE BUT
00:47:43.994 --> 00:47:45.696
AN IMPORTANT ONE SO WILL
00:47:45.762 --> 00:47:46.997
ANTICIPATE THERE MIGHT BE SOME
00:47:47.064 --> 00:47:48.665
QUESTIONS FOR YOU. AND WITH
00:47:48.732 --> 00:47:51.602
THAT- LET'S GO AHEAD AND- SEE
00:47:51.668 --> 00:47:53.904
IF WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES HERE
00:47:53.971 --> 00:47:56.673
IN ROME FORTY TWO OH THREE. WHO
00:47:56.740 --> 00:48:00.210
WOULD LIKE TO- GIVE THEIR NAME
00:48:00.277 --> 00:48:01.478
AFFILIATION AND POSITION.
00:48:01.545 --> 00:48:03.814
SEEING NONE LET'S GO TO ROOM
00:48:03.880 --> 00:48:06.216
TWENTY FORTY HOW ARE THERE. ANY
00:48:06.283 --> 00:48:08.252
WITNESSES IN ROOM TWENTY FORTY.
00:48:08.318 --> 00:48:10.387
DOESN'T APPEAR TO BE SO LET'S
00:48:10.454 --> 00:48:13.323
GO AHEAD AND MOVE TO WITNESSES
00:48:13.390 --> 00:48:16.326
WAITING TO TESTIFY. VIA
00:48:16.393 --> 00:48:19.296
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE. AND
00:48:19.363 --> 00:48:20.731
MATTER MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
00:48:20.797 --> 00:48:22.666
PLEASE PROP THOSE INDIVIDUALS
00:48:22.733 --> 00:48:24.501
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
00:48:24.568 --> 00:48:26.136
OF THIS MEASURE AB TWENTY TWO
00:48:26.203 --> 00:48:31.375
OO EIGHT. WE WILL BEGIN. THANK
00:48:31.441 --> 00:48:32.809
YOU IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN
00:48:32.876 --> 00:48:35.412
SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY TWO OH
00:48:35.479 --> 00:48:37.281
EIGHT PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN
00:48:37.347 --> 00:48:53.797
ZERO AT THIS TIME. ALL RIGHT UP
00:48:53.864 --> 00:48:56.166
MATTER MODERATOR OF ARE THERE
00:48:56.233 --> 00:48:58.535
ANY PEOPLE IN THE QUEUE AND IF
00:48:58.602 --> 00:49:01.605
SO COULD YOU TELL US HOW MANY.
00:49:01.672 --> 00:49:04.107
THANK YOU I HAVE ONE IN Q. VERY
00:49:04.174 --> 00:49:05.776
GOOD IF YOU WOULD GO AHEAD AND
00:49:05.842 --> 00:49:09.846
PROMPT THEM TO SPEAK. PINE
00:49:09.913 --> 00:49:12.516
EIGHTY FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:49:12.582 --> 00:49:14.418
YES HELLO THIS IS LUCY SELL
00:49:14.484 --> 00:49:16.720
FETAL CARTER ON BEHALF OF THE
00:49:16.787 --> 00:49:19.356
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:49:19.423 --> 00:49:21.124
NONPROFIT IN STRONG SUPPORT.
00:49:21.191 --> 00:49:25.529
THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY OTHER
00:49:25.595 --> 00:49:26.797
WITNESSES ON THE LINE MATTER
00:49:26.863 --> 00:49:28.865
MODERATOR WHO WOULD LIKE TO
00:49:28.932 --> 00:49:29.366
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS
00:49:29.433 --> 00:49:33.870
MEASURE. I HAVE NO FURTHER
00:49:33.937 --> 00:49:36.139
LINES IN Q. AT THIS TIME. VERY
00:49:36.206 --> 00:49:39.209
GOOD WE WILL MOVE NOW TO
00:49:39.276 --> 00:49:41.144
OPPOSITION ARE THERE ANY
00:49:41.211 --> 00:49:44.114
INDIVIDUALS WHO- WILL BE
00:49:44.181 --> 00:49:46.216
SPEAKING IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
00:49:46.283 --> 00:49:55.726
MEASURE. YES NOT INSURANCE IS
00:49:55.792 --> 00:49:56.893
CAMPER DEMENTIA MAP OF TECH
00:49:56.960 --> 00:50:00.197
THAT- BUT I'D BE ABLE TO SPEAK
00:50:00.263 --> 00:50:03.834
OUT YES PLEASE PLEASE PROCEED.
00:50:03.900 --> 00:50:04.968
GOOD MORNING CHAIR NUMBER SEVEN
00:50:05.035 --> 00:50:06.670
A MAJOR ATTACK NOT WE SHOULD
00:50:06.737 --> 00:50:08.372
AUTHORS GOLD TRANSPARENCY AS IT
00:50:08.438 --> 00:50:10.107
RELATES TO GENERAL FUND RAISING
00:50:10.173 --> 00:50:11.608
AND DEEPLY APPRECIATE THE WORK
00:50:11.675 --> 00:50:13.110
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND OUR STAFF
00:50:13.176 --> 00:50:14.044
HAS DONE ON THIS IMPORTANT
00:50:14.111 --> 00:50:15.645
MEASURE BUT UNFORTUNATELY AFTER
00:50:15.712 --> 00:50:16.680
NINE MONTHS OF CONVERSATIONS
00:50:16.747 --> 00:50:18.215
AND STAKEHOLDER MEETING. TECH
00:50:18.281 --> 00:50:19.182
THAT REMAINS OPPOSING LAST
00:50:19.249 --> 00:50:20.917
MINUTE ON AB TWENTY TWO OH
00:50:20.984 --> 00:50:22.853
EIGHT. I MEMBER COMPANIES WORK
00:50:22.919 --> 00:50:23.653
WITH THEIR CUSTOMERS AND
00:50:23.720 --> 00:50:25.088
PARTNERS TO RAISING PROCESS
00:50:25.155 --> 00:50:27.691
BILLION DOLLARS IN DONATIONS
00:50:27.758 --> 00:50:28.725
FOR NONPROFIT. NOW MORE THAN
00:50:28.792 --> 00:50:29.593
EVER THIS IS GOING EXPECT
00:50:29.659 --> 00:50:30.927
HIGHLIGHTED DURING THE COKE
00:50:30.994 --> 00:50:32.429
WITH NINETEEN CRISIS. AND THE
00:50:32.496 --> 00:50:33.630
REASON CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT
00:50:33.697 --> 00:50:35.232
WHEN NONPROFIT TO RAISE MONEY
00:50:35.298 --> 00:50:37.634
TO SUPPORT THOSE AND FROM MIND
00:50:37.701 --> 00:50:38.702
AND LOCAL COMMUNITY. WE WANT TO
00:50:38.769 --> 00:50:39.669
ENSURE THAT THE PROVISIONS OF
00:50:39.736 --> 00:50:41.338
AB TWENTY TWO EIGHTEEN NOT
00:50:41.405 --> 00:50:42.372
NEGATIVELY IMPACT THE
00:50:42.439 --> 00:50:43.473
SUCCESSFUL FUNDRAISING EFFORTS
00:50:43.540 --> 00:50:44.674
THAT HAVE BEEN REALIZED TO OUR
00:50:44.741 --> 00:50:46.410
PLATFORMS. IN ORDER TO
00:50:46.476 --> 00:50:47.477
ACCOMPLISH THIS WE HAVE
00:50:47.544 --> 00:50:48.779
PROPOSES HERE'S AMENDMENTS TO
00:50:48.845 --> 00:50:50.113
THE AUTHOR THAT WOULD. HELP
00:50:50.180 --> 00:50:51.348
REMEDY THE TENANTS OF THOSE
00:50:51.415 --> 00:50:53.116
LEGISLATION WITH THE REALITIES
00:50:53.183 --> 00:50:54.818
OF OUR CURRENT CHARITABLE
00:50:54.885 --> 00:50:56.286
PRACTICES. FIRST IT IS
00:50:56.353 --> 00:50:57.287
IMPERATIVE THAT OUR MEMBERS ARE
00:50:57.354 --> 00:50:58.688
PROVIDED TIME TO ADAPT TO NEW
00:50:58.755 --> 00:51:00.490
STATUTORY AND STILL UNKNOWN
00:51:00.557 --> 00:51:02.692
REGULATORY SCHEMES CONTEMPLATED
00:51:02.759 --> 00:51:04.461
IT AB TWENTY TWO OH EIGHT. FOR
00:51:04.528 --> 00:51:05.362
THIS REASON WE THINK A DELAYED
00:51:05.429 --> 00:51:07.030
IMPLEMENTATION FOR BUSINESSES
00:51:07.097 --> 00:51:11.368
TO MODIFY. THEIR CURRENT
00:51:11.435 --> 00:51:11.935
PROSTHESES. IN ORDER TO BE.
00:51:12.002 --> 00:51:13.136
WITH THE COMPREHENSIVE OVERHAUL
00:51:13.203 --> 00:51:16.540
AND CHAIRED GIVING PROCESS.
00:51:16.606 --> 00:51:19.242
SECOND WE REQUEST A LITTLE.
00:51:19.309 --> 00:51:21.111
RECIPIENTS AND STAND AT THE IN
00:51:21.178 --> 00:51:23.480
THIS. SHOULD BE MORE. OF NON.
00:51:23.547 --> 00:51:24.514
CHARITY INCLUDING THOSE OUT OF
00:51:24.581 --> 00:51:25.215
THE UNIED STATES THEY MAY NOT
00:51:25.282 --> 00:51:28.652
BE. BY THE ARE OR AT THESE WERE.
00:51:28.718 --> 00:51:30.353
THIRD TECH THAT REMAINS
00:51:30.420 --> 00:51:30.887
CONCERNED ABOUT THE BROAD
00:51:30.954 --> 00:51:32.289
STATUTE STATUTORY AT THE
00:51:32.355 --> 00:51:34.558
DEFERRED AN AGING OFFICE FOR.
00:51:34.624 --> 00:51:36.193
RULEMAKING THE BILL AS MANY
00:51:36.259 --> 00:51:37.894
PRESCRIPTIVE COMPONENTS CLEARLY
00:51:37.961 --> 00:51:38.862
OUTLINED IN THE LANGUAGE THE
00:51:38.929 --> 00:51:39.896
BILL ALSO MAKES SPECIFIC
00:51:39.963 --> 00:51:41.331
ALLOWANCE THE AG TO
00:51:41.398 --> 00:51:43.099
SIGNIFICANTLY ENHANCE. THE
00:51:43.166 --> 00:51:44.201
STATUTORY PARAMETERS OF THIS
00:51:44.267 --> 00:51:46.203
BILL ONE EXAMPLE OF THIS IS THE
00:51:46.269 --> 00:51:47.604
OPEN IN THE NATURE OF WHAT
00:51:47.671 --> 00:51:48.572
INFORMATION WOULD BE REQUIRED
00:51:48.638 --> 00:51:49.973
AND ALL TOWARDS THE AG'S
00:51:50.040 --> 00:51:51.875
OFFICE. WHICH WOULD BE RESOLVED
00:51:51.942 --> 00:51:53.710
IN STATUTE BUT WHICH COULD BE
00:51:53.777 --> 00:51:54.978
RESULT AND CATCH YOU ANOTHER
00:51:55.045 --> 00:51:55.879
EXAMPLE OF THIS PRODUCT
00:51:55.946 --> 00:51:57.781
óRDENES FOUND IN SECTION SHARE
00:51:57.848 --> 00:51:58.748
THE BILL. WITH AG IS GIVEN
00:51:58.815 --> 00:51:59.983
AUTHORITY TO ESTABLISH RULES
00:52:00.050 --> 00:52:01.585
AND REGULATIONS WHICH SHALL
00:52:01.651 --> 00:52:03.920
INCLUDE BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO.
00:52:03.987 --> 00:52:07.858
THE ADDITIONAL. ACTION
00:52:07.924 --> 00:52:09.759
SOLICITATION THAT MEET. HAVE A
00:52:09.826 --> 00:52:10.427
CHARITABLE FUNDRAISING CLASS
00:52:10.494 --> 00:52:12.696
FORMER PLATFORMS. TO JESSE
00:52:12.762 --> 00:52:14.764
CHANGES IN TECH. IN CLASS
00:52:14.831 --> 00:52:15.866
FUNDRAISING CLOUT FOR. WE
00:52:15.932 --> 00:52:17.501
BELIEVE FEATURES AND ARE BETTER
00:52:17.567 --> 00:52:19.102
OFF. AND WILL DO. BY ABILITY
00:52:19.169 --> 00:52:23.340
OUT THAN WHAT THE DOJ. THE
00:52:23.406 --> 00:52:23.940
REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN THE
00:52:24.007 --> 00:52:26.076
BILL CAN OF AND GIVING OPEN
00:52:26.142 --> 00:52:28.111
OVER PLATFORM AND FORCED A TO
00:52:28.178 --> 00:52:30.080
RE EVALUATE THE VIABILITY FOR
00:52:30.146 --> 00:52:31.414
SIX. CHARITABLE STRAW. FOR
00:52:31.481 --> 00:52:32.349
THESE REASONS AND OUTLINE INNER
00:52:32.415 --> 00:52:34.217
CITY IN AND TECHNO REMAINS IN
00:52:34.284 --> 00:52:35.685
BECAUSE I'M NOT AMENITIES LOOKS
00:52:35.752 --> 00:52:37.287
TO THE- PREDICTED CONVERSATION
00:52:37.354 --> 00:52:38.655
WITH YA THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:52:38.722 --> 00:52:39.856
THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES I
00:52:39.923 --> 00:52:41.324
BELIEVE I HAVE HER MISTER
00:52:41.391 --> 00:52:42.526
DILLON HOFFMAN WITH THE
00:52:42.592 --> 00:52:44.127
INTERNET ASSOCIATION WILL GIVE
00:52:44.194 --> 00:52:46.563
YOU ANOTHER FORTY SECONDS IF
00:52:46.630 --> 00:52:47.397
YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK. ARE YOU
00:52:47.464 --> 00:52:53.003
WITH US FOR OFTEN. I AM THANK
00:52:53.069 --> 00:52:53.904
YOU MADAM AND CENTER ON THE
00:52:53.970 --> 00:52:55.539
OCCUPANTS REALLY GREAT MY
00:52:55.605 --> 00:52:57.874
NAME'S ON HOW I'M TRYING. OF
00:52:57.941 --> 00:52:58.408
TALK GOVERNOR AFFAIRS THE
00:52:58.475 --> 00:53:00.477
INTERNET POSTED. I JUST WANT ON
00:53:00.544 --> 00:53:03.880
MY CAR WITH MIKE. FROM FROM I A
00:53:03.947 --> 00:53:05.782
AND ARE. SURE SAME CONCERNS
00:53:05.849 --> 00:53:06.750
PARTICULARLY THAT THE BILL
00:53:06.816 --> 00:53:07.951
WOULD GRANT PRETTY PROUD
00:53:08.018 --> 00:53:09.252
REGULATORY AUTHORITY THAT WE
00:53:09.319 --> 00:53:11.388
BELIEVE CAN BE ADDRESSED- IN
00:53:11.454 --> 00:53:13.189
STATURE- JUST HIGHLIGHT A
00:53:13.256 --> 00:53:15.225
COUPLE OTHER ISSUES- THAT OUR
00:53:15.292 --> 00:53:17.928
ORGANIZATION HAS FLAGS- RELATED
00:53:17.994 --> 00:53:18.929
TO THE- BILL'S COULD STAND
00:53:18.995 --> 00:53:20.497
REQUIREMENTS. WE BELIEVE
00:53:20.564 --> 00:53:22.732
ADDITIONAL AMENDMENTS- ALONE
00:53:22.799 --> 00:53:24.367
FOR A LIST OF ORGANIZATIONS IN
00:53:24.434 --> 00:53:25.335
GOOD STANDING THREE MACHINE
00:53:25.402 --> 00:53:26.469
READABLE WOULD BE HELPFUL TO
00:53:26.536 --> 00:53:28.672
REDUCE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDENS-
00:53:28.738 --> 00:53:30.073
AND MAKE IT EASIER TO IMPLEMENT
00:53:30.140 --> 00:53:32.676
THE BILL- IN- THE BILL'S
00:53:32.742 --> 00:53:34.778
REQUIRE. PLACE BURDENS ON.
00:53:34.844 --> 00:53:36.012
HUNDRED AND PLATFORMS COULD
00:53:36.079 --> 00:53:37.113
HAVE THE UNINTENDED. OF A
00:53:37.180 --> 00:53:39.115
REDUCE INSURABLE GIVEN SO
00:53:39.182 --> 00:53:40.450
HELPING READERS SOME OF THOSE
00:53:40.517 --> 00:53:41.952
BURDENS- AND ALLOW FOR
00:53:42.018 --> 00:53:44.387
AUTOMATION WOULD BE IMMENSELY
00:53:44.454 --> 00:53:51.227
BENEFICIAL- I. SIR OVER AND MY
00:53:51.294 --> 00:53:51.828
APOLOGIES FOR WE ARE TO KEEP
00:53:51.895 --> 00:53:52.429
THIS TO THE MINUTES I'M SURE
00:53:52.495 --> 00:53:53.897
THERE BE SOME QUESTIONS WHICH
00:53:53.964 --> 00:53:56.533
WILL ALLOW YOU TO- FURTHER
00:53:56.600 --> 00:53:59.369
COMMENT BUT AT THIS POINT- WE
00:53:59.436 --> 00:54:00.637
ARE TRYING TO STICK TO THE
00:54:00.704 --> 00:54:02.572
THREE MINUTE GOLAN WE WENT A
00:54:02.639 --> 00:54:03.974
LITTLE BIT OVER. AND MY
00:54:04.040 --> 00:54:08.878
APOLOGIES FOR THAT- ALL RIGHT
00:54:08.945 --> 00:54:09.512
WHAT. WE NEED TO DO NOW IS TO
00:54:09.579 --> 00:54:10.814
ASK IF THERE ARE ANY WITNESSES
00:54:10.880 --> 00:54:13.049
IN ROOM FORTY TWO OR THREE WHO
00:54:13.116 --> 00:54:14.884
WOULD LIKE TO. SPEAK IN
00:54:14.951 --> 00:54:16.219
OPPOSITION WITH THEIR NAME
00:54:16.286 --> 00:54:18.555
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
00:54:18.622 --> 00:54:21.691
BILL. SEEING NONE ROOM TWENTY
00:54:21.758 --> 00:54:24.260
FORTY IS THERE ANYONE IN ROOM
00:54:24.327 --> 00:54:25.695
TWENTY FORTY SEEING NONE. TO
00:54:25.762 --> 00:54:27.430
HAVE PEOPLE ON THE LINE COMETA
00:54:27.497 --> 00:54:30.700
MODERATOR- IF YOU WOULD Q. THEM
00:54:30.767 --> 00:54:35.138
UP AT THIS POINT IN TIME- TO
00:54:35.205 --> 00:54:36.973
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. PLEASE DO
00:54:37.040 --> 00:54:40.210
SO NOW. THANK YOU IF YOU WISH
00:54:40.276 --> 00:54:41.745
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OUT OF
00:54:41.811 --> 00:54:43.780
AB TWENTY TWO OO EIGHT PLEASE
00:54:43.847 --> 00:54:45.982
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:54:46.049 --> 00:55:13.243
TIME. HE SAID. THAT YEAH. ALL%
00:55:13.309 --> 00:55:15.378
NO MATTER MODERATOR ARE THERE
00:55:15.445 --> 00:55:18.381
ANY WITNESSES ON THE LINE WHO
00:55:18.448 --> 00:55:22.419
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
00:55:22.485 --> 00:55:23.019
THANK YOU I DO HAVE ONE ON THE
00:55:23.086 --> 00:55:25.455
LINE. IF YOU WOULD TO ENCOURAGE
00:55:25.522 --> 00:55:27.223
THEM PROMPT THEM TO SPEAK
00:55:27.290 --> 00:55:30.760
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU I
00:55:30.827 --> 00:55:33.763
WON SIXTY TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:55:33.830 --> 00:55:35.865
YES MY NAME IS JUDY BEAT ALL
00:55:35.932 --> 00:55:38.134
WITH THE K. PROGRESSIVE SOCIAL
00:55:38.201 --> 00:55:40.804
JUSTICE ORGANIZATION BASED IN
00:55:40.870 --> 00:55:42.872
LITTLE TOKYO IN LOS ANGELES AND
00:55:42.939 --> 00:55:46.009
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THIRTY
00:55:46.076 --> 00:55:46.976
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE VOTE IN
00:55:47.043 --> 00:55:48.812
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK YOU.
00:55:48.878 --> 00:55:50.180
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THIS WILL
00:55:50.246 --> 00:55:52.215
HAPPEN IT HAPPENS EVERY TIME
00:55:52.282 --> 00:55:53.750
PEOPLE WHO WEREN'T ON THE LINE
00:55:53.817 --> 00:55:55.385
IS THERE ANYONE IF YOU WOULD
00:55:55.452 --> 00:55:56.786
CHECK ONE MORE TIME AT A
00:55:56.853 --> 00:55:59.189
MODERATOR FOR ANY OPPOSITION-
00:55:59.255 --> 00:56:00.523
THIS MEASURE IF YOU WOULD
00:56:00.590 --> 00:56:01.891
PLEASE GO AHEAD AND PROMPT THEM
00:56:01.958 --> 00:56:06.029
TO SPEAK. SHE THANK YOU IF YOU
00:56:06.096 --> 00:56:07.664
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF
00:56:07.731 --> 00:56:09.632
AB TWENTY TWO OO EIGHT PLEASE
00:56:09.699 --> 00:56:11.835
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
00:56:11.901 --> 00:56:21.311
TIME. DO WE HAVE ANYONE ON THE
00:56:21.377 --> 00:56:24.180
LINE MATTER MODERATOR. I DO
00:56:24.247 --> 00:56:25.548
HAVE ONE THERE WITH AN OPERATOR
00:56:25.615 --> 00:56:27.183
RIGHT NOW IT'LL JUST BE ONE
00:56:27.250 --> 00:56:42.365
MOMENT CERTAINLY. WE GOT A LINE
00:56:42.432 --> 00:56:45.401
ONE SEVENTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:56:45.468 --> 00:56:47.470
YEAH THIS IS MARGARET GLAD SHE
00:56:47.537 --> 00:56:48.872
NUMBER HELP FROM THE CALIFORNIA
00:56:48.938 --> 00:56:50.607
RETAILERS ASSOCIATION WE
00:56:50.673 --> 00:56:54.944
APOLOGIZE FOR- ARE LATE LETTER
00:56:55.011 --> 00:56:55.512
INTO THIS WE HAVE A CALL OF
00:56:55.578 --> 00:56:57.413
SUBMITTED. WE WOULD LIKE THAT
00:56:57.480 --> 00:56:59.015
ARE ONLINE PORTALS TO BE
00:56:59.082 --> 00:57:01.384
TREATED THE SAME AS OUR BRICK
00:57:01.451 --> 00:57:04.788
AND MORTAR AND- WE DO HAVE
00:57:04.854 --> 00:57:05.388
CONCERNS WITH THE LANGUAGE OF
00:57:05.455 --> 00:57:09.359
CREDIT. THANK YOU MUCH. ANY
00:57:09.425 --> 00:57:11.161
OTHER WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
00:57:11.227 --> 00:57:16.866
MADAM MODERATOR. I HAVE NO
00:57:16.933 --> 00:57:17.834
FURTHER LINES IN Q. AT THIS
00:57:17.901 --> 00:57:21.137
TIME ALL RIGHT THE WE WILL THEN
00:57:21.204 --> 00:57:23.473
BRING THIS BACK TO DISCUSSION-
00:57:23.540 --> 00:57:25.675
ALONG THE MEMBERS AND I BELIEVE
00:57:25.742 --> 00:57:27.510
CENTER BORCHERS FALL BY CENTER
00:57:27.577 --> 00:57:29.145
Y. CASKEY. THANK YOU MADAM
00:57:29.212 --> 00:57:31.214
CHAIR I WOULD LIKE TO THINK A
00:57:31.281 --> 00:57:33.383
ASSEMBLY WOMAN OR ONE FOR
00:57:33.449 --> 00:57:35.084
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. I THINK
00:57:35.151 --> 00:57:36.920
THERE ARE SOME REALLY.
00:57:36.986 --> 00:57:39.255
IMPORTANT TOOLS THAT ARE BEING
00:57:39.322 --> 00:57:43.359
PROPOSED. ON I THINK WE HAVE
00:57:43.426 --> 00:57:46.763
SEEN THAT. WHEN PEOPLE ARE
00:57:46.830 --> 00:57:49.299
DRAWN EITHER THROUGH SOCIAL
00:57:49.365 --> 00:57:52.302
MEDIA OR ODD THROUGH OTHER TECH
00:57:52.368 --> 00:57:57.040
MEANS- TO SUPPORT A CAUSE- IN
00:57:57.106 --> 00:57:58.842
THOSE INDIVIDUALS DONATE
00:57:58.908 --> 00:58:01.377
DOLLARS TO THIS BECAUSE USING A
00:58:01.444 --> 00:58:05.448
PLATFORM. IT'S A SITUATION
00:58:05.515 --> 00:58:07.984
WHERE THINGS CAN GO AWRY
00:58:08.051 --> 00:58:09.853
MEANING THAT THE PLATFORM OR
00:58:09.919 --> 00:58:12.555
THE FOLKS THAT ARE OPERATING AT
00:58:12.622 --> 00:58:15.992
A OR SUBMITTING THE MESSAGE TO
00:58:16.059 --> 00:58:18.161
THE VIEWER CAN MISLEAD THE
00:58:18.228 --> 00:58:21.364
VIEWER- IN ALL USING EXAMPLE-
00:58:21.431 --> 00:58:23.233
THERE WAS A- THERE WAS A
00:58:23.299 --> 00:58:26.236
FOREIGN ENTITY- ASKING FOR
00:58:26.302 --> 00:58:28.438
DONATIONS TO SUPPORT TO SUPPORT
00:58:28.504 --> 00:58:31.474
THAT REFUGEES. AND IT WAS LATER
00:58:31.541 --> 00:58:34.510
REVEALED THAT IT WAS TO A
00:58:34.577 --> 00:58:37.513
TOTALLY UNRELATED- ENTITY THAT
00:58:37.580 --> 00:58:41.084
USE THAT PLATFORM TO BY PASS
00:58:41.150 --> 00:58:43.953
AND GIVE THE DOLLARS ON TO
00:58:44.020 --> 00:58:45.588
ANOTHER PURPOSE THAT SOME WITH
00:58:45.655 --> 00:58:47.423
THE THAT SCHIST FRAUD BUT I
00:58:47.490 --> 00:58:50.026
THINK T'S RIPE THAT STUFF LIKE
00:58:50.093 --> 00:58:53.162
THIS DOES HAPPEN- I THINK WE'VE
00:58:53.229 --> 00:58:56.132
HEARD THAT. EVEN WITH THIS GOOD
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:58.234
IDEA THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
00:58:58.301 --> 00:59:01.938
IMPORTANT. STAKEHOLDERS THAT
00:59:02.005 --> 00:59:04.674
ARE RECOMMENDING THE THIS. MOVE
00:59:04.741 --> 00:59:06.342
FORWARD WITH SOME AMENDMENTS
00:59:06.409 --> 00:59:08.945
AND MORE DISCUSSION AND I KINDA
00:59:09.012 --> 00:59:11.681
GETS TO MY LAST POINT IS- I
00:59:11.748 --> 00:59:13.182
WOULD LIKE TO SUPPORTER VERSION
00:59:13.249 --> 00:59:15.318
OF THIS BILL AT SOME POINT IN
00:59:15.385 --> 00:59:19.022
TIME I THINK RIGHT NOW IT'S NOT.
00:59:19.088 --> 00:59:20.723
FULLY DEVELOPED IN A WAY THAT I
00:59:20.790 --> 00:59:24.260
THINK IT COULD BE. AND I'M KIND
00:59:24.327 --> 00:59:27.430
OF CONCERNED THAT. HOW THIS
00:59:27.497 --> 00:59:29.465
FITS IN WITH OUR OVERALL-
00:59:29.532 --> 00:59:31.100
APPRECIATION OF BILLS THAT
00:59:31.167 --> 00:59:32.335
SHOULD BE HEARD IN OUR
00:59:32.402 --> 00:59:36.472
TRUNCATED- TIMELINE IT'S NOT
00:59:36.539 --> 00:59:39.008
COLLUDED RELATED. IT'S NOT TIME
00:59:39.075 --> 00:59:42.145
SENSITIVE IT'S NOT COMPLETELY
00:59:42.211 --> 00:59:44.914
VETTED SO I DON'T KNOW WHY.
00:59:44.981 --> 00:59:47.550
THIS WAS ELIGIBLE AND SHOULDN'T
00:59:47.617 --> 00:59:50.453
BE BROUGHT BACK IN JANUARY.
00:59:50.520 --> 00:59:52.422
MAYBE ALL THE FOR MY QUESTION
00:59:52.488 --> 00:59:56.259
TO CHAIR WOMAN TO EXPLAIN HOW
00:59:56.326 --> 00:59:56.759
WE'RE DEALING WITH THIS
00:59:56.826 --> 00:59:58.161
PARTICULAR BILL UNDER THE
00:59:58.227 --> 01:00:00.697
CIRCUMSTANCES. THE COVERT
01:00:00.763 --> 01:00:05.001
SESSION IS AN IMPERFECT SCIENCE.
01:00:05.068 --> 01:00:06.936
THAT THAT'S MY RESPONSE SENATOR
01:00:07.003 --> 01:00:09.372
WHY CAL SKI. WELL I'M GLAD I'M
01:00:09.439 --> 01:00:11.207
GLAD THAT THAT'S NO CLEAR THE
01:00:11.274 --> 01:00:15.611
AIR. THAT IT'S NOT BASED ON THE
01:00:15.678 --> 01:00:16.679
LETTER IN THE MAIL THAT WAS PER.
01:00:16.746 --> 01:00:18.781
I WOULD RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE
01:00:18.848 --> 01:00:19.983
BUT WE'RE NOT GOING TO HAVE
01:00:20.049 --> 01:00:22.618
THAT DISCUSSION HERE WE'RE HERE
01:00:22.685 --> 01:00:23.186
WITH THE HEARING WE'VE GOT A
01:00:23.252 --> 01:00:26.489
BILL BEFORE US- AND- SENATOR
01:00:26.556 --> 01:00:28.725
WHERE CASKEY IF YOU'D LIKE TO
01:00:28.791 --> 01:00:30.226
PROCEED PLEASE FEEL FREE. FROM
01:00:30.293 --> 01:00:32.562
THE OPPOSITE IN ABOUT NO
01:00:32.628 --> 01:00:35.131
GUIDANCE IN CERTAIN- AREAS
01:00:35.198 --> 01:00:38.534
ABOUT THE H. E. L. AT ISSUE IN
01:00:38.601 --> 01:00:40.103
THESE REGULATIONS TAKEN FROM ON
01:00:40.169 --> 01:00:41.371
THAT THEY WANT TO HAVE MORE
01:00:41.437 --> 01:00:43.306
GUIDANCE ON PAGE TEN OF OUR
01:00:43.373 --> 01:00:45.008
ANALYSIS TO TALK ABOUT DO
01:00:45.074 --> 01:00:46.476
REGISTRATION FOR COMMERCIAL
01:00:46.542 --> 01:00:50.880
CHARITIES. I WANT TO KNOW IF-
01:00:50.947 --> 01:00:52.648
IS THE SUGGESTION THAT MAYBE.
01:00:52.715 --> 01:00:55.251
THE EIGHT ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
01:00:55.318 --> 01:00:57.653
MAYBE DEPUTY LIEU ONCE ANSWER
01:00:57.720 --> 01:00:58.421
THIS FOR THE AUTHORS AT THE
01:00:58.488 --> 01:01:00.323
ATTORNEY GENERAL DOES HAVE THE-
01:01:00.390 --> 01:01:02.658
OPTION TO EXEMPT PEOPLE THAT
01:01:02.725 --> 01:01:04.761
ARE ALREADY. REPORTING
01:01:04.827 --> 01:01:07.864
REGISTERED AND LIKE WHAT IS HE
01:01:07.930 --> 01:01:10.433
AUTHORS THOUGHTS ON THAT. I'D I
01:01:10.500 --> 01:01:12.268
WOULD I WOULD FIRST LIKE TO SAY
01:01:12.335 --> 01:01:14.137
IS YOU KNOW THANK YOU AGAIN
01:01:14.203 --> 01:01:16.472
FOR. THE OPPORTUNITY TO HEAR
01:01:16.539 --> 01:01:17.540
THIS BILL AND IT IS VERY
01:01:17.607 --> 01:01:18.574
RELEVANT TO COUPLE THAT THE
01:01:18.641 --> 01:01:20.877
AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT IS COMING
01:01:20.943 --> 01:01:22.645
INTO THE ONLINE PLATFORMS IS.
01:01:22.712 --> 01:01:24.547
ABSOLUTELY EXPLODING AND IN
01:01:24.614 --> 01:01:26.649
SOME WAYS ONLINE GIVING IS THE
01:01:26.716 --> 01:01:29.318
WILD WEST SO I WOULD LIKE TO
01:01:29.385 --> 01:01:30.286
THE- THAT. THEN SENATOR
01:01:30.353 --> 01:01:33.756
JACKSON'S ABOUT OF AND REALLY
01:01:33.823 --> 01:01:35.825
GETTING DOWN INTO THE WEEDS ON
01:01:35.892 --> 01:01:37.660
THIS BILL AND IT HAS BEEN A
01:01:37.727 --> 01:01:40.897
VERY A HARD BALANCING ACT TO
01:01:40.963 --> 01:01:42.799
MAKE SURE THAT WE KEEP OUR
01:01:42.865 --> 01:01:45.835
SPONSOR- WHO IS REALLY LEADING
01:01:45.902 --> 01:01:48.504
THE DISCUSSIONS IN SUPPORT TO
01:01:48.571 --> 01:01:50.540
KEEP CAL NON PROFITS IN SUPPORT
01:01:50.606 --> 01:01:51.808
AND REALLY TRYING TO ADDRESS
01:01:51.874 --> 01:01:53.409
ALSO THE ISSUES OF TECH THAT
01:01:53.476 --> 01:01:55.445
THAT WILL CONTINUE OVER THE
01:01:55.511 --> 01:01:57.713
NEXT FEW WEEKS BUT WE ARE NOT
01:01:57.780 --> 01:02:00.383
IN ANY WAY GOING TO REDUCE
01:02:00.450 --> 01:02:02.251
CONSUMER PROTECTION WHICH IS
01:02:02.318 --> 01:02:03.252
REALLY WHAT THIS BILL IS ALL
01:02:03.319 --> 01:02:08.691
ABOUT SO. ON YOUR SPECIFIC.
01:02:08.758 --> 01:02:09.225
QUESTION I THINK IT'S MUCH
01:02:09.292 --> 01:02:10.693
BETTER THAT THE SPOT OF ANSWER
01:02:10.760 --> 01:02:12.795
THE SO I EITHER MISTER LOW OR
01:02:12.862 --> 01:02:16.699
MISTER ARMSTRONG I'M SURE CAN
01:02:16.766 --> 01:02:19.202
YOU TALK ABOUT TO REGISTRY
01:02:19.268 --> 01:02:24.607
LET'S GO AHEAD. MISSION WHEN I
01:02:24.674 --> 01:02:27.477
IS THE PERSON YOU'RE TO GET.
01:02:27.543 --> 01:02:28.778
BOB TO YOU DO THAT MR HOFFMAN
01:02:28.845 --> 01:02:31.547
FISH ON THE CALL FOR YOUR
01:02:31.614 --> 01:02:33.049
YOU'LL SIGN THIS IS HAPPENING I
01:02:33.116 --> 01:02:34.917
THINK YOU ARE. AND I THINK
01:02:34.984 --> 01:02:36.452
BRIAN WILL TRY ABOUT COULD
01:02:36.519 --> 01:02:40.656
SORRY MIGHT BE FACIAL. ALL
01:02:40.723 --> 01:02:42.058
RIGHT SO WE DO HAVE ON THE CALL.
01:02:42.125 --> 01:02:42.658
TRYING TO FLEE THROUGH ALL OF
01:02:42.725 --> 01:02:43.860
THE NOTES IS THAT RIGHT
01:02:43.926 --> 01:02:44.694
CHALLENGE WE DO HAVE LET ME IT
01:02:44.760 --> 01:02:46.095
THIS WAY WE HAVE AG ON THE CALL
01:02:46.162 --> 01:02:47.363
WHOEVER WOULD LIKE TO ANSWER
01:02:47.430 --> 01:02:49.765
THIS QUESTION FROM THE ATTORNEY
01:02:49.832 --> 01:02:50.366
GENERAL'S OFFICE THE FLOOR IS
01:02:50.433 --> 01:02:55.138
YOURS. SURE YOUR HONOR THIS IS
01:02:55.204 --> 01:02:58.708
THIS IS BRIAN ARMSTRONG. LET ME
01:02:58.774 --> 01:02:59.876
EXPLAIN A LITTLE BIT MORE OF
01:02:59.942 --> 01:03:01.711
THE CONCEPT OF A TOOL
01:03:01.777 --> 01:03:03.412
REGISTRATION AND HOW IT'S
01:03:03.479 --> 01:03:05.548
REALLY NOT A PROBLEM-
01:03:05.615 --> 01:03:07.984
ESSENTIALLY THE ATTORNEY
01:03:08.050 --> 01:03:08.885
GENERAL NEEDS TO KNOW WHO'S
01:03:08.951 --> 01:03:10.820
DOING WHAT FOR INSTANCE TWO
01:03:10.887 --> 01:03:12.488
BUTTONS AT THE WALL. THAT THE
01:03:12.555 --> 01:03:13.623
FIRM IS PLAYING WHEN THEY'RE
01:03:13.689 --> 01:03:15.625
SOLICITING DONATIONS POLLUTION
01:03:15.691 --> 01:03:18.794
HALF THE GAS. AND FIGURE THAT
01:03:18.861 --> 01:03:22.431
OUT- AND THERE ARE DIFFERENT
01:03:22.498 --> 01:03:23.833
TYPES OF REGISTRATION CATEGORY
01:03:23.900 --> 01:03:28.037
IF THERE'S ONE CALLED THE TREE
01:03:28.104 --> 01:03:33.442
HE IS A CENTURY ASKS ARE. OLD
01:03:33.509 --> 01:03:35.378
CHARITABLE ASSET. THERE'S A
01:03:35.444 --> 01:03:36.812
WEDGE AND WHAT WILL FOR THAT
01:03:36.879 --> 01:03:38.214
THAT FOCUSED ON FOR INSTANCE
01:03:38.281 --> 01:03:40.850
CHAIRED CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
01:03:40.917 --> 01:03:42.385
AND THE PROVIDING INFORMATION
01:03:42.451 --> 01:03:44.820
ALONG THE LINES OF FLAKE OUT OF
01:03:44.887 --> 01:03:46.155
FINANCIAL STATEMENT THAT YOU'LL
01:03:46.222 --> 01:03:48.591
SEE FROM AN AUDITOR IT REALLY
01:03:48.658 --> 01:03:50.426
INVOLVES FUNDAMENTAL ASPECTS OF
01:03:50.493 --> 01:03:54.163
BEING A CHARITY- MEANWHILE WHAT
01:03:54.230 --> 01:03:57.066
WE HAVE HERE IS- BUT THE BILL-
01:03:57.133 --> 01:03:59.669
ENVISIONED AS A CHARITABLE
01:03:59.735 --> 01:04:01.404
FUNDRAISING PLATFORM. IS VERY
01:04:01.470 --> 01:04:03.806
WELL MAY NOT BE AN ACTUAL
01:04:03.873 --> 01:04:05.608
CHARITY AT ALL ALTHOUGH IN SOME
01:04:05.675 --> 01:04:07.610
CASES THE COULD BE. AND THIS IS
01:04:07.677 --> 01:04:10.279
AN AND IN THE OPTIONAL ROLE
01:04:10.346 --> 01:04:12.782
THAT IF IT IS A CHARITY BUT IT
01:04:12.848 --> 01:04:13.950
MAY TAKE ON AND IT'S KIND OF
01:04:14.016 --> 01:04:15.318
LIKE THEY'RE THEY'RE TAKING ON
01:04:15.384 --> 01:04:17.653
THE ROLE OF FUND RAISING FOR
01:04:17.720 --> 01:04:19.689
OTHER CHARITY. SO WE NEED TO
01:04:19.755 --> 01:04:20.890
KNOW FOR INSTANCE WHO IS
01:04:20.957 --> 01:04:22.558
SERVING IN THAT ROLE OUR
01:04:22.625 --> 01:04:25.261
CAPACITY OF A CHARITABLE
01:04:25.328 --> 01:04:26.996
FUNDRAISING TOP FORM. SO WE CAN
01:04:27.063 --> 01:04:29.065
SUPERVISE FACILITATION FOR
01:04:29.131 --> 01:04:31.267
POSSIBLE WRONGDOING. IN THIS
01:04:31.334 --> 01:04:33.035
BAG FOR AN ADDITIONAL
01:04:33.102 --> 01:04:34.904
REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS SO WE
01:04:34.971 --> 01:04:36.405
CAN LEARN THAT FOR AN
01:04:36.472 --> 01:04:38.040
ADEQUATELY PROTECT THE PUBLIC
01:04:38.107 --> 01:04:41.344
SPECIFIC TO THE ONLINE.
01:04:41.410 --> 01:04:43.045
SOLICITATION WHAT PORTING
01:04:43.112 --> 01:04:44.213
REQUIREMENTS THAT GO WITH
01:04:44.280 --> 01:04:47.116
REGISTRATION WOULD BE SPECIFIC
01:04:47.183 --> 01:04:50.152
ALSO TO THE ONLINE FLIRTATIONS
01:04:50.219 --> 01:04:50.586
SO THERE WOULDN'T BE
01:04:50.653 --> 01:04:52.321
DUPLICATION AND REPORTING AND
01:04:52.388 --> 01:04:54.590
NOT CARD. I DO WANT TO POINT
01:04:54.657 --> 01:04:56.559
OUT TODAY THAT THERE IS A DUAL
01:04:56.626 --> 01:04:58.594
REGISTRATION AS A RELATES TO
01:04:58.661 --> 01:05:01.297
THESE TYPES OF TRUSTEES TODAY.
01:05:01.364 --> 01:05:02.398
OR NOT IT'S WHEN THEY PERFORM
01:05:02.465 --> 01:05:03.799
RAFFLES WHICH IS THE TYPE OF
01:05:03.866 --> 01:05:06.402
THE LEGAL FORM OF GAMBLING AND
01:05:06.469 --> 01:05:08.271
WHEN A CHARITY PERFORMS ARRIVAL
01:05:08.337 --> 01:05:09.272
THEY NEED TO REGISTER IN
01:05:09.338 --> 01:05:11.140
ADVANCE BEFORE PERFORMING THE
01:05:11.207 --> 01:05:13.442
RAFFLES AND PROVIDE- SEPARATE
01:05:13.509 --> 01:05:17.446
REPORTING ON THAT AS WELL- YOU
01:05:17.513 --> 01:05:19.749
KNOW THAT. THIS IS WORKED OUT
01:05:19.815 --> 01:05:21.284
FINE AND THE CAPACITY OF
01:05:21.350 --> 01:05:27.056
RAFFLES LIKE THAT. I'M. AND WE
01:05:27.123 --> 01:05:30.126
WE'RE NOT SEEING THE CONCERN
01:05:30.192 --> 01:05:31.694
THAT. IT MAY HAVE. THE DOOR
01:05:31.761 --> 01:05:34.897
REGISTRATION. THE THAT'S IT
01:05:34.964 --> 01:05:36.699
YOUR HONOR. THANK YOU DESERVE
01:05:36.766 --> 01:05:38.701
TO YEAH I THINK SO I EIGHTH.
01:05:38.768 --> 01:05:39.568
WE'RE WE'RE SAYING THAT THE
01:05:39.635 --> 01:05:42.872
POLL ON THE- THAT MAY PRESENT
01:05:42.938 --> 01:05:46.075
AS A CHARITABLE PLATFORM BUT
01:05:46.142 --> 01:05:47.476
BUT IS DIFFERENT FROM THE
01:05:47.543 --> 01:05:50.212
ACTUAL- TRUST IN THE CHURCH
01:05:50.279 --> 01:05:51.881
ORGANIZATION AND IF THERE'S
01:05:51.947 --> 01:05:53.783
DIFFERENCES THERE THEN WE WANT
01:05:53.849 --> 01:05:55.284
TO BE ABLE TO SKIP THOSE PEOPLE
01:05:55.351 --> 01:06:00.790
IN AND THE BILL. OKAY SO THE
01:06:00.856 --> 01:06:04.360
GET AN AGING THIS COULD I COME
01:06:04.427 --> 01:06:07.229
JUST MAKE ONE THE VERY BRIEFLY
01:06:07.296 --> 01:06:15.071
SIR. SURE THAT OF WE ARE.
01:06:15.137 --> 01:06:18.074
REVIEWING AMEND UNDERLYING THAT
01:06:18.140 --> 01:06:20.176
WE'RE MADE. TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:06:20.242 --> 01:06:22.712
MONDAY AFTERNOON. AND WE'RE
01:06:22.778 --> 01:06:25.748
COMMITTED TO. DISCUSSING AND-
01:06:25.815 --> 01:06:27.650
WORK THROUGH THE THINGS OF THE
01:06:27.717 --> 01:06:31.620
NEXT DAYS I THINK AS A GENERAL
01:06:31.687 --> 01:06:34.156
MATTER. YOU HOW ORGANIZATIONS
01:06:34.223 --> 01:06:35.658
THAT ARE ALREADY REGISTERED
01:06:35.725 --> 01:06:37.493
UNDER THIS LAW AS DIFFERENT
01:06:37.560 --> 01:06:39.895
ENTITIES THAT THE COMMERCIAL
01:06:39.962 --> 01:06:42.298
COVENTRY AS A- COMMERCIAL
01:06:42.365 --> 01:06:45.434
FRIENDLY MADE. AND CONDUCT THAT
01:06:45.501 --> 01:06:48.003
THIS BILL SEEKS TO ADDRESS OF
01:06:48.070 --> 01:06:49.238
COURSE THE INTERNET FUND
01:06:49.305 --> 01:06:51.774
RAISING ON THE PLATFORM SO IF
01:06:51.841 --> 01:06:54.710
YOU'RE AN EXISTING ORGANIZATION
01:06:54.777 --> 01:06:55.411
ALREADY REGISTERED AT THE END
01:06:55.478 --> 01:06:59.915
AND YOU ELECT TO. THE KIND. OF
01:06:59.982 --> 01:07:02.118
CONDUCT FALLS UNDER THE BUILD
01:07:02.184 --> 01:07:04.220
BUT NAKHTMIN ISSUE VYING.
01:07:04.286 --> 01:07:05.287
SHOULD THERE BE SEPARATE
01:07:05.354 --> 01:07:10.025
REGISTRATION. AND IN ORDER TO.
01:07:10.092 --> 01:07:11.560
FACILITATE OVERSIGHT OVER
01:07:11.627 --> 01:07:14.730
PLATFORM TYPE OF CONDUCT OR
01:07:14.797 --> 01:07:18.067
SHOULD USE SIMPLY BE ALLOWED TO
01:07:18.134 --> 01:07:19.301
ENGAGE IN THAT KIND OF CONDUCT.
01:07:19.368 --> 01:07:20.603
AND MAINTAIN YOUR PREVIOUS
01:07:20.669 --> 01:07:22.037
REGISTRATION OF A TOTALLY
01:07:22.104 --> 01:07:24.407
DIFFERENT ENTITY. WHICH WAS
01:07:24.473 --> 01:07:27.042
REQUIRED OF YOU IN THE FIRST
01:07:27.109 --> 01:07:27.576
PLACE FOR DIFFERENT SET OF
01:07:27.643 --> 01:07:31.147
CONDUCT. SO THAT'S ALL I HAVE
01:07:31.213 --> 01:07:32.782
THANK VERY GOOD THANK YOU
01:07:32.848 --> 01:07:36.385
SENATOR MONNING. THANK YOU.
01:07:36.452 --> 01:07:38.421
MADAM CHAIR AND I THINK THE
01:07:38.487 --> 01:07:40.089
AUTHOR ADDRESS THIS BUT I WOULD
01:07:40.156 --> 01:07:43.426
JUST AMPLIFY THE NEXUS WITH
01:07:43.492 --> 01:07:46.128
COVERT NINETEEN TO ME IS
01:07:46.195 --> 01:07:47.329
CRYSTAL CLEAR. THIS WEEK
01:07:47.396 --> 01:07:49.198
TOMORROW THE SIX HUNDRED
01:07:49.265 --> 01:07:51.233
DOLLARS A MONTH FOR PEOPLE
01:07:51.300 --> 01:07:54.136
WHO'VE LOST THEIR JOBS THROUGH
01:07:54.203 --> 01:07:56.906
NO CHOICE OF THEIR OWN EXPIRES
01:07:56.972 --> 01:07:59.241
NO BACK UP COMING FROM THE
01:07:59.308 --> 01:08:02.144
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT WE'RE GONNA
01:08:02.211 --> 01:08:03.412
PEOPLE FACING. FICTION THE
01:08:03.479 --> 01:08:04.680
INABILITY TO PAY RENT AND
01:08:04.747 --> 01:08:06.782
ABILITY TO PAY THEIR- FEED
01:08:06.849 --> 01:08:08.451
THEIR FAMILIES TO PUT GAS IN
01:08:08.517 --> 01:08:11.353
THEIR CARS. WERE GOING FROM
01:08:11.420 --> 01:08:15.057
CRISIS TO SUPER CRISIS AND- IN
01:08:15.124 --> 01:08:17.593
THOSE THAT HAVE BEEN DISPLACED
01:08:17.660 --> 01:08:19.428
ARE GONNA BE MORE DEPENDENT ON
01:08:19.495 --> 01:08:20.930
CHARITABLE GIVING THERE'S GOING
01:08:20.996 --> 01:08:22.665
TO BE AN INCREASE IN CHARITABLE
01:08:22.731 --> 01:08:25.201
APPEALS. MANNING HOPEFULLY MOST
01:08:25.267 --> 01:08:28.137
WILL BE LEGITIMATE SOME WILL BE
01:08:28.204 --> 01:08:30.306
CON ARTISTS WHO ARE GONNA PLAY
01:08:30.372 --> 01:08:33.008
UP ON PEOPLE'S SYMPATHY AND
01:08:33.075 --> 01:08:34.977
CONCERN FOR OTHER DISPLACED IN
01:08:35.044 --> 01:08:38.247
WITH. SUPPORT IN THIS TIME OF
01:08:38.314 --> 01:08:40.850
CRISIS SO. I DON'T THINK IT'S A
01:08:40.916 --> 01:08:43.586
STRETCH TO SEE THIS BILL IS
01:08:43.652 --> 01:08:45.654
VERY CONSISTENT WITH OUR
01:08:45.721 --> 01:08:47.857
PRIORITIZATION OF COVERT
01:08:47.923 --> 01:08:49.058
NINETEEN AND I'D LIKE TO MOVE
01:08:49.125 --> 01:08:50.192
THE BILL AT THE APPROPRIATE
01:08:50.259 --> 01:08:52.461
TIME THANK YOU THANK YOU. AND I
01:08:52.528 --> 01:08:53.462
WOULD LIKE TO SAY TO MY
01:08:53.529 --> 01:08:54.697
RESPONSE THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN
01:08:54.763 --> 01:08:56.999
A LITTLE CLIP THIS IS VERY
01:08:57.066 --> 01:08:58.234
DEFINITELY COVERED RELATED
01:08:58.300 --> 01:09:00.369
DIRECTLY WERE A COUPLE BILLS.
01:09:00.436 --> 01:09:03.739
THAT WE CONSIDERED TO HEAR
01:09:03.806 --> 01:09:05.341
DEALING WITH THIS ISSUE OF
01:09:05.407 --> 01:09:07.343
CHARITABLE GIVING AND THE
01:09:07.409 --> 01:09:10.679
MINUTE. SADLY THAT WE'RE SEEING
01:09:10.746 --> 01:09:12.481
WITH THE AUNT OF WELL MEANING
01:09:12.548 --> 01:09:15.251
IN INTEREST WHO WOULD TO HELP
01:09:15.317 --> 01:09:22.291
THOSE. NEED THIS BILL ACT. UP
01:09:22.358 --> 01:09:27.530
AS FAR THAT. AND I KNOW THAT
01:09:27.596 --> 01:09:28.297
THERE ARE TWO AMENDMENTS
01:09:28.364 --> 01:09:30.299
SHOULD'VE TO. WITH ATTORNEY
01:09:30.366 --> 01:09:32.668
OFFICE IS SORT OF THE OF IT
01:09:32.735 --> 01:09:34.503
FIND WE HAVE AN ONLINE. EMPIRE
01:09:34.570 --> 01:09:37.439
OF THE- IS THAT. THEY'RE VERY
01:09:37.506 --> 01:09:39.942
PLATFORM OUT THERE THAT ARE-
01:09:40.009 --> 01:09:41.277
WITHOUT THE PERMISSION OR
01:09:41.343 --> 01:09:43.746
APPROVAL OF THE ACTUAL CHARITY
01:09:43.812 --> 01:09:45.714
THAT IS BEING REPRESENTED
01:09:45.781 --> 01:09:48.017
CLAIMING THAT THEY ARE IN FACT
01:09:48.083 --> 01:09:49.885
RAISING MONEY FOR THEIR CHARITY
01:09:49.952 --> 01:09:53.322
AND IF THAT IS THE CASE THEN
01:09:53.389 --> 01:09:54.890
THEY SHOULD FALL WITH THE PER
01:09:54.957 --> 01:09:57.259
OF THE- GENERAL WHO. CONTROL
01:09:57.326 --> 01:09:59.862
CHAIRED GIVING SO WITH THE-
01:09:59.929 --> 01:10:01.196
INTRODUCTION AND IN FACT MEANT
01:10:01.263 --> 01:10:03.132
OF INTERNET TRANSACTIONS IN
01:10:03.198 --> 01:10:05.134
THIS WAY THERE IS REALLY BEEN
01:10:05.201 --> 01:10:07.336
INADEQUATE PROTECTIONS. FOR
01:10:07.403 --> 01:10:09.738
THOSE WHO WANT TO GIVE ONLINE
01:10:09.805 --> 01:10:10.739
FOR THOSE CHARITIES AND THAT'S
01:10:10.806 --> 01:10:13.609
ESSENTIALLY WHAT THIS BILL. IS
01:10:13.676 --> 01:10:19.848
AND A DESIGNS TO REGULATE SO.
01:10:19.915 --> 01:10:20.516
AGAIN THE CURRENT PROVISIONS
01:10:20.583 --> 01:10:22.885
ARE REGULATE MORE CHARTER A
01:10:22.952 --> 01:10:25.487
MORE TRADITIONAL SOLICITATIONS
01:10:25.554 --> 01:10:28.524
AND IT HASN'T BEEN MODERNIZED-
01:10:28.591 --> 01:10:30.726
PARTICULARLY AT THIS POINT TIME.
01:10:30.793 --> 01:10:32.628
WHERE WE'RE SEEING- THE
01:10:32.695 --> 01:10:34.330
GENEROSITY OF THE PEOPLE OF
01:10:34.396 --> 01:10:35.264
CALIFORNIA IN THE PEOPLE'S
01:10:35.331 --> 01:10:37.766
COUNTRY COMING FORWARD WE WANT
01:10:37.833 --> 01:10:40.235
TO MAKE SURE THAT THEIR GIFTS
01:10:40.302 --> 01:10:42.538
TO THOSE IN NEED GOAL TO THOSE
01:10:42.605 --> 01:10:44.740
PEOPLE IN NEED AND-
01:10:44.807 --> 01:10:47.309
UNFORTUNATELY. WE HAVE WITH
01:10:47.376 --> 01:10:47.876
THIS CRISIS AS WE SEE WITH
01:10:47.943 --> 01:10:49.578
EVERY CRISIS THERE ARE THOSE
01:10:49.645 --> 01:10:51.780
OUT THERE WANT TO TAKE
01:10:51.847 --> 01:10:53.949
ADVANTAGE OF THE CROP FOR THE
01:10:54.016 --> 01:10:57.886
PHONE. UP OFTEN. THREE SHELF
01:10:57.953 --> 01:10:59.555
AND GREED DROVE DOES AND THIS
01:10:59.622 --> 01:11:02.124
IS A MEASURE THAT TRIES TO PUT
01:11:02.191 --> 01:11:04.026
A CHECK ON THAT AND FRANKLY
01:11:04.093 --> 01:11:06.295
THAT'S THE REASON THAT I WAS-
01:11:06.362 --> 01:11:08.097
WANTING AN ANXIOUS TO HEAR THIS
01:11:08.163 --> 01:11:10.566
BILL BECAUSE I DO THINK IT WILL
01:11:10.633 --> 01:11:12.167
MOVE US FORWARD I IN THAT
01:11:12.234 --> 01:11:14.603
PROTECT. THE ARE ON GOAL.
01:11:14.670 --> 01:11:17.306
DISCUSSIONS I KNOW THAT MANY
01:11:17.373 --> 01:11:19.208
AMENDMENTS HAVE BEEN TAKEN AND
01:11:19.274 --> 01:11:21.110
I THINK ARE THERE ARE STILL.
01:11:21.176 --> 01:11:23.846
DISCUSSIONS GOING ON. BUT AT
01:11:23.912 --> 01:11:25.447
THIS MOMENT IN TIME IN ALL
01:11:25.514 --> 01:11:28.150
CANDOR WE ARE SEEING. A LOT OF
01:11:28.217 --> 01:11:30.586
MONEY MOVING ON THE INTERNET
01:11:30.653 --> 01:11:31.987
FOR CHARITABLE GIVING AND WE
01:11:32.054 --> 01:11:33.589
NEED TO MAKE SURE IT GOES WHERE
01:11:33.656 --> 01:11:34.923
IT'S SUPPOSED TO SO. I WANT TO
01:11:34.990 --> 01:11:37.860
THANK YOU FOR DOING THE AND-
01:11:37.926 --> 01:11:40.562
ALSO TO ASK YOU TO REITERATE
01:11:40.629 --> 01:11:42.931
FOR US ON THE RECORD HERE THAT
01:11:42.998 --> 01:11:44.700
ARE. IN EWING GROCERY SHOULD TO
01:11:44.767 --> 01:11:48.337
TRY TO ADDRESS- SOME OF CONCERT
01:11:48.404 --> 01:11:51.473
THAT. HAVE BEEN ARE TO. UP TO
01:11:51.540 --> 01:11:54.076
HAVE ADDRESSED MANY OF THEIR-
01:11:54.143 --> 01:11:58.914
STILL OPEN OR WORK TO DO. AS
01:11:58.981 --> 01:12:00.983
TO. IT'S IMPORTANT THAT. BUT A
01:12:01.050 --> 01:12:02.117
MEMBER CHARTER ENSURE THE DE
01:12:02.184 --> 01:12:03.719
ARE OF HOW SHARON WILL
01:12:03.786 --> 01:12:06.321
FUNDRAISING PLATFORMS AND
01:12:06.388 --> 01:12:08.390
PLATFORM CHARITIES OPERATE.
01:12:08.457 --> 01:12:10.559
INCLUDING ROBUST DISCLOSURE
01:12:10.626 --> 01:12:12.394
ABOUT FEES AND POLICIES AND
01:12:12.461 --> 01:12:14.329
PROCEDURES AND THAT THE REASON
01:12:14.396 --> 01:12:16.799
DE THAT APPROPRIATE OVERSIGHT.
01:12:16.865 --> 01:12:18.233
WITH THE ATTORNEY GENERAL THAT
01:12:18.300 --> 01:12:20.502
WE NEED TO GIVE THE AG IN ORDER
01:12:20.569 --> 01:12:23.439
TO SAVE OUR DONORS AND THOSE
01:12:23.505 --> 01:12:24.239
DONATIONS ARE TEN TO GO TO
01:12:24.306 --> 01:12:28.043
CHURCH SO WHICH SHARE WITH US
01:12:28.110 --> 01:12:29.244
ARE WHAT SOME OF THESE
01:12:29.311 --> 01:12:30.579
POTENTIAL MEMBERS ARE THAT
01:12:30.646 --> 01:12:32.681
YOU'RE PLANNING ON TAKING. AND
01:12:32.748 --> 01:12:35.350
WHICH ISSUES THESE INTENDED TO
01:12:35.417 --> 01:12:38.420
ADDRESS OF THAT BUT I WON'T PUT
01:12:38.487 --> 01:12:39.488
ANY ANY AMENDMENTS WE TAKE WILL
01:12:39.555 --> 01:12:40.823
BE PART OF THE STAKEHOLDER
01:12:40.889 --> 01:12:43.992
PROCESS WILL MAKE SURE THAT OUR
01:12:44.059 --> 01:12:47.596
SPONSOR THE DOJ. CAL PROF OR
01:12:47.663 --> 01:12:49.264
COMFORT WITH IT AND WE WILL
01:12:49.331 --> 01:12:50.399
MAKE SURE THAT ANY AND THEN
01:12:50.466 --> 01:12:52.801
SATURDAY IN ARE RUN BY THIS
01:12:52.868 --> 01:12:54.837
COMMITTEE ALSO VERY GOOD STORE.
01:12:54.903 --> 01:12:58.440
AGAIN WE ARE IN TRUNCATED
01:12:58.507 --> 01:13:02.177
COALBED. DRIVEN SEARCH IT IS
01:13:02.244 --> 01:13:06.849
NOT I DO BY ANY STRETCH. THE
01:13:06.915 --> 01:13:10.686
FRANKLY. PORT OF HIS PEOPLE FOR
01:13:10.753 --> 01:13:12.087
REACH OUT TO WE WANT TO MAKE
01:13:12.154 --> 01:13:13.756
SURE THAT THE THAT THERE IN TEN
01:13:13.822 --> 01:13:14.389
ARE MET AND THAT THE PEOPLE WHO
01:13:14.456 --> 01:13:16.458
THAT ASSISTANCE RECEIVE IT SO-
01:13:16.525 --> 01:13:20.229
WITH THAT- WE DO HAVE A MOTION
01:13:20.295 --> 01:13:22.765
THE MOTION IS TO PASS THE
01:13:22.831 --> 01:13:24.399
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS. FAMILY
01:13:24.466 --> 01:13:25.100
MEMBER OR WHEN WOULD YOU LIKE
01:13:25.167 --> 01:13:27.169
CLOSE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I
01:13:27.236 --> 01:13:31.306
THE VERY GOOD- MADAM CONSULTANT
01:13:31.373 --> 01:13:33.809
WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL-
01:13:33.876 --> 01:13:37.012
SENATORS PLEASE TURN YOUR
01:13:37.079 --> 01:13:37.946
MICROPHONES ON AT ITS- FILE
01:13:38.013 --> 01:13:41.016
ITEM SEVEN. AB TWO TWO OH EIGHT
01:13:41.083 --> 01:13:43.185
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN THE
01:13:43.252 --> 01:13:45.320
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO THE
01:13:45.387 --> 01:13:45.788
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
01:13:45.854 --> 01:13:50.092
COMMITTEE. JACKSON HI JACKSON
01:13:50.159 --> 01:13:54.630
BY BARGES. FOR JUST NOT VOTING
01:13:54.696 --> 01:13:59.768
DATA SO I RUSSELL I GONZALEZ I
01:13:59.835 --> 01:14:02.905
FROM THE LIST HI MELENDEZ NO
01:14:02.971 --> 01:14:07.009
MELENDEZ NO MONNING AYE MONNING
01:14:07.075 --> 01:14:19.555
I. STERN A- STERN I AM BURKE.
01:14:19.621 --> 01:14:26.595
WIECKOWSKI HI MY CAL SKI I. TWO
01:14:26.662 --> 01:14:28.096
FOUR FIVE. SIX TWO ONE IN THE
01:14:28.163 --> 01:14:30.065
MEMBERS APPETITE OF THE VOTE
01:14:30.132 --> 01:14:32.167
COUNT IS CURRENTLY SIX TO ONE
01:14:32.234 --> 01:14:33.268
WE HAVE A MISSING MEMBERS SO
01:14:33.335 --> 01:14:34.469
WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON CALL
01:14:34.536 --> 01:14:54.456
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER. ROOM.
01:15:03.665 --> 01:15:05.534
MAY MAY I ASK IF YOU ALSO
01:15:05.601 --> 01:15:07.569
CLEANED OFF THE MICROPHONE CAP
01:15:07.636 --> 01:15:09.738
I DIDN'T SEE THAT VERY GOOD
01:15:09.805 --> 01:15:13.542
THANK YOU SO MUCH. ALL RIGHT.
01:15:13.609 --> 01:15:17.679
WE HAVE HERE. THE OUR NEXT UP
01:15:17.746 --> 01:15:20.349
IS ASSEMBLY MEMBER CARILLO THIS
01:15:20.415 --> 01:15:24.386
BILL BUT I SEE. ASSEMBLYMEMBER
01:15:24.453 --> 01:15:27.723
GLORIA HERE- ARE YOU PRESENTING
01:15:27.789 --> 01:15:28.357
FOR HER OR YOU'RE PRESENTING ON
01:15:28.423 --> 01:15:30.559
YOUR OWN BILL FIVE WE GENERALLY
01:15:30.626 --> 01:15:32.928
GO IN FILE ORDER BUT SINCE YOU
01:15:32.995 --> 01:15:35.898
ARE PRESENT WE WILL GO AHEAD.
01:15:35.964 --> 01:15:37.532
WITH THAT ITEM UNLESS THERE'S
01:15:37.599 --> 01:15:39.534
ANY OBJECTIONHAS ANYBODY
01:15:39.601 --> 01:15:40.102
CALLED ASSEMBLY MEMBER COULD
01:15:40.168 --> 01:15:44.573
YOU. AB FORTY FOUR OUT OF ORDER
01:15:44.640 --> 01:15:46.541
THAT THAT'S A GOOD POINT SO
01:15:46.608 --> 01:15:52.781
LET'S SEE IF A. OH OKAY I DID
01:15:52.848 --> 01:15:54.716
NOT RECOGNIZE YOU IN THAT MASK.
01:15:54.783 --> 01:15:59.855
I'M SO STORAGE AREN'T. WE IN
01:15:59.922 --> 01:16:02.758
TWO R THREE DAYS AS AN ADULT
01:16:02.824 --> 01:16:10.766
CONSENT OF MOST OF THE- WHAT.
01:16:10.832 --> 01:16:14.469
AT NOW RECENTLY AFTER CALL.
01:16:14.536 --> 01:16:18.607
RIGHT OKAY ARE A NUMBER MY
01:16:18.674 --> 01:16:20.042
APOLOGIES ARE WE HAVE TO GO IN
01:16:20.108 --> 01:16:22.144
FILE ORDER BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE
01:16:22.210 --> 01:16:24.813
ON THE PHONES- CUED UP TO SPEAK
01:16:24.880 --> 01:16:27.416
AND I THINK WE ARE JUST GOING
01:16:27.482 --> 01:16:30.052
TO HAVE TO- BEAR WITH THE
01:16:30.118 --> 01:16:33.422
CURRENT SYSTEM AS- STRUCTURED
01:16:33.488 --> 01:16:37.392
INCIDENTS SO- WE WILL PROCEED I
01:16:37.459 --> 01:16:38.360
WILL INDICATE TO YOU ASSEMBLY
01:16:38.427 --> 01:16:40.696
MEMBER CARILLO THAT APPARENTLY
01:16:40.762 --> 01:16:42.664
THERE IS NO OBJECTION TO THIS
01:16:42.731 --> 01:16:47.769
MEASURE SO IF YOU'D LIKE TO BE
01:16:47.836 --> 01:16:48.470
BRIEF WOULD CERTAINLY BE THE-
01:16:48.537 --> 01:16:52.207
OF YOU. THE SOUTH. HAVE THE
01:16:52.274 --> 01:16:54.209
TWENTY ENTER BUT I WILL I HAVE
01:16:54.276 --> 01:16:56.678
EVERY CONFIDENCE YOU CAN REDUCE
01:16:56.745 --> 01:16:58.780
IT DOWN TO OF A MINUTE. ALL
01:16:58.847 --> 01:17:00.015
RIGHT VERY GOOD THANK YOU MADAM
01:17:00.082 --> 01:17:01.883
CHAIR AND MEMBERS I'M HERE 2%
01:17:01.950 --> 01:17:03.385
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY THREE
01:17:03.452 --> 01:17:04.486
TWENTY FIVE. WHICH ALLOWS
01:17:04.553 --> 01:17:05.821
INDIVIDUALS TO SUSPEND THEIR
01:17:05.887 --> 01:17:07.522
CHILD SUPPORT ORDERS WHILE
01:17:07.589 --> 01:17:10.058
INCARCERATED OR INVOLUNTARILY
01:17:10.125 --> 01:17:11.226
HELD FOR AN INSTITUTION MORE
01:17:11.293 --> 01:17:12.961
THAN NINETY DAYS. BEFORE
01:17:13.028 --> 01:17:14.563
JANUARY ONE TWENTY TWENTY
01:17:14.629 --> 01:17:15.797
CALIFORNIA PROVIDED AN
01:17:15.864 --> 01:17:17.499
AUTOMATIC PROCESSES FOR THE
01:17:17.566 --> 01:17:18.734
TEMPORARY SUSPENSION OF CHILD
01:17:18.800 --> 01:17:20.268
SUPPORT ORDERS FOR INCARCERATED
01:17:20.335 --> 01:17:22.904
PARENTS- UNFORTUNATELY THE
01:17:22.971 --> 01:17:24.840
STATE LAW EXPIRED AND ARE
01:17:24.906 --> 01:17:26.508
HOPING TO BRING IT BACK AND TO
01:17:26.575 --> 01:17:28.276
PROVIDE SOME RELIEF. FOR
01:17:28.343 --> 01:17:29.711
PARENTS WHO ARE CURRENTLY
01:17:29.778 --> 01:17:30.779
INCARCERATED IN CLEARLY WHILE
01:17:30.846 --> 01:17:32.047
YOU'RE INCARCERATED YOU DO NOT
01:17:32.114 --> 01:17:35.584
HAVE A JOB. AND SO. GIVEN THE
01:17:35.650 --> 01:17:37.619
CURRENT CIRCUMSTANCES WE HOPE
01:17:37.686 --> 01:17:39.988
TO BE ABLE TO. SLAUGHTER SPEC
01:17:40.055 --> 01:17:42.090
REQUEST I VOTE AND BEFORE WE
01:17:42.157 --> 01:17:44.693
PROCEED I WANT TO CONFIRM THAT
01:17:44.760 --> 01:17:48.730
YOU ARE ACCEPTING IT SAW.
01:17:48.797 --> 01:17:51.700
THIRTY ON PAGE TWO. A PAYCHECK
01:17:51.767 --> 01:17:53.268
COMMENT FOR THE IN OUR THAT IS
01:17:53.335 --> 01:17:54.202
YES VERY GOOD FOR GOOD ALL
01:17:54.269 --> 01:17:56.772
RIGHT SO. WE HAVE I BELIEVE
01:17:56.838 --> 01:18:00.342
WITNESSES WITNESSES HERE AGAIN
01:18:00.409 --> 01:18:02.778
I WILL REITERATE BECAUSE MY
01:18:02.844 --> 01:18:04.379
SCRIPTURES I NEED TO THE DUE TO
01:18:04.446 --> 01:18:06.548
THE CONSTRAINTS REGARDING THE
01:18:06.615 --> 01:18:08.550
LENGTH OF HEARINGS TECHNOLOGY
01:18:08.617 --> 01:18:09.785
CONSIDERATIONS AND ARE CLEAN
01:18:09.851 --> 01:18:15.023
PROTOCOLS COMMITTEES WILL INCH
01:18:15.090 --> 01:18:19.227
TIME LIMITS ON TO. OF THREE
01:18:19.294 --> 01:18:20.128
MINUTES ALL OTHER WISHING TO
01:18:20.195 --> 01:18:21.596
TESTIFY TO LIMIT THEIR
01:18:21.663 --> 01:18:23.065
COMMENTS. TO THEIR NAME
01:18:23.131 --> 01:18:25.834
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
01:18:25.901 --> 01:18:28.136
MEASURE SO WITH THAT I BELIEVE
01:18:28.203 --> 01:18:32.207
WE HAVE A TWO WITNESSES- ALICIA
01:18:32.274 --> 01:18:35.377
LEWIS OF THE CENTER FOR
01:18:35.444 --> 01:18:37.145
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES ON THE
01:18:37.212 --> 01:18:38.380
LINE IN SUPPORT. AS WELL AS
01:18:38.447 --> 01:18:40.382
VICTORY BREA ON THE CHILD
01:18:40.449 --> 01:18:42.417
SUPPORT DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION
01:18:42.484 --> 01:18:45.087
ON THE LINE IS THAT CORRECT THE
01:18:45.153 --> 01:18:53.195
MADAM MARK MODERATOR. COULD I
01:18:53.261 --> 01:18:55.030
GET AN AFFIRMATIVE ON THAT YES
01:18:55.097 --> 01:18:56.098
ALL RIGHT VERY GOOD SO LET'S
01:18:56.164 --> 01:18:59.634
BEGIN- WITH ALICIA LEWIS THE
01:18:59.701 --> 01:19:01.736
FLOOR IS YOURS BAND- I ASSUME
01:19:01.803 --> 01:19:03.205
YOU'RE GOING TO BE SHARING YOUR
01:19:03.271 --> 01:19:06.041
THREE MINUTES WITH MISTER RAY.
01:19:06.108 --> 01:19:08.910
YES NOT GONNA BE BRIEFED CHAIR.
01:19:08.977 --> 01:19:10.178
WE FEEL IF POLICY DIRECTOR FOR
01:19:10.245 --> 01:19:11.646
THE CENTER FOR EMPLOYMENT
01:19:11.713 --> 01:19:12.848
OPPORTUNITIES CUT CO SPONSORED
01:19:12.914 --> 01:19:14.916
THE MEASURE. WE ARE A NATIONAL
01:19:14.983 --> 01:19:16.451
NONPROFIT PROVIDING IMMEDIATE
01:19:16.518 --> 01:19:17.586
COMPREHENSIVE EMPLOYMENT
01:19:17.652 --> 01:19:19.554
SERVICES TO INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
01:19:19.621 --> 01:19:20.055
RETURNING HOME TO
01:19:20.122 --> 01:19:21.857
INCARCERATION. AND A PART OF
01:19:21.923 --> 01:19:23.325
OUR SUPPORTED SERVICES ARE
01:19:23.391 --> 01:19:24.493
STAFF HELPED PRODUCE.
01:19:24.559 --> 01:19:26.795
PARTICIPANT BUDGET THERE NEARLY
01:19:26.862 --> 01:19:29.631
FORTY INCOME. AND HOW TO WORK
01:19:29.698 --> 01:19:30.065
TOWARD MEETING THEIR
01:19:30.132 --> 01:19:31.299
OBLIGATIONS. EVERYDAY WORDS
01:19:31.366 --> 01:19:33.235
BEING THE DAMAGE THAT RENTAL
01:19:33.301 --> 01:19:35.370
INSURMOUNTABLE DEBT IS CAUSING
01:19:35.437 --> 01:19:37.139
ON THE ABILITY OF OUR PROGRAM
01:19:37.205 --> 01:19:41.776
PARTICIPANTS THEY GET ON TRACK.
01:19:41.843 --> 01:19:44.846
BUILDERS WHY REINSTATING
01:19:44.913 --> 01:19:46.014
AUTOMATIC MODESTY THE SMALLER
01:19:46.081 --> 01:19:47.649
MINUTES STAFF WORKING AT HAVING
01:19:47.716 --> 01:19:49.017
A IMPACT ON THE LINE THE AND
01:19:49.084 --> 01:19:50.552
MOTHERS WE WERE WITH THE REACH
01:19:50.619 --> 01:19:52.921
HELP AND SHE WE HOPE TO SEE
01:19:52.988 --> 01:19:54.156
BRIDGE AND BACK WITH BOTH THEIR
01:19:54.222 --> 01:19:57.425
FAMILY COMMUNITY WE APPRECIATE
01:19:57.492 --> 01:19:58.760
YOUR AYE ABOUT. THANK YOU VERY
01:19:58.827 --> 01:20:03.365
MUCH NEXT WITNESS. GOOD MORNING
01:20:03.431 --> 01:20:04.166
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
01:20:04.232 --> 01:20:05.300
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS VICTOR RAY
01:20:05.367 --> 01:20:07.903
I'M SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE
01:20:07.969 --> 01:20:08.670
CHILD SUPPORT DIRECTORS
01:20:08.737 --> 01:20:10.805
ASSOCIATION WHEN NON CUSTODIAL
01:20:10.872 --> 01:20:12.607
CARS WAITING AND THEY LOSE
01:20:12.674 --> 01:20:14.142
THEIR ABILITY LARGER THERE'S
01:20:14.209 --> 01:20:16.511
BALANCES ARE INEVITABLY GOING
01:20:16.578 --> 01:20:19.714
TO ACCUMULATE. ON BETTER
01:20:19.781 --> 01:20:22.250
ACTUALLY. A CHILD BEFORE WE SEE
01:20:22.317 --> 01:20:24.386
THAT LOW INCOME AND P. CAN
01:20:24.452 --> 01:20:25.187
BECOME OVER. WHEN THEY HAVE
01:20:25.253 --> 01:20:29.691
CHILD SUPPORT. OR MANY TIMES
01:20:29.758 --> 01:20:32.994
DAILY THE BAD TO SAY TO PUT PAY
01:20:33.061 --> 01:20:33.628
THEIR CHILD'S BECAUSE THEY FEEL
01:20:33.695 --> 01:20:35.163
THEY CAN CATCH UP T. PAY OFF
01:20:35.230 --> 01:20:36.965
INTO. AND TYPICAL THEY OFTEN
01:20:37.032 --> 01:20:39.501
WILL WITHDRAW FROM HI IT'S
01:20:39.568 --> 01:20:40.769
KELLY TIME THERE CHILL.
01:20:40.835 --> 01:20:44.706
DAMAGING THE A MOTIONAL. AT THE
01:20:44.773 --> 01:20:46.374
TRIAL NEEDS WITH THEIR PARENTS
01:20:46.441 --> 01:20:47.309
AS WELL AS THE FINANCIAL
01:20:47.375 --> 01:20:50.545
SUPPORT WHICH THEY'RE LOSING.
01:20:50.612 --> 01:20:51.513
WHEN THE ORDERS PENSION PROP
01:20:51.580 --> 01:20:54.115
WITH THE PLACE. THE UNIFORMED
01:20:54.182 --> 01:20:56.685
APPROACH AROUND STATE THE AREA.
01:20:56.751 --> 01:20:58.153
HOWEVER NOW THAT THE LAW SINCE
01:20:58.220 --> 01:21:00.088
IT COUNTY YOU TAKE DIFFERENT.
01:21:00.155 --> 01:21:03.124
TO MANAGING AND- CARS. ISSUE
01:21:03.191 --> 01:21:04.192
THE END RESULT BEING THAT THE
01:21:04.259 --> 01:21:06.461
WAY CASES HAVE A DEPEND ON
01:21:06.528 --> 01:21:07.762
WHICH COUNTIES AND IS IN THE
01:21:07.829 --> 01:21:10.999
CASE. AB TWENTY TO TWENTY FIVE
01:21:11.066 --> 01:21:12.234
THE BOYS ARE THE POSTING
01:21:12.300 --> 01:21:14.302
RATIONS AREA WE SEE COMMITTEE
01:21:14.369 --> 01:21:16.271
TIME CALIFORNIA. HEALTH
01:21:16.338 --> 01:21:18.206
INSURANCE PETER REASONABLE
01:21:18.273 --> 01:21:19.808
APPROPRIATE QUARTERS. AND ARE
01:21:19.874 --> 01:21:21.876
BETTER ABLE TO. HELP THE POOR
01:21:21.943 --> 01:21:24.479
CLEARLY FROM INCARCERATION IT
01:21:24.546 --> 01:21:25.580
DID NOT GIVE A FREE PASS
01:21:25.647 --> 01:21:33.088
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE THE.
01:21:33.154 --> 01:21:33.521
ABILITY TO PAY WATER
01:21:33.588 --> 01:21:40.428
INCARCERATED. AND I. THANK YOU
01:21:40.495 --> 01:21:42.797
VERY MUCH MR RARE ARM OF THE
01:21:42.864 --> 01:21:45.233
BILL THE MOTION BY SENATOR
01:21:45.300 --> 01:21:46.101
MORNING LET'S BEGIN THOUGH DO
01:21:46.167 --> 01:21:47.702
WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES TO
01:21:47.769 --> 01:21:49.738
TESTIFY ON BEHALF OF THIS BILL
01:21:49.804 --> 01:21:51.072
IN SUPPORT OF IN ROOM FORTY TWO
01:21:51.139 --> 01:21:58.546
OR THREE. SEEING NONE LET'S
01:21:58.613 --> 01:21:59.648
MOVE TO ROOM FORTY. SEEING NONE
01:21:59.714 --> 01:22:00.882
MATAMATA DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESS
01:22:00.949 --> 01:22:05.253
WAY TO TAKE VIA THE TELL. ORVIS
01:22:05.320 --> 01:22:06.755
THANK YOU IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
01:22:06.821 --> 01:22:10.525
IN SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY THREE
01:22:10.592 --> 01:22:11.226
TWENTY FIVE PLEASE PRESS ONE
01:22:11.293 --> 01:22:23.305
AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
01:22:23.371 --> 01:22:25.040
I DO HAVE FOR IN THE QUEUE VERY
01:22:25.106 --> 01:22:26.474
GOOD THANK YOU IF YOU WOULD GO
01:22:26.541 --> 01:22:28.410
AHEAD AND CALL INVITE THEM TO
01:22:28.476 --> 01:22:32.547
SPEAK. AGAIN NAME AFFILIATION
01:22:32.614 --> 01:22:33.148
AND POSITION ON THE BILL ONLY
01:22:33.214 --> 01:22:36.851
PLEASE. THANK YOU BYE AND ONE
01:22:36.918 --> 01:22:39.454
SIXTY FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:22:39.521 --> 01:22:41.022
GOOD MORNING THIS IS A REBEKAH
01:22:41.089 --> 01:22:42.157
GONZALEZ WITH THE NATIONAL
01:22:42.223 --> 01:22:44.359
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
01:22:44.426 --> 01:22:46.828
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN SUPPORT.
01:22:46.895 --> 01:22:50.065
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE.
01:22:50.131 --> 01:22:52.300
THANK YOU I TO ONE SEVENTY SIX
01:22:52.367 --> 01:22:55.737
PLEASE GO AHEAD. SHARES ON
01:22:55.804 --> 01:22:56.638
BEHALF OF A CALIFORNIA
01:22:56.705 --> 01:22:58.273
ATTORNEYS FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE
01:22:58.340 --> 01:23:00.308
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT
01:23:00.375 --> 01:23:04.512
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I ONE
01:23:04.579 --> 01:23:07.182
THIRTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:23:07.248 --> 01:23:08.216
GOOD AFTERNOON GOOD MORNING
01:23:08.283 --> 01:23:11.052
READ MY NAME IS MARA WILSON AND
01:23:11.119 --> 01:23:14.322
I AM IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS.
01:23:14.389 --> 01:23:17.225
MEASURE NOTION BILL THANK YOU
01:23:17.292 --> 01:23:20.161
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
01:23:20.228 --> 01:23:21.763
I HAVE TO AUSTIN Q. OVER THE
01:23:21.830 --> 01:23:23.998
LINE OF ONE EIGHTY SEVEN PLEASE
01:23:24.065 --> 01:23:26.568
GO AHEAD. HEY GOOD MORNING
01:23:26.634 --> 01:23:28.970
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS AS PAUL
01:23:29.037 --> 01:23:29.571
EUROPE WE HAVE TO THE CITY AND
01:23:29.637 --> 01:23:30.405
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO IN
01:23:30.472 --> 01:23:32.240
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. THANK YOU
01:23:32.307 --> 01:23:36.144
SIR NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
01:23:36.211 --> 01:23:36.745
RIDE ONE EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE GO
01:23:36.811 --> 01:23:45.687
AHEAD. ONE EIGHTY FOR YOUR LINE
01:23:45.754 --> 01:23:48.923
IS OPEN. JUST WANTED BET ON THE
01:23:48.990 --> 01:23:50.859
LESSONS ON LAW AND POVERTY AND
01:23:50.925 --> 01:23:53.528
SUPPORT. THANK YOU MA'AM. ARE
01:23:53.595 --> 01:23:55.563
THERE ANY OTHER WITNESSES- IN
01:23:55.630 --> 01:23:57.098
THE QUEUE WISHING TO SPEAK IN
01:23:57.165 --> 01:23:58.833
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE MADAME
01:23:58.900 --> 01:24:02.737
MODERATOR. I HAVE NO FURTHER
01:24:02.804 --> 01:24:03.438
LINES IN THE QUEUE AT THIS
01:24:03.505 --> 01:24:06.241
TIME. VERY GOOD THANK YOU ARE
01:24:06.307 --> 01:24:08.643
THERE ANY WITNESSES WHO WISH TO
01:24:08.710 --> 01:24:11.012
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
01:24:11.079 --> 01:24:12.747
MEASURE. I DON'T BELIEVE WE
01:24:12.814 --> 01:24:17.018
HAVE ANY LISTED- WE GET
01:24:17.085 --> 01:24:18.753
CONFIRMATION THAT THERE ARE NO.
01:24:18.820 --> 01:24:21.022
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION WISHING
01:24:21.089 --> 01:24:25.226
TO SPEAK. ALL RIGHT SEEN THAT A
01:24:25.293 --> 01:24:27.195
DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:24:27.262 --> 01:24:30.031
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM FORTY
01:24:30.098 --> 01:24:32.467
TWO OH THREE. SEEING NONE DO WE
01:24:32.534 --> 01:24:33.868
HAVE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:24:33.935 --> 01:24:36.404
OPPOSITION ROOM TWENTY FORTY.
01:24:36.471 --> 01:24:39.040
SEEING NONE DO WE HAVE ANY
01:24:39.107 --> 01:24:41.209
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION ON THE
01:24:41.276 --> 01:24:42.710
PHONE LINES ARE MATTER
01:24:42.777 --> 01:24:44.879
MODERATOR IF SO WOULD YOU
01:24:44.946 --> 01:24:48.049
PLEASE Q. THEM UP. THANK YOU IF
01:24:48.116 --> 01:24:49.684
YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
01:24:49.751 --> 01:24:52.187
OF AB TWENTY THREE TWENTY FIVE
01:24:52.253 --> 01:24:54.422
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
01:24:54.489 --> 01:25:07.902
AT THIS TIME. THE MODERATOR TO
01:25:07.969 --> 01:25:09.370
WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES CUED UP
01:25:09.437 --> 01:25:13.208
IN OPPOSITION. THERE ARE NO
01:25:13.274 --> 01:25:14.742
LINE THANK YOU AT THIS TIME ALL
01:25:14.809 --> 01:25:18.980
RIGHT. OF DO WE HAVE ANY
01:25:19.047 --> 01:25:21.249
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION HI I
01:25:21.316 --> 01:25:22.984
DID I ASK SYSTEM FORTY TWO A
01:25:23.051 --> 01:25:23.952
THREE YEAR TWENTY FORTY ALL
01:25:24.018 --> 01:25:24.486
RIGHT WE'VE ALREADY BEEN
01:25:24.552 --> 01:25:26.254
THROUGH THAT WILL BRING IT BACK
01:25:26.321 --> 01:25:29.090
THEN TO THE DíAS AND SENATOR
01:25:29.157 --> 01:25:30.291
MELINDA'S THANK YOU MADAM
01:25:30.358 --> 01:25:33.595
CHAIR- SO I HAVE A COUPLE OF
01:25:33.661 --> 01:25:39.234
QUESTIONS. LET'S ASSUME IT IS-
01:25:39.300 --> 01:25:41.436
A MOTHER WHO HAS HE'S TAKING
01:25:41.503 --> 01:25:42.670
CARE OF THE CHILDREN AND THEIR
01:25:42.737 --> 01:25:44.138
SPOUSE OR EX SPOUSES
01:25:44.205 --> 01:25:47.342
INCARCERATED. SO IF THE CHILD
01:25:47.408 --> 01:25:51.145
SUPPORT PAYMENTS STOP. THEN OUT
01:25:51.212 --> 01:25:53.715
WHAT IS THE MOTHER TO DO TO. ME
01:25:53.781 --> 01:25:55.383
IN A SUPPLEMENT THE INCOME THAT
01:25:55.450 --> 01:25:56.951
SHE WOULD HAVE BEEN RECEIVING
01:25:57.018 --> 01:25:58.653
AS CHILD SUPPORT. THAT'S AN
01:25:58.720 --> 01:26:00.922
EXCELLENT QUESTION SENATOR- ONE
01:26:00.989 --> 01:26:02.156
THING THAT WE HAVE TO CONSIDER
01:26:02.223 --> 01:26:03.892
WHEN A PARENT IS INCARCERATED
01:26:03.958 --> 01:26:06.160
IS THAT THEY MAKE ABOUT EIGHT
01:26:06.227 --> 01:26:08.763
CENTS AN HOUR. ON TOP OF THAT
01:26:08.830 --> 01:26:10.865
THE STATE TAKE THE MANDATORY
01:26:10.932 --> 01:26:12.400
55% OUT OF THE EIGHT CENTS PER
01:26:12.467 --> 01:26:14.802
HOUR. SO THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO
01:26:14.869 --> 01:26:16.604
WAY THAT A PARENT THAT IS
01:26:16.671 --> 01:26:18.806
INCARCERATED CAN CONTINUE TO
01:26:18.873 --> 01:26:19.507
MAKE THE CHILD SUPPORT
01:26:19.574 --> 01:26:21.876
PAYMENTS. IN ADDITION TO THAT
01:26:21.943 --> 01:26:23.778
THERE ARE FEES AND PENALTIES
01:26:23.845 --> 01:26:24.679
THE ONE THAT PARENTS RELEASED
01:26:24.746 --> 01:26:27.615
FROM PRISON. A HOT. THEY HAVE A
01:26:27.682 --> 01:26:30.251
DEBT. THAT THEY ARE. OFTEN NOT
01:26:30.318 --> 01:26:31.853
ABLE TO GET OUT OF I'M SORRY IN
01:26:31.920 --> 01:26:32.987
THE INTEREST OF TIME AND I
01:26:33.054 --> 01:26:33.755
APPRECIATE YOU TRYING TO
01:26:33.821 --> 01:26:37.091
EXPLAIN BUT IF YOU COULD JUST.
01:26:37.158 --> 01:26:38.660
YOU KNOW ANSWER THIS QUESTION
01:26:38.726 --> 01:26:40.728
WHICH IS WHAT IS THE- THOSE
01:26:40.795 --> 01:26:42.630
MOTHER WHO'S TAKING CARE TO
01:26:42.697 --> 01:26:44.032
CHILDREN SUPPOSED HOW WOULD HOW
01:26:44.098 --> 01:26:45.867
DOES SHE SUPPLEMENT. THAT LIKE
01:26:45.934 --> 01:26:46.801
HIM I UNDERSTAND THAT THE PRO.
01:26:46.868 --> 01:26:49.137
VISIT DOESN'T HAVE THE SAME
01:26:49.203 --> 01:26:50.838
SALARY COMING IN WELL YOU'RE
01:26:50.905 --> 01:26:53.841
ASKING A QUESTION THAT. THE
01:26:53.908 --> 01:26:54.375
ANSWER IS IN FRONT OF YOU
01:26:54.442 --> 01:26:56.511
SENATOR. A MOTHER THAT DOESN'T
01:26:56.578 --> 01:26:57.879
HAVE THE CHILD SUPPORT FROM
01:26:57.946 --> 01:26:59.647
PARENTS THAT IF INCARCERATED IS
01:26:59.714 --> 01:27:00.882
GOING TO HAVE TO LOOK FOR OTHER
01:27:00.949 --> 01:27:03.251
RESOURCES. AND LUCKILY WE LIVE
01:27:03.318 --> 01:27:04.652
IN A STATE THAT PROVIDES
01:27:04.719 --> 01:27:06.788
ADDITIONAL BENEFITS. AS LONG AS
01:27:06.854 --> 01:27:09.023
WE'RE NOT CUTTING THEM. AMID
01:27:09.090 --> 01:27:12.193
CODED AND A MAN OF VERY LITTLE.
01:27:12.260 --> 01:27:14.963
RECESSION SO WE'RE GOING TO
01:27:15.029 --> 01:27:15.697
HAVE TO BE ABLE POINT. THAT
01:27:15.763 --> 01:27:18.299
PROGRAM PROVIDE. FOOD
01:27:18.366 --> 01:27:20.268
HEALTHCARE. FOR INDIVIDUALS
01:27:20.335 --> 01:27:22.737
NEED ASSISTANCE IS AVAILABLE
01:27:22.804 --> 01:27:23.571
AND I HOPE WE CAN COUNT YOUR
01:27:23.638 --> 01:27:26.307
SUPPORT FOR THAT AND I AND IF I
01:27:26.374 --> 01:27:30.244
MAY JUST JUMP IN WE ASKED YOU
01:27:30.311 --> 01:27:32.080
YOU AGREE TO ACCEPT. IN THE
01:27:32.146 --> 01:27:38.853
PLACE THE. HI RUNNING. WORST TO
01:27:38.920 --> 01:27:40.088
PEOPLE CARS RATED YOU TO HAVE
01:27:40.154 --> 01:27:43.057
TO PAY YEARS. AND OBVIOUSLY
01:27:43.124 --> 01:27:44.158
AGENTS AN HOUR THERE GOING TO
01:27:44.225 --> 01:27:44.759
BE A TO. WELL WHAT ABOUT THE-
01:27:44.826 --> 01:27:47.462
PARENT. WHO THEN AND- EVEN RISK
01:27:47.528 --> 01:27:48.763
YOU KNOW WE HAVE TO ALSO GIVE
01:27:48.830 --> 01:27:50.965
CONSIDERATION TO THAT FACT WELL
01:27:51.032 --> 01:27:52.367
AND THAT'S WHAT THE STUDY. WILL
01:27:52.433 --> 01:27:53.868
LOOK AT WHAT SERVICES ARE
01:27:53.935 --> 01:27:56.337
AVAILABLE- BECAUSE THE CHILDREN
01:27:56.404 --> 01:27:59.774
ULTIMATELY WILL SUFFER- IF
01:27:59.841 --> 01:28:01.743
THERE IS NO SUCH. COMING IN- AT
01:28:01.809 --> 01:28:03.611
WHAT WERE YOU FREQUENTLY FIND
01:28:03.678 --> 01:28:06.080
COOLEY IS IT'S USUALLY
01:28:06.147 --> 01:28:06.781
CUSTODIAL OTHER. AND ENDS UP
01:28:06.848 --> 01:28:09.150
TAKING A SECOND JOB NO TAKING A
01:28:09.217 --> 01:28:13.021
THIRD JOB- SO THE BURDEN DAN.
01:28:13.087 --> 01:28:15.156
RETURNS TO THAT COULD STILL BE
01:28:15.223 --> 01:28:17.025
A PARENT WHICH OF COURSE WHEN
01:28:17.091 --> 01:28:18.493
PARENTS ARE NOT IN THE HOME
01:28:18.559 --> 01:28:22.096
ABLE TO DO THE NECESSARY THE
01:28:22.163 --> 01:28:22.764
DISCIPLINE AND OVERSIGHT OF
01:28:22.830 --> 01:28:24.565
CHILDREN. A CREATES A REAL
01:28:24.632 --> 01:28:25.967
PROBLEM AND THEN OF COURSE IF
01:28:26.034 --> 01:28:27.935
THERE'S NO FOOD ON THE TABLE
01:28:28.002 --> 01:28:30.905
SO. THIS BILL AT AT MY REQUEST
01:28:30.972 --> 01:28:32.774
FRANKLY. OF THE AUTHOR
01:28:32.840 --> 01:28:34.842
GRACIOUSLY AGREED TO ACCEPT.
01:28:34.909 --> 01:28:36.477
THAT AMENDMENT SO WE CAN START
01:28:36.544 --> 01:28:37.812
LOOKING AT THAT WE HAD ANOTHER
01:28:37.879 --> 01:28:40.982
BILL THAT WE PUT- A DID WAS
01:28:41.049 --> 01:28:43.551
CONSENT ITEM- BY IT ASSEMBLY
01:28:43.618 --> 01:28:48.256
MEMBER VOEPEL- THAT ALSO. LIMIT
01:28:48.322 --> 01:28:48.856
ON A SUPPORT WHEN YOU HAVE A
01:28:48.923 --> 01:28:50.391
NEW. VETERAN TO WHOSE ONLY
01:28:50.458 --> 01:28:53.828
GETTING SSI AND OBVIOUSLY
01:28:53.895 --> 01:28:54.395
DOESN'T HAVE A WHOLE LOT OF
01:28:54.462 --> 01:28:54.962
RESOURCES. THIS IS REALLY
01:28:55.029 --> 01:28:58.232
IMPORTANT WE CANNOT FORGET. THE
01:28:58.299 --> 01:28:59.901
PARENT TO INTO POTENTIALLY
01:28:59.967 --> 01:29:00.802
STUCK WITH THE BILL IF YOU
01:29:00.868 --> 01:29:03.838
WILL- BUT CLEARLY- IN THE
01:29:03.905 --> 01:29:06.941
CIRCUMSTANCES WHEN YOU HAVE
01:29:07.008 --> 01:29:07.809
PEOPLE IN PRISON I CANNOT PAY.
01:29:07.875 --> 01:29:09.777
THEY THEY JUST DON'T HAVE THE
01:29:09.844 --> 01:29:11.879
RESOURCES AN- ARM I THINK. OUT
01:29:11.946 --> 01:29:15.216
WITH THIS STUDY WILL BE ABLE
01:29:15.283 --> 01:29:16.551
TO. GET A BASS TO MAKE SURE
01:29:16.617 --> 01:29:20.822
THAT THOSE ARE. PROPERLY CARED
01:29:20.888 --> 01:29:23.558
FORCE THAT THERE NEEDS ARE NOT
01:29:23.624 --> 01:29:25.526
UNDERMINE BECAUSE THEY HAVE A
01:29:25.593 --> 01:29:31.432
PARENT TO IN MARCH. AND NOT
01:29:31.499 --> 01:29:38.840
GETTING ANY. I THINK. ANSWERED
01:29:38.906 --> 01:29:41.175
YES YEAH MA'AM IN A APPRECIATE
01:29:41.242 --> 01:29:43.845
CLARIFICATION SO I AS A PANDERS
01:29:43.911 --> 01:29:47.014
IT THEN WE BE IF THE MOTHER
01:29:47.081 --> 01:29:48.049
DOESN'T HAVE A WAY TO STOP THE
01:29:48.116 --> 01:29:49.550
IN. FOR SUPPORT SHE WOULD HAVE
01:29:49.617 --> 01:29:50.651
BEEN GETTING SHE WOULD THEN
01:29:50.718 --> 01:29:52.887
HAVE TO GO AND SOME SORT OF-
01:29:52.954 --> 01:29:54.255
GOVERNMENT ASSISTANCE WHICH I
01:29:54.322 --> 01:29:56.124
BELIEVE IS WHAT YOU WERE.
01:29:56.190 --> 01:29:58.326
RECOMMENDING OR SUGGESTING AND
01:29:58.392 --> 01:29:59.060
THE CHAIR SAID THAT YOU HAD
01:29:59.127 --> 01:30:02.730
AGREED TO PUT A STUDY IN PLACE-
01:30:02.797 --> 01:30:05.633
THOUGH THE STUDY- CERTAINLY
01:30:05.700 --> 01:30:07.435
DOESN'T HELP THE CUSTODIAL
01:30:07.502 --> 01:30:09.403
PARENT DURING THE TIME WHEN SHE
01:30:09.470 --> 01:30:10.772
STILL NEEDS TO FEED HER
01:30:10.838 --> 01:30:12.373
CHILDREN INCLUDE HER CHILDREN
01:30:12.440 --> 01:30:14.442
AND ALL THE THINGS THAT TAKE
01:30:14.509 --> 01:30:16.844
PLACE SO I DON'T KNOW I THINK
01:30:16.911 --> 01:30:18.946
THIS STUDY MIGHT COME A LITTLE.
01:30:19.013 --> 01:30:19.580
CONSOLATION TO THE ACTUAL
01:30:19.647 --> 01:30:22.784
BECAUSE OF TO BE YOU KNOW.
01:30:22.850 --> 01:30:24.218
SORRY FOR BEING A ABOUT THIS.
01:30:24.285 --> 01:30:26.154
THE I JUST HAVE ONE FINAL
01:30:26.220 --> 01:30:29.223
QUESTION- IT SAYS THIS DOES NOT
01:30:29.290 --> 01:30:30.725
APPLY WERE THE INCARCERATED
01:30:30.792 --> 01:30:32.827
INDIVIDUAL HAS THE ABILITY. TO
01:30:32.894 --> 01:30:34.829
CONTINUE MAKING CHILD SUPPORT
01:30:34.896 --> 01:30:37.732
PAYMENTS AND THAT- DOES THAT
01:30:37.799 --> 01:30:40.434
MIRROR FEDERAL LAW. OKAY AND
01:30:40.501 --> 01:30:42.203
THEN IT ALSO SAYS- IT DOES NOT
01:30:42.270 --> 01:30:45.940
APPLY. WHERE INCARCERATION IS
01:30:46.007 --> 01:30:47.909
THE RESULT OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
01:30:47.975 --> 01:30:49.443
AGAINST THEIR SUPPORTED PARTY
01:30:49.510 --> 01:30:52.046
OR CHILD IS DOES THAT ALSO MERE
01:30:52.113 --> 01:30:52.914
FEDERAL LAW OR IS THAT
01:30:52.980 --> 01:30:57.218
SOMETHING. THAT'S JUST STATE
01:30:57.285 --> 01:30:57.852
LAW. I'LL HAVE TO THE BY TO YOU
01:30:57.919 --> 01:30:58.486
ON ONE I BELIEVE IN THEIR STATE
01:30:58.553 --> 01:30:59.987
LAW BUT LET ME DOUBLE CHECK ON
01:31:00.054 --> 01:31:01.856
A STEER YOU IN THE WRONG OKAY
01:31:01.923 --> 01:31:03.357
AND IT'S JUST A MISTAKE
01:31:03.424 --> 01:31:05.226
VIOLENCE SO NO WEATHER SO IN
01:31:05.293 --> 01:31:05.960
OTHER WORDS IF THERE WERE ANY
01:31:06.027 --> 01:31:08.196
SORT OF SEXUAL ABUSE. THAT'S
01:31:08.262 --> 01:31:10.731
NOT FACTORED INTO THIS LIVE
01:31:10.798 --> 01:31:12.767
USES FACTORED INTO IT. OKAY IT
01:31:12.834 --> 01:31:13.935
IS FACTORS OR ANYTHING ELSE
01:31:14.001 --> 01:31:15.236
FACTORED IN THAT. I DON'T HAVE
01:31:15.303 --> 01:31:18.472
IN FRONT I DON'T I JUST HAVE A
01:31:18.539 --> 01:31:19.073
DOMESTIC ABUSE IN FRONT OF ME
01:31:19.140 --> 01:31:19.941
IS THERE I'M HAPPY TO GET YOUR
01:31:20.007 --> 01:31:23.477
INFORMATION ON THE BILL. OKAY
01:31:23.544 --> 01:31:27.148
SIR TO A CASKET FUND. CLEAR
01:31:27.215 --> 01:31:29.050
THAT THIS DOESN'T APPLY TO
01:31:29.116 --> 01:31:30.885
DOMESTIC PEOPLE SERVING PRISON
01:31:30.952 --> 01:31:32.587
TIME FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
01:31:32.653 --> 01:31:35.289
ALTHOUGH SOME OF THE ARGUMENTS
01:31:35.356 --> 01:31:36.591
FOR AUTOMATICALLY SUSPENDED
01:31:36.657 --> 01:31:37.992
BECAUSE OF THE ECONOMIC
01:31:38.059 --> 01:31:39.760
SITUATION WOULD APPLY TO THEM
01:31:39.827 --> 01:31:41.629
DO YOU ENVISION THE STUDY THAT
01:31:41.696 --> 01:31:44.098
YOU AGREE TO WITH THAT GIVE US
01:31:44.165 --> 01:31:48.703
REPORT ON THE IMPACT THAT.
01:31:48.769 --> 01:31:50.705
ALLOWING THE DEBT BURDEN TO
01:31:50.771 --> 01:31:52.006
CONTINUE ON THE PEOPLE WHO HAVE
01:31:52.073 --> 01:31:52.874
BEEN CONVICTED OF DOMESTIC
01:31:52.940 --> 01:31:54.909
VIOLENCE AND MONTHS SAID AND
01:31:54.976 --> 01:31:56.844
THE NONCUSTODIAL PARENTS WHAT
01:31:56.911 --> 01:31:58.913
THAT IMPACT MAY HAVE WANTS TO
01:31:58.980 --> 01:32:01.849
RELEASE FOR PAYING CHILD
01:32:01.916 --> 01:32:04.352
SUPPORT. FINDING A JOB DOING
01:32:04.418 --> 01:32:05.419
ALL THOSE OTHER THINGS I DON'T
01:32:05.486 --> 01:32:06.954
KNOW ITS ACT READ THE AMENDMENT
01:32:07.021 --> 01:32:08.856
BUT IT DOESN'T SPECIFICALLY SAY
01:32:08.923 --> 01:32:10.892
THAT IT'S ASKING FOR THOSE
01:32:10.958 --> 01:32:11.926
IMPACTS BUT I DON'T KNOW IF
01:32:11.993 --> 01:32:13.861
THAT WAS. DISCUSSED WITH YOU IN
01:32:13.928 --> 01:32:16.264
THE CHAIR WELL THEY'RE ACTUALLY
01:32:16.330 --> 01:32:16.998
HAS ALREADY BEEN RESEARCH ON
01:32:17.064 --> 01:32:19.567
THAT. AND THE RICHARD RESEARCH
01:32:19.634 --> 01:32:22.303
DOES SHOW- THAT MOST OF THE
01:32:22.370 --> 01:32:24.405
CHILD SUPPORT THAT COMES FROM
01:32:24.472 --> 01:32:26.140
PARENTS MAKING LESS THAN TEN
01:32:26.207 --> 01:32:27.875
THOUSAND DOLLARS A YEAR. AND
01:32:27.942 --> 01:32:31.078
THAT- WHAT WE'VE DONE NOW IS
01:32:31.145 --> 01:32:33.147
THERE ON TOP OF THE REAR RIDGE
01:32:33.214 --> 01:32:38.886
IS A 10% INTEREST PENALTY. SO
01:32:38.953 --> 01:32:40.187
OF THE RESEARCH HAS SHOWN THAT
01:32:40.254 --> 01:32:41.322
WHEN A PERSON COMES OUT OF
01:32:41.389 --> 01:32:43.658
PRISON. GET BACK ON THEIR FEET
01:32:43.724 --> 01:32:45.993
THEY ARE THEY PERCEIVE THAT
01:32:46.060 --> 01:32:47.895
THEY ARE IN SUCH ENORMOUS DEBT.
01:32:47.962 --> 01:32:50.031
THAT FREQUENTLY THEY WON'T THAT
01:32:50.097 --> 01:32:53.134
DAY. DISASSOCIATE FROM ANY KIND
01:32:53.200 --> 01:32:54.101
OF RELATIONSHIP WITH THEIR
01:32:54.168 --> 01:32:56.003
CHILDREN THAT'S FINANCIALLY
01:32:56.070 --> 01:32:57.905
BASED THE ROOM BARROW STORE
01:32:57.972 --> 01:32:59.073
THERE ARE DATE THEY FEEL
01:32:59.140 --> 01:33:00.741
INADEQUATE BECAUSE THEY CAN'T
01:33:00.808 --> 01:33:03.244
PROVIDE THOSE RESOURCES AND
01:33:03.311 --> 01:33:05.613
THAT- THEY DON'T REUNITE WITH
01:33:05.680 --> 01:33:07.415
THEIR FAMILY SO WOULD IT
01:33:07.481 --> 01:33:08.149
APPARENTLY INCREASES
01:33:08.215 --> 01:33:10.651
RECIDIVISM. ME TO IT'S A LOSE
01:33:10.718 --> 01:33:13.854
LOSE SITUATION I MEAN I SEE
01:33:13.921 --> 01:33:14.355
THAT WERE YOU KNOW WE'RE
01:33:14.422 --> 01:33:15.456
EXCLUDING THE ROBBERS MORE
01:33:15.523 --> 01:33:18.426
EXCLUDING THE TRUCK DRIVERS AT
01:33:18.492 --> 01:33:20.561
TO TIME BUT WE'RE NOT EXCLUDING
01:33:20.628 --> 01:33:23.164
THE PEOPLE OVER. SAID THERE CAN
01:33:23.230 --> 01:33:25.566
BEEN CONVICTED OF A DOMESTIC
01:33:25.633 --> 01:33:26.934
VIOLENCE AND I'M JUST THINKING
01:33:27.001 --> 01:33:30.204
THAT. DAY THE POLICY GOALS FOR
01:33:30.271 --> 01:33:32.106
THE GOALS WE STAYED OF FREE
01:33:32.173 --> 01:33:34.709
REUNIFICATION AND MAKING SURE
01:33:34.775 --> 01:33:35.810
THAT ONCE THEY'RE OUT. THEIR
01:33:35.876 --> 01:33:38.179
BEHAVIORS IMPROVE THAT THEY PAY
01:33:38.245 --> 01:33:40.348
WHATEVER THE AMOUNT WAS JUST
01:33:40.414 --> 01:33:41.949
WONDERFUL SHOULD BE STARTING
01:33:42.016 --> 01:33:44.518
THAT ALSO. OKAY THEIR DATE THE
01:33:44.585 --> 01:33:46.187
BE CONVICTED OF DOMESTIC
01:33:46.253 --> 01:33:49.457
VIOLENCE AND BE IN POVERTY BE
01:33:49.523 --> 01:33:50.091
POOR UPPER PER PERSON AND FALL
01:33:50.157 --> 01:33:51.692
INTO ALL THE OTHER CATEGORIES
01:33:51.759 --> 01:33:53.160
EXCEPT FOR THE CRIME THAT THEY
01:33:53.227 --> 01:33:56.263
WERE. INCARCERATED FOR AND JUST
01:33:56.330 --> 01:33:59.100
SEEMS. I DON'T KNOW. SEEMS LIKE
01:33:59.166 --> 01:33:59.700
SOMETHING YOU'D LIKE TO STUDY
01:33:59.767 --> 01:34:02.536
TO SEE. MAYBE IS THAT IS THAT
01:34:02.603 --> 01:34:04.605
HELPFUL OR HARMFUL. MAY I
01:34:04.672 --> 01:34:05.973
RESPOND IF YOU'D LIKE TO
01:34:06.040 --> 01:34:07.742
PROCEED THE RESPONSE CERTAINLY
01:34:07.808 --> 01:34:10.211
SO LET'S LET'S BE CLEAR ON THE
01:34:10.277 --> 01:34:12.246
INTENT OF THE BILL THE INTENT
01:34:12.313 --> 01:34:13.547
OF THE BILL IS TO BRING
01:34:13.614 --> 01:34:15.583
CALIFORNIA UP TO A FEDERAL
01:34:15.649 --> 01:34:19.687
STANDARD IT IS TO ENSURE THAT
01:34:19.754 --> 01:34:21.389
PEOPLE THAT ARE IN CARS. AND
01:34:21.455 --> 01:34:24.425
ADDITIONALLY. SUPPORT PAYMENTS
01:34:24.492 --> 01:34:25.359
THE DAY CURRENTLY CA MEET
01:34:25.426 --> 01:34:26.794
BECAUSE THEY ARE IN CARS AND
01:34:26.861 --> 01:34:29.363
MAKING EIGHT CENTS AN HOUR I AM
01:34:29.430 --> 01:34:30.264
MORE THAN HAPPY TO WORK WITH
01:34:30.331 --> 01:34:31.866
ALL OF YOU ON YOUR CELL SENATOR
01:34:31.932 --> 01:34:34.201
AND ANYONE IN THIS ROOM TO TRY
01:34:34.268 --> 01:34:37.304
TO DO ADDITIONAL STUDIES ON HOW
01:34:37.371 --> 01:34:37.872
TO HELP PEOPLE. GET BACK ON
01:34:37.938 --> 01:34:40.975
THEIR FEET DECREASE RECIDIVISM
01:34:41.042 --> 01:34:43.444
RATES. AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY
01:34:43.511 --> 01:34:44.945
GO BACK TO THEIR FAMILIES. PART
01:34:45.012 --> 01:34:46.414
OF THE CONVERSATION AND IF
01:34:46.480 --> 01:34:47.281
WE'RE GOING TO DO THIS I WANT
01:34:47.348 --> 01:34:49.316
TO. BUY YOUR REQUEST MADAM
01:34:49.383 --> 01:34:50.551
CHAIR KEEP THE SHORT BUT WE
01:34:50.618 --> 01:34:52.820
COULD GET INTO IT. WHAT I HAVE
01:34:52.887 --> 01:34:55.322
HEARD IN BOTH HOUSES FROM BOTH
01:34:55.389 --> 01:34:58.959
PARTIES. IS AN AGREED IS
01:34:59.026 --> 01:35:00.461
IMPLICIT BIAS. PARENTS ARE
01:35:00.528 --> 01:35:03.731
INCARCERATED THE REALITY IS THE
01:35:03.798 --> 01:35:05.633
MAJORITY OF PARENTS WANT TO
01:35:05.699 --> 01:35:07.568
REUNITE WITH THEIR FAMILIES
01:35:07.635 --> 01:35:09.503
THEY WANT TO BE A PART OF THEIR
01:35:09.570 --> 01:35:12.440
CHILD'S LIFE. BUT THE BURDENS
01:35:12.506 --> 01:35:13.674
THAT THEY ENCOUNTER ALONG THE
01:35:13.741 --> 01:35:17.678
WAY ARE SO HIGH. THEY'RE COMING
01:35:17.745 --> 01:35:19.747
OUT OF PRISON DURING PULLED IT.
01:35:19.814 --> 01:35:23.851
NO JOBS LACK OF HOUSING AN
01:35:23.918 --> 01:35:24.418
INCREDIBLY REDUCED
01:35:24.485 --> 01:35:26.487
OPPORTUNITIES IT IS OUR
01:35:26.554 --> 01:35:29.690
RESPONSIBILITY TO ENSURE THAT
01:35:29.757 --> 01:35:31.692
EVERY MEMBER OF SOCIETY. WHO
01:35:31.759 --> 01:35:33.961
HAVE CLEARLY PAID THEIR DEBT TO
01:35:34.028 --> 01:35:36.664
SOCIETY AND WANTS TO RENO TO
01:35:36.730 --> 01:35:38.699
REUNIFY WITH THEIR FAMILIES AND
01:35:38.766 --> 01:35:41.135
WHAT THEIR KIDS CAN DO SO FOR
01:35:41.202 --> 01:35:43.170
LET'S TAKE CARE OF THAT RIGHT
01:35:43.237 --> 01:35:46.073
NOW IN ITS URGENCY. AND NEXT
01:35:46.140 --> 01:35:48.109
YEAR I AM MORE THAN HAPPY TO DO
01:35:48.175 --> 01:35:49.877
ANY STUDY THAT YOU WISH TO
01:35:49.944 --> 01:35:51.912
ENSURE THAT WE ARE MOVING AN
01:35:51.979 --> 01:35:54.215
AGENDA THAT HELPS FAMILIES AT
01:35:54.281 --> 01:35:55.783
THE END OF THE DAY MADAM CHAIR
01:35:55.850 --> 01:35:57.184
I JUST WANT TO BE SURE THAT WE
01:35:57.251 --> 01:35:59.186
WERE SAYING EXACT THAT'S TRUE
01:35:59.253 --> 01:36:00.654
FOR EVERY THING EXCEPT FOR THE
01:36:00.721 --> 01:36:02.490
PERSON WHO SERVING TIME FOR
01:36:02.556 --> 01:36:04.358
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND ABUSE AS
01:36:04.425 --> 01:36:06.127
I UNDERSTAND THE BILL. I THINK
01:36:06.193 --> 01:36:07.194
THE PROBLEM IS WE DON'T WANT TO
01:36:07.261 --> 01:36:10.498
CREATE ANY POTENTIAL IN SAN.
01:36:10.564 --> 01:36:12.533
SOMEONE COMMITTED A STICK FILA
01:36:12.600 --> 01:36:14.802
AND GETS THE OPPORTUNITY IS A
01:36:14.869 --> 01:36:16.270
RESULT OF THAT TO AVOID THE
01:36:16.337 --> 01:36:17.938
RESPONSIBILITY FOR PAYING CHILD
01:36:18.005 --> 01:36:20.207
SUPPORT. THAT THAT'S A PROBLEM
01:36:20.274 --> 01:36:21.976
RIGHT RIGHT AND THAT'S WHY I'M
01:36:22.042 --> 01:36:24.044
I'M NOT. I'M JUST RAISING THE
01:36:24.111 --> 01:36:25.513
ISSUE BECAUSE I THINK THAT THIS
01:36:25.579 --> 01:36:28.015
IS. THIS IS A- AND JERRY THE
01:36:28.082 --> 01:36:30.684
LAW THAT WE TEND TO WE DON'T.
01:36:30.751 --> 01:36:32.686
ISN'T PICKY. A SITUATION WHERE
01:36:32.753 --> 01:36:34.788
PEOPLE ARE ABUSING THEIR LOVED
01:36:34.855 --> 01:36:37.525
ONES AND WE THINK YOU GET
01:36:37.591 --> 01:36:38.459
THROWN IN JAIL AND- PART OF THE
01:36:38.526 --> 01:36:40.828
GOAL HERE IS THAT REUNIFICATION
01:36:40.895 --> 01:36:42.897
AND BRINGING PEOPLE BACK IN.
01:36:42.963 --> 01:36:45.199
AND I'M JUST SAYING THERE'S- I
01:36:45.266 --> 01:36:46.233
WOULD SAY TO CARPOOL BUT THIS
01:36:46.300 --> 01:36:48.869
IS FROM A GROUP OF PEOPLE A LOT
01:36:48.936 --> 01:36:51.539
OF PEOPLE IN JAIL THAT ARE POOR
01:36:51.605 --> 01:36:52.940
THAT GOT ALL THE OTHER. ALL THE
01:36:53.007 --> 01:36:53.407
SIGNALS HERE THAT ARE
01:36:53.474 --> 01:36:55.042
PRODIGIOUS RAISING. HIS INITIAL
01:36:55.109 --> 01:36:56.310
MEAN I'LL BE SUPPORTING THE
01:36:56.377 --> 01:37:00.814
BILL TODAY BUT IT'S NOT ALL THE
01:37:00.881 --> 01:37:04.218
BOAT TO FLOAT. AT IS I IS I SEE
01:37:04.285 --> 01:37:04.785
BECAUSE THESE PEOPLE IT'S A
01:37:04.852 --> 01:37:07.888
COMPLICATED THERE'S A THOUSAND
01:37:07.955 --> 01:37:08.422
DIFFERENT. SCENARIOS WHERE
01:37:08.489 --> 01:37:12.793
PEOPLE GET CONVICTED AND- THE-
01:37:12.860 --> 01:37:14.495
WELL I'M GLAD TO RAISE THE
01:37:14.562 --> 01:37:17.164
ISSUE MORE. I THINK A THIS IS
01:37:17.231 --> 01:37:20.201
AN AREA WHERE I HAPPEN TO HAVE
01:37:20.267 --> 01:37:21.969
SOME EXPERIENCE PRESS WHEN I
01:37:22.036 --> 01:37:23.604
WAS A PRACTITIONER. AND NO ONE
01:37:23.671 --> 01:37:25.673
EVER ASKED WHAT ABOUT THE
01:37:25.739 --> 01:37:27.274
CUSTODIAL PARENT WHO'S LEFT
01:37:27.341 --> 01:37:29.677
HAVING TO GET TWO AND THREE
01:37:29.743 --> 01:37:31.879
JOBS TO MAKE ENDS MEET. I WAS
01:37:31.946 --> 01:37:33.314
JUST EXPECTED AND MOST OF THEM
01:37:33.380 --> 01:37:35.950
ARE WOMEN AND- YOU KNOW BEING
01:37:36.016 --> 01:37:37.518
IN THE LOWER PAID JOB
01:37:37.585 --> 01:37:38.953
CATEGORIES ANYWAY JUST ANOTHER
01:37:39.019 --> 01:37:41.388
ELEMENT OF THAT SUM COMING DOWN
01:37:41.455 --> 01:37:44.225
ON THE SCALE OF FAIRNESS AND
01:37:44.291 --> 01:37:47.027
JUSTICE SO. HAVING THIS I THINK
01:37:47.094 --> 01:37:48.462
IS THE FIRST TIME ACTUALLY WE
01:37:48.529 --> 01:37:49.763
WILL OF DONE THAT STUDY FROM
01:37:49.830 --> 01:37:52.299
THIS SIDE OF THE AVENUE AVENUE
01:37:52.366 --> 01:37:53.334
AND I HAVE EVERY CONFIDENCE
01:37:53.400 --> 01:37:55.469
THAT. ASSEMBLY MEMBER CARILLO
01:37:55.536 --> 01:37:58.172
BEING. VERY STRONG ADVOCATE ON
01:37:58.239 --> 01:37:59.573
BEHALF OF THE QUALITY IN
01:37:59.640 --> 01:38:00.975
PARTICULAR GENDER EQUALITY AS
01:38:01.041 --> 01:38:04.311
WELL WILK- IF NECESSARY FOLLOW
01:38:04.378 --> 01:38:07.181
UP AFTER THE INFORMATION IS.
01:38:07.248 --> 01:38:10.818
RECEIVED AND- TRY TO MAKE
01:38:10.884 --> 01:38:12.086
WHATEVER ADJUSTMENTS ARE
01:38:12.152 --> 01:38:14.755
NECESSARY UNDER AN ABSOLUTELY
01:38:14.822 --> 01:38:16.490
IT IS A TOTAL LOSE LOSE
01:38:16.557 --> 01:38:20.594
SITUATION. NO MENTION THIS SHOW.
01:38:20.661 --> 01:38:22.563
WITH THAT WE HAVE I BELIEVE A
01:38:22.630 --> 01:38:25.099
MOTION BY SENATOR MONNING THE
01:38:25.165 --> 01:38:28.035
MOTION IS. ADD TO PASS AS
01:38:28.102 --> 01:38:29.703
AMENDED TO THE SENATE
01:38:29.770 --> 01:38:31.739
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE WITH
01:38:31.805 --> 01:38:33.741
THAT MADAM CONSULTANT WOULD YOU
01:38:33.807 --> 01:38:35.175
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL AND
01:38:35.242 --> 01:38:36.110
THERE'S PLEASE TURN OUR
01:38:36.176 --> 01:38:37.911
MICROPHONE'S ON THIS IS FILE
01:38:37.978 --> 01:38:42.449
ITEM EIGHT AB TWENTY THREE
01:38:42.516 --> 01:38:42.983
TWENTY FIVE BERRYHILL THE
01:38:43.050 --> 01:38:44.952
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
01:38:45.019 --> 01:38:46.520
THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS CAN
01:38:46.587 --> 01:38:48.188
AND PERHAPS MY APOLOGIES I
01:38:48.255 --> 01:38:49.823
SHOULD LET THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:38:49.890 --> 01:38:51.659
CLOSE WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
01:38:51.725 --> 01:38:54.228
WOULD THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR- I
01:38:54.295 --> 01:38:55.229
REALLY APPRECIATE THE- VAST.
01:38:55.296 --> 01:38:59.733
JUST GOT. AND PART OF A LOT OF
01:38:59.800 --> 01:39:00.968
WHAT I HAVE HEARD I WILL REPEAT
01:39:01.035 --> 01:39:03.237
AGAIN IS JUST IMPLICIT BIAS
01:39:03.304 --> 01:39:04.705
THAT THERE ARE MEMBERS OF OUR
01:39:04.772 --> 01:39:07.408
SOCIETY THAT. ARE USING OUR
01:39:07.474 --> 01:39:09.743
PRISON SYSTEM TO AVOID. PAYING
01:39:09.810 --> 01:39:11.145
THEIR CHILD SUPPORT WHICH TO ME
01:39:11.211 --> 01:39:15.149
IS LUDICROUS. YOU CAN HAVE A
01:39:15.215 --> 01:39:18.686
SITUATION IN WHICH- PARENTS ARE
01:39:18.752 --> 01:39:22.423
HOPING TO FEED THEIR KIDS. ARE
01:39:22.489 --> 01:39:24.658
COMMIT A CRIME OF ROBBING FOOD
01:39:24.725 --> 01:39:29.029
AND THEN GOES TO PRISON. YOU
01:39:29.096 --> 01:39:31.598
CAN LOOK AT THAT AND SAY. WAS
01:39:31.665 --> 01:39:33.434
THAT INDIVIDUAL TRYING TO HELP
01:39:33.500 --> 01:39:34.968
THEIR CHILD WHILE THEY'RE
01:39:35.035 --> 01:39:37.004
PAYING CHILD SUPPORT WHAT KIND
01:39:37.071 --> 01:39:39.139
OF SYSTEM DO WE HAVE WHICH
01:39:39.206 --> 01:39:40.441
ALLOWS AN INDIVIDUAL TO
01:39:40.507 --> 01:39:42.509
CONTINUE TO WOULD GET PENALTIES
01:39:42.576 --> 01:39:44.878
AND FEES WHILE MAKING EIGHT
01:39:44.945 --> 01:39:47.147
CENTS AN HOUR. AND THEN GETS UP
01:39:47.214 --> 01:39:49.450
ON AND THEN GET THEIR LICENSE
01:39:49.516 --> 01:39:51.318
REVOKED BECAUSE THEY HAVE
01:39:51.385 --> 01:39:52.720
OUTSTANDING CHILD SUPPORT DEBT.
01:39:52.786 --> 01:39:55.756
CAN'T GET TO A JOB. DOESN'T
01:39:55.823 --> 01:39:59.393
HAVE TRANSPORTATION. CAN BARELY
01:39:59.460 --> 01:40:02.696
AFFORD TO MAKE ENDS MEET AND
01:40:02.763 --> 01:40:03.230
THEN THEY CONTINUE TO HOW
01:40:03.297 --> 01:40:04.365
ISSUES WITH THEIR CHILD SUPPORT
01:40:04.431 --> 01:40:06.200
AND THEN GO BACK INTO PRISON WE
01:40:06.266 --> 01:40:08.669
HAVE HAD A LOT OF CONVERSATIONS
01:40:08.736 --> 01:40:10.371
IN BOTH HOUSES- ON BREAK DOWN
01:40:10.437 --> 01:40:12.406
THE TUITION ALLIES RATE THEM
01:40:12.473 --> 01:40:15.209
FOR PEOPLE OF COLOR THIS. IF
01:40:15.275 --> 01:40:17.344
IDEA THAT YOU CAN PAY CHILD
01:40:17.411 --> 01:40:18.512
SUPPORT WILL MAKING EIGHT CENTS
01:40:18.579 --> 01:40:21.682
AN HOUR IS RIDICULOUS. AND
01:40:21.749 --> 01:40:23.083
THERE ARE A LOT OF THINGS THAT
01:40:23.150 --> 01:40:26.387
WE NEED TO ADDRESS BUT I JUST
01:40:26.453 --> 01:40:27.221
HOPE THAT WE ARE ACTUALLY TRUE
01:40:27.287 --> 01:40:29.123
TO OUR WORD AND IF WE ARE TO
01:40:29.189 --> 01:40:31.158
SAY THAT WE ARE ABOUT HELPING
01:40:31.225 --> 01:40:34.428
PEOPLE IN OURS. THAT WE BEGIN
01:40:34.495 --> 01:40:35.829
TO LOOK AT LAWS SECOND
01:40:35.896 --> 01:40:38.432
TENUOUSLY HARM PEOPLE OF COLOR
01:40:38.499 --> 01:40:39.933
AND IF WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT
01:40:40.000 --> 01:40:45.339
MEN. ACTUALLY HAVE A HARM. MEN
01:40:45.406 --> 01:40:45.973
OF COLOR MOSTLY FULL ARE LET ME
01:40:46.039 --> 01:40:48.909
IN BLACK. IN OUR STATE. I HOPE
01:40:48.976 --> 01:40:52.179
THAT WHILE WE DELIBERATE ON
01:40:52.246 --> 01:40:53.914
WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE THERE ARE
01:40:53.981 --> 01:40:56.116
ACTUAL PEOPLE WHO ARE HURTING.
01:40:56.183 --> 01:40:57.818
AND WHO NEED THIS LEGISLATURE
01:40:57.885 --> 01:40:59.820
TO ACT AND TO ACT NOW I
01:40:59.887 --> 01:41:01.955
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST ZERO.
01:41:02.022 --> 01:41:04.191
THANK YOU MADAM CONSULTANT IF
01:41:04.258 --> 01:41:05.559
YOU WOULD PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
01:41:05.626 --> 01:41:07.594
FROM THE MOTION THAT WAS MADE
01:41:07.661 --> 01:41:10.831
BY A I BELIEVE SENATOR MONNING.
01:41:10.898 --> 01:41:12.466
AGAIN PLEASE TURN TO MIKE FUNDS
01:41:12.533 --> 01:41:15.202
ON THIS IS FILE ITEM EIGHTY AB
01:41:15.269 --> 01:41:15.702
TWENTY THREE TWENTY FIVE
01:41:15.769 --> 01:41:17.171
CARILLO THE MOTION IS TO PASS
01:41:17.237 --> 01:41:18.739
AS AMENDED TO THE SENATE
01:41:18.806 --> 01:41:21.008
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
01:41:21.074 --> 01:41:23.143
JACKSON BY. TEXAN NINE BARGES
01:41:23.210 --> 01:41:27.414
FIVE. BRIDGES I DID A SO I DID
01:41:27.481 --> 01:41:31.785
A SO HI GOOD SERVICE I. SERVICE
01:41:31.852 --> 01:41:35.222
I MELENDEZ. MONNING THANK
01:41:35.289 --> 01:41:40.828
MONNING I STE TURNED BUT I.
01:41:40.894 --> 01:41:45.933
STERN I I'M BURKE HI AMBERG I
01:41:45.999 --> 01:41:51.972
Y. CALLES KEY HI BY CASKEY I.
01:41:52.039 --> 01:41:54.241
HE HAVE EIGHT ZERO ONE MEMBER
01:41:54.308 --> 01:41:56.543
MISSING RIGHT WE WILL- THE BILL
01:41:56.610 --> 01:41:58.745
COUNT AS A TWO ZERO WILL PUT
01:41:58.812 --> 01:42:01.014
THAT BILL ON CALL. FOR THE
01:42:01.081 --> 01:42:03.383
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU
01:42:03.450 --> 01:42:03.984
ASSEMBLYMEMBER APPRECIATE YOUR
01:42:04.051 --> 01:42:07.621
TIME. AND NEXT UP IS FILE ITEM
01:42:07.688 --> 01:42:12.259
NINE BY- IT'S AB TWENTY FOUR
01:42:12.326 --> 01:42:12.860
FORTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
01:42:12.926 --> 01:42:15.662
RADIUS AND THIS IS ON ACTION
01:42:15.729 --> 01:42:17.297
DEALING WITH CIVIL ACTIONS AND
01:42:17.364 --> 01:42:19.900
WRONGFUL DEATH AND IT HAS AN
01:42:19.967 --> 01:42:23.370
EMERGENCY PROVISIONS SO. OF
01:42:23.437 --> 01:42:27.241
MADAM REYES THE FLOOR IS YOURS
01:42:27.307 --> 01:42:28.509
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
01:42:28.575 --> 01:42:32.112
MEMBERS TO THEIR PRESENT AB
01:42:32.179 --> 01:42:32.679
TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE WHICH
01:42:32.746 --> 01:42:33.847
WILL EXTEND TO LEGAL GUARDIANS
01:42:33.914 --> 01:42:35.549
THE RIGHT TO BRING A CLAIM ON
01:42:35.616 --> 01:42:37.351
BEHALF OF THEIR CHILD IF THE
01:42:37.417 --> 01:42:41.221
CHILD PASSES AWAY DUE TO THE
01:42:41.288 --> 01:42:41.889
WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF OTHERS.
01:42:41.955 --> 01:42:43.590
CURRENT LAW SPECIFIES THE
01:42:43.657 --> 01:42:44.758
INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY BRING A
01:42:44.825 --> 01:42:46.593
CAUSE OF ACTION FOR THE DEATH
01:42:46.660 --> 01:42:47.661
OF A PERSON BECAUSE FOR THE
01:42:47.728 --> 01:42:49.129
WRONGFUL ACT OR NEGLECT. OF
01:42:49.196 --> 01:42:51.198
ANOTHER. THESE INDIVIDUALS ARE
01:42:51.265 --> 01:42:52.165
LIMITED TO THE DECEDENT'S
01:42:52.232 --> 01:42:54.601
SPOUSECHILD AND IN SOME CASES
01:42:54.668 --> 01:42:56.904
THE PARENTS. SPECIFICALLY FOR
01:42:56.970 --> 01:42:58.272
MINOR PASSES AWAY DUE TO THE
01:42:58.338 --> 01:42:59.940
WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF OTHERS AND
01:43:00.007 --> 01:43:02.209
THE MINOR IS ON MARRIED AND
01:43:02.276 --> 01:43:07.881
DOES NOT HAVE CHILDREN. THAN
01:43:07.948 --> 01:43:11.151
THOSE WHO CAN BRING FORTH A- BY.
01:43:11.218 --> 01:43:13.554
THE MY LEGAL GUARDIANS HAVE NOT
01:43:13.620 --> 01:43:15.656
OFFICIALLY ADOPTED THE MINOR
01:43:15.722 --> 01:43:17.190
THESE LEGAL GUARDIANS DO NOT
01:43:17.257 --> 01:43:19.059
HAVE LEGAL STANDING TO BRING A
01:43:19.126 --> 01:43:20.294
CLAIM IN THE EVENT OF A
01:43:20.360 --> 01:43:22.996
WRONGFUL DEATH EVEN THOUGH BOTH
01:43:23.063 --> 01:43:26.567
OF THE CHILD'S PARENTS DECEASED.
01:43:26.633 --> 01:43:28.168
AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE
01:43:28.235 --> 01:43:29.403
CORRECT THIS OVERSIGHT LAW BY
01:43:29.469 --> 01:43:31.672
ALLOWING LEGAL GUARDIANS TO
01:43:31.738 --> 01:43:33.106
BRING FORTH A WRONGFUL DEATH
01:43:33.173 --> 01:43:36.910
CASE BUT ONLY WHEN THE DECEASED
01:43:36.977 --> 01:43:38.645
CHILD'S PARENTS. HAVE ALSO
01:43:38.712 --> 01:43:41.148
PASSED AWAY. AB TWENTY FOUR
01:43:41.214 --> 01:43:41.782
FORTY FIVE ALLOWS A LEGAL
01:43:41.848 --> 01:43:43.617
GUARDIAN TO SEEK JUSTICE FOR
01:43:43.684 --> 01:43:45.519
CHILD WAS PASSED AWAY DUE TO
01:43:45.586 --> 01:43:47.187
THE WRONGFUL CONDUCT OF OTHERS
01:43:47.254 --> 01:43:48.755
WHEN THE CHILD'S PARENT CANNOT
01:43:48.822 --> 01:43:50.324
DO SO. BECAUSE THEY ARE
01:43:50.390 --> 01:43:53.060
DECEASED THIS BILL IS AN IS AN
01:43:53.126 --> 01:43:54.761
URGENCY MEASURE IN ORDER TO
01:43:54.828 --> 01:43:56.430
PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF DESERVING
01:43:56.496 --> 01:43:58.332
LEGAL GUARDIANS TO PROSECUTE
01:43:58.398 --> 01:44:01.101
WRONGFUL. ACTIONS ON BEHALF OF
01:44:01.168 --> 01:44:02.903
THEIR MINOR CHILDREN. TIME IS
01:44:02.970 --> 01:44:04.404
OF THE ESSENCE TO ENSURE THAT
01:44:04.471 --> 01:44:05.706
WRITERS CLAIMS ARE NOT TURNED
01:44:05.772 --> 01:44:08.742
AWAY DUE TO ANTIQUATED LEGAL
01:44:08.809 --> 01:44:10.444
BARRIERS. HERE TO TESTIFY VIA
01:44:10.510 --> 01:44:12.479
TELEPHONE TODAY I HAVE BILL.
01:44:12.546 --> 01:44:15.916
GALLO WANTED WAS AN ATTORNEY
01:44:15.983 --> 01:44:16.550
WITH THE LAW FIRM OF TAYLOR AND
01:44:16.617 --> 01:44:20.454
RING. THANK YOU ASSEMBLY. THE
01:44:20.520 --> 01:44:23.223
LET US SOME HERE FROM MR GILL
01:44:23.290 --> 01:44:27.561
WHAT I BELIEVE HE IS ON THE
01:44:27.628 --> 01:44:29.262
PHONE AND READY TO SPEAK IS
01:44:29.329 --> 01:44:31.732
THAT CORRECT. A THANK YOU
01:44:31.798 --> 01:44:33.400
MISTER GILL WHAT THE FLOOR IS
01:44:33.467 --> 01:44:35.569
YOURS IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING
01:44:35.636 --> 01:44:38.271
THAT HE IS THE ONLY WITNESS AND
01:44:38.338 --> 01:44:39.673
IF THAT'S THE CASE HE DOES HAVE
01:44:39.740 --> 01:44:41.541
UP TO THREE MINUTES IF HE
01:44:41.608 --> 01:44:43.210
WISHES TO TAKE IT THANK YOU.
01:44:43.276 --> 01:44:47.280
MISTER GILL WHAT THE FLOORS YOU.
01:44:47.347 --> 01:44:47.881
THANK YOU CAN EVERYONE HEAR ME
01:44:47.948 --> 01:44:54.221
OKAY. YES. OKAY MEMBERS OF THE
01:44:54.287 --> 01:44:55.722
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
01:44:55.789 --> 01:44:57.157
THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME THE
01:44:57.224 --> 01:44:58.659
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO ALL OF
01:44:58.725 --> 01:45:00.927
YOU ABOUT THIS BILL BY WAY OF
01:45:00.994 --> 01:45:03.263
INTRODUCTION MY NAME IS NEIL
01:45:03.330 --> 01:45:04.765
KELLER WHY I AM A MEMBER OF THE
01:45:04.831 --> 01:45:08.001
CONSUMER ATTORNEYS FOR IN
01:45:08.068 --> 01:45:12.939
SUPPORT OF AB. TWO FOUR FOUR
01:45:13.006 --> 01:45:14.541
FIVE. BEACH WILL. I PRACTICE IN
01:45:14.608 --> 01:45:15.475
THE AREA OF SERIOUS PERSONAL
01:45:15.542 --> 01:45:18.612
INJURY WRONGFUL DEATH AND
01:45:18.679 --> 01:45:20.981
SEXUAL ABUSE ABOVE ALL AB TWO
01:45:21.048 --> 01:45:21.481
FOUR FOUR FIVE IS ABOUT
01:45:21.548 --> 01:45:24.117
FAIRNESS THE BILL AIMS TO
01:45:24.184 --> 01:45:25.786
CORRECT INEQUITIES IN THE LAW
01:45:25.852 --> 01:45:27.421
UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE A
01:45:27.487 --> 01:45:30.657
MINOR DIES TO THE WRONGFUL
01:45:30.724 --> 01:45:32.159
CONDUCT OF OTHERS UNDER SUCH
01:45:32.225 --> 01:45:35.395
CIRCUMSTANCES THE RIGHT CARE IS
01:45:35.462 --> 01:45:38.398
IN THE WRONG ACTION. THERE WAS.
01:45:38.465 --> 01:45:40.567
NINE CHILDREN ARE THE MINOR'S
01:45:40.634 --> 01:45:42.869
PARENT HOWEVER IF THE MINERS
01:45:42.936 --> 01:45:46.006
PARENTS PREDECEASED HIM OR HER
01:45:46.073 --> 01:45:47.207
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW FOR THE
01:45:47.274 --> 01:45:49.643
MINERS LEGAL GUARDIANS TO WRITE
01:45:49.710 --> 01:45:52.012
FULLY STEP INTO THE SHOES OF
01:45:52.079 --> 01:45:53.680
THE MINERS PARENTS CAN PURSUE
01:45:53.747 --> 01:45:57.284
WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIMS ON HIS OR
01:45:57.350 --> 01:46:00.253
HER BEHALF. AS WE THE LOS WE
01:46:00.320 --> 01:46:02.389
ALREADY IN SHIP IS NOT ENOUGH
01:46:02.456 --> 01:46:04.257
THE LAW REQUIRES THE MINERS
01:46:04.324 --> 01:46:06.126
LEGAL GUARDIAN TO HAVE FORMALLY
01:46:06.193 --> 01:46:09.563
ADOPTED THE MINOR IN ORDER TO
01:46:09.629 --> 01:46:11.331
BE ABLE TO BRING A LAWSUIT ON
01:46:11.398 --> 01:46:13.433
THE MINOR'S BEHALF. OWNER IT IN
01:46:13.500 --> 01:46:15.802
CANADA. DID SHOULD ELIMINATED
01:46:15.869 --> 01:46:18.605
AS THE LAW SHOULD RECOGNIZE THE
01:46:18.672 --> 01:46:20.407
CHANGING NATURE OF FAMILY. THIS
01:46:20.474 --> 01:46:22.242
BILL WOULD STILL REQUIRE THESE
01:46:22.309 --> 01:46:24.277
LEGAL GUARDIANS TO BE FORMALLY
01:46:24.344 --> 01:46:26.747
APPOINTED AS SUCH BY THE COURT
01:46:26.813 --> 01:46:28.415
PRIOR TO THE MINOR STAFF. THIS
01:46:28.482 --> 01:46:29.816
IS IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT WOULD
01:46:29.883 --> 01:46:31.284
STILL REQUIRE A JUDICIAL
01:46:31.351 --> 01:46:33.053
OFFICER TO EVALUATE THE
01:46:33.120 --> 01:46:35.122
CIRCUMSTANCES UNDERLYING THE
01:46:35.188 --> 01:46:36.957
APPOINTMENT THANK INCLUDED THE
01:46:37.023 --> 01:46:38.492
PARTY'S BRINGING THE
01:46:38.558 --> 01:46:40.093
APPLICATION SHOULD IN FACT BE
01:46:40.160 --> 01:46:42.262
OF THE MINERS LEGAL PARTY. IT
01:46:42.329 --> 01:46:43.330
SHOULD ALSO BE NOTED THAT THIS
01:46:43.396 --> 01:46:44.798
BILL WILL NOT EXPAND THE
01:46:44.865 --> 01:46:46.700
UNIVERSE OF PLANETS THAT MARK
01:46:46.767 --> 01:46:48.935
MAY PURSUE A WRONGFUL DEATH
01:46:49.002 --> 01:46:50.003
ACTION ON BEHALF OF THE MINE.
01:46:50.070 --> 01:46:51.705
RATHER IT NEARLY ALLOW
01:46:51.772 --> 01:46:53.006
GUARDIANS TO STEP INTO THE
01:46:53.073 --> 01:46:55.008
SHOES OF THE MINERS PARENTS
01:46:55.075 --> 01:46:55.909
WHEN BOTH PARENTS HAVE PASSED
01:46:55.976 --> 01:46:59.746
AWAY. IN SOME AB TWO FOUR FOUR
01:46:59.813 --> 01:47:00.747
FIVE NARROWLY AND THEN TO
01:47:00.814 --> 01:47:02.716
EXISTING LAW TO ALLOW FOR THE
01:47:02.783 --> 01:47:04.885
FULL PROSECUTION OF WRONGFUL
01:47:04.951 --> 01:47:06.720
DEATH ACTION. STEPPING INTO THE
01:47:06.787 --> 01:47:09.156
SHOES OF THE PARENT IS NO EASY
01:47:09.222 --> 01:47:11.558
TASK WHEN INDIVIDUALS TAKE ON
01:47:11.625 --> 01:47:13.727
THIS NOBLE VENTURE THEY SHOULD
01:47:13.794 --> 01:47:15.962
BE AFFORDED THE SAME RIGHTS
01:47:16.029 --> 01:47:17.130
AFFORDED TO THE MINORS. THANK
01:47:17.197 --> 01:47:19.466
YOU. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:47:19.533 --> 01:47:21.868
TESTIMONY DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
01:47:21.935 --> 01:47:24.237
WITNESSES LINED UP TO SPEAK ON
01:47:24.304 --> 01:47:27.574
BEHALF OF THIS MEASURE. ANY
01:47:27.641 --> 01:47:31.578
SPECIFIC MESSAGES INDIVIDUALS
01:47:31.645 --> 01:47:35.382
DO WE HAVE ANYONE IN ROOM FORTY
01:47:35.448 --> 01:47:36.750
TWO OR THREE WHO WISHES TO
01:47:36.817 --> 01:47:39.419
SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE SITE.
01:47:39.486 --> 01:47:41.688
CHING NON DO WE HAVE ANY
01:47:41.755 --> 01:47:45.492
WITNESSES IN ROOM TWENTY FORTY.
01:47:45.559 --> 01:47:46.092
WHO WISH TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF
01:47:46.159 --> 01:47:48.428
THE SITE AND- SEEING NONE WE
01:47:48.495 --> 01:47:51.031
WILL GO TO THE PHONES. MATTER
01:47:51.097 --> 01:47:52.899
MODERATOR WOULD YOU PLEASE-
01:47:52.966 --> 01:47:55.135
PROMPT INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
01:47:55.202 --> 01:47:59.306
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY
01:47:59.372 --> 01:48:00.974
FOUR FORTY FIVE. AND I WILL
01:48:01.041 --> 01:48:03.210
GIVE YOU A FEW SECONDS AND THEN
01:48:03.276 --> 01:48:05.545
PLEASE. INDICATE HOW MANY THERE
01:48:05.612 --> 01:48:09.182
ARE. THANK YOU IF YOU WISH TO
01:48:09.249 --> 01:48:12.886
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB TWO FOUR
01:48:12.953 --> 01:48:14.354
FOUR FIVE PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
01:48:14.421 --> 01:48:33.206
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
01:48:43.016 --> 01:48:43.316
BETTER
01:48:43.383 --> 01:48:44.985
MODERATOR COULD YOU INDICATE
01:48:45.051 --> 01:48:47.087
FOR US IF THERE ARE ANY
01:48:47.153 --> 01:48:50.957
WITNESSES AND IF SO HOW MANY.
01:48:51.024 --> 01:48:52.092
WE DO HAVE ONE IN Q. ALL RIGHT
01:48:52.158 --> 01:48:54.294
IF THAT WITNESS WOULD GO AHEAD
01:48:54.361 --> 01:48:54.794
AND PROCEED MATTER MORE
01:48:54.861 --> 01:48:58.965
MODERATOR. THANK YOU I WON
01:48:59.032 --> 01:49:01.801
SEVENTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:49:01.868 --> 01:49:03.303
ANY REPAIRS ON BEHALF OF THE
01:49:03.370 --> 01:49:04.471
CONSUMER FEDERATION OF
01:49:04.537 --> 01:49:05.605
CALIFORNIA JUST WANTED TO
01:49:05.672 --> 01:49:07.307
EXPRESS OUR SUPPORT AS WELL.
01:49:07.374 --> 01:49:09.976
THANK YOU THANK YOU AND- ONE
01:49:10.043 --> 01:49:11.244
LAST TIME ANY ANY OTHER
01:49:11.311 --> 01:49:13.880
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THIS
01:49:13.947 --> 01:49:16.716
ITEM AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE
01:49:16.783 --> 01:49:18.818
IF YOU WOULD PLEASE SO INDICATE
01:49:18.885 --> 01:49:21.454
NOW SO THAT THE MODERATOR CAN
01:49:21.521 --> 01:49:26.126
PUT YOU IN THE QUEUE. TO HAVE
01:49:26.192 --> 01:49:26.693
ANY FURTHER WITNESSES MATTER
01:49:26.760 --> 01:49:30.764
MODERATOR. I HAVE NO FOR THE
01:49:30.830 --> 01:49:33.733
LINES IN Q. AT THIS TIME VERY
01:49:33.800 --> 01:49:35.568
GOOD THANK YOU. THE LET'S GO
01:49:35.635 --> 01:49:37.170
AHEAD NOW WE'VE HEARD FROM ALL
01:49:37.237 --> 01:49:38.738
THE SUPPORTERS WILL FOLLOW THE
01:49:38.805 --> 01:49:40.674
SAME PROCESS AND HEAR FROM ANY
01:49:40.740 --> 01:49:43.910
OPPOSITION. ARE THERE ANY
01:49:43.977 --> 01:49:46.246
OPPOSITION WITNESSES IN THE
01:49:46.313 --> 01:49:48.548
CUTE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
01:49:48.615 --> 01:49:51.785
THIS BILL ANY WITNESSES WHO
01:49:51.851 --> 01:49:54.988
HAVE BEEN SIGNED UP TO DO SO. I
01:49:55.055 --> 01:49:56.456
DON'T BELIEVE SO I'M JUST
01:49:56.523 --> 01:49:58.458
CHECKING TO MAKE SURE THAT NO
01:49:58.525 --> 01:50:01.194
ONE IS PRETTY SIGNED FOR.
01:50:01.261 --> 01:50:02.862
OPPOSITION WITNESS TESTIMONY
01:50:02.929 --> 01:50:08.768
MADAM. MODERATOR. SIR ANYONE
01:50:08.835 --> 01:50:10.570
LINED UP IN THAT Q. AT THIS
01:50:10.637 --> 01:50:14.841
POINT. GUARD HEARING NONE HAVE
01:50:14.908 --> 01:50:19.713
NOT LINE. I'M SORRY. I HAVE NO
01:50:19.779 --> 01:50:21.281
LINE THINGS AREN'T VERY GOOD
01:50:21.348 --> 01:50:22.349
LET'S SEE IF THEY'RE ANY
01:50:22.415 --> 01:50:25.318
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION TO THE
01:50:25.385 --> 01:50:26.219
MEASURE IN ROOM FORTY TWO OR
01:50:26.286 --> 01:50:30.623
THREE. SEEING NONE ARE THERE
01:50:30.690 --> 01:50:31.791
ANY WITNESSES A ROOM TWENTY
01:50:31.858 --> 01:50:34.294
FORTY. SEEING NONE LET'S GO
01:50:34.361 --> 01:50:36.429
BACK TO MATTER MODERATOR AND IF
01:50:36.496 --> 01:50:39.132
THERE ARE ANY WITNESSES WHO
01:50:39.199 --> 01:50:41.968
WISH TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:50:42.035 --> 01:50:42.402
TO THIS MEASURE VIA
01:50:42.469 --> 01:50:44.571
TELECONFERENCE- AHMED A
01:50:44.637 --> 01:50:46.272
MODERATOR WOULD YOU PLEASE PROP
01:50:46.339 --> 01:50:52.645
THOSE INDIVIDUALS AT THIS TIME.
01:50:52.712 --> 01:50:56.850
AB TWO FOUR FOUR FIVE PLEASE-PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
01:50:56.916 --> 01:51:15.502
TIME. MATTER MODERATOR. I HAVE
01:51:15.568 --> 01:51:17.704
NO LINES INTO YOU AT THIS TIME
01:51:17.771 --> 01:51:18.805
RIGHT WILL BRING THE DISCUSSION
01:51:18.872 --> 01:51:21.207
BACK TO THE DíAS I JUST WANT
01:51:21.274 --> 01:51:22.776
TO SAY THANK YOU FOR BRINGING
01:51:22.842 --> 01:51:24.010
THIS THIS IS REALLY COMMONSENSE
01:51:24.077 --> 01:51:26.146
MEASURE THAT TOWARDS THE SAME
01:51:26.212 --> 01:51:28.715
RIGHTS TO LEGAL REPRESENTATION
01:51:28.782 --> 01:51:30.583
BY IN THE CONTEXT AS PARENTS
01:51:30.650 --> 01:51:34.020
AND- JUST AS IT DOES IN OTHER
01:51:34.087 --> 01:51:37.323
CONTEXTS SO OF THE STREET I
01:51:37.390 --> 01:51:37.924
BELIEVE THE SAME STRICT TRICK
01:51:37.991 --> 01:51:40.794
TOWARD PLY. TO LEGAL GUARDIAN
01:51:40.860 --> 01:51:42.028
PARENTS YOUR CHEST ALLOWING
01:51:42.095 --> 01:51:43.763
THEM THE IF YOU WILL STAND IN
01:51:43.830 --> 01:51:44.831
SHOES I THINK IS THE
01:51:44.898 --> 01:51:47.333
EXPRESSION. AND THE ONE WHO
01:51:47.400 --> 01:51:50.303
ARE. THANK YOU FOR THE MEASURE-
01:51:50.370 --> 01:51:53.073
OTHER ANY COMMENTS. THE BILL
01:51:53.139 --> 01:51:55.675
THERE IS A MOTION BY. SENATOR
01:51:55.742 --> 01:51:57.677
UMBERG THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
01:51:57.744 --> 01:52:00.180
THE SENATE FLOOR SEEING NO
01:52:00.246 --> 01:52:02.015
FURTHER DEBATE OR DISCUSSION.
01:52:02.082 --> 01:52:03.249
ASSEMBLYMEMBER REYES WOULD YOU
01:52:03.316 --> 01:52:05.485
LIKE TO CLOSE. I THINK
01:52:05.552 --> 01:52:07.854
RECALLING THE LEGAL GUARDIAN TO
01:52:07.921 --> 01:52:08.421
BRING AN ACTION IN THE SAME
01:52:08.488 --> 01:52:10.657
MANNER. AS ANY OTHER PARENT
01:52:10.723 --> 01:52:11.758
WILL UPDATE THE WRONGFUL DEATH
01:52:11.825 --> 01:52:13.093
STATUTE TO BETTER REFLECT THE
01:52:13.159 --> 01:52:14.861
CURRENT REALITIES OF FAMILY
01:52:14.928 --> 01:52:16.229
LIFE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
01:52:16.296 --> 01:52:18.198
AYE VOTE THANK YOU AND WITH
01:52:18.264 --> 01:52:20.667
THAT- MADAM CONSULTANT WOULD
01:52:20.733 --> 01:52:22.969
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:52:23.036 --> 01:52:24.337
SENATORS PLEASE TURNER
01:52:24.404 --> 01:52:26.639
MICROPHONES OFTEN THIS IS FILE
01:52:26.706 --> 01:52:29.676
ITEM NINE IN NAY B. TWO FOUR
01:52:29.742 --> 01:52:31.711
FOUR FIVE ASSEMBLY FOR PRESS.
01:52:31.778 --> 01:52:33.680
AND IS DEEP OF THIS FLOOR.
01:52:33.746 --> 01:52:37.317
JACKSON BY. JACKSON AYE BURGESS
01:52:37.383 --> 01:52:41.020
HI. LARGEST AYE DRESSEL HI
01:52:41.087 --> 01:52:44.691
RUSSEL I GONZALEZ HI. GONZALEZ
01:52:44.757 --> 01:52:50.263
I MELENDEZ. MORNING HI MONNING
01:52:50.330 --> 01:52:56.002
AYE STERN. STERN I AM BURKE I
01:52:56.069 --> 01:52:59.639
AMBERG I Y. CASKEY HI MY CASKEY
01:52:59.706 --> 01:53:01.741
I THAT EIGHT ZERO ONE REMEMBER
01:53:01.808 --> 01:53:04.777
MISSING HI OF THE VOTE COUNT IS
01:53:04.844 --> 01:53:06.613
EIGHT TWO ZERO WE HAVE ONE FOR-
01:53:06.679 --> 01:53:09.549
NOT IN THE ROOM SO WE PUT A
01:53:09.616 --> 01:53:11.818
BILL ON CALL THANK YOU SIMPLY
01:53:11.885 --> 01:53:17.223
MAKE REYES. NEXT UP WE- A SAM
01:53:17.290 --> 01:53:18.825
MEMBER. WHO I THINK IS BEEN
01:53:18.892 --> 01:53:22.529
WAITING PATIENTLY. AND HE HAS
01:53:22.595 --> 01:53:26.733
BEFORE US FILE ITEM FIFTEEN AB
01:53:26.799 --> 01:53:27.467
THIRTY TWENTY REGARDING UNFAIR
01:53:27.534 --> 01:53:29.369
PRACTICES THE ON FOR PRACTICE
01:53:29.435 --> 01:53:34.774
ACT. AND THE IF WE CLEANED OFF
01:53:34.841 --> 01:53:36.843
EVERYTHING'S READY TO GO A
01:53:36.910 --> 01:53:38.278
SICKLY MANDATORY THE FLOOR
01:53:38.344 --> 01:53:40.613
SHOOTERS- THANK YOU MEASURE I
01:53:40.680 --> 01:53:45.218
WILL BE BRIEF THIS BILL. IS
01:53:45.285 --> 01:53:45.718
FAMILIAR TO ME MEASURES
01:53:45.785 --> 01:53:46.352
COMMITTEE AS IT APPROVED YEAR
01:53:46.419 --> 01:53:47.954
HAS AB TEAMS SEVEN HOWEVER BILL
01:53:48.021 --> 01:53:51.457
WAS UNFORTUNATELY VETOED AB
01:53:51.524 --> 01:53:52.559
THREE TWENTY OF REQUIRES
01:53:52.625 --> 01:53:53.393
PENALTIES COLLECTED BY THE CITY
01:53:53.459 --> 01:53:55.028
TO CITY ATTORNEY FROM ACTION
01:53:55.094 --> 01:53:56.596
UNDER THE UNFAIR COMPETITION TO
01:53:56.663 --> 01:53:59.265
BE PAID IN TO THE CITY DIEGO
01:53:59.332 --> 01:54:00.767
MEMBERS THIS HAS NO OPPOSITION
01:54:00.833 --> 01:54:02.769
BUT IN THE COUNTY SAN DIEGO. SO
01:54:02.835 --> 01:54:05.271
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
01:54:05.338 --> 01:54:07.941
VOTE WITH ME THIS MORNING BY
01:54:08.007 --> 01:54:10.109
PHONE I SPEAKERS HE TO MARK.
01:54:10.176 --> 01:54:12.612
THANK YOU. CONCISELY XIN TATIAN
01:54:12.679 --> 01:54:14.881
MUCH PREPAID OF WE HAVE A
01:54:14.948 --> 01:54:17.417
WITNESS ON THE PHONE. IS SAN
01:54:17.483 --> 01:54:19.319
DIEGO CITY ATTORNEY MARK
01:54:19.385 --> 01:54:22.288
ELLIOTT THE FLOOR IS YOURS.
01:54:22.355 --> 01:54:23.923
THANK YOU AND GOOD MORNING I
01:54:23.990 --> 01:54:25.291
SAN DIEGO THREE ATTORNEY MARA
01:54:25.358 --> 01:54:27.927
ALLIOT UNDER STATE LAW FOR THE
01:54:27.994 --> 01:54:29.462
ATTORNEY TO SERVICE CITY OF
01:54:29.529 --> 01:54:31.564
MORE THAN SEVEN HUNDRED FIFTY
01:54:31.631 --> 01:54:32.832
THOUSAND HAVE AUTHORITY TO
01:54:32.899 --> 01:54:34.067
BRING ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS.
01:54:34.133 --> 01:54:35.568
BASED ON ON OUR COMPETITION
01:54:35.635 --> 01:54:38.738
LAWS ON BEHALF PEOPLE OF THE
01:54:38.805 --> 01:54:39.706
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. WHEN
01:54:39.772 --> 01:54:41.174
CHOOSING WHICH CASES TO PURSUE
01:54:41.241 --> 01:54:43.643
I LOOKED FOR EGREGIOUS CASES.
01:54:43.710 --> 01:54:45.845
WHERE OUR ENVIRONMENT IS BEING
01:54:45.912 --> 01:54:49.082
HARMED CONSUMERS ARE BEING. THE
01:54:49.148 --> 01:54:50.216
WORKERS ARE BEING SHORT CHANGED
01:54:50.283 --> 01:54:52.352
FINANCE SCRUPULOUS EMPLOYER OR
01:54:52.418 --> 01:54:53.620
THE HEALTH AND WELFARE OF OUR
01:54:53.686 --> 01:54:55.421
PEOPLE IS JEOPARDIZED WE
01:54:55.488 --> 01:54:57.290
TYPICALLY GIVE THE BUSINESS AN
01:54:57.357 --> 01:54:59.192
OPPORTUNITY TO COMPLY. AND THEN
01:54:59.259 --> 01:55:00.260
WE BRING LITIGATION WHEN OUR
01:55:00.326 --> 01:55:02.462
EFFORTS TO EDUCATE AND GAIN
01:55:02.528 --> 01:55:05.198
COMPLIANCE FAIL. WE'VE BROUGHT
01:55:05.265 --> 01:55:07.033
CASES THAT ALLOWS CENSURE HARD
01:55:07.100 --> 01:55:08.768
WORKING SAN DIEGANS ARE PAID
01:55:08.835 --> 01:55:10.803
WHAT THEY'RE I WOULD COME TO
01:55:10.870 --> 01:55:11.971
WORK THEY PERFORMED. RUMORS ARE
01:55:12.038 --> 01:55:14.474
NOT CHARGED HIS. WIFE EXPLOITED
01:55:14.540 --> 01:55:15.942
POLLUTANTS ARE REMOVED FROM OUR
01:55:16.009 --> 01:55:17.377
WATER WAYS AND THAT'S FOR A
01:55:17.443 --> 01:55:19.846
TICKET TO OPIOIDS CAN ACCESS
01:55:19.912 --> 01:55:22.682
THE SERVICES THEY NEED TO
01:55:22.749 --> 01:55:23.449
RECOVER FROM ADDICTION. BECAUSE
01:55:23.516 --> 01:55:24.617
THERE'S ACCOUNTABILITY AND ARE
01:55:24.684 --> 01:55:26.786
IMPORTANT TO THE SAN DIEGO.
01:55:26.853 --> 01:55:28.588
UNDER EXISTING LAW THE CITY OF
01:55:28.655 --> 01:55:30.456
SAN DIEGO MUST SHARE THE CIVIL
01:55:30.523 --> 01:55:33.192
PENALTIES IT RECOVERS FROM
01:55:33.259 --> 01:55:34.694
THESE CASES WITH THE COUNTY OF
01:55:34.761 --> 01:55:36.329
SAN DIEGO EVEN IF THE COUNTY
01:55:36.396 --> 01:55:38.798
DOES NOT AND THE SINGLE SECOND
01:55:38.865 --> 01:55:43.236
ASSISTANCE WITH THE CHANGES. IT
01:55:43.303 --> 01:55:43.736
THE CASE UNDER THIS LAW
01:55:43.803 --> 01:55:45.705
RECOVERS PETE. A LOT OF NEW
01:55:45.772 --> 01:55:46.439
WORK THE COW TO SHOW THE
01:55:46.506 --> 01:55:49.842
CURRENT IT. THE DISTRIBUTION IS
01:55:49.909 --> 01:55:51.477
NOT FAIR AND IT DOESN'T MAKE
01:55:51.544 --> 01:55:53.913
SENSE RECOVERING FULL PENALTIES
01:55:53.980 --> 01:55:54.847
FOR THE WORK WE DO IS VERY
01:55:54.914 --> 01:55:56.616
IMPORTANT. WE REINVEST THE
01:55:56.683 --> 01:55:59.652
PENALTIES WE WRITE WE RECOVER.
01:55:59.719 --> 01:56:00.920
IN ORDER TO CONTINUE TO DO THE
01:56:00.987 --> 01:56:02.555
WORK THAT WE'RE DOING FOR
01:56:02.622 --> 01:56:03.089
CONSUMERS WORKERS AND THE
01:56:03.156 --> 01:56:05.325
ENVIRONMENT. IT'S UNFORTUNATE
01:56:05.391 --> 01:56:06.993
WE MUST REJECT THE CASE BECAUSE
01:56:07.060 --> 01:56:08.361
THE COST TO PUT YOUR PURSE
01:56:08.428 --> 01:56:10.897
TRIMMING AND- IS OUTWEIGHED BY
01:56:10.963 --> 01:56:12.465
THE PENALTIES WILL RECOVER.
01:56:12.532 --> 01:56:14.400
UNDER EIGHTY THREE TWENTY THE
01:56:14.467 --> 01:56:15.501
CITY OF SAN DIEGO WOULD KEEP
01:56:15.568 --> 01:56:16.636
ALL THE PENALTIES ARE COVERED
01:56:16.703 --> 01:56:17.704
AND WHEN THE RECOVERY IT'S
01:56:17.770 --> 01:56:20.707
USUALLY. ONLY WHEN OUR COVERAGE
01:56:20.773 --> 01:56:26.012
IS ONLY TO OWN EFFORT. I. YOU
01:56:26.079 --> 01:56:27.180
TO SUPPORT EIGHTY THIRTY
01:56:27.246 --> 01:56:28.014
TWENTY. WITH ME ON THE LINE IS
01:56:28.081 --> 01:56:28.681
THE CHIEF DEPUTIES ATTORNEY
01:56:28.748 --> 01:56:30.783
MARK AND CORN RAN ARE
01:56:30.850 --> 01:56:32.685
PERMISSIBLE AND FORCED UNIT AND
01:56:32.752 --> 01:56:33.886
IT'S AVAILABLE TO HELP ME
01:56:33.953 --> 01:56:35.521
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY
01:56:35.588 --> 01:56:37.523
HAVE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
01:56:37.590 --> 01:56:38.991
MUCH AND- IF THERE ARE
01:56:39.058 --> 01:56:40.793
QUESTIONS WILL HAVE MISTER AND
01:56:40.860 --> 01:56:43.096
CORN JOIN US BUT AT THIS POINT
01:56:43.162 --> 01:56:44.630
MY UNDERSTANDING IS HE HEARS
01:56:44.697 --> 01:56:46.299
HE'S HERE FOR TECHNICAL
01:56:46.366 --> 01:56:50.370
EXPERTISE ON. WITH THAT- DO WE
01:56:50.436 --> 01:56:52.605
HAVE ANY WITNESSES HERE IN
01:56:52.672 --> 01:56:55.241
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE. IT'S
01:56:55.308 --> 01:56:57.777
A. B. THIRTY TWENTY ITEM
01:56:57.844 --> 01:56:58.978
FIFTEEN WHO ARE HERE IN ROOM
01:56:59.045 --> 01:57:01.481
FORTY TWO OR THREE. SEEING NONE
01:57:01.547 --> 01:57:03.116
LET'S GO TO ROOM TWENTY FORTY
01:57:03.182 --> 01:57:05.284
ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES THERE.
01:57:05.351 --> 01:57:08.287
SEEING NONE. WE'LL GO TO THE
01:57:08.354 --> 01:57:09.489
PHONES AND I WANT TO REMIND
01:57:09.555 --> 01:57:12.225
PEOPLE ARE TODAY'S PARTICIPANT
01:57:12.291 --> 01:57:16.929
NUMBER. IS. ONE EIGHT FOUR
01:57:16.996 --> 01:57:22.368
FOUR. TWO NINE ONE. SIXTY THREE
01:57:22.435 --> 01:57:23.202
SIXTY FOUR AGAIN IT'S ON THE
01:57:23.269 --> 01:57:28.808
SCREEN HERE BUT I'LL REPEAT IT.
01:57:28.875 --> 01:57:29.375
ONE EIGHT FOUR FOUR TWO NINE
01:57:29.442 --> 01:57:33.112
ONE. SIX THREE SIX FOUR. THE
01:57:33.179 --> 01:57:37.517
ACCESS CODE IS SIX ONE. ONE
01:57:37.583 --> 01:57:45.625
ONE. ONE SEVEN NINE SIX ONE ONE
01:57:45.691 --> 01:57:46.192
ONE ONE SEVEN NINE AND LET'S
01:57:46.259 --> 01:57:47.760
SAY A Q. THOSE FOLKS SHOP IF
01:57:47.827 --> 01:57:49.896
THERE ARE ANY PEOPLE WHO WISH
01:57:49.962 --> 01:57:51.631
TO SPEAK MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
01:57:51.697 --> 01:57:53.299
PLEASE PROMPT THE INDIVIDUALS
01:57:53.366 --> 01:57:56.068
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
01:57:56.135 --> 01:58:01.107
OF AB THIRTY TWENTY. THANK YOU
01:58:01.174 --> 01:58:02.875
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
01:58:02.942 --> 01:58:05.011
OF AB THIRTY TWENTY PLEASE
01:58:05.077 --> 01:58:07.180
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
01:58:07.246 --> 01:58:21.661
TIME. THANK YOU MODERATOR CAN
01:58:21.727 --> 01:58:23.763
YOU PLEASE GIVE US THE TOTAL OF
01:58:23.830 --> 01:58:25.298
PEOPLE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
01:58:25.364 --> 01:58:30.770
SUPPORT. I A LIFE INTO AT THIS
01:58:30.837 --> 01:58:33.306
TIME ALL RIGHT THANK YOU. WOULD
01:58:33.372 --> 01:58:34.640
YOU ARE WILL GIVE ANOTHER TEN
01:58:34.707 --> 01:58:37.043
SECONDS IN CASE ANYONE WISHES
01:58:37.109 --> 01:58:50.056
TO. PARTICIPATE. ARE THERE ANY
01:58:50.122 --> 01:58:53.259
SUCH WITNESSES MATTER MODERATOR.
01:58:53.326 --> 01:58:56.295
I HAVE NO LINE THINK YOU AT
01:58:56.362 --> 01:58:59.031
THIS TIME VERY GOOD THANK YOU.
01:58:59.098 --> 01:58:59.665
WE'VE HEARD FROM THE SPORT SURE
01:58:59.732 --> 01:59:03.236
ANY OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE
01:59:03.302 --> 01:59:05.638
ARE I BELIEVE WE DO NOT HAVE-
01:59:05.705 --> 01:59:08.341
ANYTHING ONLINE DO WE HAVE ANY
01:59:08.407 --> 01:59:09.342
OPPOSITION ROOM FORTY TWO OR
01:59:09.408 --> 01:59:12.378
THREE. XING NON DO WE HAVE ANY
01:59:12.445 --> 01:59:15.181
IN ROOM TWENTY FORTY. SEEING
01:59:15.248 --> 01:59:17.583
NON. BY IF THERE ARE ANY
01:59:17.650 --> 01:59:20.419
WITNESSES WHO WISH TO TESTIFY
01:59:20.486 --> 01:59:22.321
VIA TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
01:59:22.388 --> 01:59:23.923
MATTER MODERATOR WOULD YOU
01:59:23.990 --> 01:59:25.625
PLEASE PROP THOSE INDIVIDUALS
01:59:25.691 --> 01:59:27.326
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
01:59:27.393 --> 01:59:31.831
OPPOSITION TO AB THIRTY TWENTY
01:59:31.898 --> 01:59:34.233
AND WILL ASK YOU TO TAKE ABOUT
01:59:34.300 --> 01:59:35.968
TEN INSTALL ITEM UP IN INTO A
01:59:36.035 --> 01:59:37.336
PRICE TO SEE IF IN FACT THERE
01:59:37.403 --> 01:59:38.738
ARE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:59:38.804 --> 01:59:41.274
OPPOSITION. WHO WISH TO SPEAK
01:59:41.340 --> 01:59:46.412
OUR ONLINE. THANK YOU IF YOU
01:59:46.479 --> 01:59:48.180
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF
01:59:48.247 --> 01:59:51.183
AB THIRTY TWENTY PLEASE PRESS
01:59:51.250 --> 02:00:05.998
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:00:06.065 --> 02:00:07.967
DO WE HAVE ANY SUCH OPPOSITION
02:00:08.034 --> 02:00:11.938
MATTER MODERATOR. I HAVE NO
02:00:12.004 --> 02:00:13.940
LINE RINGS YOU AT THIS TIME ALL
02:00:14.006 --> 02:00:17.310
RIGHT THANK YOU OF WE WILL
02:00:17.376 --> 02:00:18.778
BRING THE DISCUSSION BACK TO
02:00:18.844 --> 02:00:20.279
THE MEMBERS I WANNA THANK YOU
02:00:20.346 --> 02:00:21.280
BYE MEMBER LAURIE FOR BREATH
02:00:21.347 --> 02:00:22.848
THE BILL WE HEARD THAT
02:00:22.915 --> 02:00:25.284
PREVIOUSLY WITH RESPECT TO ALL
02:00:25.351 --> 02:00:26.319
COUNTIES THAT HAD SEVEN
02:00:26.385 --> 02:00:27.787
HUNDRED. THOUSAND OR MORE
02:00:27.853 --> 02:00:29.422
RESIDENTS AND I THINK BASICALLY
02:00:29.488 --> 02:00:33.392
THOSE ARE SAN FRANCISCO. SAN
02:00:33.459 --> 02:00:35.962
JOSE AND LOS ANGELES- AT THIS
02:00:36.028 --> 02:00:38.130
POINT THERE IS NO OPPOSITION
02:00:38.197 --> 02:00:40.166
AND THE BILL ONLY FOCUSES ON
02:00:40.232 --> 02:00:42.034
SAN DIEGO COUNTY AND CERTAINLY.
02:00:42.101 --> 02:00:44.637
YOU KNOW THERE IS AN ARGUMENT
02:00:44.704 --> 02:00:45.204
OF FAIRNESS ARGUMENT THAT IF
02:00:45.271 --> 02:00:47.473
YOU BRING THE ACTION YOU SHOULD
02:00:47.540 --> 02:00:49.942
BE ABLE TO REAP THE BENEFITS-
02:00:50.009 --> 02:00:51.243
THERE WAS SOME DISAGREEMENT
02:00:51.310 --> 02:00:55.915
ABOUT THAT THAT CAME. FROM SOME
02:00:55.982 --> 02:00:56.515
OF THE OTHER JURISDICTIONS BUT
02:00:56.582 --> 02:00:57.717
CLEARLY SAN DIEGO. RESOLVED ITS
02:00:57.783 --> 02:01:00.353
STIFF AND- WITH THAT I
02:01:00.419 --> 02:01:01.988
CERTAINLY THINK IT'S
02:01:02.054 --> 02:01:05.524
APPROPRIATE THAT UP. TO THE
02:01:05.591 --> 02:01:06.058
CITY OF SAN DIEGO AND THE
02:01:06.125 --> 02:01:08.728
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO CONTINUE TO
02:01:08.794 --> 02:01:11.564
MAXIMIZE THEIR EFFORTS AND
02:01:11.631 --> 02:01:14.166
THAT'S WHAT IT SOUNDS LIKE THIS-BILL OR THAT'S WHAT IT APPEARS
02:01:14.233 --> 02:01:16.702
AS BILL'S GOING TO DO IN ORDER.
02:01:16.769 --> 02:01:20.072
TO WHAT SUGGESTS CAN. IN THE
02:01:20.139 --> 02:01:21.273
PEOPLE THE COUNTY AND I COULD
02:01:21.340 --> 02:01:21.874
COMMEND YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
02:01:21.941 --> 02:01:23.476
AND- CERTAINLY LOOK FOR TO SPUR
02:01:23.542 --> 02:01:24.844
IT ARE THERE ANY OTHER
02:01:24.910 --> 02:01:27.380
COMMENTS. WITH THE BILL. WE
02:01:27.446 --> 02:01:29.915
HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR UMBERG
02:01:29.982 --> 02:01:31.050
TO MOVE THE BILL WE HAVE A
02:01:31.117 --> 02:01:35.121
COMMENT BY MISTER BORCHERS.
02:01:35.187 --> 02:01:38.224
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR. US BRAND
02:01:38.290 --> 02:01:41.861
THE OF HONOR HEADING INTO YOUR
02:01:41.927 --> 02:01:42.495
NAKED WOODS CHATTING WITH THE
02:01:42.561 --> 02:01:45.931
YOUR MAYOR ON CODE RE OPENING
02:01:45.998 --> 02:01:48.801
UP POLICIES AND JUST ACTUALLY
02:01:48.868 --> 02:01:52.772
LOVE YOUR BACKYARD- WHEN THIS.
02:01:52.838 --> 02:01:53.906
BILL CAME MINUTES EARLIER
02:01:53.973 --> 02:01:56.042
VERSION I HAD EXPRESSED
02:01:56.108 --> 02:01:58.778
CONCERNS THAT IT WOULD HIT
02:01:58.844 --> 02:02:00.680
COUNTIES AGAIN CITIES AND VICE
02:02:00.746 --> 02:02:04.116
VERSA AND I STILL HAVE THAT ARE
02:02:04.183 --> 02:02:05.418
CONCERNED AS I EXPRESSED
02:02:05.484 --> 02:02:12.124
EARLIER. AND THIS IS. FOCUS
02:02:12.191 --> 02:02:14.460
ONLY ON SAN DIEGO WHICH I DON'T
02:02:14.527 --> 02:02:16.662
KNOW WHY THERE CAN'T BE A
02:02:16.729 --> 02:02:18.264
COUNTY CITY REVENUE SHARING
02:02:18.330 --> 02:02:19.699
AGREEMENT I THINK EVERY YEAR
02:02:19.765 --> 02:02:21.267
EVERY COUNTY AND CITY GO
02:02:21.333 --> 02:02:23.102
THROUGH SOME SORT OF REVENUE
02:02:23.169 --> 02:02:25.104
SHARING DISCUSSION OR EVERY
02:02:25.171 --> 02:02:27.973
NUMBER OF YEARS- I'M SURPRISED
02:02:28.040 --> 02:02:29.642
JUST BY VIRTUE OF LOCAL CONTROL
02:02:29.709 --> 02:02:31.711
IF THEY CAN'T. REACH SOME SORT
02:02:31.777 --> 02:02:32.978
OF ACCOMMODATION IN YOUR
02:02:33.045 --> 02:02:35.381
EXPERIENCE ARE THESE PARTIES
02:02:35.448 --> 02:02:37.149
JUST AT AN IMPASSE. WELL NOT
02:02:37.216 --> 02:02:39.418
CITY WILL HAVE CONSENSUS
02:02:39.485 --> 02:02:40.019
BETWEEN BUT THE CITY IN THE
02:02:40.086 --> 02:02:42.621
COUNTY ON THIS BILL AND SUPPORT
02:02:42.688 --> 02:02:44.523
FOR- THAT CONSIDER CROSS
02:02:44.590 --> 02:02:46.058
AMERICAN SINCE THIS NOT EVIDENT
02:02:46.125 --> 02:02:48.294
IN THESE OTHER. CITIES THAT THE
02:02:48.360 --> 02:02:49.628
CHAIR REFERENCE AS A
02:02:49.695 --> 02:02:51.130
CONSEQUENCE THE BILL HAS BEEN
02:02:51.197 --> 02:02:52.932
NARROWED TO EXCLUDE THEM. ALL
02:02:52.998 --> 02:02:55.668
RIGHT- I'M I'M CONCERNED THAT
02:02:55.735 --> 02:02:59.271
IF THIS HAPPENS IN SAN DIEGO-
02:02:59.338 --> 02:03:01.941
WE'RE GOING TO BE FINE THAT-
02:03:02.007 --> 02:03:03.743
THE CITY OF FRESNO FOR EXAMPLE
02:03:03.809 --> 02:03:05.177
IS GOING TO WANT TO HAVE-
02:03:05.244 --> 02:03:06.412
SOMETHING DIFFERENT- FRESNO
02:03:06.479 --> 02:03:08.047
COUNTY OR JUST ACROSS THE
02:03:08.114 --> 02:03:12.618
STATE- BUT- MOST IMPORTANTLY-
02:03:12.685 --> 02:03:15.821
HOW. AGAIN IS THIS SATISFACTORY
02:03:15.888 --> 02:03:18.958
OF CONDITIONS OF HAVING. A BILL
02:03:19.024 --> 02:03:20.559
HEARD THAT WAS MY LOOK MY
02:03:20.626 --> 02:03:22.661
ULTIMATE LAST POINT HERE IT'S
02:03:22.728 --> 02:03:25.030
NOT CODE RELATED IT'S NOT TIME
02:03:25.097 --> 02:03:27.767
SENSITIVE- OR- WHAT WHAT IS THE
02:03:27.833 --> 02:03:29.568
ULTIMATE BECAUSE IT THIS SOUNDS
02:03:29.635 --> 02:03:32.371
LIKE. THIS S THE JANUARY BILL.
02:03:32.438 --> 02:03:33.706
LET ME AS FRAZIER CONCERNED IN
02:03:33.773 --> 02:03:34.740
PARTICULAR FOR THE RECORD
02:03:34.807 --> 02:03:37.276
BECAUSE UP FRESNO CANNOT BRING
02:03:37.343 --> 02:03:38.511
THESE KINDS OF ACTIONS UNDER
02:03:38.577 --> 02:03:39.678
STATE LAW CURRENTLY IS TOO
02:03:39.745 --> 02:03:42.248
SMALL. SO IT'S ONLY CITIES OF
02:03:42.314 --> 02:03:43.282
SEVENTY THOUSAND OR MORE SO IF
02:03:43.349 --> 02:03:44.683
THAT KEEP ME UP NIGHTS YOU
02:03:44.750 --> 02:03:45.684
COULD SLEEP SOUNDLY TONIGHT
02:03:45.751 --> 02:03:47.119
OKAY HA HA HA CONSISTING TO
02:03:47.186 --> 02:03:49.622
COVET YOU AND I BOTH KNOW THAT
02:03:49.688 --> 02:03:50.823
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ARE BEING
02:03:50.890 --> 02:03:52.925
SQUEEZED IN THIS PANDEMIC AND
02:03:52.992 --> 02:03:54.426
THEIR REVENUES ARE PLAN. MAKING
02:03:54.493 --> 02:03:57.062
AND HAVING TO CHOOSE VERY VOCAL.
02:03:57.129 --> 02:03:58.097
FORTIES ABOUT WHAT TO PERSON
02:03:58.164 --> 02:03:59.832
WHAT NOT TO PURSUE TO THE
02:03:59.899 --> 02:04:01.267
EXTENT THAT OUR CITY ATTORNEY
02:04:01.333 --> 02:04:03.202
HE HEARD FROM A MOMENT AGO IS
02:04:03.269 --> 02:04:06.105
ACTIVELY HAND COLLUDED CONSUMER
02:04:06.172 --> 02:04:08.107
PROTECTION CASES BUT HAS TO
02:04:08.174 --> 02:04:09.642
JUDGE ON THE FACT THAT IF SHE
02:04:09.708 --> 02:04:12.211
SPENDS A HUNDRED THOUSAND
02:04:12.278 --> 02:04:15.147
DOLLARS IN DOING IT. SHE'LL FOR
02:04:15.214 --> 02:04:21.187
THE REVENUE BACK SO. FOR SHADI
02:04:21.253 --> 02:04:23.155
TESTING. THROUGH DOING I DID
02:04:23.222 --> 02:04:24.323
DRIVE OF OPERATIONS CHARGING
02:04:24.390 --> 02:04:26.225
CUTS NOT DOING CALL TEST. ARTS
02:04:26.292 --> 02:04:27.059
TWENTY WANTS TO PASS THAT THE
02:04:27.126 --> 02:04:27.927
RIGHT NOW SHE ONLY GETS HOW OF
02:04:27.993 --> 02:04:29.461
THE- THAT COMES TO THE PROJECT.
02:04:29.528 --> 02:04:31.030
THE COMES AFTERWARDS AND IF THE
02:04:31.096 --> 02:04:32.364
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO THE SAME
02:04:32.431 --> 02:04:34.934
THING SHE GETS. NOTHING SO I
02:04:35.000 --> 02:04:36.569
HUMBLY SUGGEST THAT THIS TIME
02:04:36.635 --> 02:04:37.937
WITH CONSUMERS ARE BEING
02:04:38.003 --> 02:04:40.773
SQUEEZED BY UNSCRUPULOUS ACTORS.
02:04:40.840 --> 02:04:41.774
ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO HAVE OUR
02:04:41.841 --> 02:04:43.008
PUBLIC WATCHDOGS AFTER DOING
02:04:43.075 --> 02:04:44.610
THE WORK AND THIS WILL MAKE IT
02:04:44.677 --> 02:04:46.245
MORE LIKELY AND BECAUSE THE
02:04:46.312 --> 02:04:47.713
REVENUES UPON MANY ACTION MAKES
02:04:47.780 --> 02:04:49.548
IT LESS LIKELY WITHOUT THIS
02:04:49.615 --> 02:04:51.217
LEGISLATION. I WILL CERTAINLY
02:04:51.283 --> 02:04:53.419
APPLAUD THAT EFFORT TO DRAW A
02:04:53.485 --> 02:04:56.222
NEXUS OUGHT TO COVERED AS
02:04:56.288 --> 02:04:59.491
UNIQUE AND CREATIVE AS IT WAS.
02:04:59.558 --> 02:05:02.061
AND WHAT IF. BIGGIE GETS BACK
02:05:02.127 --> 02:05:04.296
THE- THE OVERALL ON THE OVERALL
02:05:04.363 --> 02:05:06.365
IMPORT OF THIS IS WHETHER IT'S
02:05:06.432 --> 02:05:08.934
LIMITED TO COUNTIES OVER SEVEN
02:05:09.001 --> 02:05:09.735
HUNDRED THOUSAND OR CITIES
02:05:09.802 --> 02:05:13.372
RATHER- THE IDEA OF CREATING A
02:05:13.439 --> 02:05:16.008
CONTEST BETWEEN MUNICIPALITIES
02:05:16.075 --> 02:05:18.277
AND COUNTIES EVER SIZE THEY MAY
02:05:18.344 --> 02:05:21.146
BE. HAVING SERVED AT THE LOCAL
02:05:21.213 --> 02:05:23.315
LEVEL IN BOTH LEVELS THAT'S WHY
02:05:23.382 --> 02:05:25.050
THAT'S BIGGEST SIR IS THAT WE
02:05:25.117 --> 02:05:27.152
ARE JOB CREATING AN ATMOSPHERE
02:05:27.219 --> 02:05:32.091
OF REVENUE CONTROL AND- BEING
02:05:32.157 --> 02:05:37.229
VERY DOGGEDLY IN TERMS OF- WHO
02:05:37.296 --> 02:05:40.065
HAS TURF HERE VERSUS TURF THEIR
02:05:40.132 --> 02:05:41.734
THING. IT'S IT IS SAN DIEGO.
02:05:41.800 --> 02:05:44.370
WOULD ARE AND VISOR LEFT
02:05:44.436 --> 02:05:47.306
RESPECT YOUR GOOD EFFORTS THANK
02:05:47.373 --> 02:05:49.241
YOU THANK YOU SIR. MY TEACHING
02:05:49.308 --> 02:05:51.377
NO OTHER OMMENTS- WE HAVE A
02:05:51.443 --> 02:05:54.847
MOTION BY SENATOR UMBERG THE
02:05:54.914 --> 02:05:55.848
MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE SENATE
02:05:55.915 --> 02:05:58.284
FLOOR. ASSEMBLYMEMBER GLORY
02:05:58.350 --> 02:05:59.985
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE SPECS
02:06:00.052 --> 02:06:02.988
WE ASK YOU HAVE A GOOD RIDE AND
02:06:03.055 --> 02:06:05.691
CONSULTANT IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
02:06:05.758 --> 02:06:06.525
CALL THE ROLL. SEC PLEASE TURN
02:06:06.592 --> 02:06:09.561
YOUR MICROPHONES ON. L. ITEM
02:06:09.628 --> 02:06:14.166
FIFTEEN AB THIRTY TWENTY GLORIA
02:06:14.233 --> 02:06:14.733
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE
02:06:14.800 --> 02:06:17.303
SENATE FLOOR. JACKSON I AND I
02:06:17.369 --> 02:06:21.774
PORGES. WHAT IS NOT VOTING TO
02:06:21.840 --> 02:06:26.011
WRESTLE I. RUSSELL AYE GONZALEZ
02:06:26.078 --> 02:06:29.148
I BEEN TELETHON A MELINDA'S NOW
02:06:29.214 --> 02:06:32.151
MELENDEZ NELL MINING AYE AYE
02:06:32.217 --> 02:06:38.023
MONNING AYE STERN. BUT I TURN I
02:06:38.090 --> 02:06:43.162
AM BURKE HI NUMBER I WAKE CLYDE
02:06:43.228 --> 02:06:48.233
WAY CASKEY I. THAT'S SEVENTY
02:06:48.300 --> 02:06:50.402
ONE ALL MEMBERS HERE. THE
02:06:50.469 --> 02:06:53.038
ACCOUNT IS SEVEN AT THE TWO ONE
02:06:53.105 --> 02:06:55.541
ONE NOT VOTING THE MEASURE OF
02:06:55.607 --> 02:06:57.343
PASSES THE BILL IS OUT EIGHTY
02:06:57.409 --> 02:07:18.230
SEVEN THANK YOU. YEAH. IT HOPE.
02:07:18.297 --> 02:07:21.767
THE COMPLICATED RIGHT THAT ONE
02:07:21.834 --> 02:07:22.968
IS NOT AVAILABLE RIGHT ON
02:07:23.035 --> 02:07:25.671
DOMESTIC WORK ON IN A MAIN
02:07:25.738 --> 02:07:32.711
HIGHWAY THIS IS SO THAT'S JOB.
02:07:32.778 --> 02:07:34.446
WE HAVE NECK UP OF THOSE MAY
02:07:34.513 --> 02:07:39.551
WHERE OFF I ITEM. AB THIRTY ONE
02:07:39.618 --> 02:07:40.686
TWENTY ONE TASK FORCE TO STUDY
02:07:40.753 --> 02:07:41.520
AND DEVELOPE REPARATION
02:07:41.587 --> 02:07:44.723
PROPOSALS FOR AFRICAN AMERICANS
02:07:44.790 --> 02:07:47.292
IN THE SENATOR BRADFORD WELCOME
02:07:47.359 --> 02:07:49.461
YOU WILL BE PRESENTING THIS
02:07:49.528 --> 02:07:51.263
BILL ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
02:07:51.330 --> 02:07:53.632
MEMBER WEBER I BELIEVE. CORRECT
02:07:53.699 --> 02:07:56.068
AND BEFORE YOU TO BEGIN NO I
02:07:56.135 --> 02:07:59.071
TALKED TO SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES
02:07:59.138 --> 02:08:01.106
HERE WE WANT TO GIVE A- BIG
02:08:01.173 --> 02:08:03.809
SHOUT OUT. TO THE ALICE'S ALL
02:08:03.876 --> 02:08:09.548
PAGES OF IT THERE WAS A DONE BY
02:08:09.615 --> 02:08:14.386
ALISON. MEREDITH OF IT I THINK
02:08:14.453 --> 02:08:17.156
IT IS ONE OF THE BEST HISTORY
02:08:17.222 --> 02:08:18.323
LESSONS THAT WE COULD ALL HAVE
02:08:18.390 --> 02:08:20.325
IN THE PERIOD OF TWENTY FIVE
02:08:20.392 --> 02:08:23.529
PAGES AND- I WOULD INVITE AND
02:08:23.595 --> 02:08:27.299
ENCOURAGE OF NOT ONLY THE
02:08:27.366 --> 02:08:29.735
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE IF
02:08:29.802 --> 02:08:33.272
THEY DIDN'T WEREN'T ABLE TO
02:08:33.338 --> 02:08:40.979
READ THROUGH. THAT I THINK
02:08:41.046 --> 02:08:42.247
EVERYBODY SHOULD READ SO I WANT
02:08:42.314 --> 02:08:44.783
TO GIVE HER A SHOUT OUT AS WELL
02:08:44.850 --> 02:08:46.852
AND THE HOPE THAT ONE WILL
02:08:46.919 --> 02:08:49.721
REDUCE IT'S REALLY QUITE TO.
02:08:49.788 --> 02:08:51.123
EXCEPTIONAL AND TERM APPRECIATE
02:08:51.190 --> 02:08:52.658
HER HARD WORK IN THAT AND
02:08:52.724 --> 02:08:54.560
CERTAINLY APPRECIATE YOUR-
02:08:54.626 --> 02:08:55.594
BEING HERE TODAY SENATOR
02:08:55.661 --> 02:08:57.863
BRADFORD TO PRESENT THE BILL.
02:08:57.930 --> 02:08:59.331
Q. AND I TOTALLY AGREE WITH
02:08:59.398 --> 02:09:01.200
ANALYSIS AND I THINK IT MAKES A
02:09:01.266 --> 02:09:03.936
STRONG ARGUMENT FOR ANOTHER
02:09:04.002 --> 02:09:05.270
ISSUE THE DOCTOR WHAT PERCENT
02:09:05.337 --> 02:09:06.972
CAMPAIGN AND THAT'S UP NEXT
02:09:07.039 --> 02:09:09.875
THIRTIES INSTEAD. SO ON THE DAY
02:09:09.942 --> 02:09:11.276
AS NOT ONLY CALL UP THERE BUT
02:09:11.343 --> 02:09:14.246
VICE YOUR LUNCH SO CAUCUS ON
02:09:14.313 --> 02:09:16.615
BEHALF OF DOCTOR WHERE BRUISER
02:09:16.682 --> 02:09:20.452
CHEER IMPRISONED AB. TWENTY
02:09:20.519 --> 02:09:22.588
PLEASE TOP FORCED STUDY AND OF
02:09:22.654 --> 02:09:24.790
RAPPORT. PURPLE FOR THE
02:09:24.857 --> 02:09:25.757
DESCENDANTS OF AND PEOPLE HERE
02:09:25.824 --> 02:09:27.693
IN THE UNITED STATES THE TASK
02:09:27.759 --> 02:09:29.194
FORCE WILL CONSIST OF EIGHT.
02:09:29.261 --> 02:09:30.996
APPOINTED MEMBERS AND WILL
02:09:31.063 --> 02:09:33.232
COMPILE THE HISTORICAL RECORD A
02:09:33.298 --> 02:09:37.703
BLACK SLAVERY AND AFTERMATH IN
02:09:37.769 --> 02:09:38.737
CALIFORNIA AND THIS NATION. THE
02:09:38.804 --> 02:09:41.406
BILL WOULD BAR TASK FORCE
02:09:41.473 --> 02:09:42.741
DIRECT. CORPORATE WEIGHT
02:09:42.808 --> 02:09:43.942
RESPOND TO THE HISTORY OF IN
02:09:44.009 --> 02:09:46.011
SOME REMOTE BETWEEN CALIFORNIA
02:09:46.078 --> 02:09:48.313
STATEHOOD IN EIGHTEEN FIFTY AN
02:09:48.380 --> 02:09:51.416
END OF SLAVERY IN EIGHTEEN
02:09:51.483 --> 02:09:53.018
SIXTY FIVE CALIFORNIA. WAS A
02:09:53.085 --> 02:09:55.354
FREE STATE IN NAME ONLY NOW
02:09:55.420 --> 02:09:57.389
I'LL SAY THAT AGAIN IN NAME
02:09:57.456 --> 02:10:01.627
ONLY THE STATE. HE'S OUT POLICE
02:10:01.693 --> 02:10:05.864
OF. IN SLAVERY HEARING ALL FOR
02:10:05.931 --> 02:10:06.999
EXAMPLE THIS LED TO BY ALL
02:10:07.065 --> 02:10:09.501
SOUTHERN FLAVOR. THE WHOLE
02:10:09.568 --> 02:10:11.136
PEOPLE IN BONDAGE AS LONG AS
02:10:11.203 --> 02:10:13.605
HAD ENTERED THE STATE WHAT
02:10:13.672 --> 02:10:16.708
THEY'RE IN SLAVE PROPERTY ARE
02:10:16.775 --> 02:10:18.777
TO STATEHOOD. CALIFORNIA COURTS
02:10:18.844 --> 02:10:20.879
EARLY BY THREE FOR THOSE WHO
02:10:20.946 --> 02:10:23.982
DARED TO. THE BONDS OF SLAVERY
02:10:24.049 --> 02:10:27.319
IN CALIFORNIA. IN EIGHTEEN
02:10:27.386 --> 02:10:28.554
THIRTY TWO CALIFORNIA ADOPTED A
02:10:28.620 --> 02:10:31.056
HARSH FUGITIVE FUGITIVE SLAVE
02:10:31.123 --> 02:10:33.926
ACT IN PARMA STATE AND LOCAL
02:10:33.992 --> 02:10:36.495
LAW ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITIES TO
02:10:36.562 --> 02:10:39.631
FORCE SELF **** PERSONS. BACK
02:10:39.698 --> 02:10:41.800
INTO THE CHANGE AND ENSLAVEMENT
02:10:41.867 --> 02:10:44.336
THEY ALSO A PASSED THE USE OF
02:10:44.403 --> 02:10:46.371
DEADLY FORCE IN EIGHTEEN
02:10:46.438 --> 02:10:48.140
SEVENTY TWO ALSO IN RESPONSE TO
02:10:48.207 --> 02:10:50.709
FREEZE BLACK AMERICANS HERE IN
02:10:50.776 --> 02:10:52.611
CALIFORNIA THE CALIFORNIA
02:10:52.678 --> 02:10:54.112
SUPREME COURT ORDER FUGITIVE
02:10:54.179 --> 02:10:58.217
SLAVES. AS IS. STORE IN THIS
02:10:58.283 --> 02:10:58.817
STORE CASE SUCH AS SAY A PARTY
02:10:58.884 --> 02:11:00.953
LEE RETURNED TO THEIR IN
02:11:01.019 --> 02:11:04.022
FLAVORS IN DIRECT VIOLATION OF
02:11:04.089 --> 02:11:05.757
THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION
02:11:05.824 --> 02:11:07.960
UNTIL THE END OF THE U. S.
02:11:08.026 --> 02:11:08.961
CIVIL WAR LAW ENFORCEMENT IN
02:11:09.027 --> 02:11:14.199
CALIFORNIA. AND FOR ALL THIS ON.
02:11:14.266 --> 02:11:16.134
ALICIA CONTRACT LAY SYSTEM.
02:11:16.201 --> 02:11:18.837
ALLOWING ALL. HOLDERS TO
02:11:18.904 --> 02:11:20.405
EFFECTIVELY HOLD PERSONS IN
02:11:20.472 --> 02:11:24.009
BONDAGE FOR ANOTHER NAME. IN
02:11:24.076 --> 02:11:25.344
OTHER WORDS CALIFORNIA STATE
02:11:25.410 --> 02:11:27.212
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACTIVELY
02:11:27.279 --> 02:11:29.748
SUPPORTED BLOCKS SLAVERY TO SAY
02:11:29.815 --> 02:11:31.416
NOTHING OF THE MANY RACES
02:11:31.483 --> 02:11:33.385
POLICIES THAT CAME AFTERWARDS I
02:11:33.452 --> 02:11:34.519
COULD SEE IF WE RE IN THIS
02:11:34.586 --> 02:11:38.023
COUNTRY WAS BONDAGE OF ANOTHER
02:11:38.090 --> 02:11:40.225
COMBINE RACES AN EXCLUSIONARY
02:11:40.292 --> 02:11:42.894
LAW AND HOUSING. KING PATIENT
02:11:42.961 --> 02:11:45.364
ENFORCEMENT I'M IN SO MANY
02:11:45.430 --> 02:11:48.100
ASPECTS OF DAVID DAILY LIFE
02:11:48.166 --> 02:11:48.667
MANY OF WHICH STILL EXISTS
02:11:48.734 --> 02:11:52.504
TODAY. THE OWNER SAID AND IT'S
02:11:52.571 --> 02:11:55.407
JUST. THIS YEAR BLACK MAKE UP A
02:11:55.474 --> 02:11:59.411
PERCENT OF CALIFORNIA'S. OF 40%
02:11:59.478 --> 02:12:01.480
OF THE HOMELESS POPULATION.
02:12:01.546 --> 02:12:03.048
READY TO PUBLIC POLICY IN THE
02:12:03.115 --> 02:12:06.418
STATE INSTITUTE BLACK MEN ARE
02:12:06.485 --> 02:12:09.521
56% OF CALIFORNIA'S POPULATION
02:12:09.588 --> 02:12:11.390
BUT WE MAKE UP TWENTY EIGHT
02:12:11.456 --> 02:12:14.192
POINT FIVE PERCENT. OF THOSE
02:12:14.259 --> 02:12:15.861
INCARCERATED AND THE STATE.
02:12:15.927 --> 02:12:17.629
ACCORDING TO THE LA ALL BY
02:12:17.696 --> 02:12:20.098
NEARLY EVERY STATE MEASURE.
02:12:20.165 --> 02:12:22.234
BLACKS K. TO TWELVE STUDENTS
02:12:22.301 --> 02:12:24.236
HAVE A LORD'S PERFORMANCE OF
02:12:24.303 --> 02:12:26.538
ANY RACIAL OR ETHNIC GROUP AND
02:12:26.605 --> 02:12:31.143
THE STATE AND IT'S NOT BECAUSE
02:12:31.209 --> 02:12:31.643
THEY'RE NOT COMMITTED TO
02:12:31.710 --> 02:12:33.445
EDUCATION. EVIDENCE OF THE
02:12:33.512 --> 02:12:35.447
LEGACY OF SLOW WHITE SUPREMACY
02:12:35.514 --> 02:12:37.215
THAT STILL EXISTS IN THIS
02:12:37.282 --> 02:12:38.650
COUNTRY COLBERT NINETEEN SHED
02:12:38.717 --> 02:12:41.386
MORE LIGHT ON THESE PERSISTENT
02:12:41.453 --> 02:12:43.088
DISPARITIES. THE BILL A
02:12:43.155 --> 02:12:44.656
DISPROPORTIONATE BURDEN OF
02:12:44.723 --> 02:12:46.558
ILLNESS AND DEATH TO THE
02:12:46.625 --> 02:12:47.793
COLBERT NINETEEN HAS FALLEN
02:12:47.859 --> 02:12:49.761
DRASTICALLY ON THE BLACK
02:12:49.828 --> 02:12:51.863
COMMUNITY. AND SOME.
02:12:51.930 --> 02:12:53.899
DISPLACEMENT CREATED A LEGACY
02:12:53.965 --> 02:12:55.634
OF RACIAL INEQUALITY THAT
02:12:55.701 --> 02:12:57.936
CONTINUES TO MOUNT BLACK IMPACT
02:12:58.003 --> 02:13:00.072
BLACK PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA
02:13:00.138 --> 02:13:01.440
TODAY. THOSE WHO ARE COMES AMID
02:13:01.506 --> 02:13:03.675
JUSTICE AT THE HANDS OF OUR
02:13:03.742 --> 02:13:05.143
GOVERNMENT HAVE THE RIGHT TO
02:13:05.210 --> 02:13:08.113
REDRESS WHAT NOT GRANT. BUT
02:13:08.180 --> 02:13:11.350
PEOPLE A LESSER STANDARD. THIS
02:13:11.416 --> 02:13:13.985
BILL REQUIRES AN IN DEPTH
02:13:14.052 --> 02:13:14.686
REVIEW OF THE IMPACT OF
02:13:14.753 --> 02:13:17.923
SLAVERY. AND IN CALIFORNIA
02:13:17.989 --> 02:13:18.590
INCREASE THE FRAMEWORK TO
02:13:18.657 --> 02:13:21.526
ADDRESS THE SHAMEFUL HIS. I
02:13:21.593 --> 02:13:22.861
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE
02:13:22.928 --> 02:13:25.263
TODAY WE HAVE WITNESSES ANTONIO
02:13:25.330 --> 02:13:29.801
MORE AND DOCTOR CAN JUST WATSON.
02:13:29.868 --> 02:13:33.004
THANK YOU SENATOR. OF AGAIN I
02:13:33.071 --> 02:13:34.406
NEED TO REITERATE THAT DUE TO
02:13:34.473 --> 02:13:36.041
THE CONSTRAINTS REGARDING THE
02:13:36.108 --> 02:13:38.143
LENGTH OF HEARINGS TECHNOLOGY
02:13:38.210 --> 02:13:39.378
CONSIDERATIONS AND CLEANING
02:13:39.444 --> 02:13:41.880
PROTOCOLS THE COMMITTEES ARE
02:13:41.947 --> 02:13:44.282
ALL INSTITUTING TIME ON
02:13:44.349 --> 02:13:47.519
TESTIMONY ACCORDINGLY EACH SIDE
02:13:47.586 --> 02:13:50.088
WILL BE PERMITTED A TOTAL OF
02:13:50.155 --> 02:13:52.524
THREE MINUTES. ALL OTHER WISH
02:13:52.591 --> 02:13:53.892
THE PHARMACIST THEIR COMMENTS
02:13:53.959 --> 02:13:56.695
TO THEIR NAME AFFILIATE IN M.
02:13:56.762 --> 02:13:58.830
POSITION ON THE MEASURE AS
02:13:58.897 --> 02:14:01.133
SHARON UNDER I WILL AGAIN
02:14:01.199 --> 02:14:05.437
REITERATE THE PHONE NUMBER. ONE
02:14:05.504 --> 02:14:11.943
EIGHT FOUR FOUR FOR.
02:14:12.010 --> 02:14:18.517
1-111-636-4184. FOUR TWO NINE
02:14:18.583 --> 02:14:19.151
ONE SIX THREE SIX FOUR. AND THE
02:14:19.217 --> 02:14:27.426
ACCESS CODE. IS SIX ONE. ONE
02:14:27.492 --> 02:14:32.464
ONE ONE SEVEN NINE THAT. SIX
02:14:32.531 --> 02:14:33.064
ONE ONE ONE ONE SEVEN NINE AND
02:14:33.131 --> 02:14:34.299
BEFORE WE PROCEED I'D LIKE TO
02:14:34.366 --> 02:14:37.402
HAVE SOME ASSISTANCE HERE- MY
02:14:37.469 --> 02:14:43.408
COMPUTER IS. NOT. FOCUSED ON
02:14:43.475 --> 02:14:44.876
OUR HEARING AND I NEED TO MAKE
02:14:44.943 --> 02:14:48.447
SURE THAT OUR- A MEMBER WHO IS
02:14:48.513 --> 02:14:50.649
PARTICIPATING REMOTELY IS ON
02:14:50.715 --> 02:15:05.597
OUR SCREEN. WELL. I DON'T KNOW
02:15:05.664 --> 02:15:11.837
WHERE WHERE THE OTHER. THANK
02:15:11.903 --> 02:15:16.842
YOU RIGHT THE I FULLY THERE'S
02:15:16.908 --> 02:15:17.442
SOMEONE WHO KNOWS WHAT'S GOING
02:15:17.509 --> 02:15:20.479
ON HERE. ALRIGHT WITH THAT. WE
02:15:20.545 --> 02:15:24.182
DO HAVE THOSE TWO WITNESSES AND
02:15:24.249 --> 02:15:25.183
I'D LIKE TO REMIND YOU A TOTAL
02:15:25.250 --> 02:15:27.686
OF THREE MINUTES. INTO IT
02:15:27.752 --> 02:15:29.020
WHOEVER IS FIRST WOULD YOU
02:15:29.087 --> 02:15:31.389
IDENTIFY YOURSELF AND PLEASE BE
02:15:31.456 --> 02:15:33.124
BEGIN YOUR TESTIMONY
02:15:33.191 --> 02:15:35.760
REMEMBERING THAT IT HAS TO BE
02:15:35.827 --> 02:15:39.831
SHARED SO WITH THAT WHO IS OUR
02:15:39.898 --> 02:15:41.900
FIRST. THIS TONYA MORE THANK
02:15:41.967 --> 02:15:43.368
YOU. ALLOW ME TO SPEAK ON
02:15:43.435 --> 02:15:44.436
BEHALF OF THE A LOS MOVEMENT IN
02:15:44.503 --> 02:15:46.171
AMERICAN THIS INTO SLAVERY
02:15:46.238 --> 02:15:47.572
ACROSS CALIFORNIA THE ISSUE OF
02:15:47.639 --> 02:15:49.508
RACISM IN CALIFORNIA CONNECTS
02:15:49.574 --> 02:15:50.842
TO A LARGER. ROLE LEVEL
02:15:50.909 --> 02:15:52.711
DISCRIMINATION FROM SLAVERY TO
02:15:52.777 --> 02:15:55.013
BRED LINING THE RESULT IN COST.
02:15:55.080 --> 02:15:57.349
RELATED OF MINUTES WHAT ANY
02:15:57.415 --> 02:15:59.985
QUALITY AT EIGHT THIRTY ONE
02:16:00.051 --> 02:16:02.954
TWENTY ONE WELL I JUST IN. THE
02:16:03.021 --> 02:16:05.457
INTEREST OF THE FREE. WE MEET
02:16:05.524 --> 02:16:09.794
THE FRAME OF THE STATE. THIS IS
02:16:09.861 --> 02:16:11.496
THE DENIAL OF SOFT OF OTHER AND
02:16:11.563 --> 02:16:14.466
RIGHT. SOME EVEN AT NIGHT ALL
02:16:14.533 --> 02:16:15.800
AFTER AMERICAN CAL. CALIFORNIA
02:16:15.867 --> 02:16:18.136
E. HAD A FEW SAVE FLAG
02:16:18.203 --> 02:16:19.371
MENTIONED EARLIER THIS ANY PER
02:16:19.437 --> 02:16:21.973
BROUGHT CAL PLEASE STAY OF THIS
02:16:22.040 --> 02:16:23.008
WOULD BE CONSIDERED A SLAVE THE
02:16:23.074 --> 02:16:25.243
ARE THE LAW EVEN THOUGH THE
02:16:25.310 --> 02:16:31.516
CALIPHATE TUITION BANDS IN THE.
02:16:31.583 --> 02:16:32.484
OUR OF BLACKS BROUGHT
02:16:32.551 --> 02:16:34.953
CALIFORNIA GOLD RUSH THE RESULT
02:16:35.020 --> 02:16:36.087
ACROSS IT CAN THAT COULD
02:16:36.154 --> 02:16:38.823
AMERICAN WITH THIS HAVE IN THE
02:16:38.890 --> 02:16:40.992
BENEFIT RAN WELL DO THAT
02:16:41.059 --> 02:16:43.495
BECAUSE C<c.cyan> ACCORDING TO CAL</c>
02:16:43.562 --> 02:16:47.832
MATTER BOARD ARTICLE IN TOLD
02:16:47.899 --> 02:16:52.637
BLACK X. BLACK POPULAR. BY
02:16:52.704 --> 02:16:55.106
PERCENT OF THE FORTY. IN
02:16:55.173 --> 02:16:56.942
ADDITION A REPORT CALLED COLOR
02:16:57.008 --> 02:17:01.479
WELL DONE BY YOU BUT LOS BY DO
02:17:01.546 --> 02:17:03.315
IN THE PHOTO RESERVE FOR THE
02:17:03.381 --> 02:17:05.584
REFLECT SHOWN THE WHITE FAMILY
02:17:05.650 --> 02:17:07.953
LAFAYETTE AND WORK THREE
02:17:08.019 --> 02:17:08.520
HUNDRED FIFTY FIVE THOUSAND
02:17:08.587 --> 02:17:10.388
HARD I SAID THE MIDDLE EAST
02:17:10.455 --> 02:17:13.625
ASIA. FOR A SIXTY THOUSAND PART
02:17:13.692 --> 02:17:17.562
IN OUR- LITTLE. FIVE THOUSAND
02:17:17.629 --> 02:17:18.096
EVEN THE MIDDLE ACT BLACK
02:17:18.163 --> 02:17:19.497
FAMILIES WORK A HUNDRED AND
02:17:19.564 --> 02:17:21.266
SIXTY THOUSAND PART IN SIXTY
02:17:21.333 --> 02:17:22.434
THOUSAND LOOKING THE MIDDLE
02:17:22.500 --> 02:17:24.603
NATIVE A OS FAMILY IN THE STATE
02:17:24.669 --> 02:17:27.339
OF LOS IS WORK A MERE TWO
02:17:27.405 --> 02:17:31.343
HUNDRED LIKE WE- OUT. HEART THE
02:17:31.409 --> 02:17:33.745
WAY THE MATING THAT WE WERE FOR
02:17:33.812 --> 02:17:35.814
TO AMERICA THIS IS OF LIKE AB
02:17:35.880 --> 02:17:36.581
THIRTY WILL TWENTY ONE AND I
02:17:36.648 --> 02:17:40.085
WAS ASK YOU WELL I ONLY BE
02:17:40.151 --> 02:17:40.652
THIRTY TWENTY ONE THANK YOU
02:17:40.719 --> 02:17:43.154
SIR- CONNECT IS AFTER CAN JUST
02:17:43.221 --> 02:17:45.991
WATSON OF THE RALPH J. BUNCHE I
02:17:46.057 --> 02:17:49.794
BELIEVE IT'S PRONOUNCED CENTER
02:17:49.861 --> 02:17:51.563
FOR AFRICAN KANNST BE SURE YOU
02:17:51.630 --> 02:17:55.967
SEE I GOT ABOUT A MINUTE SIR.
02:17:56.034 --> 02:17:58.970
PAUL NO THANK YOU. YOUR HONOR
02:17:59.037 --> 02:18:02.173
THE YEAH BUT THE ON THE OF AN
02:18:02.240 --> 02:18:03.675
THE BOARD OF THE BY THEN I'M
02:18:03.742 --> 02:18:05.110
ACTUALLY THE RESEARCH LAB AT
02:18:05.176 --> 02:18:06.911
HEALTH NET WE RESEARCH LAB IN
02:18:06.978 --> 02:18:11.116
THE BY DEPARTMENT AT STATE. AND
02:18:11.182 --> 02:18:13.251
THE CENTER AND I. TELL WHAT THE
02:18:13.318 --> 02:18:16.021
FREE STATE IN NAME ONLY. AND
02:18:16.087 --> 02:18:17.689
THESE. RARELY SIGHTED REALITY
02:18:17.756 --> 02:18:20.959
THERE OR A FEW THEM STORE GOAL
02:18:21.026 --> 02:18:22.394
AND EXPOSE WE CAN BLACK CALL
02:18:22.460 --> 02:18:24.329
THEM CRACK. THAT IN THE ON
02:18:24.396 --> 02:18:26.264
GOING EVERY DAY NEXT. THE ON
02:18:26.331 --> 02:18:31.102
BLACK WELL WELL THAT ARE. THE
02:18:31.169 --> 02:18:33.438
SO INCLUDES THE EXPAND TO DO IN.
02:18:33.505 --> 02:18:36.041
PERSON IT. THE BLACK PEOPLE.
02:18:36.107 --> 02:18:40.245
AND IF THEY IN ORDER THEM. WAS
02:18:40.311 --> 02:18:41.379
MENTIONED EARLIER ALBUMS A RED
02:18:41.446 --> 02:18:44.816
LINE. WITH THE DON'T CALLED.
02:18:44.883 --> 02:18:45.884
AND REALLY GIVE BEFORE CALL
02:18:45.950 --> 02:18:47.919
NIGHT. THANK YOU KIND TO ME
02:18:47.986 --> 02:18:49.421
SPIKE ALL THE HEALTH CARE FOR
02:18:49.487 --> 02:18:51.056
THE GENERAL. OUR LIFE THE- OF
02:18:51.122 --> 02:18:53.858
BLACK REMAIN PEOPLE THAT DECADE
02:18:53.925 --> 02:18:55.727
HAVE BLACK PEOPLE IN OUR MUCH
02:18:55.794 --> 02:18:57.629
LESS PEOPLE. THREE OF HIGHER
02:18:57.696 --> 02:18:59.097
RATE THE MARKET AND MORE THE
02:18:59.164 --> 02:19:03.802
THERE. THREE OUT WELL AS LONG
02:19:03.868 --> 02:19:06.004
THE ANY ABUSE BY WE AGENT. THAT
02:19:06.071 --> 02:19:07.405
RECORD CASH HOW UNDERMINE BLACK
02:19:07.472 --> 02:19:09.474
LIKE THANK YOU THE OUR NEXT.
02:19:09.541 --> 02:19:11.943
FROM THE- OUT OF RIGHTLY FOR
02:19:12.010 --> 02:19:14.045
THE LIFE ON LOOKING FOR BLACK
02:19:14.112 --> 02:19:15.880
LAW. I THINK ASSERTION THAT THE
02:19:15.947 --> 02:19:17.048
CONDITION THAT THEY NOT BEEN.
02:19:17.115 --> 02:19:19.984
BY THE OF OUR OUT ARE BLATANT
02:19:20.051 --> 02:19:21.986
YOU DOOR FOR INCREDIBLY CAR.
02:19:22.053 --> 02:19:25.390
THE FACT ONLY. SHOWED THAT- THE
02:19:25.457 --> 02:19:27.358
ENVOYS. FROM PLAYED THREE IF
02:19:27.425 --> 02:19:30.762
THEY- HELD THE BLACK PEOPLE. I
02:19:30.829 --> 02:19:33.732
HAVE ENOUGH. HERE TO ENGAGE IN
02:19:33.798 --> 02:19:35.834
A STUDY OF HOW WE MIGHT USE THE
02:19:35.900 --> 02:19:40.672
REDIRECT THE FAR. RIGHT DOCTOR
02:19:40.739 --> 02:19:44.509
WHAT. BLACKROCK IS WE CALL ON
02:19:44.576 --> 02:19:47.345
ALL OF THE FOR ITS PASSAGE THE
02:19:47.412 --> 02:19:49.614
LEGISLATIVE. THE DE AND BREADTH
02:19:49.681 --> 02:19:51.316
EVIDENCE THAT WILL CONSIDER
02:19:51.382 --> 02:19:53.151
CRITICAL ISSUE IS GIVEN IT NEW
02:19:53.218 --> 02:19:56.855
CAR AND CAUGHT THANK YOU SIR.
02:19:56.921 --> 02:19:59.224
YOUR TEST. BARD AT THIS IN TIME
02:19:59.290 --> 02:20:01.493
IF WE HAVE PEOPLE WHO WOULD
02:20:01.559 --> 02:20:06.131
LIKE TO SPEAK OF IT WERE IN
02:20:06.197 --> 02:20:08.566
ROOM FORTY TWO OH THREE IF YOU
02:20:08.633 --> 02:20:10.668
WHICH GIVE YOUR NAME AND YOUR
02:20:10.735 --> 02:20:13.037
AFFILIATION AND YOUR POSITION
02:20:13.104 --> 02:20:17.942
ON THE BILL. YEAH YOU'RE ON THE
02:20:18.009 --> 02:20:19.411
MARKET EIGHT IN FACT WERE
02:20:19.477 --> 02:20:21.346
PROBABLY DOES CALIFORNIA AND I
02:20:21.412 --> 02:20:25.150
STRONGLY SUPPORT AT THIRTY ONE
02:20:25.216 --> 02:20:26.351
TWENTY ONE PLEASE VOTE YES
02:20:26.417 --> 02:20:29.454
THANK YOU MA'AM. NEXT WITNESS.
02:20:29.521 --> 02:20:31.823
CHRIS LAWSON BABY IS MADE A
02:20:31.890 --> 02:20:33.258
DEAL WITH SACRAMENTO EIGHTY WAS
02:20:33.324 --> 02:20:35.693
CALIFORNIA ARE STRONGLY
02:20:35.760 --> 02:20:36.661
SUPPORTED ME THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:20:36.728 --> 02:20:38.163
ONE PLEASE HOLD ON. THANK YOU
02:20:38.229 --> 02:20:39.364
IT'S SO NICE TO HAVE LIVE
02:20:39.430 --> 02:20:41.633
BODIES HERE WE WELCOME YOU AND
02:20:41.699 --> 02:20:43.868
THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE AND
02:20:43.935 --> 02:20:45.503
WILLINGNESS TO TESTIFY. DO WE
02:20:45.570 --> 02:20:48.807
HAVE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM FORTY
02:20:48.873 --> 02:20:50.441
TWO OH THREE. SEEING NOT LET'S
02:20:50.508 --> 02:20:52.510
GO ROOM TWENTY FORTY. DO WE
02:20:52.577 --> 02:20:55.480
HAVE ANY WITNESSES WILLING AND
02:20:55.547 --> 02:20:57.949
WANTING TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT.
02:20:58.016 --> 02:21:01.386
SHOWING NON LET'S GO TO-
02:21:01.452 --> 02:21:03.121
WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY
02:21:03.188 --> 02:21:04.455
VIA THE TELEPHONE CONFERENCE
02:21:04.522 --> 02:21:06.858
SERVICE. MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
02:21:06.925 --> 02:21:08.526
PLEASE PROMPT INDIVIDUALS
02:21:08.593 --> 02:21:10.962
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
02:21:11.029 --> 02:21:13.131
OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE. WE
02:21:13.198 --> 02:21:15.333
WILL BEGIN WILL GIVE YOU A FEW
02:21:15.400 --> 02:21:16.935
MOMENTS TO DO THAT AND THEN IF
02:21:17.001 --> 02:21:18.570
YOU WOULD IDENTIFY HOW MANY
02:21:18.636 --> 02:21:21.206
PEOPLE WE HAVE IN THE QUEUE. IN
02:21:21.272 --> 02:21:24.142
SUPPORT THAT WOULD BE GREAT.
02:21:24.209 --> 02:21:25.810
THANK YOU IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
02:21:25.877 --> 02:21:28.813
IN SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY ONE
02:21:28.880 --> 02:21:30.014
TWENTY ONE PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
02:21:30.081 --> 02:21:50.635
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
02:22:06.618 --> 02:22:06.684
META
02:22:06.751 --> 02:22:09.454
MODERATOR COULD YOU PLEASE GIVE
02:22:09.520 --> 02:22:10.688
US A TOTAL OF THE NUMBER OF
02:22:10.755 --> 02:22:12.991
PEOPLE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
02:22:13.057 --> 02:22:17.195
SUPPORT. THANK YOU WE HAVE
02:22:17.262 --> 02:22:20.465
ABOUT SEVENTY FOUR IN Q.
02:22:20.531 --> 02:22:26.404
SEVENTY FOUR. TO GET THE RIGHT.
02:22:26.471 --> 02:22:27.038
SEVEN FOUR. I'M SORRY I DIDN'T
02:22:27.105 --> 02:22:28.673
HEAR AYE AYE SIR SAID IN HERE
02:22:28.740 --> 02:22:31.943
THE NUMBER SEVENTY FOUR OKAY
02:22:32.010 --> 02:22:33.645
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT WELL. HERE
02:22:33.711 --> 02:22:36.748
WE GO MADEMOISELLE MODERATOR.
02:22:36.814 --> 02:22:40.351
PLEASE OPEN THE LINES AND CALL
02:22:40.418 --> 02:22:40.818
THE SUPPORT WITNESSES
02:22:40.885 --> 02:22:57.535
INDIVIDUALLY. YEAH. NINE ONE
02:22:57.602 --> 02:23:02.807
FIVE THREE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
02:23:02.874 --> 02:23:04.309
PLEASE GO AHEAD AND PROCEED
02:23:04.375 --> 02:23:06.911
AGAIN FOLKS NAME AFFILIATION
02:23:06.978 --> 02:23:09.714
AND POSITION YES NO ON THE
02:23:09.781 --> 02:23:12.116
BILL- ACTUALLY RIGHT NOW WHICH
02:23:12.183 --> 02:23:15.520
IS TAKING THOSE IN SUPPORT SO
02:23:15.586 --> 02:23:16.154
IF YOU GO AHEAD META MODERATE.
02:23:16.220 --> 02:23:18.690
IF YOU. THANK YOU WHAT ARE
02:23:18.756 --> 02:23:24.462
TRYING TO FORTY PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:23:24.529 --> 02:23:25.863
POSTED CURSING THE CALIFORNIA
02:23:25.930 --> 02:23:28.533
NURSES ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT
02:23:28.599 --> 02:23:31.436
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:23:31.502 --> 02:23:33.171
YOU I AM TO FORTY FIVE PLEASE
02:23:33.237 --> 02:23:38.843
GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS JIM
02:23:38.910 --> 02:23:40.812
LIMBURG ON BEHALF OF THE
02:23:40.878 --> 02:23:41.279
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON
02:23:41.346 --> 02:23:44.849
LEGISLATION OF CALIFORNIANS.
02:23:44.916 --> 02:23:45.416
THANK YOU THANK YOU SIR NEXT
02:23:45.483 --> 02:23:51.122
WITNESS. THANK YOU A RIDE IN A
02:23:51.189 --> 02:23:53.925
ONE FORTY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:23:53.992 --> 02:23:55.193
HEY THIS IS A VERY CHAU SPREAD
02:23:55.259 --> 02:23:56.494
BECAUSE I'M WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:23:56.561 --> 02:23:59.197
DEMOCRATIC PARTY AFRICAN
02:23:59.263 --> 02:24:01.899
AMERICAN CAUCUS AND AB YOU KNOW
02:24:01.966 --> 02:24:04.502
BAKER. AND I WOULD LIKE YOU TO
02:24:04.569 --> 02:24:07.505
SUPPORT AB THREE ONE EIGHT TWO
02:24:07.572 --> 02:24:09.807
ONE. THANK YOU MA'AM NEXT
02:24:09.874 --> 02:24:13.878
WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE ONE OH
02:24:13.945 --> 02:24:16.114
EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD. JERRY
02:24:16.180 --> 02:24:17.348
BROWN BELINDA FOR THE
02:24:17.415 --> 02:24:20.184
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
02:24:20.251 --> 02:24:22.153
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. NEXT
02:24:22.220 --> 02:24:27.225
WITNESS. THANK YOU ALL RIGHT OF
02:24:27.291 --> 02:24:30.261
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:24:30.328 --> 02:24:31.462
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS
02:24:31.529 --> 02:24:33.698
BENJAMIN TRANTER THE CALIFORNIA
02:24:33.765 --> 02:24:34.465
PAN ETHNIC HEALTH NETWORK IN
02:24:34.532 --> 02:24:39.504
SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:24:39.570 --> 02:24:41.372
THANK YOU LYING TO NINETEEN
02:24:41.439 --> 02:24:44.842
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR
02:24:44.909 --> 02:24:46.744
AND MEMBERS OF THE ASSEMBLY
02:24:46.811 --> 02:24:48.446
SHOP ON BEHALF OF THE
02:24:48.513 --> 02:24:50.415
CALIFORNIA FACULTY ASSOCIATION
02:24:50.481 --> 02:24:53.151
AND IN ADDITION ON BEHALF OF
02:24:53.217 --> 02:24:54.685
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES MAYOR
02:24:54.752 --> 02:24:57.055
ERIC GARCETTI BOTH IN FRONT THE
02:24:57.121 --> 02:24:58.790
PART OF THE MEASURE THANK YOU
02:24:58.856 --> 02:25:02.527
THANK YOU WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
02:25:02.593 --> 02:25:03.895
YOU I'M TO TWENTY TO PLEASE GO
02:25:03.961 --> 02:25:08.633
AHEAD. JUSTIN ROUSER ON BEHALF
02:25:08.699 --> 02:25:10.768
OF ROOTS OF CHANGE ALSO IN
02:25:10.835 --> 02:25:12.870
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:25:12.937 --> 02:25:15.873
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:25:15.940 --> 02:25:17.708
LINE TO TWENTY SIX PLEASE GO
02:25:17.775 --> 02:25:21.546
AHEAD. ARIANNA ACOSTA ON BEHALF
02:25:21.612 --> 02:25:23.481
OF THE ACLU OF CALIFORNIA IS
02:25:23.548 --> 02:25:25.883
DONE BEFORE THANK YOU NEXT
02:25:25.950 --> 02:25:29.987
WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M FIFTY
02:25:30.054 --> 02:25:38.162
SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD. WIND WIND
02:25:38.229 --> 02:25:40.832
FIFTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:25:40.898 --> 02:25:44.735
HELLO WE HEAR YOU GO HEAD OKAY
02:25:44.802 --> 02:25:46.704
HI MY NAME IS KIM DIRE I'M WITH
02:25:46.771 --> 02:25:48.806
A DEAL WITH LOS ANGELES AND I
02:25:48.873 --> 02:25:51.309
SUPPORT AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:25:51.375 --> 02:25:53.044
ONE AND I STRONGLY URGE YOU TO
02:25:53.111 --> 02:25:55.279
VOTE YEAH INDIA THANK YOU NEXT
02:25:55.346 --> 02:25:59.817
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU RYAN
02:25:59.884 --> 02:26:00.351
ONE NINETY SEVEN PLEASE GO
02:26:00.418 --> 02:26:03.921
AHEAD. MY NAME IS JAN LOCAL
02:26:03.988 --> 02:26:06.724
MODEL A MEMBER OF NICKI
02:26:06.791 --> 02:26:08.526
PROGRESSES- ORGANIZATION IN LOS
02:26:08.593 --> 02:26:10.628
ANGELES I AM AT THE BORDER AND
02:26:10.695 --> 02:26:13.931
EIGHTY OS AND I SUPPORT AB
02:26:13.998 --> 02:26:14.499
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE
02:26:14.565 --> 02:26:17.135
VOTE YES ON THE BILL. THANK YOU
02:26:17.201 --> 02:26:20.571
MAN NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:26:20.638 --> 02:26:22.106
LINE ONE NINETY TWO PLEASE GO
02:26:22.173 --> 02:26:26.110
AHEAD. I CAN HEAR ME YES WE CAN
02:26:26.177 --> 02:26:29.313
HEAR YOU. OKAY MY NAME IS
02:26:29.380 --> 02:26:32.150
KIMBERLY HUDSON AND I AM A PART
02:26:32.216 --> 02:26:34.152
OF EIGHTY OR ITS ME AREA AND I
02:26:34.218 --> 02:26:37.288
SUPPORT MAYBE THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:26:37.355 --> 02:26:39.390
ONE SO PLEASE VERY. STRONG TO
02:26:39.457 --> 02:26:41.425
VOTE FIVE THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE
02:26:41.492 --> 02:26:44.262
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:26:44.328 --> 02:26:46.531
WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE ONE ON
02:26:46.597 --> 02:26:50.067
ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD OF ME.
02:26:50.134 --> 02:26:52.103
HELLO THIS IS. TIFFANY
02:26:52.170 --> 02:26:53.237
QUARRELSOME EIGHTY ONE
02:26:53.304 --> 02:26:55.373
LAFAYETTE. CLEAN VOTE YEAH ON
02:26:55.439 --> 02:26:57.241
AB ONE FOR ONE THANK YOU THANK
02:26:57.308 --> 02:27:01.245
YOU NAY WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM
02:27:01.312 --> 02:27:03.247
SEVENTY SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:27:03.314 --> 02:27:05.750
HELLO MY NAME IS ANGELA NIRVANA
02:27:05.816 --> 02:27:08.052
WITH A DEAL WAS SOLD CAL AND I
02:27:08.119 --> 02:27:11.422
SUPPORT SB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:27:11.489 --> 02:27:12.523
ONE PLEASE VOTE YES ON THIS
02:27:12.590 --> 02:27:15.092
BILL THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:27:15.159 --> 02:27:18.296
WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM TO
02:27:18.362 --> 02:27:21.165
SEVEN PLEASE OR HAD. HELLO MY
02:27:21.232 --> 02:27:22.833
NAME IS CHAD BROWN WITH RADIO
02:27:22.900 --> 02:27:24.569
AS LOS ANGELES I'M ALSO A
02:27:24.635 --> 02:27:26.337
MEMBER OF THE SAN FERNANDO
02:27:26.404 --> 02:27:27.572
VALLEY THE CHAPTER OF THE IN
02:27:27.638 --> 02:27:31.576
THE LACI P. I SUPPORT SB THIRTY
02:27:31.642 --> 02:27:32.176
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE VOTE YES
02:27:32.243 --> 02:27:33.744
ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU SIR
02:27:33.811 --> 02:27:38.082
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU RYAN
02:27:38.149 --> 02:27:40.985
EIGHTY SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:27:41.052 --> 02:27:44.288
HI TO THE JUST I WILL WITH ANY-
02:27:44.355 --> 02:27:47.024
OS CAL AB- AS AREA AND STRONG
02:27:47.091 --> 02:27:49.327
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:27:49.393 --> 02:27:51.229
ONE THESE ALL YES THANK YOU
02:27:51.295 --> 02:27:54.365
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:27:54.432 --> 02:27:55.700
YOU RIDE ONE SEVENTY FOUR
02:27:55.766 --> 02:28:01.772
PLEASE GO AHEAD. STE HI THIS IS
02:28:01.839 --> 02:28:04.275
COUNTY JOHN MUHAMMAD MEMBER OF
02:28:04.342 --> 02:28:05.643
EIGHT US LOS ANGELES NEW
02:28:05.710 --> 02:28:07.545
FRONTIER DAM CLOUT BLACK WOMEN
02:28:07.612 --> 02:28:09.480
SAM CLUB AND THE END OF LIFE
02:28:09.547 --> 02:28:12.783
THE P. IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE
02:28:12.850 --> 02:28:13.317
ONE TWO ONE THREE VOTE YET
02:28:13.384 --> 02:28:15.519
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:28:15.586 --> 02:28:18.889
WITNESS. THANK YOU RYAN FIFTY
02:28:18.956 --> 02:28:22.026
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:28:22.093 --> 02:28:24.328
EVE BOUCHER WITH A. B. O. S.
02:28:24.395 --> 02:28:26.964
LOS ANGELES AND I SUPPORT AB
02:28:27.031 --> 02:28:28.799
ONE TWO ONE POLICE VOTE YES ON
02:28:28.866 --> 02:28:30.368
THIS BILL THANK YOU NEXT
02:28:30.434 --> 02:28:34.505
WITNESS. THANK YOU I ONE THIRTY
02:28:34.572 --> 02:28:36.907
SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:28:36.974 --> 02:28:38.876
AFTERNOON MY NAME IS A MARA
02:28:38.943 --> 02:28:41.646
WILSON WITH EIGHTY OS
02:28:41.712 --> 02:28:43.347
CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
02:28:43.414 --> 02:28:45.216
AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE
02:28:45.283 --> 02:28:46.717
VOTE YET. THANK YOU NEXT
02:28:46.784 --> 02:28:51.589
WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM AT TO
02:28:51.656 --> 02:28:55.059
PLEASE GO ADDED. THANK YOU HI
02:28:55.126 --> 02:28:57.194
MY NAME IS LISA JORDAN AND I'D
02:28:57.261 --> 02:28:58.663
LIKE TO ASK THE SENATE TO VOTE
02:28:58.729 --> 02:29:01.732
YES ON A. B. THREE ONE TWO ONE
02:29:01.799 --> 02:29:02.833
ON BEHALF OF A DEAL AT LOS
02:29:02.900 --> 02:29:05.303
ANGELES THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:29:05.369 --> 02:29:09.974
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU RIDE A
02:29:10.041 --> 02:29:12.677
ONE FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:29:12.743 --> 02:29:14.345
A GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
02:29:14.412 --> 02:29:17.014
MONIQUE QUARRELS AND I STRONGLY
02:29:17.081 --> 02:29:19.050
SUPPORT AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:29:19.116 --> 02:29:21.018
ONE PLEASE VOTE YES. THANK YOU
02:29:21.085 --> 02:29:25.256
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM AT
02:29:25.323 --> 02:29:34.999
PLEASE GO AHEAD. WELL I AM AT
02:29:35.066 --> 02:29:38.636
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO WE HEAR
02:29:38.703 --> 02:29:44.008
YOU. OKAY SORRY I AM- MINUTE
02:29:44.075 --> 02:29:44.842
WORKING HERE THAT CONSTRUCTING
02:29:44.909 --> 02:29:47.378
THUNDERING DOWN IT'S ABOUT JB
02:29:47.445 --> 02:29:50.214
KEY IT YOU KNOW AT THE LOS
02:29:50.281 --> 02:29:59.490
ANGELES. EIGHTY THREE TWO THREE
02:29:59.557 --> 02:30:00.091
ONE TWO ONE BUT BUILT. THANK
02:30:00.157 --> 02:30:02.393
YOU SIR NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:30:02.460 --> 02:30:03.361
RIGHT A ONE FORTY PLEASE GO
02:30:03.427 --> 02:30:07.865
AHEAD. HELLO THIS IS TARA PERRY
02:30:07.932 --> 02:30:09.300
NINE A MEMBER OF A DEALER SO
02:30:09.367 --> 02:30:11.102
CAL EIGHTY L. S. CALIFORNIA
02:30:11.168 --> 02:30:13.237
BLACK PACKED DOT ORG I STRONGLY
02:30:13.304 --> 02:30:16.507
URGE FOR AN IDLE ON EIGHTY
02:30:16.574 --> 02:30:17.875
THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK YOU SO
02:30:17.942 --> 02:30:19.243
MUCH THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT
02:30:19.310 --> 02:30:23.280
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU RYAN TO
02:30:23.347 --> 02:30:26.817
FORTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:30:26.884 --> 02:30:29.353
HELLO MY NAME IS JANET TAYLOR I
02:30:29.420 --> 02:30:31.155
AM A SUPPORTER OF AGL LAST AND
02:30:31.222 --> 02:30:34.525
I SUPPORT EIGHTY THREE ONE TWO
02:30:34.592 --> 02:30:35.092
ONE PLEASE VOTE YES ON THE
02:30:35.159 --> 02:30:38.362
BILL. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:30:38.429 --> 02:30:40.064
THANK YOU RYAN TO FORTY EIGHT
02:30:40.131 --> 02:30:43.033
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI CAN YOU
02:30:43.100 --> 02:30:45.469
HEAR ME LITTLE LOUDER WE CAN
02:30:45.536 --> 02:30:49.106
HEAR YOU. OKAY HI MY NAME IS
02:30:49.173 --> 02:30:51.041
DAN WILLIAMS I'M WITH EIGHT OFF
02:30:51.108 --> 02:30:53.344
AT ALL AT BLOCKS AND WITH IT
02:30:53.411 --> 02:30:55.880
THE PORT OF AB THREE ONE THREE
02:30:55.946 --> 02:30:57.081
ONE PLEASE VOTE YES ON A. B.
02:30:57.148 --> 02:31:01.085
THREE ONE. THANK YOU WITNESS.
02:31:01.152 --> 02:31:02.686
THANK YOU RYAN ONE TWENTY
02:31:02.753 --> 02:31:12.263
PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE ONE
02:31:12.329 --> 02:31:22.039
TWENTY PLEASE GO AHEAD. LET'S
02:31:22.106 --> 02:31:23.974
MOVE ON META MODERATE MY NUMBER.
02:31:24.041 --> 02:31:25.843
THANK YOU AYE NUMBER SEVENTY
02:31:25.910 --> 02:31:29.013
NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. YOU GOOD
02:31:29.079 --> 02:31:31.015
AFTERNOON EVERYONE MY NAME IS
02:31:31.081 --> 02:31:33.050
BEVERLY SOUTHERN WHEN I'M WITH
02:31:33.117 --> 02:31:35.653
HBO AT ANGELES N. A. B. O. AT
02:31:35.719 --> 02:31:38.355
CALIFORNIA AS WELL AS IN THE
02:31:38.422 --> 02:31:41.225
BLADE THE P. PASADENA I
02:31:41.292 --> 02:31:47.131
STRONGLY SUPPORT A. B. THIRTY
02:31:47.198 --> 02:31:48.999
ONE TWENTY ONE AND I STRONG
02:31:49.066 --> 02:31:56.140
URGE. ON FIND. THANK YOU RIDE
02:31:56.207 --> 02:31:57.842
ONE NINETY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:31:57.908 --> 02:32:03.147
I YES INDEED THANK YOU. MY NAME
02:32:03.214 --> 02:32:04.648
IS ON YOUR MAC ROYAL HIGH
02:32:04.715 --> 02:32:06.817
SCHOOL STUDENT IN LOS ANGELES
02:32:06.884 --> 02:32:11.288
AND I SUPPORT A. B. THE ONE
02:32:11.355 --> 02:32:12.590
TWENTY ONE. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:32:12.656 --> 02:32:16.994
WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M TO
02:32:17.061 --> 02:32:24.735
THIRTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD. WELL.
02:32:24.802 --> 02:32:26.704
LINE TWO HNDRED AND THIRTEEN
02:32:26.770 --> 02:32:29.473
PLEASE GO AHEAD OKAY YOU GET
02:32:29.540 --> 02:32:31.542
CAN YOU HEAR ME YES INDEED.
02:32:31.609 --> 02:32:33.611
OKAY YEAH RAY FOR EVERY DAY
02:32:33.677 --> 02:32:35.613
QUARRELED EIGHT O'CLOCK SANDERS
02:32:35.679 --> 02:32:37.414
WITH BOMB WILL ARGUE TO VOTE
02:32:37.481 --> 02:32:40.184
YES ON THE BILL THANK YOU THANK
02:32:40.251 --> 02:32:43.187
YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:32:43.254 --> 02:32:45.289
LINE TWO HUNDRED AND FORTY ONE
02:32:45.356 --> 02:32:48.259
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS IS
02:32:48.325 --> 02:32:49.960
MICHAEL THOMAS WITH A YOURS
02:32:50.027 --> 02:32:52.162
CALIFORNIA AND I AM PART OF
02:32:52.229 --> 02:32:54.532
THE- A DEALER SAN DIEGO BRANCH
02:32:54.598 --> 02:32:56.433
AND ALSO A MEMBER OF BAY PACKS
02:32:56.500 --> 02:32:59.103
AND YEAR AGO AND ALSO A MEMBER
02:32:59.169 --> 02:33:01.438
OF AND DOUBLE ACP. SAN DIEGO
02:33:01.505 --> 02:33:03.841
BRANCH- I URGE YOU TO VOTE YES
02:33:03.908 --> 02:33:07.077
ON A. B. THREE TWO ONE TWO
02:33:07.144 --> 02:33:09.013
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:33:09.079 --> 02:33:13.017
WITNESS. THANK YOU LYING TO
02:33:13.083 --> 02:33:20.524
TWENTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:33:20.591 --> 02:33:22.359
LINE TWO TWO EIGHT PLEASE GO
02:33:22.426 --> 02:33:32.803
AHEAD. ONE OF ON THE LINE
02:33:32.870 --> 02:33:35.139
SEVENTY FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:33:35.205 --> 02:33:37.141
HELLO MY NAME IS FIELD COMMENTS
02:33:37.207 --> 02:33:38.309
AND I'M WITH EIGHT US
02:33:38.375 --> 02:33:41.445
CALIFORNIA AND EIGHTY- SO CAL
02:33:41.512 --> 02:33:44.081
AND I SUPPORT AB THIRTY ONE
02:33:44.148 --> 02:33:44.949
TWENTY ONE AND I URGE YOU ALL
02:33:45.015 --> 02:33:46.550
TO VOTE YES ON THIS BILL THANK
02:33:46.617 --> 02:33:50.521
YOU THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:33:50.588 --> 02:33:52.056
THANK YOU LINE FIFTY TWO PLEASE
02:33:52.122 --> 02:33:55.025
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON MY
02:33:55.092 --> 02:33:57.094
NAME IS MONICA TOLIVER I WITH
02:33:57.161 --> 02:33:57.828
THE AMERICAN DESCENDANTS OF
02:33:57.895 --> 02:34:00.364
SLAVERY SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
02:34:00.431 --> 02:34:02.099
INLAND EMPIRE HIGH GIVE IT
02:34:02.166 --> 02:34:04.802
REGION AND I SUPPORT THIS BILL
02:34:04.868 --> 02:34:06.904
PLEASE SHOW YOUR SUPPORT BIRTH
02:34:06.971 --> 02:34:08.839
BILL THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK
02:34:08.906 --> 02:34:12.676
YOU THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:34:12.743 --> 02:34:15.846
THANK YOU NEXT DOOR TO LINE ONE
02:34:15.913 --> 02:34:18.682
NINETY YOU PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES
02:34:18.749 --> 02:34:19.783
MY NAME IS LAWRENCE ALEXANDER
02:34:19.850 --> 02:34:21.118
I'M A MEMBER OF THE EIGHTY S.
02:34:21.185 --> 02:34:23.988
MOVEMENT. FORMER SO THE DOCTOR
02:34:24.054 --> 02:34:25.689
WHATEVER AND I WHOLEHEARTEDLY
02:34:25.756 --> 02:34:28.592
WANT TO SUPPORT. AB THIRTY ONE
02:34:28.659 --> 02:34:30.527
TWENTY ONE. THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:34:30.594 --> 02:34:35.165
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU RYAN
02:34:35.232 --> 02:34:37.601
FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:34:37.668 --> 02:34:39.903
HELLO MY NAME IS PRECEDED
02:34:39.970 --> 02:34:40.537
DANGERFIELD ONE OF THE FOUNDING
02:34:40.604 --> 02:34:42.573
MEMBERS OF THE AMERICAN LISTEN
02:34:42.640 --> 02:34:44.675
CLOSELY READ THE CHAPTER AND A
02:34:44.742 --> 02:34:46.610
MEMBER OF THE IN THE LACI P.
02:34:46.677 --> 02:34:49.546
OAKLAND CHAPTER AND ONE OF THE
02:34:49.613 --> 02:34:51.415
MANY DESCENDANTS OF SLAVERY IN
02:34:51.482 --> 02:34:53.350
CALIFORNIA AND I URGE THE
02:34:53.417 --> 02:34:57.254
SENATORS TO VOTE I ON A. B.
02:34:57.321 --> 02:34:58.922
THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK YOU.
02:34:58.989 --> 02:35:03.060
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:35:03.127 --> 02:35:04.862
YOU REID OF ONE TWENTY FIVE
02:35:04.928 --> 02:35:07.898
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:35:07.965 --> 02:35:09.500
ARE YOU HATE WITH EIGHTY LEFT
02:35:09.566 --> 02:35:13.137
LOS ANGELES AND I SUPPORT
02:35:13.203 --> 02:35:13.737
EIGHTY THREE THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:35:13.804 --> 02:35:15.305
ONE THE BILL GETS ON HEALTH.
02:35:15.372 --> 02:35:25.616
THANK YOU. NEXT WITNESS. NINE
02:35:25.683 --> 02:35:27.685
FORTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:35:27.751 --> 02:35:28.752
AFTERNOON THIS IS DOCTOR DUSTIN
02:35:28.819 --> 02:35:30.921
TAYLOR- CALL ON BEHALF OF THE
02:35:30.988 --> 02:35:32.656
LOS ANGELES CHAPTER OF EIGHTY
02:35:32.723 --> 02:35:35.225
OS AMERICAN FLAVORING I
02:35:35.292 --> 02:35:39.596
STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THREE ONE
02:35:39.663 --> 02:35:40.230
TWO ONE AND I ASK YOU TO DO THE
02:35:40.297 --> 02:35:40.864
SAME THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:35:40.931 --> 02:35:44.635
WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M FIFTY
02:35:44.702 --> 02:35:51.008
THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO WE
02:35:51.075 --> 02:35:52.576
CAN HEAR YOU HELLO CAN YOU HEAR
02:35:52.643 --> 02:35:54.945
ME OK MY NAME IS PAMELA GRAHAM
02:35:55.012 --> 02:35:58.549
AND I AM A MEMBER OF A DEAL AS
02:35:58.615 --> 02:36:00.484
I AM A US AND I AM ASKING THE
02:36:00.551 --> 02:36:04.621
SENATE TO VOTE YES ON A. B.
02:36:04.688 --> 02:36:05.189
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE
02:36:05.255 --> 02:36:07.658
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:36:07.725 --> 02:36:10.394
WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M MORE
02:36:10.461 --> 02:36:12.796
THAN EIGHTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:36:12.863 --> 02:36:18.702
BUT I. THIS IS LAURA WALKER IN
02:36:18.769 --> 02:36:23.207
A VOTE YES IN SUPPORT OF AB
02:36:23.273 --> 02:36:23.774
THREE ONE TWO ONE. THANK YOU
02:36:23.841 --> 02:36:27.111
NEXT WITNESS. STATE AND ONE
02:36:27.177 --> 02:36:30.481
FORTY FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HEY
02:36:30.547 --> 02:36:31.582
YOU'RE TWENTY MCCARTY AND
02:36:31.648 --> 02:36:33.584
GOALS- AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT
02:36:33.650 --> 02:36:36.120
A. B. THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE AND
02:36:36.186 --> 02:36:37.421
I URGE YOU ALL TO LOOK AT.
02:36:37.488 --> 02:36:37.921
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT
02:36:37.988 --> 02:36:42.159
WITNESS. THANK YOU RIDE ONE
02:36:42.226 --> 02:36:44.328
NINETY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:36:44.394 --> 02:36:45.662
HI THIS IS RICKY BUT
02:36:45.729 --> 02:36:48.031
WESTMORELAND I AM WITH A DEAL
02:36:48.098 --> 02:36:50.167
AS LOS ANGELES AND- A DEAL A
02:36:50.234 --> 02:36:51.935
CALIFORNIA I'M ALSO A MEMBER OF
02:36:52.002 --> 02:36:53.437
THE AND DOUBLE ACP HOLLYWOOD
02:36:53.504 --> 02:36:55.339
BRANCH AND I AM CALLING IN
02:36:55.405 --> 02:36:57.441
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:36:57.508 --> 02:36:58.809
ONE AND I A STRONG WE ASK THAT
02:36:58.876 --> 02:37:03.280
YOU- NO YES ON THIS BILL. THANK
02:37:03.347 --> 02:37:08.152
YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I
02:37:08.218 --> 02:37:09.486
DIDN'T SIXTY PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:37:09.553 --> 02:37:10.854
ARE YOU DOING MY NAME IS
02:37:10.921 --> 02:37:12.956
MICHAEL BRYANT I'M WITH A. B.
02:37:13.023 --> 02:37:15.826
O. S. LOS ANGELES. SUPPORT A.
02:37:15.893 --> 02:37:17.828
B. THREE ONE TWO ONE. THANK YOU
02:37:17.895 --> 02:37:20.964
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:37:21.031 --> 02:37:22.733
YOU I ONE THIRTY THREE PLEASE
02:37:22.800 --> 02:37:26.170
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON MY
02:37:26.236 --> 02:37:28.105
NAME IS THE OF THE DELL AND I'M
02:37:28.172 --> 02:37:29.506
A SUPPORTER DEBATE THE O. S.
02:37:29.573 --> 02:37:32.876
AND I SUPPORT BILL EIGHT BE
02:37:32.943 --> 02:37:34.812
THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK YOU.
02:37:34.878 --> 02:37:37.381
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:37:37.447 --> 02:37:39.183
YOU LINE TO FORTY NINE PLEASE
02:37:39.249 --> 02:37:43.053
GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS
02:37:43.120 --> 02:37:45.289
VALERIE WHITE FROM WHAT THE
02:37:45.355 --> 02:37:47.124
CALIFORNIA AND I ASK THAT YOU
02:37:47.191 --> 02:37:50.961
WOULD VOTE YES ON SENATE BILL.
02:37:51.028 --> 02:37:54.598
AT AB THREE ONE TWO ONE AND I
02:37:54.665 --> 02:37:56.967
AM IN FULL SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
02:37:57.034 --> 02:38:00.237
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK.
02:38:00.304 --> 02:38:02.239
YOU I IN ONE ALL FIVE PLEASE GO
02:38:02.306 --> 02:38:06.210
AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS ELISA
02:38:06.276 --> 02:38:09.379
DAVIS AND I SUPPORT A. B. THREE
02:38:09.446 --> 02:38:11.582
ONE TWO ONE. PLEASE VOTE YES ON
02:38:11.648 --> 02:38:14.885
THIS BILL. NAPA NICE VERY.
02:38:14.952 --> 02:38:19.456
THANK YOU YOU TOO. X. WITNESS.
02:38:19.523 --> 02:38:21.825
THANK YOU ARE LYING TO FORTY
02:38:21.892 --> 02:38:24.962
FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS
02:38:25.028 --> 02:38:27.297
IS WENDY DECLINE SHAPE RESIDENT
02:38:27.364 --> 02:38:29.499
OF MONROVIA CALIFORNIA CALLING
02:38:29.566 --> 02:38:32.135
IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE TWO
02:38:32.202 --> 02:38:35.205
ONE PLEASE VOTE YET. THANK YOU.
02:38:35.272 --> 02:38:39.076
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:38:39.142 --> 02:38:39.643
YOU LINE ONE FIFTY PLEASE GO
02:38:39.710 --> 02:38:44.448
AHEAD. THE LOS OPEN AND I'M
02:38:44.514 --> 02:38:46.817
WITH THE NIKKEI FOR CAN REJECT
02:38:46.884 --> 02:38:53.957
AND LOS ANGELES AND STRONG AB.
02:38:54.024 --> 02:38:56.593
YOU WANT REPRESSIONS YOU. THANK
02:38:56.660 --> 02:38:59.329
MIX WITH. THANK YOU I AM THIRTY
02:38:59.396 --> 02:39:01.899
ONE GO OUT. HI THIS IS WHERE
02:39:01.965 --> 02:39:03.734
SHE DOES HELP TACTIC AND I AM
02:39:03.800 --> 02:39:05.569
WITH NATIONAL ACTION NETWORK
02:39:05.636 --> 02:39:07.604
LOS ANGELES AS WELL AS A DEAL
02:39:07.671 --> 02:39:10.107
LAST LOS ANGELES AND I AM IN
02:39:10.173 --> 02:39:11.174
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT
02:39:11.241 --> 02:39:15.812
WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM TO
02:39:15.879 --> 02:39:22.920
FOURTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
02:39:22.986 --> 02:39:25.422
WE HEAR YOU HELLO WE HEAR YOU
02:39:25.489 --> 02:39:28.058
OKAY THE TICKET ARRAIGNMENT AT
02:39:28.125 --> 02:39:29.626
WHAT THE- THE EIGHTY- AND LOS
02:39:29.693 --> 02:39:31.495
ANGELES AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT
02:39:31.561 --> 02:39:34.631
THE DEAL THE A. B. THREE ONE
02:39:34.698 --> 02:39:35.599
TWENTY LAST FROM SUPPORT THANK
02:39:35.666 --> 02:39:39.836
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:39:39.903 --> 02:39:41.471
THANK YOU I WANT FIVE PLEASE GO
02:39:41.538 --> 02:39:45.242
AHEAD. MY NAME IS CRYSTAL
02:39:45.309 --> 02:39:46.843
GLORIA WITH A DEALER FRIENDLY
02:39:46.910 --> 02:39:49.179
AND I'D FOR COREY AB ONE CAN
02:39:49.246 --> 02:39:52.049
MIGHT RESULT YEAH THANK THANK
02:39:52.115 --> 02:39:55.652
YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:39:55.719 --> 02:39:57.654
LINE TO TWENTY SEVEN PLEASE GO
02:39:57.721 --> 02:40:00.524
AHEAD. HI THIS IS KILEY
02:40:00.590 --> 02:40:02.292
ALEXANDER FROM ASSEMBLY
02:40:02.359 --> 02:40:04.227
DISTRICT FIFTY FOUR AND YOGA
02:40:04.294 --> 02:40:06.296
CLASSES FOR THE MASSES I AM A
02:40:06.363 --> 02:40:09.166
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE
02:40:09.232 --> 02:40:09.766
TWO ONE AND I URGE YOU TO VOTE
02:40:09.833 --> 02:40:13.870
YET. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:40:13.937 --> 02:40:15.906
THANK YOU I AM TO TWENTY FOUR
02:40:15.973 --> 02:40:20.077
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
02:40:20.143 --> 02:40:22.045
IS JOHN TO CRAWSHAY OF ENGLAND
02:40:22.112 --> 02:40:23.447
CALIFORNIA I'M IN STRONG
02:40:23.513 --> 02:40:27.851
SUPPORT OF THE BILL AB THIRTY
02:40:27.918 --> 02:40:28.452
ONE TWENTY ONE AND I URGE YOU
02:40:28.518 --> 02:40:30.220
TO VOTE YES ONTHE GROUND.
02:40:30.287 --> 02:40:33.090
THANK YOU NEXT WEEK. THANK YOU
02:40:33.156 --> 02:40:34.992
I ONE SEVENTY FIVE PLEASE GO
02:40:35.058 --> 02:40:47.671
AHEAD. LINE ONE SEVENTY FIVE
02:40:47.738 --> 02:40:56.813
BRAD. WHAT A RIDE OF TWO FIFTY
02:40:56.880 --> 02:41:01.151
ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY
02:41:01.218 --> 02:41:03.053
NAME IS THE NATION HAND FROM-
02:41:03.120 --> 02:41:04.588
LA COUNTY DPSS THAT AND THE
02:41:04.654 --> 02:41:07.758
STRONG SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE
02:41:07.824 --> 02:41:09.393
TWO ONE PLEASE VOTE YET. THANK
02:41:09.459 --> 02:41:13.130
YOU NEXT WITNESS. HI THANK YOU
02:41:13.196 --> 02:41:14.698
OVER A LINE OF TWO OH EIGHT
02:41:14.765 --> 02:41:20.037
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:41:20.103 --> 02:41:21.638
CAMILLE MOORE AND I'M A
02:41:21.705 --> 02:41:23.607
RESIDENT OF LOS ANGELES
02:41:23.673 --> 02:41:25.175
CALIFORNIA I'M IN TROUBLE
02:41:25.242 --> 02:41:28.111
SUPPORT AT A. B. THREE ONE TWO
02:41:28.178 --> 02:41:30.914
ONE AND I URGE. JENNIFER MAY
02:41:30.981 --> 02:41:34.351
VOTE ON THE MATTER THANK YOU
02:41:34.418 --> 02:41:36.553
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:41:36.620 --> 02:41:38.121
YOU I AM TO TWELVE PLEASE CALL
02:41:38.188 --> 02:41:41.858
HAD. HELLO MY NAME IS DEVIN WAS
02:41:41.925 --> 02:41:43.560
MULLIN WITH VIDEO AT AND NOT
02:41:43.627 --> 02:41:47.297
THE POOR A. B. THREE ONE TWO
02:41:47.364 --> 02:41:50.000
ONE THREE VOTE YES ON THE BILL.
02:41:50.067 --> 02:41:52.803
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:41:52.869 --> 02:41:54.504
YOU I'M TWO THIRTY THREE PLEASE
02:41:54.571 --> 02:42:00.510
GO AHEAD. AND I'M SURE AND
02:42:00.577 --> 02:42:01.745
SENATORS THE CURVATURE ON
02:42:01.812 --> 02:42:05.115
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF ALAMEDA
02:42:05.182 --> 02:42:08.819
IN SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY ONE
02:42:08.885 --> 02:42:10.153
THIRTY ONE YEAH THANK YOU. THIS
02:42:10.220 --> 02:42:12.122
Q. I WON EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE GO
02:42:12.189 --> 02:42:21.064
AHEAD. NINE ONE EIGHT FOUR
02:42:21.131 --> 02:42:30.674
PLEASE GO AHEAD. WHICH WILL
02:42:30.740 --> 02:42:32.309
TWENTY NEXT LIKELY SIXTY EIGHT
02:42:32.375 --> 02:42:35.612
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:42:35.679 --> 02:42:37.314
HERE IN THE TOMBS CALM WITH THE
02:42:37.380 --> 02:42:39.149
DEAL WITH SAN DIEGO HAS
02:42:39.216 --> 02:42:42.853
STRONGLY SUPPORT- SB TWO ONE
02:42:42.919 --> 02:42:45.622
TWENTY ONE I'M SORRY AB TWO ONE
02:42:45.689 --> 02:42:46.189
THREE ONE AND I URGE YOU TO
02:42:46.256 --> 02:42:46.690
VOTE YES. THANK YOU NEXT
02:42:46.756 --> 02:42:51.962
WITNESS. THANK YOU OVER A WIDE
02:42:52.028 --> 02:42:56.967
OF EIGHTY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:42:57.033 --> 02:42:59.169
HELLO MY NAME IS A LEADER SPAN
02:42:59.236 --> 02:43:02.305
LOOK AT OS LOS ANGELES AND I
02:43:02.372 --> 02:43:04.908
STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THIRTY ONE
02:43:04.975 --> 02:43:05.542
TWENTY ONE AND URGENTLY CALLING
02:43:05.609 --> 02:43:07.310
ALL MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE.
02:43:07.377 --> 02:43:10.547
YES ON THIS BILL THANK YOU
02:43:10.614 --> 02:43:13.216
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:43:13.283 --> 02:43:15.285
YOU OVER A LINE OF TWO HUNDRED
02:43:15.352 --> 02:43:18.421
AND TWENTY PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
02:43:18.488 --> 02:43:19.055
THIS IS REBECCA GONZALEZ WITH
02:43:19.122 --> 02:43:20.423
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
02:43:20.490 --> 02:43:21.825
SOCIAL WORKERS CALIFORNIA
02:43:21.892 --> 02:43:24.194
CHAPTER IN STRONG SUPPORT AT A.
02:43:24.261 --> 02:43:26.363
B. THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE. THANK
02:43:26.429 --> 02:43:30.600
YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I
02:43:30.667 --> 02:43:39.009
WON ALL FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:43:39.075 --> 02:43:40.844
LINE ONE ZERO FOUR PLEASE GO
02:43:40.911 --> 02:43:50.954
AHEAD. BUT WHAT OF ALL I HAVE
02:43:51.021 --> 02:43:53.557
TO TWENTY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:43:53.623 --> 02:43:55.192
HELLO MY NAME IS TRACY CUT TO
02:43:55.258 --> 02:43:57.194
KIANA AND I AM WITH MAKING
02:43:57.260 --> 02:43:58.962
PROGRESS SAYS AND DIGITAL BOB
02:43:59.029 --> 02:44:01.932
AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT AB
02:44:01.998 --> 02:44:03.833
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE THANK
02:44:03.900 --> 02:44:07.237
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:44:07.304 --> 02:44:07.771
LINE TWO HUNDRED PLEASE GO
02:44:07.837 --> 02:44:11.241
AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS DAVID-
02:44:11.308 --> 02:44:13.877
MEN AND- I MET AN AMERICAN
02:44:13.944 --> 02:44:15.679
DESCENDANTS OF SLAVERY- WAS A
02:44:15.745 --> 02:44:18.014
DEAL ESTATE AREA AND I'M IN
02:44:18.081 --> 02:44:21.618
STRONG SUPPORT OF EIGHTY THREE
02:44:21.685 --> 02:44:23.220
ONE TWO ONE AND- PLEASE VOTE
02:44:23.286 --> 02:44:25.288
YES ON THE BILL THANK YOU THANK
02:44:25.355 --> 02:44:28.391
YOU THE- WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
02:44:28.458 --> 02:44:30.227
YOU IN SIXTY NINE PLEASE GO
02:44:30.293 --> 02:44:35.332
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME
02:44:35.398 --> 02:44:35.932
IS MARJORIE MELVIN AND I WOULD
02:44:35.999 --> 02:44:37.867
CALIFORNIA EIGHTY OS INLAND
02:44:37.934 --> 02:44:40.070
EMPIRE CHAPTER ALSO FORMER
02:44:40.136 --> 02:44:44.007
CALIFORNIA PAROLE BOARD MEMBER.
02:44:44.074 --> 02:44:45.775
EIGHTY THREE ONE TOOL TO ONE
02:44:45.842 --> 02:44:47.577
AND I REQUEST THAT YOU VOTE YES
02:44:47.644 --> 02:44:50.013
ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU SO MUCH
02:44:50.080 --> 02:44:54.017
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU RYAN
02:44:54.084 --> 02:45:01.591
TWO OH SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:45:01.658 --> 02:45:05.262
BLIND MILITARISTIC WE HEAR YOU
02:45:05.328 --> 02:45:08.765
AND YOUR MATE YEAH. HI MY NAME
02:45:08.832 --> 02:45:11.601
IS ADRIANA HANNAH I'M UP HERE
02:45:11.668 --> 02:45:12.702
IN NORFOLK AND I'M SUPPORTER OF
02:45:12.769 --> 02:45:16.573
A D. O. S. AND I SUPPORT AB
02:45:16.640 --> 02:45:17.173
THREE ONE TWO ONE PLEASE VOTE
02:45:17.240 --> 02:45:19.342
YES ON THE BILL THANK YOU.
02:45:19.409 --> 02:45:21.911
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:45:21.978 --> 02:45:26.116
YOU ARE LYING. TO TWENTY FIVE
02:45:26.182 --> 02:45:29.319
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU GOOD
02:45:29.386 --> 02:45:32.389
AFTERNOON. ALONG BEHALF OF
02:45:32.455 --> 02:45:34.291
QUALITY KIND OF IN SUPPORT
02:45:34.357 --> 02:45:35.258
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:45:35.325 --> 02:45:39.863
WITNESS. THANK YOU I AM TO
02:45:39.929 --> 02:45:42.299
SEVENTY ONE PLEASE STORE HAD.
02:45:42.365 --> 02:45:43.900
MADAM CHAIR OF NUMBERS HANK MC
02:45:43.967 --> 02:45:46.036
WITH SNAP MAKERS OF SNAPCHAT IN
02:45:46.102 --> 02:45:47.237
STRONG SUPPORT OF THE BILL
02:45:47.304 --> 02:45:48.872
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:45:48.938 --> 02:45:53.310
WITNESS. THANK YOU RIGHT ONE
02:45:53.376 --> 02:45:59.416
TWENTY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:45:59.482 --> 02:46:01.017
HELLO CAN YOU HEAR ME WE CAN
02:46:01.084 --> 02:46:04.988
HEAR YOU. ALRIGHT IF THE STORY
02:46:05.055 --> 02:46:06.990
WITH A ELECT LOS ANGELES-
02:46:07.057 --> 02:46:10.093
CALLING IN SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY
02:46:10.160 --> 02:46:11.127
ONE TWENTY ONE AND ASKING THAT
02:46:11.194 --> 02:46:13.797
YOU- VOTE YES ON THE BILL THANK
02:46:13.863 --> 02:46:17.467
YOU THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
02:46:17.534 --> 02:46:19.302
THANK YOU I DON'T ONE FIFTY
02:46:19.369 --> 02:46:22.939
FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY
02:46:23.006 --> 02:46:24.774
NAME IS SAMANTHA WALKER WITH A
02:46:24.841 --> 02:46:26.343
D. O. S. LOS ANGELES AND I
02:46:26.409 --> 02:46:28.311
STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THREE ONE
02:46:28.378 --> 02:46:31.047
TWO ONE. FOR THE BILL THANK YOU.
02:46:31.114 --> 02:46:34.217
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:46:34.284 --> 02:46:37.887
YOU RYAN AT ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:46:37.954 --> 02:46:40.190
HI MY NAME IS KISHA WAR I AM A
02:46:40.256 --> 02:46:41.891
SUPPORTER OF EIGHTY A LOT AND I
02:46:41.958 --> 02:46:44.527
SUPPORT EIGHTY THREE ONE TWO
02:46:44.594 --> 02:46:45.261
ONE PLEASE VOTE YES ON THE
02:46:45.328 --> 02:46:48.231
SPELL THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:46:48.298 --> 02:46:52.068
WITNESS. THANK YOU RIDE ONE
02:46:52.135 --> 02:47:03.413
NINETY THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:47:03.480 --> 02:47:05.281
BLIND ONE NINE THREE PLEASE GO
02:47:05.348 --> 02:47:14.557
AHEAD. THE TWO PHONE LINES
02:47:14.624 --> 02:47:16.493
ELEVEN PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI I'M
02:47:16.559 --> 02:47:18.528
BRIANNA CROMARTIE REPRESENTING
02:47:18.595 --> 02:47:20.330
AMERICAN DESCENDANTS OF SLAVERY
02:47:20.397 --> 02:47:22.766
LOS ANGELES AND OUR MAIN STRONG
02:47:22.832 --> 02:47:24.701
SUPPORT AND NINE COURAGE YOU TO
02:47:24.768 --> 02:47:27.570
VOTE YES ON A. B. THIRTY ONE
02:47:27.637 --> 02:47:29.506
TWENTY ONE THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:47:29.572 --> 02:47:32.308
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:47:32.375 --> 02:47:34.144
WORK OUT OF BUYING TO THIRTY
02:47:34.210 --> 02:47:37.680
SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS
02:47:37.747 --> 02:47:38.815
IS EBONY ALEXANDER I'M A
02:47:38.882 --> 02:47:40.450
RESIDENT OF LOS ANGELES AND AN
02:47:40.517 --> 02:47:41.618
AMERICAN TO THINK IN A PLAY
02:47:41.684 --> 02:47:44.454
FREE I STRONG SUPPORT AB THIRTY
02:47:44.521 --> 02:47:45.021
ONE TWENTY ONE AND ENCOURAGE
02:47:45.088 --> 02:47:47.123
YOU TO VOTE YES THANK YOU.
02:47:47.190 --> 02:47:49.659
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:47:49.726 --> 02:47:52.562
YOU LINE TO THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE
02:47:52.629 --> 02:47:54.531
GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:47:54.597 --> 02:47:56.166
GENEVIEVE GRAY I'M A RESIDENT
02:47:56.232 --> 02:47:58.067
OF INGLEWOOD CALIFORNIA AND I
02:47:58.134 --> 02:48:01.738
STRONGLY SUPPORT A. B. THIRTY
02:48:01.805 --> 02:48:04.174
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE CALL YES
02:48:04.240 --> 02:48:05.208
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:48:05.275 --> 02:48:08.678
ITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I AM
02:48:08.745 --> 02:48:11.848
THREE ARE NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:48:11.915 --> 02:48:14.017
USE DROWNED AT SEA FROM THE L.
02:48:14.083 --> 02:48:17.454
S. BAY AREA. AND I'M IN
02:48:17.520 --> 02:48:19.322
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:48:19.389 --> 02:48:22.725
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:48:22.792 --> 02:48:24.227
I'M THREE ALIVE AND PLEASE GO
02:48:24.294 --> 02:48:28.431
AHEAD. YES I'M KEVIN FLORA NOR
02:48:28.498 --> 02:48:29.766
KNOWN AS LEGAL TO LET ON
02:48:29.833 --> 02:48:33.503
TWITTER A DEAL WITH. THEM IN
02:48:33.570 --> 02:48:37.240
SUPPORT OF AB. THIRTY ONE
02:48:37.307 --> 02:48:38.041
TWENTY ONE. THANK YOU NEXT
02:48:38.107 --> 02:48:41.945
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:48:42.011 --> 02:48:43.847
ROBERT- I AM THREE SIXTEEN
02:48:43.913 --> 02:48:58.294
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THREE SIXTEEN
02:48:58.361 --> 02:48:59.262
DROPPED IT I HAVE NO FURTHER
02:48:59.329 --> 02:49:01.598
LINES IN Q. AT THIS MOMENT ALL
02:49:01.664 --> 02:49:04.834
RIGHT LET'S GO AHEAD AND ASK
02:49:04.901 --> 02:49:06.836
ONE MORE TIME IF THERE ARE. ANY
02:49:06.903 --> 02:49:09.305
OTHERS WHO WISH TO TESTIFY IN
02:49:09.372 --> 02:49:13.443
SUPPORT OF THIS ITEM. ON THE
02:49:13.510 --> 02:49:18.081
LINE AT THIS MOMENT. THANK YOU
02:49:18.147 --> 02:49:19.816
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:49:19.883 --> 02:49:22.352
OF AB THREE ONE TWO ONE PLEASE
02:49:22.418 --> 02:49:23.920
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
02:49:23.987 --> 02:49:35.031
TIME. ARE THERE ANY FURTHER
02:49:35.098 --> 02:49:38.167
WITNESSES MADAME MODERATOR. I
02:49:38.234 --> 02:49:39.736
DO HAVE ABOUT TWENTY EIGHT NEW
02:49:39.802 --> 02:49:42.872
LINES THAT. CUED UP ALL RIGHT
02:49:42.939 --> 02:49:45.508
VERY GOOD LET'S PROCEED. WITH
02:49:45.575 --> 02:49:47.043
ADDITIONAL THE WITNESSES AGAIN
02:49:47.110 --> 02:49:49.279
THESE ARE WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
02:49:49.345 --> 02:49:52.148
OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE.
02:49:52.215 --> 02:49:54.250
MADAM A MODERATOR PLEASE GO
02:49:54.317 --> 02:49:58.488
AHEAD AND OPEN THOSE LINES.
02:49:58.555 --> 02:49:59.956
THANK YOU ITEM ONE TWENTY
02:50:00.023 --> 02:50:04.260
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO THIS IS
02:50:04.327 --> 02:50:06.496
A KILO MAC WHY I'M A MEMBER OF
02:50:06.563 --> 02:50:08.531
ADOLF CALIFORNIAN ENOUGH LOS
02:50:08.598 --> 02:50:11.568
ANGELES MARK PORT AB THIRTY ONE
02:50:11.634 --> 02:50:13.269
TWENTY ONE- DUE TO ALSO BOTH
02:50:13.336 --> 02:50:15.605
WITH THEM. THANK YOU NEXT
02:50:15.672 --> 02:50:19.042
WITNESS. THANK YOU ITEM ONE
02:50:19.108 --> 02:50:26.482
EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:50:26.549 --> 02:50:28.117
LINE ONE EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE GO
02:50:28.184 --> 02:50:40.063
AHEAD. MOVE ON. TRYING TO
02:50:40.129 --> 02:50:41.197
NINETY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:50:41.264 --> 02:50:47.070
HELLO. MARLIN WATSON A MEMBER
02:50:47.136 --> 02:50:48.938
OF RADIO S. AND FOR SUPPORT OF
02:50:49.005 --> 02:50:51.674
REPARATIONS FOR AMERICAN
02:50:51.741 --> 02:50:52.775
DESCENDANTS OF SLAVERY WELL YES
02:50:52.842 --> 02:50:56.079
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:50:56.145 --> 02:50:58.281
YOU I AM THREE TWENTY PLEASE GO
02:50:58.348 --> 02:51:04.120
AHEAD. WE CAN HEAR YOU OKAY
02:51:04.187 --> 02:51:06.489
OKAY I AM- A PART OF A DEAL
02:51:06.556 --> 02:51:08.358
LESS AND I AM IN FULL SUPPORT
02:51:08.424 --> 02:51:12.061
OF SB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE
02:51:12.128 --> 02:51:14.797
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
02:51:14.864 --> 02:51:16.332
YOU LINE FIFTY NINE PLEASE GO
02:51:16.399 --> 02:51:20.570
AHEAD. THE TREES WITH A DEAL IN
02:51:20.637 --> 02:51:25.174
ANGELES IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
02:51:25.241 --> 02:51:25.808
EIGHTY THREE ONE TWO ONE PLEASE
02:51:25.875 --> 02:51:28.011
VOTE YET. THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:51:28.077 --> 02:51:32.582
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE
02:51:32.649 --> 02:51:33.116
ONE SEVENTY FIVE PLEASE GO
02:51:33.182 --> 02:51:37.954
AHEAD. HELLO I'M ERICA THOMPSON
02:51:38.021 --> 02:51:39.856
OF LOS ANGELES AND ONE OF MY
02:51:39.922 --> 02:51:42.291
AND PLAY PATRIARCH CABLE CRAIG
02:51:42.358 --> 02:51:44.894
WAS INTERVIEWED BY A CALIFORNIA
02:51:44.961 --> 02:51:46.429
CONGRESSMAN AND THE FEDERAL
02:51:46.496 --> 02:51:47.830
FLAYED NARRATIVES. HE WOULD
02:51:47.897 --> 02:51:50.466
ADMIT THAT ATONEMENT ILLEGAL
02:51:50.533 --> 02:51:52.335
AND LEGAL MISTREATMENT. COULD
02:51:52.402 --> 02:51:54.937
YOU JUST GIVE US YOUR NAME AND
02:51:55.004 --> 02:51:57.173
AFFILIATION PLEASE. ONE ONE
02:51:57.240 --> 02:51:59.308
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
02:51:59.375 --> 02:52:02.612
SO MUCH NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:52:02.679 --> 02:52:06.315
I AM TO SIX GO AHEAD. HI MY
02:52:06.382 --> 02:52:07.984
NAME IS NINA BATTLE EIGHTY AWAY
02:52:08.051 --> 02:52:11.020
FROM GEORGIA A STRONG SUPPORT
02:52:11.087 --> 02:52:13.589
AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE
02:52:13.656 --> 02:52:16.092
VOTE YES THANK YOU. WELCOME TO
02:52:16.159 --> 02:52:19.762
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU. NEXT
02:52:19.829 --> 02:52:24.600
WITNESS AND WE THANK YOU I'M
02:52:24.667 --> 02:52:25.201
TWO THIRTY ONE PLEASE COUPLE I
02:52:25.268 --> 02:52:28.871
HAD. HI MY NAME IS TERRY
02:52:28.938 --> 02:52:30.707
MORRISON I'M A RESIDENT OF
02:52:30.773 --> 02:52:33.042
INGLEWOOD- I'M A LICENSED
02:52:33.109 --> 02:52:34.544
CLINICAL SOCIAL WORKER FOR THE
02:52:34.610 --> 02:52:35.978
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND AN
02:52:36.045 --> 02:52:37.613
AMERICAN DESCENDANTS OF SLAVERY
02:52:37.680 --> 02:52:41.684
I STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THIRTY
02:52:41.751 --> 02:52:42.285
ONE TWENTY ONE AND I URGE YOU
02:52:42.351 --> 02:52:44.320
TO PLEASE VOTE YES. THANK YOU
02:52:44.387 --> 02:52:47.657
MA'AM NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:52:47.724 --> 02:52:49.258
ITEM MODEL FOR PLEASE CALL US
02:52:49.325 --> 02:52:56.899
AT. THE. NINE ONE ZERO FOUR
02:52:56.966 --> 02:53:03.673
PLEASE GO AHEAD. BUT. LET'S
02:53:03.740 --> 02:53:07.777
MOVE ON. PINE THREE OH TO
02:53:07.844 --> 02:53:10.780
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES MY NAME IS
02:53:10.847 --> 02:53:12.014
WITH CHEESY HAIR AND I'M A
02:53:12.081 --> 02:53:13.182
RESIDENT OF LOS ANGELES AND I
02:53:13.249 --> 02:53:18.020
STRONGLY SUPPORT AB. THREE ONE
02:53:18.087 --> 02:53:18.621
TWO ONE AND I STRONGLY SUGGEST
02:53:18.688 --> 02:53:19.222
YOU DO AS WELL. THANK YOU NEXT
02:53:19.288 --> 02:53:23.826
WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE THREE
02:53:23.893 --> 02:53:26.362
TWENTY ONE PLEASE CALL I HAD.
02:53:26.429 --> 02:53:28.030
HI MY NAME IS TAMPA NO SENSE
02:53:28.097 --> 02:53:30.333
FROM LOS ANGELES CALIFORNIA AND
02:53:30.399 --> 02:53:34.003
I STRONGLY SUPPORT- YES VOTE ON
02:53:34.070 --> 02:53:34.604
A. B. THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK
02:53:34.670 --> 02:53:39.308
YOU. Q. NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
02:53:39.375 --> 02:53:44.380
I'M THREE I HAD. MY NAME IS
02:53:44.447 --> 02:53:46.115
KRISTEN JACOBS FROM ENGLAND
02:53:46.182 --> 02:53:49.118
HELPLINE IN AMAZON SUPPORT OF
02:53:49.185 --> 02:53:51.621
AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE
02:53:51.687 --> 02:53:54.123
VOTE YET THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:53:54.190 --> 02:53:57.894
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M
02:53:57.960 --> 02:54:00.296
THREE SEVENTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:54:00.363 --> 02:54:02.265
HI YES GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME
02:54:02.331 --> 02:54:05.401
IS ALEXANDER I AND NUMBER EIGHT
02:54:05.468 --> 02:54:08.171
ON THE BAY AREA AND I STRONGLY
02:54:08.237 --> 02:54:11.474
URGE EVERY TO VOTE YES ON A. B.
02:54:11.541 --> 02:54:12.074
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE YOU CAN
02:54:12.141 --> 02:54:15.912
DO IT. THANK YOU THANK YOU.
02:54:15.978 --> 02:54:18.047
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:54:18.114 --> 02:54:24.320
I'M TO NINETY THREE WE HAD.
02:54:24.387 --> 02:54:35.231
SECTION. AND THE- BILL SUPPORT.
02:54:35.298 --> 02:54:37.967
THANK YOU THANK YOU NEXT
02:54:38.034 --> 02:54:41.571
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU BRIAN
02:54:41.637 --> 02:54:44.106
THREE OR SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:54:44.173 --> 02:54:45.875
HI MY NAME IS CENTER THOMAS ON
02:54:45.942 --> 02:54:48.411
ON THE STF NONPROFIT
02:54:48.477 --> 02:54:49.645
CORPORATION IF I CAN A
02:54:49.712 --> 02:54:51.347
CALIFORNIA I STRONGLY SUPPORT
02:54:51.414 --> 02:54:54.584
A. B. THREE ONE TWO ONE THANK
02:54:54.650 --> 02:54:56.652
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS
02:54:56.719 --> 02:55:01.324
PLEASE. THANK YOU I AM THREE OH
02:55:01.390 --> 02:55:04.527
FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO WE
02:55:04.594 --> 02:55:08.798
CAN HEAR YOU. HI THIS IS THE
02:55:08.865 --> 02:55:10.132
AMBER GRANT FINANCIAL ADVISER
02:55:10.199 --> 02:55:10.733
WHICH STILL REMINDING
02:55:10.800 --> 02:55:12.301
INCORPORATED FROM INGLEWOOD
02:55:12.368 --> 02:55:14.637
CALIFORNIA I STRONGLY SUPPORT
02:55:14.704 --> 02:55:17.039
THE BILL AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY
02:55:17.106 --> 02:55:18.674
ONE ENCOURAGED EDITORS TO PASS
02:55:18.741 --> 02:55:22.311
IT I AM A DESCENDANT OF. THANK
02:55:22.378 --> 02:55:26.249
YOU MA'AM. NEXT WITNESS PLEASE.
02:55:26.315 --> 02:55:28.451
THANK YOU RYAN THREE FOURTEEN
02:55:28.517 --> 02:55:32.788
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:55:32.855 --> 02:55:34.523
WILLIAM WHITE I AM A RESIDENT
02:55:34.590 --> 02:55:36.058
AN EMPLOYEE WITH THE CITY OF
02:55:36.125 --> 02:55:39.695
LOS ANGELES MY SUPPORT A. B.
02:55:39.762 --> 02:55:41.464
THREE ONE TWO ONE. THANK YOU
02:55:41.530 --> 02:55:45.268
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:55:45.334 --> 02:55:46.936
I'M TO SIXTY FIVE PLEASE GO
02:55:47.003 --> 02:55:51.641
AHEAD. THE WHICH IS BORN ON THE
02:55:51.707 --> 02:55:52.608
LOS ANGELES PRESIDENT AND
02:55:52.675 --> 02:55:54.610
UNLIKELY CLICKABLE CLOSE TO
02:55:54.677 --> 02:55:57.880
FIFTY A STRONG SUPPORT A. B.
02:55:57.947 --> 02:55:59.415
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE ENERGY.
02:55:59.482 --> 02:56:02.551
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE.
02:56:02.618 --> 02:56:11.093
THANK YOU VERY. I HAD. HELLO
02:56:11.160 --> 02:56:19.702
HELLO. HELLO YES WE HEAR YOU.
02:56:19.769 --> 02:56:22.371
THIS IS MARTY WILSON I'M WITH
02:56:22.438 --> 02:56:23.940
A. B. O. S. SACRAMENTO. I'M
02:56:24.006 --> 02:56:25.975
ALSO WITH CALIFORNIA BUT WE
02:56:26.042 --> 02:56:29.078
HELP PROJECT I AM IN SUPPORT OF
02:56:29.145 --> 02:56:31.480
AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE AND I
02:56:31.547 --> 02:56:34.216
URGE YOU TO SUPPORT. THIRTY ONE
02:56:34.283 --> 02:56:35.985
TWENTY ONE THANK YOU THANK YOU
02:56:36.052 --> 02:56:39.021
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
02:56:39.088 --> 02:56:40.623
ARE TRYING TO FIFTY FIVE PLEASE
02:56:40.690 --> 02:56:49.565
GO AHEAD. FOR SUPPORT OF AB
02:56:49.632 --> 02:56:50.099
THREE ONE TWO ONE ACTUALLY
02:56:50.166 --> 02:56:52.802
SPOKE FOR IT CAPTION. THANK YOU
02:56:52.868 --> 02:56:57.106
SIR NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M
02:56:57.173 --> 02:56:57.673
THREE TWENTY FIVE PLEASE GO
02:56:57.740 --> 02:57:02.645
AHEAD. I AM PATRICIA HARASSMENT
02:57:02.712 --> 02:57:05.147
RESIDENT OF LOS ANGELES AND I
02:57:05.214 --> 02:57:09.151
AM IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE
02:57:09.218 --> 02:57:11.487
TWO ONE AND I DESIRE TO HAVE
02:57:11.554 --> 02:57:13.422
THE BILL PASSED THANK YOU.
02:57:13.489 --> 02:57:14.023
THANK YOU SO MUCH NEXT WITNESS
02:57:14.090 --> 02:57:18.294
PLEASE. THANK YOU I'M THREE
02:57:18.361 --> 02:57:21.564
TABLET PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY
02:57:21.630 --> 02:57:23.199
NAME IS NATALIE SURE AND I
02:57:23.265 --> 02:57:26.302
SUPPORT A. B. THREE ONE TWO ONE
02:57:26.369 --> 02:57:28.070
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:57:28.137 --> 02:57:32.174
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I'M
02:57:32.241 --> 02:57:34.343
THREE FIFTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:57:34.410 --> 02:57:36.379
HI MY NAME IS EMMA NORM TEN
02:57:36.445 --> 02:57:37.847
MORE THAN OF INGLEWOOD
02:57:37.913 --> 02:57:40.850
CALIFORNIA AND I STRONG SUPPORT
02:57:40.916 --> 02:57:43.185
EIGHT B. THIRTY ONE TO ONE I
02:57:43.252 --> 02:57:44.720
URGE TO VOTE YES. THANK YOU
02:57:44.787 --> 02:57:49.458
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE TO
02:57:49.525 --> 02:57:52.194
NINETY TWO PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
02:57:52.261 --> 02:57:54.096
MY NAME IS LOUIS A CARDIO AND
02:57:54.163 --> 02:57:55.798
ON THAT RESIDENT OF INGLEWOOD
02:57:55.865 --> 02:57:58.100
CALIFORNIA AND I STRONGLY
02:57:58.167 --> 02:58:01.270
SUPPORT AB THREE ONE TWO ONE
02:58:01.337 --> 02:58:03.739
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT
02:58:03.806 --> 02:58:07.610
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I AM
02:58:07.676 --> 02:58:11.147
THREE EIGHTEEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:58:11.213 --> 02:58:12.381
HELLO MY NAME IS JESSE ACT AND
02:58:12.448 --> 02:58:13.582
SOME A LOS ANGELES CITY
02:58:13.649 --> 02:58:16.118
RESIDENT AND I STAND IN SUPPORT
02:58:16.185 --> 02:58:20.122
OF SENATE BILL I'M SORRY A. B.
02:58:20.189 --> 02:58:21.791
THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE. THANK
02:58:21.857 --> 02:58:25.528
YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
02:58:25.594 --> 02:58:26.962
YOU I'M THREE TWENTY SEVEN
02:58:27.029 --> 02:58:30.866
PLEASE GLAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:58:30.933 --> 02:58:33.002
ECONOMIST RECORDER AND I AM IN
02:58:33.069 --> 02:58:36.439
SUPPORT OF A. B. THIRTY ONE
02:58:36.505 --> 02:58:38.441
TWENTY ONE PLEASE VOTE YET.
02:58:38.507 --> 02:58:42.178
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE.
02:58:42.244 --> 02:58:43.813
THANK YOU I AM THREE THIRTY
02:58:43.879 --> 02:58:52.021
EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE
02:58:52.088 --> 02:58:52.588
THREE THREE EIGHT PLEASE GO
02:58:52.655 --> 02:58:58.127
AHEAD. IT'S GOING TO THE NEXT
02:58:58.194 --> 02:59:02.498
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I'M
02:59:02.565 --> 02:59:03.065
THREE TWENTY EIGHT PLEASE GO
02:59:03.132 --> 02:59:06.902
AHEAD. HI CAN YOU HEAR ME OK.
02:59:06.969 --> 02:59:10.706
YES WHO CAN. MY NAME IS LINDA
02:59:10.773 --> 02:59:12.308
WHY I'M OUT OF HIM IN
02:59:12.374 --> 02:59:14.343
CALIFORNIA AND I AM IN SUPPORT
02:59:14.410 --> 02:59:18.147
OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE.
02:59:18.214 --> 02:59:20.983
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE
02:59:21.050 --> 02:59:24.787
THANK YOU. THANK YOU LYING TO
02:59:24.854 --> 02:59:28.124
TWENTY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
02:59:28.190 --> 02:59:30.759
MY NAME IS SIOBHAN WHITE SAMSON
02:59:30.826 --> 02:59:32.962
I'M IN MENIFEE CALIFORNIA I'M
02:59:33.028 --> 02:59:34.630
ALSO A PARTICIPANT IN THE
02:59:34.697 --> 02:59:36.565
NONPROFIT SECTOR IN RIVERSIDE
02:59:36.632 --> 02:59:39.001
COUNTY AND I BILL YES. CHIU A.
02:59:39.068 --> 02:59:42.438
B. THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE THANK
02:59:42.505 --> 02:59:45.708
YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
02:59:45.774 --> 02:59:46.976
YOU OF MINE THREE THIRTY FIVE
02:59:47.042 --> 02:59:49.812
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS
02:59:49.879 --> 02:59:51.647
LISA FAMILY OUT OF SACRAMENTO
02:59:51.714 --> 02:59:54.316
CALIFORNIA I'M A SUPPORTER OF A
02:59:54.383 --> 02:59:58.220
DEAL AS AND I SUPPORT AB THIRTY
02:59:58.287 --> 02:59:58.821
ONE TWENTY ONE PLEASE VOTE YES
02:59:58.888 --> 03:00:01.624
ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU VERY
03:00:01.690 --> 03:00:04.493
MUCH NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
03:00:04.560 --> 03:00:06.195
YOU RYAN THREE THIRTY NINE
03:00:06.262 --> 03:00:10.199
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS
03:00:10.266 --> 03:00:14.036
JULIAN HELLO I'M IN AB S.
03:00:14.103 --> 03:00:17.907
CARSON AND LOS ANGELES. POSTED
03:00:17.973 --> 03:00:20.876
MAR SUPPORT FOR A BI THREE ONE
03:00:20.943 --> 03:00:22.978
TWO ONE. THANK YOU SIR NEXT
03:00:23.045 --> 03:00:27.816
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU I'M
03:00:27.883 --> 03:00:30.519
TO EIGHTY NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:00:30.586 --> 03:00:31.987
HELLO MY NAME IS TERRY MATTERS
03:00:32.054 --> 03:00:34.089
OF A FOUNDING MEMBER EIGHT OF
03:00:34.156 --> 03:00:35.658
EIGHT ALMOST FRESNO COUNTY AND
03:00:35.724 --> 03:00:37.393
I STAND IN SOLIDARITY WITH MY
03:00:37.459 --> 03:00:38.260
EIGHT ALSO OTHERS INSISTED IN
03:00:38.327 --> 03:00:41.497
SUPPORT OF AB B. THIRTY ONE
03:00:41.564 --> 03:00:43.032
TWENTY ONE THANK YOU THANK YOU
03:00:43.098 --> 03:00:46.168
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU
03:00:46.235 --> 03:00:47.770
RYAN THREE FORTY FOUR PLEASE GO
03:00:47.836 --> 03:00:51.207
AHEAD. MY NAME IS PAMELA DAVIS
03:00:51.273 --> 03:00:53.542
I'M AT O. S. BAY AREA I'M IN
03:00:53.609 --> 03:00:56.145
STRONG SUPPORT OF A. B. THREE
03:00:56.212 --> 03:00:59.448
ONE TWO ONE. AND I URGE YOU TO
03:00:59.515 --> 03:01:00.849
VOTE YES THANK YOU THANK YOU
03:01:00.916 --> 03:01:05.054
NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. WELL I AM
03:01:05.120 --> 03:01:05.621
THREE FORTY NINE PLEASE GO
03:01:05.688 --> 03:01:08.924
AHEAD. MY NAME IS NAY REMAIN
03:01:08.991 --> 03:01:11.126
ACT BRANCH I AM THE OWNER OF
03:01:11.193 --> 03:01:13.128
RECORD IF IT IS NONPROFIT AND I
03:01:13.195 --> 03:01:16.699
STAND IN AGREEMENT WITH A. B.
03:01:16.765 --> 03:01:18.801
THREE ONE TWO ONE. YES THANK
03:01:18.867 --> 03:01:22.671
YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
03:01:22.738 --> 03:01:23.973
YOU I HAVE NO FURTHER LINE
03:01:24.039 --> 03:01:26.008
THANK YOU AT THIS TIME. ALL
03:01:26.075 --> 03:01:27.743
RIGHT LET'S A CHECK ONE MORE
03:01:27.810 --> 03:01:32.514
TIME IF YOU WOULD. THANK YOU
03:01:32.581 --> 03:01:33.382
ONCE AGAIN IF YOU ARE IN
03:01:33.449 --> 03:01:36.418
SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE TWO ONE
03:01:36.485 --> 03:01:37.853
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
03:01:37.920 --> 03:01:56.538
AT THIS TIME.
03:01:58.907 --> 03:01:59.475
AND I DO HAVE
03:01:59.541 --> 03:02:01.610
ABOUT TEN NEW ONES IN Q. IT'LL
03:02:01.677 --> 03:02:17.092
JUST BE ONE MOMENT. OVER A
03:02:17.159 --> 03:02:18.861
WIDER ONE ZERO FOUR PLEASE GO
03:02:18.927 --> 03:02:30.072
AHEAD. LINE ONE ZERO FOR YOUR
03:02:30.139 --> 03:02:33.876
OPEN PLEASE GO I HAD. YES MY
03:02:33.942 --> 03:02:35.477
NAME IS KATHLEEN BACK IT AND
03:02:35.544 --> 03:02:36.945
I'M A SUPPORTER OF AID AND I
03:02:37.012 --> 03:02:41.684
STRONGLY SUPPORT AB THREE ONE
03:02:41.750 --> 03:02:42.318
TWO ONE PLEASE VOTE YES ON THIS
03:02:42.384 --> 03:02:44.119
BILL. THANK YOU SO MUCH NEXT
03:02:44.186 --> 03:02:48.290
WITNESS PLEASE. THANK YOU NEXT
03:02:48.357 --> 03:02:49.958
WHAT A LINE OF THREE FIFTY
03:02:50.025 --> 03:02:52.728
THREE PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY
03:02:52.795 --> 03:02:53.962
NAME IS BRIAN YOUNG FROM LOS
03:02:54.029 --> 03:02:55.564
ANGELES CALIFORNIA AND I AM
03:02:55.631 --> 03:02:58.500
SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE TWO ONE.
03:02:58.567 --> 03:03:00.969
PLEASE VOTE YES ON THIS THANK
03:03:01.036 --> 03:03:04.707
YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
03:03:04.773 --> 03:03:06.308
YOU ITEM ONE FORTY TWO PLEASE
03:03:06.375 --> 03:03:15.317
CALL HAD. LINE ONE FOUR TO YOUR
03:03:15.384 --> 03:03:21.557
LINE IS OPEN PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:03:21.623 --> 03:03:22.191
PLEASE MOVE TO THE NEXT WITNESS
03:03:22.257 --> 03:03:31.100
PLEASE. HI MY NAME IS EDDIE
03:03:31.166 --> 03:03:32.401
JEANS WARNER FROM INGLEWOOD
03:03:32.468 --> 03:03:35.204
CALIFORNIA. AND I'M IN SUPPORT
03:03:35.270 --> 03:03:37.873
OF AB THIRTY ONE TWENTY ONE
03:03:37.940 --> 03:03:41.276
PLEASE VOTE YES ON THE YEAH.
03:03:41.343 --> 03:03:43.112
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS THANK
03:03:43.178 --> 03:03:46.081
YOU. THANK YOU I AM THREE
03:03:46.148 --> 03:03:50.219
THIRTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:03:50.285 --> 03:03:51.220
HELLO MY NAME THANK YOU TODAY
03:03:51.286 --> 03:03:52.888
I'M NOT I'M IN SUPPORT OF AB
03:03:52.955 --> 03:03:55.724
THAT THREE ONE TWO ONE LEGAL
03:03:55.791 --> 03:04:00.095
YEAH. THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
03:04:00.162 --> 03:04:02.264
THANK YOU I AM THREE FIFTY FIVE
03:04:02.331 --> 03:04:05.868
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HIGHER STILL
03:04:05.934 --> 03:04:09.571
OF. IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE ONE
03:04:09.638 --> 03:04:11.940
TWO ONE AND I VOTE YES. THANK
03:04:12.007 --> 03:04:16.412
YOU NEXT WITNESS PLEASE. THANK
03:04:16.478 --> 03:04:17.012
YOU I'M THREE FORTY PLEASE GO
03:04:17.079 --> 03:04:22.217
AHEAD. YES THIS IS THEY'LL
03:04:22.284 --> 03:04:25.988
FRANCIS FROM EIGHTY OSS ANGELES.
03:04:26.054 --> 03:04:27.356
NOW BUT A FULL SUPPORT OF THIS
03:04:27.423 --> 03:04:30.526
BILL AS YOU TO YES YOU THANK
03:04:30.592 --> 03:04:33.929
YOU NEXT WOULD PLEASE. THANK
03:04:33.996 --> 03:04:35.431
YOU I'M THREE FORTY FIVE PLEASE
03:04:35.497 --> 03:04:40.536
GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS
03:04:40.602 --> 03:04:43.472
TERRA OUT ON A RESIDENT WALKS
03:04:43.539 --> 03:04:47.409
AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT A. B.
03:04:47.476 --> 03:04:48.444
THREE ONE TWO ONE I HOPE THAT
03:04:48.510 --> 03:04:50.412
YOU GUYS PLEASE VOTE YES THANK
03:04:50.479 --> 03:04:53.715
YOU OF OUR PLASTIC CARE. THE
03:04:53.782 --> 03:04:57.453
YOU. NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I
03:04:57.519 --> 03:04:59.188
AM THREE FIFTY SEVEN PLEASE GO
03:04:59.254 --> 03:05:10.299
AHEAD. BUT I AM THREE FIVE
03:05:10.365 --> 03:05:11.400
SEVEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN PLEASE
03:05:11.467 --> 03:05:14.336
GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS WILLIE
03:05:14.403 --> 03:05:16.638
BRERA THE FRIENDS IN A KILLINGS
03:05:16.705 --> 03:05:21.910
THE- AGAIN. THANK YOU SIR NEXT
03:05:21.977 --> 03:05:23.779
WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M THREE
03:05:23.846 --> 03:05:24.880
FORTY ONE PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:05:24.947 --> 03:05:28.417
HELLO I'M NOT GOING OF WATER.
03:05:28.484 --> 03:05:36.959
AB YOUR- A LITTLE YEAH BE.
03:05:37.025 --> 03:05:38.126
THIRTY ONE TWO ONE THANK YOU.
03:05:38.193 --> 03:05:41.096
THANK NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I
03:05:41.163 --> 03:05:44.366
THREE FOR NINE PLEASE AHEAD. HI
03:05:44.433 --> 03:05:46.468
THIS IS FREE MATH PRESIDENT OF
03:05:46.535 --> 03:05:49.171
IN CA. PLEASE DON'T YELL FOR
03:05:49.238 --> 03:05:51.607
THE BILL. THANK YOU MA'AM ARE
03:05:51.673 --> 03:05:52.241
THERE ANY OTHER WITNESS IN THE
03:05:52.307 --> 03:05:55.711
Q. MAN MODERATE. I HAVE TWO
03:05:55.777 --> 03:05:58.413
MORE LINES IN Q. THANK YOU
03:05:58.480 --> 03:06:03.418
PLEASE PROCEED. I NEED TO RE
03:06:03.485 --> 03:06:06.355
SIXTY EIGHT PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:06:06.421 --> 03:06:07.789
HELLO CAN YOU HEAR ME. WE CAN
03:06:07.856 --> 03:06:12.661
HEAR YOU. OKAY AREA I AM NOT A
03:06:12.728 --> 03:06:16.632
SUPPORTER OF THE A. B. THIRTY
03:06:16.698 --> 03:06:17.199
ONE TWENTY ONE AND I'M ALSO
03:06:17.266 --> 03:06:20.402
PARK EIGHTY L. LAST. THANK
03:06:20.469 --> 03:06:21.003
WOULD YOU LIKE TO GIVE US YOUR
03:06:21.069 --> 03:06:26.375
NAME FOR THE RECORD TEMP.
03:06:26.441 --> 03:06:27.509
ALREADY MOVING ALONG TO THE
03:06:27.576 --> 03:06:31.980
NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU I'M
03:06:32.047 --> 03:06:34.983
THREE SIXTY SIX PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:06:35.050 --> 03:06:37.152
HELLO THREE SIXTY SIX WITH
03:06:37.219 --> 03:06:40.989
MARIE IN DAVIS AND I HOPE THE
03:06:41.056 --> 03:06:48.664
TO VOTE THE. THANK YOU MA'AM.
03:06:48.730 --> 03:06:49.398
OTHER OTHER WITNESS IN THE- I
03:06:49.464 --> 03:06:51.133
NO FURTHER LINE THANK YOU AT
03:06:51.199 --> 03:06:54.570
THE TIME. THANK YOU PART WITH
03:06:54.636 --> 03:06:57.406
THAT OF WE WILL MOVE ON TO
03:06:57.472 --> 03:06:59.841
OPPOSITION I HAVE NO NOTICE
03:06:59.908 --> 03:07:04.580
THAT THERE IS. ANYONE WHO IS OF
03:07:04.646 --> 03:07:06.848
A SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF ANY
03:07:06.915 --> 03:07:10.586
OPPOSITION SO WE WILL MOVE THEN
03:07:10.652 --> 03:07:12.788
TO. SEE IF WE HAVE ANY
03:07:12.854 --> 03:07:14.756
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL IN ROOM
03:07:14.823 --> 03:07:19.761
FORTY TWO OR THREE. SEEING NONE
03:07:19.828 --> 03:07:20.862
ANY OPPOSITION IN ROOM TWENTY
03:07:20.929 --> 03:07:24.499
FORTY. SEEING NONE WILL BRING
03:07:24.566 --> 03:07:30.472
IT TO. YOU MODERATOR CHIU OF.
03:07:30.539 --> 03:07:32.140
PLEASE PROMPT ANY INDIVIDUALS
03:07:32.207 --> 03:07:34.376
WHO MAY BE WAITING TO TESTIFY
03:07:34.443 --> 03:07:38.747
IN OPPOSITION TO AB THIRTY
03:07:38.814 --> 03:07:39.348
TWENTY ONE WE'LL GIVE IT A FEW
03:07:39.414 --> 03:07:42.684
SECONDS. AND THEN ASK YOU TO
03:07:42.751 --> 03:07:43.285
INDICATE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE
03:07:43.352 --> 03:07:46.421
IN THE QUEUE. IS FOR PEOPLE
03:07:46.488 --> 03:07:48.223
WISHING TO WISH TO SPEAK AND-
03:07:48.290 --> 03:07:51.293
GO AHEAD IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
03:07:51.360 --> 03:07:54.162
IN OPPOSITION OF AB THREE ONE
03:07:54.229 --> 03:07:55.998
TWO ONE PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
03:07:56.064 --> 03:08:11.446
THEN ZERO OUT THIS TIME. ARE
03:08:11.513 --> 03:08:12.948
THERE ANY WITNESSES IN THE
03:08:13.015 --> 03:08:16.752
QUEUE MADAME MODERATOR. I HAVE
03:08:16.818 --> 03:08:19.321
NO LINES IN Q. AT THIS TIME.
03:08:19.388 --> 03:08:20.622
WE'LL GIVE IT ONE MORE SECOND
03:08:20.689 --> 03:08:23.125
OR TEN MORE SECONDS AND- THEN
03:08:23.191 --> 03:08:26.328
WE WILL. BRING IT BACK TO THE
03:08:26.395 --> 03:08:30.132
DIET SHIFT OR NO- COMMENTS.
03:08:30.198 --> 03:08:33.669
FROM MARA THE- PHONE CALLS FROM
03:08:33.735 --> 03:08:48.483
THE WITNESSES ON THE PHONE.
03:08:48.550 --> 03:08:50.919
MADAME MODERATOR DO WE HAVE ANY
03:08:50.986 --> 03:08:54.022
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. I HAVE
03:08:54.089 --> 03:08:56.425
NO LINE THANK YOU AT THIS TIME
03:08:56.491 --> 03:08:59.294
VERY GOOD LET'S BRING IT BACK
03:08:59.361 --> 03:09:03.398
TO DISCUSSION BY THE MEMBERS
03:09:03.465 --> 03:09:03.965
WERE GOING TO START WITH THE
03:09:04.032 --> 03:09:07.903
SENATE BOAR SENATOR. WHY CAN'T
03:09:07.969 --> 03:09:11.707
SKI THE MORNING IN I BELIEVE
03:09:11.773 --> 03:09:16.044
URBAN SO WHAT'S GOING AND THE
03:09:16.111 --> 03:09:18.146
FOR SURE SENATOR. THANK YOU
03:09:18.213 --> 03:09:21.283
MADAM CHAIR. MANY OF YOU THAT I
03:09:21.349 --> 03:09:25.487
HAVE STRONG. IN BY IN GREEK
03:09:25.554 --> 03:09:28.757
ARMENIAN. RELY ISSUES AND FOR A
03:09:28.824 --> 03:09:33.295
LONG LONG TIME I HAVE ADVOCATED
03:09:33.361 --> 03:09:35.731
FOR PREPARATION DISCUSSIONS
03:09:35.797 --> 03:09:39.134
GIVEN THE LOSS OF PROPERTY THE
03:09:39.201 --> 03:09:42.471
LOSS OF LIFE THE LOSS OF. OF
03:09:42.537 --> 03:09:45.974
VALUABLE SECOND IN TERRITORY
03:09:46.041 --> 03:09:48.443
WHEN THERE WERE THE- WHEN THERE
03:09:48.510 --> 03:09:49.845
WAS THE FORCIBLE EXCHANGE
03:09:49.911 --> 03:09:51.680
BETWEEN TURKEY AND GREECE IN
03:09:51.747 --> 03:09:54.783
THE TWENTIES PRIOR TO THAT THE
03:09:54.850 --> 03:09:57.419
PONTIC GENOCIDE GREEK GENOCIDE
03:09:57.486 --> 03:09:58.887
IN THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE. SO
03:09:58.954 --> 03:10:03.625
THIS ISSUE PRESENTS SOME VERY
03:10:03.692 --> 03:10:08.130
NOVEL AND- COMPONENTS. THAT IF
03:10:08.196 --> 03:10:11.967
I AM TO BE CONSISTENT. IN THE
03:10:12.033 --> 03:10:16.271
BELIEF THAT. HISTORY DOES NOT
03:10:16.338 --> 03:10:18.473
HAVE A STATUE OF LIMITATIONS
03:10:18.540 --> 03:10:19.007
WHEN IT COMES TO WRITING A
03:10:19.074 --> 03:10:22.944
WRONG. THEN I HAVE TO.
03:10:23.011 --> 03:10:26.114
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT SOMETHING THAT
03:10:26.181 --> 03:10:30.485
IS AS FOR DATING. AS SLAVERY
03:10:30.552 --> 03:10:34.156
THAT IS AS PROBABLY THE MOST.
03:10:34.222 --> 03:10:40.162
PROFOUND INSIGNIFICANT. CASTOR
03:10:40.228 --> 03:10:44.032
FEE TO THE FALL OF PEOPLE. AS
03:10:44.099 --> 03:10:46.968
THE INSTITUTION OF SLAVERY AS
03:10:47.035 --> 03:10:51.039
IT SPEND CONTINENTS IT SPANNED
03:10:51.106 --> 03:10:54.409
CIVILIZATIONS BUT IT CONTINUED
03:10:54.476 --> 03:10:58.146
INTO MODERN PERIODS OF TIME.
03:10:58.213 --> 03:11:00.048
DRAMATICALLY DIFFERENT THAN OUR
03:11:00.115 --> 03:11:02.117
NOTIONS OF THE ANCIENT WORLD.
03:11:02.184 --> 03:11:03.652
THE REASON WHY I'M BRINGING
03:11:03.718 --> 03:11:06.888
THIS UP IS AS AN ADVOCATE FOR
03:11:06.955 --> 03:11:11.126
THE GREEKS ARMENIANS AND OTHERS
03:11:11.193 --> 03:11:12.093
AS THEY TRIED IS TO SEEK
03:11:12.160 --> 03:11:13.829
REDRESS FROM THE HISTORICAL
03:11:13.895 --> 03:11:17.032
INJUSTICES THAT BEFELL THEM.
03:11:17.098 --> 03:11:18.633
THEN SO TOO SHOULD AFRICAN
03:11:18.700 --> 03:11:20.802
AMERICANS BE IN A POSITION TO
03:11:20.869 --> 03:11:23.004
SEEK REDRESS. UNDER THE
03:11:23.071 --> 03:11:25.140
CIRCUMSTANCES WE FIND OURSELVES
03:11:25.207 --> 03:11:28.777
IN AS AMERICANS. IT'S ONLY FAIR.
03:11:28.844 --> 03:11:33.515
HERE'S MY REQUEST TO. THE
03:11:33.582 --> 03:11:34.883
AUTHOR PERHAPS A BIT WILL BE
03:11:34.950 --> 03:11:40.622
THROUGH. THE CENTER BRADFORD- I
03:11:40.689 --> 03:11:43.458
THINK IT'S ENTIRELY APPROPRIATE
03:11:43.525 --> 03:11:45.427
FOR A BODY TO BE CONVENED TO
03:11:45.493 --> 03:11:48.930
STUDY THIS ISSUE. I'D SURPRISE
03:11:48.997 --> 03:11:53.235
THAT HASN'T BEEN DONE- BY OTHER
03:11:53.301 --> 03:11:55.170
STATES MAYBE IT HAS BEEN I
03:11:55.237 --> 03:11:57.138
DON'T I DON'T NOW. BUT HERE'S
03:11:57.205 --> 03:11:58.273
WHAT I WOULD WANT TO SEE
03:11:58.340 --> 03:12:00.675
DIFFERENT ABOUT THE PROPOSED
03:12:00.742 --> 03:12:04.913
CONSTITUTION OF THIS GROUP. IS
03:12:04.980 --> 03:12:06.748
RIGHT NOW THE APPOINTMENTS
03:12:06.815 --> 03:12:08.884
WOULD BE FROM THE GOVERNOR AND
03:12:08.950 --> 03:12:10.685
THE LEADERS OF THE ASSEMBLY AND
03:12:10.752 --> 03:12:14.623
THE SENATE. WHAT I DON'T SEE I
03:12:14.689 --> 03:12:16.858
THINK IT'S ESSENTIAL JUST AS
03:12:16.925 --> 03:12:20.028
WE'VE- LOOK AT SOUTH AFRICA
03:12:20.095 --> 03:12:22.330
CAMBODIA ARMENIA AND ELSEWHERE
03:12:22.397 --> 03:12:23.565
AROUND THE WORLD WE'VE HAD
03:12:23.632 --> 03:12:26.768
THESE CATASTROPHES IS THAT WHEN
03:12:26.835 --> 03:12:28.503
A GROUP IS CONVENE. THESE
03:12:28.570 --> 03:12:31.339
INDIVIDUALS BE PROPERLY
03:12:31.406 --> 03:12:35.944
SCHOOLED AND- ARE DISCIPLINED
03:12:36.011 --> 03:12:37.512
ON MATTERS THAT ARE RELEVANT TO
03:12:37.579 --> 03:12:40.882
THE BODY ITSELF. SO HERE'S MY
03:12:40.949 --> 03:12:42.717
RECOMMENDATION WOULD THE AUTHOR
03:12:42.784 --> 03:12:47.122
CONSIDER. THAT THE EIGHT
03:12:47.188 --> 03:12:51.359
APPOINTMENTS. BE EXPANDED I
03:12:51.426 --> 03:12:54.429
DON'T KNOW TO WHAT AMOUNT. BUT
03:12:54.496 --> 03:12:56.731
THAT IT INCLUDE COMPARED OF LAW
03:12:56.798 --> 03:12:59.935
EXPERTS. INNING THE REASON I
03:13:00.001 --> 03:13:02.904
BRING THAT UP IS BECAUSE- THE
03:13:02.971 --> 03:13:05.440
REPORT ON THE CREATION OF THIS.
03:13:05.507 --> 03:13:08.443
COMMISSION TALKS ABOUT. THIS
03:13:08.510 --> 03:13:10.712
UNITED NATIONS ORGANS IN
03:13:10.779 --> 03:13:12.247
DIFFERENT TREES AND OTHER
03:13:12.314 --> 03:13:15.083
OBLIGATIONS TO UNDERSTAND HOW
03:13:15.150 --> 03:13:18.787
OTHER COUNTRIES HAVE DONE THIS.
03:13:18.853 --> 03:13:20.889
SO COMPARED OF LAW EXPERT.
03:13:20.956 --> 03:13:22.757
SOMEONE EXPERIENCED IN FOR
03:13:22.824 --> 03:13:26.328
EXAMPLE AS A HOLOCAUST SCHOLAR.
03:13:26.394 --> 03:13:27.862
OR SOUTH AFRICAN APARTHEID
03:13:27.929 --> 03:13:30.665
SCHOLAR THESE INDIVIDUALS HAVE
03:13:30.732 --> 03:13:32.500
A BACKGROUND IN DEALING WITH
03:13:32.567 --> 03:13:36.471
REPARATIONS BUT THIS IS NOT.
03:13:36.538 --> 03:13:38.873
JUST A- NUMBER OF INDIVIDUALS
03:13:38.940 --> 03:13:40.575
APPOINTED BY THE PRO TEM THE
03:13:40.642 --> 03:13:42.577
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IN THE GOVERNOR
03:13:42.644 --> 03:13:45.313
AND LASTLY IT WOULD BE THAT
03:13:45.380 --> 03:13:46.815
THERE BE A POLITICAL CROSS
03:13:46.881 --> 03:13:48.783
SECTION REPRESENTED HERE.
03:13:48.850 --> 03:13:50.352
BECAUSE IF IT'S JUST THOSE
03:13:50.418 --> 03:13:51.753
THREE ENTITIES MAKING THE
03:13:51.820 --> 03:13:54.222
APPOINTMENT. I THINK IT WOULD
03:13:54.289 --> 03:13:57.125
BENEFIT. THE COMMISSION OR THIS
03:13:57.192 --> 03:14:00.462
COUNCIL. THAT BODY IN BENEFIT
03:14:00.528 --> 03:14:02.897
ALL OF US IF WE HAD SOME
03:14:02.964 --> 03:14:07.168
REPRESENTATION THAT REPRESENTED.
03:14:07.235 --> 03:14:09.204
THE CROSS SECTION OF OUR
03:14:09.270 --> 03:14:12.874
POLITICAL SYSTEM. I THINK DOES
03:14:12.941 --> 03:14:15.410
A REASONABLE REQUEST I DON'T
03:14:15.477 --> 03:14:16.911
KNOW IF I'D LIKE TO LEAVE IT
03:14:16.978 --> 03:14:21.116
OPEN TO. BOB THE PRESENTER I
03:14:21.182 --> 03:14:23.051
THINK THIS HAS A LOT OF MERIT.
03:14:23.118 --> 03:14:25.587
I'M SCARED. THAT IF THE
03:14:25.653 --> 03:14:28.656
COMPOSITION IS NOT. ALL TO
03:14:28.723 --> 03:14:30.825
MODIFY. DATA WON'T BE IS AS IT
03:14:30.892 --> 03:14:33.728
NEED TO BE AND I'M ALSO AFRAID
03:14:33.795 --> 03:14:36.064
THAT WILL UNNECESSARILY IGNITE
03:14:36.131 --> 03:14:39.401
PARTISAN PASSIONS. THAT I THINK
03:14:39.467 --> 03:14:42.337
ARE INAPPROPRIATE. SOME SOME
03:14:42.404 --> 03:14:43.938
MANAGER DO YOU MIND IF I
03:14:44.005 --> 03:14:47.275
THROUGH YOU. HOSE THAT REQUEST
03:14:47.342 --> 03:14:50.712
TO THE PRESENTER. I SIR THE
03:14:50.779 --> 03:14:52.747
PRESENTER CAN COMMENT ON IT IN
03:14:52.814 --> 03:14:55.183
HIS CLOTHES A BOAT YOU KNOW WE
03:14:55.250 --> 03:14:58.553
DON'T NEGOTIATE THE TERMS OF
03:14:58.620 --> 03:15:00.088
THE BILL IN ADVANCE BUT I DO
03:15:00.155 --> 03:15:02.424
BELIEVE THAT THE PROVISIONS IN
03:15:02.490 --> 03:15:04.225
THE BILL CALL FOR EIGHT PEOPLE
03:15:04.292 --> 03:15:07.195
ARE AND THAT THEY CANNOT ALL BE
03:15:07.262 --> 03:15:08.663
OF THE SAME PARTY SO BAD THAT
03:15:08.730 --> 03:15:10.865
HAS BEEN ADDRESSED BUT ALL ALL
03:15:10.932 --> 03:15:13.201
THAT THE PRESENTER COMMENT ON
03:15:13.268 --> 03:15:14.469
THAT. AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
03:15:14.536 --> 03:15:17.005
COMMENTS SO THE CENTER BOARD OF
03:15:17.072 --> 03:15:18.973
MOVING ALONG I CAN'T REMEMBER
03:15:19.040 --> 03:15:20.675
THE ORDER I INITIALLY PRESENTED
03:15:20.742 --> 03:15:22.377
BUT IF YOU'LL INDULGE ME WILL
03:15:22.444 --> 03:15:24.345
GO TO SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI
03:15:24.412 --> 03:15:26.414
IN AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE
03:15:26.481 --> 03:15:28.149
PRISONERS COMMENTS COMMENT ON
03:15:28.216 --> 03:15:31.920
HIS AT HIS CLOSE I'VE ASKED HIM
03:15:31.986 --> 03:15:34.089
TO DO THAT. A SIMPLE WHITE. THE
03:15:34.155 --> 03:15:37.792
MAN I TO WITH THE A SHOUT OUT
03:15:37.859 --> 03:15:39.394
FOR ALICE MERRILEES WHO WROTE
03:15:39.461 --> 03:15:42.464
STAFF. THIS IS. MY TENTH YEAR
03:15:42.530 --> 03:15:44.299
IN LESS. BEEN AND THE ASSEMBLY
03:15:44.365 --> 03:15:45.567
SENATE SHOULD. COMMITTEES ALL
03:15:45.633 --> 03:15:47.602
TIME AND WE DO EVERY DOES A
03:15:47.669 --> 03:15:49.537
WONDERFUL JOB THIS IS. THIS IS
03:15:49.604 --> 03:15:51.973
SOMETHING THAT. WAS WELL
03:15:52.040 --> 03:15:55.477
WRITTEN BUT IT ALSO. TEES UP
03:15:55.543 --> 03:15:57.512
THIS. TASK FORCE BECAUSE YOU
03:15:57.579 --> 03:15:59.581
KNOW WE CAN GO BACK A HUNDRED
03:15:59.647 --> 03:16:01.082
FIFTY FIVE YEARS AND ASK WHY
03:16:01.149 --> 03:16:02.784
WAS THIS NOT DONE WHEN THE
03:16:02.851 --> 03:16:04.085
CIVIL WAR WAS OVER AND THEN
03:16:04.152 --> 03:16:09.290
YOU'RE INTO. YOU KNOW THE. JIM
03:16:09.357 --> 03:16:11.092
CROW LAWS IN THE N. IT IN THE
03:16:11.159 --> 03:16:13.361
TURN OF THIS. NEARLY TWO BUT-
03:16:13.428 --> 03:16:14.262
BUT THE STAFF REPORT.
03:16:14.329 --> 03:16:15.763
HIGHLIGHTS HOW THE NEW TO WAS
03:16:15.830 --> 03:16:17.899
REAL A WHITE DEAL AND AT A-
03:16:17.966 --> 03:16:19.000
EXCLUDED TO. WORKER IN
03:16:19.067 --> 03:16:20.768
AGRICULTURAL WORKERS WHICH
03:16:20.835 --> 03:16:23.438
SEEING IT AS I READ IT
03:16:23.505 --> 03:16:25.473
YESTERDAY JUMPED OFF THE PAGES
03:16:25.540 --> 03:16:28.243
WITH ME AND THEN I MOVED INTO.
03:16:28.309 --> 03:16:30.445
THE GI WHICH EXCLUDED AND THE
03:16:30.512 --> 03:16:32.213
RED LINE THAT WE ALL KNOW ABOUT
03:16:32.280 --> 03:16:34.349
AND I WAS EXCLUDED THE AFRICAN
03:16:34.415 --> 03:16:35.350
AMERICAN PEOPLE AND THEN YOU
03:16:35.416 --> 03:16:37.318
GET INTO THE- CRIMINAL ORDERED
03:16:37.385 --> 03:16:39.387
FEDERAL CRIMINALIZATION OF LAW
03:16:39.454 --> 03:16:41.356
ON THE MASS. INCARCERATION AND
03:16:41.422 --> 03:16:44.759
YOU'VE- IF WE DON'T TO THIS.
03:16:44.826 --> 03:16:45.927
TASK FORCE AND SET UP TO
03:16:45.994 --> 03:16:48.997
REPARATION WHAT DOES IT STOP
03:16:49.063 --> 03:16:51.966
ONE TWO WHEN. ONE DISC
03:16:52.033 --> 03:16:53.801
CALIFORNIA'S INTERAMERICAN
03:16:53.868 --> 03:16:56.437
SOCIETY. LOOK AT THESE OR THAT
03:16:56.504 --> 03:16:59.941
WE HAVE IN OUR- I. THE ALL AN
03:17:00.008 --> 03:17:02.911
AS PERCENT TODAY BRING IT I'M
03:17:02.977 --> 03:17:05.980
YOU KNOW I FILLED WITH GUILT AS
03:17:06.047 --> 03:17:08.049
THEY SHOULD BE THEN ALL THE
03:17:08.116 --> 03:17:10.852
BUSH BE ABOUT. THAT THE LACK OF
03:17:10.919 --> 03:17:12.954
A TWO THAT HAD TO THIS CANCER
03:17:13.021 --> 03:17:14.389
THAT WE HAVE IN OUR AND THAT
03:17:14.455 --> 03:17:15.590
SHOULD BE ADDRESSED SO I
03:17:15.657 --> 03:17:18.826
APPRECIATE THE INDULGENCE OF
03:17:18.893 --> 03:17:20.395
THE COMMITTEE. THANK YOU SIR
03:17:20.461 --> 03:17:23.331
CENTER MORNING. THANK YOU MADAM
03:17:23.398 --> 03:17:26.534
CHAIR I ALSO WANT TO CONVEY MY
03:17:26.601 --> 03:17:29.571
THANKS TO THE AUTHOR ASSEMBLY
03:17:29.637 --> 03:17:31.773
MEMBER WEBER HER LEADERSHIP MOM
03:17:31.839 --> 03:17:34.175
ON THIS AND SO MANY RELATED
03:17:34.242 --> 03:17:36.778
ISSUES AND TO THE PRESENTER
03:17:36.844 --> 03:17:39.280
SENATOR BRADFORD. I ALSO WANT
03:17:39.347 --> 03:17:41.983
TO JUST OFFER MY THINKS- TO
03:17:42.050 --> 03:17:46.287
ALISON MEREDITH IT'S AN AMAZING.
03:17:46.354 --> 03:17:49.557
ANALYSIS I'VE PRINTED OUT TO
03:17:49.624 --> 03:17:52.660
SHARE WITH FAMILY MEMBERS END
03:17:52.727 --> 03:17:54.529
THANK YOU SECOND ALSO FORWARDED
03:17:54.596 --> 03:17:56.464
IS AN EMAIL ATTACHMENT FROM THE
03:17:56.531 --> 03:17:57.699
FIGURE OUT HOW TO DO THAT BUT
03:17:57.765 --> 03:18:02.870
IT'S- IT. SO MANY WHO INCLUDING
03:18:02.937 --> 03:18:05.473
MYSELF WERE TAUGHT IN SCHOOLS
03:18:05.540 --> 03:18:08.042
THAT CALIFORNIA'S ESTABLISHED.
03:18:08.109 --> 03:18:09.711
NOT AS A SLAVE STATE AND THAT
03:18:09.777 --> 03:18:11.980
WAS ONE OF THE FIGHTS THAT TOOK
03:18:12.046 --> 03:18:15.250
PLACE IN MONTEREY IN WHETHER OR
03:18:15.316 --> 03:18:17.118
NOT THE CONSTITUTION. OF THE
03:18:17.185 --> 03:18:18.519
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
03:18:18.586 --> 03:18:19.420
RECOGNIZE THE INSTITUTION OF
03:18:19.487 --> 03:18:23.691
SLAVERY OR NOT AND WHILE. IT
03:18:23.758 --> 03:18:28.863
DIDN'T FORMALLY YOU LOOK AT THE
03:18:28.930 --> 03:18:30.832
LEGACY IN VESTIGES OF ON SO
03:18:30.898 --> 03:18:33.635
MANY FRONTS. RECOGNIZING
03:18:33.701 --> 03:18:35.403
OWNERSHIP OF OTHER PEOPLE BY
03:18:35.470 --> 03:18:36.804
PEOPLE COMING IN TO THE STATE
03:18:36.871 --> 03:18:38.806
OF CALIFORNIA THE DENIAL OF
03:18:38.873 --> 03:18:40.975
PROPERTY RIGHTS THE RED LINING
03:18:41.042 --> 03:18:42.677
IN THE LIST GOES ON AND ON TO
03:18:42.744 --> 03:18:45.246
PUT THIS IN OUR- CHALLENGE
03:18:45.313 --> 03:18:47.282
TODAY. THE DEPTH OF THE
03:18:47.348 --> 03:18:50.285
CHALLENGE MAY BE ONLY OFFSET.
03:18:50.351 --> 03:18:53.187
BY THEM MOVEMENT UNDER WAY IN
03:18:53.254 --> 03:18:57.759
THIS COUNTRY RIGHT NOW. MOM THE-
03:18:57.825 --> 03:19:01.729
LOSS OF JOHN LEWIS IN YET. IN
03:19:01.796 --> 03:19:04.332
DEATH HIS LIFE IS BEING BETTER
03:19:04.399 --> 03:19:06.234
UNDERSTOOD AND SHARED AROUND
03:19:06.301 --> 03:19:10.138
THE COUNTRY. AND SO MANY OTHERS
03:19:10.204 --> 03:19:13.174
YOUNG PEOPLE STEPPING UP. IN
03:19:13.241 --> 03:19:17.011
RESISTANCE TO PLEASE PRACTICES
03:19:17.078 --> 03:19:19.047
BUT GOING BEYOND PLEASE
03:19:19.113 --> 03:19:21.616
PRACTICES I FULLY SUPPORT THE
03:19:21.683 --> 03:19:23.785
ESTABLISHMENT OF THIS
03:19:23.851 --> 03:19:24.619
COMMISSION I WOULD HOPE THAT
03:19:24.686 --> 03:19:28.089
PART OF THE ITS STUDY WOULD
03:19:28.156 --> 03:19:29.390
LOOK TO THE TRUTH AND
03:19:29.457 --> 03:19:31.159
RECONCILIATION COMMISSIONS
03:19:31.225 --> 03:19:34.095
ESTABLISHED BY NELSON MANDELA.
03:19:34.162 --> 03:19:36.497
FROM IN ARCHBISHOP DESMOND TUTU
03:19:36.564 --> 03:19:39.167
IN SOUTH AFRICA A DIFFERENT
03:19:39.233 --> 03:19:40.501
COUNTRY AT DIFFERENT HISTORY
03:19:40.568 --> 03:19:43.438
BUT DEEP WOUNDS COMING OUT OF
03:19:43.504 --> 03:19:48.376
DECADES OF WAR- IN APARTHEID IN
03:19:48.443 --> 03:19:52.146
CONVENING. FORUM WHERE PEOPLE
03:19:52.213 --> 03:19:54.716
FACE EACH OTHER AND SHARED
03:19:54.782 --> 03:19:57.151
THEIR LOSS THEIR GRIEF THEIR
03:19:57.218 --> 03:20:00.455
RESPONSIBILITY AND WAS A
03:20:00.521 --> 03:20:02.223
HEALING PROCESS THAT STILL
03:20:02.290 --> 03:20:05.426
UNDER WAY BUT IT WAS RECOGNIZED
03:20:05.493 --> 03:20:07.695
BY THE LEADERS. OF THE SOUTH
03:20:07.762 --> 03:20:09.731
AFRICAN REVOLUTION THAT IT WAS
03:20:09.797 --> 03:20:12.800
ESSENTIAL FOR THE COUNTRY TO BE
03:20:12.867 --> 03:20:13.334
ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD. THIS
03:20:13.401 --> 03:20:15.203
NEVER HAPPENED IN THIS COUNTRY
03:20:15.269 --> 03:20:16.804
AND I WOULD HOPE THAT THIS
03:20:16.871 --> 03:20:19.907
WOULD MARK A STARTING POINT-
03:20:19.974 --> 03:20:22.477
GLAD TO SUPPORT THE BILL I'D-
03:20:22.543 --> 03:20:25.079
BE PROUD TO. MOVE THE BILL AT
03:20:25.146 --> 03:20:26.748
THE APPROPRIATE TIME MADAM
03:20:26.814 --> 03:20:29.283
CHAIR THANK YOU. THANK YOU
03:20:29.350 --> 03:20:32.553
SENATOR TO RUSSELL FOLLOWED BY
03:20:32.620 --> 03:20:34.722
SENATOR GONZALEZ AND I SEE
03:20:34.789 --> 03:20:38.426
SENATOR STERN'S HAND IS UP SO.
03:20:38.493 --> 03:20:41.262
HE WILL BE. PROBABLY BEFORE
03:20:41.329 --> 03:20:44.132
CLOSE- BUT LET'S GO AHEAD TO
03:20:44.198 --> 03:20:45.566
SENATOR TO ROSTER THANK YOU
03:20:45.633 --> 03:20:50.571
MADAM CHAIR- THANK YOU SENATOR
03:20:50.638 --> 03:20:52.774
BRADFORD FOR. PRESENT TO A THE
03:20:52.840 --> 03:20:57.578
ANTE. A DOCTOR WEBER ON THE
03:20:57.645 --> 03:21:02.617
OFFICE OF. REPORT ON THIS. YOUR
03:21:02.683 --> 03:21:06.721
STAFF OF. THE AMAZING AND I
03:21:06.788 --> 03:21:07.922
THINK WE ALL WANT TO JUST GONNA
03:21:07.989 --> 03:21:12.226
RUSHED SHARE THIS A THE- THERE
03:21:12.293 --> 03:21:15.363
IS A SURE. A LOT THAT WILL BE
03:21:15.430 --> 03:21:19.300
ON CA AND OF. MATURE DAMAGE AND
03:21:19.367 --> 03:21:21.736
LOSSES THAT WERE INFLICTED ON
03:21:21.803 --> 03:21:23.438
ON GENERATIONS AND GENERATIONS
03:21:23.504 --> 03:21:28.876
OF BLACK AMERICANS. BUT THERE'S
03:21:28.943 --> 03:21:30.211
ALSO THE TRAUMA AND THEIR ARE A
03:21:30.278 --> 03:21:34.415
LOT OF THINGS. WHEN ASKED WHEN
03:21:34.482 --> 03:21:36.083
DOES IT STOP. IT STOPS WILL WE
03:21:36.150 --> 03:21:38.352
TO THE BOND OF IT ALL STOP SO
03:21:38.419 --> 03:21:41.088
WE REALLY FIGURE THE- OF THE
03:21:41.155 --> 03:21:46.093
DAMAGE TO- IN GENERATIONS OF A
03:21:46.160 --> 03:21:49.263
BLACK AMERICANS- AND I HOLD
03:21:49.330 --> 03:21:52.033
THROUGH THIS JUST AS- THE-
03:21:52.099 --> 03:21:55.837
ANALYSIS BECAME MORE OF A- OF A
03:21:55.903 --> 03:22:00.475
HISTORIC- PICTURE. ALL WE CAN
03:22:00.541 --> 03:22:04.245
YOU FURTHER BECAUSE AS AS
03:22:04.312 --> 03:22:05.746
SLAVES TRIED TO GET AWAY FROM
03:22:05.813 --> 03:22:07.949
SLAVERY IN THE SOUTH IN THE
03:22:08.015 --> 03:22:09.750
SOUTHEAST AND THEY WENT MORE
03:22:09.817 --> 03:22:12.954
MORE WEST- THEY WERE THEY WERE
03:22:13.020 --> 03:22:14.755
MOVING CLOSER AND CLOSER TO I
03:22:14.822 --> 03:22:17.024
MEAN THEY WANT TO TAXES UP
03:22:17.091 --> 03:22:19.060
BEFORE WITH TEXAS. BECAUSE THEY
03:22:19.126 --> 03:22:20.862
WANT TO GET AWAY FROM SLAVERY.
03:22:20.928 --> 03:22:22.763
AND THE PRIMARY REASON THAT
03:22:22.830 --> 03:22:24.332
THERE WAS A ME U. S. MEXICO
03:22:24.398 --> 03:22:27.568
WALLER WAS BECAUSE OF A VERY.
03:22:27.635 --> 03:22:29.904
THE OF PEOPLE LIVING IN TEXAS
03:22:29.971 --> 03:22:32.807
SAID WE WANT SLAVERY HERE TOO
03:22:32.874 --> 03:22:34.141
AND THEY WERE PART OF MEXICO
03:22:34.208 --> 03:22:36.143
AND IT WAS ILLEGAL IN MEXICO
03:22:36.210 --> 03:22:37.845
FOR DECADES BEFORE IT HAD.
03:22:37.912 --> 03:22:41.415
BECOME ILLEGAL SO. THERE IS SO
03:22:41.482 --> 03:22:44.352
MUCH TO UNCOVER THAT I HOPE IN
03:22:44.418 --> 03:22:49.257
THE PROCESS. OF COMING UP WITH
03:22:49.323 --> 03:22:51.492
WHAT THE- THE PLAN ON THE ON
03:22:51.559 --> 03:22:53.661
THE REPARATIONS HOW TO ADDRESS
03:22:53.728 --> 03:22:56.297
REPARATIONS THAT WE ALSO USES
03:22:56.364 --> 03:22:57.899
THE OPPORTUNITY TO REALLY.
03:22:57.965 --> 03:23:01.168
EDUCATE AND INFORM- OF SO MANY
03:23:01.235 --> 03:23:03.571
OF US ON MANY ISSUES THAT WE
03:23:03.638 --> 03:23:04.839
DON'T KNOW ABOUT AND FINALLY I
03:23:04.906 --> 03:23:06.407
WANT TO GIVE THAT AS AN
03:23:06.474 --> 03:23:08.175
EXAMPLE- I'VE MENTIONED THIS
03:23:08.242 --> 03:23:10.244
WITH REGARDS TO- THE LOSS OF
03:23:10.311 --> 03:23:12.780
CONGRESSMAN LEWIS. IN TWO
03:23:12.847 --> 03:23:13.681
THOUSAND THREE WE DID THE
03:23:13.748 --> 03:23:14.415
IMMIGRANT WORKERS FREEDOM RIDE
03:23:14.482 --> 03:23:15.883
WHICH WAS REALLY AN%
03:23:15.950 --> 03:23:18.753
EXTRAORDINARY EXPERIENCE OF
03:23:18.819 --> 03:23:20.555
AMERICANS OF ALL COLORS. OF
03:23:20.621 --> 03:23:23.224
TRAVELING ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
03:23:23.291 --> 03:23:24.191
AND FOR SEVERAL WEEKS AND
03:23:24.258 --> 03:23:26.861
STOPPING IN SMALL TOWNS AND BIG
03:23:26.928 --> 03:23:28.763
CITIES- AND ENDING UP IN AND
03:23:28.829 --> 03:23:33.501
NEW YORK AND- REMEMBER WHAT
03:23:33.568 --> 03:23:35.570
THE- IMMIGRANT TO OR THE BOOKS
03:23:35.636 --> 03:23:37.405
WHEN WE STOP. TO BURN A THE
03:23:37.471 --> 03:23:39.941
HISTORY OF SLAVERY AND AFRICAN.
03:23:40.007 --> 03:23:45.346
IN THE STORE WRITES ME. ON DATE
03:23:45.413 --> 03:23:47.949
KNOW THEY DIDN'T KNOW. THE
03:23:48.015 --> 03:23:54.755
HUMAN. NOT THE- STORK MOMENTS
03:23:54.822 --> 03:23:57.091
AND SO I SEE THIS MORE AS A
03:23:57.158 --> 03:23:58.793
EDUCATION AS MY AS IT WILL BE A
03:23:58.859 --> 03:24:02.797
RIP SO. I AM SO PROUD THAT
03:24:02.863 --> 03:24:06.133
DOING THIS FINALLY THANK YOU.
03:24:06.200 --> 03:24:06.968
THANK YOU SENATOR ALSO SENATOR
03:24:07.034 --> 03:24:09.170
GONZALEZ THANK YOU SENATOR
03:24:09.236 --> 03:24:10.571
BRADFORD AND DOCTOR WEBER AND
03:24:10.638 --> 03:24:12.239
EVERYONE WHO PROVIDED TESTIMONY
03:24:12.306 --> 03:24:14.342
IN PERSON AND OVER THE PHONE I
03:24:14.408 --> 03:24:17.111
TWO MEN STRONG SUPPORT- I WILL
03:24:17.178 --> 03:24:18.980
SAY THAT BACK HOME IN LONG
03:24:19.046 --> 03:24:20.114
BEACH- WE'RE CREATING A
03:24:20.181 --> 03:24:21.816
FRAMEWORK FOR RECONCILIATION I
03:24:21.882 --> 03:24:25.086
THINK. THIS ACTION HERE WILL
03:24:25.152 --> 03:24:27.855
SET THE STAGE IN THE FLOOR FOR
03:24:27.922 --> 03:24:28.656
WHAT COULD BE DONE BACK HOME IN
03:24:28.723 --> 03:24:30.691
LOS ANGELES AND ALL ACROSS THE
03:24:30.758 --> 03:24:32.860
STATE I HOPE THAT CITIES SEE
03:24:32.927 --> 03:24:33.794
THIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
03:24:33.861 --> 03:24:36.497
EDUCATE. I'M NOT JUST IN THE
03:24:36.564 --> 03:24:37.198
CASE IN HISTORY BY THE HIS OF
03:24:37.264 --> 03:24:38.532
EACH OF OUR CITIES IN IN IN
03:24:38.599 --> 03:24:39.634
TERMS OF RECONCILING THE
03:24:39.700 --> 03:24:42.403
HISTORY OF FOR INSTANCE THE KKK
03:24:42.470 --> 03:24:44.305
THAT WAS IN- LONG BEACH IN THE
03:24:44.372 --> 03:24:45.706
NINETEEN TWENTIES THAT WE-
03:24:45.773 --> 03:24:47.608
REALIZE. AND UNDERSTANDING WHAT
03:24:47.675 --> 03:24:53.381
WE CAN DO HERE TO CHANGE- THE.
03:24:53.447 --> 03:24:54.649
CHANGE WERE WERE WERE AT. AN
03:24:54.715 --> 03:24:56.584
IMPROVEMENT NOT JUST A- MAY
03:24:56.651 --> 03:24:57.184
IT'S GOING TO BE LISTENING AND
03:24:57.251 --> 03:24:59.320
AS A COUPLE WITH A LOT OF
03:24:59.387 --> 03:25:01.455
ACTION. WHICH IS WHAT I HOPE.
03:25:01.522 --> 03:25:03.090
THE MOST- IMPORTANT THING A
03:25:03.157 --> 03:25:04.859
PROFOUND THING FOR ME. AND THE
03:25:04.925 --> 03:25:08.095
TASK FORCE. RECOMMENDATIONS WAS
03:25:08.162 --> 03:25:08.663
THE APPROPRIATE WAYS EDUCATE
03:25:08.729 --> 03:25:10.364
THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC OF THE
03:25:10.431 --> 03:25:11.632
TASK FORCE'S FINDINGS AND
03:25:11.699 --> 03:25:13.200
ENSURING THAT EVERYBODY.
03:25:13.267 --> 03:25:14.502
UNDERSTANDS OUR HISTORY IN THIS
03:25:14.568 --> 03:25:16.303
WAY- BUT IT'S GOING TO SET THE
03:25:16.370 --> 03:25:17.571
STAGE CERTAINLY FOR
03:25:17.638 --> 03:25:20.675
TRANSFORMATIONAL CHANGE WHICH
03:25:20.741 --> 03:25:22.176
I'M VERY PROUD TO. TO THE-
03:25:22.243 --> 03:25:26.447
THANK YOU AGAIN. THANK YOU
03:25:26.514 --> 03:25:28.649
SENATOR STERN. FROM THE NETWORK
03:25:28.716 --> 03:25:31.285
OF LOS IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY
03:25:31.352 --> 03:25:33.454
A FEW WORDS WE'VE GOT YOU THERE
03:25:33.521 --> 03:25:35.289
GO AHEAD DIDN'T. SHARE WITH US
03:25:35.356 --> 03:25:36.657
YOUR THOUGHTS. THANK YOU MADAM
03:25:36.724 --> 03:25:38.526
CHAIR AND THANK YOU SENATOR
03:25:38.592 --> 03:25:41.729
BRADFORD INTO DOCTOR WEBER FOR
03:25:41.796 --> 03:25:43.664
EDUCATING ALL OF US NOT JUST-
03:25:43.731 --> 03:25:44.965
THOSE OF US IN THE IN THE
03:25:45.032 --> 03:25:46.067
BUILDING BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE
03:25:46.133 --> 03:25:48.002
STUDENTS AROUND THE STATE AND
03:25:48.069 --> 03:25:49.870
THE NATION ARE BENEFITING FROM
03:25:49.937 --> 03:25:52.339
YOUR INSISTENCE ON. SOME TRUTH
03:25:52.406 --> 03:25:53.708
AND RECONCILIATION HERE IN
03:25:53.774 --> 03:25:59.046
CALIFORNIA I DID HAVE. QUESTION
03:25:59.113 --> 03:26:01.015
JUST IN TERMS OF THE SCOPE I
03:26:01.082 --> 03:26:04.719
WAS LOOKING AT. WASHINGTON POST.
03:26:04.785 --> 03:26:09.323
IF HE'S THAT SOMEBODY USING UP
03:26:09.390 --> 03:26:12.860
AND IN. COMPLICITY IN THIS
03:26:12.927 --> 03:26:17.198
SPECIFIC UNIVERSE. TERRY
03:26:17.264 --> 03:26:20.534
INSTITUTION CHURCH THAT HAS OF
03:26:20.601 --> 03:26:22.703
DOC. HISTORY AND WHEN BACK FOR
03:26:22.770 --> 03:26:24.572
ENOUGH TO TRY THAT AND DO THE
03:26:24.638 --> 03:26:27.975
ACCOUNTING- ENDS AS IT MY
03:26:28.042 --> 03:26:29.710
COLLEAGUES IN AND YOU ALL OF
03:26:29.777 --> 03:26:31.512
BROUGHT UP CALIFORNIA'S
03:26:31.579 --> 03:26:34.815
HISTORY- IS NOT AS A FREE STATE
03:26:34.882 --> 03:26:36.617
BUT AS A SORT OF A SECRET
03:26:36.684 --> 03:26:38.819
STUDIES STATE IN FACT THE GOLD
03:26:38.886 --> 03:26:40.688
RUSH AND I PLUGGED THE ACLU FOR
03:26:40.755 --> 03:26:42.757
THEIR RECENT WORK PUBLISHING
03:26:42.823 --> 03:26:44.425
GOLD CHAINS WERE WHICH
03:26:44.492 --> 03:26:46.594
DOCUMENTED HISTORY IN FACT OF
03:26:46.660 --> 03:26:49.964
US. SELLING SLAVES IN THIS
03:26:50.030 --> 03:26:52.633
STATE AND BRINGING SLAVES IN
03:26:52.700 --> 03:26:53.768
AND IN THIS ACTUALLY BUILDING
03:26:53.834 --> 03:26:56.203
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY ON THE
03:26:56.270 --> 03:26:59.240
BACK OF SLAVERY IN HIDDEN FORM
03:26:59.306 --> 03:27:02.343
AS MINORS- AND OTHER OTHER
03:27:02.409 --> 03:27:06.080
FORCED LABOR BUT I'M WONDERING-
03:27:06.147 --> 03:27:09.250
IT IS THE- ARE REQUIREMENTS IN
03:27:09.316 --> 03:27:13.587
THE- I WAS TRYING. REACH INTO.
03:27:13.654 --> 03:27:14.388
THE TEXT ITSELF JUST MAKE SURE
03:27:14.455 --> 03:27:15.756
THE WE'RE GONNA BE ABLE PUSH
03:27:15.823 --> 03:27:17.925
PRIDE INSTITUTIONS AND SOLICIT
03:27:17.992 --> 03:27:20.761
DATA FROM THEM TO ACTUALLY BE
03:27:20.828 --> 03:27:22.496
ABLE TO GO BACK AND TRACK-
03:27:22.563 --> 03:27:23.697
FRIENDS IT'S IN BANKING
03:27:23.764 --> 03:27:26.100
INSTITUTIONS. OR UNIVERSITIES
03:27:26.167 --> 03:27:30.304
THAT MAY HAVE OWNED SLAVES- DO
03:27:30.371 --> 03:27:33.440
WE HAVE IT IT WITH IT WITH THIS
03:27:33.507 --> 03:27:36.110
COMMISSION- HAVE ENOUGH FORCE
03:27:36.177 --> 03:27:39.747
IN LAW TO BE ABLE TO- GO BACK
03:27:39.814 --> 03:27:44.385
CAN COMPEL THAT DATA. DO YOU
03:27:44.451 --> 03:27:46.487
HAVE AN ANSWER FOR THAT TO THE
03:27:46.554 --> 03:27:48.589
WORLD WAR WORKING RIGHT NOW
03:27:48.656 --> 03:27:50.858
WITH THE COMMISSIONER A RECORD
03:27:50.925 --> 03:27:52.593
A LOT OF MAKING IN GOING BACK
03:27:52.660 --> 03:27:54.728
TO STORE LOOKING AT THOSE
03:27:54.795 --> 03:27:57.598
COMPANIES BAD IN SHE- IN
03:27:57.665 --> 03:28:01.669
INVESTED IN SLAVE AND THOSE PAY
03:28:01.735 --> 03:28:02.303
OUT THAT MANY OF THESE COURT.
03:28:02.369 --> 03:28:05.306
AGREES DO TO SLAVE OWNERS SO
03:28:05.372 --> 03:28:07.675
THAT'S FIRST STARTED WE COME
03:28:07.741 --> 03:28:10.444
COMMISSIONER FOR WORKING HAND
03:28:10.511 --> 03:28:11.812
IN HAND WITH NOT ONLY DOCTOR
03:28:11.879 --> 03:28:12.847
WERE BROKE THE LEGISLATIVE LIKE
03:28:12.913 --> 03:28:18.485
OFFICE ON THE AS WELL. WE WILL
03:28:18.552 --> 03:28:20.888
OF THE DEL A LOT DEEPER I THIS
03:28:20.955 --> 03:28:22.156
EIGHT MEMBER COMMISSION HELP
03:28:22.223 --> 03:28:26.794
BILL OUT. FACT WHICH- IS
03:28:26.861 --> 03:28:28.696
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT LIKE
03:28:28.762 --> 03:28:29.964
RIGHT TO RAW AND LOCAL THE FOR
03:28:30.030 --> 03:28:35.102
AND EXT. SOME OF THE. WRONGS
03:28:35.169 --> 03:28:37.238
THAT HAVE HOP OVER THE LAST
03:28:37.304 --> 03:28:39.106
HUNDRED ANDSIXTY YEAR SINCE WE
03:28:39.173 --> 03:28:41.408
AND THE PROBLEM THAT WERE TO
03:28:41.475 --> 03:28:42.243
AFFERENTS AFTER AMERICANS HAVE
03:28:42.309 --> 03:28:43.310
BEEN BROUGH SO YOU WE LOOKING
03:28:43.377 --> 03:28:45.379
AT THAT WERE LITTLE LOOKING AT
03:28:45.446 --> 03:28:48.082
COME ALSO A YOU SAY A NEW YORK
03:28:48.148 --> 03:28:50.451
WHO INVESTED. IN THE SLAVE
03:28:50.517 --> 03:28:51.552
TRADE IN ON THESE COAST OF WELL
03:28:51.619 --> 03:28:53.320
SO WHERE WERE THE WITH THE THAT
03:28:53.387 --> 03:28:57.958
WE BE EXPLORING YES. EXCELLENT
03:28:58.025 --> 03:28:59.660
I'M LOOKING THANKS FOR THE CALL
03:28:59.727 --> 03:29:00.961
FOR THAT WAS ACTUALLY ONLY IF
03:29:01.028 --> 03:29:02.396
UP WAS HOW IT GOING THE ENSURE
03:29:02.463 --> 03:29:03.831
COMMISSIONER AS WELL AS WITH
03:29:03.898 --> 03:29:08.969
THE. UC REGENTS I KNOW WE DO A
03:29:09.036 --> 03:29:10.504
TIMING. LAW ON THE AND IS WANT
03:29:10.571 --> 03:29:11.338
TO SEE KIND OF PROGRESS ROOM.
03:29:11.405 --> 03:29:13.040
BUT YOU WILL TO ADDRESS THAT IN
03:29:13.107 --> 03:29:14.675
YOUR CLUB. THERE'S EVER AN
03:29:14.742 --> 03:29:16.243
OPPORTUNE TO WORK DO A MAY
03:29:16.310 --> 03:29:18.112
FURTHER I'D LOVE TO BE ARMS A
03:29:18.178 --> 03:29:19.980
AUTHOR BUT AT THIS POINT I JUST
03:29:20.047 --> 03:29:23.751
A- STRONG. I AND YOU KNOW TO A-
03:29:23.817 --> 03:29:25.786
I'M TODAY'S A DAY OF MY IF
03:29:25.853 --> 03:29:27.354
INDEED YOU FOR. IT'S TO SHIP
03:29:27.421 --> 03:29:29.823
WITH IS THIS. DAY OF THE YEAR
03:29:29.890 --> 03:29:33.027
WHERE WE MOURN. THE LOSS OF
03:29:33.093 --> 03:29:35.829
PEOPLE THROUGHOUT HISTORY AND
03:29:35.896 --> 03:29:39.600
OUR OUR LOSS OF HOLINESS AND-
03:29:39.667 --> 03:29:40.601
IT ADDS ONLY APPROPRIATE TODAY
03:29:40.668 --> 03:29:42.202
THAT WE REFLECT ON OUR OWN
03:29:42.269 --> 03:29:44.238
SADNESS AT THIS. FEDERAL INCOME.
03:29:44.305 --> 03:29:45.973
IN ALL THIS. THANK YOU FOR
03:29:46.040 --> 03:29:54.915
BRINGING US TODAY. MARTY THE-
03:29:54.982 --> 03:29:57.618
SINGLE FOR DEBATE OR DO ON TO
03:29:57.685 --> 03:30:00.521
THANK YOU AS WELL AND THANK THE
03:30:00.587 --> 03:30:01.588
HUNDRED SO WHO GOT ON THE PHONE
03:30:01.655 --> 03:30:04.858
AND PAY WE TO THEIR FOR THIS
03:30:04.925 --> 03:30:10.531
MEASURE. IT IS MORE LONG DUE.
03:30:10.597 --> 03:30:13.367
BOGGLES MY MIND THAT TO WE ARE
03:30:13.434 --> 03:30:16.737
SO IGNORANT ACTUALLY OF A LOT
03:30:16.804 --> 03:30:19.406
OF THE HISTORY OF THIS COUNTRY.
03:30:19.473 --> 03:30:21.175
EVEN THOSE OF OUR AND ESTERS
03:30:21.241 --> 03:30:23.544
THAT WE'RE NOT COMPLICIT BACK
03:30:23.610 --> 03:30:25.579
IN THE EIGHTEEN FIFTIES OF WHO
03:30:25.646 --> 03:30:26.714
WERE EITHER IGNORANT OR
03:30:26.780 --> 03:30:28.916
UNINFORMED AND FRANKLY IN
03:30:28.983 --> 03:30:30.451
READING THIS DOCUMENT I
03:30:30.517 --> 03:30:33.387
REALIZED THAT I ALSO LIKE I
03:30:33.454 --> 03:30:34.621
THINK PROBABLY MOST OF US. ARE
03:30:34.688 --> 03:30:38.325
NOT AWARE OF THE DEPTHS. OF THE
03:30:38.392 --> 03:30:42.629
DISCRIMINATION AND THE- CURRENT
03:30:42.696 --> 03:30:45.766
EXTRAORDINARY DE HUMANIZATION.
03:30:45.833 --> 03:30:48.168
OF OUR BROTHERS AND SISTERS IN
03:30:48.235 --> 03:30:50.070
THE AFRICAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY
03:30:50.137 --> 03:30:53.007
SO I FIND THIS TO BE A VERY
03:30:53.073 --> 03:30:54.641
IMPORTANT WORTHWHILE MOMENT TO
03:30:54.708 --> 03:30:57.711
ITS COMP AIDED. TO THE EXTENT
03:30:57.778 --> 03:31:00.481
THAT. THE AMERICA WE ALL AS A
03:31:00.547 --> 03:31:04.084
TRIBUTE TO ASCRIBE TO IS REALLY
03:31:04.151 --> 03:31:06.520
AN ASPIRATIONAL AMERICA. THAT
03:31:06.587 --> 03:31:07.721
WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT US
03:31:07.788 --> 03:31:10.824
HISTORICALLY VIRTUALLY EVERY.
03:31:10.891 --> 03:31:14.028
IMMIGRANT GROUP IN THIS COUNTRY
03:31:14.094 --> 03:31:15.796
WAS DISCRIMINATED AGAINST I
03:31:15.863 --> 03:31:17.364
THINK OF OUR NATIVE AMERICAN
03:31:17.431 --> 03:31:19.733
BROTHERS AND SISTERS WHO WERE
03:31:19.800 --> 03:31:24.338
SYSTEMATICALLY- OF VICTIMIZED-
03:31:24.405 --> 03:31:27.508
I THINK OF. A JUST ABOUT EVERY
03:31:27.574 --> 03:31:29.676
GROUP- WHEN THEY CAME NEAR THE
03:31:29.743 --> 03:31:33.514
IRISH THE ITALIANS IN NEW YORK
03:31:33.580 --> 03:31:34.615
CAN CERTAINLY MY A JEWISH
03:31:34.681 --> 03:31:38.085
ANCESTORS BUT NOBODY ARE AT
03:31:38.152 --> 03:31:42.289
UNDER WENT THE BLATANT A BREAK
03:31:42.356 --> 03:31:47.394
UP OF. AND THE D. HUMAN. WE
03:31:47.461 --> 03:31:49.563
BROUGHT PEOPLE OVER TO THEIR- A
03:31:49.630 --> 03:31:51.265
FROM AFRICA IN SEOUL OFF
03:31:51.331 --> 03:31:54.535
FAMILIES. IT IN BUT HE DIDN'T
03:31:54.601 --> 03:31:56.236
IN A WAY THAT ABSOLUTELY IN
03:31:56.303 --> 03:31:59.006
HUMAN. AND INCOMPREHENSIBLE
03:31:59.073 --> 03:32:00.808
FRANKLY I THINK TO SOME OF US
03:32:00.874 --> 03:32:03.544
SO TO LEARN ABOUT THAT IN TO
03:32:03.610 --> 03:32:04.044
FACE THE HISTORY OF THIS
03:32:04.111 --> 03:32:06.547
COUNTRY. IN HOPES SAYS IN THE
03:32:06.613 --> 03:32:08.082
SPIRIT OF JOHN LEWIS WOULD MAKE
03:32:08.148 --> 03:32:11.952
US BETTER I THINK IS. AN
03:32:12.019 --> 03:32:13.620
OPPORTUNITY THAT WE CERTAINLY
03:32:13.687 --> 03:32:15.589
CANNOT AND SHOULD NOT BUT
03:32:15.656 --> 03:32:19.159
PASSED SO WITH THAT- SENATOR
03:32:19.226 --> 03:32:20.794
SHOULD LIKE TO CLOSE FOR SMART
03:32:20.861 --> 03:32:21.962
I WOULD TAKE YOUR COMMENTS AS
03:32:22.029 --> 03:32:23.964
MY CLOTHES BUT I WILL TRY TO
03:32:24.031 --> 03:32:25.966
RESPOND TO SOME OF THE CONCERN
03:32:26.033 --> 03:32:28.268
ISSUES THAT SIN REPORTAGE REYES
03:32:28.335 --> 03:32:29.837
AS FAR AS THE NUMBER OF THE-
03:32:29.903 --> 03:32:34.842
OF. THIS ARE COMMITTEE- RIGHT
03:32:34.908 --> 03:32:38.378
NOW WHY OPEN TO GET THIS WHAT
03:32:38.445 --> 03:32:39.947
EIGHT PASSED TO SO I'M PRETTY
03:32:40.013 --> 03:32:45.886
WE WHAT WE LOOK AT A LARGE.
03:32:45.953 --> 03:32:47.221
BODY IF THAT WAS. YEAH WE WILL.
03:32:47.287 --> 03:32:50.090
BUT AS SAY YOU DO FOR ONE THAT
03:32:50.157 --> 03:32:52.493
SO START WITH THAT EIGHT BUT
03:32:52.559 --> 03:32:54.728
WE'RE- SURE AND WE ARE GONNA
03:32:54.795 --> 03:32:57.364
SIGN. THAT BILLS EIGHT OURS THE
03:32:57.431 --> 03:32:58.899
MOST. PEOPLE ON THIS WITH THIS
03:32:58.966 --> 03:33:00.701
ISSUE WE'RE JUST GONNA A SONG
03:33:00.767 --> 03:33:02.636
AN OLD PEOPLE BE A SIGN WILLIE
03:33:02.703 --> 03:33:05.305
NAY. TO LET'S LOOK AT REBEL WE
03:33:05.372 --> 03:33:07.374
WANT HIS STORY WE WANT PEOPLE
03:33:07.441 --> 03:33:08.675
WHO HAVE A LEGAL BACKGROUND
03:33:08.742 --> 03:33:11.078
RESEARCH BACKGROUND ALL THOSE
03:33:11.145 --> 03:33:12.279
THINGS ARE GONNA BE NECESSARY
03:33:12.346 --> 03:33:15.015
TO TRACE BACK ALL THE DAMAGES.
03:33:15.082 --> 03:33:18.519
AND RIGHTS THAT PEOPLE. WHO
03:33:18.585 --> 03:33:21.255
HAVE BEEN IN SLAVE ARE ENTITLED
03:33:21.321 --> 03:33:22.789
TO THROUGH OUT THE FOUR HUNDRED
03:33:22.856 --> 03:33:24.591
YEARS OF BEING BROUGHT TO THIS
03:33:24.658 --> 03:33:26.960
LAND AS FAR AS A DIVERSITY OF
03:33:27.027 --> 03:33:30.164
OPINION THAT'S CRITICAL- I A
03:33:30.230 --> 03:33:35.636
FEW SPEAKING PARTY I THINK.
03:33:35.702 --> 03:33:36.770
ONLY OUR CURRENT. WAS NOT A
03:33:36.837 --> 03:33:40.274
THAT A LINCOLN OR- IN IN AND
03:33:40.340 --> 03:33:41.909
NOT UNDER THAT HE PROBABLY
03:33:41.975 --> 03:33:43.410
WASN'T THAT AFTERNOON UP UNTIL
03:33:43.477 --> 03:33:45.746
THE SICK WERE REPUBLIC SO WE
03:33:45.812 --> 03:33:48.448
WANT DIVERSITY OF POLITICAL
03:33:48.515 --> 03:33:50.617
PARTY BACK TOOL WE WORK AS A
03:33:50.684 --> 03:33:52.286
PEOPLE AND THAT'S WHO WE WILL
03:33:52.352 --> 03:33:54.755
CONTINUE TO BE SO WE WILL WALK
03:33:54.821 --> 03:33:57.124
OUT BIPARTISAN PARTICIPATION AS
03:33:57.191 --> 03:33:59.326
IT MAKES UP THIS BODY BECAUSE
03:33:59.393 --> 03:34:00.761
AGAIN. MARTIN LUTHER KING'S
03:34:00.827 --> 03:34:02.596
FAMILY WERE REPUBLICANS UNTIL
03:34:02.663 --> 03:34:05.332
THE SIXTIES UNTIL KENNEDY. BUT
03:34:05.399 --> 03:34:07.100
A LOT OF FOLKS DON'T KNOW THAT.
03:34:07.167 --> 03:34:09.536
IN MANY BLACKS. REPUBLICANS
03:34:09.603 --> 03:34:14.608
THIS COUNTRY UNTIL THE EARLY.
03:34:14.675 --> 03:34:15.242
SIXTIES BECAUSE A RIVER LINCOLN
03:34:15.309 --> 03:34:18.312
AND HE DID THE FREE FLOW. AND
03:34:18.378 --> 03:34:20.147
WHAT HE IN A MATTER PROP. OF
03:34:20.214 --> 03:34:25.619
THE OF ROUGH. THAT WAS QUICKLY
03:34:25.686 --> 03:34:27.354
ALL. AFTER HIS A SOUTH. THE P.
03:34:27.421 --> 03:34:29.356
FILLED UNDERSTAND. AND THE
03:34:29.423 --> 03:34:30.924
ROUNDABOUT WAY TO RE
03:34:30.991 --> 03:34:33.694
INSTITUTIONALIZING SLAVERY
03:34:33.760 --> 03:34:34.695
THROUGH THE THIRTEENTH
03:34:34.761 --> 03:34:37.264
AMENDMENT MASS INCARCERATION IS
03:34:37.331 --> 03:34:39.032
NOTHING NEW HERE WHEN IT COMES
03:34:39.099 --> 03:34:40.467
TO PEOPLE OF COLOR IN THIS
03:34:40.534 --> 03:34:41.969
COUNTRY AND THE THIRTEENTH
03:34:42.035 --> 03:34:45.439
AMENDMENT HAS ALLOWED WHO BY
03:34:45.505 --> 03:34:47.908
SLAVERY THE LAST. HUNDRED AND
03:34:47.975 --> 03:34:50.644
YEARS TO MASS GARCIA. AND WHEN
03:34:50.711 --> 03:34:53.547
TALK ABOUT THE NUMBER OF SINGLE
03:34:53.614 --> 03:34:55.649
FAMILIES. LIKE FAMILIES IN THIS
03:34:55.716 --> 03:34:57.251
COUNTRY AGAIN THIS IS BEEN
03:34:57.317 --> 03:35:01.321
INSTITUTIONAL. IT WAS TO BLACK
03:35:01.388 --> 03:35:03.890
FAMILIES ADVANTAGES THE KICKED
03:35:03.957 --> 03:35:05.192
THE MAN OUT THE HOUSE BECAUSE
03:35:05.259 --> 03:35:06.893
WHAT THE IT LEARN TO SLAVERY
03:35:06.960 --> 03:35:08.462
SEPARATING FAMILIES AND THAT'S
03:35:08.528 --> 03:35:10.564
WHAT WE'VE DONE INSTITUTIONAL
03:35:10.631 --> 03:35:12.099
TO AFRICAN AMERICANS IN THIS
03:35:12.165 --> 03:35:14.635
COUNTRY. FOR AGAIN SINCE OUR
03:35:14.701 --> 03:35:16.403
EXISTENCE AND THAT'S HAS
03:35:16.470 --> 03:35:19.072
MEANING REMY TALK ABOUT HOW ARE
03:35:19.139 --> 03:35:19.873
YOU IMAGE IN THE LOW
03:35:19.940 --> 03:35:21.341
PERFORMANCE OF SCORES IN
03:35:21.408 --> 03:35:23.510
EDUCATION IN THIS COUNTRY WENT
03:35:23.577 --> 03:35:26.747
AT THE TURN OF THE CENTURY. I
03:35:26.813 --> 03:35:28.982
AN AMERICAN SHIP INSTEAD OF
03:35:29.049 --> 03:35:30.150
LEARNING THE OTHER GROUP IN
03:35:30.217 --> 03:35:31.251
THIS COUNTRY MORE THAN THE
03:35:31.318 --> 03:35:32.519
CATHOLIC MORE THAN THE JEWS
03:35:32.586 --> 03:35:34.087
MORE THAN ANYONE ELSE AND IN
03:35:34.154 --> 03:35:36.123
THE NINETEEN HUNDREDS TO THE-
03:35:36.189 --> 03:35:37.557
THOUSANDS THIS. BLACK COLLEGES
03:35:37.624 --> 03:35:40.360
WE VALUE EDUCATION BUT THROUGH
03:35:40.427 --> 03:35:46.199
THE SYSTEMATICS. SYSTEM HERE IN
03:35:46.266 --> 03:35:50.437
AMERICA DISCO OPPRESSION OF THE
03:35:50.504 --> 03:35:57.077
NILE. PUNISHING YOU LEARN
03:35:57.144 --> 03:35:58.245
GETTING YOUR EYES GOUGED OUT AS
03:35:58.312 --> 03:36:01.381
A SLAVE FOR LEARNING TO READ.
03:36:01.448 --> 03:36:04.017
BEING PUT TO DEATH LOSE YEAH I
03:36:04.084 --> 03:36:04.885
HAD EIGHT. A LAW ON THE BOOKS
03:36:04.951 --> 03:36:06.186
UP UNTIL THE LATE EIGHTEEN
03:36:06.253 --> 03:36:07.821
HUNDREDS ACT IF YOU WERE A
03:36:07.888 --> 03:36:09.756
SLAVE IN YOU TALK TO YOUR CHILD
03:36:09.823 --> 03:36:11.258
TO READ. YOU COULD BE SENTENCED
03:36:11.325 --> 03:36:14.027
TO DEATH. THERE WERE SEVENTY
03:36:14.094 --> 03:36:15.062
TWO LAWS ON THE BOOKS IN
03:36:15.128 --> 03:36:17.130
LOUISIANA. FOR DEATH FOR BLACK
03:36:17.197 --> 03:36:19.066
FOLKS ONLY TO WIN A RELATED TO
03:36:19.132 --> 03:36:21.835
WHITES. SO WHAT THIS IS AT ALL
03:36:21.902 --> 03:36:22.836
OF YOU AGREE TO IS A HISTORY
03:36:22.903 --> 03:36:24.705
LESSON. IS A HISTORY LESSON
03:36:24.771 --> 03:36:27.341
THAT WE SO BADLY NEED HERE IN
03:36:27.407 --> 03:36:30.410
THIS COUNTRY. ABOUT WHAT. WE
03:36:30.477 --> 03:36:31.912
WHAT THIS COUNTRY IS
03:36:31.978 --> 03:36:33.847
REPRESENTED. IT'S BADLY EEDED
03:36:33.914 --> 03:36:36.283
SO I'M HONORED TO BE. A JOINT
03:36:36.350 --> 03:36:37.818
AUTHORED DOCTOR WEBER A CALL
03:36:37.884 --> 03:36:41.388
AUTHORED SHOULD TO. DOCTOR
03:36:41.455 --> 03:36:44.558
WHETHER WAS DOCTOR WAS MINE.
03:36:44.624 --> 03:36:46.226
TEACHER MY FOR YEAR IN COLLEGE.
03:36:46.293 --> 03:36:48.929
AND I DROPPED TO REPLY BECAUSE
03:36:48.995 --> 03:36:51.598
I SAW HOW YOU'LL BE FEEL
03:36:51.665 --> 03:36:55.802
PREPARED I WAS. A THE BAR HIS
03:36:55.869 --> 03:36:58.905
IN THIS COUNTRY ARE AMERICA
03:36:58.972 --> 03:37:00.507
HISTORY SO. HELLO TRACK THERE
03:37:00.574 --> 03:37:03.577
BUT IT ALL TIES IN WHAT. THIS
03:37:03.643 --> 03:37:05.679
BILL IS ABOUT AND AGAIN IT DOES
03:37:05.746 --> 03:37:07.180
NOT SPELL OUT THE FORMER
03:37:07.247 --> 03:37:09.049
REFEREE THAT WE WILL THAT WE
03:37:09.116 --> 03:37:11.151
WILL TAKE. BUT I EVERY DOES
03:37:11.218 --> 03:37:13.420
TAKE A BLUE ON UP AS MESSED TO
03:37:13.487 --> 03:37:15.489
ADDRESS THE PERSISTENT A FAX OF
03:37:15.555 --> 03:37:18.191
SLAVERY AND ITS SUCCESSORS.
03:37:18.258 --> 03:37:20.994
INCLUDING JIM CORAL.
03:37:21.061 --> 03:37:23.430
SHARECROPPING REDLINING WAY TO
03:37:23.497 --> 03:37:27.067
LABOR. OVER IN CARS OVER POLICE.
03:37:27.134 --> 03:37:29.669
AND SYSTEMATIC DISCRIMINATION
03:37:29.736 --> 03:37:34.141
IN THE PAST WE HAVE. RIGHTLY
03:37:34.207 --> 03:37:35.008
ADDRESS DEGREE JUST WRONG TO
03:37:35.075 --> 03:37:36.843
REPARATIONS FOR JAPANESE
03:37:36.910 --> 03:37:38.512
BROTHERS AND SISTERS WHO WERE
03:37:38.578 --> 03:37:40.547
PUT AN INTERNMENT CAMPS DURING
03:37:40.614 --> 03:37:42.949
WORLD WAR TWO. WE'VE GOT
03:37:43.016 --> 03:37:45.118
DRESSED AND IN THE BEST WAY SO
03:37:45.185 --> 03:37:47.220
FAR FAR NATIVE AMERICANS WHO
03:37:47.287 --> 03:37:49.156
HAD. ALL OF THEIR LAND STOLEN
03:37:49.222 --> 03:37:51.725
FROM THEM. ALL THE COASTAL
03:37:51.792 --> 03:37:55.128
LOWLANDS MALIBU TO NORTHERN
03:37:55.195 --> 03:37:55.762
CALIFORNIA THAT WAS ALL NATIVE
03:37:55.829 --> 03:37:57.330
AMERICAN LANDS THOSE REST
03:37:57.397 --> 03:37:58.765
RESERVATIONS WHERE THEY ARE NOW
03:37:58.832 --> 03:38:01.535
IN LYNN AND ROCKY ON FAR BEHIND
03:38:01.601 --> 03:38:03.203
RANCH THE LAND. WAS A
03:38:03.270 --> 03:38:07.407
PUNISHMENT. THANK AND THEIR LAN
03:38:07.474 --> 03:38:08.675
STAKING AWAY THAT TO MAKE
03:38:08.742 --> 03:38:12.078
SOMEONE MAY TO MEN'S I SHOULD
03:38:12.145 --> 03:38:14.014
SAY TO. THE COMPACT SO WE
03:38:14.080 --> 03:38:16.183
PROVIDE THEM TO BUT NOT AFTER
03:38:16.249 --> 03:38:19.986
AMERICAN. WE HAVE YET TO SEE.
03:38:20.053 --> 03:38:22.355
ANY JUSTICE SO WE RECKON IT AND
03:38:22.422 --> 03:38:25.425
A THREE A RESPONSE. AND THE
03:38:25.492 --> 03:38:30.230
GREATER. THE LONGER THE LEGACY.
03:38:30.297 --> 03:38:32.165
THE WANTED AT A REPARATIONS
03:38:32.232 --> 03:38:33.800
AFTER THE CIVIL CIVIL WAR THAT
03:38:33.867 --> 03:38:36.036
WAS PROMISED THE FORTY ACRES
03:38:36.102 --> 03:38:38.772
AND A MULE WAS REVERSED AS I
03:38:38.839 --> 03:38:41.007
STATED SHIRLEY AFTER LINCOLN
03:38:41.074 --> 03:38:42.409
WAS ASSASSINATED FORMER SLAVES
03:38:42.476 --> 03:38:45.846
ENDED UP WORKING ON THE LAND.
03:38:45.912 --> 03:38:48.815
OF THEIR FORMER- AND SLIPPERS.
03:38:48.882 --> 03:38:50.383
SOME REPARATIONS WERE ACTUALLY
03:38:50.450 --> 03:38:53.420
PAID BUT NOT TO THE SLAVE BUT
03:38:53.487 --> 03:38:55.188
TO THE FARMER. AND SLAVE OWNER
03:38:55.255 --> 03:38:56.857
WHO LOST THEIR SLAVES THEY WERE
03:38:56.923 --> 03:38:58.925
PAID COMPENSATION FOR THOSE
03:38:58.992 --> 03:39:02.529
SLAVES THAT HAS SINCE BEEN FREE.
03:39:02.596 --> 03:39:05.499
AGAIN THIS PANDEMIC HAS CLEARLY
03:39:05.565 --> 03:39:07.501
SHOWN ITS DISPROPORTIONATE
03:39:07.567 --> 03:39:09.836
IMPACT ON BLACK CALIFORNIA'S AS
03:39:09.903 --> 03:39:11.638
WELL AS BLACK AMERICANS AND
03:39:11.705 --> 03:39:13.773
IT'S ONLY THE LATEST REMINDER
03:39:13.840 --> 03:39:15.809
OF THE LEGACY OF SLAVERY THAT
03:39:15.876 --> 03:39:19.179
IS NEVER BEEN TRULY ADDRESSED
03:39:19.246 --> 03:39:19.779
AND IT'S SO FITTING THAT WE'RE
03:39:19.846 --> 03:39:22.249
DOING THIS. MEASURE TODAY AGAIN
03:39:22.315 --> 03:39:25.485
WE SAN PAYING HOMAGE TO THE
03:39:25.552 --> 03:39:27.621
JEWISH RELATIONSHIP AS IT IS
03:39:27.687 --> 03:39:29.422
MORE INTO THE LOSS BUT WE MORE
03:39:29.489 --> 03:39:32.492
JOHN LEWIS TODAY HE WAS LAID TO
03:39:32.559 --> 03:39:35.495
REST TODAY AND I WAS PROVIDED.
03:39:35.562 --> 03:39:38.098
THIS ESSAY THAT HE WROTE AND IT
03:39:38.164 --> 03:39:40.200
STATES TOGETHER. YOU CAN REDEEM
03:39:40.267 --> 03:39:42.402
THE SOUL OF OUR NATION WHAT
03:39:42.469 --> 03:39:44.538
TOGETHER WE CAN REDEEM THE SOUL
03:39:44.604 --> 03:39:45.839
OF CALIFORNIA BY VOTING YES ON
03:39:45.906 --> 03:39:47.407
THIS MEASURE I RESPECTFULLY
03:39:47.474 --> 03:39:49.242
RIVAL. THANK YOU I DO WE HAVE A
03:39:49.309 --> 03:39:51.244
MOTION ON THIS MATTER- MOTION
03:39:51.311 --> 03:39:53.113
BY SENATOR MORNING AND THE
03:39:53.179 --> 03:39:56.149
MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE SENATE
03:39:56.216 --> 03:40:00.420
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. AW
03:40:00.487 --> 03:40:02.055
AND WITH THAT. ONE ANGLER PUT
03:40:02.122 --> 03:40:06.259
OF CLEAR. CHAIR SENATOR YES I'D
03:40:06.326 --> 03:40:08.562
MADE SOME. AND I'D ASK YOU TO
03:40:08.628 --> 03:40:10.430
COMMENT ON THEM FURTHER. CAN
03:40:10.497 --> 03:40:12.666
YOU TAKE THESE RECOMMENDATIONS
03:40:12.732 --> 03:40:15.235
TO THE AUTHOR AND SEE WHETHER
03:40:15.302 --> 03:40:16.403
OR NOT BEFORE IT MAKES THE
03:40:16.469 --> 03:40:18.672
SENATE FLOOR. IF SHE WOULD GIVE
03:40:18.738 --> 03:40:20.607
SERIOUS CONSIDERATION. TO
03:40:20.674 --> 03:40:26.012
ARTICULATING. IN DETAIL. THE D.
03:40:26.079 --> 03:40:27.480
PROPOSED CONSTITUTION AND
03:40:27.547 --> 03:40:29.215
COMPOSITION OF THIS COMMISSION
03:40:29.282 --> 03:40:30.584
BECAUSE I THINK THAT SENATOR
03:40:30.650 --> 03:40:32.218
THAT LEAP WHICH NOT OF THE COIN
03:40:32.285 --> 03:40:34.688
THIS ORDER WE WE'VE HAD CLOSURE
03:40:34.754 --> 03:40:37.991
SENATOR PER- BRADFORD HIS
03:40:38.058 --> 03:40:41.061
CLOSED THANK YOU FOR THE LAST
03:40:41.127 --> 03:40:41.661
TIME. IT'S NOT FOR TE AND IF
03:40:41.728 --> 03:40:43.330
YOU WISH TO DISCUSS THIS WITH
03:40:43.396 --> 03:40:45.398
HIM FOR I'M SURE BE HAPPY TO DO
03:40:45.465 --> 03:40:47.167
THAT. IT'S NOW TIME TO VOTE ON
03:40:47.233 --> 03:40:50.437
pDO PASSED THE SENATE
03:40:50.503 --> 03:40:52.973
APPROPRIATIONS BOTTOM SECTOR
03:40:53.039 --> 03:40:54.074
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THAT IS
03:40:54.140 --> 03:40:55.375
PLEASE TURN OUR MICROPHONE'S ON
03:40:55.442 --> 03:40:59.713
THIS IS FILE ITEM. SEVENTEEN
03:40:59.779 --> 03:41:01.014
EIGHTY THIRTY ONE ANYONE DOCTOR
03:41:01.081 --> 03:41:03.984
WEBER. MEMBER WEBER THE MOTION
03:41:04.050 --> 03:41:06.620
IS DUE PASSED TO THE SENATE
03:41:06.686 --> 03:41:09.990
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
03:41:10.056 --> 03:41:15.862
ACCESS BY NOT ADDRESS. WHAT IS
03:41:15.929 --> 03:41:20.033
NOT VOTING DRESSEL HI THE REST
03:41:20.100 --> 03:41:24.537
I COULD HI AND THE I LAND.
03:41:24.604 --> 03:41:29.542
MELINDA NO MONNING I MONNING I
03:41:29.609 --> 03:41:35.782
STERN. NINE STERN I AMBERG.
03:41:35.849 --> 03:41:40.387
NUMBER FIVE Y. CALLES HI I CAN
03:41:40.453 --> 03:41:45.892
I. THE TWENTIETH OR FIVE SIX
03:41:45.959 --> 03:41:52.899
THAT SEVEN I WERE NO EVER HERE.
03:41:52.966 --> 03:41:56.703
SEVEN EYES A ONE NO. ONE ON
03:41:56.770 --> 03:41:59.506
VOTING OF THE MAY PASS THANK
03:41:59.572 --> 03:42:05.245
YOU MANAGER MANY MEMBERS. CURRY
03:42:05.311 --> 03:42:07.447
FILE ITEM EIGHTEEN THAT SENATOR
03:42:07.514 --> 03:42:09.349
TO RUSSIA WILL BE PRESENTING
03:42:09.416 --> 03:42:10.884
SENATOR IF YOU WOULDN'T MIND
03:42:10.950 --> 03:42:13.653
PRESENTING- AT THE DíAS THERE
03:42:13.720 --> 03:42:15.855
SO THAT THE THOSE WATCHING OR
03:42:15.922 --> 03:42:17.857
WEIRD. WHO'S PRESENTING AND SO
03:42:17.924 --> 03:42:32.138
FORTH. RIGHT SENATOR ALSO THE
03:42:32.205 --> 03:42:34.674
FLOOR IS YOURS THANK YOU ARE ON
03:42:34.741 --> 03:42:37.610
FIVE FOR THOSE LISTENING AB
03:42:37.677 --> 03:42:38.178
THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE IT'S
03:42:38.244 --> 03:42:40.013
FILE ITEM EIGHTEEN. THANK YOU
03:42:40.080 --> 03:42:41.414
SENATOR AWESOME THANK YOU MADAM
03:42:41.481 --> 03:42:44.250
CHAIR AND- COMMITTEE MEMBERS I
03:42:44.317 --> 03:42:47.153
AM PRESENTING AB ONE THIRTY ONE
03:42:47.220 --> 03:42:47.687
THIRTY THREE ON BEHALF OF
03:42:47.754 --> 03:42:49.122
ASSEMBLYMEMBER AGUIAR-CURRY
03:42:49.189 --> 03:42:51.691
TODAY. THIS BILL CODIFIES
03:42:51.758 --> 03:42:53.693
CALIFORNIA'S COMMITMENT TO
03:42:53.760 --> 03:42:56.029
RESETTLING REFUGEES WITHOUT
03:42:56.096 --> 03:42:58.531
DISCRIMINATION AS PART OF THE
03:42:58.598 --> 03:43:00.600
U. S. RECEPTION AND PLACEMENT
03:43:00.667 --> 03:43:03.870
PROGRAM. REFUGEES ARE MEN WOMEN
03:43:03.937 --> 03:43:05.638
AND CHILDREN WHO ARE FORCED TO
03:43:05.705 --> 03:43:07.841
FLEE THEIR COUNTRY OF ORIGIN.
03:43:07.907 --> 03:43:09.642
TO SEEK SAFETY IN ANOTHER
03:43:09.709 --> 03:43:12.445
COUNTRY DUE TO WAR.
03:43:12.512 --> 03:43:14.314
GOVERNMENTAL OF HABEL OR
03:43:14.380 --> 03:43:16.416
PERSECUTION BASED UPON THE
03:43:16.483 --> 03:43:18.651
RELIGION NATIONALITY OR
03:43:18.718 --> 03:43:20.687
MEMBERSHIP IN A PARTICULAR
03:43:20.754 --> 03:43:22.789
SOCIAL OR POLITICAL GROUP.
03:43:22.856 --> 03:43:25.325
CALIFORNIA HAS A LONG TRADITION
03:43:25.391 --> 03:43:27.193
OF OFFERING REFUGE TO THOSE IN
03:43:27.260 --> 03:43:29.028
NEED HAVE BEEN RECEIVED A
03:43:29.095 --> 03:43:31.030
SUPPORTED NEARLY RECORD A NEWLY
03:43:31.097 --> 03:43:34.100
ARRIVED REFUGEES SINCE NINETEEN
03:43:34.167 --> 03:43:35.835
EIGHTY PROBABLY BEFORE THAT.
03:43:35.902 --> 03:43:37.570
THESE REFUGEES THEN TURN AROUND
03:43:37.637 --> 03:43:39.439
AND CONTRIBUTE SIGNIFICANT
03:43:39.506 --> 03:43:41.207
ECONOMIC AND CULTURAL
03:43:41.274 --> 03:43:42.675
CONTRIBUTIONS TO OUR STATE
03:43:42.742 --> 03:43:44.778
INCLUDING SEVENTEEN BILLION
03:43:44.844 --> 03:43:47.914
DOLLARS IN SPENDING POWER AND
03:43:47.981 --> 03:43:48.782
THE DIVERSITY WE ARE SO PROUD
03:43:48.848 --> 03:43:50.250
OF. WITH FEDERAL FUNDING
03:43:50.316 --> 03:43:52.152
SUPPORT RESETTLEMENT AGENCIES
03:43:52.218 --> 03:43:54.587
PROVIDE DIRECT SUPPORT TO NEWLY
03:43:54.654 --> 03:43:57.056
ARRIVED REFUGEES ASYLUM SEEKERS
03:43:57.123 --> 03:43:59.559
AND DOCTOR RECIPIENTS THIS BILL
03:43:59.626 --> 03:44:02.762
CODIFIES INTO IN OUR STATE LAW
03:44:02.829 --> 03:44:04.597
THAT WE WILL CONTINUE TO UPHOLD
03:44:04.664 --> 03:44:06.266
OUR COMMITMENT. TO ASSISTING
03:44:06.332 --> 03:44:08.134
THOSE SEEKING REFUGE IN OUR
03:44:08.201 --> 03:44:11.371
COUNTRY AND STATE. AB THIRTY
03:44:11.437 --> 03:44:12.138
ONE THIRTY THREE HAS NO
03:44:12.205 --> 03:44:14.641
OPPOSITION AND IT IS A LOT THE
03:44:14.707 --> 03:44:16.442
YOU KNOW CAUCUS PRIORITY BILL I
03:44:16.509 --> 03:44:19.412
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK
03:44:19.479 --> 03:44:21.548
YOU SENATOR DORADO AND WE DO
03:44:21.614 --> 03:44:24.250
HAVE. A TWO WITNESSES IN THE
03:44:24.317 --> 03:44:26.553
QUEUE BUT I HAVE TO REMIND YOU
03:44:26.619 --> 03:44:27.120
ALL THAT DUE TO CONSTRAINTS
03:44:27.187 --> 03:44:28.221
REGARDING THE LENGTH OF
03:44:28.288 --> 03:44:30.056
HEARINGS. TECHNOLOGY
03:44:30.123 --> 03:44:31.491
CONSIDERATIONS AND CLEANING
03:44:31.558 --> 03:44:33.927
PROTOCOLS. COMMITTEES ARE
03:44:33.993 --> 03:44:35.695
INSTITUTING TIME LIMITS ON
03:44:35.762 --> 03:44:38.264
TESTIMONY AS AS AS A RESULT
03:44:38.331 --> 03:44:40.466
EACH SIDE IS PROVIDED ONLY
03:44:40.533 --> 03:44:41.968
THREE MINUTES ALL OTHERS
03:44:42.035 --> 03:44:43.603
WISHING TO TESTIFY MUST LIMIT
03:44:43.670 --> 03:44:46.806
THEIR COMMENTS TO THEIR NAME.
03:44:46.873 --> 03:44:47.440
AFFILIATION AND POSITION ON THE
03:44:47.507 --> 03:44:50.109
MEASURE. AND WITH THAT WE HAVE
03:44:50.176 --> 03:44:51.644
TWO WITNESSES WHO WILL SHARE
03:44:51.711 --> 03:44:52.812
THAT THREE MINUTE PERIOD OF
03:44:52.879 --> 03:44:55.248
TIME DONNA DO VENN EXECUTIVE
03:44:55.315 --> 03:44:59.152
DIRECTOR OF I RC SAN DIEGO. IS
03:44:59.219 --> 03:45:01.154
ARE ON THE LINE IN SUPPORT I'M
03:45:01.221 --> 03:45:03.022
SORRY DO WE HAVE MORE THAN ONE
03:45:03.089 --> 03:45:09.796
RESEARCH HAS ONE WITNESS. IF IT
03:45:09.863 --> 03:45:11.798
IS TRUST ONE WITNESS ON THE
03:45:11.865 --> 03:45:14.267
LINE THEN YOU WILL GET THOUGH
03:45:14.334 --> 03:45:16.336
THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK. DO WE
03:45:16.402 --> 03:45:18.371
KNOW IS THERE ANYONE ELSE ON
03:45:18.438 --> 03:45:21.875
THE LINE OTHER THAN DONNA DO
03:45:21.941 --> 03:45:24.444
FAN. NOW ALL RIGHT MISS DUBIN
03:45:24.510 --> 03:45:26.546
THE FLOOR IS YOURS YOUR OF UP
03:45:26.613 --> 03:45:30.316
TO THREE MINUTES. THANK YOU SO
03:45:30.383 --> 03:45:32.418
MUCH MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS-
03:45:32.485 --> 03:45:34.888
AS BAD I AM DONE I DO THEN I'M
03:45:34.954 --> 03:45:36.356
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR WITH THE
03:45:36.422 --> 03:45:38.124
INTERNATIONAL RESCUE COMMITTEE
03:45:38.191 --> 03:45:41.194
AND SAN DIEGO. AND WHEN WE TALK
03:45:41.261 --> 03:45:42.395
ABOUT THE INTERNATIONAL RESCUE
03:45:42.462 --> 03:45:44.097
COMMITTEE WE REFER TO THAT AS
03:45:44.163 --> 03:45:47.066
THE IRISH SEA- THE I RC AS THE
03:45:47.133 --> 03:45:49.168
REFUGEE RESETTLEMENT AGENCY WE
03:45:49.235 --> 03:45:52.171
HAVE TWENTY FIVE OFFICES SPREAD
03:45:52.238 --> 03:45:54.407
ACROSS FIFTEEN STATES IN THE US.
03:45:54.474 --> 03:45:57.010
AND HEARING CALIFORNIA WE HAVE
03:45:57.076 --> 03:45:59.279
SEVEN RESETTLEMENT SITES. WE
03:45:59.345 --> 03:46:01.180
ARE ONE OF NINE NATIONAL
03:46:01.247 --> 03:46:03.983
AGENCIES ASSISTING REFUGEES AND
03:46:04.050 --> 03:46:06.085
THE MAJORITY OF WHOM ARE
03:46:06.152 --> 03:46:08.354
REUNITING WITH FAMILY AFTER
03:46:08.421 --> 03:46:10.189
FLEEING WAR CONFLICT IN
03:46:10.256 --> 03:46:12.525
PERSECUTION. I'M PARTICIPATING
03:46:12.592 --> 03:46:13.893
TODAY TO REPRESENT THE IRISH
03:46:13.960 --> 03:46:18.164
HE'D SUPPORT FOR AB THIRTY ONE
03:46:18.231 --> 03:46:19.032
THIRTY THREE. I SPONSORED BY
03:46:19.098 --> 03:46:21.935
ASSEMBLYMEMBER AGUIAR-CURRY
03:46:22.001 --> 03:46:23.636
REFUGEE RESETTLEMENT OF THE
03:46:23.703 --> 03:46:25.672
PROCESS THAT IS DESIGNED AS A
03:46:25.738 --> 03:46:28.508
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP AND
03:46:28.574 --> 03:46:30.610
EVENTS MENTIONED- IT HAS BEEN
03:46:30.677 --> 03:46:32.645
BUILT OVER THE LAST FORTY YEARS
03:46:32.712 --> 03:46:34.814
AN INCORPORATE THAT THE SUPPORT
03:46:34.881 --> 03:46:35.581
OF FEDERAL AND STATE
03:46:35.648 --> 03:46:37.817
GOVERNMENT. MANY COMMUNITY
03:46:37.884 --> 03:46:39.886
PARTNERS. AND THE REFUGEE
03:46:39.953 --> 03:46:43.222
RESETTLING- AGENCIES THAT
03:46:43.289 --> 03:46:44.891
FACILITATE A SUCCESSFUL
03:46:44.958 --> 03:46:46.993
TRANSITION FOR OUR CLIENTS. AS
03:46:47.060 --> 03:46:49.062
RECESSES RESETTLEMENT AGENCIES
03:46:49.128 --> 03:46:50.630
WE WORK CLOSELY WITH A WIDE
03:46:50.697 --> 03:46:52.465
RANGE OF LOCAL AGENCIES CAN
03:46:52.532 --> 03:46:53.800
PROVIDE FEDERALLY FUNDED
03:46:53.866 --> 03:46:56.169
SUPPORT TO HELP NEWLY ARRIVED
03:46:56.235 --> 03:46:57.837
REFUGEES AND OTHER VULNERABLE
03:46:57.904 --> 03:46:59.605
GROUPS SUCH AS ASYLUM SEEKERS
03:46:59.672 --> 03:47:02.375
TO INTEGRATE INTO AND FIVE IN
03:47:02.442 --> 03:47:03.343
THE COMMUNITY. AND DESPITE ALL
03:47:03.409 --> 03:47:05.678
THIS COORDINATION. THEIR
03:47:05.745 --> 03:47:07.613
RELATIONSHIP THAT MANIFEST IN A
03:47:07.680 --> 03:47:09.515
SUCCESSFUL RESETTLEMENT PROGRAM
03:47:09.582 --> 03:47:12.452
CAN BE ELIMINATED IN AN ACTION
03:47:12.518 --> 03:47:14.887
AND SWIFT AS AN EXECUTIVE ORDER.
03:47:14.954 --> 03:47:15.621
IN THE LAST THREE YEARS THE
03:47:15.688 --> 03:47:17.857
RESETTLEMENT INFRASTRUCTURE HAS
03:47:17.924 --> 03:47:20.093
FACED UNPRECEDENTED ATTACKS
03:47:20.159 --> 03:47:21.494
AGAINST WHAT WAS ONCE A
03:47:21.561 --> 03:47:23.196
STANDARD ENJOYED BIPARTISAN
03:47:23.262 --> 03:47:25.999
SUPPORT. IN A FEW YEARS WE HAVE
03:47:26.065 --> 03:47:28.468
WITNESSED STATE BOB TO WITHDRAW
03:47:28.534 --> 03:47:30.803
FROM THE RESETTLEMENT PROGRAM.
03:47:30.870 --> 03:47:32.905
AND THEN ADMINISTRATION WHICH
03:47:32.972 --> 03:47:34.707
THIS PAST WINTER REQUIRED
03:47:34.774 --> 03:47:35.708
GOVERNORS AND LOCAL
03:47:35.775 --> 03:47:38.111
MUNICIPALITIES. TO PUBLICLY AND
03:47:38.177 --> 03:47:39.645
PROACTIVELY CERTIFIED THEIR
03:47:39.712 --> 03:47:42.448
CONSENT IF THEY WISH TO SEE WE
03:47:42.515 --> 03:47:43.016
SETTLEMENT CONTINUING THEIR
03:47:43.082 --> 03:47:45.885
STATE. ABSENT THERE'S BY AN
03:47:45.952 --> 03:47:48.021
RESETTLEMENT WOULD HAVE ENDED
03:47:48.087 --> 03:47:49.822
IN OUR STATE COMMUNITIES.
03:47:49.889 --> 03:47:51.024
CALIFORNIA HAS ALWAYS BEEN A
03:47:51.090 --> 03:47:53.159
WELCOMING HOME FOR THE WORLD'S
03:47:53.226 --> 03:47:55.128
MOST VULNERABLE AND AT RISK IT
03:47:55.194 --> 03:47:56.496
IS THE STATE WHERE THE
03:47:56.562 --> 03:47:57.830
RESETTLEMENT PROGRAM AS WE KNOW
03:47:57.897 --> 03:47:59.699
IT TODAY WAS ACTUALLY BORN AND
03:47:59.766 --> 03:48:01.034
WHEN THE FIRST WAVE OF
03:48:01.100 --> 03:48:04.670
SOUTHEASTERN. ASIAN REFUGEES
03:48:04.737 --> 03:48:06.272
ARRIVED SEEKING SAFETY AND
03:48:06.339 --> 03:48:09.142
SHELTER. REFUGEES ARRIVED IN A
03:48:09.208 --> 03:48:12.145
VERY TO WORK AND THEY HAVE MADE
03:48:12.211 --> 03:48:12.645
THEIR MARK IN CALIFORNIA
03:48:12.712 --> 03:48:14.680
CERTAINLY. CONTRIBUTING TO
03:48:14.747 --> 03:48:16.616
MAJOR INDUSTRY STARTING
03:48:16.682 --> 03:48:18.584
BUSINESSES BOTH SMALL AND LARGE
03:48:18.651 --> 03:48:20.920
AND REVITALIZING COMMUNITIES AS
03:48:20.987 --> 03:48:22.388
THEY MAKE THEIR HOMES AND RAISE
03:48:22.455 --> 03:48:23.856
THEIR FAMILIES HERE. AND
03:48:23.923 --> 03:48:25.324
ESPECIALLY DURING THE PANDEMIC
03:48:25.391 --> 03:48:27.760
REFUGEES ARE SERVING AS THE
03:48:27.827 --> 03:48:28.661
SPECIAL WORKERS IN A VARIETY OF
03:48:28.728 --> 03:48:30.530
CAPACITIES AND THOSE WITH
03:48:30.596 --> 03:48:31.798
HEALTHCARE TRAINING ARE
03:48:31.864 --> 03:48:32.765
STEPPING UP TO HELP ON THE
03:48:32.832 --> 03:48:34.901
FRONT LINES OUR STATE AND LOCAL
03:48:34.967 --> 03:48:37.003
COMMUNITIES BENEFIT FROM THEIR
03:48:37.070 --> 03:48:38.805
RESILIENCE. FINALLY AND
03:48:38.871 --> 03:48:40.373
IMPORTANTLY GIVEN SUPPORT AND
03:48:40.440 --> 03:48:42.842
OPPORTUNITY REFUGEES GO ON TO
03:48:42.909 --> 03:48:44.110
PROBABLY BECOME THE SOME OF OUR
03:48:44.177 --> 03:48:46.612
MOST DEVOTED AND ENGAGED U. S.
03:48:46.679 --> 03:48:48.548
THAT IS AN- WE BELIEVE IT IS
03:48:48.614 --> 03:48:49.715
IMPERATIVE THAT CALIFORNIA
03:48:49.782 --> 03:48:51.017
REMAIN A WALKING STATE FOR
03:48:51.084 --> 03:48:53.486
REFUGEES. THIS BILL PROMOTE THE
03:48:53.553 --> 03:48:55.321
UNIFIED HONORING THE
03:48:55.388 --> 03:48:57.590
CONTRIBUTION OF REFUGEES THAT
03:48:57.657 --> 03:48:59.459
THEY JOINED THE FABRIC OF U. S.
03:48:59.525 --> 03:49:01.694
LIKE IN CALIFORNIA. WE ASK THAT
03:49:01.761 --> 03:49:04.897
YOU PASS AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY
03:49:04.964 --> 03:49:05.698
THREE TO PROTECT THE FUTURE OF
03:49:05.765 --> 03:49:07.166
THE US RESETTLEMENT PROGRAM
03:49:07.233 --> 03:49:09.602
HERE IN CALIFORNIA- REFUGEES
03:49:09.669 --> 03:49:13.239
WHO ARRIVE AND CALLED. THE HOME
03:49:13.306 --> 03:49:15.108
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:49:15.174 --> 03:49:16.976
RIGHT NOW WILL A GO TO ANY
03:49:17.043 --> 03:49:19.946
WITNESSES WHO ARE IN FORTY TWO
03:49:20.012 --> 03:49:20.413
OH THREE ARE THERE ANY
03:49:20.480 --> 03:49:23.015
WITNESSES HERE THAT WOULD LIKE
03:49:23.082 --> 03:49:24.784
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. SEEING
03:49:24.851 --> 03:49:26.552
NONE LET'S MOVE ON TO ROOM FOR
03:49:26.619 --> 03:49:29.222
A TWENTY FORTY. THEY DO NOT
03:49:29.288 --> 03:49:31.691
APPEAR TO BE ANY PEOPLE IN
03:49:31.757 --> 03:49:33.559
TWENTY FORTY LET'S GO TO THE
03:49:33.626 --> 03:49:37.096
PHONE LINES THEN. OF WITNESSES
03:49:37.163 --> 03:49:38.598
WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
03:49:38.664 --> 03:49:40.833
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE MATTER
03:49:40.900 --> 03:49:43.436
MODERATOR- IF YOU WOULD PLEASE
03:49:43.503 --> 03:49:45.605
PROMPT THOSE INDIVIDUALS WHO
03:49:45.671 --> 03:49:47.340
WERE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
03:49:47.406 --> 03:49:50.176
SUPPORT OF AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY
03:49:50.243 --> 03:49:53.646
THREE WE CAN BEGIN. THANK YOU
03:49:53.713 --> 03:49:55.414
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
03:49:55.481 --> 03:49:59.452
OF AB. THREE ONE THREE THREE
03:49:59.519 --> 03:50:00.086
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
03:50:00.153 --> 03:50:17.470
AT THIS TIME. THE MODERATOR DO
03:50:17.537 --> 03:50:19.372
WE HAVE ANY THE PEOPLE ON THE
03:50:19.438 --> 03:50:21.607
LINE AND IF SO HOW MANY ARE
03:50:21.674 --> 03:50:25.378
LINED UP IN THE QUEUE. THANK
03:50:25.444 --> 03:50:27.513
YOU I HAVE FOUR LINES IN Q. ALL
03:50:27.580 --> 03:50:28.714
RIGHT WHEN WE GO AHEAD AND
03:50:28.781 --> 03:50:31.851
START WITH WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
03:50:31.918 --> 03:50:34.520
AND I'D LIKE TO REMIND YOU-
03:50:34.587 --> 03:50:37.390
NAME AFFILIATION AND INDICATING
03:50:37.456 --> 03:50:37.957
YOUR SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE
03:50:38.024 --> 03:50:42.395
PLEASE. THANK YOU RYAN FOR OUR
03:50:42.461 --> 03:50:45.965
NINE PLEASE GO AHEAD. I AM NOT
03:50:46.032 --> 03:50:47.333
A POSSIBLE ON BEHALF OF THE
03:50:47.400 --> 03:50:50.570
ACLU OF CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
03:50:50.636 --> 03:50:54.941
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS. THANK
03:50:55.007 --> 03:50:55.508
YOU I AM TO TWENTY PLEASE GO
03:50:55.575 --> 03:50:58.778
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON THIS IS
03:50:58.844 --> 03:51:00.079
REBECCA GONZALEZ OF THE
03:51:00.146 --> 03:51:01.347
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL
03:51:01.414 --> 03:51:02.848
WORKERS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN
03:51:02.915 --> 03:51:05.718
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. NEXT
03:51:05.785 --> 03:51:10.556
WITNESS. THANK YOU LINE FOR
03:51:10.623 --> 03:51:13.693
TWELVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:51:13.759 --> 03:51:15.328
AFTERNOON THIS IS JIM ONE BURKE
03:51:15.394 --> 03:51:16.896
ON BEHALF OF THE FRENCH
03:51:16.963 --> 03:51:18.397
COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION OF
03:51:18.464 --> 03:51:20.166
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT THANK
03:51:20.233 --> 03:51:23.135
YOU. THANK YOU. OTHER WITNESSES
03:51:23.202 --> 03:51:26.339
PLACE NEXT WITNESS. THANK YOU
03:51:26.405 --> 03:51:27.506
LINE FOR ALL FOUR PLEASE GO
03:51:27.573 --> 03:51:35.715
AHEAD. NINE FOUR ZERO FOUR
03:51:35.781 --> 03:51:43.356
THREE STORE HAD. DO WE HAVE ANY
03:51:43.422 --> 03:51:44.724
OTHER WITNESSES IN THE QUEUE
03:51:44.790 --> 03:51:47.693
MATTER MODERATOR. I HAVE NO
03:51:47.760 --> 03:51:49.161
FURTHER LINE'S INK YOU AT THIS
03:51:49.228 --> 03:51:51.430
TIME RIGHT LET'S GIVE IT ONE
03:51:51.497 --> 03:51:53.299
ONE LAST EFFORT TO IF THERE ARE
03:51:53.366 --> 03:51:55.534
ANY PEOPLE WHO WISH TO TESTIFY
03:51:55.601 --> 03:51:59.839
IN SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE. AND
03:51:59.905 --> 03:52:02.775
I WILL REPEAT THE PARTICIPANT
03:52:02.842 --> 03:52:06.746
NUMBER ONE MORE TIME. IT IS ONE
03:52:06.812 --> 03:52:13.286
EIGHT FOUR FOUR. TWO NINE ONE
03:52:13.352 --> 03:52:18.891
SIX THREE SIX FOUR AGAIN.
03:52:18.958 --> 03:52:23.162
1-844-291-6364 AND THE ACCESS
03:52:23.229 --> 03:52:28.601
CODE IS SIX ONE. ONE ONE ONE
03:52:28.668 --> 03:52:37.410
SEVEN NINE AGAIN. SIX ONE ONE
03:52:37.476 --> 03:52:37.943
ONE ONE SEVEN NINE. MATTER
03:52:38.010 --> 03:52:39.478
MODERATOR HAVE WE GET ANYMORE
03:52:39.545 --> 03:52:43.983
TAKERS IN THE QUEUE. THANK YOU
03:52:44.050 --> 03:52:59.198
LINE FOR PLEASE GO AHEAD. DO WE
03:52:59.265 --> 03:52:59.832
HAVE ANY OTHER WITNESSES MATTER
03:52:59.899 --> 03:53:03.002
MODERATOR. I HAVE NO FURTHER
03:53:03.069 --> 03:53:04.737
BINDING YOU AT THIS TIME VERY
03:53:04.804 --> 03:53:07.340
GOOD THANK YOU LET'S- PROCEED
03:53:07.406 --> 03:53:09.375
TO OPPOSITION IS THERE ANYONE
03:53:09.442 --> 03:53:13.312
WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY IN
03:53:13.379 --> 03:53:16.182
OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE.
03:53:16.248 --> 03:53:18.250
LET'S GO TO ROOM FORTY TWO OR
03:53:18.317 --> 03:53:20.519
THREE ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES.
03:53:20.586 --> 03:53:23.255
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
03:53:23.322 --> 03:53:25.124
MOVING ALONG TO ROOM TWENTY
03:53:25.191 --> 03:53:30.396
FORTY. ANY WITNESSES NO ONE IN
03:53:30.463 --> 03:53:33.599
THAT ROOM LET'S CHECK THE LINE-
03:53:33.666 --> 03:53:35.434
AND SEE IF WE HAVE ANY
03:53:35.501 --> 03:53:39.772
WITNESSES WHO ARE IN OPPOSITION
03:53:39.839 --> 03:53:41.841
TO AB THIRTY ONE THIRTY THREE
03:53:41.907 --> 03:53:44.210
OF MATTER MODERATOR IF YOU WILL
03:53:44.276 --> 03:53:47.747
PETE PLEASE PROCEED TO- FOR
03:53:47.813 --> 03:53:50.850
THOSE WITNESSES IN THE QUEUE.
03:53:50.916 --> 03:53:52.284
THANK YOU IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
03:53:52.351 --> 03:53:55.688
IN OPPOSITION HOURS A. B. THREE
03:53:55.755 --> 03:53:58.090
ONE THREE THREE PLEASE PRESS
03:53:58.157 --> 03:54:10.202
ONE AND THEN ZERO OUT THIS TIME.
03:54:10.269 --> 03:54:11.837
META MODERATOR COULD YOU PLEASE
03:54:11.904 --> 03:54:13.606
TELL ME THE TOTAL NUMBER OF
03:54:13.672 --> 03:54:15.508
PEOPLE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
03:54:15.574 --> 03:54:19.912
OPPOSITION. I HAVE NO LINE
03:54:19.979 --> 03:54:24.216
THANK YOU AT THIS TIME ALRIGHT.
03:54:24.283 --> 03:54:25.851
WITH THAT TO JUST ASK YOU TO
03:54:25.918 --> 03:54:27.887
CHECK THE LINE ONE MORE TIME TO
03:54:27.953 --> 03:54:29.789
MAKE SURE THE REGIONAL
03:54:29.855 --> 03:54:32.057
OPPOSITION WAITING TO TESTIFY.
03:54:32.124 --> 03:54:37.296
IN THE QUEUE. I DO HAVE ONE IN
03:54:37.363 --> 03:54:40.466
Q. FIND ONE SEVENTY FOUR PLEASE
03:54:40.533 --> 03:54:43.135
GO AHEAD. TIME FOR JOHN
03:54:43.202 --> 03:54:47.406
MUHAMMAD IN OPPOSITION OF AB
03:54:47.473 --> 03:54:48.874
THREE ONE THREE THREE THANK YOU.
03:54:48.941 --> 03:54:50.643
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES
03:54:50.709 --> 03:54:54.547
IN OPPOSITION. I HAVE NO
03:54:54.613 --> 03:54:56.415
FURTHER LINE THANK YOU AT THIS
03:54:56.482 --> 03:54:58.884
TIME THANK YOU ALL RIGHT WITH
03:54:58.951 --> 03:55:02.154
THAT- WE WILL BRING THE MATTER
03:55:02.221 --> 03:55:04.723
BACK TO THE DíAS AND I WANT TO
03:55:04.790 --> 03:55:08.294
THANK A- THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
03:55:08.360 --> 03:55:09.728
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL AND TO.
03:55:09.795 --> 03:55:11.964
FORGE SENATOR DRAWS THOSE
03:55:12.031 --> 03:55:16.335
PRESENTATION. YOU KNOW WE ARE A
03:55:16.402 --> 03:55:18.571
NATION OF IMMIGRANTS. WHETHER
03:55:18.637 --> 03:55:20.840
THEY WERE THE PEOPLE WHO CAME
03:55:20.906 --> 03:55:23.209
OVER INVOLUNTARILY AS WE WERE
03:55:23.275 --> 03:55:25.010
TALKING ABOUT PREVIOUSLY AS
03:55:25.077 --> 03:55:27.179
SLAVES OR WHETHER THEY CAN THEY
03:55:27.246 --> 03:55:29.381
WERE PEOPLE WHO CAME OVER FROM
03:55:29.448 --> 03:55:31.584
ALL PARTS OF THE WORLD TO
03:55:31.650 --> 03:55:35.554
OVERCOME. OF FAMINE AND WAR
03:55:35.621 --> 03:55:40.259
AND- GENOCIDES SO IT COULD THIS
03:55:40.326 --> 03:55:41.627
COUNTRY HAS. A HISTORY OF
03:55:41.694 --> 03:55:43.796
OPENING ITSELF UP WHETHER IT'S
03:55:43.863 --> 03:55:45.498
A TOUGH ROAD TO GET THAT
03:55:45.564 --> 03:55:47.533
ACCEPTANCE ONCE THEY GET HERE.
03:55:47.600 --> 03:55:50.402
OF COURSE IS FOR THE HISTORY
03:55:50.469 --> 03:55:52.104
BOOKS TO DISCUSSION FOR US TO.
03:55:52.171 --> 03:55:54.006
LEARN ABOUT- BECAUSE IT HASN'T
03:55:54.073 --> 03:55:56.842
BEEN EASY BUT IT IS THE PLACE
03:55:56.909 --> 03:55:59.478
WHERE PEOPLE WITH THE HOPE AND
03:55:59.545 --> 03:56:02.581
EXPECTATION AND THE PROMISE.
03:56:02.648 --> 03:56:05.084
THAT IF THEY- CAME TO THIS
03:56:05.150 --> 03:56:06.552
COUNTRY AND THEY WORKED HARD
03:56:06.619 --> 03:56:07.953
AND THEY DID THEIR BEST AND
03:56:08.020 --> 03:56:09.655
THEY PLAY BY THE RULES THEY
03:56:09.722 --> 03:56:11.524
COULD SUCCEED AND IT HAS BEEN
03:56:11.590 --> 03:56:13.659
PROVEN FOR SO MANY TO BE THE
03:56:13.726 --> 03:56:18.264
CASE. AND YET OF WE STILL FINE
03:56:18.330 --> 03:56:19.231
THAT THERE ARE THOSE WANT TO
03:56:19.298 --> 03:56:23.002
PUT UP OBSTACLES AND WALLS. ARE
03:56:23.068 --> 03:56:25.571
AND KEEP OUT OTHERS AFTER WE
03:56:25.638 --> 03:56:27.840
HAVE BEEN THE BENEFICIARIES OF
03:56:27.907 --> 03:56:31.443
THAT OPPORTUNITY AND CERTAINLY-
03:56:31.510 --> 03:56:34.013
IT IS A VERY SAD MOMENT THAT IT
03:56:34.079 --> 03:56:36.515
HAS BECOME- A POLITICAL
03:56:36.582 --> 03:56:38.717
FOOTBALL. AT THIS POINT WE KNOW
03:56:38.784 --> 03:56:40.319
THE REFUGEES TRYING TO ESCAPE
03:56:40.386 --> 03:56:43.088
WAR- IN CENTRAL AMERICA THE
03:56:43.155 --> 03:56:44.890
STORIES OF LEGION PEOPLE WHO
03:56:44.957 --> 03:56:46.559
ARE HERE BECAUSE OF OPPORTUNITY
03:56:46.625 --> 03:56:50.763
BECAUSE I HAVE. FAMILY HERE FOR
03:56:50.829 --> 03:56:52.498
WHATEVER REASON. AND TO OF
03:56:52.565 --> 03:56:55.301
SADLY WE HAVE OF AN EXECUTIVE
03:56:55.367 --> 03:56:58.170
ORDER THAT- YOU KNOW HIS
03:56:58.237 --> 03:57:02.041
BASICALLY. IN CITED THOSE KIND
03:57:02.107 --> 03:57:03.509
OF INTERNET SEEN WARS AND OF
03:57:03.576 --> 03:57:06.378
COURSE THE ORDERS OF MASS- A
03:57:06.445 --> 03:57:07.813
FEDERAL OURT ACTUALLY
03:57:07.880 --> 03:57:10.416
RECOGNIZED THAT OF MR TRUMP'S
03:57:10.482 --> 03:57:13.185
ORDER EXECUTIVE ORDER THIRTEEN
03:57:13.252 --> 03:57:15.087
EIGHT EIGHTY EIGHT- WAS
03:57:15.154 --> 03:57:17.556
DEFICIENT IN TERMS OF PASSING
03:57:17.623 --> 03:57:19.258
CONSTITUTIONAL MUSTER COMPLYING
03:57:19.325 --> 03:57:20.759
WITH THE SEPARATION OF POWERS
03:57:20.826 --> 03:57:22.928
PRINCIPLES AND SATISFYING THE
03:57:22.995 --> 03:57:24.730
STRICTURES OF THE
03:57:24.797 --> 03:57:26.799
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES ACT-
03:57:26.865 --> 03:57:29.969
IN OTHER MATTERS OF LAW THAT
03:57:30.035 --> 03:57:30.970
DON'T SEEM TO. MEAN A WHOLE LOT
03:57:31.036 --> 03:57:33.806
TO. THIS INDIVIDUAL BUT TO ITS
03:57:33.872 --> 03:57:36.542
CREDIT THE OF THE FEDERAL COURT
03:57:36.609 --> 03:57:38.377
DID ENJYING THAT ORDER NONE
03:57:38.444 --> 03:57:41.547
THE LESS IT IS ON APPEAL. AND I
03:57:41.614 --> 03:57:44.950
THINK IT'S AND THAT WE-
03:57:45.017 --> 03:57:47.620
RECOGNIZE AND VALUE THOSE
03:57:47.686 --> 03:57:49.088
PEOPLE IN RECOGNIZING VALUE THE
03:57:49.154 --> 03:57:51.056
LAW. MY UNDERSTANDING IS
03:57:51.123 --> 03:57:52.257
THERE'S NO LOCALITY THAT IS
03:57:52.324 --> 03:57:53.959
SUPPOSED THIS BILL OR HAS IT
03:57:54.026 --> 03:57:56.328
SUGGESTED THAT IT'S AN UNDUE
03:57:56.395 --> 03:57:58.831
INFRINGEMENT ON LOCAL CONTROL-
03:57:58.897 --> 03:58:00.499
IT REALLY ISN'T CONTROVERSIAL
03:58:00.566 --> 03:58:02.401
IT IT SIMPLY REQUIRES THE
03:58:02.468 --> 03:58:04.503
CALIFORNIA LOCALITIES. NOT
03:58:04.570 --> 03:58:07.072
REFUSE TO CONSENT TO RESETTLE
03:58:07.139 --> 03:58:08.874
REFUGEES IN A WAY THAT
03:58:08.941 --> 03:58:10.676
INTENTIONALLY OR EFFECTIVELY.
03:58:10.743 --> 03:58:13.612
DISCRIMINATES ON THE BASIS OF
03:58:13.679 --> 03:58:15.314
RACE OR GENDER OR OTHER
03:58:15.381 --> 03:58:18.183
PROTECTED CHARACTERISTIC SO-
03:58:18.250 --> 03:58:22.421
THIS BILL REALLY. I WOULD REFER
03:58:22.488 --> 03:58:23.722
TO IT IS SORT OF A NO BRAINER.
03:58:23.789 --> 03:58:25.190
AND IT IS ESSENTIAL TO ENSURE
03:58:25.257 --> 03:58:27.393
THE CALIFORNIA CAN CONTINUE TO
03:58:27.459 --> 03:58:29.361
LEAD THE COUNTRY IN OPENING OUR
03:58:29.428 --> 03:58:33.065
DOORS. TO OUR THE REFUGEE
03:58:33.132 --> 03:58:35.501
POPULATION IT IS HERE SEEKING A
03:58:35.567 --> 03:58:37.269
BETTER LIFE IS ALL OF OUR
03:58:37.336 --> 03:58:38.837
PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS AND
03:58:38.904 --> 03:58:40.172
GREAT GRANDPARENTS AND GREAT
03:58:40.239 --> 03:58:42.574
GREAT GRANDPARENTS BEFORE THEM
03:58:42.641 --> 03:58:45.110
HAVE DONE SO WITH THAT I
03:58:45.177 --> 03:58:47.112
APPRECIATE THIS BILL AND- WOULD
03:58:47.179 --> 03:58:49.181
WELCOME ANY OTHER COMMENTS.
03:58:49.248 --> 03:58:51.383
CENTER ON BURKE MOVES THE BILL.
03:58:51.450 --> 03:58:54.420
THE COMMENTS ALL RIGHT- SENATOR
03:58:54.486 --> 03:58:55.487
DRAWN SO WOULD YOU LIKE TO
03:58:55.554 --> 03:58:57.222
CLOSE AS FOR YOUR AYE VOTE
03:58:57.289 --> 03:58:58.657
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM CHAIR
03:58:58.724 --> 03:59:01.960
VERY GOOD SO THE MOTION BY
03:59:02.027 --> 03:59:04.730
SENATOR UMBERG IS TO PASS TO
03:59:04.797 --> 03:59:06.732
THE SENATE FLOOR. MADAM
03:59:06.799 --> 03:59:09.301
CONSULTANT PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
03:59:09.368 --> 03:59:09.835
AND SO PLEASE STERN YOUR
03:59:09.902 --> 03:59:12.004
MICROPHONES ON. THIS IS FILE
03:59:12.071 --> 03:59:14.707
NUMBER EIGHTEEN A. B. THIRTY
03:59:14.773 --> 03:59:16.208
ONE THIRTY THREE AGUIAR-CURRY
03:59:16.275 --> 03:59:17.609
THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE
03:59:17.676 --> 03:59:20.312
SENATE FLOOR JACKSON HI JACKSON
03:59:20.379 --> 03:59:22.815
I A BOARD JUST. FOR JUST I DID
03:59:22.881 --> 03:59:27.886
ALSO I DID A SO I GONZALEZ I ON
03:59:27.953 --> 03:59:31.824
SERVICE I INLAND AS- MONNING HI
03:59:31.890 --> 03:59:37.162
MONNING AYE STERN. STERN I AM
03:59:37.229 --> 03:59:39.198
BURKE I'VE UMBERG AYE WHY
03:59:39.264 --> 03:59:42.501
CASCADE A CASKET EIGHT ZERO
03:59:42.568 --> 03:59:45.604
WITH THE MISSING MEMBER VOTE IS
03:59:45.671 --> 03:59:46.939
EIGHT TWO ZERO WITH A ONE ONE
03:59:47.005 --> 03:59:48.240
MEMBER MISSING WE WILL HOLD THE
03:59:48.307 --> 03:59:49.775
ROLE OPEN AND WHEN WE'RE DONE
03:59:49.842 --> 03:59:51.844
WITH OUR NEXT A BILL WE WILL
03:59:51.910 --> 03:59:53.946
ASK ANY MEMBERS WHO WERE NOT
03:59:54.012 --> 03:59:56.949
HERE WHO WISH TO VOTE TO PLEASE
03:59:57.015 --> 03:59:59.118
COME BACK BECAUSE- WE WILL THEN
03:59:59.184 --> 04:00:01.553
DO ONE ROUND. AND THEN WE WILL
04:00:01.620 --> 04:00:04.623
CLOSE THE ROLES WITH THAT WE
04:00:04.690 --> 04:00:07.526
HAVE ONE FINAL BILL THIS IS AB
04:00:07.593 --> 04:00:10.963
THIRTY THREE SIXTY C. THIRTY
04:00:11.029 --> 04:00:11.597
THREE SIXTY SIX THE. ASSEMBLY
04:00:11.663 --> 04:00:13.665
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY MEASURE
04:00:13.732 --> 04:00:15.067
FOR DEALING WITH JUDICIAL
04:00:15.134 --> 04:00:17.603
EMERGENCIES AND IT ALSO HAS AN
04:00:17.669 --> 04:00:20.506
EMERGENCY CLAUSE. OF SENATOR
04:00:20.572 --> 04:00:22.040
EXCUSE ME AS MEMBER STONE
04:00:22.107 --> 04:00:24.143
WELCOME TO A PLEASE FEEL FREE
04:00:24.209 --> 04:00:26.745
TO PRESENT. THANK YOU I THINK
04:00:26.812 --> 04:00:28.013
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT THE
04:00:28.080 --> 04:00:29.314
STATE'S RESPONSE OF PANDEMIC
04:00:29.381 --> 04:00:31.917
SHOWN THAT A LOT OF THE SYSTEMS
04:00:31.984 --> 04:00:32.484
THAT WE HAVE IN PLACE FOR A
04:00:32.551 --> 04:00:35.354
STATEEMERGENCY ARE SOMETIMES
04:00:35.420 --> 04:00:37.790
INADEQUATE IN FACT WHEN THE
04:00:37.856 --> 04:00:38.924
JUDICIAL COUNCIL NEEDED
04:00:38.991 --> 04:00:42.060
AUTHORITY TO BE ABLE TO ADJUST
04:00:42.127 --> 04:00:43.262
WHAT IT NEEDED TO ADJUST IT
04:00:43.328 --> 04:00:46.131
TOOK. A AN EXECUTIVE ORDER SO
04:00:46.198 --> 04:00:46.832
INSTEAD OF LETTING THE
04:00:46.899 --> 04:00:48.367
EXECUTIVE ALWAYS THAT THEN I
04:00:48.433 --> 04:00:50.869
THINK IT'S TIME FOR US IS AS
04:00:50.936 --> 04:00:52.504
THE LEGISLATURE TO ENSURE THAT
04:00:52.571 --> 04:00:54.206
WE HAVE THE MECHANISMS IN PLACE
04:00:54.273 --> 04:00:55.974
TO ALLOW. ALL THREE BRANCHES OF
04:00:56.041 --> 04:00:57.409
GOVERNMENT FUNCTION DURING
04:00:57.476 --> 04:01:00.245
STATEWIDE. EMERGENCIES THE
04:01:00.312 --> 04:01:03.248
EXISTING LAW. ALLOWS THE
04:01:03.315 --> 04:01:05.584
JUDICIAL COUNCIL THE CHIEF
04:01:05.651 --> 04:01:07.786
JUSTICE TO. ADDRESS SOME OF
04:01:07.853 --> 04:01:08.754
THESE EMERGENCIES BUT IT'S ONLY
04:01:08.821 --> 04:01:11.023
A COUNTY BY COUNTY BASIS AND AT
04:01:11.089 --> 04:01:12.157
THE REQUEST OF THE PRESIDING
04:01:12.224 --> 04:01:13.725
JUDGE OF THAT COUNTY WITH THIS
04:01:13.792 --> 04:01:15.294
BILL DOES IS IT GIVES A FORTY
04:01:15.360 --> 04:01:18.330
TWO. THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL TO
04:01:18.397 --> 04:01:19.932
THE CHAIR THE USUAL COUNSEL. TO
04:01:19.998 --> 04:01:22.134
THOSE ADJUSTMENTS ON WIDE OPEN
04:01:22.201 --> 04:01:24.469
BECAUSE THESE EMERGENCIES DON'T
04:01:24.536 --> 04:01:26.071
ARE NOT CONTAINED COUNTY BY
04:01:26.138 --> 04:01:27.306
COUNTY. SO IT'S ABOUT
04:01:27.372 --> 04:01:29.074
EFFICIENCY IT'S ABOUT THE
04:01:29.141 --> 04:01:31.009
LEGISLATURE SETTING THE
04:01:31.076 --> 04:01:32.945
STANDARD. FOR THE- JUDICIAL
04:01:33.011 --> 04:01:34.947
BRANCH TO BE ABLE TO DO WHAT IT
04:01:35.013 --> 04:01:36.348
NEEDS TO DO TO ADDRESS.
04:01:36.415 --> 04:01:37.983
EMERGENCIES AND I ASK FOR YOUR
04:01:38.050 --> 04:01:41.887
AYE ABOUT. THANK YOU OF WE WILL
04:01:41.954 --> 04:01:44.556
NOW GO TO OUR WITNESSES ONLINE
04:01:44.623 --> 04:01:46.491
I WILL HAVE TO REPEAT THAT DUE
04:01:46.558 --> 04:01:47.492
TO THE CONSTRAINTS REGARDING
04:01:47.559 --> 04:01:48.594
THE LENGTH OF HEARINGS
04:01:48.660 --> 04:01:50.429
TECHNOLOGY CONSIDERATIONS AND
04:01:50.495 --> 04:01:52.531
CLEANING PROTOCOLS. COMMITTEES
04:01:52.598 --> 04:01:55.167
ARE INSTITUTING OR BE REQUIRED
04:01:55.234 --> 04:01:56.635
TO INSTITUTE A THREE MINUTE
04:01:56.702 --> 04:01:59.404
TIME LIMIT- TO BE SHARED
04:01:59.471 --> 04:02:01.206
BETWEEN THE I BELIEVE THERE TO
04:02:01.273 --> 04:02:02.741
WITNESSES HERE IN SUPPORT OF
04:02:02.808 --> 04:02:04.176
THIS MEASURE. ALL OTHERS WHO
04:02:04.243 --> 04:02:06.178
WISH TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT MUST
04:02:06.245 --> 04:02:07.713
LIMIT THEIR COMMENTS TO THEIR
04:02:07.779 --> 04:02:09.882
NAME AFFILIATION AND POSITION
04:02:09.948 --> 04:02:11.617
ON THE MEASURES OF THE SAME
04:02:11.683 --> 04:02:14.152
WILL APPLY TO ANY OPPOSITION.
04:02:14.219 --> 04:02:17.122
AND WITH THAT- I BELIEVE WE
04:02:17.189 --> 04:02:19.524
HAVE- NANCY TRAVEL WITH THE
04:02:19.591 --> 04:02:20.959
CONSUMER ATTORNEYS OF
04:02:21.026 --> 04:02:21.860
CALIFORNIA ON THE LINE IN
04:02:21.927 --> 04:02:24.396
SUPPORT AS WELL AS MIKE BELOW
04:02:24.463 --> 04:02:25.964
TO ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
04:02:26.031 --> 04:02:28.400
DEFENSE COUNSEL. ALSO ON THE
04:02:28.467 --> 04:02:31.837
LINE IN SUPPORT. BETTER
04:02:31.904 --> 04:02:35.474
MODERATORS CHECK CORRECT. THANK
04:02:35.540 --> 04:02:37.042
YOU MADAM CHAIR THIS IS NANCY
04:02:37.109 --> 04:02:39.912
TRAVEL AS ASSEMBLY MEMBER STONE
04:02:39.978 --> 04:02:42.481
MANSION AND THE COPA CRISIS
04:02:42.547 --> 04:02:45.350
REALLY LAID BARE THE INADEQUACY
04:02:45.417 --> 04:02:47.653
OF THE CURRENT AUTHORITY. FOR
04:02:47.719 --> 04:02:49.955
THE CHIEF JUSTICE TO DEAL WITH
04:02:50.022 --> 04:02:51.990
THE STATE WIDE EMERGENCY. SO
04:02:52.057 --> 04:02:54.293
THIS BILL IS A NECESSARY FIRST
04:02:54.359 --> 04:02:57.996
STEP. TO GIVE HER THE AUTHORITY
04:02:58.063 --> 04:02:59.765
TO ATTEMPT TO OF HOPE WITH THE
04:02:59.831 --> 04:03:01.099
TYPE OF EMERGENCY THAT WE'VE
04:03:01.166 --> 04:03:02.534
BEEN FACING FOR THE LAST
04:03:02.601 --> 04:03:05.070
SEVERAL MONTHS. EVEN WITH THE
04:03:05.137 --> 04:03:06.805
AUTHORITY THAT SHE WAS GRANTED
04:03:06.872 --> 04:03:10.008
BY THE EXECUTIVE ORDER AND NOW
04:03:10.075 --> 04:03:11.743
THE AUTHORITY THAT WOULD BE
04:03:11.810 --> 04:03:13.478
OFFERED UNDER THIS STILL.
04:03:13.545 --> 04:03:15.480
ACROSS THE STATE WE REALLY HAVE
04:03:15.547 --> 04:03:18.984
SEEN EXTREME IN EQUITY. IN HOW
04:03:19.051 --> 04:03:20.752
FULL WHO NEED TO GO TO COURT
04:03:20.819 --> 04:03:25.757
CAN GET JUSTICE- MISTER BELOW
04:03:25.824 --> 04:03:26.892
NEIER REPRESENTING. PEOPLE WHO
04:03:26.959 --> 04:03:28.427
HAVE CIVIL CASES AND OF COURSE
04:03:28.493 --> 04:03:29.661
THAT'S EVERYTHING FROM ELDER
04:03:29.728 --> 04:03:33.165
ABUSE TO POLICE BRUTALITY TO
04:03:33.231 --> 04:03:34.533
PERSONAL INJURY TO PRODUCT
04:03:34.599 --> 04:03:36.768
LIABILITY AND WHAT WE ARE
04:03:36.835 --> 04:03:39.538
SEEING AND THIS WILL REQUIRE
04:03:39.604 --> 04:03:40.772
ADDITIONAL ATTENTION GOING
04:03:40.839 --> 04:03:42.908
FORWARD. IS THAT TRIAL DATES
04:03:42.975 --> 04:03:44.910
ARE BEING SEVERELY DELAYED IN
04:03:44.977 --> 04:03:46.945
SOME COUNTIES PEOPLE ARE ABLE
04:03:47.012 --> 04:03:49.481
TO. ELECTRONICALLY FILE AND
04:03:49.548 --> 04:03:51.516
OTHER COUNTIES THEY CAN'T IN
04:03:51.583 --> 04:03:53.151
SOME COUNTIES THEY CAN GET A
04:03:53.218 --> 04:03:54.586
COURT DATE AND OTHERS THEY
04:03:54.653 --> 04:03:58.090
CAN'T. AND SO THIS BILL. IT IS
04:03:58.156 --> 04:04:00.525
IMPORTANT TO STARTING TO HAVE
04:04:00.592 --> 04:04:02.661
UNIFORMITY INJUSTICE ACROSS THE
04:04:02.728 --> 04:04:05.097
STATE OF CALIFORNIA SO THAT IT
04:04:05.163 --> 04:04:06.732
SHOULDN'T MATTER WHICH COUNTY
04:04:06.798 --> 04:04:09.101
YOU HAPPEN TO BE IN ABOUT BEING
04:04:09.167 --> 04:04:10.869
ABLE TO GET YOUR DAY IN COURT.
04:04:10.936 --> 04:04:13.005
ON SO WE THINK IT'S ESSENTIAL-
04:04:13.071 --> 04:04:14.806
ALONG WITH NECESSARY FUNDING
04:04:14.873 --> 04:04:16.141
FOR THE COURTS SO THEY CAN
04:04:16.208 --> 04:04:18.443
OPERATE REMOTELY AND THEY CAN'T
04:04:18.510 --> 04:04:20.512
PROVIDE JUSTICE TO PEOPLE
04:04:20.579 --> 04:04:22.647
ACROSS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
04:04:22.714 --> 04:04:23.849
THANK YOU MISTER RUBBLE NEXT
04:04:23.915 --> 04:04:25.283
MADAM CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS A
04:04:25.350 --> 04:04:26.585
MIKE BELOW TO ON BEHALF OF THE
04:04:26.651 --> 04:04:28.320
CALIFORNIA DEFENSE COUNSEL I
04:04:28.387 --> 04:04:30.722
WOULD MERELY ADD. THAT THIS WE
04:04:30.789 --> 04:04:32.424
DON'T VIEW THIS INTERROGATION
04:04:32.491 --> 04:04:33.992
OF THE APPROPRIATE AND
04:04:34.059 --> 04:04:35.894
NECESSARY AUTHORITY OF
04:04:35.961 --> 04:04:38.063
INDIVIDUAL PRESIDING JUDGES. A
04:04:38.130 --> 04:04:40.565
THAT WILL ALWAYS BE TAKEN INTO-
04:04:40.632 --> 04:04:43.168
IMPORTANT CONSIDERATION- BUT
04:04:43.235 --> 04:04:46.571
AS- HIS TRAVEL NOTED YOU KNOW
04:04:46.638 --> 04:04:48.540
WE'RE IN A TIME WHERE PEOPLE
04:04:48.607 --> 04:04:51.710
OPERATE IN MULTIPLE COUNTIES-
04:04:51.777 --> 04:04:53.211
AND SO THERE OUGHT TO BE
04:04:53.278 --> 04:04:55.881
REASONABLE. ASSURANCE THAT
04:04:55.947 --> 04:05:00.819
JUSTICE WILL BE A FORM.
04:05:00.886 --> 04:05:01.353
REGARDLESS OF WHICH COUNTY
04:05:01.420 --> 04:05:05.490
YOU'RE IN ITS- HE- WRITTEN
04:05:05.557 --> 04:05:06.825
CONTEMPLATION OF A CATASTROPHE
04:05:06.892 --> 04:05:08.894
OF FIRE OR OR SOME AFFECT A
04:05:08.960 --> 04:05:10.062
SMALL NUMBER OF COUNTIES AND
04:05:10.128 --> 04:05:11.997
REALLY DIDN'T CONTEMPLATE A
04:05:12.064 --> 04:05:13.932
STATEWIDE EMERGENCY LIKE THE
04:05:13.999 --> 04:05:17.335
PANDEMIC HOUSE HAS GIVEN US SO
04:05:17.402 --> 04:05:18.937
AGAIN WE THINK THIS IS
04:05:19.004 --> 04:05:20.439
IMPORTANT REGARDLESS OF WHO THE
04:05:20.505 --> 04:05:23.175
CHIEF JUSTICE IS- IN PLANNING
04:05:23.241 --> 04:05:25.544
FOR THE FUTURE AND FOR THAT WE
04:05:25.610 --> 04:05:26.111
WOULD ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
04:05:26.178 --> 04:05:29.414
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT-
04:05:29.481 --> 04:05:33.218
LET'S GO TO- FORTY TWO OR THREE
04:05:33.285 --> 04:05:34.319
TO THE ROOM WHERE IN AND ARE
04:05:34.386 --> 04:05:36.688
THERE ANY WITNESSES HERE IN
04:05:36.755 --> 04:05:39.991
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE. SEEING
04:05:40.058 --> 04:05:42.160
ONE OF ROOM TWENTY FORTY. THERE
04:05:42.227 --> 04:05:43.662
APPEARED TO BE NO PEOPLE IN
04:05:43.728 --> 04:05:45.964
THAT ROOM SO WE WILL- TAKE IT
04:05:46.031 --> 04:05:49.034
NOW TO- WITNESSES WAITING TO
04:05:49.101 --> 04:05:50.735
TESTIFY VIA TELECONFERENCING
04:05:50.802 --> 04:05:53.371
SERVICES MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
04:05:53.438 --> 04:05:55.073
PLEASE PROMPT THE INDIVIDUALS
04:05:55.140 --> 04:05:56.975
WAITING TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
04:05:57.042 --> 04:06:00.278
OF AB THIRTY THREE SIXTY SIX.
04:06:00.345 --> 04:06:04.282
WE WILL BEGIN. THANK YOU IF YOU
04:06:04.349 --> 04:06:08.453
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB
04:06:08.520 --> 04:06:08.987
THREE THREE SIX SIX PLEASE
04:06:09.054 --> 04:06:10.755
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
04:06:10.822 --> 04:06:21.466
TIME. THANK YOU MADAM OF
04:06:21.533 --> 04:06:23.768
MODERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE GIVE
04:06:23.835 --> 04:06:25.403
ME THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PEOPLE
04:06:25.470 --> 04:06:27.706
THAT ARE WAITING TO TESTIFY IN
04:06:27.772 --> 04:06:33.145
SUPPORT. I HAVE NO LINES IN Q.
04:06:33.211 --> 04:06:35.213
AT THIS TIME I WILL- PLEASE
04:06:35.280 --> 04:06:37.249
CHECK THE LINE ONE LAST TIME TO
04:06:37.315 --> 04:06:39.751
MAKE SURE THAT THERE IS NO ONE
04:06:39.818 --> 04:06:41.286
WHO WISHES TO SPEAK ON THIS
04:06:41.353 --> 04:06:44.623
MATTER IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU
04:06:44.689 --> 04:06:46.124
ONCE AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
04:06:46.191 --> 04:06:49.394
IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE THREE
04:06:49.461 --> 04:06:51.029
SIX SIX PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
04:06:51.096 --> 04:07:08.480
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. DO WE
04:07:08.547 --> 04:07:11.883
HAVE ANYONE IN THE QUEUE. I
04:07:11.950 --> 04:07:16.588
HAVE AN ONLINE USING. YOU AT
04:07:16.655 --> 04:07:17.155
THIS TIME THANK YOU LET'S GO
04:07:17.222 --> 04:07:19.724
TO. I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT HAVEANY INDIVIDUALS LINED UP TO
04:07:19.791 --> 04:07:23.195
SPEAK ARE IN OPPOSITION IN AT
04:07:23.261 --> 04:07:26.898
THREE MINUTE TIME FRAME. IS
04:07:26.965 --> 04:07:28.099
THAT A CORRECT MATTER%
04:07:28.166 --> 04:07:30.302
MODERATORS WE HAVE NO
04:07:30.368 --> 04:07:33.738
IDENTIFIED SPEAKERS. NONE OKAY
04:07:33.805 --> 04:07:36.041
OF LET'S GO AHEAD AND SEE IF WE
04:07:36.107 --> 04:07:37.542
HAVE ANYONE IN FORTY TWO OR
04:07:37.609 --> 04:07:39.678
THREE WISHES TO SPEAK. IN
04:07:39.744 --> 04:07:42.814
OPPOSITION TO THAT MEASURE.
04:07:42.881 --> 04:07:46.051
SEEING NONE FOR ROOM TWENTY
04:07:46.117 --> 04:07:47.586
FORTY THERE ARE NO ONE IN ROOM
04:07:47.652 --> 04:07:49.120
TWENTY FORTY LET'S BRING IN THE
04:07:49.187 --> 04:07:52.190
BACK TO YOU MADAM A MODERATOR
04:07:52.257 --> 04:07:55.827
WOULD CHIU- PLEASE- LINE UP ANY
04:07:55.894 --> 04:07:58.230
WITNESSES WHO MIGHT WISH TO
04:07:58.296 --> 04:07:59.731
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
04:07:59.798 --> 04:08:03.735
MEASURE. THANK YOU IF YOU WISH
04:08:03.802 --> 04:08:05.370
TO SPEAK I OPPOSITION HOURS A.
04:08:05.437 --> 04:08:09.574
B. THREE THREE SIX SIX PLEASE-PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
04:08:09.641 --> 04:08:28.126
TIME.
04:08:33.498 --> 04:08:34.599
MADAME MODERATOR TO WE
04:08:34.666 --> 04:08:37.269
HAVE ANY WITNESSES WHO WISH TO
04:08:37.335 --> 04:08:37.836
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
04:08:37.902 --> 04:08:42.073
MEASURE. I HAVE LEVINE DRINK
04:08:42.140 --> 04:08:45.377
YOU AT THIS TIME. THE BILL WE
04:08:45.443 --> 04:08:47.045
HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR Y.
04:08:47.112 --> 04:08:48.246
CASKEY WILL THAT'S ONE MORE
04:08:48.313 --> 04:08:49.748
TIME IF THERE IS ANYONE WHO
04:08:49.814 --> 04:08:51.916
DOES WISH TO SPEAK IN
04:08:51.983 --> 04:08:57.088
OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE. IF
04:08:57.155 --> 04:08:57.522
YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN
04:08:57.589 --> 04:08:59.824
OPPOSITION- OUT OF AB THREE
04:08:59.891 --> 04:09:01.893
THREE SIX SIX PLEASE PRESS ONE
04:09:01.960 --> 04:09:10.502
AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
04:09:10.568 --> 04:09:12.304
META MODERATOR WE HAVE ANY
04:09:12.370 --> 04:09:16.041
TAKERS. I HAVE LOW LYING THANK
04:09:16.107 --> 04:09:18.143
YOU AT THIS TIME VERY GOOD THEN
04:09:18.209 --> 04:09:19.511
WE WILL BRING THIS BACK TO THE
04:09:19.577 --> 04:09:21.680
DíAS ANY COMMENTS OR THOUGHTS
04:09:21.746 --> 04:09:24.783
BY ANYBODY. ALL RIGHT I WILL
04:09:24.849 --> 04:09:27.552
SAY THAT HAVING THAT SERVING ON
04:09:27.619 --> 04:09:29.654
JUDICIAL COUNCIL THIS IS. THAT
04:09:29.721 --> 04:09:32.324
SEEMS LIKE A VERY MINOR. EFFORT
04:09:32.390 --> 04:09:34.059
BUT ACTUALLY IT'S AN IMPORTANT
04:09:34.125 --> 04:09:35.427
ONE BUT AS OF THE ASSEMBLY
04:09:35.493 --> 04:09:38.096
MEMBER POINTED OUT. WE HAVE
04:09:38.163 --> 04:09:40.231
DONE MOST OF THE WORK- TO
04:09:40.298 --> 04:09:42.300
ANTICIPATE DISASTERS AND
04:09:42.367 --> 04:09:43.968
EMERGENCIES BASED UPON THINGS
04:09:44.035 --> 04:09:46.805
LIKE FIRES AND FLOODS. BUT THIS
04:09:46.871 --> 04:09:48.740
IS THE FIRST REAL PANDEMIC. OF
04:09:48.807 --> 04:09:49.908
THE WE'VE HAD TO DEAL WITH AND
04:09:49.974 --> 04:09:51.443
I THINK A HUNDRED YEARS AND
04:09:51.509 --> 04:09:56.314
CERTAINLY. OF REDUCING. OF THE
04:09:56.381 --> 04:09:59.017
PROCESS STREAMLINING THE
04:09:59.084 --> 04:10:00.552
PROCESS HAS BECOME A VALUABLE
04:10:00.618 --> 04:10:01.453
ALTHOUGH THIS DOESN'T DO
04:10:01.519 --> 04:10:02.620
ANYTHING MORE THAN CHEN
04:10:02.687 --> 04:10:04.856
STREAMLINE IT AND TO. I THINK
04:10:04.923 --> 04:10:06.157
THAT'S PROBABLY WHY THERE'S
04:10:06.224 --> 04:10:07.892
VERY LITTLE OPPOSITION BUT IT
04:10:07.959 --> 04:10:08.993
IS IMPORTANT THAT THE CHIEF
04:10:09.060 --> 04:10:11.229
HAVE THESE. ARE DISABILITY
04:10:11.296 --> 04:10:12.630
INSIDE THANK YOU FOR BRINGING
04:10:12.697 --> 04:10:14.733
THE BILL AND- WE HAVE A MOTION
04:10:14.799 --> 04:10:17.702
BY SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI-
04:10:17.769 --> 04:10:19.471
ASSEMBLY MEMBER STONE IF YOU'D
04:10:19.537 --> 04:10:21.606
LIKE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU THIS
04:10:21.673 --> 04:10:23.541
IS A NOT A- WITH ABSOLUTELY NO
04:10:23.608 --> 04:10:27.212
OPPOSITION AND- WE AS A
04:10:27.278 --> 04:10:28.580
LEGISLATOR- HAVE A COUPLE OF
04:10:28.646 --> 04:10:30.749
CHOICES ABOUT THE
04:10:30.815 --> 04:10:33.151
ADMINISTRATION. CONTINUE TO
04:10:33.218 --> 04:10:35.186
ISSUE EXECUTIVE ORDERS TO BE IS
04:10:35.253 --> 04:10:36.688
THAT WE WOULD BE DOING WHAT WE
04:10:36.755 --> 04:10:39.124
CAN TAKE A STEP AND SET THE
04:10:39.190 --> 04:10:41.326
FRAMEWORK. FOR OTHER BRANCHES
04:10:41.393 --> 04:10:44.229
DOING THE WORK THAT THEY NEED
04:10:44.295 --> 04:10:45.363
TO DO DURING EMERGENCY THAT'S
04:10:45.430 --> 04:10:45.964
WHAT THIS BILL IS ABOUT AND I
04:10:46.030 --> 04:10:48.500
HOUSE FOR YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU.
04:10:48.566 --> 04:10:50.502
ALL RIGHT OF THE MOTION IS. TO
04:10:50.568 --> 04:10:55.540
PAY US. THREE THIS IS A DO TO
04:10:55.607 --> 04:10:56.708
SENATOR MOTION BY CENTER Y. QUE
04:10:56.775 --> 04:10:59.210
SKI MADAM CHIEF WHICH LIKE TO
04:10:59.277 --> 04:11:01.513
CALL ROLL AS SENATORS PLEASE
04:11:01.579 --> 04:11:03.114
TURN YOUR MIKE FUNDS ON AND
04:11:03.181 --> 04:11:07.519
THIS IS FILE ITEM NINETEEN AB
04:11:07.585 --> 04:11:08.119
THIRTY THREE SIXTY SIX OF THE
04:11:08.186 --> 04:11:08.953
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
04:11:09.020 --> 04:11:10.955
JUDICIARY. THE MOTION AS DO
04:11:11.022 --> 04:11:12.490
PASSED TO THE SENATE
04:11:12.557 --> 04:11:14.159
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
04:11:14.225 --> 04:11:20.098
JACKSON HI X. AND I'D FORGES.
04:11:20.165 --> 04:11:23.535
DID I SO I DRESS SO I GONZALEZ
04:11:23.601 --> 04:11:27.405
HI I'M SALAS AYE MELINDA'S.
04:11:27.472 --> 04:11:30.141
MORNING HI MONNING EYES STERN
04:11:30.208 --> 04:11:35.413
BUT I. STERN AYE UMBERG HI I'M
04:11:35.480 --> 04:11:38.983
BURKE I WAKE HOUSE SKI HI MY
04:11:39.050 --> 04:11:43.354
CASKEY I. FOR WE HAVE SEVEN TWO
04:11:43.421 --> 04:11:45.523
ZERO TWO MEMBERS MISSING SO
04:11:45.590 --> 04:11:46.491
SEVEN TO ZERO WE ARE GOING TO
04:11:46.558 --> 04:11:47.525
UPHOLD THE RULE OPEN VERY
04:11:47.592 --> 04:11:50.128
BRIEFLY AND I WOULD LIKE TO ASK
04:11:50.195 --> 04:11:58.102
THOSE WHO. AND I WANNA AS YOU
04:11:58.169 --> 04:11:59.938
LEAVE THANK YOU FOR
04:12:00.004 --> 04:12:01.039
PARTICIPATING TODAY. MORE TO
04:12:01.105 --> 04:12:12.150
COME. AND THE. WE GOT UP TO
04:12:12.217 --> 04:12:13.017
FIFTY FIVE SO WE CAN LIVE THE
04:12:13.084 --> 04:12:20.291
CALL RIGHT RIGHT K. THE COURT.
04:12:20.358 --> 04:12:24.262
AND SO WE'VE GOT- ALL OF THAT
04:12:24.329 --> 04:12:27.565
WE- YOU REMEMBER FROM USING
04:12:27.632 --> 04:12:29.467
AROUND THE FIRST ONE I MEAN THE
04:12:29.534 --> 04:12:35.540
FIRST FIFTY. IT IS. WILL RIGHT.
04:12:35.607 --> 04:12:37.041
ALL RIGHT WE NEED TO OPEN THE
04:12:37.108 --> 04:12:44.482
ROLES FOR A NUMBER OF ITEMS. I
04:12:44.549 --> 04:12:46.184
HAVE INDICATED THAT WE WOULD BE
04:12:46.251 --> 04:12:47.886
DOING THIS AND WHAT WE WILL DO
04:12:47.952 --> 04:12:50.355
IS CALL THE ROLL ONCE AND THEN
04:12:50.421 --> 04:12:55.593
WE WILL CLOSE THE ROLE. CHAU HI
04:12:55.660 --> 04:12:56.494
WHAT WE'RE GONNA DO ONE MORE
04:12:56.561 --> 04:12:59.264
TIME FOR THE RECORD HERE LET'S
04:12:59.330 --> 04:13:01.366
DO THE CONSENT CALENDAR- THE
04:13:01.432 --> 04:13:03.234
VOTE IS EIGHT TWO ZERO CHAIR
04:13:03.301 --> 04:13:05.336
VOTING HI PLEASE CALL THE
04:13:05.403 --> 04:13:09.007
ABSENT MEMBERS. A MOTION IS TO
04:13:09.073 --> 04:13:12.443
PASS THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THE
04:13:12.510 --> 04:13:16.381
RUSSELL BY. RUSSELL I NINE TWO
04:13:16.447 --> 04:13:17.215
ZERO AT THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS
04:13:17.282 --> 04:13:22.520
OUT FILE NUMBER TWO. AB
04:13:22.587 --> 04:13:23.121
NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN THE VOTE
04:13:23.187 --> 04:13:25.023
COUNT IS SIX TO THE CHAIR
04:13:25.089 --> 04:13:27.158
VOTING HI PLEASE CALL THE
04:13:27.225 --> 04:13:30.895
ABSENT MEMBERS THAT WAS SAID TO
04:13:30.962 --> 04:13:31.596
PASS TO THE SENATE
04:13:31.663 --> 04:13:36.301
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
04:13:36.367 --> 04:13:39.270
DURACELL BY NASA I. SEVEN TWO
04:13:39.337 --> 04:13:41.573
TWO THAT MEASURE IS OUT FILE
04:13:41.639 --> 04:13:45.376
ITEM SEVEN AB TWENTY TWO AWAY
04:13:45.443 --> 04:13:47.545
TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN. POLK
04:13:47.612 --> 04:13:50.915
COUNTY IS SIX TWO ONE SURE
04:13:50.982 --> 04:13:52.884
VOTING I. AM CONSOLED PLEASE
04:13:52.951 --> 04:13:55.853
THE ABSENT MEMBERS OR DRESS.
04:13:55.920 --> 04:14:00.959
NUMBER HI. NUMBER FIVE SEVEN
04:14:01.025 --> 04:14:03.728
TWO ONE THAT BILL IS OUT FILE
04:14:03.795 --> 04:14:07.899
ITEM EIGHT SHE- AB TWENTY THREE
04:14:07.966 --> 04:14:09.634
TWENTY FIVE THE VOTE COUNT IS A
04:14:09.701 --> 04:14:10.902
TWO ZERO CHAIR VOTING I SAID
04:14:10.969 --> 04:14:13.137
MADAM CONSULTANT PLEASE CALL
04:14:13.204 --> 04:14:14.472
THE ROLL. WITH THE OF THE
04:14:14.539 --> 04:14:16.374
ABSENT MEMBERS WITH THE PASSES
04:14:16.441 --> 04:14:17.575
MEDITATE THE SENATE
04:14:17.642 --> 04:14:19.043
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
04:14:19.110 --> 04:14:24.649
MELINDA'S. HI EIGHT TWO ZERO
04:14:24.716 --> 04:14:27.118
THAT MEASURE IS OUT FILE ITEM
04:14:27.185 --> 04:14:30.288
NINE AB TWENTY FOUR FORTY FIVE
04:14:30.355 --> 04:14:31.723
THE VOTE IS A TWO ZERO CHAIR
04:14:31.789 --> 04:14:33.558
VOTING I'D MADAM CONSULTANT
04:14:33.625 --> 04:14:35.293
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
04:14:35.360 --> 04:14:37.695
WITH A DO PASS TO THE SENATE
04:14:37.762 --> 04:14:41.299
FLOOR MELENDEZ. EIGHT TWO ZERO
04:14:41.366 --> 04:14:46.104
THAT BILL IS OUT. FILE ITEM
04:14:46.170 --> 04:14:48.239
EIGHTEEN A. B. THIRTY ONE
04:14:48.306 --> 04:14:48.873
THIRTY THREE THE VOTE COUNT AS
04:14:48.940 --> 04:14:51.376
A TWO ZERO THE CHAIR VOTING HI
04:14:51.442 --> 04:14:53.778
BUT I'M CONSULTANT PLEASE CALL
04:14:53.845 --> 04:14:58.549
THE ABSENT MEMBERS AND AS.
04:14:58.616 --> 04:14:59.717
EIGHT TWO ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT
04:14:59.784 --> 04:15:03.121
FILE ITEM NINETEEN AB THIRTY
04:15:03.187 --> 04:15:05.123
THREE SIXTY SIX. THE VOTE COUNT
04:15:05.189 --> 04:15:07.025
IS SEVEN TWO ZERO CHAIR VOTING
04:15:07.091 --> 04:15:09.227
HI BOTTOM CONSULTANT PLEASE
04:15:09.293 --> 04:15:10.762
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS THAT
04:15:10.828 --> 04:15:11.796
WAS A TO PASS TO THE SENATE
04:15:11.863 --> 04:15:13.231
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
04:15:13.297 --> 04:15:18.903
BORGIAS. MELENDEZ. RIGHT
04:15:18.970 --> 04:15:21.139
NEITHER OF THOSE MEMBERS ARE
04:15:21.205 --> 04:15:24.108
PRESENT SO THE VOTE COUNT TO
04:15:24.175 --> 04:15:24.976
SEVEN TWO ZERO AND THAT BILL IS
04:15:25.043 --> 04:15:26.577
OUT I WANT TO THANK ALL THE
04:15:26.644 --> 04:15:28.880
INDIVIDUALS WHO PARTICIPATED IN
04:15:28.946 --> 04:15:32.350
PUBLIC TESTIMONY TODAY IF YOU
04:15:32.417 --> 04:15:33.551
WERE NOT ABLE TO TELL. PLEASE
04:15:33.618 --> 04:15:34.585
SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS OR
04:15:34.652 --> 04:15:36.821
SUGGESTIONS IN WRITING TO THE
04:15:36.888 --> 04:15:38.856
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE OR VISIT
04:15:38.923 --> 04:15:40.224
OUR WEBSITE FOR ADDITIONAL
04:15:40.291 --> 04:15:42.593
INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO SUBMIT A
04:15:42.660 --> 04:15:44.228
COMMENT YOUR COMMENTS AND
04:15:44.295 --> 04:15:46.397
SUGGESTIONS ARE IMPORTANT TO US
04:15:46.464 --> 04:15:47.532
AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE YOUR
04:15:47.598 --> 04:15:48.966
TESTIMONY IN THE OFFICIAL
04:15:49.033 --> 04:15:51.202
HEARING RECORDS THANK YOU AND
04:15:51.269 --> 04:15:52.837
WE APPRECIATE YOUR
04:15:52.904 --> 04:15:54.706
PARTICIPATION AND THANK YOU TO
04:15:54.772 --> 04:15:57.208
STAFF WHO'S HERE THAT MADE THIS
04:15:57.275 --> 04:16:00.111
LUCKY SE IT'S NOT- BUT THANK
04:16:00.178 --> 04:16:01.446
YOU EVERYONE FOR YOUR PATIENCE
04:16:01.512 --> 04:16:03.681
AND COOPERATION AND THANKS TO
04:16:03.748 --> 04:16:05.917
MY COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
04:16:05.983 --> 04:16:08.419
EXTRAORDINARY WORK- THEY ARE AN
04:16:08.486 --> 04:16:10.088
AMAZING GROUP AND I AM VERY
04:16:10.154 --> 04:16:12.023
APPRECIATIVE OF THEIR EFFORTS.
04:16:12.090 --> 04:16:12.990
I ALSO WANT TO THANK THE
04:16:13.057 --> 04:16:14.525
SERGEANTS FOR HELPING TO KEEP
04:16:14.592 --> 04:16:16.394
THINGS RUNNING SMOOTHLY AND A
04:16:16.461 --> 04:16:18.429
SPECIAL THANK YOU TO THE TGS
04:16:18.496 --> 04:16:20.231
STAFF WHO HAVE BEEN WORKING TO
04:16:20.298 --> 04:16:21.432
KEEP OUR HEARING ROOMS AND
04:16:21.499 --> 04:16:24.001
OFFICES CLEAN SO THAT WE CAN
04:16:24.068 --> 04:16:25.336
CONTINUE TO DO THE PEOPLE'S
04:16:25.403 --> 04:16:27.772
WORK IN THE MIDST OF THIS ON
04:16:27.839 --> 04:16:30.808
PRESIDENT DID. GLOBAL PANDEMIC.
04:16:30.875 --> 04:16:33.177
PLEASE WEAR YOUR MASKS.
04:16:33.244 --> 04:16:35.346
SOCIALLY DISTANCE BY LEE SIX
04:16:35.413 --> 04:16:36.581
FEET WASH YOUR HANDS REGULARLY
04:16:36.647 --> 04:16:38.783
THERE ARE THINGS WE CAN DO. TO
04:16:38.850 --> 04:16:40.151
LOWER THIS CURVE SO WE CAN ALL
04:16:40.218 --> 04:16:42.286
GET BACK TO A NORMAL LIFE AND
04:16:42.353 --> 04:16:44.288
GET OUR KIDS TO SCHOOL-
04:16:44.355 --> 04:16:45.690
PROBABLY ONE OF THE MOST
04:16:45.757 --> 04:16:47.391
IMPORTANT THINGS FOR THE SANITY
04:16:47.458 --> 04:16:48.960
OF ALL OF US. AND FOR THEIR
04:16:49.026 --> 04:16:51.429
EDUCATION AND WITH THAT WE HAVE
04:16:51.496 --> 04:16:53.498
CONCLUDED TODAY'S AGENDA. THE
04:16:53.564 --> 04:16:55.466
SENATE COMMITTEE ON THE
04:16:55.533 --> 04:17:14.385
JUDICIARY IS ADJOURNED.