WEBVTT
00:22:07.859 --> 00:22:08.827
WE'RE GONNA GO AHEAD AND CALL
00:22:08.894 --> 00:22:10.962
THE JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
00:22:11.029 --> 00:22:14.166
COMMITTEE HEARING TO ORDER THE
00:22:14.232 --> 00:22:15.333
TEN OH FIVE WE ASK THAT THE
00:22:15.400 --> 00:22:16.802
REMAINING MEMBERS OF THE
00:22:16.868 --> 00:22:18.837
COMMITTEE PLEASE REPORT FROM
00:22:18.904 --> 00:22:19.337
FOUR FOUR FOUR SO WE CAN
00:22:19.404 --> 00:22:22.174
CONDUCT TODAY'S BUSINESS WELL
00:22:22.240 --> 00:22:22.674
FOR TO A VERY PRODUCTIVE
00:22:22.741 --> 00:22:24.776
HEARING TODAY- THING THAT WE DO
00:22:24.843 --> 00:22:26.645
NOT HAVE A QUORUM- IF I
00:22:26.712 --> 00:22:28.647
ENCOURAGE ALL MEMBERS TO PLEASE
00:22:28.714 --> 00:22:29.681
REPORT FOR FORCE OF A
00:22:29.748 --> 00:22:31.049
CONCEPTUAL WARM TO CARE OF
00:22:31.116 --> 00:22:32.851
TODAY'S BUSINESS. A BECAUSE WE
00:22:32.918 --> 00:22:34.186
DID OUT OF A QUORUM WE WANT
00:22:34.252 --> 00:22:35.487
PARADE AS A SUB COMMITTEE INTO
00:22:35.554 --> 00:22:38.724
A QUORUM IS ESTABLISHED. I'D
00:22:38.790 --> 00:22:40.892
LIKE TO NOTE AS YOU CAN SEE ON
00:22:40.959 --> 00:22:42.494
TODAY'S AGENDA THAT ASSEMBLY
00:22:42.561 --> 00:22:43.695
MEMBER GRAY HAS WITHDRAWN HIS
00:22:43.762 --> 00:22:45.564
REQUEST TAUGHT AT THE
00:22:45.630 --> 00:22:46.131
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES
00:22:46.198 --> 00:22:48.600
COMMISSION. I WOULD ALSO LIKE
00:22:48.667 --> 00:22:50.435
TO NOTE ONE CHANGE TO THE
00:22:50.502 --> 00:22:51.470
PRINTED AGENDA ASSEMBLYMEMBER
00:22:51.536 --> 00:22:53.905
C. GARCIA'S AUDIT REQUEST
00:22:53.972 --> 00:22:54.673
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE ONE
00:22:54.740 --> 00:22:56.441
THREE. REGARDING THE CITIES OF
00:22:56.508 --> 00:22:58.076
HUNTINGTON PARK IN COMMERCE IS
00:22:58.143 --> 00:22:59.010
NO LONGER HONOR CONSENT
00:22:59.077 --> 00:23:01.213
CALENDAR IS NOW ON A REGULAR
00:23:01.279 --> 00:23:03.782
CALENDAR. SO WE NOW HAVE SEVEN
00:23:03.849 --> 00:23:05.517
ITEMS ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR I
00:23:05.584 --> 00:23:07.152
WOULD ALSO LIKE TO QUICKLY
00:23:07.219 --> 00:23:08.186
MENTION THAT WE HAD THREE
00:23:08.253 --> 00:23:10.088
INFORMATIVE. AND PRODUCTIVE
00:23:10.155 --> 00:23:11.656
OVERSIGHT HEARINGS LAST MONTH
00:23:11.723 --> 00:23:12.691
REGARDING THE LOCAL CONTROL
00:23:12.758 --> 00:23:14.893
FUNDING FORMULA HATE CRIMES AND
00:23:14.960 --> 00:23:16.895
QUALIFIED MEDICAL EVALUATORS
00:23:16.962 --> 00:23:17.796
THANK YOU MEMBERS THAT
00:23:17.863 --> 00:23:19.931
PARTICIPATED IN THOSE HEARINGS
00:23:19.998 --> 00:23:20.398
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:23:20.465 --> 00:23:21.700
ATTENDANCE AT THOSE AS WELL.
00:23:21.767 --> 00:23:23.335
AND ALSO LIKE TO MAKE SURE
00:23:23.401 --> 00:23:24.102
EVERYONE IS AWARE THAT OUR
00:23:24.169 --> 00:23:25.470
COMMITTEE WILL BE HOLDING O
00:23:25.537 --> 00:23:27.305
JOINT. OVERSIGHT HEARINGS OVER
00:23:27.372 --> 00:23:29.674
THE NEXT TWO WEEKS NEXT
00:23:29.741 --> 00:23:31.543
WEDNESDAY AT ONE THIRTY WILL BE
00:23:31.610 --> 00:23:32.577
WE WILL BE HOLDING AN OVERSIGHT
00:23:32.644 --> 00:23:33.078
HEARING ON THE STATE'S
00:23:33.145 --> 00:23:34.780
PREPARATION. FOR NATURAL
00:23:34.846 --> 00:23:36.515
DISASTERS AS RELATES TO OUR
00:23:36.581 --> 00:23:38.316
MOST VULNERABLE RESIDENTS THEN
00:23:38.383 --> 00:23:39.651
THE FOLLOWING TUESDAY MARCH
00:23:39.718 --> 00:23:41.353
TENTH AT THREE PM WE WILL BE
00:23:41.419 --> 00:23:42.354
HOLDING A JOINT OVERSIGHT
00:23:42.420 --> 00:23:44.322
HEARING. ON A RECENT ON A
00:23:44.389 --> 00:23:46.291
REPORT ON CHILDHOOD LEAD
00:23:46.358 --> 00:23:48.360
LEVELS. WITH THAT LET'S GO
00:23:48.426 --> 00:23:50.228
AHEAD AND BEGIN TO ON TODAY'S
00:23:50.295 --> 00:23:51.797
AGENDA THIS IS AGENDA ITEM
00:23:51.863 --> 00:23:53.665
NUMBER ONE PRESENTATION BY THE
00:23:53.732 --> 00:23:56.701
STATE OFFERED. TALK ABOUT STATE
00:23:56.768 --> 00:24:02.841
BOARD A IN PRAGUE. I DON'T.
00:24:02.908 --> 00:24:06.011
HE'S WHEN YOU'RE RIGHT. MEMBERS
00:24:06.077 --> 00:24:08.280
THE WRECK MY NAME TO LES HOWELL
00:24:08.346 --> 00:24:10.682
ME TODAY IS MIKE TO HE A DAY
00:24:10.749 --> 00:24:12.651
STATE AUDITOR IN THE STATE
00:24:12.717 --> 00:24:13.318
AUDITOR'S OFFICE AND HE BE TO A
00:24:13.385 --> 00:24:14.286
BIT ABOUT OUR LOCAL HIGH RISK
00:24:14.352 --> 00:24:17.255
PROGRAM A DASHBOARD ASSESSMENT
00:24:17.322 --> 00:24:18.523
OF WHAT THAT WE DO AND LAUNCH
00:24:18.590 --> 00:24:20.692
LAST OCTOBER THAT REALLY LED TO
00:24:20.759 --> 00:24:21.326
THE RE THAT WE BEFORE YOU TODAY
00:24:21.393 --> 00:24:24.262
SO I AS I AFTER I. MY STATUS
00:24:24.329 --> 00:24:26.398
MISTER TILDEN WILL JUST THREE
00:24:26.464 --> 00:24:27.766
MINUTES ARE TALKING A LITTLE
00:24:27.833 --> 00:24:29.734
BIT ABOUT HOW WE CONSTRUCTED
00:24:29.801 --> 00:24:32.137
THE DASHBOARD AND WHAT LED US
00:24:32.204 --> 00:24:33.438
TO THE PROPOSALS THAT WE HAVE
00:24:33.505 --> 00:24:36.141
TODAY SO WITH THAT MISTER CHAIR
00:24:36.208 --> 00:24:38.109
WE HAVE CURRENTLY OPEN AUDITS
00:24:38.176 --> 00:24:40.145
IN PROGRESS NINE THOSE ARE
00:24:40.212 --> 00:24:41.513
AUDIT THE- JOINT LEGISLATIVE
00:24:41.580 --> 00:24:43.181
AUDIT COMMITTEE APPROVED WE
00:24:43.248 --> 00:24:45.550
HAVE TO STATUTORY AUDITS THAT
00:24:45.617 --> 00:24:48.854
WE ARE CURRENTLY CONDUCTING.
00:24:48.920 --> 00:24:51.556
AND AN APPLE YOU MAY. MISTER
00:24:51.623 --> 00:24:53.992
CHAIR THERE ARE SIXTEEN RICK.
00:24:54.059 --> 00:24:54.860
OF SOME ON A CONSENT. TODAY
00:24:54.926 --> 00:24:56.928
THAT COMMITTEE WILL BE CAN. OUR
00:24:56.995 --> 00:24:58.797
RESOURCES ALLOW US TO START
00:24:58.864 --> 00:25:01.266
BETWEEN NOW AND JUNE SIXTEEN
00:25:01.333 --> 00:25:03.301
AUDITS- MANY OF THOSE WILL BE
00:25:03.368 --> 00:25:04.636
ABLE TO START THIS NEXT MONTH
00:25:04.703 --> 00:25:06.438
IN MARCH WE HAVE SEVEN TEAMS
00:25:06.504 --> 00:25:07.472
THAT WOULD BE AVAILABLE WE'VE
00:25:07.539 --> 00:25:08.940
BEEN. PUTTING OUT A LOT OF
00:25:09.007 --> 00:25:10.041
REPORTS IN THE LAST FEW MONTHS
00:25:10.108 --> 00:25:12.043
SO WE DO HAVE TEAMS THAT WILL
00:25:12.110 --> 00:25:13.578
BE READY AND WAITING FOR ANY
00:25:13.645 --> 00:25:15.513
AUDITS THAT. THE MEMBERS THE
00:25:15.580 --> 00:25:17.048
COMMITTEE APPROVES TODAY AND
00:25:17.115 --> 00:25:19.017
THEN IN APRIL MAY AND JUNE WILL
00:25:19.084 --> 00:25:21.353
BE ABLE TO START A AN
00:25:21.419 --> 00:25:22.888
ADDITIONAL NINE OUT OF TEN IT'S
00:25:22.954 --> 00:25:23.722
TWO THREE AND FOUR BUT THE-
00:25:23.788 --> 00:25:25.891
VAST MAJORITY WE WOULD BE ABLE
00:25:25.957 --> 00:25:27.092
TO START IN MARCH. AS YOU KNOW
00:25:27.158 --> 00:25:28.994
MEMBERS THE WAY OUR LOCAL HIGH
00:25:29.060 --> 00:25:31.596
RISK PROGRAM WORKS IS OF COURSE
00:25:31.663 --> 00:25:34.099
ANY REQUESTS THAT MEMBERS HAVE
00:25:34.165 --> 00:25:35.267
SUBMITTED THAT ARE APPROVED BY
00:25:35.333 --> 00:25:36.601
THIS COMMITTEE GET FIRST
00:25:36.668 --> 00:25:39.037
PRIORITY SO WE WILL. USE OUR
00:25:39.104 --> 00:25:40.405
RESOURCES TO START JOINT
00:25:40.472 --> 00:25:42.240
LEGISLATIVE ART LEGISLATIVE
00:25:42.307 --> 00:25:44.409
QUESTS PRIOR TO STARTING THE OF
00:25:44.476 --> 00:25:48.313
OUR LOCAL HIGH RISK WORK. WITH
00:25:48.380 --> 00:25:49.414
THAT MISTER CHAIR. ONE OTHER.
00:25:49.481 --> 00:25:51.683
WE DO. RESOURCES THAT WILL BE
00:25:51.750 --> 00:25:52.817
AVAILABLE FOR THE REST OF THE
00:25:52.884 --> 00:25:54.920
YEAR NOW WHAT I HAVE MY STAFF
00:25:54.986 --> 00:25:57.155
DO MY DEPUTIES. ARE GIVE ME AN
00:25:57.222 --> 00:25:58.623
ESTIMATE OF HOW MANY AUDITS WE
00:25:58.690 --> 00:26:00.025
CAN COMMENCE THROUGHOUT THE
00:26:00.091 --> 00:26:00.725
YEAR SO THE COMMITTEE HAS AN
00:26:00.792 --> 00:26:03.028
IDEA OF. AT THE NEXT HEARING
00:26:03.094 --> 00:26:04.195
WILL THERE BE RESOURCES
00:26:04.262 --> 00:26:05.997
AVAILABLE SO AS I SAID WE HAVE
00:26:06.064 --> 00:26:08.400
RESOURCES TO START AUDITS
00:26:08.466 --> 00:26:09.200
SIXTEEN AUDITS BETWEEN NOW AND
00:26:09.267 --> 00:26:11.436
JUNE- IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THE
00:26:11.503 --> 00:26:12.971
NEXT HEARING WILL LIKELY BE IN
00:26:13.038 --> 00:26:16.241
AUGUST. AFTER YOU COME BACK
00:26:16.308 --> 00:26:17.943
ADDITIONAL FOURTEEN TEAMS
00:26:18.009 --> 00:26:20.211
AVAILABLE. ARE TO CONDUCT AUDIT
00:26:20.278 --> 00:26:22.047
WORK WE DO HAVE SOME STATUTORY
00:26:22.113 --> 00:26:23.882
AUDITS THAT WE HAVE TO START WE
00:26:23.949 --> 00:26:25.550
ALWAYS DO A PROCUREMENT AUDIT.
00:26:25.617 --> 00:26:27.652
FOR JUDICIAL COUNCIL I HAVE
00:26:27.719 --> 00:26:29.154
FACTORED THAT IN SO THOSE HAVE
00:26:29.220 --> 00:26:30.555
ALREADY BEEN DRESSED SO WE
00:26:30.622 --> 00:26:33.224
WOULD HAVE. FOURTEEN TEAMS THAT
00:26:33.291 --> 00:26:34.993
COULD START OFF BETWEEN AUGUST
00:26:35.060 --> 00:26:36.394
AND THE END OF THE FOR THE
00:26:36.461 --> 00:26:38.496
CALENDAR YEAR. SO I WANT. TO
00:26:38.563 --> 00:26:39.631
THE COMMITTEE THAT DEPEND. ON
00:26:39.698 --> 00:26:42.767
MANY CUBA PROOF TODAY. WE WERE
00:26:42.834 --> 00:26:44.069
HAVE RESOURCE AVAILABLE FOR
00:26:44.135 --> 00:26:44.769
YOUR AUDITS THAT THE
00:26:44.836 --> 00:26:47.839
LEGISLATURE ASKED TODAY. WITH
00:26:47.906 --> 00:26:49.708
THAT I'D LIKE TO IT UP MR
00:26:49.774 --> 00:26:51.676
CHILDREN IN HE WILL SAY AS AT
00:26:51.743 --> 00:26:53.144
WE'LL KEEP IT TO. TWO TO
00:26:53.211 --> 00:26:54.879
MINUTES. ARE TALKING OF ARE
00:26:54.946 --> 00:26:59.684
LOCAL PROGRAM IN THE F. AFTER.
00:26:59.751 --> 00:27:03.722
THROUGH UP TOGETHER THE DATA.
00:27:03.788 --> 00:27:06.891
PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU RIGHT
00:27:06.958 --> 00:27:07.892
.COM ONE MISTER CHAIRMAN
00:27:07.959 --> 00:27:08.493
MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE AS MISS
00:27:08.560 --> 00:27:09.761
IN THE ON THE TALK TO YOU
00:27:09.828 --> 00:27:11.563
BRIEFLY ABOUT OUR LOW HIGH RISK
00:27:11.629 --> 00:27:12.297
FOR. WE RELEASE THE DASHBOARD
00:27:12.364 --> 00:27:13.598
TALKED IN A TERMS BUILDING WHAT
00:27:13.665 --> 00:27:14.566
WE DO IS WE ANALYZE THE FOR THE
00:27:14.632 --> 00:27:16.434
HEALTH OF HUNDRED AND SEVENTY
00:27:16.501 --> 00:27:20.472
pREVIEWING AUDITED FINANCIAL
00:27:20.538 --> 00:27:20.905
STATEMENTS AND OTHER
00:27:20.972 --> 00:27:22.707
INFORMATION. IN DOING THAT WE
00:27:22.774 --> 00:27:24.442
EVALUATED THE FISCAL HEALTH OF
00:27:24.509 --> 00:27:26.478
EACH CITY USING A SET OF TEN
00:27:26.544 --> 00:27:28.880
FINANCIAL INDICATORS AND THE
00:27:28.947 --> 00:27:30.615
INDICATORS WERE DESIGNED RIDLEY
00:27:30.682 --> 00:27:32.851
TO ASSESS EACH CITIES CASH
00:27:32.917 --> 00:27:34.786
POSITION. OR ABILITY TO PAY ITS
00:27:34.853 --> 00:27:36.154
BILLS IN THE SHORT TERM OR THE
00:27:36.221 --> 00:27:38.356
COMING YEAR WE ALSO LOOK AT THE
00:27:38.423 --> 00:27:39.824
DEBT BURDEN OF EACH CITY
00:27:39.891 --> 00:27:42.327
ASSESSING ITS ABILITY TO PAY
00:27:42.394 --> 00:27:44.262
ITS BILLS IN THE LONG TERM. IN
00:27:44.329 --> 00:27:44.996
RELATED TO THAT WHAT THE
00:27:45.063 --> 00:27:46.297
SUFFICIENCY OF EACH CITIES
00:27:46.364 --> 00:27:47.999
FINANCIAL RESERVES THAT WOULD
00:27:48.066 --> 00:27:49.434
BE AVAILABLE TO COVER ANY
00:27:49.501 --> 00:27:51.770
UNEXPECTED COSTS. AND WE LOOKED
00:27:51.836 --> 00:27:53.538
AT REVENUE TRENDS TO SEE IF THE
00:27:53.605 --> 00:27:55.240
GROWTH IN THOSE REVENUE TRENDS.
00:27:55.306 --> 00:27:57.008
WOULD KEEP PACE WITH INCREASING
00:27:57.075 --> 00:27:58.510
COSTS INCLUDING INCREASING
00:27:58.576 --> 00:28:00.812
RETIREMENT COSTS. FINALLY WE
00:28:00.879 --> 00:28:02.180
LOOKED AT EACH CITY'S ABILITY
00:28:02.247 --> 00:28:03.681
TO PAY FOR THE RETIREMENT COSTS
00:28:03.748 --> 00:28:06.051
OF ITS EMPLOYEES. SO WE WENT
00:28:06.117 --> 00:28:07.485
THROUGH THE ANALYSIS AND BASED
00:28:07.552 --> 00:28:08.787
ON THE RESULTS OF THE TEN
00:28:08.853 --> 00:28:11.156
INDICATORS WE CATEGORIZE EACH
00:28:11.222 --> 00:28:13.892
CITY. AS HAVING LOW. MODERATE
00:28:13.958 --> 00:28:16.561
OR HIGH FISCAL RISK IN ADDITION
00:28:16.628 --> 00:28:18.763
WE RANK ALL FOUR HUNDRED AND
00:28:18.830 --> 00:28:20.432
SEVENTY ONE CITIES. BASED ON
00:28:20.498 --> 00:28:22.434
FISCAL HEALTH FROM HIGHEST RISK
00:28:22.500 --> 00:28:24.602
TO LOIS RISK. AND IS MISS HOW
00:28:24.669 --> 00:28:26.938
INDICATED FOR THE CITIES WHICH
00:28:27.005 --> 00:28:27.939
ARE SUBJECT TO OUR PROPOSALS
00:28:28.006 --> 00:28:30.642
TODAY WERE AMONG THE TOP TEN
00:28:30.708 --> 00:28:32.710
FINANCIALLY RISKY CITIES IN THE
00:28:32.777 --> 00:28:34.479
STATE. WHAT WHILE THE FIFTH
00:28:34.546 --> 00:28:36.815
CITY WHICH IS WEST COVINA WAS
00:28:36.881 --> 00:28:38.416
IN THE TOP TWENTY. SO BASED ON
00:28:38.483 --> 00:28:39.717
THE RESULTS OF THE DASHBOARD
00:28:39.784 --> 00:28:41.920
AND ARE ON SIDE ASSESSMENTS
00:28:41.986 --> 00:28:43.888
THAT EACH OF THE FIVE CITIES.
00:28:43.955 --> 00:28:45.156
WE DETERMINED THAT THE CITIES
00:28:45.223 --> 00:28:46.858
ARE DEMONSTRATING VARIOUS
00:28:46.925 --> 00:28:48.626
HIGHER RISK CHARACTERISTICS AND
00:28:48.693 --> 00:28:50.595
I WANT TO WALK THROUGH THOSE.
00:28:50.662 --> 00:28:53.031
VERY BRIEFLY. ONE EACH OF THE
00:28:53.098 --> 00:28:54.866
CITIES IS FACING INCREASING
00:28:54.933 --> 00:28:57.769
PENSION COSTS NOT ONLY THAT BUT
00:28:57.836 --> 00:28:58.670
THESE PENSION COSTS ARE VERY
00:28:58.736 --> 00:29:02.073
HIGH RELATIVE TO THE ANNUAL
00:29:02.140 --> 00:29:03.441
REVENUES IN EACH CITY COLLECTS.
00:29:03.508 --> 00:29:05.076
THEY ALSO HAVE SIGNIFICANT
00:29:05.143 --> 00:29:06.511
LIABILITIES FOR POST EMPLOYMENT
00:29:06.578 --> 00:29:07.979
HEALTH BENEFITS FOR THEIR
00:29:08.046 --> 00:29:09.614
EMPLOYEES AND MOST OF THESE
00:29:09.681 --> 00:29:11.916
CITIES HAVE SET ASIDE VERY
00:29:11.983 --> 00:29:13.618
LITTLE OR NO FUNDING TO PAY FOR
00:29:13.685 --> 00:29:15.453
THESE BENEFITS. WE ALSO LOOK
00:29:15.520 --> 00:29:17.355
THE CASH FLOW AND DETERMINE
00:29:17.422 --> 00:29:18.389
THAT MOST OF THE CITIES HAVE
00:29:18.456 --> 00:29:20.625
SIGNIFICANT CASH FLOW PROBLEMS
00:29:20.692 --> 00:29:23.161
AN INSUFFICIENT LIQUIDITY TO
00:29:23.228 --> 00:29:23.862
PAY THEIR BILLS IN THE NEAR
00:29:23.928 --> 00:29:26.998
TERM. RELATED TO THAT MANY OF
00:29:27.065 --> 00:29:28.333
THESE CITIES HAVE INSUFFICIENT
00:29:28.399 --> 00:29:30.535
FINANCIAL RESERVES THAT THEY
00:29:30.602 --> 00:29:31.536
COULD USE TO FUND THEIR
00:29:31.603 --> 00:29:33.104
OPERATIONS IN THE EVENT OF A
00:29:33.171 --> 00:29:35.306
FISCAL EMERGENCY OR ANY KIND OF
00:29:35.373 --> 00:29:38.276
AN ECONOMIC DOWNTURN. SOME OF
00:29:38.343 --> 00:29:38.810
THE CITIES ALSO HAVE HIGH
00:29:38.877 --> 00:29:41.212
LEVELS OF DEBT. AGAIN RELATIVE
00:29:41.279 --> 00:29:42.347
TO THEIR ANNUAL REVENUES WHICH
00:29:42.413 --> 00:29:43.982
IS GOING TO STRAIN THEIR
00:29:44.048 --> 00:29:45.850
ABILITY TO SERVICE THAT DEBT.
00:29:45.917 --> 00:29:47.318
AND FINALLY WE TOOK A LOOK AT
00:29:47.385 --> 00:29:48.853
EACH CITIES REVENUES AND WE
00:29:48.920 --> 00:29:50.221
FOUND THAT SOME OF THESE CITIES
00:29:50.288 --> 00:29:51.890
HAVE FLAT OR EVEN DECLINING
00:29:51.956 --> 00:29:54.025
REVENUES. WHICH IS TROUBLESOME
00:29:54.092 --> 00:29:55.560
GIVEN THAT THEY HAVE INCREASING
00:29:55.627 --> 00:29:59.297
COSTS- WITH THAT'D BE HAPPY TO
00:29:59.364 --> 00:29:59.898
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE
00:29:59.964 --> 00:30:02.867
DASHBOARD. THANK YOU LET ME ASK
00:30:02.934 --> 00:30:05.470
THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS. SENATE
00:30:05.537 --> 00:30:06.971
ROTH LEADING MISTER CHAIR I'M
00:30:07.038 --> 00:30:09.140
JUST CURIOUS TO FIND IN ANY OF
00:30:09.207 --> 00:30:10.875
THE CITIES THAT ARE IN IN THE
00:30:10.942 --> 00:30:13.378
HIGH RISK CATEGORY- HAVE USED
00:30:13.444 --> 00:30:15.547
TO PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS TO
00:30:15.613 --> 00:30:20.118
ATTEMPT TO DEAL WITH. COSTS OF
00:30:20.185 --> 00:30:21.986
PENSIONS OTHER POST RETURN
00:30:22.053 --> 00:30:24.289
BENEFITS. YES WE ACTUALLY DID
00:30:24.355 --> 00:30:25.657
FIND THAT THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
00:30:25.723 --> 00:30:27.425
CITIES ACROSS THE STATE IN THE
00:30:27.492 --> 00:30:29.594
HIGH RISK CATEGORY AS WELL AS
00:30:29.661 --> 00:30:31.095
IN THE MODERATE RISK CATEGORY
00:30:31.162 --> 00:30:32.363
THAT HAVE USE PENSION
00:30:32.430 --> 00:30:34.732
OBLIGATION BONDS TO BASICALLY
00:30:34.799 --> 00:30:36.434
FIND THEIR UNFUNDED RETIREMENT
00:30:36.501 --> 00:30:38.937
OBLIGATIONS WHEN WE CALCULATE
00:30:39.003 --> 00:30:40.438
ONE OF OUR INDICATORS ASSESSES
00:30:40.505 --> 00:30:42.674
THE MAGNITUDE OF THESE UNFUNDED
00:30:42.740 --> 00:30:44.175
PENSION LIABILITIES AND WHEN WE
00:30:44.242 --> 00:30:45.743
DO THAT WE INCLUDED. THE
00:30:45.810 --> 00:30:47.645
PENSION LIABILITY PLUS ANY
00:30:47.712 --> 00:30:50.615
OUTSTANDING PENSION OBLIGATION
00:30:50.682 --> 00:30:52.350
BONDS. THE TO THE EXTENT THAT
00:30:52.417 --> 00:30:54.519
IT. FITS IN WITH YOUR STANDARD
00:30:54.586 --> 00:30:56.387
PROTOCOL AND THE ISSUES THAT
00:30:56.454 --> 00:30:57.889
YOU ADDRESS AS A MATTER OF
00:30:57.956 --> 00:31:00.625
COURSE- WHEN YOU CONDUCT THESE
00:31:00.692 --> 00:31:01.993
OUT ITS I WOULD BE INTERESTED
00:31:02.060 --> 00:31:04.395
IN IN- IN READING YOUR-
00:31:04.462 --> 00:31:07.632
COMMENTARY ON THE EFFICACY. OF
00:31:07.699 --> 00:31:11.402
PENSION OBLIGATION BONDS- I
00:31:11.469 --> 00:31:12.971
ASSUME THAT YOU CAN CHOOSE.
00:31:13.037 --> 00:31:14.973
PERIODS OF TIME WITHIN WHICH
00:31:15.039 --> 00:31:17.375
THE BONDS ARE ISSUED AND
00:31:17.442 --> 00:31:18.943
REPAYABLE AND- THAT SORT OF
00:31:19.010 --> 00:31:20.845
COMMENT AGAIN I DON'T KNOW IF
00:31:20.912 --> 00:31:22.280
IT FITS WITHIN THE PARAMETERS
00:31:22.347 --> 00:31:23.648
OF WHAT YOU DO WHEN YOU CONDUCT
00:31:23.715 --> 00:31:25.149
A HIGH RISK GOT IT BUT IF YOU
00:31:25.216 --> 00:31:27.118
IF IT DOES I WOULD BE
00:31:27.185 --> 00:31:30.154
INTERESTED IN. IN HEARING FROM.
00:31:30.221 --> 00:31:33.424
OUR MODERATOR. YOUR VIEWS ON
00:31:33.491 --> 00:31:34.726
THE EFFORT OF PENSION
00:31:34.792 --> 00:31:36.327
OBLIGATION BONDS UNDER THE
00:31:36.394 --> 00:31:38.563
CIRCUMSTANCES OF SOME OF THESE
00:31:38.630 --> 00:31:40.064
CITIES INCLUDING THE HIGH RISK
00:31:40.131 --> 00:31:41.699
ONCE YOU'RE FACING. IT WOULD
00:31:41.766 --> 00:31:43.501
ABSOLUTELY BE IN THE SCOPE OF
00:31:43.568 --> 00:31:44.035
THE AUDITS THAT WE DO AND
00:31:44.102 --> 00:31:46.004
THAT'S WHY WE WANTED TO MAKE
00:31:46.070 --> 00:31:47.939
SURE. WHEN WE LAUNCHED THE
00:31:48.006 --> 00:31:48.940
DASHBOARD THAT WE HIGHLIGHTED
00:31:49.007 --> 00:31:52.310
THAT INFORMATION FOR YOU. UP
00:31:52.377 --> 00:31:54.279
THE DATA AND WHERE THEY CAN GO
00:31:54.345 --> 00:31:56.014
IN AND IDENTIFY CITY ARE BAY.
00:31:56.080 --> 00:32:03.087
TAKE AN ABA AT. IF A BOND.
00:32:03.154 --> 00:32:04.322
WHERE THE YOU KNOW A ARE
00:32:04.389 --> 00:32:06.491
PASSING THAT OP O TO OTHERS AT
00:32:06.557 --> 00:32:07.258
IT'S NOT NECESSARILY A PRACTICE
00:32:07.325 --> 00:32:08.092
BUT WE WERE AB LOOK AT THAT
00:32:08.159 --> 00:32:10.228
WHEN WE CAN THE ON AND WOMEN
00:32:10.295 --> 00:32:13.631
COME MISSED THE AYES THE WITH
00:32:13.698 --> 00:32:15.300
THE FOR A AND FIFTY WHATEVER IT
00:32:15.366 --> 00:32:17.035
IS EIGHTY PLUS PLUS IT IS THAT
00:32:17.101 --> 00:32:18.269
WE HAVE IN THE STATE OF
00:32:18.336 --> 00:32:21.639
CALIFORNIA MANY OF THEM ARE BUT
00:32:21.706 --> 00:32:23.007
ONE STEP AWAY FROM THE- HIGH
00:32:23.074 --> 00:32:24.575
RISK OR ALMOST HIGH RISK LIST
00:32:24.642 --> 00:32:26.044
AND THEY MIGHT BENEFIT FROM
00:32:26.110 --> 00:32:29.013
READING YOUR COMMENTS. BEST
00:32:29.080 --> 00:32:30.915
PRACTICES CERTAINLY CENTER
00:32:30.982 --> 00:32:32.717
THAT'S WHAT WE WE'RE INTENDING
00:32:32.784 --> 00:32:35.286
WITH THIS DASHBOARD AND WE HAVE
00:32:35.353 --> 00:32:36.888
ONE YEAR'S WORTH OF INFORMATION
00:32:36.954 --> 00:32:38.423
ON THE DASHBOARD AND THE INTENT
00:32:38.489 --> 00:32:39.390
IS TO HAVE THIS BE A
00:32:39.457 --> 00:32:41.959
LONGITUDINAL UP RESOURCE FOR
00:32:42.026 --> 00:32:44.295
CITIES FOR RESIDENTS IN
00:32:44.362 --> 00:32:46.264
CALIFORNIA TO SEE HOW WELL
00:32:46.331 --> 00:32:48.066
THEIR CITY IS DOING IS THEY'RE
00:32:48.132 --> 00:32:49.567
CITY HEADING INTO. A PORT BAD
00:32:49.634 --> 00:32:51.436
DIRECTION OR ARE THINGS GETTING
00:32:51.502 --> 00:32:53.671
BETTER SO WE INTEND TO POPULATE
00:32:53.738 --> 00:32:55.139
THE DATABASE LATER THIS YEAR
00:32:55.206 --> 00:32:56.341
WITH ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
00:32:56.407 --> 00:32:58.276
WITH RESPECT TO FINANCES AND WE
00:32:58.343 --> 00:33:01.145
HOPE THAT CITIES. WILL LOOK AT
00:33:01.212 --> 00:33:02.847
THE DASHBOARD AND SEE WILL THIS
00:33:02.914 --> 00:33:04.382
CITY SEEMS TO BE DOING WELL
00:33:04.449 --> 00:33:05.383
WHAT WHAT ARE THEY DOING
00:33:05.450 --> 00:33:07.251
DIFFERENTLY THAN WE ARE DOING
00:33:07.318 --> 00:33:09.987
WHAT ARE THE CIRCUMSTANCES ARE
00:33:10.054 --> 00:33:11.589
THERE THINGS WE COULD LEARN
00:33:11.656 --> 00:33:12.223
FROM THAT PARTICULAR LATEST THE
00:33:12.290 --> 00:33:13.725
NORTH HEALT AND HOPEFULLY AS-
00:33:13.791 --> 00:33:15.293
THE BILL. CALIFORNIA'S WILL
00:33:15.360 --> 00:33:16.861
TAKE YOUR REPORT WILL SHARED
00:33:16.928 --> 00:33:19.030
WITH THE OTHER CITIES
00:33:19.097 --> 00:33:20.498
PARTICULARLY AS YOU. INCLUDE
00:33:20.565 --> 00:33:21.999
COMMENTARY ON FINANCIAL
00:33:22.066 --> 00:33:24.335
PRACTICES BEST PRACTICES SOME
00:33:24.402 --> 00:33:25.837
THAT ARE NOT SO GOOD. I
00:33:25.903 --> 00:33:27.171
CERTAINLY HOPE THAT'S OKAY I
00:33:27.238 --> 00:33:29.140
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU DO THANK
00:33:29.207 --> 00:33:31.943
YOU MADAM ON THANK YOU FOR THE
00:33:32.009 --> 00:33:34.912
FUTURE. THANK YOU. FOR CLARITY
00:33:34.979 --> 00:33:35.513
I APPRECIATE THOSE C<c.cyan> IN</c>
00:33:35.580 --> 00:33:36.981
THAT BE BECAUSE THIS IS A CAN
00:33:37.048 --> 00:33:40.251
DOT IT FROM PREVIOUS CAR. WELL
00:33:40.318 --> 00:33:41.853
IT'S NOT NECESSARILY CONTINUED
00:33:41.919 --> 00:33:43.654
AUDIT MISTER CHAIRMAN THE
00:33:43.721 --> 00:33:45.623
DASHBOARD WAS AN ANALYSIS WE
00:33:45.690 --> 00:33:48.993
DID WE- MY STAFF MIKE STAFF OUT
00:33:49.060 --> 00:33:50.261
WENT OUT AND LOOKED AT IT WE
00:33:50.328 --> 00:33:52.430
WENT TO ALL A LOT OF THE CITY'S
00:33:52.497 --> 00:33:54.265
WEBSITE WE WENT TO OTHER
00:33:54.332 --> 00:33:55.333
RESOURCES. TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
00:33:55.400 --> 00:33:56.601
COLLECTED OPTED FINANCIAL
00:33:56.667 --> 00:33:59.103
STATEMENTS AND DID THE ANALYSIS
00:33:59.170 --> 00:34:00.171
WHAT WERE WHAT THE DAY
00:34:00.238 --> 00:34:01.739
COMMITTEE WILL BE CONSIDERING
00:34:01.806 --> 00:34:03.474
TODAY IS AS WE NOTIFIED YOU WE
00:34:03.541 --> 00:34:05.376
WENT AND SELECTED AS MR
00:34:05.443 --> 00:34:07.311
CHILDREN INDICATED. SOME OF THE
00:34:07.378 --> 00:34:08.946
CITIES THAT RANK VERY HIGH AS
00:34:09.013 --> 00:34:11.215
FAR AS FISCAL DISTRESS A LOT OF
00:34:11.282 --> 00:34:12.717
THOSE INDICATORS THEY WERE HIGH
00:34:12.784 --> 00:34:16.320
RISK SO WAY OUR STATUTE WORKS
00:34:16.387 --> 00:34:17.221
IS WE GO OUT WE NOTIFIED. YOU
00:34:17.288 --> 00:34:19.023
AND THE AND THE VICE CHAIR THAT
00:34:19.090 --> 00:34:20.525
WE'RE NOT DOING ASSESSMENT
00:34:20.591 --> 00:34:22.560
BASED ON THAT ASSESSMENT THEN
00:34:22.627 --> 00:34:26.764
WE PUT A PROPOSAL TOGETHER. IT
00:34:26.831 --> 00:34:28.599
WILL STAY AYE. WE THANK.
00:34:28.666 --> 00:34:29.567
THEY'RE SICK. PROBLEM WE WENT
00:34:29.634 --> 00:34:31.002
AND GAVE WITH THIS. I DIDN'T
00:34:31.068 --> 00:34:32.336
HEAR. THAT WERE CAN US THAT
00:34:32.403 --> 00:34:33.604
THEY HAD EVERYTHING UNDER
00:34:33.671 --> 00:34:36.140
CONTROL OR HAD ADEQUATE PLANS
00:34:36.207 --> 00:34:36.674
TO DEAL WITH THEIR FISCAL
00:34:36.741 --> 00:34:38.109
SITUATION. SO WE THINK IT WOULD
00:34:38.176 --> 00:34:39.410
BE PRUDENT FOR US TO GET OUT
00:34:39.477 --> 00:34:41.279
THERE AND CONDUCT AUDIT WORK.
00:34:41.345 --> 00:34:43.481
AND HOPEFULLY IDENTIFY SOME
00:34:43.548 --> 00:34:45.349
ISSUES OR SHARE BEST PRACTICES
00:34:45.416 --> 00:34:46.751
THAT WE'VE SEEN THAT HOPEFULLY
00:34:46.818 --> 00:34:48.453
WILL BE OF ASSISTANCE TO THE
00:34:48.519 --> 00:34:49.821
CITIES AND OTHER CITIES THAT.
00:34:49.887 --> 00:34:50.788
PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT WE'RE
00:34:50.855 --> 00:34:52.790
DOING GOT IT. AND SO THESE ARE
00:34:52.857 --> 00:34:56.060
THE- TOP TWENTY MOST CASES THE
00:34:56.127 --> 00:34:58.062
TOP TEN- HIGH RISK ALREADY
00:34:58.129 --> 00:34:59.564
IDENTIFIED IN THE DASHBOARD.
00:34:59.630 --> 00:35:02.433
WHEN WE WHEN WAS THE FIRST HIGH
00:35:02.500 --> 00:35:04.936
RISK AUDIT CONDUCTED. OR I'D
00:35:05.002 --> 00:35:06.737
HAVE TO LOOK- WE'VE DONE I
00:35:06.804 --> 00:35:11.642
THINK FOR. US WE'VE DONE FOR.
00:35:11.709 --> 00:35:14.145
AUDIT THAT THIS CA HAS APPROVED
00:35:14.212 --> 00:35:16.147
MISTER CHILDREN INDICATE HE'S
00:35:16.214 --> 00:35:17.882
THAT THOUGHT THE FIRST WE DID
00:35:17.949 --> 00:35:20.284
CITY OF HAMMETT MOM AND I THE
00:35:20.351 --> 00:35:21.486
STATE OF MAY WOOD WERE BOTH
00:35:21.552 --> 00:35:23.955
CONDUCTED IN TWENTY SIXTEEN
00:35:24.021 --> 00:35:24.555
TWENTY SIXTEEN OKAY SO THIS
00:35:24.622 --> 00:35:26.257
ISN'T SOMETHING NEW FOR ALL OF
00:35:26.324 --> 00:35:27.959
THE CITY'S A SYSTEM THAT'S BEEN
00:35:28.025 --> 00:35:29.727
AROUND FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS
00:35:29.794 --> 00:35:31.262
CORRECT CORRECT OKAY GIVE
00:35:31.329 --> 00:35:33.264
WITHOUT THERE'S A REAL
00:35:33.331 --> 00:35:34.765
QUESTIONS FROM THE DíAS FOR
00:35:34.832 --> 00:35:36.801
THE AGENDA ITEM ONE. THE STATUS
00:35:36.868 --> 00:35:39.437
REPORT WORK PROGRESS ANY THE
00:35:39.504 --> 00:35:42.607
MEMBERS. OKAY HEARING IN SAYING
00:35:42.673 --> 00:35:44.442
THAT THE YOU MADAM THINK MISTER
00:35:44.509 --> 00:35:46.744
CHAIRMAN. AT THIS TIME IS GOING
00:35:46.811 --> 00:35:55.219
AND THE STAFF QUORUM. SOUTH
00:35:55.286 --> 00:36:00.791
PRESENT. BOERNER HORVATH GEN.
00:36:00.858 --> 00:36:08.099
PATTERSON. RUBIO VOEPEL. WHAT
00:36:08.165 --> 00:36:14.205
CENTER ROCK. GORGEOUS OPENS ALL.
00:36:14.272 --> 00:36:19.076
HERTZBERG. MORNING HERE
00:36:19.143 --> 00:36:27.952
MOORLACH. WIENER. OKAY THANK
00:36:28.019 --> 00:36:29.053
YOU WE HAVE A QUORUM
00:36:29.120 --> 00:36:47.338
ESTABLISHED. OKAY WITH THAT
00:36:47.405 --> 00:36:49.240
WILL GO AHEAD AND MOVE TO THE
00:36:49.307 --> 00:36:51.108
CONSENT CALENDAR WE DID WASWE
00:36:51.175 --> 00:36:52.643
WILL MAKE TWO EXCEPTIONS ON THE
00:36:52.710 --> 00:36:54.111
PROPOSED CONSENT CALENDAR THAT
00:36:54.178 --> 00:36:58.115
IS ITEM NUMBER FOUR CITIES OF
00:36:58.182 --> 00:36:58.983
HUNTINGTON PARK IN COMMERCE
00:36:59.050 --> 00:37:00.351
CONTRACTING PRACTICES IN
00:37:00.418 --> 00:37:02.219
CANNABIS LICENCES BY. ASSEMBLY
00:37:02.286 --> 00:37:03.788
MEMBER CRISTINA GARCIA WILL BE
00:37:03.854 --> 00:37:05.256
REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT
00:37:05.323 --> 00:37:08.926
CALENDAR AND ALSO- ITEM NUMBER
00:37:08.993 --> 00:37:09.760
SEVEN TWENTY TWENTY DASH EIGHT
00:37:09.827 --> 00:37:10.361
OH FOUR CITY OF LINDSAY WILL
00:37:10.428 --> 00:37:11.796
ALSO BE REMOVED FROM THE
00:37:11.862 --> 00:37:13.998
CONSENT CALENDAR. AND THOSE
00:37:14.065 --> 00:37:15.700
WILL BE PLACED ON THE REGULAR
00:37:15.766 --> 00:37:18.703
CALENDAR AGENDA- WITH THAT DO I
00:37:18.769 --> 00:37:22.607
HAVE A MOTION TO YOU APPROVE
00:37:22.673 --> 00:37:29.513
VACANCY. ALL RIGHT. THE PERSON.
00:37:29.580 --> 00:37:30.748
RIGHT WE WERE ON THE SIDE WE
00:37:30.815 --> 00:37:33.484
MUST SUSPEND JAIL RULES NUMBER
00:37:33.551 --> 00:37:35.353
THIRTY AND OVER. AND SO WITH
00:37:35.419 --> 00:37:40.157
THAT- NOW WILL THE CORRECT. YOU
00:37:40.224 --> 00:37:43.794
CAN SO FIRST WE NEED TO VOTE ON
00:37:43.861 --> 00:37:46.397
SUSPENDING JACK RULES NUMBER
00:37:46.464 --> 00:37:48.132
THIRTEEN FOURTEEN. I DO TO
00:37:48.199 --> 00:37:50.801
MOTION WILL MOVE I MISS ROSS
00:37:50.868 --> 00:37:53.037
SECOND BY MISS RUBIO- SEXUALLY
00:37:53.104 --> 00:37:54.972
CALDERON. THE MOTION IS TO
00:37:55.039 --> 00:37:56.540
WAIVE COMMITTEE RULES THIRTEEN
00:37:56.607 --> 00:37:57.742
AND FIFTEEN AND ARE TO APPROVE
00:37:57.808 --> 00:37:59.744
THE CONSENT CALENDAR AS I'VE
00:37:59.810 --> 00:38:02.546
EVER SALAS HI. SALAS AYE
00:38:02.613 --> 00:38:11.622
BOERNER HORVATH. GEN. PATTERSON
00:38:11.689 --> 00:38:16.360
RUBIO RUBIO AYE VOEPEL AYE
00:38:16.427 --> 00:38:22.133
VOEPEL I WOULD. CENTER OFF
00:38:22.199 --> 00:38:25.036
SENATOR ROBB AYE BARGES. OR
00:38:25.102 --> 00:38:27.471
JUST I GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I
00:38:27.538 --> 00:38:33.177
HERTZBERG. MORNING MORNING I
00:38:33.244 --> 00:38:54.932
MOORLACH. WINNER.
00:38:57.301 --> 00:39:03.107
WAS THE. FOR
00:39:03.174 --> 00:39:04.475
OKAY LET ME ASK AT THIS TIME IF
00:39:04.542 --> 00:39:06.077
WE COULD HAVE AN ASSEMBLY
00:39:06.143 --> 00:39:09.914
MEMBER REPORT TO. HEARING ROOM
00:39:09.980 --> 00:39:12.850
FOR. PLEASE NOT ON THE
00:39:12.917 --> 00:39:16.620
COMMITTEE. OKAY WITH THAT WILL
00:39:16.687 --> 00:39:17.555
GO AHEAD AND WE'LL COME BACK TO
00:39:17.621 --> 00:39:18.889
THE CONSENT CALENDAR ONCE WE
00:39:18.956 --> 00:39:20.958
GET- WHAT'S WE CAN SUSPEND
00:39:21.025 --> 00:39:23.294
RULES THIRTEEN FIFTEEN TO TAKE
00:39:23.360 --> 00:39:24.095
UP THE CONSENT CALENDAR AT THIS
00:39:24.161 --> 00:39:25.463
TIME WAS GOING TO MOVE TO THE
00:39:25.529 --> 00:39:27.898
REGULAR KEPT UNDER WE WILL MOVE
00:39:27.965 --> 00:39:31.302
TO. ASSEMBLY MEMBER SANTIAGO.
00:39:31.368 --> 00:39:34.905
SO REMEMBER SANTIAGO. WHEN
00:39:34.972 --> 00:39:36.107
YOU'RE READY TO PROCEED THIS
00:39:36.173 --> 00:39:42.613
WILL BE ON AGENDA ITEM NUMBER.
00:39:42.680 --> 00:39:43.414
THIRTEEN TWENTY TWENTY THAT'S
00:39:43.481 --> 00:39:44.148
ONE OF SEVEN DEPARTMENT OF
00:39:44.215 --> 00:39:45.549
TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL LEAD
00:39:45.616 --> 00:39:47.151
CONTAMINATION CLEAN UP
00:39:47.218 --> 00:39:49.386
ASSEMBLYMEMBER SANTIAGO WHEN
00:39:49.453 --> 00:39:49.987
YOU ARE READY TO BEGIN PLEASE
00:39:50.054 --> 00:39:51.555
BEGIN SURE THANK YOU MISTER
00:39:51.622 --> 00:39:52.923
CHAIRMAN I APPRECIATE THE
00:39:52.990 --> 00:39:54.358
OPPORTUNITY PRESENT BEFORE THE
00:39:54.425 --> 00:39:55.993
COMMITTEE WHAT WE'RE REQUESTING
00:39:56.060 --> 00:39:57.962
AT THE STATE AUDITOR AUDITS IDT
00:39:58.028 --> 00:39:59.463
ESSIE SPECIFICALLY TOWARDS WORK
00:39:59.530 --> 00:40:01.565
ON EXCITE. AS YOU MIGHT RECALL
00:40:01.632 --> 00:40:02.466
ON THIS IS THE WORST
00:40:02.533 --> 00:40:03.634
ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER ON THE
00:40:03.701 --> 00:40:05.069
WEST COAST THAT WE HAVE NOW
00:40:05.136 --> 00:40:07.004
BEEN FIGHTING TO CLEAN UP- THIS
00:40:07.071 --> 00:40:09.140
BODY HAS BEEN VERY GENEROUS-
00:40:09.206 --> 00:40:11.275
AND WE'RE NOW OVER TWO HUNDRED
00:40:11.342 --> 00:40:11.809
FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS BUT
00:40:11.876 --> 00:40:13.410
THERE'S SOME BIG QUESTIONS WE
00:40:13.477 --> 00:40:14.812
HAVE BASS. NUMBER ONE WHAT TO
00:40:14.879 --> 00:40:16.947
TAKING SO LONG NUMBER TWO WHY
00:40:17.014 --> 00:40:19.416
IS THE COST OF BURIED FROM
00:40:19.483 --> 00:40:21.685
FIFTY FROM THE ESTIMATED FIFTY
00:40:21.752 --> 00:40:23.087
THOUSAND A PROP NOW EIGHTY
00:40:23.154 --> 00:40:24.855
THREE THOUSAND A PROPERTY- WE
00:40:24.922 --> 00:40:26.657
NOW KNOW THAT SOME THAT THE
00:40:26.724 --> 00:40:29.126
PROCEDURES COULD'VE BEEN DONE
00:40:29.193 --> 00:40:30.728
THAT. HOW I KNOW THE CAR TO
00:40:30.795 --> 00:40:32.997
MAKE NOT HELD IN PLACE. AND OF
00:40:33.063 --> 00:40:36.066
QUESTIONS WE FOLKS. FOLKS OF
00:40:36.133 --> 00:40:38.202
MEN THAT WE PRINT TO ADD DTS
00:40:38.269 --> 00:40:39.870
PLEASE QUITE BUT QUITE. ARE
00:40:39.937 --> 00:40:40.671
THERE'S A BIT THE DISK. AND WE
00:40:40.738 --> 00:40:42.706
WOULD LIKE THE STATE OUT OF TO
00:40:42.773 --> 00:40:44.041
AUTO IN GIVE SOME ANSWERS TO
00:40:44.108 --> 00:40:45.709
WHITES. SO MUCH LENGTH OF TIME
00:40:45.776 --> 00:40:47.444
AND HOW WE CAN BE IS PUT IN AS
00:40:47.511 --> 00:40:49.480
WE CAN WITH- PRECIOUS TAX
00:40:49.547 --> 00:40:50.981
DOLLARS. SAW THANK YOU VERY
00:40:51.048 --> 00:40:52.149
MUCH MISTER CHAIR AND I'D LIKE
00:40:52.216 --> 00:40:53.717
TO HAVE SUPERVISED RELEASE ALSO
00:40:53.784 --> 00:40:55.019
PROVIDE TESTIMONY ON THE NEED
00:40:55.085 --> 00:40:56.387
FOR THIS. PLACE SUPERVISORS
00:40:56.453 --> 00:40:57.321
THANKS FOR JOINING US THANK YOU
00:40:57.388 --> 00:40:59.456
VERY MUCH OF TO THE MEMBERS OF
00:40:59.523 --> 00:41:00.491
THE COMMITTEE AND TO THE CHAIR.
00:41:00.558 --> 00:41:01.992
I ALSO WANT TO THANK ASSEMBLY
00:41:02.059 --> 00:41:03.694
MEMBER SANTIAGO FOR INVITING ME
00:41:03.761 --> 00:41:06.630
UP TODAY- OBVIOUSLY THIS IS A
00:41:06.697 --> 00:41:08.199
VERY CRITICAL ISSUE THAT THE
00:41:08.265 --> 00:41:08.833
LEGISLATURE HAS THEIR TAKE FOR
00:41:08.899 --> 00:41:12.203
THE PAST. YEARS I DO WANT TO.
00:41:12.269 --> 00:41:12.770
UNDERSCORE THAT THE GOVERNOR
00:41:12.837 --> 00:41:17.007
HAS PROVIDED FUNDING TO PROVIDE
00:41:17.074 --> 00:41:18.442
HOWEVER WE'VE HAD ISSUES
00:41:18.509 --> 00:41:20.177
REGARDING THE ADMINISTRATION OF
00:41:20.244 --> 00:41:22.213
TSC IN TERMS OF HOW THAT CLEAN
00:41:22.279 --> 00:41:24.515
UP IS CONDUCTED. AND THAT'S WHY
00:41:24.582 --> 00:41:25.783
WE'RE HERE TODAY IN MY OPINION
00:41:25.850 --> 00:41:27.952
THIS IS OUR FLINT MICHIGAN IN
00:41:28.018 --> 00:41:29.687
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA IT'S
00:41:29.753 --> 00:41:31.655
DEVASTATING TEN THOUSAND HEALTH
00:41:31.722 --> 00:41:33.023
SCHOOLS HAVE BEEN IMPACTED. IN
00:41:33.090 --> 00:41:34.491
THE SOUTHEAST COMMUNITIES AS
00:41:34.558 --> 00:41:36.861
WELL AS A STEP HEY- HERNANDEZ
00:41:36.927 --> 00:41:38.696
AND THE RED. THAT ARE PUT
00:41:38.762 --> 00:41:40.197
FORWARD NOW I DON'T THINK ARE
00:41:40.264 --> 00:41:42.233
SUFFICIENT WE NEED TO CONTINUE
00:41:42.299 --> 00:41:44.401
TO ASK FOR DETAILS SEE TO DO
00:41:44.468 --> 00:41:45.402
THE RIGHT THING AND CONTINUE
00:41:45.469 --> 00:41:47.371
WITH THE CLEAN UP. AND TO ALSO
00:41:47.438 --> 00:41:49.573
REVIEW THE TERMS OF AGREEMENTS
00:41:49.640 --> 00:41:51.041
WITH THE CONTRACTORS BECAUSE AS
00:41:51.108 --> 00:41:54.144
A- ASSEMBLY MEMBER SAID- THERE
00:41:54.211 --> 00:41:55.179
ARE SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT. A
00:41:55.246 --> 00:41:57.481
CONTRACTING OVERHEAD CHARGES
00:41:57.548 --> 00:41:59.283
AND THAT WILL IMPACT THE CLEAN
00:41:59.350 --> 00:42:01.552
UP. THAT THEN I THINK CREEK LZ
00:42:01.619 --> 00:42:03.587
OUT OF HELPING AND HOUSEHOLDS
00:42:03.654 --> 00:42:05.756
THAT CAN'T BE REVIEWED
00:42:05.823 --> 00:42:08.259
EFFICIENTLY. AND THE COMMUTE.
00:42:08.325 --> 00:42:10.961
AND WAITING. MORE THAN TWICE A
00:42:11.028 --> 00:42:12.830
YEAR THE PLAN HAS BEEN CHAU.
00:42:12.897 --> 00:42:17.968
WITH THE IMPACT IS WHAT IT A
00:42:18.035 --> 00:42:22.873
TO. PEOPLE TO WOMEN. IT'S TIME
00:42:22.940 --> 00:42:25.943
THAT WE TAKE A SECOND LOOK. SEE
00:42:26.010 --> 00:42:28.112
MY OPINION I UNDERSTAND THE TSC
00:42:28.178 --> 00:42:29.747
HAS ABOUT NINETY FOUR MILLION
00:42:29.813 --> 00:42:31.382
DOLLARS IN FUNDS REMAINING THAT
00:42:31.448 --> 00:42:36.053
ARE ON ALLOCATED. ARE OVER
00:42:36.120 --> 00:42:37.254
FIFTY YOUR PROPERTIES ROOM TO
00:42:37.321 --> 00:42:44.094
BE. LOS APPROXIMATELY ONE
00:42:44.161 --> 00:42:45.663
THOUSAND AND FIFTY. OF
00:42:45.729 --> 00:42:47.264
PROPERTIES CAN BE CLEANED UP
00:42:47.331 --> 00:42:48.465
FOR THE NINETY FOUR MILLION IN
00:42:48.532 --> 00:42:50.401
OUR ESTIMATION. AND IT'S NOT
00:42:50.467 --> 00:42:51.969
SUFFICIENT FUNDING TO CLEAN UP
00:42:52.036 --> 00:42:54.171
THE REMAINING FIVE HUNDRED
00:42:54.238 --> 00:42:55.205
PROPERTIES TO REACH THE INTERIM
00:42:55.272 --> 00:42:57.641
GOAL OF THREE THOUSAND TWO
00:42:57.708 --> 00:42:59.076
HUNDRED THAT WAS SET BY DE TSC.
00:42:59.143 --> 00:43:00.844
SO WE KNOW TAT THIS IS A MOVE
00:43:00.911 --> 00:43:01.812
IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION IF
00:43:01.879 --> 00:43:03.447
YOU'LL APPROVED. THIS AUDIT AND
00:43:03.514 --> 00:43:04.949
WE LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
00:43:05.015 --> 00:43:06.917
YOU ANTI TNC THEY'VE COME DOWN
00:43:06.984 --> 00:43:08.686
SEVERAL TIMES. TO OUR AREA TO
00:43:08.752 --> 00:43:10.254
TALK TO CONSTITUENTS BUT I WILL
00:43:10.321 --> 00:43:12.356
SAY THAT. OF PEOPLE ARE ARE ARE
00:43:12.423 --> 00:43:14.391
VERY ANXIOUS AND WANT TO SEE
00:43:14.458 --> 00:43:16.360
REMEDIES WITH A ONE ALSO SEE
00:43:16.427 --> 00:43:18.128
THAT THERE ARE SOME CULTURAL
00:43:18.195 --> 00:43:19.096
COMPETENCE THE PROVIDED.
00:43:19.163 --> 00:43:20.631
THROUGH THE CONTRACTING IS A
00:43:20.698 --> 00:43:23.968
LIST WITH THE STAFF. BECAUSE
00:43:24.034 --> 00:43:25.970
YOU DO HAVE MANY MONOLINGUALS
00:43:26.036 --> 00:43:28.105
SPEAKING END OF IT. AND ARE.
00:43:28.172 --> 00:43:29.239
ONLY A WILL A WITH THE PATIENTS
00:43:29.306 --> 00:43:31.075
OF THE CLEAN. AND ALSO OTHER
00:43:31.141 --> 00:43:32.376
FACT IT STILL. THERE'S A SIX
00:43:32.443 --> 00:43:34.745
HUNDRED HOUSEHOLDS WERE DTS SEE
00:43:34.812 --> 00:43:36.413
HAS NOT BEEN ABLE TO OUR I'M
00:43:36.480 --> 00:43:38.682
SORRY. A THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED
00:43:38.749 --> 00:43:40.351
PROPERTIES THAT HAVE. NOT
00:43:40.417 --> 00:43:42.453
RECEIVED ADEQUATE ACCESS
00:43:42.519 --> 00:43:44.021
AGREEMENTS TO BE ABLE TO GO
00:43:44.088 --> 00:43:45.589
INTO THE PROPERTY TO IDENTIFY
00:43:45.656 --> 00:43:47.191
THE CLEANUP. AND I KNOW THAT
00:43:47.257 --> 00:43:48.525
CAN BE HARD BUT AS A COUNTY
00:43:48.592 --> 00:43:49.827
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS WERE
00:43:49.893 --> 00:43:51.462
WILLING TO WORK. WITH THE S.
00:43:51.528 --> 00:43:53.597
DTS SEE TO HELP FACILITATE THAT
00:43:53.664 --> 00:43:54.765
BUT WE'VE YET TO HEAR A
00:43:54.832 --> 00:43:56.567
RESPONSE SO I JUST READ A
00:43:56.633 --> 00:43:58.402
WRITTEN. REQUEST RESPECTFULLY
00:43:58.469 --> 00:44:00.637
THAT OU OF. PROVIDE SUPPORT
00:44:00.704 --> 00:44:02.039
FOR THIS AUDIT AND HOPEFULLY WE
00:44:02.106 --> 00:44:03.574
CAN GET TO THE BOTTOM OF A WHAT
00:44:03.640 --> 00:44:06.010
NEEDS TO BE DONE TO REMEDY. THE
00:44:06.076 --> 00:44:07.878
BANKS AND- CAN. OF OUR
00:44:07.945 --> 00:44:09.513
COMMUNITY AND THE SOUTHEAST AND
00:44:09.580 --> 00:44:11.248
EAST LOS ANGELES AREAS THANK
00:44:11.315 --> 00:44:13.317
YOU. OKAY THANK YOU APPRECIATE
00:44:13.384 --> 00:44:14.485
THE TESTIMONY AND WILL PROBABLY
00:44:14.551 --> 00:44:15.919
COME BACK TO THAT SPECIALLY IF
00:44:15.986 --> 00:44:17.121
YOU HAVEN'T RECEIVED A RESPONSE
00:44:17.187 --> 00:44:19.123
FROM THE DEPARTMENT- WILL WE
00:44:19.189 --> 00:44:19.656
COME TO THE QUESTIONS AND
00:44:19.723 --> 00:44:21.191
ANSWERS AT THIS TIME IS GOING
00:44:21.258 --> 00:44:21.825
TO MOVE TO THE STATE AUDITOR'S
00:44:21.892 --> 00:44:23.260
PRESENTATION. THANK YOU MISTER
00:44:23.327 --> 00:44:24.795
CHAIR AND MEMBERS- AS
00:44:24.862 --> 00:44:25.763
ASSEMBLYMEMBER SANTIAGO
00:44:25.829 --> 00:44:26.864
INDICATED THIS WOULD BE AN
00:44:26.930 --> 00:44:28.032
HONOR TO THE DEPARTMENT TOXIC
00:44:28.098 --> 00:44:29.833
SUBSTANCES. AND IT WOULD LOOK
00:44:29.900 --> 00:44:30.968
AT THE VARIETY OF ISSUES
00:44:31.035 --> 00:44:32.936
PRIMARILY. THE FIRST OBJECTIVE
00:44:33.003 --> 00:44:33.837
REALLY LOOKING AT THEIR
00:44:33.904 --> 00:44:36.407
CONTRACTS AND- THE CONTRACTS
00:44:36.473 --> 00:44:37.908
THAT THEY'VE EXECUTED FOR CLEAN
00:44:37.975 --> 00:44:39.009
UP ACTIVITIES AND HERE'S THE
00:44:39.076 --> 00:44:41.145
DID THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN
00:44:41.211 --> 00:44:42.579
THOSE CONTRACTS. PARTICULARLY
00:44:42.646 --> 00:44:45.849
WHEN WITH RESPECT TO PROPERTY
00:44:45.916 --> 00:44:46.984
OF VALUE BY THE CONTRACT AND
00:44:47.051 --> 00:44:48.385
THOSE DIFFERENCES REASONABLE
00:44:48.452 --> 00:44:50.354
WHAT ARE THE FACTORS. BECAUSE
00:44:50.421 --> 00:44:52.689
THOSE THERE IS. GETTING TO THE
00:44:52.756 --> 00:44:55.526
DIFFERENT. AS TOXIC SUBSTANCE.
00:44:55.592 --> 00:44:57.494
ODD IN. PLIED WITH STATE CON.
00:44:57.561 --> 00:44:58.695
RULES HAVE THEY DONE. THEY CAN
00:44:58.762 --> 00:45:00.064
COULD OR DID THEY DO EVERYTHING
00:45:00.130 --> 00:45:02.299
THEY COULD- IN AWARDING THOSE
00:45:02.366 --> 00:45:03.834
CONTRACTS MAKING SURE THAT THEY
00:45:03.901 --> 00:45:05.135
GOT THE BEST VALUE FOR THE
00:45:05.202 --> 00:45:07.337
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. ALSO IN
00:45:07.404 --> 00:45:09.139
MONITORING THOSE CONTRACTS ARE
00:45:09.206 --> 00:45:10.340
THEY ENSURING THAT THERE OF
00:45:10.407 --> 00:45:12.109
TRYING TO AVOID OR CONTAIN ANY
00:45:12.176 --> 00:45:15.079
COST INCREASES. ALSO HE HAS
00:45:15.145 --> 00:45:15.879
ASKED US TO LOOK AT THE
00:45:15.946 --> 00:45:17.381
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS WHAT COST
00:45:17.448 --> 00:45:19.483
IS THE DEPARTMENT TOXICS.
00:45:19.550 --> 00:45:21.785
SUBSTANCE CONTROL INCURRING IN
00:45:21.852 --> 00:45:24.755
MONITORING THE CONTRACTS- AND
00:45:24.822 --> 00:45:25.389
ARE THEY DOING EVERYTHING THEY
00:45:25.456 --> 00:45:27.357
CAN TO CONTAIN THOSE COSTS AS
00:45:27.424 --> 00:45:29.126
WELL. AND THEN OUR OTHER
00:45:29.193 --> 00:45:31.195
OBJECTIVE ASKING US EVALUATE
00:45:31.261 --> 00:45:32.696
THE PER PROPERTY CLEAN UP
00:45:32.763 --> 00:45:34.198
ESTIMATES SO NOT ONLY WHAT HAS
00:45:34.264 --> 00:45:36.767
OCCURRED. THUS FAR BUT WHAT ARE
00:45:36.834 --> 00:45:41.405
THE- THAT ARE TRIBUNE BRING. IN
00:45:41.472 --> 00:45:44.208
OR- SUGGESTED IN. IN THE-
00:45:44.274 --> 00:45:45.943
FUTURE. OUT REALLY LOOKING AT
00:45:46.009 --> 00:45:48.078
THAT AND MAKING. THAT TALKS AS-
00:45:48.145 --> 00:45:50.013
APPROPRIATE INFORMATION AND GET
00:45:50.080 --> 00:45:53.217
DOCUMENTS ARE FULLY DISPLAY. OF
00:45:53.283 --> 00:45:55.719
THESE MADE ARE. IN HE SAID A
00:45:55.786 --> 00:45:58.422
PART. BE ARE ALSO A US TO LOOK
00:45:58.489 --> 00:46:00.524
AT ONE TIME. WHEN IS THE ANSWER.
00:46:00.591 --> 00:46:01.792
EXT WHAT IS EXPECTATION IS FOR
00:46:01.859 --> 00:46:03.527
AS WHEN WILL THIS. PROJECT OR
00:46:03.594 --> 00:46:05.129
THIS CLEAN UP EFFORT BE FULLY
00:46:05.195 --> 00:46:07.164
COMPLETED AND DO THOSE TIME
00:46:07.231 --> 00:46:08.966
FRAMES APPEAR REASONABLE WHAT
00:46:09.032 --> 00:46:13.470
WERE THEY- ON ARE USING. PULL
00:46:13.537 --> 00:46:16.073
INFORMATION INFORM. SOME THERE.
00:46:16.140 --> 00:46:16.874
SUGGESTION AS FAR AS HOW IT
00:46:16.940 --> 00:46:17.875
WILL CLEAN UP NOT ONLY PRICE
00:46:17.941 --> 00:46:19.843
READ. BUT PERHAPS SOME COME
00:46:19.910 --> 00:46:22.713
PROPERTY IN THE REGION AS WELL.
00:46:22.779 --> 00:46:26.216
AND FOR. LOOK AT WHERE OR NOT
00:46:26.283 --> 00:46:32.389
THE- ISSUE STEP ARE THERE FISH.
00:46:32.456 --> 00:46:38.695
IS THAT. A P. TRY GET THIS CALL
00:46:38.762 --> 00:46:39.329
BETH I'M MORE LIKELY AND ONLY.
00:46:39.396 --> 00:46:41.865
CALL PASTA MATT MAN. THE HOURS
00:46:41.932 --> 00:46:42.799
FOR THIS UP TWENTY FOUR HUNDRED
00:46:42.866 --> 00:46:45.836
OUR- THIS IS WOULD SIX COME.
00:46:45.903 --> 00:46:49.173
YOU MISTER CHAIR. THANK YOU.
00:46:49.239 --> 00:46:52.843
YEAH OKAY THE TIME WE'RE GOING
00:46:52.910 --> 00:46:53.477
TO GO AHEAD AND READ FROM THE
00:46:53.544 --> 00:46:55.179
IF AGE AFTER TO IDENTIFY IF YOU
00:46:55.245 --> 00:46:56.580
CAN PLEASE BEACON WITH YOUR
00:46:56.647 --> 00:47:02.553
COMMENTS NONE OF THEM. NINE TWO
00:47:02.619 --> 00:47:04.421
HUNDRED FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS
00:47:04.488 --> 00:47:18.101
ONE OF THE. PLEASE IF YOU COULD
00:47:18.168 --> 00:47:19.603
IDENTIFY YOURSELVES AND-
00:47:19.670 --> 00:47:21.672
ORGANIZATION GOOD MORNING MY
00:47:21.738 --> 00:47:23.340
NAME IS FRANCESCA DEGREE AND
00:47:23.407 --> 00:47:24.408
THE CHIEF DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR
00:47:24.474 --> 00:47:25.509
THE DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC
00:47:25.576 --> 00:47:27.244
SUBSTANCES CONTROL AND WITH ME
00:47:27.311 --> 00:47:28.445
IS DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR SITE
00:47:28.512 --> 00:47:30.314
MITIGATION RESTORATION PROGRAM
00:47:30.380 --> 00:47:32.516
GRANT COPE- WE'RE VERY PLEASED
00:47:32.583 --> 00:47:34.151
TO BE HERE AND APPRECIATE THE
00:47:34.218 --> 00:47:36.553
OPPORTUNITY TO- TO CONTRIBUTE
00:47:36.620 --> 00:47:37.988
TO THE CONVERSATION OF THIS
00:47:38.055 --> 00:47:40.657
PROPOSED AUDIT A DTS C. M.
00:47:40.724 --> 00:47:43.393
WELCOMES AND ANY OPPORTUNITY TO
00:47:43.460 --> 00:47:44.328
BE TRANSPARENT AND ACCOUNTABLE
00:47:44.394 --> 00:47:46.396
AND ITS BUSINESS PRACTICES AND
00:47:46.463 --> 00:47:48.232
UNDERSTANDS THAT- WE UNDERSTAND
00:47:48.298 --> 00:47:50.500
THE- THE ENORMITY OF THIS
00:47:50.567 --> 00:47:53.337
PROJECT AND THE IMPACT TO THE
00:47:53.403 --> 00:47:56.039
COMMUNITIES THAT WE SERVE- WE
00:47:56.106 --> 00:47:59.209
HAVE AND IT IN. AND AN TO THAT
00:47:59.276 --> 00:48:01.278
POINT B.WE ACTUALLY RECOGNIZED
00:48:01.345 --> 00:48:03.413
THAT CONDUCTING AUDITS ON THIS
00:48:03.480 --> 00:48:06.083
PROJECT WAS VITAL POURTANT TO
00:48:06.149 --> 00:48:07.484
ENSURING THAT WE WERE MAN DEAN
00:48:07.551 --> 00:48:11.388
AND THE EXPENDITURES AND MONIES
00:48:11.455 --> 00:48:12.256
RELATED TO THIS PROJECT
00:48:12.322 --> 00:48:14.224
APPROPRIATELY I UNDERSTAND THAT
00:48:14.291 --> 00:48:16.593
AUDIT RESPONSES OR AUDIT
00:48:16.660 --> 00:48:18.061
FINDINGS HAVE BEEN PROVIDED TO
00:48:18.128 --> 00:48:19.896
YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERING. WE
00:48:19.963 --> 00:48:21.832
HAD SEVERAL- AUDIT REPORTS THAT
00:48:21.898 --> 00:48:24.301
CAME OUT ON THIS PROJECT ON ITS
00:48:24.368 --> 00:48:26.837
HELP KEEP THE FINANCE AND-
00:48:26.903 --> 00:48:28.338
THOSE AUDITS OF INDICATED THAT
00:48:28.405 --> 00:48:30.774
WE HAVE STRONG AND CONTROLS FOR
00:48:30.841 --> 00:48:32.909
MANAGEMENT OF THE EXPENDITURES
00:48:32.976 --> 00:48:36.046
FOR THIS PROJECT IF YOU HAVE
00:48:36.113 --> 00:48:37.347
ANY QUESTIONS REAL. TO THE
00:48:37.414 --> 00:48:38.282
CONTRACTS SINCE. WERE WHAT
00:48:38.348 --> 00:48:39.549
WE'VE BEEN EXPERIENCING MISTER
00:48:39.616 --> 00:48:40.417
COPE HERE TO ANSWER THOSE
00:48:40.484 --> 00:48:41.952
QUESTIONS FOR YOU THREE THANK
00:48:42.019 --> 00:48:45.155
YOU WITH THAT WE TURN IT BACK
00:48:45.222 --> 00:48:46.790
TO THE DíAS LET ME ASK THIRTY
00:48:46.857 --> 00:48:48.525
QUESTIONS FROM THE MEMBERS
00:48:48.592 --> 00:48:51.094
SENATOR MONEY PLEASE. THANK YOU
00:48:51.161 --> 00:48:54.998
MISTER CHAIR AND- THANK YOU
00:48:55.065 --> 00:48:57.301
ASSEMBLYMEMBER SANTIAGO FOR
00:48:57.367 --> 00:48:59.936
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. WELCOME
00:49:00.003 --> 00:49:01.938
SUPERVISOR SO LEASE MADAM
00:49:02.005 --> 00:49:03.740
SECRETARY WELCOME HOME NICE TO
00:49:03.807 --> 00:49:08.378
SEE YOU SO I GUESS FIRST FOR
00:49:08.445 --> 00:49:10.681
THE AUDITOR I WAS PROVIDED SOME
00:49:10.747 --> 00:49:12.582
RESPONSES PER WILL FOR THE
00:49:12.649 --> 00:49:14.451
AUTHOR I WAS PROVIDED BY JANE
00:49:14.518 --> 00:49:19.690
LACK. BY BY DTS SEEN SOME
00:49:19.756 --> 00:49:21.425
RESPONSES TO YOUR J. LACK
00:49:21.491 --> 00:49:24.594
REQUEST HAVE YOU HAD A CHANCE
00:49:24.661 --> 00:49:27.264
TO REVIEW THOSE ON UP. ON AND
00:49:27.331 --> 00:49:29.099
WE REVIEW DOCUMENTS IN THE PAST
00:49:29.166 --> 00:49:30.934
I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOUR HAND
00:49:31.001 --> 00:49:32.402
WHAT YOU HAVE AND BEFORE YOU.
00:49:32.469 --> 00:49:35.205
THIS IS. SOME RESPONSES TO
00:49:35.272 --> 00:49:37.841
QUESTIONS ON EXCITED. THERE SIR
00:49:37.908 --> 00:49:41.445
PROVIDED TO ME BY CAL EPA. OM
00:49:41.511 --> 00:49:42.979
YOU HAVEN'T PROVIDED THESE TO
00:49:43.046 --> 00:49:45.148
THE AUTHOR. THEY WERE PROVIDED
00:49:45.215 --> 00:49:48.385
HIS OFFICE WHEN IF WE PROVIDED.
00:49:48.452 --> 00:49:50.120
HAS THE AUDITOR HAD A CHANCE
00:49:50.187 --> 00:49:51.988
TRIBUNE THESE WE RECEIVE THOSE
00:49:52.055 --> 00:49:53.490
MATERIALS LAST NIGHT AND I HAVE
00:49:53.557 --> 00:49:55.125
AMEND MY I AND I HAD AN
00:49:55.192 --> 00:49:56.693
OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK AT THOSE I
00:49:56.760 --> 00:49:59.596
ALSO UNDERSTAND THAT M. GEO-
00:49:59.663 --> 00:50:01.298
DID THE AUDITS OF THEIR
00:50:01.365 --> 00:50:02.733
INTERNAL CONTROLS AND AN
00:50:02.799 --> 00:50:03.967
INTERNAL CONTROL ON IT IS
00:50:04.034 --> 00:50:05.202
DIFFERENT THAN A PERFORMANCE
00:50:05.268 --> 00:50:07.537
AUDIT WHAT WHAT THE- THE MEMBER
00:50:07.604 --> 00:50:10.607
IS ASKING US TO DO IS LOOK AT-
00:50:10.674 --> 00:50:12.809
COME. COMPARISONS OF PER
00:50:12.876 --> 00:50:15.045
PROPERTY- COST OUT LOOKING AT A
00:50:15.112 --> 00:50:16.747
COUPLE OF CONTRACTORS LOOKING
00:50:16.813 --> 00:50:18.982
AT CONTRACTING PRACTICES THOSE
00:50:19.049 --> 00:50:20.450
WERE NOT THE TYPES OF THINGS
00:50:20.517 --> 00:50:20.984
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT NGOS
00:50:21.051 --> 00:50:23.153
TERRIFIC FIRM- BUT THEY WERE
00:50:23.220 --> 00:50:24.921
LOOKING AT ARE THE EXPENDITURES
00:50:24.988 --> 00:50:27.090
BEING RECORDED APPROPRIATELY
00:50:27.157 --> 00:50:29.192
THEY LOOK AT SOME TIME SHE TO
00:50:29.259 --> 00:50:30.494
MAKE SURE THAT. PEOPLE WHO ARE
00:50:30.560 --> 00:50:32.062
ON THE PROJECT RECORDING
00:50:32.129 --> 00:50:36.566
PROPERTY LAKE THE AND IT'S- THE
00:50:36.633 --> 00:50:39.102
RESULTS ARE THAT THEIR INTERNAL
00:50:39.169 --> 00:50:41.271
CONTROL SO THAT MAY BE A
00:50:41.338 --> 00:50:44.574
PATIENT. I ON BUT IT CAN SCRIPT
00:50:44.641 --> 00:50:46.510
DOES THAT WERE AND IS THERE
00:50:46.576 --> 00:50:47.978
WHAT ASKING YOU THANK YOU
00:50:48.044 --> 00:50:52.916
HELPFUL. OF INTEREST. ONE IN
00:50:52.983 --> 00:50:54.684
USE. DOES PROPOSE A PACKAGE OF
00:50:54.751 --> 00:50:57.487
FOR DTE ANY. MISTER CENTER OF
00:50:57.554 --> 00:50:58.355
HIS CHANCE REVIEW GOVERNOR
00:50:58.422 --> 00:51:00.490
BUDGET WE HAVE BUT LOOK HERE'S
00:51:00.557 --> 00:51:02.592
WHAT'S ITS AND ALL FRAME WHY
00:51:02.659 --> 00:51:03.827
THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT TO US
00:51:03.894 --> 00:51:05.362
RIGHT BECAUSE WHAT'S AT STAKE
00:51:05.429 --> 00:51:06.663
IS OUR IS AND I DON'T THINK I
00:51:06.730 --> 00:51:07.731
THINK I DON'T THINK I HAVE TO
00:51:07.798 --> 00:51:08.665
CONVINCE ON THAT PART BUT ALL
00:51:08.732 --> 00:51:10.167
UNDERSTATEMENT THE LAST WHAT'S
00:51:10.233 --> 00:51:11.601
AT STAKE OUR COMMUNITIES HEALTH
00:51:11.668 --> 00:51:13.303
BECAUSE WHEN WE STARTED THIS
00:51:13.370 --> 00:51:14.304
THERE WAS APPROXIMATION OF HOW
00:51:14.371 --> 00:51:15.739
LONG IT WOULD TAKE TO CLEAN. WE
00:51:15.806 --> 00:51:17.808
NOW PASS THOSE TIMES THERE WAS
00:51:17.874 --> 00:51:19.242
AN APPROXIMATION OF HOW MUCH
00:51:19.309 --> 00:51:21.344
EACH PROPERTY COSTS WE HAVE NOW
00:51:21.411 --> 00:51:22.379
BE GONE BEYOND THAT IT WAS A
00:51:22.446 --> 00:51:23.113
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ONE
00:51:23.180 --> 00:51:25.248
CONTRACTOR DO CERTAIN PROPERTY
00:51:25.315 --> 00:51:26.550
FOR CERTAIN COST ABOUT SIXTY
00:51:26.616 --> 00:51:29.886
ANOTHER CONTRACTOR DOING OF
00:51:29.953 --> 00:51:32.122
ANOTHER COST ABOUT EIGHTY AND
00:51:32.189 --> 00:51:34.057
WE'LL TALK ABOUT SOME
00:51:34.124 --> 00:51:36.693
PROPERTIES. AS THE THREE. ONES
00:51:36.760 --> 00:51:38.929
WE- OUGHT TO. BUT WHAT WHAT.
00:51:38.995 --> 00:51:40.230
PERFECTLY THIS BUT PROJECT IT
00:51:40.297 --> 00:51:41.765
WITHIN OUR COMMUNITY THAT IS
00:51:41.832 --> 00:51:42.933
NOT WE DON'T BELIEVE IS BEING
00:51:42.999 --> 00:51:44.968
ADDRESSED WHILE AND WHILE I
00:51:45.035 --> 00:51:47.270
WHILE I CAN I WELL I UNDERSTAND
00:51:47.337 --> 00:51:49.873
THE RESPONSES. WE FEEL THAT WE
00:51:49.940 --> 00:51:51.508
NEED AN INDEPENDENT AUDITOR TO
00:51:51.575 --> 00:51:52.476
TAKE A LOOK AT THE QUESTIONS
00:51:52.542 --> 00:51:54.344
WERE SPECIFICALLY REQUESTING TO
00:51:54.411 --> 00:51:55.445
ENSURE NOT ONLY THAT THE
00:51:55.512 --> 00:51:56.646
REMAINING DOLLARS ARE SPENT
00:51:56.713 --> 00:51:58.482
WELL- BUT QUITE FRANKLY GIVE
00:51:58.548 --> 00:51:59.749
THIS HAPPENS IN ANYBODY ELSE'S
00:51:59.816 --> 00:52:02.052
COMMUNITY- ANY OF US WHO
00:52:02.118 --> 00:52:03.487
REPRESENT WE BE DEMANDING THE
00:52:03.553 --> 00:52:05.455
SAME SORT OF AUDIT. BECAUSE IT
00:52:05.522 --> 00:52:07.023
THIS CAN HAPPEN IN ANYBODY'S
00:52:07.090 --> 00:52:08.225
BACKYARD IN THE FACT THAT IT
00:52:08.291 --> 00:52:09.159
HAPPENED IN OUR BACKYARD LOW
00:52:09.226 --> 00:52:11.294
INCOME- LATINO NEIGHBORHOODS.
00:52:11.361 --> 00:52:12.896
BUT WE FEEL VERY STRONGLY ABOUT
00:52:12.963 --> 00:52:15.031
THIS HAPPEN LOOK AT LOOK FOR
00:52:15.098 --> 00:52:16.066
THIRTY THREE YEARS. EXIDE
00:52:16.132 --> 00:52:19.336
ALLOWED. DEED FOR X. SORRY DTS
00:52:19.402 --> 00:52:21.505
HE ALLOWED EXCITE- TO OPERATE
00:52:21.571 --> 00:52:22.806
UNDER TEMPORARY PERMIT I MEAN
00:52:22.873 --> 00:52:24.007
THAT THERE SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE
00:52:24.074 --> 00:52:25.342
BIG RED FLAG WE'VE NOT GONE
00:52:25.408 --> 00:52:27.077
THROUGH TWO OR THREE FACTORS
00:52:27.143 --> 00:52:29.079
WILL HAVE A NEW DIRECTOR NOW.
00:52:29.145 --> 00:52:30.614
WITH A REALLY GOOD OPPORTUNITY
00:52:30.680 --> 00:52:32.115
WE HAVE A NEW DIRECTOR SHE'S
00:52:32.182 --> 00:52:33.884
WORKING REALLY HARD TO GET THIS
00:52:33.950 --> 00:52:35.485
DONE AND WE BELIEVE THAT THIS
00:52:35.552 --> 00:52:37.854
WILL ALL WILL. GIVE HER TOOLS
00:52:37.921 --> 00:52:39.723
DON'T ARE ALL ON THE WORK OF
00:52:39.789 --> 00:52:41.892
THE PERSON VOTE FOR THE- TIME
00:52:41.958 --> 00:52:43.793
AND TO DO THE- TAKE CARE BUT
00:52:43.860 --> 00:52:45.161
WILL. THEN MOVE FOR AND SPEND
00:52:45.228 --> 00:52:46.763
LIKE WHY SUPPORT RE ANYMORE
00:52:46.830 --> 00:52:48.732
DOLLARS CLEAN THIS UP THE END
00:52:48.798 --> 00:52:53.603
OF THE DAY HEALTH. I DON'T. YOU.
00:52:53.670 --> 00:52:54.204
WE HAVE TO HAVE THE CONFIDENCE
00:52:54.271 --> 00:52:55.105
OF THE LET. THE COMPANY OF OUR
00:52:55.171 --> 00:52:55.972
USE THE MONIES WILL BE. WELL IN
00:52:56.039 --> 00:52:57.741
THE MOST IF. WAY WHEN IT COMES
00:52:57.807 --> 00:52:59.175
TO CLEANING UP OUR NEIGHBOR. I
00:52:59.242 --> 00:52:59.743
THINK IT'S THE RIGHT IME AND
00:52:59.809 --> 00:53:00.944
QUITE FRANKLY I THINK THE
00:53:01.011 --> 00:53:01.578
LITTLE BIT LATE THAT WERE HERE.
00:53:01.645 --> 00:53:03.446
ASKING FOR NOT A FEW YEARS
00:53:03.513 --> 00:53:04.848
LATER IN. BY CERTAINLY
00:53:04.915 --> 00:53:06.750
APPRECIATE THE GRAVITY OF THE
00:53:06.816 --> 00:53:10.387
CRISIS AS YOU DESCRIBED ITS-
00:53:10.453 --> 00:53:11.254
CALIFORNIA'S PLANT.
00:53:11.321 --> 00:53:12.222
UNFORTUNATELY WE HAVE
00:53:12.289 --> 00:53:14.124
CONTAMINATED WATER SYSTEMS
00:53:14.190 --> 00:53:15.292
THROUGHOUT THE STATE THAT IS
00:53:15.358 --> 00:53:17.227
ALSO CALIFORNIA'S FLINT RIGHT.
00:53:17.294 --> 00:53:19.296
ARM ONE OF MY CONCERNS WE'VE
00:53:19.362 --> 00:53:23.600
ALLOCATED- GENERAL FUND DOLLARS
00:53:23.667 --> 00:53:25.569
FOR THIS CLEANUP WHEN. WHAT'S
00:53:25.635 --> 00:53:28.471
THE STE. WASN'T EXCITED PAYING
00:53:28.538 --> 00:53:29.940
FOR THIS CLEANUP. THEY ARE WHAT
00:53:30.006 --> 00:53:31.441
WILL BE WILL BE I MEAN I'LL
00:53:31.508 --> 00:53:32.142
I'LL GIVE YOU THE VERY HIGH
00:53:32.208 --> 00:53:33.810
LEVEL UNDERSTANDING. THERE WAS
00:53:33.877 --> 00:53:35.412
A NON PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
00:53:35.478 --> 00:53:37.080
THAT WAS SIGNED BACK I BELIEVE
00:53:37.147 --> 00:53:39.616
IT'S TWO THOUSAND AND- FIFTEEN.
00:53:39.683 --> 00:53:42.185
THAT AT SOME POINT ONE FOUND
00:53:42.252 --> 00:53:44.621
CULPABLE- THE X. EXCITE WOULD
00:53:44.688 --> 00:53:46.890
BE RESPONSIBLE THE DOLLARS TO.
00:53:46.957 --> 00:53:47.857
BUT FOR THE DOLLARS OF CLEAN UP
00:53:47.924 --> 00:53:48.825
IN WOULD REIMBURSE THE STATE
00:53:48.892 --> 00:53:50.460
NOW IF THAT DOESN'T HAPPEN
00:53:50.527 --> 00:53:52.395
THERE THERE IS A SECOND. A IT
00:53:52.462 --> 00:53:53.663
WAS A SECOND BILL TO ADDRESS
00:53:53.730 --> 00:53:55.098
THAT ISSUE BUT AT THE END OF
00:53:55.165 --> 00:53:56.232
THE DAY WHAT WE'RE DEALING WITH
00:53:56.299 --> 00:53:58.368
RIGHT NOW IS CLEANING UP. WITH
00:53:58.435 --> 00:53:59.903
THE WITH THE DOLLARS HAVE BEEN
00:53:59.970 --> 00:54:02.138
ALLOCATED. AND I THINK THAT'S I
00:54:02.205 --> 00:54:04.040
THINK THAT'S A VERY HIGH LEVEL-
00:54:04.107 --> 00:54:05.275
YEAH BUT IF I CAN JUST ADD ON
00:54:05.342 --> 00:54:06.843
TO THAT. PLEASE SO THE THROUGH
00:54:06.910 --> 00:54:08.778
THE CHAIR POLICE- THANK YOU
00:54:08.845 --> 00:54:12.582
CHAIR I'M SORRY. SO THE US.
00:54:12.649 --> 00:54:14.050
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FIND A
00:54:14.117 --> 00:54:15.619
NON PROSECUTION AGREEMENT WITH
00:54:15.685 --> 00:54:18.822
BACKSIDE. NOT NOT THE STATE DID
00:54:18.888 --> 00:54:19.956
YOU SEE HAS BEEN ACTIVELY
00:54:20.023 --> 00:54:22.092
WORKING WITH THE STATE ATTORNEY
00:54:22.158 --> 00:54:23.927
GENERAL TO BUILD A CASE FOR
00:54:23.994 --> 00:54:25.762
COST RECOVERY AGAINST EXIDE NOT
00:54:25.829 --> 00:54:27.764
EXCITED FIGHTING US THUS FAR
00:54:27.831 --> 00:54:30.033
ADMINISTRATIVELY AT EVERY TURN.
00:54:30.100 --> 00:54:31.001
WE'RE NOT GONNA ACCEPT THAT
00:54:31.067 --> 00:54:32.035
OBVIOUSLY WE'RE GONNA MOVE
00:54:32.102 --> 00:54:33.970
FORWARD TO PROSECUTE. COST
00:54:34.037 --> 00:54:36.406
RECOVERY ACTION AGAINST EXIDE
00:54:36.473 --> 00:54:37.173
TO RECOVER ALL THE COST THAT WE
00:54:37.240 --> 00:54:39.976
CAN. WITH THE SCOPE OF THIS ON
00:54:40.043 --> 00:54:42.212
IT LOOK AT THE STATUS OF. OF
00:54:42.278 --> 00:54:45.048
THAT IN IN COST REIMBURSEMENT
00:54:45.115 --> 00:54:47.984
TO THE STATE. THIS QUESTION FOR
00:54:48.051 --> 00:54:50.153
THE MONITOR NO WE DON'T HAVE I
00:54:50.220 --> 00:54:51.421
DON'T SEE ANYTHING IN THE SCOPE
00:54:51.488 --> 00:54:54.891
OF THE HONORED AS FAR AS- COSTA.
00:54:54.958 --> 00:54:56.192
IT'S REALLY LOOKING AT TOXIC
00:54:56.259 --> 00:54:58.328
SUBSTANCES AND THEIR ACT
00:54:58.395 --> 00:54:59.562
ACTIONS WITH RESPECT TO
00:54:59.629 --> 00:55:00.864
CONTRACT FOR THE CLEAN
00:55:00.930 --> 00:55:03.333
ACTIVITIES CONTROLLING THE COST
00:55:03.400 --> 00:55:06.069
ESTIMATING HOW LONG IT WILL
00:55:06.136 --> 00:55:08.605
TAKE. SO IT'S BASICALLY IN THE
00:55:08.672 --> 00:55:10.740
SCOPE OF THE AUDIT. RIGHT IT
00:55:10.807 --> 00:55:13.576
JUST SEEMS LIKE TO GET THE FULL
00:55:13.643 --> 00:55:14.778
PICTURE THAT WOULD BE A HUMVEE
00:55:14.844 --> 00:55:17.480
ELEMENT AT. THIS STAGE OF THAT
00:55:17.547 --> 00:55:19.549
COULD BE A SUPPLEMENTAL WELL
00:55:19.616 --> 00:55:22.318
COMPONENT IF I MIGHT ADD I I'M
00:55:22.385 --> 00:55:22.952
SORRY PLEASE SENATOR WE ALL WE
00:55:23.019 --> 00:55:24.821
ALWAYS HAVE ANYTIME WE CONDUCT
00:55:24.888 --> 00:55:26.389
AN AUDIT WE ALWAYS HAVE AN
00:55:26.456 --> 00:55:27.691
OBJECTIVE IN HERE THAT IF THERE
00:55:27.757 --> 00:55:30.794
ARE THINGS THAT ARE RELEVANT TO
00:55:30.860 --> 00:55:31.394
THE SUBJECT MATTER. THE FACT
00:55:31.461 --> 00:55:32.796
YOU'RE BREAKING IT UP IT'S
00:55:32.862 --> 00:55:34.130
RELEVANT TO THE SUBJECT.
00:55:34.197 --> 00:55:35.932
SOMETHING WE COULD INCLUDE IN
00:55:35.999 --> 00:55:37.033
THE SKIN IT WOULDN'T BE A SCOPE
00:55:37.100 --> 00:55:38.068
MODIFICATION BECAUSE IT'S
00:55:38.134 --> 00:55:40.437
RELEVANT TO THE ISSUE SO IT IS
00:55:40.503 --> 00:55:42.038
SOMETHING THAT WE CAN CERTAINLY
00:55:42.105 --> 00:55:44.274
LOOK AT IF THE AUDITS PRICKED
00:55:44.340 --> 00:55:48.244
THANK YOU. SHE SO WITHIN. JACK
00:55:48.311 --> 00:55:49.579
DISMISSED IF YOU COMMENT ON
00:55:49.646 --> 00:55:51.081
THAT YEAH I WOULD INCUR APPS
00:55:51.147 --> 00:55:52.849
THAT ALL PART OF THE THAT THAT
00:55:52.916 --> 00:55:55.785
THE SEGMENT OF THE OF THE WORK
00:55:55.852 --> 00:55:57.520
IS BEING AUTUMN THAT WE-
00:55:57.587 --> 00:55:59.556
PROVIDING THE STATE COMPTROLLER.
00:55:59.622 --> 00:56:01.558
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S WITHIN
00:56:01.624 --> 00:56:02.926
THE VENUE BUT ABSOLUTELY THAT
00:56:02.992 --> 00:56:04.394
WE'RE DOING EVERYTHING POSSIBLE
00:56:04.461 --> 00:56:04.961
WITHIN THOSE PROCEDURES TO
00:56:05.028 --> 00:56:06.830
RECOVER FUNDS ABSOLUTELY
00:56:06.896 --> 00:56:08.231
CRITICAL IN A IN A NIGHT THANK
00:56:08.298 --> 00:56:10.033
YOU FOR BRINGING THAT UP YET.
00:56:10.100 --> 00:56:11.434
THANK YOU. I THANK YOU IN
00:56:11.501 --> 00:56:12.435
BEFORE WE MOVE TO THE NEXT
00:56:12.502 --> 00:56:14.137
QUESTION I WANT TO GO AHEAD
00:56:14.204 --> 00:56:14.938
SINCE WE HAVE ANOTHER MEMBER
00:56:15.004 --> 00:56:17.741
HERE. IS A QUICK TAKE A PAUSE
00:56:17.807 --> 00:56:18.808
HERE WE'RE GONNA GO AHEAD AND
00:56:18.875 --> 00:56:20.643
BRING UP THE SUSPENSION OF THE
00:56:20.710 --> 00:56:23.313
JOINT RULES. THIRTEEN AND
00:56:23.379 --> 00:56:25.215
FIFTEEN SO THAT WE CAN. THEN
00:56:25.281 --> 00:56:26.616
VOTE ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR
00:56:26.683 --> 00:56:27.684
WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE
00:56:27.751 --> 00:56:29.052
PROPOSED CONSENT CALENDAR WERE
00:56:29.119 --> 00:56:31.087
REMOVING ITEMS NUMBER FOR. AN
00:56:31.154 --> 00:56:33.923
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN- PLACE IN THE
00:56:33.990 --> 00:56:35.859
REGULAR. CALENDAR AGENDA WITH A
00:56:35.925 --> 00:56:38.228
GOOD CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
00:56:38.294 --> 00:56:46.069
MISTER SECRETARY. THIS ONE. THE
00:56:46.136 --> 00:56:48.238
IS TO WAIVE JOINT COMMITTEE
00:56:48.304 --> 00:56:50.006
RULES THIRTEEN AND FIFTEEN IN
00:56:50.073 --> 00:56:50.974
ORDER TO TAKE UP THE CONSENT
00:56:51.040 --> 00:56:55.812
CALENDAR BOERNER HORVATH. CHEN
00:56:55.879 --> 00:57:04.287
PATTERSON PROCESS I. WHAT.
00:57:04.354 --> 00:57:06.556
SENATOR HERTZBERG I CENTER
00:57:06.623 --> 00:57:08.558
HERTZBERG HIGH MORE LOCKED.
00:57:08.625 --> 00:57:14.631
WIENER. OKAY THAT MOTION
00:57:14.697 --> 00:57:16.466
CARRIES TO SPEND THE JOINT
00:57:16.533 --> 00:57:18.902
ROLES AND NOW WE WILL- TAKE A
00:57:18.968 --> 00:57:20.570
VOTE ON THE FOR THE CONSENT
00:57:20.637 --> 00:57:22.005
CALENDAR WITH THE EXCEPTIONS OF
00:57:22.071 --> 00:57:23.873
ITEM NUMBER FOUR TWENTY TWENTY
00:57:23.940 --> 00:57:24.941
DASH ONE THIRTEEN CITIES OF
00:57:25.008 --> 00:57:26.176
FUNDING TO PARK COMMERCE
00:57:26.242 --> 00:57:27.477
CONTRACTING PRACTICES CANNABIS
00:57:27.544 --> 00:57:29.646
LICENSING BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:57:29.712 --> 00:57:31.281
CRISTINA GARCIA AND ITEM
00:57:31.347 --> 00:57:33.016
NUMBERS AND TWENTY TWENTY THAT
00:57:33.082 --> 00:57:35.819
IT'LL OR CITY OF LINDSAY-
00:57:35.885 --> 00:57:37.053
REMOVING THEM FROM THE CAN
00:57:37.120 --> 00:57:40.190
CALENDAR- WITH A GO TO CALL THE
00:57:40.256 --> 00:57:44.060
ROLL. SECTION SO WE NEED AT.
00:57:44.127 --> 00:57:44.661
OKAY CAN HAVE A MOTION FOR THE
00:57:44.727 --> 00:57:45.829
CALENDAR SO MOVED BY MISTER
00:57:45.895 --> 00:57:47.931
BORCHERS SECOND BY MISS RUBIO
00:57:47.997 --> 00:57:51.067
MISS SECTOR CULTURAL. THE
00:57:51.134 --> 00:57:52.335
MOTION IS TO APPROVE THE
00:57:52.402 --> 00:57:54.971
CONSENT CALENDAR- CONSISTING OF
00:57:55.038 --> 00:57:57.373
AUTO REQUEST TWENTY TWENTY ONE
00:57:57.440 --> 00:57:59.642
OH THREE BY SENATOR BELL.
00:57:59.709 --> 00:58:00.243
TWENTY TWENTY ONE OH EIGHT BY
00:58:00.310 --> 00:58:03.513
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS TWENTY
00:58:03.580 --> 00:58:04.113
TWENTY ONE ELEVEN BY ASSEMBLY
00:58:04.180 --> 00:58:06.683
MEMBER RUBIO. TWENTY TWENTY
00:58:06.749 --> 00:58:10.920
EIGHT OH TO- CITY OF LIFE
00:58:10.987 --> 00:58:11.487
TWENTY TWENTY EIGHT OH THREE
00:58:11.554 --> 00:58:14.591
CITY OF EL SERENO. TWENTY
00:58:14.657 --> 00:58:15.158
TWENTY EIGHT OH SIX CITY OF
00:58:15.225 --> 00:58:17.293
WEST COVINA. ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:58:17.360 --> 00:58:19.863
SALAS AYE. SALAS HI
00:58:19.929 --> 00:58:25.768
BOERNER HORVATH. GEN PATTERSON
00:58:25.835 --> 00:58:27.971
PERSON I RUBIO. RUBIO AYE
00:58:28.037 --> 00:58:32.675
VOEPEL VOEPEL I WOULD. SENATOR
00:58:32.742 --> 00:58:37.914
ROTH CENTER ROTH AYE BARGES. OR
00:58:37.981 --> 00:58:40.717
JUST HI GONZALEZ GONZALEZ I
00:58:40.783 --> 00:58:44.187
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG HI MORNING
00:58:44.254 --> 00:58:50.727
MORNING HI MORLOCK. WIENER. A
00:58:50.793 --> 00:58:51.961
CONSENT CALENDARS APPROVAL HOLD
00:58:52.028 --> 00:58:53.096
THE ROLE OPEN FOR ADDITIONAL
00:58:53.162 --> 00:58:54.931
MEMBERS TO ADD ON- WITH THAT
00:58:54.998 --> 00:58:56.532
WILL GO TO RETURN BACK TO THE
00:58:56.599 --> 00:58:58.134
SANTIAGO IS ITEM I BELIEVE
00:58:58.201 --> 00:59:01.070
SENATOR GONZALEZ HAS QUESTION
00:59:01.137 --> 00:59:02.005
THEN MOVED TO CENTER ARTS FOR.
00:59:02.071 --> 00:59:03.373
I MORE OF JUST A COMMENT I JUST
00:59:03.439 --> 00:59:05.074
WANTED TO SAY THANK YOU BOTH
00:59:05.141 --> 00:59:06.009
FOR CONTINUING TO KEEP THE
00:59:06.075 --> 00:59:09.012
ISSUE ALIVE I KNOW- FURNACE IN
00:59:09.078 --> 00:59:10.546
MY BACKYARD AS WELL AND I'M
00:59:10.613 --> 00:59:13.149
NEWER TO THE ISSUE BUT- WITH
00:59:13.216 --> 00:59:14.751
ALL DUE. RESPECT THIS IS JUST
00:59:14.817 --> 00:59:16.152
IT'S GREAT THAT WE ARE
00:59:16.219 --> 00:59:18.888
CONTINUING THE DISCUSSIONS- I
00:59:18.955 --> 00:59:21.824
THINK THE ONLY. QUESTION I HAD
00:59:21.891 --> 00:59:24.494
WAS IT SAYS IT'S- THE TSC IS
00:59:24.560 --> 00:59:25.528
UNCERTAIN AS TO HOW MANY
00:59:25.595 --> 00:59:27.096
PARCELS WILL ULTIMATELY NEED TO
00:59:27.163 --> 00:59:28.264
BE CLEANED UP EVEN AS A
00:59:28.331 --> 00:59:29.565
LEGISLATOR I FEEL LIKE I CAN
00:59:29.632 --> 00:59:31.000
ANSWER THAT QUESTION BUT DO WE
00:59:31.067 --> 00:59:32.502
HAVE ANY GUESSTIMATES ON WHAT.
00:59:32.568 --> 00:59:34.137
PERCENTAGE IS. CLEANED UP
00:59:34.203 --> 00:59:37.674
ALREADY. YEAH SINCE THE CLEANUP
00:59:37.740 --> 00:59:39.542
PLAN WAS ISSUED IN TWENTY
00:59:39.609 --> 00:59:40.543
SEVENTEEN THE LATTER HALF OF
00:59:40.610 --> 00:59:42.145
TWENTY SEVENTEEN. WE CLING OF
00:59:42.211 --> 00:59:43.913
ABOUT THIRTEEN HUNDRED PARCELS.
00:59:43.980 --> 00:59:45.548
THAT BRINGS THE ENTIRE AMOUNT A
00:59:45.615 --> 00:59:47.550
NUMBER PARTIALS CLEANED UP TO
00:59:47.617 --> 00:59:49.152
OVER SIXTEEN HUNDRED AND FORTY.
00:59:49.218 --> 00:59:50.253
SO THAT'S PRETTY MUCH AN
00:59:50.320 --> 00:59:51.587
UNPRECEDENTED CLEAN UP IN THE
00:59:51.654 --> 00:59:52.455
HISTORY THE STATE IN TERMS
00:59:52.522 --> 00:59:54.190
RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES
00:59:54.257 --> 00:59:55.959
TECHNIQUES TO BE DONE AS WELL
00:59:56.025 --> 00:59:57.193
SO WHAT NEEDS TO BE SO THE
00:59:57.260 --> 00:59:58.127
LEGISLATURE WHEN THEY PROVIDED
00:59:58.194 --> 00:59:59.796
THE MONEY. SAID CLEAN UP
00:59:59.862 --> 01:00:00.763
ACCORDING TO THE THREAT
01:00:00.830 --> 01:00:02.298
REPRESENTED BY THE MATERIAL ON
01:00:02.365 --> 01:00:04.500
THE PARTIALS. AND THE POTENTIAL
01:00:04.567 --> 01:00:06.502
FOR ACTUALLY- THAT THAT HAS A
01:00:06.569 --> 01:00:08.204
SUBSTANCE THE LEAD IMPACTING
01:00:08.271 --> 01:00:10.640
HUMAN HEALTH. SO THERE'S NO SET
01:00:10.707 --> 01:00:12.742
NUMBER OF PARCELS. THAT IS
01:00:12.809 --> 01:00:15.244
ESTABLISHED IN LAW. WHAT WE
01:00:15.311 --> 01:00:17.347
THINK WE CAN DO THAT BASICALLY
01:00:17.413 --> 01:00:20.049
OUR ENGINEERS ESTIMATE SAYS.
01:00:20.116 --> 01:00:20.717
SEVENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS ON
01:00:20.783 --> 01:00:21.884
AVERAGE PER PARTIALS ABOUT HOW
01:00:21.951 --> 01:00:23.386
MUCH IT SHOULD COST WE'VE GOT
01:00:23.453 --> 01:00:25.421
ONE CONTRACTORS SIXTY THOUSAND
01:00:25.488 --> 01:00:26.055
ANOTHER CONTRACTOR OVER EIGHTY
01:00:26.122 --> 01:00:27.790
THOUSAND. SO WE WERE STARTING
01:00:27.857 --> 01:00:30.159
TO SHIFT MORE PROPERTIES TO THE
01:00:30.226 --> 01:00:32.428
LOWER COST ONE. IN AN EFFORT TO
01:00:32.495 --> 01:00:32.895
ACTUALLY CLEAN UP MORE
01:00:32.962 --> 01:00:36.165
PROPERTIES OVER TIME. WITH WE
01:00:36.232 --> 01:00:38.267
THINK WE CAN GET TO AROUND
01:00:38.334 --> 01:00:41.204
TWENTY SEVEN HUNDRED. BUT
01:00:41.270 --> 01:00:43.339
THAT'S GONNA VERY A LOT ON THE
01:00:43.406 --> 01:00:44.674
TECHNICAL COMPLEXITY OF ACTUAL
01:00:44.741 --> 01:00:46.376
CLEANING UP INDIVIDUAL PARCELS
01:00:46.442 --> 01:00:47.343
THE AMOUNT OF MATERIAL TAKEN
01:00:47.410 --> 01:00:49.746
OUT OF EACH PARCEL IT THE WE
01:00:49.812 --> 01:00:50.546
KIND OF LAID OUT IN IN THAT
01:00:50.613 --> 01:00:51.814
DOCUMENT FOR YOU. THERE'S A LOT
01:00:51.881 --> 01:00:52.915
OF FACTORS THAT GO INTO EACH
01:00:52.982 --> 01:00:54.617
INDIVIDUAL PARCEL ACTUALLY THE
01:00:54.684 --> 01:00:56.786
COST THAT IT TAKES TO CLEAN IT
01:00:56.853 --> 01:00:59.255
UP RIGHT. FOR OKAY RIGHT THANK
01:00:59.322 --> 01:01:00.757
YOU THANK YOU. SORRY JUST FOR
01:01:00.823 --> 01:01:02.458
PLEASE CLEAR FONDEST YEAH I'M
01:01:02.525 --> 01:01:05.261
SORRY IT IS JUST USE A TWENTY
01:01:05.328 --> 01:01:06.496
SEVEN HUNDRED IS YOUR GOAL. OR
01:01:06.562 --> 01:01:09.365
WEARABLES AS MEN PARTIAL PASTA
01:01:09.432 --> 01:01:10.099
THE MORE MONEY WE CAN SQUEEZE
01:01:10.166 --> 01:01:12.668
OUT OF EVERY DOLLAR WE'LL DO IT
01:01:12.735 --> 01:01:17.507
RIGHT BY. USE MENTIONED. TWENTY
01:01:17.573 --> 01:01:17.974
SEVEN HUNDRED CURRENT
01:01:18.041 --> 01:01:18.574
PROJECTIONS ARE. THANK YOU.
01:01:18.641 --> 01:01:20.910
THANK RIGHT WELL BETTER MOVED
01:01:20.977 --> 01:01:24.881
HIS HERTZBERG PLEASE. THE ON.
01:01:24.947 --> 01:01:26.649
WE DEBATED THIS MEASURE ON THE
01:01:26.716 --> 01:01:28.885
FLOOR A FEW YEARS AGO AND
01:01:28.951 --> 01:01:30.253
CENTER LENO WAS THE BUDGET
01:01:30.319 --> 01:01:32.922
CHAIR AT THE TIME- AND WE
01:01:32.989 --> 01:01:35.158
TALKED ABOUT THIS. YOU KNOW WE
01:01:35.224 --> 01:01:36.859
WERE FACED WITH A DILEMMA ON
01:01:36.926 --> 01:01:40.363
THE ONE HAND ON MISTER
01:01:40.430 --> 01:01:41.197
RESPONSIBILITY PRIVATE
01:01:41.264 --> 01:01:45.334
COMPANIES. START RESPONSIBILITY
01:01:45.401 --> 01:01:45.902
THESE COMPANIES POLLUTED AND
01:01:45.968 --> 01:01:47.103
THEY SHOULD PAY IT. THEY SHOULD
01:01:47.170 --> 01:01:49.272
PAY FOR. YOU HAVE A AS YOU IN
01:01:49.338 --> 01:01:51.374
APPOINTED A EXTRAORDINARY
01:01:51.441 --> 01:01:52.809
IMPACT HUMAN HEALTH SO WE IN
01:01:52.875 --> 01:01:55.044
GOVERNMENT- DID THE RIGHT THING
01:01:55.111 --> 01:01:56.813
AND WE STEPPED UP TO THE PLATE-
01:01:56.879 --> 01:01:58.414
IN ORDER TO DEAL WITH THE
01:01:58.481 --> 01:02:00.116
PEOPLE A COMMUNITY THAT WERE
01:02:00.183 --> 01:02:01.417
SEVERELY IMPACTED. WELL WE
01:02:01.484 --> 01:02:03.586
DIDN'T DO WHAT I WANT TO KNOW
01:02:03.653 --> 01:02:05.221
WHETHER YOU CAN AT LEAST HELP
01:02:05.288 --> 01:02:08.157
US WITH RESPECT TO THIS AUDIT
01:02:08.224 --> 01:02:08.724
THAT COULD BE IN THE PICTURE
01:02:08.791 --> 01:02:10.126
DYNAMIC. IS A TO HELP US
01:02:10.193 --> 01:02:12.195
RECOVER THE MONEY MISSION OF
01:02:12.261 --> 01:02:13.062
THE MESSAGE ASIANS WERE WE
01:02:13.129 --> 01:02:14.597
GOVERNMENTS WERE CHECKED. AS A
01:02:14.664 --> 01:02:15.631
LAWYER FOR FORTY ONE YEARS I
01:02:15.698 --> 01:02:17.600
KNOW HOW THIS GAME GETS PLAYED
01:02:17.667 --> 01:02:18.734
NOBODY'S GONNA WANT TO SETTLE
01:02:18.801 --> 01:02:20.269
COUNTIES ARE GOING TO SETTLE
01:02:20.336 --> 01:02:20.803
BECAUSE KNOWS NORDIC
01:02:20.870 --> 01:02:22.472
RESPONSIBILITY BECAUSE FOR SELL
01:02:22.538 --> 01:02:25.341
IT FOR LESS THE PEOPLE THAT ARE
01:02:25.408 --> 01:02:27.844
GONNA PAY THE LAWYERS ARE GOING
01:02:27.910 --> 01:02:28.845
TO BE RIGHT CHECKS. EVER GET
01:02:28.911 --> 01:02:30.646
GET PAID BACK REASONS MUCH
01:02:30.713 --> 01:02:32.582
MONEY IS WHICH MADE THIS A
01:02:32.648 --> 01:02:35.551
ISSUE IT HAD SIXTY PROVISIONS
01:02:35.618 --> 01:02:37.153
IN THE INTRO INDENTURE.
01:02:37.220 --> 01:02:39.455
REPAYMENT AND WE BASE MADE TO
01:02:39.522 --> 01:02:41.724
THE CAN I THINK IT WAY THAT I
01:02:41.791 --> 01:02:43.126
DON'T THINK WAS WAS MY- THE IT
01:02:43.192 --> 01:02:47.897
WILL TO REIMBURSE WAS RESPONSE
01:02:47.964 --> 01:02:49.499
BACK TO THE LOCAL ISSUES WERE
01:02:49.565 --> 01:02:52.168
THERE. WHAT WE'RE FACED TO SIT.
01:02:52.235 --> 01:02:57.006
SO MY QUESTION IS. REALLY NO
01:02:57.073 --> 01:02:58.908
WAS ANYTHING. YOU KNOW OF A
01:02:58.975 --> 01:03:00.343
NUMBER IS OUR LITIGATION WITH
01:03:00.409 --> 01:03:01.077
THIS TO FOLKS GOING AFTER. A
01:03:01.144 --> 01:03:01.978
KNOW THE- PEOPLE RISK. FOR THIS
01:03:02.044 --> 01:03:02.912
CONTENT. AND IF NOT OF THE
01:03:02.979 --> 01:03:03.479
THINGS THAT YOU CAN DO WITH
01:03:03.546 --> 01:03:04.680
WHICH- TO THE FOR. OF THIS ALL.
01:03:04.747 --> 01:03:06.315
THAT HELPS US. PUT OURSELVES IN
01:03:06.382 --> 01:03:07.850
A PROPER POSITION TO HELP US
01:03:07.917 --> 01:03:09.051
GET OUR MONEY BACK IT COUNTY
01:03:09.118 --> 01:03:10.720
GET ITS MONEY BACK. AND HOLD
01:03:10.786 --> 01:03:12.321
THE PEOPLE RESPONSIBLE.
01:03:12.388 --> 01:03:14.790
FINANCIALLY AS WE TOOK DI THE
01:03:14.857 --> 01:03:16.559
RIGHT THING TO TAKE CARE OF THE
01:03:16.626 --> 01:03:17.360
PEOPLE IN THE COMMUNITY ANY
01:03:17.426 --> 01:03:18.828
THOUGHTS IN THAT REGARD. WELL
01:03:18.895 --> 01:03:20.062
FIRST I WOULD DEFER TO THE
01:03:20.129 --> 01:03:21.330
DEPARTMENT BECAUSE A IT'S MY
01:03:21.397 --> 01:03:22.165
UNDERSTANDING APART WAS
01:03:22.231 --> 01:03:23.633
INDICATING THEY WERE WORK ARE
01:03:23.699 --> 01:03:25.001
WORKING WITH THE ATTORNEY
01:03:25.067 --> 01:03:26.235
GENERAL'S OFFICE WITH RESPECT.
01:03:26.302 --> 01:03:27.937
LITIGATE CAN SO THAT I WOULD I
01:03:28.004 --> 01:03:28.838
WOULD DEFER TO THEM. WE
01:03:28.905 --> 01:03:29.972
CONDUCTED AUDITS OF TOXIC
01:03:30.039 --> 01:03:31.374
SUBSTANCES IN THE PAST THIS
01:03:31.440 --> 01:03:32.675
DEPARTMENT AND LOOKING AT THEIR
01:03:32.742 --> 01:03:35.178
EFFORTS AS FAR AS COST RECOVERY
01:03:35.244 --> 01:03:36.913
AND- AND- IDENTIFYING. THE
01:03:36.979 --> 01:03:38.447
WRIST WELL PART IN GETTING.
01:03:38.514 --> 01:03:43.986
INTO TO. I PAY FOR THE TOXIC
01:03:44.053 --> 01:03:45.588
SUBSTANCE OR OR THE CAN IN A
01:03:45.655 --> 01:03:47.523
PARTICULAR. THE QUESTION
01:03:47.590 --> 01:03:48.891
SENATOR MINING ASKED WITH
01:03:48.958 --> 01:03:49.959
RESPECT TO COST RECOVERY I
01:03:50.026 --> 01:03:52.028
THINK AS WE LOOK AT THAT WILL
01:03:52.094 --> 01:03:54.163
LOOK AT THE EFFORTS THAT THE
01:03:54.230 --> 01:03:56.432
STATE HAS TAKEN TO ENSURE THAT
01:03:56.499 --> 01:03:58.301
ARE THERE CAPTURING THE AMOUNT
01:03:58.367 --> 01:04:00.036
OF MONEY THAT IS BEING EXPANDED
01:04:00.102 --> 01:04:02.471
CERTAINLY AND THEN WHAT EXPERTS
01:04:02.538 --> 01:04:04.674
THEY ARE TAKING TO TRY TO GET.
01:04:04.740 --> 01:04:06.409
EXCITED TO BE DEEMED AS THE
01:04:06.475 --> 01:04:08.010
RESPONSIBLE PARTY AND EXCITED
01:04:08.077 --> 01:04:10.947
TO BE OUR RISK OR FOR THE STATE
01:04:11.013 --> 01:04:13.849
BACK BUT BUT WE WOULD CERTAINLY
01:04:13.916 --> 01:04:15.551
DEFER TO OUR ATTORNEY GENERAL
01:04:15.618 --> 01:04:17.119
AND THE DEPARTMENT IS FAR GAUGE
01:04:17.186 --> 01:04:19.755
AND MAYBE BEFORE YOU AS I JUST
01:04:19.822 --> 01:04:21.457
FOLLOWING UP ON CENTER MONIES
01:04:21.524 --> 01:04:24.160
IN QUERY IS. CAN YOU ARE IN
01:04:24.227 --> 01:04:26.495
TUITION YOU CAN HELP NOT JUST
01:04:26.562 --> 01:04:28.130
GATHERING DATA OF WHAT YOU KNOW
01:04:28.197 --> 01:04:31.801
THE REIMBURSEMENT SHOULD BE BUT
01:04:31.867 --> 01:04:34.904
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF ATTORNEY
01:04:34.971 --> 01:04:36.472
GENERAL QUESTION CAN PASS THAT
01:04:36.539 --> 01:04:38.107
WOULD THEN IT HELP PROVE THE
01:04:38.174 --> 01:04:42.178
STATE CASE IN THE COUNT. WELL
01:04:42.245 --> 01:04:43.913
TO GET REMEMBER IN THE PRIVATE.
01:04:43.980 --> 01:04:45.081
NOT JUST A BASS LINE DATA BUT
01:04:45.147 --> 01:04:46.015
MADE IN COURT WITH THE LAWYERS
01:04:46.082 --> 01:04:47.216
YOUR YOUR HOME OR CAN BE QUITE
01:04:47.283 --> 01:04:48.584
VALUABLE IN HELPING THE
01:04:48.651 --> 01:04:50.052
GOVERNMENT GET ITS MONEY BACK
01:04:50.119 --> 01:04:52.555
AS I JUST WOULD. MAKE THAT
01:04:52.622 --> 01:04:53.155
SUGGESTION BECAUSE I CAN THINK
01:04:53.222 --> 01:04:54.523
IS REALLY MINING BUILDING I
01:04:54.590 --> 01:04:55.658
WOULD BECAUSE OUR MINING SAID
01:04:55.725 --> 01:04:58.261
BUT BUT I THINK THAT MIGHT BE
01:04:58.327 --> 01:04:59.795
VALUABLE FOR THEM HERE FOR THE-
01:04:59.862 --> 01:05:00.363
THAT WOULD BE TREMENDOUSLY.
01:05:00.429 --> 01:05:02.898
VALUABLE TREMENDOUSLY VITAL. IS
01:05:02.965 --> 01:05:03.633
THAT SOMETHING YOU CAN DO IF
01:05:03.699 --> 01:05:05.067
YOU COORDINATION CERTAINLY WE
01:05:05.134 --> 01:05:07.036
CAN CERTAINLY. HAVE
01:05:07.103 --> 01:05:08.104
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE ATTORNEY
01:05:08.170 --> 01:05:09.538
GENERAL'S OFFICE AND UNDERSTAND
01:05:09.605 --> 01:05:11.340
FROM THEIR PERSPECTIVE. THE
01:05:11.407 --> 01:05:12.642
TYPES OF THINGS THAT WE COULD
01:05:12.708 --> 01:05:14.377
CONDUCT IN THIS DURING THE- THE
01:05:14.443 --> 01:05:15.578
SCOPE OF THIS AUDIT THAT WOULD
01:05:15.645 --> 01:05:18.447
BE BENEFICIAL- BUT BEYOND THAT
01:05:18.514 --> 01:05:20.182
AS AS YOU KNOW WHEN WE CONDUCT
01:05:20.249 --> 01:05:20.650
OUR AUDIT WORK IT'S
01:05:20.716 --> 01:05:22.518
CONFIDENTIAL BUT WE CERTAINLY
01:05:22.585 --> 01:05:23.119
WILL ENGAGE WITH THE ATTORNEY
01:05:23.185 --> 01:05:25.388
GENERAL'S OFFICE. OUT TO SEE IF
01:05:25.454 --> 01:05:27.356
THERE ARE THINGS. WITHIN THE
01:05:27.423 --> 01:05:28.891
SCOPE OF WHAT WE'VE BEEN ASKED
01:05:28.958 --> 01:05:30.793
TO DO THAT MAY BE BENEFICIAL TO
01:05:30.860 --> 01:05:31.727
THEM AND PARTLY. STATE A
01:05:31.794 --> 01:05:34.530
CALIFORNIA. THANKS OF AMMON.
01:05:34.597 --> 01:05:35.564
THIS BY JUST THINK IT'S- REALLY
01:05:35.631 --> 01:05:37.366
IMPORTANT TO DO YOU KNOW WE-
01:05:37.433 --> 01:05:40.002
DID THE RIGHT THING BUT- WE GOT
01:05:40.069 --> 01:05:41.837
AT THE SECOND HALF OF THAT
01:05:41.904 --> 01:05:44.674
EQUATION IS WE GOT GET THE-
01:05:44.740 --> 01:05:46.742
TAXPAYER. REMEMBER BY THE-
01:05:46.809 --> 01:05:49.645
THOUGHT OF. THINK OF. WHAT THE
01:05:49.712 --> 01:05:52.048
SCOPE. THANK SAYING SHOT INTO
01:05:52.114 --> 01:05:53.683
SHE WE WILLING TO DO THAT AS
01:05:53.749 --> 01:05:55.885
WELL. REALLY THE ASSEMBLY
01:05:55.951 --> 01:05:57.453
MEMBERS WILL IN. BUT WHAT I
01:05:57.520 --> 01:06:00.323
WOULD WELL I MISTER HER IF YOU
01:06:00.389 --> 01:06:01.557
YOU IN THE CAN. SENT OUT LAW
01:06:01.624 --> 01:06:02.758
ABOUT LAW MESSAGE THAT THAT
01:06:02.825 --> 01:06:03.359
THAT THAT SORT OF SCHOOL OF
01:06:03.426 --> 01:06:05.027
WORK WHAT HOW AND I WE WOULD
01:06:05.094 --> 01:06:05.895
INCUR I THINK WE BE ON THE SAME
01:06:05.961 --> 01:06:09.131
PAGE CRIME. OKAY THIS TIME A
01:06:09.198 --> 01:06:09.732
MASK THERE'S ADDITIONAL. FROM
01:06:09.799 --> 01:06:14.036
ON THE DíAS HEARING AND SEEING
01:06:14.103 --> 01:06:15.504
NONE LET'S GO TO MOVE TO PUBLIC
01:06:15.571 --> 01:06:17.340
COMMENT THERE'S PUBLIC COM. AND
01:06:17.406 --> 01:06:23.346
I. OKAY HEARING IN SAYING NON
01:06:23.412 --> 01:06:24.313
LET ME GO AHEAD AND TURN IT
01:06:24.380 --> 01:06:26.015
BACK TO SOMEONE OVER SANTIAGO
01:06:26.082 --> 01:06:27.817
IF YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE YET NINE
01:06:27.883 --> 01:06:29.285
I'LL BE BRIEF SO RESPECTFULLY
01:06:29.352 --> 01:06:30.820
WOULD JUST ASK THAT THIS
01:06:30.886 --> 01:06:32.188
COMMITTEE VOTED TO PROCEED WITH
01:06:32.254 --> 01:06:34.890
THIS AUDIT. AND SAID COMMENTS
01:06:34.957 --> 01:06:36.759
REGARDING REIMBURSEMENT BE- BE
01:06:36.826 --> 01:06:37.760
INCLUDED IF THE COMMITTEE
01:06:37.827 --> 01:06:39.929
WISHES TO DO SO RESPECTFULLY
01:06:39.995 --> 01:06:41.063
ASK FOR NIGHT OF. ALL RIGHT
01:06:41.130 --> 01:06:42.631
THANK RESPONSE IAGO I DO SEE
01:06:42.698 --> 01:06:44.567
THIS AS A YOU KNOW. THE SCOPE
01:06:44.633 --> 01:06:46.268
OF WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS A LOT
01:06:46.335 --> 01:06:47.703
DIFFERENT THAN WHAT THE TSC
01:06:47.770 --> 01:06:49.872
ALREADY DID. APPRECIATE YES HE
01:06:49.939 --> 01:06:52.508
ACTUALLY- LOOKING INTO THIS IN
01:06:52.575 --> 01:06:53.976
A VERY SERIOUS MATTER AND-
01:06:54.043 --> 01:06:54.910
OBVIOUSLY THE YOU'VE HEARD
01:06:54.977 --> 01:06:58.347
FROM. MEMBERS OF THIS DíAS-
01:06:58.414 --> 01:06:59.648
HOW MUCH IMPORTANCE WE PLACE ON
01:06:59.715 --> 01:07:01.117
MAKING SURE THAT EXCITE IS
01:07:01.183 --> 01:07:02.017
CLEANED UP THANK YOU SUPERVISOR
01:07:02.084 --> 01:07:03.486
FOR BEING HEREAS WELL. THIS
01:07:03.552 --> 01:07:06.389
TIME BUT ASK THERE'S A MOTION
01:07:06.455 --> 01:07:08.958
FOR MISTER SUCH. I MOVE BY. OUR
01:07:09.024 --> 01:07:11.026
SECULAR BY. SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:07:11.093 --> 01:07:15.531
MISTER SECTOR. THE MOST IS TO
01:07:15.598 --> 01:07:17.166
APPROVE WATER NUMBER TWENTY
01:07:17.233 --> 01:07:18.501
TWENTY DASH ONE OH SEVEN
01:07:18.567 --> 01:07:19.769
DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCES
01:07:19.835 --> 01:07:21.837
CONTROL LEAD CONTAMINATION
01:07:21.904 --> 01:07:22.805
CLEAN UP BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:07:22.872 --> 01:07:25.374
SANTIAGO THAT'S ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:07:25.441 --> 01:07:27.376
SALAS BY SALAS HI
01:07:27.443 --> 01:07:32.481
BOERNER HORVATH. GEN PATTERSON
01:07:32.548 --> 01:07:35.484
PATTERSON I RUBIO RUBIO I
01:07:35.551 --> 01:07:40.189
VOEPEL VOEPEL I WOULD. WOULD I
01:07:40.256 --> 01:07:43.459
CENTER RAFI. SENATOR ROTH AYE
01:07:43.526 --> 01:07:47.663
FORGES OR AYE GONZALEZ GONZALEZ
01:07:47.730 --> 01:07:50.099
HI HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE
01:07:50.166 --> 01:07:53.169
MONNING. MONNING AYE MOORLACH.
01:07:53.235 --> 01:07:59.842
WIENER IT. OUR OUR OKAY THAT
01:07:59.909 --> 01:08:01.377
AUDIT SIR PROVE WILL HOLD THE
01:08:01.444 --> 01:08:03.846
ROLE OPEN FOR ADDITIONAL
01:08:03.913 --> 01:08:17.860
MEMBERS THAT MISTER THANK YOU.
01:08:17.927 --> 01:08:19.161
OKAY WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO THE
01:08:19.228 --> 01:08:20.095
NEXT AGENDA ITEM I KNOW OF I
01:08:20.162 --> 01:08:21.530
SAW ASSEMBLY MEMBER RIVAS
01:08:21.597 --> 01:08:25.968
EARLIER SEE STILL IN THE ROOM.
01:08:26.035 --> 01:08:30.072
OKAY. THIS TIME LET'S GO AHEAD
01:08:30.139 --> 01:08:31.540
AND MOVE FORWARD WITH CRISTINA
01:08:31.607 --> 01:08:36.011
GARCIA. THIS IS THE ITEM TWENTY
01:08:36.078 --> 01:08:37.313
TWENTY DASH ONE ONE THREE
01:08:37.379 --> 01:08:38.614
CITIES OF HUNTINGTON PARK AND
01:08:38.681 --> 01:08:39.882
COMMERCE CONTRACT PRACTICES IN
01:08:39.949 --> 01:08:41.884
CANNABIS LICENSING THANK YOU
01:08:41.951 --> 01:08:44.086
SEVERAL WOMEN FOR JOINING US
01:08:44.153 --> 01:08:44.687
AND WHEN YOU'RE READY TO BEGIN
01:08:44.753 --> 01:08:46.589
PLEASE BEGIN. THANK YOU OUR PRE
01:08:46.655 --> 01:08:49.859
PAID AT. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
01:08:49.925 --> 01:08:52.228
MEMBERS- I'M HERE TO YOUR
01:08:52.294 --> 01:08:53.496
QUESTION AUDIT OF CONTRACTING
01:08:53.562 --> 01:08:54.897
PRACTICES AND CANNABIS LICENSE
01:08:54.964 --> 01:08:56.365
PROCEDURES FOR THE CITIES OF
01:08:56.432 --> 01:08:58.834
COMMERCE AND HIDING THEM PARK.
01:08:58.901 --> 01:09:00.536
I BEGAN MY CAREER FIGHTING FOR
01:09:00.603 --> 01:09:01.904
TEN BEEN SEEING GOVERNMENT AND
01:09:01.971 --> 01:09:04.607
HAVE CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR THAT
01:09:04.673 --> 01:09:06.775
FROM MY TIME HERE IN SACRAMENTO.
01:09:06.842 --> 01:09:07.543
PROVIDING SOMETHING CHINA
01:09:07.610 --> 01:09:09.812
CONTRACTING IN CANNABIS IS
01:09:09.879 --> 01:09:11.247
LICENSABLE LONG WAY- TO SHOW
01:09:11.313 --> 01:09:13.249
THE PUBLIC WHAT WHAT'S GOING
01:09:13.315 --> 01:09:15.484
ON. WITH THE ADVENT OF CANNABIS
01:09:15.551 --> 01:09:17.820
LICENSES ANY TO THE CITIES AS A
01:09:17.887 --> 01:09:18.487
PART OF THAT REVIEW THEIR
01:09:18.554 --> 01:09:21.457
PRACTICES. TO ENSURE OUR THAT
01:09:21.524 --> 01:09:23.459
AS AS FOR STARTING THIS PROCESS
01:09:23.526 --> 01:09:25.561
THAT WE'RE USING IN BEST
01:09:25.628 --> 01:09:26.662
PRACTICES ALONG THE WAY. THE
01:09:26.729 --> 01:09:28.230
CITY OF COMMERCE ALREADY HAS
01:09:28.297 --> 01:09:29.398
TWENTY EIGHT CANNABIS LICENSES
01:09:29.465 --> 01:09:30.499
AND THE PROCESS WITH AN
01:09:30.566 --> 01:09:32.568
ADDITIONAL TANK CURRENTLY BEING
01:09:32.635 --> 01:09:35.371
CONSIDERED- RIGHT NEXT DOOR
01:09:35.437 --> 01:09:36.939
MONTEBELLO WE HAVE TWENTY ONE
01:09:37.006 --> 01:09:38.440
THAT ARE BEING CONSIDERED. SO
01:09:38.507 --> 01:09:39.909
WE'RE LOOKING AT OVER SIXTY
01:09:39.975 --> 01:09:43.479
PERMITS AND ELEVEN SQUARE MILES.
01:09:43.546 --> 01:09:44.513
THE CITY OF COMMERCE HAS
01:09:44.580 --> 01:09:46.181
APPROXIMATELY THIRTEEN THOUSAND
01:09:46.248 --> 01:09:47.983
RESIDENTS IN THE ABOUT THE TEN
01:09:48.050 --> 01:09:49.418
ADDITIONAL LICENSES WE'RE GONNA
01:09:49.485 --> 01:09:51.120
BE LOOKING AT ABOUT A LICENSE
01:09:51.186 --> 01:09:52.721
FOR EACH THREE HUNDRED AND
01:09:52.788 --> 01:09:54.924
THIRTY PEOPLE. IN THE CITY.
01:09:54.990 --> 01:09:57.593
OUGHT TO GIVE YOU PERSPECTIVE
01:09:57.660 --> 01:10:02.431
AND THE- CITY OF LA- THEY HAVE
01:10:02.498 --> 01:10:05.267
A LICENSE FOR ABOUT. EACH
01:10:05.334 --> 01:10:05.901
TWENTY ONE THOUSAND PEOPLE. ALL
01:10:05.968 --> 01:10:13.075
RIGHT NOW. HI HI. BUT IN A
01:10:13.142 --> 01:10:20.983
DIFFERENT. PLEASE PROCEED MY IS
01:10:21.050 --> 01:10:22.151
SLOW AT WHAT'S IN THE SOUTH THE
01:10:22.217 --> 01:10:24.253
AS A- I AND SAID THAT SOUTH YOU
01:10:24.320 --> 01:10:25.554
FOR MORE THAN ONE CITY TO BE
01:10:25.621 --> 01:10:26.355
LOOKED THAT THE HUNTINGTON PARK
01:10:26.422 --> 01:10:28.190
IS ALSO EMBARKED ON GETTING
01:10:28.257 --> 01:10:32.127
LICENSES AND HAVE AN COUPLE OF
01:10:32.194 --> 01:10:34.463
LICENSES OUT IN THEIR CITY. LET
01:10:34.530 --> 01:10:36.165
ME ADD THAT NEVER WRONG PAYING
01:10:36.231 --> 01:10:37.032
TO ADD MORE THAN SYING TO
01:10:37.099 --> 01:10:38.634
GOVERNMENT BUT GIVEN THE RAPID
01:10:38.701 --> 01:10:40.235
RATE AT WHICH IS LICENSES ARE
01:10:40.302 --> 01:10:41.604
EXPANDING AND THE SOUTHEAST I
01:10:41.670 --> 01:10:43.005
STRONGLY BELIEVE THAT THIS
01:10:43.072 --> 01:10:44.840
AUDIT IS NEEDED NOW. AND NOT
01:10:44.907 --> 01:10:48.243
LATER. I AND SO I RESPECTFULLY
01:10:48.310 --> 01:10:50.279
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE I'M HERE
01:10:50.346 --> 01:10:52.781
FOR ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE.
01:10:52.848 --> 01:10:55.217
THANK YOU FOR YOUR OPENING
01:10:55.284 --> 01:10:55.751
STATEMENT AB AT A MONITOR
01:10:55.818 --> 01:10:57.453
PLEASE. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
01:10:57.519 --> 01:10:58.554
AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER GARCIA
01:10:58.621 --> 01:10:59.888
INDICATED THIS WOULD BE AN
01:10:59.955 --> 01:11:01.223
AUDIT OF THE TO CITY CITY OF
01:11:01.290 --> 01:11:02.992
HUNTINGTON PARK AND ALSO CITY
01:11:03.058 --> 01:11:04.259
OF COMMERCE. LOOKING AT
01:11:04.326 --> 01:11:05.761
CONTRACTING THIS IS LOOKING
01:11:05.828 --> 01:11:07.162
PERMITTING PRACTICES WITH
01:11:07.229 --> 01:11:09.798
RESPECT TO CANNABIS- FIRST
01:11:09.865 --> 01:11:10.899
OBJECTIVE CONTRACTING.
01:11:10.966 --> 01:11:12.401
PROCESSES EVALUATE THEIR
01:11:12.468 --> 01:11:14.303
PRACTICES MAKING SURE THAT
01:11:14.370 --> 01:11:16.338
THEY'VE IDENTIFIED ARE
01:11:16.405 --> 01:11:18.340
APPROPRIATE STEPS THAT COMPLY
01:11:18.407 --> 01:11:20.576
WITH STATE LAWS RAGS IT CETERA-
01:11:20.643 --> 01:11:23.045
AND ALSO MENTION OF ANY. TYPE
01:11:23.112 --> 01:11:24.446
OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST. IS TO
01:11:24.513 --> 01:11:25.881
COMPARE THEIR CONTRACTING
01:11:25.948 --> 01:11:28.484
PRACTICES TO PRACTICES THAT THE
01:11:28.550 --> 01:11:29.952
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AS BOTH
01:11:30.019 --> 01:11:32.154
ENDS CON THING MAN. AND STATE
01:11:32.221 --> 01:11:33.088
IS A STRAIGHT MAN THOSE ARE
01:11:33.155 --> 01:11:35.157
SENSUAL PRACTICE. IN ADDITION
01:11:35.224 --> 01:11:36.759
SHE IS ASKING US TO LOOK AT
01:11:36.825 --> 01:11:38.260
CITY COUNCIL OF THE RESPECTIVE
01:11:38.327 --> 01:11:40.195
CITY COUNCIL. AND THEIR OVER.
01:11:40.262 --> 01:11:43.365
OVER THERE STE WHO ARE WORKING
01:11:43.432 --> 01:11:47.603
THESE CONTACTS. ALSO THING ON
01:11:47.670 --> 01:11:51.440
THE PERMITTED PROCESS MANY
01:11:51.507 --> 01:11:57.846
CONTRACT WHAT OF ALL. I BEING
01:11:57.913 --> 01:12:07.690
CUT LAST LOOK AT US. ARMS LAID
01:12:07.756 --> 01:12:09.358
OUT IN THE CONTRACT AND DO ARE
01:12:09.425 --> 01:12:11.126
THEY ENSURING THAT THEY'RE
01:12:11.193 --> 01:12:13.262
AVOIDING IN ANY TYPE OF A
01:12:13.328 --> 01:12:14.963
POTENTIAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
01:12:15.030 --> 01:12:16.598
AND THEN WITH THE- THE-
01:12:16.665 --> 01:12:18.400
PERMITTING SIDE. LOOKING AT
01:12:18.467 --> 01:12:19.568
WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE
01:12:19.635 --> 01:12:21.070
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR
01:12:21.136 --> 01:12:23.005
SEEKING AWARDING. AND CERTAINLY
01:12:23.072 --> 01:12:24.840
MONITORING CANNABIS BUSINESS
01:12:24.907 --> 01:12:27.509
PERMITS- AND MAKING SURE THAT
01:12:27.576 --> 01:12:29.078
THOSE COMPLY NOT ONLY WITH
01:12:29.144 --> 01:12:30.479
STATE BUT ANY LOCAL DANCE LOCAL
01:12:30.546 --> 01:12:32.948
A LOT REGULATIONS. ARE ALSO
01:12:33.015 --> 01:12:34.817
ASKING US RESPECTED PERMITTING
01:12:34.883 --> 01:12:37.252
ARE THOSE PROCESSES AND ALLOW.
01:12:37.319 --> 01:12:38.420
WITH THE BEST PRACTICES THAT
01:12:38.487 --> 01:12:40.489
ARE. MAY LOOK AT OTHER STATES
01:12:40.556 --> 01:12:41.790
ARE MAY LOOK AT WHAT OTHER
01:12:41.857 --> 01:12:43.726
CITIES AND CAL. HAVE ON AND
01:12:43.792 --> 01:12:47.062
THEN SHE'S A- IN OUR HOW CLEAR
01:12:47.129 --> 01:12:50.065
ENTRANCE. THE PUMP AS FOR. THE
01:12:50.132 --> 01:12:50.933
PROCESS THAT THE RESPECTIVE ARE
01:12:50.999 --> 01:12:53.802
YOU. AND THEY FOLLOWING THOSE
01:12:53.869 --> 01:12:58.807
PROCESSES AND THEN FINALLY. IN
01:12:58.874 --> 01:13:00.409
SING SOME THE- VISION MAKING
01:13:00.476 --> 01:13:01.009
THAT'S BEEN DONE BY THE WRIST
01:13:01.076 --> 01:13:02.044
CITY. ARE THEY FOLLOWING THEIR
01:13:02.111 --> 01:13:03.912
PERMITTING PROCEDURE. THEY
01:13:03.979 --> 01:13:05.781
PROVIDING AGAIN AN APPROPRIATE
01:13:05.848 --> 01:13:07.449
LEVEL OF TRANSPARENCY AND THEN
01:13:07.516 --> 01:13:09.585
ARE THEY PROVIDING SUFFICIENT
01:13:09.651 --> 01:13:10.619
OVERSIGHT TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:13:10.686 --> 01:13:11.854
THOSE BUSINESSES ARE ACTUALLY
01:13:11.920 --> 01:13:13.756
APPLYING WITH LAWS AND
01:13:13.822 --> 01:13:15.290
REGULATIONS WITH RESPECT TO
01:13:15.357 --> 01:13:16.492
PERMITS. ON THE SIDE IT'S
01:13:16.558 --> 01:13:19.161
BUDGET ABOUT TWENTY EIGHT
01:13:19.228 --> 01:13:19.728
HUNDRED HOURS TAKE US ABOUT
01:13:19.795 --> 01:13:20.796
SEVEN MONTHS. THANK YOU MISTER
01:13:20.863 --> 01:13:22.998
CHAIR THANK YOU MADAM WATER AT
01:13:23.065 --> 01:13:24.466
THIS TIME IS GOING TO MOVE TO
01:13:24.533 --> 01:13:26.068
THE AFFECTED AGENCIES IF WE
01:13:26.135 --> 01:13:27.536
HAVE ANY THIS TIME ONE BY
01:13:27.603 --> 01:13:28.203
REPRESENTATIVES FROMTHE
01:13:28.270 --> 01:13:30.773
AFFECTED AGENCIES TO THE TABLE
01:13:30.839 --> 01:13:31.840
PLEASE BEGIN BY STATING YOUR
01:13:31.907 --> 01:13:33.876
NAME AND WHICH AGENCY OR CITY
01:13:33.942 --> 01:13:52.528
YEAR WITH.
01:13:54.997 --> 01:13:55.297
PLEASE MORE MISTER
01:13:55.364 --> 01:13:56.064
CHAIRMAN OF MY NAME IS ARE
01:13:56.131 --> 01:13:58.300
ALLOWED WORSE CLASS. I AM THE
01:13:58.367 --> 01:13:59.034
CITY OF FOR THIS OF HUNTINGTON
01:13:59.101 --> 01:14:01.069
PARK. OF PERSON THIS MORNING
01:14:01.136 --> 01:14:04.606
ABOUT THE MAJORS CELLS. PLEASE
01:14:04.673 --> 01:14:06.141
MORE CHAIR MEMBERS THE
01:14:06.208 --> 01:14:06.675
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS NORMA
01:14:06.742 --> 01:14:07.876
COMPLY TO I'M IN THE ESSENCE OF
01:14:07.943 --> 01:14:10.012
YOUR TO FOR THIS COMMERCE.
01:14:10.078 --> 01:14:14.383
THANK YOU HEY. GOOD MORNING A
01:14:14.449 --> 01:14:15.117
GOOD MORNING TERM VICE CHAIR
01:14:15.184 --> 01:14:15.818
AND MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE MY
01:14:15.884 --> 01:14:17.152
NAME A KIND OF A CITY MAN WITH
01:14:17.219 --> 01:14:19.922
THIS IF I NEED TO PARK. THANK
01:14:19.988 --> 01:14:21.256
YOU. SEC PLEASE IF YOU HAVE
01:14:21.323 --> 01:14:22.558
STATEMENT. THANKS VERY MUCH FOR
01:14:22.624 --> 01:14:26.328
CHAIRMAN. OF ANY. UP I'M SORRY
01:14:26.395 --> 01:14:27.262
WILL BE STE ON BEHALF OF CITY
01:14:27.329 --> 01:14:29.598
HUNTINGTON WHERE MISS COOPER.
01:14:29.665 --> 01:14:30.399
WILL BE SPEAKING OF THIS OF
01:14:30.465 --> 01:14:32.267
KARMA IN AS MUCH AS WE ARE OUR
01:14:32.334 --> 01:14:33.735
FIRM BOTH CA. THE ISSUES FACING
01:14:33.802 --> 01:14:36.405
THE TOOK ME OR SOME WITH THE-
01:14:36.471 --> 01:14:38.574
UP. THE PURPOSE OF OUR OF OUR
01:14:38.640 --> 01:14:40.375
PARENTS THIS MORNING IS TWO
01:14:40.442 --> 01:14:43.679
FOLD OF FIRST- TO INITIALLY
01:14:43.745 --> 01:14:45.180
CITY COMMITTEES TO DIAL OF THE
01:14:45.247 --> 01:14:46.982
RESPECT WE SEE THE COMMITTEES
01:14:47.049 --> 01:14:48.650
DIAL ASSEMBLY MEMBER GARCIA'S
01:14:48.717 --> 01:14:50.652
REQUEST. OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE
01:14:50.719 --> 01:14:52.087
AT THE VERY LEAST YOU DELAY THE
01:14:52.154 --> 01:14:53.689
CONSIDERATION OF THE AUDIT
01:14:53.755 --> 01:14:57.092
REQUEST AND ALLOW THE ASSEMBLY
01:14:57.159 --> 01:14:57.726
MEMBER HER STAFF. AND THE
01:14:57.793 --> 01:15:00.095
AUDITOR STAFF WITH YOUR CITY
01:15:00.162 --> 01:15:02.197
STAFF TO DRAW THE QUESTIONS ARE
01:15:02.264 --> 01:15:03.899
CONCERNED SET FORTH IN THE
01:15:03.966 --> 01:15:05.334
LETTER DATED BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
01:15:05.400 --> 01:15:06.435
GARCIA DATE. JANUARY TWENTY
01:15:06.501 --> 01:15:10.305
FIRST. TWENTY TWENTY. IT'S
01:15:10.372 --> 01:15:10.906
INTERESTING NOTE THAT LETTER
01:15:10.973 --> 01:15:12.708
WAS NOT COPY THE CITY OF PARK
01:15:12.774 --> 01:15:13.508
ALSO NOT COPY TO THE CITY OF
01:15:13.575 --> 01:15:15.010
COMMERCE. SO WE HAD
01:15:15.077 --> 01:15:16.345
APPROXIMATELY ONE WEEK IN WHICH
01:15:16.411 --> 01:15:17.913
TO PREPARE TO ADDRESS THIS
01:15:17.980 --> 01:15:19.081
COMMITTEE AND TO TRY AND
01:15:19.147 --> 01:15:21.850
ADDRESS THE- ISSUES OF BRITISH
01:15:21.917 --> 01:15:24.419
REPLACING THE COMMITTEE. BOB NO
01:15:24.486 --> 01:15:25.287
I KNOW MEMBERS OF THIS
01:15:25.354 --> 01:15:26.822
COMMITTEE I BACK ALSO NOTICE
01:15:26.889 --> 01:15:28.423
SOME OF MEMBER GARCIA AND IT
01:15:28.490 --> 01:15:30.993
STRUCK ME THAT. AN APPROACH
01:15:31.059 --> 01:15:32.961
THAT IS MUCH BETTER TO-
01:15:33.028 --> 01:15:35.464
CONSIDER IS THAT OF INSTEAD OF
01:15:35.530 --> 01:15:36.698
GOING. DIRECTLY TO THE
01:15:36.765 --> 01:15:38.000
COMMITTEE IS TO TRY TO MEET
01:15:38.066 --> 01:15:39.501
WITH YOUR RESPECTIVE
01:15:39.568 --> 01:15:40.435
COMMUNITIES THAT YOU REPRESENT
01:15:40.502 --> 01:15:42.037
IN THIS CASE THE CITY OF
01:15:42.104 --> 01:15:43.171
HUNTINGTON PARK IS OUTSIDE THE
01:15:43.238 --> 01:15:45.540
JURISDICTION. OF ASSEMBLY
01:15:45.607 --> 01:15:47.442
MEMBER GARCIA BUT IT'S STILL A
01:15:47.509 --> 01:15:49.411
THE CITY OF HUNTINGTON PARK IS
01:15:49.478 --> 01:15:50.312
STILL OPEN AND WILLING TO MEET
01:15:50.379 --> 01:15:52.114
WITH HER AND HER STAFF IN THE
01:15:52.180 --> 01:15:54.116
AUDITOR'S STAFF. IN ORDER TO
01:15:54.182 --> 01:15:56.285
TRY TO DRAW MINIS IN ORDER TO
01:15:56.351 --> 01:15:57.719
SAVE TAXPAYER DOLLARS. THE COST
01:15:57.786 --> 01:16:01.590
OF SUCH AN ODD IT WOULD BE. IS
01:16:01.657 --> 01:16:02.457
INDICATED IN OVER THREE
01:16:02.524 --> 01:16:04.092
THOUSAND DOLLARS WELL A I THINK
01:16:04.159 --> 01:16:05.794
FIFTY YEAH THAT ARE BEING. I'M
01:16:05.861 --> 01:16:08.430
SURE QUESTION- ARE BEING SOUGHT
01:16:08.497 --> 01:16:10.999
COULD BE TEST UP. MUCH MORE
01:16:11.066 --> 01:16:13.235
FIRMLY IN TO GET TO THE SAME
01:16:13.302 --> 01:16:17.205
CONCLUSION. IN ACTING THE
01:16:17.272 --> 01:16:19.875
SEVEN. TO OF TEMPLE BURKE. MET
01:16:19.942 --> 01:16:22.210
BUT HE AUDITORS ARE THEY WERE
01:16:22.277 --> 01:16:24.212
INITIALLY THE CITY OF PARKING
01:16:24.279 --> 01:16:26.181
RISK PROFILE WE MET WITH THE
01:16:26.248 --> 01:16:27.883
AUDITOR'S OFFICE AND AFTER THAT
01:16:27.950 --> 01:16:29.151
PROCESS STUDENT COMPLETED UP
01:16:29.217 --> 01:16:33.588
THERE DID NOT MOVE FORWARD ART.
01:16:33.655 --> 01:16:35.057
WITH RESPECT TO THE K. ISSUES
01:16:35.123 --> 01:16:37.259
THE CITY FUNDING TO IS ONLY A
01:16:37.326 --> 01:16:39.094
THREE CANNABIS LICENSE LICENSES
01:16:39.161 --> 01:16:40.929
OVER THE PAST THREE YEARS- IN
01:16:40.996 --> 01:16:43.265
FACT THAT MATTER WAS CHALLENGED
01:16:43.332 --> 01:16:45.167
IN FEDERAL COURT. THE óRDENES
01:16:45.233 --> 01:16:47.202
OF THIS WAS HAVE UPHELD BY THE
01:16:47.269 --> 01:16:51.340
FEDERAL JUDGE AND- THE STANCE
01:16:51.406 --> 01:16:55.177
FOR CONFIRMED BY THE COURTS OF
01:16:55.243 --> 01:16:58.447
BY THE COURTS. UP WITH RESPECT
01:16:58.513 --> 01:16:59.414
TO CONTRACT BRIEFLY OF THE
01:16:59.481 --> 01:17:01.083
CITY'S CONTRA NOT RUBBER STAMP
01:17:01.149 --> 01:17:02.050
THEY'RE NOT PUTTING CONSENT
01:17:02.117 --> 01:17:04.820
AGENDA THEY'RE REVIEWED ONE BY
01:17:04.886 --> 01:17:06.088
ONE BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND I
01:17:06.154 --> 01:17:08.156
CAN ASSURE THE COMMITTEE. AND
01:17:08.223 --> 01:17:10.559
ALL INTERESTED PARTIES THAT THE
01:17:10.625 --> 01:17:12.094
PROPER STEPS ARE BEING TAKEN TO
01:17:12.160 --> 01:17:15.097
ENSURE THE INTEGRITY. AND THE
01:17:15.163 --> 01:17:16.298
PARENTS OF APPROVING THOSE
01:17:16.365 --> 01:17:19.167
CONTRACTS. UP WITH ASKING
01:17:19.234 --> 01:17:21.837
CLOSING FOR. CAN PARK THE
01:17:21.903 --> 01:17:26.174
NEGATIVE. IMPACT OF COST TIME
01:17:26.241 --> 01:17:26.708
EXPENSE TO THREE DAUGHTERS
01:17:26.775 --> 01:17:28.577
OFFICE OF THE CITY STAFF AND
01:17:28.643 --> 01:17:30.078
THE BUSINESS ATTRACTION AND
01:17:30.145 --> 01:17:32.781
RETENTION ISSUES ARE LOSE LOSE
01:17:32.848 --> 01:17:35.550
LOSE AS OPPOSED TO WHEN. WE ASK
01:17:35.617 --> 01:17:36.418
THAT YOU RESPECT ME TO THE
01:17:36.485 --> 01:17:38.453
COMMITTEE TO DENY THE WEST OR
01:17:38.520 --> 01:17:39.955
EAST TO DISPLAY THIS
01:17:40.022 --> 01:17:41.156
CONSIDERATION TO ALLOW CITY
01:17:41.223 --> 01:17:42.290
STUFFED WITH THESE REMEMBERS
01:17:42.357 --> 01:17:45.193
OFFICE WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:17:45.260 --> 01:17:45.761
TIME. THANK YOU. ADDITIONAL
01:17:45.827 --> 01:17:48.697
TESTIMONY FOR CITY COVERS YEAH
01:17:48.764 --> 01:17:50.232
THANK YOU SO MUCH- I WOULD LIKE
01:17:50.298 --> 01:17:52.334
TO START OFF WITH- CONTRACTING
01:17:52.401 --> 01:17:53.335
PROCEDURES AND JUST TO
01:17:53.402 --> 01:17:54.836
HIGHLIGHT SOME POINTS THAT ARE
01:17:54.903 --> 01:17:56.304
SPECIFICALLY FACT THAT ARE VERY
01:17:56.371 --> 01:17:59.908
RELEVENT- AS TO WHY WE THINK A
01:17:59.975 --> 01:18:00.675
NOT IT IS NOT APPROPRIATE IN
01:18:00.742 --> 01:18:02.511
THIS CASE. THE CITY OF COMMERCE
01:18:02.577 --> 01:18:03.845
HAS BEEN IN A FIGHT BY THE
01:18:03.912 --> 01:18:06.748
AUDITOR AS A- HAS NOT BEEN
01:18:06.815 --> 01:18:08.216
IDENTIFIED BY THE STATE AUDITOR
01:18:08.283 --> 01:18:12.421
AS A HIGH RISK MUNICIPALITY- ON
01:18:12.487 --> 01:18:13.789
THE CONTRARY. I'M GLAD THAT
01:18:13.855 --> 01:18:16.091
DEPUTY ARE OUR CHILDREN.
01:18:16.158 --> 01:18:18.460
REFERENCE TO THESE FACTS UP AT
01:18:18.527 --> 01:18:21.430
THIS HAS BEEN DESIGNATED AS A
01:18:21.496 --> 01:18:23.498
LOW OVERALL. AND RANKS THREE
01:18:23.565 --> 01:18:27.269
HUNDRED SO FOURTH. FOUR HUNDRED
01:18:27.335 --> 01:18:27.869
SEVENTY ONE CITIES RACKED WITH
01:18:27.936 --> 01:18:29.371
THAT THE ARREST CITIES WE HAVE
01:18:29.438 --> 01:18:31.973
THE LOWEST NUMBER OF FINE.
01:18:32.040 --> 01:18:34.176
FURTHER THE CITY APPROACHES
01:18:34.242 --> 01:18:36.044
AUDITED EVERY OTHER CITY AND
01:18:36.111 --> 01:18:38.346
HAS RECENTLY RECEIVED MARKS.
01:18:38.413 --> 01:18:41.283
AUDITS WITH A QUALIFY CLEAN UP
01:18:41.349 --> 01:18:44.786
THIS HAS. BEEN RECOGNIZE AS
01:18:44.853 --> 01:18:51.460
YEAR'S OVER FIND IT'S. THIS IS
01:18:51.526 --> 01:18:53.395
THE ASIA PACIFIC BUT SHE- FOR
01:18:53.462 --> 01:18:55.030
ACCESS TO FIND REPORTING. HI
01:18:55.097 --> 01:18:56.665
THIS FOLLOWS. PROCUREMENT
01:18:56.731 --> 01:18:58.100
POLICIES AND HAS NOT HAD ANY
01:18:58.166 --> 01:19:01.369
REAL ARE COME OF AND BAD ABBE.
01:19:01.436 --> 01:19:03.138
SINCE THE CITY'S CAN LAW
01:19:03.205 --> 01:19:05.173
PROGRAM AND A DO TO MAKE
01:19:05.240 --> 01:19:06.808
CORRECT. I CONCERNING ASSEMBLY
01:19:06.875 --> 01:19:08.777
GARCIA- I MENTION AS TO HOW
01:19:08.844 --> 01:19:11.046
MANY A LICENSES THERE HAD BEEN
01:19:11.113 --> 01:19:12.214
TWENTY NINE LICENSES SAYS THAT
01:19:12.280 --> 01:19:14.349
HAVE BEEN APPROVED AND THAT IS
01:19:14.416 --> 01:19:16.651
THE- THERE IS THAT THE
01:19:16.718 --> 01:19:18.153
APPLICATION PROCESS HAS
01:19:18.220 --> 01:19:20.255
CONCLUDED IN THERE IS NO. A
01:19:20.322 --> 01:19:21.556
NEAR FUTURE PLANS TO OPEN THE
01:19:21.623 --> 01:19:24.693
APPLICATION PROCESS- WE WOULD
01:19:24.759 --> 01:19:26.595
LIKE TO BRING TO LIGHT TO THE
01:19:26.661 --> 01:19:28.296
COMMITTEE THAT THERE IS ACTIVE
01:19:28.363 --> 01:19:30.298
PENDING LITIGATION AND THE LA
01:19:30.365 --> 01:19:32.033
SUPERIOR COURT. ARE CHALLENGING
01:19:32.100 --> 01:19:33.401
SOME OF THE CITY'S CAN A
01:19:33.468 --> 01:19:34.870
COMMERCIAL CANNABIS PERMITTING
01:19:34.936 --> 01:19:37.372
PROGRAM- WE BELIEVE THAT IF
01:19:37.439 --> 01:19:39.975
THERE'S WOULD BE AN AUDIT THAT
01:19:40.041 --> 01:19:41.510
IT COULD POTENTIALLY COMPROMISE
01:19:41.576 --> 01:19:43.912
THIS IS A LEGAL DEFENSE-
01:19:43.979 --> 01:19:45.981
FURTHER AID I NECESSARILY MAKE
01:19:46.047 --> 01:19:49.050
CUT- AND THIS UNNECESSARY CAST
01:19:49.117 --> 01:19:51.853
A NEGATIVE CLOUD- THAT THERE'S
01:19:51.920 --> 01:19:53.355
SOME SUGGESTION OF WRONGDOING
01:19:53.421 --> 01:19:55.056
BUT THERE HAS BEEN NO EVIDENCE
01:19:55.123 --> 01:19:56.191
TO SHOW. AND EVEN THOUGH WE
01:19:56.258 --> 01:19:57.325
FEEL CONFIDENT THAT WE WILL BE
01:19:57.392 --> 01:20:01.329
SUCCESSFUL IN THE LITIGATION-
01:20:01.396 --> 01:20:02.631
SHOULD THAT THAT CASE GO TO
01:20:02.697 --> 01:20:06.635
CHURCH TRIAL. YOU WILL THAT
01:20:06.701 --> 01:20:18.213
THIS. BUT GIVE I. I'M UP. TO I
01:20:18.280 --> 01:20:18.813
THINK THAT TRANSPARENCY IS OF
01:20:18.880 --> 01:20:20.148
THE CALL THAT WERE MADE AT CITY
01:20:20.215 --> 01:20:21.049
OF COMMERCE PAINS STAKE IN MATT
01:20:21.116 --> 01:20:23.218
MATT TO A VERY PROGRAM THE
01:20:23.285 --> 01:20:24.953
CITIES OR ALONE IS A FOR TWO
01:20:25.020 --> 01:20:27.088
PAGE OR NAY I'M NOT ONLY DID WE
01:20:27.155 --> 01:20:28.790
IMPLEMENT ALL OF THIS LICENSE
01:20:28.857 --> 01:20:31.393
RICK. WHICH BY LAW AND THAT THE
01:20:31.459 --> 01:20:33.061
OUR MINIMUM STANDARDS BUT WE
01:20:33.128 --> 01:20:35.397
WENT AHEAD AND MADE ADDITIONAL
01:20:35.463 --> 01:20:38.066
MORE REQUIREMENTS FROM THE
01:20:38.133 --> 01:20:39.201
APPLICANTS. ALTHOUGH OUR
01:20:39.267 --> 01:20:40.869
APPLICATION PROCESS OUR OUR
01:20:40.936 --> 01:20:43.104
ACTUAL APPLICATION PACKET WITH
01:20:43.171 --> 01:20:44.706
A TWENTY SIX PAGE APPLICATION
01:20:44.773 --> 01:20:47.108
PACKET FROM THE INCEPTION AND
01:20:47.175 --> 01:20:49.077
IN THE SUMMER OF TWO THOUSAND
01:20:49.144 --> 01:20:49.744
EIGHT WHEN THE CITY STARTED
01:20:49.811 --> 01:20:52.047
THIS PROGRAM WE DESIGNATED A
01:20:52.113 --> 01:20:54.216
WEBSITE. AND EVERY ACTION THAT
01:20:54.282 --> 01:20:55.483
EITHER THE PLANNING COMMISSION
01:20:55.550 --> 01:20:56.952
WAS TAKEN ANY ACTION THAT THE
01:20:57.018 --> 01:20:58.486
CITY COUNCIL ACTION WAS TAKEN
01:20:58.553 --> 01:21:00.188
NOT ONLY WAS IT UNDER A PUBLIC
01:21:00.255 --> 01:21:01.856
HEARING WHERE WE DID THE PRIOR
01:21:01.923 --> 01:21:03.792
NOTICING SO THAT EVERYBODY FROM
01:21:03.858 --> 01:21:05.760
THE PUBLIC HAD THE OPPORTUNITY.
01:21:05.827 --> 01:21:07.329
BUT EVERY ACTION THAT IS TAKEN
01:21:07.395 --> 01:21:09.764
AS POSTED ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE
01:21:09.831 --> 01:21:10.999
IF YOU PRINT THE CITY'S WEBSITE
01:21:11.066 --> 01:21:12.400
NOW JUST DESIGNATED ON CANNABIS
01:21:12.467 --> 01:21:14.703
FACTS IT'S ABOUT A TWENTY SIX
01:21:14.769 --> 01:21:18.540
PAGE DOCUMENT- HAVE ARE TO THE
01:21:18.607 --> 01:21:20.242
ORDINANCE TO THE APPLICATION
01:21:20.308 --> 01:21:25.614
ALL OF THE INFORMATION. WAS
01:21:25.680 --> 01:21:27.716
THAT'S A AND MEANS. ON THE AS
01:21:27.782 --> 01:21:32.053
WELL. I'M AT AND I IN HE DID I
01:21:32.120 --> 01:21:33.255
THE CITY OF REQUIRES IT
01:21:33.321 --> 01:21:34.723
AGREEMENT FROM THE CAN OP.
01:21:34.789 --> 01:21:36.891
EVERY ALL BUILDING FOR PER
01:21:36.958 --> 01:21:39.561
EVERY ALL THAT THE MEET ALL
01:21:39.628 --> 01:21:41.863
STATE REQUIREMENTS AND A
01:21:41.930 --> 01:21:43.999
BUSINESS LICENSE AND ONLY THEN
01:21:44.065 --> 01:21:45.734
WILL THE CITY ISSUE A
01:21:45.800 --> 01:21:48.303
COMMERCIAL CANNABIS PERMIT-
01:21:48.370 --> 01:21:51.673
THIS THIS PROCESS STARTED IN
01:21:51.740 --> 01:21:52.240
TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN OF THE
01:21:52.307 --> 01:21:55.510
SUMMER WERE NOW IN EARLY TWO
01:21:55.577 --> 01:21:56.077
THOUSAND NINETEEN OUT OF THE
01:21:56.144 --> 01:21:57.579
TWENTY NINE OPERATORS ONLY
01:21:57.646 --> 01:21:58.680
THREE APPLICANTS ARE ONLY
01:21:58.747 --> 01:22:01.683
OPERATING SO TO ME IT JUST
01:22:01.750 --> 01:22:02.817
SHOWS THAT IT IS A VERY
01:22:02.884 --> 01:22:04.919
COMPREHENSIVE LONG. AS TO BASED
01:22:04.986 --> 01:22:07.722
UP START THAT PROCESS AND THE
01:22:07.789 --> 01:22:09.591
TO ECHO OF THE COMMENTS MADE BY
01:22:09.658 --> 01:22:12.861
MR GLASSMAN WE TO WE WELCOME
01:22:12.927 --> 01:22:14.462
THE OPPORTUNITY TO MEET WITH
01:22:14.529 --> 01:22:16.264
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GARCIA AND HER
01:22:16.331 --> 01:22:20.268
STAFF FOR HAPPY TO GO OVER ANY
01:22:20.335 --> 01:22:22.137
OF THE INCREASE IS CONCERNS
01:22:22.203 --> 01:22:25.540
THAT SHE ASKED. WE JUST MIGHT
01:22:25.607 --> 01:22:26.941
HAVE THE UPPER. SKIP PROSSER
01:22:27.008 --> 01:22:29.878
AND COME TO AND TO PUT HAVE
01:22:29.944 --> 01:22:31.146
ABOUT AND THIS REQUIRE. THAT
01:22:31.212 --> 01:22:32.580
WOULD BE UNFORTUNATE OKAY THEY
01:22:32.647 --> 01:22:35.150
YOU. AT THIS TIME OF THE
01:22:35.216 --> 01:22:36.885
NOTICEABLE COMMENTED WE GOT
01:22:36.951 --> 01:22:38.353
BOTH CITIES I THINK WE'RE GOOD
01:22:38.420 --> 01:22:39.921
THIS TIME I'M RETURNING BACK TO
01:22:39.988 --> 01:22:41.723
THE DíAS ASK FOR- QUESTIONS
01:22:41.790 --> 01:22:43.425
FROM MEMBERS OF THE DICE BUT
01:22:43.491 --> 01:22:45.493
LET ME BEGIN JUST BY ASKING YOU
01:22:45.560 --> 01:22:47.729
TO THE CITIES. HAS THERE BEEN A
01:22:47.796 --> 01:22:48.430
BECAUSE YOU KNOW WE TALKED
01:22:48.496 --> 01:22:50.198
ABOUT THE AUDITS AND YOU
01:22:50.265 --> 01:22:50.832
MENTIONED THE HIGH RISK GOT ITS
01:22:50.899 --> 01:22:53.501
BUT CAN I ASK WAS RECIPROCALLY
01:22:53.568 --> 01:22:56.104
HAS EITHER THE OTHER. EVER DONE
01:22:56.171 --> 01:22:56.838
AUDIT LOOKING AT JUST THE
01:22:56.905 --> 01:23:01.076
CONTRACTING OR THE LICENSING OF
01:23:01.142 --> 01:23:04.012
CANNABIS AND WITHIN THE CITY'S.
01:23:04.079 --> 01:23:06.014
MISTER CHAIRMAN WITH RESPECT TO
01:23:06.081 --> 01:23:07.749
HUNTINGTON PARK UP AS I
01:23:07.816 --> 01:23:08.516
INDICATED IN TWO THOUSAND
01:23:08.583 --> 01:23:10.685
SEVENTEEN- WE MET WITH
01:23:10.752 --> 01:23:12.020
REPRESENTATIVES FROM THE CITY
01:23:12.087 --> 01:23:13.788
FROM THE STATE AUDITOR'S OFFICE
01:23:13.855 --> 01:23:15.256
TO REVIEW THE SIMILAR
01:23:15.323 --> 01:23:17.258
QUESTIONS- EXCLUDING CANNABIS
01:23:17.325 --> 01:23:18.860
ISSUES. A SIMILAR QUESTIONS
01:23:18.927 --> 01:23:21.563
WITH RESPECT TO THE OF
01:23:21.629 --> 01:23:22.097
MANAGEMENT OF CONTRACTING
01:23:22.163 --> 01:23:24.165
WITHIN THE CITY. ARE AFTER
01:23:24.232 --> 01:23:25.533
CAREFUL REVIEW BY THE STATE
01:23:25.600 --> 01:23:27.469
AUDITOR BACK IN TWENTY
01:23:27.535 --> 01:23:29.237
SEVENTEEN IT WAS BE ELECTED NOT
01:23:29.304 --> 01:23:31.072
TO MOVE FOR BY THE BY THE STATE
01:23:31.139 --> 01:23:34.709
AUDITOR'S OFFICE. TO TAKE ANY
01:23:34.776 --> 01:23:36.411
STEPS FOR THE TWO OF A FORMAL
01:23:36.478 --> 01:23:38.213
AUDIT. OF I GUESS ANOTHER WAY
01:23:38.279 --> 01:23:39.881
OF RESPONDING MISTER CHAIRMAN
01:23:39.948 --> 01:23:41.649
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE IS. UP
01:23:41.716 --> 01:23:43.251
EVERY COUNCIL MEETING THOSE
01:23:43.318 --> 01:23:44.819
ISSUES ARE ADDRESSED- THEY ARE
01:23:44.886 --> 01:23:48.089
EXAMINED BOTH BY MR REYES AND
01:23:48.156 --> 01:23:49.891
HIS STAFF AND ALSO BY THE CITY
01:23:49.958 --> 01:23:51.526
COUNCIL AND AS I INDICATED.
01:23:51.593 --> 01:23:53.161
THEY ARE NOT PLACED ON CONSENT
01:23:53.228 --> 01:23:55.830
THE HANDLED ITEM BY ITEM ON THE
01:23:55.897 --> 01:23:58.299
CITY COUNCIL CALENDAR ARE NEVER
01:23:58.366 --> 01:24:00.235
CAME TO ME. THANK YOU. I CAN
01:24:00.301 --> 01:24:02.303
CAN. HI AND ON MY BE TO THE
01:24:02.370 --> 01:24:04.372
HIGH RISK PART. OF ACTUALLY
01:24:04.439 --> 01:24:09.177
HAVE. WELL LET ME. RIGHT WILL
01:24:09.244 --> 01:24:10.478
TURN IT TO THE ASSEMBLY WELL
01:24:10.545 --> 01:24:12.280
LET ME START WITH QUESTIONS AND
01:24:12.347 --> 01:24:13.648
I'M SURE IT'LL COME UP AND
01:24:13.715 --> 01:24:15.750
QUESTIONS AS WELL- BUT
01:24:15.817 --> 01:24:17.886
LISTENING TO SET HER OFF THANK
01:24:17.952 --> 01:24:19.621
YOU MISTER CHAIR YOU KNOW THE
01:24:19.687 --> 01:24:20.855
FIRST NOTE YOU KNOW THERE
01:24:20.922 --> 01:24:21.956
APPEAR TO BE SOME PROCESS
01:24:22.023 --> 01:24:23.391
ISSUES WITH RESPECT TO THIS
01:24:23.458 --> 01:24:27.495
AUDIT IN TERMS OF NOTIFICATION
01:24:27.562 --> 01:24:29.030
TO SO MY COLLEAGUES AT LEAST.
01:24:29.097 --> 01:24:30.799
ONE OF WHOM WHO SITS ON THIS
01:24:30.865 --> 01:24:31.933
COMMITTEE WHO REPRESENTS THE
01:24:32.000 --> 01:24:33.234
CITY HERE IN TERMS OF
01:24:33.301 --> 01:24:35.303
NOTIFICATION OF THE YACHT IT.
01:24:35.370 --> 01:24:37.605
WILL HAVE TO DEAL WITH THAT.
01:24:37.672 --> 01:24:39.340
SOMEHOW SOME TIME IN ANOTHER
01:24:39.407 --> 01:24:43.411
WAY BUT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT
01:24:43.478 --> 01:24:45.980
NOTIFICATION TO THE ROLE
01:24:46.047 --> 01:24:48.149
RESPONDING CITIES- SIR DID I
01:24:48.216 --> 01:24:49.350
UNDERSTAND YOU TO SAY THAT YOU
01:24:49.417 --> 01:24:50.652
ONLY HAD ONE WEEK NOTICE OF
01:24:50.718 --> 01:24:54.689
THIS AUDIT. QUESTION MR MR
01:24:54.756 --> 01:24:55.190
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF THE
01:24:55.256 --> 01:24:56.624
COMMITTEE AND SENATOR THE
01:24:56.691 --> 01:24:58.460
ANSWER TO THAT IS YES- WE WERE
01:24:58.526 --> 01:25:00.061
NOT COPIED ON THE ORIGINAL
01:25:00.128 --> 01:25:01.362
LETTER SO THEY WON'T LET ME
01:25:01.429 --> 01:25:04.165
FOLLOW WITH THAT THEN SO I'M
01:25:04.232 --> 01:25:07.535
CONCERNED ABOUT THAT WE DON'T I
01:25:07.602 --> 01:25:08.136
DON'T LIKE TO DO BUSINESS THAT
01:25:08.203 --> 01:25:11.306
WAY. ARE THOSE OF THE OUTCOME.
01:25:11.372 --> 01:25:14.175
SO WHAT WOULD ADDITIONAL TIME
01:25:14.242 --> 01:25:16.377
DO FOR YOU AS A CITY IN TERMS
01:25:16.444 --> 01:25:17.979
OF BEING ABLE TO RESPOND TO
01:25:18.046 --> 01:25:19.481
THIS AUDIT REQUEST BEFORE THIS
01:25:19.547 --> 01:25:21.416
COMMITTEE. THIS IS YOUR
01:25:21.483 --> 01:25:23.618
OPPORTUNITY TO TELL US WHY YOU
01:25:23.685 --> 01:25:26.020
NEED MORE TIME. YES MISTER
01:25:26.087 --> 01:25:28.122
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. IT
01:25:28.189 --> 01:25:29.824
WOULD GIVE EACH CITY THE
01:25:29.891 --> 01:25:30.358
OPPORTUNITY TO GATHER THE
01:25:30.425 --> 01:25:34.696
REQUISITE- DOCUMENTS ORDINANCES
01:25:34.762 --> 01:25:37.866
AGENDAS OF. THE VERY OTHER
01:25:37.932 --> 01:25:40.502
ELEMENTS THIS APPROVAL PROCESS
01:25:40.568 --> 01:25:41.636
AND PRESENT TO THE COMMITTEE
01:25:41.703 --> 01:25:44.339
AND THEN- AND TO STATE AUDITOR
01:25:44.405 --> 01:25:46.241
INTO THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN ALSO.
01:25:46.307 --> 01:25:48.643
THE A COMPREHENSIVE-
01:25:48.710 --> 01:25:50.812
UNDERSTANDING OF THE STEPS THAT
01:25:50.879 --> 01:25:53.181
THE CITY'S TAKE IN ADDRESSING
01:25:53.248 --> 01:25:54.148
THESE ISSUES THAT ARE BEFORE
01:25:54.215 --> 01:25:57.519
YOU- AND WE BELIEVE THAT THE
01:25:57.585 --> 01:25:59.220
ADDITIONAL TIME WOULD ALLOW
01:25:59.287 --> 01:26:01.789
THIS COMMITTEE TO BE. BETTER
01:26:01.856 --> 01:26:04.526
INFORMED ON EXACTLY WHAT- WHAT
01:26:04.592 --> 01:26:06.794
STEPS CITIES DO TAKE IN ORDER
01:26:06.861 --> 01:26:09.898
TO MEET THE QUESTIONS AT HAND.
01:26:09.964 --> 01:26:11.599
SO WE WOULD RESPECTFULLY
01:26:11.666 --> 01:26:13.234
REQUEST A CONTINUANCE OF THE
01:26:13.301 --> 01:26:15.570
POSTPONEMENT AND WE BELIEVE WE
01:26:15.637 --> 01:26:17.005
CAN EACH CITY CAN MAKE A
01:26:17.071 --> 01:26:19.741
COMPELLING A STATEMENT AS TO
01:26:19.807 --> 01:26:21.342
THE FACT THAT BOTH CITIES ARE
01:26:21.409 --> 01:26:22.644
IN FULL COMPLIANCE WITH STATE
01:26:22.710 --> 01:26:25.013
LAW WITH AUDITING PROCEDURES
01:26:25.079 --> 01:26:26.848
AND WITH THE WHAT IS THE GOAL
01:26:26.915 --> 01:26:28.449
AND OBJECTIVE IS THE- OF THIS
01:26:28.516 --> 01:26:30.718
COMMITTEE. SO I GUESS MY NEXT
01:26:30.785 --> 01:26:32.120
QUESTION IS TO THE OTHER
01:26:32.186 --> 01:26:32.954
PROPONENT GIVEN THE FACT THAT
01:26:33.021 --> 01:26:36.491
THIS. JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
01:26:36.558 --> 01:26:38.459
COMMITTEE MEETS ON A REGULAR
01:26:38.526 --> 01:26:40.562
BASIS DURING THE COURSE OF THE-
01:26:40.628 --> 01:26:42.564
OF THE YEAR AND WILL DO SO THIS
01:26:42.630 --> 01:26:44.566
YEAR IS THERE ANY REASON TO.
01:26:44.632 --> 01:26:49.904
FOR US TO. MAKE A DECISION ON
01:26:49.971 --> 01:26:50.872
THIS PARTICULAR AUDIT ON THIS
01:26:50.939 --> 01:26:52.473
PARTICULAR DAY AS OPPOSED TO
01:26:52.540 --> 01:26:54.642
GIVING THE CITY'S ADDITIONAL
01:26:54.709 --> 01:26:56.544
TIME TO RESPOND TO THE OTHER
01:26:56.611 --> 01:26:58.413
REQUEST AND TO GIVE US AN
01:26:58.479 --> 01:27:00.381
OPPORTUNITY TO CONSIDER
01:27:00.448 --> 01:27:01.349
WHATEVER THEY PRESENT I MEAN
01:27:01.416 --> 01:27:02.984
I'M ASSUMING. YOU KNOW MORE
01:27:03.051 --> 01:27:04.686
ABOUT THE REQUEST AND I DO YOU
01:27:04.752 --> 01:27:06.087
KNOW MORE ABOUT THE SITUATION
01:27:06.154 --> 01:27:08.523
IN THE CITIES AND I DO. YOU'VE
01:27:08.590 --> 01:27:10.058
JUST HEARD THE RATIONALE FOR
01:27:10.124 --> 01:27:11.759
WANTING MORE TIME MAYBE THAT
01:27:11.826 --> 01:27:13.461
HAS VALIDITY MAYBE IT DOESN'T
01:27:13.528 --> 01:27:15.897
BUT- I GUESS I THINK MY
01:27:15.964 --> 01:27:17.665
QUESTION THANK YOU SENATOR OFF
01:27:17.732 --> 01:27:20.735
YES- SELECT TWO ITEMS- TALKING
01:27:20.802 --> 01:27:23.638
ABOUT BOTH CITIES OFFENSE. THE%
01:27:23.705 --> 01:27:26.708
HIGH RISK DESIGNATION OR LACK
01:27:26.774 --> 01:27:28.610
THERE OFF AND IN PART BECAUSE
01:27:28.676 --> 01:27:30.211
OF ITALY MENTIONED THE WORK
01:27:30.278 --> 01:27:31.746
WHEN YOU IDENTIFY POTENTIAL IN
01:27:31.813 --> 01:27:33.414
THE MET WITH THE AUDITOR THE
01:27:33.481 --> 01:27:35.216
QUESTION I'M ASKING ARE NOT
01:27:35.283 --> 01:27:37.719
RELATED TO THE HIGHER RISK. A
01:27:37.785 --> 01:27:40.054
DESTINATION WITH THE AUDITOR
01:27:40.121 --> 01:27:40.888
CAN EXPLAIN THAT A LITTLE BIT
01:27:40.955 --> 01:27:42.557
BETTER ON TO DEADLINE A
01:27:42.624 --> 01:27:46.761
CLARIFICATION. WELL MY QUESTION
01:27:46.828 --> 01:27:47.762
HAS A HOLD ON IT SO I WILL WILL
01:27:47.829 --> 01:27:48.363
ANSWER YOUR QUESTION WHICH IS
01:27:48.429 --> 01:27:49.998
WHY WITH FAMILY LATER NOT IS
01:27:50.064 --> 01:27:52.200
YOUR PART. BUT I WANTED TO TAKE
01:27:52.266 --> 01:27:53.835
OPPORTUNITY CLARIFY THAT PIECE
01:27:53.901 --> 01:27:55.503
OF THAT'S OKAY WITH YOU WELL
01:27:55.570 --> 01:27:56.571
THAT'S FINE I JUST WANNA MAKE
01:27:56.638 --> 01:27:57.872
SURE SOMEBODY. YEAH I'M A
01:27:57.939 --> 01:27:59.807
CUSTOM EVERY NOW AND THEN I
01:27:59.874 --> 01:28:00.642
WILL ANSWER IT WHEN MY OTHER
01:28:00.708 --> 01:28:02.844
CAREER I HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO
01:28:02.910 --> 01:28:05.613
SIT AT THE DíAS AND- GO IN A
01:28:05.680 --> 01:28:06.781
DIFFERENT SET OF CLOTHES AND-
01:28:06.848 --> 01:28:07.749
AND SOMEBODY'S THEY NEEDED
01:28:07.815 --> 01:28:09.817
ADDITIONAL TOP MY LISTEN TO THE
01:28:09.884 --> 01:28:10.985
RECORD. BEEN DECIDED WHETHER
01:28:11.052 --> 01:28:12.520
THE ADDITIONAL TIME REQUEST FOR
01:28:12.587 --> 01:28:14.122
ALL OF THE ORIGINAL THIS WAS
01:28:14.188 --> 01:28:16.057
REASONABLE AND SECOND WHETHER
01:28:16.124 --> 01:28:18.426
THE ADDITIONAL TIME REQUEST WAS
01:28:18.493 --> 01:28:20.128
REASONABLE ON IT WHETHER IT WAS
01:28:20.194 --> 01:28:20.895
GOING TO LEAD O A MORE
01:28:20.962 --> 01:28:23.264
PRODUCTIVE. AND I'M DECISION
01:28:23.331 --> 01:28:25.767
AND SO SOME NEEDS TO. THE LAST
01:28:25.833 --> 01:28:28.036
ACTUALLY. BUT HONESTLY IN A
01:28:28.102 --> 01:28:30.204
QUEST SO WILL HAVE ANSWER
01:28:30.271 --> 01:28:32.206
SECOND I BE ONE NO PROBLEM. SO
01:28:32.273 --> 01:28:38.346
WE HAVE HAD THE SHORT. SEC IS
01:28:38.413 --> 01:28:38.913
ONE. THE PART FOR THAT THERE
01:28:38.980 --> 01:28:40.248
PROCESS CANNABIS. EIGHTEEN IS A
01:28:40.314 --> 01:28:41.416
COMMERCE STARTED THEIR- ON
01:28:41.482 --> 01:28:42.784
CANNABIS. NOW WE HAVE THE CITY
01:28:42.850 --> 01:28:45.286
HUNTINGTON PARK WHEN NEXT.
01:28:45.353 --> 01:28:46.421
MONTEBELLO STARTING THEIR PA.
01:28:46.487 --> 01:28:47.255
WITHIN A RELEASE. WINDOW TIME
01:28:47.321 --> 01:28:48.122
WE'VE HAD. THIS LARGE. OF
01:28:48.189 --> 01:28:51.059
CANNABIS IN THE COMMUNITY. I AM
01:28:51.125 --> 01:28:53.161
FOR LEGALIZING REGULATING- AND
01:28:53.227 --> 01:28:54.062
FOR THESE BUSINESSES FINING
01:28:54.128 --> 01:28:56.164
HOMES- THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND
01:28:56.230 --> 01:28:57.131
THAT INCLUDES YOU KNOW MY
01:28:57.198 --> 01:28:59.400
BACKYARD. ON MAY BE CLEAR THAT.
01:28:59.467 --> 01:29:00.868
I THINK AT THAT RATE AT WHICH
01:29:00.935 --> 01:29:02.837
THE GROWTH IS HAPPENING. I WANT
01:29:02.904 --> 01:29:04.272
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ASK THE
01:29:04.338 --> 01:29:05.707
QUESTION ARE WE USING DESPERATE
01:29:05.773 --> 01:29:06.874
BEST PRACTICES AS THIS IS
01:29:06.941 --> 01:29:08.443
GROWING. AND IF WE ARE. THEN
01:29:08.509 --> 01:29:09.877
GREAT LET ME CONGRATULATE YOU
01:29:09.944 --> 01:29:11.779
UNLESS MAKE SURE ALL CITIES
01:29:11.846 --> 01:29:13.114
AROUND THE AREA ARE YOU SEEN
01:29:13.181 --> 01:29:14.048
THOSE PRACTICES AND THEY WERE
01:29:14.115 --> 01:29:16.551
NOT. THAT WE EARLY ON THE SIDE
01:29:16.617 --> 01:29:17.852
OKAY THIS IS NOT HOW WE SHOULD
01:29:17.919 --> 01:29:19.220
BE YOU KNOW LET'S FIX IT. SO
01:29:19.287 --> 01:29:20.088
THAT I CITIES ARE LOOKING TO
01:29:20.154 --> 01:29:21.255
EACH OTHER TO MOVE FORWARD AND
01:29:21.322 --> 01:29:23.057
BRING IN THIS BUSINESSES. WERE
01:29:23.124 --> 01:29:24.625
DOING IT IN THE BEST. POSSIBLE
01:29:24.692 --> 01:29:28.229
WAY- I. I DO NOT KNOW THAT WE
01:29:28.296 --> 01:29:29.764
NEED TO THE WAITER THAT THINGS
01:29:29.831 --> 01:29:30.665
ARE GONNA CHANGE WHEN OUR-
01:29:30.732 --> 01:29:32.266
EXPIRATION IS ABOUT. BEST
01:29:32.333 --> 01:29:34.502
PRACTICES AND- YOU KNOW IF THE
01:29:34.569 --> 01:29:36.070
CITIES ARE DOING THAT THEN THEY
01:29:36.137 --> 01:29:37.205
CREATE A MODEL FOR OTHER
01:29:37.271 --> 01:29:39.073
CITIES. ARE NOW QUICKLY LOOKING
01:29:39.140 --> 01:29:40.341
TO EXPAND AT LOOKING AT WHAT
01:29:40.408 --> 01:29:42.577
NEIGHBORING. ARE GETTING. I
01:29:42.643 --> 01:29:43.344
THINK THAT THAT GOT WHAT MY-
01:29:43.411 --> 01:29:44.879
LISTENERS. BY AND IT COULD BE
01:29:44.946 --> 01:29:49.417
SO. I SHOULD ALSO GET INTO THIS
01:29:49.484 --> 01:29:52.787
ALONG THE WAY AND SO WE HAVE.
01:29:52.854 --> 01:29:58.960
THIS DOMINO EFFECT. I TRIED ON.
01:29:59.026 --> 01:30:02.530
I'M SORRY TO SAY THAT I DIDN'T
01:30:02.597 --> 01:30:04.565
THAT'S WHAT AT THIS TIME. LET
01:30:04.632 --> 01:30:05.466
ME SAY THIS I WE DON'T GET
01:30:05.533 --> 01:30:07.368
MATERIAL VERY EARLY OURSELVES
01:30:07.435 --> 01:30:08.836
AND WE'RE NOT BEING. TO A STATE
01:30:08.903 --> 01:30:11.038
AUDIT SO I'M ALL ABOUT DUE
01:30:11.105 --> 01:30:13.674
PROCESS AROUND HERE AND I THINK
01:30:13.741 --> 01:30:15.376
PEOPLE SHOULD RECEIVE
01:30:15.443 --> 01:30:17.245
INFORMATION IN A IN A TIMELY
01:30:17.311 --> 01:30:18.980
MANNER AND IN A MANNER THAT'S
01:30:19.046 --> 01:30:20.515
DESIGNED TO GIVE THEM AN
01:30:20.581 --> 01:30:22.450
ADEQUATE OPPORTUNITY. TO
01:30:22.517 --> 01:30:23.918
PRESENT THE CASE AS TO WHY WE
01:30:23.985 --> 01:30:25.653
SHOULDN'T HAVE A STATE ON IT
01:30:25.720 --> 01:30:27.188
BECAUSE OF COURSE EVERY TIME WE
01:30:27.255 --> 01:30:30.057
VOTE FOR NOT IT. IT'S SOMEWHERE
01:30:30.124 --> 01:30:31.993
BETWEEN THREE AND FOUR HUNDRED
01:30:32.059 --> 01:30:33.161
THOUSAND DOLLARS OUT OF THE
01:30:33.227 --> 01:30:34.395
STATE AUDITOR'S BUDGET NOW IF
01:30:34.462 --> 01:30:35.663
IT'S AN APPROPRIATE ON IT I
01:30:35.730 --> 01:30:37.231
HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THAT- I.
01:30:37.298 --> 01:30:40.802
FRANKLY WAS AND I AM PREPARED
01:30:40.868 --> 01:30:43.337
TO VOTE FOR THIS AUDIT-
01:30:43.404 --> 01:30:46.340
PROVIDED MY COLLEAGUES WHO- HAD
01:30:46.407 --> 01:30:48.743
A NOTICE PROBLEM HERE IT. IS
01:30:48.810 --> 01:30:51.679
OKAY WITH THAT. BUT HAVING SAID
01:30:51.746 --> 01:30:52.780
THAT I ALSO THINK THAT THE
01:30:52.847 --> 01:30:54.982
PEOPLE THAT COME BEFORE US I TO
01:30:55.049 --> 01:30:56.584
HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT
01:30:56.651 --> 01:30:59.020
THE MATTERS. IN SUPPORT OF
01:30:59.086 --> 01:31:01.355
THEIR POSITION AND IF PEOPLE
01:31:01.422 --> 01:31:02.757
ARE GETTING TWO OR THREE DAYS
01:31:02.824 --> 01:31:04.826
OR FIVE DAYS NOTICE OF ANOTHER
01:31:04.892 --> 01:31:07.061
REQUEST IN YOUR IN SOUTHERN
01:31:07.128 --> 01:31:10.131
CALIFORNIA- THAT MAY NOT BE
01:31:10.198 --> 01:31:11.666
SUFFICIENT AND THAT'S- ASSEMBLY
01:31:11.732 --> 01:31:12.567
MEMBER THAT'S WHAT I'M
01:31:12.633 --> 01:31:15.469
CONCERNED ABOUT IT'S AT THIS
01:31:15.536 --> 01:31:16.737
POINT MORE THE OPTIC TO ME.
01:31:16.804 --> 01:31:18.206
THAN THE DECISION AND THE
01:31:18.272 --> 01:31:19.740
DECISION MAY IN FACT BE THE
01:31:19.807 --> 01:31:23.177
VERY SAME DECISION- THAT ON THE
01:31:23.244 --> 01:31:25.279
FACE OF IT I'M PREPARED TO MAKE
01:31:25.346 --> 01:31:26.647
TODAY BUT I CERTAINLY WOULD
01:31:26.714 --> 01:31:28.416
WANT PEOPLE WHO. DON'T HAVE
01:31:28.482 --> 01:31:30.017
THAT SAME POSITION TO CAN HAVE
01:31:30.084 --> 01:31:31.519
AN OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THEIR
01:31:31.586 --> 01:31:34.055
SO THAT'S THE PURPOSE FOR MY
01:31:34.121 --> 01:31:36.524
QUESTION AND I'M NOT SURE WHEN-
01:31:36.591 --> 01:31:37.925
TO BE HONEST MYSELF WOULD
01:31:37.992 --> 01:31:40.728
COMMITTEE. SENDS OUT THOSE
01:31:40.795 --> 01:31:42.330
REQUESTS I MEAN THE FOCUSES OR
01:31:42.396 --> 01:31:44.465
NOT YEAH SO THERE'S A PRETTY
01:31:44.532 --> 01:31:45.700
TWO PARTS THAT QUESTION SENATE
01:31:45.766 --> 01:31:48.302
ROTH RIGHT ONE IS- PROCEDURAL
01:31:48.369 --> 01:31:50.438
IF WITH THE CITY WHICH YOU KNOW
01:31:50.504 --> 01:31:51.806
STARKLY WE'VE- HI. THANK AT
01:31:51.873 --> 01:31:53.774
LEAST FOUR FIVE TEARS NOW.
01:31:53.841 --> 01:31:55.176
ABOUT FOLLOW THAT PROCEURE IN
01:31:55.243 --> 01:31:56.110
TERMS OF GETTING THE MATERIAL
01:31:56.177 --> 01:31:57.478
TEACHER THE J. LACK MEMBER SO
01:31:57.545 --> 01:31:58.679
THAT'S ALWAYS BEEN A FIGHTER
01:31:58.746 --> 01:32:00.147
TO. ABBOTT SECONDLY I THINK
01:32:00.214 --> 01:32:01.649
WITHIN A ROTH IS ASKING
01:32:01.716 --> 01:32:03.484
ASSEMBLY WOMAN IS YOU KNOW
01:32:03.551 --> 01:32:04.418
REACHING OUT TO THE CITY THAT
01:32:04.485 --> 01:32:06.153
ARE AFFECTED POSSIBLY. AND
01:32:06.220 --> 01:32:07.989
MAYBE IF THAT CAN BE DONE MAYBE
01:32:08.055 --> 01:32:10.591
IN THE FUTURE AS OTHER PEOPLE
01:32:10.658 --> 01:32:11.192
ARE LISTENING TO THIS HEARING
01:32:11.259 --> 01:32:13.160
AS WELL. OTHER AUTHORS BABY
01:32:13.227 --> 01:32:14.996
MINDFUL OF AS WELL. SO I THINK
01:32:15.062 --> 01:32:16.230
THAT'S A WAY OF UNDERSTANDING
01:32:16.297 --> 01:32:18.366
IT AS WELL AND I KNOW WE HAVE A
01:32:18.432 --> 01:32:20.501
NUMBER OF FAIR ENOUGH LATEST
01:32:20.568 --> 01:32:21.135
YOU LET THE COMMITTEE. THAT NOT
01:32:21.202 --> 01:32:24.038
TO THE AFFECTED HM IN A- OUT OF.
01:32:24.105 --> 01:32:25.473
STATEMENT THAT YOU'RE MAKING TO
01:32:25.539 --> 01:32:26.807
MYSELF AND OUR COLLEAGUES AS
01:32:26.874 --> 01:32:27.608
WE'RE THINKING ABOUT THIS
01:32:27.675 --> 01:32:29.110
MOVING FORWARD. WITH THAT WE'RE
01:32:29.176 --> 01:32:30.745
GONNA MOVE TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:32:30.811 --> 01:32:32.813
WOULD THEN SENATOR GONZALEZ AND
01:32:32.880 --> 01:32:34.515
TO SEND HER MONEY. PLEASE
01:32:34.582 --> 01:32:35.917
MISTER WHAT THANK YOU- THROUGH
01:32:35.983 --> 01:32:37.451
THE TRAFFIC COUPLE QUESTIONS
01:32:37.518 --> 01:32:39.720
AND IT'S- TRYING TO UNDERSTAND-
01:32:39.787 --> 01:32:42.556
SOMETHING- TO YOU TALKED ABOUT.
01:32:42.623 --> 01:32:47.361
PERMITS. YOU TALK ABOUT
01:32:47.428 --> 01:32:48.095
CONTRACT. SO I'M UNCLEAR THE
01:32:48.162 --> 01:32:48.996
CONTRACTING PART OF THAT SO CAN.
01:32:49.063 --> 01:32:50.998
EXPLAIN TO ME. IS THE CITY
01:32:51.065 --> 01:32:51.999
CONTRACTING WITH CANNABIS
01:32:52.066 --> 01:32:54.936
BUSINESSES. OR YOU CONTRACTING
01:32:55.002 --> 01:32:57.271
WITH PEOPLE PROVIDING SERVICES
01:32:57.338 --> 01:32:59.040
THAT ARE AIMED AT HELPING
01:32:59.106 --> 01:33:01.042
CANNABIS BUSINESSES BECOME
01:33:01.108 --> 01:33:02.710
COMPLIANT WITH WITH THE CITY
01:33:02.777 --> 01:33:03.811
YEAH PERHAPS WE COULD HAVE THE
01:33:03.878 --> 01:33:05.613
CITY'S RESPOND PLEASE YES THANK
01:33:05.680 --> 01:33:07.014
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN PERMITTED
01:33:07.081 --> 01:33:09.016
DRESS THE MEMBERS CERTAINLY S.
01:33:09.083 --> 01:33:12.353
UP. MY READ OF THE LETTER IS
01:33:12.420 --> 01:33:14.221
NOT AS RICH TO CONTRACTING IS
01:33:14.288 --> 01:33:17.658
NOT RELATIVE TO CANNABIS ISSUES
01:33:17.725 --> 01:33:19.860
IS RELATED TO JUST GENERAL
01:33:19.927 --> 01:33:21.862
CONTRACTING PRACTICES OF THE
01:33:21.929 --> 01:33:23.197
CITY THAT'S MY READING THE
01:33:23.264 --> 01:33:25.599
LETTER. OUR STATE CANNABIS
01:33:25.666 --> 01:33:27.835
ELEMENT HOWEVER DOES ADDRESS
01:33:27.902 --> 01:33:30.638
HOW LICENSES ARE ISSUED AND THE
01:33:30.705 --> 01:33:31.973
DEVELOPMENT CONTRACTING
01:33:32.039 --> 01:33:35.076
ELEMENTS OF THAT NO TURN OVER
01:33:35.142 --> 01:33:36.978
MISS COMPETITIVE. I WANT TO
01:33:37.044 --> 01:33:40.014
WEAR A OF KIND. AS PART OF A
01:33:40.081 --> 01:33:43.250
CANNABIS- PERMITTING PROCESS SO
01:33:43.317 --> 01:33:44.685
I THAT'S THAT'S AND LOOK AND I
01:33:44.752 --> 01:33:46.454
SAT ON MY AYE AYE HELP RIGHT
01:33:46.520 --> 01:33:49.023
THE ORIGINAL THING- MEDICAL
01:33:49.090 --> 01:33:50.558
CANNABIS REGULATORY SAFETY ACT
01:33:50.624 --> 01:33:52.326
AND THERE'S A LOT OF. THE NEW
01:33:52.393 --> 01:33:53.728
LAWS ARE BASED ON THAT BUT I
01:33:53.794 --> 01:33:56.097
NEVER I CANNOT REMEMBER THE USE
01:33:56.163 --> 01:33:57.732
OF THE WORD CONTRACTING
01:33:57.798 --> 01:33:58.566
ANYTHING YOU HAVE THAT
01:33:58.632 --> 01:34:00.201
DOCUMENTATION AND I APOLOGIZE I
01:34:00.267 --> 01:34:01.702
THINK WHAT WHAT WE'RE DIRECTING
01:34:01.769 --> 01:34:03.471
IS BASED ON THE RESPONSE OF
01:34:03.537 --> 01:34:05.106
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GARCIA'S
01:34:05.172 --> 01:34:07.441
LETTER. SHE HAS A LIST NINE
01:34:07.508 --> 01:34:09.643
QUESTIONS AND THERE'S TWO
01:34:09.710 --> 01:34:12.079
UMBRELLAS TO DIFFERENT TOPICS
01:34:12.146 --> 01:34:14.148
WHEN IS CANNABIS LICENSING
01:34:14.215 --> 01:34:16.117
PRACTICES. IN A SEPARATE PART
01:34:16.183 --> 01:34:19.020
IS THE CITY'S CONTRACT. UP UP
01:34:19.086 --> 01:34:21.555
PRACTICES SO WHERE THEY ARE I
01:34:21.622 --> 01:34:23.758
DID THE I IN THIRD THEY'RE
01:34:23.824 --> 01:34:25.126
RELATED WITH NOT THAT. BY
01:34:25.192 --> 01:34:27.495
CITIES CONTRACTING WITH KIND OF
01:34:27.561 --> 01:34:29.163
PROVIDERS A MESSAGE LIKE CLUB
01:34:29.230 --> 01:34:31.165
SO I'VE GOT A THING BUT I THINK
01:34:31.232 --> 01:34:32.566
THE CONTRA WITH INDIVIDUALS
01:34:32.633 --> 01:34:35.469
HELP CREATE THE STANDARDS FOR
01:34:35.536 --> 01:34:37.405
HOW THEY'RE GONNA BE AWARDING.
01:34:37.471 --> 01:34:38.806
LICENSES AND STUFF LIKE THAT SO
01:34:38.873 --> 01:34:40.608
THOSE THOSE CONTRACTS AT THE
01:34:40.674 --> 01:34:42.043
LAFAYETTE CONTRACTING PRACTICES
01:34:42.109 --> 01:34:44.211
BUT NOT DIRECTLY WITH THAT THIS
01:34:44.278 --> 01:34:47.748
MYTH THAT AND THAT WOULD BE MY
01:34:47.815 --> 01:34:48.916
UNDERSTAND SENATE THERE ARE
01:34:48.983 --> 01:34:53.888
BUSINESSES THAT. THEIR WORK WAS.
01:34:53.954 --> 01:34:55.222
WITH YOU KNOW HELP WITH. IN
01:34:55.289 --> 01:34:56.657
GUIDE FOR APPROPRIATE
01:34:56.724 --> 01:34:58.659
APPROPRIATE NOW FOR THE SO A
01:34:58.726 --> 01:35:00.694
COUPLE. I'M SET SIR OF
01:35:00.761 --> 01:35:01.395
SURPRISED QUITE FRANKLY THIS
01:35:01.462 --> 01:35:03.431
THAT HAVE A- ROUGHLY. CANNABIS
01:35:03.497 --> 01:35:06.067
PERMIT FOR LESS THAN FIVE
01:35:06.133 --> 01:35:07.368
HUNDRED RESIDENTS IN THE CITY
01:35:07.435 --> 01:35:09.370
OF COMMERCE THAT SEEMS. LIKE A
01:35:09.437 --> 01:35:10.971
PRETTY HIGH NUMBER IF I'M
01:35:11.038 --> 01:35:12.940
READING YOUR POPULATION OF
01:35:13.007 --> 01:35:13.941
THIRTEEN THOUSAND AND TWENTY
01:35:14.008 --> 01:35:15.476
NINE LICENSES THAT. THAT'S A
01:35:15.543 --> 01:35:18.946
BIG NUMBER- ARE THESE- PERMITS
01:35:19.013 --> 01:35:20.815
MANUFACTURING EIGHTEEN OR THE
01:35:20.881 --> 01:35:23.284
DISTRIBUTION OR THE CULTIVATION
01:35:23.350 --> 01:35:24.919
OR THEY MEAN WHAT ARE THEY
01:35:24.985 --> 01:35:26.487
BECAUSE CERTAINLY IF YOU GOT TO
01:35:26.554 --> 01:35:27.521
NINE RETAIL ESTABLISHMENTS
01:35:27.588 --> 01:35:28.889
THERE YOU GOT A LOT OF PEOPLE
01:35:28.956 --> 01:35:30.858
GOING OUT OF BUSINESS TOMORROW.
01:35:30.925 --> 01:35:33.394
AND I TO BE ARE VERY SPECIFIC
01:35:33.461 --> 01:35:35.129
THE CITY OF COMMERCE DOES NOT
01:35:35.196 --> 01:35:37.698
HAVE ANY STOREFRONT DISPENSARY
01:35:37.765 --> 01:35:39.834
NONE OF THE BUSINESSES ARE
01:35:39.900 --> 01:35:41.569
OPENED TO THE PUBLIC EVERYTHING
01:35:41.635 --> 01:35:44.438
IS CULTIVATION MANUFACTURING
01:35:44.505 --> 01:35:46.907
DISTRIBUTION AND THERE IS A NON
01:35:46.974 --> 01:35:49.643
STOREFRONT DELIVERY. BUT ALL OF
01:35:49.710 --> 01:35:51.178
THE BUSINESSES ARE CLOSED TO
01:35:51.245 --> 01:35:52.880
THE PUBLIC OKAY ALL RIGHT
01:35:52.947 --> 01:35:55.082
THAT'S THAT'S HELPFUL ELSA. BUT
01:35:55.149 --> 01:35:58.786
IF I MAY- I'D LIKE TO ALSO MAKE
01:35:58.853 --> 01:35:59.787
ONE CLEAR FIND POINT- O CENTER
01:35:59.854 --> 01:36:01.355
ROTS QUESTION EARLIER ABOUT
01:36:01.422 --> 01:36:03.124
REASONS WHY NOT TO HAVE DECIDED
01:36:03.190 --> 01:36:04.825
I THINK I CAN PROVIDE WHEN AT
01:36:04.892 --> 01:36:06.093
LEAST ACTUALLY THINK THAT WE
01:36:06.160 --> 01:36:08.329
KIND OF DRESS THAT IT'S MY TURN
01:36:08.395 --> 01:36:08.929
TO HAVE CAUGHT. THE RIGHT ARE
01:36:08.996 --> 01:36:10.498
THIS IS ALSO ANSWERS YOUR
01:36:10.564 --> 01:36:12.099
QUESTION IS ONE THAT TERMS OF
01:36:12.166 --> 01:36:13.434
THE CITY BRING TARA JENS
01:36:13.501 --> 01:36:15.870
INSTANCE OF THE CITY FUNDING TO
01:36:15.936 --> 01:36:16.470
MARKET IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE
01:36:16.537 --> 01:36:17.972
THAT THE CITY. HAS ONLY ISSUE
01:36:18.038 --> 01:36:19.907
THREE LICENSES PERMISSIBLE COLD
01:36:19.974 --> 01:36:22.009
A WE WILL WE WILL NOT ISSUE ANY
01:36:22.076 --> 01:36:24.145
MORE THAN ANY GIVEN TIME- THESE
01:36:24.211 --> 01:36:26.147
BUSINESS LICENSES WERE ISSUED
01:36:26.213 --> 01:36:29.850
BACK IN TWENTY FIFTEEN TWENTY
01:36:29.917 --> 01:36:30.417
SIXTEEN THE CITY AND ALL THE
01:36:30.484 --> 01:36:33.854
APPLICATION. SEND RISEN ONE YOU
01:36:33.921 --> 01:36:35.689
APPLICATIONS THE CITY'S CURRENT
01:36:35.756 --> 01:36:36.524
TRIGGERING THERE HASN'T SINCE
01:36:36.590 --> 01:36:37.124
TWENTY. SO IN TERM OF RELEVANT
01:36:37.191 --> 01:36:38.192
OF THIS TOP. I JUST FEEL
01:36:38.259 --> 01:36:39.593
HUNTINGTON IS BE POORLY. AND
01:36:39.660 --> 01:36:42.029
UNFAIRLY TARGETED BECAUSE
01:36:42.096 --> 01:36:42.863
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG CITY
01:36:42.930 --> 01:36:44.832
ATTORNEY US GIVE TURN CITY
01:36:44.899 --> 01:36:46.367
ATTORNEY UP I BELIEVE OUR-
01:36:46.433 --> 01:36:47.868
MUNICIPAL COURT WAS MODELED OFF
01:36:47.935 --> 01:36:50.070
THE STATE'S- MEDICAL MARIJUANA
01:36:50.137 --> 01:36:51.972
REGULATIONS. WELL ONE OF THE
01:36:52.039 --> 01:36:54.775
THINGS THAT WE- YOU KNOW THAT
01:36:54.842 --> 01:36:58.412
THE STATE THE STATE. GRANTS
01:36:58.479 --> 01:37:00.814
LICENSES BASED ON ON ON A
01:37:00.881 --> 01:37:04.485
CITIES- PERMISSION TO OPERATE
01:37:04.552 --> 01:37:07.087
SO BUT WE DO NOT DICTATE HOW
01:37:07.154 --> 01:37:10.024
THE CITY ACTUALLY. GOVERNMENTS
01:37:10.090 --> 01:37:11.825
IT'S CANNABIS INDUSTRY AND WHAT
01:37:11.892 --> 01:37:13.460
I MEAN WE SET THE FLOOR NOT A
01:37:13.527 --> 01:37:15.596
CEILING SO YOU CAN BE A LOT
01:37:15.663 --> 01:37:16.830
MORE RESTRICTIVE AT THE CITY
01:37:16.897 --> 01:37:20.100
LEVEL THAN THAN WHAT WE WEEK WE-HAVE DONE AT THE STATE LEVEL
01:37:20.167 --> 01:37:22.536
AND WE'RE VERY RESTRICTIVE SO-
01:37:22.603 --> 01:37:24.205
SO I. I'M I'M STILL YOU KNOW
01:37:24.271 --> 01:37:25.839
I'M GONNA I'M I'M GOING TO
01:37:25.906 --> 01:37:27.274
SUPPORT THE AUDIT TODAY BUT I
01:37:27.341 --> 01:37:31.212
I'M I'M- I'M JUST. STILL
01:37:31.278 --> 01:37:33.080
THERE'S PARTS OF THIS THAT MAKE
01:37:33.147 --> 01:37:35.950
ME UNCOMFORTABLE. I FRANKLY AND
01:37:36.016 --> 01:37:37.518
I THINK LOOKING AT THAT THANK
01:37:37.585 --> 01:37:40.387
YOU MISTER WOOD. OKAY WITH THAT
01:37:40.454 --> 01:37:40.955
LET'S GO TO MOVE TO SENATOR
01:37:41.021 --> 01:37:43.290
GONZALEZ. YES THANK YOU FOR
01:37:43.357 --> 01:37:45.426
BEING HERE AND YOU KNOW I SURE
01:37:45.492 --> 01:37:46.860
THE SAME SENTIMENT I KNOW WE
01:37:46.927 --> 01:37:48.629
SPOKE ASSEMBLY MEMBER I
01:37:48.696 --> 01:37:50.064
APPRECIATE YOU YOU KNOW
01:37:50.130 --> 01:37:50.831
REACHING OUT BUT IT WAS
01:37:50.898 --> 01:37:54.768
CERTAINLY AFTER THE FACT AND IT
01:37:54.835 --> 01:37:55.369
WAS SURPRISING TO ME OF COURSE
01:37:55.436 --> 01:37:58.505
THAT MY CITY WAS BEING AUDITED
01:37:58.572 --> 01:38:00.407
WITHOUT MY KNOWLEDGE SO PUT ME
01:38:00.474 --> 01:38:02.977
IN A POSITION- HERE I AM ON THE
01:38:03.043 --> 01:38:04.511
COMMITTEE AND CERTAINLY WILLING
01:38:04.578 --> 01:38:05.346
TO WORK AND I THINK THAT. I
01:38:05.412 --> 01:38:06.847
CAN'T SPEAK FOR COMMERCE BUT I
01:38:06.914 --> 01:38:08.716
CAN SPEAK FOR HUNTING PARK
01:38:08.782 --> 01:38:11.552
THERE CERTAINLY WILLING TO
01:38:11.619 --> 01:38:12.052
LEAVE THE AUDIT AND DO
01:38:12.119 --> 01:38:13.220
EVERYTHING THAT THEY NEED TO DO
01:38:13.287 --> 01:38:15.389
TO ASSURE THAT THEY'RE
01:38:15.456 --> 01:38:16.924
FOLLOWING BY STATE LAW AND
01:38:16.991 --> 01:38:18.492
GUIDELINES. YOU KNOW BUT THERE
01:38:18.559 --> 01:38:21.762
PROCESS AND SO I KNOW WE ARE AT
01:38:21.829 --> 01:38:24.465
NOW HAVE A FEW QUICK AND I KNOW
01:38:24.531 --> 01:38:27.234
UP AGAIN RESPECT INTO PARK I TO
01:38:27.301 --> 01:38:30.471
THE STATE- ALSO IF YOU KNOW
01:38:30.537 --> 01:38:31.639
JUST HAVE. A REAL TOUGH TIME
01:38:31.705 --> 01:38:34.074
WITH THIS. BECAUSE I GET IT
01:38:34.141 --> 01:38:35.042
THERE BEEN A YOU KNOW NEWS
01:38:35.109 --> 01:38:36.910
ARTICLES WE'VE SEEN YOU KNOW
01:38:36.977 --> 01:38:38.279
MANY THINGS ABOUT THE SOUTHEAST
01:38:38.345 --> 01:38:41.382
BUT UNFORTUNATELY- NOT
01:38:41.448 --> 01:38:43.884
RESPECTIVE TO JUST THESE TWO
01:38:43.951 --> 01:38:45.819
CITIES THOUGH. AND SO I WOULD
01:38:45.886 --> 01:38:46.754
SAY YOU KNOW WHEN WE HAVE A
01:38:46.820 --> 01:38:49.056
GOAL OF LOOKING AT THE REGION
01:38:49.123 --> 01:38:49.890
WE SHOULD BE LOOKING AT THE
01:38:49.957 --> 01:38:51.692
REGION AND I THINK THAT IT'S
01:38:51.759 --> 01:38:53.927
IMPORTANT FOR US TO SIT DOWN.
01:38:53.994 --> 01:38:56.330
FIRST WITH ME THEM MANY OF
01:38:56.397 --> 01:38:57.598
THESE CITIES TO ENSURE THAT
01:38:57.665 --> 01:38:59.500
WERE CAPTURING ALL. KIND OF
01:38:59.566 --> 01:39:00.901
FEEL THAT THIS WAS YOU KNOW
01:39:00.968 --> 01:39:02.102
SORT OF AN ARBITRARY LIKE WE'RE
01:39:02.169 --> 01:39:03.837
GONNA JUST PICK AND CHOOSE WHO
01:39:03.904 --> 01:39:05.773
WE WANT TO. AT TO WHO WE WANT
01:39:05.839 --> 01:39:06.874
TO AUDIT THAT MAKES ME FEEL AN
01:39:06.940 --> 01:39:11.245
EASY. I'M BUT A QUESTION FOR
01:39:11.312 --> 01:39:13.514
THE AUDITOR IS THERE WAS A AN
01:39:13.580 --> 01:39:15.482
AUDIT THAT OCCURRED I THINK IT
01:39:15.549 --> 01:39:18.152
WAS IT DIDN'T GET COMPLETED IN
01:39:18.218 --> 01:39:19.153
TWENTY SEVENTEEN WITH THE CITY
01:39:19.219 --> 01:39:21.021
OF HUNTINGTON PARK. AND IT DID
01:39:21.088 --> 01:39:22.756
MENTION IT WAS A REGARDING
01:39:22.823 --> 01:39:24.358
FUTURE FINANCIAL OBLIGATIONS
01:39:24.425 --> 01:39:25.793
AND SORT OF A POTENTIAL HIGH
01:39:25.859 --> 01:39:27.761
RISK IT DID MENTION CONTRACTING
01:39:27.828 --> 01:39:29.897
I'M NOT SURE IF YOU. I DON'T
01:39:29.963 --> 01:39:31.799
KNOW WHERE THAT WS AT AND SO I
01:39:31.865 --> 01:39:33.033
WANT TO KNOW WHERE THAT WAS AT
01:39:33.100 --> 01:39:34.568
RELATIVE TO WHERE WE'RE AT NOW
01:39:34.635 --> 01:39:36.770
WITH THIS AUDIT RIGHT AND I
01:39:36.837 --> 01:39:37.905
MIGHT HAVE A MISTER TILDEN
01:39:37.971 --> 01:39:39.740
ASSIST ME WITH THIS. BUT WHAT
01:39:39.807 --> 01:39:41.709
WHAT THE CITY IS REFERRING TO
01:39:41.775 --> 01:39:42.276
WHEN YOU WERE REFERRING TO
01:39:42.343 --> 01:39:44.178
SENATOR IS WHEN WE WHEN WE
01:39:44.244 --> 01:39:45.813
CONDUCT THE ANALYSIS THE HIGH
01:39:45.879 --> 01:39:47.181
LEVEL ANALYSIS SAYS MR CHILDREN
01:39:47.247 --> 01:39:49.583
WAS REFERRING TO EARLIER. AND
01:39:49.650 --> 01:39:50.217
WE'RE LOOKING AT FISCAL
01:39:50.284 --> 01:39:52.986
INDICATORS- YEAH- AS FAR AS YOU
01:39:53.053 --> 01:39:55.122
KNOW ABILITY TO PAY THEIR BILLS
01:39:55.189 --> 01:39:55.956
AND SHORT TERM LONG TERM DO
01:39:56.023 --> 01:39:57.224
THEY HAVE SUFFICIENT FUNDS IN
01:39:57.291 --> 01:39:58.092
RESERVE. AND OF THOSE
01:39:58.158 --> 01:40:00.661
INDICATORS APPEAR TO US TO
01:40:00.728 --> 01:40:02.896
SUGGEST THAT THE CITY IS UNDER
01:40:02.963 --> 01:40:04.998
FISCAL. CONSTRAINT THEN WE WILL
01:40:05.065 --> 01:40:07.267
GO OUT COCKED AN ASSESSMENT IT
01:40:07.334 --> 01:40:08.602
IS NOT AN AUDIT WE DO NOT A
01:40:08.669 --> 01:40:10.104
STATUTORY STODDARD AUTHORITY TO
01:40:10.170 --> 01:40:11.872
CONDUCT AN AUDIT. LOCAL HIGH
01:40:11.939 --> 01:40:13.273
RISK PROGRAM UNTIL THIS
01:40:13.340 --> 01:40:15.509
COMMITTEE APPROVES IT SO WHAT
01:40:15.576 --> 01:40:17.244
WE DID IS WE WENT OUT AND
01:40:17.311 --> 01:40:18.345
CONDUCT AN ASSESSMENT
01:40:18.412 --> 01:40:20.848
ESSENTIALLY WHAT AN ASSESSMENT
01:40:20.914 --> 01:40:24.385
IS GOING OUT MEET. IF IT PULLS
01:40:24.451 --> 01:40:26.620
IT DOING SO FOLKS LOOKING AT
01:40:26.687 --> 01:40:28.922
SOME DOCUMENTS BUT ONE. THING
01:40:28.989 --> 01:40:30.190
BUT IT WORKS WELL TEST CONTRA.
01:40:30.257 --> 01:40:31.125
WE'RE NOT TESTING EXPENDITURES
01:40:31.191 --> 01:40:32.059
THOSE ARE THINGS WERE JUST
01:40:32.126 --> 01:40:34.862
HAVING. BILLY AKON. OUGHT TO
01:40:34.928 --> 01:40:39.666
GET A FEEL FOR WHETHER OR NOT
01:40:39.733 --> 01:40:40.501
WE THINK THE CITY HAS. PLUS
01:40:40.567 --> 01:40:41.702
PLACE IF THERE IN IN OUR
01:40:41.769 --> 01:40:43.804
STRUGGLING WITH. ODD REVENUES
01:40:43.871 --> 01:40:46.573
OVER THERE EXPENDITURES ARE ARE
01:40:46.640 --> 01:40:48.909
TOO HIGH EACH YEAR- SO. ONCE WE
01:40:48.976 --> 01:40:50.477
COMPLETE THAT ASSESSMENT THEN
01:40:50.544 --> 01:40:53.714
WE HAVE TO MAKE A DETERMINATION
01:40:53.781 --> 01:40:54.348
AS TO WHETHER OR NOT SUFFICIENT
01:40:54.415 --> 01:40:55.616
CONCERN. TO COME TO THIS
01:40:55.682 --> 01:40:57.418
COMMITTEE AND ASK FOR AN AUDIT.
01:40:57.484 --> 01:40:59.319
IN THE CASE OF HUNTINGTON PARK
01:40:59.386 --> 01:41:00.487
WE DID THE ASSESSMENT. IT
01:41:00.554 --> 01:41:02.623
COMPARED TO OTHER CITIES THAT
01:41:02.689 --> 01:41:03.624
WE HAD LOOKED AT IT DIDN'T RISE
01:41:03.690 --> 01:41:05.125
TO THE LEVEL OF SOMETHING WE
01:41:05.192 --> 01:41:06.427
THOUGHT WE SHOULD COME TO THIS
01:41:06.493 --> 01:41:07.895
COMMITTEE. SO WE MAY HAVE
01:41:07.961 --> 01:41:09.329
LOOKED AT CONTRA I'M SORRY I
01:41:09.396 --> 01:41:11.465
DON'T HAVE ALL THE DETAILS- WE
01:41:11.532 --> 01:41:13.534
MAY HAVE TALKED TO THEM ABOUT
01:41:13.600 --> 01:41:15.636
THEIR CONTRACTING. DISS BUT WE
01:41:15.702 --> 01:41:17.871
CERTAINLY DIDN'T CONDUCT AUDIT
01:41:17.938 --> 01:41:18.472
WORK. IN ACTUALLY TEST CONTRA
01:41:18.539 --> 01:41:20.107
LOOKING OUT THERE PROCESS FOR
01:41:20.174 --> 01:41:21.575
REPORTING CONTRACTS. AND
01:41:21.642 --> 01:41:23.143
MONITORING CONTRACT BUT BASED
01:41:23.210 --> 01:41:24.778
ON THAT ASSESSMENT. THERE
01:41:24.845 --> 01:41:27.114
WASN'T ANYTHING OF SIGNIFICANT
01:41:27.181 --> 01:41:29.416
CONCERN TO US. THAT WOULD
01:41:29.483 --> 01:41:30.918
GENERATE AN AUDIT REQUESTS TO
01:41:30.984 --> 01:41:32.719
THIS COMMITTEE SO I HOPE THAT
01:41:32.786 --> 01:41:35.289
HELPS ANSWER YOUR- OKAY AND
01:41:35.355 --> 01:41:37.558
THEN I KNOW THAT- ASSEMBLY
01:41:37.624 --> 01:41:38.492
WOMAN YOU'D MENTIONED SOME
01:41:38.559 --> 01:41:40.427
ARTICLES BUT WAS THERE ANYTHING
01:41:40.494 --> 01:41:43.530
RECENT THAT WAS. STRIKING TO
01:41:43.597 --> 01:41:46.133
WARRANT THIS- PARTICULAR AUDIT
01:41:46.200 --> 01:41:47.568
REQUEST FOR THE CITY OF
01:41:47.634 --> 01:41:48.902
HUNTINGTON PARK I THINK THAT'S
01:41:48.969 --> 01:41:50.737
WERE LOOKING AS BUT AT A TRYING
01:41:50.804 --> 01:41:52.406
TO IDENTIFY BEST PRACTICES AND
01:41:52.473 --> 01:41:53.574
OF THE CITY FIFTEEN BEST
01:41:53.640 --> 01:41:55.075
PRACTICES THAT WAS TRYING TO
01:41:55.142 --> 01:41:55.742
FIGURE OUT WHO'S BEEN DOING
01:41:55.809 --> 01:41:57.177
THIS IS SOMEONE THAT HAS. THE
01:41:57.244 --> 01:41:58.679
SLIGHT LONGER PROCESS THAN A
01:41:58.745 --> 01:42:00.781
CUP AND THAT WE COULD THEN SAY
01:42:00.848 --> 01:42:01.949
OKAY LET'S LOOK AT THIS AND DO
01:42:02.015 --> 01:42:03.250
THEY HAVE EXAMPLES OF THINGS
01:42:03.317 --> 01:42:05.986
THAT THEY DID OR YOU KNOW THAT
01:42:06.053 --> 01:42:08.622
MAKES SENSE ON AND WE CAN SAY
01:42:08.689 --> 01:42:09.523
WELL HERE'S A COUPLE OF THE
01:42:09.590 --> 01:42:11.091
WITH THE THING THAT MAKES THIS
01:42:11.158 --> 01:42:12.226
REBEKAH BEST PRACTICES. IN
01:42:12.292 --> 01:42:14.495
THOSE DAYS. THIS TIME WHO HAVE
01:42:14.561 --> 01:42:15.863
HAD A SOME LICENSES OUT THERE
01:42:15.929 --> 01:42:16.897
FOR WHILE- WITH THE
01:42:16.964 --> 01:42:18.065
LEGALIZATION OF IT IT'S THE YOU
01:42:18.131 --> 01:42:20.267
KNOW IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S
01:42:20.334 --> 01:42:22.402
GROWING RAPIDLY NOW ON THAT
01:42:22.469 --> 01:42:23.003
WITHIN HALF WE HAVEN'T HAD TOO
01:42:23.070 --> 01:42:23.604
MANY YEARS FOR. I THINK IT'S
01:42:23.670 --> 01:42:25.239
FOR ME MAKING SURE AS IS.
01:42:25.305 --> 01:42:28.041
EXPANDING IN THE BEST POSSIBLE
01:42:28.108 --> 01:42:30.711
WAY SINCE- WE STEP BACK TO THE
01:42:30.777 --> 01:42:33.947
EARLY BUT OTHER PEOPLE FACT.
01:42:34.014 --> 01:42:37.551
APPLIQUE OKAY. I HAVE ANOTHER
01:42:37.618 --> 01:42:39.520
QUESTION HERE PLEASE SENATOR
01:42:39.586 --> 01:42:42.356
YES RIGHT I'LL I'LL HURRY IT UP
01:42:42.422 --> 01:42:43.557
OKAY SO ONE MORE THING I WOULD
01:42:43.624 --> 01:42:46.093
JUST SAY- I THINK THAT ANSWERED
01:42:46.159 --> 01:42:47.895
ALL OF MY QUESTIONS I SO I'M
01:42:47.961 --> 01:42:49.162
TEETERING BETWEEN TWO DIFFERENT
01:42:49.229 --> 01:42:50.597
THINGS BUT THE FIRST AT
01:42:50.664 --> 01:42:51.632
QUESTION I'LL ASK YOU IS
01:42:51.698 --> 01:42:55.135
WHETHER HE'D BE- YOU'D BE OKAY
01:42:55.202 --> 01:42:56.937
POSTPONING THIS UNTIL YOU SIT
01:42:57.004 --> 01:43:01.008
DOWN WITH THE LEASE. AND THEN
01:43:01.074 --> 01:43:01.975
WE CAN START A NOT AT THAT
01:43:02.042 --> 01:43:04.745
POINT. WELL I THINK I GUESS I
01:43:04.811 --> 01:43:07.948
DON'T- WHEN AUDIT STARTED ON
01:43:08.015 --> 01:43:08.949
SALE AT THE PASSES THE OUTER
01:43:09.016 --> 01:43:10.150
COAST I'M NOT SURE I MEAN I
01:43:10.217 --> 01:43:11.718
WOULD SAY THAT I WOULD. REQUEST
01:43:11.785 --> 01:43:12.886
THAT THE VOTE FOR THE LATTER TO
01:43:12.953 --> 01:43:14.187
STARE AT SOME POINT B. TAKEN
01:43:14.254 --> 01:43:15.489
TODAY WHEN KERR WORK ACTUALLY
01:43:15.556 --> 01:43:17.424
STARTS AND SO FORTH. I'M
01:43:17.491 --> 01:43:19.293
WILLING TO SAY THAT MAYBE SEE
01:43:19.359 --> 01:43:21.094
START OFFICIALLY A MONTH FROM
01:43:21.161 --> 01:43:22.262
NOW OR SOMETHING WHEN I OR
01:43:22.329 --> 01:43:23.630
WHATEVER I DON'T KNOW BUT I
01:43:23.697 --> 01:43:25.032
WOULD SAY THAT WE'RE NOT PLAN
01:43:25.098 --> 01:43:26.433
TO HAVE A MEETING FOR A COUPLE
01:43:26.500 --> 01:43:29.503
MONTHS AT LEAST. I AND- SO WHAT
01:43:29.570 --> 01:43:31.138
CAN MAYBE I CAN ADD SOME
01:43:31.204 --> 01:43:32.606
CLARITY HERE SO THERE'S TWO
01:43:32.673 --> 01:43:35.475
THINGS WE CAN DO WITH THE AUDIT
01:43:35.542 --> 01:43:37.110
COMMITTEE. THREE ONE IS. TO PUT.
01:43:37.177 --> 01:43:38.345
THE ENTIRE. AND OUR NECKS
01:43:38.412 --> 01:43:39.379
REGULAR SCHEDULED ONE WHICH
01:43:39.446 --> 01:43:40.480
WE'RE ANTICIPATING THE FIRST
01:43:40.547 --> 01:43:42.783
WEEK OF AUGUST. OR WE CAN DO IS
01:43:42.849 --> 01:43:44.418
APPROVE IT TODAY AND ASK THE
01:43:44.484 --> 01:43:47.254
AUDITOR IF SHE WOULD DELAY- THE
01:43:47.321 --> 01:43:49.289
AUDIT GOING INTO THE CITIES. SO
01:43:49.356 --> 01:43:50.757
WE'VE DONE THAT IN THE PAST AS
01:43:50.824 --> 01:43:52.292
WELL THERE'S PRECEDENT FOR THAT
01:43:52.359 --> 01:43:54.394
AS WELL SO THOSE ARE OPTIONS-
01:43:54.461 --> 01:43:55.629
BUT OF COURSE IS CONTINGENT
01:43:55.696 --> 01:43:57.130
UPON. THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN SINCE
01:43:57.197 --> 01:44:00.233
IT IS RIDE IT. AND BEYOND
01:44:00.300 --> 01:44:01.668
NEGOTIATIONS OR- DISCUSSIONS
01:44:01.735 --> 01:44:03.070
WITH THAT MEMBERS OF THE DICE.
01:44:03.136 --> 01:44:04.671
I MEAN I WOULD SAY WAITING
01:44:04.738 --> 01:44:06.907
UNTIL AUGUST. TROUBLING TO ME
01:44:06.974 --> 01:44:09.710
BUT- THE LATE IN. OF THAT THE
01:44:09.776 --> 01:44:11.011
CHAIRMAN HAS STATED TO
01:44:11.078 --> 01:44:12.412
SOMETHING I'M COMFORTABLE WITH.
01:44:12.479 --> 01:44:17.017
OKAY. ALL RIGHT- I WOULD LIKE
01:44:17.084 --> 01:44:19.453
TO THEN SAY- YOU KNOW IF WE
01:44:19.519 --> 01:44:20.320
WERE ABLE TO POSTPONE AND I
01:44:20.387 --> 01:44:22.322
WOULD PREFER THAT- TO WAIT TO
01:44:22.389 --> 01:44:25.125
OUR NEXT- MEETING JUST TO GIVE
01:44:25.192 --> 01:44:27.494
THIS THESE- TO CITIES TIME TO
01:44:27.561 --> 01:44:29.796
DISCUSS AND SIT DOWN WITH YOU-
01:44:29.863 --> 01:44:32.733
IF YOU'D BE WILLING TO DO THAT.
01:44:32.799 --> 01:44:34.701
WOULD BE MUCH APPRECIATED I'D
01:44:34.768 --> 01:44:36.269
BE WILLING TO SIT DOWN WITH YOU
01:44:36.336 --> 01:44:37.204
TO ENSURE THAT WE GET THIS
01:44:37.270 --> 01:44:38.905
RIGHT FOR THE SOUTHEAST REGION.
01:44:38.972 --> 01:44:39.973
AND ENSURE THAT THERE'S MORE
01:44:40.040 --> 01:44:41.975
CITIES THAT WE CAN INCLUDE IF
01:44:42.042 --> 01:44:44.778
THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE AS WELL.
01:44:44.845 --> 01:44:49.149
I'M MY PREFERENCES THAT WE VOTE
01:44:49.216 --> 01:44:50.350
FOR A TWO DAY I THINK WAITING
01:44:50.417 --> 01:44:51.518
THAT MANY MONTHS FOR A VOTE AND
01:44:51.585 --> 01:44:54.154
THEN- IT MAKES ME UNCOMFORTABLE
01:44:54.221 --> 01:44:55.922
UP HAVING A VOTE THAT THIS WILL
01:44:55.989 --> 01:44:58.392
HAPPEN BUT ALLOWING THE AUDITOR
01:44:58.458 --> 01:45:00.360
TO DELAY HER WORK WOULD BE WHAT
01:45:00.427 --> 01:45:02.496
I'M MORE COMFORTABLE WITH- I
01:45:02.562 --> 01:45:03.730
DON'T KNOW THAT THAT EXTRA
01:45:03.797 --> 01:45:05.165
TIMES GOING TO SWITCH THE
01:45:05.232 --> 01:45:08.835
REQUEST- AND THE WORK THAT THE
01:45:08.902 --> 01:45:10.837
AUDITOR HAVE TO DO. CUT SO THEY
01:45:10.904 --> 01:45:12.406
GO FROM THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN
01:45:12.472 --> 01:45:14.941
SHE'S A- MORE COMFORTABLE WITH-
01:45:15.008 --> 01:45:16.943
THE AUDITOR DELAYING WHEN SHE
01:45:17.010 --> 01:45:18.578
ACTUALLY GOES INTO THE CITIES.
01:45:18.645 --> 01:45:19.813
BUT I THAT LET'S GO TO MOVE TO
01:45:19.880 --> 01:45:20.847
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS WILL COME
01:45:20.914 --> 01:45:21.882
BACK TO THIS BECAUSE SOUNDS
01:45:21.948 --> 01:45:23.550
LIKE SOMETHING WE'RE GONNA NEED
01:45:23.617 --> 01:45:26.987
TO COME BACK TO. REMOVED OKAY.
01:45:27.054 --> 01:45:28.388
SENATOR ROBB MISTER MISTER
01:45:28.455 --> 01:45:30.390
CHAIR I'D PLEASE CENTER MINING
01:45:30.457 --> 01:45:31.925
IS WILLING TO LET ME JUST
01:45:31.992 --> 01:45:33.527
SUPPLEMENT MY- COMMENT. I JUST
01:45:33.593 --> 01:45:34.695
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT I'M
01:45:34.761 --> 01:45:35.929
CLEAR ON THE RECORD ONE OF THE
01:45:35.996 --> 01:45:37.864
ADVANTAGES. TO ALLOWING
01:45:37.931 --> 01:45:40.033
RESPONDING ENTITIES TO BE
01:45:40.100 --> 01:45:40.767
PREPARED WHEN THEY COME IN
01:45:40.834 --> 01:45:43.370
HERE. IS WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY
01:45:43.437 --> 01:45:46.273
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING TO DEFINE
01:45:46.339 --> 01:45:48.842
THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT. AND
01:45:48.909 --> 01:45:50.444
WHEN WE DON'T HAVE A FULL PLATE
01:45:50.510 --> 01:45:52.279
OF INFORMATION. THAT'S
01:45:52.345 --> 01:45:53.980
PRESENTED ONE WAY OR THE OTHER
01:45:54.047 --> 01:45:55.549
WHEN WE VOTE TO APPROVE AN
01:45:55.615 --> 01:45:58.151
AUDIT OR NOT. WE DON'T HAVE AN
01:45:58.218 --> 01:45:59.786
OPPORTUNITY TO SHAPE THE SCOPE
01:45:59.853 --> 01:46:02.889
OF AN ART. AND THAT'S PART OF
01:46:02.956 --> 01:46:04.758
THE REASON WHY I'M INTERESTED
01:46:04.825 --> 01:46:05.826
IN DUE PROCESS WHY I WANT
01:46:05.892 --> 01:46:07.394
PEOPLE TO HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY
01:46:07.461 --> 01:46:08.795
TO HAVE ADEQUATE NOTICE TO COME
01:46:08.862 --> 01:46:10.097
IN HERE WITH THEIR BRIEF CASE
01:46:10.163 --> 01:46:11.998
FULL OF MATERIAL. AND TRY TO
01:46:12.065 --> 01:46:14.434
CONVINCE US. EITHER TO NOT VOTE
01:46:14.501 --> 01:46:16.369
FOR THE AUDIT OR TO VOTE FOR
01:46:16.436 --> 01:46:17.804
THE AUDIT AND TO VOTE FOR A
01:46:17.871 --> 01:46:20.207
FOCUSED ON IT. OR RESHAPE
01:46:20.273 --> 01:46:22.109
DOTTED AND THAT'S MY POINT
01:46:22.175 --> 01:46:23.210
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK
01:46:23.276 --> 01:46:24.177
YOU RESTAURANTS LET ME JUST ASK
01:46:24.244 --> 01:46:25.679
THE AUDITOR MAYBE THIS OP
01:46:25.746 --> 01:46:27.047
CLARIFY A LOT OF THINGS FOR A
01:46:27.114 --> 01:46:29.516
LOT OF FOLKS- MAN WATER YOU'RE-
01:46:29.583 --> 01:46:31.284
LOOKING AT THE SCOPE OF. MISS
01:46:31.351 --> 01:46:32.819
GARCIA'S LETTER DO YOU
01:46:32.886 --> 01:46:34.221
ANTICIPATE THAT EVEN CHANGING
01:46:34.287 --> 01:46:35.789
VERY MUCH EVEN IF WE ALLOWED
01:46:35.856 --> 01:46:37.491
ADDITIONAL TIME GIVEN THAT
01:46:37.557 --> 01:46:38.558
WE'RE ONLY LOOKING AT THE
01:46:38.625 --> 01:46:39.960
CONTRACTING IN CANNABIS
01:46:40.026 --> 01:46:44.064
LICENSING. I'D IN YOUR- HISTORY
01:46:44.131 --> 01:46:45.766
IN YOUR- EXPERIENCE HAVE YOU
01:46:45.832 --> 01:46:48.702
SEEN MUCH CHANGE. OVER THE
01:46:48.769 --> 01:46:49.336
COURSE OF A COUPLE MONTHS WELL
01:46:49.402 --> 01:46:51.438
AGAIN IT. WITH ALL DUE RESPECT
01:46:51.505 --> 01:46:53.173
IT'S A TO MEMBERS REQUESTS SO
01:46:53.240 --> 01:46:54.608
IF SHE WOULD HAVE TO BE
01:46:54.674 --> 01:46:56.843
CONVINCED BY THE CITIES. THAT
01:46:56.910 --> 01:46:59.212
THEY HAVE PROVIDED- APPROPRIATE
01:46:59.279 --> 01:47:02.182
MATERIALS TO HER AND HER STAFF.
01:47:02.249 --> 01:47:03.416
OUT TO CONVINCE HER THAT SHE
01:47:03.483 --> 01:47:05.118
DOESN'T FEEL THAT THERE NEEDS
01:47:05.185 --> 01:47:07.020
TO BE A STATE AUDITOR ARE AN
01:47:07.087 --> 01:47:09.422
AUDIT OF APPROVED BY THIS
01:47:09.489 --> 01:47:11.191
COMMITTEE DIRECTING MY OFFICE
01:47:11.258 --> 01:47:13.760
TO GO IN AND- ASSESS THEIR
01:47:13.827 --> 01:47:15.195
CONTRACTING PRACTICES AND
01:47:15.262 --> 01:47:15.929
ASSESS THEIR PERMITTING
01:47:15.996 --> 01:47:20.567
PRACTICES- WE CERTAINLY. WE
01:47:20.634 --> 01:47:22.469
TYPICALLY DON'T ENGAGE WITH AN
01:47:22.536 --> 01:47:25.238
ENTITY ARE IF AN ORDER IS AN
01:47:25.305 --> 01:47:27.107
APPROVED WE ARE GOING TO HAVE
01:47:27.174 --> 01:47:29.676
PLENTY OF WORK FOR US TO DO FOR
01:47:29.743 --> 01:47:32.479
THE AUDITS THAT THE COMMITTEE.
01:47:32.546 --> 01:47:34.614
APPROVES TODAY NOW CERTAINLY WE
01:47:34.681 --> 01:47:35.348
WANT TO BE OF SERVICE TO
01:47:35.415 --> 01:47:36.950
MEMBERS SO IF MS GARCIA'S
01:47:37.017 --> 01:47:39.052
OFFICE ENGAGES WITH THE CITIES
01:47:39.119 --> 01:47:40.687
SHE RECEIVED MATERIALS SHE
01:47:40.754 --> 01:47:43.757
CERTAINLY COULD ASK US TO TAKE
01:47:43.824 --> 01:47:44.658
A LOOK AT THE END. BUT IT WON'T
01:47:44.724 --> 01:47:46.493
BE BASED ON AN AUDIT IT'LL BE
01:47:46.560 --> 01:47:48.195
JUST BASED ON IN A REASONABLE
01:47:48.261 --> 01:47:51.932
PERSON- BUT SHE AGAIN- I KNOW
01:47:51.998 --> 01:47:53.266
I'M I'M NOT BEING EXTREMELY
01:47:53.333 --> 01:47:54.868
HELPFUL HERE IT'S THE MEMBERS
01:47:54.935 --> 01:47:56.970
REQUEST AND I CERTAINLY WANT TO
01:47:57.037 --> 01:47:58.939
RESPECT THAT. IT'S HER DECISION
01:47:59.005 --> 01:48:00.907
AS TO WHETHER OR NOT SHE'S
01:48:00.974 --> 01:48:02.409
CONVINCED THAT WHAT THE CITY
01:48:02.475 --> 01:48:03.677
PROVIDES IS SUFFICIENT TO
01:48:03.743 --> 01:48:06.947
ANSWER HER QUESTIONS OKAY THANK
01:48:07.013 --> 01:48:07.480
YOU ATWATER ASSEMBLY WOMAN
01:48:07.547 --> 01:48:11.051
PLEASE I THINK FOR MYSELF AND
01:48:11.117 --> 01:48:12.619
FOR THE COMMUNITY HAVING THAT
01:48:12.686 --> 01:48:13.286
THEIR PARTY IN THE- LA ME.
01:48:13.353 --> 01:48:16.456
LEANING X. TO AT THIS DOCUMENT
01:48:16.523 --> 01:48:18.358
CENTER ON MY QUESTION THIRTY
01:48:18.425 --> 01:48:19.492
SAID THE DOCUMENT THAT I WANT
01:48:19.559 --> 01:48:21.361
TO SEE AT AGAIN THAT'S
01:48:21.428 --> 01:48:23.063
SOMETHING THAT AN INDEPENDENT
01:48:23.129 --> 01:48:25.065
AUDIT WOULD GET TO AND A MUCH
01:48:25.131 --> 01:48:28.435
BETTER CAPACITY THEM MYSELF.
01:48:28.501 --> 01:48:29.769
UNDER OKAY THAT WE HAVE A OF
01:48:29.836 --> 01:48:30.670
COURSE SO FROM THE DíAS WE'RE
01:48:30.737 --> 01:48:32.205
GONNA MOVE TO REMINDING THEM
01:48:32.272 --> 01:48:33.173
ASSEMBLY WOMAN RUBIO THAN
01:48:33.240 --> 01:48:34.774
CENTER BORDERS. THANK YOU
01:48:34.841 --> 01:48:37.811
MISTER CHAIR. ON SO MY
01:48:37.878 --> 01:48:40.347
PREFERENCE WOULD BE THAT THE
01:48:40.413 --> 01:48:42.415
AUDIT REQUEST BE POSTPONED THAT
01:48:42.482 --> 01:48:46.853
THE- ASSEMBLYMEMBER MEET WITH
01:48:46.920 --> 01:48:49.556
THE CITIES AND ENGAGE WITH THE
01:48:49.623 --> 01:48:52.559
CITY'S WITH HER QUESTIONS AND
01:48:52.626 --> 01:48:56.296
IF NOT SATISFIED RETURN. TO
01:48:56.363 --> 01:48:58.498
REQUEST THE AUDIT FROM THIS
01:48:58.565 --> 01:49:01.935
COMMITTEE. MY CONCERN OF
01:49:02.002 --> 01:49:03.570
GRANTING THE ON IT TODAY AND
01:49:03.637 --> 01:49:05.705
THEN POSTPONING IT IS THAT
01:49:05.772 --> 01:49:07.707
THERE'S THE CITY WAS HER REYES
01:49:07.774 --> 01:49:10.110
TO POTENTIAL ADVERSE IMPACT IN
01:49:10.176 --> 01:49:12.445
TERMS OF A COMING BALLOT
01:49:12.512 --> 01:49:14.547
MEASURES- POTENTIAL
01:49:14.614 --> 01:49:17.050
MISINTERPRETATION OF HEADLINES
01:49:17.117 --> 01:49:19.552
ABOUT A STATE ON IT. THAT COULD
01:49:19.619 --> 01:49:21.054
ADVERSELY IMPACT THOSE
01:49:21.121 --> 01:49:23.056
COMMUNITIES AND I JUST WANT TO
01:49:23.123 --> 01:49:24.624
ECHO THE CONCERNS RAISED BY
01:49:24.691 --> 01:49:26.192
BOTH SENATOR GONZALEZ AND
01:49:26.259 --> 01:49:27.961
SENATOR ROTH. THE WHOLE
01:49:28.028 --> 01:49:31.398
QUESTION OF DUE PROCESS I JUST
01:49:31.464 --> 01:49:32.499
THESE AUDITS KOSTELANETZ MY TAX
01:49:32.565 --> 01:49:35.035
ARE FOOTING THE BILL FOR IT AND
01:49:35.101 --> 01:49:35.936
I DON'T SEE WHY ANYONE WOULD
01:49:36.002 --> 01:49:38.338
REQUEST AN AUDIT BEFORE ASKING
01:49:38.405 --> 01:49:41.007
THE QUESTIONS TO THE ENTITY.
01:49:41.074 --> 01:49:41.908
THAT THEY WANT TO AUDIT IT JUST
01:49:41.975 --> 01:49:44.411
SEEMS LIKE THAT'S A LOGICAL
01:49:44.477 --> 01:49:47.347
FIRST STEP SO- I WILL BE NOT
01:49:47.414 --> 01:49:51.051
VOTING- FOR AN AUDIT TO BE.
01:49:51.117 --> 01:49:53.787
GENERATED TODAY I'LL BE GLAD TO
01:49:53.853 --> 01:49:54.854
WORK WITH THE PARTIES IN THE
01:49:54.921 --> 01:49:56.823
CHAIR ON IN TERMS OF TIME
01:49:56.890 --> 01:49:59.859
TABLE. ONCE THE COURTESY OF
01:49:59.926 --> 01:50:02.095
MEETING WITH THE CITY'S HAS
01:50:02.162 --> 01:50:04.397
BEEN AFFORDED THANK YOU. THANK
01:50:04.464 --> 01:50:06.199
YOU SENATOR MOUNTING KIT ON
01:50:06.266 --> 01:50:08.368
BELIEVE THOSE QUESTION AND THAT
01:50:08.435 --> 01:50:08.935
WILL MOVE TO ASSEMBLY WOMAN
01:50:09.002 --> 01:50:12.839
REVIEW. THANK YOU- SO FOR ME-
01:50:12.906 --> 01:50:14.474
AND I UNDERSTAND THAT TIME
01:50:14.541 --> 01:50:15.909
ISSUE BECAUSE THIS COMMITTEE
01:50:15.976 --> 01:50:17.477
THE MEAT ON A MONTHLY BASIS
01:50:17.544 --> 01:50:18.712
LIKE MOST OF THE OTHER
01:50:18.778 --> 01:50:20.914
COMMITTEE SO I UNDERSTAND WHY
01:50:20.981 --> 01:50:21.848
WAITING TO AUGUST WOULD BE A
01:50:21.915 --> 01:50:24.651
DIFFICULT- I THINK WE CAN COME
01:50:24.718 --> 01:50:26.553
TO MIDDLE GROUND- TO ADDRESS
01:50:26.619 --> 01:50:28.121
THE POINT OF OUR MEETING WITH
01:50:28.188 --> 01:50:29.856
THE CITIES. TO QUITE HONEST I
01:50:29.923 --> 01:50:31.358
DON'T KNOW WHICH QUESTIONS TO
01:50:31.424 --> 01:50:34.260
ASK IF I WENT TO A CITY- AND OR
01:50:34.327 --> 01:50:36.663
WHEN I HAVE ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS
01:50:36.730 --> 01:50:38.965
THAT ARE PERHAPS ONLY THE
01:50:39.032 --> 01:50:40.700
AUDITOR HAS ACCESS TO SELL TO
01:50:40.767 --> 01:50:42.102
YOUR POINT I APPRECIATE THAT
01:50:42.168 --> 01:50:44.304
COMMENT HOWEVER IF I AM. YOU
01:50:44.371 --> 01:50:45.705
KNOW TRYING TO AUDIT WHEN MY
01:50:45.772 --> 01:50:47.774
CITIES WERE I DON'T KNOW WHICH
01:50:47.841 --> 01:50:50.343
DOCUMENTS I WOULD NEED- I CAN
01:50:50.410 --> 01:50:52.445
GIVE YOU WILL- EXAMPLES OF WHY
01:50:52.512 --> 01:50:54.280
I THINK I'M NOT SHOULD BE-
01:50:54.347 --> 01:50:55.915
CONDUCTED BUT I WOULDN'T KNOW
01:50:55.982 --> 01:50:58.018
WHICH DOCUMENTS I WOULD NEED SO
01:50:58.084 --> 01:50:59.486
IN TERMS OF MEETING WITH THE
01:50:59.552 --> 01:51:01.654
CITIES I BELIEVE THAT- IF WE
01:51:01.721 --> 01:51:03.790
APPROVE AN AUDIT AND POSTPONE
01:51:03.857 --> 01:51:04.791
IT I THINK THE CITIES WOULD
01:51:04.858 --> 01:51:06.726
HAVE AN- OPPORTUNITY TO.
01:51:06.793 --> 01:51:08.928
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS AND NOW HE
01:51:08.995 --> 01:51:12.132
ASSEMBLY WOMAN WOULD HAVE THE
01:51:12.198 --> 01:51:16.636
AUDITOR'S YEAR IF YOU WILL TO
01:51:16.703 --> 01:51:17.270
BE ABLE TO. GUY THAT AND WHY.
01:51:17.337 --> 01:51:19.606
YOU KNOW BUT- OUT. FORMS OF
01:51:19.672 --> 01:51:21.674
TARA. QUESTIONS DOES ASSEMBLY
01:51:21.741 --> 01:51:22.208
WOMAN COULD NOT THAT'S IN
01:51:22.275 --> 01:51:23.977
OPINION I'M AND AGAIN REASON
01:51:24.044 --> 01:51:26.846
FOR POSTPONING WOULD BE THAT-
01:51:26.913 --> 01:51:27.981
WE DON'T MEET ON A REGULAR
01:51:28.048 --> 01:51:30.283
BASIS WE MEET UNTIL AUGUST AND
01:51:30.350 --> 01:51:32.118
SO THAT'S THE TIME CONSTRAINT
01:51:32.185 --> 01:51:35.388
ISSUES SO I AM IN FAVOR OF. OUR
01:51:35.455 --> 01:51:37.123
VOTING FOR THE AUDITS OF BY
01:51:37.190 --> 01:51:38.458
POSTPONING IT SO TO GIVE THE
01:51:38.525 --> 01:51:39.859
OPPORTUNITY TO THIS FOR THE
01:51:39.926 --> 01:51:42.228
CITIES TO RESPOND AND AT LEAST
01:51:42.295 --> 01:51:43.596
THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN WILL HAVE-
01:51:43.663 --> 01:51:45.298
THE AUDITOR KIND OF AS A
01:51:45.365 --> 01:51:47.133
SOUNDING BOARD OR BECAUSE NOW
01:51:47.200 --> 01:51:49.936
THE AUDIT IS YOU KNOW BOB.
01:51:50.003 --> 01:51:51.438
APPROVED IF THAT'S SOMETHING
01:51:51.504 --> 01:51:54.374
THAT- THE AUDITOR CAN DO PLEASE
01:51:54.441 --> 01:51:57.243
CLARIFY IF YOU CAN'T THEN BEEN
01:51:57.310 --> 01:51:57.811
MY WHOLE ARGUMENT IS OUT THE
01:51:57.877 --> 01:52:01.915
WINDOW. THE SHERMAN. LEASE SO
01:52:01.981 --> 01:52:03.083
IT SOUNDS LIKE A LOT OF
01:52:03.149 --> 01:52:04.417
DISCUSSION NEEDS TO HAPPEN ON
01:52:04.484 --> 01:52:06.719
THIS- FAIRLY QUICKLY BUT LET'S
01:52:06.786 --> 01:52:08.721
GO AHEAD AND I DIDN'T HEAR A
01:52:08.788 --> 01:52:10.590
QUESTION THERE SO LET'S GO TO.
01:52:10.657 --> 01:52:13.193
PLEASE ATWATER SO IF THE
01:52:13.259 --> 01:52:14.694
COMMITTEE APPROVES AND AGAIN
01:52:14.761 --> 01:52:16.262
THAT THE COMMITTEE HAS ALLEGE
01:52:16.329 --> 01:52:18.198
COUNSEL TO ADVISE ON COMMITTEE
01:52:18.264 --> 01:52:20.200
RULES BUT THE WHAT THE
01:52:20.266 --> 01:52:22.802
COMMITTEE APPROVES TODAY- WOULD
01:52:22.869 --> 01:52:23.870
BE THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT THAT
01:52:23.937 --> 01:52:25.672
WE WOULD DO- IF THERE'S
01:52:25.738 --> 01:52:26.573
SOMETHING THAT COMES TO OUR
01:52:26.639 --> 01:52:27.740
ATTENTION DURING THE COURSE OF
01:52:27.807 --> 01:52:28.875
THE AUDIT LIKE WE TALKED ABOUT
01:52:28.942 --> 01:52:30.810
THE PREVIOUS AUDIT ON ON TOXICS
01:52:30.877 --> 01:52:31.744
WHERE WE WOULD LOOK AT COST
01:52:31.811 --> 01:52:33.279
RECOVERY IF SOMETHING CAME TO
01:52:33.346 --> 01:52:34.481
OUR ATTENTION WE COULD EXPAND
01:52:34.547 --> 01:52:36.282
THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT BUT WHAT
01:52:36.349 --> 01:52:38.952
WE WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO DO IS.
01:52:39.018 --> 01:52:40.720
IF THIS AUDIT GETS APPROVED-
01:52:40.787 --> 01:52:42.322
PERHAPS IT'S DELAYED WE DON'T
01:52:42.388 --> 01:52:43.890
START UNTIL JUNE THIS WOULD BE
01:52:43.957 --> 01:52:45.925
THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT NOW WE
01:52:45.992 --> 01:52:47.627
WOULD BENEFIT FROM IF THE CITY
01:52:47.694 --> 01:52:48.962
BELIEVES THEY HAVE A LOT OF
01:52:49.028 --> 01:52:50.730
ANSWERS TO THESE QUESTIONS THAT
01:52:50.797 --> 01:52:52.298
WOULD REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF TIME
01:52:52.365 --> 01:52:53.199
IT WOULD TAKE US TO CONDUCT THE
01:52:53.266 --> 01:52:55.168
AUDIT IT WOULD REDUCE THE COST
01:52:55.235 --> 01:52:56.870
OBVIOUSLY- BUT WE WOULDN'T
01:52:56.936 --> 01:52:59.038
NECESSARILY BE ENGAGING WITH MS
01:52:59.105 --> 01:53:02.942
GARCIA- AS FAR AS OKAY THEY
01:53:03.009 --> 01:53:03.710
CITY HAS TOLD US THIS DO YOU
01:53:03.776 --> 01:53:04.911
HAVE ANY ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
01:53:04.978 --> 01:53:06.880
THAT NOT HOW THE PROCESS WORKS
01:53:06.946 --> 01:53:08.982
ONCE THIS. THIS PROPOSAL THAT
01:53:09.048 --> 01:53:10.517
WE PUT TOGETHER ANALYSIS THAT
01:53:10.583 --> 01:53:11.217
WE PUT TOGETHER FOR THE
01:53:11.284 --> 01:53:15.155
COMMITTEE HAS APPROVED. THIS-BASICALLY DICTATES. THE WORK
01:53:15.221 --> 01:53:16.723
THAT WE WOULD DO WE CERTAINLY
01:53:16.789 --> 01:53:18.057
CAN DELAY COMMENCING THE AUDIT
01:53:18.124 --> 01:53:20.193
AND AGAIN. IF THE CITY'S
01:53:20.260 --> 01:53:22.395
RESPECTFULLY HAVE INFORMATION
01:53:22.462 --> 01:53:24.430
THAT THEY BELIEVE WOULD.
01:53:24.497 --> 01:53:25.798
CONVINCE US THAT ALL OF THESE
01:53:25.865 --> 01:53:27.834
PROCESSES ARE TERRIFIC THEN WE
01:53:27.901 --> 01:53:29.202
WHAT WE TYPICALLY DO WHEN WE
01:53:29.269 --> 01:53:30.670
CONDUCTED NOT IF WE GET INTO AN
01:53:30.737 --> 01:53:31.704
ENTITY AND WE SAY WE'RE GONNA
01:53:31.771 --> 01:53:34.040
TEST THIRTY ITEMS. AND WE TEST
01:53:34.107 --> 01:53:35.141
FIFTEEN WE FIND NO PROBLEMS
01:53:35.208 --> 01:53:36.176
IT'S LIKE WE'RE NOT GOING TO
01:53:36.242 --> 01:53:37.944
WASTE TIME TESTING ANOTHER
01:53:38.011 --> 01:53:38.912
FIFTEEN WE WANT TO KEEP THESE
01:53:38.978 --> 01:53:40.079
AUDITS AS COST EFFECTIVE AS
01:53:40.146 --> 01:53:42.015
POSSIBLE SO THAT'S THE APPROACH
01:53:42.081 --> 01:53:43.416
WE WOULD TAKE IN CONDUCTING THE
01:53:43.483 --> 01:53:44.284
ON IT TRYING TO REDUCE THE
01:53:44.350 --> 01:53:45.919
AMOUNT OF. A COST BECAUSE WE
01:53:45.985 --> 01:53:47.787
ARE VERY SENSITIVE TO YOU KNOW
01:53:47.854 --> 01:53:49.489
THE EXPENSE OF THESE AUDITS ON
01:53:49.556 --> 01:53:50.323
WE THINK THEY'RE VALUABLE
01:53:50.390 --> 01:53:52.592
OBVIOUSLY- BUT THAT'S THAT'S
01:53:52.659 --> 01:53:53.927
WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF THE AUDITS
01:53:53.993 --> 01:53:56.563
APPROVED THIS WOULD ESSENTIALLY
01:53:56.629 --> 01:53:57.163
BE THE SCOPE OF THE WORK. THAT
01:53:57.230 --> 01:54:01.701
WE WOULD DO. CUT. YEAH AND
01:54:01.768 --> 01:54:02.936
TYPICALLY WHAT WE DO IN
01:54:03.002 --> 01:54:04.737
COMMITTEE IS- WILL WE MAKE THE
01:54:04.804 --> 01:54:06.339
MOTION WE WOULD ASK FOR A
01:54:06.406 --> 01:54:08.841
DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
01:54:08.908 --> 01:54:09.442
STATE AUDITOR MOVING IN WHICH
01:54:09.509 --> 01:54:12.145
WILL. MOST LIKELY DO WITH ONE
01:54:12.212 --> 01:54:12.712
ANOTHER ITEM THAT'S ALREADY
01:54:12.779 --> 01:54:14.147
BEEN AGREED TO LATER ON IN OUR
01:54:14.214 --> 01:54:17.016
AGENDA. SO WITH THAT WE'RE
01:54:17.083 --> 01:54:18.284
GOING TO MOVE TO CENTER BORE
01:54:18.351 --> 01:54:21.087
JUST REPLACE THANK CHAIRMAN WAS
01:54:21.154 --> 01:54:22.722
ANTICIPATING A COMMENTING ON
01:54:22.789 --> 01:54:24.457
THIS BUT THERE. WERE IN THERE'S
01:54:24.524 --> 01:54:26.092
BEEN A NUMBER OF ISSUES PUT
01:54:26.159 --> 01:54:28.027
FORWARD THAT I THINK. HAS
01:54:28.094 --> 01:54:30.463
CAUSED ME TO QUESTION. THE ROLE
01:54:30.530 --> 01:54:32.932
OF THIS BODY AND WHAT THE
01:54:32.999 --> 01:54:35.168
APPROPRIATE PROCESS SEES ARE.
01:54:35.235 --> 01:54:37.570
INTUITIVELY I WOULD THINK THAT
01:54:37.637 --> 01:54:40.707
AN AUDIT WOULD BE APPROPRIATE.
01:54:40.773 --> 01:54:41.941
WHEN AT A COUPLE THINGS HAVE
01:54:42.008 --> 01:54:44.344
ALREADY OCCURRED NAMELY THAT
01:54:44.410 --> 01:54:47.847
INFORMATION SAW IT HAS NOT BEEN
01:54:47.914 --> 01:54:50.650
PRODUCED. ANSWER QUESTIONS
01:54:50.717 --> 01:54:54.320
POSED HAVE NOT ALLOWED FOR-
01:54:54.387 --> 01:54:58.091
COMPETENT ANSWERS. OR A LAYER
01:54:58.157 --> 01:55:00.593
OF SURFACE- CERTAIN LAYERS OF
01:55:00.660 --> 01:55:02.795
SOPHISTICATION ARE REQUIRED ON
01:55:02.862 --> 01:55:06.933
THAT ARE OUTSIDE THE DOMAIN OF
01:55:07.000 --> 01:55:09.068
A GIVEN LEGISLATIVE OFFICE I
01:55:09.135 --> 01:55:10.737
THINK THAT'S ON THOSE ARE NOT
01:55:10.803 --> 01:55:13.373
ON FAIR I THINK. PRESUMPTIONS
01:55:13.439 --> 01:55:16.009
TO MAKE BEFORE IT ELEVATES TOOL
01:55:16.075 --> 01:55:17.944
FOR FULL FLEDGED USE OF
01:55:18.011 --> 01:55:19.612
TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO REVIEW
01:55:19.679 --> 01:55:22.215
SOMETHING IN IN DETAIL AND I
01:55:22.282 --> 01:55:24.217
COME FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENT ON
01:55:24.284 --> 01:55:27.153
BEFORE I- BEFORE I CAME TO THE
01:55:27.220 --> 01:55:29.489
SENATE. AND I THINK THAT THERE
01:55:29.555 --> 01:55:31.157
IS SOMETHING TO BE SAID ABOUT
01:55:31.224 --> 01:55:33.526
RESPECTING. IN GOING THROUGH A
01:55:33.593 --> 01:55:36.029
PROCESS OF A WIN- CERTAIN
01:55:36.095 --> 01:55:38.765
INDIVIDUALS REPRESENT AREAS
01:55:38.831 --> 01:55:39.632
THAT ARE GOING TO BE THE
01:55:39.699 --> 01:55:44.070
SUBJECT OF AN AUDIT ON. NOT
01:55:44.137 --> 01:55:45.305
JUST WITH THIS ISSUE I MEAN
01:55:45.371 --> 01:55:46.706
THERE'S ONE THAT'S GONNA BE
01:55:46.773 --> 01:55:48.741
COMING UP ON ITEM ONE OH TWO
01:55:48.808 --> 01:55:50.543
THAT WE WERE ONLY RECENTLY MADE
01:55:50.610 --> 01:55:54.080
AWARE OF ON THAT MY- THE AREA
01:55:54.147 --> 01:55:55.481
THAT I REPRESENT WILL BE THE
01:55:55.548 --> 01:55:57.550
SUBJECT OF AN AUDIT. I THINK WE
01:55:57.617 --> 01:55:59.686
HEARD FROM THE SENATOR A MOMENT
01:55:59.752 --> 01:56:00.753
AGO THAT SAID IT WOULD HAVE
01:56:00.820 --> 01:56:02.355
BEEN VERY HELPFUL TO HAVE
01:56:02.422 --> 01:56:04.691
GOTTEN A HEADS UP AND MAYBE
01:56:04.757 --> 01:56:05.525
QUESTIONS COULD HAVE BEEN
01:56:05.591 --> 01:56:08.161
POSED. PRIOR TO THAT IN ANSWERS
01:56:08.227 --> 01:56:11.264
GOTTEN- SO I THINK THE WRIST
01:56:11.331 --> 01:56:12.699
THERE'S A DUE PROCESS RESPECT
01:56:12.765 --> 01:56:14.434
FACTOR THAT I THINK IS
01:56:14.500 --> 01:56:15.735
SOMETHING THAT SHOULD NOT BE
01:56:15.802 --> 01:56:17.503
OVERLOOKED. BUT ALSO GIVEN THE
01:56:17.570 --> 01:56:19.272
FACT THAT IF WE'RE GOING TO
01:56:19.339 --> 01:56:20.740
ELEVATE SOMETHING TO AN AUDIT
01:56:20.807 --> 01:56:22.475
IT SAYS THAT THE INDIVIDUAL
01:56:22.542 --> 01:56:24.243
REQUESTING IT OR THE OFFICE
01:56:24.310 --> 01:56:25.945
REQUESTING IT. WITH A GROUP OF
01:56:26.012 --> 01:56:27.914
INDIVIDUALS REQUESTING IT THAT
01:56:27.980 --> 01:56:29.282
THEY PUT FORWARD THE DUE
01:56:29.349 --> 01:56:32.118
DILIGENCE TO GET ANSWERS TO
01:56:32.185 --> 01:56:33.986
THEIR QUESTIONS SPEAK WITH YOUR
01:56:34.053 --> 01:56:35.555
WITH ALL PARTIES IN THIS IS A
01:56:35.621 --> 01:56:37.790
CITY OR TWO. AND IF THEY CAN'T
01:56:37.857 --> 01:56:40.126
GET IT THEN IT BATES WORE THE
01:56:40.193 --> 01:56:44.364
LAYER OVER THE AMOUNT OF CITY
01:56:44.430 --> 01:56:46.065
CATION ON THE ISSUE REQUIRES
01:56:46.132 --> 01:56:48.768
THE INVOCATION OF ODD THE
01:56:48.835 --> 01:56:51.371
DEPARTMENT ON THOSE HERE SO
01:56:51.437 --> 01:56:52.071
WITH THAT BEING SAID. I'M
01:56:52.138 --> 01:56:55.074
SENSITIVE TO THE IDEA THAT-
01:56:55.141 --> 01:56:57.143
THERE MIGHT BE A TIMING ISSUE
01:56:57.210 --> 01:56:59.145
BUT BEAUSE IT THERE IS A DUE
01:56:59.212 --> 01:57:00.980
PROCESS THAT I THINK IS NOT
01:57:01.047 --> 01:57:03.916
BEEN FOLLOWED HERE JUST YET THE
01:57:03.983 --> 01:57:06.352
IDEA OF LAYING OUT. ON LIVE
01:57:06.419 --> 01:57:07.353
AGAIN SUMS OF TAXPAYER DOLLARS
01:57:07.420 --> 01:57:12.492
SEEMS SLIGHTLY MATURE SO WHY
01:57:12.558 --> 01:57:16.129
WOULD I WOULD RESPECT TO WISH
01:57:16.195 --> 01:57:18.631
UP. ON THIS SPOKE EARLIER.
01:57:18.698 --> 01:57:20.800
MAYBE I COME BACK THE PROBE I'M
01:57:20.867 --> 01:57:21.834
IN ALL. IF THE DO YOU DILIGENCE
01:57:21.901 --> 01:57:22.468
THAT SHOULD PUT FOR INTO INTO
01:57:22.535 --> 01:57:23.669
PRO. DOES NOT YIELD A RESULT TO
01:57:23.736 --> 01:57:26.339
ME TO. THANK CENTER BORDERS
01:57:26.406 --> 01:57:30.743
LET'S GO TO BACK TO CENTER ROTH.
01:57:30.810 --> 01:57:31.644
YOU KNOW I OBVIOUSLY ALIGN MY
01:57:31.711 --> 01:57:33.212
COMMENTS WITH MY COLLEAGUES
01:57:33.279 --> 01:57:36.816
GOOD. WHO JUST SPOKE I JUST
01:57:36.883 --> 01:57:37.750
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT I'M
01:57:37.817 --> 01:57:40.520
CLEAR ON THIS AND UNFORTUNATELY
01:57:40.586 --> 01:57:41.287
ASSEMBLY MEMBER YOU HAPPEN TO
01:57:41.354 --> 01:57:43.423
BE IN MY- LINE OF SIGHT AND
01:57:43.489 --> 01:57:44.590
UNFORTUNATELY IT'S THIS
01:57:44.657 --> 01:57:47.994
PARTICULAR AUDIT- IT IS NOT
01:57:48.060 --> 01:57:50.563
ACCEPTABLE TO ME. THAT AN AUDIT
01:57:50.630 --> 01:57:53.132
REQUEST COMES IN HERE IMPACTING
01:57:53.199 --> 01:57:55.735
A LOCAL JURISDICTION. WHEN THE
01:57:55.802 --> 01:57:57.437
COLLEAGUES WHO REPRESENTS A
01:57:57.503 --> 01:58:00.640
JURISDICTION IS NOT MADE AWARE
01:58:00.706 --> 01:58:03.075
OF THE OTHER REQUEST ONE. TWO
01:58:03.142 --> 01:58:04.777
IT'S NOT ACCEPTABLE TO ME WHEN
01:58:04.844 --> 01:58:06.179
THE PEOPLE THAT ARE HAVING THE
01:58:06.245 --> 01:58:07.680
ENTITIES THAT ARE HAVING TO
01:58:07.747 --> 01:58:09.615
RESPOND TO THE OTHER REQUEST.
01:58:09.682 --> 01:58:11.551
GET ONE WEEK'S NOTICE.
01:58:11.617 --> 01:58:12.718
REGARDLESS OF WHAT WE FEEL
01:58:12.785 --> 01:58:14.020
ABOUT THE CONTENT OF THE
01:58:14.086 --> 01:58:15.521
REQUEST REGARDLESS OF HOW WE
01:58:15.588 --> 01:58:17.523
COME IN HERE. THINKING THAT
01:58:17.590 --> 01:58:19.358
WE'RE GONNA VOTE REGARDLESS OF
01:58:19.425 --> 01:58:21.260
WHAT WE THINK WE'RE GONNA VOTE
01:58:21.327 --> 01:58:21.794
AFTER WE HEAR THE INITIAL
01:58:21.861 --> 01:58:24.864
RESPONSE. I THINK IS A BODY WE
01:58:24.931 --> 01:58:26.098
HAVE AN OBLIGATION TO MAKE SURE
01:58:26.165 --> 01:58:28.267
THAT MEANT THAT. ENTITIES AND
01:58:28.334 --> 01:58:30.369
INDIVIDUALS WHO DID WHO DO NOT
01:58:30.436 --> 01:58:32.505
SERVE HERE. THINK THAT WE SERVE
01:58:32.572 --> 01:58:35.741
HERE AT. A PROPERLY AND THAT WE
01:58:35.808 --> 01:58:36.876
HAVE CORD PEOPLE WHO COME
01:58:36.943 --> 01:58:39.245
BEFORE US. THE APPROPRIATE
01:58:39.312 --> 01:58:42.448
AMOUNT OF DUE PROCESS. DURING
01:58:42.515 --> 01:58:44.817
OUR DELIBERATIONS. HI WILL
01:58:44.884 --> 01:58:47.720
UNLESS THINGS CHANGE IN THE
01:58:47.787 --> 01:58:48.354
NEXT FEW MINUTES I WILL NOT BE
01:58:48.421 --> 01:58:51.691
VOTING- TO SUPPORT THE AUDIT
01:58:51.757 --> 01:58:54.727
TODAY. I WOULD SUPPORT A MOVE
01:58:54.794 --> 01:58:57.096
OF THE AUDIT TO THE NEXT. I THE
01:58:57.163 --> 01:58:58.464
REGULARLY SCHEDULED OR
01:58:58.531 --> 01:59:01.434
SPECIALLY SET. A MEETING OF THE
01:59:01.501 --> 01:59:02.602
JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
01:59:02.668 --> 01:59:04.036
COMMITTEE AND I'M IN FAVOR OF
01:59:04.103 --> 01:59:05.505
SPECIALLY SETTING AN AUDIT TO
01:59:05.571 --> 01:59:08.074
HEAR YOUR PARTICULAR REQUEST.
01:59:08.140 --> 01:59:09.609
AFTER WE GIVE THE INDIVIDUAL
01:59:09.675 --> 01:59:10.943
THE ENTITIES INVOLVED AN
01:59:11.010 --> 01:59:12.144
ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF TIME
01:59:12.211 --> 01:59:13.846
WHATEVER THAT ISTO BE
01:59:13.913 --> 01:59:16.249
DETERMINED BY YOU. TO COME IN
01:59:16.315 --> 01:59:17.617
HERE AND RESPOND TO THE OTHER
01:59:17.683 --> 01:59:19.252
REQUEST THE OUTCOME MAY VERY
01:59:19.318 --> 01:59:21.120
WELL BE THE SAME BUT IT'S THE
01:59:21.187 --> 01:59:23.256
OPTIC IT'S IMPORTANT TO ME. AND
01:59:23.322 --> 01:59:25.224
I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:59:25.291 --> 01:59:25.791
TO THE EXTENT THAT I WASN'T
01:59:25.858 --> 01:59:28.828
CLEAR. THAT I WAS FUZZY IN MY
01:59:28.895 --> 01:59:30.596
COMMENTS BEFORE AND IT HAS I
01:59:30.663 --> 01:59:32.198
HAVE ABSOLUTE RESPECT FOR WHAT
01:59:32.265 --> 01:59:33.833
YOU DO AND FOR THIS OTHER
01:59:33.900 --> 01:59:35.835
REQUEST. I JUST THINK WE NEED
01:59:35.902 --> 01:59:37.436
TO DO A LITTLE BIT BETTER ON
01:59:37.503 --> 01:59:39.238
THIS ONE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
01:59:39.305 --> 01:59:41.574
THANK YOU CENTER ROTH OKAY WITH
01:59:41.641 --> 01:59:43.676
THAT LET'S GO AHEAD AND- I
01:59:43.743 --> 01:59:45.111
DON'T KNOW IF I'D SIMPLY WOMAN
01:59:45.177 --> 01:59:46.646
YOU LIKED RESPOND IF THAT WILL
01:59:46.712 --> 01:59:47.947
GO TO MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENT.
01:59:48.014 --> 01:59:50.950
ABOUT ALSO DOES THE SURPLUS AND
01:59:51.017 --> 01:59:52.051
ACTUALLY AND LEAVE WE'VE BEEN
01:59:52.118 --> 01:59:53.653
HERE FOR AWHILE I THINK WHEN WE
01:59:53.719 --> 01:59:54.654
TALK ABOUT THE LEVEL OF
01:59:54.720 --> 01:59:56.722
SOPHISTICATION I MEAN I HAVE
01:59:56.789 --> 01:59:57.490
GONE ONLINE TO LOOK AT WITHOUT
01:59:57.557 --> 02:00:00.259
THEIR- AND BEEN TRACKING STUFF
02:00:00.326 --> 02:00:01.594
AND- IT'S GOTTEN TO THAT POINT
02:00:01.661 --> 02:00:02.995
OF LEVELS OF THE KIDS THAT THIS
02:00:03.062 --> 02:00:04.630
OCCASION WHERE IT'S BEYOND. MY
02:00:04.697 --> 02:00:05.965
ABILITY AND I THINK ALSO THE
02:00:06.032 --> 02:00:07.533
POINT OF WANTING TO HAVE
02:00:07.600 --> 02:00:09.101
SOMETHING THAT INDEPENDENT OF
02:00:09.168 --> 02:00:10.937
US RIGHT AND I COULD HAVE A-
02:00:11.003 --> 02:00:12.672
DIFFERENT PROFESSIONAL. LAND SO
02:00:12.738 --> 02:00:15.508
I WOULD SAY TO THAT TO THE-
02:00:15.575 --> 02:00:17.577
PROCESS TO THE AFFECTED
02:00:17.643 --> 02:00:20.413
AGENCIES I JUST ASSUME THAT THE
02:00:20.479 --> 02:00:21.747
COMMITTEE WOULD GIVE THEM.
02:00:21.814 --> 02:00:22.615
THROUGH THEIR PROCESS THAT
02:00:22.682 --> 02:00:24.684
WOULD HAPPEN AND- YOU KNOW WHAT
02:00:24.750 --> 02:00:26.052
THAT PROCESS IS A SOFTWARE THAT
02:00:26.118 --> 02:00:28.621
THE SEPARATE CONVERSATION- TO
02:00:28.688 --> 02:00:32.158
THE- TO MY CONVERSATIONS- AND
02:00:32.224 --> 02:00:32.892
WHAT I COULD HAVE SHOULD HAVE
02:00:32.959 --> 02:00:34.860
DONE. MISTER ROCK THANK YOU FOR
02:00:34.927 --> 02:00:38.431
YOUR- CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM OF
02:00:38.497 --> 02:00:41.067
THINGS THAT I SHOULD WORK ON.
02:00:41.133 --> 02:00:41.968
TIMES OUGHT WITH MY CITY OF
02:00:42.034 --> 02:00:43.202
COMMERCE WEEK I HAVE BEEN IN
02:00:43.269 --> 02:00:44.236
COMMUNICATION WITH COUNCIL
02:00:44.303 --> 02:00:46.305
MEMBERS AT DIFFERENT TIMES- AND
02:00:46.372 --> 02:00:47.440
IT'S FOR ME IS THAT THIS
02:00:47.506 --> 02:00:48.674
PROLIFERATION IS MOVING SO
02:00:48.741 --> 02:00:50.743
QUICKLY. THAT I HAVE CONCERNS
02:00:50.810 --> 02:00:51.844
AND I DO HAVE CONCERNS WAITING
02:00:51.911 --> 02:00:53.546
UNTIL AUGUST I'M NOT TO TRY TO
02:00:53.613 --> 02:00:55.348
GET TO CALL WHEN HEARINGS
02:00:55.414 --> 02:00:57.016
HAPPENED OF THEIR SPECIAL OR
02:00:57.083 --> 02:01:00.586
NOT WITH THAT. OKAY THANK YOU
02:01:00.653 --> 02:01:01.654
SOMEBODY WOMAN THAT THIS TIME
02:01:01.721 --> 02:01:03.589
LET'S GO AHEAD AND I. ASK
02:01:03.656 --> 02:01:04.323
THERE'S ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
02:01:04.390 --> 02:01:06.125
FROM THE DíAS HEARING. AND
02:01:06.192 --> 02:01:08.127
SEEING THAT LET'S GO TO MOVE TO
02:01:08.194 --> 02:01:11.197
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM.
02:01:11.263 --> 02:01:12.632
THERE IS THERE ANY PUBLIC
02:01:12.698 --> 02:01:15.501
COMMENT HEARING AND SEEING. NON
02:01:15.568 --> 02:01:17.770
ALTERNATE BACK. TO MEMBERS OF
02:01:17.837 --> 02:01:19.972
THE DICE. SIMILAR AND WOULD YOU
02:01:20.039 --> 02:01:21.340
LIKE TO CLOSE. I YOU KNOW I
02:01:21.407 --> 02:01:25.945
THINK. THE MIDDLE OF THE ROAD
02:01:26.012 --> 02:01:27.179
THAT'S BEEN PROPOSED FOR IT TO
02:01:27.246 --> 02:01:28.881
BE BY SOME FOLKS I'VE I'VE
02:01:28.948 --> 02:01:30.549
HEARD VERY AND THINGS RIGHT TO
02:01:30.616 --> 02:01:32.618
VOTE Y SOME FOLKS TO APPROVE
02:01:32.685 --> 02:01:35.187
THE AUDIT BUT WAIT- DELAYED
02:01:35.254 --> 02:01:36.922
WHEN THE UTTER BEGAN TO WORK
02:01:36.989 --> 02:01:37.490
SOMETHING AND I'M OKAY WITH
02:01:37.556 --> 02:01:38.557
THAT I DON'T THINK THAT THAT'S
02:01:38.624 --> 02:01:40.359
GOING TO CHANGE. MY PERSPECTIVE
02:01:40.426 --> 02:01:41.494
IN ME GETTING TO THAT POINT
02:01:41.560 --> 02:01:42.528
WORK THAT THEY'LL ALL WHY I'M
02:01:42.595 --> 02:01:44.430
I'M NOT PREPARED TO. ASK FOR
02:01:44.497 --> 02:01:45.965
THE LETTER TO BE ASKING FOR ANY
02:01:46.032 --> 02:01:47.533
MORE ON MAKING SURE THAT THESE
02:01:47.600 --> 02:01:48.234
ARE THE BEST PRACTICES IN
02:01:48.300 --> 02:01:50.469
GENERAL- AND SO I RESPECTFULLY
02:01:50.536 --> 02:01:53.039
ASK FOR. AN EVO OF SOME VERSION
02:01:53.105 --> 02:01:55.274
OF THE TAP NEAR TODAY THAT A
02:01:55.341 --> 02:01:55.875
LOT OF A LOT OF USEFUL
02:01:55.941 --> 02:01:57.576
DISCUSSION THANK YOU SEVERAL
02:01:57.643 --> 02:01:59.745
WOMEN AND PERHAPS I CAN. OFFER
02:01:59.812 --> 02:02:01.881
SOMETHING THAT MAY BE MAY BE
02:02:01.947 --> 02:02:02.682
USEFUL IN THE SHORT TERM IN
02:02:02.748 --> 02:02:04.250
AROUND THAT WE HAVE HERE. LET
02:02:04.316 --> 02:02:05.951
ME ASK THAT MAYBE WE TABLE THIS
02:02:06.018 --> 02:02:07.353
TILL THE END OF THE AND BRING
02:02:07.420 --> 02:02:08.454
IT BACK FOR A VOTE AT THE END
02:02:08.521 --> 02:02:11.090
OF TODAY'S HEARING MAYBE A
02:02:11.157 --> 02:02:11.724
GIVES YOU AN OPPORTUNITY IN THE
02:02:11.791 --> 02:02:13.559
NEXT. WAS WERE HEARING THE
02:02:13.626 --> 02:02:15.895
ADDITION I REQUEST TO MAYBE-
02:02:15.961 --> 02:02:17.730
MEET WITH SOME OF THE MEMBERS
02:02:17.797 --> 02:02:19.365
OF THE COMMITTEE TO DISCUSS
02:02:19.432 --> 02:02:21.967
WHAT THE PROPER WAY YOU'D LIKE
02:02:22.034 --> 02:02:22.768
TO MOVE FORWARD. SO LET'S GO TO
02:02:22.835 --> 02:02:26.739
THAT. OKAY ALL RIGHT. SO THAT
02:02:26.806 --> 02:02:27.339
WILL TAKE THAT BY. TO THE END
02:02:27.406 --> 02:02:29.275
OF TODAY AGENDA. VOTE ON. AT
02:02:29.341 --> 02:02:30.976
THIS TIME WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
02:02:31.043 --> 02:02:32.978
TO THE NEXT I REQUEST US BY
02:02:33.045 --> 02:02:42.121
ASSEMBLY MEMBER RIVAS. PART OF.
02:02:42.188 --> 02:02:55.968
YEAH SELECT UP TO LIKE. THAT'S
02:02:56.035 --> 02:03:07.546
WHAT. YEAH YEAH. THE HARD. WHAT
02:03:07.613 --> 02:03:09.248
WHAT IT. BUT IF IT IS WITH.
02:03:09.315 --> 02:03:14.987
WHEN YEAH YEAH THAT OKAY SO THE
02:03:15.054 --> 02:03:21.260
ONLY OPEN UP AGAIN. HI ABOUT
02:03:21.327 --> 02:03:27.533
MAKING PRODUCTS FOR. HAS BEEN.
02:03:27.600 --> 02:03:29.068
FIRST TIME DOING THIS SO GOT TO
02:03:29.135 --> 02:03:36.242
GO FOR NO YOU THE FIRST. ME ON.
02:03:36.308 --> 02:03:38.744
THIS NO HE WILL ALLOW 10% YEAR
02:03:38.811 --> 02:03:48.854
REQUEST THANK OUT OF HER. CAR.
02:03:48.921 --> 02:03:59.231
TO AND THAT'S BECAUSE I MEAN TO.
02:03:59.298 --> 02:04:04.937
THAT IS GOOD WITH YOUR. THE
02:04:05.004 --> 02:04:12.011
QUICKNESS YEAH YEAH. WHATEVER
02:04:12.077 --> 02:04:27.326
IF. YOU CAN GROUND AND. YEAH.
02:04:27.393 --> 02:04:30.696
NUMBER ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
02:04:30.763 --> 02:04:32.231
MISTER RIVAS I HAVE MISSED
02:04:32.298 --> 02:04:33.632
GARCIA FOR JOINING US THIS IS
02:04:33.699 --> 02:04:35.668
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN
02:04:35.734 --> 02:04:37.469
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE ONE TWO
02:04:37.536 --> 02:04:38.604
ALMOST SERVICES COUNTY
02:04:38.671 --> 02:04:40.272
CONTINUUM OF CARE LEAD AGENCIES
02:04:40.339 --> 02:04:41.640
MYSTERY OF US WHEN YOU'RE READY
02:04:41.707 --> 02:04:43.075
TO BEGIN PLACE THANK YOU MISTER
02:04:43.142 --> 02:04:44.343
CHAIR AYE AYE IT'S STILL
02:04:44.410 --> 02:04:46.645
APPROPRIATE TO SAY- YOU KNOW
02:04:46.712 --> 02:04:47.813
GOOD MORNING I WAS AFRAID I WAS
02:04:47.880 --> 02:04:48.747
GONNA SAY GOOD AFTERNOON
02:04:48.814 --> 02:04:50.583
POSSIBLY GOOD EVENING BUT IN
02:04:50.649 --> 02:04:52.651
ANY CASE IT IS GREAT TO BE HERE
02:04:52.718 --> 02:04:53.719
ONE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
02:04:53.786 --> 02:04:54.987
COLLEAGUES IN HIS AS WE ALL
02:04:55.054 --> 02:04:57.389
KNOW. HOMELESSNESS IS A STATE
02:04:57.456 --> 02:04:59.191
WIDE CRISIS THAT IS IMPACTING
02:04:59.258 --> 02:05:01.293
EVERY REGION OF CALIFORNIA AND
02:05:01.360 --> 02:05:02.928
OVER TIME THE STATE AND FEDERAL
02:05:02.995 --> 02:05:04.997
GOVERNMENT HAVE ALLOCATED-
02:05:05.064 --> 02:05:07.566
MILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF
02:05:07.633 --> 02:05:08.133
DOLLARS IN EFFORTS TO FIGHT
02:05:08.200 --> 02:05:11.370
SYSTEMIC AND TO EQUIP LOCAL
02:05:11.437 --> 02:05:12.705
GOVERNMENTS WITH THE TOOLS OR
02:05:12.771 --> 02:05:14.740
THE RESOURCES THEY NEED TO
02:05:14.807 --> 02:05:16.041
CREATE SUCCESSFUL PROGRAMS TO
02:05:16.108 --> 02:05:18.410
REDUCE OUR HOMELESS POPULATION-
02:05:18.477 --> 02:05:19.678
AND AS WE ALL KNOW BASED ON THE
02:05:19.745 --> 02:05:21.680
DAILY NEWS ARTICLES WE READ THE
02:05:21.747 --> 02:05:23.249
PEOPLE WE TALKED TO LOCAL
02:05:23.315 --> 02:05:24.617
LEADERS ELECTED OFFICIALS ARE
02:05:24.683 --> 02:05:25.918
NEIGHBORS I AM FROM THE
02:05:25.985 --> 02:05:27.186
OBSERVATIONS WE CAN MAKE
02:05:27.253 --> 02:05:28.787
WHETHER IT'S- WHILE IN THE CAR
02:05:28.854 --> 02:05:31.056
DRIVING A WALL GOING ON A WALK
02:05:31.123 --> 02:05:33.726
THESE OBSERVATIONS BACK. HOME
02:05:33.792 --> 02:05:36.662
OR DISTRICTS OR RIGHT HERE IN
02:05:36.729 --> 02:05:37.329
OUR STATE CAPITOL IN SACRAMENTO.
02:05:37.396 --> 02:05:38.864
THAT THIS HOMELESS. THIS
02:05:38.931 --> 02:05:42.434
HOMELESSNESS ISSUE HAS EXPLODED.
02:05:42.501 --> 02:05:44.470
AND IT HAS EXPLODED IN ALL
02:05:44.536 --> 02:05:46.805
PARTS OF CALIFORNIA I CLEARLY
02:05:46.872 --> 02:05:48.607
THE SITUATION THIS CRISIS HAS
02:05:48.674 --> 02:05:50.643
THE POTENTIAL TO GET MUCH MUCH
02:05:50.709 --> 02:05:52.912
WORSE WORSE BECAUSE MORE AND
02:05:52.978 --> 02:05:56.448
MORE CALIFORNIANS. FACE HOUSING
02:05:56.515 --> 02:05:58.517
IN SECURITY EACH AND EVERY DAY-
02:05:58.584 --> 02:06:00.552
AND IN RESPONSE OUR STATE HAS
02:06:00.619 --> 02:06:02.021
INCREASED ITS ROLE IN PROVIDING
02:06:02.087 --> 02:06:04.356
HOMELESSNESS FUNDING- AND IT IS
02:06:04.423 --> 02:06:05.991
CLEAR THAT ADDITIONAL FUNDS
02:06:06.058 --> 02:06:07.526
WILL CONTINUE TO BE ALLOCATED
02:06:07.593 --> 02:06:10.262
TO ADDRESS THIS CRITICAL ISSUE
02:06:10.329 --> 02:06:11.263
AND AS THE GOVERNOR SAID THE
02:06:11.330 --> 02:06:12.531
LAST WEEK IN THE STATE OF THE
02:06:12.598 --> 02:06:14.166
STATE ADDRESS THE ROAD AHEAD IS
02:06:14.233 --> 02:06:17.269
DIFFICULT. BUT NOT IMPOSSIBLE-
02:06:17.336 --> 02:06:18.771
AND WE AND WE MUST DO ALL WE
02:06:18.837 --> 02:06:21.607
CAN TO SOLVE THIS CRISIS. AND
02:06:21.674 --> 02:06:23.175
WHILE WE WRAP UP FUNDING OR AT
02:06:23.242 --> 02:06:24.576
LEAST WHAT WE CONSIDER IT AND
02:06:24.643 --> 02:06:26.045
WE DEBATED IN THE COMING WEEKS
02:06:26.111 --> 02:06:27.947
AND MONTHS IT'S CRITICAL THAT
02:06:28.013 --> 02:06:29.448
WE ALSO RAMP UP OUR ANALYSIS OF
02:06:29.515 --> 02:06:31.784
EXISTING PROGRAMS- TO ENSURE
02:06:31.850 --> 02:06:34.386
THAT WE ARE BOOSTING- THE
02:06:34.453 --> 02:06:34.954
EFFORTS THAT HAVE SHOWN THE
02:06:35.020 --> 02:06:37.823
MOST PROMISE- AND SO- I'M HERE.
02:06:37.890 --> 02:06:38.657
THIS MORNING ALONG WITH MY
02:06:38.724 --> 02:06:41.860
COLLEAGUE ASSEMBLYWOMAN GARCIA-
02:06:41.927 --> 02:06:42.861
AND WE ARE CALLING FOR STATE
02:06:42.928 --> 02:06:44.663
AUDITOR TO ANALYZE A CONTINUUM
02:06:44.730 --> 02:06:47.399
OF CARE EFFORT. BECAUSE THESE
02:06:47.466 --> 02:06:49.468
LOCAL AND REGIONAL AGENCIES ARE
02:06:49.535 --> 02:06:51.337
ANY CENTRAL TOOL- AND ESSENTIAL
02:06:51.403 --> 02:06:53.038
TOOL FOR THE STATE TO HELP OUR
02:06:53.105 --> 02:06:55.140
MOST VULNERABLE POPULATIONS.
02:06:55.207 --> 02:06:56.575
THE CONTINUUM OF CARE IS AN
02:06:56.642 --> 02:06:58.944
INTEGRATED SYSTEM OF CARE- THAT
02:06:59.011 --> 02:07:00.245
GUIDES AND TRACKS HOMELESS
02:07:00.312 --> 02:07:02.114
INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES TO
02:07:02.181 --> 02:07:03.582
HELP ORGANIZE AND PROVIDE
02:07:03.649 --> 02:07:05.617
SERVICES TO MEET THE SPECIFIC
02:07:05.684 --> 02:07:06.552
NEEDS OF PEOPLE WHO ARE
02:07:06.618 --> 02:07:08.921
HOMELESS. N. AS THEY MOVE OR
02:07:08.988 --> 02:07:10.756
TRANSITION TO STABLE LIVING
02:07:10.823 --> 02:07:12.491
ENVIRONMENTS ANOTHER SOLUTION
02:07:12.558 --> 02:07:13.692
TO ANY HOMELESSNESS ISN'T ONLY
02:07:13.759 --> 02:07:15.094
ABOUT INCREASING THE HOUSING
02:07:15.160 --> 02:07:16.295
SUPPLY OR THE NUMBER OF
02:07:16.362 --> 02:07:18.297
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS- IT'S
02:07:18.364 --> 02:07:19.832
ALSO ABOUT FOCUSING ON THE VERY
02:07:19.898 --> 02:07:22.301
NEEDS OF A SPECIFIC POPULATION.
02:07:22.368 --> 02:07:24.203
SUCH AS OUTREACH EMERGENCY
02:07:24.269 --> 02:07:26.939
SHELTERS RAPID RE HOUSING
02:07:27.006 --> 02:07:28.340
MENTAL HEALTH SUPPORTS
02:07:28.407 --> 02:07:29.575
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING AND
02:07:29.641 --> 02:07:31.610
PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE HOUSING-
02:07:31.677 --> 02:07:33.812
AND IF WE ARE TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:07:33.879 --> 02:07:35.647
WE BETTER UNDERSTAND HOW WE AS
02:07:35.714 --> 02:07:37.349
A STATE CAN BEST SOLVE OUR
02:07:37.416 --> 02:07:38.784
HOMELESSNESS CRIED. WE NEED TO
02:07:38.851 --> 02:07:40.753
LOOK AT THE TOOLS ALLIES AT THE
02:07:40.819 --> 02:07:43.055
LOCAL LEVEL TO HELP IDENTIFY
02:07:43.122 --> 02:07:44.723
THE BEST AND MOST EFFECTIVE
02:07:44.790 --> 02:07:46.492
PRACTICES. I IN ALTHOUGH EVERY
02:07:46.558 --> 02:07:47.826
COUNTY EVERY REGION'S UNIQUE
02:07:47.893 --> 02:07:50.729
AND DIFFERENT. THE LEAD THE
02:07:50.796 --> 02:07:54.366
CONTINUUM OF CARE AGENCIES THEY-
02:07:54.433 --> 02:07:56.101
WILL PROVIDE OR MAY PROVIDE
02:07:56.168 --> 02:07:57.369
UNEXPECTED OPPORTUNITIES FOR
02:07:57.436 --> 02:07:59.405
OTHER CO SEASON OUR STATE OTHER
02:07:59.471 --> 02:08:01.240
AGENCIES TO STRATEGICALLY
02:08:01.306 --> 02:08:03.042
IMPROVE THE USE OF CURRENT AND
02:08:03.108 --> 02:08:05.210
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES AGAIN FOR
02:08:05.277 --> 02:08:07.679
THE PURPOSE OF EFFECTIVELY
02:08:07.746 --> 02:08:08.680
ADDRESSING HOMELESSNESS AND
02:08:08.747 --> 02:08:10.749
SUPPORTING PEOPLE IN OUR STATE
02:08:10.816 --> 02:08:12.518
AND IN CLEARLY CURRENTLY THERE
02:08:12.584 --> 02:08:13.986
ARE GAPS IN TO EMPHASIZE. THE
02:08:14.053 --> 02:08:15.254
LEGISLATURE NEEDS TO BE AWARE
02:08:15.320 --> 02:08:16.655
OF AFFECTED STRATEGIES TO
02:08:16.722 --> 02:08:19.158
CONDUCT ACCURATE ANNUAL COUNTS
02:08:19.224 --> 02:08:20.359
ACCURATE COUNT OF THOSE
02:08:20.426 --> 02:08:22.561
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS- IN
02:08:22.628 --> 02:08:23.595
COORDINATION WITH OTHER
02:08:23.662 --> 02:08:24.863
HOMELESS SERVICE AGENCIES AND
02:08:24.930 --> 02:08:27.966
FINDING A PATHWAY- A PATHWAY
02:08:28.033 --> 02:08:29.668
THE STRATEGY THAT WORKS YOU
02:08:29.735 --> 02:08:31.036
KNOW HAVING AN ACCURATE COUNT
02:08:31.103 --> 02:08:32.237
OF A HOMELESS POPULATION IS
02:08:32.304 --> 02:08:34.239
CRITICAL IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE
02:08:34.306 --> 02:08:38.610
SURE THAT WE GET. THE MAXIMUM
02:08:38.677 --> 02:08:39.211
AMOUNT OF FUNDING AVAILABLE AT
02:08:39.278 --> 02:08:40.579
THE AND LEVEL- AND MOST
02:08:40.646 --> 02:08:42.414
IMPORTANTLY- TO GIVE US THE
02:08:42.481 --> 02:08:44.383
ABILITY TO EFFICIENTLY TARGET
02:08:44.450 --> 02:08:47.786
OR FOCUS- SUCH RESOURCES AND
02:08:47.853 --> 02:08:50.155
DOLLARS- TO THE PROBLEM- AND SO
02:08:50.222 --> 02:08:51.323
CERTAINLY THE STATE CAN
02:08:51.390 --> 02:08:54.193
IDENTIFY AND PROVIDE INCENTIVES
02:08:54.259 --> 02:08:55.294
TO THE CONTINUUM OF CARE
02:08:55.360 --> 02:08:56.795
AGENCIES TO WORK ALONGSIDE NON
02:08:56.862 --> 02:08:59.331
PROFITS AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS
02:08:59.398 --> 02:09:00.732
TO SECURE ADDITIONAL FUNDING
02:09:00.799 --> 02:09:02.935
FROM THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT-
02:09:03.001 --> 02:09:03.435
AND AS A STATE WE SHOULD
02:09:03.502 --> 02:09:05.771
STRIVE. TO LOCATE GEOGRAPHIC
02:09:05.838 --> 02:09:07.005
AREAS OR REGIONS THAT HAVE
02:09:07.072 --> 02:09:10.476
INSUFFICIENT OR IN SOME CASES
02:09:10.542 --> 02:09:11.610
NO SERVICES- AND FIND THE
02:09:11.677 --> 02:09:13.011
REASONS WHY THOSE AREAS HAVE
02:09:13.078 --> 02:09:14.713
INADEQUATE RESOURCES AND WE
02:09:14.780 --> 02:09:15.781
SHOULD BE READY TO REACH OUT TO
02:09:15.848 --> 02:09:19.251
UNDER FUNDED REGION'S FOLLOWING
02:09:19.318 --> 02:09:19.852
THE RESULTS OF THIS AUDIT. TO
02:09:19.918 --> 02:09:22.321
BE APPROVED QUICKLY SUPPLY OUR
02:09:22.387 --> 02:09:24.590
COMMUNITIES WITH THE NEST WITH
02:09:24.656 --> 02:09:25.991
THE RESOURCES TO SOLVE THERE
02:09:26.058 --> 02:09:29.962
YOU CALL SUCH SHINS I AM WILL
02:09:30.028 --> 02:09:32.831
BALLOT EN WILL CONTINUE OKAY
02:09:32.898 --> 02:09:34.833
THEN THIS SOURCE SOLVE THIS
02:09:34.900 --> 02:09:35.834
CRISIS THIS BUSINESS
02:09:35.901 --> 02:09:38.170
HOMELESSNESS CRISIS. THIS
02:09:38.237 --> 02:09:42.107
FUNDING WON'T FULLY OUR GOAL IF
02:09:42.174 --> 02:09:45.811
UNDER WHAT PRO ARE WERE THAT IS
02:09:45.878 --> 02:09:49.414
BY THE OP ED IS. OTHER MORE I
02:09:49.481 --> 02:09:52.217
DAY BUT JUST A HAPPY ON
02:09:52.284 --> 02:09:56.255
CONTINUE OF EIGHT ON THEIR WORK
02:09:56.321 --> 02:09:58.724
BUT WE TAX REASON WE THE THEY
02:09:58.790 --> 02:10:01.994
ARE IT'S A- ON AND THAT THEY A
02:10:02.060 --> 02:10:03.128
AGENCIES AND FIVE CAN. A RIDGE.
02:10:03.195 --> 02:10:05.197
THAT INCLUDE SOUTHERN. THE
02:10:05.264 --> 02:10:07.065
CENTRAL COAST THE BAY AREA THE
02:10:07.132 --> 02:10:08.233
SAN JOAQUIN VALLEY AND THE
02:10:08.300 --> 02:10:10.169
SACRAMENTO VALLEY AND SO WITH
02:10:10.235 --> 02:10:13.338
THAT I. WILL HANDED OVER TO MY
02:10:13.405 --> 02:10:14.840
COLLEAGUE- SOME THE WOMAN
02:10:14.907 --> 02:10:16.642
GARCIA PLACE NOT THINK I WANT
02:10:16.708 --> 02:10:18.377
TO THANK MR RIVAS FOR HIS
02:10:18.443 --> 02:10:19.878
THOROUGH COMMON SO KEEP MINE
02:10:19.945 --> 02:10:21.980
SHORT. I REPRESENT NINE SMALL
02:10:22.047 --> 02:10:23.982
CITIES WITHIN IN THE COUNTY OF
02:10:24.049 --> 02:10:25.517
LA AND WE'VE SEEN OUR
02:10:25.584 --> 02:10:27.386
POPULATION GROW RAPIDLY LIKE IN
02:10:27.452 --> 02:10:28.754
MOST OTHER PLACES ACROSS THE
02:10:28.820 --> 02:10:29.821
STATE WE'VE ACTUALLY HAD ONE OF
02:10:29.888 --> 02:10:32.090
THE- FASTEST RATES OF INCREASE-
02:10:32.157 --> 02:10:34.326
AND LA COUNTY. AND THE REGION
02:10:34.393 --> 02:10:35.961
THAT I AM AND SO AS WE ARE
02:10:36.028 --> 02:10:37.162
SPEND THIS MONEY I WANT TO MAKE
02:10:37.229 --> 02:10:38.864
SURE WE NOT ONLY HAVE THE BEST
02:10:38.931 --> 02:10:41.934
PRACTICES SOMEWHERE AWARE OF-
02:10:42.000 --> 02:10:42.834
WERE WERE WHAT IS AND ISN'T
02:10:42.901 --> 02:10:44.336
WORKING. BUT WHILE ALSO MAKING
02:10:44.403 --> 02:10:46.205
SURE THAT CITIES LIKE MINE ARE
02:10:46.271 --> 02:10:47.639
NOT OVERSHADOWED BY LARGE
02:10:47.706 --> 02:10:49.641
CITIES. AND THAT RESEARCHERS
02:10:49.708 --> 02:10:51.476
ARE BEING DISTRIBUTED EQUITABLY
02:10:51.543 --> 02:10:53.345
ACROSS COUNTIES AND THE STATE
02:10:53.412 --> 02:10:55.214
AND SO I DO ALSO APPRECIATE
02:10:55.280 --> 02:10:56.949
THAT FOCUS TO THE AUDIT AND SO
02:10:57.015 --> 02:10:59.618
I ALSO RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
02:10:59.685 --> 02:11:02.721
AYE VOTE. THANK YOUR THE SIMS
02:11:02.788 --> 02:11:03.555
GO TO MOVED THE OTHERS
02:11:03.622 --> 02:11:05.157
PRESENTATION THANK YOU. THANK
02:11:05.224 --> 02:11:06.391
YOU MISTER CHAIR AS THE
02:11:06.458 --> 02:11:07.960
ASSEMBLY MEMBER RIVAS AND
02:11:08.026 --> 02:11:09.695
GARCIA INDICATED WE WOULD LOOK
02:11:09.761 --> 02:11:11.630
AT FIVE COUNTIES. IN THE
02:11:11.697 --> 02:11:12.631
REGIONS THAT MR RIVAS
02:11:12.698 --> 02:11:14.333
MENTIONED- AND STARTING IN
02:11:14.399 --> 02:11:16.201
LOOKING AT PLANNING. THESE
02:11:16.268 --> 02:11:17.803
CONTINUUM OF CARE OF CO SEES
02:11:17.869 --> 02:11:19.271
ALL REFER TO THEM AS WHAT
02:11:19.338 --> 02:11:20.405
THEY'RE PLANNING IS THEIR
02:11:20.472 --> 02:11:21.740
STRATEGIES FOR ADMINISTERING
02:11:21.807 --> 02:11:23.842
SERVICES TO THOSE. IN THEIR
02:11:23.909 --> 02:11:24.943
RESPECTIVE COUNTIES WHO ARE
02:11:25.010 --> 02:11:26.979
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS ARE
02:11:27.045 --> 02:11:28.347
THEIR BEST PRACTICES THAT COULD
02:11:28.413 --> 02:11:29.715
BE SHARED AMONG THE THIS CO
02:11:29.781 --> 02:11:31.450
SEASON PERHAPS OTHER CO SEASON
02:11:31.516 --> 02:11:33.385
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. ALSO
02:11:33.452 --> 02:11:34.853
LOOKING AT AS HE MENTIONED IN
02:11:34.920 --> 02:11:36.888
HIS COMMENTS MR RIVAS. OUR
02:11:36.955 --> 02:11:38.890
WATER THE CEO SEES DOING TO
02:11:38.957 --> 02:11:40.259
CONDUCT WHAT STRATEGIES ARE
02:11:40.325 --> 02:11:41.693
THEY USING TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:11:41.760 --> 02:11:43.362
THEY'RE CONDUCTING COUNTS. OUT
02:11:43.428 --> 02:11:44.796
THAT RESULT IN AN ACCURATE
02:11:44.863 --> 02:11:46.131
COUNT OF THOSE INDIVIDUALS
02:11:46.198 --> 02:11:48.600
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS- IN
02:11:48.667 --> 02:11:50.335
THEIR RESPECTIVE COUNTIES. IN
02:11:50.402 --> 02:11:51.603
ADDITION DETERMINING THE
02:11:51.670 --> 02:11:53.672
RESOURCES AND WHAT PROTOCOLS
02:11:53.739 --> 02:11:55.474
THE CEO SEES USED TO MEASURE
02:11:55.540 --> 02:11:57.042
HOW EFFECTIVE THE PROGRAMS THAT
02:11:57.109 --> 02:11:58.377
NON PROFITS AND SERVICE
02:11:58.443 --> 02:12:00.112
PROVIDERS IN THEIR COMMUNITIES.
02:12:00.178 --> 02:12:02.281
ARE PROVIDING TO A HOMELESS
02:12:02.347 --> 02:12:04.216
INDIVIDUALS. IN ADDITION
02:12:04.283 --> 02:12:05.784
LOOKING AT COLLECTING RETAINING
02:12:05.851 --> 02:12:07.486
AND ANALYZING DATA NOT JUST
02:12:07.552 --> 02:12:08.787
WITH RESPECT TO HOMELESSNESS
02:12:08.854 --> 02:12:09.921
BUT ALSO WITH RESPECT TO
02:12:09.988 --> 02:12:11.690
SERVICES THAT ARE BEING
02:12:11.757 --> 02:12:13.225
PROVIDED TO THOSE INDIVIDUALS.
02:12:13.292 --> 02:12:16.194
SKEWS ME- AND VERIFY WHETHER TO
02:12:16.261 --> 02:12:17.462
THE EXTENT TO WHICH CEO SEES
02:12:17.529 --> 02:12:18.764
ACTUALLY COLLABORATE AND
02:12:18.830 --> 02:12:20.899
COOPERATE WITH. NONPROFIT
02:12:20.966 --> 02:12:22.868
ORGANIZATIONS ARE WITH RESPECT
02:12:22.934 --> 02:12:25.270
TO AGAIN AS MR RIVAS INDICATED
02:12:25.337 --> 02:12:27.005
OUT REACH. OUT REACHING OUT TO
02:12:27.072 --> 02:12:27.773
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE HOMELESS
02:12:27.839 --> 02:12:30.442
AND- TALKING TO THEM ABOUT OUR
02:12:30.509 --> 02:12:32.077
ARRAY OF SERVICES THAT WOULD BE
02:12:32.144 --> 02:12:33.912
BENEFICIAL TO THEM. I'M ALSO
02:12:33.979 --> 02:12:35.580
LOOKING AT OPPORTUNITIES AND
02:12:35.647 --> 02:12:36.848
INCENTIVES THAT PERHAPS STATE
02:12:36.915 --> 02:12:38.350
OF CALIFORNIA AND THE CEO SEES
02:12:38.417 --> 02:12:40.419
WORKING COLLABORATIVELY. OUR
02:12:40.485 --> 02:12:42.454
COULD SECURE ADDITIONAL FEDERAL
02:12:42.521 --> 02:12:43.622
FUNDING YOU MAY RECALL WE
02:12:43.689 --> 02:12:44.790
ISSUED AN AUDIT A COUPLE OF
02:12:44.856 --> 02:12:45.691
YEARS AGO WHERE WE LOOKED AT
02:12:45.757 --> 02:12:46.958
HOMELESSNESS WE WERE WERE
02:12:47.025 --> 02:12:47.959
SPECIFICALLY ASKED TO LOOK AT
02:12:48.026 --> 02:12:49.661
LA COUNTY. WE EXPANDED THE
02:12:49.728 --> 02:12:52.331
SCOPE UP BY DOING SOME WORK TO
02:12:52.397 --> 02:12:54.132
SEE. THE IMPACT ACROSS THE
02:12:54.199 --> 02:12:55.334
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND ONE OF
02:12:55.400 --> 02:12:57.135
THE RESULTS IN THAT AUDIT WAS
02:12:57.202 --> 02:13:00.439
WE WERE NOT TAKING ADVANTAGE OF
02:13:00.505 --> 02:13:01.073
FEDERAL MONEY LIKE OTHER STATES
02:13:01.139 --> 02:13:02.908
WERE SO THIS OBJECTIVE WOULD
02:13:02.974 --> 02:13:04.343
WOULD GET AT THAT WHAT ARE THE
02:13:04.409 --> 02:13:06.078
CEO SEES DOING TO. WORK
02:13:06.144 --> 02:13:07.279
COLLABORATIVELY TO TRY TO
02:13:07.346 --> 02:13:08.413
MAXIMIZE THE AMOUNT OF FEDERAL
02:13:08.480 --> 02:13:10.115
MONEY THAT COMES INTO
02:13:10.182 --> 02:13:12.217
CALIFORNIA FOR THIS PURPOSE. A
02:13:12.284 --> 02:13:13.652
COUPLE OF OTHER OBJECTIVES
02:13:13.719 --> 02:13:14.686
DETERMINE WHETHER STRUCTURAL
02:13:14.753 --> 02:13:15.887
CHANGES OR RESOURCES ARE
02:13:15.954 --> 02:13:18.056
NEEDED. TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
02:13:18.123 --> 02:13:20.459
CEO SEES IN THE COMMUNITIES-
02:13:20.525 --> 02:13:22.260
HAVE ACCURATE DATA ALL THE WAY
02:13:22.327 --> 02:13:24.730
THROUGH VARIOUS PROCESSES- AND
02:13:24.796 --> 02:13:26.398
CERTAINLY DURING THE EVALUATION
02:13:26.465 --> 02:13:27.566
OF SERVICE PROVIDERS THEY WANT
02:13:27.632 --> 02:13:28.867
TO MAKE SURE THEY HAVE CORRECT
02:13:28.934 --> 02:13:30.035
ACCURATE DATA WHEN THEY'RE
02:13:30.102 --> 02:13:32.003
EVALUATING. SERVICES THAT ARE
02:13:32.070 --> 02:13:33.271
BEING PROVIDED AND THEN THE
02:13:33.338 --> 02:13:34.873
LAST COUPLE OF OBJECTIVES AS
02:13:34.940 --> 02:13:36.775
FAR AS WHAT ARE THE CEO SEES
02:13:36.842 --> 02:13:37.909
DOING TO TRY TO INCREASE THE
02:13:37.976 --> 02:13:39.411
NUMBER OF SERVICE PROVIDERS
02:13:39.478 --> 02:13:40.479
WITHIN THEIR RESPECTIVE
02:13:40.545 --> 02:13:42.647
COMMUNITIES- FIRST IDENTIFYING
02:13:42.714 --> 02:13:44.416
HOW MANY THERE ARE OUT THERE IF
02:13:44.483 --> 02:13:45.283
THERE ARE SERVICE PROVIDERS WHO
02:13:45.350 --> 02:13:47.386
HAVE NOT. ENGAGED WITH THE CEO
02:13:47.452 --> 02:13:50.122
SEE TRY TO DETERMINE WHY- AND
02:13:50.188 --> 02:13:51.790
WHAT'S PROHIBITING MEMBER NOW
02:13:51.857 --> 02:13:52.824
PREVENTING THEM FROM REALLY
02:13:52.891 --> 02:13:54.693
WANTING TO. PARTICIPATE IN SOME
02:13:54.760 --> 02:13:56.027
OF THESE PROGRAMS AND THEN
02:13:56.094 --> 02:13:58.196
FINALLY WITHIN EACH OF THIS THE
02:13:58.263 --> 02:13:59.965
CONTAINER OF CARE COUNTIES.
02:14:00.031 --> 02:14:01.433
DETERMINE WHETHER THERE ARE IN
02:14:01.500 --> 02:14:03.502
MY WORDS POCKETS OR GEOGRAPHIC
02:14:03.568 --> 02:14:05.036
AREAS WITHIN THOSE COMMUNITIES
02:14:05.103 --> 02:14:06.304
WHERE THERE ARE NOT SUFFICIENT
02:14:06.371 --> 02:14:08.106
SERVICES AND DETERMINE WHAT THE
02:14:08.173 --> 02:14:09.574
CEO SEES ARE DOING TO TRY TO
02:14:09.641 --> 02:14:11.510
ADDRESS THAT ISSUE. AND THEN
02:14:11.576 --> 02:14:12.444
FINALLY LOOKING AT BEST
02:14:12.511 --> 02:14:14.146
PRACTICES AGAIN LOOKING AT
02:14:14.212 --> 02:14:15.714
IMPROVING ACCOUNTABILITY
02:14:15.781 --> 02:14:17.682
EFFICIENCY WITH RESPECT TO OUT
02:14:17.749 --> 02:14:19.418
REACH ACCURATE COUNTS UP
02:14:19.484 --> 02:14:20.952
PROVIDING SERVICES TO
02:14:21.019 --> 02:14:21.987
INDIVIDUALS IN THEIR RESPECTIVE
02:14:22.053 --> 02:14:23.355
COMMUNITIES. THE BUDGET FOR
02:14:23.422 --> 02:14:24.756
THIS OUT ITS THIRTY ONE HUNDRED
02:14:24.823 --> 02:14:26.525
HOURS NOW IT'S A TYPICAL TEAM
02:14:26.591 --> 02:14:27.692
THAT WOULD TAKE US EIGHT MONTHS
02:14:27.759 --> 02:14:29.327
WHAT I WOULD SUGGEST THAT MY
02:14:29.394 --> 02:14:30.429
OFFICE WOULD DO IN THIS ONE
02:14:30.495 --> 02:14:31.930
BECAUSE WE'RE BEING ASKED TO GO
02:14:31.997 --> 02:14:33.231
TO FIVE COUNTIES. I WOULD IN
02:14:33.298 --> 02:14:35.734
ALL LIKELIHOOD DECIDE TO PUT
02:14:35.801 --> 02:14:36.835
TWO TEAMS ON THIS SO WE HAVE
02:14:36.902 --> 02:14:37.803
TEAMS OUT. YOU KNOW
02:14:37.869 --> 02:14:39.237
CONCURRENTLY AUDITING AND
02:14:39.304 --> 02:14:40.639
DIFFERENT OP COUNTY SO WE CAN
02:14:40.705 --> 02:14:42.007
SHRINK THE AMOUNT OF TIME THE
02:14:42.073 --> 02:14:43.108
ON IT WOULD TAKE TO GET THE
02:14:43.175 --> 02:14:44.776
INFORMATION BACK TO. THE
02:14:44.843 --> 02:14:48.013
LEGISLATURE- YET TIMELY WITH
02:14:48.079 --> 02:14:49.247
THAT MISTER CHAIR I'LL
02:14:49.314 --> 02:14:50.715
HOPEFULLY ANSWER QUESTIONS
02:14:50.782 --> 02:14:52.484
MEMBERS MAY HAVE THANK YOU.
02:14:52.551 --> 02:14:53.752
THANK BETTER WATER A CAT THIS
02:14:53.819 --> 02:14:55.821
TIME. WE ASK IF THERE'S ANY
02:14:55.887 --> 02:14:57.522
AFFECTED AGENCIES I'D LIKE TO
02:14:57.589 --> 02:15:01.159
SPEAK TO THIS ITEM. HEARING AND
02:15:01.226 --> 02:15:03.662
SEEING NANA LET ME TURN IT TO
02:15:03.728 --> 02:15:05.163
MEMBERS ON DíAS FOR QUESTIONS.
02:15:05.230 --> 02:15:06.898
ASSEMBLY WOMAN BOERNER HORVATH
02:15:06.965 --> 02:15:08.834
YES- NOT SO MUCH A QUESTION I
02:15:08.900 --> 02:15:11.069
WANT TO THINK THE- REQUEST AS
02:15:11.136 --> 02:15:12.504
OF THIS AUDIT FOR SUCH A
02:15:12.571 --> 02:15:14.306
THOUGHTFUL APPROACH OF REALLY
02:15:14.372 --> 02:15:16.708
CREATING BEST PRACTICES. IN THE
02:15:16.775 --> 02:15:18.009
CONTINUE OF KAREN HOMELESSNESS
02:15:18.076 --> 02:15:20.912
I THINK THERE MANY WAYS- WE CAN
02:15:20.979 --> 02:15:22.214
GET AT THE HEART OF THE ISSUE
02:15:22.280 --> 02:15:23.615
OF MANY THINGS THAT WE FACE IN
02:15:23.682 --> 02:15:25.016
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND
02:15:25.083 --> 02:15:27.586
I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE ON
02:15:27.652 --> 02:15:28.086
IT'S A VERY WELL THOUGHT
02:15:28.153 --> 02:15:29.054
THROUGH CHRIST. THANK YOU
02:15:29.120 --> 02:15:30.789
CERTAINLY WOMAN- LET ME TURN IT
02:15:30.856 --> 02:15:32.824
BACK TO HEARINGAND SEEING NO
02:15:32.891 --> 02:15:35.093
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS. OR
02:15:35.160 --> 02:15:35.961
COMMENTS FROM MEMBERS ON THE
02:15:36.027 --> 02:15:38.029
DíAS LET ME ASK THE MEMBER IF
02:15:38.096 --> 02:15:40.131
YOU'D LIKE TO CLOSE BRIEFLY.
02:15:40.198 --> 02:15:42.601
JUST A RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR-
02:15:42.667 --> 02:15:43.869
AND I ABOUT. MAKING MONEY THANK
02:15:43.935 --> 02:15:46.037
YOU BUT LET ME ASK JUST TO AND
02:15:46.104 --> 02:15:48.440
ALL DUE DILIGENCE. IS THERE ANY
02:15:48.507 --> 02:15:51.676
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM.
02:15:51.743 --> 02:15:52.844
ALL RIGHT IT'S BEEN MOVED BY
02:15:52.911 --> 02:15:54.379
MISTER ROTH SECOND BY MISS
02:15:54.446 --> 02:15:55.614
RUBIO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING
02:15:55.680 --> 02:15:56.615
THIS IS OBVIOUSLY A VERY
02:15:56.681 --> 02:15:58.850
IMPORTANT ISSUE HOMELESSNESS
02:15:58.917 --> 02:15:59.751
AND HOW WE'RE DOING WITH THE-
02:15:59.818 --> 02:16:00.852
RESOURCES WE'VE ALLOCATED
02:16:00.919 --> 02:16:02.020
TOWARDS AS IN THIS IS A GOOD
02:16:02.087 --> 02:16:03.488
REASONABLE MEASURED APPROACH.
02:16:03.555 --> 02:16:05.891
SO IT'S BEEN MOVED JUST IN
02:16:05.957 --> 02:16:06.391
MOTION AND MISS SEXUALLY
02:16:06.458 --> 02:16:09.761
CALDERON. THE MOTION IS TO
02:16:09.828 --> 02:16:11.930
APPROVE I REQUEST NUMBER TWENTY
02:16:11.997 --> 02:16:14.399
TWENTY DASH ONE TWELVE. ALMOST
02:16:14.466 --> 02:16:16.568
SERVICES COUNTY CONTINUED
02:16:16.635 --> 02:16:18.370
CONTINUUM OF CARE LEAD AGENCIES
02:16:18.436 --> 02:16:19.938
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBERS OF ROBERT
02:16:20.005 --> 02:16:21.606
RIVAS AND CRISTINA GARCIA
02:16:21.673 --> 02:16:24.009
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS AYE SALAS
02:16:24.075 --> 02:16:26.278
AYE BOERNER HORVATH.
02:16:26.344 --> 02:16:28.847
BOERNER HORVATH I CHEN.
02:16:28.914 --> 02:16:32.250
PATTERSON PATTERSON I RUBIO
02:16:32.317 --> 02:16:38.323
RUBIO I VOEPEL VOEPEL I WOULD.
02:16:38.390 --> 02:16:42.494
SENATOR ROBB ROTH I BOARD JUST.
02:16:42.561 --> 02:16:47.799
GONZALEZ HERTZBERG. GOOD
02:16:47.866 --> 02:16:58.276
MORNING. MORE LOCKED. WIENER.
02:16:58.343 --> 02:16:59.911
OKAY THAT ITEMS ON CALL AND
02:16:59.978 --> 02:17:01.012
WE'LL LEAVE IT OPEN FOR
02:17:01.079 --> 02:17:02.847
ADDITIONAL MEMBERS THAT ARE GET
02:17:02.914 --> 02:17:03.915
THIS TIME WAS GOOD AND I
02:17:03.982 --> 02:17:05.050
CONTINUED ON THE AGENDA CENTER
02:17:05.116 --> 02:17:07.018
BRADFORD HAVE BELIEVE YOU'RE
02:17:07.085 --> 02:17:15.860
SIGNED IN NEXT. OKAY TO THE
02:17:15.927 --> 02:17:17.629
GENEROSITY OF CENTER BRADFORD
02:17:17.696 --> 02:17:20.065
IS YIELDING TO MISS COM LAGER
02:17:20.131 --> 02:17:21.733
SOME WE WOMAN THANK YOU FOR AT
02:17:21.800 --> 02:17:23.501
FOR JOINING US THIS IS ON
02:17:23.568 --> 02:17:27.238
AGENDA ITEM. TO WORRY. AGENDA
02:17:27.305 --> 02:17:28.940
ITEM NUMBER TEN TWENTY TWENTY
02:17:29.007 --> 02:17:31.776
DASH ONE OH TWO. THIS IS
02:17:31.843 --> 02:17:33.979
REALIGNMENT FUND SPENDING.
02:17:34.045 --> 02:17:36.081
THANK YOU AND SEVEN ONE PLEASE
02:17:36.147 --> 02:17:37.449
THANK YOU TO SENATOR BRADFORD
02:17:37.515 --> 02:17:41.052
FOR- ALLOWING US TO- GO BEFORE
02:17:41.119 --> 02:17:42.220
HIM WE HAVE WITNESSES THAT HAVE
02:17:42.287 --> 02:17:44.556
A FLIGHT TO CATCH THANK YOU
02:17:44.623 --> 02:17:46.324
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS GOOD.
02:17:46.391 --> 02:17:48.326
AFTERNOON ON THE DOCTOR. SINCE
02:17:48.393 --> 02:17:51.162
THE PASSAGE OF PRISON ALIGNMENT
02:17:51.229 --> 02:17:53.732
LEGISLATION IN TWENTY ELEVEN
02:17:53.798 --> 02:17:54.833
CALIFORNIA HAS SENT MORE THAN
02:17:54.899 --> 02:17:56.434
EIGHT BILLION DOLLARS TO
02:17:56.501 --> 02:17:57.969
COUNTIES TO COVER THE COST OF
02:17:58.036 --> 02:17:59.204
MOVING INCARCERATED PEOPLE FROM
02:17:59.270 --> 02:18:02.007
PRISONS TO JAILS. THIS STATE
02:18:02.073 --> 02:18:02.574
HAS MORE THAN A HUNDRED AND
02:18:02.641 --> 02:18:06.044
TEN. LONG TERM JAIL FACILITIES
02:18:06.111 --> 02:18:06.678
AND DEPARTMENTS ARE NOW
02:18:06.745 --> 02:18:08.513
RESPONSIBLE FOR POPULATIONS
02:18:08.580 --> 02:18:10.215
THAT ARE LARGER AND FAR MORE
02:18:10.281 --> 02:18:12.484
DIVERSE. CONDITIONS SUCH AS
02:18:12.550 --> 02:18:15.086
OVERCROWDING POOR PHYSICAL AND
02:18:15.153 --> 02:18:16.721
MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT AND
02:18:16.788 --> 02:18:17.956
MISMANAGEMENT OF FUNDS BY
02:18:18.023 --> 02:18:19.157
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENTS HAVE
02:18:19.224 --> 02:18:21.292
BECOME FAR TOO FREQUENT READS
02:18:21.359 --> 02:18:23.928
IN ARTICLES IN THE NEWSPAPERS
02:18:23.995 --> 02:18:27.465
AND ALSO FAR TOO FREQUENT IN
02:18:27.532 --> 02:18:28.099
JAILS ACROSS THE STATE. AND WE
02:18:28.166 --> 02:18:28.600
KNOW THAT THE EFFICIENT
02:18:28.667 --> 02:18:29.968
RESPONSIBLE SPENDING OF PRISON
02:18:30.035 --> 02:18:32.003
REALIGNMENT FUNDS IS INCREDIBLY
02:18:32.070 --> 02:18:34.272
CRITICAL. LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
02:18:34.339 --> 02:18:35.640
CONTINUE TO MOVE PRISON
02:18:35.707 --> 02:18:37.175
REALIGNMENT FUNDS FROM ONE LAW
02:18:37.242 --> 02:18:38.977
ENFORCEMENT PURPOSE TO ANOTHER
02:18:39.044 --> 02:18:41.446
WITH LIMITED STATE OVERSIGHT.
02:18:41.513 --> 02:18:43.848
TODAY I'M HERE TO REQUEST THE
02:18:43.915 --> 02:18:44.749
IMPLEMENTATION OF SUCH
02:18:44.816 --> 02:18:47.185
OVERSIGHT PARTICULARLY OVER LOS
02:18:47.252 --> 02:18:49.220
ANGELES COUNTY ALAMEDA COUNTY
02:18:49.287 --> 02:18:50.355
AND FRESNO COUNTY SHERIFF'S
02:18:50.422 --> 02:18:52.657
DEPARTMENTS. I ALONG WITH MANY
02:18:52.724 --> 02:18:55.026
ADVOCATES ARE CONCERNED ABOUT
02:18:55.093 --> 02:18:56.695
BUDGET BATTLES COUNTY LEVEL
02:18:56.761 --> 02:18:58.563
REFUSALS TO CONDUCT AN AUDIT
02:18:58.630 --> 02:19:00.331
AND DEATHS WITHIN FACILITIES
02:19:00.398 --> 02:19:03.134
RESPECTIVELY THE LOS ANGELES
02:19:03.201 --> 02:19:03.935
COUNTY JAIL SYSTEM IT'S THE
02:19:04.002 --> 02:19:05.970
LARGEST SYSTEM IN THE WORLD.
02:19:06.037 --> 02:19:08.239
HAS ITS FAIR SHARE OF TROUBLES
02:19:08.306 --> 02:19:10.175
IN OCTOBER TWENTY NINETEEN THE
02:19:10.241 --> 02:19:11.142
LOS ANGELES COUNTY BOARD OF
02:19:11.209 --> 02:19:13.178
SUPERVISORS VOTED UNANIMOUSLY
02:19:13.244 --> 02:19:15.046
TO IMPROVE TO APPROVE A PARTIAL
02:19:15.113 --> 02:19:18.116
FREEZE OF A HUNDRED FORTY THREE
02:19:18.183 --> 02:19:18.750
POINT SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS OF
02:19:18.817 --> 02:19:20.719
THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT'S
02:19:20.785 --> 02:19:21.986
BUDGET. OVER SPEND UNDER THE
02:19:22.053 --> 02:19:23.722
CURRENT SHERIFF IS MORE THAN
02:19:23.788 --> 02:19:24.222
FOUR TIMES THAT OF HIS
02:19:24.289 --> 02:19:26.658
PREDECESSOR. ALAMEDA COUNTY IS
02:19:26.725 --> 02:19:28.426
JAIL POPULATION HAS DECREASED
02:19:28.493 --> 02:19:30.662
BY HALF SINCE PRISON ALIGNMENT
02:19:30.729 --> 02:19:32.597
TOOK EFFECT YET EVEN WITH THE
02:19:32.664 --> 02:19:33.898
POPULATION DECREASED THE
02:19:33.965 --> 02:19:35.567
ALAMEDA COUNTY SHERIFF'S HAS
02:19:35.633 --> 02:19:37.736
EXPERIENCED A BUDGET GROWTH BY
02:19:37.802 --> 02:19:40.038
A HUNDRED AND FORTY FOUR
02:19:40.105 --> 02:19:40.605
MILLION DOLLARS. IN THE PAST
02:19:40.672 --> 02:19:41.906
FOUR YEARS IN THE PAST TEN
02:19:41.973 --> 02:19:44.209
YEARS MY BAD TOTALING FOUR
02:19:44.275 --> 02:19:45.110
HUNDRED AND FORTY THREE MILLION
02:19:45.176 --> 02:19:47.612
DOLLARS AND TWENTY NINETEEN.
02:19:47.679 --> 02:19:49.114
FORTY FIVE INCARCERATED PEOPLE
02:19:49.180 --> 02:19:51.349
DIED WHILE HELD AT ALAMEDA
02:19:51.416 --> 02:19:54.219
COUNTIES SANTA. RITA JAIL IN
02:19:54.285 --> 02:19:56.821
THE FIVE YEARS BETWEEN TWENTY
02:19:56.888 --> 02:19:58.490
FOURTEEN AND TWENTY NINETEEN
02:19:58.556 --> 02:20:00.358
IT'S THE HIGHEST DEATH RATE IN
02:20:00.425 --> 02:20:03.027
THE BAY AREA. THE FRESNO COUNTY
02:20:03.094 --> 02:20:04.963
JAIL WHICH HOUSES MORE THAN
02:20:05.029 --> 02:20:07.298
THREE THOUSAND INMATES HAS SEEN
02:20:07.365 --> 02:20:08.733
THE SHARPEST INCREASE OF DEATHS
02:20:08.800 --> 02:20:10.935
OF ANY CALIFORNIA JAIL SINCE
02:20:11.002 --> 02:20:12.370
THE PASSAGE OF REALIGNMENT
02:20:12.437 --> 02:20:16.474
LEGISLATION. FRESNO COUNTY
02:20:16.541 --> 02:20:18.076
LARGER JAIL SYSTEMS THE
02:20:18.143 --> 02:20:20.845
CALIFORNIA DOJ HAS REPORTED
02:20:20.912 --> 02:20:22.514
TWENTY THREE DEATHS IN THE
02:20:22.580 --> 02:20:23.581
SEVEN YEARS PRECEDING PRISON
02:20:23.648 --> 02:20:25.383
REALIGNMENT. THAT FIGURE HAS
02:20:25.450 --> 02:20:26.584
MORE THAN DOUBLED SINCE
02:20:26.651 --> 02:20:28.520
REALIGNMENT AT FORTY SEVEN
02:20:28.586 --> 02:20:30.288
DEATHS IN ONLY ONE OF THOSE
02:20:30.355 --> 02:20:32.624
DEATHS WAS CAUSED BY A FELLOW
02:20:32.690 --> 02:20:34.626
INCARCERATED PERSON. CALIFORNIA
02:20:34.692 --> 02:20:36.661
IS ONE OF THE LEADING STATES IN
02:20:36.728 --> 02:20:37.762
PROGRESS OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE
02:20:37.829 --> 02:20:39.664
REFORM YET THERE IS LITTLE OR
02:20:39.731 --> 02:20:41.099
NO ACCOUNTABILITY FOR COUNTY
02:20:41.166 --> 02:20:43.168
SHERIFF'S TO ENSURE THAT THEY
02:20:43.234 --> 02:20:44.869
ARE SPENDING REALIGNMENT FUNDS
02:20:44.936 --> 02:20:47.105
AS INTENDED. THE VASTLY
02:20:47.172 --> 02:20:48.840
DIFFERENT WAYS THAT THREE OUT
02:20:48.907 --> 02:20:50.708
FOR MENTION COUNTIES HAVE SPENT
02:20:50.775 --> 02:20:51.743
THEIR FUNDS ATTEST TO THIS
02:20:51.810 --> 02:20:53.945
FACT. MY HOPE IS THAT THIS
02:20:54.012 --> 02:20:55.413
AUDIT OF THREE SHERIFF'S
02:20:55.480 --> 02:20:56.848
DEPARTMENTS WILL OPEN THE DOOR
02:20:56.915 --> 02:20:58.383
TO AUDITING OTHER SHERIFF'S
02:20:58.449 --> 02:20:59.350
DEPARTMENTS THROUGHOUT THE
02:20:59.417 --> 02:21:01.619
STATE. WE MUST WORK TO SUPPORT
02:21:01.686 --> 02:21:02.787
THE DIGNITY AND HEALTH OF
02:21:02.854 --> 02:21:04.422
INCARCERATED CALIFORNIANS IN
02:21:04.489 --> 02:21:06.624
ACCESS TO DATA THAT IS FULL AND
02:21:06.691 --> 02:21:08.726
TRANSPARENT IS NECESSARY IN
02:21:08.793 --> 02:21:09.627
ORDER TO CRAFT LEGISLATIVE
02:21:09.694 --> 02:21:11.830
SOLUTIONS SO HERE IN SUPPORT I
02:21:11.896 --> 02:21:13.464
HAVE MARC ANTHONY CLAYTON
02:21:13.531 --> 02:21:15.400
JOHNSON OF JUSTICE LA. AS WELL
02:21:15.466 --> 02:21:18.102
AS EVETTE OUTLAY OF DIGNITY AND
02:21:18.169 --> 02:21:20.505
POWER NOW AND I RESPECTFULLY
02:21:20.572 --> 02:21:22.073
ASK YOUR I. BUT- HI THANK YOU
02:21:22.140 --> 02:21:26.411
ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY. A GOOD
02:21:26.477 --> 02:21:28.813
AFTERNOON- MEMBERS THANK YOU
02:21:28.880 --> 02:21:29.681
FOR HAVING THIS DISCUSSION AND
02:21:29.747 --> 02:21:31.816
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER COMMA
02:21:31.883 --> 02:21:33.051
FOR BRINGING THIS TO THE LIGHT
02:21:33.117 --> 02:21:34.519
JUST SO LAYS A COALITION OF
02:21:34.586 --> 02:21:35.620
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS
02:21:35.687 --> 02:21:36.821
ADVOCATES AND FOLKS ARE
02:21:36.888 --> 02:21:38.189
IMPACTED BY INCARCERATION OF
02:21:38.256 --> 02:21:40.525
LOS ANGELES COUNTY- AND WE COME
02:21:40.592 --> 02:21:41.426
TO THIS CONVERSATION REALLY
02:21:41.492 --> 02:21:42.894
WITH HOLLY PLEASE IF YOU WE
02:21:42.961 --> 02:21:44.495
COULD HAVE YOUR NAME AS WELL
02:21:44.562 --> 02:21:45.096
FOR THE RECORD I'M SORRY MARC
02:21:45.163 --> 02:21:47.332
ANTHONY CLAYTON JOHNSON. WE
02:21:47.398 --> 02:21:48.433
COME TO THIS CONVERSATION WITH
02:21:48.500 --> 02:21:50.034
THE HOPE TO GROUND US AND THE
02:21:50.101 --> 02:21:52.170
IMPETUS BEHIND AB ONE OH NINE
02:21:52.237 --> 02:21:52.971
WHICH WAS THE BROWN VERSUS PLOT
02:21:53.037 --> 02:21:55.139
THAT CASE- WHAT'S- AB ONE
02:21:55.206 --> 02:21:56.975
ANNISE OFTEN TALKED ABOUT. AS A
02:21:57.041 --> 02:21:57.675
STRATEGY TO REDUCE
02:21:57.742 --> 02:21:59.277
INCARCERATION- REDUCE
02:21:59.344 --> 02:22:00.879
OVERCROWDING REDUCE RECIDIVISM.
02:22:00.945 --> 02:22:02.680
AND WHAT WE KNOW IS THAT THAT
02:22:02.747 --> 02:22:04.582
CASE WAS ALSO ABOUT MEDICAL
02:22:04.649 --> 02:22:06.251
NEGLIGENCE AND ABUSE. ON THAT.
02:22:06.317 --> 02:22:09.487
AMOUNTED TO A CONDITIONS- THAT
02:22:09.554 --> 02:22:10.788
WORD NAME THIS CRUEL AND
02:22:10.855 --> 02:22:12.090
UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT AS DEFINED
02:22:12.156 --> 02:22:13.458
BY THE FOURTH AMENDMENT. AND SO
02:22:13.524 --> 02:22:14.692
THE FUNDAMENTAL CONTRADICTION
02:22:14.759 --> 02:22:16.561
WE HAVE TO ASK AN ADDRESS IS
02:22:16.628 --> 02:22:18.897
HOW WE HAVE MOVED RESOURCES. ON
02:22:18.963 --> 02:22:20.098
FROM THE PRISON SYSTEM TO THE
02:22:20.164 --> 02:22:21.499
LOCAL JAIL SYSTEMS-
02:22:21.566 --> 02:22:22.901
PARTICULARLY IN PLACES LIKE
02:22:22.967 --> 02:22:24.469
LAST SENTENCE WHICH HAVE FAILED
02:22:24.535 --> 02:22:26.070
ON THE SAME PREMISE IN FACT THE
02:22:26.137 --> 02:22:28.706
DOJ IS OPEN UP INVESTIGATIONS-
02:22:28.773 --> 02:22:29.707
INTO THE LESS IT IS COUNTY JAIL
02:22:29.774 --> 02:22:32.110
SYSTEM FOR THAT VERY. REASON
02:22:32.176 --> 02:22:33.378
ARE CRUEL AND UNUSUAL
02:22:33.444 --> 02:22:34.812
PUNISHMENT AROUND THE ISSUES OF
02:22:34.879 --> 02:22:35.713
HEALTH CARE ON THE ISSUES OF
02:22:35.780 --> 02:22:37.482
OVER CUTTING ON AROUND ISSUES
02:22:37.548 --> 02:22:40.618
OF ABUSE. AND IN IN FACT. THIS
02:22:40.685 --> 02:22:43.054
LAST YEAR WE'VE SEEN- THE
02:22:43.121 --> 02:22:44.455
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENTS BUDGETS
02:22:44.522 --> 02:22:46.925
GO UP WITH RESPECT TO AB ONE OH
02:22:46.991 --> 02:22:48.660
NINE ALLOCATION SPECIFICALLY
02:22:48.726 --> 02:22:50.028
44% OF AB ONE ON NINE
02:22:50.094 --> 02:22:51.162
ALLOCATIONS LOS ANGELES HAVE
02:22:51.229 --> 02:22:51.796
GONE TO THE SHERIFF'S
02:22:51.863 --> 02:22:53.364
DEPARTMENT IS TWO HUNDRED
02:22:53.431 --> 02:22:54.799
THIRTY FOUR MILLION DOLLARS.
02:22:54.866 --> 02:22:56.067
51% NOW LET ME HAVE GONE TO THE
02:22:56.134 --> 02:22:57.869
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT AND FRESNO
02:22:57.936 --> 02:23:01.372
SEEN. AGAIN 53% GOING TO
02:23:01.439 --> 02:23:03.041
CUSTODY ALLOCATION THAT SO WE
02:23:03.107 --> 02:23:05.009
ARE ALL SET TO ASK OURSELVES.
02:23:05.076 --> 02:23:07.512
HOW WE ALLOCATING THESE FUNDS.
02:23:07.578 --> 02:23:10.748
TO ENTITIES ATTACKS DON'T HAVE.
02:23:10.815 --> 02:23:14.986
A INTEREST DIVERTED. OUT OF THE-
02:23:15.053 --> 02:23:15.920
THAT THAT MOVES. THOSE PEOPLE
02:23:15.987 --> 02:23:16.521
OUT OF THEIR WRIST. AND IN THE
02:23:16.587 --> 02:23:18.122
UPPER. OF A OTHER DEPARTMENTS
02:23:18.189 --> 02:23:18.990
SUCH AS THE DEPARTMENT PUBLIC
02:23:19.057 --> 02:23:19.757
HEALTH DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
02:23:19.824 --> 02:23:21.326
SERVICES- AND THEREFORE
02:23:21.392 --> 02:23:23.628
WEAKENING THE JUSTIFICATION.
02:23:23.695 --> 02:23:25.630
FOR THAT MONEY IN THEIR BUDGETS
02:23:25.697 --> 02:23:26.564
I THINK ONE THING IT'S REALLY
02:23:26.631 --> 02:23:28.766
IMPORTANT TO NOTE. THAT THESE
02:23:28.833 --> 02:23:31.102
ISSUES OF- CRUEL AND UNUSUAL
02:23:31.169 --> 02:23:32.437
PUNISHMENT IN OUR JAIL SYSTEM
02:23:32.503 --> 02:23:34.572
CONTINUE TO- CONTINUE TO
02:23:34.639 --> 02:23:37.108
HAPPEN- SUCH AS THE H. THE-
02:23:37.175 --> 02:23:38.776
OCCURRENCE OF THE DEATH OF ONE
02:23:38.843 --> 02:23:40.511
GLORIA HE WAS A YOUNG MAN DON'T
02:23:40.578 --> 02:23:43.281
LÏNG LATINO MEN AND LOSS AND
02:23:43.348 --> 02:23:44.115
JUST COUNTY JAIL. WHO HAD A
02:23:44.182 --> 02:23:45.984
MENTAL HEALTH CONDITION WAS
02:23:46.050 --> 02:23:47.285
PEPPER SPRAY TO DEATH BY THE
02:23:47.352 --> 02:23:48.186
LOS ANGELES SHERIFF'S
02:23:48.252 --> 02:23:50.088
DEPARTMENT. HE IS ONE OF EIGHT
02:23:50.154 --> 02:23:51.456
PEOPLE HAVE DIED LAST YEAR LOSS
02:23:51.522 --> 02:23:53.224
CENTERS COUNTY JAIL SYSTEM-
02:23:53.291 --> 02:23:55.026
WHEN WE HAVE OTHER METHODS
02:23:55.093 --> 02:23:56.160
OTHER MECHANISMS OF THE
02:23:56.227 --> 02:23:57.228
STRATEGIES THAT ARE MORE
02:23:57.295 --> 02:23:58.663
EFFECTIVE IN WE HAVE WAVE THEM.
02:23:58.730 --> 02:24:01.599
AGAIN TO THE PATTERN OF AB ONE
02:24:01.666 --> 02:24:02.767
OH NINE ALLOCATIONS AS LAID
02:24:02.834 --> 02:24:04.836
OUT. WE HAVE THE BENEFIT OF THE
02:24:04.902 --> 02:24:06.404
PUBLIC DEBATE THAT HAPPENED ON
02:24:06.471 --> 02:24:07.305
AUGUST THIRTEENTH IN THE
02:24:07.372 --> 02:24:09.874
COUNTY. OF LOS ANGELES WHERE
02:24:09.941 --> 02:24:11.109
THE COUNTY ELIMINATED AND
02:24:11.175 --> 02:24:13.878
DECIDED TO CANCEL A CONTRACT OF
02:24:13.945 --> 02:24:14.679
FOUR BILLION. FOUR BILLION
02:24:14.746 --> 02:24:16.414
DOLLARS TO APPROVE A MENTAL
02:24:16.481 --> 02:24:18.783
HEALTH- JAIL SYSTEM. AND IT'S
02:24:18.850 --> 02:24:20.351
IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE
02:24:20.418 --> 02:24:22.620
OFFICE OF DIVERSION AND RE
02:24:22.687 --> 02:24:23.588
ENTRY IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY HAS
02:24:23.654 --> 02:24:26.257
A- NON RECIDIVISM RATE OF
02:24:26.324 --> 02:24:27.792
NINETY ONE PERCENT- AT SIX
02:24:27.859 --> 02:24:29.394
MONTHS AND EIGHTY FOUR PERCENT.
02:24:29.460 --> 02:24:30.495
AT TWELVE MONTHS FOR PEOPLE WHO
02:24:30.561 --> 02:24:32.597
HAVE MENTAL HEALTH- SERIOUS
02:24:32.663 --> 02:24:34.065
MENTAL HEALTH DISABILITIES
02:24:34.132 --> 02:24:35.600
VIOLENT CHARGES AND SUBSTANCE
02:24:35.666 --> 02:24:36.934
USE WHILE THE SHERIFF'S
02:24:37.001 --> 02:24:39.203
DEPARTMENT. HAS A RECIDIVISM
02:24:39.270 --> 02:24:41.105
RATE OF 60% AND LASTLY I JUST
02:24:41.172 --> 02:24:42.340
WANT TO SAY THAT IT'S IMPORTANT
02:24:42.407 --> 02:24:43.307
TO ALSO LOOK AT THE BIGGER
02:24:43.374 --> 02:24:44.842
PICTURE. WHERE THE LAR IN THE
02:24:44.909 --> 02:24:47.412
LARGEST COUNTY IN LAW IT
02:24:47.478 --> 02:24:49.847
LARGEST COUNTY IN THE COUNTRY.
02:24:49.914 --> 02:24:50.948
PARMA MENTAL HEALTH DEPARTMENT
02:24:51.015 --> 02:24:51.649
HEALTH SERVICES THE OFFICE OF
02:24:51.716 --> 02:24:53.017
DIVERSION REENTRY AND THE PART
02:24:53.084 --> 02:24:54.652
IN A PUBLIC HEALTH COLLECTIVELY
02:24:54.719 --> 02:24:56.254
RECEIVE SEVENTY SEVEN MILLION
02:24:56.320 --> 02:24:59.090
DOLLARS. THAT IS 17% OF AB ONE
02:24:59.157 --> 02:25:01.759
ON NINE ALLOCATIONS AND 20% OF
02:25:01.826 --> 02:25:03.761
THE SHARES ALLOCATION OF TWO
02:25:03.828 --> 02:25:04.328
HUNDRED THIRTY FOUR MILLION
02:25:04.395 --> 02:25:04.929
DOLLARS EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE
02:25:04.996 --> 02:25:07.331
BEST POISED TO. FACILITATE MORE
02:25:07.398 --> 02:25:09.901
EFFECTIVE SOLUTIONS. THANK YOU
02:25:09.967 --> 02:25:10.835
IN THE INTEREST OF TIME FOR
02:25:10.902 --> 02:25:12.437
COULD BE VERY CONCISE BECAUSE
02:25:12.503 --> 02:25:14.172
WE MVED TO THE STATE AUDITOR'S
02:25:14.238 --> 02:25:16.307
PRESENTATION. PLEASE KEEP THE
02:25:16.374 --> 02:25:17.975
FAST MY NAME IS THE BALLET I AM
02:25:18.042 --> 02:25:19.210
THE SENIOR POLICY LEAD FOR
02:25:19.277 --> 02:25:20.812
DIGNITY EMPOWER NOW. A MEMBER
02:25:20.878 --> 02:25:22.547
OF THE JUSTICE LA COALITION FOR
02:25:22.613 --> 02:25:23.848
NEARLY A DECADE OUR MEMBERS
02:25:23.915 --> 02:25:25.416
HAVE CALLED FOR THE EVALUATION
02:25:25.483 --> 02:25:26.784
OF AB ONE OR NINE SPENDING IN
02:25:26.851 --> 02:25:28.719
OUR COUNTY. AND REINVEST AND
02:25:28.786 --> 02:25:29.520
COMMUNITY BASED ALTERNATIVES TO
02:25:29.587 --> 02:25:31.322
INCARCERATION. I'M HERE ON
02:25:31.389 --> 02:25:32.256
BEHALF OF OUR COALITION IN
02:25:32.323 --> 02:25:33.424
STRONG SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
02:25:33.491 --> 02:25:34.792
MEMBER COME AUGUST REQUEST FOR
02:25:34.859 --> 02:25:36.060
AN AUDIT OF LA COUNTY SHERIFF'S
02:25:36.127 --> 02:25:37.528
DEPARTMENT AB ONE OR NINE
02:25:37.595 --> 02:25:39.230
SPENDING. BUT WE ALSO ASK THAT
02:25:39.297 --> 02:25:40.998
THE AUDIT EXTEND TO ALL THE LAW
02:25:41.065 --> 02:25:42.400
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES RECEIVING
02:25:42.467 --> 02:25:44.035
AB ONE OR NINE ALLOCATIONS.
02:25:44.102 --> 02:25:45.703
INCLUDING THE LA COUNTY
02:25:45.770 --> 02:25:48.372
PROBATION OFFICE SINCE TWO
02:25:48.439 --> 02:25:48.973
THOUSAND ELEVEN LA COUNTY HAS
02:25:49.040 --> 02:25:50.508
RECEIVED OVER A BILLION IN AB
02:25:50.575 --> 02:25:51.409
ONE OH NINE FUNDING INTENDED
02:25:51.476 --> 02:25:52.110
FOR ALTERNATIVES TO
02:25:52.176 --> 02:25:54.812
INCARCERATION. BUT SO FAR AB
02:25:54.879 --> 02:25:55.913
ONE OH NINE HAS NOT BEEN ABLE
02:25:55.980 --> 02:25:56.948
TO FULFILL ITS PURPOSE OF
02:25:57.014 --> 02:25:58.616
REDUCING RECIDIVISM AND JAIL
02:25:58.683 --> 02:25:59.951
POPULATIONS BECAUSE THE FUNDING
02:26:00.017 --> 02:26:01.486
HAS NOT REACHED. COMMUNITY
02:26:01.552 --> 02:26:02.787
ORGANIZATIONS WEBER
02:26:02.854 --> 02:26:03.855
DEMONSTRATED SIGNIFICANT
02:26:03.921 --> 02:26:05.857
IMPACTS ON REENTRY NEEDS. THE
02:26:05.923 --> 02:26:07.759
MAJORITY OF AB ONE OH NINE
02:26:07.825 --> 02:26:08.559
FUNDING HAS GONE TO THE COUNTY
02:26:08.626 --> 02:26:09.727
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT AND
02:26:09.794 --> 02:26:11.262
PROBATION OFFICE. TO PERPETUATE
02:26:11.329 --> 02:26:12.530
THE HIGHEST LEVELS OF JAIL
02:26:12.597 --> 02:26:14.098
INCARCERATION IN THE ENTIRE
02:26:14.165 --> 02:26:16.667
COUNTRY. IN FISCAL YEAR TWO
02:26:16.734 --> 02:26:17.869
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN THROUGH TWO
02:26:17.935 --> 02:26:18.369
THOUSAND NINETEEN THESE
02:26:18.436 --> 02:26:19.737
DEPARTMENTS RECEIPT OVER
02:26:19.804 --> 02:26:21.239
SEVENTY SEVEN PERCENT. OF AB
02:26:21.305 --> 02:26:22.707
ONE ON I'M FUNDING AND SAID OF
02:26:22.773 --> 02:26:23.808
USING THESE FUNDS TO FULFILL
02:26:23.875 --> 02:26:26.010
THE INTENT OF AB ONE OH NINE
02:26:26.077 --> 02:26:26.577
THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT HAS
02:26:26.644 --> 02:26:28.012
CHOSEN TO USE A LARGE PORTION
02:26:28.079 --> 02:26:29.647
OF THE- FUNDS. TO PAY FOR STOP
02:26:29.714 --> 02:26:31.849
OVER TIME. THE RETURN ON YOUR
02:26:31.916 --> 02:26:32.817
INVESTMENT HAS BEEN A
02:26:32.884 --> 02:26:36.187
RECIDIVISM RATE OF 60% OF OVER
02:26:36.254 --> 02:26:37.922
60% LIKE MARC ANTHONY POINTED
02:26:37.989 --> 02:26:40.324
OUT. BY CONTRAST THE OFFICE OF
02:26:40.391 --> 02:26:42.927
DIVERSION RE ENTRY RECEIVED
02:26:42.994 --> 02:26:46.164
YOUR 5% AND I COLLEAGUES MARK
02:26:46.230 --> 02:26:49.433
AT THE NO. AT THE 84% RICH.
02:26:49.500 --> 02:26:57.675
RATE DOLLAR FOR. INVEST.
02:26:57.742 --> 02:26:59.677
RECEIVE A THOROUGH AUDIT OF ITS
02:26:59.744 --> 02:27:01.379
AB ONE OR NINE SPENDING. THANK
02:27:01.445 --> 02:27:02.880
YOU IT WAS GOING TO MOVE TO THE
02:27:02.947 --> 02:27:03.814
STATE AUDITOR'S PRESENTATION
02:27:03.881 --> 02:27:05.550
PLEASE. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
02:27:05.616 --> 02:27:06.817
AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER COM LONGER
02:27:06.884 --> 02:27:08.386
INDICATED WE WOULD GO TO THREE
02:27:08.452 --> 02:27:09.287
DIFFERENT COUNTIES ALAMEDA
02:27:09.353 --> 02:27:12.023
FRESNO LA- AND SHE'S ASKED US
02:27:12.089 --> 02:27:13.391
TO LOOK AT A FEW ISSUES HERE
02:27:13.457 --> 02:27:14.592
AND I'LL GO A RELATIVELY
02:27:14.659 --> 02:27:16.427
QUICKLY. FIRST ASKING US TO
02:27:16.494 --> 02:27:18.162
LOOK AT A TEN YEAR WINDOW- WITH
02:27:18.229 --> 02:27:20.731
RESPECT TO POPULATION- AND THAT
02:27:20.798 --> 02:27:22.300
WILL ALLOW US TO LOOK AT
02:27:22.366 --> 02:27:24.035
POPULATION CHARACTERISTICS
02:27:24.101 --> 02:27:25.903
PRIOR TO REALIGNMENT AND AFTER
02:27:25.970 --> 02:27:27.338
REALIGNMENT AND- AND SHE'S
02:27:27.405 --> 02:27:28.706
ASKED US OVER THAT TEN YEAR
02:27:28.773 --> 02:27:30.474
WINDOW TO LOOK AT TRENDS. ARE
02:27:30.541 --> 02:27:31.509
AND CERTAINLY TRY TO LOOK AT
02:27:31.576 --> 02:27:33.377
SOME DEMOGRAPHICS WITH RESPECT
02:27:33.444 --> 02:27:35.279
TO RACE RACE AND ETHNIC MAKE UP
02:27:35.346 --> 02:27:36.847
AND CERTAINLY ON THE NUMBER OF
02:27:36.914 --> 02:27:39.116
INMATE DEATHS. IN ADDITION ARE
02:27:39.183 --> 02:27:40.918
ASKING US TO LOOK AT FUNDING
02:27:40.985 --> 02:27:42.019
THAT IS GOING TO EACH OF THESE
02:27:42.086 --> 02:27:44.322
COUNTIES. AND THE AMOUNT THAT
02:27:44.388 --> 02:27:45.022
IS GOING TO SHERIFF'S
02:27:45.089 --> 02:27:46.224
DEPARTMENT'S BUT WE ALSO IN
02:27:46.290 --> 02:27:47.658
HAPPEN THE OBJECTIVE ANY OTHER
02:27:47.725 --> 02:27:48.859
RELEVANT DEPARTMENT SO THAT
02:27:48.926 --> 02:27:50.127
WOULD ON ALL LIKELIHOOD PICK UP
02:27:50.194 --> 02:27:51.696
THE PROBATION DEPARTMENTS. IN
02:27:51.762 --> 02:27:53.664
THESE THREE COUNTIES ALSO
02:27:53.731 --> 02:27:54.799
LOOKING AT WHAT THE COUNTIES
02:27:54.865 --> 02:27:56.467
ARE PROJECTING AS FAR AS FUTURE
02:27:56.534 --> 02:27:57.702
REALIGNMENT FUNDING THAT THEY
02:27:57.768 --> 02:27:59.870
WILL RECEIVE. THEN ON THE FLIP
02:27:59.937 --> 02:28:01.372
SIDE LOOKING AT EXPENDITURES
02:28:01.439 --> 02:28:02.974
AND THE CATEGORIES OF
02:28:03.040 --> 02:28:04.675
EXPENDITURES FIRST OF ALL. ARE
02:28:04.742 --> 02:28:06.577
THE ARE THE COUNTIES OUT
02:28:06.644 --> 02:28:07.578
SPENDING ALL THE FUNDS THEY'RE
02:28:07.645 --> 02:28:10.481
RECEIVING BURST. A SECOND IT IT
02:28:10.548 --> 02:28:12.316
IN THAT FOR THE EXPENDITURES
02:28:12.383 --> 02:28:13.784
WHAT MAJOR CATEGORIES
02:28:13.851 --> 02:28:16.087
ENFORCEMENT TREATMENT- AN
02:28:16.153 --> 02:28:17.555
OPERATION SO HOW MUCH ARE THEY
02:28:17.622 --> 02:28:18.990
SPENDING ON ENFORCEMENT VERSUS
02:28:19.056 --> 02:28:20.124
TREATMENT OF THE AT THE
02:28:20.191 --> 02:28:21.359
INDIVIDUALS AND IN THEIR
02:28:21.425 --> 02:28:23.127
RESPECTIVE JAILS. AND FOR
02:28:23.194 --> 02:28:25.463
OPERATIONS. AND THEN WHETHER OR
02:28:25.529 --> 02:28:26.764
NOT THESE EXPENDITURES THAT WE
02:28:26.831 --> 02:28:29.734
LOOK AT OUR ACTUALLY CONSISTENT
02:28:29.800 --> 02:28:31.335
WITH REALIGNMENT REQUIREMENTS.
02:28:31.402 --> 02:28:32.336
AND THEN THE FINAL TWO
02:28:32.403 --> 02:28:34.372
OBJECTIVES EVALUATING AGAIN
02:28:34.438 --> 02:28:36.307
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES ARE AT
02:28:36.374 --> 02:28:37.808
EACH OF THE RESPECTIVE OF
02:28:37.875 --> 02:28:39.443
FACILITIES ARE THREE RESPECTIVE
02:28:39.510 --> 02:28:41.078
COUNTIES. ARE TO DETERMINE
02:28:41.145 --> 02:28:42.480
WHETHER THEIR BEST PRACTICES IN
02:28:42.546 --> 02:28:44.649
OPPORTUNITIES TO IMPROVE NOT
02:28:44.715 --> 02:28:46.050
ONLY ACCOUNTABILITY OF THEIR
02:28:46.117 --> 02:28:47.818
FINANCES AND REALIGNMENT FUNDS
02:28:47.885 --> 02:28:49.387
BUT TRANSPARENCY OF THAT.
02:28:49.453 --> 02:28:51.088
OVERSIGHT OF THE USE OF THOSE
02:28:51.155 --> 02:28:53.324
FUNDS AND THEN FINALLY- TRYING
02:28:53.391 --> 02:28:54.925
TO DETERMINE THE IMPACT OF
02:28:54.992 --> 02:28:57.228
REALIGNMENT ON EACH JAILS
02:28:57.295 --> 02:28:58.529
POPULATION. NOT JAIL STAFF BUT
02:28:58.596 --> 02:29:00.531
ENFORCEMENT AND POTENTIALLY
02:29:00.598 --> 02:29:02.066
LOOKING AT WHAT'S OCCURRING IN
02:29:02.133 --> 02:29:03.834
THE SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES-
02:29:03.901 --> 02:29:05.636
THE BUDGET FOR THIS AUDIT ABOUT
02:29:05.703 --> 02:29:06.871
TWENTY SIX A LITTLE OVER TWENTY
02:29:06.937 --> 02:29:07.772
SIX HUNDRED HOURS. THAT WOULD
02:29:07.838 --> 02:29:09.073
TAKE US A LITTLE OVER SIX
02:29:09.140 --> 02:29:10.408
MONTHS TO COMPLETE. THANK YOU
02:29:10.474 --> 02:29:12.943
MISTER CHAIR. THANK YOU MADAM
02:29:13.010 --> 02:29:14.278
AUDITOR OKAY AT THIS TIME IS
02:29:14.345 --> 02:29:15.246
GOING TO MOVE TO THE AFFECTED
02:29:15.313 --> 02:29:16.647
AGENCIES THIRTY AFFECTED
02:29:16.714 --> 02:29:18.215
AGENCIES I WISH TO SPEAK ON
02:29:18.282 --> 02:29:25.923
THIS AGENDA ITEM. PLEASE JOIN
02:29:25.990 --> 02:29:36.901
US UP HERE. YOU CAN BEGIN BY
02:29:36.967 --> 02:29:38.569
ANNOUNCING A YOUR NAME AND
02:29:38.636 --> 02:29:40.237
WHICH CITY OR WITH OKAY I'M NOT
02:29:40.304 --> 02:29:41.605
SURE OF GREG AARON ALAMEDA
02:29:41.672 --> 02:29:43.407
COUNTY SHERIFF THANK YOU ON A
02:29:43.474 --> 02:29:46.677
COUPLE THINGS- REGARDS TO THE
02:29:46.744 --> 02:29:51.315
AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT WE- OKAY.
02:29:51.382 --> 02:29:53.484
CAN I HAVE ONE PERSON ALLOW THE
02:29:53.551 --> 02:29:59.890
ADDITIONAL. FOR SOME TESTS.
02:29:59.957 --> 02:30:02.393
PLEASE FUNDS FOR A AB ONE OH
02:30:02.460 --> 02:30:04.862
NINE OR- CONTROLLED BY THE
02:30:04.929 --> 02:30:06.797
PROBATION OFFICERS IN EACH
02:30:06.864 --> 02:30:08.232
COUNTY AND THERE ALLOCATED TO.
02:30:08.299 --> 02:30:12.136
OF THE DIFFERENT ENTITIES BASED
02:30:12.203 --> 02:30:16.107
ON APPROVAL FROM THE A-
02:30:16.173 --> 02:30:17.108
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS
02:30:17.174 --> 02:30:19.844
PARTNERSHIP OF SO THE SHERIFF'S
02:30:19.910 --> 02:30:22.513
OFFICE SIMPLY REQUEST THE FUNDS
02:30:22.580 --> 02:30:25.383
AND IN OUR CASE OF. A 50% OF
02:30:25.449 --> 02:30:26.550
MONEY GOES OUT TO COMMITTEE
02:30:26.617 --> 02:30:28.719
BASED ORGANIZATIONS TO HELP
02:30:28.786 --> 02:30:30.588
FACILITATE OF THE INMATES AND
02:30:30.654 --> 02:30:34.291
RE ENTRY WHILE THE FUNDS THAT
02:30:34.358 --> 02:30:35.993
ASSURES OFFIC ALAMEDA COUNTY
02:30:36.060 --> 02:30:38.562
SHERIFF'S OFFICERS ARE A DIRECT
02:30:38.629 --> 02:30:41.265
PAYMENT FOR THE NUMBER OF DAYS
02:30:41.332 --> 02:30:43.234
AND MAJOR SPENT IN CUSTODY
02:30:43.300 --> 02:30:45.369
CHARGED AT AN AVERAGE DAILY
02:30:45.436 --> 02:30:50.074
RATE. AND SO- WE BILL BASICALLY
02:30:50.141 --> 02:30:52.576
FOR EACH DAY THAT WE HAVE THE
02:30:52.643 --> 02:30:56.347
PEOPLE IN CUSTODY ARE RELATED
02:30:56.414 --> 02:30:58.149
TO AB ONE NINE. A NEXT SOME OF
02:30:58.215 --> 02:31:01.252
THE NUMBERS THAT- WERE-
02:31:01.318 --> 02:31:04.054
DEDICATED TO OTHERS BODY A
02:31:04.121 --> 02:31:05.623
SHOWED THAT THE WERE
02:31:05.689 --> 02:31:08.225
RESPONSIBLE FOR A FORTY FIVE
02:31:08.292 --> 02:31:10.327
THAT'S WHEN IN FACT WE BELIEVE
02:31:10.394 --> 02:31:12.496
THAT NUMBER TO BE THIRTY NINE
02:31:12.563 --> 02:31:14.298
TO US AND WE- UNDERSTAND THAT
02:31:14.365 --> 02:31:16.333
ONE DEATH IS TOO MANY. AND WE
02:31:16.400 --> 02:31:19.303
MONITOR OF THOSE WE HAVE A
02:31:19.370 --> 02:31:22.106
OVERSIGHT- ALREADY IN PLACE-
02:31:22.173 --> 02:31:23.874
THE DEALS WITH OUR- MEDICAL
02:31:23.941 --> 02:31:25.509
PROGRAM OR MENTAL HEALTH
02:31:25.576 --> 02:31:28.612
PROGRAM AND ARE OF. ISSUES
02:31:28.679 --> 02:31:31.449
REGARDING THE DEATHS THAT OCCUR
02:31:31.515 --> 02:31:33.851
IN INSIDETHE FACILITY AND I'D
02:31:33.918 --> 02:31:34.819
BE WILLING TO ANSWER ANY
02:31:34.885 --> 02:31:36.821
QUESTIONS THAT- YOU MIGHT HAVE
02:31:36.887 --> 02:31:39.089
THANK YOU PLEASE ADDITIONAL
02:31:39.156 --> 02:31:40.624
TESTIMONY. PLEASE ANNOUNCE
02:31:40.691 --> 02:31:42.359
YOURSELF US WELL FOR THE RECORD
02:31:42.426 --> 02:31:45.262
MARGARET MEN SHARE FOR FRESNO
02:31:45.329 --> 02:31:47.965
COUNTY I DID. REALIGNMENT WAS
02:31:48.032 --> 02:31:50.835
ESTABLISHED AS- PREVIOUSLY
02:31:50.901 --> 02:31:52.470
OUTLINED. AND THE REALIGNMENT
02:31:52.536 --> 02:31:53.871
MANY THAT CAME TO COUNTIES WAS
02:31:53.938 --> 02:31:55.773
TO OFFSET THE IMPACTS OF THAT
02:31:55.840 --> 02:31:57.875
REALIGNMENT. IN THE IMPACTS
02:31:57.942 --> 02:32:00.277
WERE GREAT FOR INSTANCE 50% OF
02:32:00.344 --> 02:32:01.979
THE PAROLE SUPERVISION CASES
02:32:02.046 --> 02:32:03.914
NOW ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF
02:32:03.981 --> 02:32:06.250
COUNTY PROBATION DEPARTMENT THE
02:32:06.317 --> 02:32:08.419
WAY THE FUNDS GET ALLOCATED AND
02:32:08.486 --> 02:32:10.020
THE OVERSIGHT IS THROUGH OUR
02:32:10.087 --> 02:32:11.288
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS
02:32:11.355 --> 02:32:13.858
PARTNERSHIP. A SEVEN MEMBER A
02:32:13.924 --> 02:32:16.026
COMMITTEE THAT MAKES A DECISION
02:32:16.093 --> 02:32:18.929
ON HOW THE FUNDING IS ALLOCATED
02:32:18.996 --> 02:32:21.699
DEPENDING ON THE PRESENTATIONS
02:32:21.765 --> 02:32:22.299
THAT ARE PROVIDED BEFORE THAT
02:32:22.366 --> 02:32:25.035
COMMITTEE. SO AS A SHERIFF'S
02:32:25.102 --> 02:32:26.770
OFFICE AND ANYBODY THAT WANTS
02:32:26.837 --> 02:32:29.707
TO TALK ABOUT NEEDING CCP MONEY
02:32:29.773 --> 02:32:31.575
HOW WE MAKE THAT PRESENTATION
02:32:31.642 --> 02:32:33.077
THE COMMITTEE OF SEVEN MEMBERS
02:32:33.143 --> 02:32:36.013
THAN VOTES. AFTER WE VOTE ON
02:32:36.080 --> 02:32:37.982
HOW ARE BUDGET WILL GO FOR THE
02:32:38.048 --> 02:32:39.750
YEAR AT THE IT'S NOT OVER
02:32:39.817 --> 02:32:41.485
THAT'S NOT THE FINAL APPROVAL
02:32:41.552 --> 02:32:42.319
GOES ON TO OUR BOARD OF
02:32:42.386 --> 02:32:44.788
SUPERVISORS WHO THEN APPROVED
02:32:44.855 --> 02:32:47.825
THE BUDGET OR CAN DENY. AT THE
02:32:47.892 --> 02:32:50.461
BUDGET THAT IS PRESENTED. SO AT
02:32:50.528 --> 02:32:52.263
AND ALSO RECENTLY WE'VE WE'VE
02:32:52.329 --> 02:32:54.331
HAD AN AUDIT OF FINANCIAL AUDIT
02:32:54.398 --> 02:32:56.333
OF OUR C. C. P. IN THE WE ARE
02:32:56.400 --> 02:32:58.168
FUNDS ARE REALIGNMENT FUNDS ARE
02:32:58.235 --> 02:33:01.505
SPENT- BROWN ARMSTRONG DID THE
02:33:01.572 --> 02:33:03.641
AUDIT. THERE WERE NO FINDINGS
02:33:03.707 --> 02:33:06.343
NOTE NO EXCEPTIONS A WE SPEND
02:33:06.410 --> 02:33:07.912
96% OF THE MONEY THAT WE GET
02:33:07.978 --> 02:33:11.215
FROM A REALIGNMENT. I AM AT HAD
02:33:11.282 --> 02:33:12.349
ANY OF THESE QUESTIONS BEEN
02:33:12.416 --> 02:33:13.984
ASKED OF ME BEFOREHAND I WOULD
02:33:14.051 --> 02:33:15.119
I WOULD CERTAINLY HAVE ANSWERED
02:33:15.185 --> 02:33:17.555
THESE QUESTIONS. ABOUT WE HAVE
02:33:17.621 --> 02:33:19.056
RECENTLY HAD AN AUDIT THE
02:33:19.123 --> 02:33:20.491
FUNDING DOES HAVE OVERSIGHT
02:33:20.558 --> 02:33:21.992
WITH R. C. C. P. OUR BOARD OF
02:33:22.059 --> 02:33:25.996
SUPERVISORS. AT AN OUT ALL
02:33:26.063 --> 02:33:26.564
INTERNET QUESTIONS THAT YOU
02:33:26.630 --> 02:33:29.400
HAVE. THANK YOU SHERIFF- AT
02:33:29.466 --> 02:33:31.268
THIS TIME LET ME ASK IF. I
02:33:31.335 --> 02:33:31.802
DON'T BELIEVE THERE'S ANY
02:33:31.869 --> 02:33:33.504
ADDITIONAL AGENCIES AND THE
02:33:33.571 --> 02:33:35.172
ROOMS THAT ARE AFFECTED.
02:33:35.239 --> 02:33:36.173
HEARING IN SAYING THAT LET ME
02:33:36.240 --> 02:33:37.241
TURN IT BACK TO MEMBERS ON THE
02:33:37.308 --> 02:33:38.509
DíAS FOR QUESTIONS ON A
02:33:38.576 --> 02:33:39.710
SOUTHERN BORDER JUST IF YOU
02:33:39.777 --> 02:33:41.745
LIKE. TO BEGIN PLEASE THANK YOU
02:33:41.812 --> 02:33:44.214
CHAIRMAN OF WE HAD A VERY
02:33:44.281 --> 02:33:45.215
INTERESTINGAND I THINK
02:33:45.282 --> 02:33:48.419
CONSTRUCTIVE- CONVERSATION ON.
02:33:48.485 --> 02:33:49.920
SOMETHING ANALOGOUS TO WHAT
02:33:49.987 --> 02:33:53.123
WE'RE EXPERIENCING HERE- WHAT
02:33:53.190 --> 02:33:55.726
IS THE ROLE OF THIS BODYAND
02:33:55.793 --> 02:33:58.495
WERE RISE TO THE LEVEL- SUBJECT
02:33:58.562 --> 02:34:00.598
MATTER WISE AND PROCESS WAS-
02:34:00.664 --> 02:34:03.300
DESERVING- AN AUDIT. ESPECIALLY
02:34:03.367 --> 02:34:05.002
ONE THAT RAISES THE LEVEL OF
02:34:05.069 --> 02:34:06.203
THREE HUNDRED AND FIFTY
02:34:06.270 --> 02:34:08.038
THOUSAND DOLLARS WHICH IS NOT
02:34:08.105 --> 02:34:13.477
CHUMP CHANGE. I LOOKED AT A
02:34:13.544 --> 02:34:14.845
JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
02:34:14.912 --> 02:34:17.147
COMMITTEE SHEET HERE. AND IT
02:34:17.214 --> 02:34:19.450
KIND OF CONFIRMED INTUITIVELY I
02:34:19.516 --> 02:34:20.684
THINK WHAT WE TALKED ABOUT
02:34:20.751 --> 02:34:23.621
BEFORE. WHAT THE PROCESS IS FOR
02:34:23.687 --> 02:34:25.489
SOMEONE ORDERS IN ORGANIZATION
02:34:25.556 --> 02:34:28.626
TO ELEVATE. A MATTER TO YOU-
02:34:28.692 --> 02:34:31.195
PURPOSES OF A OF AN AUDIT. AND
02:34:31.261 --> 02:34:33.330
I THINK THIS IS THE INFORMATION
02:34:33.397 --> 02:34:34.131
SHEET THAT EVERYONE FILLS OUT
02:34:34.198 --> 02:34:37.334
WHEN THEY- OF PUT FORWARD. A
02:34:37.401 --> 02:34:42.106
REQUEST. IT HAS- IT'S CALLED
02:34:42.172 --> 02:34:43.307
THE INFORMATION SHEET FROM
02:34:43.374 --> 02:34:44.308
JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
02:34:44.375 --> 02:34:46.076
COMMITTEE THE REASON I BRING IT
02:34:46.143 --> 02:34:49.580
UP IS THAT ON- NUMBER SIX
02:34:49.647 --> 02:34:51.215
SEVEN. THE QUESTION IS
02:34:51.281 --> 02:34:52.449
EXPLAINED THE STEPS YOU'VE
02:34:52.516 --> 02:34:54.485
TAKEN TO ADDRESS THE ISSUE OR
02:34:54.551 --> 02:34:57.554
TOPIC OF THE AUDIT. AND THE
02:34:57.621 --> 02:34:58.789
FIRST QUESTION IS HAVE YOU
02:34:58.856 --> 02:35:00.557
REQUESTED THE AGENCY TO PROVIDE
02:35:00.624 --> 02:35:02.159
THE INFORMATION YOU SEEK TO
02:35:02.226 --> 02:35:06.497
OBTAIN. IN THE AUDIT. SO I JUST
02:35:06.563 --> 02:35:09.333
LEARNED OF THIS AUDIT. RECENTLY
02:35:09.400 --> 02:35:11.835
AND I THINK OF FRESNO LEARNED
02:35:11.902 --> 02:35:13.370
OF IT NINETEEN THROUGH THE
02:35:13.437 --> 02:35:15.339
TWENTIETH LAST WEDNESDAY LAST
02:35:15.406 --> 02:35:17.374
WEDNESDAY ART SO WE KNOW OF
02:35:17.441 --> 02:35:19.643
ANOTHER SITUATION WHERE WE'RE
02:35:19.710 --> 02:35:21.378
WE'RE JUST FINDING OUT ABOUT IT.
02:35:21.445 --> 02:35:22.746
ADEQUATE PREPARATION MAY NOT
02:35:22.813 --> 02:35:25.416
HAVE ALLOWED FOR A GIVEN THE
02:35:25.482 --> 02:35:28.285
TIME CONSIDERATIONS. BUT THE
02:35:28.352 --> 02:35:29.653
SHERIFF MENTION A COUPLE THINGS
02:35:29.720 --> 02:35:32.356
I THINK ARE REALLY APPROPRIATE
02:35:32.423 --> 02:35:33.323
AND IMPORTANT FOR US TO
02:35:33.390 --> 02:35:35.192
APPRECIATE. THAT THERE WAS IT
02:35:35.259 --> 02:35:38.195
IN AUDIT OF FRESNO COUNTY BY A
02:35:38.262 --> 02:35:40.597
FIRM CALLED BROWN AND ARMSTRONG
02:35:40.664 --> 02:35:43.967
THAT- HAD FINDINGS RELEVANT TO
02:35:44.034 --> 02:35:46.103
THE AREAS IN OF THE SCOPE OF
02:35:46.170 --> 02:35:48.939
THIS PROPOSED INQUIRY- WINDED-
02:35:49.006 --> 02:35:51.709
THE REQUESTING PARTY. GET A
02:35:51.775 --> 02:35:53.444
COPY OF THAT BROWN ARMSTRONG.
02:35:53.510 --> 02:35:55.679
ARM AUDIT TO MY KNOWLEDGE IT
02:35:55.746 --> 02:35:58.916
WAS NEVER REQUESTED ALL RIGHT.
02:35:58.982 --> 02:36:00.751
THE OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE FOR THE
02:36:00.818 --> 02:36:04.588
BOARD OF SUPERVISOR- PROCESS
02:36:04.655 --> 02:36:06.223
THAT WENT THROUGH IN TERMS OF
02:36:06.290 --> 02:36:07.391
APPROPRIATING DOLLARS THAT DEAL
02:36:07.458 --> 02:36:10.227
WITH- ALL THE ISSUES THAT ARE
02:36:10.294 --> 02:36:13.030
BEING BROUGHT UP TODAY DID- AND
02:36:13.097 --> 02:36:15.332
AT THAT INFORMATION GET A QUICK
02:36:15.399 --> 02:36:16.200
REQUESTED AS WELL NOT TO MY
02:36:16.266 --> 02:36:18.102
KNOWLEDGE. ART SO I THINK WE
02:36:18.168 --> 02:36:19.770
HAVE A SITUATION HERE AGAIN
02:36:19.837 --> 02:36:24.475
WHERE. WE JUST FOUND OUT ABOUT
02:36:24.541 --> 02:36:26.376
THIS AUDIT. AND SOME OF THE
02:36:26.443 --> 02:36:28.746
MOST PRESSING IN CLEAR CUT
02:36:28.812 --> 02:36:30.547
OPPORTUNITIES TO PROVIDE
02:36:30.614 --> 02:36:33.484
INFORMATION WERE NOT PURSUED.
02:36:33.550 --> 02:36:35.652
AND IT'S EVEN NAME EVEN IN OUR
02:36:35.719 --> 02:36:38.255
OWN COMMITTEE PROCESS SO MY
02:36:38.322 --> 02:36:41.258
RECOMMENDATION IS THAT THE
02:36:41.325 --> 02:36:43.761
REQUESTING PARTY. DO THE DUE
02:36:43.827 --> 02:36:45.963
DILIGENCE GET THE INFORMATION
02:36:46.029 --> 02:36:49.600
FROM THESE THREE COUNTIES ARE
02:36:49.666 --> 02:36:51.902
TWO OF THE LEADERS ARE ALREADY
02:36:51.969 --> 02:36:53.270
HERE IS THAT A REASONABLE
02:36:53.337 --> 02:36:57.007
REQUEST I WOULD I THINK SO
02:36:57.074 --> 02:36:57.641
UNDER THE MICE YOU KNOW FOR MY
02:36:57.708 --> 02:37:00.511
STANDPOINT. AS WE WERE ASKING
02:37:00.577 --> 02:37:01.011
FOR THREE HUNDRED FIFTY
02:37:01.078 --> 02:37:02.646
THOUSAND DOLLARS TWENTY SIX
02:37:02.713 --> 02:37:04.948
HUNDRED WORK HOURS WORTH TWENTY
02:37:05.015 --> 02:37:05.716
TWO HUNDRED HOURS WORTH OF
02:37:05.783 --> 02:37:08.719
INVESTMENT. BINDING ON THE
02:37:08.786 --> 02:37:10.721
AUDIT DEPARTMENT I THINK IT
02:37:10.788 --> 02:37:12.790
NEEDS TO RISE TO A LEVEL THAT
02:37:12.856 --> 02:37:14.958
EITHER. YOU'VE DONE THE DUE
02:37:15.025 --> 02:37:16.660
DILIGENCE AND NOT GOTTEN THE
02:37:16.727 --> 02:37:17.995
INFORMATION YOU WANTED OR THE
02:37:18.061 --> 02:37:19.863
LEVEL OF SOPHISTICATION IS JUST
02:37:19.930 --> 02:37:21.832
TOO MUCH WHEN YOU NEED A THIRD
02:37:21.899 --> 02:37:24.401
PARTY TO INVOLVE THEMSELVES.
02:37:24.468 --> 02:37:24.968
BUT I THINK HAVING NOT DONE
02:37:25.035 --> 02:37:28.071
THAT. I THINK THAT THIS IS
02:37:28.138 --> 02:37:30.374
EARLY PREMATURE MIGHT IN MY
02:37:30.440 --> 02:37:31.408
OPINION AND RESPECTFULLY WOULD
02:37:31.475 --> 02:37:34.912
ASK MAYBE THE MAKER OF THIS-
02:37:34.978 --> 02:37:37.381
THIS AUDIT REQUEST WOULD IT GO
02:37:37.447 --> 02:37:39.449
BACK TO THOSE THREE COUNTIES
02:37:39.516 --> 02:37:40.717
GET THAT INFORMATION AND THEN
02:37:40.784 --> 02:37:42.452
IF THE IF YOU DON'T LIKE WHAT
02:37:42.519 --> 02:37:44.588
YOU GET PORTS INCOMPLETE. THEN
02:37:44.655 --> 02:37:46.590
BRING BACK THIS AUDIT REQUEST
02:37:46.657 --> 02:37:48.158
AND I THINK THAT WOULD MAKE IT
02:37:48.225 --> 02:37:49.760
A BILL YOU RIGHT REQUEST AT
02:37:49.827 --> 02:37:51.895
THAT TIME. TWENTY ASSEMBLY
02:37:51.962 --> 02:37:53.297
WOMAN IF YOU'D LIKE TO RESPOND
02:37:53.363 --> 02:37:55.632
WELL YES THANK YOU AND THANK
02:37:55.699 --> 02:37:57.467
YOU FOR- THE COMMENTS AND
02:37:57.534 --> 02:37:59.469
MAYBE- SOME OF THE ADVOCATES
02:37:59.536 --> 02:38:01.505
CAN ALSO RESPOND WE KNOW THAT
02:38:01.572 --> 02:38:03.574
REQUESTS AUDIT REQUESTS WERE
02:38:03.640 --> 02:38:06.376
ASKED- FOR ALAMEDA COUNTY AND
02:38:06.443 --> 02:38:07.911
OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY IN THOSE
02:38:07.978 --> 02:38:09.346
ON ITS HAVE NOT HAPPENED AND
02:38:09.413 --> 02:38:10.547
THAT'S BEEN. AS CONTENTIOUS
02:38:10.614 --> 02:38:11.815
CONVERSATION THAT'S BEEN
02:38:11.882 --> 02:38:12.683
HAPPENING IN BOTH OF THOSE
02:38:12.749 --> 02:38:14.685
COUNTIES RESPECTIVELY WE ALSO
02:38:14.751 --> 02:38:15.619
KNOW THAT NONE OF THESE
02:38:15.686 --> 02:38:17.487
COUNTIES HAVE THERE SEE C. PAP
02:38:17.554 --> 02:38:20.190
CURRENCY CPSC PLANS WHICH TALK
02:38:20.257 --> 02:38:22.392
ABOUT THE SPENDING. ON THE B.
02:38:22.459 --> 02:38:24.361
SEC WEBSITE AND THIS IS A
02:38:24.428 --> 02:38:26.630
WEBSITE WHERE YOU CAN GO TO GET
02:38:26.697 --> 02:38:27.931
INFORMATION ON HOW THE
02:38:27.998 --> 02:38:28.765
DIFFERENT DEPARTMENTS ARE
02:38:28.832 --> 02:38:30.434
SPENDING IN ALLOCATING THE
02:38:30.500 --> 02:38:32.603
MONIES AND WE HAVE HAD.NO
02:38:32.669 --> 02:38:34.872
UPDATED PLANS SENSE IN SOME
02:38:34.938 --> 02:38:37.241
INSTANCES TWENTY ELEVEN OR
02:38:37.307 --> 02:38:37.808
TWENTY FOURTEEN IT DOES SAY
02:38:37.875 --> 02:38:39.142
THAT THEY DO NOT HAVE TO REVISE
02:38:39.209 --> 02:38:41.245
IT BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT IF
02:38:41.311 --> 02:38:42.913
THEY ARE MAKING CHANGES AND HOW
02:38:42.980 --> 02:38:43.547
THEY'RE SPENDING THE
02:38:43.614 --> 02:38:45.449
REALIGNMENT FUNDS. THAT WE AS A
02:38:45.515 --> 02:38:47.651
STATE AND AS COUNTIES HAVE AN
02:38:47.718 --> 02:38:50.053
OPPORTUNITY AN OBLIGATION TO BE
02:38:50.120 --> 02:38:53.924
ABLE TO ACCESS THAT INFORMATION.
02:38:53.991 --> 02:38:55.359
I WOULD JUST ADD LEASE. I WOULD
02:38:55.425 --> 02:38:56.393
JUST ADD TO THIS CONVERSATION I
02:38:56.460 --> 02:38:57.861
THINK IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY WE
02:38:57.928 --> 02:39:00.297
CERTAINLY. HAD A NUMEROUS.
02:39:00.364 --> 02:39:01.798
ATTEMPTS BAR COUNTY BOARD OF
02:39:01.865 --> 02:39:02.766
SUPERVISORS TO ACTUALLY GET
02:39:02.833 --> 02:39:04.034
INFORMATION FROM THE COUNTY
02:39:04.101 --> 02:39:05.602
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT CLOTHING-
02:39:05.669 --> 02:39:06.904
INFORMATION ON THE CAUSES
02:39:06.970 --> 02:39:08.038
DEATHS THAT HAPPEN INSIDE THE
02:39:08.105 --> 02:39:08.972
COUNTY JAILS INCLUDING
02:39:09.039 --> 02:39:10.407
INFORMATION ABOUT WHY. THE
02:39:10.474 --> 02:39:11.041
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENTS
02:39:11.108 --> 02:39:12.709
REQUESTING THREE POINT NINE
02:39:12.776 --> 02:39:15.045
BILLION DOLLARS- FOR ITS BUDGET
02:39:15.112 --> 02:39:16.413
DESPITE THE FREEZE THAT HAS
02:39:16.480 --> 02:39:17.648
HAPPENED AND DESPITE A LACK OF
02:39:17.714 --> 02:39:19.349
TRANSPARENCY AROUND HOW THESE.
02:39:19.416 --> 02:39:20.918
FUNDS ARE SPENT AND SO THERE IS
02:39:20.984 --> 02:39:21.785
CERTAINLY A TRACK RECORD IN
02:39:21.852 --> 02:39:23.954
WHICH WE COULD PROVIDE YOU- A
02:39:24.021 --> 02:39:25.022
LIST OF SOME OF THOSE MOTIONS
02:39:25.088 --> 02:39:26.156
AND OUTCOMES OF SOME THOSE
02:39:26.223 --> 02:39:26.657
MOTIONS THAT HAVE BEEN
02:39:26.723 --> 02:39:28.025
UNSATISFACTORY TO THE COUNTY
02:39:28.091 --> 02:39:30.794
AND CERTAINLY TO US. AS WHO
02:39:30.861 --> 02:39:32.896
FOLKS OF LOVE ONCE INSIDE.
02:39:32.963 --> 02:39:35.933
THANK YOU IF ALL QUESTIONS ARE
02:39:35.999 --> 02:39:38.101
BORDERS ARE PRECISELY I THINK-
02:39:38.168 --> 02:39:40.103
AND- I THINK WE'VE HEARD FROM
02:39:40.170 --> 02:39:41.905
SOME FOLKS THAT THERE MIGHT BE
02:39:41.972 --> 02:39:43.173
INSTANCES WHERE THINGS HAVE NOT
02:39:43.240 --> 02:39:44.374
BEEN PRODUCED AND SHOULD HAVE
02:39:44.441 --> 02:39:45.208
BEEN OR COULD HAVE BEEN
02:39:45.275 --> 02:39:47.377
PRODUCED AND WARRANT WE HAVE A
02:39:47.444 --> 02:39:49.746
GLARING SITUATION HERE AT LEAST
02:39:49.813 --> 02:39:52.115
ONE POSSIBLY TWO COUNTIES. ARE
02:39:52.182 --> 02:39:55.352
WHERE REQUEST HAD NOT EVEN BEEN
02:39:55.419 --> 02:39:58.755
MADE. LIKE I DON'T WANT TO
02:39:58.822 --> 02:40:01.491
PREJUDGE SITUATION BUT- I WOULD
02:40:01.558 --> 02:40:03.026
MAKE ONE FINAL RESPECTFUL
02:40:03.093 --> 02:40:05.862
REQUEST. BRING THIS MATTER BACK
02:40:05.929 --> 02:40:08.131
IN AT IF YOU'RE NOT ABLE TO
02:40:08.198 --> 02:40:10.500
GET. WE HAVE OUT FRESNO ONE
02:40:10.567 --> 02:40:13.003
ALAMEDA- I WOULD JUST
02:40:13.070 --> 02:40:14.204
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOU
02:40:14.271 --> 02:40:16.006
CONSIDER IT I HEAR YOU I ALSO
02:40:16.073 --> 02:40:17.641
KNOW THAT THEIR OF BEEN
02:40:17.708 --> 02:40:19.176
CONVERSATIONS OF THE BOARD OF
02:40:19.242 --> 02:40:20.577
SUPERVISORS LEVEL AT ALAMEDA
02:40:20.644 --> 02:40:21.945
COUNTY WORK COMMUNITY HAS
02:40:22.012 --> 02:40:23.480
REQUESTED AUDIENCE. AND THEY
02:40:23.547 --> 02:40:25.148
HAVEN'T RECEIVED THEM AND SO WE
02:40:25.215 --> 02:40:26.216
HAVE ONCE AGAIN AND TALKING TO
02:40:26.283 --> 02:40:27.317
ADVOCATES AND PEOPLE IN THE
02:40:27.384 --> 02:40:28.852
VARIOUS COUNTIES AND LOOKING AT
02:40:28.919 --> 02:40:29.786
THE NUMBER OF SHERIFF'S
02:40:29.853 --> 02:40:31.588
DEPARTMENTS ACROSS THE STATE.
02:40:31.655 --> 02:40:32.589
AND WHAT'S BEING DONE WITH
02:40:32.656 --> 02:40:33.790
REALIGNMENT OR WHAT WE DON'T
02:40:33.857 --> 02:40:35.859
KNOW WHAT'S BEING DONE WITH
02:40:35.926 --> 02:40:36.560
REALIGNMENT DOLLARS YOU KNOW
02:40:36.626 --> 02:40:39.696
WE'VE- LOOKED AT SOME OF THE
02:40:39.763 --> 02:40:41.965
CAR FEW OF THE DEPARTMENTS
02:40:42.032 --> 02:40:43.567
WHERE EITHER MOST EGREGIOUS
02:40:43.633 --> 02:40:44.968
ACTIVITIES. HAVE BEEN TAKING
02:40:45.035 --> 02:40:47.804
PLACE OR WHERE THERE'S JUST A
02:40:47.871 --> 02:40:49.172
HIGH DEGREE OF OPAQUE MATH.
02:40:49.239 --> 02:40:50.507
THANK YOU WITH THAT WE'RE GONNA
02:40:50.574 --> 02:40:51.074
BE GOING TO MOVE TO SENATOR
02:40:51.141 --> 02:40:56.646
ROTH. LET ME JUST A OFFICE MY
02:40:56.713 --> 02:40:58.815
COMMENTS BY SAYING HOW MUCH
02:40:58.882 --> 02:41:00.117
RESPECT I HAVE FOR THE
02:41:00.183 --> 02:41:02.252
REQUESTER AND THE SPECTACULAR
02:41:02.319 --> 02:41:04.721
JOB THAT SHE DOES- IN THE
02:41:04.788 --> 02:41:06.690
ASSEMBLY AND CERTAINLY WITH
02:41:06.757 --> 02:41:09.393
THIS REQUEST FRANKLY I.
02:41:09.459 --> 02:41:12.796
REVIEWED MY- BINDER- OVER THE
02:41:12.863 --> 02:41:17.434
pPREPARED TO OF. VOTE TO APPROVE
02:41:17.501 --> 02:41:19.469
THIS REQUEST BUT I HAVE TO
02:41:19.536 --> 02:41:22.672
JOIN. IN THE COMMENTS OF MY
02:41:22.739 --> 02:41:24.674
COLLEAGUE ONCE AGAIN A- I'M
02:41:24.741 --> 02:41:26.576
BOTHERED BY THE FACT THAT IT'S
02:41:26.643 --> 02:41:30.514
A. ENTITIES THAT ARE BEING
02:41:30.580 --> 02:41:34.885
AUDITED DON'T GET SUFFICIENT.
02:41:34.951 --> 02:41:36.920
ADVANCE NOTICE OF THE FACT OF
02:41:36.987 --> 02:41:38.455
THE AUDIT REQUEST IN THE
02:41:38.522 --> 02:41:41.291
DETAILS SURROUNDING IT TO COME
02:41:41.358 --> 02:41:43.393
TO THIS HEARING THAT WE HAVE
02:41:43.460 --> 02:41:47.397
PREPARED TO ADDRESS THE REQUEST.
02:41:47.464 --> 02:41:50.200
PROVIDE INFORMATION THAT MIGHT
02:41:50.267 --> 02:41:54.704
ENABLE US TO- BUT JUST THE
02:41:54.771 --> 02:41:55.205
SCOPE OF THE AUDIT WERE
02:41:55.272 --> 02:41:58.275
APPROPRIATE. ANNA I THINK THAT
02:41:58.341 --> 02:42:01.745
MAY. REFLECT A STRUCTURAL
02:42:01.812 --> 02:42:04.081
DEFECT THEY WE HAVE PERHAPS IN
02:42:04.147 --> 02:42:06.850
OUR PROCESS IF WE HAVE AUDIT
02:42:06.917 --> 02:42:08.752
REQUESTS AND IF RESPONDING
02:42:08.819 --> 02:42:10.220
ENTITIES COME HERE WITH SO
02:42:10.287 --> 02:42:12.255
WEEKS NOTICE FOR FIVE DAYS
02:42:12.322 --> 02:42:14.458
THREE DAYS NOTICE OR WHATEVER
02:42:14.524 --> 02:42:16.760
THE NOTICE PERIOD IS. IT MAY
02:42:16.827 --> 02:42:18.895
VERY WELL BE THAT WE VOTE TO
02:42:18.962 --> 02:42:20.897
APPROVE THE AUDIT ANYWAY AND I
02:42:20.964 --> 02:42:22.933
CERTAINLY THINK THAT. IN THIS
02:42:22.999 --> 02:42:24.634
PARTICULAR AREA THERE PROBABLY
02:42:24.701 --> 02:42:27.137
NEEDS TO BE A NOT IT SOMEWHERE
02:42:27.204 --> 02:42:29.406
SOMEHOW. BUT I AM CONCERNED
02:42:29.473 --> 02:42:31.241
ABOUT THE FACT THAT WE'RE BEING
02:42:31.308 --> 02:42:32.943
ASKED TO PROVIDE IT'S WHERE THE
02:42:33.009 --> 02:42:34.077
RESPONDING ENTITIES DON'T
02:42:34.144 --> 02:42:35.579
REALLY HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:42:35.645 --> 02:42:37.247
COME IN HERE WITH THEIR- PLATE
02:42:37.314 --> 02:42:39.649
OF INFORMATION THAT ENABLES US
02:42:39.716 --> 02:42:41.051
TO MAKE AN INFORMED DECISION ON
02:42:41.118 --> 02:42:42.719
THE- THE WAY THE AUDIT IS
02:42:42.786 --> 02:42:47.457
FRAMED THE SCOPE OF THE IT SO.
02:42:47.524 --> 02:42:48.825
HAVING SAID I DON'T HAVE A
02:42:48.892 --> 02:42:50.260
QUESTION I'M JUST NAY ACUTE
02:42:50.327 --> 02:42:51.795
JOINING IN THE COMMENTS OF MY
02:42:51.862 --> 02:42:55.532
COLLEAGUE. IT IT CAUSES ME TO
02:42:55.599 --> 02:42:58.201
BE UNCOMFORTABLE. AS A MEMBER
02:42:58.268 --> 02:42:59.936
OF A JOINT LEGISLATIVE AUDIT
02:43:00.003 --> 02:43:01.905
COMMITTEE APPROVING THE
02:43:01.972 --> 02:43:03.473
EXPENDITURE OF NOT IN
02:43:03.540 --> 02:43:05.041
SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNTS OF MONEY
02:43:05.108 --> 02:43:07.377
APPROVING ANY IN ESSENCE THE
02:43:07.444 --> 02:43:09.679
SCOPE OF AN AUDITING THAT IS
02:43:09.746 --> 02:43:14.518
FRAMED BY THE REQUEST. HOWEVER
02:43:14.584 --> 02:43:16.353
WELL RESPECTED BY ME AND OTHERS
02:43:16.419 --> 02:43:18.588
AND HOWEVER WILL ROUTE-
02:43:18.655 --> 02:43:21.591
RESPECTED BY MY COLLEAGUES. AND
02:43:21.658 --> 02:43:22.959
JOINED IN BY THE AUDITOR WHEN
02:43:23.026 --> 02:43:23.827
WE DON'T HAVE ENOUGH
02:43:23.894 --> 02:43:25.028
INFORMATION TO DECIDE WHETHER
02:43:25.095 --> 02:43:26.263
THAT'S THE SCOPE OF THE AUDIT
02:43:26.329 --> 02:43:27.531
THAT SHOULD BE APPROVED OR NOT
02:43:27.597 --> 02:43:29.633
PERHAPS. AND I DON'T KNOW HOW
02:43:29.699 --> 02:43:31.768
WE DEAL WITH THAT. MAYBE I
02:43:31.835 --> 02:43:33.403
COULD SHED SOME LIGHT ON THIS
02:43:33.470 --> 02:43:34.037
RIGHT JUST BECAUSE HISTORICALLY
02:43:34.104 --> 02:43:36.173
SPEAKING- WE'VE ALLOWED THE
02:43:36.239 --> 02:43:38.175
REQUEST YOUR ONE TO TWO WEEKS
02:43:38.241 --> 02:43:39.342
BEFORE THE HEARING TO ACTUALLY
02:43:39.409 --> 02:43:41.011
ADJUST THE SCOPE BASED OFF
02:43:41.077 --> 02:43:42.345
THEIR CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
02:43:42.412 --> 02:43:44.948
ENTITIES INVOLVED. I SEEMS TO
02:43:45.015 --> 02:43:46.316
ME THAT TODAY'S HEARING THERE
02:43:46.383 --> 02:43:48.185
SEEMS TO BE TWO DIFFERENT.
02:43:48.251 --> 02:43:50.053
THINGS GOING ON ONE IS THE
02:43:50.120 --> 02:43:52.122
ACTUAL NOTIFICATION WHICH WE'VE
02:43:52.189 --> 02:43:53.657
GIVEN DEFERENCE TO EACH OTHER
02:43:53.723 --> 02:43:55.859
OUR COLLEAGUES TO CHANGE THE
02:43:55.926 --> 02:43:57.260
SCOPE WITHIN ONE TO TWO WEEKS
02:43:57.327 --> 02:43:59.062
BEFORE AND SECONDLY WHETHER THE
02:43:59.129 --> 02:44:00.964
REQUESTED ARE ACTUALLY REACHING
02:44:01.031 --> 02:44:02.132
OUT TO THE IT TO THE ENTITIES
02:44:02.199 --> 02:44:03.567
INVOLVED WHEN THEY'RE EXPLORING
02:44:03.633 --> 02:44:05.602
THE IDEA. OF A POSSIBLE I
02:44:05.669 --> 02:44:08.338
REQUEST AND IT'S AND IT SEEMS
02:44:08.405 --> 02:44:12.008
TO ME THAT- THE LATTER IS THAT
02:44:12.075 --> 02:44:13.510
SEEMS LIKE WERE REQUESTING OF
02:44:13.577 --> 02:44:14.978
OUR COLLEAGUES IS IF THEY COULD
02:44:15.045 --> 02:44:17.981
AT LEAST GIVE A- HEADS UP OR
02:44:18.048 --> 02:44:19.082
HAVE A DISCUSSION WITH THE
02:44:19.149 --> 02:44:20.550
MEMBER ONE WHOSE JURISDICTION
02:44:20.617 --> 02:44:24.321
THAT A FAX. AND SECONDLY-
02:44:24.387 --> 02:44:25.722
PERHAPS EVEN CONTACTING SOME
02:44:25.789 --> 02:44:26.590
THE AGENCIES PRIOR TO
02:44:26.656 --> 02:44:29.626
SUBMITTING A REQUEST TO THE
02:44:29.693 --> 02:44:31.228
ATTIC BUT- READ. MISTER CHAIR
02:44:31.294 --> 02:44:33.797
IF I MAY BE IF I MAY JUST.
02:44:33.863 --> 02:44:36.066
FURTHER MY COMMENT THEN I GUESS
02:44:36.132 --> 02:44:37.133
THE QUESTION I HAVE IS WHAT IS
02:44:37.200 --> 02:44:39.569
OUR ROLE ARE WE SIMPLY A RUBBER
02:44:39.636 --> 02:44:41.037
STAMP WHEN SOMEONE COMES IN AND
02:44:41.104 --> 02:44:42.439
PRESENTS AN AUDIT SCOPE OR DO
02:44:42.505 --> 02:44:43.974
WE HAVE AS A AS A AS A
02:44:44.040 --> 02:44:44.975
COMMITTEE THE AUTHORITY TO
02:44:45.041 --> 02:44:46.910
ADJUST. THE SCOPE OF THE OTHER
02:44:46.977 --> 02:44:48.011
BASED ON THE INFORMATION
02:44:48.078 --> 02:44:49.746
PROVIDED IF WE'RE SIMPLY RUBBER
02:44:49.813 --> 02:44:52.082
STAMP THEN I CAN SET UP STAIRS
02:44:52.148 --> 02:44:53.683
EAT MY LUNCH SINCE WE ALL GET
02:44:53.750 --> 02:44:56.219
ON IT IN RIGHT CORRECT NO-
02:44:56.286 --> 02:44:57.621
MAYBE WE NEED TO WOULD HAVE FOR
02:44:57.687 --> 02:44:59.022
THE YEAH THE CLARIFICATION THEN
02:44:59.089 --> 02:45:00.523
WOULD BE YOU KNOW AS WE ALLOW
02:45:00.590 --> 02:45:02.259
OUR COLLEAGUES THE WHAT THE-
02:45:02.325 --> 02:45:03.493
THE ONE TO TWO WEEKS AS ARE
02:45:03.560 --> 02:45:05.228
ADJUSTING THEIR SCOPE IS TO
02:45:05.295 --> 02:45:06.363
WORK WITH COMMITTEE STAFF. IN
02:45:06.429 --> 02:45:07.564
ADJUSTING THAT SCOPE WHERE
02:45:07.631 --> 02:45:10.000
APPROPRIATE AND SO- NOT A
02:45:10.066 --> 02:45:11.368
RUBBER STAMP BUT REALLY
02:45:11.434 --> 02:45:12.502
ACTUALLY TRYING TO BE INVOLVED
02:45:12.569 --> 02:45:13.737
IN THE PROCESS AS WELL HELPING
02:45:13.803 --> 02:45:15.705
THE MEMBERS I DETERMINE THE
02:45:15.772 --> 02:45:17.741
SCOPE OF THEIR AUDIT AS A BRING
02:45:17.807 --> 02:45:18.842
THAT BEFORE THE SLUDGE THAT
02:45:18.908 --> 02:45:21.278
APPLY. AND IF I MAY ADD THEN
02:45:21.344 --> 02:45:23.847
SAM YOU KNOW WE SOME FINALIZED-
02:45:23.913 --> 02:45:24.981
ADJUSTED THE SCOPE OF THIS
02:45:25.048 --> 02:45:26.049
AUDITOR'S REQUEST IN
02:45:26.116 --> 02:45:27.617
CONSULTATION WITH THE STATE
02:45:27.684 --> 02:45:29.219
AUDITOR'S OFFICE SO IT WASN'T
02:45:29.286 --> 02:45:31.454
AS IF THIS OFFICE JUST DECIDED
02:45:31.521 --> 02:45:32.155
TO ASK A BUNCH OF RANDOM
02:45:32.222 --> 02:45:34.691
QUESTIONS. WITHOUT SEEKING ANY
02:45:34.758 --> 02:45:35.959
GUIDANCE FROM THE STATE
02:45:36.026 --> 02:45:37.861
AUDITOR'S OFFICE WE ALSO KNOW
02:45:37.927 --> 02:45:39.029
THAT THIS IS A CONTENTIOUS
02:45:39.095 --> 02:45:40.697
ISSUE QUITE FRANKLY YOU KNOW IN
02:45:40.764 --> 02:45:41.965
A COUPLE OF THESE COUNTIES AT
02:45:42.032 --> 02:45:43.600
LEAST AND WE HAVE SEEN AND
02:45:43.667 --> 02:45:45.235
HEARD OF THE STRUGGLES THAT THE
02:45:45.302 --> 02:45:47.170
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ARE FACING
02:45:47.237 --> 02:45:49.906
WHEN TRYING TO ACCESS A LOT OF
02:45:49.973 --> 02:45:50.507
THIS INFORMATION AND SO OFTEN
02:45:50.573 --> 02:45:52.609
TIMES. IT'S NOT ABOUT RUBBER
02:45:52.676 --> 02:45:54.144
STAMPING BUT IT'S ABOUT
02:45:54.210 --> 02:45:56.346
PROVIDING THE WEIGHT. AND THE
02:45:56.413 --> 02:45:59.115
OVERSIGHT FROM THE STATE TO SAY
02:45:59.182 --> 02:46:00.917
YOU KNOW THESE ARE OUR DOLLARS
02:46:00.984 --> 02:46:02.786
THAT WE THEN PASSED ON TO YOU
02:46:02.852 --> 02:46:04.120
AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:46:04.187 --> 02:46:05.422
THIS REALIGNMENT OR THIS
02:46:05.488 --> 02:46:07.090
INVESTMENT IS BEING USED
02:46:07.157 --> 02:46:08.458
ACCORDING TO THE WISHES OF THE
02:46:08.525 --> 02:46:10.193
NEEDS OF THE TAXPAYERS. AND
02:46:10.260 --> 02:46:12.429
LASTLY I THINK AS WE ALL WOULD
02:46:12.495 --> 02:46:13.830
HOPE I CERTAINLY DO I HOPE THAT
02:46:13.897 --> 02:46:15.131
WHATEVER TRANSPIRES WITH THE
02:46:15.198 --> 02:46:18.468
AUDITS ARE DONE IN PARTNERSHIP
02:46:18.535 --> 02:46:19.069
WITH THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
02:46:19.135 --> 02:46:20.437
THIS IS CERTAINLY NOT I GOT YOU
02:46:20.503 --> 02:46:22.706
BUT IN FACT THIS IS A THIRD ASK
02:46:22.772 --> 02:46:24.240
TO SAY HOW ARE THESE DOLLARS
02:46:24.307 --> 02:46:26.142
BEING USED BECAUSE WE CERTAINLY
02:46:26.209 --> 02:46:28.645
CAN'T SEE THEM ON THE WEBSITE.
02:46:28.712 --> 02:46:30.880
SO ARE THEY BEING USED WELL ARE
02:46:30.947 --> 02:46:35.018
THEY YOU BEING USED AND IF NOT
02:46:35.085 --> 02:46:35.585
WHAT ARE SOME COMMENDATIONS
02:46:35.652 --> 02:46:36.186
THAT YOU ARE AND- TO MAKE SURE
02:46:36.252 --> 02:46:36.786
THAT THE- DOLLARS. WELL SPENT
02:46:36.853 --> 02:46:39.255
AT THE END OF THE DAY I THINK I
02:46:39.322 --> 02:46:40.757
WAS TAXPAYERS THAT'S WHAT WE
02:46:40.824 --> 02:46:42.559
WANT WE WANT TO KNOW THAT WE
02:46:42.625 --> 02:46:44.327
ARE GETTING A STRONG RETURN ON
02:46:44.394 --> 02:46:45.762
INVESTMENT. WE ALSO WANT TO
02:46:45.829 --> 02:46:46.963
MAKE SURE THAT THE MENTAL AND
02:46:47.030 --> 02:46:47.931
THE PHYSICAL HEALTH IN THE
02:46:47.997 --> 02:46:49.232
CONDITIONS OF THOSE THAT ARE
02:46:49.299 --> 02:46:50.934
BOTH INCARCERATED IN WORKING IN
02:46:51.000 --> 02:46:53.303
THOSE FACILITIES. ARE BEING
02:46:53.370 --> 02:46:55.038
TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT BUT WE
02:46:55.105 --> 02:46:57.140
CERTAINLY. GIVEN THE FACT THAT
02:46:57.207 --> 02:46:58.541
REALIGNMENT HAPPENED WANT TO
02:46:58.608 --> 02:47:00.410
KNOW THAT THAT'S- THAT WHAT
02:47:00.477 --> 02:47:01.478
WE'RE DOING WITH OUR DOLLARS IS
02:47:01.544 --> 02:47:02.679
WHAT WE SAID WE WANTED TO HAVE
02:47:02.746 --> 02:47:07.150
DONE. AND ONCE AGAIN. YOU KNOW.
02:47:07.217 --> 02:47:09.786
THEY'RE THE ARM OF THE STATE.
02:47:09.853 --> 02:47:11.354
CAN BE VERY USEFUL AND HELPING
02:47:11.421 --> 02:47:14.090
TO GUIDE THAT KIND OF. RESEARCH
02:47:14.157 --> 02:47:16.426
WELL I THINK THE ME JUST MISTER
02:47:16.493 --> 02:47:17.394
CHAIR IS ME JUST LIKE A FINAL
02:47:17.460 --> 02:47:19.729
COMMENT. SO MRI THANK YOU YOU
02:47:19.796 --> 02:47:22.732
AND YOUR AUDIT REQUEST JUST GOT
02:47:22.799 --> 02:47:23.199
CAUGHT UP IN A LARGER
02:47:23.266 --> 02:47:24.534
CONVERSATION. IT REALLY HAS
02:47:24.601 --> 02:47:26.569
NOTHING TO DO FRANKLY WITH THE
02:47:26.636 --> 02:47:28.838
NATURE OF THE REQUEST. FOR OR
02:47:28.905 --> 02:47:30.774
THE VALIDITY OF THE REQUEST OR
02:47:30.840 --> 02:47:32.776
PROBABLY THE NEED FOR YOU GOT
02:47:32.842 --> 02:47:34.077
IT THIS JUST HAPPENS TO BE THE
02:47:34.144 --> 02:47:35.311
SECOND TIME WE'VE HAD
02:47:35.378 --> 02:47:37.213
RESPONDING ENTITIES COME. AND
02:47:37.280 --> 02:47:38.548
SAY THEY FOR HAD VIRTUALLY NO
02:47:38.615 --> 02:47:41.151
NOTICE OF REQUEST- AND THEN
02:47:41.217 --> 02:47:43.019
WE'RE BEING ASKED TO DO WHAT I
02:47:43.086 --> 02:47:44.621
DON'T KNOW. SO MY COMMENTS
02:47:44.687 --> 02:47:47.557
REALLY YOU ARE- SIGNAL TO THE
02:47:47.624 --> 02:47:49.492
PEOPLE THAT RUN THIS SHOP-
02:47:49.559 --> 02:47:51.361
WHEREVER THEY ARE THAT MAYBE WE
02:47:51.428 --> 02:47:52.929
NEED TO TAKE A LOOK AT THIS AT
02:47:52.996 --> 02:47:55.432
THE STRUCTURAL. A MECHANISM BY
02:47:55.498 --> 02:47:57.200
WHICH WE PROCESS AUDIT REQUESTS
02:47:57.267 --> 02:47:58.701
AND THE NOTICE THAT WE GIVE TO
02:47:58.768 --> 02:48:00.303
THE PEOPLE TO COME BEFORE US
02:48:00.370 --> 02:48:01.571
BECAUSE IF WE WERE. ON THE
02:48:01.638 --> 02:48:04.441
RECEIVING END. WE WOULD
02:48:04.507 --> 02:48:06.342
PROBABLY WANT TO BE TREATED A
02:48:06.409 --> 02:48:09.846
LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY. THANK
02:48:09.913 --> 02:48:11.614
YOU ASSEMBLY WOMAN FOR YOUR
02:48:11.681 --> 02:48:16.019
RESPONSE THAT WAS GOOD AND.
02:48:16.085 --> 02:48:18.721
EURO YOUR NEXT. WE'RE GONNA
02:48:18.788 --> 02:48:21.124
MOVE TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:48:21.191 --> 02:48:22.091
PATTERSON THEN ASSEMBLY WOMAN
02:48:22.158 --> 02:48:25.562
RUBIO BUT LET ME REMIND THAT
02:48:25.628 --> 02:48:26.696
THE COMMITTEE THAT WERE ALSO
02:48:26.763 --> 02:48:29.332
BOUND BY THE RULES- BETWEEN THE
02:48:29.399 --> 02:48:31.100
TWO HOUSES AND SO THIS IS SET
02:48:31.167 --> 02:48:32.702
OUT IN THE RULES IF WE'D LIKE
02:48:32.769 --> 02:48:33.803
TO CHANGE THAT MORE THAN HAPPY
02:48:33.870 --> 02:48:35.505
TO DISCUSS THE CHANGES AS WE
02:48:35.572 --> 02:48:36.706
MOVE FORWARD BUT THIS IS
02:48:36.773 --> 02:48:37.974
OUTLINED IN THE RULES BETWEEN
02:48:38.041 --> 02:48:40.677
THE JOINT HOUSES- FOR HOW THIS
02:48:40.743 --> 02:48:42.645
COMMITTEE OPERATES SO WITH THAT
02:48:42.712 --> 02:48:43.613
LET'S GO TO MOVE TO ASSEMBLY
02:48:43.680 --> 02:48:45.348
MEMBER PATTERSON THEM TO
02:48:45.415 --> 02:48:46.649
ASSEMBLY WOMAN REVIEW. HELLO
02:48:46.716 --> 02:48:49.219
THINGS HERE THAT UP ARE I THINK.
02:48:49.285 --> 02:48:53.556
ABSOLUTELY STRIKING. WE HAVE-
02:48:53.623 --> 02:48:54.724
THE SHARE FOR FRESNO COUNTY
02:48:54.791 --> 02:48:56.726
SITTING HERE SAYING THAT THEY
02:48:56.793 --> 02:48:59.562
HAD NO NOTICE. NUMBER ONE
02:48:59.629 --> 02:49:01.631
NUMBER TWO THAT THEY HAVE
02:49:01.698 --> 02:49:04.601
DOCUMENTATION. WITH RESPECT
02:49:04.667 --> 02:49:09.439
297% OF THEIR FUNDS BEING SPENT
02:49:09.506 --> 02:49:11.574
THERE IS AN OVERSIGHT PROCESS
02:49:11.641 --> 02:49:16.045
THAT HAS BEEN. UP ARTICULATED
02:49:16.112 --> 02:49:19.916
AND THAT A THAT WELL REGARDED
02:49:19.983 --> 02:49:23.286
DEEPLY RESPECTED AUDITING. FIRM
02:49:23.353 --> 02:49:25.321
HAS IN FACT AUDITED. THE
02:49:25.388 --> 02:49:28.458
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT. HOW THIS
02:49:28.525 --> 02:49:31.394
BODY COULD CONTINUE TO PUSH AN
02:49:31.461 --> 02:49:33.530
AUDIT FOR A PARTICULARLY FRESNO
02:49:33.596 --> 02:49:36.666
COUNTY AT THIS MOMENT WITH THIS
02:49:36.733 --> 02:49:38.768
INFORMATION ON RESOLVED AND NOT
02:49:38.835 --> 02:49:41.804
A PART OF THEIR DUE DILIGENCE
02:49:41.871 --> 02:49:44.073
ON THEIR DELIBERATIONS.
02:49:44.140 --> 02:49:47.243
HONESTLY STRIKES ME FAR MORE
02:49:47.310 --> 02:49:52.415
MEDICAL THEN A REAL EFFORT AT
02:49:52.482 --> 02:49:55.251
GETTING AT THE TRUTH. IF YOU'RE
02:49:55.318 --> 02:49:56.286
INTERESTED IN GETTING AT THE
02:49:56.352 --> 02:49:58.221
TRUTH WE HAVE INFORMATION THAT
02:49:58.288 --> 02:50:00.390
CAN GET YOU THERE AND IT'S BEEN
02:50:00.456 --> 02:50:02.525
PUBLICLY NOTED THAT FOR THE
02:50:02.592 --> 02:50:04.961
RECORD I WANT TO JUST ALSO SAY
02:50:05.028 --> 02:50:06.162
I'M I'M NEW TO THE COMMITTEE.
02:50:06.229 --> 02:50:09.699
AND MY EXPERIENCE WITH THIS
02:50:09.766 --> 02:50:11.434
COMMITTEE FIRST OF ALL WAS WITH
02:50:11.501 --> 02:50:13.770
A REQUEST FOR AN AUDIT OF THE
02:50:13.836 --> 02:50:15.805
HIGH SPEED RAIL. IT TOOK
02:50:15.872 --> 02:50:18.374
PROBABLY. TWO YEARS THREE YEARS
02:50:18.441 --> 02:50:22.912
AGO APPROVED WE ARE UTILIZED A
02:50:22.979 --> 02:50:24.280
GREAT DEAL OF HELP FROM A
02:50:24.347 --> 02:50:28.117
BIPARTISAN GROUP OF LEGISLATORS.
02:50:28.184 --> 02:50:30.453
AND IT DID COME TO THIS BODY
02:50:30.520 --> 02:50:32.522
THAT'S THE KIND OF PROCESS THAT
02:50:32.589 --> 02:50:35.892
I THINK WE HAVE TO. AND HERE TO
02:50:35.959 --> 02:50:38.294
IN ORDER TO BE ABSOLUTELY FAIR
02:50:38.361 --> 02:50:39.862
THAT THOSE AGENCIES THAT ARE
02:50:39.929 --> 02:50:42.332
BEING REQUIRE ARE REQUESTED TO
02:50:42.398 --> 02:50:44.233
BE AUDITED. HAVE THE
02:50:44.300 --> 02:50:48.171
OPPORTUNITY OF ENGAGING. WAY
02:50:48.237 --> 02:50:51.240
PRIOR TO A NOTIFICATION OR WAY
02:50:51.307 --> 02:50:52.875
PRACTICE AS HAVING TO SIT
02:50:52.942 --> 02:50:55.979
THROUGH THIS. AND I REALLY AM.
02:50:56.045 --> 02:50:59.649
RIGHT CONCERNED THAT SENSE I
02:50:59.716 --> 02:51:01.117
SAT ON THIS COMMITTEE I HAVE
02:51:01.184 --> 02:51:05.388
HAD THIS. REALLY SERIOUS UNDER
02:51:05.455 --> 02:51:09.959
CURRENT OF DREAD THAT THIS BODY
02:51:10.026 --> 02:51:11.594
IS ALLOWING ITSELF TO BE
02:51:11.661 --> 02:51:14.831
POLITICIZED AND I WANT TO WARN
02:51:14.897 --> 02:51:17.967
AGAINST THAT THE CREDIBILITY OF
02:51:18.034 --> 02:51:20.536
THIS GROUP IS AT STAKE I AM NOT
02:51:20.603 --> 02:51:21.904
SUGGESTING THAT WE DON'T DO
02:51:21.971 --> 02:51:24.507
ANYTHING. WHAT I'M SUGGESTING
02:51:24.574 --> 02:51:26.943
IS THERE IS NO NECESSITY TO
02:51:27.010 --> 02:51:29.379
RUSH INTO THIS PARTICULARLY
02:51:29.445 --> 02:51:31.914
GIVEN THE PUBLIC TESTIMONY OF
02:51:31.981 --> 02:51:33.783
AT LEAST ONE AGENCY THAT HAS
02:51:33.850 --> 02:51:35.685
LEGITIMATE CLEAR INFORMATION
02:51:35.752 --> 02:51:37.353
READY AT HAND AND READY TO IT
02:51:37.420 --> 02:51:39.188
AT THAT TO PREPARE TO BE. TO BE
02:51:39.255 --> 02:51:42.258
PUT FORWARD SO- I I'M I'M GOING
02:51:42.325 --> 02:51:44.394
TO HAVE TO VOTE NO ON THIS- BUT
02:51:44.460 --> 02:51:46.162
I DO THINK THAT IT IS A
02:51:46.229 --> 02:51:48.698
APPROPRIATE WARNING THAT OTHERS
02:51:48.765 --> 02:51:51.034
HAVE BEEN GIVEN HERE. THAT WE
02:51:51.100 --> 02:51:53.102
HAVE GOT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
02:51:53.169 --> 02:51:54.804
AGENCIES THAT ARE COMING UNDER
02:51:54.871 --> 02:51:56.506
THE PURVIEW OF IT A LOT OF
02:51:56.572 --> 02:52:00.209
REQUEST. BE GIVEN A DUE PROCESS
02:52:00.276 --> 02:52:03.146
OPPORTUNITY OF ENOUGH TIME TO
02:52:03.212 --> 02:52:05.848
FULLY BE ABLE TO RESPOND TO THE
02:52:05.915 --> 02:52:08.151
UNDERLYING QUESTIONS. MOST OF
02:52:08.217 --> 02:52:11.154
THE A QUESTIONS COULD VERY WELL
02:52:11.220 --> 02:52:13.189
BE ANSWERED WITHOUT OF THREE
02:52:13.256 --> 02:52:15.425
HUNDRED THOUSAND. DOLLARS WORTH
02:52:15.491 --> 02:52:18.661
OF INQUIRY IF WE WOULD JUST.
02:52:18.728 --> 02:52:21.864
SLOW DOWN TAKE A DEEP BREATH.
02:52:21.931 --> 02:52:24.100
AND ASK THE INFORMATION GIVE
02:52:24.167 --> 02:52:26.302
PEOPLE PLENTY OF TIME AND THEN
02:52:26.369 --> 02:52:30.339
GO FORWARD. THE DRESS PATTERSON
02:52:30.406 --> 02:52:32.175
REMOVED TO ASSEMBLY WOMAN RUBIO
02:52:32.241 --> 02:52:33.342
THANK YOU AND THANK YOU
02:52:33.409 --> 02:52:34.744
ASSEMBLYMEMBER FOR OUR YOUR
02:52:34.811 --> 02:52:37.380
REQUEST- I THINK BEING FROM LA
02:52:37.447 --> 02:52:40.216
COUNTY- I THINK THAT- WE ARE
02:52:40.283 --> 02:52:41.184
TALKING ABOUT A COUPLE
02:52:41.250 --> 02:52:42.218
DIFFERENT THINGS THE PROCESS
02:52:42.285 --> 02:52:44.120
ABSOLUTELY HAS TO BE LOOKED AT
02:52:44.187 --> 02:52:47.223
HOWEVER IN MY OPINION. IF I AN
02:52:47.290 --> 02:52:49.025
AGENCY WITH WHOEVER MAY BE EVEN
02:52:49.092 --> 02:52:50.393
IN MY OFFICE IF SOMEBODY IS
02:52:50.460 --> 02:52:52.662
DOING THEIR JOB- AND THE
02:52:52.729 --> 02:52:55.264
QUESTION IS ASKED YOU PULL OUT
02:52:55.331 --> 02:52:57.834
AND I'M WITH A FILE AND PROVIDE
02:52:57.900 --> 02:52:59.669
THE INFORMATION SOLD THE
02:52:59.736 --> 02:53:00.503
ARGUMENT THAT THERE IS NOT
02:53:00.570 --> 02:53:02.405
ENOUGH TIME TO PROVIDE THAT
02:53:02.472 --> 02:53:04.207
INFORMATION. LEADS ME TO THINK
02:53:04.273 --> 02:53:05.141
THAT THERE OUGHT THEIR
02:53:05.208 --> 02:53:08.177
PROCESSES ARE NOT NECESSARILY-
02:53:08.244 --> 02:53:10.947
FLOWING PROPERLY BECAUSE IF YOU
02:53:11.013 --> 02:53:12.315
NEED MORE THAN THAN YOU KNOW A
02:53:12.381 --> 02:53:14.250
WEEK'S TIME TO PROVIDE PRODUCE
02:53:14.317 --> 02:53:16.619
THAT INFORMATION THEN. WHERE
02:53:16.686 --> 02:53:17.687
WHO IS WORKING ON THAT
02:53:17.754 --> 02:53:19.522
INFORMATION NUMBER ONE NUMBER
02:53:19.589 --> 02:53:20.323
TWO THIS IS MY FAVORITE
02:53:20.389 --> 02:53:21.991
COMMITTEE BECAUSE WE GET TO
02:53:22.058 --> 02:53:24.827
LOOK AT- DIFFERENT AGENCIES AND
02:53:24.894 --> 02:53:26.195
DIFFERENT- PROCESSES AND
02:53:26.262 --> 02:53:28.197
PROCEDURES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
02:53:28.264 --> 02:53:29.766
SO IN THIS CASE WE HAVE
02:53:29.832 --> 02:53:31.000
MULTIPLE AGENCIES THERE ARE
02:53:31.067 --> 02:53:33.169
BEING AUDITED SO IF YOU GUYS
02:53:33.236 --> 02:53:34.604
ARE DOING A GREAT JOB I WOULD
02:53:34.670 --> 02:53:36.239
LOVE TO TAKE WHAT YOU'RE DOING.
02:53:36.305 --> 02:53:38.107
AND PUT IN AN ALLEY COUNTY AS A
02:53:38.174 --> 02:53:39.642
MODEL OF HOW LA COUNTY SHOULD
02:53:39.709 --> 02:53:42.311
RUN THIS PARTICULAR- ITEM SOUL
02:53:42.378 --> 02:53:44.280
IN IN AUDITING YOUR YOUR
02:53:44.347 --> 02:53:46.415
SPECIFIC AGENCIES AND IF YOU
02:53:46.482 --> 02:53:48.351
ARE DOING A GREAT JOB I WOULD
02:53:48.417 --> 02:53:50.486
LOVE TO HAVE THAT INFORMATION
02:53:50.553 --> 02:53:51.954
SO THAT WE CAN GO TO LA COUNTY
02:53:52.021 --> 02:53:53.289
AND SAY LOOK AT THE GREAT JOB
02:53:53.356 --> 02:53:54.390
THAT THESE TWO AGENCIES ARE
02:53:54.457 --> 02:53:56.592
DOING. CAN WE MODEL AFTER THAT
02:53:56.659 --> 02:53:59.395
AND THE STATE AUDITOR'S. JOB IS
02:53:59.462 --> 02:54:01.464
NOT A GOTCHA BUT STATE EITHER
02:54:01.531 --> 02:54:03.199
JET AUDITOR'S JOB IN MY OPINION
02:54:03.266 --> 02:54:06.102
IS TO- PRODUCE BEST PRACTICES
02:54:06.169 --> 02:54:07.336
FOR WHATEVER AGENCY THAT WE
02:54:07.403 --> 02:54:08.104
AUDITING AND MAKE
02:54:08.171 --> 02:54:09.639
RECOMMENDATIONS AS TO HOW OTHER
02:54:09.705 --> 02:54:11.374
PROPHECIES CAN BE BETTER AND
02:54:11.440 --> 02:54:13.609
WHAT BETTER WAY TO DO THAT THAN
02:54:13.676 --> 02:54:16.445
TO SEE. OTHER AGENCIES THAT ARE
02:54:16.512 --> 02:54:17.046
DOING WHAT THEY'RE SUPPOSE TO
02:54:17.113 --> 02:54:19.615
BE DOING ANY AND IN LA COUNTY
02:54:19.682 --> 02:54:21.517
TAKE YOU OF THE MODEL SO THAT
02:54:21.584 --> 02:54:23.085
WE CAN SAY HATE THEY'RE DOING A
02:54:23.152 --> 02:54:24.754
GREAT GREAT JOB LEADS DO WHAT
02:54:24.821 --> 02:54:28.891
THEY'RE DOING AND THE OTHER- I
02:54:28.958 --> 02:54:30.059
GUESS ISSUE IS THAT. WE ARE
02:54:30.126 --> 02:54:33.129
RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT MONEY- THE
02:54:33.196 --> 02:54:34.497
PUBLIC DOES NOT HAVE THE
02:54:34.564 --> 02:54:36.566
AUTHORITY TO AUDIT ANYBODY ANY
02:54:36.632 --> 02:54:38.000
OF OUR THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND
02:54:38.067 --> 02:54:39.802
THE AGENCIES HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE
02:54:39.869 --> 02:54:40.903
TO GET THAT INFORMATION ON THE
02:54:40.970 --> 02:54:43.206
WEBSITE. THEN THE NORMAL PUBLIC
02:54:43.272 --> 02:54:44.140
HASN'T BEEN ABLE TO GET THAT
02:54:44.207 --> 02:54:45.575
INFORMATION ON THE WEBSITE AND
02:54:45.641 --> 02:54:47.476
IT IS OUR RESPONSIBILITY. TO
02:54:47.543 --> 02:54:48.611
MAKE SURE THAT THE MONEY THAT
02:54:48.678 --> 02:54:50.513
WE PROVIDE IS BEING ACCOUNTED
02:54:50.580 --> 02:54:52.915
FOR AND IN THIS CASE. AGAIN IF
02:54:52.982 --> 02:54:53.783
THAT INFORMATION IS NOT
02:54:53.850 --> 02:54:55.985
PROVIDED WHY IS IT NOT PROVIDED
02:54:56.052 --> 02:54:57.320
DO THEY NEED A YEAR TO FIX
02:54:57.386 --> 02:54:58.821
THAT. YOU KNOW SHOULD WE GAVE
02:54:58.888 --> 02:55:00.323
THEM GIVE THEM A YEAR. IN
02:55:00.389 --> 02:55:01.891
ADVANCE I HEADS UP THAT WE'RE
02:55:01.958 --> 02:55:02.758
GOING TO I DID THEM SO THAT
02:55:02.825 --> 02:55:03.926
THEY NOW THEY PUT IT ON THE
02:55:03.993 --> 02:55:04.694
WEBSITE THAT IS THE
02:55:04.760 --> 02:55:06.062
RESPONSIBILITY IS TO PROVIDE
02:55:06.128 --> 02:55:07.630
ACCURATE INFORMATION. AND IF
02:55:07.697 --> 02:55:09.065
THEY'RE NOT DOING IT THE MEMBER
02:55:09.131 --> 02:55:11.234
OF THE PUBLIC DON'T HAVE THE
02:55:11.300 --> 02:55:12.535
ABILITY THAT WE DO TO AUDIT
02:55:12.602 --> 02:55:14.337
THESE AGENCIES. SO IN THE BEST
02:55:14.403 --> 02:55:16.372
INTEREST OF THE TAXPAYER AND
02:55:16.439 --> 02:55:18.908
BEST INTEREST OF OUR MONEY I.
02:55:18.975 --> 02:55:20.543
THINK THAT WE SHOULD ADDED
02:55:20.610 --> 02:55:21.944
THESE PROGRAMS AND AGAIN TO THE
02:55:22.011 --> 02:55:23.679
AGENCIES AFFECTED. YOU KNOW WE
02:55:23.746 --> 02:55:25.181
WANT TO TAKE YOUR BEST
02:55:25.248 --> 02:55:26.983
PRACTICES INPUT IN LA COUNTY
02:55:27.049 --> 02:55:28.150
BECAUSE GUESS WHAT WE HAVE
02:55:28.217 --> 02:55:29.852
ISSUES AN ALLEY COUNTY IS VERY
02:55:29.919 --> 02:55:31.587
WELL KNOWN. AND IF THE BOARD OF
02:55:31.654 --> 02:55:33.089
SUPERVISORS HAVE HAVEN'T BEEN
02:55:33.155 --> 02:55:34.757
ABLE TO GET THAT INFORMATION
02:55:34.824 --> 02:55:36.092
AFTER MULTIPLE REQUESTS THAN IT
02:55:36.158 --> 02:55:37.159
TAKES US TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT
02:55:37.226 --> 02:55:39.428
INFORMATION IS PROVIDED. SO I
02:55:39.495 --> 02:55:41.230
TO YOUR POINT I KNOW I DO
02:55:41.297 --> 02:55:42.164
UNDERSTAND THE WHOLE TIME
02:55:42.231 --> 02:55:43.232
FACTOR BUT IF YOU GUYS ARE
02:55:43.299 --> 02:55:44.867
DOING A GREAT JOB I WOULD LOVE
02:55:44.934 --> 02:55:46.235
TO SEE THAT. AND I WILL BE THE
02:55:46.302 --> 02:55:47.803
FIRST ONE TO SEND OUT A LETTER
02:55:47.870 --> 02:55:49.071
INTO A PRESS RELEASE ON YOUR
02:55:49.138 --> 02:55:51.240
BEHALF AND HOW. ELLIE COUNTY
02:55:51.307 --> 02:55:51.741
SHOULD MODEL AFTER YOUR
02:55:51.807 --> 02:55:53.643
PRACTICES BECAUSE OF WHAT'S
02:55:53.709 --> 02:55:55.544
HAPPENING IN LA COUNTY IS NOT
02:55:55.611 --> 02:55:57.380
GOOD FOR THE RESIDENTS. SO TO
02:55:57.446 --> 02:55:58.581
THAT POINT YU KNOW THANK YOU
02:55:58.648 --> 02:56:00.616
AGAIN FOR PROVIDING THIS
02:56:00.683 --> 02:56:01.417
INFORMATION BUT TO YOU IT'S NOT
02:56:01.484 --> 02:56:02.852
A GOTCHA WE WANT TO TAKE YOUR
02:56:02.919 --> 02:56:04.954
WHAT YOU'RE DOING. AND MODEL
02:56:05.021 --> 02:56:06.956
AFTER YOU TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL
02:56:07.023 --> 02:56:09.292
THE OTHER AS- SHERIFF
02:56:09.358 --> 02:56:10.159
DEPARTMENTS ARE DOING THE SAME
02:56:10.226 --> 02:56:11.193
THING AND I JUST AN ALLEY
02:56:11.260 --> 02:56:13.529
COUNTY BUT IF ACROSS THE STATE.
02:56:13.596 --> 02:56:15.564
IF THERE ARE PROBLEMS IN THOSE
02:56:15.631 --> 02:56:18.167
OTHER AGENCIES THAN YOUR WHAT
02:56:18.234 --> 02:56:19.735
YOU'RE DOING SHOULD BE A MODEL
02:56:19.802 --> 02:56:21.337
FOR THE STATE NOT JUST FOR
02:56:21.404 --> 02:56:24.507
ELLIE MONEY. THANK YOU. I WANT.
02:56:24.573 --> 02:56:27.343
THOSE WELL. THANK YOU FOR THAT
02:56:27.410 --> 02:56:28.744
ALICE WOULD THE ASSEMBLY WILL
02:56:28.811 --> 02:56:30.246
INVERTER INTO THE GUNS YEAH I
02:56:30.313 --> 02:56:31.113
LIKE TO ECHO THE COMMENTS OF
02:56:31.180 --> 02:56:32.014
THE SOME MEMBER WILL BE THAT
02:56:32.081 --> 02:56:34.850
WAS WELL. MAYBE THE- THE
02:56:34.917 --> 02:56:37.086
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CAN GO THROUGH
02:56:37.153 --> 02:56:39.622
AND KIND OF OUTLINE WHY YOU
02:56:39.689 --> 02:56:41.424
CHOSE THESE THREE COUNTIES
02:56:41.490 --> 02:56:43.326
BECAUSE CLEARLY OF ARTICULATED
02:56:43.392 --> 02:56:45.494
THE PUBLIC ACCESS ISSUES WITH
02:56:45.561 --> 02:56:47.296
THE INFORMATION FOR ALAMEDA AND
02:56:47.363 --> 02:56:49.765
LA RIGHT RIGHT- MAYBE YOU CAN
02:56:49.832 --> 02:56:52.068
ARTICULATE TO US WHY YOU'VE
02:56:52.134 --> 02:56:53.869
INCLUDED FRESNO IN THIS IS IT
02:56:53.936 --> 02:56:55.271
EXAMPLE OF THEY'RE DOING IT
02:56:55.338 --> 02:56:57.206
WELL OR HOW THEY GOT INCLUDED
02:56:57.273 --> 02:56:59.241
IN THIS AUDIT NOT HELP CLARIFY.
02:56:59.308 --> 02:57:00.409
SOME OF THE INFORMATION BE
02:57:00.476 --> 02:57:03.746
HAPPY TO WE- LOOKED AT THE
02:57:03.813 --> 02:57:06.115
COUNTY- DEPARTMENTS THE
02:57:06.182 --> 02:57:07.316
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENTS ACROSS
02:57:07.383 --> 02:57:10.753
THE STATE. AND DETERMINE THAT
02:57:10.820 --> 02:57:12.455
WITH AN INCREASE IN DEATHS THAT
02:57:12.521 --> 02:57:13.522
WERE HAPPENING WITHIN THE
02:57:13.589 --> 02:57:15.558
COUNTY JAIL IN FRESNO THAT THAT
02:57:15.624 --> 02:57:16.926
WAS A TRIGGER LOOKING OUT
02:57:16.993 --> 02:57:18.761
ARTICLES AND RESEARCH THAT HAS
02:57:18.828 --> 02:57:20.196
BEEN DONE ON SOME OF THE OTHER
02:57:20.262 --> 02:57:22.264
COUNTY FACILITIES IN THE STATE
02:57:22.331 --> 02:57:23.532
ALAMEDA IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY
02:57:23.599 --> 02:57:25.534
HAVE BUBBLED UP REPEATEDLY.
02:57:25.601 --> 02:57:26.902
EITHER FOR A GROWTH IN THE
02:57:26.969 --> 02:57:27.503
SPENDING EVEN THOUGH YOU'VE
02:57:27.570 --> 02:57:29.071
SEEN POPULATION DECREASES IN
02:57:29.138 --> 02:57:31.540
THE COUNTY JAILS OR WITH A TUG
02:57:31.607 --> 02:57:33.009
OF WAR THAT'S HAPPENING AT THE
02:57:33.075 --> 02:57:34.810
LOCAL LEVEL WITH REGARDS TO
02:57:34.877 --> 02:57:37.980
BALLOONING- BUDGETS AND LACK OF
02:57:38.047 --> 02:57:40.249
ACCESS. SO THAT'S WHY THOSE
02:57:40.316 --> 02:57:42.151
THREE WERE SELECTED. IN FRESNO
02:57:42.218 --> 02:57:44.220
COUNTY HAS A LEGITIMATE
02:57:44.286 --> 02:57:46.922
VALIDATED. AUDIT THE DAY OF
02:57:46.989 --> 02:57:48.924
RECENTLY COMPLETED. WE WOULD
02:57:48.991 --> 02:57:50.292
LOVE TO SEE THAT WE WOULD LOVE
02:57:50.359 --> 02:57:51.961
TO HAVE THAT BE SHARED WITH THE
02:57:52.028 --> 02:57:52.862
STATE AUDITOR'S DEPARTMENT
02:57:52.928 --> 02:57:54.230
BECAUSE THAT COULD INFORM A
02:57:54.296 --> 02:57:55.331
NUMBER OF THE QUESTIONS THAT
02:57:55.398 --> 02:57:57.600
ARE ASKED IN THE SCOPE. AND
02:57:57.666 --> 02:57:59.435
COULD ALSO PROVIDE SOME
02:57:59.502 --> 02:58:01.670
INCREDIBLY RICH DATA TO BE
02:58:01.737 --> 02:58:02.538
SHARED WITH THE OTHER COUNTIES
02:58:02.605 --> 02:58:04.940
ARE ALSO BEING AUDITED THIS IS
02:58:05.007 --> 02:58:06.509
NOT A GOTCHA BUT WE ARE
02:58:06.575 --> 02:58:07.810
INCREDIBLY CONCERNED WITH THE
02:58:07.877 --> 02:58:09.278
AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT CONTINUES
02:58:09.345 --> 02:58:10.880
TO GO TO EACH OF THE SHERIFF'S
02:58:10.946 --> 02:58:12.448
DEPARTMENT IT'S AN INORDINATELY
02:58:12.515 --> 02:58:14.283
HIGH NUMBER. AND THERE ARE
02:58:14.350 --> 02:58:15.851
QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW THE FUNDING
02:58:15.918 --> 02:58:17.386
IS BEING USED IT DOESN'T MEAN
02:58:17.453 --> 02:58:19.221
IT'S BEING USED POORLY. DOES
02:58:19.288 --> 02:58:21.023
NOT AN INDICTMENT BUT IT IS A
02:58:21.090 --> 02:58:23.292
REQUEST FOR THE INFORMATION AND
02:58:23.359 --> 02:58:24.493
YOU CAN OFFER INFORMATION AND I
02:58:24.560 --> 02:58:27.129
OBJECTIVE WAY IT'S CALLED DATA
02:58:27.196 --> 02:58:28.664
AND THEN YOU USE THAT TO SAY
02:58:28.731 --> 02:58:30.066
HOW CAN WE BE HELPFUL EITHER
02:58:30.132 --> 02:58:31.300
THROUGH LEGISLATION OR
02:58:31.367 --> 02:58:33.536
REGULATION TO HELP SHIP OR WORK
02:58:33.602 --> 02:58:35.104
WITH YOU TO MAKE SURE THAT.
02:58:35.171 --> 02:58:36.605
YOU'RE ABLE TO HAVE ACCESS TO
02:58:36.672 --> 02:58:38.107
MAYBE INCREASING FUNDING AND
02:58:38.174 --> 02:58:40.242
PROGRAMS THAT WORK DIVERTING
02:58:40.309 --> 02:58:42.578
INTO PILOT PROGRAMS THAT WOULD
02:58:42.645 --> 02:58:44.413
MAKE MORE SENSE GIVEN WHAT
02:58:44.480 --> 02:58:46.749
MAYBE YOU'VE BEEN TRYING RIGHT
02:58:46.816 --> 02:58:47.383
OR EXPERIMENTING WITH IN YOUR
02:58:47.450 --> 02:58:49.385
OWN COUNTY. FOUR HUNDRED FOR
02:58:49.452 --> 02:58:51.320
RIDE SOME. GLOBAL DECISION
02:58:51.387 --> 02:58:53.522
MAKING AUTHORITY AROUND THINGS
02:58:53.589 --> 02:58:54.790
THAT ARE NOT WORKING BUT YOU
02:58:54.857 --> 02:58:56.025
KNOW THERE HAS TO BE A REASON
02:58:56.092 --> 02:58:58.260
WHY FORTY SOME FOLKS DIED IN
02:58:58.327 --> 02:58:59.228
THE COUNTY JAIL. WE WANT TO
02:58:59.295 --> 02:59:00.296
KNOW WHY THERE'S OVER SPENDING
02:59:00.362 --> 02:59:03.332
WITH REGARDS TO SOME OF LAW
02:59:03.399 --> 02:59:05.301
ENFORCEMENT PERSONNEL AND MAYBE
02:59:05.367 --> 02:59:07.536
A DIVERSION AND PROGRAMMING AND
02:59:07.603 --> 02:59:09.605
HATE MAYBE THE ASSUMPTIONS THAT
02:59:09.672 --> 02:59:11.707
WE HAVE MADE. WILL TURN OUT NOT
02:59:11.774 --> 02:59:13.109
TO BE TRUE BASED ON THE DATA
02:59:13.175 --> 02:59:14.810
THAT WE RECEIVE BUT IT ALSO
02:59:14.877 --> 02:59:16.245
DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FOR US TO
02:59:16.312 --> 02:59:17.246
SIT AROUND WITH ASSUMPTIONS
02:59:17.313 --> 02:59:18.447
WITHOUT HAVING THE DATA TO
02:59:18.514 --> 02:59:19.849
EITHER PROVE OR DISPROVE WHAT
02:59:19.915 --> 02:59:21.217
WE'RE THINKING AND WHAT WE'RE
02:59:21.283 --> 02:59:22.718
SEEING AND WHAT WE'RE READING.
02:59:22.785 --> 02:59:26.255
THANK YOU I AM A SENATOR
02:59:26.322 --> 02:59:30.493
GONZALEZ PLEASE. THANK YOU AND
02:59:30.559 --> 02:59:31.560
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS
02:59:31.627 --> 02:59:33.195
REQUEST I AM CERTAINLY MOST
02:59:33.262 --> 02:59:34.697
CONCERNED WITH LA COUNTY BEING
02:59:34.763 --> 02:59:37.299
IN LA COUNTY MEMBER- BECAUSE I
02:59:37.366 --> 02:59:38.834
KNOW WE HAVE THE LARGEST SYSTEM
02:59:38.901 --> 02:59:40.469
AND NOT ONLY THIS STATE BUT THE
02:59:40.536 --> 02:59:42.004
COUNTRY AND YOU KNOW CERTAINLY
02:59:42.071 --> 02:59:43.506
A LOT OF CONCERNS THAT WE NEED
02:59:43.572 --> 02:59:44.573
TO ADDRESS THERE SO I REALLY
02:59:44.640 --> 02:59:45.374
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
02:59:45.441 --> 02:59:49.845
FORWARD. AND ARTICULATING THIS
02:59:49.912 --> 02:59:51.680
IN A WAY THAT IS SO VERY-
02:59:51.747 --> 02:59:53.048
RESPONSIVE TO OUR COMMUNITY
02:59:53.115 --> 02:59:53.983
MEMBERS BECAUSE THAT'S EXACTLY
02:59:54.049 --> 02:59:55.851
WHAT THEY THEY'RE ASKING FOR
02:59:55.918 --> 02:59:59.088
PAIN. NOW BUT I ALSO KNOW JUST
02:59:59.155 --> 03:00:00.756
RESPECTIVE TO WHAT SENATOR ROBB
03:00:00.823 --> 03:00:02.224
MENTIONED AND GIVEN THE
03:00:02.291 --> 03:00:03.292
LANDSCAPE OF WHAT WE'VE BEEN
03:00:03.359 --> 03:00:04.860
DEALING WITH IN THIS COMMITTEE
03:00:04.927 --> 03:00:08.998
JUST TODAY. MYSELF INCLUDED-
03:00:09.064 --> 03:00:11.033
WONDERING IF THERE IS AN
03:00:11.100 --> 03:00:13.035
OPPORTUNITY I KNOW THAT. TO
03:00:13.102 --> 03:00:15.938
YOUR- POINTS THAT FRESNO IN
03:00:16.005 --> 03:00:16.405
ALAMEDA HAVE NOT BEEN
03:00:16.472 --> 03:00:19.341
RESPONSIVE. ON'T WITH THE BOARD
03:00:19.408 --> 03:00:20.743
OF SUPERVISORS HAVEN'T BEEN
03:00:20.809 --> 03:00:22.311
RESPONSIVE NECESSARILY. I'M
03:00:22.378 --> 03:00:24.647
SORRY LOS ANGELES MY APOLOGIES
03:00:24.713 --> 03:00:30.019
GOT THAT WRONG. SO IF WELL I
03:00:30.085 --> 03:00:30.986
MEAN AS THE BOARD OF
03:00:31.053 --> 03:00:32.755
SUPERVISORS HAD ASKED FOR IT
03:00:32.821 --> 03:00:35.257
AND THAT WAS DENIED. OKAY SO
03:00:35.324 --> 03:00:36.926
THAT WENT TO THE BOARD SO
03:00:36.992 --> 03:00:38.494
ALAMEDA NOT TONIGHT OKAY.
03:00:38.561 --> 03:00:40.396
WORKING FROM A PRIVATE COUNTY I
03:00:40.462 --> 03:00:41.864
MEAN THIS STAKEHOLDERS IN THE
03:00:41.931 --> 03:00:42.965
DAY WITH A NINE HUNDRED MEN'S
03:00:43.032 --> 03:00:45.301
GROUP NO RIGHT OKAY A LOT NO
03:00:45.367 --> 03:00:47.203
GOVERNMENT OFFICIAL AFTER THAT.
03:00:47.269 --> 03:00:50.806
SO GIVEN THE FACT THAT I THINK
03:00:50.873 --> 03:00:51.407
ARE COLLEAGUES ALSO WANT TO BE
03:00:51.473 --> 03:00:53.342
IN. INCLUDED IN THE DISCUSSIONS
03:00:53.409 --> 03:00:55.611
GOING FORWARD POTENTIALLY. IT
03:00:55.678 --> 03:00:57.846
SEEMS LIKE THEY DO- IS IT
03:00:57.913 --> 03:00:59.381
POSSIBLE TO START WITH LA
03:00:59.448 --> 03:01:01.250
COUNTY AND THEN PERHAPS FEES IN
03:01:01.317 --> 03:01:03.252
FRESNO AND ALAMEDA AT LIKE A
03:01:03.319 --> 03:01:05.120
THREE MONTH POINT. AFTER
03:01:05.187 --> 03:01:07.489
THERE'S- STILL NO RESPONSE JUST
03:01:07.556 --> 03:01:09.191
A SUGGESTION WELL I THINK WE
03:01:09.258 --> 03:01:10.459
WERE CERTAIN WE WOULD BE OPEN
03:01:10.526 --> 03:01:13.062
TO- THE STARTING WITH ALAMEDA
03:01:13.128 --> 03:01:14.396
AND LOS ANGELES AND THEN
03:01:14.463 --> 03:01:15.598
PHASING IN FRESNO GIVEN THEY
03:01:15.664 --> 03:01:16.999
ARE THE ONLY COUNTY THAT. YOU
03:01:17.066 --> 03:01:18.300
KNOW HAS COME HERE TO STATE
03:01:18.367 --> 03:01:19.335
THAT THEY HAVE JUST COMPLETED
03:01:19.401 --> 03:01:21.937
ON IT BUT ALAMEDA HAS NOT. OKAY
03:01:22.004 --> 03:01:23.672
WHEN YOU HAVE LOS ANGELES.
03:01:23.739 --> 03:01:25.608
RESPONSE NO RESPONSE OKAY.
03:01:25.674 --> 03:01:26.942
GREAT PREP STATE AUDITOR YOU
03:01:27.009 --> 03:01:29.845
COULD. SO I NEED TO BE CLEAR ON
03:01:29.912 --> 03:01:31.013
WHAT THE EXPECTATION IS BECAUSE
03:01:31.080 --> 03:01:32.314
OF THE AUDIT IS APPROVED WE CAN
03:01:32.381 --> 03:01:33.816
CERTAINLY START IN LOS ANGELES
03:01:33.882 --> 03:01:34.984
COUNTY SAN THE TEAM THEIR
03:01:35.050 --> 03:01:36.885
FIRST. AND THEN SEND THAT THE
03:01:36.952 --> 03:01:38.087
THAT HAVE THE TEAM GO TO
03:01:38.153 --> 03:01:40.055
ALAMEDA COUNTY NEXT BUT WE
03:01:40.122 --> 03:01:40.889
WOULD STILL GO TO FRESNO
03:01:40.956 --> 03:01:43.058
COUNTY- AND CONDUCT THE SAME
03:01:43.125 --> 03:01:44.960
PROCEDURES IT WOULD JUST BE
03:01:45.027 --> 03:01:46.395
OUT. FOR A COUPLE MONTHS FROM
03:01:46.462 --> 03:01:48.564
NOW AS FAR AS WHEN WE GET TO
03:01:48.631 --> 03:01:50.866
FRESNO VERSES LA OR ALAMEDA. I
03:01:50.933 --> 03:01:51.467
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE IT WAS
03:01:51.533 --> 03:01:53.269
CLEAR TO THE COMMITTEE THAT WE
03:01:53.335 --> 03:01:55.170
WOULD STILL BE AUDITING FRESNO.
03:01:55.237 --> 03:01:57.640
BOB IF THE IF THE- THE
03:01:57.706 --> 03:01:58.774
REQUESTED APPROVED BY THE
03:01:58.841 --> 03:02:00.776
COMMITTEE. UNDERSTOOD REMOVED
03:02:00.843 --> 03:02:02.478
HIS SOMEONE MEMBER PATTERSON
03:02:02.544 --> 03:02:04.980
YEAH THIS CENTER BOARD JUST
03:02:05.047 --> 03:02:07.483
HOPEFULLY BRIEFLY. HEY WE SEVEN
03:02:07.549 --> 03:02:10.819
ADDITIONAL ITEM ON THE AGENDA.
03:02:10.886 --> 03:02:12.254
FOR THE RECORD I WOULD LIKE TO
03:02:12.321 --> 03:02:13.555
JUST MAKE SURE I WANT TO ASK
03:02:13.622 --> 03:02:16.992
THE SHERIFF UP FROM FRESNO TO
03:02:17.059 --> 03:02:19.261
REITERATE WHEN. WERE YOU
03:02:19.328 --> 03:02:21.630
NOTIFIED THAT YOU ARE SUBJECT
03:02:21.697 --> 03:02:25.301
OF THE AUDIT. I RECEIVED AN
03:02:25.367 --> 03:02:26.669
EMAIL ON WEDNESDAY THE
03:02:26.735 --> 03:02:31.607
NINETEENTH. WERE YOU AT THAT
03:02:31.674 --> 03:02:33.409
TIME OR ANY TIME SUBSEQUENT TO
03:02:33.475 --> 03:02:37.546
THAT. ASK FOR ANY SUPPORTIVE
03:02:37.613 --> 03:02:41.083
DATA ANY DIRECT INFORMATION ANY
03:02:41.150 --> 03:02:43.686
AUDITS OR ANY OTHER INFORMATION.
03:02:43.752 --> 03:02:49.291
NO YOU KNOW MISTER CHAIRMAN OF
03:02:49.358 --> 03:02:50.759
UNDER ON TO THAT OUGHT TO BE
03:02:50.826 --> 03:02:51.293
HONEST THAT THAT TO ME WE
03:02:51.360 --> 03:02:55.097
REALLY. THIS IS NOT A FAIR AND
03:02:55.164 --> 03:02:58.600
UNBIASED ASSETS FRESNO COUNTY
03:02:58.667 --> 03:03:01.103
HAS BEEN THROWN IN TO TWO OTHER
03:03:01.170 --> 03:03:01.704
COUNTIES THAT HAVE APPARENTLY
03:03:01.770 --> 03:03:05.341
SOME. CONFLICT OR SOME SOME
03:03:05.407 --> 03:03:08.277
KIND OF RIGHT SO I CAN'T VOTE
03:03:08.344 --> 03:03:09.378
FOR THIS AND I REALLY WISH MY
03:03:09.445 --> 03:03:11.046
COLLEAGUES WOULD SAY- YOU GOT
03:03:11.113 --> 03:03:12.481
TWO OF THEM UP HERE YOU WANT
03:03:12.548 --> 03:03:13.916
AUDIT FINE FRESNO COUNTY I
03:03:13.982 --> 03:03:14.650
THINK SHOULD BE GIVEN AN
03:03:14.717 --> 03:03:17.986
OPPORTUNITY. TO RESPOND AND TO
03:03:18.053 --> 03:03:20.956
BE A AT TO BE ABLE TO DIRECTLY
03:03:21.023 --> 03:03:25.728
ANSWER THE BASIC. QUESTIONS AS
03:03:25.794 --> 03:03:26.295
TO FIRST OF ALL WHAT DO YOU
03:03:26.362 --> 03:03:28.464
SPENDING YOUR MONEY ON. 97% IS
03:03:28.530 --> 03:03:31.367
GOING OUT THE DOOR. AND NUMBER
03:03:31.433 --> 03:03:35.771
TWO. THAT THAT THE AUDIT IS IN
03:03:35.838 --> 03:03:41.477
FULL VIEW EXCEPT HERE. THANK
03:03:41.543 --> 03:03:42.911
THANK YOU MISTER PATTERSON
03:03:42.978 --> 03:03:43.912
EITHER WASN'T A QUESTION THERE
03:03:43.979 --> 03:03:45.114
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO CENTER
03:03:45.180 --> 03:03:46.715
BORE GISTS BUT THOSE MISTER
03:03:46.782 --> 03:03:48.384
PATTERSON'S REQUEST AND- WE
03:03:48.450 --> 03:03:49.985
JUST COMMENT THAT NO WE USUALLY
03:03:50.052 --> 03:03:51.487
GIVE DEFERENCE TO THE MEMBER
03:03:51.553 --> 03:03:53.689
THAT REQUEST THE AUDIT TO
03:03:53.756 --> 03:03:55.391
CHANGED SCOPE WITHIN THE
03:03:55.457 --> 03:03:58.961
ALLOTTED TIME- SO WITH THAT
03:03:59.027 --> 03:04:02.097
WILL LOSE CENTER BORDERS IN THE
03:04:02.164 --> 03:04:03.966
HOME I'LL BE BRIEF. I THINK. I
03:04:04.032 --> 03:04:05.601
THINK THAT INTO A CENTER
03:04:05.667 --> 03:04:08.203
GONZALEZ HAD- PUTTING FORWARD
03:04:08.270 --> 03:04:10.239
AN IDEA THAT. I THINK COULD
03:04:10.305 --> 03:04:12.074
SATISFY EVERYONE'S INTEREST
03:04:12.141 --> 03:04:14.209
YOUR DESIRE FOR INFORMATION AND
03:04:14.276 --> 03:04:15.377
OUR DESIRE TO MAKE SURE THAT
03:04:15.444 --> 03:04:16.812
THERE'S AN APPROPRIATE PROCESS
03:04:16.879 --> 03:04:19.348
THAT IS HONORED- I THINK IT'S
03:04:19.415 --> 03:04:22.284
CLEAR THAT. BASED ON THE- AN
03:04:22.351 --> 03:04:24.253
INFORMATION SHEET WHICH
03:04:24.319 --> 03:04:25.687
SPECIFICALLY REQUEST
03:04:25.754 --> 03:04:27.423
INFORMATION ON WHAT STEPS TAKEN
03:04:27.489 --> 03:04:29.024
WERE TAKEN. TO OBTAIN
03:04:29.091 --> 03:04:31.593
INFORMATION THAT FORM THE BASIS
03:04:31.660 --> 03:04:33.695
HAVING NOT GOTTEN RESPONSES
03:04:33.762 --> 03:04:34.897
THAT FORMS THE BASIS OF THE
03:04:34.963 --> 03:04:39.134
AUDIT. SO HOW ABOUT THIS. THAT
03:04:39.201 --> 03:04:42.204
ARE YOU MENTIONED- THAT IN
03:04:42.271 --> 03:04:43.038
AUDIT LIKE THIS WOULD TAKE
03:04:43.105 --> 03:04:44.907
ABOUT SIX MONTHS THAT WE SAID
03:04:44.973 --> 03:04:46.241
THAT'S CORRECT SENATOR HOW
03:04:46.308 --> 03:04:48.844
ABOUT THIS WHAT IF WE WERE TO-
03:04:48.911 --> 03:04:52.080
AUTHORIZE. THE AUDIT OF LOS
03:04:52.147 --> 03:04:53.415
ANGELES COUNTY BECAUSE CLEARLY
03:04:53.482 --> 03:04:55.684
THERE'S SOME HISTORY THERE
03:04:55.751 --> 03:04:56.285
WHERE INFORMATION IS NOT BEEN
03:04:56.351 --> 03:05:00.589
DISCLOSED. AND IN THE- IN THE
03:05:00.656 --> 03:05:02.958
IN THE INTERIM OVER THE NEXT.
03:05:03.025 --> 03:05:04.693
TWO MONTHS. THAT ALL THE
03:05:04.760 --> 03:05:06.361
INFORMATION THAT YOU ARE
03:05:06.428 --> 03:05:08.897
REQUESTING BE PRODUCED BY BOTH
03:05:08.964 --> 03:05:11.834
ALAMEDA AND FRESNO FRESNO
03:05:11.900 --> 03:05:12.935
PARTICULAR BECAUSE I REPRESENT
03:05:13.001 --> 03:05:15.404
THAT AREA- THAT THEY PROVIDE
03:05:15.471 --> 03:05:17.606
ALL THE INFORMATION. THAT YOU
03:05:17.673 --> 03:05:19.374
ARE REQUESTING IF FOR SOME
03:05:19.441 --> 03:05:22.344
REASON THE DO NOT PROVIDE
03:05:22.411 --> 03:05:22.778
INFORMATION TO YOUR
03:05:22.845 --> 03:05:24.613
SATISFACTION. THEN WE'RE
03:05:24.680 --> 03:05:26.882
MEETING HERE IN AUGUST IS THAT
03:05:26.949 --> 03:05:28.817
THE NEXT AVAILABLE MEETINGS
03:05:28.884 --> 03:05:30.819
THAT AUGUST GERMAN CORRECT AND
03:05:30.886 --> 03:05:33.689
I HAD JUST CONFERRING WITH THE
03:05:33.755 --> 03:05:34.189
RULES AS WELL AS WE CAN
03:05:34.256 --> 03:05:35.457
ACTUALLY. IF IT'S UP TO THE
03:05:35.524 --> 03:05:37.192
AUTHOR SHE WANTED TO EXCLUDE
03:05:37.259 --> 03:05:39.161
ONE OF THE CONTY SETS HER PER
03:05:39.228 --> 03:05:40.362
WHAT THE THAN FOR VICE LEE IT
03:05:40.429 --> 03:05:42.698
IS IF YOU WERE JOKES COLLUDED
03:05:42.764 --> 03:05:43.198
THAT. IN IF THEY'RE NOT
03:05:43.265 --> 03:05:45.167
COMPLYING. BRING THIS MATTER
03:05:45.234 --> 03:05:47.202
BACK IN IOWA ACTUALLY SUPPORT
03:05:47.269 --> 03:05:48.704
THE AUDIT OF MY OWN COUNTY
03:05:48.770 --> 03:05:50.839
UNDER THOSE VERY UNIQUE. BUT
03:05:50.906 --> 03:05:52.374
HOT HARDLY FORESEEABLE
03:05:52.441 --> 03:05:54.843
CIRCUMSTANCES. THAT I THINK GET
03:05:54.910 --> 03:05:56.144
YOU EVERYTHING YOU WANT WELL IT
03:05:56.211 --> 03:05:58.347
DOESN'T PENALIZE FOLKS. WERE
03:05:58.413 --> 03:05:59.982
BLINDLY BEING BROUGHT INTO THIS
03:06:00.048 --> 03:06:01.617
PROCESS. WHEN THEY WOULD
03:06:01.683 --> 03:06:03.085
CERTAINLY HAVE BEEN WILLING TO
03:06:03.151 --> 03:06:05.554
PROVIDE INFORMATION ON THAT
03:06:05.621 --> 03:06:06.054
WOULD BE HELPFUL TO YOUR
03:06:06.121 --> 03:06:08.857
PURSUIT OF IT. WAS SENATOR I
03:06:08.924 --> 03:06:10.125
UNFORTUNATELY DON'T HAVE THE
03:06:10.192 --> 03:06:12.060
CAPACITY TO CONDUCT MY OWN
03:06:12.127 --> 03:06:14.229
AUDIT IN MY OFFICE- AND IF I'M
03:06:14.296 --> 03:06:16.498
HEARING YOU. THAT'S ESSENTIALLY
03:06:16.565 --> 03:06:19.301
WHAT YOU WOULD BE ASKING OF ME.
03:06:19.368 --> 03:06:21.336
ARE YOU HAVE NINE QUESTIONS
03:06:21.403 --> 03:06:22.671
THAT YOU ARE PROPOSING THE
03:06:22.738 --> 03:06:25.240
SCOPE OF THIS AUDIT. CERTAINLY
03:06:25.307 --> 03:06:28.777
CERTAINLY. ARE A RESPONSE FROM-
03:06:28.844 --> 03:06:31.914
FROM A COUNTY. WOULD BE ABLE TO
03:06:31.980 --> 03:06:34.550
ANSWER THESE NINE QUESTIONS.
03:06:34.616 --> 03:06:36.451
WITH RELATIVE EASE. THAT WOULD
03:06:36.518 --> 03:06:39.655
BE MY HOPE TO BUT THAT IS- THE
03:06:39.721 --> 03:06:40.889
HOPE THAT I'M NOT WILLING TO
03:06:40.956 --> 03:06:42.391
PUT IN THE BANK I KNOW THAT WE
03:06:42.457 --> 03:06:43.559
HAVE A STATE AUDITOR'S
03:06:43.625 --> 03:06:45.394
DEPARTMENT WHO IS GOT THAT
03:06:45.460 --> 03:06:47.930
PROFESSIONAL. A CAPACITY AS
03:06:47.996 --> 03:06:49.031
WELL AS THE INFRASTRUCTURE TO
03:06:49.097 --> 03:06:50.999
CONDUCT THIS AND I CERTAINLY
03:06:51.066 --> 03:06:54.469
WOULD NOT WANT TO. OVERSTEP MY
03:06:54.536 --> 03:06:56.672
PAY GRADE IN TRYING TO GO AHEAD
03:06:56.738 --> 03:06:57.940
OF THE LEGISLATOR AND CONDUCT
03:06:58.006 --> 03:07:00.008
AN AUDIT. I AM CERTAINLY
03:07:00.075 --> 03:07:01.743
WILLING TO CONSIDER SOME DEGREE
03:07:01.810 --> 03:07:03.712
OF FLEXIBILITY WITH REGARDS TO
03:07:03.779 --> 03:07:05.714
THE AUDIT. AND HAVING ALAMEDA
03:07:05.781 --> 03:07:07.115
LOS ANGELES BE PART OF THE
03:07:07.182 --> 03:07:10.018
FIRST WAVE. AND THEN HAVE
03:07:10.085 --> 03:07:11.787
FRESNO SENSE AS THEY MENTIONED.
03:07:11.853 --> 03:07:13.255
THEY HAVE JUST COMPLETED AN
03:07:13.322 --> 03:07:15.357
AUDIT IN HAVING 97% OF FUNDING
03:07:15.424 --> 03:07:16.892
GO OUT THE DOOR IS ONE THING
03:07:16.959 --> 03:07:18.260
KNOWING HOW IT IS BEING SPENT
03:07:18.327 --> 03:07:19.361
AS SOMETHING ELSE AND THAT'S
03:07:19.428 --> 03:07:21.430
WHAT YOU FIND WHEN YOU CONDUCT
03:07:21.496 --> 03:07:23.599
AN AUDIT. SO I'VE I CAN I WOULD
03:07:23.665 --> 03:07:26.635
LIKE TO COUNTER. YOUR OFFER- BY
03:07:26.702 --> 03:07:29.471
ASKING FOR THOSE TWO TO BE
03:07:29.538 --> 03:07:31.940
AUDITED FIRST. FOUR THANK YOU
03:07:32.007 --> 03:07:33.475
THERE'S YOUR ANSWER ME THIS
03:07:33.542 --> 03:07:34.509
BOERNER HORVATH IF WE COULD
03:07:34.576 --> 03:07:36.078
MOVE QUICKLY WAS EVIDENT TIONAL
03:07:36.144 --> 03:07:37.779
ITEMS ON THE AGENDA I KNOW WHEN
03:07:37.846 --> 03:07:40.949
I'M LYING IS ON THE AGENDA TOO-
03:07:41.016 --> 03:07:41.316
I APPRECIATE THE
03:07:41.383 --> 03:07:43.652
ASSEMBLYMEMBER. STAGGERING THAT
03:07:43.719 --> 03:07:45.554
OUT AND SAYING ALAMEDA AND LA
03:07:45.621 --> 03:07:47.723
WHERE CLEARLY. YOU THERE HAVE
03:07:47.789 --> 03:07:49.291
BEEN A REQUESTED INFORMATION
03:07:49.358 --> 03:07:54.830
HAS NOT COME BACK- HE'S- SO.
03:07:54.896 --> 03:07:56.164
ALSO ADULT WAS THE TEST OF I'M
03:07:56.231 --> 03:07:59.701
SORRY. PLEASE WAS BORDERLINE I
03:07:59.768 --> 03:08:01.670
THOUGHT I HEARD FROM THE
03:08:01.737 --> 03:08:03.271
REQUESTED- OUR COLLEAGUE
03:08:03.338 --> 03:08:05.374
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COMMA OTHER THAN
03:08:05.440 --> 03:08:06.241
THAT INFORMATION IS REQUESTED
03:08:06.308 --> 03:08:08.143
AND I AM GOING WITH WHAT MY
03:08:08.210 --> 03:08:10.145
COLLEAGUE SAYS PLEASE DO NOT
03:08:10.212 --> 03:08:12.881
INTERRUPT ME. AND I DO THINK
03:08:12.948 --> 03:08:15.851
THERE'S A VALUE IF FRESNO IS
03:08:15.917 --> 03:08:17.085
ALREADY DONE WE'VE WE'VE DEALT
03:08:17.152 --> 03:08:18.286
WITH THIS ON A NUMBER OF
03:08:18.353 --> 03:08:19.488
DIFFERENT THINGS LAST YEAR IF
03:08:19.554 --> 03:08:20.856
FRESNO IS ALREADY DONE THAT ON
03:08:20.922 --> 03:08:22.024
IT MAYBE THE STATE ORDER CAN
03:08:22.090 --> 03:08:23.492
CAN CHIME IN IF THAT
03:08:23.558 --> 03:08:24.559
INFORMATION IS ALREADY THERE
03:08:24.626 --> 03:08:25.694
YOU'RE NOT DUPLICATING THE
03:08:25.761 --> 03:08:27.362
INFORMATION SORRY THERE YOU'RE
03:08:27.429 --> 03:08:28.263
PROVING OF THAT INFORMATION
03:08:28.330 --> 03:08:30.032
SATISFIES. THE REQUEST OF THE
03:08:30.098 --> 03:08:31.667
IDEA IS THAT CORRECT IS NOT
03:08:31.733 --> 03:08:33.468
ADDITIONAL AUDITING OF AN
03:08:33.535 --> 03:08:35.203
EXISTING ARE ADDED THAT IS
03:08:35.270 --> 03:08:37.005
CORRECT SO TO THE EXTENT AN
03:08:37.072 --> 03:08:38.240
AUDIT HAS BEEN DONE WE WILL
03:08:38.306 --> 03:08:39.474
LOOK AT THAT WORK DETERMINE
03:08:39.541 --> 03:08:40.842
WHETHER WE CAN RELY ON IT IF
03:08:40.909 --> 03:08:42.210
IT'S DONE BY A REPUTABLE FIRM I
03:08:42.277 --> 03:08:43.612
WOULD ASSUME WE WOULD BE ABLE
03:08:43.679 --> 03:08:45.647
TO RELY ON IT. WE WOULD WE
03:08:45.714 --> 03:08:46.915
WOULD. WANT TO MAKE SURE WE
03:08:46.982 --> 03:08:47.983
COULD RELY ON THE INFORMATION
03:08:48.050 --> 03:08:49.384
IF WE DEEM THAT WE CAN RELY ON
03:08:49.451 --> 03:08:51.520
IT THEN WE WILL NOT DUPLICATE.
03:08:51.586 --> 03:08:52.854
THE WORK THAT'S ALREADY BEEN
03:08:52.921 --> 03:08:54.890
DONE WE WILL USE THAT WORK TO
03:08:54.956 --> 03:08:55.457
ANSWER SOME OF THE QUESTIONS
03:08:55.524 --> 03:08:57.025
THAT HAVE BEEN ASKED. SO IN
03:08:57.092 --> 03:08:58.393
THEORY THIS COULD ACTUALLY
03:08:58.460 --> 03:08:59.895
REDUCE ACTION THE TOTAL NUMBER
03:08:59.961 --> 03:09:01.263
OF HOURS. IF THE WORK THAT
03:09:01.329 --> 03:09:03.398
FRESNO HAS BEEN DONE. SATISFIES
03:09:03.465 --> 03:09:05.600
THE QUESTIONS OF THE AUDIT AS
03:09:05.667 --> 03:09:06.168
WELL CORRECT THAT IS CORRECT
03:09:06.234 --> 03:09:10.005
OKAY. OR IF THANK GOODNESS ADAM
03:09:10.072 --> 03:09:11.373
AT THE REALLY IMPORTANT UNLESS
03:09:11.440 --> 03:09:13.208
IT WAS A DIRECT QUESTION TO YOU
03:09:13.275 --> 03:09:15.210
WE NEED TO MOVE ON. OKAY AT
03:09:15.277 --> 03:09:16.611
THIS TIME HEARING AND SEEING NO
03:09:16.678 --> 03:09:18.947
MORE. QUESTIONS FROM MEMBERS OF
03:09:19.014 --> 03:09:21.383
THE DíAS. LET'S GO TO MOVE TO
03:09:21.450 --> 03:09:31.793
PUBLIC COMMENT. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:09:31.860 --> 03:09:33.895
MY NAME IS JOHN LINDSAY POLAND
03:09:33.962 --> 03:09:34.496
I'M WITH THE AMERICAN FRIENDS
03:09:34.563 --> 03:09:36.164
SERVICE COMMITTEE A HERE IN
03:09:36.231 --> 03:09:38.200
REPRESENTATION OF MORE THAN
03:09:38.266 --> 03:09:39.267
FIFTY COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS
03:09:39.334 --> 03:09:41.303
FROM ALAMEDA COUNTY IN STRONG
03:09:41.369 --> 03:09:44.139
SUPPORT OF THIS REQUEST. WE
03:09:44.206 --> 03:09:45.807
HAVE WORKED FOR MORE THAN TWO
03:09:45.874 --> 03:09:47.676
YEARS IN ALAMEDA COUNTY TO TRY
03:09:47.743 --> 03:09:49.478
TO GET A PERFORMANCE AND
03:09:49.544 --> 03:09:51.213
FINANCIAL AUDITS OF THE ALAMEDA
03:09:51.279 --> 03:09:53.448
COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE THAT A
03:09:53.515 --> 03:09:54.750
REQUEST HAS ALSO BEEN SUPPORTED
03:09:54.816 --> 03:09:56.685
MORE THAN A YEAR AGO. BY A
03:09:56.752 --> 03:09:58.286
LETTER FROM SENATOR SKINNER
03:09:58.353 --> 03:10:00.088
WHOSE DISTRICT DICTION OF THIS
03:10:00.155 --> 03:10:02.157
IS IN WHO ALSO CALLS FOR A FULL
03:10:02.224 --> 03:10:03.959
PERFORMANCE AND FINANCIAL
03:10:04.025 --> 03:10:05.627
AUDITS I WOULD NOTE THAT THE
03:10:05.694 --> 03:10:07.028
ALAMEDA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
03:10:07.095 --> 03:10:08.764
USE ONE ON A AB ONE ONLINE
03:10:08.830 --> 03:10:10.966
FUNDS. IS COMPLETELY OPAQUE IT
03:10:11.032 --> 03:10:13.335
IS NOT AVAILABLE ON ANY
03:10:13.401 --> 03:10:15.437
PUBLICLY AVAILABLE SITE. ED NOT
03:10:15.504 --> 03:10:16.838
THAT LONG AGO SHERIFF A HER
03:10:16.905 --> 03:10:18.306
THEMSELVES SAID PUBLICLY THAT
03:10:18.373 --> 03:10:20.408
HE WELCOMES AN AUDIT. AND I
03:10:20.475 --> 03:10:22.677
WOULD SAY FINALLY THAT- HOW THE
03:10:22.744 --> 03:10:24.913
FUNDS ARE I DON'T AS MY
03:10:24.980 --> 03:10:26.348
UNDERSTAND IT OTHER AUDITS AND
03:10:26.414 --> 03:10:27.716
REPORTS AND POTENTIALLY EVEN
03:10:27.783 --> 03:10:29.384
THE ONE FOR FRESNO. ARE NOT
03:10:29.451 --> 03:10:31.419
ACTUALLY ASKING HOW ARE THE
03:10:31.486 --> 03:10:32.888
FUNDS THAT THE SHERIFF'S ARE
03:10:32.954 --> 03:10:34.756
USING FURTHERING THE PURPOSE OF
03:10:34.823 --> 03:10:36.958
AB ONE ON THE LINE FOR NINE AND
03:10:37.025 --> 03:10:37.893
QUIRK INCARCERATION
03:10:37.959 --> 03:10:40.962
pOUT BY MISTER CLAYTON JOHNSON.
03:10:41.029 --> 03:10:42.164
THAT IS ONE OF THE KEY POINTS
03:10:42.230 --> 03:10:43.965
OF THE OF THE AUDIT REQUEST
03:10:44.032 --> 03:10:45.200
THAT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED FOR
03:10:45.267 --> 03:10:46.768
ALL THREE COUNTIES THANK YOU
03:10:46.835 --> 03:10:48.069
THANK YOU. ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY
03:10:48.136 --> 03:10:49.271
BIGGER PLEASE BE CONCISE WITH
03:10:49.337 --> 03:10:50.505
THEIR COMMENTS SHORT KAELIN
03:10:50.572 --> 03:10:51.907
DEAN WITH THE ALLIANCE FOR BOYS
03:10:51.973 --> 03:10:53.475
AND MEN OF COLOR AT POLICY LINK
03:10:53.542 --> 03:10:55.177
WE ARE IN STRONG COSPONSORED
03:10:55.243 --> 03:10:56.444
SUPPORT OF THIS AND WE WANT TO
03:10:56.511 --> 03:10:57.179
THANK THE MEMBER FOR BRINGING
03:10:57.245 --> 03:10:59.014
THIS REQUEST FORWARD. AND ALSO
03:10:59.080 --> 03:11:00.081
THANK YOU REMEMBER RUBIO FOR
03:11:00.148 --> 03:11:01.783
YOUR REMARKS TODAY WE REPRESENT
03:11:01.850 --> 03:11:02.751
OVER TWO HUNDRED PARTNERING
03:11:02.818 --> 03:11:03.885
ORGANIZATIONS THROUGHOUT THE
03:11:03.952 --> 03:11:06.288
STATE OF CALIFORNIA THANK YOU.
03:11:06.354 --> 03:11:07.689
ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY. JOSH
03:11:07.756 --> 03:11:08.623
DUGGAR WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:11:08.690 --> 03:11:10.292
STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES.
03:11:10.358 --> 03:11:11.226
JUST WANNA MAKE IT CLEAR WE
03:11:11.293 --> 03:11:12.427
HAVE NO CONCERNS WITH
03:11:12.494 --> 03:11:13.829
TRANSPARENCY IN REALIGNMENT
03:11:13.895 --> 03:11:15.063
SPENDING AND WELCOME THAT
03:11:15.130 --> 03:11:17.032
CONVERSATION. HOWEVER WE DID
03:11:17.098 --> 03:11:18.900
WANT TO NOTE THAT THE YEAR IT
03:11:18.967 --> 03:11:20.368
THERE IS A ANNUAL REPORTING
03:11:20.435 --> 03:11:21.703
FROM COUNTIES TO THE BOARD OF
03:11:21.770 --> 03:11:22.938
STATE COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS AND
03:11:23.004 --> 03:11:24.873
REPORTS POSTED ON THE- SEC'S
03:11:24.940 --> 03:11:26.775
WEBSITE. I THINK THE REPORTS
03:11:26.842 --> 03:11:28.410
YOU KNOW APPROXIMATELY FOUR
03:11:28.476 --> 03:11:29.044
HUNDRED PAGES INCLUDES
03:11:29.110 --> 03:11:31.112
INFORMATION ABOUT. PROGRESS IN
03:11:31.179 --> 03:11:32.881
ACHIEVING OUTCOMES IDENTIFIED
03:11:32.948 --> 03:11:34.883
IN C. C. P. PLANS. ON
03:11:34.950 --> 03:11:36.351
ALLOCATION OF FUNDING BETWEEN
03:11:36.418 --> 03:11:37.853
DEPARTMENTS PROGRAMS AND
03:11:37.919 --> 03:11:40.922
SERVICES THAT ARE- TARGETED.
03:11:40.989 --> 03:11:42.991
AND THERE IS THE ANNUAL FUNDING
03:11:43.058 --> 03:11:44.659
AND THE ON BOARD OF SAYING
03:11:44.726 --> 03:11:45.360
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS BUDGET
03:11:45.427 --> 03:11:47.162
THAT FUNDS. THE GATHERING OF
03:11:47.229 --> 03:11:48.630
THE C. C. P.'S IN EACH COUNTY
03:11:48.697 --> 03:11:49.798
AND COUNTIES DON'T RECEIVE
03:11:49.865 --> 03:11:51.233
THOSE FUNDS UNLESS THEY-
03:11:51.299 --> 03:11:53.101
RESPOND TO ALL THE QUESTIONS
03:11:53.168 --> 03:11:55.170
AND INFORMATION. REQUESTED BY
03:11:55.237 --> 03:11:57.405
STATE. I WILL SKIP THE PIECE
03:11:57.472 --> 03:11:59.975
ABOUT THE CONTEXT SETTING ON
03:12:00.041 --> 03:12:00.609
TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN REALIGNMENT
03:12:00.675 --> 03:12:01.209
I THINK WE'VE HEARD A LOT OF
03:12:01.276 --> 03:12:02.544
CONVERSATION ABOUT THAT ALREADY
03:12:02.611 --> 03:12:03.879
BUT- JUST ONE MAKE IT CLEAR
03:12:03.945 --> 03:12:06.648
COUNTY STEPPED. UP TO PARTNER
03:12:06.715 --> 03:12:07.282
WITH THE STATE. TO HELP SOLVE A
03:12:07.349 --> 03:12:09.584
VERY COMPLEX PROBLEM. AND THE
03:12:09.651 --> 03:12:11.720
SOLUTION THAT WAS AGREED UPON-
03:12:11.786 --> 03:12:13.755
DID NOT INCLUDE TRYING TO MAKE
03:12:13.822 --> 03:12:16.124
EVERY. COUNTY IN THE STATE LOOK
03:12:16.191 --> 03:12:17.993
LIKE EACH OTHER NOR LOOK LIKE
03:12:18.059 --> 03:12:20.028
THE STATE SYSTEM- SO LIKE I
03:12:20.095 --> 03:12:23.164
SAID- WE ARE. OPEN TO
03:12:23.231 --> 03:12:24.266
TRANSPARENCY IN FURTHER
03:12:24.332 --> 03:12:26.501
CONVERSATIONS BUT- JUST WANTED
03:12:26.568 --> 03:12:27.702
TO MAKE SURE. IT'S CLEAR WHAT
03:12:27.769 --> 03:12:29.170
INFORMATION IS OUT THERE THANK
03:12:29.237 --> 03:12:32.440
YOU. THANK YOU ADDITIONAL
03:12:32.507 --> 03:12:34.309
PUBLIC COMMENT PLEASE. A MAKE A
03:12:34.376 --> 03:12:35.477
MOTEL WITH THE YOUNG WOMEN'S
03:12:35.543 --> 03:12:36.611
FREEDOM CENTER AND THIS IS TO
03:12:36.678 --> 03:12:38.513
WORRY YEARS FREEDOM COALITION.
03:12:38.580 --> 03:12:40.015
REPRESENTING FIVE HUNDRED
03:12:40.081 --> 03:12:42.684
COALITION MEMBERS OF THAT ARE
03:12:42.751 --> 03:12:43.818
HOLDING DOWN CHAPTERS IN EACH
03:12:43.885 --> 03:12:46.121
OF THE- COUNTIES THAT AUDITS
03:12:46.187 --> 03:12:50.091
WERE REQUESTED. OF ITS THE- OF
03:12:50.158 --> 03:12:51.026
REQUESTS THAT WE STRONGLY
03:12:51.092 --> 03:12:53.728
SUPPORT- AND PROTECTION OF OUR
03:12:53.795 --> 03:12:55.730
LOVED ONES ON THE INSIDE AND
03:12:55.797 --> 03:12:57.165
ARE FORMALLY INCARCERATED WOMEN
03:12:57.232 --> 03:12:59.534
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. THANK YOU
03:12:59.601 --> 03:13:01.436
NATIONAL TEST MONEY PLACE. GOOD
03:13:01.503 --> 03:13:02.537
AFTERNOON CHEN MEMBERS DENNIS
03:13:02.604 --> 03:13:04.105
LET US ROMERO WITH ACLU OF
03:13:04.172 --> 03:13:05.707
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT OF TIS
03:13:05.774 --> 03:13:07.575
AUDIT REQUEST- ONE OF OUR
03:13:07.642 --> 03:13:08.710
AFFILIATES ACLU OF NORTHERN
03:13:08.777 --> 03:13:10.045
CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN ACTIVELY
03:13:10.111 --> 03:13:11.813
ENGAGED IN THE AUDIT- ALAMEDA
03:13:11.880 --> 03:13:13.548
COUNTY REQUEST FOR THE PASS
03:13:13.615 --> 03:13:15.817
OVER THE LAST PAST YEAR SO WE
03:13:15.884 --> 03:13:18.053
STRONGLY URGE- THE COMMITTEE TO
03:13:18.119 --> 03:13:18.653
SUPPORT THIS AUDIT. THANK YOU
03:13:18.720 --> 03:13:20.655
THANK YOU. ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY
03:13:20.722 --> 03:13:21.756
WELL MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS
03:13:21.823 --> 03:13:23.191
BRENDAN UP ON BEHALF OF LOS
03:13:23.258 --> 03:13:25.160
ANGELES COUNTY SHERIFF. ONE WE
03:13:25.226 --> 03:13:25.760
DON'T HAVE A POSITION ON THE
03:13:25.827 --> 03:13:28.096
AUDIT REQUEST. TO IF WE WERE UP
03:13:28.163 --> 03:13:29.531
PROVIDED THE NINE QUESTIONS WE
03:13:29.597 --> 03:13:30.999
WOULD OF CERTAINLY RESPONDED
03:13:31.066 --> 03:13:33.868
AND PRESIDENTIAL FLANK ONCE
03:13:33.935 --> 03:13:36.338
QUESTIONS. AND NUMBER THREE- WE
03:13:36.404 --> 03:13:37.472
LOOK FORWARD TO IF THIS IS
03:13:37.539 --> 03:13:38.907
GRANT OF THE RESULTS BECAUSE
03:13:38.974 --> 03:13:39.908
WHO KNOWS MAYBE WE'LL SHOW THE
03:13:39.975 --> 03:13:41.609
LA COUNTY IS A MODEL COUNTY.
03:13:41.676 --> 03:13:43.511
ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU. MISSIONAL
03:13:43.578 --> 03:13:45.080
TESTIMONY MISTER CHAIRMAN WRIST
03:13:45.146 --> 03:13:46.081
CORSAGE ALONG HAVE THE
03:13:46.147 --> 03:13:47.582
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
03:13:47.649 --> 03:13:48.850
ON SUPPORTER IN OPPOSITION TO
03:13:48.917 --> 03:13:50.385
THE REQUEST. BUT WE JUST NOTE
03:13:50.452 --> 03:13:51.353
THAT REALIGNMENT WAS A
03:13:51.419 --> 03:13:53.388
MONUMENTAL REFORM. THAT BROUGHT
03:13:53.455 --> 03:13:55.290
COUNTIES IN THE STATE TOGETHER
03:13:55.357 --> 03:13:56.725
IN PARTNERSHIP NOT ONLY AT THE
03:13:56.791 --> 03:13:58.059
STATE AND COUNTY LEVEL BUT ALSO
03:13:58.126 --> 03:13:59.327
COUNTY AGENCIES JUSTICE
03:13:59.394 --> 03:14:01.463
PARTNERS WORKING TOGETHER. TO
03:14:01.529 --> 03:14:04.332
ADDRESS NOT ONLY ALTERNATIVES
03:14:04.399 --> 03:14:05.500
TO ARBITRATE PRISONER RELEASES
03:14:05.567 --> 03:14:06.768
THAT WOULD HAVE RESULTED FROM
03:14:06.835 --> 03:14:08.903
THE PRISON OVERCROWDING- BUT TO
03:14:08.970 --> 03:14:10.705
ADDRESS LOCAL SYSTEM NEEDS WE
03:14:10.772 --> 03:14:11.840
STARTED WITH FIFTY EIGHT
03:14:11.906 --> 03:14:13.041
COUNTIES IN FIFTY EIGHT
03:14:13.108 --> 03:14:14.743
DIFFERENT SPOTS. WE HAVE TO
03:14:14.809 --> 03:14:16.578
REALIZE THAT FLEXIBILITY IN
03:14:16.644 --> 03:14:19.614
THIS IS VITAL- THE PLANS FOR
03:14:19.681 --> 03:14:21.916
EACH COUNTY ARE ON THE BSE SEE
03:14:21.983 --> 03:14:24.919
WEBSITE. THEY ARE UPDATED- THE
03:14:24.986 --> 03:14:26.388
BE A C. C. DOESN'T ANNUAL
03:14:26.454 --> 03:14:27.856
REPORT THAT SHOWS HERE'S WHAT
03:14:27.922 --> 03:14:29.324
THE COMMITTEE WITH THE COUNTIES
03:14:29.391 --> 03:14:31.126
HAVE PUT TOGETHER. THE CCP
03:14:31.192 --> 03:14:32.594
PROCESSES PUBLIC THE COUNTY
03:14:32.660 --> 03:14:34.095
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HAVE ARE
03:14:34.162 --> 03:14:35.930
THE ABILITY TO DIE I REQUEST
03:14:35.997 --> 03:14:37.799
FOR FUNDING. IT'S ALL PUBLIC
03:14:37.866 --> 03:14:39.200
IT'S ALL NOTICED. IT'S ON THE
03:14:39.267 --> 03:14:40.935
BSE SEE WEBSITE SO WOULD
03:14:41.002 --> 03:14:42.103
COMMEND THAT TO THE COMMITTEE'S
03:14:42.170 --> 03:14:43.805
ATTENTION- AND JUST ASK YOU
03:14:43.872 --> 03:14:46.708
THAT AS YOU CONSIDER THIS AUDIT
03:14:46.775 --> 03:14:47.308
REQUEST THANK YOU THANK YOU.
03:14:47.375 --> 03:14:47.876
RIGHT MASS BECAUSE THERE'S
03:14:47.942 --> 03:14:49.611
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT.
03:14:49.677 --> 03:14:51.713
HEARING AND SAYING NONO. RETURN
03:14:51.780 --> 03:14:53.581
IT BACK TO THE DíAS ASSEMBLY
03:14:53.648 --> 03:14:54.916
MEMBER IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
03:14:54.983 --> 03:14:57.552
CLOSE. YES I WOULD. JUST LIKE
03:14:57.619 --> 03:14:58.720
TO SAY THANK YOU TO ALL THOSE
03:14:58.787 --> 03:15:01.423
WHO PROVIDED COMMENT WE- TO ARE
03:15:01.489 --> 03:15:02.557
NOT SUGGESTING THAT EVERY
03:15:02.624 --> 03:15:03.625
COUNTY LOOK LIKE EACH OTHER WE
03:15:03.691 --> 03:15:04.893
JUST WANT TO KNOW WHAT'S
03:15:04.959 --> 03:15:05.727
HAPPENING IN THREE OF THE
03:15:05.794 --> 03:15:07.896
COUNTY- AND HOPEFULLY WHAT
03:15:07.962 --> 03:15:10.065
COMES BACK FROM. THE AUDIT OF
03:15:10.131 --> 03:15:11.466
LOS ANGELES COUNTY WILL REVEAL
03:15:11.533 --> 03:15:12.934
THAT SOME OF THE PRACTICES.
03:15:13.001 --> 03:15:14.636
THAT THEY ARE EMPLOYING COULD
03:15:14.702 --> 03:15:15.603
SERVE AS MODELS AND BEST
03:15:15.670 --> 03:15:17.739
PRACTICES FOR OTHER DEPARTMENTS
03:15:17.806 --> 03:15:19.707
ACROSS THE STATE. AND LASTLY. I
03:15:19.774 --> 03:15:21.509
PRINTED OUT THE PAGE FOR THE B.
03:15:21.576 --> 03:15:24.212
STC OF THE PLANS AND FOR FISCAL
03:15:24.279 --> 03:15:25.713
YEAR TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN AND
03:15:25.780 --> 03:15:26.781
IN TWO THOUSAND TWENTY THERE
03:15:26.848 --> 03:15:28.683
ONLY THREE PLANS ON THERE KERN
03:15:28.750 --> 03:15:30.385
COUNTY CALAVERAS AND STANISLAUS
03:15:30.452 --> 03:15:32.787
COUNTY. THOSE ARE ALMOST THE
03:15:32.854 --> 03:15:41.296
SAME. UNTIL TWO THOUSAND.
03:15:41.362 --> 03:15:42.897
TWELVE THIRTEEN SO YOU KNOW
03:15:42.964 --> 03:15:45.066
FIVE YEARS IS A LONG TIME. A
03:15:45.133 --> 03:15:46.334
LOT OF THINGS THAT HAPPENED IN
03:15:46.401 --> 03:15:48.103
THE LAST FIVE YEARS THIS ALL
03:15:48.169 --> 03:15:50.138
THE REQUESTED ASKING OR THESE
03:15:50.205 --> 03:15:51.206
NINE QUESTIONS THAT HAVE BEEN
03:15:51.272 --> 03:15:52.373
DONE IN CONSULTATION WITH THE
03:15:52.440 --> 03:15:55.176
STATE AUDITOR'S DEPARTMENT WHEN
03:15:55.243 --> 03:15:56.211
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
03:15:56.277 --> 03:15:58.179
VOTE. THANK YOU ASSEMBLY WOMAN
03:15:58.246 --> 03:15:59.781
YEAH I BELIEVE IN TRANSPARENCY
03:15:59.848 --> 03:16:00.682
ACCOUNTABILITY BELIEVE ASSEMBLY
03:16:00.748 --> 03:16:02.584
WOMAN ARTICULATED IT REALLY
03:16:02.650 --> 03:16:03.685
WELL I DON'T THINK THIS IS A
03:16:03.751 --> 03:16:05.086
GOTCHA BUT RATHER SING WHAT
03:16:05.153 --> 03:16:06.321
BEST PRACTICES ARE OUT THERE IN
03:16:06.387 --> 03:16:08.289
OF THE STATE ADDRESS DONE THAT
03:16:08.356 --> 03:16:08.890
WITH A NUMBER OF AGENCIES IN
03:16:08.957 --> 03:16:11.893
THE PAST- WE WILL REVISIT
03:16:11.960 --> 03:16:13.294
PERHAPS WE HAVE TO ADJUST THE
03:16:13.361 --> 03:16:15.263
JOINT ROLES BETWEEN THE HOUSES.
03:16:15.330 --> 03:16:16.331
AFTER SOME OF THE OTHER ISSUES
03:16:16.397 --> 03:16:18.833
AS WELL BUT THIS TIME I WILL BE
03:16:18.900 --> 03:16:21.069
SUPPORTING THE AUDITED THE
03:16:21.136 --> 03:16:22.737
SECRETARY. CALDERON WE NEED A
03:16:22.804 --> 03:16:25.573
MOTION. THE LET ME ASK FOR THE
03:16:25.640 --> 03:16:28.042
MOTION WE WILL. HAS COME UNDER
03:16:28.109 --> 03:16:28.910
LET ME MAKE SURE I GET THIS
03:16:28.977 --> 03:16:30.745
CORRECT SO EMOTIONAL BE TO
03:16:30.812 --> 03:16:34.649
APPROVE THE ODD IT. LOOKING AT
03:16:34.716 --> 03:16:37.018
LOS ANGELES FIRST ALAMEDA
03:16:37.085 --> 03:16:39.154
SECONDED FRESNO THIRD CORRECT
03:16:39.220 --> 03:16:41.422
YES. OKAY WITH THAT DO I HAVE A
03:16:41.489 --> 03:16:44.259
MOTION ON. MOVED BY MISTER WOOD
03:16:44.325 --> 03:16:46.094
OF THE SECOND SECOND BY MISS
03:16:46.161 --> 03:16:55.904
RUBIO- MISS SECTOR CALDERON.
03:16:55.970 --> 03:17:01.342
CORRECT. THE MOTION IS TO
03:17:01.409 --> 03:17:03.378
APPROVE AUTUMN REQUEST NUMBER
03:17:03.444 --> 03:17:04.646
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE OF TWO
03:17:04.712 --> 03:17:08.483
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER COM LONGER.
03:17:08.550 --> 03:17:10.618
REGARDING LOS ANGELES COUNTY
03:17:10.685 --> 03:17:12.954
SHERIFF'S NUMBER ONE NUMBER TWO
03:17:13.021 --> 03:17:15.690
ALAMEDA COUNTY AND THREE FRESNO
03:17:15.757 --> 03:17:17.759
COUNTY. SHERIFF'S OFFICES
03:17:17.825 --> 03:17:19.494
REALIGNMENT FUND SPENDING
03:17:19.561 --> 03:17:22.096
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS HI SALAS
03:17:22.163 --> 03:17:24.966
HI BOERNER HORVATH. HI
03:17:25.033 --> 03:17:27.702
BOERNER HORVATH HI JAN.
03:17:27.769 --> 03:17:31.206
PATTERSON PATTERSON NOW RUBIO
03:17:31.272 --> 03:17:33.641
RUBIO HIGH VOEPEL VOEPEL I
03:17:33.708 --> 03:17:42.350
WOULD. WHAT I SENATOR ROTH.
03:17:42.417 --> 03:17:47.388
BARGES BORDERS NOW GONZALEZ
03:17:47.455 --> 03:17:55.730
GONZALEZ I MINING. MORE LOCKED.
03:17:55.797 --> 03:18:01.970
WIENER. OKAY THAT ITEMS ON CALL
03:18:02.036 --> 03:18:03.471
LEAVE A FOR ADDITIONAL MEMBERS
03:18:03.538 --> 03:18:09.944
THAT ON THANK YOU. OKAY MEMBERS
03:18:10.011 --> 03:18:11.713
AT THIS TIME WE'RE GONNA MOVE
03:18:11.779 --> 03:18:13.948
TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN
03:18:14.015 --> 03:18:14.882
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE ONE FOR
03:18:14.949 --> 03:18:16.718
CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES BOARD
03:18:16.784 --> 03:18:18.253
GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTION
03:18:18.319 --> 03:18:20.054
PROGRAMS BY SENATOR BRADFORD.
03:18:20.121 --> 03:18:21.222
AS A ROUGH FOR WHEN YOU'RE
03:18:21.289 --> 03:18:22.557
READY TO BEGIN PLEASE. THANK
03:18:22.624 --> 03:18:26.327
YOU. I AFTER AN AFTERNOON
03:18:26.394 --> 03:18:31.266
AFTERNOON HAVE BEEN HERE SINCE.
03:18:31.332 --> 03:18:34.102
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
03:18:34.168 --> 03:18:35.970
WE'RE HERE TODAY ON THE ISSUE
03:18:36.037 --> 03:18:38.506
THAT IS NOT NEW TO ANY OF US
03:18:38.573 --> 03:18:40.541
HERE IT'S ONE THAT HAS BEEN
03:18:40.608 --> 03:18:43.211
DISCUSSED- BOTH OPENLY AND
03:18:43.278 --> 03:18:45.313
BEHIND CLOSED DOORS FOR A
03:18:45.380 --> 03:18:46.748
NUMBER OF YEARS OF MY NINE
03:18:46.814 --> 03:18:48.549
YEARS OF BEING HERE IN THE
03:18:48.616 --> 03:18:50.051
LEGISLATURE'S A ISSUE THAT HAS
03:18:50.118 --> 03:18:52.220
ALWAYS RISEN ITSELF AND LOOKING
03:18:52.287 --> 03:18:54.088
AT HOW EFFECTIVE WE ARE
03:18:54.155 --> 03:18:55.957
ALLOCATING MONEY. TO
03:18:56.024 --> 03:18:58.626
TRANSPORTATION CLIMATE PROGRAMS
03:18:58.693 --> 03:19:00.928
AND TWO THOUSAND AND NINETEEN
03:19:00.995 --> 03:19:03.264
BUDGET FOUR HUNDRED AND EIGHTY
03:19:03.331 --> 03:19:05.500
FIVE MILLION AND G. G. R. F.
03:19:05.566 --> 03:19:08.069
MONEY WAS ALLOCATED TO CAR LOW
03:19:08.136 --> 03:19:09.704
CARBON TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS
03:19:09.771 --> 03:19:11.806
IN TOTAL GARBAGE BIN OUT
03:19:11.873 --> 03:19:14.108
ALLOCATED TWO POINT TWO BILLION
03:19:14.175 --> 03:19:15.710
AGAIN TWO POINT TWO BILLION
03:19:15.777 --> 03:19:18.379
FORCE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS.
03:19:18.446 --> 03:19:20.915
THIS INCLUDES LIGHT AND HEAVY
03:19:20.982 --> 03:19:22.383
DUTY EQUIPMENT PROGRAMS. THE
03:19:22.450 --> 03:19:26.054
CALIFORNIA VEHICLE- RECYCLING
03:19:26.120 --> 03:19:27.288
PROGRAM SCHOOL BUS REPLACEMENT
03:19:27.355 --> 03:19:28.923
AND OTHER PROGRAMS AND YET THE
03:19:28.990 --> 03:19:31.359
LEGISLATIVE LEGISLATURE. HAS
03:19:31.426 --> 03:19:33.294
NOT ORDERED A COMPREHENSIVE
03:19:33.361 --> 03:19:35.963
REVIEW OF THE THIRTY TWO
03:19:36.030 --> 03:19:37.732
TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS AT CAR.
03:19:37.799 --> 03:19:38.933
THERE ARE BE REVIEWS OF CERTAIN
03:19:39.000 --> 03:19:41.069
PROGRAMS LIKE THE CALL CARL
03:19:41.135 --> 03:19:43.905
MARKET MORE YOUR PROGRAM- BUT
03:19:43.971 --> 03:19:44.472
THAT WAS OVER THIRTEEN YEARS
03:19:44.539 --> 03:19:46.641
AGO. SOME CAR PROGRAMS HAVE
03:19:46.708 --> 03:19:48.976
BEEN SCOPED INTO MULTI AGENCY
03:19:49.043 --> 03:19:51.279
AUDITS BUT NOT A SIMILAR AUDIT
03:19:51.346 --> 03:19:54.215
AS IT RELATES TO CARPET SO. IN
03:19:54.282 --> 03:19:54.849
TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN THE SENATE
03:19:54.916 --> 03:19:55.917
AND ASSEMBLY TRANSPORTATION
03:19:55.983 --> 03:19:57.618
COMMITTEE ATTEMPTED TO ASSESS
03:19:57.685 --> 03:19:59.520
THE COST IN GOLD THE VARIOUS
03:19:59.587 --> 03:20:01.255
CAR PROGRAMS BY THE END OF THE
03:20:01.322 --> 03:20:02.757
YEAR THOSE COMMUNITIES WERE
03:20:02.824 --> 03:20:04.859
ABLE TO DO SO TO JUST FIVE OF
03:20:04.926 --> 03:20:06.194
THOSE PROGRAMS. FOUR YEARS
03:20:06.260 --> 03:20:09.063
LATER THEY'RE STILL NOT BEEN AN
03:20:09.130 --> 03:20:11.065
OVER ARCHING REVIEW OF ALL
03:20:11.132 --> 03:20:13.067
THESE PROGRAMS AND THEIR
03:20:13.134 --> 03:20:16.137
AGGREGATED A FAX AS A RESULT.
03:20:16.204 --> 03:20:18.172
AND AS OF- THE LEGISLATIVE
03:20:18.239 --> 03:20:20.675
ANALYST'S OFFICE HAS TOLD US WE
03:20:20.742 --> 03:20:22.777
DO NOT HAVE COMPLETE. A
03:20:22.844 --> 03:20:24.379
COMPLETE UNDERSTANDING OF THE
03:20:24.445 --> 03:20:25.913
SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC COSTS
03:20:25.980 --> 03:20:27.749
ASSOCIATED WITH THESE VARIOUS
03:20:27.815 --> 03:20:29.250
PROGRAMS AND AS LEGISLATORS I
03:20:29.317 --> 03:20:30.985
THINK WE WOULD ALL WANT TO KNOW
03:20:31.052 --> 03:20:32.520
THE ANSWERS TO THAT. THE
03:20:32.587 --> 03:20:33.955
REQUEST IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
03:20:34.021 --> 03:20:36.157
PUT THIS QUESTION TO BED ONCE
03:20:36.224 --> 03:20:38.359
AND FOR ALL A MOVE FOR WHAT A
03:20:38.426 --> 03:20:39.961
COMMON UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT
03:20:40.027 --> 03:20:41.963
WORKS AND WHAT DOESN'T. THE
03:20:42.029 --> 03:20:43.664
ONLY GOOD FOR CALIFORNIA YOU
03:20:43.731 --> 03:20:45.366
KNOW AGAIN IT ONLY MAKES SENSE
03:20:45.433 --> 03:20:47.602
WE CAN ASSESS. THESE PROGRAMS
03:20:47.668 --> 03:20:49.237
BASED ON THE COST OF EACH
03:20:49.303 --> 03:20:51.973
METRIC TONS OF CARBON DIOXIDE
03:20:52.039 --> 03:20:54.108
THE REDUCE. AND THAT MEASURE
03:20:54.175 --> 03:20:56.077
VERY SIGNIFICANTLY SOME
03:20:56.144 --> 03:20:58.713
PROGRAMS COSTS. LESS IS HUNDRED
03:20:58.780 --> 03:21:00.114
ALL THE TIME WELL THERE'S OTHER
03:21:00.181 --> 03:21:02.150
PROGRAMS IT'S COST AS MUCH AS
03:21:02.216 --> 03:21:03.017
THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS A TODD
03:21:03.084 --> 03:21:05.086
AGAIN WE SHOULD WANT TO KNOW
03:21:05.153 --> 03:21:07.822
THOSE COST. BUT A FEW METRICS
03:21:07.889 --> 03:21:09.891
DOESN'T GET THE UNDERSTANDING
03:21:09.957 --> 03:21:12.927
TO THE QUESTIONS HERE. WHICH IS
03:21:12.994 --> 03:21:13.428
HOW EFFECTIVE ARE THESE
03:21:13.494 --> 03:21:15.396
PROGRAMS WORKING TOGETHER AS A
03:21:15.463 --> 03:21:17.865
WHOLE. ALTOGETHER THESE
03:21:17.932 --> 03:21:19.233
PROGRAMS REPRESENT A MASSIVE
03:21:19.300 --> 03:21:21.469
AGGREGATE AND INVESTMENT IN LOW
03:21:21.536 --> 03:21:23.671
CARBON FUTURE CARP HAS BEEN
03:21:23.738 --> 03:21:25.573
AUDITED BEFORE BUT IT'S
03:21:25.640 --> 03:21:27.408
TRANSPORTATION CLIMATE PROGRAMS
03:21:27.475 --> 03:21:28.309
HAVE NOT BEEN ANALYZED IN
03:21:28.376 --> 03:21:30.077
RECENT YEARS THE LEGISLATIVE
03:21:30.144 --> 03:21:32.013
ANALYST'S OFFICE TRIED TO TAKE
03:21:32.079 --> 03:21:33.514
AN INITIAL SURVEY OF THESE
03:21:33.581 --> 03:21:38.853
PROGRAMS. THE LACK OF
03:21:38.920 --> 03:21:41.022
CONSISTENT POLICY EVALUATION
03:21:41.088 --> 03:21:42.623
POTENTIAL FOR COUNTERPRODUCTIVE
03:21:42.690 --> 03:21:44.992
I MISSION SHUFFLING AND SOME
03:21:45.059 --> 03:21:46.994
AMOUNT OF ON QUANTIFIABLE
03:21:47.061 --> 03:21:49.230
RESOURCES ARE BEING WASTED FOR
03:21:49.297 --> 03:21:51.566
FREE RIGHTS WHAT CAR IS MADE
03:21:51.632 --> 03:21:53.034
DATA AVAILABLE ON PROGRAM
03:21:53.100 --> 03:21:54.869
SPENDING IT IS STILL UNCLEAR
03:21:54.936 --> 03:21:56.838
HOW THEY INTERACT AND WHAT THAT
03:21:56.904 --> 03:21:59.307
MEANS FOR NET CARBON REDUCTIONS
03:21:59.373 --> 03:22:01.476
ARE. AS WE'VE SEEN IN THE
03:22:01.542 --> 03:22:04.078
LECTURE CITY SECTOR SOMETIMES
03:22:04.145 --> 03:22:06.013
PROGRAMS ARE COMBINED. SO
03:22:06.080 --> 03:22:06.848
SOMETIME PROGRAM COMBINED
03:22:06.914 --> 03:22:08.749
EFFECTS LEAD TO A MISSION
03:22:08.816 --> 03:22:10.852
SHUFFLING RATHER THAN NET
03:22:10.918 --> 03:22:13.688
REDUCTIONS IT IS ALSO UNCLEAR
03:22:13.754 --> 03:22:15.590
IF WE ARE UNDER UNDER UNDER
03:22:15.656 --> 03:22:17.425
FUNDING PROGRAMS. WITH
03:22:17.492 --> 03:22:19.927
EFFICIENT ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL
03:22:19.994 --> 03:22:22.230
COST OR OVER FUNDING
03:22:22.296 --> 03:22:23.865
INEFFICIENT PROGRAMS TAKE THE
03:22:23.931 --> 03:22:25.266
PORT OF LOS ANGELES FOR EXAMPLE
03:22:25.333 --> 03:22:27.034
WHICH IS IN MY DISTRICT PORCH
03:22:27.101 --> 03:22:30.271
LEAD TO STAY ON DEVELOPING SHIP
03:22:30.338 --> 03:22:32.473
TO SHORE POWER. HOWEVER CARPOOL.
03:22:32.540 --> 03:22:35.476
AT BIRTH. PROPOSED RULE ARE
03:22:35.543 --> 03:22:37.378
SIGNIFICAN MORE THE EMPIRE
03:22:37.445 --> 03:22:39.313
REQUIREMENTS IT'S UNCLEAR WHAT
03:22:39.380 --> 03:22:41.115
IF ANYTHING CARP IS DOING WITH
03:22:41.182 --> 03:22:43.417
THESE POLICIES TO ENSURE OUR
03:22:43.484 --> 03:22:44.619
PORTS STAY COMPETITIVE TO
03:22:44.685 --> 03:22:46.287
PRIVATIZE COST EFFECTIVENESS
03:22:46.354 --> 03:22:48.389
REQUIREMENTS AND TO CONTINUE TO
03:22:48.456 --> 03:22:50.491
DEVELOP A ROBUST LABOR FORCE
03:22:50.558 --> 03:22:51.826
AGAIN MEMBERS WE WILL NOT BE
03:22:51.893 --> 03:22:53.928
THE FIFTH LEADING ECONOMY IF
03:22:53.995 --> 03:22:56.030
OUR PORCH SHUT DOWN. WHAT OUT
03:22:56.097 --> 03:22:58.299
AUDIT WE WILL NOT KNOW IF CARBS
03:22:58.366 --> 03:23:00.468
PROGRAMS ARE PRIORITIZE A LEASE
03:23:00.535 --> 03:23:02.403
COSTS BEST FITS WHAT OUT OF
03:23:02.470 --> 03:23:04.805
AUDIT WE WILL NOT KNOW WHETHER
03:23:04.872 --> 03:23:05.973
THESE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM TO
03:23:06.040 --> 03:23:07.608
HELP IN THE STATE DEVELOP AN
03:23:07.675 --> 03:23:10.011
EQUITABLE AND DIVERSE WORKFORCE
03:23:10.077 --> 03:23:12.146
FOR EXAMPLE IF SIT SIGNIFICANT
03:23:12.213 --> 03:23:14.015
AMOUNTS OF INSTEAD OF DOLLARS
03:23:14.081 --> 03:23:14.849
ARE GOING TO WEALTHY FREE
03:23:14.916 --> 03:23:17.018
RIGHTS THEN THE POLICY NEEDS TO
03:23:17.084 --> 03:23:19.921
BE CHANGED WE REFORM. THEIR UP
03:23:19.987 --> 03:23:22.023
THE C. B. R. P. PROGRAM TO
03:23:22.089 --> 03:23:23.357
FOCUS ON MIDDLE AND WORKING
03:23:23.424 --> 03:23:25.126
CLASS FAMILIES BUT HOW MANY OF
03:23:25.192 --> 03:23:26.360
THE OTHER PROGRAMS HAVE THE
03:23:26.427 --> 03:23:29.564
SAME STRUCTURAL INADEQUACIES
03:23:29.630 --> 03:23:31.499
ALL THIS AUDIT WOULD ALSO A
03:23:31.566 --> 03:23:33.334
SENSE THAT THE LEGISLATURE HAS
03:23:33.401 --> 03:23:34.602
GIVEN CAR A LOT OF
03:23:34.669 --> 03:23:36.470
RESPONSIBILITIES AND I SUPPORT
03:23:36.537 --> 03:23:39.240
CARDS EFFORTS JUST LIKE I
03:23:39.307 --> 03:23:42.810
SUPPORT CLIMATE INVESTMENTS. IF
03:23:42.877 --> 03:23:44.412
FOR THESE READ ALONE. THAT I
03:23:44.478 --> 03:23:45.746
CARE ABOUT THE CONTINUED
03:23:45.813 --> 03:23:47.548
EXISTENCE AND I WANT THEM TO BE
03:23:47.615 --> 03:23:49.083
FAIR AND EFFECTIVE BASED ON
03:23:49.150 --> 03:23:50.918
ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COSTS AND
03:23:50.985 --> 03:23:51.786
THAT'S WHY I RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:23:51.852 --> 03:23:54.355
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE TODAY. THANK
03:23:54.422 --> 03:23:55.690
YOU SENATOR- MADAM HONOR
03:23:55.756 --> 03:23:57.658
PLEASE. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
03:23:57.725 --> 03:23:59.393
AS AS A SENATOR BRADFORD
03:23:59.460 --> 03:24:00.528
INDICATED THAT IT WOULD BE AN
03:24:00.595 --> 03:24:02.263
AUDIT OF THE CAR PROGRAM AND T
03:24:02.330 --> 03:24:03.531
WOULD BE SPECIFIC TO THE
03:24:03.598 --> 03:24:04.999
TRANSPORTATION SECTOR. SO
03:24:05.066 --> 03:24:06.233
STARTING OUT IDENTIFYING THE
03:24:06.300 --> 03:24:07.735
NUMBER AND TYPE OF PROGRAMS AS
03:24:07.802 --> 03:24:08.936
HE INDICATED THERE'S
03:24:09.003 --> 03:24:10.137
APPROXIMATELY THIRTY FOUR
03:24:10.204 --> 03:24:11.305
PROGRAMS BUT WE NEED TO
03:24:11.372 --> 03:24:13.507
UNDERSTAND THIS THE TYPE. OF
03:24:13.574 --> 03:24:14.542
PROGRAM AND WHAT WHAT THE
03:24:14.609 --> 03:24:15.476
INTENT OF THAT PARTICULAR
03:24:15.543 --> 03:24:17.011
PROGRAM IS AND THAT TIES TO THE
03:24:17.078 --> 03:24:18.779
NEXT OBJECTIVE WHICH WOULD BE.
03:24:18.846 --> 03:24:20.314
LOOKING AT THE EXTENT TO WHICH
03:24:20.381 --> 03:24:22.016
ANY OF THESE PROGRAMS OVERLAP
03:24:22.083 --> 03:24:23.584
ONE ANOTHER AND HOW THEY-
03:24:23.651 --> 03:24:25.353
INTERACT WITH ONE ANOTHER. AND
03:24:25.419 --> 03:24:26.654
THEN HE'S ASKING US TO LOOK AT
03:24:26.721 --> 03:24:29.323
A SELECTION OF THESE PROGRAMS
03:24:29.390 --> 03:24:30.691
OF THESE GHG ARM GREENHOUSE GAS
03:24:30.758 --> 03:24:32.226
EMISSION REDUCTION PROGRAMS.
03:24:32.293 --> 03:24:33.861
AGAIN SPECIFICALLY IN THE
03:24:33.928 --> 03:24:35.296
TRANSPORTATION SECTOR- AND
03:24:35.363 --> 03:24:36.697
DETERMINE WHETHER FIRST OF ALL
03:24:36.764 --> 03:24:37.732
WHETHER CARB DOES ANY
03:24:37.798 --> 03:24:39.634
ASSESSMENT OR EVALUATION OF THE
03:24:39.700 --> 03:24:41.202
EFFECTS OF THE PROGRAMS ON
03:24:41.268 --> 03:24:43.237
COMMUNITIES. AND HOUSEHOLDS OUT
03:24:43.304 --> 03:24:44.872
WHAT AFTER THAT AFTER THEY
03:24:44.939 --> 03:24:47.408
IMPLEMENT THE PROGRAMS. AND IF
03:24:47.475 --> 03:24:48.709
THAT'S NOT HAPPENING WHICH IT
03:24:48.776 --> 03:24:50.478
APPEARS THAT IT ISN'T FOR ALL
03:24:50.544 --> 03:24:53.214
PROGRAMS- HE'S ASKING US TO THE
03:24:53.280 --> 03:24:55.082
EXTENT POSSIBLE. ASSESS HOW
03:24:55.149 --> 03:24:56.584
EACH OF THESE PROGRAMS AFFECT
03:24:56.651 --> 03:24:57.752
HOUSEHOLDS IN COMMUNITIES WE
03:24:57.818 --> 03:24:59.587
MAY NEED TO HIRE A CONSULTANT
03:24:59.654 --> 03:25:00.688
TO ASSIST US WITH THAT BUT
03:25:00.755 --> 03:25:02.189
WE'VE DONE THAT IN THE PAST. IN
03:25:02.256 --> 03:25:04.125
ADDITION- SOME OF THE
03:25:04.191 --> 03:25:06.994
ADDITIONAL OBJECTIVES RELATED
03:25:07.061 --> 03:25:07.561
TO THE SELECTION OF PROGRAMS
03:25:07.628 --> 03:25:10.297
WOULD BE. AS CENTER BRADFORD
03:25:10.364 --> 03:25:11.932
REFER TO IT AS SHUFFLING IS IT
03:25:11.999 --> 03:25:13.200
REALLY A REDUCTION OR IS IT A
03:25:13.267 --> 03:25:15.803
SHIFTING OF. THE MISSIONS
03:25:15.870 --> 03:25:17.171
RATHER THAN AN ELIMINATION OF
03:25:17.238 --> 03:25:18.773
THOSE PARTICULAR MISSION THAT'S
03:25:18.839 --> 03:25:19.640
MOVING THE EMISSIONS ARE
03:25:19.707 --> 03:25:21.242
SHUFFLING AS A SENATOR REFERRED
03:25:21.308 --> 03:25:22.410
TO IT. ALSO LOOKING AT THE
03:25:22.476 --> 03:25:23.611
PROGRAMS IN THEIR COST
03:25:23.678 --> 03:25:26.447
EFFECTIVENESS- INCLUDING SOCIAL
03:25:26.514 --> 03:25:28.416
BENEFITS AND COSTS AND COMPARE
03:25:28.482 --> 03:25:30.051
THE PROGRAMS OUT TO ONE
03:25:30.117 --> 03:25:32.553
ANOTHER. FROM THAT PERSPECTIVE.
03:25:32.620 --> 03:25:33.788
ALSO LOOKING AT WHETHER OR NOT
03:25:33.854 --> 03:25:35.289
CARP STRATEGIES ARE REDUCING
03:25:35.356 --> 03:25:36.524
THE OCCURRENCE OF A PARTICULAR
03:25:36.590 --> 03:25:37.692
ISSUE HOW WELL ARE THESE
03:25:37.758 --> 03:25:38.959
PROGRAMS WORKING. AND
03:25:39.026 --> 03:25:41.128
ENCOURAGING PARTICIPANTS TO
03:25:41.195 --> 03:25:43.197
REDUCE. GREENHOUSE GAS.
03:25:43.264 --> 03:25:45.232
EMISSIONS ARE. REDUCED AND
03:25:45.299 --> 03:25:46.701
THEIR ACTIVITIES ARE
03:25:46.767 --> 03:25:47.601
PARTICULARLY WITH RESPECT TO
03:25:47.668 --> 03:25:50.037
VEHICLES- ALSO A COUPLE OF
03:25:50.104 --> 03:25:51.138
OTHER OBJECTIVES HE'S ASKED US
03:25:51.205 --> 03:25:52.506
TO LOOK AT IS ASSESSING THE
03:25:52.573 --> 03:25:54.408
PROCESS CAR MUSES WHEN THEY-
03:25:54.475 --> 03:25:55.509
WHEN THEY DRAFT THEIR INITIAL
03:25:55.576 --> 03:25:57.044
STATEMENT OF REASONS WHEN
03:25:57.111 --> 03:25:57.778
THEY'RE PROPOSING A NEW
03:25:57.845 --> 03:25:59.880
PROGRAM. FOR THE SPECIFICALLY
03:25:59.947 --> 03:26:01.215
AGAIN FOR THE TRANSPORTATION
03:26:01.282 --> 03:26:02.683
SECTOR AND HE'S ASKED US A FEW
03:26:02.750 --> 03:26:04.351
THINGS RELATED TO THAT. HOW
03:26:04.418 --> 03:26:06.053
DOES CARB CONSIDER THE EFFECTS
03:26:06.120 --> 03:26:07.421
OF THE PROGRAM ON AIR QUALITY
03:26:07.488 --> 03:26:08.823
THE ENVIRONMENT THE
03:26:08.889 --> 03:26:09.924
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS THE
03:26:09.990 --> 03:26:11.525
OVERALL ECONOMY AND CERTAINLY
03:26:11.592 --> 03:26:13.060
HOW WITH THIS PARTICULAR
03:26:13.127 --> 03:26:14.628
PROGRAM AFFECT LOW INCOME AND
03:26:14.695 --> 03:26:16.430
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES-
03:26:16.497 --> 03:26:18.532
AGAIN. WITH RESPECT TO THE
03:26:18.599 --> 03:26:19.667
INITIAL STATEMENT OF REASONS
03:26:19.734 --> 03:26:22.069
FOR A NEW PROGRAM. HOW IS CARP
03:26:22.136 --> 03:26:22.837
CONSIDERING POTENTIAL
03:26:22.903 --> 03:26:24.205
INTERACTIONS AGAIN AND EFFECTS
03:26:24.271 --> 03:26:25.840
WITH THE ALREADY EXISTING
03:26:25.906 --> 03:26:27.208
PROGRAMS ARE THEY TAKING THAT
03:26:27.274 --> 03:26:29.009
INTO CONSIDERATION. AND THEN
03:26:29.076 --> 03:26:31.378
FINALLY- ASKING FOR SUGGESTED
03:26:31.445 --> 03:26:33.247
CHANGES- WHETHER THERE NEED TO
03:26:33.314 --> 03:26:34.682
BE ANY CHANGES TO ANY OF THESE
03:26:34.749 --> 03:26:36.250
PROGRAMS- AND WHETHER THOSE
03:26:36.317 --> 03:26:38.085
CHANGES CAN BE. CHANGED THROUGH
03:26:38.152 --> 03:26:40.020
LEGISLATIVE ACTION OR THROUGH
03:26:40.087 --> 03:26:41.789
REGULATION BY CARB THEMSELVES
03:26:41.856 --> 03:26:44.024
OF THE AUDIT IS ABOUT TWENTY
03:26:44.091 --> 03:26:44.759
SEVEN HUNDRED HOURS AS I
03:26:44.825 --> 03:26:46.694
INDICATED- BECAUSE OF STE THE
03:26:46.761 --> 03:26:47.928
TECHNICAL NATURE OF SOME OF
03:26:47.995 --> 03:26:49.430
THIS WILL MAKE A DETERMINATION
03:26:49.497 --> 03:26:50.998
IF THE AUDITS APPROVED. WE NEED
03:26:51.065 --> 03:26:52.333
TO HIRE A CONSULTANT TO ASSIST
03:26:52.399 --> 03:26:53.768
US WE CERTAINLY HAVE THE
03:26:53.834 --> 03:26:55.669
RESOURCES TO DO THAT- AND THE
03:26:55.736 --> 03:26:57.071
ABILITY TO DEATH WITH THAT
03:26:57.138 --> 03:26:58.773
MISTER CHAIR ALTERNATE BACK TO
03:26:58.839 --> 03:27:01.442
YOU. THANK YOU THANK YOU. ARE
03:27:01.509 --> 03:27:02.543
THE SAME GOING TO MOVE TO THE
03:27:02.610 --> 03:27:27.802
AFFECTED AGENCIES. PLEASE.
03:27:30.704 --> 03:27:31.038
ARE
03:27:31.105 --> 03:27:33.407
A TIME THANK YOU CHAIR AND
03:27:33.474 --> 03:27:34.275
COMMITTEE MY NAME'S RICHARD
03:27:34.341 --> 03:27:36.243
CORY I'M THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER
03:27:36.310 --> 03:27:37.511
THE CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES
03:27:37.578 --> 03:27:39.947
BOARD I'M JOINED HERE WITH OUR
03:27:40.014 --> 03:27:42.683
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR DR DAVID
03:27:42.750 --> 03:27:44.552
GARCIA. I APPRECIATE THE
03:27:44.618 --> 03:27:45.452
OPPORTUNITY TO TALK WITH YOU
03:27:45.519 --> 03:27:48.055
ABOUT CALIFORNIA'S APPROACH TO
03:27:48.122 --> 03:27:48.556
REDUCING GREENHOUSE GAS
03:27:48.622 --> 03:27:50.891
EMISSIONS AND IT'S IMPORTANT.
03:27:50.958 --> 03:27:52.193
AIR POLLUTION FROM THE
03:27:52.259 --> 03:27:53.961
TRANSPORTATION SECTOR. THE
03:27:54.028 --> 03:27:55.529
CHIEF STATE AND FEDERAL
03:27:55.596 --> 03:27:57.531
REQUIREMENTS INCLUDING HEALTH
03:27:57.598 --> 03:27:58.666
BASED AIR QUALITY STANDARDS
03:27:58.732 --> 03:28:00.568
CALIFORNIA USES A MIX OF
03:28:00.634 --> 03:28:03.437
MANDATES INCENTIVES AND MARKET
03:28:03.504 --> 03:28:05.372
MECHANISMS MEANING MANY OF
03:28:05.439 --> 03:28:08.242
CARBS PROGRAMS ACHIEVE A TRIPLE
03:28:08.309 --> 03:28:09.977
BANG FOR THE BUCK BY ONE.
03:28:10.044 --> 03:28:11.278
REDUCING EMISSIONS OF TOXIC
03:28:11.345 --> 03:28:12.813
SUBSTANCES AND TRADITIONAL AIR
03:28:12.880 --> 03:28:14.882
POLLUTANTS THAT DIRECTLY IMPACT
03:28:14.949 --> 03:28:16.884
PUBLIC HEALTH TO REDUCING
03:28:16.951 --> 03:28:19.386
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS THAT
03:28:19.453 --> 03:28:19.920
AFFECT CLIMATE CHANGE AND
03:28:19.987 --> 03:28:22.489
THREE. CHEATING COST EFFECTIVE
03:28:22.556 --> 03:28:24.325
AND EQUITABLE OUTCOMES NOW AS
03:28:24.391 --> 03:28:25.860
FOR HOW CARBS MISSION RELATES
03:28:25.926 --> 03:28:28.462
TO THIS AUDIT. AB THREE NINETY
03:28:28.529 --> 03:28:30.364
EIGHT BY ASSEMBLYMAN. GARCIA
03:28:30.431 --> 03:28:32.766
AND TWENTY SEVENTEEN EXTENDED
03:28:32.833 --> 03:28:33.300
THE CAP AND TRADE PROGRAM
03:28:33.367 --> 03:28:35.569
ADDITIONALLY. AB THREE NINETY
03:28:35.636 --> 03:28:36.871
EIGHT REQUIRED THE LA- TO
03:28:36.937 --> 03:28:39.673
REPORT ON THE ECONOMIC IMPACTS
03:28:39.740 --> 03:28:41.709
AND BENEFITS OF CALIFORNIA'S.
03:28:41.775 --> 03:28:44.311
GHG EMISSIONS GOALS THE TWENTY
03:28:44.378 --> 03:28:45.913
EIGHTEEN LA- REPORT SPUR THE
03:28:45.980 --> 03:28:47.314
AUDIT REQUEST FOR THIS
03:28:47.381 --> 03:28:49.116
COMMITTEE BUT UNFORTUNATELY.
03:28:49.183 --> 03:28:50.618
CAR WAS NOT AFFORDED THE
03:28:50.684 --> 03:28:52.686
OPPORTUNITY RESPOND. NOR WERE
03:28:52.753 --> 03:28:55.723
EVEN AWARE OF THE QUESTIONS
03:28:55.789 --> 03:28:57.157
THAT HAVE BEEN POSED UNTIL. I
03:28:57.224 --> 03:28:59.393
RECEIVED THE REQUEST TO APPEAR
03:28:59.460 --> 03:28:59.927
BEFORE THIS COMMITTEE LAST
03:28:59.994 --> 03:29:02.763
WEDNESDAY. WHAT THE COMMITTEE
03:29:02.830 --> 03:29:04.265
MAY FIND HELPFUL TO KNOW IS
03:29:04.331 --> 03:29:05.566
THAT THE LA AUDIT REPORT IS
03:29:05.633 --> 03:29:07.601
CONSTRAINED BY STATUTE TO FOCUS
03:29:07.668 --> 03:29:10.504
NARROWLY ON GHG REDUCTIONS
03:29:10.571 --> 03:29:12.373
GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTIONS IT
03:29:12.439 --> 03:29:14.041
DOES NOT CONSIDER THE OTHER
03:29:14.108 --> 03:29:16.010
STATE AND FEDERAL MANDATES ON
03:29:16.076 --> 03:29:18.145
CARBS PROGRAMS. THE CONSTRAINT
03:29:18.212 --> 03:29:19.713
ELIMINATES THE ABILITY OF THE
03:29:19.780 --> 03:29:20.981
REPORT TO ADDRESS THE OTHER KEY
03:29:21.048 --> 03:29:22.516
DRIVERS TO CALIFORNIA'S
03:29:22.583 --> 03:29:23.784
TRANSPORTATION STRATEGIES
03:29:23.851 --> 03:29:25.686
NAMELY. THE NEED TO REDUCE
03:29:25.753 --> 03:29:27.354
EMISSIONS THAT NEGATIVELY
03:29:27.421 --> 03:29:27.888
IMPACT THE HEALTH OF ALL
03:29:27.955 --> 03:29:30.157
CALIFORNIANS PARTICULARLY THOSE
03:29:30.224 --> 03:29:31.125
AND DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES
03:29:31.191 --> 03:29:33.894
AND COMMUNITIES OF COLOR.
03:29:33.961 --> 03:29:34.528
SPECIFICALLY THE REPORT FOCUSES
03:29:34.595 --> 03:29:35.863
ON GHG EMISSIONS RATHER THAN A
03:29:35.930 --> 03:29:37.731
KEY DRIVER BEHIND THE MOBILE
03:29:37.798 --> 03:29:40.067
SOURCE MEASURES WHICH REDUCE
03:29:40.134 --> 03:29:41.902
DIESEL PARTICULATE MATTER. AS
03:29:41.969 --> 03:29:44.872
WELL SMOG FORMING POLLUTANTS
03:29:44.939 --> 03:29:45.372
ARE PREPARED TO RESPOND
03:29:45.439 --> 03:29:47.241
QUESTIONS YOU HAVE. BUT MY MAIN
03:29:47.308 --> 03:29:48.375
RESPONSE IS WHEN A
03:29:48.442 --> 03:29:50.244
DISAPPOINTMENT OVER THE FACT IT
03:29:50.311 --> 03:29:51.512
WOULD NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
03:29:51.578 --> 03:29:53.614
TO DISCUSS AND RESPOND TO THE
03:29:53.681 --> 03:29:55.983
REQUEST. PRIOR TO APPEARING
03:29:56.050 --> 03:29:58.118
BEFORE YOU TODAY IN SUMMARY. I
03:29:58.185 --> 03:29:59.019
REQUEST OF THE COMMITTEE
03:29:59.086 --> 03:30:01.121
CONSIDER DIRECTING CARB TO WORK
03:30:01.188 --> 03:30:02.890
WITH SENATOR BRADFORD TO
03:30:02.957 --> 03:30:05.059
RESPOND AS QUESTIONS. SURE
03:30:05.125 --> 03:30:06.160
ANSWERED BE INSUFFICIENT
03:30:06.226 --> 03:30:07.161
COMMITTEE COULD CONSIDER
03:30:07.227 --> 03:30:09.530
APPROVING A REVISED AND BETTER
03:30:09.596 --> 03:30:11.565
INFORMED I REQUEST. AT THAT
03:30:11.632 --> 03:30:14.301
TIME THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR.
03:30:14.368 --> 03:30:17.871
RIGHT ADDITIONAL I THINK YOU'RE
03:30:17.938 --> 03:30:19.173
THE ONLY AFFECTED AGENCY THANK
03:30:19.239 --> 03:30:20.574
YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY AT THE
03:30:20.641 --> 03:30:22.042
TIME WAS GOING TO TURN IT TO
03:30:22.109 --> 03:30:23.811
MEMBERS ON THE DíAS FOR
03:30:23.877 --> 03:30:24.712
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ASSEMBLY
03:30:24.778 --> 03:30:25.980
MEMBER WOULD THEN CENTER
03:30:26.046 --> 03:30:28.248
BORDERS THANK YOU PLEASE VOTE
03:30:28.315 --> 03:30:29.483
THANK YOU- SENATOR BRADFORD FOR
03:30:29.550 --> 03:30:32.987
BRINGING THIS FORWARD- I THINK
03:30:33.053 --> 03:30:34.555
THAT THE FACT THAT THERE WAS A
03:30:34.621 --> 03:30:36.657
POTENTIAL AUDIT REQUEST- LAST
03:30:36.724 --> 03:30:37.524
YEAR SHOULD HAVE GIVEN YOU
03:30:37.591 --> 03:30:38.993
PLENTY OF WARNING THAT WE
03:30:39.059 --> 03:30:40.260
WANTED ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
03:30:40.327 --> 03:30:41.395
ALTHOUGH THAT ARE DID MOVE
03:30:41.462 --> 03:30:42.629
FORWARD SO THIS SHOULDN'T
03:30:42.696 --> 03:30:43.931
REALLY BE A SURPRISE TO YOUR
03:30:43.998 --> 03:30:47.701
AGENCY QUITE FRANKLY- AND- I
03:30:47.768 --> 03:30:50.170
THINK THE QUESTIONS ARE VALID-
03:30:50.237 --> 03:30:51.705
YOU TALK ABOUT DISADVANTAGED
03:30:51.772 --> 03:30:52.873
COMMUNITIES I'M GONNA GET A
03:30:52.940 --> 03:30:53.607
LITTLE LITTLE BIT ON THE SUB
03:30:53.674 --> 03:30:56.443
SOAP BOX HERE BUT- I REPRESENT
03:30:56.510 --> 03:30:57.711
SOME OF SOME POOR COMMUNITIES
03:30:57.778 --> 03:30:59.546
IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. WE
03:30:59.613 --> 03:31:01.148
DON'T QUALIFY UNDER YOUR AND
03:31:01.215 --> 03:31:02.816
YOUR DEFINITION OF ENVIRO OF
03:31:02.883 --> 03:31:03.951
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES
03:31:04.018 --> 03:31:06.353
BECAUSE IN GENERAL MOST OF THE
03:31:06.420 --> 03:31:07.821
YEAR UNLESS WE HAVE A WILD FIRE
03:31:07.888 --> 03:31:08.922
WHICH YOU GUYS DON'T WANT TO
03:31:08.989 --> 03:31:11.992
MEASURE THAT BY THE WAY- WE
03:31:12.059 --> 03:31:14.728
DON'T WE HAVE CLEAN AIR WE ALSO
03:31:14.795 --> 03:31:16.597
HAVE CLEAN WATER BECAUSE WE
03:31:16.663 --> 03:31:17.231
SUPPLY WATER TO A HUGE PART OF
03:31:17.297 --> 03:31:18.866
THE STATE. WE HAVE A LOT OF
03:31:18.932 --> 03:31:19.967
TREES AND THEY HAD TEND TO BE
03:31:20.034 --> 03:31:21.902
CARBON SINKS WE HAVE A LOT OF
03:31:21.969 --> 03:31:23.971
PEOPLE AND MARK COMMUNITY THAT
03:31:24.038 --> 03:31:26.440
ARE- THAT HAVE SMALL BUSINESSES
03:31:26.507 --> 03:31:28.342
THAT HAVE RETROFIT REQUIREMENTS
03:31:28.409 --> 03:31:31.345
FOR TRACTORS FOR TRUCKS AND SO
03:31:31.412 --> 03:31:32.679
ONE AND THEY DON'T QUALIFY FOR
03:31:32.746 --> 03:31:34.348
A LOT OF PROGRAMS AND OTHER
03:31:34.415 --> 03:31:35.315
PEOPLE IN OTHER STATES THAT
03:31:35.382 --> 03:31:36.850
PART THE STATE DO AND WE'RE
03:31:36.917 --> 03:31:39.887
LOOKING AT G. H. G. PRODUCTION
03:31:39.953 --> 03:31:42.322
AS A STATEWIDE ISSUE WHY ARE
03:31:42.389 --> 03:31:44.992
YOU GUYS DISADVANTAGED PUTTING
03:31:45.059 --> 03:31:46.326
OUR COMMUNITIES AT A
03:31:46.393 --> 03:31:48.328
DISADVANTAGE BECAUSE G. H. G.
03:31:48.395 --> 03:31:50.597
IS A G. H. G WORDS GENERATED
03:31:50.664 --> 03:31:52.499
IN. THROUGHOUT AND I THINK
03:31:52.566 --> 03:31:53.801
THAT'S I THINK THAT'S A
03:31:53.867 --> 03:31:56.170
DISSERVICE TO- TO A LOT OF US
03:31:56.236 --> 03:31:58.172
IN IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA I'M
03:31:58.238 --> 03:31:59.473
NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO FEELS THIS
03:31:59.540 --> 03:32:01.208
WAY THE WHOLE COALITION OF
03:32:01.275 --> 03:32:03.477
FOLKS WITH THE BAY AREA- CAUCUS
03:32:03.544 --> 03:32:05.746
THAT FEEL THE SAME WAY AND I
03:32:05.813 --> 03:32:07.147
GET THAT WE WANT TO FOCUS ON
03:32:07.214 --> 03:32:09.216
THE COMMUNITIES THAT MAYBE NEED
03:32:09.283 --> 03:32:11.485
SOME OF THIS THE MOST BUT- I
03:32:11.552 --> 03:32:14.321
WOULD SAY THERE'S AN IN EQUITY
03:32:14.388 --> 03:32:17.758
FOR RURAL COMMUNITIES AND WE
03:32:17.825 --> 03:32:18.859
GIVE AN EXAMPLE EVERYBODY FOR
03:32:18.926 --> 03:32:19.460
X. THAT RURAL COMMUNITY. IT'S
03:32:19.526 --> 03:32:21.228
THE TO LIVE IS LOW THEIR- IT'S
03:32:21.295 --> 03:32:23.097
NOT. THE WE HAVE TO TRY. BY
03:32:23.163 --> 03:32:25.699
TRUCK. EVERYTHING INTO MY
03:32:25.766 --> 03:32:28.068
DISTRICT BECAUSE WE DON'T WE
03:32:28.135 --> 03:32:29.670
DON'T HAVE A REAL PORT THAT
03:32:29.736 --> 03:32:31.305
THAT BRINGS GOODSAND SERVICES
03:32:31.371 --> 03:32:33.574
AND SO WE ARE INFLUENCED BY THE
03:32:33.640 --> 03:32:36.610
TRANSPORTATION SECTOR SIX IT
03:32:36.677 --> 03:32:37.778
MAY NOT BE SO THAT THE AIR IS
03:32:37.845 --> 03:32:40.013
BROWN VISIBLY BROWN BUT WE ARE
03:32:40.080 --> 03:32:43.150
INFLUENCED BY THAT. AND SO. YOU
03:32:43.217 --> 03:32:44.985
THERE IS A FRUSTRATION AND IN
03:32:45.052 --> 03:32:46.286
EQUITY PART OF THIS THAT
03:32:46.353 --> 03:32:49.256
DOESN'T FEEL RIGHT. AND IN IF
03:32:49.323 --> 03:32:51.458
YOUR DEPARTMENT AS WE'VE HEARD
03:32:51.525 --> 03:32:53.794
FROM OTHERS IS OTHER PEOPLE
03:32:53.861 --> 03:32:55.095
HERE IF. IF YOU'RE DOING
03:32:55.162 --> 03:32:56.396
EVERYTHING GREAT YOU SHOULD
03:32:56.463 --> 03:32:57.931
WELCOME THIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY
03:32:57.998 --> 03:32:59.433
TO SHOWCASE HOW GOOD WHAT A
03:32:59.500 --> 03:33:01.535
GOOD JOB YOU'RE DOING. AND YOU
03:33:01.602 --> 03:33:03.036
SHOULD HAVE BEEN ON NOTICE
03:33:03.103 --> 03:33:04.404
THERE BEEN MULTIPLE ATTEMPTS TO
03:33:04.471 --> 03:33:05.506
TRY TO GET INFORMATION ABOUT
03:33:05.572 --> 03:33:07.641
THIS AND YOU SHOULD OF BEEN ON
03:33:07.708 --> 03:33:08.909
NOTICE THAT THIS MIGHT BE
03:33:08.976 --> 03:33:09.877
COMING AT SOME POINT. BUT IT'S
03:33:09.943 --> 03:33:11.278
HERE AND I PLAN TO SUPPORT
03:33:11.345 --> 03:33:14.114
THIS- FOR THIS AND AMERICA BY
03:33:14.181 --> 03:33:18.385
THE REASONS. THANK YOU. HELLO
03:33:18.452 --> 03:33:20.387
MISTER WOULD YOU EXPECT A
03:33:20.454 --> 03:33:21.321
RESPONSE IF NOT WE'LL MOVE ON
03:33:21.388 --> 03:33:26.126
TO. PLEASE DON'T HI ACTION I
03:33:26.193 --> 03:33:27.928
JUMPING BIKE A APPS. LIKED
03:33:27.995 --> 03:33:30.964
RESPOND TO FEW FEW POINTS. ONE
03:33:31.031 --> 03:33:32.699
YOUR POINT OF DISOBEY
03:33:32.766 --> 03:33:34.201
COMMUNITIES. AND YOU'RE REALLY
03:33:34.268 --> 03:33:36.470
TALKING ABOUT I BELIEVE G. G.
03:33:36.537 --> 03:33:38.438
R. F. CAP AND TRADE FOR
03:33:38.505 --> 03:33:40.407
EXPENDITURES WHICH ARE
03:33:40.474 --> 03:33:41.942
APPROPRIATE BY THE LEGISLATURE.
03:33:42.009 --> 03:33:42.910
BUT THEY ARE APPROPRIATE
03:33:42.976 --> 03:33:45.078
ACCORDING TO STATE LAW STATE
03:33:45.145 --> 03:33:47.915
LAW A. B. FIFTEEN FIFTY DEFINES
03:33:47.981 --> 03:33:48.782
EXPENDITURES AND THE
03:33:48.849 --> 03:33:50.717
PERCENTAGES THE NEED TO BE
03:33:50.784 --> 03:33:51.518
EXPANDED DISADVANTAGED
03:33:51.585 --> 03:33:53.253
COMMUNITIES NOW IT'S NOT ALL
03:33:53.320 --> 03:33:54.621
THE DOLLARS ARE SIGNIFICANT. A
03:33:54.688 --> 03:33:56.957
TRANSPORTATION FUNDING AND MANY
03:33:57.024 --> 03:33:57.758
OTHER PROGRAMS THE LEGISLATURE
03:33:57.824 --> 03:33:59.459
APPROPRIATES THOSE DOLLARS TWO
03:33:59.526 --> 03:34:01.328
DOZEN PLUS AGENCIES. THEY'RE
03:34:01.395 --> 03:34:03.163
GOING UP AND DOWN THE STATE IF
03:34:03.230 --> 03:34:04.565
THE POINT IS THERE'S NOT ENOUGH
03:34:04.631 --> 03:34:06.833
MONEY ABSOLUTELY THE POINT IS
03:34:06.900 --> 03:34:08.535
THOSE DOLLARS ARE MISSING
03:34:08.602 --> 03:34:09.937
CERTAIN COMMUNITIES ARE NEVER
03:34:10.003 --> 03:34:11.471
ENOUGH BUT THEY'RE CERTAINLY
03:34:11.538 --> 03:34:13.207
MULTIPLE EXAMPLES. OF A
03:34:13.273 --> 03:34:15.809
COMPETITIVE PROCESS ACROSS THE
03:34:15.876 --> 03:34:16.910
STATE IN TERMS OF HOW THOSE
03:34:16.977 --> 03:34:19.947
EXPENDITURES ARE DETERMINED AND
03:34:20.013 --> 03:34:21.215
I'D I'D SUBMIT AN THIS IS
03:34:21.281 --> 03:34:24.151
IMPORTANT. WHEN IT COMES TO THE
03:34:24.218 --> 03:34:25.619
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION WITH
03:34:25.686 --> 03:34:27.287
FULLY FOLLOW IT WE FULLY FALL
03:34:27.354 --> 03:34:28.589
LEGISLATION THAT CONCERNS
03:34:28.655 --> 03:34:30.324
EXPENDITURESEXPENDITURE THOSE
03:34:30.390 --> 03:34:32.125
DOLLARS THEN GO THROUGH A FULL
03:34:32.192 --> 03:34:33.527
PUBLIC PROCESS YOU CAN TAKE A
03:34:33.594 --> 03:34:35.295
YEAR IN TERMS OF THE
03:34:35.362 --> 03:34:37.364
SOLICITATIONS THE GUIDANCE IN
03:34:37.431 --> 03:34:38.832
THE ULTIMATE WHERE THOSE
03:34:38.899 --> 03:34:40.567
DOLLARS. IN THOSE ALSO TAKE
03:34:40.634 --> 03:34:42.169
INTO ACCOUNT THE POINT YOU MADE
03:34:42.236 --> 03:34:43.403
ABOUT THIS IS MUCH MORE THAN
03:34:43.470 --> 03:34:45.872
GHGS IT'S DIESEL PM IN FACT THE
03:34:45.939 --> 03:34:47.207
MENTIONED AT THE CENTER
03:34:47.274 --> 03:34:50.944
BRADFORD MADE OF FIVE AT BIRTH.
03:34:51.011 --> 03:34:52.446
BY THE PORTS THAT'S ABOUT
03:34:52.512 --> 03:34:55.182
DIESEL THAT'S LOCAL EXPOSURE TO
03:34:55.249 --> 03:34:56.917
DIESEL PM THE ADVERSELY IMPACTS
03:34:56.984 --> 03:34:58.585
PUBLIC HEALTH RELEASE ANY OF
03:34:58.652 --> 03:35:04.625
THE GHG ISSUE. SO PROCESS WISE.
03:35:04.691 --> 03:35:06.193
I ALWAYS OPEN TO HIM AND MAKE
03:35:06.260 --> 03:35:08.195
SURE THEM CLEAR AND HER OF LAW
03:35:08.262 --> 03:35:09.463
WE FOR. THE PROCESS WE GO
03:35:09.529 --> 03:35:11.198
THROUGH. IN THE FULL DISCLOSURE
03:35:11.265 --> 03:35:12.666
ALL WHAT WE JUST TALKED ABOUT
03:35:12.733 --> 03:35:14.401
IN TERMS OF EXPENDITURES.
03:35:14.468 --> 03:35:16.603
DOCUMENTED EVERY YEAR EVERY
03:35:16.670 --> 03:35:17.671
YEAR TO REPORT TO THE
03:35:17.738 --> 03:35:19.339
LEGISLATURE FOR ALL THOSE
03:35:19.406 --> 03:35:21.375
EXPENDITURES THOSE APPROPRIATED
03:35:21.441 --> 03:35:23.744
G.G. G. R. F. DOLLARS. REALLY
03:35:23.810 --> 03:35:26.213
IMPORTANT IN MY CONCERN ON THE
03:35:26.280 --> 03:35:27.714
SLEEVE WITH THE REQUEST. WASN'T
03:35:27.781 --> 03:35:30.183
THE ONE CONCERN WITH THE
03:35:30.250 --> 03:35:32.319
QUESTIONS ALL ABOUT GHGS WHEN
03:35:32.386 --> 03:35:33.654
MANY OF THE TRANSPORTATION
03:35:33.720 --> 03:35:35.188
PROGRAMS ACTUALLY ARE FOCUSED
03:35:35.255 --> 03:35:38.892
ON DIESEL AND KNOCKS NGH
03:35:38.959 --> 03:35:40.260
JENNINGS WAS THE OPPORTUNITY TO
03:35:40.327 --> 03:35:41.495
REALLY WORK FOR OF YOUR POINT
03:35:41.561 --> 03:35:42.796
ABOUT LAST YEAR WE RESPONDED IN
03:35:42.863 --> 03:35:44.131
WRITING I RESPOND IN WRITING
03:35:44.197 --> 03:35:45.699
MULTIPLE TIMES TO EVERY
03:35:45.766 --> 03:35:48.035
QUESTION THAT WAS RAISED AS
03:35:48.101 --> 03:35:48.735
WELL AS MET WITH THE CHAIR A
03:35:48.802 --> 03:35:51.371
FEW TIMES DOING OUR LEVEL BEST
03:35:51.438 --> 03:35:52.806
MY TO BE FULLY RESPONSIVE AND
03:35:52.873 --> 03:35:55.642
YOU'LL ALWAYS GET THAT FULL
03:35:55.709 --> 03:35:56.109
COMMITMENT TO BE FULLY
03:35:56.176 --> 03:35:58.979
RESPONSIVE. THANK YOU. CAN I
03:35:59.046 --> 03:36:01.815
MISSED HER WHAT LEASE JUST JUST
03:36:01.882 --> 03:36:03.583
YOU KNOW AS- A LITTLE BIT AT IS
03:36:03.650 --> 03:36:05.252
ALL THIS INFORMATION THAT YOU
03:36:05.319 --> 03:36:06.853
THESE REPORTS ARE THEY ALL
03:36:06.920 --> 03:36:08.322
ELIGIBLE ARE THEY ALL.
03:36:08.388 --> 03:36:11.024
TRANSPARENT TO THE PUBLIC THIS
03:36:11.091 --> 03:36:11.525
CAN PUBLIC SEE ALL THESE
03:36:11.591 --> 03:36:13.427
REPORTS YES. THE CHALLENGE AND
03:36:13.493 --> 03:36:14.361
I WANT TO BE CLEAR ON THIS
03:36:14.428 --> 03:36:15.762
BECAUSE IT'S A IT'S A IT'S A
03:36:15.829 --> 03:36:17.364
FAIR POINT BECAUSE THE POINT IS
03:36:17.431 --> 03:36:20.133
BEEN MADE BEFORE. IS THE OTHER
03:36:20.200 --> 03:36:21.702
AGENCIES FIFTY YEARS WITH FIFTY
03:36:21.768 --> 03:36:22.836
YEARS OLD THE NUMBER OF MOBILE
03:36:22.903 --> 03:36:24.404
SOURCE SPECIALS WHY DO WE HAVE
03:36:24.471 --> 03:36:25.572
ANOTHER MOBILE SOURCE MEASURES
03:36:25.639 --> 03:36:27.407
WE HAVE THIRTY VEHICLES OF CARS
03:36:27.474 --> 03:36:29.042
TRUCKS AND VARIOUS EQUIPMENT ON
03:36:29.109 --> 03:36:31.211
THE ROAD AGENCY. I HAS
03:36:31.278 --> 03:36:32.679
STRINGENT FEDERAL APARTMENTS IN
03:36:32.746 --> 03:36:34.281
TERMS OF IMPROVING YOUR QUALITY
03:36:34.348 --> 03:36:35.782
WHICH BY THE WAY CALIFORNIA'S
03:36:35.849 --> 03:36:37.217
AIR QUALITY IS VASTLY BETTER
03:36:37.284 --> 03:36:38.952
THAN IT USED TO BE. OF COURSE
03:36:39.019 --> 03:36:40.487
99% CLEANER TODAY THAT
03:36:40.554 --> 03:36:42.389
INFORMATION'S AVAILABLE BUT ONE
03:36:42.456 --> 03:36:43.156
THING IT WAS CLEAR IT WAS CLEAR
03:36:43.223 --> 03:36:46.226
TO ME. IS CLEARLY ACCESSING ANY
03:36:46.293 --> 03:36:47.594
INFORMATION ON THE WEB THAT CAN
03:36:47.661 --> 03:36:49.196
BE HARD. THAT CAN BE DIFFICULT
03:36:49.262 --> 03:36:50.597
WE'VE REVAMPED WERE IN THE
03:36:50.664 --> 03:36:51.865
MIDDLE OF REVAMPING THE
03:36:51.932 --> 03:36:53.533
WEBSITES OF THE SEARCH ENGINES
03:36:53.600 --> 03:36:54.468
MAKE IT EASIER TO FIND
03:36:54.534 --> 03:36:56.536
INFORMATION. AND RELATED
03:36:56.603 --> 03:36:57.838
BECAUSE I CAN BE TOUGH SO THAT
03:36:57.904 --> 03:36:59.806
SO THAT IS AN AREA THAT WE TOOK
03:36:59.873 --> 03:37:02.309
TO HEART. BASED ON THE LA OLD
03:37:02.376 --> 03:37:05.145
REPORT AS WELL AS THE PARENTS
03:37:05.212 --> 03:37:06.446
FOR THIS COMMITTEE LAST YEAR. I
03:37:06.513 --> 03:37:07.381
WOULD JUST I WOULD JUST SAY
03:37:07.447 --> 03:37:08.849
THAT I'M I'M GLAD YOU ARE
03:37:08.915 --> 03:37:11.618
BECAUSE- RECENTLY AT A AT A AT
03:37:11.685 --> 03:37:13.053
A CONFERENCE I WAS ASKED I
03:37:13.120 --> 03:37:16.556
ASKED THE CHAIR. WHY WHY- I
03:37:16.623 --> 03:37:17.924
WENT TO A WEB BUT WHEN YOUR WEB
03:37:17.991 --> 03:37:20.927
PAGES. AND SAID LAST REVIEWED
03:37:20.994 --> 03:37:23.096
MARCH OF TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN.
03:37:23.163 --> 03:37:28.301
I CAPTURED. THAT ON MY PHONE.
03:37:28.368 --> 03:37:29.202
AND THE ANSWER I GOT WAS SOME
03:37:29.269 --> 03:37:30.871
THIS. AND I'M- BY THAT FRANKLY.
03:37:30.937 --> 03:37:34.040
BUT MIRACULOUSLY MONDAY THAT
03:37:34.107 --> 03:37:35.509
WAS CHANGED IN THE LINKS I WAS
03:37:35.575 --> 03:37:37.177
ASKING FOR WERE THERE AND IT
03:37:37.244 --> 03:37:37.878
WAS IT WAS MIRACULOUSLY
03:37:37.944 --> 03:37:41.281
UPDATED. BUT THAT TROUBLES ME.
03:37:41.348 --> 03:37:44.484
THAT THAT ON SOMETHING RELATED
03:37:44.551 --> 03:37:46.586
TO WILDFIRES AND YOUR YOU HAD
03:37:46.653 --> 03:37:47.220
NO LINKS THERE WERE NO
03:37:47.287 --> 03:37:49.122
HYPERLINKS THERE. AND IT'D BEEN
03:37:49.189 --> 03:37:51.224
LAST REVIEWED AND SINCE. TWO
03:37:51.291 --> 03:37:53.026
THOUSAND THIRTEEN. SO THAT
03:37:53.093 --> 03:37:54.861
MAKES ME WONDER. AND THAT'S ONE
03:37:54.928 --> 03:37:55.896
OF THE REASON I WANT TO SUPPORT
03:37:55.962 --> 03:37:57.831
SENATOR BRADFORD. HOW MANY
03:37:57.898 --> 03:37:59.533
OTHER INSTANCES OF THESE KINDS
03:37:59.599 --> 03:38:00.801
OF THINGS AROUND THERE THERE
03:38:00.867 --> 03:38:02.936
WERE THERE ISN'T THE
03:38:03.003 --> 03:38:04.404
INFORMATION. THAT THAT THAT IS
03:38:04.471 --> 03:38:07.908
A IS AVAILABLE TO PEOPLE. YEAH
03:38:07.974 --> 03:38:10.744
I THINK AB. YOU KNOW AFTER IS
03:38:10.811 --> 03:38:11.578
THAT THINK IT'S A IT'S A FOR
03:38:11.645 --> 03:38:13.547
QUESTION THAT THIS COMMITTEES
03:38:13.613 --> 03:38:14.714
LOOKED AT IN THE PAST AS WELL
03:38:14.781 --> 03:38:15.949
MISTER WOULD YOU KNOW IN OTHER
03:38:16.016 --> 03:38:17.851
COMMITTEES AND SPA REALLY IN
03:38:17.918 --> 03:38:18.852
THE BUDGET HEARINGS AS WELL IN
03:38:18.919 --> 03:38:20.520
BOTH HOUSES AT. CENTER BRADFORD
03:38:20.587 --> 03:38:22.222
ALLUDED TO IS THE EASE OF WHICH
03:38:22.289 --> 03:38:23.690
TO FIND ALL THE INFORMATION
03:38:23.757 --> 03:38:25.759
BECAUSE A LOT OF TIMES IT WAS.
03:38:25.826 --> 03:38:27.027
AND ONE PAGE THAT WAS RELATED
03:38:27.093 --> 03:38:28.829
TO ANOTHER AND IT SOUNDS LIKE
03:38:28.895 --> 03:38:29.396
MISTER COREY SAYING THEY'RE
03:38:29.463 --> 03:38:30.931
TRYING TO REVAMP THE- THE
03:38:30.997 --> 03:38:32.399
WEBSITE TO HELP MAKE THAT A
03:38:32.466 --> 03:38:33.066
LITTLE MORE MANAGEABLE
03:38:33.133 --> 03:38:34.701
HOPEFULLY AT. ADDRESSING SOME
03:38:34.768 --> 03:38:35.569
OF THE CONCERNS THAT WE
03:38:35.635 --> 03:38:36.970
CONTINUE TO RAISE YEAR IN AND
03:38:37.037 --> 03:38:38.538
YEAR OUT IN THIS COMMITTEE- I
03:38:38.605 --> 03:38:39.673
DON'T GET BOGGED DOWN LET'S
03:38:39.739 --> 03:38:41.274
MOVE TO CENTER BORDERS. THANK
03:38:41.341 --> 03:38:45.712
YOU. COUPLE RANDOM QUESTIONS IF
03:38:45.779 --> 03:38:47.647
I MAY QUICKLY. CENTER BRADFORD
03:38:47.714 --> 03:38:48.682
DO YOU HAVE A SCIENCE
03:38:48.748 --> 03:38:52.185
BACKGROUND- OR SOME SORT OF-
03:38:52.252 --> 03:38:54.688
RELEVANT. EDUCATION IN THIS
03:38:54.754 --> 03:38:56.256
PARTICULAR AREA TRANSPORTATION
03:38:56.323 --> 03:38:58.458
EMISSIONS. SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
03:38:58.525 --> 03:38:59.793
NOT IN THIS PARTICULAR AREA BUT
03:38:59.860 --> 03:39:01.595
I WAS OF ALL THE MAJOR IN
03:39:01.661 --> 03:39:04.798
COLLEGE TO HAVE SUMMONS SALAS
03:39:04.865 --> 03:39:06.867
GERMAN DO YOU HAVE A SCIENCE
03:39:06.933 --> 03:39:09.336
BACKGROUND. NOT LICENSED ALL
03:39:09.402 --> 03:39:12.906
RIGHT- THE REASON WHY I ASK IS
03:39:12.973 --> 03:39:14.207
WE'VE HAD A COUPLE DISCUSSIONS
03:39:14.274 --> 03:39:16.877
TODAY ON WHAT THIS BODIES
03:39:16.943 --> 03:39:19.679
POLICIES SHOULD. BE LIKE IF
03:39:19.746 --> 03:39:21.915
WE'RE ASKING FOR INFORMATION.
03:39:21.982 --> 03:39:24.050
THIS IS A HIGHLY TECHNICAL AREA
03:39:24.117 --> 03:39:27.387
OF INQUIRY. TO ME THAT RISES TO
03:39:27.454 --> 03:39:29.456
THE LEVEL OF HAVING THE
03:39:29.523 --> 03:39:32.325
RESOURCES THAT- IN YOUR OFFICE
03:39:32.392 --> 03:39:33.326
CAN BRING TO BEAR ON SOMETHING
03:39:33.393 --> 03:39:36.496
LIKE THIS IS A CLASSIC EXAMPLE.
03:39:36.563 --> 03:39:39.099
IN THE EARLIER EXAMPLE THE LAST
03:39:39.165 --> 03:39:41.535
YEAR YOU REQUESTED ON A LOT OF
03:39:41.601 --> 03:39:42.736
INFORMATION AND WE HER JUST
03:39:42.802 --> 03:39:44.204
RECENTLY THAT YOU WERE
03:39:44.271 --> 03:39:46.473
RESPONSIVE TO OR YOU YOU
03:39:46.540 --> 03:39:47.874
RESPONDED TO THE REQUEST FOR
03:39:47.941 --> 03:39:51.044
INFORMATION. THAT TO RISE TO
03:39:51.111 --> 03:39:53.613
THE LEVEL THAT THE MAKER OF THE
03:39:53.680 --> 03:39:55.782
INQUIRY LAST YEAR WAS NOT
03:39:55.849 --> 03:39:58.285
SATISFIED WITH THE INFORMATION
03:39:58.351 --> 03:40:00.620
THAT HE GOT BACK. BOTH OF THOSE
03:40:00.687 --> 03:40:02.789
SITUATIONS ARE CLASSIC EXAMPLES
03:40:02.856 --> 03:40:04.524
OF NGUYEN SOMETHING'S HYPER
03:40:04.591 --> 03:40:07.928
TECHNICAL RESOURCE DRIVEN AND
03:40:07.994 --> 03:40:09.663
OUR EFFORTS HAVE BEEN MADE IN
03:40:09.729 --> 03:40:11.898
THE PAST TO WARRANT AN AUDIT.
03:40:11.965 --> 03:40:13.600
THIS IS A CLASSIC EXAMPLE OF
03:40:13.667 --> 03:40:15.201
WHERE IN AUDIT IS MOST
03:40:15.268 --> 03:40:17.571
APPROPRIATE MY OPINIONS SO I'LL
03:40:17.637 --> 03:40:18.338
CERTAINLY BE SUPPORTING IT WILL
03:40:18.405 --> 03:40:19.973
OF COURSE THE WITH THE OUTCOME-
03:40:20.040 --> 03:40:21.942
BRINGS ABOUT BUT THIS IS REALLY
03:40:22.008 --> 03:40:24.077
WHAT THIS BOARD IS DESIGNED. ON
03:40:24.144 --> 03:40:25.745
THIS COMMITTEES DESIGNED TO
03:40:25.812 --> 03:40:26.980
MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT THANK
03:40:27.047 --> 03:40:28.615
SENATOR I BELIEVE THE AUDITOR
03:40:28.682 --> 03:40:29.816
ACTUALLY MENTIONED AS WELL SHE
03:40:29.883 --> 03:40:31.651
HAS RESOURCES AND CAPACITY TO
03:40:31.718 --> 03:40:32.719
EVEN BRING IN CONSULTANTS IF
03:40:32.786 --> 03:40:34.487
SHE NEEDS AT EXPERTISE AS WELL
03:40:34.554 --> 03:40:35.655
TO CONDUCT THE AUDIT. RIGHT
03:40:35.722 --> 03:40:38.058
WITH THAT LET ME ASK THERE'S
03:40:38.124 --> 03:40:38.558
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS. OR
03:40:38.625 --> 03:40:39.926
COMMENTS FROM MEMBERS THE DíAS
03:40:39.993 --> 03:40:41.962
HEARING AND SEEING NONE WE GOT
03:40:42.028 --> 03:40:49.469
TO MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENT. GOOD
03:40:49.536 --> 03:40:50.503
AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR ALEX
03:40:50.570 --> 03:40:52.305
JACKSON ON BEHALF OF THE
03:40:52.372 --> 03:40:52.839
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE
03:40:52.906 --> 03:40:54.307
COUNCIL RESPECTFULLY IN
03:40:54.374 --> 03:40:55.642
OPPOSITION TO THE PROPOSED
03:40:55.709 --> 03:40:57.377
AUDIT TODAY LET ME BE CLEAR WHY
03:40:57.444 --> 03:40:59.446
THOUGH WE ARE CERTAINLY NOT
03:40:59.512 --> 03:41:01.548
OPPOSED TO TRANSPARENCY. OR
03:41:01.615 --> 03:41:03.583
RIGOROUS PROGRAM EVALUATION WE
03:41:03.650 --> 03:41:04.818
HAVE TO KNOW WHAT WE'RE GETTING
03:41:04.884 --> 03:41:06.820
FOR INVESTMENT DOLLARS. BUT AS
03:41:06.886 --> 03:41:07.754
WE HEARD THROUGHOUT THE
03:41:07.821 --> 03:41:08.855
DISCUSSION TODAY ON THE OTHER I
03:41:08.922 --> 03:41:10.156
REQUEST WE FEEL LIKE THERE'S
03:41:10.223 --> 03:41:11.691
BEEN A REAL BREAKDOWN IN THE
03:41:11.758 --> 03:41:13.760
PROCESS WHERE YOU HAVE. THE
03:41:13.827 --> 03:41:17.564
AGENCY BEING AUDITED GETTING
03:41:17.631 --> 03:41:19.199
OUR NOTICE A WEEK AGO. A WEEK
03:41:19.265 --> 03:41:21.334
AGO AND AS A RESULT WE'RE LEFT
03:41:21.401 --> 03:41:22.769
WITH THE SCOPE THAT WERE
03:41:22.836 --> 03:41:23.503
CONCERNED IS NOT GOING TO
03:41:23.570 --> 03:41:25.271
PRODUCE. A AN AUDIT THAT'S
03:41:25.338 --> 03:41:26.640
GONNA MATERIALLY IMPROVE THESE
03:41:26.706 --> 03:41:27.841
PROGRAMS MOVING FORWARD BECAUSE
03:41:27.907 --> 03:41:29.976
IT CLEARLY DOESN'T INCLUDE A
03:41:30.043 --> 03:41:31.544
HUGE PART OF THEIR BEES MANDATE
03:41:31.611 --> 03:41:33.613
RELATED TO REDUCING TOXIC AND
03:41:33.680 --> 03:41:35.248
CRITERIA MISSIONS. IF WE HAD
03:41:35.315 --> 03:41:36.349
HAD THAT PROPER NOTICE WHICH
03:41:36.416 --> 03:41:39.486
WAS USED BY MEMBERS ON THIS
03:41:39.552 --> 03:41:40.854
DíAS TO. YOU KNOW HOW THEY
03:41:40.920 --> 03:41:42.022
WERE EVALUATING OTHER REQUESTS
03:41:42.088 --> 03:41:43.923
WE COULD HAVE PRODUCED A MORE
03:41:43.990 --> 03:41:45.659
RELEVANT INQUIRY WE COULD GIVEN
03:41:45.725 --> 03:41:47.193
THE AGENCY A CHANCE TO RESPOND.
03:41:47.260 --> 03:41:48.495
EL AND WE THINK THAT WOULD BE
03:41:48.561 --> 03:41:50.030
WARRANTED MOVING FORWARD WE
03:41:50.096 --> 03:41:51.097
ALSO ARE CONCERNED THAT THE
03:41:51.164 --> 03:41:53.366
NATURE OF THE INQUIRY. AS
03:41:53.433 --> 03:41:54.567
SOMETHING THAT IS GOING TO BE.
03:41:54.634 --> 03:41:57.270
AS YOU NOTED SENATOR BOARD YES.
03:41:57.337 --> 03:41:59.305
TECHNICAL AND REQUIRES FOLKS
03:41:59.372 --> 03:42:00.807
WITH EXPERTISE IN AND
03:42:00.874 --> 03:42:03.276
TRANSPORTATION POLICY- AND WE
03:42:03.343 --> 03:42:04.277
ARE WORRIED THAT ADDING THIS
03:42:04.344 --> 03:42:05.912
REQUEST IN ITS CURRENT SCOPE
03:42:05.979 --> 03:42:07.547
IT'S GONNA TAKE TIME AND
03:42:07.614 --> 03:42:09.182
RESOURCES AWAY FROM THE AGENCY.
03:42:09.249 --> 03:42:10.383
WHO DESPERATELY NEED TO BE
03:42:10.450 --> 03:42:12.719
FOCUSED ON THE URGENT MISSION
03:42:12.786 --> 03:42:13.253
OF REDUCING TRANSPORTATION
03:42:13.319 --> 03:42:15.522
POLLUTION- AT A MINIMUM WE
03:42:15.588 --> 03:42:17.657
THINK THE- BEAR THE BURDEN OF
03:42:17.724 --> 03:42:18.625
ESTABLISHING THERE HASN'T BEEN
03:42:18.692 --> 03:42:19.726
RESPONSIVENESS THAT THERE'S AN
03:42:19.793 --> 03:42:21.161
ISSUE HAS A BIT MATT. AND AS
03:42:21.227 --> 03:42:22.395
THE FOR THAT REASON WE OPPOSE
03:42:22.462 --> 03:42:24.431
THIS REQUEST. THANK YOU IN ALL
03:42:24.497 --> 03:42:25.999
FAIRNESS YOU KNOW THESE ARE
03:42:26.066 --> 03:42:26.800
ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN BROUGHT
03:42:26.866 --> 03:42:29.102
UP YEAR AFTER YEAR. PLEASE
03:42:29.169 --> 03:42:31.938
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT.
03:42:32.005 --> 03:42:33.673
CATHERINE PHILLIPS WAS SIERRA
03:42:33.740 --> 03:42:35.341
CLUB CALIFORNIA INDEED THIS.
03:42:35.408 --> 03:42:37.410
AUDT REQUESTS IS UP FOR
03:42:37.477 --> 03:42:38.578
ESSENTIALLY THE SECOND YEAR IN
03:42:38.645 --> 03:42:40.180
A ROW AND DESPITE THE FACT THAT
03:42:40.246 --> 03:42:41.981
THE CALIFORNIA RESOURCES BOARD
03:42:42.048 --> 03:42:43.817
GROUP. LAST YEAR THIS BODY
03:42:43.883 --> 03:42:45.719
DECIDED NOT TO GO FORWARD WITH
03:42:45.785 --> 03:42:48.254
AN AUDIT BUT INSTEAD DID AND- A
03:42:48.321 --> 03:42:49.956
DIRECT CONVERSATION BETWEEN THE
03:42:50.023 --> 03:42:54.027
CHAIR AND- AND THE- BOARD. AND
03:42:54.094 --> 03:42:56.930
IT SEEMS THAT. DESPITE THAT
03:42:56.996 --> 03:42:58.998
WERE COMING BACK NOW WITH THIS
03:42:59.065 --> 03:43:01.301
AUDIT REQUEST AGAIN. AND THE
03:43:01.367 --> 03:43:02.969
EFFECT OF THIS IS THAT WE'RE
03:43:03.036 --> 03:43:04.738
GOING TO IF WE GO FORWARD WITH
03:43:04.804 --> 03:43:05.972
THIS AUDIT REQUEST WITH LIGHT
03:43:06.039 --> 03:43:08.408
WHICH I. I MISSED HOW LONG MISS
03:43:08.475 --> 03:43:09.843
HOWELL SAID IT WOULD TAKE BUT
03:43:09.909 --> 03:43:11.644
I'M- GONNA GUESS IT'S GONNA
03:43:11.711 --> 03:43:13.580
TAKE A LOT LONGER. THAN SHE
03:43:13.646 --> 03:43:15.248
EVEN ESTIMATES BECAUSE THE
03:43:15.315 --> 03:43:17.117
BREADTH OF THIS AUDIT REQUEST.
03:43:17.183 --> 03:43:20.320
IS OF FAIRLY INCREDIBLE. THIRTY
03:43:20.386 --> 03:43:22.989
FOUR TRANSPORTATION PROGRAMS.
03:43:23.056 --> 03:43:23.723
THIRTY FOUR PROGRAMS YOU'RE
03:43:23.790 --> 03:43:25.425
GONNA LOOK AT WHAT THE GHG
03:43:25.492 --> 03:43:27.794
IMPACTS COSTS AND BENEFITS ARE
03:43:27.861 --> 03:43:30.063
FOR EACH OF THOSE PROGRAMS.
03:43:30.130 --> 03:43:31.798
MANY MANY OF THOSE PROGRAMS.
03:43:31.865 --> 03:43:33.533
HAVE NOTHING TO WERE NOT
03:43:33.600 --> 03:43:36.136
INTENDED TO INITIALLY ADDRESS
03:43:36.202 --> 03:43:39.305
GHGS THEIR ATTENDED TO PROVIDE.
03:43:39.372 --> 03:43:40.774
PUBLIC YOU KNOW TO GO AFTER
03:43:40.840 --> 03:43:43.276
CRITERIA POLLUTANTS. TO THAT
03:43:43.343 --> 03:43:45.111
IMPACT PUBLIC HEALTH. SO
03:43:45.178 --> 03:43:47.046
FIGURING OUT WHAT THE GHG
03:43:47.113 --> 03:43:49.048
BENEFITS IT'S A CO BENEFIT IS
03:43:49.115 --> 03:43:50.850
GOING TO BE PRETTY TECHNICALLY
03:43:50.917 --> 03:43:54.287
DIFFICULT- FOR AN AUDIT BUREAU.
03:43:54.354 --> 03:43:55.188
UNLESS YOU'RE BRINGING IN
03:43:55.255 --> 03:43:58.091
ENGINEERS AND AS AS WAS ALLUDED
03:43:58.158 --> 03:44:00.260
TO BY OF THE PREVIOUS TESTIFY
03:44:00.326 --> 03:44:01.895
ARE. BRINGING IN PEOPLE WHO
03:44:01.961 --> 03:44:05.231
ARE- VERY SKILLED AT- PUBLIC
03:44:05.298 --> 03:44:06.966
POLICY AT THE TRANSPORTATION
03:44:07.033 --> 03:44:09.035
POLICY. BUT I'D LIKE TO NOTE
03:44:09.102 --> 03:44:12.505
SOMETHING ELSE. RIGHT NOW. THIS
03:44:12.572 --> 03:44:15.809
IS MINUTES THIS THE TRUMP
03:44:15.875 --> 03:44:16.810
ADMINISTRATION. IS SPENDING AN
03:44:16.876 --> 03:44:20.413
AWFUL LOT OF TIME. IN OF IN
03:44:20.480 --> 03:44:21.514
CONJUNCTION WITH THE OIL AND
03:44:21.581 --> 03:44:23.183
GAS INDUSTRY TE FOSSIL FUEL
03:44:23.249 --> 03:44:25.919
INDUSTRY AND THE AND CERTAIN
03:44:25.985 --> 03:44:27.420
AUTOMAKERS THEY'RE SPENDING A
03:44:27.487 --> 03:44:28.555
LOT OF TIME GOING AFTER
03:44:28.621 --> 03:44:31.257
CALIFORNIA'S ABILITY TO CONTROL
03:44:31.324 --> 03:44:32.926
AIR POLLUTION FROM VEHICLES.
03:44:32.992 --> 03:44:35.028
AND THE WAIVER THAT ALLOWS
03:44:35.094 --> 03:44:38.198
THIS. STATE THE CONTROL IS HERE
03:44:38.264 --> 03:44:39.098
POLLUTION TO PROTECT PUBLIC
03:44:39.165 --> 03:44:42.669
HEALTH IS BEING CHALLENGED. AND
03:44:42.735 --> 03:44:45.805
MY CONCERN IS THAT ONCE MORE
03:44:45.872 --> 03:44:48.708
WE'RE GOING TO BE PUT INTO A
03:44:48.775 --> 03:44:51.010
LEGISLATIVE BODY WILL BE SAYING
03:44:51.077 --> 03:44:54.647
PUBLICLY WE DON'T TRUST. WE
03:44:54.714 --> 03:44:56.516
DON'T TRUST THE AGENCY THAT'S
03:44:56.583 --> 03:44:58.051
RESPONSIBLE FOR CONTROLLING
03:44:58.117 --> 03:45:00.186
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS FROM
03:45:00.253 --> 03:45:04.357
TRANSPORTATION. I WOULD BEG YOU
03:45:04.424 --> 03:45:06.392
TO NOT DO THIS THIS YEAR. DON'T
03:45:06.459 --> 03:45:07.794
GIVE DONALD TRUMP ANOTHER
03:45:07.861 --> 03:45:09.929
TALKING POINT BECAUSE THAT'S
03:45:09.996 --> 03:45:11.865
WHAT YOU WILL BE DOING. AND
03:45:11.931 --> 03:45:13.233
THIS IS NOT THE YEAR TO DO THIS
03:45:13.299 --> 03:45:15.501
KIND OF AUDIT THE AUDIT IS FAR
03:45:15.568 --> 03:45:17.570
TOO BROAD AND ONE MORE THING. I
03:45:17.637 --> 03:45:19.272
WANT TO COMMENT ON THE CONCERN
03:45:19.339 --> 03:45:20.373
ABOUT THE ABILITY TO FIND
03:45:20.440 --> 03:45:22.075
INFORMATION I'M ONE OF THOSE
03:45:22.141 --> 03:45:23.776
PEOPLE THAT GOES IN AND USES
03:45:23.843 --> 03:45:25.311
CARBS WEBSITE ON A REGULAR
03:45:25.378 --> 03:45:26.980
BASIS. WE GIVE IT IS CANCER
03:45:27.046 --> 03:45:28.748
OVER IT IS COMPLEX IT IS
03:45:28.815 --> 03:45:31.584
CLUMSY. AND I'M I'M HAPPY TO
03:45:31.651 --> 03:45:32.685
HEAR THAT THEY'RE GOING TO
03:45:32.752 --> 03:45:34.587
IMPROVE IT BUT THAT BEING SAID
03:45:34.654 --> 03:45:35.889
IF YOU SPEND THE TIME YOU CAN
03:45:35.955 --> 03:45:38.358
ULTIMATELY FIND THE ANSWER TO
03:45:38.424 --> 03:45:39.025
MOST OF THE QUESTIONS HAVE BEEN
03:45:39.092 --> 03:45:41.127
RAISED TODAY. M. MR WHAT I'D
03:45:41.194 --> 03:45:42.228
LOOK DOCTOR WHAT I'D LOVE TO
03:45:42.295 --> 03:45:44.097
COME IN AND TALK TO YOU ABOUT
03:45:44.163 --> 03:45:45.164
WHAT'S GOING ON IN YOUR
03:45:45.231 --> 03:45:47.166
DISTRICT BECAUSE I THINK I
03:45:47.233 --> 03:45:48.268
THINK THERE ARE SOME THINGS
03:45:48.334 --> 03:45:49.802
THAT WE SHARE IN COMMON IN OUR
03:45:49.869 --> 03:45:52.472
CONCERNS ABOUT- THE ABILITY OF
03:45:52.538 --> 03:45:54.474
YOUR DISTRICT TO GET ACCESS TO
03:45:54.540 --> 03:45:56.576
CERTAIN KINDS OF FUNDS. THE
03:45:56.643 --> 03:45:58.077
THANK YOU THANK YOU LET ME ASK
03:45:58.144 --> 03:45:59.178
THERE'S ADDITIONAL PUBLIC
03:45:59.245 --> 03:46:00.613
COMMENT AT THIS TIME HEARING
03:46:00.680 --> 03:46:02.882
AND SEEING NON- I DO BELIEVE
03:46:02.949 --> 03:46:04.751
PROBABLY MEMBERS ON THIS DíAS-
03:46:04.817 --> 03:46:05.518
DON'T SHARE THE SAME
03:46:05.585 --> 03:46:07.553
INTERPRETATION AND IN REGARDS
03:46:07.620 --> 03:46:09.055
TO THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION.
03:46:09.122 --> 03:46:11.357
AND THE OUT A REQUEST AT THIS
03:46:11.424 --> 03:46:12.191
TIME MISTER BRADFORD IF YOU'D
03:46:12.258 --> 03:46:14.027
LIKE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU MISTER
03:46:14.093 --> 03:46:17.363
CHAIR AND I APPRECIATE THE
03:46:17.430 --> 03:46:18.798
COMMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN MADE BY
03:46:18.865 --> 03:46:19.599
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND I
03:46:19.666 --> 03:46:21.200
THINK BASED ON WHAT WE'VE
03:46:21.267 --> 03:46:23.536
HEARD. THIS AGAIN IS AUDIT
03:46:23.603 --> 03:46:25.571
THAT'S WALL OVERDUE BUT MORE
03:46:25.638 --> 03:46:27.974
IMPORTANTLY DESERVING- WE HAVE
03:46:28.041 --> 03:46:30.643
TALKED ABOUT THE COMPLEX ISSUES
03:46:30.710 --> 03:46:32.345
THAT CARP HAS DEALT WET BUT
03:46:32.412 --> 03:46:33.579
PART OF THE PROBLEM THAT OF
03:46:33.646 --> 03:46:34.847
PART OF THE CONFUSION IS THE
03:46:34.914 --> 03:46:36.182
CONSTANT MOVING OF THE GOAL
03:46:36.249 --> 03:46:39.052
POST ON. WHAT OUR GOALS ARE OR
03:46:39.118 --> 03:46:39.686
WHAT THEIR GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
03:46:39.752 --> 03:46:42.055
ARE TO SAY THAT THIS IS GONNA
03:46:42.121 --> 03:46:46.459
HAND- WASHINGTON A WIN AND I.
03:46:46.526 --> 03:46:48.594
TEND TO DISAGREE WITH THIS IF
03:46:48.661 --> 03:46:54.467
ALL WHAT CARNOSINE IT'S TRUE.
03:46:54.534 --> 03:46:55.034
AND THEY'RE DOING ALL THESE
03:46:55.101 --> 03:46:55.935
FANTASTIC GROUND IN JUST A- FOR
03:46:56.002 --> 03:46:58.137
THE- THIS AUDIT WILL SPELL THIS
03:46:58.204 --> 03:46:59.339
OUT ANY TO HELP BUTTRESS UP
03:46:59.405 --> 03:47:01.140
THAT WHAT YOU WERE DOING. AND
03:47:01.207 --> 03:47:03.409
HELP PUSH BACK ON THE CRAZY
03:47:03.476 --> 03:47:04.711
PROGRAMS THAT WERE SEEN FROM
03:47:04.777 --> 03:47:06.646
WASHINGTON DC OR THE STOP GAP
03:47:06.713 --> 03:47:07.714
MEASURES THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO
03:47:07.780 --> 03:47:09.949
PUT FORTH. SO AUDIT HELPS
03:47:10.016 --> 03:47:11.751
CONTINUE THE GREAT WORK THAT
03:47:11.818 --> 03:47:13.786
THIS AGENCY CLAIMS TO BE DOING
03:47:13.853 --> 03:47:15.221
BUT AGAIN I WANT TO SPEAK TO
03:47:15.288 --> 03:47:17.156
WHAT. ASSEMBLYMAN WOULD STATED
03:47:17.223 --> 03:47:19.759
ABOUT. LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
03:47:19.826 --> 03:47:21.194
AN IMPACT TO COMMUNITIES
03:47:21.260 --> 03:47:22.729
BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT MONOLITHIC
03:47:22.795 --> 03:47:24.831
THEY DON'T LOOK ALIKE. AT I AM
03:47:24.897 --> 03:47:26.733
REALLY TIRED OF CARP TALKING
03:47:26.799 --> 03:47:28.501
ABOUT LOW INCOME PEOPLE WHEN
03:47:28.568 --> 03:47:30.870
VERY FEW OF THOSE PROGRAMS EVER
03:47:30.937 --> 03:47:32.438
REACHED THOSE COMMUNITIES
03:47:32.505 --> 03:47:33.673
REGARDLESS OF WHERE THE MONEY
03:47:33.740 --> 03:47:36.609
IS BEING SPENT. AND I TOO WAS
03:47:36.676 --> 03:47:38.745
AT A CONFERENCE AND WE HEARD
03:47:38.811 --> 03:47:40.847
THE DIRECTOR STATE THAT. LOW
03:47:40.913 --> 03:47:42.582
INCOME PEOPLE WANT ZERO
03:47:42.648 --> 03:47:44.684
EMISSION VEHICLES. LOW INCOME
03:47:44.751 --> 03:47:46.452
PEOPLE WANT CLEAN AIR THEY WANT
03:47:46.519 --> 03:47:47.487
CLEAN WATER THEY WANT CLING
03:47:47.553 --> 03:47:48.921
SOIL BUT I'VE YET TO HEAR ONE
03:47:48.988 --> 03:47:50.656
SAY I WANTED ZERO EMISSION.
03:47:50.723 --> 03:47:53.126
VEHICLE THEY SAID I WANT A JOB
03:47:53.192 --> 03:47:55.028
SO IF THAT IS WHAT THOSE PEOPLE
03:47:55.094 --> 03:47:56.195
WERE SEEING WERE IS THE DATA
03:47:56.262 --> 03:47:58.197
FROM THOSE SURVEYS THAT SAY
03:47:58.264 --> 03:47:59.499
THIS IS WHAT LOW INCOME PEOPLE
03:47:59.565 --> 03:48:01.401
WANT BECAUSE I'VE YET TO HEAR.
03:48:01.467 --> 03:48:03.302
NOT ONE LOW INCOME PERSONS AB
03:48:03.369 --> 03:48:04.937
ONE ZERO EMISSION VEHICLE. I'VE
03:48:05.004 --> 03:48:06.706
HEARD LOW INCOME FOLKS IN THE
03:48:06.773 --> 03:48:08.374
REASON I DRIVE MY TWENTY YEAR
03:48:08.441 --> 03:48:10.076
OLD FORD EXPLORERS BECAUSE I
03:48:10.143 --> 03:48:11.911
CAN'T FIT MY FAMILY A SIX IN
03:48:11.978 --> 03:48:13.579
THERE AND I CAN'T AFFORD TO US
03:48:13.646 --> 03:48:15.148
ALL. AND THEY WON'T FIT INTO A
03:48:15.214 --> 03:48:18.918
PRIUS. SO CONTINUE TO USE POOR
03:48:18.985 --> 03:48:20.553
PEOPLE AS WHY WE DO A LOT OF
03:48:20.620 --> 03:48:21.988
THESE PROGRAMS BUT AGAIN THEY
03:48:22.055 --> 03:48:23.322
DO NOT DIRECTLY SEE THE
03:48:23.389 --> 03:48:25.291
BENEFITS OF THESE PROGRAMS. I
03:48:25.358 --> 03:48:27.326
THINK THE AUDIT WILL X. EXPOSED
03:48:27.393 --> 03:48:29.562
ALL OF THAT. AND I THINK THIS
03:48:29.629 --> 03:48:31.898
AUDIT ONLY FURTHERS. JUSTIFIES
03:48:31.964 --> 03:48:33.733
THE WORK THE CARBS DOING BUT
03:48:33.800 --> 03:48:34.367
MORE IMPORTANTLY THE WORK THAT
03:48:34.434 --> 03:48:35.935
IS LEGISLATURE HAS BEEN DOING I
03:48:36.002 --> 03:48:37.036
THINK IT'S A COMMONSENSE
03:48:37.103 --> 03:48:38.171
MEASURE I THINK IT'S LONG
03:48:38.237 --> 03:48:39.939
OVERDUE BECAUSE AGAIN AT. THE
03:48:40.006 --> 03:48:42.008
INFORMATION THE CARPETS. I HAVE
03:48:42.075 --> 03:48:43.543
PUT PUTS OUT BE IT ON THEIR
03:48:43.609 --> 03:48:45.745
WEBSITE IS PEACE MILLET BASS IS
03:48:45.812 --> 03:48:46.579
SCATTERED IT'S NOT
03:48:46.646 --> 03:48:49.282
COMPREHENSIVE. AND AS MY
03:48:49.348 --> 03:48:50.917
COLLEAGUE STATED YOU ALMOST
03:48:50.983 --> 03:48:52.685
HAVE TO BE A SCIENTIST TO
03:48:52.752 --> 03:48:53.920
UNDERSTAND THAT WHICH YOU DO
03:48:53.986 --> 03:48:55.621
MAKE AVAILABLE SO. THE
03:48:55.688 --> 03:48:57.590
ARROGANCE OF THIS AGENCY TO ME
03:48:57.657 --> 03:48:59.926
IT IS JUST SAYING NO IS LONG
03:48:59.992 --> 03:49:01.461
OVERDUE I AM NOT THE FIRST
03:49:01.527 --> 03:49:03.329
MEMBER TO ASK FOR THIS AUDIT I
03:49:03.396 --> 03:49:05.598
WON'T BE THE LAST. AND I THINK
03:49:05.665 --> 03:49:07.767
IT'S TIMES COMES OUT RESPECT
03:49:07.834 --> 03:49:09.035
LAST RIVAL. THANK YOU SENATOR
03:49:09.102 --> 03:49:11.037
BRADFORD- BUT LET ME JUST MAKE
03:49:11.104 --> 03:49:11.938
A COUPLE COMMENTS BEFORE WE
03:49:12.004 --> 03:49:14.073
MAKE THE MOTION- FIRST THANK
03:49:14.140 --> 03:49:15.174
YOU FOR BRINGING THIS AUDIT
03:49:15.241 --> 03:49:16.776
OBVIOUSLY WE- WE'RE LOOKING AT
03:49:16.843 --> 03:49:17.743
SOME OF THESE ISSUES AND THESE
03:49:17.810 --> 03:49:19.479
ARE NOT ISSUES THAT ARE DUE TO
03:49:19.545 --> 03:49:20.613
THE LEGISLATURE EVEN TO THIS
03:49:20.680 --> 03:49:22.248
COMMITTEE- WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING
03:49:22.315 --> 03:49:23.116
AT AN AGENCY THAT'S BEEN AROUND
03:49:23.182 --> 03:49:24.484
EVELYN BEST COURSE IT FOR FIFTY
03:49:24.550 --> 03:49:25.751
PLUS YEARS. HAS NEVER HAD A
03:49:25.818 --> 03:49:27.620
COMPREHENSIVE AUDIT OF THE TWO
03:49:27.687 --> 03:49:29.155
POINT TWO BILLION PLUS DOLLARS
03:49:29.222 --> 03:49:31.357
THAT. HAVE BEEN SPENT I DO
03:49:31.424 --> 03:49:33.159
APPRECIATE THAT IN YOUR LETTER
03:49:33.226 --> 03:49:34.827
YOU DO TALK ABOUT BUILDING OFF
03:49:34.894 --> 03:49:37.163
OF WHAT THE LA JOH. RELEASED IN
03:49:37.230 --> 03:49:38.297
AND THEIR REPORT AND THEN
03:49:38.364 --> 03:49:38.898
LOOKING AT THE COST
03:49:38.965 --> 03:49:40.633
EFFECTIVENESS OF SOME OF THESE
03:49:40.700 --> 03:49:41.834
PROGRAMS AND TRANSPORTATION
03:49:41.901 --> 03:49:43.436
PROGRAMS PARTICULARLY FOR THE
03:49:43.503 --> 03:49:45.171
MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES.
03:49:45.238 --> 03:49:46.239
THOSE HEAVILY BURDENED
03:49:46.305 --> 03:49:47.607
COMMUNITIES WHEREVER THEY EXIST
03:49:47.673 --> 03:49:49.308
WHETHER THEY EXIST UP. NORTHERN
03:49:49.375 --> 03:49:50.743
CALIFORNIA CENTRAL CALIFORNIA
03:49:50.810 --> 03:49:52.645
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA- THESE ARE
03:49:52.712 --> 03:49:54.013
ISSUES THAT- WE HOPE THE OUTER
03:49:54.080 --> 03:49:55.648
CAN SHED SOME LIGHT ON IN TERMS
03:49:55.715 --> 03:49:58.751
OF. HOW WE CAN MOVE FORWARD-
03:49:58.818 --> 03:50:00.086
COST EFFECTIVELY BUT WHICH
03:50:00.153 --> 03:50:01.220
PROGRAMS ARE EVEN WORKING AT
03:50:01.287 --> 03:50:03.656
CARVE THAT WE CAN. PERHAPS A
03:50:03.723 --> 03:50:04.957
REPLICATED OTHER PARTS OF THE
03:50:05.024 --> 03:50:06.993
STATE OF THE ART. HAVING THE
03:50:07.059 --> 03:50:08.094
TARGETED RESULTS THAT WERE
03:50:08.161 --> 03:50:09.829
LOOKING FOR SO WITH THAT I'LL
03:50:09.896 --> 03:50:11.330
ASK FOR A MOTION ON CENTER
03:50:11.397 --> 03:50:14.267
BRADFORD'S- AUDIT. SECOND MOVE
03:50:14.333 --> 03:50:16.302
BY ASSEMBLY WOMAN RUBIO SECOND
03:50:16.369 --> 03:50:19.939
BY MISTER WOOD. MISTER SECTOR
03:50:20.006 --> 03:50:22.708
KALRA. THE MOTION ANSWER
03:50:22.775 --> 03:50:23.876
APPROVAL. QUOI TWENTY TWENTY
03:50:23.943 --> 03:50:25.578
DASH ONE FOURTEEN CALIFORNIA
03:50:25.645 --> 03:50:27.847
AIR RESOURCES BOARD GREENHOUSE
03:50:27.914 --> 03:50:29.682
GAS REDUCTION PROGRAMS. BY
03:50:29.749 --> 03:50:31.584
CENTER BRADFORD. ASSEMBLYMEMBER
03:50:31.651 --> 03:50:34.387
SALAS. SALAS HI BOERNER HORVATH
03:50:34.453 --> 03:50:38.491
NO. BOERNER HORVATH. NO CHEN.
03:50:38.558 --> 03:50:44.530
PATTERSON RUBIO RUBIO I VOEPEL
03:50:44.597 --> 03:50:48.234
NOT VOTING VOEPEL NOT VOTING.
03:50:48.301 --> 03:50:53.739
WHAT WHAT I. CENTER ROTH. MORE
03:50:53.806 --> 03:50:57.009
JUST FOR JUST AYE GONZALEZ.
03:50:57.076 --> 03:51:04.550
HERTZBERG MORNING. MORE LOCKED.
03:51:04.617 --> 03:51:08.821
MORE LOCK HI WIENER. OKAY THAT
03:51:08.888 --> 03:51:10.156
ITEMS ON COMMERCE REDFORD THANK
03:51:10.223 --> 03:51:12.391
YOU AS CHAIR MEMBERS THANK YOU
03:51:12.458 --> 03:51:14.360
THIS TIME I LET'S CALL IT A
03:51:14.427 --> 03:51:17.129
CALL OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER MEDINA.
03:51:17.196 --> 03:51:22.034
THIS IS ON FILE ITEM. NUMBER
03:51:22.101 --> 03:51:22.635
ELEVEN TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE
03:51:22.702 --> 03:51:24.203
OH FOUR CALIBRATE COLLEGE
03:51:24.270 --> 03:51:25.338
ASSEMBLYMEMBER NEED SOMEONE
03:51:25.404 --> 03:51:26.505
EVER MEDINA WHEN YOU'RE READY
03:51:26.572 --> 03:51:38.351
TO BEGIN PLEASE. THANK YOU
03:51:38.417 --> 03:51:40.419
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I
03:51:40.486 --> 03:51:42.054
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY
03:51:42.121 --> 03:51:44.590
PRESENT AND FOR THIS MEETING. I
03:51:44.657 --> 03:51:45.825
ALONG WITH MY COLLEAGUES
03:51:45.891 --> 03:51:49.462
ASSEMBLY MEMBER- QUIRK SILVA
03:51:49.528 --> 03:51:51.230
AND SENATOR WIENER SUBMITTED A
03:51:51.297 --> 03:51:53.799
LETTER TO RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
03:51:53.866 --> 03:51:54.734
THAT THIS COMMITTEE APPROVED AN
03:51:54.800 --> 03:51:57.069
AUDIT THE CALIFORNIA ONLINE
03:51:57.136 --> 03:51:59.505
COLLEGE WHICH IS ALSO KNOWN AS
03:51:59.572 --> 03:52:01.874
CAL BRIGHT COLLEGE. CALIBRATE
03:52:01.941 --> 03:52:03.342
COLLEGE WAS DEVELOPED AND
03:52:03.409 --> 03:52:04.543
IMPLEMENTED UNDER THE PREVIOUS
03:52:04.610 --> 03:52:07.413
ADMINISTRATION. THROUGHOUT ITS
03:52:07.480 --> 03:52:09.148
DEVELOPMENT MY COLLEAGUES IN
03:52:09.215 --> 03:52:10.750
THE ASSEMBLY AND THE SENATE
03:52:10.816 --> 03:52:13.519
VOICE SEVERAL CONCERNS ABOUT
03:52:13.586 --> 03:52:15.721
THE STRUCTURE AND PROGRAMMING.
03:52:15.788 --> 03:52:17.256
MY COLLEAGUES AND I HOPE THAT
03:52:17.323 --> 03:52:19.125
THIS AUDIT REQUESTS CAN
03:52:19.191 --> 03:52:21.127
ACCOMPLISH SEVERAL THINGS.
03:52:21.193 --> 03:52:22.762
FIRST WE WOULD LIKE THE ADDED
03:52:22.828 --> 03:52:24.297
TO REVIEW THE CURRENT STATUS OF
03:52:24.363 --> 03:52:26.732
CAB RIDES COLLEGE EFFORTS TO
03:52:26.799 --> 03:52:27.833
MEET ITS GOAL OF PROVIDING
03:52:27.900 --> 03:52:30.436
ECONOMIC MOBILITY. FOR WORKING
03:52:30.503 --> 03:52:33.572
ADULTS WHO LACK EASY ACCESS FOR
03:52:33.639 --> 03:52:34.640
TRADITIONAL FORMS OF HIGHER
03:52:34.707 --> 03:52:38.044
EDUCATION. SECOND WE WOULD LIKE
03:52:38.110 --> 03:52:39.812
THE IDEA TO REVIEW THE STATUS
03:52:39.879 --> 03:52:41.814
OF KEY MILESTONES SUCH
03:52:41.881 --> 03:52:43.749
ACCREDITATION. AS WELL AS
03:52:43.816 --> 03:52:45.484
EXPENDITURES OF APPROPRIATED
03:52:45.551 --> 03:52:47.787
FUNDS TO ENSURE THE COB RIGHT
03:52:47.853 --> 03:52:50.122
COLLEGES PROGRESSIVELY
03:52:50.189 --> 03:52:52.058
EFFECTIVELY AND EFFICIENTLY
03:52:52.124 --> 03:52:55.461
MEETING ITS GOAL. FINALLY WOULD
03:52:55.528 --> 03:52:57.196
LIKE THE AUDITOR TO REVIEW THE
03:52:57.263 --> 03:52:59.398
REVISED APPROACH BEING PROPOSED
03:52:59.465 --> 03:53:00.900
BY THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
03:53:00.966 --> 03:53:02.802
COMMUNITY COLLEGE CHANCELLOR'S
03:53:02.868 --> 03:53:05.905
OFFICE AS IT RELATES FIRST TO
03:53:05.971 --> 03:53:07.973
THE ACCREDITATION PATH. SECOND
03:53:08.040 --> 03:53:09.475
TO COLLABORATION WITH COMMUNITY
03:53:09.542 --> 03:53:11.877
COLLEGES AND THIRD DEFICIENCY
03:53:11.944 --> 03:53:14.280
OF INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO MEET
03:53:14.347 --> 03:53:16.549
THE NEEDS OF SCALINGUP ADULTS
03:53:16.615 --> 03:53:18.384
TOO MANY IMMEDIATELY ENTER THE
03:53:18.451 --> 03:53:20.753
WORKFORCE. AS THE CHAIR OF
03:53:20.820 --> 03:53:22.822
HIGHER EDUCATION AND A FORMER
03:53:22.888 --> 03:53:24.790
EDUCATOR I AM COMMITTED TO
03:53:24.857 --> 03:53:26.158
ENSURING ACCESS TO HIGHER
03:53:26.225 --> 03:53:28.861
EDUCATION. HOWEVER WE MUST
03:53:28.928 --> 03:53:30.763
ENSURE THAT STATE INSTITUTIONS
03:53:30.830 --> 03:53:32.631
AND PROGRAMS CREATED TO PROMOTE
03:53:32.698 --> 03:53:35.201
ACCESS ARE IN FACT ACHIEVING
03:53:35.267 --> 03:53:37.670
THESE GOALS. THIS IS DONE IN A
03:53:37.737 --> 03:53:39.905
COLLABORATIVE WAY AND THE
03:53:39.972 --> 03:53:41.807
STUDENTS ARE SUCCESSFUL. WE
03:53:41.874 --> 03:53:42.908
HOPE THAT THE STATE AUDITOR
03:53:42.975 --> 03:53:44.210
FINDS THAT THE STAFF WAS SPENT
03:53:44.276 --> 03:53:45.978
OF THE CUP RIGHT COLLEGE IS
03:53:46.045 --> 03:53:47.446
PROCEEDING IN AN EFFECTIVE AND
03:53:47.513 --> 03:53:49.715
EFFICIENT MANNER. IF CHANGES
03:53:49.782 --> 03:53:51.150
ARE NEEDED WE BELIEVE THAT IS
03:53:51.217 --> 03:53:54.019
BEST TO IDENTIFY. THESE CHANGES
03:53:54.086 --> 03:53:56.055
AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. WITH ME
03:53:56.122 --> 03:53:57.656
HERE TODAY IS JIM MAILER
03:53:57.723 --> 03:53:59.692
PRESIDENT OF THE CALIFORNIA
03:53:59.759 --> 03:54:01.794
FEDERATION OF TEACHERS.
03:54:01.861 --> 03:54:04.029
COMMUNITY COLLEGE COUNCIL AND
03:54:04.096 --> 03:54:07.032
CARLOS TURNER CORTEZ PRESIDENT
03:54:07.099 --> 03:54:08.634
OF SAN DIEGO CONTINUING
03:54:08.701 --> 03:54:11.137
EDUCATION. THANK THANKFUL FOR
03:54:11.203 --> 03:54:12.738
THEM JOINING ME AND THEY WILL
03:54:12.805 --> 03:54:14.707
BE ON HAND TO ANSWER ANY
03:54:14.774 --> 03:54:17.076
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS GREAT THANK
03:54:17.143 --> 03:54:18.878
YOU YOU HAVE TESTIMONY AS WELL
03:54:18.944 --> 03:54:20.246
OKAY IF YOU HAVE LIMITED TO TWO
03:54:20.312 --> 03:54:22.381
MINUTES SIR. I'M JIM MILLER
03:54:22.448 --> 03:54:23.315
PRESIDENT OF THE COMMUNITY
03:54:23.382 --> 03:54:24.283
COLLEGE COUNCIL OF THE
03:54:24.350 --> 03:54:25.584
CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF
03:54:25.651 --> 03:54:26.819
TEACHERS HOPEFULLY THIS AUDIT
03:54:26.886 --> 03:54:28.220
REQUESTS WILL BE LESS
03:54:28.287 --> 03:54:28.888
CONTENTIOUS AND SOME OF THE
03:54:28.954 --> 03:54:31.190
PREVIOUS ONES- I THINK IT'S
03:54:31.257 --> 03:54:32.858
VERY TIMELY THAT WE ARE HAVING
03:54:32.925 --> 03:54:34.827
THIS SITE REQUEST IN THAT AND I
03:54:34.894 --> 03:54:36.328
HOPEFULLY THAT THE COMMITTEE
03:54:36.395 --> 03:54:38.130
WILL. VOTE TO PERFORM THE
03:54:38.197 --> 03:54:40.533
AUDIT- IT COULD BE MORE OF A
03:54:40.599 --> 03:54:43.569
BETTER SPEND THAT AUDIT I THINK
03:54:43.636 --> 03:54:44.970
IN TERMS OF THE AMOUNT OF MONEY
03:54:45.037 --> 03:54:46.472
THAT WE FEEL TAXPAYERS ARE
03:54:46.539 --> 03:54:49.208
CURRENTLY- ON THE HOOK FOR AND
03:54:49.275 --> 03:54:50.676
I THINK THE STATE IS MISS
03:54:50.743 --> 03:54:52.845
SPENDING QUITE FRANKLY- WITH
03:54:52.912 --> 03:54:54.547
RESPECT TO FUNDING CALIBRATE IF
03:54:54.613 --> 03:54:56.215
YOU LOOK AT THE FUNDING. PER
03:54:56.282 --> 03:54:57.650
FULL TIME EQUIVALENT STUDENT
03:54:57.716 --> 03:54:59.919
FOR CAL BRIGHT AND THIS IS NOT
03:54:59.985 --> 03:55:01.554
AN EXAGGERATION I TEACH MATH
03:55:01.620 --> 03:55:03.622
SAN DIEGO CITY COLLEGE WHEN I'M
03:55:03.689 --> 03:55:05.224
NOT DOING THIS JOB- THEY'RE
03:55:05.291 --> 03:55:07.760
BEING FUNDED AT A RATE OF ONE
03:55:07.827 --> 03:55:09.528
THOUSAND TIMES WHAT THE RIVER
03:55:09.595 --> 03:55:10.830
COMMUNITY COLLEGE STUDENTS ARE
03:55:10.896 --> 03:55:11.897
GETTING FOR. OUR TRADITIONAL
03:55:11.964 --> 03:55:14.266
COLLEGE AND A SITTING THE BACK
03:55:14.333 --> 03:55:15.301
OF THE ROOM LOOK AT THE OTHER
03:55:15.367 --> 03:55:16.168
OUT OF YOUR I JUST DID QUICK
03:55:16.235 --> 03:55:18.871
OUT THE AMOUNT WERE FUNDING FOR
03:55:18.938 --> 03:55:21.073
CALIBRATED AN ON GOING BASIS
03:55:21.140 --> 03:55:23.175
EACH YEAR WHAT FUND THREE TIMES
03:55:23.242 --> 03:55:24.643
THE AMOUNT OF ALL OF THE ODD
03:55:24.710 --> 03:55:26.612
IT'S BEEN REQUESTED TODAY'S
03:55:26.679 --> 03:55:29.515
DOCKET SO YOU COULD FIND FORTY
03:55:29.582 --> 03:55:30.416
EIGHT AUDIT REQUESTS THAT THE
03:55:30.483 --> 03:55:31.817
AMOUNT OF. FUNDING WE'RE
03:55:31.884 --> 03:55:36.188
FIGHTING. FOR THIRTY EIGHT.
03:55:36.255 --> 03:55:36.689
COSTS COULD STUDENTS. IN
03:55:36.755 --> 03:55:37.256
CALGARY NOW SO. IT'S QUITE
03:55:37.323 --> 03:55:38.557
BOGGLING IN THE AMOUNT EVERY.
03:55:38.624 --> 03:55:39.892
IT'S BEING SPENT THE SERVER SO
03:55:39.959 --> 03:55:42.661
FEW STUDENTS- DUPLICATION IS
03:55:42.728 --> 03:55:43.863
ANOTHER BIG ISSUE THERE ARE
03:55:43.929 --> 03:55:44.597
THREE PROGRAMS BEING OFFERED
03:55:44.663 --> 03:55:46.232
AND CAL BRIGHT ALL THREE OF
03:55:46.298 --> 03:55:47.199
THOSE PROGRAMS WE CURRENTLY
03:55:47.266 --> 03:55:48.567
OFFER IN FIFTY ONE DIFFERENT
03:55:48.634 --> 03:55:51.036
COMMUNITY COLLEGES- SO THERE'S-
03:55:51.103 --> 03:55:52.771
THERE'S NOT REALLY A NEED TO.
03:55:52.838 --> 03:55:54.773
REPLICATE THOSE DESPITE CAL
03:55:54.840 --> 03:55:55.407
BRIGHTS CLAIMS THAT THEY'RE NOT
03:55:55.474 --> 03:55:57.109
BE A DUPLICATE OF. THEIR EXTRA
03:55:57.176 --> 03:55:58.544
EXTREMELY DUPLICATIVE WHAT WERE
03:55:58.611 --> 03:56:00.713
ALREADY OFFERING. ANOTHER MAJOR
03:56:00.779 --> 03:56:02.014
ISSUE THAT I HOPE THE IF THE
03:56:02.081 --> 03:56:03.549
AUDITOR WILL FOCUS ON IS THE
03:56:03.616 --> 03:56:05.618
ACCREDITATION STATUS. ALL
03:56:05.684 --> 03:56:06.919
HUNDRED AND FOURTEEN COLLEGES
03:56:06.986 --> 03:56:08.254
IN THE COMMUNITY COLLEGE SYSTEM
03:56:08.320 --> 03:56:10.222
ARE ACCREDITED BY ONE AGENCY.
03:56:10.289 --> 03:56:13.192
THE ACC J. C. AND THAT PROVIDE
03:56:13.259 --> 03:56:15.060
THOSE STUDENTS TO TAKE COLLEGE
03:56:15.127 --> 03:56:17.263
COURSES TO. TRANSFER GET
03:56:17.329 --> 03:56:18.764
FINANCIAL AID IT CETERA
03:56:18.831 --> 03:56:20.533
CALIBRATE IS NOT ACCREDITED NOT
03:56:20.599 --> 03:56:21.066
ONLY THAT THEY'RE SEEKING
03:56:21.133 --> 03:56:22.935
ACCREDITATION. FROM AN OUTSIDE
03:56:23.002 --> 03:56:25.437
ENTITY THAT'S NOT A TO SEE JC-
03:56:25.504 --> 03:56:26.972
BECAUSE IT'S BASICALLY A LOWER
03:56:27.039 --> 03:56:28.073
BAR TO PASS BUT IT'S NOT GOING
03:56:28.140 --> 03:56:29.675
TO HELP OUR STUDENTS. IF THEY
03:56:29.742 --> 03:56:32.144
ARE SUCCESSFUL AT THAT
03:56:32.211 --> 03:56:33.812
ACCREDITATION. LASTLY ON THAT
03:56:33.879 --> 03:56:35.714
POINT IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
03:56:35.781 --> 03:56:37.683
MEANINGFUL DISTANCE EDUCATION.
03:56:37.750 --> 03:56:39.051
THERE HAS TO BE REGULAR AND
03:56:39.118 --> 03:56:40.586
SUBSTANTIVE CONTACT BETWEEN
03:56:40.653 --> 03:56:42.788
STUDENT AND TEACHER THAT'S NOT
03:56:42.855 --> 03:56:44.189
HAPPENING AT CAL BRIGHT THE
03:56:44.256 --> 03:56:45.658
STUDENTS ARE. DOING NOW PRETTY
03:56:45.724 --> 03:56:48.294
MUCH OFF THE SHELF COURSES
03:56:48.360 --> 03:56:50.396
LEARN AS YOU GO KIND OF THINGS.
03:56:50.462 --> 03:56:52.064
AND YOUR GIVE ME THE I. LIKE
03:56:52.131 --> 03:56:53.933
I'M OUT OF TIME YOU ARE. I
03:56:53.999 --> 03:56:55.434
THANK GOD AND I LEADERS QUITE
03:56:55.501 --> 03:56:57.369
THAT WAS HIS BABY ARISE. FROM
03:56:57.436 --> 03:56:58.170
THAT COMMENT AS WELL THANK YOU
03:56:58.237 --> 03:57:01.874
ESTATE. IF YOU MAY BEGIN WITH
03:57:01.941 --> 03:57:03.042
YOUR PRESENT. RIGHT GIVEN
03:57:03.108 --> 03:57:04.043
ADDITIONAL PERSON TO GET LEASE
03:57:04.109 --> 03:57:05.477
WE CAN. CARLIST COURT TO PRESS
03:57:05.544 --> 03:57:07.179
SAN DIEGO CONTINUING A- OF AN
03:57:07.246 --> 03:57:09.014
EDUCATOR FOR TWENTY YEARS A CEO
03:57:09.081 --> 03:57:10.282
FOR OVER TEN YEARS. I'VE BEEN
03:57:10.349 --> 03:57:11.483
AT THE HELM OF SAN DIEGO
03:57:11.550 --> 03:57:12.751
CONTINUING EDUCATION A LARGEST
03:57:12.818 --> 03:57:14.987
ADULT NOT CREDIT ORGANIZATION.
03:57:15.054 --> 03:57:16.088
IN THE STATE SINCE TWO THOUSAND
03:57:16.155 --> 03:57:19.525
FIFTEEN. AND TWO THOUSAND
03:57:19.592 --> 03:57:20.159
EIGHTEEN I WAS APPOINTED TO THE
03:57:20.225 --> 03:57:21.527
FLOW COMMITTEE. AT THAT TIME I
03:57:21.594 --> 03:57:22.661
DISCLOSE THAT CYNICAL
03:57:22.728 --> 03:57:24.229
CONTINUING EDUCATION HAD BEEN
03:57:24.296 --> 03:57:25.698
IN THE PROCESS FOR THE PAST
03:57:25.764 --> 03:57:26.532
FIVE YEARS OF DEVELOPING A
03:57:26.599 --> 03:57:28.400
FULLY ONLINE EDUCATIONAL.
03:57:28.467 --> 03:57:30.169
INSTITUTION THAT WOULD HAVE MET
03:57:30.235 --> 03:57:31.537
THE GOVERNOR'S REQUEST I SHOULD
03:57:31.604 --> 03:57:33.105
STATE THAT I'M VERY SUPPORTIVE.
03:57:33.172 --> 03:57:34.073
OF FORMER GOVERNOR BROWN'S
03:57:34.139 --> 03:57:35.307
REQUEST TO EXPAND DISTANCE
03:57:35.374 --> 03:57:36.942
EDUCATION OPPORTUNITIES JUST
03:57:37.009 --> 03:57:38.744
NOT HOW IT WAS OPERATIONALIZED
03:57:38.811 --> 03:57:40.946
BY OUR SYSTEMS LEADERSHIP- I
03:57:41.013 --> 03:57:42.281
WAS ON THE FLOW COMMITTEE I
03:57:42.348 --> 03:57:43.916
BROUGHT FOR THE ONLY PROPOSAL
03:57:43.983 --> 03:57:45.050
TO CREATE A FULLY ONLINE
03:57:45.117 --> 03:57:47.119
ORGANIZATION. AND THAT PROPOSAL
03:57:47.186 --> 03:57:49.021
WAS NOT ACKNOWLEDGED NOT AT
03:57:49.088 --> 03:57:51.557
THAT TIME I DID SHARE THAT WE
03:57:51.624 --> 03:57:52.191
ARE IN THE PROCESS OF LAUNCHING
03:57:52.257 --> 03:57:53.692
A WE WILL LAUNCH THIS SUMMER.
03:57:53.759 --> 03:57:55.160
THE INTERACTIVE COMPETENCY
03:57:55.227 --> 03:57:56.261
BASED ONLINE MICHAEL
03:57:56.328 --> 03:57:59.264
CREDENTIALING A CAT ACADEMY- IN
03:57:59.331 --> 03:57:59.865
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY WHICH
03:57:59.932 --> 03:58:01.300
WILL PROVIDE. FULLY ONLINE
03:58:01.367 --> 03:58:02.601
DISTANCE EDUCATION ADULT
03:58:02.668 --> 03:58:04.336
EDUCATION CERTIFICATES. THESE
03:58:04.403 --> 03:58:06.538
PROGRAMS ARE DUPLICATIVE OF
03:58:06.605 --> 03:58:07.806
PROGRAMS OF THE CURRENT
03:58:07.873 --> 03:58:09.108
PROGRAMS OFFERED BY CULPRIT ARE
03:58:09.174 --> 03:58:10.609
DUPLICATIVE OF THOSE IN PLACE.
03:58:10.676 --> 03:58:11.944
ON THERE ALSO CHARGING THAT THE
03:58:12.011 --> 03:58:13.345
NEED FOR CAL BRIGHT IS A NEW
03:58:13.412 --> 03:58:14.480
COMPETENCY BASED EDUCATION
03:58:14.546 --> 03:58:15.714
WHICH WE ALREADY DO WOULD NOT
03:58:15.781 --> 03:58:17.116
CREDIT EDUCATION. THE KEY
03:58:17.182 --> 03:58:18.250
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN OUR
03:58:18.317 --> 03:58:19.218
APPROACH AND THE CALIBER TO
03:58:19.284 --> 03:58:20.953
APPROACH FIRST IS THE ROLE OF
03:58:21.020 --> 03:58:23.355
FACULTY FACULTY ARE INVOLVED
03:58:23.422 --> 03:58:24.923
FROM THE OUTSET AND DEVELOPING
03:58:24.990 --> 03:58:25.958
THE CURRICULUM. AND DESIGNING
03:58:26.025 --> 03:58:27.793
THE PROGRAM AS THEY SHOULD BE.
03:58:27.860 --> 03:58:28.961
SECOND IS THE RELATIONSHIP
03:58:29.028 --> 03:58:30.396
BETWEEN FACULTY AND STUDENT
03:58:30.462 --> 03:58:31.897
THERE WAS REQUIRED SICKNESS
03:58:31.964 --> 03:58:34.466
FACE TO FACE INSTRUCTION WHICH
03:58:34.533 --> 03:58:36.168
DOES NOT OCCUR IN THE
03:58:36.235 --> 03:58:39.038
COUNTERPART ORGANIZATION. AS
03:58:39.104 --> 03:58:39.605
WELL AS THE REQUIREMENT PER
03:58:39.672 --> 03:58:41.974
STUDENT THIS. TO COLLABORATION
03:58:42.041 --> 03:58:43.575
REQUIRE COLLAB WORK IN STUDENTS
03:58:43.642 --> 03:58:44.877
TO ME ALL. OF TIME WEEK TO FACE
03:58:44.943 --> 03:58:46.445
AS WELL MOST IMPORTANTLY I
03:58:46.512 --> 03:58:48.547
SHOULD STATE. THAT THE COST OF
03:58:48.614 --> 03:58:51.984
LAUNCHING I COME ACADEMY IS
03:58:52.051 --> 03:58:52.718
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
03:58:52.785 --> 03:58:55.421
LESS THAN 1% AND I REITERATE.
03:58:55.487 --> 03:58:56.889
THAN 1% OF THE INVESTMENT PUT
03:58:56.955 --> 03:58:59.091
IN CALPERS. WE COULD DO A LOT
03:58:59.158 --> 03:59:00.225
MORE TO. COME TO SUPPORT
03:59:00.292 --> 03:59:02.227
STUDENTS. PORT THE EXPANSION IT
03:59:02.294 --> 03:59:04.196
IS THAT YOU CATION BY REINVEST
03:59:04.263 --> 03:59:05.964
THAT FUNDING IN EXISTING
03:59:06.031 --> 03:59:07.800
DISTRICTS THAT ARE. AIMING TO
03:59:07.866 --> 03:59:09.501
EXPAND DISTANCE EDUCATION
03:59:09.568 --> 03:59:11.570
OPPORTUNITIES. FOR THEIR
03:59:11.637 --> 03:59:12.404
STUDENTS THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
03:59:12.471 --> 03:59:13.706
ALSO OVER THE STATE OUT OF
03:59:13.772 --> 03:59:15.474
PRESIDENT PLEASE YOU. THANK YOU
03:59:15.541 --> 03:59:17.676
MISTER CHAIR VERY QUICKLY. AS
03:59:17.743 --> 03:59:19.945
ASSEMBLYMEMBER. INTO LOOKING AT
03:59:20.012 --> 03:59:24.316
CAP RIGHT. FIRST OF GIVE IS
03:59:24.383 --> 03:59:27.319
ASKING A TO I BY. STUDENTS IN.
03:59:27.386 --> 03:59:28.387
IN THE OFFER AND VARIOUS PER.
03:59:28.454 --> 03:59:29.288
THAT ARE OF THROUGH CAL BREAK
03:59:29.354 --> 03:59:30.422
ASKING US FOR SOME DEMO. AND
03:59:30.489 --> 03:59:31.557
REAL ARE RELATED TO ETHNIC
03:59:31.623 --> 03:59:34.193
DIVERSITY AGE INCOME THEIR
03:59:34.259 --> 03:59:34.827
REASONS FOR ENROLLING DID THEY
03:59:34.893 --> 03:59:36.729
HAVE OTHER OPTIONS OR WAS THIS
03:59:36.795 --> 03:59:39.698
THEIR BEST OPTION. ALSO WHETHER
03:59:39.765 --> 03:59:40.566
OR NOT THE STUDENTS ARE
03:59:40.632 --> 03:59:42.868
ACTUALLY PROGRESSING AND IN THE
03:59:42.935 --> 03:59:44.737
VARIOUS COURSES AND PROGRAMS.
03:59:44.803 --> 03:59:46.071
WITH RESPECT TO THERE ARE
03:59:46.138 --> 03:59:48.006
CERTAIN KEY MILESTONES AND THE
03:59:48.073 --> 03:59:49.374
ACT IT'S CALLED THE CALIFORNIA
03:59:49.441 --> 03:59:51.610
ONLINE COMMUTER COLLEGE ACT. ON
03:59:51.677 --> 03:59:53.178
AND HE'S ASKING US TO EVALUATE
03:59:53.245 --> 03:59:54.313
THEIR EFFORTS IN ACHIEVING
03:59:54.379 --> 03:59:56.048
THOSE KEY MILESTONES THAT FIRST
03:59:56.115 --> 03:59:57.950
ONE IS ACCREDITATION. ON THE
03:59:58.016 --> 03:59:59.351
SECOND ONE IS RELATED TO
03:59:59.418 --> 04:00:00.919
FACILITATING INTERNSHIPS AND
04:00:00.986 --> 04:00:02.321
JOB PLACEMENTS WORKING WITH
04:00:02.387 --> 04:00:04.189
EMPLOYERS AND INDUSTRY GROUPS.
04:00:04.256 --> 04:00:04.923
TO GET THE STUDENTS
04:00:04.990 --> 04:00:06.925
OPPORTUNITIES TO SERVE IN AN
04:00:06.992 --> 04:00:08.527
INTERNSHIP WHICH HOPEFULLY
04:00:08.594 --> 04:00:10.729
TRANSLATES INTO A JOB. ALSO ARE
04:00:10.796 --> 04:00:12.598
THEY ARE PREPARING TO RECEIVE
04:00:12.664 --> 04:00:14.133
AND EDUCATE STUDENTS WHO ARE
04:00:14.199 --> 04:00:15.901
THEY RECRUITING FACULTY. ARE
04:00:15.968 --> 04:00:18.403
AND QUALIFIED FACULTY TO SERVE
04:00:18.470 --> 04:00:21.306
THE STUDENTS- THE OTHER.
04:00:21.373 --> 04:00:22.341
OBJECTIVES ARE RELATED TO
04:00:22.407 --> 04:00:24.443
OUTREACH- WHAT EFFORTS HAVE
04:00:24.510 --> 04:00:26.712
THEY- ARE ENGAGED IN TO REACH
04:00:26.779 --> 04:00:28.814
OUT TO THE TYPES OF STUDENTS
04:00:28.881 --> 04:00:30.716
THAT THIS. TYPE OF ONLINE OUR
04:00:30.783 --> 04:00:31.984
COMMUNITY COLLEGE WAS INTENDED
04:00:32.050 --> 04:00:33.786
TO SERVE ARE THEY MEETING THEIR
04:00:33.852 --> 04:00:36.955
ENROLLMENT GOALS- ALSO- WITH
04:00:37.022 --> 04:00:38.957
RESPECT TO DUPLICATION. HE'S
04:00:39.024 --> 04:00:39.992
ASKED US TO LOOK AT THEIR
04:00:40.058 --> 04:00:41.927
PROGRAMS AND COURSES AND
04:00:41.994 --> 04:00:43.862
COMPARE THOSE TO A SELECTION OF
04:00:43.929 --> 04:00:46.431
COMMUNITY COLLEGE ONLINE.
04:00:46.498 --> 04:00:47.666
PROGRAMS AND DETERMINE THERE
04:00:47.733 --> 04:00:49.468
ARE NOT THEY ARE IN FACT CLICK
04:00:49.535 --> 04:00:54.773
IF. AND THE FINAL CUT OF. CAR
04:00:54.840 --> 04:00:57.309
YOU CAN SHOW THAT. ALBRIGHT
04:00:57.376 --> 04:00:58.310
COLLEGE IS COMPLY WITH LAWS IN
04:00:58.377 --> 04:00:59.111
RAGS WITH RESPECT EMPLOYMENT
04:00:59.178 --> 04:01:00.445
PER TO THE TIP THINGS AS A AND
04:01:00.512 --> 04:01:01.747
THAT'S UP AND THEN THE
04:01:01.814 --> 04:01:03.015
EFFICIENCY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF
04:01:03.081 --> 04:01:04.249
HOW THEY'RE USING THEIR
04:01:04.316 --> 04:01:06.685
RESOURCES- AND COMPARING THAT
04:01:06.752 --> 04:01:08.420
THE ONLINE PROGRAMS THAT
04:01:08.487 --> 04:01:10.088
CALIBRATE HAS TWO OTHER
04:01:10.155 --> 04:01:11.323
COMMUNITY COLLEGES IN
04:01:11.390 --> 04:01:12.591
CALIFORNIA AND THEN FINALLY
04:01:12.658 --> 04:01:14.326
LOOKING AT A SAMPLE OR
04:01:14.393 --> 04:01:16.495
SELECTION OF SOME EXPENDITURES
04:01:16.562 --> 04:01:17.930
FOR REASONABLE NESS AND
04:01:17.996 --> 04:01:18.864
APPROPRIATENESS THE USE OF
04:01:18.931 --> 04:01:20.332
THOSE FUNDS- THE BUDGET TO
04:01:20.399 --> 04:01:22.034
START IT'S ABOUT TWENTY EIGHT
04:01:22.100 --> 04:01:22.601
HUNDRED HOURS AGAIN THAT'S
04:01:22.668 --> 04:01:24.436
ABOUT A SEVEN MONTH THOUGHT IT.
04:01:24.503 --> 04:01:25.971
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR. THANK
04:01:26.038 --> 04:01:26.939
YOU AT THIS TIME OF GOING TO
04:01:27.005 --> 04:01:32.044
MOVE TO THE AFFECTED AGENCIES.
04:01:32.110 --> 04:01:45.757
THE. GOOD AFTERNOON. CHAIRMAN
04:01:45.824 --> 04:01:48.594
SALAS INVASIVE AT CHRISTMAS
04:01:48.660 --> 04:01:50.362
ROTH IS IN HERE MET UP MEMBERS
04:01:50.429 --> 04:01:51.964
OF THE COMMITTEE- LEASE THAT
04:01:52.030 --> 04:01:53.332
STATE YOUR NAME I AM ALSO FOR
04:01:53.398 --> 04:01:56.168
THAT'S MY NEXT LINE THANK. I'M
04:01:56.235 --> 04:01:56.735
TIME IT'S NINE PRESENT BOARD
04:01:56.802 --> 04:02:00.939
CHEST OF A CABARET CABA. AND
04:02:01.006 --> 04:02:04.943
THIS IS. SORRY THEIR CHOICE SIR
04:02:05.010 --> 04:02:06.378
CHIEF FINANCIAL BOB OF CAP
04:02:06.445 --> 04:02:09.915
BROUGHT AND GET OKAY. BUT WE
04:02:09.982 --> 04:02:10.482
WELCOME THE OPPORTUNITY TO
04:02:10.549 --> 04:02:11.316
ADDRESS THIS REQUEST FOR NOT OF
04:02:11.383 --> 04:02:12.851
CAL AND EXPLAIN THE PROGRESS
04:02:12.918 --> 04:02:14.353
WE'VE MADE SO FAR. WE SHARE THE
04:02:14.419 --> 04:02:16.188
DESIRE OF ASSEMBLYMAN MEMBER
04:02:16.255 --> 04:02:18.423
MEDINA TO ENSURE THE CAB RIGHT
04:02:18.490 --> 04:02:19.992
IS OPERATING IN AN EFFECTIVE
04:02:20.058 --> 04:02:21.093
AND TRANSPARENT MANNER WE
04:02:21.159 --> 04:02:22.427
WELCOME YOUR SUGGESTIONS ABOUT
04:02:22.494 --> 04:02:24.096
HOW WE CAN BETTER ACHIEVE OUR
04:02:24.162 --> 04:02:25.731
MISSION OR IMPROVE OUR METHODS.
04:02:25.797 --> 04:02:27.466
RESPECTFULLY THOUGH WE FEEL AN
04:02:27.532 --> 04:02:29.434
AUDIT IS PREMATURE AND ITS
04:02:29.501 --> 04:02:31.737
SCOPE COVERS MANY AREAS WHICH
04:02:31.803 --> 04:02:32.871
CALIBRATED STILL DEVELOPING AND
04:02:32.938 --> 04:02:34.740
TESTING AS A RESULT WE GOT
04:02:34.806 --> 04:02:35.874
WE'RE CRESCENT OPPORTUNITY TO
04:02:35.941 --> 04:02:36.808
WORK WITH THE COMMITTEE AND THE
04:02:36.875 --> 04:02:38.210
LEGISLATORS TO ASK FOR THE
04:02:38.277 --> 04:02:41.580
AUDIT. TO MODIFY ITS TIMING AND
04:02:41.647 --> 04:02:43.515
SCOPE. WE'RE STILL IN THE VERY
04:02:43.582 --> 04:02:45.117
EARLY STAGES OF LAUNCHING THIS
04:02:45.183 --> 04:02:47.119
COLLEGE CABARET WAS ANNOUNCED
04:02:47.185 --> 04:02:48.453
TO THE PUBLIC ONLY LAST MAN
04:02:48.520 --> 04:02:50.122
BEGAN ACCEPTING APPLICANTS FOR
04:02:50.188 --> 04:02:52.090
ADMISSION IN OCTOBER. WE HAVE
04:02:52.157 --> 04:02:53.625
ONLY FOR ME FORTY PERMANENT
04:02:53.692 --> 04:02:54.726
EMPLOYEES AND OF SPENT A SMALL
04:02:54.793 --> 04:02:55.694
FRACTION OF OUR INITIAL
04:02:55.761 --> 04:02:58.897
ALLOCATION. WE ARE PLEASED THAT
04:02:58.964 --> 04:02:59.531
MORE THAN FIVE HUNDRED STUDENTS
04:02:59.598 --> 04:03:00.933
AND HAVE ENROLLED AND LET ME
04:03:00.999 --> 04:03:03.068
JUST- RESPOND TO ONE OF THE
04:03:03.135 --> 04:03:04.002
COMMENTS EARLIER THE NOTION
04:03:04.069 --> 04:03:06.305
THAT WE'RE SPENDING A THOUSAND
04:03:06.371 --> 04:03:08.407
TIMES MORE PER STUDENT IS
04:03:08.473 --> 04:03:10.776
REALLY NOT CREDIBLE GIVEN. THE
04:03:10.842 --> 04:03:12.277
EARLY STAGES THAT WE ARE IN IN
04:03:12.344 --> 04:03:14.046
THE FACT THAT WITH THE- THIS IS
04:03:14.112 --> 04:03:16.381
JUST A PILOT OF AN INITIAL.
04:03:16.448 --> 04:03:17.849
COHORT OF STUDENTS THAT WE'RE
04:03:17.916 --> 04:03:19.851
JUST LEARNING FROM. A THIS
04:03:19.918 --> 04:03:20.919
PILOT GROUP WILL HELP US
04:03:20.986 --> 04:03:22.554
IMPROVE OUR CURRICULUM SUPPORT
04:03:22.621 --> 04:03:24.623
SERVICES AND TECHNOLOGY BEFORE
04:03:24.690 --> 04:03:25.190
WE EXPAND MORE BROADLY THIS
04:03:25.257 --> 04:03:27.359
SUMMER. WE BELIEVE IT WOULD BE
04:03:27.426 --> 04:03:29.194
FAR MORE FRUITFUL. TO AUDIT
04:03:29.261 --> 04:03:30.662
CALIBRATE AFTER THE START UP
04:03:30.729 --> 04:03:32.297
PHASE HAS BEEN COMPLETED AND
04:03:32.364 --> 04:03:34.066
THE RESULTS CAN BE EVALUATED.
04:03:34.132 --> 04:03:35.567
TODAY WE MET ALL THE MILESTONES
04:03:35.634 --> 04:03:36.868
REQUIREMENTS LAID OUT FOR THE
04:03:36.935 --> 04:03:37.769
COLLEGE IN THE AUTHORIZING
04:03:37.836 --> 04:03:40.205
LEGISLATION. WE ARE CRIER TO
04:03:40.272 --> 04:03:41.573
BEGIN ENROLLING STUDENTS BY THE
04:03:41.640 --> 04:03:43.141
END OF Q. FOUR LAST YEAR AND
04:03:43.208 --> 04:03:44.242
ACCOMPLISH THAT GOAL THREE
04:03:44.309 --> 04:03:45.777
MONTHS EARLY. WE ARE REQUIRED
04:03:45.844 --> 04:03:47.446
TO HAVE THREE PROGRAM PATHWAYS
04:03:47.512 --> 04:03:49.147
IN PLACE WITHIN TWO YEARS OF
04:03:49.214 --> 04:03:50.882
OPENING OUR DOORS. BUT WE'RE
04:03:50.949 --> 04:03:54.052
ABLE TO SUPPORT THAT. AT OUR
04:03:54.119 --> 04:03:54.987
LAUNCH A FEW MONTHS AGO. WE
04:03:55.053 --> 04:03:57.889
ALSO HAD A CLEAN EXTERNAL AUDIT.
04:03:57.956 --> 04:03:59.191
LAST WE'RE WORKING DILIGENTLY
04:03:59.257 --> 04:04:00.425
WITH OUR PARTNERS IN THE STATE
04:04:00.492 --> 04:04:01.860
ACADEMIC SENATE TO QUICKLY HIRE
04:04:01.927 --> 04:04:03.261
FACULTY POSITIONS AND PLAN TO
04:04:03.328 --> 04:04:05.197
FINALIZE THE TIRES IN THE
04:04:05.263 --> 04:04:06.565
COMING MNTHS THE ACADEMIC
04:04:06.631 --> 04:04:07.532
SENATE'S LEADERSHIP HAS
04:04:07.599 --> 04:04:09.701
TESTIFIED PUBLICLY THAT THEY
04:04:09.768 --> 04:04:10.669
ARE PLEASED WITH OUR CURRENT
04:04:10.736 --> 04:04:12.971
PROGRESS. NOT WITHSTANDING
04:04:13.038 --> 04:04:14.773
THOSE SUCCESSES WE RECOGNIZE
04:04:14.840 --> 04:04:16.508
THERE WERE CONCERNS ABOUT THE
04:04:16.575 --> 04:04:17.442
INITIAL LEADERSHIP TEAM AND CAL
04:04:17.509 --> 04:04:19.344
RIGHT. I'M PLEASED TO SHARE
04:04:19.411 --> 04:04:21.013
WITH YOU TODAY THE CALVERTS NEW
04:04:21.079 --> 04:04:23.648
INTERIM CEO A G. TO TELL WALKER
04:04:23.715 --> 04:04:25.951
MEN AND STARTS TODAY. MS MEN
04:04:26.018 --> 04:04:27.452
AND LED THE ADVANCE TEAM THAT
04:04:27.519 --> 04:04:28.653
IMPLEMENTED THE LEGISLATION
04:04:28.720 --> 04:04:29.755
CREATING CALIBRATE AND HAS A
04:04:29.821 --> 04:04:31.056
DEEP COMMITMENT TO THE MISSION
04:04:31.123 --> 04:04:32.724
OF THE INSTITUTION. SHE SERVED
04:04:32.791 --> 04:04:33.959
AS A KEY HIGHER EDUCATION
04:04:34.026 --> 04:04:35.260
ADVISER IN THE OBAMA WHITE
04:04:35.327 --> 04:04:36.962
HOUSE AND THE US DEPARTMENT OF
04:04:37.029 --> 04:04:38.730
EDUCATION AS WELL AS ROLESIN
04:04:38.797 --> 04:04:40.265
CONGRESS AND NONPROFIT
04:04:40.332 --> 04:04:40.999
ORGANIZATIONS THAT HELP
04:04:41.066 --> 04:04:43.769
STUDENTS. AS INTERIM CEO SHE'S
04:04:43.835 --> 04:04:44.803
LOOKING FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
04:04:44.870 --> 04:04:45.337
THE LEGISLATURE AND
04:04:45.404 --> 04:04:47.039
STAKEHOLDERS AS WE CONTINUE
04:04:47.105 --> 04:04:48.073
BUILDING CALIBRATE FROM THE
04:04:48.140 --> 04:04:50.242
GROUND UP. SHE UNDERSTANDS THE
04:04:50.308 --> 04:04:51.576
CONCERNS HAVE BEEN RAISED ABOUT
04:04:51.643 --> 04:04:53.645
HOW BRIGHT AND WILL DEFINITELY
04:04:53.712 --> 04:04:55.113
TAKE THOSE CONCERNS TO HEART.
04:04:55.180 --> 04:04:56.848
THEREFORE WE RESPECTFULLY ASK
04:04:56.915 --> 04:04:58.417
THE COMMITTEE TO GIVE SERIOUS
04:04:58.483 --> 04:05:00.085
CONSIDERATION TO I REQUEST THAT
04:05:00.152 --> 04:05:02.587
THIS AUDIT BE DELAYED. IF IT IS
04:05:02.654 --> 04:05:04.056
WE PROMISE TO WORK HAND IN HAND
04:05:04.122 --> 04:05:04.823
WITH THIS COMMITTEE AND
04:05:04.890 --> 04:05:06.024
INTERESTED MEMBERS OF THE
04:05:06.091 --> 04:05:07.459
LEGISLATURE. TO PROVIDE ANY
04:05:07.526 --> 04:05:09.094
INFORMATION THAT IS NECESSARY
04:05:09.161 --> 04:05:10.495
FOR YOUR GUIDANCE AND OVERSIGHT
04:05:10.562 --> 04:05:13.765
OF COUNT RIGHT. THANK YOU.
04:05:13.832 --> 04:05:15.400
THANK YOU. KAYLA THIS TIME WAS
04:05:15.467 --> 04:05:16.902
GONNA MOVE TO QUESTIONS AND
04:05:16.968 --> 04:05:19.704
ANSWERS. QUESTIONS COMMENTS
04:05:19.771 --> 04:05:21.473
FROM- MEMBERS OF THE DíAS MR
04:05:21.540 --> 04:05:25.077
DATA IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT.
04:05:25.143 --> 04:05:26.545
YOU'D LIKE TO PROCEED WITH THIS
04:05:26.611 --> 04:05:28.613
AUDIT REQUEST CONTINGENT ON TWO
04:05:28.680 --> 04:05:31.249
FACTORS ONE IS A CONTINGENT
04:05:31.316 --> 04:05:32.217
THAT THERE'S FUNDING IN THE
04:05:32.284 --> 04:05:33.552
BUDGET FOR CALIBRATED WILL
04:05:33.618 --> 04:05:35.587
CONTINUE TO MOVE FORWARD AND AS
04:05:35.654 --> 04:05:37.189
SUCH A DELAYING THE AUDITOR
04:05:37.255 --> 04:05:38.423
LOOKING AT THIS REQUEST UNTIL
04:05:38.490 --> 04:05:40.792
AFTER JULY FIRST SO THAT WE
04:05:40.859 --> 04:05:41.393
KNOW WHAT THE BUDGET ACTION IS
04:05:41.460 --> 04:05:45.130
AN- AND- THIS. THIS HOUSE I
04:05:45.197 --> 04:05:47.232
WOULD I WOULD SAY THAT THAT.
04:05:47.299 --> 04:05:49.101
BRING IN THIS AUDIT FORWARD WAS
04:05:49.167 --> 04:05:51.336
TO MAKE BEST USE OF THE STATE'S
04:05:51.403 --> 04:05:53.939
OF LIMITED RESOURCES. HAVE
04:05:54.005 --> 04:05:56.408
SALAH I AM VERY AWARE OF THE
04:05:56.475 --> 04:05:57.943
HEARING THAT THE SENATE HAD-
04:05:58.009 --> 04:06:01.079
JUST- LAST WEEK CORRECT- AND
04:06:01.146 --> 04:06:04.516
THE- QUESTIONS OR- THE- TO ME
04:06:04.583 --> 04:06:06.918
A- WATCHING IT YOU KNOW THE
04:06:06.985 --> 04:06:10.155
LACK. OF CAL RIGHT ACTUALLY-
04:06:10.222 --> 04:06:11.623
BEING ABLE TO PROVIDE THE
04:06:11.690 --> 04:06:14.092
INFORMATION BUT I DO REALIZE
04:06:14.159 --> 04:06:17.329
THAT THAT THEIR- BEEN IN
04:06:17.395 --> 04:06:19.030
OPERATION FOR PERHAPS A SHORT
04:06:19.097 --> 04:06:21.133
AMOUNT OF TIME. I THINK IT IS
04:06:21.199 --> 04:06:22.134
IN THE INTEREST OF THE
04:06:22.200 --> 04:06:24.069
LEGISLATURE- THEREFORE TO VERY
04:06:24.136 --> 04:06:26.805
NOT VERY MUCH NO- HOW THEY'RE
04:06:26.872 --> 04:06:28.306
DOING BUT I WOULD NOT BE
04:06:28.373 --> 04:06:33.078
OPPOSED TO- DELAYING- THE
04:06:33.145 --> 04:06:35.780
AUDIT. IN IN THE SEQUENCE OF
04:06:35.847 --> 04:06:37.482
THE OF THE AUDITS AS YOU
04:06:37.549 --> 04:06:39.284
SUGGEST THANK YOU THANK YOU
04:06:39.351 --> 04:06:41.586
MISTER- MEDINA APPRECIATE THAT
04:06:41.653 --> 04:06:45.524
OKAY HEARING NO QUESTIONS FROM
04:06:45.590 --> 04:06:46.591
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
04:06:46.658 --> 04:06:48.193
HEARING AND SEEING ON LET'S GO
04:06:48.260 --> 04:06:51.396
TO MOVE TO PUBLIC COMMENT. I'M
04:06:51.463 --> 04:06:53.732
SORRY WAS OUR QUESTION. BUT
04:06:53.798 --> 04:06:58.103
ALSO TO PUBLIC COMMENT PLEASE.
04:06:58.170 --> 04:06:59.037
GOOD AFTERNOON STEPHANIE
04:06:59.104 --> 04:07:00.205
GOLDMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
04:07:00.272 --> 04:07:01.473
FACULTY ASSOCIATION OF THE
04:07:01.540 --> 04:07:03.108
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES
04:07:03.175 --> 04:07:04.643
PROUD TO CO SPONSOR THIS AUDIT
04:07:04.709 --> 04:07:06.211
WE'VE SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT
04:07:06.278 --> 04:07:07.879
THE DUPLICATION OF PROGRAMS AND
04:07:07.946 --> 04:07:09.181
ALSO THE USE OF THE HUNDRED
04:07:09.247 --> 04:07:09.714
FORTY MILLION DOLLARS IN
04:07:09.781 --> 04:07:11.750
FUNDING. I'D ALSO LIKE TO ADD
04:07:11.816 --> 04:07:12.751
THAT THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
04:07:12.817 --> 04:07:13.885
COLLEGE INDEPENDENCE CAN BE
04:07:13.952 --> 04:07:16.121
HERE TODAY BUT THEY ASKED ME TO
04:07:16.188 --> 04:07:17.155
SHARE THEIR ALSO PART BECAUSE
04:07:17.222 --> 04:07:19.457
ON TO THIS THANK YOU. DOES YOUR
04:07:19.524 --> 04:07:20.158
MEMBERS BRIAN HOW THE
04:07:20.225 --> 04:07:21.293
CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF
04:07:21.359 --> 04:07:22.661
TEACHERS WE REALLY APPRECIATE
04:07:22.727 --> 04:07:24.729
THIS REQUEST AND- WITH THE PORT
04:07:24.796 --> 04:07:25.630
WHAT CODES COMMITTEE AND THE
04:07:25.697 --> 04:07:26.865
AND ALONG WITH THE MEMBER.
04:07:26.932 --> 04:07:30.902
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
04:07:30.969 --> 04:07:32.037
HEARING AND SEEING NO
04:07:32.103 --> 04:07:33.138
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC I'LL RETURN
04:07:33.205 --> 04:07:35.707
IT BACK TO THE DíAS- DO I HAVE
04:07:35.774 --> 04:07:39.444
A MOTION TO APPROVE SOME OF
04:07:39.511 --> 04:07:41.179
EVER MEDINA IS I REQUEST WITH
04:07:41.246 --> 04:07:42.581
THE DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION
04:07:42.647 --> 04:07:44.482
UNTIL JULY ONE CONTINGENT ON
04:07:44.549 --> 04:07:46.251
THE FACT THAT IT'S CONTINUE TO
04:07:46.318 --> 04:07:47.886
BE FUNDED IN THE STATE BUDGET.
04:07:47.953 --> 04:07:48.987
SO WILL BY ASSEMBLY WILL
04:07:49.054 --> 04:07:50.322
BOERNER HORVATH TO HAVE A
04:07:50.388 --> 04:07:52.924
SECOND SEC BY MISTER VOEPEL
04:07:52.991 --> 04:08:01.299
PROJECT CALDERON. DR A
04:08:01.366 --> 04:08:06.605
CONTINGENT ON. THE MOTION IS TO
04:08:06.671 --> 04:08:08.506
APPROVE ATER QUEST TWENTY
04:08:08.573 --> 04:08:09.741
TWENTY DASH ONE OH FOUR
04:08:09.808 --> 04:08:11.176
CALIBRATE COLLEGE BY ASSEMBLY
04:08:11.243 --> 04:08:16.047
MEMBER MEDINA- WITH THE MOTION
04:08:16.114 --> 04:08:18.650
IS TO APPROVE THE AUTO REQUEST
04:08:18.717 --> 04:08:21.987
BUT DELAYED UNTIL JULY FIRST OF
04:08:22.053 --> 04:08:23.088
TWENTY TWENTY CONTUSION UPON-
04:08:23.154 --> 04:08:25.423
BUDGET FUND FURTHER FINDING OUT
04:08:25.490 --> 04:08:27.092
THE BUDGET WORK OUT RIGHT
04:08:27.158 --> 04:08:29.194
COLLEGE AS A MEMBER SALAS AYE
04:08:29.261 --> 04:08:31.663
SALAS AYE BOERNER HORVATH I
04:08:31.730 --> 04:08:34.833
BOERNER HORVATH HI GEN.
04:08:34.899 --> 04:08:38.937
PATTERSON RUBIO RUBIO AYE
04:08:39.004 --> 04:08:43.775
VOEPEL VOEPEL I WOULD. CENTER
04:08:43.842 --> 04:08:50.248
RAFI. GORGEOUS GONZALEZ.
04:08:50.315 --> 04:08:56.688
HERTZBERGMORNING. MORE LOCKED.
04:08:56.755 --> 04:09:01.192
WIENER. THAT MOTIONS ON CALL
04:09:01.259 --> 04:09:03.194
THANK YOU MISTER DATA THANK YOU
04:09:03.261 --> 04:09:03.962
RIGHT AT THIS TIME WE'RE GONNA
04:09:04.029 --> 04:09:06.431
MOVE TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER%
04:09:06.498 --> 04:09:08.033
FOURTEEN TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE
04:09:08.099 --> 04:09:08.933
OH NINE IN HOME SUPPORTIVE
04:09:09.000 --> 04:09:10.669
SERVICES PROGRAM FUNDING BY
04:09:10.735 --> 04:09:13.171
ASSEMBLY WOMAN BOERNER HORVATH
04:09:13.238 --> 04:09:15.540
ASSEMBLY WOMAN WHEN YOU ARE
04:09:15.607 --> 04:09:34.392
READY TO BEGIN PLEASE BEGIN.
04:09:40.799 --> 04:09:41.399
WHEN YOU'RE READY TO BE IN
04:09:41.466 --> 04:09:42.634
SETTLEMENT WHERE WHERE FOR THE
04:09:42.701 --> 04:09:59.551
WITNESSES. PLEASE. BUT. OKAY.
04:09:59.617 --> 04:10:01.419
SO I'M GOOD MORNING MISTER
04:10:01.486 --> 04:10:02.587
CHAIR MEMBERS I'M HERE TODAY
04:10:02.654 --> 04:10:04.356
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THE JOINT
04:10:04.422 --> 04:10:05.824
LEGISLATIVE AUDIT COMMITTEE
04:10:05.890 --> 04:10:07.092
APPROVE A STATE AUDIT TO
04:10:07.158 --> 04:10:09.160
EXAMINE EXPENDITURE OF STATE
04:10:09.227 --> 04:10:10.362
FUNDS ALLOCATED TO COUNTIES IN
04:10:10.428 --> 04:10:11.796
SUPPORT OF THE IN HOME SUPPORT
04:10:11.863 --> 04:10:14.699
SERVICES I HSS PROGRAM WE ALL
04:10:14.766 --> 04:10:16.468
KNOW OUR STATE ALLOCATES FUNDS-
04:10:16.534 --> 04:10:18.636
ANNUALLY TO SUPPORT AYE HSS
04:10:18.703 --> 04:10:19.871
THAT ARE COMBINED WITH LOCAL
04:10:19.938 --> 04:10:20.972
COUNTY DOLLARS AS WELL AS
04:10:21.039 --> 04:10:22.307
FEDERAL MATCHING FUNDS TO
04:10:22.374 --> 04:10:24.209
PROVIDE IN HOME DOMESTIC AND
04:10:24.275 --> 04:10:25.176
RELATED SERVICES SUCH AS
04:10:25.243 --> 04:10:26.378
HOUSEWORK TRANSPORTATION AND
04:10:26.444 --> 04:10:28.213
PERSONAL CARE SERVICES TO
04:10:28.279 --> 04:10:30.315
ELIGIBLE LOW INCOME AGED BLIND
04:10:30.382 --> 04:10:32.417
AND DISABLED PERSONS. THE GOAL
04:10:32.484 --> 04:10:33.818
OF THE PROGRAM IS TO PROGRAMS
04:10:33.885 --> 04:10:35.220
TO HELP INDIVIDUALS MEET REMAIN
04:10:35.286 --> 04:10:37.255
IN THEIR HOME AND PREVENT MORE
04:10:37.322 --> 04:10:39.224
COSTLY INSTITUTIONALIZATION
04:10:39.290 --> 04:10:40.859
HOWEVER IT IS ABUNDANTLY CLEAR
04:10:40.925 --> 04:10:42.227
THERE'S A SORT SHORTAGE OF
04:10:42.293 --> 04:10:43.695
PROVIDERS THROUGHOUT THE STATE
04:10:43.762 --> 04:10:44.796
WITH THE PROBLEM BEING MORE
04:10:44.863 --> 04:10:47.098
CUTE CONCERNED COUNTIES SOME
04:10:47.165 --> 04:10:49.267
HAVE ATTRIBUTED THE PROBLEM TO
04:10:49.334 --> 04:10:51.403
THE LESS COMPETITIVE WAGE BEING
04:10:51.469 --> 04:10:53.138
OFFERED AND THE LACK OF
04:10:53.204 --> 04:10:55.774
BENEFITS OF A JUMBO PROVIDERS.
04:10:55.840 --> 04:10:58.543
THE OTHERS APPOINT A- TO THE-
04:10:58.610 --> 04:10:59.177
IN LENGTH OF TIME IT TAKES FOR
04:10:59.244 --> 04:11:01.312
TO BE APPROVED. AT HSS PROVIDE
04:11:01.379 --> 04:11:04.015
AS I AGES AS PER. WITH AN
04:11:04.082 --> 04:11:05.550
AVERAGE WE TIME OF SIX FOR
04:11:05.617 --> 04:11:07.185
PROVIDER TO RECEIVE THEIR FIRST
04:11:07.252 --> 04:11:08.386
TIME SHE'D LET ALONE THE FIRST
04:11:08.453 --> 04:11:10.822
PAYCHECK. I DON'T KNOW ABOUT
04:11:10.889 --> 04:11:11.589
YOU BUT I COULDN'T DEAL WITH
04:11:11.656 --> 04:11:13.625
THAT. THE SHORTAGE IS ONLY
04:11:13.691 --> 04:11:14.826
GOING TO GROW WORSE AND WITH
04:11:14.893 --> 04:11:16.928
THE COMING SUMMER TSUNAMI THE
04:11:16.995 --> 04:11:17.695
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE ESTIMATES
04:11:17.762 --> 04:11:19.998
THAT OVER. THE NEXT FORTY YEARS
04:11:20.064 --> 04:11:22.066
OUR STATE SIXTY FIVE OF THOSE
04:11:22.133 --> 04:11:24.569
OVER SIXTY FIVE YEARS AND OLDER
04:11:24.636 --> 04:11:26.037
FOR INCREASED FROM FIVE POINT
04:11:26.104 --> 04:11:28.072
FIVE MILLION TO THIRTEEN POINT
04:11:28.139 --> 04:11:31.142
FIVE MILLION. BY TWENTY SIXTY.
04:11:31.209 --> 04:11:31.876
WITH THAT IN MIND I AM
04:11:31.943 --> 04:11:33.378
REQUESTING THE APPROVAL OF THE
04:11:33.445 --> 04:11:35.880
STATE ORDER TO LOOK AT WHETHER
04:11:35.947 --> 04:11:36.481
COUNTIES ARE MAXIMIZING THESE
04:11:36.548 --> 04:11:38.116
FUNDS TO ENSURE. THE MOST
04:11:38.183 --> 04:11:41.019
ROBUST SUPPLY. OF IHS WORKER I
04:11:41.085 --> 04:11:43.855
EACH AS AS WORKERS POSSIBLE
04:11:43.922 --> 04:11:44.989
INCLUDING PROVIDING WAGES THAT
04:11:45.056 --> 04:11:46.624
PREVENT ATTRITION WERE
04:11:46.691 --> 04:11:48.660
POSSIBLE. SPECIFICALLY I'D LIKE
04:11:48.726 --> 04:11:49.461
TO REQUEST THE STATE ORDER OF
04:11:49.527 --> 04:11:50.995
VALUE AND SELECTION OF FOR
04:11:51.062 --> 04:11:52.664
COUNTIES. OF VARYING
04:11:52.730 --> 04:11:54.866
POPULATIONS REGION'S URBAN
04:11:54.933 --> 04:11:56.301
RURAL MAX AND PROVIDER
04:11:56.367 --> 04:11:57.936
CONTRACTS STATUS IN THEIR
04:11:58.002 --> 04:12:00.004
ADMINISTRATION OF I. H. S. S.
04:12:00.071 --> 04:12:01.172
FUNDING WITH THE FOLLOWING
04:12:01.239 --> 04:12:02.941
QUESTIONS IN MIND. OUR COUNTY
04:12:03.007 --> 04:12:05.510
IS FULLY EXPANDING THEIR HSS
04:12:05.577 --> 04:12:07.946
DOLLARS OR FUNDS BEING LEFT ON
04:12:08.012 --> 04:12:09.948
SPENT ON AN ANNUAL BASIS. WHAT
04:12:10.014 --> 04:12:11.316
PERCENT OF THE FUNDS ARE BEING
04:12:11.382 --> 04:12:12.750
ALLOCATED DIRECTLY TO PROVIDER
04:12:12.817 --> 04:12:15.954
WAGES AND BENEFITS. HOW ARE AYE
04:12:16.020 --> 04:12:17.922
HSS FUNDS STATE FEDERAL COUNTY.
04:12:17.989 --> 04:12:20.258
ACCOUNTED FOR AND TRACKED IN
04:12:20.325 --> 04:12:22.627
THE COUNTY BUDGETING PROCESS.
04:12:22.694 --> 04:12:24.562
OUR AYE AGES AS FUNDS BEING
04:12:24.629 --> 04:12:26.531
USED FOR ANYTHING OTHER THAN I
04:12:26.598 --> 04:12:28.199
AGENTS AS PROVIDER WAGES AND
04:12:28.266 --> 04:12:30.468
DIRECT ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS FOR
04:12:30.535 --> 04:12:32.070
THE PROGRAM. THE COUNTY LEVEL
04:12:32.136 --> 04:12:33.872
IF SO WHERE THOSE FOLKS GOING
04:12:33.938 --> 04:12:37.675
TOWARD THEM WHY. ARE THE NUMBER
04:12:37.742 --> 04:12:39.310
OF I. PROVIDERS INCREASING OR
04:12:39.377 --> 04:12:40.478
DE. WITHIN THE COUNTY AT WHAT
04:12:40.545 --> 04:12:42.347
RATE. WHAT IS THE SHORTAGE FOR
04:12:42.413 --> 04:12:43.815
EACH COUNTY IN TERMS OF HSS
04:12:43.882 --> 04:12:46.584
PROVIDER PROVIDER HOURS NEED TO
04:12:46.651 --> 04:12:48.586
MEET EXISTING DEMANDS. WHAT IS
04:12:48.653 --> 04:12:49.921
THE AVERAGE MINIMUM WAGE FOR
04:12:49.988 --> 04:12:50.788
EACH COUNTY AND HOW DOES IT
04:12:50.855 --> 04:12:53.124
COMPARED TO THE I. H. AS AS
04:12:53.191 --> 04:12:55.093
PROVIDER RATE FOR THAT COUNTY
04:12:55.159 --> 04:12:56.160
AND HOW DOES IT COMPARE THE
04:12:56.227 --> 04:12:58.162
COST OF LIVING. WITHIN THAT
04:12:58.229 --> 04:12:59.964
COUNTY. WHAT ARE THE CHALLENGES
04:13:00.031 --> 04:13:01.866
WITH THING IHS PROVIDER WAGES
04:13:01.933 --> 04:13:03.768
IN EACH COUNTY WHAT IS THE%
04:13:03.835 --> 04:13:05.403
ESTIMATED COSTS FOR RECRUITING
04:13:05.470 --> 04:13:06.804
AND TRAINING NEW PROVIDERS.
04:13:06.871 --> 04:13:08.773
WHAT IS ESTIMATED IMPACT IN
04:13:08.840 --> 04:13:10.208
EACH COUNTY OF LOW WAGE
04:13:10.275 --> 04:13:12.544
BENEFITS ON ABILITY OF IHS
04:13:12.610 --> 04:13:14.245
CONSUMERS. TO RECRUIT AND
04:13:14.312 --> 04:13:16.147
RETAIN I JUST PROVIDERS WITH A
04:13:16.214 --> 04:13:17.682
SPECIAL EMPHASIS ON CONSUMERS
04:13:17.749 --> 04:13:19.217
WITHOUT FAMILY SUPPORT THAT'S A
04:13:19.284 --> 04:13:21.419
VERY BIG ISSUE. WHAT IF
04:13:21.486 --> 04:13:23.555
ANYTHING A ONE OF ANY HAS BEEN
04:13:23.621 --> 04:13:25.890
THE IMPACT OF THE TIMELINE FOR
04:13:25.957 --> 04:13:26.591
NEW PROVIDERS TO BECOME
04:13:26.658 --> 04:13:28.893
ENROLLED. IN AYE AGE INTO AYE
04:13:28.960 --> 04:13:30.662
HSS RECEIVE THEIR FIRST TIME
04:13:30.728 --> 04:13:32.864
SHEET. WITH ME TODAY IN SUPPORT
04:13:32.931 --> 04:13:34.465
OUR CRISTINA BASS HAMILTON
04:13:34.532 --> 04:13:36.401
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR FOR UNITED
04:13:36.467 --> 04:13:37.201
DOMESTIC WORKERS AND MARKETS
04:13:37.268 --> 04:13:39.671
RUBIO A U. D. W. MEMBER. AND I
04:13:39.737 --> 04:13:41.739
HSS PROVIDER FROM BAKERSFIELD.
04:13:41.806 --> 04:13:43.308
WHO HAS TO PEOPLE SHE CARES FOR
04:13:43.374 --> 04:13:45.143
UNDER THIS PROGRAM SO TURN OVER
04:13:45.209 --> 04:13:46.644
CRISTINA I THINK WE'VE HAD A
04:13:46.711 --> 04:13:48.346
LONG HEARING SO MAYBE KEEP ALL
04:13:48.413 --> 04:13:49.714
COMMENTS TWO MINUTES OF A-
04:13:49.781 --> 04:13:50.982
OKAY. OKAY THANK YOU FORGET
04:13:51.049 --> 04:13:54.485
MAKE IT CONCISE TO STATE YOUR
04:13:54.552 --> 04:13:56.521
NAME FOR THE RECORD PLEASE. A
04:13:56.588 --> 04:13:58.056
SOMEONE YES GOOD AFTERNOON
04:13:58.122 --> 04:14:01.059
EVERY. I'M LIKE A YOU MY NAME
04:14:01.125 --> 04:14:05.363
IS MARK THE YOUR- I. NOT A- HM
04:14:05.430 --> 04:14:09.500
IT'S AS PROVIDE IN BAKER. MANY
04:14:09.567 --> 04:14:13.171
MANY WISH AS- ARE FORMALLY
04:14:13.237 --> 04:14:15.239
GIVERS BUT I AM CARE FOR MEMBER
04:14:15.306 --> 04:14:17.709
INDICUM WHO HAS NOT ONE HOURS
04:14:17.775 --> 04:14:20.144
TO TAKE CARE OF THEM. THIS IS
04:14:20.211 --> 04:14:21.546
ONE OF MICHAEL HIS NAME IS. MR
04:14:21.613 --> 04:14:23.848
J. BROWN. WE ARE CRITICAL PART
04:14:23.915 --> 04:14:26.150
OF CALIFORNIA COMMUNITIES WE
04:14:26.217 --> 04:14:27.552
MAKE IT'S POSSIBLE FOR SENIORS
04:14:27.619 --> 04:14:29.954
AND PEOPLE WHO DISOBEYED IT IS
04:14:30.021 --> 04:14:33.191
TO. LEAVE OUR HOME EVERYONE THE
04:14:33.257 --> 04:14:34.225
SERVICE THE RICE TO LEAVE OUR
04:14:34.292 --> 04:14:37.795
HOME BUT THERE IS NOT ENOUGH OF
04:14:37.862 --> 04:14:39.764
OUT BECAUSE THERE. PAY IS SO
04:14:39.831 --> 04:14:42.467
LOW. LAST YEAR IN MY COUNTY.
04:14:42.533 --> 04:14:44.702
THEY WERE FOUR HUNDRED AND
04:14:44.769 --> 04:14:47.405
FIFTY THOUSAND I H. SS HOURS
04:14:47.472 --> 04:14:50.041
THEY WORK I KNOW ME. ALMOST
04:14:50.108 --> 04:14:51.943
HALF A MILLION HOURS OF CARE
04:14:52.010 --> 04:14:55.213
THAT PEOPLE NEEDS. THAT THEY'D
04:14:55.279 --> 04:14:58.483
NEVER CAUGHT WHAT HAPPENED. TO
04:14:58.549 --> 04:15:00.685
ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO DIDN'T GET
04:15:00.752 --> 04:15:04.989
THEIR DAILY NEEDS MET. MADE
04:15:05.056 --> 04:15:05.990
SOME OF THEM WHEN INTO A
04:15:06.057 --> 04:15:07.892
NURSING HOMES AGAIN THERE WILL
04:15:07.959 --> 04:15:10.261
AND THEY'RE GREAT EXPENSE SO TO
04:15:10.328 --> 04:15:13.331
TAXPAYERS SOME MAY BE BECAME
04:15:13.398 --> 04:15:16.167
HOMELESS ARE PASSED AWAY. I'VE
04:15:16.234 --> 04:15:18.870
AS YOU ALL I'M SO THE SENIORS
04:15:18.936 --> 04:15:23.174
PURPLE AND THEY SAID GNARLY. BY
04:15:23.241 --> 04:15:25.109
TWENTY THIRTY WHO WILL CARE FOR
04:15:25.176 --> 04:15:28.413
ALL BOTH. THERE IS PLEASE
04:15:28.479 --> 04:15:31.215
CRISIS IN WE NEED THE ADDRESS
04:15:31.282 --> 04:15:33.151
WE NEED TO ADDRESS THIS RIGHT
04:15:33.217 --> 04:15:35.019
AWAY BEFORE THE MORE PEOPLE
04:15:35.086 --> 04:15:37.588
SUFFER OR DIE. WE NEED TO RE
04:15:37.655 --> 04:15:40.625
CREATE AND RETAIN RETAIN A
04:15:40.692 --> 04:15:42.326
HIGHER POVERTY CARE FOR WORSE
04:15:42.393 --> 04:15:46.931
FORCED. THE ONLY WAY TO DO THIS
04:15:46.998 --> 04:15:51.469
IS TO PAY I SSA. CARE GIVERS
04:15:51.536 --> 04:15:53.738
THE NAFTA THEY WILL WANT TO DO
04:15:53.805 --> 04:15:56.641
THAT THESE THESE WORK. PLEASE
04:15:56.708 --> 04:15:59.410
UPLOAD APPROVED THESE OUT THERE
04:15:59.477 --> 04:16:04.482
SO WE CAN FIND OUT WHY I H. SS
04:16:04.549 --> 04:16:07.151
MAY REMAIN SOLO. WE NEED TO
04:16:07.218 --> 04:16:10.955
MAKE THESE DONNA WE NEED TO
04:16:11.022 --> 04:16:14.392
MAKE SURE THAT YOU I THAT I. H.
04:16:14.459 --> 04:16:20.598
S. SAYS FARMS ARE BEGIN. WHICH
04:16:20.665 --> 04:16:21.899
IS MY SECOND THERE WERE NO
04:16:21.966 --> 04:16:23.034
YOU'RE FINE IT'S ALL FOR
04:16:23.101 --> 04:16:26.671
JOINING US. I'M SO NERVOUS
04:16:26.738 --> 04:16:29.607
THAT. THEY GET IT THEY MISTER
04:16:29.674 --> 04:16:32.410
JAMES. LOGAN WAS WORTH LIKE A
04:16:32.477 --> 04:16:34.812
COMMERCIAL I'M SORRY I'M LIKE
04:16:34.879 --> 04:16:37.215
IT'S GETTING. OKAY YEAH MOVE TO
04:16:37.281 --> 04:16:39.550
THE STATE PRESENTATION PLEASE
04:16:39.617 --> 04:16:41.319
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AS
04:16:41.385 --> 04:16:42.687
ASSEMBLYMEMBER BOERNER HORVATH
04:16:42.754 --> 04:16:45.556
INDICATED AN AUDIT OF AYE HSS-
04:16:45.623 --> 04:16:46.791
AND LOOKING AT FOR COUNTY SHE'S
04:16:46.858 --> 04:16:48.593
OF COURSE WILL GO LARGE SMALL
04:16:48.659 --> 04:16:50.094
RURAL URBAN TO GET A GOOD
04:16:50.161 --> 04:16:51.529
GEOGRAPHIC DIVERSITY OF THE
04:16:51.596 --> 04:16:52.730
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND
04:16:52.797 --> 04:16:53.731
QUICKLY GO THROUGH THE
04:16:53.798 --> 04:16:54.866
OBJECTIVES LOOKING AT THE
04:16:54.932 --> 04:16:56.968
EXPENDITURES OF AYE HSS FUNDING
04:16:57.034 --> 04:16:58.436
BY THE COUNTIES TO ADMINISTER
04:16:58.503 --> 04:17:01.272
A- I HSS HOW MUCH OF THAT IS
04:17:01.339 --> 04:17:02.774
GOING TOWARDS PROVIDER WAGES
04:17:02.840 --> 04:17:04.041
AND BENEFITS VERSUS OTHER
04:17:04.108 --> 04:17:05.743
EXPENSES ARE THE COUNTY
04:17:05.810 --> 04:17:07.612
SPENDING ALL OF THE AYE HSS
04:17:07.678 --> 04:17:09.280
FUNDING THAT THEY RECEIVE EACH
04:17:09.347 --> 04:17:10.548
YEAR. AND AGAIN HOW MUCH OF
04:17:10.615 --> 04:17:12.416
THAT IS GOING TOWARD PROVIDER-
04:17:12.483 --> 04:17:14.485
WAGES VERSES ADMINISTRATIVE
04:17:14.552 --> 04:17:17.021
COSTS OUT WITH RESPECT TO THE
04:17:17.088 --> 04:17:19.090
SUPPLY OF PROVIDERS MS
04:17:19.157 --> 04:17:20.124
BOERNER HORVATH IS ASKING AS
04:17:20.191 --> 04:17:21.626
IDENTIFY TRENDS SO WE'LL HAVE
04:17:21.692 --> 04:17:23.294
TO LOOK AT A CERTAIN TIME FRAME
04:17:23.361 --> 04:17:24.796
IN HE NUMBER OF PROVIDERS AND
04:17:24.862 --> 04:17:26.330
RECIPIENTS WITHIN EACH OF THOSE
04:17:26.397 --> 04:17:28.599
COMMUNITIES. AND ASSESS WHETHER
04:17:28.666 --> 04:17:29.433
THE COUNTY HAS A SHORTAGE OF
04:17:29.500 --> 04:17:31.102
PROVIDERS AND TRY TO DETERMINE
04:17:31.169 --> 04:17:33.204
WHAT THE REASONS ARE FOR THAT
04:17:33.271 --> 04:17:35.072
PARTICULAR SHORTAGE AGAIN AS A
04:17:35.139 --> 04:17:36.974
MEMBER INDICATED SHE WANTS US
04:17:37.041 --> 04:17:37.575
TO LOOK AT THE AVERAGE MINIMUM
04:17:37.642 --> 04:17:39.844
WAGE OF EACH COUNTY COMPARE
04:17:39.911 --> 04:17:41.946
THAT TO THE AVERAGE WAGE FOR
04:17:42.013 --> 04:17:44.015
PROVIDERS AND THEN ALSO LOOK AT
04:17:44.081 --> 04:17:45.216
THE COST OF LIVING WITHIN THAT
04:17:45.283 --> 04:17:46.884
COMMUNITY TO TRY TO GET A- AN
04:17:46.951 --> 04:17:48.553
OVERALL PICTURE. OF THE
04:17:48.619 --> 04:17:50.454
SITUATION- IN EACH OF THOSE
04:17:50.521 --> 04:17:52.690
COUNTIES ASSESS CHALLENGES TO
04:17:52.757 --> 04:17:54.525
INCREASING WAGES WITH ANY TO
04:17:54.592 --> 04:17:58.596
THE COUNTIES- LOOKING AT COUNTY
04:17:58.663 --> 04:18:00.198
EFFORTS TO RECRUIT AND PROVIDE
04:18:00.264 --> 04:18:02.567
TRAINING TO NEW INDIVIDUALS NEW
04:18:02.633 --> 04:18:05.236
PROVIDERS AND THEN. AGAIN THE
04:18:05.303 --> 04:18:07.238
MEMBER INDICATED TRYING TO
04:18:07.305 --> 04:18:08.773
IDENTIFY THE CHALLENGES THAT
04:18:08.840 --> 04:18:12.310
EXIT PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE WHO
04:18:12.376 --> 04:18:14.679
DO NOT HAVE FAMILY TO SUPPORT
04:18:14.745 --> 04:18:15.446
THEM WHEN THEY'RE TRYING TO
04:18:15.513 --> 04:18:18.449
HIRE AND RETAIN UP. ON AND
04:18:18.516 --> 04:18:19.984
REALLY SING ON SS ACTIVELY
04:18:20.051 --> 04:18:21.352
CHOOSE ONE RECRUITING AND
04:18:21.419 --> 04:18:23.487
HIRING AND LEE RETAINING
04:18:23.554 --> 04:18:25.923
FIGHTERS AND FAST QUESTION IS
04:18:25.990 --> 04:18:28.125
REALLY TO THE SHEETS TO HOW IT
04:18:28.192 --> 04:18:29.694
TO NEW ON OUR TO GET A NEW TIME
04:18:29.760 --> 04:18:31.329
SHE SO THAT THEY DO GET. FOR
04:18:31.395 --> 04:18:34.765
THIS THAT PROVIDING THAT'S TRUE
04:18:34.832 --> 04:18:36.133
THAT WE'VE LOOKED AT AND PASSED
04:18:36.200 --> 04:18:39.470
ON SO IT WOULD BE A FOLLOW OF.
04:18:39.537 --> 04:18:41.706
THEM FALL APART NOT F. THREE
04:18:41.772 --> 04:18:43.174
YEARS AGO. BUDGET ABOUT TWENTY
04:18:43.241 --> 04:18:44.742
SEVEN OUR- MEANS THAT PRODUCT
04:18:44.809 --> 04:18:45.309
TO ABOUT SEVEN ON TO COMPLY
04:18:45.376 --> 04:18:45.910
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK
04:18:45.977 --> 04:18:47.812
YOU ALL RIGHT LET ME MOVE TO
04:18:47.879 --> 04:18:50.348
BACK TO THE DíAS LET ME ASK IF
04:18:50.414 --> 04:18:52.216
THERE'S- QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
04:18:52.283 --> 04:18:54.685
FROM MEMBERS ON DíAS. OKAY
04:18:54.752 --> 04:18:55.319
HEARING AND SEEING THEM PRETTY
04:18:55.386 --> 04:18:57.521
STRAIGHT FORWARD. LET ME ASK IF
04:18:57.588 --> 04:18:58.122
THERE'S PUBLIC COMMENT AT THIS
04:18:58.189 --> 04:19:01.759
TIME. REVIEW PLEASE BE CONCISE
04:19:01.826 --> 04:19:03.728
WITH THE PUBLIC COMMENTS
04:19:03.794 --> 04:19:04.295
BECAUSE WITHOUT A VERY LONG
04:19:04.362 --> 04:19:06.964
HEARING. HI MY NAME IS YOLANDA
04:19:07.031 --> 04:19:10.434
TOLIVER I AM I JUST PROVIDER
04:19:10.501 --> 04:19:12.770
FOR CENTER CANTONI HUNDREDS AND
04:19:12.837 --> 04:19:14.305
THOUSANDS OF OUR HOURS AND I IT
04:19:14.372 --> 04:19:16.674
JUST SAYS CARE IN THE COUNTY
04:19:16.741 --> 04:19:19.577
ARE GOING ON MATT. PLEASE
04:19:19.644 --> 04:19:21.579
APPROVE THIS AUDIT SO WE CAN
04:19:21.646 --> 04:19:26.284
FIND OUT HOW TO COVER THAT MEET
04:19:26.350 --> 04:19:28.119
THANK YOU. NATIONAL PUBLIC TO
04:19:28.185 --> 04:19:29.887
COMMENT PLEASE HI MY NAME IS
04:19:29.954 --> 04:19:32.056
MARCEL LOWER AND I'M I JUST AS
04:19:32.123 --> 04:19:33.591
PROVIDE FOR BIãU PLEASE
04:19:33.658 --> 04:19:34.926
APPROVE THE SITE SO WE CAN MAKE
04:19:34.992 --> 04:19:36.894
SURE THAT AGES AS PROGRAM AS
04:19:36.961 --> 04:19:37.962
HEALTHY AND VIABLE FOR THE
04:19:38.029 --> 04:19:39.797
FUTURE THANK YOU THANK YOU.
04:19:39.864 --> 04:19:41.432
NATIONAL PUBLIC COME HI MY NAME
04:19:41.499 --> 04:19:43.000
IS A MAJOR HERNANDEZ AND I AM
04:19:43.067 --> 04:19:44.802
AN HSS PROVIDER FOR BUTTE
04:19:44.869 --> 04:19:46.504
COUNTY THERE AREN'T ENOUGH CARE
04:19:46.570 --> 04:19:48.639
GIVERS IN MY COUNTY BECAUSE
04:19:48.706 --> 04:19:51.442
PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO WORK FOR
04:19:51.509 --> 04:19:52.643
SUCH LOW PAY. IS APPROVED AUDIT
04:19:52.710 --> 04:19:54.145
SO WE CAN MAKE SURE ENOUGH I IT
04:19:54.211 --> 04:19:56.213
JUST SAYS FUNDING IS GOING
04:19:56.280 --> 04:19:57.949
DIRECTLY TO PROVIDING CARE.
04:19:58.015 --> 04:19:59.817
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL COMMENTS.
04:19:59.884 --> 04:20:01.218
HELLO MY NAME IS ALEXANDER GO
04:20:01.285 --> 04:20:02.586
DEAN S. I AM HERE WITH UNITED
04:20:02.653 --> 04:20:04.422
DOMESTIC WORKERS- PLEASE
04:20:04.488 --> 04:20:05.990
APPROVE THIS AUDIT THIS THE I
04:20:06.057 --> 04:20:07.558
JUST AS AS A VITAL PROGRAM THAT
04:20:07.625 --> 04:20:09.060
KEEPS PEOPLE IN THEIR HOMES.
04:20:09.126 --> 04:20:10.695
BUT IT ONLY WORKS IF THE P. IF
04:20:10.761 --> 04:20:12.196
THE PROVIDERS ARE GETTING PAID
04:20:12.263 --> 04:20:14.966
FAIR WAGES THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
04:20:15.032 --> 04:20:17.201
PLEASE ME NOBODY'S MONTGOMERY'S
04:20:17.268 --> 04:20:18.636
SO THERE'S- PROVIDE OR ARE THEY
04:20:18.703 --> 04:20:20.805
YEAH CHASEZ SAME THAT GONZALEZ
04:20:20.871 --> 04:20:22.039
SADDAM. MITCHELL SUNLIGHT A
04:20:22.106 --> 04:20:23.874
SINGLE. IT'S NOT OUT OF THE
04:20:23.941 --> 04:20:25.476
DEAL MINIMAL DISASTROUS
04:20:25.543 --> 04:20:26.811
ENQUIRING YOU THIS IS THE MOST
04:20:26.877 --> 04:20:28.245
AS THOUGH THE INSEPARABLE THIS
04:20:28.312 --> 04:20:29.613
QUOTED COMPONENT THAT IS
04:20:29.680 --> 04:20:30.815
ALLOWED TO THE LAST PERSONAS
04:20:30.881 --> 04:20:32.917
COMO. CASSETTE BRICKELL BUT
04:20:32.984 --> 04:20:33.751
BOND AS THE MASS WHICH
04:20:33.818 --> 04:20:35.586
ADDRESSES CLASSES BUT US IRAQI
04:20:35.653 --> 04:20:37.455
CAN ALSO THROWS. PLEASE DIGITAL
04:20:37.521 --> 04:20:39.323
PUBLIC COMMENT. AT SO IN
04:20:39.390 --> 04:20:40.858
TRANSLATION FOR MARK THAT MY
04:20:40.925 --> 04:20:42.793
NAME IS MARK THE RUSE I'M A- I
04:20:42.860 --> 04:20:44.028
JUST AS PROVIDER AND SUTTER
04:20:44.095 --> 04:20:46.230
COUNTY- RP HAS BEEN MINIMUM
04:20:46.297 --> 04:20:48.499
WAGE FOR. FIVE YEARS AND WE
04:20:48.566 --> 04:20:49.734
NEED DECIDED SO WE CAN FIGURE
04:20:49.800 --> 04:20:51.836
HOW TO RAISE. THE PAY FOR FOLKS
04:20:51.902 --> 04:20:56.240
LIKE ME WHO. CARE FOR OTHERS
04:20:56.307 --> 04:20:57.308
THANK YOU. I WANT IS IAN ON THE
04:20:57.375 --> 04:21:00.478
PROVIDE IF YOU PLEASE APPROVE
04:21:00.544 --> 04:21:01.979
THIS AUDIT. HI JEFF THIS IS A
04:21:02.046 --> 04:21:03.447
VITAL PROGRAM TO KEEP PEOPLE IN
04:21:03.514 --> 04:21:04.915
THEIR HOMES BUT IT ONLY WORKS
04:21:04.982 --> 04:21:06.117
IF PEOPLE ARE PAID ENOUGH TO DO
04:21:06.183 --> 04:21:08.386
THE WORK. THANK YOU THANK YOU
04:21:08.452 --> 04:21:10.021
NATIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT. A
04:21:10.087 --> 04:21:11.422
DOCTOR REVEREND MINISTER CIVIL
04:21:11.489 --> 04:21:12.690
RIGHTS AND HUMAN RIGHTS SAID
04:21:12.757 --> 04:21:14.325
PLEASE APPROVED DECIDED JOSH
04:21:14.392 --> 04:21:16.160
WHAT DOCTOR REFERENCE. JOSH
04:21:16.227 --> 04:21:18.162
LOOK MUCH OF. THANK YOU. PLEASE
04:21:18.229 --> 04:21:20.131
DOCTOR ROBIN JUMBLE CAMACHO AND
04:21:20.197 --> 04:21:21.232
I'M HERE RIPPLES OF THIS AUDIT
04:21:21.298 --> 04:21:23.934
PLEASE. HUMAN RIGHTS AND HUMAN
04:21:24.001 --> 04:21:25.669
DECENCY. THANK YOU ADDITIONAL
04:21:25.736 --> 04:21:26.737
PUBLIC COMMENT TIFFANY RIGHT
04:21:26.804 --> 04:21:27.204
WITH THAT THE ARE YOU
04:21:27.271 --> 04:21:28.873
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT OF THE
04:21:28.939 --> 04:21:31.375
REQUEST THANK YOU THANK YOU. HI
04:21:31.442 --> 04:21:32.810
MY NAME IS AMY DAY I'M WITH
04:21:32.877 --> 04:21:34.178
UNITED DOMESTIC WORKERS I
04:21:34.245 --> 04:21:35.913
SUPPORT THIS AUDIT. THERE ARE
04:21:35.980 --> 04:21:38.082
SOBRE FOLKS IN BOTH- CENTER AND
04:21:38.149 --> 04:21:40.117
YOU COUNTIES THAT ARE GOING ON
04:21:40.184 --> 04:21:41.719
WITHOUT CARE BECAUSE HOME CARE
04:21:41.786 --> 04:21:43.687
WORKERS CANNOT AFFORD TO LIVE
04:21:43.754 --> 04:21:45.056
ON THE WAGES THAT THEY ARE
04:21:45.122 --> 04:21:46.624
RECEIVING RIGHT NOW. MINIMUM
04:21:46.690 --> 04:21:48.059
WAGE IS NOT A LIVABLE WAGE
04:21:48.125 --> 04:21:49.927
THESE FOLKS ARE SUFFERING AND
04:21:49.994 --> 04:21:51.395
SO I WOULD STRONGLY SUGGEST
04:21:51.462 --> 04:21:52.229
THAT YOU BUY SUPPORT THIS
04:21:52.296 --> 04:21:54.665
AUDIT. THANK YOU. THERE'S NO
04:21:54.732 --> 04:21:57.134
PUBLIC COMMENT. HELLO MY NAME
04:21:57.201 --> 04:21:59.236
IS HANA CARBALLO I'VE BEEN IN
04:21:59.303 --> 04:22:00.905
AYE HSS PROVIDER FOR ALMOST
04:22:00.971 --> 04:22:01.972
FORTY YEARS I WORK FOR NON
04:22:02.039 --> 04:22:04.175
FAMILY MEMBERS. THIS IS MY
04:22:04.241 --> 04:22:05.910
CAREER THIS IS MY CALLING THIS
04:22:05.976 --> 04:22:08.279
IS MY LIFE. AND I AM NOT GOING
04:22:08.345 --> 04:22:09.847
ANYWHERE I'M HERE IN FRONT OF
04:22:09.914 --> 04:22:11.148
YOU AS I HAVE BEEN IN FRONT OF
04:22:11.215 --> 04:22:13.584
LEGISLATIVE BODY SINCE NINETEEN
04:22:13.651 --> 04:22:14.218
EIGHTY SIX ADVOCATING FOR
04:22:14.285 --> 04:22:15.453
HIGHER WAGES FOR AYE HSS
04:22:15.519 --> 04:22:18.255
WORKERS. I HAVE SEVERAL STORIES
04:22:18.322 --> 04:22:19.323
TO TELL YOU WHEN I WILL TAKE MY
04:22:19.390 --> 04:22:20.724
FULL TWO MINUTES THANK YOU.
04:22:20.791 --> 04:22:22.126
FIRST OF ALL I WANT TO TELL YOU
04:22:22.193 --> 04:22:23.461
ABOUT MY OWN PERSONAL HOUSING
04:22:23.527 --> 04:22:24.862
STORY WHICH IS THAT IN THE
04:22:24.929 --> 04:22:26.363
SUMMER OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN I
04:22:26.430 --> 04:22:28.332
LOST MY HOUSE RIGHT RENTAL HOME
04:22:28.399 --> 04:22:29.533
DUE TO AN OWNER MOVE IN
04:22:29.600 --> 04:22:31.135
EVICTION I LIVE IN BERKELEY
04:22:31.202 --> 04:22:32.870
CALIFORNIA RENTS ARE VERY HIGH.
04:22:32.937 --> 04:22:34.371
MY FAMILY COULD NOT AFFORD TO
04:22:34.438 --> 04:22:36.040
GET A NEW HOME IN CALIFORNIA
04:22:36.107 --> 04:22:37.975
AND THE BAY AREA MY DAUGHTER
04:22:38.042 --> 04:22:39.910
WAS GRADUATING HIGH SCHOOL WENT
04:22:39.977 --> 04:22:41.412
TO COLLEGE. SHE HAS HER COLLEGE
04:22:41.479 --> 04:22:43.013
TUITION PAID FOR AND HER
04:22:43.080 --> 04:22:45.216
HOUSING THANK GOODNESS SHE'S A
04:22:45.282 --> 04:22:46.817
VERY BRIGHT GIRL AND SHE'S GOT
04:22:46.884 --> 04:22:49.520
SCHOLARSHIP. MY PARTNER. IS NOT
04:22:49.587 --> 04:22:51.388
WORKING BECAUSE HE WAS TO SAVE.
04:22:51.455 --> 04:22:52.756
AND HE MOVED TO SOUTH AMERICA
04:22:52.823 --> 04:22:56.727
BECAUSE HE COULD NOT LET HIS
04:22:56.794 --> 04:22:57.628
IMPORTANCE WOULD NOT. A LOT
04:22:57.695 --> 04:22:58.896
THEM TO STAY IN THE BAY AREA. I
04:22:58.963 --> 04:23:00.598
HAVE BEEN FORTUNATE TO HAVE A
04:23:00.664 --> 04:23:02.166
LIVING ROOM OFFERED TO ME SO
04:23:02.233 --> 04:23:03.400
THAT I CAN REMAIN IN THE BAY
04:23:03.467 --> 04:23:04.602
AREA AND DO THE WORK THAT IS SO
04:23:04.668 --> 04:23:05.936
IMPORTANT TO ME AND MY
04:23:06.003 --> 04:23:09.206
COMMUNITY. OKAY THE NEXT STORY
04:23:09.273 --> 04:23:10.407
I WANT TO TELL YOU IS NOT ABOUT
04:23:10.474 --> 04:23:12.710
ME. I'M SORRY PLEASE LET ME
04:23:12.776 --> 04:23:14.545
INTRODUCE MYSELF AGAIN I AM A
04:23:14.612 --> 04:23:16.614
MEMBER OF HAND IN HAND WHICHIS
04:23:16.680 --> 04:23:19.517
PART OF THE NATIONAL DOMESTIC
04:23:19.583 --> 04:23:20.050
WORKERS ALLIANCE IT IS THE
04:23:20.117 --> 04:23:22.686
EMPLOYER. ARM OF THAT MOVEMENT
04:23:22.753 --> 04:23:25.322
AND I AM AN ALLY WITH THE
04:23:25.389 --> 04:23:27.158
ATTENDANT EMPLOYERS I'M ALSO A
04:23:27.224 --> 04:23:29.326
MEMBER OF SEIU TWENTY FIFTEEN
04:23:29.393 --> 04:23:30.861
AND I AM ACTIVE IN MY UNION.
04:23:30.928 --> 04:23:34.131
AND ARE VERY PROUD OF THAT. I
04:23:34.198 --> 04:23:35.666
ALSO WANT TO TELL YOU ABOUT MY
04:23:35.733 --> 04:23:38.969
FRIEND TOM WHO WAS IN. GOT SICK
04:23:39.036 --> 04:23:42.106
AND WENT INTO THE HOSPITAL AND
04:23:42.173 --> 04:23:44.074
HAD TO HAVE A TRAE TAKE. HE
04:23:44.141 --> 04:23:46.777
WAS FINALLY WELL ENOUGH TO GO
04:23:46.844 --> 04:23:47.545
HOME AFTER FIVE MONTHS IN THE
04:23:47.611 --> 04:23:48.979
HOSPITAL BUT HE HAD NO
04:23:49.046 --> 04:23:50.481
ATTENDANTS HAD LOST ALL OF ITS
04:23:50.548 --> 04:23:52.983
INDEPENDENCE. AND HE SPENT
04:23:53.050 --> 04:23:53.951
THREE MONTHS TRYING TO PUT
04:23:54.018 --> 04:23:56.187
TOGETHER A STAFF AND FINALLY HE
04:23:56.253 --> 04:23:58.088
WAS ABLE TO GO HOME AND THE
04:23:58.155 --> 04:24:01.125
STAFF. ONLY LASTED A FEW MONTHS
04:24:01.192 --> 04:24:02.626
BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT MENTALLY
04:24:02.693 --> 04:24:04.728
STABLE HIS LIVE IN ATTENDANCE
04:24:04.795 --> 04:24:07.498
WAS NOT. STABLE ENOUGH TO
04:24:07.565 --> 04:24:08.999
PROVIDE THE CARE THAT HE NEEDED
04:24:09.066 --> 04:24:10.901
AND HE ENDED UP BACK IN A
04:24:10.968 --> 04:24:13.037
FACILITY FOR SEVERAL MONTHS CAN
04:24:13.103 --> 04:24:13.871
YOU TELL ME HOW MUCH THAT WOULD
04:24:13.938 --> 04:24:15.606
COST. THE STATE TO
04:24:15.673 --> 04:24:17.741
INSTITUTIONALIZE PEOPLE WHO ARE
04:24:17.808 --> 04:24:19.443
WELL AND CAN REMAIN IN THEIR
04:24:19.510 --> 04:24:21.412
OWN HOMES IS ABSOLUTELY
04:24:21.478 --> 04:24:23.814
OUTRAGEOUS I HAVE VERY GOOD
04:24:23.881 --> 04:24:25.783
NEWS HE IS HOME NOW HE'S BEEN
04:24:25.849 --> 04:24:27.585
HOME FOR SEVERAL MONTHS. BUT
04:24:27.651 --> 04:24:29.186
THAT WAS AFTER AT SECOND
04:24:29.253 --> 04:24:31.989
INSTITUTIONALIZATION THAT WAS
04:24:32.056 --> 04:24:33.424
CAUSED ONLY BY THE LACK OF.
04:24:33.490 --> 04:24:35.526
QUALIFIED CARE GIVERS THANK YOU
04:24:35.593 --> 04:24:37.561
I ALSO IF I HAVE JUST ONE MORE
04:24:37.628 --> 04:24:39.129
MOMENT I WANT TO TELL YOU ABOUT
04:24:39.196 --> 04:24:40.364
SOMEBODY ELSE WHO I KNOW WHOSE
04:24:40.431 --> 04:24:42.132
ATTENDANTS ARE HOMELESS VERY
04:24:42.199 --> 04:24:44.268
QUICKLY THEY'RE WORKING. SIXTY
04:24:44.335 --> 04:24:46.537
HOURS. EVERY TWO WEEKS SHE HAS
04:24:46.604 --> 04:24:47.871
TWO SMALL CHILDREN HER HUSBAND
04:24:47.938 --> 04:24:50.241
ALSO WORKS AND THERE'S NO WAY
04:24:50.307 --> 04:24:51.575
THEY COULD AFFORD A HOME IN AN
04:24:51.642 --> 04:24:52.643
IN BERKELEY CALIFORNIA.
04:24:52.710 --> 04:24:54.878
ATTENDANTS ARE PAID FOURTEEN
04:24:54.945 --> 04:24:55.479
SEVENTY FIVE AN HOUR WHICH IS
04:24:55.546 --> 04:24:57.114
ALAMEDA COUNTIES WAGE BUT
04:24:57.181 --> 04:24:59.283
MINIMUM WAGE IS FIFTEEN FIFTY
04:24:59.350 --> 04:25:00.818
NINE SO YOU CAN BET PEOPLE ARE
04:25:00.884 --> 04:25:02.186
GOING AND SELLING. SELLING
04:25:02.253 --> 04:25:04.855
THINGS AND DOING OTHER JOBS SO
04:25:04.922 --> 04:25:06.824
I AM THAT'S MY COMMENT A
04:25:06.890 --> 04:25:07.891
FABERGE THAT IN THE WORK THAT
04:25:07.958 --> 04:25:10.527
YOU DO. ALL RIGHT ADDITIONAL
04:25:10.594 --> 04:25:18.602
PUBLIC COMMENT. I'M GONNA BE
04:25:18.669 --> 04:25:21.038
VOICING FOR HAIL SURFACED THIS
04:25:21.105 --> 04:25:23.474
IS HELD TO KISS HI ALL ITS BEEN
04:25:23.540 --> 04:25:24.408
AND I IT JUST SAYS CONSUMER
04:25:24.475 --> 04:25:26.577
SINCE NINETEEN SEVENTY TWO HE
04:25:26.644 --> 04:25:27.511
IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE
04:25:27.578 --> 04:25:29.647
ARCHITECTS OF THE PROGRAM HE IS
04:25:29.713 --> 04:25:32.483
A GRADUATE OF UC BERKELEY WITH
04:25:32.549 --> 04:25:34.151
TWO BACHELOR'S DEGREES ONE IN
04:25:34.218 --> 04:25:35.653
RUSSIAN ONE IN MATHEMATICS HE
04:25:35.719 --> 04:25:36.120
HAPPENS TO HAVE BEEN A
04:25:36.186 --> 04:25:38.489
CLASSMATE OF. A SOME
04:25:38.555 --> 04:25:40.491
ASSEMBLYMAN OR SENATOR BIDEN
04:25:40.557 --> 04:25:42.559
MINING YES HE WENT TO SCHOOL
04:25:42.626 --> 04:25:45.829
WITH SENATOR MINING AND- WANTED
04:25:45.896 --> 04:25:49.566
TO MAKE NOTE OF THAT- HAIL. HAS
04:25:49.633 --> 04:25:52.703
RECENTLY- BEEN APPROVED FOR
04:25:52.770 --> 04:25:54.638
FUNDING THROUGH THE- REGIONAL
04:25:54.705 --> 04:25:57.875
CENTER TO HAVE. A TWENTY FOUR
04:25:57.941 --> 04:25:59.476
HOUR ATTENDANT SERVICES HOWEVER
04:25:59.543 --> 04:26:02.112
IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO FIND PEOPLE
04:26:02.179 --> 04:26:03.580
AND I HAVE BEEN WORKING
04:26:03.647 --> 04:26:05.749
LITERALLY NIGHT AND DAY. I PAID
04:26:05.816 --> 04:26:07.785
TO TRY TO FIND HILL SOME HERE
04:26:07.851 --> 04:26:09.253
HOME CARE WORKERS WE HAVE GONE
04:26:09.320 --> 04:26:11.588
THROUGH COUNTLESS INTERVIEWS WE
04:26:11.655 --> 04:26:13.324
HAVE TRAINED PEOPLE WHO STAY
04:26:13.390 --> 04:26:15.059
TWO DAYS AND THEN LEAVE. IT
04:26:15.125 --> 04:26:17.961
SAYS AND I'M- I'M TENABLE
04:26:18.028 --> 04:26:20.898
SITUATION OKAY THANK YOU THANK
04:26:20.964 --> 04:26:21.832
YOU FOR MAKING THE TRIP UP
04:26:21.899 --> 04:26:23.767
HERE. I THINK THERE'S A LITTLE
04:26:23.834 --> 04:26:25.502
BIT MORE THAT WE NEED TO SAY
04:26:25.569 --> 04:26:26.837
AND I'M SORRY THAT I'M NOT
04:26:26.904 --> 04:26:29.807
FULLY PREPARED- HALE ALSO
04:26:29.873 --> 04:26:33.143
WANTED TO LET YOU KNOW THAT-
04:26:33.210 --> 04:26:35.145
THIS IS NOT A UNIQUE SITUATION.
04:26:35.212 --> 04:26:36.714
AND THERE'S THIS PROJECTED
04:26:36.780 --> 04:26:38.182
SURPLUS OF JET SEVERAL BILLION
04:26:38.248 --> 04:26:39.950
DOLLARS IN THE GENERAL FUND AND
04:26:40.017 --> 04:26:41.418
HE WOULD LIKE TO SEE SOME OF
04:26:41.485 --> 04:26:43.454
THAT GO TO PAY HIGHER WAGES FOR
04:26:43.520 --> 04:26:45.689
AYE HSS WORKERS. THANK YOU AND
04:26:45.756 --> 04:26:47.524
THAT'S PROBABLY BETTER SUITED
04:26:47.591 --> 04:26:48.492
FOR OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS AS
04:26:48.559 --> 04:26:51.995
WELL WHERE THE B. ALLOCATED THE
04:26:52.062 --> 04:26:52.596
MONEY IN THE STATE BUDGET FOR
04:26:52.663 --> 04:26:53.330
TO AUDIT I UNDERSTAND YOUR
04:26:53.397 --> 04:26:54.531
SUPPORT OF SOMEONE-
04:26:54.598 --> 04:26:56.433
BOERNER HORVATH. AUDIT AS WE
04:26:56.500 --> 04:26:58.102
LOOK AT THE AGES US IN THAT THE
04:26:58.168 --> 04:27:01.171
RATES OF WHICH IT'S- ACTUALLY
04:27:01.238 --> 04:27:03.307
AFFECTS DIFFERENT AREAS OF THE
04:27:03.374 --> 04:27:03.907
STATE IN THE REGION THANK YOU
04:27:03.974 --> 04:27:07.111
THANK YOU. FIGHT WITH THAT LET
04:27:07.177 --> 04:27:07.678
ME ASK IF THERE'S ADDITIONAL
04:27:07.745 --> 04:27:09.646
PUBLIC COMMENT. HEARING AND
04:27:09.713 --> 04:27:10.714
SEEING MAN LET ME RETURN IT
04:27:10.781 --> 04:27:13.083
BACK TO THE DYESS SOMEONE WOMAN
04:27:13.150 --> 04:27:14.284
BOERNER HORVATH WOULD YOU LIKE
04:27:14.351 --> 04:27:16.019
TO CLOSE YES I RESPECTFULLY ASK
04:27:16.086 --> 04:27:17.788
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. ALL RIGHT
04:27:17.855 --> 04:27:20.124
WITH THAT THE APPRECIATE YOUR
04:27:20.190 --> 04:27:22.659
CONCISE CLOSE. I WITH THAT I'LL
04:27:22.726 --> 04:27:23.627
BE SUPPORTING THIS AUDIT I DO
04:27:23.694 --> 04:27:26.163
WANT TO THANK YOU FOR- FOR
04:27:26.230 --> 04:27:27.064
BRINGING THE OUT A FORWARDED
04:27:27.131 --> 04:27:29.199
I'VE- I DO VALUE THE WORK THAT
04:27:29.266 --> 04:27:31.668
EACH OF THESE MEMBERS- THAT
04:27:31.735 --> 04:27:33.203
TESTIFIED HERE TODAY- DO DO AND
04:27:33.270 --> 04:27:35.139
I ACTUALLY FOR TO THE RESULTS
04:27:35.205 --> 04:27:38.575
OF. THE STATE AUDITOR AS WELL
04:27:38.642 --> 04:27:39.209
WITH THAT LET ME ASK IF THERE'S
04:27:39.276 --> 04:27:41.678
A MOTION. MOVE BY SENATOR
04:27:41.745 --> 04:27:43.981
WIENER SECOND BY MISTER VOEPEL-
04:27:44.047 --> 04:27:48.752
THE SECTOR CALL THE ROLL. THE
04:27:48.819 --> 04:27:49.953
MOTION IS TO APPROVE ATER
04:27:50.020 --> 04:27:51.488
REQUEST NUMBER TWENTY TWENTY
04:27:51.555 --> 04:27:53.090
DASH ONE OH NINE IN HOME
04:27:53.157 --> 04:27:54.725
SUPPORTIVE SERVICES PROGRAM
04:27:54.792 --> 04:27:56.059
FUNDING BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
04:27:56.126 --> 04:27:58.095
BOERNER HORVATH ASSEMBLY MEMBER
04:27:58.162 --> 04:28:00.364
ALAS AYE. SALAS HI
04:28:00.431 --> 04:28:02.533
BOERNER HORVATH HI
04:28:02.599 --> 04:28:04.301
BOERNER HORVATH I GEN.
04:28:04.368 --> 04:28:10.808
PATTERSON RUBIO. VOEPEL VOEPEL
04:28:10.874 --> 04:28:17.514
I WOULD. CENTER ROTH. GORGEOUS
04:28:17.581 --> 04:28:22.953
GONZALEZ. HERTZBERG MORNING
04:28:23.020 --> 04:28:26.990
MOORLACH MOORLACH AYE WIENER.
04:28:27.057 --> 04:28:30.360
WIENER AYE. RIGHT YEAH MOTIONS
04:28:30.427 --> 04:28:32.596
ON CALL AND WILL ALLOW TIME FOR
04:28:32.663 --> 04:28:34.298
ADDITIONAL MEMBERS TO FAT I
04:28:34.364 --> 04:28:35.432
THINK THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK
04:28:35.499 --> 04:28:38.035
YOU ALL RIGHT AT THIS TIME- I
04:28:38.101 --> 04:28:40.938
DO SEE SENATOR HER TITLE HERE I
04:28:41.004 --> 04:28:43.140
DON'T SEE. ASSEMBLYMEMBER SO
04:28:43.207 --> 04:28:44.508
PREP SO HER DAUGHTER IF YOU'D
04:28:44.575 --> 04:28:45.809
LIKE T COMMENT WORLD THIS WILL
04:28:45.876 --> 04:28:48.312
BE ITEM TWENTY TWENTY DASH ZERO
04:28:48.378 --> 04:29:13.170
FOUR CITY OF LINDSAY. YES.
04:29:14.972 --> 04:29:20.277
CENTER THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
04:29:20.344 --> 04:29:22.312
OKAY IF YOU'D LIKE TO- OPEN
04:29:22.379 --> 04:29:25.782
SENATOR THAT BE GREAT. THANK
04:29:25.849 --> 04:29:26.817
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
04:29:26.884 --> 04:29:28.919
MEMBERS- I'M JUST HERE IN
04:29:28.986 --> 04:29:31.188
SUPPORT OF TWO REPRESENTATIVES
04:29:31.255 --> 04:29:32.256
FROM THE CITY OF LONDON I'LL
04:29:32.322 --> 04:29:33.457
JUST GO AHEAD AND HAD THE MIKE
04:29:33.524 --> 04:29:35.325
OVER TO THEM TO THE OPTION TO
04:29:35.392 --> 04:29:36.493
SPEAK PERHAPS BEFORE WE GIVE IT
04:29:36.560 --> 04:29:37.461
TO THAT WE CAN HAVE THE STATE
04:29:37.528 --> 04:29:39.496
AUDITOR- GIVE A PRESENTATION ON
04:29:39.563 --> 04:29:41.798
THE CITY OF WHIMSY CERTAINLY
04:29:41.865 --> 04:29:42.399
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN HER
04:29:42.466 --> 04:29:43.867
AND HANDED OVER TO MR CHILDREN
04:29:43.934 --> 04:29:44.768
BUT THIS IS ONE OF THE ARTISTS
04:29:44.835 --> 04:29:47.104
THAT WE REQUESTED- AUTHORITY
04:29:47.170 --> 04:29:49.540
TO. CONDUCT AFTER WE CONDUCTED
04:29:49.606 --> 04:29:50.807
AN ASSESSMENT WE WENT OUT TO
04:29:50.874 --> 04:29:52.409
THE CITY OF LINDSAY SPENT A
04:29:52.476 --> 04:29:53.844
COUPLE OF WEEKS MEETING WITH
04:29:53.911 --> 04:29:54.811
OFFICIALS LOOKING AT SOME
04:29:54.878 --> 04:29:56.713
DOCUMENTS ARE CONDUCTED THE
04:29:56.780 --> 04:29:58.916
ASSESSMENT. THE WAY OUR PROCESS
04:29:58.982 --> 04:30:00.484
WORKS IS WE DO GIVE THE ENTITY
04:30:00.551 --> 04:30:01.952
THE OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND TO
04:30:02.019 --> 04:30:03.620
OUR ASSESSMENT THAT IS INCLUDED
04:30:03.687 --> 04:30:05.155
IN THE MATERIALS THAT WE SHARED
04:30:05.222 --> 04:30:07.090
WITH THE MEMBERS WHAT I'D LIKE
04:30:07.157 --> 04:30:08.158
MISTER CHILDREN TO DO AND A
04:30:08.225 --> 04:30:09.326
VERY HIGH LEVEL AND HE'S
04:30:09.393 --> 04:30:10.494
PREPARED TO DO THAT WILL KEEP
04:30:10.561 --> 04:30:11.228
IT HIGH LEVEL WHAT THE KEY
04:30:11.295 --> 04:30:12.996
ISSUES WORK THAT WE IDENTIFIED
04:30:13.063 --> 04:30:15.065
AND WHY WE STILL BELIEVE THAT
04:30:15.132 --> 04:30:16.600
IT WOULD BE BENEFICIAL FOR.
04:30:16.667 --> 04:30:18.569
THIS COMMITTEE TO APPROVE NOT
04:30:18.635 --> 04:30:22.005
IT THANK YOU THANK YOU. A GOOD
04:30:22.072 --> 04:30:22.573
AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
04:30:22.639 --> 04:30:23.140
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE FOR
04:30:23.206 --> 04:30:23.707
THE RECORD MY NAME IS. STILL
04:30:23.774 --> 04:30:26.343
NOT. PARTNER SO IS MISS HOW
04:30:26.410 --> 04:30:28.378
INDICATED WE ANALYZE THE CITY
04:30:28.445 --> 04:30:29.580
LYNSEY'S FINANCES WHEN WE
04:30:29.646 --> 04:30:30.747
ISSUED OUR DASHBOARD AND WE
04:30:30.814 --> 04:30:31.615
DETERMINED THAT THEY WERE THE
04:30:31.682 --> 04:30:33.483
FOURTH. MOST FISCALLY
04:30:33.550 --> 04:30:35.485
CHALLENGED CITY IN THE STATE
04:30:35.552 --> 04:30:36.019
AND ESSENTIALLY THAT WAS
04:30:36.086 --> 04:30:37.888
BECAUSE- THEY ARE HAVING
04:30:37.955 --> 04:30:39.222
DIFFICULTIES IN TERMS OF THEIR
04:30:39.289 --> 04:30:41.158
CASH POSITION AND RESERVE TO
04:30:41.224 --> 04:30:42.926
PAY THEIR BILLS. AND THEY ALSO
04:30:42.993 --> 04:30:43.894
HAVE INCREASING RETIREMENT
04:30:43.961 --> 04:30:46.096
COSTS. SO WHAT'S GOING ON THERE
04:30:46.163 --> 04:30:47.397
IS THEY'VE BASICALLY BEEN
04:30:47.464 --> 04:30:51.802
INCURRING- REGULAR OPERATING
04:30:51.868 --> 04:30:52.836
LOSSES AND SEVERAL OF THEIR FOR.
04:30:52.903 --> 04:30:53.570
ANOTHER ISSUE THAT THEY- IS
04:30:53.637 --> 04:30:55.973
THAT THE GENERAL FUND HAS LOAN
04:30:56.039 --> 04:30:56.707
SAID STANGEL AMOUNTS OF MONEY
04:30:56.773 --> 04:30:58.141
TO OTHER FUNDS INCLUDING
04:30:58.208 --> 04:30:59.776
SEVENTEEN MILLION DOLLARS. TO
04:30:59.843 --> 04:31:00.844
ANOTHER FUND TO BUILD AN INDOOR
04:31:00.911 --> 04:31:03.113
SPORTS COMPLEX. BECAUSE THAT
04:31:03.180 --> 04:31:04.181
COMPLEX DIDN'T GENERATE ENOUGH
04:31:04.247 --> 04:31:05.616
REVENUE TO BASICALLY TO PAY THE
04:31:05.682 --> 04:31:07.651
LOAN OFF. CITY COUNCIL FOR GAVE
04:31:07.718 --> 04:31:09.820
THAT LOAN WHICH RESULT IN A
04:31:09.886 --> 04:31:10.988
PRETTY SUBSTANTIAL HIT THE
04:31:11.054 --> 04:31:13.256
GENERAL FUND. BECAUSE OF THAT
04:31:13.323 --> 04:31:14.591
AT THE OPERATING LOSSES THE
04:31:14.658 --> 04:31:16.526
LOANS THAT WERE WRITTEN OFF.
04:31:16.593 --> 04:31:18.261
THE CITY WHEN'S THE GENERAL HAS
04:31:18.328 --> 04:31:20.364
A VERY SIGNIFICANT DEFICIT.
04:31:20.430 --> 04:31:21.632
GENERAL RESERVES. I AND FROM WE
04:31:21.698 --> 04:31:23.600
TO THE DASHBOARD THE CITY OF
04:31:23.667 --> 04:31:26.603
LINDSEY'S. NEGATIVE FIVE.
04:31:26.670 --> 04:31:28.238
GENERAL FUND RESERVE WAS THE
04:31:28.305 --> 04:31:30.974
SECOND LARGEST IN. THE ENTIRE
04:31:31.041 --> 04:31:31.975
STATE AT NINE POINT FOUR
04:31:32.042 --> 04:31:34.478
MILLION. BECAUSE OF THE ISSUES
04:31:34.544 --> 04:31:35.278
THIS THESE EXTERNAL HAS A-
04:31:35.345 --> 04:31:37.981
GOING. ABOUT AND BASICALLY HAS
04:31:38.048 --> 04:31:40.250
SAID THE CITY HAS SUBSTANTIAL
04:31:40.317 --> 04:31:43.120
DOUBT ABOUT THE CITY'S ABILITY
04:31:43.186 --> 04:31:45.222
TO CONTINUE AS A GOING CONCERN.
04:31:45.288 --> 04:31:46.823
IN THE MOST RECENT AUTO REPORT
04:31:46.890 --> 04:31:48.225
THE ORDER WENT SO FAR AS TO
04:31:48.291 --> 04:31:49.693
CALL THE CITY FUNCTIONALLY
04:31:49.760 --> 04:31:52.429
BANKRUPT- SO WE HAVE A NUMBER
04:31:52.496 --> 04:31:54.398
OF DIFFERENT- AUDIT OBJECTIVES
04:31:54.464 --> 04:31:55.666
BUT TO KEEP IT BRIEF
04:31:55.732 --> 04:31:57.567
ESSENTIALLY IF THE AUDIT IS
04:31:57.634 --> 04:31:59.770
APPROVED- THAT WOULD GIVE US AN
04:31:59.836 --> 04:32:01.638
OPPORTUNITY TO DO A DEEPER DIVE
04:32:01.705 --> 04:32:03.573
AND REALLY- PUT TOGETHER A FULL
04:32:03.640 --> 04:32:04.808
ACCOUNTING OF THE CITY'S
04:32:04.875 --> 04:32:06.476
FINANCIAL OPERATIONAL
04:32:06.543 --> 04:32:08.545
MANAGEMENT RISKS. AND MORE
04:32:08.612 --> 04:32:09.713
IMPORTANTLY WE GIVE US AN
04:32:09.780 --> 04:32:11.114
OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE DETAILED
04:32:11.181 --> 04:32:12.849
AND PRACTICAL RECOMMENDATIONS
04:32:12.916 --> 04:32:14.451
TO THE CITY THAT WOULD ALLOW
04:32:14.518 --> 04:32:15.419
THEM TO CREATE A CORRECTIVE
04:32:15.485 --> 04:32:17.954
ACTION PLAN ESSENTIALLY TO
04:32:18.021 --> 04:32:20.123
ADDRESS THE FINDINGS. AND WE
04:32:20.190 --> 04:32:21.358
HAVE ESTIMATED THAT THE ART IT
04:32:21.425 --> 04:32:24.061
WOULD TAKE ABOUT ONE THOUSAND
04:32:24.127 --> 04:32:24.661
NINE HUNDRED NINETY SIX HOURS
04:32:24.728 --> 04:32:25.729
TO COMPLETE. AND THAT WOULD
04:32:25.796 --> 04:32:27.197
EQUATE TO ROUGHLY FOUR FIVE
04:32:27.264 --> 04:32:33.036
MONTHS. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
04:32:33.103 --> 04:32:34.304
OKAY THAT GETS US TO THE
04:32:34.371 --> 04:32:35.472
AFFECTED CITIES A MEASURE
04:32:35.539 --> 04:32:36.473
REPORT YOUR AND YOU HAVE ANY
04:32:36.540 --> 04:32:38.175
MORE TO ADD TO THE REPORT NO NO
04:32:38.241 --> 04:32:39.910
THANK YOU OKAY WELCOME CITY OF
04:32:39.976 --> 04:32:42.379
ANTI. YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN NAME
04:32:42.446 --> 04:32:44.414
IS PAM CAMPBELLI'M MAYOR OF
04:32:44.481 --> 04:32:45.816
THE CITY LINDSEY AND- WELCOME
04:32:45.882 --> 04:32:47.184
THIS OPPORTUNITY THANK YOU FOR
04:32:47.250 --> 04:32:49.119
ALLOWING ME TO SPEAK TO
04:32:49.186 --> 04:32:50.387
YOURSELF AND OTHER MEMBERS OF
04:32:50.454 --> 04:32:53.390
THE COMMITTEE. WE THANK YOU FOR
04:32:53.457 --> 04:32:54.424
YOUR CONCERN ABOUT OUR
04:32:54.491 --> 04:32:56.927
FINANCES. AS A SMALL VERY
04:32:56.993 --> 04:32:59.596
DISADVANTAGED. OF AG BASED
04:32:59.663 --> 04:33:01.064
COMMUNITY WE HAVE BUILT MOSTLY
04:33:01.131 --> 04:33:03.700
ALONE AND- DEALING WITH OUR
04:33:03.767 --> 04:33:07.571
WITH OUR DEEP CHALLENGES. AND
04:33:07.637 --> 04:33:10.741
THEY'VE GONE BACK FOR DECADES-
04:33:10.807 --> 04:33:12.275
WE ARE IN THE CITRUS SPELLED WE
04:33:12.342 --> 04:33:13.844
FACED A NUMBER OF DEVASTATING
04:33:13.910 --> 04:33:15.946
FREEZES WE'VE HAD BUSINESSES
04:33:16.012 --> 04:33:18.281
CLOSE AND LEAVE WE- ARE
04:33:18.348 --> 04:33:21.585
POPULATION IS PRIMARILY-
04:33:21.651 --> 04:33:25.155
HISPANIC FARM WORKER. WE HAVE
04:33:25.222 --> 04:33:27.124
LOW GROWTH THERE'S A FEW WAYS
04:33:27.190 --> 04:33:29.226
TO RAISE FUNDS IN OUR IN OUR
04:33:29.292 --> 04:33:32.262
COMMUNITY BUT- WE DON'T THINK
04:33:32.329 --> 04:33:33.530
OUR STRUGGLES ARE THAT UNIQUE
04:33:33.597 --> 04:33:35.198
TO US THEIR SHARED BY MOST
04:33:35.265 --> 04:33:37.100
CITIES IN OUR AREA WITH THE
04:33:37.167 --> 04:33:38.969
EXCEPTION OF THE FACT THAT WE
04:33:39.035 --> 04:33:41.772
DID. HAVE A MAJOR EFFORT
04:33:41.838 --> 04:33:44.274
UNDERTAKEN TO TRY TO RISE ABOVE
04:33:44.341 --> 04:33:46.443
OUR POVERTY. ABOUT FIFTEEN
04:33:46.510 --> 04:33:50.347
YEARS AGO IN CREATING THIS.
04:33:50.413 --> 04:33:51.882
REGIONAL SPORTS AND RECREATION
04:33:51.948 --> 04:33:53.550
FACILITY IN AN OLD ABANDONED
04:33:53.617 --> 04:33:55.952
PACKING HOMES. AND AT THE SAME
04:33:56.019 --> 04:33:57.320
TIME WE DID DOWNTOWN
04:33:57.387 --> 04:33:59.222
IMPROVEMENTS TRYING TO INVITE.
04:33:59.289 --> 04:34:01.725
PEOPLE BACK INTO OUR COMMUNITY-
04:34:01.792 --> 04:34:02.859
FOR VARIOUS REASONS THIS MAJOR
04:34:02.926 --> 04:34:08.598
EFFORT. WAS DID FAIL- SOME OF
04:34:08.665 --> 04:34:10.367
THEM ARE CALDERON WEAKNESSES
04:34:10.433 --> 04:34:11.234
AND SOME OF THEM WERE THINGS
04:34:11.301 --> 04:34:12.402
LIKE THE GREAT RECESSION THAT
04:34:12.469 --> 04:34:14.504
HIT OUR AREA VERY HARD AND WE
04:34:14.571 --> 04:34:15.405
WERE A LONG TIME CLIMBING OUT
04:34:15.472 --> 04:34:17.808
OF. OF THE RE SENDING A
04:34:17.874 --> 04:34:19.242
REDEVELOPMENT WHICH WE HAD
04:34:19.309 --> 04:34:21.611
RELIED UPON AND THINGS LIKE
04:34:21.678 --> 04:34:22.746
THAT THAT WERE SOMEONE OUT OF
04:34:22.813 --> 04:34:24.080
OUR CONTROL BUT IT LEFT US WITH
04:34:24.147 --> 04:34:27.951
A BIG HOLE ULTIMATELY- WHICH WE
04:34:28.018 --> 04:34:30.520
HAVE ADMITTED TO IN OUR GENERAL
04:34:30.587 --> 04:34:32.556
FUND. AND I BELIEVE MADE THE
04:34:32.622 --> 04:34:34.925
RIGHT DECISION IN. FORGIVING
04:34:34.991 --> 04:34:36.159
ORLEANS TO OURSELVES SO THAT WE
04:34:36.226 --> 04:34:38.428
CAN MOVE FORWARD WE BELIEVE
04:34:38.495 --> 04:34:40.230
THAT WAS THE RIGHT DECISION WE
04:34:40.297 --> 04:34:41.998
HAVE OTHER HELLO THAT WE'VE HAD
04:34:42.065 --> 04:34:46.636
TO. PAY BACK ON SOME GRANTS
04:34:46.703 --> 04:34:47.337
THAT WERE DEEMED BY THE STATE
04:34:47.404 --> 04:34:49.139
TO BE. NOT PROPERLY
04:34:49.206 --> 04:34:51.474
ADMINISTERED AND WE HAVE WORKED
04:34:51.541 --> 04:34:52.709
THROUGH THOSE ISSUES AS WELL
04:34:52.776 --> 04:34:53.977
AND MAYES SETTLEMENTS ARE A
04:34:54.044 --> 04:34:55.712
REALLY CLOSE TO SETTLING WITH.
04:34:55.779 --> 04:34:57.314
IN AND ALL OF THOSE INSTANCES
04:34:57.380 --> 04:34:59.449
SO WE FEEL LIKE WE HAVE. TAKEN
04:34:59.516 --> 04:35:01.384
THE STEPS WE NEED TO CLIMB OUT
04:35:01.451 --> 04:35:03.019
OF THIS SITUATION WE HAVE
04:35:03.086 --> 04:35:04.654
MANAGED TO AVOID BANKRUPTCY
04:35:04.721 --> 04:35:06.089
OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS IT'S
04:35:06.156 --> 04:35:07.757
BEEN HARD WORK WE'VE DONE.
04:35:07.824 --> 04:35:09.693
EVERYTHING THAT WE'VE MADE CUTS
04:35:09.759 --> 04:35:11.695
TO THE BONE WE HAVE RAISED
04:35:11.761 --> 04:35:13.697
REVENUES THROUGH A ONE CENT
04:35:13.763 --> 04:35:16.733
SALES TAX THAT WE WERE.
04:35:16.800 --> 04:35:19.369
SUCCESSFUL IN PASSING. ON BUT
04:35:19.436 --> 04:35:21.071
WE ARE A POOR COMMUNITY AND
04:35:21.137 --> 04:35:22.138
THERE'S LIMITS TO REVENUES THAT
04:35:22.205 --> 04:35:24.507
WE CAN REYES AND THERE'S LIMITS
04:35:24.574 --> 04:35:25.909
TO SERVICES THAT WE CAN PROVIDE.
04:35:25.976 --> 04:35:29.145
SO BUT WE FEEL WE MOVED IN THE
04:35:29.212 --> 04:35:31.381
RIGHT DIRECTION WE DON'T
04:35:31.448 --> 04:35:33.583
DISPUTE A LOT OF YOU KNOW THE
04:35:33.650 --> 04:35:35.051
AUDITOR'S REPORT NECESSARILY
04:35:35.118 --> 04:35:37.888
BUT WE DO THINK THAT THAT V. I
04:35:37.954 --> 04:35:40.090
REQUEST LETTER DOES NOT
04:35:40.156 --> 04:35:40.824
ACCURATELY REFLECT OUR CURRENT
04:35:40.891 --> 04:35:44.094
SITUATION AND EFFORTS THAT WE
04:35:44.160 --> 04:35:46.997
HAVE MADE. THE PAST WE THINK
04:35:47.063 --> 04:35:48.298
WE'VE OVERCOME BUT WE HAVE MANY
04:35:48.365 --> 04:35:51.268
CONCERNS ABOUT THE FUTURE WE
04:35:51.334 --> 04:35:51.868
HAVE MANY NEEDS FOR THE FUTURE
04:35:51.935 --> 04:35:53.003
THAT WE DON'T KNOW HOW WE'RE
04:35:53.069 --> 04:35:54.771
GOING TO MEET SO WE'RE STILL IN
04:35:54.838 --> 04:35:56.473
A PRECARIOUS SITUATION. FOR
04:35:56.539 --> 04:35:57.340
EXAMPLE OUR WATER
04:35:57.407 --> 04:35:59.776
INFRASTRUCTURE IS A BIG CONCERN
04:35:59.843 --> 04:36:02.212
FOR US THAT WE DESPERATELY NEED
04:36:02.279 --> 04:36:03.780
A NEW WATER TREATMENT PLANT FOR
04:36:03.847 --> 04:36:05.148
EXAMPLE AND WE HAVE NO WAY TO
04:36:05.215 --> 04:36:09.119
FIND IT- STIGMA IS EVEN A BIG
04:36:09.185 --> 04:36:10.186
BURDEN WE HAVE TO FIGURE OUT
04:36:10.253 --> 04:36:13.356
HOW TO. PAY FOR PLANS THAT WILL
04:36:13.423 --> 04:36:15.125
ULTIMATELY HURT OUR AG ECONOMY
04:36:15.191 --> 04:36:17.761
AND THOSE ARE ON CITY FINANCES.
04:36:17.827 --> 04:36:19.562
SO IT'S THINGS LIKE THIS OF
04:36:19.629 --> 04:36:24.334
DESERT AREA STRUCK THE SHOWING
04:36:24.401 --> 04:36:26.903
WITH ADEQUATELY STAFFING PUBLIC
04:36:26.970 --> 04:36:29.906
SAFETY DEPARTMENTS. WE DO THE
04:36:29.973 --> 04:36:32.409
BEST WE CAN WE OUT OF NECESSITY
04:36:32.475 --> 04:36:34.544
COMBINED POLICE AND FIRE AND
04:36:34.611 --> 04:36:36.846
CROSS TRAIN THOSE OFFICERS JUST
04:36:36.913 --> 04:36:39.082
SO THAT WE COULD HANDLE THESE
04:36:39.149 --> 04:36:42.018
ISSUES- I MEAN WE WELCOME AT
04:36:42.085 --> 04:36:44.020
AUDIT IF IT CAN GIVE US ANY ANY
04:36:44.087 --> 04:36:46.056
IDEAS ON HOW TO DO THINGS
04:36:46.122 --> 04:36:47.757
BETTER THANK GOD I THINK-
04:36:47.824 --> 04:36:49.693
THAT'S ONE THING THAT WE HEAR
04:36:49.759 --> 04:36:50.927
ABOUT AS WELL AS WE FIND BEST
04:36:50.994 --> 04:36:52.462
PRACTICES. SO THE STATE
04:36:52.529 --> 04:36:54.397
AUDITOR'S LOOKED AT A NUMBER OF
04:36:54.464 --> 04:36:55.098
CITIES ALREADY UNDER THE HIGH
04:36:55.165 --> 04:36:57.801
RISK SO PERHAPS IT. IDEAS THERE
04:36:57.867 --> 04:37:00.236
THAT MIGHT BENEFIT THE CITY OF
04:37:00.303 --> 04:37:01.871
LINDSAY AND ONE OF THE THINGS
04:37:01.938 --> 04:37:02.505
ABOUT HAVING AN AUDITOR GOODWIN
04:37:02.572 --> 04:37:03.807
IS LOOK AT SEE WHAT CITY OF
04:37:03.873 --> 04:37:05.241
LINDSAY FOR INSTANCE IN THIS
04:37:05.308 --> 04:37:08.078
CASE IS DOING SAYING OUR FAXES
04:37:08.144 --> 04:37:10.146
MADE ANOTHER SMALL CITY OR CITY
04:37:10.213 --> 04:37:11.414
MIGHT ACTUALLY BE ACTUAL
04:37:11.481 --> 04:37:13.416
SOMETHING MAYBE YOU MIGHT NOT
04:37:13.483 --> 04:37:14.918
HAVE CONSIDERED OR SOME OTHER
04:37:14.985 --> 04:37:20.390
FINANCE MECHANISM. HELPED A OUT.
04:37:20.457 --> 04:37:22.659
SO I THINK THAT'S THE SCOPE AND-
04:37:22.726 --> 04:37:23.960
IF YOU WANT TO HONOR WE HOPE
04:37:24.027 --> 04:37:24.995
CAN GET SOME OUT OF WE DO THINK.
04:37:25.061 --> 04:37:26.196
A YOU FROM NOW. YOU'LL SEE SOME
04:37:26.262 --> 04:37:27.364
VERY DIFFERENT THINGS BECAUSE
04:37:27.430 --> 04:37:29.199
WE HAVE PUT A LOT OF THINGS IN
04:37:29.265 --> 04:37:31.201
PLACE. THANK YOU. ALRGHT LET
04:37:31.267 --> 04:37:32.502
ME ASK IF THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS
04:37:32.569 --> 04:37:34.371
FOR MEMBERS ON THE DíAS CENTER
04:37:34.437 --> 04:37:37.907
MORLOCK THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
04:37:37.974 --> 04:37:39.643
MAYOR THANKS FOR COMING. THANK
04:37:39.709 --> 04:37:41.144
YOU AND YOU SAID IT WAS PAM
04:37:41.211 --> 04:37:43.847
CAMILLA CAMPBELL CAMPBELL THANK
04:37:43.913 --> 04:37:49.686
YOU. THERE ARE A FEW CITIES ON
04:37:49.753 --> 04:37:52.689
OUR AGENDA TODAY- I HAVE
04:37:52.756 --> 04:37:56.259
REVIEWED YOUR KAFIRS. AND JUST
04:37:56.326 --> 04:37:58.628
DID A SIMPLE METRIC AND- THE
04:37:58.695 --> 04:38:00.730
STATE AUDITOR HAS HER OWN DEEP
04:38:00.797 --> 04:38:02.732
DIVE SHE LOOKS AT ABOUT TEN
04:38:02.799 --> 04:38:05.235
CRITERIA I ONLY LOOK AT ONE-
04:38:05.301 --> 04:38:06.169
AND THAT IS YOUR OWN RESTRICTED
04:38:06.236 --> 04:38:08.171
NEXT POSITION WHICH CURRENTLY
04:38:08.238 --> 04:38:12.075
IS A DEFICIT- BUT I DIVIDE THAT
04:38:12.142 --> 04:38:15.345
BY YOUR POPULATION. AND OF THE
04:38:15.412 --> 04:38:17.781
FOUR HUNDRED EIGHTY TWO CITIES-
04:38:17.847 --> 04:38:21.084
YOUR IN- THREE HUNDRED AND
04:38:21.151 --> 04:38:22.685
THIRTY ONE. THAT'S FOR YOUR
04:38:22.752 --> 04:38:24.554
RANK TO THE OTHER CITIES AT
04:38:24.621 --> 04:38:26.656
TODAY THE OTHER FOUR ARE
04:38:26.723 --> 04:38:29.392
ACTUALLY IN WORSE SHAPE. THAN
04:38:29.459 --> 04:38:34.364
YOU ARE BASED ON MY METRICS.
04:38:34.431 --> 04:38:38.168
BLYTH IS AT THREE SEVENTY SIX
04:38:38.234 --> 04:38:42.505
WEST COVINA IS A. FOUR FOUR
04:38:42.572 --> 04:38:44.774
FIVE EL SERENO IS A FOUR FIVE
04:38:44.841 --> 04:38:47.077
FOUR AND THEN GABRIEL IS A FOUR
04:38:47.143 --> 04:38:49.212
FIVE FIVE. SO WE HAVE A LOT OF
04:38:49.279 --> 04:38:52.749
CITIES. IN YOUR POSITION AND
04:38:52.816 --> 04:38:54.551
WORSE AND SO YOU CAN LOOK AT
04:38:54.617 --> 04:38:56.052
ALL THE OTHER CITIES AND HOW
04:38:56.119 --> 04:38:59.456
THEY RANK ON MY WEBSITE. BUT
04:38:59.522 --> 04:39:01.891
IT'S SYSTEMIC OF WHAT'S GOING
04:39:01.958 --> 04:39:03.626
ON IN THE STATE AND IT'S BEEN
04:39:03.693 --> 04:39:05.361
FRUSTRATING FOR ME MISTER CHAIR
04:39:05.428 --> 04:39:07.897
AS A SENATOR IN THE LEGISLATURE
04:39:07.964 --> 04:39:09.432
THAT WERE SET NOT TWENTY ONE
04:39:09.499 --> 04:39:10.900
BILLION DOLLARS IN THE SURPLUS.
04:39:10.967 --> 04:39:12.635
IN OUR CITIES HAVE NO WAY OF
04:39:12.702 --> 04:39:14.704
RAISING REVENUES YOU CAN'T
04:39:14.771 --> 04:39:16.473
TOUCH THE PROPERTY TAX YOU
04:39:16.539 --> 04:39:17.707
COULD TRY DO AN ASSESSMENT OR
04:39:17.774 --> 04:39:19.609
PARTIAL TO ACT YOU CAN DO A
04:39:19.676 --> 04:39:21.010
SALES TAX INCREASE BUT WE'VE
04:39:21.077 --> 04:39:21.711
GOT CITIES COMING HERE ASKING
04:39:21.778 --> 04:39:24.447
TO GO WELL BEYOND THE 2% THAT.
04:39:24.514 --> 04:39:26.483
WE CAP THE MAT SO- THE DESERT
04:39:26.549 --> 04:39:28.284
RELISHING TIMES FOR OUR CITIES
04:39:28.351 --> 04:39:30.520
AND OUR COUNTIES- OUR SCHOOL
04:39:30.587 --> 04:39:31.855
DISTRICTS THAT DON'T EVEN GET
04:39:31.921 --> 04:39:32.655
ME STARTED ON THE NINE HUNDRED
04:39:32.722 --> 04:39:34.791
AND FORTY FOUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS
04:39:34.858 --> 04:39:38.995
BUT- I'M JUST CURIOUS AS HOW-
04:39:39.062 --> 04:39:40.897
HOW MANY OF THESE TYPES OF
04:39:40.964 --> 04:39:43.633
AUDITS HAVE YOU DONE. HIGHER
04:39:43.700 --> 04:39:45.368
YEARS FOR CITIES. IN A AND
04:39:45.435 --> 04:39:48.404
WHAT'S BEEN THE WORK PRODUCT
04:39:48.471 --> 04:39:50.874
THAT'S BEEN GIVEN TO THE CITY'S.
04:39:50.940 --> 04:39:52.942
WELL WE'VE AUDITED AT LEAST
04:39:53.009 --> 04:39:55.078
FOUR OR FIVE CITIES ARE VIA
04:39:55.145 --> 04:39:57.147
THIS LOCAL HIGH RISK PROGRAM
04:39:57.213 --> 04:39:59.182
THAT WHERE THAT WE'VE REQUESTED
04:39:59.249 --> 04:40:00.283
AUTHORITY FROM THE JOINT
04:40:00.350 --> 04:40:01.784
LEGISLATIVE AUDIT COMMITTEE AS
04:40:01.851 --> 04:40:02.886
I MENTIONED IN MY OPENING
04:40:02.952 --> 04:40:04.487
REMARKS THE FIRST TWO WE DID
04:40:04.554 --> 04:40:05.722
WERE THE CITY OF HAMILTON CITY
04:40:05.788 --> 04:40:07.357
MAY WOULD. THEN WE ALSO LOOKED
04:40:07.423 --> 04:40:08.925
AT THE CITY OF MONTEBELLO AND
04:40:08.992 --> 04:40:10.860
LYNN WORK SO WE AT LEAST FOUR
04:40:10.927 --> 04:40:12.462
ON MY LAST- AND WE MAKE
04:40:12.529 --> 04:40:13.263
DIFFERENT TYPES OF
04:40:13.329 --> 04:40:15.465
RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE CITIES
04:40:15.532 --> 04:40:18.535
WITH RESPECT TO- OPPORTUNITIES
04:40:18.601 --> 04:40:19.869
TO RAISE REVENUE AREAS WHERE
04:40:19.936 --> 04:40:23.439
THEY CAN CUT COSTS- LOOKING FOR
04:40:23.506 --> 04:40:24.874
EFFICIENCIES HELPING THEM WITH
04:40:24.941 --> 04:40:26.409
JUST. BASIC MANAGEMENT
04:40:26.476 --> 04:40:28.678
PRACTICES INTERNAL CONTROLS THE
04:40:28.745 --> 04:40:31.047
BASIC FUNDAMENTALS ARE AND NO
04:40:31.114 --> 04:40:32.315
DISRESPECT TO THE C. ANY THE
04:40:32.382 --> 04:40:34.350
CITY'S JUST GIVING THEM SOME
04:40:34.417 --> 04:40:36.519
ADVICE FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE THE
04:40:36.586 --> 04:40:37.720
STAFF THE TYPICALLY WORK ON
04:40:37.787 --> 04:40:39.756
THESE AUDITS LIKE MR CHILDREN
04:40:39.822 --> 04:40:41.457
ARE FISCAL EXPERTS FROM MY
04:40:41.524 --> 04:40:43.593
OFFICE WHO EITHER WORK ON THE
04:40:43.660 --> 04:40:44.961
AUDIT THAT WE DO ON AN ANNUAL
04:40:45.028 --> 04:40:46.396
BASIS OF THE STATE'S FINANCIAL
04:40:46.462 --> 04:40:48.031
STATEMENTS. THEIR CPA'S- OR
04:40:48.097 --> 04:40:49.666
THEY HAVE THAT TYPE OF A
04:40:49.732 --> 04:40:51.034
BACKGROUND SO WE THINK WE
04:40:51.100 --> 04:40:52.502
REALLY COULD PROVIDE A SERVICE
04:40:52.569 --> 04:40:54.337
TO CITIES IN CALIFORNIA AND I
04:40:54.404 --> 04:40:55.338
THINK IF YOU SPOKE WITH THE
04:40:55.405 --> 04:40:57.407
CITIES THAT WE'VE AUDITED THUS
04:40:57.473 --> 04:41:00.076
FAR- NOBODY LOVES TO BE HAUNTED
04:41:00.143 --> 04:41:01.110
THAT'S FOR SURE I'VE BEEN DOING
04:41:01.177 --> 04:41:02.979
IT FOR. TWENTY YEARS AS THE
04:41:03.046 --> 04:41:03.913
STATE AUDITOR AND NOBODY LIKES
04:41:03.980 --> 04:41:05.949
US CALM BUT I THINK AFTER THE
04:41:06.015 --> 04:41:09.319
FACT. WE CONDUCT THE WORK THEY
04:41:09.385 --> 04:41:10.353
THINK FAIR AND REASONABLE AND
04:41:10.420 --> 04:41:12.422
HAVE BEEN THEM SOME SOME FOOD
04:41:12.488 --> 04:41:14.891
FOR THOUGHT AS AS THINGS THEY
04:41:14.958 --> 04:41:17.160
CAN DO TO TRY TO. STRENGTHEN
04:41:17.227 --> 04:41:21.798
THEIR FISCAL POSITION I'M
04:41:21.864 --> 04:41:23.666
OPTIMISTIC ALL UP. USING BERMAN
04:41:23.733 --> 04:41:26.803
ALL G. K. WITH CALL IT AN AUDIT.
04:41:26.869 --> 04:41:29.606
AB CALL IT MAN COACHING. OR A
04:41:29.672 --> 04:41:31.674
SYSTEM BECAUSE WE'RE WE'RE NOT
04:41:31.741 --> 04:41:32.875
SCHOLAR BEING I JUST GIVE YOU
04:41:32.942 --> 04:41:34.911
AN EXAM MISTER CHAIR I DID THIS
04:41:34.978 --> 04:41:36.913
PROCESS OF CALLING IN TRYING TO
04:41:36.980 --> 04:41:38.715
GET KAFIRS FROM COUNTIES WHEN I
04:41:38.781 --> 04:41:40.283
WAS THE CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD
04:41:40.350 --> 04:41:41.351
IN TWENTY TWELVE AND I CALLED
04:41:41.417 --> 04:41:45.121
MODOC AND I SAID YOU'RE KAFFIR
04:41:45.188 --> 04:41:46.122
IS NOT ON YOUR WEBSITE. COULD
04:41:46.189 --> 04:41:47.724
YOU HAVE YOUR AUDITOR
04:41:47.790 --> 04:41:48.324
CONTROLLER CALLED ME BACK AND
04:41:48.391 --> 04:41:50.126
LET ME KNOW HOW I CAN OBTAIN A
04:41:50.193 --> 04:41:52.528
COPY AND THE SECRETARY SAID
04:41:52.595 --> 04:41:54.464
WELL YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO
04:41:54.530 --> 04:41:55.565
GIVE US A TOLL FREE NUMBER.
04:41:55.632 --> 04:41:57.333
BECAUSE WE DON'T MAKE LONG
04:41:57.400 --> 04:41:57.867
DISTANCE PHONE CALLS WERE
04:41:57.934 --> 04:41:59.535
PROHIBITED. IS IT KIND OF GIVES
04:41:59.602 --> 04:42:01.471
YOU A CLUE OF HOW TIED. THE
04:42:01.537 --> 04:42:02.972
BUDGET WISE THERE'S LIKE ALL MY
04:42:03.039 --> 04:42:04.307
GOODNESS SN'T YOU CAN EVEN PUT
04:42:04.374 --> 04:42:06.175
A PDF ON YOUR WEBSITE. YOU CAN
04:42:06.242 --> 04:42:07.477
EVEN CALL ME BACK UNLESS THEY
04:42:07.543 --> 04:42:08.311
GIVE YOU AN EIGHT HUNDRED
04:42:08.378 --> 04:42:09.912
NUMBER- SO THERE'S SOMETHING
04:42:09.979 --> 04:42:12.415
GOING ON MISTER CHAIR. AND SO.
04:42:12.482 --> 04:42:14.751
WE NEED TO HELP. AND SO I'M
04:42:14.817 --> 04:42:17.320
WONDERING ARE YOU ALSO GOING TO
04:42:17.387 --> 04:42:18.755
REVIEW THE MO USE FOR ALL THAT.
04:42:18.821 --> 04:42:20.723
AB A BARGAINING UNIT
04:42:20.790 --> 04:42:25.828
NEGOTIATIONS. I DON'T KNOW
04:42:25.895 --> 04:42:27.930
SENATOR IF THAT IS A SPECIFIC
04:42:27.997 --> 04:42:29.165
OBJECTIVE ACTIVELY MINISTER
04:42:29.232 --> 04:42:31.501
TOLD HIM BUT WE DO LOOK AT. THE
04:42:31.567 --> 04:42:33.403
EXPENDITURES AND AS THE MAYOR
04:42:33.469 --> 04:42:34.904
INDICATED THIS IS A CITY THAT
04:42:34.971 --> 04:42:37.340
HAS HAD TO. COMBINED POLICE AND
04:42:37.407 --> 04:42:39.042
FIRE SO ESSENTIALLY AS WE
04:42:39.108 --> 04:42:39.776
DESCRIBE IN THE IN THE
04:42:39.842 --> 04:42:42.145
ANALYSIS. THE POLICE OFFICERS
04:42:42.211 --> 04:42:43.846
ARE SERVING AS POLICE OFFICERS
04:42:43.913 --> 04:42:44.947
A FIRE BREAKS OUT THERE
04:42:45.014 --> 04:42:45.915
SHIFTING GEARS IN THEIR
04:42:45.982 --> 04:42:47.517
BECOMING. ESSENTIALLY
04:42:47.583 --> 04:42:50.053
FIREFIGHTERS SO WE WOULD LOOK
04:42:50.119 --> 04:42:51.187
AT SOME OF THAT. THE
04:42:51.254 --> 04:42:52.255
CONSTRAINTS THAT THE CITY IS
04:42:52.322 --> 04:42:53.623
UNDER WE HAVE LOOKED AT THAT
04:42:53.690 --> 04:42:55.458
SITUATION. IN OTHER CITIES
04:42:55.525 --> 04:42:56.726
PARTICULARLY SOME OF THE CITIES
04:42:56.793 --> 04:42:58.127
THAT ARE BEING CONSIDERED TODAY
04:42:58.194 --> 04:43:01.097
WHERE. THERE HAVE BEEN- SALARY
04:43:01.164 --> 04:43:02.932
INCREASES AND THERE HASN'T
04:43:02.999 --> 04:43:04.300
REALLY BEEN A CONSIDERATION AS
04:43:04.367 --> 04:43:05.735
TO HOW THOSE SALARY INCREASES
04:43:05.802 --> 04:43:07.370
ARE GOING TO BE PAID FOR. AND
04:43:07.437 --> 04:43:08.571
WHAT THE IMPLICATIONS ARE WITH
04:43:08.638 --> 04:43:10.273
RESPECT TO RETIREMENT BENEFITS
04:43:10.340 --> 04:43:12.442
AND CERTAINLY- PAP. IT'S NOT
04:43:12.508 --> 04:43:13.943
SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFIED IN THE
04:43:14.010 --> 04:43:15.378
OBJECTIVES THAT I CAN SEE
04:43:15.445 --> 04:43:18.314
QUICKLY- BUT IT'S SOMETHING
04:43:18.381 --> 04:43:19.682
THAT WE COULD LOOK. ANYWHERE IN
04:43:19.749 --> 04:43:22.719
THE CITY IT STICK. THAT THAT
04:43:22.785 --> 04:43:24.387
HELP. IS YOU'RE YOU'RE A GOT A
04:43:24.454 --> 04:43:25.788
FEW OF THESE ARE. SO AND YOU
04:43:25.855 --> 04:43:26.422
SHOULD BE DOING THE SAME THING
04:43:26.489 --> 04:43:28.491
BUT RIGHT. I INTO THOUSAND SIX
04:43:28.558 --> 04:43:30.460
I WORKED ON. NEGOTIATING WITH
04:43:30.526 --> 04:43:32.495
OUR BARGAINING UNITS TO ADDRESS
04:43:32.562 --> 04:43:34.497
OUR RETIREE MEDICAL LIABILITY
04:43:34.564 --> 04:43:36.599
IT WAS. PRETTY COUNTY TIMES ONE
04:43:36.666 --> 04:43:38.434
POINT FOUR BILLION DOLLARS IN.
04:43:38.501 --> 04:43:40.436
AND ARE ANYA REQUIRED
04:43:40.503 --> 04:43:42.372
CONTRIBUTION WAS JUST. LOST
04:43:42.438 --> 04:43:44.540
SOUL LARGE WAS LIKE TWO HUNDRED
04:43:44.607 --> 04:43:48.378
AND THIRTY. MILLION A YEAR. AND
04:43:48.444 --> 04:43:50.513
SO WE NEGOTIATED AND WE MADE
04:43:50.580 --> 04:43:51.647
SOME MINOR CHANGES LIKE
04:43:51.714 --> 04:43:54.083
INTEGRATE WITH MEDICARE- REDUCE
04:43:54.150 --> 04:43:56.085
THE COLA IN A FEW. KEY THINGS
04:43:56.152 --> 04:43:57.887
VERY SIMPLE BUT WE WERE ABLE TO
04:43:57.954 --> 04:43:59.455
REDUCE THE UNFUNDED LIABILITY
04:43:59.522 --> 04:44:02.859
BY 71% BY A BILLION DOLLARS.
04:44:02.925 --> 04:44:04.494
AND IT REDUCED OUR AND REQUIRED
04:44:04.560 --> 04:44:06.396
CONTRIBUTION DOWN TO LIKE A
04:44:06.462 --> 04:44:10.199
HUNDRED- IS THE REASON LIKE A
04:44:10.266 --> 04:44:11.134
HUNDRED MILLION A YEAR. THEY
04:44:11.200 --> 04:44:12.368
WANT IF PROVIDES BY THE TIME I
04:44:12.435 --> 04:44:13.569
WAS SUPERVISOR SABLE WE LOSS IN
04:44:13.636 --> 04:44:15.338
THE BANKRUPTCY DESPITE THAT
04:44:15.405 --> 04:44:19.809
ONE- OPPORTUNITY. AND SO IT YOU
04:44:19.876 --> 04:44:21.077
KNOW IF WE CAN PROVIDE THOSE
04:44:21.144 --> 04:44:23.813
KINDS OF. A BENEFITS WERE YOU
04:44:23.880 --> 04:44:25.148
CAN SAY HERE'S HERE'S OF YOU
04:44:25.214 --> 04:44:28.684
CAN ACTUALLY CHANGE- I KNOW YOU
04:44:28.751 --> 04:44:29.719
CAN'T CHANGE THE PENSION. YOU
04:44:29.786 --> 04:44:31.087
KNOW THAT WE'VE GOT LAWSUITS IN
04:44:31.154 --> 04:44:32.755
STATE SUPREME COURT ON THAT
04:44:32.822 --> 04:44:34.824
BUT- BUT BOY IF WE TO WALK AWAY
04:44:34.891 --> 04:44:36.058
FROM THESE ASSIGNMENTS WHERE WE
04:44:36.125 --> 04:44:38.561
WERE ADDED SOME VERY. AND THEN
04:44:38.628 --> 04:44:41.397
MAYBE WE NEED TO. DO SOME KIND
04:44:41.464 --> 04:44:44.066
OF PUBLICATION TO ALL THE OTHER
04:44:44.133 --> 04:44:46.402
CITIES. BECAUSE MISTER CHAIR
04:44:46.469 --> 04:44:47.804
YEAH I KNOW WHAT THE LIKE
04:44:47.870 --> 04:44:49.105
ESCONDIDO THEY HAD A THEY HAD A
04:44:49.172 --> 04:44:50.506
WHOLE WORK STUDY SESSION FOR
04:44:50.573 --> 04:44:53.342
THEIR CITY COUNCIL AND HOW ARE
04:44:53.409 --> 04:44:53.843
THEY GOING TO MAKE THEIR
04:44:53.910 --> 04:44:54.911
PENSION PAYMENT. YOU KNOW I'VE
04:44:54.977 --> 04:44:57.380
I'VE GOT CITIES. THAT CAME OUT
04:44:57.447 --> 04:44:59.415
TO CALPERS. WHEN I ASKED FOR
04:44:59.482 --> 04:45:01.851
JUST SOME. ACTUARIAL DATA AND
04:45:01.918 --> 04:45:03.653
THEY STARTED GIVING CALPERS
04:45:03.719 --> 04:45:04.854
FINANCE ADMINISTRATIVE
04:45:04.921 --> 04:45:06.255
COMMITTEE THE DATES THEY'D RUN
04:45:06.322 --> 04:45:07.990
OUT OF CASH. AND HOW THEY
04:45:08.057 --> 04:45:09.325
REDUCE THEIR POLICE DEPARTMENTS
04:45:09.392 --> 04:45:11.093
IN THEIR FIRE DEPARTMENT. BY
04:45:11.160 --> 04:45:14.630
25% WE'VE WE'VE WE'VE GOT WE
04:45:14.697 --> 04:45:16.866
GOT A WHOLE STRUCTURE THAT IS
04:45:16.933 --> 04:45:18.668
OUR SIT THERE ARE SUBSIDIARIES
04:45:18.734 --> 04:45:20.002
BETTER ARE HAVING A DIFFICULT
04:45:20.069 --> 04:45:23.573
TIME SO I WOULD MADAM MADAM
04:45:23.639 --> 04:45:24.507
MAYOR I WOULD LOOK AT THIS AS
04:45:24.574 --> 04:45:26.542
AN AUDIT I WOULD LOOK AT THIS
04:45:26.609 --> 04:45:28.377
IS A VERY HELPFUL IF YOU WOULD
04:45:28.444 --> 04:45:30.279
CALL IT AN AUDIT. PERCEPTION
04:45:30.346 --> 04:45:31.514
BUT LITERALLY WERE FINDING BEST
04:45:31.581 --> 04:45:33.082
PRACTICES THAT HAVE HAPPENED IN
04:45:33.149 --> 04:45:34.450
OTHER HIGH LOOK AT THEIR
04:45:34.517 --> 04:45:36.486
RESIDENT STATUS FROM THIS DATE.
04:45:36.552 --> 04:45:38.421
TO PROVIDE SOME ASSISTANCE TO
04:45:38.488 --> 04:45:40.690
YOU IN YOUR CITY MANAGER.
04:45:40.756 --> 04:45:42.325
BECAUSE MISS HOW IS A
04:45:42.391 --> 04:45:44.060
CONSUMMATE PROFESSIONAL YOU'RE
04:45:44.126 --> 04:45:44.961
GONNA GET ONE OF THE BEST
04:45:45.027 --> 04:45:47.196
TEAMS. COMING INTO YOUR CITY
04:45:47.263 --> 04:45:49.499
THE REVIEWER KAFFIR. AND YOUR
04:45:49.565 --> 04:45:50.633
BALANCE SHEET AND YOUR
04:45:50.700 --> 04:45:53.503
CONTRACTS. AND I WILL I WILL I
04:45:53.569 --> 04:45:55.071
WILL TELL YOU A BIT I CAN
04:45:55.137 --> 04:45:56.205
GUARANTEE YOU BUT I WILL TELL
04:45:56.272 --> 04:45:57.373
YOU'RE GOING TO GET. SOME REAL
04:45:57.440 --> 04:45:59.542
VALUE ADDED FROM THAT EXERCISE
04:45:59.609 --> 04:46:01.644
AND I WOULD NOT FEAR THAT
04:46:01.711 --> 04:46:02.578
WOULD. EMBRACE THANK YOU
04:46:02.645 --> 04:46:04.347
SENATOR LET ME ASK THERE'S
04:46:04.413 --> 04:46:04.947
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS FROM THE
04:46:05.014 --> 04:46:10.853
DíAS. HEARING AND SEEING NONE
04:46:10.920 --> 04:46:12.555
LET'S GO TO MOVE TO PUBLIC
04:46:12.622 --> 04:46:13.155
COMMENT PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS
04:46:13.222 --> 04:46:17.693
ITEM. HEARING AND SAYING MAN
04:46:17.760 --> 04:46:19.428
LET ME ASK IF THE AUTHOR WOULD
04:46:19.495 --> 04:46:21.397
LIKE TO CLOSE HELLO MR TELL
04:46:21.464 --> 04:46:23.199
CHILDREN SURE ONE MORE COMMON
04:46:23.266 --> 04:46:25.067
GETTING BACK TO THE ANIMAL USE
04:46:25.134 --> 04:46:26.736
WHEN WE WORK ON THE LOCAL HIGH
04:46:26.802 --> 04:46:28.404
RISK AUDITS WE DO TYPICALLY
04:46:28.471 --> 04:46:29.572
TAKE A LOOK AT THE BARGAINING
04:46:29.639 --> 04:46:31.541
UNIT AGREEMENTS. AND THE REASON
04:46:31.607 --> 04:46:33.109
WE DO THAT IS OBVIOUSLY THE
04:46:33.175 --> 04:46:33.843
PERSONNEL COSTS THOSE ARE
04:46:33.910 --> 04:46:36.112
REALLY SIGNIFICANT EXPENDITURES
04:46:36.179 --> 04:46:37.680
FOR ALL THE CITIES. SO TO THE
04:46:37.747 --> 04:46:39.148
EXTENT THAT THEY HAVE.
04:46:39.215 --> 04:46:40.816
EMPLOYEES THAT ARE COVERED BY
04:46:40.883 --> 04:46:41.918
UNIONS WE WANT TO LOOK AT THOSE
04:46:41.984 --> 04:46:42.952
FAMILY USE AND WHAT WE'RE
04:46:43.019 --> 04:46:45.855
LOOKING FOR IS. THE SALARIES
04:46:45.922 --> 04:46:47.023
THAT ARE PAID TO THE
04:46:47.089 --> 04:46:48.024
MISCELLANEOUS EMPLOYEES PUBLIC
04:46:48.090 --> 04:46:51.427
SAFETY EMPLOYEES IN A
04:46:51.494 --> 04:46:52.061
PARTICULAR WE'RE LOOKING AT THE
04:46:52.128 --> 04:46:53.829
PENSION BENEFIT BECAUSE WHAT WE
04:46:53.896 --> 04:46:54.997
FIND SOME SKIS. THERE WAS A
04:46:55.064 --> 04:46:57.500
TIME WHEN. HE WAS ACTUALLY
04:46:57.567 --> 04:46:58.434
MAKING THE EMPLOYEE
04:46:58.501 --> 04:47:02.538
CONTRIBUTION TO PENSION COSTS
04:47:02.605 --> 04:47:03.172
WE WANT TO TAKE A LOOK AT. THE
04:47:03.239 --> 04:47:04.073
OTHER THING IS THE- THESE HAVE.
04:47:04.140 --> 04:47:06.943
RETIREMENT FOR WAS SOME CITIES
04:47:07.009 --> 04:47:08.511
FOR. EVEN FOR MISCELLANEOUS
04:47:08.578 --> 04:47:10.112
EMPLOYEES IT'S TWO POINT SEVEN
04:47:10.179 --> 04:47:12.348
AT FIFTY FIVE. FOR OTHERS IT'S
04:47:12.415 --> 04:47:13.783
TOO AT FIFTY FIVE SO WE ALWAYS
04:47:13.849 --> 04:47:14.784
LOOK AT THOSE ARGUED
04:47:14.850 --> 04:47:16.485
AGREEMENTS. BECAUSE THOSE ARE
04:47:16.552 --> 04:47:18.321
REALLY DRIVING SOME OF THE
04:47:18.387 --> 04:47:21.257
COSTS THAT WERE SEEN. ALL RIGHT
04:47:21.324 --> 04:47:22.458
THANK YOU I THINK THAT WAS OUR
04:47:22.525 --> 04:47:24.293
LOWS. OF WILL OKAY WELL I WOULD
04:47:24.360 --> 04:47:25.294
JUST SAY THAT THERE WAS A STYLE
04:47:25.361 --> 04:47:26.896
DRIFTED JUJU DRIFTED FROM YOUR
04:47:26.963 --> 04:47:28.864
CORE. RESPONSIBILITIES WITH THE
04:47:28.931 --> 04:47:31.434
SPORTS. CENTER BUT THAT'S
04:47:31.500 --> 04:47:33.336
PASSED SO NOW WE GOT TO FIGURE
04:47:33.402 --> 04:47:35.004
OUT HOW TO. RUN FREE HOW WE DID
04:47:35.071 --> 04:47:36.038
IT WE PAID A LOT OF MONEY FOR
04:47:36.105 --> 04:47:37.607
REALLY GREAT RECREATION
04:47:37.673 --> 04:47:39.709
DEPARTMENT YEAH. OKAY SO WITH
04:47:39.775 --> 04:47:42.278
THAT MSTER CHAIR WITHOUT FOR
04:47:42.345 --> 04:47:43.613
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU. CAN YOU
04:47:43.679 --> 04:47:47.617
HAVE A MOTION. TO APPROVE- ITEM
04:47:47.683 --> 04:47:48.184
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ZERO FOUR
04:47:48.250 --> 04:47:50.886
CITY LYNSEY. MOVE I CENTER
04:47:50.953 --> 04:47:54.657
MORLOCK SECOND BY.
04:47:54.724 --> 04:47:56.826
ASSEMBLYMEMBER VOEPEL- MISTER
04:47:56.892 --> 04:47:59.929
SECRETARY KALRA. THE MOTION IS
04:47:59.996 --> 04:48:01.964
TO APPROVE ATER REQUEST NUMBER
04:48:02.031 --> 04:48:02.865
TWENTY TWENTY DASH EIGHT OH
04:48:02.932 --> 04:48:05.801
FOR- HIGH RISK LOCAL GOVERNMENT
04:48:05.868 --> 04:48:07.837
AGENCY AUDIT PROGRAM BY FOR THE
04:48:07.903 --> 04:48:09.338
CITY OF LINZ THE REQUESTED BY
04:48:09.405 --> 04:48:11.107
THE STATE AUDITOR ASSEMBLY
04:48:11.173 --> 04:48:12.808
MEMBER SALAS HI. SALAS HI
04:48:12.875 --> 04:48:17.680
BOERNER HORVATH. GEN PATTERSON
04:48:17.747 --> 04:48:22.685
RUBIO RUBIO I'D VOEPEL VOEPEL I
04:48:22.752 --> 04:48:26.956
WOULD WOULD I. SENATOR ROTH.
04:48:27.023 --> 04:48:33.295
GORGEOUS GONZALEZ. HERTZBERG
04:48:33.362 --> 04:48:37.600
MORNING. MORE A LOT MORE LIKE
04:48:37.667 --> 04:48:41.971
AYE WIENER. WIENER AYE OKAY
04:48:42.038 --> 04:48:45.241
WELL THAT OPEN A- THAT ITEM
04:48:45.307 --> 04:48:46.909
WILL BE HELD OPEN SO OTHER
04:48:46.976 --> 04:48:48.377
MEMBERS CAN ADD ON RIGHT THIS
04:48:48.444 --> 04:48:49.745
TIME I BELIEVE WE HAVE ASSEMBLY
04:48:49.812 --> 04:48:52.181
MEMBER KILEY HERE WILL MOVE TO
04:48:52.248 --> 04:48:54.283
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWELVE TWENTY
04:48:54.350 --> 04:48:55.217
TWENTY DASH ONE OH SIX
04:48:55.284 --> 04:48:58.054
STATEWIDE HOMELESSNESS FUNDING
04:48:58.120 --> 04:48:58.654
ABBAS KILEY WHEN YOU'RE READY
04:48:58.721 --> 04:49:02.825
TO BEGIN. PLEASE. HI HOW ARE
04:49:02.892 --> 04:49:17.073
YOU. DOING ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU
04:49:17.139 --> 04:49:18.374
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS SAID
04:49:18.441 --> 04:49:20.476
EXCEPT FOR GERMANY JAPAN CHINA
04:49:20.543 --> 04:49:22.411
AND THE UNITED STATES ITSELF
04:49:22.478 --> 04:49:23.779
CALIFORNIA IS A STATE PRODUCES
04:49:23.846 --> 04:49:25.381
MORE WEALTH THAN EVERY COUNTRY
04:49:25.448 --> 04:49:27.216
IN THE WORLD YET ON ANY GIVEN
04:49:27.283 --> 04:49:29.785
NIGHT AT LEAST A HUNDRED FIFTY
04:49:29.852 --> 04:49:30.352
THOUSAND OF OUR PEOPLE ARE
04:49:30.419 --> 04:49:31.187
HOMELESS MANY OF THEM VETERANS
04:49:31.253 --> 04:49:33.422
MANY OF THEM CHILDREN. OF THE
04:49:33.489 --> 04:49:34.256
FIVE CITIES IN THE COUNTRY WITH
04:49:34.323 --> 04:49:36.225
THE WORST HOMELESSNESS PROBLEM
04:49:36.292 --> 04:49:39.628
FOR OUR IN CALIFORNIA IN
04:49:39.695 --> 04:49:40.296
201-810-0040 SEVEN HOMELESS
04:49:40.362 --> 04:49:41.263
PEOPLE DIED ON THE STREETS OF
04:49:41.330 --> 04:49:43.466
LOS ANGELES TWICE AS MANY. AS
04:49:43.532 --> 04:49:45.434
JUST A FEW YEARS EARLIER. IN
04:49:45.501 --> 04:49:46.802
HIS STATE OF THE STATE ADDRESS
04:49:46.869 --> 04:49:48.170
GOVERNOR NEW SUMMER RIGHTLY
04:49:48.237 --> 04:49:50.206
CALLED OUR HOMELESSNESS CRISIS
04:49:50.272 --> 04:49:52.375
A DISGRACE. AND IT'S GETTING
04:49:52.441 --> 04:49:53.776
WORSE WELL HOMELESSNESS
04:49:53.843 --> 04:49:55.244
DECLINED IN MOST STATES OVER
04:49:55.311 --> 04:49:56.879
THE PAST YEAR THEY WANT MORE
04:49:56.946 --> 04:50:00.216
THAN 16% IN CALIFORNIA. THAT'S
04:50:00.282 --> 04:50:01.050
TWENTY THOUSAND MORE
04:50:01.117 --> 04:50:03.152
CALIFORNIANS WITHOUT A HOME.
04:50:03.219 --> 04:50:04.787
ACCORDING TO THE GOVERNOR.
04:50:04.854 --> 04:50:06.522
TOTAL STATE FUNDING ACROSS
04:50:06.589 --> 04:50:08.457
MULTIPLE AGENCIES HAS GROWN TWO
04:50:08.524 --> 04:50:10.393
POINT SEVEN BILLION DOLLARS IN
04:50:10.459 --> 04:50:11.727
THE PAST TWO YEARS ALONE WITH
04:50:11.794 --> 04:50:13.262
AN ADDITIONAL ONE POINT FOUR
04:50:13.329 --> 04:50:15.331
BILLION. PROPOSED THIS YEAR.
04:50:15.397 --> 04:50:16.499
NOW GOVERNOR NEWSOME DESERVES
04:50:16.565 --> 04:50:18.567
CREDIT FOR FACING THIS CRISIS
04:50:18.634 --> 04:50:20.569
WITH A SENSE OF URGENCY IT
04:50:20.636 --> 04:50:23.172
DEMANDS. BUT WE CANNOT WAIT
04:50:23.239 --> 04:50:25.107
MONEY SPENT WITH PEOPLE HELPED
04:50:25.174 --> 04:50:26.942
THAT'S NEITHER PRUDENT NOR
04:50:27.009 --> 04:50:29.311
COMPASSIONATE. A RECENT REPORT
04:50:29.378 --> 04:50:30.513
BY THE NONPARTISAN LEGISLATIVE
04:50:30.579 --> 04:50:33.349
ANALYST WARNS THAT NEW FUNDING
04:50:33.415 --> 04:50:35.184
COULD QUICKLY DISSIPATEWITHOUT%
04:50:35.251 --> 04:50:37.153
DEMONSTRATING MUCH PROGRESS IT
04:50:37.219 --> 04:50:38.554
INVESTMENTS ARE MADE WITHOUT A
04:50:38.621 --> 04:50:40.523
CLEAR PLAN. THE REPORT
04:50:40.589 --> 04:50:42.758
CONCLUDES THAT WITHOUT DATA AS
04:50:42.825 --> 04:50:44.894
GUIDEPOSTS SPENDING IS LESS
04:50:44.960 --> 04:50:46.295
LIKELY TO MAKE A MEANINGFUL
04:50:46.362 --> 04:50:48.464
ONGOING IMPACT ON THE STATE'S
04:50:48.531 --> 04:50:50.800
HOMELESSNESS CRISIS. MISTER
04:50:50.866 --> 04:50:52.701
CHAIR THE GOVERNOR UNDERSTANDS
04:50:52.768 --> 04:50:54.136
THAT WE NEED TO DO BETTER THAT
04:50:54.203 --> 04:50:55.638
WE NEED AN EVIDENCE BASED
04:50:55.704 --> 04:50:57.239
STRATEGY THAT'S WHY HE
04:50:57.306 --> 04:50:58.374
EXPLICITLY CALLED FOR A
04:50:58.440 --> 04:51:00.276
COMPREHENSIVE AUDIT IN HIS
04:51:00.342 --> 04:51:02.111
STATE OF THE STATE ADDRESS. IN
04:51:02.178 --> 04:51:03.612
ADDITION THE GOVERNOR'S
04:51:03.679 --> 04:51:05.247
HOMELESSNESS TASK FORCE LED BY
04:51:05.314 --> 04:51:06.615
SACRAMENTO MAYOR DARRELL
04:51:06.682 --> 04:51:08.150
STEINBERG LA COUNTY SUPERVISOR
04:51:08.217 --> 04:51:09.752
MARK LUCE GOOD RITAM RIDLEY
04:51:09.819 --> 04:51:11.320
THOMAS MADE THE SAME POINT. ITS
04:51:11.387 --> 04:51:12.955
REPORT CONCLUDES THAT IN ORDER
04:51:13.022 --> 04:51:14.657
TO EXPAND ACCESS TO MENTAL
04:51:14.723 --> 04:51:15.958
HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE ABUSE
04:51:16.025 --> 04:51:17.026
TREATMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS
04:51:17.092 --> 04:51:18.627
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS THE
04:51:18.694 --> 04:51:19.895
STATE SHOULD WORK IN TANDEM
04:51:19.962 --> 04:51:21.297
WITH COUNTIES TO ENSURE THAT
04:51:21.363 --> 04:51:23.465
EXISTING FUNDING. ALIGNS WITH
04:51:23.532 --> 04:51:25.601
THE STATE'S GOALS TO IMPROVE
04:51:25.668 --> 04:51:27.770
ACCESS TO TREATMENT. TO GUIDE
04:51:27.837 --> 04:51:29.705
ANY ADDITIONAL INVESTMENTS WE
04:51:29.772 --> 04:51:30.940
NEED TO ASK THE BASIC YET
04:51:31.006 --> 04:51:33.142
IMPORTANT QUESTIONS. WHERE ARE
04:51:33.209 --> 04:51:34.844
THESE DOLLARS GOING HOW ARE
04:51:34.910 --> 04:51:36.278
THEY BEING SPENT AND WHAT
04:51:36.345 --> 04:51:38.147
OUTCOMES ARE WE ACHIEVING.
04:51:38.214 --> 04:51:39.381
THESE ARE THE QUESTIONS I SEEK
04:51:39.448 --> 04:51:41.917
TO ANSWER IN THIS REQUEST FOR A
04:51:41.984 --> 04:51:42.918
STATE WIDE ON IT OF
04:51:42.985 --> 04:51:43.919
HOMELESSNESS SPENDING TO HELP
04:51:43.986 --> 04:51:46.555
US BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT IS
04:51:46.622 --> 04:51:49.725
AND IS NOT WORKING IN OUR USE
04:51:49.792 --> 04:51:50.759
OF EXISTING RESOURCES NOTE WHAT
04:51:50.826 --> 04:51:52.428
IS IT. IS NOT THERE'S A LOT
04:51:52.494 --> 04:51:54.163
TEMAS I'M SURE BEING DONE THAT
04:51:54.230 --> 04:51:55.331
ARE WORKING QUITE WELL AND WE
04:51:55.397 --> 04:51:57.233
WANT TO IDENTIFY WHAT THOSE
04:51:57.299 --> 04:51:58.767
ARE. SO WE CAN DO MORE OF THEM.
04:51:58.834 --> 04:51:59.869
THE AUDIT ONE SURE THAT
04:51:59.935 --> 04:52:01.570
SPENDING IS TRACKED AND RESULTS
04:52:01.637 --> 04:52:02.938
ARE MEASURED TO HELP THE
04:52:03.005 --> 04:52:05.040
LEGISLATURE PRIORITIZE. THE
04:52:05.107 --> 04:52:06.141
MOST EFFECTIVE STRATEGIES IT'LL
04:52:06.208 --> 04:52:08.077
HELP US. TO MEASURE PROGRESS IN
04:52:08.143 --> 04:52:10.079
THE WAY THE MAPS. HELPING OUR
04:52:10.145 --> 04:52:12.581
FELLOW CALIFORNIANS ARE
04:52:12.648 --> 04:52:13.249
CONSTITUENTS. TRANSITION OUT OF
04:52:13.315 --> 04:52:14.550
HOMELESSNESS. OR AVOIDED
04:52:14.617 --> 04:52:18.320
ALTOGETHER. THIS PROPOSAL HAS
04:52:18.387 --> 04:52:20.322
OVERWHELMING PUBLIC SUPPORT.
04:52:20.389 --> 04:52:21.824
THE US THE SCHWARZENEGGER
04:52:21.891 --> 04:52:22.958
INSTITUTE AND PRICE SCHOOL OF
04:52:23.025 --> 04:52:24.927
PUBLIC CALL UPON THE SEA. JUST
04:52:24.994 --> 04:52:27.363
CONDUCTED A POLL THAT TESTED
04:52:27.429 --> 04:52:29.765
THIS SPECIFIC AUDIT REQUEST.
04:52:29.832 --> 04:52:31.200
EIGHTY SEVEN POINT 5% OF
04:52:31.267 --> 04:52:33.769
CALIFORNIANS ARE IN SUPPORT.
04:52:33.836 --> 04:52:34.703
EIGHTY SEVEN FIVE POINT 5%
04:52:34.770 --> 04:52:36.272
THAT'S WELL ABOVE ANY OTHER
04:52:36.338 --> 04:52:37.973
PROPOSAL AND FRANKLY A LEVEL OF
04:52:38.040 --> 04:52:40.175
CONSENSUS RARELY SEEN IN
04:52:40.242 --> 04:52:42.344
POLITICS. AND OF COURSE RECENT
04:52:42.411 --> 04:52:44.313
SURVEYS CONSISTENTLY SHOW THAT
04:52:44.380 --> 04:52:45.714
CALIFORNIANS YOU HOMELESSNESS
04:52:45.781 --> 04:52:48.484
AS THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT
04:52:48.550 --> 04:52:50.019
ISSUE FACING THE STATE. IN
04:52:50.085 --> 04:52:53.589
OTHER WORDS THIS PROPOSAL IS
04:52:53.656 --> 04:52:54.757
WHAT THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA
04:52:54.823 --> 04:52:57.993
C. AS THE MOST PROMISING STEP
04:52:58.060 --> 04:52:58.661
FORWARD FOR OUR STATE MOST
04:52:58.727 --> 04:53:01.030
SERIOUS PROBLEM. THE PUBLIC
04:53:01.096 --> 04:53:02.665
UNDERSTANDS THIS AUDIT CAN
04:53:02.731 --> 04:53:04.366
PROVIDE THE FOUNDATION FOR A
04:53:04.433 --> 04:53:06.402
SMARTER AND MORE COMPASSIONATE
04:53:06.468 --> 04:53:09.338
APPROACH THE HOMELESSNESS. AND
04:53:09.405 --> 04:53:10.806
THE GOVERNOR UNDERSTANDS THAT
04:53:10.873 --> 04:53:12.074
TOO AS HE SAID IN THE STATE OF
04:53:12.141 --> 04:53:13.842
THE STATE MORE MONEY IS NOT
04:53:13.909 --> 04:53:15.244
GOING TO SOLVE THIS ALONE WE
04:53:15.311 --> 04:53:17.012
NEED REAL ACCOUNTABILITY AND
04:53:17.079 --> 04:53:20.049
TRANSPARENCY. THANK YOU AND I
04:53:20.115 --> 04:53:22.484
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR HIGH THAT.
04:53:22.551 --> 04:53:24.186
THANK YOU- MATTER MONITOR
04:53:24.253 --> 04:53:25.354
PLEASE THANK YOU MISTER
04:53:25.421 --> 04:53:26.588
CHAIRMAN AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER
04:53:26.655 --> 04:53:28.457
KILEY INDICATED THIS IS A AN
04:53:28.524 --> 04:53:29.725
AUDIT OF HOMELESSNESS IN
04:53:29.792 --> 04:53:31.126
CALIFORNIA CERTAINLY LOOKING AT
04:53:31.193 --> 04:53:32.528
FUNDING AND THE EFFECTIVENESS
04:53:32.594 --> 04:53:34.430
OF THAT FUNDING SO WHAT HE HAS
04:53:34.496 --> 04:53:35.831
ASKED US TO DO IS TO LOOK AT A
04:53:35.898 --> 04:53:37.967
THREE YEAR WINDOW AS FAR AS THE
04:53:38.033 --> 04:53:38.534
STATE BUDGET STARTING WITH
04:53:38.600 --> 04:53:40.135
FISCAL YEAR SEVENTEEN EIGHTEEN.
04:53:40.202 --> 04:53:42.271
A CONTINUING THROUGH NINETEEN
04:53:42.338 --> 04:53:43.038
TWENTY LOOKING AT HOMELESSNESS
04:53:43.105 --> 04:53:45.207
FUNDING INCLUDING ANY EMERGENCY
04:53:45.274 --> 04:53:47.076
A PROVIDED TO LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
04:53:47.142 --> 04:53:49.044
ALSO LOOKING AT APPROPRIATIONS
04:53:49.111 --> 04:53:50.079
THAT WERE IDENTIFIED A
04:53:50.145 --> 04:53:51.613
REFERENCED IN RECENT EXECUTIVE
04:53:51.680 --> 04:53:53.015
ORDER THAT THE GOVERNOR SIGNED
04:53:53.082 --> 04:53:54.383
AND A VARIETY OF THINGS HE'S
04:53:54.450 --> 04:53:55.751
ASKING US IDENTIFY RESPONSIBLE
04:53:55.818 --> 04:53:58.220
STATE AGENCIES LOCAL ENTITIES
04:53:58.287 --> 04:54:00.155
THE FUNDING SOURCE OR COMPONENT
04:54:00.222 --> 04:54:01.724
FOR EACH OF THOSE ENTITIES. THE
04:54:01.790 --> 04:54:02.925
PERCENTAGE OF FUNDING THAT IS
04:54:02.992 --> 04:54:04.626
BEING DIRECTLY OR PRIMARILY
04:54:04.693 --> 04:54:05.761
FOCUSED ON REDUCING THE
04:54:05.828 --> 04:54:07.529
HOMELESSNESS POPULATION ARE THE
04:54:07.596 --> 04:54:08.330
HOMELESS POPULATION IN
04:54:08.397 --> 04:54:10.599
CALIFORNIA IN ADDITION THE
04:54:10.666 --> 04:54:12.067
DEPLOYMENT CLIMATE OF THESE
04:54:12.134 --> 04:54:14.303
EMERGENCY AID FUND IT ARE THOSE
04:54:14.370 --> 04:54:16.271
FUNDS ACHIEVING MEASURABLE
04:54:16.338 --> 04:54:19.074
RESULTS CERTAINLY IN THE SHORT
04:54:19.141 --> 04:54:20.909
TERM ALSO LOOKING AT A
04:54:20.976 --> 04:54:24.146
SELECTION OF LOCAL AGENCIES GET
04:54:24.213 --> 04:54:27.549
IT TO THE LOWER LEVEL IN
04:54:27.616 --> 04:54:31.186
UNDERSTANDING WHAT THE **** WAS
04:54:31.253 --> 04:54:32.588
ACTUAL TO KILEY INDICATED
04:54:32.654 --> 04:54:35.324
PREVENTING AT RISK IN THE- FROM
04:54:35.391 --> 04:54:39.928
BE. HOME I LAST US TRY TO BUY
04:54:39.995 --> 04:54:43.098
IN A TO MAKE COST POSIT COM AT
04:54:43.165 --> 04:54:45.367
BY THE OF FUN. AND WHETHER OR
04:54:45.434 --> 04:54:46.902
NOT THESE CAN BE TRACK AND CAN
04:54:46.969 --> 04:54:48.837
BE PER SEEN TOWARDS BEAT
04:54:48.904 --> 04:54:50.973
MEASURABLE GOALS THAT HAVE BEEN
04:54:51.040 --> 04:54:56.979
A STE I'M. IN THE EXECUTIVE
04:54:57.046 --> 04:54:58.580
ORDER WHETHER OR NOT THE STORE
04:54:58.647 --> 04:55:00.082
STATE AND LOCAL AGENCIES ARE
04:55:00.149 --> 04:55:01.884
DEFINING. THEIR MEASURES OF
04:55:01.950 --> 04:55:03.852
SUCCESS WHETHER OR NOT FUNDING
04:55:03.919 --> 04:55:06.388
IS ACTUALLY TIED TO OUTCOMES-
04:55:06.455 --> 04:55:08.490
AND- FOR HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS
04:55:08.557 --> 04:55:10.059
AND INDIVIDUALS AT RISK OF
04:55:10.125 --> 04:55:11.660
BECOMING HOMELESS. A WHETHER OR
04:55:11.727 --> 04:55:13.195
NOT THE STATE LOCAL ENTITIES
04:55:13.262 --> 04:55:15.597
ARE ACTUALLY CALCULATING AND A-
04:55:15.664 --> 04:55:17.800
ASSESSING AND EVALUATING COST
04:55:17.866 --> 04:55:19.501
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE- THE
04:55:19.568 --> 04:55:20.869
MEASURES THAT THEY'VE PUT INTO
04:55:20.936 --> 04:55:22.404
PLACE TO TRY TO ADDRESS OTHER
04:55:22.471 --> 04:55:23.806
HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS OR THOSE
04:55:23.872 --> 04:55:26.108
AT RISK OF BECOMING HOMELESS- A
04:55:26.175 --> 04:55:27.576
COUPLE OF OTHER OBJECTIVE SEIZE
04:55:27.643 --> 04:55:29.578
ASSETS. IS THE TRANSPARENCY CAN
04:55:29.645 --> 04:55:31.380
THE PUBLIC TRACK THESE POSITIVE
04:55:31.447 --> 04:55:33.182
OUTCOMES BY A VARIETY OF
04:55:33.248 --> 04:55:35.484
DIFFERENT- SPECIFIC POPULATIONS
04:55:35.551 --> 04:55:37.653
CAL WORKS FAMILY SENIORS YOUTH
04:55:37.719 --> 04:55:39.855
FOSTER YOUTH. UP FOLKS WITH A
04:55:39.922 --> 04:55:41.690
MENTAL ILLNESS AND OTHERS-
04:55:41.757 --> 04:55:43.959
SUFFERING ARE VICTIMS OF
04:55:44.026 --> 04:55:45.194
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN ADDITION
04:55:45.260 --> 04:55:46.762
MR KILEY IS ASKING US TO LOOK
04:55:46.829 --> 04:55:48.597
AT STATE LOCAL ENTITIES AS FAR
04:55:48.664 --> 04:55:49.865
AS COORDINATION. ARE WITH
04:55:49.932 --> 04:55:51.834
RESPECT THE DECISION MAKING IS
04:55:51.900 --> 04:55:53.268
THAT ADEQUATE OVERSIGHT
04:55:53.335 --> 04:55:55.504
COORDINATION AND TRACKING OF
04:55:55.571 --> 04:55:56.939
EXPENDITURES THAT OUR CURRENT
04:55:57.005 --> 04:55:57.706
BOTH AT THE STATE AND LOCAL
04:55:57.773 --> 04:55:59.208
LEVEL. ARE THERE ANY IT
04:55:59.274 --> 04:56:01.009
REDUNDANT IS THAT EXIST ON
04:56:01.076 --> 04:56:03.178
EARTH TING. THE COORDINATED
04:56:03.245 --> 04:56:05.013
RESPONSE THE EXPENDITURES AND
04:56:05.080 --> 04:56:06.248
THEN AGAIN TYING BACK TO
04:56:06.315 --> 04:56:08.050
ACCOUNTABILITY METRICS A
04:56:08.117 --> 04:56:09.051
DETERMINING WHETHER THESE
04:56:09.118 --> 04:56:10.919
METRICS ARE ACKLES. ADEQUATE
04:56:10.986 --> 04:56:13.055
EXCUSE ME TO MEASURE THE
04:56:13.122 --> 04:56:14.256
SUCCESS OF EXPENDITURES NOT
04:56:14.323 --> 04:56:15.657
ONLY TODAY BUT IN THE FUTURE
04:56:15.724 --> 04:56:16.892
ARE THESE THE RIGHT MEASURES
04:56:16.959 --> 04:56:18.260
THAT THAT THE STATE OF
04:56:18.327 --> 04:56:19.962
CALIFORNIA SHOULD BE USING. TO
04:56:20.028 --> 04:56:21.430
DETERMINE WHETHER NOT THE STATE
04:56:21.497 --> 04:56:25.734
IS A CHEAP. THE GOAL OF
04:56:25.801 --> 04:56:26.235
REDUCING AND- FULLY SOME
04:56:26.301 --> 04:56:27.870
ELIMINATE HOMELESS CALIFORNIA
04:56:27.936 --> 04:56:30.038
AND THEN HIS LAST QUESTION IS
04:56:30.105 --> 04:56:32.040
ASKING FOR SUGGESTIONS. AND
04:56:32.107 --> 04:56:33.542
DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT THERE
04:56:33.609 --> 04:56:35.177
NEED TO BE SOME LEGISLATIVE OR
04:56:35.244 --> 04:56:37.579
EXECUTIVE POLICY CHANGES- TO
04:56:37.646 --> 04:56:39.314
STRENGTHENED. CALIFORNIA'S
04:56:39.381 --> 04:56:40.415
APPROACH TO ACHIEVING
04:56:40.482 --> 04:56:42.484
MEASURABLE RESULTS WITH RESPECT
04:56:42.551 --> 04:56:43.485
TO REDUCING HOMELESSNESS IN
04:56:43.552 --> 04:56:45.320
CALIFORNIA THE BUDGET FOR THIS
04:56:45.387 --> 04:56:46.822
AUDIT ABOUT THIRTY THREE
04:56:46.889 --> 04:56:48.891
HUNDRED HOURS- THAT WOULD TAKE
04:56:48.957 --> 04:56:50.425
US ABOUT EIGHT MONTHS TO
04:56:50.492 --> 04:56:51.994
COMPLETE- WE COULD REDUCE THE
04:56:52.060 --> 04:56:54.396
AMOUNT OF TIME- IF WE PUT MORE
04:56:54.463 --> 04:56:56.231
TEAMS. ARE ON THIS PARTICULAR
04:56:56.298 --> 04:56:57.432
AUDIT REALLY WILL DEPEND UPON
04:56:57.499 --> 04:56:58.600
HOW MANY ON IT'S THE COMMITTEE
04:56:58.667 --> 04:57:00.235
APPROVED TODAY WITH THAT MISTER
04:57:00.302 --> 04:57:01.870
CHAIR ALTERNATE BACK TO YOU.
04:57:01.937 --> 04:57:04.773
THANK YOU MADAM WATER LET'S GO
04:57:04.840 --> 04:57:05.274
TO MOVE TO THE AFFECTED
04:57:05.340 --> 04:57:27.296
AGENCIES. PLEASE. GOOD
04:57:27.362 --> 04:57:28.797
AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
04:57:28.864 --> 04:57:32.367
MAP UNDER THE SUN KEPT. MATT
04:57:32.434 --> 04:57:33.802
BETTER ACTING DEPUTY DIRECTOR
04:57:33.869 --> 04:57:34.970
FOR LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS AT THE
04:57:35.037 --> 04:57:36.438
DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES
04:57:36.505 --> 04:57:39.408
THANK YOU FOR THE INVITATION OF
04:57:39.474 --> 04:57:40.842
DTS IS INVOLVEMENT HOMELESSNESS
04:57:40.909 --> 04:57:42.144
BEGAN SEVEN WEEKS AGO WHEN THE
04:57:42.211 --> 04:57:43.845
GOVERNOR ISSUED EXECUTIVE ORDER
04:57:43.912 --> 04:57:45.814
AND TWENTY THREE TWENTY UNDER
04:57:45.881 --> 04:57:47.683
THAT ODER DTS WAS DIRECTED TO
04:57:47.749 --> 04:57:49.117
REFUSED STATE OWNED PROPERTY TO
04:57:49.184 --> 04:57:50.886
IDENTIFY SITES. THE COULD BE
04:57:50.953 --> 04:57:52.754
USED BY LOCAL PARTNERS FOR
04:57:52.821 --> 04:57:54.122
SHORT TERM EMERGENCY SHELTER
04:57:54.189 --> 04:57:55.891
FOOD NAG REVIEWED FAIRGROUNDS
04:57:55.958 --> 04:57:57.426
OFSHE FED ASSIST BACON
04:57:57.492 --> 04:57:59.127
HEALTHCARE FACILITIES CALTRANS
04:57:59.194 --> 04:58:00.762
DEVELOPED A MODEL LEAST
04:58:00.829 --> 04:58:01.964
TEMPLATE FOR ITS PROPERTY.
04:58:02.030 --> 04:58:03.899
WE'VE IDENTIFIED TWO HUNDRED
04:58:03.966 --> 04:58:04.366
EIGHTY SIX STATE OWNED
04:58:04.433 --> 04:58:05.567
PROPERTIES MOSTLY CALTRANS THAT
04:58:05.634 --> 04:58:06.702
ARE AVAILABLE FOR LOCAL
04:58:06.768 --> 04:58:08.270
PARTNERS INTERESTED PROVIDING
04:58:08.337 --> 04:58:10.072
EMERGENCY SHELTER. GOVERNOR
04:58:10.138 --> 04:58:11.740
ANNOUNCED THE AVAILABILITY THE
04:58:11.807 --> 04:58:14.610
MAP ON FRIDAY. ADIDAS IS ALSO
04:58:14.676 --> 04:58:15.611
PROVIDING NINETEEN I TRAVEL
04:58:15.677 --> 04:58:17.312
TRAILERS TO LOCAL AGENCIES TO
04:58:17.379 --> 04:58:19.314
ASSIST PROVIDING SHELTER OF THE
04:58:19.381 --> 04:58:20.682
EXECUTIVE ORDER CALLS FOR
04:58:20.749 --> 04:58:21.717
ACCOUNTABILITY METRICS AND
04:58:21.783 --> 04:58:23.452
REGULAR POSTING OF DATA
04:58:23.518 --> 04:58:24.886
GOVERNOR STAY THE STATE LIKE
04:58:24.953 --> 04:58:27.155
WAS EMPHASIZED. METRICS
04:58:27.222 --> 04:58:28.557
ACCOUNTABILITY AND MATCHING
04:58:28.624 --> 04:58:30.892
RESOURCES TO RESULTS THAT'S
04:58:30.959 --> 04:58:31.426
SOMETHING ALL OF US TAKE
04:58:31.493 --> 04:58:33.662
SERIOUSLY- WITH RESPECT TO THE
04:58:33.729 --> 04:58:34.730
AUTO REQUEST WE OFFER THE
04:58:34.796 --> 04:58:36.498
FOLLOWING COMMENTS FIRST AND
04:58:36.565 --> 04:58:37.799
FOREMOST WILL COOPERATE FULLY
04:58:37.866 --> 04:58:38.800
WITH ANY AUDIT REQUEST BY THE
04:58:38.867 --> 04:58:40.469
COMMITTEE THAT'S TRUE OF DTS
04:58:40.535 --> 04:58:42.204
AND I THINK IT'S- TRUE THE
04:58:42.271 --> 04:58:44.206
OTHER DEPARTMENTS HERE TODAY-
04:58:44.273 --> 04:58:45.407
THAT SAID WE KNOW THAT WE JUST
04:58:45.474 --> 04:58:45.874
START IMPLEMENTING THE
04:58:45.941 --> 04:58:47.576
EXECUTIVE ORDER SEVEN WEEKS AGO
04:58:47.643 --> 04:58:49.745
SO IT MAY BE. A LITTLE EARLY TO
04:58:49.811 --> 04:58:51.380
ASSESS THE EFFECTIVENESS OF OUR
04:58:51.446 --> 04:58:53.348
EFFORTS ANOTHER FACTOR TO
04:58:53.415 --> 04:58:54.316
CONSIDER IS THAT THE BUDGET
04:58:54.383 --> 04:58:56.118
PROCESS IS ALREADY UNDER WAY
04:58:56.184 --> 04:58:58.287
BUDGET COMMITTEES ARE RIVER.
04:58:58.353 --> 04:58:59.421
ARE REVIEWING ALL THE STATE'S
04:58:59.488 --> 04:59:00.722
PLANS PRIORITIES WITH RESPECT
04:59:00.789 --> 04:59:02.591
HOMELESSNESS FUNDING ASSEMBLY
04:59:02.658 --> 04:59:04.726
SUB SIX HELD A HEARING TWO
04:59:04.793 --> 04:59:05.894
WEEKS AGO ASSEMBLY JUST SUBS
04:59:05.961 --> 04:59:08.830
WANT FOR LAST WEEK AND A SENATE
04:59:08.897 --> 04:59:10.332
FULL BUDGET IS MEETING TOMORROW
04:59:10.399 --> 04:59:12.200
ON THIS. UNFORTUNATELY IN ORDER
04:59:12.267 --> 04:59:14.036
TO PROVE TODAY AS THE AUDITOR
04:59:14.102 --> 04:59:15.137
INDICATE WOULD NOT BE READY IN
04:59:15.203 --> 04:59:17.205
TIME TO INFORM THE IMPORTANT
04:59:17.272 --> 04:59:18.674
BUDGET DECISIONS MADE BEING
04:59:18.740 --> 04:59:20.542
MADE THIS YEAR- WITH RESPECT TO
04:59:20.609 --> 04:59:22.477
THE ISSUES THE COMMITTEE HAS
04:59:22.544 --> 04:59:23.045
BEEN HAVING A DISCUSSION ON
04:59:23.111 --> 04:59:25.514
THROUGHOUT THE HEARING- DTS
04:59:25.580 --> 04:59:26.481
FIRST EARNED ABOUT THIS REQUEST
04:59:26.548 --> 04:59:28.617
FROM THESE LETTER A WEEK AGO.
04:59:28.684 --> 04:59:30.952
ADEN ANOTHER REQUEST YEARS HAD
04:59:31.019 --> 04:59:35.624
CONTACTED DTS A RIVER IN THIS
04:59:35.691 --> 04:59:36.291
REQUEST. EXECUTIVE OR OR- SINCE
04:59:36.358 --> 04:59:38.794
THE EXECUTIVE WAS. I ALSO.
04:59:38.860 --> 04:59:41.229
WOULD LIKE THE OPPORTUNITY TO A
04:59:41.296 --> 04:59:43.598
READ THE FULL SECTION OF THE
04:59:43.665 --> 04:59:45.267
GOVERNOR'S STATE OF THE STATE
04:59:45.334 --> 04:59:46.935
THAT I BELIEVE WAS QUOTED IN
04:59:47.002 --> 04:59:51.573
PART. THE GOVERNOR- WAS. WELL
04:59:51.640 --> 04:59:53.642
INTO HIS SPEECH AT THIS POINT.
04:59:53.709 --> 04:59:54.843
SOME OF REQUIRE THE YEARS WHAT
04:59:54.910 --> 04:59:56.712
HE SAID SOME OF RECOMMENDED A
04:59:56.778 --> 04:59:58.513
LEGAL RIGHT TO SHELTER IT'S A
04:59:58.580 --> 04:59:59.848
PROVOCATIVE IDEA WHICH FORCED
04:59:59.915 --> 05:00:01.016
THE STATE TO EXPLORE THE LIMITS
05:00:01.083 --> 05:00:02.184
OF WHAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN
05:00:02.250 --> 05:00:04.219
BE COMPELLED TO DO. RIGHT NOW
05:00:04.286 --> 05:00:05.454
OUR IMPERATIVE MUST BE BRING
05:00:05.520 --> 05:00:07.189
GOVERNMENTS TOGETHER AS WORKING
05:00:07.255 --> 05:00:08.990
PARTNERS NOT SPARRING PARTNERS
05:00:09.057 --> 05:00:11.159
IN A COURT OF LAW. SO INSTEAD
05:00:11.226 --> 05:00:11.893
WE ARE PROPOSING STRICT
05:00:11.960 --> 05:00:13.562
ACCOUNTABILITY COMPREHENSIVE
05:00:13.628 --> 05:00:15.097
AUDITS AND A DO IT OR LOSE IT
05:00:15.163 --> 05:00:16.164
POLICY TO HOLD LOCAL
05:00:16.231 --> 05:00:17.332
GOVERNMENTS RESPONSIBLE FOR
05:00:17.399 --> 05:00:19.534
RESULTS TAKE ACTION OR LOSE
05:00:19.601 --> 05:00:21.336
ACCESS TO THIS NEW FUNDING I
05:00:21.403 --> 05:00:23.071
MENTION THIS ONLY TO NOTE THAT
05:00:23.138 --> 05:00:24.940
THE ISSUE OF COMPREHENSIVE
05:00:25.006 --> 05:00:26.341
AUDITS WAS REYES SPECIFICALLY
05:00:26.408 --> 05:00:27.809
RESPECT WITH RESPECT TO STATE
05:00:27.876 --> 05:00:29.978
AND LOCAL RELATIONS. THANK YOU
05:00:30.045 --> 05:00:31.480
THANK YOU ADDITIONAL TESTIMONY
05:00:31.546 --> 05:00:33.482
PLEASE. YES GOOD AFTERNOON
05:00:33.548 --> 05:00:34.449
MISTER CHAIRMAN THANK YOU FOR
05:00:34.516 --> 05:00:36.118
HAVING ME I AM ERIC ROSE OKAY
05:00:36.184 --> 05:00:37.652
AND THE ACTING CHIEF DEPUTY
05:00:37.719 --> 05:00:39.354
DIRECTOR AT THE OFFICE OF
05:00:39.421 --> 05:00:40.055
STATEWIDE HEALTH PLANNING AND
05:00:40.122 --> 05:00:41.256
DEVELOPMENT. AS FAR AS I
05:00:41.323 --> 05:00:42.858
UNDERSTAND- I'VE BEEN INVITED
05:00:42.924 --> 05:00:43.992
TODAY TO GIVE YOU A BRIEF
05:00:44.059 --> 05:00:47.028
UPDATE ON OUR ROLE IN THE- A
05:00:47.095 --> 05:00:49.064
RECENT EXECUTIVE ORDER. SO PER
05:00:49.131 --> 05:00:51.466
THE JANUARY NINE- TWENTY TWENTY
05:00:51.533 --> 05:00:52.634
EXECUTIVE ORDER OFSHE BID
05:00:52.701 --> 05:00:54.136
CONDUCTED AN INITIAL ASSESSMENT
05:00:54.202 --> 05:00:55.370
OF THE APPROPRIATENESS AND
05:00:55.437 --> 05:00:57.205
AVAILABILITY OF VACANT AND
05:00:57.272 --> 05:00:59.174
DECOMMISSIONED HOSPITALS. AND
05:00:59.241 --> 05:01:00.942
HEALTHCARE FACILITIES FOR USE
05:01:01.009 --> 05:01:02.344
BY LOCAL PARTNERS ON A SHORT
05:01:02.411 --> 05:01:04.146
TERM EMERGENCY BASIS. TO
05:01:04.212 --> 05:01:05.914
PROVIDE SHELTER FOR INDIVIDUALS
05:01:05.981 --> 05:01:08.183
WHO ARE HOMELESS. IN JANUARY
05:01:08.250 --> 05:01:09.851
TEN AWESOMENESS OFSTED BEGAN
05:01:09.918 --> 05:01:11.953
THE PROCESS TO IDENTIFY.
05:01:12.020 --> 05:01:14.256
POTENTIAL CANDIDATES THAT MIGHT
05:01:14.322 --> 05:01:17.159
BE AVAILABLE FOR THIS PURPOSE-
05:01:17.225 --> 05:01:19.161
A JANUARY FOURTEEN ARCH BIDS
05:01:19.227 --> 05:01:20.295
INITIAL ASSESSMENT WAS
05:01:20.362 --> 05:01:22.197
COMPLETE. WITH FORTY TWO
05:01:22.264 --> 05:01:23.732
POTENTIAL ADDED SITES IN
05:01:23.799 --> 05:01:24.666
EIGHTEEN COUNTIES WERE
05:01:24.733 --> 05:01:26.067
IDENTIFIED THAT HAVE ONE OR
05:01:26.134 --> 05:01:27.536
MORE BUILDINGS THAT ARE EITHER
05:01:27.602 --> 05:01:29.237
VACANT. OR WHOSE CURRENT USE
05:01:29.304 --> 05:01:31.173
COULD NOT BE EASILY DETERMINED.
05:01:31.239 --> 05:01:33.275
AND WE'RE STANDING BY- IN THE
05:01:33.341 --> 05:01:34.843
EVENT UP FOR THE FOLLOW UP IS
05:01:34.910 --> 05:01:37.112
NEEDED THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
05:01:37.179 --> 05:01:38.280
THE SMELL TEST RUN THE PLACE
05:01:38.346 --> 05:01:39.448
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR AND
05:01:39.514 --> 05:01:40.882
MEMBERS ARE TARA BROUGHT US
05:01:40.949 --> 05:01:42.517
DEPUTY SECRETARY AT THE
05:01:42.584 --> 05:01:43.718
DEPARTMENT OF FOOD AND
05:01:43.785 --> 05:01:45.454
AGRICULTURE. MY COMMENTS ARE
05:01:45.520 --> 05:01:46.588
SIMILAR TO THOSE OF MY
05:01:46.655 --> 05:01:48.256
COLLEAGUES FROM POSH PENDANT
05:01:48.323 --> 05:01:50.258
FROM CAL TRANS WE WERE TASKED
05:01:50.325 --> 05:01:52.260
TO THE SPECIFIC ASSESSMENT. OF
05:01:52.327 --> 05:01:54.262
THE FAIRGROUNDS. I'M HAPPY TO
05:01:54.329 --> 05:01:56.231
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS- ALI MY
05:01:56.298 --> 05:01:57.599
COMMENTS AT THAT AND JUST MAKE
05:01:57.666 --> 05:01:58.233
MYSELF AVAILABLE IF THERE'S ANY
05:01:58.300 --> 05:02:01.036
FOLLOW UP QUESTIONS THANK.
05:02:01.102 --> 05:02:02.604
THANK YOU PLEASE MISTER CHAIR
05:02:02.671 --> 05:02:03.805
MY NAME IS JIM OF THE CHIEF
05:02:03.872 --> 05:02:05.874
DIRECTOR AT CALTRANS IN HERE TO
05:02:05.941 --> 05:02:07.142
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS YOU MAY
05:02:07.209 --> 05:02:09.077
HAVE. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT WITH
05:02:09.144 --> 05:02:12.280
THAT LET'S- RETURN IT BACK TO
05:02:12.347 --> 05:02:12.781
MEMBERS ON THE DíAS FOR
05:02:12.848 --> 05:02:16.117
QUESTIONS. RIGHT HEARING AND
05:02:16.184 --> 05:02:17.052
SEEING ON THAT MEANS IT'S VERY
05:02:17.118 --> 05:02:18.753
STRAIGHTFORWARD WE DID TALK
05:02:18.820 --> 05:02:19.988
ABOUT SOME OF THESE ISSUES
05:02:20.055 --> 05:02:22.557
ALREADY AN AGENDA ITEM- TWENTY
05:02:22.624 --> 05:02:23.391
TWENTY DASH ONE ONE TWO AS
05:02:23.458 --> 05:02:25.627
WELL. SO WITH THAT LET'S GO
05:02:25.694 --> 05:02:27.629
AHEAD AND THERE'S NO QUESTIONS
05:02:27.696 --> 05:02:28.897
FOR MEMBERS OF FROM THE DíAS
05:02:28.964 --> 05:02:30.799
LET'S GO TO TURN TO. PUBLIC
05:02:30.866 --> 05:02:33.802
COMMENTS. PUBLIC COMMENT ON
05:02:33.869 --> 05:02:39.674
THIS ITEM. HI MR KILEY WOULD
05:02:39.741 --> 05:02:42.210
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE- YES I JUST-
05:02:42.277 --> 05:02:44.045
I THINK THE COMMITTEE FOR YOUR
05:02:44.112 --> 05:02:45.881
CONSIDERATION- AND I JUST WANT
05:02:45.947 --> 05:02:47.616
TO EMPHASIZE THAT THE ISSUE OF
05:02:47.682 --> 05:02:49.084
HOMELESSNESS RIGHT NOW THE
05:02:49.150 --> 05:02:50.185
GOVERNOR HAS RECOGNIZED AS A
05:02:50.252 --> 05:02:51.887
TOP PRIORITY- CALIFORNIA'S OF
05:02:51.953 --> 05:02:53.188
ALL PARTY AFFILIATIONS
05:02:53.255 --> 05:02:54.956
IDENTIFIED AS THE MOST PRESSING
05:02:55.023 --> 05:02:57.425
ISSUE FACING THE STATE AND WHEN
05:02:57.492 --> 05:02:58.360
IT COMES TO THE DIFFERENCE
05:02:58.426 --> 05:02:59.961
BETWEEN SPENDING MONEY AND SPUN
05:03:00.028 --> 05:03:01.463
SPENDING AND EFFECTIVELY.
05:03:01.530 --> 05:03:02.230
THAT'S THE DIFFERENCE THAT
05:03:02.297 --> 05:03:03.431
REALLY MATTERS FOR FOLKS WHO
05:03:03.498 --> 05:03:05.166
ARE STRUGGLING WITH
05:03:05.233 --> 05:03:06.535
HOMELESSNESS THAT CAN BE THE
05:03:06.601 --> 05:03:07.669
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN LIFE AND
05:03:07.736 --> 05:03:08.904
DEATH THAT CAN BE THE
05:03:08.970 --> 05:03:10.372
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TURNING YOUR
05:03:10.438 --> 05:03:11.940
LIFE AROUND AND STARTING A
05:03:12.007 --> 05:03:13.141
FAMILY IN PURSUING YOUR DREAMS
05:03:13.208 --> 05:03:15.844
OR- YOU KNOW WITH THE RING TO
05:03:15.911 --> 05:03:17.445
MENTAL ILLNESS OR DRUG
05:03:17.512 --> 05:03:19.681
ADDICTION AND SO IF WE CAN HAVE
05:03:19.748 --> 05:03:21.550
THE DATA THE WILL HELP US
05:03:21.616 --> 05:03:22.884
IDENTIFY WHAT STRATEGIES ARE
05:03:22.951 --> 05:03:24.653
WHAT. AND WHICH ONES ARTS YOU
05:03:24.719 --> 05:03:26.621
CAN GET THAT HIGHEST IMPACT AND
05:03:26.688 --> 05:03:28.223
DO THE MOST GOOD WITH THE FUNDS
05:03:28.290 --> 05:03:29.424
WE HAVE I THINK THAT'S
05:03:29.491 --> 05:03:30.559
SOMETHING THAT'S WELL WORTH
05:03:30.625 --> 05:03:31.593
THAT AT THE TIME OF THE
05:03:31.660 --> 05:03:32.761
AUDITOR'S OFFICE IT WOULD BE A
05:03:32.827 --> 05:03:34.696
VERY VALUABLE TOOL TO INFORM
05:03:34.763 --> 05:03:36.231
OUR POLICY MAKING FOR THE REST
05:03:36.298 --> 05:03:37.332
OF IT THE ARMY ON BUT
05:03:37.399 --> 05:03:39.968
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR ABOUT. OR
05:03:40.035 --> 05:03:41.570
THANK RISK KILEY. CAN I ASK MAY
05:03:41.636 --> 05:03:43.038
ASK YOU A QUESTION AND I'M
05:03:43.104 --> 05:03:44.072
SORRY TO GIVE YOU A HEADS UP ON
05:03:44.139 --> 05:03:46.408
THIS BUT GIVEN THAT WE PASSED
05:03:46.474 --> 05:03:47.609
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE ONE TWO
05:03:47.676 --> 05:03:49.110
ALREADY LOOKING AT SOME OF THE
05:03:49.177 --> 05:03:50.145
HOMELESS SERVICES WHICH WE HAD
05:03:50.211 --> 05:03:51.947
A DISCUSSION ABOUT- WOULD YOU
05:03:52.013 --> 05:03:54.950
BE AMENABLE TO HOLDING YOUR
05:03:55.016 --> 05:03:56.318
REQUEST OVER TO MAYBE THE NEXT
05:03:56.384 --> 05:03:57.719
HEARING TO SEE WHAT WE
05:03:57.786 --> 05:04:00.322
ASCERTAIN AND LEARN FROM THE
05:04:00.388 --> 05:04:01.356
AUDIT THAT THIS COMMITTEES
05:04:01.423 --> 05:04:03.758
ALREADY VOTED ON I MEAN HOW
05:04:03.825 --> 05:04:04.726
QUICKLY ARE WE GONNA HAVE THE
05:04:04.793 --> 05:04:06.294
RESULTS OF THAT ON IT. IT'LL BE
05:04:06.361 --> 05:04:08.496
OVER OUR NEXT SCHEDULED HEARING
05:04:08.563 --> 05:04:10.365
FOR J. LACK TENTATIVELY IS
05:04:10.432 --> 05:04:11.900
PROPOSED FOR THE FIRST WEEK OF
05:04:11.967 --> 05:04:14.235
AUGUST. BUT WE MAY HEAR. WE MAY
05:04:14.302 --> 05:04:17.472
DO A HEARING- BEFORE THAT. OKAY
05:04:17.539 --> 05:04:19.507
I'M AYE AYE THAT'S NOTIDEAL.
05:04:19.574 --> 05:04:20.542
BECAUSE I THINK THAT YOU KNOW
05:04:20.609 --> 05:04:22.477
AS A- WE ALL RECOGNIZE HIM AS
05:04:22.544 --> 05:04:23.511
THE GOVERNMENT AND FACTLY
05:04:23.578 --> 05:04:25.313
STATED THIS IS A VERY URGENT
05:04:25.380 --> 05:04:26.448
MATTER AND WE'RE ALREADY GONNA
05:04:26.514 --> 05:04:28.650
BE LOOKING AT- UP TO EIGHT
05:04:28.717 --> 05:04:29.284
MONTHS POTENTIALLY FOR THE
05:04:29.351 --> 05:04:31.953
AUDIT TO BE CONDUCTED- I WILL
05:04:32.020 --> 05:04:33.288
SAY THAT. YOU KNOW I SUPPORT-
05:04:33.355 --> 05:04:34.923
SOMEONE WILL READ THIS IS.
05:04:34.990 --> 05:04:36.791
AUDIT REQUEST I THINK THAT'S
05:04:36.858 --> 05:04:37.826
GOING TO YIELD USEFUL
05:04:37.892 --> 05:04:38.560
INFORMATION BUT IT'S-
05:04:38.627 --> 05:04:39.828
INFORMATION OF A VERY DIFFERENT
05:04:39.894 --> 05:04:42.731
KIND- THAN THAT WHICH WERE
05:04:42.797 --> 05:04:44.666
SEEKING WITH THIS REQUEST I
05:04:44.733 --> 05:04:46.234
THAT IS LIMITED. TO THIS SEE.
05:04:46.301 --> 05:04:48.336
IT I IS I. CONCERNED WITH
05:04:48.403 --> 05:04:50.538
SPENDING AND I EVEN IF IT WERE
05:04:50.605 --> 05:04:53.708
IT WOULD ONLY- EVEN POTENTIALLY
05:04:53.775 --> 05:04:54.542
COVER ABOUT TWO PERCENT. OF THE
05:04:54.609 --> 05:04:56.378
OVERALL SPENDING THAT TIME THIS
05:04:56.444 --> 05:04:57.545
AUDIT WOULD LOOKING AT AND THAT
05:04:57.612 --> 05:04:59.147
WOULD NOT BE SOME SORT OF
05:04:59.214 --> 05:05:01.483
REPRESENTATIVE SAMPLE WOULD
05:05:01.549 --> 05:05:02.817
ONLY BE ONE. HI SO THAT.
05:05:02.884 --> 05:05:03.385
FRIENDS I'D LOVE. THE
05:05:03.451 --> 05:05:04.519
COMMITTEES. TODAY OF COURSE
05:05:04.586 --> 05:05:06.221
FAT. IF I IN THE IN THE WISDOM
05:05:06.287 --> 05:05:07.822
OF THE MEMBERS I'D THE VOTES
05:05:07.889 --> 05:05:08.790
ARE NOT THERE AND YOU'D LIKE TO
05:05:08.857 --> 05:05:10.225
TAKE IT UP. AT SOME POINT DOWN
05:05:10.291 --> 05:05:12.494
THE LINE I'D BE VERY EAGER TO
05:05:12.560 --> 05:05:14.029
WORK WITH YOU ON THAT. OKAY
05:05:14.095 --> 05:05:15.030
YEAH I DON'T BELIEVE THE VOTES
05:05:15.096 --> 05:05:16.431
ARE THERE FOR YOUR AUTO. SO IF
05:05:16.498 --> 05:05:17.599
YOU'D LIKE TO BULLETIN WRAPS
05:05:17.666 --> 05:05:18.299
WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH
05:05:18.366 --> 05:05:20.402
MISTER REVERSES. THAT MAY
05:05:20.468 --> 05:05:22.470
CHANGE- THE MIND OF SOME OF THE
05:05:22.537 --> 05:05:24.172
MEMBERS ON THE DíAS. SO THIS
05:05:24.239 --> 05:05:24.806
TIME WOULD YOU LIKE TO TABLE OR
05:05:24.873 --> 05:05:26.508
WOULD YOU LIKE TO. MOVE FORWARD
05:05:26.574 --> 05:05:27.575
WITH THE MOTION WELL I MEAN I
05:05:27.642 --> 05:05:28.476
WOULD LIKE TO GET FOLKS CAN'T
05:05:28.543 --> 05:05:30.145
DEVOTE WE CAN ALWAYS REVISIT IT
05:05:30.211 --> 05:05:32.313
UNDER CONSIDERATION IS THAT
05:05:32.380 --> 05:05:33.915
RIGHT. THE RULES ARE DIFFERENT
05:05:33.982 --> 05:05:34.983
LET ME CONSULT WITH. WHITE
05:05:35.050 --> 05:05:36.618
RULES FOR THE TWO COMMITTEES
05:05:36.685 --> 05:05:37.519
BECAUSE WE HAVE THE TWO HOUSES.
05:05:37.585 --> 05:05:39.688
OKAY BUT YOU CAN ALWAYS.
05:05:39.754 --> 05:05:41.823
RESUBMIT A LETTER. YES WHAT DO
05:05:41.890 --> 05:05:43.324
WE DO THAT ONE WE DO ABOUT. I'D
05:05:43.391 --> 05:05:45.226
I'D LIKE JUST TO. YOU KNOW I'VE
05:05:45.293 --> 05:05:45.960
HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH
05:05:46.027 --> 05:05:47.262
DIFFERENT MEMBERS AND I THINK
05:05:47.328 --> 05:05:48.563
THIS IS. AN URGENT MATTER AND
05:05:48.630 --> 05:05:50.465
DIE. YOU KNOW I DON'T. I VERY
05:05:50.532 --> 05:05:52.600
MUCH URGE A YES VOTE TODAY. AND
05:05:52.667 --> 05:05:53.702
IF THINGS GO OTHERWISE THEN WE
05:05:53.768 --> 05:05:55.136
CAN TAKE FROM THERE. ARE THANK
05:05:55.203 --> 05:05:57.372
YOU. KILEY APPRECIATE THAT- YOU
05:05:57.439 --> 05:05:59.240
KNOW OBVIOUSLY THE SCOPE IS.
05:05:59.307 --> 05:06:01.409
VERY LARGE THE COST IS VERY
05:06:01.476 --> 05:06:01.976
LARGE FOR THIS. THIS TIME I
05:06:02.043 --> 05:06:03.311
WON'T BE ABLE TO SUPPORT IT.
05:06:03.378 --> 05:06:05.180
BUT I. NOT SAYING I WOULDN'T
05:06:05.246 --> 05:06:07.148
SUPPORT IN THE FUTURE I DO WANT
05:06:07.215 --> 05:06:08.083
TO SEE WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN
05:06:08.149 --> 05:06:09.517
WITH. ASSEMBLY MEMBER PREVIOUS
05:06:09.584 --> 05:06:12.454
BUDGET INTO. TWENTY DASH ONE.
05:06:12.520 --> 05:06:14.155
TWO AND FOUR BEYOND WHERE WE
05:06:14.222 --> 05:06:15.256
SHOULD BE LOOKING AT. SAYING
05:06:15.323 --> 05:06:17.158
THAT. AT THE FORMA BASIS. AS
05:06:17.225 --> 05:06:18.727
WE- FOLLOW. I WITH THAT LET ME
05:06:18.793 --> 05:06:20.261
ASK IF THERE'S A MOTION. FOR
05:06:20.328 --> 05:06:23.698
ASSEMBLYMEMBER KILEY THOUGHT IT.
05:06:23.765 --> 05:06:24.733
RIGHT MOVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
05:06:24.799 --> 05:06:26.634
JAY SECOND BY MISTER MISTER
05:06:26.701 --> 05:06:30.238
SECTOR COLOR. THE MOTION IS TO
05:06:30.305 --> 05:06:32.040
APPROVE OUR REQUEST TWENTY
05:06:32.107 --> 05:06:33.208
TWENTY DASH ONE OH SIX
05:06:33.274 --> 05:06:33.908
CONCERNING STATEWIDE
05:06:33.975 --> 05:06:35.510
HOMELESSNESS FUNDING BY
05:06:35.577 --> 05:06:36.945
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KILEY. SO
05:06:37.011 --> 05:06:41.850
NUMBER SALAS. BOERNER HORVATH
05:06:41.916 --> 05:06:44.919
NO BOERNER HORVATH NO GEN GEN
05:06:44.986 --> 05:06:49.758
HI PATTERSON PERSON HI RUBIO.
05:06:49.824 --> 05:06:56.531
VOEPEL VOEPEL I WOULD. SENATOR
05:06:56.598 --> 05:07:02.337
ROTH. GORGEOUS BEEN DOLLARS
05:07:02.403 --> 05:07:10.712
HERTZBERG. MINING. MORE LOCKED.
05:07:10.779 --> 05:07:15.817
WIENER. OKAY THAT ITEMS ON CALL
05:07:15.884 --> 05:07:17.018
THANK YOU MISTER THANK YOU.
05:07:17.085 --> 05:07:18.820
WHERE THIS TIME WILL BE WILL
05:07:18.887 --> 05:07:20.789
MOVING TO OUR LAST AGENDA ITEM.
05:07:20.855 --> 05:07:23.958
THIS IS A CHEN ITEM NUMBER
05:07:24.025 --> 05:07:24.526
SEVENTEEN TWENTY TWENTY DASH
05:07:24.592 --> 05:07:28.429
ZERO FIVE CITY OF SAN GABRIEL.
05:07:28.496 --> 05:07:30.165
AND OVER AGAIN WITH THE STATE
05:07:30.231 --> 05:07:31.533
AUDITOR'S PRESENTATION AND I
05:07:31.599 --> 05:07:32.934
BELIEVE YOU HAVE CANCER TO OPEN
05:07:33.001 --> 05:07:34.068
AGAIN. THAT'S CORRECT AGAIN
05:07:34.135 --> 05:07:35.203
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
05:07:35.270 --> 05:07:37.238
THIS IS A NOT IT WE'RE ASKING
05:07:37.305 --> 05:07:38.940
AUTHORITY TO CONDUCT THE CITY
05:07:39.007 --> 05:07:41.109
OF SAN GABRIEL- OUR OUR OUR
05:07:41.176 --> 05:07:43.411
STAFF WENT AND CONDUCTED AN
05:07:43.478 --> 05:07:44.746
ASSESSMENT IN THE FALL OF
05:07:44.813 --> 05:07:46.447
TWENTY NINETEEN- COMPLETED THAT
05:07:46.514 --> 05:07:47.849
IT ASSESSMENT IN DECEMBER
05:07:47.916 --> 05:07:49.884
SHARED THE RESULTS WITH THE
05:07:49.951 --> 05:07:51.152
CITY. BUT CERTAINLY RECEIVE
05:07:51.219 --> 05:07:52.687
FEEDBACK FROM THE CITY THAT
05:07:52.754 --> 05:07:53.755
AGAIN IS CONTAINED IN THE
05:07:53.822 --> 05:07:56.457
ANALYSIS THAT. WE PROVIDED TO
05:07:56.524 --> 05:07:58.026
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS- BUT I
05:07:58.092 --> 05:07:59.427
WILL ASK MR CHILDREN TWO AGAIN
05:07:59.494 --> 05:08:01.462
A VERY HIGH LEVEL. OVER THE
05:08:01.529 --> 05:08:03.364
ISSUES WE IDENTIFIED THAT WE
05:08:03.431 --> 05:08:06.201
BELIEVE ARE. SUPPORTS THE
05:08:06.267 --> 05:08:09.838
COMMITTEE'S APPROVAL OF THE ART
05:08:09.904 --> 05:08:10.438
REQUEST WE HAVE FOR YOU TODAY
05:08:10.505 --> 05:08:11.906
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. PLEASE
05:08:11.973 --> 05:08:13.508
OKAY AGAIN FOR THE RIGHT MY
05:08:13.575 --> 05:08:14.042
NAME IS MIKE TILTON I'M A
05:08:14.108 --> 05:08:16.010
DEPUTY STATE AUTO. SO SINK
05:08:16.077 --> 05:08:18.012
PEARL THE FINANCIAL CHALLENGES
05:08:18.079 --> 05:08:18.913
THAT WERE SEEN THERE REALLY
05:08:18.980 --> 05:08:21.883
BOILS DOWN TO INSUFFICIENT
05:08:21.950 --> 05:08:24.786
RESERVES IN CASH TO PAY FOR
05:08:24.853 --> 05:08:28.456
THEIR ON GOING BILL AND- ALL.
05:08:28.523 --> 05:08:33.027
FOR THEIR- WERE. BECAUSE
05:08:33.094 --> 05:08:34.629
BASICALLY AREN'T SAN SAN
05:08:34.696 --> 05:08:36.664
GABRIEL CHOATE N. AS IN TWO. IN
05:08:36.731 --> 05:08:37.298
FOURTEEN. THEIR CITY K. OF. A
05:08:37.365 --> 05:08:38.733
LAW. AND PART OF THE- AGREEMENT
05:08:38.800 --> 05:08:40.235
WITHOUT LOANS THE CITY HAD TO
05:08:40.301 --> 05:08:42.470
SET ASIDE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
05:08:42.537 --> 05:08:44.205
OF ITS GENERAL FUND CASH AS
05:08:44.272 --> 05:08:45.707
COLLATERAL FOR THE LOAN FOR TEN
05:08:45.773 --> 05:08:48.276
YEARS. SO CONSEQUENTLY TODAY
05:08:48.343 --> 05:08:48.877
SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS OF SAN
05:08:48.943 --> 05:08:51.145
GABRIELS CASH. IS CURRENTLY NOT
05:08:51.212 --> 05:08:53.414
AVAILABLE FOR SPENDING ON TOP
05:08:53.481 --> 05:08:54.749
OF THAT OVER THE LAST THREE OR
05:08:54.816 --> 05:08:56.284
FOUR YEARS SAN GABRIEL ACTUAL
05:08:56.351 --> 05:08:58.386
EXPENDITURES. HAVE EXCEEDED
05:08:58.453 --> 05:08:59.888
THEIR REVENUES WHICH AGAIN IS
05:08:59.954 --> 05:09:02.757
PUTTING FURTHER STRESS ON THEIR
05:09:02.824 --> 05:09:03.791
GENERAL FUND AS A RESULT OF
05:09:03.858 --> 05:09:05.994
BOTH THE LOAN AND YOU DEFICIT
05:09:06.060 --> 05:09:07.629
SPENDING SAN GABRIELS GENERAL
05:09:07.695 --> 05:09:10.131
FUND RESERVES. DECLINE FROM A
05:09:10.198 --> 05:09:11.332
POSITIVE TEN MILLION DOLLAR
05:09:11.399 --> 05:09:14.235
BALANCE BACK IN TWO THOUSAND
05:09:14.302 --> 05:09:15.036
FOURTEEN ALL THE WAY DOWN TO AN
05:09:15.103 --> 05:09:16.471
EIGHT POINT FIVE MILLION DOLLAR
05:09:16.537 --> 05:09:20.275
DEFICIT IN. TWO THOUSAND
05:09:20.341 --> 05:09:20.875
EIGHTEEN NINETEEN. IN RESPONSE
05:09:20.942 --> 05:09:23.578
TO. THESE FINANCIAL CONDITIONS
05:09:23.645 --> 05:09:25.446
THE CITY'S EXTERNAL AUDITOR HAS
05:09:25.513 --> 05:09:26.581
EXPRESSED SOME CONCERNS
05:09:26.648 --> 05:09:28.216
OBVIOUSLY WITH THE CITY'S
05:09:28.283 --> 05:09:30.018
FINANCIAL CONDITION AND WITH
05:09:30.084 --> 05:09:32.420
ITS CONSTITUENTS OUR ABILITY TO
05:09:32.487 --> 05:09:34.422
CONTINUE AS A GOING CONCERN.
05:09:34.489 --> 05:09:35.823
OUR UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THE
05:09:35.890 --> 05:09:37.325
CITY'S RESPONSE TO THAT IS THEY
05:09:37.392 --> 05:09:39.260
ARE RELYING ON THE VOTERS TO
05:09:39.327 --> 05:09:41.562
PASS. A NEW TAX MEASURE NEXT
05:09:41.629 --> 05:09:43.698
MONTH AND ALSO RECEIVING
05:09:43.765 --> 05:09:44.966
INCREASE REVENUE FROM A NEW
05:09:45.033 --> 05:09:46.734
HOTEL THAT'S IN THE PROCESS OF
05:09:46.801 --> 05:09:48.636
BEING BUILT. SO BASED ON THAT
05:09:48.703 --> 05:09:49.938
WE LOOKED AT THE CITY'S
05:09:50.004 --> 05:09:51.806
HISTORIC REVENUES AND
05:09:51.873 --> 05:09:53.942
EXPENDITURES AND WE PROJECTED
05:09:54.008 --> 05:09:56.344
THOSE OUT INTO THE FUTURE FOR
05:09:56.411 --> 05:09:57.445
THREE OR FOUR YEARS AND WHEN WE
05:09:57.512 --> 05:09:59.881
DID THAT. WE ALSO FACTORED IN
05:09:59.948 --> 05:10:02.183
SAN GABRIELS OWN TESTAMENTS OF
05:10:02.250 --> 05:10:04.185
THE NEW REVENUE THAT THE SALES
05:10:04.252 --> 05:10:05.987
TAX MEASURE WOULD GENERATE IF
05:10:06.054 --> 05:10:08.957
IT ACTUALLY PASSES. IN THE NEW
05:10:09.023 --> 05:10:10.858
HOTEL AND WHEN WE DID THAT. OUR
05:10:10.925 --> 05:10:12.927
ESTIMATE SHOWS THAT THE CITY'S
05:10:12.994 --> 05:10:14.595
GENERAL FUND WOULD STILL HAVE A
05:10:14.662 --> 05:10:16.464
NEGATIVE RESERVE BALANCE IN
05:10:16.531 --> 05:10:18.166
FISCAL YEAR TWENTY THREE TWENTY
05:10:18.232 --> 05:10:20.702
FOUR. WE ALSO LOOK AT THE
05:10:20.768 --> 05:10:22.770
CITY'S BUDGETING PROCESS SEES
05:10:22.837 --> 05:10:24.372
AND BASICALLY WE FOUND THAT
05:10:24.439 --> 05:10:26.374
OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS THERE
05:10:26.441 --> 05:10:27.208
BUDGETS HAVE AN OVERLY
05:10:27.275 --> 05:10:29.277
OPTIMISTIC. AND THAT'S RESULTED
05:10:29.344 --> 05:10:30.411
IN SIGNIFICANT REVENUE
05:10:30.478 --> 05:10:34.515
SHORTFALLS AND- EXPENDITURE
05:10:34.582 --> 05:10:36.117
OVERRUNS. THIS IS A QUICK
05:10:36.184 --> 05:10:37.552
EXAMPLE THERE NINETEEN TWENTY
05:10:37.618 --> 05:10:39.587
BUT DID INCLUDE PROJECTED
05:10:39.654 --> 05:10:43.191
REVENUE OF SEVEN HUNDRED
05:10:43.257 --> 05:10:43.791
THOUSAND DOLLARS. FROM THE TAX
05:10:43.858 --> 05:10:45.093
MEASURE THAT HASN'T EVEN PASSED
05:10:45.159 --> 05:10:48.429
YOU. SO IF YOU'RE DE PASS. IT
05:10:48.496 --> 05:10:49.630
LOOKS LIKELY THE CITY'S
05:10:49.697 --> 05:10:54.635
EXPENSES ARE GOING TO WORK.
05:10:54.702 --> 05:10:55.970
AGAIN EXPERTS REVENUES. AREA
05:10:56.037 --> 05:10:56.537
FOR BERMAN THE COST ANOTHER
05:10:56.604 --> 05:10:57.138
AREA THAT'S STE ON THIS CHIU
05:10:57.205 --> 05:10:59.207
FUND. THEY HAVE AN UNFUNDED
05:10:59.273 --> 05:11:01.042
PENSION LIABILITIES SIXTY SEVEN
05:11:01.109 --> 05:11:02.677
MILLION DOLLARS CALPERS
05:11:02.744 --> 05:11:04.278
PROJECTS AT THEIR ANNUAL
05:11:04.345 --> 05:11:06.414
WRITTEN. REQUIRED CONTRIBUTIONS
05:11:06.481 --> 05:11:07.081
TO THAT PLAN ARE GOING TO
05:11:07.148 --> 05:11:09.417
INCREASE BY 30% OVER THE NEXT
05:11:09.484 --> 05:11:11.352
FIVE YEARS. IN ADDITION TO THAT
05:11:11.419 --> 05:11:12.520
THE CITY HAS NOTHER
05:11:12.587 --> 05:11:15.123
SIGNIFICANT UNFUNDED LIABILITY
05:11:15.189 --> 05:11:16.624
FOR ITS POST EMPLOYMENT HEALTH
05:11:16.691 --> 05:11:19.193
BENEFITS. AND THAT'S FORTY FOUR
05:11:19.260 --> 05:11:20.361
MILLION DOLLARS AND THAT
05:11:20.428 --> 05:11:22.063
LIABILITIES ALSO INCREASING
05:11:22.130 --> 05:11:23.765
BECAUSE THE CITY IS NOT FULLY
05:11:23.831 --> 05:11:25.933
OF FUNDING. THE COST OF THOSE
05:11:26.000 --> 05:11:28.036
BENEFITS. IN TERMS OF AUDIT
05:11:28.102 --> 05:11:29.404
OBJECTIVES THAT THE AUDIT
05:11:29.470 --> 05:11:30.905
ANALYSIS CONTAINS A NUMBER OF
05:11:30.972 --> 05:11:32.340
OBJECTIVES BUT ESSENTIALLY WHAT
05:11:32.407 --> 05:11:33.574
IT BOILS DOWN TO IS IF THE
05:11:33.641 --> 05:11:35.676
AUDIT IS APPROVED WHAT WE'LL DO
05:11:35.743 --> 05:11:37.478
IS EVALUATE SAN GABRIELS
05:11:37.545 --> 05:11:39.414
CURRENT FINANCIAL CHALLENGES.
05:11:39.480 --> 05:11:41.416
AND FINANCIAL CONDITION AND
05:11:41.482 --> 05:11:43.251
ABILITY TO MEET ITS SHORT TERM
05:11:43.317 --> 05:11:44.385
AND LONG TERM OBLIGATIONS WHILE
05:11:44.452 --> 05:11:46.921
CONTINUING TO PROVIDE SERVICES
05:11:46.988 --> 05:11:48.556
TO ITS RESIDENTS. WE ALSO LIKE
05:11:48.623 --> 05:11:50.558
TO IDENTIFY THE INVENTORY OF
05:11:50.625 --> 05:11:52.560
CAUSES OF SAN GABRIELS
05:11:52.627 --> 05:11:54.328
FINANCIAL CHALLENGES AND FIGURE
05:11:54.395 --> 05:11:55.930
OUT WHETHER THE CITY. HAS
05:11:55.997 --> 05:11:58.266
DEVELOPED AN ADEQUATE PLAN FOR
05:11:58.332 --> 05:11:59.700
DRESSING THOSE CHALLENGES THE
05:11:59.767 --> 05:12:01.069
THIRD THING THAT WE WANT TO
05:12:01.135 --> 05:12:02.070
TAKE A LOOK AT HIS SAN GABRIELS
05:12:02.136 --> 05:12:04.238
BUDGETING PROCESS SEAT. TO
05:12:04.305 --> 05:12:04.939
FIGURE OUT IF THEY ARE
05:12:05.006 --> 05:12:07.108
COMPLYING WITH BEST PRACTICES
05:12:07.175 --> 05:12:08.543
AND IS A PART OF THAT WE TAKE A
05:12:08.609 --> 05:12:10.945
LOOK AT THEIR PROCEDURES AN
05:12:11.012 --> 05:12:12.180
UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS FOR
05:12:12.246 --> 05:12:13.448
PROJECTING FUTURE REVENUES AND
05:12:13.514 --> 05:12:15.450
EXPENDITURES. TO REALLY
05:12:15.516 --> 05:12:16.751
DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT THOSE
05:12:16.818 --> 05:12:18.052
ARE RESULTING IN BALANCED
05:12:18.119 --> 05:12:21.189
BUDGETS AND ACCURATE FINANCIAL
05:12:21.255 --> 05:12:23.157
FORECASTS. WE ESTIMATE THAT THE
05:12:23.224 --> 05:12:25.626
AUDIT WITH. TWO THOUSAND THREE
05:12:25.693 --> 05:12:26.127
HUNDRED FORTY HOURS AND
05:12:26.194 --> 05:12:27.495
PROBABLY WOULD TAKE ABOUT FOUR
05:12:27.562 --> 05:12:42.710
MONTHS TO COMPLETE. THANK YOU
05:12:42.777 --> 05:12:43.678
WELL IT'S GOING TO MOVE TO THE
05:12:43.744 --> 05:12:45.680
AFFECTED CITIES PLEASE THANK
05:12:45.746 --> 05:12:46.747
YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
05:12:46.814 --> 05:12:48.382
COMMITTEE HI MY NAME IS MARK
05:12:48.449 --> 05:12:49.784
LAZARETTO AND THE CITY MANAGER
05:12:49.851 --> 05:12:51.619
FOR THE CITY OF SAN GABRIEL-
05:12:51.686 --> 05:12:53.221
KENNETH LEWIS OUR INTERIM
05:12:53.287 --> 05:12:55.123
FINANCE DIRECTOR. I HAD SOME
05:12:55.189 --> 05:12:56.757
PREPARED REMARKS THAT I WILL
05:12:56.824 --> 05:12:57.892
SPARE YOU ALL FROM GIVEN THE
05:12:57.959 --> 05:12:59.260
AMOUNT OF TIME THAT YOU SPENT-
05:12:59.327 --> 05:13:01.095
SITTING HERE TODAY PLEASE THINK
05:13:01.162 --> 05:13:02.163
IT WILL GIVE ME A LITTLE CREDIT
05:13:02.230 --> 05:13:03.564
FOR NOT GOING INTO THE DETAIL
05:13:03.631 --> 05:13:04.232
THAT IT WOULD HAVE ALREADY GONE
05:13:04.298 --> 05:13:06.534
INTO- I'LL TELL YU THAT I'VE
05:13:06.601 --> 05:13:07.468
ONLY BEEN ON BOARD WITH THE
05:13:07.535 --> 05:13:09.737
CITY FOR LESS OR A LITTLE. MORE
05:13:09.804 --> 05:13:11.973
THAN TO JUST OVER TWO YEARS
05:13:12.039 --> 05:13:13.641
WHEN I CAME INTO THE CITY I
05:13:13.708 --> 05:13:16.978
FOUND OUT THAT THE- FINANCIAL
05:13:17.044 --> 05:13:17.879
POSITION THAT THE CITY.
05:13:17.945 --> 05:13:19.313
ADMINISTRATION WAS FOR TRYING
05:13:19.380 --> 05:13:21.215
TO THE COUNCIL NICK ANY WAS
05:13:21.282 --> 05:13:25.119
THERE NAY GREASE DIFFERENT FROM
05:13:25.186 --> 05:13:25.720
WHAT THE ACTUAL YOUR CURRENT.
05:13:25.786 --> 05:13:27.588
pEVERYTHING THAT HE SAID THIS IS
05:13:27.655 --> 05:13:29.857
EXACT TROOP AND WHEN WE FOUND
05:13:29.924 --> 05:13:32.627
THAT OUT- I INFORM THE COUNCIL
05:13:32.693 --> 05:13:35.263
THE COMMUNITY AND SINCE THAT TO
05:13:35.329 --> 05:13:36.164
BE THE CASE THE COUNCIL HAS
05:13:36.230 --> 05:13:37.932
TAKE PRESTIGE STEPS TO. SIZE
05:13:37.999 --> 05:13:40.735
ARE IS IT I'M CHEN YOUR- BECOME
05:13:40.801 --> 05:13:44.539
X. OF FINANCE THE TRANCE. OF
05:13:44.605 --> 05:13:47.875
MAKING SURE THE NEWS ARE BACK
05:13:47.942 --> 05:13:49.810
HERE THE PROJECT. AND THERE
05:13:49.877 --> 05:13:51.479
POINT I'M SORRY THE BE. AND
05:13:51.546 --> 05:13:54.148
TECH BUT I NEED TO CRY HIS OPEN
05:13:54.215 --> 05:13:55.917
FOR RECORD ON POINT. A AND I
05:13:55.983 --> 05:13:57.652
TAKE PRIDE IN THIS BIG I'M WITH
05:13:57.718 --> 05:14:00.521
FOR NINETEEN BUT- AND NINETEEN
05:14:00.588 --> 05:14:02.290
TWENTY BUDGET WE ARE ABSOLUTELY
05:14:02.356 --> 05:14:05.293
TO OUR REVENUES. WERE PETER
05:14:05.359 --> 05:14:07.061
ABOUT SEVEN HUNDRED FIFTY
05:14:07.128 --> 05:14:08.763
THOUSAND DOLLARS IN A SALES TAX
05:14:08.829 --> 05:14:10.731
MEASURE THAT WAS ON THE NOT
05:14:10.798 --> 05:14:13.401
CORRECT THAT WAS FOR THE SALE
05:14:13.467 --> 05:14:18.039
LOW PRO. EIGHT POUNDS WE IS LAW
05:14:18.105 --> 05:14:19.707
MONTH WHEN OUR HOUSE APPROVED
05:14:19.774 --> 05:14:24.946
SAID. TECH IS ON FOR THIS MONTH
05:14:25.012 --> 05:14:26.147
AND WE DON'T HAVE A THE- FUN
05:14:26.214 --> 05:14:27.014
OUR CURRENT BUDGET FOR THAT ARE.
05:14:27.081 --> 05:14:28.583
BUDGET IS BALANCED. I AM PROUD
05:14:28.649 --> 05:14:29.183
TO SAY AS WELL WOULD PUT IN.
05:14:29.250 --> 05:14:29.917
BACK OUR OUR RESERVE LAST. YEAR
05:14:29.984 --> 05:14:32.353
FOR THE FIRST TIME IN A DE. ONE
05:14:32.420 --> 05:14:33.487
THE STATE. CONTACT US IN. WE
05:14:33.554 --> 05:14:34.422
WERE ALREADY WORKING AND
05:14:34.488 --> 05:14:35.723
STEALING BEST PRACTICES AND
05:14:35.790 --> 05:14:37.258
PROCEDURES AND PROCESSES IN
05:14:37.325 --> 05:14:38.659
ORDER TO HAVE THE INTERNAL
05:14:38.726 --> 05:14:39.560
CONTROLS THAT BETTER CITIES
05:14:39.627 --> 05:14:41.696
HAVE. A WERE INCREDIBLE CITY
05:14:41.762 --> 05:14:42.897
BUT WE DON'T HAVE THE INTERNAL
05:14:42.964 --> 05:14:44.699
CONTROLS BECAUSE OF THE WORK
05:14:44.765 --> 05:14:45.800
THAT HAS BEEN NEGLECTED OVER
05:14:45.866 --> 05:14:48.202
THE YEARS. AND WE ARE PUTTING
05:14:48.269 --> 05:14:50.471
THOSE INTO PLACE. EVERYTHING
05:14:50.538 --> 05:14:51.872
THAT HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED BY THE
05:14:51.939 --> 05:14:53.040
AUDITOR WERE ALREADY WORKING
05:14:53.107 --> 05:14:55.276
ON. THE AUDITOR AS WAS
05:14:55.343 --> 05:14:57.111
DISCUSSED IN IN DISCUSSIONS OF
05:14:57.178 --> 05:14:58.913
CITIES BEFORE OURS WE LOOK AT
05:14:58.980 --> 05:15:00.114
THIS AS A VERY COLLABORATIVE
05:15:00.181 --> 05:15:01.716
COOPERAIVE PROCESS WE LOOK AT
05:15:01.782 --> 05:15:03.484
THAT AS BEING A PARTNERSHIP.
05:15:03.551 --> 05:15:05.386
EVERYTHING THAT- MISS HOW HIS
05:15:05.453 --> 05:15:06.954
STATED ABOUT COMING AND GIVING
05:15:07.021 --> 05:15:08.856
US MANAGEMENT COACHING IS
05:15:08.923 --> 05:15:10.358
SOMETHING THAT WE WOULD WELCOME
05:15:10.424 --> 05:15:12.226
OUR ISSUES ONLY ONE OF TIMING
05:15:12.293 --> 05:15:13.928
ARTS CITY COUNCIL IS LOOKING
05:15:13.995 --> 05:15:15.997
FORWARD TO THE AUDIT TO. GIVE
05:15:16.063 --> 05:15:17.331
US A CLEAN BILL OF HEALTH AND
05:15:17.398 --> 05:15:19.500
ALSO TO FIND ANY AREAS WHERE WE
05:15:19.567 --> 05:15:21.469
CAN GET BETTER. ON THE ISSUE
05:15:21.535 --> 05:15:23.237
AGAIN IS ONLY TIMING I TELL YOU
05:15:23.304 --> 05:15:24.739
WHY THAT IS A TIMING ISSUE AND
05:15:24.805 --> 05:15:27.375
IT'S TWO FOLD. ONE IS BECAUSE
05:15:27.441 --> 05:15:29.210
OF THAT LOAN THAT MR TILDEN
05:15:29.277 --> 05:15:32.313
STATED- THAT IS IN FACT THE
05:15:32.380 --> 05:15:33.481
CASE THAT WE HAVE A LOAN THAT'S
05:15:33.547 --> 05:15:34.882
PUTTING A BURDEN ON OUR GENERAL
05:15:34.949 --> 05:15:36.550
FUND. AND WE'RE IN THE PROCESS
05:15:36.617 --> 05:15:37.952
OF REFINANCING THAT LOAN AS WE
05:15:38.019 --> 05:15:40.254
SPEAK- WE DON'T WANT TO HAVE
05:15:40.321 --> 05:15:42.590
THE- STIGMA OF AN AUDIT EVEN
05:15:42.657 --> 05:15:43.524
THOUGH IT'S MANAGEMENT COACHING
05:15:43.591 --> 05:15:46.727
IT'S AN ODD- IN TERMS OF THE
05:15:46.794 --> 05:15:48.629
LENDING WORLD. AND WE FEEL THAT
05:15:48.696 --> 05:15:51.265
THAT WOULD. HINDER CANCER OF
05:15:51.332 --> 05:15:53.668
REFI UP LOW TAKE. OFF OF OUR
05:15:53.734 --> 05:15:55.836
GENERAL FOR. THE BIGGER REASON-
05:15:55.903 --> 05:15:59.273
OR EQUALLY A BIG REASON IS THAT
05:15:59.340 --> 05:16:01.242
WE ARE WORKING ON ALL OF THE
05:16:01.309 --> 05:16:02.643
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES THE
05:16:02.710 --> 05:16:06.314
AUDITOR HAS. OUT OF WE A VERY
05:16:06.380 --> 05:16:09.417
SMALL BUT MY SO. HAVE A SIX
05:16:09.483 --> 05:16:13.187
MA'AM OF. IN A FIGHT DEPARTMENT.
05:16:13.254 --> 05:16:14.922
AND HAVE BEEN SPENDING ALL OF
05:16:14.989 --> 05:16:18.626
THEIR- GET READY A BUNCH
05:16:18.693 --> 05:16:24.165
PROCESS THIS YEAR AS AS ADOPT
05:16:24.231 --> 05:16:34.342
HIS NEW. IMPROVE. MOVED THE
05:16:34.408 --> 05:16:35.710
REQUEST TO BE MOVED TO YOUR
05:16:35.776 --> 05:16:37.578
AUGUST MEETING AT THAT TIME WE
05:16:37.645 --> 05:16:39.380
WOULD BE MUCH BETTER OFF AND
05:16:39.447 --> 05:16:40.848
AGAIN AS I SAID OUR COUNCIL IS
05:16:40.915 --> 05:16:43.250
WELCOMING. THE AUDITOR'S OFFICE
05:16:43.317 --> 05:16:44.251
TO COME IN AND CONTINUE THAT
05:16:44.318 --> 05:16:45.986
PARTNERSHIP THAT WE'VE HAD. AND
05:16:46.053 --> 05:16:47.755
AT THAT TIME WE WOULD HAVE A
05:16:47.822 --> 05:16:49.223
REFINANCE THE LOAN TAKING MORE
05:16:49.290 --> 05:16:50.891
THAN SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS AWAY
05:16:50.958 --> 05:16:54.061
FROM OUR- GENERAL FUND DEFICIT.
05:16:54.128 --> 05:16:55.296
AND THEN WE WILL HAVE INSTALLED
05:16:55.363 --> 05:16:56.931
A MANY OF THE TEAM PRACTICES WE
05:16:56.997 --> 05:16:57.932
FEEL THAT MISS HOW THIS. HAS
05:16:57.998 --> 05:16:59.266
ALREADY IDENTIFIED AND WE
05:16:59.333 --> 05:17:00.634
IDENTIFY BEFORE YOU CAME INTO
05:17:00.701 --> 05:17:02.536
TOWN SO WITH THAT I WOULD REACH
05:17:02.603 --> 05:17:06.841
ACTUALLY. IT NOT BE VOTED ON A
05:17:06.907 --> 05:17:09.210
AS A- THAT IT BE PUT OFF. AND
05:17:09.276 --> 05:17:11.979
WE CAN AFTER ALL MADE THAT I'M
05:17:12.046 --> 05:17:13.647
HERE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS THANK
05:17:13.714 --> 05:17:16.384
LET ME TURN IT. MEMBERS ON THE
05:17:16.450 --> 05:17:20.554
DIE FOR QUESTION. A CENTER MORE
05:17:20.621 --> 05:17:23.758
LIKE PLEASE THANK YOU MISTER A
05:17:23.824 --> 05:17:29.897
REPEAT. YOU KNOW. THE LAST BUT
05:17:29.964 --> 05:17:35.136
BUT WORLD AND IS FOUR HUNDRED
05:17:35.202 --> 05:17:37.438
FIFTH FIFTH POPS OUT OF FOUR
05:17:37.505 --> 05:17:39.940
HUNDRED EIGHTY TWO CITIES
05:17:40.007 --> 05:17:40.875
TWENTY SEVEN FROM THE BOTTOM.
05:17:40.941 --> 05:17:41.976
AND A WOULD THINK IT THE WAY
05:17:42.042 --> 05:17:45.613
WOULD BE. IN A BY. I THINK WE
05:17:45.679 --> 05:17:47.281
NEED TO HELP AND WE SHOULD GET
05:17:47.348 --> 05:17:48.516
IN THERE SCHOOL AS WE CAN WITH
05:17:48.582 --> 05:17:52.353
PERFECT. TEAM SO WHEN IT'S TIME
05:17:52.420 --> 05:17:54.054
TO OPEN TO PROPER LEFT TO MAKE
05:17:54.121 --> 05:17:55.356
THE MOTION THANK YOU MUCH CHAIR
05:17:55.423 --> 05:17:57.958
THANK YOU RIGHT QUESTIONS FOR A
05:17:58.025 --> 05:18:01.829
MEMBER OF THE DIE. ASSEMBLY
05:18:01.896 --> 05:18:03.564
MEMBER SO WOMAN RE PLAY YEAH IT
05:18:03.631 --> 05:18:08.769
JUST. THAT YOU KNOW I. SO A
05:18:08.836 --> 05:18:09.970
SEVERAL OF MY ARE IN THAT LIST
05:18:10.037 --> 05:18:10.738
I YOU KNOW I WOULD LIKE TO
05:18:10.805 --> 05:18:12.907
OFFER A SOME SOME. I A I SHARE
05:18:12.973 --> 05:18:13.908
EARLIER HELD IS MY FOR
05:18:13.974 --> 05:18:14.575
COMMITTEE BECAUSE I HAVE THE UP
05:18:14.642 --> 05:18:17.111
MORE OF RESPECT AND COME IN THE
05:18:17.178 --> 05:18:18.345
AUDITOR'S THIS IS NOT A GOTCHA
05:18:18.412 --> 05:18:20.147
TYPE OF <c.cyan>0C A MY PIN IT'S</c>
05:18:20.214 --> 05:18:22.016
NOT A TO COMMIT WHAT IT FOR ME.
05:18:22.082 --> 05:18:23.551
IS TO ASSIST THOSE PEOPLE THAT
05:18:23.617 --> 05:18:25.186
OR THOSE ORG AN ENTITY THAT
05:18:25.252 --> 05:18:27.788
NEED THE SO FROM THE I. THAT
05:18:27.855 --> 05:18:29.490
OFFICE IS A ME AND WHEN WE'VE
05:18:29.557 --> 05:18:31.459
DONE AND WE RECEIVE THE AUDIT
05:18:31.525 --> 05:18:33.794
REPORT IT'S ALWAYS WITH THE OF
05:18:33.861 --> 05:18:35.729
WHAT TO DO. AND I YOU KNOW I
05:18:35.796 --> 05:18:37.932
WILL MY SPORT IT'S NOT CITY I
05:18:37.998 --> 05:18:41.702
KNOW THAT THE RUBIO. I'M THE
05:18:41.769 --> 05:18:44.405
WHAT I WANT IS IT YOU NEED ANY
05:18:44.472 --> 05:18:46.640
KIND SUPPORT OUTSIDE OF YOU
05:18:46.707 --> 05:18:47.575
KNOW NINETY TWO COMMAND THE
05:18:47.641 --> 05:18:49.910
CITY FOR X. THE I COMMEND YOU
05:18:49.977 --> 05:18:53.147
FOR THE WHAT HOW FAR COME SINCE.
05:18:53.214 --> 05:18:56.984
WHATEVER AN OFFER HELP I BUT
05:18:57.051 --> 05:18:59.119
FOR ME TO BILLION FOR THAT HAVE
05:18:59.186 --> 05:19:02.656
PROFESSIONALS LIKE THE I
05:19:02.723 --> 05:19:04.959
AUDITOR'S ON TO YOU EVERY IN
05:19:05.025 --> 05:19:09.296
ANYWAY THAT WE CAN. THANK YOU.
05:19:09.363 --> 05:19:12.166
ADDITIONAL FUNDS FROM NUMBERS
05:19:12.233 --> 05:19:18.038
ON A DIET HERE AND IN A THAT.
05:19:18.105 --> 05:19:18.639
WE'LL TRY TO WORK WITH YOU TO
05:19:18.706 --> 05:19:20.841
THE IN. GONNA BE IT IS JUST TRY
05:19:20.908 --> 05:19:22.142
TO SOME OF THE PRESSURES AND OF
05:19:22.209 --> 05:19:23.978
TIME. PERCENT SHE HASN'T OF
05:19:24.044 --> 05:19:25.346
SAID AND PRESS OF SOME THAT YOU
05:19:25.412 --> 05:19:28.282
CAN. ON WITH THE STATE ON AS
05:19:28.349 --> 05:19:29.183
AND LIKE WE SAW PRETTY YOU KNOW
05:19:29.250 --> 05:19:31.819
THIS IS HOPEFULLY. THE BEST AND
05:19:31.886 --> 05:19:33.287
THINGS THAT MAYBE CAN SEE A
05:19:33.354 --> 05:19:35.456
OTHER CITIES ACT COULD POSSIBLY
05:19:35.523 --> 05:19:37.057
THE CITY OF SAN GABRIEL WELL SO
05:19:37.124 --> 05:19:38.058
WITH THAT LET ME ASK FOR A
05:19:38.125 --> 05:19:40.160
MOTION THOSE WERE BY SEN MORE
05:19:40.227 --> 05:19:43.297
ON I'M SORRY LET ME ASK A
05:19:43.364 --> 05:19:47.301
PUBLIC COMMENT. HEARING SAYING
05:19:47.368 --> 05:19:48.669
NO PUBLIC. ATWATER WHICH LIKE
05:19:48.736 --> 05:19:50.938
CLOSE ASPIRIN AYE VOTE. ALL
05:19:51.005 --> 05:19:52.172
RIGHT THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT WE
05:19:52.239 --> 05:19:53.908
HAVE A MOTION SENATOR. LOCKED
05:19:53.974 --> 05:19:58.445
WITH. SUBSTITUTE. A SUB TO
05:19:58.512 --> 05:20:03.884
MOTION. ALL RIGHT FEDERAL DO A-
05:20:03.951 --> 05:20:09.189
BOTH. SEC RIGHT WOULD YOU LIKE
05:20:09.256 --> 05:20:09.790
IT'D HAPPEN MAKE THE MOST AND
05:20:09.857 --> 05:20:12.126
THE COMMITTEE DECIDES THERE%
05:20:12.192 --> 05:20:14.395
SUBS TO MOTION IN SUBSIDY
05:20:14.461 --> 05:20:15.429
MOTION IS THAT WE DO UNTIL
05:20:15.496 --> 05:20:17.831
AUGUST AND LET THEM BRING BACK
05:20:17.898 --> 05:20:19.400
I WAS THE MAYOR ANISE COUNCIL
05:20:19.466 --> 05:20:22.736
IN A VERY SMALL CITY. A QUARTER
05:20:22.803 --> 05:20:24.505
THE SIZE A SAYING DURING BUT
05:20:24.572 --> 05:20:25.839
DURING BY TIME I KNOW. THE CHIU.
05:20:25.906 --> 05:20:28.275
THAT THAT'S THAT SMALL CITIES.
05:20:28.342 --> 05:20:30.811
OF THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT SIX
05:20:30.878 --> 05:20:32.279
PEOPLE. LIKE A DREAM TRUE FOR
05:20:32.346 --> 05:20:33.147
CITY OF A- THOUSAND BUT WE DID
05:20:33.213 --> 05:20:34.248
HAVE THAT. SO THE FACT THAT
05:20:34.315 --> 05:20:36.050
THEY LOOKING TO. THEIR THEIR
05:20:36.116 --> 05:20:37.418
LOAN AND THEY ARE WORK ON THESE
05:20:37.484 --> 05:20:39.553
I JUST WOULD HAVE THAT WE CAN.
05:20:39.620 --> 05:20:41.622
IT OKAY UNTIL AUGUST SAYS OF
05:20:41.689 --> 05:20:47.394
SUPER. TO TABLE THIS ITEM UNTIL.
05:20:47.461 --> 05:20:50.064
OUR IS THERE A SECOND ON THE
05:20:50.130 --> 05:20:53.067
OCEAN. ALL RIGHT SIR BY BEST.
05:20:53.133 --> 05:20:59.239
CALL. THE MOTION IS TO APPROVE
05:20:59.306 --> 05:21:01.976
ATER ONE TWENTY EIGHT OH FIVE
05:21:02.042 --> 05:21:03.811
HI RISK LOCAL AID OUGHT PROGRAM
05:21:03.877 --> 05:21:05.546
CITY SAN GAY RIVER BY THE
05:21:05.613 --> 05:21:11.652
AUDITOR. WITH AYE DEFERRAL
05:21:11.719 --> 05:21:13.153
UNTIL AUGUST OF TWENTY TWENTY
05:21:13.220 --> 05:21:17.057
CORRECT. SO THE MOTION IS TO
05:21:17.124 --> 05:21:18.459
APPROVE THE AUDIT IF HE GETS
05:21:18.525 --> 05:21:19.727
APPROVED IS TO BRING IT BACK
05:21:19.793 --> 05:21:21.428
FOR CONSIDERATION THE TABLE TO
05:21:21.495 --> 05:21:22.596
TABLE THE MOTION IS ON THE
05:21:22.663 --> 05:21:26.066
TABLE THE ITEM UNTIL UNTIL
05:21:26.133 --> 05:21:27.434
AUGUST. UNTIL AUGUST. THE
05:21:27.501 --> 05:21:29.203
CURRENT MOTION IT'S THE TABLE
05:21:29.269 --> 05:21:30.437
THE AUTHOR REQUEST TWENTY
05:21:30.504 --> 05:21:31.772
TWENTY DASH EIGHT OH FIVE THE
05:21:31.839 --> 05:21:33.841
CITY OF SAN GABRIEL REQUESTED
05:21:33.907 --> 05:21:35.776
BY THE STATE AUDITOR. THE
05:21:35.843 --> 05:21:36.944
COMMITTEE WOULD RETAIN THE
05:21:37.011 --> 05:21:39.179
MOTION UNTIL AUGUST. ASSEMBLY
05:21:39.246 --> 05:21:40.748
MEMBER SALAS NO SOME MEMBER
05:21:40.814 --> 05:21:43.317
SALAS NOW BOERNER HORVATH.
05:21:43.384 --> 05:21:47.121
BOERNER HORVATH I GEN. GEN NOT
05:21:47.187 --> 05:21:50.591
VOTING PATTERSON. PATTERSON NOW
05:21:50.658 --> 05:21:55.229
RUBIO. RUBIO NOT VOTING VOEPEL.
05:21:55.295 --> 05:21:59.400
VOEPEL NOW WOULD. WHAT I
05:21:59.466 --> 05:22:02.336
SENATOR BORDERS. I'M SORRY
05:22:02.403 --> 05:22:08.075
SENATOR ROTH. BUT OKAY- CENTER
05:22:08.142 --> 05:22:10.978
GONZALEZ. OKAY SENATOR
05:22:11.045 --> 05:22:18.719
HERTZBERG. IS A SENATOR MINING.
05:22:18.786 --> 05:22:21.822
MORNING HIGH MORAL MORE LIKE
05:22:21.889 --> 05:22:24.491
NOW SENATOR WIENER. SENATOR
05:22:24.558 --> 05:22:31.699
WINNER. SO A CALL THE ABSOLUTE.
05:22:31.765 --> 05:22:38.205
SENATOR OFF. NON AS A MEMBER.
05:22:38.272 --> 05:22:43.744
HELLO SENATE ROTH WELL ROTH I
05:22:43.811 --> 05:22:50.951
BORDERS. CENTER. I'M JUST TO
05:22:51.018 --> 05:22:59.359
THAT SERVICE. THEY BRING.
05:22:59.426 --> 05:23:16.477
KICKOFF CENTER. THE. IF. OKAY.
05:23:16.543 --> 05:23:19.413
HERTZBERG NOW. HEY THAT MOTION
05:23:19.480 --> 05:23:22.082
FELL I'LL GO TO ME LET ME ASK
05:23:22.149 --> 05:23:23.951
WHERE MOTION ON THE RIGHT AUDIT
05:23:24.017 --> 05:23:26.687
WILL BY CENTER MORE LAW SECOND
05:23:26.754 --> 05:23:29.223
BY SO ROBB I'M SIXTY CALL THE
05:23:29.289 --> 05:23:33.293
ROLL. THIS MOTION IS TO A
05:23:33.360 --> 05:23:35.763
AUTUMN REQUEST TWENTY TO DASH
05:23:35.829 --> 05:23:36.997
OH FIVE. HIGH RISK LOCAL AGENCY
05:23:37.064 --> 05:23:38.832
AUDIT PROGRAM CITY OF SAN
05:23:38.899 --> 05:23:40.534
GABRIEL REQUESTED BY THE STATE
05:23:40.601 --> 05:23:42.236
AUDITOR ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS
05:23:42.302 --> 05:23:45.773
AYE. SALAS HI LEARN MORE ABOUT.
05:23:45.839 --> 05:23:49.843
BOERNER HORVATH HI GEN. CHEN
05:23:49.910 --> 05:23:52.279
NOT VOTING PATTERSON PATTERSON
05:23:52.346 --> 05:23:59.553
HI RUBIO RUBIO I'D. VOTE HI
05:23:59.620 --> 05:24:04.958
WOULD. SENATOR ROTH HI CENTER
05:24:05.025 --> 05:24:10.597
ROCK HI BORDERS. GONZALEZ
05:24:10.664 --> 05:24:12.466
GONZALEZ I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
05:24:12.533 --> 05:24:16.737
HIGH MINING MINING HI MORE LA
05:24:16.804 --> 05:24:24.278
MOORLACH I. WIENER AYE. MOTION
05:24:24.344 --> 05:24:25.445
CARRIES WILL THAT OVER FOR DISH
05:24:25.512 --> 05:24:30.651
MEMBERS TO ON THANK YOU. OKAY
05:24:30.717 --> 05:24:32.085
AT THIS TIME I WE'RE TO RETURN
05:24:32.152 --> 05:24:34.221
BACK TO IN A CALL. THE ROLL ON
05:24:34.288 --> 05:24:37.891
OPEN I DO WILL. CENTER HAS MOST
05:24:37.958 --> 05:24:43.263
FOR ON. CRISTINA AS WHICH IS.
05:24:43.330 --> 05:24:45.065
RESIDENT GEN I NUMBER FOR THIS
05:24:45.132 --> 05:24:48.402
IS TWENTY TWO DASH ONE ONE
05:24:48.468 --> 05:24:49.236
THREE THREE OF HAVING TO PARK
05:24:49.303 --> 05:24:53.073
AND CON PRACTICES AGAIN LIFE SO
05:24:53.140 --> 05:24:55.843
GOOD. OCEAN THANK YOU I'D LIKE
05:24:55.909 --> 05:24:57.611
TO THINK MISTER CHAIR I LIKE TO
05:24:57.678 --> 05:25:00.214
MAKE THE MOST TO RETAIN US A
05:25:00.280 --> 05:25:02.950
MEMBER OR OUT A REQUEST THIRTY
05:25:03.016 --> 05:25:07.421
OR MORE DO FOR HER TO WEAR WITH
05:25:07.487 --> 05:25:12.259
THIS HUNTING. YOU WILL HAVE. TO
05:25:12.326 --> 05:25:15.696
HEARING ASSEMBLY MEMBER UP. OUR
05:25:15.762 --> 05:25:18.265
QUEST AND I AM CERTAINLY. APPLY
05:25:18.332 --> 05:25:19.666
THE IF SHE WOULD TO CHANGE A
05:25:19.733 --> 05:25:20.767
REQUEST TO THAT TIME THEN WE-
05:25:20.834 --> 05:25:22.970
CHANGE THE SCOPE AND BACK AND
05:25:23.036 --> 05:25:26.039
DISCUSS THAT. IF NEED BE LAST
05:25:26.106 --> 05:25:26.874
WOULD LIKE TO. THE MOTION TO A
05:25:26.940 --> 05:25:28.108
WAVE OF ANY OF. COMMITTEE WERE
05:25:28.175 --> 05:25:29.776
THAT WERE PREVENT. US FROM HOW.
05:25:29.843 --> 05:25:31.945
ALL RIGHT YOU THANK CENTER OF
05:25:32.012 --> 05:25:33.847
THE MOTION BEFORE US IS TO HAVE
05:25:33.914 --> 05:25:34.648
A VOTE ONLY HEARING IN THIRTY
05:25:34.715 --> 05:25:36.450
OR MORE DAYS DURING. THAT TIME
05:25:36.516 --> 05:25:39.052
ASSEMBLY GARCIA CAN REFER OUR
05:25:39.119 --> 05:25:41.355
LAST MOST AS TO WHY COMMITTEE
05:25:41.421 --> 05:25:43.557
RULES AND- ROLLED. THAT WOULD
05:25:43.624 --> 05:25:45.058
PREVENT FROM. THAT'S THE MOST
05:25:45.125 --> 05:25:51.832
BY. SOME GONZALO I WAS. SENATOR
05:25:51.899 --> 05:26:04.544
HERTZBERG. SO UP THE KALRA.
05:26:04.611 --> 05:26:08.181
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS HI. SOUTH
05:26:08.248 --> 05:26:09.783
I BOERNER HORVATH
05:26:09.850 --> 05:26:13.120
BOERNER HORVATH I JAN. GEN
05:26:13.186 --> 05:26:15.188
VOTING PATTERSON. PATTERSON NOT
05:26:15.255 --> 05:26:20.193
VOTING RUBIO RUBIO I VOEPEL.
05:26:20.260 --> 05:26:21.428
VOEPEL NOT VOTING ASSEMBLY
05:26:21.495 --> 05:26:27.768
MEMBER WILL. WHAT I CENTER ROCK.
05:26:27.834 --> 05:26:32.339
CENTER ROTH HI. FOR JUST AYE
05:26:32.406 --> 05:26:40.314
GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ I HURTS.
05:26:40.380 --> 05:26:41.081
WILL HOLD IT OPEN FOR
05:26:41.148 --> 05:26:43.016
ADDITIONAL MEMBERS TO ADD ON AT
05:26:43.083 --> 05:26:44.184
THIS TIME WE'VE EXHAUSTED THE
05:26:44.251 --> 05:26:47.821
AGENDA LIST SO WE WILL GO BACK
05:26:47.888 --> 05:26:50.657
AND CALL ABSENT MEMBERS. SO THE
05:26:50.724 --> 05:26:56.797
FIRST ONE IS. RIGHT SO. I'M
05:26:56.863 --> 05:26:58.332
CALL THE BOATS UNTIL SO THAT
05:26:58.398 --> 05:27:02.269
YOUR- YES. CLOSE SO THE FIRST
05:27:02.336 --> 05:27:04.171
THE WOOL OVER THE ROLE OPEN
05:27:04.237 --> 05:27:06.406
WILL OPEN THE ROLE FOR THE
05:27:06.473 --> 05:27:08.675
ITEMS THAT TO ALLOW MEMBERS SAT
05:27:08.742 --> 05:27:10.310
ON THE FIRST ONE IS THE WAVING
05:27:10.377 --> 05:27:12.713
OF JOINT RULES THIRTEEN AND
05:27:12.779 --> 05:27:13.347
FIFTEEN SO THAT WE CAN TAKE UP
05:27:13.413 --> 05:27:15.315
THE CONSENT CALENDAR OF A
05:27:15.382 --> 05:27:16.950
STRUCTURE CALL THE ROLL
05:27:17.017 --> 05:27:18.852
INDICATING THE JURORS BUT AGAIN
05:27:18.919 --> 05:27:20.554
THE MOTION IS TO WAIVE
05:27:20.620 --> 05:27:22.289
COMMITTEE WILL THIRTEEN AND
05:27:22.356 --> 05:27:22.923
FIFTEEN IN ORDER TO APPROVE THE
05:27:22.990 --> 05:27:23.790
CONSENT CALENDAR
05:27:23.857 --> 05:27:25.926
BOERNER HORVATH. FOR ABOUT AYE
05:27:25.993 --> 05:27:30.063
CHAN CHAN I WOULD. WHAT I
05:27:30.130 --> 05:27:32.432
SENATOR MORLOCK MOORLACH AYE
05:27:32.499 --> 05:27:39.406
WIENER WIENER AYE. RIGHT
05:27:39.473 --> 05:27:43.577
CONSENT CALENDAR. THE MOTION
05:27:43.643 --> 05:27:47.347
SIR PER THE CONSENT CALENDAR
05:27:47.414 --> 05:27:47.948
TWENTY TWENTY ONE OH THREE BY
05:27:48.015 --> 05:27:49.649
SENATOR BELL TWENTY TWENTY ONE
05:27:49.716 --> 05:27:50.250
OH EIGHT BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:27:50.317 --> 05:27:54.521
SALAS. TWENTY TWENTY ONE
05:27:54.588 --> 05:27:55.088
ELEVEN. BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:27:55.155 --> 05:27:57.190
RUBIO TWENTY TWENTY EIGHT OH
05:27:57.257 --> 05:27:57.791
TWO CITY OF LIFE BY THE STATE
05:27:57.858 --> 05:28:02.062
AUDITOR. TWENTY TWENTY EIGHT OH
05:28:02.129 --> 05:28:02.696
THREE CITY OF EL SERENO BY THE
05:28:02.763 --> 05:28:05.565
STATE AUDITOR TWENTY TWENTY
05:28:05.632 --> 05:28:06.800
EIGHT OH SIX CITY OF WEST
05:28:06.867 --> 05:28:08.468
COVINA BY THE STATE AUDITOR.
05:28:08.535 --> 05:28:10.971
THE GERMANS VOTED BY-
05:28:11.038 --> 05:28:13.140
BOERNER HORVATH.
05:28:13.206 --> 05:28:16.043
BOERNER HORVATH HI GEN. GEN HI
05:28:16.109 --> 05:28:20.247
WOOD. WOOD I. SENATOR MORLOCK
05:28:20.313 --> 05:28:24.051
MOORLACH HI WIENER WIENER ON.
05:28:24.117 --> 05:28:27.154
THE MOTION CARRIES. WE NOW MOVE
05:28:27.220 --> 05:28:30.757
TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER TEN THIS
05:28:30.824 --> 05:28:32.225
IS TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE OF
05:28:32.292 --> 05:28:34.394
TWO ALAMEDA FRESNO LOS ANGELES
05:28:34.461 --> 05:28:34.895
COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
05:28:34.961 --> 05:28:36.496
REALIGNMENT FUNDING FUND
05:28:36.563 --> 05:28:39.800
SPENDING- MISTER RECALLED. THE
05:28:39.866 --> 05:28:41.701
MOTION IS TO APPROVE TWENTY
05:28:41.768 --> 05:28:43.136
TWENTY ONE OH TO ALAMEDA FRESNO
05:28:43.203 --> 05:28:44.104
LOS ANGELES COUNTY SHERIFF'S
05:28:44.171 --> 05:28:46.940
OFFICE REALIGNMENT FUND
05:28:47.007 --> 05:28:47.574
SPENDING BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER COM
05:28:47.641 --> 05:28:50.377
LONGER. SO MEMBER CHAD. SO
05:28:50.444 --> 05:29:00.520
AMBER CHEN HI. SENATOR ROTH.
05:29:00.587 --> 05:29:04.691
BARGES NO ON THE REPORT IS NOW
05:29:04.758 --> 05:29:06.326
YOU'RE RIGHT YEAH THIRTY FIVE
05:29:06.393 --> 05:29:08.495
SENATOR HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG HI
05:29:08.562 --> 05:29:17.070
MORNING. AND SENATOR WINNER. WE
05:29:17.137 --> 05:29:19.706
HAVE FIVE DID YOU GET THAT ONE
05:29:19.773 --> 05:29:24.344
WHAT THE DIPLOMA MORE YEAH YEAH.
05:29:24.411 --> 05:29:31.284
I GOT YOUR- ONE. MONEX THAT'S
05:29:31.351 --> 05:29:32.919
ABOUT THE DOESN'T MUNNINGS.
05:29:32.986 --> 05:29:36.823
MONIES I FELT MORE. MONEY ZERO
05:29:36.890 --> 05:29:41.728
NINE ALSO. YES ABOUT THE- BUT
05:29:41.795 --> 05:29:43.130
BUILT LIKE A REFRIGERATION TO
05:29:43.196 --> 05:29:47.434
CHANGE MY VOTE FOR THE PAST-
05:29:47.501 --> 05:29:50.437
ALMOST OF SO PLEASE. SO THAT GO
05:29:50.504 --> 05:29:52.739
THROUGH IT ONCE MORE AND PLEASE
05:29:52.806 --> 05:29:53.840
ANNOUNCE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHAD
05:29:53.907 --> 05:29:55.575
THIS MOTION WAS YOUR PROVIDER
05:29:55.642 --> 05:29:57.244
QWEST TWENTY TWENTY ONE OR TWO
05:29:57.310 --> 05:29:58.812
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER COM LONGER
05:29:58.879 --> 05:30:02.449
I'LL JUST GO THROUGH THANKS BYE
05:30:02.516 --> 05:30:03.783
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS. HI
05:30:03.850 --> 05:30:07.187
BOERNER HORVATH. OUR EVERY
05:30:07.254 --> 05:30:08.755
NOTING JUST NOT ABSENT ONE OKAY
05:30:08.822 --> 05:30:13.693
SO CHEN YELLOW CHANGE. FROM HI
05:30:13.760 --> 05:30:16.830
TO FROM FROM EITHER NOT VOTING.
05:30:16.897 --> 05:30:23.803
YEAH YEAH YEAH. THE BILL. THE
05:30:23.870 --> 05:30:29.442
GENERAL. AND UNTIL. CORRECT CAN
05:30:29.509 --> 05:30:33.613
CHANGE THE OUTCOME OF THE- OKAY
05:30:33.680 --> 05:30:38.785
YEAH THE SERVICE THROUGH. BUT
05:30:38.852 --> 05:30:42.389
IT DOESN'T. IN A DOZEN ON
05:30:42.455 --> 05:30:46.359
ASSEMBLYMEMBER AJ. CENTER
05:30:46.426 --> 05:30:51.998
MONNING I SEC THE SUN. TWENTY
05:30:52.065 --> 05:30:52.832
TWENTY YEAH TWENTY TWENTY A
05:30:52.899 --> 05:30:55.635
TWENTY. HEY WE ARE THAT THE
05:30:55.702 --> 05:30:59.940
BOOK. IS THAT WHAT YOU CALL IT.
05:31:00.006 --> 05:31:03.376
SO WE'RE WE'RE GONNA HAVE SOME-ACCOUNTABILITY OR SO FOR TWENTY
05:31:03.443 --> 05:31:06.780
TWENTY DASH ONE OH TWO. THIS IS
05:31:06.846 --> 05:31:07.647
A VOTE ON THIS IS HOW WE HAVE
05:31:07.714 --> 05:31:09.816
IT. WE HAVE A THE CHAIRMEN
05:31:09.883 --> 05:31:11.084
SUMMER CELLS VOTING AYE
05:31:11.151 --> 05:31:12.319
BOERNER HORVATH WE HAVE AS
05:31:12.385 --> 05:31:14.621
EDUCATED AS MY- ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:31:14.688 --> 05:31:16.089
CHAD AS A NOT VOTING WHICH
05:31:16.156 --> 05:31:17.023
DOESN'T CHANGE THE OUTCOME OF
05:31:17.090 --> 05:31:18.491
THE VOTE. ASSEMBLYMEMBER
05:31:18.558 --> 05:31:20.594
PATTERSON IS NO ASSEMBLY WOMAN
05:31:20.660 --> 05:31:21.728
RUBIO IS YES TO MY MEMBER
05:31:21.795 --> 05:31:23.129
VOEPEL YES SOMEONE MEMBER WOULD
05:31:23.196 --> 05:31:26.099
YES. ON THE SENATE SIDE SENATOR
05:31:26.166 --> 05:31:28.168
ROTH WE HAVE IS VOTING I. AS
05:31:28.235 --> 05:31:30.036
OUR BORDERS VOTING NO SENATOR
05:31:30.103 --> 05:31:31.605
GONZALEZ YES CENTER HERTZBERG
05:31:31.671 --> 05:31:35.442
GAS. CENTER MINING YES SIR MORE
05:31:35.508 --> 05:31:38.211
LOCKED UP VOTING CENTER WIENER
05:31:38.278 --> 05:31:40.247
AYE. JUST SO WE'RE ALL CLEAR
05:31:40.313 --> 05:31:42.215
THE MOTION CARRIES THANK YOU
05:31:42.282 --> 05:31:42.749
LET'S MOVE ON TO THE NEXT
05:31:42.816 --> 05:31:44.851
AGENDA ITEM. THE GENDER ITEM
05:31:44.918 --> 05:31:46.953
NUMBER ELEVEN TWENTY TWENTY
05:31:47.020 --> 05:31:47.654
DASH ONE OH FOUR CALVARY
05:31:47.721 --> 05:31:49.789
COLLEGE THE STRUCTURE CALL THE
05:31:49.856 --> 05:31:53.693
ABSENT MEMBERS. CAN WHAT WAS
05:31:53.760 --> 05:31:56.363
THE MOTION YEAH I'M NOT. BUT
05:31:56.429 --> 05:31:58.565
YEAH THE MOTION WAS TO- PROCEED
05:31:58.632 --> 05:32:02.769
WITH THE AUDIT WAS CARRIED. FOR
05:32:02.836 --> 05:32:04.738
THAT AUDIT NO JUST TO GET
05:32:04.804 --> 05:32:09.876
OTHERWISE KNOWN. SO YEAH I'M
05:32:09.943 --> 05:32:11.144
SORRY I THOUGHT YOU WERE ASKING
05:32:11.211 --> 05:32:16.516
ABOUT. THE MOTION FOR TWENTY
05:32:16.583 --> 05:32:18.351
TWENTY DASH ONE OH FOUR FOR.
05:32:18.418 --> 05:32:20.253
THE CALIBRATED TO THE MOTION AT
05:32:20.320 --> 05:32:23.690
THE TIME WAS MADE THAT. WE
05:32:23.757 --> 05:32:25.158
WOULD DELAY THE AUDITOR LOOKING
05:32:25.225 --> 05:32:26.626
AT THIS UNTIL AFTER JULY FIRST
05:32:26.693 --> 05:32:28.395
A CONTINGENT UPON IT BEING
05:32:28.461 --> 05:32:31.264
FUNDED IN THE STATE BUDGET. SO
05:32:31.331 --> 05:32:33.767
THOSE WERE THE TWO MOTIONS.
05:32:33.833 --> 05:32:35.468
WELL NOT FUNNY FOR ME NO NO NO
05:32:35.535 --> 05:32:37.203
FUNDING THAT CALIBRATE THAT THE
05:32:37.270 --> 05:32:38.705
ONLY COLLEGE CONTINUES IN THE
05:32:38.772 --> 05:32:41.007
BUDGET BECAUSE OF THE- IT
05:32:41.074 --> 05:32:42.776
DOESN'T. IT'S A MOOD VûI MOVE
05:32:42.842 --> 05:32:47.113
POINT. THAT MAKES SENSE NOTE.
05:32:47.180 --> 05:32:50.984
OKAY ALL RIGHT AGAIN. IN THE
05:32:51.051 --> 05:32:52.752
DISCUSSIONS DURING THE HEARING
05:32:52.819 --> 05:32:54.187
OR WANTED TO DO IS MAKE SURE
05:32:54.254 --> 05:32:55.455
THAT IF THE AUDITOR WERE TO
05:32:55.522 --> 05:32:57.424
PROCEED WITH THE AUDIT THE TWO
05:32:57.490 --> 05:32:58.925
CONDITIONS BE MET ONE THAT IT
05:32:58.992 --> 05:33:00.593
HAPPENED AFTER JULY FIRST WHICH
05:33:00.660 --> 05:33:01.728
ALLOWS THIS HOUSE THE
05:33:01.795 --> 05:33:03.129
DELIBERATION BETWEEN THE BUDGET
05:33:03.196 --> 05:33:05.799
COMMITTEES TO DECIDE WHETHER OR
05:33:05.865 --> 05:33:07.367
NOT THE ON MY COLLEGE COLLEGE
05:33:07.434 --> 05:33:08.368
WILL CONTINUE TO BE FUNDING.
05:33:08.435 --> 05:33:10.403
FUNDED IF IT IS FUNDED THEN THE
05:33:10.470 --> 05:33:12.238
ODD IT WILL GO THROUGH IT'S NOT
05:33:12.305 --> 05:33:13.940
FUNDED IT BECOMES A MOOT POINT
05:33:14.007 --> 05:33:15.775
AND WE DON'T WANT TO HAVE THE
05:33:15.842 --> 05:33:16.943
AUDITOR LOOK AT SOMETHING
05:33:17.010 --> 05:33:18.345
THAT'S NO LONGER BEING FUNDED
05:33:18.411 --> 05:33:21.214
BY. THE LEGISLATURE. OKAY ALL
05:33:21.281 --> 05:33:22.682
RIGHT THANK YOU AT THIS TIME
05:33:22.749 --> 05:33:23.283
WE'RE GOING TO CALL THE ABSENT
05:33:23.350 --> 05:33:27.654
MEMBERS ON. THE MOTION IS TO
05:33:27.721 --> 05:33:30.824
APPROVE AUTUMN REQUEST TWENTY
05:33:30.890 --> 05:33:31.391
TWENTY ONE OH FOUR CALIBRATE
05:33:31.458 --> 05:33:32.492
COLLEGE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:33:32.559 --> 05:33:34.728
MEDINA WITH THE INTENTION TO
05:33:34.794 --> 05:33:36.463
START THE AUTO ON OR AFTER JULY
05:33:36.529 --> 05:33:38.465
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY. AND
05:33:38.531 --> 05:33:39.733
DEPENDENT ON FURTHER BUDGET
05:33:39.799 --> 05:33:43.737
FUNDING OF CALIBRATE COLLEGE.
05:33:43.803 --> 05:33:45.605
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHAD ALL RIGHT
05:33:45.672 --> 05:33:48.908
GEN I PATTERSON. PATTERSON I
05:33:48.975 --> 05:33:52.979
WOULD. WOULD HI SENATOR ROBB.
05:33:53.046 --> 05:33:55.548
SENATOR ROBB I'D FORGES. FOR
05:33:55.615 --> 05:33:57.851
JUST HI GONZALEZ GONZALEZ HI
05:33:57.917 --> 05:34:01.821
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG HIGH MINING
05:34:01.888 --> 05:34:06.025
MINING HI MOORLACH MOORLACH HI
05:34:06.092 --> 05:34:09.295
WIENER WIENER HI. THAT MOTION
05:34:09.362 --> 05:34:11.398
CARRIES A MOVING ON TO AGENDA
05:34:11.464 --> 05:34:13.400
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE TWENTY
05:34:13.466 --> 05:34:14.267
TWENTY DASH ONE OH SIX
05:34:14.334 --> 05:34:15.335
STATEWIDE HOMELESSNESS FUNDING
05:34:15.402 --> 05:34:17.504
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KILEY CALL
05:34:17.570 --> 05:34:18.471
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:34:18.538 --> 05:34:26.112
BOERNER HORVATH FOUND RUBIO.
05:34:26.179 --> 05:34:30.383
YES IT'S TWENTY TWENTY ONE OH
05:34:30.450 --> 05:34:30.950
SIX BY THE MEMBER KILEY NOT
05:34:31.017 --> 05:34:36.823
PUTTING OKAY. SENATOR ROTH.
05:34:36.890 --> 05:34:43.296
WHAT THE ROTH I. GORGEOUS
05:34:43.363 --> 05:34:46.232
GORGEOUS I GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ
05:34:46.299 --> 05:34:52.806
HI HERTZBERG. MORE LACK MORE
05:34:52.872 --> 05:35:07.020
LIKE I. I THINK. THIS IS I
05:35:07.086 --> 05:35:07.687
THINK THERE MAY BE SOME
05:35:07.754 --> 05:35:09.422
CONFUSION ON WHAT THIS ITEM IS
05:35:09.489 --> 05:35:11.191
IT'S TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE OH
05:35:11.257 --> 05:35:12.225
SIX STATEWIDE HOMELESSNESS
05:35:12.292 --> 05:35:13.293
FUNDING BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:35:13.359 --> 05:35:14.994
KILEY IS THAT. CORRECT WITH
05:35:15.061 --> 05:35:21.935
EVERYONE. OKAY I DON'T THINK.
05:35:22.001 --> 05:35:27.373
THAT'S RIGHT. WE HAVE COMPETING.
05:35:27.440 --> 05:35:32.879
BILLS BECAUSE THE- SURE. THE
05:35:32.946 --> 05:35:37.116
OTHER. ALRIGHT THAT WILL KEEP
05:35:37.183 --> 05:35:39.586
OKAY THAT MOTION FAILS. I AM
05:35:39.652 --> 05:35:46.259
MOVING ON TO. PLEASE CREATION
05:35:46.326 --> 05:35:46.826
OF HONORED BY TWENTY TWENTY
05:35:46.893 --> 05:35:51.231
THAT BUT I CAN READ WITH WITH
05:35:51.297 --> 05:35:54.300
MEETING COMMITTEE. I KNEW WHAT
05:35:54.367 --> 05:36:02.642
THE. MISTER SECRETARY. THE VOTE
05:36:02.709 --> 05:36:08.481
STANDS WHERE. THREE EYES AND
05:36:08.548 --> 05:36:09.115
THE REST ARE EITHER NOT VOTING
05:36:09.182 --> 05:36:11.985
OR NOW FOR THE ASSEMBLY ON THE
05:36:12.051 --> 05:36:18.458
SENATE SIDE WE HAVE. THREE EYES
05:36:18.525 --> 05:36:22.495
AND FOR NOT VOTING. GOT A
05:36:22.562 --> 05:36:23.963
MISTER CHEN- WIDE EYES EXCUSE
05:36:24.030 --> 05:36:25.732
ME COMMISSION FOR THE J. LACK
05:36:25.798 --> 05:36:28.601
ANYBODY CAN RESUBMIT A LETTER
05:36:28.668 --> 05:36:30.603
FOR AN UPCOMING HEARING. SO
05:36:30.670 --> 05:36:32.772
WHAT SHOULD YOU SPOKE WITH MADE
05:36:32.839 --> 05:36:37.076
A MOTION TO RECONSIDER- ON. IS
05:36:37.143 --> 05:36:38.044
THAT WHAT YOU'RE REFERRING TO
05:36:38.111 --> 05:36:39.879
MR CHEN TO BE REMOTE FIGURE
05:36:39.946 --> 05:36:44.784
THIS HERE. NOW IN THE FUTURE NO.
05:36:44.851 --> 05:36:51.224
SORT OF THE POINT. SAME HERE.
05:36:51.291 --> 05:36:55.862
OKAY SO PURSUANT TO. THE JOINT
05:36:55.929 --> 05:36:57.964
ROLES MR CHEN IS ASKING THAT
05:36:58.031 --> 05:37:03.069
THIS AUDIT. THE REQUESTED. YOUR
05:37:03.136 --> 05:37:05.471
MOTION IS TO ALLOW TO BE HEARD
05:37:05.538 --> 05:37:07.740
AT A SUBSEQUENT HEARING CORRECT
05:37:07.807 --> 05:37:23.556
OKAY. THIS. ONE OF THE FIVE
05:37:23.623 --> 05:37:24.991
POINT POINT OF THIS WILL BE A
05:37:25.058 --> 05:37:28.127
VOTE YEAH COULD YOU CLARIFY SO.
05:37:28.194 --> 05:37:30.263
WE'RE NOT VOTING THAT WE WILL
05:37:30.330 --> 05:37:31.531
WE'RE ONLY VOTING THAT WE WILL
05:37:31.598 --> 05:37:33.266
HEAR THE ENTIRE THING AGAIN
05:37:33.333 --> 05:37:35.034
WHAT WE DID TODAY AT A
05:37:35.101 --> 05:37:36.235
SUBSEQUENT HEARING THAT'S
05:37:36.302 --> 05:37:39.138
CORRECT OKAY. SO THE MOTION IS
05:37:39.205 --> 05:37:39.739
TO ALLOW RECONSIDERATION LIKE
05:37:39.806 --> 05:37:42.575
WE- BUT IT'S PURSUANT TO THE
05:37:42.642 --> 05:37:44.043
JOINT ROLLING WE NAME IT'S
05:37:44.110 --> 05:37:46.613
WHAT'S THE GENERAL. THIRTY
05:37:46.679 --> 05:37:48.548
THREE THIRTY BE. A MOTION Y.
05:37:48.615 --> 05:37:49.882
WILL READ THIRTY BE INTO THE
05:37:49.949 --> 05:37:51.551
RECORD SO EVERYBODY'S CLEAR A
05:37:51.618 --> 05:37:52.919
MOTION TO RECONSIDER A VOTE BY
05:37:52.986 --> 05:37:54.187
WHICH AND I REQUEST THAT HAS
05:37:54.253 --> 05:37:56.422
BEEN DEFEATED SHELBY IN ORDER
05:37:56.489 --> 05:37:57.357
AND SHALL BE VOTED UPONAT THE
05:37:57.423 --> 05:37:59.959
SAME. THE SAME MEETING. AND
05:38:00.026 --> 05:38:02.261
SUCH A MOTION IF SUCH A MOTION
05:38:02.328 --> 05:38:04.931
IS CARRIED BY A VOTE OF FOUR
05:38:04.998 --> 05:38:05.565
MEMBERS FROM EACH HOUSE THE OUT
05:38:05.632 --> 05:38:06.566
A REQUEST FOR EACH. WHICH
05:38:06.633 --> 05:38:07.500
RECONSIDERATION HAS BEEN
05:38:07.567 --> 05:38:08.501
GRANTED PURSUANT TO THIS
05:38:08.568 --> 05:38:09.602
PARAGRAPH SHALL NOT BE HEARD
05:38:09.669 --> 05:38:11.237
AGAIN UNTIL A SUBSEQUENT
05:38:11.304 --> 05:38:13.906
MEETING OF THE COMMITTEE. SO
05:38:13.973 --> 05:38:17.110
THAT'S A MOTION. ALL RIGHT SO
05:38:17.176 --> 05:38:18.645
THERE'S A MOTION BY ASSEMBLY
05:38:18.711 --> 05:38:20.647
MEMBER CHANNELS ARE SECONDS.
05:38:20.713 --> 05:38:24.684
SECOND BY SENATOR ROBB. OKAY
05:38:24.751 --> 05:38:26.853
MISTER ROTH IS CONCEDING THE
05:38:26.919 --> 05:38:27.353
SECOND MOTION TO SENATOR
05:38:27.420 --> 05:38:34.460
MORLOCK. FANTASTIC ALL RIGHT.
05:38:34.527 --> 05:38:36.629
AB MR SURGERY CALL THE ROLL THE
05:38:36.696 --> 05:38:39.666
MOTION IS- TO RECONSIDER AT A
05:38:39.732 --> 05:38:41.868
SUBSEQUENT HEARING HOTTER QUEST
05:38:41.934 --> 05:38:42.735
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE OH SIX
05:38:42.802 --> 05:38:44.070
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KILEY
05:38:44.137 --> 05:38:46.305
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SALAS AYE SALAS
05:38:46.372 --> 05:38:47.840
HI BOERNER HORVATH
05:38:47.907 --> 05:38:50.243
BOERNER HORVATH HI GEN GEN HI
05:38:50.309 --> 05:38:53.112
PATTERSON PATTERSON I RUBIO
05:38:53.179 --> 05:38:59.185
RUBIO HI. VOEPEL. WOULD WOULD I
05:38:59.252 --> 05:39:03.122
CENTER ROTH ROTH AYE FORGES
05:39:03.189 --> 05:39:06.092
BORDERS HI GONZALEZ GONZALEZ HI
05:39:06.159 --> 05:39:08.027
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG HIGH
05:39:08.094 --> 05:39:11.030
MORNING MONNING AYE MOORLACH
05:39:11.097 --> 05:39:14.233
MOORLACH HI WIENER WIENER AYE
05:39:14.300 --> 05:39:15.668
THE MOTION CARRIES ITS WE'RE
05:39:15.735 --> 05:39:17.370
GOING TO MOVE ON TO AGENDA ITEM
05:39:17.437 --> 05:39:18.805
NUMBER THIRTEEN TWENTY TWENTY
05:39:18.871 --> 05:39:19.605
DASH ONE OH SEVEN DEPARTMENT OF
05:39:19.672 --> 05:39:21.641
TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL LEAD
05:39:21.708 --> 05:39:22.642
CONTAMINATION CLEAN UP BY
05:39:22.709 --> 05:39:25.144
ASSEMBLYMEMBER SANTIAGO MISTER
05:39:25.211 --> 05:39:26.012
SECRETARY CALL THE ROLL.
05:39:26.079 --> 05:39:28.481
BOERNER HORVATH BOERNER HORVATH
05:39:28.548 --> 05:39:32.185
HI GEN GEN I. CENTER MORE
05:39:32.251 --> 05:39:38.224
LOCKED. CENTER MOORLACH I
05:39:38.291 --> 05:39:40.893
CENTER WIENER WIENER AYE. THE
05:39:40.960 --> 05:39:45.698
MOTION CARRIES. WE'RE NOW
05:39:45.765 --> 05:39:46.599
MOVING TO AGENDA ITEM NUMBER.
05:39:46.666 --> 05:39:47.333
FOR TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE OH
05:39:47.400 --> 05:39:48.735
NINE IN HOME SUPPORTIVE
05:39:48.801 --> 05:39:49.302
SERVICES PROGRAM FUNDING MY
05:39:49.368 --> 05:39:51.838
ASSEMBLY WOMAN BOERNER HORVATH
05:39:51.904 --> 05:39:54.073
THE STRUCTURE CALL THE ROLL.
05:39:54.140 --> 05:39:56.709
SOMEONE OUR CHEN. GEN I
05:39:56.776 --> 05:40:04.784
PATTERSON PATTERSON I RUBIO.
05:40:04.851 --> 05:40:10.790
WOULD WHAT I CENTER RAFI ROCK
05:40:10.857 --> 05:40:14.427
HIGH WAGES ORDERS AYE GONZALEZ
05:40:14.494 --> 05:40:17.029
GONZALEZ I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
05:40:17.096 --> 05:40:19.832
HIGH MINING MINING FIVE. YEAH
05:40:19.899 --> 05:40:23.069
THAT MOTION CARRIES REMOVING TO
05:40:23.136 --> 05:40:25.071
FILE ITEM AGENDA NUMBER FIFTEEN
05:40:25.138 --> 05:40:26.105
TWENTY TWENTY DASH ONE TWELVE
05:40:26.172 --> 05:40:27.106
HOMELESS SERVICES COUNTY
05:40:27.173 --> 05:40:28.574
CONTINUUM OF CARE LEAD AGENCIES
05:40:28.641 --> 05:40:30.643
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER RIVAS THE
05:40:30.710 --> 05:40:32.378
SECRETARY CALL THE ROLL. SUMMER
05:40:32.445 --> 05:40:37.049
CHEN GEN HI SOMEONE NUMBER
05:40:37.116 --> 05:40:41.053
WOULD WOULD I SENATOR GORGEOUS
05:40:41.120 --> 05:40:43.856
GORGEOUS HI GONZALEZ INSULTS HI
05:40:43.923 --> 05:40:48.895
HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG HI MORNING.
05:40:48.961 --> 05:40:51.197
MONNING AYE MOORLACH. MORE LIKE
05:40:51.264 --> 05:40:55.434
NO WIENER. WIENER HI. RIGHT
05:40:55.501 --> 05:40:58.371
THAT MOTION CARRIES. MOVING TO
05:40:58.437 --> 05:41:00.139
FILE ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN TWENTY
05:41:00.206 --> 05:41:01.707
TWENTY DASH ONE ONE FOR
05:41:01.774 --> 05:41:02.742
CALIFORNIA RESOURCES BOARD
05:41:02.809 --> 05:41:04.076
GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTION
05:41:04.143 --> 05:41:06.512
PROGRAMS BY SENATOR BRADFORD MR
05:41:06.579 --> 05:41:08.514
SECTOR CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:41:08.581 --> 05:41:12.552
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHAD GEN I
05:41:12.618 --> 05:41:13.586
PATTERSON PATTERSON HI SENATOR
05:41:13.653 --> 05:41:21.360
ROBB. CENTER GONZALEZ GONZALEZ
05:41:21.427 --> 05:41:25.198
I HERTZBERG. CENTER BRAD
05:41:25.264 --> 05:41:28.301
ROBERTS HI. HERTZBERG AYE
05:41:28.367 --> 05:41:35.641
MONNING. CENTER WINNER. CENTER
05:41:35.708 --> 05:41:42.448
WINNER NOW. OKAY THAT MOTION
05:41:42.515 --> 05:41:48.120
CARRIES. NOW WILL MOVE TO
05:41:48.187 --> 05:41:50.223
AGENDA ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN
05:41:50.289 --> 05:41:50.790
TWENTY TWENTY DASH EIGHT OH
05:41:50.857 --> 05:41:52.225
FIVE CITY OF SAN GABRIEL CALL
05:41:52.291 --> 05:41:57.196
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. AGENDA ITEM
05:41:57.263 --> 05:42:04.503
NUMBER SEVENTEEN. SENATOR
05:42:04.570 --> 05:42:09.575
GORGEOUS. CENTER BORDERS I.
05:42:09.642 --> 05:42:14.981
OKAY NO. CORRECT I CALL THE
05:42:15.047 --> 05:42:17.016
ABSENT MEMBERS FOR TWENTY
05:42:17.083 --> 05:42:18.551
TWENTY DASH EIGHT OH FOUR CITY
05:42:18.618 --> 05:42:18.985
OF LINDSEY THIS WAS
05:42:19.051 --> 05:42:21.220
ADDITIONALLY ON THE AGENDA IS
05:42:21.287 --> 05:42:22.722
FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN IT WAS
05:42:22.788 --> 05:42:24.390
PULLED FROM CONSENT AND MOVED
05:42:24.457 --> 05:42:26.125
TO THE REGULAR ITEMS TWENTY
05:42:26.192 --> 05:42:28.327
TWENTY DASH IT'LL FOR CITY OF
05:42:28.394 --> 05:42:30.763
LINDSAY CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:42:30.830 --> 05:42:34.033
ON SAN DIEGO. ON THE AND WE'RE
05:42:34.100 --> 05:42:36.936
CALLING THAT WAS NEVER CLEAR
05:42:37.003 --> 05:42:39.405
VOTED ON IT'S TOO MUCH TO MORE
05:42:39.472 --> 05:42:44.110
SENATE-ROOM WE HAVE A. ONLY THE
05:42:44.176 --> 05:42:47.480
FAVORITE OF MANY YEAH. WE HAVE.
05:42:47.546 --> 05:42:48.714
ASSEMBLYMEMBER OF THE PAST IN
05:42:48.781 --> 05:42:52.184
THE ASSEMBLY HOW WE TO. AND
05:42:52.251 --> 05:42:57.823
ABSENT MEMBERS ELSE ABSENT. FOR
05:42:57.890 --> 05:43:01.294
CALLING UP SOME MEMBERS GRAY.
05:43:01.360 --> 05:43:03.229
THANK THE ABSENT MEMBERS BURNER.
05:43:03.296 --> 05:43:07.166
BURGER HI GEN GEN I. PATTERSON
05:43:07.233 --> 05:43:11.737
I SENATOR ROTH CENTER ROTH AYE
05:43:11.804 --> 05:43:15.007
FORGES OR JUST I GONZALEZ
05:43:15.074 --> 05:43:18.544
GONZALEZ I HERTZBERG. CENTER
05:43:18.611 --> 05:43:21.914
MONEY MORNING HI THAT MOTION
05:43:21.981 --> 05:43:24.984
CARRIES. ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
05:43:25.051 --> 05:43:34.226
MEMBERS. SHE SAID IT'S. MAY
05:43:34.293 --> 05:43:35.695
HAVE BEEN THE ONE. ALL RIGHT
05:43:35.761 --> 05:43:37.396
THANK YOU MEMBERS FOR TODAY'S
05:43:37.463 --> 05:43:39.598
HEARING OF SHE WAS A LONG AND
05:43:39.665 --> 05:43:43.202
ROBUST HEARING. SO THANK YOU.
05:43:43.269 --> 05:44:05.324
OF. THERE WERE. YEAH