ALLEN.
ANDERSON ATKINS.
BATES [inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
THE FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG [inaudible]
HILL [inaudible]
HUESO [inaudible]
JACKSON [inaudible]
LARA [inaudible]
LABOR REQUIRE [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONEY [inaudible]
MORE LOCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN YOU KNOW [inaudible]
ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN [inaudible]
STONE [inaudible]
BUT ACT [inaudible]
BY KATHY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
WILK.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY A
QUORUM IS PRESENT WITH THE
MEMBERS AND OUR GUESTS BE ON THE
RAIL AND IN THE GALLERY PLEASE
RISE.
WILL BE LED IMPROVE THIS MORNING
BY OUR CHAPLAIN SISTER MICHELLE
GORMAN AFTER WHICH PLEASE REMAIN
STANDING AND WILL BE LED IN THE
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE BY SENATOR
BELL.
LET'S BRITAIN'S SOME DEEP
BREATHS WITH GOD'S ENERGY AND
BREATHE BREATHE OUT SOME OF OUR
TIREDNESS.
AND SO WE PRAY TODAY --
GODS.
HELP ME TO BELIEVE THE TRUTH
ABOUT MYSELF.
NO MATTER HOW BEAUTIFUL IT IS.
HELP ME TO BELIEVE THE TRUTH
ABOUT MYSELF.
NO MATTER HOW BEAUTIFUL IS IS A
MAN.
REPEAT AFTER ME I PLEDGE
ALLEGIANCE. TO THE FLAG OF YEAH
STATES OF AMERICA.
AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT
STANDS. ONE ASIAN UNDER GOD
INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND
JUSTICE FOR ALL.
GOOD MORNING MEMBERS I WOULD
LIKE TO RECOGNIZE MAJORITY
LEADER SENATOR MONEY.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT GOOD
MORNING MEMBERS --
JUST AN OVERVIEW OF HOW WE'RE
GONNA PROCEED TODAY --
THERE'LL BE ABOUT SEVENTY SIX
ASSEMBLY BILLS ELIGIBLE ON THIRD
READING WE WILL BE STARTING WITH
SENATE BILLS ON UNFINISHED
BUSINESS.
THERE'S ABOUT SIXTY SEVEN
ELIGIBLE ON CONCURRENCE SOME OF
THOSE WILL BE ELIGIBLE FOR
CONSENT.
WE WILL BE STARTING WITH THOSE
SENATE BILLS ON CONCURRENCE
WE'LL WORK THROUGH THAT FILE AND
THEN WE'LL MOVE TO THE ASSEMBLY
THIRD READING FILE --
LUNCH WILL BE SERVED WE'RE NOT
GOING TO BREAK FOR LUNCH IF YOU.
GO OFF THE FLOOR PLEASE KEEP
YOUR EARS TUNED SO YOU CAN ADD
IN ON VOTES WERE GONNA TRY TO
KEEP OUR FULL HOUSE HERE FOR
THESE EARLY VOTE SO WE DON'T
HAVE.
TO PUT BILLS ON CALL BUT IF YOU
DO HAVE BUSINESS.
PLEASE LET ME KNOW AND WE'LL
ACCOMMODATE THAT.
WE'RE GONNA WORK HARD THROUGH
THE AFTERNOON.
WE'RE GONNA TOUCH BASE --
LATE AFTERNOON SEE WHERE WE ARE
DINNER WILL BE SERVED --
IN IF WE WORK HARD WE WILL BE
REWARDED FOR HARD WORK THAT'S
ABOUT ALL I CAN SAY.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THANK
YOU SENATOR MEMBERS MESSAGES
FROM THE GOVERNOR WILL BE DEEMED
READ MESSAGES FROM THE ASSEMBLY
WILL BE DEEMED READ.
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES WILL BE
DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
ADOPTED.
MOTIONS RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES.
TO BE THE APPROPRIATE TIME TO
TAKE SOMETHING OFF OF CONSENT OR
MOVE TO THE INACTIVE FILE
[inaudible]
SEEING NONE.
WE WILL MOVE TO CONSIDERATION.
OF THE DAILY FILE.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ THE
SECOND FILE FLICKERING FILE
ASSEMBLY BILL TWO THIRTY FIVE
SEVEN NO NINE TWENTY SIX OH FIVE
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY SIX SIXTY
FOUR ASSEMBLY BILL. ONE EIGHTY
SEVEN FORTY SEVEN AND ASSEMBLY
BILL.
TWENTY SEVEN EIGHTY SEVEN THANK
YOU MISTER SECRETARY THE SECOND
READING FILE WILL BE DEEMED
ADOPTED.
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO
GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENTS.
WE'RE GOING TO START WITH FILE
ITEM NUMBER EIGHT SENATOR
CANNELLA.
THIS IS FOR CARLA NEMETH AS
DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
WATER RESOURCES MISNAMED IF
PREVIOUSLY SERVED AS DEPUTY SECT
SECRETARY.
AND SENIOR ADVISER FOR WATER
POLICY THE CALIFORNIA THAT'S
RESOURCES AGENCY.
SHE WAS APPROVED BY THE RULES
COMMITTEE ON AUGUST FIFTEENTH A
FIVE ZERO VOTE AS FOR ABOUT.
THE CENTER CANNELLA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALAN.
AYE ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
[inaudible]
BILL.
I BERRYHILL RECORD [inaudible]
NOAH.
BY BY CHIANG [inaudible]
BY DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES.
BY GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ.
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
[inaudible]
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA TIME ACQUIRE.
BY MITCHELL.
AYE MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
BY NGUYEN [inaudible]
BY NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I'VE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
GOD WILLING STERN.
YEAH I STONE.
I'VE I'VE ACT [inaudible]
BY COUNTY [inaudible]
HI WINNER [inaudible]
I WILL.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD.
BY DE LEóN [inaudible]
DODD.
NIELSEN EITHER BY [inaudible]
SKINNER.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS I
APPRECIATE YOUR ENTHUSIASM THIS
MORNING BUT IT DOES GET A LITTLE
LOUD AND IT'S HARD FOR THE
SECRETARY TO HEAR HOW PEOPLE ARE
VOTING.
WE'RE MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINE SENATOR CANNELLA.
MISTAKE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT THIS IS FOR TROY A
TYRONE TO THE BOARD OF PAROLE
HEARINGS.
MISTER TARA HAS PREVIOUSLY
SERVED AS A COMMISSIONER AND
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER ON THE BOARD.
HIS POINT WAS APPROVED ON A FIVE
ZERO VOTE BY THE SENATE RULES
COMMITTEE ON AUGUST TWENTY
SEVENTH PASS RIGHT ON THANK YOU
SENATOR CANNELLA MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON NO ATKINS
[inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BILL.
WELL I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
BY CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON.
DELGADO.
BY DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER.
BY HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
[inaudible]
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
BY NELSON [inaudible]
NGUYEN NO [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN PORTANTINO [inaudible]
PORTANTINO I ROTH.
AYE SKINNER.
AYE STERN.
AYE STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO WIECKOWSKI.
AYE WIENER.
AYE WILK.
BY LEGALLY ABSENT MEMBERS BATES
[inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
NIELSEN THERE'S NO.
EYES TWENTY SIX KNOWS TEN THE
MEASURE PASSED AT THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED MEMBERS
WE ARE GOING TO MOVE BACK TO
FILE ITEM.
EIGHT AND LIFT THE CALL MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BATES AYE [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
DODD AYE.
BY ZUBIATE NO ZERO THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED MOVING
TO FILE ITEM NUMBER TEN CENTER
CANNELLA.
THANK YOU BETTER PRESENT THIS IS
OUR LAST GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENT
FOR THE YEAR.
THIS IS NEIL SCHNEIDER TO THE
BOARD OF PAROLE HEARINGS MISTER
SCHNEIDER HAS THIRTY FOUR YEARS
OF LAW ENFORCEMENT EXPERIENCE
WITH THE SACRAMENTO POLICE
DEPARTMENT.
HIS POINT WAS APPROVED BY THE
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE ON AUGUST
TWENTY SEVENTH PASSED FOR TIME.
THE CENTER CANNELLA MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
AYE ANDERSON AYE ATKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
BILL.
BY BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA HEIGHT AYE TEARING
[inaudible]
WHAT DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO.
DODD THAT'S A I THOUGHT I FULLER
[inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
I AND IT'S I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
BY MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
BY STERN AYE STONE.
NO BUT ACT.
NO I COUNTY WITH AYE WIENER AYE
WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BATES NO [inaudible]
BERRYHILL CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE MORLOCK [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO WILK.
I SWINGS SEVEN KNOWS NINE THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED MEMBERS
TWENTY ONE OF OUR SIXTY SEVEN
MEASURES ARE CANDIDATES FOR
SPECIAL CONSENT WHICH WILL BE
TAKEN UP TONIGHT.
THE ITEMS WE WILL BE TAKING UP
RIGHT NOW DO NOT QUALIFY IF YOU
WOULD LIKE TO KNOW IF YOUR ITEM
OR ONE OF YOUR ITEMS QUALIFIES
FOR SPECIAL CONSENT.
PLEASE SEE THE DESK WE'RE GOING
TO START WITH UNFINISHED
BUSINESS FILE ITEM TWELVE
SENATOR HUESO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
JOINT RESOLUTION TWENTY TWO BY
SENATOR HUESO RELATIVE TO THE
TIJUANA RIVER VALLEY
[inaudible]
CENTER HUESO.
THANK YOU --
MAN PRESIDENT MEMBERS AS CHAIR
ARE TWENTY TWO IS BACK FOR
CONSCRIPTS THE AMENDMENTS AT CO
AUTHORS.
AND CLARIFY THE TIMELINE OF
LEGAL ACTION FILED AGAINST THE
IV WC.
AS ALL ALL OF YOU KNOW ADDRESS
IN THE CROSS BORDER POLLUTION IN
THE DECLINE RIVER VALLEY HAS
BEEN ONE OF MY TOP PRIORITIES
THROUGHOUT.
MY CAREER AS A PUBLIC SERVANT --
I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
FOR THIS MEASURE IN CONCURRENCE
AND AND AND AND ALSO A SUPPORT
THE WORK OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
AND BRING IN THIS LAWSUIT TO
COMPLETION.
THANK YOU SENATOR HUESO MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
THE I BILL.
BY BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA.
BY CHIANG.
KAI DE LEóN.
DELGADO.
AYE DODD [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES.
BY GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
AYE MORLOCK.
AYE MORRELL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN AYE STONE.
I AYE DECK.
AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE WIENER.
I WILK AYE BY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS BERRYHILL.
DE LEóN [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I EYES THIRTY SEVEN NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
GOING TO MOVE BACK TO MOTIONS
AND RESOLUTIONS.
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE TWENTY
NINE TEN D. THE FOLLOWING BILLS
ARE REFERRED TO THE RULES
COMMITTEE.
ITEM SIXTEEN S. B. TWENTY FIVE
S. B. ONE TWENTY S. B. TWO
SEVENTY FIVE S. B. THREE FORTY
NINE EST BEFORE.
FIFTY TWO S. B. FIVE SEVENTY
SEVEN S. B. SIX NINETY FIVE S.
B. SEVEN TWENTY SIX SB EIGHT
TWENTY NINE AND S. B..
ELEVEN THIRTY MOVING ONTO FILE
ITEM THIRTEEN SENATOR WIENER
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TWO TWENTY ONE BY
SENATOR WINNER AND ACT REALLY TO
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICTS.
SENATOR WIENER THANK YOU
ENTERPRISE AND COLLEAGUES US
SENATE BILL --
TWO TWENTY ONE IS --
A MEASURE THAT WILL BE AND GUN
SHOWS AND SALE OF GUNS AND
AMMUNITION --
AT THE COW PALACE WHICH IS THE
STATE.
ARE ON THE BORDER OF DALY CITY
AND SAN FRANCISCO AND MY
DISTRICT THIS IS A DISTRICT BILL --
DEKALB PALACE --
HAS APPROXIMATELY SIX GUN SHOWS
EVERY YEAR ODD DESPITE THE FACT
THAT FOR DECADES AND THE
SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES HAVE
BEEN ASKING --
THAT THOSE GUN SHOWS AND
UNFORTUNATELY DESPITE THE
OVERWHELMING LOCAL OPPOSITION
THESE GUN SHOWS THE CAL PALACE
HAS CHOSEN TO CONTINUE THEM.
OUGHT TO BE VERY CLEAR THIS IS
NOT CONTROVERSIAL I IN MY
COMMUNITY BY THE SAN FRANCISCO
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS VOTED
UNANIMOUSLY TO SUPPORT THIS BILL.
OUTSIDE THE CEMETERY COUNTY
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS VOTED
UNANIMOUSLY TO SUPPORT THE DALY
CITY COUNCIL VOTED UNANIMOUSLY
TO SUPPORT.
BOTH THE SAN FRANCISCO UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT AND THE
JEFFERSON HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT
IN DALY CITY VOTED UNANIMOUSLY.
TO SUPPORT THE BILL AGAIN THE
STOCK CONTROVERSIAL PEOPLE WANT
THIS TO GO AWAY OUT WE HAVE HAD
NOW PROTESTS BY HIGH SCHOOL
STUDENTS MOMS ORGANIZING. TO ASK
THAT THESE GUN SHOWS AND OUR
ENTIRE LEGISLATIVE DELEGATION
FROM SAN FRANCISCO COUNTY --
AND FROM CEMETERY COUNTY IN BOTH
HOUSES ARE AUTHORED CO AUTHORING
THIS BILL AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
NIELSEN.
MADAM PRESIDENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THE SENATE THIS THIS
BILL HAS BEEN AROUND BEFORE.
THIS BILL HAS BEEN DEFEATED
BEFORE.
AND I THINK THE POLITICAL
STATEMENT [inaudible]
THAT'S FINE.
THE PEOPLE IN THE AREA.
DON'T LIKE GUNS AGASSI DON'T
LIKE GUNS.
BUT I ASSURE YOU [inaudible]
THE CRIMINALS THE USE GUNS IN
THE COMMISSION OF THEIR CRIMES
DO NOT COME TO CAL POLICIES
[inaudible]
GUN SHOWS [inaudible] TO ACQUIRE
[inaudible]
THE RIFLES.
OTHER HAND GUNS.
THAT IS NOT THE PREFERRED VENUE.
BECAUSE THEN YOU ARE SUBJECTED
TO SOME OF THE REQUIREMENTS
IMPOSED BY LAW HERE NOW
[inaudible]
UNLAWFUL [inaudible]
GUN OWNERS [inaudible]
SO.
THE PROBLEM OF CRIME IN THE AREA.
HAS NOTHING TO DO.
WITH THE GUN SHOWS.
THE COW PALACE.
RATHER THEY HAVE A LOT TO DO
WITH POLICIES.
PROMULGATED IN THIS LEGISLATURE
[inaudible]
BORDERED ON THE ALLOW.
UNREAL MILITATED INDIVIDUALS
WITHIN OUR COMMUNITIES.
AND FACING DIMINISH TO NO
CONSEQUENCES FOR THEIR CONTINUED
[inaudible]
CRIMINALITY.
AGAIN THAT'S GOT NOTHING TO DO.
WOOD GUN SHOWS.
THE COW PALACE.
AND I GUARANTEE YOU.
WHAT THIS BILL TO PASS AND BE
SIGNED INTO LAW?
YOU WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO
IDENTIFY ANY [inaudible]
DIMINISH CRIME.
IN THAT REGION [inaudible]
ATTRIBUTABLE.
THE RUNNING GUN SHOWS.
NOT OF THE CAPITALISTS I URGE A
NO VOTE.
THE YOU CENTER NIELSEN MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE SENATOR
WINNER WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
THANK YOU AYE MADAM PRESIDENT
OUR PERSONAL THIS BILL IS NOT A
POLITICAL SAME AND THIS BILL AS
HE CAME TO ME BECAUSE BOTH --
HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS AND PARENTS
IN MY COMMUNITY --
ARE HORRIFIED THAT THIS IS GOING
SHOWS ARE STILL HAPPENING.
IS ANYTHING BUT A POLITICAL
STATEMENT ITEMS A CRIME PUBLIC
SAFETY I WOULD SAY OUR LOCAL
COMMUNITIES KNOW BEST AND IN
CEMETERY COUNTY AND SAN
FRANCISCO THE LOCAL COMMUNITIES
ARE.
OVERWHELMINGLY SUPPORTIVE OF
ENDING HIS GUN SHOWS BECAUSE
THEY KNOW WHAT'S BEST FOR THE
PUBLIC SEE TO THEIR COMMUNITY.
AND FINALLY I WILL KNOW --
IN TERMS OF CRIMINALITY --
THE OPERATOR OF THIS DONE SO
OPERATION TO OTHER FAMILY
MEMBERS BECAUSE IT TURNS OUT HE
HAS A FIRE ARMS CONVICTION --
IN THE PAST THAT HE'S INELIGIBLE
TO DO IT SO THIS IS NOT SOME
SORT OF PERFECT ON CHAU AYE
COLLEAGUES I ANSWER I DON'T.
THINK YOU SENATOR WIENER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
JERRY.
NO DALY OWN [inaudible]
I DELGADO.
I DODD.
AYE FULLER YOU KNOW GAINES NO
GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
BY MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
AYE SKINNER.
AYE STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO I CAN'T SEE.
I WINNER.
AYE WILK NOW NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL.
I SWINGS SIX KNOWS THIRTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FOURTEEN CENTER PORTANTINO
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR PORTANTINO IN AKRON
FARMS.
CENTER PORTANTINO THANK YOU ARE
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I SB
ELEVEN SEVENTY SEVEN IS BACK ON
CURRENT.
AND IT WILL PROHIBIT ANY PERSON
FROM MAKING AN APPLICATION TO
PURCHASE ONE MORE THAN ONE LONG
GONE WITHIN ANY THIRTY DAY
PERIOD.
AND WOULD BECOME UNIFORMLY
CONSISTENT WHAT WAS WHICH IS
ALREADY LAW FOR HANDGUNS AND I
RESPECFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD ELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG.
BUT NO DELEON.
I DON'T AUTO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
AYE LARA.
BY LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK [inaudible]
NO REAL [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
I I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
I WINNER BY WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BATES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BERRYHILL GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
BY [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
ROTH.
I SWEAR HE FIVE KNOWS TWELVE THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN MOVING TO FILE ITEM FIFTEEN
SENATOR HILL MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
SEVENTY SIX BY SENATOR HILL AND
ACKNOWLEDGE TRANSPORTATION AND
MAKING AN APPROPRIATION
THEREFORE.
SENATOR HILL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SB
THIRTEEN SEVENTY SIX ENSURES
CALIFORNIA'S DISABLED CITIZENS
HAVE ACCESS TO UBER AND LIVE
SERVICES.
IS WAS THE GOAL OF THE BILL WHEN
YOU ORIGINALLY SOUGHT IN APRIL
AND THAT IS THE GOAL TODAY.
DID MANAGE TO SB THIRTEEN
SEVENTY SIX TAKEN IN THE
ASSEMBLY DETAIL HOW THE CPUC
WILL ADDRESS THIS DISPARITY IN
CALIFORNIA.
BY DEVELOPING REGULATIONS FOR
TNC DISABILITY ACCESS INCLUDING
ASSESSING A MINIMUM FIVE CENT
FEE ON TNC USED TO FUND ON
DEMAND WHEELCHAIR ACCESSIBLE
SERVICES. THIRTEEN SEVENTY SIX
ALSO ALLOWED TNC TO OFFSET TO BE
ACTUALLY CUT OFF THAT.
IF IT HAD TO BE EXCUSED FROM
THIS FEE IF THEY DIRECTLY INVEST
IN WHEELCHAIR ACCESSIBLE
SERVICES ON THEIR APPS THIS
MEASURE HAS NO OPPOSITION.
SUPPORTED BY A COALITION OF
DISABILITY ADVOCATES AND UBER
AND LIFT COLLEAGUES ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE ON SB THIRTEEN SEVENTY SIX
THANK YOU SENATOR HEALTH MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
HI ANDERSON [inaudible]
I ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG.
NO DAILY ON DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
BY THAT I I'D LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I MORE LUCK NO MORALE
[inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NELSON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BY ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
NOVAK [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
BUT COUNTY [inaudible]
BY WINNER.
THE PIE WILK [inaudible]
I BY.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I BATES.
BATES I DON'T KNOW [inaudible]
DALY OWN [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I EYES THIRTY NO STATE THE
MEASURE PASSES [inaudible]
MEMBERS. FOR THE PRESIDING
OFFICER.
WE'RE GONNA BE TAKING UP THREE
BILLS.
THOSE THREE FILE ITEMS ARE FILE
ITEM.
SEVENTY TWO FILE ITEM.
TWENTY IN FILE ITEM [inaudible]
SIXTY ONE CENTER LEYVA.
DELAYED IS PREPARED TO TAKE UP
FILE ITEM SEVENTY TWO FIRST.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FIFTY SIX BY
SENATOR LEYVA AND ACT GOING TO
HEALTHCARE COVERAGE THE MORNING
CENTER LEYVA.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
MORNING MEMBERS SB ELEVEN FIFTY
SIX IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE.
AMENDMENTS TAKEN IN THE ASSEMBLY
SIMPLIFIED IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
BILL AND DRAMATICALLY REDUCED
IMPLEMENTATION COST.
STRENGTHENED PENALTIES FOR NON
COMPLIANCE A PATIENT PROTECTIONS
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE ON CONCURRENCE [inaudible]
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
THE FLOOR.
FINAL CALL DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THE FLOOR.
HEARING SEEN NINE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALAN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES.
NOBEL.
AYE BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG.
NO DALY OWN.
I DON'T GOT NO [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO.
BY JACKSON.
PILOTA [inaudible]
I LEYVA.
I MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NELSON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK [inaudible]
BY KATHY.
I WIENER AYE WILK [inaudible]
HI.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BERRYHILL.
CANNELLA.
BY [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO ROSS.
BUT I'D ASK.
I TWENTY SIX KNOWS IT.
EIGHT THE MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WERE NOW MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM TWENTY FOR THE
PRESIDING OFFICER.
MISTER SECRETARY.
CAN YOU PLEASE CALL EXCUSE ME
KEEP PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THREE TWENTY BY
SENATOR LEYVA AND ACT WILLING TO
PUBLIC HEALTH MAKING PREPARATION
THEREFORE.
MADAM SENATOR THE FLOOR IS YOURS
BIG YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
MORNING MEMBERS SB THREE TWENTY
IS BACK FOR CONCURRENCE THIS
BILL WOULD REQUIRE ALL ON CAMPUS
STUDENT HEALTH CENTER IS A
PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES. TO PROVIDE
MEDICATION ABORTION BY JANUARY
TWENTY TWENTY TWO THE AMENDMENTS
TAKEN IN THE ASSEMBLY RENAME THE
FUND ESTABLISHED IN THE BILL TO
THE COLLEGE STUDENT HEALTH
CENTER SEXUAL AND REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH.
PREPARATION FUND REQUIRES THE
CALIFORNIA COMMISSION ON THE
STATUS OF WOMEN AND GIRLS TO
ADMINISTER THE FUND AND PROVIDES
GRANTS OF TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS. TO EACH STUDENT HEALTH
CENTER AND TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS TO EACH PUBLIC
UNIVERSITY SYSTEM IN ORDER TO
HELP.
THE CENTER PREPARE.
PREPARE TO PROVIDE THIS SERVICE
CLARIFY THE REPORT REQUIREMENTS
IN THE BILL I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE.
SENATORS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
THE FLOOR WE DO HAVE SOME.
CENTER MORE LUCK THE FLOORS ARE
SIR.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT TIDY --
YOU KNOW LOOKING AT THE
COMPREHENSIVE ANNUAL FINANCIAL
REPORT FOR THE UNIVERSITY
CALIFORNIA THEY ARE ABOUT
NINETEEN BILLION DOLLARS.
UNDER WATER WITH UNRESTRAINED
UNRESTRICTED NET DEFICIT IN IN
THE BUDGET.
DOCUMENT THAT WE APPROVED THIS
YEAR THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE
INCLUDED A LITTLE FOOTNOTE
STATING THAT THE RETIREE MEDICAL.
FOR THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
IS NINETEEN BILLION DOLLARS AS
WELL WHICH MEANS THAT.
THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE
UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA THAT WILL
COME OUT IN A COUPLE MONTHS. FOR
THE YEAR ENDED JUNE. THIRTY
TWENTY EIGHTEEN WILL WORLD
REFLECT [inaudible]
A NEGATIVE [inaudible]
THIRTY EIGHT BILLION DOLLARS.
COLLEAGUES THIS FANTASTIC
UNIVERSITY SYSTEM WILL BE COMING
TO THIS FLOOR.
AND ASKING FOR EVEN MORE FUNDING
IN FUTURE YEARS.
THE POLITICAL PRESSURE FOR THE
BORDER REGIONS.
AGAINST RAISING TUITION IS JUST
TOO STRONG.
OR THEY IT THEY WERE BABY HAD A
MIRACLE BY JUST SAYING WE COULD
REDUCE OUR TUITION BY SIXTY
DOLLARS BECAUSE AN ANNUAL
ASSESSMENT FOR A LAWSUIT --
SETTLEMENT --
HAD FINISHED AND SO THEY GOT
SOME GREAT PR THAT BUT THAT'S
JUST A SHORT TERM --
PAUSE IN WHAT'S GOING TO
BECOMING ON THE HORIZON SO
CONTRACTING WITH OTHER HEALTH
CARE PROVIDERS AND POTENTIAL
INSURANCE COST INCREASES HIT
WARRANT A NO VOTE ON S. B..
THREE TWENTY JUST WE JUST MET
WITH THAT CHANCER CHEN IN THE
PAUL TANA JUST A COUPLE WEEKS
AGO AND THE FOCUS WAS ON STUDENT
HOUSING NOT ON ALL THIS OTHER
PERIPHERY.
STEP WE WE'VE STILL GOT A STOP
INCOME BRING OUR EDUCATIONAL
SYSTEMS HE'LL LOOK AT THAT.
CAL STATE UNIVERSITY SYSTEM
THEIR LITTLE AND BILL BETTER
SHAPE THEY'RE JUST UNDER FOUR
BILLION DOLLARS [inaudible]
WITH DEFICIT.
THE COMBINED IT.
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICTS ARE
ABOUT FIVE POINT FIVE BILLION
DOLLARS NEGATIVE SO WE'VE GOT
SOME.
BIG NUMBERS ON THE HORIZON WE'RE
ALSO LOOKING AT SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
AT FIFTY BILLION UNDER WATER SO
MISTER CHAIR MISTER PRESIDENT WE
GOT TO STOP.
PUTTING MORE FINANCIAL PRESSURE
ON OUR SYSTEMS BECAUSE IT WILL
COME BACK.
AND IT WILL COME TO US BECAUSE
THEY CAN BLAME US. FOR HAVING
CREEK INCREASE THEIR BUDGET SO I
RESPECTFULLY URGE A NO ONE SB.
THREE TWENTY THANK YOU SO MUCH
MISTER SENATOR.
MEMBERS BEFORE WE GO TO THE NEXT
SENATOR TO SPEAK IF WE CAN ASK.
ON THE FLOOR TO LOWER OUR VOICES
AND THOSE WHO ARE IN THE BACK TO
PLEASE LOWER VOICES.
AS WE'RE GOING TO HAVE SOME
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR
ASSISTANCE LET'S GO TO SENATOR
JACKSON.
CLICK YOU MISTRESS ARE QUESTION
OF THE FLOOR MANAGER OF THE
AUTHOR EXCUSE ME ABSOLUTELY NOT
IN SENATOR THIS THANK YOU.
UP THE SENATOR --
HOW MUCH IS THIS GOING TO COST
THE UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA WE
THINK ZERO DOLLARS THAT'S WHY WE
WENT OUT AND GOT PRIVATE FUNDING
AND AS I SAID IN MY STATEMENT
PREVIOUSLY --
EACH CAMPUS WILL BE PROVIDED
WITH -- TO
AND EACH SYSTEM WILL BE PROVIDED
WITH AN ADDITIONAL TWO HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS THEY SO THANK
YOU SO I KNOW THAT MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE FROM UP ORANGE COUNTY
LIKES TO TALK ABOUT NUMBERS BUT
EITHER HE WASN'T LISTENING.
OR THAT'S REALLY NOT WHAT IT
THAT OBJECTION IS ABOUT.
OF THE NOTION THAT THIS KIND OF
A HEALTH CARE IS ON THE
PERIPHERY.
IS THE KIND OF RESPONSE THAT
CAUSES A MOST WOMEN PARTICULARLY
ONE THAT YOUNG WOMEN THE
INDIGNATION.
THE NOTION THAT WOMEN ARE NOT
GOING TO HAVE ACCESS TO THEIR
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.
WHEN THEY NEED THAT SUPPORT WHEN
THEY NEED THAT ASSISTANCE FOR
MEDICAL TREATMENT FRANKLY IS
OFFENSIVE?
SO IF WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT AN
ISSUE THIS ISN'T ABOUT THE MONEY
COULD IT'S NOT GOING TO COST THE
STATE A DYING IT'S ARE GONNA
COST THE UNIVERSITY CALIFORNIA A
DYING.
LET'S GET DOWN TO IT A YOUNG
WOMEN ARE WOMEN WHO ARE IN THEIR
REPRODUCTIVE YEARS WE KNOW THAT
YOUNG WOMEN NEED THIS KIND OF
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE WE KNOW
THAT IN ORDER FOR WOMEN TO BE
ABLE TO EXERCISE CONTROL OVER
THEIR OWN REPRODUCTIVE SIT
DECISIONS.
THIS IS WHAT THEY WILL AT SOME
POINT IN TIME PERHAPS NEED
THAT'S WHY THIS BILL IS BEEN
INTRODUCED THAT'S WHY WE NEED TO
GET IT PASSED THAT'S WHY THE
WOMEN WHO GO TO COLLEGE WHO WON
AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THEIR CAREER.
NEED TO BE ABLE TO EXERCISE THAT
RIGHT AND WITH THAT I WOULD ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THAT YOU CENTER JAXA
[inaudible]
MEMBERS.
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THE FLOOR [inaudible]
FINAL CALL.
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR.
HERE YOU SEE NINE CENTER
LABELLED YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THAT
YOU MISTER PRESIDENT THANK YOU
FOR THE DISCUSSION MEMBERS I
WOULD JUST SAY.
THAT A WOMAN SHOULD ALWAYS HAVE
THE RIGHT TO DECIDE WHEN SHE
INCORPORATES A FAMILY INTO HER
LIFE AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
BY ANDERSON.
NO NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG.
NO DAILY ON I DELGADO
[inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES.
NO GOT JOHNNY.
BY GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
AYE LARA.
AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL
[inaudible]
I MONEY.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
BY STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT NO I COUNTY.
BY WIENER.
AYE WILK [inaudible]
NO.
MISTER SECRETARY CAN YOU PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS WE KNOW
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
BY.
I TWENTY SIX NOS THIRTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES.
SENATORS THIS WILL BE THE FINAL
BILL.
WITH THE PRESIDING OFFICER FINAL
ITEM SIXTY ONE MISTER SECRETARY.
HE PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN SEVENTY TWO BY
SENATOR LEYVA AND ACT BILLION
CLIMATE CHANGE SENATOR LEYVA
WELCOME BACK.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
MORNING AGAIN MEMBERS SENATE
BILL TEN SEVENTY TWO IS BACK FOR
CONCURRENCE AFTER RECEIVING
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN THE
ASSEMBLY.
THE AMENDMENTS TAKEN IN THE
ASSEMBLY AMONGST OTHERS REMOVE
MINIMUM SET ASIDE FUNDING
REQUIREMENTS FOR INVOLVED
AGENCIES CLARIFY DEFINITIONS AND
PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS TO SUPPORT.
THE STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNCILS
IMPLEMENTATION O THE PROGRAM S.
B. TEN SEVENTY TO ENSURE CENTERS.
EQUITABLE ACCESS TO FUNDING
PROGRAMS THAT IMPROVE THE HEALTH
OF ALL OF OUR COMMUNITIES.
THE BILL IS SUPPORTED BY DOZENS
OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
GOVERNMENT AN ENVIRONMENTAL
JUSTICE ORGANIZATIONS THE BILL
HAS NO OPPOSITION AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LEYVA MEMBERS
BEFORE MOVE THE DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
KNOW THAT WE ARE I IN THE HOME
STRETCH OF THIS MARATHON WEEK.
WE CAN ASK ALL MEMBERS ON THE
FLOOR.
IN ALL IN THE BACK ROOM TO
PLEASE LOWER OUR VOICES RABBITS
AND SENATORS.
I MEAN CHALLENGE ME OUT HERE.
DO NOW WE HAVE TO CONTINUE BASS
IS PERFECT JUST LOWER VOICE IS
VERY MUCH APPRECIATED THANK YOU
FOR YOUR ASSISTANCE WITH THIS.
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR SENATOR LARA GOOD MORNING
SIR THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
MEMBERS AGAIN THIS IS A VERY
IMPORTANT BILL ESPECIALLY FOR
OUR SMALLER CITY THAT NEED THAT
ADDITIONAL ASSISTANCE.
TONY MEET THEIR NEW OBLIGATIONS
ON THE SEVERAL BILLS THAT WE
PASSED.
BUT ALLOW THEM TO COMPETE FOR
CRITICAL FUNDING SO THAT THEY
CAN ALSO HAVE OPPORTUNITY COMES
FORM THAT COMMUNITIES IN MAY
COME A LOT MORE GREENER.
THANK YOU SALLY OFFICE IMPORTANT
BILL I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I
DON'T.
THANK YOU SIR LARA ADDITIONAL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THE
FLOOR.
FINAL CALL FOR DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THIS ITEM.
SENATOR LEYVA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT.
MEMBERS I'D IS THE RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE AND JUST LET
YOU KNOW HOW EXCITED I AM ABOUT
THIS BILL THIS IS OUR THIRD TIME
ADDED AND IT LOOKS LIKE WE MIGHT
GET A TO THE GOVERNOR'S DESK I
SPENT LESS FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY CAN
YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DALY ON I DELGADO [inaudible]
DODD.
THERE ARE AYE.
NOTE DELGADO AYE DODD AYE FULLER
[inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
I WAS SO [inaudible]
BY JACKSON.
PILOTA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
BY MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I MORE LOCK.
NO NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN.
I KNOW SON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER.
BUT I WILK.
I BY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BY.
EYES TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS TEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WERE
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM TWENTY
THREE SENATOR PORTANTINO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THREE FIFTY FOUR BY
SENATOR PORTANTINO AND ACT GOING
TO SPECIAL EDUCATION CENTER
PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU OUT MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS --
S. B. THREE FIFTY FOUR IS BACK
WITH AMENDMENTS TAKING IN THE
ASSEMBLY WERE CLARIFYING WITH
REGARDS.
THE COMMONLY RECOGNIZED LANGUAGE
BY LOCAL EDUCATION AGENCIES AND
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THINK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
AYE CHAIN.
I DALY ON I DELGADO.
AYE DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES.
BY GOD JOINING.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
AYE LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
I MONNING I MORE LOCK
[inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BY ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE.
NO FIVE ACT.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILL.
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
WILK AYE [inaudible]
ANDERSON NO [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I MORE LUCK [inaudible]
NO.
BY DEREK NOTE I EYES THIRTY
THREE NO SIX THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM TWENTY
EIGHT SENATOR WIENER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN HUNDRED BY
SENATOR WIENER AND ACT REALLY
AND ENERGY CENTER WIENER.
I THINK YOU AND PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES I RISE TO PRESENT
SENATE BILL SEVEN HUNDRED WHICH
IS BACK HOME CONCURRENCE.
I'M WHICH IT STANDS --
THE S. CHIP PROGRAM THE CELTS
GENERATION INCENTIVE PROGRAM UP
FOR AN ADDITIONAL FIVE YEARS
PAST CURRENT EXPIRATION.
LA THIS BILL --
WILL HELP TO EXPAND AYE ENERGY
STORAGE I CALIFORNIA SO THAT WE
CAN --
REALLY ODD BALANCE AL ARE A
RENEWABLE ENERGY IN PARTICULAR
SOLAR ENERGY PRODUCTION.
OUGHT TO ENSURE THE PEOPLE CAN
PRODUCE DURING THE DAY.
I KNOW WHEN THE SUN IS NO LONGER
SIGNING CONTINUE TO USE --
THAT ENERGY I RESPECTFULLY OUR
MEMBERS JUST XIN OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON NO ATKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
BY CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON.
I DON'T FOLLOW.
BY DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
HI HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
BY JACKSON.
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT.
NO I COUNTY.
I WIENER.
AYE WILK [inaudible]
NO.
PLEASE GO THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
PAN.
EYES TWENTY FIVE KNOWS TWELVE
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN SENATOR LARA FULL
PURPOSE TO RISE.
THANK YOU FOR ON A PRIVILEGE OF
THE FLOOR MAT A PRESIDENT.
PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU MEMBERS
IT'S MY HONOR TO PRESENT YOU MY
GODSON LICCARDO ALEXANDER OR
DIESEL HERE TODAY VISITING.
HE IS A BIG FAN OF POLITICS HE
KNOWS ALL THE CURRENT ISSUES AND
HE'S TALKED TO ME SEVERAL TIMES
THAT HE WANTS TO BE.
THE YOUNGEST CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
IN THE CITY OF PARAMOUNT AND
WANTS TO COME BACK AS THE
GOVERNOR SO.
I PLEASE HELP ME WELCOME HIM. TO
THE CAPITAL WELCOMES FOR YOUR
FIRST TIME HERE EIGHT BENNETT'S.
WE WILL LOOK FORWARD TO BIG
THINGS FROM YOU YOUNG MAN.
ALRIGHT MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO
FILE ITEM THIRTY CENTER
PORTANTINO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SOME FORTY SIX BY
CENTER PORTANTINO NECK RELATING
TO FIREARMS [inaudible]
SENATOR PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS --
S. B. SEVEN FORTY SIX IS BACK ON
CONCURRENT WITH AMENDMENTS THAT
ARE TECHNICAL IN CLARIFYING IN
NATURE AND ADDRESS MOSTLY
CHAPTER GOING OUT CONFLICTS AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE.
THE CENTER PORTANTINO MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
I BELL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG.
THE THE ON HI DEL GADO
[inaudible]
I DIED [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG [inaudible]
BY HILL.
IF I HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
NADA.
JACKSON AYE LARA AYE LEYVA
[inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
I MORALE [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PARA I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
I VIED ACT [inaudible]
BY KELSEY [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
I WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN.
BUT I BIDAK [inaudible]
NO WILK [inaudible]
I I CITY THREE KNOWS TO THE
ASSEMBLYMAN RENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM THIRTY ONE SENATOR
JACKSON MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
CIVIL A TWENTY SIX BY SENATOR
JACKSON AND KNOCKED RELATING TO
CORPORATIONS.
SENATOR JACKSON THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I'M VERY
PROUD TO BE JOINED IN THIS BILL
BY.
MY JOINT AUTHOR PRESIDENT PRO
TEM TONI ATKINS AS WE BRING THIS
BACK BILL. TO THE ASSEMBLY ON
CONCURRENCE THIS MEASURE
INCREASES GENDER DIVERSITY ON
CORPORATE BOARDS BY REQUIRING
THAT EACH PUBLICLY TRADED
CORPORATION HEADQUARTERED HERE
IN CALIFORNIA.
WILL HAVE AT LEAST [inaudible]
AT AT LEAST.
ONE WOMAN ON ITS BOARD BY THE
END OF TWENTY NINETEEN BEGINNING
IN JULY.
TWENTY TWENTY ONE THE BILL
REQUIRES A MINIMUM OF TWO WOMEN
DIRECTORS ON BOARDS THAT HAVE
FIVE DIRECTORS.
AND AT LEAST THREE WOMEN ON
BOARDS THAT HAVE SIX OR MORE
DIRECTORS AMENDMENTS TAKEN IN
THE ASSEMBLY MODIFY THE BILL'S
PENALTIES FOR FAILURE TO COMPLY
WITH ITS REQUIREMENTS.
AND CLARIFY THAT A PARTIAL YEAR
OF SERVICE BY A FEMALE BOARD
MEMBER IS NOT A VIOLATION OF THE
BILL.
COLLEAGUES.
THE TIME IS NOW THE TIME HAS
COME WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT
ARE.
A BUSINESS ENTITIES ARE MORE
PRODUCTIVE AND MORE PROFITABLE
AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT ADDING
WOMEN TO THESE BOARDS WILL DO
WITH THAT I URGE YOUR A AYE VOTE
ON CONCURRENCE IN THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS.
WE YOU CENTER JACKSON MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
[inaudible]
SENATOR ANDERSON.
MEMBERS AYE I CAN'T SUPPORT A
BILL.
IN MY OPINION THAT
UNDERESTIMATES THE POWER AND
STRENGTH OF WOMEN.
AND FOR THOSE THAT SERVE ON
BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS INNER ARE
ALREADY VERY DISCOUNTS THEIR
ABILITIES.
WE HAVE TREMENDOUS WOMEN LEADERS
HERE IN CALIFORNIA HER DOING
[inaudible]
INCREDIBLE THINGS AND TO SAY
THAT THEY COULD NEVER FIND THEIR
WAY ONTO A BOARD WITHOUT OUR
HELP.
UNDERMINES ALL THEIR HRD WORK
WHEN I THINK ABOUT HILLARY
CLINTON OR MEG WHITMAN.
AND OTHER POWERFUL STRONG WOMEN
TO THINK THAT THEY DON'T HAVE A
SEATED ABOARD.
WITHOUT OUR HELP.
I THINK IS JUST INCORRECT AND I
KNOW THAT I'M VERY PROUD OF MY
WIFE FROM VERY FRONT OF MY
DAUGHTERS.
AND I DON'T BELIEVE THAT THEY
NEED ME PASSING THIS BILL FOR
THEM TO BE QUALIFIED IT HAD TO
BE ON A BOARD IN I THINK THAT --
THIS UNDERMINES THOSE QUALIFIED
WOMEN WHO HAVE WORKED SO HARD.
IF YOU SENATOR ANDERSON MADAM
PRO TEM.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND I
KNOW THIS BILL IS BACK ON
CONCURRENT SINCE SO WE SHOULD BE
ABLE.
TO MOVE QUICKLY BUT I DO FEEL
COMPELLED TO SPEAK ON THIS FOR A
NUMBER OF REASONS.
YOU KNOW WHEN WE TALK WE'VE
TRIED TO INCENTIVIZE THIS.
WE'VE TRIED TO DO IT THE WAY BED --
ENTICES ENCOURAGES --
CORPORATE BOARDS AND
CORPORATIONS TO UNDERSTAND THAT
THIS WOULD BE IN YOUR BEST
INTEREST AND WE'VE QUOTED
STUDIES REAL STUDIES THAT SAY.
YOUR BOTTOM LINE WILL BE BETTER
SERVED BY DIVERSITY.
AND I'VE HEARD THE ARGUMENT THAT --
MAYBE SUPPORTING SOMETHING LIKE
THIS DISADVANTAGES OTHER --
MARGINALIZED MINORITY GROUPS.
HECK THEY'RE NOT DOING SO WELL
EITHER LAST TIME I LOOKED AT THE
STATISTICS ON THAT.
SO ARE ALL OF THE ARGUMENTS THAT
RESONATE AGAINST DOING THIS.
TALK ABOUT CONSTITUTIONALITY.
I I JUST GOTTA WONDER THE
CONSTITUTION DOES SUPPORT WOMEN
AS WELL.
I I WONDER ABOUT THE BALANCE
WITH CONSTITUTIONALLY
CONSTITUTIONALITY IN NOT
SUPPORTING ACCESS TO MORE THAN
50% OF THE POPULATION. TO BE
ABLE TO DO THIS AND WE CAN TALK
ABOUT WOMEN WHO'VE MADE IT.
I JUST REMEMBER A COLLEAGUE OF
MINE WHO NOW SERVES IN THE
ASSEMBLY.
TALKING ABOUT A GLASS CEILING IN
SHE SAID GLASS CEILING.
THAT CEILING WAS BOLTED SHUT
WITH METAL.
IF IT WERE GLASS I CAN HANDLE IT
[inaudible]
I JUST.
YOU KNOW I UNDERSTAND THERE'S
LOTS OF BARRIERS TO PUT UP TO
SAY WHY NOT TO DO THIS WHY NOT
TO ENCOURAGE IT WE'VE TRIED
WE'VE TRIED --
I THINK THEIR NEEDS TO BE
MOVEMENT HERE AND I THINK IT
STARTS WITH OUR EFFORTS.
AND LOTS OF THINGS HAVE STARTED
WITH WITH LAWS THAT HAVE SOME
DISPUTE OR DEBATE ABOUT
CONSTITUTIONALITY.
ARE IN FACT IT'S REFERENCED ON
ONE OF OUR PUBLIC SAFETY ISSUES
THAT WE WERE RECENTLY DISCUSSING
AND EVERYBODY AGREED WHAT WE
HAVE IN PLACE IS NOT
CONSTITUTIONAL.
AND YET.
WE STILL HAVE TO WORK TO MAKE IT
SO WE'RE GONNA BE DOING THAT SO.
I HEAR THE ARGUMENTS BUT I ALSO
SEE IN PRACTICE INCREDIBLE WOMEN.
WITH CREDENTIALS AND DEGREES AND
REAL EXPERIENCE AND I CAN QUOTE
YOU REAL LIFE EXPERIENCES OR A
GROUP OF WOMEN WITH ALL OF THAT.
LOST OUT TO THOSE LESS
[inaudible]
EXPERIENCED.
LESS TALENTED LESS DEGREES AND
AGAIN IT CONTINUES MEMBERS IT
STARTS WITH US.
WE WILL WORK OUT THE FALLOUT OF
ANY PIECE OF LEGISLATION WE
ALWAYS DO.
I ACTUALLY HAVE TO SAY THE TIME
IS NOW AND AYE.
I YEAH I I WILL QUOTE ONE LAST
PERSON.
THIS IS NOT MY LIFE NOW BUT I
REMEMBER --
ONE OF OUR STRONG WOMEN.
SPEAKING DECADES AGO AT A
CONVENTION WHEN SHE SAID I AM
SICK AND TIRED OF BEING SICK AND
TIRED AND I AM SICK AND TIRED.
OF BE IN A POSITION OF INFLUENCE
AND POWER AND YET SEEING SO MANY.
PEOPLE LIKE ME WHO ARE STILL
PLEADING TO BE GIVEN THAT
OPPORTUNITY AND THEY'VE DONE
EVERYTHING THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO
TO BE READY.
I WOULD ASK YOU TO REALLY
CONSIDER THIS WHEN TODAY THANK
YOU AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ATKINS SENATOR
BILL -- JUST
BRIEFLY I I THINK OF THE OTHER
PROBLEMS WE'VE HAD IN SILICON
VALLEY WITH --
THIS ISSUE --
MOST COMPANIES ARE NOW
RECOGNIZING.
THAT WITHOUT WOMAN IN THE
LEADERSHIP POSITIONS ON THE
BOARDS --
ARCHON ANYONE THRIVE IT'S SIMPLY
WON'T THRIVE.
AND IF WE LOOK TO THE FUTURE --
WE HAVE TO PASS THIS LAW WE HAVE
TO HAVE A DIRECTIVE.
ODD THE DIS TAKES PLACE IT'S
TIME TO MAKE THE CHANGE SO.
LET'S MAKE THIS MOVE AND VOTE
FOR THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SENATOR PELL MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE SENATOR
JACKSON WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
THANK YOU AN IMPRESSION I WANT
TO THANK MY CHOI NOT AUTHOR.
FOR SORT OF MAKING THE MOST
ELOQUENT TO A OF THE
JUSTIFICATION FOR THIS YOU KNOW
WE DID TRY THIS BACK IN TWENTY
THIRTEEN WE DID IT IN THE FORM
OF A RESOLUTION --
WE URGED THESE COMPANIES TO
RECOGNIZE THE PROFITABILITY
THEIR PRODUCTIVE INDEED THE
BENEFITS ALL THE BENEFITS OF
PUTTING WOMEN ON THESE BOARDS
AND HELPING RUN COUNTRY OUR
COUNTRY --
WE KNOW THAT WOMEN ARE 70% OF
THE CONSUMERS NOT TO HAVE THE
VOICE OF WOMEN ON THOSE BOARDS
COSTS THESE COMPANIES MONEY.
BECAUSE WE KNOW TAT THAT'S
SOMETHING THAT MOST THESE
COMPANIES ALL CONSIDER ABOUT
EXCLUSIVELY.
BUT THEY DIDN'T LISTEN AND SO
NOW IS THE TIME WHEN WE HAVE TO
STEP FORWARD AND SAY WE'RE NOT
GOING TO ASK ANYMORE.
WE ARE TIRED OF BEING NICE WE
ARE TIRED OF BEING POLITE WE'RE
GOING TO REQUIRE THIS BECAUSE
IT'S GOING TO BENEFIT THE
ECONOMY IT'S GOING TO BENEFIT
EACH OF THESE COMPANIES.
IT'S GOING TO BENEFIT THE
SHAREHOLDERS IT'S GOING TO
BENEFIT THE PEOPLE WHO WORK IN
THESE COMPANIES IT'S TIME THAT
WE BURST THAT MAN CAVE AND PUT
WOMEN IN THE CORPORATE BOARDROOM.
WHERE WE WILL DEMONSTRATE YET
AGAIN?
THOSE COMPETENT WOMEN AND THERE
ARE THOUSANDS OUT THERE WHO
WOULD TRUST LIKE THE OPPORTUNITY
TO BECOME.
THE LEADERS OF THESE BUSINESSES
IT BENEFITS US ALL THE TIME IS
NOW.
I WOULD ASK FOR YOUR I VOTING
CONCURRENCE ON ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS.
THANK YOU CENTER JACKSON MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
PATTERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
WELL.
BUT I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
SHARING [inaudible]
THE LEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
I DON [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG [inaudible]
HILL [inaudible]
BY HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
AYE LADA.
AYE LEYVA [inaudible]
MY MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
BUT ACT.
NO MY COUNTY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
I WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
HERTZBERG.
MITCHELL AYE AYE NGUYEN
[inaudible]
STONE [inaudible]
WIECKOWSKI.
APPLIES TO ME [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
STONE [inaudible]
NO.
KNOWS NINE THE ASSEMBLYMAN MINTS
ARE I HEARD IN MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING TO FILE ITEM THIRTY TWO
SENATOR WIENER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
FEDERAL A TWENTY EIGHT BY
SENATOR WIENER AN ACT RELATING
TO LAND USE SENATOR WIENER.
I'VE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT I THIS ARE SENATE BOY
TWENTY EIGHT EYES A REFORM TO
THE REASON HOUSING NEEDS
ASSESSMENT ARENA.
OTHER BILLS BACK ON CONCURRENT
SO WILL ENSURE THAT ALL
COMMUNITIES DURING THEIR FAIR
SHARE IN TERMS OF MEETING ARE
HUGE HOUSING NEEDS --
THE BILL --
HAS BEEN AMENDED --
IMPART TO INSURE THAT IT IS
COMPLEMENTARY --
TO ASSEMBLY BILL SEVENTY SEVENTY
ONE WHICH I PRESENTED YESTERDAY
AND SO THE TWO BILLS IN TOWN
THEM I THINK WILL REALLY MOVE
THE DIAL.
IN ENSURING --
THAT WE ARE SETTING --
HOUSING GOALS FOR ALL
COMMUNITIES TO ACTUALLY MEET OUR
HOUSING NEEDS AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WINNER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION SEEING AND HEARING
MEN MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
SHARING [inaudible]
NOTABLY ON I DEL GADO
[inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO DIED [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER.
BUT NO HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
NO LARA [inaudible]
LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING I'M MORE LOCK
[inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
BIDAK [inaudible]
AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WIENER I'D [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD CANNELLA [inaudible]
CANNELLA AYE [inaudible]
LOTTE [inaudible]
MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MORE LOCK [inaudible]
WHEN [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
STONE I PORTANTINO I KNOW
[inaudible]
PORTANTINO.
STERN I DO KNOW.
HOLD ON HOLD ON PORTANTINO I
DON'T KNOW PORTANTINO I DUNNO
[inaudible]
LEARN [inaudible]
STERN I I DON'T KNOW.
OPPOSES PROTEGER TURN I DUNNO
[inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NOTE I ANDERSON NOTE ON I SWING
ONE THOSE THIRTEEN THE
ASSEMBLYMAN RENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM THIRTY
FOUR SENATOR GLAZER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT THIRTY FIVE BY
SENATOR GLAZER INOCULATING THE
PARKS CENTER GLAZER THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS THIS
BILL COMES BACK FOR CONCURRENCE
IN THE ASSEMBLY.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS CLARIFY THE
SMOKING BAN LOCATIONS AND MAKE
TECHNICAL CHANGES.
THESE REASONS ARE RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AND I THINK YOU CENTER
GLAZER MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
WELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHAIRING.
NO DALY ON I DELGADO
[inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ AYE [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA [inaudible]
I LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
HI MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN.
SKINNER AYE STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
I WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
GAINES NO [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
WIECKOWSKI.
AYE AYES TWENTY FIVE KNOWS
ELEVEN THE ASSEMBLYMAN RENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM THIRTY
FIVE SENATOR GLAZER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY THIRTY SIX BY SENATOR
GLAZER AN ACT RELATING TO STATE
EACH.
SENATE GLAZER THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS THIS ONES I'VE
BILL SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSES THE
BEACHES ISSUE.
BACK FROM ASSEMBLY FOR
CONCURRENT SIGNED THE ASSEMBLY
WE MADE SOME TACTICAL AND
CLARIFYING CHANGES.
AND FOR THOSE REASONS I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR HIVE OF THE
U. CENTER GLAZER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I ENTER SINCE.
NO ATKINS.
BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL.
THIS IS A FIVE BERRYHILL
BRADFORD [inaudible]
HI CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO SHARING.
NO DE LEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
I DIED [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER.
BUT I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA [inaudible]
I LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
NO TIDAK.
NO WHY COUNTY.
I WIENER.
AYE WILK.
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ATKINS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
BY TWENTY FIVE KNOWS ELEVEN THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING TO FILE ITEM.
FORTY SEVEN SENATOR WIENER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
FEDERAL NOT A FIVE BY SENATOR
WIENER INOCULATING ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGES SENATOR WIENER AYE
THANK YOU --
MADAM PRESIDENT --
AYE IT A SPEED NINE TO FIVE IS
BACK ON THE CURRENTS OF THIS IS
OUR LOCAL CONTROL BILL --
THAT WILL ALLOW AYE NINE CITIES --
TO DECIDE FOR THEMSELVES WHETHER
TO EXTEND --
THERE NIGHT LIFE --
HOURS.
I'VE THIS IS A AGAIN IS A LOCAL
CONTROL BILL --
THE NINE CITIES THAT ARE
INCLUDED IN THIS FIVE YEAR PILOT
PROGRAM HAVE ALL COME TO US YOU
THE CITY COUNCIL OR THE MAYOR.
I SAID THAT THEY WANT TO HAVE
THIS LOCAL FLEXIBILITY --
THIS BILL HAS BROAD SUPPORT IN
THE ASSEMBLY YESTERDAY IT
RECEIVED BROAD SUPPORT AMONG
LIBERAL DEMOCRATS AND HALF OF
THE REPUBLICANS VOTED FOR IT.
HAS SUPPORT FROM UNITED HERE AND
THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE --
THIS IS A BROADLY SUPPORTED BILL
I WE DID WORK HARD IN THE
ASSEMBLY TO CONTINUE TO REFINE
IT INCLUDING ABA A REQUIREMENT
FOR YEARLY LAW ENFORCEMENT
REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE --
ADDING -- TO
CITY -- AND
THIS AND OTHER CLARIFICATIONS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AIBO.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG.
NO DALY ON I DELGADO
[inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
NADA [inaudible]
I LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
HIGH MORALE [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I'VE ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
STONE. FIVE I'D ACT.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
SENATOR BATES FOR A PURPOSE TO
RISE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS IN THE
* LOUNGE PLEASE THANK YOU
SENATOR MINING FOR A PURPOSE YOU
RISE YES.
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS IF I
COULD HAVE YOUR ATTENTION BEFORE
THE REPUBLICANS GO TO THEIR
CAUCUS -- WE
WILL.
BE IN RECESS DURING THEIR CAUCUS --
THERE WILL NOT BE A DEMOCRATIC
CAUCUS BUT LUNCH IS AVAILABLE IN
THE HALLWAY.
AND PLEASE STAY CLOSE TO THE
FLOOR BECAUSE WE ANTICIPATE
ABOUT A HALF HOUR.
CAUCUS SPACE DONE --
THE REPRESENTATION FOR MINORITY
LEADER AND I WANT TO STEAL TO
GET GOING SO CALIBRATE ABOUT --
TWELVE FORTY FIVE AND WE'VE DONE.
FOURTEEN BILLS PLUS ONE ON CALL
WE HAVE MORE IN CONCURRENCE TO
GO AND AB IS READY TO GO SO.
BACK HERE IN ONE HALF HOUR THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONEY MEMBERS
TO YOU IN THIRTY MINUTES
THE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS HAS
ENDED AND WE ARE READY TO GET
BACK TO WORK PLEASE MAKE YOUR
WAY TO THE SENATE FLOOR
SENATORS
WE ARE READY TO RECONVENE PLEASE
MAKE YOUR WAY TO THE SENATE
FLOOR
[inaudible]
MEMBER [inaudible]
START FILE ITEM FORTY EIGHT
SENATOR LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE FIFTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR LOTT A AND ACTUALLY
VEHICLES THINNER LARA.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS S. B. NINE FIFTY SEVEN
PROVIDES A PATHWAY FOR LOW
INCOME AND MODERATE INCOME
CALIFORNIANS TO ACCESS OUR CLEAN
STICKER INCENTIVES.
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS MAKE THE
LANGUAGE CONSISTENT WITH THE
RECENT BUDGET TRAILER BILL AND
DELAY IMPLEMENTATION.
OF THE PILOT PROGRAM ONE YEAR TO
FACILITATE THE IMPLEMENTATION
CALIFORNIA'S INCENTIVE PROGRAMS
SHOULD NOT ONLY BENEFIT ARE
WEALTHY CALIFORNIANS.
THIS GIVES OUR LOW MODERATE
MODERATE INCOME.
FAMILIES AN OPPORTUNITY TO ALSO
PARTAKE IN THIS THING A PROGRAM
THAT WE KNOW IS VITAL FOR FOLKS
THAT ARE --
WANTING TO INVEST AND ACTUAL
VEHICLES RESPECT ANSWER AGO.
THINKING SENATOR LARA MISTER
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BELL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI [inaudible]
BY GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
HILL HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
LOTTE.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONEY.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
WHEN I [inaudible]
NIELSEN PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
ROTH.
BY SKINNER.
AYE STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
I'VE IDEC [inaudible]
WHAT COUNTY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
WILK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ALLEN HIGH [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
ATKINS BATES [inaudible]
FELL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
JACKSON [inaudible]
MCGUIRE.
BY MITCHELL AYE BY MORE LUCK
[inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I BY DAK [inaudible]
BY KELSEY [inaudible]
WILK.
HI WILL GUY.
EYES TWENTY THREE KNOWS FOR THE
ASSEMBLYMAN MINTS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM. FIFTY THREE
SENATOR DODD [inaudible]
MEMBERS.
I SHOULD NOT OF CALLED THAT BIT
THAT BUILD WE'RE GONNA GO AHEAD
PUT FILE ITEM FORTY EIGHT ON
CALL.
AND WE ARE STILL GONNA MOVE TO
FILE ITEM FOR AT FIFTY THREE
SENATOR DODD.
NOT AT HIS DESK FILE ITEM FIFTY
FIVE SENATOR LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN THIRTEEN BY
SENATOR LOTT A AN ACCOLADE
GREENHOUSE GASES.
CENTER LARA.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS AS WE TEN THIRTEEN IS
BACK --
CONCURRENCE A BILL PRESERVES THE
RECENTLY VACATED EPA SNAP PHASE
DOWN DEADLINES FOR H. OF SEASON
CALIFORNIA.
AND ESTABLISHES AN INCENTIVE
PROGRAM TO AID THE TRANSITION TO
BETTER ALTERNATIVES ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS CLARIFY AIR BE
AUTHORITY CRITERIA AND
DEFINITIONS AND THAT A SAFETY
PROVISION.
ADDITIONALLY THE AMENDMENTS --
SOME AMENDMENTS FOR A ONE YEAR
EXTENSION FOR HOUSEHOLD
REFRIGERATOR MANUFACTURERS FROM
THE ORIGINAL EPA STAFF PHASE
DOWN DEADLINES.
THIS BILL IS AN IMPORTANT PART
OF OUR EFFORTS TO REDUCE AGENCY
EMISSIONS FROM REFRIGERANT
APPLICATIONS ARE SPEC FREE RISK.
RESPECTFULLY ASK ARRIVAL.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
THUNDERSTONE.
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM PRESIDENT
AND MEMBERS AYE AYES AYE BRICE'S
SUPPORT SP TEN THIRTEEN I'D LIKE
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WERE TAKEN IN
THE ASSEMBLY.
THE MAJOR CONCERNS THAT I
EXPRESS WHEN I SAW THIS BILL ON
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE
HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED SP TEN
THIRTEEN HAS FOUND A WAY TO
CREATE A BALANCE.
AND ADDRESS A MUCH NEEDED
SOLUTION FOR CREATING CERTAINTY
IN THE MARKETPLACE.
THE FAX THE HYDROCARBONS HAVE ON
OUR CLIMATE FOR THESE REASONS I
WOULD URGE HERE YES VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE THIRD OR
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
I JUST WANT TO NOTE BY SENATOR
STONE SUPPORT TO DAVE THURSDAY
AT TWELVE FIFTY NINE FROM LARA
BELL.
HIGH PRESELI BY I RESPECT LESSER
AYE VOTE.
AND THE DESK WILL NOTE MR
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO SHARING [inaudible]
DALY OWN [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD.
I FULLER.
KNOW GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ
[inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HILL.
I HUESO.
I JACKSON [inaudible]
ISLA.
BY LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL BY MONEY.
I MORE LUCK [inaudible]
THE RAIL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NELSON [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE STERN.
AYE STONE.
AYE BIDAK.
NO I CAN'T SEE [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILL.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY SIX SENATOR ALLEN
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN SEVENTEEN BY
SENATOR ALAN AND ACTUALLY
FISHERIES IN MAKING A
PREPARATION THERE [inaudible]
FOR SENATOR ALLEN.
MEMBERS AYE YOU'LL RECALL LAST
YEAR I WAS INVOLVED WITH THE OF
A WHILE BILL INVOLVING OFF
HIGHWAY VEHICLES THAT STARTED
OUT FROM THE PLACE WHERE WE
THOUGHT THAT WE COULD NEVER GET
IT GOING TO COME TOGETHER.
AND THAT WE FINALLY DID AND I IT
WAS A MOMENT OF REAL PRIDE --
IT'S WITH A SIMILAR DEGREE OF
PRIDE THAT I PRESENT --
SP TEN SEVENTY BACK ON
CONCURRENCE WITH A A A SEVENTY
EIGHT ZERO VOTE ON THE ASSEMBLY
FLOOR YESTERDAY THIS IS THE BILL.
THE YOU MAY RECALL HAD TO DO
WITH.
SORT FISH INDUSTRY INTO
TRANSITIONING AWAY FROM HARMFUL
DRIFT ON THAT TO MORE
SUSTAINABLE AND MORE PROFITABLE
HERE TYPES THAT IS DEEP SAID BOO
YEAR.
THE BILL ESTABLISHES A PROGRAM
TO BUYBACK STATE DRIFT ON THAT
PERMITS WITH PUBLIC AND PRIVATE
FUNDS AND IMMENSELY SUNSETS THE
FISHERY.
NO WE PASSED THE BILL.
I COMMITTED VERY FIRMLY TO
WORKING WITH ALL STAKEHOLDERS TO
TRY TO FIND A COMPROMISE THAT
WORKS FOR THE FLEET.
AND MADE SENSE FOR A NATURAL
RESOURCES I PERSONALLY CALLED
MOUNT MANY FISHERMEN HAD MANY
CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM OF
LEARNED A LOT MORE ABOUT --
DE THE SWORDFISH FISHERY HAD
EVER THOUGHT I WOULD.
AND WE CONVENE SEVERAL
STAKEHOLDER MEETINGS AND CALLS.
WE WERE ABLE TO ADDRESS SOME OF
THE CAN --
OF THE KEY CONCERNS RAISED I
THINK THE THE KEY CONCERNS WERE
ADDRESSED ULTIMATELY THE THE
ISSUE HERE WAS MAKING SURE.
THAT THE FOLKS FELT AS THOUGH
THEY HAD THE COMPETITION THEY
NEEDED TO FEEL COMFORTABLE.
ARE HAVING THEIR PERMITS BY OUT
SO THEY COULD TRANSITION TO
DIFFERENT YEAR OR MAKE THEIR OWN
PERSONAL DECISIONS BY THE END OF
THE DAY WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO OFFER --
AND AMOUNT WE BEEN ABLE TO
INCREASE THE THE OUT THE THE
AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT WILL BE
OFFERED FOR THE FISHING TO
HUNDRED TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS.
WELL I TO HAVE THEIR PERMITS BY
SO AS TO ALLOW FOR A TRANSITION
MISS WILL BE FUNDED THROUGH A
COMBINATION OF PUBLIC AND
PHILANTHROPIC FUNDS SOME
FOUNDATION FINDS.
ARE WE ALSO ADDRESS THAT WE WERE
ABLE TO ADDRESS THE FOR THE THE
FEAR THE MONEY FOR THE PROGRAM
NEVER MATERIALIZED.
NOW THE BILL --
DOES NOT SUNSET THE FISHERY
UNTIL FOUR YEARS AFTER
PHILANTHROPIC SOURCES ARE ABLE
TO RAISE AT LEAST ONE MILLION
DOLLARS.
AND ADDITIONALLY DIRECTS THE
OCEAN PROTECTION COUNCIL TO USE
ONE MILLION DOLLARS FOR THE
FUNDING WE APPROPRIATE THIS YEAR
FOR WHALEN SEA TURTLE MENTAT ON
ITS FOR THIS EFFORTS OF THE
MONEY HAS ALREADY BEEN
APPROPRIATED.
IN THE BUDGET.
ARE WE WILL ONLY SUNSET THE
PROGRAM THE PERMITS UNTIL FOUR
YEARS AFTER THE PRIVATE SIDE THE
PHILANTHROPIC MONEY MATERIALIZES
OF THE PRINT BONTA THAT MONEY
DOESN MATERIALIZE.
THE PERMITS ARE ALLOWED.
IN IT YOU KNOW OUT INTO THE
FUTURE.
SO AT THIS MEASURE HAS RECEIVED
BROAD BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AS HE
SAID YESTERDAY ON THE ASSEMBLY
FLOOR. SEVENTY EIGHT ZERO VOTE
IT'S SUPPORTED BY TWO HUNDRED
FIFTY ORGANIZATIONS AND
BUSINESSES INCLUDING THE
CALIFORNIA FISH AND GAME
COMMISSION THE AMERICAN
SPORTFISHING ASSOCIATION.
APPEAR CHARITABLE TRUST SIERRA
CLUB OCEANIC CONGRESS
CONGRESSIONAL SPORTSMAN'S
FOUNDATIONS IN THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF ZOOS AND AQUARIA.
AYE I'D I'M PROUD OF THIS EFFORT
AND YOU KNOW YOU FOR INCREDIBLE
WORK ON BRINGING THE STAKE
HOLDERS TOGETHER AND I ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE. TO CONCUR WITH
SOMETHING AMISS.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
JACKSON'S [inaudible]
LADIES.
FOR ACTUALLY I YEAH.
WELL THAT'S A GOOD --
ONE I ONE IS THE STANDIN AND
APPLAUD MY COLLEAGUE FROM LOS
ANGELES IS HAS BEEN A VERY TOUGH
ISSUE FOR THE FISHERMEN IN MY
DISTRICT.
WHO HAVE BEEN AMONG THE MOST
SUSTAINABLE THE MOST PROGRESSIVE
THE MOST ENVIRONMENTALLY SOUND
IN THE STATE PERHAPS EVEN IN THE
COUNTRY AND THIS HAS BEEN A VERY
VERY DIFFICULT --
EFFORT WHICH I KNOW SOME OF THEM
ARE STILL NOT IN SUPPORT BUT I
KNOW THAT THE CLUB.
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM LOS
ANGELES HAS REALLY MOVED THAT
NEEDLE A TO DO EVERYTHING
POSSIBLE TO ACCOMMODATE OTHER
CONCERNS WHAT THE SAME TIME
RECOGNIZING THE IMPORTANCE.
OF DOING THIS LEGISLATION I JUST
WANTED TO GIVE HIM MY THANKS AND
APPRECIATION IN ORIGIN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU CENTER JACKSON CENTER
LARA.
BUT A PRESIDENT I JUST WANNA
THANK --
SENATOR ALLEN SPECIALLY FOR HIM
COORDINATING SEVERAL SHAFTS
INTERRUPT MY DINNER IN MY
DISTRICT.
TOOK MY ME OF THE IMPORTANCE OF
THIS BILL IT'S ALWAYS NICE TO
HAVE --
INTERRUPTED CONVERSATION WE ARE
JOINED DINNER SO APPROACH --
SUPPORT THE SPELL.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR GAINES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS IF I GET --
ASK A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
SENATOR ALLEN WILL YOU TAKE A
QUESTION SALUTE.
PLEASE PROCEED AND REALLY
APPRECIATE ALL THE WORK THAT
YOU'VE BEEN DOING ON THIS OF
LEGISLATION AND MY CONCERN.
SOLICIT DO WITH THE THE
REIMBURSEMENT RESERVE.
USER PEOPLE THAT HAVE BUSINESSES
THAT.
OUR REGION OF FAMILIES ON THE
INCOME RAISED AND MY CONCERN IS --
IF OF THIS LEGISLATION MOVES
FORWARD IS THAT ENOUGH MONEY
BECAUSE IF YOU'VE BEEN A
FISHERMAN ALL YOUR LIFE CAN YOU
TRANSITION INTO.
MAYBE A DIFFERENT FORM OF
FISHING [inaudible]
BUT IS THI THE I DON'T PERSONS
OUT OF THOSE WITH THE VALUE OF
OFFICIAL BUSINESS WOULD BE.
I DON'T KNOW IT'S WEIRD INCOME
THEY'RE MAKING.
ARE CAN YOU SHED SOME LIGHT ON
THAT PLEASE.
SENATOR ALLEN SO ARE THIS IS THE
PRODUCT OF INTENSE NEGOTIATIONS
WITH SOME OF THE FOLKS OUT WE
WERE ABLE WE ORIGINALLY IT'S
THAT.
AND THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND NOW
MOVED A HUNDRED TEN THOUSAND YOU
THIS IS IT WE WE LOOK AT THE
COSTS ASSOCIATED.
WITH BUYING THE DEEP SAID BUOYED
YEAR --
WHICH IS SIGNIFICANTLY LOWER THE
UNDER TEN THOUSAND I MEAN I KNOW
I KNOW THERE ARE SOME MEMBERS OF
THE FLEET YOU STILL WANT TO GET
MORE.
ARE BUT THERE ARE A YOU AFTER
HAVING TALKED TO MEN A NUMBER OF
THEM -- THEY
DO SEEM LIKE A REALLY FAIR
AMOUNT IT'S PRETTY GENEROUS
GIVEN OUR UNDERSTANDING OF THE
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH.
TRANSITIONING TO THE DEEP
SEPARATE DEAR I WAS YOU'RE READY
TO TO ACCEPT THIS OFFER RIGHT
NOW -- THERE
WILL BE A FEW OTHERS TOO MAY
HOLD OUT FOR A LITTLE LONGER AND
AND THAT NEGOTIATION WILL
CONTINUE WITH THEM --
BUT ILL AFTER SPENDING TIME
REALLY LOOKING AT THE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THE TRANSITION
TO DEEP SIBUK HERE.
WE FOLLOWS THAT WE CAME TO A
FAIR PLACE --
AND YOU DID THE APPROPRIATIONS
CHAIR GOT VERY INVOLVED WITH
THIS ON THE ON THE ASSEMBLY SIDE
SHE'S GOT A NUMBER OF THESE
FISHERMEN IN HER DISTRICT BECAME
AND MET WITH THEIR AND THAT'S
PART OF HOW WE GOT TO THE PLACE
WHERE WE INCREASE THE AMOUNT
PRETTY SIGNIFICANTLY.
SO.
ARE YOU KNOW IT'S IT'S ONE OF
THE THINGS I MEAN THERE ARE
CERTAINLY SOME WHO ONE HOLD OUT
FOR MORE MONEY --
BUT BUT IT THIS IS THIS IS NOW
QUITE A BIT THIS IS THIS IS
QUITE A BIT MORE THAN WHERE WE
BEEN LOOKING EARLIER AND AND AND
YOU FOLKS FROM PEW FEELS WHAT'S
REALLY FAIR THEY'VE BEEN SETTING
US FOR A LONG TIME DIDN'T EVEN.
SUPPORT MY BILL LAST TIME
BECAUSE THEY WERE TRYING TO WORK
CLOSELY WITH THE FISHERMEN THEY
FEEL REAL COMFORTABLE THIS
AMOUNT NOW.
NOT SO I CAN NEVER SAY COULD
AFFIRMATIVELY THAT THIS IS GOING
TO SOLVE FOR EVERY EVERY
FISHERMAN'S ECONOMIC CHALLENGES.
BUT WE REALLY DO YOU FEEL AS
THOUGH THIS IS THIS IS A A FAIR.
GENEROUS AMOUNT OF MONEY TO HELP
FOLKS TRANSIT GET BACK ON THEIR
FEET.
AYE IF THEY DO DECIDE TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THIS GREAT THANK
YOU IF THEY USE THAT THE NEW
DEBT SYSTEM BACON.
CAN I MAKE A SIMILAR INCOME TO
WHAT THEY WERE MAKING SUPERIOR
STUDY DAYS AND THEY THEY'VE
ACTUALLY FOUND THAT --
THAT THAT.
ACCORDING TO THEIR STUDIES AND I
THINK SAY THEY THEY DID NOT TAKE
A STAND ON LAST.
SESSIONS BILL SO BIG THEY WERE
REALLY TRYING TO WORK HARD.
WITH THE FISHERMEN ACCORDING
THEIR STUDIES THEY FOUND THIS
OTHER DEEP SAID FOOD HERE IS
ACTUALLY MORE PROFITABLE NOT
BECAUSE IT CATCHES MORE FISH.
BECAUSE THE FISH THAT IT DOES
CATCH -- AND
THAT BEING LESS DAMAGE OKAY SO
ARE YOU KNOW ONCE AGAIN WE HEAR
WE HEAR DIFFERENT CLAIMS MADE ON
BOTH SIDES --
WE'RE GONNA CONTINUE TO MONITOR
THIS I I WILL SAY I I I I I AM
CERTAINLY COMMITTEE SEEMED TO
WORKING WITH.
ARE MEMBERS WHO'VE WAITED ON
THIS ISSUE TO TO ENSURE THAT
WE'VE DONE RIGHT BY THESE
FISHERMEN IN THAT WE DON'T LEAVE
THEM IN THE LURCH AND IF THERE'S
ANY KIND OF FIX THE NEED TO BE
MADE OR TWEAK TO THE AMOUNT.
OFFERED OR OR OR SOME SORT OF NO
HOLD SOME SORT OF OF OF OF THREE
TO THE ISSUES RELATED TO THE TO
THE TO THE TO THE GEAR I'M I'M
SO HOW OPEN TO HAVING A
CONVERSATION I CERTAINLY WELCOME
YOU BEFORE THE COMPETITION.
TO BRING ABA FROM OUR
PERSPECTIVE.
IT'S A IT'S A GOOD YEAR AND AND
THAT'S BEEN DOCKED UP BY A
NUMBER OF SCIENTIFIC STUDIES IN
Q. STUDIES.
GREAT THANK YOU FOR THE
CLARIFICATION PROCEEDED.
THANK YOU CENTER GAINES CENTER
CHIANG.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF OF THIS
GREAT BILL --
IT'S JUST UNFORTUNATE I WOULD
HAVE LOVED TO HAVE BEEN A CO
AUTHOR WANNA DO THINK OF THE
GOOD SENATOR FROM SANTA MONICA.
FOR FOR OF BRINGING THIS BILL
FORWARD AND I URGE AND I VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER THE CENTER
CHIANG MEMBERS FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE SENATOR AL WHICH I
TO CLOSE REALLY APPRECIATE THE
COMMENTS FROM MY COLLEAGUES AND
I AND I DO REITERATE TO YOU
COLLEAGUES. TO THAT I THAT I'M
COMMITTED TO MAKING SURE THAT
THIS IS IMPLEMENTED EFFECTIVELY
AND FAIRLY.
I EFFORT FOR THE FLEET AND ALSO
FOR OUR ENVIRONMENTAL PARTNERS
AND SO --
PLEASE WORK WITH ME IF THIS BILL
PASSES AND SIGNED INTO LAW --
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE HAVE A FAIR
AND JUST AND SUSTAINABLE
IMPLEMENTATION.
AYE WITHOUT OUR STEADFAST NEVER.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
AYE ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BELL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
BY CHIANG.
AYE DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
BYE DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES.
I GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
BY HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
PILOTA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
BY MONEY [inaudible]
MORE LOCKED [inaudible]
PRIME REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
BY SKINNER.
I STERN.
BY STONE [inaudible]
I BIDAK [inaudible]
NO WIECKOWSKI.
AYE WIENER AYE WILK.
AYE.
SENATOR MUSICAL MEMBERS WE ARE
GOING TO MOVE BACK TO FILE ITEM
FIFTY THREE SENATOR DODD.
YOU READY.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL NINE SEVENTY THREE
BY SENATOR DODD AND ACT REALLY
INTO ALCOHOL CHO ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGES SENATOR DODD BETTER
PRESIDENT MEMBERS --
SP NIGHT SEVENTY THREE IS
DESIGNED TO REDUCE.
THE NUMBER OF DRUG DRIVERS ON
CALIFORNIA'S ROADS.
AMENDMENTS TAKING IN THE
ASSEMBLY AUTHORIZED DISTILLED
SPIRITS MANUFACTURERS TO PROVIDE
CONSUMERS FREE OR DISCOUNTED
RIDES.
THE FURTHER PUBLIC SAFETY AND
ADDRESSCHATTERING OUT ISSUES
WITH A. B. THIRTY TO SIXTY FOUR
I ASKED DR OF THE CENTER DODD
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
THING IN HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
PI ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
WELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
BYE DOT.
AYE FULLER.
AYE GAINES.
I GOT JERRY [inaudible]
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
[inaudible]
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL.
I MONNING BY MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN.
I PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER.
AYE STERN AYE STONE.
AYE BIDAK.
MY OUR COUNTY AYE WIENER AYE
WILK AYE.
CYNDER MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
REMOVING THE FILE ITEM FIFTY
EIGHT SENATOR WIENER.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TEN FORTY FIVE A
SENATOR WIENER AND ACT RELATED
TO CONSERVATORSHIP.
I THINK NOTHING CENTER WIENER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR UNDER
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I SP TEN
FORTY FIVE IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE --
THIS BILL YOU WILL RECALL I
CREATES A NEW.
NARROW CONSERVATORSHIP --
FOR SOME OF OUR RESIDENTS ON
MANY OF WHOM ARE CHRONICALLY
HOMELESS --
WHO ARE AYE DETERIORATING AND --
TRAGICALLY DYING PEOPLE LIVING
WITH SEVERE ON MENTAL HEALTH
ISSUES SEVERE DRUG ADDICTION.
PEOPLE INCAPABLE OF MAKING
DECISIONS FOR THEMSELVES TERMS
OF WHETHER TO ACCEPT SERVICES IN
TERMS OF GETTING THEM.
IN THE HOUSING HOW WE SEE THESE
PEOPLE ON OUR STREETS
PARTICULARLY IN OUR CITIES BUT
ELSEWHERE AS WELL --
AND IT IS A DAILY TRAGEDY IN
PEOPLE WALK BY AND WONDER WHY IS
NO ONE DOING ANYTHING.
ABOUT THIS PERSON WHO IS
SLEEPING IN HER FECES IN MY
NEIGHBORHOOD.
WHY IS NO ONE DOING ABOUT
ANYTHING ABOUT AND THE REASON?
IS THAT THE LAW HAS NOT KEPT UP.
WITH THE REALITY --
IN MANY COMMUNITIES IN
CALIFORNIA.
AND SO I THREE TEN FORTY FIVE
CREATES IN A NARROW NEW
CONSERVATORSHIP.
AYE TO ALLOW FOR THREE PILOT
COUNTIES LOS ANGELES COUNTY SAN
FRANCISCO COUNTY AND SAN DIEGO
COUNTY -- TO
HELP GET THESE FOLKS IN THE
HOUSING AND THE CARE --
SAVE THEIR LIVES GET THEM BACK
ON TRACK THE BILL CONTAINS FULL
DUE PROCESS A JUDICIAL OVERSIGHT.
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
IF SEEING AND HEARING A MAN YEP.
ó I'M SORRY COULDN'T SEE YOU
SENATOR STERN PLEASE PROCEED.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT --
AYE RIGHT IN SUPPORT IS A JOINT
AUTHORED THIS MEASURE AND I WANT
TO THANK THE GOOD MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE FROM.
SAN FRANCISCO FOR HIS LEADERSHIP
ON THIS --
I'M DELIGHTED IT'S GONNA BE A
PART OF THIS PILOT PROGRAM --
WE CANNOT KEEP USING LAW
ENFORCEMENT AS OUR AUXILIARY
SOCIAL SERVICES ARM IN THIS
STATE.
WE CANNOT BE USING OUR COPS AND
SHERIFFS TO GO OUT AND DEAL WITH
THE HOMELESSNESS PROBLEM THAT IS.
AN EPIDEMIC IN OUR CITIES THIS
BILL STARTS TO SHIFT IS FROM A
LAW ENFORCEMENT APPROACH TO
DEALING WITH THOSE WHO ARE
CHRONICALLY --
HOMELESS --
MENTALLY --
UNFIT TO MAKE THEIR OWN
DECISIONS SEVERELY DRUG ADDICTED
AND SHIFTED TO WHERE IT RIGHTLY
BELONGS IN A CONSERVATORSHIP
PROGRAM WHERE COUNTIES CAN
EMPLOY SERVICES --
AND AND START TO ACTUALLY TACKLE
THESE PROBLEMS AT THE ROOT WHEN
YOU WALK BY PEOPLE IN FROM YOUR
HOUSE -- AND
YOU SEE THEM ARE COMPLETELY
INCAPABLE HELPING THEMSELVES YOU
CAN EITHER WALK PAST THEM AND
WATCH THEM DIE ON OUR DOORSTEPS.
WHAT WE CAN DO SOMETHING ABOUT
IT?
WE'RE DOING SOMETHING ABOUT IT
HERE TODAY AND THAT'S WHY I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER STERN
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE SENATOR
WINNER WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU CENTER WINNER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
FOUND.
I ANDERSON AYE ATKINS
[inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA.
I CHANGE.
BY DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
I HUESO AYE JACKSON.
BY LOTTE AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCK I'M REAL
[inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
BY SKINNER.
I AYE STERN AYE STONE.
AYE BIDAK AYE WHAT COUNTY
[inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
BY.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS ARE
MOVING TO FILE ITEM SEVENTIES
SENATOR HERTZBERG.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FORTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR HERTZBERG AN ACT
RELATING TO OIL AND GAS
[inaudible]
SENATOR HERTZBERG.
I HAVE.
SIX OKAY SO I APOLOGIZE I GOT IT
[inaudible]
DATE PALM [inaudible]
BUT THIS.
THANK YOU AND PRESIDENT'S IS
BACK ON CONCURRENCE BASICALLY
WHAT HAPPENED A AND THE REASON
FOR THIS BILL IS PLATFORM HOLLY --
WAS SOLD TO AN OIL COMPANY
DIDN'T HAVE A LOT OF MONEY AND
WENT BANKRUPT.
AND WHEN IT WENT BANKRUPT.
THE WOULD WE DO IT AND TOOK A
LOOK AND THE UNDERLYING BOND
WASN'T ENOUGH TO PAY FOR THE
LIABILITY WE JUST APPROPRIATED I
THINK A HUNDRED AND SOME MILLION
DOLLARS JUST TO DO PARTIAL CLEAN
UP.
BECAUSE THE RESPONSIBILITY CAME
BACK TO THE STATE.
RESULT OF THAT THAT INCIDENT IN
ANOTHER PLATFORM WHICH I DON'T
REMEMBER AS I'M SITTING HERE NOW.
POT WHERE WE'RE LOOKING AT
RAISING THE AMOUNT ARE OF THE
BONDS THAT ARE REQUIRED FOR
THESE PLATFORM SO IF THEY JUST
IF THEY DO GO BANKRUPT.
THERE'S ENOUGH MONEY TO PROTECT
THE TAXPAYERS ASK YOU SUPPORTERS
MEASURE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG'S
BERG O. DISCLOSURE DEBATES UNDER
JACKSON.
THIS IS ABOUT THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I WANT TO THANK MY
GOOD COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL PLATFORM
HOLLY IS ONE OF A OF A NUMBER
ACTUALLY I THINK THERE ARE STILL.
ELEVEN OF THESE PLATFORMS LEFT
ON THE OF SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL --
THESE ARE THE ALL OF A YEARS OF
OIL DRILLING BY PRIVATE
COMPANIES WHICH TAKEN.
A OF REMOVE OF MILLIONS AND
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF THE
PEOPLE'S ASSETS IN THE FORM OF
OIL.
SELL IT AND MAKE ENORMOUS
PROFITS FROM WHAT HAS HAPPENED
HERE.
IS THAT WHEN THESE COMPANIES --
THOSE SHELL TO LESSER COMPANIES
IN THOSE COMPANIES GO OUT OF
BUSINESS.
WE THE TAXPAYER.
ARE LEFT WITH HOLDING THE BAG.
OF BECAUSE OF A THEIR LACK OF
RESPONSIBILITY.
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF OTHER.
A OF THESE PLATFORMS THAT ARE
STILL LEFT IN OUR OCEAN WATERS
AND AS THESE COMPANIES A SQUEEZE
OUT THE LAST PENNY FROM THE
PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA.
A WE ARE GOING TO FIND OURSELVES
HAVING TO CONTINUE.
OUGHT TO CHARGE THE TAXPAYER TO
CLEAN UP THE MESS THEY MADE AND
TO RESTORE OUR OCEAN WATERS.
IT'S TIME THAT THESE COMPANIES
WHICH HAVE BENEFITTED TO THE
EXTENT OF BILLIONS AND BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS TAKE SOME
RESPONSIBILITY TAKEN OFF THE
TAXPAYER WHO ALREADY PAYS
ENORMOUSLY.
OF A FOR THE BENEFIT OF THESE
PRIVATE COMPANIES WITH THAT I
WOULD URGE AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR JACKSON CENTER
HERTZBERG WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
WHICH SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN.
AYE ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES.
HI BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO.
DE LEON I DELGADO I DODD
[inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
BY LOTTE.
AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK AYE MORRELL.
AYE NGUYEN.
AYE NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN.
AYE STONE.
I'VE TACK.
BY WHAT COUNTY.
AYE WIENER.
AYE WILK.
I AYE SENATOR MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WERE GONNA MOVE BACK ONE
FILE ITEM TO FILE ITEM SIXTY
NINE SENATOR SKINNER MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL ELEVEN THIRTY EIGHT
BY SENATOR SKINNER AND ACT
RELATED TO NUTRITION CENTER
SKINNER.
THANKS SO MUCH MEMBERS MY BILL
S. B. ELEVEN THIRTY EIGHT IS
BACK FOR CONCURRENCE --
IT'S THE BILL THAT HELPS INSURE
THEIR SUPPLANT BASED OPTION FOR
THOSE WHO ARE IN HOSPITALS OR
STATE FACILITIES.
I'M IT'S NOT BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR SKINNER
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA AYE CHAIN AYE DELEON
[inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT.
DODD AYE FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES.
AYE GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
I LOTTA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL.
AYE MONNING.
I'M.
AYE MORRELL [inaudible]
BY NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER.
I STERN.
AYE STONE.
MR BY BIDAK.
IOWA COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
WILK [inaudible]
BY.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
SEVENTY FIVE SENATOR STERN
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN SEVENTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR STERN AND ACT
BERLIN ENERGY.
THUNDERSTORM.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS.
SB FOURTEEN SEVENTY SEVENS BACK
ON CONCURRENCE WOULD TRY TO
TACKLE TO THE MOST IMPORTANT
PROBLEMS FACING CALIFORNIA RIGHT
NOW.
CLIMATE CHANGE --
AND ENERGY POVERTY ALONG WITH
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THIS BILL
INTENDS TO SOLVE BOTH BY MAKING
IT MORE AFFORDABLE TO LIVE IN
YOUR HOME AND OPERATE YOUR HOME
WITH MORE EFFICIENT APPLIANCES.
AND AT THE SAME TIME REDUCE
POLLUTION IN OUR COMMUNITIES
THIS BILL IS A VERY UNLIKELY
COALITION BEHIND IT WHERE YOU
HAVE.
DEVELOPERS AND ENVIRONMENTALISTS
ARE ON THE SAME PAGE ALL SAYING
THAT WE NEED MORE EFFICIENT MORE
MODERN HOMES OF FOR ACTUALLY
GONNA TACKLE THIS HOUSING CRISIS
AND NOT EXACERBATES ARE OUR
POLLUTION PROBLEM AT THE SAME
TIME.
AND WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
DR VOTE THANK YOU CENTER STERN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE WHICH
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
HI ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG.
NO DALY ON DELGADO [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK NO MORALE.
NO WIN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
NO BY THAT.
NO I COUNTY.
AYE WIENER AYE WILK.
NO SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM SEVENTY
SIX SENATOR LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN NINETY ONE
BY SENATOR LOTT A AN ACT
RELATING TO JUVENILES CENTER
LARA THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
AND MEMBERS --
S. P. THIRTEEN ANYONE IS BACK
FROM CONCURRENCE IT'S A REALLY
IMPORTANT BILL MEMBERS THAT.
WILL PROHIBIT FOURTEEN AND
FIFTEEN YEAR OLD CHILDREN FROM
BEING SENT TO THE ADULT PRISON
SYSTEM.
AND I'M PROUD THAT MY GODSON
TODAY'S HERE WHOSE TO OUR
CLIENTS AND SEVENTH GRADE I
REALLY PUT A FACE TO SO MANY.
CHILDREN AND BY THE WAY HE HE
WAS THE ONE WHO BROUGHT THOSE
GREAT CHOCOLATES FROM LONG BEACH
FOR EACH AND EVERYONE OF YOU --
SO MEMBERS THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS THAT A PROVISION
ALLOWING FOR ADULT SENTENCING OF
INDIVIDUALS WHO EVADE CAPTURE IN
THEIR YOUTH.
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT IN MAKING
SURE A PERPETRATOR IS HELD
ACCOUNTABLE EVEN IF THE VICTIM
DOES NOT COME FORWARD UNTIL THAT
LATER IN THE YEARS.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE
ON THIS IMPORTANT BILL THANK YOU
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
MITCHELL.
MADAM PRESIDENT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH I JUST WANNA STAND AND SAY
HOW PROUD I WAS --
TO COAL OFFERED THIS BILL WITH
MY COLLEAGUE ON FROM LONG BEACH --
TO ONCE AGAIN AT EQUITY AND
JUSTICE PACKETS OF BILLS BRING A
FACE TO THE REALITY OF WHAT
YOUNG LARGELY BLACK AND BROWN.
AND POOR CHILDREN ARE FACING IN
OUR VERY OWN STATE SO I PROUD TO
STAND WITH HIM AND WILL BE
CASTING MY VOTE FOR CONCURRENCE
TODAY FOR S. B..
THIRTEEN NINETY ONE I THINK YOU
SENATOR MITCHELL CENTER NIELSEN.
BUT A PRESIDENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THE SENATE.
THESE ARE YOUNG PEOPLE.
BUT THE THINGS THEY DO.
A VERY BAD [inaudible]
SOCIETY [inaudible] FOR HUMANS.
AND FOR THEIR OWN CHARACTER.
THE CHARACTER FLAWS [inaudible]
EXTANT.
CAUSE HIM TO DO THESE THINGS.
AND THAT IS SOMEWHAT PREDICTIVE
OF FUTURE BEHAVIOR.
AND THAT'S SHED.
AT THE LEAST THERE MUST BE SOME
ACCOUNTABILITY. TO ENSURE
JUSTICE. FOR VICTIMS OF THE
CRIMES THAT THEY'VE COMMITTED.
WE MUST NOT.
TURN OUR BACKS ON THAT.
AND SAY IT DIDN'T HAPPEN BUYER
GENOVA.
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN SARAH
ARE WHICH LIKE TO CLOSE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I'M SORRY.
SENATOR DODD.
YEAH I WAS NOT GOING TO SPEAK ON
THAT THAT ISSUE AND THAT THE
GOOD SENATOR FROM TO HIM I JUST.
MAYBE THINK ABOUT AYE TH YOU
KNOW PARTICULARLY.
LOCKING UP AT YOUNG PEOPLE LIKE
THAT THAT HAVE --
I I THINK GIVING THEM A BREAK
ACTUALLY GIVES THEM AN
OPPORTUNITY TO GET OUT OF JAIL
AND TO STAY OUT OF THE SYSTEM.
IN INCENTIVIZE IS THEM COULD BE
BETTER AND THAT'S THE REASON MET
MUCH OF THE REASON WHY OUR JAILS
ARE SO FULL TODAY.
IN I THINK THIS IS A GOOD BILL
IT'S SOMETHING THAT --
GIVES PEOPLE OPPORTUNITY HOLD
THEM ACCOUNTABLE BUT GIVES THEM
AN OPPORTUNITY SO WE DON'T LOCK
COME UP AND THROW THE KEY AWAY
FOREVER I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT
ON THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD SEVERAL
ARE PLEASE CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS IT IS TIME TO
THANK THEM TAKE A MOMENT. TO
THANK THE SPEAKER AND THE
ASSEMBLY YESTERDAY WHO REALLY
TOOK A BOLD STEP.
AND SPENDING THAT LOUD MESSAGE
THAT EVERY CHILD IS REDEEMABLE.
AND WHAT WE FAIL TO ACKNOWLEDGE
IN A LOT OF THESE CASES IS THAT
THESE CHILDREN ACTUALLY VICTIMS
THEMSELVES.
AND YES SOME OF THEM HAVE CREAM
HAVE CREATED SOME --
HORRIBLE CRIMES BUT GUESS WHAT.
BIGELOW DJJ.
DJJ IS NOT.
SOME SORT OF HOTEL OR VACATION
IT IS PRESENT.
BUT THE ONLY THING THE BIG
DIFFERENCE IS THAT IN DJJ THEY
ACTUALLY HAVE REHABILITATIVE
SERVICES.
WHERE WE CAN LOOK AT THE ENTIRE
CHILD?
AS A WHOLE COMPREHENSIVELY WHAT
IS HAPPENING IN THE HOME WHAT
HAPPENED TO THIS INDIVIDUAL WHO
VICTIMIZE THIS CHILD.
SO THAT THEY'RE GIVEN THE
OPPORTUNITY. TO ENTER INTO
SOCIETY.
AND HOPEFULLY BE ABLE TO
REESTABLISH THEIR LIFE.
IN THE END BY NO MEANS ARE WE
SAYING THEY GET A FREE PASS.
THEY DO THERE TIME THEY'RE ABLE
TO HAVE SOME SERVICES AND AGAIN
THE NUMBERS ARE STAGGERING
MEMBERS.
STAGGERING ON THE FACT THAT
BLACK AND BROWN CHILDREN ARE
MORE LIKELY TO BE SENT.
THE ADULT SYSTEM.
AND AS WE WERE DEBATING THIS
BILL AND TRYING TO COME UP WITH.
A REPEAL TALKING TO OUR
COLLEAGUES.
AT THE END OF THE DAY WE WERE
SAYING OKAY YOU DON'T WANT TO
SUPPORT THIS BILL.
BEEN LET'S TREAT BLACK AND BROWN
KIDS LIKE WHITE CHILDREN.
WERE SOMEHOW THEY ARE MORE
REDEEMABLE AND ARE LESS LIKELY
TO BE PUT IN THE ADULT SYSTEM.
AND THAT'S JUST THE REALITY.
THAT'S THE REALITY OF ALL THESE
CONVERSATIONS WERE HAVING AROUND
PUBLIC SAFETY.
IS CHANGING THE DYNAMIC AND
REALLY.
BEING HONEST ABOUT THE INHERENT
BIAS THAT EXIST IN OUR SYSTEM.
AND HOW SOME PEOPLE ARE GONNA
GET.
A BETTER SHOW UP A BACK OF MORE
FAIR SHAKE BECAUSE OF THE COLOR
OF THEIR SKIN.
OR BECAUSE OF WHERE THEY LIVE OR
BECAUSE OF THEIR INCOME STATUS.
AND SO ALL THESE BILLS ARE THESE
BILLS -- ARE
COMING TO YOU BECAUSE FOR US TO
FIVE A SYSTEM THAT HAS BEEN
PROVEN NOT ONLY TO NOT WORK. TEN
NOT REHABILITATE FOLKS IN THE
ADULT SYSTEM AND THAT HAS BEEN --
COMPLETED DISCRIMINATORY TO SO
MANY PEOPLE THAT LOOK LIKE
CENTER HONEY MITCHELL MY AND SO
FOR THOSE REASONS I EXPECT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
AYE ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
NO GLAZER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HILL.
I HUESO AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
BY LOTTE.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
BY MONEY.
I MORE LOCK KNOW MORALE.
NO WIN [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE.
NO BUT ACT.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK.
NO.
PUT CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ATKINS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
DE LEON [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO THE TWO KNOWS FIFTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM SEVENTY SEVEN SENATOR
SKINNER. SEVENTY SEVEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR SKINNER AND ACT
WIENER MURDER [inaudible]
SENATOR SKINNER.
THANK YOU --
MADAM PRESIDENT IN MEMBERS SP
FOURTEEN THIRTY SEVEN IS BACK
FROM CONCURRENCE. FOURTEEN
THIRTY SEVEN NARROWS THE
APPLICATION OF CALIFORNIA'S
FELONY MURDER RULE.
SO THAT ACCOMPLICES IN A FELONY
CAN ONLY BE CHARGED WITH FIRST
DEGREE MURDER.
IF THEY ARE THE ACTUAL KILLER.
IF THEY AIDED ABETTED COMMANDED
INDUCED ASSISTED.
THE MURDER.
WORTH THEY ACTED AS A MAJOR
PARTICIPANT IN THE FELONY.
INDIFFERENCE [inaudible]
HUMAN LIFE.
WHAT THE BILL DOES BY NARROWING
THE STATUTE IS RESERVES ARE
HARSHEST PUNISHMENTS? FOR THOSE
WHO IN HANDED THEIR INVOLVEMENT.
IN A KILLING.
IN THE ASSEMBLY WE TOOK A NUMBER
OF AMENDMENTS THAT NARROW THE
BILL FROM WHEN YOU SAW IT.
AND THIS HOUSE DID SUPPORT THIS
BILL WITH THE TWENTY EIGHT VOTE.
BUT WE NARROWED IT.
AND WE NARROWED IT SO THAT
[inaudible]
APOLOGIES.
SO THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THE
BILL DO NOT APPLY.
EITHER THE RECENT SCENE PORTION
OR GOING FORWARD IF A LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICIAL IS KILLED
IN THE COMMISSION OF THE FELONY.
WE CLARIFIED THAT THE RE
SENTENCING PROVISION.
MAKES IT CLEARER THAT THE
PETITIONER [inaudible]
MUST.
PROOF BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT
IN WITH A CLEAR AND CONVINCING
CASE.
THAT HE OR SHE IS ENTITLED FOR
THE COURT TO CONSIDER RECENT
SING.
THAT IS VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE
IT GREATLY NARROWS.
THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO WOULD
EVEN BE [inaudible]
ABLE.
PETITION THE COURT FOR RE
SENTENCING.
AND BECAUSE OF THE STANDARD THAT
THE COURT MUST REACH IN ORDER TO
CONSIDERED THEM TO EVEN GRANT A
HEARING.
IT AS I INDICATED GREATLY
MINIMIZES THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE
WHO WOULD EVEN BE BEFORE THE
RECENT SING PREVENTION.
IT ALSO SPECIFIES THAT IF THE
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.
ON THE UNDERLYING FELONY HAS RUN.
THAT IF THE PERSON IS CONSIDERED
FOR RECENT SAYING.
THAT THAT STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS
WOULD NOT APPLY TO IN OTHER
WORDS THEY PUT WOULD STILL BE
CONSIDERED. FOR THE UNDERLYING
FELONY.
AND IF PERMITS JUDGES.
IF THE PERSON IS SUCCESSFUL IN
THE RECENT SCENE PROCESS. TO
IMPOSE A TERM OF PAROLE
SUPERVISION --
IT ALSO MAKES IT CLEAR THAT THE
DA IS ALLOWED TO USE.
ANY AND ALL EVIDENCE WHETHER
INTRODUCED IN THE ORIGINAL COURT
HEARING OR NOT.
CHALLENGE THE PETITION.
AND OR IF THREE SENTENCING
PETITION IS GRANTED.
IN THAT RECENT STING HEARING.
I THINK YOU HAVE ALL RECEIVED
SOME MATERIALS THAT INDICATE THE
WIDESPREAD [inaudible]
TOM.
UNDERSTANDING OR RATHER.
MISS UNDERSTANDING THAT MOST
PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA.
IT WOULD NEVER OCCUR TO THEM IT
DOES NOT OCCUR TO THEM IF YOU
WERE TO ASK THEM.
CAN YOU BE.
CHARGED AND CONVICTED OF FIRST
DEGREE MURDER.
IF YOU DID NOT COMMIT THE MURDER
WERE NOT PRESENT AT THE MURDER.
DID NOT DIRECT THE MURDER.
COULD YOU STILL BE CONVICTED AND
CHARGED WITH FIRST DEGREE MURDER
IN CALIFORNIA.
THEY'D LOOK AT YOU.
AND THEY SAY NOT.
AND YET THAT IS SO.
THAT IS WHAT HAPPENS IN
CALIFORNIA.
AND 72% OF THE WOMEN IN
CALIFORNIA THAT ARE SERVING LIFE
SENTENCES.
OUR PEOPLE THAT ARE WOMEN THAT
DID NOT COMMIT A HOMICIDE.
AND WITHOUT I ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
BY CHANGE [inaudible]
NO DELEON.
I'VE PROVIDER GOTTA [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
BY JACKSON [inaudible]
HI NADA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
MITCHELL.
I AYE MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK [inaudible]
BY MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN.
NO NO SON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER.
BY STERN AYE STONE [inaudible]
NOVI DECK.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
WITH NO.
PLEASE CALL ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
ROTH.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS NINE THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS THAT
FINISHES OUR UNFINISHED BUSINESS
WE ARE NOW MOVING TO SENATE
THIRD READING WHERE WE HAVE ONE
ITEM.
FILE ITEM SEVENTY NINE SENATOR
LARA.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE RESOLUTION ONE TWENTY
FIVE BY SENATOR LADA RELATIVE TO
SUPER POLLUTANTS REDUCTION WEEK.
SENATOR LAURA THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS ON A MUCH
LIGHTER NOTE.
CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN A LEADER ON
FIRE FIGHTING CLIMATE CHANGE FOR
A LONG TIME PREVIOUSLY OUR
EFFORTS PRIMARILY IT SENATE ON
CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSION
REDUCTIONS.
NOW WE HAVE PIVOTED TO A FAR
MORE IMPACTFUL CLIMATE FORCING
CHEMICALS SHORT LIVED CLIMATE
POLLUTANTS WHICH ARE.
I PREFER TO CALL SUPER BALLOONS
ARE 1-020-001-0000 TIMES MORE
IMPACTFUL TO THE CLIMATE THAT
ACTUAL CARBON DIOXIDE.
THAT CAR BEN HAS A GLOBAL
WARMING POTENTIAL OF OVER. THREE
THOUSAND TIMES MORE THAN CARBON
DIOXIDE.
OF FLUOROCARBONS HAVE GLOBAL
WARMING POTENTIAL BETWEEN.
FOURTEEN HUNDRED TO FOUR
THOUSAND TIMES HIGHER THAN
CARBON DIOXIDE METHANE HAS A
GLOBAL WARMING POTENTIAL EIGHTY
TIMES HIGHER THAN CARBON DIOXIDE
THE SUPER POLLUTE CONTRIBUTE
ABOUT. 40% TO THE CURRENT ARE
TIED TO GLOBAL ALREADY ACTIVE
FORCING --
EACH YEAR AGENCIES LEAK FROM --
AN AVERAGE SUPERMARKET
REPRESENTING THE EQUIVALENT
EMISSIONS OF THREE HUNDRED CARS
ON THE ROAD.
PHILIP PULLMAN'S HAVE A FAR MORE
IMPACT IN OUR VULNERABLE
COMMUNITIES BLACK CARBON IS NOT
ONLY A POWERFUL GREENHOUSE GAS.
BUT ALSO THE SERIOUS HEALTH
IMPACTS INCLUDING INCREASE OF
ASTHMA ATTACKS CARDIOVASCULAR
AND RESPIRATORY DISEASES AND
SLOW LONG DEVELOPMENT AND OUR
CHILDREN WHICH BY THE WAY IS A
MAJOR EPIDEMIC IN.
AND AROUND THE THIRTY THIRD
SENATE DISTRICT --
BLACK CARBON IS PART OF A ARE
DIESEL EXHAUST.
WITHIN EXHAUSTED EXPOSING PEOPLE
OUGHT TO BLACK CARBON AND NEARLY
FORTY OTHER EPA IDENTIFIED
HAZARDOUS AIR CONTAMINANTS.
MEMBERS OF THE GOVERNOR AND
THERE'D BE A DESERVES CREDIT FOR
TAKING THIS ISSUE SERIOUSLY AND
PROVIDING CALIFORNIA WHAT THE
PATHWAY FORWARD TO EMBRACE NEW
TECHNOLOGIES.
AND REDUCE SUPER POLLUTANT
EMISSIONS CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA
HAS SHOWN LEADERSHIP IN
PARTICULAR WHEN IT COMES TO
ENGAGING WITH OUR DAIRIES TO
REDUCE METHANE EMISSIONS.
ARE MEMBERS THIS --
RESOLUTION SHINES A LIGHT ON THE
EXTREMELY HARMFUL SOBRE
POLLUTANTS ANSWER POLLUTANTS
WEEK WILL BE AN OPPORTUNITY
SOBRE REDUCTION --
SUBURBAN REDUCTION WE WOULD BE
APART --
OPPORTUNITY FOR CALIFORNIA TO
HIGHLIGHT THE SUCCESS AND WORK
WITH OTHERS TO NATIONAL
GOVERNMENTS AS WE CONVENE IN SAN
FRANCISCO.
CLIMATE SUMMIT I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
ANDERSON.
MEMBERS I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THE
RESOLUTION TODAY BUT I WOULD
LIKE TO POINT OUT THAT WE NEED
TO DO A BETTER JOB OF MANAGING
OUR WILD FIRES.
MANAGING OUR FORCE WALL WE'VE
DONE AN INCREDIBLE JOB SAVINGS.
WE FAR EXCEEDED.
THROUGH THE WILDFIRES IN SO
WHATEVER WE CAN DO TO PRUNE
THOSE FORCE WHERE WE CAN DO TO
REDUCE.
THE WILDFIRES THAT WE'VE BEEN
DOING OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS I
THINK IT'S VERY IMPORTANT NOT
JUST FOR OUR SAFETY BUT ALSO.
FOR THOSE SAME CONCERNS.
WOULD YOU CENTER ANDERSON
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE THING THEN.
THIRD ARE REJECT CLOSE THANK YOU
BYE MADAME PRESIDENT ABSOLUTELY
AGREE WITH SENATOR UNDERSTAND.
WE TO DO MORE TO BUY CARE FOR
OUR FORESTS AND MANAGE THEM A
PROPERLY PROPERLY SO THAT WE
MITIGATE THESE AWFUL AND
DEVASTATING FIRES.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE
THANK YOU CENTER LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
I A ANDERSON.
I ATKINS AYE BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
GEN [inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI [inaudible]
BY GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
AYE LARA.
AYE LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
WHEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
WHEN I NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
BUT ACT [inaudible]
BY KATHY.
AYE WIENER.
AYE WILK.
I AYE BYE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL CANNELLA [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
HI I FULLER [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MORLOCK [inaudible]
I MORRELL.
AYE.
NIELSEN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
FIND OUT.
I STERN FOREIGN NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
NOW GOING TO MOVE ON TO ASSEMBLY
THIRD READING WE'RE GOING TO
START WITH FILE ITEM. NINETY TWO
SENATOR MORLOCK.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ FILE
ITEM.
NINETY TWO PICK A TIME NO
PROBLEM.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO FIFTEEN BY SENATOR KILEY
RELATIVE TO THE TWENTY THREE
ASYLUM ARE AYE A AYE PRINCIPLES.
SKINNER MORLOCK THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT TO SURPRISE YOU JUMPED
A FEW NUMBERS THERE.
COLLEAGUES THAT TODAY I PRESENT
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION.
TWO ONE FIVE THROUGH WHICH ARE
LEGISLATURE WILL EXPRESS ITS
SUPPORT. FOR THE ASILOMAR
PRINCIPLES AS GUIDING VALUES.
FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE.
THANK --
IMAGE RECOGNITION OR SPEECH
RECOGNITION AND TRANSLATION OR
AUTOMATED TRAINING.
OR MORE POPULAR NOW AUTONOMOUS
VEHICLES COLLEAGUES THIS IS THE
NEW AND THE NEXT FRONTIER.
THE ASILOMAR PRINCIPLES ALL
TWENTY THREE OF WHICH ARE SET
FORTH IN TODAY'S RESOLUTION.
WERE DEVELOPED HERE IN
CALIFORNIA.
THEY GET THEIR NAME FROM THE
CONVENTION SITE NEAR PACIFIC
GROVE.
IN MONTEREY COUNTY WHERE IN
JANUARY OF TWENTY SEVENTEEN THE
WORLD'S LEADING ARTIFICIAL ARE A
AYE RESEARCHERS ECONOMISTS LEGAL
SCHOLARS AND PHILOSOPHERS MET.
THE DISCUSS HOW BEST TO ENSURE A
AYE IS DEVELOP SAFELY AND
ETHICALLY.
THE PRINCIPAL STRESS THE NEED
FOR SAFETY [inaudible]
TRANSPARENCY PRIVACY AND
ALIGNMENT WITH HUMAN VALUES.
NOTABLY ONE OF THE PRINCIPLES
PROVIDES THAT THERE SHOULD BE
CONSTRUCTIVE AND HELP YOU
EXCHANGE.
BETWEEN A AYE RESEARCHERS AND
POLICY MAKERS.
ANOTHER STATES THAT THE
APPLICATION OF A AYE TO PERSONAL
DATA MUST NOT UNREASONABLY
CURTAIL PEOPLE'S REAL OR
PERCEIVED LIBERTY.
AND ANOTHER SET FORTH.
POWER CONFERRED BY CONTROL OF
HIGHLY ADVANCED A AYE SYSTEMS
SHOULD RESPECT AND IMPROVE
RATHER THAN SOME BURKE.
THE SOCIAL AND CIVIC PROCESSES
ON WHICH THE HEALTH OF SOCIETY
DEPENDS.
THE A CIVIL OUR PRINCIPLES HAVE
BEEN INDEPENDENTLY ENDORSED BY
MORE THAN TWELVE HUNDRED LEADING
EXPERTS IN THE FIELD OF A AYE
INCLUDING THE LATE STEPHEN
HAWKING.
YILAN MUSK AND DHIMMIS.
HER SERVICE FOUNDER OF DEEP MIND.
THEY HAVE RECEIVED UNANIMOUS
SUPPORT ME ASSEMBLY AS WELL AS
THE SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
BY ENDORSING THESE PRINCIPLES
TODAY WE WILL JOIN IN THE
RECOGNITION OF SHARED VALUES
THAT CAN BE APPLIED TO RESEARCH.
DEVELOPMENT AND LONG TERM
PLANNING HELPING TO REINFORCE
CALIFORNIA'S COMPETITIVE EDGE IN
THE FIELD OF ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE.
WHILE ENSURING THAT ITS BENEFITS
ARE MANIFOLD AND WIDESPREAD I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
ON ACR TWO ONE FIVE THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT THE CENTER
MORLOCK MEMBERS FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
MONNING.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
AND BRIEFLY SINCE I REPRESENT --
PACIFIC GROVE IN THE ASILOMAR
CONFERENCE CENTER WHERE THESE
PRINCIPLES WERE DEVELOPED I WANT
TO STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT --
ALSO POINT AT ASILOMAR IS THE
STATE OWNED PROPERTY BY STATE
PARKS BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY.
WHAT'S BROUGHT FORTH HERE BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KILEY.
AND BY -- MY
GOOD FRIEND ORANGE COUNTY --
WHO'S MANAGING HERE ON THE FLOOR
TODAY [inaudible]
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE HAS.
PAST CITY TO MOVE FORWARD MORE
RAPIDLY THAN OUR ABILITY TO
DISCUSS SOCIAL IMPLICATIONS
ETHICAL IMPLICATIONS ETCETERA SO
THIS IS INDEED TIMELY.
YEAH IT'S A RESOLUTION TODAY BUT
I'M HOPING WE CAN CONTINUE TO
WORK ON THIS AND PROVIDE THE
APPROPRIATE LEGISLATIVE
OVERSIGHT.
THE PROTECTS FREE SPEECH AND
FIRST AMENDMENT RIGHTS WHILE
ALSO MAKING SURE WE DON'T HAVE.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE RUNNING
OFF THE RAILS IN A MANNER THAT
DAMAGES A THE HUMAN CONDITION OR
NATURAL RESOURCES I URGE AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONNING SEE NO
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SANDRA BULLOCK WOULD LIKE TO
CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
I WANT TO THANK ASSEMBLY MEMBER
KILEY FOR HIS.
VISION BECAUSE THIS IS CUTTING
EDGE THIS IS THE FUTURE I HAVE A
SENSE THAT WE'LL BE DOING A LOT
OF LEGISLATION ON THIS AREA. TO
MAKE SURE THAT --
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCES KEPT
WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES THAT IT
SHOULD BE AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THAT YOU CENTER MORLOCK MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
HI BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
HIGH CHAIN [inaudible]
I DELEON.
I DON'T I DON'T [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
BY JACKSON.
I LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
BY BIDAK. FIVE I COUNTY.
AYE WIENER.
AYE WILK.
BY SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
LET ME GIVE YOU THE NEXT FIVE
FILE ITEMS. ONE ZERO FOUR ONE
ZERO FIVE ONE THIRTEEN ONE
SIXTEEN AND ONE EIGHTEEN WILL
START WITH ONE ZERO FOUR SENATOR
HILL.
PASS SOME FILE FILE ITEM ONE
ZERO FIVE SENATOR PORTANTINO.
ONE ZERO FIVE VERY GOOD MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY
BILL TWENTY THREE FORTY TWO BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER BURKE AND THAT
REALLY TO CANCER [inaudible]
SENATOR PORTANTINO. SEVEN AND
MEMBERS --
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT BILL BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BURKE I AB
TWENTY THREE FORTY TWO IS A
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS
PRIORITY.
REQUIRING HEALTH PLANS INSURERS
AND D. H. CS TO COVER BREAST AND
OVARIAN CANCER PREVENTION
RECOMMENDATIONS AS MADE BY THE
U. S. PRESENT PRESS PREVENTIVE
SERVICES TASK FORCE.
AB TWENTY THREE FORTY TWO
ENSURES THAT AS SCIENTIFIC
ADVANCEMENTS IN GENETIC TESTING
FOR BREAST AND OVARIAN CANCER
MADE.
NEW RECOMMENDATIONS BY THE TASK
FORCE ARE COVERED CURRENTLY THE
TASK FORCE RIGHT RECOMMENDS THAT
WOMEN WHO HAVE NOT BEEN
DIAGNOSED WITH BREAST OR OVARIAN
CANCER.
BUT WHO COULD BE CONSIDERED HIGH
RISK OUR SCREEN AND IF
APPROPRIATE RECEIVE GENETIC
COUNSELING AND TEST FOR THE
BRACCO ONE IN BRACKET TO GENETIC
MUTATIONS.
ARE THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
THESE PREVENTIVE MEASURES ARE
COVERED AB TWENTY THREE FORTY TO
MAKE SURE THAT NO MATTER WHAT
HAPPENS TO THE ACA.
CALIFORNIANS WILL STILL RECEIVE
THIS SCREENING IT IS IMPERATIVE
THAT ALL HIGH RISK WOMEN EVEN
THOSE WITHOUT SYMPTOMS ARE THOSE.
WHO ARE DIAGNOSED OF BREAST OR A
VERY?
IN THE OPPORTUNITY TO RECEIVE
SCREENING COUNSELING AND TESTING
AS RECOMMENDED BY THE U. S.
PREVENTIVE SERVICES TASK FORCE
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
MEMBER BURKE.
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEANT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
I ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES.
HI BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
FULLER.
I GAINES.
AYE GALGIANI [inaudible]
BY GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
AYE LARA AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL AYE MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN.
AYE STONE.
AYE VIDAK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WIENER AYE WILK I'VE BY.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTEEN SENATOR MORLOCK MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO FIFTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
HARPER IMPULSIVE TO SUICIDE
PREVENTION WEEK IN CALIFORNIA.
SENATE MORLOCK THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT.
COLLEAGUES --
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TWO FIVE FIVE WILL PROCLAIM THE
WEEK OF SEPTEMBER. NINE TWENTY
EIGHTEEN TO TWENTY SEPTEMBER
FIFTEENTH.
INCLUSIVE A SUICIDE PREVENTION
WEEK IN CALIFORNIA.
FROM THE AMERICAN FOUNDATION FOR
SUICIDE PREVENTION IN CALIFORNIA
A PERSON DIES.
BY SUICIDE EVERY TWO HOURS.
ACCORDING TO THE CENTERS FOR
DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION.
SUICIDE IS THE SECOND LEADING
CAUSE OF DEATH.
AMONG INDIVIDUALS BETWEEN THE
AGES OF FIFTEEN AND TWENTY FOUR
AND THE FOURTH LEADING CAUSE OF
DEATH AMONG INDIVIDUALS BETWEEN
THE AGES OF THIRTY FIVE AND
FIFTY FOUR CURRENTLY THE SUICIDE
EPIDEMIC.
THAT'S BECOME MORE SEVERE AMONG
YOUNG ADULTS SPECIFICALLY
COLLEGE AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS.
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF SUICIDE
PREVENTION WEEK IN CALIFORNIA
HOPEFULLY WILL HELP FURTHER AID
IN THE PREVENTION AND AWARENESS
OF SUICIDE AMONG INDIVIDUALS OF
ALL AGES.
BEING A MEMBER OF THE MENTAL
HEALTH CAUCUS.
THE SENATOR FROM --
SAN JOSE.
BROUGHT RUN DMC IS DARRYL
MCDANIELS HERE.
TO THE CAPITOL AND HE SAID.
SOMETHING THAT PRESIDENT IT
WOULD ME SAID WITH PEOPLE BETTER
STRUGGLING ONE THEY HURT
THEMSELVES THE MAY HURT OTHERS
PRETEND THEY KILL THEMSELVES.
AND SO WE NEED --
TO REALLY.
HEIGHTEN THE AWARENESS AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST TONIGHT
VOTE ON ACR TO BUY.
FIVE I THINK IT'S AN A MORE LIKE
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON.
I ATKINS AYE BATES.
AYE BELL.
AYE BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA.
AYE CHAIN [inaudible]
DELEON.
LIFE AYE DELGADO [inaudible]
BYE DOT [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
ATLANTA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONEY.
AYE MORLOCK AYE MORRELL
[inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE.
I FIGHT BACK [inaudible]
BUT KATHY [inaudible]
I WIENER.
I WILL I SENATOR MUSICAL MEMBERS
REMOVING THE FILE ITEM ONE
SIXTEEN CENTER PORTANTINO MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY BILL NINETEEN TWELVE BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER RODRIGUEZ AND
ACTUALLY TO PUBLIC AGENCIES AND
MAKING A PREPARATION THEREFORE.
CENTER PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I RISE TO PRESENT
ASSEMBLY BILL NINETEEN TWELVE ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ.
SOME OF YOU MIGHT BE AWARE THAT
LAST YEAR A JPA CALLED LA WORKS
A BRADLEY SET ABRUPTLY CEASED
OPERATION.
TERMINATED ALL OF ITS EMPLOYEES
AND HAD ITS CONTRACT WITH
CALPERS TERMINATED AFTER IT LOST
ITS SOLE SOURCE OF REVENUE.
THIS RESULTED IN UP TO SIX THREE
IN UP TO A 63% CUT TO THE
PENSIONS OF MANY OF THE JP AGE
RETIREES.
AFTER THE MEMBER AGENCIES THAT
CREATED THE JPA FAILED TO BE
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE JPA SUCCESS
AND FAILURE.
THIS BILL IS IN RESPONSE TO THAT
ISSUE THERE ABOUT A HUNDRED
SIXTY JPA IS THE CONTRACT WITH
CALPERS AND MANY OTHERS IN
PENSION SYSTEM ARE OVER TWENTY
FIVE THOUSAND EMPLOYEES AND
RETIREES.
IT'S EITHER RETIREMENT BENEFITS
CUT IF THE JPA DISSOLVES CEASES
OPERATION OR ITS CONTRACT WITH
CALPERS IS TERMINATED.
SOME OF THE KEY PROVISIONS OF
THIS BILL ARE IT ESTABLISHES A
CONTINGENT LIABILITY FOR THE
RETIREMENT OBLIGATION OTHER JPA.
BY ITS MEMBER AGENCIES IF THE J..
CONTRACT WITH CALPERS SHOULD ANY
OF THIS THESE ISSUES OCCUR 100%
OF THE RETIREMENT LIABILITY MUST
BE APPORTIONED TO THE MEMBER
AGENCIES --
BECAUSE OF WHAT HAPPENED TO THE
READ RETIREES OF LA WORKS IT
REQUIRES CALPERS PRIOR TO
REDUCING A RETIREMENT BENEFIT TO
CONSIDER AN EXHAUST OTHER
OPTIONS.
THIS BILL IS ABOUT PROTECTING
RETIREMENT SECURITY OF EMPLOYEES --
IT IS SPONSORED BY SEIU BUT
SUPPORTED BY OTHERS AND ENJOYS
IT REMOVED WHICH IT HAS ENJOYED
THE REMOVAL OF MUCH OF ITS
OPPOSITION --
MEMBERS I CAN TELL YOU THAT
THERE WERE A SERIES OF
CONVERSATIONS BETWEEN THE CITIES
JPA PARTNERSHIPS.
AND THE SPONSOR AND THOSE WERE
VERY PRODUCTIVE AND IT MOVED OUT
OF S. OUT OF ASSEMBLY PER SENATE
PURGE WHICH STRONG SUPPORT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PORTANTINO
MEMBERS ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
BY BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG
[inaudible]
I HILL.
I WAS SO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MONEY [inaudible]
MONEY I MITCHELL AYE.
MORLOCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO.
AYE ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT [inaudible]
BUT COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
NO NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM ONE EIGHTEEN SENATOR MONEY
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY BILL SIX THIRTY EIGHT
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER COMING
GENERAL AND EXPLAIN TO
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
[inaudible]
THURMOND.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS.
IN RESPONSE THE NINETEEN EIGHTY
SIX FEDERAL IMMIGRATION REFORM
AND CONTROL ACT.
ESTABLISHED CALIFORNIA ESTABLISH
DECLASSIFICATION NOISE KNOWN AS
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS.
THESE CONSULTANTS WERE INTENDED
TO HAVE A LIMITED SCOPE IN THEIR
DUTIES AND ARE MEANT ONLY TO BE
ABLE TO ASSIST.
IN THE PREPARATION OF SIMPLE
IMMIGRATION FORMS.
HOWEVER HOWEVER OVER THE PAST
THIRTY YEARS THERE BEEN NUMEROUS
CHANGES IN FEDERAL IMMIGRATION
LAW.
AND RECENT CHANGES BY THE U. S.
CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION
SERVICES HAVE MADE THIS TAKES
MUCH HIGHER. FOR THOSE APPLYING
FOR LEGAL STATUS.
CURRENTLY UNDER THE NEW FEDERAL
GUIDELINES AN APPLICANT CAN BE
DENIED FOR NOT FULLY FILLING OUT
APPLICATIONS FOR NOT ADEQUATELY
PROVIDING INFORMATION REQUESTED
IN THE APPLICATION.
OR FOR OTHER VERY SIMPLE
MISTAKES.
ADDITIONALLY USCIS AGENTS HAVE
BEEN RECENTLY INSTRUCTED GIVE
ANY DENIED APPLICATION TO
IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT IN ORDER
TO PLACE THE DENIED INDIVIDUAL
IMMIGRATION INTO IMMEDIATE.
IMMIGRATION REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS.
TODAY'S IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
ARE NOT WHAT THEY WERE INTENDED
TO BE IN.
NINETEEN EIGHTY SIX AND THE
REPERCUSSIONS OF THEIR ACTIONS
ARE FAR MORE IMPACTFUL IN THE
CURRENT NATIONAL CLIMATE.
MANY OF THESE CONSULTANTS ARE
BAD ACTORS WHO OFFER FALSE
PROMISES OF IMMIGRATION BENEFITS.
AND THE OVER CHARGE CLIENTS.
THE COMPLETE DOCUMENTS
INCORRECTLY KNOWING THAT THESE
ACTIONS WILL RESULT IN DIRE
IMMIGRATION CONSEQUENCES FOR
THEIR CLIENTS AND DO SO FOR THE
MONEY RECEIVED.
AB SIX THIRTY EIGHT OR PROTECT
IMMIGRANTS WHO ARE APPLYING FOR
LEGAL STATUS IN CALIFORNIA.
BY PROHIBITING ANY INDIVIDUAL
FROM PROVIDING IMMIGRATION
RELATED SERVICES WHO IS NOT AN
ATTORNEY OR AN ACCREDITED
REPRESENTATIVE WITH THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
THIS CHANGE WILL ENSURE THAT ANY
IMMIGRATION SERVICES OFFERED IN
CALIFORNIA ARE PROVIDED BY
EXPERTS IN IMMIGRATION LAW.
WHO HAD THE PROPER TRAINING
LEGAL EXPERIENCE AND PERHAPS
MOST IMPORTANTLY?
OVERSIGHT TO HANDLE A SENSITIVE
PROCESS THAT IF IMPROPERLY
HANDLED CAN RESULT IN
IRREVERSIBLE IMMIGRATION
CONSEQUENCES.
MEMBERS AB SIX THIRTY EIGHT IS
CRITICAL REFORM.
THAT WILL PUT THE INTERESTS OF
CALIFORNIA'S IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY
FIRST.
MEMBERS THANK YOU I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER MONNING
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
HUESO.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE
IN OPPOSITION OF AB.
SIX THIRTY EIGHT YOU KNOW UP
BEFORE WE WE DECIDE TODAY.
A CLOSE OVER A THOUSAND
BUSINESSES IN CALIFORNIA AND
POTENTIALLY.
BUT TWENTY THOUSAND PEOPLE.
IN UNEMPLOYMENT LINES.
WE SHOULD REALLY CONSIDER TODAY
WHAT WE ARE DOING.
AND WHO THIS MEASURES AND TENDED
TO BENEFIT.
I'VE BEEN WORKING WITH THE
AUTHOR FOR OVER A YEAR ON
ADDRESSING SOME OF THE CONCERNS.
THAT HAVE EEN POSED ABOUT
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS AND
THEIR SERVICE TO OUR STATE.
AND EVERY AMENDMENT THAT WE HAVE
PROPOSED HAS BEEN REFUSED AND
ANY EFFORT [inaudible] TO REFORM.
THE LAWS GOVERNING GOVERNING.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS HAS BEEN
REFUSED.
I ALWAYS WORKED VERY HARD TO
REPRESENT.
THE CONSUMER'S HERE IN THIS BODY
MAKE SURE THAT CONSUMERS ARE
PROTECTED.
IN EVERY WAY WE CAN.
BUT THERE HAVE BEEN NO EFFORTS
BY THE PROPONENT OF THIS BILL.
TO MAKE THEIR NECESSARY REFORMS
TO PROTECT CONSUMERS.
SO I THINK TODAY IN ON I HAVE
QUITE A BIT OF INFORMATION HERE.
THAT MAKES A VERY VERY STRONG
CASE WHY THIS BILL IS THE WRONG
APPROACH TO SOLVING THIS PROBLEM.
AND AND I AND I ASK PEOPLE. TO
PLEASE GIVE ME THE OPPORTUNITY
TO PRESENT.
MY CASE TODAY BECAUSE I'M VERY
CONCERNED.
THE WERE GONNA PUT A LOT OF
INNOCENT PEOPLE OUT OF BUSINESS
AND INTO UNEMPLOYMENT LINES.
AND HAVE A DIRECT [inaudible]
IMPACT.
ON THE IMMIGRANTS OUT THERE THAT
DESPERATELY NEED AFFORDABLE
SERVICES AT THAT ARE ABLE TO GO
SOMEWHERE FOR HELP.
IF THEY NEED IT [inaudible]
MANY.
MANY OF THESE OPERATORS.
OUR BUSINESSES OWNED BY FEMALE.
HISPANICS AND IMMIGRANTS
THEMSELVES. ONE IN ONE IN
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT HAS BEEN
HELPING IMMIGRANTS IN PANORAMA
CITY.
SINCE NINETEEN NINETY FIVE
ANOTHER ONE IN DOWNEY FOR TWENTY
FIVE YEARS.
ANOTHER ONE HAS BEEN IN BUSINESS
IN SANTA ANA FOR TWENTY YEARS.
AND IN MY DISTRICT.
BUT POLICE CHAU.
HAS BEEN IN PRACTICE FOR FIFTY
SEVEN YEARS.
NOW I I WORK WITH A LOT OF
IMMIGRANTS IN MY DISTRICT AND
THEY COME TO ME OFTENTIMES FOR
ASSISTANCE.
AND I I DEPENDING ON WHAT THEY
ATTORNEYS.
OR IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT MY BRO
BROTHERS ACTUALLY IMMIGRATION
ATTORNEY.
SO FOR ME PERSONALLY.
I'M LOOKING AT THE SAME WHAT'S
BEST FOR THE IMMIGRATION
[inaudible]
COMMUNITY.
I THINK WITH ALL THE THE WORK
THAT I'VE DONE OVER THE LAST
YEAR.
I'VE BEEN ABLE TO PUT TOGETHER A
LOT OF INFORMATION THE SHOWS
THAT YOUR IF YOU'RE AN EXPERT.
IN IMMIGRATION AND YOUR SOUL
INTERESTED TO HELP THE
IMMIGRANTS.
YOU'RE YOU'RE PROBABLY OPPOSED
TO THIS BILL.
IF YOU DON'T HAVE A FINANCIAL
INTEREST IN THIS BILL.
YOU'RE PROBABLY OPPOSED TO IT.
AND I HAVE OVERWHELMING EVIDENCE
TO SUPPORT THAT.
I HAVE A FRIEND WHO'S AN
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT IN THE
SAN AN AREA THAT I'VE BEEN
WORKING. FOR YEARS TO RAISE
MONEY FOR SCHOLARSHIPS FOR
STUDENTS A LOT OF THESE BUSINESS
PEOPLE DON'T GET SUED THEY DON'T
GET COMPLAINTS AGAINST THEM.
THEY'RE OUT UPSTANDING A MEMBERS
OF OURS COMMUNITY BUT POLICE
SECOND SALAS AND HER LAST FIFTY
SEVEN YEARS.
HAS BEEN A WONDERFUL ADDITION TO
OUR COMMUNITY AND A VERY
RESPECTED LEADER NOT SOMEBODY
THAT A SUIT OR IS ISSUED
COMPLAINTS AGAINST BUT SOMEBODY
THAT HAS HELPED.
LOTS AND LOTS OF PEOPLE.
IN -- IN ONE
BUSINESS THAT'S BEEN IN BUSINESS
FOR FOURTEEN YEARS HE REPORTS
HAT IT IS TO LOCATIONS THIS IS
A FORMER DISTRICT DIRECTOR OF
THE INS.
AND HE HAS BEEN AND IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS SINCE NINETEEN
EIGHTY FIVE IN LOS ANGELES WITH
TWO OFFICES ONE IN MONTEREY PARK.
AND AND AND AND ANOTHER BSINESS
FOR TWENTY THREE YEARS IN THE
POMONA AREA.
HE REPORTS THAT IN THESE TOOK
LOCATIONS HE'S HAD TOGETHER
SERVED OVER SIXTY THOUSAND
CLIENTS.
THE CALIFORNIA BUSINESS A
PROFESSION CODE SECTIONS.
TWO TWO FOUR FOUR ZERO IT A DASH
FOR FOUR NINE ESTABLISHES THE
GUIDELINES.
BY WHICH BUT AUDIT IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANT MAY PRACTICE THEY ARE
REQUIRED TO REGISTER WITH THE
SECRETARY STATE.
GET A BACKGROUND CHECK
FINGERPRINTING AND OBTAIN A BOND
OF A HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS-ATTORNEYS OFFICES DON'T HAVE
BONDS FOR A HUNDRED THOUSAND
THIS IS ON A A VERY LARGE
REQUIREMENTS IF.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT SERVICES
ARE LIVE LIMITED TO NON LEGAL
ADVICE.
THEIR PRACTICE CONSIST OF
TRANSLATION GETTING COPIES OF
SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS AND FORM
SUBMITTALS.
THEIR JOB IS IS HANDLE IN THE
APPLICATION PROCESS THIS NON
TECHNICAL.
THESE ARE BASIC BUT INVALUABLE
SERVICES TO THE IMMIGRANT
COMMUNITIES AT AFFORDABLE PRICES
FOR EXAMPLE AN IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANT COULD CHARGE SIXTY
DOLLARS FOR A SIMPLE CHANGE OF A
LEGAL PERMANENT RESIDENT
RESIDENT CARD.
WEARS ATTORNEY CHARGES TWO
HUNDRED TO FOUR HUNDRED FOR THE
SAME THING.
IN FACT ATTORNEYS REGULAR REFER
CASES TO IN.
BURKE TWO OF IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS FOR THAT VERY SAME
REASON.
AND IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
REFER THEIR CLIENTS TO ATTORNEYS
WHEN THEY CAN'T HANDLE THE
MATTER THAT IS ABOVE.
THEIR THEIR EXPERIENCE
[inaudible]
DESPITE.
REFERRING TO THIS BILL.
AS A WORK IN PROGRESS THE AUTHOR
HAS MADE NO SIGNIFICANT CHANGES.
SINCE HIS.
LAST YEAR [inaudible]
MADAM PRESIDENT.
I RECEIVED A LETTER FROM ARNOLD
ROSENBERG HE SAID AN ATTORNEY.
THAT HAVE SOME VERY COMPELLING
INFORMATION TO AND WITH YOUR
PERMISSION I'D LIKE TO READ
PORTIONS OF IT.
WITHOUT OBJECTION BECAUSE THIS
LETTER.
FROM AN ATTORNEY WHO HAS IS.
A IS AN OBJECTIVE OBSERVER WITH
AN ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF EXPERIENCE
IN THIS MATTER.
RAISES HIS OBJECTIONS TO THIS
BILL AND THAT THEY WERE SEVERELY.
HURT THE IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY.
HE SAYS I DO NOT HAVE A HORSE IN
THIS RACE I AM SIXTY SEVEN YEARS
OLD.
MY EX WIFE NELLIE ROOT ROOT.
ROOT NELLY RADIUS WASN'T
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS SAN
FRANCISCO AND BEFORE THAT IN
OAKLAND SINCE.
NINETEEN NINETY ONE I PRACTICED
LAW FOR OVER FORTY YEARS INSULT
WHAT SHE DID AND HOW MUCH GOOD
SHE DID FOR HER CLIENTS.
IN FACT SHE WAS AWARDED THE
PHILLIP BURTON CIVIL RIGHTS
AWARD IN SAN FRANCISCO NINETEEN
NINETY FIVE FOR HER WORK FOR
IMMIGRANTS.
I KNOW WHAT'S GOOD I KNOW WHAT
IT IS GOOD IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS CAN DO.
I I AM A HARVARD LAW SCHOOL
ALUMNUS RETIRED ASSISTANT DEAN
OF CALIFORNIA WESTERN SCHOOL OF
LAW.
AND NOT PRONE TO CONDONING BAD
WORK.
BUT I ALSO DO BELIEVE THAT
LAWYERS ARE NOT ONLY ARE NOT THE
ONLY ONES CAPABLE OF PERFORMING
SIMPLE TAX.
ON BEHALF OF IMMIGRANTS
MONOPOLIZED IN THESE TASKS.
WOULD BE THE EFFECT OF AB
[inaudible]
SIX THIRTY EIGHT JUST RAISES --
I'M SORRY.
MONOPOLIZING THIS TASK WOULD BE
THE EFFECT OF AB.
SIX THIRTY EIGHT JUST RAISES
FEES BEYOND WHAT THESE LARGELY
AND THE GINGER PEOPLE CAN AFFORD.
LAWYERS CHARGE FOUR THOUSAND FOR
THE SAME ROUTINE SERVICES WHICH
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS CAN
CHARGE ONE THOUSAND OR LESS AND
BELIEVE ME.
THERE IS NOT USUALLY A LOT OF
DIFFERENCE IN QUALITY MY MY EX
WIFE'S CLIENTS HAD A MUCH BETTER
RECORD BEFORE.
WHAT THEN WAS CALLED THE
IMMIGRATION AND NATURALIZATION
SERVICES AND MORE SO LAWYERS
CLIENTS DID?
IN CALIFORNIA ONE THOUSAND
SIXTEEN REG REGISTERED
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS ASSIST
OVER TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
IMMIGRANTS EACH YEAR WITH
ROUTINE VISA APPLICATIONS.
AN ESTIMATED 37% ALMOST
[inaudible]
SEVENTY FIVE THOUSAND OUR
INDIGENT.
WHICH WOULD QUALIFY FOR FOR FREE
FREE LEGAL SERVICES IF THEY HAD
A GREEN CARD.
I COULD NOT AFFORD COUNSEL IF
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS ARE
ELIMINATED. ONE EXPERT ATTORNEY
WHO WORKS FOR A PUBLIC INTEREST
ORGANIZATION AND OPPOSES AB.
SIX THIRTY EIGHT ESTIMATES THAT
40% OF THESE IMMIGRANTS.
ABBY NEITHER COUNSEL ON
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT AND SO
UNABLE TO FILE BE SEPARATE
APPLICATIONS WOULD BE AT RISK OF
DEPORTATION IF THIS BILL PASSES.
HAT'S THIRTY THOUSAND
IMMIGRANTS A YEAR.
NOR ARE IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
DISPROPORTIONATELY GUILTY OF
MISCONDUCT.
THE RATE OF A COMPLAINTS ABOUT
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS FILED
WITH THE ATTORNEYS GENERAL'S
OFFICE IS THE LOWER.
THAN THE RATE OF COMPLAINTS
ABOUT ATTORNEYS FILED BY THE
STATE BAR AND I WANT TO MAKE A
COMMENT ABOUT THAT.
BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE TALKING ABOUT.
FRAUD IN ABOUT COMPLAINTS.
AND AND THERE ARE NUMBERS
ALLEGING THAT THERE ARE A LOT OF
COMPLAINTS AGAINST IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO
GET UP TAME SOME INFORMATION.
FIRST OF ALL.
OTHERS OF MY PRESIDENT THERE IS
A A FORM THAT.
THE PROPONENTS OF THE BILL HAVE
BEEN --
CIRCULATING MAKING A CASE THAT
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS ARE
INVOLVED IN FRAUD.
AND IF I CAN JUST HOLD IT UP.
MADAM PRESIDENT IS OUT OF ORANGE
HERE IS WHAT THEY'VE BEEN SECURE
CHELATING BUT IN THIS CASE
[inaudible]
THE PERSON.
THAT WAS ACCUSED OF FRAUD WAS
SOMEBODY POSE SEEN AS AN
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT
[inaudible]
WE HAVE.
THEY HAVE BEEN ALSO MAKING --
CLAIMS OF A STATISTICS SO
SHOWING THAT THERE'S AN ENORMOUS
AMOUNT OF FRAUD YET NOBODY.
HAS BEEN ABLE TO PROVIDE BE THIS
DATA WHERE IS THIS INFORMATION.
THAT CONFIRMS BUT THERE WERE
THERE ARE ACTUAL CASES OF FRAUD
WITHIN THEIR IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANT COMMUNITY THE ONLY
THING THAT WE KNOW.
IT IS INFORMATION THAT WAS CUT
BY THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES.
BUT HAS SHOWED IN INCREASE IN
COMPLAINTS RELATED TO
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS BUT THEY
CANNOT ASCERTAIN.
WHETHER THESE COMPLAINTS WERE
ACTUALLY IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
YES WE HAVE CAST CASELOAD
SHOWING.
BUT INDIVIDUALS WERE WERE FOUND
TO HAVE BEEN COMMITTED FRAUD BUT
THEY WERE IN.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS AND THEN
WE HAVE OTHER.
SORRY JUST LOST OF DOCUMENT HERE.
WE HAVE INFORMATION THAT
SUGGESTS THAT --
BUT IMMIGRATION.
OUR COME A COMPLAINTS AGAINST
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS HAVE
GONE UP [inaudible] TWO THINGS.
CAN BE CONTRIBUTING TO THIS
NUMBER ONE THAT IN THAT IN AN
ENVIRONMENT WHERE MORE PEOPLE
NEED.
IMMIGRATION SERVICES THERE ARE
MORE PEOPLE OUT THERE PRETENDING
TO BE IMMIGRATION CALLED
SHELTON'S WHO ARE NOT AND NOT
PROVIDING THE RIGHT PROPER
SERVICES.
AND THAT IS IN IN --
THE IMMIGRATION COMPLACENT
RECEIVED --
IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN WERE.
TWO HUNDRED FOUR AND THE ONE TO
RECEIVE A TWENTY TING REPORTER.
TWENTY SEVEN BUT WE ALSO HAVE
INFORMATION SUGGESTS THAT
THERE'S BEEN AN INDIVIDUAL.
BOB BY THE NAME OF SEBASTIAN MET
MEDVED A ON ATTORNEY IN THE LOS
ANGELES AREA THAT SUED.
ABOUT SEVENTY IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS IN THE LA AREA.
HE DID NOT KNOW THEM HE DID NOT
GO TO THEM FOR SERVICES.
HE HAD NEVER WORKED WITH THEM.
HE HAD NO ONE THAT HE
REPRESENTED THAT WAS HARMED BY
THEM [inaudible]
IT.
QUITE CONTRARY HE WAS.
A HE WOULD HIMSELF WAS NOT ONLY.
THE THE ATTORNEY BUT THE BUT THE
PLAINTIFF IN THE CASE
[inaudible]
AND I HE HE CREATED A
CORPORATION CALLED THE
IMMIGRATION.
RIGHTS DEFENSE COUNSEL WHICH IS
CREATED BY HIM WHO IS LISTED.
AS THE PLANE THEM THE OFFENDED
KNOW EVERY I'M SORRY THE
PLAINTIFF.
IN EVERY LAWSUIT AND MADAM
PRESIDENT I HAVE A IF ANYBODY
HEARS INTERESTED IN REVIEWING
ONE OF THESE.
YOU CAN SEE THAT IT IS NOT --
A A LAWSUIT THAT HAS A CLIENT A
REAL CLIENT WHO WOULD.
I MEAN HOW DOES AN ASSOCIATION
WALK INTO AN OFFICE AND SAY I
WANT SERVICES THAT DOES NOT
HAPPEN IN INDIVIDUAL DEBTS.
AND AN INDIVIDUAL REQUIRING
SERVICES DOES.
AND IN THIS CASE YOU'LL SEE THAT
IT HAS HIS [inaudible]
A HIS PLAINTIFF IS THE IMMIGRANT
CERTAIN RIGHTS DEFENSE COUNSEL.
AND HE BASICALLY LAYS OUT THE
ENTIRE CODE WHICH I HAVE HERE.
ACCUSING.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS OF
VIOLATING EVERY SINGLE CODE AND
IT'S ALL THAT PLAYED OUT.
AND NOT MAKING ANY REFERENCE TO
ANY SERVICE THAT HE WAS DENIED.
AND THAT IS SIMPLY SKEWING.
THE MOUND OF LAWSUITS IN THIS
PROCESS [inaudible]
AND ALSO.
USING HIS USING BASICALLY THE
LOS A PLATFORM TO PROFFER FROM
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS BECAUSE
MOST OF THESE COULD NONE OF
THESE CASES HAVE HAVE.
GONE TO TRIAL HE HAS SETTLED ALL
OF THEM ANOTHER WORDS HE
BASICALLY TOOK MONEY FROM THESE
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS AND
NEVER IN ANY ONE OF THESE LOSS
WAS A WAS ANY ONE OF THOSE.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS FOUND
GUILTY.
SO AYE I KNOW EVERYBODY IS
GETTING A LITTLE BIT --
NANCY AND I KNOW I'M GOING ON
FOR A LONG TIME BUT YOU KNOW
THIS IS A A AND ISSUES FOR
IMPORTANT TO ME BECAUSE I WORK.
WITH A LOT OF IMMIGRANTS MY
DISTRICT.
AND THIS LAW WILL MAKE IT MUCH
MORE DIFFICULT FOR ME TO SERVE
MY CONSTITUENTS.
IT WON'T MAKE IT MORE DIFFICULT.
FOR THEM TO GO SOMEWHERE THAT
CAN THAT CAN BE REPRESENTED IN
THEIR COMMUNITY WITHIN ACCESS OF
UNDERSTANDS THEIR ISSUES.
IN THEIR OWN LANGUAGE WE HAVE
TALKED ABOUT REFORMING THE BAR
THAT THE BARS NOT REPRESENTATIVE.
OF THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
AND AND THE BAR HAS A LOT OF
WORK TO DO TO CREATE.
THAT THE THE THE THE KIND OF
SERVICE IN OUR STATE THAT
REPRESENTS THAT'S THAT'S WHAT
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE PEOPLE IT
SERVES NOT ONLY TO THE JUDICIAL
SYSTEM BUT THE ROUTE THROUGH THE
ATTORNEY SYSTEM.
AND AND AND THE THESE ARE.
THESE ARE SERVICES ARE PROVIDED
BY PEOPLE THAT ARE HAVE BEEN
THROUGH.
BUT DON'T THE PROCESS THAT
UNDERSTAND.
A HOWL VACANCY BETTER SERVE THE
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY.
AND AND YOU KNOW I ALSO WANNA
[inaudible]
SAY THAT.
THESE NUMBERS IF THIS BILL.
IS ELIMINATED THE NUMBERS OF
COMPLAINTS WILL GO UP.
THE AMOUNT OF PEOPLE POSING AS
ATTORNEYS OR NOTARIES OR
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS I HAVE
FRIENDS THAT HAVE BEEN RIPPED
OFF.
BUT THEY HAVEN'T BE RIPPED OFF
BY SOMEBODY WITH AN OFFICE WAS
BONDED BY THE SECRETARY OF STATE
WHO IS HAS A BUSINESS BY SINCE
THEY WERE RIPPED OFF BY PEOPLE
THAT SAID I CAN HELP YOU.
GIVE ME FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
THEY DO AND THEY NEVER SEE THEM
AGAIN.
THAT IS GONNA CONTINUE THIS BILL
WILL NOT CHANGE THAT.
PEOPLE THOSE INCIDENTS.
OF FRAUD OR GOING TO GO UP IF
IMMIGRANTS DON'T HAVE A GOOD
PLACE TO GO.
BEN AND AYE AYE AT I ASKED ALL
OF YOU TO DO SOMETHING HERE AYE
I THINK.
WE WE HAVE A LOT OF WORK TO DO
TO ENSURE THAT WE HAVE A A
BETTER ENVIRONMENT THEY DIS
FRAUD.
BIG THESE AMOUNT OF INCIDENTS
WHERE PEOPLE HAVE BEEN DEFRAUDED
ARE HAPPY NOT ON THE POOREST
PEOPLE THE MOST A DISADVANTAGE
ONES THAT MAY BE EDUCATED BUT
DON'T UNDERSTAND OUR SYSTEM OF
GOVERNMENT.
THEY MAY BE COMING FROM OTHER
COUNTRIES AND MAYBE HERE IN THE
COUNTRY LEGALLY OR NOT.
BUT THEY DON'T HAVE I MEAN THE
WORKING VERY VERY HARD. TO PUT
FOOD ON THE TABLE AND THEY IF
THEY SEE SOMEBODY GIVE THEM HOPE.
THEY'RE WILLING TO GIVE THEIR
THEIR HARD EARNED CASH FOR THAT.
AND WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING TO
ENSURE THAT THEY'RE NOT
DEFRAUDED BUT WE NEED TO ENSURE
THAT WE HAVE THEY HAVE SOMEWHERE
TO GO WE'VE.
ALREADY HAVE AN ESTABLISHED
NETWORK ACROSS THE STATE CAN WE
STRAY FROM IT YES AND I ASK ALL
OF YOU THAT WE WORK ON THIS.
THAT WE DON'T THROW THE BABY OUT
WITH THE BATH WATER AND SAY --
WITH THEIR A FEW INCIDENTS OF
FRAUD ELIMINATE THE ENTIRE
INDUSTRY.
I HAVE CASES THAT WERE THERE ARE
ANECDOTES THEIR ACTUAL CASES
[inaudible]
IN WHICH IN WHICH THE FOR
EXAMPLE IN ONE CASE IN LOS
ANGELES I'M GETTING KIND OF
BURIED IN MY OWN BUREAUCRACY
HERE.
BUT THERE BEEN THERE WAS A CASE
IN LOS ANGELES FOR EXAMPLE IN
THE CITY OF PARMA [inaudible]
THAT.
REALLY DON'T HAVE THAT.
NUMBER ANYWAY IT WAS A CASE IN
WHICH MANY MEN.
THERE WAS A A NICE CRACKDOWN AT
A BUSINESS.
AND A LOT OF THESE --
KNOW IF EMPLOYEES --
WON'T WORK ON THE THREAT OF
DEPORTATION AND THERE WAS NOT
ENOUGH.
BETWEEN OUR ARE ADVOCACY
ORGANIZATIONS THAT REPRESENT
IMMIGRANTS AND THE LEGAL
COMMUNITY THAT WERE NOT ENOUGH
PEOPLE AVAILABLE TO REPRESENT.
THESE IMMIGRANTS AND THE RESULT
IS THAT THE MAJORITY OF THEM DID
NOT HAVE REPRESENTATION AND THEY
WERE DEPORTED.
LAST YEAR WE WE WE PASSED A FUND
TO HELP.
US PROVIDE LEGAL DEFENSE TO A OF
A LOT OF IMMIGRANTS A FACING
DEPORTATION AND WE HAVE FOUND
THAT WHEN THEY HAVE
REPRESENTATION THERE'S A 70%
CHANCE OF THE STATE IN THE
COUNTRY.
BUT THESE NUMBERS GO UP
ENORMOUSLY WHEN THEY HAVE SOME
KIND OF LEGAL REPRESENTATION
THAT WE'RE DOING TODAY.
IS BAKER BASICALLY DID DIDN'T.
ERODING OUR NETWORK OF SUPPORT
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THAT'S GONNA DIRECTLY LEAD
[inaudible]
CHIU.
MORE DEPORTATIONS I WANNA GO
BACK TO THE LETTER OF THE
ATTORNEY [inaudible]
THAT -- THAT
A I WANNA BASICALLY A MAN
PRESENT MAYBE AND BY COMMENTS.
WITH HIS FINAL COMMENTS WITHOUT
OBJECTION AND DID HE HE SAYS THE
SUPPORTERS OF AB SIX THREE EIGHT
SAY.
IF WE ELIMINATE IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS ALL THESE ARE
UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS WILL GO TO
ATTORNEYS.
THIS IS JUST NOT THE CASE ALMOST
SEVENTY FIVE THOUSAND
UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS A YEAR.
WILL WIND UP WITH NEITHER AN
ATTORNEY.
NORTH IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT AND
THIRTY THOUSAND WILL WIND UP AT
RISK OF DEPORTATION.
IS THAT A BETTER RESULT THAN
WHAT WE HAVE NOW.
THE SUPPORTERS SAY YES IT IS A
BETTER RESULT.
BECAUSE ALL IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS ARE WORTHLESS AND
DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING
AND ARE PRACTICING LAW WITHOUT A
LICENSE.
THIS TOO IS NOT THE CASE.
THE SUPPORTERS OF THIS BILL
WON'T ADMIT.
THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE WHO ARE
DOING WONDERFUL WORK.
DO KNOW WHAT THEY ARE DOING.
AND ARE NOT PRACTICING LAW
WITHOUT A LICENSE AS THE SUPREME
COURT DEFINES IT.
IT IS REALLY.
IF THEY REALLY WANTED TO DELIVER
GOOD AFFORDABLE SERVICES TO
IMMIGRANTS.
THEY WOULD SUPPORT MANDATORY
TRAINING AND LICENSING FOR
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS A BILL
BAY TURNED DOWN.
MEMBERS PLEASE VOTE NO.
ON THIS MEASURE.
THANK YOU SENATOR HUESO SENATOR
ANDERSON.
MEMBERS ARE A WHEN I FIRST
LOOKED AT THIS HIGH IE --
WAS INCLINED TO SUPPORT IT.
AND I KNOW THIS MAY SEEM ODD
MANY OF YOU MAY NOT KNOW THIS
ABOUT MY DISTRICT.
BUT WE HAVE A LOT OF REFUGEES
WE'VE BEEN ONE OF THE TARGETS OF
ALL THE MIDDLE EASTERN REFUGEES
AND AND WE'VE HAD AND WE WILL
GLADLY WELCOMED THESE REFUGEES
FROM AROUND THE WORLD.
BUT MANY OF THEM --
HAVE BEEN TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF
THEIR NEW TO THIS COUNTRY THEY
DON'T KNOW THE RULES AND
REGULATIONS.
AND SOME NEFARIOUS PEOPLE HAVE
TAKEN ADVANTAGE OF THEM.
LAST YEAR I BELIEVE IS THE YEAR
BEFORE --
GONZALEZ FLETCHER RAN AB ELEVEN
FIFTY NINE AND I CO AUTHOR THAT
BILL.
BECAUSE IN THAT BILL WE GET
ATTORNEYS IN INCOME AND
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS.
TELLING PEOPLE THERE WAS A BILL
IN THE U. S. SENATE.
IF THEY WANT TO BE FIRST TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THAT BILL.
THEY SHOULD HIRE THEM.
AND SO PEOPLE WOULD DO TEN
TWENTY THIRTY THOUSAND ARE
DEPOSITS.
AND THEN YOU'D SEE FIVE HUNDRED
HOURS A MONTH BURN AWAY AS YOU
WERE CHECKING ON THE PROGRESS OF
THAT.
US.
SENATE BILL DATE WAS NOT MOVING
AND PROBABLY WILL NEVER MOVE.
AND IT'S NOT RIGHT. TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF ANYONE BUT
ESPECIALLY NOT RIGHT TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF P. POPULATIONS THE
NEED.
YEAH.
WHAT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT WITH
THIS [inaudible]
IT IS.
NOT EVERY CONSULTANT
[inaudible]
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT.
IS DOING A BAD JOB MAYOR DOING
GREAT JOBS.
AND WHEN I LOOK AT THESE PEOPLE
THAT REFUGEES THERE COMING.
THEY HAVE NOTHING.
ZERO THEY'RE WORKING IN
STRUGGLING TO PUT A ROOF OVER
THEIR HEADS INFOOD IN THEIR
CHILDREN'S MOUTHS.
AND THEY ALL CAN AFFORD
ATTORNEYS.
AND NOT EVERYTHING THAT YOU NEED.
REQUIRES AN ATTORNEY
TRANSLATIONS DOES REQUIRED
ATTORNEY.
HELPING A PERSON COMPLY BUT
TELLING THEM WHERE TO GO TO GET
THE DOCUMENTS THEY NEED FOR THAT
FOR THE FORM.
THAT'S YOU DON'T NEED AN
ATTORNEY FOR THAT.
IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT YOU CAN'T
USE HER A CONSULTANT IN ADDITION
TO AN ATTORNEY.
THEREFORE ONLY PAIN FOR THE
ATTORNEY FOR THE VERY CRUCIAL
ELEMENTS THAT ONLY AN ATTORNEY
CAN PROVIDE.
NOW.
I ALSO HAVE MY DISTRICT HAS THE
DISTINCTION NOT THIS PARTICULAR
YEAR BUT IN PAST YEARS OF BEING
THE EPICENTER FOR EVERY FIRE
THAT COMES TO CBO COUNTY.
PACKED IN THE CEDAR FIRE MY
DISTRICT LOST TWO THOUSAND HOMES.
AND WHAT DO WE HAVE.
WE HAD A WHOLE BUNCH OF
CONSTRUCTION FOLKS COMING IN TO
BACK FILL THAT VOID.
IT WHEN THEY DID.
LOT OF MORE CHARLATANS DIDN'T
HAVE LICENSES.
THEY TOOK PEOPLE'S DEPOSITS AND
THEY TOOK OFF.
SO THIS ISN'T THE FIRST TIME
WE'VE HAD A CRISIS WERE
CHARLATANS ARE COMING IN MAKING
CLAIMS ARE SIMPLY NOT TRUE.
THE DIFFICULTY I HAVE WITH THIS
BILL.
IS THAT TO ME THIS IS MORE OF A
SCOPE OF PRACTICE ISSUE WHERE WE
LAY DOWN STRONG GUIDELINES.
AND I THINK IF WE HAD SPECIFIC
TRAINING.
WITH CERTIFICATION ON THEIR
TRAINING.
SO THAT THAT PERSON WOULD KNOW.
I CAN'T JUST TALK TO A NOTARY I
CAN'T JUST TALK TO CONSULTANT
THEY'VE GOT TO HAVE A FIVE STAR --
CERTIFICATION FROM THE STATE.
AND THEN I KNOW THAT IF IF
THERE'S JUST LIKE THAT
CONSTRUCTION PERSON WITH WITH A
LICENSE.
I DO CONSTRUCTION THEN I KNOW
I'M DEALING WITH SOMEBODY WHO'S
PROPERLY TRAINED.
AND I'M GETTING IT IN AFFORDABLE
RATE.
WHAT I DON'T WANT IS ANYBODY
PRAYED ARE IN A PARK DEBTS IN A
POPULATION OF NEED?
AND I WANT TO BALANCE THAT
PEOPLE GET REPRESENTATION
[inaudible]
YOU KNOW.
WHEN YOU'RE DIRT POOR?
AND EVERYTHING IN YOUR LIFE.
YOU WILL HAVE A HOME ANY MORE
BECAUSE ARE THE GONNA EXECUTE
YOU BASED ON YOUR RELIGIOUS
BELIEFS.
OR FOR ANY OTHER REASON AND
YOU'RE STRUGGLING.
WHY WOULD WE WANT TO DENY THEM
MULTI LAYERS OF SUPPORT WHY
WOULD WE ALLOW THEM TO GO TO A
NOTARY INITIALLY THAT IS TRAINED
IN THIS AREA WITHOUT NOTARY OR
THAT?
SOLD AND CAN TURN AROUND SAY I
CAN TAKE IT THIS FAR WHICH YOU
NEED AN ATTORNEY MOVING FORWARD.
AND I WOULD I WOULD ALSO SUGGEST.
BUT PERHAPS THAT PROGRAM WOULD
WORK FOR ATTORNEYS AS WELL.
BECAUSE I THINK A LOT OF
ATTORNEYS DO EVERYTHING FOR
EVERYBODY.
AND I'M NOT SURE THAT GOOD.
SPECIALIZED AND THINGS ARE SO
CRITICAL TO PEOPLE SAFETY AND IN
A IN A AND I WANT TO THANK.
HOW MY GOOD FRIEND FROM SAN
DIEGO WHO MADE SOME INCREDIBLE
POINTS BUT I WOULD JUST LEAVE
YOU ARE ON THE NOTION
[inaudible]
IN MY DISTRICT.
IF WE ELIMINATE THESE POSITIONS.
THEY'RE GONNA BE REFUGEES.
WHO ARE NOT REPRESENTED IN ANY
WAY SHAPE OR FORM?
AND THEY'RE NOT COULDN'T AFFORD
ATTORNEY AND THEY'RE NOT GONNA.
THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE TREATED
[inaudible]
YES.
GOOD AMERICANS WOULD TREAT ANY
GUEST THAT THEY INVITED INTO
THEIR COUNTRY.
I URGE A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATOR LARA.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
WELCOME TO OUR LATINO CAUCUS
DRAMA.
YOU ARE.
WITNESSING US AIRING.
AIRING OUT OUR DIRTY LAUNDRY PUT
IT'S AN END IN IMPORTANT
CONVERSATION.
THAT NEEDS TO HAPPEN.
IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT
CONVERSATION AND I THAT THAT
NEEDS TO BE HAD IN THIS
LEGISLATURE [inaudible]
SPECIALLY AFTER.
THE LAST TWENTY YEARS MEMBERS
THAT IMMIGRATION AND HAS BECOME
INCREDIBLY COMPLEX IN THIS
COUNTRY.
USED TO BE A LOT EASIER.
BUT THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS
THAT UNDER THIS ADMINISTRATION
NOW MORE THAN EVER.
IT IS STILL DIFFICULT TO FIGURE
OUT WHAT TYPE OF RELIEF.
YOU QUALIFY.
FOR NOW DO YOU QUALIFY FOR A A
U. VISA A T. VISA.
A SPECIAL IMMIGRANT --
JUVENILE STATUS [inaudible]
A FEDERAL
I MEAN JUST TO FIGURE TO STILL
ACTUALLY FILL OUT THE FORM.
IF YOU FILL OUT THE WRONG FORM
TODAY.
IF YOU FILL OUT THE WRONG FORM
YOU GONNA GET DEPORTED.
IT'S JUST EASIER THAT.
THAT IS THE CURRENT SITUATION.
AND THE QUESTION THAT WE HAVE.
IS HOW DO WE PROTECT.
ALREADY VULNERABLE IMMIGRANT
POPULATION.
AND NOW MEMBERS YOU KNOW OVER
THE LAST FIFTEEN YEARS.
I HAVE WORKED DILIGENTLY
ALONGSIDE ALL OF YOU.
ON POLICIES TO PROTECT OUR
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES.
AND I THINK THIS BILL.
IS IN THE SAME.
ARE IN THE SAME SPIRIT.
AS IMMIGRANTS INTEGRATE AND
PARTICIPATE.
AND APPLY FOR PROGRAMS.
YOU KNOW THEY PUT THEIR FAITH IN
THE SYSTEM.
AND WE'VE SAID THAT WE SHOULD
TRUST THAT [inaudible]
NOW.
WE'RE ASKING IN THIS BILL.
WHICH BY THE WAY OUR CURRENT
ATTORNEY GENERAL SUPPORTS THIS
VERSION OF THE BILL --
IS REQUIRING THAT YOU EITHER
BECOME A PARALEGAL OR AFFILIATE
WITH AN ATTORNEY.
JUST LIKE MANY NONPROFITS TO
ALREADY THAT DO THIS WORK AND DO
THIS WORK VERY WELL.
SHEILA THAT IS AND I'M ON THE
BOARD OF MORRELL.
WHICH WE DO THE CITIZENSHIP
DRIVES ALL THE TIME AND GUESS
WHAT AT THE END OF THAT WORKSHOP
THERE IS AN ATTORNEY.
THAT REVIEWS YOUR DOCUMENTS
BEFORE YOU PUT THEM IN THE MAIL.
WELL BETTER ASSURANCE DO YOU
HAVE THAT THERE'S SOMEBODY
THAT'S ACTUALLY UNDERSTANDING
THE LAW KNOWS THE LAW I CAN
ACTUALLY REPRESENT YOU.
AND COURT UNLIKE AN IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANT [inaudible]
CAN.
THE BE ABLE TO HELP YOU WITH
YOUR CASE NOW I HAD THIS BILL
WHEN I WAS CHAIR OF
APPROPRIATIONS.
AND I WE WE HONESTLY TRY TO COME
UP WITH -- A
COMPROMISE TRY TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT UP A FEE SCHEDULE WOULD
LOOK LIKE OF WHAT WOULD YOU CAN
CHARGE FOR CERTAIN DOCUMENTS
WHAT DOCUMENTS CAN YOU CAN YOU
NOT FILL OUT.
WITH GET GUESS WHAT ALL THOSE
DOCUMENTS.
OUR FREE.
ALREADY.
BOTH ARE FREE DOCUMENTS THAT YOU
NO ONE CAN ARGUE THAT LOOK WE
PAY TAX PREPARERS TO PREPARE OUR
TAXES THAT YOU KNOW THOSE ARE
FREE DOCUMENTS.
AND THAT WOULD.
BE A FAIR ANALOGY IF WE WERE
LIVING UNDER THIS CURRENT REGIME.
THAT YOU KNOW IF YOU MISS HANDLE
YOUR TAXES.
YOU PAY A FINE YOU WILL FEEL YOU
PAY --
YOU'LL YOU'LL GET AUDITED BUT
HERE F THE FILL OUT THE WRONG
FORMS ARE YOU FOR THE MODERN
CORRECTLY GUESS WHAT.
YOU'RE BEING DEPORTED.
YOUR BE YOUR OF BEING SEPARATED
FROM YOUR FAMILY.
AND SO I UNDERSTAND.
THAT AND I ACKNOWLEDGE IN I WANT
TO PUBLICLY ACKNOWLEDGE THAT NOT
EVERY IMMIGRANT IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANT.
IS DOING BAD THINGS ARE IS BEING
NEFARIOUS.
BUT IS JUST SO IMPORTANT TO GET
THIS RIGHT THE FIRST TIME.
SO MANY OF OUR OR NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATIONS SPEND.
SO MUCH TIME.
TRYING.
TO REPAIR THE MASS THAT HAS BEEN
CREATED.
IN SOME OF THESE CASES.
AND THEY INVEST THE TIME AND
MONEY TO BE ABLE TO OBTAIN
ATTORNEYS. TO TO LOOK AT THESE
CASES.
AND YOU KNOW [inaudible]
SADLY.
YOU KNOW IF THIS IS THE CURRENT
STATE WHERE RECENT.
POLICIES DIRECTED BY THIS
PRESIDENT PUT SO MANY PEOPLE IN
PARA.
IMPERIL -- I
WANTED JUST FOR FOR MY
COLLEAGUES YOU KNOW THESE ARE
THE SITUATIONS OF WHERE HEARING
OF PEOPLE BEING DEFRAUDED OR OR
BEING DEPORTED --
ARE NOT UNIQUE AND ACTUALLY
OCCURRED THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE
STATE LAST YEAR SANTA CLARA
COUNTY DA AND DIED A LONG TIME
BONDED.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT HOMES
HANDLE PAPERWORK RESULTING IN A
KIND BEING A STRANDED IN MEXICO
THE CITY OF OAKLAND ONE A
FIFTEEN MILLION DOLLAR JUDGMENT.
AGAINST IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
WHO MISLED CLIENTS NEEDING TO
TEN INDIVIDUALS BEING ARE
PUTTING THEM IN THE REMOVAL
PROCEEDINGS AND TO BEING
DEPORTED ANOTHER FAMILIES
SEPARATED FOR TEN YEARS.
THE DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER
AFFAIRS --
AROUND TWO THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED
INDIVIDUALS WHO UNLAWFULLY
ASSIST WITH IMMIGRATION MATTERS
IN CALIFORNIA.
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES.
SECURE CONVICTIONS AGAINST A
PROMINENT CONSULTANT FOR THE
UNLICENSED PRACTICE OF
IMMIGRATION LAW.
WHICH ALLEGEDLY PUT CLIENTS AND
IT IMMIGRATION THEIR IMMIGRATION
STATUS AT RISK.
OF COURSE NOT ALL OF THESE I
SAID HIS CONCERNS ENGAGE IN
FRONT.
BUT IMMIGRATION CONTINUES TO BE
SO COMPLEX MEMBERS IT IS
LITERALLY.
A LIFE AND DEATH DECISION.
LITERALLY A LIFE AND DEATH
DECISION.
SO WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE.
THAT WE PROTECT OUR COMMUNITY
AND THAT WE STEER THEM THE
DIRECTION WITH PEOPLE WHO
ACTUALLY KNOW THE LAW AND AGAIN
CAN ACTUALLY REPRESENT THEM.
NOT JUST FILL OUT DOCUMENTS AND
HOPE FOR THE BEST [inaudible]
AND ANOTHER ISSUE THAT CONTINUES
TO HAPPEN IS THAT.
THERE BE THE FOLKS ARE BEING A
COUNSELED TO FILL OUT THEIR OWN --
DEPORTATION DOCUMENTS THOUGHT TO
SELF DEPORT.
YOU KNOW WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN
THERE'S TONS OF CASES OF THIS
HAPPENING UP AND DOWN THE STATE.
SO AGAIN MEMBERS LOOK I
UNDERSTAND AND I'M NOT GONNA
JUDGE WHERE YOU FALL ON THIS.
BUT THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
CONVERSATION THAT NEEDS TO
HAPPEN AND I RESPECT.
MY GOOD FRIEND AND COLLEAGUE
SENATOR FROM SAN DIEGO OUR
CHAIRMAN OF THE LATINO CAUCUS
BUT THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
CONVERSATION THAT WE HAVE TO
HAVE.
NOW MORE THAN EVER.
DEWEY STEER FOLKS TO PEOPLE THAT
ACTUALLY HAVE THE EXPERIENCE AND
HAVE TE OPPORTUNITY TO BE ABLE
TO REPRESENT.
MANY OF THESE FAMILIES IN COURT
AND I THINK A. B. SIX THIRTY
EIGHT ENSURES THAT --
THAT PERSONS ANSWERING IMPORTANT
LEGAL QUESTIONS ARE ACTUALLY
AUTHORIZED TO PROVIDE LEGAL
ADVICE.
THIS IS LEGAL ADVICE MEMBERS.
APPARENTLY ONE ATTORNEY SHOULD
BE ABLE.
TO PROVIDE THAT THIS INFORMATION
THIS IS LEGAL ADVICE.
THIS IS NOT CONSULTATION.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT IS
IMPORTANT AND WE HAVE ATTORNEYS
AND LEGAL PROFESSIONALS
PROFESSIONAL STANDING BY TO
SERVE THIS COMMUNITY WE'VE
ACTUALLY INVESTED MONEY FROM OUR
OWN.
COFFERS. TO PROVIDE LEGAL
REPRESENTATION FOR CHILDREN THAT
HAVE COME HERE AS UNACCOMPANIED
MINORS WERE NOT SENDING THEM TO
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS WERE
SENDING THEM TO ATTORNEYS.
BECAUSE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY ACTUALLY HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO STAY IN THIS
COUNTRY.
AND YES WE HAVE TO INVEST MORE
MONEY WE HAVE TO INVEST MORE
MONEY IN EDUCATION WE HAVE TO
INVEST MORE OF OUR RESOURCES TO
HOW.
FOLKS BECOME CITIZENS AND
RESIDENTS BECAUSE GUESS WHAT THE
ONLY WAY.
AS AN IMMIGRANT YOU'RE GOING TO
PROTECT YOURSELF FROM THIS
CURRENT ADMINISTRATION IS THAT
BECOMING A U. S. CITIZEN.
AND THE ONLY WAY YOU DO THAT IS
WITH THE HELP OF ATTORNEYS.
AND THE HELP OF PARALEGALS AND
ORGANIZATIONS THAT ACTUALLY HOW
OF FOLKS.
HOW FOLKS ON STAFF IN UNDER
CONTRACT THAT ARE CAN BE HELD
LIABLE [inaudible]
IF THEY PURPOSELY.
MISREPRESENT THEMSELVES OR
PURPOSELY HARM A PERSON'S CASE
TO BECOME A CITIZEN.
THAT'S WHY THIS IS SO CRUCIAL
AND IMPORTANT.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THINK YOU CENTER LARA SENATOR
DELGADO.
MEMBERS THIS IS THE FIRST TIME
I'M ACTUALLY SPEAKING ON AN
ISSUE AND IT'S TRUE THIS IS THE
TOPIC OF BUT THE NO CAUCUS AND
IN A LOT OF WAYS.
BUT IT'S A A PEOPLE ISSUE AND
IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TO THE
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY --
MY GRANDFATHER IS EIGHTY SEVEN
YEARS OLD HE CAME HERE AS
ADDRESS AT ALL.
BUT CHOSE NOT TO BECOME A
CITIZEN.
AND A WITH THE CHANGE IN THE
ADMINISTRATION HE WAS SO SCARED
ABOUT THE POLICIES AND ALL OF
THE ISSUES.
THAT HE WANTED TO BECOME A
CITIZEN SO THAT TRUMP DIDN'T
KICK HIM OUT.
AND HE DID ON THE EVE OF HIS
EIGHTY SEVENTH BIRTHDAY HE
BECAME A CITIZEN AND BAKERSFIELD.
SO I UNDERSTAND THE FEAR.
THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE.
BUT THAT'S WHY I VISITED THE
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT OFFICE IN
MY DISTRICT I MET TWO OF THEM.
ONE OFFICE IT HELPED TWENTY TWO
THOUSAND PEOPLE.
OBTAIN DAUCUS STATUS OR JUST GET
HELP.
AND THAT'S CRITICAL.
IF WE IMPLEMENT THIS LAW --
AFFECT.
ONE THOUSAND BUSINESSES WILL BE
SHUT DOWN.
AND THAT'S NOT OKAY.
THE RIGHT THING TO DO HERE IS TO
IMPOSE STANDARDS. TO HAVE PEOPLE
GET LICENSES AND MAKE SURE THAT
THE SCOPE OF WORK UP THERE
PRACTICING IS NOT.
LEGAL WORK.
THAT'S THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
IF WE WANT TO HELP IMMIGRANTS.
IF OU WANT TO HELP PEOPLE LIKE
MY GRANDFATHER.
YOU NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT THERE
IS THIS LEVEL OF SERVICE
AVAILABLE TO THEM IN ADDITION TO
ATTORNEYS [inaudible]
THIS.
BILL THOUGH I HAVE SO MUCH
RESPECT FOR ITS AUTHOR.
IT'S NOT INTENDED.
TO I DON'T THINK IT WILL HELP
IMMIGRANTS.
BUT YOU SENATOR DELGADO.
SENATOR MITCHELL.
THE QUESTION OF THE FLOOR
MANAGER PLEASE CEREMONY WOULD
TAKE A QUESTION YES PLEASE
PROCEED --
EXIST.
IT BILL LISTENING TO OUR
COLLEAGUES ON THE FLOOR IF YOU
COULD WALK US THROUGH IF THIS
BILL WERE TO BECOME LAW WHAT
OPTIONS.
I WOULD HAVE IN GOING FORWARD IF
IF I IF IF THESE.
THOUSANDS OF BUSINESSES WERE TO
CLOSE ACROSS THE STATE WHAT
WOULD BE MY HALF WAY TO RECEIVE
THE KIND OF HELP THAT I I FEEL I
WOULD BE ENTITLED TO CENTER
MONNING THANK YOU I APPRECIATE
THE QUESTION BECAUSE THAT'S AT
THE CORE OF THE CONCERN FOR THE
LA BITING WELL.
INTENTIONED --
CONSULTANTS AND CONSULTANT
ORGANIZATIONS.
AS HAS BEEN POINTED OUT --
THERE'S A VAST RANGE OF
DIFFERENCE INCAPACITY SKILL
KNOWLEDGE IN WITH EVER CHANGING
TECHNICAL LAW THAT'S WHY.
IN THE BAR ATTORNEYS GET
SPECIALIZED CERTIFICATION AS
IMMIGRATION ATTORNEYS.
PEOPLE WORKING UNDER THEM ARE
SUBJECT TO THAT TRAINING AND
THAT ACCOUNTABILITY TO THE STATE
BAR INEPT CARRY MALPRACTICE
INSURANCE IF IF THROUGH THEIR
NEGLIGENCE.
THEY MISHANDLED PERSONS CLAIM
BUT BACKED YOUR QUESTION THE
PATHWAYS ARE SEVERAL.
A LARGE CONSULTING ORGANIZATION
LIKE THE ONE REFERENCE --
BY OUR SENATE COLLEAGUE A FROM
THE SOUTH.
THEY COULD APPLY FOR NONPROFIT
STATUS BECOME CERTIFIED.
AS THE NONPROFIT.
RECOGNIZED --
IMMIGRATION SERVICE THAT CAN
ONLY BE RECOGNIZED BY THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT FOR EXAMPLE.
NAM SO SUMMIT GOT AN ESTABLISHED
BUSINESS.
THERE'S NO REASON THEY CAN'T
INCORPORATED AS A NONPROFIT.
OR IS A FOR PROFIT ARM IN IN AND
SEEK THE FEDERAL [inaudible]
CERTIFICATION.
AN INDIVIDUAL OR GROUP OF
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE KNOWLEDGE
AND EXPERTISE ARE GONNA BE A
HIGH PREMIUM TO BE HIRED.
BY A LAW FIRM THAT'S DOING
IMMIGRATION LAW THEY CAN USE
MORE SKILLED.
MULTI LINGUAL A PARALEGALS THIS
COULD ACTUALLY BE AN ON RAMP. TO
A MORE SPECIALIZED A
PROFESSIONAL STATUS A WITH THE
SUPPORT AND RESOURCES.
OF ATTORNEYS WHO BOUND BY THE
LAW [inaudible]
STAY CURRENT IN THE EVER
CHANGING FIELD OF IMMIGRATION SO
THOSE ARE A COUPLE POSSIBILITIES
BECOME A NONPROFIT AND GET
CERTIFIED.
WORK AS A PARALEGAL OR SICK
CONSULTANT OF LEGAL AID WITHIN.
THE LEGAL ORGANIZATION.
IT'S DOING YOU ALSO GET YOURSELF
THE PROTECTION.
IF AN ERROR IS MADE TO HAVE THE
BACKUP.
OF AN ORGANIZATION THAT CARRIES
MALPRACTICE INSURANCE IN HAS
HIGHER UPS THAT WOULD BE
RESPONSIBLE.
IF I MAY FALL WITH ANOTHER
QUESTION WITHOUT OBJECTION IS
THERE ANY CONCERN ABOUT CAPACITY
ARE THERE CURRENTLY TODAY IF THE
BILL WERE TO BECOME LAW.
ANOTHER NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS
OUT WHERE --
SUPPLY WOULD MEET DEMAND IF YOU
WELL SO I KNOW THAT I HAVE THE
EXPERTISE ON THAT I DO KNOW THAT
WITH.
THE NEW ADMINISTRATION AND THE
INCREASED OUR ENFORCEMENT OF
IMMIGRATION LAWS AND RAPIDLY
CHANGING IMMIGRATION LAWS.
THERE IS INDEED A SHORTAGE OF OF
BAILABLE SKILLED ARM
REPRESENTATIVES THAT THERE IS A
PLACE FOR THOSE THAT HAVE THE
SKILL THE EXPERIENCE AND THE
KNOWLEDGE AND WANT TO BE PART OF
THE SOLUTION.
AGAIN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
ONLY RECOGNIZES PRACTITIONERS
THAT ARE FEDERALLY CERTIFIED SO
A CONSULTANT A MATTER HOW MANY
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE THEY HAVE.
THEIR WORK ADVISING ON FILLING
OUT OF FORMER FILLING OUT A FORM
IS NOT RECOGNIZED BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
SO THERE IS A NEED UNFORTUNATELY
APPEARS TO BE A GROWING NEED.
AND I THINK CREATIVE MINDS
BUSINESS MINDED FOLKS WILL
FIGURE OUT A WAY TO INCORPORATE
THOSE WHO HAVE A GOOD TRACK
RECORD.
WHO WANT TO SERVE PEOPLE IN WHO
AREN'T THERE TO EXPLOIT PEOPLE?
AND WE'VE HEARD SOME OF THE
STORIES.
MY WORK IN THE SALINAS VALLEY I
PRACTICE IMMIGRATION LAW.
IN THE EIGHTIES.
A FOUR YEAR HIATUS AND WORKED IN
EAST COAST WHEN I CAME BACK I
DIDN'T PICK UP DOING IMMIGRATION
LAW BECAUSE I HADN'T STAYED
CURRENT.
BUT THERE ARE PATHWAYS AND I
THINK.
SHOULD THIS BILL BECOME LAW.
YOU WILL SEE ADAPTATION WHERE
THE BEST AND THE BRIGHTEST THOSE
ORGANIZATIONS THAT ARE
ESTABLISHED AND PROVEN
THEMSELVES.
THEY WILL FIND A PLACE.
I APPRECIATE THAT JUST BRIEFLY
I'M I I KNOW OF SOME OF THE
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS THAT
REPRESENT LITTLE ETHIOPIA AND MY
DISTRICT HAS A LARGE.
AFRICAN IMMIGRANT --
COMMUNITY IN ITS MIDST REALLY
IMPORTANT --
THAT WE MAKE SURE THAT --
THE NONPROFIT SECTOR AS A STEP
IN ARE EQUIPPED UNABLE TO
PROVIDE ON SERVICES ARE.
ON THAT ARE CULTURALLY COMPETENT
TO THE VARIETY OF IMMIGRANTS
THAT WE ALL HAVE BEEN ACROSS THE
BOARD IN OUR COMMUNITIES FOR
THANK YOU FOR ALL THAT
CLARIFICATION APPRECIATED.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
SENATOR ROTH.
A QUESTION FOR THE OF FOR
MANAGER OF MADAME PRESIDENT
CENTER MONEY WE TAKE A QUESTION
YES IS A RECEIPT.
SO JUST TO FOLLOW UP ON THE
CAPACITY QUESTION YOU KNOW I
PRACTICE FOR IS.
YOU DID NOT IN THIS AREA BUT FOR
MANY MANY YEARS AND I HAD
OCCASION TO TRY TO RELY ON THE
SERVICES OF IMMIGRATION LAWYERS
IN THE EMPLOYMENT CONTEXT.
BOTH -- FOR
TAKING ATTEMPTING TO TAKE CARE
OF WORKERS WHO HAD DOCUMENTATION
PROBLEMS AND ALSO --
SOME RECRUITING OF WORKERS FROM
OUTSIDE OF THE COUNTRY TO COME
IN TO FILL PARTICULAR --
PARTICULAR POSITIONS ON CATIA
PROGRAM AT SOME OF THE OTHER
PROGRAMS THAT WERE CERTAINLY IN
EXISTENCE BACK.
IN THE OLD DAYS WHEN I PRACTICED
AND WHAT I REMEMBER FROM THOSE
DAYS WAS THAT THERE WAS A
SHORTAGE OF WHAT I WOULD CALL
QUALITY.
IMMIGRATION ATTORNEYS AND OR AN
OVERALL SHORTAGE OF IMMIGRATION
ATTORNEYS --
ACROSS THE BOARD CERTAINLY IN
INLAND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SO
AGAIN FOLLOWING UP ON THE
CAPACITY QUESTION I UNDERSTAND
THERE'S A DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION
HERE.
BUT HAS THERE BEEN ANY STUDY AND
IS THERE ANY PLAN WITH GOALS AND
OBJECTIVES IN TERMS OF OF
INCREASING THE SUPPLY.
OF TALENTED QUALIFIED CERTIFIED
IMMIGRATION ATTORNEYS AND AN
EQUALLY PARALEGALS BECAUSE IF
YOU'RE A PARALEGAL YOU JUST
DON'T FLIP A SWITCH AND BECOME.
ONE THERE'S TYPICALLY A COURSE
OF STUDY AND I WOULD IMAGINE AS
COMPLICATED AS THIS SYRIA IS IT
IS EVEN MORE.
A DIFFICULT AND ARDUOUS TO
ATTAIN PARA LEGAL STATUS HERE.
SO MY QUESTION AGAIN IS A
CAPACITY ONE AND AND HAS THERE
BEEN A PLAN OR ARE WE SIMPLY
FLIPPING OFF THE SWITCH.
AND HOPING THAT THE ENVIRONMENT
CATCHES UP TO THE NEW RULES OF
THE GAME AND THEN WHAT HAPPENS
TO ALL THE PEOPLE WHO GET
DROPPED THROUGH THE CRACKS.
WELL THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THE
QUESTION.
APPRECIATE YOUR THOUGHTFULNESS
ON THIS.
THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE.
FIRST I DON'T KNOW THAT I HAVE
AN ANSWER BUT MAYBE I CAN HAVE A
BUY MY CLOTHES ABOUT ANY
STRATEGIC PLANNING --
AS YOU MENTIONED KNOW THERE'S A
DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS
BY ONE YEAR SO THERE'S A ONE
YEAR RAMP UP TIME FOR THIS
ADAPTATION IF YOU WILL.
I ALSO KNOW THAT WE'VE SEEN AN
INCREASE PARTICULARLY COMMUNITY
BASED LAW SCHOOLS A PEOPLE FROM.
A DIVERSE COMMUNITIES NOT JUST
SPANISH SPEAKING BUT OTHER
DIVERSE COMMUNITIES WHO HAD
ACCESS TO LEGAL EDUCATION
BECAUSE OF COMMUNITY BASED NIGHT
SCHOOLS ACCREDITED LAW SCHOOLS.
BUT IN RURAL AREAS OF CALIFORNIA
THEY ARE PROVIDING.
APPLY OF NEW YOUNG ATTORNEYS
MANY OF WHOM ARE COMMITTED --
TO SERVING THE COMMUNITIES THAT
THEY'VE COME FROM.
I THINK WE ALSO SEE A A NUMBER
OF NON PROFITS IF MEMBERS IF YOU
JUST LOOK AT THE ANALYSIS THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS ON THIS BILL
IF YOU LOOK AT THE SUPPORTING
ORGANIZATIONS.
THERE IS A BROAD SWATH.
QUALIFIED NONPROFIT SOME OF WHOM
ARE RECEIVING STATE RESOURCES TO
PROVIDE SUPERVISED QUALITY
SERVICES TO THE IMMIGRANT
COMMUNITY.
AND AGAIN THE SPECTRUM OF
IMMIGRANT NEEDS.
WE SEE HIGH PROFILE ABOUT
POLITICAL ASYLUM IN PEOPLE WHO
ARE VICTIMS OF VIOLENCE OR
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE IN THEIR HOME
COUNTRY.
BUT THERE THERE'S A PLETHORA OF
IMMIGRATION ISSUES FROM --
A FAMILY MEMBER ADJUSTING STATUS
THROUGH A US CITIZEN CHILD.
OR SPOUSE THAT'S A WHOLE
SPECIALIZED AREA OF IMMIGRATION
LAW TO POLITICAL ASYLUM TO
WORKERS STATUS AND WORK PERMITS
IN BEING ABLE TO WORK HERE
LEGALLY WHILE IN IMMIGRATION
CASE.
IS PENDING AND REPORTING INCOME
ETCETERA.
SKILLED IMMIGRATION LAWYERS DO
THIS NOT.
CIVIL ATTORNEYS WHO HAVE A
GENERAL PRACTICE BUT YOU WILL
FIND IN THE IMMIGRATION WORLD.
THOSE PRACTICING.
THEY'RE DOING EXCLUSIVELY
IMMIGRATION WORK AND THEY HAVE
THE SUPPORT.
OF CONTINUING EDUCATION ARE THAT
THEY HAVE TO TAKE TO MAINTAIN
THEIR LONG LICENSE FOR THAT
THEIR CURRENT WITH THESE EVER
CHANGES IN THE LAW.
SO MAYBE MY CLOTHES ALL ADDRESS
THE OTHER PART OF YOUR QUESTION
BUT THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONNING
THUNDERSTONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THEM
AND COLLEAGUES.
I HAVE A A LARGE IMMIGRANT
POPULATION IN IN MY DISTRICT IN
PARTICULAR IN THE IN THE
COACHELLA VALLEY [inaudible]
THAT -- HAVE
BEEN.
EXTREMELY A FRIGHTENING TO OVER
THE PAST FEW YEARS --
ABOUT THEIR THEIR STATUS ABOUT
BEING DEPORTED.
THAT ARE REALLY --
SOME OF THE HARDEST WORKING
HUMAN BEINGS THAT I'VE EVER SEEN
THAT --
DON'T MAKE A LOT OF MONEY.
OUR LOOKING FOR ASSISTANCE AND
NOT. ONE OF THE BEAUTIFUL THINGS
ABOUT THE COACHELLA VALLEY THAT
I REPRESENT PROBABLY --
CITIES LIKE RANCHO MIRAGE IN
PALM DESERT IN COACHELLA
[inaudible]
BLYTH.
IS THAT MANY THE NONPROFITS HAVE
STEPPED UP.
AND MANY OF THESE CONSULTANTS
HAVE STEPPED UP. TO HELP THIS
VULNERABLE POPULATION.
THAT DON'T HAVE THE FINANCIAL
RESOURCES. TO ENGAGE IN ATTORNEY.
HA OR TO ENGAGE IN SOME OF THESE
MORE EXPENSIVE SERVICES SO THEY
CAN BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT THEIR
OPTIONS ARE.
AND I WANT OUR STRONGLY --
COMMAND --
MY COLLEAGUE OF FROM CURRENT
COUNTY. FOR TWO REASONS.
THE FIRST REASON IS OVER THE
PAST FOUR YEARS I THOUGHT I GIVE
THE LONGEST FLOOR SPEECH ON THE
SENATE FLOOR.
BUT I HAVE NOW BEEN SURPASSED MY
MY WONDERFUL COLLEAGUE FROM
IMPERIAL COUNTY.
BUT NOT ONLY WAS HIS SPEECH LONG
I FELT IT WAS VERY ARTICULATE.
I THOUGHT IT WAS VERY PASSIONATE
THEN I'LL BE HONESTLY I CAME ON
THE FLOOR NOT REALLY KNOWING HOW
IT'S GOING TO VOTE ON THIS ISSUE
AND ALSO.
WANT TO COMMEND OUR NEW A
SENATOR FOR STANDING UP AND VERY
ARTICULATE AND HER VIEWS
ENSURING.
HOW THE PLIGHT OF HER HER
GRANDFATHER --
YOU KNOW.
IN EVERY PROFESSION.
WE SEE SNAKE OIL SALES PEOPLE
THAT TAKE ADVANTAGE OF PEOPLE IS
REALLY UNFORTUNATE AND WE NEED
TO DO THE BEST WE CAN. TO ENSURE
THAT ALL OF OUR CITIZENS ARE NOT
RIPPED OFF ESPECIALLY OUR
ELDERLY CITIZENS.
OUR DISABLED CITIZENS.
AND ARE IMMIGRANT CITIZENS.
AN I THINK THAT BY PASSING THIS
BILL TODAY.
WE ARE GOING TO BE TAKING
OPTIONS OFF THE TABLE FOR THEM
SOME OF THE AFFORDABLE OPTIONS
THAT THEY HAVE NO ALTERNATIVE.
OTHERWISE IF THEY DON'T SEE
THESE OPTIONS.
WHAT MANY HAVE DONE IN THE
COACHELLA VALLEY?
IS THEY'VE PICKED THEIR FAMILIES
UP.
AND ON THEIR OWN THE THEM MOVED
BACK TO MEXICO.
OR MANY OF THEM OF MOUSA MESA
ARIZONA AND ENGAGED IN.
AGRICULTURAL JOBS THERE WITHOUT
THE THREATS THAT THEY FEEL HERE.
IN IN CALIFORNIA [inaudible]
AND AS A RESULT.
ARE EGG COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT
MY DISTRICT INCLUDING THE
SOUTHWESTERN PART WHERE WE HAVE
A LOT OF WINERIES.
THERE'S NOT ENOUGH PEOPLE TO
PICK THE FRUIT.
WE'RE PICKING WINE GRAPES RIGHT
NOW THERE'S NOT ENOUGH PEOPLE TO
PICK THE GRAPES.
SO MAYBE WE MAY END UP A LOT OF
PORT INTO MACULAR THIS YEAR.
BECAUSE GREAT SERVER BE SET ON
THE MINDS LONGER THAN THEY
SHOULD.
GATHERING SUGARS AND THERE'S NOT
A WHOLE LOT MORE YOU CAN DO WITH
THOSE CRATES OF THAN MAKE SWEET
WINES WITHOUT.
THIS IS A HUMANITARIAN ISSUE.
WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT JUST DON'T
DO THIS FOR A LIVING THESE ARE
PEOPLE THAT DO IT A PASSION IT'S
A HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION.
THAT WE ARE TRYING.
TO DECIMATE WITH THIS BILL ALL
THESE NONPROFIT CENTER IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL ARE STILL
GOING TO BE THERE WHETHER WE
PASS THIS BILL WE DON'T.
I THINK AS WE MOVE FORWARD INTO
THE NEW YAR AND I HOPE TO SEE
MANY OF YOU BACK HERE --
IN THE NEXT SESSION IS THAT WE
WORK TO REFINE THE CREDENTIALS
OF THOSE THAT ARE GIVING NO
SERVICES SO THAT SOMEBODY HAS
THE FAITH TO KNOW THOUGH MOMMY
GETTING ADVICE THAT THEY'RE
GETTING ARE FROM A A BONAFIDE
PERSON THAT IS LICENSED AND HELD
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR FOR THEIR
ADVICE.
AND CERTAINLY MANY OF THEM ARE
GOING TO NEED TO HAVE SERVICES
BUT THERE ARE MANY SERVICES THAT
THEY CAN OBTAIN --
WITHOUT --
LEGAL SERVICES IN THEIR
INITIATION TO FIND OUT WHERE
THEY STAND AND HOW THEY CAN STAY
IN HOW THEY CAN WORK AND HOW
THEY CAN SUPPORT THEIR FAMILIES.
SO FOR THOSE REASONS MY FRIENDS
LET'S NOT THROW THE BABY OUT
WITH THE BATH WATER LET'S REFINE
THE SYSTEMS IN PLACE TODAY AND
LET'S GET THOSE PROFESSIONALS
THE TOOLS THAT THEY NEED.
PROTECT OUR IMMIGRANT
COMMUNITIES EVERY THOUGHT TO TO
UNDERSTAND WHAT THEIR RIGHTS ARE
AND TO ALLOW THEM TO CONTINUE.
OUGHT TO WORK IN OUR BEAUTIFUL
STATE I URGE A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THEM CEREMONY
MAKE CLOTHES FOLKS USE ME
SENATOR DALY ON BIGGER MUCH OF
MADAME PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES
[inaudible]
A WHEN RISE IN SHARE A FEW
PERSPECTIVES I THINK IT'S BEEN A
VERY INTRIGUING DEBATE ON ON
BOTH SIDES --
FOR DISCLOSURE PURPOSES. FOR
DISCLOSURE PURPOSES.
I HAVE FRIENDS ON BOTH SIDES.
OF THIS ARGUMENT.
I HAVE FRIENDS ON BOTH SIDES OF
THIS ARGUMENT AND YOU'VE HEARD
MY STORY AT BAD NAUSEAM WITH
REGARDS TO MY ORGANIZING DAYS
AND MY DAYS HELPING IMMIGRANTS
SPECIFICALLY UNDOCUMENTED
IMMIGRANTS WERE I ACTUALLY CUT
MY TEETH POLITICALLY.
DOING THIS WORK.
FEELING I WHEN THIRTIES FOR
LEGAL PERMANENT RESIDENCY I NINE
THESE.
AND FOUR HUNDRED SWITCHES.
NATURALIZER IS CONVERTS YOU FROM
A LEGAL PERMANENT RESIDENT
UNITED STATES AMERICA.
KNOWN AS A GREEN CARD.
A TO NATURALIZED UNITED STATES
CITIZEN THEN FOUR HUNDRED SUB
DUNLOP THIS WORK.
BY MYSELF AND PROBABLY LEGALIZED --
EASILY.
TENS OF THOUSANDS OF INDIVIDUALS
WHO VENTURE BECAME LEGAL PERMIT
RA A NOT LEGAL FROM RESIDENTS
BUT U. S..
NATURALIZED CITIZENS.
AND I PLOY HAD DONE TENS OF
THOUSANDS OF THOSE INDIVIDUAL
STUDENT.
EVENTUALLY VOTER REGISTRATION
AND THEN BECOMING VOTERS.
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT ISSUE MS NO
QUESTION ABOUT IT.
THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT ISSUE
AND THIS IS A GOOD TO HAVE THIS
DEBATE.
I HAVE ABOUT FRIENDS BUDGETS
OUTSIDE OF THIS BUILDING ON
OPPOSITE SIDES.
MYERS WE HAVE FRIENDS.
UNDER THIS CAPITOL DOME.
ON THIS.
RED CARPET ON OPPOSITE SIDES
FRIENDS WHO I BOTH RESPECT
ADMIRE.
AND SUPPORT NO VERY MUCH SO --
BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT.
WELL WE HAVE [inaudible]
BAD TEACHERS.
WE DON'T ELIMINATE THE TEACHING
PROFESSION.
BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT WHEN WE
HAVE BAD ENGINEERS.
WE DON'T ELIMINATES THE WHOLE
ENGINEERING PROFESSION
[inaudible]
HOLD FAILED.
ELIMINATE ALL TOGETHER.
I DO YOU KNOW BECAUSE IT IS
ACCURATE.
BUT WE HAVE HAD AGREED JUST
CASES THAN A GOOD SENATOR FROM
LONG BEACH ARTICULATED A HANDFUL
OF THOSE CASES THAT WITHOUT
QUESTION.
OR REAL HAVE HAD IMPACTED HUMAN
LIVES.
BUT THE REAL CASES.
BUT I ALSO TO WE HAVE THOSE
CASES IF YOU'RE A MEDICAL DOCTOR.
AND YOU DON'T ELIMINATE THE
MEDICAL PROFESSION [inaudible]
OR DENTISTRY.
OR CERTIFIABLE PUBLIC
ACCOUNTANTS AND SO FORTH.
THAT'S NOT WHAT WE DON'T THAT'S
NOT WHAT WE DO HERE.
AND ON THE ISSUE OF SUPPLY.
I WISH THAT.
AND I KNOW THE THE GOOD CENTER
FROM RIVERSIDE AND ASK THE
QUESTION.
AND I KNOW MY VERY GOOD FRIEND --
SOME WHITE MEYER GREATLY OUR
MAJORITY LEADER WILL ADDRESS IT.
I WILL GIVE YOU SUPPLY ISSUE
ARGUING RIGHT NOW.
THERE IS NO SUPPLY.
BECAUSE THE NUMBER OF APPLICANTS
FOR LAW SCHOOLS TODAY HAS
PLUMMETED.
THERE WERE LESS PEOPLE GOING TO
LAW SCHOOL.
IN CALIFORNIA AND THROUGHOUT THE
NATION.
SO YOU WANT TO WHAT YOU SUPPLY.
THERE IS NO SUPPLY THERE IS NO
STREAM OF INDIVIDUALS.
SO IF YOU WANNA GET TO
IMMIGRATION LAW SPECIFICALLY
[inaudible]
LITIGATION.
CORPORATE LAW CRIMINAL DEFENSE.
IMMIGRATION LAW [inaudible]
THAT NUMBER.
SHRIEKS EVEN MORE SO.
SO DON'T KNOW FREEFLOW SUPPLY
HAVE BEEN INDIVIDUALS ON THE
CAPACITY ISSUE AS IT RELATES TO
THE SUPPLY ISSUE.
IT DOESN'T EXIST.
LET'S NOT CREATE SOMETHING.
BUT DOESN'T EXIST [inaudible]
NOW.
ON THIS ISSUE I WISH WE COULD
HAVE AND I WILL BE HERE BUT
PERHAPS AND I WON'T KNOW WHAT
THE FATE WILL BE AT THE BILL AT
THE MOVES ON FORTY MOVES FORWARD.
IF IT DOESN'T IT STAYS THE ISSUE
SHOULD REMAIN --
ALIVE WITH REGARDS TO SHOULD WE
HAVE CREATED A REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK.
SHOULD WE HAVE STATED.
MAYBE THERE'S CERTAIN TYPES OF
APPLICATIONS.
IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS SHOULD
NOT [inaudible]
FILL OUT.
AND OTHERS THEY SHOULD.
BUT I'M NOT SURE IF THERE WERE
NEGOTIATIONS ARE ALL
CONVERSATION NO WE TRIED I KNOW
THAT.
THE SENATOR CHAIR OF
APPROPRIATIONS AND I IN GOOD
FAITH ACTUALLY ON THE SAME SIDE
WE TRIED TOGETHER TO TOOTSIE WE
COULD FIGURE IT OUT --
BUTTON FOR CHILI AND THAT'S YOU
ALL KNOW BECAUSE THE ROLE
RESPONSIBILITIES THE PRO TEN
SHIP IN EVERYTHING CRASH ON
ONE'S SHOULDERS.
WE HAD TO FOCUS ON SOME OTHER
ISSUES SUCH AS THE BUDGET AND
SOME OTHER* TO DEAL WITH
[inaudible]
BUT THIS WAS OR I SORTA KINDA
CUT MY TEETH POLITICALLY.
AND IF WE HAD CONVERSATIONS ON
FEE SCALES.
A SORT OF THE PARAMETERS OF WHAT
YOU CAN AND CHARGE.
FEELING IN THE FLOOR.
CERTAIN TYPES OF APPLICATIONS.
BUT PERHAPS WILL PREJUDICE WINDS --
APPLICATION IN THE IMMIGRATION
PROCESS.
I'M NOT SURE BY I DON'T KNOW IF
WE HAD THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
BUT WE SHOULD HAVE THOSE
CONVERSATIONS KNOW SHOULD HAVE
CREATED MORE SO EVERITT TOWARD
FRAMEWORK.
AS OPPOSED TO TAKING A VOTE TO
ELIMINATE.
ALL OF THESE POSITIONS.
WHICH QUITE FRANKLY.
THEY WERE TO DO THAT.
THE NUMBER OF LAWYERS OR
PARALEGALS DO NOT EXIST ON THE
CAPACITY ISSUE.
IT'S NONSENSICAL THE MAKE UP IN
THE NUMBERS.
BECAUSE THE NUMBERS OR THE
NUMBERS.
SO WHAT WE ONE ULTIMATELY IS TO
PROVIDE.
GOOD QUALITY WORK.
THE HARD WORKING PEOPLE WHO
ASPIRED TO BECOME LEGAL PER
RESIDENTS.
RENEW THEIR GREEN CARDS.
BECOME.
UNITED STATES CITIZENS AND IT IS
CORRECT.
THAT THESE ARE VERY DIFFICULT
TIMES.
WITH THE CURRENT ADMINISTRATION
WITH THEIR VIEWPOINTS A
PERSPECTIVES ON THE ISSUE OF
IMMIGRANTS LEGAL OR NOT FLY
CITIZENS.
AND ANY MISTAKES WITH ITS A
COLIN WAT THE SEMI COLON.
THAT'S OUT OF PLACE.
WITH A HIGHLY SUBJECTIVE
ADMINISTRATION.
IT MAKES THE STAKES HIGHER NO
QUESTION ABOUT IT.
BUT TO SOME MEDICINE STONE
CHORDIFY STATUTORILY.
POSTED TWENTY TWENTY
ADMINISTRATION WE DON'T KNOW
WHAT THE RESULTS WILL BE.
WILL ELIMINATE AGAIN
[inaudible]
THE WHOLE.
GROUP OF INDIVIDUALS.
THAT OTHERWISE THAT I KNOW DO
HARD.
WORK DO GOOD WORK BECAUSE I KNOW
A LOT OF THESE CONSULTANTS
MYSELF.
TO AND I KNOW THE LOT OF THEM
ARE HARD WORKING.
PROFESSIONALS WHO DEDICATED IN
PROVIDING QUALITY SERVICES.
AT A LO FI COSTS TO THEIR
CONSTITUENTS WHO OTHERWISE WOULD
NOT BE ABLE TO AFFORD THE PRICES
THAT A LAWYER CHARGES.
LET'S BE HONESTIF YOU GO TO LAW
SCHOOL HAVE A HANDFUL OF LAWYERS
HERE.
SOME VERY SUCCESSFUL THE PRIVATE
SECTOR SOME DIDN'T SUCCEED WELL
THEY BECAME POLITICIANS.
AND HE CAN SENATORS.
YOU'RE.
WE ARE NOW OF COURSE.
EVERYONE OF OUR SUCCESSFUL AND
SWEET.
EVERYONE OF OUR SUCCESSFUL AND
THE NOW LAS APPOINTING A BILL TO
HAVE A PERFECT PICTURE.
COULD YOU EVER GALA.
YOU DON'T NEED AN IMMIGRATION
ATTORNEY.
ON EVERY SINGLE TYPE OF
APPLICATION.
YOU JUST DON'T.
EN MY GOOD FRIEND.
FROM LONG BEACH IS IS RIGHT.
THE STAKES ARE HIGH.
WE GOTTA BE DONE CORRECTLY.
AND WE ALL AGREE THAT.
BUT I DON'T THINK THAT THE LIMON
DATING AND SAYING ONLY EXCLUSIVE
LAWYERS.
WHAT THE BAD WITH THAT CURRENTLY
EXIST?
WHICH THAT MA'AM WHAT'S SIMPLY
IS NOT THERE.
THE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCE WILL
BE HUGE.
AND HOW THESE INDIVIDUALS WILL
BE BE ABLE THE PART TO BE IN THE
SYSTEM --
LASTLY LET ME JUST SAY.
IS.
GOOD ISSUE TO BE DISCUSSED
FRIENDS ON BOTH SIDES.
IT'S MY HOPE THAT PERHAPS.
ALL OF YOU.
WILL BE ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD
WITH THIS ISSUE.
IN THE SUBSEQUENT YEAR AND GET
IT RIGHT.
AND SET THE FRAMEWORK OF DIRECT
REGULATORY FRAME FOR BOTH SIDES
TO BE HERE FOR OUR FRIEND FROM
THE ASSEMBLY.
PAID IS IS IS A SUCCESSFUL WHICH
IS OUR HOPE SHE IS AND SHE LANDS
ON THIS RED CARPET.
SHE A BILL THE WORK WITH OUR
COLLEAGUE FROM SAN DIEGO AND OUR
FUTURE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER ON
BOND ISSUES SO WE CAN FIND SOME
COMMON GROUND AND MOVE THIS
ISSUE TOGETHER SO WITH THAT.
MADAM PRESIDENT AND COLLEAGUES
[inaudible]
BY.
NOT GOING TO SIT BE SUPPORTING
THIS BILL.
BUT I ASK YOU TAKE EVERYTHING
INTO CONSIDERATION EL AND ALSO.
TO THE UNITED FARM WORKERS.
NOT LONG AFTERWARDS.
THE COMPASS INNOCENT LOOK BUT
DIVA CAMPESINA WHICH REPRESENTS
FARMWORKERS ARE NOW POSITIONED
HIS BILL BUT BETTER YET WHATEVER
THE RESULTS ARE FOR THIS MEASURE.
WHEN WERE DONE ON THIS BILL?
ON THE VOTES.
WE HAVE BY LET US.
MAY HE GUIDE US.
EMILY MONNING THE SUN THE YEAH.
THE FACADE STRIVE VERY BUT LET
US RIGHT OUTSIDE THE HALLWAY FOR
EVERYONE --
COME GET SOME FUN LET THE SOUTH
TOWARDS THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT.
THANK YOU SENATOR DALY OWN
MISTER ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE THING NONE CEREMONY
PLEASE CLOSE WELL THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT.
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES --
NOT ONLY THOSE WHO PARTICIPATED
BUT THOSE WHO BEEN PATIENT AND
LISTENING TO THESE.
VARIOUS POINTS I WOULD URGE YOU
NOT TO GO FOR THE POLITE THIS
INTEL WE VOTE ON THIS MATTER --
I DO WANT TO JUST COME OUT A
COUPLE THINGS I HAVE THE UTMOST
RESPECT FOR THE CHAIR OF THE
LATINO CAUCUS.
OUR PRO TEM EMERITUS.
OUR SHORT SERVING BUT HIGHLY
RESPECTED.
COLLEAGUE FROM THE SOUTH
[inaudible]
A THIS IS A CONVERSATION AMONG
FRIENDS AND FAMILY WE SHARE ONE
THING WE WANT THE BEST. FOR THE
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITY WE DIFFER ON
WHAT AT THIS POINT IN TIME IN US
HISTORY.
IS GOING TO GUARANTEE THE BEST
SERVICE POSSIBLE FOR PERHAPS THE
MOST SUSCEPTIBLE INVULNERABLE
COMMUNITY.
IMMIGRANTS WHO LIVE ON COMMON
EQUAL DOSES OF FEAR AND HOPE.
FEAR OF SEPARATION FROM THEIR
FAMILY.
HOPE FOR A FUTURE FOR THEIR
CHILDREN.
AND THEIR FAMILIES.
YOU COMBINE FEAR AND HOPE AND
YOU ADD TO THAT RECIPE.
A CONSULTANT WHO OFFERS.
A PLATE OF THE HOPE.
AND EXPLOIT THE FEAR.
AND FOR A FEE OF A THOUSAND
DOLLARS OR FIFTEEN HUNDRED OR
TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR
PEOPLE THAT ARE WORKING AT
MINIMUM WAGE OR OFTEN LESS
BECAUSE THEY'RE WORKING IN AN
UNDERGROUND ECONOMY.
BEING PAID IN CASH.
WITH NO HEALTH INSURANCE NO
WORKERS COMP COVERAGE IN
FAMILIES I'VE SEEN IT IN MY WORK
IN THE SALINAS VALLEY FAMILIES
PULL TOGETHER IN THE TAP ON
UNCLES AND AUNTS AND COUSINS.
A POOL THOSE RESOURCES TO PUT UP
THAT THOUSAND DOLLARS THAT
FIFTEEN HUNDRED DOLLARS.
WE WANT AFFORDABLE OPTIONS YES.
BUT AND AFFORDABLE OPTION IS NOT
A GOOD OPTION IF IT'S A BAD
OPTION IF IT'S SOMEBODY WHO'S
MORE INTERESTED IN TAKING YOUR
MONEY.
THEN HAVING THE ABILITY TO
NAVIGATE A VERY COMPLEX LEGAL
SYSTEM AND THROUGH THEIR
MALPRACTICE THEIR NEGLIGENCE
THEIR LACK OF KNOWLEDGE.
THEY GET YOU.
MORE QUICKLY ON THAT PLANE OR
ARRESTED OR DETAINED OR
INCARCERATED BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T
FILL OUT THE FORMS RIGHT.
OR THEY DIDN'T EVEN SHOW UP TO
FILE THE FORMS EVEN THOUGH THEY
TOLD YOU THEY DID AND THEY ASK
YOU FOR THE NEXT PAYMENT AND THE
NEXT PAYMENT IN THE NEXT PAYMENT.
WE'VE SEEN THOSE EXAMPLES SO AN
AFFORDABLE OPTION IS NOT ALWAYS
A GOOD OPTION.
KEEPING PEOPLE IN BUSINESS WHO
AREN'T DOING WHAT'S IN THE BEST
INTEREST.
OF WERE SUSCEPTIBLE VULNERABLE
IN A IMMIGRANT IS NOT WHAT WE
WANT.
FRIENDS NOT ALL OF THESE
CONSULTANTS ARE GUIDED BY
HUMANITARIAN BELIEFS AND
ASPIRATIONS.
WE HEARD AN ANALOGY [inaudible]
TO WE WOULDN'T GET RID OF
TEACHERS IF THERE'S SOME BAD
TEACHERS WE WOULDN'T GET RID OF
ARCHITECTS IF THERE'S SOME BAD
ARCHITECTS.
PRINCE TEACHERS ARE CREDENTIALED
ARCHITECTS ARE CREDENTIALED.
THE COMPARISON WOULD BE THE
UNDERGROUND ECONOMY CARPENTER
WHO DOESN'T GET THE BUILDING
PERMITS AND WHO WIRES A HOUSE
IMPROPERLY THAT LEADS TO A FIRE.
IN A CONFLAGRATION THAT MAYBE
KILLS AN IMMIGRANT FAMILY
[inaudible]
THIS BILL.
TALKS ABOUT A CLASS OF PEOPLE.
WHO ARE NOT RECOGNIZED BY THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO OFFER
IMMIGRATION ADVICE?
ARE FEDERAL IN THE GOVERNMENT
THE IMMIGRATION AND
NATURALIZATION SERVICE DOES NOT
RECOGNIZE IMMIGRATION
CONSULTANTS AS PROVIDING EITHER
GOOD ADVICE.
OR RECOGNIZE TO REPRESENT.
ON REPRESENTED IMMIGRANTS IN OUR
IMMIGRATION COURTS.
THE PATHWAY IN MY RESPONSE TO
THE CHAIR OF OUR BUDGET
COMMITTEE THERE ARE MANY
PATHWAYS.
ARE THEY ALL WORKED OUT NO
[inaudible]
BUT CONSULTANTS.
LIKE OTHERS IN OUR BUSINESS
COMMUNITY ARE INNOVATIVE.
THEIR BUSINESS PEOPLE THEY DO
HAVE OPTIONS GET YOUR OWN
NONPROFIT STATUS.
AFFILIATE WITH THE LAW FIRM AND
OFFER YOUR MULTI LINGUAL
SERVICES YOUR KNOWLEDGE YOUR
COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS AND
STRENGTHEN THAT LAW FIRM WITH
YOUR KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERTISE.
THESE PEOPLE WILL BE AT A
PREMIUM.
AND WE DO HAVE.
BUILDING CAPACITY AMONG
ESTABLISHED ORGANIZATIONS
RECOGNIZED BY THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
THIS BILL IS SUPPORTED BY THE
CRUZ REYNOSO BAR ASSOCIATION THE
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION THE
CENTRAL AMERICAN RESOURCE CENTER
OF CALIFORNIA.
ARE ATTORNEY GENERAL I COULD
READ ON A NONE WHAT DO ALL OF
THESE ORGANIZATION SHARE IN
COMMON.
EXPERTISE AND EXPERIENCE IN
IMMIGRATION LAW THE PROTECTION
OF IMMIGRANTS AND CONCERN AND
VIGILANCE. FOR THOSE THAT ARE
BEING EXPLOITED [inaudible]
MISREPRESENTED.
HAVING THEIR MONEY TAKEN.
AND YES OFTEN ENDING UP.
BEING DEPORTED WHEN THEY MIGHT
HAVE HAD A STRONG CASE FOR JUST
ONE OF STATUS.
MEMBERS AGAIN THANK YOU FOR YOUR
PATIENCE WE SHARE A COMMON
CONCERN. FOR THE IMMIGRANT
COMMUNITY FOR THE WORKING
COMMUNITY.
I URGE HERE I VOTE I WANNA THANK.
THE AUTHOR OF THIS BILL MY GOOD
FRIEND THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FROM
SALINAS AYE URGING AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONEY MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
NO DOT [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
NO GLAZER [inaudible]
NO HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
NO HERTZBERG [inaudible]
HILL [inaudible]
NO HUESO [inaudible]
NO JACKSON [inaudible]
I LOTTE [inaudible]
I'M REQUIRE [inaudible]
MITCHELL.
BY MONEY AND BUY MORE LOCK
[inaudible]
NO MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN.
NO NO SAN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN [inaudible]
STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT [inaudible]
WHAT COUNTY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
WILK [inaudible]
NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS THE
NEXT FIVE ITEMS THAT WE ARE
GOING TO OUR FILE ITEM. ONE
TWENTY FOUR ONE THIRTY THREE ONE
THIRTY FOUR ONE THIRTY SEVEN AND
ONE THIRTY EIGHT WE WILL START
WITH FILE ITEM.
ONE TWENTY FOUR SENATOR MCGUIRE.
PASS ON FILE.
FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY THREE
SENATOR HERTZBERG. ONE THIRTY
THREE MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY FIVE A
ONE BY SME MEMBER TO ENACT
RELATING TO DRINKING WATER
[inaudible]
CENTER HERTZBERG.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF MADAM
PRESIDENT THIS MEASURE WILL
IMPROVE THE TOOLS.
THE STATE WATER RESOURCES
CONTROL BOARD CAN UTILIZE TO
SECURE SAFE DRINKING WATER.
IN DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES
SPECIFICALLY THROUGH
CONSOLIDATION APPOINTMENT OF
ADMINISTRATOR WE SEEN THIS IN A
BILL THAT I CARRIED WITH RESPECT
THE SEWERS AND SEPTIC TANKS IN
THE OTHER HOUSE.
WE SOUGHT WITH RESPECT TO SOME
OTHER LEGISLATION WE ARE WORKING
LIKE CRAZY TO AVOID WHAT WE HAVE
SEEN.
IN FLINT MICHIGAN WHERE AND
OTHER MEMBERS ON THIS FLOOR
DOING THINGS IN OTHER CONTEXTS
TO MAKE SURE THEY'RE SAFE.
AND CLEAN DRINKING WATER FOR
EVERYONE IN CALIFORNIA CURRENT
LAW BRIEFLY MADAM PRESIDENT
ALREADY ALLOWS THE WATER BOARD
TO REQUIRE CONSOLIDATION
EXTENSION OF SERVICES TO WATER
SYSTEMS.
THEY'RE STRUGGLING TO PROVIDE
THIS VERY IMPORTANT CLEAN
DRINKING WATER.
THE CURRENT LAW ALLOWS THE BOARD
TWO APPOINTED ADMINISTRATOR TO
MANAGE OPERATE.
BUT FAILING WATER SYSTEM THIS
BILL STRENGTHENS THOSE TOOLS
JUST BRIEFLY BY EXPANDING THE
BOARD'S AUTHORITY TO USE IN
CONSOLIDATION ADMINISTRATION
AUTHORITY. TO SERVE DOMESTIC
WELLS AND REALLY SMALL WATER
SYSTEMS AND LOCAL EDUCATIONAL
AGENCIES ARE OFTEN OVERLOOKED.
BUT ARE THE MOST VULNERABLE I
ASK YOU BOARD MEASURE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES.
THE WORK BATES NO [inaudible]
WELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
DODD I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG --
HIGH HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
JACKSON [inaudible]
ISLETA.
HI AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
BY MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY [inaudible]
MURDOCH [inaudible]
NO MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
BY STERN AYE STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT NO I COUNTY
[inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
WILK [inaudible]
NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM OF ONE THIRTY FOUR I
THOUGHT IT BEEN ALLEN --
SENATOR LARA FIND [inaudible]
ONE THIRTY FOUR SKIP MOMENTARILY.
WE ARE GOING TO MOVE TO FILE
ITEM.
ONE THIRTY SEVEN SENATOR GAINES
FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY SEVEN NOT
AT HIS DESK.
FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY EIGHT
SENATOR JACKSON MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
THE SUMMER CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TWO EIGHTY FOUR BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER THURMAN RELATIVE
TO COURT ADOPTION AND PERMANENCY
MONTH.
SENATE JACKSON THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I AM
PLEASED TO PRESENT ACR TWO
EIGHTY FOUR WHICH DESIGNATES
NOVEMBER TWENTY EIGHTEEN AS CORD
ADOPTION.
AND PERMANENCY MONTH CONSISTENT
WITH ITS COMMITMENT TO SUPPORT
PRACTICES AND PROCEDURES THAT
PROMOTE ACCESS TO JUSTICE AND
IMPROVE CASE OUTCOMES.
A CALIFORNIA'S CHILDREN AND
FAMILIES THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
HAS RECOGNIZED NOVEMBER AS CORD
ADOPTION AND PERMANENCY MONTH.
EVERY YEAR SINCE NINETEEN NINETY
NINE AS SOON AS AS AND THIS.
SIDE.
OUR THE COURT HOUSE IS VERY
RARELY A PLACE WHERE PEOPLE COME
WITH SMILES ON THEIR FACE.
AN EVEN LESS.
FREQUENTLY DO THEY LEAVE WITH
SMILES ON THEIR FACE BUT WHEN IT
COMES TO ADOPTIONS AND PERMANENT
SEES THIS IS THE ONE MOMENT WHEN
THE COURT HOUSE IS A PLACE OF
JOY.
AND HAPPINESS HALF A MILLION
INCIDENTS OF CHILD ABUSE AND
NEGLECT THE REPORTED EVERY YEAR
AND ABOUT TWENTY ONE THOUSAND
CHILDREN ENTER CHILD WELFARE
SUPERVISE FOSTER CARE FOR THE
FIRST TIME.
NEARLY SEVENTY ONE HUNDRED
DEPENDENT USE AN ELEVEN HUNDRED
YOUTH AND JUVENILE JUSTICE
SYSTEMS REMAIN UNDER THE COURT'S
JURISDICTION AS YOUNG ADULTS AND
ARE DESERVING OF PERMANENCY AND
STABLE LIVING ENVIRONMENTS.
THIS PROGRAM THESE PROGRAMS ARE
THOSE FEW MOMENTS WHEN THE
COURTS ARE ABLE TO PROVIDE THAT
KIND OF STABILITY THAT KIND OF
SECURITY THAT THESE YOUNG PEOPLE
NEED.
THIS IS THE COURTS AT A POINT
WHERE THEY ARE TRULY DOING A
SERVICE THAT MAKES EVERYONE WITH
IN ITS A COURTHOUSE BOUNDARIES A
SMILE WITH GREAT JOY AND PRIDE
IN WITH THAT I WOULD ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE.
BIGGIE CENTER JACKSON MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I ENTER SENT [inaudible]
I ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BY BILL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA AYE CHAIN.
AYE DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES.
FULLER AYE GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
AYE GLAZER.
BY HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
BY LARA AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING [inaudible]
MORE LOCK.
I AM A REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
I'VE I'VE ACT [inaudible]
AYE WIECKOWSKI [inaudible]
BY WINNER [inaudible]
WILK [inaudible]
HI BY.
CENTER MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE BACK TO FILE
ITEM ONE THIRTY SEVEN SENATOR
GAINES MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO EIGHTY THREE BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COOLEY RELATIVE
TO CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
APPRECIATION WEEK [inaudible]
SENATOR GAINES.
CHRIS THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS ARE PRICE TODAY PERCENT
ACR TWO EIGHTY THREE WHICH
DESIGNATES THE SECOND WEEK OF
EVERY OCTOBER.
AS CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
APPRECIATION WEEK CALIFORNIA
CURRENTLY HAS APPROXIMATELY
THREE THOUSAND CODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
WHO PROVIDE FOR THE SAFETY
HEALTH AND WELFARE OF CITIZENS
IN COMMUNITIES AND THROUGHOUT
THE STATE?
CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS HAVE
CHALLENGING AND DEMANDING ROLES
AND OFTEN DO NOT RECEIVE
RECOGNITION FOR THE JOB THEY DO
IMPROVING QUALITY OF LIFE FOR
RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES.
OF LOCAL COMMUNITIES CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS ARE
DEDICATED.
HIGHLY QUALIFIED AND HIGHLY
TRAINED PROFESSIONALS WHO SHARE
THE GOALS OF PREVENTING
NEIGHBORHOOD DETERIORATION.
ENHANCING COMMUNITIES ENSURING
SAFETY AND PRESERVING PROPERTY
VALUES THROUGH KNOWLEDGE
TRAINING IN APPRECIATION OF
HOUSING ZONING.
AND NUISANCE WALLACE'S
RESOLUTION SIX TO RECOGNIZE HE'S
BRAVE MEN AND WOMEN. FOR THEIR
WORK [inaudible]
AND HONORED THE THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS WHO HAVE
LOST THEIR LIVES IN THE LINE OF
DUTY WITHIN THE PAST DECADE.
THANK YOU A BETTER PRESENT
MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I
VOTE THE SENATOR GAINES MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I HENDERSON.
AYE ATKINS [inaudible]
BATES.
I BILL.
AYE BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
I HIGH CANNELLA.
BY CHAIN.
BY DELEON [inaudible]
BY DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
I HEARD IT IS [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
I THAT I HIGH LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY [inaudible]
MURDOCH.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN.
AYE.
AYE PAN [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
AYE STONE.
I'VE AYE DAK AYE WHAT COUNTY
[inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
WILK [inaudible]
I SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
WE ARE DOWN TO OUR LAST THREE
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING BILLS
AFTER THAT WE WILL BE LIFTING
THE CALL ON VOTES AND THEN WILL
YOU BE MOVING ON TO BUDGET BILLS.
SO IF YOU'RE ON THE FLOOR THANK
YOU PLEASE STAY HERE IF YOU ARE
NOT ON THE FLOOR PLEASE MAKE
YOUR WAY BACK.
WE'RE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM ONE
FORTY FIVE SENATOR JACKSON'S.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY FIVE THIRTY
FOUR BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER LIMON AND
ACTUALLY TO PUBLIC RESOURCES
THINNER JACKSON THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT AND COLLEAGUES.
COLLEAGUES THIS IS A BILL ABOUT
PUBLIC ACCESS TO THE GREATEST
NATURAL RESOURCE IN CALIFORNIA
OUR COAST.
THIS BILL IS A STATE WIDE BILL.
WITH BOTH THE STATE AND THE A
DISTRICT SPECIFIC BENEFITS.
THIS BILL BUILT ON THE PREMISE
THAT ACCESS TO OUR PARKS OR
BEACHES.
AND OUR PUBLIC RESOURCES SHOULD
BE AVAILABLE FOR EVERYONE TO
ENJOY.
REGARDLESS OF THEIR ZIP CODE.
OR THEIR BANK ACCOUNT.
THIS BILL DOES TWO THINGS
[inaudible]
IT CREATES.
IT CREATES A GRANT PROGRAM.
IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE ABILITY
OF UNDERSERVED AN AT RISK
POPULATIONS TO PARTICIPATE IN
OUTDOOR ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION
PROGRAMS [inaudible]
AND TO IT TAKES AN IMPORTANT
STEP TOWARD REMOVING BARRIERS
THAT HAVE PREVENTED THE PUBLIC
FROM ACCESSING IN ENJOYING AN
EIGHT AND A HALF MILE STRETCH OF
THE COAST.
AT HOLLISTER RANCH IN SANTA
BARBARA COUNTY.
IN MY DISTRICT.
PUBLIC ACCESS AT THIS LARGE
SECTION OF THE COAST HAS NOT
BEEN ACHIEVED FOR THE PAST
THIRTY SIX YEARS.
THIS CONTRADICTS THE CLEAR IT
LEGISLATIVE INTENT THAT
ENVISIONED THE PHASED ACCESS
PROGRAM.
AS WELL AS APPROVAL IN NINETEEN
EIGHTY TWO BY AN ACCESS PLAN FOR
THAT AREA.
WE HAVE HEARD AND I CAN ATTEST
TO THIS FACT FROM THOUSANDS.
OF OUR CONSTITUENTS WHO ARE
CONCERNED WITH THE LACK OF
COASTAL ACCESS AND IT'S CLEAR.
THE CALIFORNIA WANTS THE STATE
TO ASSIST IN REACHING AN
EQUITABLE OUTCOME FOR THE PEOPLE
OF THIS STATE.
PROVIDING CHILDREN AND EVERYONE.
WITH ACCESS TO OUTDOOR
EXPERIENCES IMPROVES THEIR LIVES
IN THE OVERALL WELL BEING OF
CALIFORNIA'S COMMUNITIES.
I HAVE UP [inaudible]
OF WITH ME --
WHY HAVE I SHOULD SAY --
HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO HEAR THIS
MEASURE ALONG WITH MY COLLEAGUES
IN OUR NATURAL RESOURCES
COMMITTEE --
THERE IS QUITE CLEARLY A NEED
FOR THIS ACCESS THERE IS CLEARLY
A NEED FOR THE STATE TO COMMIT
TO REINVESTING.
IN COASTAL ACCESS THE COASTAL
TRAILS THIS IS A CRITICAL PART
OF THAT COASTAL CRIER A TRAIL
SYSTEM.
THAT THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA
MADE CLEAR BACK IN THE NINETEEN
SEVENTIES THEY WANTED AVAILABLE.
THE COAST COLLEAGUES DOES AND
SHOULD CONTINUE TO BELONG TO ALL
OF US AND WITH THAT I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER JACKSON MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
[inaudible]
THUNDERSTONE.
THANK YOU --
MADAM PRESIDENT AND WITH WITH A
GREAT DEAL OF RESPECT FOR MY MY
COLLEAGUE FROM.
SANTA BARBARA --
I RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE AB.
TWENTY FIVE THIRTY FOUR YOU SEE
MY FRIENDS --
THIS IS A A LAW THAT WERE GOING
TO BE.
PUTTING INTO PLACE IF THIS BILL
GETS ON TO THE GOVERNOR'S DESK
AND HE SIGNS IT WHICH IS GOING.
TO AND BY DESIGN EFFECTUATE THE
OUTCOME OF AN ONGOING.
LITIGATION [inaudible]
OVER.
THE HOLLISTER RANCH [inaudible]
ACCESSIBILITY.
TO OF THE OCEAN
[inaudible]
CALIFORNIA.
AND IF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
NEEDS THEIR PROPERTY OR PARK
SISTER NEEDS THEIR PROPERTY TO
GAIN ACCESS.
TO THE BEACHES IN THE OCEANS ON
THAT WE OF YOUR PACIFIC OCEAN
THEM THEY SHOULD GO THROUGH THE
LEGAL PROCESS OF EMILY DOMAIN
AND A LEADING THE THE OWNER OF
THE PROPERTY ENSURE THAT THEY'RE
GETTING THE HIGHEST BEST USE FOR
THEIR PROPERTY.
THE BOTTOM LINE MY FRIENDS IS
THAT WE ARE CHANGING THE LAW IN
THE MIDST OF A LAWSUIT TO GIVE
ONE SIDE A MATERIAL ADVANTAGE
OVER THE OTHER.
I DON'T THINK GETS THE ROLE OF
THE LEGISLATURE WE SHOULD BE
FAIR AND JUST IN A COURT OF LAW
EQUAL JUSTICE FOR ALL.
THOSE REASONS I STAYED.
PLEASE VOTE NO ON AB.
TWENTY FIVE THIRTY FOUR THANK
YOU CENTER STONE CENTER STERN
VERY BAD PRESIDENT --
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
MEASURE WHICH I WORRY HAS BEEN.
OF MISREPRESENTED IS SOMETHING
BIGGER THAN WHAT IT IS.
THIS IS NOT AN INTERVENTION INTO
ACTIVE LITIGATION OR ANY
SETTLEMENT.
IS THE MERE ESTABLISHMENT OF TO
SERVE ACCOUNTS --
FOR THE ISSUES RAISED REGARDLESS
OF WHAT SIDE OF THIS HOLLISTER
ISSUE YOU MAY.
FIND YOURSELF ON WHAT YOU WANT
ENHANCE ACCESS WHERE THE YOUTH
SUPPORT THIS SETTLEMENT WHETHER
YOU OPPOSE IT WHETHER YOU THINK
THERE SHOULD BE ONGOING
LITIGATION WHAT DO YOU THINK IT
SHOULD CEASE --
FRANKLY IRRELEVANT TO THE THIS
BILL -- AND
WE ESTABLISHED THAT VERY CLEARLY
IN COMMITTEE THROUGH --
DISCUSSIONS WITH BOTH THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL AS WELL AS THE
LITIGANTS --
SO I I SOME OF THESE BILLS ARE
BIGGER THAN WHAT THEY SEEM BUT I
THINK THIS.
ONE IN FACT MAY BE SMALLER THAN
WHAT IT SEEMS --
A MODEST PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH
TWO ACCOUNTS.
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR STERN SEE NO
FURTHER TO SOAP CENTER HUESO.
THANK YOUR GONNA PRESIDENT AS A
FORMER --
STATE COSTA COMMISSIONER.
WHO -- DEALT
WITH THIS ISSUE ON THE COASTAL
COMMISSION I HAVE.
TO A RISE IN SUPPORT AND JUST SO --
LET PEOPLE KNOW.
THAT THE ONE OF THE OBJECTIVES
OF THE COASTAL COMMISSION.
THE COAST COMMISSION AS TO
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT DETECTIVES
ONE IS TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL
CALIFORNIANS HAVE ACCESS TO THE
COAST.
NO MATTER WHERE YOU LIVE.
IF YOU'RE FROM FRESNO COUNTY
IMPERIAL COUNTY INLAND
CALIFORNIA IF YOU LIVE IN THE
BORDER WITH ARIZONA.
THE COAST OF CALIFORNIA BELONGS
TO EVERYBODY EVERYBODY HAS.
A RIGHT TO ACCESS IT FROM ANY
POINT IN THE COAST.
BUT THE HOLLISTER RANCHES BEEN A
PROJECT THAT HAS BEEN FIGHTING
COASTAL ACCESS SINCE THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF THE COLD FACT
IN.
NINETEEN SEVENTY SIX AND IT'S
TIME NOW IT'S TIME TO ALLOW
PEOPLE TO ACCESS THEIR COASTLINE.
BELONGS TO THEM AND THIS BILL
WILL GO A LONG WAY MAKE SURE
THAT EVENTUALLY THAT HAPPENS.
PLEASE SUPPORT THIS MEASURE FOR
ALL OF OUR COMMUNITIES.
AND AND LET'S GET BEYOND THIS.
THANK YOU SENATOR HUESO.
THE NO FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATE JACKSON.
ON SENATOR ALLEN WOULD YOU LIKE
TO SPEAK PUFFERY PLEASE GO RIGHT
AHEAD.
I JUST I WANTED RISE. TO TO TO
REITERATE THE COMMENTS MADE BY --
BITE BY CENTER STERN THE SENATE
FOR CANOGA PARK IT'S WEEK WE
CANNOT OVER READ THIS DECISION I
THINK THAT SOME OF THE COMMENTS
THAT HAVE BEEN MADE BY THE
COMMITTEE IN HERE.
HAVE EXAGGERATED THE SCOPE.
OF WHAT THIS BILL WILL DO WITH
VIS A VIS.
I'VE THE SALARY AGREEMENT AND
AND SOME OF THE NEGOTIATIONS AND
SO I I FIRMLY ASSOCIATE MYSELF.
WITH THE COMMENTS FROM THE AT
THE CENTER FROM CANOGA PARK AS A
MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE THAT.
OVERHEARD THIS BILL BEFORE AND
IS NOW HEARING IT ON THE FLOOR
TODAY.
THANK YOU SENATOR ALLEN.
SEEING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATOR JACKSON YOU MAY
CLOSE IS I JUST WANT TO GO TO
CLARIFY THAT DURING THE
DISCUSSION YESTERDAY.
IT WAS MADE CLEAR THIS BILL
DOESN'T INTERFERE WITH EXISTING
A LITIGATION SO THAT.
IS NOT AN ACCURATE
CHARACTERIZATION THIS IS INDEED
A SMALL.
ON THE ONE HAND A SMALL ISSUE OF
TRYING TO CREATE THESE TO SUB
ACCOUNTS BUT IT IS ALSO AN ISSUE
ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT THE PEOPLE
OF CALIFORNIA.
ARE IN FACT GOING TO HAVE ACCESS
TO THE COAST WHICH IS SOMETHING
THAT THE COASTAL ACT WHICH WAS
PROMOTED AND PASSED BY THE
PEOPLE OF THE STATE.
NOT BY THE LEGISLATURE BUT BY
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA BACK IN.
NINETEEN SEVENTY TWO WERE
ENTITLED EVERYONE ENTITLED
INCLUDING PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN MY
GOOD FRIENDS OF FROM TO A A TO
HIM A COUNTY WHICH I DON'T
BELIEVE HAS A WHOLE LOT OF
COASTLINE TO IT.
I AND ALL OF THOSE WHO LIVE
ALONG THE MAKE SURE THEY HAVE
ACCESS TO IT A TWO SUB ACCOUNTS.
TIME TO GET THIS THING MOVING --
WE AREN'T MOVING THE GOAL POST
WHICH IS TRYING TO MAKE SURE
SOMEBODY ELSE OPPORTUNITY TO
KICK THE FOOTBALL IN THAT
DIRECTION.
AND WITH THAT I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR JACKSON'S
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON NO AKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
BELL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
DALY ON I DON'T GOT NO
[inaudible]
BYE DOT.
I FULLER.
KNOW GAINES.
NO GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
I LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY [inaudible]
WARLOCK [inaudible]
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH AYE SKINNER [inaudible]
BY.
STERN.
AYE STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT [inaudible]
MY COUNTY [inaudible]
I WIENER.
BY WILK.
AYE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL CANNELLA [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
I MONNING.
BYE BYE DECK [inaudible]
NO NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MEMBERS
MOVING ON TO ONE FORTY SIX
SENATOR HILL.
FILE ITEM ONE FORTY SIX MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY EIGHTY FOUR
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA AN ACT
RELATING TO SHORT AND REPORTERS
SENATOR HILL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AB
TWENTY EIGHTY FOUR PROHIBITS OUT
OF STATE NON LICENSEE OWNED
COMPANIES.
THAT PROVIDE PRIVATE.
PROVIDE COURT REPORTING SERVICES
FROM VIOLATING FOR SPECIFIC LAWS
AND REGULATIONS APPLICABLES TO
PROTECTING THE INTEGRITY AND
IMPARTIALITY OF THE COURT RECORD
IN A MANNER THAT DOES NOT
ADVANTAGE ONE PARTY OVER ANOTHER.
LICENSEE OWNED FIRMS BASED IN
CALIFORNIA ALREADY MUCH FOLLOW
THESE RULES AND ARE SUBJECT TO
REGULATORY AUTHORITY BY THE
BOARD.
THE COURT REPORTERS BOARD THIS
IS A MUCH NARROWER BILL IN SCOPE
FROM A BILL THAT PASSED THIS
BODY LAST YEAR THAT WOULD HAVE
REQUIRED REGULATORY AUTHORITY
THROUGH FIRM REGISTRATION ON ALL
COURT REPORTING LAWS.
AND REGULATIONS IT IS THE INTENT
OF AB TWENTY EIGHTY FOUR TO BE A
STRONG DETERRENT AGAINST THE
MOST EGREGIOUS ACTIONS TAT
COMPROMISE THE NEUTRAL CARE.
OF THE COURT REPORTER'S
TRANSCRIPT BY NON LICENSEE OWNED
FIRMS WHO HAVE CONTINUED TO SHOW
UP SOMEWHAT DISREGARD FOR
FOLLOWING OUR LAWS AROUND COURT
REPORTING I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE MEMBERS THINK YOU
CENTER HELL MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
AYE CHAIN.
AYE DELEON.
I DELGADO.
AYE DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
THERE [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
HI JACKSON [inaudible]
LOTTE I AYE LEYVA [inaudible]
I MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK NO MORALE.
NO WIN.
NO NO SON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE.
NOVI ACT KNOW WHY COUNTY BY
WINNER [inaudible]
BY WILK [inaudible]
NO.
SENATOR MOVES A CALL MOVING ON
TO WHAT THE FILE ITEM ONE FORTY
EIGHT SENATOR PORTANTINO.
BOTTOM.
ONE FORTY EIGHT MR SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO FORTY THREE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
EDUARDO GARCIA RELATIVE TO
CROSSING GUARDS KEEP OUR
CHILDREN SAFE MONTH [inaudible]
SENATOR PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU ARE MADAM PRESIDENT I
MEMBERS --
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS THE
SECOND HIGHEST NUMBER OF
CROSSING GUARDS IN THE COUNTRY
AND THIS MEASURE WOULD
ACKNOWLEDGE THE IMPORTANCE OF
ADULT CROSSING GUARDS.
AND THE ROLE THEY PLAY IN OUR
COMMUNITIES ADULT SCHOOL
CROSSING GUARDS PLAY A VITAL
ROLE IN THE LIVES OF CHILDREN
WHO WALK OR BIKE TO SCHOOL BY
HELPING THEM SAFELY.
ACROSS THE STREET AT KEY
LOCATIONS THE JOB OF A CROSSING
GUARD IS DANGEROUS OFTENTIMES
AND GOES UNAPPRECIATED BY MANY
MOTORISTS --
WHO PUT THEM AT RISK PARENTS AND
CIVIC LEADERS ARE PERSISTENT AND
THEIR DEMANDS FOR MORE SIGNS
MARKINGS AND SIGNALS AROUND
SCHOOL AREAS AND OTHER LOCATIONS
HOW CROSSING GUARDS ARE ROLE
MODELS WHO UP CHILDREN DEVELOP
SKILLS -- SO
THE LEGISLATURE MUST RECOGNIZE
THEIR IMPORTANCE ABOUT --
CROSSING GUARDS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
ON BEHALF OF EDUARDO GARCIA ON
ACR.
TO FORTY THREE THANK YOUSENATOR
PORTANTINO MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING THAT
MUCH SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
I ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
I DELEON.
I DON'T AUTO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
BY HILL.
AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
PILOT I AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LOCKED.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
BY NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I HAVE [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROUGH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
BY STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
I FIGHT ACT [inaudible]
AYE WIECKOWSKI [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
I WILK.
I WORK ACT PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBER [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
BERRYHILL.
BUYS THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO
GREAT JOB MEMBERS IT IS THREE
THIRTY ONE AND WE HAD JUST
ESTABLISHED UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
ALRIGHT WE ARE MOVING.
IT GOT EXCITED LITTLE THINGS IN
LIFE MOVING ON TO WE'RE GONNA
MOVE BACK ACTION A FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTY FOUR SENATOR LARA MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT LISTEN TO
SEVENTY NINE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
KALRA RELATIVE TO PLANT BASED
DIET.
SENATOR LAURA THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS THIS IS --
SIMPLE RESOLUTION BUT I THINK
HAS REALLY IMPORTANT CONNOTATION
IT PROMOTES --
THE BENEFITS OF A PLANT BASED
DIET.
A AND IT PASSED THE ASSEMBLY ON
CONSENT --
WITH --
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AGAIN JUST --
A RESOLUTION THAT TALKS ABOUT
THE BENEFITS OF A PLAN FOR THE
PLAN --
BASED DIET SO RESEARCHERS FOR
ABOUT.
YOU SENATOR LARA MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE.
EYES THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES SEE HOW FUN THAT
DOES.
FILE ITEM ONE FORTY NINE SENATOR
MCGUIRE.
PASS SOME FILE FILE ITEM ONE
FIFTY SENATOR PAN.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO SEVENTY FOUR BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER GABRIEL RELATIVE
TO CHILDHOOD CANCER AWARENESS
MONTH SENATOR PAN THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT SENATORS SIDE
RICE PRESENT ACR TWO SEVEN FOUR
ON BEHALF ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GABRIELLE.
ACR TWO SEVENTY FOUR RECOGNIZES
THE MONTH OF SEPTEMBER TWENTY
EIGHTEEN THIS CHILDHOOD CANCER
AWARENESS MONTH.
MORE THAN A THOUSAND SEVEN
HUNDRED CHILDREN AND YOUNG
ADULTS UNDER THE AGE OF TWENTY
ARE DIAGNOSED WITH CANCER EACH%
YEAR IN OUR STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
THESE CHILDREN A FAMILY
STRUCTURE SUPPER BOTH PHYSICAL
AND EMOTIONAL PAIN UNDER
STRUGGLES AGAINST THIS TERRIBLE
DISEASE.
THIS MEASURE NOT ONLY BRINGS
AWARENESS ABOUT CANCER BUT ALSO
REAFFIRMS OUR COMMITMENT TO
FINDING A CURE IN PREVENTING
CHILDHOOD CANCER.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PAN.
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING ANALYZE
THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES NICE JOB.
ALRIGHT WE'RE INTO A LITTLE
QUICK BREAK HERE DO NOT LEAVE.
SENATE MCGUIRE WOULD LIKE TO
FILE ITEM ONE FORTY NINE IT'S
PLEASES A SECRETARY PLEASE READ
A SINECURE RESOLUTION TO SEVEN
ONE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER ACOSTA
RELATIVE TO THE TWO THOUSAND
EIGHT FIRE SEASON.
SENATE MCGUIRE THANK YOU SO MUCH
BETTER PRESIDENT GRATEFUL TO
SIMMER CASA FOR BRINGING THIS
APP RESOLUTION FOR IN RISE RISEN
ACR.
TWO SEVENTY ONE WHICH
COMMEMORATES THE TWO THOUSAND
EIGHT CALIFORNIA WILDFIRE SEASON.
IN THE THIRTEEN FIREFIGHTERS WHO
TRAGICALLY PAIRS WHILE FIGHTING
THE FIRES.
OVER THE TWO THOUSAND EIGHT FIRE
SEASON THIRTEEN FIREFIGHTERS
PAIRS FOR BATTLING STATES
WILDFIRES WHICH TRAGICALLY TOOK
THE LIVES OF THIRTY SEVEN
RESIDENTS.
WELL THE FIRES THAT HAVE A LARGE
IMPACT ON THE PEOPLE WITH THE
AFFECTED COMMUNITIES THE
EXTRAORDINARY EFFORTS OF
THOUSANDS OF DEDICATED
FIREFIGHTERS PREVENTED EVEN
GREATER IMPACTS.
WE ARE FOREVER INDEBTED TO ALL
THESE FIREFIGHTERS AND WOOD FOR
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
ON BEHALF OF THIS AND NUMBER
COSTS.
THANK YOU CENTER REQUIRE MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SITTING IN HEARNG THEM EYES
THIRTY NINE NOSE ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
ABOUT TO MOVE ON TO OUR BUDGET
BILLS JUST.
GIVE US A MOMENT.
SENATOR BATES WHAT PURPOSE YOU
RISE.
A BRIEF OF REPUBLICAN CAUCUS IN
THE COX LOUNGE A BRIEF
REPUBLICAN CAUCUS IN THE COX LOUNGE.
DEMOCRATIC MEMBERS STAY CLOSE
THIS HAS ENDED MEMBERS IF YOU
CAN ALL MAKE YOUR WAY BACK TO
YOUR DESKS SO THAT WE CAN GET
STARTED ON THE BUDGET BILLS. FOR
THOSE OF YOU WHO ACTUALLY LEFT
THE RED CARPET PLEASE MAKE YOUR
WAY BACK TO THE RED CARPET
WE'RE
READY TO GET STARTED ON THE
BUDGET BILLS IF EVERYONE CAN
MAKE THEIR WAY BACK TO THE RED
CARPET
.
SENATOR WHITE HOUSE GIVE YOU CAN
MAKE YOUR WAY BACK TO THE SENATE
FLOOR WE WOULD LIKE TO BEGIN
WELCOME BACK SENATOR WYCHE
HEALTHY MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO
TAKE UP BUDGET BILLS MADAM
BUDGET CHAIR ARE YOU PREPARED TO
PRESENT ON FILE ITEM.
THIRTY EIGHT MR SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL A SIXTY TWO BY THE
COMMITTEE ON BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW.
AND EXPLAIN TO THE STATE BUDGET
AND MAKING APPROPRIATIONTHEREFORE TO TAKE EFFECT
IMMEDIATELY BUDGET BILL.
SENATOR MITCHELL THANK YOU SO
MUCH MADAME PRESIDENT BUSH'S THE
OPPORTUNITY.
COLLEAGUES A THE SENATE BILL.
THAT MAKES CHANGES AND
CORRECTIONS TO THE PROVISIONAL
LANGUAGE IN APPROPRIATIONS IN
THE BUDGET ACT OF TWENTY
EIGHTEEN MOST SIGNIFICANTLY
COLLEAGUES THAT APPROPRIATES
TWENTY THREE POINT FIVE MILLION.
FOR VARIOUS DRINKING WATER
RELATED PROJECTS INCLUDING WATER
TANK INSTALLATION WELL
REPLACEMENT SEPTIC REPLACEMENT
AND THE SAFE DRINKING WATER FOR
SCHOOLS GRANT PROGRAM.
PROVIDES TEN MILLION DOLLARS TO
THE OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES
FOR GRANTS RELATED TO HUMAN
TRAFFICKING SERVICES.
ALLOWS FOR THE APPROPRIATION
MEDICINAL FUNDS FOR THE D. IN
THE TO LEVY A TO PREVENT WAIT
TIMES AT FIELD OFFICES THE
ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATION MUST BE
JUSTIFIED BASED ON THE RESOURCES
NECESSARY. TO REDUCE WAIT TIMES
TO BUY A SPECIFIED AMOUNT.
ITINCREASES THE TRIAL COURT
TRUSTS FRONT APPROPRIATION BY
FIFTEEN MILLION AND ASK
PROVISIONAL LANGUAGE TO SUPPORT
START OF ACTIVITIES ASSOCIATED
WITH PRE TRIAL REFORM.
AT APPROPRIATE SEVEN HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS THE DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE FOR ENFORCEMENT
ACTIVITIES RELATED TO THE
CALIFORNIA CONSUMER PRIVACY ACT
OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN MAKES VARIOUS
CHANGES TO EDUCATION PROGRAMS TO
REFLECT UPDATED ESTIMATES.
A FEDERAL FUND AWARD AMOUNTS AND
LASTLY IT MAKES VARIOUS OTHER
TECHNICAL IN CLARIFYING CHANGES.
TO THE BUDGET ACTIVE.
TWENTY EIGHTEEN THANK YOU
SENATOR MITCHELL.
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BELL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
[inaudible]
BY LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL
AYE HIGH MONEY.
BY MORE LOCK.
MORALE [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN.
I KNOW SAN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
HI PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH.
I SKINNER AYE BY STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
FIGHT BACK.
BYE.
BYE CATHY.
BY WINNER [inaudible]
BY WILK [inaudible]
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
GALGIANI AYE [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL CHIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
DALY OWN [inaudible]
WARLOCK [inaudible]
STONE.
EYES TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS NINE
NINE THE ASSEMBLY MOVEMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM FORTY TWO
SENATOR MITCHELL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL EIGHT SEVENTY FIVE BY THE
COMMITTEE ON BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND ACT LINK PUBLIC
RESOURCES AND MAKING A
PREPARATION THEREFORE TO TAKE
EFFECT ME LEGAL RELATED BUT
SENATE MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT IN COLLEGE BEFORE I
MOVE ONTO THE TRAILER BILL THEY
JUST WANNA PAS VERY BRIEFLY AND
THINK NOT ONLY THE SENATE BUDGET
COMMITTEE STAFF AND THE STAFF OF
THE JOINT.
BUDGET REVIEW COMMITTEE BUT ALL
OF OUR STAFF WHO SUPPORT ALL OF
YOU IF YOU SERVE ON BUDGET
COMMITTEE OR NOT.
ON THE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS STAFF
WHO SUPPORT THEM IN BUDGET NO
BUDGET IS A VERY TECHNICAL
PRECISE --
PROCESS AND THEM GETTING IT
RIGHT THE FIRST TIME ON HEALTH
SERVICE DO THE JOBS WE NEED TO
DO TO LEAVE THE FIFTH LARGEST
ECONOMY IN THE WORLD SO I'M
GONNA TIP MY HAT.
AND THANK ALL THE STAFF WHO
SPEND HUNDREDS OF HOURS IF NOT
THOUSANDS ON THE BUDGET.
CLEARLY THROUGHOUT THE COURSE OF
THE YEAR.
COLLEAGUES S. B. EIGHT SEVEN
FIVE MAKES TECHNICAL IN
CLARIFYING CHANGES RELATED TO
NATURAL RESOURCES AND
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION THAT
ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE
IMPLEMENTATION IN THE BUDGET ACT
OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN ASKING FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
WOULD YOU CENTER MITCHELL
SENATOR NELSON.
THAT A PREZ LADIES CHEN THE
SENATE I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO
THANK ALL OF THE STAFF AND THEY
ARE.
OR HAVE PUT IN IN THE THOUSANDS
OF HOURS VERY PATIENTLY THROUGH
THE PROCESS.
IT IS A LABORIOUS PROCESS.
SO MUCH NOW IS DONE IN THE
BUDGET.
THE TO BECOME A MUCH BIGGER AND
MORE ARDUOUS TASK.
I'D LIKE TO THANK THE CHAIR FOR
THE COURTESIES THAT SHE IS
EXTENDED. TO ME AND TO THE
MINORITY CONSULTANTS IN OUR
MEMBERS THROUGH THE COURSE OF
OUR BUDGET HEARINGS THAT HELP
THINGS TO MOVE ALONG IT EASY
PACE.
AND WE GOT THROUGH IT IN GOOD
ORDER.
THANK YOU SENATOR NIELSEN
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
THING THAT MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON.
BY ATKINS.
AYE BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
BY CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
BY LOTTE.
AYE LEYVA AYE AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK.
I'M A REAL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN.
NO I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO.
AYE ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
AYE STONE [inaudible]
I BIDAK WELL I WIECKOWSKI.
I WINNER.
AYE WILK.
AYE.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG.
I DELEON.
BY.
I WAS THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ONE THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE AND FORTY THREE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY SIX BY
THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND ACTING HUMAN SERVICES
MAKING APPROPRIATION THEREFORE
TAKE EFFECT MERELY BILL RELATE
TO THE BUDGET.
SENATE MITCHELL MADAM PRESIDENT
THIS IS A CLEAN UP BUDGET
TRAILER BILL FOR HUMAN SERVICES
PROVISIONS IN THIS BUILDING
TECHNICAL AND NON SUBSTANTIVE
CHANGES RELATED TO THE COW WORKS
HOME THIS INITIATIVE THE IN HOME
SUPPORT SERVICES PROGRAM.
AND THE HOME BASE FAMILY CARE
RATE ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE.
BIG YOU SENATOR MITCHELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING THEN MR SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS.
ANDERSON NO ATKINS AYE BATES
[inaudible]
I FELL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA BY CHIANG
[inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
HI DELGADO [inaudible]
HI DOT.
I FULLER.
AYE GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
I HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
BY LARA.
I LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I MORE LUCK NO MORRELL
[inaudible]
BY NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
IBM.
BY PORTANTINO.
AYE ROTH [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE.
BYE BYE JACK.
I LIKE COUNTY.
BY WINNER BY WILK.
IRAQ YEARS AGO THERE ARE WILK
AYE INNOCENT AYE PLEASE CALL.
BEING I SENATOR WILK PLEASE GO
THE ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL.
EYES THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ONE THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S ARE
CONCURRED IN.
FILE ITEM FORTY MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SIXTY NINE BY
THE COMMITTEE IN BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND THAT CLAIMED
ELECTIONS MAKING PREPARATION
THEREFORE TO TAKE EFFECT MERELY
BILL RELIGION BUDGET
[inaudible]
SENATE MITCHELL.
THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN COLLEAGUES
A TRAILER BILL THAT MAKE
STATUTORY CHANGES THE PROVISIONS
OF AND PROVIDES APPROPRIATIONS
RELATING.
TO OUR ELECTIONS AND MAKE CELLS
A PREPARATION BILLION TO THE
BUDGET BILL.
SPECIFICALLY REPEALS AND RE
ENACTS THE VARIOUS STATUTORY
CHANGES RELATING TO ELECTIONS IN
SAN DIEGO COUNTY MADE BY A
PREVIOUS TRAILER BILL S. B..
EIGHT SIX SIX IT MAKES
LEGISLATIVE FINDINGS AND
DECLARATIONS ASKED TO THE
NECESSITY OF A SPECIAL STATUTE
FOR SENDING A COUNTY.
THAT APPROPRIATES FUNDS TO THE
SECRETARY OF STATE TO IMPROVE
COUNTY ELECTION SYSTEMS ASKING
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
THING IN HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I ENTER SIN.
NO ATKINS AYE BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
BY BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG.
NO DAILY ON AYE DELGADO
[inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG [inaudible]
HILL.
I HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
I LARA.
AYE LEYVA.
I AM MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL AYE AYE MONEY.
I'M MORE LARK NO MORALE.
NO WIN.
NO NO SON.
NO PAN.
AYE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK.
NO I COUNTY.
BY WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK.
WILK NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS HERTZBERG AYE
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL.
I STIRRED EYES TWENTY SIX KNOWS
THIRTEEN THE ASSEMBLY MEMONS ARE
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS I'M GONNA
GO THROUGH THE ROLE TWICE SO
THERE'S NO NEED TO CALL OUT YOUR
VOTE WE WILL GET TO YOU.
FILE ITEM FORTY FOUR MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY SEVEN
BY THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET
FISCAL REVIEW AND THAT GOING TO
STATE GOVERNMENT AND MAKING
PROGRESS THERE FOR TO TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY BILL RELATE
TO THE BUDGET.
SENATE MITCHELL THANK YOU%
COLLEAGUESTHIS IS THE GENERAL
GOVERNMENT BUDGET TRAILER BILL
THE BILL MAKES TECHNICAL
SECRETARY CHANGES TO IMPLEMENT
THE TWENTY EIGHTEEN BUDGET ACT
FOR GENERAL GOVERNMENT
OPERATIONS ON STATE
ADMINISTRATION.
IT MAKES THE CONTINUOUS
APPROPRIATION TO SUPPORT LONG
TERM MONITORING ACTIVITIES IN
THE HOUSING FOR A HEALTHY
CALIFORNIA PROGRAM STREAMLINES
THE USE OF EMERGENCY NO BID
CONTRACTS FOR PUBLIC WORKS
PROJECTS SUCH AS ROAD REPAIR
PROJECTS FOLLOWING.
NATIONAL DISASTERS SIMPLIFIES
THE CONTRACTOR REQUIREMENTS FOR
CONTRACTS RELATED TO THE STATE'S
EFFORTS IN THE TWENTY TWENTY
SENTENCE AND EXTEND THE
REPAYMENT DATE FOR CERTAIN LOANS
MADE THE LOCAL TRANSIT AGENCIES.
ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I HENDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
AYE BATES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
AYE CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON.
I DON'T DORADO.
AYE DODD.
AYE FULLER.
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
BY GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
I HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
I LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
AYE AYE MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE.
NO WIN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE.
NO FIGHT ACT NO I COUNTY
[inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
NO.
HOW EYES TWENTY SEVEN THOSE
ELEVEN HIM ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S
ARE CONCURRED IN?
FILE ITEM THIRTY SEVEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ
[inaudible]
YES.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SIXTY ONE BY
THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND AYKROYD RELATING TO
THE NTIONAL MORTGAGE SETTLEMENT
IN MAKING A PREPARATION
THEREFORE TO TAKE EFFECT ME LEAD
TO RELATE TO THE BUDGET.
SENATE MITCHELL THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT THIS IS A BUDGET
TRAILER BILL RELATED TO THE
NATIONAL MORTGAGE SETTLEMENT.
IT IS DECLARATIVE OF EXISTING
LAW AND PROVIDES LEGISLATIVE
CONFIRMATION OF BUDGETARY
DECISIONS MADE BETWEEN TWENTY
TWELVE AND TWENTY FOURTEEN AS
BACKGROUND.
THE TWENTY TWELVE NATIONAL
MORTGAGE SETTLEMENT REQUIRED THE
NATION'S LARGEST MARKET SERVICES
THE COMPENSATE THOSE IMPACTED BY
THE TWO THOUSAND EIGHT FINANCIAL
CRISIS.
IT PROVIDED TWENTY BILLION
DOLLARS DIRECTLY TO CONSUMERS
IMPACTED BY THE CRISIS
[inaudible]
IN ADDITION IT PROVIDED TWO
POINT FIVE BILLION DIRECTLY TO
STATE GOVERNMENTS.
OFFSET CRISIS RELATED SAY CROSS
CALIFORNIA SHARE AT THIS TWO
POINT FIVE BILLION WAS A FOUR
HUNDRED AND TEN MILLION DOLLARS.
DURING THE STATE'S FISCAL CRISIS
THE STATE TRANSFERRED A
SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THIS
FORMED IN TEN MILLION TO THE
GENERAL FUND TO OFFSET EXISTING
RELATED COSTS.
PRIMARILY TO PAY FOR DEBT
SERVICE ON HOUSING RELATED BOMB.
THE STATE WAS SUBSEQUENTLY SUED
OVER THESE TRANSFERS AND WAS
RECENTLY ORDERED TO REPAY THREE
HUNDRED AND THIRTY ONE MILLION
FROM THE GENERAL FUND. TO THE
SPECIAL DEPOSIT FUN THE STATE IS
APPEALING THE APPELLATE COURT'S
DECISION.
THIS BILL PROVIDES LEGISLATIVE
CONFIRMATION THAT BUDGETARY
DECISIONS MADE BETWEEN TWENTY
TWELVE AND TWENTY FOURTEEN WERE
MADE IN COMPLIANCE WITH BOTH
EXISTING LAW.
AND LEGISLATIVE INTENT.
AND THAT THE LEGISLATURE WAS
AWARE OF AN APPROVED THESE
TRANSFERS ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL.
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE SENATOR
WHEN.
DIDN'T TODAY I RISE IN
OPPOSITION TO S. B..
EIGHT SIX ONE S. B. EIGHT SIX
ONE IS AN ATTEMPT TO LEGISLATE.
THE MISUSE OF FUNDS IN THE
NATIONAL MORTGAGE SPECIAL
DEPOSIT FUN.
AFTER CALIFORNIA RECEIVE OVER
FOUR HUNDRED MILLION IN
SETTLEMENT FUNDS WHICH WERE
MEANT TO POVIDE RELIEF TO HOME
OWNERS.
NOT THE STATE GOVERNMENT TO THE
FORECLOSURE CRISIS THE STATE
USED TO DIVERT MOST OF THE MONEY
TO BACK FILL GAPS IN THE BUDGET.
IT TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN THE
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
RULED THAT THE STATE IN A
PROPERLY SPENT MORE THAN THREE
HUNDRED THIRTY ONE MILLION
DOLLARS FOR THE MORTGAGE
SETTLEMENT FUNDS.
THIS MONEY SHOULD HAVE GONE TO
SAYS THE THOUSANDS OF HOMEOWNERS
WHO WERE AFFECTED BY THE
FORECLOSURE CRISIS.
IT COULD HAVE BEEN USED FOR LIFE
CHANGING PROCESSES SUCH AS
HELPING DIDN'T LOW MODIFICATIONS
RESTORING CREDIT SCORES.
BY NEW HOMES OR PAY FOR MOVING
KOSS'S.
TAKING MONEY THAT WOULD HAVE
HELPED STRUGGLING CALIFORNIANS
WAS WRONG.
AND PASSING A BILL TO TRY TO
JUSTIFY THE MIS USE AFTER THE
FACT IS ALSO WRONG I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE I'M A NO VOTE.
BANKY SENATOR WHEN CENTER WHICH
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE HAPPY.
TO COLLEAGUES I'M GOING TO
RESTATE THE AGREEMENTS OF THE
NATIONAL MORTGAGE SETTLEMENT.
WE HAD A LENGTHY DISCUSSION IN --
BUDGET COMMITTEE AND WE PROVIDED
CLARITY --
AT THAT POINT [inaudible]
AGAIN.
THE SETTLEMENT THAT WAS
NEGOTIATED ON OUR BEHALF BY OUR
THEN ATTORNEY GENERAL.
CREATED AN OPPORTUNITY THAT
PROVIDED TWENTY BILLION DIRECTLY
TO CONSUMERS IMPACTED BY THE
CRISIS.
THERE WAS A SECOND POT OF MONEY.
AGAIN NATIONALLY TWO POINT FIVE
BILLION.
THAT WAS DIRECTED TO STATE
GOVERNMENTS TO OFFSET CRISIS
RELATED STATE COSTS.
WELL YOU ALL SHOULD BE HAPPY AND
PROUD TO KNOW.
THAT ALL OF THE CALIFORNIA SHARE
OF THE FIRST POT THE TWENTY
BILLION.
WENT TO SAID.
PURPOSE. TO SUPPORT CALIFORNIA
HOMEOWNERS WHO WERE CAUGHT UP.
IN THE NATIONAL CRISIS.
THE ADDITIONAL RESOURCES THAT
THE LAW OF THAT THAT THE
NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT CLEARLY
ALLOW.
FOR WERE USED IN CALIFORNIA'S
GENERAL FUND.
TIPOFF THAT ARE.
FISCAL CRISIS THAT WE ARE
EXPERIENCING BETWEEN THE YEARS
OF TWENTY TWELVE AND TWENTY
FOURTEEN THIS BODY --
SUPPORTED BY SOME AND NOT OTHERS --
HAVE DEVOTED A GREAT DEAL OF
TIME AND ENERGY. TO COMING UP
WITH PROGRAMS AND RESOURCES TO
SUPPORT OF THE HOUSING CRISIS IN
THE STATE AS WELL AS THE HOME
OWNERSHIP CRISIS WE EXPERIENCE.
AGAIN A WE ARE CRYSTAL CLEAR
THAT WE WERE WELL WITHIN THE
CONFINES OF LEGISLATIVE INTENT
AND WHAT'S ALLOWED BY THE LAW.
A AND EXIST IN IN IN THAT
CONTEXT BIOS HOME FOR YOU --
TO RATIFY THAT BY SO FOR YOU
ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR MITCHELL MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN.
AYE ANDERSON NO ATKINS
[inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
NO CHIANG.
NO DAILY ON I DELGADO
[inaudible]
BYE DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER.
NO GAINES NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
BY THAT I AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
I MITCHELL.
I MONEY BY MORE LOCK
[inaudible]
NO REAL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
HI PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BY ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER I STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BUT ACT [inaudible]
I BY COUNTY.
AYE WIENER [inaudible]
I WILL [inaudible]
NO.
I SWINGS SEVEN NOES TWELVE BE
SOME WOMEN'S ARE CONCURRED IN
FILE ITEM THIRTY NINE MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL A SIXTY SEVEN BY THE
CAMINO BUDGET FISCAL REVIEW
RELATING TO THE LEGISLATIVE
COUNSEL BUREAU AND MAKING AN
APPROPRIATION THEREFORE TO TAKE
AFFECT ME LIEBER RELATED BUDGET.
SENATOR MITCHELL THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES THIS IS THE
WORKPLACE CONDUCT TRAILER BILL.
THIS BILL RESULTS FROM THE WORK
THE LAW HUNDREDS OF HOURS OF
WORK THAT MANY OF US PUT IN. TO
THE JOINT RULES COMMITTEE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON SEXUAL
HARASSMENT PREVENTION RESPONSE
WHICH IDENTIFIED AS THE PRIMARY
GOAL IN THE LEGISLATIVE REFORM
EFFORTS THE TRANSFORMATION OF
THE LEGISLATURE'S WORKPLACE
CULTURE. TO PROMOTE RESPECT
CIVILITY AND DIVERSITY.
SPECIFICALLY THE PROVISIONS OF
THIS BILL INCLUDE REQUIRING THE
LEDGE COUNCIL TO ESTABLISH A
UNIT AN INDEPENDENT UNIT TO
PROVIDE ADVICE INVESTIGATION
SERVICES. TO THE LEGISLATURE
RELATED TO WORKPLACE MISCONDUCT
REQUIRES LET'S CUNSEL TO RETAIN
BY CONTRACT A ROTATING PANEL OF
EXPERTS TO REVIEW INVESTIGATIONS
UNDERTAKEN BY THE UNIT AND MAKE
RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE
LEGISLATURE REGARDING MATTERS
UNDER INVESTIGATION.
IT APPROPRIATES ONE POINT FIVE
MILLION TO LET'S COUNSELOR TO
CARRY OUT THE REQUIREMENTS OF
THIS BILL ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
BY BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
AYE CHAIN.
AYE DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO [inaudible]
BYE DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER.
I GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL.
AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
AYE LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL [inaudible]
BY MONNING.
BY MORE LOCKED.
BY AMARILLO [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
BY SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE.
I'VE I'D ACT IOWA COUNTY
[inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
I PLEASE GO THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ANDERSON [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
BERRYHILL.
I CERTAINLY EIGHT NEWS ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS AE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM FORTY ONE
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY THREE
BY THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET
FISCAL REVIEW AN ACT RELATING TO
STATE PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT MAKING A
PURPOSE THEREFORE TAKE AFFECTING
ME LIEBER RELATED BUT SENATE
MITCHELL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT EIGHTY
EIGHT FEES ME S. B. EIGHT SEVEN
THREE PROVIDES LEGISLATIVE
RATIFICATION.
OF EIGHT IMHO YOU AGREEMENT
BETWEEN THE STATE AND THE
BARGAINING UNIT BE YOU NINE
REPRESENT PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS
AND BARGAINING UNITS TEAN
REPRESENTING THE PROFESSIONAL
SCIENTISTS.
THE IMHO YOU FOR BARGAINING UNIT
NINE WILL BE IN EFFECT FROM JULY
ONE TWENTY EIGHTEEN THROUGH JUNE
THIRTIETH.
TWENTY TWENTY THE MOU FOR
BARGAINING UNITS TEN WILL BE IN
EFFECT FROM JULY ONE TWENTY
EIGHTEEN THROUGH JULY FIRST.
TWENTY TWENTY THE BILL EXTENDS
THE VESTING PERIOD FOR RETIREE
DENTAL BENEFITS FOR NEW
EMPLOYEES HIRED AFTER JANUARY.
ONE TWENTY NINETEEN THE BILL
ALSO PROVIDES BARGAINING UNIT
UNIT NINE MEMBERS A FOUR AND ONE
HALF PERCENT GENERAL SALARY
INCREASE IN.
TWENTY EIGHTEEN AND A 4%
INCREASE IN.
TWENTY NINETEEN THE BARGAINING
UNIT TEN MEMBERS FOR BRINGING
YOU THE TEN MEMBERS THE BILL
PROVIDES A 5% GENERAL SALARY
INCREASE.
IN TWENTY NINETEEN AND IN.
TWENTY TWENTY JUST FOR POINT OF
INFORMATION FOR OUR COLLEAGUES
THE PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERS IN
CALIFORNIA THOSE IN BERGEN YOU.
NINE COMPLETED A SALARY SURVEY
TAUGHT IN JULY THIS YEAR WHICH
FOUND THAT STATE SALARY FOR
ENGINEERS LAGGED BEHIND OTHER
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES.
BY 226%.
AND TWENTY SIXTEEN CAL HR ALSO
CONDUCTED A STATE EMPLOYEE TOTAL
COMPENSATION REPORT FOR THE
PROFESSIONAL SCIENTISTS WHICH
FOUND THAT STATE ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENTISTS SALLY LAGGED BEHIND
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
BY 5%.
AND 47% BEHIND THE PRIVATE
SECTOR.
WITH THAT I'M ASKING FOR AN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEM MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NO BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA.
I CHIANG.
NO DELEON [inaudible]
BY DORADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON.
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE I MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
I MITCHELL.
I MONEY.
BY MORE LUCK.
NO MORALE [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO NELSON [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
NOVAK.
NO I COUNTY [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILK [inaudible]
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN.
AYE AYE [inaudible]
I'M BERRYHILL [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
BY.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS ELEVEN
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM FORTY
FIVE MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY EIGHT
BY THE COMMAND BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND ACCOLADES TAXATION IN
MAKING PREPARATION FOR TO TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY BICU RELATE
TO THE BUDGET.
SENATE MITCHELL THANK YOU HAVE
THIS IS CLEAN UP TO THE FILM AND
TAX CREDIT BUDGET TRAILER BILL
THAT WAS PASSED EARLY THIS
SUMMER --
AND IN S. B. EIGHT SEVEN ONE
SPECIFICALLY THIS BILL MODIFY
THE DATE BY WHICH THE LA ALMOST
PREPARE REPORTS RELATED TO THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF ADMINISTRATION
OF THE FILM TAX CREDITS FROM.
HONOR BEFORE JULY ONE TWENTY
NINETEEN TO HONOR BEFORE JANUARY.
ONE TWENTY TWENTY THREE IT WILL
DEFINE QUOTE PREVIOUSLY
ALLOCATED CREDITS NOT CERTIFIED
IN QUOTE AND CLARIFIED THAT THE
CALIFORNIA FILM COMMISSION MAY
ALLOCATE SUCH CREDITS ON OR
AFTER JULY.
ONE TWENTY TWENTY FIVE THESE ARE
MINOR AND CLARIFYING CHANGES
ASKING FOR NINE BUCKS.
WE BE SENATOR MITCHELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE THING IN A
HURRY MEN MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
AYE ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA
I CHIANG.
AYE DELEON [inaudible]
DALY ON I DON'T I DON'T.
HI DOT AYE AYE FULLER
[inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
I GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER.
I HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON.
AYE OTTA AYE BY LEYVA.
I AM A CHOIR AYE MITCHELL.
I I MONNING.
AYE MORE LUCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN.
AYE STONE.
I FIGHT ACT.
I WORKOUT CD [inaudible]
I WINNER [inaudible]
I WILL [inaudible]
BY.
PLEASE GO THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL BETA [inaudible]
MARLA.
FIVETHIRTYEIGHT KNOWS ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CREAM CURD
AND FILE ITEM FORTY SIX MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY NINE
BY THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET
FISKER VIEW AND THAT CLING TO
PUBLIC SAFETY AND MAKING
APPROPRIATION THEREFORE TO TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY THEIR
RELIGION BUT SENATE MITCHELL.
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES THIS
TRAILER MAKES TECHNICAL CHANGES
AND TECHNICAL FUNDING
ADJUSTMENTS AS WELL AS NECESSARY
CLARIFICATIONS TO ACCOMPANY THE
BUDGET ACT ASKING FOR NINE VOTE.
BUT YOU CENTER MITCHELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING THEN MR
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON AYE ATKINS
[inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA.
I CHIANG.
AYE DELEON.
AYE DELGADO [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES.
I GOT JOINING.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA.
BY LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE [inaudible]
BY MITCHELL [inaudible]
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK [inaudible]
BY MORRELL [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
I STONE [inaudible]
I BIDAK.
I WHAT COUNTY [inaudible]
BY WINNER [inaudible]
I WILL [inaudible]
I PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
BAKES [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
BY.
BY IS THIRTY NINE THOSE ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM THIRTY
SIX MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL EIGHT FORTY SIX BY
THE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET FISCAL
REVIEW AND ACT GOING TO
EMPLOYMENT AND MAKING A PURPOSE
THEREFORE TO TAKE EFFECT
IMMEDIATELY BILL RELATED ABOUT
[inaudible]
SENATOR MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT --
THIS BILL REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT
GENERAL SERVICES TO PERIODICALLY
REVIEW [inaudible]
STATE CON THE MANUAL AND
REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION RELATED
PURCHASES FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
THE BILL ALSO CLARIFIES AN
EMPLOYEE HIRED BY THE KERN
COUNTY HOSPITAL AUTHORITY MAY
PARTICIPATE IN THE RETIREMENT
ASSOCIATION AS LONG WITH THE
DOES NOT IMPACT THE ASSOCIATIONS
TAX QUALIFIED STATUS.
UNDER FEDERAL LAW LAUGHTER THE
BILL STATES THAT SPECIFIED IN
THINGS ARE NOT LIABLE FOR CLAIMS
REGARDING AGENCY OR FAIR SHARE
FEES AS PRESCRIBED AND THAT
EMPLOYEE SHOULD NOT HAVE
STANDING TO PURSUE CLAIMS IF
FEES ARE PERMITTED.
PRIOR TO JUNE TWENTY SEVEN
TWENTY EIGHTEEN ASKING FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING MEN MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD AYE AYE AYE
CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
DELEON.
I DON'T GOT NO [inaudible]
I DONT.
I FULLER NAY.
GAINES [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL.
AYE HUESO [inaudible]
BY JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MITCHELL.
HI I MONEY.
I I MORE LOCKED.
NO MORALE.
NO.
WIN [inaudible]
NO NIELSEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
I SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK [inaudible]
MY COUNTY [inaudible]
YEAH WHILE I WINNER.
BY WILK [inaudible]
NO.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
FULLER.
BY TO ASK.
BY CITY SEVEN KNOWS TEN THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN SENATOR MITCHELL --
YES I'D LIKE TO TAKE UP FILE
ITEM ONCE I DO WE WANT TO DO.
ONE FORTY TWO DO WE WANT TO DO
RECONSIDERATION ON FILE ITEM
THIRTY EIGHT NOT YET I WANTED TO
TAKE UP A FILE ITEM ONE FORTY
TWO MISTER SECRETARY ESPY
EXAMINED.
FOR CAN WE DO THAT MY APOLOGIES
WE CERTAINLY TIME PROBLEM
[inaudible]
PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY BILL EIGHTEEN FORTY BY
THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUDGET
AND EXPLAINED EDUCATION FINANCE
AND MAKING APPROPRIATE THEREFORE
TO TAKE EFFECT REALLY BILL
RELATED BUDGET.
SENATE MITCHELL THANK YOU VERY
MUCH YES COLLEAGUES THIS IS AB
EIGHTEEN FORTY AND THAT'S THE
EDUCATION CLEAN UP TRAILER BILL.
THE BILL INCLUDES CHANGES IN THE
SUPPORTING OVERSIGHT OF SCHOOL
DISTRICTS IN FISCAL DISTRESS
WITH ADDITIONAL DUTIES ASSIGNED
TO COUNTY OFFICES OF EDUCATION
THE STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION THE
FISCAL CRISIS MANAGEMENT
ASSISTANCE TEAM.
IN REGARD TO OPEN UNIFIED IN
ENGLAND YOU INGLEWOOD UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT THE BILL
PROVIDES THAT THROUGH THE ANNUAL
BUDGET PROCESS ADDITIONAL FUNDS
MAY BE PROVIDED.
IF CERTAIN BENCHMARKS FOR
INCREASING FISCAL STABILITY ARE
MET.
THE BILL ALSO INCLUDES
CONDITIONS FOR THE SALE OR LEASE
OF SURPLUS PROPERTY BY SCHOOL
DISTRICTS WITH THE EMERGENCY
APPORTIONMENT LOANS.
THE BILL INCREASES FISCAL
TRANSPARENCY WITHIN THE LOCAL
CONTROL AND ACCOUNTABILITY PLAN
TO MAKE IT MORE ACCESSIBLE FOR
PARENTS AND STAKEHOLDERS.
THE BILL INCLUDES TWENTY ONE
MILLION FOR THE CHARTER SCHOOL
FACILITY GRANT PROGRAM THESE
FUNDS WERE ACCIDENTALLY EXCLUDE
EXCLUDED FROM THE PRIOR
EDUCATION TRAILER BILL.
THE BILL ALSO CLARIFIES THAT
INCREASES IN RATE ADJUSTMENT
FACTORS FOR CHILDCARE AND SLEEPY
SCHOOL PROGRAMS WILL BE
EFFECTIVE AS OF JANUARY.
BILL ESTABLISHES THE COMMUNITY
COLLEGE FUNDING FORMULA
OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE AND REQUIRES
IT TO MAKE SPECIFIED
RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE
LEGISLATURE.
PRIOR TO THE FULL IMPLEMENTATION
OF THE STUDENT FOCUSED FUNDING
FORMULA ASKING FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE CENTER
MORLOCK.
THANK YOU AND PRESIDENT SAYS
BILL.
WILL ALLOW FOR THE STATE.
TO LOAN DISTRICTS BETTER HAVING
BUDGET DEFICIT SEPTA TWENTY FIVE
FIFTY OR 75%.
BUT THE GOOD NEWS IS THAT GOD TO
HAVE A PLAN TO WORK OUT FROM
THERE FISCAL DISTRESS.
BUT IT DOES LEAVE A RATHER
[inaudible]
OMINOUS POTENTIAL.
A CASH FLOW.
CONCERN ON THE HORIZON SO I
WOULD ENCOURAGE THAT WE GET THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE IS CASH
FLOW MANAGEMENT SKILL SETS.
UP TO SPEED BECAUSE SOME
INTERESTING THINGS COULD HAPPEN
BUT AT LEAST THIS PLAN BEATS
WHAT WE'RE DOING WITH THE DMV
WHICH HAS.
JUST GIVING AS MUCH MONEY AS IT
TAKES TO ADDRESS A MISMANAGED
DEPARTMENT.
I ENCOURAGE MY BOAT ON AB.
EIGHTEEN FORTY YOU CENTER MODEL
MORLOCKS CENTER STONE.
THANK A MATTER PRESIDENT --
I RESPECTFULLY I'M GOING TO VOTE
NO ON AB EIGHTEEN FORTY THIS
TRAILER BILL.
WHILE I APPRECIATE --
THE LEGISLATURE HELPING
DISTRICTS HAD BEEN SIGNIFICANTLY
HURT BY THIS YEAR'S FILED FIRES
THIS BILL.
THAT'S A BACK PRESIDENT.
BY PUTTING THE STATE ON THE HOOK
FOR LOCAL DISTRICT BUDGET
PROBLEMS AND REWARD THEM FOR
ONGOING THIS MANAGEMENT WITHOUT
A MITIGATION PLAN TO SEE HOW
THEY'RE GOING TO COME OUT OF
THERE.
ECONOMIC DEBACLES EXTRA FUNDS TO
ASSIST MISS MANNERS SCHOOL
DISTRICTS SHOULD BE LOANS.
AND NOT HANDOUTS.
THOSE REASONS I URGE A NO VOTE.
YOU SENATOR STONE SENATOR
BRADFORD.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I WANT
TO APPLAUD THE BUDGET COMMITTEE
IN THE LEADERSHIP OF MY
COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES --
FOR BRINGING THIS MEASURE FOR
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE IN THE
GOVERNOR PROVIDING THE NECESSARY.
EIGHT TO DISTRICTS SUCH A SINGLE
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT BEEN
UNDER A DIFFICULT TIME.
DO A LOT OF STUDENTS --
UNDER ENROLLMENT --
THAT ARE MIGRATING TO OTHER
SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT HAVE
BROUGHT. FOR SOME OF THESE
CHALLENGES THIS IS BY NO MEANS A
BILL OUT ARE AUTOMATIC --
BILL OUT FOR THE US SCHOOL
DISTRICT BUT A COMPREHENSIVE
APPROACH TO HELP THE DISTRICTS
GET BACK ON TRACK.
ANY CLUES PACIFIC BIT BENCHMARKS
DESIGNED TO ELIMINATE DEFICITS
AND INCREASED SAVINGS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER BRADFORD SEEN
NO FURTHER DISCUSSION SENATOR
MITCHELL WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
I WOULD VERY MUCH --
MADAM PRESIDENT I THINK MY
COLLEAGUES FOR THEIR ARTICULATE.
A REPRESENTATION OF THE FACTS ON
THIS ISSUE AND ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ANDERSON NO ATKINS
[inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD%
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA.
I CHIANG.
AYE DELEON.
AYE DELGADO [inaudible]
I THOUGHT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
I LADA [inaudible]
LEYVA [inaudible]
BY MCGUIRE.
I MITCHELL AYE BY MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK.
I AM A REAL [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH [inaudible]
BY.
SKINNER.
AYE BY STERN [inaudible]
BY STONE.
NO BUT ACT.
I WOULD COUNTY.
I WIENER I WILK.
AYE.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
LADA [inaudible]
I I CITY FIVE KNOWS.
FOR THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS OR
THE MEASURE PASSES AND MADAME
PRESIDENT ELECT TO REQUEST
IMMEDIATE TRANSMITTAL TO THE
ASSEMBLY OF AB EIGHTEEN FORTY
THAT SHOULD BE THE ORDER
[inaudible]
SENATOR MITCHELL --
YES COLLEAGUES I HAVE VOTED TO
MORE --
ISSUES TO ADDRESS FIRST OF ALL
AT THE REQUEST OF OUR THE
REPUBLICAN LEADER I NEED TO ASK
FOR RECONSIDERATION ON FILE ITEM.
THIRTY EIGHT AS BE EIGHT SIX TWO
THANK YOU MEMBERS IS THERE
OBJECTION TO THE MOTION OF
RECONSIDERATION.
SITTING IN THE HEARING NONE
RECONSIDERATION IS GRANTED EYES
THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
FOR ITEM.
THIRTY EIGHT MEMBERS THIS IS
ITEM THIRTY EIGHT S. B. EIGHT
SIXTY TWO IT IS THE FIRST ONE
THAT MADAM BUDGET CHAIR DID.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
I BILL [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
DELEON.
I DON'T I DON'T.
TIE DOT [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG
[inaudible]
I HILL [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON.
I AYE LADA.
AYE LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE.
AYE MITCHELL AYE AYE MONEY.
I'M MORE LUCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NO NGUYEN.
I KNOW SON [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I PORTANTINO [inaudible]
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN AYE STONE [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
BIDAK [inaudible]
IOWA COUNTY.
I WIENER.
AYE WILK [inaudible]
NO.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS BERRYHILL CHIANG
[inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
MORLOCK.
EYES THIRTY KNOWS SEVEN THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN.
MANY BUDGET CHAIR.
I GUESS WE MOVE TO MOST OF THE
RESOLUTIONS OF ANIMAL SOME ITEMS
TO THE NOW REAR I'LL IF I MAY WE
WILL MOVE TO MOTIONS AND
RESOLUTIONS ABSOLUTELY
APPRECIATE THAT --
I'D LIKE TO MOVE FILE ITEM
EIGHTY SEVEN FUSE ME FILE ITEM
NINETY SEVEN A. B..
EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINE FILE ITEM
NINETY EIGHT AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY
FIVE FILE ITEM NINETY NINE AB.
EIGHTEEN FORTY THREE FILE ITEM
ONE HUNDRED A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY
FOUR FILE ITEM ONE OH ONE AB
EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE FILE ITEM
ONE THOUGH TO A. B..
NINETEEN FORTY SIX FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTY ONE A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY
ONE FILE IEM ONE THIRTY NINE AB.
EIGHTEEN TWENTY EIGHT FILE ITEM
ONE FORTY AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY TWO
FILE ITEM ONE FORTY ONE A BE
EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE AND FILE
ITEM.
ONE FORTY THREE A. B. EIGHTEEN
FORTY THREE TO THE INACTIVE FILE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MITCHELL ALSO
WILL BE THE ORDER [inaudible]
SENATOR GALGIANI.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS OF MY TO MOVE FILE ITEM
ONE OH NINE AB TWENTY ONE
SEVENTY ONE TO THE INACTIVE FILE
THE DESK WILL NOTE SENATOR LAURA.
THANK YOU GONNA PRESIDENT I HAVE
A LETTER TO THE JOURNAL TO
CLARIFY THE INTENT.
OF S. B. TEN THIRTEEN THAT'S
BEEN APPROVED BY BOTH SIDES
THANK YOU.
SEEING NO OTHER SENATOR MONNING
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT UNDER
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS MEMBERS
IS A RESOLUTION OF THE DESK
REQUESTING PERMISSION TO SUSPEND.
JOINT RULE SIXTY ONE FOR THE
PURPOSE OF ALLOWING THE
FOLLOWING ASSEMBLY BILL ELEVEN
EIGHTY FOUR TO BE HEARD AND
REPORTED BY COMMITTEE.
THIS REQUEST HAS BEEN APPROVED
BY THE RULES COMMITTEE ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONNING MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
RESULT THE JOINT RULE SIXTY ONE
BE DISPENSED WITH TO ALLOW SOME
A BILL ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR TO BE
HEARD AND REPORTED BY POLICY IN
FISCAL COMMITTEES AFTER THE
DEADLINES.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
I ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BILL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CANNELLA [inaudible]
I CHIANG [inaudible]
NO DELEON [inaudible]
I DELGADO.
AYE DODD.
AYE FULLER [inaudible]
NO GAINES [inaudible]
NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
I GLAZER [inaudible]
I HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
BY LARA.
AYE LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE
[inaudible]
BY MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I MORE LUCK [inaudible]
MORRELL [inaudible]
NGUYEN.
NO NELSON.
NO PAN [inaudible]
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
AYE SKINNER.
BY STERN.
AYE STONE [inaudible]
NO BIDAK [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
LIKE COUNTY [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
I I WAS TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS EIGHT
THE JOINT RULES ARE SUSPENDED
SENATOR MONNING.
THANK YOU MEMBERS I MOVE JOINT
RULE SIXTY TWO A TO BE WAIVED
FOR THE NATURAL RESOURCES IN
WATER COMMITTEE. TO ME IN HERE
ASSEMBLY BILL ELEVEN EIGHTY FOUR
WITHOUT THE FOUR DAYS NOTICE IN
THE DAILY FILE.
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU CENTER MONNING MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
THE PREVIOUS ROLL CALL VOTE.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN DOES.
EIGHT THE JOINT RULES ARE
SUSPENDED [inaudible]
SENATOR MONNING --
UNDER UPDATES --
FRIENDS WE'RE GOING TO NOW MOVE
TO LIFT BECAUSE FOLLOWING THE
LIFTING OF THE BILLS ON CALL.
WERE GONNA TAKE UP THREE NEW
ASSEMBLY BILLS.
THEN WE'RE GONNA DO OUR CONSENT
CALENDAR.
THEN WE'RE GONNA RECONNOITERING
GIVE YOU AN UPDATE AT THAT POINT
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER MONNING ONE
MOMENT.
MEMBERS WE ARE STILL UNDER
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS.
WITHOUT OBJECTION THE ACTION
TAKEN ON A. B. THIRTY ONE
FIFTEEN ON AUGUST TWENTY SEVENTH
TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN REFERRING
THE BILLS TO THE RULES COMMITTEE
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE TWENTY
NINE TEN SEE.
WILL BE RESCINDED AND REPLACED
WITH THE ACTION RE REFERENCE TO
RULES.
WITHOUT OBJECTION THE FOLLOWING
SENATE BILLS WILL BE PLACED ON
TODAY'S SPECIAL CONSENT CALENDAR.
S. B. TWO SIXTY ONE SP THREE
FORTY THREE S. B. FIVE OH ONE S.
B. NINE SIXTY S. B..
NINE SIXTY SIX S. B. NINE SIXTY
EIGHT S. B..
NINE SEVENTY S. B..
ONE THOUSAND S. B..
TEN FORTY ONE S. B..
TEN FIFTY S. B. TEN SEVENTY ONE
S. B..
TEN EIGHTY THREE SB.
TEN EIGHTY SEVEN SPT.
S. B. ELEVEN FIFTEEN S. B.
ELEVEN TWENTY THREE SB ELEVEN
THIRTY ONE SB.
ELEVEN FORTY EIGHT SB ELEVEN
SIXTY FOUR AND S. C. R..
ONE FOURTEEN MEMBERS WE ARE JUST
GIVING THE CALL LIST TOGETHER
AND THEY WILL START LIFTING
CALLS
MEMBERS PLEASE DO NOT
LEAVE THE RED CARPET WILL BE
RATE A LIFT CALLS IN ABOUT TWO
MINUTES
I TO LIFTING CALLS WE
ARE GOING TO TAKE UP.
FILE ITEM [inaudible]
ONE FIFTY ONE SENATOR NGUYEN
[inaudible]
MISTER SECRETARY [inaudible]
PLEASE READ.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO EIGHTY FIVE BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER GONZALEZ FLETCHER
RELATIVE TO DIAPER NEED
AWARENESS WEEK.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY
SENATOR NGUYEN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT ACR.
TWO EIGHT FIVE ACR TO EIGHT FIVE
A RECOGNIZE SEPTEMBER TWENTY
FOURTH THROUGH SEPTEMBER
THIRTIETH.
OF THIS YEAR AS NATIONAL DIAPER
NEED AWARENESS WEEK ACCESS TO
RELIABLE SUPPLY OF CLEAN DIAPER
IS NECESSARY FOR THE HEALTH AND
WELL BEING OF INFANTS AND
TODDLERS.
THEIR FAMILIES AND THE CHILD
CARE PROVIDERS AS WELL ONE IN
THERE ONE AND THREE FAMILIES
EXPERIENCE DIAPER NEED.
AND NEARLY HALF OF FAMILIES.
THE SURVEY REPORTED DELAY
CHANGING.
DIRTY DIAPER TO EXTEND THOSE
SUPPLY.
I OF THIS BILL HAS RECEIVE
UNANIMOUS SUPPORT I RESPECTFULLY
ASK ME AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR NGUYEN.
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SITTING IN HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
MEMBERS WE ARE ALSO GOING TO
TAKE UP FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY
SENATOR PAN MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SOME A CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
RESOLUTION TO SEVENTY SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MEDINA RELATIVE
TO EPILEPSY AWARENESS MONTH.
SENATOR PAN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATORS TODAY PRESENT
ACR TWO SEVEN SEVEN BY SUMMER
MEDINA WHICH PROCLAIMS NOVEMBER
TWENTY EIGHTEEN IT'S UP.
ABOUT ONE IN TEN PEOPLE IN THE
UNITED STATES HAS.
A SINGLE HAVE HAD A SINGLE
UNPROVOKED SEIZURE ARE
[inaudible]
EPILEPSY MANY PEOPLE LIVING WITH
APPS THAT LET'S SEE FACE A SENSE
OF DISCRIMINATION ISOLATION FROM
THEIR PEERS.
WE CAN HELP THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN
AFFECTED BY BRAIN AWARENESS OF
THE CONDITION.
ALLEVIATING THE FEAR
DISCRIMINATION AND BARRIERS TO
EMPLOYMENT EXPERIENCED BY PEOPLE
LIVING WITH EPILEPSY
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
ACR TWO SEVEN SEVEN CALLS UPON
ALL CITIZENS GOVERNMENT AGENCIES
PUBLIC AND PRIVATE INSTITUTIONS
BUSINESSES AND SCHOOLS TO
RECOMMIT.
OUR COMMUNITY TO INCREASING
AWARENESS UNDER AND
UNDERSTANDING OF THOSE WHO LIVE
WITH EPILEPSY I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THINKING SENATOR PAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION USING A UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES ROOM TO MOVE TO
FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY SIX SENATOR
PAN.
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT RESOLUTION
TO A TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
GLORIA RELATIVE TO FILIPINO
AMERICAN HISTORY MONTH.
SENATOR PAN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATORS ON BEHALF OF
THE ASIAN PACIFIC ISLANDER --%
LET'S SAY CAUCUS I'M PROUD TO
PRESENT ACR TWO EIGHTY TWO BY
SOME MEMBER GLORIA WHICH IT
RECOGNIZE OCTOBER.
TWENTY EIGHTEEN S. FILIPINO
AMERICAN HISTORY MONTH FROM THE
FARM WORKER MOVEMENT DECADES AGO
TO THOSE CURRENTLY CONTRIBUTING
TO SUCCESS OF OUR STATE IS
IMPORTANT THAT WE RECOGNIZE HOW.
ESSENTIAL FILIPINO AMERICANS
HAVE BEEN TO THE PROSPERITY OF
CALIFORNIA.
HOWEVER THIS RESOLUTION IS NOT
JUST ABOUT DESIGNATING ONE MONTH
OF THE YEAR TO A NUMBER OF OUR
CONSTITUENTS BASED SIMPLY ON THE
ORIGINS FROM THE GROUP OF
ISLANDS OUT IN THE PACIFIC.
RATHER WE CELEBRATE THIS MONTH
AS WITH THEIR CONSTITUENTS PATH
TO ASK THAT WE CONSIDER THIS
RESOLUTION IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
HIGHLIGHT AND REFLECT THE
QUALITIES OF SOME A FILIPINO
AMERICANS.
HAVE MADE THEIR MARK ON
CALIFORNIA AND ON THE ENTIRE
COUNTRY I SPECT WE ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SITTING IN HEARING MEN MEMBERS
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING NONE EYES
THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
ART MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO LIFT
CALLS AT THIS TIME.
WE ARE GOING TO START WITH FILE
ITEM.
FORTY SEVEN MR SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
JACKSON [inaudible]
MITCHELL [inaudible]
STERN [inaudible]
MITCHELL I EYES TWENTY EIGHT
KNOWS EIGHT THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM FORTY EIGHT PLEASE LIFT THE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES [inaudible]
I FELL [inaudible]
BY BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I DELEON [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
I HERTZBERG [inaudible]
I JACKSON [inaudible]
NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN.
BUT ASK.
OUR AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I CITY.
ONE KOBE ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE
TIME PLEASE FILE ITEM
[inaudible]
FORTY EIGHT BERRYHILL.
DALY OWNED.
BY [inaudible]
JACKSON [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
BUT EYES THIRTY TWO KNOWS FOR
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA
GO TO FILE ITEM FIFTY FIVE FIFTY
SIX FIFTY THREE FIFTY EIGHT AND
SEVENTY STARTING WITH FILE ITEM
FIFTY FIVE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
NOBEL.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I CHANGE.
NO DALY OWN [inaudible]
I GAINES [inaudible]
NO HERNANDEZ.
I MORE LOCK [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
EYES TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS TEND THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM FIFTY SIX PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BATES.
BY BERRYHILL BRADFORD.
I DALY OWN [inaudible]
I FULLER [inaudible]
MONNING [inaudible]
BY NIELSEN.
NGUYEN NOTE I NUYS THIRTY SIX
KNOWS ONE THING ASSEMBLYMAN
MINCE ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
FIFTY THREE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
I I I CITY SEVEN EIGHT NO
[inaudible]
BATES AYE.
NON PROBLEM EYES THIRTY EIGHT
KNOWS ONE THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
IT'S ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
FIFTY EIGHT MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BATES [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
DELEON [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I PAINT [inaudible]
I FIVE THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
ASSEMBLYMAN MENTOR CONCURRED IN
FILE ITEM SEVENTY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BY BERRYHILL [inaudible]
JIANG [inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
I NIELSEN [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
PARA [inaudible]
CHANG I THERE'S NOT.
ICE THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ANTS ARE
CONCURRED IN.
FILE ITEM SIXTY NINE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ANDERSON [inaudible]
ATKINS.
BY.
ANDERSON AYE.
BERRYHILL DE LEóN [inaudible]
I PAN.
I AYE AYES THIRTY NINE NO ZERO
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S OUR
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM SEVENTY
FIVE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
ATKINS.
I BERRYHILL BRADFORD
[inaudible]
I DELEON.
I DON'T I DON'T [inaudible]
I NGUYEN [inaudible]
NO PAN [inaudible]
I EYES TWENTY SIX KNOWS THIRTEEN
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S R.
CONCURRED IN.
MOVING TO FILE ITEM.
929-092-1051 THIRTEEN ONE
SIXTEEN AND ONE EIGHTEEN WILL
START WITH FILE ITEM NINETY TWO
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
BRADFORD [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
I SKINNER [inaudible]
I BRADFORD I EYES THIRTY NINE NO
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES FILE
ITEM ONE OH FIVE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
HI MORLOCK [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
SKINNER.
CANNELLA AYE SKINNER.
EYES THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ONE THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTEEN PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CHIANG [inaudible]
I DODD [inaudible]
I MITCHELL [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
BIDAK.
MITCHELL MITCHELL AYE BIDAK AYE
[inaudible]
SKINNER.
I CITY NINE NOS ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES FILE ITEM ONE SIXTEEN
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
HI [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
NO BERRYHILL [inaudible]
JIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
THE I GALGIANI [inaudible]
MORLOCK [inaudible]
NGUYEN [inaudible]
ROTH.
ROTH AYE STERN.
AYE BIDAK [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
GALGIANI I EYES TWENTY SEVEN
KNOWS TEN THE MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM ONE EIGHTEEN PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
BELL [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
FOR CHIANG [inaudible]
DE LEóN [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
MCGUIRE [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
ROTH [inaudible]
SKINNER [inaudible]
I STERN [inaudible]
BIDAK [inaudible]
I WACHOWSKI [inaudible]
BY [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
WIENER I WAS THIRTEEN NO
SEVENTEEN THE MEASURE FAILS FILE
ITEM ONE THIRTY THREE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
ATKINS.
BY BERRYHILL.
CHIANG [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
DELGADO [inaudible]
I HUESO [inaudible]
BY MORNING [inaudible]
BY PAN [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
WIENER.
I SWINGS SIX NEWS THIRTEEN THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTY EIGHT PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ATKINS [inaudible]
I BERRYHILL [inaudible]
MONNING [inaudible]
I PAN [inaudible]
I WIENER.
AYE AYES THIRTY NINE NEW ZERO
THE MEASURE PASSES BUT ITEM ONE
THIRTY SEVEN PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
ATKINS.
I BERRYHILL.
FULLER [inaudible]
I MONNING [inaudible]
PAN [inaudible]
I WIENER [inaudible]
WE ARE.
ICE THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES FILE AND ONE
FORTY FIVE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
BATES [inaudible]
BERRYHILL [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
JANE.
A AYES TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS NINE
THE MEASURE PASSES FINALLY THE
ONE FORTY SIX PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
BATES.
NO BERRYHILL FULLER [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
JACKSON.
EYES TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS ELEVEN
THE MEASURE PASSES.
RIGHT MEMBERS WE HAVE COVERED
ALL OF THE ITEMS THAT WERE ON
CALL GIVE US ONE MOMENT
.
WE ARE GOING TO TAKE UP THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
IF YOU HAVE AN ITEM THAT YOU
WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE FROM
CONSENT.
IF YOU HAVE AN ITEM THAT YOU
WOULD LIKE TO REMOVE FROM
CONSENT THIS IS THE APPROPRIATE
TIME TO DO SO.
SEEING NO MICROPHONES UP MR
SECRETARY PLEASE READ THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
SENATE BILL. TWO SIXTY ONE THREE
FORTY THREE FIVE A
ONE NINE
SIXTY NINE SIXTY SIX NINE SIXTY
EIGHT NINE SEVENTY ONE THOUSAND
TEN FORTY ONE TEN FIFTY TEN
SEVENTY ONE TEN EIGHTY THREE TEN
EIGHTY SEVEN TO NINETY SEVEN
ELEVEN FIFTEEN ELEVEN TWENTY
THREE ELEVEN THIRTY ONE ELEVEN
FORTY EIGHT ELEVEN SIXTY FOUR
SENATE.
CONCURRENT RESOLUTION.
ONE FOURTEEN SENATE BILL.
TWO TWENTY FOUR SENATE BILL.
816-881-1380 SEVEN FOURTEEN A
THREE FORTY NO.
SIX FOURTEEN EIGHTY TO FOURTEEN
NINETY ONE THANK YOU MISTER
SECRETARY MEMBERS IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING UNANIMOUS.
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL FOR THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
SEEING AND HEARING THEM ICE
THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
CONSENT CALENDAR IS ADOPTED
SENATOR MITCHELL.
UNDER BUSH THE RESOLUTION PLEASE
PROCEED OUR RIGHTS REQUEST
UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO SUBMIT A
LETTER TO THE JOURNAL FOR MY SP
TEN EIGHTY THREE TO CLARIFY THE
INTENT OF THE BILL IT WAS JUST
PASSED.
ON AND THE CONSENT CALENDAR
WITHOUT OBJECTION.
SENATOR MONNING FOR WHAT PURPOSE
TO RISE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT WERE.
GONNA BE WRAPPING UP WITH SOME
ANNOUNCEMENTS IS THERE'S A
NUMBER OF COMMITTEE MEETINGS
THAT ARE GONNA MEET UPON
ADJOURNMENT.
AMONG THEM ANNOUNCE IF YOU PAY
ATTENTION AND ANNOUNCE THE ROOMS
BECAUSE THEIR SEQUENTIAL.
COMMITTEE STACKING UP ON THE
ADJOURNMENT OF THE PRIOR ALL
THEN GIVE A QUICK BILL COUNT FOR
THE DAY INTERNET OVER TO THE PRO
TEM.
PAY ATTENTION MEMBERS IN ROOM
THREE ONE NINE ONE ON
ADJOURNMENT.
FIRST COMMITTEE WILL BE
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENTS. THREE ONE NINE ONE
FOLLOWED IN THREE ONE NINE ONE
BY ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.
UPON ADJOURNMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY HUMAN
SERVICES.
THOSE THREE COMMITTEES IN ROOM.
THREE ONE NINE ONE IN ROOM.
ONE TWELVE GOVERNMENTS AND
FINANCE FIFTEEN MINUTES AFTER
ADJOURNMENT.
FOLLOWED BY JUDICIARY.
SO GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
FOLLOWED BY JUDICIARY IN ROOM.
ONE TWELVE IN ROOM FORTY TO A
THREE ON ADJOURNMENT
[inaudible]
HEALTH COMMITTEE.
FOLLOWED BY EDUCATION COMMITTEE
THAT'S FROM FORTY TWO OH THREE
HEALTH COMMITTEE.
UPON ADJOURNMENT FOLLOWED BY
EDUCATION.
MEMBERS DINNER WILL BE SERVED
HERE SO YOU'RE WELCOME --
BASED ON YOUR COMMITTEE
OBLIGATIONS TO GET SOME DINNER
HERE MEMBERS HERE'S THE WORK
THAT WE'VE COMPLETED TODAY.
WE CONCURRED ON SIXTY FIVE
SENATE BILLS. SEVENTEEN ASSEMBLY
BILLS PASSED --
AND WE WILL ADJOURN TO OUR
COMMITTEES WE'RE GONNA HAVE A
FULL DAY AND EVENING TOMORROW
NIGHT -- YOU
SHOULD PLAN TO GO TO MIDNIGHT
AND POSSIBLY PAST MIDNIGHT.
BECAUSE WE CAN GO PAST MIDNIGHT --
BUT WE WILL.
BE ADJOURNING THEY'LL BE NO
SESSION TONIGHT AFTER COMMITTEES
WILL BE DONE --
THAT'S THE PLAN WE DONE THE WORK
THAT WE CAN DO.
MORE WILL BE COMING THIS WAY.
SO WE'RE GONNA GET A EARLY START
TOMORROW --
WELL I'VE STILL GOT THE
MICROPHONE MADAME PRESIDENT
UNDER MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS.
AT THE REQUEST OF THE AUTHOR
I'VE BEEN ASKED TO MOVE THAT
ITEM.
ONE TWELVE AB FIFTEEN SIXTY
REMOVED TO THE INACTIVE FILE.
THE DESK WILL NOTE THINK IF
ANYONE'S CONFUSED ABOUT THEIR
COMMITTEE LOCATION COMMON I'VE
GOT THE LIST AND MADAM PRESIDENT
NOW TO THE PRO TEM THANK YOU
THANK YOU CENTER MONNING MEMBERS
IF THERE IS NO FURTHER BUSINESS.
SENATOR ATKINS A DESK IS CLEAR
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
COLLEAGUES --
WE'VE WORKED AS MUCH AS WE CAN
TODAY WE'VE DONE ALL THAT WE CAN --
AND I THINK IT'S A GOOD THAT WE
GET OUR COMMITTEES DONE I WOULD
URGE YOU ALL TO HAVE AN EARLY
NIGHT.
AND GET A GOOD NIGHT'S SLEEP.
BECAUSE TOMORROW NIGHT WILL NOT
BE THIS EARLY SO I THANK YOU FOR
YOUR WORK TODAY.
WE WILL ADJOURN AND RECONVENE
FRIDAY AUGUST THIRTY FIRST AT
TEN AM.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THE
COMMAND APPROACH WE WILL
RECONVENE TOMORROW AT TEN A. M..
A GREAT EVENING