COMMITTEE TO MEET.
LET US SO PLEASE GO AHEAD.
AND ESTABLISH A CORE.
JACKSON HERE JACKSON HERE MORE
LOOK.
MORE LIKE HERE ANDERSON
HERTZBERG MINING.
MINING HERE STERN CASKEY.
CASKEY HERE.
WARM IS PRESENT WE WILL NOW
TURN.
TO OF THE MEASURE THAT IS BEFORE
US TODAY THIS IS A C. R.. TO
FIFTEEN TO TWENTY THREE
ASILOMAR.
OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
PRINCIPLES.
I DON'T NEED TO RECITE THE RULES
BECAUSE YOU ONLY HAVE ONE
WITNESS AND I DON'T THINK WE'LL
HAVE TO MANY WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION BUT GENERALLY WE HAVE
TWO WITNESSES TWO MINUTES EACH.
WE'LL GIVE YOU A CHANCE PERHAPS
THREE OR FOUR MINUTES IF YOU
WOULD LIKE --
ON WHAT IS A VERY INTERESTING
AND I THINK --
ANXIETY CAUSING THE SITUATION SO
WITH THAT --
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KYLIE FOOD LIKE
TO PROCEED.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND IT IS
--
AN HONOR TO BE HERE BEFORE THE
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND
HAVE A CHANCE TO PRESENT --
I APPRECIATE YOU I I FOR A FOR
MY RESOLUTION TODAY I THINK IT'S
YOUR ONLY ITEM ON THE AGENDA BUT
I THINK YOU'LL FIND IT
WORTHWHILE AS ITS US CERTAINLY
AND AS YOU SAY INTERESTING AND
IMPORTANT TOPIC --
SO THIS IS A SOMEWHAT CONCURRENT
RESOLUTION.
TO FIFTEEN THROUGH WHICH OUR
LEGISLATURE WERE EXPRESSED ITS
SUPPORT FOR THE ASILOMAR
PRINCIPLES AS GUIDING VALUES FOR
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE.
THE LAST FEW YEARSTHE
CAPABILITY OF ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE HAS REACHED
MILESTONES THAT SOME PREDICTED
WERE EITHER UNACHIEVABLE WERE
STILL DECADES AWAY.
PROVIDING A GLIMPSE OF THE
UNBOUNDED POTENTIAL FOR ECONOMIC
AND SOCIAL IMPACT.
IN MARCH OF TWENTY SIXTEEN
GOOGLE DEEP MINES ALFA GO BEAT
THE WORLD'S REIGNING AGO
CHAMPION.
USING TACTICS THAT EXCEEDED IN
SOPHISTICATION AND ELEGANCE
STRATEGIES DEVELOPED OVER TWO
MILLENNIA OF HUMAN EXPERIENCE.
IN NOVEMBER OF TWENTY SEVENTEEN
TESLA ANNOUNCED THAT ITS
VEHICLES HAD COLLECTIVELY DRIVEN
OVER THREE HUNDRED MILLION MILES
USING AUTONOMOUS STEERING AND
NAVIGATION.
SURPASSING BY UP 240% THE SAFETY
RECORD OF HUMAN DRIVERS.
AND JUST LAST MAY GOOGLE
UNVEILED A NEW TYPE OF A. I.
ASSISTANT WHICH USES A LANGUAGE
INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM THAT OF A
NATIVE SPEAKER TO MAKE
RESERVATIONS BOOK FLIGHTS AND
SCHEDULE MEETINGS OVER THE
PHONE.THIS IS JUST THE
BEGINNING.
OVER THE NEXT FEW YEARS
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IS POISE
TO DISRUPT DOMAINS THAT INCLUDE
HEALTHCARE LAW FINANCE
MANUFACTURING IDEA EDUCATION AND
YES EVEN GOVERNMENT.
IN EACH AREA HEY I CARRIES THE
POTENTIAL TO DRAMATICALLY
IMPROVE ECONOMIC PROSPERITY AND
HUMAN WELL BEING.
SO LONG AS IT IS DEVELOPED IN A
MANNER THAT ENSURES SECURITY
RELIABILITY AND CONSONANCE WITH
HUMAN VALUES.
THE PURPOSE OF TODAY'S
RESOLUTION IS TO IDENTIFY A SET
OF SHARED VALUES SECOND UNDERPIN
COLLABORATION BETWEEN POLICY
MAKERS AI RESEARCHERS AND OTHER
STAKEHOLDERS AS WE WORK TOGETHER
TO REALIZE THE POSITIVE
POTENTIAL OF ARTIFICIAL.
INTELLIGENCE.
THE ASILOMAR PRINCIPLES ALL
TWENTY THREE OF WHICH ARE SET
FORTH IN TODAY'S RESOLUTION WERE
DEVELOPED HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
THEY GET THEIR NAME FROM THE
CONVENTION SITE NEAR PACIFIC
GROVE WHERE IN JANUARY TWENTY
SEVENTEEN THE WORLD'S LEADING
THE A. I. RESEARCHERS A CONDOM
IS LEGAL SCHOLARS AND
PHILOSOPHERS.
MET TO DISCUSS HOW BEST TO
ENSURE A EYES DEVELOP SAFELY.
AND ETHICALLY.
PRINCIPLES ADOPTED ASILOMAR
STRESSED THE NEED FOR SAFETY
TRANSPARENCY PRIVACY AND
ALIGNMENT WITH HUMAN VALUES.
NOTABLY ONE OF THE PRINCIPALS
PROVIDES THAT THERE SHOULD BE
CONSTRUCTIVE AND HEALTHY
EXCHANGE BETWEEN A I RESEARCHERS
AND POLICY MAKERS.
ANOTHER STATES THAT THE
APPLICATION OF A I'D A PERSONAL
DATA MUST NOT UNREASONABLY
CURTAIL PEOPLE'S REASONABLE OR
PEOPLE'S REAL OR PERCEIVED
LIBERTY.
AND ANOTHER SETS FORTH THE POWER
CONFERRED BY CONTROL OF HIGHLY
ADVANCED A. I. SYSTEMS SHOULD
RESPECT AND IMPROVE RATHER THAN
SUBVERT.
THE SOCIAL AND CIVIC PROCESS HE
IS IT DEPENDS.
THE ASILOMAR PRINCIPLES HAVE
BEEN INDEPENDENTLY ENDORSED BY
MORE THAN TWELVE HUNDRED LEADING
EXPERTS IN THE FIELD OF A YACHT
A YACHT.
INCLUDING THE LATE STEPHEN
HAWKING HE LAWN MOSS AND DENNIS
A SOB AS FOUNDER OF THE MIND.
BY ENDORSING THESE PRINCIPLES
TODAY WE WILL JOIN IN THE
RECOGNITION OF SHARED VALUES
THAT CAN BE APPLIED TO RESEARCH
DEVELOPMENT AND LONG TERM
PLANNNG.
HELPING TO REINFORCE
CALIFORNIA'S CONTENDED THAT
COMPETITIVE EDGE IN THE FIELD OF
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE WHILE
ASSURING THAT ITS BENEFITS ARE
MANIFOLD AND WIDESPREAD.
THE RESOLUTION ITSELF IS
SPONSORED BY THE FUTURE OF LIFE
INSTITUTE AN ORGANIZATION
FOUNDED BY MIT PROFESSOR MAX
TEGMARK AND YOU SEE A SANTA CRUZ
ROFESSOR ANTHONY AGAIN RIGHT
THAT'S COMMITTED TO A I SAFETY
RESEARCH.
AND DEVELOPMENT OF BENEFICIAL
ALLY.
HERE TODAY TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
OF AC ARE TWO FIFTEEN AS JESSICA
COUSINS AND A I POLICY
SPECIALIST AT THE FUTURE OF LIFE
INSTITUTE.
THANK YOU AND GOOD AFTERNOON.
GOOD AFTERNOON AND THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME TODAY IT'S AN HONOR TO
BE HERE.
MY NAME IS JESSICA COUSINS AND I
AM A I POLICY SPECIALIST AT THE
FUTURE OF LIFE INSTITUTE FOR AT
THE LINE.
AND NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
WORKING TO DETERMINE POSITIVE
WAYS TO HARNESS CONSEQUENTIAL
TECHNOLOGIES SUCH AS ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE.
I'M HERE TODAY IN STRONG SUPPORT
OF AC ARE.
TWO ONE FIVE TO FIFTEEN A
RESOLUTION THAT IS AN IMPORTANT
AND HISTORIC SHOW OF SUPPORT
ACROSS SECTORS TOWARDS OUR
COMMON GOAL OF ENABLING SAFE AND
BENEFICIAL A I AS PROFOUND
SOCIETAL IMPACTS TODAY I ARE NOW
BEING REALIZED.
FROM FACIAL RECOGNITION
TECHNOLOGY INTO DRONES
SURVEILLANCE AND THE SPREAD OF
TARGETED DISINFORMATION
CAMPAIGNS.
PEOPLE ARE WAKING UP TO THE FACT
THAT A I IS A DUAL USE
TECHNOLOGY.
IT IS BOTH AN INCREDIBLY
EXCITING TOOL FOR INDUSTRY AND
SERVICES.
AND THE THREAT OF CYBER SECURITY
POLITICAL AND AND NATIONAL
DEFENSE.
WE URGENTLY NEED TO DEVELOP
NORMS FOR A. I. THAT COUNTERACTS
DANGEROUS RACE DYNAMICS.
AND INSTEAD CENTER ON TRUST
SECURITY AND THE COMMON GOOD.
I THOUGHT I WAS HONORED TO LEAD
THE DEVELOPMENT AT THE ASYLUM
ARE A I PRINCIPLES THROUGH
COLLABORATIVE AN ITERATIVE
PROCESS IN TWO THOUSAND
SEVENTEEN AM PACIFIC GROVE
CALIFORNIA.
THE PRINCIPLES REPRESENT BROAD
AREAS OF CONSENSUS.
AND SINCE THE INAUGURAL MEETING
AND THEY HAVE DRAWN SUPPORT FROM
THOUSANDS OF RESPECTED A I
RESEARCHERS AND LEADERS.
THE PRINCIPLES REMAIN UNIQUELY
INFLUENTIAL AND WIDELY
RECOGNIZED GLOBALLY.
INDUSTRY AND CIVIL SOCIETY
INITIATIVES LIKE THAT SOME ARE A
I PRINCIPLES HAVE BEEN AN
IMPORTANT FIRST STEP TOWARDS
BUILDING A CULTURE THAT TAKE
SAFETY AND ETHICAL
CONSIDERATIONS SERIOUSLY.
BUT WE KNOW THAT IT'S NOT
ENOUGH.
WHAT IS URGENTLY NEEDED NOW IS
THAT COLLABORATION BETWEEN
POLICY MAKERS AND RESEARCHERS?
AROUND THE WORLD ARE SEEING A
RAPID INCREASE OF INTEREST FROM
POLICYMAKERS AND SIGNS OF THEIR
SOLIDARITY WITH INDUSTRY AND
CIVIL SOCIETY. FOR EXAMPLE OVER
THE LAST FEW MONTHS THE EUROPEAN
COMMISSION CREATED A HIGH LEVEL
GROUP ON A I OTHER EXPERTS FROM
ACROSS INDUSTRY BUSINESS AND
CIVIL SOCIETY TO ASSIST IN THAT
REGION ON A. I. STRATEGY IN
POLICY MAKING.
TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE BECAUSE A
I IS BECOMING MORE POWERFUL
EVERY DAY.
AND IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE TAKE
THE STEPS TO RECOGNIZE A FREE
MARKET SHARED VALUES.
AND AS A LEADER IN MANY OF THE
RESPONSIBLE TECHNOLOGIES OF THE
FUTURE CALIFORNIA IS THE IDEAL
HOME FOR RESOLUTION OF THIS
KIND.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
CONCERN FORESIGHT IN
CONSIDERATION OF THE SUPPORT
MATTER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THEIR
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION ARE
YOU IN SPORTS ARE.
VERY GOOD DROVE COOK FOR THE
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS AND
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION WE'RE IN
SUPPORT THANKS.
THANK YOU.
MANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE LET'S BRING IT BACK
TO THE DIET SINO CENTER WHERE
CASKEY HAD SOME QUESTIONS AND
THEN FALL BY SENATOR.
MOANING AND SENATOR MORE LIKE AN
OLD CLOSE IT OUT.
I'M ON THE END OF PAGE NINE OF
THAT AS STAFF ANALYSIS THEY'RE
TALKING ABOUT ARTIFICIAL GENERAL
INTELLIGENCE THIS.
AS EMBRACED IN PRINCIPLE
NINETEEN WE'RE GOING --
TO IF THE IF THE VESSEL MORE
PRINCIPLES ARE GENERALLY GOOD
EMBRACE THAT I DON'T QUITE
UNDERSTAND WHAT THAT IS IF YOU
COULD.
EXPLAIN TO ME TAKE THAT.
ONE YOU'RE ASKING AND WHAT
ARTIFICIAL GENERAL INTELLIGENCE
IS OR WHAT THE RELATION AS WITH
THE ALLEGATIONS [inaudible]
THE CREATED BY --
III APPLICATIONS I ASSUME.
SO I THINK FEE THIS SUMMER AT
PRINCIPLES AND THEMSELVES --
AREN'T SAYING NECESSARILY WHERE
I A I DEVELOPMENT IS GOING TO GO
THAT IT WILL NECESSARILY CREATE
AN ARTIFICIAL GENERAL
INTELLIGENCE OR SUPER
INTELLIGENCE WHICH WOULD BE A
RECURSIVE FORM OF INTELLIGENCE
THAT.
AND DIDN'T NEED HUMAN
INTELLIGENCE TO LEARN FROM THAT
WAS ACTUALLY LEARNING FROM
ITSELF I ENTERED A PLEA --
I THINK THAT THAT THE PRINCIPLES
ARE BROAD ENOUGH THAT.
IT'S JUST SAYING WE DON'T KNOW
AT THIS POINT WHAT THAT UPPER
LIMIT IS OF WHERE THE A. I.
TECHNOLOGY WILL GO WE'RE SEEING
PRETTY RAPID ADVANCES AT THIS
POINT.
AND SO WITHOUT KNOWING THAT
UPPER LIMIT LET'S BE PREPARED
LET'S LOOK ABOUT WHAT THOSE
FEATURES COULD BE AND THE SO ALL
I JUST ADD THAT SENATOR I'M YOU
DO SEE THIS DISTINCTION DRAWN
BETWEEN --
WHAT WE ALREADY HAVE WHICH IS
ACTUALLY I YOU KNOW I?
PERFORMANCE THAT EXCEEDS HUMAN
CAPABILITIES WITHIN VERY NARROW
DOMAINS SUCH AS PLAIN GUY OR
SOMETHING LIKE THAT AT AND THEN
--
THAT IS TO BE DISTINGUISHED FROM
THIS CONCEPT OF ARTIFICIAL
GENERAL INTELLIGENCE WHICH WOULD
INVOLVE.
A YOU KNOW ARTIFICIAL AND HAS A
CERTAIN LEVEL OF CAPABILITY
ACROSS DIFFERENT DOMAINS TIME
AND NO ONE THINKS THAT THAT IS
ACTUALLY.
SOMETHING THAT WERE ANYWHERE
CLOSE TO DEVELOPING AT THIS
POINT THERE'S SOME DEBATE IN THE
COMMUNITY AS TO WHETHER IT'S
POSSIBLE WHAT WHETHER IT'S GONNA
HAPPEN IN A HUNDRED YEARS OR
THREE HUNDRED YEARS AND SO I
THINK THAT'S WHY.
THE FUTURE OF LIFE INCIDENT
INSTITUTE IN ITS PRINCIPLES KIND
OF FLAG THAT ISSUE NEAR THE END
OF THE SORT OF LONG TERM.
HORIZON.
THANK YOU SENATOR MONEY.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR --
I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR
BRINGING THIS FORWARD AND TO
KNOW THAT.
THE ASILOMAR PRINCIPLES ARE
NAMED AFTER A STATE PARK
FACILITY IN MY DISTRICT THE ONE
WHERE CONFERENCE CENTER. SEVEN
THEY'RE CONSIDERING THE MODERN
PRINCIPLES BUT A WE'LL TAKE IT
SOMEWHERE IT'S WELL KNOWN IN
THIS WILL MAKE IT BETTER KNOWN.
NOW SOMEONE IT KNOWLEDGE THE
STAFF WORK ON THIS AND NOW SIS
WHICH I THINK WAS REALLY
HELPFUL.
TO ME THERE'S A COMMENT BY
HARVARD PROFESSOR STEVEN.
PINKER WHO KNOWS THAT THERE'S A
FORM OF INTELLIGENCE THAT DOES
NOT TEND TO DESIRE TO CONQUER
AND SUBJUGATE OTHERS
[inaudible]
WOMEN.
HE STATES THAT IT MAY NOT BE A
COINCIDENCE THAT THOSE WHO THINK
THAT INTELLIGENCE ENTAILS THE
DESIRE TO DOMINATE.
GENERALLY BELONG TO A PARTICULAR
GENDER -- I
JUST THOUGHT THAT WAS AN
INTERESTING PIECE OF THE
LITERATURE ON THIS SUBJECT.
ON THE PRACTICAL FRONTLINE
QUESTION EITHER FOR THE AUTHOR
OR YOUR WITNESS.
SO THIS IS IN THE FORM OF A
RESOLUTION IN IT IT IT.
IT WOULD CONVEY THE SENTIMENT OF
THE LEGISLATURE.
IS THERE ANY SIMILAR EFFORTS
HAPPENING IN THE US CONGRESS
THAT YOU'RE AWARE OF NOT THAT
I'M AWARE OF I BELIEVE THERE WAS
A A SELECT COMMITTEE.
THAT WAS LOOKING AT ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE ISSUES.
AND I I'M NOT.
ENTIRELY SURE WHAT PROGRESS
THEY'VE MADE IN RECENT MONTHS
BUT I BELIEVE WOULD BE THE FIRST
BODY IN THE UNITED STATES.
TO EXPRESS OUR SUPPORT FOR THESE
SPECIFIC PRINCIPLES.
AND AGAIN THE PRINCIPLES ARE ONE
THING AND THEN THE CHALLENGE IS
HOW DO YOU.
VANCE THESE PRINCIPLES INTO
PUBLIC POLICY AND NOT JUST ON
THE GOVERNMENT SIDE BUT PERHAPS
MORE IMPORTANTLY.
IN WITH THE PRIVATE SECTOR THOSE
THAT ARE DEVELOPING THE
TECHNOLOGY ON ANY THOUGHT SON
HAVE ANY PRIVATE SECTOR.
INNOVATORS EMBRACED THESE
PRINCIPLES GUIDING THEIR WORK
YEAH ABSOLUTELY AND WE HEARD
ABOUT ADAMS IS OBVIOUS WAS ONE
OF THE ORIGINAL AND SIGNERS
FELINE MASK MANY FROM INDUSTRY
AND KIND OF LEADING A I'D
RESEARCHERS.
HAVE THAT SUPPORTED THE
PRINCIPLES AND I THINK THAT'S
ONE OF THE MAIN BENEFITS THAT WE
SEE RIGHT NOW IF THERE ARE OTHER
EXAMPLES OF THIS AT GOOGLE HAS
THEIR OWN A I PRINCIPLES THAT
RECENTLY COME OUT WITH --
DEEP MIND ITSELF HAS THAT
ETHICAL PRINCIPLES THAT THEY
ABIDE BY --
BUT THE SYLMAR ADMISSIBLE SORT
OF UNIQUELY HAVE --
GARNERED SUPPORT FROM FROM
INDUSTRY FROM CIVIL SOCIETY AND
NOT FROM POLICY MAKERS AND I
THINK I'M MORE THAN ANY OTHERS
HAVE FLAT --
REALLY HAD THAT BASE OF SUPPORT
FROM WITHIN INDUSTRY IN THE
PEOPLE WHO ARE REALLY BUILDING
THE TECHNOLOGY.
AN IMPORTANT CONVERSATION AND I
THINK THERE'S A PARALLEL IN.
PUBLIC HEALTH PREVENTION.
IS KEY AND NOT JUST FROM AN
ECONOMIC POINT OF VIEW BUT FROM
A PUBLIC HEALTH POINT OF VIEW
THAT.
THE MORE THE FRONT END OF
ADVANCING THIS CONVERSATION MY
FEAR OF COURSE FOR THOSE WITH.
MALON TENSION WILL NOT BE
IMPACTED BY ANY SET OF
PRINCIPLES OR ANY.
HEAD OF THE PUBLIC COMMONS
ESTABLISHING PRINCIPLES BUT
HOPEFULLY
BY EMBRACING IN POPULARIZING
THIS MAYBE IT ALSO CREATES.
A GENERATION OF WHISTLE BLOWERS
IF THEY END UP WITHIN AN
INDUSTRY THAT THEY FEEL IS.
IN VIOLATION OF THE SO.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND THANKS
AUTHOR OF BE GLAD TO MOVE THE
BILL AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME
THANK YOU AND I HAVE A FEELING
WE'RE GOING TO GET INTO PUBLIC
HEALTH AT SOME POINT IN THAT
SECTION BUT THANK YOU I THINK.
PREVENTION IS CRITICAL AND I
ANTICIPATE THAT'S PART OF WHY.
THIS IS BEEN RAISED NOW BEFORE.
THE WINNERS OF THE ANIMALS HAVE
LEFT THE BARN AND THERE'S NO WAY
WE'RE GOING TO GET HIM BACK IN
SO.
CENTER MORLOCK FLOOR'S YOURS
MINIATURE.
A CINNAMON HIGHLY IF IF WE DON'T
DO THIS THEN WHAT DO WE DO.
IF WE DON'T TAX PASSED THE
RESOLUTION THE WHAT DO WE DO
THIS IS A NEW FRONTIER AND
THERE'S JUST A LOT HAPPENING
PROBABLY FOR LAST. THREE OR FOUR
DECADES AND IT'S JUST INVOLVED
TO SOME INCREDIBLE LEVELS.
AS I'M I'M JUST YOU KNOW I'M I'M
JUST REALLY.
BEING DONE HERE.
IN THE CAPITAL BUT I THIS THIS
IS A GOOD FIRST STEP.
BUT IF WE DIDN'T DO THIS WHAT
WHAT WHAT SHOULD WE BE DOING.
WELL ON I THINK THAT THE
APPROACH WITH THIS RESOLUTION IS
I I'M NOT.
YOU KNOW IN A POSITION TO BE --
OVERLY PRESCRIPTIVE IN TERMS OF
HERE'S A GIVEN SET OF POLICIES
THAT ALIGNS WITH EACH OF THE
PRINCIPLES THAT ARE ARTICULATED
--
YOU KNOW AS YOU SAID WE REALLY
INTEND FOR THIS.
TO BE THE BEGINNING OF A
CONVERSATION AND TO TRY --
TO IDENTIFIED WHAT I'M I BELIEVE
ARE GOING TO BE --
CHALLENGES WE'RE GOING TO SEE
UNFOLD IN THE YEARS AHEAD THAT
WILL HAVE A SWEEPING
IMPLICATIONS FOR ALMOST EVERY
POLICY AREA THAT WE DEAL WITH
HERE.
AND SO -- I
THINK THAT --
ON THE POLICY LEVEL SINCE SOME
OF IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO SORT OF
BE DEALT WITH AS THE CHALLENGES
PRESENT THEMSELVES --
IT BUT I THINK IT BEHOOVES US TO
START THINKING --
IN A BROAD SENSE ABOUT WHAT KIND
OF CHALLENGES THAT WE MIGHT FACE
AND I THINK THAT --
THE EFFORT THAT THE FUTURE OF
LIFE INSTITUTE --
AND THAT. TWELVE HUNDRED A I
RESEARCHERS WHO HAVE ENDORSED
THAT PRINCIPALS HAVE HAD BEGUN
TO SOMETHING THAT TIME YOU KNOW
WOULD BE GOOD FOR US TO BE PART
OF WHAT.
WHAT WOULD YOU DO OF --
SOMEONE VIOLATED ONE OF THE
PRINCIPALS WITH.
BUT I'M NOT SURE WE HAVE --
ENFORCEMENT POWER --
BUILT INTO THIS BUT I THINK THAT
WITHIN THE A. I. RESEARCH
COMMUNITY THERE ARE NORMS
DEVELOPING AROUND THESE
PRINCIPLES AND THAT YOU KNOW IF
YOU HAD SOMEONE WHO IS
FLAGRANTLY VIOLATING THEM --
THERE WOULD PROBABLY BE --
OPTIONS IN TERMS OF THE
OPPORTUNITIES THAT ARE AVAILABLE
TO THEM --
BUT MAYBE YOU CAN SPEAK MORE
THAT SINCE YOU'RE MORE FAMILIAR
WITH THE NORMS THAT ARE
DEVELOPING WITHIN THE COMMUNITY
SO I MEAN I THINK WE'RE REALLY
SEEING A SEA CHANGE AND THAT
KIND OF EXPECTATION THAT
ENGINEERS WOULD THINK ABOUT
SOCIETAL IMPLICATIONS OR SAFETY
IMPLICATIONS AT ALL.
AND I DON'T THINK THAT WAS
CONSIDERS NORMAL ARE PART OF THE
CURRICULUM EVEN IF A COUPLE
YEARS AGO AND NOW IT IS CHANGING
PEOPLE ARE REALIZING ACTUALLY
WE'RE BUILDING TECHNOLOGY THAT
IS SHAPING THE FUTURE IT'S
SHAPING PEOPLE'S REALITY IS --
WE DO NEED TO BE HELD
ACCOUNTABLE AND TO THE PEOPLE
WHO ARE USING THAT AND THE
SYSTEMS THAT WERE CHANGING --
SO I THINK THINGS LIKE THIS ARE
REALLY VALUABLE TO GET IN AT
THIS STAGE AND SAY THESE ARE THE
VALUES THAT WE WANT TO SEE IN
THAT AND ANYWHERE ELSE.
I WAS SO VIDEO RECENTLY WAS VERY
LONG BUT IT.
TO WAS LIKE A STEVE JOBS KIND OF
PRESENTATION WHERE SOMEONE GETS
UP ON THE STAGE AND SAYS TALK
LIKE APART LIKE A TED TALK IN.
AND HE HAS A LITTLE DRONE ANY
THROWS IT OUT INTO THE AUDIENCE
AND IT FLIES IN IT.
FLIES AROUND THE ROOM AND IT
RECOGNIZES A MANNEQUIN AND SHE
TRIED FOR THE MANNIKIN HITS IT
AND EXPLODES LIKE A WEAPON.
IT WAS THE MOST TERRIFYING
LITTLE VIDEO.
I DON'T KNOW IF YOU IF YOU'RE
AWARE OF IT BUT HERE'S FACE
RECOGNITION HERE'S A DOING IT
ALL BY ITSELF RUNNING AROUND.
FLYING AROUND THE ROOM AND THEN
IT SHOWED ANOTHER VIDEO WITH
MULTIPLES OF THESE THINGS FLYING
AROUND AND IF YOU LET THAT GO IN
THE CAPITAL.
YOU KNOW JUST WHERE IT WAS VERY.
SO ARE YOU MAD AT ME UP IT WAS
ONE OF ABOUT TWO MEETINGS
SHAKING UP BUT IT SHOOK ME UP.
ANOTHER CONVERSATION HAD
RECENTLY WAS SO THAT THAT THEY
HAD.
TO A I SYSTEMS AND THEY STARTED
COMMUNICATING.
WITH EACH OTHER AND DEVELOP
THEIR OWN.
INDEPENDENT LANGUAGE IS THAT
CORRECT YOU'RE YOU'RE NODDING
YOUR HEAD.
COULD YOU EXPLAIN WHAT WHAT THAT
IS SPIKE IT WAS SAT AT ONE OF
THE MAIN TECHNOLOGY COMPANIES
AND AND IT WAS THAT TRANSLATION
SERVICE SO THEY HAD A AND MANY I
PROGRAM AND I'M NOT AN EXPERT ON
THIS THIS IS MY UNDERSTANDING OF
IT.
AND SO THERE WAS THAT WHAT THEY
WERE DOING ORIGINALLY WAS
TRANSLATING BACK THROUGH A
COMMON LANGUAGE TYPICALLY IN
ENGLISH AND THEN THE SYSTEMS
REALIZE WE DON'T NEED TO DO
THAT.
WE CAN ACTUALLY TRANSLATE
BETWEEN LANGUAGES FASTER --
AND IN THE PROCESS OF DOING THAT
YOU KNOW QUOTE UNQUOTE CREATED
THEIR OWN LANGUAGE AT WHICH MADE
THEM NERVOUS ENOUGH THAT THEY
SET THE WHOLE THING DOWN.
SO THAT'S WHO I THINK THERE'S
SOME.
MADAM CHAIR THAT.
WE SHOULD BE GETTING IN FRONT OF
SOMEHOW IF NOT HERE NATIONALLY
SO THANK YOU I APPRECIATE.
I APPRECIATE THE SUBJECT THERE'S
A LOT.
THAT WE NEED TO DO THAT THANK
YOU MADAM CHAIR I THINK SO MUCH
OF WHAT WE'RE LOOKING AT ARE
THINGS THAT WE CAN'T EVEN
CONCEIVE OFF TODAY LIKE CREATING
YOUR OWN LANGUAGE SO --
ONE OF MY QUESTIONS TO YOU IS.
YOU KNOW SO MUCH OF THIS WEEK.
PROBABLY SHOULD'VE ADDRESSED A
DECADE OR MORE AGO AND I'M
CONCERNED WE'RE GOING TO BE.
PLAYING CATCH UP THAT THAT THAT
THESE THINGS ARE GONNA HAPPEN
THEY WERE GOING TO SAY NO THAT
ISN'T OKAY AND OF COURSE.
SITUATION WITH DRONES WE'VE NOT
GOT THE HEAD OF THE ISSUE OF
DRONES AND NOW.
WE'RE SEEING.
AN ATTEMPTED TO SAY NATIONAL
LEADER IN THE NOTION THAT THESE
THINGS CAN IDENTIFY AND BE USED
--
AND WEAPONIZED AND HAVE BEEN --
BUT I GUESS ONE OF THE
QUESTIONS.
AND I DON'T KNOW IF YOU CAN
ANSWER THIS BUT YOU KNOW WHAT
WHAT ARE GOING TO BE OR WHAT DO
YOU SEE TODAY IS SOME OF THE
MORE PRESSING ARTIFICIAL
INTELLIGENCE RELATED ISSUES.
OVER THE NEXT FIVE TO TEN YEARS
THAT WE MIGHT TRY TO ANTICIPATE
AND GET A EAD OFF IF IT ISN'T
ALREADY TOO LATE DO YOU HAVE ANY
THOUGHTS ON THAT.
YEAH I MEAN I THINK ONE OF THE
FIRST THINGS THAT WE'RE SEEING
IS AUTOMATION OF JOBS.
AT A MUCH KIND OF HIGHER RATES
AND THERE'S THERE'S DIFFERENT
OPINIONS ABOUT WHAT HOW THAT
WILL PLAY OUT AND CERTAINLY JOBS
ARE ALSO BEING CREATED BY A I
TECHNOLOGIES --
THAT WE'RE SEEING IT'S NOT JUST
THE KIND OF MANUAL LABOR JOBS
THAT ARE --
AUTOMATED BALL BUT ALL KINDS OF
CREATIVE JOBS AS WELL AS A I
CREATED MOVIES NOW SK I CREATED
SONGS AND PAINTINGS AND THINGS
THAT WE JUST NEVER EVEN THOUGHT
THAT WOULD THAT BE POSSIBLE.
CERTAINLY THAT'LL BE A VERY BIG
IMPACT THE WORLD AND THAT HAD
CERTAIN COMMUNITIES HARDER.
AND WHAT WHAT WILL BE REQUIRED
--
TO TO DEAL WITH THAT AT THE
SOCIETAL LEVEL --
OTHER ISSUES.
I THINK RELATE --
TO HOW WHAT THE ROLE IS OF
AUTOMATED SYSTEMS AND KIND OF
PUBLIC SERVICE AS USES --
THERE'S A LOT OF CONCERN AROUND
WHERE.
WHERE --
AUTOMATED ALGORITHMS FOR EXAMPLE
PUT THEIR PLACES IN LAW
ENFORCEMENT --
ARE THINGS LIKE THE FACIAL
RECOGNITION TECHNOLOGY NOW BEING
USED WITH ON SOME POLICE FORCE
SAYS -- ON
THE KIND OF SURVEILLANCE AND
PRIVACY QUESTIONS THAT COME UP
WITH THAT AS A REALLY BIG ONE ON
A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE GRAPPLING
WITH -- BUT
THERE'S THERE'S JUST A THERE'S A
LOT OF FAT.
THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFERENT
NATIONS YEAH AND YOU KNOW I
PRETTY MUCH ANY ENTERPRISE THAT
--
THAT THAT USES THAT YOU KNOW
DATA IS --
CAN BE --
IMPROVED AND AT THROUGH THE
TOOLS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
AND WE'RE SEEING THAT ACROSS
MANY DOMAINS INCLUDING
HEALTHCARE.
EDUCATION AND THAT YOU KNOW THE
THE POINT OF THE RESOLUTION IS A
IT IS TWO FOLD IT'S TWO ONE
UNDERSCORE THE TREMENDOUS
OPPORTUNITY TO IMPROVE THAT
HUMAN WELL BEING.
THROUGH THESE TOOLS WHILE AT THE
SAME TIME.
YOU KNOW STRESSING THAT WE NEED
TO BE MINDFUL OF SOME RISKS THAT
MIGHT ARISE ALONG THE WAY.
WITH THAT AND THAT WOULD BRINGS
ME TO MY MY OTHER QUESTION WHICH
IS.
YOU KNOW WE ARE.
WE LOOK AT THESE ISSUES SORT OF
RE ACTIVELY PIECEMEAL SO.
OF YOU KNOW AS I MENTIONED WE WE
TRY TO PROPOSE BILLS OF ADDRESS
THINGS LIKE DRONES AND MAYBE
SELF DRIVING CARS WHICH WE ARE
PROBABLY GOING TO HAVE.
TO DO SOONER RATHER THAN LATER
--
BOX.
ARE I JUST WONDERED IS THERE A
WAY THAT WE COULD BE APPROACHING
THIS MORE HOLISTICALLY OR WHICH
IS GOING TO HAVE TO DO THIS. ONE
CHALLENGE AT A TIME BECAUSE AS
YOU SAY THERE ARE SOME VERY
EXCITING.
POSSIBLE USES OF ALL OF THIS
DRONES HAVE SOME TREMENDOUSLY
HELPFUL CAPABILITIES LIKE
HELPING FIGHT FIRES FOR EXAMPLE
USING NOW.
BUT IT ALSO CAN BE WEAPONIZED IT
CAN ALSO VIOLATE OUR PRIVACY IS
THERE SOMEWHERE WE CAN START
ADDRESSING THIS WHOLE SET OF
ISSUES HOLISTICALLY ARE WE GOING
TO HAVE TO DO IT.
AS EACH ONE OF THESE
TECHNOLOGIES EMERGES.
RIGHT RIGHT REACTIVE VERSUS
PROACTIVE I MEAN WE HAD THE
FUTURE OF LIFE INSTITUTE
CERTAINLY THINK THAT ADDRESSING
THEM POLITICALLY.
MAKES SENSE WHILE AT THE SAME
TIME THE WITHIN EACH SECTOR
WITHIN EACH STATE AND AND
COUNTRY FIGURING OUT WHAT MAKES
SENSE NOT CONTEXT --
IS SO I THINK BOTH BOTH ARE
NECESSARY AND IMPORTANT --
BUT TAKING A HOLISTIC.
APPROACH IS STARTING TO BE
RESTRAINED SEE MORE OF IT THERE
IS AN INTERNATIONALLY I
STRATEGIES EMERGING NOW FROM
THAT.
OVER A DOZEN COUNTRIES --
PLATE COUNTRIES ARE SAYING THAT
--
A I A SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH IT'LL
HAVE ENOUGH MPACT ON POLITICS
AND ON THE ECONOMY --
THAT WE ACTUALLY NEED THAT
NATIONWIDE STRAW --
WITH THAT INCLUDES WHAT CAN YOU
GIVE US A LITTLE SENSE OF WHAT
THAT IS CHARSET FOR EXAMPLE
INCLUDING ON WHAT IT WHAT WILL
IT TAKE TO TRAIN ENOUGH YOUNG
PEOPLE IN THESE TECHNOLOGIES SO
THAT WE'RE NOT LEFT BEHIND --
WHAT WHAT SHOULD OUR MILITARY BE
DOING AND THINKING SO THAT IF WE
DO SEE IT YOU KNOW THE KIND OF
SLAUGHTER BOTS TYPE?
ATTACKS THAT WE'RE NOT --
COMPLETELY AD CAUGHT OFF GUARD
--
YOU KNOW HOW CAN WE PUT THAT
PROTECTS.
POLITICAL SYSTEMS VOTING --
ELECTIONS --
FROM BEING HACKED AND THAT.
THE KIND OF CYBER ATTACKS THAT
ADAM COULD BEING INCREASINGLY
AUTOMATED WITH SOME OF THESE SAD
TECHNOLOGIES.
AND PROBABLY A LOT MORE THAT WE
JUST DON'T EVEN KNOW ABOUT
TODAY.
SO -- WITH
THAT --
SIMPLY MEMBER YOU CAN CLOSE AND
THANK YOU I HAVE A FEELING WE'LL
BE SEEING MORE.
OF THIS AND THANK YOU FOR FOR
RAISING THIS VERY IMPORTANT
ISSUE SO WE HAVE A MOTION BY.
A SENATOR MINING IF YOU'D LIKE
TO CLOSE.
YES I JUST I REALLY APPRECIATE
THE VERY THOUGHTFUL QUESTIONS
AND COMMENTS AND DISCUSSION AND
LOOK FORWARD TO THE CHANCE TO
ADD. TO COLLABORATE IN THESE
THINK THESE ISSUES THROUGH MORA
AS WE MOVE FORWARD AND SARS BUT
BY ASPIRIN I'VE A THANK YOU.
ALRIGHT THE MOTION IS.
THAT THE RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED
IN ORDER TO THIRD READING PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
JACKSON HIGH JACKSON I AM MORE
LOCK FOR LUCK I ANDERSON.
HERTZBERG MORNING.
MORNING I STERN BY CASKEY.
ALRIGHT THE BILL HAS THREE VOTES
WE WILL -- I
ASKED PLEASED TO HAVE THE FIRST
COME IN AND VOTE --
WE'VE CONFERENCE COMMITTEE.
ON THE SENATOR DODD'S BILL AT
TWO O'CLOCK WHICH IS NOW AND I
SIT ON THAT [inaudible]
COMMITTEE.
THE CS A CLEAR COURSE BUT IF WE
COULD CLOSE OUT THE ROLE AS
QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE AND
APPRECIATED.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU TO OUR CALLERS
.
OR IS THE SECOND.
ROLE FOR SENATOR WHITE HOUSE
KEEP PLEASE CALL THANK YOU.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ANDERSON HERTZBERG STERN WHAT
CASSIE.
CASKEY I VERY GOOD YEAH
[inaudible]
THANK YOU
STERN RIGHT THAT BILL HAS FIVE
VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLE OF THE
ONE MORE TIME.
THANK YOU --
NO WORDS CAN OKAY ALL RIGHT.
UP GOING TO CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME IN THE
CLOSER ROLE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
HERTZBERG STERN.
ALRIGHT FIVE TO ZERO THAT
RESOLUTION IS OUT AND WE ARE
ADJOURNED