WEBVTT
00:00:17.884 --> 00:00:19.052
COMMITTEE --
00:00:19.119 --> 00:00:20.387
WE'RE SERVICES SUBCOMMITTEE HERE
00:00:20.453 --> 00:00:21.888
WERE STILL WAITING FOR FULL
00:00:21.955 --> 00:00:24.324
MEMBERSHIP TO ESTABLISH A QUORUM --
00:00:24.391 --> 00:00:27.494
I KNOW THERE'S JUDICIARY PENDING.
00:00:27.560 --> 00:00:29.629
SALADA COMPETING COMMITTEES HERE
00:00:29.696 --> 00:00:32.465
BUT FIGURED EVERYONE'S CONVENE
00:00:32.532 --> 00:00:34.801
WE DON'T TO BELABOR THIS --
00:00:34.868 --> 00:00:36.970
SO GIVE ME AN OPPORTUNITY TO AT
00:00:37.036 --> 00:00:37.570
LEAST START WITH YOUR OPENING
00:00:37.637 --> 00:00:39.005
AND THEN.
00:00:39.072 --> 00:00:40.807
HOPEFULLY SERGEANTS DO WE KNOW
00:00:40.874 --> 00:00:43.309
OR OTHER MEMBERS BEEN CALLED.
00:00:43.376 --> 00:00:45.011
ALRIGHT --
00:00:45.078 --> 00:00:46.980
WELCOME CENTER MULLIN AB FOR
00:00:47.046 --> 00:00:48.581
THANK YOU SIR.
00:00:48.648 --> 00:00:49.716
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS THANK YOU
00:00:49.783 --> 00:00:51.551
VERY MUCH FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:00:51.618 --> 00:00:53.820
PRESENT AB EIGHTY FOUR WHICH HAS
00:00:53.887 --> 00:00:54.854
GENERATED.
00:00:54.921 --> 00:00:55.889
SOME INTEREST AS YOU CAN SEE
00:00:55.955 --> 00:00:58.124
WITH OUR FOLKS IN THE ROOM HERE
00:00:58.191 --> 00:00:59.392
OF I DO WANT TO CLARIFY.
00:00:59.459 --> 00:01:01.761
SOME MISCONCEPTIONS ABOUT WHAT
00:01:01.828 --> 00:01:03.329
THE BILL DOES.
00:01:03.396 --> 00:01:04.464
FIRST OF ALL.
00:01:04.531 --> 00:01:06.299
AS MOST IN THIS ROOM NOW I HAVE
00:01:06.366 --> 00:01:07.400
BEEN AND CONTINUE TO BE AS
00:01:07.467 --> 00:01:08.868
STRONG CHAMPION. FOR
00:01:08.935 --> 00:01:11.137
TRANSPARENCY AND DISCLOSURE IN
00:01:11.204 --> 00:01:12.772
CAMPAIGN FINANCE.
00:01:12.839 --> 00:01:15.208
I WAS A PROUD AUTHOR OF AB TWO
00:01:15.275 --> 00:01:17.677
FORTY NINE THE DISCLOSE ACT OF
00:01:17.744 --> 00:01:18.511
TWENTY SEVENTEEN THIS YEAR I AM
00:01:18.578 --> 00:01:21.114
THE PROUD AUTHOR OF AB TWENTY
00:01:21.181 --> 00:01:21.681
ONE EIGHTY EIGHT THE SOCIAL
00:01:21.748 --> 00:01:23.116
MEDIA DISCLOSE ACT.
00:01:23.183 --> 00:01:24.717
IN A WORKING CLOSELY WITH MANY
00:01:24.784 --> 00:01:25.919
OF THE SAME ADVOCATES UP BEHIND
00:01:25.985 --> 00:01:27.487
ME WITH.
00:01:27.554 --> 00:01:29.489
TRENT LOTT LANG FROM CALIFORNIA
00:01:29.556 --> 00:01:31.724
CLEAN MONEY ARE AND OTHER SO
00:01:31.791 --> 00:01:33.660
NORMALLY WEAR ON THE SAME SIDE
00:01:33.726 --> 00:01:35.829
OF THE TABLE A TODAY THAT'S NOT
00:01:35.895 --> 00:01:37.163
THE CASE BUT TOM.
00:01:37.230 --> 00:01:38.731
I AM ON THE SAME PAGE WITH
00:01:38.798 --> 00:01:41.534
NEARLY EVERYONE I IN THE ROOM ON
00:01:41.601 --> 00:01:42.435
THE ISSUE OF TRANSPARENCY AND
00:01:42.502 --> 00:01:44.137
ACCOUNTABILITY IN OUR ELECTIONS
00:01:44.204 --> 00:01:46.206
PROCESS.
00:01:46.272 --> 00:01:47.474
BUT WE DO HAVE A DIFFERENCE OF
00:01:47.540 --> 00:01:50.810
OPINION ON THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE --
00:01:50.877 --> 00:01:53.746
WHICH IS MANIFESTED IN AB --
00:01:53.813 --> 00:01:55.648
EIGHTY FOUR IN JULY I AMENDED MY
00:01:55.715 --> 00:01:57.750
BILL AB EIGHTY FOUR WHICH IS
00:01:57.817 --> 00:01:59.652
CONSISTENT WITH THOSE VALUES ARE
00:01:59.719 --> 00:02:01.054
AND POLICY.
00:02:01.120 --> 00:02:02.755
PRESCRIPTIONS AB EIGHTY FOUR
00:02:02.822 --> 00:02:04.257
SIMPLY EXTRACTS FROM THE CURRENT
00:02:04.324 --> 00:02:06.259
OPAQUE POLITICAL PARTY FUND
00:02:06.326 --> 00:02:07.527
RAISING PROCESS.
00:02:07.594 --> 00:02:09.696
AND CREATES A PARALLEL COMMITTEE
00:02:09.762 --> 00:02:12.165
AND ADDS MUCH NEEDED SUNSHINE.
00:02:12.232 --> 00:02:13.066
THAT'S IT.
00:02:13.132 --> 00:02:15.001
THAT'S WHAT THE BILL DOES SOME
00:02:15.068 --> 00:02:17.036
OPPONENTS HAVE DESCRIBED AB
00:02:17.103 --> 00:02:18.605
EIGHTY FOUR AS A SHADOW SYSTEM.
00:02:18.671 --> 00:02:20.640
THAT WILL BRING IN MOUNTAINS OF
00:02:20.707 --> 00:02:22.275
MORE OUTSIDE CORPORATE MONEY AND
00:02:22.342 --> 00:02:23.810
THAT MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATURE
00:02:23.877 --> 00:02:25.144
WILL BE BEHOLDEN TO THOSE
00:02:25.211 --> 00:02:26.646
INTERESTS [inaudible]
00:02:26.713 --> 00:02:28.214
I DISAGREE.
00:02:28.281 --> 00:02:29.549
THE MOUNTAINS OF OUTSIDE
00:02:29.616 --> 00:02:31.784
CORPORATE MONEY OFTEN COMES IN
00:02:31.851 --> 00:02:33.052
THE FORM OF INDEPENDENT
00:02:33.119 --> 00:02:35.255
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEES WE PLAY
00:02:35.321 --> 00:02:37.056
AN INCREASING ROLE.
00:02:37.123 --> 00:02:40.994
IN OUR POLITICS BEYOND THE REACH
00:02:41.060 --> 00:02:42.295
OF ELECTED OFFICIALS.
00:02:42.362 --> 00:02:43.730
AND BEYOND THE REACH IN MANY
00:02:43.796 --> 00:02:46.499
RESPECTS OF ACCOUNTABILITY.
00:02:46.566 --> 00:02:48.034
THE REALITY IS ELECTIONS IN
00:02:48.101 --> 00:02:49.636
CALIFORNIA.
00:02:49.702 --> 00:02:51.371
ARE ENORMOUSLY EXPENSIVE I
00:02:51.437 --> 00:02:53.006
DISLIKE FUNDRAISING MOST ELECTED
00:02:53.072 --> 00:02:55.141
OFFICIALS I KNOW DO BUT I AM AN
00:02:55.208 --> 00:02:56.376
ACTIVE PARTICIPANT IN THIS
00:02:56.442 --> 00:02:57.744
PROCESS.
00:02:57.810 --> 00:02:59.512
UNFORTUNATELY IN CALIFORNIA TO
00:02:59.579 --> 00:03:00.647
GET THEIR MESSAGE OUT IT IS
00:03:00.713 --> 00:03:02.815
INCREASINGLY EXPENSIVE AND UNTIL
00:03:02.882 --> 00:03:04.517
WE COME UP WITH ANOTHER WAY LIKE
00:03:04.584 --> 00:03:06.319
PUBLIC FINANCING WE HAVE TO
00:03:06.386 --> 00:03:07.587
FUNDRAISE TO GET ELECTED
00:03:07.654 --> 00:03:07.887
[inaudible]
00:03:07.954 --> 00:03:11.124
STATE ELECTED. TO BE SURE MONEY
00:03:11.190 --> 00:03:11.925
IS BEING RAISED FROM LOTS OF
00:03:11.991 --> 00:03:13.326
DIFFERENT SOURCES.
00:03:13.393 --> 00:03:14.627
I WILL TELL YOU THAT UNDER THE
00:03:14.694 --> 00:03:17.297
EXISTING PARTY SYSTEM IT IS VERY
00:03:17.363 --> 00:03:19.332
DIFFICULT TO TRACK DONORS AND
00:03:19.399 --> 00:03:21.401
RECIPIENTS.
00:03:21.467 --> 00:03:23.002
ALL A AB EIGHTY FOUR DOES IS
00:03:23.069 --> 00:03:24.737
ALLOW FUNDS TO BE DIRECTLY
00:03:24.804 --> 00:03:26.673
DONATED TO THE FOR CAUCUS LEADER
00:03:26.739 --> 00:03:27.707
COMMITTEES.
00:03:27.774 --> 00:03:29.475
AND REQUIRE MONTHLY REPORTS OF
00:03:29.542 --> 00:03:32.245
MONEY DONATED AND MONEY
00:03:32.312 --> 00:03:33.313
ALLOCATED YOU'LL BE ABLE TO SEE
00:03:33.379 --> 00:03:35.582
WHICH LEADER SOLICITED FUNDS.
00:03:35.648 --> 00:03:37.317
WHO DONATED AND HOW THAT MONEY
00:03:37.383 --> 00:03:39.786
WAS SPENT SOMETHING THAT WOULD
00:03:39.852 --> 00:03:41.321
TAKE A FORENSIC ACCOUNTING
00:03:41.387 --> 00:03:43.289
PROCESS RIGHT NOW TO FIGURE OUT
00:03:43.356 --> 00:03:44.123
THROUGH OUR CURRENT PARTY BASED
00:03:44.190 --> 00:03:44.424
[inaudible]
00:03:44.490 --> 00:03:46.125
SYSTEM.
00:03:46.192 --> 00:03:47.393
I HAVE MUCH MORE TO SAY I THINK
00:03:47.460 --> 00:03:49.228
IN RESPONSE PROBABLY TO WHAT WE
00:03:49.295 --> 00:03:50.530
HEAR IN TERMS OF SOME OF THE
00:03:50.597 --> 00:03:52.265
ISSUES I THINK I BELIEVE THAT
00:03:52.332 --> 00:03:53.533
THAT MISTER CHAIR.
00:03:53.600 --> 00:03:54.233
I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:03:54.300 --> 00:03:56.569
CONSIDERATION AND I LOOK FORWARD
00:03:56.636 --> 00:03:58.438
TO A HEARING OUT FROM THE PUBLIC --
00:03:58.504 --> 00:04:00.473
A PUBLIC WHICH UP I THINK
00:04:00.540 --> 00:04:02.609
NORMALLY I I AM IN ALIGNMENT
00:04:02.675 --> 00:04:03.876
WITH WHEN IT COMES TO THESE
00:04:03.943 --> 00:04:05.912
ISSUES AROUND DISCLOSURE AND
00:04:05.979 --> 00:04:07.814
TRANSPARENCY THANK MISTER.
00:04:07.880 --> 00:04:09.248
THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER --
00:04:09.315 --> 00:04:10.416
DO WE HAVE ANY WITNESSES HERE IN
00:04:10.483 --> 00:04:17.190
SUPPORT.
00:04:17.256 --> 00:04:19.592
SO I WOULD JUST PAUSE FOR A
00:04:19.659 --> 00:04:20.927
BRIEF MOMENT --
00:04:20.994 --> 00:04:22.228
AND ESTABLISH A QUORUM THAT'S
00:04:22.295 --> 00:04:23.997
ALRIGHT --
00:04:24.063 --> 00:04:26.065
IT'S CALDERON.
00:04:26.132 --> 00:04:28.434
STERN HERE STERN HERE ANDERSON
00:04:28.501 --> 00:04:30.803
YOUR ANDERSON HERE ALLEN.
00:04:30.870 --> 00:04:32.372
HERTZBERG HERE HERTZBERG HERE
00:04:32.438 --> 00:04:35.241
LEYVA.
00:04:35.308 --> 00:04:37.010
THANK YOU SO SEEING NO WITNESSES
00:04:37.076 --> 00:04:38.611
IN SUPPORT --
00:04:38.678 --> 00:04:41.147
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION --
00:04:41.214 --> 00:04:42.882
PLEASE COME FORWARD I THINK WHAT
00:04:42.949 --> 00:04:43.449
WE'RE GONNA TRY TO DO HERE I
00:04:43.516 --> 00:04:45.685
KNOW THERE'S THERE'S FOLKS HAVE
00:04:45.752 --> 00:04:48.655
TRAVELED FROM ALL OVER THE STATE --
00:04:48.721 --> 00:04:51.591
WERE GONNA TRY TO DIVVY UP THE
00:04:51.658 --> 00:04:53.426
OPPOSITION TESTIMONIALS OF FOUR
00:04:53.493 --> 00:04:55.261
MINUTES EACH.
00:04:55.328 --> 00:04:56.796
AND THEN EVERYONE ELSE WILL HAVE
00:04:56.863 --> 00:05:00.066
AN OPPORTUNITY --
00:05:00.133 --> 00:05:01.167
TO TWO SUSPECTED SAY YOUR NAME
00:05:01.234 --> 00:05:02.368
WHERE YOU'RE FROM AND YOUR
00:05:02.435 --> 00:05:03.002
POSITION ON THE BILL BUT IF THE
00:05:03.069 --> 00:05:05.171
IF THE FOLKS IN THEIR ROOM WHEN
00:05:05.238 --> 00:05:06.873
JUSTIN TOLD ME THAT WHAT WE'RE
00:05:06.939 --> 00:05:07.974
GOING TO GET INTO THE SUBSTANCE
00:05:08.041 --> 00:05:09.575
OF IT ALL TOO BUT JUST IN TERMS
00:05:09.642 --> 00:05:10.777
OF PROCESS.
00:05:10.843 --> 00:05:12.979
I AFTER THE INITIAL OPPOSITION
00:05:13.046 --> 00:05:14.347
TESTING WE'RE JUST GONNA ASKED
00:05:14.414 --> 00:05:16.549
NAME WHERE YOU'RE FROM AND
00:05:16.616 --> 00:05:18.351
POSITION ON BILL --
00:05:18.418 --> 00:05:19.385
WITHOUT FURTHER ADO --
00:05:19.452 --> 00:05:21.788
THE FLOOR IS YOURS SO GOOD
00:05:21.854 --> 00:05:23.089
AFTERNOON SENATORS ON HELEN
00:05:23.156 --> 00:05:24.691
HUTCHISON AND I'M THE PRESIDENT
00:05:24.757 --> 00:05:25.792
OF THE LEGAL MOVE VOTERS OF
00:05:25.858 --> 00:05:27.393
CALIFORNIA.
00:05:27.460 --> 00:05:29.729
THE LEAGUE FIGHTS EVERYDAY TO
00:05:29.796 --> 00:05:31.364
BILL THE PUBLIC'S FAITH IN THE
00:05:31.431 --> 00:05:33.800
DEMOCRATIC PROCESS. TO COMBAT
00:05:33.866 --> 00:05:35.768
CYNICISM CYNICISM AND THE
00:05:35.835 --> 00:05:37.470
CATARACT THE PERCEPTION THAT THE
00:05:37.537 --> 00:05:38.871
VOTING THAT VOTING IN OUR
00:05:38.938 --> 00:05:40.573
ELECTIONS IS A POINTLESS FUNERAL
00:05:40.640 --> 00:05:42.375
EXERCISE.
00:05:42.442 --> 00:05:43.843
THERE'S LITTLE DOUBT THAT MONEY
00:05:43.910 --> 00:05:45.011
PRESENTS THE GREATEST THREAT TO
00:05:45.078 --> 00:05:46.012
OUR REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY
00:05:46.079 --> 00:05:47.647
TODAY.
00:05:47.714 --> 00:05:49.082
AB EIGHTY FOUR MAKES THIS
00:05:49.148 --> 00:05:51.584
PROBLEM EVEN WORSE.
00:05:51.651 --> 00:05:53.286
WE UNDERSTAND THAT THE BILL WAS
00:05:53.352 --> 00:05:55.321
IN THE WORKS FOR A YEAR.
00:05:55.388 --> 00:05:56.689
THE FIRST WE HEARD OF IT WAS
00:05:56.756 --> 00:05:58.391
WHEN THE LANGUAGE WAS INTRODUCED.
00:05:58.458 --> 00:05:59.625
AS A GUT AND AMEND THE DAY
00:05:59.692 --> 00:06:01.994
BEFORE RECESS.
00:06:02.061 --> 00:06:03.463
A BILL THAT A MAN'S THE PUBLIC
00:06:03.529 --> 00:06:05.198
REFORM ACT THE LAW THAT IS
00:06:05.264 --> 00:06:07.166
DESIGNED TO PREVENT CORRUPTION
00:06:07.233 --> 00:06:07.867
AND THE UNFAIR PROTECTION OF
00:06:07.934 --> 00:06:10.103
INCUMBENTS.
00:06:10.169 --> 00:06:12.038
SURELY NOT BE CRAFTED IN THE
00:06:12.105 --> 00:06:13.573
BACK ROOMS AND PASSED AT THE
00:06:13.639 --> 00:06:15.541
ELEVENTH HOUR WITHOUT ANY REAL
00:06:15.608 --> 00:06:16.709
OPPORTUNITY FOR MEANINGFUL
00:06:16.776 --> 00:06:18.811
PUBLIC INPUT.
00:06:18.878 --> 00:06:20.012
THE LEAGUE IS STRONGLY OPPOSED
00:06:20.079 --> 00:06:21.714
TO A. B. EIGHTY FOUR BOTH AS A
00:06:21.781 --> 00:06:22.715
MATTER OF OF SUBSTANCE AND OF
00:06:22.782 --> 00:06:28.121
PROCESS.
00:06:28.187 --> 00:06:30.189
CHAIR STERN MEMBERS.
00:06:30.256 --> 00:06:31.057
NICHOLAS HAD ON WITH CALIFORNIA
00:06:31.124 --> 00:06:33.126
COMMON CAUSE. ONE BEGIN BY
00:06:33.192 --> 00:06:34.327
SAYING THAT WE HAVE A GREAT DEAL
00:06:34.393 --> 00:06:35.328
OF RESPECT FOR SOMEONE MEMBER
00:06:35.394 --> 00:06:37.296
MELONES WORK ON ELECTIONS AND
00:06:37.363 --> 00:06:38.564
CAMPAIGN FINANCE IN FACT COME
00:06:38.631 --> 00:06:39.766
BECAUSE HE SCORED MORE MULLIN
00:06:39.832 --> 00:06:41.167
DOES THIS YEAR.
00:06:41.234 --> 00:06:42.435
THAN ANY OTHER AUTHOR.
00:06:42.502 --> 00:06:43.636
NOTING THAT WE MUST NONE THE
00:06:43.703 --> 00:06:45.304
LESS RESPECTFULLY BUT FIRMLY
00:06:45.371 --> 00:06:47.006
OPPOSE A. B. EIGHTY FOUR IN OUR
00:06:47.073 --> 00:06:48.374
OPINION AB.
00:06:48.441 --> 00:06:49.175
EIGHTY FOUR WILL BE THE BIGGEST
00:06:49.242 --> 00:06:50.610
ROLLBACK CALIFORNIAS CAMPAIGN
00:06:50.676 --> 00:06:53.613
FINANCE LAW IN AT LEAST A DECADE.
00:06:53.679 --> 00:06:54.781
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND MOST
00:06:54.847 --> 00:06:56.149
STATES INCLUDING CALIFORNIA HAVE
00:06:56.215 --> 00:06:57.817
CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTION LIMITS
00:06:57.884 --> 00:06:59.452
CONTRIBUTION ITSELF TO RUN
00:06:59.519 --> 00:07:01.087
CORRUPTION UNDUE INFLUENCE.
00:07:01.154 --> 00:07:03.055
AND THE DISPIRITING APPEARANCE.
00:07:03.122 --> 00:07:04.190
OF CORRUPTION BY PRINTING
00:07:04.257 --> 00:07:05.958
CANDIDATES MUST LEGISLATORS FROM
00:07:06.025 --> 00:07:08.327
OVERLY RELIANT ON HUGE DONATIONS
00:07:08.394 --> 00:07:10.129
FROM ANYONE WEALTHY CONTRIBUTORS.
00:07:10.196 --> 00:07:11.531
FOR THAT REASON CALIFORNIA'S YOU
00:07:11.597 --> 00:07:12.965
WELL KNOW CAN IT'S FOR OFFICE
00:07:13.032 --> 00:07:14.267
ARE PROHIBITED FROM ACCEPTING
00:07:14.333 --> 00:07:16.402
CONTRIBUTIONS CURTAIN FORTY FOUR
00:07:16.469 --> 00:07:16.969
HUNDRED DOLLARS FROM ANYONE
00:07:17.036 --> 00:07:18.271
DONOR.
00:07:18.337 --> 00:07:19.605
UNFORTUNATELY AB EIGHTY FOUR
00:07:19.672 --> 00:07:20.673
WOULD SERIOUSLY UNDERMINE HIS
00:07:20.740 --> 00:07:22.208
CAMPAIGN FINANCE PROTECTIONS AS
00:07:22.275 --> 00:07:23.843
THE LEGISLATIVE LEADERS.
00:07:23.910 --> 00:07:25.044
AND THEIR ROLES DIRECTING THE
00:07:25.111 --> 00:07:26.145
FOR NEW CAUCUS COMMITTEES
00:07:26.212 --> 00:07:28.614
LEADERS COULD ACCEPT THIRTY SIX
00:07:28.681 --> 00:07:29.182
THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLAR
00:07:29.248 --> 00:07:30.349
CONTRIBUTIONS TO SPEND ON DIRECT
00:07:30.416 --> 00:07:31.350
CONTRIBUTIONS.
00:07:31.417 --> 00:07:32.952
IN UNLIMITED AMOUNTS. TWO OTHER
00:07:33.019 --> 00:07:34.754
CANDIDATES.
00:07:34.821 --> 00:07:36.322
THIS IS MORE THAN EIGHT TIMES
00:07:36.389 --> 00:07:37.056
HIGHER THAN CURRENT CANDID
00:07:37.123 --> 00:07:38.491
LIMITS.
00:07:38.558 --> 00:07:39.759
IN FACT THAT LIMIT IS HIGHER
00:07:39.826 --> 00:07:40.493
THAN CALIFORNIA'S PER CAPITA
00:07:40.560 --> 00:07:42.495
INCOME.
00:07:42.562 --> 00:07:44.096
TYPICAL VOTERS ARE NOT MAXING
00:07:44.163 --> 00:07:45.431
OUT OF FORTY FOUR HUNDRED DOLLAR
00:07:45.498 --> 00:07:46.632
LEVEL AND THEY'RE CERTAINLY NOT
00:07:46.699 --> 00:07:49.035
ANY MAXING OUT AT THIRTY SIX
00:07:49.101 --> 00:07:49.602
THOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLAR
00:07:49.669 --> 00:07:50.136
LEVEL.
00:07:50.203 --> 00:07:51.337
ONLY WEALTHY SPECIAL INTERESTS
00:07:51.404 --> 00:07:53.573
WILL BE ABLE TO DO SO.
00:07:53.639 --> 00:07:55.174
THERE'S MORE THEM CHANDER AB
00:07:55.241 --> 00:07:56.209
EIGHTY FOUR LEADERS COULD EVEN
00:07:56.275 --> 00:07:57.610
SOLICIT RECEIVED THEN SPEND.
00:07:57.677 --> 00:07:59.712
UNLIMITED FUNDS ON INDEPENDENT
00:07:59.779 --> 00:08:00.913
SPENDERS SUPPORTING CAN CANDID
00:08:00.980 --> 00:08:03.015
CAMPAIGNS SOMETHING THAT IS
00:08:03.082 --> 00:08:05.117
ILLEGAL UNDER CURRENT LAW.
00:08:05.184 --> 00:08:06.252
CORD OF THE CALIFORNIA SUPREME
00:08:06.319 --> 00:08:07.153
COURT THE PURPOSE OF THE
00:08:07.220 --> 00:08:08.421
POLITICAL REFORM ACT JUST
00:08:08.487 --> 00:08:09.555
RANSACK QUOTE CORRUPTION OF THE
00:08:09.622 --> 00:08:11.357
POLITICAL PROCESS.
00:08:11.424 --> 00:08:13.192
THE AXE FINDINGS AND PURPOSES
00:08:13.259 --> 00:08:14.293
WHICH EGGMAN UNCHANGED SINCE
00:08:14.360 --> 00:08:14.794
THEIR PASSED IN NINETEEN
00:08:14.861 --> 00:08:16.362
SEVENTIES.
00:08:16.429 --> 00:08:18.130
CIVIC QUOTE PUBLIC OFFICIALS TO
00:08:18.197 --> 00:08:19.165
PERFORM THEIR DUTIES IN AN
00:08:19.232 --> 00:08:21.801
IMPARTIAL MANNER FREE FROM BIAS
00:08:21.868 --> 00:08:23.002
BECAUSE BY THE FINANCIAL
00:08:23.069 --> 00:08:23.603
INTERESTS OF PEOPLE WHO
00:08:23.669 --> 00:08:25.671
SUPPORTED THEM.
00:08:25.738 --> 00:08:27.340
INCREASING A FULL THE AMOUNT THE
00:08:27.406 --> 00:08:28.674
LEADERS CAN RECEIVE FROM WEALTHY
00:08:28.741 --> 00:08:30.176
DONORS WHO'VE INTEREST BEFORE
00:08:30.243 --> 00:08:31.944
THIS BODY SIMPLY DOES NOT
00:08:32.011 --> 00:08:33.980
FURTHER THAT PURPOSE.
00:08:34.046 --> 00:08:35.281
ANOTHER PURPOSELY ACT IS TO
00:08:35.348 --> 00:08:37.483
ABOLISH QUOTE LAWS AND PRACTICES
00:08:37.550 --> 00:08:39.518
UNFAIRLY BENEFITING INCUMBENTS.
00:08:39.585 --> 00:08:41.254
HOWEVER AB EIGHTY FOUR SAYS IN
00:08:41.320 --> 00:08:42.488
THE LAW THE CAUCUS COMMITTEE
00:08:42.555 --> 00:08:44.090
FUNDS SHOULD BE USED TO QUOTE
00:08:44.156 --> 00:08:45.391
ADVANCE THE INTERESTS OF LESS OF
00:08:45.458 --> 00:08:47.927
CAUCUS MEETING CAUCUS INCUMBENTS.
00:08:47.994 --> 00:08:49.328
THAT TOO DOES NOT FURTHER THE
00:08:49.395 --> 00:08:51.397
PURPOSES OF THE ACT.
00:08:51.464 --> 00:08:52.398
WE'RE IN A TIME OF GREAT
00:08:52.465 --> 00:08:54.934
NATIONAL CYNICISM WITH DEMOCRACY
00:08:55.001 --> 00:08:56.068
WE NEED AT THIS POINT B.
00:08:56.135 --> 00:08:57.403
STRENGTHENING NOT LISTENING.
00:08:57.470 --> 00:09:00.172
OUR CAMPAIGN FINANCE LAWS.
00:09:00.239 --> 00:09:00.740
FINALLY I WON'T MENTION THE
00:09:00.806 --> 00:09:02.141
COMMON CAUSE HAS GREAT CONCERNS
00:09:02.208 --> 00:09:03.376
ABOUT THE TIMING OF THIS BILL
00:09:03.442 --> 00:09:04.277
WHICH IS BEING BROUGHT FORWARD
00:09:04.343 --> 00:09:05.745
AT THE END OF SESSION AND WITH
00:09:05.811 --> 00:09:08.180
AN URGENCY BECAUSE WE SHOULD NOT
00:09:08.247 --> 00:09:09.782
BE MAKING HUGE CHANGES TO OUR
00:09:09.849 --> 00:09:11.217
CAMPAIGN FINANCE LAWS WITH
00:09:11.284 --> 00:09:12.685
UNCERTAIN CONSEQUENCES.
00:09:12.752 --> 00:09:13.986
IN THE HOME STRETCH OF AN
00:09:14.053 --> 00:09:14.954
ELECTION WITH ONLY A MONTH
00:09:15.021 --> 00:09:17.990
REVIEW. FOR ALL THESE REASONS WE
00:09:18.057 --> 00:09:19.659
OPPOSE EIGHTY EIGHTY FOUR AND WE
00:09:19.725 --> 00:09:21.294
URGE THE MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE
00:09:21.360 --> 00:09:21.727
SUPPOSE BILLS WELL.
00:09:21.794 --> 00:09:23.262
THANK.
00:09:23.329 --> 00:09:24.730
THANK YOU MISTER EINHORN --
00:09:24.797 --> 00:09:25.665
WILL TAKE --
00:09:25.731 --> 00:09:27.533
THE REMAINING [inaudible]
00:09:27.600 --> 00:09:31.370
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION CERTAIN
00:09:31.437 --> 00:09:34.206
TO MORAL LEAD AND THEN.
00:09:34.273 --> 00:09:36.375
SO FOUR MINUTES [inaudible]
00:09:36.442 --> 00:09:38.477
ACTUALLY.
00:09:38.544 --> 00:09:38.711
YOU'RE.
00:09:38.778 --> 00:09:39.679
YOU'RE [inaudible]
00:09:39.745 --> 00:09:41.747
FOR DO.
00:09:41.814 --> 00:09:43.149
I DID IF I WE CAN RESERVE THEY
00:09:43.215 --> 00:09:44.250
WERE SHORT SO.
00:09:44.317 --> 00:09:45.818
I'M CERTAINLY PLEASED YET WHEN
00:09:45.885 --> 00:09:47.620
DID WE MIGHT BE MISUNDERSTOOD
00:09:47.687 --> 00:09:48.688
IT'S OKAY.
00:09:48.754 --> 00:09:49.322
GOOD AFTERNOON THANK YOU
00:09:49.388 --> 00:09:50.289
CHAIRMAN STERN.
00:09:50.356 --> 00:09:52.091
A GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
00:09:52.158 --> 00:09:53.559
COMMITTEE AND THE MEMBERS OF THE
00:09:53.626 --> 00:09:54.560
PUBLIC MY NAME IS TO ROCCO LEARN
00:09:54.627 --> 00:09:55.761
MORE HALL.
00:09:55.828 --> 00:09:57.029
I'M THE VICE CHAIR OF THE
00:09:57.096 --> 00:09:58.597
CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY ON
00:09:58.664 --> 00:10:00.099
BEHALF OF CHAIRMAN BAO MEN ON MY
00:10:00.166 --> 00:10:01.534
FELLOW STATEWIDE OFFICERS AND
00:10:01.600 --> 00:10:03.002
THE ENTIRE CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC
00:10:03.069 --> 00:10:06.672
PARTY WE URGE A NO VOTE ON AB.
00:10:06.739 --> 00:10:07.173
EIGHTY FOUR YOU KNOW THE
00:10:07.239 --> 00:10:09.275
DEMOCRATIC PARTY ISN'T KNOWN FOR
00:10:09.342 --> 00:10:12.178
BEING I'M ALWAYS IN LOCKSTEP --
00:10:12.244 --> 00:10:13.879
WERE KIND OF FAMOUSLY A FREE
00:10:13.946 --> 00:10:15.748
THINKERS A BUT FOR A PARTY THAT
00:10:15.815 --> 00:10:17.216
HAS BEEN AT EACH OTHER'S THROATS
00:10:17.283 --> 00:10:18.718
FOR THE LAST YEAR OVER LIKE RE
00:10:18.784 --> 00:10:20.453
LITIGATING THE TWENTY SIXTEEN
00:10:20.519 --> 00:10:21.520
PRIMARY ELECTION.
00:10:21.587 --> 00:10:23.923
THIS BILL HAS UNIFIED THE PARTY
00:10:23.990 --> 00:10:25.291
MORE THAN ANYTHING I'VE SEEN IN
00:10:25.358 --> 00:10:26.525
MY TENURE AS A PARTY OFFICER IN
00:10:26.592 --> 00:10:27.660
TEN YEARS [inaudible]
00:10:27.727 --> 00:10:29.228
I'M.
00:10:29.295 --> 00:10:32.064
EVERY ELEMENT OF THIS PARTY FROM
00:10:32.131 --> 00:10:34.533
THE TOP LEVEL WITH A UNANIMOUS
00:10:34.600 --> 00:10:36.202
DECISION BY OUR EXECUTIVE BOARD
00:10:36.268 --> 00:10:37.803
DOWN TO THE SCORES OF CENTRAL
00:10:37.870 --> 00:10:38.871
COMMITTEES COUNTY CENTRAL
00:10:38.938 --> 00:10:40.072
COMMITTEES AND CLUBS.
00:10:40.139 --> 00:10:40.906
THAT HAVE BEEN CALLING THE
00:10:40.973 --> 00:10:42.074
REPRESENTATIVES SENDING IN
00:10:42.141 --> 00:10:43.476
LETTERS AND PASSING RESOLUTIONS
00:10:43.542 --> 00:10:45.077
ARE FINALLY SPEAKING WITH ONE
00:10:45.144 --> 00:10:47.480
VOICE TO SAY THAT A. B..
00:10:47.546 --> 00:10:48.981
EIGHTY FOUR WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL
00:10:49.048 --> 00:10:51.917
TO OUR PARTY'S ABILITY TO HONOR
00:10:51.984 --> 00:10:53.853
OUR DEMOCRATIC PROCESSES IT
00:10:53.919 --> 00:10:55.821
WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO ENGAGING
00:10:55.888 --> 00:10:57.623
NEW ACTIVISTS IN NEW VOLUNTEERS
00:10:57.690 --> 00:10:59.325
IT'S DETRIMENTAL TO BUILDING
00:10:59.392 --> 00:11:00.760
POLITICAL POWER WHICH IS OUR
00:11:00.826 --> 00:11:01.394
CHARGE.
00:11:01.460 --> 00:11:03.295
AND FRANKLY HONESTLY IN IF I CAN
00:11:03.362 --> 00:11:05.231
SPEAK ESPECIALLY DIRECTLY TO THE
00:11:05.297 --> 00:11:06.065
DEMOCRATIC MEMBERS OF THIS
00:11:06.132 --> 00:11:06.832
COMMITTEE.
00:11:06.899 --> 00:11:09.502
IT IS DETRIMENTAL TO OUR ABILITY
00:11:09.568 --> 00:11:11.470
IF LONG TERM IN ELECTING MORE
00:11:11.537 --> 00:11:13.672
DEMOCRATS TO THIS CHAMBER AND
00:11:13.739 --> 00:11:15.641
EVERY OTHER CHAMBER IN THE STATE.
00:11:15.708 --> 00:11:17.176
THE REASON FOR THAT IS THAT
00:11:17.243 --> 00:11:19.545
FRANKLY IF WE CAN JUST BE HONEST
00:11:19.612 --> 00:11:20.946
THIS IS NOT A TRANSPARENCY BILL.
00:11:21.013 --> 00:11:23.616
ASKING OUR COMMITTEES TO FILE
00:11:23.682 --> 00:11:24.450
THREE MORE --
00:11:24.517 --> 00:11:26.419
REPORTS A YEAR IS NOT GOING TO
00:11:26.485 --> 00:11:27.887
DO ANYTHING TO ADVANCE OTHER
00:11:27.953 --> 00:11:30.222
CLEAN MONEY BECAUSE I'M IN
00:11:30.289 --> 00:11:31.891
ADDITION IF THERE ARE ISSUES
00:11:31.957 --> 00:11:33.426
WITH TRANSPARENCY IN THE CURRENT
00:11:33.492 --> 00:11:35.294
SYSTEM WE AS A PARTY ARE
00:11:35.361 --> 00:11:36.896
ABSOLUTELY OPEN TO TALKING ABOUT.
00:11:36.962 --> 00:11:38.197
REFORMS THAT WOULD MAKE IT WOULD
00:11:38.264 --> 00:11:39.832
ADD MORE TRANSPARENCY TO THE WAY
00:11:39.899 --> 00:11:41.367
THAT WE WORK WITH OUR PARTNERS
00:11:41.434 --> 00:11:42.234
IN THE LEGISLATURE TO ELECT
00:11:42.301 --> 00:11:43.302
DEMOCRATS [inaudible]
00:11:43.369 --> 00:11:45.071
I'M.
00:11:45.137 --> 00:11:46.472
WE NEED DON'T ALWAYS SEE EYE TO
00:11:46.539 --> 00:11:48.407
EYE A 100% WITH OUR FRIENDS AND
00:11:48.474 --> 00:11:50.076
THEY ARE FRIENDS IN THE GOOD
00:11:50.142 --> 00:11:51.310
GOVERNMENT COMMUNITY.
00:11:51.377 --> 00:11:52.645
AND WE HAVE SOME DIFFERENCES
00:11:52.711 --> 00:11:54.146
HERE AND THERE AND POLICY BUT
00:11:54.213 --> 00:11:56.415
THEY ARE 1100% RIGHT BUT THERE'S
00:11:56.482 --> 00:11:57.917
TOO MUCH MONEY IN POLITICS.
00:11:57.983 --> 00:11:59.051
AND THAT WE NEED TO BE MOVING
00:11:59.118 --> 00:12:01.387
THE BALL FORWARD THIS BILL IS A
00:12:01.454 --> 00:12:02.688
STEP BACKWARDS CALIFORNIA
00:12:02.755 --> 00:12:04.924
POLITICS SIMPLY DOES NOT NEED
00:12:04.990 --> 00:12:06.392
MORE OPPORTUNITIES FOR BIG
00:12:06.459 --> 00:12:09.562
CHECKS TO GO TO CAMPAIGNS PERIOD.
00:12:09.628 --> 00:12:10.830
BUT FOR US THERE'S AN ADDED
00:12:10.896 --> 00:12:12.398
ELEMENT HERE THAT IS EXTREMELY
00:12:12.465 --> 00:12:14.400
IMPORTANT AN EXISTENTIAL.
00:12:14.467 --> 00:12:15.935
POLITICAL PARTY FUNDRAISING
00:12:16.001 --> 00:12:17.436
COMMITTEES SHOULD BE CONTROLLED
00:12:17.503 --> 00:12:19.438
BY POLITICAL PARTIES.
00:12:19.505 --> 00:12:21.607
THIS IS A FUNDAMENTAL LOGIC OF
00:12:21.674 --> 00:12:23.142
THE HISTORY OF CAMPAIGN FINANCE
00:12:23.209 --> 00:12:24.743
REFORM IN THE STATE AND I THINK
00:12:24.810 --> 00:12:25.878
IT WOULD MAKE SENSE TO ANYBODY
00:12:25.945 --> 00:12:28.080
YOU TALK TO ON THE STREET.
00:12:28.147 --> 00:12:29.882
IN ORDER TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
00:12:29.949 --> 00:12:31.951
THE LAW AS WRITTEN THAT ALLOWS
00:12:32.017 --> 00:12:34.220
US TO GET BIGGER CONTRIBUTIONS
00:12:34.286 --> 00:12:35.788
THAN AN INDIVIDUAL CANDIDATE AND
00:12:35.855 --> 00:12:37.256
MAKE UNLIMITED EXPENDITURES TO
00:12:37.323 --> 00:12:38.557
SUPPORT OUR CANDIDATES IT'S
00:12:38.624 --> 00:12:39.458
WRITTEN BECAUSE POLITICAL
00:12:39.525 --> 00:12:41.427
PARTIES CAMPAIGN FOR TONS OF
00:12:41.494 --> 00:12:42.661
CANDIDATES UP AND DOWN THE STATE.
00:12:42.728 --> 00:12:44.964
SO IT MAKES SENSE BUT THE WHAT
00:12:45.030 --> 00:12:46.165
MAKES THAT ACCOUNTABLE IN
00:12:46.232 --> 00:12:47.399
DEMOCRATIC IS THAT THOSE
00:12:47.466 --> 00:12:49.568
COMMITTEES ARE ARE ACCOUNTABLE
00:12:49.635 --> 00:12:51.604
AND BEHOLDEN AND CONTROLLED BY
00:12:51.670 --> 00:12:53.906
DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED.
00:12:53.973 --> 00:12:55.741
LEADERSHIP AND ACTIVISTS OF A
00:12:55.808 --> 00:12:57.510
POLITICAL PARTY WHAT THAT MEANS
00:12:57.576 --> 00:12:59.512
CONCRETELY IS FOR EXAMPLE THE
00:12:59.578 --> 00:13:00.546
CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY HAS
00:13:00.613 --> 00:13:01.914
A POLICY.
00:13:01.981 --> 00:13:02.982
THE WE DO NOT TAKE DIRECT
00:13:03.048 --> 00:13:04.350
CONTRIBUTIONSFROM THE FOSSIL
00:13:04.416 --> 00:13:05.851
FUEL INDUSTRY WE CANNOT TAKE
00:13:05.918 --> 00:13:07.353
DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THE
00:13:07.419 --> 00:13:09.722
PRIVATE PRISON INDUSTRY.
00:13:09.788 --> 00:13:11.323
WE MADE THOSE DECISIONS TOUGH AS
00:13:11.390 --> 00:13:12.758
THEY ARE BECAUSE WE'D LIKE
00:13:12.825 --> 00:13:14.527
ANYBODY UP ON THIS DYESS ARE
00:13:14.593 --> 00:13:16.262
POLITICAL ANIMALS AND KNOW WHAT
00:13:16.328 --> 00:13:18.230
WHAT CAMPAIGNS COST WE DID
00:13:18.297 --> 00:13:19.632
BECAUSE OF OVERWHELMING PRESSURE
00:13:19.698 --> 00:13:21.267
FROM OUR GRASSROOTS ACTIVISTS.
00:13:21.333 --> 00:13:23.969
IT WAS A DEMOCRATIC DECISION.
00:13:24.036 --> 00:13:24.570
EIGHTY EIGHTY FOUR WOULD ALLOW
00:13:24.637 --> 00:13:25.671
OUR LEADERSHIP IN THE
00:13:25.738 --> 00:13:27.439
LEGISLATURE TO SIDE STEP BACK
00:13:27.506 --> 00:13:29.041
DEMOCRATIC DECISION.
00:13:29.108 --> 00:13:31.443
MOST FUNDAMENTALLY IN ORDER FOR
00:13:31.510 --> 00:13:33.612
A CANDIDATE TO GET THE THE
00:13:33.679 --> 00:13:35.948
PRIVILEGE OR THE ADVANTAGE OF
00:13:36.015 --> 00:13:37.316
SUPPORT OF A PARTY COMMITTEE
00:13:37.383 --> 00:13:38.751
THEY SHOULD BE ENDORSED BY A
00:13:38.817 --> 00:13:40.619
POLITICAL PARTY.
00:13:40.686 --> 00:13:42.855
AND WE HAVE A PROCESS FOR
00:13:42.922 --> 00:13:44.056
ENDORSEMENT BUT FRANKLY IF I CAN
00:13:44.123 --> 00:13:44.957
BE [inaudible]
00:13:45.024 --> 00:13:47.593
TOTALLY HONEST WE GIVE OUR
00:13:47.660 --> 00:13:50.496
ELECTED OFFICIALS EXTRA VOISIN
00:13:50.563 --> 00:13:51.964
AND OUR LEADERSHIP IN THE
00:13:52.031 --> 00:13:52.932
ASSEMBLY AND SENATE EXTRA VOICE
00:13:52.998 --> 00:13:56.302
AND SO THAT THEY CAN BAKED HAM.
00:13:56.368 --> 00:13:58.037
INTERVENE TO HELP US CHOOSE WHO
00:13:58.103 --> 00:13:59.538
THAT CANDIDATE IS WITH A BIGGER
00:13:59.605 --> 00:14:00.539
VOICE FRANKLY THAN OUR AVERAGE
00:14:00.606 --> 00:14:02.808
MEMBERSHIP.
00:14:02.875 --> 00:14:04.677
THAT'S BECAUSE WE'RE PARTNERSHIP
00:14:04.743 --> 00:14:06.512
AB EIGHTY FOUR IS IKE YOUR
00:14:06.579 --> 00:14:08.347
FILING DIVORCE PAPERS.
00:14:08.414 --> 00:14:09.782
AND SAYING THAT INSTEAD OF THAT
00:14:09.848 --> 00:14:12.084
PARTNERSHIP YOU YOU WILL BE ABLE
00:14:12.151 --> 00:14:13.085
TO GO IT ALONE CHOOSE YOUR OWN
00:14:13.152 --> 00:14:14.520
CANDIDATES.
00:14:14.587 --> 00:14:15.988
CAMPAIGN FOR WHOMEVER NO MATTER
00:14:16.055 --> 00:14:17.590
WHO THE PARTY HAS CHOSEN.
00:14:17.656 --> 00:14:19.792
I DON'T KNOW HOW I CAN CONTINUE.
00:14:19.858 --> 00:14:21.760
AS AN ACTIVIST TO GO AND TALK TO
00:14:21.827 --> 00:14:24.196
YOUNG PEOPLE AND PEOPLE OF COLOR
00:14:24.263 --> 00:14:26.198
AND UNION MEMBERS AND
00:14:26.265 --> 00:14:27.700
DISAFFECTED FOLKS IN THE SOCIETY
00:14:27.766 --> 00:14:29.201
AND SAY HEY IF YOU WANT TO MAKE
00:14:29.268 --> 00:14:30.803
A CHANGE A GOOD WAY TO DO THAT.
00:14:30.869 --> 00:14:31.737
IS TO COME AND GET INVOLVED IN
00:14:31.804 --> 00:14:33.172
OUR PARTY AND THEN YOU HAVE A
00:14:33.239 --> 00:14:35.407
MEANINGFUL SAY OVER OUR PLATFORM
00:14:35.474 --> 00:14:36.709
AND A MEANINGFUL SAY OVER WHO
00:14:36.775 --> 00:14:37.977
ARE CANDIDATES ARE.
00:14:38.043 --> 00:14:40.045
ó BUT BY THE WAY ARE LEADERS
00:14:40.112 --> 00:14:41.547
IN THE ASSEMBLY IN THE SENATE IF
00:14:41.614 --> 00:14:43.515
THEY DISAGREE WITH US CAN JUST
00:14:43.582 --> 00:14:45.651
TURN AROUND AND RUN A CAMPAIGN
00:14:45.718 --> 00:14:49.054
WITH GIGANTIC A CONTRIBUTIONS.
00:14:49.121 --> 00:14:50.823
TOTALLY SEPARATE AND INDEPENDENT
00:14:50.889 --> 00:14:52.391
FROM WHATEVER YOU'VE JUST HAD AN
00:14:52.458 --> 00:14:53.859
INPUT INTO AND WHATEVER DECISION
00:14:53.926 --> 00:14:56.061
WE'VE MADE US PARTY.
00:14:56.128 --> 00:14:58.364
NOBODY WANTS THIS BILL.
00:14:58.430 --> 00:14:59.598
YOU CAN SEE FROM THE COALITION
00:14:59.665 --> 00:15:01.200
THAT HAS ASSEMBLED HERE.
00:15:01.267 --> 00:15:02.868
FROM HE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS
00:15:02.935 --> 00:15:04.470
TO YOUR OWN CONSTITUENTS AND
00:15:04.536 --> 00:15:06.505
ACTIVISTS BUT WEAR OUT THEIR
00:15:06.572 --> 00:15:08.407
SHOES TO PUT YOU IN OFFICE
00:15:08.474 --> 00:15:10.376
NOBODY WANTS THIS BILL I HAVEN'T
00:15:10.442 --> 00:15:11.910
HEARD A SINGLE WORD OF SUPPORT.
00:15:11.977 --> 00:15:13.579
FROM ANYBODY WHO FRANKLY DOESN'T
00:15:13.646 --> 00:15:15.014
WORK IN THIS BUILDING.
00:15:15.080 --> 00:15:16.949
IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE IT'S
00:15:17.016 --> 00:15:18.717
RUSHED WE CAN FIX THE PROBLEMS
00:15:18.784 --> 00:15:20.085
THAT HAVE BEEN THAT HAVE BEEN
00:15:20.152 --> 00:15:21.820
BROUGHT UP IN A MORE TRANSPARENT
00:15:21.887 --> 00:15:23.589
AND COLLABORATIVE WAY.
00:15:23.656 --> 00:15:25.024
I ASK YOU ON BEHALF OF THE
00:15:25.090 --> 00:15:26.558
CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY.
00:15:26.625 --> 00:15:28.427
STOP THIS BILL NOW WOULD SIT
00:15:28.494 --> 00:15:29.928
DOWN LIKE ADULTS AND PARTNERS
00:15:29.995 --> 00:15:31.764
AND WORK AND WORK TO MOVE THE
00:15:31.830 --> 00:15:33.432
BALL FORWARD ON GETTING MONEY
00:15:33.499 --> 00:15:35.067
OUT OF POLITICS AND FRANKLY MORE
00:15:35.134 --> 00:15:36.035
DEMOCRATS IN OFFICE THANK YOU.
00:15:36.101 --> 00:15:39.138
THANK YOU MISTER VICE CHAIR.
00:15:39.204 --> 00:15:39.738
AND IF YOU DON'T MIND JUST BE
00:15:39.805 --> 00:15:41.707
BRIEF.
00:15:41.774 --> 00:15:42.808
IS THERE A YEAH ANSWER EMILY
00:15:42.875 --> 00:15:44.943
RAIMES.
00:15:45.010 --> 00:15:46.245
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF CAL PER
00:15:46.312 --> 00:15:47.446
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC INTEREST
00:15:47.513 --> 00:15:49.448
RESEARCH GROUP I'M SO I'M JUST
00:15:49.515 --> 00:15:51.383
IN CLOSING I WANT SUPPLY ONCE
00:15:51.450 --> 00:15:52.985
AGAIN ECHO MIGHT THE COMMENTS OF
00:15:53.052 --> 00:15:54.253
CALIFORNIA COMMON CAUSE AND WE
00:15:54.320 --> 00:15:55.688
CAN WIN VOTERS THAT WE ARE VERY
00:15:55.754 --> 00:15:57.089
CONCERNED THAT THIS BILL IN
00:15:57.156 --> 00:15:59.124
PARTICULAR OPENS UP. FOR NEW
00:15:59.191 --> 00:16:00.993
AVENUES FOR REALLY BIG
00:16:01.060 --> 00:16:02.628
CONTRIBUTIONS TO FLOW INTO OUR
00:16:02.695 --> 00:16:03.829
POLITICAL SYSTEM.
00:16:03.896 --> 00:16:05.130
WE'VE LONG OPPOSE CAMPAIGN
00:16:05.197 --> 00:16:06.465
CONTRIBUTION LIMITS THAT ARE OUT
00:16:06.532 --> 00:16:07.399
OF REACH FOR ORDINARY
00:16:07.466 --> 00:16:08.901
CALIFORNIANS.
00:16:08.967 --> 00:16:10.269
THE MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME AND
00:16:10.336 --> 00:16:12.838
CALIFORNIA RIGHT NOW IS ABOUT
00:16:12.905 --> 00:16:13.639
SIXTY SIX THOUSAND DOLLARS IF
00:16:13.706 --> 00:16:15.341
YOU TAKE YOU KNOW THE CONCEPT OF
00:16:15.407 --> 00:16:18.344
EACH SPOUSE BEING ABLE TO GIVE.
00:16:18.410 --> 00:16:19.244
THIRTY SIX FIVE UNDER THIS BILL
00:16:19.311 --> 00:16:20.579
THAT'S EASILY EXCEEDING THE
00:16:20.646 --> 00:16:21.980
MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME IN
00:16:22.047 --> 00:16:24.116
CALIFORNIA RIGHT NOW.
00:16:24.183 --> 00:16:24.650
I'M.
00:16:24.717 --> 00:16:26.852
AND FORTY FOUR I SENT FORTY FOUR
00:16:26.919 --> 00:16:27.486
HUNDRED DOLLAR CAMPAIGN COUNTRY
00:16:27.553 --> 00:16:28.954
SOME SORT LEGISLATIVE CANDIDATES
00:16:29.021 --> 00:16:30.789
ARE ALREADY OUT OF REACH FOR
00:16:30.856 --> 00:16:32.358
MOST AVERAGE CALIFORNIA TO WHAT
00:16:32.424 --> 00:16:34.226
THEY COULD AFFORD TO GIVE TO THE
00:16:34.293 --> 00:16:35.594
CANDIDATE OF THEIR CHOICE.
00:16:35.661 --> 00:16:37.930
I'M SO WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THIS
00:16:37.996 --> 00:16:39.498
BILL WILL LEAD TO MORE.
00:16:39.565 --> 00:16:41.133
REALLY BIG CONTRIBUTIONS AND THE
00:16:41.200 --> 00:16:43.035
POLITICAL SYSTEM.
00:16:43.102 --> 00:16:44.703
I'M AND WELL WE UNDERSTAND THAT
00:16:44.770 --> 00:16:46.505
THE BILL WAS DESIGNED TO YOU ARE
00:16:46.572 --> 00:16:48.040
NOT WRITTEN IN PART TO COUNTER
00:16:48.107 --> 00:16:49.375
THE EFFECTS OF INDEPENDENT
00:16:49.441 --> 00:16:50.476
EXPENDITURES FLOWING INTO
00:16:50.542 --> 00:16:52.311
ELECTION SYSTEMS.
00:16:52.378 --> 00:16:53.746
AND YOU KNOW I WANT TO NOTE THAT
00:16:53.812 --> 00:16:55.314
WHILE WE OPPOSE THE SUPREME
00:16:55.381 --> 00:16:56.849
COURT DECISIONS THAT LED TO
00:16:56.915 --> 00:16:58.150
INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES
00:16:58.217 --> 00:16:59.785
BALLOONING OVER THE PAST SEVERAL
00:16:59.852 --> 00:17:01.353
EARS WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT THIS
00:17:01.420 --> 00:17:03.455
BILL IS AN APPROPRIATE RESPONSE.
00:17:03.522 --> 00:17:04.957
ONE OF OUR CONCERNS IS THAT THE
00:17:05.023 --> 00:17:05.557
PERCEPTION OF CORRUPTION IS
00:17:05.624 --> 00:17:06.625
HIGHER.
00:17:06.692 --> 00:17:08.427
WIN BIG DONORS GIVE DIRECTLY TO
00:17:08.494 --> 00:17:10.596
LEGISLATIVE CAMPAIGNS --
00:17:10.662 --> 00:17:11.096
AND THAT PERCEPTION OF
00:17:11.163 --> 00:17:12.798
CORRUPTION IS ALREADY A VOTING
00:17:12.865 --> 00:17:14.566
PUBLIC TRUST IN OUR GOVERNMENT
00:17:14.633 --> 00:17:15.501
WE DON'T WANT TO SEE A ROAD IT
00:17:15.567 --> 00:17:18.137
ANY FURTHER SO ONCE AGAIN WE
00:17:18.203 --> 00:17:18.737
URGE YOU TO A POSSIBLE FAMOUS
00:17:18.804 --> 00:17:19.171
RUSSIAN.
00:17:19.238 --> 00:17:21.974
OTHERS IN OPPOSITION.
00:17:22.040 --> 00:17:25.744
YOU CAN LINE UP.
00:17:25.811 --> 00:17:26.278
GIVE ME JUST A SEC TO GET
00:17:26.345 --> 00:17:30.315
SETTLED.
00:17:30.382 --> 00:17:34.153
THANK YOU ARE.
00:17:34.219 --> 00:17:35.854
OKAY I'VE TRENT LANE PRESIDENT
00:17:35.921 --> 00:17:38.223
CALIFORNIA CLEAN MONEY CAMPAIGN
00:17:38.290 --> 00:17:39.591
THANK YOU MEMBERS --
00:17:39.658 --> 00:17:41.960
OF WE HAVE INCREDIBLE ADMIRATION
00:17:42.027 --> 00:17:43.095
FOR ASSEMBLY MEMBER MULLIN HE
00:17:43.162 --> 00:17:44.363
HAS TRULY BEEN A LEADER IN
00:17:44.430 --> 00:17:45.531
TRANSPARENCY AND WE ARE
00:17:45.597 --> 00:17:46.598
CONTINUING.
00:17:46.665 --> 00:17:47.900
AND WILL CONTINUE TO WORK BY HIS
00:17:47.966 --> 00:17:50.035
SIDE ON THE SOCIAL MEDIA
00:17:50.102 --> 00:17:51.670
DISCLOSE ACT AND OTHER BILLS.
00:17:51.737 --> 00:17:52.771
WE RESPECT THAT THE THE
00:17:52.838 --> 00:17:54.473
TRANSPARENCY ASPECTS OF IT BUT
00:17:54.540 --> 00:17:56.341
THEY ARE WAY TOO MODEST FOR THE
00:17:56.408 --> 00:17:57.609
INCREDIBLE CHANGE HERE.
00:17:57.676 --> 00:17:58.844
THERE REALLY IS NOT ENOUGH
00:17:58.911 --> 00:18:00.212
REFORM THERE REALLY IS NOT
00:18:00.279 --> 00:18:02.581
ENOUGH TIME TO LOOK AT IT.
00:18:02.648 --> 00:18:04.049
EVERY SINGLE ACTIVISTS WE TALKED
00:18:04.116 --> 00:18:05.384
TO IT'S BEEN APPALLED HE WILL
00:18:05.451 --> 00:18:06.819
TRY TO DESCRIBE IT FAIRLY SELF.
00:18:06.885 --> 00:18:09.087
AND WE RESPECT THE URGES A A NO
00:18:09.154 --> 00:18:10.789
VOTE AND WE CANCOME BACK LOOK
00:18:10.856 --> 00:18:11.523
THESE ISSUES NEXT YEAR WHEN
00:18:11.590 --> 00:18:12.791
THERE'S TIME THANK YOU GREAT
00:18:12.858 --> 00:18:14.126
THANK YOU WRESTLING AND FROM
00:18:14.193 --> 00:18:16.061
HERE ON OUT I'M GONNA ASK JUST
00:18:16.128 --> 00:18:17.396
NAME WHERE YOU'RE FROM CLEAN
00:18:17.463 --> 00:18:18.697
MONEY CAMPAIGN HADN'T HAD A
00:18:18.764 --> 00:18:19.865
CHANCE TO SPEAK YET.
00:18:19.932 --> 00:18:21.834
SO ONE INDULGE THAT BUT IF
00:18:21.900 --> 00:18:23.635
THAT'S ALRIGHT MISTER ASHER.
00:18:23.702 --> 00:18:24.803
I RYAN'S GONNA CATHERINE
00:18:24.870 --> 00:18:25.904
DEMOCRATIC PARTY SENIOR VALLEY
00:18:25.971 --> 00:18:27.439
STRONGLY OPPOSED TO AB AT THANK
00:18:27.506 --> 00:18:29.274
MISCONDUCT.
00:18:29.341 --> 00:18:30.576
EARLY STERLING EXECUTIVE
00:18:30.642 --> 00:18:31.710
DIRECTOR OF THE YELLOW COUNTY
00:18:31.777 --> 00:18:32.945
CENTRAL COMMITTEE STRONGLY
00:18:33.011 --> 00:18:34.112
OPPOSED TO A BT FOUR THANKS SO
00:18:34.179 --> 00:18:37.649
MUCH.
00:18:37.716 --> 00:18:39.451
IF YOU GUYS ROTATE THROUGH AFTER
00:18:39.518 --> 00:18:40.752
YOU SPEAK IN THE NEOVIA LOOP
00:18:40.819 --> 00:18:41.787
BACK AROUND THE ROOM
00:18:41.854 --> 00:18:42.087
[inaudible]
00:18:42.154 --> 00:18:42.921
YEAH.
00:18:42.988 --> 00:18:45.190
THANK YOU ALL.
00:18:45.257 --> 00:18:46.391
NUMBER SURE GOING TO HAVE THE
00:18:46.458 --> 00:18:47.993
AMERICAN SICK PUBLIC AFFAIRS
00:18:48.060 --> 00:18:50.195
SOCIUS I STRONGLY OPPOSE ALSO
00:18:50.262 --> 00:18:51.697
WAS AN EXECUTIVE BOARD MEMBER
00:18:51.763 --> 00:18:53.298
THE CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY.
00:18:53.365 --> 00:18:54.199
IF YOU'RE LOOKING FOR A WAY TO
00:18:54.266 --> 00:18:56.735
UNITE THE PARTY AGAINST THOSE
00:18:56.802 --> 00:18:57.369
PEOPLE THAT ARE VOTING FOR THIS
00:18:57.436 --> 00:18:58.370
BILL.
00:18:58.437 --> 00:19:02.107
I FOUND A WAY THANK YOU.
00:19:02.174 --> 00:19:03.909
LINDA DIAZ DAVIS CALIFORNIA
00:19:03.976 --> 00:19:05.010
STRONGLY OPPOSE THANK YOU THANK
00:19:05.077 --> 00:19:06.745
YOU SO MUCH.
00:19:06.812 --> 00:19:08.013
HI MY NAME IS EVAN MAINTAIN THEM
00:19:08.080 --> 00:19:09.948
WITH CALIFORNIA VOICES FOR
00:19:10.015 --> 00:19:10.916
PROGRESS WERE OPPOSED IN LESS
00:19:10.983 --> 00:19:12.951
AMENDED AT WE WOULDN'T REMOVE
00:19:13.018 --> 00:19:14.686
OUR OPPOSITION AND LAST OF FOUR
00:19:14.753 --> 00:19:16.622
AND THE FOUR POLITICAL PARTIES
00:19:16.688 --> 00:19:18.190
SECTION FOR A STRIP FROM THE
00:19:18.257 --> 00:19:19.391
BILL SECTION FOUR IS THE
00:19:19.458 --> 00:19:21.360
CREATION OF THE FOUR POLITICAL
00:19:21.426 --> 00:19:21.593
PARTIES.
00:19:21.660 --> 00:19:23.328
THEY CAN THANK YOU.
00:19:23.395 --> 00:19:25.197
HELLO MY NAME IS VAN RAINY WITH
00:19:25.264 --> 00:19:26.999
LITTLE MORE INDIVISIBLE.
00:19:27.065 --> 00:19:28.500
AND ALSO WOULD LIKE TO REMIND
00:19:28.567 --> 00:19:29.668
YOU THAT WE ARE THE REAL
00:19:29.735 --> 00:19:31.436
CITIZENS UNITED AGAINST THIS
00:19:31.503 --> 00:19:35.941
BILL THANK.
00:19:36.008 --> 00:19:38.710
BOB WORD WILL LOOK CREEK --
00:19:38.777 --> 00:19:40.245
ROSS MORE DEMOCRATIC CLUB.
00:19:40.312 --> 00:19:41.813
AND I'M STRONGLY OPPOSED TO THIS
00:19:41.880 --> 00:19:45.317
BILL THANK YOU SIR.
00:19:45.384 --> 00:19:46.818
TREVOR MARTIN --
00:19:46.885 --> 00:19:48.253
DISTRICT NINETEEN REFORM
00:19:48.320 --> 00:19:50.455
DEMOCRAT SAN FRANCISCO TREASURER
00:19:50.522 --> 00:19:51.790
OF THE SAN FRANCISCO BERNIE
00:19:51.857 --> 00:19:53.659
KRATZ TREASURE OF SAN FRANCISCO
00:19:53.725 --> 00:19:55.027
FOR DEMOCRACY AND FOUNDING
00:19:55.093 --> 00:19:56.128
MEMBER OF SAN FRANCISCO
00:19:56.194 --> 00:19:57.963
PROGRESSIVE ALLIANCE.
00:19:58.030 --> 00:20:00.432
WE STAND INCOMPLETE OPPOSITION
00:20:00.499 --> 00:20:03.902
TO AB EIGHTY FOUR THANK YOU.
00:20:03.969 --> 00:20:05.804
CONNIE ANDERSONSACRAMENTO
00:20:05.871 --> 00:20:08.106
FORMER MEMBER I HAVE CAL AT THE
00:20:08.173 --> 00:20:09.942
ON CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY
00:20:10.008 --> 00:20:11.677
IN SACRAMENTO COUNTY --
00:20:11.743 --> 00:20:14.079
CENTRAL COMMITTEE SO PLEASE VOTE
00:20:14.146 --> 00:20:15.647
NO THIS IS A CITIZENS UNITED
00:20:15.714 --> 00:20:18.917
LIGHT WE BELIEVE WE CAN KEEP THE
00:20:18.984 --> 00:20:20.052
GOOD PARTON DO WAY OFF THE MARK.
00:20:20.118 --> 00:20:23.755
THANK YOU.
00:20:23.822 --> 00:20:25.223
KIANA BLISS GRASSROOTS VOLUNTEER
00:20:25.290 --> 00:20:26.592
COORDINATOR OF THE MOVE TO AMEND
00:20:26.658 --> 00:20:28.527
COALITION I'M STRONG OPPOSITION
00:20:28.594 --> 00:20:30.729
TO THIS BILL AND OUR MIND OF THE
00:20:30.796 --> 00:20:31.997
DEMOCRATIC PARTY MEMBERS OF THIS
00:20:32.064 --> 00:20:32.531
COMMITTEE --
00:20:32.598 --> 00:20:34.700
THAT YOUR UP TWENTY EIGHTEEN
00:20:34.766 --> 00:20:36.134
PLATFORM ON POLITICAL REFORM --
00:20:36.201 --> 00:20:37.869
EXPRESSLY CALLED UPON YOU TO
00:20:37.936 --> 00:20:39.738
OPPOSED THE CULTURE OF CRONYISM
00:20:39.805 --> 00:20:41.306
AND CORRUPTION IN THIS BILL --
00:20:41.373 --> 00:20:42.808
AND ALSO DEMAND EQUAL
00:20:42.874 --> 00:20:44.509
OPPORTUNITY FOR INFLUENCE OF
00:20:44.576 --> 00:20:45.677
SUPPORT AND ENCOURAGE THE
00:20:45.744 --> 00:20:46.478
IMPLEMENTATION OF FULL
00:20:46.545 --> 00:20:49.381
DISCLOSURE THEN ACCESSIBILITY
00:20:49.448 --> 00:20:52.117
AND ACCOUNTABILITY AS WELL THANK.
00:20:52.184 --> 00:20:53.852
NGUYEN DAVIDSON CALIFORNIA VOTER
00:20:53.919 --> 00:20:55.754
FROM BERKELEY STRONGLY OPPOSED
00:20:55.821 --> 00:20:58.423
TO THIS BILL THANK.
00:20:58.490 --> 00:21:00.225
JOAN LECTURE MEN FROM OAKLAND UP
00:21:00.292 --> 00:21:02.761
THE CW A NINE ONE ONE NINE WERE
00:21:02.828 --> 00:21:03.862
TOTALLY OPPOSED TO THIS.
00:21:03.929 --> 00:21:05.697
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:21:05.764 --> 00:21:07.032
NORMAL COLOR I'M WITH THE
00:21:07.099 --> 00:21:08.367
CHICANO LATINO CAUCUS THE
00:21:08.433 --> 00:21:09.568
CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY AND
00:21:09.635 --> 00:21:10.102
WE ARE OPPOSED [inaudible]
00:21:10.168 --> 00:21:12.704
THANK YOU.
00:21:12.771 --> 00:21:14.573
GARY APPEL MILL VALLEY --
00:21:14.640 --> 00:21:15.440
MILL VALLEY COMMUNITY ACTION
00:21:15.507 --> 00:21:16.975
NETWORK WITH A THOUSAND MEMBERS
00:21:17.042 --> 00:21:20.045
I'M OPPOSED --
00:21:20.112 --> 00:21:22.147
S. B. OAKLAND.
00:21:22.214 --> 00:21:26.652
A. B. EIGHTY FOUR THANKS.
00:21:26.718 --> 00:21:27.753
FOR SUSAN PENNER EMERYVILLE
00:21:27.819 --> 00:21:29.388
CALIFORNIA OPPOSED TO THE BILL
00:21:29.454 --> 00:21:31.590
THANK MISTER.
00:21:31.657 --> 00:21:33.258
PAULA WE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS
00:21:33.325 --> 00:21:37.195
SACRAMENTO COUNTY OPPOSED.
00:21:37.262 --> 00:21:38.263
SEAT YOU EVER LEGISLATIVE
00:21:38.330 --> 00:21:39.665
COMMITTEE CHAIR PEACE AND
00:21:39.731 --> 00:21:41.233
FREEDOM PARTY CALIFORNIA IN
00:21:41.299 --> 00:21:42.934
FIGHTING NOW BAD LEGISLATION FOR
00:21:43.001 --> 00:21:44.269
OVER FIFTY YEARS [inaudible]
00:21:44.336 --> 00:21:46.405
THANKS WEBER.
00:21:46.471 --> 00:21:48.173
ACKLAND DOOR SACRAMENTO OR JUROR
00:21:48.240 --> 00:21:50.809
NO VOTE ON EIGHTY FOUR BILL
00:21:50.876 --> 00:21:52.310
KNOCKS DAVIS CALIFORNIA READ
00:21:52.377 --> 00:21:53.111
ABOUT THIS FIRST IN THE
00:21:53.178 --> 00:21:54.579
SACRAMENT BEING ANGRY AND OPPOSE.
00:21:54.646 --> 00:21:56.782
THANK YOU.
00:21:56.848 --> 00:21:58.316
RALPH FINLEY SANTA CRUZ
00:21:58.383 --> 00:22:00.252
MOUNTAINS REPRESENTING THREE
00:22:00.318 --> 00:22:01.019
FIFTY DOT ORG.
00:22:01.086 --> 00:22:03.622
ANY INCREASE IN LARGE DARK MONEY
00:22:03.689 --> 00:22:06.525
DONATIONS WILL FEEL PUN INTENDED
00:22:06.591 --> 00:22:07.292
OUR CURRENT CLIMATE CRISIS
00:22:07.359 --> 00:22:07.592
[inaudible]
00:22:07.659 --> 00:22:09.761
THANK YOU.
00:22:09.828 --> 00:22:10.929
LAURIE JUNE SACRAMENTO
00:22:10.996 --> 00:22:12.564
CALIFORNIA STRONGLY URGE NO ON
00:22:12.631 --> 00:22:13.465
EIGHTY FOUR TOOK THANK YOU SO
00:22:13.532 --> 00:22:15.367
MUCH.
00:22:15.434 --> 00:22:16.568
JOHN IRVING NAY COMMUNICATIONS
00:22:16.635 --> 00:22:17.436
DIRECTOR FOR THE CALIFORNIA
00:22:17.502 --> 00:22:18.804
DEMOCRATIC PARTY REITERATING
00:22:18.870 --> 00:22:20.906
OFFICERS FORMAL SUPPORT
00:22:20.972 --> 00:22:23.341
OPPOSITION THANK YOU.
00:22:23.408 --> 00:22:25.110
MARK'S MUSKY VALLEY GLAND
00:22:25.177 --> 00:22:25.610
STRONGLY OPPOSE.
00:22:25.677 --> 00:22:30.482
THANK YOU SIR. TO NASA TELLIN
00:22:30.549 --> 00:22:31.817
SURPRISING INDIVISIBLE STATE
00:22:31.883 --> 00:22:33.518
STRONG FIFTY THOUSAND MEMBERS
00:22:33.585 --> 00:22:35.554
INDIVISIBLE UP GROWTH AND AND
00:22:35.620 --> 00:22:37.022
WESTERN PROGRESSIVE DEMOCRATS IN
00:22:37.089 --> 00:22:38.323
VEHEMENT OPPOSITION [inaudible]
00:22:38.390 --> 00:22:40.125
VERY MUCH.
00:22:40.192 --> 00:22:42.761
TINA MCKENNA OPERATIONS DIRECTOR
00:22:42.828 --> 00:22:43.595
FOR THE CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC
00:22:43.662 --> 00:22:45.797
PARTY AND MEMBER OF THE BLACK
00:22:45.864 --> 00:22:46.832
WOMEN'S DEMOCRATIC CLUB.
00:22:46.898 --> 00:22:50.969
OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:22:51.036 --> 00:22:52.571
MY DS THATTA CANDIDATE FOR THE
00:22:52.637 --> 00:22:53.739
SIXTY THIRD ASSEMBLY DISTRICT
00:22:53.805 --> 00:22:54.840
WHICH IS ONE OF THE MOST
00:22:54.906 --> 00:22:55.841
UNDERREPRESENTED DISTRICTS IN
00:22:55.907 --> 00:22:56.808
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WHICH
00:22:56.875 --> 00:22:58.577
HAS ALSO THE MOST --
00:22:58.643 --> 00:22:59.678
ENVIRONMENTALLY HAZARDOUS
00:22:59.745 --> 00:23:01.913
CONDITIONS IN THE STATE.
00:23:01.980 --> 00:23:03.515
AND HAS OBVIOUSLY THERE ARE
00:23:03.582 --> 00:23:05.283
CORPORATIONS REPRESENTED A IS
00:23:05.350 --> 00:23:08.553
STRONGLY OPPOSED TO DISPEL.
00:23:08.620 --> 00:23:10.255
I'D JUST LIKE SWELLED SAN MATTEO
00:23:10.322 --> 00:23:11.790
A CO CHAIR OF THE PENINSULA
00:23:11.857 --> 00:23:12.824
CHAPTER OF THE DEMOCRATIC
00:23:12.891 --> 00:23:14.526
SOCIALISTS OF AMERICA AS AN
00:23:14.593 --> 00:23:16.762
ORGANIZATION WE STRONGLY OPPOSE
00:23:16.828 --> 00:23:19.397
ABA BEFORE THANK YOU THANKS.
00:23:19.464 --> 00:23:21.099
LOU ANNA VILLANUEVA.
00:23:21.166 --> 00:23:22.400
YOLO COUNTY.
00:23:22.467 --> 00:23:24.536
PROGRESSIVES DEMOCRATIC CLUB
00:23:24.603 --> 00:23:28.073
VERY OPPOSED TO THIS BILL.
00:23:28.140 --> 00:23:30.075
MARY FILTH SHEA SAN FRANCISCO
00:23:30.142 --> 00:23:31.243
VOTER REPRESENTATIVE OF CLEAN
00:23:31.309 --> 00:23:35.814
MONEY STRONGLY OPPOSE THE BILL.
00:23:35.881 --> 00:23:37.749
DOTTY NYGAARD SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY
00:23:37.816 --> 00:23:39.017
DELEGATE FOR OUR CENTRAL
00:23:39.084 --> 00:23:41.520
COMMITTEE ADAMANTLY OPPOSE THIS
00:23:41.586 --> 00:23:44.289
BILL THINKING.
00:23:44.356 --> 00:23:45.924
MARGARETMARY FROM PINOLE I
00:23:45.991 --> 00:23:50.762
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:23:50.829 --> 00:23:52.531
CARRY COREY STOCKTON ASSEMBLY
00:23:52.597 --> 00:23:53.999
DISTRICT DELEGATE THIRTEEN
00:23:54.065 --> 00:23:55.433
OPPOSE THIS BILL AS WELL AS THE
00:23:55.500 --> 00:23:56.401
GREATER LODI AREA DEMOCRATS
00:23:56.468 --> 00:23:57.435
OPPOSED.
00:23:57.502 --> 00:24:00.172
VERY GOOD THANKS SO MUCH.
00:24:00.238 --> 00:24:02.207
NOT DEPEND SONICS PROUD RESIDENT
00:24:02.274 --> 00:24:04.609
OF OAKLAND I OPPOSE THIS BILL
00:24:04.676 --> 00:24:06.611
BECAUSE IT WILL ONLY ADD TO MORE
00:24:06.678 --> 00:24:07.345
CORPORATE BRIBERY.
00:24:07.412 --> 00:24:10.215
THANK.
00:24:10.282 --> 00:24:12.083
HELENA VAIL OAKLAND STRONGLY
00:24:12.150 --> 00:24:12.484
OPPOSE [inaudible]
00:24:12.551 --> 00:24:14.953
THANK.
00:24:15.020 --> 00:24:16.254
DEBORAH MECKLER SOUTH SAN
00:24:16.321 --> 00:24:18.924
FRANCISCO DARK MONEY DESTROYS
00:24:18.990 --> 00:24:22.160
DEMOCRACY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:24:22.227 --> 00:24:23.662
DONNA DE TOMAR REPRESENTING THE
00:24:23.728 --> 00:24:25.564
ALBENA CAUCUS A GROUP OF VOTERS
00:24:25.630 --> 00:24:27.599
FROM A ALAMEDA AND CONTRA COSTA
00:24:27.666 --> 00:24:29.000
COUNTY.
00:24:29.067 --> 00:24:29.634
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK
00:24:29.701 --> 00:24:32.070
YOU HAVE.
00:24:32.137 --> 00:24:33.705
WELL MARY RYAN SAN FRANCISCO
00:24:33.772 --> 00:24:34.472
VOLUNTEERS CALIFORNICA MONEY
00:24:34.539 --> 00:24:36.107
CAN'T BUY.
00:24:36.174 --> 00:24:36.708
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOU VOTE
00:24:36.775 --> 00:24:39.277
NO.
00:24:39.344 --> 00:24:40.278
CHRIS SALMON FROM BERKELEY
00:24:40.345 --> 00:24:43.849
PLEASE VOTE NO.
00:24:43.915 --> 00:24:45.283
GORDON MILLER WALMART CREEK
00:24:45.350 --> 00:24:47.085
MONEY OUT PEOPLE AND COALITION
00:24:47.152 --> 00:24:49.054
WERE VIGOROUSLY OPPOSED TO THIS
00:24:49.120 --> 00:24:49.754
BILL.
00:24:49.821 --> 00:24:51.756
AS A SOLUTION I CAN SAY THAT
00:24:51.823 --> 00:24:54.059
THERE SAYS GUIDED A LOT OF WHAT
00:24:54.125 --> 00:24:55.093
REMAINED OF MY FAITH IN THE
00:24:55.160 --> 00:24:56.795
POLITICAL SYSTEM AND AMENDED IT
00:24:56.862 --> 00:24:58.530
WITH A DEEP AND ABIDING DISTRUST
00:24:58.597 --> 00:24:58.830
[inaudible]
00:24:58.897 --> 00:25:02.300
PLEASE SUPPOSED.
00:25:02.367 --> 00:25:04.035
IT ARE LINE OAKHURST CALIFORNIA
00:25:04.102 --> 00:25:05.871
UNDER THE SMOKY SKIES --
00:25:05.937 --> 00:25:07.372
ALSO REPRESENTING MY WIFE ARLENE
00:25:07.439 --> 00:25:09.207
OKAY IN MY DAUGHTER WHO HOPES TO
00:25:09.274 --> 00:25:10.242
VOTE IN JUNE.
00:25:10.308 --> 00:25:12.210
SHE TURNS.
00:25:12.277 --> 00:25:13.245
EIGHTEEN AND SYSTEM SHE CAN
00:25:13.311 --> 00:25:14.312
BELIEVE AND I'M A DELEGATE TO
00:25:14.379 --> 00:25:15.647
THE POOR --
00:25:15.714 --> 00:25:16.848
EIGHTY FIVE DEMOCRATIC PARTY AND
00:25:16.915 --> 00:25:18.283
THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE MEMBER ASK
00:25:18.350 --> 00:25:19.351
FOR YOUR OPPOSITION THANK YOU SO
00:25:19.417 --> 00:25:22.854
MUCH THANK YOU.
00:25:22.921 --> 00:25:24.322
PLEASE MAIL ANYTHING SAID
00:25:24.389 --> 00:25:25.991
SACRAMENTO THANKING YOU ADVANCED
00:25:26.057 --> 00:25:28.026
PROCESS SENDING US BACK TO THE
00:25:28.093 --> 00:25:28.560
DRAWING BOARD [inaudible]
00:25:28.627 --> 00:25:31.196
THANKS HI KAREN BACK FROM
00:25:31.263 --> 00:25:32.998
DANVILLE PART OF MOVEON TYRONE
00:25:33.064 --> 00:25:34.466
BAILEY DEMOCRATIC CLUB.
00:25:34.532 --> 00:25:35.267
AND I REALLY HOPE YOU'LL VOTE
00:25:35.333 --> 00:25:36.935
AGAINST US TRONG [inaudible]
00:25:37.002 --> 00:25:39.537
THANK.
00:25:39.604 --> 00:25:41.039
HI I'M MARY LYNTON FROM SAN
00:25:41.106 --> 00:25:42.307
RAMON CALIFORNIA.
00:25:42.374 --> 00:25:44.042
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
00:25:44.109 --> 00:25:45.810
I THINK WE NEED BIG MONEY OUT OF
00:25:45.877 --> 00:25:47.279
POLITICS DEMOCRACY.
00:25:47.345 --> 00:25:48.346
BUT YES DEMOCRACY NO ON THIS
00:25:48.413 --> 00:25:51.650
BILL TAKES MY S. TEACHER I KNOW
00:25:51.716 --> 00:25:54.586
FROM SALINAS FROM SASS SAFE BAG
00:25:54.653 --> 00:25:55.987
SAFE SCHOOLS.
00:25:56.054 --> 00:25:57.722
A DERIVATIVE OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:25:57.789 --> 00:26:01.192
FOR PESTICIDE REFORM ANDWE HOPE
00:26:01.259 --> 00:26:03.061
TO HAVE THIS BILL DEFEATED
00:26:03.128 --> 00:26:06.064
VACATION MUCH.
00:26:06.131 --> 00:26:07.265
JIM HART PERENNIAL VOTER IN
00:26:07.332 --> 00:26:09.000
SACRAMENTO HOPE YOU'LL DEFEAT
00:26:09.067 --> 00:26:12.270
THIS BILL TODAY TAKE SOME.
00:26:12.337 --> 00:26:14.005
DONNA POLISH A LOS ALTOS
00:26:14.072 --> 00:26:16.641
CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA CLEAN MANY
00:26:16.708 --> 00:26:19.844
CAMPAIGN PLEASE OPPOSE THANK.
00:26:19.911 --> 00:26:21.446
I AIR GOOD SO DEMOCRAT FROM
00:26:21.513 --> 00:26:22.547
DAVIS CALIFORNIA ALSO
00:26:22.614 --> 00:26:23.748
COMMISSIONER AND A FORMER
00:26:23.815 --> 00:26:25.016
CANDIDATE FOR CITY COUNCIL FOR
00:26:25.083 --> 00:26:26.584
THE CITY OF DAVIS I URGE YOU TO
00:26:26.651 --> 00:26:27.953
VOTE NO AND I'M IN STRONG
00:26:28.019 --> 00:26:28.553
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL THANK
00:26:28.620 --> 00:26:31.589
YOU THANK.
00:26:31.656 --> 00:26:33.158
I KAREN BERNAL --
00:26:33.224 --> 00:26:34.426
CHAIR OF THE PERMITS THAT IF
00:26:34.492 --> 00:26:35.694
CAUCUS OF THE STATE DEMOCRATIC
00:26:35.760 --> 00:26:38.463
PARTY TO MY FELLOW DEMOCRATS.
00:26:38.530 --> 00:26:40.031
THIS ONE SAY CAN'T BE SAID THAT
00:26:40.098 --> 00:26:41.633
CITING WITH THE PEOPLE WHO
00:26:41.700 --> 00:26:43.034
CONSTITUTE OUR BASE IS EVEN
00:26:43.101 --> 00:26:44.803
REMOTELY POSSIBLE WHEN THE PARTY
00:26:44.869 --> 00:26:45.704
METERS MAY.
00:26:45.770 --> 00:26:46.972
MAKE CHOICES FOR WHO'S ON THE
00:26:47.038 --> 00:26:49.841
TEAM BASED ON PAY TO PLAY PLEASE
00:26:49.908 --> 00:26:53.144
VOTE NO.
00:26:53.211 --> 00:26:55.347
I AMY CHAMP FROM AMADOR COUNTY I
00:26:55.413 --> 00:26:56.281
AM A VICE CHAIR OF THE
00:26:56.348 --> 00:26:57.582
CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY
00:26:57.649 --> 00:26:58.883
RURAL CAUCUS.
00:26:58.950 --> 00:27:01.019
AND A REGIONAL DIRECTOR FOR FOR
00:27:01.086 --> 00:27:03.421
ASSEMBLY DISTRICTS I OPPOSE ANY
00:27:03.488 --> 00:27:04.823
BILL THAT.
00:27:04.889 --> 00:27:05.123
WILL ALLOW.
00:27:05.190 --> 00:27:08.626
FURTHER DOWN THE FOSSIL FUEL
00:27:08.693 --> 00:27:10.261
INDUSTRY DUE TO THE CLIMATE
00:27:10.328 --> 00:27:10.762
CRISIS THING [inaudible]
00:27:10.829 --> 00:27:14.165
THANK YOU.
00:27:14.232 --> 00:27:15.233
I'M JUDY BLACK COME FROM
00:27:15.300 --> 00:27:17.135
SUNNYVALE I AM A CLEAN MONEY
00:27:17.202 --> 00:27:18.770
SUPPORTER AND I AM A LEAGUE OF
00:27:18.837 --> 00:27:20.038
WOMEN VOTERS MEMBER AND I
00:27:20.105 --> 00:27:20.472
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
00:27:20.538 --> 00:27:20.772
[inaudible]
00:27:20.839 --> 00:27:24.275
THANK.
00:27:24.342 --> 00:27:25.577
ESTHER SISTAN FROM DAVIS
00:27:25.643 --> 00:27:27.379
CALIFORNIA I'M A SUPPORTER OF
00:27:27.445 --> 00:27:28.646
THE CLEAN MANY CAMPAIGN AND THAT
00:27:28.713 --> 00:27:30.482
CALIFORNIA DISCLOSE ACT AND I
00:27:30.548 --> 00:27:33.184
STRONGLY OPPOSE THAT AB EIGHTY
00:27:33.251 --> 00:27:34.452
FOUR IN ITS CURRENT FORM THANK
00:27:34.519 --> 00:27:37.822
YOU THANK YOU.
00:27:37.889 --> 00:27:39.257
MY NAME IS RICHARD ROSE ARE FROM
00:27:39.324 --> 00:27:41.192
SAN MATEO CALIFORNIA AND I'M
00:27:41.259 --> 00:27:42.293
STRONGLY AGAINST THIS BILL THANK
00:27:42.360 --> 00:27:45.864
YOU VERY.
00:27:45.930 --> 00:27:47.799
DON CURRY FROM MENLO PARK.
00:27:47.866 --> 00:27:48.333
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL
00:27:48.400 --> 00:27:48.633
[inaudible]
00:27:48.700 --> 00:27:51.169
THANK YOU.
00:27:51.236 --> 00:27:52.170
THEY WERE HELD AROUND POLITICAL
00:27:52.237 --> 00:27:53.338
DIRECTOR FOR WHILE SOME
00:27:53.405 --> 00:27:54.239
PROGRESSIVE DEMOCRATS OF
00:27:54.305 --> 00:27:55.673
SACRAMENTO WERE IN FIRM
00:27:55.740 --> 00:27:55.974
OPPOSITION.
00:27:56.041 --> 00:27:57.976
TAKES.
00:27:58.043 --> 00:27:59.277
I'M MAILING STEPHAN FROM
00:27:59.344 --> 00:28:01.446
SUNNYVALE PEACE BOAT NO THANK
00:28:01.513 --> 00:28:04.682
YOU THANK YOU.
00:28:04.749 --> 00:28:07.252
I'M JIM DAVIDSON FROM LOS ALTOS
00:28:07.318 --> 00:28:07.919
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:28:07.986 --> 00:28:10.922
THANK YOU SIR.
00:28:10.989 --> 00:28:12.857
KATHY FORTIS DAVIS CALIFORNIA
00:28:12.924 --> 00:28:14.692
MONEY OUT DISCLOSURE IN PLEASE
00:28:14.759 --> 00:28:18.463
VOTE DON'T PICK.
00:28:18.530 --> 00:28:20.365
EMMY GREATEST FROM DAVIS TIME
00:28:20.432 --> 00:28:22.634
CHAIR OF YOLO PROGRESSIVES HOW
00:28:22.700 --> 00:28:25.036
DARE ANY DEMOCRAT VOTE FOR THIS
00:28:25.103 --> 00:28:28.640
HEINOUS BILL OPPOSE.
00:28:28.706 --> 00:28:30.508
I'M CHRISTOPHER LIST FROM SANDRA
00:28:30.575 --> 00:28:34.045
FELT PLEASE OPPOSE.
00:28:34.112 --> 00:28:35.513
I'M LORRAINE CAME FROM A RURAL
00:28:35.580 --> 00:28:36.848
EL DORADO COUNTY AND I STRONGLY
00:28:36.915 --> 00:28:37.415
OPPOSE THE BILL [inaudible]
00:28:37.482 --> 00:28:39.551
THANKS.
00:28:39.617 --> 00:28:41.119
MY NAME IS ALEX HOQUIAM FROM
00:28:41.186 --> 00:28:42.287
SACRAMENTO CALIFORNIA I OPPOSE
00:28:42.353 --> 00:28:46.257
THIS BILL --
00:28:46.324 --> 00:28:48.026
AMY HINDSIGHT LEGISLATIVE AND
00:28:48.093 --> 00:28:49.294
POLITICAL DIRECTOR FOR THE
00:28:49.360 --> 00:28:50.395
UNIVERSITY PROFESSIONAL AND
00:28:50.462 --> 00:28:51.329
TECHNICAL EMPLOYEES
00:28:51.396 --> 00:28:52.897
COMMUNICATION WORKERS OF AMERICA
00:28:52.964 --> 00:28:54.666
LOCAL NINE ONE ONE NINE IN
00:28:54.732 --> 00:28:55.433
STRONG OPPOSITION TO THE BILL
00:28:55.500 --> 00:28:58.303
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:28:58.369 --> 00:29:00.038
MICHAEL CARSON MARTINEZ STRONGLY
00:29:00.105 --> 00:29:03.441
OPPOSE A BE A FOR THANK YOU SIR.
00:29:03.508 --> 00:29:05.944
LEN HUYDECOPER MENLO PARK A
00:29:06.010 --> 00:29:07.679
SILICON VALLEY COURAGEOUS
00:29:07.745 --> 00:29:09.714
RESISTANCE AND THE BAYSHORE
00:29:09.781 --> 00:29:11.749
PROGRESSIVE DEMOCRATS A NEW
00:29:11.816 --> 00:29:13.551
BERNIE CRACK CLUB WE WE OPPOSE
00:29:13.618 --> 00:29:13.852
[inaudible]
00:29:13.918 --> 00:29:17.355
THANK YOU.
00:29:17.422 --> 00:29:21.860
STEVE ALLEN REDWOOD CITY OPPOSE.
00:29:21.926 --> 00:29:23.561
JENNIFER HAY FROM SAN FRANCISCO
00:29:23.628 --> 00:29:25.430
US SUPPORTER OF CLEAN MONEY
00:29:25.497 --> 00:29:27.932
PLEASE VOTE NO THANK YOU.
00:29:27.999 --> 00:29:29.601
BUSINESS HAD HER HOME FROM SAN
00:29:29.667 --> 00:29:30.235
FRANCISCO PLEASE VOTE NO.
00:29:30.301 --> 00:29:32.770
THANK YOU.
00:29:32.837 --> 00:29:35.306
ALL CARS FROM MARTINEZ PLEASE
00:29:35.373 --> 00:29:39.777
KILL THIS BILL TODAY.
00:29:39.844 --> 00:29:41.246
SUSAN ARNETT FROM STOCKTON
00:29:41.312 --> 00:29:42.914
CALIFORNIA OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:29:42.981 --> 00:29:46.284
THANK ME.
00:29:46.351 --> 00:29:49.120
MARIA DE GROOT FROM LYNDON
00:29:49.187 --> 00:29:50.755
CALIFORNIA RURAL.
00:29:50.822 --> 00:29:53.291
A COUNTY LIBERAL CITY NEXT TO
00:29:53.358 --> 00:29:54.792
STOCKTON CALIFORNIA.
00:29:54.859 --> 00:29:57.428
OF MEN IMMIGRANT SUPPORT SINGLE
00:29:57.495 --> 00:29:59.464
PAYER HEALTHCARE AND I POST THIS
00:29:59.531 --> 00:30:02.700
BILL VERY STRONG BUT I THINK.
00:30:02.767 --> 00:30:04.402
HI I'M A BIT KENNEDY I DROVE
00:30:04.469 --> 00:30:06.638
HERE FROM MIDDLETOWN CALIFORNIA.
00:30:06.704 --> 00:30:09.607
I'M A DEMOCRATIC PARTY DELEGATE
00:30:09.674 --> 00:30:11.276
FOR ASSEMBLY DISTRICT.
00:30:11.342 --> 00:30:13.478
FOR AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
00:30:13.545 --> 00:30:17.048
BILL THING EACH YEAR.
00:30:17.115 --> 00:30:18.483
CAR LOOKING KID YOSHI CALIFORNIA
00:30:18.550 --> 00:30:20.852
SAN FRANCISCO MY DESCRIPTORS FOR
00:30:20.919 --> 00:30:22.120
THIS BILL ARE.
00:30:22.187 --> 00:30:24.589
A CORRUPTING POWER GRABBING AND
00:30:24.656 --> 00:30:26.124
MISGUIDED PLEASE VOTE NO ON THIS
00:30:26.191 --> 00:30:28.726
BILL THANK.
00:30:28.793 --> 00:30:30.161
MANY IN THE SUMMER STE ONE I'M
00:30:30.228 --> 00:30:31.930
FROM SAN DIEGO CALIFORNIA AND ON
00:30:31.996 --> 00:30:33.865
BEHALF OF MY FAMILY AND MYSELF
00:30:33.932 --> 00:30:34.866
PLEASE VOTE NO THANK YOU FOR
00:30:34.933 --> 00:30:35.133
YOUR TIME.
00:30:35.200 --> 00:30:38.536
OKAY THANK YOU.
00:30:38.603 --> 00:30:39.637
MY NAME'S DAVID SCHMIDT ARE FROM
00:30:39.704 --> 00:30:41.206
SARAH CISCO AND A LONGTIME
00:30:41.272 --> 00:30:42.774
VOLUNTEER WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:30:42.840 --> 00:30:44.175
CLEAN MONEY CAMPAIGN.
00:30:44.242 --> 00:30:45.043
PLEASE VOTE NO ON THE BILL
00:30:45.109 --> 00:30:47.545
THANKS.
00:30:47.612 --> 00:30:48.746
DAVID CARRY FROM BELMONT
00:30:48.813 --> 00:30:50.281
CALIFORNIA PLEASE NOTE WILL ON
00:30:50.348 --> 00:30:52.217
THIS BILL WHICH IS IMPORTANT TO
00:30:52.283 --> 00:30:55.520
A DEMOCRACY THANK YOU THANK YOU.
00:30:55.587 --> 00:30:56.588
GREG SWAYNE FROM OAKLAND
00:30:56.654 --> 00:30:57.422
CALIFORNIA STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
00:30:57.488 --> 00:31:00.992
BILL THANK.
00:31:01.059 --> 00:31:02.527
THOMAS O'BRIEN FROM SACRAMENTO
00:31:02.594 --> 00:31:03.161
CALIFORNIA STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
00:31:03.228 --> 00:31:03.528
BILL [inaudible]
00:31:03.595 --> 00:31:06.464
THANKS.
00:31:06.531 --> 00:31:08.199
JOHN SCHMIDT MODESTO CALIFORNIA
00:31:08.266 --> 00:31:09.033
OPPOSE THIS BILL [inaudible]
00:31:09.100 --> 00:31:12.136
THANKS.
00:31:12.203 --> 00:31:13.871
SHERRI FITZGERALD PLAY HOPE
00:31:13.938 --> 00:31:15.106
CALIFORNIANS OPPOSITION TO THE
00:31:15.173 --> 00:31:15.873
BILL [inaudible]
00:31:15.940 --> 00:31:20.778
THANK YOU.
00:31:20.845 --> 00:31:21.980
WHAT DO WE HAVE ANY OTHERS IN
00:31:22.046 --> 00:31:24.082
OPPOSITION YEAH WE TICKET TIME
00:31:24.148 --> 00:31:25.650
MA'AM THAT'S ALRIGHT
00:31:25.717 --> 00:31:25.950
[inaudible]
00:31:26.017 --> 00:31:31.556
I THINK.
00:31:31.623 --> 00:31:32.590
DISH.
00:31:32.657 --> 00:31:34.926
HAVE [inaudible]
00:31:34.993 --> 00:31:36.494
HI.
00:31:36.561 --> 00:31:38.229
I'M CAROLE PENSON --
00:31:38.296 --> 00:31:39.731
I'M FROM MARTINEZ CALIFORNIA
00:31:39.797 --> 00:31:41.532
MEMBER OF MOVED TO MAN AND I
00:31:41.599 --> 00:31:43.434
STRONGLY OPPOSE A. B..
00:31:43.501 --> 00:31:51.509
EIGHTY FOUR THANK YOU MA'AM.
00:31:51.576 --> 00:31:53.344
NANCY NOW FROM PALO ALTO OF
00:31:53.411 --> 00:31:54.646
VOLUNTEER WITH CLEAN MONEY
00:31:54.712 --> 00:31:56.614
CAMPAIGN SINCE.
00:31:56.681 --> 00:31:57.248
TWO THOUSAND SIX OPPOSE THE BILL
00:31:57.315 --> 00:31:59.284
THANK.
00:31:59.350 --> 00:32:00.685
CRAIG DUNKERLEY SAN JOSE
00:32:00.752 --> 00:32:01.719
CALIFORNIA.
00:32:01.786 --> 00:32:03.354
A LONGTIME VOLUNTEER WITH
00:32:03.421 --> 00:32:05.223
CALIFORNIA CLEAN MANY CAMPAIGN
00:32:05.290 --> 00:32:05.823
ALSO SERVE ON THE SANTA CLARA
00:32:05.890 --> 00:32:06.991
COUNTY.
00:32:07.058 --> 00:32:08.493
CITIZENS ADVISORY COMMISSION ON
00:32:08.559 --> 00:32:09.927
ELECTIONS HOW STRONGLY OPPOSE
00:32:09.994 --> 00:32:11.362
THE BILL WE CAN DO BETTER.
00:32:11.429 --> 00:32:12.597
THANK YOU CREDIT THANK YOU FOR
00:32:12.664 --> 00:32:14.666
AN ORDERLY PROCESS EVERYONE --
00:32:14.732 --> 00:32:15.900
FOR WEIGHING IN IN MAKING THE
00:32:15.967 --> 00:32:18.670
TRIP WE DO APPRECIATE THE INPUT --
00:32:18.736 --> 00:32:21.072
I WILL BRING IT BACK NOW TO THE
00:32:21.139 --> 00:32:21.773
DYESS.
00:32:21.839 --> 00:32:24.542
AND THOSE YOU WERE HERE AT THE
00:32:24.609 --> 00:32:26.778
OUTSET WE HAD COMMON CAUSE ONLY
00:32:26.844 --> 00:32:28.279
WOMEN VOTERS ALSO IF YOU IF YOU
00:32:28.346 --> 00:32:30.348
HAVE QUESTIONS. FOR THEM BUT
00:32:30.415 --> 00:32:36.020
MEMBERS QUESTIONS COMMENTS
00:32:36.087 --> 00:32:36.321
[inaudible]
00:32:36.387 --> 00:32:37.488
GOOD.
00:32:37.555 --> 00:32:43.094
I CENTER HERTZBERG.
00:32:43.161 --> 00:32:44.629
WE TAKEN NOTES LISTENING TO ALL
00:32:44.696 --> 00:32:46.297
OF THE ARGUMENTS I JUST WANT TO
00:32:46.364 --> 00:32:49.233
PURPOSES BY THE FACT THAT.
00:32:49.300 --> 00:32:52.303
JOINT AUTHORED PROPOSITION.
00:32:52.370 --> 00:32:54.605
THIRTY FOUR CREATED THIS PROCESS.
00:32:54.672 --> 00:32:56.207
AND JUST GIVE LITTLE CONTEXT IF
00:32:56.274 --> 00:32:57.875
IT'S APPROPRIATE ON BOTH
00:32:57.942 --> 00:33:00.411
PERSONALLY AND BOMB [inaudible]
00:33:00.478 --> 00:33:01.612
STATUTORILY CONSTITUTIONALLY IN
00:33:01.679 --> 00:33:03.948
CALIFORNIA --
00:33:04.015 --> 00:33:06.217
THERE WAS THIS THERE WAS IN
00:33:06.284 --> 00:33:06.851
NINETEEN NINETY SIX PROPOSITION
00:33:06.918 --> 00:33:08.353
UP TO EIGHT THAT LIMITED
00:33:08.419 --> 00:33:09.921
CONTRIBUTIONS THAT WAS A SUPREME
00:33:09.987 --> 00:33:11.456
COURT CASE IN DECEMBER OF THAT
00:33:11.522 --> 00:33:12.357
YEAR.
00:33:12.423 --> 00:33:13.324
THEIR WAS A SERIES OF
00:33:13.391 --> 00:33:15.226
INITIATIVES BACK AND FORTH AND
00:33:15.293 --> 00:33:16.828
AND ULTIMATELY.
00:33:16.894 --> 00:33:18.996
PROPERTY FOR IT WAS INFORMED BY
00:33:19.063 --> 00:33:20.698
THE SHRINK MISSOURI CASE.
00:33:20.765 --> 00:33:22.767
WHERE ARE THE ISSUE WASN'T SO
00:33:22.834 --> 00:33:24.369
MUCH ABOUT DISCLOSURE BUT THE
00:33:24.435 --> 00:33:26.871
ISSUE IS ABOUT CONTRIBUTIONS --
00:33:26.938 --> 00:33:28.172
AT IT WHATEVER THE LEVELS WITH
00:33:28.239 --> 00:33:29.507
THE CONTRIBUTIONS SENATOR BURTON
00:33:29.574 --> 00:33:30.675
I JOINT AUTHORED THIS
00:33:30.742 --> 00:33:31.943
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT VOTERS
00:33:32.009 --> 00:33:32.744
APPROVED [inaudible]
00:33:32.810 --> 00:33:35.446
ON TO SET A LIMIT THAT WAS
00:33:35.513 --> 00:33:39.150
CONSISTENT WITH THE COST OF
00:33:39.217 --> 00:33:40.785
LIVING IN CALIFORNIA MARRYING
00:33:40.852 --> 00:33:43.388
AGAINST SHRINK MISSOURI CASE.
00:33:43.454 --> 00:33:44.889
AND I JUST WANTED JUST BEFORE
00:33:44.956 --> 00:33:46.424
ASSN QUESTIONS CRITICAL NOTES
00:33:46.491 --> 00:33:47.759
ABOUT SOME OF THE CONCLUSIONS
00:33:47.825 --> 00:33:49.527
THAT PEOPLE GAVE WITH RESPECT TO
00:33:49.594 --> 00:33:50.895
THIS MATTER.
00:33:50.962 --> 00:33:53.097
YOU KNOW I I JUST ANT YOU KNOW
00:33:53.164 --> 00:33:53.631
TO THOSE WHO WERE IN THE
00:33:53.698 --> 00:33:55.166
AUDIENCE BY CAMEL WHAT YEAR IT
00:33:55.233 --> 00:33:56.634
WAS.
00:33:56.701 --> 00:33:58.002
PROP SIXTY EIGHT I DON'T KNOW
00:33:58.069 --> 00:33:59.504
WHAT YEAR THAT WAS IN THE COMMON
00:33:59.570 --> 00:34:01.839
CAUSE LISA FOSTER --
00:34:01.906 --> 00:34:02.707
YOU KNOW PARTIAL PUBLIC
00:34:02.774 --> 00:34:05.276
FINANCING WITH COMMON CAUSE PROP --
00:34:05.343 --> 00:34:07.111
AT ONE THIRTY ONE WHERE THE
00:34:07.178 --> 00:34:08.279
AUTHOR WITH THE AUTHOR OF THE
00:34:08.346 --> 00:34:09.814
FAIR PICKLE PRICES COMMISSION
00:34:09.881 --> 00:34:10.681
WAS OUR TREASURE.
00:34:10.748 --> 00:34:12.383
BOB STERN.
00:34:12.450 --> 00:34:14.585
PHONE THE HE SIX EXTRAORDINARY
00:34:14.652 --> 00:34:16.587
EFFORTS TO TRY TO DEAL WITH THIS
00:34:16.654 --> 00:34:19.524
ISSUE OF TRANSPARENCY.
00:34:19.590 --> 00:34:20.858
AND TO ME WHEN I ANALYZE THIS
00:34:20.925 --> 00:34:22.927
AND I LISTEN I THINK. FIVE OR
00:34:22.994 --> 00:34:23.895
SIX PAGES OF NOTES OF WHAT
00:34:23.961 --> 00:34:25.630
PEOPLE TESTIFIED TO TRY TO FIND
00:34:25.696 --> 00:34:27.498
COMMON THEMES.
00:34:27.565 --> 00:34:28.966
SOMEONE WHO'S BEEN IN AT THE
00:34:29.033 --> 00:34:30.168
OTHER END OF THIS STUFF OF MY
00:34:30.234 --> 00:34:31.903
OWN PARTY AND REDISTRICTING LIE
00:34:31.969 --> 00:34:33.538
SIDE WITH COMMON CAUSE MY PARTY
00:34:33.604 --> 00:34:34.839
WAS MAD AT ME AND STUFF.
00:34:34.906 --> 00:34:35.873
BECAUSE I THOUGHT IT WAS THE
00:34:35.940 --> 00:34:37.341
RIGHT THING TO DO.
00:34:37.408 --> 00:34:38.776
I LOOK AT THIS ISSUE AND I WANT
00:34:38.843 --> 00:34:40.111
TO FIRST EXAMINE THE NOTION OF
00:34:40.178 --> 00:34:41.946
TRANSPARENCY.
00:34:42.013 --> 00:34:43.514
BECAUSE AS SOME OF YOU MAY KNOW
00:34:43.581 --> 00:34:45.049
I SERVED LEADERSHIP POSITION A
00:34:45.116 --> 00:34:46.651
COUPLE OF DECADES AGO.
00:34:46.717 --> 00:34:47.251
AND I KNOW WHAT THE OLD RULES
00:34:47.318 --> 00:34:48.886
LOOK LIKE.
00:34:48.953 --> 00:34:50.421
AND I ALSO KNOW HOW THE PROCESS
00:34:50.488 --> 00:34:52.890
WORKS IN TERMS OF HOW MONEY
00:34:52.957 --> 00:34:54.492
WORKS IN THE SYSTEM AND WHETHER
00:34:54.559 --> 00:34:56.294
GO TO THE PARTY AND SO I MY
00:34:56.360 --> 00:34:57.728
SENSE OF THIS ISSUE AS I
00:34:57.795 --> 00:34:59.263
DIAGNOSIS.
00:34:59.330 --> 00:35:00.531
USERS TO SEPARATE [inaudible]
00:35:00.598 --> 00:35:03.701
WE ISSUES NOW ONE ISSUE IS IS TO
00:35:03.768 --> 00:35:05.636
MAKE SURE THAT.
00:35:05.703 --> 00:35:07.972
BOTTOM ANY CONTRIBUTION THAT IS
00:35:08.039 --> 00:35:09.841
GIVEN AT ALL.
00:35:09.907 --> 00:35:11.809
IT IS LIMITED I'M ITS EXPERT IS
00:35:11.876 --> 00:35:13.411
IS TRANSPARENT.
00:35:13.478 --> 00:35:15.046
IS TRANSPARENT AND IS
00:35:15.112 --> 00:35:16.380
TRANSPARENT AND THAT EVERYBODY
00:35:16.447 --> 00:35:18.015
UNDERSTANDS WITH US BECAUSE
00:35:18.082 --> 00:35:19.750
WHO'S MAKING THE CONTRA. FOR
00:35:19.817 --> 00:35:21.886
WHAT PURPOSE YOU MORE IS AGO.
00:35:21.953 --> 00:35:24.088
AND CERTAINLY IN MY JUDGMENT I
00:35:24.155 --> 00:35:25.223
KNOW I'VE HAD SOME DISCUSSIONS
00:35:25.289 --> 00:35:26.624
WITH SOME OF THE ADVOCATES WHO
00:35:26.691 --> 00:35:27.925
HAVE BEEN TALKING TO AND WORK
00:35:27.992 --> 00:35:29.460
WITH FOR MANY MANY YEARS.
00:35:29.527 --> 00:35:31.028
I I'D BUT I KNOW PEOPLE USE THE
00:35:31.095 --> 00:35:32.029
TERM DARK MONEY AND CORRUPTION
00:35:32.096 --> 00:35:33.831
AND THE LIKE.
00:35:33.898 --> 00:35:35.833
THE CORRUPTION CONCEPT TO ME
00:35:35.900 --> 00:35:37.702
COMES INTO DOT TO FIT INTO SOME
00:35:37.768 --> 00:35:40.371
PARTS ONE IS OBVIOUSLY.
00:35:40.438 --> 00:35:41.405
BAR HOW MUCH MONEY PEOPLE CAN
00:35:41.472 --> 00:35:43.407
GIVE IS A LIMITATION ON WHAT HOW
00:35:43.474 --> 00:35:44.509
MUCH MONEY CAN GIVE SO THAT SOME
00:35:44.575 --> 00:35:46.277
WAS ON BUDDIES BIG CHECKS WE
00:35:46.344 --> 00:35:47.378
COULD DRIVE A TRUCK THROUGH NOW
00:35:47.445 --> 00:35:48.079
WITH THESE INDEPENDENT
00:35:48.145 --> 00:35:49.313
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEE WHICH IS
00:35:49.380 --> 00:35:50.748
NOW INFORMED OUR POLITICAL
00:35:50.815 --> 00:35:52.183
PROCESS SINCE.
00:35:52.250 --> 00:35:53.985
WITH THE CASE.
00:35:54.051 --> 00:35:55.386
TING COURT CASE CITIZENS UNITED
00:35:55.453 --> 00:35:57.555
HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE.
00:35:57.622 --> 00:35:58.656
AND THEN THE OTHER QUESTION IS
00:35:58.723 --> 00:36:00.591
MAKING SURE WE KNOW IMMEDIATELY
00:36:00.658 --> 00:36:03.094
WHO GAVE THE MONEY.
00:36:03.160 --> 00:36:04.795
AND AND WHAT THEY GAVE IT.
00:36:04.862 --> 00:36:06.497
TO POLITICIANS GETTING MONEY IS
00:36:06.564 --> 00:36:08.199
ALWAYS A PROBLEM ANYTIME ANYBODY
00:36:08.266 --> 00:36:09.433
WRITES A CHECK SOMEBODY FROM THE
00:36:09.500 --> 00:36:12.003
ANY SOURCE IT'S ALWAYS QUESTION.
00:36:12.069 --> 00:36:13.604
AS TO WHAT THE MOTIVATION IS AND
00:36:13.671 --> 00:36:14.972
I THINK KIND OF THE LARGER
00:36:15.039 --> 00:36:16.474
DYNAMIC OF WHAT THE THE
00:36:16.541 --> 00:36:18.209
LITERATURE HAS AND WHAT THE BEST
00:36:18.276 --> 00:36:20.011
THINKERS HAVE IS.
00:36:20.077 --> 00:36:21.512
DISCLOSURE DISCLOSURE DISCLOSURE
00:36:21.579 --> 00:36:23.915
AND I DO BELIEVE THAT --
00:36:23.981 --> 00:36:25.650
CREATING THESE COMMITTEES YOU'VE
00:36:25.716 --> 00:36:26.951
GOT DISCLOSURE DISCLOSURE
00:36:27.018 --> 00:36:28.653
DISCLOSURE --
00:36:28.719 --> 00:36:30.688
IN TERMS OF WHAT THE ISSUE IS.
00:36:30.755 --> 00:36:32.857
PA AND I DO THINK IT DOES CREATE
00:36:32.924 --> 00:36:35.259
A LARGER DYNAMIC THAT CAME FROM
00:36:35.326 --> 00:36:36.694
PROP.
00:36:36.761 --> 00:36:37.662
THIRTY FOUR ABOUT PARTIES AND
00:36:37.728 --> 00:36:39.230
WHAT THAT MEANS.
00:36:39.297 --> 00:36:40.331
BUT IT MAKES MY HEART SING THAT
00:36:40.398 --> 00:36:41.632
A RELEASE COMING TOGETHER IN THE
00:36:41.699 --> 00:36:43.334
PARTY BECAUSE I DIDN'T LIKE THIS
00:36:43.401 --> 00:36:44.635
UNITY EIGHT WHAT WE WHAT AHEAD
00:36:44.702 --> 00:36:46.003
TOGETHER AT LEAST THIS TO MY
00:36:46.070 --> 00:36:47.605
LIMITED INTEREST IN POLITICS
00:36:47.672 --> 00:36:49.473
THAT'S HOWEVER MAKE A COUPLE
00:36:49.540 --> 00:36:51.742
COMMENTS I'M GLAD ABOUT THAT.
00:36:51.809 --> 00:36:53.277
BUT THE THE PUBLIC SOME
00:36:53.344 --> 00:36:54.445
QUESTIONS THAT I HAD IN THE
00:36:54.512 --> 00:36:57.648
PARTY AND YOU KNOW THE THE ISSUE
00:36:57.715 --> 00:36:59.350
OF DETRACTING FROM LONG TERM
00:36:59.417 --> 00:37:00.718
ELECTED OFFICIALS AND WHAT WE'RE
00:37:00.785 --> 00:37:02.453
TRYING TO DO.
00:37:02.520 --> 00:37:03.688
JUST WANTED TO ASK YOU PARTY%
00:37:03.754 --> 00:37:04.889
VICE CHAIR ABOUT THAT ISSUE
00:37:04.956 --> 00:37:07.959
BECAUSE SINCE WE PASS THIS AND
00:37:08.025 --> 00:37:09.560
YOU MARRY THIS WE NOW HAVE THE
00:37:09.627 --> 00:37:10.695
OPEN PRIMARY THE SCHWARZENEGGER
00:37:10.761 --> 00:37:13.197
PUT ON THE IN THE SYSTEM.
00:37:13.264 --> 00:37:14.632
AND THAT SH HOPING PRIMARY WE
00:37:14.699 --> 00:37:15.833
SAW IN THE GOVERNOR'S RACE HAD
00:37:15.900 --> 00:37:17.201
IMPACT LOOKING DIFFERENTLY WE
00:37:17.268 --> 00:37:18.936
SEE OTHER RACES.
00:37:19.003 --> 00:37:21.272
MY THOUGHT IS THAT TRYING TO GET
00:37:21.339 --> 00:37:23.274
A ELECTED OFFICIALS THAT ARE
00:37:23.341 --> 00:37:24.241
CONSISTENT WITH THE VALUES OF
00:37:24.308 --> 00:37:25.109
THE MAJORITY OF THE DEMOCRATIC
00:37:25.176 --> 00:37:27.979
PARTY. TO BE THOUGHT THROUGH
00:37:28.045 --> 00:37:30.615
THIS IMPACT BECAUSE WE FELT IT
00:37:30.681 --> 00:37:32.717
RIGHT WE FELT IT IN TERMS OF
00:37:32.783 --> 00:37:34.118
WHAT WE COULD OR COULDN'T DO.
00:37:34.185 --> 00:37:36.821
AND TRYING TO SUPPORT PEOPLE WHO
00:37:36.887 --> 00:37:38.255
WE CARE ABOUT AND LOVE TO HEAR A
00:37:38.322 --> 00:37:39.256
GOOD COUPLE OF THE QUESTIONS FOR
00:37:39.323 --> 00:37:40.691
YOU BUT LIKE TO YOUR COMMENTS.
00:37:40.758 --> 00:37:41.892
WITH RESPECT TO THE NOTION OF
00:37:41.959 --> 00:37:43.995
THE OPEN PRIMARY COULD YOU
00:37:44.061 --> 00:37:44.562
CERTAINLY SAW OUR DEMOCRATIC
00:37:44.629 --> 00:37:44.996
NOMINEE [inaudible]
00:37:45.062 --> 00:37:47.898
A WORK IN THE IN THAT AREA AND
00:37:47.965 --> 00:37:50.201
AND AND AND HOW THAT WORKS AND
00:37:50.267 --> 00:37:50.835
WHAT SUITS YOUR THOUGHTS WERE IN
00:37:50.901 --> 00:37:52.203
THAT REGARD.
00:37:52.269 --> 00:37:53.104
YEAH THANK YOU SENATOR HERTZBERG
00:37:53.170 --> 00:37:56.207
AND YES OBVIOUSLY TOP TWO HAS
00:37:56.273 --> 00:37:56.440
BEEN --
00:37:56.507 --> 00:37:59.043
QUITE A THE BOOMERANG FOR US TO
00:37:59.110 --> 00:38:01.879
TRY TO FIGURE OUT YOU KNOW HOW.
00:38:01.946 --> 00:38:03.214
TO STAY A COHERENT PARTY A SAY
00:38:03.280 --> 00:38:04.281
THE GUESTBOOK PARTY DID THE
00:38:04.348 --> 00:38:05.816
REPUBLICANS HAVEA PARTY WOULD
00:38:05.883 --> 00:38:07.485
TO DEMOCRATS CAME IN TOP WHAT
00:38:07.551 --> 00:38:08.019
WOULD HAVE NORMALLY BEEN
00:38:08.085 --> 00:38:09.320
REPUBLICAN INDUSTRY SOME BACK
00:38:09.387 --> 00:38:10.588
AND FORTH ALL OVER YEAH AND MY
00:38:10.655 --> 00:38:11.656
UNDERSTANDING IS AND I MEAN IN
00:38:11.722 --> 00:38:12.657
TERMS OF WHERE THE PARTIES ARE
00:38:12.723 --> 00:38:14.525
AT AND I DON'T.
00:38:14.592 --> 00:38:15.126
I I WILL CONFESS THAT I DON'T
00:38:15.192 --> 00:38:17.995
SPEND I'M IN THE REPUBLICAN
00:38:18.062 --> 00:38:19.130
PARTY BUT MY UNDERSTANDING IS
00:38:19.196 --> 00:38:19.697
THAT IT THAT THAT THEY DON'T
00:38:19.764 --> 00:38:21.198
LIKE IT EITHER --
00:38:21.265 --> 00:38:22.700
AND ARE HAPPY WITH THE CURRENT
00:38:22.767 --> 00:38:24.235
SYSTEM BUT THE VOTERS APPROVED
00:38:24.301 --> 00:38:25.636
TOP TWO AYE IT'S THE CITIZENS
00:38:25.703 --> 00:38:27.838
SITUATION WE HAVE AND SO WE HAVE
00:38:27.905 --> 00:38:28.472
TO LEARN HOW TO OPERATE WITHIN
00:38:28.539 --> 00:38:29.140
IT.
00:38:29.206 --> 00:38:31.242
AND SO WE HAVE BEEN BEEN VERY
00:38:31.308 --> 00:38:32.943
VERY CLOSE BY YOU KNOW
00:38:33.010 --> 00:38:35.012
NEGOTIATION AND DISCUSSION WITH
00:38:35.079 --> 00:38:36.447
OUR ALLIES AND THE DEMOCRAT
00:38:36.514 --> 00:38:38.649
SENATE DEMOCRATS --
00:38:38.716 --> 00:38:39.984
TO THE ASSEMBLY DEMOCRATS AND
00:38:40.051 --> 00:38:40.985
ALSO WITH WITH --
00:38:41.052 --> 00:38:42.953
OUR FOLKS AT THE NATIONAL LEVEL
00:38:43.020 --> 00:38:44.088
WORKING ON COMMERCIAL CAMPAIGNS.
00:38:44.155 --> 00:38:47.458
THAT WE HAVE TO MAINTAIN OUR
00:38:47.525 --> 00:38:51.128
PARTY DEMOCRACY EVEN IN A TOP TO
00:38:51.195 --> 00:38:52.396
A SITUATION THAT WOULD HAPPEN
00:38:52.463 --> 00:38:53.998
WHAT I MEAN IS THAT WE HAVE TO
00:38:54.065 --> 00:38:54.598
HAVE.
00:38:54.665 --> 00:38:56.867
A PARTICIPATORY PROCESS FOR
00:38:56.934 --> 00:38:58.836
DECIDING WHO THE DEMORATIC
00:38:58.903 --> 00:38:59.970
ENDORSED CANDIDATE US.
00:39:00.037 --> 00:39:02.807
THAT WE WE CAN'T HAVE THAT TOP
00:39:02.873 --> 00:39:03.941
TWO CAN'T BE AN EXCUSE FOR US TO
00:39:04.008 --> 00:39:05.676
JUST THROW UP OUR HANDS AND
00:39:05.743 --> 00:39:07.378
MOVED TO THE D. TRIPLE C. MODEL
00:39:07.445 --> 00:39:08.379
OF JUST SAYING THAT YOU KNOW
00:39:08.446 --> 00:39:09.880
VOTE FOR WHOEVER RAISES THE MOST
00:39:09.947 --> 00:39:10.448
MONEY.
00:39:10.514 --> 00:39:12.383
VIC THE CAUCUS PROFESSIONALS
00:39:12.450 --> 00:39:13.050
WILL DECIDE THAT THAT'S WHO THE
00:39:13.117 --> 00:39:14.618
CANDIDATE IS IN THE BACK TO THE
00:39:14.685 --> 00:39:15.352
CANDIDATE WILL BE.
00:39:15.419 --> 00:39:17.955
THAT WE HAVE TO MAINTAIN --
00:39:18.022 --> 00:39:19.724
I ENGAGEMENT WITH OUR GRASSROOTS
00:39:19.790 --> 00:39:21.592
ACTIVISTS TO GIVE THEM A SAY
00:39:21.659 --> 00:39:23.561
EVEN A TOP TWO SITUATION OF WHO
00:39:23.627 --> 00:39:24.962
THEY THINK THE BEST CANADA'S
00:39:25.029 --> 00:39:27.364
WEIGHING VIABILITY AND PRINCIPLE
00:39:27.431 --> 00:39:29.700
AND AND BACKGROUND ET CETERA --
00:39:29.767 --> 00:39:31.635
FOUR CAMPAIGN WE ALSO AS I
00:39:31.702 --> 00:39:33.304
ALLUDED TO IN MY IN MY COMMENTS
00:39:33.370 --> 00:39:35.039
WE ALSO MOVED IN ENGAGED IN A
00:39:35.106 --> 00:39:36.841
MAJOR INTERNAL REFORM --
00:39:36.907 --> 00:39:39.543
IN CLOSE COOPERATION WITH SENATE
00:39:39.610 --> 00:39:41.045
DEMOCRATS ASSEMBLY DEMOCRATS IT
00:39:41.112 --> 00:39:43.280
CHANGED OUR ENDORSEMENT PROCESS
00:39:43.347 --> 00:39:44.749
THAT GAVE THE LEADERSHIP LEADERS
00:39:44.815 --> 00:39:46.083
ARE PARTY LEADERS IN THE
00:39:46.150 --> 00:39:47.384
LEGISLATURE --
00:39:47.451 --> 00:39:49.620
EXTRA DELEGATES IN ORDER TO WAY
00:39:49.687 --> 00:39:53.124
N. EXACTLY IN THOSE RACES WHERE
00:39:53.190 --> 00:39:55.126
MAYBE THE GRASSROOTS ARE SPLIT
00:39:55.192 --> 00:39:56.427
BUT WE REALLY WANT TO MAKE SURE
00:39:56.494 --> 00:39:57.995
WE GOING TO TALK TO WITH IT LIKE
00:39:58.062 --> 00:39:59.363
BEHIND A SINGLE CANDIDATE.
00:39:59.430 --> 00:40:00.798
SO WE'RE NOT SPLITTING THE VOTE
00:40:00.865 --> 00:40:02.566
AND HANDING ELECTIONS TO OUR
00:40:02.633 --> 00:40:04.668
OPPONENTS ON JUST WITH AN OWN
00:40:04.735 --> 00:40:07.138
GOAL RIGHT SO I'M SO WE GAVE
00:40:07.204 --> 00:40:08.506
THOSE DELEGATES TO THE
00:40:08.572 --> 00:40:09.473
LEADERSHIP PRECISELY SO THAT
00:40:09.540 --> 00:40:10.040
THEY COULD.
00:40:10.107 --> 00:40:12.643
WEIGH AND SAY LOOK THIS IS A
00:40:12.710 --> 00:40:15.412
TARGETED RACE. TO GET BEHIND
00:40:15.479 --> 00:40:18.849
THIS CANDIDATE UP BECAUSE WE ARE
00:40:18.916 --> 00:40:21.152
A A OF PARTNERSHIP.
00:40:21.218 --> 00:40:22.419
THAT AND OUR CORE AS AN
00:40:22.486 --> 00:40:23.721
ORGANIZATION WHERE PARTNERSHIP
00:40:23.788 --> 00:40:24.421
BETWEEN --
00:40:24.488 --> 00:40:25.790
DEMOCRATS IN OFFICE AND
00:40:25.856 --> 00:40:26.991
DEMOCRATS OUT IN THE COMMUNITY
00:40:27.057 --> 00:40:28.626
IN THE STREETS IS THE DEMOCRATIC
00:40:28.692 --> 00:40:30.327
PARTY AND THINK ABOUT THIS TO
00:40:30.394 --> 00:40:31.862
JUST ANSWER THE QUESTION.
00:40:31.929 --> 00:40:33.230
IS THE DEMOCRATIC ELECTED
00:40:33.297 --> 00:40:35.633
OFFICIAL SOMEONE WHO GETS
00:40:35.699 --> 00:40:37.601
ELECTED AS A DEMOCRAT
00:40:37.668 --> 00:40:39.537
DESIGNATING TO THE PUBLIC.
00:40:39.603 --> 00:40:40.805
DE TELLING THE PUBLIC THAT I'M A
00:40:40.871 --> 00:40:42.940
DEMOCRAT. FOR IS THE DEMOCRAT
00:40:43.007 --> 00:40:45.142
OFFICIAL THE PERSON WHO SUPPORT
00:40:45.209 --> 00:40:47.912
WHO WHO'S INDOORS FOR THE PARTY.
00:40:47.978 --> 00:40:48.879
RIGHT WHEN YOU REPEAT THE
00:40:48.946 --> 00:40:49.480
QUESTION WILL BE COULD THINK
00:40:49.547 --> 00:40:51.448
ABOUT THIS I KNOW IN IN IN IT
00:40:51.515 --> 00:40:52.716
FOR EXAMPLE BETWEEN BOTH HOUSES
00:40:52.783 --> 00:40:54.018
IN BOTH PARTIES HERE OF
00:40:54.084 --> 00:40:55.820
LEGISLATORS THAT HAVE SERVED.
00:40:55.886 --> 00:40:57.421
IN BOTH THE DISEASE AND THE OURS
00:40:57.488 --> 00:41:00.124
IS NO INDEPENDENCE NOW THAT
00:41:00.191 --> 00:41:00.658
WE'RE NOT ENDORSED BY THE
00:41:00.724 --> 00:41:01.859
RESPECTIVE PARTIES.
00:41:01.926 --> 00:41:03.761
BUT THEY GOT ENDORSED BUT THEY
00:41:03.828 --> 00:41:05.296
GOT ENDORSED BY WINNING.
00:41:05.362 --> 00:41:07.965
AS REPRESENTING TO THE PUBLIC.
00:41:08.032 --> 00:41:10.000
WHO REGISTERED AS A MEMBER OF
00:41:10.067 --> 00:41:11.302
THE PARTY COMMUTERS ACTIVISTS TO
00:41:11.368 --> 00:41:12.770
A PARTY WHO SAY I'M GONNA TAKE
00:41:12.837 --> 00:41:14.772
THE TIME TO WALK PRECINCTS AND
00:41:14.839 --> 00:41:15.906
DO THE HOMEWORK?
00:41:15.973 --> 00:41:17.608
AND TRY TO GET PEOPLE ELECTED.
00:41:17.675 --> 00:41:18.776
THERE'S OTHER PEOPLE WHO FOR
00:41:18.843 --> 00:41:20.644
WHATEVER REASON IDENTIFYWITH
00:41:20.711 --> 00:41:21.679
DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS IN
00:41:21.745 --> 00:41:23.347
THEIR CORE VALUES.
00:41:23.414 --> 00:41:25.282
THEY SIGN UP AND SAY I'M A
00:41:25.349 --> 00:41:26.851
MEMBER OF THE RESPECTIVE PARTY.
00:41:26.917 --> 00:41:28.052
THEY DON'T PARTICIPATE THEY'RE
00:41:28.118 --> 00:41:29.753
NOT ACTIVISTS THEY DON'T GO TO
00:41:29.820 --> 00:41:31.255
THE CONVENTION BUT THEY VOTE.
00:41:31.322 --> 00:41:33.657
SO WE HAVE A SITUATION HERE THIS
00:41:33.724 --> 00:41:35.259
IS KIND OF ONE OF THAT GUY GETS
00:41:35.326 --> 00:41:36.293
THE NUB OF WHAT THE ISSUE IS
00:41:36.360 --> 00:41:36.994
HERE.
00:41:37.061 --> 00:41:38.262
WHEN WE HAVE MEMBERS OF BOTH
00:41:38.329 --> 00:41:40.397
PARTIES WHO WERE OPPOSED BY
00:41:40.464 --> 00:41:42.132
THEIR OWN PARTY?
00:41:42.199 --> 00:41:42.700
BECAUSE THERE WERE CERTAIN
00:41:42.766 --> 00:41:44.068
FACTIONS WITHIN THE RESPECTIVE
00:41:44.134 --> 00:41:45.736
PARTIES THAT THAT THEY WON'T
00:41:45.803 --> 00:41:46.670
SUPPORT IT.
00:41:46.737 --> 00:41:47.805
BUT WHEN THEY PRESENTED
00:41:47.872 --> 00:41:49.540
THEMSELVES TO THE VOTERS.
00:41:49.607 --> 00:41:50.507
THE VOTERS OF THAT PARTY ELECTED
00:41:50.574 --> 00:41:52.042
THEM.
00:41:52.109 --> 00:41:53.878
YOU CAN LOOK AT SOMEBODY DEVOTE
00:41:53.944 --> 00:41:55.279
ELECTED THEM REGULARLY.
00:41:55.346 --> 00:41:56.680
ONE EXCEPT IT ME AGAIN AS YOU
00:41:56.747 --> 00:41:58.048
MENTIONED WITH TOP TWO THAT
00:41:58.115 --> 00:41:59.216
CHANGES IT.
00:41:59.283 --> 00:42:00.384
NO T WAS ONE THING WHEN WE HAD
00:42:00.451 --> 00:42:01.819
A PARTY PRIMARY AND WE COULD SAY
00:42:01.886 --> 00:42:02.786
LOOK WE'LL FIGHT IT OUT THERE IS
00:42:02.853 --> 00:42:04.688
THE PRIMARY ONE DEMOCRAT EMERGES
00:42:04.755 --> 00:42:05.756
TO THE GENERAL AND THEN WE UNITE
00:42:05.823 --> 00:42:07.324
BEHIND THAT PERSON.
00:42:07.391 --> 00:42:09.293
WITH TOP TWO YOU CAN AS A BEACON
00:42:09.360 --> 00:42:11.262
RUN AS A DEMOCRAT IN THE FIRST
00:42:11.328 --> 00:42:13.430
ROUND BUT TOTALLY APPEAL TO
00:42:13.497 --> 00:42:14.498
REPUBLICAN I GOT THAT BUT FOR US
00:42:14.565 --> 00:42:15.900
IT I THINK IT UP IT DOESN'T THE
00:42:15.966 --> 00:42:16.600
PERSON.
00:42:16.667 --> 00:42:17.468
WHO CHOOSES TO REGISTER AS A
00:42:17.534 --> 00:42:21.405
PARTY PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY VOTE
00:42:21.472 --> 00:42:22.806
HAVE A VOICE GOT UP SO EARLY?
00:42:22.873 --> 00:42:25.075
OKAY SO IF THEY HAVE A VOICE I
00:42:25.142 --> 00:42:26.510
AGAIN ON MONTH BY MONTH AND JUST
00:42:26.577 --> 00:42:27.511
THINKING ABOUT IT THIS IS A
00:42:27.578 --> 00:42:29.213
LEGISLATIVE PROCESS IS GIVEN
00:42:29.280 --> 00:42:30.581
TAKE THAT WE ASK OURSELVES.
00:42:30.648 --> 00:42:32.483
THE TOUGH QUESTIONS IF THEY HAVE
00:42:32.549 --> 00:42:33.684
A VOICE I KNOW OF A COUPLE OF
00:42:33.751 --> 00:42:35.119
MEMBERS WHO HAD MORE INDOORS
00:42:35.185 --> 00:42:36.120
BECAUSE THEY GOT THE BEEF WITH
00:42:36.186 --> 00:42:37.721
CERTAIN ELEMENT OF ONE PARTY AND
00:42:37.788 --> 00:42:38.355
CERTAINLY ONE OF THE WHAT THE
00:42:38.422 --> 00:42:39.123
OTHER PARTY.
00:42:39.189 --> 00:42:41.425
BUT THEY REALLY DID WRONG ON
00:42:41.492 --> 00:42:43.093
CORE VALUES OF THAT PARTICULAR
00:42:43.160 --> 00:42:44.862
PARTY AND THE VOTERS IN THE
00:42:44.929 --> 00:42:46.563
DISTRICT CHOSE THEM TO REPRESENT
00:42:46.630 --> 00:42:48.599
THEM FOR THOSE COMMUNITIES.
00:42:48.666 --> 00:42:49.867
AND SO WHAT I'M TRYING TO GET TO
00:42:49.934 --> 00:42:52.069
IS DOESN'T THAT MEAN ANYTHING
00:42:52.136 --> 00:42:53.837
BECAUSE WHAT HAPPENS HERE THE
00:42:53.904 --> 00:42:55.339
REAL PRACTICAL REALITY THAT I'VE
00:42:55.406 --> 00:42:56.907
EXPERIENCED OVER DECADES.
00:42:56.974 --> 00:42:58.375
IS THAT A SOMEBODY WILL GET
00:42:58.442 --> 00:42:59.109
ELECTED.
00:42:59.176 --> 00:43:00.678
ARE ON NOT ENDORSED BY THEIR
00:43:00.744 --> 00:43:02.012
PARTY.
00:43:02.079 --> 00:43:05.049
IN BODY ON A VOTE CARD THE CORE
00:43:05.115 --> 00:43:05.883
VALUES OF RESPECTIVE PARTIES
00:43:05.950 --> 00:43:07.685
ABOUT ONE OUT SOMEPLACE ELSE
00:43:07.751 --> 00:43:09.253
THEY REPRESENT EITHER PARTY
00:43:09.320 --> 00:43:10.654
THEIR SAME CORE VALUES.
00:43:10.721 --> 00:43:11.722
BUT FOR WHATEVER REASON THEY
00:43:11.789 --> 00:43:13.157
DON'T HAVE A POOR RELATIONSHIP
00:43:13.223 --> 00:43:14.692
WITH THE VOTERS AT THE PARTY
00:43:14.758 --> 00:43:16.260
LEVEL BUT THEY ARE ABLE TO
00:43:16.327 --> 00:43:18.495
PERSUADE THE PARTY MEMBERS IN
00:43:18.562 --> 00:43:19.530
THEIR DISTRICT.
00:43:19.596 --> 00:43:23.334
SO WHAT I'M TRYING TO GET TO IS.
00:43:23.400 --> 00:43:25.035
DOESN'T LEADERSHIP HAVE A RIGHT
00:43:25.102 --> 00:43:26.303
TO SUPPORT THOSE PEOPLE BECAUSE
00:43:26.370 --> 00:43:27.638
THEY ELECTED BY THEIR BY THEIR
00:43:27.705 --> 00:43:29.306
PEOPLE IN THE DISTRICT.
00:43:29.373 --> 00:43:30.507
I MEAN IF IF LEADERSHIP COMES
00:43:30.574 --> 00:43:31.442
ALONG AND SAYS I WANT TO HELP
00:43:31.508 --> 00:43:33.143
YOU GET REELECTED U. ENDORSED BY
00:43:33.210 --> 00:43:34.812
THE PARTY IN THE PARTY WON'T
00:43:34.878 --> 00:43:36.080
CONTINUE TO RE AND WE WISH YOU
00:43:36.146 --> 00:43:37.614
CAN'T CAN'T LEADERSHIP SAY.
00:43:37.681 --> 00:43:39.583
YOU REPRESENT CORE VALUES AND WE
00:43:39.650 --> 00:43:41.318
THINK THAT THAT'S A RIGHT THING
00:43:41.385 --> 00:43:42.886
TO DO DON'T FORGET EVERY EVERY
00:43:42.953 --> 00:43:44.488
PERSON IN THIS BODY WHEN YOU
00:43:44.555 --> 00:43:45.022
TALK ABOUT DEMOCRACY
00:43:45.089 --> 00:43:45.322
[inaudible]
00:43:45.389 --> 00:43:47.257
YOU KNOW.
00:43:47.324 --> 00:43:48.859
EVERYONE OF US WERE ELECTED.
00:43:48.926 --> 00:43:50.594
WE ALL THAT 50% PLUS ONE TO GET
00:43:50.661 --> 00:43:52.129
ELECTED BY THE PEOPLE AND
00:43:52.196 --> 00:43:53.897
ULTIMATELY DEMOCRACY IS INFORMED
00:43:53.964 --> 00:43:55.766
BY THE PEOPLE AND WE ALL GOT
00:43:55.833 --> 00:43:56.734
ELECTED.
00:43:56.800 --> 00:43:57.935
EACH OF THEIR COUNTERBALANCE
00:43:58.002 --> 00:44:00.304
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IN TERMS OF
00:44:00.371 --> 00:44:01.772
THE EFFORTS THAT WERE ENGAGED IN
00:44:01.839 --> 00:44:03.941
AND HOW WE CHARGED HARMONIZE
00:44:04.008 --> 00:44:05.175
ISN'T A FACTOR.
00:44:05.242 --> 00:44:07.211
AGAIN I DIDN'T THINK ABOUT UNTIL
00:44:07.277 --> 00:44:07.978
I JUST LISTEN TO YOUR ANSWERS
00:44:08.045 --> 00:44:08.812
ARE NOT.
00:44:08.879 --> 00:44:10.314
JUST TRYING TO ENGAGE YOU TO AN
00:44:10.381 --> 00:44:11.715
HONEST DISCUSSION ISN'T IT
00:44:11.782 --> 00:44:13.617
SHOULD NOT BE A HUGE FACTOR IN
00:44:13.684 --> 00:44:14.451
DETERMINING.
00:44:14.518 --> 00:44:15.419
WHAT WE'RE RESOURCES GO
00:44:15.486 --> 00:44:16.720
ABSOLUTELY IT'S A HUGE FACTOR
00:44:16.787 --> 00:44:18.989
AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHY WE GAVE
00:44:19.056 --> 00:44:19.790
THE -- CAN
00:44:19.857 --> 00:44:22.259
CDVA LEGISLATIVE LEADERS EXTRA
00:44:22.326 --> 00:44:24.061
DELEGATES AN EXTRA SAY IN WHO
00:44:24.128 --> 00:44:25.429
ARE CAMPAIGNS ARE BECAUSE OF
00:44:25.496 --> 00:44:26.263
COURSE WE RESPECT YOUR
00:44:26.330 --> 00:44:27.498
PERSPECTIVE OR THE PERSPECTIVE
00:44:27.564 --> 00:44:28.766
OF ELECTED OFFICIALS.
00:44:28.832 --> 00:44:29.466
ON WHO WOULD MAKE GOOD
00:44:29.533 --> 00:44:33.303
COLLEAGUES BUT THAT PERSON WHAT
00:44:33.370 --> 00:44:33.937
EIGHTY EIGHTY FOUR DOES IS ALLOW
00:44:34.004 --> 00:44:36.340
A TOTAL AND RUN AROUND INSTEAD
00:44:36.407 --> 00:44:37.574
OF HAVING TO COME TO THE PARTY
00:44:37.641 --> 00:44:38.642
AND MAKE THE CASE FOR YOUR FOR
00:44:38.709 --> 00:44:39.276
CANDIDATES.
00:44:39.343 --> 00:44:40.477
THAT YOU'RE SUPPORTING EVEN WITH
00:44:40.544 --> 00:44:42.713
EXTRA VOTES --
00:44:42.780 --> 00:44:44.281
IT ALLOWS THAT THE LEGISLATIVE
00:44:44.348 --> 00:44:45.115
LEADERS TO JUST COMPLETELY
00:44:45.182 --> 00:44:47.584
BYPASS IT NO ONE SHOULD HAVE A
00:44:47.651 --> 00:44:49.386
MONOPOLY ON POWER IN THE
00:44:49.453 --> 00:44:50.187
DEMOCRATIC PARTY ESPECIALLY OUR
00:44:50.254 --> 00:44:50.687
PARTY.
00:44:50.754 --> 00:44:52.689
FUND GRASSROOTS SHOULD NOT BE
00:44:52.756 --> 00:44:54.391
ABLE TO COMPLETELY --
00:44:54.458 --> 00:44:55.759
FAUVER RIHT THE OPINION OF THE
00:44:55.826 --> 00:44:57.628
PEOPLE WHO WE WE TRUST AND WE
00:44:57.694 --> 00:44:59.163
ELECT TO MAKE --
00:44:59.229 --> 00:45:00.898
COMPROMISES AND AND CRAFT LAW ON
00:45:00.964 --> 00:45:02.733
OUR BEHALF AT THE SAME TIME
00:45:02.800 --> 00:45:03.801
LEADERSHIP SHOULDN'T BE ABLE TO
00:45:03.867 --> 00:45:04.935
SAY HEY WE JUST DON'T AGREE WITH
00:45:05.002 --> 00:45:06.503
THE PARTY ON THIS ONE SO WE'RE
00:45:06.570 --> 00:45:07.404
GOING TO GO TO LOAN.
00:45:07.471 --> 00:45:09.339
AND SHEEP THE ENTIRE CAMPAIGN
00:45:09.406 --> 00:45:11.408
FINANCE SYSTEM TO ALLOW THEM TO
00:45:11.475 --> 00:45:13.043
DO THAT BUT THEY'RE REALLY DOING
00:45:13.110 --> 00:45:14.244
THAT BUT I COME FROM THE SHIP IN
00:45:14.311 --> 00:45:16.046
A VALLEY ALSO SOME HERE FROM THE
00:45:16.113 --> 00:45:17.114
VALLEY GLENN.
00:45:17.181 --> 00:45:18.315
BUT WE HAVE TO DIPS OF THE
00:45:18.382 --> 00:45:19.583
DEMOCRATIC PARTY OF SAN FRAN
00:45:19.650 --> 00:45:22.052
ABOUT STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BUT
00:45:22.119 --> 00:45:22.586
WHO STRONGLY PUT IT ON MY
00:45:22.653 --> 00:45:23.687
QUESTION.
00:45:23.754 --> 00:45:25.089
YOU RAISED HEARING YOUR
00:45:25.155 --> 00:45:26.490
TESTIMONY IF YOU TALKED ABOUT
00:45:26.557 --> 00:45:27.991
THE POLITICAL PARTIES HAVE TO
00:45:28.058 --> 00:45:29.126
CONTROL THIS THE POLITICAL
00:45:29.193 --> 00:45:29.860
COMMITTEES WE SHOULDN'T HAVE
00:45:29.927 --> 00:45:31.462
ANYBODY WHO IS YOUR BILL TO
00:45:31.528 --> 00:45:32.896
RAISE MONEY WITH THE NAME
00:45:32.963 --> 00:45:33.964
DEMOCRATIC PARTY OR SANCTIONED
00:45:34.031 --> 00:45:35.165
BY THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY NOW I
00:45:35.232 --> 00:45:36.934
KNOW THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY'S
00:45:37.000 --> 00:45:38.035
LITIGATED AGAINST IPS OF CLUB.
00:45:38.102 --> 00:45:39.703
DEAL WITH THIS FOR MANY YEARS
00:45:39.770 --> 00:45:40.704
THEY DON'T LIKE THEM TO HAVE THE
00:45:40.771 --> 00:45:42.506
NAME DEMOCRATIC PARTY'S CENTRAL
00:45:42.573 --> 00:45:45.909
VALLEY THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY'S
00:45:45.976 --> 00:45:46.643
SANFORD ABOUT LEE HAS.
00:45:46.710 --> 00:45:47.845
ONE AND SO THIS IS AN ISSUE
00:45:47.911 --> 00:45:48.579
AGAIN AND JUST USES EXAMPLE
00:45:48.645 --> 00:45:49.613
POSITION BUT THE HEART OF MY
00:45:49.680 --> 00:45:51.415
BACKYARD OF PEOPLE I CARE ABOUT
00:45:51.482 --> 00:45:52.182
DEEPLY.
00:45:52.249 --> 00:45:54.785
AND ARM THIS IS A WHOLE THING OF
00:45:54.852 --> 00:45:56.553
THE YOU CAN'T USE THE PARTY NAME
00:45:56.620 --> 00:45:58.122
I MEAN THE TECH THE TEST IS.
00:45:58.188 --> 00:45:59.790
LEGISLATORS RAISE MONEY TO
00:45:59.857 --> 00:46:01.592
SUPPORT THEMSELVES TO SUPPORT
00:46:01.658 --> 00:46:03.360
THEIR FRIENDS TO SUPPORT CAUSES
00:46:03.427 --> 00:46:04.561
TO SUPPORT THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY
00:46:04.628 --> 00:46:06.130
IS TO ALL OF THE REPUBLICAN
00:46:06.196 --> 00:46:07.631
PARTY WHATEVER THE CASE MAY BE
00:46:07.698 --> 00:46:08.799
THEY DO THAT.
00:46:08.866 --> 00:46:12.069
THE QUESTION HERE IN THIS BILL.
00:46:12.136 --> 00:46:15.639
TO ME HE IS WHETHER OR NOT.
00:46:15.706 --> 00:46:17.241
BY THE WAY GOING BACK TO WHAT
00:46:17.307 --> 00:46:18.642
THE STATUS QUO WAS BECAUSE THE
00:46:18.709 --> 00:46:20.477
ONLY REASON THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY
00:46:20.544 --> 00:46:21.311
GETS ALL THE CAMPAIGN
00:46:21.378 --> 00:46:23.313
CONTRIBUTIONS.
00:46:23.380 --> 00:46:25.282
FROM DELIVERS THE DEMOCRATIC
00:46:25.349 --> 00:46:26.884
PARTY OF IT IN MY SAID DON'T
00:46:26.950 --> 00:46:28.385
REPUBLICANS I DO THINK THEY HAVE
00:46:28.452 --> 00:46:29.753
A SEPARATE OFFICE OPERATION.
00:46:29.820 --> 00:46:31.188
GETS THE CONTRIBUTIONS JUST
00:46:31.255 --> 00:46:32.322
BECAUSE THEY HAVE A HIGHER LIMIT.
00:46:32.389 --> 00:46:34.258
SO SOME OF LEGISLATOR OR
00:46:34.324 --> 00:46:35.792
REPRESENTATIVE GOES TO SOMEBODY
00:46:35.859 --> 00:46:37.361
AND SAYS LOOK IN ADDITION TO
00:46:37.427 --> 00:46:38.695
SUPPORTING ME CAN YOU HELP THE
00:46:38.762 --> 00:46:39.997
DEMOCRATIC PARTY BECAUSE WE WANT
00:46:40.063 --> 00:46:41.598
MONEY IT'S GOOD BECAUSE OF THE
00:46:41.665 --> 00:46:42.766
NAME IT'S GOOD BECAUSE THE FRANK
00:46:42.833 --> 00:46:44.668
THE PRANK YOUR PRIVILEGES OF
00:46:44.735 --> 00:46:45.202
SEVEN NINE CENTS LESS ONS
00:46:45.269 --> 00:46:46.370
POSTAGE.
00:46:46.436 --> 00:46:47.104
AND ALL THOSE THINGS ARE
00:46:47.171 --> 00:46:49.439
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT.
00:46:49.506 --> 00:46:52.176
BUT BUT IT'S A TOOL THAT
00:46:52.242 --> 00:46:53.744
LEADERSHIP USES THERE'S NO
00:46:53.810 --> 00:46:55.479
SECRET ABOUT THAT TO HELP
00:46:55.546 --> 00:46:58.015
SUPPORT THE ISSUES THAT MATTER.
00:46:58.081 --> 00:46:59.783
A GETTING PEOPLE ELECTED HELPING
00:46:59.850 --> 00:47:01.818
IN THOSE TYPES OF THINGS THAT'S
00:47:01.885 --> 00:47:03.887
THAT'S ALL WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
00:47:03.954 --> 00:47:05.589
AND SO THE QUESTION BECOMES.
00:47:05.656 --> 00:47:07.491
THE TOOL THAT HAS BEEN USED
00:47:07.558 --> 00:47:09.893
SINCE THE INCEPTION BEFORE PROP
00:47:09.960 --> 00:47:10.861
NINE WHEN WE HAD TRUST BECAUSE
00:47:10.928 --> 00:47:12.162
WE JUST ON ROUTE SPEAKER.
00:47:12.229 --> 00:47:13.830
ALL OF THOSE THINGS WE MADE ALL
00:47:13.897 --> 00:47:15.465
OF THIS PROGRESS AND THEN WE
00:47:15.532 --> 00:47:17.668
MADE A DECISION WAS IT YOURS AT
00:47:17.734 --> 00:47:18.402
TWO THOUSAND WAS.
00:47:18.468 --> 00:47:19.536
HELEN WHAT WE ARE TO PROPERTY
00:47:19.603 --> 00:47:21.038
FORCE TWO THOUSAND WHATEVER IT
00:47:21.104 --> 00:47:21.805
WAS.
00:47:21.872 --> 00:47:22.706
PICK BECAUSE OF THE SHRINK
00:47:22.773 --> 00:47:24.508
MISSOURI CASE TO COME UP WITH
00:47:24.575 --> 00:47:26.443
THIS TOOL AND ARE TOWARDS THE
00:47:26.510 --> 00:47:27.678
CHAIR OF OUR PARTY.
00:47:27.744 --> 00:47:29.313
AND AND IT'S OKAY FIND THIS A
00:47:29.379 --> 00:47:31.481
TOOL TO BE ABLE TO ALLOW.
00:47:31.548 --> 00:47:32.950
THE DEMOCRATIC LEADERSHIP
00:47:33.016 --> 00:47:35.219
DEMOCRATIC MEMBERS CANDIDATES TO
00:47:35.285 --> 00:47:37.221
RAISE MONEY IN THE PARTY TO HELP
00:47:37.287 --> 00:47:39.056
OKAY SO.
00:47:39.122 --> 00:47:39.957
THE ISSUES IT'S NEVER NOT BEEN
00:47:40.023 --> 00:47:41.625
THERE THE ISSUE IS IT'S
00:47:41.692 --> 00:47:43.527
REVERTING BACK TO WAY TO CREATE
00:47:43.594 --> 00:47:44.661
A MECHANISM.
00:47:44.728 --> 00:47:46.230
AND THAT MECHANISM A GUY DON'T
00:47:46.296 --> 00:47:47.297
KNOW YOU KNOW THIS IS BUT A
00:47:47.364 --> 00:47:48.966
REALLY TOUGH ISSUE FOR ME I
00:47:49.032 --> 00:47:49.600
GRAPPLE WITH THIS THING HAVE
00:47:49.666 --> 00:47:51.235
SPENT. THIRTY YEARS OF MY LIFE
00:47:51.301 --> 00:47:52.369
WORKING IN THIS FIELD MEASURE
00:47:52.436 --> 00:47:53.837
EACH IN LA.
00:47:53.904 --> 00:47:55.405
WITHIN THIS FIELD BUT I I'VE
00:47:55.472 --> 00:47:57.441
LEARNED A LOT IN THIS PROCESS
00:47:57.507 --> 00:47:59.576
ABOUT.
00:47:59.643 --> 00:48:01.111
YOU KNOW KIND OF LIKE WHAT WE
00:48:01.178 --> 00:48:02.713
WHAT WHAT REALLY GOES ON MAY
00:48:02.779 --> 00:48:04.681
HAVE TO SPEND SEVENTY FIVE TO
00:48:04.748 --> 00:48:05.282
EIGHTY THOUSAND DOLLARS YEAR
00:48:05.349 --> 00:48:06.116
IN COMPLIANCE AFTER SETTING THE
00:48:06.183 --> 00:48:06.883
YOU'RE NOT YOU'RE.
00:48:06.950 --> 00:48:08.252
JUST TO FILL OUT ALL THE FORMS
00:48:08.318 --> 00:48:09.820
YOU HAVE TO HAVE AN AUDITOR WHO
00:48:09.886 --> 00:48:11.588
AUDITS MYAUDITOR BECAUSE THEY
00:48:11.655 --> 00:48:13.523
MAKE MISTAKES AND I'M SCARED TO
00:48:13.590 --> 00:48:14.691
DEATH.
00:48:14.758 --> 00:48:15.459
THAT'LL HELP MAKE A MISTAKE ILL
00:48:15.525 --> 00:48:16.927
DEFINED.
00:48:16.994 --> 00:48:18.095
IT'S UNBELIEVABLE HOW MUCH SO
00:48:18.161 --> 00:48:19.830
HOPEFUL THAT COMPLIANCE EIGHT
00:48:19.896 --> 00:48:21.164
SOMEONE MENTIONED IN COMPLIANCE
00:48:21.231 --> 00:48:22.532
COSTS WHICH IS AN ISSUE.
00:48:22.599 --> 00:48:23.367
SO THE QUESTION IS WHAT ARE WE
00:48:23.433 --> 00:48:25.869
TRYING.
00:48:25.936 --> 00:48:27.638
TO VERBAL HERE IN GOVERNMENT
00:48:27.704 --> 00:48:29.339
WHAT'S THE HARM.
00:48:29.406 --> 00:48:30.907
DOES NO QUESTION THE LATENESS OF
00:48:30.974 --> 00:48:32.542
THIS IS AN ISSUE.
00:48:32.609 --> 00:48:33.844
THE ISSUES OF PEOPLE MADE THOSE
00:48:33.910 --> 00:48:34.878
ARE ALWAYS A CHALLENGE THERE'S
00:48:34.945 --> 00:48:36.313
NO QUESTION WE PUT THE SEVENTY
00:48:36.380 --> 00:48:37.881
TWO HOUR RULE IN PLACE.
00:48:37.948 --> 00:48:38.482
NO QUESTION IT'S A COMPELLING
00:48:38.548 --> 00:48:40.117
ARGUMENT.
00:48:40.183 --> 00:48:41.351
A SENSITIVE ISSUE PERSONAL
00:48:41.418 --> 00:48:43.453
QUESTION THAT THE IMPACT IT'S
00:48:43.520 --> 00:48:44.788
HAD ON LEAST ON WITH ITS OF THE
00:48:44.855 --> 00:48:46.390
REPUBLICAN PARTY WOULD HERE IN A
00:48:46.456 --> 00:48:47.491
MINUTE THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY.
00:48:47.557 --> 00:48:48.492
IT'S BEEN SOMEWHAT CHALLENGING
00:48:48.558 --> 00:48:50.894
AND OR UNITED.
00:48:50.961 --> 00:48:51.862
I'M TRYING TO GET TO THE CORE OF
00:48:51.928 --> 00:48:53.330
THIS.
00:48:53.397 --> 00:48:56.566
ABOUT WHAT REALLY IS GOING ON
00:48:56.633 --> 00:48:58.268
BECAUSE I DON'T SEE THAT THE
00:48:58.335 --> 00:49:00.404
TRANSPARENCY THING THE AMOUNT OF
00:49:00.470 --> 00:49:01.772
MONEY UNLESS THE MY WRONG SHE
00:49:01.838 --> 00:49:03.307
CHAIRMAN THE MONEY CONTRIBUTION
00:49:03.373 --> 00:49:04.775
THAT'S BEING MADE TO A
00:49:04.841 --> 00:49:06.143
LEADERSHIP COMMITTEE APART
00:49:06.209 --> 00:49:07.711
WHATEVER THE IS THE SAME AMOUNT
00:49:07.778 --> 00:49:08.745
THAT YOU MAKE TO THE PARTY.
00:49:08.812 --> 00:49:10.514
IT'S NOT AS IF SOMEBODY WANTS TO
00:49:10.580 --> 00:49:11.882
GIVE MONEY AND A BUNCH MORE DARK
00:49:11.948 --> 00:49:13.283
MONEY COMES IN I GUESS THE
00:49:13.350 --> 00:49:13.884
ARGUMENT IS THAT YOU GIVE TO
00:49:13.950 --> 00:49:14.718
BOTH.
00:49:14.785 --> 00:49:17.421
SO MAYBE YOU SAY OKAY FINE IF.
00:49:17.487 --> 00:49:19.423
ONE RIGHT YOU CAN GO TO BOTH BUT
00:49:19.489 --> 00:49:21.124
WHICH HAPPENS IN THE PARTY IS
00:49:21.191 --> 00:49:22.626
THE GIVEN TOPIC THEY GIVE ALL
00:49:22.693 --> 00:49:24.161
THE COUNTY COMMITTEES NOT JUST
00:49:24.227 --> 00:49:25.962
WHAT HAPPENS GO TO AUDIT THE
00:49:26.029 --> 00:49:27.297
WHOLE PROCEDURE.
00:49:27.364 --> 00:49:29.599
I DON'T MUCH SO SURE WHAT YOU'RE
00:49:29.666 --> 00:49:31.068
REALLY TALKING ABOUT HERE
00:49:31.134 --> 00:49:32.669
BECAUSE YOU'RE TALKING IS A
00:49:32.736 --> 00:49:34.538
DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED PEOPLE.
00:49:34.604 --> 00:49:35.772
THESE DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED
00:49:35.839 --> 00:49:36.807
PEOPLE OF BOTH PARTIES ARE
00:49:36.873 --> 00:49:39.076
GRAZING MONEY.
00:49:39.142 --> 00:49:40.277
THEY'RE PUTTING MONEY INTO
00:49:40.344 --> 00:49:42.379
TRANSPARENT TOOL.
00:49:42.446 --> 00:49:44.748
THE TRANSPARENT TOOL BE EVEN ONE
00:49:44.815 --> 00:49:46.583
FORMER ANOTHER ARE PUTTING INTO
00:49:46.650 --> 00:49:47.984
TRANSPARENT TOOL I DON'T SEE
00:49:48.051 --> 00:49:49.886
THAT PICTURE LIMIT THEM MAKE
00:49:49.953 --> 00:49:51.154
LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY PEOPLE
00:49:51.221 --> 00:49:53.056
CAN GIVE I'M ALL FOR THAT.
00:49:53.123 --> 00:49:53.924
BODY WHATEVER.
00:49:53.990 --> 00:49:55.992
BUT IT'S ALL ABOUT WHETHER THE
00:49:56.059 --> 00:49:57.461
LEADERSHIP CAN DO WHAT AND THE
00:49:57.527 --> 00:49:59.129
LEADERSHIP ISN'T SOME NON
00:49:59.196 --> 00:50:00.497
ELECTED PEOPLE.
00:50:00.564 --> 00:50:01.898
LEADERSHIP A THEMSELVES GOT
00:50:01.965 --> 00:50:05.135
ELECTED AND BE ELECTED BY EVERY
00:50:05.202 --> 00:50:06.503
BUT ALL THEIR PEOPLE ARE ELECTED.
00:50:06.570 --> 00:50:07.838
IN THE DITTMAR PARTIES WERE SELF
00:50:07.904 --> 00:50:09.473
SELECTING.
00:50:09.539 --> 00:50:11.675
I WENT VOLUNTEERS YOUNG TEENAGER
00:50:11.742 --> 00:50:13.577
AND HELPED IN CAMPAIGNS AND WE
00:50:13.643 --> 00:50:15.078
CAN SOLVE SELECTING I'VE BEEN
00:50:15.145 --> 00:50:16.380
WHAT THE THIRTY DEMOCRATIC
00:50:16.446 --> 00:50:17.881
CONVENTION SELF SELECTING PAID
00:50:17.948 --> 00:50:18.415
FOR IT MYSELF [inaudible]
00:50:18.482 --> 00:50:19.983
RIGHT [inaudible]
00:50:20.050 --> 00:50:21.818
DEMOCRATIC PARTY.
00:50:21.885 --> 00:50:24.654
IS EVERYBODY REPUBLICAN PARTY IS
00:50:24.721 --> 00:50:25.055
EVERYBODY.
00:50:25.122 --> 00:50:25.756
SO.
00:50:25.822 --> 00:50:29.426
MY THERAPY THIS IS A TOUGH ISSUE --
00:50:29.493 --> 00:50:31.995
YOU KNOW IN THE END FARM CALL IT
00:50:32.062 --> 00:50:34.064
THE REPUBLICANS GO ON ABOUT THIS
00:50:34.131 --> 00:50:36.333
BUT I DON'T THINK THIS IS DARK
00:50:36.400 --> 00:50:37.267
MONEY.
00:50:37.334 --> 00:50:38.635
BUT BUT I DON'T THINK IT'S START
00:50:38.702 --> 00:50:39.503
MONEY BECAUSE I THINK IT'S
00:50:39.569 --> 00:50:41.705
DISCLOSURE BUT I DO I DO THINK
00:50:41.772 --> 00:50:43.807
THERE'S A THERE'S A LOT OF
00:50:43.874 --> 00:50:45.142
PEOPLE SINGULAR QUESTIONS.
00:50:45.208 --> 00:50:47.444
A LOT OF CHALLENGES AND ALSO ON
00:50:47.511 --> 00:50:48.845
A PERSONAL LEVEL YOU KNOW A GOT
00:50:48.912 --> 00:50:49.913
A BILLION TELEPHONE CALLS ON
00:50:49.980 --> 00:50:50.947
THIS THING FOR PEOPLE I CARE A
00:50:51.014 --> 00:50:52.749
LOT ABOUT.
00:50:52.816 --> 00:50:53.717
AND PEOPLE'S OPINION I RESPECT A
00:50:53.784 --> 00:50:54.985
LOT BITE.
00:50:55.051 --> 00:50:56.620
ME THIS IS NOT THIS IS TOUGH
00:50:56.686 --> 00:50:58.121
BECAUSE IT'S EACH IT'S EASY TO
00:50:58.188 --> 00:51:00.157
BEAT UP A BILL AGAINST SOMEBODY
00:51:00.223 --> 00:51:02.058
WHO WHO SHARE OUR OPPONENTS.
00:51:02.125 --> 00:51:04.895
IT'S HARD WHEN YOUR FRIENDS.
00:51:04.961 --> 00:51:07.230
PHONE WHO YOU KNOW PIKE I STAND
00:51:07.297 --> 00:51:09.099
UP WHAT SHE CALLS YOU KNOW WHEN
00:51:09.166 --> 00:51:11.601
SHE CALLS ME I LISTEN SO IT'S A
00:51:11.668 --> 00:51:12.869
BECAUSE THESE GUYS HAVE GREAT.
00:51:12.936 --> 00:51:14.271
GREAT TRACK RECORDS OF DOING
00:51:14.337 --> 00:51:16.273
GREAT THINGS SO I SORT OF GO ON
00:51:16.339 --> 00:51:17.441
SO LONG I WANTED TO COME TO
00:51:17.507 --> 00:51:19.009
FRAME A LITTLE BIT BUT I I JUST
00:51:19.075 --> 00:51:19.943
THINK THAT.
00:51:20.010 --> 00:51:21.044
THE ONE PIECE YOU'RE MISSING IN
00:51:21.111 --> 00:51:21.678
THIS.
00:51:21.745 --> 00:51:24.047
IS THAT THE PUBLIC IS ENGAGED
00:51:24.114 --> 00:51:26.683
THE PUBLIC DOES MAKE DECISIONS
00:51:26.750 --> 00:51:28.652
POLITICIANS ARE HELD ACCOUNTABLE
00:51:28.718 --> 00:51:29.986
FOR EVERY DOLLAR THAT THEY ASK
00:51:30.053 --> 00:51:32.022
ANYBODY FOR FOR WHATEVER PURPOSE.
00:51:32.088 --> 00:51:33.323
EVEN IF IT'S RAISING MONEY IN
00:51:33.390 --> 00:51:35.725
THE PAST IN CONTEXT WE'VE BEEN
00:51:35.792 --> 00:51:36.426
WORKING ON THIS ISSUE FOR TWENTY
00:51:36.493 --> 00:51:38.328
FIVE THIRTY YEARS.
00:51:38.395 --> 00:51:39.863
SO I AYE JOURNALISM DEAR THANK
00:51:39.930 --> 00:51:41.465
YOU SAILOR FROZE PERSONA ONCE OR
00:51:41.531 --> 00:51:42.833
NOT IT WAS HEALTH FOR THE FREE
00:51:42.899 --> 00:51:44.034
ME ISSUES AND YOU KNOW.
00:51:44.100 --> 00:51:44.968
I DON'T KNOW IF OTHER MEMBERS
00:51:45.035 --> 00:51:46.002
HAVE QUESTIONS I DIDN'T WANT TO
00:51:46.069 --> 00:51:48.004
GIVE THE AUTHORS CHANCE ALSO TO
00:51:48.071 --> 00:51:50.407
ENGAGE HERE I CAN I JUST MAKE
00:51:50.474 --> 00:51:51.708
ONE POINT A FACT THOUGH THAT WAS
00:51:51.775 --> 00:51:52.108
BROUGHT.
00:51:52.175 --> 00:51:53.810
UP THROUGH THE JUST JUST TO MAKE
00:51:53.877 --> 00:51:55.979
TO BE CLEAR IT IF IN THE GENERAL
00:51:56.046 --> 00:51:57.681
ELECTION THERE IS ONE DEMOCRAT
00:51:57.747 --> 00:51:59.082
AND ONE REPUBLICAN OR ONE NON
00:51:59.149 --> 00:51:59.716
DEMOCRAT.
00:51:59.783 --> 00:52:01.218
IN THE GENERAL ELECTION BY OUR
00:52:01.284 --> 00:52:04.154
PARTY RULES WE AUTOMATICALLY
00:52:04.221 --> 00:52:05.388
ENDORSE THE DEMOCRAT.
00:52:05.455 --> 00:52:06.056
BUT IF IT IS IN FACT TRUE THAT
00:52:06.122 --> 00:52:08.291
LIKE SOMEONE RAN WAS NOT
00:52:08.358 --> 00:52:08.859
ENDORSED BY US IN THE FIRST
00:52:08.925 --> 00:52:10.026
ROUD.
00:52:10.093 --> 00:52:11.495
BUT SOME BUT THE VOTERS LIKE
00:52:11.561 --> 00:52:12.596
SOMEBODY ELSE AND THEY GOT
00:52:12.662 --> 00:52:13.997
THROUGH INTO THE ONLY DEMOCRAT
00:52:14.064 --> 00:52:15.098
THAT THEY'RE AUTOMATICALLY ARE
00:52:15.165 --> 00:52:16.199
ENDORSED CANDIDATE AND WE WOULD
00:52:16.266 --> 00:52:17.434
COOPERATE WITH THEIR CAMPAIGN TO
00:52:17.501 --> 00:52:19.135
GET THEM ELECTED.
00:52:19.202 --> 00:52:19.936
GREAT.
00:52:20.003 --> 00:52:21.938
FUN CENTER WOULD YOU MIND IF I
00:52:22.005 --> 00:52:23.206
AS A TOPIC.
00:52:23.273 --> 00:52:24.474
CHERISHED THROWN.
00:52:24.541 --> 00:52:26.042
THROUGH THE CHAIR HAD TARIFFS
00:52:26.109 --> 00:52:27.444
SURE MISTER I DON'T THINK YOU
00:52:27.511 --> 00:52:28.612
SHOULD PLEASE.
00:52:28.678 --> 00:52:29.379
I THINK YOU RAISE AN EXCELLENT
00:52:29.446 --> 00:52:30.914
POINT WHICH IS BRING UP THE IDEA
00:52:30.981 --> 00:52:32.449
WILL MAYBE TO ENSURE THERE'S NO
00:52:32.516 --> 00:52:33.750
ACTUAL INCREASE MONEY MAYBE IT
00:52:33.817 --> 00:52:35.385
SHOULD BE KEPT DONATIONS TO THE
00:52:35.452 --> 00:52:36.319
PARTY.
00:52:36.386 --> 00:52:38.522
OR LET'S OF CAUCUS MANY THING
00:52:38.588 --> 00:52:41.091
THAT SOME.
00:52:41.157 --> 00:52:41.925
THE BILL SHOULD REALLY THINK
00:52:41.992 --> 00:52:43.093
TAKING PLACE NEXT YEAR WHEN
00:52:43.159 --> 00:52:44.561
THERE'S TIME TO DISCUSSES TOUCH
00:52:44.628 --> 00:52:45.695
POSSIBILITIES.
00:52:45.762 --> 00:52:47.297
COULD ALSO MENTION THAT THE MAIN
00:52:47.364 --> 00:52:48.899
THRUST OF THIS WHY THIS IS
00:52:48.965 --> 00:52:50.100
IMPORTANT IS DISCLOSURE.
00:52:50.166 --> 00:52:52.335
WELL IF IT REALLY THE MAIN GOAL
00:52:52.402 --> 00:52:53.403
WAS DISCLOSURE THERE'S ACTUALLY
00:52:53.470 --> 00:52:54.137
BETTER WAYS THAT WE CAN
00:52:54.204 --> 00:52:55.305
ACCOMPLISH THAT GOAL WITHOUT
00:52:55.372 --> 00:52:57.374
EVEN CREATING FOUR NEW POLITICAL
00:52:57.440 --> 00:52:58.642
PARTIES WE COULD SIMPLY REQUIRE.
00:52:58.708 --> 00:53:00.043
ANY BUT HASN'T CAMPAIGN
00:53:00.110 --> 00:53:01.444
CONTRIBUTION OVER A CERTAIN
00:53:01.511 --> 00:53:03.013
AMOUNT OF WOULD HAVE TO BE
00:53:03.079 --> 00:53:03.914
REPORT AND THEN YOU'D ACTUALLY
00:53:03.980 --> 00:53:05.649
GET BETTER DISCLOSURE BECAUSE
00:53:05.715 --> 00:53:07.083
CURRENTLY IF LEADERSHIP.
00:53:07.150 --> 00:53:10.086
CONTINUES TO MAKE REQUESTS OF
00:53:10.153 --> 00:53:11.454
PEOPLE TO GIVE MONEY TO THE
00:53:11.521 --> 00:53:12.622
PARTY BECAUSE OF MAX OUT THEIR
00:53:12.689 --> 00:53:14.057
LIPS OF CAUCUS THAT STILL WON'T
00:53:14.124 --> 00:53:15.692
BE DISCLOSED UNDER THIS BILL.
00:53:15.759 --> 00:53:16.693
AND IF OTHER PEOPLE OTHER THAN
00:53:16.760 --> 00:53:18.361
LEADERSHIP MAKE THOSE REQUESTS
00:53:18.428 --> 00:53:18.962
THAT WON'T BE DISCLOSED UNDER
00:53:19.029 --> 00:53:21.331
THIS BILL TOO SO ALL THAT TO SAY.
00:53:21.398 --> 00:53:22.432
I THINK THEY'RE MORE ISSUES THAT
00:53:22.499 --> 00:53:23.633
COULD BE DISCUSSED IF WE HAD
00:53:23.700 --> 00:53:25.035
MORE TIME WHICH IS PART THE
00:53:25.101 --> 00:53:26.469
REASON WHY WE THINK THE SHUTTLE
00:53:26.536 --> 00:53:26.836
HAD.
00:53:26.903 --> 00:53:28.605
THANK YOU MISTER I DON'T --
00:53:28.672 --> 00:53:31.007
MEMBERS THE PART AS I READ THAT
00:53:31.074 --> 00:53:35.111
I'D LIKE TO HUMILITY AUTHOR
00:53:35.178 --> 00:53:36.580
ACCELERATE THE STRETCHER.
00:53:36.646 --> 00:53:38.815
SURE SOME EVER DID YOU AND JUST.
00:53:38.882 --> 00:53:39.482
WHY CAN COMPREHEND A CITY JUST
00:53:39.549 --> 00:53:40.584
ON THIS COLLOQUY BUT A FEW
00:53:40.650 --> 00:53:41.885
POINTS SAY I WILL HAVE A A CLOSE
00:53:41.952 --> 00:53:43.053
AT THE END OF SURE IF I MAY BE
00:53:43.119 --> 00:53:45.021
JUST A FEW POINTS ON ON SOME OF
00:53:45.088 --> 00:53:46.389
THE TESTIMONY AND I?
00:53:46.456 --> 00:53:48.692
I'M I'M GRATEFUL FOR THE PASSION
00:53:48.758 --> 00:53:49.726
IN THE INTEREST OF THE FOLKS
00:53:49.793 --> 00:53:51.461
BEHIND ME AND AS I INDICATED.
00:53:51.528 --> 00:53:53.630
LIKE THE SENATOR SAID I WORK
00:53:53.697 --> 00:53:54.864
HIGH IN CLOSE CONCERT WITH MANY
00:53:54.931 --> 00:53:56.466
OF THESE PEOPLE ON A VARIETY OF
00:53:56.533 --> 00:53:57.667
ISSUES AROUND.
00:53:57.734 --> 00:54:01.771
A CAMPAIGN REFORM SO THIS HOUSE.
00:54:01.838 --> 00:54:03.406
AND BUT I I WOULD NOT BE PUTTING
00:54:03.473 --> 00:54:05.308
MY NAME ON THIS BILL IF I DIDN'T
00:54:05.375 --> 00:54:07.477
THINK IT WAS AN IMPROVEMENT OVER
00:54:07.544 --> 00:54:08.845
THE STATUS QUO WHICH IS AN
00:54:08.912 --> 00:54:11.047
OPAQUE.
00:54:11.114 --> 00:54:14.117
PROCESS VERY DIFFICULT TO FIND.
00:54:14.184 --> 00:54:15.385
IF THE LEGISLATIVE LEADERS ARE
00:54:15.452 --> 00:54:17.320
RAISING FUNDS.
00:54:17.387 --> 00:54:18.254
WHOSE --
00:54:18.321 --> 00:54:19.823
GIVING TO THE LEGISLATIVE
00:54:19.889 --> 00:54:22.058
LEADERS WHO SOLICITED.
00:54:22.125 --> 00:54:23.627
AND THEN WHO IS BENEFITING FROM
00:54:23.693 --> 00:54:24.728
FINES THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED BY
00:54:24.794 --> 00:54:26.396
THE LEGISLATIVE LEADERS
00:54:26.463 --> 00:54:26.696
[inaudible]
00:54:26.763 --> 00:54:30.133
THIS REMOVES BUT THAT PROCESS
00:54:30.200 --> 00:54:31.034
THE IT IT CREATES A PARALLEL
00:54:31.101 --> 00:54:32.969
PROCESS.
00:54:33.036 --> 00:54:34.471
WITH LEGISLATIVE LEADERS ELECTED
00:54:34.537 --> 00:54:36.306
OFFICIALS.
00:54:36.373 --> 00:54:38.074
AND HE KNOWS I'M GOING TO ROCK
00:54:38.141 --> 00:54:40.810
AND I DO HAVE A LOT OF RESPECT.
00:54:40.877 --> 00:54:42.512
FOR IRAQ AND HIS WORK --
00:54:42.579 --> 00:54:44.314
IN THE PARTY HE MENTIONED.
00:54:44.381 --> 00:54:45.682
THAT THIS BILL IS A UNIFYING
00:54:45.749 --> 00:54:47.617
FORCE I WAS SORT OF TRAPPED OF
00:54:47.684 --> 00:54:48.818
BEING A UNIFIER.
00:54:48.885 --> 00:54:50.387
RIGHT IN ENVISIONED THE SLOPPY
00:54:50.453 --> 00:54:50.754
HOW [inaudible]
00:54:50.820 --> 00:54:53.590
IT HAPPENS.
00:54:53.657 --> 00:54:56.393
THAT'S NOT HOW I DREAMT IT --
00:54:56.459 --> 00:54:58.795
BUT INTERESTING NONE THE LESS --
00:54:58.862 --> 00:55:00.296
WHERE WE FIND OURSELVES SO JUST
00:55:00.363 --> 00:55:02.065
A COUPLE OF UP APPOINTS?
00:55:02.132 --> 00:55:04.968
ON THE PROCESS YES I WISH I RAN
00:55:05.035 --> 00:55:07.537
THIS BILL IN JANUARY --
00:55:07.604 --> 00:55:08.271
THERE WERE A VARIETY OF
00:55:08.338 --> 00:55:09.606
DISCUSSIONS ARE HAPPENING OVER
00:55:09.673 --> 00:55:11.508
THE COURSE OF THE YEAR --
00:55:11.574 --> 00:55:12.642
WE PUT THIS BILL IN A PRINT IN
00:55:12.709 --> 00:55:15.378
JULY -- SO
00:55:15.445 --> 00:55:17.313
IT'S BEEN IN PRINT FOR AWHILE
00:55:17.380 --> 00:55:17.981
AND BELIEVE ME I'VE BEEN HEARING
00:55:18.048 --> 00:55:20.917
ABOUT THIS BILL SINCE JULY.
00:55:20.984 --> 00:55:21.518
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE MULTIPLE
00:55:21.584 --> 00:55:23.820
HEARINGS MULTIPLE FLOOR VOTES
00:55:23.887 --> 00:55:27.257
POTENTIALLY IF IT GETS --
00:55:27.323 --> 00:55:29.459
HOUSE COMMITTEE TODAY.
00:55:29.526 --> 00:55:31.161
AND A TWO THIRDS VOTE WITH THE
00:55:31.227 --> 00:55:32.295
WITH THE MOB.
00:55:32.362 --> 00:55:34.197
POLITICAL REFORM ACT.
00:55:34.264 --> 00:55:35.131
PROBABLY REQUIRES BIPARTISAN
00:55:35.198 --> 00:55:36.733
SUPPORT.
00:55:36.800 --> 00:55:38.068
AND ULTIMATELY THE GOVERNOR THE
00:55:38.134 --> 00:55:39.135
ORIGINAL AUTHOR OF THE POLITICAL
00:55:39.202 --> 00:55:40.670
FORMAT PASSED TO BE OKAY WITH
00:55:40.737 --> 00:55:41.671
THIS SO THERE IS A PROCESS
00:55:41.738 --> 00:55:42.872
UNFOLDING A BELIEVE ME THE
00:55:42.939 --> 00:55:44.674
PUBLIC IS FULLY ENGAGED.
00:55:44.741 --> 00:55:46.509
BECAUSE IN THIS PROCESS A COUPLE
00:55:46.576 --> 00:55:48.011
OF POINTS LIKE I KEEP HEARING
00:55:48.078 --> 00:55:50.280
THE WORD AND I'M ON FACEBOOK AND
00:55:50.346 --> 00:55:51.648
I SEE THE WORD UNLIMITED
00:55:51.715 --> 00:55:53.316
UNLIMITED UNLIMITED.
00:55:53.383 --> 00:55:54.818
THIS BILL CONFORMS TO THE
00:55:54.884 --> 00:55:56.219
EXISTING.
00:55:56.286 --> 00:55:59.489
LIMITS OF THIRTY SIX FIVE THIS
00:55:59.556 --> 00:56:01.458
IS A REPLICATION.
00:56:01.524 --> 00:56:04.394
OF THE EXISTING PROCESS THIS IS
00:56:04.461 --> 00:56:06.963
NOT SOME NEW AVENUE WERE WERE
00:56:07.030 --> 00:56:08.798
LIFTING CAPS AND LIFTING LIMITS
00:56:08.865 --> 00:56:10.066
IT'S GOING TO INVITE.
00:56:10.133 --> 00:56:11.835
TYPES OF MONEY WHERE YOU SEE THE
00:56:11.901 --> 00:56:15.305
INCREASE IN FUNDS IN CALIFORNIA
00:56:15.371 --> 00:56:17.674
POLITICS IS INDEPENDENT
00:56:17.741 --> 00:56:19.342
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEES.
00:56:19.409 --> 00:56:21.344
WHO ARE AT THE BANE OF THE
00:56:21.411 --> 00:56:22.312
EXISTENCE OF MANY ELECTED
00:56:22.378 --> 00:56:23.713
OFFICIALS I KNOW SOME OF WHOM
00:56:23.780 --> 00:56:25.248
HAVE BENEFITTED FROM INDEPENDENT
00:56:25.315 --> 00:56:27.350
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEES?
00:56:27.417 --> 00:56:29.119
BUT THE FRUSTRATION WHEN YOU
00:56:29.185 --> 00:56:30.053
HAVE INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURE
00:56:30.120 --> 00:56:32.322
COMMITTEES.
00:56:32.388 --> 00:56:34.090
ON ELECTED FOLKS IN CHARGE OF
00:56:34.157 --> 00:56:35.558
THIS MILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF
00:56:35.625 --> 00:56:38.461
CORPORATE MONEY.
00:56:38.528 --> 00:56:41.131
IN MANY WAYS APPLYING PRESSURE
00:56:41.197 --> 00:56:42.699
VIA THE INITIATIVE PROCESS TO
00:56:42.766 --> 00:56:45.034
THIS LEGISLATURE.
00:56:45.101 --> 00:56:46.169
BECAUSE WE DON'T WANT TO SEE AN
00:56:46.236 --> 00:56:47.170
INITIATIVE ON THE BALLOT WE TAKE
00:56:47.237 --> 00:56:48.772
ACTION.
00:56:48.838 --> 00:56:50.540
THAT WE'D RATHER NOT TAKE.
00:56:50.607 --> 00:56:52.108
WHO IS EXERTING THAT INFLUENCE
00:56:52.175 --> 00:56:53.910
NOT THE ELECTED OFFICIALS IT IS
00:56:53.977 --> 00:56:55.345
THE OUTSIDE IN APPENDIX MANAGER
00:56:55.411 --> 00:56:56.279
COMMITTEES?
00:56:56.346 --> 00:56:58.882
THIS MEASURE IS A MODICUM
00:56:58.948 --> 00:56:59.182
[inaudible]
00:56:59.249 --> 00:57:00.984
AMADA COME.
00:57:01.050 --> 00:57:04.154
OF COUNTERWEIGHT TO THAT OUTSIDE
00:57:04.220 --> 00:57:07.157
INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURE MONEY I
00:57:07.223 --> 00:57:09.058
HEAR THE WORDS DARK MONEY.
00:57:09.125 --> 00:57:11.528
MONEY GENERALLY REFERS TO PLAY
00:57:11.594 --> 00:57:12.462
UNLIMITED DONATIONS FROM
00:57:12.529 --> 00:57:14.597
CORPORATIONS INDIVIDUALS AND
00:57:14.664 --> 00:57:15.298
UNIONS I WAS SORT A NEW WITH
00:57:15.365 --> 00:57:17.000
DARK MONEY MEN BUT ACTUALLY
00:57:17.066 --> 00:57:19.569
LOOKED IT UP THIS MORNING.
00:57:19.636 --> 00:57:20.770
UNLIMITED DONATIONS FROM
00:57:20.837 --> 00:57:22.405
CORPORATIONS INDIVIDUALS AND
00:57:22.472 --> 00:57:23.740
UNIONS WHERE THE DONORS ARE NOT
00:57:23.807 --> 00:57:25.441
REQUIRED TO DISCLOSE THEIR
00:57:25.508 --> 00:57:27.510
DONORS.
00:57:27.577 --> 00:57:29.445
AB EIGHTY FOUR IS THE OPPOSITE
00:57:29.512 --> 00:57:31.681
OF THAT.
00:57:31.748 --> 00:57:33.716
THE OPPOSITE OF THAT.
00:57:33.783 --> 00:57:36.753
THIS IS AN ANTI DARK MONEY BILL.
00:57:36.820 --> 00:57:39.055
SO I GET SO FRUSTRATED.
00:57:39.122 --> 00:57:40.290
WHEN I HEAR?
00:57:40.356 --> 00:57:42.325
THESE WONDERFUL GROUPS.
00:57:42.392 --> 00:57:44.194
THAT I'M A MEMBER OF THAT I
00:57:44.260 --> 00:57:46.663
BELIEVE IN THE MISSION OF
00:57:46.729 --> 00:57:47.363
CALLING MY BILL A DARK MONEY
00:57:47.430 --> 00:57:48.198
BILL.
00:57:48.264 --> 00:57:49.933
WE ARE REMOVING.
00:57:49.999 --> 00:57:53.236
THIS OPAQUE PROCESS THIS YOU
00:57:53.303 --> 00:57:54.737
NEED TO BE A FORENSIC ACCOUNTANT
00:57:54.804 --> 00:57:56.039
IF ACCOUNTED DEFINE HOW THE
00:57:56.105 --> 00:57:57.740
MONEY WORKS.
00:57:57.807 --> 00:57:58.575
WE'RE MOVING THAT INTO THE
00:57:58.641 --> 00:58:00.376
PUBLIC SPHERE TO THE PRESS THE
00:58:00.443 --> 00:58:02.245
PUBLIC OTHERS CAN SEE WHAT'S
00:58:02.312 --> 00:58:03.980
GOING ON HERE AND HOW MONEY IS
00:58:04.047 --> 00:58:05.815
MOVING IN CALIFORNIA.
00:58:05.882 --> 00:58:07.617
I UNDERSTAND THAT FOLKS IN MY
00:58:07.684 --> 00:58:08.785
DEMOCRATIC PARTY BY THE WAY HAVE
00:58:08.852 --> 00:58:09.786
BEEN A DUES PAYING MEMBER OF THE
00:58:09.853 --> 00:58:12.222
DEMOCRATIC PARTY SINCE.
00:58:12.288 --> 00:58:12.755
NINETEEN EIGHTY EIGHT THE
00:58:12.822 --> 00:58:14.157
DUKAKIS ERA.
00:58:14.224 --> 00:58:15.892
THAT WAS AN ERA CULINARY.
00:58:15.959 --> 00:58:17.961
REFILL CARE OF LONG HISTORY IN A
00:58:18.027 --> 00:58:18.828
SENATE DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL
00:58:18.895 --> 00:58:20.196
COMMITTEE --
00:58:20.263 --> 00:58:22.465
PERSON MY FIRST ELECTIVE OFFICE
00:58:22.532 --> 00:58:23.433
I HAVE TO GO TALK TO MY
00:58:23.499 --> 00:58:24.400
DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL COMMITTEE
00:58:24.467 --> 00:58:26.035
FOLKS ON THURSDAY THEY'RE NOT
00:58:26.102 --> 00:58:27.737
HAPPY WITH ME BUT THEIR ISSUE IS
00:58:27.804 --> 00:58:28.438
THEY DON'T.
00:58:28.504 --> 00:58:30.640
WANT TO HAVE TO DO ADDITIONAL
00:58:30.707 --> 00:58:31.975
REPORTING.
00:58:32.041 --> 00:58:34.077
BECAUSE IT'S PROBABLY KIND OF A
00:58:34.143 --> 00:58:36.012
PAIN IN THE NECK FORM.
00:58:36.079 --> 00:58:38.147
AND YOU KNOW WHAT I DON'T WANT.
00:58:38.214 --> 00:58:38.815
TO I DON'T WANNA MAKE LIFE MORE
00:58:38.882 --> 00:58:40.717
DIFFICULT. FOR THE SMALLER
00:58:40.783 --> 00:58:42.752
COMMITTEES BUT WE CAME UP WITH
00:58:42.819 --> 00:58:44.354
THE STANDARD OF FIFTY THOUSAND
00:58:44.420 --> 00:58:45.455
DOLLARS ACRSS THE CYCLE WHICH
00:58:45.521 --> 00:58:46.689
MEANS THERE'S SOME MONEY MOVING
00:58:46.756 --> 00:58:48.925
THROUGH THE CENTRAL COMMITTEES.
00:58:48.992 --> 00:58:49.826
AND I'M GONNA FIGURE OUT A WAY
00:58:49.893 --> 00:58:51.261
TO TRY TO HELP THEM IF IF THERE
00:58:51.327 --> 00:58:53.263
REALLY IS AN ISSUE THEIR WITH
00:58:53.329 --> 00:58:54.631
THEM DOING THAT DISCLOSURE BUT
00:58:54.697 --> 00:58:55.665
WE OUGHT TO BE THE PARTY OF
00:58:55.732 --> 00:58:56.799
DISCLOSURE.
00:58:56.866 --> 00:58:59.435
AND REPORTING AND SHARING WITH
00:58:59.502 --> 00:59:01.671
THE PUBLIC WHAT IS HAPPENING IN
00:59:01.738 --> 00:59:03.172
THESE PARTIES [inaudible]
00:59:03.239 --> 00:59:05.541
SO.
00:59:05.608 --> 00:59:07.410
I'M NOT SURPRISED THAT FOLKS IN
00:59:07.477 --> 00:59:08.378
THE CALIFORNIA DEMOCRATIC PARTY
00:59:08.444 --> 00:59:09.746
ARE NOT THRILLED WITH THIS
00:59:09.812 --> 00:59:10.046
[inaudible]
00:59:10.113 --> 00:59:13.149
BUT PAUL THE RESPECTED BARAKA
00:59:13.216 --> 00:59:15.285
AND OTHERS YES THESE FOLKS ARE
00:59:15.351 --> 00:59:17.053
ELECTED BY THEIR DELEGATES.
00:59:17.120 --> 00:59:19.188
WE ARE ELECTED BY THE PUBLIC
00:59:19.255 --> 00:59:20.723
THIS IS INVESTING SOME
00:59:20.790 --> 00:59:22.725
ADDITIONAL AUTHORITY ELECTED
00:59:22.792 --> 00:59:24.227
LEADERS ACCOUNTABLE TO THE
00:59:24.294 --> 00:59:26.763
PUBLIC WITH STRINGENT REPORTING.
00:59:26.829 --> 00:59:28.598
REQUIREMENTS SO THIS IS AN
00:59:28.665 --> 00:59:30.700
IMPROVEMENT.
00:59:30.767 --> 00:59:32.869
OVER THE STATUS QUO.
00:59:32.936 --> 00:59:33.670
WITH THAT MISTER CHAIR I WILL
00:59:33.736 --> 00:59:35.438
LEAVE IT TOUGH FOR ADDITIONAL
00:59:35.505 --> 00:59:37.073
COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS.
00:59:37.140 --> 00:59:37.640
AND WE'LL REVISIT FOR CLOSE
00:59:37.707 --> 00:59:38.841
FRANKLY [inaudible]
00:59:38.908 --> 00:59:41.044
CLEARLY.
00:59:41.110 --> 00:59:43.012
THANK YOU --
00:59:43.079 --> 00:59:44.814
THIS IS A HARD ONE THIS IS
00:59:44.881 --> 00:59:46.482
REALLY HARD --
00:59:46.549 --> 00:59:48.051
YOU KNOW YOU LOOK AT THINGS
00:59:48.117 --> 00:59:50.753
DIFFERENTLY WHEN YOU RICKY WHEN
00:59:50.820 --> 00:59:54.223
YOU'RE AN ELECTED OFFICIAL --
00:59:54.290 --> 00:59:55.358
WAS AN ACTIVIST FOR TWELVE
00:59:55.425 --> 00:59:56.426
STOCKS ARE MUSCLE THE NEXT
00:59:56.492 --> 00:59:58.294
ACTIVISTS BUT WAS AN ACTIVIST IN
00:59:58.361 --> 00:59:59.929
THE LABOR MOVEMENT FOR TWENTY
00:59:59.996 --> 01:00:00.663
YEARS BEFORE.
01:00:00.730 --> 01:00:03.399
I RAN FOR OFFICE --
01:00:03.466 --> 01:00:05.501
AYE -- TO
01:00:05.568 --> 01:00:07.170
BUT SOME A MULLIN FOG GET
01:00:07.236 --> 01:00:08.805
FRUSTRATED WHEN PEOPLE TALK
01:00:08.871 --> 01:00:10.073
ABOUT THIS BEING DARK MONEY
01:00:10.139 --> 01:00:11.574
BECAUSE IT IS JUST THE OPPOSITE
01:00:11.641 --> 01:00:12.709
OF THAT.
01:00:12.775 --> 01:00:15.979
I WORRY ABOUT TRANSPARENCY --
01:00:16.045 --> 01:00:18.314
WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS I THINK
01:00:18.381 --> 01:00:19.983
IT DOES AGGREGATES THE MONEY SO
01:00:20.049 --> 01:00:21.884
WE CAN SEE EXACTLY WHERE IT CAME
01:00:21.951 --> 01:00:22.618
FROM?
01:00:22.685 --> 01:00:25.021
SO THAT WE KNOW EXACTLY WHO
01:00:25.088 --> 01:00:27.123
CONTRIBUTED WHAT TO WIN I KNOW
01:00:27.190 --> 01:00:29.625
TO JUST HEAR ME OUT OKAY --
01:00:29.692 --> 01:00:31.728
I'VE LOST SLEEP OVER THIS OKAY
01:00:31.794 --> 01:00:34.464
NONE OF US NONE OF US TAKES A
01:00:34.530 --> 01:00:37.967
VOTE LATELY --
01:00:38.034 --> 01:00:39.235
BUT YOU ALSO GET HERE AND YOU
01:00:39.302 --> 01:00:40.403
SEE WHAT HAPPENS WITH THE I.
01:00:40.470 --> 01:00:41.170
<c.green> IN THE END PICKED</c>
01:00:41.237 --> 01:00:42.005
INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURE
01:00:42.071 --> 01:00:43.539
CAMPAIGNS.
01:00:43.606 --> 01:00:44.407
AND SMETIMES WE DON'T HAVE A
01:00:44.474 --> 01:00:46.175
WAY TO FIGHT BACK.
01:00:46.242 --> 01:00:47.810
AND THIS MIGHT BE A WAY TO HELP
01:00:47.877 --> 01:00:51.614
US FIGHT BACK --
01:00:51.681 --> 01:00:53.182
I WILL SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY.
01:00:53.249 --> 01:00:55.118
AND THERE I HAVE QUESTIONS I
01:00:55.184 --> 01:00:57.253
HAVE CONCERNS I'VE SPOKEN TO OUR
01:00:57.320 --> 01:00:59.555
LEADERSHIP ABOUT IT THE PRO TEM.
01:00:59.622 --> 01:01:00.823
AND THERE'S SOME THINGS I WANT
01:01:00.890 --> 01:01:03.192
US TO WORK ON BUT I WILL SUPPORT
01:01:03.259 --> 01:01:04.594
IT SO THAT WE CAN SO THAT WE CAN
01:01:04.660 --> 01:01:06.195
I KNOW I SEE YOU PT YOUR THUMBS
01:01:06.262 --> 01:01:08.197
DOWN IT'S NOT AN EASY JOB OKAY
01:01:08.264 --> 01:01:09.265
WHEN YOU'RE AN ELECTED OFFICIAL
01:01:09.332 --> 01:01:10.800
YOU MAKE HARD DECISIONS.
01:01:10.867 --> 01:01:12.635
YOU WEIGH IT AND YOU TRY TO MAKE
01:01:12.702 --> 01:01:14.303
THE BEST DECISION POSSIBLE.
01:01:14.370 --> 01:01:15.438
I THINK TRANSPARENCY IS
01:01:15.505 --> 01:01:16.939
IMPORTANT I DON'T TAKE MONEY
01:01:17.006 --> 01:01:18.508
FROM OIL FROM TOBACCO FROM
01:01:18.574 --> 01:01:20.443
WALMART YOU HAVE TO HAVE LINE
01:01:20.510 --> 01:01:21.711
IN THE SAND.
01:01:21.778 --> 01:01:22.478
AND I THINK WE CAN ALWAYS DO
01:01:22.545 --> 01:01:24.180
BETTER AND I THINK THIS IS A
01:01:24.247 --> 01:01:25.982
BILL ON ITS WAY IT STILL NEEDS
01:01:26.049 --> 01:01:27.683
SOME WORK BUT I THINK THIS IS A
01:01:27.750 --> 01:01:29.118
BILL THAT CAN.
01:01:29.185 --> 01:01:31.254
WITH SOME TWEAKS CAN HELP US DO
01:01:31.320 --> 01:01:33.122
BETTER I WORRY ABOUT INDEPENDENT
01:01:33.189 --> 01:01:35.224
EXPENDITURE CAMPAIGNS IF ANYBODY
01:01:35.291 --> 01:01:36.959
ISN'T WORRIED ABOUT THOSE YOU
01:01:37.026 --> 01:01:38.728
SHOULD BE THESE ARE THE THINGS
01:01:38.795 --> 01:01:40.663
THAT ARE REALLY DRIVING --
01:01:40.730 --> 01:01:42.165
OUR OUR PARTY IN THE WRONG
01:01:42.231 --> 01:01:44.667
DIRECTION THIS IS MIGHT BE
01:01:44.734 --> 01:01:45.668
WE DON'T EVER KNOW THIS MIGHT BE
01:01:45.735 --> 01:01:49.272
A WAY.
01:01:49.338 --> 01:01:50.907
AND I DO THINK THAT IT'S FAR
01:01:50.973 --> 01:01:52.842
MORE TRANSPARENT THAN THE
01:01:52.909 --> 01:01:54.744
CURRENT PROCESS WE HAVE IS IT A
01:01:54.811 --> 01:01:56.546
PERFECT BILL NO IT'S NOT A
01:01:56.612 --> 01:01:57.847
PERFECT BILL.
01:01:57.914 --> 01:01:59.082
AND I HOPE THAT MOVING FORWARD
01:01:59.148 --> 01:02:01.117
WE CAN DO BETTER.
01:02:01.184 --> 01:02:02.618
AND THAT WE CAN LIKE ALL FEEL
01:02:02.685 --> 01:02:03.820
THE SUPPORTED ON THE FLOOR BUT
01:02:03.886 --> 01:02:05.488
IF WE CAN'T MAKE SOME CHANGES
01:02:05.555 --> 01:02:06.622
THAT I MIGHT NOT BILL SUPPORTED
01:02:06.689 --> 01:02:08.191
ON THE FLOOR.
01:02:08.257 --> 01:02:10.927
OKAY THANK YOU SENATOR LEYVA.
01:02:10.993 --> 01:02:13.162
WEAK INCOME BRINGING HIM BACK TO
01:02:13.229 --> 01:02:14.130
THE DAYS MISTER VICE CHAIR
01:02:14.197 --> 01:02:14.831
ANYTHING SCHOOL I HAD A FEW
01:02:14.897 --> 01:02:17.266
COMMENTS BUT WITH THIS NOW WITH
01:02:17.333 --> 01:02:18.234
THE PROBLEMS THAT IS.
01:02:18.301 --> 01:02:19.469
SO -- TWELVE
01:02:19.535 --> 01:02:22.839
THAT WE HAVE FOR THE MINISTER
01:02:22.905 --> 01:02:24.640
MLLIN AND ACTUALLY FOR THE
01:02:24.707 --> 01:02:25.241
OPPOSITION TO ONLY GO OVER.
01:02:25.308 --> 01:02:27.844
POINTS THAT I THINK SHOULD BE
01:02:27.910 --> 01:02:30.780
CLARIFIED FOR THE RECORD SO --
01:02:30.847 --> 01:02:35.718
PROCESS WISE --
01:02:35.785 --> 01:02:37.653
NOT IDEAL CIRCUMSTANCES.
01:02:37.720 --> 01:02:39.856
BUT I WILL SAY THAT THIS HEARING
01:02:39.922 --> 01:02:41.557
IS AN INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT VENUE
01:02:41.624 --> 01:02:41.858
[inaudible]
01:02:41.924 --> 01:02:44.827
AND I THINK.
01:02:44.894 --> 01:02:46.729
THE MEMBERS THINK YOU'RE YOU'RE
01:02:46.796 --> 01:02:48.064
YOU'RE READING IT ON THEIR FACE
01:02:48.131 --> 01:02:49.799
IN IN THEIR COMMENTS --
01:02:49.866 --> 01:02:51.601
HAVE.
01:02:51.667 --> 01:02:53.903
THOROUGHLY HEARD YOU --
01:02:53.970 --> 01:02:56.472
IF WE DID HAVE MORE TIME --
01:02:56.539 --> 01:02:58.107
THERE WOULD BE OPPORTUNITIES AND
01:02:58.174 --> 01:02:59.642
I REGRET FRANKLY --
01:02:59.709 --> 01:03:01.010
THE TIMING I WOULD CALL THIS THE
01:03:01.077 --> 01:03:03.246
TENTH HOUR PERHAPS NOT THE
01:03:03.312 --> 01:03:06.115
ELEVENTH BUT <c.green> YOU KNOW ON</c>
01:03:06.182 --> 01:03:07.950
THE ON THE PROCESS AYE I DO HAVE
01:03:08.017 --> 01:03:10.419
SERIOUS CONCERNS --
01:03:10.486 --> 01:03:11.854
ON THE SUBSTANCE OF IT.
01:03:11.921 --> 01:03:13.956
I I WANTED TO SORT OF
01:03:14.023 --> 01:03:15.324
INTERROGATE THIS ISSUE THERE
01:03:15.391 --> 01:03:16.325
SEEMS TO BE A SORT OF
01:03:16.392 --> 01:03:17.894
FUNDAMENTAL DISPUTE ABOUT
01:03:17.960 --> 01:03:19.228
WHETHER THIS WILL LEAD TO MORE
01:03:19.295 --> 01:03:21.364
MONEY OR IS IT THE SAME AMOUNT
01:03:21.430 --> 01:03:23.166
OF NET MONEY.
01:03:23.232 --> 01:03:24.634
GOING INTO DIFFERENT CHANNELS
01:03:24.700 --> 01:03:25.968
BUT IT SEEMS LIKE THAT THE
01:03:26.035 --> 01:03:26.769
ARGUMENT IS.
01:03:26.836 --> 01:03:31.107
WELL IF THERE'S IF IF IT'S THEN.
01:03:31.174 --> 01:03:33.209
THE DOLLARS WILL JUST FLOW
01:03:33.276 --> 01:03:34.810
THROUGH ONE OF THESE LEGISLATIVE
01:03:34.877 --> 01:03:36.312
COMMITTEES AND THAT --
01:03:36.379 --> 01:03:37.547
YOU KNOW WOULD BE MORE
01:03:37.613 --> 01:03:38.981
TRANSPARENT THAN.
01:03:39.048 --> 01:03:39.849
FOR SORT OF GETTING BANKS
01:03:39.916 --> 01:03:41.984
SHOUTED ON THE OTHER HAND IF YOU
01:03:42.051 --> 01:03:42.952
HAVE A IT'S A DIFFERENT VIEW
01:03:43.019 --> 01:03:44.620
THAT IT'S NOT ZERO SUM IN THERE
01:03:44.687 --> 01:03:46.455
IS ENDLESS POLITICAL MONEY OUT
01:03:46.522 --> 01:03:47.590
THERE THAT WOULD ACTUALLY
01:03:47.657 --> 01:03:49.592
INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF MONEY --
01:03:49.659 --> 01:03:53.229
YOU KNOW I IT'S HARD TO EVALUATE
01:03:53.296 --> 01:03:54.764
A HYPOTHETICAL HERE BECAUSE WE
01:03:54.830 --> 01:03:56.532
REALLY DON'T KNOW HOW THIS WOULD
01:03:56.599 --> 01:03:58.301
PLAY OUT IF IT BECAME LAW NO ONE
01:03:58.367 --> 01:04:01.637
REALLY KNOWS BUT I DO THINK --
01:04:01.704 --> 01:04:04.040
CENTER LABELS POINT IS WELL
01:04:04.106 --> 01:04:05.174
TAKEN IN THAT.
01:04:05.241 --> 01:04:08.644
THE THE THE TRUE ENEMY HERE IS
01:04:08.711 --> 01:04:10.046
INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES IN
01:04:10.112 --> 01:04:11.547
CITIZENS UNITED I WOULD SAY
01:04:11.614 --> 01:04:13.249
FIRST AND FOREMOST --
01:04:13.316 --> 01:04:16.786
AND PUBLIC FINANCING --
01:04:16.852 --> 01:04:19.222
DESERVES NOT JUST HEARING BUT
01:04:19.288 --> 01:04:21.524
REAL ENGAGEMENT --
01:04:21.591 --> 01:04:24.694
AND I WANT THIS COMMITTEE TO
01:04:24.760 --> 01:04:27.063
TAKE THAT ISSUE ON IT IS VERY
01:04:27.129 --> 01:04:28.965
HARD TO DO ANY CITIZENS UNITED
01:04:29.031 --> 01:04:30.733
CLIMATE AS MANY OF YOU MAY KNOW
01:04:30.800 --> 01:04:33.636
BUT WATCHING IN A RECENT SPECIAL
01:04:33.703 --> 01:04:36.205
ELECTION.
01:04:36.272 --> 01:04:36.872
NO IT DIDN'T.
01:04:36.939 --> 01:04:38.441
FALL IN ALL THE MAYBE THREE
01:04:38.507 --> 01:04:39.942
MILLION DOLLARS ARE SO AN
01:04:40.009 --> 01:04:41.344
INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES IN A
01:04:41.410 --> 01:04:43.412
VERY SUBSTANTIAL CHUNK OF THAT
01:04:43.479 --> 01:04:46.315
COMING FROM THE OIL INDUSTRY --
01:04:46.382 --> 01:04:48.517
THE YOU KNOW MADE ME INCREDIBLY
01:04:48.584 --> 01:04:49.986
UNCOMFORTABLE AND CONCERNED
01:04:50.052 --> 01:04:52.088
ABOUT THESE DARK FORCES --
01:04:52.154 --> 01:04:54.190
I DO NOT THINK.
01:04:54.257 --> 01:04:56.892
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER IS PROPONENT
01:04:56.959 --> 01:04:58.628
FOR THE THOSE INTERESTS --
01:04:58.694 --> 01:05:00.630
NOR ANYONE ON THIS COMMITTEE BUT
01:05:00.696 --> 01:05:02.798
I I WILL SAY --
01:05:02.865 --> 01:05:05.067
YOU NO WE HAVE TO COMBAT THAT --
01:05:05.134 --> 01:05:06.135
THERE ARE ALSO THE POLITICS OF
01:05:06.202 --> 01:05:07.703
IT.
01:05:07.770 --> 01:05:08.638
AN INTERESTING POSITION WHERE I
01:05:08.704 --> 01:05:10.506
I MEAN THE LEGISLATURE HERE SO I
01:05:10.573 --> 01:05:11.907
CAN'T REALLY THINK ABOUT MY
01:05:11.974 --> 01:05:13.276
POLITICAL SELF INTEREST TO
01:05:13.342 --> 01:05:15.077
RELEASE THAT OUGHT NOT BE THE
01:05:15.144 --> 01:05:16.445
JURISDICTION OF THIS COMMITTEE.
01:05:16.512 --> 01:05:19.115
BUT I DO WORRY ABOUT THE SIGNAL
01:05:19.181 --> 01:05:20.850
WILL BE SENDING THAT WE WANT%
01:05:20.916 --> 01:05:22.518
MORE ACTIVISTS ENGAGE THAT WE
01:05:22.585 --> 01:05:25.521
WANT TO BE AN OPEN PARTY AND AND
01:05:25.588 --> 01:05:27.023
OTHER REPUBLICANS CAN.
01:05:27.089 --> 01:05:28.357
YOU KNOW THEY'LL DO WHAT THEY'RE
01:05:28.424 --> 01:05:29.792
GONNA DO IT HOWEVER THEY WANT TO
01:05:29.859 --> 01:05:31.260
ENGAGE THEIR BASE BUT THAT.
01:05:31.327 --> 01:05:33.429
THAT IS OF OF CONCERN TO ME BUT
01:05:33.496 --> 01:05:36.265
AND I I IF WE COULD.
01:05:36.332 --> 01:05:38.467
JUST SPEND A SECOND.
01:05:38.534 --> 01:05:39.535
SORT OF EVALUATING THIS QUESTION
01:05:39.602 --> 01:05:43.105
OF IT WAS IT WAS IT COMMON CAUSE
01:05:43.172 --> 01:05:44.707
WHO SAID INCREASING EIGHT FOLD.
01:05:44.774 --> 01:05:46.475
WHERE IS THAT FROM THE ORDERS?
01:05:46.542 --> 01:05:49.245
MISTER I DON'T JUST SO.
01:05:49.312 --> 01:05:50.513
CONDIT'S NOTION OF IS IS IT
01:05:50.579 --> 01:05:52.148
REALLY INCREASING A. PULLED I
01:05:52.214 --> 01:05:55.151
GET IF YOU ADD UP. THIRTY SIX
01:05:55.217 --> 01:05:56.719
FIVE TIMES WHATEVER THAT'S A
01:05:56.786 --> 01:05:58.921
THAT'S A TO ACCEPT BUT HAVE YOU
01:05:58.988 --> 01:06:00.089
HAVE YOU SORT OF LOOKED AT THIS
01:06:00.156 --> 01:06:02.425
ISSUE AS TO SORT OF THE NET
01:06:02.491 --> 01:06:03.926
GIVING AND HOW YOU SEE I MEAN
01:06:03.993 --> 01:06:05.528
HOW IS A PLAYED OUT PERHAPS IN
01:06:05.594 --> 01:06:06.495
OTHER STATES OR OTHER
01:06:06.562 --> 01:06:07.897
JURISDICTIONS.
01:06:07.963 --> 01:06:09.165
I'M LOOKING FOR SOME KIND OF
01:06:09.231 --> 01:06:10.833
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS ARE WE ON
01:06:10.900 --> 01:06:12.368
OUR OWN HERE ARE THERE IS A
01:06:12.435 --> 01:06:14.236
STUDENT SENATE JUST.
01:06:14.303 --> 01:06:16.439
AND I DON'T KNOW THAT I CAN GIVE-YOU COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
01:06:16.505 --> 01:06:18.074
FORECASTS FOR ANOTHER YEAR WE
01:06:18.140 --> 01:06:21.644
MIGHT BE ABLE TO DO SO.
01:06:21.711 --> 01:06:22.912
BUT I WHAT I CAN SAY IS WE DO
01:06:22.978 --> 01:06:24.046
THINK THIS WILL LEAD TO
01:06:24.113 --> 01:06:25.281
INCREASED TOTAL AMOUNT OF
01:06:25.348 --> 01:06:26.449
FUNDING YOU'VE GOT PEOPLE WHO
01:06:26.515 --> 01:06:27.850
ARE MAXING OUT TO THE PARTY
01:06:27.917 --> 01:06:29.385
CURRENTLY AND WILL LIKELY MAX AT
01:06:29.452 --> 01:06:30.720
THESE LEGISLATIVE CAUCUS
01:06:30.786 --> 01:06:31.721
COMMITTEES IN ADDITION TO THE
01:06:31.787 --> 01:06:32.154
PARTY.
01:06:32.221 --> 01:06:33.522
SO WE DO THINK IT'S GOING TO
01:06:33.589 --> 01:06:34.523
LEAD TO INCREASE MONEY OF PEOPLE
01:06:34.590 --> 01:06:36.258
WHO DON'T EVEN HAVE SOLICITED
01:06:36.325 --> 01:06:37.893
DONATIONS FROM LEADERSHIP WE'RE
01:06:37.960 --> 01:06:39.095
GOING TO ON THEIR OWN MAKE
01:06:39.161 --> 01:06:40.663
DONATIONS TO LEADERSHIP.
01:06:40.730 --> 01:06:42.264
WITH THE KERN DO PRIOR.
01:06:42.331 --> 01:06:43.566
AND I THINK THE OTHER THING TO
01:06:43.632 --> 01:06:44.934
UNDERSTAND THOUGH IS IT'S NOT
01:06:45.000 --> 01:06:46.502
EVEN IT'S NOT SOLELY THAT
01:06:46.569 --> 01:06:48.404
PHYSICS CAN LEAD TO AN INCREASED
01:06:48.471 --> 01:06:49.105
AMOUNT OF MONEY IN THIS.
01:06:49.171 --> 01:06:50.840
SYSTEM.
01:06:50.906 --> 01:06:52.942
IT'S THAT IT INCREASES ITS.
01:06:53.008 --> 01:06:54.610
HAVING A DONATION TO THE PARTY
01:06:54.677 --> 01:06:56.245
IS OF COURSE ONE THING THE PARTY
01:06:56.312 --> 01:06:57.747
DOESN'T MAKE LAWS YOU GUYS MAKE
01:06:57.813 --> 01:06:59.281
CLOTHES.
01:06:59.348 --> 01:07:00.683
ADDING THAT INCREASED SIZE EIGHT
01:07:00.750 --> 01:07:02.451
FULL DONATION TO LEGISLATE
01:07:02.518 --> 01:07:03.953
EARLIER WHO DOES MY CLOSET HAS
01:07:04.019 --> 01:07:05.354
MORE INFLUENCE THAN ANYONE ELSE
01:07:05.421 --> 01:07:06.856
AND SPOTTY TO ME BECAUSE THAT'S
01:07:06.922 --> 01:07:07.790
THE DIFFERENCE.
01:07:07.857 --> 01:07:09.825
THE VALUE THE CONTRIBUTION GOES
01:07:09.892 --> 01:07:11.093
WAY UP IN HIS THE VALUE GOES UP
01:07:11.160 --> 01:07:13.062
THE POSSIBILITY FOR UNDUE
01:07:13.129 --> 01:07:13.596
INFLUENCE GOES UP.
01:07:13.662 --> 01:07:14.430
I THINK WE'RE I THINK WE'RE ALL
01:07:14.497 --> 01:07:18.067
ABLE TO AGREE.
01:07:18.134 --> 01:07:18.868
IS WORTH FOREIGN BUYS MORE
01:07:18.934 --> 01:07:20.369
INFLUENCE RELEASED.
01:07:20.436 --> 01:07:21.804
THAT ELEVATES INFLUENCE THAN A
01:07:21.871 --> 01:07:23.339
ONE HUNDRED DOLLAR CONTRIBUTION
01:07:23.406 --> 01:07:24.740
CERTAINLY A CONTRIBUTION WITH NO
01:07:24.807 --> 01:07:26.108
RESTRICTIONS UNDER COMPLETE
01:07:26.175 --> 01:07:27.576
CONTROL LEADERSHIP.
01:07:27.643 --> 01:07:29.145
CERTAINLY HAS MORE VALUE.
01:07:29.211 --> 01:07:29.812
THAN ONE THAT HAS STRINGS
01:07:29.879 --> 01:07:31.814
ATTACHED.
01:07:31.881 --> 01:07:33.816
WE GET YEAH PLEASE SETTLE ON
01:07:33.883 --> 01:07:34.350
YOUR ON YOUR APPOINTMENTS
01:07:34.417 --> 01:07:35.484
CHAIRMAN.
01:07:35.551 --> 01:07:36.419
AND THAT IS A SHORT STICK WITH
01:07:36.485 --> 01:07:37.353
YOU ON THIS BECAUSE THIS IS
01:07:37.420 --> 01:07:38.988
IMPORTANT DISCUSSION.
01:07:39.054 --> 01:07:41.157
MY EXPERIENCE HAS ALWAYS BEEN
01:07:41.223 --> 01:07:42.858
THE NUMBER TO MAKE UP THINGS TO
01:07:42.925 --> 01:07:44.527
CHANGE ABOUT SUGGESTING IT'S NOT.
01:07:44.593 --> 01:07:46.562
IF SOMEBODY WANTS TO RAISE MONEY
01:07:46.629 --> 01:07:48.431
FOR SUPER ELECTED OFFICIAL OR
01:07:48.497 --> 01:07:50.800
SENATE CANDIDATE OF THEIR CHOICE.
01:07:50.866 --> 01:07:52.001
AND WHAT THEY'LL DO IS A SAY
01:07:52.067 --> 01:07:53.669
WILL RAISE SIX DOLLARS AND WHAT
01:07:53.736 --> 01:07:55.438
HAPPENS IS IF IT'S OVER AND
01:07:55.504 --> 01:07:57.106
ABOVE THE CONTRIBUTION TO THE TO
01:07:57.173 --> 01:07:58.374
THE INDIVIDUAL ALL.
01:07:58.441 --> 01:08:00.042
THE MONEY GOES TO THE PARTY.
01:08:00.109 --> 01:08:01.644
IF IT'S OVER ABOVE THAT NUMBER
01:08:01.710 --> 01:08:02.778
IT GOES TO ALL THE OTHER PARTY
01:08:02.845 --> 01:08:04.947
COMMITTEES THERE ARE TONS OF
01:08:05.014 --> 01:08:06.415
PARTY COMMITTEES ALL THROUGHOUT
01:08:06.482 --> 01:08:07.983
THE STATE THAT HAVE GOTTEN
01:08:08.050 --> 01:08:09.452
CONTRIBUTIONS.
01:08:09.518 --> 01:08:10.686
THAT HAVE BEEN DIRECTED BY
01:08:10.753 --> 01:08:12.455
VARIOUS LEGISLATORS TO TRY TO
01:08:12.521 --> 01:08:14.256
HELP THE CAT IN THAT AREA OR
01:08:14.323 --> 01:08:15.958
WHATEVER SO I I JUST I I ONLY
01:08:16.025 --> 01:08:16.926
THING I DO IS.
01:08:16.992 --> 01:08:18.327
THE OF YOUR POINT ABOUT ABOUT
01:08:18.394 --> 01:08:19.795
CONTRIBUTION AMOUNTS I DON'T
01:08:19.862 --> 01:08:22.164
OBJECT TO AT ALL BUT I JUST I
01:08:22.231 --> 01:08:23.466
JUST DON'T THINK THAT ALL OF A
01:08:23.532 --> 01:08:24.800
SUDDEN THIS IS GOING TO RESULT
01:08:24.867 --> 01:08:26.535
IN A BUNCH MORE MONEY.
01:08:26.602 --> 01:08:28.604
IN THE SYSTEM BECAUSE THE SYSTEM
01:08:28.671 --> 01:08:30.272
ALREADY HAS A HUNDRED AVENUES
01:08:30.339 --> 01:08:30.873
PARTICULAR THROUGH THE
01:08:30.940 --> 01:08:32.508
DEMOCRATIC PARTY THAT HAS BEEN
01:08:32.575 --> 01:08:33.976
USING SINCE PROP THIRTY FOUR
01:08:34.043 --> 01:08:35.744
CAME INTO EFFECT WHERE PEOPLE
01:08:35.811 --> 01:08:36.879
HAVE MADE CONTRIBUTIONS TO ALL
01:08:36.946 --> 01:08:38.380
SORTS OF PARTIES ON ALL SORTS OF
01:08:38.447 --> 01:08:39.982
COUNTY COMMITTEES.
01:08:40.049 --> 01:08:41.083
AND THE LIKE AROUND THE STATE
01:08:41.150 --> 01:08:42.251
THAT JUST HAPPENS TO DATE IS
01:08:42.318 --> 01:08:44.420
THERE THE EVIDENCE IS THERE THE
01:08:44.487 --> 01:08:45.988
F. PPC FILINGS ARE THERE.
01:08:46.055 --> 01:08:47.990
RIGHT SO I I JUST I DO YOUR
01:08:48.057 --> 01:08:50.726
NOTION OF HYPOTHETICAL NOTION
01:08:50.793 --> 01:08:51.627
THAT.
01:08:51.694 --> 01:08:52.795
IT'S GONNA BE EIGHT FOLD AND THE
01:08:52.862 --> 01:08:54.063
MONEY'S GOING TO GROW ON TREES
01:08:54.129 --> 01:08:55.297
ARE TO COME OUT OF SOMEWHERE AND
01:08:55.364 --> 01:08:56.966
THEY'RE GONNA PUSH IT MORE.
01:08:57.032 --> 01:08:58.100
MAYBE TWO I'M NOT SUGGESTING
01:08:58.167 --> 01:08:59.668
YOU'RE WRONG I'M JUST SUGGESTING
01:08:59.735 --> 01:09:01.770
FROM MY OWN OBSERVATION THERE'S
01:09:01.837 --> 01:09:03.606
A HUNDRED AVENUES AND THAT THE
01:09:03.672 --> 01:09:05.007
POINT THAT MISTER MULLIN MAKES
01:09:05.074 --> 01:09:06.275
IT LOOK AT ME.
01:09:06.342 --> 01:09:08.611
IS THAT THOSE HE'S TRYING TO
01:09:08.677 --> 01:09:09.879
MOVE AWAY FROM THAT OPAQUE
01:09:09.945 --> 01:09:12.081
SYSTEM THAT SAYS ALL PROMISE
01:09:12.147 --> 01:09:13.682
ACTS AND GIVE IT TO FIVE
01:09:13.749 --> 01:09:14.517
DIFFERENT PARTY SEE YOU COULDN'T
01:09:14.583 --> 01:09:15.885
OTHERWISE SEE IT UNLESS SHE HAD
01:09:15.951 --> 01:09:16.886
A SEARCH WARRANT.
01:09:16.952 --> 01:09:20.356
AND KNEW WHAT WAS GOING ON TO
01:09:20.422 --> 01:09:21.891
AND DISCLOSE IT WHICH IS THE
01:09:21.957 --> 01:09:23.292
CORNERSTONE A WE'VE BEEN
01:09:23.359 --> 01:09:26.262
FIGHTING FOR SINCE PROP.
01:09:26.328 --> 01:09:27.530
NINE IT YOU KNOW MOVING AWAY
01:09:27.596 --> 01:09:29.265
FROM A TRUST MODEL WENT WITH
01:09:29.331 --> 01:09:30.466
THAT WAS PASSED WITH JERRY BROWN
01:09:30.533 --> 01:09:33.168
WAS STICK DE SECTOR STATE.
01:09:33.235 --> 01:09:34.904
SO HOW DO YOU WOULD YOU COME UP
01:09:34.970 --> 01:09:36.038
THE CONCLUSIONS NICE ARGUMENT TO
01:09:36.105 --> 01:09:37.673
MAKE BUT FROM MY POINT OF VIEW
01:09:37.740 --> 01:09:40.075
IT JUST IT HAS NO BASIS IN ANY
01:09:40.142 --> 01:09:42.611
EVIDENCE THAT I'VE EVER SEEN.
01:09:42.678 --> 01:09:45.881
THROUGH THE CHAIR PLEASE.-FIRST A CLARIFICATION.
01:09:45.948 --> 01:09:46.916
THE EIGHT FOLD INCREASE WE'RE
01:09:46.982 --> 01:09:48.117
NOT SAYING THAT THE TOTAL AMOUNT
01:09:48.183 --> 01:09:49.151
OF MONEY WILL INCREASE A FULL
01:09:49.218 --> 01:09:50.486
THE EIGHT FOLD INCREASES THE
01:09:50.553 --> 01:09:53.322
AMOUNT CURRENTLY A CANDY CAN GET.
01:09:53.389 --> 01:09:53.923
FORTY FOUR HUNDRED VERSUS THE
01:09:53.989 --> 01:09:54.657
AMOUNT THAT CAN BE DIRECTLY
01:09:54.723 --> 01:09:56.792
CONTROLLED BY A CANDID IN THIS
01:09:56.859 --> 01:09:58.160
CASE LEGISLATIVE LEADERS.
01:09:58.227 --> 01:09:59.361
TIED TO THEIR NEW COMMITTEE
01:09:59.428 --> 01:10:01.030
WHICH IS THIRTY SIX THOUSAND
01:10:01.096 --> 01:10:01.630
FIVE HUNDRED THAT'S THE EIGHT
01:10:01.697 --> 01:10:02.131
FOLD INCREASE.
01:10:02.197 --> 01:10:03.465
TIES IN WITH THAT GOES TO IS THE
01:10:03.532 --> 01:10:05.301
VALUE OF THE CONTRIBUTION TO THE
01:10:05.367 --> 01:10:06.702
LISTENER LEADER I DON'T THINK
01:10:06.769 --> 01:10:07.870
THERE'S ANY QUESTION.
01:10:07.937 --> 01:10:08.938
THAT THE VALUE TO LEADER OF A
01:10:09.004 --> 01:10:10.439
CONTRIBUTION GOES DIRECTLY TO
01:10:10.506 --> 01:10:11.607
THEM VERSUS A SUGGESTION THAT
01:10:11.674 --> 01:10:13.108
SOMEONE GETS THE PARTY ANY
01:10:13.175 --> 01:10:14.543
SUGGESTION THAT THE PARTY THEN.
01:10:14.610 --> 01:10:16.345
MAKE EXPENDITURES ON MORALS
01:10:16.412 --> 01:10:18.013
VALUES CLEARLY MUCH HIGHER THAN
01:10:18.080 --> 01:10:19.114
IN THE VALUES CLEARLY MUCH
01:10:19.181 --> 01:10:20.115
HIGHER THE POTENTIAL RENTS
01:10:20.182 --> 01:10:21.884
INFLUENCES ALSO CLEARLY MUCH
01:10:21.951 --> 01:10:22.384
HIGHER.
01:10:22.451 --> 01:10:24.019
BETTER THE ISSUE WILL THIS LEAD
01:10:24.086 --> 01:10:24.820
TO MORE FUNDING I THINK CLEARLY
01:10:24.887 --> 01:10:25.788
THAT WELL.
01:10:25.854 --> 01:10:27.022
WHEN YOU HAVE FOR NEW COMMITTEES
01:10:27.089 --> 01:10:27.923
THAT ARE CREATED TO GIVE YOU
01:10:27.990 --> 01:10:29.491
DIRECT ACCESS GIVING DONATIONS
01:10:29.558 --> 01:10:30.793
DIRECTLY BELIEVES HAVE THE
01:10:30.859 --> 01:10:32.127
LEADERSHIP WILL CONTROL?
01:10:32.194 --> 01:10:34.263
THAT IS FAR MORE TRY TO PLACE TO
01:10:34.330 --> 01:10:35.197
PLACE YOUR MONIES IN THE MADERA
01:10:35.264 --> 01:10:36.465
COUNTY DEMOCRATIC CENTRAL
01:10:36.532 --> 01:10:39.268
COMMITTEE WELL I CAN TELL YOU AS
01:10:39.335 --> 01:10:40.402
SOMEONE WHO USED TO RUN THAT.
01:10:40.469 --> 01:10:41.604
IT'S NOT OF ITS TRUE IN THE IN
01:10:41.670 --> 01:10:42.771
THE PRACTICE HAS BEEN TO IN MY
01:10:42.838 --> 01:10:44.707
EXPERIENCE IN THE REASON IS IS
01:10:44.773 --> 01:10:45.975
BECAUSE EVERY KETTERING FOR
01:10:46.041 --> 01:10:47.810
OFFICE MARKETS OUTSIDE REASONS
01:10:47.876 --> 01:10:50.079
WHY BUT YOU BUDDY. TO BE ABLE TO
01:10:50.145 --> 01:10:52.615
WIN AND YOU HAVE NO YOU KNOW I
01:10:52.681 --> 01:10:54.283
LEFT EIGHT ZERO I GIVE
01:10:54.350 --> 01:10:55.451
EVERYTHING AWAY TO EVERYBODY TO
01:10:55.517 --> 01:10:56.652
MAKE SURE WE CAN WIN WHEN I
01:10:56.719 --> 01:10:57.486
STARTED WITH THIRTY NINE OF MY
01:10:57.553 --> 01:10:58.821
PARTY IN TH.
01:10:58.887 --> 01:11:00.222
DO YOU MY HOUSE WHEN I LEFT
01:11:00.289 --> 01:11:01.957
BECAUSE EVERY DOLLAR I REYES WAS
01:11:02.024 --> 01:11:02.925
TO HELP EVERY CANDIDATE FOR
01:11:02.992 --> 01:11:05.027
BECAUSE AND EVERYBODY IN EVERY
01:11:05.094 --> 01:11:06.462
GRASSROOTS THING THAT WE DID ALL
01:11:06.528 --> 01:11:08.063
ACROSS THE STATE AND THAT'S JUST
01:11:08.130 --> 01:11:09.064
THE WAY IT WORKS TO ME.
01:11:09.131 --> 01:11:10.633
THE BASED THE STATE LEADER HE
01:11:10.699 --> 01:11:12.401
GOT HELP BECAUSE THIS IS NOT
01:11:12.468 --> 01:11:13.802
RIGHT SO YOU'RE NOT USING THE
01:11:13.869 --> 01:11:15.638
MONEY FOR ANYTHING ELSE.
01:11:15.704 --> 01:11:16.805
ELECT PEOPLE OF YOUR PARTY
01:11:16.872 --> 01:11:18.040
THAT'S FOR SURE.
01:11:18.107 --> 01:11:19.274
YOU KNOW ME THAT BELIEVE ME THE
01:11:19.341 --> 01:11:21.443
PRESSURE AMONG CANDIDATES AND
01:11:21.510 --> 01:11:22.911
GRASSROOTS AND PEOPLE CALLING
01:11:22.978 --> 01:11:24.246
YOU AND ASKING FOR SUPPORT AND
01:11:24.313 --> 01:11:25.581
SUPPORT THIS AND THAT.
01:11:25.648 --> 01:11:27.483
IS EXTRAORDINARY I I JUST DON'T
01:11:27.549 --> 01:11:29.184
THINK THAT'S PRAGMATIC IN TERMS
01:11:29.251 --> 01:11:29.885
OF HOW THE WITHOUT THE WORLD
01:11:29.952 --> 01:11:31.153
WORKS I I DO THINK THERE'S A
01:11:31.220 --> 01:11:32.221
NUMBER OF THE POINTS YOU MAKE
01:11:32.287 --> 01:11:33.489
THEIR VERY MCCOY SO MUCH TAKEN
01:11:33.555 --> 01:11:34.089
AWAY FROM YOU.
01:11:34.156 --> 01:11:35.391
I JUST WANT TO HAVE AN HONEST
01:11:35.457 --> 01:11:37.526
DISCUSSION ABOUT MY HISTORY AND
01:11:37.593 --> 01:11:39.094
THE OBSERVATIONS IN THIS
01:11:39.161 --> 01:11:41.330
PARTICULAR AREA.
01:11:41.397 --> 01:11:42.731
THANK YOU SENATOR --
01:11:42.798 --> 01:11:45.234
WANTED TO BRING IT BACK SO
01:11:45.300 --> 01:11:47.136
THAT'S A DISCUSSION ABOUT AMOUNT
01:11:47.202 --> 01:11:48.137
IS ANOTHER DISCUSSION TO HAVE
01:11:48.203 --> 01:11:49.371
MET -- TYPE
01:11:49.438 --> 01:11:51.807
OF MONEY NOT TOTAL AMOUNT BUT
01:11:51.874 --> 01:11:53.042
WHICH MONEY.
01:11:53.108 --> 01:11:57.012
IN WHICH MONEY MATTERS SO --
01:11:57.079 --> 01:11:58.280
TO OUR FRIENDS IN THE DEMOCRATIC
01:11:58.347 --> 01:12:00.616
PARTY HERE MEAN.
01:12:00.683 --> 01:12:01.450
THESE -- THE
01:12:01.517 --> 01:12:03.152
PLATFORM PRINCIPLES THAT THE
01:12:03.218 --> 01:12:05.320
PARTY HAS ADOPTED ON WHICH MONEY
01:12:05.387 --> 01:12:06.889
TO TAKE IN WHICH NOT TO TAKE IS
01:12:06.955 --> 01:12:09.024
THAT -- IS
01:12:09.091 --> 01:12:10.626
THAT IT IN YOUR BY LAWS AT THIS
01:12:10.693 --> 01:12:13.028
POINT DE HOW WHAT WAS THE STE
01:12:13.095 --> 01:12:14.430
YOU MENTION A FEW DIFFERENT
01:12:14.496 --> 01:12:15.998
INJURIES THAT YOU ARE THAT THEY
01:12:16.065 --> 01:12:17.566
PARTY DOESN'T TAKE MONEY FROM
01:12:17.633 --> 01:12:19.968
HOW IS HOW IS THAT BEING NICE TO
01:12:20.035 --> 01:12:20.536
INTERACT.
01:12:20.602 --> 01:12:22.137
WITH THREE I'D SAY THERE'S THREE
01:12:22.204 --> 01:12:23.405
DIFFERENT THINGS FIRST FROM
01:12:23.472 --> 01:12:24.940
THEIR BEEN RESOLUTIONS THAT HAVE
01:12:25.007 --> 01:12:27.376
PASSED AT EITHER KEYBOARDS OR
01:12:27.443 --> 01:12:30.012
CONVENTIONS FOR EXAMPLE THE THE
01:12:30.079 --> 01:12:31.580
PRESCRIPTION ON DIRECT
01:12:31.647 --> 01:12:33.482
CONTRIBUTIONS FROM OIL COMPANIES
01:12:33.549 --> 01:12:34.016
THAT WAS.
01:12:34.083 --> 01:12:35.451
YOU KNOW THAT WAS OUR FAIR
01:12:35.517 --> 01:12:36.418
ENVIRONMENTAL CHAIR ARE ALL
01:12:36.485 --> 01:12:38.721
MILLER ORGANIZING DIE DELEGATES
01:12:38.787 --> 01:12:39.955
ON THE FLOOR AND WAS A VOTE.
01:12:40.022 --> 01:12:41.523
THE MOST FINANCING THE PLATFORM
01:12:41.590 --> 01:12:42.825
NOW I'M NOT A FLAT NOT THE
01:12:42.891 --> 01:12:44.293
PLATFORM IS A RENTAL STANDS A
01:12:44.359 --> 01:12:45.094
RESOLUTION ADOPTED AS I
01:12:45.160 --> 01:12:46.895
MENTIONED OUT ITS CO EQUAL IN
01:12:46.962 --> 01:12:50.265
TERMS OF CERTAIN LEGISLATIVE
01:12:50.332 --> 01:12:52.234
POWER WITHIN AN ORGANIZATION --
01:12:52.301 --> 01:12:53.669
AND THEN FOR EXAMPLE ARE A
01:12:53.736 --> 01:12:54.870
PRESCRIPTION ON PROHIBITION ON
01:12:54.937 --> 01:12:56.472
TAKING MONEY FROM.
01:12:56.538 --> 01:12:59.942
THAT WAS JUST OF THE OFFICERS --
01:13:00.008 --> 01:13:01.510
THAT WEAVES A CODE DECORATIVE
01:13:01.577 --> 01:13:03.412
COMMITTEE SORT OF THE OF THE
01:13:03.479 --> 01:13:04.546
STATEWIDE OFFICE SOME SORT OF
01:13:04.613 --> 01:13:05.814
CASE STATEMENT THAT WE WILL BE
01:13:05.881 --> 01:13:07.049
CO DEFYING --
01:13:07.116 --> 01:13:08.617
IN RESOLUTION --
01:13:08.684 --> 01:13:10.285
AND THEN THE THIRD THING IS THAT
01:13:10.352 --> 01:13:13.122
WE HAVE BUT I JUST FORMED AA BUT
01:13:13.188 --> 01:13:15.257
I CAMPAIGN FINANCE WORKING GROUP.
01:13:15.324 --> 01:13:16.725
NOT WHERE WE'VE INVITED --
01:13:16.792 --> 01:13:18.227
LEGISLATIVE LEADERSHIP AND
01:13:18.293 --> 01:13:19.695
GRASSROOTS ACTIVISTS AND CLEAN
01:13:19.762 --> 01:13:20.729
MONEY ACTIVISTS TO TALK MORE
01:13:20.796 --> 01:13:23.065
POLITICALLY EXACTLY ABOUT HOW WE
01:13:23.132 --> 01:13:24.600
CAN DEAL WITH THINGS LIKE.
01:13:24.666 --> 01:13:26.535
THE THE YOU KNOW HOW TO TRACE
01:13:26.602 --> 01:13:27.736
THE ORIGIN OF FUNDS THAT HAVE
01:13:27.803 --> 01:13:28.904
BEEN GIVEN TO ONE COMMITTEE AND
01:13:28.971 --> 01:13:30.139
THEN ANOTHER COMMITTEE EXACT
01:13:30.205 --> 01:13:30.939
EXACTLY THE THINGS THAT HAVE
01:13:31.006 --> 01:13:32.574
BEEN RAISED --
01:13:32.641 --> 01:13:33.375
WE WANT TO HAVE THAT DISCUSSION
01:13:33.442 --> 01:13:34.843
WELL I'M THAT DISCUSSION IS
01:13:34.910 --> 01:13:35.844
MOVING FORWARD --
01:13:35.911 --> 01:13:38.413
BUT SO FAR IT'S HAPPENED BOTH BY
01:13:38.480 --> 01:13:38.881
EXECUTIVE DECISION AND
01:13:38.947 --> 01:13:41.083
RESOLUTION GOT IT OKAY THANK YOU
01:13:41.150 --> 01:13:44.586
THAT'S HELPFUL --
01:13:44.653 --> 01:13:47.289
YEAH YOU KNOW I I SEE.
01:13:47.356 --> 01:13:50.759
I SEE THE THE ABILITY.
01:13:50.826 --> 01:13:55.998
FOR A THE CAUCUS POTENTIALLY --
01:13:56.064 --> 01:13:58.033
TO FIND ITSELF IN A TOUGH SPOT
01:13:58.100 --> 01:13:59.568
FOR INSTANCE IF IT WERE TO TAKE
01:13:59.635 --> 01:14:01.570
MONEY THAT THE PARTY WASN'T
01:14:01.637 --> 01:14:03.505
TAKING RIGHT I MEAN THAT'S IF
01:14:03.572 --> 01:14:05.040
THIS BILL BECAME LAW YOU COULD
01:14:05.107 --> 01:14:06.375
FIND YOURSELF IN A SITUATION
01:14:06.442 --> 01:14:07.643
WHERE.
01:14:07.709 --> 01:14:09.945
LEGISLATIVE LEADERSHIP IS --
01:14:10.012 --> 01:14:11.647
PARTICIPATING IN FUNDRAISING
01:14:11.713 --> 01:14:13.749
THAT THE PARTIES IS NOW AND I
01:14:13.816 --> 01:14:14.650
YEAH.
01:14:14.716 --> 01:14:15.517
BATTLE BE A FIGHT I WOULD
01:14:15.584 --> 01:14:17.386
IMAGINE --
01:14:17.452 --> 01:14:18.954
WILLIS AND I YOU KNOW.
01:14:19.021 --> 01:14:20.622
I DIDN'T IF THEY'RE MORE ISSUES
01:14:20.689 --> 01:14:22.024
THAT NEEDED TO SORT OF BE
01:14:22.090 --> 01:14:24.026
LITIGATED HERE I I DO WANT TO
01:14:24.092 --> 01:14:26.395
GIVE A CHANCE TO HEAR THOSE OUT --
01:14:26.461 --> 01:14:28.730
DE IF YOU'LL INDULGE ME ASSEMBLY
01:14:28.797 --> 01:14:31.400
MEMBER WOMAN FOR A YEAR MISTER
01:14:31.466 --> 01:14:32.634
ALL -- AS
01:14:32.701 --> 01:14:33.869
SOMEONE WHO WAS AT COUNTY
01:14:33.936 --> 01:14:35.771
CENTRAL COMMITTEE CHAIR FOR TEN
01:14:35.838 --> 01:14:37.806
YEARS AND FOUND COOPERATED WITH
01:14:37.873 --> 01:14:39.341
THE WHO ARE BOTH ASSEMBLY
01:14:39.408 --> 01:14:40.542
DEMOCRATS AND THE SENATE
01:14:40.609 --> 01:14:42.244
DEMOCRATS ELECTORAL PROGRAM
01:14:42.311 --> 01:14:43.846
UNDER SEVERAL.
01:14:43.912 --> 01:14:45.347
SPEAKERS AND PRO TEM'S YOU KNOW
01:14:45.414 --> 01:14:46.348
THAT THERE IS A VERY DIFFERENT
01:14:46.415 --> 01:14:48.217
WAY THAT IT'S THAT THAT PROGRAM
01:14:48.283 --> 01:14:49.918
IS THOUGHT ABOUT BY THE PARTY
01:14:49.985 --> 01:14:52.187
FOLKS AND BY THE LEGISLATORS AND
01:14:52.254 --> 01:14:52.821
THAT'S THAT.
01:14:52.888 --> 01:14:53.989
YOU KNOW A LOT OF TIMES THE
01:14:54.056 --> 01:14:55.557
LEGISLATIVE LEADERSHIP SEES IT
01:14:55.624 --> 01:14:56.758
AS A PASS THROUGH THE WAY THAT
01:14:56.825 --> 01:14:58.093
WE'VE CONSERVE DESCRIBED IT.
01:14:58.160 --> 01:14:59.194
YOU CAN GIVE A BUNCH OF MONEY TO
01:14:59.261 --> 01:15:00.195
THIS COUNTY COMMITTEE AND THEN
01:15:00.262 --> 01:15:02.030
THEY MAKE CONTRIBUTIONS ONTO A
01:15:02.097 --> 01:15:02.564
CAMPAIGN.
01:15:02.631 --> 01:15:04.433
BUT IMPRACTICALITY ESPECIALLY
01:15:04.500 --> 01:15:05.167
OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS SINCE
01:15:05.234 --> 01:15:07.302
THE PARTY HAS BEEN MORE AND MORE
01:15:07.369 --> 01:15:08.770
INFLUENCED BY GRASSROOTS
01:15:08.837 --> 01:15:11.340
ACTIVISTS AND AND AND MORE
01:15:11.406 --> 01:15:15.510
ENGAGED ON THE I'M YOU KNOW I
01:15:15.577 --> 01:15:17.246
WAS ABLE TO TELL BOTH THE SENATE
01:15:17.312 --> 01:15:18.914
AND ASSEMBLY LEADERSHIPS THAT.
01:15:18.981 --> 01:15:20.148
LIKE IN SANTA BARBARA WE'RE NOT
01:15:20.215 --> 01:15:21.550
GONNA ACCEPT ANY OIL MONEY WAY
01:15:21.617 --> 01:15:24.019
BEFORE THE STATE PARTY TOOK THAT
01:15:24.086 --> 01:15:24.653
UP BECAUSE OBVIOUSLY WE'RE SANTA
01:15:24.720 --> 01:15:25.420
BARBARA --
01:15:25.487 --> 01:15:26.622
BUT WE WOULDN'T TAKE MONEY FROM
01:15:26.688 --> 01:15:27.923
ANY EMPLOYER THAT WAS HAVING
01:15:27.990 --> 01:15:29.324
PROBLEM WITH THEIR UNION YOU
01:15:29.391 --> 01:15:30.525
NICE WORKFORCE IT'S ADDRESS.
01:15:30.592 --> 01:15:32.794
SO SO EVEN UNDER THE CURRENT
01:15:32.861 --> 01:15:34.796
SYSTEM THERE IS FAT
01:15:34.863 --> 01:15:36.298
ORGANIZATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY
01:15:36.365 --> 01:15:38.400
AND BECAUSE IT ISN'T TO PASS
01:15:38.467 --> 01:15:39.534
THROUGH AND THE LAW IS WRITTEN
01:15:39.601 --> 01:15:40.736
VERY EXPLICITLY TO MAKE SURE
01:15:40.802 --> 01:15:42.271
IT'S NOT A PASS THROUGH OR A
01:15:42.337 --> 01:15:43.906
QUID PRO QUO OR WHATEVER.
01:15:43.972 --> 01:15:45.440
WE DON'T MAKE THE SAME AMOUNT OF
01:15:45.507 --> 01:15:46.575
DONATIONS OUT OF THE
01:15:46.642 --> 01:15:48.377
CONTRIBUTIONS THAT WE THAT WERE
01:15:48.443 --> 01:15:50.078
SOLICITED BY LEADERS INTO OUR
01:15:50.145 --> 01:15:50.746
COMMITTEE.
01:15:50.812 --> 01:15:52.281
THAT DIFFERENCE WHICH SOME
01:15:52.347 --> 01:15:53.282
PEOPLE CYNICALLY CALL IT
01:15:53.348 --> 01:15:55.550
SURCHARGE THAT DIFFERENCE IS
01:15:55.617 --> 01:15:57.753
WHAT WE SPEND ON INFRASTRUCTURE
01:15:57.819 --> 01:15:59.755
CLUB DEVELOPMENT ELECTING PEOPLE
01:15:59.821 --> 01:16:01.290
AT THE GRASSROOTS THE DOWN THE
01:16:01.356 --> 01:16:02.624
TICKET ELECTING PEOPLE EGGMAN
01:16:02.691 --> 01:16:04.059
MEEKLY MOAN TO THE SCHOOL BOARD
01:16:04.126 --> 01:16:04.860
WHO THEN GOES ON TO BE AN
01:16:04.927 --> 01:16:05.928
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
01:16:05.994 --> 01:16:07.829
RIGHT THAT IT'S NOT WE'RE NOT
01:16:07.896 --> 01:16:09.331
JUST A BANK ACCOUNT WEARING
01:16:09.398 --> 01:16:11.300
ORGANIZATION OF PEOPLE.
01:16:11.366 --> 01:16:12.734
AND IT'S VERY DISTURBING AFTER
01:16:12.801 --> 01:16:14.503
BEING TOLD BY LEADERS AND ALL
01:16:14.569 --> 01:16:16.672
AND THE AUTHOR BEFORE THAT HE
01:16:16.738 --> 01:16:17.472
WERE JUST SETTING UP THESE
01:16:17.539 --> 01:16:19.308
COMMITTEES WERE STILL OF COURSE
01:16:19.374 --> 01:16:19.942
GOING TO WORK WITH TH PARTY BUT
01:16:20.008 --> 01:16:20.709
NOW HEARING.
01:16:20.776 --> 01:16:22.077
HEY THIS IS A BETTER SYSTEM THAN
01:16:22.144 --> 01:16:25.013
THE CURRENT SYSTEM AND WE'RE
01:16:25.080 --> 01:16:26.214
GOING TO REPLACE IT.
01:16:26.281 --> 01:16:27.849
IS EVEN MORE DISTURBING IF
01:16:27.916 --> 01:16:28.750
THERE'S A PROBLEM WITH
01:16:28.817 --> 01:16:29.718
TRANSPARENCY IN THE CURRENT
01:16:29.785 --> 01:16:31.253
SYSTEM LET'S TALK ABOUT THAT
01:16:31.320 --> 01:16:32.487
LET'S FIX THIS.
01:16:32.554 --> 01:16:34.556
PLEASE DON'T MOVE THIS BILL
01:16:34.623 --> 01:16:36.224
FORWARD SO WE CAN HAVE THAT
01:16:36.291 --> 01:16:38.060
CONVERSATION AND NOT BE TALKING
01:16:38.126 --> 01:16:39.828
ABOUT REPLACING THE CURRENT
01:16:39.895 --> 01:16:40.963
ACCOUNTABLE DEMOCRATIC
01:16:41.029 --> 01:16:42.431
PARTICIPATORY STRUCTURE WITH THE
01:16:42.497 --> 01:16:43.532
TOP DOWN [inaudible]
01:16:43.598 --> 01:16:46.735
ONE OKAY.
01:16:46.802 --> 01:16:50.739
THANK YOU MISTER LAMB OFFER.
01:16:50.806 --> 01:16:52.741
A WE CAN'T DO APPLAUSE BUT THANK
01:16:52.808 --> 01:16:56.111
YOU FOR YOUR PLATE HAND WAVING --
01:16:56.178 --> 01:16:58.347
COMPELLING ARGUMENTS --
01:16:58.413 --> 01:16:59.948
I DO WANT TO GIVE THE AUTHOR A
01:17:00.015 --> 01:17:01.583
CHANCE TO RESPOND IN HIS CLOTHES
01:17:01.650 --> 01:17:02.985
BUT MEMBERS IF YOU HAD OTHER
01:17:03.051 --> 01:17:04.486
FURTHER.
01:17:04.553 --> 01:17:06.188
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS NOW'S THE
01:17:06.254 --> 01:17:09.691
TIME YEAH CENTER HERTZBERG.
01:17:09.758 --> 01:17:12.227
YEAH I ALREADY OWNED JOINTURE
01:17:12.294 --> 01:17:13.495
KNOWN FULL DISCLOSURE OF THE
01:17:13.562 --> 01:17:15.263
PARTY CHAIRS A CONSTITUENT OF
01:17:15.330 --> 01:17:17.532
MINE LIVES NOT A MILE DOWN THE
01:17:17.599 --> 01:17:19.935
STREET IN MY HOUSE. FIVE
01:17:20.002 --> 01:17:21.269
DIFFERENT ABOUT THAT MY PART
01:17:21.336 --> 01:17:22.704
INTIMATE PRESSURE INHERENT HERE
01:17:22.771 --> 01:17:23.972
TELLING ME IN THE MIDDLE THE
01:17:24.039 --> 01:17:25.140
PARTY CHAIR YOU KNOW THAT EXISTS
01:17:25.207 --> 01:17:27.109
BUT AS WELL AS THE CONTROLLER
01:17:27.175 --> 01:17:30.045
BEING MY BEST FRIEND.
01:17:30.112 --> 01:17:33.115
BUT THE THE IT YOU DON'T LET ME
01:17:33.181 --> 01:17:34.449
SAY SOME IS WHAT I THINK WE
01:17:34.516 --> 01:17:35.851
SHOULD DO TODAY IN MY JUDGMENT
01:17:35.917 --> 01:17:38.387
TAUGHT LISTEN TO THIS.
01:17:38.453 --> 01:17:39.321
THERE'S SOME HOLE THERE'S A
01:17:39.388 --> 01:17:40.956
PRETTY BIG HOLES IN THIS THING
01:17:41.023 --> 01:17:41.757
ONE IS IS CERTAINLY THE ISSUE OF
01:17:41.823 --> 01:17:44.793
TIMING. TO WHICH THE ISSUE I
01:17:44.860 --> 01:17:46.194
THINK THAT BUT THE MECHANICAL
01:17:46.261 --> 01:17:47.529
ISSUE AFFECTING BROUGH COUNTY
01:17:47.596 --> 01:17:49.564
COMMITTEES ALIKE. THREE I THINK
01:17:49.631 --> 01:17:50.766
THAT THERE COULD BE SOME FURTHER
01:17:50.832 --> 01:17:52.000
DISCUSSION CONCERNING DISCLOSURE
01:17:52.067 --> 01:17:53.802
WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE.
01:17:53.869 --> 01:17:55.937
I I YOU KNOW.
01:17:56.004 --> 01:17:56.805
MISTER MULLIN IS A GREAT
01:17:56.872 --> 01:17:58.807
LEGISLATOR.
01:17:58.874 --> 01:18:01.143
HE'S A GREAT LEGISLATOR I TRUST
01:18:01.209 --> 01:18:02.244
HIM.
01:18:02.310 --> 01:18:03.245
HE WHICH HE DID THIS YOU ARE THE
01:18:03.311 --> 01:18:04.846
DISH WITH HIM ON A BILL WE CAN
01:18:04.913 --> 01:18:06.648
ALWAYS DISAGREE ON A BILL BUT
01:18:06.715 --> 01:18:08.050
USE STRAIGHT UP THESE HONORABLE
01:18:08.116 --> 01:18:09.584
HE'S COMPLETELY TRUSTED AND I
01:18:09.651 --> 01:18:10.952
TRUST THEM.
01:18:11.019 --> 01:18:13.088
AND SO MY THINKING IS WE DO HAVE
01:18:13.155 --> 01:18:15.357
UNTIL THE END OF THIS WEEK TO
01:18:15.424 --> 01:18:16.625
FIGURE OUT IF THERE'S A SOLUTION
01:18:16.691 --> 01:18:18.193
HERE.
01:18:18.260 --> 01:18:19.895
BOB AND THE SINGLE IN IN THIS
01:18:19.961 --> 01:18:21.763
TIME OF ALL IN THE LEGISLATURE
01:18:21.830 --> 01:18:23.665
THESE ON LIFE TIMES TO UP. TO DO
01:18:23.732 --> 01:18:25.500
THIS AND AND I I THINK WE SHOULD
01:18:25.567 --> 01:18:26.968
GIVE THEM THAT SHOT AND I WHAT
01:18:27.035 --> 01:18:28.370
I'M SUGGESTING.
01:18:28.437 --> 01:18:29.671
AND I THINK WHAT I'M GONNA DO IS
01:18:29.738 --> 01:18:32.040
I LISTEN TO EVERYBODY HERE TODAY.
01:18:32.107 --> 01:18:33.408
HE IS TO KIND OF TAKE THE SAME
01:18:33.475 --> 01:18:34.609
ADMONITION THAT SENATOR LABOR
01:18:34.676 --> 01:18:35.544
DID WHICH IS [inaudible]
01:18:35.610 --> 01:18:37.212
BOMB.
01:18:37.279 --> 01:18:38.713
SAY THAT FOR PURPOSES OF GIVING
01:18:38.780 --> 01:18:39.815
HIM AN OPPORTUNITY TO SEE IF WE
01:18:39.881 --> 01:18:41.149
CAN REACH AN ACCOMMODATION WITH
01:18:41.216 --> 01:18:42.918
EVERYBODY REACH REACHES THE
01:18:42.984 --> 01:18:43.718
ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN FLUSHED
01:18:43.785 --> 01:18:45.187
OUT I TOOK ALL THE NOTES OF WHAT
01:18:45.253 --> 01:18:46.354
EVERYBODY SAID.
01:18:46.421 --> 01:18:47.689
AND SEE IF THERE'S A WAY TO DO
01:18:47.756 --> 01:18:48.690
IT THERE'S NOT YOU GOTTA GET
01:18:48.757 --> 01:18:50.258
VOTES THE FLOOR YOU GOTTA GO TO
01:18:50.325 --> 01:18:51.626
APPROPRIATIONS OF THIS IS NOT
01:18:51.693 --> 01:18:52.794
OVER STILL GOT TO GO.
01:18:52.861 --> 01:18:54.229
CONCURRENCE IS A WHOLE BUNCH OF
01:18:54.296 --> 01:18:55.597
STUFF THAT HAS TO HAPPEN THAT
01:18:55.664 --> 01:18:57.666
ENGAGES THE PROCESS AT THE END
01:18:57.732 --> 01:18:58.767
OFTHE DAY YOU COULD SAY WHAT
01:18:58.834 --> 01:19:01.036
YOU WANT BUT EVERYBODY OF ALL
01:19:01.103 --> 01:19:01.937
HUNDRED TWENTY MEMBERS WE STEP
01:19:02.003 --> 01:19:05.107
ON TWENTY COMPLEMENT YEAH. ONE
01:19:05.173 --> 01:19:08.176
HUNDRED TWENTY WE DO ACTUALLY A
01:19:08.243 --> 01:19:08.777
HUNDRED TWENTY PEOPLE AND LET
01:19:08.844 --> 01:19:09.711
THEM MAKE A VOTE IN THE WHAT'S
01:19:09.778 --> 01:19:11.213
THE CASE SO I'M NOT GOING.
01:19:11.279 --> 01:19:12.881
TO I'M KIND OF ON THE FENCE AS
01:19:12.948 --> 01:19:14.116
TO WHAT TO DO THIS I THINK IF
01:19:14.182 --> 01:19:15.517
SOME OF THESE CHANGES ARE MADE
01:19:15.584 --> 01:19:16.384
I'M NOT GONNA VOTE FOR THIS ON
01:19:16.451 --> 01:19:18.120
THE FOOR NOT IN APPROPRIATIONS
01:19:18.186 --> 01:19:18.587
COMMITTEE.
01:19:18.653 --> 01:19:20.355
BUT I DO THINK IT'S FAIR TO
01:19:20.422 --> 01:19:21.823
MISTER MARLAND. TO GIVE THEM
01:19:21.890 --> 01:19:23.692
EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO TRY TO WORK
01:19:23.758 --> 01:19:24.860
OUT SOMETHING IF IT'S HUMANLY
01:19:24.926 --> 01:19:26.528
POSSIBLE HE'S OPEN MINDED HIS
01:19:26.595 --> 01:19:28.463
HEART'S IN THE RIGHT PLACE HE'S
01:19:28.530 --> 01:19:29.831
HELD EVERY PIECE OF LEGISLATION.
01:19:29.898 --> 01:19:32.033
STUFF WE DID LAST YEAR ON AND ON
01:19:32.100 --> 01:19:33.368
TRANSPARENCY STUFF WE CAN HELP
01:19:33.435 --> 01:19:35.604
YOU GET THE VOTES AND MAKE THAT
01:19:35.670 --> 01:19:37.405
STUFF HAPPENED SO I I'M GONNA
01:19:37.472 --> 01:19:39.174
I'M GONNA GIVE YOU A SHOT TO TRY
01:19:39.241 --> 01:19:40.342
TO DO IT BUT YOU KNOW WITH THE
01:19:40.408 --> 01:19:41.710
ADMONITION THAT.
01:19:41.776 --> 01:19:42.777
IT'S NOT DONE THAT THERE'S A
01:19:42.844 --> 01:19:43.812
CHALLENGES THAT I THINK
01:19:43.879 --> 01:19:45.547
EVERYBODY RAISED HERE TODAY BUT
01:19:45.614 --> 01:19:46.815
I THINK IT'S A FAIR AND
01:19:46.882 --> 01:19:48.116
APPROPRIATE THING.
01:19:48.183 --> 01:19:49.918
BUT TO LINK TO LINK YOU CAN KEEP
01:19:49.985 --> 01:19:51.520
GOING GIVEN EVERY CHART TO SEE
01:19:51.586 --> 01:19:52.621
IF WE CAN COME UP WITH A
01:19:52.687 --> 01:19:54.623
COMBINATION. TO TO MAKE IT WORK
01:19:54.689 --> 01:19:55.857
I THINK THAT LEADERSHIP IN BOTH
01:19:55.924 --> 01:19:58.193
HOUSES A REASONABLE TO DEAL WITH.
01:19:58.260 --> 01:19:59.361
AND I DO THINK THAT THERE'S
01:19:59.427 --> 01:20:00.996
INTELLIGENT ARGUMENTS ON BOTH
01:20:01.062 --> 01:20:04.065
SIDES SO I WENT VOTE FOR IT --
01:20:04.132 --> 01:20:07.435
IT WOULD BECAUSE I CONFIDENCE.
01:20:07.502 --> 01:20:08.937
I THINK THAT WE SHOULD RUN IT
01:20:09.004 --> 01:20:10.272
LIVE GOT WHAT IT TO THE GROUND
01:20:10.338 --> 01:20:11.573
IT REQUIRES TWO THIRDS VOTES
01:20:11.640 --> 01:20:13.375
ANYWAY CORRECT. TO GET OUT OF
01:20:13.441 --> 01:20:14.843
BOTH HOUSES AND I THINK THAT IS
01:20:14.910 --> 01:20:16.411
A LOT OF PEOPLE WE'VE BEEN
01:20:16.478 --> 01:20:18.580
TALKING ABOUT A LOT BUT IT OUR
01:20:18.647 --> 01:20:20.115
CAUCUS IN THERE'S A LOT OF IT IS
01:20:20.182 --> 01:20:21.049
INTEREST BUT THERE'S A LOT YOU
01:20:21.116 --> 01:20:22.417
KNOW LIKE EVERYBODY'S FOCUS ON
01:20:22.484 --> 01:20:23.218
IT WOULD BE PEOPLE IN BOTH
01:20:23.285 --> 01:20:23.985
PARTIES.
01:20:24.052 --> 01:20:25.687
DONE A VERY VERY GOOD JOB AT OF
01:20:25.754 --> 01:20:26.855
THE HUNDREDS OF BILLS THAT ARE
01:20:26.922 --> 01:20:27.989
PENDING BEFORE US PUTTING THIS
01:20:28.056 --> 01:20:30.225
OFF THE TOP OF THE LIST IN TERMS
01:20:30.292 --> 01:20:31.226
OF MAKING SURE WE THINK ABOUT IT.
01:20:31.293 --> 01:20:32.294
SO.
01:20:32.360 --> 01:20:32.928
THAT'S WHAT I'LL BE DOING TODAY
01:20:32.994 --> 01:20:34.162
MISTER CHAIRMAN.
01:20:34.229 --> 01:20:36.765
MISTER VICE CHAIR.
01:20:36.831 --> 01:20:38.767
AND I LISTENED TO ALL THE
01:20:38.833 --> 01:20:40.435
ARGUMENTS VERY CLOSELY
01:20:40.502 --> 01:20:40.735
[inaudible]
01:20:40.802 --> 01:20:44.206
AND TWO MEMBERS WHO REFERRED TO
01:20:44.272 --> 01:20:46.208
CHANGES THAT NEED TO OCCUR BUT I
01:20:46.274 --> 01:20:46.841
HAVEN'T HEARD WITH THOSE CHANGES
01:20:46.908 --> 01:20:48.376
ARE.
01:20:48.443 --> 01:20:50.779
IN OUR VIEW INTERESTED NO.
01:20:50.845 --> 01:20:51.379
WHAT THOSE CHANGES WOULD LOOK
01:20:51.446 --> 01:20:52.514
LIKE?
01:20:52.581 --> 01:20:54.149
I HAVE MOVING FORWARD IF
01:20:54.216 --> 01:20:55.784
SOMEBODY HAS AN IDEA MAYBE
01:20:55.850 --> 01:20:58.486
SOMEBODY MENTIONED THOSE CHANGES.
01:20:58.553 --> 01:21:02.157
BY I DIDN'T HEAR THEM AND SO IF
01:21:02.224 --> 01:21:03.892
THERE ARE CHANGES THAT WERE
01:21:03.959 --> 01:21:06.494
THINKING IN TERMS OF IF YOU
01:21:06.561 --> 01:21:09.431
WOULDN'T MIND OR IF ANYBODY.
01:21:09.497 --> 01:21:12.434
WHO SPOKE KNEW WHAT THEY WERE
01:21:12.500 --> 01:21:12.734
[inaudible]
01:21:12.801 --> 01:21:14.736
I PER.
01:21:14.803 --> 01:21:15.070
IS THE CHAIR.
01:21:15.136 --> 01:21:16.705
SHORT.
01:21:16.771 --> 01:21:18.006
I DON'T KNOW OF ANY SPECIFIC
01:21:18.073 --> 01:21:19.374
CHANGES WHEN I TALK ABOUT
01:21:19.441 --> 01:21:20.575
CHANGES MY THOUGHT IS WE MIGHT
01:21:20.642 --> 01:21:22.110
BE ABLE TO WORK WITH THE
01:21:22.177 --> 01:21:23.678
OPPOSITION TO FIND OUT IF WE CAN
01:21:23.745 --> 01:21:24.879
GET THEM TO A PLACE WHERE THEY
01:21:24.946 --> 01:21:27.115
WOULD EITHER NOT OPPOSE THE BILL.
01:21:27.182 --> 01:21:28.850
OR EVEN SUPPORT THE BILL SO I
01:21:28.917 --> 01:21:30.518
DON'T HAVE ANYTHING YOU KNOW IN
01:21:30.585 --> 01:21:32.187
MY BACK POCKET RAY TO SAY LET'S
01:21:32.254 --> 01:21:33.955
DO THIS BUT YOU KNOW.
01:21:34.022 --> 01:21:35.824
AS YOU KNOW AS A LEGISLATOR WERE
01:21:35.890 --> 01:21:37.359
ALWAYS LOOKING FOR WAYS WHERE WE
01:21:37.425 --> 01:21:40.495
CAN COME TOGETHER VERSES NOT.
01:21:40.562 --> 01:21:42.230
AND HAVE BEEN COMING FROM A
01:21:42.297 --> 01:21:43.999
POSITION OF OPPOSITIONS WHAT I
01:21:44.065 --> 01:21:45.900
MEANT.
01:21:45.967 --> 01:21:48.403
MR IS SO MISTER RICHARD YOU KNOW.
01:21:48.470 --> 01:21:50.205
I'M NOT GOING TO BE SUPPORTING
01:21:50.272 --> 01:21:51.006
THE BILL --
01:21:51.072 --> 01:21:53.775
TODAY AND I CAN'T I CAN'T FROM A
01:21:53.842 --> 01:21:55.710
PROCESS PERSPECTIVE I HAVE TO
01:21:55.777 --> 01:21:56.978
BUILD SOME PRINCIPLES HERE'S THE
01:21:57.045 --> 01:21:59.848
CHAIR AND SAY IF THIS IS IN.
01:21:59.914 --> 01:22:02.751
FULLY BAKED IN MY VIEW OR ALL
01:22:02.817 --> 01:22:05.387
THE WAY THEY'RE GANNETT AND I
01:22:05.453 --> 01:22:07.088
HAVE TO MAKE THAT CLEAR BUT JUST
01:22:07.155 --> 01:22:08.857
TO TRY TO SYNTHESIZE I GUESS FOR
01:22:08.923 --> 01:22:11.126
THE ISSUE SAID.
01:22:11.192 --> 01:22:14.195
THERE WAS DISCUSSION ABOUT --
01:22:14.262 --> 01:22:16.298
NOT THAT IT THAT OVERALL LIMITS
01:22:16.364 --> 01:22:19.301
RATE SO THAT THIRTY SIX FIVE
01:22:19.367 --> 01:22:21.369
TIMES THAT --
01:22:21.436 --> 01:22:23.004
FOR IS IN EXCESS OF WHAT THE
01:22:23.071 --> 01:22:24.939
PARTY HAS IT TODAY ANOTHER THAT
01:22:25.006 --> 01:22:26.474
YOU TALK ABOUT DEMOCRATIC PARTY
01:22:26.541 --> 01:22:27.776
CHANGES TO WHICH REALLY NOT
01:22:27.842 --> 01:22:28.777
PARTICULARLY GERMANE TO THIS
01:22:28.843 --> 01:22:29.811
BILL SO THAT'S SOMETHING WE
01:22:29.878 --> 01:22:31.146
COULD PROBABLY.
01:22:31.212 --> 01:22:35.850
LOOK INTO OUTSIDE IS A PROCESS --
01:22:35.917 --> 01:22:36.818
BUT ASSEMBLY OR I MEAN IT'S YOUR
01:22:36.885 --> 01:22:38.853
BILL SO THAT YOU KNOW I I DON'T
01:22:38.920 --> 01:22:40.789
WANT TO IMPOSE ANY OTHER.
01:22:40.855 --> 01:22:43.658
POINTS ON YOU OR OR PRESUME YOUR
01:22:43.725 --> 01:22:45.727
INTENT HERE BUT BUT I WOULD
01:22:45.794 --> 01:22:47.696
OFFER IT TO YOU TO CLOSE AND
01:22:47.762 --> 01:22:48.563
PERHAPS IN YOUR CLOTHES YOU
01:22:48.630 --> 01:22:49.064
COULD.
01:22:49.130 --> 01:22:51.766
FIT ARTICULATE IF YOU SHOULD THE
01:22:51.833 --> 01:22:53.034
BILL MOVE.
01:22:53.101 --> 01:22:56.137
FOR A WHAT YOUR INTENTIONS ARE
01:22:56.204 --> 01:22:57.939
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
01:22:58.006 --> 01:22:58.973
OF FOR THE ROBUST DISCUSSION I
01:22:59.040 --> 01:23:00.408
WANT TO THANK --
01:23:00.475 --> 01:23:02.777
THE ADVOCATES PA WHO TESTIFIED
01:23:02.844 --> 01:23:03.978
ALONE I THINK IRAQ AND COULD
01:23:04.045 --> 01:23:05.980
WORK AT THE PARTY --
01:23:06.047 --> 01:23:08.249
SO I AM OPEN TO REFINING THIS
01:23:08.316 --> 01:23:10.251
BILL IF THERE ARE ISSUES THAT
01:23:10.318 --> 01:23:12.020
CAN BE ADDRESS THAT CONCERN IS
01:23:12.087 --> 01:23:12.687
WE ARE.
01:23:12.754 --> 01:23:14.122
UP AGAINST A LITTLE BIT OF A
01:23:14.189 --> 01:23:16.291
WINDOW IN THAT THE BILL NEEDS ME
01:23:16.358 --> 01:23:19.027
IN CRANFORD TWELVE DAYS --
01:23:19.094 --> 01:23:19.661
AND THE VERSION OF A POLITICAL
01:23:19.728 --> 01:23:20.929
REFORM ACT --
01:23:20.995 --> 01:23:22.697
AND OUR OUR SESSION ADJOURNS AT
01:23:22.764 --> 01:23:24.332
THE END OF THE MONTH SO IS OF A
01:23:24.399 --> 01:23:26.601
RELATIVELY --
01:23:26.668 --> 01:23:28.103
A TIGHT WINDOW BUT THIS BILL
01:23:28.169 --> 01:23:29.437
MANY [inaudible]
01:23:29.504 --> 01:23:31.639
FORUMS.
01:23:31.706 --> 01:23:35.176
AND THEY PARTICULAR I AM --
01:23:35.243 --> 01:23:37.579
I WANT TO BE SENSITIVE TO THE
01:23:37.645 --> 01:23:38.980
SMALLER --
01:23:39.047 --> 01:23:41.649
CENTRAL COMMITTEE STUFF LOCAL
01:23:41.716 --> 01:23:43.585
COUNTY BY COUNTY ACTIVISTS.
01:23:43.651 --> 01:23:45.520
BOB MANY YOU WHO MANY OF WHOM
01:23:45.587 --> 01:23:46.888
ARE LOOKING AT THIS SAYING OKAY
01:23:46.955 --> 01:23:48.423
THIS IS JUST MORE PAPERWORK
01:23:48.490 --> 01:23:49.791
MISTER CHAIR I BELIEVE IT WOULD
01:23:49.858 --> 01:23:50.592
HAVE LEADERS MISTER SHARON ON
01:23:50.658 --> 01:23:52.093
SARS MISDEMEANOR HERTZBERG
01:23:52.160 --> 01:23:53.061
TALKING ABOUT.
01:23:53.128 --> 01:23:54.396
THE VOLUMES OF PAPERWORK AND
01:23:54.462 --> 01:23:56.598
SOMEBODY WHO IS ENGAGED IN THIS
01:23:56.664 --> 01:23:58.700
SYSTEM FILLING OUT PAPERWORK I
01:23:58.767 --> 01:24:00.168
DON'T WANT TO CREATE UNNECESSARY.
01:24:00.235 --> 01:24:02.303
UP PAPERWORK ABOUT FOR A FOR
01:24:02.370 --> 01:24:04.472
SMALL -- YOU
01:24:04.539 --> 01:24:06.107
KNOW VERY MODESTLY STRUCTURED
01:24:06.174 --> 01:24:08.009
CENTRAL COMMITTEES I THINK SOME
01:24:08.076 --> 01:24:10.178
OF THE LARGER CENTRAL COMMITTEES --
01:24:10.245 --> 01:24:12.013
A REALLY HAVE A PRETTY ROBUST OF
01:24:12.080 --> 01:24:13.681
FUND RAISING A MECHANISM AND
01:24:13.748 --> 01:24:15.550
MAYBE HAVE THE CAPACITY TO DO
01:24:15.617 --> 01:24:16.918
SOME OF THE REPORTING SELF.
01:24:16.985 --> 01:24:19.053
I WILL CERTAINLY LOOK AT THAT
01:24:19.120 --> 01:24:22.690
ISSUE CALM AND WE ARE ARE GOING --
01:24:22.757 --> 01:24:23.992
TO SYNTHESIZE THE DISCUSSION
01:24:24.058 --> 01:24:25.794
HERE TODAY I WOULD LOVE NOTHING
01:24:25.860 --> 01:24:27.562
MORE THAN THE GOOD GOVERNMENT
01:24:27.629 --> 01:24:28.730
GROUPS -- TO
01:24:28.797 --> 01:24:29.731
WHICH I'VE BEEN ALIGNED IN A
01:24:29.798 --> 01:24:32.167
VARIETY OF FRONTS ON DISCLOSURE
01:24:32.233 --> 01:24:32.867
AND TRANSPARENCY OF THEIR
01:24:32.934 --> 01:24:34.569
SOMETHING HOW THAT CAN GET THOSE
01:24:34.636 --> 01:24:36.137
FOLKS TO OF MORE OF A COMFORT
01:24:36.204 --> 01:24:36.805
LEVEL.
01:24:36.871 --> 01:24:38.206
I DON'T KNOW THAT WILL GET THEM
01:24:38.273 --> 01:24:39.441
TO SUPPORT --
01:24:39.507 --> 01:24:41.276
WHERE DO HERE I'D SOME GENERAL
01:24:41.342 --> 01:24:42.977
AGREEMENT IS IN THE GENERALLY
01:24:43.044 --> 01:24:45.613
SHARED ANTIPATHY TO INDEPENDENT
01:24:45.680 --> 01:24:47.282
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEES?
01:24:47.348 --> 01:24:51.052
BEYOND ELECTED OFFICIALS BEYOND
01:24:51.119 --> 01:24:53.521
BIG MONEY THAT MOVES MONEY
01:24:53.588 --> 01:24:55.056
AROUND IN THE POLITICAL SYSTEM.
01:24:55.123 --> 01:24:56.224
IN SOME CASES AS YOU SEE WITH
01:24:56.291 --> 01:24:58.827
ISSUE ADS EVEN AS WE SPEAK WITH
01:24:58.893 --> 01:24:59.894
VERY LITTLE DISCLOSURE.
01:24:59.961 --> 01:25:02.130
THAT IS AN ISSUE --
01:25:02.197 --> 01:25:04.032
THAT IS TO CALM.
01:25:04.098 --> 01:25:05.366
BECAUSE THERE'S A LOT OF MONEY
01:25:05.433 --> 01:25:06.868
BEING SPENT TRIED INCLUDES VOTES
01:25:06.935 --> 01:25:09.037
IN THIS LEGISLATURE ON TV WITH
01:25:09.103 --> 01:25:10.805
VERY LITTLE DISCLOSURE.
01:25:10.872 --> 01:25:12.240
IT AN ISSUE FOR ANOTHER ANOTHER
01:25:12.307 --> 01:25:14.375
DAY MISTER CHAIR LAWS SO I I
01:25:14.442 --> 01:25:15.910
WANT TO SHARE THAT.
01:25:15.977 --> 01:25:17.178
LET ME JUST SAY IF I IF I MAY IS
01:25:17.245 --> 01:25:19.414
A VERY BRIEF CLOSE --
01:25:19.481 --> 01:25:20.548
RIGHT NOW INDEPENDENT
01:25:20.615 --> 01:25:22.050
EXPENDITURE COMMITTEES WHO UNDER
01:25:22.116 --> 01:25:23.685
THE CITIZENS UNITED DECISION AS
01:25:23.751 --> 01:25:25.253
HAS BEEN REFERENCE CAN RAISE
01:25:25.320 --> 01:25:26.721
UNLIMITED FUNDS AND SPEND
01:25:26.788 --> 01:25:28.823
UNLIMITED FUNDS.
01:25:28.890 --> 01:25:29.357
AND THAT IS WHAT IS TRULY
01:25:29.424 --> 01:25:30.225
CORRUPTING.
01:25:30.291 --> 01:25:32.360
OUR SYSTEM AB EIGHTY FOUR
01:25:32.427 --> 01:25:33.394
RETAINS ALL THE FUND RAISING
01:25:33.461 --> 01:25:35.330
CAPS.
01:25:35.396 --> 01:25:36.164
UNDER EXISTING.
01:25:36.231 --> 01:25:37.966
LAW.
01:25:38.032 --> 01:25:39.501
THAT SOMETHING BY THE WAY THAT
01:25:39.567 --> 01:25:41.069
THE INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURE
01:25:41.135 --> 01:25:42.704
COMMITTEES ARE NOT SUBJECT.
01:25:42.770 --> 01:25:44.372
TO WE ARE GOING TO BE OPERATING
01:25:44.439 --> 01:25:47.008
WITHIN THAT CONSTRUCT BABY
01:25:47.075 --> 01:25:47.909
EIGHTY FOUR ALLOWS LEGISLATIVE
01:25:47.976 --> 01:25:49.711
LEADERS OF BOTH PARTIES TO
01:25:49.777 --> 01:25:51.846
RESPOND THE ESCALATION OF AYE
01:25:51.913 --> 01:25:52.413
EASE THAT OUTSIDE CORPORATE
01:25:52.480 --> 01:25:53.314
MONEY.
01:25:53.381 --> 01:25:54.449
WE ARE LIVING IN A TIME WHERE A
01:25:54.516 --> 01:25:56.017
ENORMOUSLY WEALTHY INTEREST
01:25:56.084 --> 01:25:56.851
GROUPS ARE DIRECTING MONEY
01:25:56.918 --> 01:25:58.486
TOWARD I USE AS WELL AS
01:25:58.553 --> 01:26:00.321
LEVERAGING THE LEGISLATURE IN
01:26:00.388 --> 01:26:01.589
OTHER WAYS NOT ALWAYS IN THE
01:26:01.656 --> 01:26:02.390
BEST INTERESTS.
01:26:02.457 --> 01:26:04.459
OF CALIFORNIANS LEADERS IN THE
01:26:04.526 --> 01:26:06.060
LEGISLATURE ARE SEEKING WAYS TO
01:26:06.127 --> 01:26:08.029
DEFEND AGAINST THIS OUTSIDE
01:26:08.096 --> 01:26:09.030
MONEY.
01:26:09.097 --> 01:26:10.031
THESE INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES
01:26:10.098 --> 01:26:12.267
UNLEASHED BY THE CITIZENS UNITED
01:26:12.333 --> 01:26:14.302
DECISION EIGHTY EIGHTY FOUR IS A
01:26:14.369 --> 01:26:17.138
VERY MODEST TOOL A SMALL COUNTER.
01:26:17.205 --> 01:26:20.174
REALLY. TWO THAT OUTSIDE
01:26:20.241 --> 01:26:21.943
INFLUENCE I WILL STIPULATE THAT
01:26:22.010 --> 01:26:23.478
A. B. EIGHTY FOUR'S NOT.
01:26:23.545 --> 01:26:25.213
A PERFECT SOLUTION AND I THINK
01:26:25.280 --> 01:26:26.714
OUR ATTENDANCE HERE HAS MADE
01:26:26.781 --> 01:26:28.516
THAT CLEAR IT IS NOT A PERFECT
01:26:28.583 --> 01:26:29.417
SOLUTION.
01:26:29.484 --> 01:26:31.352
BUT IT IS BETTER THAN THE STATUS
01:26:31.419 --> 01:26:33.855
QUO WHEN IT COMES TO DISCLOSURE.
01:26:33.922 --> 01:26:35.890
AND TRANSPARENCY.
01:26:35.957 --> 01:26:37.525
LET ME JUST SAY I AGREE THAT
01:26:37.592 --> 01:26:39.794
ANYTHING SHORT OF FULL PUBLIC
01:26:39.861 --> 01:26:42.664
FINANCING. FOR A CONSTITUTIONAL
01:26:42.730 --> 01:26:43.865
AMENDMENT ADDRESSING CITIZENS
01:26:43.932 --> 01:26:45.533
UNITED.
01:26:45.600 --> 01:26:47.235
IS ONLY A PARTIAL SOLUTION AND
01:26:47.302 --> 01:26:48.770
THAT'S WHAT THAT'S WHAT WE'RE
01:26:48.836 --> 01:26:49.304
CONSIDERING TODAY PARTIAL
01:26:49.370 --> 01:26:50.538
SOLUTION.
01:26:50.605 --> 01:26:52.006
BUT IN LIEU OF THOSE BIG
01:26:52.073 --> 01:26:54.375
STRUCTURAL CHANGES I HOPE WE CAN
01:26:54.442 --> 01:26:55.410
HAVE REASONABLE LIMITS ON
01:26:55.476 --> 01:26:57.345
CONTRIBUTIONS WAS STRONGER
01:26:57.412 --> 01:26:59.280
DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY OF
01:26:59.347 --> 01:27:01.649
THE DONATIONS SO THE PUBLIC.
01:27:01.716 --> 01:27:03.985
AND THE PRESS CAN INDEED FOLLOW
01:27:04.052 --> 01:27:06.387
THE MONEY TO SEE HOW CAMPAIGN
01:27:06.454 --> 01:27:08.222
MONEY IS MOVING IN STATE
01:27:08.289 --> 01:27:10.758
LEGISLATIVE RACES AND WITH THAT
01:27:10.825 --> 01:27:11.459
PASS FOR ABOUT.
01:27:11.526 --> 01:27:12.894
THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:27:12.961 --> 01:27:14.295
FOR SECRETARY.
01:27:14.362 --> 01:27:17.165
SO PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:27:17.231 --> 01:27:18.433
MOTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
01:27:18.499 --> 01:27:20.268
APPROPRIATIONS BECAUSE ARGUE WE
01:27:20.335 --> 01:27:22.670
HAVE A MOTION [inaudible]
01:27:22.737 --> 01:27:26.674
REAL MODE.
01:27:26.741 --> 01:27:28.276
THE MOTION FROM SENATOR HERZOG.
01:27:28.343 --> 01:27:32.447
STERN NO STERN NO ANDERSON AYE
01:27:32.513 --> 01:27:34.649
ANDERSON AYE ALLEN.
01:27:34.716 --> 01:27:37.318
HERTZBERG REPLY HERTZBERG AYE
01:27:37.385 --> 01:27:39.854
LEYVA AYE AYE LEYVA AYE.
01:27:39.921 --> 01:27:41.222
SO WILL LEAVE THAT MEASURE ON
01:27:41.289 --> 01:27:47.261
CALL A CURRENTLY IT'S THREE TO
01:27:47.328 --> 01:27:47.495
ONE SO.
01:27:47.562 --> 01:27:49.831
SERGEANTS BABY.
01:27:49.897 --> 01:27:51.699
CALL SENATOR ALLEN STEVES AT A
01:27:51.766 --> 01:27:53.501
TRANSPORTATION I KNOW HE'S HELD
01:27:53.568 --> 01:27:58.239
UP OVER THERE.
01:27:58.306 --> 01:27:58.773
FIGURES ALONE WILL LEAD A
01:27:58.840 --> 01:28:01.109
MEASURE ON CALL.
01:28:01.175 --> 01:28:02.510
BUT TO THOSE WHO TRAVELED UP
01:28:02.577 --> 01:28:03.811
THANK YOU THANK YOU EVERYBODY
01:28:03.878 --> 01:28:21.162
FOR FIGHT GOES ON AND
01:28:35.510 --> 01:28:51.526
YEAH
01:31:36.657 --> 01:31:36.724
.
01:31:36.724 --> 01:31:37.925
RIGHT OPEN THE ROLES.
01:31:37.992 --> 01:31:40.661
OF THE MOTION IS TO PASS AND
01:31:40.728 --> 01:31:42.530
REFER TO SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
01:31:42.597 --> 01:31:43.297
COMMITTEE THE CURRENT VOICE
01:31:43.364 --> 01:31:45.132
THREE TO ONE SHARE VOTING NO --
01:31:45.199 --> 01:31:47.902
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:31:47.969 --> 01:31:49.103
ALLEN NO ALLEN NO.
01:31:49.170 --> 01:31:50.504
THREATS THREE TO THE BILL IS OUT
01:31:50.571 --> 01:31:51.739
BY ONE VOTE --
01:31:51.806 --> 01:31:56.410
AND IT WILL BE IN APPROPRIATIONS.
01:31:56.477 --> 01:32:12.593
HOW WITH
01:32:15.663 --> 01:32:16.030
THAT SAID ELECTIONS IS
01:32:16.097 --> 01:32:32.179
GERMAN