EVERYONE IS BEING A QUITE BUSY
AND APPRECIATE EVERYONE'S
PATIENCE AND I APOLOGIZE THAT
WERE STARTING HEARING OFF LATE
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
--
WITH THE COMMITTEE AND I WANT TO
SAY THANK YOU TO OUR VICE CHAIR
AND CENTER MORE LOCKED FOR A
BEING HERE IS WELL ALONG WITH A
VERY CAPABLE AYE STAFF TEAM IN
OF COURSE. TO ALL THE WORK THAT
WENT IN FROM THE GOT AND FINANCE
CONSULTING TING THANK YOU SO
MUCH BY AS WE HAVE QUITE A FEW
BILLS IN FRONT OF US TODAY.
WE WILL BE STARTING IN THE
HEARING OFF AS A SUBCOMMITTEE
WITH THAT TO BETTER TAKE A FEW
MOMENTS TO BE A FOCUS ON THE
HOUSEKEEPING OF THE DAY.
WITH THAT BEARD A FOCUS FOR
CENTER CONSENT CALENDAR FILE
ITEM NUMBER --
ONE AB THREE EIGHTY TWO IS NOT
GONNA BE HEARD TODAY --
AS IT DID NOT PASS AYE
TRANSPORTATION IN HOUSING
YESTERDAY WANNA MAKE SURE THAT
--
WERE ALL ON THE SAME PAGE AND
FILE ITEM NUMBER.
ONE FILE ITEM THIRTEEN IS GOING
TO BE PULLED OFF OF CONSENT
THAT'S AB TWENTY TWO SIXTY THREE
AND WILL BE ASKING THE AUTHOR
FOR FOR PRESENTATION TODAY.
THE REMAIN DEEMED A BILLS ON
CONSENT WILL BE ADVANCING FILE
ITEM.
NINETEEN EIGHTY TWENTY SEVEN
FIFTY THREE FILE ITEM TWENTY SIX
AB THIRTY ONE NINETEEN AND FILE
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY EIGHT A. B.
--
THIRTY ONE NINETY FOUR IN WANT
TO SAY THANK YOU TO ALL OF THE
GOOD ASSEMBLYMAN ON MISTER
CUNNINGHAM WHO'S HERE TODAY AS
WE NEED TO GET AT THIS MOVED --
BY NOON TODAY SO THAT --
THE GOOD TO SOME AND CAN LIVE
THE DREAM IN HOUSE LATER --
THIS AFTERNOON SO WE'RE GONNA AT
THIS DOES HAVE A DO PASS
RECOMMENDATION TO HEALTH.
IN THE SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH TO
THE AUTHOR FOR ALL THIS WORK.
MR SOME AND YOU HAVE --
AT BIPARTISAN SUPPORT SO WE'RE
GONNA ASK YOU TO BE ABLE TO
ADVANCE A TRUNCATED PRESENTATION
TODAY SINCE YOU DO HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN THE SAME
OF YOU WITNESSES.
THE FLOOR IS YOURS SIR AND
WELCOME TO COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
SENATORS I WILL BE BRIEF IN THE
MIDDLE I HAVE RURAL PART OF
SANTA BARBARA COUNTY WE HAVE
SIGNIFICANT ISSUES WITH ACCESS.
TO MEDICAL CARE IN PARTICULAR
COMMUNITY OF LONG POST.
WHICH IS ADJACENT TO A FEDERAL
PRISON N AIRFORCE BASE AND A
LARGE.
PART OF THAT POPULATION SERVICES
TO FACILITIES AND VARIOUS MEANS
OF EMPLOYMENT.
A LUMP LOCALES PARTICULARLY
ACUTE HEALTH CARE ACCESS ISSUES
THE CLOSEST HOSPITAL TO THEM IS
ACTUALLY FORTY MINUTES AWAY IN
SANTA MARIA.
AND MIRIAM HOSPITAL AND COTTAGE
HOSPITAL IN SANTA BARBARA IS
FIFTY TWO MILES AWAY --
AB SIX FIFTY THREE WILL EXPAND
HEALTH CARE SERVICES TO THE
COMMUNITY.
IT WILL ALLOW LOMPOC VALLEY
HEALTHCARE DISTRICT TO
COLLABORATE WTH COTTAGE HEALTH
A NONPROFIT HOSPITAL TO DEVELOP
A JOINT POWERS AGREEMENT.
THAT WILL ENABLE THEM TO
COLLABORATE WITH COLLABORATE ON
PROVIDING PRIMARY CARE AND
URGENT CARE FACILITIES AND LONG
POKE REGION --
CAT CATS GOT REPRESENTING LONG
HOPE VALLEY HEALTHCARE DISTRICT
IS HERE.
TO SO IF YOU WORDS ABOUT THE
BILL AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
NINE VOTE SIMILAR THINK IF YOU
WORK ON THIS FISCAL YEAR
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT WE'RE GONNA
ASK FOR A SHORT STATEMENT FOR
SOURCE.
PROCESS GOT A PRESIDING LOMPOC
HEALTHCARE DISTRICT I THINK THE
AUTHOR DID A GREAT JOB WERE
EXCITED TO IMPLEMENT ADDITIONAL
HEALTH CARE RESOURCES IN THE
COMMUNITY INCLUDING --
CRISIS STABILIZATION UNITS AND
URGENT CARE WE ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'RE
NOW GOING TO ASK FOR ANYONE NOT
SUSAN SUPPORT TO PLEASE ADVANCE
AT THIS TIME WE'RE LOOKING FOR
THOSE WHO EARN SUPPORT TO PLEASE
ADVANCE.
LAST CALL FOR SUPPORT ACTUALLY I
COULDN'T YOU KNOW COLLEGE HEALTH
IS ALSO IN SUPPORT AS WELL THEIR
FIRST AND MAKE IT THIS MORNING
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
NOW LIKELY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE OPPOSED TO PICK PLEASE
ADVANCE AT THIS TIME THOSE WERE
OPPOSED LAST CALL FOR OPPOSE FOR
BRINGING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE.
UNFORTUNATE WERE UNABLE TO MAKE
A MOTION TO SIMON'S WE ARE
STARTING.
LIKE BASICALLY ME QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
[inaudible] THIRTY ARE THESE.
THE EMPLOYEES OF THESE TWO
HOSPITALS ARE THEY PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES.
BUT NEVER GET ENOUGH SO THAT
THEY AND THEIR ACTUALLY --
THE MERGER WILL NOT MAKE THEM
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES LIKE TO SHARE
EMPLOYEES SO THAT I CAN CLARIFY
STUFF FOR YOU --
BUT MY MY UNDERSTANDING IS IS
THAT I'M THE WAY THEY'RE GOING
TO MANAGE HAT IT'S NOT REALLY
MERGER THE WAY THEY'RE GOING TO
MANAGETHIS A COLLABORATIVE
AGREEMENT ISTHEY'LL.
SHARE --
EMPLOYEES FROM EITHER ENTITIES
SO LONG PARKS ARE PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES LOMPOC SKIS ME MOM
FOLK HEALTHCARE DISTRICT ARE
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FOR COTTAGES
ARE NOT.
FOR FOR PLACE SO SO THEY'RE
GONNA BE ALL.
DELINEATED IN IN IN THE
AGREEMENT YES YET BUT CARE WHAT
LIABILITY AND CORRECT YES THAT
CRAP THEY WILL BE A VERY STRONG
--
COLLABORATION AGREEMENT AND THEN
PUBLIC AS WELL BECAUSE THE GBA
REQUIRES THAT UNFORTUNATE TAXING
AUTHORITY AS WELL JOBS ARE
CONCERNED IS THAT.
WITH THAT WITH THAT.
JP HAYES FALLING APART AND ALL
THE SUDDEN WHO PAYS FOR THE
PENSIONS THAT'S GOING TO BE.
THAT'LL BE START YES DELINEATED
BY BOTH OLD AND PART OF THAT IS
BECAUSE LOMPOC BEING A PUBLIC
ENTITY AND THEN THE GPA BEING
PUBLIC.
PASS TO BE OPEN TO ALSO AND WE
CAN FOR THAT TO YOU AS SOON AS
IT'S DEVELOPED ONCE THE JP IT'S
APPROVED IF THAT'S FULL.
THANK YOU BACON AS MISTER CHAIR.
SO MUCH OF MISTER MORLOCK ANY
ADDITIONAL OF QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
WHERE HAVE YOU SIMPLY DO A
CLOSING STATEMENT PLEASE?
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY BOAT
THANK YOU SO MUCH AS A MEMBER WE
ARE GONNA --
WORK TO GET THIS QUORUM SO WE
CAN GET THIS PUPPY UP OVER IN
ACROSS THE DESK TO BE TO GET TO
HEALTH I APOLOGIZE WE DON'T HAVE
THAT AT THIS TIME.
WILL I KEEP YOUR STAFF IN THE
LOOP I THINK YOU SOME
ATTRIBUTES.
I NEVER SUPPORT NOW GONNA BE
MOVING ON TO A FILE ITEM NUMBER
THREE IS HIS AB SEVEN OR NINE I
BY THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
SACRAMENTO MISS MCCARTY.
THIS DOES HAVE A I DO PASS FLORA
RECOMMENDATION.
MCCARTY WE WELCOME YOU TO
COMMITTEE THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
TAKING THE TIME SIR IT IS A BUSY
WEEK FOR EVERYONE AT AND I KNOW
YOU'RE RUNNING THE FLOORS OR SIR
ON SECOND REGIONAL TRANSIT THANK
YOU I I THINK YOU I HEARD THIS
BILL ON YOUR OTHER COMMITTEES SO
--
AS YOU KNOW THIS IS THAT I
DISTRICT BILL RELATE TO OUR
SACRAMENTO REGIONAL TRANSIT
BOARD.
AND UPDATES ARE --
BY LAWS AND CODIFY SOME CHANGES
TO OUR A GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE --
ALLOWS THEM TO ESSENTIALLY THAT
TWO MAJOR THINGS PLACES SALES
TAX MEASURE ON THE BALLOT AT
INCRIMINATE 18% AS OPPOSED TO
ONE QUARTER CENT.
AND JAPAN ANOTHER SIGNIFICANT
CHANGES RELATE TO THAT --
VOTING STRUCTURE TOP PARTY IS
THE PRIMARY PUBLIC
TRANSPORTATION AGENCY IN OUR
REGION HERE USE THAT AS YOU KNOW
YOU'RE HERE IN SACRAMENTO YOU
SEE THE BUSES AND TRAINS GO BY.
AND THIS WILL HELP THEM
MODERNIZE THEIR THAT'S HERE AT
THE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR WE ARE
GOING TO ASK OUR WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT TO BE ABLE TO INTRODUCE
THEMSELVES FIRST AND LAST
ORGANIZATION IN YOUR TWO
MINUTES.
GERMAN ARE YOU SPEAKING IN
SUPPORT.
OF THEM SORRY. EIGHT THAT MISTER
LEE IS HERE TO ANSWER TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS I THINK YOU SO MUCH
WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR INDIVIDUALS
BECOME FORTY IN SUPPORT IF YOU
PLEASE TAKE YOUR FIRST AND LAST
ALONG WITH THE ORGANIZATION OF A
JONES ABOUT THE CITY SACRAMENTO
IN SUPPORT.
BUT I COULD TO SEE IF THERE IS
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION IF WE
CAN HAVE THEM PLEASE ADVANCE AT
THIS TIME THOSE WERE IN
OPPOSITION TO BE PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
SCENE NINE LAST CALL IS BRING
BACK TO COMMITTEE TO RECEIVE ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
COMMITTEE THIS TIME.
SEE NINE MISTER SENATOR I
APOLOGIZE THAT WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM WOULD INVITE YOU KNOW TO
BE ABLE TO MAKE A A CLOSING
COMMENT SIR.
I THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR
WORKING WITH US ON THIS HOT AND
ANNOUNCES THAT LAYS IT OUT AND
ASK HEREBY BUT WHEN YOU GET A
QUORUM REVIEW SHEET CERTAIN
AGAIN I APOLOGIZE IT'S GOOD TO
SEE THIS RECORD.
THANK YOU SO MUCH ONLY IF.
UNFORTUNATELY I SUMMER BROKE
COULD NOT BE WITH US TODAY ON
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWENTY ONE THIS
IS AB.
TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY FIVE AYE SO
WE LIKE THE CALM JOHN SECOND
FIDDLE MORE LOCK --
HE'S HERE --
MR MORLOCK IS FIRED UP AND READY
TO GO --
MISTER BREAUX HAS A VERY
SPECIAL.
FAMILY OCCASION HERE TODAY IN
TIME WE KNEW THAT HE WASN'T
GOING TO MAKE IT ANY APOLOGIZES
[inaudible]
BUT THE MAN THE MYTH THE LEGEND
FROM ORANGE COUNTY'S HERE TO BE
A PRISON ON HIS BEHALF.
BUT THIS DOES HAVE BIPARTISAN
WE'RE GONNA ASK YOU TO A ADVANCE
--
BAD CUT YOUR TWENTY TWO MINUTE
PRESENTATION DOWN BY JUST A BIT
IF YOU DON'T MIND SO.
IF YOU EVER GO SOONER THE BODY
BEHIND ME MISTER CHAIR HEYDARIEH
WHO I WILL TAKE THE FULL FORTY
MINUTE ARTS HE FOR INTEL SOMEONE
ARRIVES NOT A VICE CHAIR ANY
THOUGHTS ON THIS.
I SEE TWENTY SECONDS FERRIDAY
CEDAR GO THANK YOU OF THE FLOOR
IS YOURS MRS ENERGY A BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT. FOR THIS IS BETTER THAN
DOING THE KABUKI DANCE OF THANK
YOU VERY GO EXACTLY --
I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR --
FOR ALLOWING ME THE OPPORTUNITY
PRESENTS --
ON A FUN TOPIC NET OPERATING
LOSS --
ASSUMING I DEALT WITH WHEN I WAS
A CPA.
TWENTY PLUS YEARS AGO --
BUT THE AUTHOR IS ACCEPTING
PROPOSED COMMITTEE AMENDMENT THE
COMMITMENT AMENDMENT TO PERMIT
FOR THE SUSPENSION OF THE
APPLICATION FOR TENTATIVE REFUND
DURING FISCAL EMERGENCIES.
SO MEMBERS AB TWO EIGHT FIVE
FIVE WILL EXPEDITE TAX REFUND SO
BUSINESSES.
WE'LL HAVE TIMELY ACCESS TO
CAPITAL OWED AS A RESULT OF AN
OPERATING LOSS.
AFTER GOOD YEARS.
I BUSINESS INCURRING A TOUGH
HERE CAN GO BACK AND APPLY IT'S
NET OPERATING LOSS TO THE TWO
PRIOR PROFITABLE YEARS PROVIDING
A CASH REFUND.
AT A CRITICAL TIME IN THEIR
BUSINESS CYCLE THIS UNIQUE
OPPORTUNITY IS BUSINESS FRIENDLY
AND ACTING THIS CHANGE WOULD
BENEFIT TAXPAYERS IT WOULD
SIMPLIFY FILING RETURNS
ALLOW BUSINESSES TO OBTAIN THEIR
REFUNDS QUICKER WHILE ALSO
REDUCING INTEREST PAID BY THE
STATE.
AB TWO EIGHT FIVE FIVE IS
SUPPORTED.
BY A BROAD COALITION OF TAXPAYER
ADVOCATES BUSINESS
ORGANIZATIONS.
AND EVEN.
A DIANNE PRO [inaudible]
BOARD SO I HAVE HEARD DIANNE
DEATH THREATS HERE TO TESTIFY AS
A WITNESS AS WELL AS TOURIST TO
MAKE.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR WE LOVE
IT WHEN UP OF CAL TAX AND DIANE
IS HERE I WHO WOULD LIKE TO BE
TO KICK IT OFF YOU DO HAVE A
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR TRUNCATED
STATEMENT IT'S COULD YOU SEEN
THEM.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR MEMBER
SEARCH TO MAY REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION
THIS BILL IS A GOOD GOVERNMENT
COMMONSENSE MEASURE WHAT IT DOES
IS IT REDUCES THE INTEREST
EXPENSE PAID BY THE FRANCHISE
TAX BOARD. FOR DELAYED REFUNDS
AND IT ALSO INFUSES CASH INTO
BUSINESSES TO PROMOTE ECONOMIC
GROWTH WE ARE CHAIR SUPPORT
[inaudible] FOUR DOORS.
AND I'M DIANE DEATH THREATS OF
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR FOR
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD AND I'M HERE
TO THINK THE AUTHORS OFFICE FOR
BRINGING THIS APP LEGISLATIVE
PROPOSAL FORWARD FOR AS AND TO
STATE THAT WE'RE IN SUPPORT.
AND FOR MR BE WERE ALWAYS A
GRATEFUL I AM AND I SAID WELL
LOOK AS IF YOU QUESTIONS FOR YOU
AS WELL SO I HEY THERE YOU GO.
HI DAGO WE'RE GONNA OPEN UP FOR
ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF
YOU COULD PLEASE COMPORT THIS
TIME LOOKING FOR THOSE WHO ARE
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL TO PLEASE
ADVANCE [inaudible] ONE ANSWER.
MORNING REX W. HYMEN BE HAVE A
CALIFORNIA'S PROPOSITION SUPPORT
WHICH IS GOOD TO SEE THANK YOU
FOR COMING.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO IN
SUPPORT OF IT PLEASE ADVANCE.
NOW GONNA LOOK TO THOSE WHO
MAYBE OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSED. FOR
BRINGING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE TO
BE ABLE TO SEE IF WE HAVE ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS UNABLE TO
MAKE A MOTION DUE TO THE FACT WE
ARE SUBCOMMITTEE.
SEEING NONE CENTER MALIK WOULD
LIKE TO CLOSER THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN.
I APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY
PRESENTED I THINK THIS IS A
RIGHT THING TO DO AND LOOK
FORWARD TO THE VOTE ONCE SAID WE
HAVE A QUORUM.
MUCH VERY GRATEFUL SIR.
MEMBERS WHO WE ARE NOW GOING TO
BE MOVING FORWARD ON TO BILLS --
FROM --
MISTREATMENT ACTUALLY GONNA
START WITH UP FILE ITEM THIRTEEN
AB.
TWENTY TWO SIXTY THREE WE'RE
VERY GRATEFUL THAT AYE THE SILLY
WOMAN IS HERE SOMEONE I'M GONNA
RUN TO ELECTIONS I APOLOGIZE NOT
TRYING TO BE RUDE --
THEREBY TO SHUT DOWN IN ATTICA
PRISON THE BILL AND THEY TURN
THE GAVEL OVER TO OUR VICE CHAIR
VICE CHAIR WYNN.
I'M AND I WILL BE RIGHT BACK IN
IT'S ALWAYS WONDERFUL TO HAVE
YOU COMMITTEE IN THANK YOU FOR
ALL YOUR WORK.
ON BEHALF OF CREATING THE SAN.
HARASSMENT HERE --
IN THE LEGISLATURE WE'RE
GRATEFUL FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP THE
FLOOR IS YOURS MA'AM YOU FOR THE
WARM WELCOME.
THE MORNING GOOD MORNING SO WE
DOING TWENTY TWO SIXTY THREE
FIRST I'M TWENTY GETTING. TWENTY
SIXTY THREE THREE THANK YOU
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE I AM
VERY PROUD TODAY TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY TWO SIXTY THREE A BILL
THAT'S A GARNERED --
WIDE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT --
TO ENSURE LOCALS HISTORIC
CHARACTERS MAINTAIN WANTS
ADVISING ADAPTER FOR USE OF
EXISTING HISTORICAL STRUCTURES
FOR MUCH NEEDED USE WHETHER IT'S
COMMERCIAL OR HOUSING.
I'M DEDICATED TO HISTORIC
PRESERVATION IN FACT I CAME TO
POLITICS BY WAY OF BEING A
HISTORIC PRESERVATION VOLUNTEER
IN LOS ANGELES SO THIS ISSUE IS
VERY CLOSE TO MY HEART.
AND ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I'VE
SEEN OVER TIME IS THAT SOME OF
THE BUILDINGS THAT COMMUNITIES
LOVE THE MOST AND CHERISH THE
MOST END UP SITTING UNUSED.
BECAUSE THEY DON'T NEED TO
TODAY'S CURRENT PARKING
STANDARDS AND TO ME THE ULTIMATE
FORM OF RECYCLING IS ALSO
RECYCLING OUR OLD BUILDINGS FEES
ARE BUILDINGS THAT COMMUNITIES
WANT PRESERVE THEY DON'T WANT
TORN DOWN THESE ARE BUILDINGS
THAT ARE LISTED ON A HISTORIC
REGISTER.
AND WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT
FOLLOWS --
INCENTIVES THAT ARE IN LOS
ANGELES CITY AND ALSO IN THE IN
MY HOME CITY OF GLENDALE THAT
GIVE OUR PARKING EXEMPTIONS I'M
FOR THE ADOPTED FOR USE OF THOSE
BUILDINGS.
I'M I'M WITHOUT I'M HAPPY TO
ANSWER QUESTIONS AND I
RESPECTFULLY I'M REQUESTED MY
VOTE.
IN ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
ANY INDIVIDUAL IN OPPOSITION
SCENE.
NINE HE HAD A QUESTION OR EFFORT
ABOUT [inaudible]
TWENTY FOUR OKAY.
BUT WE DO MEAN WE NEED TO MAKE.
AND I HAVE ANOTHER BILL AS WELL
SHE HAS WHAT OF COURSE I SAY
THAT THIS BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION
--
AND THERE'S TIGHTEN AGAIN VERY
WIDE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT --
AND I'M VERY PASSIONATE IT'S A
SMALL BILL BUT I THINK IT'S
GOING TO DO A LOT TO HELP SAVE.
BUILDINGS THAT PEOPLE
COMMUNITIES REALLY CARE ABOUT OF
THE CHOSEN TO PRESERVE AND IT
BRINGS NEW LIFE INTO THEM AND WE
KNOW I'VE SEEN A LOT OF A DOCTOR
FOR USE.
ALL AROUND THE COUNTRY AND IT'S
JUST WONDERFUL TO SEE A PRECIOUS
OLD BUILDING ALL OF A SUDDEN.
KING GIVEN A NEW CHANCE --
TO BE SOMETHING ELSE AND YOU
KNOW GENERALLY I FIND THAT --
PEOPLE TEND TO NOT MOVE USES AND
THAT ARE INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE
PARKING THAT THEY NEED FOR THEIR
OWN BUSINESS.
SO -- I
HAVEN'T SEEN IT BE YOU KNOW MUCH
OF A PROBLEM IT'S IT'S A
REASONABLE AMOUNT OF PARTS 25%
PARKING REDUCTION FOR
COMMERCIAL.
A MORE FOR HOUSING IF IT'S CLOSE
TO TRANSIT.
THIS IS BEEN A GREAT TOOL IN LOS
ANGELES WE'VE SEEN A LOT OF
THOSE OLD BUILDINGS BEING
REUSED.
HOUSE AFTER STRETCHING THE TIME
A LITTLE BIT.
LET ME ADD TO IT. TWENTY FIVE
YEARS AGO I APPLIED TO BE ON THE
STATE HISTORICAL RESOURCES
COMMISSION EUROPE IN SACRAMENTO
RIGHT --
GOVERNOR WILSON WAS THE GOVERNOR
AND THE AREA IS REPRESENTATIVES
SAID HOW ABOUT SERVING ON THE
CESSPOOL CENTENNIAL.
EFFORT. TO HUNDRED FIFTIETH
ANNIVERSARY SO THERE WAS A LOT
OF FUN BUT AYE.
I VISITED MORE THAN A THOUSAND
OF THE STATE HISTORICAL
LANDMARKS I THINK A VOTE FOR
YOUR BILL.
THANK YOU APPRECIATE IT YOU'RE
GONNA MOVE ON TO THE NEXT
BUILDING YEAH BECAUSE WE WILL BE
ABLE TO MAKE A MOTION AT THIS
TIME TO MADAM CHAIR --
AYE AYES SOME ITEM.
TWENTY THREE A. B.. TWENTY NINE
ELEVEN THANK YOU OFFER SAID LIKE
TO ACCEPT THE PROPOSED COMMITTEE
AMENDMENT ON PAGE FOR UNDER
COMMENT TO THE ANALYSIS IS AN
AUTHORS AMENDMENT.
I IT'S OBVIOUSLY BECOME CLEAR
OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS THAT WE
HAVE TO DO MORE TO HELP PREVENT
FIRES IN CALIFORNIA THIS IS A
HUGE IMPERATIVE.
MY COMMUNITY WAS OF FIRE
IMPACTED NOT IS BADLY LIKELY AS
MANY OTHERS BUT WE A LOT OF US
REPRESENT DISTRICTS THAT ARE IN
HIGH FIRE AZARD ZONES.
AND THIS BILL IS AN EFFORT TO
ENSURE THAT THE CITY'S --
HAVE THE TOOLS THEY NEED TO
PREVENT AND REDUCE THE RISK OF
WILDFIRES AB TWENTY NINE ELEVEN
SIX TO PROVIDE RECOMMENDATIONS
FOR FIRE SAFETY PLANNING
EFFORTS.
STRENGTHENED DEFENSIBLE SPACE
REQUIREMENTS AND CLARIFY
VEGETATION CLEARANCE
REQUIREMENTS AROUND UTILITY
LINES ALL WHILE PROMOTING
HABITAT RESTORATION.
GIVEN THE DEVASTATION OF THE
WILDFIRE SEASON LAST YEAR AND
UNFORTUNATELY THIS YEAR IT'S
IMPERATIVE THAT WE REEVALUATE
AND UPDATE OUR CURRENT FIRE
SAFETY MEASURES.
THERE IS ARE CURRENTLY NO KNOWN
OPPOSITION TO AB TWENTY NINE
ELEVEN AND I RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE.
AND WE DO HAVE A WITNESS HERE IN
SUPPORT.
THANK IN MOURNING NIGGLING AT AN
UNDISCOVERED AFFAIRS FOR SENEGAL
GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY AND WE
ARE HERE IN SUPPORT OF THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS WHICH WOULD
EXPAND THE BILL TO THAT HIGH
FIRE THREAT DISTRICT AS
DESCRIBED BY THE CPUC.
I'M SENDING AHEAD GAS ELECTRIC
AS BEEN RECOGNIZED.
IN OUR WEATHER STATION --
OLIVER SYSTEM HARDENING AND
OTHER PROGRAMS ON THIS BILL AS
MISSION WOULD EXPAND OUR
RESPONSIBILITY I'M INTO THE AREA
NOW SECRETIVE PROCESS TO WORK
WITH LANDOWNERS WHICH WHERE --
EXCITED ABOUT WERE ALSO PLEASED
AT THIS BILL ENCOURAGES RIGHT
TREE RIGHT PLACE WHICH IS --
VERY SPECIES THAT CAN BE PLANTED
AROUND OUR ELECTRICAL FACILITIES
AND OVER THE SPAN OF THE
VEGETATION LIFE WOULD NEVER HAVE
TO BE PRUNED WHICH HELPS --
ALIVE AND SO AND WE BELIEVE THIS
BILL IS A GREAT AND STAFF AND
HELPING MITIGATE THE RISK
VEGETATION POSES TO WELFARE
IGNITION IMMIGRANT RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
THANK YOU ANY OTHER.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
ANYONE -- IN
OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE COLLEAGUE SENATOR
MARLA THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR --
IT'S FRIEDMAN --
YOU DO THE POLITE THING YOU YOU
NOTICE THAT THE OWNER AND YOU
GIVE THEM.
A AN ABILITY TO RESPOND.
SO DO THEY HAVE THE CHOICE OF
CLEARING THE VEGETATION AND
THEMSELVES OR DO THEY JUST WAIT
FOR SAN DIEGO.
GAS ELECTRIC TO SHOW UP AND DO
IT.
I BELIEVE THAT THEY HAVE THE
CHOICE --
UPDATE WHETHER THEY WANT TO DO
IT THEMSELVES THE WOULD --
IT WOULD IT WOULD IT BE DONE FOR
FREE UTILITY CAME IN AND DID IT
OVER THEY BE CHARGED.
THAT WORK IS A VERY --
I'VE I BELIEVE IT WOULD BE OUR
RESPONSIBILITY.
SO I COULD HAVE IT DONE FOR FREE
WHEN YOU WRITE AT SINGING OF BUT
IT'S KIND OF A NICE.
BENEFIT DIDN'T DO YOU HAVE.
ANY I HAVE.
IT IS IT'S ALREADY SORT OF OUR
OPERATIONAL ARE YOU READY KIND
OF DOING THIS WITH PROPERTY
OWNERS CONTACTING THEM AND WE WE
DO CONTACT THEM BUT IF.
THEY'RE DEBATE ON ALLOWS TO
GOING TO THE PROPERTY THEN WE WE
DON'T AND TO THEIR PROPERTY OKAY
SO DO YOU HAVE A LOT OF
OPPOSITION AND THAT.
FROM LANDOWNERS --
I HAVE TO GET BACK TO YOU ON
STORAGE WHAT HERE IS WHERE YOU
SAY HEY WILL WILL COME ON WILL
MITIGATE.
AGAIN ORANGE COUNTY IF YOU DON'T
CLEAR OUT YOUR WEEDS WE CHARGE
YOU AND PUT ON YOUR TAX BILL BUT
THIS IS.
SOMETHING THAT'S GOT SOMETHING
TO PROMOTE THAT WOULD BE A NICE.
A PUBLIC SERVICE OPPORTUNITY
BRAVE IF IT'S MARKETED PROPERLY.
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
LIKE A MINIATURE.
THANK YOU --
WE CANNOT MAKE THE MOTION YET
WHICH IS LIKE TO PLEASE CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I
BOTH -- BOTH
OF THESE BILLS HAVE.
GARNERED NAM BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
AND WE'RE ART ON THEM SO.
RESPECTFULLY I'M FOR QUESTION
AYE VOTE THANK YOU WHEN WE HAVE
A QUORUM WE WILL.
SEEK FOR MOTION THANK YOU
MEDICARE.
WE NOW I SEE I AM ASSEMBLY WOMAN
RADIUS.
WORD ITEM SIX A. B..
FOURTEEN FORTY FIVE PLEASE.
SOME BANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS NUMBER.
I WOULD LIKE TO START OFF BY
THANKING THE CHAIR AND TO
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR WORK
ON THIS BILL.
AND BY ACCEPTING AMENDMENTS
RECOMMENDED BY THE COMMITTEE
ENSURING THAT DISCLOSURE
REQUIREMENTS IN THIS BILL ARE
SHARED AT THE POINT OF SALE OR
LEASE.
AB FOURTEEN FORTY FIVE IS A BILL
AIMING SIMPLY TO INCREASE
TRANSPARENCY.
SO SPECIFICALLY THE BILL
REQUIRES THAT WHEN A CITY OR
COUNTY PARTICIPATES IN A
TRANSACTION FOR THE SALE OR
LEASE THE PUBLIC PROPERTY WITHIN
A QUALIFIED OPPORTUNITY.
ZONE FUND THAT THE FUNDS
OPERATOR MUST PROVIDE BASIC
INFORMATION RELATING TO THE
PROJECT'S DEVELOPMENT.
LAST YEAR CONGRESS PASSED
LEGISLATION THAT MADE
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES TO THE
FEDERAL TAX CODE.
WHICH AMONG OTHER IMPACTS
CREATED OPPORTUNITY ZONES.
THE GOAL OF THESE ZONES TO
ADDRESS POVERTY IN LOW INCOME
AREAS SPECIFICALLY THROUGH THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF AN OPPORTUNITY
FUND.
INVESTMENT THROUGH THIS
MECHANISM ALLOWS THE ENTITY
THROUGH ELIMINATE FEDERAL TAXES
ON CAPITAL GAINS AS AN INCENTIVE
TO INVEST IN DESIGNATED ZONES.
AND APRIL THE US DEPARTMENT OF
TREASURY CERTIFIED CALIFORNIA'S
NOMINATED OPPORTUNITY ZONES
DESIGNATING NINE I'M SORRY EIGHT
HUNDRED SEVENTY NINE CENSUS
TRACKS THROUGHOUT THE STATE THAT
ARE ELIGIBLE TO BENEFIT FROM
THIS PROGRAM.
ALTHOUGH INCREASING THE FLOW OF
CAPITAL INTO THE INTO THESE
COMMUNITIES IS IMPORTANT IT IS
ALSO CRITICAL THAT WE IN SHORT.
THE INSURER IT BE DONE IN A WAY
THAT EMPOWERS THE COMMUNITIES.
IF INVESTMENT IS NOT DIRECTLY
LINKED TO THE SCHOOL THE DEBT
DESIGNATION UTILIZATION OF
OPPORTUNITY ZONES MAY LEAD TO
DISPLACING RESIDENTS.
POOR NEIGHBORHOODS OR SIMPLY
BENEFITING DEVELOPERS NEITHER OF
WHICH BRINGS VALUE TO
OPPORTUNITY ZONES.
A BEAT FOURTEEN FORTY FIVE
ADDRESSES THIS BY PUTTING IN
PLACE REQUIRED QUESTIONS THAT
MUST BE ANSWERED AT THE POINT OF
SALE OR LEASE.
THESE INCLUDE THE TIMELINE FOR
THE COMPLETION OF THE INVESTMENT
ACTIVITY.
THE NUMBER OF LOCAL JOBS
ESTIMATED AND THE WORKFORCE
UTILIZATION STRATEGIES.
THE BILL SEEKS TO ENSURE THE
PRIVATIZATION.
PUBLIC BENEFIT WITH THEIR IS
PURCHASE OR LEASE A PUBLIC LAND.
THINK I WOULD THAT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT NO STAFF
[inaudible]
ANYWAY.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
ANY OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE.
COLLEAGUES.
ANY QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
SENATOR MOVED MORE LAW.
SO THIS WAS JUST ESTABLISHED
[inaudible]
IN DECEMBER [inaudible]
I'M.
ARE WE TRYING.
TO PROVIDE CONFORMITY WITH STATE
LAW.
PER WEEK.
TRYING TO PREVENT JUST CERTAIN
TRANSACTIONS OF A PUBLIC LAND.
THE BASIC THING WERE TRYING TO
DO IS PROVIDE TRANSPARENCY WE
KNOW THAT --
OPPORTUNITY ZONES AS YOU SAY
SOMETHING NEW.
AND IT IS TO BENEFIT OUR POOREST
COMMUNITIES WHILE ALSO HELPING
THOSE INVESTORS --
ON CAPITAL GAINS TAX AT THAT
WOULD NORMALLY HAVE TO PAY IT
ALLOWS THEM TO BE ABLE TO PUT
THEM.
INTO THESE OPPORTUNITY ZONES AND
THEY WOULD GAIN THE BENEFIT.
RATHER THAN HAVING TO PAY THE
TAX ON THE CAPITAL GAINS.
AND WE JUST WANT TO BE ABLE TO
PROVIDE TRANSPARENCY IF A COUNTY
OR CITY CELLS.
CITY OR COUNTY PROPERTY COULD
THOSE INVESTORS WE DO WANTED
THESE THREE THINGS TO BE
PROVIDED.
IT'S PART OF WHAT NEEDS TO BE
PROVIDED AT THE TIME OF SAILOR
LEAKS.
THANK YOU THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
THANK YOU.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO PLEASE CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE SO THAT WE CAN CONTINUE
WITH THIS AND AND PROVIDE THOSE
OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE COMMUNITY
THANK YOU AND WHEN WE HAVE
ESTABLISHED A CORPSMAN.
WILL SEEK FOR MOTION AND CALL
FOR A VOTE THINK WONDERFUL THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
AND I SEE WE HAVE.
ASSEMBLY WOMAN CABBY ERA.
YOU'VE GOT THREE BILLS.
ITEM SEVEN EIGHT AND ITEM SEVEN
A. B.. EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE
PLEASE ASSEMBLY WILL THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
SO YOU KNOW WE DON'T HAVE A
QUORUM YET SO YES.
JUST DID A HEARING AND THEY WILL
SEEK FOR A MOTION ONCE WE HAVE A
QUORUM ESTABLISH THANK YOU SO
MUCH AND I APPRECIATE YOU.
THE MEETING AND GIVING ME THE
OPPORTUNITY PRESENT ITSELF.
FIRST I'D LIKE TO THINK THE
CHAIR IN THE STAFF FOR THEIR
HELP WITH THE BILL.
WE WORKED HARD TO FIND A
COMPROMISE AND I'M HAPPY TO
ACCEPT THE PROPOSED COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS.
THAT WILL REDUCE THE PROPOSED
NUMBER OF COMPENSABLE MEETING
DAYS.
FROM UP.
TO TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN REQUIRE
THE WATER DISTRICT BOARD TO
ANNUALLY ADOPTING REVIEW EVERITT
WRITTEN COMPENSATION POLICY AND
MAKE A FINDING BASED ON SUPPLY
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE.
THAT MORE THAN TEN MEETING DAYS
PER MONTH ARE NECESSARY FOR THE
EFFICIENT OPERATION OF THE WATER
DISTRICT AND INCLUDE A FIVE YEAR
SUNSET.
SUCH THAT THE PREVIOUSLY STATED
PROVISIONS ARE REPEALED UNLESS A
SUNSET DATE IS DELETED OR
EXTENDED.
MIA BEFORE JANUARY FIRST.
TWENTY TWENTY FOUR AB EIGHTEEN
EIGHTY NINE IS A DISTRICT BILL
THAT AMENDS THE SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT ACT TO
MAKE THREE IMPORTANT REFORMS.
IT IMPROVES FAIRNESS FOR LOW
INCOME SENIORS TO PART IN PARCEL
TAX EXEMPTION PROCESSING.
IT INCREASES IN BOARD
COMPENSATION TO ENSURE SOCIO
ECONOMIC DIVERSITY ON THE BOARD
OF DIRECTORS AND ENSURES THAT
ANY APPOINTMENT TO FILL A MID
YEAR VACANCY ON THE BOARD IS
FILLED BY A RESIDENT.
FROM THE DISTRICT WHERE THE
VACANCY OCCURS IF YOU'RE TO
PROCESS A PARCEL TAX EXEMPTION
REQUIRES LOW INCOME SENIORS TO
VERIFY THEIR INCOME EVERY YEAR
WHICH IS CUMBERSOME.
MANY SENIORS FAILED TO RETURN
THEIR YEARLY PAPERWORK IT AND
THAT PAYING THE TAX BOB THIS
BILL WOULD ALLOW THE LOW INCOME
SENIORS TO ENROLL IN THE
PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTION ONCE.
AND RESPOND TO AN ANNUAL FILING
IT.
BUT IF THEIR INCOME TAX FOR THAT
YEAR EXCEEDS THE THRESHOLD FOR
THE EXEMPTION SO IT'S THE
OPPOSITE --
THIS WILL ENSURE THAT LOW INCOME
SENIORS WHO MAY HAVE HEALTH
CONCERNS OR HAVE OTHERS HANDLING
THEIR PERSONAL BUSINESS CONTINUE
TO BENEFIT.
FROM THAT THE PARCEL TAX
EXEMPTION THE NEXT REFORM WOULD
INCREASE THE SOCIO ECONOMIC
DIVERSITY OF THE BOARD OF
DIRECTORS BY INCREASING THE
NUMBER OF MEETING DAYS FOR WHICH
A MEMBER FROM THE BOARD IS
ELIGIBLE FOR REMUNERATION.
BECAUSE THE MEETING ALLOWANCES
CURRENTLY KEPT TEN DIRECTORS WHO
MANAGE THE WATER SUPPLY.
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP FLOOD
PROTECTION AND GROUNDWATER FOR
NEARLY TWO MILLION PEOPLE OFTEN
MISS WORK LONG HOURS WITHOUT
REMAIN REMAIN COMMUNICATION AS A
RESULT THE PEOPLE WHO SERVE ON
THE BOARD ARE EITHER RETIRED OR
INDEPENDENTLY WEALTHY.
KEEPING MANY WORKING FAMILIES
AND PEOPLE OF COLOR FOR SIR FROM
SERVING ON THE BOARD.
THIS BILL A SPORT IS SUPPORTED
BY A DIVERSITY OF BUSINESS LABOR
AND SOCIAL SOCIAL JUSTICE GROUPS
INCLUDING THE BAY AREA COUNCIL
ASKS ME SILICON VALLEY
LEADERSHIP GROUP.
LET US A ROUND TABLE OF
CALIFORNIA AT THE CALIFORNIA
CONFERENCE OF AN E. CP THE ASIAN
LAW ALLIANCE AND MANY OTHERS
THESE GROUPS ALL SUPPORT
COMPENSATING THE BOARD FOR THE
NUMBER OF DAYS THEY ACTUALLY
WORK. FOR THE QUALIFIED
INDIVIDUALS MAY SERVE.
THE FINAL REFORM AT THE DISTRICT
WILL ENSURE APPROPRIATE
COMMUNITY REPRESENTATION.
BY REQUIRING THE APPOINTMENT TO
A VACANT BOARD.
THAT IS THAT THEY BAKER WHERE
THE VACANCY EXISTS RATHER THAN
FROM ANYWHERE IN THE COUNTY.
I I THINK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION
TODAY AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE.
WITH ME HERE TODAY IS THE CHAIR
OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE
SANTA CLARA VALLEY WATER
DISTRICT RICHARD SANTOS.
HE STILL.
FOR GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIRMAN
COMMITTEE MEMBERS A RICHER SET
OF THE CHAIR.
THEM LIKE CLOSER TO USER IF
THERE.
GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR
COMMITTEE MEMBERS A RICHER SET
OF THE CHAIR OF SENATOR VALLEY
WATER DISTRICT.
AND COURSE I YOUR JUDITH SUPPORT
A. B..
EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE EACH YEAR
pSENIORS WITH A PARTIAL TAX
EXEMPTION FAILED TO RETURN.
ANNUAL.
A INCOME VERIFICATION FORM.
AB EIGHTY NINE WILL HELP SOLVE
THIS PROBLEM WITH A ONE TIME
APPLICATION FOR ELIGIBILITY.
THAT IS A SMART.
THAT WILL BOTH COMPLY WITH THE
LAW.
AND KEEP LOW INCOME SENIORS FROM
OVER PAIN AND THE PARTIAL TAXES.
THIS BILL WILL INCREASE THE
NUMBER OF MEETING DAYS FOR WHICH
A WATER DISTRICT BOARD MEMBER
CAN RCEIVE REMOVED.
GREEN NUMERATION.
OUR WORK LOAD IS HEAVY AND SEEM
TO BE INCREASING EVERY YEAR.
THE ONE SIZE FITS ALL APPROACH.
IN CURRENT LAW ALLOWS THE SAME
NUMBER OF MEETINGS. TEN PER
MONTH WITH YOUR CURRENTLY NEW
WATER DISTRICTS SERVE IT TO
OTHER PEOPLE OR AS IN OUR CASE
MAKING WATER SUPPLY
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP AND
FLOOD PROTECTION DECISION FOR
NEARLY. TWO MILLION PEOPLE.
ON AVERAGE I WORK. SEVENTEEN TO
TWENTY TWO DAYS A MONTH.
MY FELLOW DIRECTORS WORK.
VIRTUALLY THE SAME AMOUNT OF
DAYS AT ANY GIVEN TIME OUR
DISTRICT HAS NUMEROUS MULTI.
HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR WATER
SUPPLY AND FLOOD PROTECTION
PROJECTS UNDERWAY.
WE MUST RESPOND TO OUR
CONSTITUENTS NEEDS THE BIG JOB.
WORKERS MOSTLY AND UNDERPAID.
AND UNLESS YOU'RE RETIRED YOU
CAN AFFORD TO SERVE ON THE
BOARD.
WHICH OF OUR DIRECTORS ARE
INDIVIDUALLY ELECTED FROM
DISTRICTS NEARLY THREE HUNDRED
THOUSAND PEOPLE AS YOU KNOW
PEOPLE WANT TO HEAR FROM.
I CORRESPOND WITH AND HAVE
ACCESS TO THEIR ELECTED
OFFICIALS WHO REPRESENT THEIR
NEIGHBORHOOD.
IT ALSO INCREASES THE CAPACITIVE
DIRECTORS TO REPRESENT THE
PUBLIC INTEREST.
MY PROVIDING MORE PUBLIC
OVERSIGHT OF WATER SUPPLY. FOR
PROTECTION GROUND WATER
MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS FOR THE
PEOPLE OF SENATOR COUNTY
PROBABLY.
THE BILL FIXES AN OLD FOR
PROVISION OF OUR DISTRICT ACT
THAT ALLOWS A MID TERM BOARD
VACANCY TO BE FILLED BY A PERSON
RESIGNING ANY OR A SANTA CLARA
COUNTY.
AB EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE WOULD
REQUIRE THAT.
ANY APPOINTMENTS BEFORE.
FROM THE ELECTED DISTRICTS
VACANT AND NOT.
HELLO FROM ANYWHERE IN THE
COUNTY.
ALL THESE THE CHARGES.
CHANGES ARE NUMEROUS AND REFORMS
THAT WILL HELP OUR WATER
DISTRICT FUNCTION BETTER AT
LOWER BOARD TO BETTER REPRESENT
THE PEOPLE.
WE CAN ELECT TO SERVE AYE ISSUE
TO SUPPORT EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE
AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
KILL.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES AND S. FIVE
PLEASE.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS ERIC
HARRIS.
I AM THE I REPRESENT THE
CALIFORNIA STATE CONFERENCE OF
THE NAACP.
IT B. EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE A
MAN'S THE SANTA CLARA WATER.
DISTRICT ACT. TO ADDRESS INCOME
BIAS IN STATE LAW TO
DISENFRANCHISE IS COMMUNITIES OF
COLOR.
CURRENTLY THE ONLY PEOPLE WHO
CAN AFFORD TO SERVE ON THE WATER
DISTRICT BOARD ARE EITHER
RETIRED WITH BIG PENSIONS OR
AB EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE FIXES
THE ONE SIZE FITS ALL.
STATUTE.
THAT HAS RESULTED IN NOT EVEN
ONE AFRICAN AMERICAN WATER
DISTRICT DIRECTOR AND ONLY TO
LATINOS. FOR ASIAN AMERICANS AND
FOR WOMEN TO HAVE EVER SERVED ON
THE WATER DISTRICT BOARD.
SINCE ITS ESTABLISHMENT IN.
NINETEEN TWENTY NINE SENATE
CLEAR COUNTY IS ONE OF THE MOST
DIVERSE JURISDICTIONS IN THE
NATION.
THE RACIAL GENDER AND SOCIO
ECONOMIC MAKEUP OF THE WATER
DISTRICT.
BOARD SHOULD REFLECT THE DIVERSE
COMMUNITIES IT SERVES AND AB
EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE ADDRESS IS
A MAJOR INCOME BARRIER CREATED
BY A ONE SIZE FITS ALL STATE
LAW.
CURRENT LAW LIMITING THE WATER
DISTRICT BOARD TO JUST TEN
COMPENSABLE MEETING DAYS PER
MONTH IS A DE FACTO INCOME TEST.
THAT PEOPLE OF COLOR OFTEN
CANNOT PASS.
THIS BILL ALSO FIXES AN OLD LAW
THAT ALLOWS WATER DISTRICT BOARD
VACANCIES TO BE FILLED.
ON AN AT LARGE BASIS BY A PERSON
REGARD RESIDING ANYWHERE IN
SANTA CLARA COUNTY.
LARGE APPOINTMENTS HAVE THE FACT
OF EXCLUDING COMMUNITIES OF
COLOR FROM LEADERSHIP POSITIONS.
CONSIDERING THE ONE SIZE FITS
ALL INCOME TESTS AND THE AT
LARGE APPOINTMENT PROCESS IT IS
NO SURPRISE THAT NO AFRICAN
AMERICANS AND VERY FEW WOMEN AND
OTHER PEOPLE OF COLOR.
HAVE EVER SERVED ON THE WATER
DISTRICT BOARD AND IT'S NEARLY
NINETY YEAR HISTORY.
IT IS IMPERATIVE THAT THIS
INJUSTICE BE CORRECTED TO THE
SMART REFORMS IN AB EIGHTEEN
EIGHTY NINE THE CALIFORNIA STATE
CONFERENCE OF THE NAACP
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
ON AB EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE THANK
YOU.
WE USUALLY ALLOWED TO WITNESSES
TO SPEAK IF YOU HAVE A COMMENT
MAYBE CAN JOIN IT PLEASE NO I
HAVE NO COMMENTS ON HERE FOR A
TENER EIGHT ANSWER THE TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS.
UMBRA KELLER CHIEF OF EXTERNAL
AFFAIRS FOR THE SENATE.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
PLEASE COME FORWARD AND STATE
YOUR NAME.
AFFILIATION AND I SUPPORT
[inaudible]
POSITION.
HELLO MY NAME IS AMELIA GOMEZ
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF LESSER
ROUNDTABLE THAT CALIFORNIA --
IN SUPPORT OF AB.
EIGHTEEN THANK YOU.
THEY KNOW WHAT'S UP WITH THE
CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL UTILITIES
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
MORNING ROUNDS OF AUSSIE WITH
THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
ASSOCIATION SUPPORT THANK YOU
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION.
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION IN
GENERAL THEN.
SEEN NONE COLLEAGUES
[inaudible]
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
SENATOR MOORE LA.
SANTOS ARE YOU THE RETIRED
MILLIONAIRE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
NUMBER RETIRED FIRE CAPTAIN OF
THIRTY THREE YEARS.
THAT A GOOD PENSION THEY HAD.
THANK YOU --
MADAM ASSEMBLY WOMAN WOULD YOU
LIKE TO PLEASE CLOSE
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WILL NOW
MOVE ON SINCE WE HAVE NO CORN
YET WILL MOVE ON TO ITEM FILE.
EIGHT AB.
TWENTY TWENTY THREE PLEASE GO
FOR GO AHEAD.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS I WANNA THANK THE
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THE WORK I
WILL BE SUGGEST ACCEPTING.
BUT SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS AND A
PLEASED TO PRESENT AB TWENTY
TWENTY THREE WHICH WOULD UPON.
AN ANNUAL BUDGET ACT MAKE THE
CALIFORNIA CHILD AND DEPENDENT.
CARE CREDIT.
CARE EXPENSES CREDIT REFUNDABLE
SO THAT LOW AND MODERATE INCOME
WORKING FAMILIES CAN BENEFIT
FROM THE CREDIT TO ASSIST WITH
THEIR CHILDCARE EXPENSES.
THIS IS A WORKING FAMILIES TAX
CREDIT. TO QUALIFY THE TAX
PROBLEM A SHOW THAT HERE SHE
INCURRED.
CHILDCARE EXPENSES IN ORDER TO
BE ABLE TO WORK THE CREDIT
ALLOWS TAXPAYERS WITH ADJUSTED
GROSS INCOMES BELOW ONE HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS TO REDUCE THEIR
TAX LIABILITY BY A PERCENTAGE.
OF THEIR ELIGIBLE CHILDCARE
EXPENSES IN TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN
AT AB AMIDST ALL OF THE BUDGET
SHORTFALLS THE CREDIT WAS MADE
NON.
REFUNDABLE WHAT THIS MEANS IS
THAT FAMILIES WITH INCOME BELOW
FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS GENERALLY
RECEIVE NO BENEFIT BECAUSE THEY
DON'T HAVE A STATE TAX LIABILITY
SO IT ENDED UP THAT THIS TAX
CREDIT HAS BEEN AVAILABLE.
FOR FAMILIES EARNING FIFTY TO A
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS BUT NOT
MUCH FOR FAMILIES BELOW FIFTY
THOUSAND DOLLARS WHICH IS
REALLY.
KIND OF PERVERSE SO --
SINCE THE WHEN WHEN THE CREDIT
WELL AS I SAID WHEN POOREST
FAMILIES BENEFITTED ASSISTING
THEM TO MEET THEIR BASIC
EXPENSES FOOD LAW HOUSING
TRANSPORTATION.
AND WE KNOW THAT THE CHAIR THE
CARE OF AB CHILDREN IS VERY
EXPENSIVE AND AN INCREASING
BURDEN ON CALIFORNIA'S WORKING
FAMILIES THE LACK OF ACCESS TO
AFFORDABLE CHILDCARE IS A HUGE
PROBLEM AND WE NEED MULTIPLE
SOLUTIONS THIS IS ONE OF THEM.
MAKING THE CREDIT REFUNDABLE
AGAIN WILL PUT MONEY BACK INTO
THE POCKETS OF THE FAMILIES THAT
ACTUALLY NEED IT THE MOST.
I'M HERE WITH ME TODAY TO TEST
TRANSPORT HAVE REMEMBER NOW WITH
THE CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC
CONFERENCE INCORPORATED.
I DON'T THINK THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN
FOR THIS VERY IMPORTANT BILL MY
NAME IS RAY BURNELL THE
CALIFORNIA CAO THE CONFERENCE
STRONGLY SUPPORTS AB.
TWENTY TWENTY THREE THIS BILL
WILL RESTORE THE REFUND ABILITY
OF OUR CALIFORNIA CHILD AND
DEPENDENT CARE TAX CREDIT.
SO THAT WORKING FAMILIES WITH
YOUNG CHILDREN CAN RECEIVE THE
SENSUAL SUPPORT TO AFFORD
QUALITY CHILDCARE.
ACCESS TO HIGH QUALITY CHILDCARE
AND EARLY EDUCATION NOT ONLY
PROMOTES A CHILD'S DEVELOPMENT.
BUT IT ALSO HEALTH SUPPORTS
PARENTS WHO ARE STRUGGLING TO
BALANCE WORK AND FAMILY
OBLIGATIONS.
WATER STATE FUNDS CHILDCARE
SLOTS FOR THE NEEDIEST CHILDREN
ONLY A SMALL PERCENTAGE OF LOW
INCOME CHILDREN ARE ENROLLED IN
THESE PROGRAMS.
THIS MEANS A SIGNIFICANT NUMBER
OF LOW INCOME FAMILIES MUST PAY
FOR CHILDCARE OUT OF THEIR
POCKETS OR FORGO EMPLOYMENT
BECAUSE THEY CANNOT AFFORD THE
COSTS.
AT THE SAME TIME MIDDLE INCOME
FAMILIES WHO DON'T QUALIFY FOR
STATE PROGRAMS ALSO STRUGGLE
WITH EXPENSIVE OUT OF POCKET
CHILDCARE COSTS.
WE SUPPORT AB TWENTY TWENTY
THREE BECAUSE IT WILL HELP
PARENTS GO TO WORK TO MEET THE
ECONOMIC CHALLENGES OF RAISING A
FAMILY.
AND IMPROVE ACCESS TO QUALITY
CHILDCARE ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF
ARE AGING POPULATION AND
PROJECTED SKILLED.
OZ SKILLED WORKFORCE NEEDS.
IN SO DOING EACH CHILD'S GOOD
EVERY FAMILY'S GOOD AND OUR
COMMON GOOD ARE ALL BENEFITTED
AND TRULY ENRICHED. FOR THESE
REASONS AS THE OFFICIAL PUBLIC
POLICY VOICE OF THE CATHOLIC
CHURCH IN CALIFORNIA WE ARE JR
AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME
AFFILIATION AND THE PETITION
DENNIS ALL BE ON OUR BEHALF THE
FAMILY BUSINESS ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA.
WHAT'S GOOD FOR THE WORKFORCE IS
GOOD FOR BUSINESS SINCE THAT WE
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING ALEX TO CAPRI ON
BEHALF OF FIRST FIVE CALIFORNIA
AND SUPPORT.
JIM LINDBERGH ON BEHALF OF THE
FRIEND'S COMMUNITY COMMITTEE ON
LEGISLATION THE CALIFORNIA OR IN
SUPPORT.
ANGELIQUE ARCHIVE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
AND SUPPORT.
I SHERMAN GO BLOOM ON BEHALF OF
THE WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
POVERTY IN SUPPORT.
WES SAM'S ON BEHALF OF UNITED
WAYS CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
RENDON CAROL ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CHILD DEVELOPMENT
ADMINISTERS ASSOCIATION AND
SUPPORT.
FIRST AMICORE AUTONOMY HAVE
ALAMEDA COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS ALSO SUPPORT
THINKING.
THANK YOU.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
OR JUST TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
SEEING NONE.
WHICH YOU LIKE TO PLEASE CLOSE.
ALL YOU HAVE A QUESTION THAT WE
CAN.
CAN LOOK THAT HE WANTED TO
QUESTIONS JUST. FOR THE EARNED
INCOME TAX CREDIT IS READY
REFUND.
HOW DID IN IRAQ WITH THE THE
CHILDCARE?
CREDIT WOULD YOU GIVE BOTH.
M. EACH YEAR FOR INTO THE EITC
IN REGARDS TO THIS YES.
YES SO THAT SO THEY'RE THEY'RE
THEY'RE DIFFERENT OUT ONE IS
BASED ON INCOME AND ONE IS BASED
ON WHETHER YOU HAVE CHILDCARE
EXPENSES AND YOU CAN'T CLAIM THE
CHILD CARE EXPENSES UNLESS YOU
HAVE THEM.
NUMBER NET AND I'M JUST THAT
SOME TO CONFIRMING THAT YES
APPLIED FOR BOTH YOU GET THEM
BOTH CORRECT SO.
THE GOVERNOR'S HAD A PRETTY GOOD
HISTORY OF VETOING CREDIT.
BILL SO WHAT MAKES YOU
OPTIMISTIC ABOUT THIS.
ONE WELL I A. M. WHEN AT THE THE
KEY PIECES OF OF THAT CHILDCARE
CREDIT.
INFORMATION IS THAT ON WHAT WE
KNOW ABOUT HER ABOUT VIOLENCE
AND DISTRESSING COMMUNITIES IS
THAT OPPORTUNITIES PROVIDE IT'S
A PROPHYLACTIC MEASURE FOR
CHILDREN UP THEY DO BETTER
ACADEMICALLY --
THEY ARE MORE SUCCESSFUL THEY
MAKE MORE MONEY LONGER TERM IF
THEY'RE IN GOOD CHILDCARE UMPS.
BAD SITUATIONS AND EARLY
CHILDHOOD EDUCATION REALLY
ADVANCES THAT SO I'M HOPING TO
APPEAL TO THE ECONOMICS OF THE
SITUATION WHICH IS THAT THE
STATE.
BENEFITS WHEN CHILDREN ARE
TAKING CARE OF A AT AN EARLY AGE
AND IT'S ALL A LOT ALL OF THE
RISKY BEHAVIORS THAT END UP
COSTING US A LOT OF MONEY IN
LATER YEARS --
THERE THERE'S AT AS I SAID A
PROPHYLACTIC EFFECT AND IT'S IT
HELPS US SO LONG TERM I THINK
THIS IS REALLY WHAT WERE WE NEED
TO GO WE NEED TO REALLY INVEST
IN CHILDREN.
AT THE EARLIEST OPPORTUNITY SO
THAT WE DON'T END UP WITH
PROBLEMS UP LATER IN LIFE AND SO
IT'S IT'S UP IT'S IT'S REALLY AT
A PREVENTION MEASURE THAT'S
GOING TO SAVE US MONEY IN THE
LONG RUN.
Q. SO I'M HOPING [inaudible]
HE AGREES.
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AM I JUST GOING TO ADD TO WHAT
YOU STATE ASSEMBLY MOMENT YOUR
ABSOLUTE RIGHT AND I'VE GOT A
SEVEN YEAR ON A FIVE YEAR OLD.
AND BOTH OF THEM --
HAD TO GO TO CHILD CARE BECAUSE
I'D BEEN WORKING --
AND THEY WERE BORN WHY I'VE BEEN
IN OFFICE AND SO ON I'VE WATCHED
CHILDREN IF YOU HAVE STARTED
DAY.
CHILDCARE.
OR DAYCARE WITH THEM AT EIGHT
MONTHS IN SIX MONTHS AND HOW
THEY DEVELOP AND THEN ON TO THE
NEXT.
YOU KNOW WHEN NEW KIDS COME IN
AT THREE FOUR FIVE YEARS OLD
[inaudible]
HUGE DIFFERENCE --
YOU KNOW ACADEMICALLY
[inaudible]
SOCIALLY.
I MEAN YOU NAME IT EVERYTHING
AND ANYTHING CAN COME INTO PLAY
ON AND AND SO IT'S I'M I'M A
HUGE SUPPORTER OF OF OF EARLY
YOU KNOW PRE K..
ON THE FIRST.
FIVE I I HAVE BEEN SEVERELY
BEFORE HAVING THE KIDS BUT I'VE
ACTUALLY PERSONALLY WITNESSES
TODAY ON HOW BENEFICIAL IT IS.
FOR MY CHILDREN AND FOR I
BELIEVE IT SHOULD BE FOR ALL
CHILDREN.
SO THANK YOU AND I'M.
WE WOULD NOT TAKE A VOTE AGAIN
BECAUSE WE DO NOT HAVE A QUORUM
--
WE WILL --
INDICATED A MOTION LATER THE
NEXT ITEM WOULD BE ITEM NUMBER
NINE AB.
TWENTY FIFTY WHAT A GOOD CAREER
--
THE ONLY [inaudible]
PERFECT [inaudible]
I SUPPORTED [inaudible]
YES.
THE HAY AND PLEASE GO FOR IT
DONE AND I YOU KNOW I I'M.
SORRY I HAVEN'T SET THE RULES
YET BUT SUPPORT EACH WITNESS CAN
NO MORE THAN TWO MINUTES PLEASE.
I NAY VIEW CAN WE DO HAVE A LONG
AGENDA CITY CAN JOIN YOUR
MESSAGES WE WOULD APPRECIATE IT.
PLEASE ASSEMBLY ONE THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR AND SENATORS I'M
PLEASED TO PRESENT AB.
TWENTY FIFTY THE SMALL SYSTEMS
WATER THIRTY ACT OF TWENTY
EIGHTEEN THE STATE WATER
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD HAS
IDENTIFIED NEARLY THREE HUNDRED
WATER SYSTEM STATEWIDE THAT
CHRONICALLY SERVE CONTAMINATED
DRINKING WATER.
AND CANNOT PROVIDE THE RESIDENTS
WITH A RELIABLE WATER SERVICE IT
IS UNACCEPTABLE FOR CALIFORNIANS
TO BE SO POORLY SERVED MANY OF
WHOM ARE MY CONSTITUENTS. ONE
METHOD FOR ADDRESSING THESE
PROBLEMS IS TO MERGE FAILING
SYSTEMS.
TRADITIONAL CONSOLIDATIONS MUCH
RELY ON A LARGER HOST AGENCY TO
FACILITATE THE CONSOLIDATION.
AB TWENTY FIFTY PROVIDES AN
ALTERNATE SOLUTION BY MERGING
SMALL NON COMPLIANTWATER
SYSTEMS INTO A LARGER MORE
ROBUST PUBLIC WATER SYSTEM THAT
CAN TAKE ADVANTAGE OF IMPROVED
ECONOMIES OF SCALE.
STREAMLINED MANAGERIAL FUNCTIONS
AND ENHANCED FINANCIAL
CAPACITIES AS A LARGER RATE
PAYER BASE.
THE MERGE SYSTEMS WILL BE FORMED
AS INDEPENDENT SPECIAL DISTRICTS
AND PROVIDED WITH NEW INTERNAL
AND EXTERNAL FINANCING
OPPORTUNITIES.
AND INCREASED TRANSPARENCY
INCLUDING INCLUDING AN ELECTED
BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
THE KNEW PUBLIC AUTHORITIES WILL
BE SCALED TO DEVELOP COORDINATE
FOR CONTRACTS THROUGH REGIONAL
AGREEMENTS IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
THE NECESSARY INFRASTRUCTURE TO
TREAT CONTAMINATION ISSUES.
THIS IN TURN WILL LEAD TO MORE
SUSTAINABLE.
DELIVER SAFE AND AFFORDABLE
DRINKING WATER.
AB TWENTY FIFTY BORROWS HEAVILY
FROM THE EXISTING MUNICIPAL
WATER DISTRICT ACT IN TERMS OF
HOW THE NEW SMALLER SYSTEMS ARE
CREATED.
IT ESTABLISHES A ROADMAP FOR THE
CONSOLIDATION OF MULTIPLE
SYSTEMS AND DOES NOT RELY ON A
LARGER HOST AGENCY WHICH IS
IMPORTANT AS MANY OF THE SYSTEMS
ARE NOT ADJACENT TO A LARGER
SYSTEM.
THAT ROADMAP UTILIZES EXISTING
STATUTORY PROVISIONS FOR MERGERS
DISSOLUTIONS AND CONSOLIDATIONS
IN THE LAST.
LASCAR LA WITH MY LOCAL
GOVERNMENT EXPERIENCE I FEEL
STRONGLY THAT THAT THE PROCESS
NEEDS TO BE DRIVEN LOCALLY IN AN
OPEN PUBLIC FORUM.
SO AFFECTED PARTIES MAY
PARTICIPATE THAT IS WHY THE BILL
DOES NOT SOLELY GIVE THE STATE
WATER.
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD
OWNERSHIP ALL OVER ALL OF THE
CONSOLIDATION PROCESS BUT
EMPOWERS THE BOARD WITH AN
IMPORTANT NEW TOOL TO FINALLY
ROLL UP SMALL FEELING OPERATORS.
IN NORTHERN TULARE COUNTY THE
CONSOLIDATION OF SEVEN SMALL
SYSTEMS HAS BEEN ONGOING FOR TEN
YEARS.
FROM FRANKLY I FIND FIND THAT
REALLY UNACCEPTABLE.
AB TWENTY FIFTY GIVES ABOARD A
NEW TOOL TO FINALLY DELIVER A
STATE CERTAIN FOR THOSE
RESIDENTS AND TULARE COUNTY AND
IN MONTEREY COUNTY AND
THROUGHOUT THE STATE THAT HAVE
SUFFERED WITH CONTAMINATED
WATER.
THREE YEARS AGOTHE LEGISLATURE
GAVE THE BOARD AUTHORITY TO
ORDER CONSOLIDATIONS BETWEEN
LARGE AND SMALL SYSTEMS.
IN THAT TIME JUST TO
CONSOLIDATIONS HAVE OCCURRED
MEANWHILE MANY OF MY CONSIDERS
SECOND STICK JOINTS CONTINUE TO
GO WITHOUT CLEAN WATER.
THE SOLUTION IN STATUTE CLEARLY
IS NOT SUFFICIENT TO PROTECT
CALIFORNIANS AS HUNDREDS OF
SYSTEMS AND MILLIONS OF
RESIDENTS STILL LACK CONSISTENT
CLEAN DRINKING WATER.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE IN WITH ME HERE TODAY IN
SUPPORT IS DEBBIE CHERNEY DEPUTY
GENERAL MANAGER FOR THE EASTERN
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT.
AGAIN AND DOT DANIELLE
BLANCHETTE DIRECT.
MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSOCIATION
PLEASE.
THANK YOU THANK YOU VICE CHAIR
NO AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
I AM DEBBIE TOURNEY DEPUTY
GENERAL MANAGER OF THE EASTERN
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT.
WE SERVE WATER WASTEWATER AND
RECYCLE WATER SERVICES TO EIGHT
HUNDRED TWENTY THOUSAND
RESIDENTS IN WESTERN RIVERSIDE
COUNTY.
FIRST I'D LIKE TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR TAKING UP AB
TWENTY FIFTH DAY A TODAY AND I'D
SPECIALLY LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CABALLERO FOR HER
COMMITMENT AND DEDICATION TO THE
ISSUE.
OVER THE PAST DECADE MW DIS
GENERAL MANAGER PAUL JONES AND I
HAVE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE
INVOLVED IN NUMEROUS SUCCESSFUL
CONSOLIDATIONS.
INCLUDING MOST RECENTLY A SMALL
FAILING SYSTEMS HERE SERVING A
SEVERELY DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITY
IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
THE VAST MAJORITY OF FAILING
SYSTEMS LACK THE FINANCIAL
RESOURCES ECONOMIES OF SCALE
TECHNICAL CAPABILITIES AND RATE
BASE TO MEET THEIR CUSTOMERS
BASIC WATER NEEDS.
THE MOST EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT
WAY TO SHOULD ENSURE SAFE
DRINKING WATER FOR THESE
COMMUNITIES.
IT'S TO CHANGE THE WATER SERVICE
DELIVERY MODEL MAY REFORMING THE
SMALL CHRONICALLY NONCOMPLIANT
SYSTEMS INTO LARGER CONFIDENT
WATER AGENCIES.
BY ELIMINATING OPERATIONAL
REDUNDANCIES IN EXCESS OF
OVERHEAD RATES WE BELIEVE THE
OUT OF CRIME COMPLIANT SYSTEMS
CAN BE TRANSFORMED FREEING UP
RATE REVENUE TO USE FOR CORE
OPERATIONS IN BE SUBSTANTIALLY
MORE ATTRACTIVE TO HIRE
COMPETENT PROFESSIONAL STAFF.
WE BELIEVE AB TWENTY FIFTY
PROVIDES A POWERFUL ADDITIONAL
TOOL THAT WILL SIGNIFICANTLY
ACCELERATE THE NUMBER OF
COMMUNITY WATER SYSTEMS THAT CAN
BE BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE.
IN DEVELOPING THE BILL WOULD
SEEM YOU AND THE AUTHORS OFFICE
WE'VE COORDINATED WITH MULTIPLE
STAKEHOLDERS AND EXPERTS
INCLUDING MUTUAL AND PRIVATE
WATER COMPANY ASSOCIATIONS.
LAUGH CHO REPRESENTATIVES PUBLIC
WATER PROVIDERS ENVIRONMENTAL
JUSTICE ADVOCATES AND THE STATE
WATER BOARD REPRESENTATIVES.
THE RESULT IS A BILL THAT
PROVIDES A DEFINED STEP BY STEP
PROCESS AND TIMELINE TO EITHER
BRING INTO COMPLIANCE OR
DISSOLVE AND REFORM SYSTEMS THAT
ARE THREATENING PUBLIC HOUSE.
HE FLATTENED MASS FORWARD A
LITTLE BIT EVEN THOUGH THE BY
TEN SECONDS YES SO --
FOR DISSOLVED PRIVATE WATER
COMPANIES FORMER OWNERS ARE
COMPENSATED THROUGH DEFINE
VALUATION PROCESS WHICH TAKES
INTO ACCOUNT THE VALUE OF SYSTEM
ASSETS WHAT DEDUCTING
LIABILITIES INCLUDING THE COST
TO BRING THE FAILING SYSTEMS
INTO CONTEMPORARY.
DRINKING WATER STANDARDS IN
SUMMARY WE BELIEVE THIS IS AN
IMPORTANT TOOL TO ADD TO THE
TOOL BOX.
AND TAKE A COMPREHENSIVE
SYSTEMATIC APPROACH THAT WILL
RESULT IN THE PERMANENT
REDUCTION OF HUNDREDS OF FAILING
WATER SYSTEMS.
IT'S FOR THESE REASONS THAT I
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR AYE VOTE
NOT AB TWENTY FIFTY THANK YOU
THANK YOU.
ANY WHAT'S WITH CALIFORNIA
MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSOCIATION
GOOD MORNING WE ARE PROUD TO
BECAUSE SPONSORS AND SUPPORTERS
OF AB TWENTY FIFTY AND
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S EFFORTS.
ON THIS ISSUE --
AS MY COLLEAGUE NOTED AB.
STATES CONSOLIDATION AUTHORITY
AND SETS OF THE UNIQUE PROCESS
FOR CONSOLIDATION THAT WHILE
COMPLEMENTARY DOES NOT MERELY
THE EXISTING AUTHORITIES THERE
ARE SEVERAL IMPORTANT REASONS
FOR THAT FIRST WE BELIEVE A
LOCALLY CONTROLLED PUBLIC
PROCESS IS ESSENTIAL TO LONG
LASTING GOOD GOVERNANCE.
CUSTOMERS CAN AND SHOULD FULLY
PARTICIPATE IN DECISIONS RELATED
TO THE DELIVERY OF SAFE DRINKING
WATER IN THEIR COMMUNITIES.
AB TWENTY FIFTY AND SHRINES
FUNDAMENTAL STEPS THAT IN
CERTAIN COMMUNITIES WILL HAVE A
VOICE IN THE FUTURE OF THEIR
WATER SUPPLY FROM ENGAGEMENT
WITH THE COUNTY LAST GO. TO
REPRESENTATION ON A LOCALLY
ELECTED BOARD OF DIRECTORS
SECOND AND INCLUDES FIRM
DEADLINES THROUGHOUT THE PROCESS
HAVING A DEFINITIVE TIMELINE IS
ESSENTIAL WHEN THE STATE BOARD
AND DOES IMPOSE DEADLINES TO
THEIR EXISTING MANDATORY
CONSOLIDATION AUTHORITY.
THEY WORK WE RECOGNIZE IT WILL
TAKE SIGNIFICANT RESOURCES TO
IMPLEMENT THIS BILL BUT WE ALL
MUST STOP AND THINK FOR A MOMENT
ABOUT THE COST OF DOING NOTHING
OR CONTINUING IN A PATTERN.
WHERE THERE'S ONLY BEEN TWO
MANDATORY CONSOLIDATIONS IN
THREE YEARS EVEN AFTER INCLUDING
VOLUNTARY CONSOLIDATIONS ARE
STILL OVER THREE HUNDRED
SYSTEMS?
AND HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
PEOPLE WITH ACT WITHOUT ACCESS
TO SAFE DRINKING WATER THE TIME
IS NOW TO ADDRESS THESE
CHALLENGES FACING OUR STATE AB
TWENTY FIFTY PROVIDES
SUSTAINABLE PATH FORWARD TO HELP
ACHIEVING THAT GOAL AND WE URGE
DRIVE OF THANK YOU SO MUCH MAN.
AND I'M JUST SO VERY GREAT FROM
IN THE OF YOUR HERE AND I'M
SORRY ABOUT COME IN HALF WAY TO
YOUR TESTIMONY I DO NOT MEAN TO
BE SLOT ON THAT.
THAT WAS UP IN ELECTIONS SO I DO
APOLOGIZE GROUP.
BUT ISN'T IT WHEN I WOULD LIKE
TO BE A WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT AND WE ASK YOU TO PLEASE
KEEP TO YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME
YOUR ORGANIZATION WELCOME TO
COMMITTING THANK YOU FOR BEING
HERE.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN FIRST
DEATH A LOSS ON BEHALF OF INLAND
EMPIRE UTILITIES AGENCY THE
SANTA WATERSHED PROJECT
AUTHORITY AND THE CUCAMONGA
VALLEY WATER STITCH DISTRICT ALL
IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIR JOHN O'MALLEY ON BEHALF OF
MISSILE WATER DISTRICT.
IN WEST BASS MUNICIPAL WATER
DISTRICT IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ONE OF THEM.
MONNING MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE PAMELA MILLER WITH
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION
COMMISSIONS AND WE OWE SUPPORT
THIS EFFORT.
I DO WANT TO SAY IF YOU JUST
INDULGING FOR JUST A MOMENT WE
HAVE BEEN WORKING WITH THE
SPONSORS AND THE AUTHOR FOR
ABOUT SIX MONTHS ON THIS.
THIS IS A COMPLICATED PROBLEM BY
AND YOU KNOW IF ITERA IF THERE
WAS SOLUTIONS THAT WERE EASY.
THERE WOULDN'T BE THIS MANY
PEOPLE WITHOUT A DRINKING WATER.
SO WE REALLY APPRECIATE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO BE INVOLVED IN
THE PROCESS WE FULLY SUPPORT
LOCAL DECISIONS AND AND WE THINK
THAT THE PROCESS OUTLINED IN AB
TWENTY FIFTY ACTUALLY WORK SO --
WE WOULD SUPPORT THE MEASURE
THANK YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
HIM.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE PAUL
GIVES ALL OF US HERE TODAY ON
BEHALF OF THE ORANGE COUNTY
WATER DISTRICT WOULD LIKE TO
THANK THE SINCE THE ASSEMBLY
WOMAN FOR HER LEADERSHIP ON THIS
ISSUE AND ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH GOOD MORNING
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS ADAM CAN UNITS ON BEHALF
OF THE ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
WATER AGENCIES REPRESENTING
APPROXIMATELY FOUR HUNDRED FIFTY
PUBLIC WATER AGENCIES IN SUPPORT
THINKING.
MORNING MA'AM MORNING CAROLYN
JENSEN ON BEHALF OF WESTERN
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT IN
SUPPORT.
MAKE.
CORNY SIR THAT ROBIN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA WATER ASSOCIATION IN
STRONG SUPPORT I THINK YOU.
GOOD MORNING TO YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS MARINO HEREIN
REPRESENTING THE IRVINE RANCH
WATER DISTRICT IN VERY STRONG
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE WHICH IS
BASED ON LENGTHY EXPERIENCE IN
THE FIELD.
GOING.
MORNING.
THE MORNING STEPHANIE MORAL
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF MUTUAL WATER
COMPANIES IN SUPPORT.
YOU SO MUCH GOOD MORNING GOOD
MORNING CARA ALSO BE UP THE CITY
OF SACRAMENTO IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL COURTESY.
MORNING MINING THERESA BROKERAGE
ON BEHALF OF CERES AND THE LOCAL
DIRECTORS OF ENVIRONMENTAL
HEALTH AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
GOOD MORNING.
MORNING BOARD ROOM SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT IN STRONG
SUPPORT HERE TANKERS AND VISITED
A GOOD MORNING REYES TIMES OF
METROPOLITAN WATER DISTRICT OF
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ALSO IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE
GOOD MORNING SIR.
MORNING --
SPENCER SAXON THE GUELPH CHO
GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE LONG
BEACH WATER DEPARTMENT AND THE
SAN MARINO VALLEY MINUTES BUT
WATER DISTRICT IN SUPPORT EVER
BUSINESS WELCOME.
GOOD MORNING.
MORNING.
ROUND DRAW SEE WITH THE
CALIFORNIA SPECIALIST THANK YOU
SIR.
WHY DON'T WE ONLY BE HALF OF
SANTA CLARA VALLEY WATER AGENCY
WE SUPPORT?
THANK YOU SO MUCH OF AN PLAYS
JOEY THAT VIDEO AND ALL --
LAST CALL LAST CALL FOR THOSE
WHO ARE IN SUPPORT.
WE ARE NOW GONNA BE TURNED OVER
TO A LEGEND HERE THE COMMITTEE
WE HAVE MISTER WOLF ARE WHO WILL
BE LEADING US OFF IN OPPOSITE.
IT'S WHAT IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU
AYE IT IS HAD TO BE A CRAZY WEEK
FOR YOU YES YES HERMAN HOUSE
WHEN INDEED AND WELCOME BACK TO
YOU SIR IT'S GOOD TO HAVE YOU
BACK I APOLOGIZE MEMBERS THE
MORNING DAVID WILL FOOT THE
HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION --
TB TWENTY FIFTY HERE TODAY.
MEMBERS LET ME JUST START OUT BY
SAYING WE DO APPRECIATE --
AN AMENDMENT TAKEN TO THIS BILL
IN THE ASSEMBLY REGARDING THE
REDUCTION OF THE AMOUNT OF
STANDBY CHARGES THAT WOULD BE
COLLECTED BY THE AUTHORITY WE DO
APPRECIATE THAT AMENDMENT. TO
MISTER CHAIRMAN WERE ALSO
SYMPATHETIC --
TO THIS BILL IN GENERAL I WOULD
SAY CONSOLIDATIONS FOR SOME THE
SMALL WATER DISTRICTS ARE
APPROPRIATE IF THEY'RE DONE
CORRECTLY AND I THINK --
YOU KNOW THE LAUGHTER PROCESS IN
THIS BILL IN THE FORMATION THERE
AND IS LARGELY APPROPRIATE
MEMBERS I WOULD.
MENTION THA THERE'S A MILLION
PEOPLE OR A NOUN THE STATE
WITHOUT ACCESS TO CLEAN DRINKING
WATER WE DO RECOGNIZE THAT THIS
IS A SERIOUS CONCERN.
AND WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH AQUA
AND OTHERS CLOSELY TO ENSURE
THAT THIS SITUATION IS RESOLVED
HOWEVER.
THERE'S A PORTION IN THIS BILL
THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE VOTER
APPROVAL FOR LONG TERM DEBT.
WE'VE ALWAYS BELIEVED THAT ANY
DATA FOR ANY PROJECT APPROVED BY
LOCAL VOTER SHOULD REQUIRE TWO
THIRDS VOTER APPROVAL.
BECAUSE THE BONDS BEING ISSUED
MISTER CHAIRMAN IN THIS CASE ARE
REVENUE BONDS VOTER APPROVAL FOR
US REMAINS ABSOLUTELY IMPERATIVE
WE ACTUALLY SUPPORTED A
STATEWIDE INITIATIVE THAT WOULD
REQUIRE VOTER APPROVAL. FOR A
WIDE NUMBER REVENUE BONDS JUNE
TWO YEARS AGO AND MEMBERS IT'S
ESPECIALLY TRUE SINCE REVENUE
BONDS UNLIKE STATE GENERAL
OBLIGATION BONDS.
DON'T HAVE THE FULL FAITH AND
CREDIT OF A GENERAL FUND SO FOR
ALL THOSE THAT THINK VERY VALID
REASONS I'D ASK FOR ANOTHER.
WHEN MANAGING MONEY REDUCING
YOURSELF THAT YOU HAVE TWO
MINUTES WE WERE COMMUNICATING?
HE THE SENIOR LEADERSHIP COUNCIL
FOR JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY
AND WE OF COURSE APPRECIATE AND
SHARE THE AUTHORS AND SPONSORS
COMMITMENT TO SAFE DRINKING
WATER --
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA IN ANGRY
WITH THE NEED TO ADDRESS
GOVERNMENTS AS WELL AS CAN
FINANCIAL CONSTRAINTS TO ADDRESS
THE ISSUE.
COME UNFORTUNATELY AS CURRENTLY
DRAFTED WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT
TWENTY FIFTY ADDRESSES THE THE
OBSTACLES CURRENTLY IN PLACE FOR
CALIFORNIANS THROUGHOUT THE
STATE.
UMPQUA AB TWENTY FIFTY PRESENTS
WHAT COULD BE A VIABLE OPTION
FOR SOME WATER SYSTEMS YOU
CREATE A PROCESS THAT SIMPLY
WILL NOT WORK FOR MOST WHAT
COSTING THE STATE AND LOCAL
AGENCIES SIGNIFICANT TIME AND
MONEY.
IGNORING THE SEVERAL TOOLS THAT
WE THE CURRENTLY.
THE STATE HAS AT THIS POINT TO
ADDRESS DRINKING WATER ON UNSAFE
DRINKING WATER.
AB TWENTY FIFTIES PREMISES THAT
BY GROUPING FAILING SYSTEMS
TOGETHER TO CREATE ECONOMIES OF
SCALE WE WILL CURE ALL ILLS
HOWEVER.
AS THE THE COMMITTEES ANALYSIS
POINTED OUT.
TOGETHER COULD SIMPLY FOR WAIT
FOR GOVERNANCE.
AB TWENTY FIFTY CREATES AN
ARBITRARY THRESHOLD OF FIVE
SYSTEMS WHEN WHAT THEN BECOMES
OF THE FIVE FAILING SYSTEMS ARE
THREE FAILING SYSTEMS ARE TO
FAILING SYSTEMS.
THAT ARE DEEMED A PILOT SUBJECT
TO CONSOLIDATION TODAY SIMPLY
STAND ANNA ANNA.
IN PURGATORY WAITING FOR OTHER
SYSTEMS TO FAIL UNABLE TO ACCESS
THE OTHER TOOLS AT THEIR
DISPOSAL SUCH AS FUNDING
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE ETCETERA --
IT IS UNCLEAR IF AND HOW AB
TWENTY FIFTY INTERACTS WITH THE
SEVERAL TOOLS OF THE STATE
ALREADY HAS SB.
EIGHTY EIGHT S. B. FIVE FIVE TWO
AND CETERA TO ADDRESS CHECKING
WATER DEFICIENCIES OF A
COMMUNITY IS WITHIN A HUNDRED
YARDS OF A LARGE SUSTAINABLE
SYSTEM WOULD SB EIGHTY EIGHT THE
STATE'S CURRENT CONSOLIDATION
AUTHORITY COME INTO PLAY.
OVER THE COMMUNITY ANSWER THE AB
TWENTY FIFTY FRAMEWORK AND BE
SUBJECT TO THE CUMBERSOME COSTLY
AND UNCERTAIN PROCESS THAT AB
TWENTY FIFTY LAYS OUT.
RATHER THAN SIMPLY CONNECTING TO
A NEIGHBORING SYSTEM --
THAT THE THE OFFERING HER
COMMENTS IDENTIFIED TO OBSTACLES
THAT WE CURRENTLY SEE ONE AS THE
NORTH TULARE.
ON CONSOLIDATION PROCESS BASED
ON OUR EXPERIENCE NORTH TULARE
THE OBSTACLE THERE IS FUNDING IT
IS SIMPLY A FUNDING ISSUE.
IT ISN'T AN ISSUE OF GOVERNMENT
OBSTACLES AROUND GOVERNANCE AND
AGREED DEFINITELY THAT THERE
HAVE BEEN OBSTACLES TO
CONSOLIDATIONS AN SPD A CONTEXT.
AND WE'RE WORKING WITH I'M WITH
HIM.
S. B. EIGHT CURRENTLY HAS TO IN
AND IN ORDER TO FACILITATE MORE
CONSOLIDATIONS IF THIRTY SECONDS
AGAIN WE VERY MUCH APPRECIATE
THE TOOL THAT AS A BABY FIT
TWENTY FIFTY PRESENTS.
AND WE THINK THAT IT COULD BE A
VIABLE TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX BUT
AS CURRENTLY DRAFTED WE SEE THAT
IT TAKES PRECEDENCE OVER OTHER.
VIABLE SUCCESSFUL TOOLS AND
ABOVE ALL CANNOT SUCCEED WITHOUT
A BY A LONG TERM SUSTAINABLE
FUNDING SOURCE TO SUPPORT ITS
ITS GOALS THANKS TO MY HE
SWITCHED THE CUTEST RANGING
GRATEFUL.
WHEN I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME
THOSE WHO OPPOSE FOR AN*
YOUR FIRST LASSEN ORGANIZATION
AS WELL I IS YOUR POSITION ON
THE BILL GOOD MORNING JENNIFER
CLARY ON BEHALF OF CLEAN WATER
ACTION?
AND COMMUNITY WATER SENATOR --
ALIGNING OURSELVES WITH
LEADERSHIP COUNSEL'S COMMENTS IN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU MCVICKER.
WELCOMING THE MORNING.
THE SCENE MASSEY ALSO A
COMMUNITY WATER CENTER IN
OPPOSITION THE REASONS EXPRESSED
BY MY COLLEAGUES THINKING
BECAUSE MUCH OF BEING HERE.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO OPPOSE
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSED.
BUT TO BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE TODAY TO SEE IF WE
HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
PLEASE ENTER MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I'M JUST
WONDERING JOBFINCHER USING
LAUGHED CHO.
WOULD THE NOT DO A VERY
THOROUGH REVIEW ON THE
CONSOLIDATION TO MAKE SURE THERE
IS ENOUGH REVENUE.
TO YOU KNOW THAT THAT THAT THE
MERGER TELEVISION TO MAKE SENSE
OF YES THAT THAT WOULD BE
REQUIRED.
THAT'S PART OF THEIR THERE'S THE
SERVICES THAT THEY RENDER WHEN
THEY WHEN THEY DO AN ANALYSIS
BACK WE SAW THEM.
HOW DO WE HOW DO WE HELP BUT
DISTRICT THAT REALLY DOESN'T
HAVE REVENUE SOURCE WE'RE JUST
GONNA RELY ON THE [inaudible]
COUNTY WIDE.
DISTRIBUTOR CREATING TO SOMEHOW
BUT RAISE RATES HER SPREAD.
SPREAD THE COSTS AMONGST OTHER
RATEPAYERS IN OTHER AREAS OF THE
COUNTY.
I THINK WHAT WE'RE WE'RE
PROBABLY GONNA FIND IS IS
EXACTLY WHAT THE COST IS GOING
TO BE.
IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO DO A
CONSOLIDATION WHAT KIND OF
UPGRADES ARE GOING TO BE NEEDED
IN THAT HAS TO BE ARTICULATED IN
A REPORT --
AND IF THERE ARE STATE RESOURCES
THAT ARE NEEDED IN ORDER TO BE
ABLE TO HELP DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES AND THERE ARE STATE
RESOURCES THE CHALLENGES GETTING
THOSE RESOURCES.
INTO A FAILING SYSTEM DOESN'T
HELP.
WE CONTINUE OR IT DOESN'T HELP
THE SYSTEM TO PROVIDE THAT CLEAN
WATER WHAT WE WHAT WHAT WE WANT
IS FOR THEM TO HAVE THE MISSION
OF CLEANING THE WATER.
AND THEN PROVIDING A AT THE RATE
PAYERS WITH THE RATE THAT THEY
CAN AFFORD BECAUSE MANY OF THESE
ARE AND DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES AND THAT'S PART OF
THE CHALLENGE AS WELL.
AND SO YOU'RE GIVING THEM
PERMISSION TO ISSUE REVENUE --
BONDS -- IT.
I I I DON'T SEE A PROBLEM WITH
THAT IF YOU HAVE AN ON GOING
[inaudible]
RATE.
PAYER REVENUE STREAM --
SO I'M JUST CURIOUS MR WOLF --%
HELP ME OUT OF IT IZZARD
DISTRICT THAT.
FAILED TO PAY ITS --
REVENUE BONDS AND AND HAD AN
ISSUE.
ISTER MARLAND THANKS FOR THE
QUESTION WERE NOT AWARE OF A
SPECIFIC DISTRICT I THINK OUR
OPPOSITION TO BE MORE BASED ON
PHILOSOPHICAL RATIONALES AND
THAT ANY TIME.
THERE IS A NEW ISSUANCE HAVE ANY
LONG TERM DEBT AND ANY KIND EVEN
REVENUE BY.
YOU THINK THAT SHOULD REQUIRE A
TWO THIRDS VOTE IN THIS WOULD BE
A NEW AUTHORIZATION.
SO.
I WOULDN'T THE BOND HOLDERS BE
AT RISK WITH THE REVENUE BOND.
IF I MEAN IF THE IF IF THAT
WATER DISTRICT DIDN'T PAY OR
FAILED TO PAY.
THEN THEN THEY WOULD DEFAULT ON
THE BOND HOLDERS RIGHT.
THEY WERE DEFAULT ON THE BOND
HOLDERS IS TOMORROW AT CORRECT
WITH THAT COULD RUN THE RISK OF
PAYMENT BY GENERAL TAXPAYERS
OBVIOUSLY IN THE EVENT OF A
DEFAULT BECAUSE AGAIN REVENUE
BONDS DON'T HAVE THE FULL FAITH
AND CREDIT OF A MUNICIPALITIES
GENERAL FUND.
RIGHT BUT IF THEY WERE IN
DEFAULT THEY PROABLY GO TO
CHAPTER NINE BANKRUPTCY COURT.
PROBABLY HAVE THE DEBT FORGIVEN
RIGHT.
MR MAROC AFTER A CERTAIN POINT I
pKNOCKING ARGUE WITH THE CPA.
JIM THAT'S A MISS WHAT THE
LEGEND HERE IN THE COMMITTEE
COUNSELOR. TO APPLY I HOW I HOLD
YOUR YOUR CONCERNS IN HIGH
REGARD THAT'S WHY I'M ASKING THE
QUESTIONS--
BECAUSE I SEE THIS IS IT'S MAYBE
A SMALL SMALL ISSUE IN IN THE
BIG PICTURE OF WHAT THIS.
BILL IS TRYING TO DO SO.
YOU KNOW I DON'T WANT TO
DISAPPOINT YOU BUT I I I MAY BE
SUPPORTING THIS BILL BUT I IF
YOU CAN GIVE ME A RELEASED YOU
KNOW SOME HISTORY OF WHERE WE'VE
HAD.
REVENUE BONDS THAT THEY HAVE TO
HAVE REALLY CAUSE SOME
DISRUPTION.
THAT'S THAT WOULD BE DEBT I'D
LOVE TO OUR HISTORY HAVE LIKE TO
HAVE.
AYE NINETY MORRIS CENTER BE MORE
THAN WILLING TO TRACK THAT DOWN
WE MAY HAVE SOME EXAMPLES IN OUR
OFFICE.
THANK YOU PRETTY WELL THANK YOU
MISTER.
IT'S WHAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE
IF WE NEED TO SHOW QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS AND I DO KNOW THAT WE
HAVE.
SOME MEMBER GRAY HERE WHO HAS A
NEW.
FLIGHT IN FIFTY MINUTES THAT I
AND HE'S OCCURRED UP SO WE GOTTA
MAKE SURE THAT WE MOVE ON THIS
BUT I MISS CARRIER WOULD LIKE TO
BE OF VALUE.
QUITE YEAH EXACTL HOW DAY.
I WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE TO
ATTENDED OVER DECENTLY WOMAN
I'VE EVER CLOSING COMMENTS
PLEASE THINK YOU AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH UP WE'RE GOING
TO HOLD ON THAT JUST BECAUSE WE
HAVE A SUBCOMMITTEE THIS MOMENT
ONCE I THINK YOU CAN SKIP YOUR
FOR ALL THE HARD WORK.
BY IT I KNOW IT WASN'T HEARING
THE PEOPLE STILL WANT TO SAY
THANK YOU FOR WORKING WITH US ON
THE SENATE CLARA VALLEY WATER
DISTRICT BILL.
THANK YOU VERY THANK YOU TO ALL
OF OUR WITNESSES THANK YOU.
WE'RE NOT ANY MOVING OVER --
TO MISTER GRAY THIS IS FILE ITEM
TWENTY FIVE THAT MR GREY.
AB TWENTY NINE SEVEN THREE
ENJOYS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
BOB ONE TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU'RE
GONNA BE TAKING THE AMENDMENTS
AND WE WELCOME A TRUNCATED
PRESENTATIONS ARE THE FORESHORES
PUBLIC TAKE.
YES I UPDATE COMMITTEE AND THE
CHAIR FOR ALL THE AMENDMENTS
WILL BE ACCEPTING THOSE TODAY OF
THIS IS A MAP EXTENSION FOR
ECONOMICALLY BREAST COUNTIES NOW
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
DON'T YOU THINK.
A THEIR OTHER THAT.
HE WAS HE THINKING THIS IN THE
MEMBER FOR ALL OF THE WORKING
WORKING WITH US IS WELL I AM
VERY GRATEFUL IN THERE BUT FOR
THE COLLABORATION WE'D LIKE TO
BETTER SEE IF WE HAVE ANYONE IN
SUPPORT.
OF FILE ITEM TWENTY FIVE IF YOU
PLEASE COME FORWARD THIS TIME
THOSE IN SUPPORT PLEASE ADVANCED
LAST CALL.
ELECTED TO SEE IF WE HAVE THOSE
WHO ARE OPPOSED IF THEY COULD
PLEASE COME FORTH THIS TIME.
OPPOSED LAST CALL BRING IT BACK
TO COMMITTEE THEY'RE MORE LIKE
GET TWENTY FIVE MINUTES FOR THE
QUESTION SIR.
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT HE HOOKED UP
PUMPKIN AND GIVEN A HARD TIME I
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
THE COMMITTEE IT'S IT AT THIS
TIME.
MR YOU DO ENJOY BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON THIS BILL I WE WILL
TAKE IT UP AS SOON AS WE HAVE A
QUORUM WOULD YOU LIKE TO MAKE A
CLOSING STATEMENT.
THANK YOU THE COMMITTEE AND
THANK YOU TO SENATE MORLOCK
PFIZER INC THINK VERY HARD WORK
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
LADIES GENTLEMEN UP WE'RE GOING
TO NEED TO TAKE A EIGHTY FIVE
MINUTE RECESS --
WE HAVE TWO BILLS THAT WE ARE
CONTINUING TO WORK ON THAT ARE
GOING TO BE HEARD TODAY WHICH I
THINK WE'RE GETTING VERY CLOSE.
AT TO AGREEMENT ON IN WE DO SEEM
TO BE A TOUCH BASE ON THOSE SO
WE'RE GONNA DO A FIVE MINUTE
RECESS I APOLOGIZE ABLE
RECONVENE WE DO NOT HAVE AN
OFFER ANYWAY.
ABOUT FIVE MINUTES WILL BE BACK
WITH YOU THINK YOU
I AS YOU KNOW
THERE ARE --
BUT IF YOU BILLS THAT ARE MOVING
THIS WEEK IN THERE ARE A FEW
THAT WE ARE STILL TRYING TO NAIL
DOWN THE DETAILS ON THAT AND
WE'RE VERY YEAR GETTING VERY
CLOSE.
WE MAY NEED TO TAKE ONE
ADDITIONAL RECESS HERE AYE IN
THE NEXT HALF HOUR FORTY FIVE
MINUTES ON THAT WE'RE GETTING
CLOSE AND DO APPRECIATE YOUR
PATIENCE ALLOWS FLEXIBILITY.
THAT WILL MAKE A NOTE WE'RE
GOING TO HAVE TO VACATE THIS AYE
ROOM AT ONE FIFTEEN TODAY.
I AND WE WILL RECONVENE AFTER
ENERGY COMMITTEE SAID ENERGY
INCIDENT ENERGY SHOULD AND
AROUND NINE FORTY FIVE THIS
EVENING.
SO -- MISTER
WOLF IS BRINGING THE MARGARITAS
AND COFFEE SO I THINK IT'S SO
MUCH BOB WE'RE GOING TO IT AND
INVITE --
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM EAST BAY
ON FILE ITEM FIVE EIGHTY NINE
TWENTY FOUR TO BE A TO COME
FORWARD MISTER BONTA --
I WANNA BEFORE MISTER BUT GETS
GOING I WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO
SAY THANK YOU TO HIM --
IS WELL AS HIS WITNESSES THERE
ARE.
QUITE A FEW FOLKS WHO HAVE BEEN
WORKING A LONG TIME ON THIS
ISSUE.
AND AND I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
TO THIS IN THE MEMBER FOR
WORKING WITH OUR COMMITTEE ON AB
--
NINE TWENTY FOUR THIS COMMITTEE
WILL BE ADVANCING ALONG WITH THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER --
AMENDMENTS FROM THE SENATE
COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND
PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT.
AND WE'RE GOING TO BE ABLE TO
CONTINUE TO DISCUSS BUT THIS
BILL AS IT'S AMENDED
[inaudible]
BOB AND THE SEVEN MEMBER AND HAS
BEEN.
ON THE TIP OF THE SPEAR AS WE'VE
BEEN MOVING FORWARD WITH
LEGALIZATION BOTH ON MEDICAL AS
WELL AS RECREATIONAL FOR SEVERAL
YEARS NOW --
HE HAS.
BEEN FIGHTING FOR ACCESS BY AND
HE'S BEEN --
IN THE MIDDLE OF QUITE A FEW
BATTLES AND I JUST WANT TO SAY
THANK YOU DECEMBER WERE BONTA
FOR ALL OF HIS WORK AND WHY
WE'VE MADE TREMENDOUS STRIDES IN
DEVELOPING A SYSTEM.
FOCUS ON NATIVE AMERICAN
COMMUNITIES I STILL THINK WE
HAVE A WAYS TO GO ON A AND THE
SIMPLY MEMBER --
SENATOR HILL WHOSE CHAIR BITS AS
WELL AS OUR COMMITTEE ARE
COMMITTED TO CONTINUE WORK
THROUGH BY THE NEXT THIRTY TO
FORTY FIVE DAYS OR SO HARD TO BE
ABLE TO GET THIS RIGHT.
AYE IN AGAIN I JUST WANT TO SAY
THANK YOU SO MUCH TIED TO THE
SIMILAR BURKE TO ALL OF THOSE
HAVE BEEN WORKING WE HAVE --
FORMALLY TO THE GOVERNOR
BUSTAMANTE WHOSE HERE'S WELL
ONCE I THINK YOU LOOK TO THE
GOVERNOR FOR ALL OF HIS WORKING
WERE HONORED THAT HE IS IN OUR
PRESENCE TODAY IT'S WELL.
UNDER TURN THE FLOOR OVER TO
SOME MEMBER BONTA I DID BE AND
MAKE A PRESENTATION ON THE
AMENDED BILL ON EIGHTY NINE
TWENTY FOUR WELCOME SIR TO
COMMITTING THINK YOU CAN
PROBABLY WORK.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
COLLEAGUES IN THANK YOU STAFFERS
MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU FOR YOUR
KIND WORDS I REALLY APPRECIATE
THEM AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TREMENDOUS LEADERSHIP IN THIS
FIELD AND AND MANY OTHERS AND
APPRECIATE OUR ONGOING
PARTNERSHIP --
IN TRYING TO TRYING TO GET THIS
RIGHT.
I'M THIS IS BEEN A VERY TRICKY
ISSUE THE ISSUE OF HAVING OUR
OUR TRIBES --
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
PARTICIPATE AND THE GROWING
REGULATED CANNABIS MARKETPLACE
AND WE'RE TALKING SPECIFICALLY
ABOUT TRIBES THAT --
FOR THE MOST PART DON'T ENJOY A
GAME IN ECONOMIC ACTIVITY ON
THEIR OWN ON THEIR TRIBES IN OUR
ARE FOR THE MOST PART POOR.
AND SMALLER AND SEEKING A
ECONOMIC CATALYST AND ECONOMIC
DRIVER TO I SUPPORT THEIR TRIBAL
MEMBERS AND THAT THAT'S HOW I
ORIGINALLY CAME AT THIS ISSUE.
AND BECAUSE OF SOVEREIGNTY WHICH
ARE AT CRADLE IMPORTANT WITH --
AN EQUAL PLAYING FIELD HOW HAS
BEEN DIFFICULT --
BUT IT'S CERTAINLY NOT FOR LACK
OF TRYING THAT OUT WE WE'VE BEEN
AT THIS ISSUE FOR OVER THREE
YEARS NOW THAT THE ISSUE WAS
FIRST RAISED AND AD TWENTY
FIFTEEN AND SOME OF OUR EARLY
EFFORTS.
WE WERE ASKED.
TO TO THE PAS BUTTON AND WAIT.
AND WE HAVE PUT MORE MORE WORK
INTO THIS AS THE COALITION ARE
COALITION HAS GROWN OUR SUPPORT
HAS GROWN ARE ARE IMPORTANT
INSIGHT I THINK --
HAS HAS INCREASED AND WE HAD --
A BILL IN BP COMMITTEE THAT HAVE
A LOT OF OUR BEST THINKING.
AND WE HOPE AND BELIEVE THAT
THAT SHOULD CONTINUE TO BE A
GUIDE OFFER INPUT CERTAINLY --
FOR RESPONSE IS AN IMPROVEMENT
AND STRENGTHENING DIE BUT WE
REALLY APPRECIATE ONE THAT THE
COMPLEXITY OF THIS ISSUE TO THE
IMPORTANCE OF THIS ISSUE WITH
THREE THE NEED. FOR ALL THE
STAKEHOLDERS TO COME TOGETHER
AND REALLY ROLL UP OUR SLEEVES
GET TO WORK AND TRY TO KNOCK IT
OUT SOLVE AND THAT'S WHAT WE
HOPE WILL.
OCCUR OVER THE SUMMER SO THANK
YOU FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP AND AND
PARTNERSHIP IN HELPING GET THIS
DONE WE LOOK FORWARD TO THAT THE
WEEKS AHEAD TAPPED TO GET IT
DONE RIGHT.
AND WITH ME HERE TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT IS.
ASIDE TO BE SHOT SHOSHONE TRIBE
AS WELL AS JOE SAN DIEGO WITH
THE HOPMAN BAND OF POMO INDIANS
AND MARK --
LEVITON IS ALSO HERE LEGAL
COUNSEL WITH THAT TO MASSAGE A
COUNTY TRUCK.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AIMED AT
pYOUR TO BE TAKING AND BUSINESS
PROFESSIONS MEANS TODAY IN
GOVERNED FIVE TO ALLOW THE
COMPOSITION CONTINUE.
I AM THAK YOU FOR THE
CLARIFICATION DON'T THINK YOU SO
MUCH OUT AND WE'RE GRATEFUL TO
THESE TRIBAL LEADERS WHO ARE
HERE TODAY --
REPRESENTING THEIR GOVERNMENTS
WERE GONNA START WITH CHAIRMAN.
YES MY NAME'S GEORGE GOALS AND
THE CHAIRMAN FOR THE TIMBER
SHOSHONE TRIBE ELOQUENCE AND THE
CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE FOR
TAKING THE TIME. TO LISTEN TO ME
--
WE ARE IN DEATH VALLEY AND WHERE
SEVERELY LIMITED ON ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT WE'RE SURROUNDED BY
PARK AND ONE PARCEL OF LAND AND
AND IS JUST SO REMOTE THE
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITIES DO NOT
EXIST FOR US.
SO WE'RE GRANT DRIVEN AND A LOT
OF THOSE GRANTS ARE COMPETITIVE
SO YOU TAKE A TRIBE LIKE OURS
WHO DOESN'T HAVE A GRANT WRITER
AND YOU COMPARED TO SOME OF THE
OTHER TRIBES WHO HAVE TEAMS OF
GRANT WRITERS.
THERE'S REAL NO THERE'S REALLY
NO COMPETITION THERE WE CAN'T
COMPETE.
SO THIS GIVES US THE ECONOMIC
OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE FOR OUR
PEOPLE THE EDUCATION WE DON'T
HAVE BROADBAND SO WHERE SERVE
WHERE WHERE IN THE MIDDLE OF NO
WHERE.
NOT ONLY IT GEOGRAPHICALLY BUT
CHARITIES THAT OTHER TRIBES HAVE
THAT WE DON'T EVEN HAVE MONEY TO
BURY OUR PEOPLE AND LISTENING TO
SOME OF THE PREVIOUS BILL THAT
CAME THROUGH TALKING ABOUT CLEAN
DRINKING WATER.
I THINK WATER WOULD JUST BE
SUFFICIENT FOR SOME OF THE
PEOPLE THAT WE HAVE BECAUSE THEY
DON'T HAVE WATER THEY DON'T HAVE
ELECTRICITY.
AND WE DON'T HAVE THE MEANS TO
PROVIDE THE INFRASTRUCTURE TO
DEVELOP THOSE WE HAVE VERY
LIMITED HOUSING AND THIS AB NINE
TWENTY FOUR WOULD OPEN THE DOOR.
NOT ONLY ECONOMICALLY BUT
EDUCATION MEDICAL --
CRIMINAL ACTIVITIES WHERE WE'RE
SO ISOLATED IT TAKES AN HOUR FOR
IF ONE OF OUR ELDERS FALL OR IF
WE HAVE A PROBLEM TAKES AN HOUR
FOR SOMEBODY TO GET THERE.
AS A PERSON COULD DIE IN THE
EXTREME HEAT SO WHERE WE HAD A
HUNDRED AND THIRTY FOUR ONE
SUMMER OR TWO HUNDRED EIGHTY
FEET BELOW SEA LEVEL WE LIVE IN
A VERY DESOLATE --
PLACE AND THAT SORT OF WORK
SEEKING SUPPORT FOR A BI NINE
TWENTY FOUR SO THAT WE CAN.
CREATE A PARADIGM SHIFT FOR OUR
PEOPLE TO PROGRESS WITH THE REST
OF SOCIETY.
THIS CHAIRMAN THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING HERE COMMITTEE WE'RE
GRATEFUL FOR PRESENCE TODAY IN
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY CENTER.
A GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
AND NON MEMBERS MONIES JUST SAN
DIEGO --
ELECTED --
TRIBAL LEADER FOR THE HAPPEN
BETTER POLLINI IS WAS THE
CHAIRMAN FOR FROM ARCO WHICH IS
CALIFORNIA NATIVE AMERICAN CAN
ASSOCIATION --
YOU KNOW ONE OF THE THINGS I
JUST WANT TO START OUT BY SAYING
IS THAT.
THE YOU KNOW WHO LISTEN ACCOR
REPRESENT TWENTY THREE MEMBER
TRIBES AMINA SUCH AS MUCH
REVENUE AND CHAIRMAN GOLSON'S
WERE --
TWENTY THREE TWENTY ONE OTHERS
--
AND YOU KNOW WE WE'VE ACTUALLY
CRAFT THIS LEGISLATION THAT
ENSURES AFFECTED REGULATION
ACCOUNTABILITY ABA CONSISTENCY
IN THE MARKET A REGULATORY
STANDARDS OFFER ON AND OFF
RESERVATION --
AS WELL AS MUTUAL COOPERATION
YOU KNOW AND HAVING SAID THAT.
SO NOT COULD YOU KNOW WE CREATED
IT BACK --
LAST YEAR DOWN AND THE
CALIFORNIA.
IT WE CREATED IT NOT ONLY SO
THAT ALL THESE TRIBAL LEADERS
CAN HAVE A VOICE IN THESE
DIFFERENT TRIES TO COME
TOGETHER%
HAVE A VOICE.
BUT ALSO THAT YOU KNOW COULD BE
A VEHICLE AND ALSO AN OPEN HERE
FOR ANY OF OUR OUR STATESMEN
ELECTED OFFICIALS ANYBODY WHO
WANTS TO COME OUT BECAUSE I'M
SURE YOU GUYS ARE WHERE.
A LOT OF TIMES YOU HAVE ISSUES
AND YOU KNOW THAT IT'S ALWAYS
TROUBLE CONSULTATION TRIBE TO
TRIBE.
AND WE FEEL THAT THIS WOULD BE A
YOU KNOW A BETTER WAY.
TO REACH MULTIPLE TRIBES RATHER
THAN JUST YOU KNOW A SINGLE
TRIBE --
AFTER READING THE MERSEY RAGS
ISSUE BUT THE STATE YOU KNOW WE
BASICALLY SAW THERE WAS NO.
MENTION OF TRIBES IN THERE
ANYWHERE ON WHICH YOU DRAFTING
THIS NIGHT. TWENTY FOUR NINE
TWENTY FOUR SIX IS FILLED IN
SANTA VOTERS IN PROPOSITION.
SIXTY FOUR BY A DEVELOPING LEGAL
CANNABIS MARKET TO ITS FULL
POTENTIAL IN TRIBAL LANDS.
AND IT ALSO SEEKS TO RESPECT THE
SOVEREIGNTY OF TRIBAL NATIONS AS
WELL AS THAT WHICH IS MUTUAL
COOPERATION AND RESPECT.
BETWEEN SOVEREIGN GOVERNMENTS TO
THE ULTIMATE BENEFIT OF ALL
CALIFORNIANS --
YOU DON'T FINALLY I WAS READING
SOME OF THE THE KEEP IN MIND
COMMENTS YOU KNOW AS FAR AS A
REGULATORY.
I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT YOU KNOW
--
TRIBES YOU KNOW FOR THE WE WE'VE
HAD ALONG.
A TRACK RECORD OF OF REGULATING
OURSELVES NAM I MYSELF YOU KNOW
SPENT.
YOU KNOW FIFTEEN YEARS THE
GAMING INDUSTRY AS WELL AS A
TIME IS A GAME COMMISSIONER IN
WORKING WITH AN AGENCY WORKING
WITH THE OJ --
AND I YOU KNOW I THINK WE WE
COULDA.
BE DEATHLY SUCCESSFUL THAT AREA.
WELL WE JUST WORKED REALLY HARD
ON THIS CRUZ BUSTAMANTE OUR
LEGAL COUNSEL --
IN EVERYBODY ALL THESE PROBLEMS
ARE JUST WHAT THEY WELL I IN THE
IT'S ALWAYS GOOD.
TO IF YOU THINK YOU VERY MUCH.
WE THANK YOU VERY MUCH WE KNOW
IT LIKELY TO WELCOME ANYONE ELSE
WHO'S IN SUPPORT OF IT PLEASE
ADVANCE AT THIS TIME PERSON
LASSEN ORGANIZATION GOOD
MORNING.
AND GOOD MORNING HOLLY FOR MANY
OF WHITE HOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF OF THE ELK VALLEY REENTRY
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
MORNINGSTAR CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
AMY JENKINS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION OUR BOARD OF
DIRECTORS TOOK A SUPPORT
POSITION ON THE BELLAS AS
CURRENTLY WRITTEN SO AS AMENDED
ON JUNE EIGHTEENTH AND WE LOOK
FORWARD TO ONGOING DISCUSSIONS
WITH SONATA AND ADDS A MEMBERS
OF THE WORKING GROUP.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING MOURNING MOUNTING
CUEVAS WITH THE CANTATA CRUISE
COMPANY ON BEHALF OF THAT TYPE
OF RAMONA --
OUR SUPPORT WAS CONTINGENT ON A
STAKEHOLDER MEETING AS WELL AS
OUR TRIED BEING A PART OF THOSE
STAKEHOLDERS.
IN TWENTY SIXTEEN OR WITH THE
FIRST TRIED TO ADDRESS THE
CANNABIS TRIBAL ISSUE WITH
LEGISLATION ACTUALLY WITH THE
SAME AUTHOR --
SO OUR SUPPORT IS CONTINGENT ON
THAT STAKEHOLDER PROCESS OVER
THE BREAK THE GIVE MUCH
APPRECIATED.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE CHRIS
CARGO UNSEEN SUPPORT WITHOUT LAS
CRUCES BANNEKER WE EXPAND UNIONS
KICKS SO MUCH SIR THANK YOU FOR
BEING HERE.
THAT DREADED YOUR LAST CALL FOR
THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT LAST
CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT.
NOW LIKELY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE WHO'S OPPOSED TO PLEASE
ADVANCE THIS TIME LOOKING FOR
OPPOSED LAST CALL. THREE BACK TO
COMMITTEE FOR ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS. THREE NINE AND MISTER.
I HAVE EVERY HOPE.
I AM NO IT'S OF BUT THANK YOU.
SO WHERE WOULD THAT BE TO GO OUT
WITH THIS AND OVER THE JULY
BREAK THERE'S GONNA BE SOME OF
ROBUST CONVERSATION STILL BE
ADVANCE.
OUT WITH SENATOR HILL AND ASSN
REMEMBER BONTA.
HAD TO BE ABLE TO HAVE.
WHAT WE WOULD HELP COME TO SOME
TYPE OF CONCLUSION HER ON THIS
ISSUE?
SUMMER BONTA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
GET A CLOSER.
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
PRESENT AND LAY OUT THE SORT OF
DRIVING.
OUT REASONS BEHIND THIS BILL WE
LOOK FOR TO THE PROCESS IN THE
WEEKS AHEAD AND AND READY TO
ROLL UP OUR SLEEVES AND GET SOME
DOT THANK YOU RESPECTFULLY ASK
DRIVE OUT VERY GRATEFUL IN
CHAIRMAN THANK YOU VERY MUCH
BOTH YOU FOR BEING HERE TODAY.
OKAY GRATEFUL THANK YOU SOONER.
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA BE MOVING
FORWARD ONTO UP BILLS I AM
WORKING THE WELCOMING --
SIMILAR VIRTUE FROM THAT THE
CITY BY THE BAY HE HAS FILE ITEM
NUMBER FOUR AB EIGHT TWENTY NINE
WHICH OF RIVERS BURGEONING
FIRST.
HE WOULD NAME TRANSITION TO FILE
ITEM TEN AB.
TWENTY ONE SIXTY TWO AND HE WILL
ALSO BE PRESENTING A ASSEMBLY
MEMBER TEAMS BILL HERE IN JUST A
BIT.
BUT WE'RE GONNA HAVE ON KICK OFF
WITH FILE ITEM FOR AB.
EIGHT TWENTY NINE WE WELCOME YOU
SIR RIGHT TO COMMITTEE AND I
JUST WANNA TAKE A MOMENT.
BUT BOTH OF THESE BILLS.
SAY THANK YOU TO THE SUMMER
MEMBER UP FOR HIS WILLINGNESS TO
BE ABLE TO STAY UP LATE AND GET
THE JOB DONE --
AND I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR ALL OF
YOUR WORK SIR --
SITTING COUNTY SAN FRANCISCO IS
VERY LUCKY TO HAVE YOU AS THEIR
ADVOCATE THE FOR SURE SIR ON
FILE ITEM THE BEFORE.
I PROJECT AND I ALSO JUST THANK
YOU AND YOUR FOR A DEEP
ENGAGEMENT ON ALL THE ISSUES
THAT WE'RE DISCUSSING TODAY AS
WELL AS A NIGHT YOUR WORK LATE
INTO THE NIGHT AND EARLY IN THE
MORNING.
AB -- EIGHT
TWENTY NINE THIS IS A COMMITTEE
THAT WELL KNOWS THE HOMELESS AND
HOUSING CRISIS THAT WE'VE BEEN
EXPERIENCING AND IS.
INTIMATELY FAMILIAR WITH THE
PACKAGE OF BILLS THAT WE PASSED
LAST YEAR TO STREAMLINE HOUSING
PRODUCTION.
INCREASE FUNDING FOR HOUSING AND
HOLD LOCAL COMMUNITIES
RESPONSIBLE BY AND WERE ALSO
VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE FACT THAT
WE ARE ASKING VOTERS THIS FALL
TO SUPPORT SIX BILLION DOLLARS
THE FUNDING FOR AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND SUPPORT OF HOUSING.
THIS BILL ADDRESSES THE FACT
THAT THERE IS AT LEAST ONE MAJOR
CITY IN OUR STATE --
WHERE AFFORDABLE AND SUPPORT OF
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS ARE BEING
SLOW TO WAR STOPPED?
PROJECTS WE ARE PROJECTS ARE
REQUIRED TO GET A LETTER OF
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT FROM A
INDIVIDUAL CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
IN WHICH IN WHOSE DISTRICT A
PROJECT IS LOCATED AS A
CONDITION OF RECEIVING LOCAL
FUNDING.
IF THOSE LETTERS ARE PROVIDED A
PROJECT CANNOT GET INTO A
PIPELINE FOR FUNDING.
MOST IF NOT ALL OF THESE
PROJECTS ARE ALSO RECEIVING
STATE FUNDING.
BY AND THE CITY HAS ITS OWN SET
ASIDE FOR LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX
CREDITS SO AS A RESULT OF THIS
POLICY STATE FUNDING IS BEING
STYMIED.
PROJECTS THAT MAY MEET LOCAL
PLANNING AND ZONING REQUIREMENTS
ARE BEING HALTED HER STALL
BECAUSE THEY CAN'T GET THE SIGN
OFF OF A LOCAL OFFICIAL.
THIS BILL WOULD PROHIBIT THE USE
OF AN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT LETTER AS
A THRESHOLD CONDITION TO APPLY
FOR FUNDING.
IF A HOUSING DEVELOPMENT WILL
ALSO RECEIVE [inaudible]
HOUSING. TO MAXIMIZE OUR STATE
INVESTMENT IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
WE REDUCE BARRIERS TO PROVE
LOCAL SUPPORT OF HOUSING WITH
THAT LIKE TO TURN IT OVER TO OUR
WITNESS.
YOU KNOW MY JUST INTRODUCING
YOURSELF ORGANIZATION YOU HAVE
TWO MINUTES AND WE WELCOME YOU
TO COMMITTEE SIR --
ANYA LAWLER ON BEHALF OF THE
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW ND
POVERTY AND THIS ONE OUT A FEW
THINGS TO THE CONVERSATION ON
THIS ISSUE FIRST OFF.
THE STATE RD HOUSE ALL ON THE
BOOKS GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION
SIX FIVE ZERO ZERO EIGHT THAT'S
STATES THAT CITIES AND COUNTIES
ARE NOT PERMITTED TO IMPOSE ANY
REQUIREMENTS.
ON SUBSIDIZED HOUSING PROJECTS.
WHETHER FEDERAL STATE OR LOCAL
IS SUBSIDIZED THE DO NOT ALSO
APPLY TO MERCURY PROJECTS.
IT'S HARD TO ARGUE THAT THIS
ISN'T A DIFFERENT REQUIREMENT.
THAT IS ALREADY BEING IMPOSED IN
VIOLATION GOVERNMENT CODES
EXERCISERS ARE EIGHT AND YET
HERE WE ARE RUNNING A BILL TO
TRY TO STOP THE CITY OF LOS
ANGELES FROM CONTINUING THIS
PRACTICE --
BUT THE FEDERAL LEVEL THE GAO
THE IRIS IN HUD HAVE ALL NOTED
THE LETTERS OF SUPPORT
REQUIREMENTS ARE PROBLEMATIC
FROM A FAIR HOUSING PERSPECTIVES
--
POTENTIALLY VIOLATING THE
FEDERAL FAIR HOUSING ACT AND
HAVE DISCOURAGED STATES FROM
IMPOSING SUCH REQUIREMENT AND
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF LOW INCOME
HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM.
AND SEVERAL YEARS AGO ADVOCATES
A MARYLAND FILED HOUSING
DISCRIMINATION COMPLAINT WITH
HUD AGAINST THE STATE BECAUSE OF
FOR A HOUSING DEVELOPERS WERE
REQUIRED TO OBTAIN A LOT OF
SUPPORT FROM THE LOCAL GOVERNING
BODY -- OF
THE JURISDICTION AND WHERE A
PROJECT WILL BE LOCATED --
TO SETTLE THAT COMPLAIN MARILYN
WAS FORCED TO STOP THE PRACTICE
AND WOULD ARGUE THAT LOS ANGELES
PRACTICE IS ACTUALLY WORSE
BECAUSE IT REQUIRES AN
INDIVIDUAL CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE PROJECT --
DEVELOPERS ARE FORCED TO SEEK A
LETTER --
WITH NO PUBLIC PROCESS BASED ON
ABSOLUTELY NO STANDARDS IT'S
ENTIRELY ARBITRARY --
ESSENTIALLY FUNCTIONS AS A
POCKET VETO FOR PROJECT THE FOR
A DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION HAS
EVEN BEEN FILED --
IF WE'RE SERIOUS ABOUT ADDRESS
OUR HOUSING CRISIS IN REDUCING
HOMELESSNESS WE NEED TO REMOVE
BARRIERS --
THE MOST EGREGIOUS VARIOUS FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THIS IS
ONE OF THEM ALL HOUSING PROJECT
SHOULD HAVE AN EQUAL SHOT AT
BEING CONSIDERED FREE FROM THE
PRESSURE OF DISCRIMINATORY BIAS.
DOT IS -- IN
FACT OF THE SITE ALREADY THE LAW
AND WE WOULD URGE YOUR SUPPORT
ON THIS MATTER THINK THANK YOU
SO MUCH THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE
OF ALL YOUR ADVOCACY WORK AND
WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT
PLEASE COMPORTMENT YOU DONE GOOD
MORNING.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN KEITH
DOWN HERE ON BEHALF THE CALVARY.
IMPORTANT LEGISLATION THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING SIR.
MICHAEL A WITH THE NONPROFIT
HOUSING ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIANS STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU [inaudible]
GOOD MORNING.
LOUIS MANDE WITH CALIFORNIA BE
IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
GOOD MORNING.
MORNING SHARON REPORT WITH THE
CORPORATION FOR SUPPORT OF
HOUSING IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
MORNING TO YOU.
BORING HIGGINS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
NOT ENOUGH PARA BUCKLEY ON BE OF
HOUSING CALIFORNIA ALSO SPORT
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR.
BUT THAT WAY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE ELSE IS SUPPORTED VIC
PLEASE COME FORWARD TO BE THE
LAST CALL FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT.
THE KNOW LIKE RICHARD OVER TO
THOSE WHO MAY BE OPPOSED TO
PLEASE ADVANCE AT THIS TIME
LOOKING FOR THOSE WHO MAY BE
OPPOSED.
LAST CALL WORKING TO BRING IT
BACK TO COMMITTEE --
IT WE ARE STARTING IN THE
SUBCOMMITTEE WE DO WANT TO SAY
WELCOME.
TO HIDE CENTER HERTZBERG YEARS
HAD A OVERSIGHT HEARING ON A
POTENTIAL BOND PROPOSAL IT'S CAN
BE MOVING WANNA SAY THANK YOU
FOR ALL OF US WORK ON THAT AND
LOOKING COMMITTEE SIR GOOD
MORNING.
I'M WHERE CERTAIN IS A
SUBCOMMITTEE RESOURCES
SUBCOMMITTEE I SHOULD SAY IF
THERE ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ON
FILE ITEM THE BEFORE AB.
TWENTY NINE SENIOR QUESTIONS
FROM COMMITTEE ESTIMATE WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSER PROCEED ASK
YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE ARE AT SUBCOMMITTEE UNABLE TO
TAKE ACTION ON THAT I DO
APOLOGIZE --
IN WE WILL BE GETTING BACK TO
THAT ISSUE LADIES AND GENTLEMAN
THIS WEDNESDAY IS THE DAVID CHIU
SHOW.
HIGH SO WE ARE NOW GOING TO BE A
TURNING OVER TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER.
TEN AB TWENTY ONE SIXTY TWO THIS
IS THE SECOND OF FOUR BILLS HE'S
GONNA BE PRESENTING --
THIS HAS A DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS CERTAIN
RECOMMENDATION.
ONCE HE FRANK YOU TO BE GOOD IS
SOMEONE.
THAT FOR TACKLING ONE OF THE
TOUGHEST CRISIS THAT WE HAVE IN
THIS STATE AND THAT'S ON ISSUES
OF HOMELESSNESS IN PARTICULAR
WHEN IT COMES.
TO A HOMELESS SUPPORTIVE HOUSING
BY AS A MEMBER THE FLOOR
SORCERER ON AB TWENTY ONE SIXTY
TWO AS WAS SAM HAPPY BE PART OF
THE MIKE MCGUIRE SHOW FOR
PORTION OF YOUR SHOW --
BUT THIS IS A BILL TO HELP
ADDRESS ONE OF THE WORST
HOMELESSNESS CRISES THAT OUR
STATE HAS EVER EXPERIENCED AT
THIS TIME IN HISTORY.
ABOUT WHEN CALIFORNIA HAS TWENTY
FIVE ARE.
ACTUALLY THINK 27% OF OUR
NATION'S HOMELESS POPULATION AND
42% OF OUR NATION'S CHRONICLE
LIST.
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS TO STREAMLINED
APPROVAL OF A 100% AFFORDABLE
DEVELOPMENTS INCLUDE A MINIMUM
OF SUPPORTIVE HOUSING UNITS
ALONG WITH ON SITE SERVICES
LOCALS WOULD BE ABLE TO APPLY
OBJECTIVE AND QUANTIFIABLE
DESIGN STANDARDS.
IMPORTANT THAT AS WE FINALLY
BEGIN AS A STATE TO START
INVESTING IN HOMELESSNESS AND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT WE GET
MORE CERTAINTY FOR THOSE THAT
ARE BUILDING THESE UNITS TO GET.
THEM ONLINE MORE QUICKLY
ANALYTIC MOMENT THANK YOU AND
YOUR STAFF YOUR WORK ON THIS
BILL -- WE
WILL BE ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS
TO GIVE MORE DISCRETION TO
SMALLER JURISDICTIONS WITH LOWER
NUMBERS OF HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS
AND AT THE START.
WOULD LIKE TO TURN IT OVER TO
OUR WITNESSES.
IF YOU SO MUCH AGAIN IS A MEMBER
WE WELCOME THAT BOTH YOU TO
COMMITTEE IF YOU COULD YOU
PLEASE GIVE US YOUR FIRST LASSEN
ORGANIZATION YOU HAVE TWO
MINUTES THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE
FOR ADVOCACY THE FLOOR'SYOURS
MA'AM.
AND THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HAVING
ME MY NAME IS SANDRA JOHNSON AND
I'M A SPEAK UP ADVOCATE FOR
CORPORATION SUPPORTIVE HOUSING.
AND ALSO I JUST WANTED TO PUT A
COOL DOWN THAT I JUST FELT WHILE
SITTING OUT THERE BECAUSE I
HEARD SOMETHING ABOUT.
THE RESTORATION OF A HUMAN BEING
IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL IN THE
MOST CREATIVE.
THAT ANOTHER HUMAN BEING CAN DO
FOR ANOTHER --
LIVED EXPERIENCE INDIVIDUALS I
WAS HOMES FROM THE AGE OF
FOURTEEN TO FIFTY THREE THAT
MEANS FOR FOURTEEN YEARS TO
FIFTY THREE YEARS OLD HOUSE
HOMELESS.
DUDE INCARCERATION AND A LOT OF
DYSFUNCTION IN MY FAMILY A WHOLE
LOT OF DIFFERENT THINGS AND IT
TAKES A LOT OF TIME TO TELL
THAT.
BUT WHAT I'M SAYING IS THAT
SUPPORTIVE HOUSING SAVED MY LIFE
IF I HAD NOT OF HAD THAT I
WOULDN'T BE THE PERSON THAT I AM
TODAY I'D.
BE DEAD SOMEWHERE BURIED IN
PRISON FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE.
BUT IT SAVED MY LIFE I LIVE IN A
NO HOLDS SENIOR VILLA WHICH IS A
SUPPORTIVE HOUSING ON THE SENIOR
I WORK I WORK AT ALL OCEAN Y.
FOR COMPANY CALLED LAND LEASE.
I M. A SAFETY ENVIRONMENTAL
SECURITY WHAT I DO IS I BACKED
UP OSHA LAWS FOR ALL THE WORKERS
TO COME IN PP READY AND MY JOB
IS A VERY IMPORTANT JOB.
THE MY FIRST LOVE IS ADVOCATING
FOR THE HOMELESS BECAUSE I WAS
HOMELESS MYSELF.
AND I KNOW WAS A LOT OF WORK YOU
KNOW I REALLY DO I KNOW THIS IS
VERY VERY HARD FOR A LOTOF
INDIVIDUALS.
TO ALL THE PAPERWORK TOGETHER
AND DO EVERYTHING THAT YOU HAVE
TO DO THAT I LOVE YOU ALL FOR
WHAT YOU DO AND I KNOW THAT YOU
GOING TO MAKE THE BEST DECISION
FOR NOT JUST.
FOR ME OF ALREADY BEEN HELP BUT
I'M STILL BEING HELD BUT FOR
THOSE THAT I HAVE NO VOICE THAT
IS HERE TODAY THEY THEY NEED A
CHANCE. TO TO BECOME THE PRODUCT
THAT I AM AND IT'S BECAUSE OF
YOUR VOLTS AND WHAT YOU DO IN
YOUR OFFICE IS ALL THE LAWS THAT
ARE WRITTEN BY ALL.
OF YOU ALL YOU SAVELIVES YOU
REALLY DO YOU MAY NOT SEE HIM
BUT YOU REALLY SAVE LIVES IS A
WHOLE LOT OF ME OUT THERE THAT'S
WORKING PRODUCTIVE.
LIVING A WONDERFUL LIFE LIVING
I'VE ONE IN THEIR CHILDREN AND
THAT MEANS THAT.
BUT IT ALSO [inaudible]
SO I I HOPE FROM THE BOTTOM OF
MY HEART.
THAT YOU ALL CONTINUE TO DO THE
RIGHT THING THANK YOU CHATS
THINKS BEEN INSPIRATION THIS
MORNING WE'RE GRATEFUL THAT GOOD
MORNING I'M SHARON REPORT WITH
THE CORPORATION FOR SUPPORTIVE
AS A HOUSING AS WELL AND I'M
JUST WANTED TO SAY ON OF AS MS
JOHNSON STORY INDICATES SUPPORT
OF HOUSING.
REALLY DOES SAVE LIVES IMPROVE
WAS ON HEALTH BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
EMPLOYMENT OUTCOMES PEOPLE CAN
REMAIN SAFELY HOUSE FOR LONG
PERIODS --
AND NOT FACE THE DANGER OF
LIVING ON THE STREETS --
DATA ALSO SO SUPPORTIVE HOUSING
IMPROVES PROPERTY VALUES AND
DECREASES BLADES AND CRIME IN
THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
AND FOR THESE REASONS THE STATE
HOUSE INVESTED HEAVILY AND
HOPEFULLY WILL BE INVESTING
HEAVILY.
IN THE NEAR FUTURE FOR IN
SUPPORT OF HOUSING. TO BE
COMPETITIVE FOR THESE FUNDS
THOUGH SUPPORTIVE HOUSING
TYPICALLY HOUSE TO BE MORE GREEN
AT HOUSE TO BE MORE SECURE.
AND IT HAS TO BE MORE BEAUTIFUL
THAN RENTAL HOUSING OF THE SAME
COMMUNITY --
YET THESE PROJECTS OFTEN ARE
STYMIED SIMPLY BECAUSE OF AN MBA
ISM.
AB TWENTY ONE SIXTY TWO WOULD
ALLOW SUPPORTIVE HOUSING
PROVIDERS RECEIVE FIVE RIGHT
APPROVAL ARE PROJECTS AS LONG AS
THAT PROJECT MEETS THE CITIES OR
COUNTIES OBJECTIVE STANDARDS.
IT WOULD ENSURE THAT THESE
PROJECTS ARE NOT --
DECLINED A SIMPLY BECAUSE OF AN
ENVIOUS ON IT ENSURES
DEVELOPMENTS CAN GET THE MOST
VULNERABLE CANNOT CALIFORNIANS
OFF THE STREETS QUICKLY.
AND IT HAS THE POTENTIAL OF
SAVING THOUSANDS OF LIVES OF THE
MOST VULNERABLE CALIFORNIANS FOR
THESE REASONS I'D LIKE TO THINK
--
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS SHE WENT DALY
FOR THERE'S SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
AND I URGE YOUR AYE OPPOSED
THANK YOU SO MUCH MA'AM WE'RE
GRATEFUL WE'RE NOW GOING TO BE
--
OPENING UP FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT OF TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD TO HE'S BACK AT WE
WELCOME BACK MR DONE.
HE WAS CHAIRMAN KEITH DONE HERE
ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA HARM
ASSOCIATION LIKE TO THINK THE
AUTHOR MR DAILY AS WELL FOR THIS
EFFORTS IMPORTANT MEASURE WE ASK
FOR SUPPORT THINK THIS DOWN
WELCOME BACK.
ON OUR ON BEHALF OF WESTERN TERM
ON POVERTY IN THE CALIFORNIA
RURAL LEGAL ASSISTANCE.
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT
THINK YOU SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING SYLVIA
FOR OUR IN BEHALF OF FACEBOOK IN
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU GOOD MORNING.
KAREN BUCKLEY ON BEHALF HOUSING
CALIFORNIA PLEASE A CO SPONSORS
BUILT THANK THE MEMBER FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE.
THANK YOU.
TAKE A MORNING ELIANA BENDER
WITH PUBLIC ADVOCATES AND SPORT
DEEPER MEANER HEY HEY I TWENTY
AYE CAROLING ABOUT OF MAYOR MARK
FARRELL IN THE CITY AND COUNTY
OF SAN FRANCISCO AND SONGS PART
OF OUR MEMBERS BUILT STATE THANK
YOU SO MUCH DISTILLING GOOD
MORNING.
MORE IN IT IN THE BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM IN
SUPPORT.
WELCOME BACK.
LOUIS MONTANA WE HAVEOF
CALIFORNIA ME IN SUPPORT OF THE
LIST GOOD MORNING ANGELIQUE YORK
NATIONALS LACED NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS
AND STRONG SUPPORT.
SO GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS TIM SHOT ON
BEHALF OF THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY
AREA RAPID TRANSIT DISTRICT IN
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SIR TAKE A MORNING.
MORE IT WAS SAM'S AT UNITED WAYS
CALIFORNIANS STRONG SUPPORT
THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK.
GOOD MORNING SIR MICHAEL IN WITH
THE NONPROFIT HOUSING
ASSOCIATION OF THE CALIFORNIA
STRONG SUPPORT BY.
MORNING NAM SANTEE GEORGE WITH
BECCA PLAYING ASSOCIATION ALSO
IN SUPPORT EGGMAN GEORGE.
LET ME TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
ELSE WOULD LIKE YOU TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE THIS TIME.
THIS CAN BE LAST CALL FOR
SUPPORT.
WE NOW GO TO WELCOME THOSE WHO
MAY BE OPPOSED IF YOU TO PLEASE
COME FORWARD WERE LOOKING FOR
THOSE WHO WERE OPPOSED.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSITION.
REMAIN BACK TO COMMITTEE TO BE
TO SEE IF WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE
THIS TIME.
COMMITTEE OF SENATOR MORLOCK HAY
SATIRIC OUT BY NIGHT SCENE THAT
WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS BEING ADVANCED WHERE
TURNED OVER TO THE GOOD SENATOR
DID TO COULD SOME MEMBER FROM
SAN FRANCISCO TO BE A REALLY
OFFER CLOSING COMMENTS THING MS
JOHNSON WAS THE BEST.
SPOKESPERSON FOR THIS BILL
ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU SO MUCH --
SUMMER PROBABLY WORK ON THIS
MISS JOHNSON DID A FABULOUS JOB
YOU'RE WELCOME ANYTIME THANK YOU
NO THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE'LL TAKE THAT UP AS SOON AS WE
HAVE A QUORUM.
MEMBERS WERE NOW MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM TWENTY FOUR WHICH IS
AB.
TWENTY NINE TWENTY THREE BUT
JUST A FEW COMMENTS AND I JUST
WANNA SAY THANK YOU.
TIED TO SOME MEMBER CHIU FOR HIS
TIRELESS EFFORTS.
BRING IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO
THE BAY AREA IN THE GOLDEN STATE
PARTICULARLY HIGH AS CHAIR OF
HOUSING IN ASSEMBLY [inaudible]
IT IS.
THE EASY DEBATE A SAY ABOUT
FOLKS BUT I'VE BEEN SINCERE HE'S
A PLEASURE TO BE ABLE TO WORK
WITH.
THAT THROUGHOUT THIS PROCESS WE
HAVE HAD SOME LATE NIGHTS SOME
EARLY MORNINGS NOT BUT THIS IS A
BIG DEAL --
WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED TODAY --
ALONG WITH THIS ENDEAVOR GRAYSON
FOR THE LEGISLATURE WILL BE AT
TEN TO THE GRANTING A TREND
TRANSITING SEE THE LADIES OF
SORTIE THAT HAS BEEN RESERVE
LESS FAR.
UP FOR CITIES AND COUNTIES --
GOOD TO BE SUPPORTIVE OF THIS
BILL TODAY I'LL HAVE A FEW OTHER
COMMENTS BUT AGAIN I JUST WANT
TO SAY THANK YOU TO AYE SOME
MEMBER CHIU.
UP FOR TAKING THIS ON BY IT IS
NOT BEEN EASY --
IN VERY VERY GRATEFUL ALONG WITH
SOME NUMBER GRAYSON AYE HIS
PARTNER I IN THIS --
ENDEAVOR SIN NUMBER AT THE FLOOR
IS YOURS SIR AND ALL I MAKE SOME
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS IN A BIT.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND LET
ME SAY IT'S IT'S PRETTY TYPICAL
FOR US TO THANK THE CHAIRMAN
STAFF FOR THEIR WORK BUT I
REALLY DO WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR DEEPING
GAUGE IN ON THIS THROUGH.
I THINK AT LEAST A FOR LENGTHY
DISCUSSIONS OVER THIS I WANT.
TO APPLAUD YOU FOR YOUR STAFF I
THINK YOU'VE SOME OF THE BEST
LAND USE ABOUT FOLKS AT YOUR
SIDE -- AND
I DO THINK THIS IS SIGNIFICANT
--
AND WE I THINK WORK THROUGH AND
CAME UP WITH SOME IMPORTANT
CREATIVE SOLUTIONS WHICH I DO
THINK IS GOING TO MOVE US
FORWARD IN A SIGNIFICANT WAY.
LET ME JUST INDICATE FOR THE
RECORD AT THE OUTSET THAT I
ACCEPT ALL THE COMMITTEES
AMENDMENTS AND APPRECIATE THE
WORK ON IT.
SO WHAT ARE WE TRYING TO DO WITH
THIS BILL WHY HAVE WE ASKED TO
MOVE FORWARD BAR TANSITORY
DEVELOPMENT WE KNOW THAT THE BAY
AREA -- AS
THE AT THE CENTER OF THE HOUSING
AND CONGESTION CRISES THAT WE
ARE EXPERIENCING THROUGHOUT OUR
STATE OUR IS SUFFERING.
AND BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF
HOUSING RESIDENTS HAVE BEEN
SPENDING COUNTLESS HOURS DRIVE
IN BETWEEN WHERE THEY WORK AND
WHERE THEY LIVE THE LAST
AUTISTIC WAS.
AN AVERAGE OF SEVENTY NINE HOURS
SITTING IN GRIDLOCK IN THE BAY
ON TOP OF ALREADY LONG COMMUTES.
AN UNFORTUNATE THE SAME TIME WE
HAVE DOZENS BUT BART STATIONS
SURROUNDED BY HUNDREDS OF ACRES
OF ASPHALT PARKING LOTS FILLED
WITH CARS BY DAY.
AND VACANT LOTS BY NIGHT.
THIS BILL IS NECESSARY BECAUSE
BART HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE FOR
OVER FORTY FIVE YEARS --
BUT THE ESTIMATE IS OVER 95% OF
DEVELOPER PARCELS ARE STILL
PARKING LOTS TOO MANY CITIES
UNFORTUNATELY HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE
TO BUILD HOUSING NEXT DEPART
STATIONS.
AND THE ONES THAT HAVE BEEN ABLE
TO BUILD HOUSING OFTEN HAD TAKEN
DOWN PROJECTS --
DILUTED THEM AND OFTENTIMES IT
TOOK TWIN TEN TO FIFTEEN TO
TWENTY FIVE YEARS FOR APPROVAL.
THIS BILL WHICH I AM PROUD TO
JOIN THE AUTHOR WITH MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE FROM EAST BAY.
WOULD REQUIRE THE BART BOARD
WHICH IS A DIRECTLY ELECTED
BOARD TO ESTABLISH BROAD TRANSIT
ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT ZONING
STANDARDS THAT SUPPORT
SUSTAINABLE MIXED USE
DEVELOPMENT ON LAND OWNED BY
PART.
WITHIN A HALF MILE THE STATION.
BILL JEWEL PROJECTS WOULD THEN
BE STREAMLINED CAN DEVELOPED IN
LAST YEAR'S HOUSING PACKAGE.
BART IS A UNIQUE SPECIAL
DISTRICT IN THAT IT IS DIRECTLY
ELECTED BY AND IT'S A PUBLIC
AGENCY THAT OWNS LAND.
IF CONSTITUENTS OF CHOOSE THEY
CAN'T ELECT AND REMOVE BOARD
MEMBERS.
PART HAPPENS TO OWN PROPERTY
ADJACENT TO MANY OF ITS TRANSIT
STATIONS THAT SERVE MORE THAN
FOUR HUNDRED THOUSAND PASSENGERS
EVERY DAY.
THIS PROPOSAL WILL NOT ONLY
CREATE NEW HOUSING IT WILL
REDUCE CONGESTION AND GREENHOUSE
GAS.
EMISSIONS IT'LL INCREASE TRANSIT
RIDERSHIP IT WILL HELP TO CREATE
JOBS.
LET ME TAKE A MOMENT --
IT TOO AGAIN JUST THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR WORKING WITH US
THROUGH A SIGNIFICANT AMENDMENTS
AND AT A HIGH LEVEL --
THERE ARE AMENDMENTS THAT HELP
TO ADDRESS AND BE RESPECTFUL OF
HOW COMMNITIES HAVE CHOSEN
OUGHT TO ENVISION THEMSELVES --
WE ALSO HAVE AMENDMENTS TO
ENSURE REAL AFFORDABILITY IN
FUTURE HOUSING THAT BART HELPS
TO DEVELOP --
TO DEFINE EXACTLY WHAT WOULD BE
CONSIDERED TRANSITORY
DEVELOPMENT AROUND OPERATE ABOUT
PARK ON LAND. TO ADDRESS
POTENTIAL DISPLACEMENT ISSUES
OUGHT TO ENSURE THAT BART IS
FOCUSED ON PARKING REPLACEMENT
AND ONE OF THE AMENDMENTS WOULD
INSURE THAT.
THESE PROVISIONS WOULD SUNSET --
OVER A DECADE TO WE SEE HOW THIS
GOES AND I THINK FOR MANY OF US
WE'RE HOPING.
ARE IN THE COMING YEARS WE READ
THE ADDRESS BOTH.
CONGESTION CRISES AND AND AND
HOPEFULLY IN TEN YEARS --
IF THIS IS NOT NEEDED I WOULD BE
THE FIRST TO TO CELEBRATE THAT
SO WELL WITH THAT AGAIN WANT TO
THANK EVERYONE INVOLVED AND TURN
IT OVER TO MY JOINT AUTHORED.
INDICATES HOW MUCH I MISS
RESUMING THE FLOOR IS YOURS AND
TO MAKE SOME QUICK COMMENTS
RIGHT AFTER MISTER GRAYSON
PLEASE SIR.
BY THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
MISTER CHAIR WOULD LIKE TO THANK
YOU AND COMMITTEE STAFF. FOR THE
GREAT EFFORTS THAT YOU WENT TO
TO HELP MAKE THIS BILL --
BETTER AND THANK YOU.
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS I
WOULD ALSO THINK MY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER A DAVID CHIU FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE.
AND MOVING IT FORWARD AS STRONG
--
AND CONFIDENTLY AS HE HAS WE
NEED TO MAKE IT EASIER TO
DEVELOP AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
AND TO BRING OUR HOUSING SUPPLY
UP TO BETTER MEET --
TO ANY LONG TERM SOLUTION FOR A
HOUSING NEEDS --
IS FOUND RIGHT HERE IN THIS BILL
AND BEING ABLE TO DEVELOP A
TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT
AROUND BART STATIONS THIS BILL
WILL MOVE OUR REGION FORWARD.
WITH SMART TRANCE OR IN A
DEVELOPMENT THAT BENEFITS
FAMILIES WORKERS AND EMPLOYEES
OR EMPLOYERS ALIKE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR HAVE A MR
CINNAMON I I AGREE I AND WE'RE
GONNA GET TO ARE WITNESSES IN
JUST A MOMENT AIMED AT DISTRICT
WITH THE CHAIR'S PREROGATIVE
THAT I I THINK THAT --
BILL IT'S GONNA CREATE MAJOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AROUND KEY
LOCATIONS IN THE BAY AREA I
THINK ONE OF THE ITEMS IT IS
BEEN FOCUSING ON AND I DON'T
EVER SPEAK FOR THE AUTHORS.
BUT NOT JUST IN CITY CENTERS.
BOB BUT TAKING A LOOK AT
BUILDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
ALONG THE BART LINE NO MATTER IF
YOU ARE IN URBAN NUYS
MUNICIPALITY A OR IN A SUBURB.
AND I THINK WE'RE GOING TO SEE
--
OUR SCHOOLS BENEFIT FROM THAT
PUBLIC SERVICES BENEFIT THAT
PRISSY LESS TRAFFIC CONGESTION
AS A RESULT I AND THROUGH BOTH
OF THESE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS.
I'D BEGIN A ALSO BE A TO PROVIDE
A SET OF AMENITIES --
FOR CONVENIENCE OF THOSE FOLKS
WILL BE LIVING NEAR AYE THEIR
TRANSIT HUB.
AYE AS IT WAS A SIMILAR CHIU IN
GRAYSON WANTING TO BE A FOCUS ON
MIXED USE IS WELL WHICH MAKES
SENSE.
I ALSO I WANNA SAY THANK YOU AS
THEY'VE BEEN FOCUS.
ON AFFORDABLE A CURRENT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS WELL.
NOT IN EACH OF THEM WERE VERY
FOCUSED ON STRONG DISPLACEMENT
PROVISIONS --
THAT WILL BE IN PLACE NOT SO
THAT.
AT BY DEVELOPMENT --
WILL BE ABLE TO CONTINUE TO LIVE
AND RAISE THEIR FAMILY IN THE
COMMUNITY THAT THEY CALL HOME.
A AND I'M VERY VERY GRATEFUL FOR
THAT THAT AND I THINK CANDIDLY
THIS BILL REPRESENTS A HUGE STEP
FORWARD IN A CATALYST FOR CHANGE
BY IN THE GREATER SAN FRANCISCO
BAY AREA AND I WANT TO SAY THANK
YOU TO BOTH OF THEM.
AYE AND OBVIOUSLY WE STILL NEED
TO TAKE A VOTE ON THIS BILL OUT
BUT I I JUST VERY VERY GRATEFUL
FOR YOUR LEADERSHIP.
WE HAVE TWO WITNESSES EACH OF
YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES WHO WOULD
LIKE TO BE A KICK* OFF.
MIKE WELCOME BACK SIR THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OF GERMAN WHERE
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA.
AND OUR HOUSING AFFORDABILITY
CRISIS IS URGENT MATTER
STATEWIDE CONCERN AND NOT JUST A
LOCAL MUNICIPAL AFFAIR ALTHOUGH
IT IS THAT. TO TO BE CLEAR WE
HAVE A LACK OF PROPERTIES ON
MULTI FAMILY HOUSING SITES FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
IF WE ARE SERIOUS ABOUT
ADDRESSING THE HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS AND CLIMATE
CHANGE.
WE NEED PROPERTIES OWNED SITES
AT SUFFICIENT DENSITY HAD AN
EXPEDITED APPROVAL PROCESS.
AND THE BEAR WERE LAND CAN GO
FOR MORE THAN TEN MILLION
DOLLARS PER ACRE PUBLICLY HELD
LAND IS A VALUABLE AND PRECIOUS
RESOURCE.
GIVEN THE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
INVESTMENT PLAN TO BE INVEST IN
THE PARK SYSTEM THIS LAND MUST
BE USED ISELY PROVIDE REAL
COMMUNITY BENEFITS.
PRIOR TO THE TWENTY SEVENTEEN
ADOPTION BOARDS TOT GUIDELINES
THERE WAS A MORE THAN TO YOUR
PUBLIC PROCESS IN MY
ORGANIZATION ALSO PARTICIPATED
IN THAT PROCESS.
THESE ARE SMART AND PROGRESS AYE
GUIDELINES ARE VERY WELL KNOWN.
THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING POLICY
INCLUDE IS EXCELLENT AND WE NEED
THE COOPERATION OF AND PART
PARTNERSHIP WITH.
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS NOW FOR
EXPEDITED IMPLEMENTATION IN
ORDER TO ENSURE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS ARE
FEASIBLE BUT THE APPROPRIATE
DENSITY AND DEVELOPMENT
STANDARDS.
THESE POLICIES ARE ALREADY
EMBEDDED IN THE STATE'S KEY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FINANCE
PROGRAMS INCLUDING CAP AND TRADE
AND A TAX CREDIT PUBLIC
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE PROGRAMS.
OUR MEMBERS STAND READY TO
DELIVER TRANSIT OR AND
AFFORDABLE HOMES ARE BARRED
SITES BUT WE NEED THE ZONING.
DENSITY AND DEVELOPMENT
STANDARDS TO BE ALIGNED WITH
RESPECT TO REQUEST MY VOTE.
AND I THINK TRAIN WITH THE CIVIC
SMITH.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN FIRST
EQUITY JEREMY SMITH HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING AND
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL.
A WE HAVE WHEN SUPPORT THE BILL
TODAY WE HAVE ALWAYS BEEN STRONG
SUPPORTERS OF FRIENDS OR IN
DEVELOPMENT WRITTEN THAT
PROVIDES WORKING FAMILIES WITH
ACCESS.
TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND CLEAN
MODES OF TRANSPORTATION.
AS WE ALL KNOW BAR IS A CRITICAL
PART OF THE BAY AREA'S
INFRASTRUCTURE --
IN TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE
AND ECONOMY SO DOES MAKE SENSE
THAN WE THINK --
TO AS HOUSING COSTS CONTINUE TO
RISE TO OPEN UP BAR OWNED
PROPERTIES.
A TO THE CONSTRUCTION OF MIXED
USE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
UP WITH WALKABLE NEIGHBORHOODS
ADJACENT TO CLEAN MASS TRANSIT
SO FOR THOSE REASONS WERE HAPPY
TO SUPPORT.
THANK YOU THINK THANK YOU SO
MUCH FOR SMITH WERE NOT A
WELCOME I HAVE MISTER DUNN BACK
HE'S GONNA GET HIS OWN PERSONAL
CHAIR HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM
--
PURPOSE IN THE APARTMENT SO SHE
XIN APPELLEE TODAY I SERVED THE
FLOOR IS YOURS THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN SIZE NICE TO HAVE A HAT
TRICK HERE BEFORE YOUR COMMITTEE
I AM PLEASED TO SUPPORT THIS
IMPORTANT LEGISLATION AGAIN WE
BELIEVE FOR WHAT HOUSING NEXT
MASS TRANSIT.
IS A SWITCH FOR CALIFORNIA THANK
OUR AUTHORS WOULD ASK FOR
SUPPORT THANK YOU SO MUCH THOSE
IN SUPPORT OF IT PLEASE ADVANCE.
CORNELIUS PART WITH THE BEAR
COUNCIL REPRESENT THREE UNDER
THE LARGEST EMPLOYERS IN TE BAY
AREA AND STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS
IMPORTANT BILL THANKS FOR BEING
HERE SIR.
WELCOME BACK.
LUIS MONTERO CALIFORNIA BEING
STRONG SUPPORT IS VERY PRINT
MEASURE THANK YOU THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
OR ANYTHING AND I HAVE A BRIDGE
HOUSING IS PART.
SLANG.
CAROLING AGAIN ON BEHALF OF
MAYOR MARK FOR IN THE CITY
COUNTY SOME JUST ON SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MORNING BLACK
SHEPHERD REPRESENTING THE
SILICON VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ELIANA BENDER WITH PUBLIC
ADVOCATES WE SUPPORT AS AMENDED
THERE'S STILL SOME ISSUES WE
NEED TO WORK OUT BUT WE
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR WORKING
WITH US.
THANK YOU.
MONEY I HAVE IN A STAFF ATTORNEY
BRENNAN DEFENSE ALSO HERE TODAY
--
REPRESENT MISS HIRED HA A PHILIP
RANDOLPH INSTITUTE ANYA
COMMITTEE DEVELOPERS WHO
ASSIGNED OUNCES PER LETTER AND
RESPONSE SUPPORT THANK YOU.
WELCOME BACK HOLLY FOR MEDIA
OUTLET HAS PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF OF HABITAT FOR HUMANITY
CALIFORNIA ALSO IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU GOOD MORNING.
CARRIES GLITCH ON BEHALF OF THE
NATURAL RESOURCE. FOR THAT TO BE
TO DO A LAST CALL OF LAST CALL
FOR THOSE WHO MAY BE IN SUPPORT.
BUT I GOT A WELCOME THOSE WHO
ARE OPPOSED WE'RE GONNA WELCOMED
BY TWO WITNESSES THAT WE WILL
HAVE A PRIMARY AND A SECONDARY.
SURE TO COME FORWARD.
LET US KNOW WHO ARE PRIMARY IS
GOING TO BE OUR PRIMARY WITNESS
WILL HAVE AYE THREE MINUTES IN
OUR SECRETARY WILL HAVE TWO
MINUTES.
BUT WE WELCOME SIR TO COMMITTEE
THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE.
ONCE UPON THE MIGHT CLOSE.
WHO THINK IT IS UP?
YES.
GOOD MORNING TWENTY A BUNDLE
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
THINK FOR THE OPTION YOU SPEAK
TODAY MY NAME'S LOOKS AND I'M
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR.
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN AND I'M
SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE CITIES
OF THE EAST BAY.
OUR CITIES TO ARE DEEPLY
CONCERNED ABOUT THE AVAILABILITY
AFFORDABILITY OF HOUSING.
BUT IS IT TRUE ISSUE IN OUR
COMMUNITIES KIND THROUGHOUT THE
EAST BAY IN THE BAY AREA.
WE UNDERSTAND AND APPRECIATE THE
DESIRE OF THE BILL'S AUTHORS TO
FIND FEASIBLE SOLUTIONS TO THE
HOUSING CRISIS.
THE SPACE CITIES UNDERSTAND WE
NEED MORE HOUSING MORE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING WHO RECOGNIZE
THE POTENTIAL AROUND OUR BART
STATIONS.
AND ALSO THE NEED FOR A ROBUST
AND RELIABLE TRANSPORTATION
SYSTEM.
WE ALL WANT OUR RESIDENTS WITH
THE THEY LIVE A HALF MILE FROM
HARD CORE FOR MILES FROM PART.
TO HAVE THE CHOICE TO GET OUT OF
THEIR CARS AND TAKE TRANSIT.
AND TO ACHIEVE THESE OBJECTIVES
WE KNOW THAT WE NEED
TRANSPORTATION PARTNERS LIKE
BART.
THAT'S WHY ARE EAST BAY CITIES
CONTINUE TO MAKE TRANSIT
ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT A PRIORITY
AND THE REALITY.
NOT JUST WORDS ON PAPER.
IT'S WHY FREMONT HAS PRODUCED
ARE ENTITLED NEARLY FORTY FIVE
HUNDRED HOUSING UNITS NEAR ITS
THREE BART STATION.
Y. DUBLIN AND OUR NEIGHBORS
PLEASANTON.
HAVE PRODUCED OR AND PADDLE OVER
THIRTY FIVE HUNDRED UNITS NEAR
ITS TO BART STATIONS AND WHY
WALNUT CREEK.
WHO YOU HEARD FROM YESTERDAY HAS
PRODUCED?
OR ENTITLED OVER TWO THOUSAND
UNITS.
AND I WOULD IMAGINE THAT IS WHY
AFTER CAREFUL CONSIDERATION THE
BART BOARD HAS TAKEN A NEUTRAL
POSITION ON THIS MATTER.
THE BOTTOM LINE HAVE TO WORKING
ON TEO DE PROJECTS FOR OVER
TWENTY YEARS LONG BEFORE WE EVEN
KNEW THEY WERE CALLED TEO DE.
I GUARANTEE THAT CITIES ARE NOT
THE IMPEDIMENT DEVELOPING PARK
PROPERTY WITH TRANSIT RICH SMART
GROWTH HOUSING.
DUBLIN HAS ALREADY ZONED AND
SECRET HAVE SECRET CLEARANCE IN
PLACE CONSISTENT WITH PART
OBJECTIVES.
OTHER CITIES LIKE CONCORD
HAYWARD UNION CITY SAN LEANDRO
AND RICHMOND DO AS WELL.
EQUALLY WORRISOME THIS BILL DOES
NOT REQUIRE BART TO WORK FOR
THEIR CITIES TO DEVELOP TOT
STANDARDS BUT ADDRESS THE UNIQUE
REALITY OF EACH OF OUR STATIONS.
WELL GIVES BART UNILATERAL
AUTHORITY FOR A ONE SIZE FITS
ALL TEAR DE PLANNING APPROACH
WITHOUT LOCAL CITIZEN INPUT.
IT DOES NOT REQUIRE BART TO
PROPERLY BALANCE EXISTING
PATRONS THAT HAVE NO VISIBLE
MEANS TO GET TO A BART STATION.
A OTHER THAN PATRONS THAT CANNOT
WALK TO BART STATION OR IT'S NOT
SERVED BY PUBLIC GROUND
TRANSPORTATION.
IN CLOSNG I WOULD JUST SIMPLY
SAY.
WHAT OUR RESIDENTS AND
BUSINESSES SAY ABOUT THAT THE
NEED FOR THIS BILL?
BARTON NEEDS TO PRIORITIZE TRAIN
SERVICE HEAT THE TRAINS AND
STATIONS SAFE AND CLEAN SO
PEOPLE WILL ACTUALLY WANT TO USE
THE SYSTEM.
AND BRING IT BACK TO THE WORLD
CLASS SYSTEM IT ONCE WAS.
THIS IS UNPRECEDENTED IN SHORT
SIGHTED SHOULD COMMUNITIES OKAY
REGIONAL GOVERNING BODY THAT
MOST FOLKS AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
ART DISCONNECTED FROM.
WHAT LITTLE ACCOUNTABILITY LAND
USE DECISIONS REMAIN SHOULD
REMAIN WITH LOCALLY ELECTED
REPRESENTATIVES WE ASK THAT YOU
HOLD THE BILL IN COMMITTEE?
SO THAT IT CAN BE PART OF A
THOUGHTFUL AND COMPREHENSIVE
DISCUSSION IN THE COMING MONTHS.
ON HOW TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN
ACTUALLY ACHIEVING DENSITY
AROUND TRANSIT STATIONS THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING HERE
SIR.
HEY GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING I
MISSED YOUR MEMBERS JASON RILEY
CALIFORNIA CITIES AND TO BE
CLEAR THE LEAGUE IS VERY
SUPPORTIVE A TRANS OR IN
DEVELOPMENTS.
WE SUPPORTED S. B. THREE SEVEN
FIVE ONE OVER A DECADE AGO NOW
THAT REALLY KICKED INTO HIGH
GEAR ON BUT WE DO HAVE
FUNDAMENTAL CONCERNS WITH THIS
BILL.
AND THE HOUSE'S DOES A REALLY
GREAT JOB OF OUTLINING SOME OF
THOSE FUNDAMENTAL ISSUES AND YOU
CAN FIND THE ONE CERTAIN REALLY
ON PAGE.
SEVEN I MEAN THE THE ISSUE FOR
US ISN'T DO WE NEED GREATER
DENSITY AROUND TRANSIT BECAUSE
THAT'S A SIMPLE ANSWER NETS
ABSOLUTELY WHEN YOU GREATER
DENSITY.
AROUND TRANSIT IT'S WHO SHOULD
BE MAKING THOSE DECISIONS AND
THE CONSTITUTION IS VERY CLEAR
THAT THOSE DECISION NAVY MADE BY
CITIES AND COUNTIES WE HAVE THE
LAND USE AUTHORITY THERE'S BEEN
GRANTED TO US IN THE
CONSTITUTION.
WE BELIEVE WE'RE IN THE BEST
PLACE TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS.
TAKING THAT AUTHORITY AWAY FROM
A CITY OR COUNTY AND BESTOWING
IT ONTO A SPECIAL DISTRICT ORDER
OF THAT THINK PART.
OF IT IS A FUNDAMENTAL ISSUE
THAT WE BELIEVE IS
UNCONSTITUTIONAL I'M IN IS
OUTSIDE THE PURVIEW OF BARK BARK
IS A A SPECIALIST WHEN IT COMES
TO TRANSPORTATION.
THEY'RE NOT EXPERTS IN LAND
DEVELOPMENT OR LAND USE
AUTHORITY SO WE QUESTION WHY WE
THINK THAT CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
AND SUPERVISORS ARE LACKING IN
THE ABILITY TO MAKE APPROPRIATE
DECISIONS.
AND WHY WE THINK BART WOULD BE
THE BETTER ALTER WHATEVER THAT
RIGHT THING MAY BE GONE SO WE
BELIEVE ANY OF THAT DECISIONS
NEED TO BE TO REMAIN IN THE
COMMUNITY REMAIN WITH THAT WITH
THE CITY OR COUNTY.
THE OTHER ISSUE HERE IS THIS IS
A VERY BAD PRECEDENT JUST SINCE
THE BILL'S BEEN INTRODUCED
MULTIPLE AGENCIES ALREADY
COMPORTED SAYING HEY WE WANT
THIS AUTHORITY TO WE WANT TO BE.
THE ENTITY DECIDING WHAT IS
GONNA HAPPEN ON OUR LAND.
A PROPERTY THAT THEY OWN THEY DO
NOT WANT TO HAVE TO WORK WITH
THE CITY OR WORK WITH THE COUNTY
IN ORDER --
TO ADD TO THE FURTHER
DEVELOPMENT ON THAT PROPERTY --
AND THEN FINALLY.
I'D LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT --
ON A PIECE EAT THAT THIS ALSO
APPLIES TO PLAN STATIONS SO IT'S
NOT AS IF WE HAVE TRAINED
TRANSIT OF DEVELOPMENT ARE YOU
THERE THIS IS A GREEN FIELD
THAT'S NOW GOING TO HAVE HOUSING
POTENTIALLY ON TOP OF IT THEY
MEAN AND BE SERVED.
BY THE THE BY THE FIX RAIL SO
FOR THOSE REASONS WE ASK YOU TO
HOLD THIS MEASURE WE'RE GONNA
HAVE A VERY EXTENSIVE
CONVERSATION BUDDY TWENTY SEVEN
AND HOW THAT'S GONNA MOVE FOR WE
THINK THIS FITS PERFECTLY.
AND THAT DISCUSSION ADVANCING
THIS ARTICLE SEND THE WRONG
SIGNAL AYE AND UNDERMINE THOSE
DISCUSSIONS OF THAT WE OPPOSE
THIS MEASURE THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY AYE INTO ARE
THE FOLKS WHO ARE GOING TO BE
SPEAKING IF IT'S OKAY WITH ALL
OF YOU WOULD LIKE ME TO
ESTABLISH.
A QUORUM OF THE COMMITTEE WE'VE
NOT BEEN ABLE TO DO SO YET NOT
AT ALL TRYING TO BE RUDE.
IF WE CAN JUST I TAKE THIRTY
SECONDS. TO LAOS ESTABLISH A
QUORUM IS THAT WE'RE ABLE START
VOTING ON BILLS MISLEAD CHESTER
BROKAW PLEASE LIAR HERE REQUIRE
PRESIDENT PLAN.
BELL BELL PRESENT HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG.
MISREPRESENT LARA MORLOCK
[inaudible]
IT'S ROCK.
ALRIGHT I DO APOLOGIZE SIR I DO
NOT MEAN DE PUT A DELAY AND YET
WE WELCOME YOU AYE TO THE
COMMITTEE IF YOU JUST GIVE OUR
FIRST AND LAST AS WELL AS THE
ORGANIZATION HE REPRESENT AND WE
ARE IN THE OPPOSE CATEGORY.
GOOD MORNING.
STEVEN FAULK I'M THE LAFAYETTE
CITY MANAGER REPRESENTING THE
CITY OF LAFAYETTE THE WHICH IS
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH THINK YOU'RE
BEING A COMMITTEE.
GOOD MORNING GOOD MORNING SANTEE
GEORGE WITH AMERICAN PLANNING
ASSOCIATION EVEN WITH THE
AMENDMENTS WE MUST CONTINUE
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE THINKING I
THINK YOU.
BASS MISTAKEN IT'S GOOD
AFTERNOON GOOD AFTERNOON ADDS
THREE SICUT COMEY HAVE FOR THE
ALAMEDA COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS AYE IN OPPOSITION IN
THIS MOMENT BUT VERY MUCH
LOOKING FORWARD TO REVIEWING THE
AMENDMENTS IN POTENTIALLY
REASSESSING THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH MORE EASILY
AND WE HAVE THE CALIFORNIA STATE
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES ALSO
WANT TO REVIEW THE AMENDMENTS
BUT RIGHT NOW RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSED.
THANK YOU SO MUCH ALSUP SAYING
GOOD MORNING ALSO GOOD AFTERNOON
PERFECT ALEX GIVES HERE ON
BEHALF TOWNSEND PUBLIC AFFAIRS
ON THE OF THE FOLLOWING EAST BAY
CITIES WERE IN OPPOSITION THE
CITIES OF WALNUT CREEK BERKELEY
HAYWARD.
AS WELL AS THE TRI VALLEY CITIES
OF DANVILLE DUBLIN LIVERMORE
PLEASANTON IN SAN RAMON THANK
YOU NICKY SO MUCH GRATEFUL.
WE'D LIKE TO BE ABLE TO OFFER A
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED IF YOU TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD THIS CAN BE LAST CALL
FOR POST.
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE UP FOR ANY DISCUSSION
--
THAT I ANY MEMBERS HAVE AND WE
ALSO WELCOME THE MOTION CENTER
HERTZBERG.
VIRTUAL MOVE THE BILL BUT
SECONDLY BOMB OR ASK THE
OPPOSITION [inaudible]
WE HAVE. FIVE THOUSAND ONE
HUNDRED SIXTY SIX SUBDIVISIONS
OF GOVERNMENT CALIFORNIA.
THE CONSTITUTION GIVES THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA THE RESPONSIBILITY
TO GOVERN THE AFFAIRS OF THE
SUBDIVISIONS OF THAT. FIFTY
EIGHT COUNTIES FORTY EIGHTY TWO
CITIES.
ALL OF THESE OTHER DISTRICTS.
WE GOT TAXPAYERS WOULD PICK UP
THE TAB.
ON THE WORK THAT WE DO.
IN THIS COMMITTEE AND THE LASKO
WORK THAT I DID FOR MANY YEARS
AND ALL THESE OTHER THINGS.
WE IN GOVERNMENT TOO MUCH FOCUS
ON OUR OWN POWER.
AND OUR OWN SENSE OF WHO SHOULD
BE DOING THE WORK.
VERSUS WHAT'S THE DELIVERABLE
FOR THE FOLKS.
RIGHT HOW MUCH HOW HE IT COST
EFFECTIVE AND GET STUFF DONE.
I THINK THAT THE AUTHOR WHO'S
DONE A LOT OF BIG LEGISLATION
AROUND HERE INVITES INTO BIG
GIGANTIC DEALS AND REALLY WORKS
HARD AT IT --
YOU KNOW BECAUSE CHINA TO LOOK
BEYOND THE MY OPEN MYOPIC AND
LOOK INTO THE STRUCTURAL.
IS SEEN IN TWO MONTHS MANY OTHER
AREAS ITEM LAST NIGHT MY OFFICE
DOING THE VERY SAME THING.
AT MIDNIGHT IS A HARD WORKING
GUY.
IT WAS HE TRYING TO DO HERE.
HE'S TRYING TO SAY THAT WE'VE
HAD THIS CHALLENGE WE'VE GOT
THIS BIG HOUSING PROBLEM AND IS
TRYING TO COME UP WITH AN
ALTERNATIVE TO FIX IT.
WHEN I LOOK AT ALL THE OPPONENTS
SAY LOOK AT IT AND SAY IT'S
STATUS QUO?
WHAT I WANT TO KNOW IS WHO CARES
WHAT DOES IT WITH ITS PARTNER
THIS GROUP OR THAT GROUP THE
QUESTION IS HOW DO YOU DELIVER
FOR PEOPLE?
AND WHY IS IT THAT YOUR DELIVERY
SYSTEM IS GOING TO BE IN YOUR
DECISION MAKERS ARE BETTER THAN
AND REGIONAL ENTITY THAT'S
LOOKING AT BOTH TRANSIT HOUSING
AND A MUCH BROADER WAY.
EXPLAIN THE ANSWER THAT QUESTION
YET NO HE MAKE AN EXCELLENT
POINT AND WE I WOULD GREET YOU
COMPLETELY.
I THINK THE THE ISSUE HERE IS
WHO'S MAKING THE DECISION AND
THE LEGISLATURE IS ALTERNATELY
IN THE DRIVER'S SEAT FOR FOR
DICTATING YOU KNOW WHO'S REALLY
DOING WHAT.
I'M WITH CITY COUNTIES YOU HAVE
THAT EXTRA LAYER OF THE
CONSTITUTION THE GRANT US
ADDITIONAL POWERS BUT IF THE
LEGISLATURE WANTED TO TELL
CITIES --
YOU KNOW WE NEED HAVE EXTENSIVE
THE EXITE WE NEED NATIONS THAT
WOULD BE A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT
CONVERSATION AND WOULD BE
COMPLETE WITHIN YOUR POWERS TO
PRE OF CITIES WITH CHARTER IN
GENERAL ALL.
I THINK IT MAKES OF THE
DIFFERENCE WHO CARES RIGHT WITH
WE TELL ONE GROUP THAT'S CREATED
BY THE STATE OR ANOTHER GROUP.
IF IF THE IDEAS MORE REGIONAL
AND AND WHAT HE'S DOING HERE IS
PRETTY SMART FELLA TRYING.
TO COME UP WITH A REGIONAL
SOLUTION THAT AVOID SOME OF THE
CHALLENGES THAT OFTEN.
BECAUSE IT IS PICKY WITH ISSUE
OF HOUSING.
ON HOW DO WE CAN LOCATE STUFF
DOES THAT'S WHY MOVE THE BILL IT
SEEMS PRETTY SMART TO ME.
AND IF IT DOESN'T WORK GUESS
WHAT YOU PICK IT UP AND YOU TRY
SOMETHING NEW BUT WHAT.
HAPPENED SO FAR BEYOND
PROTECTION HASN'T REALLY
PRODUCED MANY DELIVERABLE SO HE
SHOULD BE CREATED TO FIX THAT.
RIGHT I THINK THERE TO READ TOO
WELL HAVE FINALLY SHE'S HERE ONE
THE LEGISLATURE'S SHOULD SAY
WHAT THEY WANT AND NOT LEAVE IT
UP TO PART TO DECIDE AND TO BAR
IS NOT SO THEY'RE NOT A LAND USE
--
DEVELOPMENT ENTITY THEIR
EXPERTISE IS TRANSIT SO I WOULD
THINK THAT THERE BRIAN NOT THE
BEST POSITION TO DECIDE WHAT'S
BEST FOR HIGH DENSITY THAT SORT
OF STUFF I MEAN I THINK THAT THE
BEST. TO WORK WITH THE BOARD AS
THE CURRENT LAW YOU KNOW
SEXUALLY REQUIRES AND THAT CITY
COUNCIL MEMBERS LISTEN TO THEIR
COMMUNITIES I'M DETERMINE WHAT
THAT BEST AND IT IS SO I WOULD
ENCOURAGE THE LEGISLATURE TO
SAY.
WHAT YOU ALL LIKE TO SEE AROUND
TRANSIT OR IN DEVELOPMENT AND
SEE CITIES COUNTIES YOU DAYS GO
FIGURE OUT BASED ON INPUT FROM
THE COMMUNITY GO WORK WITH PART
TO TO DO IT?
AND THEN IT'S IT'S A WIN FOR
EVERYBODY.
BUT IF I MAY ADD WORDS BEEN
SUCCESSFUL SIR.
IS IN THE COMMUNITY WHERE DUBLIN
AND OTHERS SAN LEANDRO IT IS
ACTUALLY HAPPENING I INVITE ALL
OF YOU TO COME TO OUR
COMMUNITIES AND SEE THE
THOUSANDS OF UNITS ARE ACTUALLY
BEING BUILT.
TODAY.
AFTER MANY YEARS BUT I GUARANTEE
YOU IT'S NOT THE CITY THAT HAS
CAUSED THOSE DELAYS BY OTHER ALL
I CAN TELL YOU IS IF I LOOK AT
THIS MEASURE YOU'VE GOT
ASSEMBLYMEMBER CHU WHO'S A JOINT
AUTHORED I SEE WITH MISTER
GRAYSON WHO ALSO REPRESENTS THE
REGION.
THAT'S A MILLION PEOPLE.
THEN YOU'VE GOT MORE MISTER
MULLIN WHO ALSO IS IN THE
REGION.
BLOOM IS IN MY NECK OF THE WOODS
AND MISTER TANG.
HE GOT TO WHO MILLION PEOPLE
BEING WHERE GOT A BRILLIANT
WE'VE GOT SITTING NEXT TO GET
THE CHAIR OF NOT WHICH IS A
YEARS AGO THE WHOLE BAY AREA
STOP.
WHO ARE REALLY UNBELIEVABLY
EFFECTIVE THEY KICK OUR BUTTON
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ALL THE TIME
BECAUSE THEY GOT MUCH FEWER
PEOPLE ARE MUCH?
MORE ORGANIZED AND WE ARE SO AND
THEY'RE ALL ORGANIZED AND
THEY'RE SAYING THIS IS A
SOLUTION WHY IS THAT.
WHY IS THAT NOT PRETTY TO ME
THAT'S PERSUASIVE THEY'RE ALL
INTELLIGENT THEY'RE ALL REALLY
TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT THERE
THAT ALSO BEACH IS VERY SIMILAR
LOCAL ISSUES?
AND THEY'RE ALL SAY AND LET'S
GIVE IT A SHOT IT'S NOT JUST ON
THEIR SECRETIONS JOINT AUTHORED
THIS THING.
RIGHT LOOK AT WHAT HIS COMMUNITY
IS ACROSS THE BAY.
VERSES MISTER ACCUSED COMMUNITY
E. THAT SIMPSON MAY THAT AT
LEAST WE SHOULD GIVE IT A SHOT
AND IF IT A COUPLE YEARS IT
DOESN'T WORK THEN WE DON'T WE
ALWAYS DO WE WE VISITED.
AND WE FIX IT AGAIN.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SENATOR T.
WE'RE GONNA GO TO CENTER MORE
LOCK IN THE WRINGER CENTER BELL.
THANK YOU RICHARD MAYBE OUT OF
TAKE THE CON ON THAT ONE A
LITTLE BIT AND HAVE SOME FUN WE
HAVE THE LAWS AND COURT ARE
GOING TO ORANGE COUNTY.
AND I I WOULD SAY THAT WE'RE
PROBABLY NOT DOING OUR LIFE GOOD
JOB PUTTING GOOD HOUSING NEXT TO
THE TO THE RAIL SO I I I GET
THIS AND I I WAS VERY INTRIGUED
WITH SENATOR WINNERS BILL AS
WELL AS SORRY THAT.
THAT IT MOVE FORWARD BUT WE'VE
GOT CITIES THAT HAVE
[inaudible]
DONE IT [inaudible]
SO -- MR
STEMS -- YOU
GET A SUCCESSFUL MODEL --
HAS BARGE.
DONE ANYTHING WITH THEIR
PROPERTIES OTHER THAN.
IN THE THREE CITIES THAT YOU
MENTIONED.
HEY I KNOW HAVE PARTNERS WITH
OTHER CITIES IN THE SPACE SAID
VERY SUCCESSFULLY --
IN DUBLIN --
WE HAVE PROPERTIES THAT THEY
CONTROL PANEL WHICH ARE.
NOT ONLY STRUCTURE.
WHERE THERE IS VERY LITTLE OF
SURFACE PARKING AND UPLAND WE
HAVE DEVELOPED OUR TRANSIT
CENTERS TWO OF THEM?
WITH OVER THREE THOUSAND UNITS.
SO ARE THEY STRUCTURED SO THAT
THERE IT'S A IT'S A PARKING
STRUCTURE MENUS THE AIR SPACE
ABOVE FOR HOUSING.
AYE IT'S ADJACENT TO THE HOUSING
PROJECT HOME IMMEDIATELY
ADJACENT YES AND EMILIE DE SOME
TO THE BART STATIONS THEMSELVES.
I DON'T SEE SAN FRANCISCO
OPPOSING THIS BILL AND LET'S I
MISSED IT [inaudible]
I'M.
SO DO THEY HAVE.
PARKING STRUCTURES WHERE THEY
CAN.
AT HOUSING ON TOP OR HOW I HOW
WOULD YOU PROPOSE IF IF I COULD
THE THE THE THRUST OF THIS BILL
IS REALLY TO ADDRESS HUNDREDS OF
ACRES OF BART OWN LAND AROUND
BART STATIONS THAT ARE CURRENTLY
SURFACE PARKING LOTS.
THAT'S REALLY WHAT WE'RE FOCUSED
ON SO I JUST WANNA MAKE THAT
VERY CLEAR WE'RE NOT TRYING TO
DEVELOP OTHER ASPECTS OF OF OF
OF THE CITY WERE TALKING ABOUT
LAND THAT HAS BEEN OWNED BY
BART.
THAT PART HAS BEEN TRYING FOR
DECADES. TO WORK WITH CITIES TO
DEVELOP WHERE CITIES HAVE NOT
CHOSEN TO SUPPORT IT.
BOMB THE AYE AS A FORMER LOCAL
OFFICIALS I THINK ALMOST ALL OF
US ARE AYE I'M VERY.
VERY VERY RESPECTFUL OF OF OF
ENSURING THAT LOCAL COMMUNITIES
ARE ABLE TO CONTROL THEIR
DESTINY AND AND SHIP THEIR
COMMUNITIES AS THEY SEE FIT BUT
AT THIS TIME IN HISTORY.
WHEN WE HAVE THE INTENSITY OF
THE HOUSING CRISIS AND?
IDEA THAT PART CAN'T THINK OF
HOW TO BUILD A HOUSING A MIXED
USE DEVELOPMENT ON TOP A SURFACE
PARKING LOTS THAT'S THAT'S THE
PROBLEM THAT WE ARE TRYING TO
SOLVE.
AND A IN A AGAIN I WANNA THINK
THE CHAIR BECAUSE WE'VE WE'VE
WORKED THROUGH THESE TOUGH
ISSUES AND I THINK THE SOLUTIONS
THAT ARE EMBODIED IN THE IN THE
IN THE AMENDMENTS REALLY
REPRESENT.
ELEGANT WAYS OF BOTH RESPECTING
WHERE -- HOW
COMMUNITIES ENVISION THEMSELVES
BUT ALSO ENSURING THAT HOPEFULLY
IF THIS BILL WERE TO PASS FOR
ACTUALLY MOVING FORWARD
ADDITIONAL DEVELOPMENT AND AND
WE JUST MENTION THAT WE DO HAVE
A REPRESENTATIVE FROM BART HERE
IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS YOU LIKE
TO DIRECT TO THEM DIRECTLY
BECAUSE I KNOW?
YOU HAD A QUESTION ABOUT BART'S
EXPERIENCE AND AND TRY TO BUILD
THIS HOUSING.
WELL I'M JUST TRYING TO PREVENT
THIS FUNCTIONALISM BECAUSE
YOU'VE GOT THE CITY CENTER.
BUT KNOWING THAT IT CAN BE DONE
AND I'D RATHER START LOOKING AT
SOME CARROTS AT STATISTICS --
OF COURSE I'M FROM SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA SO I USE BARK WHEN I
FLY INTO THE AIRPORT AND GO IN
THE TOWN I LET SAN FRANCISCO
BAGHDAD BY THE BAILIFF.
GROUP CAME FAN I'M I'M ALL THERE
BUT YOU KNOW IF WE GOT SOME SOME
CITIES THAT ARE DOING WHAT
THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO BE DOING AND
AND WHAT I GET TO SEE PART I SEE
ON THE NEWS HERE I GET TO HEAR
ABOUT CRIME AND AMAZING STORIES
ABOUT WHAT GOES.
ON HIS TRAIN STATIONS AYE.
AYE AYE BUT AL ALTHOUGH WE
DEFINITELY TIME BUT I I I I I'M
JUST RIGHT THERE AND HOW DO I
INCUR. TO TO EXPEDITE AND AND I
DON'T I I'M HAVING.
THE DISCONNECT HERE SO PLEASE
PLEASE USHER AND I APPRECIATE
THAT YOU KNOW I KNOW THE LEAGUE
OF CITIES REFERENCE THAT SUPPORT
OF MANY YEARS AGO OF OF S. B.
THREE SEVENTY FIVE AND I THINK.
SB THREE SEVENTY FIVE WE ALL HAD
THE GREAT HOPE THAT THAT WOULD.
BE A SET OF CARROTS TO
BRING-ALONG TRANSITORY
DEVELOPMENT AND
THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS IT IT
JUST HASN'T HAPPENED.
AND THEN UP AGAIN I'M LIKE I
MEAN THIS WITH GREAT RESPECT I
KNOW THAT --
THAT THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE
SPACE CITIES HAS TALKED ABOUT
WHAT SOME OF THE CITIES ARE
DOING -- BUT
WHAT DO THOSE OF US WHO'VE BEEN
OBSERVING THIS WE HAVE A VERY
DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE ABOUT WHAT
CITIES ARE NOT DOING SO FOR
EXAMPLE CITY A DOUBLE IN JUST A
COUPLE MONTHS AGO.
VOTED HUNDREDS OF UNITS DOWN
NEAR THE DUBLIN PLEASANTON BART
STATION LAFAYETTE FORCED A
DEVELOPER TO CHANGE PLANS FOR AN
APARTMENT BUILDING OF THREE
HUNDRED FIFTEEN UNITS DOWN
TO FORTY FOUR HIGH AND SINGLE
FAMILY HOMES WITHIN WALKING
DISTANCE OF A PARK STATION IN
WALNUT CREEK SITE OF ANOTHER
BART STATION.
THAT CITY KILLED HOUSING
DEVELOPMENT ON A FORMER GOLF
COURSE BY COLLECTING SIGNATURES
TO PUT DEVELOPMENT TO A PUBLIC
VOTE.
ANOTHER TRANSITORY DEVELOPMENTS
ON PARK LAND IN WALNUT CREEK
THAT STARTED BEING DEVELOPED IN.
TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN YEARS AGO
HAS ONLY BEGAN TO BREAK GROUND
IN PLEASANTON THAT CITY HAD AN
ABSOLUTE HOUSING CAP FOR YEARS
BEFORE LAWSUITS OVERTURNED THEM.
AND IN THE CITY LIVERMORE PART
RECENTLY MADE A NEW PROPOSED
LIVERMORE BART STATION WHICH
WOULD COST ONE POINT SIX BILLION
DOLLARS IN PART BECAUSE
LIVERMORE.
CHOSE. TO DERAIL THE ORIGINAL
PROPOSED SITE IN THE DOWNTOWN
AREA TO MOVE IT TO A LESS DENSE
AREAS SO --
IF THERE'S A DIFFERENCE OF A
PERSPECTIVE ON THIS BUT I WANTED
TO PROVIDE THAT TOO BECAUSE I
THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO GET
CONTEXT AND WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO
ADDRESS.
AN EXCELLENT RESPONSE BUT THANK
YOU THANK YOU YOU ARE.
SO SO.
MAYBE I COULD GET.
THE REVITALIZED THIS SUDDEN MP
FAME WHAT WHAT WHAT WHAT'S
PREVENTING YOU FROM.
FROM BEING A LITTLE MORE
SUCCESSFUL AND IF IT WORKS AND
ASK EACH OF OUR OPPOSED IT TO BE
OF USE IT REINTRODUCE HIMSELF
WHEN THEY SPEAK TO SO WE HAVE A
RECORD OKAY LOOK SIMS COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR OF ITS CITY
DO.
DUBLIN AND IN FAIRNESS --
SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF DUBLIN AND
WHAT WE'VE BEEN ABLE DORADO PARK
STATION --
EOBARD HAS BEEN A TREMENDOUS
PARTNER REALLY HAS COME TO WHERE
I THINK THE CONCERN COMES IN IS
THAT IF I MAY IS IN THE IS
ADDING A LAYER OF BUREAUCRACY
THE IF I MAY WHAT WE NEED TO DO
IN ORDER TO MOVE FORWARD IS.
GET THERE WHERE THE RUBBER MEETS
THE ROAD AND LET THESE
COMMUNITIES WORK WITH BART TO
DEVELOP THEIR PROPERTIES.
MANY THESE DELAYS A PEOPLE
TALKED ABOUT.
HAVE BEEN BECAUSE BECAUSE OF
ISSUES WITH BART --
FINANCING LE THEY NEED TO PAY
FOR REPLACEMENT PARKING THAT IS
ON THE SURFACE LOTS OTHERWISE
HOW ARE PEOPLE GOING TO GET TO
THE BART STATION OF THE LIVE
MORE THAN A HALF A MILE AWAY --
ALL OF THESE VERY COMPLICATED
ISSUES NEED TO BE ADDRESSED AND
THEY'RE NOT EASY AND EACH CITY
IS A LITTLE BIT.
DIFFERENT --
SO.
THAT'S WHY IS THIS BILL SELF IS
JUST KIND OF A ONE OFF THING I
THINK LOOKING AT IT IN A MORE
COMPREHENSIVE WAY WITH THE OTHER
BILLS LETTER.
COMING BEFORE YOU IN THE MONTHS
AHEAD IT MAKES.
IT'S MORE SENSE.
BECAUSE MUCH SIMILAR LOOKING
OTHER ITEMS.
SURE THINK UNANSWERED COMMENTS
BUT I WANNA TURN OVER CENTER
BALLOT IS ONE EIGHT KNOWLEDGE.
CENTRE BELL --
HE WORKED ON THIS BILL --
WITH THE SENATE MEMBER ONLINE
AFFORDABILITY I KNOW THAT'S BEEN
A REALLY BIG PRIORITY FOR HIM
AND I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
CENTER BELL AS CHAIR I
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING
[inaudible]
WELL THE I JUST WANNA THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR WORKING WITH US THINK
THAT.
THE CITY GOVERNMENTS --
FOR OF PARTICIPATING IN.
YOU KNOW WE HAVE TO THINK ARE
OBVIOUSLY OUT TO START THINKING
OUT OF THE BOX SO.
IN TERMS OF FROM [inaudible]
CREATING --
THIS NEW OF TRANSIT ORIENTED
URBANISM THAT'S GOING TO TAKE
PLACE IN.
CITIES AND THE BAY AREA CALL.
MY CITY INCLUDED SALAS A SENSE
WERE ABOUT TO OPEN --
A KNEW BART STATION IN SAN JOSE
--
SO.
I AM VERY PLEASED TO TELL THE
COMMITTEE THAT --
THE BART EXTENSION INTO SANTA
CLARA COUNTY --
THE CITY MILPITAS SUBSIDIES SAN
JOSE.
OR THE JURISDICTIONS IN A A
FULLY ENGAGED AND TRANSIT OR IN
DEVELOPMENT --
IT'S BEING BUILT NOW OF
THOUSANDS OF U. S.. SIX SEVEN
STOREY HIGH --
UNITS WITH A FOUR IT WAS SOME OF
THE IN AFFORDABLE --
HAVE BEEN BUILT.
IN THOSE COMMUNITIES SO IT'S
THEIR FULLY ENGAGED IN THE
PROCESS.
I THINK YOU ARE OFFICIAL USE OF
LAND.
AND EFFICIENT USE OF LAND THAT
ENCOURAGES NAM [inaudible]
TRANSIT.
WILL BE A ECONOMIC LIFESAVER FOR
THE AY AREA WE JUST HAVE TO DO
THOSE.
WE HAVE TO ENCOURAGE.
AN EFFICIENT USE OF LAND --
WITHOUT SACRIFICING THE THIS
DATA CONCERNS --
COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT CONCERNS
ALL THOSE KINDS OF THINGS HAVE
TO BE.
PART OF THAT NINE KNOW THAT PART
IS COMMITTED.
TO THOSE KINDS OF PLANNING
[inaudible]
PROCESSES.
OF THAT I WOULD INSIST ON BEING
A PERSON THAT HAS OF DISCIPLINE
IN.
URBAN PLANNING SO I I I THINK
THOSE THINGS ARE VERY IMPORTANT
--
THE WAY BOARD DESIGNS IN WORKS
WITH THE COMMUNITIES AND ALSO
THE ENVIRONMENTAL.
ISSUES IS SO HAVE A MAJOR IMPACT
ON GREENHOUSE GASES.
BY PUTTING MORE PEOPLE CLOSE TO
TRANSIT.
IT'LL MAKE THE AIR CLEANER GET
PEOPLE OUT OF THEIR CARS SO.
I EXPECTED SO --
WE WILL SEE A URBAN AS AND THAT
BECOMES ATTRACTED TO PEOPLE --
AND THEN THE LAST WEEK MISTER
CHAIRMAN.
I BELIEVE THAT.
WHEN WE USE PUBLIC LAND LOS?
AND WE'VE PUT A BART STATION IT
GENERATES ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
IT WILL DIE OUT THE DEFINITELY
INCREASE PROPERTY VALUES AROUND
THE BART STATION.
WE ALL KNOW THAT'S GOING TO
HAPPEN.
IT HAS HAPPENED IN THE PAST BUT
THERE ARE SOME BAD THINGS THAT
HAPPEN.
WHEN YOU HAVE ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
SOMETIMES AND THAT'S THAT?
IT HAS THE ISSUE OF
DISPLACEMENT.
OF OF PEOPLE OF THAT LIVING IN
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
AND THANK YOU --
TO THE OFFICER.
FOR PUTTING IN --
PROVISIONS THAT PROTECT THAT AND
ALSO REQUIRE A CERTAIN
PERCENTAGE.
OF THE HOUSING UNITS TO BE
AFFORDABLE. FOR LOW IN VERY LOW
INCOME I KNOW OTHER PEOPLE HAVE
A DIFFERENCE OF OPINION.
AND BUT MY OPINION DOES IS
[inaudible]
FAURIA -- IS
IN A NEW ERA WHERE THE STATE IS
INVESTING.
SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT MONIES IN THE
TRANSPORTATION AND HOUSING IN
FACT AND HOUSING WERE --
HOPEFULLY GOING TO HIT --
A BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR IF THE
BOND MEASURE IS APPROVED.
WE WILL HIT A BILLION DOLLARS IN
YEAR AND THAT WILL BE CLOUT FOR
HOW AFFORDABLE HOUSING SO THAT
OF THE CLOTHES.
THAT WE CLOSE --
TO THE LEVEL.
THE LEVEL OF THAT --
WE ACHIEVE WHEN WE HAD
REDEVELOPMENT.
AND THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING COULD
BE BUILT NEXT TO THE TRANSIT TO
HELP THE COMMUNITIES.
DO BETTER PLANNING [inaudible]
AND ARE IS VERY EXCITING FOR THE
BAY AREA.
AND I THINK TO BURY IS VERY
POSITIVE ABOUT BAR --
PEOPLE WERE READY AND WAITING
FOR AND SAN JOSE --
WERE SO EXCITED ABOUT --
PART PROJECT THAT WE VOTED --
FOR THE ARE HIM.
THREE PASSED IN THE BAY AREA.
AND THAT'S ANOTHER VALIDATION
[inaudible]
THE PEOPLE.
VOTED FOR LE THE FUNDING FOR
FOREIGN HALF BILLION DOLLARS
WORTH OF PROJECTS.
THAT INCLUDE BART INCLUDE TO
PARK CARS.
AND HELPING --
BOARD HAVE A FINANCIAL
STABILITY.
WITH UPGRADING THEIR EQUIPMENT
AND NO.
SO I I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHORS
FOR THOSE.
I KNOW --
BOTH OF THEM CARE ABOUT THIS
THIS IS THE FUTURE OF THE BAY
AREA.
AND WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE ITS ALL
INCLUSIVE THANK YOU.
FOR YOUR AMENDMENTS THAT
INCLUDED MORE --
AFFORDABILITY AND THE LATEST AND
I KNOW THE PLANNING WILL TAKE
CARE OF THE PLANNING AND WE'RE
GOING TO HAVE SOME GOOD PLANS
FOR THE STATIONS --
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE GOOD PROF I
QUALITY PROJECTS.
BECAUSE I DON'T THINK A BOARD
BOARD MEMBER WOULD APPROVE A
PROJECT AND IT WASN'T A HIGH
QUALITY.
AND IS IT A LOT PEOPLE WATCHING
THESE --
PROJECTS AS THEY DEVELOP SO THAT
WE HAVE --
GOOD QUALITY PROJECTS AND ARE
BARRED STATIONS AND I KNOW
THAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN.
AND EVERYBODY'S HOPEFUL THAT --
OF WE'RE ALL WORK TOGETHER TO
MAKE THAT HAPPENED SO INO THE
PLANNING WILL BE PART OF THIS --
ALSO SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
APPRECIATE MR CHAIRMAN OF A
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND I MEAN IT
AT ONCE I THINK YOU TO THE
CHAIRMAN OF TRANSPORTATION AND
HOUSING.
UPPER HIS PARTNERSHIP ON THIS --
AS HARSH STEPS TO WORKING
TOGETHER IN VERY VERY GRATEFUL
MISTER CHAIR OF FOR ALL YOU WORK
SIR THANK YOU SAID ABOUT.
ITEM A CLOSING COMMENT BEFORE I
GO THERE IS FUN TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM THIS COMMITTEE --
WHEN WE TAKE A LOOK AT A LOT OF
WHAT OUR DEFICIT IS WHEN IT
COMES TO JUST AFFORDABLE HOUSING
UNITS IN THE STATE? THREE POINT
FOUR MILLION. THREE POINT FOUR
MILLION.
THAT'S WHAT IT COMES AFFORDABLE.
APARTMENTS CONDOS AND SINGLE
FAMILY HOMES.
THIS BILL IS SOLELY FOCUSED --
ON THOSE THREE HUNDRED ACRES OF
PARKING LOTS AND LOTS OF
POTENTIAL STATIONS THAT ARE
GONNA BE MOVING.
OR BY IT'S VERY SPECIFIC POT AS
THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD.
BUT THE AUTHOR.
I WAS WILLING TO BE TO WORK WITH
US ON THE ISSUE OF EMINENT
DOMAIN -- IN
THAT I THINK THAT'S ANOTHER
IMPORTANT PROTECTION FOR LOCAL
GOVERNMENT --
THE WAY HE IS SHOWN ITS
COMMITMENT TO HOUSING.
IS AND FOR WORKING FAMILIES
WORKING WITH THE CHAIR
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING ON THE
ISSUE OF THE AFFORDABLE
PERCENTAGE.
AND THIS BILL GUARANTEES THAT AT
LEAST HALF AT LEAST HALF --
WILL BE AT THAT SQUARE FOOTAGE
OF THE PROJECT WILL BE
GUARANTEED.
FOR HOUSING.
HOUSING FOR FAMILIES IN THE BAY
--
IT ALSO HAS SOME OF THE
STRONGEST.
DISPLACEMENT PROVISIONS OTHER
THIS LEGISLATURE SEEN.
A HEARING TEAM IF AN
INDIVIDUAL'S DISPLACED THEY
STILL ARE GOING TO LIVE IN IN
THE COMMUNITY THAT THEY CALL
HOME [inaudible]
AND AGAIN. TO MAKE SURE THAT
THIS WORKS.
BUT THERE IS A AN OFFRAMP AND
THAT'S TENURE SUNSET --
AND I THINK THAT PUTS THE ONUS
ON THE BARD. TO BE ABLE TO GET
THESE UNITS BUILT.
I'M AND THEN THE BEST WAY TO BE
ABLE TO SEE IF THIS WORKS IS YOU
COME BACK.
AYE IN IF IT'S NOT WORKING IT'S
CAN BE VERY CLEAR.
IF IT.
SIX I TO BOTH ASSEMBLYMEMBERS
FOR ALL THE WORK ON THIS OFC
THINK YOU TO THOSE.
WHO SPEND TIME HERE ODAY TRAVEL
FAR AND WIDE THINKING SAY
MANAGERS WELL?
ARMED WERE OPPOSED UNLESS IT
THANK OU TO LISTENERS CHOOSE TO
STAFF THAT KEVIN IS HERE TODAY
--
KEVIN I DIDN'T SLEEP LAST NIGHT
SO -- HE'S
HAD THREE RENTALS TODAY SO WE
APOLOGIZE --
AND ALSO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
TO IN TIME.
BUT TODAY IN OUR FIRST PHONE
CONVERSATION WAS ABOUT TEN THE
SIX OF THIS MORNING SO THIS WAS
A THINK IT AND TURN ON THIS.
A SIMILAR THANK YOU FOR YOUR
PARTNERSHIP SIR ARE GRATEFUL FOR
YOUR WORK.
AND HAVE YOU CLOSE.
JUST QUICKLY I JUST TO TESTIFY
OF BOMBARDS COLLABORATION AND
WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH LOCALS.
AS OF MAYOR OF THE CITY BEFORE I
CAME A ASSEMBLY MEMBER --
BART VOLUNTARILY STEPPED OUT AND
APPROACHED THE CITY BY BEFORE
THEY STARTED CAPITAL
IMPROVEMENTS IN A DOWNTOWN PARK
STATION.
AND WAS SO WILLING TO WORK WITH
THE CITY THEY EVEN CHANGE THEIR
LIGHTS STANDARDS TO OUR REQUEST
INTO OUR DESIRES SO AS A
TESTIMONY --
FOR TO EQUAL THAT OF DUBLIN --
BAR IS A GOOD PARTNER AND DIE I
BELIEVE A SENATOR BILL BROUGHT
UP THE POINT MANY EYES ARE ON
THIS.
AND WE WILL SEE HIGH QUALITY
PROJECTS RESULT FROM THIS
[inaudible]
COMMITMENT.
THANK YOU LET ME ALSO A ECHO
COUPLE OF ADDITIONAL THANKS IN
ADDITION TO TO MY STAFF WHO.
LIKE SENATE MCGUIRE STAFF HAS
BEEN WORKING ROUND THE CLOCK --
IN RECENT DAYS ON THIS I WANT TO
THANK -- WE
HERE -- HIS
COLLEAGUE JONATHAN WHO HAS ALSO
WORKED AROUND THE CLOCK ON THIS
ABOUT CENTER BELL THANK YOU FOR
YOUR ENGAGEMENT IN YOUR
COMMITTEE YOU I THINK A PAVE THE
WAY FOR A NUMBER OF THE MAJOR
CONCEPTS THAT WE ARE.
CAN BE TAKEN AS A MEMBERS OF
THIS COMMITTEE AND THEN AGAIN
ABOUT THE CHAIRMAN OF THIS
COMMITTEE OF FOR YOUR YOUR DEEP
ENGAGEMENT ON THIS.
ALBUM.
AT THE END OF THE DAY WE
SIGNIFICANTLY NEED TO THINK OF
HOW WE'RE GONNA FIGURE OUT
TRANSITORY DEVELOPMENT AND I
KNOW THAT --
THERE WERE EARLIER CONVERSATIONS
THIS YEAR BUT WE REALLY BELIEVE
THAT THIS IS AS SCULPTED AND IS
CAREFULLY CRACKED CRAFTED AS WE
POSSIBLY CAN.
AND I WANT TO SAY TO THE CITIES
WHO STILL REMAIN IN OPPOSITION A
THANK YOU FOR ENGAGEMENT WITH
OUR MUTUAL OFFICES ON THIS OP I
DO HOPE THAT YOU WILL SEE IN THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE ACCEPTED.
THAT WE REALLY HAVE BEEN
LISTENING ARE AND WHILE.
WE MAY NOT HAVE COMPLETE
AGREEMENT --
WANT EXACTLY WHERE IT IS WE WILL
CONTINUE TO TO TO TRY TO REFINE
THIS TO GET TO THE GOAL OF OF
BUILDING HOUSING.
ADDRESSING CONGESTION INCREASING
TRANSIT RIDERSHIP AND AND
CREATING JOBS AT THE SAME TIME
BOTOMIAN AND WITH --
WITH ONE POINT IF HOPEFUL A
LEVITY HERE WHICH IS THERE'S THE
OLD JONI MITCHELL SONG.
ABOUT HOW THEY PAVED PARADISE
AND PUT UP A PARKING LOT.
AND OUR HOPE WITH THIS BILL IS
THAT WE'RE GOING TO TAKE THOSE
PARKING LOTS AND BRING BACK NEW.
NEIGHBORHOOD SET REFLECT THAT
NEW PARADISES OF HOW WE LIVE OUR
IN OUR DENSE URBAN COMMUNITIES
AND AND MOVE BEYOND THE HOUSING
AND TRANSIT CRISIS THAT WE HAVE
AND WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR SUPPORT.
BIGGEST IMAGISM MEMBER IN THANK
YOU SOME EVER FOR ALL OF YOU.
TWO WERE ALSO TAKING
TRANSPORTATION --
SUMMER TO CONFIRM THAT WERE
TAKING GOVERNMENT FINANCE ON THE
MIDSUMMER CONFIRM WORLD STICKING
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING AND
ABSOLUTELY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
OUT WITHOUT THIS IS SAID TO HAVE
A MOTION ON THE FLOOR.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR BELL
THIS IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS ROLL CALL PLEASE
MUSLIM CHESTERTON.
AYE WIRE AYE NGUYEN FELL.
BILL I'VE HERNANDEZ GONNA DECIDE
HERTZBERG.
LARA [inaudible]
MARLA.
MORE NO. THREE THEIR CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A THREE ONE THAT WE'RE
GOING TO KEEP THAT ON CALL.
BY IT WILL AT YOUR OFFICE IS NO
SINCE WE GET A QUORUM THINK A SO
MUCH.
EVERY BRIDES OF SORRY I SINCE WE
HAVE A MISTER LARA MISTER AYE
HERTZBERG AYE OR VICE CHAIR WYNN
BACK I DO APOLOGIZE THINKING.
UPSWING KEEP THAT BILL OPEN
MEMBERS WE HAVE TO VOTE ON A
FILE ITEM TO AT THE MOMENT
BECAUSE THIS HAS TO BE
TRANSMITTED OVER TO HEALTH. FOR
AN AFTERNOON HEARING.
ON THAT WE STILL HAVE ONE
ADDITIONAL --
BILL THAT MR CHOOSE CAN BE
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF MR TING
THAT'S FILE ITEM.
TWENTY TWO I THINK MISTER TING
IS HOT NOT BEEN WITH THE
GOVERNOR BROWN AND CHAIR
MITCHELL AYE AS GET THE BUDGET
SIGN SO --
BILLS ARE GONNA BE PAID A BUT WE
DECADE TAKE ACTION AND FILE ITEM
NUMBER.
TWO BY IN IF IT'S THE WILL OF
THE COMMITTEE WOULD ACTUALLY
LIKE TO BE ABLE TO CLOSE THE
ROLE.
ON THIS BILL BECAUSE WE HAVE TO
BE ABLE TO GET OVER TO HEALTH.
WHICH MEANS WE HAVE TO CROSS IT
--
OVER ON THE FLOOR SO WHAT I'D
LIKE TO BE A TO DO IS ASK FOR A
MOTION THIS IS A DO PASSED THE
HEALTH.
AND THEN --
EVEN THOUGH WE DON'T HAVE ALL
THE RICH HERE WE'RE GONNA NEED
TO BE A CLOSE IT DOWN.
BY AND PASS IT OUT TO GET OVER
TO HEALTH.
BY IS THERE.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SEN
HERNANDEZ THIS IS A DO PASSED TO
HELP.
ACQUIRED BY WIRE ALWYN.
DEL.
VALLE AYE HERNANDEZ.
AND DECIDE HERTZBERG LARA MORE
LAW.
ALRIGHT MORE LOCKED EYES.
YOU KNOW WHAT MORE LIKE.
HOW DO YOU?
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
PAY THEIR YEAH EXACTLY.
AYE AYES ON FILE ITEM TO
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
PREFER GOD [inaudible]
HERTZBERG BY [inaudible]
BUT THAT [inaudible]
I DIDN'T [inaudible] TO FIVE I
LEARNED QUITE A MEMBERS I'D THAT
IS A FIVE OH VOTE OUT BECAUSE OF
TIME CONSTRAINTS WERE GOING TO
CLOSE THE ROLE PASSED THE BILL
OUT.
AND WE'RE GOING TO TRANSMIT OVER
TO HEALTH FIVE THOUGH OUT OF
COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING ON THE
FILE ITEM TWENTY TWO AB TWENTY
EIGHT NINETY ASSEMBLYMEMBER TING
AYE STANDING IN FOR THE BUDGET
YEAR WE HAVE AS AND NUMBER CHIU.
THAT MR SUMMON HE FLOORS OR SIR
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR BEFORE I
WEAR OUT MY WELCOME APPRECIATE
YOUR CONSIDERATION OF THIS BILL
ON BEHALF OF MY SAN FRANCISCO
COLLEAGUE.
LA I WILL SAY THAT MR TING WILL
BE ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
MINUTES TO BRING FEES BACK TO
EXISTING LAW.
AND TO SPECIFY MINISTERIAL
APPROVAL ONLY BILL WOULD REMOVE
BARRIERS TO THE WIDESPREAD
ADOPTION.
OF EXCEPT THREE DWELLING UNITS
AS A LOW COST ENERGY EFFICIENT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. EIGHTY USE
AS WELL AS JUNIOR EIGHTY YEARS
ARE A FORM OF HOUSING THAT CAN
BE RAPIDLY INCREASED WITH LITTLE
COST TO THE STATE.
RECENT STUDY BY THE TURNER
CENTER FROM UC BERKELEY
DOCUMENTED THAT DESPITE NUMEROUS
EIGHTY LOOK AT YOU LAWS BEEN
ENACTED IN RECENT YEARS.
MANY CITIES AND COUNTIES
CONTINUE TO AND EVENLY IMPOSED
BARRIERS THAT HAVE PREVENTED
THEIR DEVELOPMENT.
THIS BILL WOULD REMOVE THESE
TYPES OF BARRIERS TO ALLOW FOR
THE NON DISCRIMINATORY BUILDING
OF EIGHTY USE AND JUNIOR EIGHTY
USE THROUGHOUT OUR STATE.
IN ADDITION THIS BILL WILL HELP
TO RAPIDLY INCREASE HOUSING
STOCK IN DENSE URBAN AREAS BY
ALLOWING THE CONSTRUCTION OF
MULTIPLE EIGHTY USE ON MULTI
FAMILY PROPERTIES.
AND ALLOWING THE CONSTRUCTION OF
BOTH AND EIGHTY YOU IN A JUNIOR
EIGHTY YOU ON SINGLE FAMILY LOTS
WHICH HAS BEEN A PARTICULARLY
CRITICAL FOR FIRE ZONES --
SO FOR EXAMPLE CINEMA COUNTY AND
SANTA BARBARA HAVE BEEN
ENCOURAGING THE BUILDING OF
THESE UNITS QUICKLY TO REBUILD
HOMES THAT WERE DEVASTATED BY
LOCAL FIRES.
THIS BILL WILL ALLOW
CALIFORNIANS BILL MORE HOUSING
AND ADDRESS THE HOUSING CRISIS
WHAT THAT I LIKE TO TURN IT OVER
TO A WITNESSES STARTING FIRST
WITH MS DENISE PINKS AND FROM
THE BAY AREA COUNCIL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH CHANGES TO
MAKE NOTE FOR THE COMMITTEE THE
COMMITTEE SAW SIMILAR BILLS THAT
WERE ADVANCED BY CENTER RIGHT
HOUSE SCENE SENATOR SKINNER.
HAD COME THROUGH THIS COMMITTEE
THESE AMENDMENTS CONVERT THAT
BRING CENTER TEENS BILL IN
CONFORMITY WITH THOSE TWO OTHER
SENATE BILLS THAT HAVE RT
ADVANCE THIS YEAR. TO APOLOGIZE
WHEN IT TURNED OVER YOU HAVE TWO
MINUTES TO WELCOME THE COMMITTEE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
I'M HERE TODAY IS A VOLUNTEER
[inaudible]
MANY TO BRING TO A BILL THAT
REFLECTS OF SEVERAL YEARS OF
WORK OF VOLUNTEERS WHO BUILD
EIGHTY USE HOMEOWNER SHOULD LIKE
TO BUILD A TO USE BUT CAN'T --
RETIRED AND COULD CURRENT OF
PLANNING PROFESSIONALS WHO
DEVELOPED A LIST OF BEST
PRACTICES RECOMMENDED AT UC
BERKELEY UCLA PLUS CENTERS.
FOR HOUSING POLICY --
INCORORATE BEST PRACTICES FOR
EIGHTY USE AROUND THE UNITED
STATES --
INCLUDING RECENTLY
RECOMMENDATIONS BY THE NATIONAL
A. P. A. FOR ELIMINATING
OUTMODED ZONING STANDARDS LIKE
MINIMUM LOT SIZE --
HOMEOWNERS ARE IT DEVELOPERS.
AND ONE OF THE THINGS IT'S
IMPORTANT THAT WE'RE LEARNING IN
THE ASIA WOULD YOU WORLD IS THAT
PLANNING AND ZONING RULES CAN
PREVENT HOMEOWNERS FROM EVER
GETTING A BUILDING PERMIT.
SO WHAT FOLKS DO IN THAT
INSTANCE IS IF THEY NEED THEM
THEY BUILD THEM ILLEGALLY THE
BILL THEM AND SAFELY AND THEY
NEVER MEET HEALTH AND SAFETY
CODES.
SO WITH THESE BILLS TO DO IS
REMOVE THE MOST PERSISTENT AND
PERNICIOUS ZONING BARRIERS TO
ACCESS REDRAWING UNITS TO GET
OUT OF THE WAY SO HOMEOWNERS CAN
MAKE THESE THINGS LEGAL AND SAFE
--
AND LET THEM TAKE OFFICE A FORM
OF INVISIBLE INFILL --
THIS BILL IS OE OF THE FEW WAYS
TO MAKE AN IMMEDIATE DENT IN THE
HOUSING CRISIS THAT HAS PEOPLE
IN CALIFORNIA SLEEPING IN THEIR
CARS ON A REGULAR BASIS.
TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE THERE ARE
ALMOST NO HOUSING POLICIES THAT
CAN GO FROM YOUR VOTE TO
BUILDING PERMIT IN TWELVE MONTHS
OR LESS.
SO I ASK IN THAT NATURE FOR YOUR
STRONG SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH REFER HERE AT
WELCOME BACK MA'AM IT'S NICE TO
SEE YOU.
THE FLOORS GEORGE OF TWO
MINUTES%
OKAY PARA MY NAME'S DEBBIE
SANDERSON I'M ALSO RETIRED
PLANNING MANAGER I'VE SPENT
TWENTY FIVE YEARS DOING LOCALLY
AND USE.
THE PLANNING --
SO.
I'M HERE TO SUPPORT THIS BILL I
WHO HAVE DECIDED TO SPEND THEIR
FREE TIME?
AFTER WORK --
EXCEPT TRYING TO REMOVE
OBSTACLES TO BUILDING EIGHTY
YEARS. ONE IMPORTANT THING BUT
I'D LIKE FOR EVERYONE TO
UNDERSTAND IS THAT.
THIS BILL REPRESENTS A SLIGHT
SHIFT IN POWER AT THE LOCAL
LEVEL FROM.
THE NEIGHBORS WHO CAN COME TO
PUBLIC HEARINGS AND OPPOSE
THINGS AND AND STOP THEM A
LITTLE BIT TOWARD THE HOMEOWNERS
--
THE THIS SHIFT IS UP HOOPS THIS
SHIFT IS ESSENTIAL FOR YOU TO
GET I DO USE BELT --
THERE ARE THOUSANDS AND
THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS OF THESE
UNITS THAT EXIST.
NEIGHBORS ALREADY LIVE WITH THEM
THEY DON'T CALL THE CODE
ENFORCEMENT AND TURN THE MAN.
HOMEOWNERS OF BUILT UP ALL OVER
THE PLACE.
BOB DID FAMILIES ARE DESPERATE
AND WHEN THEY NEED THIS THEY
WILL BUILD IT BECAUSE THEY WILL
WORK FOR THEIR FAMILIES EVEN IF
IT MEANS.
BUILDING SOMETHING WITHOUT
PERMITS SO THE ISSUE IS NOT THE
NEIGHBORS.
COMPLAINING ABOUT AN ILLEGAL
UNIT OR THE HOMEOWNERS NOT
WANTING TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM
THE ISSUE IS THAT THE ZONING
RESTRICTIONS [inaudible]
WHICH CHANGE VERY SLOWLY ARE
CREATING AN OBSTACLE.
LINE FOLKS TO SAID WHY NOT WAIT
WHY ARE WE DOING THIS SO QUICKLY
YOU KNOW LET'S JUST WAIT TWO
MORE YEARS.
WELL THAT'S LIKE IF YOU'RE
STARVING SOMEONE SITS OUT
KNOCKIN TODAY WE'RE GOING
TO EAT TOMORROW.
YOU FAMILIES ARE DESPERATE THEY
HAVE CHILDREN AND PARENTS AND
GRANDPARENTS IT THEY NEED TO
CARE.
FOR AND THEY CAN'T AND THEY
CAN'T LIVE ANYWHERE NEAR THEM.
THERE THIS IS THE CHEAPEST AND
FASTEST WAY.
UP TO GET NEW HOUSING IT'S ALSO
EQUITABLE.
THE MOST OF THE ZONING
RESTRICTIONS AFFECT MUCH MORE
SMALL LOTS WHERE YOU HAVE LOW
AND MODERATE INCOME HOMEOWNERS
WHO ARE LOSING THEIR PROPERTIES
BECAUSE THEY CAN'T KEEP UP WITH
THE COST.
SO CONTRARY TO SOME OF THE
BELIEVES THIS DOES NOT SLOW THE
PERMITTING PROCESS IF A
COMMUNITY IS GOING.
TO ADOT NEW ZONING THEY KEEP
PERMITTING AS THEY GO UP UNTIL
THE NEW RULES COME INTO EFFECT.
THAT YOU HAVE A WAVE OF
HOMEOWNERS WHO ARE SITTING
WAITING.
COME IN AND BUILD THEIR A DO YOU
WHEN THE RULES CHANGE THIRTY
SECOND SO --
I'D ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT
THIS BILL AND POINT OUT THAT --
APA DESPITE ITS ARE LOBBYING OP.
SHOOT IT SAID NATIONAL STANDARDS
PRINCIPLES FOR HOUSING AND THEY
CLEARLY SUPPORT.
OF AB REDUCING THE LOCAL
RESTRICTIONS IN ZONING SO THAT
WE CAN GET MORE HOUSING BUILT.
THANK YOU YOU GIVE YOUR
TESTIMONY WERE NOW TO WELCOME
FOLKS WHO LIKELY TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL PLEASE
COMPORT THIS TIME.
PERSON LAST NAME ALONG WITH YOUR
POSITION.
LOUIS MONTA AND THE HAVE
CALIFORNIAN BEEN SUPPORT THANK
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
MICHAEL IN WITH THE NONPROFIT
HOUSING ASSOCIATION THE
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT YOU GOOD
AFTERNOON. THREE SEPARATE BIDS
ON BEHALF OF THE NATURAL
RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT OF IT
PLEASE ADVANCE FOR LOOKING FOR
SUPPORT.
TIFFANY VAN HAVE A BRIDGE
HOUSING SUPPORT THANK YOU SO
MUCH LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE
IN SUPPORT.
WE HAVE SQUISHY IF YOU WE WE
WILL WELCOME SQUISHY.
THANK YOU GOOD AFTERNOON
SENATORS --
AND YOU KNOW SOME HAVE THE
ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA WATER
AGENCIES WERE CURRENTLY NEUTRAL
ON THE BILL IN LARGE PART
BECAUSE OF THE WORK OF THIS
COMMITTEE.
AND THE AGREEMENT THAT WAS
REACHED ON THIS BILL AND SP.
EIGHT THREE ONE OF AYE I BELIEVE
ONE OF THE AMENDMENTS THAT WAS
ACCEPTED IS.
TO CLARIFY THE LANGUAGE --
THAT WAS A RESULT OF THAT
AGREEMENTS AB DRAFTING YOUR WE
IDENTIFIED SUBMITTED A LANGUAGE
TO THIS COMMITTEE AND THE AUTHOR
--
SO HOPEFUL THAT THAT WILL THAT
WILL BE TAKEN TO COMMITMENTS
THANK YOU ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED OR SQUISHY.
I'M SORRY I SUPPORTERS WHICH WE
WELCOME THOSE WHO OPPOSE ANYONE
ELSE THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR GOING
TO WELCOME THAT THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED.
WILL HAE ONE PRIMARY WITNESS
WHO WILL BE THREE MINUTES ARE
SECONDARY WITNESS WILL BE TWO
MINUTES WHO WOULD LIKE TO BE A
KICK* OFF.
ALRIGHT SEARS IDEA ME OUT OF THE
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
COUNTIES REGRETTABLY IN
OPPOSITION AND WE DO APPRECIATE
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS WE
THINK DOES GO A LONG WAY TOWARDS
ADDRESSING SOME OF OUR CONCERNS.
I'M BUT IT'S CLEAR THAT WE DO
HAVE A PHILOSOPHICAL DIFFERENCE
WITH THE AUTHORS OFFICE ON AT
LEAST A COUPLE ISSUES AND I OWN
A HIGHLIGHT THOSE --
FOR YOU THE FIRST ONE IS REALLY
THE PARCEL SIZE ISSUE SPECIALLY
IS RELATED TO UNINCORPORATED
AREAS AND WE'VE SEEN LOCAL
AGENCIES ESTABLISH THEIR PARCEL
SIZE LIMITATIONS FOR AREAS THAT
ARE ON SEPTIC AND WELL.
BASED ON STANDARDS ADOPTED BY
THE STATE WATER RESOURCES
CONTROL BOARD FOR ON SITE WATER
TREATMENT SYSTEMS WE THINK
THAT'S A REASONABLE POLICY AND
THAT THERE SHOULDN'T BE A
PREEMPTION IN STATE LAW FROM
DOING THAT IN THE ORDINANCE.
AND IT SOUNDS LIKE A LITTLE BIT
OF A TECHNICAL ISSUE BUT THE
REASON WE WANT TO DO THAT IS A
FOOL THE PHILOSOPHY BEHIND
LOCALS WHO ARE SETTING UP THESE
NEW MINISTERIAL APPROVAL PROCESS
USE.
IS THAT THEY WANT THE BEST
APPLICATIONS THAT ARE GOING TO
BE ABLE TO CHECK THE BOX AND GO
THROUGH TO QUICKLY DO THAT SO
THE ARGUMENT IS THAT BY REMOVING
THOSE LIMITATIONS FOR THE AREAS
THAT ARE NOT ON PUBLIC WATER AND
SEWER.
AND WE'RE JUST SETTING PEOPLE UP
FOR A MORE DRAWN OUT PROCESS
WHERE HE REALLY THE BENEFIT OF A
MINISTERIAL PROCESS GOES AWAY
AND IT'S GETTING MORE ON A
DISCRETIONARY CASE BY CASE
BASIS.
CAN YOU HAVE ENOUGH ROOM TO
ACCOMMODATE THE SEPTIC NEEDS
ETCETERA ETCETERA AND SO THAT IS
AN ISSUE AND WE THINK THAT THE
THE BILL SHOULD BE AMENDED TO
ALLOW CONSIDERATION WHEN THERE'S
PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY.
LIMITATION SUCH AS THAT AND THE
OTHER ONE IS THE BY RIGHT
EXPANSION WHICH I BELIEVE IS
SUBDIVISION IN THIS BILL IS SORT
OF ANY EXCEPTION THAT EIGHT THE
RULE.
I'M THE LIMITATIONS THAT WERE A
STANDALONE EIGHTY USE AND THE
BILL ALLOWS NOT ONLY.
SINGLE FAMILY ZONES BUT IT
BEHIND APARTMENT BUILDINGS --
THEIR LIMITATIONS THAT CAN BE
BUILT BASED ON HEALTH AND SAFETY
REASONS --
UNDER THIS BILL THOSE PROVISIONS
DON'T APPLY TO THESE THESE BY
RIGHT --
EIGHTY USE AND WE THINK THAT
THEY SHOULD SO FOR EXAMPLE --
SOME ORDINANCES HAVE SAID IN
HIGH FIRE HAZARD SEVERITY ZONES
YOU CAN'T DO A STANDALONE EIGHTY
YEAR OR IT'S GONNA BE
DISCRETIONARY AND SO WE THINK
THAT'S A REASONABLE POLICY --
AND AND SHOULD NOT BE PRECLUDED
BY THAT SUBDIVISION
LANGUAGE I'M ASIDE FROM THE
PARCEL SIZE ISSUE THE AUTHORS
OFFICE HAS INDICATED THAT
THEY'RE WILLING TO WORK WITH US
ON SOME OF THESE HEALTH AND
SAFETY CONCERNS.
IT'S WE HOPE OF THE BILL NEWS
FOR TODAY WE CAN CONTINUE TO
HAVE A CONVERSATION ABOUT THAT
TO MAKE SURE WERE LINING UP WITH
OTHER STATE POLICY GOALS.
TIME BUT FOR THOSE REASONS I SEE
SACK AND THE RURAL COUNTY
REPRESENTS THE CALIFORNIA AND
THE URBAN COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA
ARE ALL RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED.
YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU RE HERE
SIR WELCOME BACK IN HIS CHAIR
MEMBERS JASON RILEY CALIFORNIA
CITIES BUT WE OPPOSE
THIS-MEASURE OF CLOUDS NONE OF
THEIR
SUMMER.
BUILT OF THE SEASONS ALERTING
BUILT ON BUT IT WE ARE OPPOSED
TO OBSERVE ME THE REASONS AS HE
SIXTY TWO BUT I THINK ONE THING
THAT THAT I CALL IT DIDN'T
STATE.
IS THAT THIS IS THE THIRD YEAR
IN A ROW THAT WE'VE SEEN TO
FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE THE EIGHTY
LAWS AND I THINK OF THE LAWS
THAT ARE IN PLACE NOW ARE
ACTUALLY WORKING.
WE'VE SEEN A A BIG INCREASE IN
THE NUMBER PERMITS ISSUED
PARTICULARLY AND LA W'VE SEEN A
TWENTY FIVE TIMES INCREASE IN
THE NUMBER PERMITS.
IN SAN FRANCISCO CA TWELVE TIMES
[inaudible]
S. AS PART OF THE HOUSING I'M
CRISIS SOLUTION ARM BUT WE DO
NOT THINK WE NEED TO CHANGE THE
LAW FUNDAMENTALLY FOR THE THIRD
YEAR IN A ROW SINCE IT IS
ACTUALLY WORKING.
BUT ONE OF THE THING TO POINT
OUT TO IS THAT PART OF THAT
FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE IS THAT WE A
CURRENT LAW NOW REQUIRES THAT WE
TO ALLOW FOR NEEDY YOU ON ANY
LOT THAT IS RESIDENTIALLY ZONED.
THAT'S THE LAW WE HAVE TO DO
THAT ON THIS IS GOING TO EXPAND
IS SAID TO BE GETTING A LOT THAT
HAS A HOME ON IT AND THIS COULD
BE LOCATIONS OR WE DO NOT WANT
TO ENCOURAGE ADDITIONAL GROWTH.
OF EXISTING LAW NOW ALLOWS US
SOME FLEXIBILITY IN SAY NO WE
SHOULDN'T DO THOSE THERE THIS
WOULD KICK THE DOOR WIDE OPEN TO
ANY EIGHTY YOU ON ANY LOT THAT
ALREADY HAS A HOME ON IT.
REGARDLESS OF WHAT THOSE ISSUES
ARE WITH THAT INDIVIDUAL
PROPERTY THE OTHER THING TO
HIGHLY TO IS THAT THIS BILL WILL
ALLOW FOR A DETACHED EIGHTY YOU
AT AN ATTACHED ACCESSORY OR A
JUNIOR EIGHTY YOU.
GREATLY ADDING TO THE DENSITY ON
THAT PARCEL AND WERE STILL
UNABLE TO REQUIRE ANY SORT OF
PARKING REQUIREMENTS IF YOU'RE
WITH A HALF MILE TRANSIT OR YOU
HAVE A RIGHT SURE CAR NEARBY.
AND FOR THOSE REASONS WE REMAIN
OPPOSED WE DO APPRECIATE THE
AUTHOR WORKING WITH THIS HE HAS
TAKEN A NUMBER OF AMENDMENTS
ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS THERE A FEW
LINGERING ISSUES THAT WE HOPE WE
CAN TO ADDRESS THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'RE GRATEFUL
THAT WE WELCOME YOU MA'AM
EFFORTS LAST ORGANIZATION AND WE
ARE IN A POST. TO LEARN THAT
LINDSAY REPRESENT AMERICAN
PLANNING ASSOCIATION OPPOSITION
THANK YOU BEFORE. ONE CAN CURE
RUSSELL BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
SAN MARCOS IN OPPOSITION THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
ANYONE ELSE OPPOSED [inaudible]
LAST CALL.
BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE TO BE
TO SEE IF WE HAVE ANY.
OTHER QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS THAT
FOLKS WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE TO
ADDRESS.
OKAY THING NINE IS THERE SOME
THAT LIKE TO BE A NEW ADVANCE A
MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
NAMED IS IS A DO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WOULD
YOU LIKE TO BE TO CLOSE ON THE
HAVE FOR MISTER TING WE
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR SUPPORT I
CAN.
YOU SO MUCH AGAIN DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
AB MISSING JUST ROLL CALL PLEASE
WIRE I REQUIRE AYE NGUYEN FELL.
DEL I'VE HERNANDEZ FERNANDES
SIDE HERTZBERG.
LARA MORE LAW.
OR LOG FLUME.
THREE I THAT IT CURRENTLY DOES
HE THREE ONE IS A MEMBER --
MISTER CHIU MISS YOU ARE GONNA
HAVE WORDS NOW --
AND I'M.
AND IT WILL BE KEEPING A ROLL
OVER.
THERE IS I DO BELIEVE THAT --
SIMILAR GIPSON IN A SIMILAR
COOLEY HAVE WORKED OUT A DEAL
THAT MISTER GIBSON'S GONNA MOVE
BECAUSE HE HAS A WITNESS WHO IS
ABOUT TO GET ON A FLIGHT. FIVE
SO WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO GET
THIS MOVES UP THANK YOU SO MUCH
TO SOME OF A COOLEY WELCOME.
BY THE GOOD SENATOR TO GET TO
SOME MMBERFROM --
LOS ANGELES HERE WE'RE GONNA
START HIS FILE ITEM.
TWELVE BY AB.
TWENTY ONE SEVENTY NINE THIS
ENJOYS BIPARTISAN SUPPORT SIR
THAT WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR A
TRUNCATED --
PRISON TATIAN ON FILE ITEM.
TWELVE POINT. SEVENTY NINE TO
GET IN THE FLOOR IS YOURS THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS THAT YOU ALLOW ME TO
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL.
I'M TWENTY ONE SEVEN I WHICH
WOULD IMPROVE THE SEWER
INFRASTRUCTURE UP IN CALIFORNIA
DAYS AGO.
OKAY --
CALIFORNIA MANAGING SEWER
SYSTEMS CAN --
BE --
EXPRESSLY DIFFICULT FOR SMALL
SEWER SYSTEMS BECAUSE THEY OFTEN
HAVE FEWER RESOURCES FOR
MAINTENANCE AND TREATMENT AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK AND I BOTH
HATED THAT WATCH OUT WE HAVE A
MOTION BY YEAH CENTER BELL ON
FILE ITEM TWELVE MAYBE TWENTY
ONE SEVENTY NINE WE'RE GOING TO
ASK.
UP FOR OUR WITNESSES TO BE ABLE
TO OFFER A TRUNCATED VERSION OF
THEIR STATEMENT.
HA ON FILE ITEM TWELVE AB TWENTY
ONE SEVENTY NINE RESEARCH
PROJECT WALKS MA NAM BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA WATER SAYS HE ASIAN
--
WE REPRESENT THE UTILITIES UNDER
THE JURISDICTION OF THE
CALIFORNIA PC --
THIS BILL AS THE NEXT ONE COMING
UP CAME OUT OF A WORKING GROUP
THAT ASSEMBLY MEMBER GIPSON --
CONVENE LAST FALL [inaudible]
THIS. FOR THAT WORKING GROUP WAS
TO COME UP WITH IDEAS TO HELP
FACILITATE.
VOLUNTARY CONSOLIDATION AND HELP
THE STATE'S CONSOLIDATION POLICY
THIS IS ONE OF THOSE --
OF REMOVING THIS INCONSISTENCY
IN THE VOTER THRESHOLD ON THE
SMALL MUNICIPAL SEWER SIDE --
IS ONE OF THOSE IDEAS AND WILL
HELP THE A CONSOLIDATION PROCESS
THANK YOU SO MUCH IT BRINGS A
CONCERT AND BRINGS CONSISTED OF
THE PROCESS IS WELL THANK YOU.
BELOW.
ONE BUT WE AGAIN I WANNA REMIND
FOLKS WE HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT.
EYES WERE ASKING NOW FOR THOSE
WHO ARE IN SUPPORT I FIRST
LASSEN ORGANIZATION WELCOME
JENNIFER COMPUTERS ARE BEHALF OF
LIBERTY UTILITIES AND THE CITY
OF PARIS WHICH IS THE EXAMPLE.
OF WHERE THERE WAS A FAILED
ELECTION BECAUSE OF THE VOTER
INCONSISTENCY IN SUPPORT
THINKING BIGGEST PETER BRING%
GRATEFUL GOOD MORNING.
THE MORNING GOOD AFTERNOON
HUSSEIN I APOLOGIZE FINE FUND
JUSTINE MASSEY WITH COMMUNITY
WATER CENTER IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
WE LIKELY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE ELSE WHO IS IN SUPPORT IF
YOU COULD PLEASE COME FORWARD
LOOKING FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT.
LAST CALL ME NOW WOULD LIKE TO
SEE IF ANYONE IS SUPPOSED TO BE
A PLEASE ADVANCE THOSE OPPOSED
LAST CALL.
BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE WE
HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR BELL ON
FILE ITEM TWELVE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATOR WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE A
CLOSE.
RESPECTFUL ASSN AYE VOTE THANK
YOU SO MUCH MR CINNAMON.
AT THIS IS A DO PASS TO THE
FLOOR IS WINCHESTER ROLL CALL
PLEASE WIRE AYE LIAR AYE NGUYEN.
BELL.
BELL I'D HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
LARA MARLOWE. ONE GUY
FLINTRIDGE.
CURRENTLY JURIES A FOUR ZERO
VOTE IT'S A NUMBER OF WERE AND
KEEP THIS.
AS WE HAVE OTHER MEMBERS SHOW UP
YOU VERY MUCH AND THEY SAID THEY
WERE STILL MOVING ON TO AB
TWENTY THREE THIRTY NINE I'VE WE
ARE GRATEFUL I TO BE ABLE TO
WORK WITH THESE IN THE MEMBER ON
THIS --
IMPORTANT ISSUE I WANT TO SAY
THANK YOU THIS IN THE MEMBER FOR
BEING SO GRACIOUS IN THE
CONVERSATIONS THAT WE HAD.
OVER THE LAST SEVERAL DAYS
AMENDMENTS ARE CURRENTLY BEING
PASSED OUT BY TWO COMMITTEE
MEMBERS THAT WERE REFLECT THE
AMENDED FORM OF THE BILL --
THESE ARE I'LL SAY CONCEPTS NOT
SPECIFIC DETAILS BUT YOU WILL
SEE THAT WHAT WILL BE IN THE
BILL -- ON
ITEMS ONE THROUGH FIVE I'M GOING
TO TURN IT OVER TO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER AGAIN MISTER GIPSON THANK
YOU SO MUCH BUT FOR THE
COOPERATION THAT THE FLOOR IS
YOURS SIR ANYONE AND MAKE SURE
YOU CAN TAKE ME COMMITMENTS.
ABSOLUTELY AND SO THANK YOU
AGAIN MET MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS I THINK IF ALLOW ME TO
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY
THREE THIRTY NINE WHICH SEEKS TO
IMPROVE DRINKING WATER FOR
CALIFORNIANS THROUGH SMALL
SYSTEM CONSOLIDATION.
I GOT INVOLVED IN THIS ISSUE
BECAUSE OF A SMALL TROUBLED
WATER SYSTEM IN MY DISTRICT --
AS GOOD AS I EXPLORED THIS ISSUE
I REALIZE THAT THE CONSOLIDATION
OF SMALL SYSTEMS --
ARE VERY ARE VERY VERY DIFFICULT
TASK THAT'S BEFORE CALIFORNIANS
TODAY.
A MANY CALIFORNIA'S RECEIVE THE
DRINKING OF WATER FROM SMALL
WATER --
SYSTEMS THAT ARE DIFFICULT TO
MAINTAIN AND MANAGE --
AT THESE TROUBLED SYSTEMS ALL --
FUNDING SYSTEMS TO IMPROVE --
AND IT CAN BE VERY VERY
EXPENSIVE SMALL TROUBLE WATER
SYSTEMS CAN OVER CAN BE OVERCOME
--
BY CHALLENGES WITH CONSOLIDATING
ITSELF WITH A NEIGHBORING ARM
SYSTEM CONSOLIDATING WATER
SYSTEMS CAN SHARE COSTS AND
PROVIDE BETTER WATER SERVICES
THROUGH --
ECONOMY OF SCALES ALTHOUGH SOME
CITIES.
MAY WANT TO VOLUNTARILY
CONSOLIDATED THEIR THEIR WATER
SYSTEMS TO REMOVE BARRIERS THAT
MAY EXIST ONE BAY AREA IS THE
COSTS OF HOLDING A FULL BLOWN
ELECTION TO APPROVE THE SCALE.
OF A SALE OF THOSE STUDENTS
SELLABLE WATER ON PUBLIC SYSTEM
--
THAT -- HAS --
TROUBLE --
WAS MAINTAINING WITH ITS
MANAGEMENT AND THINGS OF THAT
NATURE --
WHILE THE COST TO HOLD AN
ELECTION --
OF MAYBE --
INSURMOUNTABLE --
FOR SOME SMALL AGENCIES OTHER IN
OTHER CITIES CAN AFFORD IT BUT
SMALLER AGENCIES BECAUSE OF THE
CONGRESS SCALE COULD BE VERY
VERY DIFFICULT THEREFORE THIS
BILL SEEKS TO MODIFY THE
ELECTION REQUIREMENTS.
AND ALLOW CITIES TO SELL THEIR
SMALL PUBLIC WATER SYSTEMS IF IT
IS NOT IN THE PUBLIC'S BEST
INTEREST TO OWN OPERATE THEM --
THIS ISSUE WITH SMALL MUNICIPAL
WATER SYSTEMS --
CAN BE PREVENTED BY AGAIN
CONSOLIDATION ON COMMUNITIES OF
LOS ANGELES --
WHERE SMALLER SYSTEMS WHERE
THAT?
I'M HAVE DIFFICULT A MAINTAINING
THOSE PARTICULAR --
ENTITIES FOR EXAMPLE THE CITY OF
COMPTON HAS NINE WATER --
PROVIDING ON SYSTEMS THAT
PROVIDES NINETY FIVE ON THOUSAND
PEOPLE WOULD SERVICES.
IN THIS PARTICULAR BILL AND I
WANNA THANK THE CHAIR OF THE ONE
TO GET WORKING VERY CLOSELY WITH
US -- HE
ALREADY ALLUDED TO THE NIGHT
THAT WE'VE SPENT ON THE PHONE
AND MEETING FACE TO FACE TO
REACH A CONCLUSION --
WE HAVE SOME AMENDMENTS HERE
THAT WILL BE ACCEPTING THESE
AMENDMENTS --
WANT TO SHOP MUCH APPLAUSE AND
AT LEAST GIVE OF THE MAYOR
MONTEBELLO THE OPPORTUNITY TO
SAY A FEW WORDS AGAIN AND MR
SOME AND YOU ARE INCREDIBLE
ADVOCATE FOR THOSE WHO YOU WORK
FOR AND WORK WITH I WANT TO SAY
THANK YOU.
AT FOR BEING SO GRACIOUS
THROUGHOUT THIS PROCESS ALSO AS
I THINK YOU TO YOUR AYE STAFF
TEAM AS WELL UP FOR ALLOF THEIR
WORK ON THIS BILL.
PLAYS WELL ON THIS IN THE WERE
VERY VERY GRATEFUL RETURN OVER
THE MAYOR --
IN IF YOU MIND INTRODUCE
YOURSELF AND I APOLOGIZE IF
WE'RE RUNNING LATE TODAY SIR
YEAH THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING
HERE -- MAKE
YOU PLEASURES MINE MY NAME IS
JACKIE GENUINE.
A SERVE ON THE CITY COUNCIL AND
CITY OF MONTEBELLO I THINK YOU.
ARE BUT CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE.
A WORLD ELECTED. TO FOR OUR
MUNICIPALITIES.
THAT'S THAT'S WHAT'S EXPECTED OF
EVERY RESIDENT.
AND CONSTITUENTS WE CURRENTLY
PAY ABOUT FOUR HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS A YEAR. TO HAVE OUR
WATER OPERATION MANAGED.
BY A UTILITY COMPANY WE WE DON'T
CURRENTLY MANAGE OURSELVES --
OUR SERVICE IS IN NEED OF ABOUT
TWENTY FIVE MILLION DOLLARS IN
INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT.
AND ON TOP OF THAT WE HAVE ABOUT
SIXTY FOUR MILLION DOLLARS AND
SEWERS AND NEED TO BE.
REAP REPAIRED WE WE DON'T HAVE
THE MONEY.
TO COVER THOSE THOSE
INVESTMENTS.
ASIDE WE TOOK THIS MATTER --
TO THE VOTE OF THE PEOPLE AND
JUNE OF TWENTY SIXTEEN AT A COST
OF ABOUT SIXTY FIVE THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
IT IT.
WAS A DEFEATED BY LESS THAN A
HUNDRED VOTES --
THE ISSUE IS OBVIOUSLY A BURDEN
ON THE CITY FINANCIALLY.
IT DOES PREVENT US FROM
PROVIDING COMPETITIVE --
WAGES.
FOR BOB PUBLIC SAFETY EMPLOYEES.
THE WATER OPERATION CURRENTLY
SERVES ABOUT --
TWELVE HUNDRED MY HOMES.
WHICH IS ABOUT 9% OF THE
COMMUNITY --
IT'S NOT SCALABLE WE CAN
INCREASE THE NUMBER OF END
USERS.
SO WE CAN.
MAKE THIS WORK AS A AS A CITY
OWNED OPERATION.
MOST RESIDENTS WHO VOTED DOWN OF
THE BALLOT MEASURE DIDN'T KNOW
THAT THE CITY'S GENERAL FUND IS
SUBSIDIZING --
THE WATER OPERATION.
AND WHEN I WENT OUT TO TALK TO
THE RESIDENTS ABOUT HOW
IMPORTANT WAS THE JUST DIDN'T
KNOW THE FACTS AND TO THIS DAY
SOME ARE SO FRUSTRATED.
ABOUT HOW IT WAS DEFEATED.
INCLUDING THE SIX HUNDRED AND
TEN EMPLOYEES OF THE CITY.
WHO WE HAVE BEEN UNABLE --
TO PROVIDE RAISES.
TO WE OUR VERY --
CHALLENGED BECAUSE WE HAVE A LOT
OF EMPLOYEES WHO ARE CONCEALING
FOR ANOTHER JOB JUST HAPPEN.
ABOUT ONE OF OUR TOP EMPLOYEES
LEAVE TO A CITY ORANGE COUNTY --
WHO WE?
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT THE
COMMITTEE DO APPROVE --
DISASSEMBLY BILL.
THANK YOU SO I CAN GET I WANT TO
THANK YOU FOR HANGING WITH US
ALL DAY TODAY I'M SORRY THAT
IT'S BEEN SO LONG.
AND I DO APOLOGIZE AND WE'RE
VERY GRATEFUL FOR HERE YOUR TEST
WHICH I THINK IS A MUCH.
PLEASE OBJECT SKIPPING JACK
WALKS AGAIN NUMBER HAVE THE
CALIFORNIA WATER CESSATION THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE FOR A LIVING IS
PRESENT THIS BILL TO YOU TODAY
--
THAT COUNCIL MEMBER HAVE GINNI
IN.
THE HANDS WHAT FOR BUTCHERING
YOUR I HIM BASICALLY ASSERTED
ALL HERE THIS ISN'T A ANOTHER
IMPORTANT --
BILL IN THE CONSOLIDATION ARENA
WILL BE IMPORTANT --
I'M ARROW IN THE STATE'S
CONSOLIDATION --
SITS IN AND IT'S A NICE ADDITION
--
TO SP EIGHTY EIGHT ALTHOUGH ONCE
AGAIN THIS BILL IS A VOLUNTARY.
CONSOLIDATION IS NOT MANDATORY
CONSOLIDATION THAT'S AN
IMPORTANT DISTINCTION --
DENIES.
I CAN GIVE YOU LOTS OF OTHER BUT
I BELIEVE IN YOU YOUR WHAT YOU
WILL UNDERSTAND THIS BILL SO
I'LL GO AHEAD AND WRAP IT UP WE
JUST ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND AGAIN I
pAPOLOGIZE BUT THE DELAY TODAY
HERE IN THE BILL'S WE'RE
GRATEFUL IN THE COOPER BEING IN
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
NOT IN A WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL PIC
PLEASE ADVANCE GIVES FIRST
LASSEN ORGANIZATION.
GET ROMAN OURS ON BEHALF OF
SINGULAR VALLEY WATER COMPANY IN
SUPPORT ROTH THANK YOU SO MUCH
SIR.
THAT PRETTY THERE'S ANYONE ELSE
IN SUPPORT OF IT PLEASE
COMPORTED THIS TIME.
SUPPORT OF THE AMENDED BILL.
NOW LIKELY TO SEE IF WE HAVE
ANYONE WHO IS OPPOSED TO PLEASE
ADVANCED THIS TIME WITH LOOKING
FOR THOSE PROPOSED.
LAST CALL TO BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE TO BEARD SECRETLY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS WE WOULD
ALSO WELCOME [inaudible]
A ALRIGHT THANK YOU SO MUCH WE
DO HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR
GET THIS I THIRTY SECONDS
PLEASE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE DO HAVE A
MOTION BY SENATE IS IS IS THAT
THIS IS ENJOYS A DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR --
MR SOME NUMBER THANK YOU AGAIN.
BUT PLEASE IF YOU WANNA CLOSE
BECKY VERY MUCH AGAINST
INSURANCE COMMITTEE I WANT TO
UNDERSCORE THAT OF THIS IS THAT
MY JOINT AUTHORED WHICH IS
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
JAMES GALLAGHER COULD NOT BE
HERE REPS AND YUBA CITY IS ALSO
VERY ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THIS
BILL AND START WAS TRYING TO
RISE BECAUSE OF THE TIME TRYING
TO GET.
OUR MAYOR BACK TO HIS CITY BEGIN
JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN I
VOTE X. MUCH AS HUMANLY US ONCE
I THINK IT MISTER AYE GALLAGHER
AS WELL FOR ALL THIS WORK ON
THIS ISSUE.
IS FRANCESA ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE REQUIRED.
Y. I WIN BELLE.
BELLE.
LARA.
MORE LOCKED.
MORE LIKE AYE THOSE.
ESTIMATES THAT ENJOYS A FOUR
ZERO VOTE VERY VERY GRATEFUL
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE HAVE THEIR CHAIRMAN OF THE
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE HERE HE'S
BRINGING FORWARD FILE ITEM
ELEVEN FILE ITEM ELEVEN IN
JULIE'S.
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT WE HAVE A
BIPARTISAN GROUP HUG HEARING
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE IS AB
TWENTY ONE SIXTY FOUR WE'RE
GOING TO ASK MISTER CHAIRMAN.
GUIDE -- TO
PLEASE PROVIDE A TRUNCATED
VERSION OF HIS STATEMENT OF
COURSE COURSES ELLIS HERE COREY
AYE IS --
GOING ON VACATION HERE VERY
SHORTLY IT WAS IS HELLA WITHOUT
THE KID SO HE'S VERY EXCITED AS
WELL HAVE YOU THOUGHT ABOUT THAT
CORY.
HE'S HE'S FIRED UP OKAY.
CORY'S ALSO ASSERTED THAT HE
EVER TOLD ME THAT SO --
BURGER TURNED OVER TO MR
ASSEMBLY MEMBER VICOR IS ALSO
PUSHING SORT.
WE'RE JOURNALISM A VACATION AT
THIS MOMENT ARE A VERY GO COREY
LEASES UNIFICATION RIGHT NOW.
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS AB
TWENTY ONE SIXTY FOUR RELATES TO
GOVERNMENT ORDINANCES ON ILLEGAL
CANNABIS CULTIVATION.
THE BILL IS DESIGNED TO PUT A
NEW TOOL KIT A PERMISSIVE TOOL
IN THE FOOL COULD LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS.
A ILLEGAL ARE CANNABIS GROW
THOSE ARE SORT OF PAPA
BUSINESSES HE TOOK OVER HOUSE
THEY PUT EVERYTHING THEY NEED
FOR THE GROW IF YOU SHOW UP IN
SIGHT THEM AND LEAVE.
IT WILL EXTENSIVE PEER WITHIN
HOURS STILL PULL UP A TRUCK AND
THEN GET HAULED AWAY THIS WILL
ALLOW.
MUNICIPALITIES LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
TO ADOPT AN ORDINANCE TO ALLOW
THEM.
TO IDENTIFY AND SITE IMMEDIATELY
IMPOSE A FINE SO THAT POP UP
THING DOESN'T GET.
ALLOW DISCORD TO OUR QUESTION I
VOTE BIGGEST WHICH DELIVER IN A
DISS A SAID THIS WAS A MONTH
EARLIER TODAY YOU HAVE OF BEING.
ONE OF THE FANTASTIC TO THE
ASSEMBLY ON ALL ISSUES OF
CANNABIS WHETHER T'S THE ISSUE
OF MEDICAL RECREATION NINETIES
WHEN TAKE MOMENTS I THINK YOU.
HAVE FOR ALL OF YOUR WORK SIR
AND YOUR CONTINUED EFFORTS AS
WELL RETURN OVER COURSES DELUDE
CALIFORNIA MAKE ME TURN GREEN
BUT THAT WOULD PUT ME IN YOUR
TRY HAY SEE THERE YOU GO LIKE
THIS.
SIZZLE MISTER SHARON MEMBERS
COREY SAYS ALL ON BEHALF OF
SHARE YOUR WORK ON THE BILL
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR --
HEATING THE CHAIRS ADMONITION
LOCAL CONTROL TOOL IN THE
TOOLBOX FOR THE KIDS US FOREVER
AND EVER GOT THINK IT'S THANK
YOU SO MUCH SADNESS ZILLA IT'S A
IT'S FOR THE KIDS ABSOLUTELY.
WE'RE NOT GONNA ASK FOR THOSE
WHO ARE IN SUPPORT OF THINK WE
CB WHAT SUPPORT.
HOW ABOUT THOSE WHO MAY BE
OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME FORWARD?
GOOD LUCK WITH YOUR COMMON.
FOR YOU KNOW I JUST GIVE IT YOUR
FIRST AND LAST IS A YOU Y. IT
BOTTLED UP REX W. I'M
CALIFORNIA'S PROP DISSOCIATION
WE WERE OPPOSE BUT THANKS TO THE
AMENDMENTS ARE WORKING WITH THE
OTHER WE'RE GONNA CHANGE A
NEUTRAL POSITION LOOK AT I DON'T
THINK MISS RENTS.
REGRETFUL.
IT WOULD ALSO LIKE YOU TO
TESTIFY WERE UNDER OPPOSITION TO
SIGN ANYONE ELSE WHO'S OPPOSED
TO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
IS GOING TO BE OUR LAST CALL
RIPPING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE.
I IS THERE ANYONE THAT WOULD AND
INTENSE IN MOTION OR HAVE
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
A WE HAVE A MOTION BY SEYMOUR
IRAQ TO DO ONE SCENE.
WELL I VOTE.
NO IT'S ALL GOOD.
PARTS OF THIS ENJOYS A DO PASS
OF THE FLOOR I'VE MISSED
QUESTION I VOTE THEY THINK YOU
IN.
WORDS I THINK IT WAS COOLEY HE'S
BEEN HERE FOR WELL OVER AN HOUR
AND I APOLOGIZE SIR THANK YOU SO
MUCH FOR YOUR PATIENCE.
ON THE SAME CHESTER RECOVER
PLEASE WIRED I WHY I WIN BELL.
BELLE AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
LARA.
MORE LOT.
MORE LIKE GUY THREE CD BAKER IN
THE JOYS OF THREE ZERO MISTER
CINNAMON GONNA KEEP THAT ARE ON
OFFER.
I AYE HOLDEN TO WE GET A FULL
HOUSE MAKES TOO MUCH.
MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING ON TO
SOME MEMBER GLORIA THIS IS AB.
TWENTY THREE SEVENTY TWO THIS
HAS BEEN A BIG BILL ISN'T
WORKING ON I THIS IS FILE ITEM
FIFTEEN IN LOSS OF THE SECOND
BILLS WELL.
SOME NEVER TO FORCE YOURSELF
TAKING WAS CHAIRMAN NAY PRESSED
FOR TIME SAU DO THIS VERY
QUICKLY DUH AB TWENTY THREE
SEVENTY TWO THOSE CALIFORNIA'S
SUSTAINABLE AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING ACT.
BASICALLY WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS
INCENTIVIZE THE THE DEVELOPMENT
OF HOUSING IT'S AFFORDABLE --
TO WORKING CALIFORNIANS THIS
BILL HAS --
ENJOYED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AYE
IN THE ASSEMBLY AND IN THE
SENATE IRISH I'M HERE TO JOIN
TODAY LOVE BY MORE TOP.
REPRESENTING THAT THE BILL
SPONSORED CITY STATE DIEGO --
THAT AS I MENTIONED YOU DON'T
UNANIMOUS.
SOME EVER WE DO HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON THIS WE WELCOME THIS
TOPIC AS FOR TRUNCATED VERSION
YOUR STATEMENT WELCOME.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS WHERE TOP ON BEHALF OF
AMERICA HAVING FAULKNER AND THE
ENTIRE CITY OF SAN DIEGO CITY
COUNCIL.
NOW WE ARE PROUD TO BE THE
SPONSORS OF THE MEASURE JUST
WANT TO REITERATE THAT THIS IS
AN OPT IN THIS DOES PROVIDE AN
OPTION FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES TO
USE WE THINK IT CAN BE QUITE
VALUABLE.
IN --
IMPROVING THE HOUSING SITUATION
--
IN SAN DIEGO AND THEN UP AND
ANOTHER COMMUNITY SO WE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE IF
YOU SO MUCH GRATEFUL THAT BOTH
YOUR HERE UBER AND WELCOME THOSE
IN SUPPORT.
YOU CHAIR MEMBERS RAN OUT THERE
AND READING ASSOCIATES
REPRESENTING THE SAN DIEGO
COUNTY APARTMENT ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU TO SEE THANK
YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON AFTER MISTER
MEMBERS BRIAN WHITE HERE WE HAVE
TO CALVET HOUSING ALLIANCE ALSO
SUPPORT THANKS FOR BEING HERE.
WELCOME BACK SECURE MEMBERS
IRAQ'S W. I'M OF HAVE CALIFORNIA
BITS PROPERTIES OF STATION ALSO
IN SUPPORT EGGS SUCH.
WELCOME FIFTY FAN OF BRIDGE
HOUSING IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
LIKELY TO DO LAST CALL LAST CALL
FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT ON TWENTY
THREE SEVENTY TWO WE NOW LIKELY
SUITORS ANYWHERE IN OPPOSITION
IF YOU CAN PLEASE COME FORTH
THIS TIME WE LOOK AT PROPOSITION
[inaudible]
LAST CALL.
BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE TO
BASICALLY ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS Y. ALSO WELCOME A
MOTION AS WELL.
WITH A MOTION BY THE GOOD
SENATOR FROM SAN JOSE CENTER
BALLOTS HAS A DO PASSED THE
FLOOR RECOMMENDATION.
INITIAL COMMENTS FROM THE
COMMITTEE SEEN NINE RESEARCH
SERMON WHICH THAT CLOSE PART OF
THE HOUSE MORE PEOPLE OF THE
SHIPMENT ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU SO MUCH SERVICE LINE JUST A
RECALL VOTE PLEASE REQUIRE AYE
FLY AYE NGUYEN.
BELL.
DEL AYE HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG LARA
MORLOCK.
THERE ARE GUYS WHO CAME THREE
ZERO LOOKING AT BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT MORLOCKS ROLLING.
BUT THAT'S ON FILE ITEM FIFTEEN
WERE TO KEEP THE ROLE OPEN ON
THAT.
NEIGHBORS ARE NOW MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM TWENTY SEVEN AB THIRTY
ONE THREE IN THE COMMITTEE
AMENDS ALSO ATTACK MOMENT SAY I
THINK IT IS IN THE MEMBER FROM
--
SAN DIEGO FOR ALL HIS WORK ON
THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE I KNOW THIS
IS BEEN --
AYE SIXTY ONE AT TIMES BUT IN A
VERY GRATEFUL SIR --
YOU HAVE BEEN A GENTLEMAN TO BE
TO WORK WITH THE FLOOR IS YOURS
SIR.
BUT THE FEELINGS MITCHELL AS
CHAIRMAN THANK YOU SO MUCH AND
YES I WOULD LIKE TO BE IN BY
ACCEPTING THE SUGGESTED
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS.
WITH APPRECIATION TO YOU SIR AND
YOUR STAFF WHO HAVE BEEN
COMMITTED I KNOW GREAT DEAL TIME
TO MAKING SURE THAT WE GET THIS
BILL -- IN
GOOD SHAPE.
MEMBERS IS VERY QUICKLY GET
RECOGNIZE THE TIME THAT YOU'RE
UP AGAINST ESSENTIALLY WHAT THIS
BILL SEEKS TO DO IS TO RE
IMPLEMENT --
AN EXECUTIVE ORDER THAT WAS
RECENTLY RESCINDED BY THE
CURRENT ADMINISTRATION THAT WAS
PUT IN PLACE BY PRESIDENT OBAMA.
IT WAS IT ATTEMPTS TO TRY AND
REGULATE THE THE ACQUISITION AND
USE OF MILITARY GRADE WEAPONS --
EQUIPMENT --
BY LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT --
WE GET TRY TO BE SHORT MISTER
CHAIRAN I BY REQUIRING A PUBLIC
FORUM -- FOR
COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO PARTICIPATE
IN THE DISCUSSION OF WHAT THIS
ADEQUATE MILBY AT ACQUIRED AND
THEN USED IN COMMUNITIES THIS
BILL WILL IN MY JUDGMENT IMPROVE
THE RELATIONSHIP THE COMMUNITY.
HOUSE WITH THEIR LOCAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT --
AND WITH ME THIS MORE AFTERNOON
NOW -- IS
THAT EVEN THAT BIT RAN FROM THE
ACLU I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SO MUCH IN
EVERYONE OF THE WORDS INTO THE
MOUTH OF THE SIMILAR TO THIS --
WITH THESE AMENDMENTS
ESSENTIALLY BRINGS IN LYING
ABOUT WHAT THIS PLEA TO STATE
POLICY WOULD BE WHAT WOULD WE
HAD AT WITH FEDERAL POLICY PRIOR
EIGHT TO IT BEING RESCINDED --
SO IT IT BRINGS CONSISTENCY TO
IT DO APPRECIATE AT WORKING
AGAIN WITH THE CHAIRMAN FROM A
SAN DIEGO MAN WE WELCOME YOU
COMMITTEE YOU HAVE. THREE
MINUTES AS OUR PRIMARY WITNESS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS A THAT THE TRYING HERE
ON BEHALF OF THE ACLU OF
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT OF THIS
BILL.
MORE PROUD TO CO SPONSOR AB
THIRTY ONE THIRTY ONE BECAUSE WE
BELIEVE IT BRINGS NECESSARY
LOCAL CONTROL ACCOUNTABILITY TO
THE PROCESS OF ACQUIRING AT
TIMES DANGEROUS COSTLY AND
POTENTIALLY DIVISIVE MILITARY
EQUIPMENT.
WE THINK IT FILLS AN IMPORTANT
GAP LEFT --
AND LEFT WHEN THIS CURRENT
ADMINISTRATION RESCINDED
PRESIDENT OBAMA'S EXECUTIVE
ORDER WE THINK OF THE ORDER
SAFEGUARDS WERE CONSISTENT WITH
BEST PRACTICES FOR PUBLIC SAFETY
BUILDING TRUST AND
ACCOUNTABILITY BETWEEN THE
COMMUNITY AND LAW ENFORCEMENT
OFFICIALS.
AND THEY ALSO WHO THEY ALSO KEPT
A WEAPONS OF WAR DESIGN FOR THE
BATTLEFIELD OFF OF CALIFORNIA'S.
PLACE THE QUESTION OF WHETHER TO
ACQUIRE THIS MILITARY EQUIPMENT
IN THE HANDS OF THE ELECTED
OFFICIALS WHO ARE CLOSEST TO THE
AFFECTED COMMUNITIES --
AND CRUCIALLY IT DOESN'T
PREEMPTIVELY BAND TRANSFER OF
ANY EQUIPMENT AS THE OR THE
ORDER HAD DONE BUT RATHER PLACE
OF THE QUESTION OF WHETHER THAT
EQUIPMENT IS TRULY NEEDED IN THE
HANDS OF OUR COMMUNITY.
COOKIES REASONS THAT THE ACLU
THINKS THE AUTHORS FOR THEIR
LEADERSHIP AND STANDS FIRMLY
BEHIND THIS BILL AND URGES ARE
AYE VOTE THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'RE
GRATEFUL HERE TODAY THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY AS WELL.
WE'D LIKE TO WELOME ANYONE
WHO'S IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
THE PLEASE ADVANCE THIS TIME.
LOOKING FOR FIRST LASSEN
ORGANIZATION WELCOME SIR.
JIM WINDER GA BEHALF OF THE
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
CALIFORNIA CO SPONSOR AND URGENT
I'VE.
THINKING JIM THANKS FOR BEING
HERE.
THAT WAY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL IF YOU COULD PLEASE COME
FORWARD THIS TIME WITH A GOOD
FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT.
LAST CALL NOW WOULD LIKE TO BE
CBO RECEIVE ANYONE WHO MAY BE
OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
BRIAN HAVE OUR OPPOSITION TO
TAKE AT THE FIRST TWO SEATS.
WE'RE GONNA ASK A ONE INDIVIDUAL
TO BE OUR PRIMARY THAT IN
OPPOSITION OUR PRIMARY
OPPOSITION WAS THREE MINUTES ARE
SECONDARY --
WITNESS WILL HAVE TWO MINUTES
WHO'D LIKE TO BE TO KICK US OFF.
MR LEVEL IS HERE A HE IS A
LEGEND HERE IN THIS BUILDING WE
WELCOME YOU SIR I AM VERY
GRATEFUL I'M SERIOUS BREAK A
BROAD AFTERNOON FOR FIRST OF ALL
I WOULD BE REMISS ON A JOHN
LEVEL ON BEHALF OF THE
ASSOCIATION FOR LA DEPUTY
SHERIFFS.
THE LOS ANGELES POLICE
PROTECTIVE LEAGUE AND THE LA
COUNTY PROFESSIONAL PEACE
OFFICERS ASSOCIATION.
VERY QUICKLY I'D BE REMISS IF I
DIDN'T MAKE SPECIAL NOTE OF THE
TRULY HIGH QUALITY OF THE
ANALYSIS THAT WAS DEVELOPED ON
THIS BILL.
JESS ANDREW WAS A FAMILY FRIEND
OF OURS AND I CAN REMEMBER AS A
KID.
JESS SUNROOF ARTICULATING HIS
VISION OF THE ENHANCE
PROFESSIONALISM OF A FULL TIME
LEGISLATURE --
I'M SURE HE HAD THIS QUALITY OF
ANALYSIS IN MIND WHEN HE
ARTICULATED THAT VISION HUMMING
LA DOT IN TIME AS ALWAYS NOW
USES TO TERRIFIC.
HERE VERY BY THE WAY MR LEVEL
CALLS HIMSELF GRADUATIONS
EXCITING.
OF THEM [inaudible]
HE THE IMPACT OF THIS BILL.
WILL BE TO SIMPLY WIPE OUT TEN
THIRTY THREE AVAILABILITY FOR
ANY CALIFORNIA LAW ENFORCEMENT
--
ORGANIZATION AND HERE'S WHY.
UNDER THE FEDERAL --
GUIDELINES --
THERE'S A PROCESS WE END UP
PROPERTY BECOMES AVAILABLE.
AND AND IT IS FINALLY AVAILABLE
TO LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT.
THERE IS A SIX TO TWELVE DAILY
WINDOW AND A FOR CLAIM IS NOT
MADE DURING THAT PERIOD YOU
CAN'T MAKE IT.
OVER OUT MOREOVER EVERY OTHER
LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY IN THE
COUNTRY IT'S GONNA GET THEIR
FIRST.
BUT CHALLENGE WITH THIS BILL IS
THAT IT CREATES A PROCESS THAT
IS VERY CUMBERSOME I USE TO BE
CHIEF COUNSEL TO THE LA CITY
ATTORNEY YEARS AGO.
THE BILL FAST SOLELY TALKS ABOUT
--
IT TAKES AN ORDINANCE I CAN
ASSURE YOU THAT ORDINANCES DID
NOT GET ADOPTED AT THE LOCAL
LEVEL IN THE SIX TWELVE DAY
WINDOW FROM THE TIME PROPERTY
BECOMES AVAILABLE.
SO THE IMPACT OF THIS BILL IF
YOU WANNA WIPE OUT TEN THIRTY
THREE IF YOU THINK IT'S BAD
PUBLIC POLICY.
THEN BY ALL MEANS VOTE FOR THIS
BILL BUT THAT IS THE IMMUTABLE
IMPACT OF THIS BILL AS IT IS
CURRENTLY.
AT IS EH AS IT IS CURRENTLY
CRAFTED IF WE WANT TO DEAL WITH
THE WRONGFUL RECISION IN OUR
PART.
OF PRESIDENT OBAMA'S EXECUTIVE
ORDER WHAT WE DO IS WE SIMPLY
TAKE THE TEXT OF THAT EXECUTIVE
ORDER HOW WE WORK GET.
SO THAT IT'S CONSISTENT WITH THE
WITH THE POLICY MAKING PROCESS
IN CALIFORNIA BUT THIS BILL
RIGHT NOW --
MAY LET THERE BE NO MISTAKE IT'S
ASKING YOU TO CROSS A PUBLIC
POLICY RUBICON AND WIPE OUT --
TEN THIRTY THREE FOR FOR
CALIFORNIA WE ARE STRONGLY
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL --
WE THINK IT WILL.
REALLY HAMPER THE ABILITY OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT PARTICULARLY LESS
AFFLUENT AGENCIES. TO ACQUIRE
EQUIPMENT THAT IS NEEDED FOR
THEM TO PROTECT PUBLIC SAFETY IN
THEIR COMMUNITIES THANK YOU SO
MUCH [inaudible]
MR LEVEL.
GOOD AFTERNOON MA'AM IT'S GOOD
TO SEE YOU THAT AFTERNOON MISTER
CHAIRMAN RESOLUTION MUCH LATER
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION'S
OUT%
REAL QUICKLY.
ON WE BELIEVE THAT THE SHERIFF'S
ARE CERTAINLY CAPABLE OF
RESPONDING TO THE CONCERNS OF
THEIR CONSTITUENTS WHEN IT COMES
TO PURCHASING AND DEPLOYMENT OF
APPROPRIATE EQUIPMENT.
ON A STAT SHOULD ARISE IN THE
COMMUNITY AND FOR THESE REASONS
WE ASK YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS
BILL THANK YOU. FOR AS OPPOSED
TO BE A STAY APPEAR TO SWIM BY
TIME IF THEY LIKE AYE BUT WE
WOULD ALSO WELCOME THOSE WHO
WELL.
ANYONE ELSE WHO MAY BE OPPOSED
TO BE ABLE TO ADVANCE.
YOUR FIRST AND LAST NAME YOUR
ORGANIZATION.
ALRIGHT WE'RE GONNA BRING BACK
TO COMMITTEE I I ONE THING I
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE SO DID THE
AMENDMENTS THAT ARE ARE BEING
ADVANCED TODAY.
OUR IS FAR AS THE AUTHORIZATION
IT'S GOING TO BE ON TYPES OF
ITEMS NOT INDIVIDUAL FEW WELL SO
WE ARE BRINGING IN LINE.
BOND WITH THE FEDERAL POLICY I A
AND IT SHOULD ADDRESS THE
CONCERNS AT LEAST WHAT OUR
BELIEF IS ON THE ON ACQUISITION.
BUT IN THE SCENE THE MINSITER
BEING BROUGHT FOR MR SOME WOMEN
I DON'T KNOW IF THEY'RE ANY
ITEMS YOU WANT TO BE ABLE TO
BRING FOR NO MISTER LEVEL WOULD
LIKE BETTER SPEAK.
THE MEASURE SOMEONE I DON'T KNOW
IF THERE'S ANY AND HE WOULD LIKE
TO BE HEARD AT DIDN'T REFLECTING
MISTER LEVELS COMMENTS ABOUT THE
QUALITY OF THE HOUSES ARE YOU
EXACTLY RIGHT THE AMENDMENT
WOULD IDEALLY WHAT CATEGORY
LOCAL APPROVALS.
I'M I THINK ADDRESSES THE NEED
FOR SPEED --
BUT ALSO KNOWLEDGE THE FACT THAT
THE SPEED OF ACQUISITION OF THIS
EQUIPMENT HAS OFTEN LED TO THEM
--
EXCESSIVE SPENDING OF FOR WHAT
IS ALLEGEDLY FREE EQUIPMENT --
AND THE KINDS OF CONCERNS OF THE
COMMUNITY OF OUR RAISING SO I'M
I BELIEVE THE CATEGORICAL
APPROVALS WILL ALLOW CONDUCT LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO ACQUIRE THEM THEM
EQUIPMENT THAT THEY WANT.
IT TIMELY WAY BOB I PROCEED
AGAIN YOUR HELP AND THE HELP AND
ADVICE IN THE BILL TO MAKE IT SO
I THINK IT'S A MUCH SIMILAR
GOING AFTER CLOSING COMMENTS IN
JUST A BIT AT MISTER LEVEL SIXTY
SECONDS ARE UP.
I WOULD JUST TAKE ISSUE THE FACT
THAT IT'S AN ORDINANCE RATHER
THAN A SIMPLE RESOLUTION SAYS IT
ALL.
ORDINANCES TAKE MORE THAN SIX
DAYS TO PUT TOGETHER I MEAN I
REMEMBER THIS FROM MY CITY
COUNCIL DAY ORANGE CITY ATTORNEY
DAYS IN LOS ANGELES.
BUT YOU YOU HAVE THE RIGHT IT IT
IT DOES TAKE LONGER AS OURS IF
IT -- AND
ORDINANCE THAT THERE IS A SET
PERIOD OF TIME TO BE ABLE TO
ADOPT AN ORDINANCE IN PUBLIC
HEARING --
BUT IT LATELY SAYS IT THE ISSUES
OF ACQUISITION IT SHOULD ADDRESS
THOSE CONCERNS BUT YOU ARE RIGHT
IN REGARDS TO THE PROCESS --
ABOUT THE THE RESOLUTION VERSES
THE ORDINANCE WOULDN'T DISAGREE
THERE BUT ON THE ACQUISITION
SIDE OB.
SHOULD ADDRESS THE CONCERNS IN
REGARDS TO TEN THIRTY THREE
AGAIN STAYS. TWELVE DAY TIME
PERIOD AND THAT CLOCK STARTS AS
SOON AS THAT PROPERTIES
AVAILABLE --
AND OUR PROCESS WILL TAKE SO
LONG THAT.
WILMINGTON DELAWARE WILL GET THE
PROPERTY FIRST WHEN YOU'RE
YOU'RE WIPING OUT.
THIS AVAILABILITY IN CALIFORNIA
WITH THIS BILL RIGHT NOW.
IN A DISCIPLINE OF THE
INDIVIDUAL WHO WROTE DENOUNCES I
THINK THERE IS GONNA BE THAT
STANDING AUTHORIZATION FOR THE
YEAR BUT I'M HAPPY TO TALK MORE
ABOUT THAT IS WELL THAT AGAINST
LEVEL THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BUT WE'RE GOING TO TURN IT OVER
TO THE SAME NUMBER FOR ANY
CLOSING COMMENTS HI I JUST
WANTED SHOULD RECORD IT
ABUNDANTLY CLEAR MISTER CHAIRMAN
I AS A FORMER CITY COUNCIL
MEMBER COUNCIL PRESIDENT IN
MAYOR -- WE
ADOPT IN --
ORDNANCE TO PAY OUR POLICE
OFFICERS TO BY THE BULLETS DID
PUT GAS IN THE SQUAD CARS AND
THEY HAVE NEVER GONE WITHOUT
LOVE AS YOU NOTE I THIS IS A BIT
DONE ON A PER A PROSPECTIVE
BASIS.
UMBEL IF THAT'S THE CONCERN --
I'M HAPPY TO DISCUSS THIS WITH
THE OPPONENTS FURTHER --
BUT I BELIEVE THE NEED FOR SPEED
ON IS MORE THAN ACCOMMODATED BY
THE LIMITS OFFER TODAY AGAIN I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU EITHER.
THINK YOU SO MUCH FOR ME TO SEE
IF WE HAVE AN INDIVIDUAL LIKE
CAN ALSO WAIT ON THAT AS WELL
THE SENATE ABOUT OFFERED LETTER
TO I'M SORRY YOU'RE RIGHT I DO
APOLOGIZE THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE DO OF THE MOTION BY SENATOR
BELL -- IN
THIS IS A DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS THANK YOU TO
THOSE WHO WERE IN OPPOSITION AND
ALSO THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT
SENATOR THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK
ON THIS AS WELL.
MISS LANE JUST RICARDO PUT WIRE
HIGH WIRE AYE NGUYEN BELL
HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG LARA
MORLOCK.
WARLOCK NO.
ONE CURRENTLY IS A ONE ONE WE
GET HORSERACE GOING RIGHT NOW
WAIT I TO BE ABLE TO ADD FOLKS
ON AS WE MOVE FORWARD.
IF YOU JUST GIVE US THIRTY
SECONDS JUST A HEADS UP AND I
APOLOGIZE.
WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO VACATE
THIS ROOM.
I AT APPROXIMATELY.
ONE FIFTEEN BY A BUT I MISS
IRWIN IS --
PREACHER A THEIR AGO SO IT
EGGMAN IS GETTING GOING SO I
JUST GIVE US THIRTY SECONDS
PLEASE [inaudible]
JUST
[inaudible]
WHERE OPERATE
[inaudible]
JUST VERBALLY. OH NO AND I
BETTER GET YOUR VOTE TO FIGHT.
PLEASE IN JENIN WE HAVE ASSEMBLY
WOMAN IRWIN HERE THIS IS. THREE
SEVEN WOMAN YOU HAVE BY.
WERE GOING TO ASK --
HOPE.
WE HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR --
BY SENATOR FROM ORANGE COUNTY
WE'RE GOING TO ASK FOR A VERY
BRIEF.
I'M SURE IT'S CAN BE ELOQUENT
SOMEONE --
AB TWENTY FIVE A THREE WOULD
ALLOW FTP TO ADMINISTRATIVELY
DISSOLVED DOMESTIC CORPORATIONS
AN LLC SET UP TO THIS HE'S DOING
BUSINESS FOR AT LEAST FIVE
YEARS.
AYE TO SIMILAR BILL THAT WAS FOR
NON PROFITS TWENTY ONE THOUSAND
NON PROFITS HAVE BEEN
SUCCESSFULLY REMOVED FROM THE
STATE'S BUCK CENSUS
IMPLEMENTATION.
HAD NO NO VOTES AND IT WENT
THROUGH --
JUDICIARY ON CONSENT.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE SOON
THINK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
RESTATEMENT BERGEN ANSWER
WITNESSES BRIEF BUT ELOQUENT UP
POLICEMAN.
THERESA MAY REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW THE FCB TO
REMOVE FROM THEIR BOOKS ACCOUNT
SO OUR PHANTOM REVENUE THAT
OTHERWISE WOULD STAY IN THE
BOOKS FOR TWENTY YEARS.
IS IS A MORE ACCOUNTABLE
APPROACH WE ASKED WE AYE VOTE
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
HEY FROM FTP ANY ITEMS THAT YOU
LIKE TO BE A BAD.
NOW I WOULD JUST LIKE TO SAY
THAT WERE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
BILL THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR ME TO
WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT
PERSON LASSEN ORGANIZATION
PLEASE.
JENNIFER TANNAHILL WITH AARON
READ ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
SOCIETY OF ENROLLED AGENTS ALSO
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU SANAM.
BUT HEY REX REX EVERY I'M OF
HAVE CALIFORNIA'S PROP
DISSOCIATION ALSO IN SUPPORT
THING TRAIN WITH US TODAY.
LET ME SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
ELSE -- IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE ADVANCE YOU KNOW LIKE THE
TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE I
OPPOSE THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSE.
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE WE HAVE A MOTION THIS
IS DUE PASSED YOUR PREPARATIONS
IS SIMILARLY LIKE TO CLOSE
PLEASE --
I'M DEAD.
NO RIGHT HERE WE GO ASSANGE AT
SEVERAL COUPLE PLEASE WIDER HIGH
WIRE AYE NGUYEN BELL HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA MORE LOCK.
WE'RE LOOKING IT'S A TWO ZERO
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
ISSUES WE CAN LOOK AT FOLKS ON
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BOB WORKING --
AT THE SERGEANTS WERE ONLY GONNA
WE'RE GONNA TAKE ASSEMBLY WOMAN
EGGMAN AND MR GARCIA AND THEN
WE'RE GOING TO NEED TO CALL IT A
DAY SO WE CAN ALSO LET.
THOSE REMAINING OFFICES KNOW
THAT WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO SHUT IT
DOWN TEMPORARILY UNTIL AFTER
ENERGY SO I MISS A GREEN AND MR
GARCIA AT WILL BE OUR FINAL TO
FOR THIS ROUND.
WE WELCOME THE SAN THE WOMAN IN
ONCE WE THANK YOU FOR ALL OF
YOUR WORK ON BEHALF OF THE
STUDENTS OF THE STATE.
SOMEONE I THINK I WOULD VERY
BRIEF TODAY WERE PRESENTING AB
TWENTY SEVEN SEVENTY ONE THE
HIGHER FACILITIES BOND ACTIVE
TWENTY EIGHTEEN WE HAVE NOT CHEN
--
INVESTED IN OUR SYSTEMS OF
HIGHER EDUCATION --
AND WELL OVER GENERATIONWE KNOW
THERE WERE PERSONALLY FORTY
THOUSANDS HIGH CALIFORNIA STOOD
TWO DID NOT HAVE A PLACE TO PUT
WE KNOW THAT IRAN'S WE KNOW
DEFERRED WRITTEN MAINTENANCE IS
IS A WEEK WEEK.
AND WE ARE WORKING WITH THE
AUTHORS OF THE HIGHER ED BOND ON
THIS SIDE AS WE MOVE FORWARD --
WE NEED TO INVEST IN EDUCATION.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS SYLVIA
SOLELY SEAN BEHALF OF THE TWENTY
EIGHT THOUSAND MEMBERS OF THE
CALIFORNIA FACULTY ASSOCIATION
WHERE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
MEASURE.
AYE WE KNOW THE CSU HAS A
DEFERRED MAINTENANCE BACKLOG OF
OVER TWO BILLION DOLLARS FATHER
REVENUE FROM THESE BONDS WORLD
MULTI BILLION DOLLAR INVESTMENT
TO MEET DEFERRED MAINTENANCE
STUDENT HOUSING.
STUDENT HOUSING AND EXPAND CHAIN
NEEDS OF OUR HIGHER EDUCATION
SEGMENTS OR INSTRUCTS PORTAL
THINK YOU'D THINK ME AND GOOD TO
SEE YOU.
BUT I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME
ANYONE ELSE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT AT THIS RATE BILL IF
YOU CAN PLEASE COME FORWARD.
YOU KNOW WHEN YOU SEE YOURSELF
FIRST LASSEN ORGANIZATION.
ABSOLUTELY THINKING MAGGIE WHITE
WITH THE CAL STATE STUDENT
ASSOCIATION REPRESENT OZZY AS HE
STUDENTS AND STRONG SUPPORT
INDIA.
THE SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
LAST CALL NOW LIKE TODAY TO SEE
IF THERE'S ANYONE OPPOSE IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE THIS TIME.
LAST CALL THIS BRING BACK TO
COMMITTEE TO BE ABLE TO SEE IF
WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS COMMENTS
Y. ALSO WELCOME.
MISTER CHAIR I I'LL BE OPPOSED
--
EVEN THOUGH I'M A CSU GRADUATE
FORMALIN NIGHT OF THE YEAR COULD
YOU STILL MAKE EMOTIONAL STORY.
I'M FROM.
JONO Y. KIM HI I HAD THE
PRIVILEGE OF WRITING THE BALLOT
ARGUMENT AGAINST THE FOUR
BILLION DOLLAR [inaudible]
PARK BOND.
I DON'T KNOW IF I'LL.
BE ASKED TO DO THIS.
ONE OUT OF I WANT TO DO THAT'S
WHAT -- BUT
IT'S GONA COST FOURTEEN BILLION
TO PAY IT OFF IT'S GOING TO BE
OUT OF THE GENERAL FUND.
AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE THAT
MONEY COMES FROM I DIE YOU KNOW
THE GOVERNOR HAS NOT BEEN
ISSUING.
BONDS FOR THE SCHOOL BOND WE DID
TWO YEARS AGO FOR NINE BILLION
EVEN PARSON THAT OUT --
SO.
I'M I'M JUST CONCERNED ABOUT THE
GENERAL FUND IT'S NOT THAT I
DON'T WANT TO SUPPORT MY OF
ALUMNI AND I AT THAT YOU KNOW
I'M ON EDUCATION SUB ONCE I'M.
I THOUGHT IT WOULD DO IF IT
BREAKS MY HEART BUT IT MAY I
JUST DON'T SEE WHERE THE CACHE
IS COMING FROM SOME MISTER CHAIR
I I I CAN MAKE A MOTION AT THIS
TIME I APOLOGIZE.
BENTSEN A MEMBER WE ARE GOING TO
HAVE TO HOLD ON THE MOTION WE
WILL BRING IT UP I AS THE FIRST
ITEM --
IMMEDIATELY --
WHOM --
ENERGY COMMITTEE BUT WHAT I'D
LIKE YOU TO BE ABLE TO YOUR
CLOSING COMMENT --
IS WELL FIVE I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE AS WE INVEST IN
OUR CALIFORNIA SCHOOL ARE
CALIFORNIANS IN OUR CALIFORNIA
ECONOMY THANK YOU SO MUCH THIS
IS GONNA AT THIS HAS A DO PASSES
A MINUTE TO PREPARATION
RECOMMENDATION.
WILL WAIT TO BE TO GET THAT
MOTION AS SOON AS WE WE CAN BE
LOOKING VERY APOLOGETIC THANK
YOU SO MUCH. FOR NOW ON TOUR
LAST ITEM FOR THE FIRST ROUND --
GOVERN FIVE YEAH I WILL I SIT
THANK YOU TO MISTER GARCIA FOR
ALL OF HIS WORK ON THIS ISSUE
AND OF COURSE ON ALL ISSUES --
ON BEHALF OF NAFTA RESOURCES IN
THE STATE.
OF MR SOME IN THIS HOUSE THAT
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON THE BILL
WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR A SHORT BIT
ELOQUENT STATEMENTS ARE SILLY
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A AYE VOTE
ON AB.
TWENTY SEVEN FORTY SIX HER FIGHT
THE STATE'S INTENT OF THE LAW BY
ENABLING TREASURE TAX COLLECTORS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE TO CONTINUE
THEIR TAX CELLS PROCESS WITHOUT
BEING IMPAIRED IF BANKRUPTCIES
FILED AFTER THE NIGHT.
WELL HAVE TO THE RIGHT OF
REDEMPTION HAS ITS BY
RESPECTFULLY AS FOR APPLE THANK
YOU SO MUCH WE DO HAVE A MOTION
ON THE FLOOR THANK YOU SOME
REMEMBER WE'RE GOING TO ASK OUT
FOR ANY COMMENT AND WE'RE GOING
TO ASK FOR A BRIEF BUT ELOQUENT
--
INCURABLE WILL TREASURE TAX
COLLECTED FROM PILL COUNTY AND
I'M JUST ASKING FOR YOUR SUPPORT
PRINCIPALSHIP LET ALL ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS IF YOU HAVE ANY.
PAIN THANKS FOR BEING HERE TODAY
IS WHAT WE'RE VERY GRATEFUL
THANKS FOR HANGING WITH US SO
IT'S BEEN A LONG DAY SO I THINK
IF.
WE GET AFTERNOON MISTER
CARDMEMBERS CAROLING OF OF THE
CALPERS DECISIONA COUNTY
TREASURES AND TAX COLLECTORS
THIS CATCHES THE STATUTE UP TO
THE WAY THAT WE DO TAX SALES NO
HOUSE FOR ABOUT THE Q. THANK YOU
WE ALWAYS LOVE IT WHEN I MISS
THING IS IN COMMITTEE THANK YOU.
SO MUCH WE LIKELY TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANYON ELSE IN SUPPORT IF
YOU COULD PLEASE COME FORWARD.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
LAST CALL.
WE WOULD NOW LIKE TO BE OF THE
WELCOME ANYONE WHO MAY BE
OPPOSED IF YOU COULD PLEASE
ADVANCE AT THIS TIME WE'RE
LOOKING FOR THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSED.
FROM GLAD YOU BROUGHT THE PAPER
AND I IT A SAY SO THERE GO.
I THINK YOU SO MUCH FOR BRINGING
IT BACK TO COMMITTEE WE DO HAVE
A MOTION ON THE FLOOR BY CENTER
MORE LOCK THIS HAS. TO DO PASSED
TO THE FLOOR MOTION MISTER
SOMEONE WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
JUST WHAT IT WAS MORE LIKE FOR
WRITING THE OPPOSITION TO PROP
SIXTY EIGHT DATA.
HELPED US TREMENDOUSLY IN THE
HEAD.
AND THE HIGH ONE RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AND WHAT THE UP.
HI DAY VERY GO WHO'S WHO IN
DOING A TWIST RIGHT THERE ARE I
WATCH OUR RIGHT WE'RE GONNA DO A
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE IS
LANCASTER.
REQUIRE HIGH WIRE AYE NGUYEN NOW
WHEN AND IF HERTZBERG LARA MORE
LAW.
I WANT.%
NINE TO CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO
ZERO VOTE WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN LAYS JAMMING I WANNA
Y..
SOON I KNOW OFF THE ITS NAME IS
JONATHAN PETERSON IS COMING FROM
THE LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S OFFICE
IT'S GOING TO BE THE NEW CONCERT
WITH GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE IT
WE COULD WELL GIVE THEM A WARM.
WELCOME [inaudible]
MY I DON'T THINK WE'RE VERY
EXCITED THAT YOU'RE HERE AND IN
TURN WILL SOON BE GIVING YOU
ABOUT FORTY TWO BILLS SO --
WHERE I WE'RE GRATEFUL THANK YOU
SO MUCH SO HERE'S HOW IT'S GOING
TO WORK IN ME TEN SECONDS OR TO
CONFIRM THE ROOM AND THEY WILL
MAKE THE ANNOUNCEMENT ON WHEN
WE'RE GONNA RECONVENE?
CENTER MORE LOCK --
IT.
AND I OF WE NEED TO DO IT SHIP.
BUT WE HAVE TO DO THE AYE NEXT
AROUND TO CHECK THESE.
OKAY ALRIGHT EIGHT WE GOT.
WELL LET ME GOOD YEAH OKAY HANG
ON ONE SECOND THEN IT'S
CONFIRMED THE ROOM AND WE ARE
BACK. THIRTY DURING THE ALRIGHT
WE HAVE A NEW ROOM WE ARE
HEADING OVER TO ROOM. TWENTY
FORTY TWENTY FORTY TO BE ON UPON
THE GERMAN OF THE ENERGY
COMMITTEE.
THERE ARE SOME.
TINKER BELL'S MEANS TO MEET THE
BILLS THAT ARE GONNA BE IN
ENERGY SO WE'LL RECONVENE AT
ELEVEN PM --
IT WILL BE RIGHT BACK WITH YOU
I'M EXAGGERATING ONLY BE NINE PM
SO WE WILL SEE YOU BACK IN ROOM
TWENTY FORTY UPON THE GERMAN AND
ENERGY ROOM TWENTY FORTY UPON
THE ADJOURNMENT AND ENERGY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SEASON JIM
BACK EVERYBODY ADD TO THE
GOVERNANCE IN FINANCE COMMITTEE
OF CABINET SEATS IN IT WE ARE
GRATEFUL THAT WE HAVE VICE CHAIR
VICE CHAIR WYNN HERE.
ALONG WITH THE MAN THE MYTH
LEGEND FROM ORANGE COUNTY THAT
IS MISTER JOHN MORLOCK WE'RE
GRATEFUL.
FOR BUT SO DISTURBED LAYING OUT
WHAT WE HAVE IN FRONT OF US WE
HAVE.
A SIMILAR HARPER WHO'S GOING TO
BYZANTINE AB.
TWENTY SEVEN THIRTY I WE ALSO
WITHIN ARE GOING HERE.
TAKE AFTER MISTER HER PRETEND
BERMAN ASKED FOR MOTION ON THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
THEN WE HAVE --
OVER TWO DOZEN BILLS THAT WE
NEED TO BE TO WORK THROUGH TO BE
TO TAKE ACTION ON A GET MOTIONS
ON AND TAKE ACTION AS WELL.
SO OUT WOULD LET'S GET THIS
COOKING WE'RE VERY GRATEFUL THAT
A SIMILAR HARPER IS HERE HE'S
GONNA BE RESENTING AB TWENTY
SEVEN THIRTY SIR.
I WANNA APOLOGIZE TO CEMENT HE
GOT IN PATHS WE WERE RETURNING I
DIDN'T MAKE ROOM FOR THE
INSURANCE COMMITTEE I IN BEING
BOOTED OUT SO I DO.
YEAH I DO APOLOGIZE --
AT ABOUT THAT AND I AT THAT WE
WELCOME THE SIM INTO COMMITTEE.
THE FLOORS ARE SIR.
WE'RE GOING TO PRESS UP PERFECT.
I THINK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS I'M HERE PRESENT
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY SEVEN
THIRTY WHICH PASSED OUT OF ALL
COMMITTEES AND THE ASSEMBLY
FLOOR WITHOUT ANY OPPOSITION.
BY THIS BILL WOULD PROHIBIT THIS
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD OR ANY OTHER
PRIVATE ENTITY FROM CONDUCTING
WAGE GARNISHMENT.
BUT GUARDSMEN'S EN BANC LEVEES
FOR THE COLLECTION OF UNPAID
TOOLS OR PULL OF ASIAN
PENALTIES.
CALIFORNIANS OFTEN FACE ARE THEY
ARE OFTEN USED TOLL ROADS OR
BRIDGES TO COMMUTE TO WORK OR
TRAVEL AYE THEY EITHER PAY WITH
TOLL OR CASH OR SOMETIMES THEY
HAVE A A FAST TRACK OR
EXPRESSED.
ACCOUNT.
WHEN INDIVIDUALS FEEL TO PAY A
TOLL THEY'RE SUBJECT TO
PENALTIES THESE PENALTIES RANGE
FROM TWENTY FIVE DOLLARS TO FIVE
HUNDRED DOLLARS PER PENALTY?
IN TWENTY FIFTEEN TOOL AGENCIES
WERE AUTHORIZED TO CONDUCT WAGE
AND BANK LEVEES THROUGH THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD.
AGAINST INDIVIDUALS WHO FAIL TO
PULL VIOLATIONS IN ADDITION
PENALTY FEES CONTINUE TO ACCRUE
ON UNPAID BALANCES WHILE THE
WAGE AND THINK LEVEES ARE IN
EFFECT.
EVEN THOUGH THE FRANCHISE TAX
BOARD ONLY GETS INVOLVED AFTER
PERSON IS EXHAUSTED THE APPEALS
PROCESS TO OVERTURN PULL
VIOLATIONS ALL FINES AND
PENALTIES.
HAVE BEEN PAID I HAVE TO BE PAID
UP FRONT BEFORE THAT PROCESS CAN
BEGIN.
IF SOMEONE HAS TEN THOUSAND
DOLLARS AND TOLD VIOLATIONS AND
AN ADDITIONAL PENALTIES IT IS
HIGHLY.
LIKELY THAT THEY CANNOT AFFORD
TO FILE AN APPEAL.
NEAR NOT APPEALING THE TOLL
VIOLATIONS CAN LEAD TO AWAIT
WAGE GARNISHMENT THE FRANCHISE
TAX BOARD HAS THE AUTHORITY TO
CONDUCT WAGE GARNISHMENT FOR UP
225% OF PAYCHECK.
THEY ALSO HAVE THE ABILITY TO
GARNISH THE WAGES OF THE DEBTOR
SPOUSE THAT MEANS THE CALIFORNIA
FAMILY IS AT RISK TO HAVE ONE
QUARTER OF THEIR MONTHLY INCOME
TAKEN AWAY FROM THEM.
THIS HURTS THEIR ABILITY P. ABLE
KEEP FOOD ON THE TABLE CLOTHES
ON THEIR BACK AND A ROOF OVER
THEIR HEAD.
NUMEROUS RESIDENTS ORANGE COUNTY
RECEIVED MASSIVE TOLL FUNDS FOR
QUITE RATIONS THESE INCLUDE FOR
EXAMPLE BRING IMPOSSIBLE
GONZALEZ WHO FAIL TO PAY SIXTY
DOLLARS AND FOURTEEN CENTS AND
TOLLS.
AND WERE BILLED SEVENTY EIGHT
THOUSAND SEVEN HUNDRED AND
EIGHTY DOLLARS IN PENALTIES.
STEPHANIE AND BRIAN YOUNG RACKED
A FIVE HUNDRED DOLLAR PROFIT
EARNING EIGHTY DOLLARS ON PAY
TOLLS AFTER CREDIT CARD LINKED
TO THEIR TOLL TRANSPONDER
ACCOUNT EXPIRED BUT THEY FACED.
FIFTY THREE THOUSAND FIVE
HUNDRED AND FIFTY DOLLARS IN
FINES.
A THIRD EXAMPLE SHERRI HUTTON
WHO WAS UNAWARE THAT HER FAST
TRACK PASSED WAS NO LONGER
LINKED HER BANK ACCOUNT HER
PENALTIES IN LATE FEES ADD UP TO
MORE THAN FORTY NINE THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
CURRENTLY TOLL AGENCIES HAVE THE
ABILITY TO IMPOSE LESS INTRUSIVE
MEANS OF COLLECTING UNPAID TOLL
OVATION PENALTIES THESE INCLUDE
PLACING A HOLD ON VEHICLES
REGISTRATION.
OBTAINING ASSIST CIVIL JUDGMENT
CONTRACTING WITH THE TOLL
COLLECTION HR BLOCK WITH THE
CALL A COLLECTION AGENCY AND
DEDUCTING FROM A TAX REFUND AND
PLACING A LIEN ON THE VEHICLE.
WITH CALIFORNIA BEING ONE THE
MOST EXPENSIVE STATES ELEVEN
RESIDENTS CAN OF WE CANNOT
AFFORD TO HAVE THEIR EARNED
INCOME TO BE FALSE FORCIBLY
TAKEN FROM THEM BECAUSE OF AN
HONEST MISTAKE.
I THE INTENTION OF THIS BILL IS
TO ELIMINATE THOSE WAGE
GARNISHMENT SPREAD TAXATION SEE
AS A MEANS OF COLLECTING FEES
AND PENALTIES.
AND IT DOES NOT IMPACT THE
EXORBITANT PENALTIES THAT WILL
STILL BE REQUIRED TO PAY.
SUPPORTING THIS BILL WILL
PROTECT CALIFORNIANS FROM BEING
PUSHED INTO POVERTY BECAUSE
MINOR TOLL VIOLATION.
VOTING AGAINST THIS BILL WOULD
HURT.
YEAH LOW INCOME DRIVERS AND
PUNISH THEM FOR A SIMPLE MISTAKE
--
I BELIEVE MY OF MY WITNESS IS
NOT HERE WITH ME ANYMORE HE WAS
HERE FOR THE AT THE MORNING
SESSION.
I BUT I THINK I YOU VERY MUCH
FOR THE ABILITY BE ABLE PRESENT
THIS BILL THAT --
HAD NO VOTES IN OPPOSITION AND I
RESPECTFULLY OSCAR FOR YOUR
SUPPORT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AS SOMEONE
AGAIN I APOLOGIZE ABOUT NOT
GOING EARLIER I WE JUST ONE OF
THOSE CRAZY DAYS OF HAVING THEIR
TO MAKE ROOM FOR INSURANCE I HAD
TO COMMITTEES TO THIS MORNING'S
I UNDERSTAND ME AS A LITTLE TO
SHELVE SO I APOLOGIZE.
AND WHAT WE'D LIKE TO BE A TO DO
IT S. OUT WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE
IN SUPPORT TO BE ABLE TO ADVANCE
THAT PLEASE ADVANCE MICROPHONE
AT THIS TIME THOSE IN SUPPORT.
NOW WOULD LIKE TO BE A WELCOME
THOSE WHO MAY BE OPPOSED IF YOU
COULD PLEASE COME FORWARD.
YES MISTER CHAIRMAN --
COMMITTEE MEMBERS BOB NAYLOR I
REPRESENT THE TRANSPORTATION
CORRIDOR AGENCIES THE ORANGE
COUNTY TOLL ROADS.
AND MISTER HARPER'S ACTUALLY.
TAKE FREQUENT USER OF THE TOLL
ROADS THEY GO THROUGH THE US
DISTRICT --
I WANNA REMIND THE COMMITTEE
THAT WE COLLECT THE TOLLS TO PAY
THE BONDS THAT WERE USED TO
BUILD FIFTY ONE MILES OF
FREEWAY.
WITHOUT TAXPAYER EXPENSE AND
TURNED OVER TO THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
STILL HAVE TO COLLECT THOSE
TOLLS.
WE BY THE WAY HAVE A MAXIMUM
PENALTY OF A HUNDRED DOLLARS AND
DO OUR BEST TO WORK OUT.
PAYMENT PLANS AND SO ON WITH
DELINQUENT TOLD PLAYERS BUT
SOMETIMES WE HAVE.
TO GO TO A COLLECTION PROCESS.
D. M. V. IS THE MOST EFFICIENT
COLLECTION PROCESS.
MISTER HARPER AS KIND ENOUGH TO
SET UP A MEETING WITH THE D. M.
V. SO THEY COULD TRY TO TELL US.
HOW MUCH OF THEIR COLLECTIONS
ARE FROM REGISTRATION HOLES AND
HOW MUCH I FROM THE FRANCHISE
TAX BOARD PROCESS?
THEY SAID WE'RE GOING TO GO BACK
AND GET THAT DATA AND WE'RE
STILL WAITING FOR THE DATA.
SO WE CAN'T.
SAY AS WE STAND HERE HOW MUCH
FINANCIAL IMPACT THIS BILL WILL
HAVE ON US BECAUSE WE DO NOT
HAVE THE DATA.
THAT BEING THE CASE WE
RESPECTFULLY HAVE TO CONTINUE TO
OPPOSE THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE LIKE GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE OUT TO MAY BE OPPOSED TO
THE LEGISLATION IF YOU COULD
PLEASE HAVE ASKEDTHIS TIME
LOOKING FOR THOSE WHO MAY BE
OPPOSED [inaudible]
LAST CALL.
WE'RE BRINGING BACK TO
COMMITTEE.
I HAVE A FEW OTHER COMMENTS BUT
I'D LIKE TO BETTER SEE IF WE
HAVE A PLEASE.
SEND HERNANDEZ SIMPLER QUESTION
YOU IT.
STATED SOME OF THE FINDS THAT
SOME OF THESE INDIVIDUALS HAVE
WHICH SEEM PRETTY HIGH SO YOU
CAN A CHEERY EACH AND EVERYONE
OF THEM JST TO THE TOLL AND I
HAVE TO WHAT THE OPPOSITION SAID
WHICH COULD BE A COMBINATION OF
THE TOLL.
AND OR LET'S SAY LATE FEES LATE
FEES OUR YOU KNOW THE DMB FOR
THEIR LICENSE OR WHATEVER SO ALL
OF ITS TOLD THE TRIBUTE TO THE
TOLLS A TRIBUTE TO THE TOLLS AND
THAT.
BECAUSE THE LATE FEES I CAN
COME.
FINANCIAL MEMBERS OF THE HIGHS
HE SAID WITH A HUNDRED DOLLARS I
THINK PER MEMBER THAT'S NOT THE
ONLY TOLL AGENCY THAT'S THAT'S
POTENTIALLY INVOLVED.
BUT THE THING THAT I TRY TO GET
AT AND THE PURPOSE OF THIS BILL
AYE IS.
THE PHENOMENON OF THE FRANCHISE
TAX BOARD AND THE AND THE TAX
COLLECTION AGENCY IS A
RELATIVELY NEW PHENOMENON IT WAS
INCLUDED IN A BUDGET TRAILER
BILL I JUST A FEW YEARS AGO
[inaudible]
I I THINK THAT THE THE TAX
AGENCY IS TO HAVE YOUR HAND TO
BE ABLE CLICK IS THERE'S A LOT
OF OTHER AND HEROES IN THE
QUIVER --
THERE OR HAD THE TOLL AGENCY
ITSELF THE DMV THE COURTS THE
STATE CONTROLLER AS WELL AS
CALTRANS UP ALL ARE ABLE TO HELP
WITH TOLL.
WHICH WILL COLLECTION I THE
ISSUE THAT WE'RE TRYING TO MAKE
SURE TO HAVE IS THAT CONNECTION.
PEOPLE WHO ARE SCOFFLAWS UNCLES
OR TO MAYBE HAVE MAKING A MEDIA
MISTAKE TO TRY TO GET THEM INTO
THAT COMPLIANCE LEVEL.
I IN SO WE'RE IN THE PROCESS OF
MAKING SURE WORK WITH THE DMV
BECAUSE I IS POINTED OUT OF BY
THE THE REPRESENTED FROM A FROM
A TRANCE A TOLL ROAD AUTHORITY.
IDEAS I THINK THAT THE THING
THAT WE NEED TO MAKE SURE HERE
IS TAT THERE'S AN ABILITY OF
THE DMV TO BE ABLE TO DO THOSE
HOLDS IN A TIMELY WAY IN AN
APPROPRIATE WAY.
I'D THAT DON'T MAKE SURE TO
MOTIVATE PEOPLE TO PAY THEIR
POLLS AND ESPECIALLY IN A TIMELY
MATTER BUT THAT DOESN'T ALLOW
FOR THESE.
LATE FEES TO BE ABLE TO RACK.
THE LONG LONG ANSWER FOR IF A
REAL SHORT SHORT GUY SPONSORING
NEEDED SO.
THANKS AND WELCOME.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR HERTZBERG
IN CINEMA REPRESENT ORANGE
COUNTY TOLL ROAD.
NO NO I JUST OF REPRESENT AN
AREA THAT SIDE THE SAN JOAQUIN
HILLS ARE TRANSPORTATION
CORRIDOR WHICH IS ONE OF THE
THREE I TOLL ROADS IT'S OPERATE
ORANGE COUNTY.
I'M GOING TO WRITE DOWN THAT
ROAD [inaudible] OH YES DO.
YEAH BECAUSE VERY USEFUL TO
BEGET ESPECIALLY LAGUNA BEACH AS
WELL AS LOOK AT WHAT'S PARTS
MIGHT.
YOU KNOW ON DO WE KNOW HAVE YOU
TAKEN A LOOK AT THE CLEARLY THE
THE BOND.
WHEN THEY DID THE BUSINESS PLAN
FOR THE BOND HOLDERS TO REPAIR
A?
COSTS DRIVEN LOOK AT WITH THEIR
BUSINESS MODEL WAS ABOUT
REPAYMENT.
A OF THOSE BOND HOLDERS.
I GUESS IT IS A POINTED OUT EACH
OF THOSE BONDS WAS DONE PRIOR TO
THE AUTHORITY THAT WAS GIVEN TO
THE FRANCHISE TAX BOARD THAT'S A
RELATIVELY NEW PHENOMENON.
I'D THAT THIS WAS NOT SOMETHING
THAT WAS CONTINGENT ON SO IF THE
QUESTION IS ABOUT WHAT I WAS
TRYING TO UNDERSTAND HAVE THERE
BEEN.
CLEARLY WHEN THEY MODEL THIS
THEY MODEL SCOFFLAWS THE MODEL
OF PEOPLE NOT GETTING PAID TO
THE MODEL PENALTIES TO THE
MORROW ALL THAT OTHER STUFF.
WHICH IS WHICH IS CAUSING THE
LEVEL OF THE PROBLEM TO
UNDERSTAND THE RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN THE FINANCIAL MODEL FOR
REPAYMENT OF THE BOND HOLDERS SO
WE DON'T GO UPSIDE DOWN.
AGAINST THE ACTUAL --
PERFORMANCE WHAT'S REALLY GOING
ON YOU KNOW BECAUSE I'VE HAD
SERIES OF SEVEN BILLS AS YOU
MAYOR NOW BECAUSE I THINK YOU
SUPPORT MOST OF THEM.
THAT THAT DEALT WITH THIS LARGER
ISSUE FEES AND FINES WHERE.
BECAUSE GOVERNMENT HAS SO MUCH
PRESSURE TO RAISE MONEY FOR THIS
REASON OR THAT REASON ARE THIS
COMPETITION AMONG A WHATEVER THE
REASON IS I IT'S NOT RELEVANT.
AND IN THE IMPACT IS IT'S JUST
IT MISSES THE REAL HUMAN SIDE.
YOU KNOW WHAT IMPACT ON PEOPLE'S
LIVES ARE THE PUNISHMENT HAS TO
FIT THE CRIME RIGHT NOW IN THIS
INSTANCE.
ARE NONE OF THESE FORUMS THAT
YOU'RE DEALING WITH HAVE ANY
GOVERNMENTAL AND I MEAN HAVE
ANY.
CRIMINAL ENFORCEMENT THAT ALL
CIVIL ENFORCEMENT THIS KNOW
PARENTS IS ALTHOUGH THE WAY THEY
WRITE THESE THINGS THAT SOMEONE
STILL LICENSE PLATE FROM ME.
AND I WOULD ADVERT IN ONE ACROSS
THE BRIDGE FIFTY TIMES EVER
BECAUSE NO I WASN'T THERE.
AND I HAD NO RECOURSE BECAUSE I
KEPT CALLING IN THEY DON'T HAVE
BEEN ABILITIES REALLY
PROBLEMATIC BUT THERE'S ONLY
CIVIL IMPLICATIONS NOT GROW.
DO YOU KNOW IF IF IF THESE
ENTITIES CAN READ --
CREDIT BUREAU.
THAT I'M NOT SURE IMPORTANT IN
TERMS OF WANTING TO HAVE AN
OBLIGATION OUT THERE THEY CAN'T
REPORT YOUR CREDIT BUREAU WHAT
REALLY GOES ON OR THAT THEY HAVE
A CHILLING EFFECT IN PLACE.
IT IS A YOU KNOW IMPLICATE YOU.
IN THIS IN THIS STUFF I I THINK
I I SUPPORT WHAT YOU'RE DOING.
ON I THINK THE GOVERNMENT IS TOO
HEAVY HANDS ON THIS STUFF --
BUT IT LAST QUESTION TO EACH
THROUGH QUICKLY TO TO YOUR
KNOWLEDGE OF THE MANY STUDIES ON
THIS.
DO DO WE KNOW WHAT TRYING TO
UNDERSTAND WITHRESPECT TO
ENFORCEMENT.
COLLECTION AND WHAT THAT REALLY
LOOKS LIKE IS GOVERNMENT OR SO
OVERCOOKED IN ITS HAND.
THAT IT A. M. YOU GOTTA MAKE
SURE THE ORGANIZATION GETS
FUNDED.
YOU GOTTA MAKE SURE THE BONDS
GET PAID BACK BUT ARE THESE
GIGANTIC FEES AND FINES A
WAS THE COLLECTION BECAUSE WHEN
WE HAD THIS FERGUSON PROBLEM
WITH TEN BILLION DOLLARS OF
UNCOLLECTED FINES AND IT WAS
RIDICULOUS.
PEOPLE LOSING THEIR LICENSES AND
STUFF YOU KNOW HAPPENING THERE.
BUT WHAT'S ACTUALLY IMPLICATION
OUR THE ACTUALLY BALANCING THEIR
BOOKS AND IS THIS EXTRA MONEY
THAT THEY'RE CHARGING EVERYBODY
INCLUDING PEOPLE'S LIVES AND
OVERREACH.
IT DOESN'T REALLY SERVE A
GOVERNMENT PURPOSE IN CERTAIN TO
GET TO IN SO THAT THE BILL'S
THERE BECAUSE WE HAVE THIS
DISCUSSION IS EXCEPT WHEN WE
GOT.
MET WITH THE DMV AS WELL AS BE
UNTIL TOLL ROAD AUTHORITY --
WHAT WAS DISCLOSES THAT THIS IS
INDEED A VERY SMALL AMOUNT?
OF THE ISSUES YOU KNOW WHEN.
WHEN EACH OF THESE OTHER ITEMS
YOU KNOW MOST PEOPLE DON'T GET
ALL THE WAY TO THE THE TAX
COLLECTION --
OR THE TAX COLLECTING AUTHORITY
EATING IN THE HANDS OF US OF
TRYING TO COLLECT THE TOLL
THAT'S KIND OF A LAST RESORT.
AND SO ON THE OVERWHELMING
MAJORITY OF FOLKS --
WHETHER IT'S JUST THE TOLL
AGENCY CLICKING UPS ITSELF BY
THE DMV AYE IN THESE OTHERS I
TEND TO HANDLE THE ISSUE SO
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT A VERY VERY
SMALL PERCENTAGE WHERE.
IT ACTUALLY HAS THE THE TALK IF
YOU HAVE ANY NUMBERS YOU CAN
SHARE WITH THE COMMITTEE WOULD
APPRECIATE IT SUIT LOOKS LIKE
AND WE HAD THIS KIND OF ISSUE IF
YOU REMEMBER I THINK.
WITH THE SANTA MONICA MOUNTAINS
CONSERVANCY IN THE CHARGE THAT
THEY WERE CHARGING.
YOU KNOW IN FUNDING
ORGANIZATIONS TRAFFIC TICKETS.
I I JUST LIKE TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANY LEVEL OF STUFF HERE BECAUSE
THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT
PARTICULARLY INTERESTED IN
MAKING SURE THAT THE PUNISHMENT
FITS THE CRIME.
NOT REALLY OVER CHARGING PEOPLE
BUT YOU'RE PAYING FOR THE COSTS
AND ALSO NOT ENCOURAGING
SCOFFLAWS YOU WANT TO DO TAT
TOO YEAH IT.
I DON'T RECALL THE ONLY A NUMBER
OF TIMES THAT I USE TO PROVIDE
IT TO THE CHAIR AND I'M MORE
THAN HAPPY THANK YOU TO GET THAT
[inaudible]
BUT A QUICK QUESTIONS BEEN SURE
[inaudible]
YET.
OBVIOUSLY PRETTY INTIMIDATING
WHEN YOU GET.
THE FRANCHISE TAX YEAH INVOLVED
IN THE COLLECTION PROCESS DO YOU
HAVE ARCHITECTS I NEVER SHORT ON
THAT YOU SEE A BOARD.
SO I'M JUST CURIOUS WHAT OTHER
ALTERNATIVE COLLECTION.
OPTIONS ARE SERVICES THAT ARE
AVAILABLE.
THE TOLL AGENCY ITSELF AND
THAT'S ACTUALLY HOW MOST OF THE
THE THE UNPAID TOLLS I GET
COLLECTED JUST SIMPLY --
BY MAIL OR BY OTHER MEANS
CONTACTING THE THE FOLKS AT OVER
THE TOLLS AND IN BEING ABLE
COLLECT.
THE DMV IS AS I POINTED OUT CAN
PLACE A HOLD ON A VEHICLES
REGISTRATION --
THAT I TEND TO BE VERY EFFECTIVE
--
ON A COLLECTING A TOLL BUT YOU
CAN ALSO GO TO THE COURTS THREE
CIVIL JUDGMENT --
IS WALLS STATE BECAUSE THE
CONTROLLER TAME THE OFFSET
AGAINST ANY AYE TAX REFUND UP OR
LOTTERY WINNINGS THE DIFFICULTY
THERE HAPPENS TO BE.
IS OFTEN THE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN
THIS SITUATION USUALLY AREN'T DO
A SIGNIFICANT TAX REFUND WHERE
IT COULD BE OFFSET AGAINST.
I'VE BEEN ALSO CALTRANS AYE HAS
THE ABILITY TO BE ABLE TO PLACE
A LIEN ON A VEHICLE AS WELL AND
SO THOSE.
ARE OUR OF FIVE QUIVER OF ARROWS
IN THE QUIVER AND THAT I THINK
ARE ARE ENOUGH AND FOR MOST OF
THE EIGHT I AGE OF THE THE TOLL
ROAD AGENCY.
I CAN ORANGE COUNTY AS WELL AS
IN OTHER PLACES AYE THOSE HAVE
BEEN -- DO
USE THE FOR IS A SAID THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD ADDITION --
WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS A RECENT
ADDITION --
INCLUDE A LAST MINUTE INTO A
TRAILER BILL.
THAT ON A PERSONAL LEVEL I DON'T
MEAN TO BE RUDE BUT YOU LOOK
OLDER TODAY.
IT IS MY BIRTHDAY OF THAT
PICTURE AT ALL.
IT'S SORT OF AN AWKWARD HOMELY
YEAH.
WHEN YOU'RE FORTY FOUR PAGES NOT
AN INSULT?
IT'S APPRECIATED THANK YOU THANK
YOU CENTER DAY AFTER BIRTH DATE
I COULD HURT IF THEY HAVE IF
THAT.
IF IF THAT THE IT YEAH
INFLUENCES YOUR VOTE AT ALL I
WILL USE ANY.
EFFORTS MIGHT HAVE TACTIC. TWO I
MAKE AN APPEAL.
SO WHAT GOES CREE.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS HE DOES HAVE
SOME ITEMS I WANT TO BE A FOLLOW
UP WITH ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.
I IN I KNOW THAT WE ARE ALSO
CALLING ARE COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE ABLE TO
GET THAT MISTER LARA IS WELL AS
NOW.
SO THAT WE CAN BOTH.
AND PRETTY FIGHT IS GOING TO SAY
I THINK YOU THE SIMPLY MEMBER
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD --
IN I THINK AS I AS I'VE GOTTEN
FINANCE AND SHARE THERE ARE SOME
CONCERNS I AND WANNA WORK WITH
YOU ON THOSE.
THINK THAT IT WHEN WE TAKE A
LOOK AT THEIR FRANCHISE TAX FOR
THE LEGISLATURE'S.
I HAVE REPEATEDLY TURNED THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD HAD TO BE
ABLE TO LOOK AT TAX COLLECTION
FOR A VARIETY OF REASONS AND
ISSUES --
OVER THE DECADES.
I'M AND CANDIDLY ONE OF THE
REASONS WHY WE LOOK TO THE FD
BEES BECAUSE THERE MUST AFFECT.
IF WE LOOK FOR EXAMPLE AT THE
DMV.
AND AND YOU CAN STILL DRIVE
WITHOUT --
REGISTRATION FOR EXAMPLE IT'S
MUCH MORE DIFFICULT TO BE ABLE
TO COLLECT.
I AND I DO THINK THAT IS A
MEMBER HARPER HAS BROUGHT
FORWARD NOT SOME COMPELLING
ACCOUNTS OF TWO INDIVIDUALS HERE
TODAY AND I UNDERSTAND THAT
THERE WILL BE MORE.
WHO WE TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE --
WHO ARE PAIN WORD ABOUT WERE 90%
PAYMENT --
IN REGARD TO COLLECTING
STATEWIDE NECK TO BE.
TOLL ROADS BRIDGES YOU NAME IT I
IT'S IT'S A VERY EFFECTIVE
PROGRAM --
AND THE FTP HAS BEEN VERY
EFFECTIVE FOR THE MOST PART AND
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT SIR
THERE ARE OUT LIGHTERS IN THE
SYSTEM THAT WE NEED TO BE ERA
CORRECT.
AND I CAN'T SUPPORT THIS CURRENT
BILL TODAY UP BUT HE MY
COMMITMENT TO YOU WOULD BE THIS.
I I THINK THAT --
THE EXAMPLES THAT YOU ABROAD --
FOR ARE --
OUTSIDE THE REALM OF COMMON
SENSE.
SHOULD NOT HAPPEN.
I AND WHAT MY COMMITMENT WOULD
BE IS TO BE ABLE TO WORK WITH
YOU AND I AM PARTNERSHIP TO
BEARDED FIGURE OUT.
A MANY USE THAT THE GOOD SENATOR
HOW TO BE TO BRING --
THOSE FINES AND PENALTIES IN
LINE WITH WHAT THE ACTUAL ISSUE
IS -- BUT I
THINK THAT IF LOOKING AT ARE
PUTTING INTO A PRIVATE TAX.
PRIVATE COLLECTORS HANDS THEY
CAN ALSO BE JUST AS AGGRESSIVE
[inaudible]
I'M.
THERE HAVE BEEN ATTEMPTS ON THE
DB SIDE AND THEY HAVE NOT BEEN
VERY CANDID IT HAS NOT BEEN
ALWAYS THE MOST EFFECTIVE --
SO WHAT I'D LIKE TO BE TO DO --
AND YOU HAVE MY WORD IS TO BE TO
WORK WITH YOU ON THAT PARTICULAR
FOR THOSE OUT LIARS BUT I THINK.
I IT CANNOT SUPPORT THE BILL AS
IT IS CURRENTLY.
IN PRINT TODAY BUT DO YOU THINK
THAT YOU BRING PORTS AND
COMPELLING AYE ISSUES AND WOULD
LIKE TO GO TO WORK WITH YOU ON
THAT NIGHT BE HAPPY BE AGAIN
MEETING SCHEDULED HERE.
WITHIN THE NEXT WEEK I'D BETTER
TALK ABOUT WHAT POTENTIAL NEXT
STEPS COULD BE IN A ROW ALSO
HEARD IT'S AT CENTER HERTZBERG I
DON'T WANNA UP I THINK THAT IS A
FACTOR.
I BUT I THINK THAT'S AN ISSUE
THAT HE'S ALSO VERY INTERESTED
IN AS WELL.
AND THANK THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
APPRECIATE.
THE BILL IT IF TRADE GO TO CLOSE
OR YEAH HE'S GOING TO ANSWER.
AYE I APPRECIATE THAT AND DONE
AND I KNOW THAT --
YOUR OFFICE HAVE EXPRESSED OUR
CONCERNS TO MIND OF BEFORE TODAY
OF COURSE WE'RE IN A A CRUNCH I
SEE YOUR SCHEDULE --
FOR FOR TODAY AND I BEING ABLE
TO ADDRESSES MANY ISSUES I IS
YOU DO INDEED HAVE --
BUT I AGREE --
WITHOUT TRYING TO FIND A
SOLUTION AYE WHERE ALL
STAKEHOLDERS I CAN BE ABLE TO
APPROACH IT.
I I TRIED TO NARROW THE NARROWLY
TAILORED THIS --
AS MUCH AS I COULD SO THAT OTHER
ISSUES I DIDN'T POTENTIALLY.
FIVE CRITICS ABILITY TO BE ABLE
TO PASS THROUGH LOT BY DAY GIVE
US.
IF THAT WAS REQUIRED TO BE ABLE
TO TAKE TO GET TO BE ABLE PASSED
THROUGH THIS COMMITTEE UP
POTENTIALLY IN THIS SESSION I'D
BE VERY HAPPY --
TO WORK WITH YOU ON THIS.
I TRY TO MOVE.
YEAH THINK DID IT BE TO
CHALLENGE THAT WE HAVE IS WE
WERE FACING THE DEADLINE HERE
TODAY -- SO
THAT'S THE ISSUE I MEAN
OBVIOUSLY WE CAN LOOK FOR OTHER
VEHICLES RIGHT --
HERE -- IN
TO BE A MOVE THAT I DON'T FEEL
COMFORTABLE ABOUT MOVING THIS
SPECIFIC BILL HERE TODAY OUT
THAT HAPPY TO GET TOGETHER WITH
YOU --
EITHER TOMORROW OR LOOKING AT
FIRST THING NEXT WEEK WATER HERE
AYE AND SET UP A TIME WITH YOU
TO BE ABLE TO AT AND TRY TO WORK
THROUGH THOSE ISSUES BECAUSE
AGAIN.
SIR I THINK THAT YOU YOU BRING
UP SOME COMPELLING --
COMPELLING ARGUMENTS IN REGARDS
TO LIMITING OUT WHAT THOSE
PENALTIES TRULY ARE THAT SAID I
ALSO WOULD BE HAPPY TO BE TO
TAKE A MOTION.
UP FROM THE COMMITTEE AS WELL
AND OR WE CAN APART THIS YEAR
TODAY AND I GET TOGETHER
TOMORROW FIRST THING NEXT WEEK
--
THAT HAPPY TO BE A TO WORK WITH
YOU ON WE SPENT A VICE CHAIR
MISTER CHAIRMAN IT SOUNDS LIKE.
YOU WOULD BE WILLING TO SUPPORT
IT WITH SOME AMENDMENTS.
MAY I ASK IF WE CAN GO AHEAD
WOULD YOU CONSIDER SUPPORTING IT
WHAT A COMMITMENT FROM THE
AUTHOR THAT.
IS THAT AMENDMENT DOESN'T HAPPEN
YOU DON'T ALLOW THE BILL TO GO
FORWARD TO ANOTHER.
STEP YEAH I MEAN I MEAN IF IF
THAT'S BECAUSE IT IS THE
DEADLINE IN THE BILL'S GONNA IT
WON'T VANCE AT ALL WITHOUT BEING
ALLOW IT AND THAT A BREATH.
YEAH OF AND SO IF WE CAN JUST
MAYBE LET IT GO THROUGH TODAY
WHAT THE COMMITMENT THAT HE
COMES BACK HERE AT YOUR
DISCRETION.
ON YOU KNOW IF THEY'VE YOU CAN
IF THEY ALSO CAN WORK WITH YOU
DIRECTLY AT THE NEXT DAY OR TWO
BECAUSE IF IT DOESN'T GO OUT
TODAY IT'S DONE. FOR THIS
SESSION AND I AND I DON'T MEAN
SOUNDS LIKE IT'S WORKABLE.
ON IS NOT LIKE YOU'RE SAYING I
DON'T WANT TO I DON'T LIKE IT I
THINK THERE'S AN OPPORTUNITY
THERE MAY BE.
ALLOWED TO PASSED TODAY AND YOU
HOLD A VERY TIGHT LEASH ON IT
[inaudible]
SURE THE I THINK THAT --
ALWAYS WILLING TO WORK AHEAD OF
TIME AND WE'VE HAD SEVERAL
MINUTES WE'VE HAD TO BE A WORK A
COMING INTO TODAY I DON'T FEEL
COMFORTABLE RIGHT NOW SUPPORTING
THIS CURRENT BILL --
THAT SAID BE HAPPY TO BE OF IT
AND YOU HAVE MY COMMITMENT TO BE
ABLE TO GET TOGETHER --
HERE -- WE
CAN TRY TOMORROW FIRST THING
NEXT WEEK AYE AYE HOW ABOUT HOW
ABOUT I BE ABLE TO TO COMMIT. TO
NOT MOVE IT FORWARD TO THE FLOOR
IN LESS WITH SOME AND YOUR
SUPPORT ABOUT.
I THINK THAT WOULD THAT WOULD
ADDRESS WHAT THE WHAT THE CENTER
WAS WELL YEAH I CAN'T SUPPORT
THIS BILL IT TODAY AND I AM NOT
AT ALL I TRYING TO GET IN THE
BACK AND FORTH ON THE UC THEIR
SUPPORT THIS BILL TODAY BUT
HAPPY TO BE OUT OF WORK.
ON THIS ISSUE CONTINUE WORK ON
THIS ISSUE.
BUT BUT WHAT OTHER VEHICLES LEFT
FOR THE SOME WOMEN THAT IF IT
DOESN'T GET OUT TODAY AND PUT A
HOLD ON IT BEFORE THOSE WHO
FLOOR GAP WITH PROBLEMS.
AND IT'S HIS BIRTHDAY A THERE IS
KNOW.
I I I THINK THAT THIS COMMITTEE
KNOWS IT --
I WORK WITH EVERYONE TO BE ABLE
SO ON AND CANDIDLY WE HAVE NOT
EVEN HAD A DISCUSSION ABOUT THIS
BILL --
LEADING TODAY I AND WE'VE
EXPRESSED CONCERNS OVER A WEEK
AGO SO ON THAT SAID I'M HAPPY TO
BE ABLE TO SIT DOWN WITH THE
ASSEMBLY MAN.
I'D TO BE ABLE TO HAVE A
DISCUSSION WILL NEXT YEAR SO --
SO THAT WOULD THAT'S ONE THING
THAT THAT THAT SAID --
HAPPY TO OFFER AND IF ANYONE
WOULD LIKE TO BID OFFER MOTION
I'M NOT GONNA BE ABLE TO BE
SUPPORTIVE OF TODAY.
OKAY SO WE HAVE A MOTION BY
SENATOR MORE LOCK --
ON AB TWENTY SEVEN THIRTY AT
WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE ABLE TO
OFFER ONE LAST CLOSING STATEMENT
SIR.
WELL IT IS ON MY STAFF AND I
COMMUNICATED I'M MORE THAN HAPPY
TO WORK AYE IN.
BEGINNING OF OUR LAST --
LAST WEEK MORE THAN HAPPY TO
WORK WITH THE CHAIR IN TERMS OF
A I REACHING AN AGREEMENT AND
SO.
THE WILLINGNESS IS ALWAYS BEEN A
ON MY PART DIED THIS IS A BILL I
THAT IS ENJOYED BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT AYE THROGHOUT DIE IT'S
A COMMITTEE PASSAGE IN THE
ASSEMBLY.
I WIZARD PARA.
NO VOTES AND THEN ON THE IS.
DEEPLY ASK BECAUSE I THINK THAT
THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT WE CAN
ADDRESS --
THIS YEAR BY RATHER THAN PUSHING
UP TO US A FUTURE I TIME I TO BE
ABLE TO MAKE SURE THAT WE DON'T
HAVE THAT.
OVER AYE HEAVY HANDED USE OF THE
F. FRANCHISE TAX BOARD AYE AND
ARE PROTECTIVE.
OF THE THOSE WHO USE OUR ROLE
ROADS TOLL WAYS BY ANOTHER A
CONVEYANCES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA SO I SINCERELY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE NICKY SO MUCH.
THAT WE HAVE A DO PASSED
APPROPRIATIONS MOTION BY CENTER
MORE LOCK UP MISSING JUST ROLL
CALL PLEASE ACQUIRED NO CHOIR NO
WIND AYE AYE NGUYEN AYE BELL.
BILL NO HERNANDEZ.
FINANCES NOW HURTS.
FOR LARA.
MORE LOCKED [inaudible]
YOU BERKELEY LACKEY.
WARLOCK I THANK YOU SO MUCH
WE'RE GONNA WAIT TO I HAVE
SEVERAL ARE AND ON TO THIS BILL
--
IN WE WILL BE IN TOUCH OUT TODAY
TO BE A SET UP A MEETING IF YOU
ARE A CONSIDERATION I'LL BE
AVAILABLE THINK YOU SO MUCH
SENATOR VERY GRATEFUL.
ASSEMBLY IT WHEN I SEE CENTER N
THE FUTURE THIS TUNE I APOLOGIZE
A OTHER AGO SOMEONE EVER.
AND THERE WE GO --
WE LOVE MISTER MOORE LA.
IT REALLY PERKED OBSERVER LOCK
THE BATTALION FRIDAY.
ALRIGHT.
HEY WE ALL RIGHT LAYS IN GERMAN
I GIVE US SIXTY SECONDS WILL BE
LIKELY TO DO IS HE MOTIONS.
I CAME IN.
YEAH THERE WE GO TO GIVE A SIXTY
SECONDS IN HERE WE GOT
.
SO WE'RE GONNA START WITH THE
CONSENT CALENDAR --
WE HAVE THREE ITEMS IN THE CAN
SINK COUNTER AS ITEM THIRTEEN
WAS PULLED OFF WE HAVE THE ITEM
NINETEEN TWENTY SIX IN TWENTY
EIGHT FILE ITEMS NINETEEN TWENTY
SIX AND TWENTY EIGHT EYES ARE
CONSENT COUNTER AND I I DO
ASSUME THAT WE'VE WE'VE CALLED A
MISTER LAWRENCE WELK RIGHT.
SO WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG ON THE KITCHEN COUNTER
ISN'T JUST A ROLL CALL PLEASE
WIRE I FLY I WIN.
WIN AYE BELL THOUGH I HERNANDEZ
INSIDE HERTZBERG.
IF YOU'RE A GUY LARA.
MORE LIKE MORE LIKE I SIX SIX
ZERO WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE
OPENED AND ALLOW CENTRAL ARE NOT
TO BE ABLE TO ADD ON MEMBERS ARE
MOVING ON A FILE ITEM THREE A.
B. SEVEN OH NINE WE NEED A
MOTION PLEASE.
HEARING THEM CLOSER WHERE THAT
WINTER CLOTHES THAT BECAUSE I
HAD TO GET THE HELL --
IN TO APOLOGIZE BUT WE HAD TO
GET IT ACROSS BY NOON DE GET IT
WOULD HAVE YEAH.
I APOLOGIZE THINK YOU SHOULD
MENTION THAT.
I'M FILE ITEM THREE AB SEVEN OR
NINE MCCARTY SO WE HAVE A MOTION
BY SENATOR HERTZBERG RIGHT HERE
THAT YES OKAY A THIS IS A DO
PASSED TO THE FLOOR MISLED JUST
A ROLL CALL PLEASE INQUIRE AYE
CHOIR AYE WE NO.
WIN NOBEL.
BILL AYE HERNANDEZ IN INDESIGN
ARTS BURKE.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA MORE LOT.
MORE LIKE THEM.
FOR ED ENJOYS A FOR TO BRING
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN MEMBERS
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM FOR A. B.
EIGHT TWENTY NINE IS OUR MOTION
TO DO PASSED THE FLOOR WITH THE
MOTION BY SENATOR HERTZBERG TO
PASS A FLOOR MISLED JUST ROLL
CALL PLEASE WIRE.
AYE MCGUIRE AYE NGUYEN.
BELLE.
BELLE AYE HERNANDEZ IN AND
DECIDE HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA MORE LOCKED
ON WHEN I GOT BY. FIVE ZERO WERE
TO KEEP THE ROLE OPEN AYE
INADVERTENCE FROM OUR AND ON
MEMBERS REMOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
--
FIVE EIGHTY NINE TWENTY FOUR
AGAIN.
ITEM AT THIS BILL HAS BEEN
BROUGHT DOWN TO INTENT LANGUAGE
IN THE AUTHORS AGREED TO BE TO
WORK WITH THIS COMMITTEE AS WELL
AS THE BUSINESS PROFESSIONS
COMMITTEE DURING THE SUMMER WORK
PERIOD TO TRY TO COME TO
SOME-RESOLUTION.
IS THERE A MOTION TO APPROVE AYE
AYE FILE ITEM FIVE ICE IN
HERTZBERG IS THE DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATION ROLL
CALL PLEASE REQUIRE.
AYE REQUIRE I WIN NO WIN NO AND
THIS AYE HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA MORE LOCKED
ALRIGHT MORLOCK GUY YOU AND FIVE
ONE WE ARE GOING TO ROLL OPEN
MEMBERS REMOVING ON THE FILE
ITEM SIXTY BE FOURTEEN FORTY
FIVE IS THERE A MOTION.
SAN HERNANDEZ IS ALL OVER IT
EVER GOT THIS IS DUE PASSES
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR --
MISLAID JUST ROLL CALL PLEASE
MCGUIRE AYE AYE AYE NGUYEN AYE
NGUYEN AYE BELL.
SHALL I HERNANDEZ FERNANDES AYE
HERTZBERG.
IT'S LIKE I LARA MORLOCK.
MORE LIKE I SIX SIX ZERO
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT BATES GERMAN
NEVER HEATHROW LOW POINT.
MISS CAMBIADO A FILE ITEM SEVEN
AB EIGHTEEN EIGHTY NINE DRIVEN
MOTION PLEASE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE MOTION
BY SENATOR BALANCES DO PASSES
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR.
BESIDE JUST A ROLL CALL PLEASE
REQUIRE I I NGUYEN.
I WENT AYE BELL.
BELL I HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
PREFER GUY LARA.
MORE LOCK.
WHEN I GOT YOU HAVE SIXTEEN SIX
YEAR I SAW THAT LOOK BY OF THE
VICE CHAIR GOING AT THE AUDIENCE
WATCH OUT?
I WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM EIGHT AB TWENTY TWENTY
THREE THIS AD WE HAVE A MOTION
PLEASE.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY THE VICE
CHAIR THIS IS DO PASS AS AMENDED
IS I JUST RECALL PLEASE INQUIRE
AYE MCGUIRE AYE NGUYEN.
AYE NGUYEN AYE BELL.
BELL I HEARD IN THIS.
ROOM AND SAW HER. TO FIVE ZERO
WERE HE TO ROLL OPEN FOR MR LARA
MEMBERS MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM
NINE MISCAVIGE AERO THIS HAS TO
DO PASSED APPROPRIATIONS MOTION
IS THERE A MOTION TO APPROVE.
THIS IS A WE ABOUT MOTION BY SEN
HERNANDEZ TO PASS APPROPRIATIONS
ESSENTIAL SOROKA PLEASE WIRE AYE
MCGUIRE AYE NGUYEN AYE AYE
NGUYEN AYE BELL.
DEL AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
IF YOU'RE A GUY LARA MORE LOCK.
MORE LUCK I SIX ZERO THE WORKING
PEOPLE ROLL OPEN FROM MISTER
LARA MOVING ON TO FILE AND TIN
AB TWENTY ONE SIXTY TWO IS OUR
MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
BALANCES DO PASSES AMENDED
APPROPRIATIONS MISLED JUST HURT
RECALL PLEASE WIRE AYE WHY I WIN
[inaudible]
BELL.
BELL AYE HERNANDEZ AND AND FOR
REFER GUY LARA.
MORE LOCKED. ONE GUY. FIVE FIVE
ZERO WE'RE GOING TO KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN THINKING.
MEMBERS MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
ELEVEN AB TWENTY ONE SIXTY FOUR
IS THERE A MOTION.
SIR WE DON'T KNOW YET HOW AYE
AYE POLITICS MY DAD SO SORRY AT
THIS CURRENT VOTE IS THREE ZERO
CHAIR VOTING AYE MY MISTAKE --
MISSING JUST SIR PLEASE AT WHEN
I WENT AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ
AYE HERTZBERG.
REFER GUY LARA. SIX ZERO
BIPARTISAN LOVE RIGHT THERE ARE
ABLE TO KEEP IT WILL OPEN
TIMBERS REMOVING ON THE FILE AND
TWELVE AB TWENTY ONE SEVENTY
NINE THIS IS A TO PASS THE FOUR
MOTION CURRENT VOTERS FOUR ZERO
CHAIR VOTING I THINK JUST.
WHEN I WENT AYE HERTZBERG?
RICHARD GUY LARA. SIX ZERO AND
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN --
ENOUGH FOR MR LARA.
MEMBERS REMOVING.
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM THIRTEEN
WE NEED A MOTION PLEASE WE HAVE
A MOTION BY SENATOR MORE LACKEY
SAYS EMOTION DO PASS
APPROPRIATIONS ESSENTIAL SIROCCO
PLEASE REQUIRE AYE WHY I'VE
NGUYEN.
BELLE BELLE ARGUMENTATIVE INSIDE
HER TUMOR. THREE LARA MORE
LOCKED.
WHEN I GOT [inaudible] FIVE ZERO
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN.
MEMBERS REMOVING ON FILE ITEM
FOURTEEN AB.
TWENTY THREE THIRTY NINE THIS AS
A DO PASS OF THE AS AMENDED TO
THE FLOOR MOTION CURRENT VOTERS
FOUR ZERO CHAIR VOTING I THINK
JUST [inaudible]
NGUYEN.
I WENT I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG GOD
LARA. SIX ZERO ROOKIE THROW OPEN
AND I WANT TO THANK YOU TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR ALL OF YOU
ASSISTANCE WITH THAT BILL VERY
VERY CREE.
FILE ITEM FIFTEEN AB TWENTIES
TWENTY THREE SEVENTY TWO CURRENT
VOTE IS THREE ZERO THE MOTION IS
TO DO PASSED TO THE FLOOR.
WHAT YOU'RE PUTTING ON A
SCIENTIST WHEN I WENT AYE PLAN
ADD THIS?
IN AND DECIDE HERTZBERG.
REFER A GUY LARA. SIX YEAR WHEN
PEOPLE ROLL OPEN ON FILE ITEM
FIFTEEN FILE ITEM SIXTEEN
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO ZERO
VOTES -- AB
TWENTY FIVE OF THREE SHSU WHEN I
WHEN I DEL.
VALLE I'VE HERNANDEZ.
FROM INSIDE HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA YOU HAVE. SIX
SIX YEAR RICKY FEDERAL OF OVER
NINETEEN FILE ITEM EIGHTEEN AB
TWENTY SEVEN FORTY SIX TWO SO
THAT YOU VALUE THE CITY HERE
WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR A MOTION
PLEASE ON FILE ITEM.
EIGHTEEN WE HAVE A MOTION BY
CENTER BELLE DU PASSIVELY.
YEAH FIVE ZERO ATTITUDE AND I
MAY HAVE BEEN OUT --
I APOLOGIZE AND MAY BE.
I MAY BEEN OUT PRESENTING --
AT COMMITTEE AT THAT TIME SO.
YEAH PROBABLY.
SO I APOLOGIZE.
OKAY IS IF FOR SOME REASON IN
RECORD THAT I APOLOGIZE SO WE'RE
GONNA BE MOVING.
I CAN VOTED FOR THE OKAY WE'RE
GONNA WE'RE GONNA OPEN UP THE
ROLE AND FILE ITEM EIGHTEEN AND
THIS IS.
RESEARCHERS VOTING ON YEAH YEAH
[inaudible]
I HAVE.
VERY GOODTUOLUMNE I THINK.
THEIR VIDEO IT'S IN MY HEAD I
THINK I SHOULD STOP DOING THOSE
MARGARITAS EARLIER.
I DO MY BLAME LANE CHESTER SEE
THEIR EGO HIGH DAY SHOULD BRING
IN THE FLASK.
SO --
ALRIGHT IT EVERY YET SEE THERE
YOU GO ALRIGHT.
WE'RE GETTING PUNCHY FILE ITEM
EIGHTEEN MY BAD A CHAIR VOTING I
CURRENTLY DO AS A TWO ZERO YEAH.
WELL I HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE LARA
OF SIX SIX YEAR AND KEEP THE
ROLE OF YEAH.
FIGURED IT [inaudible]
BOTH [inaudible]
SO AT WHAT ABOUT.
MEMBERS REMOVING FORD ON FILE
ITEM TWENTY AB TWENTY SEVEN
SEVENTY ONE WE DO NOT HAVE A
MOTION.
BOTH SO WE HAVE A MOTION BY
CENTER HERTZBERG THIS IS TO PASS
AS A MANAGER PREPARATIONS MISLED
JUST RECALL PLEASE MCGUIRE AYE
MCGUIRE AYE NGUYEN [inaudible]
BELL.
FELL I HERNANDEZ GONNA DECIDE
HERTZBERG.
RIVER GUIDE LARA MORLOCK NO MORE
LOCKED NO. FOR ONE FOUR ONE
WE'RE GONNA KEEP RURAL OPEN.
WE DO APOLOGIZE YOU HAVE TO VOTE
FOR THIS IN CENTER MORE LOCK --
PRESENTED THIS BILL SO --
FOR TO HAPPEN IS YOU'LL GO REYES
BILL YEAH.
ANYMORE LA CANNA AT A PRESENT
TODAY [inaudible]
YEAH [inaudible]
DOES THAT.
RELEVANT MOTION IRAQ HATE SO WE
HAD ABOUT THE VICE CHAIR IS HERE
YEAH EXACTLY.
WELL I DO ALRIGHT SO FILE I AM
TWENTY ONE WE HAVE A MOTION BY
THE VICE CHAIR BY SHEER
WITNESSES DO PASSES EMITTER
PREPARATIONS AND MISS
LANCHESTER.
FLYER AYE MCGUIRE AYE NGUYEN.
I WENT AYE BELL DEL AYE
HERNANDEZ POLITICIZED HERTZBERG
I PREFER GUY LARA MORE LOCKED.
WAKAI SIX SIX ZERO BIPARTISAN
MIRIELLO LACKEY.
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM TWENTY TWO MAYBE TWENTY
EIGHT NINETY CURRENTLY JOSIE
THREE ONE VOTE CHAIR VOTING I'M
A SCIENTIST [inaudible]
WHEN?
HERTZBERG BY RICHARD AYE LARA.
FORMER WEINBERG KEEP THE ROLE OF
FROM MISTER LARA.
MEMBERS REMOVING NINETY FIVE AND
TWENTY THREE WE TWENTY THREE AB
TWENTY NINE ELEVEN TO HAVE A
MOTION.
THE OF THE MOTION PRESS INTERNET
ISSUE PASSES AMENDED TO
PREPARATIONS MISLED CHESTER
REQUIRE AYE MCGUIRE AYE.
WHEN I WHEN I DEL?
BILL AYE HERNANDEZ.
UNITS AYE HERTZBERG.
WHEN A GUY SIX SIX ZERO WE'RE
GONNA KEEP FEDERALOPEN?
WE ARE FINDING OUT WHERE MR LAR
IS CORRECT ALRIGHT HEY THERE YOU
GO.
I WERE.
AND LIFE MOVED ON TO FILE ITEM
TWENTY FOUR AB TWENTY NINE
TWENTY THREE FIVE CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A THREE ONE VOTE CHAIR
VOTING MISS THANK CHESTER WENT
NO WIN NOW [inaudible]
HERTZBERG.
IT'S VERY AYE ALARM HIM FOR FOR
TO BRING TO KEEP THE ROLE OF
FILE ITEM TWENTY FIVE AB TWENTY
NINE SEVEN THREE WE NEED A
MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY VICE CHAIR
WYNN THIS IS A DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS MISLED
CHESTER WICKWIRE BY FOUR I WOULD
LIKE CLEAN I'D GO.
THEY'LL AYE HERNANDEZ INSIDE
HERTZBERG REFER GUY LARA MORE
LOCKED.
WHEN I KANSEN SIX ZERO IF THE
ROLE?
AND OUR FINAL ITEM FOR THE DAY
FILE ITEM TWENTY SEVEN AB TWENTY
ONE THIRTY ONCE IS DO PASSES A
MINUTE TO PREPARATIONS WE HAVE A
HORSE RACE.
GOING RIGHT NOW IT'S CURRENTLY A
ONE ONE I CHAIR VOTING I MISLED
JUST WIN [inaudible]
DEL.
SO I REMOVED IT.
AND THEN DECIDE HERTZBERG
[inaudible]
USE.
I THOUGHT YEAH THIS [inaudible]
YEAH [inaudible]
HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA GET FULL. FOR
ONE AND THAT WE'RE GOING TO KEEP
SEVERAL OPEN MEMBERS --
EYESORE TO SAY THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
FOR ALL THE INCREDIBLE WORK --
IT WAS IMMEDIATE ONE TODAY I
ALSO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO
COLIN IN THE ENTIRE TEAM I'D AND
TIME TO MARNIE --
YET CALLING GOT A FRESH
YESTERDAY IT'S LOOKING GOOD DAYS
HE WATCH OUT.
SO IT'S GOOD STUFF COLLEGE LIKE
THE SAME I LOST FIVE POUNDS A
THEIR EGO EXACTLY.
SO IT'S GOOD STUFF.
I DO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO
THE MEMBERSHIP FOR OTHER WORK --
ALSO ON AUGUST EIGHTH WE DO HAVE
A HEARING AUGUST EIGHT TAX
LEVIES CENTER MORLOCK IS READY
TO ROLL ON TAX LEVIES.
WE HAVE EIGHT TO TEN BILLS AND
SENATOR HEARD SEE IS WELL IT'S
GOING TO MAKE AN APPEARANCE AT
EXACTLY SEE THERE WE GO.
WE'RE GOOD.
AS SIMILAR SHOULD.
ALRIGHT CENTER LARA IS IT'S ONLY
ABOUT A HALF HOUR AWAY
[inaudible]
ALRIGHT [inaudible]
PAGE
BUT FORGET THINK I WANT TO
THANK YOU THE SERGEANTS FOR ALL
THE WORK --
OVER THIS PAST SESSION IS WELL
VERY VERY GRATEFUL AND COULD NOT
DO THIS WITHOUT A SIMILAR WE'RE
GONNA START WITH THE CONSENT
CALENDAR.
ON WE PULLED ITEM THIRTEEN OFF
THE CONSENT COUNTER --
IN SO ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR WE
HAVE NINETEEN TWENTY SIX IN
TWENTY EIGHT FILE ITEMS.
IN JUST A HEADS UP --
CENTER LARA FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO
WE HAD TO VOTE ON EARLIER TODAY
TO GET IT ACROSS THE DESK
ITSELF.
ARE WONDERFUL SO WE TO CLOSE
ROLE SO LET'S MOVE AYE HERE WE
GO MISLED CHESTER --
CALL THAT'S MEMBERS ON THE
KITCHEN COUNTER LARA IDLER ICE
AND SEVEN ZERO WITH THE CONSENT
CALENDAR IT'S CLOSE IN WE ARE IN
THAT BILL THOSE BILLS ARE OUT.
WE'RE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
THREE YEAH A CURRENT VOTERS FOR
TO CHAIR VOTING AYE MISLED JUST
LARA I'VE FLOOR ARE. FOR FIVE
TWO THAT BILL IS THAT WERE
CLOSED.
FILE ITEM FOR CURRENT VOTE IS
FIVE ZERO MISSING CHESTER LA.
LA ARE ON SIX ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT CLOSING THE ROLE.
SIR LARA WE ARE TAKING THE
AMENDMENTS FROM BEING P. ON FILE
ITEM FIVE MAYBE NINE TWENTY FOUR
IT'S WE'RE GONNA BE WORKING ON
IT WITH THE CHAIR OF BEING P.
OVER THE SUMMER PERIOD SELL
EITHER CURRENT.
CURRENT VOTE IS FIVE ONE ON THIS
I JUST LARA AYE. SIX ONE THAT
BILL IS OUT CLOSING THE ROLE
FILE ITEM SIX CURRENT VOTE IS
SIX ZERO MISLED CHESTER
[inaudible]
LARA LARA. SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL
IS OUT CLOSING ROLE.
FILE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN CURRENT
VOTE IS SIX ZERO ESSENTIAL SIR
LARA AYE LARA AYE. SEVEN ZERO
THAT BILLS OUT CLOSING WILL.
FILE ITEM EIGHT CURRENT VOTE IS
FIVE ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER LARA
AND I LARA I SIX ZERO THAT BILLS
OUT CLOTHES AND WILL.
FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE CURRENT
VOTE IS SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER
LARA.
LARA AYE. SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL
IS OUT CLOSING THE ROLE FILE
ITEM TEN CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE
ZERO VOTE MISLED CHESTER LARA.
OR I SIX ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT
CLOSING THE ROLE.
FILE ITEM ELEVEN A CURRENT VOTE
IS SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER LARA
[inaudible]
LARA I SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT CLOSING THE ROLE FILE ITEM
TWELVE CURRENT VOTE IS SIX ZERO
MUSLIM CHESTER ARE [inaudible]
OR I SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT
FLOWS IN THE ROLE FILE ITEM
THIRTEEN CURRENT VOTE IS.
FIVE ZERO IS THEY JUST ARE.
ARE AYE. SIX ZERO THAT BILLS OUT
CLOSING THE ROLE FILE ITEM
FOURTEEN OUR CURRENT VOTE IS SIX
ZERO MISSED LANCASTER LARA.
RIGHT WHERE I SEVEN OH THAT BILL
IS OUT TO FLOWS IN THE ROLE.
FILE ITEM FIFTEEN CURRENT VOTE
IS SIX ZERO MISLAID CHESTER ARE.
YOU ARE ON SEVEN ZERO THAT BILL
IS OUT CLOSE IN THE ROLE.
FILE ITEM SIXTEEN CURRENT VOTE
IS SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER
LARA.
OR I THINK. SEVEN ZERO THE BILL
IS OUT CLOSING THE WRONG FILE
ITEM EIGHTEEN CURRENT VOTE IS
SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER
[inaudible] EIGHTEEN WHATEVER
OUR I DON'T KNOW WHERE MY HARPER
SHE DID [inaudible]
THAT'S I DO APOLOGIZE
[inaudible]
IT'S GREAT.
ALRIGHT I AM SO SORRY --
MISTER LAWRENCE WERE ON FILE
ITEM.
SEVENTEEN THE CURRENT VOTE IS
TWO THREE THE CHAIR IS VOTING NO
ON FILE ITEM SEVENTEEN MISS
LANCHESTER.
LARA KNOW LARGE NO. THREE THREE
THE BILL FAILS A AND FOR A GIVE
US ONE MOMENT
.
THANK YOU SO MUCH YOU WOULD LIKE
TO BE ABLE TO ANNOUNCE THE FINAL
VOTE ON FILE ITEM SEVENTEEN IS
TO AFFORD THE BILL FAILS WE WILL
BE GRANTED RECONSIDERATION. FOR
CLOSING THE ROLE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PATIENTS
IN THAT FILE ITEM EIGHTEEN
CURRENT VOTE IS SIX ZERO MISLIM
CHESTER.
LARA ARE YOU ARE ON SOME. SEVEN
ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WE'RE
CLOSING THE ROLE.
A FINAL FILE ITEM NUMBER TWENTY
KERN VOTE IS FOR ONE CHAIR
VOTING I MISSED MANCHESTER LARA
ON OUR FIVE ONE THE BILL IS OUT
WE'RE CLOSING THE ROLE.
FILE ITEM TWENTY ONE CURRENT
VOTE IS SIX ZERO MISLED GESTURE
LARA BY OUR EYES. SEVEN ZERO THE
BILL IS OUT FOR CLOSING THE FILE
ITEM TWENTY TWO CURRENT VOTE IS
FOR ONE CHAIR VOTING I MISS
LANCHESTER ARE.
MORE I FIVE ONE THE BILL IS OUT
CLOSE LITTLE.
FILE ITEM TWENTY THREE VOTE IS
SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER LARA
AYE LARA AYE. SEVEN ZERO THE
BILL IS OUT RECORDS IN THE FILE
ITEM TWENTY FOUR CURRENT VOTE IS
FOR TWO MISSED LANCHESTER LARA.
AYE AYE LARA AYE.
AT FIVE TO THE BILL IS OUT CLOSE
THE ROLE.
FILE ITEM TWENTY FIVE CURRENT
VOTE IS SIX ZERO MISS LANCHESTER
LARA [inaudible]
I SEVEN ZERO THE BILL IS OUT.
CLOSER OF ALL FILE ITEM TWENTY
SEVEN CURRENT VOTE IS FOR ONE
CHAIR VOTING I MISSED MY
INTEREST LARA. FIVE ONE THE BILL
IS OUT CLOSE THE ROLE.
THAT IS IF IT'S FAKE YOU SO MUCH
MISTER LARA GOOD TO SEE YOU
THANK YOU ALL FOR ALL THE HARD
WORK.
WE WILL SEE YOU ON AUGUST EIGHTH
FOR OUR NEXT HEARING --
IN COLIN IS FIRED UP FOR TAXIS
MIRACLE IN.
ALRIGHT SIR A VERY GO THANK YOU
SO MUCH WE ARE ADJOURNED UNTIL
AUGUST EIGHTH