SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
COMMITTEES COME TO ORDER.
WE HAVE A THIRTY NINE BILLS --
ON THE AGENDA YOU WOULD'VE
THOUGHT THAT THE CHAIRMAN WHAT I
GOT HERE ON TIME BUT I HAD 2%
AND INTO DIFFERENT COMMITTEES
THIS MORNING SO THANKS FOR YOUR
PATIENCE.
WE ALSO HAVE FOURTEEN CONSENT
ITEMS NORMAL HAD REDONE --
IN THE SAKE.
BECAUSE OF TIME I'M NOT GONNA
READ THOSE BUT WE WILL --
WHEN?
WE HAVE A QUORUM AND WE VOTE ON
ORDERS START.
AS A SUBCOMMITTEE MISTER COOLEY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER COOLEY.
I A BE [inaudible]
TWO NINE ONE FOUR WELCOME.
WELCOME GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
HERE TODAY TO RESENT AB TWENTY
NINE FOURTEEN RELATED TO CAN
ALCOHOL AND CANNABIS.
I WANT TO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS AS OUTLINED IN THE
ANALYSIS I THINK YOUR STAFF FOR
THEIR WORK ON THE BILL.
A STUDY SHOWED A SIGNIFICANT
AMOUNT OF ALCOHOL USE WITH
CANNIBALISTIC DEPLETE INCREASES
THE INFLUENCE.
CASEY IN THE PERSON'S BLOOD.
BUT AS THE STUDIES ARE ONGOING
AND WILL CONTINUE NO DOUBT AS
OTHER STATES LEGALIZE CANNABIS
PROTESTANT.
PORTANTO SHOE WE DO KNOW THAT
ALCOHOL AND CANNABIS HAVE A
MULTIPLIER EFFECT.
THAT --
ENHANCES THE IMPACT OF THE TNC.
OF THIS BILL CODIFIES THE
EXISTING REGULATIONS TO THE
STATE ON THE GENERAL TOPIC --
AND RELATED TO THE INFUSION OF
CANNABIS AND ALCOHOL I REQUEST
AND I VOTE.
THIS ISN'T SUPPORT.
KAREN MEMBERS BUT SEE ARMSTRONG
ON BEHALF THE COUNTY HEALTH
EXECUTIVES ASSOCIATION
REPRESENTING CALIFORNIA'S LOCAL
HEALTH DEPARTMENTS IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY OTHER
WITNESSES SUPPORT.
EITHER BRANDON ROBERTS HERE ON
BEHALF TO HELP OFFICERS
ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA HERE IN
SUPPORT.
OF THE DEAD JUST SEALED THE DEAL
RIGHT THERE.
I IN A WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
OKAY ANY MEMBERS WISHING --
TO SPEAK.
THEY WOULD TO HAVE THIS IN BNP
LAST WEEK IS A GREAT BILL.
AND I CALL THAT A WE DON'T HAVE
YOU NOT A THING ORANGE SO WE'RE
GOING TO HEAR THIS AS SOON AS WE
HAVE A QUORUM ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
TO HAVE A COMMENT THAT SENATOR
WILL ALWAYS WE HEARD THIS AND BE
IN PEACE GRAY BILL PLANNED SPORT
AGAIN TODAY.
IT'S INFUSED AND I APPRECIATE
YOUR ENTHUSIASM.
THANK LOSE TEN INFUSE.
MR CHECK WE PULL MISTER BECAUSE
OTHER BILL THAT'S ON CONSENT OFF
CONSENT FOR THAT BAD JOKE.
IT IT IT.
I LIKE THE WAY YOU'RE THINKING.
UP.
A BROCADE IS A MYSTERY CUT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA HERE.
NOW WE HAVE THIS ISSUE.
HERE WE GO [inaudible]
EVEN.
WE HAD A NO PHONES [inaudible]
BUSH BECAUSE WAS IT WAS
.
SO REMEMBER EARLY MON WELCOME.
WE HAVE --
AB TWO TO FIVE AND HE BE.
TWO TWO FIVE TWO TRANSPOSES
NUMBERS VARIABLE START WITH AT
AB TWO TWO FIVE TWO HAS BUT OKAY
YEAH.
I THINK YOU'RE AT CHAIR AND
MEMBERS NONPROFITS RANK IS THE
FOURTH LARGEST INDUSTRY IN
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYING NEARLY ONE
MILLION PEOPLE AND PRODUCING
MORE JOBS IN CONSTRUCTION
FINANCE OR REAL ESTATE
INDUSTRIES.
FEDERAL STATE AND LOCAL CRAFTS
MAKE UP HALF OF THE NONPROFIT
REVENUE.
AND MAKING THIS FUNDING SOURCE
CRITICAL TO THE SUCCESS OF THE
INDUSTRY.
CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY DOES NOT
HAVE A CENTRALIZED DATABASE THAT
NONPROFITS CAN ACCESS TO
IDENTIFY STATE GRANTS THEY MAY
BE ELIGIBLE.
FOR THE MEEK THIS MAKES IT
DIFFICULT FOR MANY NON PROFITS
TO FIND THE INFORMATION THEY
NEED ABOUT STATE FUNDING
OPPORTUNITIES.
IT DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTS
UNDERSERVED IN RURAL COMMUNITIES
MAKING IT HARDER FOR THEM TO
COMPETE FOR AND PROCURE STATE
FUNDS AB TWENTY TWO FIFTY TWO
WILL CREATE A CENTRALIZED
SEARCHABLE DATABASE OF ALL STATE
GRANT OPPORTUNITIES BY MAKING
CALIFORNIA GRANTS ACCESSIBLE AND
TRANSPARENT.
THAT WE WE CAN ENSURE THAT ALL
INTERESTED ENTITIES HAVE A FAIR
SHOT AT STATE FUNDING.
I DID HARM WITNESSES AND I DON'T
SEE THEM SO THAT'S OKAY.
OKAY ANY WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
BUT WHEN YOU.
YES.
THIS IS IN I DID SAY THIS AT THE
TOP THIS IS A SUPPORT SUPPORT
AND WE'VE GOT A LOT OF BILLS ON
THINGS SO SHORT BREVITY IS YOUR
FRIEND. FOR THE MOST VOTES
[inaudible]
BEST.
HI SO IM APRIL JABBA'S I AM THE
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
SACRAMENTO PUBLIC LIBRARY
FOUNDATION.
AND MY ENTIRE JOB IS ALL ABOUT
FUNDRAISING.
SO LIBRARIES YOU PROBABLY HEARD
THIS MANY MANY TIMES NEED MORE
MONEY.
SO THEY HAVE FOUNDATIONS AND
THEY HAVE FRIENDS OF LIBRARIES
ARE TRYING TO RAISE MORE MONEY.
WE'RE ALL SUBJECT TO THIS
PARAMETER THAT 70% OF OUR
DOLLARS RATIO GO TO PROGRAM
FRANK.
AT THE SAME TIME THOUGH WE'RE
ALL RUNNING AROUND LOOKING HAD
DIFFERENT PLACES AND SPENDING
OUR TIME OUR FUND RAISING OR
ADMINISTRATIVE TIME.
LOOKING FOR GRANTS KIND OF IN A
LOT OF DIFFERENT PLACES
DIFFERENT ORGANIZATIONS PUT HIM
IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE
WEBSITE.
SO IT'S JUST A BIG WASTE OF TIME
RAIN.
AND I BET THE GOVERNMENT AND
STATE AGENCIES DON'T ALWAYS FIND
THE GRANTEES THEY'D LIKE TO FIND
EITHER.
SO TO DO FIVE TWO SOLVE THE LOT
OF PROBLEMS THAT WAY EVERYBODY
WINS.
EVERYBODY GET SOMETHING BETTER
IN TERMS OF FUNDING FUNDING GOES
MORE DIRECTLY TO PROGRAMMING.
AND IT SEEMS KIND OF LIKE A NO
LIKE.
BOTTOM IT'S A WIN WIN VERY
GOVERNMENTS IT.
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS
[inaudible]
I'M.
A MEASURE OF THE PHONE GRIFFITH
[inaudible]
SOME.
BUT MY NAME IS ERICA OLLMANN SAN
I'M A PROM PROJECT COORDINATOR
FOR A PACK FOUNDRY I REPRESENT
OVER TWO HUNDRED AND FORTY TO
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS.
AND I BELIEVE THAT DAYS --
WEBSITE ACTUALLY YOU HAD ASSIST
A LOT OF THE NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATIONS THAT I WORK WITH --
PUTTING --
ALL THE STATE GRANTS IN ONE AREA
WHERE THEY'RE ABLE --
TO FIND ALL THE INFORMATION
WOULD BE AND MUCH MORE OF A
SUCCESS FOR THEM IN BEING ABLE
TO APPLY AND SINCE NONPROFITS
ARE.
ALWAYS TRYING --
TO THEY'RE BASICALLY THE
LIFEBLOOD OF ON THE ALL GRANTS
ARE THE LIFEBLOOD OF NONPROFIT
ORGANIZATIONS.
AND I THINK THAT --
THIS WAS SENSUALLY HELP MALCOLM
COMPLETELY ALLY AND MORE
RESOURCES BUT WE CAN BE MORE --
FOR FOSTER CARE ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION WELFARE --
HEALTHCARE EDUCATION AND FOR OUR
AMERICAN MILITARY VETERANS SO I
HOPE YOU GUYS ARE AS I'M
CONSIDERED THE AB TWO TWO BY TWO
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH PRODUCTS
WITNESSES SUPPORT PLEASE ON A
HASSELBLAD --
WITH UNITED WAYS OF CALIFORNIA
ON BEHALF OF OUR THIRTY ONE
MEMBER ASSOCIATIONS IN EVERY
COUNTY IN CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT
OF AB TWO TWO FIVE TWO THANK YOU.
THANK YOU [inaudible]
NEXT.
MICHELMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS ALSO IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE --
ANY COMMENTS.
SO THERE WILL YEAH THANK YOU
SURE THIS IS A GREAT BUILDING AT
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT LEVEL
THAT GRANTS DOT GOV.
WHICH IS QUITE EASY --
TO NAVIGATE A COURSE WE SAW THIS
BILL AND BE IN PEACE AND ARE
HILLA MYSELF GREAT BILL AND I
THINK IT IS IT IS A WIN WIN FOR
ALL PARTY SO THANK YOU FOR DOING
THIS THANK YOU.
OKAY WE HAVE A MOTION.
BUT WE CAN'T DO THAT THAT WOULD
BE HERE BEFORE YOU LEAVE THAT
THIS IS A AGREE BUT I CAN'T TELL
YOU HOW MANY TIMES PEOPLE.
CALL OUR OFFICE ASK IS DO WE
HAVE A CLEARINGHOUSE OF GRANTED
SO IT'S GREAT BILL SO WILL.
GET A VOTE ON IT IS SINCE WE
HAVE A QUORUM.
A WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE UP NEXT
THOUGH HAVE A AB EIGHTEEN
SEVENTY SEVEN DONE THAT IS FILE
ITEM NUMBER.
FOUR AB EIGHTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN
REQUIRES PUBLIC AND FEES BUT
REQUIRES PUBLIC FACING EMERGENCY
COMMUNICATIONS TO INCLUDE CLEAR
TRANSLATION FOR THE MOST
COMMONLY SPOKEN LANGUAGE OTHER
THAN ENGLISH WITH 44% OF
CALIFORNIANS OVER THE AGE OF
FIVE SPEAKING A LANGUAGE OTHER
THAN ENGLISH AT HOME.
IT IS VITAL THAT YOU MERGING SEE
COMMUNICATIONS ARE MADE
AVAILABLE IN LANGUAGES OTHER
THAN ENGLISH.
THAT CAL O. YES OFFICE FOR
ACCESS AND FUNCTIONAL NEEDS WAS
ESTABLISHED IN TWO THOUSAND
EIGHT FOR THE PURPOSES OF
IDENTIFYING THE EMERGENCY
CONCERNS OF POPULATIONS WITH
ACCESS AND FUNCTIONAL NEEDS
BEFORE DURING.
DESPITE THE FACT THE INDIVIDUALS
WHO ARE NON ENGLISH SPEAKING OR
LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY ARE
INCLUDING AN AXIS AND FUNCTIONAL
NEEDS CONSIDERATION.
EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS ARE
STILL NOT REQUIRED TO BE MADE
AVAILABLE IN LANGUAGES OTHER
THAN ENGLISH COMMUNITIES IN THE
DISTRICT THAT I REPRESENT
EXPERIENCE FIRSTHAND THE IMPACT
OF EXCLUSIVE EMERGENCY
COMMUNICATION DURING THE
DEVASTATING THOMAS FIRE WHICH
BURNED OVER TWO HUNDRED EIGHTY
ONE ACRES AND FORCED.
EXCUSE ME OVER A HUNDRED AND
FOUR THOUSAND RESIDENTS TO
EVACUATE.
DURING THE INITIAL DAYS OF THE
THOMAS FIRE THERE WERE
UNDERSTANDABLY COMMUNICATION
GAPS.
BUT SCHEDULED EMERGENCY
COMMUNICATION UPDATES TOOK IN A
LANGUAGE OTHER THAN ENGLISH TOOK
A WEEK OVERDUE AT TOOK A WEEK
TOOK OVER A WEEK TO BE PROVIDED
FROM THE DATE THE FIRE INITIALLY
STARTED THIS LEFT MANY COMMUNITY
MEMBERS FEELING UNSAFE UNSURE
WHETHER TO BACK WE ARE NOT.
THE COMMUNICATION NEEDS OF
INDIVIDUALS A SPEAK LANGUAGES
OTHER THAN ENGLISH ARE NOT
SUFFICIENTLY INCORPORATED INTO
EMERGENCY PLAN THIS OVERSIGHT
PLACES THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
ALL CALIFORNIANS INCLUDING FIRST
RESPONDERS AT RISK DURING TIMES
WHEN A FISHING COMMUNICATIONS IS
MOST NEEDED.
MY OFFICE HAS BEEN WORKING
CLOSELY WITH CALLIE ES ON THIS
LEGISLATION AND WILL CONTINUE TO
DO SO IF THE SMELL MOVE FORWARD
TODAY WITH ME TODAY I HAVE
ACCURATE.
ROSS ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
SANTA ROSA.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS CARE ROSS ON BEHALF OF
THE CITY OF SANTA ROSA AT LAST
FALL DURING THE DEVASTATING
NORTH BAY FIRES LOCAL AGENCIES
INCLUDING OURSELVES WERE
SCRAMBLING TO TRANSLATE
EMERGENCY COMMUNICATION FOR A
VARIETY OF COMMUNICATION
PLATFORMS. TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
OUR SPANISH SPEAKING COMMUNITY.
MESSAGES CHANGE FREQUENTLY AS
NEW INFORMATION BECAME AVAILABLE
AND LIMITED BILINGUAL STAFF
REPRESENTATIVES WERE AVAILABLE
TO SUPPORT AND SUSTAIN ROUND THE
CLOCK NEED FOR SEVERAL DAYS AND
EVEN WEEKS.
WELL ONLY S. PROVIDED MUCH
SUPPORT ON A VARIETY OF FRANCE
THIS IS ONE AREA WHERE GREATER
ASSISTANCE.
WAS NEEDED FOR A COMMUNITY WE
BELIEVE THIS BILL WILL HELP WITH
THIS VERY CRITICAL NEED AND ASK
YOUR ABOUT.
THANK YOU OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
CHRISTY WAS WITH THE AMERICAN
RED CROSS IN SUPPORT.
HE WITNESSES OPPOSITION.
OKAY I THINK WE HAVE ANOTHER
GOOD BILL HERE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND WILL
VOTE ON THAT THAT WILL BE A
QUORUM ITEM NUMBER.
TWELVE AB.
TWO TWO TWO FIVE ASSEMBLY BILL
TWO TWO TWO FIVE RESTORES THE
PREVIOUSLY EXISTING REQUIREMENT
THAT NON PERMANENT DOCUMENTS
FOLLOW THE SAME UNIFORM
ELECTRONIC MEDIA STANDARDS THAT
APPLY TO PERMANENT DOCUMENTS.
WITHOUT THIS REQUIREMENT THE NON
PERMANENT.
RECORDS FOLLOW ANY SORT OF
ELECTRONIC STORAGE STANDARD AND
WITHOUT ANY STATUTORY CLARITY
FOR HOW. TO HANDLE THESE RECORDS
AND THERE IS ARGUABLY A HUGE
RISK POSED TO THE STATE.
THIS BILL IMPROVES COORDINATION
WITH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THAT HAVE
ENTERED INTO A WERE IN AGREEMENT
WITH THE STATE AGENCY.
MY OFFICE HAS WORKED TO SET
PRODUCTIVE COLORS AND WE WILL
CONTINUE TO WORK TO ADDRESS
ISSUES RAISED.
WITH ME TODAY I HAVE AT TED MORE
HAUSER FROM WITH THE SECRETARY
OF STATE'S OFFICE AND SAY HOME
WITH THE AND THE SACK.
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS TED MORE HAUSER ON
BEHALF OF SECRETARY OF STATE
ALEX PADILLA SECRETARY OF STATE
IS A PADILLA IS PLEASED TO
SUPPORT AB.
TWENTY TO TWENTY FIVE THIS BILL
COMPLIMENTS RECENT LEGISLATIVE
EFFORTS TO UPDATE THIS AREA OF
LAW -- THANK
YOU -- TO
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LIMON FOR
AUTHORING THE BILL AND FOR
COORDINATING ONGOING
COLLABORATION WITH INTERESTED
GROUPS.
THANK YOU NEXT GOOD MORNING MY
NAME IS HANS I AM THE CHIEF
INFORMATION OFFICER WITH THE
CITY OF ROSEVILLE AND I ALSO
REPRESENT THE MUSIC COMMUNITIES.
MUSIC IS A MUNICIPAL INFORMATION
SYSTEM ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
CONSISTS ABOUT TREAT HUNDREDS
ODD STATE LOCAL MERELY LOCAL
AGENCIES AND SPECIAL DISTRICT IT
DIRECTORS AND CHIEF INFORMATION
OFFICER.
WILL HEAR DISAPPOINT AB TWENTY
TO TWENTY FIVE TWENTY TO TWENTY
FIVE SERVE TWO PURPOSES. ONE IS
CLOUT STORY TO PUBLIC RECORDS
WITH PRIVACY AND THE SECOND PART
HAVE INTER AGENCY STATE AND
LOCAL GOVERNMENT INTRACONFERENCE
PUT IN PLACE.
AND THIS DOES NOT CREATE ANY
SPECIAL MANDATES OR ANY LOCAL
MANDATES WITH THE LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS AS THE BILL THAT'S
BEING DISCUSSED TODAY BUT IT
DOES PUT IN SOME CONTROL
STRATEGIES IN PLACE.
AND WHAT HE CAN TO SUPPORT BILLS.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
OKAY THANK YOU AND WE WILL VOTE
ON THIS WHEN WE HAVE A CORE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
SO I FIGURED.
OBERNOLTE WAS HERE.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER OBERNOLTE --
AB
.
TWENTY TWENTY TWO GO AHEAD SIR
OR MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS I'M SURE
YOU'RE ALL FAMILIAR WITH THE
HIGH RISK LOCAL GOVERNMENT
AGENCY AUDIT PROGRAM THIS IS AN
IMPORTANT PROGRAM THAT ALLOWS
THE AUDITOR TO DO.
PRE AUDIT PRELIMINARY WORK ON
AGENCIES THAT --
SHE DID DESIGNATES AS BEING HIGH
RISK HOWEVER RECENTLY SOME
CONTROVERSY HAS EMERGED AS TO
WHAT SOURCES OF INFORMATION THE
AUDITOR MIGHT USE TO MAKE THAT
DETERMINATION AND A LETTER READ
WRITTEN RECENTLY BY THE OFFICE
OF LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL.
PODCAST THE OPINION THAT ONLY
THE LISTED IN STATURE IT MIGHT
BE USED FOR THAT SO THIS BILL
CLARIFIES THAT ANY PUBLICLY
AVAILABLE INFORMATION MAY BE
CONSIDERED.
BY THE AUDITOR FOR THE PURPOSES
OF DESIGNATING --
AGENCY HIGH RISK IN BEGINNING
THIS PROCESS SO WITH THAT I'D BE
HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS --
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES OPPOSITION.
I ASSEMBLY MEMBER I EARLIER THIS
THIS YEAR THE COMMITTEE
UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED S. B.
TWELVE NINETY THREE BY SENATOR
LARA WHICH I THINK YOU'RE AWARE
OF WHICH SEEKS.
TO CLARIFY THE AUDITOR'S
AUTHORITY UNDER THE HIGH RISK
LOCAL AGENCY INITIAL ASSESSMENT
PROGRAM.
AND ADDITIONALLY AB TWENTY SEVEN
TWENTY NINE BY SEVEN OR SIMPLY
MEMBER MURATSUCHI CLARIFIES THE
AUDITOR MAY REVIEW.
PUBLICLY IN A AVAILABLE
INFORMATION SO I GUESS FROM MY
STANDPOINT I LOOK AT THESE AND
SAY WHAT WE NEED A THIRD BILL
HERE SO I'M GONNA.
YEAH I'M.
YOU MAY BE ABLE TO TALK ME OUT
OF MY OPPOSITION TO HEAR YOUR
BILL OR LAID OFF IT.
I HAVE ADDED.
UP THE DEBT EXCELLENT QUESTIONS --
ALL DRESSED THEM INDIVIDUALLY SO
ON SENATOR LARA'S BILL THIS BILL
IS DESIGNED TO WORK WITH THAT
HIS HIS BILL TOUCHES ON THE WORK
THAT THE AUDITOR CAN DO WHEN
THEY COME INTO A LOCAL AGENCY --
AND DO THE PRELIMINARY WORK --
ON ON THE AUDIT OF MY BILL
TOUCHES ON THE INFORMATION THAT
THEY CAN USE TO DECIDE WHICH
AGENCIES THEY'RE GOING TO GO
INTO SO WE'VE DESIGNED THOSE TWO
PROVISIONS TO WORK IN AND
CONJUCTION WITH EACH OTHER.
A MISTER MERRETT SUSHI'S BILL --
THERE'S A SUBTLE.
AND THAT HE'S ALONG THE AUDITOR
USE OF THE INFORMATION THAT I
MEAN ALLOWING THE ORDERS TO USE
HIS BILL ALLOWS THE AUDITOR TO
USE.
BY ANY PUBLICLY AVAILABLE
INFORMATION PROVIDED BY THE
ENTITIES SO FOR EXAMPLE IF A
CITY PROVIDED TO THE PUBLIC A
COPY OF THEIR BUDGET THAT'S
SOMETHING THE AUDITOR COULD
CONSIDER.
THIS BILL TWENTY TWENTY TWO
ALLOWS THE AUDITOR TO CONSIDER
ANY PUBLICLY AVAILABLE
INFORMATION SO FOR EXAMPLE IF A
NEWSPAPER DID SOME INVESTIGATIVE
REPORTING AND PUBLISH AN ARTICLE.
THE I THAT IS INFORMATION THAT
WOULD BE ALLOWED TO BE USED
UNDER MY BILL BUT NOT UNDER
MISTER MERCHANT SHE'S BILL SO WE
STILL FEEL LIKE THIS IS --
AN IMPORTANT ISSUE AND AND
SHOULD MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT
INFORMATION BE ABLE TO USE UNDER
CENTER LARS BILL.
YEAH AT WORK A YES STATE THEY
WORK IN CONJUNCTION BUT WITH
EACH OTHER.
ALRIGHT.
ANY OTHER COMMENTS QUESTIONS.
I DO FOR YOU BOB THIS IS A GREAT
ABILITY DOES WORKING CONJUNCTION
AND YOUR BILL PROVIDES GREATER
TRANSPARENCY HANNAH AND
ACCOUNTABILITY BECAUSE ABOUT THE
AUDITOR WILL BE ABLE TO USE OUR
OUTSIDE SOURCES SO I THINK I
THINK IT'S GREAT BILL.
SO I'M GONNA BE SUPPORTING IT
NUMBER TO ADJUST WITH
CONGRATULATIONS ARE IN ORDER
THIS COMMITTEE TODAY'S HURT
HEARING THIRTY NINE BILLS IN
YOUR THE ONLY RUB REPUBLICAN ARE
AUTHOR WE'RE HEARING FROM TODAY
SO.
THAT'S LIKE A BADGE OF SHAME
THANK YOU SIR.
I'M I'M THROUGHOUT THE BODY YOU
WOULD YOU LIKE TO YOU SENATOR I
WITH WILK STATEMENT IS YOUR
CLOTHES AT PERHAPS NOT BUT I
THINK THIS IS.
I THINK THIS IS A BIPARTISAN
ISSUE THAT EVERYONE SHOULD
SUPPORT I RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED
AYE VOTE AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME
THAT YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENTATION.
I DO WANT TO TAKE UP VIRTUALLY
AT THIS TIME TO I INTRODUCED THE
NEWEST MEMBER --
OF OUR COMMITTEE AND IT SENATORS
WELCOME ABOARD.
GREAT GREAT TO HAVE YOU.
I REALLY LOVE THIS THIS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER QUIRK.
AB [inaudible]
TWENTY NINE FIFTY EIGHT GOV
[inaudible]
MR HELL [inaudible]
JUST SENIOR --
OR A THANK YOU SENATORS SAID
THANK YOU CHAIR --
THANK YOU SENATORS WILL WIENER
INHALE FOR BEING HERE.
MAYBE WE WERE NEVER COR AND ARE
NOW -- AB
TWENTY FIVE NINETY EIGHT WOULD
ALLOW ADVISORY COMMITTEES THAT
TO ME VIA TELECONFERENCE
PROVIDED THEY MEET CERTAIN
REQUIREMENTS THESE CONCLUDE
ADOPTING GUIDELINES POSTING ONE
PHYSICAL LOCATION.
WORK FORM WOULD BE PRESIDENT
INFORMATION AND HOW THE PUBLIC
CAN PARTICIPATE.
THE ADVISORY COMMITTEES ARE
MOSTLY COMPRISED OF ON FIVE
UNPAID VOLUNTEERS.
SPECIALIZED TECHNICAL EXPERTISE
XIN OF NO POLICY MAKING
AUTHORITY.
PROVIDE THE STATE A GREAT
SERVICE BY VOLUNTEERING THEIR
TIME AND SHARING TALENT.
THAT WOULD BE HARD TO FIND
ELSEWHERE IN EXPENSIVE TO HIRE.
ANY REPORTS A PRODUCER FORWARDED
TO THE RESPECTIVE STATE BODY.
THAT WILL DEBATE AND IMPLEMENT
POLICY IS NECESSARY.
BOB.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MY MEMBER BY
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION-[inaudible]
QUESTIONS.
I JUST HAVE A QUICK COMMENT.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S HAPPENING
YOU THIS YEAR WERE YOU YOU HAVE
A GREAT BILL PACKAGE SO I WANT I
WANT TO COMMEND YOU FOR YOUR
BILL PACKAGING YOU'RE DOING A
GREAT JOB.
WELL THANK YOU --
I WISH ALL SENATORS FELT THAT
WAY AT CLOSE A YES MY CLOTHES IS
THAT THE NEWSPAPERS --
DEDUCE ASSOCIATION HAS BEEN
OPPOSED WERE VERY CLOSE TO
RESOLVING THAT RIGHT NOW.
ARE THEY SUGGESTED ABOUT FIVE
CHANGES WHICH ACCEPTED FOR AND
WE'RE NEGOTIATING ON THE FIFTH.
I I HOPE THAT WE WILL LA HAVE%
THEIR RIDE THAT THEIR SUPPORT
WILL BE OFF.
BY THE TIME THIS REACHES THE
FLOOR THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER
THIS IT ENJOYS A TO PASS BUT
WHAT YOU'RE THINKING THIS
DOESN'T IS VAGUELY KEEN AND THE
BROWN ACT AS A SIMILAR.
RESTRICTIONS DOZEN --
THERE THE BAGLEY KEENE FOLKS
WERE TALKING ABOUT ARE STRICTLY
ADVISORY COMMITTEES BROWN ACT.
WELL LIKE ROUTINE ALSO YOU KNOW
TALKS ABOUT --
DECISION MAKING SAID IS THE
BROWN ACT.
WE'RE JUST BEING VERY SELECTIVE.
ON ADVISORY COMMITTEES BAGLEY
KEENE ONLY IN PART BECAUSE
ADVISORY COMMITTEE SAID THE
STATE LEVEL GET PEOPLE FROM ALL
OVER THE STATE.
AND ARE.
WELL WE ARE INSISTING ON A
QUORUM AT A LOCATION WHERE
ALLOWING PEOPLE FROM OTHER PARTS
OF THE STATE TO COME SUCH A VERY
SPECIALIZED BILL FOR SPECIALIZED
CONCERN.
DO THEY KNOW THIS IS SIMILAR
CONDITIONS AND AND STRUGGLES ARE
FACED WITH THROUGH THE BROWN
ACTON YEAH COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT
ARE TRAVELING AND HAVE TO NOTICE
THE MEETING AT THE HOTEL THAT
THEY'RE STAYING AT IN THE BUT
MAKE SURE QUITE DIFFICULT IN THE
BUT WE CAN WORK ON THAT.
TOGETHER NEXT YEAR SOUNDS LIKE A
GOOD IDEA THIS IS VERY GOOD OF
LOOKING FOR TO SUPPORT US THANK
YOU THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK.
MASON WERE WAITING FOR AN AUTHOR
[inaudible]
GOMEZ RECORDED [inaudible]
AB.
TWENTY I DON'T GET INTO
SENIORITY BATTLES.
OVER THERE.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN I
APPRECIATE THAT AYE GOOD MORNING
MEMBERS --
AB TWENTY EIGHT NINETY EIGHT
EXTENDS THE CITY'S --
EMERGENCY DECLARATION A NEW
REQUIREMENT FROM THIRTY TO SIXTY
DAYS I MUST EFFORT SOME IN BAY
PUT INFORMATION INTO THEM JUST
PUT YOU LIKE THIS.
WHEN I WAS ON THE CITY COUNCIL
PASTORS COUNCIL PRESIDENT WE
WOULD HAVE A SUMMER RECESS LIKE
WHAT WE HAVE HERE IN THE
LEGISLATURE?
BUT WE DON'T ALWAYS HAVE TO
CONVENE AT LEAST ONCE DURING
THAT PROCESS IN ORDER TO RENEW
THESE DECORATIONS THE COMMANDED
BY THE STATE.
DOING THAT COST THOUSANDS OF
DOLLARS TO COMPLETELY
UNNECESSARY BECAUSE WE KNOW THAT
WOULD EXTEND IT.
BUT THE CONVENING OF THAT
MEETING THE PUBLIC NOTICING THE
PAIN OF STAFF THE TRANSMITTER ON
THE BROADCASTING TO THE PUBLIC.
CAME WITH SUBSTANTIAL EXPENSE TO
SIMPLY EXTEND THESE THINGS BY
ALLOWING SIXTY DAYS WE DON'T
HAVE TO DO THAT THAT'S TRUE
ACROSS STATE CALIFORNIA.
IS RESULT IN GOVERNMENT
EFFICIENCY AND SAVINGS FOR
TAXPAYERS I ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE.
THEY GRAB I WON WITH THE STATE'S
CHRISTY WOODS DIRECTOR OF THE
CALIFORNIA STATE COME RELATIONS.
FOR THEIR OF THE RED CROSS
[inaudible]
A SEAT [inaudible]
LIKE [inaudible]
THE PUSH A BUTTON --
SO THE AMERICAN RED CROSS IS
FULLY INTEGRATED WITH GOVERNMENT
IN PREPARING RESPONDING
RECOVERING FROM DISASTERS.
MANAGING DISASTERS IN
EMERGENCIES OF ALL SIZES ARE
COMPLICATED AND A LARGE RESPONSE
CAN BE QUITE LENGTHY.
THERE ARE MANY RESPONSIBILITIES
AND CHALLENGES IN THE MANAGEMENT
OF INCIDENT RESPONSE BUT
WORKFORCE TOOLS AND EQUIPMENT
MANY PARTNER OF MANY PRTNERS
ARE WOVEN TOGETHER THROUGHOUT
THE RESPONSE.
THIS BILL WOULD GIVE MORE
FLEXIBILITY TO GOVERNING --
BODIES THAT ARE MANAGED IN A
FAST PACED THE COMPLICATED
RESPONSE THE RED CROSS
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
SUPPORT OF AB.
TWENTY EIGHT NINETY EIGHT THANK
YOU OTHER WITNESSES.
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
MEMBERS.
I THINK IT'S GREAT BILL IT'S GOT
A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION ON IT --
BUT WE HAVE TO WAIT TO WE HAVE A
QUORUM TO VOTE ON IT SOUTH WHICH
I CLOSE RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE BUT THINK IT'S TREASURER
MUCH ASSEMBLY MEMBER GLORIA.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COLDER ON WE
DON'T.
YEAH FOR AMERICAN YET YOU KNOW
I'M SORRY --
SAID ASSEMBLYMEMBER I DIDN'T SEE --
SEVEN MEMBER BERMAN WHO SIDE DID
AHEAD OF YOU.
YOU'RE THE THE WHOLE TIME THAT --
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GLORIA WHETHER
IT'S IT'S ONLY BECAUSE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CALDERON KEPT ON ALMOST
HITTING ME IN BATTING PRACTICE
LAST NIGHT.
BUT I WILL HAPPILY TAKE THIS
OPPORTUNITY.
MRS STERN SENATORS CALIFORNIA
BRADY WHOLESALERS IN DISTILLED
SPIRITS WHOLESALERS ARE
CURRENTLY REQUIRED TO MEET
MAINTAIN CERTAIN QUALIFICATIONS
RELATED TO THE QUANTITY STORAGE
AND OWNERSHIP OF INVENTORY.
HOWEVER THIS IS NOT THE CASE FOR
BEER WHOLESALE WHOLESALERS THIS
BILL WILL BRING PARITY TO
CALIFORNIA LAW BY SETTING FORTH
QUALIFICATIONS FOR A BEER
WHOLESALER THAT ARE CONSISTENT
WITH QUALIFICATIONS FOR BRANDON
DISTILLED SPIRITS WHOLESALERS.
I'LL BE TAKING THE AMENDMENTS AS
OUTLINED IN THE COMMITTEE
ANALYSIS WITH ME TODAY IS DENNIS
LOW OVER REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA BARRON BEVERAGE
DISTRIBUTORS AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AYE VOTE ON THE BE.
TWENTY FOUR SIXTEEN NINE THANK
YOU.
SHERMAN DOES ORDER A PRISON IN
CALIFORNIA BEER BEVERAGE ST
PETER'S HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
MEMBERS.
WE OF COURSE.
I MEAN IT ONE MORE.
STILL NEED ONE MORE. OH OKAY --
WERE WAITING ON A QUORUM WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE RESPECT
ESCRIBIR WHEN THE TIME IS RIGHT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU
[inaudible]
HE CONCERT.
BUT WAIT TO SEE IF SOMEONE'S
GONNA COME AND RIP IT UP HAVE ON
AT SIMILAR MARRIAGE JUST WALKING
IN THE DOOR RIGHT NOW. SEVEN
MEMBER CALDERON WELCOME THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
AND AS A COMPLEX ENGINEERING
TECHNOLOGY IT IS IMPORTANT FULLY
UNDERSTAND THE LEGAL
IMPLICATIONS AND THE POTENTIAL
CONSEQUENCES OF STATE LOCAL
REGULATION A BLOCKCHAIN.
AB TWENTY SIX FIFTY EIGHT WILL
SALAS WORKING FOR TO THE
LEGISLATURE ON POTENTIAL USES
RISKS AND BENEFITS OF THE USE A
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY BY STATE
GOVERNMENT AND CALIFORNIA BASED
BUSINESSES.
THE WORKING GROUP WILL ALSO
RECOMMEND AMENDMENTS TO CODE
SECTIONS IN ORDER TO FOSTER
INNOVATION.
IN CALIFORNIA WITH THE
BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY THEY CAN I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
NAY YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER --
IN THE WITNESS IS IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WOULDN'T.
ONE IT'S CHAIR MEMBERS CHAD
WOULD ASSUME YOU WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CREDIT UNION LEAGUE
IN SUPPORT.
A WITNESS IS OPPOSITION.
CAN YOU --
DEFINED FOR ME BLOCKCHAIN YEAH I
WITHOUT LOOKING YOUR NOTES THE
DIGITAL LEDGER.
AND SO IT'S IT'S A MEANS BY
WHICH YOU CAN YOU KNOW IT IT'S
SO IF YOU HAVE EMAIL AND THE
INTERNET --
BLOCKCHAIN WOULD BE THE INTERNET
WERE EMAIL WOULD BE THE CRYPTO
CURRENCY.
WELL THIS WILL HAVE A A DO PASS
RECOMMENDATION THAT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
I SO WERE WAY TOO WE HAVE THAT --
WAS AT YOU BECAUSE MY CLASS AND
I VOTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH SEMI
MEMBER.
NUMBER IS A CHIU HOURS A YEAR A
YOUR CAREER CHAU.
WHICH WAS FIRST.
THE BATTERY.
IS [inaudible]
JOSH STEINER.
YES SANTA MARIA ASSEMBLYMEMBER
AGUIAR-CURRY AB TWENTY FOUR
FIFTY TWO WELCOME.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND A
MEMBERS AB TWENTY FOUR FIFTY TWO
UPDATES TIED HOUSE LAW TO
ACCOMMODATE FOR WIDESPREAD.
USE OF SOCIAL MEDIA TODAY.
THIS BILL WILL A WOULD ALLOW A
PICTURE OF AN EVENT SPACE OR
RESTAURANT TO BE INCLUDED IN THE
SOCIAL MEDIA.
HOST WITH THE INFORMATION ABOUT
IN THE UPCOMING INSTRUCTIONAL
EVENT LIKE A WINEMAKERS DINNER
OR SPIRITS TASTING.
IT WOULD ALSO ALLOW FOR AN EMAIL
ADDRESS AND WEBSITE TO BE
INCLUDED.
UNDER CURRENT LAW THIS IS
PROHIBITED AND QUITE SURPRISING.
POSTING A PICTURE WITH TEXT IS A
MUCH MORE DESCRIPTIVE AN EYE
CATCHING WAY FOR LICENSEES TO
PROMOTE EVENTS FOR THEIR OWN
PRODUCTS.
WHEN THERE ARE LIMITATION THE
TAKES AWAY FROM THE INDUSTRY'S
ABILITY TO SOCIAL MEDIA AS A
RESOURCE?
I ASK FOR YOUR VOTE AND I HAVE
MISSED RELIGION PRIVILEGE ON
BEHALF OF THE NAPA VALLEY
VINTNERS I'M.
THINKING THAT CHAIR FOR HIS CO
AUTHORSHIP OF THE BILL IN ONE
SPORT.
THANK YOU MISS LEADS ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
MELISSA WARNER ON BEHALF OF THE
FAMILY MY MAKERS OF CALIFORNIA
ALSO IN SUPPORT THINK YOU.
CHRIS WALKER CALIFORNICA UPPERS
ASSOCIATION SPORT.
ME WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE WE DO NOT DO NOT
HAVE A QUORUM YET SO WILL BE
VOTING THAT WE GET TE QUORUM.
I WOULD LIKE TO A CLOSE.
SO FOR THAT'S WHAT I WROTE GOOD
BILL.
WE'LL HAVE AN IRAQ OF THINKING
[inaudible]
BILL.
YEAH THAT'S A NO [inaudible]
HIT [inaudible]
WE
PHILIP BILLABLE HOUR CLOCK
.
I REALIZE THAT
[inaudible]
AND APB [inaudible]
TWENTY ONE TWENTY FOUR GOOD
WRITING.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN WAS
OF THE COMMITTEE ON BEHALF OF
THE LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS
ASSEMBLY WOMAN BAKER AND I WOULD
LIKE TO PRESENT ONE OF OUR
CAUCUS PARROTBILLS AB.
TWENTY ONE TWENTY FOUR AB TWENTY
ONE TWENTY FOUR WILL REQUIRE THE
SERVICES CONTINGENT UPON FUNDING
IN THE STATE BUDGET.
TOWARD FUNDS UP TO ELEVEN DA
OFFICE SAYS THAT EMPLOY VERTICAL
PROSECUTION PROGRAMS FOR THE
PROSECUTION OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING
CRIMES.
VERTICAL PROSECUTION TEAMS ARE
THE MOST EFFECTIVE IN
PROSECUTING HUMAN TRAFFICKING.
VERTICAL PROSECUTION UNITS
INVOLVED ONE OF THE MOST ONE OR
MORE STAFF ATTORNEYS WHO HANDLE
A SPECIFIC TYPE OF CASE. FOR
AGREEMENT TO CONVICTION.
ARE RATHER THAN A DIFFERENT
ATTORNEYS HANDLING DIFFERENT
STAGES OF THE PROSECUTION IN
ORDER TO RECEIVE AN AWARD.
OF GRANT FUNDING UNDER THIS BILL
A PROSECUTING OFFICER MUST HAVES --
SPECIFIED STAFFING DEDICATED FOR
HUMAN TRAFFICKING VERTICAL
PROSECUTION PROVIDE ANNUAL DATA
ON THE NUMBER OF CASES FILED BY
THE COUNTY AND THEIR OUTCOMES.
AND HAVE A MEMORANDUM OF
UNDERSTANDING WITH AN ADVOCACY
AGENCY TO THAT PROVIDE
COUNSELING AND OR SERVICES TO
VICTIMS.
AS ARE AS WE ALL KNOW HUMAN
TRAFFICKING IS A HUGE PROBLEM IN
CALIFORNIA WITH APPROXIMATELY
1-400-021-7000 VICTIMS --
WHERE --
FOURTEEN THOUSAND THE VICTIMS
ARE TRAFFIC IT INTO THE UNITED
STATES ANNUALLY BETWEEN TWENTY
TENANTS WHEN TWELVE CALIFORNIA'S
NINE REGIONAL HUMAN TRAFFICKING
TASK FORCES IDENTIFIED ONE
THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED AND SEVENTY
SEVEN VICTIMS.
IN NATION INITIATED TWO THOUSAND
FIVE HUNDRED AND FIFTY TWO
INVESTIGATIONS ARRESTED ONE
THOUSAND SEVEN HUNDRED AND
NINETY EIGHT INDIVIDUALS AND
PROVIDED CRITICAL TRAINING TO
MORE THAN TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND
LAW ENFORCEMENT.
PERSONNEL PROSECUTORS VICTIM
SERVICE PROVIDERS AND FIRST
RESPONDERS IT IS MY HOPE.
THAT MORE SUCCESSFUL ARREST AND
PROSECUTION OF HUMAN TRAFFICKERS
WILL SERVE AS A DETERRENT AND
REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF HUMAN
TRAFFICKING OCCURRING IN OUR
STATE.
THANK YOU AND WITH ME TODAY I OF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER --
BAKER WHO HAS BEEN INSTRUMENTAL
IN OUR FIGHTING FOR THIS BILL
AND I WITHOUT THE COMMITMENT.
THANK YOU I'M ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RUBIO THANK YOU AND MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS I JUST.
WOULD LIKE TO UNDERSCORE THAT
VERTICAL PROSECUTON IS A VICTIM
CENTRIC FORM OF PROSECUTION AND
WHAT IS BECOMING THE WITH THE
FBI HAS FOUND BE THE FASTEST
GROWING CRIMINAL ENTERPRISE
UNITED STATES THAT'S HUMAN
TRAFFICKING THERE'S A CONTINUUM
OF EFFORTS THAT WE CAN UNDERTAKE
TO FIGHT HUMAN TRAFFICKING.
PREVENTION CATCHING THE
CRIMINALS WHO ARE DOING IT AND
THEN PROSECUTING THEM FULLY
RIGHT NOW BECAUSE THE CASES ARE
SO COMPLEX --
OFTEN THE DA OFFICES DON'T HAVE
THE RESOURCES TO PROSECUTE THEM
AS NECESSARY --
THE VICTIMS ARE OFTEN --
NOT COOPERATIVE AT FIRST BECAUSE
THEY MIGHT GET A DIFFERENT DE A
AT EVERY SINGLE STAGE OF THE
PROCESS IT'S ALMOST LIKE A OF
SPOUSAL ABUSE AND DRUMS THAT ARE
FOUND OUT THERE THE ONLY PERSON
THE MOST RECENTLY WERE ABLE TO
COOPERATE WITH WAS THE
TRAFFICKER.
AND SO THIS ALLOWS THE VICTIM
WHEN THEY CALL TO FIND OUT ABOUT
THE CASE WHEN THEY'RE DEALING
WITH A DIFFERENT STAGE
PROSECUTION HAVE ONE PERSON WITH
HIM THEY CONNECTED.
AND HE PROSECUTORS GET GOOD AT
THE BECAUSE THEY'RE ABLE TO
SPECIALIZE IN THEM WHAT THIS
MEANS IS WE SEE OUTCOMES WHERE
SOMEONE WHO'S COMMITTED.
HUMAN TRAFFICKING IS FULLY
PROSECUTED INSTEAD OF SEEING A
PLEA DOWN TO PEMBINA
PROSTITUTION OR PERHAPS NOT
PROSECUTED ALL AND THAT'S WHY
THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT PART
NOT ONLY FOR THE LEGISLATIVE
WOMEN'S CAUCUS BUT THINK FOR THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN FIGHTING
HUMAN TRAFFICKING.
AND OF RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE I THINK TODAY WE HAVE A
COUPLE WITNESSES AARON DE
FERRARI FROM THE CONTRA COSTA
COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S
OFFICE.
AND THEM ALSO DON KOPECKY FROM
CRIME VICTIMS UNITED IF THEY'VE
MADE IT HERE.
COME FOR POLICE.
PARITY FERRARI ON BEHALF OF OF
THE PROSECUTORS ASSOCIATION IN
CONTRA COSTA COUNTY I WAS A
CRIMINAL HAVE BEEN A CRIMINAL
PROSECUTOR FOR FOURTEEN YEARS
ONE OF MY ASSIGNMENTS WAS
PROSECUTING HUMAN TRAFFICKERS.
AND I'D LIKE TO THANK THE CHAIR
AND THE COMMITTEE FOR HEARING US
OUT I CAN TELL YOU THAT HAVING
PROSECUTED.
DOZENS OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING
CASES HAVING ONE PROSECUTOR
ASSIGNED TO THE CASES FROM THE
TIME THEY'RE FILED ALL THE WAY
TO THE TIME OF CONVICTION IS
CRITICAL.
IN ASSURING.
ACCESS IN HUMAN TRAFFICKING
PROSECUTIONS.
THANK YOU VERY MCH ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
MEMBERS [inaudible]
COMMENTS.
I THINK IT'S A GREAT BILL IT'S
GOT A LOT DO PASS RECOMMENDATION
AS SOON AS WE GET A QUORUM WILL
BE VOTING ON IT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH WHICH I CLOSE.
THANK YOU WE RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH APPRECIATE YOUR TEST.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER KALRA
[inaudible]
AB.
NINETEEN EXCUSE ME AB TWO
THOUSAND GRAY NUMBER LIKE THAT I
DO [inaudible]
LITTLE THINGS.
CLICK THE VICTIMS SHARON
SENATORS OF THE OPPORTUNITY
PRESENT AB TWO THOUSAND A BILL
THAT WOULD ADD TIED HOUSE
EXCEPTIONS FOR PROFESSIONAL
STADIUMS THAT FOUND THE GIANTS
AND OF HOUSING EARTHQUAKES.
ADDITIONALLY THE BILL WOULD
REVISE AN EXISTING TITLES
EXCEPTION FOR THE ESCAPEES
CENTER HOME TO THE SAN JOSE
SHARKS.
THESE ADDITIONS ARE CHANGE AND
CHANGE WILL PROVIDE THREE
PROFESSIONAL SPORTS TEAMS IN SAN
JOSE.
ON PAR WITH OTHER SIMILAR
PROFESSIONALSPORTS ARENAS AND
STADIUMS IN CALIFORNIA THEREBY
ALLOWING OWNERSHIP.
GROUP OF OWNERSHIP TEAMS THE
LEGAL OWNERSHIP OF THE TEAMS
ILLEGAL CERTAINLY TO EXPLORE AND
DEVELOP ALCOHOL BEVERAGE
SPONSORSHIPS THAT ARE COMMON
AMONG FASHION SPORTS TEAMS AND
CONSISTENT WITH THEM WHAT OTHER
AT ARENAS STADIUMS DAMP.
I HAVE WITH ME IN SUPPORT OF AB
TWO THOUSAND AND TWO GOVERNOR ON
BEHALF THAT SOUNDS A GIANTS AND
RICHARD COSTS IN ON BEHALF OF
THIS HOUSE A SHARKS [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
ENTER GOVERNOR BEHALF THE SAN
JOSE GIANTS IN THE EARTHQUAKES
IN SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING RICHARD CASTING ON
BEHALF OF THE SAN JOSE SHARKS
ALSO IN SUPPORT.
S. ANY OTHER WITNESSES SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
MEMBERS.
HE GONNA FIX THE A TIGHT HAS.
RULE ONE OF WHAT GOD I'M GLAD
IT'S BROUGHT THAT UP MISTER
CHAIR THAT SIDE.
WHODUNIT COULD GET TWO WEEKS I
DO THIS OUT EVERYONE OF THESE --
ASSEMBLY MEMBER YOU SEEN IN YOUR
AREA IN THE ANALYSIS.
WE CONTINUE TO DO THIS OVER AND
OVER AGAIN AT SOME POINT IN TIME
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO US --
WOULD WE WE JUST GOT TO START
LOOKING AT IT NOW ANOTHER WAY
I'LL BE SUPPORTING YOUR BILL THE
DAY READ BUT I THINK WE'VE JUST
GOT TO MAKE SURE THAT --
WE START WORKING ON THIS FOR IT
FOR NEXT YEAR.
I GRIMACE SHARE.
GREAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANKS TO WITNESSES.
IS IT MURATSUCHI IRWIN.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MURATSUCHI.
AB.
TWENTY SEVEN TWENTY NINE WELCOME
ADDED MISTER CHAIRMAN
[inaudible]
SENATORS.
I'M HERE TO PRESENTE AB --
TWENTY SEVEN TWENTY NINE THIS IS
A BILL THAT --
SIX TO CLARIFY THE STATE
AUDITOR'S TO A HIGH RISK AUDIT
PROGRAM.
AS CHAIR OF THE JOINT
LEGISLATIVE AUDIT COMMITTEE --
I BECAME A PRICE OF AN ISSUE
WITH THE CURRENT PROGRAM --
AS WAS REYES THROUGH A WRITTEN
LEGAL OPINION FROM THE
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL'S OFFICE --
INDICATING THAT UNDER EXISTING
LAW THE STATE AUDITOR DOES NOT
HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO CONDUCT.
THE TYPE OF INVESTIGATIONS THAT
THEY HAPPEN CONDUCTING UNDER THE
LOCAL HIGH RISK ON A PROGRAM IN
TERMS OF INFORMATION GATHERING
AND SO -- I
INTRODUCED THIS BILL GOT TO
CLARIFY THAT PROCESS --
A PARTICULARLY THE THE INITIAL
ASSESSMENT PROCESS THAT LEADS TO
THE AUDIT FOR THE LOCAL HIGH
RISK --
EITHER PROGRAM.
I'VE BEEN IN CONVERSATIONS WITH
A CENTER LARA.
WHO IS THE ORIGINAL --
AUTHOR OF THIS PROGRAM.
AND WE HAVE REACHED AN AGREEMENT
I BELIEVE.
I IN TERMS OF US --
MAKING SURE THAT --
WE CAN HAVE A EFFECTIVE BEEN
FUNCTIONING LOCAL HARRIS GOT A
PROGRAM --
WELL.
SHARING DATA WE HAVE A STRONG
AND ROBUST --
A PROGRAM TO HOLD OUR LOCAL
AGENCIES ACCOUNTABLE BE HAPPEN
AT ANSWERING QUESTIONS.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
CHAIR MEMBERS A COMMITTEE DEAL
GIVEN CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION RECCHIA
REMOVING OUR OPPOSITION TO SPILL
ALONG WITH THE LEAGUE CALIFORNIA
CITIES AND THE ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA HEALTHCARE DISTRICTS --
ONE I TINK THE THE THE AUTHOR
FOR WORKING WITH US ON THIS BILL --
THE HIGH RISK LOCAL AGENCY OUT
OF PROGRAMS PROGRAM THAT IS
WORKING.
AND BECAUSE OF THE LEGISLATIVE.
COUNSEL'S OPINION A LEGISLATION
IS NEEDED IN ORDER --
TO HAVE THEIR EFFORTS CONTINUE --
SO WE CAN HOLD OUR LOCAL
AGENCIES A AND IT SURE THAT THEY
ARE --
UPHOLDING THE PUBLIC'S TRUST.
AND SO WITH THE MEMONS --
ARE ASSOCIATIONS WHO ARE
REMOVING OUR OPPOSITION.
THANK YOU ANY OTHER.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT WITNESSES
OPPOSITION.
SCENE TURN BACK TO COMMITTEE.
SENATOR CANNELLA THINKING
SHERMAN SO FAR YOURSELF AND
RICARDO LARA CAME TO AGREEMENT
THAT WILL VOTE FOR LARA'S BILL
JUST FEW MONTHS AGO.
SO BUT OUT OF ALL THIS BUT I DID
SUED IS.
THE DEAL YOU'VE REACHED IS THAT
IN THE AMENDMENTS.
I BELIEVE --
BUT CAN YOU EXPLAIN TO CAN YOU
DESCRIBE WHAT THE DEAL IS THAT
YOU CAME TO SINCE.
NO TWO MAIN POINTS ONE IS THAT --
THE J. LACK COMMITTEE WILL BE
RECEIVING NOTICE OF A PENDING --
INVESTIGATION OF A LOCAL AGENCY
[inaudible]
AND TO THAT --
THAT WERE CLARIFYING WHAT
INFORMATION.
THE STATE AUDITOR CAN ACCESS
PRIOR -- TO
SUBMITTING AN AUDIT REQUEST
THROUGH THE JOINT LEGISLATIVE
AUDIT COMMITTEE.
OKAY SO THOUGH SO THOSE REFLECT
IN THE AMENDMENTS OR IS THAT
GONNA BE HANDLED.
THAT IS A KIND OF THAT IS NOT AS
OF YET AND CENTER LAWRENCEVILLE
THE THAT THE PLAN IS. FOR FOR
CENTER LARA TO ADOPT --
THE LANGUAGE IN MY BILL AND AND
I'LL BE DROPPING [inaudible]
OKAY.
OKAY WITH THAT UNDERSTANDING
I'LL BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
TODAY WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM YET
THAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
SPECTER ASKED QUIETLY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH APPRECIATED THANK YOU.
NEXT UP ASSEMBLY MEMBER IRWIN.
AB [inaudible]
TWENTY THIRTEEN WELCOME.
THANK YOU SENATOR DODD AND
SENATORS --
I AM HERE TO PRESENT AB TWENTY
EIGHT THIRTEEN WHICH WOULD
CODIFY VERBATIM THE GOVERNOR'S
EXECUTIVE ORDER THAT CREATED THE
CALIFORNIA CYBERSECURITY
INTEGRATION CENTER THIS BILL IS
INTENDED TO GIVE THE GOVERNOR
ANOTHER CHANCE TO EVALUATE HIS
VISION. FOR THE CALYCES SICK
BEFORE HE LEAVES OFFICE
CYBERSECURITY UNFORTUNATELY WILL
BE A CONTINUING THREAT FACTOR
FOR CALIFORNIA JUST AS MENACING
AS FIRES EARTHQUAKES AND FLOODS.
OUR STATE DESERVES A PERMANENT
SOLUTION TO MEET THAT THREAT AND
AB TWENTY EIGHT THIRTEEN CAN
PROVIDE THAT CERTAINTY TO
CALIFORNIA.
SPEC WE ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU ARE ANY MEMBER
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
WITNESSES OPPOSITION MEMBERS.
BUT I THINK THE GRAY BILL SOON
IS THAT WE GET A QUORUM WILL
MOVE IT AND VOTE ON THANK YOU
SALLY MEMBER.
GOT THREE KIDS CHIP
ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CHAD COME ON DOWN.
AB.
TWENTY SEVEN FORTY EIGHT I HAVE
ANOTHER ONE HERE A. B.. THIRTY
ONE NINETY THREE DEVELOP BUSY
MORNING ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
CONGRADULATIONS.
MISTER CHAIR AND SENATORS OUT AB
TWENTY SEVEN FORTY EIGHT WILL
ESTABLISH A VOLUNTARY PILOT
PROGRAM. FOR UP TO FIVE COUNTY
ELECTION OUT OF OFFICIALS TO
HAVE AN INDEPENDENT
CYBERSECURITY ASSESSMENT.
OF THEIR ELECTION OF THEIR
ELECTION INFRASTRUCTURE
ACCESSIBLE THROUGH THE INTERNET.
IN THE YEAR TWENTY FIFTEEN
GOVERNOR JERRY BROWN SIGNED AN
EXECUTIVE ORDER TO ESTABLISH TO
CALIFORNIA CYBERSECURITY.
IMMIGRATION CENTER TO ADDRESS
CYBER INCIDENTS IN CALIFORNIA IT
INCLUDES AGENCIES LIKE THE
OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES O.
E. S..
THE DEPARTMENT OF TECHNOLOGY CDT
AND THE MILITARY DEPARTMENTS C.
M. D..
IN TWENTY FIFTEEN CALIFORNIA
ENACTED A. B. SIX SEVENTY TWO
REQUIRED THESE AGENCIES TO
ANNUALLY CONDUCT INDEPENDENT
SECURITY ASSESSMENTS OF THIRTY
FIVE STATE AGENCIES AND
DEPARTMENTS.
AB TWENTY SEVEN FORTY EIGHT IS
AN EFFORT TO TAKE WHAT WE HAVE
LEARNED BY PULLING OUT STATES
RESOURCES AND APPLIED THE THESE
RESOURCES IN CRITICAL AREAS
INCLUDING ELECTIONS.
IT DOES SO BY ESTABLISHING A
PILOT PROGRAM TO PERFORM
SECURITY ASSESSMENTS WHICH ARE
SIMILAR TO A. B. SIX SEVENTY OF
OUR ELECTION INFRASTRUCTURE IN
PARTICIPATING COUNTIES ALL OF
THE RESULTS ARE CONFIDENTIAL AND
NOT THIS CLOSE BOTH TO THE
PUBLIC.
ARE WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENT A MEMBER
WITNESSES SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
WELL.
WHAT WOULD KNOW WHICH WENT
WINNER?
RIGHT BETWEEN ELEVATION IF I GOT
UP ON THE YOU'LL BE COMFORTED IN
KNOWING YOU'RE NOT THE FIRST
ONCE TODAY THAT HAVE DONE THAT.
THEIR ACTIONS THIS IS ONE NO
THIS IS THE KEYWORD AB TWENTY
SEVEN FORTY EIGHT ANY WITNESSES
IN OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
SEEING NONE IN THE MEMBERS
QUESTIONS.
NO IT'S GOOD BILL.
HILL BACK HAS A DO PASS
RECOMMENDATION AS SOON AS WE GET
WARM THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBERS
WHICH I TO CLOSE AYE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU.
NOW.
319-3 I THANK YOU AGAIN MR AND
NOT SENATORS.
A. B. THIRTY ONE NINETY THREE
ADDRESSES AN ISSUE THAT WAS
BROUGHT UP IN A JOINT OVERSIGHT
HEARING ON CYBERSECURITY IN
FEBRUARY.
THIS BILL SEEKS TO ENSURE THAT
THE OFFICE OF INFORMATION
SECURITY OR ALLY S. WITHIN CDT
OBTAIN A COMPLETE PICTURE OF THE
INFORMATION SECURITY IN THE
EXECUTIVE BRANCH.
CURRENTLY THE LEGISLATURE HAS
CHARGED Y. S. WITH DUTIES OVER
STATE AGENCIES IN THE EXECUTIVE
BRANCH IN ONE PART OF THAT
STATUE.
OF BUT IN THE NEXT STEP PART OF
THE SAME STATUE ONLY CERTAIN
STATE ENTITIES THAT DIRECTLY
REPORT TO THE GOVERNOR ARE
REQUIRED TO COMPLY WITH THE
WHOLE I S. ISSUE STANDARDS AND
POLICIES.
ON SO AS YOU KNOW THERE'S SO INS
INCONSISTENCIES IN AND OUT
DISCREPANCIES A. B. THIRTY ONE
NINETY THREE REMOVES ANY
AMBIGUITY IN THE LAW AND CLEARLY
STATES AT ALL STATE AGENCIES
MUST COMPLY.
WITH ALL WHY S. ISSUE
INFORMATION SECURITY
REQUIREMENTS A WITHOUT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOU AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SO A MEMBER --
WITNESSES SUPPORT [inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
SENATORS OF THE COMMITTEE MY
NAME IS VERONICA GEORGE AND I'M
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCATE WITH THE
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL.
ON BEHALF OF THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S OFFICE I AM HERE TODAY
TO EXPRESS OUR OPPOSITION TO AB.
THIRTY ONE NINETY THREE AND THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE'S STRONG
CONCERNS WITH THIS BILL WHILE WE
SUPPORT THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
GOAL OF IMPROVING IN
STANDARDIZING INFORMATION
SECURITY ACROSS STATE GOVERNMENT.
I WANT TO BE SURE THAT THE
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE
UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY'RE VOTING
FOR IT TODAY --
THIS IS NOT A SIMPLE
CYBERSECURITY STANDARDIZATION
BELL PALM THE BILL NOW PUTS
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES LIKE DOJ
UNDER THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT
TECHNOLOGIES.
AUTHORITY.
ARE THE AMENDMENT TO GOVERNMENT
CODE SECTION ONE ONE FIVE FOUR
NINE POINT THREE BE WHILE
SEEMINGLY SMALL.
MARKS THE SUBSTANTIVE CHANGE TO
DOJ'S INFORMATION SECURITY
POLICIES PROCEDURES AND
PRACTICES.
THIS CHANGE WILL HAVE SERIOUS
RAMIFICATIONS. FOR DO DAY AND
THE CONFIDENTIAL DATA OF
CALIFORNIANS HAVE PART OF TO
PRIVATE CALIFORNIA CITIZENS
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TENS OF
MILLIONS OF RECORDS.
OF CALIFORNIANS CRIMINAL HISTORY
PATIENT MEDICAL INFORMATION AS
WELL AS HIGHLY SENSITIVE
INFORMATION ON DOJ'S
CONFIDENTIAL AND FIGURE.
INVESTIGATIONS AND LITIGATION.
IN ORDER TO SAFEGUARD THIS
HIGHLY SENSITIVE INFORMATION
DOJ'S INFORMATION SECURITY
STANDARDS AND PRACTICES ALREADY
MUST ADHERE TO SPECIALIZED.
STRINGENT AND A SECURITY
MEASURES REQUIRED NOT ONLY BY
STATE LAW BY THAT BUT ALSO BY
THE FEDERAL BUREAU OF
INVESTIGATION STANDARDS AS WELL.
THIS BILL PLACES DOJ'S PRACTICES
AND PROCEDURES AT RISK AND
CONSEQUENTLY THE DATA.
OF MANY CALIFORNIANS AT RISK AS
WELL.
SINCE OUR TESTIMONY BEFORE THE
ASSEMBLY ON APRIL SEVENTEENTH WE
HAVE MET WITH THE AUTHORS OFFICE
COMPOSED QUESTIONS THAT HAVE NOT
YET BEEN ADEQUATELY ANSWER.
WE URGE THE COMMITTEE TO
CONSIDER THE AND ASK THE SAME
QUESTIONS TODAY SOME OF THEM ARE
UNDER AB THIRTY ONE NINETY THREE
CITIES HE WILL BE LEADING AND
REPRESENTING DOJ.
IN INFORMATION SECURITY AND DATA
SHARING MATTERS PERTAINING TO
CRIMINAL JUSTICE DATA INCLUDING
FEDERAL AGENCIES HOW WILL CD DE
WORK.
REPRESENT THE STATE ON THESE
FEDERAL ADVISORY GROUPS WHEN
THEY ARE NOT THE CRIMINAL
JUSTICE AGENCY THEMSELVES AS
REQUIRED BY THE FBI.
OR WITHOUT ANY STATE OR
BACKGROUND IN THE CRIMINAL
JUSTICE COMMUNITY.
IN ORDER TO IT HERE TO THE
SPECIALIZED AND STRINGENT
SECURITY MEASURES AS A CONDITION
OF EMPLOYMENT ALL DOJ EMPLOYEES.
THAT HAVE ACCESS TO SECURITY
RELATED DATA MUST FIRST UNDERGO
THE PEACE OFFICER STANDARDS AND
TRAINING BACKGROUND
INVESTIGATION AND PERSONAL
SCREENING.
HOW WILL CDT EMPLOYEES MEET THAT
STANDARD?
HOW OF DOJ CONTINUE TO REMAIN
IMPARTIAL INVESTIGATORY AND
PROSECUTORIAL MATTERS IF DOJ IT
NO LONGER HAS THE TIME TO ME AND
SEPARATION FROM OTHER STATE
GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND OFFICERS?
UNDER THIRTY ONE NINETY THREE
CDT WILL HAVE THE DISCRETION OF
CREATING ISSUING AND MAINTAINING
POLICIES STANDARDS AND
PROCEDURES.
THAT DIRECT STATE AGENCIES OUGHT
TO MANAGE SECURITY AND RESTS
THIS PRETTY MUCH INCLUDES ALL
TECHNOLOGY AND INFRASTRUCTURE
WILL CDTV ABLE TO NOW FORCE THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL AND ELECT A
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICER.
HOW TO PRIORITIZE ITS I HIT?
DOJ'S OPERATIONS BASED ON CDC'S
REQUIREMENTS AND PREFERENCES.
CTT I I'D A DOJ ALSO UNDER
ALREADY UNDER GOES FBI AUDITS
EVERY THREE YEARS AS WELL AS
MANY OTHER INTERNAL AND
INDEPENDENT AUDITS.
WHAT IS THE VALUE ADDED TO
CALIFORNIA CITIZENS BY ANOTHER
CDT AUDIT?
I HAVE FINALLY CONCEDED TO
DIRECT DOJ SECURITY TECHNOLOGY
TOOLS AND PROCUREMENT DECISIONS
AND REQUIRED DO YOU DATE UCT
TECHNOLOGY SERVICES.
AND DISALLOW CURRENT DOJ
TECHNOLOGY TO TO SEE THE TIP
REFERENCE.
I URGE THE COMMITTEE AGAIN TO
CONSIDER AND ASK THE SAME
QUESTIONS OB I WOULD ALSO LIKE
TO ECHO THE CONSTITUTIONAL
CONCERNS RAISED BY MY COLLEAGUES.
THE SECRETARY OF STATE OFFICE
AND THE SECRETARY IN STATE
COMPTROLLER'S OFFICE WE THANK
YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND YOUR
CONSIDERATION.
WE WILL HAVE I'M AN OFFICIAL
LETTER CLUB FORTHCOMING SHORTLY.
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
MORNING MR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS
MY NAME IS TODD BUILT A SON THE
CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICER FOR
THE CITY COMPTROLLER'S OFFICE.
AND I'M HERE TO REPRESENT STATE
CONTROLLER BETTY WHO IS ALSO IN
OPPOSITION OF AB --
THIRTY ONE NINETY THREE WE ECHO
MANY OF THE STATE WELL IT'S
RECOGNIZING THAT FOR THE STATE
COMPTROLLER'S OFFICE
SPECIFICALLY ONE OF OUR RULES IS --
PRODUCING A AUDITS AND AS MANY
OF THOSE AUDITS ARE IF TIED TO
AGENCIES AND DEPARTMENTS UNDER
THE GOVERNOR'S ADMINISTRATION SO
WE BELIEVE THIS CREATES A
CONFLICT OF INTEREST.
AND COULD EVEN LEAD TO IMPROPER
DISCLOSURE PUT PRIVILEGED
INFORMATION NOT ONLY THAT IT UP
PLEASES BURDENS OF
RESPONSIBILITY IN FINANCIAL AND
OTHERWISE --%
WHICH MAY NOT ALIGNED WITH OUR
ELECTED OFFICIALS --
PARTICULAR PARTIES.
SO BESIDES UNDERMINING ERODING
THIS IT INDEPENDENT
CONSTITUTIONAL AUTHORITY WE ARE
IN OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL.
IF YOU NEXT WITNESS.
TIFFANY MARKER BEHALF OF
SECRETARY OF STATE WE BELIEVE
THIS LOWERS OUR CYBERSECURITY.
I ANY OTHER WITNESSES OPPOSITION
BACKING ON ROSS CHIEF
INFORMATION OFFICER REPRESENTING
STATE TREASURER JOHN CHIANG WE
ARE ALSO OPPOSED WE'VE MET WITH
IT MEMBERS STAFF WE'VE SUBMITTED
A LETTER WE ARE VERY CONCERNED
THAT IT VIOLATES.
THE CONSTITUTIONAL
STRUCTURALISTS ALREADY OF THE
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICES WE OPPOSE
THIS BILL [inaudible]
X..
SUE BANG ON BEHALF OF STATE
SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC
INSTRUCTION TOM TARLETON ALSO
STRONGLY IN OPPOSITION.
OKAY SO --
OBVIOUSLY YOUR TESTIMONY --
BURKE BRING SOME INFORMATION
APPEAR THAT WE NEED TO DISCUSS
THE I'M REALLY DISAPPOINTED THAT
WE DON'T HAVE MORE OF OUR
MEMBERS HERE.
TOO YOU KNOW TO HEAR THIS
TESTIMONY I GUESS THE QUESTION
IS -- IT IT
IT IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING WHAT
THIS BILL DOES IS SET PROTOCOLS
OUT -- IT IN
THIS AREA [inaudible]
AND AB WHAT I HEARD FROM YOU AT
THE FOR THE FIRST BAKER FROM --
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE
WHOSE NAME I'M SORRY PREDICATE
GEORGE THAT'S THANK YOU MISTER
ORANGE --
THAT ALL SAID THAT THE VIEWER IT
INDICATED THIS PUT YOU UNDER
THEIR DEPARTMENT IN TERMS OF
CYBERSECURITY YOU KNOW LOOK AT
THIS IS JUST A YOU KNOW.
I I I HAVE NOT READ THIS PART OF
THIS PARTICULAR BILL BUT I MEAN
IF YOU HAVE A HIGHER STANDARD
THAN WHAT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY HAS --
DON'T YOU GET A PASS ON THAT.
I DON'T WANT IT WITH
RESPECTFULLY WE THINK IT'S MORE
THAN THAT FOR TO ANSWER THE
FIRST PART OF YOUR QUESTION --
IF WE WERE LOOKING AT AS
SUBSECTION BE.
OF ELLA. ONE ONE FIVE FOUR NINE
POINT THREE THIS NOW REQUIRES
THAT -- THAT
ALL STATE AGENCIES WITH WAS
PREVIOUSLY WAS STATE ENTITIES
UNDER WHICH THE CONSTITUTION
OFFICES WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN COME
UNDER.
NOW ALL STATE AGENCIES --
TELL IMPLEMENT THE POLICIES AND
PROCEDURES ISSUED BY THE OFFICE
[inaudible]
AND LOOKING BOTH AT THAT AND
THEN ALSO SUBSECTION A WHICH
DELINEATES ALL THE VARIOUS TYPES
OF I'M POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
I'M AND NOT IT'S NOT.
THAT'S LIMITED BUT NOT.
NOT LIMITED TO SIMPLY THOSE BUT
THAT'S JUST THE BEGINNING OF THE
LAST IT'S REALLY QUITE BROAD --
AND ESSENTIALLY COULD --
NOT ONLY DOES DOES IT PUT CD T.
I'M.
OVERSIGHT OVER I'M DOJ'S
SECURITY PRACTICES THAT
TECHNOLOGY I'M.
DECISIONS BUT IT WILL ALSO RUN
INTO THE ISSUE OF OF THE ACCESS
RIGHT OUR EMPLOYEES AS I STATED
BEFORE ARE REQUIRED HARM TO
UNDERGO EXTENSIVE PERSONAL
SCREENING AND THE UC PEACE
OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING
BACKGROUND INVESTIGATIONS A WEEK.
YOU KNOW WE'RE PUTTING THIS
INFORMATION AT REST.
BOB HAD.
BELIEVES THAT CAN HURT OF YOUR
QUESTION SENATOR IODIDE WAS --
IF WE ALREADY MEET THE STANDARDS --
DON'T WE ALREADY GET A PASS I'M
I'D.
IT DOESN'T CHANGE THAT IT.
UNDER THIS BILL NOW THAT THEY
HAVE AUTHORITY IN OVERSIGHT AND
THE VILLAGE ABILITY TO ACCESS
DOJ INFORMATION I'M I I DON'T
SEE HOW WE GET A PASS IT IF THEY
CONTINUE TO BE ABLE TO INTERVENE.
ON IN THE SECURITY SYSTEM THAT
WE'VE ALREADY SET UP AND MAY
REQUIRE SOMETHING ENTIRELY
DIFFERENT.
I THANK YOU.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER CHAU AYE AYE
MITCH'S DID --
IN HAVE ADDRESSED THE SITUATION
THEN ALSO WHAT YOU SEEM WITHIN
LET'S JUST SAY THE STATE
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS --
PRIVACY POLICIES THINGS THAT ARE
SUBSTANDARD TO MAKE THIS POLICY.
AN IMPORTANT POLICY GOING
FORWARD FOR THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
YEAH LET ME LET ME ADDRESS THE
ISSUES ARE RAISED AND FIRST
THOUGHTS.
ARE WITH RESPECT TO THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ARE ALL
IT'S BEEN BROUGHT TO MY
ATTENTION THAT THEY DO SO.
SPECIAL SERVICES AND AUDIT SET
THAT UP MAY REQUIRE THAT WE ARE
PAY PARTICULAR ATTENTION A MAYBE
A CAR FELL FOR SOME SOME OF THE
ACTIVITIES FOR THE OJ.
NOW THAT'S BEEN IN DISCUSSION
AND OUT WE ARE WAITING FOR IN
FACT FOR LANGUAGE YEAH --
TO ADDRESS THAT PARTICULAR ISSUE
ARE THAT WE ARE VERY SENSITIVE
TO THAT PARTICULAR ISSUE.
NOW THE OVERALL OUR GOAL OF THIS
BILL IS SAID TO MAKE SURE THAT
THE OUR STATE AGENCIES ARE.
ARE PROTECTED AND FROM.
AND THAT THERE IN LIES THE
AMBIGUITY AND THAT IS WHAT IS
DEFINED AS THE ENTITY.
ARE OR STATE AGENCIES AND THERE
IS OBVIOUSLY A DISCREPANCY AND
I'LL IN OUR STATUTE.
THAT THERE ARE THERE IS SUIT
INCONSISTENCIES RIGHT THERE
BETWEEN AGENCIES VERSES ENTITIES
SO WHAT ARE AGENCIES SAYS
OBLIGATED TO COMPLY WITH.
SO ONE OF ONE OF THE REASONS WHY
WE DOING HIS BILL IS TO MAKE
SURE THAT WE ARE CORRECT ANY
AMBIGUITY MAKE SURE THAT ALL
STAGING STATE AGENCIES ARE ARE
OBLIGATED TO COMPLY WITH THE
SAME.
SET OF AUG GUIDELINES SO
INCLUDING CYBERSECURITY AND WE
DO WANT TO PROVIDE THE BEST
CYPRUS --
SECURITY PROTECTION FOR ALL
STATE AGENCIES AND OUT OF THE
UNDERLYING --
YEAH LE PRINCIPLE AND WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE WANT TO LET
LEVERAGE ALL THE RESOURCES THAT
WE HAD AT AT THE STATE LEVEL
INSTEAD HAVE OF HAVING SILO
APPROACHES.
AMONGST THE VARIOUS STATE
AGENCIES SO THAT THE UNDERLYING
ALL INTENT OF THE BILL.
BUT I'LL I'LL BE HAPPY TO
CONTINUE TALKING HILL CHERRY
PICK YOUR SECURITY CHAIR AND I
THINK YOU RAISED IT IS THAT THE
QUESTION ON THE ISSUE IT BUT I
BELIEVE IS.
BECAUSE OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL
NATURE OF THE OFFICES THAT WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT.
THIS THEIR QUESTIONING OUR
JURISDICTION --
OR AUTHORITY TO MAKE THOSE
CHANGES WHICH IS INTERESTING
I'VE A BILL IN YOUR COMMITTEE
THIS AFTERNOON WITH THE SAME.
PARAMETERS IN A DIFFERENCE
SETTING BUT A THE HOW DO YOU.
ADDRESS THAT PART OF THEIR
CONSTITUTIONAL OR THEIR
PERCEPTION OF CONSTITUTIONAL
INDEPENDENCE.
AND NOT SUBJECT TO OUR AUTHORITY
OVER THESE ISSUES THAT THEY'RE
TALKING ABOUT I THINK ONE OF THE
ISSUES THAT --
HAS BEEN RAISED BY OPPOSITION IS
THE THE ALLEGED THE ALLEGED.
THAT WHO EXACTLY LIKE YOU
MENTIONED OR WHETHER OR NOT
LET'S SAY.
THE CT HAS ANY JURISDICTION OVER-OTHER CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS.
BUT LET ME JUST REITERATE THE
FACT THAT YOU KNOW WE'RE ALL AT
THE STATE LEVEL AND WE WANT TO
UTILIZE AND LEVERAGE.
OUR STATE RESOURCES TO THE BEST
OF ALL ABILITY.
SO.
WHAT WE DOING UNDER C. T. IS
[inaudible]
WE HAVE THE CAPACITY AND
RESOURCES TO ADDRESS
CYBERSECURITY ISSUES THROUGHOUT
THE STATE.
AND OUGHT TO BE ROBUST AND OUGHT
TO BE YOU UNIFORM.
AND WHETHER OR NOT IT IS A STAGE
STATE AGENCY LET'S A DEPARTMENT
OF FINANCE OR CONSTITUTIONAL
OFFICERS.
BECAUSE THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE
PART OF THE STATE THOUGHT WELL
AGENCIES AS WELL SO SO THEREIN
LIES THE D. AMBIGUITY WHETHER OR
NOT CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS
OUGHT TO BE DEEMED.
A STATE AGENCIES --
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION NO I
APOLOGIZE --
CHIU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
IN OPPOSITION I WAS TAUGHT THAT
I SHOULD BE ABLE TO PREDICT THAT.
A ROBERT HER OUT WITH THE
INSURANCE COMMISSIONERS OFFICE
WE WERE ONE OF THE SIGNATORIES --
TO THE LETTER OF MANY OF THE
CONSTITUTIONAL SUPPOSE IN THE
BILL FOR THE REASONS THAT HAVE
BEEN DISCUSSED THOROUGHLY
ALREADY IN THIS COMMITTEE
APOLOGIZE FOR THE TARDINESS
THANK YOU. ONE OTHER THING THAT
I LIKE TO BRING TO THE ATTENTION
OF THE MEDIA IS THAT.
IN OUR SUITS THE REGULATIONS ARE
THEY ARE STILL CONSIDERED TO BE
A PART OF US THE STATE AGENCY
UMBRELLA OR FAMILY [inaudible]
ALRIGHT A COMMENT.
AB THEM TIFFANY MARKHAM WE HAVE
THE SECRETARY STATE.
I THINK WE WOULD LIKE TO
EMPHASIZE WE COULDN'T AGREE MORE
THAT IT'S SO IMPORTANT TO
LEVERAGE OUR STATE RESOURCES.
AND UTILIZE ALL THAT WE HAVE
AGAIN CYBERSECURITY WHERE WE
FEEL THAT THIS BILL UNDERMINES.
ARE CYBERSECURITY IS THAT IT
DOESN'T JUST.
MAKE US LEVERAGE THE RESOURCES
WHICH THE SECRETARY OF STATE'S
OFFICE CURRENTLY DOES WE WORK
WITH CDT ON NUMEROUS ISSUES IT
MANDATES IN SECTIONS SEE.
THE ASSESSMENTS THAT MUST OUR
COMPLIANCE BASED AND SO INSTEAD
OF A CONTINUOUS GROWTH MODEL TO
ENSURE THAT IF WE EXCEED THE
STANDARDS THAT ARE IN THE
COMPLIANCE.
BASED ASSESSMENTS WE MAYBE
PROVIDED US PENALTIES OR EVEN
DOWNGRADED AND THE PERCEPTION OF
OUR CYBERSECURITY BECAUSE WE
HAVEN'T.
MET.
SPECIFIC CHECK BOXES AND SO
WITHOUT A ROLE IN SETTING THOSE
POLICIES AND BEING ABLE TO
COMMENT AND EVALUATE THOSE IN A
SYSTEMATIC WAY.
THIS ISN'T JUST ABOUT OUR
CURRENT.
UP IN THE ADMINISTRATION AND THE
CDT LEADERSHIP WHICH WE DEEPLY
RESPECT IT'S ABOUT.
THAT THIS WOULD BE CODIFIED IN
LAW ONGOING REGARDLESS OF
ADMINISTRATIONS AND LEADERS AND
THAT'S THE FUNDAMENTAL CONCERN
THAT THERE ISN'T THOSE CERTAIN.
SAFEGUARDS FOR ENSURING THAT
WHEN ANOTHER AND SHE COMES IN
ACCESSES OUR DATA AND ATTITUDE
TO REVIEW IT FOR ASSESSMENTS.
THAT WE DON'T HAVE ASSURANCE OF
HOW IT WILL BE USED.
OR KEPT SAID.
OKAY A ASSEMBLY MEMBER WERE --
AT THIS POINT WOULD YOU LIKE
CLOSE YEAH ABSOLUTELY I YOU WILL
BE VERY HAPPY TO CONTINUE
WORKING ITH ALL THE STAR
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS.
AND I THINK TO THE EXTENT THAT
WE COULD KINDA --
TWEAK.
THE BILL ALLUDED TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEY'RE ALL OKAY I DID I DO
WANT TO EMPHASIZE ONE POINT AND
THAT IS SET.
UP I THINK CDT DOES HAVE THE
MOST EXPERTISE SO I COME TO
CYBERSECURITY AND THE INTENT IS
FOR US TO AS I MENTIONED BEFORE.
TO OUR PROVIDE AND LEVERAGE OUR
RESOURCES ARE WITH CDT SO THAT
WE WANT TO PROTECT THESE
AGENCIES OR OFFICES FROM A CYBER
ATTACKS I THINK THAT'S THE
UNDERLYING INTENTION OF THE BILL.
AND YOU KNOW AS I MENTIONED I
ARE THE PPOSITION YOU KNOW FROM
FROM NOW UNTIL WHENEVER TO MAKE
SURE THAT IT THAT WORKS WITH THE
EVERYONE.
I GUESS I YOU I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN
BUSY WITH OTHER BILLS AND YOU'VE
DONE A GOOD JOB WITH THE THE
OTHER BILLS BUT THIS IS A
DIFFICULT BILL WHAT I HAVE IN
FRONT IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL --
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN
OPPOSITION YOUR BILL.
IT MAKES IT VERY VERY DIFFICULT
I DON'T KNOW THAT.
AT THE TIME.
IT YOU ALWAYS GET ALLOW FOR THIS
BUT WE WILL TALK ABOUT THAT --
IT WHEN NINE WHEN WE VOTE ON
YOUR BILL WHICH I CLOSE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK HER ABOUT I
THINK YOU VERY MUCH SEMI MEMBERS.
IT THIS TIME WE'RE GONNA STAB US
QUORUM THANK YOU [inaudible]
DODD.
HERE DIED HERE WILK PRESIDENT
WELL CARE BRADFORD CANNELLA.
CANNELLA HERE GAINES GALGIANI.
GALGIANI HERE GLAZER HILL.
HERE HILL HERE WESO LARA.
PORTANTINO BITE AFTER.
BITE ACCURATE WIENER.
THERE'S A WINNER HERE.
THE OWES TO THE CONSENT CALENDAR
WHILE WE'RE HERE.
THANK YOU WE HAVEN'T GOT A
MOTION FROM SENATOR CANNELLA.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL DIED.
I DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HILL.
I'D HILL AYE HUESO.
LARA.
PORTANTINO.
RIGHT ACT.
BY THAT I WIENER AYE WIENER AYE
HOLDING OPEN.
WELL HOLD THAT UP OPEN --
SEVEN MEMBERS AYE GARCIA.
WE HAVE AB [inaudible]
TWENTY ONE OH SIX WELCOME.
YES I THINK YOU MISTER
COLLEAGUES ASSEMBLY MEMBER
TWENTY ONE OH SIX BUILDS ON AN
EFFORT.
BUT FOR BY SOME REMEMBER COMING
INTO A BEACON.
TO THE BILL THAT --
ESTABLISHED A 5% BIT PREFERENCE --
FOR OUR CALIFORNIA GROWERS.
THE BILL --
WOULD KICK IN IN.
TWENTY TWENTY ONE AND WILL TAKE
THE CURRENT EXISTING BIT
PREFERENCE FROM 5210%. FOR STATE
PURCHASES RELATED O CALIFORNIA
GROWN.
OR CALIFORNIA PACK AGRICULTURAL
PRODUCTS --
THE GOAL OF THE BILL IS TO BRING
IT.
CERTAINTY TO THE AG INDUSTRY IN
CALIFORNIA.
THE NEVER ENDING PRESSURES OF
STATES THAT COMPETE WITH
CALIFORNIA'S.
AGRICULTURE IS ONE OF THE
REASONS WHY WE BRING THIS
FORWARD IN MY DISTRICT --
IF YOU LOOK SOUTH OF THE BORDER
THAT CERTAINLY IS A PLACE WHERE
MANY OF PRODUCTS THAT ARE GROWN
IN REPEAL COUNTY ARE ALSO GROWN
AS WELL.
SO THAT'S WHY AB TWENTY SIX
TWENTY ONE OF SIX BEFORE YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
A GOOD MORNING TILL RUSSIAN WITH
A CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU WERE
STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY
ONE OF SEX.
I'M WHICH WE BELIEVE WILL ALLOW
CALIFORNIA PRODUCERS TO BETTER
PARTICIPATE IN THE STATE
PROCUREMENT PROCESS.
AND CALIFORNIA GROWN IS MORE
THAN JUST A MARKETING PLOY IT IS
A REFLECTION ON HOW A PRODUCT IS
GROWN AND HARVESTED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE HIGHEST WAGE
LABOR.
OF FOOD SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL
STANDARDS ALONG WITH TENS OF
THOUSANDS OF JOBS FOR
CALIFORNIANS.
AND JUST THE STATE HAS MADE
TARGETED INVESTMENTS IN ZERO
MISSION ALONE MISSION ST FLEET.
I ENERGY CONSCIOUS BUILDING
STANDARDS AND STATE FACILITIES
BEAT TO BELIEVE THE STATE SHOULD
MAKE INVESTMENTS IN CALIFORNIA
AGRICULTURE SO IT'S ALWAYS
REQUEST IN A BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOU OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT [inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION.
SCENE NINE ANY QUESTIONS.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM CENTER
CANNELLA THAT THIS --
BILL -- IT'S
GOOD BILL --
I'D FOR THE REASONS THAT --
YOU BROUGHT FORWARD I THINK I
THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
SUPPORT AGRICULTURE THEY'VE --
THEY'VE HAD SIGNIFICANT.
YEAH ISSUES WITH POLICIES A
STATE OF CALIFORNIA THIS BECAUSE
THERE MEMBERS LOTS OF MONEY
THING WE CAN DO TO SUPPORT THEIR
INDUSTRY --
I CAN SUPPORT SO THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
WE CALL THE ROLL THIS AS A DO
PASS RECOMMENDATION.
FILE ITEM TEN AB TWENTY ONE OH
SIX MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
AYE BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO LARA PORTANTINO
[inaudible]
BY JACK [inaudible]
WIENER [inaudible]
WIENER AYE. SIX WILL DEFEND THAT
HAS SIX VOTES WILL HOLD IT OPEN
ASSEMBLY MEMBER [inaudible]
ASSEMBLYMEMBER WALDRON.
AB [inaudible]
TWO OH EIGHT SEVEN CLOSE.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
COMMITTEE.
A WIN ONE OF THOSE DAYS.
A I AM HERE TODAY TO PRESENT A.
B. TWENTY EIGHTY SEVEN TO BRING
CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT INTO THE
TWENTY FIRST CENTURY IF THAT'S
POSSIBLE.
AND WE ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS.
AND AS YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA'S
WOEFULLY BEHIND IN MAKING USE OF
TECHNOLOGY TO STREAMLINE
OPERATIONS AND IMPROVE PUBLIC
TRANSPARENCY.
ARE STATEMENTS ENCOURAGED
MODERNIZATION IN ORDER TO CREATE
FAMILY FRIENDLY WORKPLACES
REDUCE SPENDING INCREASE
EFFICIENCIES ON CYBERSECURITY.
STREAMLINED PROCESSES AND REDUCE
CARBON EMISSIONS.
INNOVATIONS IN TECHNOLOGY CAN
HELP LEGISLATIVE JUDICIAL AND
EXECUTIVE BRANCHES OPERATE MORE
EFFICIENTLY.
ENCOURAGE MORE WOMEN TO
PARTICIPATE IN THE WORKFORCE AND
CREATE PUBLIC TRANSPARENCY.
CALIFORNIA'S MISSING OUT ON MANY
BENEFITS ASSOCIATED WITH A
MODERNIZED WORKPLACE.
AB TWENTY EIGHTY SEVEN WOULD
REQUIRE EACH STATE AGENCY
INCLUDING THE LEGISLATURE TO
ESTABLISH MODERNIZATION GOALS BY.
JANUARY FIRST TWENTY TWENTY AND
TO CREATE AN IMPLEMENTATION.
ACOSTA ASSESSMENT PLAN. FOR
ACHIEVING THEM OF FOR EXAMPLE.
YOU KNOW YOU LOOK AT THE DMV AND
WE'RE GETTING A LOT OF
COMPLAINTS LATELY ABOUT PEOPLE
WHO AWAITING SIX HOURS AND DMV'S
EVEN THOUGH THEY HAVE AN ONLINE
APPOINTMENT SYSTEM.
MY SON JUST GOT HIS DRIVER'S
LICENSE LAST YEAR AND IN ORDER
FOR THEM TO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT.
AND GET THEIR INITIAL DRIVERS.
DEAL FORTY FOUR FORM.
NOT AVAILABLE AT THE DMV NOT
AVAILABLE ONLINE YOU HAVE TO
ACTUALLY WRITE IN.
OR CALL AND IT TOOK ME THREE OR
FOUR TIMES TO CALL IN TO TRY TO
GET THE FORM WHEN IT NEVER CAME
AND THAT YOU KNOW HIS.
BIRTHDAY IS COMING AND GOING IN
THE REALLY WANTED TO GET IN.
AHEAD TO USE MY DISTRICT STAFF
PERSON TO MAKE THE CALL AND
CONTACT THEIR LIAISON HERE IN
SACRAMENTO TO GET THE FORM SO
WHAT IS THE AVERAGE CITIZEN
SUPPOSED TO DO.
OF FOR EXAMPLE IS AN ONLINE
APPOINTMENT SYSTEM IS GREAT YOU
CAN MAKE AN APPOINTMENT BUT YOU
CAN CANCEL ONE IF YOU HAVE TO
CANCEL.
SO THEY HAVE THIS FULL
APPOINTMENT SCHEDULE WILL ONLY
MAYBE HALF THE PEOPLE ARE
ACTUALLY LEGITIMATELY COMING TO
THE APPOINTMENTS.
WHEN HAS THE LEGISLATURE LAST
LOOKED AT MODERNIZING ITS
SCHEDULE ITS CALENDAR AND
OPERATIONS TO ENCOURAGE THE
FAMILY FRIENDLY WORKPLACE OR
REDUCING CARBON EMISSIONS?
USE OF TECHNOLOGIES AVAILABLE TO
EFFICIENTLY PERFORM DAILY CHECK
INS FOR LEGISLATURE'S VOTE ADD
ONS FOR MEMBERS SERVING IN
MULTIPLE COMMITTEES AT THE SAME
TIME WHAT.
WE'RE EXPERIENCING TODAY
[inaudible]
SO -- AND
ALSO THE SUPPORT AND POSES AN
ADD ONS BY LOBBYISTS IN
ASSOCIATIONS.
SO AND SO MUCH MORE WITH ME
TODAY HER HAVE GERALD COOK FROM
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING AND
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION.
AND I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
BUT WE DO HAVE A SUPPORT SUPPORT
RECOMMENDATIONS SO IF YOU CAN BE
BRIEF BUT POLICE --
WITNESSES SUPPORT [inaudible]
SHARE.
THANK YOU I'VE BEEN TO THE CHAIR
THE COMMITTEE OF ANY WITHDRAWAL
COOK FOR THE CALIFORNIA
MANUFACTURERS AND TECHNOLOGY
ASSOCIATION --
WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL IS
A FLEXIBLE COMMONSENSE MEASURE
AGENCIES WILL BE ABLE TO CHOOSE
HOW THEY ACHIEVE GOALS LIKE
INCREASING CYBERSECURITY --
USE INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGY AND
OTHER MEASURES THAT WOULD
INCREASE THEIR ABILITY TO
DELIVER CRUCIAL SERVICES IN
ADDITION TO THE BENEFIT THAT
THIS WILL HAVE FOR THE STATE AND
THE PUBLIC --
EIGHT HAD IT.
ALSO HAS A BENEFIT FOR THE
PRIVATE SECTOR IT ATTRACTS
INVESTMENT WE ARE CONSUMERS OF
THESE PUBLIC SERVICES AND WE
WANT TO BE LOCATED IN STATES
WHERE THE ADMINISTRATION FONG
AND THE VICTIM.
EFFICIENTLY AND EFFECTIVELY
ABOUT THE OPPOSITE --
WHEN STATES FAILED TO DO SO WAS
ALSO PARA?
A FAILURE TO MODERNIZE WE SAW
EARLIER THIS YEAR IN CITIES LIKE
ATLANTA --
WHERE THE CITY SERVICES WERE
CRIPPLED --
HINDERS THE ABILITY TO US
SUPPORT ITS PEOPLE AND ITS
BUSINESSES AND SO WE ENCOURAGE
OUR I'VE.
BALLINGER FOR THE CALIFORNIA
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE WE ARE IN
SUPPORT WE LOOK AT THIS BILL OF
IT WOULD FACILITATE
PARTICIPATION.
ON STAKEHOLDERS PART.
WITH THE PROCESS THANK YOU THANK
YOU.
I ANY WITNESSES OPPOSITION.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
VIED ACCURATE [inaudible]
ANY DISCUSSION.
CALL THE ROLL PLEASE.
FILE ITEM NINE AB TWENTY EIGHTY
SEVEN MOTION IS DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD I
THOUGHT AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE GAINES
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO LARA PORTANTINO.
BIDAK AYE BIDAK AYE WIENER AYE
AYE WIENER AYE [inaudible] SEVEN
HOLDEN.
GOV SEVEN VOTES WILL HOLD THE
ROLE OPEN [inaudible]
SO MUCH.
PRE.
SET ASSEMBLY MEMBER GRAY.
AB. EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT
EIGHT EIGHT EIGHTY EXCUSE ME
WRONG Y..
GOOD MORNING CENTERS
[inaudible]
CHAIRMAN.
THE GOAL OF AB EIGHT EIGHTY IS
TO FACILITATE SELF GOVERNANCE
AND IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE
OF TRIBAL PEOPLE THROUGHOUT THE
STATE [inaudible]
SINCE TWENTY TWELVE THE TRIBAL
NATION GRANT FUND HAS BEEN
INCLUDED EIGHTEEN TRIBAL STATE
GAMING COMPACTS.
IF COME BEFORE THIS BODY
EXECUTED BY GOVERNOR BROWN AS A
MEANS TO INCREASE THE AMOUNT OF
REVENUE.
SHARE BETWEEN THE SEVENTY PLUS
TRIBES WERE ELIGIBLE FOR REVENUE
SHARING TRUST FUND ALLOCATIONS.
THE TNG EFFORTS TO FIND WITH
THOSE CONTACTS IS A FUND TO MAKE
DISCRETIONARY DISTRIBUTION OF
FUNDS TO NON GAMING TRIBES AND
LIMITED GAMING TRIBES. FOR
PURPOSES RELATED TO EFFECTIVE
SELF GOVERNANCE SELF DETERMINED
COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT.
AS RESULT OF THE RE NEGOTIATED
COMPACTS REVENUE SHARING TRUST
FUND REVENUES ARE FOR THE FIRST
TIME.
SUFFICIENT TO FULLY FUND THE R.
S. T. F. DISTRIBUTIONS TO
ELIGIBLE RECEIVE --
INDIAN TRIBES.
THIS SOLVENCY WILL ALLOW FOR THE
ALLOCATION OF FUNDS IN THE NEW
CREATED TRIBAL NATION GRANT FUND.
HOWEVER FOR ANY APPROPRIATION
CAN OCCUR SP EIGHT EIGHTY WILL
NEED TO BE ADOPTED TO PROVIDE
GUIDELINES FOR THE OPERATION AND
EXECUTION OF THE FUND.
THE VARIOUS SPECIFICS OF THE TNG
EFFORT OPERATE WE'RE NOT
DETAILED PRIOR COMPAQ'S.
SO TO ALL IT SHOULD PARTY'S KEPT
HIS PAID A BROADER DISCUSSION
TRIBAL PARTICIPATION IS TAKING
PLACE IN THE FORM OF DISCUSSIONS
INFORMAL CONSULTATIONS HELD
BETWEEN THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE.
AND CALIFORNIA'S R. S. T. F.
ELIGIBLE TRIBES.
FOLLOWING THESE FORMAL
CONSULTATIONS WITH TRIBAL
LEADERS AND AFTER COMMENT PERIOD
LANGUAGES DRAFTED THAT CORPORATE
THE IDEAS CONCERNS SUGGESTIONS
AND FINDINGS.
LAST SEPTEMBER THE LANGLAIS
WHICH WAS AMENDED INTO A BILL TO
GIVE THE RESPECTIVE STAKEHOLDERS
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE
FURTHER INPUT ON THIS IMPORTANT
TOPIC.
IN APRIL TWENTY EIGHTEEN A JOINT
INFORMATION HEARING WAS HELD BY
THE SAID ASSEMBLY GEO COMMITTEES
TO INFORM MEMBERS ABOUT THE
HISTORY OBJECTIVES OF TRIBAL
NATION GRANT FUND.
UNDERSTAND THE IMPLEMENTATION
FRAMEWORK ESTABLISHED BY THE
PROPOSED LEGISLATIVE LANGUAGE
AND SEEK FURTHER INPUT FROM ALL
INTERESTED STAKEHOLDERS OF
POTENTIAL REFINEMENTS AND
IMPROVEMENTS TO THAT FRAMEWORK.
PARTICIPANTS INCLUDE LEGISLATIVE
ANALYST'S OFFICE REPRESENTED
FROM THE OFFICE OF GOVERNOR
COMMISSION IN THE BUREAU AND
TRIBAL LEADERS.
TODAY YOU HAVE BEFORE YOU A
PROPOSAL THAT MEETS THE GENERAL
POLICY OBJECTIVES HAS STATED
RECENT COMPACTS TO DEVELOP AND
ESTABLISH THE TNG F..
AS A MEANS TO DIRECT MONEY
TOWARDS TRIBAL GOVERNMENTS TO
ENABLE THEM TO MAKE A
SIGNIFICANT POSITIVE IMPACT ON
TRIBAL COMMUNITIES.
I HAVE WITH ME TODAY JOE DON'T
FOR THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE RIDE
FURTHER INFORMATION ASK ANY
QUESTIONS OF THE KIDNEY THEY
HAVE ON THE ON THE BILL
[inaudible]
MISTER DILLON.
THANK YOU CHAIRMAN --
THANK YOU CHAIRMAN BECAUSE THE
WORK THAT THIS COMMITTEE
ASSEMBLY GEO OUR OFFICE IN THE
TRIBE YOU'VE NEGOTIATED WITH
HAVE DONE THERE'S A FAIR AND
EFFECTIVE WAY TO GET MONEY.
THE TRIBAL NATION GRANDSON THIS
BILL PROVIDES.
A FAIR AND EFFECTIVE WAY TO GET
OUT TO THE TRIBES THAT WOULD
BENEFIT FROM IT.
THE BILL --
PLACES RESPONSIBILITY FOR MAKING
DECISIONS IN THE HANDS OF TRIBAL
LEADERS THAT PURPOSES THE FINEST
ENHANCE TRIBAL GOVERNMENTS SELF
DETERMINATION THERE IN THE BEST
POSITION TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS
[inaudible]
AND IT HAS A NUMBER OF
PROVISIONS OF THE GOD
ACCOUNTABILITY TRANSPARENCY --
AND SPECIFICALLY THAT --
I SHOULD NOTE THAT THAT THAT
FOCAL POINT WITHIN THE STATE
GOVERNMENT FOR MAKING DECISIONS
IS THAT TRIBAL ADVISE IT AGAIN
THE CONTROL COMMISSION HISTORY
MINISTRY RESPONSIBILITIES BUT
IT'S A TRIBAL ADVISOR THEY'LL
WORK WITH THE TRIBAL.
LEADERS. TO IMPLEMENT --
GOVERNOR BROWN THROUGH EXECUTIVE
ORDER BE TEN ELEVEN CREATED THE
TRIBAL ADVISER POSITION AND
WE'VE BEEN ALL BETTER OFF FOR
HAVING.
A A MEMBER OF A CALIFORNIA
NATIVE AMERICAN TRIBE WITHIN THE
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR ENHANCE
YOUR COMMUNICATION AND
COOPERATION TRIBAL GOVERNMENTS
THIS BILL MAKES A POSITION
PERMITTED SO HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS.
ABOUT THAT WOULD LIKE TO TURN IT
OVER TO AND TRAVEL ADVISOR
SNYDER.
THANK YOU CHAIRMAN THANK YOU JOE --
I'M CRISTINA SNYDER IN THE
TRIBAL ADVISER FOR THE GOVERNOR
AND MEMBER OF DRY CREEK
RANCHERIA BAND OF POMO INDIANS
I'M I'M HERE JUST TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE BUT I'M
READY TO HIT THE GROUND RUNNING
ON THIS ON AS SOON AS IT'S
EMPLOYMENT OR YET THE THEME.
IS THAT'S ENACTED --
I'M READY.
TO DO CONSULTATION AND TO
IMPLEMENT IT FULLY.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
IN SUPPORT.
BORN IN.
THOSE AVAILABLE TO REMOTE
RABBINICAL WE'RE TROUBLE
CHAIRMAN A LOOK IN THE SUBURBS I
COUNTY CALIFORNIA.
SO I DON'T WANT --
WE'RE HERE IN SUPPORT OF THE A
WILL FOR SUCH THAT I THINK THE
AUTHOR OF THIS BILL AND MORE
HERE SUPPORTIVE OF THE BILL --
IT WOULD ALLOW TRIBES.
TO BUT WILL IT WOULD ALLOW THE
PROCESS OF IMITATION FOR THE
TRIBAL GOD I'D MET RELIGIOUS
GRANTLAND --
WHICH IS BEEN LONG AWAITED SO IT
WE WOULD URGE YOUR YES VOTE ON
IS ALSO -- A
LITTLE BIT MORE A ROOM TO
DEVELOP PROGRAMS AND ENHANCE
OLDER PROGRAMS --
AND ALSO ALLOW FOR GOOD CRITICAL
SOMETIMES CRITICAL UP FOR ME
WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT BE CRITICAL
BUT TO LISTA.
DEVELOP SOME KIND OF PROGRAM FOR
BEFORE INFRASTRUCTURE.
BEFORE --
GETS TOO LATE.
THANK YOU MISTER CLINTON BANG.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SOME
MORNING OF MY NAME'S MICHELLE
APPENA I'M HERE TODAY ON BEHALF
OF THE DRY CREEK RANCHERIA
ANTIPOLO INDIANS.
OF THE POTTER VALLEY TRIBE AND
HOOPER VALLEY TRIBE.
AND WE ARE HERE TO EXPRESS OUR
SUPPORT AND OUR GRATITUDE FOR
THE AUTHOR MOVING THIS BILL
FORWARD.
I'M ABLE PROVIDED MUCH NEEDED --
PROCESS FOR THE TRIBAL NATIONS
GRANT FUND TO FINALLY BE
DISSEMINATED IN AND PUT TO GOOD
USE BY THE TRIBE THAT NEED IT
MOST THANK YOU [inaudible]
YOU.
WITNESSES OTHER WITNESSES THAT
SUPPORT MISTER CHAIRMAN YES I'M
SORRY I WAS HUNGRY AND HAS A
CASE.
BUT NO PROBLEM A MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS AND READ REPRESENTING
FEDERATED INDIANS GREAT.
SHARIA IN YOUR DISTRICT HER --
AND I'M HERE PROUDLY TO SAY
THEY'RE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
MEASURE I'M WRITING IT IN IN
YOUR ANALYSIS YOUR CONSULTANT
HAS A PUT A PART OF THE LETTER
FROM OUR CHAIRMAN GREGG SERWIS.
INTO YOUR NOW SAID JUST LIKE TO
READ ONE SENTENCE PLEASE OF IT
AND IT SAYS --
OUR TRIBE IS PROUD TO PAY INTO
THE P. AND G. F. AND AS SUCH WE
HAVE A SIGNIFICANT INTEREST IN
ENSURING THAT THE MONEY.
WE PAY INTO THE TNC HAVE GOES TO
THE TRIBES IN OUR STATE THAT
NEED FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE AND
PROVIDE SERVICES TO THE TRAVEL
MEMBERS SO THERE AND FULL
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
THANK YOU MISTER REED.
BECAUSE GOD EVERYBODY HERE.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
BUT ALSO ON OUR BEHALF OF THE
WELL TEN RANCHERIA AND SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
REMEMBER FRANK MARINO BEHALF THE
SALMON WILL BEND MISSION
INNOCENT SUPPORT.
AFRICA ORDERS FOR THE SHINGLE
SPRINGS BAND WE LOCK INDIANS IN
SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
SEE THAT'S NOT SURPRISING DOMES
SO A MEMBER GRAY --
BECOME BRING IT BACK HERE IN THE
COMMENTS THESE GREAT BUILT GOT A
DO PASS RECOMMENDATION THANK YOU
ASSEMBLY MEMBER GRAY WHICH I
CLOSE.
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
SO WE MOVED CENTER HILL IS MOVE
THE BILL COULD BE CALL THE ROLL
PLEASE FILE ITEM MINE AB EIGHT
EIGHTY MOTION AS PURSUANT TO
SENATE RULE TWENTY NINE TEN THAT
THE MEASURE BE REFERRED TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
DODD AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK
AYE BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER.
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO LARA [inaudible]
YOU KNOW [inaudible]
RIGHT ACT.
WIENER.
AYE WIENER AYE [inaudible]
THAT'S EQUAL.
BUT THAT'S OUT ITS GET A VOTE
BUT WILL HOLD ROLE BUT A MIXTURE
SENATORS.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
WITNESSES.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER DALY.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS.
SPILL EXTENDS THE SUNSET DATE ON
A PROGRAM THAT GIVES STATE
EMPLOYEES THE FLEXIBILITY TO USE
ALL TYPES OF TRANSPORTATION AND
LODGING OPTIONS.
INCLUDING SUCH SERVICES AS UBER
LEFT AND AIRBNB WHILE TRAVELING.
ON STATE BUSINESS.
THESE INTERNET BASED PLATFORMS
ARE SOMETIMES THE MOST RELIABLE
CONVENIENT AND COST EFFECTIVE
OPTIONS TO STATE EMPLOYEES.
ESPECIALLY IN COMMUNITIES THAT
LACK TRADITIONAL TRANSPORTATION
OR LODGING CHOICES.
THIS MEASURE WILL ENSURE THE
STATE EMPLOYEES CONTINUE TO HAVE
ACCESS TO A VARIETY OF OPTIONS
SO THEY CAN CHOOSE WHAT BEST
SUITS THEIR BUSINESS TRAVEL
REQUIREMENTS.
WITH ME TODAY IS KEVIN MCKINLEY
REPRESENTING THE INTERNET%
ASSOCIATION AND GRAY CASE
REPRESENTING AIRBNB.
YEAH THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
AND MEMBERS ON BEHALF OF BOTH
LIFT AND AIRBNB GREG HAYES --
HERE TESTIFIED SUPPORT THE BILL
REPRESENTS --
FLEXIBILITY COST SAVINGS FOR
STATE EMPLOYEES IN THE STATE WE
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU KEVIN KELLY WITH
INTERNET ASSOCIATION ABOUT WE
FEEL THE BILL'S NECESSARY TO
ENSURE.
THAT STATE EMPLOYEES CONTINUE TO
HAVE THE SERVICES AVAILABLE AS
AN OPTION FOR TRAVEL THANK YOU.
TERRIFIC IN ANY OTHER WITNESSES
SUPPORT [inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION.
MEMBERS WE HAVE A MOTION BY
SENATOR BIDAK.
THE OTHER COMMENT I SAW
QUESTIONED WHY DON'T WE JUST
REMOVE THE SUNSET ENTIRELY --
IN THIS SEEMS LIKE IT SHOULD THE
SPONSORS REAL QUICKLY HERE OF I
LIKE YOUR QUESTION A LOT.
AND I CAN'T RECALL WHAT THE
DECISIONMAKING WAS CHAIRMAN
AGREES.
AND I I WE WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF
THE S. SUGGESTION YEAH.
YES WE CAN AMENDED ON THE FLY.
KYRIE OBSCURA SCREW THEM OUT WE
TOOK A WE'RE NOT ENTIRELY SURE
THAT BILL --
SO FAR THE EXPERIENCE OF STATE
EMPLOYEES HAS BANNED THAT THERE
HAS BEEN A SAVINGS I COULD JUST
SAY AS A STATE EMPLOYEE USED TO
TRAVEL. ONE OF THE CHALLENGES
WAS GETTING LODGING CLOSE TO
WHERE MY MEETINGS ARE BECAUSE NO
I UNDERSTAND THE NEED FOR THE
BILL I JUST WONDER WHY WE THREE
LIMON EIGHT OF SUNSET ENTIRELY.
I THINK IN THE EARLY CAUCUS IN
EARLY CONVERSATIONS WE
ANTICIPATED A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF
PUSH BACK.
AND WE DECIDED TO TAKE THIS
ROUTE BUTTA.
FRANKLY THE PUSH BACK HASN'T
REALLY UP --
BUT THE COME UP.
RIGHT MINUS JUST CURIOUS YOU
APPRECIATE THAT [inaudible]
CENTER WILL.
YOU CAN DO IT.
I THINK THE BILL THAT YOU KNOW
SHOULD CARRY TOGETHER NEXT YEAR.
ALRIGHT.
OKAY.
BUT THAT WE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE
THE SANTA DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.
FILE ITEM TWENTY FIVE AB TWENTY
SEVEN SEVENTY SEVEN MOTION IS
DUE PASSED TO APPROPRIATIONS
DODD.
HI DOT AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE AYE
BRADFORD CANNELLA.
CANNELLA EYES GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HILL.
HUESO LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
BYE DOT I FIGHT ACAI WIENER.
WIENER AYE.
THE THAT A VOTES THAT'S OUT BUT
WILL HOLD ROLE OF A FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANKS FO THE SUGGESTIONS AND
NOW.
ARE BEING TOUCH THANK
[inaudible]
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
SOME A MEMBER WOULD A. B..
NINETEEN NINETEEN WERE YOU
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
LATE ON THE NIGHT OF OCTOBER
EIGHTEENTH SURE YOU KNOW THIS
WELL SENATOR --
WILDFIRES RACED TO NAPA CINNAMON
MENDOCINO COUNTIES AND LIVES
WERE FOREVER CHANGED.
THE FIRES DESTROYED EVERY
THOUSAND HOMES INCLUDING OVER
THREE THOUSAND IN THE CITY OF
SANTA ROSA ALONE.
THOUSANDS OF MY CONSTITUENTS
LOST THEIR HOMES IN ONE NIGHT.
AND THIS NIGHTMARE SCENARIO TOOK
WHAT WAS ALREADY A DIFFICULT
HOUSING MARKET AND TURNED IT
INTO A CRISIS.
CURRENT LAW PREVENTS THE COST OF
ANY GREATER SERVICE INCLUDING
HOUSING FROM BEING RAISED MORE
THAN 10% DURING A DECLARE
DISASTER.
UNFORTUNATELY UNSCRUPULOUS
LANDLORDS AND VACATION RENTAL
HOUSE HAVE MANAGED TO SKIRT
THESE PROTECTIONS AND ARE NOW
TAKING ADVANTAGE OF THOSE WHO
LOST EVERYTHING.
AND LESS THAN ONE WEEK THE
MEDIAN RENTAL RATE IN CINEMA
COUNTY JUMP BY OVER 35%.
NEVER DOZENS OF EXAMPLES OF
HOMES BEING OFFERED FOR MORE
THAN DOUBLE THE PRE DISASTER
PRICE OF SIMILAR HOMES.
THIS HAPPENED BECAUSE CURRENT
LAW DOES NOT PROVIDE A METHOD
FOR DETERMINING THE BASE RENT OF
A HOME.
THAT WAS NOT ON THE RENTAL
MARKET BEFORE DECLARE DISASTER
AS RESULT HOMEOWNERS WHO HAVE A
SECOND HOME IN THE AREA HAVE
BEEN ABLE TO PUT THEIR HOME ON
THE MARKET AT WHATEVER PRICE
THEY DEEM FIT.
THE LOSS OF OVER 5% OF
ACCOUNTING COUNTIES HOUSING
STOCK MY DISTRICT IS BECOME A
PRIME HUNTING GROUND FOR
LANDLORDS TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
FIRE VICTIMS.
AB NINETEEN NINETEEN CLOSES THE
NEW RENTAL A LOOPHOLE TO
EXISTING LOOK IN EXISTING LAW BY
DEFINING BASE RENT IS A HUNDRED
AND 60% OF THE HUD FAIR MARKET
PRICE.
THIS DEFINITION PROVIDES A
CLEARLY DEFINED NUMBER FOR BOTH
LANDLORDS AND TENANTS TO ENSURE
EVERYONE IS PLAYING BY THE RULES.
I'D LIKE TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
STAFF AND STAKEHOLDERS FOR THEIR
WORK ON THIS BILL AS WE CONTINUE
TO WORK THROUGH THE UNIQUE
ISSUES THAT COME OUT OF THESE
TERRIBLE CIRCUMSTANCES.
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE -- I
THOUGHT WE HAD A WITNESS BUT I
DON'T SEE HER AT THIS POINT SO.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WITNESSES.
YEAH WERE HIGH CATEGORY BUT THE
WESTERN MANUFACTURED HOUSING
COMMUNITIES ON WERE NEITHER IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION WERE STILL
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR ON
SOMEONE THEN MINCED YUBA CLEAR
UP OUR ISSUES THANK YOU.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
SEE NONE.
BUT CENTER WILK.
YEAH I WILL BE SUPPORTING THIS
BILL THE DAY I THINK I THINK
IT'S A GREAT BILL I HEN I WAS
IN THE SIMPLY I REPRESENTED A
PORTER RANCH THAT HAD THE LEAST
SO CANYON --
GET A GAS LEAK WERE.
OVER TWENTY THOUSAND PEOPLE OF
THE COMMUNITY OF THIRTY THOUSAND
HAD TO MOVE OUT AND THE AND THE
GOUGING WAS RIDICULOUS AND
UNFAIR AND UNJUST SO.
I'M TO BE SUPPORTED THE BILL
TODAY.
THEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER I'LL TELL
YOU THIS IS --
AT THE RIGHT TIME I DON'T KNOW
IF IT'S GOT AN URGENCY --
CAUSE TO IT BUT THIS IS
SOMETHING MORE.
IT'S IT'S HAPPENING A LOT.
WHERE PEOPLE THAT NEVER HAD
THEIR HOMES RENTED BEFORE SAYING
HEY?
THIS IS NOT GALGIANI I NEVER%
READ IT BEFORE SO THIS IS THE
MARKET THIS IS WHAT I'M GONNA DO
IT IT'S THAT.
REALLY CREATED PROBLEMS I WILL
BE SUPPORTING YOUR BILL TODAY.
WE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE.
FILE ITEM FIVE AB NINETEEN
NINETY WHAT WE NEED A MOTION.
MOVES ARE LARA.
AB NINETEEN NINETEEN MOTION IS
DUE PASSED TO APPROPRIATIONS
DODD AYE AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE
WILK AYE BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER HILL [inaudible]
HUESO.
LARA RIGHT LARA AYE PORTANTINO
BIDAK ALRIGHT BIDAK AYE WIENER.
AYE WIENER AYE.
THAT'S IT WILL TAKE A VOTES WILL
HOLD ROLL OPEN VERY MUCH THANK
YOU VERY MUCH SOMEONE MEMBER.
SO REMEMBER SANTIAGO.
WE HAVE AB.
TWELVE SEVENTEEN HERE ARE.
ALSO MEMBERS BILLION.
THIS IS THEY HAVE.
SO WERE READY.
FOR BUT YOU MISTER CHAIR HOW ONE
OF FIRST THINK VIA COMMITTEE FOR
THEIR WORK AND I WANT EXCEPT VIA
COMMITTEE MEMBERS HAVE SUGGESTED --
AB TWELVE US IN IN THE IF THE
CHURCH PREFERS I WOULD BE BRIEF.
YEAH WE DO HAVE A SUPPORT
SUPPORT YOU'D ACCEPTED THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WE HAVE A
SUPPORT SUPPORT SO.
AND YEAH I THINK.
I ACCEPT THEM [inaudible]
GOOD ANSWER.
YOU KNOW WHAT THEY ARE.
HE SHOULD ABOUT THAT WHEN YOU
SAID YOU BEFORE YOU SAID I
ACCEPT THEM AND WHERE I SHOULD
PUT HIM [inaudible]
I'M.
ALRIGHT LET'S MOVE ON AND IT'S
JUST A TIME IN ONE OF MY
WITNESSES A DAUGHTER JUST THE
WATER JUST BROKE IN OREGON ANY
NEEDS TO CATCH A PLANE.
SAW SIMPLY SAY THAT A. B. --
TWELVE SEVENTEEN WILL AUTHORIZE
A A. B. C. A TO ISSUE A SPECIAL --
ONLINE AND A GENERAL ALCOHOL
BEVERAGE LICENSE TO HOLLYWOOD
SENATE UP FOREVER CEMETERY IN
LOS ANGELES.
I THINK MISTER CHAIR AND I NOW
TURN IT OVER TO OUR WITNESSES
WILL ALSO BE BRIEF.
MY NAME IS G. V. AIRS I M. --
GOING TO BE A GRANDFATHER FOR
THE THIRD TIME TODAY.
I REPRESENT HOLLYWOOD FOR EVER
THE SPONSORS.
TWELVE SEVENTEEN I APPRECIATE MR
LOPEZ'S --
THOROUGH ANALYSIS AND THE
AMENDMENTS WHICH NARROW FOCUS
THE BILL.
I THINK YOU VERY MUCH HOLLYWOOD
FOREVER CEMETERY IS AN ICONIC
CEMETERY AND LOS ANGELES --
WHILE WE FULFILL ITS OUR
FUNDAMENTAL PURPOSE OF HONORING
THE DEAD HOLLYWOOD FOR EVER TO
BECOME A CENTER OF CULTURAL AND
SOCIAL ACTIVITY FOR THE LIVING.
I WANT INTRODUCED AYE COUPLE
PEOPLE --
FOR HERE FOR QUESTIONS GUY J.
BALK BOILEAU HOLLYWOOD
EXECUTIVES VICE PRESIDENT AND
DIRECTOR OF CULTURAL EVENTS AND
THEN ALFORD I FRY LOW.
I WAS SHEPHERD MORE WHEN A LAW
FIRM AND LOS ANGELES ON BEHALF
OF MADAM [inaudible]
HOLLYWOOD FOREVER.
THANK YOU OUR FATHER WITNESSES
SPORT.
WITNESS IN OPPOSITION.
BOSNIA SAY LISA FOR THIS BILL
DIED YOU HAVE A PLACE.
FOR NEVER MIND ALRIGHT SO I'D
MEMBERS.
WE HAVE A MOTION AND BY --
SYMBOL SENATOR CANNELLA --
THIS HAS A DO PASS
RECOMMENDATION.
WE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE FILE
ITEM THREE AB TWELVE SEVENTEEN
MOTION IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
BY DODD AYE WILK AYE.
WILK AYE BRADFORD.
CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE GAME
GAINES AYE GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
HELL.
HUESO.
LARA AYE LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
BIDAK BIDAK HIGH WIENER.
THAT SIX HOLDEN THAT SIX WILL
HOLD ROLL OPEN SOMEONE MEMBER
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU SIR THANK YOU TO THE
WITNESSES [inaudible]
YEAH.
AND MANY MORE.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IN THIS AREA
[inaudible]
AND AND THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS.
I'LL JUST JUMP RIGHT INTO IT AB
TWENTY SIX EIGHTY ONE WOULD
REQUIRE BUILDING DEPARTMENTS AND
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO CREATE AN
INVENTORY POTENTIALLY
SEISMICALLY.
VULNERABLE BUILDINGS WITHIN
THEIR JURISDICTION AND SUBMITTED
TO THE OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
SERVICES TO CREATE A STATEWIDE
INVENTORY.
CALIFORNIA HAS THOUSANDS OF
BUILDINGS THAT ARE KNOWN TO
PRESENT A HEIGHTENED EARTHQUAKE
RISK OF DEATH INJURY AND DAMAGE
BASED ON THEIR AGE STRUCTURAL
SYSTEM SIZE AND LOCATION.
THE MOST RECENT CALIFORNIA
SHAKEOUT STUDY ESTIMATES THAT A
MAJOR QUAKE ALONG THE SAN
ANDREAS FAULT COULD CAUSE MORE
THAN TWO HUNDRED BILLION.
DOLLARS IN PHYSICAL AND ECONOMIC
DAMAGE AND EIGHTEEN HUNDRED OR
MORE DEATHS.
JUST LAST MONTH ARIZONA RAND
DISASTER DRILLS IN ANTICIPATION
OF RECEIVING. FOUR HUNDRED
THOUSAND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIANS
FOLLOWING SIGNIFICANT SEISMIC
ACTIVITY ON THE SAN ANDREAS
FAULT.
THE CHRONIC LABOR AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING SHORTAGES MOST
CALIFORNIA CITIES ALREADY SUFFER
WOULD DRAMATIC DRAMATICALLY
INCREASE FOR YEARS TO COME
FOLLOWING A LARGE EARTHQUAKE.
WHILE SOME CITIES MOST NOTABLY
LA AND SAN FRANCISCO HAVE
IDENTIFIED VULNERABLE BUILDINGS
AND IMPLEMENTED MANDATORY
RETROFITS LARGE PARTS OF THE
STATE HAVE NOT.
AN ACCURATE STATEWIDE BUILDING
VULNERABILITY MAP IS AN
ESSENTIAL FIRST STEP IN
DEVELOPING LONGER TERM SOLUTIONS
TO MITIGATE THE EFFECTS OF A
MAJOR EARTHQUAKE.
AND BY THE WAY THIS IS NOT A
MITIGATION DEL --
I'M JOINED BY MISTER LESS LOW
BALK JUNIOR ON BEHALF OF THE
UNITED STATES GREEN BUILDING
COUNCIL.
AND MISTER EDWIN LOMBARD OF ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA BLACK
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER RYAN CHRIS
THING.
CHAIR OF THE STRUCTURAL
ENGINEERS ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE COMMITTEE.
TO ANSWER YOUR TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS [inaudible]
OKAY.
I WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
IF YOU GOT SOME TO TALK TO SAY
PLEASE NASA OF I'M MY NAME'S LOS
LOBOS I'M THE IT PRESIDENT FOR
EQ OPTIMIZER WHICH IS A
CONSULTING FIRM THAT DEALS WITH
ENVIRONMENTAL.
AND RESILIENCY MATTERS WE JUST
COMPLETED A SIX MONTH INDEPTH
STUDY FOR THE CITY OF BOSTON ON
THAT.
FILES SO ADVISE THE U. S. GREEN
BUILDING COUNCIL AND RESILIENCY
AND OTHER MATTERS OF THE US
GREEN BUILDING COUNCIL WITH THE
COMPANY.
ORGANIZATION TO OVER TWELVE
THOUSAND COMPANY SMALL LARGE
BELONG THERE.
IN THE MEMBERS OF THOSE
COMPANIES EMPLOYEES IN TURN
PARTICIPATE.
IN THE GREEN BUILDING A MOVEMENT
WHICH IS FOR UTILITY ENERGY
ENVIRONMENTAL AND NOW RESILIENCY
ISSUE.
A WE RECOGNIZE IT THE EARTHQUAKE
IN SEISMIC ACTIVITIES IN
CALIFORNIA OUR OWN PREVENTABLE.
BUT WE CAN TAKE MEASURES TO DEAL
WITH THE POTENTIAL NEGATIVE
IMPACTS WOULD HAPPEN TO OUR
SOCIETY HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
BOTH INTERVIEW IN LIFE BUILDINGS
INFRASTRUCTURE --
ECONOMICS WHICH WOULD BE
DEVASTATING AS WELL AS THE
ENVIRONMENT.
THE US GREEN BUILDING COUNCIL
HAS HAD A LETTER TO MEMBERS OF
THIS COMMITTEE AND OTHERS.
AND THAT IT HAS DISTRIBUTED
COPIES THAT LETTER TO ITS
MEMBERSHIP THROUGHOUT THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA STRONGLY
SUPPORTING THIS IMPORTANT MAJOR
NOT JUST FOR THE PRESENT
GENERATION BUT FOR GENERATIONS
TO COME.
AND I URGE YOU TO PLEASE PASS IT
THANK YOU [inaudible]
NEXT YES MY NAME'S EDWIN LOMBARD
REPRESENTING THE REASON A BLACK
CHAMBER OF SAN FERNANDO VALLEY
AND THE BLACK CHAMBERS OF
COMMERCE OF WELL I AM A BLACK
BUSINESS ASSOCIATION.
OF OF WRITTEN GREATLY REDUCE MY
STATEMENT FOR TIME.
WHEN BUILDINGS THE DAMAGED BY
EARTHQUAKE THERE A RED TAG IN
SMALL BUSINESS OFFER SETTINGS A
SETTING OFF?
A RESIDUAL WAVES OF HARDSHIP
THAT CAN DEVASTATE ECONOMIES.
EVERY SHUDDERED OF BUSINESS
BRINGS UNEMPLOYMENT TO A
COMMUNITY.
EVERY WORKER LEFT HOMELESS
LEAVES A HOLE IN THE LOCAL
WORKFORCE THE GREATER THE DAMAGE.
THE MORE SEVERE THE DEVASTATION
TO TRADE INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE
BUSINESS RED TAG FROM.
EXCUSE ME THE THREAT OF
EARTHQUAKES IN CALIFORNIA IS
VERY REAL.
BUILDING OWNERS AND TENANTS HAVE
A RIGHT TO KNOW THE PERSONAL AND
ECONOMIC RISK OF BUT THEY FACE
WHEN IT COMES TO THE SAFETY OF
THE BUILDINGS THEY USE FOR THEIR
OPERATIONS AND FOR THEIR HOMES.
AB TWENTY SIX EIGHTY ONE WILL
IDENTIFY CALIFORNIA'S VULNERABLE
COMMUNITIES AND PROVIDE A
THOROUGH ASSESSMENT OF THE
POTENTIAL IMPACTS WE FACE AS A
STATE WE SUPPORT AB.
TWENTY SIX EIGHTY ONE THANK YOU
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
MISTER CHAIR IF I MAY JUST --
RANCOR SUMA SIAKI AND WE'RE HERE
TO ANSWER QUESTIONS DAY IN
SUPPORT OF BILL THANK YOU SIR.
I THANK YOU CARE MEMBERS
DUNGEONS COME BEHALF THAT THE
EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH
INSTITUTE IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
WITNESSES OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
WHERE IT
?
THANK YOU CHAIR MEMBERS OF MY
NAME'S KATIE ALLMA I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING OFFICIALS TO TESTIFY ON
THIS BILL.
AS LOCAL ENFORCEMENT FORSMAN
OFFICERS BUILDING OFFICIALS ARE
GOVERNED WITH THE TASK OF
ADMINISTERING THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING CODES.
THE BUILDING AND SAFETY
REQUIREMENTS FOR COMMERCIAL AND
RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURES ARE
CONSTANTLY CHANGING WITH OUR
SURROUNDING ENVIRONMENT.
BUILDING OFFICIALS MUST MEET
THESE EVER EVOLVING REQUIREMENTS
TO ENSURE PUBLIC SAFETY AND
COMPLIANCE.
AB TWENTY SIX EIGHTY ONE THE
PLACE ADDITIONAL BURDENS ON
LOCAL BUILDING DEPARTMENTS BY
MANDATING THAT EACH DON'T
BUILDING DEPARTMENT.
NOT ONLY IDENTIFY CREATE AN
INVENTORY OF POTENTIALLY
VULNERABLE BUILDINGS BUT ALSO
INFORM EACH OWNER THAT THEY'RE
BUILDING HAS BEEN DEEMED A SUCH.
UPDATE THE BUILDING INVENTORY IN
THE TRACK ALL EXISTING DOCUMENTS.
REQUIRING LOCAL BUILDING
DEPARTMENTS TO TAKE ON THIS
RESPONSIBILITY WOULD BE COSTLY
ESPECIALLY CONSIDERING THAT NO
FUNDING HAS BEEN SECURED FOR
THIS MEASURE.
CALVET WAS CONCERNED WITH THE
LACK OF FUNDING PROVIDED IN THIS
MEASURE IT WOULD BURN IT ALREADY
OVER EXTENDED BUILDING
DEPARTMENT BY ADDING THESE
ADDITIONAL DUTIES WITHOUT ANY
FUNDING.
CALVO SUPPORT SEISMIC RESILIENCY
EFFORTS IT SUPPORTS THEIR
DEVELOPMENT.
HOWEVER WITH A STATEWIDE MANDATE
BE PLACED ON ALL CALIFORNIA
BUILDING DEPARTMENTS WE MUST
HOLD A STRONG OPPOSE.
A STATEWIDE MANDATE DOES NOT
TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE DIVERSE
NATURE OF CALIFORNIA'S REGION'S
CITIES AND POPULATIONS.
COMBOS SUPPORTS LOCALITIES THAT
ARE DEVELOPING THEIR OWN SEISMIC
ORDINANCES IN A TURN SUPPORT
THEIR LOCAL DISTRICT NEEDS THANK
YOU [inaudible]
THAT'S PAT GOOD MORNING --
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
RUN AGREE TO GO HERE ON BEHALF
OF THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA
CITIES --
WHILE WE APPRECIATE BEING --
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS LEADERSHIP ON
SEISMIC SAFETY --
ISSUES IN THE STATE AND
INCLUSION IF THEY CALL PROCESS --
UNFORTUNATELY WE STILL ARE
OPPOSED TO THE BILL IN ITS
CURRENT FORM.
I'M AS AS CURRENTLY DRAFTED IM
AB TWENTY SIX EIGHTY ONE A WE
SEE AS AN UNFUNDED MANDATE --
ON ALL FIVE ENGINE FORTY CITIES
AND COUNTIES ARE THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIA.
CUT THE BILL ALLOWS CALLOW YES
TO SIMPLY IDENTIFY --
BUT NOT NECESSARILY SECURE
FEDERAL STATE AND LOCAL FUNDS
FOR THIS BILL TO BECOME
OPERATIVE --
IN OTHER WORDS THIS ENTIRE
PROGRAM COULD FALL --
SQUARELY JUST ON THE BACKS OF
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS --
WHO HAVE A LIMITED RESOURCES
THAT HE AS YOU KNOW --
MEN ARE CONSTANTLY --
HAVING TO MAKE TOUGH CHOICES AYE
IS SPECIALLY AS IT RELATES --
TO BY RESPONDING --
TO EMERGENCY EMERGENCIES EXCUSE
ME.
CA WHAT MORE INFORMATION IS
BETTER AND WE DON'T DISAGREE
WITH THE MERITS OF THAT --
THIS BILL WILL ACTUALLY REQUIRE
BUILDING OWNERS TO MAKE THEIR
BUILDINGS SAFER UNFORTUNATELY --
AND AND THE ONLY THING THAT I
WOULD ADD IS IS THAT IF THIS
WERE A PIE IF THIS REALLY IS A
PRIORITY THAT --
WE WOULD WE WOULD SUGGEST --
THAT THERE'D BE A A FUNDING HAVE
SECURE FOR THIS FOR THIS PROGRAM
US WITH THAT WE WOULD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOU KNOW
VOTE.
A BUT DO APPRECIATE THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS LEADERSHIP ON THIS ISSUE
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING AYE TRACY RYAN ON
BEHALF OF THE WORLD COUNTY
REPRESENTS OF CALIFORNIA AND
ALSO WITH CALIFORNIA STATE
ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES ALSO IN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU
[inaudible]
OKAY [inaudible]
MEMBERS [inaudible]
YEAH.
SENATOR GAINES YEAH YEAH I AM.
I GOT A CONCERN --
JUST THE TERMS OF THE THE
EXPOSURE SO WE REALLY HAVE
EXPOSURE PRIMARILY IN LA IN THE
SENATE SAM CISCO HERBARIA.
SUMMARY ABOUT PUTTING IN PLACE --
REGULATORY --
GOOD WORK.
WELL YOU MEAN LIABILITY.
YEAH I I SORT.
THERE'S NO LIABILITIES GIVEN TO
WELL THAT THE CHALLENGE THOUGH
IS THAT.
I THINK VIRTUALLY EVERY BUILDING
IN THE CITY CALIFORNIA.
IS PRONE TO EARTHQUAKE DAMAGE.
WE WE DON'T HAVE THAT MANY
EARTHQUAKES BUILDINGS IN THE SIX
CALIFORNIAS IN OUR SETTING.
IN PLACE OF REGULATORY --
SYSTEM --
THAT IS GOING TO MAKE A
DETERMINATION ON EXPOSURE. FOR
BUILDINGS AND YOURS OVER SETTING
THAT.
AND A BLANKET OF THE ENTIRE
STATE WHICH HAS DIFFERENT
EARTHQUAKE EXPOSURE SO.
THE SACRAMENTO AREAS PERRY IS
NOT REALLY PRONE --
TO AN EARTHQUAKE AS COMPARED.
TO THE LA AREA OR THE BAY AREA
SO.
I JUST THINK YOU'RE GONNA.
FROM MY VANTAGE ABOUT VANTAGE
POINT I THINK THERE'S IT'S A TWO
OBTRUSIVE. FOR BUILDING OWNERS
IN THE STATE WHEN YOU HAVE KIND
OF UNEVEN EXPOSURES THROUGHOUT
THE STATE.
AND IF IT WERE CRAFTED IN A WAY
WHAT WE'RE LIMITED.
ON PARTICULAR COUNTIES I THINK
THAT WOULD.
MAKE MORE SENSE.
BUT I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER BUT
INSTEAD OF DUPLICATING WHAT AN
ASK BRIAN.
TO GET INTO IT MORE HAPPEN
ANSWER SENATOR OF THE BILL HAS
BEEN WRITTEN WITH LANGUAGE IT
ESSENTIALLY CARDS OUT THE MOST
HIGHLY SENSITIVE REGIONS OF THE
STATE.
SO THERE'S A TRIGGER ON THE
ACCELERATION THE THE SEISMICITY
OF THE AREA AND SO THE CENTRAL
VALLEY AREA FOR EXAMPLE A IS AN
AREA OF LESS SEISMICITY AND SO
WE'VE CARVED OUT THAT IN THESE
BUILDINGS WOULDN'T HAVE TO BE
IDENTIFIED IN SEARCH.
REGION'S SO THERE'S A THRESHOLD
OF VERY SCIENTIFIC NUMBER --
AND THAT WE'VE HELPED TO
IDENTIFY MOSTLY THE COASTAL
CALIFORNIA CERTAINLY THE BAY
AREA AND THE LOS ANGELES BASIN
BALL ALONG THE COAST AS WELL ARE
COME THE AREAS OF HIGH SEISMIC
SEALER TARGETED BY THIS BILL.
OKAY ALRIGHT --
ANOTHER CHALLENGE I HAVE WITH
THAT THOUGH IS THAT YOU'RE.
NOW PUTTING A COST ON BUILDING
OWNERS WITHIN THOSE AREAS THAT
YOU'VE IDENTIFIED.
THAT IS NOT GOING TO GO HUESO.
NOW I'VE GOT A REPORT THAT SAYS
YOUR BUILDING IS NOT EARTHQUAKE
SAFE WHICH WILL BE VIRTUALLY ALL
THOSE BUILDINGS.
SECONDLY YOUR HAPPENING EXPOSURE
NOW FROM A LIABILITY STANDPOINT
WHICH TO CREATE LITIGATION.
THIRDLY YOU'RE IN REDUCE ABOUT
PROPERTY VALUES AS A RESULT OF
HAVING A REPORT SAYING THERE'S A
EARTHQUAKE DAMAGE PRONE.
AS I'M JUST WORRIED ABOUT WHAT
YOU'RE SETTING UP AND THE
CHALLENGES THAT WILL BE GOOD.
FOR A LOT OF PROPERTIES IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I WOULD HAVE
BEEN MORE THAN HAPPY TO COME AND
MEET WITH YOU IN YOUR OFFICE AND
SPEAK WITH YOU BUT I THINK
YOU'VE ALREADY COME TO YOUR OWN
CONCLUSION ON THIS --
THE REALITY IS THAT THERE'S NO
EXPOSURE NOR LIABILITY.
WHEN YOU PURCHASE A PROPERTY YOU
ALREADY ASSUMED LIABILITY ANYONE
HERE WILL SAY THAT?
THAT'S WHY THE CITY OF LA HAS
IDENTIFIED OVER WAS FIFTEEN
THOUSAND BUILDINGS PERSONAL
LIABILITY AT EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT
ONEROUS ADDITIONAL LIABILITY ON
ANY OF THESE.
BUILDING OWNERS THE REALITY IS
THAT.
IF WE DON'T KNOW WHAT WE'RE
DEALING WITH THEN WE DON'T KNOW
WHAT WHAT ASSISTANCE TO ASK.
FOR AND THIS BILL.
BUT WHEN I HAD FIRST INTRODUCED
IT WAS LOOKING AT DOING THREE
THINGS AND I AM AND I'LL ADMIT
IT WAS VERY BIG AT THAT TIME.
WHOSE IDENTIFYING THE NUMBER OF
BUILDINGS IT WAS MAKING AN
ASSESSMENT PROCESS.
AND THEN IT WAS MITIGATING.
I'VE TAKEN OUT THE LATTER TWO
PARTS.
SO IT'S BEEN DRASTICALLY REDUCED
IT IN COST IT'S ONLY.
IT'S ONLY.
BASICALLY AN IDENTIFICATION TOOL
RIGHT NOW.
AND EVERY MOST CITIES OR
JURISDICTIONS NO.
ALREADY WHAT BUILDINGS ARE
VULNERABLE AND IF THEY DON'T IN
ALL HONESTY --
AYE I FEAR FOR THOSE
JURISDICTIONS BECAUSE THEY'RE
GONNA BE.
STREAMLINED VULNERABLE WHEN A
MAJOR SEISMIC ACTIVITY TAKES
PLACE THEY SHOULD ALREADY KNOW
WHAT BUILDINGS BASED ON THEIR
COATS.
THAT HAS BEEN ON THE BOOKS FOR A
LONG TIME [inaudible]
A THAT IS GONNA PUT THEM IN WHAT
WEAK POSITION WHEN SOMETHING
WENT A DISASTROUS SITUATION LIKE
THIS HAPPENS.
SO THERE ISN'T ANY LIABILITY AYE
I DON'T HAVE ANYBODY ELSE REALLY
WANTS TO ADDRESS THIS BUT I
THINK.
I DO.
IF THIS THERE WAS LIABILITY
FOURTEEN JURISDICTIONS
THROUGHOUT THE COASTAL
CALIFORNIA.
UP PARTS OF OF THE STATE WOULD
NOT HAVE IDENTIFIED.
THEIR OWN INVENTORY LIST AND
THAT'S PARTIALLY BECAUSE THE
STATE WASN'T TAKING LEADERSHIP
AND DOING THIS.
SENATOR WELCOME THANK YOU
APPRECIATE IT.
WELL YOU KNOW I SURVIVED THE
NORTHRIDGE EARTHQUAKE AND SAW
THE DEVASTATION FIRSTHAND I WAS
THE CHIEF OF STAFF TO STATE
LEGISLATOR AT THE TIME HER
HOUSES RED TAGGED.
AS THE EPICENTER WAS IN OUR
DISTRICT I SAW APARTMENT
BUILDINGS COMPLETELY LEVEL.
AND WE'VE ALSO TRAVEL TO THE
ARMENIAN TOGETHER AND THAT
EARTHQUAKE WAS IN NINETEEN
EIGHTY EIGHT AND THEY'RE STILL
THERE STILL DAMAGING COUNTRY.
FROM THAT SO I THINK THIS IS
PROACTIVE JUST LIKE WE'RE TAKING
STEPS TO BE PROACTIVE ON
WILDFIRES --
BECAUSE THAT'S THE NEW NORMAL
WELL HE'S NOT A QUESTION OF IF
IT'S A QUESTION A WIN HOW THESE
ARE GOING TO OCCUR I THINK YOU
HAVE THE PROPER CARVE A CAR
BALLOTS.
AND I AM PREPARED TO SUPPORT
YOUR BILL TODAY AND I WILL MAKE
THE MOTION WHEN IT'S APPROPRIATE.
IT'S LIKE CLOTHES.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE BOAT
AYE PETE WHERE YOU ARE.
SAY CAN YOU STATE ON THE RECORD
EXCEPT THE AMENDMENTS PLEASE
[inaudible] OH YES --
YES I THINK WE'RE TAKING THE
AMENDMENTS [inaudible]
YOU THINK [inaudible]
BUT IT WAS JUST AN ISSUE OF
TIMING RIGHT I THINK WE'RE
TAKING IT IN IN IN THE NEXT
COMMITTEE.
YES GOOD FOR YOU.
THIS IS THE NEXT THIS IS THE
NEXT COMMITTEE YES.
SO YES YOU'RE TAKING THE MAMMOTH
YES THANK YOU ASSEMBLY YOU.
THANK YOU PROCEED I DIDN'T
MENTION THAT BEFORE I FORGOT.
I WAS A HELL OF A CLOSE.
A CALL ROLE PLAYS WE HAVE A
MOTION FIRST.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR HILL.
FILE ITEM I MOVED FILE ITEM
NINETEEN AB TWENTY SIX EIGHTY
ONE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
BY DODD I WILL DIE WILK AYE AYE
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES NO GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
LARA [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BIDAK.
RIGHT ACT NO WIENER. ONE THREE
FOUR FIVE TO TO HOLD IT. TO KEEP
THE ROLE OPEN THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OF A MEMBER.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER LOW. TWO TWO
BILLS.
START OUT WITH I REMEMBER TO A.
B. [inaudible]
EIGHTY EIGHT EXCUSE ME
[inaudible]
I GUESS.
YEAH START WITH WHATEVER ONE YOU
WANT ARE AT IT.
OF AWFULLY THERE ARE BOTH EASY
BUT THE OF THAT THEN DOLLAR
LIMIT JUST GET TO A ASSEMBLY
BILL.
TWENTY FIVE YEAH YET TOOK --
TWENTY FIVE SEVEN THREE WHICH IS
WITH RESPECT TO CLASS WHERE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE
[inaudible]
BUT WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS BOTH
ELECTION WITH ANHEUSER BUSCH IN
SUPPORT.
AND BRIAN REESE ON BEHALF OF
MILITARISM SUPPORT.
OTHER WITNESSES SPORT WITNESSES
OPPOSITION.
MEMBERS BILL.
A MOTION BY SENATOR WILK.
WE'D LIKE TO CLOSE EXPECT
ESCRIBO IF YOU DID THAT SO.
BOAT FILE ITEM SIXTEEN AB TWENTY
FIVE SEVENTY THREE MOTION IS DUE
PASSED TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD
AYE.
DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE
GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
LARA [inaudible]
PORTANTINO.
BY TACK WIRE BIDAK AYE WIENER
[inaudible] SEVEN ZERO I HAS
SEVEN VOTES WILL HOLD ROLL OPEN
THANK YOU SEMI MEMBER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND IS THAT
MISTER CHAIR BY MIGHT ASSEMBLY
BILL --
EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT THANK YOU
AGAIN OF FOR ALLOWING US TO WORK
WITH YOUR COMMITTEE IN YOUR
COUNTY STAFF AND HOW WE LIKE TO
ACCEPT THE A COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS.
NOW -- THIS
AS YOU KNOW SEEKS TO DELETE THE
SUNSET FOR THEY ARE FIFTY FIFTY
RAFFLES WHICH ALLOWS OUR MAJOR
SPORTS LEAGUES TO SUPPORT
CHARITABLE FOUNDATIONS.
AT TODAY IS WITH ME IN SUPPORT
OF MONACO THE SAN JOSE SHARKS IN
AND YOU GOVERNOR WITH ITS
EMPHASIS CHO FORTY NINERS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE
[inaudible]
OKAY.
WHEN THIS SPORT?
RIGHT THERE --
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS I WANNA FIRST THANK YOU
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK
WITH YOU TODAY I'M AS HE SAID I
MONICA NISKANEN I'M WITH THE SAN
JOSE SHARKS FOUNDATION AND I AM
THE FIFTY FIFTY SUPERVISOR.
SO AS A FIFTY FIFTY SUPERVISOR I
SEE FIRSTHAND THE IMPACT THAT
THIS RAFFLE HAS MADE --
IN MY COMMUNITY.
I AM VERY PROUD TO RUN THE
RAFFLE AND WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO
MAKE AN INCREASE OF 20% IN OUR
ANNUAL GIVING.
SENDS THEN THE M. INCEPTION OF
THE RAFFLE.
WE HAVE --
PROVIDED FUNDING TO TWENTY
ADDITIONAL CHARITIES ANNUALLY
AND WE'VE GIVEN BACK NEARLY ONE
MILLION DOLLARS TO OUR COMMUNITY
AND THE TWO YEARS WE'VE RUN THE
RAFFLE.
THE MONEY HAS GONE TO A VARIETY
OF CLOCK CAUSES INCLUDING CANCER
SUPPORT IN RESEARCH EDUCATION
MILITARY AND VETERANS MENTAL
HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT. TO
BE CHOSEN AS A FIFTY FIFTY
BENEFICIARY --
ARE NON PROFITS HAVE TO GO
THROUGH OUR EXTENSIVE GRANT
PROCESS THEY HAVE TO BE A FIVE
OH ONE C. THREE PUBLIC CHARITY
IN GOOD STANDING WITH THE IRS.
THEY AND 51% OF THE FUNDS MUST
STAND SANTA CLARA COUNTY. ONE OF
OUR BENEFICIARIES CASSIE HOW
MANY OF YOU MAY HAVE SEEN OUR
SUPPORT LETTER --
THEY ARE COUNSELING SUPPORT
SERVICES --
FOR YOU AND THEY IF THEM FROM
THE FIFTH IF YOU RAFFLE THEY
WERE ABLE TO PROVIDE FIVE
HUNDRED ADDITIONAL STUDENTS WITH
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES ON THEIR
SCHOOL CAMPUSES.
AND IN ADDITION TO MONETARY
SUPPORT WHERE INCREASING
AWARENESS FOR THESE --
NOT LOCAL NONPROFITS THEIR
MISSION IS BEING SPREAD TO OUR
FANS IN GAME ANDTHROUGH OUR
VARIOUS MEDIA CHANNELS --
IN MY PERSONAL OPINION ONE OF
THE GREATEST BENEFITS THAT HAS
COME FROM THE RAFFLE IS OUR
FLEXIBILITY OF FUNDS.
FOR A DISASTER RELIEF WE'VE
GIVEN --
NEARLY A HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLARS IN DISASTER RELIEF
THROUGH AWFUL FUNDS ALONE FOR
CAUSES SUCH AS THE CINEMA.
AND NAPA FIRES ON IN ADDITION
WHO WE HAVE BEEN COMPLETELY
TRANSPARENT THROUGH THIS PROCESS
WE FILE IN NINE NINETY EVERY
YEAR WE SUBMIT OUR ANNUAL REPORT
TO THE BUEAU OF GAMBLING AND
WHO WE WILL PROVIDE A COMMUNITY
ANNUAL REPORT THAT'S ON OUR
WEBSITE AND DISTRIBUTED. TO MANY
OF OUR SUPPORTERS WHICH HAS A
BREAKDOWN OF ALL FUNDS GIVEN TO
A FIFTY FIFTY IT'S BEEN A GREAT
TWO SEASONS THAT WE'VE RUN THE
RAFFLE WERE ALWAYS LOOKING TO DO
MORE -- IN
SUBMARINES THE RAFFLES ALLOWED
US TO MAKE A GREATER IMPACT ON
OUR COMMUNITY BY BOTH PROVIDING
PUBLICITY AND FUNDS TO MORE
LOCAL NONPROFITS.
AND IT'S GIVEN OUR FANS WHO ARE
JUST THERE TO WATCH A HOCKEY
GAME A CHANCE TO MAKE A
DIFFERENCE IN OUR COMMUNITY --
THANK YOU AGAIN FOR YOUR TIME
AND CONSIDERATION I APPRECIATE
IT MAN HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS [inaudible]
YOU.
XANDER GOVERNOR ABOUT THE CENSUS
CHO FORTY NINERS LOS ANGELES
DODGERS OF KANYE'S AND SAN DIEGO
PADRES INSTANCES COULD GIANTS.
A AND WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL CLEAR THE SPONSORS OF THE
BILL THREE YEARS AGO THIS
LEGISLATURE GRANTED THE ABILITY
FOR SPORTS TEAMS AROUND FIFTY
FIFTY RAFFLES. TO TRY AND GET
MORE MONEY TO NON PROFITS IN
THEIR COMMUNITY IT STARTED IN
CANADA AS A WAY TO REALLY GET
FANS ENGAGE IN GIVING AND IT'S
BEEN A TREMENDOUS SUCCESS.
OVER THE PAST TWO YEARS OF THE
PROGRAM WE'VE RAISED AN UPPER TO
TEN MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR FOR
CHARITY. FOR INSTANCE THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS HAVE FORTY FOUR
HOME GAMES THEY DEDICATE EVERY
SINGLE HOME GAME TO A DIFFERENT
CHARITIES OF THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS IF THIS SUNSET ISN'T
REMOVED.
AND THEN YOU CAN TELL FORTY FOUR
CHARITIES THAT THEY CAN'T GET
THAT INDIVIDUAL SUPPORT AND
THOSE FORTY FOR CHARITIES WILL
TELL YOU.
IN ADDITION TO THE MONETARY
SUPPORT THEY GET THE MARKETING
IN THE RECOGNITION OF HAVING
YOUR CHARITY ANNOUNCED OVER AND
OVER. TO THOUSANDS OF FANS AT A
KINGS GAME IS ALMOST BETTER THAN
THE MONETARY DONATION AS MONICA
SAID.
BEAST SPORTS TEAM CHARITIES TWO
ONE THREE THAT OTHER CHARITIES
IN THE STATE DON'T THEY FILE
THEIR NINE NINETY FORM THAT
EVERY CHARITY FILES.
THEN THEY FILE THEIR BUREAU OF
GAMBLING INTRO REPORT WHICH
DETAILS ARE FIFTY FIFTY RAFFLE
THEN THE CHARITIES THEY GIVE THE
MONEY TO REPORT THAT THEY ARE
RECEIVING THE MONEY.
SO THERE ARE THREE PUBLICLY
AVAILABLE REPORTS OUT THERE AND
I PULLED UP EVERY SINGLE REPORT
MYSELF ON THE AGES WEBSITE NOT
THE EASIEST WEBSITE TO MANEUVER --
BUT I WAS ABLE TO GET IT AND ALL
THE INFORMATIONS THERE SO WE
BELIEVE THE SUNSET SHOULD BE
REMOVED WE BELIEVE THE BILL THAT
WE BELIEVE THIS PROGRAM SHOULD
CONTINUE SO THEY COULD RAISE
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS FOR CHARITY
THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
CHARITIES LIKE LA FAMILIA CHECKS
IN CRISIS VISION TO LEARN HOME
FOR OUR TROOPS OPERATION CARE
INCOME FOR IT IS A LIST OF
HUNDREDS IF NOT THOUSANDS OF
CHARITIES THAT ARE NOW GETTING A
NEW INFUSION OF MONEY.
THANKS TO FIFTY FIFTY RAFFLES
AND FOR THAT REASON WE ASK FOR
YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU.
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT THEN
WENT ON TO HAVE A GOLDEN STATE
WARRIORS IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
BUSCA MAPS OF THE SAN FRANCISCO
GIANTS IN SUPPORT.
NAOMI RODRIGUEZ ON BEHALF OF THE
LOS ANGELES DODGERS IN SUPPORT.
BETH RELIGION DOT COM BE OUT
THIS IF CISCO FORTY NINERS
SUPPORT.
PRETTY GOOD PRETTY GOOD.
OKAY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
PLEASE.
I SO.
I AM THE CEO OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF NONPROFITS A
STATEWIDE ASSOCIATION OF MORE
THAN TEN THOUSAND NON PROFITS.
AND I AM ALSO A WARRIORS GIANTS
AND FORTY NINERS FAN --
DIDN'T EXCUSE ME IN CALIFORNIA
ONLY NONPROFITS CAN LEGALLY HOLD
RAFELSON THAT'S WHY WE IS A
NONPROFIT ASSOCIATION ARE VERY
INTERESTED IN A CONTINUING WAY.
AND MAKING SURE THAT RAFFLE STAY
CHARITABLE RATHER THAN BECOMING
GAMBLING AND THAT RAFFLE LAWS
ARE ADEQUATELY ENFORCED.
AS WE TESTIFIED IN TWENTY
FIFTEEN WHEN THIS BILL FIRST
CAME UP.
BUT HAVING FIFTY FIFTY RAFFLE
SIGN THIS SCALE RUNS A
SIGNIFICANT RISK OF HAVING THE
PUBLIC BEGAN TO SEE RAFFLES
MORRIS GAMBLING RATHER THAN IS
CHARITABLE ACTIVITY.
WHICH HAPPENS TO BE THE NUMBER
ONE CONCERN OF OUR TEN THOUSAND
MEMBERS WHEN IT COMES TO THE
ISSUE OF RAFFLES.
BUT WERE VERY GLAD TO SEE SEN
CALIFORNIA GET A LITTLE BIT MORE
MONEY BUT THAT SHOULDN'T BE THE
ONLY MEASURE [inaudible] FOR
EXAMPLE.
THE TEAMS COULD ALSO PUT SLOT
MACHINES IN THEIR STADIUMS MAKE
MORE MONEY GIPSON NONPROFITS BUT
WE WOULD OPPOSE THAT AS WELL.
THE NINETY TEN PROVISIONS THAT
ALL OTHER CHARITIES ARE GOVERNED
BY INSURE THAT THE PRIMARY
PURPOSE OF A RAFFLE IS TO
BENEFIT THE POP PUBLIC GOOD IT
JUST DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FOR
MAJOR LEAGUE AND MINOR LEAGUE
TEAMS. TO HOLD HIGH DOLLAR
RAFFLES AT THE SPCA THE
NEIGHBORHOOD CHURCH THE ROTARY
AND THE PTA CANNOT HOLD THEM
WITHOUT BREAKING THE LAW.
WHEN THE LA AUTHORIZING
EXCLUSIVELY?
RULES FOR MAJOR LEAGUE TEAMS
WITH ENACTED THE AUTHOR
EMPHASIZES IT WITH SUB SUNSET IN
THREE YEARS.
AND THAT THERE WOULD BE DATA ON
HOW THEY HAVE BEEN OPERATING
UNFORTUNATELY DOJ HAS NOT
APPROPRIATED THE FUNDS TO
OVERSEE THIS PROGRAM AND WE DO
NOT KNOW THE ANSWERS TO THESE
QUESTIONS OUR OWN ANALYSIS OF
THE REPORTS FILED BY THE TEAM
FOUNDATIONS.
APPEAR TO BE INCOMPLETE
INADEQUATE OR MISSING ALTOGETHER
AND WHAT WE DO SEE RAISES A
GREAT MANY QUESTIONS FOR EXAMPLE
IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN THE LOS
ANGELES DODGERS.
FOUNDATION REPORTED IN THE
ELEVEN OF THE NINETY RAFFLES
THAT THEY CONDUCTED THAT THERE
WAS NO WINNER.
WHAT OES COME THROUGH FROM THE
REPORTS IS THAT THE PRIMARY
BENEFICIARIES OF THESE RAFFLE SO
THE TEAMS FOUNDATIONS?
NOT THE COMMUNITY EFFORTS SUCH
AS VETERANS ORGANIZATIONS THAT
PORT OF THE LOT IN ANTICIPATION
OF FUNDING.
IT'S PREMATURE TO REMOVE THE
SUNSET COOPER SUNSET CLAUSE
PERMANENTLY WITHOUT THE
ACTIVITIES BEING EITHER
ARCHITECTURE ANALYZE.
THE AMENDMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN
PROPOSED ARE HELPFUL IN
STRENGTHENING THE SELF REPORTING
REQUIREMENTS BUT THEY'RE STILL
WHOLLY INADEQUATE FOR US TO BE
ABLE TO REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL.
OTHER WITNESSES EDITION.
MISTER CHAIR --
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE POETRY
ON BEHALF OF BOTH THE CHONG AND
COLUSA TRIBES.
AND I THINK WHAT YOU'LL FIND IS
WITH OTHER TRIBES TO THAT WILL
BE TESTIFYING IS THAT WE HAVE
NOTHING AGAINST FEHERTY'S WE
OURSELVES GIVE MILLIONS TO
CHARITIES EACH YEAR.
THIS WAS AN EXTREMELY GENEROUS
GIFT THAT THIS COMMITTEE AND THE
OTHER HOUSE GAVE. TO SPORTS.
TEAMS TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THIS
FORM OF GAMING BECAUSE IT REALLY
IS GAMING.
I MEAN WHEN YOU HAVE A AN
AVERAGE JACKPOT OF BETWEEN FIVE
THOUSAND AND A HUNDRED AND
THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND OF THOSE
ARE HUGE SLOT MACHINE PAYOUTS IT
ANY CASINO THAT ARE ARE
AUTHORIZED BY CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENT.
SO THE QUESTION THAT WE HAVE IS
IT IS NOTHING AGAINST THE
CHARITIES BUT BECAUSE THIS ISN'T
A HUGE EXPANSION OF GAMING I
THINK THAT THE MAJORITY OF THE
TRIBES WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE
SUNSET. FOR ANOTHER ONE OR TWO
YEARS AND FOR DOJ THAT ALREADY
HAS IT IN THE ORIGINAL LAW TO
AUDIT.
THE FOUNDATIONS FROM THE MOMENT
THE PROGRAM TOOK PLACE TO SEE IS
IT TRULY GOING TO CHARITIES IS A
JUST BEING HELD WITH THE
FOUNDATIONS --
IS IT TRUE AND I'VE SEEN IT
KINGS DAMES YOU CAN SIT IN YOUR
SEAT AND PUT UNLIMITED AMOUNTS
ON YOUR CREDIT CARD TO MAKE A
PURCHASE.
IT THE SAME GAMES --
ROOM IT'S ADVERTISE THAT IT GOES
TO A CERTAIN CHARITY AND WE KNOW
FROM THE RECORDS AT THE END OF
THE NIGHT A SMALL PORTION GOES
TO THE CHARITY BUT NOT A FIFTY
FIFTY SO I'M JUST SAYING THERE'S
LOTS OF QUESTIONS FOR THE AMOUNT
OF MONEY THAT'S HERE.
UMP FOR THE EXPANSION THAT YOU
GAVE AND EXPANSIONISM MEAN --
WHICH OTHERS HAD TO GET
CONSTITUTE [inaudible]
PASS IS THAT IT DOESN'T SEEM
UNFAIR TO ME TO ASK FOR A ONE TO
TWO YEAR EXTENSION OF THE SUNSET
WITH AN AUDIT TO DOJ BY
DIRECTING DOJ.
AND IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE A
FISCAL NOTE BECAUSE IN THE BILL
SAYS THAT THEY CAN CHARGE THE
FOUNDATIONS TO MAKE SURE THAT
THEY AUDITS DONE.
SO THAT'S THE REQUEST FROM THE
TRIBES [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
OTHER WITNESSES OPPOSITION
CAROLINE BEALE HUNTER ON BEHALF
OF YOUR TODAY HE WENT TO NATION
WE WOULD ALIGN OUR COMMENT SOME
WITH WITH THEM THE PREVIOUS
OFFICE BUT PREVIOUS SPEAKERS BUT
SPECIFICALLY ONE IS THAT THAT WE
THOUGHT DEPARTING FROM THE
TRADITIONAL NINETY TEN RAFFLE
WAS A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN THE
LAWS.
GOVERNING.
RICK CAROLL RAFFLES AND SO WE
THINK THAT OVERSIGHT IS CRITICAL
SO WE BUT CERTAINLY LIKE TO SEE
AN OP AND WILL I THINK WHEN WE
PASSED WE ALSO DID WITH THE
UNDERSTANDING THE DOJ WOULD BE
DOING SOME SORT OF A REVIEW.
AND THAT KIND REVIEW IT'S
CRITICAL AT THIS STAGE SO WE
WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE EXTENSION
OF THE SUN SET FOR AT LEAST TWO
MORE YEARS OF WE CAN HAVE THAT
AUDIT THAT WITH SOME.
THAT WE WERE POLITICAL BEFORE WE
RUN TO THE IMPRESSION THAT WE
WOULD BE HAVING THAT SORT REVIEW
THANK YOU.
TURN MEMBERS FRICKLEY DIFFERENT
SALMON WHILE BETTER MISSION IN
ITS INITIAL MISSION IS PRETTY
SHAPE THE AUTHOR SEPARATES HERE
WE DO AGREE THAT --
NOT IT IS NECESSARY AND WE ARE
FANCIFUL HAVE THE PREVIOUS WELL
THANK YOU.
CHAIR NUMBER IS NOT EQUIPPED US
WITH THE CANTON A CRUISE COMPANY
ON BEHALF OF THE VA HUSBAND OF
COMMUNITY INDIANS WE ALSO ALIGN
OUR OPPOSITION TO THE PREVIOUS
COMMENTS WE FEEL IT'S SIMPLY TOO
SOON FOR US ON THAT REMOVAL
WOULD PREFER AN EXTENSION AS
WELL AS MORE OVERSIGHT.
THINK YOU.
HELLO AFRICAN ARTISTS FOR THE
RINCON TRIBE APPRECIATE THE THAT
REACHED THE SPONSORS AND THE
AUTHOR OF DONE IN THE COMMITTEES
STUNT. TO WORK TOWARDS --
TOWARD MORE OF MORE LANGUAGE
READING AUDIT AND AND
TRANSPARENCY --
NOT SURE IT'S QUITE ENOUGH FOR
THE RINCON TRY BUT WE RESTORE
REVIEWING THESE AMENDMENTS AND
WE'LL LET YOU KNOW THANK YOU OR
PROSECUTE.
THEY COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
SKINNER LAR BUT THEY ARE AFTER.
LARA THE QUESTION ON THE THE OF
OPPOSITION TALKED ABOUT THE
ISSUE THAT HAPPENED WITH THE
DODGERS.
WHERE THERE WAS NO WINNER?
THAT CLAIMED THE THE THERE HAVE
FOR THE PRIZE.
MY UNDERSTANDING UNDER THE BILL.
SOME OUT DODGERS AND NO WINNER
KINDA HA HA GENERATES A BILL
THAT [inaudible] TO SAY.
I'LL TAKE IT DOWN --
YOU'LL BE.
SO MY UNDERSTANDING IS WHEN THAT
HAPPENS IN THE BILL IN THE SKY
SUCH A THAT'S A LONG NOW.
THAT MONEY GOES TO THE CHARITY.
SO THEY DID THAT MONEY GO TO THE
CHARITY THEM CORRECT THEY HAVE
ELEVEN NON WINNERS AND THERE WAS
ACTUALLY POINT OUT A DISCREPANCY
IN THE BCG FORM BECAUSE IT TURNS
OUT THE FORM DOESN'T ASK FOR NON
WINNERS THAT'S ONE OF THE OTHER
SHORTCOMINGS IN THE FORM.
THAT ELEVEN NON WINNERS OF A
100% OF THAT MONEY REVERTED BACK
TO THE LARGEST LOS ANGELES
DODGERS FOUNDATION IN THE LOS
ANGELES DODGERS FOUNDATION USES
THEIR FIFTY FIFTY RAFFLES FOR
THEIR DREAM FIELDS PROGRAM. FOR
THEIR I'D BE I PROGRAM IN THE
READING PROGRAM SOLVE THIS
PROCEEDS AND WENT BACK OUT TO
CHARITY AS PER THE BILL IN THE
REGULATIONS.
BUT IT'S NOT THE CHARITY THAT.
THAT DAY OF THE FOR THE DODGERS
DON'T IDENTIFY A CHARITY IN THAT
NIGHT THERE'S TWO WAYS THAT
PEOPLE DO IT SO THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS FOR INSTANCE IDENTIFY
EVERY SINGLE NIGHT OF FORTY FOUR
HOME GAMES.
THEY DESIGNATE TO A CHARITY THAT
THE SACRAMENTO KINGS THEY
ACTUALLY SPLIT 50% OF THE
PROCEEDS OF THAT NIGHT'S CHARITY
THEY TELL THE CHARITIES IN
ADVANCE OF THE 50% THAT GOES TO
CHARITY. 25% WILL GO --
TO HABITAT FOR HUMANITY AND THEN
ANOTHER 25% WILL GO TO THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS FOUNDATION AND
THEN THE SECOND A KINGS
FOUNDATION WILL GIVE THAT MONEY
OUT.
THE DODGERS DEDICATE THEIR MONEY
TO OTHER THINGS SO ON A GIVEN
NIGHT THAT CHARITY IS THE LOS
ANGELES DODGERS FOUNDATION WHICH
THEN GIVES OUT THE MONEY
[inaudible]
AND OKAY.
BEFORE THEY DO IT A COUPLE OF
DIFFERENT WAYS AND THE BILL IS
VERY CLEAR AND IT'S HOW THEY DO
IT AND TWENTY SIX OTHER STATES
AROUND THE COUNTRY.
OUT OF THE DODGERS AND SELECT
THE CHARITIES ARE TO MOUNT.
SUPPORTERS UP TO THEIR
FOUNDATION TO THE FOUNDATION
THEY HAVE AN APPLET THEY HAVE
FOR SO THEY HAVE A CHARTER.
EVERY FOUND EVERY CHARITY OF THE
CHARTER OF WHAT THEY DO ALL THE
SPORTS TEAMS FOCUS ON YOUTH
EDUCATION TRUANCY THINGS LIKE
THAT PHYSICAL FITNESS THAT
WITHIN THE PURVIEW OF THEIR
CHARTER.
THEY THEN ALLOW ANY NONPROFIT TO
APPLY AND THEN THEY WILL SELECT
BASED ON THEIR CHARTER BUT IN
ADDITION THOUGH THE DODGERS ARE
DEDICATED TO THE DREAM FIELD IN
THE RB I PROGRAM AND THE READING
PROGRAM SO THEY THEN USE THEIR
MONEY FROM THE LOS ANGELES
DODGERS CHARITY FOUNDATION. TO
PUT OUT INTO THE COMMUNITY
THROUGH THE DREAM FIELD IN THOSE
PROGRAMS.
COMMANDER OPPOSITION JUST.
I THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR ONTO
THE CHAIR MISTER LARA A JENNIFER
FAN ON BEHALF OF COUNT ON
PROFITS.
AND THAT.
BUT MR GOVERNOR'S RIGHT THERE
THERE ISN'T A PROCESS OUTLINED
IN S. B. FIVE FOUR NINE THAT
STIPULATES THAT THE FUNDS HAVE
TO LETTER REYES BY THE NON
WINNER PORTION OF THE PROCEEDS
GO TO ANYTHING OTHER THAN THE
FACT THAT.
TEAMS FOUNDATIONS THEY ARE THEN
AT THEIR LEISURE IN THEIR
DISCRETION TO TO EITHER SPEND
THOSE ON THEIR OWN NIGHT
NONPROFIT PROGRAMS THAT THEY
OPERATE OR GIVE THEM TO OTHER
COMMUNITY PROGRAMS.
I'M BY I AM CONFUSED A BIT.
ACKERMAN A KINGS FOUNDATION AND
I FEEL SINCE EVERYONE ELSE HAS
WE OFF TO STIPULATE THAT WE ARE
IN FACT FANS I AM KINGS FAN --
BUT THE REPORTS THAT I'VE READ
FROM THE KINGS THE VAST MAJORITY
IN FACT EVERY SINGLE RAFFLE THE
KINGS FOUNDATION IS THE PRIMARY
AS THE PRIMARY --
RECIPIENT OF THOSE FUNDS THEY
OCCASIONALLY HAVE A SECONDARY
CHARITY THAT THE NAME THAT NIGHT
THEN THE REPORTS I REVIEWED THE
ONLY HALF OF THE POT THAT WAS
REMAINING WAS GIVEN TO THAT
CHARITY ON A GIVEN NIGHT.
SO I AM A LITTLE BIT CONFUSED
ABOUT THE NOTION THAT IT EVERY
SINGLE GAME THEY WERE GIVING UP
TO OTHER CHARITIES THAT'S NOT
HOW IT'S BEEN DONE.
BUT I WANT TO BE CLEAR THAT'S
BECAUSE THE LEAGUE REGINALD LAW
DIDN'T REQUIRE THIS TO BE DONE
IN ANY PARTICULAR WAY AND THESE
ARE AMONG THE CONCERNS THAT WE
HAVE.
THAT ABSENT DE OF MEANINGFUL DOJ
OVERSIGHT OF THIS PROGRAM IN ANY
AUDIT WE HAVE NO ONE TO ASK
THESE QUESTIONS OF AND WE HAVE
NO WAY TO KNOW WETHER WE SHOULD
BE ADJUSTING.
OUR POLICY OF HOW THESE UNFAIR
RAFFLES ARE BEING OPERATED AND
WE CAN'T HAVE A MEANINGFUL
STAKEHOLDER DIALOGUE ABOUT IT
BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A STATE
AGENCY THAT UNDERSTANDS IT WELL
ENOUGH.
TIME TO ANSWER THE QUESTIONS I
THINK THAT THE CHARITABLE SECTOR
IS RIGHT CITY POSING AND THAT'S
WHY WE THINK IT'S PREMATURE TO
EXTEND THE SUNSETFOREVER.
WITHOUT GETTING IT ON A BETTER
HANDLE ON IT.
YOU US SENATOR GAINES YES THANK
YOU AND DIO.
I THINK ASSEMBLY MEMBER LOW FOR
BRINGING THE BILL FORWARD AND
I'M WONDERING IF YOU COULD JUST
HELP US --
IN TERMS OF THE AUDIT RELATED
QUESTIONS IS IT DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE'S WOULD BE FOLLOWING UP
ON THIS.
AND WHY HAVEN'T THEY AND IS THAT
MOVING FORWARD.
YOU COULD HELP YES SIR --
TO THIS IMPASSE Y. IT'S ALREADY
IN IN STATUTE AND GO CODES --
I CAN'T SPEAK FOR THE PART
JUSTICE BUT IT AMENDMENTS SAID
TAKING THIS COMMITTEE --
CLARIFIES ADDITIONAL --
TRUE.
AS WELL WITH ALL STAKEHOLDERS TO
ENSURE THAT WE CAN HAVE
DEPARTMENT JUSTICE SIMILARLY
LOOK INTO THAT OKAY DO SO.
AS A RESULT OF YOUR LEGISLATION
WILL THERE BE --
MORE TRANSPARENCY IN TERMS OF
HOW THESE CONTRIBUTIONS OR OF
THE MADE I MEAN THERE'S ALREADY
REPORTING GOING ON RIGHT WE KNOW
WE KNOW THAT'S HAPPENING --
WE JUST NEED TO ADD IT THERE'S
YOUR BILL GET THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE ACTING SALUTE THEY'RE
DOING.
SOMETHING.
LOVE IT WILL BE WE WANT TO USE
THIS AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
ADVANCE THAT CONVERSATION AND
THAT'S A BUT THIS IS ALSO ABOUT
IT AGAIN.
AMENDMENTS TAKING IN THIS
COMMITTEE AS WELL WE'VE JUST
THAT EARLIER ACCEPTED A CLARIFY
THAT TO TRYING TO GET ADDITIONAL
TRANSPARENCY OKAY AND THEN
BECAUSE WE AGREE WITH THAT
COMPONENT OKAY GREAT AND THEN
SECONDLY ON THIS ISSUE SUNSET --
IS THAT SOMETHING YOU'RE OPEN TO
IN TERMS OF LOOKING AT THE
SUNSET WITH THIS PROGRAM GIVEN --
THE CONCERNS BY THE OPPONENTS.
OTHER THAN THAT'S NOT CURRENTLY --
AN ISSUE THAT WE HAVE AS WITH
THE BILL THAT IS PRESENTED
BEFORE YOU BEGAN WITH A
SIGNIFICANT --
ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN INTERESTS
WITH RESPECT TO TRANSPARENCY
AGAIN WE ARE HAVING.
CONVERSATIONS TO ENCOURAGE
DEPARTMENTS AT TO FURTHER THAT
CONVERSATION.
NUCLEAR FIGHT HOPE THIS YOU
WOULD CONSIDER THAT AS IT MOVES
FORWARD BECAUSE I THINK THERE
ARE SOME LEGITIMATE CONCERNS ARE
BEING RAISED AS IT MOVES FORWARD
I SUPPORT.
I SUPPORT WHAT YOU'RE WHAT
YOU'RE DOING I LIKE THE IDEA OF
FOUND.
PURCHASE PAYING A FIFTY FIFTY
RAFFLE BUT I THINK THEY'LL BE
SCRUTINIZED IN THE SAME WAY AS A
NONPROFIT WOULD --
IN TERMS OF THE AUDIT ASPECT AND
I THINK THE CONCERN ABOUT SUNSET
IS LEGITIMATE IN THE EVENT THAT.
THERE ARE ISSUES SO [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
SHERIFF I COULD RESPOND TO
CENTER OF NOT TO HAVE BEEN GOING
QUICKLY.
BUT CENTER GAINES THE DEPARTMENT
ACTUALLY ALREADY THROUGH TWO
MECHANISMS HAS THE ABILITY TO
AUDIT THESE CHARITIES I'M JUST
LIKE THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
NONPROFIT WHEN YOU FILE YOUR
NINE NINETY FORM THEIR IDEA OF
AUDITOR'S THERE.
THE DEPARTMENT ISN'T REALLY
DOING ANYTHING IN THE GENERAL
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE THEY HAVE
THE ABILITY TO ADDED ON A
COMPLAINT BASIS THEY TELL US
THEY GET FIFTY COMPLAINTS A WEEK
IN THE GENERAL.
NONPROFIT DIVISIONS THEY HAVE TO
INVESTIGATE WE WERE ON THE CALL
WITH THE DOJ.
SO HE GOT IT.
YET I'LL GIVE YOU EQUAL TIME IT
QUICK I JUST LIKE TO SAY THAT IN
IN AMENDMENTS THAT WE DISCUSSED
WITH THE AUTHORS OFFICE WE WOULD
LIKE TO COMPEL DOJ TO COMPLETE
THAT AUDIT --
YES THEY HAVE THE MAY THEY MAY
AUDIT WE WOULD LIKE TO COMPILE
THEM TAUGHT IT DOESN'T ONLY
EXTEND THE SUNSET WHEN THE
RESULTS OF THAT AUDIT HAVE COME
FOR TO THE LEGISLATURE.
REVIEW BEFORE TAKE ANYMORE OF
CLARIFY WHAT THE AMENDMENTS DO I
JUST THINK IT'S IMPORTANT.
FIRST THE MAN'S WOULD REQUIRE
NON PROFITS TO POST ON EITHER
THE WEBSITE WHERE THE TEAMS
WEBSITE SPECIFIED.
PER RAFFLE INFORMATION INCLUDING
WHO THE BENEFICIARY NONPROFIT IS
HOW MUCH THE NONPROFIT RECEIVED
AS WELL AS THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF
THE PRIZE [inaudible]
SECOND.
YES THIS IS NO THIS IS THESE ARE
THE MEN THAT HE JUST TOOK.
I IN ADDITION THE IMMENSE TO
LEAD THE CURRENT REPORTING
REQUIREMENT INSTEAD REQUIRE NON
PROFITS. TO SUBMIT THE PER
RAFFLE INFORMATION THAT I
MENTION.
NONPROFITS WOULD ALSO BE
REQUIRED TO REPORT THE TOTAL
NUMBER.
OF RAFFLES CONDUCTED PER YEAR
THE TOTAL RAFFLE TICKET SALES.
THE PRIZE TOTALS AS WELL AS
OTHER ANNUAL INFORMATION.
BOTH NEXT BOTH THE NONPROFIT IN
THE D. O. G. WOULD THEN BE
REQUIRED TO POST THAT REPORT.
ON THEIR RESPECTIVE WEBSITES.
SIXTY DAYS AFTER THE INTO THE
LEAGUE SEASON OR YEAR.
MAX I BELIEVE ABOUT.
I BELIEVE THESE THAT IT ONE OF
THE REASONS WHY I ASK FOR THESE
IS I HAVE A LOT OF STAKEHOLDERS
THAT WE'RE COMING TO BE.
YOU KNOW ONE IN THESE DODD THESE
WEIRD THINGS ARE VERY VERY
IMPORTANT SO THAT WE HAD --
YOU KNOW TRANSPARENCY WITHIN THE
SYSTEM AND EVERYTHING WAS ON THE
UP AND UP THE MINUTES ALSO
PROVIDED DEPARTMENT THOUGH WITH --
A MUCH MORE RELEVANT INFORMATION
WHICH THEY AS THE ENFORCEMENT
AGENCY CAN USE TO DECIDE IF THEY
WANT AUDIT IN THE NONPROFIT.
N. AS THE OVERSIGHT AGENCY THE
DOJ.
COURTESY EIGHT ANYTHING THEY
WANT [inaudible]
IN SO.
THE O. N. I REALLY BELIEVE IF
THE DOJ FIXERS A PROBLEM AND BY
THE WAY THEY CAN GET RECEIVE
COMPLAINTS.
FROM ANYBODY THAT'S CONCERNED
ABOUT THIS PROGRAM THEY THEN
HAVE THAT WITHIN THEIR ABILITY.
TO EITHER INSTIGATE THAT
REPORTER NOT CENTER LARA.
THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THE THE
AMENDMENTS THAT CAN COMMIT MAKES
A BILL BETTER AND AGAIN I AM
SUPPORTIVE OF THE OF OF WHAT
WE'RE TRYING TO DO HERE AND I
SUPPORT THE BILL.
COUPLE YEARS AGO.
MONEY.
BUT THE PROBLEM HAVING AS THAT --
THE FOUNDATIONS OF THE FAITH OF
THE GIANTS FOUNDATION.
KEEPS THE MONEY AND THEN THEY
DETERMINE WHERE THAT MONEY'S
GOING TO GO.
TO THAT CAN SERVE VARIOUS AND
OTHER INTEREST SO THAT'S THE
ONLY THING THAT THE ONLY ISSUE
THAT I'M HAVING WITH BUT YOU
KNOW SOME MORE TRANSPARENCY AND
APART WOULD BE.
IMPORTANT FOR ME BUT JUST FOOD
FOR THOUGHT AS WE MOVE FORWARD
CENTER BUT ASSEMBLY MEMBER LOW
COULD YOU JUST RESPONDED THAT AS
YOUR CLOTHES ORDINARY CLOTHES.
WHATEVER YOU WANTED.
I APPRECIATE THAT OBSERVATION
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE.
OKAY WITH THAT.
THE CALL THE ROLL PLEASE FILE
ITEM TO A THIS HAS A TO PASS AT
RECOMMENDATION.
DO PASS AS AMENDED AB EIGHT
EIGHT EIGHT MOTION IS DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD
AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA
AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WET SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE AYE TAX BY THAT
AYE WIENER.
AYE WIENER AYE.
SO THAT'S TWELVE EXCLUSION.
TWELVE WILL HOLD THE ROLE OF OF
FOR ONE MORE MEMBER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH LOVE THANK
YOU IT IS.
OKAY WE'RE GONNA START FROM THE
TOP WE'RE GONNA OPEN THE ROLE
[inaudible]
TAKE CARE.
STARTING WITH THE CONSENT
CALENDAR CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ABSENT MEMBERS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GLAZER [inaudible]
WEST SO.
I WESO AYE LARA CLOSED LARA AYE
PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I SAW ELEVEN ZERO
HOLDING OPEN FOR GLAZER CLOSER
HOLD IT OPEN --
ITEM NUMBER ONE A. B. EIGHTY
GRAY.
AS A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.
THIS SAYS SENATE RULE TWENTY
NINE TEN MEASURES TO BE RE REFER
TO APPROPRIATIONS AB EIGHT
EIGHTY FILE ITEM ONE MISSING
MEMBERS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER.
WEST SO.
WES SO FIVE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE RIGHT ACT.
FIGHT ACT AYE. ELEVEN ZERO
ELEVEN ZERO LEVIN ZERO PULLED
OVER.
ON ITEM NUMBER TWO IT IS
EVERYBODY IN THE ROOM THE VOTED
ON THAT.
WE JUST VOTED ON THAT GREAT I'M.
THREE AB TWO TWELVE SEVENTEEN
SANTIAGO MOTION AS YOU PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
MEMBERS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HILL.
HILL AYE WESO.
HUESO AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VIED ACT.
I'M RIGHT AYE WIENER.
WIENER AYE [inaudible] ELEVEN
ZERO SEVEN ZERO I NEXT NUMBER
FOUR WE DO NEED A MOTION ON FOUR
AND EIGHTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN
MOTION BY SENATOR WILK.
BUT WHAT MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES [inaudible]
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER [inaudible]
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WEST SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE I'D ACT.
BIDAK AYE WIENER [inaudible]
WIENER AYE [inaudible] ELEVEN
AUTOMOTIVE [inaudible] TEN TENTH.
OKAY SO --
AT WORK FILE ITEM.
SEVEN WE NEED A MOTION ON THAT.
WITH.
AND SEVEN LAST [inaudible]
TO SO I IT'S A BAD THOUSAND
KALRA.
YEP WE NEEDED I FILE ITEM
[inaudible]
FIVE DO.
FILE ITEM FIVE AB NINETEEN
NINETEEN MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
ABSENT MEMBERS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER.
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WET SO I PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE.
SO THAT'S ELEVEN DESIRABLE DOZER
WILL HOLD THAT OPEN.
I DON'T KNOW SEVEN WE DO NEED A
MOTION.
BUT MOST BY SENATOR HILL ITEM
SEVEN AB TWO THOUSAND MOTIONS
YOU PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
AYE AYE DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK
AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA
AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER HILL PARK
HILL AYE HUESO.
WAS SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE I'D ASK.
BIDAK AYE WIENER [inaudible]
WIENER AYE. TWELVE TWELVE VOTES.
ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TWO ó
EIGHT SEVEN MOTION IS DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
ABSENT MEMBERS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GLAZER [inaudible]
HUESO.
WESO AYE LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
PORTANTINO I SO THAT'S TWELVE
ZERO TWELVE ZERO TWELVE ZERO AND
ITEM NUMBER TEN AB TWENTY ONE OH
SIX MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT MEMBERS
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GLAZER [inaudible]
WHAT'S SO.
SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VITA.
BITE ACT BY TWELVE ZERO VOTES --
ZERO ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN RUBIO A
TWENTY ONE TWENTY FOUR MOTION IS.
MOTION A MOTION ON THAT SO MOVED.
THERE A MOTION BY WILK CENTER
WILK AB TWENTY ONE TWENTY FOUR
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
DODD AYE DODD AYE WILK BY WILK
AYE BRADFORD WHY.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES I GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
I WAS SO I LARA.
LARA I PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VITA.
AYE AYE WIENER.
WIENER AYE.
THIRTEEN ZERO THAT'S OUT.
I HAVE.
TWELVE WE NEED A MOTION AB --
TWO TWO FIVE BY --
SENATOR LARA MOTION IS TO PASS
TO APPROPRIATIONS DOT AYE DODD
AYE WILK HIGH WILK AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL HILL AYE HUESO.
AYE HUESO AYE LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO PORTANTINO
I'VE I ACT.
BY THAT KIND WIENER.
WIENER AYE THIRTEEN ZERO
THIRTEEN AB TWENTY TWO FIFTY TWO
WE NEED A MOTION [inaudible]
SOME OF MOTION IS YOU PASS
THROUGH APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE
DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA
AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WEST SO I LARA.
FLOOR AYE PORTANTINO
[inaudible]
PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VITA OUR FIGHT
AYE WIENER.
WIENER AYE.
THIRTEEN ZERO USERS --
NEXT ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN TWENTY
FOUR FIFTY TWO REGULAR CURRY
MOTION IS DUE PATRICK.
WE HAVEN'T HAD ANY EMOTION.
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE DODD AYE
WILK AYE WILK AYE AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HILL HILL AYE HUESO
HUESO AYE LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE BY TAX BITE OUT
WIENER AYE. THIRTEEN ZERO ZERO
ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN TWENTY FOUR
SIX THAT I BERMAN WE NEED A
MOTION.
MOTION IS DO BRADFORD MOTIONS DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES GAINES AYE
GALGIANI AYE GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
HUESO AYE LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
I PORTANTINO AYE VITA.
BIDAK AYE WIENER.
AYE WIENER AYE.
THIRTEEN ZERO OR TWO ZERO ITEM
NUMBER SIXTEEN CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE WESO.
WEST SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE WIENER
[inaudible]
WIENER AYE.
AS IS THIRTEEN ZERO ZERO A ITEM
NUMBER SEVENTEEN CALDERON AB
TWENTY SIX FIFTY A POSER DEL
SHARON.
WILK PROMOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD ON DODD I
WILL TRY WILK AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES GAINES AYE
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WITH SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE IDEA.
BIDAK AYE WIENER.
WIENER AYE. THIRTEEN ZERO
THIRTEEN ZERO ESOS OUR EAT
KNOCKED OUT A NUMBER. NINETEEN
TWENTY SIX ANYONE IS THERE A
CALL THAT'S ABOUT.
APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT MEMBERS
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE.
GLAZER [inaudible]
GLAZER.
LIKE YOU KNOW GLAZER AYE
[inaudible]
HUESO.
PUESTO AYE LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
PORTANTINO I BUT WIENER.
I WIENER AYE.
MANY.
NINE TEN TO TWO BUT ONCE TEND TO
DRUGS OUT --
THIS WITH --
AB TWENTY SEVEN TWENTY NINE
UMBER SUCI --
WE NEED A MOTION.
I WILL MOVE THE I WILL MOVE THE
BILL JUST FROM THAT MEMBERS NOW
WE HAVE REACHED A A AN AGREEMENT
HOUNDS CERTAIN RESEARCH GOING TO
DROP HIS BILL.
AND I WILL BE A PRINCIPAL
COAUTHOR OF MIND WITH THE
AMENDMENTS WERE TAKING AND FROM
HAS SUGGESTIONS TALK.
MOTION IS.
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE AYE DODD
AYE WILK.
WITH THOSE COMMENTS FROM CENTER
LARA HOBBY AND AYE.
WILK AYE BRADFORD [inaudible]
CANNELLA [inaudible]
GAINES.
GAINES NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
LAKE [inaudible]
GALGIANI I GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WEST SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VITA.
DESPITE ACT NO WIENER.
WIENER AYE. ONE BRADFORD I ONE
TWO SEVEN NINE TEND TO TWO TO
BILLS ABOUT.
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY THREE AB
TWENTY SEVEN FORTY EIGHT SHALL.
MOTION MOTION WILL.
MOTION MODE MOTIONS YOU PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE DODD AYE
WILK AYE WILK AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA CANNELLA
AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
ITEM TWENTY THREE JOBS.
QUEST SO I LARA.
ARE AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE VITA.
FIGHT ACT AYE WIENER.
I'VE.
WIENER AYE. THIRTEEN ZERO ZERO
THAT BILLS OUTSIDE OF THE TWENTY
FIVE AB TWENTY SEVEN SEVENTY
SEVEN CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
PLEASE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT MEMBERS
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
PORTANTINO I THAT'S TWELVE ZERO
VOTES ZERO THE BILL'S OUT ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY SEVEN AB TWENTY
THIRTEEN IRWIN WE NEED A MOTION
[inaudible]
LARA.
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE DODD AYE
WILK AYE WILK AYE AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES GAINES AYE
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
HUESO AYE LARA AYE LARA AYE
PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE RIGHT ACT FIGHT
ACAI WIENER.
WIENER AYE. THIRTEEN ZERO THIRTY
EIGHT ZERO THE PILLS OUT ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY EIGHT AB TWENTY
EIGHT EIGHTY TWO OBERNOLTE.
RENEE. TWENTY THREE TWENTY
TWENTY TWO SCUSE ME.
SO LARA.
MOTION IS DO PASSED MOTIONS YOU
PASSED APPROPRIATIONS DODD.
WELL I WILK AYE AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE.
CANNELLA CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HILL HILL AYE HUESO.
HUESO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE I'D ACT.
BIDAK AYE WIENER.
WIENER AYE.
TWELVE ZERO THAT BILLS OUT.
TWELVE ZERO ABOUT. TWO TWENTY
EIGHT NINETY TWENTY EIGHT NINETY
EIGHT GLORIA.
WE NEED A MOTION ON THAT YES WE
GOT.
SAID A LARGE MOTION IS DUE
PASSED TO THE FLOOR DODD AYE
DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES GAINES AYE
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
GLAZER AYE HILL HILL AYE HUESO.
WAS SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE I'D ACT.
RIGHT ACT AYE WIENER.
I'VE WIENER AYE THIRTEEN ZERO
TWO ZERO THAT BILLS OUT ITEM
NUMBER THIRTY THREE TWENTY AND
FIFTY EIGHT QUIRK AND WE NEED.
THIRTY TWO AB TWENTY FILE ITEM
THIRTY TWO AB TWENTY NINE
FOURTEEN MOTION IS TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD
AYE.
DODD AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE
BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES GAINES AYE
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
GLAZER AYE HILL HILL AYE HUESO.
WHAT'S SO I LARA.
LARA AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I'VE AYE ACT.
BY ACT AYE WIENER AYE WIENER AYE.
THIRTEEN ZERO THIRTY THREE THERE
UNDER DIFFERENT --
TWENTY NINE FIFTY A QUIRK MOTION
PLEASE [inaudible]
BRADFORD.
MOTION IS MOTION IS TO PASS
THROUGH APPROPRIATIONS DODD AYE
DODD AYE WILK.
I WILK AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER GLAZER AYE HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO --
WHEN?
LARA AYE PORTANTINO [inaudible]
BY THAT.
BY DAK I YEAH IRAQ I WILL WIENER
[inaudible]
WIENER AYE.
THAT IS TWELFTH.
ZERO NEXT IS AB THIRTY ONE
NINETY THREE CHAO.
I NEED HIM TO AN ACQUITTAL.
WE NEED A MOTION.
LARA BY LARA MOTION IS DUE
PASSED TO APPROPRIATIONS DODD GO.
DODD NO.
LOOK WELL HIGH WILK AYE BRADFORD
[inaudible]
BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
CANNELLA AYE GAINES.
GAINES NO GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
HILL.
HILL AYE HUESO.
WEST SO I LARA [inaudible]
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
VITA.
BIDAK NO WIENER.
OKAY FUND. THREE FOUR TO THREE A
pSENATOR GLAZER HAS.
MEASURES TO VOTE.
OKAY -- FOR
THOSE MEMBERS A DEMOCRATS WE
HAVE A CAUCUS THAT WERE.
MADE ABOUT A HALF AN HOUR LATE.
FOR I TOLD I ASK YOU TO REPORT
IMMEDIATELY IF NOT SOONER.
I AM YES WE IN THE MAKE SURE
HE'S ON THE CONSENT.
I THINK HE IS.
A LITTLE TRICKIER PROBLEM.
THERE.
OKAY [inaudible]
VERY.
CONSENT CALENDAR. FOR THE REST
OF THE GLAZER [inaudible]
GLAZER I FILE ITEM ONE A. B..
EIGHTY ABSENT MEMBERS GLAZER
[inaudible]
GLAZER I THIRTEEN ZERO FILE ITEM
TO ABA EIGHTY MOTIONS DEPARTS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS UP
MEMBERS GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE THIRTEEN ZERO THAT'S
OUT.
FILE ITEM THREE AB TWELVE
SEVENTEEN MOTION IS TO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT
MEMBERS GLAZER.
I GLAZER AYE.
HE DUCKED OUT [inaudible]
PURCHASE.
ZERO FILE ITEM FOR EIGHTY
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN MOTION IS
TO PASTOR FOR FREEING SENDS OUT
SOME OF THE GLAZER BECAUSE
GLAZER AYE.
THIRTEEN ZERO FILE ITEM FIVE
EIGHTY NINETEEN NINETEEN MOTIONS
YOU PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS
GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE THROUGHOUT.
FILE ITEM SEVEN AB TWO THOUSAND
MOTIONS YOU COST APPROPRIATIONS
GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE.
FILE ITEM NINE AB TWENTY EIGHTY
SEVEN MOTIONS DO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS.
ABSENT MEMBERS PLEASE ARCHIVE.
GLAZER AYE CHURCH STARTED OUT.
FILE ITEM TEN AB TWENTY ONE OH
SIX MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT MEMBERS
GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE STIRRED
[inaudible]
OKAY.
YOU KNOW I THOUGHT THERE WAS
SENT [inaudible]
ITEM.
SEVENTEEN YOU BEYOND THE I HAVE
YOU.
ALRIGHT.
THANK YOU.
OKAY THAT CONCLUDES THE OF
BUSINESS BEFORE --
THE GEO COMMITTEE TODAY IN THIS
MEETING IS NOW ADJOURNED