AND WELCOME TO THE SENATE
COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS
PROFESSIONS IN ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT FOR OUR JUNE TWENTY
FIFTH TWENTY EIGHTEEN HEARING.
WHERE THIRTY SIX BILLS ON OUR
FILE FOR TODAY HOWEVER FILE ITEM
TWENTY HAS BEEN PULLED BY THE
AUTHOR?
WE HAVE FOUR ITEMS --
PROPOSED FOR CONSENT.
pTHIRTY FOUR FILE ITEM TWENTY ONE
AB.
TWENTY SIX EIGHTY SEVEN FILE
ITEM THIRTY FOUR A. B. THIRTY TO
FIFTY SIX AND FILE ITEM THIRTY
FIVE AB --
THIRTY TO SIXTY ONE IN ORDER TO
ACCOMMODATE MR MULLIN WHO IS
PRESIDING OVER TODAY'S ASSEMBLY
FOR FLOOR PROCEEDINGS THAT WE
WILL TAKE UP FILE ITEM.
TWENTY NINE AB THIRTY ONE TEN
FIRST TODAY SO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MONTH PLEASE [inaudible]
COME FORWARD [inaudible]
WELCOME TODAY.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SENATOR
BENEATH YOU. FOR THE
ACCOMMODATION I DO A GREATLY
APPRECIATE IT I KNOW YOU HAVE A
A HEAVY DOCKET TODAY.
SO MISTER CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS CALIFORNIA IS THE ONLY
STATE IN THE COUNTRY THAT DOES
NOT REGULATE THE PROFESSION OF
ATHLETIC TRAINING.
AB THIRTY ONE TEN ESTABLISHES
THE ATHLETIC TRAINING PRACTICE
ACT A BILL CREATES THEM OR LET
ANY TRAINING BEFORE WE START I
APOLOGIZE I JUST WAS A WE ARE
BEGINNING AS A SUBCOMMITTEE
SINCE WE HAVE NOT ESTABLISHED A
QUORUM IS YET.
THEY ARE NOTHING ALREADY SENATOR
THE BILL CREATES THE BOARD OF
ATHLETIC TRAINING AND A
REGISTRATION MECHANISM TO
REGULATE ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
IT ALSO RESERVES THE ATHLETIC
TRAINER TITLE FOR THOSE WHO ARE
NATIONALLY CERTIFIED.
ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE HEALTH
CARE PROFESSIONALS WHO WORK IN A
VARIETY OF SETTINGS SUCH AS
EDUCATION HEALTHCARE
PROFESSIONAL SPORTS AND OTHER
INDUSTRIES.
THEY'RE OFTEN CHARGED WITH
MANAGING SERIOUS MEDICAL
CONDITIONS SUCH AS CONCUSSIONS
HE ILLNESS CITING CARDIAC ARREST
AS WELL AS MUSCULOSKELETAL
ISSUES LIKE DISLOCATIONS AND
FRACTURES.
CURRENTLY THERE'S NO ACCURATE OR
SYSTEMIC WAY FOR THE PUBLIC TO
REPORT EVIDENCE OF HARM AGAINST
ATHLETIC TRAINERS AND HOW THOSE
REPORTS TRACKED.
HOWEVER THERE IS ANECDOTAL
EVIDENCE OF HARM TO PATIENTS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
AB THIRTY ONE TEN REQUIRES THAT
THOSE PROVIDING ATHLETIC
TRAINING SERVICES REGISTER WITH
THE BOARD OF ATHLETIC TRAINING.
WHICH WILL MAINTAIN INFORMATION
ON ATHLETIC TRAINERS WHERE THEY
ARE LOCATED AND THE SERVICES
THAT THEY PROVIDE.
I INTRODUCED AB THIRTY ONE
TENNIS A LICENSE FOR BILL AND
ACCEPTED MAJOR AMENDMENTS TO IT
IN ASSEMBLY BUSINESS AND
PROFESSIONS COMMITTEE TO SCALE
IT BACK SIGNIFICANTLY.
INTO A REGISTRATION ENTITLED
PROTECTION I HAVE WITH ME HERE
TODAY ANTHONY MCLISH THE
ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER OF THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS.
HEAD COACH OF THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS DAVE YEAGER AND DOCTOR
JASON BRALEY THE TEAM'S CHIEF OF
SPORTS MEDICINE TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT WE ALSO HAVE MY CHIPS
ARE.
AN ATHLETIC TRAINER AND PHYSICAL
THERAPISTS REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA ATHLETIC TRAINERS
ASSOCIATION TO ANSWER YOUR
QUESTIONS AND I'M SURE THERE
WILL BE SOME.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
MISTER MOMENT AND BEFORE WE
PROCEED IF WE COULD ESTABLISH A
QUORUM PLEASE PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
HERE HEALTHCARE FULLER.
LAKE HERE ALAN.
DOT.
DOT HERE NOT HERE HERE
[inaudible]
GALGIANI LASER.
LATER HERE HERNANDEZ AND WELL
[inaudible]
I WILL.
THANK YOU DON'T IMMEDIATELY.
ANYWAY BEST GAL YOU KNOW YOU'RE
JUST.
BURGER WE'VE ESTABLISHED A
QUORUM THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND A
COUPLE OF OTHER THINGS THAT THEY
WERE GOING TO HAVE PLAYED OUT
FOR TODAY BECAUSE OF THE SIZE
AND THE LENGTH OF OUR AGENDA WE
WILL ALLOW TWO MINUTES. FOR EACH --
FOR TO MEMBERS TO RESPOND IN
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION AND THEN
THOSE WHO WANT.
TO SPEAKER MORE CAN THAT COME TO
THE MICROPHONE TO MAKE COMMENTS
WE WILL GET A HOLD OF THAT
LOOSELY BUT I DO WANT TO SET
SOME PARAMETERS AROUND AND ALSO.
I WOULD LIKE TO DO WHEN BILLS
COME FORWARD FOR A PRESENTATION --
WE WILL --
ALSO STATE WHETHER THE
REPUBLICAN ANALYSIS SHOWS --
SUGGESTED SUPPORT AND DEMOCRATIC
ONE ALSO IS A SUGGESTED SUPPORT.
SO THAT THAT WAY MEMBERS CAN AND
CAN HEAR THAT THERE WHETHER
THERE'S OPPOSITION OR OR WITH
THE ODDS ARE THERE THEY COULDN'T
WORK AND FIGURE THAT OUT SO.
PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU AND
WELCOME THANK YOU AT DINNER A
CHAIRMAN HELEN SENATORS AND
STAFF ARMENIANS BY CHIPS ARE
WITH THE CALIFORNIA ATHLETIC
TRAINERS ASSOCIATION.
NO WHERE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS BILL.
ON BUT I WILL SEE MY TIME TOO
AND THE PRESENTERS FROM THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS --
AND BE AVAILABLE TO ANSWER
QUESTIONS LATER VERY GOOD THANK
YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON.
I'M MY NAME IS ANTHONY MCLISH
I'M THE ASSISTANT GENERAL
MANAGER FOR THE SACRAMENTO KINGS
AS WELL AS THE GENERAL MANAGER
FOR MINOR LEAGUE AFFILIATE THAT
IS BASED ON STOCKTON.
WE ALONG WITH OTHER PROFESSIONAL
SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS
UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES.
OUR HUGE ECONOMIC GENERATORS IN
THE STATE.
THE CURRENT UNREGULATED STATUS
OF ATHLETIC TRAINERS PLACES
INCREASED LIABILITY ON OUR
ORGANIZATION.
AS WELL AS OTHER ORGANIZATIONS
AND INSTITUTIONS.
AS INDICATED BY THE COALITION
SUPPORTING THE REGULATION OF
THIS PROFESSION.
WE ARE NOT ALONE AND OUR SUPPORT
OF REGULATION OF ATHLETIC
TRAINING PROFESSION.
UNIVERSITIES BIG AND SMALL.
REDLANDS STANFORD AND USC.
PROFESSIONAL TEMS SUCH AS THE
SAN FRANCISCO FORTY NINERS.
AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS LIKE THE
NC DOUBLE A CIF IN THE NHL.
HAVE ALSO PORTED REGULATION OF
THE ATHLETIC TRAINING PROFESSION.
ADDITIONALLY HEALTHCARE
COMPANIES ARE ALSO PART OF THIS
COALITION AND SHARE SIMILAR
CONCERNS. FOR THESE
ORGANIZATIONS AND INSTITUTIONS
ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE THE ONLY
HEALTH CARE PROFESSION.
THAT IS NOT LICENSE.
THE COST OF THIS IS SIGNIFICANT.
WITHOUT A SCOPE OF PRACTICE FOR
OUR ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
ORGANIZATIONS AND SCHOOLS HAVE
NO CERTAINTY ON WHAT THEIR
ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE LEGALLY
ALLOWED TO DO.
THIS PLACE IS ALL OF US AT RISK.
WE ARE ALSO CONCERNED FOR OUR
ORGANIZATION AND OUR ATHLETIC
TRAINERS WHEN WE TRAVEL TO A
NUMBER OF STATES.
THEY REQUIRE OUT OF STATE
ATHLETIC TRAINERS TO BE
REGULATED IN THEIR RESPECTIVE
HOME STATES.
AS A MEMBER OF THE KING'S FAMILY
WE CONTINUALLY STRIVE TO BE AN
INTEGRAL PART OF THIS COMMUNITY.
AND IN AN EXAMPLE OF THE
POSITIVITY OF SPORT.
WE WANT KIDS HERE IN SACRAMENTO
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA WHO PLAY
SPORTS TO BE PROTECTED BY
COMPETENT QUALIFIED INDIVIDUALS.
AND WHILE WE WOULD NEVER HIRE AN
ATHLETIC TRAINER WHO WASN'T
CERTIFIED.
OVER A HUNDRED AND FIFTY SCHOOLS
CURRENTLY DO SO.
BECAUSE OF THIS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOU TO JOIN US INTO QUOTE
AND SUPPORTING AB.
THIRTY ONE TEN BY VOTING YES.
THANK YOU VERY THANK YOU NEXT
WITNESS IN SUPPORT GOOD
AFTERNOON I'M DAVE YEAGER ON THE
HEAD COACH OF THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS AND TRUE AN HONOR TO BE
HERE TODAY THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TIME CHAIRMAN HILL SENATORS.
AND WE APPRECIATE THIS
OPPORTUNITY UP TO SPEAK TO YOU
ON BEHALF OF THE KING'S
ORGANIZATION I LIKE TO EXPRESS
OUR STRONG SUPPORT.
OF FOR AB.
THIRTY ONE TEN WERE VERY
FORTUNATE TO HAVE CERTIFIED
ATHLETIC TRAINERS --
THAT PROVIDES US WITH AN
INCREDIBLY HIGH LEVEL OF CARE
FOR FOR OUR PLAYERS AND WHETHER
THERE WERE PREVENTING INJURY OR
BRINGING THEM BACK FROM INJURY
AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE THE MOST
IMPORTANT THING IS TO BRING THEM
BACK AS SAFELY AS POSSIBLE --
AS A AS A COACH ABA MORE
IMPORTANTLY IN MY PERSONAL LIFE
AS A FATHER.
I DON'T REALLY UNDERSTAND WHY
YOU KNOW STE CAT STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IS THE ONLY.
A STATE THAT DOES NOT REGULATE
THIS PER --
ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE
RESPONSIBLE FOR MANAGING
SIGNIFICANT INJURIES.
AND IT'S DIFFICULT TO EXPECT
SOMEONE WITHOUT THE EDUCATION IN
THE CERTIFICATION TO PERFORM
THESE TASKS.
ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE OFTEN THE
FIRST LINE OF DEFENSE FOR OUR
KIDS AND YET MANY SCHOOLS THAT
RESPONSIBILITY HAS ABDICATED.
SOMEONE WHO HASN'T BEEN DUCATED
HASN'T PROVEN THAT THEY'RE
COMPETENT TO DO THE JOB.
IT'S A LITTLE BIT MORE SCARY.
BECAUSE ANYONE THAT CAN CALL
THEMSELVES AN ATHLETIC TRAINER
PEOPLE BECAUSE OF THAT PEOPLE
ARE UNQUALIFIED.
END UP HAVING TO EVALUATE A
CONCUSSION WE GET INTO
CONCUSSION PROTOCOL AND THOSE
KINDS OF THINGS WHICH I THINK
VERY SERIOUS AS AN NBA COACH.
I KNOW WHAT A CERTIFIED ATHLETIC
TRAINER NEEDS TO DO AND I I
DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY WE ALLOWED
NON QUALIFIED PROVIDERS TO
MANAGE OUR KIDS HEALTH CARE.
AS A MEMBER OF THE KING'S
ORGANIZATION AND AS A COACH
MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY IN THE
IN OUR STATE --
THANK YOU FOR THE TIME AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOU OF
VOTE YES ON AB.
THIRTY ONE TEN VERY GOOD THANK
YOU.
OTHERS IN SUPPORT AFTERNOON MY
NAME IS JASON REALLY HIGH I AM A
LEAD POSITION FOR THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS IN A SPORTS MEDICINE
PHYSICIAN HERE SACRAMENTO A ALSO
ECHO THE OPPORTUNITY IN AND OUT.
THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME BE HERE
THIS AFTERNOON.
AS THE SPORTS MEDICINE POSITION
I COLLABORATE WITH A TEAM OF
ALLIED HEALTH PROFESSIONALS TO
INCLUDE PHYSICAL THERAPISTS.
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST
REGISTERED NURSES PHYSICIAN
ASSISTANTS AND ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
THE ATHLETIC TRAINERS OF THE
ONLY PROFESSIONALS I WORK WITH
THAT ARE NOT LICENSED.
IMPORTANT UNDERSTAND THAT MANY
SCHOOLS RELY ON WHAT THEY CALL
THEIR TRAINER BUT WHO IS NOT
ACTUALLY A CERTIFIED ATHLETIC
TRAINER.
THIS IS A VITAL DISTINCTION.
A CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINER IS
A PERSON WITH A SPECIFIC DEGREE
IN THE RECOGNITION AND
MANAGEMENT.
OF ATHLETIC ORTHOPEDIC AND
MEDICAL CONDITIONS.
I CONTINUE TO BE PERPLEXED AND
ASTOUNDED THE CALIFORNIA REMAINS
THE ONLY STATE THAT DOESN'T
RECOGNIZE THE PROFESSION OF
CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
IN THIS IMPORTANT TIME OF
HEIGHTENED AWARENESS IN THE
REGARD TO THE DANGERS OF SPORTS
RELATED CONCUSSION.
IT'S IMPERATIVE THAT THOSE
TAKING PART IN FIELD SITE
EVALUATION AND MANAGEMENT OF
STUDENT ATHLETES BE TRULY
QUALIFIED TO DO SO.
BUT YET THAT IS NOT WHAT IS
OCCURRING IN CALIFORNIA.
CURRENTLY PEOPLE WITHOUT THE
REQUISITE EDUCATION ARE
MASQUERADING AS ATHLETIC
TRAINERS IN MANY DIFFERENT
ATHLETIC ENVIRONMENTS.
PEARSON STUDENT ATHLETES ARE
LIKELY NOT AWARE WHEN
UNQUALIFIED PERSONS ARE IN PLACE
BUT CONTINUE TO RELY ON THE
SCHOOL'S TRAINER FOR ADVICE.
THIS IS A FRIGHTENING OUT
PROPOSITION.
THERE'S ALSO NO CURRENT MANDATE
THAT PEOPLE WORKING AS TRAINERS
WORK UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF A
PHYSICIAN.
THEY'RE CURRENTLY THOUSANDS OF
CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINERS
PRACTICING IN CALIFORNIA IN A
VARIETY OF SETTINGS WITH A
VARIETY OF PATIENTS.
KERN ENVIRONMENTS WERE CERTIFIED
ATHLETIC TRAINERS PROVIDE
EXPERTISE INCLUDES SCHOOLS
SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS LIKE THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS.
HEALTHCARE FACILITIES THE
PERFORMING ARTS INDUSTRIAL
WORKPLACES AND THE MILITARY.
I UNDERSTAND THAT THERE BEEN
ARGUMENTS MADE THAT ATHLETIC
TRAINERS SHOULDN'T WORK IN THE
SETTINGS.
YET BOTH IN CALIFORNIA AND THE
OTHER FORTY NINE STATES THAT
REGULATE THE PROFESSION. ONE
THIRD OF ATHLETIC WEAR ONE THIRD
OF ATHLETIC TRAINERS WORKING THE
SETTINGS PREVENTING AND TREATING
THE SAME TYPES OF INJURIES THAT
ATHLETES HAVE.
SOMETHING THEIR EDUCATION
TRAINING PREPARE THEM TO DO WITH
A VARIETY OF PATIENT TYPES.
IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THIS HAS
MORE TO DO WITH THEIR DEGREE
NAME RATHER THAN OBJECTIVELY
LOOKING AT THEIR QUALIFICATIONS.
IT WOULD BE SIMILAR TO SAYING
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST SHOULD
ONLY WORK WITH OCCUPATIONAL
PATIENTS HOWEVER WE KNOW THAT
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS ARE
VALUABLE IN THE REHABILITATION
NEEDS.
OF PATIENTS IN AREAS OUTSIDE OF
JUST THE SPECIFIC OCCUPATIONAL
PROBLEM.
WHILE I CENTER IS THE ONLY REAL
SOLUTION TO ALL THE ISSUES THAT
THE CURRENT LACK OF REGULATION
OF ATHLETIC TRAINING PROFESSION
CAUSES.
THIS BILL IS THIS IS STILL A
SENSIBLE AN EXCELLENT FIRST STEP.
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE THE
FOLLOWING.
USING THE NATIONALLY ESTABLISHED
EDUCATIONAL AND CERTIFICATION
CRITERIA FOR ONE TO BE CALLED A
CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINER.
OUTLINED A SCOPE OF PRACTICE
THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH THAT
EDUCATION CERTIFICATION.
SUPERVISION THERE IS CONSISTENT
WITH HOW ATHLETIC TREAT TRAINERS
AND POSITIONS CURRENTLY PRACTICE.
THE EFFORT TO TRAINERS ARE MY
EYES IN YEARS AND MUST HAVE THE
ABILITY TO REACT TO SITUATIONS
IN REAL TIME AS THEY OCCUR.
PROTOCOLS ARE ESTABLISHED LIKE
THEY ARE FOR OTHER HEALTHCARE
PROFESSIONS WHICH DICTATE
TREATMENT AND REFERRAL
PARAMETERS.
THERE IS THERE'S A REASON THAT
THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION THE CALIFORNIA
OSTEOPATHIC PHYSICIAN SOCIETY
AND NATIONAL PHYSICIANS GROUPS
INCLUDING THE AMERICAN SOCIETY
FOR SPORTS MEDICINE.
HAVE SUPPORTED LICENSURE AND ARE
SUPPORTING A. B..
THIRTY ONE TEN IF THIS BILL OUT
ATHLETIC TRAINERS TO WORK
WITHOUT APPROPRIATE SUPERVISION
OR ALLOWED ATHLETIC TRAINERS TO
DO THINGS THAT ARE OUTSIDE THEIR
EDUCATION TRAINING.
THIS BILL WOULD NOT HAVE THIS
LEVEL OF SUPPORT.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR YES
VOTE ON THIS BILL VERY GOOD
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT
PLEASE COME FORWARD AND STATE
YOUR NAME AND AFFILIATION.
AND SUPPORT.
THANK A BUSTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
BOB NAIL REPRESENTING STANFORD
UNIVERSITY IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS BILL THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
AT AGE OUR NUMBERS MAKE IT
ALRIGHT ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
SHARON MEMBERS DUNCAN MCFETRIDGE
REPRESENTING UNIVERSITIES
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA TRANSPORTED
BILL THANK YOU.
GEN NATIONALS REPRESENTING JUST
HIGH SCHOOL SACRAMENTO IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
THANK YOU.
MY NAME IS JOSHUA TO SIGN IN
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR COMING.
AARON SNYDER ATHLETIC TRAINER
SACRAMENTO STATE IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
ANY MCCLURE ATHLETIC TRAINER
CENTER MEDICAL FOUNDATION
ORTHOPEDICS STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
LARA TO SOUTH QUE ATHLETIC
TRAINER WITH BIBLE CHARACTER
BOTH PATIENT AND PICK HER
CONSTRUCTION.
STRONG SUPPORT MAKE YOU.
CHAIR MEMBERS PRICE DOCKERY
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA ORTHOPEDIC
ASSOCIATION IT'S THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
FOR GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS TOM WHO WITH THE
ASSOCIATION OF INDEPENDENT
CALIFORNIA COLLEGES AND
UNIVERSITIES IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
LISA VARNUM UC DAVIS SPORTS
MEDICINE AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
HE LEARN HAD ATHLETIC TRAINER OF
THE STOCKTON KINGS STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ARENDELLE ATHLETIC TRAINER MARIN
ACADEMY IN STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
SARAH GLOBAL ATHLETIC TRAINER
JUSTIN SIENA HIGH SCHOOL IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
YOUNG MEN DIRECTOR OF SPORTS
MEDICINE FOR THE SACRAMENTO
KINGS.
VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT IN
PARTICULAR FOR THE CHILDREN.
I SCHOOL AND AND YOUNGER KIDS IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
THANK YOU WE SHOULD YOU BE HERE.
MIKE COFFMAN AHEAD OF HER
TRAINER SEGMENTS AT COLLEGE IN
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
JOSHUA CARY ATHLETIC TRAINER
SOVEREIGN STATE IN STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MANY ROMERO HEAD ATHLETIC
TRAINER SACRAMENTO KINGS FATHER
THREE EACH SMALL CHILDREN PLEASE
SUPPORT THIS BILL [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
OUR ASSISTANT ATHLETIC TRAINER
SACRAMENTO KINGS IN STRONG
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
OF THINK ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
SEE NO ONE THOSE IN OPPOSITION
PLEASE.
IMPORT OF PERHAPS YOU COULD --
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE YOU BEING HERE TODAY
AND OF AFTER A FEW COULD OBSERVE
RIGHT MAYBE JUST A BACK THERE
THERE MAY BE SOME QUESTIONS FOR
YOU UNDER APPRECIATED THANK YOU
[inaudible] FOR FOR COMING.
IF YOU READ THANK YOU.
MR REID WHICH LIKE TO BEGIN.
THIS IS OPPOSITION.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE FOR
ALLOWING ME THE OPPORTUNITY TO
SPEAK TODAY MY NAME IS CHRIS
READ GOVERNOR FAIRS COMMITTEE
CHAIR FOR THE CATHOLIC IS WILL
THERE BE ASSOCIATION.
I'M A LICENSED I'M A COMPANY
LIKE THIS PHYSICAL THERAPIST AND
CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINER.
I SPEAK IN OPPOSITION AB.
THIRTY ONE TEN THE PROPONENTS OF
THIS BILL ARGUE THAT THERE ARE
BAD INDIVIDUALS POSERS ATHLETIC
TRAINERS AND WORKING CALIFORNIA
HIGH SCHOOLS WHO ARE UNQUALIFIED.
PROPONENTS ALSO USE THE ARGUMENT
THE ATHLETES ARE SAFER WHEN A
CERTIFIED ATHLETIC TRAINERS ON
THE SIDELINES.
WE ABSOLUTELY AGREE THE HAVE A
QUALIFIED PROFESSIONAL THE
SIDELINES IS IMPORTANT THE
SAFETY AND WELL BEING OF OUR
ATHLETES.
HOWEVER THE REACH RECENT
AMENDMENT LANGUAGE IN THIS BILL
SHOW THEIR TRUE INTENT HAS
NOTHING TO DO WITH WORKING WITH
ATHLETES SPORTS SPORTS TEAMS OR
SPORTS VENUES.
INSTEAD THE BILL NOW TALK ABOUT
ATHLETIC TRAINERS WORKING WITH
PATIENTS FOR TREATMENT.
IT CREATES A NEW BATTERIES LEVEL
HEALTHCARE PROVIDER WITH THE
FREEDOM TO WORK WITH ANY PERSON
FOR NEARLY ANY CONDITION WITH A
VERY BROAD POSITION OVERSIGHT.
THE DEFINITION CONTAIN AB THIRTY
ONE TEN ARE CIRCULAR AN OVERLY
BROAD DEFINES ATHLETES AS A
PERSON WHO PARTICIPATE IN
ATHLETIC ACTIVITY AND TO FIND I
THINK ACTIVITY AS PARTICIPATION
IN A SERIES OF ACTIVITIES.
BY AN ATHLETE.
THE BROAD DEFINITION OF THIS
PRIVATELY ALL ACTIVITY PERFORMED
BY ANY AND ALL PERSONS.
IT IS NOT SPECIFIC TO SPORT OR
ATHLETICS IN ANYWAY.
IT WOULD ALLOW AN ATHLETIC
TRAINER IN CALIFORNIA TO WORK
WITH AND IN ANY AND ALL PATIENTS.
THE REFORMS OF THIS BILL HAVE
ALSO CONVENIENTLY USE THE
ARGUMENT AT THEIR TRAINERS
WORKING MULTIPLE DIFFERENT
SETTINGS SUCH AS PHYSICIAN
OFFICES PHYSICAL THERAPY CLINICS
AND INDUSTRIAL SETTINGS.
WITH A NEGLECT TO MENTION IS
THAT WHEN WORKING IN THESE
ALTERNATIVE SETTINGS THEY'RE NOT
WORKING AS ATHLETIC TRAINERS
INSTEAD THEY'RE OFTEN WORKING AS
MEDICAL ASSISTANCE OR MEDICAL
TECHNICIANS WHO HAPPEN TO BE
ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
OR PHYSICAL THERAPISTS ARE
PHYSICAL THERAPIST ASSISTANTS
WHO HAPPEN TO BE ATHLETIC
TRAINERS.
I TAKE THE SURVEY EVERY YEAR
FROM THE ENTITY A TO ASK ME WHAT
SETTING I WORK IN.
AS AN ATHLETIC TRAINER I MARK
PHYSICAL THERAPY BUT I'M A
PHYSICAL THERAPIST WHO HAPPENS
TO BE AN ATHLETIC TRAINER --
THE INCLUSION OF EMPLOYMENT
ACTIVITIES IN THE DEFINITION OF
ATHLETIC ACTIVITY WOULD MEAN
THAT MOVING BOXES IN A WAREHOUSE
OR DIGGING HOLES A GARDENER.
OR UNLOADING CARGO IS A LONG
HAUL TRUCKER WOULD NOW BE
CLASSIFIED ADS ATHLETIC
ACTIVITIES.
AS FOR THE CONSUMER PROTECTION
COMPONENTS OF THE BILL AB THIRTY
ONE TEN CALLS POSITION OVERSIGHT
OF ATHLETIC TRAINER THAT IS FAR
MORE LENIENT THAN THAT OF OTHER
HEALTH CARE PER PROFESSIONS WHO
HAVE A GREATER LEVEL OF
EDUCATION TRAINING.
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW AN
ATHLETIC TRAINER TO TREAT A
PATIENT FOR INJURY OR ILLNESS
FOR UNRESTRICTED AMOUNT OF TIME
WITHOUT THE PATIENT EVER HAVING
TO SEE A PHYSICIAN.
THIS LEVEL POSITION OVERSIGHT IS
VASTLY MORE LENIENT RATHER
TRANSLATE PATRONS LEVEL OF
EDUCATION WITH THE CALIBER
LEGISLATURE HAS AUTHORIZED OR
PHYSICIAN ASSISTANTS OR
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST WITH A
MASTER'S DEGREE.
OR FOR VISIT PHYSICAL THERAPIST
WITH A DOCTOR'S DEGREE.
ADDITIONALLY THE RECENT
AMENDMENTS THERE IS NOW THE
LIKELIHOOD THAT ALL FITNESS
PROFESSIONALS WILL BE REQUIRED
TO REGISTER WITH THE ATHLETIC
TRAINING.
FOR THE REQUIREMENTS
REGISTRATION ONLY STATE THAT A
REGISTRANT HAVE TO INDICATE IF
THEY HAVE A CERTIFICATION
THROUGH THE BOARD CERTIFICATION.
OR ANOTHER NATIONAL CERTIFYING
AGENCY APPROVED BY THE BOARD.
IT DOES NOT PROHIBIT ONE WITHOUT
A CERTIFICATION AND WITH THE
BOARD.
ONLY FROM CALLING THEMSELVES AN
ATHLETIC TRAINER.
IF ATHLETIC ACTIVITY INCLUDE
PARTICIPATION IN FITNESS AND
WELLNESS AND ATHLETIC TRAINING
IS DEFINED AS RISK MANAGEMENT AN
INJURY OR ILLNESS PREVENTION
THROUGH EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS
PHYSICAL CONDITIONING.
AND RECONDITION PROGRAMS A
PROMOTION OF HEALTHY BEHAVIORS
THAT IT SEEMS TO ME THAT ALL
PERSONAL TRAINERS YOGA
INSTRUCTORS PLOT IS INSTRUCTORS
AND MANY OTHERS IN THE FITNESS
INDUSTRY WORLD.
WOULD BE REQUIRED TO REGISTER
[inaudible]
FINALLY.
OKAY COMMISSION I DIFFICULT
FINALLY WITH THE RECENT
AMENDMENTS THE BILL IS NOW VOID
OF WHAT IT WAS TRYING TO RESOLVE.
UNFORTUNATELY AB THIRTY ONE TEN
NOW CREATES A NEW CALIFORNIA
BATCHES OF A HEALTHCARE
PROFESSIONAL THERE IS AUTHORIZED
TO TREAT PATIENTS FOR NEARLY ANY
INJURY OR ILLNESS WITH
ESSENTIALLY NO OVERSIGHT.
BY POSITION OR OTHER APPROPRIATE
LICENSE HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL
THERE ARE CURRENTLY SEVERAL
CALVIN LICENSE HEALTHCARE
PROVIDERS.
PHYSIOTHERAPIST PHYSICIAN
ASSISTANTS NURSE PRACTITIONERS
NAME A FEW WHO ARE AUTHORIZED BY
THE STATE BY THE TYPE OF CARE
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW.
IN EVERY CASE THAT THE KIND OF
THE LOWER EDUCATIONAL STANDARD
AND YOU WILL BE AUTHORIZED HAVE
A MUCH BROADER SCOPE OF THE BILL.
THANK YOU TO READ I ASK FOR YOU
KNOW VOTE THANK YOU.
I THINK OPPOSITION THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS AT WHALEN
ELVES AND WILL NEVER SEE HERE ON
BEHALF OF UNITED NURSES
ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA WILL BE
VERY BRIEF WITH ALL DUE RESPECT
I'M NOT URE THE PROPONENTS HAVE
READ THE BILL BECAUSE THE
ARGUMENTS THEY'RE MAKING.
ARE NOT ADDRESSED BY THE BILL --
WOOD WOOD WITH THE KINGS ALLOW
AN ATHLETIC TRAINER ALONE TO
TAKE CARE OF ONE OF THEIR TOP
DRAFT PICKS.
I SUSPECT NOT WE KNOW NOT
BECAUSE THEY BROUGHT THEIR
DOCTOR SPORTS MEDICINE SAID HE
CONSULTS WITH THEM BUT UNDER THE
BILL THE VAST MAJORITY OF
ATHLETIC TRAINERS WHO PRACTICE
IN IN A WIDE VARIETY OF SETTINGS
WITHOUT THE RESOURCES OF THE
SACRAMENTO KINGS.
WOULD BE ALLOWED TO TREAT
VIRTUALLY ANY AND ALL INJURIES
WITHOUT EVER.
THE PATIENT EVER SEEING A DOCTOR.
SECONDLY THEY TALK ABOUT A
HUNDRED AND FIFTY OR SO ATHLETIC
TRAINERS WHO ARE NOT CERTIFIED
UNDER THIS BILL.
THOSE PEOPLE COULD CONTINUE TO
PRACTICE JUST AS THEY ARE TODAY
THE ONLY THING IS THAT WOULD BE
ALLOWED TO CALL THEMSELVES
ATHLETIC TRAINERS BUT THAT'S SO
REGISTER WITH THE BOARD AND
CONTINUE TO DO EXACTLY WHAT
THEY'RE DOING.
THE IRONY HERE IS THERE IS A
BILL THERE IS A DEAL BILL HERE
WE WERE WORKING TOWARDS IT UNTIL
THE AMENDMENTS CAME IN LAST WEEK.
BILLS LIKE THIS HAVE GOTTEN OUT
OF THE LEGISLATURE WITH ALL OF
THE OPPONENTS WITHDRAWING THEIR
OPPOSITION IN SOMETIMES PORTING
IT.
AS OF LAST WEEK THAT JUST WHEN
THE HUNDRED EIGHTY DEGREES FROM
WHERE THEY WERE GOING THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
I MINISTER CHAIRED MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS I'VE BEEN ALL TOMORROW
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF BOTH THE
CALIFORNIA AND THE NATIONAL.
WELL OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY
ASSOCIATION --
ASSOCIATIONS AND I I WON'T
REITERATE THE THE AKP ARGUMENTS
IN OPPOSITION THEY HAVE BEEN
MADE WE WILL ALIGN OURSELVES
THOSE COMMENTS I WOULD JUST SAY
THAT -- THAT
PRIOR TO TODAY'S HEARING WE WERE
IN OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED
POSITION AND WE THOUGHT WE WERE
MOVING TOWARDS --
A SPOT WHERE WE WERE GONNA BE
ABLE TO GO NEUTRAL AND POSSIBLY
EVEN SUPPORT THE BILL AND AND
ATTACKING A UT A HAVE IN THE
PAST I'M WORKED WITH ATHLETIC
TRAINERS AND GOTTEN TO THAT
POINT -- IT
IS NOT THAT WE DISAGREE WITH
WITH -- THE
ATHLETIC TRAINERS AND THEIR NEED
FOR SOME FORM OF OF
CERTIFICATION TITLE PROTECTION
REGISTRATION WE WORK WITH THEM
IN THE PAST.
ON A LICENSURE BILL --
BUT BILL.
IFIF BIG STEP BACKWARDS WITH
THE AMENDMENTS LAST WEEK I HAVE
THE UTMOST RESPECT FOR THE
AUTHOR AND WE WORKED WELL.
IN THE PAST TOGETHER --
NEW BUT WE ARE NOW IN A
PROSTRATE OPPOSE POSITION BASED
ON THE AMOUNT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
I HAVE ALONE THANK YOU FOR
ALLOWING THE OPPORTUNITY FOR
PUBLIC COMMENT MY NAME IS DAVE
YOU BANKS MY WIFE AND I OPENED
ACROSS ITS ACT RIGHT HERE IN
SACRAMENTO.
BACK IN TWENTY TEN AND I'M PROUD
TO SAY THAT WE OWN A BUSINESS
THAT EMPLOYS A HANDFUL OF PEOPLE
AND KEEP HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE
HEALTHIER.
LIKE MANY ACROSS THE GEMS --
WHERE MORE THAN JUST THE
BUSINESS FOR A COMMUNITY?
MY CONCERN TODAY IS WITH THE
DEFINITION OF ATHLETIC TRAINER
IN THIS BILL.
BUT ALSO INCLUDES MANY
ACTIVITIES I PERFORM AS A
TRAINER SPECIFIC TO CHAPTER FIVE
POINT.
EIGHT ARTICLE ONE SECTION --
TWENTY SIX NINETY SEVEN POINT.
ONE BOB BESIDES IN PERSON
DISCUSSION WITH OUR ATHLETES WE
USE AN ONLINE WAVERING PARK YOU
TO MANAGE ARE RISKING INJURY
PREVENTION THROUGH PRE
PARTICIPATION SCREENING
EVALUATION.
OUR PROGRAM IS DESIGNED NOT JUST
TO INCREASE HEALTH AND FITNESS
BUT TO EDUCATE OUR MEMBERS ON
THINGS THAT WE CAN DO --
BOTH INSIDE AND OUTSIDE THE GYM.
TO ACHIEVE AND MAINTAIN FITNESS
WE DO THIS BY DISCOVERING
DISCUSSING LIFESTYLE CHOICES AND
PROMOTING HEALTHY BEHAVIORS.
THIS IS THE FOUNDATION FOR A
PROGRAM.
ON A DAILY BASIS WE MEET OUR
CLIENTS IN PHYSICAL CONDITIONING
RECONDITIONING WORKOUTS DESIGNED
TO IMPROVE THEIR HEALTH AND
FITNESS IN SO DOING WE MUST THIS
UNNECESSARILY.
REDUCE ENVIRONMENTAL RISK
FACTORS BY ENSURING OUR
EQUIPMENT IS WELL MAINTAINED
PROPERLY POSITION IN USED
CORRECTLY.
AND THAT OUR WORKOUTS ORGANIZED
IN SUCH A WAY AS TO SPACE
BETWEEN ATHLETES.
WHILE I APPRECIATE THE GOOD
INTENTIONS OF REGULATING
ATHLETIC TRAINERS I'M HERE TODAY
TO HELP PROTECT MY RIGHT NOW TO
HELP KEEP PEOPLE.
FIT AND HEALTHY I THINK YOU GET
FREE TIME LET ME SHARE MY
PERSPECTIVE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE THANK YOU ARE
GOOD AFTERNOON I'M MY NAME IS
BRET YOU WERE AND I SPEAK ON
BEHALF OF CROSSFIT INC ACROSS
LINK IS THE LARGEST JIM CHAIN IN
THE WORLD AND IT WAS FOUNDED IN
CALIFORNIA. TO HER MAJOR
CORPORATE OFFICES ARE LOCATED IN
SANTA CRUZ AND SAN DIEGO.
BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY
CALIFORNIA'S HAS TO NEARLY NINE
HUNDRED OF OUR AFFILIATE JAMS
INCLUDING DAVE'S.
ALL INDEPENDENTLY OWNED AND
OPERATED AND ALL IMPROVING
HEALTH AND FITNESS OF
CALIFORNIANS EVERY DAY.
AND WELCOME THE OPPORTUNITY
TODAY TO VOICE SOME OF OUR
CONCERNS WITH A. B. THIRTY ONE
TEN UNLESS AMENDED.
AB THIRTY ONE TEN WOULD PROTECT
THE TITLE OF OF FUNNY TRAINERS
AND WOOD ESTABLISH A REGISTRY
BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY WOULD
REGULATE THE PRACTICE OF
ATHLETIC TRAINING.
WE FIRMLY BELIEVE THAT THIS WAS
CONCEIVED WITH THE BEST
INTENTIONS BUT ITS DEFINITION OF
ATHLETIC TRAINING THAT'S
OUTLINED SCOPE OF PRACTICE FOR
ATHLETIC TRAINERS INCLUDES
ACTIVITIES AND SERVICES THAT ONE
WOULD REASONABLY INTERPRET TO
INCLUDE.
A FITNESS TRAINERS THAT WOULDN'T
TO INCLUDE THOSE FITNESS
TRAINERS REGULARLY PERFORM FOR
THEIR CLIENTS.
WE DON'T BELIEVE THAT THAT'S THE
INTENTION BUT IT IS THE REALITY.
WE'RE CONCERNED WITH THE SCOPE
OF PRACTICE PROVIDED IN SECTION
FOUR ARTICLE ONE TWENTY SIX
NINETY SEVEN POINT ONE
PARENTHESES THREE FOR THE CITY'S
PARENTHESES DE PARENTHESES.
ONE MOST OF THESE ACTIVITIES
DESCRIBED ARE THOSE PRACTICE BY
FITNESS TRAINERS AND THIS
LEGISLATION IS NOT CLEAR AS TO
WHETHER THESE ACTIVITIES ARE
EXCLUSIVE TO ATHLETIC TRAINERS
OR WHETHER THEY'RE SHARED AMONG
A NUMBER OF PROFESSIONS.
THESE ACTIVITIES INCLUDE
EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMS USE OF
PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT PROMOTION
OF HEALTH HEALTHY BEHAVIORS
PRODUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS
PHYSICAL CONDITIONING AND
RECONDITIONING AND CREEP
PARTICIPATION SCREENING AND
EVALUATION.
FITNESS TRAINERS PERFORM EACH OF
THESE ACTIVITIES BEFORE
LAUNCHING A FULL TRAINING
PROGRAM FITNESS TRAINERS OFTEN
SCREEN FOR HEALTH CONDITIONS
ATHLETIC BACKGROUNDS AND OTHER
FACTORS THAT MIGHT REQUIRE
SCALING OR OTHERWISE ADOPTING
THEIR CLIENTS TRAINING.
AND FITNESS TRAINERS BY
DEFINITION LEAVE THEIR CLIENTS
AND EDUCATIONAL PROGRAM
REGARDING BEST PRACTICES IN
ENSURING FITNESS.
THAT IN ITSELF IS A PROMOTION OF
HEALTHY BEHAVIOR.
A REDUCTION OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RISKS CREATING DESIGNATED ZONES
FOR AT A CERTAIN EXERCISES
KEEPING ADEQUATE SPACE BETWEEN
ATHLETES MAKING SURE QUITMAN
THIS PLACE CORRECTLY.
CLEANING FACILITIES AFTER USE
PREVENTS INJURY OR ILLNESS AND
IS ALSO FUNDAMENTAL TO FITNESS
TRAINING.
PHYSICAL CONDITIONING AND
RECONDITIONING IS THE
IMPROVEMENT OF PHYSICAL HEALTH
THROUGH PROGRAM OF EXERCISE IS
SOMETHING OUR TRAINERS DO
EVERYDAY.
AND PHYSICAL CONDITIONING AND
RECONDITIONING ALSO STAND OF
SERVICES THAT ANY FITNESS
TRAINER WOULD REASONABLY PROVIDE
THE PREVENTION OF ILLNESS TO
INCLUDE TYPE TWO DIABETES
OBESITY AND OTHER CHRONIC
DISEASES.
GRETA PLEASE VERY QUICK THAT WE
I THINK WE GET THE POINT THANK
YOU -- WE
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR TAYLOR
JACKSON WITH THE CALIFORNIA
NURSES ASSOCIATION NGUYEN OPPOSE
LOS AMENDED POSITION --
ALSO ON OUR COMMENTS WITH OF THE
FORMER SPEAKERS --
WE ALSO BELIEVE THE BILL IS
OVERLY BROAD WE LIKE THE
DIRECTION THAT PREVIOUS VERSIONS
OF THE BILL WE'RE MOVING IN THE
TITLE PROTECTION CERTIFICATION
WE BELIEVE THAT'S MORE
APPROPRIATE FOR THIS PROFESSION.
THINK FAQ.
THAT AFTERNOON I'M ZOO MCGINTY
M. RETIRED PROFESSOR AND CHAIR
MERIT IS OF THE CALIFORNIA OF
THE DEPARTMENT FISCAL THERAPY
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
SACRAMENTO AND HERE IN STRONG
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL REALLY
THANK YOU KNOW IMAGE THAT.
I THINK YOU FOR COMING TODAY.
GOOD AFTERNOON XANDER HERERO ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION WE ARE
WITHDRAWING OUR OPPOSITION AND
WE'D LIKE TO THINK THE AUTHOR
AND STAFF FOR ACCEPTING OUR
COMMITMENT THANK YOU VERY GOOD
THANK YOU OTHERS IN OPPOSITION
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
SEEING NO ONE AND HEARING NO AND
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
FOR CONSIDERATION IN QUESTIONS
COMMENTS IS SENATOR DODD --
YES ASSEMBLY MEMBER AYE YA I'VE
HEARD A LOT OF THINGS --
ON ON ON BOTH SIDES OF ITS BY
THINK THAT PERHAPS MAYBE THAT.
DOCTOR COULD ADDRESS IT WE IN
PRO IN IN PRO SPORTS TEAMS --
THEY HAVE [inaudible]
POSITIONS.
PROBABLY MORE LIKELY COLLEGE
EVEN IN HIGH SCHOOL I THINK.
THEY HAVE PRE --
ATHLETIC PHYSICALS SO WHAT THE
TRAINERS ARE DOING ARE.
BY AND LARGE I WOULD.
EXPECT TO BE.
YOU KNOW.
FOR ATHLETES ARE ALREADY CLEAR.
THE ARE TO DO THAT KIND OF JOB.
IN I GUESS TO SOME OF THE SOME
OF THE THINGS THAT CONCERN ME
ABOUT THIS BILL OR ATHLETIC
DUTIES OUTSIDE SPORTS
ESSENTIALLY IS HOW I'VE.
PARAPHRASING --
THAT WAS SOMEHOW THERE'S THERE'S
I THOUGHT PROCESS YOU CAN TAKE
THE SAME.
ATHLETIC TRAINING AND CATER IT --
TO I'D ADD A DOCTOR WHAT I'M NOT
A MEAT HERE TO LOOK AT A COMPANY.
BUT WHAT I'M NOT CLEAR ON IS IS
THAT COMPANY HAVE TO HAVE.
A PHYSICIAN AT THE COMPANY WOULD
THAT THESE ATHLETIC TRAINERS.
WOULD BE RESPONDING TO OR
REPORTING.
SO CENTER WE ARE TAKING
PHYSICIAN SUPERVISION LANGUAGE
IN THE BILL MAGINOT CMA AYE IS
SUPPORTING.
ARE THESE FOLKS WE WORKING UNDER
THE SUPERVIION OF A PHYSICIAN
WHICH IS CURRENTLY NOT REQUIRED.
AND CALIFORNIA'S TO THE BILL A
REQUIRES VERBAL ORDER IF THE
PHYSICIAN I IS PRESENT ON SITE
OR WRITTEN ORDER PROTOCOLS IF
THE PHYSICIAN IS DOT.
THEIR ON SITE SO WE TOOK SOME
AMENDMENTS TO TO CLARIFY THE
PHYSICIAN'S SUPERVISION PIECE OF
IT.
I'M COMFORTABLE WITH THAT AND A
NOTE.
FOR SUPPORTERS WOULD LIKE TO ADD --
ANY.
THOUGHTS ON THAT.
I I BELIEVE THAT MAKES SENSE I
WOULD JUST SPEAK FOR MYSELF IN
THAT HAVE NOT BEEN PART OF ANY
POLICY FORMATION IN AN
INDUSTRIAL ENVIRONMENT BUT MY
UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THAT'S
GOING TO BE TYPICAL IT'S IT'S
VERY SIMILAR TO ANOTHER
ENVIRONMENT IF YOU WERE TO HAVE
A AN INSULAR.
HEALTHCARE PROVIDER --
WOULD HAVE TO HAVE SOME SORT OF
OVERSIGHT AND AND AND WHO THEY
WOULD REPORT.
TO I AT THAT ANOTHER THING THAT
I JUST WROTE DOWN HERE THAT YOU
WOULD HAVE A BACHELOR'S LEVEL.
PROFESSIONAL.
DOING THIS WORK AS OPPOSED
ASSEMBLY THAT'S HAD --
YOU'LL GRADUATE TYPING DEGREE
WORK.
THERE WERE KIND OF BY TAKING IN
EXPANDING THIS.
POLICY HERE.
WE'RE KIND OF GOING AWAY --
FOR YOU KNOW THAT.
THE TRADITIONAL TYPE OF SCOPE
SCOPE OF PRACTICE A MORE IF WE
COULD RESPOND TO THAT.
SO CURRENTLY AFTER TRAINERS HAVE
AND SOME ARE EDUCATED A
BACHELOR'S DEGREE LEVEL SUMMER
TO MASTER'S DEGREE BUT THEY ALL
GO THROUGH AN ACCREDITED
PROFESSIONAL PROGRAM OF TWO TO
THREE YEARS IN LENGTH DEPENDING
ON THE SCHOOL.
THE GROUP THAT ACCREDITS.
THE ACCREDITATION PROGRAMS.
THEY A CREDIT PT EDUCATION THEIR
CREDIT O. T. EDUCATION THEIR
CREDIT PA EDUCATION SO THE SAME
OVERSIGHT.
I'M RIGHT NOW AND ALL THESE
PROFESSIONS STARTED A BACHELOR
DEGREE NOT THAT LONG AGO THERE
WERE PA'S THAT WERE.
OF ASSOCIATE DEGREE LEVEL YOU
KNOW THEY HAVE THAT OPTION ALL
MASTER STREETBALL AFTER TRAINING
PROGRAMS BY TWENTY TWENTY TWO
WILL BE MASTER'S DEGREE PROGRAMS
[inaudible]
THAT'S GUARANTEED.
BECOME CERTIFIED YOU HAVE TO GO
THROUGH A MASTERS DEGREE PROGRAM
THAT WILL ALL THAT WILL BE
AVAILABLE.
VIOLINIST CHAIR YES OF COURSE
I HAVE A QUESTION I DIDN'T
REALLY GET WHERE THE GENTLEMAN
FROM -- THAT
THAT WERE FITNESS TRAINERS --
THAT THEIR THEIR POINTS THIS I
JUST HAD TO ASK.
I HAD ASKED THE QUESTION IS IT
THAT THEY DON'T WANT TO BE.
INVOLVED IN THIS THAT THEY FEEL
LIKE S. FITNESS TRAINERS THEY
ARE GOING TO BE.
A WRAP GARY DID RABBIT WRAPPED
INTO THIS LICENSING RIGHT OR
THAT THEY THAT THEY THOUGHT
BECAUSE THEIR FITNESS TRAINERS.
THEY SHOULD BE PUT AND I JUST
THEN IF I COULD CLARIFY OF
CLEANER DOT THE SO THAT
OPPOSITION AND THOSE CONCERNS
CAME FOR WE WERE MADE AWARE OF
THAT IN THE AUTHOR HAS AGREED.
TO TO REFINE THE BILL AFTER. TO
TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S IT'S NOT
IS IS --
DOESN'T CAPTURE THE AREAS WITH
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES SO
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT WE WERE
PLANNING TO DO WITH THE AUTHOR.
TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT.
IT IS A LITTLE MORE SPECIFIC IN
THEIR YES SENATOR PAT.
I THANK YOU --
SEVERAL OF THIS COMPONENT TO
TESTIFIED MADE REFERENCE TO NEW
AMENDMENTS TAKE CAN AND I DON'T
KNOW WHETHER HE SHOULD ANSWER
THIS QUESTION TERMS OF I'M JUST
TRYING AND PEOPLE SAID WELL
THINGS REMOVING THEIR ATTRACTION.
I GUESS UNTIL THEN.
YEAH -- SO
BECAUSE THIS IS HOW YOU DEFINE
RIGHT YEAH I GUESS A HOUSE SO I
THINK I GUESS COMES CAN THERE BE
SOME ELABORATION AS TO WHERE THE
BILL.
WAS WHEN IT NICE AND PASSED OUT
OF THE ASSEMBLY FOR CARE AND
WHAT.
TRANSPLANT ANYMORE WHY WHY WHY
THIS.
THIS DIALOGUE ABOUT.
NOW THESE AND AND IT'S AT OUR
SITE S SO TO BE HELPFUL TO
UNDERSTAND LIKE WHERE WAS THE
BILL BEFORE THAT PEOPLE WERE I
GUESS HAPPIER ALTHOUGH
APPARENTLY THEY WERE STILL
SAYING THEY'RE TRYING TO MOVE IT
SOMEPLACE.
AND NOW WAS THERE ANY IS THERE
ARE BROADENING OF THE SCOPE FIRE
WHAT WHAT WHAT EXACTLY WAS
[inaudible]
TRANSPIRED.
I DON'T SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THE
OPPOSITION BUT I THINK PART OF
WHERE THE ISSUE WAS THERE WAS A
CLAUSE.
WHEN WE CAME OUT OF THEM?
APPROACH ARICEPT BBMP --
THAT ALLOWED TO BOARD TO DEFINE
SETTINGS.
AND THAT DIDN'T SEEM APPROPRIATE
TO GIVE THE POOR THAT FULL
AUTHORITY --
WHEN WE'RE TALKING TO STAFF SO
REFINED IT TO INCLUDE THE?
AND WE TOOK A LANGUAGE FROM
OTHER STATES --
TO ACCOMMODATE.
YOU KNOW THAT THE BOMBERS
OCCURRED THE ATTIC TRAINERS ARE
WORKING UNDER THEIR SUPERVISION.
AND EDUCATION AND TO ALLOW THAT
TO CONTINUE.
AND THE HAPPEN AGAIN WE LOOK TO
OTHER STATES FOR THOSE EXAMPLES
[inaudible]
M..
AGAIN IF THE BOARD WAS GOING TO
BE ABLE TO DECIDE THAT LEFT EVEN
MORE OPEN THAN THE CURRENT
LANGUAGE AS WE THINK WE'VE
NARROWED THAT DOWN A LITTLE BIT.
OKAY SO SO BASICALLY --
SO WAS IT PREVIOUSLY THE BOARD
THE FIND WHICH OF COURSE THAT
HAS ITS OWN ISSUES AND THEN THAT
WE CHANGE THAT.
TO MORE SPECIFIC LANGUAGE IN THE
BILLS THAT WHAT HAPPENED.
THE CENTER BELIEVE IN OUR
CONVERSATION AS IT BECAME
APPARENT THAT WE NEED TO SPECIFY
AND CLARIFY IN THE CODE GOING
AND WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
WITH REGARD TO EMPLOYMENT
ACTIVITIES IN THE UNIVERSE OF
PEOPLE THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
HERE.
IT'S A CLEANER.
WAY TO APPROACH IT AND LEAVING
IT OPEN ENDED.
FOR THIS BOARD THAT IS YET TO BE.
ESTABLISHED SO WE MADE THE
CHOICE TO TO CALL THAT OUT
SPECIFICALLY OKAY [inaudible]
ALRIGHT THEN --
ACTUALLY TALKING ABOUT THE BOARD
ONE OF THE UP POLICY COMMENTS
MADE ANALYSIS IS --
WELL I THINK ONE OF THE
CHALLENGES HOW MANY BOARDS THE
CA HAS THE ABILITY TO MANAGE
THEM HOW MANY PEOPLE THERE ARE
TO HAVE SUPPORT INFRASTRUCTURE
OF A BOARD.
HELP WHAT EFFECT IT HAS ON FEES
AND SO FORTH.
I REALIZE IT'S BEEN A NELSON.
TRIED OTHER THAN PREVIOUS BILLS
AND SO FORTH.
THERE --
MUCH REASON FOR TRY ESTABLISH A
SEPARATE BOARD GIVEN THE NUMBER
OF VERSES MAKING THIS A
COMMITTEE EXCEPT COMMITTEE%
WHATEVER.
OF EXISTING BOARD.
SO BIGGER THE QUESTION SENATOR
BECAUSE THE INITIAL VERSION OF
THE BILL HAVE THIS UNDER.
THE OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY BOARD
WITH SOME OVERSIGHT THERE --
TO ADDRESS SOME CONCERNS --
FROM FROM THOSE FOLKS.
WE MADE THIS A STAND ALONE BOARD
UNDER THE BROADER UMBRELLA OF
DCA BUT I AM NOT WEDDED TO ANY
PARTICULAR APPROACH HERE THE
GOAL HERE IS THAT.
DISKETTES DOT I AM NOT --
HOLDING FIRM TO YOU A STANDALONE
UNDER DCA I THINK THAT MAY.
GIVEN ALL OF OUR CONVERSATIONS
MAKE THE MOST SENSE.
BUT I AM OPEN TO LOOKING AT THE
EXISTING BOARD STRUCTURE I KNOW
THAT -- I'VE
HEARD THE MEDICAL BOARD
SUGGESTION AS THE AUTHOR I'M%
OPEN TO THAT --
BUT I WOULD LIKE --
ARE EIGHTY FOLKS A TO COMMENT ON
THAT SINCE THE BEEN IMMERSED IN
THAT CONVERSATION.
WE WOULD AGREE.
WE WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU AND I DID
THE A COULD YOU DO JUDICIARY DID
YOU WANT TO RESPOND TO SENATOR
DODD'S QUESTION I HEARD THAT WAS
A CO OWNER LA DOT IT CENTER
PANTS QUESTION A POSSIBLE.
OR HOW ABOUT THE CHANGES IN
SCOPE.
SO IN THE ASSEMBLY --
AND SO THE BMP COMMITTEE THE
AUTHORS OFFICE ACCEPTED
AMENDMENTS THERE REALLY TIED
THAT THE PRACTICE ABOUT THEIR
TRAINING INTO THE ATHLETIC WORLD.
RISE ELICITED AS INTERSCHOLASTIC
LEAGUE DRAFT I THOUGHT OCCURRED
ASSOCIATIONS --
AMATEUR ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION AND
IT SAID THAT YOU HAD ABA COACH.
RALEY'S GOTTA PRACTICES.
BRING THIS EFFORT GAMES THEIR
EVENTS.
BY IN.
AND THEN THEY ADDED IN THE EXTRA
CLOSET SAID THAT THE THE
ATHLETIC TRAINING BOARD WOULD BE
ABLE.
TO IDENTIFY OTHER ACTIVITIES AS
ATHLETIC AS IT SAW FIT.
RIGHT SO WHAT THEY'VE DONE HERE
THEY'VE REMOVED ALL OF THAT
LANGUAGE.
AND NOW PUT IN THIS VERY BROAD
DEFINITION OF ATHLETIC ACTIVITY
THAT INCLUDES EXERCISE FITNESS
WELLNESS [inaudible]
AND EMPLOYMENT ACTIVITIES THERE
WHICH BROADENS IT WAY PASSED
ATHLETICS.
TO EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE.
THE WHAT ONE OF THE OTHER ISSUES
OF THAT WE HAD WAS WITH
SUPERVISION RIGHT WE JUST WANTED
TO BE TIGHTENED UP A LITTLE BIT
SAU A AN ATHLETE THAT WAS --
THAT WAS BEING TREATED BY NOT
LIKE TRAINER AT SOME POINT WE
HAVE TO CHECK IN WITH THE
POSITIONS BY.
AS A REQUIREMENT NOT JUST AS IT
SHOULD THE AFFECT TRANSIT THOSE
NECESSARY.
IN PHNOM PENH.
ADDITIONALLY THE THE THE
SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS DOESN'T
LIMIT THE NUMBER ABOUT THAT
TRANSIT POSITION CAN SURPRISE.
THINGS ARISE A HUNDRED ATHLETICS
ATHLETIC TRAINERS NOT. SEVEN
MISTER CHAIR IF I COULD JUST
COMMENT HERE THIS ISSUE.
THE CROSSFIT ISSUE I THINK CAN
BE DEALT WITH --
THE ISSUE AROUND EMPLOYMENT
SETTINGS A FULL ONE THIRD OF
THESE FOLKS RIGHT NOW.
OUR IN SETTINGS IN A VARIETY OF
OF A WORKPLACE SETTINGS NOT
SPECIFIC TO AN ATHLETE ON A
PLAYING FIELD.
AND IT WOULD REALLY I THINK JUST
ARM NOT MAKE MUCH SENSE TO
EXCLUDE THE FULL ONE THIRD SOME
EIGHT HUNDRED FOLKS THAT.
ARE IN THESE OTHER SETTINGS WERE
GONNA CREATE OF THIS KIND OF
FIRST STEP REGULATORY MECHANISM
WE NEED TO PUT ALL THE TEASING
THAT SO THAT WAS SPECIFIED.
IN THE AMENDMENTS THAT WE TOOK
CLARIFIES THAT JUST FOR SOME
PERSPECTIVE AGAIN THE OF THE
DOCKING SPEAK TO KIND OF WHAT AN
ACL AS FOR AN ATHLETE OR NON
ATHLETE BUT JUST IN TERMS OF THE
REST OF THE COUNTRY.
JUST LIKE MOST OF THE THE BOARDS
IN CALIFORNIA THEY DON'T ADDRESS
SETTING A PATIENT.
OUR EDUCATION REQUIRES THAT YOU
WORK WITH PEOPLE ACROSS THE
LIFESPAN IN A VARIETY OF
SETTINGS YOU CAN'T JUST GO
THROUGH YOUR EDUCATION.
AND WORK ONLY WITH ATHLETES
YOU'RE WORKING WITH A VARIETY OF
PATIENTS WITHIN THAT EDUCATIONAL
SETTING.
IN TERMS OF STATUTE TEN STATES
DON'T EVEN ADDRESS IT AT ALL.
THIRTY NINE ALLOW NON
TRADITIONAL ATHLETIC SETTINGS.
SO OF THE THREE NINE STATES THAT
HAVE REGULATION THE MOST OF
THOSE LICENSOR ALL BUT FIVE OF
THEM. THIRTY NINE ALLOW.
THIS AND I KNOW FROM OUR DATA
EVER FOR THE BOARD CERTIFICATION
DATA THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE IN
ALL FIFTY STATES WORKING IN
THESE DIFFERENT SETTINGS
INCLUDING THE MILITARY.
CLOUDING NASA COULD WORK OTHER
WORKPLACE SETTINGS POLICE AND
FIRE VRY GOOD THANK YOU OKAY AS
WELL THEN THAT MONEY JUST FOR
ONE SECOND DOCTOR PUNITIVE AND
BEFORE I HAVE TO LIVE IN VOTE.
AND IN A COMMITTEE SO I'M GOING
TO TURN THIS OVER TO SENATOR
DODD IN BRIEF MOMENT BUT NO I
THINK JUST.
TO INCLUDE WE CONCLUDE THE THE
ANALYSIS TALKS ABOUT AND THE
AMENDMENTS REALLY CLARIFY I
BELIEVE THAT.
PHYSICIAN OVERSIGHT POSITION
PROTOCOL ESTABLISHMENT WORKS
WITHIN THIS CONTEXT HAS WORKED.
IN I THINK IN THOSE AREAS WHERE
IT'S BEEN AMENDED INTO THE BILL
WITH ITS EXERCISE SPORT GAME
RECREATION.
WELLNESS FITNESS THAT IN THE
CONVERSATIONS THAT WE WILL
CONTINUE TO HAVE WILL BE ABLE TO
WORK AROUND SOME OF THOSE THINGS
TO KIND OF FINE TUNE IT LITTLE
MARCIA THAT'S MY THINKING ON
THAT BEHALF IT IS.
SO -- OF
LET'S GET ANOTHER ISSUE THEN --
IN TERMS OF SO WHAT
DISTINGUISHES.
A ATHLETIC TRAINER FROM THE
PHYSICAL THERAPISTS IN A
WORKPLACE SETTING [inaudible]
AND THERE ARE NOT ENOUGH BLOOD
EXCITING.
SO I THINK YOU'RE AM PART OF
THAT IS IS WORKING WITH THE TEAM
EACH TEAM AS A LITTLE BIT
DIFFERENT.
ON HOW THEY WOULD FUNCTION WE
USUALLY WORK COLLABORATIVELY.
WITH A VARIETY OF PROFESSIONS --
IN SOME CASES THE ATHLETIC
TRAINER IT'S GONNA TYPICALLY DO
MORE OF THE FRONT AND NO THAT
IMMEDIATE CARE.
AND THAT REFERRAL TO THE
PHYSICIAN --
THEY MAY COLLABORATE WITH THE
PHYSICAL THERAPIST ON THAT
REHABILITATION.
AND CERTAINLY NOTHING IN THIS
BILL WOULD ALLOW US TO WORK.
YOU KNOW WITH THE STROKE PATIENT
OR THINGS LIKE THAT THAT WE'VE
GOT OF HER THAT THE SCOPE ALLOWS.
AND ACTUALITY.
SCOPE PROPOSED BY THE
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS.
AND WE IT AMENDED THAT INTO THE
BILL I'M WITH THIS LANGUAGE CAME
OUT IN TERMS OF THAT SCOPE.
AND BY NO YOU HAVE AT THEIR
TRAINERS AND PHYSICAL THERAPIST
THAT YOU WORK WITH.
YOU'RE I SEE THIS GOING ON THE
PATHWAY OF OF THE WORKPLACE AND
THAT'S OBVIOUSLY VERY IMPORTANT
AND YOU AYE I THINK THE BIG KEY
TO ME IS THAT EACH OF THESE
GROUPS.
FEELS AS THOUGH THEIR RIGHT TO
MANAGE CERTAIN FORMS OF
PRESENTATION WITH THAT INJURY
ILLNESS CENTER NEEDS TO BE
PROTECTED.
I GET THAT I THINK.
I THINK THE BIG CONCERN ME THAT
THIS REALLYNEEDS COME BACK TO
IS WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE
SCHOOL IN THE EDUCATIONAL
SETTING.
THEY GUESS IS THE KEY POINT
THERE AND I WOULD JUST SAY THAT.
TO ME IS A SO I WOULD BACK UP
BECAUSE WHAT HAPPENS IS THAT
THERE'S A DEFINITIONS SCOPE THAT
ASIDE OUTSIDE OF NIGHT YOU HEAR
WHAT YOU'RE SAYING ABOUT WELL
YOU KNOW DO WE DISTRICT PEOPLE
BY SETTING RIGHT.
THE OTHER BASED ON THEIR SKILL
SETS ARE NOW.
MRS STAKE A NON AT YOU KNOW.
YEAH AT A WORKPLACE SETTING THAT
ISN'T RELATED SPECIFICALLY TO
ATHLETICS BUT WE'RE HAVING WE'RE
SAYING WE HAVE ATHLETIC TRAINERS
WHAT'S THEIR ROLE IN COMPARISON
TO A PHYSICAL THERAPIST IN A I
DON'T KNOW AND YOU KNOW IN IN A
WAREHOUSE [inaudible]
SETTING.
SO AND ANOTHER TRAINER WOULD DO.
WITH THE SCOPE THAT IS IN THE
BILL RIGHT THEY CAN DO ERGONOMIC
ASSESSMENTS I HAVE A NUMBER OF
FORMER STUDENTS ARE WORKING
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY HAVE ONE
ATHLETE OR ONE FORMER SUDANESE.
AT BOEING --
AS WELL SOME OF THE STATE BUT
THEY DO ERGONOMIC ASSESSMENT
LOOK AT AND HOW THEY ARE WORKING.
IN THEIR ENVIRONMENT DETERMINE
EITHER EXERCISE THAT MIGHT BE
APPROPRIATE.
WERE AGAINST SOME ERGONOMIC
CHANGES TO THEIR WORKSTATION
THAT MIGHT BE APPROPRIATE AND
THAT MIGHT OVERLAP OF THE
PHYSICAL THERAPISTS AND SOME
FACILITIES HAVE PHYSICAL
THERAPIST.
SOME HAVE AFFLECK TRAINERS AND
IS ANOTHER TRAINER WERE MORE
TRAINING TO KEEP MANAGEMENT.
AND SO WERE ON SITE AND CAN
CONDUCIVE EVALUATIONS THERE'S
ALWAYS GOING TO BE A MEDICAL AND
THE SETTINGS THERE'S ALWAYS A
MEDICAL --
DOCTOR WHO'S IN CHARGE OF THE
PROGRAM --
SO THAT WE WOULD REFER TO THAT
PERSON AND BE UNDER THAT PERSON
SUPERVISION.
OKAY YOU I CAN HELP YOU CAN HE
RESPOND TO YOUR QUESTION
GENTLEMAN BACKS ARE YOU ACTUALLY
WOULD THEN I HAVE A FOLLOW UP TO
ALSO.
WHAT?
IF THERE'S ONE APPOINT OUT THERE
WHEN YOU ASK WHAT WHAT THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A PHYSICAL
THERAPISTS AND ATHLETIC TRAINER
WAS IN THE WORKPLACE SETTINGS.
THAT THE IMMEDIATE ANSWER WAS WE
WORK WITH TEAM SO THEY WENT
RIGHT BACK TO THE SPORTS ANALOGY
AGAIN.
HEY AND THEN WHEN PRESSED ON
THAT THEY TALKED ABOUT DOING
ERGONOMICS.
RIGHT RIGHT SO I I I WOULD STILL
ASK WHAT'S THE DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN A PHYSICAL THERAPIST AND
AUTHOR TRAINER.
IN THE WORKPLACE SETTING IN THE
WAREHOUSE RIGHT THERE THIS
UNIQUE SKILL SET OF AN ATHLETIC
TRAINER IS WORKING WITH AN
ATHLETE.
ON THE FIELD FOR ATHLETIC
INJURIES.
RIGHT IT'S NOT WORKING WITH THE
WAREHOUSE WORKER.
IT'S NOT WORKING WITH THE DAY
LABOR [inaudible]
SO [inaudible]
OKAY.
OKAY THE UNIQUE SKILL SET FOR
NATHAR TRAINERS WORKING ACROSS
THE CONTINUUM OF CARE.
SO WE DO MUCH MORE PREVENTION IS
A THREE MENTAL CREDENTIALS PT IF
I WAS IN A PHYSICAL THERAPY
CLINIC.
I WOULD BE DOING A TON OF
PREVENTION PRESIDENT WORK SITE
SETTING MAYBE --
BUT WE IS ATHLETIC TRAINERS ARE
TRAINED ACROSS A CONTINUUM
PREVENTION IMMEDIATE EMERGING
CARE -- IT
REFERRAL TREATMENT SELL IT AND
LET ME JUST AND AND THE OTHER
THING THAT WAS BROUGHT UP WAS
THE ISSUE AROUND --
YELPS APPRECIATE SUPERVISION BY
THE PHYSICIAN --
IN TERMS OF AND YOU MADE
REFERENCE ACTUALLY ABOUT
REFERRALS BUT IS SO IS THERE A
REQUIREMENT THAT --
THAT AFTER THE INITIAL
EVALUATION THAT --
THERE IS AN EXAMINATION OF
ACTUALLY BY THE VISION.
THAT IS STATED --
IN THE BILL IN A COUPLE PLACES
ABOUT WHAT THE REQUIREMENTS ARE
FOR THAT REFERRAL.
AS WELL AS YOUR BE A REQUIREMENT
IN THE PROTOCOLS.
THAT THE PHYSICIAN DETERMINES
WHAT THAT CRITERIA [inaudible]
OKAY.
AND THEN IN TERMS OF THE RATIO.
SO YOU KNOW THAT'S COME UP IN
TERMS OF SUPERVISION IS THERE
[inaudible]
SOME.
ON A SERIOUS THE FIRST TIME I'VE
HEARD THAT WAS TODAY. ONE THAT
THAT THAT IS A COMMON ISSUE IN
MANY OTHER PLACES WERE UNDER
SUPERVISION [inaudible]
SO IS THERE MAY I THROUGH CHAIR.
YES I I WOULD JUST LIKE TO
BOTTOM TALK ABOUT THOSE
REQUIREMENTS FOR REFERRAL IT'S
IT'S A IT'S OUTSIDE THE SCOPE OF
NOT THEIR TRAINER THAN THEY'RE
REQUIRED TO REFER.
OR IF THE THE ATHLETE ISN'T
PROGRESSING IN A WAY THAT THEY
EXPECTED THEM.
TO BUT THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT
OF REFERRAL AFTER A CERTAIN TIME
FRAME.
OR YEAH AFTER THE INITIAL
EXAMINATION [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU OTHER QUESTIONS OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
E..
SEEING NONE A YES SENATOR
GALGIANI.
AND TIME NOW WITH WITH THE
PROPONENTS LAST WEEK AND I'M ALL
IN FAVOR OF DEFINING A SCHOOL
AND FURTHERING THE PROFESSION --
I DID USED TO WORK AS A PHYSICAL
THERAPY AIDE AND THEY'RE UNDER
THE SUPERVISION OF A LICENSED
THERAPIST I HAVE A GREAT DEAL IS
RESPECT FOR THAT RELATIONSHIP.
AND THE CIRCUMSTANCES
CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH OF
PHYSICAL THERAPY AID OR
ASSISTANCE WOULD WOULD KNOW TO
STEP BACK AND ASK FOR MORE
GUIDANCE IN THE CARE OF THE
PATIENT.
AND IT WITH THE AMENDMENTS THAT
WERE RECENTLY TAKEN.
WITH THE BILL THERE HAS BEEN THE
CONCERN THAT WE'VE ALL HEARD
TODAY AND THAT CONCERNS ME.
AS WELL BUT I WANTED I WANTED TO
GIVE YOU A CHANCE.
TO AND FURTHER REFINE THE SCOPE
AND I HAVE IT BE DIRECTED AT AND
THOSE FIGURES.
TRULY FOCUSED ON AS OPPOSED TO
SUCH A BROAD SCOPE WHICH CLIENTS
ARE THE OPPONENTS BELIEVE THAT
ADDRESSES NOW SO I'M GONNA
SUPPORT IT TODAY BUT I'M GOING
TO ALSO I'M WITH.
THAT'S ON THE CONDITION THAT HE
WILL CONTINUE TO WEAR A FEW. FOR
THAT WE FIND THE SCOPE AS THE
CHAIRED DISCUSS SO THAT IT.
AT LEAST FACT WE FOUND.
THE SCOPE OF THE FAIR AND THE
PHYSICAL THERAPIST IN THAT
RELATIONSHIP --
WHEN THEY EVEN HAVE TO GO BACK?
PATIENT CONSULT WITH A PHYSICIAN
FOR FURTHER TREATMENT BEYOND
FORTY FIVE DAYS SO I WOULD.
I WILL RESERVE MY VOTE ON THE
SENATE FLOOR BASED ON WHAT
HAPPENS BETWEEN NOW AND THEN.
I WILL GO AHEAD AND SUPPORT THE
THANK YOU SAID ARE FAIR ENOUGH
AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
THOSE ISSUES YOU HAVE SENATOR
DON THAT.
I'D LIKE TO ASSOCIATE MY
COMMENTS WITH A CENTER GALGIANI
AYE I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THIS
[inaudible]
LICENSING --
PROFESSIONALISM OF ATHLETIC
TRAINERS.
I THINK IT'S A GOOD STEP AND
YOU'RE GOING FOR EVEN DOCTOR I
THINK APPLIED AT THAT.
YEAH HIS FOCUS WAS WAS PRIMARILY
ALL YA ON THE ATHLETIC.
YES SIDE OF THINGS.
I I'D LIKE TO SEE YOU DO SOME
WORK HERE AND SEE IF WE KEY HAD --
NARROW THIS SO THAT --
BURIED THERE AT LEAST IS SOME
DIRECTION GOING FORWARD OF
WHAT'S GOING TO BE HAPPENING
OUTSIDE THE SCOPE OF YOU KNOW.
THE ATHLETIC TEAM ENVIRONMENT IT.
S. SENATOR PAN YOU HAD A COMMENT.
YES I ACTUALLY JUST FOR THIS
BILL'S GOING FROM OF YOUR DATA
INTO PREPARATIONS OKAY --
SO.
FIRST OF ALL I MET IT WOULD
WE'VE BEEN CLEARLY FROM ALL THE
PAST BILLS WE'VE BEEN WRESTLING
THIS ISSUE FOR AWHILE AND I
APPRECIATE.
A SUMMER MELON THAT YOU'RE
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO LAND
THIS THING IN THE AND I AGREE
WITH THE PROPONENTS THAT WE DO
NEED TO HAVE A THEY'LL
CERTIFICATION Y. STIR PROCESS
FOR ATHLETIC TRAINERS THE FACT
THAT WE'RE THE ONLY STATE.
THAT DOESN'T HAVE WHAT IS
PROBLEMATIC AND THAT IT DIDN'T
AND CERTAINLY CONCERNED THAT YOU
HAVE PEOPLE WHO CAN CALL
THEMSELVES UP LIKE TRAINERS WHO
DON'T.
HAVE -- THAT
HAD AND DIDN'T THEIR LITTLE. FOR
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA --
I AM --
CONCERNED.
THAT -- THAT
EVEN AS WE'RE TRYING TO NAVIGATE
THIS -- THAT --
THAT IF A THINK POLICE.
THAT'S THE SCOPE STILL SEEMS A
BIT BROAD --
I REALIZED OR MAYBE ATHLETIC
TRAINERS ARE PEOPLE CALLING THE
SELF LYFT TRAINERS WHO WERE YOU
KNOW NOT IN NECESSARILY SPORTS
TYPE SETTINGS BUT I THINK WE
HAVE TO BE VERY CAREFUL ABOUT
THAT.
AND MAYBE AS WE HAVE MORE
EXPERIENCE THAT WILL YOU KNOW
MAYBE THEN.
THAT JUST MEANS CAN BE MADE THAT
WHETHER THAT'S MORE CLEARLY
DEFINE AYE I THINK THAT THERE'S
BIT OF OVERLAP --
AND AND AND AND AND WITH SOME OF
THE OTHER.
QUESTIONS THAT I THINK CREATES
FACE SOME CONFUSION AND ALSO
WITH AND THAT THEY MAY HAVE.
DIFFERENT --
INCLUDING HIGHER STANDARDS OF
TRAINING [inaudible]
YEAH --
ACTUALLY --
AT THE OTHER PART IS A THIS
SUPERVISION PIECE I APPRECIATE
THERE IS THE SUPERVISION PIECE --
I DON'T THINK THERE IS LIKE ANY --
PROFESSIONALS BEING SUPERVISED --
YOU KNOW WE HAVE PROTOCOLS AT
SOME PLACE THAT'S IN THE BILL
BUT I THINK THERE IS SOME
REQUIREMENT FOLLOW UP THAT NEEDS
THAT SHOULD BE PART OF THIS --
AND I REALIZE THAT THAT SOME OF
THAT WILL BE DEFINED BY THE
PROTOCOLS BUT I I THINK THERE'S
SOME AND ALSO.
DURATION OF FLIGHT DEL TWO
HUNDRED ATHLETIC TRAINERS --
AS SO I THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE
PROBLEMATIC IS THAT THE QUESTION
IS REALLY WHAT BECAUSE YOU
PROVISIONS REALLY HAPPENING --
BUT I ALSO AM CONCERNED ABOUT
THAT POLICY COMING IN THERE
ABOUT THE WEATHER --
AND I APPRECIATE YOU BEING OPEN
TO THAT IS THAT WHETHER A
SEPARATE BOARD.
IS REALLY THE BEST WAY TO GO
PERHAPS --
ACTUALLY SINCE THEY ARE BEING
GOING TO BE SUPERVISED BY.
PHYSICIANS MAYBE THE MEDICAL
BOARD.
RIGHT IT MAY BE THE BEST PLACE
TO START LANDING IT SINCE.
THAT SINCE THEY HAVE --
TO TERMS OF BEING ABLE TO DEAL
WITH THE SUIT WELL --
SO -- SO SO
I THINK THAT THAT'S SOMETHING
THAT --
HOPEFULLY CAN.
THE ADDRESS IT AGAIN AND AGAIN
THEY'LL IF IT TURNS OUT THAT
THERE IT MAKES SENSETO HAVE A
SEPARATE BOARD EVENTUALLY BASED
ON THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE WITH
FEDERAL DEBT CAN BE THIS IN THE
FUTURE ABOUT JUST CONCERNED
STARTING IT OFF THAT WAY --
ILL HAVE TO STRUGGLE WITH YOU
BOARD COMBINED WITH HER BUT BUT
I I DO --
HOPE THAT IF THEY DO THINK THAT.
THEY RECOGNIZE WHY YOU PROBABLY
DID THIS BECAUSE YOU'RE AFRAID
OF LEAVING SOME POTENTIALLY SOME
AT LIKE TRAINERS BEHIND --
BUT I YOU KNOW I AM CONCERNED
THAT THOSE.
BUT AT THAT THE LARGER SCOPE
THAT WAS PUT IN.
LEAVE SYSTEM VAGARIES AND ALSO --
ABOUT EXACTLY THE ROLE AND AND
AND I THINK --
OKAY TREAT SOME CHALLENGES IN
TERMS OF WHAT THE ACTUAL
EXPECTATION OF PEOPLE'S
UNDERSTANDING AND AND THAT THAT
CAN LEAD TO CHALLENGES IN THE
FUTURE CALTRANS OF PATIENTS AND
PEOPLE BEING TREATED ABOUT YOU
KNOW WHY.
THIS PERSON REALLY DOING WHAT
THEY SHOULD BE DOING ARE DOING
SOMETHING THAT MIGHT BE OUTSIDE
THEIR SCOPE ETCETERA.
SO IDEA BUT I HOPE THAT YOU BE
WILLING.
TO A LOOK AT THE MAKE
ADJUSTMENTS OF THESE ISSUES
[inaudible]
BILL [inaudible]
FLOOR -- IT
WOULD BE LIKE.
EXPECTING TO SEE SOME OF THOSE
THINGS THAT TRUST --
BEFORE GOOD FOR FLOOR.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER MARC.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
MEMBERS FOR THE ROBUST
CONVERSATION IF I MIGHT JUST AN
IMMEDIATE RESPONSE I'M SURE THE
RATIO ISSUES CAN BE.
WORKED THROUGH --
THE NOTIONS ABOUT SCOPE HOWEVER
IF YOU KNOW THESE FOLKS ARE --
THE 35% THAT ARE WORKING IN NON
ATHLETIC SPECIFIC THOUGHT NON
ATHLETES SPECIFIC --
SCENARIOS THEY ARE ALREADY DOING
THIS SO THEY ARE ALREADY
EMPLOYED OUT THERE IT'S NOT AS
THOUGH THIS WILL OPEN UP A NEW
AVENUE.
OF FOR FOLKS A BUT THE THAT THIS
WHOLE PANOPLY OF ISSUES DOCTOR
PAN I PROMISE TO WORK ON THIS
AND THE STRUCTURE.
LA IS THERE ARE COST ISSUES I
WHICH WILL BE DEALING WITH AN
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE BUT
LOOKING AT THE EXISTING MEDICAL
BOARD STRUCTURE CERTAINLY
SOMETHING I'M OPEN TO SO.
I REALLY APPRECIATE THIS
CONVERSATION I THINK IT'S GONNA
HELP US REFINE IT GET A BETTER
BILL LET ME JUST CLOSE VERY
BRIEFLY --
CHAIRMAN BY SAYING THIS BILL
WILL PROTECT THE PUBLIC DOUBLE
PROTECT EMPLOYERS OF ATHLETIC
TRAINERS AND IT'S GOING TO
PROTECT IF ANY TRAINERS
THEMSELVES IT'S TIME FOR
CALIFORNIA THE COUNTRY'S MOST
POPULOUS STATE.
TO FINALLY AFTER A LONG SORDID
HISTORY ON THIS ISSUE FINALLY
JOINED THE RANKS OF ALL OF THE
STATES TO REGULATE ATHLETIC
TRAINING AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK.
FOR THANK YOU SEE AND REMEMBER
MOMENT IS THERE A MOTION.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MOTION BY
SENATOR GLAZIER OF PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL RUSSIA'S JEFF PASSED
THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE HEALTH I HILL AYE
FULLER.
ALLEN.
NOT AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER AYE GLAZER
AYE HERNANDEZ.
PAN.
I CAN I WILL THOSE WILK NO
[inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
FULLER NO [inaudible]
MITCHELL.
BUT THAT THE BILL HAS SIX VOTES
WILL HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU THERE
ARE NOT THIS IS ENOUGH TO GET
OUT SIR THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND
REMEMBER MULLIN APPRECIATE THAT
[inaudible]
SO [inaudible]
FOR OKAY.
NO WHAT DO ONE MORE.
WELL ACTUALLY --
STE.
RIGHT ICY ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK
SILVA IS HERE.
I DON'T SEE ANY OTHER MEMBERS
SHOWS WE WILL.
SO WE WILL PLEASE COME FORWARD
WILL MOVE NOW.
TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK SILVA
ITEM NUMBER. THREE THREE FIVE
THIRTEEN IS THIS OF COURSE WORK
IT YES SIGNATURE DROVE I WILL.
WHO DID? TO HAVE ALL THE BUILT.
USER ITEM NUMBER.
THREE WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
SENATOR.
DODD -- WE
ALSO HAVE AMENDMENTS
[inaudible]
A LITERACY.
JOHN COMMENT SIX OF THEM.
YES WOULD YOU HAVE A WE DO SO
AMENDMENTS.
THAT TO HIM PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
TO REQUIRE THE CENTER TO BE
REVIEWED AND UPDATED WHEN
NECESSARY.
SO THAT --
WE WILL.
TAKE THOSE.
AND YOU SAID IT'S A SUPPORT
SUPPORT IF OUT OF VOTE JUST LET
YOU KNOW THAT --
THIS IS ACTUALLY A PIECE OF
LEGISLATION THAT HAS COME UP
MANY TIMES --
WHEN LOUIS OR DOING COMMUNITY
GROUPS THAT ARE DISTRICT?
AND WE TALK ABOUT GOBIZ AND WE
GET A VERY GOOD RESPONSE FOR ONE
WE ASK PEOPLE THEY KNOW HOW TO
GET TO THE SITE IF THEY CAN PULL
IT UP ON THEIR PHONE THAT THEY
CAN BE.
UNSURE OF WHERE TO GO SO THIS
WILL KIND OF UPDATE US MAKING
SURE -- THAT
WITH THE PORTAL THAT IT WILL
BECOME MORE USER FRIENDLY AND
THAT YOU CAN JUST.
UP POP UP ON YOUR OWN PHONING
GET THERE AND THAT'S WHAT WE
WANT TO DO FOR OUR SMALL
BUSINESSES THAT WILL ACT --
IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
HAPPY TO ANSWER FOR YOU THANK
YOU VERY MUCH --
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS A MEMBER
ANYONE HERE IN SUPPORT. ZERO
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION SEEING
NO ONE BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
FROM MEMBERS.
AND THIS IS --
IS OUR MOTION.
THAT MOVEMENT I FIGURED HAD
ALREADY MOVED THAT SENATOR DODD
MADE THE MOTION PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
I REMEMBER THREE MOTIONS TO PASS
AS AMENDED THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS THE HEALTH AYE
HILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE DODD AYE
GALGIANI.
GLAZER HERNANDEZ HAND
[inaudible]
WELL.
THE BILL HAS FOUR VOTES WILL
HOLD THE ROLE OF CONTRAPTION
MEMBERS MOVING OUT ITEM NUMBER
FIVE AB FIFTEEN FORTY SEVEN
PLEASE PROCEED.
ALSO HAS THE SAME.
A SUPPORT SUPPORT SUGGESTIONS.
UP ALRIGHT AGAIN ON MAKE UP
BRIEFLY YOU HAVE --
SOME OF SUPPORTERS HERE THAT
WANTED TO MAKE A VERY BRIEF
COMMENTS BUT AB FIFTEEN FORTY
SEVEN MAKES UP PROGRAM BUT
PROGRAM CHANGES FOR THE SMALL
BUSINESS CAPITAL ACCESS LOAN
PROGRAM. FOR CALIFORNIA
AMERICANS WITH DISABILITY AND
AGAIN THE ENTIRE FOCUS HERE IS
TO MAKE SURE THAT FUNDS THAT
HAVE BEEN SET ASIDE THAT ARE
ACTUALLY.
USED IN WE KNOW THAT BECAUSE
THERE WERE HAD ONLY BEEN ONE
APPLICANT OVER A HANDFUL OF
PERIOD THAT WE NEED TO DO MORE
SO THAT WE CAN GET.
OUR SMALL BUSINESSES.
WITH US WE HAVE AYE SPEAKING OUT
RENEE WEBSTER HOPPED AUCTIONS
[inaudible]
SUDDENLY [inaudible]
THE INGO.
ABOUT THE SHUTTLE.
WELL HERE FOR OH OKAY WE HAVE
THE DIRECTORS HERE BUT ADVISED
PULLING.
WE'RE GONNA MAKE VERY WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT PLEASE THAT YES QUICK
COMMENTS AND THANK YOU SENATORS
FOR ALLOWING US TO BE HERE AND
MAKE SOME COMMENTS IN SUPPORT OF
THIS.
FIRST I WOULD LIKE THINK THE
SAID THAT SENT THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER FOR PROVIDING US THE
OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE THIS BILL
FORWARD.
AND THE NOTION OF SUPPORTING
SMALL MANUFACTURERS IN
CALIFORNIA IF YOU'RE FAMILIAR
WITH THE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT
BOND PROGRAM YOU KNOW THAT IT
SUPPORTS UP FINANCING LOW COST
FINANCING FROM MANUFACTURERS.
THAT ARE LOOKING TO BUILD HOMES
HERE WHETHER IT'S OUT. TOO BYE
LIANE TO OR TO GET EQUIPMENT OR
TO EXPAND THEIR OPERATIONS WHICH
IS OBVIOUSLY VERY IMPORTANT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPERS IN OUR STATE.
I'M MORE VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT OF
ELIMINATING SIT BACK AS WE
BELIEVE IT REQUIRES DUPLICATE
REVIEW.
OF A TOOL THAT'S ALREADY
GOVERNED BY THE THE FEDERAL
FINANCE SYSTEM AND ALSO BY THE
IRS SO.
WE KNOW THAT THERE'S LOTS OF
TOOLS ALREADY I PLACE TO HELP
MANUFACTURERS BUT WE THINK THIS
IS A NECESSARY ONE TO HELP OUR
MANUFACTURES GROW.
AND TO EXPAND IN THE STATE SO
WE'RE VERY GRATEFUL TO THE
TREASURER'S OFFICE AS WELL FOR
LISTENING TO OUR CONCERNS THEY
HAVE THE BENEFIT OR MAYBE NOT
BENEFIT OF SEEING ME FOR THE
LAST THREE YEARS.
ASKING TO REMOVE THIS AND WE'RE
VERY PLEASED TO BE HERE AND WE
ASK FOR YOUR YES VOTE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
GOOD AFTERNOON SHARED MEMBERS OF
THE BLOOD JOHNSON LET'S HAVE
COORDINATOR HOME BEHALF OF STATE
TREASURER JOHN CHIANG.
THE TRAGIC WOULD SHARE THAT THE
AUTHORITIES IN THIS BILL WOULD
LIKE TO THANK THE MEMBER QUIRK
SILVA FOR HER LEADERSHIP ON THIS
IMPORTANT ISSUE.
AND WE HAVE A THREE ELECTED
DIRECTORS HERE TO ANSWER ANY
TECHNICAL QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE
WONDERFUL THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
EITHER OF THEM.
AB PEOPLE HERE IN SUPPORT PLEASE
COME FORWARD.
WELL MY NAME IS HELEN JOB MYRON
SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ENTERPRISE
DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND SWUNG
IT SAY WE ARE IN A LINE.
WITH A THE VIEWS EXPRESSED BY
THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION FOR
LOCAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHO
BELIEVE MANUFACTURERS SHOULD
HAVE A CLEAR PATH TO ACCESS THE
LOW COST IN THE INDUSTRIAL
DEVELOPMENT BOND.
OF FINANCING TOOL TO GROW.
THANK THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS
IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
SEEN NO ONE FEEDBACK FOR
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
THE BILL WITH THE MOTION WOULD
LIKE TO CLOSE.
I JUST ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT VERY
GOOD THANK YOU WE HAVE A MOTION
FROM SENATOR DODD PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
DO YOU PATTERSON [inaudible]
WELL I WELL I FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE DODD AYE
GALGIANI.
GLAZER GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AYE AND I WILL
DIE WILL DIE.
THE BILL HAS A VOTE TO UPHOLD
THE RULE OVER FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ITEM NUMBER
THIRTEEN AB.
TWENTY FOUR SIXTY THREE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER QUIRK SILVA.
AND THIS IS OUR SMALL BUSINESS
ASSISTANCE ACT AND THIS WILL.
ENHANCE THE PROGRAM.
AGAIN WORKING CLOSELY WITH
GLOBUS OUR COMMITTEE HAS WORKED
VERY CLOSELY WITH GOBIZ IN
TWENTY EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINETEEN
OUT WE UP THROUGH THE STATE
BUDGET PASSED BOTH HOUSES.
WHICH INCLUDED SEVENTEEN MILLION
FOR THIS PROGRAM WE HAD SEVENTY
MINUTES A SEVENTY SMALL
BUSINESSES AND THE AT THAT ARE
LOCATED THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
AND WE KNOW THAT THIS WOULD BE
THE FIRST OF PORT AND SEVERAL
YEARS FOR SMALLVILLE BUSINESS
DEVELOPMENT CENTERS.
VERY GOOD THINKING YUBA DOING A
VERY GOOD JOB ON THIS --
SUBJECT MATTER TO THANK YOU FOR
THAT ASSEMBLYMEMBER OVERNIGHT
OVER.
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT
PLEASE COME.%
FOR GOOD AFTERNOON AFTERNOON
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MORE
ATOP ON BEHALF OF ORANGE COUNTY
BUSINESS COUNCIL ON SUPPORTER
YOU THINK YOU.
MEMBERS DAVID JONES AND HAVE THE
CITIES OF LOS BANOS MARIETTA AND
THE CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURING
TECHNOLOGY CONCERT.
THANK YOU.
SURE MEMBERS ALL ROCK OR A
CALIFORNIA LIFE SCIENCES
ASSOCIATION OR BURGER THANK YOU.
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION.
YOU KNOW ONE BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE [inaudible]
YEAH SURFACE.
RIGHT WILL YOU WE DO HAVE --
ISSUE.
HERE'S THE CURRENT BUDGET
TRAILER BUDGET TRAILER BILL IS
DEALING WITH THIS ISSUE AS WELL
[inaudible]
SO.
YOU KNOW SO THIS IS CLEAN UP BUT
WE ALSO JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE
WE KEPT MOVING I MAKE SURE THAT
ANYTHING CHANGED WE HAD A
VEHICLE.
VERY VERY GOOD THANK YOU --
DOUG CAN MOVE IT IS.
WILL MOTION FOR DOCTOR PATTEN'S
CALL THE ROLL.
AS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HEALTH
AYE HILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ON I DIED I THOUGHT I GALGIANI.
LASER.
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ I
CAN'T I CAN'T I WILL WRITE.
FILLED WITH THE HOLY. EIGHT
VOTES THAT WILL HOLD THE ROLE OF
OF THE ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU
VERY MUCH I THINK IT SENATORS.
WE KNOW WHO.
THE ACTUAL ITEM NUMBER SIX I SEE
IS --
SIMILAR I CDVA.
AB FIVE ZERO FIVE ITEM NUMBER
[inaudible]
TWO GOOD AFTERNOON [inaudible]
THAT AFTERNOON.
JOINT HEALTH BEHIND IT IS
[inaudible]
AMERICAN.
TUSHAR WITH ITEM NUMBER TWO AB
FIVE OH FIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
IN EVERY THERE'S A CLARIFYING
AMENDMENT THAT --
I GUESS.
CHAIRMAN HELEN SENATORS I THINK
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY PRESENT THE
AB FIVE OH FIVE WHICH WOULD
EXTEND THE TIME FOR DISCLOSURE
OF AN EXPERT WITNESS. TO ONE
HUNDRED DAYS UNDER CERTAIN
CIRCUMSTANCES IN JUDICIAL
MATTERS BROUGHT BY THE MEDICAL
BOARD OF CALIFORNIA.
ON LET ME START BY SAYING I'M
HAPPY TO TAKE THE COMMITTEES
CLARIFYING AMENDMENTS TO CONFORM
KNOWING WHICH TO THE CODE
SECTION I THINK MAKES A LOT OF
SENSE.
MEDICAL EXPERT WITNESSES PROVIDE
TESTIMONY RELATIVE CASE IS BEING
HEARD BY THE MEDICAL BOARD.
BOTH SIDES OF A CASE ARE PRETTY
THIS CERTAIN INFORMATION
REGARDING THE EXPERT WITNESS AND
THIS INFORMATION MUST BE GIVEN
TO THE OTHER PARTY PRIOR TO THE
HEARING DATE.
HOWEVER RECENT RULES REGARDING
EXPERT WITNESS REPORTS AND
TESTIMONY PUT IN PLACE LAST YEAR
HAVE CREATED A UNIQUE.
AND I A UNDUE BURDEN ON THE
DEFENDANT PHYSICIANS THESE NEW
RULES DO NOT ALLOW FOR
AMENDMENTS TO BE MADE TO THE
TESTIMONY DO NOT ALLOW FOR
SUMMARY EXCHANGE AND CREATE AN
INFLEXIBLE TIMELINE. FOR
EXCHANGE OF A MEETING DATE IS
CHANGED.
AB FIVE OH FIVE ADDRESSES THESE
ISSUES BY INCREASING THE TIME
FRAME FOR DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT
WITNESS TESTIMONY FROM THIRTY TO
ONE HUNDRED DAYS.
BASED ON A SHOWING OF GOOD CAUSE
AND SUBJECT TO THE APPROVAL OF
THE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
FROM THE CASE.
IT IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT
THIS ONE HUNDRED EXTENSION WILL
NOT INTERFERE WITH THE OTHER
PARTIES ABILITY TO EVALUATE THE
DISCLOSURE OF THE EXPERT WITNESS.
BECAUSE THEY DID DISCLOSURE WILL
STILL HAVE TO TAKE PLACE AT
LEAST THIRTY DAYS PRIOR TO THE
HEARING DATE.
THIS ADDITIONAL TIME PERIOD WILL
ENSURE BOTH PARTIES IN THE CASE
HAVE ADEQUATE TIME TO PREPARE.
FOR EXPERT WITNESS TESTIMONY
TESTIMONY WHICH IS VITAL TO
PROTECTING THE RIGHTS OF DUE
PROCESS.
I STANDARD WE ALL EXPECT IN ANY
JUDICIAL SYSTEM IN THE UNITED
STATES.
IT'S SUPPORT OF FAIR TREATMENT
IN ALL CASES HEARD BY THE
MEDICAL CARD I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE TODAY.
WITH ME TODAY IS MEGAN AL READ
FROM THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
[inaudible]
DOESN'T SUPPORT.
THANK YOU CHAIR AND MEMBERS MAKE
IT ALRIGHT ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
SABRI SHADE ALL THE STAKEHOLDER
INPUT THAT WENT INTO ON CRAFTING
THESE.
AT THIS FIX AND WE'VE
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR ABOUT VERY
GOOD THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT
THANK TIM PERSON MOST OF THE
MEDICAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA
ALTHOUGH THE BOARD DOESN'T HAVE
A POSITION AT THIS TIME.
THE BOARD DID WORK WITH ALL
INTERESTED PARTIES AND PROVIDE
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE ON THE
LANGUAGE AND STOP WILL BE
RECOMMENDING THAT THE BOARD
SUPPORT THE STARTING IN JULY
THINK VERY GOOD THANK YOU OTHERS
IN SUPPORT PLEASE COME FORWARD.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION.
SEEING NO ONE WE HAVE A MOTION.
FOR I'M SENATOR GLACIER.
OF WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE.
HERE I THINK YOU VERY LIFE
SIMPLY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS A MINUTE
TO SEND TO THE SENATE FLOOR
HEALTH I FEEL I'VE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
AND I'D DODD AYE AYE GALGIANI.
GLAZER GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AND HIS AYE PAN AYE AND I WILL.
LOOK I EIGHT EIGHT EIGHT VOTES --
WILL HOLD THE RULE CONTRAPTION
PRODUCTION MEMBER THERE WILL
MOVE THAT ITEM NUMBER TWENTY TWO
EIGHTY TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY NINE
BRINGING THAT BACK FROM --
PREVIOUS --
HEARING WE HAD SIR THANK YOU FOR
COMING BACK THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
AND LET ME START BY SAYING
EXCEPT THAT THERE COMMITTEES
RECOMMENDATIONS AND HAVE AMENDED
THE BILL TO EXEMPT INDEPENDENT
PHARMACIES AS WELL AS REDEFINE
SAFE STORAGE PRODUCTS AND I I
HAVE HERE SOME OF THE EXAMPLES.
OF THE PRODUCTS THAT --
THAT I I HAVE COLLECTED AS I'VE
GONE AROUND TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT.
HOW WHAT YOU'RE FINISHING MAKES
SENSE -- AB
TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY NINE WOULD
INCREASE THE AVAILABILITY OF
SAFE STORAGE DEVICES IN PHARMACY
SO IT'S TO CURE DANGER.
AS TO SECURE DANGEROUS AND
ADDICTIVE MEDICATIONS AT HOME.
THE OPIOID EPIDEMIC HAS SPREAD
TO MASSIVE PROPORTIONS IN OUR
COUNTRY OVER THE PAST DECADE IN
YOU YOU'VE SEEN THESE --
OPIOIDS KATE --
AT BILL SO I IT'S I'M NOT
TELLING YOU ANYTHING THAT YOU
HAVEN'T HEARD ALREADY
APPROXIMATELY 15% OF
CALIFORNIANS HAD AN ACTIVE
OPIOID PRESCRIPTION IN.
TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN PLACING
OPIOIDS IN MILLIONS OF HOMES
ACROSS THE STATE.
THIS PREVALENCE OF PRESCRIBED
OPIOIDS MAKES AN EASILY
ACCESSIBLE TO YOUNG CHILDREN AND
TEENS THROUGH THEIR PARENTS
MEDICINE CABINETS LEADING TO AN
INCREASED ACCIDENTAL INGESTION
IT'S AN EARLY ONSET ABUSE.
THE NUMBER OF ACCIDENTAL
POISONINGS OF TODDLERS HAS
TRIPLED SINCE NINETEEN NINETY
SEVEN LEADING TO A YEARLY
AVERAGE OF SIXTY THOUSAND
CHILDREN.
UNDER THE AGE OF FIVE THAT END
UP IN EMERGENCY ROOMS BECAUSE
THEY SWALLOW DANGEROUS
MEDICATIONS.
ADDITIONALLY RECENT DATA SHOWS
THAT 70% OF THE PRESCRIPTION
DRUGS OBTAINED FOR NON MEDICAL
USE BY CHILDREN TWELVE AND OLDER.
ORIGINALLY CAME FROM A HOUSEHOLD
AND EVERY DAY THREE THOUSAND
CHILDREN AGES TWELVE TO
SEVENTEEN ABUSE OF PRESCRIPTION
PAINKILLER FOR THE FIRST TIME.
AND THE AVAILABILITY OF THESE
AND THIS MEDICATION TO CHILDREN
AT HOME IS A DANGEROUS THREAT.
AND IN IS DUE IN LARGE PART TO
THE LACK OF A SAFE STORAGE
PRACTICE.
THE CDC HAS REPORTED THAT FEWER
THAN 3% OF HOUSEHOLDS NATIONWIDE
LOCK UP THEIR PRESCRIPTION
MEDICATIONS AND YOU KNOW YOU
PROBABLY HEARD OF KIDS TEENS.
AND ENGAGING IN PILL PARTIES AND
REALTORS REQUIRING THAT ALL
MEDICATIONS IN THE HIGH IN THE
HOME BE LOCKED UP.
BEFORE THEY END UP SHOWING THE
HOME BECAUSE VISIT.
DIFFERENT OPEN HOUSES AND GO
THROUGH THE MEDICINE CABINETS
AND RIFLE THROUGH THE DRUGS IT
BETTER -- IT
LOCATED IN THOSE HOMES ALL OF
THESE ARE REAL SERIOUS --
LIFE STORIES AND SO ON THE RE
THAT'S REALLY THE REASON FOR IT
FOR THIS BILL INCREASING THE
AVAILABILITY OF SAFE STORAGE
OPTIONS WILL HELP EDUCATE.
PARENTS ABOUT SECURE STORAGE
PRACTICES.
SAFEGUARDING CHILDREN FROM
ACCIDENTAL INGESTION ENCOURAGE
EXPERIMENTATION.
AND IT'S A SMALL BUT I'M
SIGNIFICANT PREVENTIVE MEASURE
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
I'VE OTHER THANK YOU VERY MUCH --
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
JOHN LINGER ON DEATH A
GATEKEEPER INNOVATION IN SUPPORT
ALSO BEEN ASKED TO VOICE SUPPORT
FOR THE CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR
CHILDREN'S HEALTH AND SAFETY.
AS WELL AS CORPS MEDICAL CLINIC
WHICH IS A SUBSTANCE USE
DISORDER FACILITY THAT HAS SEEN
FIRST HAND HOW MANY TEENS ARE
BECOMING ADDICTED TO THE
MEDICINE CABINET HOME SO WE URGE
YOUR SUPPORT THROUGH THANK YOU.
WITH YOUR MEMBERS RAND ONE ON
BEHALF OF THE AIDS HEALTHCARE
FOUNDATION THE CDC HA
ACKNOWLEDGED THAT THERE IS A
DIRECT CORRELATION BETWEEN --
OPIOID USE ON THE RISE IN THE
HIV EPIDEMIC I'M WE HAVE SEEN IT
ON THE FRONT LINES OF ANYTHING.
LIKE THIS BILL THAT CAN HELP US
STEM THAT RISE WOULD BE --
WOULD BE REALLY HELPFUL WE URGE
YOUR SUPPORT PHILIP THANK YOU
VERY MUCH REGARD OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
THE YOU KNOW WON THE IS THERE
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
COME FORWARD [inaudible]
WIENER.
AND AFTER NAY MACHAR REVERSAL
THE PHARMACISTS ASSOCIATION WANT
TO THANK THE CHAIR AND STAFF AND
OF COURSE THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
FOR WORKING WITH US TO ADDRESS
OUR CONCERNS.
WITH THE RECENT AMENDMENTS TO
THE BILL WHERE REMOVING
OPPOSITION THINK AFTER GOOD
THANK YOU APPRECIATE THAT OTHERS
IN OPPOSITION OR REMOVING.
YOU KNOW WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
SENATOR GLAZER WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NOW THANK
YOU VERY MUCH PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
QUESTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS.
HELL I KNOW I FULLER
[inaudible]
ALAN.
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE AYE DODD AYE
GALGIANI AYE GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE.
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AYE AYE AND I
WILL.
WILL GUIDE [inaudible]
IF.
THE BILL HAS EIGHT VOTES AND IT
IS OUT THANK YOU VERY MUCH VERY
MUCH THEY KICKING OFF.
THANK YOU WANNA TAKE UP THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
IF WE COULD THAT'S ITEM NUMBER
NINE TWENTY ONE THIRTY FOUR AND
THIRTY FIVE BUT IS THERE A
MOTION.
MOTION BY SENATOR WILL PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL HEALTH I KNOW AYE
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN.
AYE DODD.
DODD AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE PAN AYE PAN AYE WELL TIME
WILL BY.
FIGURED THAT THEIR CONSENT
CALENDARS UP WITH NINE VOTES AND
I SEE ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHEN.
HE'D LIKE TO COME FORWARD THANK
YOU ARE MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER
SIX AB.
SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN GOOD
AFTERNOON.
GOOD AFTERNOON SIR THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME REMEMBERS.
I'M HERE TODAY TO PRESENT AB
SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN AND THIS
BILL WOULD AUTHORIZE TRAINED
BOTANIST UTILIZES SPECIFICALLY
DESIGNED.
FDA CLEARED DEVICE ALLOWS BLOOD
TO BE DRAWN VEIN UTILIZING A
PERIPHERAL IV CATHETER.
BEFORE BEGIN LET'S DISCUSS THE
AMENDMENT THAT HAD BEEN
AMENDMENTS WERE DEVELOPED WITH
THE COOPERATION OF COMMITTEE
STAFF TO ADDRESS CONCERNS.
STATED IN THE ANALYSIS THE FIRST.
ONE IS A FOUR ONE THIS WOULD NOT
BE ABLE USE THIS DEVICE ON ANY
PATIENT WITHOUT THE APPROVAL THE
PERSON MANAGING THE PATIENTS IV.
SPECIFICALLY OFTEN THE CASE
OWNER'S.
NUMBER TWO IT WILL REQUIRE FULL
BOTTOM IS TRAINED INCLUDE AT
LEAST FIFTY SUCCESSFUL BLOOD
DRAWS USING THIS DEVICE.
THE THIRD WANTED REQUIRE THE
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
REVISED ITS REGULATIONS FOR FULL
BONHOMIE CERTIFICATION.
INCLUDE EDUCATION TRAINING ON
BLOOD WITHDRAWAL FROM AND
FLETCHER OF A PERIPHERAL VENOUS
CATHETER.
THIS WE DIDN'T PRESENT NO FOUR
ONE MS WILL BE WILL UTILIZE THIS
DEVICE UNTIL REGULATIONS ARE
COMPLETE AND THEY'RE PROBABLY
TRAINED AND CERTIFIED.
AND WHAT THE ACCEPT THESE
AMENDMENTS AS MY AUTHORS
AMENDMENTS VERY GOOD THANK YOU
AND I APPRECIATE YOUR
WILLINGNESS TO WORK IN THE AND
COME TO AN AGREEMENT ON THAT.
REPEAT THAT THANK YOU THANK YOU
MISTER.
ON THANK YOU MEMBERS ARE REALLY
PROCEDURE STAFF FOR ALL THE HELP
UP A COUPLE HINGS Y. THIS IS AN
IMPORTANT BILL.
WAS DRAWS ARE ONE OF THE MOST
IMPORTANT MOST COMMON FREQUENT
PROCEDURES AT HOSPITALS.
THE CURRENT METHOD OF DRAWING
BLOOD LISA ABOUT TWO HUNDRED
NEIL RELATED TREES DALY AMONG
HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS.
IN TWENTY SIXTEEN IT WAS
ESTIMATED AMONG ADULT PATIENTS
28% HAVE TO BE STUCK AT LEAST
TWICE TO DROP.
TRUST WHEN.
THIS GOES 2404% AMONG CHILDREN.
REPEATED ATTEMPTS SINCE HER
NEEDLES INTO VEINS AND TREATMENT
DELAYS CAN HER PATIENT
SATISFACTION AND INCREASED COSTS
OF CARE AND EFFORT TO ADDRESS
THIS PROBLEM FTA RECENT CLEARED.
A REVOLUTION DEVICE ALLOWS
HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS TO DRAW
BLOOD THROUGH AN IV CATHETER
RATHER THAN PAINFUL NEEDLE STICK
METHOD TO GET THEIR BLOOD
SPECIMEN.
IN TWENTY SIXTEEN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA HOSPITALS OR CLINICS
BEYOND TRAINING NURSES TO
UTILIZE THIS TECHNOLOGY.
BUT UNLIKE THE REST OF THE
NATION CALIFORNIA [inaudible]
FOR RICHARD.
BECAUSE CURRENT LAW SPECIFICALLY
LIMITS THE FULL BOTTOM IS TO
SKIN PUNCTURE THE DRAW BLOOD IT
IS SIMPLY LOGICAL BUT ONE HEALTH
CARE PROFESSIONAL.
ABOUT MISS WHOSE SOLE PURPOSE
WITHDRAW BLOOD CANNOT PERFORM
THIS NEW BLOOD DRAW PROCEDURE.
MAYBE SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVEN WOULD
FIX THIS PROBLEM AND AUTHORIZED
THE BOTTOMLESS AFTER APPROPRIATE
TRAINING CERTIFICATION AND
FACILITY APPROVAL TO DRAW BLOOD.
WHO'D ALREADY ESTABLISHED IV
CATHETER AND AVOID THE PATIENT
EXPERIENCING A PAINFUL MEAL
STATE.
METHOD EVERY TIME JUST TO GET
THE BLOOD SPECIMEN.
WITH ME TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY AND
HELP ANSWER QUESTIONS UP TO DATE
GONE KEEP MEDICAL OFFICER OF ONE
OF THE BEST TO IMPOSE ACTUAL
BASED MEDICAL DEVICE COMPANY.
ANTON DONE.
BURGER THANK YOU [inaudible]
PLEASE PROCEED [inaudible]
WHOEVER REFLECTED [inaudible]
YES.
LITTLE NEW WITH THAT.
HI MY NAME IS DOCTOR PLUMBER
DEATH GUN I'M A CO FOUNDER AND
CHIEF MEDICAL OFFICER OF A LOT
OF VASCULAR SAN FRANCISCO BASED
MEDICAL DEVICE COMPANY.
AND ALSO THE INVENTOR OF OUR FDA
CLEARED NEEDLE FREE BLOOD
COLLECTION TECHNOLOGY THAT'S
CALLED PEABO.
PEOPLE IS A SINGLE USE
DISPOSABLE STERILE DEVICE A
TEMPORARILY CONNECTS TO
HOSPITALIZE PATIENTS IV CATHETER.
I AM TO RELIABLY TO ENABLE
VIRTUALLY PAINLESS AND RELIABLE
BLOOD SAMPLING.
HOSTELS AROUND THE COUNTRY
INCLUDING IN CALIFORNIA ARE
STANDARDIZING ON IV CTHETER
BLOOD COLLECTION WITH PEABO.
BRYSON OBVIOUS BENEFITS. ONE TO
IMPROVE THE PATIENT EXPERIENCE
TO TO REDUCE THE RISK OF
ACCIDENTAL NEEDLE INJURIES TO
THEIR STAFF. THREE TO IMPROVE
LAB EFFICIENCY BY REDUCING
PROJECTED SPECIMEN RIGHTS.
AND THEN FINALLY TO REDUCE THE
NEED TO ACCESS THEIR PATIENTS
CENTRAL LINES ARE IMPLANTED
PORTS WHICH USUALLY CARRIER
HIGHER RISK OF INFECTION.
THERE'S ROBUST EVIDENCE
SUPPORTING BLOOD DRAWS FROM IV
CATHETERS WITH PEABO. FOR PEER
REVIEW JOURNAL PUBLICATIONS HAVE
DEMONSTRATED SEVERAL THINGS.
LOVES COLLECTED WITH PEOPLE ARE
EQUIVALENT TO VENA PUNCTURE.
USING PEOPLE DOES NOT NEGATIVELY
AFFECT THE IV CATHETER LIFE.
USING VETO CAN REDUCE POOR
QUALITY SAMPLES WHICH DIRECTLY
TRANSLATES INTO LESS REPEAT
TESTING FOR PATIENTS AND BETTER
HOSPITAL WORK FLOW.
IN ADDITION TO THE CLINICAL
EVIDENCE THE PEOPLE PROCEDURE
HAD BEEN SAFELY PERFORMED
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF TIMES
IN THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS ALL
WITHOUT A SINGLE ADVERSE EVENT
[inaudible]
SINGLE.
ONE THESE IT CATHER BLOOD DRAWS
AND PERFORMED BY BOTH NURSING
AND PHLEBOTOMY.
AND ALL PATIENT CARE AREAS IN A
HOSPITAL INCLUDING ICE TO USE
LABOR DELIVERY EMERGENCY ROOMS
MEDICAL SURGICAL CENTERS OR A
FLOORS AND IN PEDIATRICS.
PATIENT SAFETY IS PARAMOUNT AND
THIS NEW PROCEDURE STILL PLACES
NURSING IN CONTROL OF THE
PATIENTS IV THERAPY.
IF INFUSION IS RUNNING ON A
BLOOD DRAWS REQUIRED THE
PATIENT'S NURSE WILL DECIDE
BRIEFLY IF PAUSING THE IV
CATHETER BRIEFLY.
ON IS APPROPRIATE AND WILL FLUSH
THE IV LINE BEFORE A FULL BOTTOM
THIS WOULD COLLECT THE BLOOD
SAMPLE.
CLEAR FOR BOTANISTS WILL NEVER
START STOP STOP OR PAUSE ANY
RUNNING INFUSIONS.
THIS COORDINATION BETWEEN FOR
BONHOMIE AND NURSING IS ACTUALLY
NOT NEWMAN IS ALREADY A
IMPLEMENTED TODAY FOR
TRADITIONALLY THE PUNCTURE.
LASTLY ALL PROVIDERS COMPLETE IN
PERSON TRAINING AND DEMONSTRATE
COMPETENCY TO PERFORM THE
PROCEDURE SAFELY AND EFFECTIVELY.
IN CALIFORNIA TODAY THE MAJORITY
OF BLOOD DRAWS ARE CONDUCTED BY
FOUR BOTANISTS AND THIS BILL
WILL ENABLE THEM IN
COLLABORATION WITH THEIR NURSE
COLLEAGUES TO UTILIZE A SAFER
AND MORE HUMANE PROCEDURE FOR
THE HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS.
I URGE THE COMMITTEE TO VOTE --
IN FAVOR THE BILL AND BE HAPPY
TO DEMONSTRATE THE DEVICE LATER
THE TIME ALLOWS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
I'M TIED DOWN ON THE DIRECTOR OF
INNOVATION FOR INTERMOUNTAIN
HEALTHCARE WHERE I TWENTY TWO
HOSPITAL TWO HUNDRED CLINIC
INTEGRATED DELIVERY NETWORK
CONSULT LAKE CITY.
OVER HALF OF OUR CITIZENS VISIT
OUR HOSPITALS WE DO ABOUT A
MILLION BLOOD DRAWS PER YEAR
THROUGHOUT THE SYSTEM.
AND ABOUT THREE YEARS AGO WE
WERE LOOKING QUITE DEEPLY AT THE
DATA IN THE WORK FLOW AROUND
BLOOD DRAWS.
AND WE HAPPEN TO BE INTRODUCED.
A LOT OF VASCULAR SPEEDO DEVICE.
AND WE THINK IT'S A OR HUMANE
WAY OF DRAWING BLOOD SO WE
DECIDED TO DO A PILOT WITH THEM.
WITH OUR FULL BOTTOM ESTA NURSES
AND LAB TEAMS COLLABORATING WE
DID SIXTEEN THOUSAND DRAWS
WITHOUT ONE ADVERSE EVENT.
IN THESE IN VERY CRITICAL CARE
PATIENTS IN THE CARDIAC ICE TO
YOU WE'VE DONE THIS IN THE PIC
YOU.
PEDIATRIC INTENSIVE CARE UNIT.
AFTER THAT SUCCESSFUL THEY WOULD
DECIDED TO GO INTO A BROADER
PILOT ROLL THIS OUT ACROSS OUR
ENTIRE SYSTEM.
WE'RE HAPPY THAT WE WERE THE
FIRST IN THE COUNTRY TO GET TO
DO THIS.
WE WILL FINISH THE ROLL OUT OF
ALL TWENTY TWO HOSPITALS JULY
TENTH OF THIS YEAR.
SINCE THEN WE'VE DONE A HUNDRED
AND FIFTY THOUSAND ROSS.
WITHOUT ONE SINGLE ADVERSE EVENT
AND ARE FULL BOTTOM THIS HAVE
DRAWN OVER A HUNDRED THOUSAND OF
THOSE.
SUCCESSFULLY IN WORK WITH OUR
NURSES.
HIS DAUGHTER TO HAVE GONE SAID
THEY DO NOT TOUCH THE PUMPS ARE
FROM BOTTOMS DON'T TOUCH THE
PALMS OF THE WORKFLOW STAYS HE
SAME.
PATIENT SAFETY IS PARAMOUNT US
THE NUMBER ONE THING THAT WE
CARE.
FOR WE'VE HAD WONDERFUL SUCCESS.
LETTERS FROM PATIENTS LETTER
FROM KERRY.
FAMILY MEMBERS HAVE WRITTEN S.
THANKING US FOR DOING THAT.
AND SO FROM A PROVIDE
PERSPECTIVE THAT SEES PATIENTS.
EVERY SINGLE DAY.
WE ALSO RECOMMEND OR GET YOU
VOTED FAVOR OF THE BILL VERY
GOOD THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THAT
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
PLEASE COME FORWARD ANYONE IN
OPPOSITION.
PLEASE COME FORWARD [inaudible]
GOOD AFTERNOON [inaudible]
NO.
SPEAKER IF I HAVE RIGHT.
I AM MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBER
STEPHANIE ROBERSON ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA NURSES
ASSOCIATION AND OPPOSITION TO
THE BILL.
WHY WE DO NOT OPPOSE THE USE OF
THE TECHNOLOGY WE THINK IT'S
FABULOUS TECHNOLOGY WE KNOW OUR
NURSES USE AND SOME OF THESE
FACILITIES?
IS THE FACT THAT FOR BOTTOM IS
WHO ARE TRAINED IN DOING I THE
BLOOD DRAWS WOULD BE --
PERFORM THESE FUNCTIONS AND FOR
US THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF KIND
OF A CONCERN ON THAT ONE TO LAY
UP OUT FRONT.
OF THE AMENDMENTS DO NOT ADDRESS
OUR CONCERNS WE UNDERSTAND THIS
MORNING THAT THEY'RE BEING
AMENDMENTS FLOATED THAT SAID
THAT TO NAY WAS IN SUPPORT OF
THEM.
WE AREN'T ON AND THERE WAS ALSO
ANOTHER MISCONCEPTION THAT --
WE SUPERVISE PHLEBOTOMY ES
NURSES DO NOT SUPERVISE FOR
BOTTOM AS THEY ARE A SUPERVISED
BY A CLINICAL LAB SPECIALIST WE
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THAT
WAS.
OUT FRONT SO I JUST WANT TO TURN
THE REST OF MY TIME OVER --
TO MY REGISTERED NURSE I WANT MY
BOARD.
BEDSIDE AT KAISER AND OTHER
FACILITIES TO WALK THROUGH A
NURSING PRACTICE AND AND WHAT
SHE DOES IN HER EVERYDAY WORK.
THANK YOU MS KENNEDY WELCOME.
WELCOME BY RESCUES ME THANK YOU.
BEEN A LONG DAY ALREADY --
WITHOUT FEELING AS HAS A
REGISTERED NURSE YOU KNOW AGAIN
I I SAW THE VIDEO I THINK THE
TECHNOLOGY IS GREAT.
AND LISTENING TO THE INVENTORS
OF THE DEVICE WHERE IT'S USED IN.
A LOT OF THE CRITICAL CARE AREAS
I SEE YOU LABOR AND DELIVERY
PEDIATRICS WHERE MULTIPLE STYX'S
YOU KNOW SOMETHING THAT WE TRY
NOT TO DO --
SO YOU KNOW THE TECHNOLOGY IS
GOOD BUT WHEN I HEARD HIM SAY
THAT THE REGISTERED NURSE IF
YOU'RE GOING TO PAUSE THE IV
FLUIDS THE REGISTERED NURSES
FLUSHING THE LINE.
ANDTHEN IF APPROPRIATE THE
LOCAL HADN'T DRAW THE DROP OF
BLOOD THEN YOU AGAIN THE NURSE
WOULD HAVE TO FLUSH THE LINE AND
THEN RESUME THE IV FLUIDS SO.
MY QUESTION IS.
PROBABLY THE NURSES CAN DO THAT
I MEAN WE WOULD DO THAT ANYWAY
SO WE WOULD REALLY NEED THE FULL
BOTTOM US WE COULD USE THE
TECHNOLOGY --
AND AS AN RN I WOULD I WOULD
USES TECHNOLOGY BUT TO HAVE A
FLAT BOTTOM MISTER THAT INSTEAD
OF ME.
I REALLY DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY
YOU WOULD NEED THAT PERSON ON A
FLOOD BOTANIST'S YOU KNOW WHAT
WHILE THEY ARE NEEDED.
AND THEY DON'T HOLD A LICENSE
THEY HAVE DUTIES [inaudible]
JOBS.
I'M AND THIS IS NOT AS THE SUIT
THEY DON'T HAVE A SCOPE OF
PRACTICE.
AND AND MIKE.
BUT I THINK --
SO. FOR ME --
I CAN'T SEE A FLAT BOTTOM THIS
EVEN AFTER.
FIFTY TEMPS OF DOING THIS SINCE
SUCCESSFUL ARM WITHDRAWING OF
LIGHT USING THIS DEVICE THAT.
MKE CONCERNED WOULD BE REALLY.
IF THEY ARE FLUSHING WATER THEY
FLASHING BY THE FLUSHING OUT
WITH SALINE.
ON AND IF THEY ARE.
I DON'T THINK THAT THAT'S
APPROPRIATE FOR FULL BOTTOM IS
TO DO.
WE'RE GOOD THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE THE TESTIMONY OTHERS
IN OFFICE AND IN OPPOSITION.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS FRIEND
MARTIN ON BEHALF OF THE AIDS
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION AND FOR
THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW H. UP IS
THE LARGEST PROVIDER OF CARE AND
TREATMENT OF PEOPLE WITH HIV AND
AIDS IN THE WORLD.
I'M VERY LARGE HERE IN
CALIFORNIA AND WE HAVE --
HUNDREDS OF PATIENTS ON THAT WE
THAT WE SERVE MANY OF THEM ARE
SUFFERING FROM AN ACUTE STAGE OF
THE DISEASE.
NAM IF THEY HAVE A CATHETER
INSERTED IT'S BECAUSE THEY ARE --
IN AN ACUTE STAGE OF OF AIDS.
WHEN I BROUGHT THIS ISSUE TO OUR
DIRECTOR OF MANAGED CARE LAST
WEEK -- AND
TALK TO HER ABOUT IT YOU KNOW
SHE HAPPENS TO BE IN THE ORIENT
AYE SHE EXPRESSED IMMEDIATE
RESERVATIONS ABOUT HAVING
SOMEBODY OTHER THAN ARE INVOLVED
IN.
INVOLVED IN THIS PROCEDURE IT'S
NOT THAT YOU CANNOT BE TRAINED
TO USE THE THE THAT TECHNOLOY --
ANYBODY CAN BE TRAINED TO USE
THE TECHNOLOGY THE QUESTION IS
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOUR A
VULNERABLE PATIENT I'M IN A IN
IS IN A SITUATION WHERE A PERSON
WITH AN ACUTE STAGE OF AIDS --
AND YOU AND SOMETHING GOES AWRY
IN THE USE OF THE PROCEDURE --
THE PERSON.
ADMINISTERING THE PROCEDURE
UNDER THIS BILL WOULD NOT HAVE
THE SKILL THE TRAINING NECESSARY
TO RESPOND THE CATHETER RUPTURES
IF IT LEAKS ANYTHING ALONG THOSE
LINES.
I'M WOULD WOULD OBVIOUSLY
REQUIRE SOMEBODY TO TO STEP IN
AND DEAL WITH THAT BUT I'M NOT
NECESSARILY GOING HAVE SOMEBODY
TO STEP IN AND DEAL WITH IT AT
THE MOMENT THAT'S HAPPENING WE
PREFER THAT IN OUR AND BE THERE
WITH THAT KIND OF A VULNERABLE
POPULATION.
AND WE WOULD ENCOURAGE THAT THE
SENATE BILL NOT MOVE FORWARD IN
ITS CURRENT FORM THINK.
WE'RE GOOD THANK YOU RESTORED
AND OTHERS IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
COME.
SHARE MEMBERS MAP BROUGHT HERE
ON BEHALF ENGINEERS AND
SCIENTISTS OF CALIFORNIA --
I APOLOGIZE WE DON'T HAVE A
LETTER ON FILE WE'RE WAITING TO
HEAR BACK FROM OUR PRINCIPLES
AND THEY'VE SORT OF ACT OF THE
SIMILAR CONCERNS IT'S DNA HAS
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU WHICH BROUGHT.
OF OTHERS IN OPPOSITION.
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
FOR QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
SEEING NONE THE LESS SENATORS
LATER.
IF YOU MISTER CHAIR --
BY COUPLE THINGS I SO WE DID
HEAR FROM TESTIMONY THAT --
THAT.
THE FULL BODY MASSAGE NEEDED.
I DON'T ASSUME THAT THERE'S SOME
COST EFFICIENCY AND AND THAT THE
USE OF THEM BUT MAYBE YOU COULD
ADDRESS THAT ISSUE OF US.
IT'S GONNA SAVE MONEY --
YES SENATOR LATER I DO BELIEVE
WILL SAVE MONEY THE PRIME ROLE
THE FULL BOTTOM THIS IS TO
WITHDRAW BLOOD.
AND UNFORESEEN TO STANDS RIGHT
NOW ON SOME THE LANGUAGE STATES
THAT IN ORDER FOR THE BLOOD TO
BE DRAWN TO HAVE TO HAVE IT
ADDITIONAL PUNCTURED TO THAT.
THIS TECHNOLOGY PREVENTS THAT
AND RIGHT NOW I WAS THE FORMER
HELP THAT BEFORE LA COUNTY
SUPERVISOR MIKE ANTONOVICH ONE
THE MAJOR ISSUES WE HAVE WITH
OUR FIVE COUNTY HOSPITALS OR
TWELVE COUNTY CLINICS.
WAS THE DAILY ISSUES OF DRAWING
BLOOD WE HAD OVER TWO HUNDRED
ISSUES OUT HAPPEN ON A DAILY
BASIS.
THE LETTER INCREASE HEALTHCARE
COSTS POLITICAL DELAYS OF HEALTH
CARE PROCEDURES SO I TRULY
BELIEVE THIS WILL NOT ONLY
INCREASE PATIENT SAFETY BUT
DECREASE AMOUNT OF HEALTH CARE
COST A PROVIDED.
REPUBLIC OR PRIVATE HEALTH CARE
DELIVERY SYSTEM.
AT ANOTHER FOLLOW UP QUESTION SO
I UNDERSTAND THT THERE IS THAT
THIS IS A UNIQUE DEVICE ITS
COLOR PEOPLE DEVICE MADE BY A
SINGLE COMPANY.
YES SENATOR IS THERE ANYTHING IN
THIS BILL THAT WOULD PREVENT
ANOTHER COMPANY FROM MY CREATING
THEIR OWN TECHNOLOGY HAVE ALWAYS
SENSITIVE TO BRIGHT BLUE ITALY
ARTE.
BENEFIT ANY SINGLE COMPANY
ANYWHERE THREE THING IN YOUR
BILL THAT WOULD LIVE AND ANOTHER
COMPANY FROM.
I ENGAGE IN THE SAME TYPE OF
PRACTICE THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION
CENTER NOT AT ALL --
WELL AMOUNT TIME THEN. TO ME
THIS SEEMS LIKE A I AYE
THOUGHTFUL --
ANSWER TO A LOT OF THE CONCERNS
WE HAD NOT JUST PATIENT HEALTH
WHO.
WHO OF US IS NOT IT DURING ALL
THE NEEDLE STICKS AND SPECIALLY
WHEN YOU'RE IN?
CRITICAL CONDITION HOSPITAL IT
SEEMS LIKE THAT'S A GREAT
PATIENT CARE ELEMENT.
THAT'S ATTRACTED TO MAY AND WE
ALWAYS LOOK FOR WAYS TO REDUCE
HEALTHCARE COSTS AND AND THAT
THE THAT THE CHALLENGE.
AND HERE'S A PLACE WHERE WE
COULD DO IT WITH PATIENT SAFETY
BEING FOREMOST IN HER MIND AND
AND I'M GLAD TO HEAR THAT
THERE'S NOTHING IN THE BILL THAT
WOULD LIMIT OTHER TECHNOLOGIES
THAT WOULD COME INTO THE SPACE.
AND SO WITH THOSE RECENT SOME
HAPPY TO MOVE GOT THANK YOU VERY
MUCH SENATORS LEISURE AND AND I
AGREE WITH ALL YOUR COMMENTS
TODAY.
OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS SEEN
THEN WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
SENATORS PLEASE WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE.
REMEMBER CHEN.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE
BAILEY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HEALTH BY.
BILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE DODD AYE
GALGIANI AYE GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ
[inaudible]
AND WELL.
I WILL BUY.
THE IT REALLY IMPLICIT.
IF YOU KNOW. SEVEN ALL BILL HAS
SEVEN VOTES EACH OUT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER UGH WE ARE CURRY
IC IS HERE.
WONDERFUL WILL MOVE NOW.
TO ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN AB TWENTY
FIVE SEVENTY SIX GOOD AFTERNOON
ASSEMBLY MEMBER [inaudible]
AGAIN ARTERY.
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
AMBER'S.
AB TWENTY FIVE SEVENTY SIX TAKES
HER RECENT EXPERIENCES OF
CLINICS PHARMACIES AND HEALTH
PROVIDERS INTO ACCOUNT AND
PROPOSES CHANGES THAT WILL
PROVIDE. FOR CONTINUITY OF CARE
IN THE FACE OF NATURAL DISASTERS.
NEARLY TWO DOZEN COMMUNITY
HEALTH CENTERS WERE THOUSAND
SEVENTEEN WHILE FAR SEASON.
PUTTING THOUSANDS OF PATIENTS
CARE AT RISK THIS BILL SETS OUT
AND ACCELERATE PERMITTING
PROCESS FOR TEMPORARY PHARMACY
LICENSES DURING A PROCLAIM TO
STATE OF EMERGENCY.
WHICH IS ESSENTIAL INA HEALTH
CARE CENTER HAS BEEN DESTROYED A
CANNOT OPERATE THE PHARMACY TO
DISPENSE MEDICATION TO PATIENTS.
AUTHORIZING THE BOARD OF
PHARMACY TO ISSUED TEMPORARY
PHARMACY LICENSES TO CLINICS AND
MOBILE PHARMACIES WILL PROVIDE
PATIENTS IN THE DISTRESS.
AXIS THIRD OF THEIR MEDICATIONS
WITHOUT DISRUPTION.
IT IS IN EVERYONE'S BEST
INTEREST TO TEMPORARILY INCREASE
FLEXIBILITY DURING THESE TRYING
TIMES AND TO PROVIDE FOR
PATIENTS NEEDS.
EYEWITNESS FROM THE CALIFORNIA
HEALTH PLUS AND ADVOCATES.
THE MOTION FROM SENATOR DODD AND
IN THIS IS A SUPPORT SUPPORT
RECOMMENDATIONS PLEASE PROCEED
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN BURST
MEGAN SUPER SOME BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIA HEALTH PLUS ADVOCATES
A CO SPONSOR REPRESENTING
THIRTEEN HUNDRED COMMUNITY
HEALTH CENTERS AND CLINICS IN
CALIFORNIA.
I KNOW YOU'RE UNDER A TIME
CRUNCH HERE WE'RE PRICELESS
CLASSES AND ASK YOUR I THINK YOU.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU VERY MUCH
AND YOU ARE TAKING THE
AMENDMENTS ASSEMBLYMAN REGULAR
CURRY YORK.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH REYES LONG
HAIR YOU'RE TAKING HEALTH AND
THEY WERE JUST THERE.
CONFIRMING THAT PRIOR THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT
PLEASE AFTERNOON COMMITTEE
MEMBERS THAT YOU HAVE SPENT ON
BEHALF OF THE COUNTY HEALTH
EXECUTIVES ASSOCIATION
REPRESENTING CALIFORNIA'S LOCAL
[inaudible]
PERMITS [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
I'M SORRY THIS CALIFORNIA
PHARMACISTS IN SUPPORT GREAT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION.
YOU KNOW WHEN WE DO HAVE A
MOTION FROM SENATOR DODD.
OF PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HEALTH AYE HILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ALLEN I'VE DONE.
I THOUGHT AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI
AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ
AYE PAN AYE PAN AYE WELL.
LOOK I IS NINE VOTES IT'S OUT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH GRADUALLY
.
WE WILL OPEN THE ROLE ON A FEW
BILLS THAT WE HAD TO ACTUALLY
ACTED MEMBERS WILL START WITH
ITEM NUMBER TWO AB FIVE ZERO
FIVE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
THEY GALGIANI.
I GALGIANI AYE IT'S NINE VOTES
IT IS OUT.
ITEM NUMBER THREE BY AB SEVEN
SIXTY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
QUIRK SILVA PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
[inaudible]
I THERE'S ARE I'VE.
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AYE
AND I WILL.
I WILL GUIDE. NINE ZERO THAT
BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER FIVE AB
FIFTEEN FORTY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER QUIRK SILVA PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE IS NINE VOTES THAT
IS OUT.
AND ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB
TWENTY FOUR SIXTY THREE BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK SILVA
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
GALGIANI [inaudible]
GALGIANI I IN THAT IS OUT AS
WELL.
AND WE HAVE ITEM NUMBER TWENTY
NINE EIGHTEEN THIRTY ONE TEN BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER MULLIN PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS RIGHT
VOTERS [inaudible]
SIX TO HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
THIS IT.
SO SIX TWO AND OF THAT IS OUT
[inaudible]
THAT.
I THINK WE WILL.
GO WHAT WE WILL BE DOING IS --
RECESSING UNTIL AFTER ARE OWN
LEGISLATIVE SESSION THAT BEGINS
AT TWO O'CLOCK [inaudible]
THANK YOU
DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE. FOR TODAY
AND HOPEFULLY WE'LL HAVE SOME
ASSEMBLY AUTHORS SHORTLY
.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK WELCOME TO
OUR COMMITTEE WE WILL.
NOW MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB
[inaudible]
TWENTY TWENTY PLEASE PROCEED.
THANK YOU CHAIR HILL
[inaudible]
SENATORS.
FULLER AND HERNANDEZ.
ARE AB TWENTY TWENTY GRANTS
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS.
THE SORDID APPROVED PERMITS FOR
TEMPORARY CANNABIS RELATED
EVENTS.
IN THEIR OWN JURISDICTION.
UNDER CURRENT LAW TEMPORARY
EVENTS THAT INVOLVE THE SALE.
OR CONSUMPTION OF CAMPUS CAN
ONLY HAPPEN AT THAT COUNTY
FAIRGROUND.
WERE DISTRICT AGRICULTURAL
ASSOCIATION VENUE.
THIS IS LIMITING FOR MANY CITIES
AND LOCAL COMMUNITIES LIKE OUR
SPOTS OF THE CITY OF OAKLAND.
THEN OTHERS LIKE EMERYVILLE IN
SACRAMENTO.
OAKLAND FOR EXAMPLE IS THIRTY
MILES.
FROM THE COUNTY FAIRGROUNDS.
AB TWENTY TWENTY GIVE CITIES
FULL CONTROL OVER THE APPROVAL
OF TEMPORARY EVENT PERMIT.
CITY COUNTY OR STATE REGULATIONS
REGARDING CANNABIS CONCEPTION OR
SECONDHAND SPOTS.
FURTHER MORE RECENT AMENDMENT
STRENGTHENED ENFORCEMENT BY
ENSURING ONLY LICENSED VENDORS.
CAN PARTICIPATE IN THESE EVENTS
AND GIVES A BUREAU OF CANNABIS
[inaudible]
CONTROL AUTHORITY. TO ENFORCE
AGAINST BAD ACTORS AB TWENTY
TWENTY HAS BEEN CRAFTED THROUGH
DIALOGUE WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT.
INDUSTRY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THERE
IS NO OPPOSITION.
WITH ME TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS
NICOLO DELUCA.
REPRESENTING THE CITY OF OAKLAND.
MR RATHKE MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
NICOLE O'DONNELL CAME HERE
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF OAKLAND
AND IN ADDITION THE SPONSOR
ADDITION THE CITY OF AND REBUILD
STRONG SUPPORT.
I WON I THINK ASSEMBLY MEMBER
QUIRK FOR ALL HIS WORK ON THIS
BILL -- THE
CITY VOCALS WON THE FIRST IF NOT
FOR CITIES TO HAVE IT HATE ME
REGULATED WELL FUNCTIONING
CANNABIS PROGRAM --
THEY CANNABIS INDUSTRY AN OPEN
PROVIDES QUALITY JOBS IN A LOT
OF SALES TAX REVENUE --
AS EASILY MEMBERS SAID UNDER
CURRENT LAW KIMBER EVENTS
INVOLVE THE FIELD CAN THAT CAN
ONLY HAPPEN AT A COUNTY FAIR
GROUND OR DISTRICT AG
ASSOCIATION OF WHICH OAKLAND HAS
NEITHER --
THIS BILL IS VERY SIMPLE AS IT
MERELY EXPANDS UPON CURRENT LAW
BY ALLOWING THESE TEMPORARY
VANCE. TO BE HELD IN ANY VENUE
EXPRESSLY APPROVED BY LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS.
THE WAY THE RAGS ARE WRITTEN NOW
IS CITY HAS THE AUTHORITY TO SAY
YES OR NO TO SPECIAL OF THAT.
BUT CITIES ARE SEVERELY LIMITED
AS TO WHERE THE EVENTS CAN TAKE
PLACE WITH THAT HAPPY TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR SERVER GOOD THANK YOU WITH
A LOOK OTHERS IN SUPPORT PLEASE
COME FORWARD [inaudible]
GOOD AFTERNOON.
BOB YEAH BUT WE DROPPED CANNABIS
LOREEN SUPPORT THING TAKE YOU.
MARIN AND WE HAVE THE NET A
CANISTER THIS ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT OF BILL WE THINK MISTER
CRACK FOR KEEPING THE DISPENSARY
AT AS MAKING THAT DANTE MAKING
TO SELL.
I THINK YOU [inaudible]
FOR THANK YOU.
THE ONLY WAY THIS WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS MANY FAR
SHARES IS THE ISSUE.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION S. COME FORWARD.
SEE NO ONE PRINTED BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS.
LEARN PROJECT CLOSE.
THANK YOU SIR.
THANK THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND I
MEAN THIS IS A VERY GOOD BILL
VERY APPROPRIATE AND VERY TIMELY
SIR THANK YOU FOR THAT IS OUR
MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
HERNANDEZ PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
[inaudible]
STEVE POWER SENATE.
MANY HEALTH AYE HILL AYE FULLER
[inaudible]
ALAN [inaudible]
DODD [inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
PAN WELL GOD WILL GUIDE.
WITH THREE VOTE WILL HOLD WILL
OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS THANK
YOU MISTER CORPORATE RECREATED
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
I SEE ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA.
I REMEMBER.
FOR AB [inaudible]
NINE TWENTY FOUR WELCOME BILL.
GOOD AFTERNOON TO FITS AT
TARRANT OF GOOD AFTERNOON
COLLEAGUES AND STAFF.
FIRST OFF THANK YOU FOR YOUR
WORK ON MISTER CHAIR WE'VE BEEN.
I'M COMMUNICATING AND I
APPRECIATE.
ARE YOUR EFFORTS AYE I THINK YOU
ALSO APPRECIATE HOW HOW
DIFFICULT OF A PROBLEM THIS IS
THAT WE'RE FACING.
THERE ARE A NUMBER OF SMALLER
TRIBES THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WHO I DON'T HAVE A
LOT OF ECONOMIC DRIVERS THAT ARE
SEEKING AN OPPORTUNITY TO
PARTICIPATE AND GROWING
REGULATED LEGAL CANNABIS
MARKETPLACE THAT.
ARM MANY OTHER BUSINESSES IN
CALIFORNIA PARTICIPATING IN A
WE'RE TRYING TO BALANCE THE
ISSUES OF TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY
WITH A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD FOR
ALL AND THAT'S JUST NOT EASY WE
STARTED THIS PROCESS.
BOB IN.
TWENTY FIFTEEN AND MULTIPLE
TIMES THROUGHOUT WE WERE.
TOLD THAT.
IT'S NOT READY AND WE NEED TO
WAIT AND WE NEED TO TRY TO GET
IT RIGHT AND WE'VE BEEN
PATIENTLY PLUGGING AWAY.
AND WE HOPE THAT THIS YEAR WITH
YOUR HELP AND I WITH THE INPUT
OF OF YOU AND YOUR TEAM AND
OTHERS WHO I THINK NEED TO BE AT
THE TABLE.
WE CAN GET SOMETHING DONE SO
BOTTOM.
THERE'S MULTIPLE STAKEHOLDERS
WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO KEEP THE
MALL ON ON THE SAME BOAT AND I
WILL BE MY TICKET ONE WAY A
LITTLE BIT TO HELP MOVE ONE
DIRECTION SOME IT CAN FALL OFF.
A BUT AT THAT THE SAME DELICATE
BALANCE THAT WE THAT SOUGHT TO
ACHIEVE THROUGH THEM SIERRA SAY
IN SOME THE OTHER CANNABIS --
BILLS AND LEGISLATION THAT WE
PASSED ANYTHING WE CAN DO IT
HERE SO I KNOW THAT WERE SORT OF
TAKING.
A STEP BACK TOGETHER IN ORDER
[inaudible]
LONGER AND YOU SHOULD THE
AMENDMENTS YOU'RE YOU'RE.
PUTTING FORWARD WE DON'T WANT
THE WORK THE WORK THAT WE'VE
DONE TO GET LOST I THINK THAT
THAT CAN BE.
AWESOME REALLY GOOD INPUT TO
HELP US GET TO A A FINAL LANDING
SPOT TO BUILD CLOSE THE STEEL.
ARM SO WE JUST WE REALLY
APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS AND
THANK YOU FOR THE MEMBERS HAPPY
TO ACCEPT THEM TODAY AND I WILL
BE LOOKING AFTER ALL UP OUR
SLEEVES AND THE IN THE
JOURNALISM A RECESS TO GET IT
DONE A LOT FOR DOING THAT WITH
THE ONLY WILL.
AND I HAVE AYE WITH ME SOME AYE
WITNESSES.
WE HAVE --
CHAIRMAN GEORGE GOAL SHAUN WITH
THE TO BE SHOSHONE TRIBE IN
CHAIRMAN. FOR DEPEND AS WITH A
E. PIE NATION OF SANTA ISABEL
TRIBE.
WE ALSO HAVE FOR TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE IF DEPENDING HOW FAR
WE WANT TO GET INTO THE BILL
TODAY AND I KNOW THERE'S A LOT
MORE TO DO GOING FORWARD.
MARK THAT LIVE EATEN WITH LEGAL
COUNSEL WITH THEM. TO BE
SUFFICIENTLY TRIBE AND RICH
MATCH ATTORNEY IN AUSTIN HAGEL
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. SEVEN MY
NAME'S GEORGE COLSON AND THE
CHAIRMAN FOR THE TIMBER SHOSHONE
TRIBE IN DEATH VALLEY DON'T I
THINK THAT THE CHAIRMAN OF THE
COMMITTEE FOR TAKING THE TIME TO
LISTEN TO US.
I'M FOR US THIS IS THIS IS VERY
DETRIMENTAL AND I'VE HOPE THAT
SINCE I'VE SPENT SOMETIME HERE.
THAT YOU HAVE LEARNED A LITTLE
BIT ABOUT WHERE WE'RE AT AND AND
THE THINGS THAT WE FACE I THINK
THAT WHAT HAPPENS SOMETIMES WHEN
OR WHEN YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT
TRIBES THAT WE GET.
WE GET UP THROWN INTO OF GROUP
INTO A BUNCH AND SOME OF THE
TRIBES ARE WEALTHY AND SOME OF
THEM ARE NOT.
AND I THINK WHAT.
I WOULD LIKE TO CONVEY IS THAT
WE'RE ALL PEOPLE.
AND THEM I'M HERE REPRESENTING
MY PEOPLE.
AND WE HAVE WE HAVE REAL
PROBLEMS THAT --
PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT ON THE
RESERVATION DON'T FACE --
WE ARE NOT EVEN ABLE TO BURY OUR
OUR PEOPLE WHEN THEY DIE WE HAVE
TO GO TO THE BUREAU OF INDIAN
AFFAIRS TO ASK FOR MONEY WHERE
GRANT DRIVEN.
AND E DON'T HAVE ANY ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT SO IT'S IT'S HIGHLY
DISTURBING TO US WHEN WE CAN
EVEN BURY OUR OWN PEOPLE.
WE DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO
EDUCATE OUR PEOPLE.
WE DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO
BUILD HOUSING WE'VE GOT A
SEVERAL THOUSAND ACRES WE CAN
PUT HOUSING ON BECAUSE WE JUST
DON'T HAVE THE MONEY.
AND WE DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES
NO THE GRANTS ARE USUALLY
COMPETITIVE WE WE REALLY HAVE A
GRANT WRITER WE CAN AFFORD A
GRANT WRITER SO SOME OF THE
TRIBES WHO HAVE --
CASINOS THEY CAN AFFORD A TEAM
OF GRANT WRITERS SO WHEN IT
COMES TO BEING COMPETITIVE WE
CAN BE COMPETITIVE.
AND DID THE SAME FOR THE
CANNABIS MARKET WEAK WE DON'T
HAVE THE ABILITY TO REALLY BE
COMPETITIVE.
SO THIS IS A GREAT ECONOMIC
DRIVER FOR US AND COULD BE A
PARADIGM SHIFT ON HOW WE
FUNCTION GOING INTO THE FUTURE
WE WANT TO HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE
WELL EDUCATED.
AND PEOPLE WHO WILL BE ABLE TO
COME BACK TO THE RESERVATION
BECAUSE WE HAVE INDUSTRY THAT
WILL SUPPORT THEIR DEGREE.
IF THEY GO AND GET A DEGREE IN
SOMETHING IS AS SIMPLE AS
ENGLISH OR ENGLISH LIT OR
SOMETHING THEY CAN'T COME BACK
TO THE RESERVATION BECAUSE
THERE'S NO PLACE TO USE THAT.
WE DON'T HAVE ANY PLACE FOR
THOSE THINGS WE DON'T HAVE
EDUCATION WE DON'T EVEN HAVE
BROADBAND WE LIVE IN THE HOTTEST
PART OF THE COUNTRY OR THE WORLD
FOR THAT MATTER.
AND WE DON'T HAVE BROADBAND SO
WE DON'T HAVE A LOT OF SERVICES
THAT OTHER PEOPLE HAVE AND TAKE
FOR GRANTED.
SO THIS IS THIS IS VERY VERY
IMPORTANT. TO OUR TRIBE AND I
KNOW THERE ARE A LOT OF OTHER
TRIBES.
THAT ARE IN THE SAME SITUATION.
IT WOULD BE BE.
VERY HELPFUL TO GET YOUR SUPPORT
AND HELPING US GET THIS THROUGH
SO WE CAN.
I TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY.
WE'RE GOOD THANK YOU.
OF OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS.
MY NAME IS FERTILE PEREZ ON THE
TRAVEL CHAIRMAN FOR THE PAIN
ASIAN INCENTIVES ABOUT.
AND MUCH LIKE WITH HIM SHOSHONI.
WE ARE AT A REMOTE LOCATION.
SO.
YOU KNOW GAMING DOES NOT WORK
FOR US PRETTY FAR AWAY
[inaudible]
UP THE CANNABIS MARKET WOULD BE
IDEAL FOR US TO GET INTO BECAUSE
ONCE AGAIN A RURAL LOCATION
WOULD ACTUALLY BE AN ASSET WE
WOULDN'T BE.
ARE THERE WOULD BE NO ISSUES
WITH US GROWING IN SOMEBODY'S
BACKYARD ROUND THE MIDDLE OF
NOWHERE.
SO I SEE THIS AS A GOOD.
OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR TRIBE TO
ENTER INTO THIS MARKET.
I AB -- NINE
TWENTY FOUR YOU KNOW WILL
HOPEFULLY RIGHT THE WRONG.
WHICH TRIBES WERE EXCLUDED OUT
OF THIS.
ADDED THE A LOS WE CAN'T
PARTICIPATE IN CALIFORNIA'S
MARKET.
SO WE HAVE TRAVEL AYE SINCE IS
THAT ARE RECOGNIZED [inaudible]
THE EXCLUSION.
COULD BE FIXED WITH AB NINETEEN
AND TWENTY FOUR AND YOU KNOW ONE
OF THE THINGS THAT WE LIKE TO
SEE IF WE WE WANT FAIRNESS.
WE'RE NOT LOOKING FOR A SPECIAL
CARBON I THINK THAT'S WHERE YOU
KNOW A LOT OF THE OPPOSITION
COMES FROM.
TRIED TO HAVE IT ALL.
VERY FEW TRIBES.
THAT HAVE GAMING.
MOST OF US TRIBES LIVE AT THE
POVERTY LEVEL OR BELOW.
IF WE HAD THIS ECONOMIC
GENERATOR ARMY WOULD DEFINITELY
ASSIST IN EDUCATION.
IT WOULD DEFINITELY ASSIST IN
OUR INFRASTRUCTURE IF YOU WERE
TO TAKE UP A VISIT TO OUR TRIBAL
LANDS.
YOU WOULD SEE WERE IN NEED OF
THAT WE JUST DON'T HAVE THE
ECONOMIC GENERATOR.
SO ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE DO
RIGHT NOW AND WE'VE WE'VE
CONSTANTLY DONE IS WE PROVIDE
POLICE AND FIRE PROTECTION.
OUR THROUGH OTHER REVENUES AYE
THAT WE'VE THAT WE PRODUCED OVER
THE YEARS.
WHEN WE OFFER THAT FIRE
PROTECTION WE ALREADY ASSIST?
WITH A COUNTY AGREEMENT. TWO
THOSE COMMUNITY MEMBERS OFF
RESERVATION THAT OUR TRIBAL
MEMBERS SO WE ALREADY WERE
CONTRIBUTOR AND I THINK A LOT OF
PEOPLE LOOK AT AS AS YOU KNOW
WE'RE GONNA KEEP TAKING TAKING
TAKING AND ALL WE WANT TO DO IS
BE ABLE. TO TO LIVE A BETTER
LIFE.
THIS IS BY NO MEANS GOING TO
MAKE IS RICH THIS IS JUST A
MEANS FOR US THE PAY FOR
INFRASTRUCTURE.
WERE NOT A CALIFORNIA CITY THAT
RELIES ON TAXES TO BE ABLE.
TO PUTTING NEW ATTRACTION NEW
ROADS.
PAY FOR THE FIRE POLICE.
WE HAVE TO PRODUCE ALL OF THOSE
THINGS OURSELVES SO THIS WOULD
BE A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR US.
AND HOPEFULLY ALL OF YOU WILL
BUILD A SPORT THAT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
WHICH COME FORWARD.
GOOD AFTERNOON AMY JENKINS ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CANNOT
CANNABIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL --
WE WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR AND
THE SPONSORS THEY WERE VERY
COLLABORATIVE WITH US IN
ADDRESSING A LOT OF OUR CONCERNS --
SO WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE
TO ENGAGE IN THE CONVERSATIONS
GOING FORWARD THANK YOU THANK
YOU.
ONLY CUEVAS ON BEHALF OF REMOTE
NOW WE ARE ACTUALLY THE FIRST
TRIED TO INTRODUCE THE CONCEPT
OF TRIBAL CANNABIS.
VIA LEGISLATION A TWENTY SIXTEEN
AB TWENTY FIVE FORTY FIVE WITH
THE SAME AUTHOR.
WE ARE SUPPORTIVE OF THE CHAIRS
AND STAKEHOLDER CONCEPT ON THE
CONTINGENCY THAT WE ARE ONE OF
THE STAKEHOLDERS.
WE DON'T FEEL IT'S APPROPRIATE
FOR ONE ASSOCIATION TO BE MAKING
UNILATERAL DECISIONS ON BEHALF
OF ALL INDIAN COUNTRY.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CURATION.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS MAP BROUGHT
ON BEHALF THE TEAMSTERS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MISTER CHAIR JASON BRAM HAVE A
CALIFORNIA GROWERS ASSOCIATION
WE ARE IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
RETURN MEMBERS CHRIS GUY OUR
LITTLEST COYOTES BAND THE QUEEN
COOPER UNION'S THANK YOU VERY
MUCH [inaudible]
GOOD AFTERNOON.
MISTER TIPTON.
ALEXANDER SHELTER THE SECRETARY
FOR THE SENATE AS A BAND COOLEY
INDIAN [inaudible]
AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANYONE
ELSE IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION.
OKAY.
BEFORE MISTER JUNE SECOND MISTER
CHAIRMAN CENTERS APPROACH RICK
APPEARING ON BEHALF OF THE
UNITED FOOD AND COMMERCIAL
WORKERS WESTERN STATES COUNCIL.
WE DID SIMILAR OPPOSITION LATE
LAST WEEK HOWEVER WERE
SUPPORTIVE OF THIS A CONCEPT
WRITTEN ANALYSIS IN WHICH MR
BONTA.
AGREED TO ACCEPT HIS AUTHORS
AMENDMENTS TO THE FOURTY
DISCUSSION TODAY COMMITTED TO
RICO OTHERS IN OPPOSITION.
YOU KNOW ONE BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE I AM I JUST WANTED
TO SAY HOW MUCH I ENJOYED THE
OPPORTUNITY TO MEET WITH THE
TRIBAL LEADERS AND AND REALLY
UNDERSTAND BETTER THE THE
CHALLENGES THAT YOU'RE FACED
WITH IN YOUR TRIBES IN THAT THAT
THE NEED.
AND RECOGNITION I THINK ALL OF
US FOR SOME ECONOMIC GROWTH AND
DEVELOPMENT A IN THAT I THINK IS
PARAMOUNT AND THE OTHER.
ISSUE THAT --
AND ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA I'VE
GOING TO THANK HIM FOR HIS
LEADERSHIP NOT JUST IN THIS
ISSUE BUT WELL IN THIS BILL BUT
IN THE ENTIRE ISSUE.
OF CANNABIS AND THIS FRANK THAT
HE BROUGHT TO THAT HAS BEEN VERY
HELPFUL THAT THE CHALLENGE THAT
WE WERE FACED WITH AND AND JURY
OF GOING THROUGH THE FIRST HOUSE
AND COMING TO US WITH SOME WORK.
IN SOME.
KENNETH DIGESTING AND CHANGING
AND AND AMENDING AND AND KIND OF
WORKING IT AND WE HAD A SHORT
PERIOD OF TIME. TO REALLY DO
THAT AND OF ONE WE FOUND THAT --
AS WE WERE TALKING AND IF THE
TIME WAS GETTING VERY SHORT AND
I JUST THOUGHT THAT THERE WOULD
BE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO COME
TOGETHER.
WITH STAKEHOLDERS CERTAINLY WITH
YOU IN IN HERE RECOGNIZING THE
TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY.
THAT I THINK IS THE PARAMOUNT
ISSUE WE HAVE TO RECOGNIZE AND
WANT TO CONTINUE TO RECOGNIZE
BUT WITHIN THAT.
THE FRAMEWORK OF THAT TO SEE HOW
WE CAN WORK TO PREPARE CERTAINLY.
TO TO PROTECT IN THE INTEREST OF
CALIFORNIA AS WELL SO I THINK WE
CAN DO THAT AND I THINK THIS THE
THROUGH THE THE MONTH OF JULY
WILL BE ABLE. TO TO CRAFT
SOMETHING WE ARE YOU I'M
CERTAINLY COMMITTED I KNOW THE
AUTHORS COMMITTED AND THE STAFF
OF THIS COMMITTEE IT IS
DEFINITELY COMMITTED TO TO
COMING TO THAT AGREEMENT AND AND
THAT THING THAT WILL WORK. TO TO
CREATE THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE
TRIBES THAT REALLY NEED IT SO
ONE OF THANK YOU FOR OF THE
CONVERSATION AND THE
CONTINUATION OF THOSE
CONVERSATIONS IN THE FUTURE SO
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
YES.
SENATOR GALGIANI AND I WANT TO
THANK THE AUTHOR AND THE CHAIR
AND ACTUALLY --
THE STAKEHOLDERS ON ALL SIDES
FOR THE WORKING TOGETHER ON THIS
I KNOW --
LAST YEAR YEAR BEFORE THEY'RE
BEEN NEGOTIATIONS AND JUST IN
GENERAL ON THE ORIGINAL BALLOT
MEASURE AND WE HAVEN'T
NECESSARILY BEEN PRIVY TO ALL OF
THAT.
BUT THOSE NEGOTIATIONS HAPPEN
AND WE HAD --
BOTH THE TEAMSTERS AND UFCW HAD
AGREED TO THOSE THINGS AND WHEN
THIS CAME UP I WANTED TO SEE IT
MOVE FORWARD BUT I KNEW ALSO
THAT.
I'M WITH MORE DISCUSSION AND
EVERYBODY LOOKING AT WHAT HAD
BEEN AGREED TO PREVIOUSLY ON
THAT I BELIEVE THAT WE COULD ALL
GET THERE TO SOMETHING THAT WAS
SOMEWHERE THAT THAT EVERYBODY
COULD.
AND GET BEHIND AND SUPPORT SELF
THANK YOU FOR THE CHAIRS AND PUT
ON THE CITY STAFF'S WORK ON THIS
AND I LOOK FORWARD.
TO BY WORKING WITH YOU AND I AM
WILLING TO MOVE THE BILL BURGER
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SENATOR GOT
REALLY WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA.
JUST LOOKING FOR THE WORK AHEAD
AND ASK THEM TO GET THEM
TOGETHER WILL DO IT I I AM CAN
YOU CHECKCOMMITTED TO THIS I I
WANT TO SEE IT WORK AND AND I
THINK WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING IN.
I'M NOT ONE TO TO LET IT --
LET IT GO IT'S ESPECIALLY IT'S
BEEN GOING ON TOO LONG WILL IT
WILL MAKE IT HAPPEN BUT WE ASK
YOU AYE VOCAL YOU THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SO.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
GALGIANI PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
QUESTION AS SHE PASSED THE
SENATE GOVERNANCE AND COMMITTEE
KILL AYE.
HILL AYE FULLER [inaudible]
ALAN [inaudible]
DODD.
GALGIANI AYE GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
PAN WILK AYE WILK AYE.
BEFORE VOTE TO UPHOLD THE RULE
OPEN FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS AND
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. FOR BEING
HERE.
GOING TO PRESENT A BILL
[inaudible]
ARE.
CLUSTER BUT WHAT ABOUT WANTS HIM
SHE WANTED IT HAS ANOTHER BILL.
BUT TWENTY AB.
TWENTY THIRTY SEVEN ITEM NUMBER.
EIGHT THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
COLLEAGUES.
AB TWENTY THIRTY SEVEN AUTHORIZE
A PHARMACY TO PROVIDE SERVICES
TO PATIENTS OF SAFETY NET
CLINICS.
THROUGH THE USE OF AN AUTOMATED
DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM VERY FEW
SAFETY NET CLINICS INCLUDING
NONPROFIT.
COMMUNITY CLINICS FREE CLINICS
AND OTHER FQHCS UTILIZE AN
AUTOMATED DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM
BECAUSE THEY DO NOT HAVE
SUFFICIENT.
RESOURCES THE BEAR
RESPONSIBILITY FOR AND INTO
STAFF THE AUTOMATED DRUG
DELIVERY SYSTEM AB TWENTY THIRTY
SEVEN WILL ALLOW CALIFORNIA
LICENSE PHARMACIES TO BEAR THAT
RESPONSIBILITY OF MAINTAINING
AND OPERATING.
AND AUTOMATED DRUG DELIVERY
SYSTEM IN SAFETY NET CLINICS IN
NEARLY IDENTICAL BILL.
PASSED THIS COMMITTEE LAST YEAR
WITH BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AS THIS
BILL MOVES FORWARD I PLAN TO
ENSURE THAT THERE ARE PROPER
CLARIFYING AND CHATTERING
AMENDMENTS WITH DOCTOR HERNANDEZ
IS THE SENATE BILL.
FOURTEEN FORTY SEVEN
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
PRESENT.
AND I HAVE WITH ME HERE TODAY
KEVIN RULE AND TERRY MCCALEB
REPRESENTING I MG ARE ACTS
SPONSORED RATE OF THE BILL AND
WE I DO HAVE A SUGGESTED SUPPORT
SUPPORT ON THIS ITEM.
SO WE'RE STILL GOING THROUGH THE
PROCESS BUT OF WITH THAT MIND WE
ARE GOING TO HAVE A TWO MINUTE
LIMIT.
AND WE'LL BEGIN WITH THOSE IN
FAVOR THE BILL MADAM CHAIR TERRY
MIKHAIL THEIR READING ASSOCIATES
ABLE TO READ THE TEA LEAVES WILL
KEEP THIS TO FIFTEEN SECONDS
SENATOR HERNANDEZ DOES HAVE A
BILL WE ARE WORKING CLOSELY WITH
HIS OFFICE.
AND WITH THE STAFF TO MAKE SURE
THAT A CONSOLIDATION IS
NECESSARY WILL TAKE PLACE THANK
YOU.
SENATORS THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AND FOR
YOUR CONSIDERATION I'M KEVIN
ROOF FROM I AM GRX THE CEO.
AND YOU.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU.
AND OTHERS A AND SUPPORT.
AND ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
INNOCENT HERNANDEZ INNOCENT
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS --
LAND THINK US AND I MEAN
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA OF COURSE
THE SENATE STAFF --
THEY'RE GONNA BE WORKING HAND IN
HAND WITH MY COMPANION BILL BIG
DIFFERENCES THIS ONE DEALS WITH
A THREE FORTY B. DRUG PRICING
AND WITH THAT I'M WILLING TO GO
THE BILL.
SO SLINGERLAND DISMISS THE BILL
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
BUT FASTER AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
QUESTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HEALTH.
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLAN
DODDS GALGIANI.
LASER HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ
AYE HAN WELL [inaudible]
WILK AYE [inaudible] THREE THAT
VOTE HAS THREE WILL HOLD THE
ROLE OPEN UNTIL THE OTHERS
COMMAND THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES THANK YOU
STAFF.
OF I SEE ASTHMA MEMBER CHAU IN
THE BACK I THINK AND SO WILL
RETURN TO ITEM ONE A. B..
THREE FORTY SEVEN THESE TO GET
PAID VERY MUCH ON MADAM CHAIR --
AB THREE FORTY SEVEN EXTEND THE
SUNSET DATA FOR THE COMMERCIAL
WEIGHING AND MEASURING DEVICE
REGISTRATION PROGRAM.
WHICH ALLOWS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
TO IMPOSE REGISTRATIONFEES ON
WEIGHTS AND MEASURES DEVICES. TO
OFFSET THE COST OF INSPECTION
AND TESTING.
A MIX OF THE CHANGES TO PROGRAM
AS WELL.
COUNT COUNTY SEALERS OF WEIGHTS
AND MEASURES AWE INSPECTING
TESTS ALL COMMERCIAL SCALING AND
ALL NATURAL MEASURING DEVICES TO
ENSURE.
THEY ARE ACCURATE --
TO THAT THEIR CUSTOMERS. FOR A
PURCHASE PRODUCT THAT THIS ALSO
KEEPS A LEVEL.
PLAYING FIELD BETWEEN RETAILERS
THE PROGRAM APPLIES TO VIRTUALLY
ALL DEVICES COMMERCIALLY.
AND DAHLE HOWEVER THE AUTHORITY
TO COLLECT FEES ON THAT PROGRAM
WAS SUNSET THERE ON JANUARY
FIRST.
TWENTY NINETEEN AB THREE FOUR
SEVEN WILL CONTINUE TO PROGRAM
THROUGH JANUARY FIRST.
TWENTY TWENTY TWO THE BILL ALSO
APPLIES LE THE DEVICE FEE
LIMITATIONS FOR LIQUEFY
PETROLEUM GAS METERS TWO
LIQUEFIED.
GAS AND COMPRESSED NATURAL GAS
DISPENSERS DUE TO THERE ARE
COMPARABLE TESTING REQUIREMENTS
AND CLARIFIES THAT THE DEVICE
FEE LIMITATION. FOR JURY AND
PRESCRIPTION SKILLS ALSO APPLIES
TO CLASS TWO SCALES AND
VIOLATING INCREASES THE DEVICE
REGISTRATION FEE LIMITATIONS.
FOR COMPUTING SCALES FROM TWENTY
DOLLARS TO TWENTY THREE DOLLARS
A O OFFSET INCREASED TESTING
COSTA WITHOUT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
EUROPE IDLE AND THEN TURNED OVER
TO MY WITNESS.
WHEN THIS IS IN SUPPORT?
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS MATTHEW SO I
REALLY HAVE THE CALIFORNIA
AGRICULTURAL COMMISSIONERS AND
SEALERS ASSOCIATION.
OF AS THE MEMBER SAID AND I GOT
ABOUT A LONG DAY EVERY THREE TO
FIVE YEARS WE BRING THIS MEASURE
BACK. TO INCREASE THE SUNSET TO
OUR TO RESET THE SUNSET OF BRING
MEMBERS THE TABLE TO TALK ABOUT
THE FEW CATS WE HAVE IN PLACE
FOR THE VARIOUS COMMERCIAL
WEIGHING MEASURING DEVICES THEY
USE.
AND THAT'S WHAT WE'VE DONE THIS
TIME WHILE WE ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU.
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE ANY
COMMENTS WITH THE BILL.
WE HAVE AM A MOVEMENT FOR THE
BILL AND WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
I RESPECTFULLY ASK HER I DON'T
THINK VERY MUCH PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
MISSION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATE COMMITTEE HELL.
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN DIED
GALGIANI GLAZER HERNANDEZ AYE
NANA'S AYE PAN WILK.
LOOK I THANK YOU THEN WILL BE
HOLDING IT OPEN FOR THE OTHERS
TO VOTE THANK YOU.
ITEM NUMBER TEN KALRA.
THANK YOU BUT I'M SURE SENATORS.
I PROJECT OPPORTUNITY PRESENT AB.
TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN TODAY
VETERINARIANS IN CALIFORNIA
ALIKE POSITIONS HAD ABSOLUTELY
NO PROTECTION FROM BEING SUBJECT
DISPLAYING ACTION DISCIPLINARY
ACTION. FOR HAVING A SIMPLE
DISCUSSION WITH.
THEIR OF CLIENTS ABOUT CANNABIS.
AB TWENTY TO FIFTEEN WOULD ALLOW
VETERINARIANS DISCUSSED THE USE
OF CANNABIS WITHOUT FEAR OF
LOSING THEIR STATE LICENSE.
AND ENABLES CANNABIS FOR
MEDICINAL ANIMAL USE BE
ACCEPTABLE TO CONSUMERS IN
REGULATED DISPENSARIES.
ADDITIONALLY CALIFORNIANS HAVE
GREATER ACCESS TO CANNABIS EVER
BEFORE AND MANY PET OWNERS ARE
ALREADY LOOKING AT CANNABIS
PROVIDE THERAPEUTIC AND MEDICAL
RELIEF. TO ENSURE CANNABIS
PRODUCTS FOR MEDICINAL USE ON
ANIMALS CAN BE AVAILABLE TO
CONSUMERS IN A REGULATED MARKET.
AB TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN AS THESE
PRODUCTS THE DEFINITION UNDER
THE MEDICINAL AN ADULT USE
CANNABIS REGULATIONS SAFETY ACT.
THIS WILL ENABLE CANNABIS
PRODUCTS TO COME TO MARKET THAT
ARE SAFE FOR ANIMAL USE RATHER
THAN PET OWNERS USING CANNABIS
PRODUCTS DESIGNED FOR HUMAN USE
ON THEIR PETS.
OR REVERTING TO AN UNDERGROUND
MARKET.
AB TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN A
SUPPORTED BY THE CALIFORNIA
VETERINARY MEDICAL BOARD AND THE
CALIFORNIA VETERINARY MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION.
AS WELL AS BUSINESS GROUPS A
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION AND SOCIAL
COMPASSION IN LEGISLATION OF THE
STATE'S LEADING ANIMAL WELFARE
ADVOCACY GROUPS.
I WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR THEIR GUIDANCE AND I'M
COMMITTED TO CONTINUING TO WORK
WITH THEM ON ADDRESS ISSUES.
SURROUNDING UNREGULATED HAVE
PRODUCTS.
I HAVE WITH ME TODAY I DR CHERYL
WATER HOUSE PRESIDENT OF THE
VETERINARY MEDICAL BOARD AS WELL
AS MIKE DILLON ON BEHALF TO
CALIFORNIA.
VETERINARY MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
FOR BRIEF COMMENTS.
A GOOD AFTERNOON --
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS I AM
DOCTOR CHAU WATERHOUSE PRESIDENT
OF UNDER A MEDICAL BOARD AND I'D
LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLYMAN KALRA
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD.
OF THIS ISSUE HAS BEEN DEBATED
BY SOMETIME IN THIS BILL WHILE
NOT PERFECT DOES STRIKE THE
APPROPRIATE BALANCE.
OF THE BOARD BELIEVES IT IS
REASONABLE FOR VETERANS TO
DISCUSS CANNABIS.
OF THE BEDROOM MEDICAL BOARD
WILL DEVELOP GUIDELINES AS THE
BILL REQUIRES WHICH WILL GIVE AN
AREA STRUCTURE. FOR HAVING THESE
IMPORTANT CONVERSATIONS WITH
THEIR CLIENTS.
WE HAVE ASKED FOR AN EXTENSION
OF THE GUIDELINE IMPLEMENTATION
WHICH THE AUTHOR HAS GRACIOUSLY
AGREED TO WE THANK HIM BECAUSE
OR BOARD ONLY MEANS FOUR TIMES A
YEAR -- AND
FIRST THIS --
ISSUE IS GOING TO NEED TO GO TO
OUR MULTI DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE
FOR DISCUSSION.
SO I'M ALSO HERE TO ANSWER ANY
TECHNO PUSH AND YOU MAY HAVE
BOTH AS PRESIDENT OF ANY MEDICAL
BOARD AND AS A VETERINARIAN IN
PRIVATE PRACTICE [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
BUT MEDICARE MEMBERS OF VERY
BRIEFLY MIKE DILLON REPRESENT
THE VETERINARY MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION --
VETERINARIANS HAVE TOLD US FOR A
SOMETIME THAT THEY MAY SEE A
COUPLE CASES A WEEK WERE A PAID
A A AND MONNING --
BY AND BRINGS IN A DOG SUFFERING
FROM EATING A BROWNIE OR
SOMETHING LIKE THAT THE MORE
RECENTLY THE ANIMAL OWNING
CLIENTS ARE COMING WITH
QUESTIONS LIKE.
MY NEIGHBOR HUSING CBD OIL ON AN
OLDER DOG HIP AND SEEMS. TO TO
MAKE A DIFFERENCE OF OR I GOT
THIS BROCHURE FROM A PET STORE
IN AT LEAST A LOT OF OF THINGS
IN HERE AND TERMS OF THE
BENEFITS OF CBT WHICH SOME OF
WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT BE TRUE --
AND THEN BECAUSE THE VETERINARY
MEDICAL BOARD LEGAL COUNSEL IS A
PINE THIS JUST BEEN MENTIONED
THAT VETERINARIANS CANNOT EVEN
DISCUSS IT.
OF THE VETERINARIAN IS LEFT WITH
THE PROBLEM OF CLIENT COMES IN
AND SAYS WHAT DO YOU THINK
DOCTOR AND THEY REALLY CAN'T
DISCUSS WITHOUT POSSIBLE FEAR OF
OF DISCIPLINARY ACTION BY THE
WAR BOARD SO WE ALSO WOULD THINK
MISTER KALRA. FOR HIS LEADERSHIP
ON THIS VERY VERY IMPORTANT
ISSUE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
ON BEHALF OF SOCIAL
COMPASSIONATE LEGISLATION AS
WELL AS THE ONE BEACH COLLECTORS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THINKING
THANK YOU.
AMY JENKINS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT AND ON
BEHALF OF MY COLLEAGUES MAX
MICHAEL AND AS HIS CLIENT THAT
CBD AND SUPPORT.
THANK YOU.
MARIN PANETTA WE HAVE THE
MEDICAID AS BUSINESS ALLIANCE WE
HAVE OVER A HUNDRED DISPENSARIES
SOUGHT THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA.
AND THOSE PRODUCTS ARE ON
OURSELVES SO WE DO NEED THE
GUIDANCE I THINK YOU FOR YOUR
SUPPORT [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
BRINGING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE [inaudible]
WHO DEVELOPED?
WE HAVE MOTION.
A WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
OF FIRST I DO NEED THANK YOU I
DO NEED TO ASK BUT THE
AMENDMENTS YES AND AND I DO A
EXCEPT THAT THE COULD IMMINENCE
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
I THINK YEAH MOVING THE BILL
WHICH CLOSE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE WITH THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
SUB WE ASK FROM.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
S. AS AMENDED [inaudible]
HILL.
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN DODD
GALGIANI LASER HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE.
AND WILK WILL GUIDE.
WE HAVE THREE VOTES AND WILL
HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR OTHERS TO
VOTE AS THEY CAN THANK YOU
[inaudible]
AND IS ASSEMBLY MEMBER BLOOM.
I BELIEVE NUMBER --
ITEM.
ELEVEN I A. B. --
TWENTY TWO TWENTY ONE A REVEALS
FIRST [inaudible]
RUBIO WAS [inaudible]
REALLY.
WE HAVE VOTED ON THIS AND
CONSENT TO THOSE I HAVE TWO
BILLS.
ONES ON CONSENT --
HIS WE'RE GONNA GO TWENTY FOUR
THEN [inaudible]
THAT [inaudible]
I'M SORRY --
ITEM.
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY EIGHT NINETY
NINE THANK YOU GIFT AFTER AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS I'D LIKE TO
THINK MY COLLEAGUES FROM OUTGROW
FOR BEING A JOINT AUTHORED ON
THIS BILL.
AS YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA STARTED
AUDITIONING FEET CANNABIS
LICENSES AT THE BEGINNING OF
THIS YEAR THERE IS A MINOR YOU
CALLING CURRENT LAW THAT DOES
NOT CLARIFIED THAT SUSPENDED
LICENSES ARE UNABLE. TO ENGAGE
IN MARKETING OR ADVERTISING
ACTIVITIES WHILE SUSPENDED AB
TWENTY NINETY NINE WILL HELP
ADDRESS THIS ISSUE BY
PROHIBITING A LICENSEE FROM
PUBLISHING ARTISTS LE
DISSEMINATING ADVERTISING OR
MAKE MARKETING.
WHILE THE LICENSEES LICENSE IS
SUSPENDED THIS LEGISLATION IS A
SMALL STEP FORWARD THAT WILL
HELP PROPERLY REGULATE LICENSEES.
AND THEIR BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
HERE WITH ME TODAY HAVE TECH
TONY DO WE ARE REPRESENTING
CANNABIS THIS OF RIVER CANNABIS
DISTURBED THAT THIS READING
COMPANY WHO IS IN SUPPORT OF OUR
BELL AND ALSO MARVIN PINATA
REPRESENTING ELITE DISPENSARIES.
MARGARET AND I WEREOUT WITH THE
MEDICAID AS IN THIS ALLIANCE MC
CHEN EVER SAT.
THANK YOU FOR HE AND HIS BILL.
AND LOS ANGELES WHERE KILEY --
COMPETING WITH HUNDREDS OF A LOT
OF THEM ARE UNDER THE MANTLE OF
COLLECTING AS A GREEN HAS A
COLLECTIVE COLLECTIVE RIGHT NOW.
SO THERE'S NO ENFORCEMENT EYES
IS THE STATE THAT ARE A STEP IN
THE RIGHT DIRECTION.
AS WE NEED TO COMPETE LEE IN THE
FUTURE SHUT DOWN ALL HE LEGAL
ADVERTISEMENTS AYE WE DO WE
THINK YOU AND WE ASK FOR ENABLE
[inaudible]
BUT TWENTY BOY WITH RIVER
DISTRIBUTING OF RIVERS RIBBONS
ON THE LARGEST AND MOST ABBAS
LICENSE COMES TO BRING
CALIFORNIA WE FACILITATE OVER A
HUNDRED STATES OF I TESTED ON
CAMPUS PARTS INSTEAD OF THIS
YEAR.
WE'VE I'VE BEEN ALWAYS COMMITTED
TO SUPPORTING LEGAL RETAILERS
AND SUPPLIERS IN THE CAMPUS
MARKET WE FEEL THIS BILL WILL
HELP.
THAT A BELIEVER AB DOESN'T STOP
TO ENSURE THAT LEGAL AND PLANT
OPERATORS WHO BEAR THE FINANCIAL
RESPONSIBILITY OF BEING A PLAN
ARE NOT PUT AT A COMPETITIVE
DISADVANTAGE IN THE MARKET.
ADDITIONALLY THIS BILL WILL
PREVENT CONSUMERS FROM
PURCHASING UNTESTED.
PRODUCTS IN THE BLACK MARKET AND
WILL HELP INCREASED TAX REVENUE
FOR THE STATE CALIFORNIA.
NOW WE ASK YOU AYE VOTE ON THIS
BILL AND THINGS RUBIO AND COOPER
ON ON THIS BILL THANK YOU VERY%
MUCH FOR THE YEAR FOR THIS
SUPPORT.
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
HIGHER NO IT ON BEHALF OF THE
CANDIDATES SITUATION ASSOCIATION
THE SITE OF THE COMMON.
THANK ANY FUN BEHALF OF THE LONG
BEACH COLLECTORS ASSOCIATION AND
SPRING BREAK YOUR IN THE JENKINS
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
CANNABIS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
SUPPORT PRETTY GOOD THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
GOOD AFTERNOON TRACY STEVENS ON
BEHALF OF THE SOLUTIONS AND
SUPPORT MAKE YOU VERY MUCH.
DAVID JONES ABOUT THE CITY
SACRAMENTO IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
MATT BROWN BE AFTER THE
TEAMSTERS IN SUPPORT OF YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH BROAD OTHERS
IN SUPPORT IS THERE ANYONE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
SHE KNOWN GREAT IDEA GREAT BILL
A ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM.
COMMITTEES REMOVE THE BILL THAT
PROTECTING CLOSE THANK YOU I
JUST RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
IBOOK VERY GOOD WE DO HAVE A
MOTION FROM SENATOR WILL PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
PRECIOUS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HEALTH
AYE HILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN GUT GALGIANI
LASER HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ
AYE PAN WELL I'M A GUY.
BEFORE VOTE WILL THE ROLLOVER
TRIP TO MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ASSEMBLY OF RUBIO.
AS THE SAID ASSEMBLYMEMBER BLOOM
WELCOME [inaudible]
GOOD AFTERNOON.
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN AB.
TWENTY TWO TWENTY ONE START WITH
WAS STARTING.
WE'VE WITNESS WHO HAS A DAMN
GOOD FUMBLED WILL GO TO AB
TWENTY NINE NINETY EIGHT ITEM.
TWENTY SEVEN PLEASE PROCEED.
WHEN CUMPLIR COMFORTABLE THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS AB
TWENTY NINE NINETY EIGHT WILL
PROTECT CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS
FIVE PROHIBITING THE SALE OF
JUVENILE PRODUCTS MATTRESSES?
AND UPHOLSTERED FOR RE
UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE THAT
CONTAINED FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS THIS IS IN ACCORDANCE
WITH CALIFORNIA'S UPDATED
FLAMMABILITY STANDARDS THEY WERE
UPDATED IN THE TWENTY THIRTEEN
EVERYDAY CALIFORNIANS ARE
EXPOSED TO THESE CHEMICALS OVER
TIME.
BIG HUMILIATE OUR BODIES AND IN
THE ENVIRONMENT CAUSING A
VARIETY OF ADVERSE HEALTH
EFFECTS INCLUDING AND TREND.
AND FIERY DESTRUCTION CANCER AND
HARMFUL NEUROLOGICAL IMPACTS.
ALTHOUGH FLAME RETARDANTS ARE
DANGEROUS TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC
THAT BECAUSE A PARTICULARLY HIGH
THREAT TO SPECIFIC POPULATIONS.
INCLUDING CHILDREN AND
FIREFIGHTERS WHO ARE EXPOSED TO
THESE CHEMICALS AND THEIR
DERIVATIVES AT EVEN HIGHER RATES
THAN THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
INFANTS ARE OFTEN EXPOSE STEP
THROUGH CONTAMINATED DUST AND
BREASTMILK AND EVAN FOUND IT'S
BEEN FOUND THAT THESE CHEMICALS
ARE IN THEIR BODIES AT LEVELS
THREE TO FIVE TIMES.
THE LEVELS IN THEIR MOTHERS.
FIREFIGHTERS ARE ALSO EXPOSED TO
THESE CHEMICALS AT ALARMINGLY
HIGH --
AMOUNTS WHEN FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS BURNED THEY RELEASE
CARCINOGENIC SUBSTANCES AND
KNOWN AS DIOXINS AND FURANS.
AND THESE CHEMICALS ARE INHALED
BY FIREFIGHTERS AND EVEN LINGER
ON PROTECTIVE CLOTHING LONG
AFTER THE FIREFIGHTER LEAVES THE
SITE OF THE FIRE.
AS A RESULT WHICH SADLY WHERE
SEEING HIGHER CANCER RATES AMONG
THE FIREFIGHTERS THAN EVER
BEFORE.
IN ADDITION TO BEING TOXIC THAT
THESE CHEMICALS ARE ALSO ON
NECESSARY TO MEET OUR CURRENT
FLAMMABILITY STANDARDS.
IN TWENTY THIRTEEN CALIFORNIA
UPDATED ITS FLAMMABILITY
STANDARD AND THE PRODUCTS
AFFECTED BY THIS BILL DO NOT
NEED FLAME RETARDANTS IN ORDER
TO MEET THE STANDARD.
AND THAT'S WHY MANY FIFTH
MANUFACTURERS THROUGHOUT THE
STATE HAVE ALREADY VOLUNTARILY
PHASE THEM OUT.
HOWEVER STRAGGLERS CONTINUE TO
REMAIN AND WE CANNOT AND WILL
NOT BE ABLE TO PROTECT THE
PUBLIC WITHOUT A RESTRICTION.
ON THE SALE OF SPECIFIC PRODUCTS
CONTAINING THESE CHEMICALS.
HENCE THIS BILL AB TWENTY NINE
NINETY EIGHT WHICH PRIORITIZES
THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF ALL
CALIFORNIANS BY PHASING THE
CHEMICALS OUT FOR GOOD.
AND LIKE CLOSE BY ADDRESSING
SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT HAVE
BEEN RAISED ON THIS BILL BY THE
MATTRESS INDUSTRY.
AND AMENDMENTS THAT I PROPOSE TO
ADDRESS THEM.
THE MATTRESS INDUSTRY HAS RAISED
THE CONCERN THAT THE DEFINITION
OF FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICAL IN
THE BILL IS SO BROAD THAT IT
COULD LIMIT THEM FROM USING SOME
OF THE MATERIALS.
AND TECHNOLOGIES CURRENTLY USED
TO INHIBIT THE SPREAD OF FIRE
AND MATTRESSES THESE THE INCLUDE
MATERIAL SUCH AS RAYON SILICA
AND KEVLAR.
WE'VE HAD MANY CONVERSATIONS
WITH THE INDUSTRY IN A PROPOSED
A MUCH MORE NARROW DEFINITION.
FOR FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICALS
WHICH YOU CAN FIND ON PAGE TEN
AND ELEVEN OF YOUR ANALYSIS.
UNDER THIS NEW DEFINITION WHICH
THE BILL GOING FORWARD THE ONLY
FLAME RETARDANT CHEMICALS
AFFECTED BY THE BILL.
ARE HALOGENATED ORGANICS FORESTS.
ORGANIC NITROGEN OR NANOSCALE
CHEMICALS I GOT THROUGH IT I
WASN'T SURE I WOULD --
OR CHEMICALS THAT ARE LISTED ON
TWO KEY LESS THE PROP SIXTY FIVE
LIST AND THE WASHINGTON
DEPARTMENT OF WHEN WASHINGTON'S
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY LIST OF
CHEMICALS OF HIGH CONCERN.
THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT
SIGNIFICANTLY NARROW THE BILL
AND COUPLED WITH AN EXEMPTION
FOR THE THREAD THAT USED TO BIND
MATTRESSES MATTRESS COMPONENTS
TOGETHER.
WILL ALLOW MATTRESS MANUFACTURES
TO CONTINUE USING THE
OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF THE
MATERIALS THEY CURRENTLY IS TO
REDUCE THE RISK OF FIRE.
AND WE REMAIN TO CONTINUE IT
WILL REMAIN COMMITTED TO
CONTINUING THE THE OTHER
DISCUSSIONS THAT WE'VE HAD WITH
THE INDUSTRY.
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL OUR OF OUR ACOSTA NOVA ON
BEHALF OF THE CENTER FOR
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH.
AND ADAM BECAUSE YOU'RE ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
PROFESSIONAL FIREFIGHTERS AND
AND READ A SCIENTIST WITH THE
ENERGYSEE IS ALSO PRESENT TO
ANSWER TECHNICAL QUESTIONS
SHOULD THEY ARISE NICKY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER BLOOM PLEASE HE'D
LIKE TO BEGIN.
SURE SIR THANK CHAIRMAN HILL AND
THE BUSINESS PROFESSIONS AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT MEMBERS MY
NAME AS I LOOK ASSN OF AND I'M
THE POLICY MANAGER AT THE CENTER
FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH.
AND I'M HERE TO ASK YOUR SUPPORT
FOR ASSEMBLY BILL.
TWO NINE NINE EIGHT FIRST OF ALL
LIKE TO START WITH ONE VERY
IMPORTANT FACT CALIFORNIA'S
BUREAU OF ELECTRONIC AN
APPLIANCE REPAIR HOME
FURNISHINGS AND THERMAL
INSULATION HAS CONCLUDED THAT
FAME ATTORNEY CHEMICALS AND
FURNITURE DO NOT PROVIDE
MEANINGFUL FIRE SAFETY BENEFIT.
AND ARE NOT NECESSARY TO MEET
THE STATE'S ABILITY STANDARD.
THEY HAVE ALSO DETERMINE THE
CHILDREN'S PRODUCTS DO NOT POSE
A FIRE SAFETY RISK TO THEIR
SMALL SIZE AND FEEL LOW.
CALIFORNIA VALUES A HEALTHY
MARKETPLACE IN A STRONG ECONOMY
THAT THRIVES ON THE AVAILABILITY
OF DEMAND FOR SAFE COST
EFFECTIVE PRODUCTS.
ALL CALIFORNIANS KNEE CERTAINLY
THAT PRODUCTS THE BY ARE SAFE
AND DO NOT CAUSE HARM.
AB TWENTY NINE NINETY EIGHT WILL
ENSURE THAT ALL CALIFORNIANS
REGARDLESS OF INCOME WILL BE
ABLE TO PURCHASE UPHOLSTERED
FURNITURE.
STERN JONES PRODUCTS AND
MATTRESSES THAT DO NOT CONTAIN
TOXIC FROM RETURNING CHEMICALS.
MANY CONSUMERS INCORRECTLY
BELIEVE THEM CALIFORNIA CHANGES
AFFORDABILITY STANDARD THAT
FURNITURE INSURANCE PRODUCTS NO
LONGER CONTAIN THESE CHEMICALS.
HOWEVER PRODUCT TESTING HAS
SHOWN THAT APPROXIMATE 25% OF
THE PULSE OF FURNITURE AND
CHILLS PRODUCTS STILL CONTAIN
TOXIC FROM RETURNING CHEMICALS.
THIS BILL WILL ENSURE THAT THOSE
LAGGARD BUSINESSES CATCH UP TO
THE REST OF THE MARKETPLACE AND
WILL ENSURE THAT CONSUMERS ARE
ACTUALLY GETTING PRODUCTS THAT
DO NOT CONTAIN.
HARMFUL UNNECESSARY AND
INEFFECTIVELY RETURNING
CHEMICALS.
MANY LARGE MANUFACTURERS HAVE
ALREADY MOVED AWAY FROM SELLING
PRODUCTS TO USE FROM TURN
CHEMICALS SUCH AS IKEA.
ASHLEY FURNITURE LAZY BOY HERMAN
MILLER CREIGHTON BARREL TO NAME
A FEW.
IN FACT AB TWENTY NINE NINETY A
AS A SUPPORTER FURNITURE
MANUFACTURER ROOM AND BOARD.
AND SUSTAINABLE FURNISHINGS
COUNCIL WHICH REPRESENTS SOON OF
MORE THAN FOUR HUNDRED
MANUFACTURERS RETAILERS AND
DESIGNERS DEDICATED TO EXPANDING
THE ADOPTION OF ENVIRONMENTALLY
SUSTAINABLE PRACTICES.
ACROSS THE HOME FURNISHINGS
INDUSTRY.
IN ADDITION TO THE SUPPORT FOR
MANUFACTURERS AB TWENTY NINE
NINETY AS A SUPPORT OF LARGE
MEDICAL INSTITUTIONS AN
ARCHITECTURAL FIRM SUCH AS
KAISER PERMANENTE A DIGNITY
HEALTH HDR.
PERKINS I'M WELL.
WHO ARE ALL LARGE PROCEDURES
HAVE COMMITTED TO PURCHASING
FURNITURE AND MATTRESSES FREE OF
TOXIC WHEN RETARDANTS IN ORDER
TO PROVIDE HEALTHY IN TOXIC FREE
ENVIRONMENT TO THEIR CLIENTS?
THIS BILL GO A LONG WAY TO
PROTECTING FAMILIES ARE
HEALTHIER WORKFORCE AND FOR
THESE REASONS WE RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE ON A BETWEEN
AND I THANK YOU VERY MUCH YOU
WERE TRYING TO HOLD TO ABOUT A
TWO MINUTE.
TESTIMONY IF WE CAN SO --
PLEASE SIR PROCEED.
SENATOR HEALTH MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE THANK YOU FOR THE
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH YOU
TODAY.
MY NAME IS ADAM BECAUSE THEY'RE
IN THE FIREFIGHTER PARAMEDIC
WITH IT SANTA CLARA COUNTY FIRE
DEPARTMENT.
EVERY YEAR RIGHT OUT IN CAPITOL
PARK CALIFORNIA ADDS FIFTEEN
NAMES THE CALIFORNIA
FIREFIGHTERS MEMORIAL.
MANY OF THOSE INDIVIDUALS MY
BROTHER AND SISTER FIREFIGHTERS
WERE VICTIMS OF JOB RELATED
CANCER COVERS BECAUSE OF
PROLONGED EXPOSURE TO
CARCINOGENS ON THE JOB.
WHEN A FIRE FIGHTER INTERCEPTOR
FIRE WERE SURROUNDED BY A HAZE
OF CANCER CAUSING TOXINS
INCLUDING THOSE CONTAINED IN A
CHEMICAL FLAME RETARDANT?
WHEN THEY BURN THESE CHEMICALS
CAN COMBINE TO FORM EVEN MORE
TOXIC COMPOUNDS?
THE SEEP INTO OUR PROTECTIVE
CLOTHING AND A TRAITOR BREATHING
APPARATUS AND EVEN CREATE
SECONDARY EXPOSURES KNOCKED AT
THE STATION.
THE CUMULATIVE EFFECTS OF THESE
EXPOSURES OVER THE COURSE OF A
CAREER CAN BE DEVASTATING.
NOT ONLY CANCER BUT HEART LUNG
AND OTHER DEVELOPED DEBILITATING
DISEASES CAN BE TRACED A
PROLONGED EXPOSURE TO TOXINS
LIKE THOSE IN CHEMICAL FLAME
RETARDANT.
THESE PRODUCTS ARE ADDED TO
FURNITURE IN THE BELIEF THAT
THEY ARE MAKING THEM SAFER FROM
FIRE.
AS A FIREFIGHTER I CAN TELL YOU
FIFTIES TOXIC RETARDANTS PROVIDE
NO MEANINGFUL FIRE SAFETY
BENEFIT.
FIRES BURN HOTTER THAN THEY USED
TO AND THE MATERIALS USED TO
MAKE FURNITURE CAN RENDER THESE
RETARDANTS ALMOST USELESS.
ALL THESE CHEMICALS REALLY DO IS
CREATE HEALTH RISKS FOR
CONSUMERS WHEN THEY DON'T BURN
AND SERIOUS TOXIC EXPOSURES
RISKS WHEN THEY DO.
CALIFORNIA'S MADE GREAT STRIDES
IN GETTING THESE DANGEROUS
CHEMICALS OUT OF THE HOUSEHOLD
PRODUCTS.
WE'VE ADDED WARNING LABELS
UPDATED FLAMMABILITY STANDARDS
AND BENEFITED FROM OUR STATE'S
MARKET POWER TO ENCOURAGE
RETAILERS TO MOVE AWAY FROM
THESE HAZARDOUS PRODUCTS.
YET THESE CHEMICALS CONTINUE TO
FIND THEIR WAY INTO OUR
FURNITURE AND OTHER PRODUCTS.
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY NINE NINETY
EIGHT PROTECTS OUR CHILDREN AND
OUR FIREFIGHTERS BY INDIAN THE
SALE OF FURNITURE AND OTHER
PRODUCTS TREATED WITH THESE
DEADLY TOXINS.
THE RISKS FACED BY CONSUMERS AND
FIRST RESPONDERS HASN'T GONE
AWAY AND NEITHER HAVE THE
CHEMICAL COMPANIES EFFORTS TO
KEEP PUTTING THEM IN OUR
PRODUCTS. FOR THE SAFETY OF OUR
RESIDENTS AND MY BROTHER AND
SISTER FIREFIGHTERS.
ONCE AND FOR ALL [inaudible]
AND WE NEED TO GET THESE FLAME
RETARDANTS OUT OF OUR HOMES ONCE
AND FOR ALL. FOR THESE REASONS
AS RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU TO
SUPPORT AB.
TWENTY NINE NINETY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
KNOWN OPPORTUNITY FOR OTHERS IN
SUPPORT TO COME FORWARD.
GOOD AFTERNOON.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN BURST
MY CONSUMERS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA PROFESSIONAL
FIREFIGHTERS WE ARE CO SPONSOR
THE SPELL AND ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT TODAY THEY WOULD MAKE
YOU.
ON BEHALF OF CALPERS IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU.
DANIEL SAVANNAH ASSOCIATION OF
REGIONAL CENTER AGENCIES ALTER
IN SUPPORT VERY GOOD THANK YOU.
ARIEL HIM ON BEHALF OF THE
BREAST CANCER PREVENTION
PARTNERS IN SUPPORT FOR YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
YOU KNOW ONE IS THERE ANYONE
HERE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
AND IF PERHAPS YOU COULD
[inaudible]
GENTLEMEN WELCOME.
BOB JUST MISTER SHERMAN
ACCENTURE SIX CRITICAL FIRST I
JUST WANT YOU TO KNOW THE
COMMITTEE STAFF APPARENTLY LEFT
OFF THE OFF POSITION ON THE BILL
SO WE WANT TO HELP THE LIST
PASSED OUT OF THE OPPOSITION WAS
VERIFIED.
FROM LAST WEEK'S HEARING IN
SENATE USE OF MEMBERS COULD SEE.
THOSE PARTIES ARE.
YOU THINK YOU HAVE A CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ITEMS
JUST LIKE WITH THE AMERICAN
CHEMISTRY COUNCIL APPRECIATE THE
UP TO MAKE A COUPLE COMMENTS
TODAY.
OF REGARDING OUR OPPOSITION THE
BILL IT CENTERS ON A COUPLE
BROAD POLICY --
ISSUES --
RELATIVE TO SCIENTIFIC POLICY
AND EXISTING LAW A GOVERNING
UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE.
OF WELL WE APPRECIATE
UNDISTURBED LOOMS OUR ATTEMPT TO
NARROW THE DEFINITION WE WE HAVE
A FUNDAMENTAL DISAGREEMENT THAT
THE LEGISLATURE SHOULD BE.
ADOPTING POLICY THAT.
MAKES GENERAL SWEEPING --
ALLEGATIONS ABOUT CHEMICALS AND
HOW THEY MAY BE USED
[inaudible]
CANNOT.
SOUND SCIENTIFIC POLICY DOES NOT
ALLOW -- FOR
OR SHOULD IT ALLOW FOR SWEEPING
GENERALIZATIONS ABOUT HOW
CHEMICALS ARE USED IN CERTAIN
PRODUCTS YOU CAN'T SIMPLY
CLASSIFY CHEMICALS IS BEING
TOXIC.
OR NON TOXIC SAFE OR UNSAFE YOU
pHAVE TO ASSESS THEIR HAZARD
TRAITS HOW THEY'RE USED.
POTENTIAL EXPOSURES AERIAL
SCENARIOS ALL OF THOSE COUPLE
TOGETHER ALLOW ONE TO DETERMINE
WHETHER OR NOT A CHEMICAL COULD
BE USED AS SAFELY A FOR ITS
INTENDED USE.
EVEN PROSECUTE BY DOESN'T BANNED
CHEMICALS --
AND ONLY REQUIRES A WARNING WHEN
EXPOSURES EXCEED A THIRTEEN
CERTAIN THRESHOLD.
IT IS FOR THIS REASON THE
LEGISLATURE ADOPTED AND GAVE
AUTHORITY TO THE DEPARTMENT
TOXICS TO VALUE A CHEMICALS IN
CONSUMER PRODUCTS.
AND MAKE A REGULATORY DECISION
SCIENTIFIC ANALYSIS THAT
INCLUDES DEVELOPING A LIST OF
PRIORITY CHEMICALS EVALUATING
HOW THEY'RE USED AND DETERMINING
WHETHER OR NOT SAFER
ALTERNATIVES EXIST.
THE LEGISLATURE INCREASED DTS
HE'S BUDGET ONE POINT TWO
MILLION THIS YEAR --
TO EXPEDITE A REVIEW OF THOSE
TYPES OF CHEMISTRIES AND
PRODUCTS UNDER THE SAFER
CONSUMER PRODUCTS PROGRAM WE DO
BELIEVE THAT THAT IS THE MOST
APPROPRIATE VENUE --
TO ASSESS THESE CHEMISTRIES AND
HOW THEY MAY BE USED AND
IDENTIFY --
AN APPROPRIATE REGULATORY SPOTS
THE FINAL POINT I'LL MAKE --
IS THAT --
IT WAS ALLUDED TO EARLIER THE
STATE EGGS ALREADY HAS A
FURNITURE LABELING LAW ON THE
BOOKS ARE REQUIRING FURNITURE TO
BE LABELED A WHETHER OR NOT IT
DOES OR DES NOT CONTAIN --
FLAME RETARDANTS IN ARGUE
CONSUMERS TO HAVE THE ABILITY TO
MAKE INFORMED PURCHASING
DECISION --
WE BELIEVE THIS NET LEGISLATION
IS OVERLY BROAD --
AND SIDE STEPS EXISTING A
REGULATORY PROGRAM AT UT ESSIE
AND FOR THOSE REASONS I WE
REMAIN OPPOSED THANK.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN TOM
SHE HERE REPRESENTING THE
INTERNATIONAL SLEEP PRODUCTS
ASSOCIATION ARE ISPA.
ISPA REPRESENTS ALL THE MAJOR
OUR MATCHES MANUFACTURES IN
NORTH AMERICA.
ARM I WANT TO FIRST ACKNOWLEDGE
THE AUTHORS MOVEMENT.
AND RECOGNITION THAT NOT ALL
FIRE RETARDANTS OR HARMFUL.
A BY DEFINITION HIS AMENDMENT TO
THIS BILL THAT HE'S PROPOSING
NOW SHOWS INSTEAD OF HAVING A
VERY BROAD.
DEFINITION OF FIRE RETARDANTS
HE'S NOW STARTING TO NEVER BUT
THERE ARE FAR FAR* THAT WE
USE IN THE MATTRESS INDUSTRY.
THAT ARE NOT HARMFUL THEY'RE NOT
HARMFUL UNDER ANY NORMAL USAGE
CONDITIONS SO WE REALLY
APPRECIATE THAT.
HOWEVER THIS BILL EVEN AS IS
PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED WITH THE
MEMBER CENTER IN THE ANALYSIS.
STILL PRECLUDE THE SALES OF
LARGE NUMBERS OF MATTRESS UNITS
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THAT
YOU CERTAIN SAFE TECHNOLOGIES
THAT ARE INCLUDED MISTER BLOOMS
A MEMBER.
ON THE OF THE BILL STARTED
OFFICE I SAID WITH AN OVERLY
BROAD DEFINITION HAS BEEN
NARROWED.
BUT THE RESULT OF THE BILL EVEN
IN ITS CURRENT AS PROPOSED TO BE
AMENDED FORM WOULD PROHIBIT
MATTRESS SALES IN THE IN
CALIFORNIA.
IT WOULD DESTROY HUNDREDS OF
GOOD MANUFACTURING AND RETAIL
JOBS IT COULD COST THE STATE
TENS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN
LOST SALES TAX REVENUE TO THE
GENERAL FUND AS WELL AS WITH THE
LOCAL GOVERNMENT LEVEL.
AND IT'S GOING TO CREATE SOME
PRETTY SERIOUS SERIOUS
ENFORCEMENT CHALLENGES THAT
COULD HURT TRADITIONAL BRICK AND
MORTAR SELLERS LET ME EXPLAIN
WHY.
MATTRESSES ARE DIFFERENT THAT
FURNITURE MATTRESSES ARE
REGULATED AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
ALL MATTRESSES SOLD THE UNITED
STATES MUST MEET TO FEDERAL
STANDARDS ONE OF THOSE IS AN
OPEN FLAME TESTS AND THE OTHER
ONE IS A SMOLDERING CIGARETTE
TUFTS.
MATTRESSES CONTAIN LATEX OR
POLYURETHANE FOAM THAT'S WHAT
PROVIDES CONSUMERS COMFORT AND
SUPPORT WHEN THEY SLEEP AT NIGHT.
HOWEVER IF IGNITED THESE
MATERIALS QUICKLY LEAD TO DEADLY
FIRES.
AWARE OF THE HEALTH RISKS
ASSOCIATED WITH TRADITIONAL
FLAME RETARDANT USED IN THE PAST
IN THESE FORUMS THE MATTRESS
INDUSTRY AS A WHOLE SHOULD THESE
TYPES OF OUR CHEMICALS.
AND INSTEAD THEY USE FIRE
BARRIERS SO WE UNDERSTAND MISTER
BLOOM TRYING TO GET OUT AND WE
MOVED AWAY FROM THOSE CHEMICALS
BUT EVEN THESE FIRE BARRIERS
THAT WE USE WHICH TENDED BIG
WHICH ARE BENIGN SUBSTANCES.
WHICH FALL UNDER SOME OF THE
DEFINITION HIS BILL AND BE
PRECLUDED BY HIS BILL FOR
ABILITY TO USE IT.
THESE BARRIERS BE TO FIBRIN
FABRIC IN CLOSE THE FOAM AND THE
BLOCK HEATER OXYGEN FOR REACHING
IT SO IT DOESN'T AT NIGHT.
FIRE BARRIERS TO MATE WITH
VARIOUS FLAME RETARDANT
CHEMICALS SOME OF WHICH NOW
MISTER BLOOM HAS ACKNOWLEDGED
ARE SAFE THERE ARE OTHERS THAT
ARE SAFE TO THAT WE NEED.
THE CONSUMER PRODUCT SAFETY
COMMISSION IS TESTED THOSE FIRE
RETARDANT CHEMICALS AND THEY
FELL THEM SAY FOR CONSUMERS
THERE'S A LOT OF LITERATURE ON
THIS OKAY IT'S IT'S NOT.
IT'S ISN'T JUST A MATTER OF
OPINION --
EVEN SO THE BILL'S TERMS WOULD.
UP NOT ONLY BE ON FIRE RETURNS
FROM PHONE WHICH WE DON'T HAVE
PUBLIC SCHOOLS YOU DON'T USE UP
BUT THEY WOULD BASS MOTHER
MATERIALS THAT WE DO NEED TO
MEET THE FEDERAL STANDARDS.
LAST YEAR CALIFORNIA'S BOUGHT
NEARLY FIVE MILLION DOLLARS
WORTH OF MATTRESSES.
I'M SORRY THEY POT NEARLY FIVE
MILLION MATTRESSES IN THE STATE
WORTH TWO BILLION DOLLARS IF
THIS BILL PASSES IN ITS PROPOSED
TO BE AMENDED FORM THERE WILL BE
SIGNIFICANT LOSS IN SALES OF
PRODUCTS THAT WE CAN'T SELL
CALIFORNIA.
WE WILL BE ABLE TO MEET
CONSUMERS NEEDS.
FINALLY UNLESS CALIFORNIA HIRES
HUNDREDS OF ENFORCEMENT
PERSONNEL MANY INTERNET SALES OF
THESE PRODUCTS WILL ESCAPE THE
BILL'S OVERLY BROAD BANDS AND
TRADITIONAL RETAILERS OF BRICK
AND MORTAR STORES ARE GONNA BE
IMPACTED.
THIS BILL WILL WE APPRECIATE THE
MOVEMENT TO NARROWING THE
DEFINITION IT'S STILL TOO BROAD
OF A DEFINITION WILL PREVENT US
FROM SELLING SIGNIFICANT CLASSES
OF MATTRESSES OF THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA.
IT WILL COST JOBS AND ALSO
BECAUSE REVENUE DOCUMENT USUALLY
APPRECIATE THAT THE TESTIMONY
OTHERS IN OPPOSITION PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
MELISSA ORDER ON BEHALF OF THE
RETAIL INDUSTRY LEADERS
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION THANK
YOU THANK YOU.
PROGRESSIVE CHAIR MEMBERS DON
KHAKI MCCUE KEPT CAN ASSIST IT'S
ABOUT THE CALIFORNIA
MANUFACTURES THE TECHNOLOGY
ASSOCIATION C. MTA ALSO OPPOSE
THE QUEUE.
THAT AFTERNOON AT WRIGLEY ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
OF COMMERCE IN OPPOSITION THINK
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
CHARLES LEWIS OF THE NATIONAL
FEDERATION OF ANY BUSINESS
REPRESENTING SMALL BUSINESS
OWNERS ALSO OPPOSE THINKING.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS MITZI
JOHNSON HER BEHALF OF PHILIPS
NORTH AMERICA WITH A TWEENER OUT
WE ARE NOT OPPOSED WE WOULD JUST
WANTED EXPRESSED A CONCERN WE'D
LIKE TO SEE.
EXPRESS PREEMPTION CLAUSE IN THE
BILL TO ENSURE THAT THE
RESTRICTIONS IN THIS BILL ARE
APPLIED STATEWIDE THANK YOU.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION ZENO
AND BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS PERHAPS
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER BLOOM YOU
COULD RESPOND.
TO SOME OF THE COMMENTS THAT
WERE MADE BY THE OPPOSITION I'M
BETTER AT BEING BUDGET WOULD
HAVE JUST HAPPY OPPOSITION
DIDN'T TELL US HOW.
DIFFICULT IT WOULD BE TO REMOVE
THE LABEL OFF OF THOSE
MATTRESSES BECAUSE I KNOW THAT'S
IN VIOLATION OF FEDERAL LAW I
THINK.
TO RIGHT.
OF HAVING BAD JOKE THANK THANK
YOU -- AYE
MISTER CHAIR AND I HAVE --
WITH ME NOW AND I READ IT --
WHO IS A SCIENTIST WITH THE
ENERGY GO --
ISSUES --
THE OPPOSITION MAKES A NUMBER OF
POINTS --
ONE THAT THEY BEGAN WITH IS THAT --
OF THE BILL MAKES A SWEEPING
GENERALIZATIONS AFFECT I HEARD
THAT -- TERM
SEVERAL TIMES THIS IS NOT A BILL
THAT MAKES SWEEPING
GENERALIZATIONS IT ACTUALLY ACTS
UPON CALIFORNIA LAW PASSED IN
TWENTY THIRTEEN REGARDING FLAME
RETARDANTS.
AND IT.
A RESTRICTS THE USE OF FLAME
RETARDANT IN VERY VERY SPECIFIC
CATEGORIES IT IS IN FACT
DELIBERATELY TAILORED IS A VERY
NARROW BILL IT'S NOT SWEEPING AT
ALLTHOUGH IT WILL HAVE.
A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON SELECT
POPULATIONS OF A OF CALIFORNIANS
BUT IMPORTANT POPULATIONS WERE
TALKING ABOUT INFANTS CHILDREN
AND FIREFIGHTERS.
OF AND I WAS GOING TO RESERVE IT
FOR MY CLOSING BUT I THINK WHEN
WE THINK ABOUT FIREFIGHTERS --
THERE ARE FIREFIGHTERS WHO ARE
RETIRING FROM THE FORCE TODAY
WHO'VE BEEN EXPOSED TO THESE
CHEMICALS THEIR ENTIRE LIVES AND
FOR THOSE FIREFIGHTERS SADLY
THERE'S VERY LITTLE WE CAN DO
FOR THEM.
BUT WE CAN DO SOMETHING FOR ALL
OF THE FIREFIGHTERS WHO ARE
BEING HIRED TODAY THE CURRENT
GENERATION OF INCOMING FIRE
FIGHTERS WHO DON'T HAVE TO LIVE
WITH THESE CHEMICALS.
BECAUSE IT'S ALREADY BEEN
DECIDED THAT THERE UNNECESSARY
CONCEDE THAT YOU NEED TO LEAVE
BEHIND YOUR TO GO.
ON A BILL STRIVE POLITICS FOR
THAT.
WE HAVE A NOT CONCEDED THE ISSUE
OF SAFETY OF FOR A OF OTHER
ITEMS THAT WAS ALSO SENT IN IT
WAS REPEATED.
OF WHAT WE HAVE DONE IS EXEMPTED
FOUR OF THE FIVE SUBSTANCES THAT
ARE USED.
BASED O THE INDUSTRY THE
MATTRESS INDUSTRIES CLAIM THAT
IF WE DIDN'T DO THAT THEY
WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO SELL
MATTRESSES HERE AT ALL THAT WE
HAVE ALLOWED IN THE BILL. FOUR
OF FIVE TECHNOLOGIES CAN BE USED --
FOR A FLAME RETARDANT --
A TO MAKE THE OF THE MATTRESSES
FLAME RETARDANT --
OF FINALLY OF A POINT WAS MADE
ABOUT TO A GREEN CHEMISTRY THIS
IS NOT AN APPROPRIATE JUSTICE
THAT HAS ACTUALLY COME UP FOR A
NUMBER OF TIMES THAT THROUGH THE
COURSE OF THE BILL.
BUT THE GREEN CHEMISTRY PROGRAM
IS REALLY NOT APPROPRIATE HERE.
OF GREEN CHEMISTRY PROVIDES FOR
AN ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS WHERE
WE WANT TO LOOK FOR CHEMICALS
THAT ARE SAFER THAN THOSE THAT
ARE CURRENTLY IN USE IN TWENTY
THIRTEEN AGAIN THE STATE
DETERMINED.
THAT THIS CLASS OF CHEMICALS IS
UNNECESSARY THEY DON'T*
FIRES AND THEREFORE THEY ARE
UNNECESSARY SO THAT WHOLE --
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS THAT GREEN
CHEMISTRY PROVIDES US WITH IS
UNNECESSARY IN THE SETTING.
BRINGING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE.
SENATOR HERNANDEZ HERE YOU JUST
TOUCH UPON A BRIEFLY IN YOUR
OPENING REMARKS AS WELL RIGHT
NOW WITH REGARD TO TO PRIME.
STEPHANIE.
THANK YOU KIND OF EXPLAIN A
LITTLE BIT THE OTHER WAS A
COMMENT WAS MADE BY THE
OPPOSITION ABOUT BENIGN BARRIERS
WITH REGARD TO THE THE BEDS THAT
THE MANUFACTURING OF THEM AND
THAT THAT WAS BROUGHT INTO THE
QUEUE KIND OF ADDRESS THAT AT
ALL.
I THINK --
OF WHAT YOU'RE REFERRING TO IS
THE TECHNOLOGIES OF THAT ARE
USED BY THE MATTRESS INDUSTRY OF
THERE ARE FIVE OF THEM --
IN THE AMENDMENTS TO THE BILL
THAT WE'VE PROPOSED WE WOULD
ALLOW THE USE OF FOUR OF THOSE
FIVE THE ONLY --
EXCUSE ME WE WOULD --
LIKE THE ONLY ONE THAT WOULD NOT
BE -- ABLE
TO BE REALLY [inaudible]
FIBRE.
HI I ENTERED WITHOUT ENOUGH
RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL --
BE ONE OF THE TECHNOLOGY THAT
HE'S REFERRING TO MONICA A FIVER
HOUSE TRAILER ANTIMONY TRIOXIDE
IN IT.
AND IT'S LISTED AS BY IRAQ I
SAID --
POSSIBLE CHRISTIAN AND IS ALSO
LISTED ON THE ARM WASHINGTON
STATE --
LIST FOR AND CHEMICALS CONCERN
FOR CHILDREN I'M SO WE DECIDED
THAT -- THE
OTHER FOUR OUR AYE NOT LISTED AS
CARCINOGENS IN THAT BUT THE FACT
ONE WE WOULD.
IT WOULD BE CONSIDERED A HELP
HARM [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
WE LOOK MANY COMMENTS.
DO YOU LIKE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
DRIVERS AND UP THERE AREN'T ANY
AMENDMENTS OR ANYTHING FROM
[inaudible]
CHAIR [inaudible]
OKAY.
OKAY SO DO WE HAVE A MOTION.
SENATOR LANDIS MOVES BILL.
AND PLEASE CULTURAL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HILL.
FULLER NO FULLER NO.
ALLEN DODD GALGIANI GLAZER
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WILK
[inaudible]
WELL NOW.
WITH -- ONE
VOTES AT THIS TIME WILL LEAVE
THE ROLE OPEN FOR OTHERS TO COME
AND AT ON THANK YOU.
AND YOU HAVE ANOTHER BILL.
PARTIALLY YES.
A ITEM.
ELEVEN TO TWENTY TWO TWENTY ONE
THANK YOU MADAM CO CHAIR AND
MEMBERS.
ARE ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY TWENTY
TWENTY TWO TWENTY ONE UPDATES
THE OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY
PRACTICE ACT.
AND I'D LIKE TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
DILIGENT WORK THAT YOU PUT INTO
THIS BILL AND WILL ACCEPT.
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS THAT
ARE ON PAGE SEVEN AND EIGHT OF
THE ANALYSIS.
THESE AMENDMENTS REFLECT THE
FINAL PORTION OF NEGOTIATIONS
BETWEEN OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS
AND THEIR LICENSING BODY.
SPECIFICALLY THE AMENDMENTS
CLARIFY THAT OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPISTS THAT OUR TEACHERS
HAVE TO BE LICENSED O. TEAS AND
STRIKE PROVISIONS REGARDING
ATTESTATION.
WITH THESE AMENDMENTS THE
CALIFORNIA BOARD OF OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY THE LICENSING BODY FOR A
CHEESE WILL BE SUPPORTERS OF THE
MEASURE.
THIS PRACTICE ACT WAS WRITTEN
OVER EIGHTEEN YEARS AGO AND THIS
A BILL SIMPLY UPDATES AND
CLARIFIES THE ACT TO ENSURE THAT
O. TEASE.
CAN PRACTICE TO THE FULL EXTENT
OF THEIR EDUCATION AND TRAINING
WITH ME ARE IVAN ALTAMURA OF THE
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY ASSOCIATION
OF CALIFORNIA.
AS WELL AS AMERICAN OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY ASSOCIATION THE SPONSORS
OF THE MEASURE OF AND WE ALSO
HAVE TRUCKS WILMARTH.
BODY ES OTA DIRECTOR OF STATE
BEFORE WE GO ANY FURTHER AD SAY
THIS BILL HAS SUGGESTED SUPPORT
SUPPORT.
SOUNDS LIKE WE HAVE A MOTION ON
THE BILL.
AND WE HAVE A TWO MINUTE LIMIT
WHICH WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
I WILL BE VERY QUICK MADAM CHAIR
MEMBERS IVAN ALTAMURA --
ON BEHALF OF THE OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY ASSOCIATION CALIFORNIA
AND THE AMERICAN OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY ASSOCIATION.
AYE AS WAS STATED LE THERE'S
IT'S BEEN LONG TIME SINCE OF THE
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY PRACTICE
ACT HAS BEEN BEEN PASSED AND
SINCE THAT TIME IT REALLY HAS
NOT HAD.
ANY SIGNIFICANT UPDATES ARE
ALTHOUGH THE PRACTICE OF
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY HAS
ADVANCED IN THE EDUCATION OF OUR
PRACTITIONERS AS ADVANCED.
QUITE SUBSTANTIALLY AND AND
CHUCK WILL MARTHA TALK A LITTLE
BIT ABOUT THAT I JUST LIKE TO
SAY THAT THE THAT THE BILL THAT
YOU HAVE BEFORE YOU.
IS THE EFFORT OF A LOT OF WORK
ON THE FRONT END OF SHARING WITH
OUR OTHER ALLIED HEALTH
PROFESSIONALS AND AND OTHER
HEALTH PROFESSIONALS AND IN
GENERAL.
THE LANGUAGE EARLY ON AND OFF
AND AND WE GOT TO A POINT WHERE
YOU HAVE NO OPPOSITION ON THIS
BILL INSIDE LIKE JUST ACTORS A
POINT OUT THAT.
I AM WE WORKED REALLY HARD TO TO
IMPROVE OUR PRACTICE ACT WHILE
AT THE SAME TIME STAYING IN
EARLY [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
MADAM MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE APPRECIATE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO OF S. FOR YOUR
SUPPORT FOR ASSEMBLY TWENTY TWO
TWENTY ONE I'M.
CHUCKLE MARTHA I'M WITH THE
NATIONAL PROFESSIONAL
ASSOCIATION AND I WILL BE BRIEF
AS WELL.
OF WE'RE HAPPY THAT THIS BILL
pIS THE PRACTICE ACT.
OF MANY CHANGES HAVE HAPPENED
WITHIN THE OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY
PROFESSION OVER THE PAST
EIGHTEEN YEARS.
OF THE BILL REVISES OUR SCOPE OF
PRACTICE.
STAKEHOLDERS TO MAKE SURE THAT
WE STAND IN OUR LINE.
OF THE BILL OF IS THAT ADDRESSES
THE PURPOSE OF OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY TO CLARIFY THAT
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS PROVIDE
HABILITATION REHABILITATION
SERVICES.
OF THE BILL ALSO ARE IN OUR VIEW
IT IN IMPROVES ACCESSED
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY BY
ADDRESSING.
OF THE NUMBER OF OCT
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY SYSTEMS
THAT CAN BE SUPERVISED BY AN
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST.
SO ARE WE LOOKED AT WE
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO A
TALK TO ABOUT THIS BILL AND ASK
FOR SUPPORT THANK YOU.
OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
HI MY NAME IS MORE LOPEZ I'M A
LICENSED OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST
MY SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK YOU.
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION.
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE OTHER ANY
COMMENTS [inaudible]
THE BILL.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR IBOOK
THANK YOU PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HILL.
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN.
DODD GALGIANI GLAZER HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WELL.
LOOK I THE BILL HAS THREE VOTES
A WILL HOLD THE ROLE OPEN NOW
FOR THIS TO ADD ON THANK YOU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
NUMBER ITEM NUMBER --
TWELVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER HOLDEN
[inaudible]
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY THREE YEAH
[inaudible]
COME UP [inaudible]
UP [inaudible]
WELCOME.
IF A KID IS ALSO.
BETTER SHARE THANK YOU IN
MEMBERS HAD TODAY I'M PRESENTING
AB TWENTY FOUR TWENTY THREE A
BILL THAT WERE REMOVED HARMFUL
BARRIER. FOR STUDENTS WITH
DISABILITIES THAT WAS
INADVERTENTLY CREATED BY STATE
REFORM.
THE CHILD HAS A DISABILITY THE
FEDERAL IDEA ACT AND CALIFORNIA
LAW REQUIRES EDUCATORS PARENTS.
AND OTHER ADVISERS TO COME
TOGETHER AND CREATE A PLAN THAT
ENABLES A CHILD TO GET THE BEST.
POSSIBLE EDUCATION.
THIS IS CALLED THE
INDIVIDUALIZED EDUCATION PLAN OR
IEP.
THE IEP CAN INCLUDE ANYTHING
FROM WHERE STUDENTS SHOULD SIT
IN CLASS TO THE TYPE OF DESTINY
TO HOW OFTEN THEY NEED BREAKS.
IT CAN ALSO RECOMMEND VISITS BY
A PHYSICAL THERAPIST TO ENSURE
THEIR MOBILITY ISSUES DO NOT
HINDER THEIR EDUCATION PROCESS.
AND TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN THE
LEGISLATURE PASSED AB ONE
THOUSAND WHICH ALLOWED PATIENTS
DIRECT ACCESS TO PHYSICAL
THERAPISTS FOR FORTY FIVE DAYS.
OR TWELVE VISITS BEFORE NEEDING
A MEDICAL DOCTORS REFERRAL.
THIS WAS A MAJOR CHANGE FOR
PATIENTS OF PHYSICAL THERAPIST
IN A MEDICAL SETTING HOWEVER IT
ACCIDENTALLY CREATED SERIOUS
COMPLICATIONS WHERE THERE WERE
NONE FOR STUDENTS WITH
DISABILITIES THAT CREATES
CONFUSION FOR SCHOOLS.
PARENTS AND PT'S.
AB TWENTY FOUR TWENTY THREE WILL
CLARIFY THAT AB ONE THOUSAND
DOES NOT APPLY TO THE SERVICES
PROVIDED TO STE IMPROVE STUDENTS
EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE.
ACCORDING TO THE I EP.
THERE A NUMBER OF REASONS
STUDENTS RECEIVING THE SIR
SERVICES UNDER IEP DO NOT NEED
THE SAME LIMITS AS OTHER SEEKING
MEDICAL TREATMENT [inaudible]
FIRST.
THESE ARE NOT TREATMENTS OR
CURES FOR MEDICAL CONDITIONS IN
THE WAY WE TYPICALLY THANK.
THESE ARE ACCOMMODATIONS AND
EXERCISES USED TO ENSURE THE
STUDENT IS IN THE PAST.
POSITION TO LEARN.
AS PHYSICAL THERAPIST SEE
STUDENTS ON A LESS FREQUENT
BASIS OFTEN WITH MORE THAN FORTY
FIVE DAY.
DAYS BETWEEN VISITS WHICH MEANS
A CHILD WOULD NEED A NEW
REFERRAL EVERY TIME THEY ARE DUE
TO VISIT.
FROM THE PHYSICAL THERAPISTS.
IF OUR PARENTS IF PARENTS CANNOT
GET A REFERRAL IN A TIMELY
MANNER PT SERVICES OR DELAYED.
THIS IS HAPPENING NOW AND IS A
BARRIER.
IF CHILDREN SEE A DOCTOR.
A I'VE CHILDREN SEEN A DOCTOR IS
YOUR CONCERN.
BELIEVE ME THAT IS MY CONCERN.
TO TRUSTED PEDIATRICIANS IN MY
DISTRICT EDUCATORS AND OTHER
HEALTH PRACTITIONERS SAY THAT
THIS BILL IS NARROW ENOUGH.
DO NOT INTERFERE WITH THEIR
PARTICIPATION IN THEIR PATIENTS
HEALTH.
AB TWENTY FOUR TWENTY THREE IS
NOT A NEW POLICY.
IS A POLICY THAT GOVERN THESE
SERVICES FOR DECADES IN
CALIFORNIA.
AND WHILE WE DO NOT HAVE COME
COMPLAINTS OR REPORTS THAT PT'S
CROSS THE BOUNDARIES OF THEIR
PRACTICE ACT BEFORE AB.
ONE THOUSAND THERE HAVE BEEN
COMPLAINTS THAT BE TO SERVICES
HAVE BEEN DELAYED SENSE AB.
ONE THOUSAND THIS IS WHY SPECIAL
EDUCATIONAL LOCAL PLAN AREA
ADMINISTRATORS AND THE
ASSOCIATION OF REGIONAL CENTER
AGENCIES SUPPORT THE BILL.
I AM WILLING TO SIT DOWN AT THE
DOCTORS AND CRAFT INTENT
LANGUAGE AMENDMENTS THAT ENSURE
THAT IT IS CLEAR.
THIS EXCEPTION NARROWLY APPLIES
TO IP OR AYE FSP CASES.
AND FOR THESE REASONS I RESPECT
WHERE YOU LIVE.
WHEN AMENDMENTS UNLESS
[inaudible]
BILL.
A ARE YOU TAKING AMENDMENTS A WE
ARE PREPARED TO TAKE THE
AMENDMENT CHAU THANK YOU --
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS SAY CARL
LUNDEN HER MATH THE CALIFORNIA
PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATION --
I HAD THE A WITNESS WHO HAD
GOING EMERGENCY SURGERY A
BELIEVER NOT SOME GOING TO THE
BEST I CAN FROM HER NOTES --
SHE WOULD BE CLEARLY MORE EXPERT
THAN ME BUT UM IS FROM.
MRHOLDS DISTRICT ONLY MY BEST
REPRESENT INTEND WHICH YOU WOULD
HAVE SAID.
FIRST NOTE THAT TO REITERATE
WHAT HAVE MISTER HOLDEN SAYS
THAT THE SERVICES UNDER THERE.
IE PEAS OR ISPS HAVE BEEN AROUND
FOR FORTY THREE AND THIRTY TWO
YEARS RESPECTIVELY SINCE HIS
ACCIDENT PUT IN PLACE.
THERE'S NEVER BEEN A SINGLE
ISSUE WITH IT.
WHEN WE DID --
AB ONE THOUSAND FIVE YEARS AGO
WHICH IS THAT SO FOR SCHOOL
THERAPY WITH SOME LIMITS ON IT.
WE INADVERTENTLY WALKED TO AN
AREA THAT NOW REQUIRES
CLARIFICATION JUST TO MAKE SURE
THAT THAT DOES NOT IMPEDE THE
SERVICES THAT THE FEDERAL LAW
REQUIRES.
WE CANNOT AT THE STATE LEVEL
CREATE IMPEDIMENTS AND BARRIERS
TO THE SERVICES TO CHILDREN.
AND I THINK YOUR BODY
UNIVERSALLY AGREES WE DON'T WANT
TO SLOW THOSE UP --
PHYSICAL THERAPISTS ARE QUITE
QUALIFIED AND DO PROVIDE THE
SERVICES EVERY SINGLE DAY IS
NOTED.
AND THE EARLY START SERVICES ARE
FEDERALLY MANDATED BE IP
SERVICES ARE MANDATED AS MISTER
HOLTON SAID THROUGH ID ES.
EN EVEN GUIDELINES PUT FORTH BY
THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF
PEDIATRICS.
STATE THAT EVEN WHEN HE SPECIFIC
NOT NEURO MOTOR DIAGNOSIS HAS
NOT BEEN IDENTIFIED.
CHILDREN WITH MOTOR DELAYS
BENEFIT FROM EDUCATIONALLY.
BASED THERAPIES AND
EDUCATIONALLY NECESSARY
THERAPIES WHO'S A DIFFERENT
STANDARD HERE THAN THE
TRADITIONAL HEALTHCARE SYSTEM.
WE'RE LOOKING UP QUESTION A
MEDICAL NECESSITY THIS IS AND
WHETHER OR NOT THESE ARE
EDUCATIONALLY NECESSARY NOT IN
THE FEDERAL LAWS PRETTY CLEAR ON
THAT --
EARLY INTERVENTION SKILLS OR
SERVICES ARE AIMED AT HELPING
PARENTS DEVELOP THE SKILLS
KNOWLEDGE THEY NEED. TO SUPPORT
THEIR CHILD'S DEVELOPMENT AT THE
HOME.
IN THE COMMUNITY RATHER THAN
REMEDIATION OF IMPAIRMENTS
RELATED TO MEDICAL DIAGNOSIS.
EARLY START WAS ESTABLISHED IN
PART TO MINIMIZE THE POTENTIAL
FOR DEVELOPMENT TWO WAYS THAT
THEY HAVE.
AND MINIMIZE THE NEED FOR
SPECIAL EDUCATION LATER IN THE
RELATED SERVICES WHEN THEY REACH
SCHOOL AND AND LATER A ADULT AGE --
WE WERE A HAPPY TO HAVE WORK
THROUGH THESE ISSUES THROUGH
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE EDUCATION
COMMUNITY INCLUDING THE
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION.
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
AND THE CALIFORNIA PODIATRIC
MEDICAL ASSOCIATION OUT ALSO
MAKE ONE LAST NOTED THAT IS.
ANOTHER RELATED SERVICE IN THIS
THERAPY.
HAS IS --
OCCUPATIONAL THERAPISTS WERE
JUST UP THERE IN THEIR BILL HAVE
A SPECIFIC EXEMPTION THAT
MIRRORS THIS IN THEIR PRACTICE
ACT AS WELL --
TO RECOGNIZE THE FEDERAL LAW AND
WITHOUT IT WOULD TO ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
OTHER WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
DANIEL SERENA ASSOCIATION OF
REGIONAL CENTER AGENCIES.
ARE INTERNALLY AT THE STAFF
LEVEL WE'VE HAD EXTENSIVE
DISCUSSIONS ON THIS BILL BOTH IN
ITS CURRENT FORM IN THE PRIOR
VERSION.
WITH ALTERED HIS CONVERSATIONS
WITH REGIONAL REGIONAL CENTER
STAFF WHOSE AREAS OF EXPERTISE
OUR EARLY START THE FSP
COMPONENT.
AND REALLY THE SUMMATION OF ALL
OF OUR RESEARCH ON THE SOME
DISCUSSIONS AS WHAT THE AUTHOR
SAID IN HIS OPENING STATEMENT.
THIS IS NOT A NEW POLICY
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL
ENERGIZED PASSAGE.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
.
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE
BRYCE STOCKARD IN BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ORTHOPEDIC
ASSOCIATION.
ARE WE FIND OURSELVES IN OPPOSE
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION.
UNDERSTAND THE WINDOW ON TRYING
TO CRAFT AMENDMENTS TO TAKE CARE
OF OUR CONCERNS IS CLOSING.
SO IN TWO MINUTES HERE WE GO --
NUMBER ONE AS WELL AS MENTIONED
BY THE PROPONENTS AND IN THE
ANALYSIS THAT WAS IS VERY
COMMITTEE WHERE WE REACHED
AGREEMENT AB.
ONE THOUSAND ON WAYS IN WHICH
PEAK INDIVIDUALS WOULD HAVE
DIRECT ACCESS TO PT SERVICES
PHYSICAL THERAPY SERVICES.
I THOUGHT WE AGREED AT THAT TIME
ON AFTER FORTY FIVE DAYS AND OR
TWELVE VISITS TO A PHYSICAL
THERAPIST.
BODIES WERE MEDICAL INTERVENTION
WHICHEVER OCCURS FIRST IF THE
PATIENT IS NOT GETTING BETTER.
SOMETHING ELSE IS GOING ON WE
AGREED AT THAT TIME THAT THE
FORTY SIX DAY OR THE THIRTEEN
VISIT WHATEVER OCCURS FIRST.
WOULD BE GROUNDS FOR REFERRAL TO
A PHYSICIAN OR PODIATRIST OR
TREATMENT PLAN CAN BE DEVELOPED.
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO
UNDERSTAND THAT ARM THESE ARE
WELL KIDS.
THERE IS ALSO AN EXEMPTION TO
DIRECT AXIS FOR PT SERVICES FOR
WELLNESS SERVICES.
THOSE WERE DESCRIBED US AT THE
TIME AS SERVICES PROVIDED IN THE
HEALTH CLUB MAYBE THE PHYSICAL
THERAPIST AS A PERSONAL TRAINER --
THESE ARE NOT FOLKS THAT THEY
ARE GOING TO PRESENT WITH THEM --
UNDERPINNING MEDICAL CONDITION.
THIS BILL ATTEMPTS TO ADD AN
EXEMPTION TO THAT PROVISION.
THESE ARE NOT WELL KIDS ARE IN
ORDER TO QUALIFY FOR AN IEP.
YOUR CHILD CAN HAVE AUTISM.
IT COULD BE DEATH THEY CAN BE
BLIND.
THEY CAN HAVE AN EMOTIONAL
DISTURBANCE THAT COULD BE
HEARING IMPAIRED.
THEY CAN HAVE AN INTELLECTUAL
DISABILITY THEY CAN HAVE
MULTIPLE DISABILITIES THEY CAN
HAVE AN ORTHOPAEDIC IMPAIRMENT.
THEY COULD HAVE SPEECH LANGUAGE
IMPAIRMENT THEY COULD EVEN HAVE
A TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY.
THESE ARE NOT WELL KIDS.
UP WE WOULD ALSO SUBMIT TO YOU
THAT THERE IS A PROVISION THE PT
PRACTICE ACT THAT IF THEY ARE
SEEING.
PATIENT PRESENTS WITH SOMETHING
THAT HAS.
BEEN RECOGNIZED TO BE OUTSIDE OF
THEIR SCOPE OF PRACTICE THERE TO
IMMEDIATELY REFER THAT PATIENT.
TO PHYSICIAN AND SURGEON A
PODIATRIST WE WOULD SUBMIT TO
YOU THAT THERE PROBABLY IS NO
PROBLEM WITH THIS BILL BECAUSE
EVERY TIME.
A CHILD IS PRESENTED IT PT'S
OFFICE OR SCHOOL WITH THESE
SORTS OF CONDITIONS IT SHOULD
TRIGGER A REFERRAL TO A
PHYSICIAN SURGEON.
WE'VE HEARD FOR THREE MONTHS
VARIOUS PROBLEMS WHY THIS BILL
IS NEEDED.
THE FIRST PROBLEM WAS THAT THERE
WAS ENOUGH PHYSICIANS TO TO SEE
THESE KIDS.
THAT'S EASILY RECTIFIABLE ARE
NOW WE'RE HEARING THAT THERE'S
DISCREPANCY BETWEEN FEDERAL LAW
AND STATE LAW FEDERAL LAW TRUMPS
STATE LAW WE CAN'T DO ANYTHING
IN STATE LAW TO FURTHER
RESTRICT KIDS ACCESS.
THAT IS NOT WHAT WE'RE ASKING
FOR WE'VE COME UP WITH THREE OR
FOUR DIFFERENT SETS OF
AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD ALLOW THE
I EP TO CONTINUE.
BUT IN FACT IF THE KID IS NOT
GETTING BETTER WITHIN FORTY FIVE
DAYS OR TWELVE VISITS WHICH IS
ONE OF THE REFERRAL TO HAPPEN.
THE ONE THING THAT --
WE ALSO DON'T UNDERSTAND IS THIS
ISN'T THE SENATE EDUCATION
COMMITTEE ARE ALTHOUGH WE DO OF
THE CHAIR OF THE SENATE
EDUCATION COMMITTEE ON THE
COMMITTEE THIS IS A PRISON
PROFESSIONS COMMITTEE.
ARE THIS IS AN EDUCATION ISSUE.
WE DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THE I EP
IS ARE DEVELOPED.
WE DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT WHAT
GROUNDS.
THOSE PROGRAMS ARE TO BE AUDITED.
WE DON'T KNOW WHAT BENCHMARKS
ARE TIME TABLES ARE TO BE IN
THESE IP PROGRAMS FOR PURPOSES
OF TRYING TO FIGURE OUT IF THE
KID IS GETTING BETTER.
AND WITHOUT THAT INFORMATION.
UNFORTUNATELY SCHOOL DISTRICTS
ARE WASTING TIME ENERGY AND
RESOURCES.
ON POTENTIALLY PROVIDING
SERVICES THAT MAY NOT BE IN THE
BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD --
IN TERMS OF THIS HAPPENING FOR
LAST FORTY FIVE YEARS.
YOU KNOW WE WE DO THINGS IN IN
THIS BUILDING ALL THE TIME TO
MAKE LAWS BETTER MAKE PEOPLE
SAFER.
BOB THERE WAS A TIME WHEN
WEARING A SEATBELT WAS OKAY --
WE CHANGE LAWS TO MAKE PEOPLE
SAY FOR ALL THE TIME WE THINK
THIS NEEDS A A DEEPER LOOK --
IF THE END OF THE DAY WE WANT
WHAT'S BEST FOR THE KIDS AND WE
START GETTING CLOSE START TWO
MINUTE LIMITS.
WEEK WE'VE SAID FROM THE
BEGINNING THAT WE WANT TO MAKE
SURE KIDS GET THE ACCESS THE
SERVICES BUT WE DON'T WANT.
PARENTS TO HAVE A FALSE SENSE OF
HOPE THAT IF THEY'RE IN IP
PROGRAM WITH THEIR KID IS GONNA
GET MARGINALLY BETTER SO.
WITH ME TODAY IS NINE SHIP YOU
SKI THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
THE COMPANY ORTHOPEDIC
ASSOCIATION HAPPEN ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS [inaudible]
YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON AND THANK YOU FOR
THE OPPORTUNITY --
TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY ON TO AB.
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY THREE OH AS
BRYCE MENTIONED WE REPRESENT
ORTHOPEDIC SURGEONS MANY OF WHOM
ARE INVOLVED IN TREATING FOUND
CHRONICALLY ILL KIDS.
THEY'VE BEEN INVOLVED IN THE CCS
PROGRAM FOR MANY YEARS AND
THEY'RE VERY COMMITTED AND
DEDICATED TO THESE CATS.
AND I FOUND THESE KIDS IF
THERE'S ANY PATIENT POPULATION
FOUND THAT NEED A TEAM OF
MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS TO HELP
THEM.
THIS IS THAT.
A WE ACTUALLY BELIEVE THAT --
AB ONE THOUSAND GOT IT EXACTLY
RIGHT FIVE YEARS AGO WE THE BILL
ALLOWS THE PHYSICAL THERAPIST TO
HAVE DIRECT ACCESS TO PATIENTS
WE THAT WAS REPRESENTED THESE
WOULD BE.
OTHERWISE WELL PATIENCE AT THE
TIME.
AND AND THEY COULDN'T OF COURSE
IT MEANT.
AS BRYCE SAID WHEN THE PHYSICAL
THERAPIST REALIZE THAT THERE WAS
AN UNDERLYING MEDICAL CONDITION
AND THE PHYSICAL THERAPIST IS
SUPPOSED TO IMMEDIATELY REFER
THAT PATIENT. TO A PHYSICIAN FOR
A DIAGNOSIS OF WHAT'S REALLY
GOING ON IT'S HARD FOR US TO
UNDERSTAND HOW WHEN THE PHYSICAL
THERAPIST IS TREATING THESE KIDS.
THAT THEY DON'T RECOGNIZE THAT
THERE'S AN UNDERLYING MEDICAL
CONDITION THAT'S CAUSING THESE
PROBLEMS.
WHEN WHEN THEY REALIZE THAT
WHETHER THEY'RE ON THE SECOND
VISIT OR THE THE TWELFTH VISIT?
THEY SHOULD ACTUALLY BE MAKING A
REFERRAL TO THE PHYSICIAN UNDER
CURRENT LAW.
IF THEY DID THAT A WE'RE TOLD BY
THE PHYSICAL THERAPIST THAT
THERE ISN'T A PROBLEM.
ONCE THE CHILD HAS MEDICAL
DIAGNOSES THERE'S A TEAM OF
HEALTH PROFESSIONALS THEY
DEVELOP A TREATMENT PLAN.
AND NOT TO DISAGREE WITH THE
AUTHOR BUT THIS WOULD NOT
INVOLVE --
HAVING TO GO BACK TO THE
PHYSICIAN EVERY FORTY FIVE DAYS.
THE THE PHYSICIAN WOULD BE
INVOLVED IN DEVELOPING A
TREATMENT PLAN WHICH COULD BE AN
UNLIMITED AMOUNT OF PHYSICAL
THERAPY SERVICES FOR AN
UNLIMITED AMOUNT OF TIME.
JUST AS THE BILL IS ASKING FOR
SO WE THINK IT'S TERRIBLY
IMPORTANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
CHILD ACTUALLY IS DIAGNOSED AND
THE AND THE SCHOOL TO KNOWS WHAT
THEY'RE DEALING WITH.
IF THIS CHILD GOES TO SCHOOL AND
HAS A SEIZURE AND THEY DON'T
REALLY HAVE A MEDICAL DIAGNOSIS
ON THAT CHILD THE SCHOOL WON'T
KNOW HOW TO REACT EITHER.
SO WE THINK AB ONE THOUSAND GOT
IT RIGHT THAT IT ALLOWS THE
PHYSICAL THERAPIST HAVE DIRECT
ACCESS BUT AFTER A CERTAIN
NUMBER OF VISITS THAT THERE
SHOULD BE.
FOUND THEY SHOULD MAKE SURE THAT
THERE'S A MEDICAL DIAGNOSIS SO
THEY KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON WITH
THE CHILD.
SO WE WOULD REALLY ASK THAT THE
AS BRYCE MENTIONED THAT THIS IS
KIND OF AN INTERESTING BILL IT'S
KIND OF A COMBINATION OF OF THE
BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS AND
EDUCATION AND IT'S TAKEN THE FOR
AWHILE TO GET UP TO SPEED ON
THIS.
WE REALLY THINK THAT THIS BILL
SHOULD GO TO MEDIA AS WELL AND
BE HELD HERE UNTIL THERE'S BEEN
A BROADER DISK.
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION.
ANY COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE
SENATOR HERNANDEZ.
YEAH I JUST WANNA FOLLOW UP IN A
COMMENT THAT YOU MADE COMPARING
AB.
ONE THOUSAND YOU FELT YOU GOT IT
RIGHT AND YOU HAVE A POPULATION
THAT MEAN THAT IS A FROM WHAT
I'M GONNA SEND YOU SING IS
HEALTHIER AS OPPOSED TO CHILDREN
IN THIS --
AREA WHICH ARE LESS HEALTHY AND
THEREFORE NEEDING THEY HAVE TO
DIAGNOSIS ALIENS I KNOW SO THE
QUESTION I WOULD POSES.
SO LET'S SAY A PATIENT COMES IN
UNDER AB ONE THOUSAND AND THERE
IS SOME KIND OF CONDITION
PATHOLOGY DISEASE.
DO THE PT'S NOT HAVE THE ABILITY
TO DIAGNOSE THOSE OR CHILE SAY
TO LEAST RECOGNIZE THAT AND I
KNOW THE LEGALLY I DON'T THINK
THEY LEGALLY CAN DIAGNOSE BUT
DON'T THEY HAVE THE ABILITY
LEAST RECOGNIZED GET THAT TO THE
TO THE POSITION OR NOT.
AND MAYBE THE PROPONENTS COULD
ANSWER THAT.
THEY GO STAFF AT IT FIRST FUNDS
ARE UNDERSTANDING AND THERE WAS
AGREEMENT WHEN AB ONE THOUSAND
WENT TO THAT PHYSICAL THERAPISTS
DO NOT HAVE THE ABILITY TO MAKE
A MEDICAL DIAGNOSIS.
WE WOULD CERTAINLY HOPE THEY
HAVE THE ABILITY TO RECOGNIZE
WHEN THERE'S AN UNDERLYING
MEDICAL CONDITION.
AND THIS PETITION IS NOT GETTING
BETTER SO YES WE TOOK THAT ON
TRUST AND FAITH THAT THE
PHYSICAL THERAPIST.
A WOULD MAKE THE APPROPRIATE
REFERRAL TO THE PHYSICIAN.
WE KIND OF WONDER IF THAT'S
ACTUALLY HAPPENING TODAY THOUGH
BECAUSE NOW WE'RE BACK --
WITH THIS WITH THEM A DISCUSSION
ABOUT THESE ID A PROGRAMS
AND THESE CHRONICALLY ILL KIDS
WHERE THE PHYSICAL THERAPIST
BELIEVES THAT THEY HAVE THE
ABILITY. TO OFFER SERVICES FOR
THEM ON AN ONGOING BASIS FOREVER
THERE'S THERE'S NO LIMITATION AT
ALL -- SO
THAT MAKES US PAUSE TO FOUND
pWONDER WHETHER OR NOT THE
PHYSICAL THERAPISTS ARE REALLY
COMPLYING WITH THE EXISTING LAW
RIGHT NOW SO.
AND I UNDERSTAND THAT THROUGH
STATUE THEY DON'T HAVE THE
AUTHORITY TO DIAGNOSE BUT MY
UNDERSTANDING THROUGH.
OCCASIONS THEY HAVE THE ABILITY
LEAST RECOGNIZE AND MAKE THOSE
DECISIONS. TO REFER AND IF
YOU'RE TELLING ME THAT AB ONE
THOUSAND WAS [inaudible]
YOU KNOW.
THE BILL THAT.
SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED THEN
[inaudible]
KEY IN.
IN THEORY IT SHOULD BE OCCURRING.
AND I WOULD THINK THAT THE I
WOULD THINK THAT THAT WOULD
TRANSPOSE TO THE CHILDREN AS
WELL AS YOU'RE TELLING ME
OTHERWISE IF THERE'S A MUCH MORE
ON HEALTHIER POPULATION.
IT'S A LITTLE BIT MORE OVERSIGHT
THAT'S THAT'S THE TO COMMANDER
I'M THAT I'M TRYING TO DO
[inaudible] TO TO GRAPPLE WITH
AND MAYBE YOU CAN CLARIFY AS FAR
AS THE EDUCATION OF THE P. P.'S.
YOU'RE.
A MAN AND CHAIR --
GARLAND INDIANA MAP THE
CALIFORNIA PHYSICAL THERAPY
ASSOCIATION AGAIN JUST TO
REFRESH ON THIS.
FOR BEEN OVER FORTY YEARS OVER
THIRTY YEARS AND THESE TWO
SYSTEMS BOTH THE EDUCATIONAL
SYSTEM.
AND THE EARLY INTERVENTION.
THE SCHOOL THERAPY SERVICES HAVE
BEEN MANDATED BY FEDERAL LAW TO
BE PART OF WHAT'S INCLUDED IN
AVAILABLE THE CHILDREN EITHER AS
PART OF THEIR EARLY INTERVENTION
SERVICES.
OR THROUGH SERVICES THAT ARE
SCHOOL BASED FOR SCHOOL AGE
CHILDREN.
NO RESTRICTION ON THAT IT'S A
TEAM APPROACH OCCUPATIONAL
THERAPY.
A SPEECH LANGUAGE NURSING ALL
KINDSOF SERVICES ARE STACKED IN
THAT FEDERAL LAW THIS IS THE
SERVICES.
HAVE TO BE AVAILABLE ON ARE
MANDATED TO BE AVAILABLE IN THE
EDUCATION SYSTEM IS FOR THE
PURPOSE OF THE CHILD.
PARTICIPATING AS FULLY AS THEY
POSSIBLY CAN IN THEIR EDUCATION
SO CONSULTANT SOME PROVIDERS
WITHIN THAT SYSTEM UNDER FEDERAL
LAW.
ARE MANDATED TO HELP THE CHILD
DO EVERYTHING THEY CAN WITH
THOSE SERVICES TO HELP THEM
ACCESS THEIR EDUCATION IN EARLY
INTERVENTION.
JUST AS THE NOTED EARLIER THIS
IS FOR THE ZERO THREE CROWD.
AND MANY TIMES AND WE HAD
DISCUSSIONS WITH THE AMERICAN
ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS PEDIATRICS --
THEIR CHIEF PEDIATRICIAN OR HEAD
OF THEIR GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS
COMMITTEE BASICALLY NOTED DURING
OUR CONFERENCE CALLS THAT LOOK.
THERE'S MANY TIMES AND I REFER A
KID OVER --
FOR EARLY INTERVENTION Y. DON'T
QUITE HAVE A DIAGNOSIS YET
THERE'S SOME MILESTONES.
MAYBE SOME THINGS WERE LOOKING
AT BUT THE BENEFIT FROM THE
SERVICES WHICH INCLUDES PT AND
MANY OTHER THINGS.
AND THEY THEN GET THOSE SERVICES
PLANS ARE DEVELOPED IN THOSE
SYSTEMS BY A MULTI DISCIPLINARY
TEAM.
AND OFTENTIMES THAT ONE CLUE
IMPETUS OF POSITIONS AS WELL BUT
NOT ALWAYS --
MANY TIMES IT DOES IF THE CHILD
HAS A DIAGNOSIS FOR EXAMPLE
ACCEPTABLE POLICY.
THAT'S TYPICALLY A LIFE LONG
DIAGNOSIS WE KNOW WHAT THAT IS
WHO WILL BE IN THE RECORD
THERE'S NO ISSUE WITH PROVIDING
THE SERVICES.
WE'RE NOT EVEN TOTALLY.
SURE THAT THE BILL'S NECESSARY
IN ONE REGARD ON THE OTHER HAND.
WE HAVE BEEN GETTING BECAUSE OF
DISCREPANCY BETWEEN STATE LAW
AND FEDERAL LAW WE'VE HAD SOME
LEGAL COUNSEL.
QUICKLY FROM SCHOOL DISTRICTS
AROUND THE STATE TO KEEP RAISING
THE QUESTION.
DID YOU GUYS WHEN IN IN --
TO TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN WHEN
YOU DID AB ONE THOUSAND DIGIT
CRATER THING THAT WE'RE SUPPOSED
TO DO.
THE ANSWER TO PLEASE COME BACK
FROM EVERY LEAD DEFICIT NO BUT
THE QUESTIONS KEEP GETTING ASKED
THIS IS INTENDED MERELY. TO
CLARIFY THAT WE DIDN'T MEAN TO
WALK IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT
FEDERAL LAW MANDATE WHEN WE DID
THAT BILL BACK THEN MOSTLY PUT
FRANKLIN DISCUSSIONS.
RELATED HEALTH CARE SERVICES AND
SERVICES THAT ARE MEDICALLY
NECESSARY.
AND THAT THAT THAT WAS COVERED
PRETTY WELL WHERE WE WORKED OUT
A DEAL --
WITH MEDICAL ASSOCIATION OTHERS
AROUND THE THINGS THAT DIANA
DESCRIBE WHAT I'M STILL TRYING
TO GET TO THE POINT OF THE
CONCERN OF THE OPPOSITION OF THE
ABILITY FOR THE PHYSICAL THINK
THE PTZ BE ABLE [inaudible]
TO APPROPRIATELY --
RECOGNIZE AND BE ABLE TO TREAT
AND AND TRY AGAIN GOING BACK.
TO MY QUESTION TO YOU IS DO THE
PT'S HAVE THE ABILITY TO AT
LEAST RECOGNIZING NO LEGALLY OR
STATUTORY THEY CAN'T LEGALLY
DIAGNOSE.
ES AND THE OTHER THING I'D
THROW HOT AGAIN THIS IS BEEN A
TRACK RECORD.
SO IT'S EASY TO SAY WE THINK
THIS BAD THING MIGHT HAPPEN AND
FOR SOMEBODY TRY TO PROVE A
NEGATIVE.
IN THIS CASE WE HAVE A TRACK
RECORD OF FORTY THREE YEARS IN
THIRTY FIVE YEARS.
WHERE IF WE WERE DOING A POOR
JOB?
OF THAT ISSUE AND NOT
RECOGNIZING THE ISSUES.
WE KNOW ABOUT IT WOULD HAVE A
LIABILITY CASE SOMEWHERE IN FACT
WE HAVE THE ZERO LIABILITY CASES
IN THAT REGARD ZERO COMPLAINTS
AGAINST PHYSICAL THERAPISTS
WORKING EVEN ONE OF THOSE
CAPACITIES.
AND THAT THAT IS YOU KNOW ADMIT
THAT'S ABOUT AS GREAT A TRACK
RECORD YOU CAN HAVE NOT ONE I
MEAN IF.
IF I SAW WANTED SAY WHILE IT'S
AT LEAST LOOK AT THAT WOMEN SEEN
ONE SO.
AGAIN THERE'S A REASON THAT THE
EDUCATION COMMUNITY HAS BEEN
BEHIND THIS BILL.
THAT --
REGIONAL CENTERS A BEHIND THE
BILL THE THE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION.
AND PODIATRY THE CONCERNS EVEN
THOUGH THEY ARE THE PEOPLE WE'RE
SUPPOSED TO REFER TO UNDER THE
FORTY FIVE TWELVE RULE.
AND THOSE GUYS ARE ALL ON BOARD
THIS IS THE ONLY GROUP LEFT IT
IS REMAINING WITH OF CONCERN.
SENATOR FIND THAT IT JUST SAID
AS WELL.
CERTAIN ADVANTAGES REALLY WELL
OKAY AND SO ON I CERTAINLY
UNDERSTAND THEM WITH MISTER
LONDON IS REFERRING.
TO A IT'S CERTAINLY TRUE THAT
THE I. D. E. A. PROGRAM DOES
REQUIRE A CERTAIN --
LAUNDRY LIST OF SERVICES THAT
WHILE MUST BE MADE AVAILABLE TO
THESE KIDS I WOULD MAKE I WOULD
POINT OUT THAT WHAT THEY CALL
MEDICAL SERVICES IS ALSO ONE OF
THOSE SERVICES.
AND HOW THEY DESCRIBE MEDICAL
SERVICES IS A LICENSED PHYSICIAN
TO DETERMINE A CHILD'S MEDICAL
RELATED DISABILITY.
SO IT'S CERTAINLY CLEAR THAT THE
I. D. A PROGRAM IN VISIONS THAT
A PHYSICIAN WOULD BE INVOLVED IN
MAKING ACTUALLY A DIAGNOSIS OF
WHAT THAT CHILD'S ACTUAL
CONDITION YES --
I WOULD ALSO THEM I DON'T KNOW
WHETHER OR NOT THERE ARE ANY
LAWSUITS AGAINST PHYSICAL
THERAPIST FOR THEIR ACTIVITIES
BUT I CERTAINLY KNOW THERE'S ON
A NUMBER OF LAWSUITS FILED BY
PARENTS.
WHERE THEY DO NOT BELIEVE THE I
EP PROGRAM IS ADEQUATELY
PROVIDING THE SERVICES FOR THEIR
DISABLED CHILD --
I'VE SPENT SOMETIME ON FRIDAY
TALKING WITH AN ATTORNEY HERE IN
SACRAMENTO THAT DOES NOTHING BUT
HANDLES CASES --
TWENTY TWO YEARS OF REPRESENTING
CHILDREN AND WHERE THEY THE I EP
PROGRAM HAS NOT DONE A GOOD JOB
OF OF OF ALLOCATING THE SERVICES
THAT THEY BELIEVE THEIR CHILD
NEEDS.
AND I BELIEVE IN THOSE CASES
GENERALLY THE PARENTS WIN WHEN
THEY GO TO COURT AND THEM.
THE SCHOOLS ARE DIRECTED TO OUR
REQUIRED TO MANDATE THOSE
ADDITIONAL SERVICES SO I THINK
THAT'S AN ILLUSTRATION THAT.
IF THE MEDICAL PROVIDERS WERE
INVOLVED AT THE GET GO IN
DEVELOPING THESE PLANS MAYBE
THESE KIDS WOULD HAVE ACCESS TO
THE RIGHT SERVICES MORE QUICKLY.
SO IN YOUR OPENING STATEMENT FOR
THE OPPOSITION.
SO DOUGHERTY MENTIONED THAT YOUR
OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED WHAT ARE
YOUR SUGGESTION AMENDMENTS AND
YOU ALSO MENTIONED THAT YOU'RE
RUNNING SHORT OF TIME YOU WANT
TO GET.
KIND OF EXPLAIN IN TWO MINUTES
WHICH GUYS WENT WAY OVER TWO
MINUTES A BUT WE ARE.
DID YOU WE CONTINUE.
TO PROVIDE AMENDMENTS --
LIKE WE SAID WE WANT TO IF
THERE'S A PROBLEM IT TOOK US
WILD UNDERSTAND IT --
AND WE'VE PRESENTED TOWARD THREE
SETS OF DIFFERENT AMENDMENTS
INITIALLY IT WAS.
THE FACT OF JUST LETTING THE
PHYSICIAN BUT THE CHILD'S
TREATING PHYSICIAN AWARE OF THE
I EP -- THAT
COULD BE IS SOMETHING AS SIMPLE
AS ONE THAT FORTY SIX THERE THAT
THIRTEEN VISIT OCCURS THAT JUST
THE FACT OF A MAKING THAT
REFERRAL HAS TO HAPPEN NOT
STOPPING THE I EP BY ANY MEANS.
OUR OR FORWARDING DOT COPY OF
THE IEP UNDER FEDERAL PRIVACY
LAWS WHENEVER POSSIBLE HAVING
THE PARENT PROVIDE THAT TO THE
PHYSICIAN.
AND PROBABLY WOULD BE TREATED IS
LIKE A NEGATIVE LAB RESULT RIGHT
SO IF YOU GO TO QUEST LATIN GET
SOME BLOODWORK DONE YOU'RE NOT
GOING TO HEAR FROM YOUR POSITION
LESS OR SOMETHING ABNORMAL --
SO OUR GOAL WAS JUST TO TRY AND
FIGURE OUT A WAY WITHOUT BEING
OVERLY RESTRICTIVE UNDERSTANDING
THE FIREWALL BETWEEN FEDERAL LAW
AND STATE LAW.
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT A WAY WERE
PHYSICIANS CAN BE INFORMED THAT
THESE CHILDREN ARE IN AN IEP OR
AS DIANA SAID AT THE OUTSET WE
BELIEVE CD AND WE BELIEVE
IDEA.
PROVIDES GUIDANCE TO STATES BUT
WE THINK THERE'S A LOT OF PLAY
THERE IN TERMS OF WHO CAN BE
PART OF THAT MANDATED TEAM.
AND WHAT WE KEEP HEARING IS.
WE DON'T WANT TO TIP BEEN AND
THAT HAVE THAT SORT OF
CONVERSATION WE YOU KNOW THE THE
THE TENOR IS WE DO NOT WANT
PHYSICIANS INVOLVED SO WE'RE
JUST A LITTLE BIT CONCERNED WHY.
WE CAN'T BE A LITTLE BIT MORE
HEAVY HANDED IN RUSSIAN FIGURE
OUT HOW.
THESE KIDS CAN HAVE PHYSICIAN
INVOLVEMENT AT LEAST OF THE
OUTSIDE OF THE DEVELOPING FIRED
AT THE SIMPLE AS YOURS.
ARE ALLOWING THE IEP IS TO GIVE
NOTICE OF POSITION AND YOU'RE
OKAY WITH THAT WOULD YOU BE IF.
YOU REMOVE THE OPPOSITION ARE.
AND I THINK THE OTHER AMENDMENT
WOULD BE TO BETTER DEFINE WHAT
REALLY EVEN TALKING ABOUT ABOUT
ABOUT P. T. EDUCATION SERVICES.
AND YOU KNOW --
THE SUPPORTERS OF THE BILL
FREELY ADMIT I BELIEVE THAT
WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT
REHABILITATIVE SERVICES FOR
THESE KIDS RETARDING ABOUT
SERVICES FOR THEM TO NAVIGATE
THE SCHOOL.
THERE'S THERE'S SOME QUESTIONS
RAISED BY THE AMERICAN PHYSICAL
THERAPY ASSOCIATION AS TO
WHETHER OR NOT THOSE EDUCATION
SERVICES ARE WITHIN THE SCOPE OF
PRACTICE OF A PHYSICAL THERAPIST --
BUT THEM YOU KNOW SOME ALLEN
HANDS AROUND WHAT SERVICES ARE
REALLY TALKING ABOUT HERE.
ALRIGHT THANK YOU I MEAN I'M
JUST CURIOUS I MEAN IT SEEMED
LIKE A I DON'T KNOW WE WANT TO
BE WRITING.
YOU KNOW AMENDMENTS AND LAWS IN
COMMITTEE.
EIGHT TRUST THE CHAIR HE DOES IS
DUE DILIGENCE AND THANK YOU.
YOU THINK IT'LL OUR VISSCHER
CONTINUALLY WHICH I GET MYSELF A
LITTLE ORIENTED HERE AGAIN SO WE
WERE.
AT THE POINT OF A HIGH THING
COMPLETED OPPOSITION
[inaudible]
AND SENATOR HERNANDEZ POPULAR
BATHROOM AND A VERY GOOD.
WE HAVE QUESTIONS BUT WE DO'T
HAVE A MOTION YET AND THE OTHER
HASN'T AND MANY OF THE CLOTHES
ARE VERY VERY GOOD AND I HAD A
COUPLE OF QUESTIONS AS WELL BUT
I DON'T KNOW IF THEY CAN ANSWER
NOT SENATOR ALLEN.
JUST MY BEEN A FUNDS BECAUSE NO
ROOM AYE I THINK.
YOU KNOW THE THE I APPRECIATE
WHAT THE OPPOSITION SAYING BUT I
THINK THAT THE IMPLICATIONS ARE
ARE PRETTY DRAMATIC WERE TO
SUGGEST THAT.
WE OUGHT TO HAVE --
POSITION SIGNED OFF ON EVERY IEP
IN THE STATE WE'RE TALKING ABOUT --
AYE ENORMOUS.
POTENTIAL COST BURDEN ASSOCIATED
WITH THAT ASKING ME I YOU KNOW
IF IF IN IN A WORLD OF UNLIMITED
RESOURCES THAT WOULD --
YOU KNOW THAT THAT COULD BE
FANTASTIC BUT TIME.
BUT I THINK IT SAID THERE THERE
THERE'S A REASON WHY IT'S NOT A
REQUIRED PART OF THE IEP PROCESS.
I JUST WITH I MEAN I'D I THINK
THE QUESTION THAT WE HAVE IS.
THE METHOD AMENDED BY WHICH THE
I EP IS DEVELOPED.
I MEAN.
THERE IS THERE HAS TO BE A
DISCUSSION AROUND A SPECTRUM I'M
SURE THERE'S A SEVERITY OF YOU
KNOW.
CONDITIONS THAT THESE CHILDREN
HAVE -- SOME
REALLY CHRONIC ALL THE WAY TO
MAYBE MAYBE NOT THAT BAD SO.
WHEN THE DEBATE WHEN THE I EP IS
DIVERT BEING DEVELOPED WHETHER
THAT'S A SCHOOL DISTRICT OR
WHETHER THAT IS WHATEVER SCHOOL
AGENCY IS RESPONSIBLE FOR
DRAWING ON THE FUNDS IN CREATING
THE I EP?
WHO IS MAKING THAT ASSESSMENT
THAT DECISION ABOUT WHICH
MANDATED SERVICES SHOULD BE A
PART OF THAT IP FOR THAT CHILD
WE'RE NOT?
I DON'T THINK WE'RE GOING TO BE
AS HEAVY HANDED TO SAY EVERY
SINGLE TIME A KID GETS INTO AN
IEP.
AYE FSP MIGHT BE A DIFFERENT
STORY BUT WHEN IS THAT OCCURRED
HAS TO BE THE THE THE THE RESULT
OF A COMET [inaudible]
DISCUSSION WITH THE WITH THE
THERAPIST THAT THE THE FAMILY
THE CARE --
THE DISTRICT SOMETIMES A LAWYER
[inaudible]
I AND THAT'S THE WAY IT'S
TYPICALLY RIGHT BUT I I DON'T I
DON'T JUST MEAN TONIGHT YOU'RE.
HAVING THIS DISCUSSION IS
HELPFUL BECAUSE I I I DON'T
DISAGREE THAT I'M.
THERE WOULD BE VALUE YOU KNOW WE
HAVE VAST WORLD TO THE HOUSE.
NO MORE REPLIES AND SYSTEMATIC.
DOCTORS EMPLACEMENT YOU GUYS WHO
PRICE.
WITH THAT HE WOULD HE WOULD
THERE THERE'S A LOT OF AND IT
WAS JUST A BECAUSE COST FOR THIS
ASSOCIATED WITH MANY.
AND AND THANK YOU FOR THAT AND I
APPRECIATE YOU AS THE EDUCATION
CHAIR BECAUSE I'VE HAD THE
SIMILAR CONCERNS ABOUT THE THE
IEP AND YEAH THAT'S SOMETHING
THAT'S NOT REALLY MANDATED BY
THE ADMIN THE STATE DOESN'T HAVE
THE CONTROL OVER THAT AND THAT'S
FORMED ELPHABA HAD SOME
QUESTIONS PUT.
TOGETHER LIKE IF YOU DON'T MIND
IF I COULD ASK THEM THEY MAY
HAVE BEEN ALREADY.
RESOLVING I WOULD APPRECIATE IT --
THE YEAR.
IN REVIEW QUESTION FOR YOU IN
PT'S HAVE HOW OFTEN.
DO THEY WITHIN THE I EP
[inaudible]
PROCESS HOW OFTEN DO PT'S REFER
OUT TO A PHYSICIAN.
OR DO THEY EVER.
REACH THAT TWELVE VISAGE WITHIN
FORTY FIVE DAYS AND THEN FEEL
THAT THEY HAVE TO DO THAT.
THIRTY AS MR CHAIRMAN --
BUT I THINK THERE IS A VARIETY
OF WAYS THAT THEY WOULD GET FOR
THAT ONE HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED
THAT IF YOU.
SAW SOME MEDICAL REASON. TO MAKE
A REFERRAL RIGHT AWAY WE ARE AS
WAS DISCUSSED --
FOUND BY LAW TO MAKE THAT
REFERRAL AND AGAIN THERE'S NO
EVIDENCE.
THAT IS COOL HURVITZ DON'T DO A
REALLY BANG UP JOB THAT THEY'RE
QUITE GOOD AT THAT [inaudible]
THE THE OTHER ISSUE THE FORTY
FIVE GRAVE TWELVE VISIT LIMIT.
WE SEE RELATIVE TO THIS ISSUE IS
MORE OF A NEED FOR CLARIFICATION
BECAUSE AGAIN FOR THE PAST.
NO FORTY THREE AND THIRTY TWO
YEARS THEY'VE BEEN DOING THIS.
WE SORT OF THIS OTHER BILL THAT
WE DID FIVE YEARS AGO.
STEPPED IN THE MIDDLE OF THIS
LITTLE BIT A RAISE THE QUESTION
LEGAL COUNSEL BEEN ASKING ABOUT
THIS.
AND REALLY ALL THIS IS DESIGNED
TO DO IS CLARIFY THAT A WHEN WE
DID THAT DISCUSSION.
WE WE DID MEAN A STEP IN THE
MIDDLE OF THE FEDERAL LAW.
WERE MAKE IT VERY CLEAR THE
PROBLEM FOR BEAUTY IS OUT THERE
IS OF A LEGAL COUNSEL FROM THE
SCHOOL DISTRICT.
SAYS I KNOW YOU'RE PROVIDING
PHYSICAL THERAPY SERVICES UNDER
THAT I FEAR I'VE SP.
BUT THIS OF THE LAW WOULD USE
WAS DO WITH THAT IT RAISES THE
ISSUE WE'RE JUST TRYING TO
CLARIFY WHAT WOULD IT MEAN TO
STEP IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT FOR
THE PURPOSES OF THESE. TWO
SERVICE AREAS AND ONLY THESE TWO
SERVICE AREAS AND AGAIN.
AFTER MANY CONVERSATIONS WITH
THE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION PODIATRY
IN OTHERS WE REACHED A POINT
WHERE.
I FELT LIKE NEVER JUST ABOUT
EVERYBODY IS SATISFIED ONE GROUP
IS NOT NEWS WE TRAIN AND
INTERVIEW COULD.
HOW MANY OF?
US IN THIS MAYHAVE BEEN
ANSWERED I APOLOGIZE HOW MANY
IEP TEAMS INCLUDE PHYSICIANS AND
AND DO THEY AT SOME POINT IN
TIME AND I I THINK THEY HATE HIM
FOR MY UNDERSTANDING --
THE IP AND JUST FOR WHAT IT'S
WORTH I'M A PARENT WITH A A
TWENTY ONE YEAR OLD YOUNG MAN I
GO THROUGH AN IEP EVERY YEAR
WITH MY OWN SON.
IS THE MANY PHYSICAL AND
INTELLECTUAL CHALLENGES --
SO I'M VERY FROM OF THIS PROCESS
AND PERSONAL LEVEL --
THERE'S NOT BEEN ONE SINGLE
INSTANCE WHERE WE'VE HAD A
PHYSICIAN'S.
IN HIS PARTICULAR IP HE DOES
HAVE A FORMAL DIAGNOSIS IT DATES
BACK TO THE TIME HE WAS.
YOU KNOW BORN BUT HE STILL
EXPERIENCES OTHER CHANGES ALONG
THE WAY AND IP DOESN'T DEMAND
THAT BUT WHAT THEY DO LOOK AT
AGAIN IS FOR THE PURPOSE OF
DETERMINING WHAT WILL HELP THEM
AXIS IS EDUCATIONAL.
EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT MOST
EFFECTIVELY WHAT SERVICES WILL
BE BENEFICIAL THEM WITHOUT A
MEDICAL NECESSITY TEST IT'S WHAT
IS EDUCATIONALLY NECESSARY FOR
HIM.
TO HAVE THE BEST CHANCE OF
SUCCESS.
HE DID DO THE EARLY INTERVENTION
SERVICES THAT.
THE TIME WHEN HE WAS IN THE ZERO
TO THREE RANGE.
AND AGAIN THERE WAS NOT A
PHYSICIAN SITTING THERE EVERY
SINGLE TIME WE GET ACCUTANE
ACCOUNT THE DOCTORS.
ABSOLUTELY WE WE WERE FOR THEIR
BY A PEDIATRICIAN HAS.
EVENTS OCCURRED AT BIRTH.
ACTS A VERY COMMON CASE WITH
EVEN THE PEDIATRICIANS LOOKING
AND SAYING I'VE NO IDEA WHAT IS
OUTCOMES GONNA BE AT WATSON OVER
THERE.
TO YOU KNOW TO CHECK THIS OUT
AND WE'LL FIGURE THIS OUT AS WE
GO ALONG WITH THINK YOU'LL
BENEFIT.
FROM FAMILY SERVICES.
WHICH THE REGIONAL CENTERS
PROVIDE FOR THE ZERO THREE IS
AND THEN ONCE YOU THREE YOU
GOING TO SCHOOL SYSTEM.
SO IT IT'S A YES IT'S NOT
SOMETHING EVER THAT WE HAD A
POSITION SITTING IN ANY OF THOSE
TABLES BUT MEDICAL RECORDS.
YOU KNOW SOMETIMES OUR ACCESS TO
PART OF IT FOR SURE.
OKAY THANK YOU FOR INDULGING ME
YES AND I I WOULD IF IF THIS IF
THE COMMITTEE DOES --
APPROVED THE BILL I IT WOULD BE
FANTASTIC YOU JUST.
GIVE THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE
STAFF JUST THE OPPORTUNITY
REVIEW IF THERE'S AN ENORMOUS
RED FLAG.
OUR CONCERN THAT THEY HAVE THEY
CAN WORK WITH THE AUTHOR IN THE
CHAIR IN THE PROBES.
CHAIRED IT TO ADDRESS WHATEVER
[inaudible]
I'VE.
YOU HAVE WOULD HAVE LEADERS EXIT
IF THAT'S IF THAT'S OKAY WITH
FOLKS BECAUSE I I DO I I I THINK
YOUR POINTS TAKEN THIS IS
STEPHANIE TREADING INTO.
SOME EDUCATION POLICY SIDE
ISSUES AND IT WOULD BE
APPROPRIATE FOR THE STAFF AT THE
LEAST.
TAKE A REVIEW AGO I WOULD.
NO I AGREE I ED THEY WERE HAPPY
TO DO THAT.
OF IT IN HIS IS I SEE IT IN
ENOUGH CONVERSATIONS AND THANK
YOU FOR THE TIME ON ON SATURDAY
THAT WE'VE SPENT --
IT IS AND THEN IT THAT RAISE
SOME ISSUES AND WE DID MORE
RESEARCH ON OVER THE WEEKEND AND
I THINK YOU KNOW I'VE CERTAINLY
REACH TO A COMFORT LEVEL THAT
THIS.
YEAR THERE ARE ENOUGH.
THERE'S THERE'S ENOUGH I GUESS
PLANNING AND OVERSIGHT WITHIN
THE CERTAINLY WITHIN THE IP CHIT
THAT THAT.
ESTABLISHES A PROTOCOL TO FOLLOW.
A THE TWELVE VISITS FORTY FIVE
DAYS AS WE KNOW WHEN THAT WAS
CRAFTED AND CAME TOGETHER A FEW
YEARS AGO THERE WAS NO MAGIC
NUMBER WITH THAT OF THE THAT WAS
A COMPROMISE [inaudible]
CREATED. TO TO DO THAT AND SO
IT'S A YOU KNOW I'M CERTAINLY
COMFORTABLE MOVING THE BILL AND
FEEL THAT IT'S A IT'S CERTAINLY
IN THE BEST INTEREST AT LEAST
CLARIFY --
THAT THAT POTENTIAL CONFLICT
THAT I THINK DOES EXIST AND I
THINK THIS WOULD HELP THAT SO
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER HOLDEN.
THANK YOU I MISS SHARON I I
WOULD JUST SAY THAT I THINK ALL
THE POINTS HAVE BEEN MADE.
AND I THINK WE'VE.
WE'RE CERTAINLY --
APPRECIATIVE OF SOONER ALAN'S.
SUGGESTION WE DID NOT REFER THE
BILL OUT.
RULES DID AND SO WE ARE COMING
TO THE COMMITTEE THAT --
THE BILL LANDED AND I THINK WHAT
WE WERE TRYING TO DO IS
RECOGNIZE THAT IT'S NOT OUR
INTENTION OR GOAL TO REWRITE.
OF THE BILL FOR FIVE YEARS AGO
AB -- ONE
THOUSAND BUT WE DO UNDERSTAND
BASED ON HOW THINGS PLAY OUT
THAT THERE'RE SOME UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES HERE THAT WE THINK.
ISSUES THAT NEEDED TO BE
ADDRESSED THAT I THINK THAT WAS
NOT THE INTENTION.
WHEN AB ONE THOUSAND WAS --
WAS PASSED THERE WE WOULD SEE
CREATED SO.
OF WELL I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE VOTE I BELIEVE THIS IS A
GOOD FIX ON TO THE ISSUE AT HAND
AND LOOK FOR YOUR SUPPORT WE'RE
GOOD THANK YOU VERY MUCH
[inaudible] ZERO MOTION.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MOTION BY
SENATOR GALGIANI PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
QUESTION IS DO YOU PASS AT THE
MINUTE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE HELD AYE HILL AYE
FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE DODD AYE
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ AYE PAN.
WILK AYE BOOK AYE.
THE BOOK DOUBLE HAS SEVEN VOTES
WILL HOLD THE ROLLOVER FOR
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ASSEMBLYMEMBER HOME CREATED.
THE MOVE TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MCCARTY.
I REMEMBER FOURTEEN AB TWENTY
FOUR EIGHTY SEVEN GOOD AFTERNOON
GOOD EVENING.
KID THANK YOU PHILOSOPHY OF MY
WITNESSES BUT IT WILL BE OKAY.
SUPPORT SUPPORT THAT THIS IS IN
RESPONSE TO THE GROWING OPIATE
EPIDEMIC --
I'M GREAT PLEASE ANNOUNCE THEY
WORKED WITH THEIR OPPOSITION THE
ASSEMBLY AND CAME BACK WITH.
A GREAT SOLUTION DEALING WITH
CONTINUE EDUCATION.
ANSWERING THAT FRONTLINE A
DOCTORS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
TREAT --
THIS WITH THAT.
MEDICALLY ASSISTED TREATMENT
WITH ME IS OUR ARGUES THANK YOU
AND AS MENTIONED WE DO HAVE
RECOMMENDATIONS SUPPORT ON BOTH
SIDES.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS TIMID REPS
IN CALIFORNIA CHAPTER THE
MIRACLES MERCY FISSIONS WE JUST
WANNA THINK MR MCCARTY FOR
WORKING WITH US TO COME UP WITH
WE THINK IS A GOOD SOLUTION. TO
CREATE INCENTIVES FOR PHYSICIANS
TO ON TAKE EDUCATION TO HELP US
ADDRESS OUR OPIATE DEPENDENT
PATIENTS.
WITHOUT A RESPECTFULLY ASK DR
THEY COULD TO HELP OTHERS IN
SUPPORT [inaudible]
GOOD EVENING.
GOOD EVENING REMOTE COSTS LONG
CALIFORNIA Y. TERRITORY
AMERICANS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
I GOOD EVENING MISS SHARE BRED
IN MARCH WITH CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
ASSOCIATION AND THAT WE WANT TO
THANK THE AUTHOR VERY VERY MUCH
FOR WORKING WITH US ON THIS BILL.
I'M WITH THE LAST AMENDMENTS
THAT WENT INTO PRINT WE ARE NOW
NEUTRAL ON SO THANK YOU THANK
YOU WISHES THAT --
BRING IT BACK TO ANYONE ELSE IN
OPPOSITION.
WE'LL BRING IT TO THE COMMITTEE
FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS.
SCENE NINE WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
AND REMOVE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
ENTERTAIN A MOTION.
WILL BASIS SENATOR WILL PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL MISSION IS TO PASS
THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE HEALTH AYE HILL AYE
FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN AYE
ALLEN AYE DODD AYE GOD I'D
GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ AYE PAN
WILK I WILL GUIDE.
THE BILL HAS SEVEN VOTES WILL
HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY MUCH
NUMBER MCCARTY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
COOLEY.
GOOD EVENING.
WE'LL MOVE NOW TO ITEM NUMBER
FIFTEEN AB TWENTY FIVE FIFTY
FIVE AND THEN I SEE YOU HAVE.
A TWENTY FIVE NINETY SIX AS WELL
CASSIDY [inaudible]
PLEASE PROCEED.
COLLEAGUES ARE GOOD AFTERNOON
I'M HERE TODAY TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY FIVE FIFTY FIVE RELATED
TO CANNABIS PLANTAGENET I COULD
ALSO SAY THIS BILL.
IT ENJOYS A SUPPORT SUPPORT
RECOMMENDATION.
THIS BILL CLARIFIES THE STANDARD
FOR MATURE PLANET EIGHTEEN
INCHES WITH MOST RECENT
AMENDMENTS.
THIS FITS WITH WHAT HAPPENED
OTHER STATES HIGHER CHEN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
BY THE WISHES WITH WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION [inaudible]
SUPPORT.
GOOD EVENING MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS AMY JENKINS FUNDED HALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA CANNABIS
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION AND FOR RAN
MARTIN CMG KHALIFA.
I'M WE AT C. SCCA IS NOT
OFFICIALLY IN SUPPORT BUT WE ARE
PRESENTING IT TO OUR BOARD
EVERYONE I THINK THE AUTHOR FOR
WORKING WITH US TO ADDRESS OUR
CONCERNS.
AND THEN FOR CLEVELAND I'M SORRY
RAND IS NOT HERE AND THEY ARE IN
SUPPORT SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MARIN BANALITY MEDICAID AS
BUSINESS ASSOCIATION --
ISSUE QUIZ BILL I WOULD SAY IT'S
THAT IT MAKES IT EASIER FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT TO COME INTO ANY
QUOTATION SITE.
AND FIGURE OUT WHAT PAN IS LEGAL
AND WHAT IS IN LEAGUE WITH THE
UNIQUE IDENTIFIER SO.
WHY WHAT HIS BILL DOES IS WHAT I
WHICH WE DECIDED NOT TO FOLLOW
IN THE REGULATIONS SO THIS FIX
IT THANK YOU?
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION PLEASE
COME FORWARD.
SEEING NO ONE OF BRINGING IT
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE ASSEMBLY
MEMBER QUESTION AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CURRENTLY VERY MUCH.
A WE HAVE A MOTION FROM A VICE
CHAIR FULLER PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
AS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HELD
AYE AYE FULLER AYE FULLER AYE
ALLEN.
ALLEN I DIED I THOUGHT I
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
MANDA HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WELL.
LOOK I IT'S SEVEN VOTES THAT THE
BILL HAS ENOUGH BUT WILL HOLD
WILL OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
THINK REMOVING ITEM SEVENTEEN AB
TWENTY FIVE NINETY SIX THAT ALSO
ENJOYS.
IMPORTANT --
AND SUPPORT SUGGESTIONS SENT
FROM.
YEAH THIS BILL RELATES --
TO ASKED IN THE GOVERNOR'S
OFFICE TO PRESERVE SEEK TIME FOR
ALL. TO LEAD TO DEVELOP --
OR NOTE TO LEAD THE PREPARATION
OF A CALIFORNIA ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT ACTION PLAN.
I HAVE BROAD SUPPORT HERE AND
WANTED TO FOR THEM TO MAKE BRIEF
STATEMENTS TO THE COMMITTEE --
IN RECOGNITION OF THE LATE HOUR
THANK YOU VERY MUCH
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COOLEY COOPER UTV
MISTER CHAIRMAN --
I'M VERY BERMAN THE PRESIDENCY
OF THE THE RIVER SEVENTY
STATEWIDE ORGANIZATIONS THAT
WERE WORKING ON SINCE IT'S
GETTING LATE AND IT'S ALREADY IN
SUPPORT.
OF FABIA PAINFUL EXPLANATION BUT
BASICALLY IS A PLAN OPPORTUNITY
FOR THE CIVIC INSTITUTIONS OF
CALIFORNIA COME TOGETHER TO WORK
MORE CLOSELY COLLECTIVELY WHAT
THE STATE.
OF THE BILL TO POSITIVELY AND TO
IMPACT CALIFORNIA COMMUNITIES
AND FAMILIES MORE FAVORABLY
TWENTY TWO STATES OPERATE
SIMILAR TO THIS AND YOU KNOW.
WE DO HAVE A NUMBER OF STATES
THAT TARGET US COMPETITIVELY --
WE THINK A LOT OF STRONGER
EFFORT AMONG STATE PARTNERS CAN
HANDLE THAT MUCH MORE
EFFECTIVELY WE THINK THERE'S
ALSO A BETTER STORY FOR
CALIFORNIA BUSINESS CLIMATE THAN
IS.
CURRENTLY BEING TOLD AS YOU KNOW
CALIFORNIA BUSINESSES ARE THE
MOST PROFITABLE IN AMERICA.
ARE CONDOMS 33% MORE PRODUCTIVE
THAN THE U. S. AVERAGE AND
DRAMATICALLY MORE PRODUCTIVE AND
PROFITABLE IN TEXAS.
I THINK WE HAD A BETTER EFFORT
TOGETHER WE CAN TELL A GREATER
STORY FOR CALIFORNIA TO BETTER
FOR COMMUNITIES.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
CORNELIUS PERMIT THE BAY AREA
COUNCIL.
REPRESENT ALMOST THREE HUNDRED
THE TOP EMPLOYERS THE NINE
COUNTY BAY AREA REGION.
JOB CREATION HE KIND OF ON THE
CHALLENGE OF THE BAY AREA TO OUR
STATE THIS BILL HELP TO SOLVE
THAT PROBLEM WITH THAT.
RECKLESS ACTS FOR AN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE
SUPPORT.
CHAIR MEMBER CHAD WHAT HAS TO BE
A WITH THE CALIFORNIA CREDIT
UNION LEAGUE IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
HUMAN OVER STEPHEN JONES ABOUT
THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO IN STRONG
SUPPORT VERY GOOD THANK YOU VERY
MUCH MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE DAY BUTLER ON BEHALF
OF THE UNITED CHAMBER ADVOCACY
NETWORK A COALITION OF LOCAL
CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE HEARING
THAT.
SACRAMENTO MARKETPLACE AND WE
ALSO SUBMIT A LETTER ON BEHALF
OF THE INDUSTRY COALITION GROUP.
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SEAN WAS THE NATIONAL
FEDERATION OF INDEPENDENT
BUSINESS REPRESENTING SMALL
BUSINESS OWNERS AND SUPPORT ALSO
ON BEHALF THE COMPANY BUSINESS
PROPERTY ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MR TAMRAZ MORE ASSEMBLE WITH SHY
ORDER ENTRY ON BEHALF OF THE
PASSACAGLIA BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
AND SUPPORT THERE YOU THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
S. COME FORWARD.
YOU KNOW ONE BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE.
LITTLE BIT EMOTION FROM SENATOR
W. LIKE TO CLOSE CARSON AYE VOTE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
TIME ACCUSED AND REMEMBER COOLEY.
OF WE HAVE A MOTION PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
QUESTION IS DO YOU PASSED THE
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HELD AYE.
I'VE FULLER AYE FULLER AYE ALLEN.
I THOUGHT AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI.
THE AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WILL RISE BOOK
I THE BILL HAS SEVEN VOTES WILL
HOLD THE ROPE ATTRACTION MEMBERS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ARE YOU
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ASSEMBLY MEMBER WOULD.
GOOD EVENING WELCOME MOVING TO
ITEM EIGHTEEN AB.
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIRMAN
SENATORS HAVE LIKE TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE STAFF AND STAKEHOLDERS
CURRICULA BY HAVE OFFICE TO
FURTHER STRENGTHEN THIS BILL.
IN NOVEMBER TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN
VOTERS APPROVED PROJECTS BEFORE
WHICH LEGALIZED THE PURCHASING
ASSUMPTIONS OF RECREATIONAL
CANNABIS.
ALL THE CURRENT LAW AUTHORIZES
THE SALE CONSUMPTION OF
RECREATIONAL CANNABIS AT A
COUNTY FAIR DISTRICT
AGRICULTURAL VENT.
THEIR CURRENTLY ONLY RETAILER
MICRO BUSINESS LICENSEES WHO ARE
PERMITTED TO SELL DIRECTLY TO
CONSUMERS.
SMALL AND MEDIUM PRODUCERS FACE
MANY CHALLENGES IN THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR THEM TO MARKET
THEIR OWN PRODUCTS HAS PROVEN TO
BE.
BENEFICIAL TO BUILDING PERSONAL
RELATIONSHIPS WITH CONSUMERS AS
WELL AS INCREASING CONSUMER
KNOWLEDGE OF PRODUCTS ON THE
MARKET WHEN THEY DECIDE TO VISIT
RICK TRADITIONAL RETAIL SETTINGS.
HISTORICALLY PRODUCERS HAVE
PARTICIPATED IN CANNABIS EVENTS
SUCH AS THE EMERALD CUFF WHICH
IS IN MY DISTRICT.
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW THEM THE
OPPORTUNITY CONTINUE FOSTERING
THAT RELATIONSHIP WITH CONSUMERS.
AB TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE WILL
ALLOW THE BUREAU OF CANNABIS
CONTROL TO ISSUE STATE A
TEMPORARY RETAILER LICENSE TO A
SMALL LICENSE CANNABIS.
CULTIVATOR MANUFACTURED AND A
LICENSE TEMPORARY CANNABIS EVENT
THAT HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE
LOCAL JURISDICTION.
THE BILL IS ONE MORE WAY TO HELP
FURTHER INCENTIVIZE THE
PRODUCERS PARTICIPATION IN THE
REGULATED MARKET.
HERE TESTIFIED SUPPORT OUR
KIMBERLY CARGO OWNER OF A
THERAPEUTIC ALTERNATIVE HERE IN
SACRAMENTO A LICENSE RETAILER.
AND JASON BRIAN REPRESENTING THE
CALIFORNIA --
GROWERS ASSOCIATION.
I'VE MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS JASON
BROWN TO HAVE THE CALIFORNIA
GROWERS ASSOCIATION GIMLI
CARGILL TO MY LEFT --
WITH THEIR VEHICLE TURNED IT
FROM HERE IN SACRAMENTO.
THE BILL REALLY PROVIDES
OPPORTUNITIES FOR PRODUCERS TO
ESTABLISH. ONE ON ONE PERSONALRELATIONSHIPS WITH THEIR WITH
THEIR CONSUMERS --
AT TEMPORARY ADVANCED
EXCLUSIVELY AND WE TAKE A NUMBER
OF CLARIFYING THEM IS THAT WE
THINK MAKE.
TEMPORARY EVENTS IN THE RULES
GOVERNING THOSE EVENTS MUCH
STRONGER.
AND AND AND WE THINK BECAUSE
WE'VE TAKEN THOSE AMENDMENTS AND
AND AND THE EVENTS ARE WILL BE
STRONGER FOR ICENSEES.
THAT THERE'S GOOD POLICY HERE.
THAT WILL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
FOR SMALL CULTIVATORS ONLY SMALL
PRODUCERS ONLY. TO BE ABLE TO
TAKE A PARTICULAR AS OF UP TO
FOUR EVENTS PER YEAR --
TO IN ORDER TO MEET THOSE AT
CONSUMERS --
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR AS A WE
SUPPORT THE BILL AND APPRECIATE
THE THE OTHER SIDE LEADERSHIP ON
ON THE BILL NOT INTRODUCED EMILY
CARLISLE.
BUSINESS TAKEN TO HAVE THAT AS
WELL.
THE DAY THANK YOU FOR YOUR
SUPPORT ON THE SPELL.
I AM A RETAILER AND ON BEHALF OF
MANY RETAILERS ME.
AND BELIEVES THAT WHEN PATIENTS
AND CONSUMERS GO TO EVENTS ARE
ABLE TO ME BREATH THE
CULTIVATORS WITH THE
MANUFACTURERS WITH THE PRODUCER
AND MAKERS OF THESE PRODUCTS.
THEY GAIN TRUST IN THE PRODUCT
AND THEN AFTER WHICH THEY WILL
COME TO US TO PURCHASE THE
PRODUCTS IN THE FUTURE.
ON OUR INDUSTRY AT THIS TIME
NEEDS AS MUCH SUPPORTER.
SEPARATING THE LICENSE MARKET
FROM THE UNLICENSED THE
UNREGULATED FROM THE REGULATED
AND THE TAX FROM THE AND TAX
MARKET.
STYLE OF THIS PARTICULAR BILL
SUPPORTS AT TYPE OF ST INCLUDING
RETAIL THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FOR SCOTLAND I SEE OF
DISTRICTS ARE A MESS FOR KILLERS
HERE MATH OF FLOW CON I'M COULD
FRY TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE OF
THEIR QUESTIONS OF THE CONTENT
OF THE BILL.
LIKE MAKE YOU OTHER OTHERS IN
SUPPORT [inaudible]
PLEASE COME.
ALRIGHT THANK YOU.
S. CHAIRMAN DAVID JONES AGAIN UP
BY FOR THE CITY SACRAMENTO
THINKS A STRONG REGULATORY BILL
SUPPORTED GREAT THANK YOU.
THREATENING AIR NOTABLY HALF THE
CANNABIS DISTRIBUTION AS
ATTRITION ALSO INSTRUCT THE
ARCTIC YOU.
PENNY JENKINS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION STRONG SUPPORT
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
TRACY STEVENS ON BEHALF OF THE
SOLUTIONS OF STRONG SUPPORT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MATT BROUGHT
ON BEHALF OF THE TEAMSTERS IN
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
WELL ANYWAY THIS ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA CANNABIS
MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION ALSO
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
RICH BELUR MATH AMERICAN
ALLIANCE MEDICAL CANNABIS IN
SUPPORT [inaudible]
IF YOU.
ELLEN COME FROM CALIFORNIA
NORMAL SUPPORTING THE BILL THANK
YOU VERY MUCH A ANY ANYONE ELSE
IN SUPPORT.
IF THERE'S ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
GOOD AFTERNOON DRIVE DAD ABBAS
J. MEMBERS I MIGHT BE THAT I
HERE TO INTRODUCE A HAVE YOUR
MOTIVES ON BEHALF OF THE UNITED
CAMAS DISASSOCIATION.
WE HAVE OVER A HUNDRED
DISPENSARIES FROM SAYING
CALIFORNIA AND PROTECT KITCHEN
PURPOSES WHERE THERE IS A
LIMITATION.
FOR A THOUSAND SIX BY TEN
THOUSAND SQUARE FEET.
IT'S ANY INDIVIDUAL WHETHER
YOU'RE SMALL GLITTERING OR NOT
COULD OBTAIN THAT LICENSE
THERE'S NO PROVISION IN THE BILL
THAT PROTECTS.
CONSIDER A COMPANY NOW COMPETING
IN THE RETAIL SYSTEM OPTION IT
OVER TO ACT THAT I HAVE YEAR A
MOMENTOUS.
MISTER AND MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
HOW MANY MAHABIR MONTH HAS HAD
TIME TO VICE PRESIDENT OF THE
UNITED CANNABIS BUSINESS
ASSOCIATION REPRESENTING.
LEGAL RETAIL DISPENSARY IS A LOS
ANGELES SANTA ANA AND THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIA MEMBERS INCLUDE
DISTRIBUTORS MANUFACTURERS AND
CULTIVATORS.
WE OPPOSE ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY
SIX FORTY ONE AS IT WE FEEL IT
UNDERMINES RETAILERS THAT ARE
CURRENTLY STRUGGLING WITH THE
ILLEGAL MARKET AND ITS CONTINUED
PROLIFERATION.
OUR MEMBERS ARE UNION UFCW OF
ALL SIGNED LABOR PEACE
AGREEMENTS FOR SMALL BUSINESS
OWNERS THAT HAVE SPENT
SUBSTANTIAL FINANCIAL RESOURCES.
TO GET A LICENSE OUR FAMILIES
PATIENTS AND EMPLOYEES DEPEND ON
OUR BUSINESS HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL.
RETAILERS HAVE TO GO THROUGH
RIGOROUS COMPLIANCE LICENSING
AND REGULATORY COSTS TO OPERATE
LEGALLY IN THE CALIFORNIA MARKET
MOST OF US ARE TAKING ON DEBT.
AND ALSO CLIMBING OUT OF THAT
JUST TO STAY ALIVE.
THERE'S NO OTHER INDUSTRY LIKE
OURS WHERE.
THERE ARE NO ILLEGAL LIQUOR
STORES COMPETING AGAINST THE
UNDERGROUND MARKET LIKE WE LIKE
WE DO.
MORE TO YOU OF AN INDUSTRY TO
START CARVING OUT NEW LICENSE
TYPES WITHOUT REALLY KNOWING THE
FINANCIAL STRESS TO PERMANENT
RETAILERS THAT GONE THROUGH THE
RIGOROUS PROCESS TO HAVE A
RETAIL LICENSE.
THIS BILL FURTHER COMPLICATES
THE GROWTH OF LEGAL RETAIL I CAN
SEE CONSIDERATIONS AND
CONVERSATIONS HAPPENING IN A
COUPLE YEARS FROM YOU LICENSE
TYPES BUT WITHOUT A REAL
UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT ARE
REGULATED MARK YOU.
WILL DO IS PREMATURE LET'S NOT
JUMP INTO NEW CATEGORIES THAT
TAKE AWAY FROM THE ONES THAT
CURRENTLY EXISTS TODAY.
RETAIL DISPENSARY IS PLAIN
IMPORTANT PART IN THE SUPPLY
CHAIN.
THIS BILL UNDERMINES FRITO
DISPENSARIES AND WE'RE ASKING
FOR A NO VOTE AND CONTINUED
SUPPORT ON ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY
TWENTY WHICH IS ALSO IN EVENTS
BUT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
YESTERDAY HELLO MY NAME IS GERRY
CARLO ON THE PRESIDENT OF THE
CBA -- IN
THIS NEWLY REGULATED INDUSTRY
THIS IS A KNEE JERK REACTION TO
PLACE ANOTHER LICENSE TYPE IN A
SEA OF LIFE AND TH TYPES.
THERE CURRENTLY TWENTY TWO
LICENSE TYPES AVAILABLE AND
THERE ARE SUBSTANTIAL NOTICE TO
ENTER THE REGULATED CAMIS
INDUSTRY AS A RETAILER IF SO
DESIRED --
I'VE BATTLE PERSONALLY
PROFESSIONALLY FOR FOURTEEN
YEARS HAVE ACCESS TO A STATE
RETAIL LICENSE WITH CONSIDERABLE
EFFORT AT ALL LEVELS OF
GOVERNMENT.
AND HAVE BEEN A LEADER IN THE
UNITED CANVAS BUSINESS
ASSOCIATION ORGANIZES RETAILERS
IN THE STATE TO SECURE GOOD
REGULATIONS FOR A BRICK AND
MORTAR LOCATIONS.
I'VE A RETAIL TYPE TEN LICENSE
APPLE I WHICH IS FIFTY PAGES
LONG AND ALSO AN EQUALLY LONG
APPLICATION TO THE CITY OF LOS
ANGELES THAT SHOWS A SIMILAR
AMOUNT OF HISTORY.
GOOD BUSINESS PRACTICES AND
COMPLIANCE TO BE A GOOD STEWARD
FOR THIS IMPORTANT SEGMENT.
OF THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND TO BE
JUST BE APPROVED FOR RETAIL
LICENSE THAT HAVE ANOTHER
LICENSE TYPE ATTEMPT TO SKIP THE
LINE INTO POSITION HAS BEEN
CLEARLY ESTABLISHED THE
REGULATIONS.
IS PREDATORY IN PREMATURE.
WE SUPPORT AB TWENTY TWENTY A
SPECIAL EVENTS BILL THAT HAS NO
OPPOSITION KEEPS RETAILERS IN
THEIR RIGHTFUL POSITION AND
SUPPORTED INDUSTRY WIDE.
SINCE THERE IS NO DATA OR
ANALYTICS OFFERED BY THE
SUPPORTERS OF THIS BILL TO SHOW
THE ECONOMIC IMPACT THIS HAS ON
THE SMALL FARMER.
ARE ANALYSIS OF THIS BILL SHOWN
IF THAT IS NOT THE BASTION OF
HOPE FOR SMALL FARMERS HAVE BEEN
PERPETUATED BECAUSE THE COST OF
COMPLIANCE.
I'M WITH THE OPPORTUNITY FOR
REVENUE LOOKS LIKE A ZERO SUM
GAME FOR THE TEMPORARY RETAILERS
AND OF THE HEAVY LEFT FOR THE
STATE TO ADD A NEW LICENSE TYPE.
WHAT THE CONSEQUENCES ARE FOR
LACK OF COMPLIANCE FOR THIS NEW
REAL THIS RETAIL LICENSE AND FOR
TRACK AND TRACE TO IMPLEMENT
TEMPORARY CUSTODY OF RETAIL
GOODS?
WE ARE LEGISLATING A LICENSE
TYPE INTO LAW AND PICKING IT
AGAINST A MOVING TARGET FOR
REGULATIONS THAT HAVE YET TO BE
FINALIZED FOR THE INDUSTRY.
AB TWENTY TWENTY OF THE BILL
THAT KEEPS EVERYONE IN THEIR
LANE AND ALLOWS THE EXPERIENCE A
SPECIALIZED OPERATORS TO LEAD
THE INDUSTRY THROUGH A
COMPLICATED SET OF REGULATORY
HURDLES.
AND TAXES THAT WE ASK FOR NO ONE
AB TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE THANK
YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD.
MISTER FERRER I MISSED CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE AT
FIRST I WANT TO EXTEND MY
APOLOGIES TO THE AUTHOR OUR
LETTER OF OPPOSITION WAS JUST
ISSUED.
BY MY CLIENT EARLIER TODAY AND
I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF GOLDEN
SYSTEMS.
DOING BUSINESS AS SEE FOR DISTRO
ARE AND WILL ASSOCIATE OUR OUR
COMMENTS WITH THE PRIOR SPEAKERS
I THINK OUR CONCERN IS IS THAT.
UP UNTIL A TRACK AND TRACE AND
OTHER PROTECTIONS ARE IN PLACE
WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT --
FOLKS ARE ABUSING THE SYSTEM AND
OPERATING OUTSIDEPARTICULARLY
AS WE'RE GOING FROM A BLACK
MARKET MARKETPLACE TO LIGHT
MARKET MARKETPLACE.
THAT WE OUGHT TO BE PARTICULARLY
CAUTIOUS ABOUT THAT TRANSITION
THANK YOU THANK YOU MISTER
PRAYER.
YES MA'AM GOOD EVENING NOW
ARAFAT WITH THE SANTA ANA CABS
SUFFICIENT IN STRONG OPPOSITION
TO THIS MATTER THANK YOU THANK
YOU OTHERS IN OPPOSITION.
YOU KNOW AND BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS SO
PERHAPS THE MINISTER WOULD YOU
COULD.
RESPOND SUCH AS OFFERS YEAH YES
YOUR AUTHORS AMENDMENT YOU ARE
ACCEPTING.
ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS SO.
IF YOU ARE YOU KNOW [inaudible]
THERE I THINK OF IMPORTING TO
BEAR IN MIND HERE IS THAT --
THAT WE ARE EVERYBODY IN THIS IN
THIS PROCESS WILL BE LICENSE OF
THE SQUEEZING THESE WILL BE
LICENSED CULTIVATORS.
AND WE'RE TALKING ABOUT FOR
POTENTIALLY SPECIAL EVENTS A
YEAR -- I
AND I THINK A LOT OF I THINK OF
WHAT WE HEARD FROM --
FOLKS EARLIER THAT SOME OF THE
CONCERN FROM FROM --
SOME OF THE LARGER DISPENSARIES
IS IT SOME OF THEM AREN'T
VERTICALLY INTEGRATED.
MEAN THEY GROW THEIR OWN
PRODUCTS --
AND AND SELL THEIR OWN PRODUCTS
AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT FOR
THE SMALLER GUYS TO HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY I REPRESENT ON THE
LARGEST GROWING AREA IN THE
STATE --
6270% OF ALL CANNABIS IS GROWN
IN IN MY DISTRICT.
AND MOST OF THEM ARE SMALL
GROWERS AND THE ONLY
OPPORTUNITIES I BELIEVE THAT WE
HAVE TO BRING PEOPLE MORE PEOPLE
INTO COMPLIANCE IS TO GIVE THEM
AWAY. TO GET THEIR PRODUCT TO
MARKET AND SO WE ARE NOT TRYING
TO SKIP THE LINE WE ARE TRYING.
TO WE TRYING TO CUT OUT THE
BLACK MARKET.
I I YOU KNOW I I'M NOT AWARE
THAT THERE IS --
CONCERN FROM RETAILERS IN MY
DISTRICT ABOUT THIS --
IF YOU WANT TO INTRODUCE NEW
PRODUCTS TO THE MARKET HOW HOW
WAS HE GOING TO FEEL IT IN
THAT'S MY THINKING AND THIS GIRL
I MET MADE THAT THAT ARGUMENT
AND I THINK IT'S BALLOT THAT
SENATOR DODD ASIAN HERE'S A
CHAIR OF GEO BUT I THINK THERE'S
LEGISLATION LOOKING.
AROUND LOOKING AT THE SMALL
DISTILLERIES IN.
IN CALIFORNIA THAT HAVE NOT HAD
THE OPPORTUNITY WHERE THEY ARE
NOW ALLOWED TO HAVE TASTINGS AN
OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE. TO TO BE
INTRODUCED TO THEIR PRODUCTS
WHICH THEN CAN.
BRING TO THE LARGER MARKET AND
THEY COULD CERTAINLY RETAIL
THOSE IN IN THE IN A LATER DATE
SO I THINK IT'S A IT CERTAINLY
WORKS AND I THINK IT'S A GOOD
OPPORTUNITY. TO TO ENHANCE THE
THE INDUSTRY AND A AND CRTAINLY
BE BENEFICIAL TO IT SO I
CERTAINLY WOULD SUPPORT OTHER
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS OTHER
RIGID REJECTED CLOSES AND
REMEMBER WHAT I DESPITE I JUST A
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR ELBOW.
RATED THANK YOU VERY MUCH
DESERVED.
THE MOTION.
I WILL MOVE THE BILL.
MISSION IS TO PASS AS A MINUTE
OF SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE HELP AYE HILL AYE
FULLER ALLAN.
DODDS GALGIANI.
GLAZER HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ
AYE PAN WILK NO WILK NOW.
BILL HAS TO VOTE TO UPHOLD THE
RULE OPEN TRAFFIC MEMBERS THANK
YOU MISTER WOULD.
MISTER GIPSON ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON WELCOME GOOD AFTER GOOD
EVENING.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
TODAY BUT I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN
BUSY AT ANOTHER COMPUTER.
IT'S BEEN A BUSY DAY IT HAS BEEN
AYE ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN AB.
TWENTY SIX SEVENTY SIX FOUR SIX
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
OBSERVERS IS HERE MEMBERS.
AND IF YOU THINK IT'LL ALLOW ME
TO PRESENT --
LOUISVILLE TWENTY TWENTY SIX
SEVENTY SIX WHICH SEEKS.
TO ENSURE JUNK DEALERS AND
RECYCLERS HAVE A LEGITIMATE
BUSINESS LICENSE WHAT OPERATING
CALIFORNIA TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN
SB FOUR EIGHTY FIVE CREATE AN
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT. FOR
RECYCLERS WHO SUBMIT
APPLICATIONS FOR A NEW WEIGHT
MASTER LICENSE OR RENEWAL OF THE
LICENSE WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF
FOOD AND AGRICULTURE.
THESE ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS
HELP STOP UNSCRUPULOUS AND
UNCONFINED NONCOMPLIANT A
RECYCLERS I'M WITH IN THE
INDUSTRY --
AS SUCH ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY SIX
SEVENTY SIX WILL EXTEND THE
SUNSET PROVISION THAT ALLOWS THE
SUCCESSFUL PROGRAM TO CONTINUE
TO OPERATE ON IN THIS STATE WITH
ME TO PROVIDE SUPPORTING
TESTIMONY BUT TWENTY SIX SEVENTY
SIX IS MISTER RYAN FLANAGAN.
REPRESENTING THE WEST COAST --
CHAPTER OF THE INSTITUTE.
FOR AND I FEEL DIMENSION THAT
THIS DOES ENJOY SOME SUPPORT
SUPPORT ON BOTH SIDES OF THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
THAT FROM HERE MEMBERS BRIAN
FLANAGAN ON BHALF OF THE WEST
COAST CHAPTER OF THE INSTITUTE'S
CRAFT RECYCLING INDUSTRIES WHERE
THE SPONSOR THIS BILL AND WE ARE
TO SPONSOR THE PREVIOUS
LEGISLATION.
ARM THE ORIGINAL TEN THIS
LEGISLATION IS A CRACKDOWN OR
HELP CURB THE METAL THEFT ISSUE
BY CRACKING DOWN ON WE CONSIDER
ROLLED RECYCLERS THE COLOR OF
RECYCLERS THE PEOPLE THAT.
ARE SET UP SHOP THE RECYCLERS A
SET UP SHOP.
EVEN SOMETIMES RIGHT DOWN THE
STREET THEY DON'T ABIDE BY ANY
OF THE LAWS PERTAINING TO
BUSINESS LICENSE STORMWATER
PERMITS --
PAYMENT TO CUT PROPERTY AND TO
CUSTOMERS CRIMINAL BACKGROUND
CHECKS --
SUPER THIS LEGISLATION PLACE OF
THE LAST FIVE YEARS HAVE SEEN A
MARKED IMPROVEMENT.
AND CURVE IN THE MIDDLE THEFT
ISSUE ARM STILL ODDITIES ROVER
CYCLES YOU GO OUT OF BUSINESS OR
COMPLY WITH THE LAW.
THAT DEPARTMENT FOOD NAG WHO
OVERSEES THIS PROGRAM IS CALLED
A SUCCESS THEY'VE SEEN IN A
DRAMATIC IMPROVEMENTS AND
COMPLIANCE RATES AS WELL AS A
DRAMATIC DECREASE AND METALCRAFT
SO WE'RE THE ONES WHO ACTUALLY
PAY THE FEE. FOR THE S. YEAH
FACILITIES ARE FOR THIS PROGRAM
AND WE WOULD WE WANT TO SEE THIS
THINKING NEEDS TO DO TO BE
FUNDED AND BE SUCCESSFUL AND
ENSURE A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD FOR
OUR INDUSTRY SO AFTER I GOT THIS
VERY NICE TO HEAR THANK YOU VERY
MUCH MISTER FLANAGAN.
OTHERS IN SUPPORT YES THANK YOU
CATHERINE BRANDENBURG
REPRESENTING CHANCER SCALE LIKE
TO ECHO WHAT MR PLANNING AND FED.
AND LOUDLY WANNA SEE THIS
PROGRAM CONTINUE THINKING.
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE BRING IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE WORK.
MOTION WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE THEM
RESPECTFULLY ASK WHEN I THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
OF A MOTION A PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
QUESTION AS YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HELD
AYE HILL AYE FULLER.
FULLER NOW ALLEN.
DODD GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WELL
[inaudible]
WILK AYE.
BILL HAS FOUR VOTES WILL HOLD
THE RULE OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND WILL NOW
MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER TWENTY SIX
AB [inaudible]
TWENTY NINE EIGHTY AND THE
PLEASE PROCEED WITH ME PLEASE
CHECK ONE THING HERE
[inaudible]
NO.
WE HAVE SOME SUPPORT SUPPORT WE
DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER OKAY.
RELATED SEED THANK YOU VERY
LOBBYIST HERE MEMBERS THANK YOU
ALLOW ME TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY
BILL --
TWENTY NINE EIGHTY WHICH SEEKS
TO ENSURE THE LOCAL CITIES --
CAN OPERATE THERE ARE SOCIAL
EQUITY PROGRAM THE LOS ANGELES
SOCIAL EQUITY PROGRAM HAS
ADOPTED. TO ADDRESS.
THE NEGATIVE IMPACT ON COMMUNITY.
DUE TO THE WAR ON DRUGS THIS
BILL SEEKS TO REVISE THE
DEFINITION OF PREMISE TO ALLOW
TO CANNABIS LICENSE TO OCCUPY
THE SAME AREA.
THIS CHANGES NEEDED IN ORDER TO
ENSURE EQUITABLE ACCESS TO LEGAL
CANNABIS INDUSTRY AND EXPAND
OPPORTUNITIES FOR THOSE.
WHO WERE ONCE AND TARGETED?
CRIMINALS ARM IN WHAT IS NOW A
MULTI BILLION DOLLAR --
INDUSTRY WITH ME TO PROVIDE
SUPPORTING TESTIMONIES IS A
REPRESENTATIVE WAS SELF
INTRODUCED A VERY MELODIC
CANNABIS BUSINESS ASSOCIATION.
SO MARIN BEEN AND MAKE SURE I
KNOW THERE'S A LOT GOING ON
MIGHT BE NOTING A CHEMIST IT'S
ASSOCIATION IN THE CITY OF LOS
ANGELES.
I SUPPLIER OF RECEIVING A
LICENSE WERE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE
SOME LEASING SPACE TO
INDIVIDUALS THAT WERE IN THE
COMING LANCASTER IN THE WORLD
AYE THAT DRUG THE WAR ON DRUGS.
WHERE THERE ARE LOW INCOME SAID
HIS BILL ALLOWS TO PROVIDE HIM
SHARING SPACE SO WE COULD SHARE
AND SHE SAYS CAN COMMON SPACES?
OUT WE ASK FOR SUPPORT VERY GOOD
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
GOOD EVENING KIDDING RAPE ON
BEHALF OF THE LONG BEACH
COLLECTORS ASSOCIATIONS PARTLY
THINK THE OFTEN PICK YOU.
BELOW IS A MORE WITH SHIRE ANTI
ON BEHALF OF MAYOR CITY IN THE
CITY OF LOS ANGELES IN SUPPORT
WONDERFUL THANK YOU.
NEXT WEEK WAS ON BEHALF OF FLU
CON IN SUPPORT WE ALSO WANT TO
REITERATE AND SUPPORT THIS BILL
BECAUSE IT MAKES A CHANGE THAT
THAT NEEDS TO BE APPLIED ACROSS
ALL REGULATORY AUTHORITIES.
THANK YOU THANK YOUVERY MUCH
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION.
FORWARD SEE NO ONE BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS
[inaudible]
COMMENTS AND SHALL.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE IS NEVER
GOING TO HAVE TO LIVE A VERY
GOOD.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WE DO HAVE A
MOTION FROM SENATOR WILL PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
DO YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HEALTH
I I'VE FULLER.
FULLER NO ALLEN.
DODD AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN WILK.
I WILL TRY. FIVE TO ONE IT WILL
IT WILL HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU MISTER
GIPSON APPRECIATE IT.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER IRWIN WELCOME
[inaudible]
GOOD EVENING.
WE HAVE TO ITEM NUMBER.
TWENTY THREE AB.
TWENTY EIGHT EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE
PROCEED THANK YOU CHAIRMAN HELEN
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FIRST I'M
HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE AMENDMENT
YOU HAVE FEET FOR YOU.
AB TWENTY EIGHT EIGHT FOUR
PROVIDES MUCH YOU NEEDED ETHICS
THE REAL ESTATE LAW WHICH HAS
NOT BEEN UPDATED IN DECADES.
THIS -- BILL
IS THE RESULT OF MANY
STAKEHOLDER MEETINGS AND MUCH
WORK TO ENSURE THAT THE PROCESS
WAS TRANSPARENT AND THAT THE
EXISTING CONSUMER PROTECTIONS
ARE PRESERVED.
THE PRACTICE OF REAL ESTATE HAS
CHANGED CONSIDERABLY IN THE
YEARS SINCE MOST OF THE REAL
ESTATE LAW WAS ENACTED.
AT THE TIME THESE LAWS WERE
ENACTED THERE WERE NO ELECTRONIC
TRANSACTION PLATFORMS ARE E.
SIGNATURES AND THE LICENSING
DIDN'T EXIST NEW TYPES OF
BROKERAGE MODELS HAVE.
MERGED MANY LICENSING MATTERS
ARE NOW HE LICENSE THE BOARD OF
REAL ESTATE.
RATHER THAN THROUGH MAIL OF THE
BILL UPDATES AND CLARIFIES THE
LAW I APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE'S
STAFFS OF BUFFALO ANALYSIS AND
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
ON THIS BILL WITH ME TODAY IS
SUNDAY.
WIDELY MARKLEEVILLE YOU DO YOU
HAVE A MOTION THIS DISC GROUP
PLEASE PROCEED IN YOU I COULD BE
BRIEF I THINK THAT. TO ALL OF
OUR ADVANTAGE.
THANK EACH YEAR MEMBERS THAT I
WILL BE BRIEF WE ARE THE
SPONSORS OF AB TWENTY EIGHT
EIGHTY FOUR AND BELIEVE THAT FOR
THE REASONS STATED BY THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
OF IRWIN THAT THIS IS A VALUABLE
AND IMPORTANT UPDATE TO THE REAL
ESTATE LAW WE WOULD LIKE IN
PARTICULAR.
IT THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR
WORKING WITH US ON THIS BILL OF
WE BELIEVE THAT MEN AND SAID
THAT ARE BEING OFFERED.
WILL ADD FOR THEIR CLARITY AND
ADDRESS ANY OUTSTANDING CONCERNS
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I'D
VOTE YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS LET
ME KNOW VERY GOOD THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OF A ARE THERE OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION.
THE NO ONE FOR HIM BACK WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE.
PICTURE ARES PART TAKE YOU VERY
MUCH WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
SENATOR WILK PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
IF PASSED BY THE MINUTE.
I KNOW I'VE FULLER FULLER AYE
ALLEN.
O'DONNELL AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI.
I GLAZER DEMAND.
I CAN WILK.
YOU VERY MUCH SIX VOTES WILL
HOLD THE RULE OPEN FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS THANK YOU.
VERY MUCH.
IT'S A SEE CHAIR LOW.
THE CHAIRMAN OF THE GREAT
PHYSICIAN PROFESSION COMMITTEE
OF THE ASSEMBLY WELCOME GOOD
EVENING.
YOU VERY MUCH I UNDERSTAND YOU
CAN HAVE CAUSED QUITE SOME TIME
SO LOGO IS AND YOU KNOW THAT IF
I WAS.
HE SETS HIS.
IBM A LIST.
WE'LL START WITH ITEM NUMBER
THIRTY IF THAT WORKS ALRIGHT --
AT A. B..
THIRTY ONE FORTY ONE WONDERFUL
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THIS IS THE
SUNSET EXTENSION FOR THE BUREAU
OF OUR MORE PROFANITY ACTUALLY
ASK ARRIVAL.
WITH THE MOTION FROM SENATOR HER
NET WELL WE HAVE ANYONE IN
SUPPORT PLEASE COME FORWARD
[inaudible]
THE DIFFERENT.
A CHAIR MEMBERS JERRY DESMOND OF
HALF THE PROFESSIONAL FIDUCIARY
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA OF WE
WERE THE CO SPONSORS OF THE
RITUAL LEGISLATION.
WE SUPPORT OF IN THE SENSE THAT
WOULD RATHER THE PIEROGI MADE
PERMANENT BUT SUPPORT A FOUR
YEAR EXTENSION FOR THE BUREAU
IMPORTANT CONSUMER PROTECTIONS.
WE DO HAVE ONE ISSUE CONTINUE
WORK ON HOPE WE WOULD HAVE AN
OPPORTUNITY TO TALK ABOUT ONE OF
THE PROVISIONS OF THE BILL THAT
WOULD PROHIBIT A LICENSED
PROFESSIONAL FIDUCIARY FROM
CHARGING A CLIENT.
OF FOR RESPONDING TO COMPLAIN
WITH THE BUREAU WE HOPE THERE IS
ROOM FOR SOME REVISION T THAT
TO A COP. TO ACCOMMODATE A
SITUATION WHERE A FIDUCIARY IS
FOUND NOT TO BE AT FAULT NOT IS
NOT CITED REFINED OR DISCIPLINED
BY THE BUREAU.
THEY ALSO WANT TO MENTION THAT
AS PER THE A PUBLIC MEETING LAST
WEEK HELD BY THE BUREAU WE NOTE
THAT THERE IS A STRONG
ENFORCEMENT.
OF GOAL OF OBJECTIVE FOR THE
BUREAU AND THE CURRENT OF BUREAU
CHIEF OF THAT IS OF DOCUMENTED
AND CONFIRMED BY THE NUMBER BOTH
OF THE LIFE OF THE
ACCOMPLISHMENTS OF REMADE IN
ORDER TO LOWER THE NUMBER OF
COMPLAINTS.
OF THE TIME TAKES TO FINISH A
PLATE ON THE NUMBER CITATIONS AT
HER ISSUES.
AND WITH THAT WE SUPPORT THE
CONTINUATION OF THE VERY GOOD
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHERS IN
SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION.
I MEAN NO ONE WAS IN FACT WE DO
HAVE A MOTION.
FOR WHICH ARE YOU SPEAKING IN
OPPOSITION.
A BRIDGE COMPORT.
MAN CAUGHT UP WEEK.
WE'RE TRYING TO KEEP WHICH ABOUT
TWO MINUTES EACH IF THAT WORKS
OR YOU READ MY MIND THANK YOU.
THEN THE KING QUE BOTH COALITION
FOR ELDER IN DISABILITY RIGHTS.
ELDER ABUSE BY LIKE THE
PROFESSIONALS WHO DO SHRIS IS
RAMPANT.
FINANCIAL ABUSE OF BECAUSE IS ON
PEER F MISTER CHAIRMAN YEAH
JUST AS A CLARIFICATION FAR IT
WITNESSES WERE TESTIFYING THIS
IS ON AB THIRTY ONE FORTY ONE
THAT THERE ARE TWO ONE FORTY
THREE LEFT THERE ON FORTY FIVE
OKAY. FORTY FOUR FIDUCIARY HERE.
YET WE SEE YOU KNOW WHAT GUESTS
YEAH.
IT WAS AN AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR.
AS YOUR CAR DOING.
AS IF.
THAT WHEN WE CAN HANDLE VERY
GOOD WE DO HAVE A VOTE FOOTED
LIKE TO CLEAR.
SAID.
THAT'S BIZARRE RESPECTFULLY ASK
HOW YOU THINK YOU VERY MUCH OF
THE IN DEPTH.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
HERNANDEZ PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
YEAH XIN THE STEVE PASSED THE
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HEALTH I I'VE FULLER.
FULLER AYE ALLEN.
DOT.
DOT I GALGIANI OJ ANY AYE GLAZER
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN.
WELL I WILL DIE. SIX VOTE TO
UPHOLD THE RULE OPEN FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS ITEM THIRTY ONE AB
THIRTY ONE FORTY TWO PLEASE
PROCEED THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MISTER CHAIR THIS IS A B. THIRTY
ONE FORTY TWO THE ACUPUNCTURE
BOARD SUNSET.
EXTENSION AND THIS A ALSO
INCLUDE SOME TECHNICAL CHANGES.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK RIGHT GOOD
THANK YOU WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
AND THE AUTHOR MILLION FROM
COUNSEL FOR ACUPUNCTURE AND
ORIENTAL MEDICAL ASSOCIATION IS.
THAT BE YOUR UP THERE LICENSED
ACUPUNCTURISTS AND CLEANUPS
PROFESSIONAL.
WE'D LIKE TO SEE APPLE WORKERS
YOUR DISH HERE SIR.
IN THE NEXT TWO YEARS TO GET THE
FULL YEAR EXTENSION.
LETTER FROM CARE MEMBERS SEE
THAT ON TOBY APPLE COM AWAY
SIMPLE THIS BILL THANK YOU
[inaudible]
IF YOU.
THEY OWN A I THANK YOU POOR CAR
WELL.
OUR FEET TO LIVE.
I CAME FROM THE LOS ANGELES TO A
LONG WAY TO HEAR ABOUT MY JOB IS.
A STRONG SUPPORT FOR THE LOS
VEGAS THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
COMING.
PLEASE HOPING PM ACUPUNCTURE
LICENSE LAY.
AND FIRST THIS AWFUL THANK YOU.
HELLO MY NAME IS ANTHONY TO
SOLVE I'M A STUDENT OF
ACUPUNCTURE CURRENTLY.
WHAT IF THIS THANK YOU FOR
COMING TODAY APPRECIATE THAT
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT?
IS THERE ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
WE GET BCK TO THE COMMITTEE WE
DO HAVE A MOTION FROM VICE CHAIR
FULLER WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE.
YES RIGHT VOTE THANK YOU VERY
MUCH FEAR LOW AND PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL.
MOTION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HELD
AYE.
HILL AYE FULLER AYE FULLER AYE
ALAN DOT.
DOT AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ
AYE PAN WELL.
BILL HAS FIVE VOTES AND WILL
HOLD A LITTLE BEFORE AT WELL
LOCI OF SIX VOTES WITH ALL THE
RELEVANT FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER THIRTY TWO
AB.
THIRTY ONE FORTY THREE CARILLO
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR
THIS IS THE CALIFORNIA TAX
EDUCATION COUNCIL.
AND THIS TO CLOSE THE LOOPHOLE
THAT COULD POTENTIAL OUT
INDIVIDUALS TO PREPARE TAXES.
A TWO AND A PROPERLY EXEMPTS
FROM REGISTRATION AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR DR.
EDU THANK YOU HER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU AND WE'RE
TRYING TO KEEP THE TESTIMONY
[inaudible]
TO M..
THEY WERE TRYING TO LIMIT THE
TESTIMONY TO BRIEF AS POSSIBLE
TO MINUTES IS MOST PLEASE WE
CERTAINLY APPRECIATE THAT YOU
PUT ON A LONG DAY YOU HAVE AS
WELL AFTER YOU HAVE BEEN HERE
ALL DAY.
TO MY NAME IS RUTH GOT FREE AND
I ON THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF
THE CALIFORNIA TAX EDUCATION
COUNCIL.
AND I HAVE WITH ME TODAY CELESTE
HERITAGE WHO IS OUR
ADMINISTRATOR AND ALISON SIEGEL
WHO IS OUR LEGAL COUNSEL.
WE APPRECIATE THE FOR AB
OPPORTUNITY DISCUSS OUR PROGRAM
WITH YOU.
THE NINETEEN NINETY SIX LAW
CREATED THE COUNCIL TO PROTECT
THE CONSUMER IN CALIFORNIA AND
THAT HAS BEEN OUR PRIMARY GOAL
SINCE ITS INCEPTION --
CPA'S WHO ARE LICENSED BY THE
CBA ENROLLED AGENTS WHO ARE
ENROLLED THE IRS AND ATTORNEYS
WHO ARE ACTIVE MEMBERS OF THE
STATE BAR.
AND THEIR EMPLOYEES ARE EXEMPT
FROM THE LAW.
AT THE TIME OF THE TREND OF THE
CREATION OF THE COUNCIL THEY
WERE PRICE MAY TWENTY SEVEN
THOUSAND REGISTERED TAX
PREPARERS IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY BE REGISTER
ANNUALLY ABOUT.
FORTY THOUSAND CALIFORNIA
REGISTER TAX REPAIRS REQUIRED TO
TAKE AN INITIAL SIXTY HOURS OF
QUALIFYING IN.
AN ADDITIONAL TWENTY HOURS EACH
YEAR TO CONTINUE THEIR AND ROMAN
AND THEY ALSO HAVE. TO FIVE IF I
FELT DOLLARS PURITY BY
[inaudible]
UBER.
SEE TECH ALSO OVERSEES PROVIDERS
AS WELL AS PREPARERS AND
REQUIRES THAT THEIR TAX
EDUCATION PROGRAMS I GO THROUGH
AN EXTENSIVE REVIEW PROCESS.
WE HAVE APPROXIMATELY REPROVE
SCHOOLS THAT OFFER BOTH CLASS
AND WHY IN PERSON AND ONLINE
CLASSES ENCOMPASSING BOTH.
BEGINNING QUALIFYING AND
CONTINUING EDUCATION.
MEASURE BY ANY YARDSTICK SEE
TECH HAS BEEN IMMENSELY
SUCCESSFUL.
IT RARELY RECEIVES COMPLAINTS
ABOUT REGISTER TAX REPAIRS AND
IS A MODEL OF PROCESSING
EFFICIENCY.
READ YOU REGISTRATION FEE FOR
ATTACKS REPAIRS ONLY THIRTY
THREE DOLLARS TAX REPAIRS CAN
REALLY BECAME BEGIN REPAIRING
THREE TURNS AFTER COMPLETING
THEIR ONLINE REGISTRATION
PROCESS ONCE THEY'VE COMPLETED
THEIR REQUIRED EDUCATION.
WE'RE CONCERNED THAT THE
AMENDMENTS --
FOR THE LAW WILL INCREASE OUR
FEES LINFEN PROCESSING TIMES AND
THEREFORE MAY CREATE A BARRIER
TO THE ENTRY INTO THE TAX
PROCESSING TAX PREPARATION FIELD.
WE PARTNER WITH THE CALIFORNIA
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD.
WHOSE FRAUD UNITS ARE OUT IN THE
FIELD IDENTIFYING AND INCITING
ILLEGAL PREPARES REQUIRING THEM
TO REGISTER RECEIPT TECH.
ALL PENALTIES THAT THEY COLLECT
GO INTO THE GENERAL FUND OF THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
IN CLOSING I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
THE COMMITTEE FOR WORKING WITH
US ON THE PROPOSEDAMENDMENTS
WOULD LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
IN THAT DIALOGUE AND WILL COOPER
TO CULMINATE IN FURTHER
PROTECTION FOR THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA CONSUMER.
DO YOU THINK IF YOU ARE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS LEGISLATION VERY
GOOD THANK YOU.
MA'AM WHICH I THINK TO STEP AYE
OTHERS DIRECTOR OF SOME EL ALSO
IN SUPPORT OF THE LEGISLATION
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR COMING
THIS EVENING APPRECIATE THAT
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
PLEASE I SOLANO RACE DIRECTOR OF
STATE LOCAL POLICY WITH
PROSPERITY NOWTHEY'D LIKE TO
THANK AND THE MEMBERS IN A CHAIR
FOR THESE AMENDMENTS AND WE
FULLY SUPPORT.
REALLY THANK YOU.
ON A HASSELBLAD WITH UNITED WAYS
OF CALIFORNIA AYE WE ALSO --
ARE IN A SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
WITH AS AMENDED APPRECIATE THE
WORK OF THE COMMITTEE AND STAFF
ON ON THOSE AMENDMENTS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OTHER
OPPOSITION [inaudible]
ANOTHER SUPPORT.
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION.
BRING IT BACK. TO THE COMMITTEE
[inaudible]
OF SENATOR FULL ANOTHER I'D
APPRECIATE THE THE INTENT.
AND I JUST HAVE ONE CONCERN AND
THAT IS THAT THE BACKGROUND
CHECKS THAT WOULD NOT BE
DUPLICITOUS.
SO I'M HOPE THAT'LL CONTINUE
WORK BUT I'D LIKE TO SEE THE
MOVIE DOUBLE FORWARD SO I'LL
JUST BE STAYING OFF TODAY
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
I THINK YOU WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
HAIRLIKE.
BURGER THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF
THEIR MOTION.
THE GOOD MOTION BY SENATOR
GALGIANI PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
THAT MISSION IS TO PASS THE
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
HILL AYE HILL AYE FULLER
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
DODD.
I THOUGHT I GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AYE
AND I WILL AND I WILL DIE
[inaudible] SEVEN WAVES IT IS
SEVEN VOTES WILL HOLD WILL OPEN
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU
VERY MUCH --
MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER THIRTY
THREE SPK AB THIRTY ONE FORTY
FOUR THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
CHAIR MEMBERS THIS IS THE
PROFESSIONAL FINISHER IS BUREAU.
SUNSET AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AYE VOTE VERY GOOD THANK YOU.
THOSE IN SUPPORT.
HI MY NAME IS JULIA BISHOP I'M
THE ASSISTANT DEPUTY DIRECTOR
FOR LEGISLATION THAT DEPARTMENT
OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS WELL THE
DEPARTMENT DOESN'T HAVE A
POSITION ON THE BILL WE'RE HERE
FOR ANY TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.
THREE THANK YOU.
BUT JERRY DOESN'T AGAIN ON AB
THREE ONE FOUR FOUR FOR THE
REASONS STATED THE PREFECTS
SUPPORTS THE CONTINUATION OF THE
BUREAU HOPES FOR A CHANCE TO
DISCUSS THE ISSUE OF FOUGHT
CHARGING CLIENTS IN THE STATE'S
IN SITUATIONS WHERE WE'RE NOT
FOUND AT FAULT.
SUPPORT THE EFFORTS ARE BEING
MADE TO INCREASE ENFORCEMENT BY
THE BUREAU TODAY.
A GOOD THANK YOU.
OF ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE HERE IN
OPPOSITION PLEASE COME FORWARD
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU AGAIN NOT A THANK YOU
FOR PLEASE PROCEED.
LINDA KING QUE COALITION FOR
OLDER AND DISABILITY RIGHTS.
ELDER ABUSE BY LIKE A
PROFESSIONAL FISHERIES IS
RAMPANT FINANCIAL ABUSE OF
CONSERVATIVES IS THE NORM.
ISOLATION ABUSE AND FALSE
IMPRISONMENT ARE ALSO COMMON ALL
ARE VIOLATIONS OF PENAL CODE.
THREE SIXTY EIGHT AND TWO
THOUSAND SEVENTEEN WE REPORT OF
THREE CASES OF ISOLATION ABUSE
AND FALSE IMPRISONMENT
PERPETRATED BY LIFE OF
PROFESSIONAL FIDUCIARY.
PATTY COONEY IN MONTEREY COUNTY.
THESE ARE JUST THREE OF OUR
COMPLAINTS WE SUBMITTED THERE
ARE MANY MORE.
IN EACH CASE THE PROFESSIONAL
PETITIONS BUREAU FOUND NO
VIOLATION OF THE RULES.
WE OPPOSE CONTINUING THE PSP IN
ITS CURRENT FORM.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH USER QUICKER
CALHOUN CEDAR I DID PASS OUT MY
LIST OF REQUESTS FOR CHANGES.
PFD IS OUT OF CONTROL AND
CALIFORNIA'S WOULD BE BETTER OFF
WITHOUT IT THAN WITH IT.
IF YOU LOOK AT MY FIRST REQUEST
IS SIMPLY TO REQUEST THAT THE
PROFESSIONAL FIDUCIARY KING
NEVER CLAIM THAT VIOLATED THE
LAW IS IN BETTER INTEREST OF
THEIR CONSERVATIVELY AND NOT
VIOLATING THE LAW AND THAT'S
WHAT THEY'RE CURRENTLY DOING.
THEY'RE SAYING THAT ISOLATING
THE CONSERVATIVELY AND THROWING
AWAY THE KEY AND ALLOWING NO ONE
TO VISIT THAT CONSERVATIVELY IS
IN THAT CONSERVATIVES BEST
INTERESTS WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT
IS TRUE.
WITHOUT WE SOLVE THAT PROBLEM
BACK IN.
NINETEEN I'M SORRY NIGHT
NINETEEN IN.
TWO THOUSAND INSTEAD THE
FIDUCIARY TO AN UP AND DOWN THE
CENTRAL VALLEY AND TAUGHT
TRAINING CLASSES ON HOW TO
SURVIVE CONSERVATORSHIP AFTER AB.
NINE THIRTY SEVEN THEY DO THAT
BY USING TEMPORARY RESTRAINING
ORDERS AND THEN THEY DELAY
HEARING AFTER HEARING AFTER
HEARING AND KEEP THE PERSON OUT.
THE NEXT.
ONE BILL DENY RENEWAL IF THE
APPROPRIATE MISLEADS THE COURT.
WE HAVE TURNED AND CONFLICTING
SWORN TESTIMONY BY ONE PRO FADE
WHEN HE SAID SOMETHING HAPPENED
IN ONE HEARING ANOTHER HEARING
WHERE THEY TRY TO GET A
RESTRAINING ORDER AGAINST A
DIFFERENT PERSON THEY SAID THAT
OTHER PERSON DID.
LIMITED BOTH TRANSCRIPTS THE PFD
AND THEY SAID NO VIOLATION
AGAINST A LICENSING OCCURRED.
THIRD ONE IF THEY ISOLATE
SOMEONE IN VIOLATION OF WELFARE
INSTITUTIONS CODE AND IN
VIOLATION PROBATE CODE THEN
THERE NO LICENSE SHOULD NOT BE
RENEWED.
THOSE ARE STANDARD LAWS THAT ARE
ALREADY ON THE BOOKS WERE JUST
ASKING THAT THEY FOLLOW THE
CURRENT LAW THAT'S ALL WE'RE
ASKING.
FOR THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE
FOR THE TESTIMONY WOULD YOU HAVE
YOUR YOUR COMMENTS HERE AND AND
WE WILL CERTAINLY LOOK AT THEM
AND AND REVIEW THEM AFTERWARDS
THE HEALTH THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
FOR THAT OTHERS IN OPPOSITION.
SEE KNOW --
ONE PRINA BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
QUESTION COME WHICH WE HAVE A
MOTION FROM SENATOR GLAZIER --
CHAIR LOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE AT THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND
I ALSO RESPECT HARASSMENT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THAT
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SINCE YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE HEALTH
AYE HILL AYE FULLER AYE FULLER
AYE ALLEN [inaudible]
DODD.
DODD AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AYE
AND AYE WILK AYE WILK AYE.
BILL IS A LITTLE HOLD RULED IN
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS AND GET ONE
MORE ITEM THIRTY SIX AJ ARE.
TWENTY SEVEN WHICH RECEIVING
DIRECT MR AND I THINK AND BUT
PERHAPS MIGHT HAVE TWO LEFT
THERE HOPEFULLY YOU SEE THAT ON
THEIR FALLEN NUMBER THIRTY FIVE
AND THIRTY SIX OVER.
THE KANSAS OMNIPOTENCE THIRTY
FIVE WAS IRAQ THAT OKAY THIRTY
ONE THIRTY FIVE RUN CONSENT THAT
WOULD JUST BE QUICK WITH THIS
WATER INTO WHICH IS --
ENSURING THAT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA MAKES A CLEAR
STATEMENTS ARE TURNING GENERAL
JEFF SESSIONS [inaudible]
ON RISK.
CALIFORNIA'S POSITION WITH UPS
AND ON CANNABIS RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR A VOTE.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU WITNESSES
SUPPORT.
OF A PR TWENTY SEVEN S. AMY
JENKINS ON BEHALF OF THAT
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
WELL HE GAVE US ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS
MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION ALSO
IN STRONG SUPPORTER YOU THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
CLEANUP ON BEHALF OF WE DROP
CANNABIS SLAVERY IN THE LONG
BEACH COLLECTIVES ASSOCIATION IN
STRONG SUPPORT WE GIVE.
DAYS OF OUR CALIFORNIA GROWERS
ASSOCIATION.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
TRACY STEVENS ON BEHALF OF EASE
ENSIGN EVEN SUPPORT THE THANK
YOU.
PARENTS ARE WHAT ABOUT THE
CANNABIS DISTRIBUTION
ASSOCIATION AS OURS.
VERY GOOD THANK YOU AND ANYONE
ELSE IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
CHRISTINE NO ONE GAVE BACK.
THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY QUESTIONS
COMMENTS CONCERNS.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
GLAZIER.
CARE LOVE YOU VERY MUCH FOR
PATIENTS COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND
MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU VERY MUCH
I THINK YOU MUCH REVIEW THE GOOD
LEGISLATION.
A PEACEFUL WORLD PRECIOUS TO
PASS THE SENATE FLOOR HILL AYE
HILL AYE FULLER [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
DODD.
I THOUGHT I GALGIANI GALGIANI
AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE PAN AND I AND I
WILL -- BOOK
I SEVEN VOTES WILL HOLD A
ROLLOVER FRACTION MEMBERS THANK
YOU AGAIN MISTER CHAIR
APPRECIATED.
WIENER TO ASSEMBLYMEMBER LEVINE
[inaudible]
WELCOME [inaudible]
GOOD EVENING.
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY FIVE AB.
TWENTY NINE SIXTY EIGHT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR --
THIS BILL UPDATES REQUIREMENTS
FOR DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER
AFFAIRS INFORMATION BROCHURE FOR
VICTIMS OF PSYCHOTHERAPIST
PATIENT SEXUAL CONTACT.
AND ADVOCATES FOR THOSE VICTIMS
WITH ME TODAY IS THE CHAIR OF
THE CALIFORNIA BORDER PSYCHOLOGY
DOCTOR MICHAEL ERICKSON THEY'RE
GOOD THANK YOU.
SEVERITY.
HELLO WELL CHAIRMAN HILL VICE
CHAIRMAN FULLER AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS SO I'M DOCTOR MICHAEL
ERICKSON I'M HERE ON BEHALF OF
THE BOARD OF PSYCHOLOGY --
TO REQUEST YOUR SUPPORT FOR AB
TWENTY NINE SIXTY EIGHT OUR
MISSION IS TO ADVANCE QUALITY
PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES FOR
CALIFORNIANS.
BY ENSURING ETHICAL AND LEGAL
PRACTICE BY LICENSED
PSYCHOLOGIST WITH THE ULTIMATE
GOAL OF CONSUMER PROTECTION.
BASICALLY THIS BILL WOULD.
PROVIDE THE STATUTORY CHANGE
THAT WOULD ALLOW THIS BROCHURE
TO BE UPDATED. TO TAKE INTO
ACCOUNT TECHNOLOGICAL AND SOCIAL
MEDIA CHANGES THAT HAVE TAKEN
PLACE IN RECENT YEARS.
HOUSE BACKGROUND THE BOARD HAS
WORKED --
I'M NOT ONLY WITH ASSEMBLYMAN
LEVINE BUT BUT THE CALIFORNIA
MEDICAL BOARD THE OSTEOPATHIC.
SUPPORTED BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
AND SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS TO
DEVELOP A PROPOSED LANGUAGE FOR
THE NEW BROCHURE.
IT WOULD DO THREE THINGS AT
LEAST REMOVE OBSOLETE LANGUAGE.
SECONDLY I IT WOULD INCLUDE
OTHER RECOGNIZED FORMS OF SEXUAL
EXPLOITATION AND BEHAVIOR
FACILITATED BY MODERN
COMMUNICATIONS.
AND THIRDLY WOULD CLEARLY
ARTICULATE TO CONSUMERS.
THE MOST EFFECTIVE COURSE OF
ACTION WHEN REPORTING THESE
TYPES OF ALLEGATIONS ALSO A NEW
THRESHOLD FOR REPORTING.
THE BOARD THANKS EACH OF YOU FOR
YOUR THOUGHTFUL CONSIDERATION
AND WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST A I
BOTH TRIGGER THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
PLEASE COME FORWARD.
WAS AND HOW THOSE REPRESENTING
THE BORDER BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
WE WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE BOARD
OF PSYCHOLOGY FOR LEADING THIS
EFFORT.
WE FEEL THAT THIS UP AMENDMENTS
MISSPELLED TAKE IMPORTANT STEPS
TOWARD MODERNIZING THE STATUTE
AND WE ARE IN SUPPORT PERIOD
THANK YOU OTHERS IN SUPPORT
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION.
SEEN KNOWN BRING IT BACK TO THE
VILLAGE WHICH WE HAVE A MOTION
FROM SENATOR DODD WOULD LIKE TO
CLOSE.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER LIVING I JUST
WANNA SAY THANK YOU TO THE
COMMITTEE AS WELL AS TO
COMMITTEE CONSULTANT MISS
PADANIA WHO'S ANALYSIS SUMMARY I
READ AS MY PRESENTATION JUST NOW
IF IF IT WAS SO GOOD I JUST
THOUGHT I'M GONNA READ THAT --
LIKE IT THANK YOU IT'S GOOD
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE
MOTION FROM SENATOR DODD PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
TENNESSEE PASSED THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS THE HEALTH AYE
HILL AYE FULLER AYE FULLER AYE
ALLEN.
DODD AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE PAN.
AND I WILL WILK AYE.
BILL HAS A VOTES WILL HOLD THE
ROLL OVER FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS
THANK YOU VERY MUCH APPRECIATED.
MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER TWENTY
EIGHT ASSEMBLY MEMBER COOPER A.
B. THIRTY SIXTY NINE IN THIS
BILL DOES ENJOY THE SUPPORT.
OF RECOMMENDATIONS FROM.
BOTH SIDES OF THE AISLE SO
PLEASE PRISSY THAT MISTER
CHAIRMAN FIRST CURRENT
REGULATIONS MAKE IT DIFFICULT
FOR THE GOVERNMENT AGENCIES TOLD
CANNABIS.
INFORMATIONAL EDUCATIONAL
TRAINING EVENTS FOR STAFF THE
CORPORATE POLICIES PART OF THE
INSTRUCTION.
AB THIRTY SIXTY NINE WOULD MAKE
SOME EXEMPTIONS FOR GOVERNMENT
AGENCIES THE HEALTH CHEMISTRY
AND PUBLIC AND PRIVATE EDUCATION
USED PRODUCTS TO TRAIN THEIR
EMPLOYEES.
AB THREE SIXTEEN I WILL REQUIRES
TRAINING MUST BE HELD FOR
EDUCATIONAL OR INFORMATIONAL
PURPOSES.
CIVIC CANNOT BE ACCESSIBLE THE
PUBLIC.
BILL PROHIBITS THE SALE
CONSUMPTION PROVIDING CANNABIS
STEP OF THE EVENT I DO ACCEPT
YEARS AMENDMENTS.
WE REALLY PLAYED WITH WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
READY OR NOW AN EVENING GOOD
EVENING MELANIE GRIFFITH AT THE
CANTON OCCURS COMPANY ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA CANNABIS
MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION THE
SPONSORS OF THE MEASURE.
AND THE USE OF THE AUTHOR INTO
THE COMMITTEE FOR WORKING ON
THESE MOMENTS WE FEEL LIKE IT
HAS ACTUALLY IMPROVE THE BILL
FROM ITS STARTING PLACE.
AND JUST A LITTLE HISTORY VERY
QUICKLY LAST YEAR WE HELD AN
EDUCATIONAL EVENT HERE AT THE
CAPITOL WHERE OUR BOARD MEMBERS
CEOS OF MANUFACTURING COMPANIES
BROUGHT AN ACTUAL PRODUCTS AND
PARAPHERNALIA.
AND HOSTED AN EDUCATIONAL ABOUT
IT IT WAS VERY VERY WELL
ATTENDED.
AND SEVERAL STAFFERS AND MEMBER
FIRST TIME THAT THEY HAD SEEN A
PRODUCT IN PERSON OR INTERACTED
WITH A CANNABIS INDUSTRY
PROFESSIONAL AND SO WE REALIZE
THE IMPORTANCE OF THESE A
EDUCATIONAL EVENTS AT THAT
MOMENT.
THIS YEAR WE SET OUT TO HOST
ANOTHER EDUCATIONAL AND ONLY TO
FIND THAT THE LAW WAS VERY VAGUE
AND OUR INTERPRETATION WAS THAT
THIS TYPE OF THAT WAS IN FACT
ILLEGAL.
AND WE THINK THAT IT'S VERY
IMPORTANT THAT THESE EVENTS
CONTINUE TO BE HOSTED FOR FOLKS
LIKE YOU FANDOM WE HOPE THAT WE
HAVE YOUR SUPPORT.
REVIEW THANK YOU KNOW AMY
JENKINS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION WE WERE PART OF THE
EVENT LAST YEAR T AGAIN
ATTEMPTED TO HOST AN EVENT THIS
YEAR FOUND.
THAT -- THE
INFORMATION WAS INVALUABLE FROM
MEMBERS AND SO WE WANNA I WANNA
ECHO THE COMMENTS MADE BY MY
COLLEAGUE AND MELANIE CUEVAS AND
WE URGE SURE YOU'RE STRONG
SUPPORT TODAY BEFORE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT
PLEASE.
I KATIE MADE BOBBY HAVE A WE
DROP CANNABIS LIVER ENZYMES
SUPPORT THINKING IF YOU.
TRACY STEVENS ON BEHALF OF WHEAT
MAPS EXCUSE ME.
ON BEHALF OF THE SOLUTIONS.
I DON'T KNOW WHO I AM TWENTY
ANSONIA THANK YOU VERY MUCH
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
OTHER SUPPORT.
MORE INTERNET ON BEHALF OF THE
UNITED CAN AS IN THIS
ASSOCIATION SUPPORT VERY GOOD
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT IS THERE
ANYONE HERE IN OPPOSITION.
YOU KNOW WHAT BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE [inaudible] FOR
VERY GOOD WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COOPER WE HAVE A
MOTION FROM SENATOR GLAZER
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
MISTY PASS AS AMENDED THE SENATE
FLOOR HILL.
AYE HILL AYE FULLER AYE FULLER
AYE ALLEN.
DODD.
I THOUGHT I GALGIANI GALGIANI
AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ
AYE.
HERNANDEZ I CAN I CAN I WILL.
WILL. EIGHT A BILL WHICH WILL
HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH ASSEMBLY MEMBER COOPER
APPRECIATE THAT CONCLUDES.
OUR BILL.
HEARING PORTION WHO WILL BACK IN
THROUGH THE VOTES ON OUR BILLS
[inaudible]
MANY OR TO LEARN.
I THINK I'M HERE [inaudible]
SELECT.
PERFECT.
LETTERS AWESTRUCK WITH WHAT.
AND WHEN.
IS WHAT I'M TO THE BUT I DON'T
KNOW THAT.
DOWN THE LIST.
THIS ACTION WITH.
WE'LL START WITH ITEM NUMBER ONE
AND CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS A.
B. THREE FORTY SEVEN PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
THE PATH.
IN A STEEP PATH SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
VOTES.
THREE TWO ZERO HILL AYE.
HILL AYE ALLEN.
DODD I GOT I GALGIANI GALGIANI
AYE GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE AND I AND I EIGHT
ZERO WILL HOLD THE ROLE OPEN FOR
THE ABSENT MEMBERS --
I REMEMBER.
FOR A AB NINE TWENTY FOUR
PEACEFULLY ABSENT MEMBERS.
MISSION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
GOVERNMENT THE FINANCE COMMITTEE
KERN VOTES [inaudible]
FOR TWO ZERO FULLER [inaudible]
ALAN.
DODD WHY DON I GLAZER.
GLAZER I AND I AND I SEVEN
LETTERS.
SEVEN WILL HOLD THE RULE OPEN
FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
I REMEMBER SEVEN A AB TWENTY
TWENTY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
SAYS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
BOATS THREE TWO ZERO COLOR
[inaudible]
ALLEN FULLER [inaudible]
FULLER NOW [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
DODD -- NOT
AYE GALGIANI.
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE.
AND I CANNOT. SEVEN ONE WILL
HOLD WILL OPEN FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
I REMEMBER EIGHT AB TWENTY
THIRTY SEVEN PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS MISSION IS TO
PASS THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTES. TWO
ZERO HEALTH AYE HILL AYE ALLEN.
DODD AYE DODD AYE.
GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE GLAZER
MAYES ARE AYE PAN AYE
[inaudible]
AND I IT IS A VOTE TROUBLED ROLE
OPEN FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS --
TENNIS I REMEMBER TEN AB TWENTY
TWO FIFTEEN PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
MOTION AS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
CURRENT VOTES THREE TWO ZERO
HILL AYE HILL AYE ALLEN.
DODD AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
LASER AYE AND I CAN'T I BILL IS
A BILL WHICH WILL HOLD THE ROLE
PERHAPS IN MEMBER ITEM NUMBER.
ELEVEN PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS MACHINIST YOU PASS OF
THE MEDICINE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CURRENT.
THREE TWO ZERO HILL AYE HILL AYE
ALAN.
DOT AYE THOUGHT AYE GALGIANI
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
IS ARE AYE PAN AYE AYE AND I AND
BOOTS THAT WILL HOLD A LITTLE
CONTRAPTION MEMBERS THERE AS
WELL.
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE AB TWENTY
FOUR TWENTY THREE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS MISSION IS TO
PASS AS AMENDED TO SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
VOTE.
SEVEN TO ZERO GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE PAN.
I I AND I IT HAS ITS OUT NINE
VOTES.
IT'S OUT MOVING [inaudible]
TO ITEM [inaudible] FOURTEEN AB
TWENTY FOUR EIGHTY SEVEN PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
SPECIALISTS YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
ROBERT SEVEN ZERO LASER.
GLAZER AYE PAN. EIGHT ZERO
THAT'S OUT.
OF I REMEMBER FIFTEEN AB TWENTY
FIVE FIFTY FIVE WHICH WILL HAVE
TO MEMBERS.
XIN ISSUE PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CRANK
OUT SEVEN ZERO LASER.
GLAZER AYE PAN.
THE BILL HAS NINE VOTES IT IS
OUT.
I REMEMBER SEVENTEEN AB TWENTY
FIVE NINETY SIX PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS MISSION IS TO
PASS THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTE.
SEVEN ZERO LASER.
IS ARE AYE PAN AYE AND I NINE
ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT. EIGHTEEN
BUT I REMEMBER EIGHTEEN AB
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
MISSION ENERGY PASS AS AMENDED
TO SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CURRENT VOTES.
TWO TO ONE FULLER.
FULLER NOW ALLEN.
DODD AYE DODD AYE GALGIANI
[inaudible]
GLAZER [inaudible]
AND AND I NIELSEN.
OKAY HOLD HER THAT BILL HAS FOUR
VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLE OPEN
FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS --
MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER
NINETEEN AB TWENTY SIX SEVENTY
SIX PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
IT HAS TO PASS THIS ON
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
VOTES [inaudible]
FOR TWO ONE ALAN [inaudible]
DODD ALRIGHT DOT I LASER.
GLAZER I AND MY AND I FULLER.
FULLER NO TE I EIGHT ZERO WILL
HOLD THE ROOM OPEN FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
WE NOW.
TO I REMEMBER.
TWENTY THREE AB TWENTY EIGHT
EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
FRANK ABOUT [inaudible]
SIX ZERO ALAN [inaudible]
GLAZER.
GLAZER I CAN I CAN I BILL IS A
VOTE TO UPHOLD THE RULE PREFER
ABSENT THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
MOVING.
TO ITEM NUMBER. TWENTY FOUR AB
TWENTY EIGHT NINETY NINE PLEASE
CALL THE AFTER MEMBER.
S. HAS TO PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CREDIT
VOTES FOR TWO ZERO ALLEN.
DODD.
DODD AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE PAN AYE AYE
[inaudible]
AND I EIGHT VOTES WILL HOLD THE
ROLE OPEN FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
TWENTY FIVE AB TWENTY NINE SIXTY
EIGHT PLEASE CALL YES A MEMBER
MACHINIST YOU PASS AND
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
THAT'S A TWO ZERO ALLAN.
HOLD THE RULER OPEN FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBER.
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY SIX AB.
TWENTY NINE EIGHTY USUALLY
ABSENT MEMBERS NATIONALISTIC
PASSES SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CURRENT THAT'S FIVE TO
ONE ALAN [inaudible]
GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE AND AND I BILL IS
SEVEN VOTES WILL HOLD THE ROLE
OPEN FOR THE ABSENT MEMBER.
I REMEMBER TWENTY SEVEN HE BE
TWENTY NINE NINETY EIGHT PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
SHE HAS TO PASS AS A MEDICINE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CURRENT
VOTES.
ONE TO TWO HILL AYE HILL AYE
[inaudible]
ALAN.
DODD.
DOT AYE GALGIANI GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER.
GLAZER I AND I AND I SEVEN VOTES
WILL HOLD THE ROLE WILL PREFER
THE OPTION MEMBER [inaudible]
THIRTY BUT AND NUMBER THIRTY AB
THIRTY ONE FORTY ONE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS FASCIST YOU
PASS THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE CONVERT SIX ZERO ALAN
[inaudible]
GLAZER.
GLAZER AYE PAN [inaudible]
AND I BILL HAS EIGHT VOTES WILL
HOLD WILL OPEN FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
A ITEM NUMBER THIRTY ONE A. B.
THIRTY ONE FORTY TWO PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
AS YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE KERN
VETS ZERO ALAN.
LASER GLAZER AYE PAN
[inaudible]
AND I THE IT ZERO THAT IT WILL
HOLD WILL OPEN FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
THEIR ITEM NUMBER THIRTY TWO A.
B. THIRTY ONE FORTY THREE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
SPECIALIST YOU PASS THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE CRAP
ABOUT THE SEVEN ZERO FULLER
[inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
WILL [inaudible]
ISSUE.
IF YOU DID.
A LITTLE THERE WILL OPEN FOR
ABSENT MEMBERS AND THIRTY THREE
B..
THIRTY ONE FORTY FOUR THAT'S
STILL WAITING FIRST SENATOR
ALLEN TO COME BACK.
I REMEMBER [inaudible]
JAKE WAS [inaudible] THIRTY FOUR
THAT WAS CONSENT.
SO NOW GOOD IF THE ITEM NUMBER.
THIRTY SIX PAGE A OUR TWENTY
SEVEN PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
FULLER ALLEN. SEVEN WILL HOLD
THAT RULE OVER FOR A FEW MEMBERS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR EVERYONE
YES [inaudible]
CAN.
YOU VOTED AYE.
WE TWENTY ONE TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN
YEARS [inaudible]
RAW
[inaudible]
YEAH [inaudible]
RENDON.
BUT WE WILL RECONVENE THE
BUSINESS OF PROFESSIONS
COMMITTEE.
A AND CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ON
ITEM NUMBER.
ONE AB THREE FORTY SEVEN PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS AND VOTE
EIGHT ZERO ALAN [inaudible]
ALLEN I THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM
NUMBER FOUR EP NINE TWENTY FOUR
PLEASE CALL THE AFTER MEMBER.
THAT'S SEVEN ZERO ALLEN.
ALLEN I EIGHT ZERO THAT VILLAGE
OUT ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB TWENTY
TWENTY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible] EIGHT ONE THAT
GOES OUT ITEM NUMBER EIGHT AB
TWENTY THIRTY SEVEN PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN.
ALLEN NINE NINE ZERO THAT BILL
IS OUT ITEM NUMBER TEN AB TWENTY
TWO FIFTEEN WHICH WELL AFTER
MEMBER ALAN. TWENTY TWO FIFTEEN
ITEM [inaudible]
TEN ALLEN.
THE BILL IS OUT.
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN AB TWENTY TWO
TWENTY ONE PLEASE FOR THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible] ZERO ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT [inaudible]
ITEM NUMBER [inaudible]
THE LIKENESS [inaudible]
I REMEMBER [inaudible] EIGHTEEN
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE KERN VOTERS
OR YOU [inaudible]
ALLEN.
HER ITEM RIVER AT NIGHT --
WILL BE THE ROLE OPEN ON THAT
BILL ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN AB
TWENTY SIX SEVENTY SIX WHICH
WILL HAVE TO MEMBER.
WAY A NINETEEN NINETEEN ALLEN.
ALLEN AYE NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT.
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY THREE AB
TWENTY EIGHT EIGHTY FOUR PLEASE
CALL THE AFTER MEMBER ALLEN.
ALLEN I NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT.
I AM TWENTY FOUR AB TWENTY EIGHT
NINETY NINE FISCALLY AFTER
MEMBER [inaudible]
ALLEN [inaudible]
ALLEN I NINE ZERO THAT VILLAGE
OUT.
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY FIVE AB
TWENTY NINE SIXTY EIGHT PLEASE
CALL THE AFTER MEMBER ALAN
[inaudible]
ALLEN I NINE ZERO THAT BILL WAS
OUT ITEM NUMBER TWENTY SIX AB
TWENTY NINE EIGHTY PLEASE CALL
THE EFFORT MEMBER.
BEEN TO ONE ALLEN.
ALAN HI EIGHT ONE THAT BILL IS
OUT ITEM NUMBER TWENTY SEVEN AB
TWENTY NINE NINETY EIGHT
PEACEFULLY AFTER MEMBER FROM
PARIS [inaudible] SIX TO ALAN.
ALAN BY SEVEN TO THAT BILL IS
OUT AB.
TWENTY TERRY FILE ITEM TWENTY
EIGHT A. B. THIRTY SIXTY NINE
PLEASE CALL THE AFTER MEMBER
[inaudible] ZERO ALLEN
[inaudible]
ALLEN I NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS
OUT ITEM NUMBER THIRTY A. B.
THIRTY ONE FORTY ONE BECAUSE
AFTER MEMBER [inaudible]
ALAN. NINE ZERO THAT PHIL IS OUT
IS WELL ITEM THIRTY ONE A. B.
THIRTY ONE FORTY TWO PLEASE CALL
THAT'S A MEMBER.
ALAN. NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT
ITEM NUMBER THIRTY TWO A. B.
THIRTY ONE FORTY THREE PLEASE
CALL THE AFTER MEMBER. SEVEN
ZERO FULLER ALAN [inaudible]
ALLEN I EIGHT ZERO THE BILL IS
OUT ITEM NUMBER THIRTY SIX AJ
ARE [inaudible] THREE THREE I'M
SORRY.
I REMEMBER THIRTY THREE A. B.
THIRTY ONE FORTY FOUR PLEASE
CALL THE AFTER MEMBER AFFECTS
EIGHT ZERO ALAN.
ALLEN NINE ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT.
ITEM THIRTY SIX AJ ARE TWENTY
SEVEN PLEASE CALL THE ESTIMATES
[inaudible]
FULLER [inaudible]
ALAN ALLEN I EIGHT ZERO THAT
BILL IS OUT.
NOW WE WILL GO BACK.
TO ITEM NUMBER. EIGHTEEN AB
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
CURRENT FOES FORGET TO ALLEN
[inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
LASER
.
PLEASE GO ABSENT MEMBERS ON ITEM
NUMBER EIGHTEEN AB [inaudible]
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE ALLEN
[inaudible]
GALGIANI [inaudible]
GLAZER
.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS I
RIVER EIGHTEEN AB.
TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE I'M VOTE
SUPPORTED TO ALLEN [inaudible]
ALLEN I GALGIANI GLAZER.
BILL HAS FIVE VOTES IS IS OUT.
THAT CONCLUDES THE BUSINESS AND
PROFESSIONS COMMITTEE MEETING
FOR TODAY WHERE JOURNAL