FOR ON BEHALF OF THE ENTIRE
COMMITTEE OF THE SENATE
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WE ARE
GRATEFUL THAT ALL OF YOU ARE
HERE TODAY WELCOME.
TO THIS WEDNESDAY OF THE NINE
ADDITION. WOULD LIKELY TO TAKE
CARE OF SOME HOUSEKEEPING AS WE
TYPICALLY DO BUT WE HAVE TWO
ITEMS THAT ARE ON CONSENT THAT'S
ITEM NUMBER TWO S. B. TEN EIGHTY
FOUR AND ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN S.
B. TWELVE FIFTY ONE. ITEM NUMBER
EIGHTEEN.
WILL NOT BE MOVING IN ON THIS
MORNING'S AGENDA. BUT THAT IS
MISTER MORALE WE'RE GONNA BE
MOVING THAT BILL TO THE
SIXTEENTH IN THE SENATORS FULLY
IN THE LOOP ON THAT.
WE ALSO WILL BE TURNING THE
GAVEL OVER TO THE VICE CHAIR AS
I WILL BE OUT FOR ABOUT A HALF
HOUR TO FORTY FIVE MINUTES. BUT
DUE TO A LONG PLANNED PRESS
CONFERENCE ON FIRE IN MUTUAL AID
BUT WHAT WE KICK IT OFF FIRST
WITH CENTER TO GAIN CENTER
GAINES. HAS THREE BILLS THAT
HE'S GOING TO BE PRESENTING ITEM
NUMBER NINE FIRST TELVE
EIGHTEEN ITEM NUMBER TEN SECOND
S. B. TWELVE FORTY SIX. THEN
ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN S. C. A.
NINETEEN CENTER GAINS ARE GOING
TO BE STARTING AS A SUB
COMMITTEES WE HAVE YET TO
ESTABLISH A QUORUM WE WELCOME
YOU SIR I'M AND I WANT TO SAY IS
FISH THEN S. B.. TWELVE EIGHTEEN
WE WILL SAY THANK YOU TO CENTER
GAINES FOR WORKING WITH THE
COMMITTEE TO BETTER REDUCE THE
FISCAL IMPACT OF THE BILL. BUT
THERE ARE GOING TO BE.
HE HAS TAKEN AMENDMENTS THAT
INSTEAD OF A DEDUCTION OF UP TO
TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS BURGUNDY
FOCUSING DEDUCTION FOR THREE AT
THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR
SINGLE FILERS AND SIX THOUSAND
FOR JOINT. AGAIN CENTER GAINES
YOU'VE BEEN FANTASTIC TO WORK
WITH AND WE'RE GRATEFUL THE
FLOOR IS YOURS SIR.
WONDERFUL YET THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
.
CHAIRMAN MCGUIRE AND MEMBERS.
I JUST WANT TO THANK YOU AGAIN
FOR. WORKING WITH US ON THOSE
AMENDMENTS AND.
COLLEGE COSTS HAVE BEEN
INCREASING MUCH FASTER THAN.
IT COMES AND INFLATION IN
CALIFORNIA.
THANK YOU.
AND STATE SUPPORT FOR OUR PUBLIC
UNIVERSITIES PLAYS A SMALLER
PART THAN IT HAS IN THE PAST
ACCORDING TO THE.
PP I SEE YOU SEE FUNDING.
PER FULL TIME.
EQUIVALENT STUDENT HAS FROM OF
TWENTY THREE THOUSAND DOLLARS IN
NINETEEN SEVENTY SEVEN.
WHICH IS IRONICALLY THE YEAR
WHAT UC DAVIS.
HAS NOT AMAZING.
YEAH TO EIGHT THOUSAND DOLLARS.
AND TWENTY SEVENTEEN.
THE CSU IS DROPPED FROM ELEVEN
THOUSAND DOLLARS TO NINE
THOUSAND.
DURING THAT TIME.
LOWER SUPPORT AND RISING COSTS
OF LEAD TO AN INCREASE OF
STUDENT DEBT.
BUT THE AVERAGE DEBT LOAD OF
AROUND TWENTY TWO THOUSAND
DOLLARS FOR CURRENT GRADUATING
STUDENTS.
FIVE TWENTY NINE COLLEGE PLANS.
CAN HELP FIGHT GET SOME OF THOSE
TRENDS.
HOW THESE PLANS ALLOW
CONTRIBUTIONS TO GROW TAX
DEFERRED AND AS LONG AS THE
MONEY IS SPENT ON QUALIFYING
EXPENSES SUCH AS BOOKS?
TUITION AND DISTRIBUTIONS.
ARE TAX FREE SO CALIFORNIA
ALREADY OFFERS FAVORABLE TAX
TREATMENT TO COLLEGE SAVINGS.
BUT IS ONLY ONE OF NINE STATES
WITH AN INCOME TAX IT DOESN'T
OFFER SOME DEDUCTIBILITY FOR
CONTRIBUTIONS HIS BILL WOULD
MERELY AT ANOTHER LABOR AFFAIRS
A FAVORABLE TREATMENT. BY
ALLOWING INDIVIDUALS TO DEDUCT
CONTRIBUTIONS INTO THOSE PLANS.
DEDUCTIBILITY WOULD GIVE PARENTS
AND GRANDPARENTS AND OTHER
PEOPLE WHO WANT TO CONTRIBUTE.
TO PROGRAMS THAT ADDITIONAL
INCENTIVE TO DO SO THESE PLANTS
ARE NOT CURE ALLS BUT. ALONG
WITH ADDITIONAL STATE SUPPORT
FEDERAL SUPPORT INCREASED
EFFICIENCIES IN EDUCATION
DELIVERY CERTAIN OTHER SAVINGS
AVAILABLE TO OUR CAMPUSES.
SAVINGS PLANS CAN HELP MAKE
COLLEGE
MORE AFFORDABLE AND WITH ME TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS TO CALL
AND POLICY DIRECTOR OF THE
SACRAMENTO. TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION.
SUCH MISTER HOME BEFORE YOU GET
INTRODUCED ONE IF YOU WOULD
ALLOW US TO BE ABLE TO ESTABLISH
A QUORUM BOMB IN THEN I DO WANNA
LET YOU KNOW WEHAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON ITEM ON ALL THREE THE
BILL'S. NINE.
CAN ITEM NUMBER NINETEEN IN
NINETEEN AS WELL SO UP THE FREE
TO BE ABLE TO TRUNCATE THE
TESTIMONY I WILL HAND AS WELL
BUT BEFORE WE GO TO MR OWN
THAT'S GO TO SOCIAL CORMS THING
CHESTER.
WIRE HERE REQUIRE PRINCIPLE IN.
HERE INCRETIN DEL HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ PRESENT HERTZBERG LARA
MORE LOCK. LOCK TRANSIT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH THANK CHESTER
WE WILL KEEP BILLS ON CALL ON
YOU WANNA LET FOLKS KNOW I'M
GONNA HAVE TO STEP OUT
CUNNINGHAM THE GAVEL OVER TO THE
VICE CHAIR AND WILL BE BACK
ABOUT FORTY TO A THIRTY TO FORTY
FIVE MINUTES. IS HARD I
APOLOGIZE I DON'T MEAN TO BE
RUDE BUT WE WELCOME YOU TO
COMMITTEE SIR OF ALL THE FORMER
STAFFER MISTER CHAIRMAN I
UNDERSTAND THE YOU KNOW. THE UP
PUSH AND PULL OF THE POSITIONS
THANK YOU SIR AND THE THE NEED
FOR BREVITY THAT SEGMENT OF
TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION BELIEVES
THAT THIS BILL ISN'T AN AWESOME
STEP. IN THE DIRECTION OF GIVING
CALIFORNIA FAMILIES THE ABILITY
TO
PROVIDE THEIR CHILDREN WITH THE
OPPORTUNITY TO ACHIEVE HIGHER
EDUCATION.
WITH THE.
UPWARD PRESSURE OF TUITION
COSTS AND THE BURDENS THAT
FAMILIES CARRY IN OUR STATE.
ANYTHING ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF
THE FACT THAT THE AFTER TAX
DOLLARS ARE USED SO THERE FOR
THE LOST OF THE STATE IF YOU
WILL. ON A.
AN ON GOING BASIS SEEMS TO BE
PRETTY MINIMAL AND WE ARE GLAD
TO SUPPORT FOR THE SENATORS
MEASURE.
THIS IS IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. OF.
GOOD MORNING DANIELLE CANDLE
KAISER ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA TAX FORM ASSOCIATION.
OUR ORGANIZATION HAS A
LONGSTANDING HISTORY OF OPPOSING
BILLS OF THIS NATURE. MEASURES
SUCH AS THIS ONE DO YOU FAVOR
THOSE FAMILIES AND INDIVIDUALS
WERE ALREADY MORE LIKELY. AND
ABLE TO AFFORD COLLEGE WHILE
REDUCING GENERAL FUNDS THAT ARE
NECESSARY TO SUPPORT THE
DELIVERY OF PUBLIC EDUCATION SO
WE URGE YOUR NO VOTE THANK YOU.
THINK.
WHEN THIS IS IN. OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE SENATOR GAINES WOULD
YOU BE TAKING THE AMENDMENTS.
YES.
WILL ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE.
A MEMBERS THANK YOU.
COLLEAGUES.
SENATOR SENATOR MORE THAN I.
THIS TEAM MADE THE STATEMENT
SENATORGAINES SAID.
CALIFORNIA'S ONLY ONE OF NINE
STATES THAT DO NOT ALLOW.
FIVE TRYING I PLANS THAT TO TAKE
A STATE TAX DEDUCTION AND. YOU
HAVE TO KNOW WHY WITH WHAT THE
HISTORY IS.
I DO NOT KNOW THE HISTORY NO.
DARDEN IT'S IT'S HISTORICALLY I
BELIEVE GOOD AND THE FACT THAT
THERE HAS BEEN THE WHEN THEY
WHEN THEY CALCULATE THE AFTER
TAX.
DID IT TYPICALLY FAMILIES DON'T
HAVE A LOT U
THROW INTO THE.
THE ACCOUNT BUT THE STATE HAS
NEVER WANTED TO BE ABLE TO.
SURRENDER IF YOU WILL THE
THOUGHT THAT.
THAT TOM
BETWEEN BEING.
GIVING A SAY AT ATTACKS.
BENEFIT.
IN AN AFTER TAX.
.
FUNDS. IT IS NOT SOMETHING THAT
THEY THEY WANTED TO SET A
PRECEDENT FOR IN THE STATE. SO
SO WE HAVE FORTY ONE OTHER
STATES THAT HAVE DONE IT OR THEY
DON'T HAVE INCOME TAX BRENT.
AND.
WE'VE ONLY SEEN ONE BILL TO DATE
THIRD.
COULD TO ALLOW IT AS. WELL AND
THAT AND THAT THAT'S WHY.
SENATOR GAINES IS BILL IS SO
IMPORTANT BECAUSE THE SIMPLE
FACT IS THAT. IT IS. AND AND
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT TO THE
OPPOSITION. THE CONCEPT OF
REDUCED
TAX REVENUE TO THE STATE WHEN
YOU'RE USING AFTER TAX FUNDS.
THAT TAXES ALREADY BEEN PAID ON
THOSE FUNDS OR AT LEAST DEDUCTED.
AND SO THE THE LOSS OF REVENUE
SHOULD BE FAIRLY MINIMAL AND
GIVEN THE FACT THAT A LOT OF
FAMILIES. MAY NOT BE ABLE TO
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS ACROSS
THE BOARD. GIVING AY FAMILY IN
CALIFORNIA THE OPPORTUNITY. TO
SET ASIDE TAX FREE DOLLARS IF
YOU WILL FOR THEIR CHILDREN'S
EDUCATION SEEMS TO BE A VERY
WISE MOVE.
YOU SENATOR GAINES THANK YOU
MADAM CHAIR. THAT THE SENATOR
HERNANDEZ HIM.
.
YOU HAVE WOOD WE HAVEN'T
ESTIMATED IT BECAUSE IT'S
OBVIOUS HE TAX CREDIT AND WE
HAVE AN ESTIMATE THE AMOUNT OF
MONEY THAT'S GOING TO AFFECT THE
GENERAL FUND ROUGHLY.
I DID HIM PUT THAT HASN'T BEEN
DONE YET SENATOR WE HAVE NO IDEA
I MEAN JUST. A BALLPARK AT ALL.
LET ME.
LET LET ME JUST POSE. DISTRICT
A QUESTION I AM I THINK IT'S A
GREAT IDEA THAT PARENTS ARE
ALLOWED TO. HAVE A TAX DEDUCTION
TO PUT MONEY ASIDE FOR AN
EDUCATION BUT.
I I I KIND OF AGREE WITH WHAT
THE OPPOSITION JUST CAME UP THAT.
YOU THINK THE PARENTS ARE GOING
TO DO THAT ARE MORE LIKELY THE
PARENTS THAT HAVE THE FINANCIAL
MEANS TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT WITH
MY CONCERN IS THAT.
MIDDLE CLASS FAMILY. THAT FAMILY
MEMBER.
WHO LIVE REALLY WORKS ON
PAYCHECK TO PAYCHECK BUT? MAKES
ENOUGH THAT THEY DON'T QUALIFY
FOR FINANCIAL AID OR GRANTS
THE DON'T HAVE THE FINANCIAL
RESOURCES TO PUT THAT MONEY AND.
I GUESS THE REASON WHY I POSED
THE QUESTION ABOUT YOU KNOW HOW
MUCH TAX CREDIT.
YOU KNOW WHAT IF WE JUST TOOK
THAT AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT'S IN
THE GENERAL FUND AND HELPED
SUPPLEMENT.
THE KIDS IT REALLY REALLY NEED
IT THE MOST THAT'S WHY JUST POSE
THE QUESTION.
FIVE A I JUST HAVE A CONCERN
ABOUT THE ONE WHO WHAT THE
ABILITY FOR FAMILIES WHO REALLY
NEED IT WHO DON'T HAVE THE
FINANCIAL MEANS AVAIL PUT ASIDE
MONEY.
YEAH RELIGIOUS STATEMENT I'M NOT
ASKING A QUESTION.
BUT I THINK IT'S A THE CONCERN
THE.
.
CERTAINLY WE WANT TO TRY TO HELP.
STUDENTS GET AND THAT WE'RE NOT
REALLY THE INTENT IS NOT TO HELP
OF THE WEALTHY.
WOULD REALLY BE MORE.
TO MIDDLE CLASS AND WOULD THEY
HAVE THAT ABILITY TO SET.
HE SAID THAT I THINK THE MIDDLE
CLASS OF TODAY DOESN'T HAVE THE
ABILITY TO PUT MONEY ASIDE THEY
DON'T AND.
I MEAN THIS IS A TAX CREDIT THEY
THINK IS GOING TO BENEFIT THOSE
WHO HAVE THE FINANCIAL MEANS
THAT HAVE THE ABILITY TO PUT
EXTRA MONEY ASIDE AND GET A TAX
CREDIT AND I THINK THEY. YOU
KNOW I THINK THERE'S A
DISADVANTAGE TO THE.
TO THE WORKING POOR.
THE OTHER CURRENT.
SENATOR WHICH I LIKE TO CLOSE.
YES I JUST THE URGE YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU.
THERE'S A MOTION AND THIS IS DUE
PASSED AS A MINUTE TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE.
MCGUIRE. WHEN AYE NGUYEN AYE
BELL. BELL ALRIGHT. HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
LARA.
MORE LOCK. MORLOCK GUY FOR.
PRESUMING OBLIGATORY THREE THREE.
THREE ZERO WILL HOLD A ROLL CALL
OPEN.
OF SENATOR FELLOW.
MADAM CHAIR IT'S SO.
THE SHADOW DAY FOR FOSTER
YOU'VE TODAY I REQUEST
PERMISSION TO ALLOW THE FOSTER
YOU FOR.
.
TO.
CENTER ON THE DESK BEHIND ME IF
THAT'S ALLOWED.
I'D I'D.
BUT IS REQUESTING SO WE CAN SIT
BACK HERE THAT THAT'S WHAT I
DON'T KNOW THE RULES FOR THAT
SAID OKAY YOU KNOW OKAY.
THIS IS A. ANTHONY IN HIS CAR
RONDO FUSS USE.
NAM.
HE WILL BE SHALL REMAIN TODAY SO.
.
LEARN TO CENTER COMMITTEE
WELCOME AND.
POLITICAL WATCHING ALL OUR
ACTION.
I MEAN WHO WOULD HAVE TO MAKE IT
TOUGH FOR YOU SO THAT MAKES.
YOU LOOK.
THE POINT BREAK.
WHO'S GOING TO QUIT.
NEXT ITEM IS.
ITEM TEN SP TWELVE FORTY SIX AM
AGAIN THIS HAS.
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
OKAY VERY WELL.
GREAT THANK YOU.
.
SURE WOMEN WHEN AND MEMBERS.
.
S. B. AT FOUR FORTY SIX.
.
ISABEL I'M PRESENTING IT WILL
STREAMLINE AND MODERNIZE THE
PROCESS FOR EXPANDING PROPERTY
TAX REFUNDS.
TO CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS UNDER
CURRENT LAW AN OUTDATED REFUND
CLAIM FORM IS REQUIRED TO BE
MAILED TO A MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC
WHO IS OWED MONEY. TO TURN OVER
PAYMENT OF TAXES OR OTHER COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH LOCAL TAXES THE
CLAIM FORM MUST BE SIGNED AND
RETURNED BY THE TAXPAYER FOR THE
COUNTY CAN REFUND WHAT IS
RIGHTFULLY THEIRS. THIS BILL
WILL SPEED UP THE PROCESS TO
ALLOW THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY PAY
THE TAXPAYER WHAT IS SO WENT
OVER PAYMENT REFUND IS
DISCOVERED WITHOUT THE TIME
CONSUMING PAPERWORK. REQUIRED
UNDER CURRENT LAW LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THEIR CONSTITUENTS DO NOT
OVERPAY THEIR TAXES.
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
RESOLVE THESE ISSUES IT
SUFFICIENTLY. ACT QUICKLY AS
POSSIBLE AT ARCHER AYE AYE
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. SYNDICATE
RISES IN SUPPORT MADAM CHAIR
MEMBERS NOT USE REALLY HAVE
THE STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTY
AUDITORS ARE NOT TO BE TOO
REPETITIVE BUT WE FEEL THAT.
THIS BILL STREAMLINED THE
PROCESS ALLOWS PEOPLE TO.
TO BE REPAID MORE EFFICIENTLY
MORE QUICKLY TIME WE DISCOVER
ISSUES OF A OF.
OVERPAYMENTS BY CONSTITUENTS
WILL MAKE SURE HEY GET THEIR
MONEY BACK AND HANDED SIZE
QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE SO WE URGE
YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS BILL THANK
YOU. THANK YOU ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
AND NEED TO ONE IN OPPOSITION TO
TESTIFY OR TWO.
A POST.
SEEING NONE COLLEAGUES IN THE
QUESTIONS COMMENTS.
THERE'S A MOTION.
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE SENATOR
GAINES.
YES YEAH WE'RE ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENT
AND I WOULD URGE AYE VOTE THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU.
MORE BUT PLEASE CALL FOR THE.
WIRED NGUYEN AYE NGUYEN AYE BELL.
BILL AYE HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG LARA.
MORE LOCK.
MORE LIKE GUY TOWARDS THE WORLD.
BUT IS IT BOARD SEE MORE ZERO
WILL KEEP THE CALL VOCAL OPEN
AND IT'S ON DO PASS AS AMENDED
TO APPROPRIATIONS. THINKING.
ITEMS SENATOR GAINES LAST ONE IS
ITEM NINETEEN S. C. A. NINETEEN.
BOTH SIDES.
THANK YOU THIS IS.
SCA NINETEEN.
HAD SAID THAT RENTS PROP
THIRTEEN. FACE YOUR TRANSFER.
AND.
WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR WORKING WITH ME ON THE
BILL. AND WE'RE HAPPY TO ACCEPT
THE AMENDMENTS
TO CAP THE INCOME FOR ELIGIBLE
VETERANS.
AT FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS PER
INDIVIDUAL AND HUNDRED THOUSAND
HOURS.
BY JOINTLY IN THE YEAR THAT THEY
TAKE THE PROPOSED BENEFIT.
I HAD SCA NINETEEN OFFERS A WELL
DESERVED BENEFIT TO CALIFORNIA'S
HONORABLY DISCHARGED VETERANS.
GUYS YOU KNOW CALIFORNIANS
SUFFER WAS OF THE HIGHEST
HOUSING COSTS IN THE NATION.
BECAUSE THOSE HIGH COST. THE
FIFTEENTH HIGHEST.
BOB PROPERTY TAXES IN THE NATION
EVEN WITH PROP THIRTEEN. TAX
PROTECTIONS.
AND.
I HAVE THOUGHT.
DON'T CALL IT HERE.
TO SPEAK TO THE BILL.
AND ALSO.
.
A REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE
VETERANS GROUP.
I THINK.
WITNESSES TO TESTIFY. HERE.
PLEASE BEGIN.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
THE SENATE TAX PAYERS
ASSOCIATION AGAIN BELIEVES THAT
THIS IS A BILL OF EQUITY.
FOR OUR VETERANS THAT HAS.
GREAT MERIT AND ALLOWS THOSE WHO
HAVE SERVED OUR COUNTRY TO TAKE
WITH THEM MUCH LIKE THEIR VA
LOAN IF THERE.
.
ABLE TO. ENSURE THAT THEY MEET
THE TERMS OF THEIR LOAN THEY CAN
TAKE THAT THAT THAT. BENEFIT IF
YOU WILL TO THE NEXT HOME THAT
THEY PURCHASE.
ALSO ALLOWING THEM TO TAKE THEIR
AND TAX EXEMPTION.
ARE THE PROP THIRTEEN FIGURES.
WITH THEM WOULD BE. A GREAT
HELP TO THOSE WHO HAVE SERVED
OUR COUNTRY SO VALIANTLY.
THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING. PINNACLE WITH READ
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
REPRESENTING THE AMERICAN GI
FORUM AND THAT'S THE AMERICAN
LEGION CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
COUNTY VETERANS SERVICE OFFICERS
THE CALIFORNIA STATE COMMANDERS
VETERANS COUNCIL. THE MILITARY
OFFICERS ASSOCIATION AMERICAN
THE VIETNAM VETERANS AMERICANS
SUPPORT.
SHOULD THE STATE SEEK TO ATTRACT
AND RETAIN VETERANS OF A SUBSET
OF VETERANS OUR MILITARY
RETIREES. FROM NINE ELEVEN TO
TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN CALIFORNIA
SHARE OF MILITARY RETIREES IS
FALLEN FROM TEN AND A HALF
PERCENT TO SEVEN TO HELP PERCENT.
WELL NATION WIDE THAT NUMBER OF
RETIREES INCREASED BY SIXTEEN
POINT EIGHT PERCENT. RETIREES IN
CALIFORNIA ALONE RECEIVE ALMOST
FOUR BILLION A YEAR IN DOD
PENSION PAYMENTS MILITARY
RETIREES OFTEN RETIRE. AFTER
TWENTY YEARS IN ARE IN THEIR
EARLY FORTIES. MOST OF THEM
GOING TO SECOND AND THIRD
CAREERS IN SKILLED PROFESSIONS.
MANY VETERANS RECEIVE FEDERAL
BENEFITS FROM THE VA LAST FISCAL
YEAR WELL OVER FOUR HUNDRED AND
THIRTY MILLION IN SUCH MONETARY
BENEFITS WERE PAID DIRECTLY TO
VETERANS IN CALIFORNIA.
THESE BENEFITS UNABLE COST
AVOIDANCE TO MEDI CAL AND OTHER
STATE LOCAL PROGRAMS.
BECAUSE THESE VETERANS ARE BEING
ASSISTED BY THE APPROPRIATE
FEDERAL PROGRAM THE FEDERAL VA
HEALTH HOSPITALS IN SACRAMENTO
FRESNO LIVERMORE MENLO PARK PALO
ALTO LOW MELINDA LONG BEACH LA
SAN DIEGO. IF THE VETERANS
POPULATION DECREASES THESE
FACILITIES GO TO OR THE VETERANS
OR. IN ALL THOSE SKILLED DOCTORS
NURSES HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS
MAINTENANCE WORKERS AND
SUPPLIERS DECREASE OR GO AWAY AS
WELL. IN FY FIFTEEN THE VA SPEND
FIFTEEN POINT SIXBILLION IN
CALIFORNIA ON ITS OPERATIONS AND
FACILITIES. IT BEHOOVES
CALIFORNIA TO RETAIN AND ATTRACT
VETERANS TO LIVE IN THE STATE
THEY FORM THE NUCLEUS OF A
CONSTANT AND SOLID MIDDLE CLASS.
THEY BRING NEW FEDERAL MONEYS
AND BENEFITS INTO THE STATE
WHICH THE ORDINARY AS A RESULT
OF THE MILITARY SERVICE THANK
YOU.
ANY WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
A NEED ONE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION.
GOOD MORNING DANIELLE KENDO
KAISER ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA TAX REFORM
ASSOCIATION WE RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSE THE BILL. THIS WOULD
REPRESENT AN ADDITIONAL
EXPANSION OF THE ALREADY FLAWED
PROP THIRTEEN WHICH AFFORD
SIGNIFICANT BENEFITS TO
HOMEOWNERS. GENERAL FUND REVENUE
IN PARTICULAR.
CRITICAL PUBLIC SERVICES IN
WHICH GROUPS LIKE VETERANS RELY
WOULD BE IMPACTED WITH LITTLE TO
NO PUBLIC POLICY BENEFIT WE ARE
JOURNAL THAT.
THANK YOU.
ANY.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
COLLEAGUES QUESTION COMMENTS.
IN MOTION.
I WOULD.
THERE'S A MOTION.
I'M THIS IS WHAT BE ADOPTED AS
AMENDED TO THE SENATE AND THE
ELECTIONS A CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENTS.
FUND SENATOR GAINES CAN I IF YOU
BLOOM I WOULD ALLOW FOR I CAN BE
ON AS A CO AUTHOR.
ABSOLUTELY SURE THANK YOU.
PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE.
CHOIR WHEN I AYE BELL FILL OUR
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG LARA. LARA I'M MORE
LOT. MORE LIKE I. PLEDGE TO YOU.
BY.
THANK YOU READY FIVE ZERO WILL
KEEP THE WILL CALL BUT THERE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH COMMITTEE
MEMBERS PER SHOULD.
IF IF IF IT. IS.
SEC SENATOR STONE.
WHICH YOU LIKE TO COME.
A JOYFUL YOU OKAY I'M SORRY YEAH.
HIS HIS WITNESSES HERE.
WISEMAN.
FILE ITEM SEVENTEEN S. B.
FOURTEEN EIGHTY FOUR CENTER
HERNANDEZ THE IMMINENT CHAIR
MEMBERS I THINK THE CAR LIKE TO
THINK COMMITTEE AND STAFF FIVE
WORKING AND SPILL. ON
CALIFORNIA'S MADE POSITIVE
STRIDES TO PREVENT THE SPREAD OF
HIV AIDS AND EXTEND THE LIVES OF
THOSE INFECTED.
HOWEVER LONG TERM SPECIALIZED
CARE CAN BE EXPENSIVE AND
ULTIMATELY PREVENT SOME
INDIVIDUALS FROM SEEKING
TREATMENT.
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS LIKE
AIDS HEALTH FOUNDATION OPERATE
THRIFT STORES TO GENERATE
REVENUE TO HELP ALLEVIATE THESE
COST IN SINCE NINETEEN NINETY
SIX CALIFORNIAS GRANTED THESE
THRIFT STORES A SALES TAX
EXEMPTION TO WRITE MUCH NEEDED
FUNDS.
THIS BILL REMOVES THE SUNSET ON
THE TAX EXEMPTION ALLOWING
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION TO
CONTINUE PROVIDING ACCESS TO
ESSENTIAL MEDICAL SERVICES. AND
TREATMENTS TO THOSE NEEDED.
I MEDIAN CALIFORNIA AND WITH
THAT MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
RAND MORE NOW BEHALF OF THE AIDS
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION HOW TO THE
CO SPONSOR WITH FIONA MA ON THIS
BILL. I'M A JEFF IS THE LARGEST
PROVIDER OF CARE AND TREATMENT
OF PEOPLE WITH HIV IN THE WORLD.
SOMEWHERE VERY LARGE IN
CALIFORNIA VERY LARGE IN LA
COUNTY AND
A KILLER WE PRIDE OURSELVES ON
OUR ABILITY TO PROVIDE SERVICES
REGARDLESS OF THE ABILITY TO PAY
ONE OF THE WAYS WE DO THAT IS
THROUGH OUR.
THRIFT STORES WHICH BRING IN A
SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF REVENUE TO
HELP INDIGENT PEOPLE RECEIVE HIV
CARE AND THE SALES TAX EXEMPTION
THAT WE'VE ENJOYED SINCE
NINETEEN NINETY SIX HAS HELPED
US TO ACHIEVE THAT.
THAT AIM TIME WE ASK THAT YOU
SUPPORT THIS BILL APPRECIATE
THANK YOU.
I THINK YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME'S CASEY
O'CONNOR IN THE LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR BILI VICE CHAIR
FIONA MA. THE VICE CHAIR IS VERY
SUPPORTIVE OF THIS MEASURE IN
TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN WHEN SHE PUT
ON THE LAST SUNSET EXTENSION WE
THINK AFTER TWENTY. THE NEW
CIVIC CENTER HAS EXPIRED PROVING
TO BE WHERE THE INVALUABLE
RESOURCE FOR FOLKS THAT NEED
EMOTES MOST THROUGHOUT
CALIFORNIA. IN OUR HAPPY BECAUSE
ONCE THE BILL AND THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR BRING IT FORWARD AND
WE JUST ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU.
ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION OR TO.
OPPOSE.
SCENE NINE COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS
COMMENT. GOOD THERE'S A MOTION
WHICH ELECT TO PLEASE CLOSE AS
RENEBERG MEN CHAIR MEMBERS THIS
IS DUE PASSED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE WIRE
WHEN I AND AYE BELL. BELL I
HERNANDEZ AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG LARA.
WELL ARE I'VE MORE LOCK MORE
LIKE NINE. FEET LONG FIVE ZERO
BUT WILL KEEP THE WILL CALL OPEN
THANK YOU HAVE.
SENATORS DON'T.
WHO SENATORS DON'T HAS TO FILE
ITEM BY ITEM THREE WHICH IS S.
B. TEN NINETY ONE?
AND ALSO.
NUMBER FOURTEEN S. B. THIRTEEN
FIFTY TWO WILL TAKE THE TIME.
BUT I AM SIX FIRST SP TWELVE OF
TWO.
OKAY.
HOW DO I?
POEMS ARE TEN NINETY ONE I'M
SORRY SENATOR. IF THREE YOU HAVE
THREE.
YES MA'AM WE HAVE THREE CATS ARE
ITS MY FAULT. SORRY I GOT THE
HIGHER I'M SORRY THAT'S
PRETENDING TO EXPRESS THE GOOD
MORNING MISS VICE CHAIR AND.
MEMBERS.
I'M PRESENTING S. B. TEN NINETY
ONE WHICH WOULD ALLOW PROPERTY
OWNERS WHO ARE AFFECTED BY ONE
OF LAST YEAR'S GOVERNOR DECLARED
NATURAL DISASTERS.
DEVOID PROPERTY TAX REASSESSMENT.
AND TRANSFER THE PROP THIRTEEN
BODIES YEAR VALUE FROM ONE HOME
TO ANOTHER COMPARABLE RESIDENT.
PRESIDENTS WHEN FORCED TO
RELOCATE. S. B. TEN NINETY ONE
IS THE LEGISLATIVE COMPANION TO
A CA TWENTY FOUR WHICH IS BEEN
INTRODUCED BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MARIE WALDRON.
AND TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN
CALIFORNIA.
SUFFERED NUMEROUS NATURAL
DISASTERS THAT HAVE CREATED
FISCAL CHALLENGES TO HOMEOWNERS
WHO ARE FACING UNEXPECTED COSTS
AFTER NEEDING TO REBUILD OR
RELOCATE THEIR HOMES WHICH WERE
DAMAGED OR DESTROYED BY THE
NATURAL DISASTERS. THIS BILL
ALONG WITH THE VOTER APPROVED
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT SIX TO
PROVIDE EQUITY. FOR CALIFORNIA
RESIDENTS THAT WERE FORCED TO
RELOCATE DUE TO ONE OF THE
NATURAL DISASTERS IN TWO
THOUSAND SEVENTEEN. HIS HOMERS
HAVE ALREADY SUFFERED AN
INCREDIBLE LOSS CREATING A WAY
FOR THEM TO REMAIN. IN A
COMPARABLE HOME WITHOUT BEING
BURDENED WITH MUCH HIGHER
HOUSING COSTS IS THE LEAST WE
CAN DO. I'VE BEEN WORKING
CLOSELY WITH THE SPONSOR OF S.
B. TEN NINETY ONE BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION MEMBER JEROME
HORTON. AND HIS WONDERFUL STAFF
I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME AND
INTRODUCE CYNTHIA BRIDGES MEMBER
OF HORTON'S OUT MISTER HORTON
CBI ó WE TAX CONSULTANT WHO IS
HERE TODAY IN SUPPORT. MISS
BRIDGES.
THANK YOU BY GOOD MORNING VICE
CHAIR OF MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE.
TO HELP CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
BURDENED WITH HIGHER HOUSING
COSTS FOLLOWING THIS DESTRUCTION
OF THEIR PRIMARY HOME FROM ONE
OF LAST YEAR'S NATURAL DISASTER
EVENTS. SP TO NINETY ONE WILL
BRING FINANCIAL COMFORT TO THE
THOUSANDS WHO LOST THEIR HOMES
ARE SUFFERED PROPERTY DAMAGE
FROM THE DEVASTATING. OF
WILDFIRES MET FLY MUDSLIDES AND
FLOODS.
BY ALLOWING THEM TO REBUILD
THEIR HOMES AT A SITE OF THEIR
CHOOSING WITHOUT LOSING THEIR
CURRENT PROPERTIES BASED YEAR.
YEAH.
.
EVEN THOUGH A THERE MAY BE SOME
POTENTIAL FISCAL IMPACT TO LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS.
WE ANTICIPATE THAT THAT WILL BE
MINIMAL AS.
.
MANY OF THESE PROPERTIES WILL BE
OFFSET BY INVESTOR PURCHASES ON
THE SALE OF THE DAMAGED AND
DESTROYED PROPERTIES THAT WILL
OFFSET THE LOWER VALUATIONS. AND
WITH THAT WE ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT THANK YOU DAVID'S
MADAM PRESSURE MEMBERS GOOD
MORNING DAVID WILL FOR THE
HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION ALSO IN SUPPORT OF
THIS BILL.
MEMBERS WE JUST THINK IN THE
EVENT OF THESE NATURAL DISASTERS
AND NAPA AND AL A AND OTHER
COMMUNITIES OR INDIVIDUALS HAVE
LOST EVERYTHING GIVING. THESE
INDIVIDUALS THE FLEXIBILITY TO
TRANSFER THEIR PROP THIRTEEN
BISHER VALUE.
IS NECESSARY AND IMPORTANT AND
ADD TO GIVEN THE FLEXIBILITY TO
DO THAT ACROSS COUNTIES
CONCEIVABLY IS ALSO IMPORTANT.
SET FOR THOSE REASONS WHY
ASPIRIN ABOUT.
THANK YOU. ANY OTHER WITNESSES
IN SUPPORT.
HE NEED ONE TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION URGE TO STATE AND
OPPOSITION.
CNN COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS
COMMENTS.
THERE'S A MOTION BY SENATOR
MOORE LA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
PLEASE CLOSE SENATOR THANK YOU
RESPECTFULLY ASK AND I WILL KNOW
ANYTHNG MISS BRIDGES AND.
MEMBER HORTON FOR THEIR
LEADERSHIP ON THE CITY.
THIS IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS PLEASE CALL FOR
THE VOTE WIRE WHEN I WHEN I BELL.
BELL AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG LARA.
MORE LOCK.
MORE LIKE GUYS LOOSELY.
FOUR ZERO WILL KEEP THE ROLL
CALL OPEN THANK YOU THANK YOU
MADAM VICE CHAIR LEANED NEXT
ITEM IS NUMBER SIX.
TWELVE VOTE TO.
AND I BELIEVE THAT SUPPORTABLE
TRACK.
PLUS IT SUPPORT ON BOTH SIDES.
BIG YUBA MADAM VICE CHAIR I'M
HERE HOW TO PRESENT THE SP
TWELVE VOTE TO. I WOULD LIKE TO
THANK THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
THEIR HARD WORK AND WORKING WITH
US AND HELP CREATE A BILL THAT I
THINK WILL WORK FOR EVERYONE.
I'M PLEASED TO TAKE THE DAY
SUGGESTED COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
WHICH WOULD NARROW THE BILL TO
SAY THAT.
IF A LOCAL AGENCY FAILS TO
COMPLY WITH THE REPORTING
REQUIREMENTS FOR THREE YEARS. SP
TWELVE A TWO WOULD TRIGGER AN
INDEPENDENT AUDIT AND THE LOCAL
AGENCY WOULD HAVE TO PAY THE
COST OF THAT AUDIT. WE THINK
THIS WOULD HAVE HAD A POSITIVE
IMPACT WHEN IT COMES LOCAL
AGENCIES TO CONTINUE TO COLLECT
MEDICATION FEES FOR NUMEROUS
YEARS IN A ROW. BUT DID NOT
COMPLETE THE NECESSARY REPORTS.
WITH ME TODAY FROM MY DISTRICT
TO SPEAK IN FAVOR S. B. TOLL BUT
TO IS GRETCHEN GUTIERREZ CEO OF
THE DESERT VALLEY'S BUILDERS
ASSOCIATION. FROM THE PALM
SPRINGS AREA IN THE COACHELLA
VALLEY.
.
PLEASE WELCOME BOB DESCRIPTION
GET TOGETHERS FISCAL HAD GOOD
MORNING. GOOD MORNING MADAM VICE
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
ON BEHALF OF THE DESERT VALLEY
BUILDERS ASSOCIATION WOULD LIKE
TO SAY THANK YOU FOR HEARING OUR
BILL THAT WE HAVE PROPOSED TO
YOU TODAY.
AS STATED MY NAME IS GRETCHEN
GUTIERREZ AND I AM THE CEO OF
THE DESERT VALLEY BUILDERS
ASSOCIATION LOCATED IN THE
COACHELLA VALLEY AND IMPERIAL
COUNTY AREAS. I HAVE ALSO WITH
ME TODAY OUR BOARD PRESIDENT
MISTER FRED BELL OF NOBEL ENERGY
SOLUTIONS THAT ARE LEGISLATIVE
ANALYST MISTER JAMES BROWN YOUR.
BEFORE HE WAS A.
AN AMENDMENT.
BEFORE YOU IS A FIX FOR THE
MITIGATION FEE ACT WHICH WAS
ADOPTED BACK IN NINETEEN SIXTY
FOUR. CURRENTLY THERE'S NO
PENALTY ON THE BILL IF AS AGENCY
DOES NOT COMPLY WITH THE
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS THAT THEY
ARE SUPPOSED TO GENERATE ON AN
ANNUAL BASIS.
APPROXIMATELY THIRTY PERCENT OF
THE AGENCIES AROUND THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA ARE FAILING TO MEET
THAT ANNA REQUIREMENT AT THIS
POINT IN TIME. WHAT WE'RE ASKING
OF YOU WAS THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS
IS TO ADOPT THE PROPOSED
LEGISLATION SO THAT THOSE
AGENCIES WOULD BE COMPELLED? AND
REQUIRED TO REPORT THEIR
FINDINGS ON THEIR DEVELOPMENT
FUNDS THAT THEY COLLECT ON AN
ANNUALIZED BASIS BASICALLY
THEY'RE COLLECTING FUNDS AND
EXPENDING THEM AND WE HAVE NO
WAY OF TRACKING WHAT THOSE
EXPENDITURES ARE BEING SPENT ON.
AND IF THEY'RE BEING USED
APPROPRIATELY SO WE ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT ON THIS MEASURE AT THIS
TIME. THIS IS A FIX.
AND IT WOULD BE AN APPROPRIATE
FIX TO A A SITUATION WE DEAL
WITH ON AN ANNUALIZED BASIS
WITHIN THE DEVELOPMENT COMMUNITY.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
THE STATE YOUR NAME AND. WHERE
YOU'RE FROM AND YOUR POSITION
PLEASE MORNING ASSISTANCE AND
I'LL BE OFF THE CALIFORNIA
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS?
ANY. WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
OF SENATE BILL.
THE QUESTION I HAVE IS SO MANY
OF. THIS PROUD TO SERVE.
ADOPTING.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FEES.
.
THOSE KINDS OF FEES HAD BECAUSE
THIS LAW APPLY TO THOSE KINDS OF.
IT WOULD STILL HAVE THE SAME
EFFECT ON IT AT THIS PARTICULAR
POINT IN TIME IF A DEVELOPER IS
REQUIRED TO PAY A A FEE IN
INCLUSIONARY FEE OR IF HE THAT
WOULD BE TAG TO. AFFORDABLE
HOUSING THE CITY IS STILL GOING
TO BE REQUIRED TO DO THAT AS
PART OF THEIR ANNUAL REPORTING
THAT WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO NOT
SHOW WHAT THEY'VE EXPENDED THOSE
FUNDS ON AND IF THOSE FUNDS ARE
TO BE DIRECTED TOWARDS
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
APPLY TO THAT PARTICULAR LINE
ITEM ON ON THEIR ACCOUNTING SO
THAT IS THE.
SO I I I I AM A DEVELOPER AND
MY THE CITY APPLIES AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FEE.
LIKE MY CITIES.
GOT AN ORDINANCE PENDING ON US
ALL THAT'S WHY I'M ASKING.
HOW DOES THAT?
WHAT HOW DOES THE PROCESS WORK
CAN YOU GO THROUGH THAT?
THE WEIGHTED THE ENTIRE PROCESS
WORKS AND I MIGHT ACTUALLY AS MY
LEGISLATIVE ANALYST'S TO COME
FORWARD IF YOU'LL INDULGE US
MOMENT BECAUSE HE'S THE
GENTLEMAN WHO SITS AND READS IT
ON AN ANNUALIZED BASIS WITH ALL
OF US AND I DON'T WANT TO MISS
SPEAK.
.
ANY DEVELOPMENT FEE THAT IS
COLLECTED BY AN AGENCY WHETHER
IT'S A CITY A SCHOOL DISTRICT A
WATER AGENCY ETCETERA IS
REQUIRED UNDER THE MITIGATION
FEE ACT TO PUT FORWARD ON AN
ANNUALIZED REPORTING BASIS.
THE LEVEL OF INCOME THAT THEY
RECEIVED AND WHAT THEY EXPECT
AND ON AND THERE ARE VERY
CLEARLY DEFINED.
LEVELS OF WHAT THEY CAN SPEND
IT ON WITHIN THE MITIGATION FEE
ACT AND ALSO WHAT THEY CAN'T.
THE PROBLEM WE HAVE RIGHT AT THE
MOMENT AND WHAT THIS BILL IS
ATTEMPTING TO ADDRESSES THOSE
AGENCIES THAT DON'T SUPPLY ANY
OF THAT INFORMATION OUT TO US.
SO IF AN AGENCY HAS COLLECTED
TEN MILLION DOLLARS AND SPENT
NINE MILLION DOLLARS AS AN
EXAMPLE WE'D LIKE TO KNOW WHAT
THEY SPENT THE NINE MILLION
DOLLARS ON. THEIR FAILING TO
EVEN X..
EXPERT WAS THAT PARTICULAR
REPORTING OF ACCOUNTING SO AGAIN
IF THEY HAVE A LINE ITEM THAT
SAYS WE'RE GOING TO USE IT FOR
ACTS THEY NEED TO BE USING IT
FOR ACCESS AND NOT OVER FOR A
BEER CITY.
I'M NOT SURE OF THAT
SPECIFICALLY ADDRESSED QUESTION
BUT.
PRISON MITIGATION OFFI LAW.
DIRECT THAT THE HAVE TO SKINNER
ONLY ON CERTAINTHINGS BETTER
HAVE NEXUS TO THE YES THEY ARE
REQUIRED TO HAVE THE FEE
COLLECTED YES SIR THEY ARE
REQUIRED TO DO A NEXT TO STUDY
BEFORE THEY ADOPTED FEE OF ANY
SORT.
AND THAT HAS TO BE VETTED AND
APPROVED.
WE HAVE CITIES IN JURISDICTIONS
THAT DO THEM ON AN ANNUALIZED
BASIS SOME DO THEM BY ANNUALLY
TRY ANNUALLY EVERY FIVE YEARS.
IT IS A REQUIREMENT THOUGH OF
THE MITIGATION FEE ACT THAT THEY
DO HAVE TO DO A NEXUS STUDY
BEFORE THEY ADOPTED FEES. OKAY
HONEST MY QUESTION I'M SURE I'M
NO MORE QUESTION I SUPPORT THIS
BILL.
THANK YOU AYE I'M BEFORE ASK FOR
A MOTION I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE
THAT WE'RE CLEAR THAT THE MAN
WANTS TO NOT AUTOMATICALLY
TRIGGER AN AUDIT. IT MUST BE
REQUESTED FOR AND ANYONE CAN
REQUESTED AND THE CITY AND
COUNTY CITY OR COUNTY MUST AND
TURN THEM MUST AND PAY FOR IT.
YES.
IF THERE IS A MOTION WHICH YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE THANK YOU.
MADAM CHAIR THIS IS A A BILL
THAT'S GOING TO PROVIDE A LOT
MORE TRANSPARENCY AND.
PROACTIVE THIS OF
MUNICIPALITIES TO.
HOPEFULLY APPROVE PROJECTS
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SENATOR
VELVET.
I AGREE WITH YOU WE NEED TO.
WE NEED TO BUILD MORE.
AND I ALSO WANT TO.
JUST AGAIN EXTEND MY THANKS TO
THE STAFF.
AND TO US SENATOR OF MCGUIRE
MISTER CHAIRMAN FOR HELPING US
WITH THIS BUILDING.
WE WE PROBABLY TAKE THE
AMENDMENTS AND PROBABLY HOPE TO
SEE THIS MOVE FORWARD.
THANK YOU OR DRIVE OUT. THERE
THIS IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE FLOOR PLEASE CALL FOR THE
VOTE CHOIR WHEN I WHEN I BAIL
BILL AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
LARA.
LARA I'M MORE LOCK. MORE LUCK I
WILL RECEIVE. FOUR ZERO AND WE
WILL KEEP THE WILL CALL OPENED
THANK YOU. ONE WE HAVE ONE MORE
THANK YOU.
ITEM FOURTEEN.
S. B. ONE THREE FIVE TWO
AFFORDABLE FOR.
THANK YOU AGAIN.
MADAM VICE CHAIR. VERY PROUD TO
PRESENT THE SP THIRTEEN FIFTY
TWO. ONCE AGAIN I WOULD LIKE TO
THANK HE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
ALL THEIR HARD WORK IN HELPING
TO NARROW THE BILL.
I'M HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS WHICH WOULD
CREATE A TWENTY PERCENT TAX
CREDIT FOR CONTRIBUTIONS TO CAL
ABLE ACCOUNTS.
STARTING IN TWO THOUSAND AND
NINETEEN.
AS YOU ARE ALL AWARE CARING FOR
A LOVED ONE WITH DISABILITIES IS
BECOMING MORE AND MORE A
CHALLENGE SHE STAYS ESPECIALLY
FOR OUR LOVED ONES WITH AL
SIGNERS.
IN OUR YOUNGSTERS THAT HAVE
AUTISM.
ACOSTA CARE IS GOING THROUGH THE
ROOF.
THIS IS JUST ONE MORE WAY THAT
WE CAN HELP ALLEVIATE THOSE
COSTS BY INCENTIVIZING
CONTRIBUTIONS DIGS ACCOUNTS.
IT COULD BE USED TO PAY FOR THE
COST OF THIS EXPENSIVE CARE.
THIS WILL BE AN EXTREMELY
VALUABLE TOOL FOR CALIFORNIANS
TO USE APPRECIATE YOUR
CONSIDERATION OF A S. B.
THIRTEEN FIFTY TWO AND REQUEST
FULLY. PASS FOR A NIGHTCLUB.
THANK YOU A NEED. BUDDY HERE TO
TESTIFY. OR TO STATE AND A
SUPPORT PUB MANAGER COMBO BILLER
AND THE HASSLES BEST BUDDIES
INTERNATIONAL AND RUN SUPPORT
THINKING.
ANY WITNESSES TO TESTIFY OR STAY%
IN OPPOSITION SEEN THEM.
COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS COMMENTS OR
IF THERE PLAINTIFF FOR MOTION.
HERE IS THERE ANYBODY ELSE WHO
WANTS TO OPPOSE OR SUPPORT.
BEFORE CLOSING.
THERE'S A MOTION BY SENATE OF
BELL. BUSINESS DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO APPROPRIATIONS.
PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE I'M
SORRY SENATOR WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
PURSUE A CLASS RIGHT VOTE THANK
YOU THANK YOU.
PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE OF.
REQUIRE WHEN AYE AYE BELL BILL
AYE HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG.
LARA.
LARA I'M MORE LOCK.
WE'VE SEEN THREE ZERO WILL KEEP
THE VOCAL OPEN FIGURE MINIMIZE
HER THANK YOU MEMBERS.
SENATOR ANDERSON.
WE HAVE TO FILE ITEM.
FILE ITEM SEVEN WILL STAY WITH
THAT S. B. TWELVE ELEVEN AND I
BELIEVE IT'S SUPPORTABLE SIDE.
IT'S SUPPORT ON BOTH SIDES.
FIRST FAR I I'D LIKE TO.
.
THINK THE CHAIR AGAIN THE
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
THOUGHTFUL TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS
AYE I GLADLY ACCEPT THEM.
SP TWELVE.
EXCUSE ME THIS IS THE SECOND OF
MY FOR BILL MIDDLE CLASS AND
WORKING POOR TAX RELIEF PACKAGE.
I WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
FOR ALREADY PASSING MY CHILD
CARE TAX CREDIT.
YES INFLATION GAS PRICES RENTAL
COSTS UTILITY PRICES CHILD CARE
IN THE STATE INCOME TAX ALL
INCREASE
MIDDLE CLASS AND WORKING POOR IN
CALIFORNIA ARE FALLING BEHIND.
FINDING THEMSELVES HAVING MORE
MONTH THAN MONEY.
THAT'S WHY I'M OFFERING A
PACKAGE OF TAX RELIEF BILL ALSO
OR IS DEFINED BY THE REVENUE
FOLKS HERE IN THE CAPITAL TAX
EXPENDITURES.
BUT S. B. TWELVE ELEVEN IS MORE
THAN JUST AN EXPENDITURE ITS
INVESTMENT IN A WORKERS FUTURE.
IN THEIR CAREER.
I HOPE THAT YOU AGREE WITH ME
THAT IT'S WORTH SPENDING TO
INVEST IN WORKERS BY MAKING
EASIER FOR EMPLOYERS TO PROVIDE
A PARTNERSHIPS FOR. WITH THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS DESCRIBES AS.
QUOTE
DISCONNECTED YOUTH.
MY FIRST BILL TODAY. THE SECOND
IN THE PACKAGE.
IT'S S. B. TWELVE ELEVEN IS A
TAX CREDIT FOR QUALIFIED
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS.
THIS BILL WILL MATCH EMPLOYEES
WAGES UP TO TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED
DOLLARS WHILE AS AN APPRENTICE.
ACCORDING TO THE REPORT CITED IN
THE ANALYSIS ONE IN SEVEN
AMERICANS BETWEEN SIXTEEN AND
TWENTY FOUR YEARS OF AGE IS
NEITHER WORKING NOR IN SCHOOL.
THAT'S FIVE POINT EIGHT MILLION
YOUNG PEOPLE.
IN FACT THE TOP TWO COUNTIES
ARE IN THE COUNTRY.
OUR HERE IN CALIFORNIA BOTH
RIVERSIDE AND SAN BERNARDINO.
THE LACK OF JOB READINESS
IN TRAINING OUR PROBLEMS IN THE
APPRENTICESHIPS NEED TO BE A BIG
PART OF THAT SOLUTION.
WITH ME TODAY CYNTHIA BRIDGES OF
THE OFFICE OF HONORABLE CHORE
DRONE PORTEN.
MEMBER OF THE STATE BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION AND THE SPONSOR OF
THIS TAX RELIEF PACKAGE.
HIS CO HAD.
GOOD MORNING VICE CHAIR MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE.
YOU CAN WITH THAT MIKE OVERLOAD
THAT THING OKAY. CAN YOU HEAR ME
NOW. HOOKED A. THUMB.
MEMBER JORDAN HAS MADE SEVERAL
OBSERVATIONS ONE THE WAY
BUSINESS IS CONDUCTED IN
CALIFORNIA IS CHANGING. WITH THE
ADVANCES IN TECHNOLOGY AND
AUTOMATION CORPORATIONS ARE
BECOMING MORE EFFICIENT AND
THERE IS A GROWING OPPORTUNITY
FOR SKILLED WORKERS WITHIN EVERY
INDUSTRY.
SECONDLY MILLIONS OF WORKERS
WERE DISPLACED FROM LONG TERM
JOBS DURING THE RECESSION HOW
WHILE SOME WERE RE EMPLOYED AT
LOWER WAGES THAN AT THEIR
PREVIOUS JOBS.
OTHERS REMAINED UNEMPLOYED DUE
TO SKILLED DEFICIT.
AND THIRD THERE IS A SHORTAGE
NATIONALLY WITH REGARD TO.
SKILLED WORKERS IN THE
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY WHICH IS
ALSO CREATING.
A CRISIS.
.
THIS IN TURN HAS NEGATIVE
IMPACTS ON ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
FOR THE STATE. AS WELL AS OF THE
RECENTLY ENACTED MEASURES TO
ADDRESS CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING
CRISIS. BY CAUSING.
CONSTRUCTION DELAYS AND
INFLATING BUDGETS TO ACCOMMODATE.
OUT OF TOWN WORKERS. THAT IS WHY.
HE IS HIS.
AT A.
SUPPORTIVE OF.
SENATOR STONE'S INTRODUCTION OF
SP TWELVE ELEVEN WHICH WILL
ENCOURAGE CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS
TO HIRE AND TRAIN NEW WORKERS IN
THE CONSTRUCTION TRADES
MANUFACTURING HEALTH CARE AND
TOURISM INDUSTRIES. AND HE ASK
FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER. WITH IMPORTED
MEDITERRANEAN BIRDS RICHARD MARX
AND ON BEHALF OF THE SAN DIEGO
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA AND CENTRAL
CALIFORNIA CHAPTERS OF
ASSOCIATED BUILDERS AND
CONTRACTORS THE PLUMBING HEATING.
COOLING CONTRACTORS OF
CALIFORNIA AND THE WESTERN
ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS
ASSOCIATION OF THEIR ALL
SPONSORS OF APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAMS IN THE CONSTRUCTION
TRADES OF THIS IS A MODEST
CONTRIBUTION. IN THE TERMS OF A
STATE SUPPORT FOR APPRENTICESHIP.
UP MOST OF THE EMPLOYERS THAT A
HIT WILL INDENTURE AN APPRENTICE
ARE MAKING A FIVE YEAR
COMMITMENT.
TO THESE APPRENTICES WHERE
THEY'RE NOT ONLY PAID PREVAILING
WAGE A BUT THEY RECEIVE PENSION
CONTRIBUTIONS AND HEALTH CARE
BENEFITS BOTH FOR THEMSELVES AND
THEIR FAMILY. A THIS IS A
REASONABLE MEASURE UP AND
INDICATES THAT THE STRONG
SUPPORT OF THE LEGISLATURE OF
FOR APPRENTICESHIP AS THE PATH
TO CAREERS WE SUPPORTED STRONGLY
THINKING.
GIVE FINNAIR WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
ANY WITNESSES TO TESTIFY OR STAY
OF OPPOSITION.
SEEING NONE HOPE I'M SORRY.
GET OUT OR GOOD MORNING AT
DANIEL CAN BECAUSE ARE ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA TAX REFORM
ASSOCIATION. WE FULLY SUPPORT.
EXPANSION OF APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAMS BUT. WE BELIEVE THAT A
MORE EFFICIENT WAY TO REACH THE
AUTHOR STATED GOAL IS TO EXPAND
ON.
CURRENT APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS
IN THE STATE RATHER THAN THIS WE
ARE JUNO VOTE.
THANK YOU.
COLLEAGUES ARE CURRENTLY DOES
NOT A COMMENT AS WERE VOTING ON
ALL THESE TAX CREDIBILITY AS
WELL AS THE CHAIR OF
APPROPRIATIONS. I'D JUST WON A.
YOU KNOW THAT I AM SUPPORTING
SOME OF THESE BUT WILL BE
LOOKING AT THESE ARE ALL THESE
TAX CREDIT BILL THEM. TAX
DEDUCTION INSTEAD OF TAX
EXEMPTIONS.
A HUNDRED DIFFERENT LANDS.
WHEN THEY'RE AND APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE WE TAKE IT EVERYTHING
INTO ACCOUNT AND TERMS OF THE
SUSPENSE FILESIZE ONE MAKE THAT
NOTE AS WERE. A I DON'T WANT TO
CONFUSE MY VOTE FOR SOME OF
THESE TARA.
YEAH EXPRESS SUPPORT WHAT WERE
IN DELIBERATIONS IN THE SUSPENSE
FILE.
THANK YOU.
THROUGH THE CHAIR WERE ALL VERY
AWARE.
YEAH.
SCRUTINY.
BUT.
SAID A BILL.
NO.
.
DO THESE THESE APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAMS HAVE TO GO THROUGH SOME.
CERTIFICATION.
IN TERMS OF THE APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAM.
TWO BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE TAX
CREDIT.
AT THE OTHER WORDS YOU KNOW I I
CAN CALL.
YOU KNOW SOMEBODY AN APPRENTICE
IN AND.
CLAIM A TAX CREDIT BUT DO THEY
HAVE TO GO THROUGH SOME KIND.
CERTIFICATION.
TO BE FORMALLY DECLARED A
PRINTER PRINTERS I WOULD DEFER
TO MY LIVING WITH WITNESS BUT
ABSOLUTE.
.
I ACTUALLY I WOULD CONCUR WITH
THE RESPONSE PROVIDED BY A
SENATOR.
PATTERSON AND THAT YES OF THE
PROGRAM WOULD BE ADMINISTERED
THROUGH TO.
THE.
.
AGENCY BY ITS AT THE DIVISION
OF OUR DEPARTMENT OF.
.
GO THROUGH THE WHOLE.
GOES RELATIONS WHICH OVERSIGHTS
THOUGH. APPRENTICESHIPS.
WHO WHO OF?
YES THERE IS A SPECIAL PROGRAM
AND ONE OF THE AGENCIES THAT
CURRENTLY ADMINISTERS
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS AND THEY
WOULD ALSO BE THE ONE TO.
CERTIFIED THE APPRENTICES FOR
THIS PARTICULAR A MEASURE AS
WELL.
WHEN THAT BE THE THE VISION OF
APPRENTICESHIP STANDARDS YES
THANK YOU VERY MUCH BY I WAS
JUST RIGHT FOR THAT MATTER THAT
IS A KIND OF WENT BLANK.
SO THEY HAVE THEY HAVE CALM IN
THEIR PROGRAM.
.
A NUMBER.
A NUMBER OF CURRENT.
.
PEOPLE THAT ARE REGISTERED.
IN THAT PROGRAM AS AN APPRENTICE
PRESENTLY.
OUR PRESIDENT ENROLLEES ELIGIBLE
FOR THIS ORDER SISTERS
NEW. APPRENTICE.
OVERHEADS BUT F A GUY BAY ARE
EXTRA TO SUMMARIES ARE IN THE
FRIDGE PROGRAM I THINK THIS
PARTICULAR MEASURE IT IS A IT IS
SILENT ON THAT.
CERTAINLY IF THAT IS AN AREA
THAT IS OF INTEREST THEN PERHAPS.
YOU KNOW AMENDMENTS CAN BE
CONSIDERED TO YOU SPECIFICALLY
STATE THAT. I DID HAPPEN TO ALSO
NOTICE THAT IN SOME OF THE
STATISTICS PROVIDED BY THE D. A.
S..
THAT.
THERE IS A LOW PARTICIPATION
RATE ALSO BY WOMEN I THINK IT'S
ONLY A AS OF THEIR LAST RECORD
SIX PERCENT OF THE PARTICIPANTS.
WERE WERE WOMEN.
THAT COULD BE ANOTHER AREA THAT
COULD ALSO BE CONSIDERED.
I.
WELL MY PERSONAL OPINION IS ARE
VERY OPEN TO TAKING AMENDMENT
BUT. I HAD ALWAYS THOUGHT IN
TERMS OF GROWING THE PROGRAMS
AND THAT THIS WOULD BE AN
IMPETUS TO GROW THE PROGRAM AND
BRING MORE PEOPLE ACTORS I US.
SO REALLY WORRY SENATORS LIKE
FIFTY THOUSAND APPRENTICES.
OKAY SUM UP SOME OF THAT YOU
KNOW IS A LARGE NUMBER THERE ARE
TO REGISTER.
IN.
THOSE SYSTEM.
AND IF THESE PEOPLE HAVE TO BE
REGISTERED IN THIS SYSTEM.
YOU KNOW YOU WANT TO BE VERY
CLEAR ABOUT THAT THOUGH YOU KNOW
THEY CAN.
I CAN CALL.
ANYBODY ON OUR PREMISE AND GET
A TAX CREDIT THAT'S NOT.
NO YOU DON'T WANT THAT SO.
THE OTHER QUESTION IS WHAT KIND
OF A PROMISES IS THERE A RANGE
OF ELIGIBILITY WAS THAT ANY OF
PRESS.
DOT THERE ARE JUST SOME.
BASIC.
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS.
OR.
ONLY CERTAIN TYPES OF JOBS
REGISTERED UNDER THE LAW.
TO BE CLASSIFIED AS AN
APPRENTICE.
ARE SOME JAW IS THERE A LIMIT TO
THE TYPES OF APPRENTICES.
IN EXISTING STATUTES.
MAINLY BECAUSE WE ASSUME
CONSTRUCTION I KNOW WE HAVE A
PRESENCE THERE. BUT ARE I DON'T
KNOW IF OTHER INDUSTRIES HAVE.
APPRENTICES THOUGH.
YEAH OKAY IF THERE'S WE WE HAVE
IMMENSELY CONSTRUCTION THING. WE
HAVE AN EXPERT IF I MAY DEFER TO
OUR EXPERTS.
HE THE CHAIR OF ST REBEL OF THE
DIVISION OF APPRENTICESHIP
STANDARDS IN ADDITION TO THE A
TYPICAL CONSTRUCTION TRADES
WHICH MAKE UP THE BULK OF
REGISTERED APPRENTICES IN
CALIFORNIA. MOSTLY CONSTRUCTION
HOWEVER THERE ARE PRETTY SHOES A
PRINT SHIPS THAT ARE APPROVED IN
MANUFACTURING. COSMETOLOGY
HEALTH CARE OF THERE ARE NEW
PROGRAMS THAT ARE ACTUALLY
SPONSORED BY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA FOR IT SERVICES THOSE
ARE ALL RELATIVELY SMALL. BUT
CERTAINLY.
OVER NINETY PERCENT ARE IN THE
CONSTRUCTION TRADES RIGHT NOW IN
THE BILL ONLY APPLIES TO CREDIT
FOR THE FIRST TWO YEARS. OF THAT
THE APPRENTICE IS REGISTERED IN
THE PROGRAM SO IN TERMS OF YOUR
CONCERN.
ABOUT GROWING THE PROGRAM OR
THAT THE NUMBER OF APPRENTICES
THAT ARE ALREADY INDENTURED.
PASSED THE SECOND YEAR THAT
THEY ARE EMPLOYER WOULD NO
LONGER BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE
CREDIT.
I MEAN A PROM.
I BELIEVE IT'S OKAY AMASSING
SOME SPECIFIC QUESTIONS BECAUSE
I.
THAT YOU KNOW STUDY THIS ISSUE
VERY CAREFULLY IF MY OTHER
LEGISLATION.
.
SENATOR I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW.
AT SOME POINT.
AS WE PROCEED WITH THIS BILL.
WHAT KIND OF APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAMS?
ARE ELIGIBLE FOR THIS TAX CREDIT
VETOED LIST THAT WOULD HELP. SO.
AND I'M SURE SENATOR UMPS OF
ANDERSON CAN GET THAT BUT OF THE
NONTRADITIONAL PROGRAM'S STATED
YEARS ACCORD AS MENTIONS HEALTH
CARE. ADVANCED MANUFACTURING AND
ALSO INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
AS WELL.
IT WERE THEY HAVE TO BE
REGISTERED UNDER THE.
THE HAVE TO BE A REGISTERED
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM IS WHAT
I'M BRIGHT YOU DID THE DIVISION
OF OPPRESSION STANDARDS UP TO GO
THROUGH A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS.
OF APPLICANTS TO SPONSOR A STATE
REGISTERED APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAM.
AND THEIR SCRUTINIZED AND IF
THEY ARE IN THE CONSTRUCTION
TRADES THAN THOSE PROGRAMS HAVE
TO BE APPROVED BY THE CALIFORNIA
APPRENTICESHIP COUNCIL.
AND THEIR PRESSURE KRAUS WILL
CUT OUT LIKE A HUNDRED DIFFERENT
CATEGORIES TOMORROW.
IF THIS BILL PASSES THAT'S ONE
OF THE.
GET OUT AND GET NOW IT'S IT IT'S
UNLIKELY SENATOR WELL THAT'S
WHAT I WANT WHO CONTROLS THEM
YET THAT THE THE LABOR CODE IS
VERY SPECIFIC ON EXPANSION. OF.
CONSTRUCTION TRADES PROGRAMS
OTHERS WHAT'S CALLED THE NEEDS
TESTED LABOR CODE SECTION THIRTY
SEVENTY FIVE. THAT I REQUIRES A
DETERMINED SHORTAGE DEFINITION
IT AND ACTUALLY IT REQUIRES AN
ANALYSIS THAT THE EXISTING
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS IN THAT
REGION CANNOT ADEQUATELY SUPPORT
THE APPRENTICESHIP NEEDS BEFORE
NEW PROGRAMS. IN THE
ALRIGHT ALL OVER CONFER WITH THE
AUTHOR ON THIS A LITTLE BIT I
THINK.
I THINK.
.
MADAM CHAIR I THINK I SUPPORT
THE BILL I JUST HAVE THESE
QUESTIONS. OF I THINK GO.
IF WE'RE GOING TO GIVE A.
BENEFIT WITH THE TAX CREDIT
SHOULD BE FOR.
NEW NEW.
AREA AND SECONDLY IT PROBABLY
SHOULD BE FOR.
AREAS WHERE THERE'S SIGNIFICANT
DEFINED LABOR SHORTAGES IN
FIELDS THAT WE NEED.
CRITICAL WORKERS AND.
THAT COULD.
BENEFIT FROM AN APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAM.
BAH I KNOW CONSTRUCTION IS
OBVIOUSLY GOING TO BE ONE.
SINCE SO. THE OVER THE NEXT FEW
YEARS WE'RE GOING TO DO A LOT OF
CONSTRUCTION.
DUE TO SP ONE JUST WANT TO MAKE
A LITTLE COMMENT.
.
OTHERS GOT RELY CONSTRUCTION DO
THE HOUSING HOUSING.
NOSE AND THE CONSTRUCTION
INDUSTRY BUT THERE'S ALSO OTHER
AREAS THAT WE NEED LABOR SHORES
LIKE HEALTHCARE.
WE HAVE A CRITICAL SHORTAGE OF
EDUCATORS SO. THERE'S OTHER.
AND I DON'T KNOW IF THE DIVISION
OF THOSE. AS SOME KIND OF.
CRITERIA TO DIRECT THE TAX
CREDIT TO.
AREAS CALIFORNIA HAS A LABOR
SHORTAGE.
SO ANYWAY I'M JUST ASKING A
QUESTION SO YOU KIND OF.
MAYBE EVEN DEFINED THE PUBLIC
BENEFIT A LITTLE MORE ON THE TAX
CREDIT.
WHAT? SENATE BILL I I THINK YOU
MAKE A. THROUGH THE CHAIR I
THINK IT YOU MAKE SOME EXCELLENT
POINTS I THINK THAT ONE OF
THINGS THAT WE SHOULD
INCIDENT THAT YOU BROUGHT UP
THAT I HAD THOUGHT OF THIS.
THIS MONEY SHOULD NOT GO TO
APPRENTICESHIPS WORKSHOPS ARE
NOT WAITING FOR THOSE FOLKS.
TO TO TO GO THROUGH TRAINING.
AND THEN NOT HAVE A PLACE TO BE
EMPLOYED MAKES NO SENSE. SO I
AGREE WITH YOU ARE
WHOLEHEARTEDLY WILL GO BACK AND
LOOK AT THAT. TO NURTURE THAT
THERE'S SO THERE'S A CAREER PATH
AT THE END OF THE APPRENTICESHIP.
RIGHT.
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER COMMENT SENATOR MOORE
LA.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR.
SENATOR LARA WAS GOOD TO.
TALK ABOUT THAT.
OPERATIONS HURDLE.
IT IN THE NEXT HURDLE IS THE
GOVERNOR.
I SHOULD GET TO HIS DESK AND
HE'S BEEN.
PRETTY CONSISTENT. LONG AS I'VE
BEEN HERE THAT HE SEEMS TO VETO
CREDIT.
BILLS I'M JUST CURIOUS.
WHAT THE STRATEGY IS TO GET HIS
AUTOGRAPH ON THIS BILL? AB MY
STRATEGY IS GET NIVEAU FROM YOU
TODAY. AND MOVED TO THE NEXT
COMMITTEE.
RE GROUP AND AND GO AYE.
GETTING TO THE GOVERNOR'S DESK
IS SO FAR AWAY. I STILL HAVE TO
GO TO THE ASSEMBLY. AFTER GO
THROUGH OUR ARMY AND OF A
CHAIRMAN AND APPROPRIATIONS.
THERE'S A LOT OF HURDLES
THOUGHT I'M JUST.
YOU KNOW IT'S ALL GREAT TASKS
START WITH LITTLE STEPS AND THIS
IS JUST ANOTHER LITTLE STEP IN
THAT PATH.
SO CURRENTLY WERE.
PROBABLY AT OUR LOWEST.
UNEMPLOYMENT NUMBERS IN QUITE
SOME TIME SO WITH THIS.
THIS IS A CREDIT TO ENCOURAGE
HIRING.
I'M WONDERING IF THIS IS THE
RIGHT TIME OR ARE YOU EXPECTING
THE RECESSION THAT.
GOVERNOR BROWN'S BEEN TALKING
ABOUT. THE START ON JANUARY
FIRST TWENTY NINETEEN AND GO
THROUGH.
TWENTY TWENTY FOUR.
I AM.
I'M I I I'M NOT ISLAM IDEA
PROFITS OF THEM WHILE I'M I'M
NUYS LOFTY IN MY THOUGHTS. IT'S
VERY SIMPLE TO ME.
WHEN YOU MAKE AN INVESTMENT IN A
YOUNG PERSON'S LIFE.
IF GIVING THEM THAT
QUALIFICATIONS AND TRAINING TO
HAVE A CAREER. YOU'VE WON
IMPROVE THEIR LIFE INTO.
CREATED THE TAXPAYER. FOR THE
NEXT GOVERNOR BOTHERED. FOR HIS
BUDGET.
SO I'M LOOKING AT TO WE COULD.
IN THESE PEOPLE ON THE FRONT END.
SO WE CAN PAY FOR THEM ON THE
BACK. WHEN THEY'RE THEY'RE NOT
TAXPAYERS THEY'RE IN OUR PRISONS
ARE THERE ON THE STREETS AND SO
I'D RATHER MAKE AN INVESTMENT UP
FRONT. NOW I DON'T THINK THAT
EVERYBODY NEEDS TO GO TO COLLEGE
TO HAVE A GREAT CAREER. AND I
THINK THAT THESE APPRENTICESHIP
PROGRAMS THAT WE'RE TALKING
ABOUT HER FANTASTIC PROGRAMS
THAT THEY GIVE PEOPLE CAREERS. I
THINK IT'S
I THINK IT'S INCUMBENT UPON US
NOT TO THINK IN TERMS OF JOBS
BUT CAREERS. AND ALLOWING PEOPLE
TO CONTROL THEIR OWN DESTINY.
I THINK IT'S JUST REALLY
IMPORTANT I DON'T KNOW. IF THE
ECONOMY'S GOING TO CLASS TODAY
GOING CLAPS TOMORROW OR IF IT'S
GOING TO GROW. BUT I DO KNOW
THAT AFTER THEY FINISHED THESE
PARTNERSHIPS THEY'LL HAVE SKILL
SETS FOR LIFE THERE WILL PROVIDE
FOR THE AT THE ALLOW THEM TO
PROVIDE FOR THEIR FAMILY AND
THEIR FUTURE. IN A CAREER.
AND IT IS THAT IF THE BEAR A
BAND CHAIR A FEW LIKE. I'M HAPPY
TO USE THAT AS MY CLOTHES. THANK
YOU IS THERE A MOTION.
I'M OF THE BATTLE.
WITH AMENDMENTS SAYS HE SAID.
THIS IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS PLEASE CALL FOR
THE VOTE.
CHOIR WHEN I WHEN I HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG.
LARA.
MORLOCK.
LYRICAL BILL NO UPSURGE SENATOR
PELL WE WILL WORK ON
THE WILL CALL OPEN.
HUMANITARIAN.
BEFORE WE GET YOUR NEXT ONE A
MINUTE JUST ASK FOR. CALL VOTE
ON CONSENT ITEMS.
WE HAVE TO CONSENT ITEMS.
CONSENT ITEM TO S. B. ONE ZERO
EIGHT FOUR SENATOR BERRYHILL AND
THEN THE SECOND CONSENT ITEM IS.
ITEM ELEVEN S. B. TWELVE FIFTY
ONE WHICH IS THE CHAIRMAN'S BILL.
AND THAT'S IT PLEASE CALL FOR
THE VOTE.
I'M SORRY GUEST PRESCRIPTION.
MCGUIRE WHEN I WHEN I BELL BILL
I'VE HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG. LARA
MORE LOCK MORE LUCK GUY MEANS
THE. THREE ZERO WILL KEEP THE
WILL CALL OPEN THANK YOU SENATOR
ANDERSON.
ALLOWING.
S. B. TWELVE TWELFTH COMPLETE
PICTURE NAM CHAIR OF MY NEXT
MY PACK MY MIDDLE CLASS THE
WORKING POOR RELIEF PACKAGE. SP
TWELVE TWELVE WILL INCREASE THE
RUNNERS CREDIT.
UNFORTUNATELY NOT EVERYONE IS
SAFE IS ABLE TO AFFORD A HOME.
AND CLEARLY VERY FEW YOUNG
PEOPLE STARTING OFF IN THEIR
CAREER ARCHEAN PURCHASE A HOME.
WHEN THEY'RE ENTERING THE
WORKFORCE.
IN MANY SENIORS CHOOSE TO RUN IS
THEY REQUIRE MORE CARE OR ANSWER
LIFESTYLE CHANGES.
EITHER WAY RENTAL PRICES
CONTINUE TO RISE IN THE COST OF
LIVING BECOMES UNAFFORDABLE.
CALIFORNIA'S RENTAL CREDIT
HASN'T BEEN A TRUSTED IN A
QUARTER OF A CENTURY.
S. B. TWELVE TWELVE WOULD HELP
ADJUST FOR INFLATION.
I AND ASSIST THOSE WHO NEED THE
HELP MOST BY INCREASING THE
SINGLE FILER CREDIT FROM SIXTY
DOLLARS TO TWO HUNDRED FIFTY.
AND A JOINT FILERS CREDIT FROM A
HUNDRED AND TWENTY TWO FIVE
HUNDRED.
AGAIN WITH ME IS CYNTHIA
PURCHASE FROM THE OFFICE OF THE
HONORABLE DRONE CORDON MEMBER OF
THE STATE BOARD OF EQUALIZATION.
AND HE'S THE SPONSORED THIS TAX
MEASURE.
THEY'RE BUSY TODAY.
CHEERS YES I M..
HIS FULL HEAD THEY BELIEVE IS A
SPORT ON BOTH SIDES.
GOOD MORNING VICE CHAIR MEMBERS
OF THE COMMITTEE.
CALIFORNIA HAS TWO THIRDS OF
LOWEST HOMEOWNERSHIP RATE IN THE
FOURTH HIGHEST RENT IN THE
COUNTRY.
HOUSING COSTS ARE BURDEN ON
FINANCES WHEN THEY SURPASSED
THIRTY PERCENT OF INCOME AND
NEARLY ONE IN THREE RENT OUR
HOUSE HAS SPENT AT LEAST HALF OF
THEIR INCOME. ON RENT ACCORDING
TO A PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE OF
CALIFORNIA STUDY. THE COST OF
RENTING AN APARTMENT OR HOME IS
AT IS AS HIGH AS IT'S EVER BEEN
IN FACT MANY MILLENNIALS ARE
MOVING FROM CALIFORNIA BECAUSE
THE DREAM OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
SEEMS SO UNLIKELY. IT'S
NECESSARY THAT WE DO SOMETHING
TO LOWER THE COST OF RUNNING
ONCE RESIDENTS IN THE STATE
PARTICULARLY SINCE THERE HAVE
BEEN MANY. INITIATIVES AND
MEASURES THAT HAVE.
HELP HOMEOWNERS BUT RARELY EVER
DID.
PROVIDE ANY RELIEF OR
ASSISTANCE TO YOU.
THE RENTER POPULATION AND WITH
THAT.
MEMBER HORTON ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT.
YOU HAVE ANY OTHER WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT.
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION.
SCENE NINE COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS
COMMENTS OR IF I CAN ASK FOR A
MOTION. SENATOR BELL. OF.
IF YOU HAVE CALM.
LOOK AT HOUSING.
ISSUES.
.
HE WANTED TARGET THERE'S.
.
REYNOLDS.
RENTAL.
.
WHAT DID YOU COME UP WITH THE
NUMBER THE INCOME LEVELS WHERE
THOSE COME FROM?
BUT THEY BASED ON SIR THAT
MEDIAN FAMILY INCOME. OR OR YOU
LOOKING OUT TO SOME OTHER FACTOR
DETERMINE.
.
THOUGH.
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND AND FIFTY
THOUSAND OR IS THERE JUST OF A
NUMBER.
PICKED OUT OF THE ERROR WHERE
THAT COME FROM A. CONVO THEIR
INCOME LEVELS WHERE WHAT WAS
ALREADY EXISTING AND CURRENT LAW.
SO.
SO JUST KEEPS THAT THE YOU KNOW
HOW LONG HAS THAT BEEN THERE.
AT THE EARLY MAKES TWENTY FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS A YEAR IN MY
AREA WELL IT'S ACTUALLY DJUSTED
ANNUALLY FOR INFLATION.
AND SO THE ACTUAL AMOUNT IS.
HIGHER AND BASED ON THAT
ADJUSTMENT.
IT'LL BE ADJUSTED YES.
.
THAT'S WITHIN THE OF THE OTHER
QUESTION WOULD BE.
.
SKINNER COSTS.
GENERAL FUND LIKE.
THREE HUNDRED BILLION OR MAYBE
MORE.
DID YOU CONSIDER IN THE BILL A
ARM.
BOB SAID A THING.
REDUCTION.
IT'S SOME OTHER HOUSING AREA TO
COMPENSATE.
TO BE REVENUE NEUTRAL.
IN TERMS OF THE TAX CREDIT.
ARE CONSIDERED.
BUT OFFICE SAID.
A ARE SAID TO THREE HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS THAT ACROSS THE
STATE GENERAL FUND.
YES.
MEMBER HORTON IS QUITE AWARE
THAT THERE ARE SEVERAL EXISTING
TAX EXPENDITURES THAT ARE NOT
CURRENTLY FULLY UTILIZED AND
BASICALLY THOUGHT THAT SOME OF
THAT UNDER UTILIZED OF PORTION
OF THE.
ALLOCATIONS COULD BE APPLIED
TOWARDS. THIS PARTICULAR
EXPENDITURE WHICH ONES TRICKERY
ARE YOU.
CALIFORNIA COMPETES COMES TO
MIND AND.
THERE ARE TWO OTHERS I ACTUALLY
HAVE SOME OF THAT INFORMATION
UNFORTUNATELY I DID NOT BRING IT
WITH ME TODAY BUT I CAN ALSO
PROVIDE IT TO YOU. A AND YOUR
PHONE TO YOUR OFFICE.
THEY ARE HOME.
I THINK.
LE JUST.
IF YOU.
SENATOR TO THREE HUNDRED MILLION.
HIT ON THE GENERAL FUND THAT'S
KIND OF A HIGH MOUNTAIN TO CLIMB
HERE.
YOU KNOW.
MEAN YOU WE WANT TO HELP RENTERS
BUT THE SAME TIME.
SO HIGH MOUNT THE CLIMB.
AND.
.
I THINK YOU MIGHT CONSIDER.
IF THIS IS A REASONABLE THING TO
DO.
LOOK AT IT FROM A BIGGER
STANDPOINT ABOUT.
WHO SHOULD GET A TAX EXPENDITURE?
AN AREA HOUSING WHERE THE HOUSES
DUCKS VENTURES ARE GOING.
AT THIS TIME.
TO OFFSET IT.
THIS OF A LARGE BUREAU.
ANNUALIZED BECAUSE ON THE
GENERAL FUND.
IT IS YOU HAVE TO.
RECORD A BOUNCER BOOKS EVERY
YEAR SO.
THAT'S SOMETHING I WOULD LIKE
YOU TO.
LOOK AT. MAKA ANDA AUDIT MIGHT
ALSO ADD THAT I BELIEVE RECENT
REPORTS HAVE INDICATED A AT THAT
THE.
.
STATE REVENUES BASICALLY HAVE
BEEN EXCEEDING.
CURRENT.
BUDGET IT FORECAST SO THAT
COULD POTENTIALLY ALSO BE
ANOTHER SOURCE OF FUNDING.
AND WE CAN SHOW US THE THREE.
UNDER UTILIZED.
AREAS THAT THAT COULD BE APPLIED
TOWARDS IT AS AN OFFSET.
OKAY.
I JUST WANT TO POINT OUT THAT
THOUGH.
THE GENERAL FUND IS.
SIMPLY RECOVERING FROM.
THE TWO THOUSAND SEVEN.
EIGHT BUDGET.
WORD DRIPPED.
PRECIPITOUSLY.
.
FOURTEEN BILLION DOLLARS AS NOW
CLIMB BACK.
ABOVE WHERE IT WAS.
TEN YEARS AGO.
SO WAS OF RATHER VERY VERY.
SIGNIFICANT TROUGH THAT WAS
CREATED.
SOME PEOPLE ONLY LOOK AT THE
RISE IN THE GENERAL FUND.
BUT I LOOK AT A LONGER TERM VIEW
CAN SEE THIS BIG TROUGH THAT
OCCURRED.
AND THEY'RE STILL ALLOT OF
PROGRAMS THAT ARE.
THERE WERE ELIMINATED.
DURING THAT TEN YEAR PERIOD.
THAT REMAIN.
UNFUNDED.
OF FROM PROGRAMS THAT WERE
FUNDED BY FOR MANY MANY DECADES
BY THE STATE CALIFORNIA.
OF SUCH AS EDUCATION AND OTHER
AREAS SO.
THIS IS THIS IS THE CONCERN
ABOUT.
NO OFFSETTING THE TAX CREDIT.
THE ISSUE IS WE DON'T WANT TO
AFFECT THE EDUCATION PART OF THE
BUDGET FOR EXAMPLE THAT.
SENATOR I THINK THROUGH THE
CHAIR I THINK THAT.
YOU HAVE EXCELLENT POINTS I
THINK THAT WILL HAVE TO. PUT A
PACKAGE TOGETHER WILL GET TO
APPROPRIATIONS TO SHOW THOSE
OFFSETS.
BECAUSE.
THE CHAIR FROM APPROPRIATIONS
HAS.
VERY SCRUTINY SCRUTINIZES
EVERYTHING VERY CLOSELY AND I
THINK THAT'S AN EXCELLENT POINT
THOSE MEMBERS.
I THINK MY.
TO LEARN MORE LOT.
YOU'RE NOTHING THINNER BELLS.
GETTING TO THE KEY QUESTION AND
AND YOU TOUCHED ON IT BUT.
IF IF THESE CREDITS YOU MUCH THE
GENERAL FUND BUT WHAT ABOUT.
THE PROP NINETY EIGHT EDUCATION
SIDE IS THAT. ALLOCATED THE SAME
WAY.
FORTY PERCENT.
PROP NINETY EIGHT SIXTY PERCENT.
GENERAL FUND WITHIN. WERE WERE
IMPACTING THE EDUCATIONAL BUDGET
TO WRITE.
IT'S VERY FORGET THE.
OKAY AND THEN.
THEN A RIVER ABOUT FORTY PERCENT
OF OUR RESIDENTS RUNNERS.
SO.
I JUST DID IT CENTER BELL CAME
OVER THREE HUNDRED MILLION AYE I
HAVEN'T SEEN ANY NUMBER. CAN IN
THAT THE BRIEFINGS SO.
I'M JUST CURIOUS.
FUND UP PAGES THIRD OF THOSE
STATS.
FORECAST ARE PROJECTED TO BE TWO
HUNDRED NINETY MILLION IN TWENTY
NINETEEN TWENTY N. AND THREE
HUNDRED MILLION HUNDRED TWENTY
TWENTY TWENTY ONE EIGHT TWENTY
ONE. YES.
TWO HUNDRED AND ADVICE YOU KNOW
THEY CAN.
YES.
EVEN IF WE HAVE ANOTHER BILL OF
THE SAME NATURE OF THAT WILL BE
HEARING SOON.
SP ELEVEN A TWO BY SENATOR
LAZER AYE ANY COMMENTS ABOUT.
WORKING TOGETHER OR.
JUST GONNA MOVE THEM BOTH
THROUGH AND WE.
THAT THE GOVERNOR DECIDED.
WELL.
IF WE BOTH GET TO THE GOVERNOR I
SUSPECT ONE OF THEM'S
NOCTURNALLY OF APPROPRIATIONS.
BUT.
I'M I I CANNOT IMAGINE THE
GOVERNOR NOT CHOOSING ONE.
YEAH AND.
.
SENATOR GLAZERS BILL AS I
BELIEVE IS THAT SENATOR GLAZERS
THAT HASN'T YET.
OUR I I SUPPORT THAT BILL TO I
THINK IT'S.
I I THINK THAT THESE FOLKS.
NEED RELIEF.
WE IS PRETTY QUARTER OF A
CENTURY SINCE I'VE HAD ANY
ADJUSTMENT.
AND WHAT WE'VE DONE HOMEOWNER
EXEMPTION. ADJUSTMENTS FOR
HOMEOWNERS AND WE'VE DONE OTHER
THINGS FOR
FOR HOMEOWNERS WHO'VE DONE VERY
LITTLE. FOR RENTERS
AND THAT POPULATION WALL.
IT'S LARGE
STILL DESERVES.
OUR OUR FOCUS SHOULD BE AND LAY
XIN ADJUSTMENTS.
THE CENTER THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR
THANK YOU.
THE OTHER DIDN'T ADVENTURE IF I
COULD PLEASE THAT THE.
THREE BILLS ON THE TABLE THIS
YEAR YOURS PLAGIARISM ASSEMBLY
MEMBER. SANTIAGO'S AND HE HAS.
SOMETHING I I KIND OF LIKE AND
THAT'S THE.
INCREASING THE CREDIT BASED ON
THE MEDIAN RENT OF THAT RENDERS
SAID THE SO THAT'S.
THAT'S A KIND OF IMPORTANT AND.
ARE I'M SORRY SIR BUT I DIDN'T
HEAR YOU SING THOUGH. THE RENTER
CREDIT BASED ON THE MEDIAN RENT
AND A IN A RENTERS CITY AND.
PLEASE BASIN ON KIND OF ALL.
THE YOU KNOW REFLECTING ON THE
DIFFERENCES IN RENTS.
AND VARIOUS AREAS OF.
CALIFORNIA IN THE FOR ABILITY TO
SERVE ON AFFORDABILITY.
.
REQUIREMENT THAT THE JUST THE
RUNNER CREDIT BASED ON
AFFORDABILITY.
SO IF IT'S A HIGHER RENT AREA.
THERE'S AN ADJUSTMENT BASED ON
THAT I HAVE I I THOUGHT ABOUT.
THROUGH THE CHAIR I THOUGHT
ABOUT DOING SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
THE DIFFICULTY IS RANCHERS
SOMETIMES MOVE FOR JOBS AND
OTHER REASONS
AND IF THEY'RE MOVING THROUGHOUT
THE STATE. THEN WOULD BE
SPENDING MORE MONEY CHASING DOWN
WHERE THERE WAS ACCURATE
ACCURATELY REFLECTED YESES TO
DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES THAT
PERSON LIVED Y. WAS PRO RATED
CORRECTLY. AS OPPOSED TO
SOMETHING THAT'S JUST SIMPLE AND
STRAIGHTFORWARD ARE I DON'T WANT
TO MAKE IT MORE CONFUSING. I
JUST WHY DO SOME SIMPLE.
WE EAT WE YOU COULD MAKE THAT
ARGUMENT UNDER THE CURRENT
SYSTEM WE HAVE NOW IS IT'S A
FLAT RUNNERS CREDIT. IS I
THOUGHT.
KEEPING CONSISTENT WITH WHAT
WE'VE DONE IN THE PAST.
WOULD MAKE IT BETTER I WOULD
HATE TO HAVE TO HIRE.
A BUNCH OF.
EMPLOYEES.
JUST TO ENSURE THAT PEOPLE ARE
GETTING THEIR CRACKED CREDIT
WHEN WHEN WITH THE CURRENT FORM
IS STRAIGHTFORWARD.
THAT BUT THAT WAS MY RATIONALE.
OF DO YOU THINK GOOD
INCREASINGLY.
MEMBER BOARD STAFF YOU THINK
THAT INCREASING THE SUPPLY OF
RENTAL HOUSING.
WOULD AFFECTED.
.
THE.
.
THE.
RANTS GO FOR PEOPLE IN
CALIFORNIA.
AND HOW WOULD THAT AFFECT THE
RUNNERS TALK SCREWED IF WE
INCREASE THE SUPPLY OF RENTAL
HOUSING.
WELLS CERTAINLY.
WERE ILLEGAL HOUSING IF IF YOU
CONSIDER THE CONCEPT OF SUPPLY
AND DEMAND I THINK THEN THAT BY
INCREASING IT ULTIMATELY
HOPEFULLY IT SHOULD HAVE.
IT SHOULD BECAUSE PERHAPS THE
RENTAL.
.
COST TO.
BEGAN TO DECLINE WELL A LITTLE
BIT AND OF COURSE.
.
I THINK THAT THE EXISTING AMOUNT
OF THE RICHEST CREDIT IS PERHAPS
A BIT IT'S SUFFICIENT
CONSIDERING THAT IT WAS
IMPLEMENTED BACK AND I THINK.
.
AS. THE LATE NINETIES.
AND CERTAINLY IT IT WARRANT
SOME KIND OF ADJUSTMENT
CONSIDERING THE INFLATION THAT
HAS OCCURRED OVER THE. PAST
TWENTY PLUS YEARS OF WE HAD IT
HOUSING IT'S SO TO QUALIFIES FOR.
THE PEOPLE THAT WE HAVEHERE.
UNDER YOUR BILL.
OF SENATOR.
THE.
.
TWENTY FIVE AND FIFTY THOUSAND.
DOLLARS WITH THAT JUST MONTHS.
WHO THE INCREASE OF SUPPLY OF OF
HOUSING?
AND THAT COULD HAVE A MILL RATE
MAYBE THE COST OF THE BILL.
AT SOME POINT IT IN I THINK
HOPEFULLY WILL YOU SUPPLY MORE
HOUSING FOR FOR FOLKS TO A PHONE.
GETTING AMMAR DIRECTORAL SO THAT
ARE SO IT'S WOULD NEED RIGHT
AWAY RIGHT IAN IN NOW SO THINGS
THAT.
HERE'S A PERSON ARE GAS MORE
PEOPLE RENT THAT MEANS THERE'S
MORE WORKERS.
THAT MEANS THERE'S MORE WORKERS
INCOME TAXES SO WE'RE GONNA SEE.
AN INCREASE IN REVENUE OFFSET.
OFFSETTING THIS CREDIT BECAUSE
WILL BE MORE WORKERS IN
CALIFORNIA.
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER COMMENTS MAY I ASK FOR
A MOTION.
I WILL MOVE IT.
THERE'S A MOTION VICE.
SENATOR BELL WOULD SHE LIKE TO
PLEASE BECAUSE I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
BUT THIS IS DO PASSING
APPROPRIATIONS PLEASE CALL FOR
THE VOTE CHOIR WHEN I WHEN I
BAIL. BILL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA. MORLOCK.
TWO ZERO TWO ZERO WILL KEEP THE
WILL CALL OPENED THANK YOU THANK
YOU MA'AM CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS.
SO WHERE GOING ON FILE AYE.
ORDER. A I SEE SENATOR DODD.
AND THEN AFTER THAT WILL BE
SENATOR GLAZERS.
SORRY I WAS BEEN I'VE BEEN TOLD
BY THE CHAIR THE WOULD YOU FLY
ORDER.
SO AS MEMBERS COMMAND I'M.
TAKING THEM BY THE ORDER OF THE
ITEM.
SENATOR DODD.
IN THIS CHAIR AND MEMBERS TODAY
I AM BUT I PRESENTING S. B. NINE
FIFTY EIGHT.
I LIKE TO START BY THANKING THE
CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
THEIR DILIGENT WORK ON THIS BILL.
IN KNOW THAT I'LL BE ACCEPTING
THE AMENDMENTS REQUEST BY THE
CHAIR OUTLINED IN THE COMMITTEE
ANALYSIS.
FOR DECADES THE CITY OF DAVIS
HAS APPROVED LOCAL PARCEL TAXES
TO FUND THE DAVIS JOINT SCHOOL
DISTRICT EDUCATION PROGRAMMING.
REAFFIRMING A LOCAL COMMITMENT
TO PRIORITIZING HIGH QUALITY
EDUCATION TO THE COMMITTEE
COMMUNITY.
AS AMENDED S. B. NINE FIFTY
EIGHT IS A DISTRICT BILL THAT
WOULD AUTHORIZE A DAVIS JOINT
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT. TO
ALLOW PARCEL TAX EXEMPTION FOR
TEACHERS AND SCHOOL EMPLOYEES.
IN ADDITION TO SS I RECIPIENTS
IN SENIORS THAT ALSO RECEIVED A
PARCEL TAX EXEMPTION.
THIS BILL WILL PROVIDE
ADDITIONAL INCENTIVES FOR PUBLIC
EDUCATION EDUCATORS AND SCHOOL
STAFF TO LIVE IN THE COMMUNITY
OF DAVIS WHERE THEY WORK.
THIS FINANCIAL BENEFIT IS
IMPORTANT PARTICULARLY IN THE
LIGHT OF THE HIGH COST OF LIVING
THE TEACHERS MUCH SHOULDER IN
ORDER TO LIVE IN THEIR PLACE OF
WORK.
IT IS IMPERATIVE THE TEACHERS
WRECKED ARE RECOGNIZED FOR THE
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT ROLE THEY
PLAY IN SERVING THEIR
COMMUNITIES.
I AM PROUD TO PRESENT THIS BILL
IN ORDER TO PROVIDE A TOOL FOR
TEACHERS AND SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
AND DAVIS AND LOOK FORWARD TO
CONTINUING TO EXPLORE STATEWIDE
OPPORTUNITIES TO SUPPORT. OUR
HARD WORKING PUBLIC SECTOR
EDUCATORS WITH ME TODAY IN
SUPPORT IS ALLEN FERNANDES ON
BEHALF OF THE. BILL SPONSORED
DAVIS JOINT UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT THAT BLAIR. HOWARD A
TEACHER WITH THE DAVIS CASE
JOINT UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
GREAT THANK YOU.
MADAM CHAIR BUT MADAM VICE
CHAIR SENATORS ALLEN FERNANDEZ
SAW ON BEHALF OF THE DAVIS JOINT
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT I WHERE
I SERVED AS A TRUSTEE IN ELECTED
TRUSTEE OF THE BOARD. THIS THIS
MEASURE IS SPONSORED BY THE
DISTRICT.
IT HAD THE UNANIMOUS SUPPORT OF
MY COLLEAGUES ON A FIVE ZERO
VOTE. AND I THINK THE SENATOR
OUTLINED IT PERFECTLY WHAT WE'RE
DOING HERE OR ASKING FOR IS SOME
FLEXIBILITY FROM THE STATE.
ON HOW WE CAN ALLOCATE THE
LOCALLY PASSED REVENUES THAT OUR
CITIZENS HAVE. THAT PROBABLY
CONTINUOUSLY SUPPORTED SINCE
NINETEEN EIGHTY FOUR WE HAVE
REPEATEDLY DONE TO OUR VOTERS
AND MET THAT TWO THIRDS
THRESHOLD EVERY SINGLE TIME
BECAUSE THEY HAVE A HIGH DEGREE
OF CONFIDENCE. THAT WE ARE GOOD
STEWARDS OF OUR PUBLIC RESOURCES.
THAT BECAUSE OF THE RECENT
CHANGES TO LC FF THE LOCAL
CONTROL FUNDING FORMULA.
DISTRICTS LIKE OURS A WILL OVER
TIME SEAT DISPARITY IN FUNDING
WHICH MEANS THAT THERE WILL BE
OF GROWING.
ISSUE FOR US TO MEET THE
DEMANDS OF OUR WORK FORCE IN
SPECIFICALLY.
A YOU KNOW ALLOWING THEM TO
LIVE AND WORK IN THE CAN
ANY AND WE THINK
THIS MEASURE UP PROVIDES OF THE
FIRST STEP IN THAT. IN THAT
DIRECTION I WANT TO THINK THAT.
COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS IN THE
CHAIR WORKING WITH US.
WERE SUPPORTIVE OF THE
NARROWING THAT WE DO THINK IT
MERITS STATEWIDE CONSIDERATION
AT SOME POINT IN THE FUTURE AND
WE'D LIKE THE OPPORTUNITY. TO
PROVE THIS CONCEPT.
TO BRING BACK FOR FURTHER
CONSIDERATION DOWN THE ROAD.
AND I KNOW.
ARAB BLAIR HOWARD IS AN ACTUAL
REAL TEACHER IN DAVIS AND CAN.
AT FIRST AND ON LIVING AND
WORKING IN THE COMMUNITY NOW BUT.
THE DIFFICULTIES FOR OUR YOUNG
TEACHERS.
PRIOR SO.
GO AHEAD GOOD MORNING AND.
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
TO SPEAK ON THIS ISSUE MY NAME'S
BLAIR HOWARD AND I'M A TEACHER
AND DAVIS.
IT WAS A DECADES LONG CHALLENGE
FOR ME TO A BE ABLE TO AFFORD TO
BUY A HOME IN THE COMMUNITY IN
WHICH I TEACH.
BOB I WAS ABLE TO DO THIS
BECAUSE THE CITY DEVELOP SOME
AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
AND I WAS ABLE TO BY HOUSE WELL
BELOW. MARKET PRICE.
AT AS WELL AS MY AND INCOME
FINALLY.
IMPROVING ENOUGH TO BE ABLE TO
AFFORD A HOME.
DAVIS IS LONG VALUE TEACHERS AS
MEMBERS OF THEIR COMMUNITY WITH
EDUCATION TYING COMMUNITY.
TOOK TIME THE COMMUNITY
TOGETHER IN SO MANY WAYS LIVING
IN TOWN AND NOT COMMUTING ALLOWS
ME TO SPEND MORE TIME AT MY
SCHOOL.
WORKING WITH STUDENTS IN
IMPROVING THEIR LEARNING I TEACH
AT A CONTINUATION SCHOOL WITH.
IN OF STUDENTS WHO EXEMPLIFY
THE ACHIEVEMENT GAP WHO HAVE A A
NUMBER OF STRUGGLES AND SO EVERY.
HOUR I CAN SPEND WITH THEM IN
ADDITION IS.
IS IS A BENEFIT TO THEM.
UNFORTUNATELY LESS STATE
FUNDING COMPARED TO SURROUNDING
DISTRICTS HAS LED TO A
COMPENSATION GAP PAIRED WITH
HIGHER HOME PRICES.
THAT UP PRICED MANY YOUNGER
TEACHERS LIKE MYSELF OUT OF
BUYING A HOME IN THE COMMUNITY
OR HONESTLY EVEN AFFORDING RENT
IN DAVIS.
I LOVE TEACHING AND DAVIS AND
BEING ABLE TO LIVE IN TOWN HAS
KEPT ME THERE DESPITE KNOWING I
COULD MAKE THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS.
OF MORE DOLLARS I'M COMMUTING OR
LIVING IN ANOTHER COMMUNITY.
BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT MANY
TEACHERS HAVE LEFT THROUGH THE
YEARS TO TAKE JOBS IN OTHER
DISTRICTS CLOSER TO HOME. OR
WHERE.
THEY THEY CAN A FOR A AFFORD WE
HAVE SEVERAL T. I KNOW SEVERAL
TEACHERS WHO ARE ABLE TO LIVE IN
TOWN WORK IN OTHER DISTRICTS.
AND A YOU KNOW IN THE FOR THE
LIVING DAVIS BECAUSE THOSE DATE
THOSE.
DISTRICTS PAY THEM. ENOUGH TO
AFFORD IN DAVIS THEY'D LIKE TO
TEACH IN DAVIS I TALK TO THEM
TRY TO RECRUIT THEM. AND THEY.
CAN'T QUITE DO IT.
.
IF THE STATE IS NOT GOING TO
JUST FUNDING TO ALLOW DISTRICTS
LIKE DAVIS TO ATTRACT AND RETAIN
TEACHERS IS MEMBERS THAT OUR
COMMUNITY. THAT I WOULD ASK FOR
THE ABILITY OF THE COMMUNITY OF
DAVIS TO CHOOSE WHETHER OR NOT
TO PUT MORE MONEY IN THE POCKETS
OF TEACHERS. SO THEY CONTINUE TO
LIVE AND SERVING THE COMMUNITY
THANK YOU.
BUT SIR.
WE'RE NOT GONNA OPEN UP TO ALL
THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT WE'RE
GOING TO ASK YOU TO JUST DIE
SENIOR FOR SOME LAST SEEN IN OR
ANY ORGANIZATION WE WELCOME YOU
MA'AM.
TONY TO CAROL AND THEY HAVE THE
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
WERE IN FULL SUPPORT THANK YOU
SO MUCH WITH ACTIVITY SEAT
THERE'S ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT
IF YOU COULD PLEASE ADVANCE AT
THIS TIME ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT
LAST CALL.
WE'RE NOT GOING TO BRING BACK TO
COMMITTEE AND OFFER THOSE WHO
ARE.
BUT WHO ARE OPPOSED AND WE'RE
GONNA WELCOME MISTER WILL FLAT
TO COMMITTEE MISTER WHAT FOLLOWS
COULD SEE SIR MISTER CHAIRMAN
THANK YOU AND WELCOME BACK THEY
THINK IT'S SO MUCH I APOLOGIZE I
I REALLY DO I'M SO SORRY WAS A
TIME I CAN. BE WITH SENATOR DODD
THOUGH IT TALKING ON ALL ISSUES
FIRE AND IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT
I'M I'M REALLY GRATEFUL I IN
DUPAGE YOUR PATIENTS HAVE SOME.
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS GOOD
MORNING DAVID WILL FOR THE
HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION WERE OPPOSED TO U.
S. B. NINE FIFTY EIGHT HERE
TODAY. MEMBERS TO START OUT WE
DO APPRECIATE THE AMENDMENT
NARROWING THE BELTS ONE DISTRICT
HOWEVER WE MUST CONTINUE UP
SPACETIME. SALAS OFF OR REASONS.
MEMBERS HOWARD JARVIS HAS A LONG
HISTORY IN THIS CODE SECTION.
WE ACTUALLY WORK THAT TEN MEN
THE BILL TO AMEND THIS CODE
SECTION POSITIVELY LAST YEAR AND
ALSO OPPOSED I'M EXPANDING THE
EXEMPTION TO THOSE ON SSI AND A
SOCIETY FIVE YEARS AGO SO WERE
WELL VERSED IN THIS CODE SECTION.
WE APPRECIATE MEMBERS THAT EVEN
THOUGH THE BILL HAS AN OPT IN
PROFOUND PROPOSAL AND IS IT THAT
DISCRETION OF THE SCHOOL
DISTRICT IN ORDER TO TAKE IT OUT.
WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT A
SLIPPERY SLOPE.
AND BASICALLY JUST THE ROLE OF
THE CONTINUED TWO THIRDS VOTE
AND PERSONAL TAXES. WITH ALL DUE
RESPECT TO TEACHERS AND SCHOOL
DISTRICT EMPLOYEES
JUST LIKE PARENTS WE THINK THEY
SHOULD HAVE SKIN IN THE GAME TO.
GET THE PERSONAL TAXES TOO
AGGRESSIVE FORWARD SOME TEACHERS
TO PAY MAYBE IT'S AN INDICATION
THAT THE TAX SHOULDN'T BE ON THE
BALLOT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
AND AGAIN THERE'S A SLIPPERY
SLOPE HERE MEMBERS AS WELL IF WE
ADOPT THIS BILL DOESN'T MEAN
WATER AND TRANSPORTATION
EMPLOYEE SHOULD BE EXEMPTED FROM
SPECIAL TAXES THAT IMPACT THEM.
MEMBERS THE MORE PEOPLE THAT ARE
EXEMPTED FROM PAYING PERSONAL
TAXES THE LESS VALUE.
THE TWO THIRDS VOTE WILL HAVE
IN THEIR US REVENUE THAT THE
SCHOOL DISTRICT WILL GENERATE
WILL BE LESS REVENUE IS A RESULT
OF THIS BILL PASSING. SO BEFORE
WE CONTINUE DO EXAMS.
EXISTING CLASSES THE PEOPLE
FROM HANG PERSONAL TAXES.
AND DUST PLACE MORE THE TAX
BURDEN ON MIDDLE CLASS PROPERTY
OWNERS I THINK WE SHOULD VERY
CAREFULLY THINK WHAT WE'RE DOING
HERE ASK FOR ANOTHER. PICKY SO
MUCH AS WHAT WE KNOW WOULD LIKE
TO WELCOME ANYONE ELSE WHO'D
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION IF
YOU COULD PLEASE ADVANCE AT THIS
TIME ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION
TO PLEASE COME FOR.
LAST CALL.
WHEN I MEAN BRINGING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE WOULD LIKE TO BE TO
SEE IF WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FOR OR SENATOR DIED
FROM THE COMMITTEE.
BUT WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
BELL THIS IS A DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO THE FLOOR A AND I
ALSO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO
SENATOR DODD FOR.
WORKING WITH THE COMMITTEE TO
BE ABLE TO AND THEN THE BILL
THAT SENATOR DODD WOULD YOU LIKE
TO GET OFF A CLOSING COMMENT SIR.
YOU KNOW I I REALLY APPRECIATE
THE COMMITTEE STAFF AND AND YOU
MISTER CHAIR FOR WORKING WITH US
ON THIS BILL TO MOVE A LINE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE BUT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AGAIN THIS IS
A MOVE BY SENATOR BALLOT THANK
YOU SENATOR DODD FOR ALL YOUR
WORK ON THIS SIR THIS IS A DO
PASS IS AN INDIGENT THE FLOOR
MISS LANE CHESTER ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE REQUIRE AYE. WIRE AYE
NGUYEN.
WHEN NOBEL BILL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA MORLOCK.
WE'RE NOT KNOWN TO.
BUT CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO TWO I
SAID I WOULD KEEP THE ROLE
OPENING HAVE FOLKS ADELINE THINK
SO MUCH SENATOR DR MEMBERS THANK
YOU.
MEMBERS WE NOW CAN BE MOVING ON
TO ITEM NUMBER FIVE S. B. ELEVEN
EIGHTY TO FOCUS ON RICHARD'S
CREDIT.
WE'RE GRATEFUL THAT.
SENATE GLACIER IS HERE.
SENATE GLAZERS WE PRESENTING ON
SB ELEVEN EIGHTY TWO MISTER
GLAZIER THE FLOORS OR CERTAINLY
WELCOME YOU KATE TO A COMMITTEE
AGAIN. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
AND. WE DID HAVE AN INTERESTING
CONVERSATION ON THE RUNNERS
ANOTHER WRITER'S CREDIT BILLS TO
YOU SIR GOT STUCK TRYING TO TAKE.
GO OVER SOME AYE AYE. DEBATING
GROUND READY BUT I'M HAPPY TO
PRESENT THIS BILL I YOU KNOW
IT'S BEEN A LONG. ROAD TO
INCREASING THE RENTERS TAX
CREDIT WAS FIRST INCREASED LAST
INCREASED THE DAY THAT THE
CHAIRMAN WAS THE YEAR THE
CHAIRMAN WAS BORN IN. NINETEEN
SEVENTY NINE.
AND OUT.
ALTHOUGH THE LEGISLATURE PASSED
A VERY ROBUST HOUSING PACKAGE
LAST YEAR THAT PACKAGE DID NOT
PROVIDE DIRECT RELIEF TO THOSE
WHO NEED IT THE MOST AND THAT'S
OUR RANCHERS. WITH THIS BILL WE
HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE AN
IMMEDIATE IMPACT AND HELP THOSE
WITHIN THE LOW INCOME COMMUNITY.
STRUGGLE THE MOST TO MAKE EACH
MONTH'S RENT.
MORE IMPORTANTLY THIS BILL MAKES
THE CREDIT MUCH MORE FAIR AND
HELPFUL TO SINGLE MOMS SINGLE
DADS AND FAMILIES AND I'LL
EXPLAIN.
THE CURRENT FORMULA GIVES.
COUPLES WITH NO DEPENDENTS TWICE
AS MUCH AS A SINGLE PARENT WITH
KIDS.
RIGHT.
TWICE AS MUCH TO A COUPLE. WITH
NO DEPENDENTS AS A SINGLE PARENT
WITH KIDS EVEN IF THE COUPLES IN
A ONE BEDROOM APARTMENT. AND THE
SINGLE MOM HAS A TWO BEDROOM
APARTMENT THAT COSTS MORE. THIS
BILL CORRECTS THAT THAT
DISPARITY AND SIMULTANEOUSLY
CATCHES THE CREDIT UP TO WHERE
IT WOULD HAVE BEEN HAD IT KEPT
PACE WITH INFLATION SINCE
NINETEEN SEVENTY NINE.
WE THIS BITS AS THAT THE BILL
PROPOSES TO PHASE THAT IN OVER
FIVE YEARS.
TO KEEP THE UP FRONT COSTS LOW
AND GIVE THE GOVERNOR THE
ABILITY TO PAUSE THE SCHEDULE.
IF THERE IS AN ECONOMIC
EMERGENCY.
CURRENTLY A SINGLE MOM HER
FATHER EARNING LESS THAN FORTY
THOUSAND.
RECEIVES A SIX US SIXTY DOLLAR
CREDIT. BY AS ILLUSTRATED BY
THIS FIRST POSTER.
THE CURRENT GENERAL FUND COSTS
OF THE RENTER'S CREDIT IS TWO
HUNDRED FIFTEEN MILLION DOLLARS
A FRACTION OF THE FIVE POINT.
EIGHT BILLION.
THE STATE. GIVES UP FOR
HOMEOWNER SUBSIDIES.
THE SECOND GRAPH FIVE.
SHOWS THE NEW CATEGORY THAT
WE'RE CREATING.
THAT WOULD TRIPLE THE TOTAL
CREDIT FOR A SINGLE MOM.
OR FATHER.
FROM ITS CURRENT SIXTY DOLLAR
RANGE TWO HUNDRED SEVENTY EIGHT
DOLLARS.
BY THE END OF THE FIVE YEAR
PHASE IN PERIOD FAMILIES OR SIVA
CREDIT OF ABOUT FOUR HUNDRED AND
THIRTY FOUR DOLLARS POINT IN
THIRTY FOUR DOLLARS.
THE COST OF THIS INCREASE IS
PROJECTED TO BE FORTY FOUR
MILLION DOLLARS IN THE FIRST
YEAR AFTER IMPLEMENTATION. THE
OVERALL COST OF THE STATE OF THE
FIVE YEAR PHASE IN PERIOD. IT'S
THREE HUNDRED SEVENTY NINE
MILLION DOLLARS STILL A SMALL
FRACTION OF THE FIVE POINT EIGHT
BILLION THAT WE CURRENTLY
PROVIDE AND EVERY EVERY YEAR TO
HOMEOWNERS.
THE WRITER'S CREDIT DIRECTLY
HELP CALIFORNIANS WHO NEED IT
THE MOST.
WELL THE MORTGAGE DEDUCTION GOES
TO BETTER OFF RESIDENTS THIS IS
A SMART PROGRESSIVE BILL THAT
GIVES DIRECT DATA RENTERS. WHO
NEED THAT NEED THE HELP IT'S A
PERFECT COMPLEMENT TO OUR LONG
TERM EFFORTS TO BUILD MORE LOW
INCOME HOUSING AS SENATOR PELL
AS INDICATED EARLIER IN THE
HEARING TODAY?
AND THOSE ARE EFFORTS THAT TAKE
YEARS TO TAKE ROOT.
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE CAN
DO TO HELP PEOPLE RIGHT NOW AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
CONSIDERATION TODAY I'M OF THE
BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AT CENTER
GLAZER WE DO HAVE A MOTION ON
THE FLOOR WHICH WE'RE GOING TO
ASK HER OUT WITNESSES TO BE ABLE
TO GIVE BRIEF TESTIMONY AS WE
ARE GOING TO HAVE SOME
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
ON THIS BILL SIMPLY SERVIDO MY
INTRODUCING YOURSELF AND WE'RE
GONNA ASK FOR A BRIEF TESTIMONY
ABSOLUTELY.
MY NAME'S LOUIS MONTANA HERE TO
EXPRESS CALIFORNIAN BE SUPPORT
FOR S. B. ELEVEN EIGHTY TO A
CALIFORNIA BEER YES MY BACKYARD
IS A NETWORK OF THOUSANDS OF.
HOUSING ADVOCATES ARE ON THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA PRIMARILY
RENTAL TENANTS ABOUT WHO PROMOTE
POLICY TO MAKE HOUSING MORE
AFFORDABLE.
WORD STRONG SUPPORT OF THE BILL
IT'S A PRUDENT MEASURE TO PHASE
AND IT AND IT JUST MEANT I TO IF
THAT ADJUST FOR INFLATION.
SINCE THE RENTER'S CREDIT WAS
LAST
I INCREASE IN NINETEEN SEVENTY
NINE I JUST WANT TO ASK OUR
STRONG SUPPORT FOR THE BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH YEARS GREATLY
YOU'RE HERE GOOD MORNING SERVE
WELCOME TYRONE BUCKLEY ON BEHALF
OF HOUSING CALIFORNIA.
WE ALSO LEARNED STRONG SUPPORT
OF THIS MEASURE ON THE NEED HAS
SAVED FOR IS VERY HIGH AND WE
KNOW THE ONE THREE CALIFORNIA'S
ARE UNABLE FOR THEIR RENT.
MANY PEOPLE ARE SPENDING AS
MUCH AS THIRTY PERCENT FIFTY
PERCENT OF THEIR INCOME ON RENT
AND THAT MEANS A KANSEN MONEY
ANOTHER LIFE NEEDS LIKE
HEALTHCARE LIKE TRIPS SAFE
TRANSPORTATION OTHER LIFE NEEDS.
SO WE'D REALLY SUPPORT THIS
LACY GO FORWARD AND APPRECIATE
YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING HERE Q. SIR WELCOME IF
YOU JUST GIVE US YOUR FIRST AND
LAST ORGANIZATION THINGS FOR
BEING HERE THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR OF MANNING ON BEHALF OF
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING ALLIANCE
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL. VICTIMS
MEANING CORNMEAL.
MARRIED ALONG WITH CAL STATE
UNIVERSITY XIN AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
GOING TO HER.
SHARE MEMBERS PAT RAN WITH THEIR
MARINE ASSOCIATES REPRESENTING
THE SAN DIEGO COUNTY APARTMENT
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU
THANK YOU SO MUCH COOPER BEST
MISREAD. MORNING MA'AM.
GOOD MORNING MORNING CARVE
ALTERNATIVE STRATEGY GROUP ON
BEHALF THE CONSUMER FEDERATION
OF CALIFORNIA ALSO IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU SO MUCH. GOOD MORNING.
THREE MORNING THAT'S A GONZALEZ
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
COUNCIL FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
IN SUPPORT BECAUSE SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING.
BURNING ASSISTANCE IN A BATH THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION WE DON'T HAVE A
LETTER ON FILE BUT WHERE IT'S
PART.
WONDERFUL THANK YOU HEY THAT
THEY ARE OVER THE CALIFORNIA
BUSINESS PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION
SUPPORT THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BUT IT MAY TO DO A LAST CALL
ANYONE WHO WATCHES IN SUPPORT TO
PLEASE ADVANCED THIS TIME LAST
CALL FOR SUPPORT.
WE'RE NOT GONNA ASK ANYONE WHO'S
OPPOSITION TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
WE'RE GONNA BRING BACK TO
COMMITTEE ACT AS WE DID HAVE A
PREVIOUS BILL ON A VERY SIMILAR
TAX CREDIT LIKELY TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
WE DO HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR
BY CENTER BELL CENTRE BELL WITH
A QUESTION.
THOUGH.
YEAH COULD MAYBE GIVE YOUR
PERSPECTIVE
PEOPLE HERE. ABOUT.
.
THE IMPACT OF.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CONSTRUCTION.
ON.
RANTS AND HOW THAT WOULD APPLY
AND MAYBE A MILL RATE.
.
THE.
REVENUE SITUATION THAT WE HAVE
HERE. IT THIS THIS BILL HAS A
LESS OF.
.
DOESN'T HAVE THAT BIG WALKER
THREE HUNDRED MILLION BUT IT'S
SO.
IT GOES UP TO SEVENTY FIVE
MILLION A THREE YEARS SO.
.
IF THE.
RENTER RENNER HOUSING
CONSTRUCTION.
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
WAS INCREASING CALIFORNIA HOW
WOULD IT AFFECT US.
RENTERS TAX CREDIT.
IN HIGH COST AREAS PLEASE
BORROWING SQUADRON THROUGH THE
CHAIR I THINK THAT CERTAINLY AT.
THE ADDING MORE SUPPLY WILL HELP.
AT IT REDUCE THAT NCREASES IN
RENTS BECAUSE THE SUPPLY WOULD
BE THERE AND IT WILL TAKE TIME
AS YOU KNOW. THE LEGISLATURE'S
TAKEN SOME IMPORTANT STEPS TO
INCREASE THAT SUPPLY IT'S GOING
TO TAKE TIME.
YEARS AND YEARS.
BECAUSE WE ARE SO FAR BEHIND
THIS BILL DOES GIVE FLEXIBILITY
BY THE GOVERNOR IN IN ECONOMIC
PROBLEMS THAT TO FREEZE IT WOULD
WE CAN ALSO GO COME BACK AND
REVISIT IT AS THAT HOUSING STOCK
IS IMPROVED AND. THAT'S WHY THIS
HELPS OUT THE RANCHERS NOW AND
WE CAN ALWAYS REVISITED GOING
GOING FORWARD IN TERMS OF
WHETHER THAT BALANCE IS STILL
BEING ACHIEVED.
MR BLASIER I THINK IT'S
IMMEDIATE SHOT IN THE ARM SO.
IT WHEN WE TAKE A LOOK AT THE
HOUSING STOCK TAKING YEARS TO BE
OF THE BELT WE'RE LOOKING AND
IMMEDIATE RELIEF SO THINK SO
MUCH AS THEY'RE WRONG. EARNED.
IF YOU'VE TARGETED LIKE THE LAST
BILL TO.
INCOME LEVELS HAVE CAN YOU GIVE
YOUR COMMENT ON THAT. SO THIS
DOES THAT STILL CREATING INCOME
OF THE CEILING TO BE ELIGIBLE.
SO YOU HAVE TO IF YOU'RE SINGLE
IT'S STILL FORTY THOUSAND
PROXIMALLY. OUGHT TO BE TO BE
ELIGIBLE LAW HIGHER THAN THE
LAST BILL. I THINK IT'S ACTUALLY
A LITTLE BIT LOWER LOWER I
THOUGHT HE HAD FIFTY AND A
HUNDRED WAS HIS INCOME CEILINGS
THE KNEES ARE SET.
I EACH YEAR AND I BELIEVE THAT
THERE LOWER RIGHT FORTY THOUSAND
SEVENTY EIGHT DOLLARS FOR A
SINGLE.
I.
IS THE IS THE. WHAT'S CURRENTLY
PROVIDED IN THE BILL YARMULKE.
AND IF I INCLUDING DIE
DEPENDENTS WERE ACTUALLY TAKING
THEM INTO ACCOUNT WHEN WE'VE
NEVER TAKEN THEM TO IT IN
ACCOUNT BEFORE THIS THIS WILL
DEAL WITH ARE. REGIONAL.
AFFORDABILITY INDEX IT DOESN'T
ALTHOUGH I'M VERY OPEN MINED TO
THAT CONCEPT TO SEE HOW WE COULD
IMPLEMENTED IF IT'S A IF IT'S
THE RIGHT THING TO DO IS RADICAL
DIFFERENCES IN THE STATE ON
AFFORDABILITY SO. YEAH JUST YOU
KNOW WHEN YOU'RE LOOKING AT.
DOING SOME TICKER LEVEL I THINK.
AFFORDABILITY INDEX IS
DISCOVERED HE ACTUAL FACTUAL
ISSUE FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE.
AND A VERY OPEN TO THAT TO WHAT
DISCUSSING THAT FURTHER INCIDENT
THAT COULD BE ENOUGH A PART OF
THIS BILL.
THANK YOU SO MUCH CENTER.
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
TO ONE ACKNOWLEDGE OUR VICE
CHAIR WAS A CO AUTHOR ON THIS
BILL THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE
WORK AS WELL MADAM VICE CHAIR
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS WE DO HAVE A
MOTION FOR BY SENATOR BELL THIS
IS A DO PASSED YOUR PREPARATIONS.
COMMITTEE COMFORTABLE MOVING
FORWARD ON A ROLL CALL VOTE.
BUT WE DO THAT AS SOON GLAZER
WOULD YOU LIKE TO MAKE CLOSING
COMIC YOUR CONSIDERATION THANK
YOU VERY WORK ON THIS SIR AND
AGAIN THIS IS AN IMMEDIATE SHOT
IN THE ARM FOR THOSE WHO ARE
PRINTED IN STATE IN. IN SEEN
SIGNIFICANT INCREASES MISS LANE
CHESTER BROKE UP PLEASE REQUIRED
BY WHERE I WIN. WIN I'D BILL.
BILL AYE HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG LARA MORE LOCK.
THREE ZERO WE CURRENTLY HAVE A
THREE ZERO AND KEEP ROLL OPEN
AND LET YOU KNOW WHEN FOLKS AT
ON THANK YOU SO MUCH THINKING
SWISHER. NOW CAN BE MOVING ON TO
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE S. B. TWELVE
FIFTY THREE SENATOR JACKSON'S IS
FOCUS ON LOW INCOME HOUSING
CREDIT.
SENATE JACKSON THE FLOOR IS
YOURS AND WE LOOKING MAN TO
COMMITTEE. SO MUCH MISTER CHAIR
THINK THIS.
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
.
SO EXCEED YOU HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON THIS BILL A VERY GOOD
US ALL TRY TO MAKE IT QUICK.
IF SOMEONE HANDS TO OUR FEW HAND
SOMEONE FIFTY CENTS AND THEY
HAND YOU BACK THREE DOLLARS.
THAT'S A WINNER.
AND IN A WAY THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT
THIS MEASURE THAT. IS THE
SUBJECT OF S. B. TWELVE FIFTY
THREE WILL DO.
IT WILL DOUBLE THE FUNDING FOR
STATE LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX THE
TAX CREDIT PROGRAM. AND DONE A
DO IT OVER A TEN YEAR PERIOD KEY
TACK.
IS THE TAX CREDIT ALLOCATION
COMMITTEE.
WHICH WILL AND DOES ADMINISTER
THE CURRENT PROGRAM. WE NOW FIND
OURSELVES.
LEAVING A LOT OF FEDERAL MONEY
ON THE TABLE. THIS BILL WILL
ENCOURAGE AN INCREASE.
THE OPPORTUNITIES FOR LOW INCOME
HOUSING TO BE DEVELOPED WE ALL
KNOW THAT WE ARE.
THOUSANDS HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS
OF UNITS SHORT.
WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE DEVELOPERS
DON'T WANT TO DEVELOP BLESSING
CAN MAKE A PROFIT AND BY
PROVIDING THEM WITH THIS TAX
CREDIT.
WE PUT IN ABOUT A DOLLAR AND
GET BACK.
ABOUT A DOLLAR EIGHTY OR CLOSE
TO TWO DOLLARS FROM THE FEDS
PLUS PRIVATE MONEY. SO IT'S
BASICALLY FOR EVERY DOLLAR WE
INVEST WILL GET ABOUT THREE
DOLLARS BACK. IN TERMS OF
BENEFITS SO.
WITH SUPPORT ON BOTH SIDES I
WON'T GO THROUGH MY A
BEAUTIFULLY PREPARED. WORK BY MY
STAFF BY AND SIMPLY. ASK YOU TO
SUPPORT OF REALLY I THINK A VERY
HELPFULL COMMONSENSE.
A APPROACH TO DEALING WITH OUR
HOUSING SHORTAGE THAT WILL
BENEFIT. ALL OF US HERE IN THE
STATE REDUCE NEED TO. CHARGE
ADDITIONAL FUNDS PUT OUT BONDS.
IT'S A WIN WIN AND WITHOUT I
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE THINK YOU SO MUCH
SENATOR WE TAKE A BIT TO SEE IF
WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE THAT WOULD
LIKE TO BE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL. WE WELCOME MA'AM.
THE LEARNING ASSISTANCE AND ON
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS. THANK YOU
BRING WITH US.
ANYONE ELSE LIKE UBER SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF SENATOR JACKSON'S
BILL HE COULD PLEASE COME
FORWARD AT THIS TIME.
LAST CALL.
IT'S LOOK TO ANYONE WHO WOULD
LIKE TO BE ABLE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE AT THIS
TIME.
LAST CALL.
LET'S BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE
TO BE RECEIVED WITH ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS WE'D ALSO.
OFFER A PROMOTION IS WELL.
WE I WE'VE BEEN AND MOTIONS IS A
TO PASURE APPROPRIATIONS BY
SENATOR BATTLE WOULD LIKELY TO
SEE IF WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS BY THE COMMITTEE TO
SIGN.
SCENE NINE SENATOR JACKSON'S
LIKE TO CLOSE PLEASE VERY
BRIEFLY PAST FEAR I WILL. THINK
IS WHAT SENATOR WE DO HAVE A DO
PASSED TO APPROPRIATION MOTION
ON THE FLOOR BY CENTER BELL
MISLEAD CHESSER ROLL CALL VOTE
PLEASE MCGUIRE AYE WIRE AYE
NGUYEN.
BILL. BILL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA MORLOCK.
MORE LIKE GUY THREE ZERO. THEIR
AGO IT IS BIPARTISAN LOOK AT
THAT A THERE YOU GO.
I JUST ABOUT FELL OFF MY CHAIR
A. ON TAKE THE VOTE THANK YOU
LAW CENTER MORLOCKS GOOD GUYS
HIS KIDS GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH
OR DID THEY THROW YOU WORK ON
THIS AS WELL THANK YOU GOOD TO
SEE YOU.
I WOULD KEEP THE ROLE OPEN ON
SENATE BILL TWELVE. FIFTY THREE
AND AD FOLKS ON WERE NOW CAN BE
MOVING ON.
.
THREE MORE LOCKUP BUT YOU.
WOULD YOU LIKE. TO I APOLOGIZE
IT'S CONSIDERED BIDAK.
ALL OF THE SHOP.
I THINK WE SHOULD GO.
PRESIDENT.
BOB I.
THE SENATE BIDAK IS CAN BE
PRESENTING ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN THIRTY
SEVEN I JUST WANTED MOMENT SAY
THANK YOU SO MUCH MR BUDAK FOR
WORKING. WITH THE COMMITTEE TO
BUT TO REDUCE BOTH THE FISCAL
IMPACT OF THE BILL AND PROVIDE
SOME CLARIFYING LANGUAGE. BY
THERE WILL BE AMENDMENTS WILL
MAKE SURE THAT OF THE CENTER
WILL BE TAKEN IN THE MIDST AYE
AND PLACE A TWELVE HUNDRED FIFTY
DOLLAR CAP ON THE AMOUNT OF
CREDIT. AND A PLAYER CAN RECEIVE
AS WELL AS AMENDMENTS ON
LANGUAGE TO PREVENT BUSINESSES
FROM THE MULTIPLE INTERNSHIP
CREDITS BY IN RATE REHIRING THE
SAME IN TURN.
ONE I'VE BEEN A TURN IT OVER TO
THE GOOD SENATOR WE WANT TO
THANK YOU SO MUCH CENTER FOR
WORKING OUT WITH THE COMMITTEE
ON THIS BILL IS A GOOD ONE. AYE
IN PLEASE OF FLOORS JORDAN SB
THIRTEEN THIRTY SEVEN BOTH THANK
YOU CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
S. B. THIRTEEN THIRTY SEVEN WILL
HELP LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD BY
ALLOWING SMALL BUSINESSES TO
RECEIVE A TAX CREDIT OF UP TO
HALF OF THE STUDENTS IN TERMS OF
HOURLY WAGE. FOR THE FIRST
NINETY DAYS OF EMPLOYMENT I AM
HAPPY TO TAKE THE COMMITTEE
AMENDMENTS WHICH WILL TEAR OF
THE BILL AND CAP THE BENEFIT
WAGES UP TO TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED.
WITH ME TODAY IS P. LARA.
PORTERVILLE UNIFIED SCHOOL BOARD
PRESIDENT.
IS PRESENTLY WORKING ME SIR VERY
LUCKY TO HAVE SURVIVED ACT AS
YOU SENATOR WE'RE GRATEFUL
YOU'RE HERE SIR THE FLOOR IS
YOURS AYE THANK YOU THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TIME. WOULD HAVE BEEN
THE RICHEST MOST PROPERLY
PROSPEROUS COUNTRY ON EARTH AND
CALIFORNIANS ARE RICHEST STATE
IN THAT COUNTRY WITH A FIFTH
LARGEST ECONOMY IN THE WORLD AND
FOR THAT. WE THIS IS FOR THE
CALIFORNIA THANKFUL MUCH OF THE
PROSPERITY CAN BE CREDITED TO
THE VISIONARY RULES AND
REGULATIONS ALLOWED TO COME
FORTH LIST.
BUILDING THANK YOU OFTEN COME
HERE ASKING FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF
SB THIRTEEN THIRTY SEVEN A BILL
THAT WOULD UNLEASH THE POTENTIAL
START IN OUR HIGH SCHOOL
STUDENTS. AFFORDING THESE YOUNG
CITIZENS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
PARTICIPATE IN A REAL AND
MEANINGFUL. AND PERHAPS LIFE
CHANGING WAY IN OUR ECONOMY.
THROUGH PAID INTERNSHIPS OUR
STUDENTS WILL. PUT TO PRACTICE
THE SKILLS THEY HAVE DEVELOPED
IN SCHOOL.
REPEAT INTERNSHIP STUDENTS
THROUGHOUT OUR GREAT REPUBLIC
MORGANTON MEXICAN BORDER WOULD
BE PRESENTED AN OPPORTUNITY TO
THRIVE. HAVE A COUPLE OF
EXAMPLES RATE CUT COME FROM
TERRIBLE A SMALL COMMUNITY. FROM
A POOR FAMILY SADLY MANY FAMILY
AND FRIENDS.
ARE IN GANGS.
HOME BREAKING THAT LITTLE OF
ENGINEERING TOUGHEST THING WITH
LOW THROUGH AN INTERNSHIP IN A
QUOTE FROM RAINY.
WHEN I PUT ONLY BORROWED SHIRT
AND TIGHT FROM.
AND REPORTED TO WORK I FELT
ACCEPTED AN EQUAL FOR THE FIRST
TIME IN MY LIFE.
HE IS A SENIOR AT THE UNIVERSITY
OF ARIZONA ENGINEERING COUGH
AND THERE'S MANY MANY EXAMPLES
OF THAT.
HANNAH.
THE. PATHWAYS.
AND.
.
HEALTH CAREERS. INTERNED IN THE
EMERGENCY ROOM AT A LOCAL
HOSPITAL HAS HELPED SAVE LIVES
AND DELIVER TWO BABIES AS A HIGH
SCHOOL STUDENT. ANOTHER ONE IT
WANTS TO COME BACK GRADUATED
FROM MASSEY. WANTS TO DESIGNS
PROSTHETICS FOR INFANTS.
SO. ALL I'M ASKING IS PLEASE
INVEST IN THE POTENTIAL OF THESE
INCIDENTS SINCE.
AND WHAT I FEEL IS A VERY LOW
COST HELPING PURSUE.
THE AMERICAN DREAM.
CANNELLA SUCCESS TO THEIR
FULLEST POTENTIAL.
THANK YOU LIKE IT'S MUCH IS
PRESENT WERE GRATEFULLY TRAVELED
SEGMENT TODAY AND ALSO BEING AN
OFFER THOSE VERY PERSONAL
STORIES THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR
AND GRATEFUL FOR ALL YOUR WORK.
WE NOW WOULD LIKE YOU TO WELCOME
THAT ANYONE ELSE WAS IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL TO TO SEE IF FOR
SOME LASSEN ORGANIZATION WELCOME.
ERICA OFTEN A BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
ASSOCIATION VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT
THINK SO MUCH HAS HAPPENED
THANKS FOR BEING HERE ANYONE
ELSE IN SUPPORT IF YOU COULD
PLEASE ADVANCED THIS TIME.
LAST CALL FOR SUPPORT.
NOW LIKELY TO SEE IF WE HAVE
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
THE PLEASE COME FORWARD.
WELCOME WE. CANNELLA DAVE HOW
YOU DOING ITS GOOD TO SEE AGAIN.
GOOD MORNING DANIELLE COUNTER
BECAUSE OUR ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA TAX REFORM
ASSOCIATION.
WHILE WE AGREE THAT THESE
OPPORTUNITIES TO VALUE BAD TO
PROVIDE VALUABLE EXPERIENCES.
WE BELIEVE THAT THEY SHOULD NOT
BE SUBSIDIZE US AT THE TAXPAYERS
EXPENSE. BY THE MEASURE MEASURE
WILL REDUCE GENERAL FUNDS
NECESSARY TO SUPPORT THE
DELIVERY OF PUBLIC EDUCATION
VITAL SERVICE SERVICES TO
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
OVER THE NEXT COUPLE OF YEARS
AND WE URGE YOU KNOW VOTE THANK
YOU.
IT'S MUCH THINK YOUR COMMENTS
WOULD LIKE ME TO SEE IF ANYONE
ELSE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION IF TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD MICROPHONE WE WELCOME
YOU TO THIS TIME.
GLASCOFF PROPOSITION.
THAT'S BRING ABOUT COMMITTEE.
PUB.
WE DO HAVE AN AMENDED BILL IN
FRONT OF US WHO EITHER QUESTIONS
COMMENTS OR WILL ALSO ACCEPT THE
MOTION THIS TIME FOR MEMBERS.
WE HAVE A MOTION UP BY A SENATOR
BELL THIS IS A DO PASSED.
CHAIRMAN I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT.
OF WE HAVE.
.
THE FOSTER USE LE TRAILING MADE
TODAY FROM TARA.
SO HE'S A MADERA FROM.
THERE CANNELLA SARIN SERVITE ACT.
SO.
.
HE WAS TO BE AN INTERN.
SOMEDAY MAYBE.
OUR OPPORTUNITY SO.
IS LOOK AND.
WERE WAS A SPONSOR YOU FOR.
DAY IN ORDER THAT ALL VOTE FOR
THIS BILL.
AWESOME HELP YOU THINK IT MIGHT
CENTER BELT WE ARE AND WE DO
HAVE A DO PASSES A MINUTE
APPROPRIATIONS.
I MISS ABOUT IT WOULD YOU LIKE
TO BE TO MAKE CLOSING COMES
PLEASE I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
IBOOK BECAUSE SO MUCH TO SAYS
HAVE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. MISSING
JUST A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE
MCGUIRE AYE AYE AYE NGUYEN BELLE.
BELLE AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG LARA MORE LOCK.
TWO ZERO.
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO ZERO VOTE
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
IN AT FOLKS ON THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
CENTER. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
FACE CHEN OR NOW WELCOME IN THE
MAN THE MYTH THE LEGEND IS NAME
IS SENATOR CANNELLA HE'S GOING
TO PRESENT HIM AS HE FOURTEEN
SEVENTEEN.
ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN BUT THIS
DOES HAVE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
MISTER CANNELLA.
.
THE FLOOR IS YOURS SIR.
VIC YOU.
.
CHAIRMAN S. B. FOURTEEN
SEVENTEEN REPLACES THE STATE'S
CURRENT ONE SIZE FITS ALL
MINIMUM FRANCHISE TAX CODE. WITH
PROGRESSIVE TAX BASED ON
CORPORATIONS ANNUAL GROSS
RECEIPTS.
THIS CHANGE WILL ASSIST NEW AND
STRUGGLING BUSINESSES AND HELP
BUSINESS OWNERS CONFORM TO
CHANGES IN FEDERAL TAX CODE.
WE HAVE AMENDED THE BILL.
SEASONING.
AT THE SUGGESTION OF THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD SPECIFYING
THAT THE LEGISLATION IS FOCUSED
ON C. CORPORATIONS. AS RESULT OF
THE CORPORATE SCOPE OF THIS BILL
UPDATED ANALYSIS FROM THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD ESTIMATES.
THE EXPECTED REVENUE LOSSES THE
STATE REDUCED BY NEARLY FIVE
HUNDRED MILLION DOLLARS PER YEAR.
SP FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN PROVIDES
MUCH NEEDED RELIEF FOR SMALL
BUSINESSES IN OUR STATE. AND
MODERNIZE OUR TAX CODE TO ENSURE
THAT CALIFORNIA'S IS AN IDEAL
DESTINATION FOR SMALL BUSINESSES.
WITHOUT A PLEASED TO WELCOME A
BUDGET COOLEY ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA SMALL BUSINESS
ASSOCIATION.
AND I CANNOT WE WELCOME YOU
MA'AM YOU ARE ON. THEIR WAY.
I THANK YOU I'M BODY JERKED
COLEY REPRESENTING CALIFORNIA
SMALL BUSINESS ASSOCIATION. AND
I'M ALSO SMALL BUSINESS OWNER OF
ICE.
I PURPOSES BY SAYING I STARTED
IN THE CORPORATE WORLD. AND
BECAME A SMALL BUSINESS OWNER
QUITE BY ACCIDENT BUT DOING
SMALL BUSINESS ADVOCACY AND THE
FUTURE OF SMALL BUSINESSES
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO NOT ONLY
MYSELF BUT THE ORGANIZATION.
I AS AN ORGANIZATION WE HAVE TO
BOB MAJOR OBJECTIVES.
WE WANT TO REMAIN SMALL BUSINESS
WANTS TO REMAIN THE JOB CREATORS.
OF THAT WE ARE KNOWN TO BE.
AND.
WE ALSO BELIEVE IN THE AMERICAN
DREAM THAT ANYBODY HAS A RIGHT
TO START A SMALL BUSINESS.
THIS IS A PROACTIVE BILL. AND I
WANT TO TELL YOU WHY.
TAXES ARE A BIG ISSUE.
OF THE LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION
DID.
A STUDY ON THE UNDERGROUND
ECONOMY. AND THE AND THIS IS
BEEN GROWING AND WE HAVEN'T BEEN
ABLE SO FAR TO STOP IT.
WE WANNA STOP BUT WE WANT SMALL
BUSINESSES TO INCORPORATE AND BE
GOOD CITIZENS NOT ONLY FROM THE
RISK CRIED MELODY. BUT WE
BELIEVE AND ARE TOLD TO MY
SOURCE OF OF INFORMATION IS THE
U. S. CHAMBER SMALL BUSINESS
COUNCILS TAX ADVISER.
THAT UNLESS
SMALL BUSINESSES ARE S. OR C.
CORPORATIONS THEY WILL NOT BE
ABLE TOFILE THEIR BUSINESS
EXPENSES WITH THE NEW TAX REFORM.
NOW HAVING BEEN TOLD THAT
THERE'S NO PLACE IT'S IN WRITING
IT BUT WE'RE GOING TO BE
PROACTIVE AND I WANT TO TALK
PRIMARILY ABOUT BUSINESSES WITH
EMPLOYEES.
IN CALIFORNIA IN TWO THOUSAND
AND SEVEN WE HAD THIS IS S. B.
ACES DISTRICTS WE HAD ONE POINT
ONE MILLION SMALL BUSINESSES
WITH EMPLOYEES.
IN TWO THOUSAND AND TWELVE WHICH
IS THE LAST YEAR IT IS BROKEN
OUT BY THE SBA IS SIX HUNDRED
AND THIRTY EIGHT THOUSAND. AND
WE THINK DUE TO THE UNDERGROUND
ECONOMY IT'S PROBABLY EVEN LOWER
THAN THAT NOW.
OF THAT NUMBER. OF ALL AND
THERE'S OVER. PINS ON WHICH
NUMBER YOU WANT TO LOOK FOR
THESE TWO MILLION THREE MILLION.
TWO POINT TWO MILLION SMALL
BUSINESSES WITH AND WITHOUT
EMPLOYEES IN THE STATE.
BUT OUR OBJECTIVE IS CURRENTLY
SEVENTEEN PERCENT OF THE SMALL
BUSINESSES IN CALIFORNIA ARE
INCORPORATED AS AN S. OR C.
CORPORATION.
THAT WOULD ONLY MEAN SEVENTEEN
PERCENT OF THEM IF THE TAX
FEDERAL TAX RULES OR RIGHT. THAT
YOU HAD TO BE AN ANSWER SEE
CORPORATION TO OUR.
A COUNTRY BUSINESS EXPENSES.
WE HAVE A LOT OF HER.
SO WE'RE GOING TO BE PROACTIVE
AND WE ARE GOING TO WORK WITH A
SMALL BUSINESSES IN CALIFORNIA
NOT ONLY FROM A RISK STANDPOINT.
BUT FROM A BUSINESS STANDPOINT
AND SO WE ARE OUT ARE OFFERING A
SLIDING SCALE WE DON'T THINK
MICRO BUSINESSES.
THAT HAVE TWO POINT FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS IN GROSS REVENUES SHOULD
PAY THE SAME MINIMUM FRANCHISE
TAX AS SOMEBODY THAT DOES
FIFTEEN MILLION.
AND IF MY ARITHMETIC IS RIGHT
AND I WAS PRETTY GOOD IN MATH.
EIGHTY TWO MILLION ROUGHLY AS
WHAT'S COMING IN CURRENTLY WAS
SEVENTEEN PERCENT AT EIGHT
HUNDRED DOLLARS. IF WE CAN GET
FIFTY PERCENT OF JUST THE ONES
WITH EMPLOYEES.
THAT WOULD GROW TO A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY MILLION. AND IF WE GOT
SEVENTY PERCENT. IT WOULD GROW
TO A TWO HUNDRED AND ó ARE TWO
ONE POINT EIGHT TRILLION.
AND THAT'S BASED ON FORTY
PERCENT REMAINING AND THE TWO
HUNDRED DOLLARS MICRO BUSINESS.
AND ABOUT TWENTY TWENTY TWENTY
AS THE WAY IT'S BROKE OUT AND
WE'RE GONNA IT'S GETTING
INCLUDING ABOUT THIRTY SECONDS
RIGHT AND.
SO WE THINK WE THINK IT'S A
POSITIVE BILL.
AND THAT THERE'S TWO REASONS
FOR DOING IT.
WE NEED TO CHANGE THE IMAGE THAT.
PERSON A GOOD PLACE FOR SMALL
BUSINESS TO BE IT'S CALIFORNIA'S
A GREAT PLACE TO BE WHERE THE
FUTURE.
AND.
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THIS STATE
GROWS AND SURVIVES AND WE ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE FUNDS NOTHING SO
MUCH MORE AS A THANK YOU FOR
YOUR ADVOCACY IN YOUR HARD WORK
ON BEHALF OF SMALL BUSINESS IS
THE HEART OF CALIFORNIA'S
ECONOMY THREE POINT FOUR MILLION
ACROSS THE STATE. MORE THAN ANY
OTHER STATE IN THE UNION IN A
VERY VERY GRATEFUL FOR ALL OF
YOUR HARD WORK AND IT'S
WONDERFUL TO HAVING COMMITTEE
TODAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE LIKELY TO SEE IF WE HAVE
ANYONE ELSE WHO'D LIKE TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE AT THIS
TIME. IF YOU JUST PLEASE STATE
YOUR FIRST AND LAST AND BY YOUR
POSITION ON THE BILL.
JACK MADONNA FROM BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIA AUTOMOTIVE BUSINESS
COALITION IN SUPPORT THANK YOU A
CHECK THANKS FOR BEING HERE
TODAY.
I DO ANSWER.
I AARON BROWN CEO FOR MY HEALTH
CHAMPIONS A MANAGING GENERAL
AGENCY. IN SUPPORT AND THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING.
BRING DAY BUTLER AND BE HAPPY
KNIGHTED CHAMBER ADVOCACY
NETWORK A COALITION LOCAL
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
ORGANIZATIONS IN SUPPORT THANKS
FOR BEING HERE TODAY WARNING HIM.
I DON'T.
BRING BACK A LLEWELLYN AND NOW
I'M A SMALL BUSINESS HERE IN THE
STATE MEANING BUSINESS FORTY
THREE YEARS. SO I HOPE THAT WE
CAN KEEP SMALL BUSINESSES AND
THE STATE. I'M PRESIDENT OF THE
CALIFORNIA SMALL BUSINESS
ASSOCIATION BELONG TO WOMEN
CONSTRUCTION OWNERS AND
EXECUTIVES.
AND NOT.
THE WOMEN IN THIS STATE WANT
SMALL BUSINESSES DAY.
PLEASURE TO HAVE YOU HERE THANK
YOU SO MUCH MA'AM.
REPORTER.
WE LIKE ME TO DO A LAST CALL
LAST CALL FOR ANYONE WHO'S IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE ADVANCE THE MICROPHONE AT
THIS TIME LAST CALL.
WE KNOW THAT TO SEE IF ANYONE IS
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL.
TO PLEASE COME FORWARD WE
WELCOME YOU BACK.
THEY GO TO THE TABLE OR THE
MICROPHONE.
BRIEFLY GOOD MORNING AGAIN
WARNING AND YELL COUNTER BECAUSE
OUR BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA TAX
REFORM ASSOCIATION WE DO HAVE A
HISTORY OF OPPOSING MEMBER
MEASURES SUCH AS THIS. AND TERM.
THE SAVINGS TO BUSINESSES
AFFORDED BY THE PROPOSAL WOULD
BE MINIMUM MINIMAL AT BEST AND
IT'S UNLIKELY THAT IT WOULD MAKE
A BREAK SMALL BUSINESSES.
AND SO WE BELIEVE THAT THE COST
TO THE STATE WILL BE STILL
EXORBITANT EVEN WITH AMENDMENTS
AND WE DO OUR TURNOUT VOTE THANK
YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH.
WE DON'T REALLY SEE IF ANYONE
ELSE IS OPPOSED TO ANYONE ELSE
OPPOSED.
THAT'S BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE TO BE RECEIVED WE HAVE
A MOTION ON THE FLOOR THIS IS
DUE PASS.
TO APPROPRIATIONS.
BUT I GUESS IF WE HAVE ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
THE NO QUESTIONS COMMENTS SENATE
CANNELLA FLOOR'S YOURS FOR CLOSE
TO SAYS FOR NAY VOTE THANK YOU
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR.
THIS IS A DO PASSED HER
APPROPRIATIONS WE HAVE A MOTION
BY SENATOR BELL. MISSING JUST A
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE CHOIR HIGH
WIRE AYE NGUYEN.
WHEN I BAIL. BILL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
MORE LAW.
LIKE I SEE. IT IS CURRENTLY A
FIVE ZERO MISTER CALDERON THOUGH%
IT KEEP THE ROLE OPEN THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
THANK YOU MA'AM GOOD TO SEE YOU.
IT PLAYS IN JIMMER NOW BE.
WERE MOVING ITEM NUMBER TWENTY
WHICH IS A CONSTITUTIONAL LIMIT
TWENTY TWO SENATOR ALLEN THIS IS
IN REGARDS TO SCHOOL DISTRICTS
IN PARCEL TAXES WE WELCOME THE
GOOD SENATOR THE CHAIR OF
EDUCATION TO THE COMMITTEE.
THE FLOOR IS YOURS SIR.
MEMBERS.
I MANY OF YOU KNOW THAT I. CAME
TO THIS POSITION HAVING SERVED
FOR TWO TERMS ON THE SCHOOL
BOARD.
IN MY HOMETOWN THE SANTA MONICA.
AND I WAS ELECTED IN TWENTY TWO
THOUSAND EIGHT.
AND DE LITERALLY I THINK THAT I
WAS ON THE BALLOT THE.
A FOR THE NOVEMBER ELECTION AND
IN OCTOBER.
THE STOCK MARKET CRASH THE
SUBPRIME MORTGAGE.
YOU KNOW HIT. FULL DISASTER MODE
AND.
BUSY MY ENTIRE TIME ON THE
SCHOOL BOARD WAS SPENT TRYING TO
FIGURE OUT WAYS TO.
BOUNCE THE BUDGET KEEP OUR OF
FINANCIAL CONTROLS IN PLACE WILL
ALSO MAKE SURE WE GET EVERY WE
COULD TO PRESERVE PROTECT.
THE CORE PROGRAMS THAT MADE SUCH
A DIFFERENCE FOR OUR COMMUNITY
IN OUR SCHOOLS.
AND. YOU KNOW THE STATE WAS IN
THERE FOR US.
AND WE HAD TO FIGURE OUT WAYS
TO GET THE COMMUNITIES STEP UP
IN VARIOUS WAYS MAKE SOME CUTS
WE LAID PEOPLE OFF WE. PINK SLIP
PEOPLE IT WAS A REALLY DIFFICULT
PROCESS I THINK ANYBODY AND
NUMBER OF YOU WERE SERVING LOCAL
GOVERNMENT.
AND HAD TO GO THROUGH THAT SAME
PERIOD OF TIME THAT WAS
INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT.
AND IT GOT ME THINKING A LOT
ABOUT WHAT SORT OF MECHANISMS WE
HAVE IN PLACE TO ENSURE THAT
COMMUNITIES IF THEY WANT TO. CAN
STEP UP AND PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT TO THEIR LOCAL SCHOOL
SYSTEMS.
AND THAT'S REALLY WHAT IS AT THE
HEART OF THIS DISC DECISION
TODAY. YOU KNOW DO WE REALLY
BELIEVE IN LOCAL THE TERMINATION
OF A CONTROL ESPECIALLY AFTER WE
HAVE TOTALLY REVAMPED THE WAY WE
FINANCE SCHOOLS. IN OUR SYSTEM
SO THAT NOW INSTEAD OF JUST
GIVING OUT A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF
MONEY TO EVERY SCHOOL OF.
BASED ON THE NUMBER OF KIDS HEY
HAVE WERE DOING IT BASED ON THIS
NEW MORE REDISTRIBUTIVE FORMULA.
THAT WE'VE WE'VE NOW ADDRESS A
LOT OF THE CORE EQUITY CONCERNS
THAT EXISTED IN THE PAST WHEN IT
CAME TO.
PARCEL TAXES.
WITH THAT IN MIND DO WE REALLY ALLOW SUCH A SMALL PORTION OF
POPULATION AND.
IN IN VARIOUS DISTRICTS TO
BASICALLY DENY THE VAST MAJORITY
OF VAST MAJORITY OF OF THE
POPULATION THE RIGHT TO.
VOTE TO.
THIRD YOU KNOW RAZOR ON TAXES
ARE MAINTAINED TAXES.
TO INVEST IN THE LOCAL SCHOOL
SYSTEM.
AND ULTIMATELY I IT'S MY FIRM
BELIEF THAT.
VOTERS ARE MUCH MORE INTERESTED
IN BEING ABLE TO LOOK AT THEIR
SCHOOL BOARD. ANDHOLD THEIR
LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD ACCOUNTABLE
FOR THE EXPENDITURES IF THEY
MAKE LOCALLY. RATHER THAN.
THEN BEEN.
THERE'S A MUCH HIGHER BROUGH
WILLINGNESS.
ON THE PART OF VOTERS TO.
I'D TO ENGAGE WITHIN AND HOLD A
LOCAL SCHOOL BOARD ACCOUNTABLE
BUT ALSO TAKE THE LEAP OF FAITH
AND. PUT MORE INVESTMENT LOCAL
SCHOOLS.
RATHER HOW THAT MONEY GO TO
SACRAMENTO.
AND SO. ARE YOU KNOW THE FACT IS
THAT OUR SCHOOLS ARE STILL
STRUGGLING.
INSIGHT AND DESPITE SIGNIFICANT
STATE FUNDING INCREASES THE
SCHOOLS THE PAST FIVE YEARS MANY
SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE ARE ARE
REALLY ARE STRUGGLING TO
MAINTAIN QUALITY EDUCATION
SERVICES. IN THE FACE OF RISING
OPERATING COSTS MANY THOSE COSTS
IMPOSED UPON THEM BY. THINGS
THAT WE DO HERE. NOW I'M SERVING
AS EDUCATION CHAIR NOW AND I'M
FACING I'M FACED WITH THIS
CHALLENGE EVERY SINGLE DAY.
I AN ESTIMATED ONE THIRD OF
DISTRICTS ARE EXPERIENCING
DEFICIT TO TWENTY EIGHTEEN
TWENTY NINETEEN TWO THIRDS OF
DISTRICTS ARE EXPECTED TO HAVE
DEFICITS. IN TWENTY NINETEEN
TWENTY TWENTY.
BECAUSE RESULT MANY DISTRICTS
ARE MAKING THE DIFFICULT CHOICE
THAT WE THOUGHT. THAT WE WE HAD
GOTTEN OURSELVES THROUGH BEFORE
DELAY OFFER LOW TEACHERS
CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES CUT SCHOOL
PROGRAMS AND SERVICES SO.
NEAR PARCEL TAXES ARE REALLY ONE
OF THE VERY FEW MECHANISMS THAT
LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS HAVE. TO
RAISE REVENUE TO SUPPLEMENT THE
FUNDS OF A RECEIPT FROM THE
STATE UNLIKE CITIES THAT CAN
IMPOSE ALL SORTS OF TAXES AND
AND FEES ON EVERYTHING FROM
PARKING TO.
YOU KNOW IT'S A.
YOU KNOW CAR DEALERSHIPS TO.
HOTELS TRANSIT OCCUPANCY TAXES
ARE SCHOOL DISTRICTS DON'T HAVE
THOSE KINDS OF MECHANISMS.
AND THOSE COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE
PAST PERSONAL TAXES.
I HAVE BEEN ABLE TO NOW PUT THAT
MONEY INTO KEEPING THEIR CLASS
SIZES SMALLER PROVIDING ART
MUSIC
SPORTS PROGRAMS OTHER PROGRAMS
SUSTAINING SCHOOL LIBRARIANS
NURSES COUNSELORS. OTHER
IMPORTANT PRIORITIES.
BUT ULTIMATELY ARE REQUIRING A
TWO THIRDS VOTE HAS ALLOWED A
MINORITY OF VOTERS AND TO
PREVENT MANY COMMUNITIES FROM A
VERY SMALL MINORITY OF THE
VOTERS TO PREVENT MANY
COMMITTEES FROM ACCESSING THESE
REVENUES. IT'S PREVENTED A LOT
OF SCHOOL DISTRICTS FROM PUTTING
MEASURES LIKE THIS ON THE BALLOT.
IT'S.
IT'S ALSO AND MADE IT SO THAT
ONLY CERTAIN TYPES OF
COMMUNITIES ARE ABLE TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THIS REVENUE OPTION
COMMITTEES LIKE SANTA MONICA.
THAT THAT HAVE SHOWN A
WILLINGNESS TO STEP UP AND
INVEST IN A VERY SERIOUS WAY BUT
OTHER COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE
EQUALLY DESERVING SCHOOL SYSTEMS.
BOB THAT HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO.
TO TO TO BRING IN ADDITIONAL
REVENUE HAVE ALSO NOW SUFFERED
AN ADDITIONAL HEAD. ARE BASED ON
THE NEW PENSION LIABILITIES UPON
THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND. THE.
THE THAT WE DISTRIBUTED OUTSIDE
DEVELOP CFF.
SO. ARE. YOU KNOW OF THE TWENTY
SIX SCHOOL PARCEL TAXES THAT WE
FAIL PASSAGE OF TWENTY TWELVE
TWENTY SEVENTEEN TWENTY ONE
EXCEEDED THE FIFTY FIVE PERCENT
THRESHOLD WOULD HAVE PASSED. HAD
THIS BEEN A FACT.
AND THAT'S OUR THOUGHT THAT THIS
WILL ALLOW MORE DISTRICTS A
LARGER ENROLLMENTS OF LOW INCOME
STUDENTS TO GENERATE FUNDS.
IT WILL.
YOU KNOW ULTIMATELY I MAKE IT A
LITTLE FAIRY WILL PROVIDE AN
OPPORTUNITY FOR WHAT IS
ULTIMATELY THE HEART OF THIS
ACCOUNTABILITY THE LOCAL LEVEL.
STE LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS
KEEPING FAITH WITH THEIR LOCAL
POPULATION. THAT'S WHAT THIS IS
ALL ABOUT AND WITHOUT AYE
HOPEFULLY I HOPE THAT YOU AYE
AYE I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
SUPPORT I WANTED TO MAKE ONE
LITTLE NOTE BEFORE WE GOT CLOSE.
AND THE TEAM OF COMMERCE REYES
OPPOSITION POINTS BY UP SOONER
STAND THEIR CONCERNS OF THE
BILLS THAT THE BILL AS DRAFTED
WOULD NOT COMPLY WITH THE
UNIFORMITY STANDARD. ESTABLISH
IN THE BRICK IS COURT CASE THAT
WAS IN ALAMEDA COUNTY CASE THAT
MANY OF YOU KNOW. SO I'VE
COMMITTEE HAVE ALREADY SPOKEN TO
THE CHAMBER OF COMMITTED TO
AMEND THE BILL TO ADDRESS OUR
CONCERNS.
THAT THE ISSUES THEY RAISE OUR
OF BUT NOTHING TO DO WITH THE
ISSUES I'M TRYING TO ADDRESS.
SO I BUT DUE TO THE TIME
CONSTRAINTS ASSOCIATE WITH THE
POLICY COMMITTEE DEADLINE I'M
NOT ABLE TO CAUSE THEM TO TELL
THE BILL GOES TO THE.
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE BUT I I
FULLY INTEND TO RECTIFY THE
REDUCE ISSUE THAT I WAS RAISED
BY THE OPPOSITION.
I THINK IT'S MUCH FASTER AND I
KNOW THAT I CENTER MORE LIKE
IT'S A VERY EXCITED TO VOTE FOR
THE BILL TODAY SO.
IF BUT MORE LIKE THEY WERE GONNA
MORE LOOK AT THE STRONG LOCAL
CONTROL SUPPORTERS SENATE GY
BUYS YOU ARE MORE LIKE GREAT
THERE A SENIOR AGO.
TO MAKE THE. PAY THEIR.
WHAT ARE WE GOING TO LET THOSE
WHO ARE IN SUPPORT AT?
PLEASE YOU WANNA COMPORT
JUSTICE TO YOUR FIRST AND LAST.
SHARE BALK AT THE LOS ANGELES
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT ARE
BORED LAST NIGHT PASSED A
RESOLUTION TO SUPPORT THIS
MEASURE THAT SINCE THE PASSAGE
OF PROP THIRTEEN LOCAL SCHOOL
DISTRICTS. HAS SEEN A CONTINUED
DECLINE THE LEVEL PER PUPIL
FUNDING.
CALIFORNIA RECENTLY NAMED THE
FIFTH LARGEST ECONOMY IN THE
WORLD IS ROUTINELY REPORT IN THE
BOTTOM OF MOST LESS THAT TRACK
BY A PER PUPIL FUNDING. FOR THE
SCHOOL DISTRICTS RELY HEAVILY ON
THE SUPPORT OF THE STATE AND THE
CURRENT LEVEL PER PUPIL FUNDING
IS NEARLY HALF THE LEVEL
INVESTMENT OF OTHER STATES. IT'S
CRITICAL THAT THE SCHOOL
DISTRICT HAVE MORE TOOLS TO
ADDRESS THE NEEDS THAT THEY HAVE
TO IT BAD DEAL WITH ON A DAILY
BASIS. FUNDS THAT PROVIDE
STUDENT RESOURCES PROVIDE THE
ABILITY TO REPAIR SCHOOLS AND
CLASSROOMS.
AND INVEST IN HUMAN CAPITAL FOR
SUPPORT PROGRAMS LIKE ARTS
STEM SPECIAL EDUCATION EL
UNIFIED BELIEVES THAT OF THIS
PROPOSAL IS CONSISTENT WITH PROP
THIRTY NINE. FROM TWO THOUSAND
THAT REDUCED THE VOTER THRESHOLD
TO PASS LOCAL BONDS TO SUPPORT
SCHOOL FACILITIES. AND THAT
RESULTED IN EXTREMELY POSITIVE
BENEFITS THAT SUPPORTED OUR
COMMUNITIES OUR STUDENTS PER
TEACHERS.
THAT FOR THOSE REASONS WAGER
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU SO
MUCH SIR.%
WELCOME BACK.
THANK YOU ERICA HOFFMAN ON
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
BOARDS ASSOCIATION.
PERSONAL TAXES ARE ABOUT THE
ONLY ADDITIONAL RESOURCE FOR
SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
IF THEY CAN GET THE PAST TO USE
FOR OPERATIONAL EXPENSES.
AT THIS POINT IN TIME THOUGH.
LOWER INCOME COMMUNITIES LESS
AFFLUENT COMMUNITIES ARE VERY
LIMITED IN IN THE PASSAGE OF
THESE AT A TWO THIRDS VOTE. WE
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS MEASURE WE
STRONGLY URGE ARRIVE OUT THANK
YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
GOOD MORNING RUNNING CRISTINA
MARCELLUS ON BEHALF OF THE
COUNTY OFFICES OF EDUCATION IN
ALAMEDA CONTRA COSTA SANTA
BARBARA IN SANTA CLARA IN
SUPPORT BECAUSE SO MUCH.
GOOD MORNING SIR AYE A PAGE A
LITTLE KAPPA VISORS GROUP ON
BEHALF OF SAN FRANCISCO UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT. PASADENA
UNIFIED AND PARAMOUNT UNIFIED
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH GOOD
MORNING.
MORNING NICK ROMAN ON BEHALF OF
THE SAN DIEGO COUNTY OFFICE OF
EDUCATION AND ALSO ON BEHALF OF
THE SMALL SCHOOL DISTRICTS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MORNING IN. THE
MORNING MICHELLE MCCANN ORDER ON
BEHALF OF THE TORRANCE UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH. CORNER SIR.
I GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN
AND MEMBERS DOMINIC TOMORROW
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
CHARTER SCHOOL ASSOCIATION.
NOT EXACTLY IN SUPPORT WE WANT
TO SUPPORT WE CANNOT CONSIDER
OURSELVES TWEETERS AT THIS POINT
WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH YOU
AUTHORED A FIGURE OUT. HOW HOME
CHARTER SCHOOLS MIGHT BE ABLE
TAXES
THESE PERSONAL TAXES A LITTLE
BIT? MORE READILY INSTEAD OF
CREATE A MORE EQUITABLE AND
STABLE FUNDING SOURCE FARCE WE
DON'T OFTEN. THE BENEFITS OF
THESE PARCEL TAXES OFTEN DON'T A
CREW TO CHARTER SCHOOLS IT'S A
VERY LOCALIZED SITUATION. SO FOR
INSTANCE HERE IN WEST CONTRA
COSTA COUNTY IN OAKLAND WE'VE
BEEN ABLE TO ACCESS THE PARCEL
TAXES TO AND THE BENEFIT OF
CHARTER SCHOOLS AND STUDENTS.
BUT IN SAN JOSE AND SAY THE
OTHER JURISDICTIONS.
HOME WE ARE ALAMEDA BEING ONE WE
HAVE NOT SO WE'VE BEEN WORKING
WITH THE AUTHOR TO FIGURE OUT A
MORE EQUITABLE WAY FOR US ACCESS
THESE PARCEL TAX.
THANK YOU AND THANK YOU SO MUCH.
A GROUP OF FOR THOSE COMMENTS.
WE'D LIKE YOU TO SEE IF ANYONE
ELSE WOULD LIKE ME TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OR IN THE SQUISHY
CATEGORY EPIC PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
ALRIGHT LET'S GO TO THOSE WHO
ARE OPPOSED TO GOING TO LEAD OFF
WITH MISTER WOLFE.
WELCOME HIM AS WELL AS WHAT FOR
SURE SIR. MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS THANK YOU DAVID WILL FOR
THE HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION THAT IN OPPOSITION
DESI TWENTY TWO. MEMBERS ON TO
START OUT BY SAYING I THINK THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS AYE HITS IT
WELL. THERE IS AND SHOULD BE A
TWO THIRDS THRESHOLD THERE IS IN
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT FOR. THE
INCREASES OF REVENUE THERE'S
ALSO A TWO THIRDS VOTE NOT ONLY
IN CALIFORNIA BUT IN MANY OTHER
STATES AND I DO WANNA APPRECIATE
THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS FOR
REFERENCING THAT.
MEMBERS I THINK THIS IS A QUOTE
ONCE ATTRIBUTED TO BEN FRANKLIN.
HE SAID DEMOCRACY IS TWO WOLVES
AND A SHEEP DECIDING WHAT'S FOR
DINNER.
MEMBERS IN THAT SITUATION THE
SHEEP GETS EATEN.
AND THE SHEEP NEEDS PROTECTION.
THAT IS THE POINT OF THE TWO
THIRDS VOTE.
AND AS IT PERTAINS TO PERSONAL
TAXES IT'S INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT
BECAUSE WELL EVERYONE GETS TO
VOTE ON PERSONAL TAXES IN A
COMMUNITY IN A SCHOOL DISTRICT.
ONLY THE PROPERTY OWNERS PAY.
IT'S IMPORTANT THE SHEEP THOSE
PROPERTY OWNERS IN THAT
SITUATION GET PROTECTED. MEMBERS
WE FURTHER ARGUE THAT LOWERING
THE TWO THIRDS VOTE IS
UNNECESSARY THERE'S A NUMBER OF
COMMUNITIES INCLUDING AN ORANGE
COUNTY WHERE I KNOW MISS WHEN IN
MISTER MAROC ARE FROM. THAT HAVE
INCREASED.
SALES TAXES FOR TRANSPORTATION
PURPOSES AND IN FACT THEY'VE
DONE IT NOT ONCE BUT TWICE IF
THERE IS APPROPRIATE
JUSTIFICATION THE THRESHOLD CAN
BE REACHED.
ACCORDING TO OUR WEBSITE
CALIFORNIA CITY FINANCE RUN BY
MICHAEL COLEMAN.
THEY'VE DONE REVIEWS OF SCHOOL
DISTRICT PARCEL TAXES SINCE
TWENTY TWELVE LOOKING AT
NOVEMBER ELECTIONS.
AND IN THAT ANALYSIS FORTY ONE
OF FIFTY FIVE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PERSONAL TAXES OVER SEVENTY FOUR
PERCENT. WERE APPROVED.
.
I JUST AS A FINAL COMMENT
PERSONAL TAX IS A VERY
REGRESSIVE.
NO MATTER THE SIZE OF YOUR
PERSONA MATTER THE SIZE OF YOUR
HOME YOU'RE PAYING THE SAME
PERSON.
IS IT FAIR THAT A MIDDLE CLASS
FAMILY PAYS THE SAME PATH TOXIN
ON A SOMEONE WHO LIVES IN A
MILLION DOLLAR MANSION AND AGAIN
THAT SPEAKS TO ANOTHER REASON
AND RATIONALE. WHY THE TWO
THIRDS VOTE NEEDS TO REMAIN IN
PLACE?
MEMBERS FINALLY I DO WANNA JUST
COMMENT I DO SYMPATHIZE WITH THE
AUTHOR ON THIS AND I DO
SYMPATHIZE.
REGARDING EDUCATION FUNDING ON
SOME LEVEL BACK WHEN I WORKED IN
THE LEGISLATURE TEN YEARS AGO AS
A FELLOW MY THAN BOSS
ASSEMBLYMAN GUY HOUSTON WORKED
VERY HARD ON EQUALIZATION
FUNDING. YOU KNOW ENSURING THAT
SCHOOL DISTRICTS ALL UP AND DOWN
THE STATE GOT MORE APPROPRIATE
FINDS IN MORE APPROPRIATE
SUPPORT. I THINK WE SHOULD ALSO
CONTINUE TO LOOK AT CHANGING HOW
THAT ONE PERCENT PROP THIRTEEN.
TAX THRESHOLD IS ALLOCATED AMONG
COUNTIES AND AMONG LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS
TO ENSURE SCHOOLS GET MORE
FUNDING MEMBERS THAT FORMULA
HASN'T BEEN LOOKED AT FOR
DECADES.
YEAH I KNOW THAT'S DIFFICULT
IT'S A DIFFICULT POLITICAL
CALCULATION IT'S A LOT EASIER TO
WORRY THE TWO THIRDS VOTE TO
FIFTY FIVE PERCENT BUT I DO
THINK THAT IS SOMETHING THAT
SHOULD BE REVIEWED.
BUT INTEL AND WOOD ASK FOR AN
OVER ME SO MUCH IT'S WORTH GOOD
MORNING SCHEDULE YOU. THERESA
MAY REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION AND WHILE
WE APPRECIATE THE INTENT OF THE
BILL WE NOTE THAT THIS BILL
WOULD INCREASE HOUSING BECAUSE.
THE LEGISLATURE HAS MADE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING OF FOR FRONT
TO DISCUSSION OVER THE LAST
COUPLE YEARS AND THIS COMMITTEE
TODAY HAS HEARD BILLS UP
REGARDING THE RENTERS TAX CREDIT
AS WELL AS LOW INCOME HOUSING
TAX CREDIT. BY FACILITATING A
TAX INCREASE ON PARCELS FISCAL
COULD INCREASE PROPERTY TAX
BILLS ANYWHERE FROM A COUPLE
HUNDRED DOLLARS TO A COUPLE
THOUSAND DOLLARS ANNUALLY. THIS
COSTS WOULD BE BORNE BY
HOMEOWNERS AS WELL AS WINTERS IN
THE FORM OF INCREASED RENT WE
HEARD EARLIER TODAY THAT
CALIFORNIA HAS THE FOURTH
HIGHEST AVERAGE RENTAL COSTS IN
THE NATION.
WE'RE ALSO CONCERNED THAT THIS
BILL IS UNNECESSARY BASED ON
DATA GOING BACK TO TWENTY TEN
BETWEEN TWENTY TEN AND TWENTY
SEVENTEEN. ONLY ONE HUNDRED NINE
A PARCEL TAXES FAILED OUT OF
FIVE HUNDRED THAT'S LESS THAN
TWENTY PERCENT BY MOVING FROM A
TWO THIRDS THRESHOLD TO A FIFTY
FIVE PERCENT THRESHOLD. WE
BELIEVE THIS BILL IS UNNECESSARY
AS THE THE UP PUBLIC POLICY
INSTITUTE OF CALIFORNIA THIS MAY
OR ITS GIVES ME THIS MARCH
CONDUCTED A POLL. IN THE POLL
ACROSS ALL VOTER REGISTRATION
ACROSS SEGMENTS OF INCOME AND
REGIONS IN CALIFORNIA INDICATED
THAT THEY DID NOT FAVOR. MOVING
THE VOTE THRESHOLD FROM TWO
THIRDS TO FIFTY FIVE PERCENT. WE
ALSO BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTS
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND
LOWER INCOME FAMILIES ESPECIALLY
THOSE ON FIXED INCOME BECAUSE
THIS IS NOT AN AD VALOREM TAX
BUT IT'S A FLAT RATE. WE ALSO
BELIEVE THIS BILL UNDERMINES THE
PROFITS THAT THE PROPERTY TAX
PROTECTIONS. UNDER PROPOSITION
THIRTEEN AND WHERE WHERE
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE THIS
LEGISLATION BIG SO I THINK YOU
FOR COMMENTS WE'D LIKE TO BE TO
SEE IF WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE IS
SUPPOSE IF YOU COULD PLEASE COME
FORWARD THIS TIME ANYONE WHO'S
OPPOSED PLEASE ADVANCE.
GLASCOFF FOR THOSE OPPOSED.
LET'S BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE
FOR OUR QUESTIONS OR
CONVERSATION.
WE HAVE THAT PLEASE CENTER
MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN THANK
YOU FOR INVOKING MY NAME.
AS FORMER TREASURER TAX
COLLECTOR FOR THE COUNTY OF
ORANGE.
WE'RE RUNNING OUT OF BILL SPACE
OF ALL THE BOND MEASURES AND ALL
THE TAXES THAT ARE SHOWING UP
FACTOR CONTROL.
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT
SCHOOL DISTRICT NOW MULTIPLE
BOND MEASURES THAT HAVE BEEN
APPROVED.
SO HOMEOWNERS ARE GETTING TAX
BILLS THAT ARE PRETTY. OWNERS
WERE THIS ONE PERCENT PROP
THIRTEEN AREAS GONE YOU'VE GOT.
ONE PERCENT CLASS YOU KNOW
ANOTHER HIGH PERCENTAGE OF ALL
THESE. ADELINE SO.
WITH THAT I AM I AM A LITTLE
CONCERNED IT PROBABLY WILL BE
MAKING THE MOTION BUT I. I JUST
WANNA MAKE THE OBSERVATION THAT.
.
TEN YEARS AGO I FILED A LAWSUIT
AGAINST.
THE ORANGE COUNTY.
ASSOCIATION OF DEPUTY SHERIFFS
IT WAS KIND OF. AN INTERESTING
CASE BUT WE GIVE THEM THREE
PERCENT FIFTY RETROACTIVE TO THE
DATE HIGHER. IN THE STATE
CONSTITUTION SAYS THAT'S A DEBT.
YOU KNOW IT AND YOU'RE NOT
SUPPOSED TO ENCOURAGE DEBT
WITHOUT THE VOTE OF TWO THIRDS
OF YOUR VOTERS TO APPROVE THAT
THAT.
AND AND THE HISTORY WAS THAT.
IN THE LATE EIGHTEEN HUNDREDS
THE A FEW CITIES WERE TRYING SO
HARD TO GET RAILROADS TO COME
INTO THEIR CITIES. AND SO THE
CITY COUNCILS BY PEOPLE WERE
OCCURRING MASSIVE DEBTS TO
ENCOURAGE THE ROADS ONLY TO HAVE
THE REAL WILL NOT SHOW UP. AND
IN THE CITY WAS NOW IT
ENCUMBERED WITH ALL THIS.
DEBTS OF THE CONSTITUTION INTO
ARTICLES.
YOUR MANDATES THAT NO DEBT NO
DEBT CAN BE AS A TAKEN BY COUNTY
WITHOUT A TWO THIRDS VOTE OF ITS.
OF ITS RESIDENTS SO I AM REAL
CONCERN ABOUT THAT THRESHOLD
THERE'S A THERE'S A REASON
SIDIOUS SAN DIEGO HISTORICALLY
ACTUALLY WENT BANKRUPT WITH HAVE
HIM BACK IN THE LATE EIGHTEEN
HUNDREDS DON'T TALK ABOUT IT
MUCH BUT.
SO SO THOSE ARE THE THINGS I'M
CONCERNED ABOUT APPRECIATE WE
TRYING TO ADJUST.
I'M HAVING TROUBLE WITH THE
THRESHOLD BEAUTICIAN THIS IS NOT
IS NOT DEAD ACCRUAL THIS BILL.
BUT I KNOW THAT I'M ABOUT BUT
I'M JUST SAYING MY HISTORY. YOU
KNOW MADE MY CONTEXT IS YOU KNOW
WE SOMEWHERE SOMEHOW SOMEONE
SAID THIS IS A GOOD THRESHOLD TO
PREVENT. AND MAYBE HELP.
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
HELP THEMSELVES WITHOUT GETTING
INTO A DEAD SITUATION THAT THEY
CAN HANDLE OR OR SOME SOME
OTHERS IN I DON'T I WAS ABOUT TO
DEBT. BY THINK IT UP IT APPLIES.
TO THE PARTIAL TAXES WELL.
IT'S I'VE BEEN OPPOSED TO IT
REDUCTIONS EVEN FOR THE SCHOOL
BY WHICH PROPERTY NINE.
RIGHT OUT FIFTEEN TWENTY YEARS
AGO I DIE WHO OPPOSE THAT IS
WELL I'M JUST REAL NERVOUS ABOUT
LOWERING THE THRESHOLD SO THAT'S
WORK WHERE I MET SO. I THEREFORE
WILL NOT BE MAKING THE MOTION
BUT I I APPRECIATE THE FACT THAT
YOU'RE ENCOURAGING ABOUT THE
GOOD SENATOR. OF SENATOR ALLEN
WHO IS JUST INCREDIBLE ASSOCIATE
ABSOLUTELY THINK IT'S MY SIMMER
LIKE LET'S GO SENATOR HURTING.
WHY NOT FIFTY ONE PERCENT?
LOOK I THINK I'M.
YOU KNOW I I THINK IT'S A GOOD
QUESTION IT'S A VERY GOOD
QUESTION.
I I THINK THAT.
WE'VE HAD A LONG TRADITION OF
HAVING A HIGH BAR ASSOCIATED
WITH PARCEL TAX.
AND YOU KNOW I I DO I I I I I I
HAVE SOME SYMPATHY FOR SOME OF
THE ARGUMENTS HAVE BEEN MADE.
ABOUT ENSURING THAT IF WE ARE
GOING TO RAISE PEOPLE'S TAXES
ARE WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
THERE'S SOME FORM OF
SUPERMAJORITY.
YOU KNOW WE'VE WE'VE WE LAND I.
FIFTY FIVE PERCENT FOR SCHOOL
BONDS.
BUT WILL SAY ALL SORTS OF
SPECIAL.
YEAH.
SALES AND USE TAXES COULD BE.
PASSED. BY CITY WITH THE
MAJORITY VOTE.
BUT I I THINK THAT THIS IS A
THIS IS A GOOD COMPROMISE.
GIVEN WHERE WE HAVE BEEN A TWO
THIRDS.
I IN A WAY THAT I THINK PEOPLE
WILL FIND MORE PALATABLE.
WHY NOT THE NOVEMBER TWENTY
TWENTY VALID INSTEAD OF THE
NOVEMBER EIGHTEEN BILL AND I'M
HAPPY DE UM?
TO LOOK AT THAT. IF IF IF FOLKS
WHO SUPPORT THIS THINK THAT
THAT'SA BETTER MOVE. THAT'S
THAT'S AN OPTION.
ONLY BECAUSE IF YOU DO IT THE
END OF THE GAME DAY ITS
POLITICAL WAS. TRYING TO GET
MORE PEOPLE TO BALLOT YOU'LL GET
MORE TO PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION.
THEN YOU WELL. UNFORTUNATELY THE
GUBERNATORIAL ELECTION I'M VERY
OPEN TO THAT CONVERSATION CENTER.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
WE ALSO WELCOME A MOTION ON THE
FLOOR.
I HAVE HAD.
THEY.
AWKWARD SILENCE ARE AYE.
THANKS SO MUCH CENTER BELL WE
THIS MOTION IS ABBY DOT TO
DECIDE ELECTIONS AND
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS.
SURROUND YOU WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
PLEASE I LISTEN I APPRECIATE THE
THOUGHTFUL DISCUSSION.
OF EVERYBODY INVOLVED IN.
THE LIBERAL YOU LOOK FOR TO WORK
WITH EVERYONE IS THIS IS MOVES
ALONG AND I ALSO WAS.
WANT TO THANK THE FOLKS WHO
SPOKE OUT BOTH IN OPPOSITION AND
THE TRAINERS AND SUPPORT I THINK
I THINK IT. WAS A PATH HERE AND
ULTIMATELY THIS IS ABOUT
PROVIDING LOCAL VOTERS
WITH MORE LOCAL CONTROL OVER DE.
THE HEAD OVER THEIR OWN.
TAXATION SYSTEM THEIR OWN
REVENUE GENERATION SYSTEM FOR
THE LOCAL SCHOOLS.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AROUND WE HAVE
A.
EMOTIONAL FOR BE TAPPED TO
DESCEND ELECTIONS ACCOUNTS YOU
FROM THEM IT'S NOT BY CENTER
MORE LUCK BUT BY SENATOR BELL.
SO A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE
HUSSEIN GESTURE MCGUIRE AYE
WHERE I WIN.
NGUYEN NOBEL. DEL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG.
YEAH HER HIGH LARA.
MORLOCK. MORLOCK KNOW THREE TO
THE CURLY JOE IS A THREE TO
PROCEDURAL OPEN MISTER ALLEN IN
WILL BE BACK TO THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BUT IS IT A NEW. THE GOOD
SENATOR FROM ORANGE COUNTY'S
HERE TODAY.
HE HAS A BILL SENATE BILL ELEVEN
SIXTEEN.
I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH
TO THE SENATOR FOR WORKING WITH
THE COMMITTEE TO BETTER PROVIDE
CLEAR FINE LANGUAGE AND MINUTES
AGO. WE HAVE GIVEN GREATER
DEFINITION TO FIRST TIME HOME
BUYER. WE'VE EXCLUDED SELLERS
WHO SELL TO RELATED PARTIES FROM
QUALIFYING FOR THE INCREASE
EXCLUSION. ARE ADDITIONALLY
WE'VE ALSO INCLUDED A
VERIFICATION PROCESS IN WHICH
THE SELLER MUST OBTAIN A SIGNED
CERTIFICATE FOR THE BUYER SAY
THAT THE BUYER IS A QALIFIED.
FIRST TIME HOME BUYER I WANT TO
CONFIRM WHAT THE GOOD SENATOR
FROM ORANGE COUNTY THAT HE'S IN
WE TAKE ANY AMENDMENTS.
THAT WOULD BE CORRECT ALRIGHT I
IN AGAIN CENTER MORE LUCK IS A
PLEASURE TO WORK WITH I JUST
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU THE FLOOR
IS YOURS SIR IN YOU AT
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT SURF SO. FEEL
FREE TO AYE ADVANCE A BRIEF
PRESENTATION THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR
HELP AND IT IS AN HONOR TO WORK
WITH YOU AND. YOU AND I ARE THE
LAST TWO BILLS LEFT SO. GOOD TO
BE BACK HERE WITH YOU THERE AGO
SIR.
COLLEAGUES AT OVER THE WEEKEND
I WAS READING A BOOK
AND IT WAS A REPORT ISSUED BY
THE GENET TO BIAS WHO WAS THE
EXECUTIVE. SECRETARY OF THE SAN
DIEGO JEWISH WELFARE SOCIETY AND
IT WAS DATED MAY FOURTEENTH
NINETEEN FORTY SEVEN. SEVEN
YEARS AGO ALMOST TO THE DAY AND
IT IT RECOUNTED THAT WHAT THE
POST WAR PERIOD. CAME NEW
CHALLENGES.
ESPECIALLY HOUSING.
SEN DIEGO'S POPULATION
SKYROCKETED AFTER THE WAR THE
MILD CLIMATE
AND BOOMING DEFENSE ECONOMY
ATTRACTED RETURNING SOLDIERS AND
THEIR FAMILIES AS WELL AS OTHER
AMERICANS WHO SAW OPPORTUNITY
AND FAIR WEATHER AS A WINNING
COMBINATION. AT A BABY BOOM TO
THE SWELL OF NEWCOMERS IN SAN
DIEGO FOUND ITSELF WITH A REAL
HOUSING SHORTAGE.
SO TOBIAS CALLED HOUSING THE
BIGGEST AND TOUGHEST CHALLENGE.
FACING THE AGENCY IN THE
IMMEDIATE POSTWAR PERIOD AND
COLLEAGUES WE ARE HERE AGAIN HAD
SEVEN YEARS LATER AND HERE WE
ARE FACING. ANOTHER HOUSING
SHORTAGE.
AT THIS PARTICULAR TIME IN OUR
STATE'S HISTORY FOR THE GOOD
NEWS IS IS THAT.
AS YOU'VE SEEN WHO HAD JUST
INCREDIBLE ARRAY OF BILLS TODAY
ARE TRYING TO ADDRESS THE
SITUATION AND OF THE LEGISLATURE
HAS BEEN LOOKING AT NUMEROUS
OTHER SOLUTIONS.
TO ADDRESS THIS MAJOR CONCERN
ONCE AGAIN SENATE BILL ONE ONE
ONE SIX WHICH IS BEFORE YOU IS
ONE OF THOSE POSSIBLE
RECOMMENDATIONS TO CONSIDER.
VERY SIMPLE THERE ARE MANY
BENEFITS AVAILABLE THE FIRST
TIME HOME BUYERS IN CALIFORNIA
BUT MOST OF THEM ASSIST IN
LENDING ALTERNATIVES.
BUT IF A YOUNG COUPLE DOES NOT
HAVE THE BEST OFFER IN A HOT
MARKET.
THEN THE FINANCING
OPPORTUNITIES WILL NOT BE
AVAILABLE.
SO HOW DO WE ASSIST IN
OVERCOMING THIS HURDLE IF WE CAN
GET THE SELLER THE SELLER NOT
THE BUYER BUT THE SELLER AN
INCENTIVE. TO SELL A PERSONAL
RESIDENTS TO A FIRST TIME HOME
BUYER THEN WE COULD CHANGE THE
GAME. SO LET'S SAY A SELLER
RECEIVES TWO OPERAS BOTH FOR
FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
ONE PARTY IS AN INVESTOR WHO'S
GONNA RENTED OUT THE OTHER PARTY
IS A YOUNG COUPLE. STARTING OUT.
WHO LIVE THERE YOU KNOW WE WANT
TO GIVE AN INCENTIVE TO THE
SELLER TO PICK
IF THEY GET TO PICK THE BUYER?
THEN MAKE SURE THAT IT'S THE
YOUNGER COUPLE IF THE INVESTOR.
UPS THE BED THEN AT LEAST
THERE'S SOME ROOM FOR THAT
SELLERS TO SAY WAIT A SECOND
WE'RE STILL GOING TO SELL THE
YOUNG COUPLE BECAUSE. WILL MAKE
IT UP IN A TAX SAVINGS SO.
THE TAX SAVINGS. ALLOW FOR AN
ADDITIONAL FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
TO THE CAPITAL GAINS EXCLUSION
THAT'S IN FEDERAL LAW. IT WOULD
BE THAT'S FOR SINGLE PERSON BE
HUNDRED THOUSAND FOR A JOINT
RETURN.
SO WITH THAT WE'VE WE'VE GOT TAG.
SELLERS THAT MAYBE ARE MOVING ON
TO RETIREMENT FACILITIES CLOSING
DOWN SELLING OUT.
I WOULD THINK THEY WOULD LOVE
TO BE ABLE TO SELL TO A YOUNG
COUPLE AND LEAVE A.
AN OPPORTUNITY TO ANOTHER YOUNG
FAMILIES STARTING OUT JUST LIKE
THEY DID SO. THAT'S THE
INTRINSIC VALUE WAS WELL
COLLEAGUES THIS IS AN
OPPORTUNITY TO KEEP YOUNGER
MEMBERS OF OUR WORKFORCE IN
CALIFORNIA. ALLEN I THINK THE
CHAIR THE COMMITTEE STAFF IN THE
FRANCHISE TAX BOARD FOR THE
RECOMMENDED AMENDMENTS WHICH I
GLADLY ACCEPT.
CLARIFYING THE DEFINITION OF A
FIRST TIME BUYER PROVIDING
VERIFICATION OF SAME PREVENTING
CONVERSION. OF A TO NON
RESIDENTS AND PROHIBITING THIS
BENEFIT FOR TRANSACTIONS BETWEEN
RELATED PARTIES THEY'RE ALL
EXCELLENT ADDITIONS AND I
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN AYE VOTE
AND I'M HONORED TO HAVE TONY
KEPT TELLING.
I'LL WHO IS THE.
BRAINCHILD OF THIS IDEA.
AND SOME I KNOW FOR A LONG TIME.
ACTUALLY IT WENT TO HIS WEDDING
MANY YEARS AGO HOFFA TO HAVE HIM
AS MY KEY WITNESS BUT SPEAKING
OF WEDDINGS THAT IS MAY NINTH
AND I WANT TO SAY ON THE RECORD
THAT.
THIRTY EIGHT YEARS AGO TODAY I
PROPOSED TO MY WIFE SO HA THAT
LIFE IS GOOD. VERY GIVING.
HOW WE?
HOW DO YOU PROPOSE?
TOOK HER TO A RESTAURANT I
INCLUDE IN NEWPORT BEACH CREDIT
MARQUARDT CALL FIVE CROWNS
RETURN PCH AND.
AFTER DINNER I PULLED OUT THE
RING IN.
THAT'S AND DEATH.
WITH A GREAT WAS A GREAT EVENING
OF THIS IS A WONDERFUL LADY AND
SHE'S PUT UP WITH THIS CRAZY
SCHEDULE BUT YOU AND I. AND
CENTER BALANCE CENTER WHEN PUT
UP WITH IT'S NOT EASY BEING THE
SPOUSE OF A.
OF THE STATE SENATOR BUT DOES
SHE'S JUST BEEN VERY SPECIAL
WIENER IS.
WAS I NERVOUS YEAH.
YES I WAS ARE ENGAGED WHICH I
HAVE HAD FOR A. WONDERFUL THE A
GRADUATIONS HOW LONG HAVE YOU
BEEN MARRIED.
I'VE BEEN MARRIED FOR NINE YEARS
AGO THAT AND DISLIKE RIGHT OFF
THE BAT I LIKE.
LIFE IS LOOSING ABOUT RIGHT HEY
THERE YOU GO.
WHERE TO GET IT RIGHT? THIS YEAR
HE GIVES US OF THE FLOORS ARE
YOU A BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
HERE.
GOOD MORNING SIR MCGUIRE AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME THIS MORNING THAT LIKE
SO MANY TODAY ALL STATE THE
OBVIOUS WE'RE IN THE MIDST OF A
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY CRISIS.
STATES MEDIAN HOME PRICE IN
MARCH WAS ABOUT FIVE HUNDRED
FORTY THOUSAND DOLLARS THAT
MEANS ONLY THIRTY PER TWO
PERCENT. OF RESIDENTS IN THE
STATE CAN AFFORD TO BUY MEDIAN
PRICED HOME.
THE SOLUTION TO THIS IS SIMPLE
SUPPLY.
COMPOSTING THE SOLUTION HOWEVER
WILL TAKE IS DECADES.
IN THE MEANTIME THE SUPPLY
SHORTAGE AS THE GOOD SENATOR
STATED IS ARTIFICIALLY CREATED
AN ALTAR COMPETITIVE SELLERS
MARKET.
KENTUCKY PERSONALLY I SOLD MY
THREE BEDROOM TOWN ON THE COSTA
MESA IN NINE HOURS.
LAST MONTH.
THE MEDIAN DAYS A MARKET ORANGE
COUNTY WAS ABOUT THIRTEEN DAYS.
FIRST TIME BUYERS FINING.
HOME IS ESPECIALLY DIFFICULT
REAL SEE TRANSACTION IS
INCREDIBLY COMPLICATED. AND WHEN
MOST TO LOOKING TO SELL THEIR
HOME THEIR SIMULTANEOUSLY FORCED
OF OLDER SIMULTANEOUSLY LOOKING
FOR THEIR NEXT MOVE. ALL CASH
BUYERS IN THOSE WITH LARGE DOWN
PAYMENTS ARE APPEALING TO
SELLERS BECAUSE AT RISK OF
FALLING AS GROWS VERY LOW.
FIRST TIME BUYERS HOWEVER ARE
OFTEN APPROACHING A TRANSACTION
WITH AS LITTLE AS THREE POINT
FIVE PERCENT DOWN TO PUT SIMILAR
AT A NATURAL DISADVANTAGE.
AND STILL MARKET ONLY
EXACERBATES THE PROBLEM.
ACCORDING TO ADAM DATA SOLUTIONS
TEN PERCENT OF SALES IN TWO
THOUSAND SIX WERE ALL CASH SALES.
IN TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN THAT
NUMBER IS UP TO TWENTY NINE
PERCENT.
WHAT IS RESULTING IS A STEADILY
DECLINING CALIFORNIA
HOMEOWNERSHIP RATE ACCORDING TO
US CENSUS THE OWNER OCCUPIED
RATE WENT FROM FIFTY SEVEN POINT
FOUR IN TWO THOUSAND TEN?
THE FIFTY FOUR POINT ONE AND TWO
THOUSAND SIXTEEN THAT ALTHOUGH
THIS DOESN'T SEEM LIKE MUCH OF A
CHANGE THE DANGER LIES IN THE
FACT THAT NUMBER HAS NOT APPROVE
IMPROVE WITH THE ECONOMY.
THE STOCK MARKET IS UP
UNEMPLOYMENT'S DOWN ENRAGES ARE
SLOWLY RISING YEAH HOMEOWNERSHIP
IS STEADILY DECLINING.
S. B. ELEVEN SIXTEEN WORKS TO
LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD.
HOMEOWNERSHIP IS THE BEST AND
EASIEST WAY TO MOVE UP THE
ECONOMIC LADDER AND GENERATE
WILL FOR YOUR FAMILY. THE
AVERAGE HOMEOWNER HAS A HUNDRED
NINETY NINE THOUSAND DOLLARS AND
WEALTH FOR THE AVERAGE RUNNER
ONLY HAS TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED. IS
DECLINING HOMEOWNERSHIP RATE IS
CREATING GENERATIONAL ECONOMIC
DIVIDES AND KEEPING MONTHLY
HOUSING LIABILITIES HIGH.
AS A MORTGAGE IS STILL MORE
AFFORDABLE THAN RENTING SO I
KINDLY ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR VERY
GRATEFUL THAT BE TO SEE IF
ANYONE ELSE ISN'T SUPPORT IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE MIKE FRONT
THIS TIME WE WELCOME.
NOW WOULD LIKE TO SEE IF ANYONE
IS OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD ANYONE AS OPPOSED.
BUT ISN'T GENERALLY COMMITTEE
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT UP ALRIGHT
WE HAVE MOTION WE HAVE A MOTION
THE FLOOR. BUT GETS INTO FROM
SAN JOSE.
I NEED TO XIN DISCUSSION. ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE AND
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
THURMOND UP WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE
A CLOSE PLEASE.
SURE I REQUEST RESPECTFULLY AND
I VOTE THANK YOU SO MUCH WE DO
HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR THIS
IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS BY SENATOR BELL.
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE TO SANCHEZ
WIRE HIGH WIRE IRWIN.
WE AYE BELL. AYE HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
MORLOCK I LIKE GUY FIVE.
FIVE ZERO BIPARTISAN GROUP HUG%
HERE TODAY THANKS SO MUCH OF AND
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN.
A THERE WE GO.
I'M GONNA BE AT PRESENT IN OUR
FINAL BILL THE DAY WHICH IS.
ON ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN
BE. NO EXCUSE THE SP FOURTEEN
SIXTEEN I DO APOLOGIZE A CITY
FOURTEEN SIXTEEN.
THE ADVICE YOU.
ITEM FIFTEEN S. B. FOURTEEN
SIXTEEN.
WE'RE GOING TO.
WE DO NEED TO GET LIKE IBM I
HAVE LITTLE. IF IT IF IT FITS
I'M CHAIR A. B.. TO GET.
REACHING.
MRS CHAIRMAN PLEASE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH BETTER VICE
CHAIR.
THIS COMMITTEE IS VERY FAMILIAR
WITH THE HEARINGS THAT WE HELD.
APPROXIMATELY YEAR AND A HALF
AGO. ABOUT THE GHOST SHIP FIRES
BUT MANY OF YOU PARTICIPATED IN
THEM. LATE ON THE NIGHT OF
DECEMBER SIXTH DECEMBER SECOND
TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN A
CATASTROPHIC FIRE. AT A
CONVERTED WAREHOUSE KNOWN AS THE
GHOST SHIP. RESULT IN THE TRAGIC
DEATHS OF THIRTY SIX RESIDENTS.
THE HIGHEST DEATH TOLL FOR
STRUCTURAL FIRE THE UNITED
STATES IN DECADES.
IT REALLY WAS TRULY DEVASTATING
FOR THE COMMUNITY. AND FOR THE
REST OF CALIFORNIA. THIS FAST
MOVING FIRE SHIPPED TO COMMUNITY
VOCAL IN OF THE REST OF THE
STATE.
IN RESPONSE THIS COMMITTEE ON
CHAIRS ARE OPPOSITION OF THIS
MEASURE.
YES THERE IS. AN OPPOSITION TO
FILE.
WELL ON OUR SIDE. THOUGH.
MANAGERLEAGUE.
I WAS WE COULD GET YOU FROM
FIGHTING FOR A TO MOVE IT I LIKE
TO MOVE IS WELL.
AND SO DO WE WANT TO LIKE ARM
WRESTLE OUT OKAY SO AM. I THINK
THE I THINK I THINK IS IT'S
ALMOST NOON MISTER CHAIRMAN I
THINK SOME OF US ARE HUNGRY
THAT'S WHAT.
I WILL KEEP THIS.
SHORT AND YOU SEE THIS MEMBERS
THERE TO REFORM MEASURES THAT
ARE MOVING FORWARD TO BE ABLE TO
PROTECT.
WE GO TO PROTECT THOSE RESIDENTS.
BY AND ENSURE THAT CITIES HAVE
THE TOOLS THEY NEED TO BE ABLE
TO ENFORCE LAWS THAT ARE
CURRENTLY ON THE BOOKS.
I HAVE WITH ME TODAY TO PREPARE
BE ABLE TO PROVIDE A TESTIMONY
MR PROCIDA WHOSE A PUBLIC SAFETY
MANAGER FOR.
THE GOOD CITY TO OUR TO HE'S A
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF CODE
FORCING OFFICERS AND I DO WANT
TO SAY THANK YOU LARRY THIS MAN
I AS I JUST SAID NEED TO BE ABLE
TO GET AN APARTMENT HE'S HERE SO
OFTEN. OF HELP AND WORK ON THESE
BILLS WERE VERY GRATEFUL AND WE
ALSO HAVE THE VERY COUNTY KEY
KATIE ALMOND HERE TODAY EVER
AFFAIRS MANAGERFOR CALIFORNIA
BUILDING OFFICIALS. OUGHT TO BE
A RIVER PROVIDE SOME VERY BRIEF
TESTIMONY IN SUPPORT.
ABSOLUTELY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
SENATOR MCGUIRE AND I LOST LIKE
TO THINK CENTER MCGUIRE FOR ALL
OF HIS EFFORTS AND TIME INVESTED
IN THIS IS A BEEN A YEAR IN THE
MAKING PUTTING ALL THIS
LEGISLATION TOGETHER. BUT ALSO
LIKE TO THANK.
AYE IS A STAFF MEMBER AND TIME.
WE'VE GONE BACK AND FORTH
SEVERAL TIMES A LIKE CENTER
MCGUIRE MENTIONED WITH S. B.
FOURTEEN FIFTEEN AND S. B.
FOURTEEN SIXTEEN WHICH IS WHAT
YOU'RE HEARING TODAY.
IT'S BEEN IT'S BEEN A PROCESS A
VERY VERY BIG PROCESS AND THESE
TWO BILLS WORK IN CONCERT WITH
ONE ANOTHER TO HELP RESOURCES
LOCALLY. AND COUNTIES LOCALLY SO
THAT WE CAN.
GET THE RESOURCES WE NEED TO
MAKE ENFORCEMENT STATE HOUSING
AS WE KNOW IN AND COULDN'T FOR
SOME AND.
WE REPRESENT AT I'M A
REPRESENTATIVE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF ODE ENFORCEMENT
OFFICERS ARE NOT REPRESENT COULD
FORCE IN OFFICES ACROSS THE
ENTIRE STATE AND WHAT WE HAVE TO
DEAL WITH. DAY IN AND DAY OUT IS
VIOLATIONS WE HAVE PEOPLE THAT
ARE ARE PROPERTY OWNERS AND LAND
OWNERS AND THE RUNNING WE DO
THERE IS A TESTIMONY EARLIER
ABOUT.
RENTING IN TENANTS NOT SORT OF
THING AND THE WORST SCENE IS
THAT WE'RE SEEING THESE
PROPERTIES ARE BEING SUBSTANDARD
AT LEAST OUT SO THEY'RE THEY'RE
BE RENTED OUT SUBSTANDARD
CONDITIONS. FIRE HOUSES
ELECTRICAL HAZARDS IT'S ALL
KINDS OF DIFFERENT ISSUES AND
THIS BILL WHAT THIS ACCOMPLISHES
IS IT ACTUALLY SETS A COURT SET
SETS RESOURCES. FOR CODE
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS FIRE
INSPECTORS AND SO ON TO GO OUT
THERE AND INSPECT THE
SUBSTANDARD HOUSING SUBSECTORS
INSPECTORS PROPERTIES AND MAKE
SURE THAT THEY'RE BEING PROPERLY
MAINTAINED. AND IT SETS FORTH
THIS LEGISLATION SO IT'S REALLY
IMPORTANT FOR I THINK NOT ONLY
FOR COULD FORCE MY OFFICE BUT
FIRE INSPECTORS BUT FOR RENTERS
INTENDED SO THAT THEY'RE BEING
TREATED EQUALLY AND I SAY
EQUALLY.
BECAUSE NOT ONLY ARE THEY OF
BRANCHING OUT THE SUBSTANDARD
HOUSING BUT WE ALSO HAVE A
SITUATION WHERE WE HAVE SOME
LANDOWNERS AND THIS ONLY
ADDRESSES BAD ACTORS.
BAD ACTORS BADLAND ORDERS DAD OR
TAKING ADVANTAGE OF TENANTS AND
RENTERS AND WHAT THIS ADDRESSES
JUST THEM A DOZEN TO REPRESS
EVERY OTHER POPULATION JUST
ADDRESS AND FOCUSES ON THEM. SO
WE GET THOSE RESOURCES BACK AND
FROM THOSE BAD ACTORS AND ONLY
ADDRESSING THOSE SITUATIONS BUT
FURTHERMORE IT ALSO IT ALLOWS A
RESOURCE TO GO DIRECTLY BACK
INTO THE ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM.
NOT BACK INTO THE GENERAL FUND
SO THAT WE CAN FOCUS AGAIN PRO
ACTIVELY ON MAKING SURE WE DON'T
HAVE SITUATIONS LIKE THE GHOST
FIRE OCCUR ONCE AGAIN.
SO MUCH.
THESE AYE KITTY ALMOND WITH THE
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS
AYE KALPOE DOES SUPPORT THIS
BILL AS IT SEES THE NEED FOR
IMPROVING SAFETY S. STANDARDS
REGARDING BUILDINGS. AND WE ALSO
SEE THAT THESE FINES AS MANDATED
IN THE BILL WOULD HELP LOCAL
AGENCIES INCREASE AND I GET THE
FUNDS THAT ARE NECESSARY TO
INCREASE HIS INSPECTIONS. AND
DEAL WITH THE SAFETY ISSUE THANK
YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH IT. SURE.
THE.
I DON'T. THINK THERE'S A MOST
SEN.
AND THE MORE SUPPORT PLEASE ROLE
THAT YOU'RE.
BILL OR LIKE IT'S A FAIR CALL
WELL AND.
I LIKE CHOPPED LIVER NOW AND
MAILLET MEAN YEAH YOU KNOW I
HAVE A GIFT CODE FOR THE PLEASE.
THE. COURT BACKYARD WITH THE
CALIFORNIA BUSINESS PROPERTIES
ASSOCIATION WE PARTICIPATED IN
THE TASK FORCE PACKAGES WILL
QUICKLY SAY WE REALLY APPRECIATE
THAT THE AUTHOR AND THE STAFF.
HAS DISTINGUISHED BETWEEN ACTUAL
WAREHOUSES THAT ARE OPERATING AS
WAREHOUSES AND THOSE OLDER
BUILDINGS THAT ARE FALLING OUT
OF THAT OPERATIONS AND ARE ARE
MOVING ON TO OTHER USES. THAT'S
AN IMPORTANT DISTINCTION FOR MY
MEMBERS WHO WILL CALL THE GOOD
ACTORS AND WE REALLY APPRECIATE
THE SUPPORT OF KABUL AND ALL THE
CODE FOLKS OUT THERE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
GOOD AFTERNOON ELIZABETH
ESPINOSA HERE TODAY ON BEHALF OF
THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS WE APPRECIATE THE
BILL SENATE MCGUIRE AND ARE
PLEASED TO SUPPORT THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER SUPPORT ANY OPPOSITION
SEEN NONE. THERE'S A MOTION
WHICH YOU LIKE TO CLOSE ODYSSEY.
TWENTY SECONDS WE KNOW WHAT
WE'RE TRYING MULTIPLE
STAKEHOLDERS HAVE BEEN AT THE
TABLE UP FOR MULTIPLE MONTHS AND
IT'S HARD TO SAY THANK YOU TO
ALL OF THEM HAVE BEEN
PARTICIPATING. IN A ROW SPECIAL
SHOUT OUT IN TIME WHO HAS BEEN
WORKING ON NUMEROUS ISSUES OVER
THE PAST MANY MONTHS FOR THE
WORKING GROUP AND THAT WOULD NOT
HAVE BEEN ABLE TO BRING FOR
THESE REFORMS. OUT WITHOUT HIM
AND OF COURSE WORKING GROUP
THINK YOU WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE AT AN
APPROPRIATE TIME.
THERE'S A LOT TO SAY SENATOR.
CHOIR THAT THEY ARE YOU KNOW
ORANGE COUNTY HAS A WE'D
ABATEMENT PROGRAM AND YEAH
TREASURER TAX COLLECTOR.
YOU KNOW WE WE PUT IT ON THE TAX
BILL IF WE HAD TO GO IN AND
CLEAN OUT YOUR WEEDS WHICH WAS A.
YOU KNOW A REMOVAL OF FIRE
HAZARDS
THAT WE WOULD PUT ON YOUR TAX
BILLS ALINA JUSTICE.
PROCESS AND SO I THINK THIS IS A
BRILLIANT IDEA. IT WAS DONE BY
THE AGRICULTURAL COMMISSIONER OF
THE COUNTY BUT YOU KNOW WE JUST
WISH WE SHOULD BE THINKING ABOUT.
URBAN CONFLAGRATIONS AND SO I
APPRECIATE ALL YOUR HARD WORK.
WELL ON ON THIS.
EFFORT AND.
IN HIM HAPPY TO CODE A MOTION
YOUR BILL.
OKAY AND BE GRATEFUL TO BE TO
WORK WITH YOU SIR THANK YOU ALL
AND ALL OF YOU THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
THERE'S A MOTION BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG AND SENATOR SIX
HUNDRED.
SENATOR MORE LOCKED.
PLEASE CALL A THIS IS DO PASSED
TO THE FLOOR PLEASE CALL FOR THE
WIRE AYE. AYE NGUYEN.
BELLE. BELLE I HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE LARA
MORE LOCK.
WHEN I GUY WHO SEE ROOM.
THIS FOUR ZERO AND WE WILL KEEP
THE WILL CALL OPEN.
I HAVE CLEARLY MORE BILLS
TO VOTE ON CAN HE MOVE CAN. WE
GO TO THOSE TWO.
OR MATERIAL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF WHAT.
WHAT WOULD YOU TWELVE AND
THIRTEEN PERSON?
THE FALCON.
PLEASE JOIN THE COMMITTEE WE ARE
GOING TO TAKE ITEM NUMBER TWELVE
AND THIRTEEN FIRST WE ARE GOING
TO WAIT TO TAKE THE REMAINDER
UNTIL SENATOR LARA GETS HERE
BECAUSE OF THE VICE CHAIR HAS TO.
RUN TO A NOTHER MEETING AND AS
WE'RE GONNA TAKE ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE.
IN THIRTEEN QUICKLY.
MEMBERS ITEM NUMBER TWELVE AND
THIRTEEN.
THIS IS S. B. NO ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE IS SP TWELVE FIFTY THREE
THIS IS A DO PASS APPROPRIATIONS
CURRENT VOTERS THREE ZERO CHAIR
VOTING I. MISS LANE CHESTER
PROCOL PLEASE WIN. WIN AYE
HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
CURRENTLY HAVE BIBLE.
BUT CURRENTLY A FIVE ZERO ORGAN
AT ON SENATOR LARA AND WE'VE
BEEN TOLD THAT CENTER NAY DAYS I
IS.
HAS MEETINGS FOR THE REST OF
THE DAY WILL NOT BE COULD RETURN
TO COMMITTEE SO WILL THIS BE
LOOKING AT A. POTENTIAL FULL SIX
OH PURSES A SEVEN OF TODAY JUST
WHEN WE SHOULD THE COMMITTEE
KNOWS.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO MOVE ON ITEM
NUMBER THIRTEEN WHICH IS S. B.
THIRTEEN THIRTY SEVEN. BUT THIS
HAS A DEEP PASSES AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENTLY ENJOYS
A TWO ZERO A CHAIR VOTING I'M
MISSING CHESTER WHEN. WIN AYE
HERNANDEZ. HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
AYE LARA. AYE AYE LARA ONLY.
ZERO FIVE ZERO.
BY THAT BILL IS OUT WE'RE GOING
TO CLOSE THE ROLE AN ITEM
THIRTEEN.
NGGA BACK THROUGH REPORT.
YOU KNOW. EDITOR GO.
MEMBERS WERE GONNA TAKE UP OF
THE CONSENT CALENDAR FIRST THIS
IS ITEM NUMBER TWO AN ITEM
NUMBER ELEVEN.
THIS IS A DO PASSED TO THE
FLOOR.
HUSSEIN CHESTER ROLL CALL PLEASE
REQUIRE HIGH WIRE ALRIGHT
HERNANDEZ. HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
AYE LARA AYE FLORA AYE SIX
SIX ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT WERE
CLOSED THE ROLE THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO BE MOVING ON
TO ITEM NUMBER ONE IT CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A TWO TO VOTE. I'D CHAIR
VOTING.
AYE A ROW CALL VOTE PLEASE.
HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG
AYE LARA FLORA NINE FOUR TWO
FOUR TWO THAT BILL EASE OUT
WE'RE CLOSING THE ROLE THINK YOU
SO MUCH. FOR NOW.
WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
NUMBER THREE S. B. TEN NINETY
ONE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
VOTE THIS IS THE DO PASSED
APPROPRIATIONS. BROKAW PLEASE
HOSSEIN CHESTER.
MCGUIRE BY WHERE MY.
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE.
YOU HAVE.
I THINK THAT IS A SIX ZERO THAT
BILL IS OUT WERE CLOSE IN THE
ROLE FOR NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
NUMBER FOUR SENATOR MORE LOCK SP
ELEVEN SIXTEEN CURRENTLY ENJOYS
A FIVE ZERO DO PASSES MINGE
PREPARATIONS. AS LAKE CHESTER
HERNANDEZ LARA I'M LARA AYE. SIX
YEAR THAT BILL IS OUT WE'RE
CLOSING THE ROLE IT DOES PASS
ITEM NUMBER FIVE SP ELEVEN
EIGHTY TWO.
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE ZERO
VOTE. ROLL CALL PLEASE USSEIN
GESTURE HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG ON
HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
AT NUMBER FIVE BY POLICE ABOUT
I'M A.
WIENER.
SO YOU HAVE MORE LAKE. PLACID
ITEM NUMBER FIVE PATRICK AYE AYE.
LARA I. SEE.
THE WORK. THAT IS A FIVE ZERO
VOTE THE BILL IS OUT FOR CLOSELY
ROLE THANK YOU SO MUCH ITEM
NUMBER SIX.
BUT THIS DOES ENJOY BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT S. B. TWELVE OH TO
CURRENTLY AT A FOUR ZERO MISS
LANE CHESSER
WHY I WIRE AND HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG GUYS SIX
SIX ZERO THAT BILL EASE OUT
PROPOSED IN THE ROLE THANK YOU
SO MUCH ITEM NUMBER SEVEN IS THE
TWELVE ELEVEN. THIS DOES HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT I THINK.
AHEAD TWO ZERO.
MISS ROSE MISSING CHESSER
BROKAW PLEASE AT NUMBER SEVEN
MCGUIRE AYE WIRE I HEARD AND
THIS HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG AYE
LARA. LARA I'M.
THE FIVE ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT
WE'RE CLOSE IN THE RAIN. ITEM
NUMBER EIGHT S. B. TWELVE TWELVE
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO ZERO.
I THINK JUST A ROLL CALL PLEASE
QUIET AYE WIRE ALRIGHT HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
LARA I'M.
FIVE ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT WE'RE
CLOSE IN THE ROLE. SO MUCH NOW
ITEM NUMBER NINE.
THIS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE
ZERO S. B. TWELVE EIGHTEEN MISS
LANE CHESTER MCGUIRE AYE CHOIR
AYE LOW OR. HERTZBERG.
RICHARD GUY AND YOU HAVE.
FIVE ZERO FIVE ZERO THAT BILL IS
THAT WERE CLOSE THE ROLE THANK
YOU SO MUCH WE'RE NOW MOVING ON
TO ITEM NUMBER TEN CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO. I SP TWELVE
FORTY SIX HUSSEIN CHESTER WIRE
HIGH WIRE ALRIGHT HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE SIX. THAT ENJOYS A
SIX YEAR THE BILL IS OUT WE'RE
CLOSING THE ROLE THAT WE'RE NOW
MOVING ON TO.
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE WHICH IS
SENATOR JACKSON SP TWELVE FIFTY
THREE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE
ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER.
HERNANDEZ LARA I'VE LEARNED I
SIX.
ZERO THAT BILL IS THAT WERE
CLOSE IN THE ROLE MOVING ON TO
ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN S. B.
THIRTEEN FIFTY TWO CURRENTLY%
ENJOYS A THREE ZERO VOTE MISS
LANE CHESTER Y. AYE WIRE AND
HERNANDEZ. HERTZBERG AYE
HERTZBERG AYE FIVE.
FIVE ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WE'RE
CLOSING THE ROLE AND I.
S. B. FIVE FOURTEEN SIXTEEN
NUMBER FIFTEEN THIS IS A DO PASS
TO THE FLOOR MISS LANE CHESTER.
HERNANDEZ LARA.
LARA I.
FIVE ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WERE
CLOSE IN THE WORLD. WE'RE NOW
MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN
S. B. FOURTEEN SEVENTEEN
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO
MISS LANE CHESTER HERNANDEZ LARA.
LARA HIGHS SIX SIX ZERO THE BILL
IS OUT WE'RE CLOSING THE ROLE ON
ITEM NUMBER SEVENTEEN CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO THIS IS S. B.
FOURTEEN EIGHTY FOUR MISS LANE
CHESTER. REQUIRE AYE WIRE AND IT.
HURTS FOR PERJURY AND SAID THAT.
SEVEN ZERO I FIRST ONE OF THE
DAY THAT BILL IS OUT IN YOUR
CLOTHES IN THE ROLE BUT NOW
MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER
NINETEEN S. C. A. NINETEEN
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO.
MISLAID CHESTER REQUIRE HIGH
WIRE AND HERTZBERG.
YOU KNOW WHO'S. NO MEDICAL CORPS
IT'S CA NINETY.
YEAH.
YEAH YEAH.
HERTZBERG AYE.
SEVEN ZERO.
THAT IS A SEVEN ZERO VOTE TO THE
BILL EASE OUT I AM BECAUSE THE
ROLE THANK YOU SO MUCH IT
FINALLY LEADS IN GERMAN ITEM
NUMBER TWENTY AS CA TWENTY TWO
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE. TWO
VOTE MISS LANE CHESTER HERNANDEZ
LARA AYE WHO ARE. HERE TO.
THREE HUNDRED. THAT ENJOYS A
FORWARD TO IT IS THE BILL IS OUT.
FOR CLOSE THE ROLE MEMBERS WE
HAVE A LINK THE HEARING.
NEXT WEEK I WOULD SAY PLAN ON
FIVE HOURS.
MINIMUM.
WITH A LARGE HEARING SO WE'LL
HAVE BILLS.
FROM NINE THIRTY TO ELEVEN AND
THEN WE'RE GOING TO BE HERE WE
HAVE A SPECIAL ORDER HEARING
WITH AS SENATOR HERTZBERG.
IN THAT IT WILL PROBABLY TAKE
ABOUT TWELVE HOURS
SO.
THE INQUISITION AND THERE GO IN
ALL SERIOUSNESS I I I PLAN FOR A
TOTAL OF FOUR TO FIVE HOUR
HEARING.
WITH THE BILL ACTION AS WELL AS
SENATOR HERTZBERG BILL.
IT WILL BE MEETING ONE AND
WE'LL SEE YOU NEXT WEEK WE ARE
ADJOURNED