FIVE WILL CONVENE.
.
RIGHT WORD YEAH.
WE HAVE SOME VOTE ONLY ITEMS I
WILL HOLD ON THE VOTE ON THE
ITEMS UNTIL MY VICE CHAIR
ARRIVES.
I'M IN SO WE'LL OPEN INSTEAD ON
OUR FIRST DISCUSSION ITEM EIGHTY
ONE TWENTY WHICH IS ON THE
COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER
STANDARDS AND TRAINING.
I SO LET'S SEE WE HAVE.
PRESENTING ON THAT.
ARE I BELIEVE ON THE FIRST
ISSUE. WHICH IS THE UPDATE ON
THE POST MENTAL HEALTH TRAINING
MANNY ALVAREZ AND.
JANNA MONK CIGARETTE.
THEY COME TO THE TABLE PLEASE.
NOW.
GOOD MORNING.
RICK.
YOU MAY PROCEED GOOD MORNING
THANK YOU. MELITTA JENNA
COULDN'T START AND IF YOU COULD.
TO SO IDENTIFY YOURSELVES
RECORD.
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS JOHN
AMONG KIND OF PLAY WITH THE
COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER
STANDARDS AND TRAINING.
MY CURRENT POSITION IS BUREAU
CHIEF FOR THE TRAINING PROGRAM
SERVICES BUREAU. AND.
ORIGINALLY WHEN THE SENATE BILL
ELEVEN AND SENATE BILL TWENTY
NINE CAME UP. I'M I WAS A NEW
HIRES A CONSULTANT FOR THE
COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER
STANDARDS AND TRAINING.
SO I WAS VERY INTIMATELY
INVOLVED WITH.
INCORPORATION OF IT INTO LAW
ENFORCEMENT TRAINING.
AND I MANY ALVAREZ ON THE
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF POST.
SO I'M.
WHAT I THOUGHT I WOULD DO WAS
WAS CLICK SOME NUMBERS IN TERMS
OF HOW SUCCESSFUL THE TRAINING
HAS BEEN?
AND.
I'VE A VERY BRIEF PRESENTATION
FOR YOU ON THIS.
SINCE INCORPORATION OF S. B.
ELEVEN AS BETWEEN AYE
LEGISLATION INTO THE BASIC
COURSE.
THEY HAVE TO PROGRAM IMPOSE
MANDATES
WE'VE HAD EIGHT THOUSAND THIRTY
SEVEN RECRUITS GO THROUGH THE
PACES BASIC COURSE WITH NEW
TRAINING TESTING SPECS.
WORKBOOKS AN HOURLY DISTRIBUTION.
WE'VE HAD ONE THOUSAND EIGHT
HUNDRED AND SEVENTY SEVEN AFTER
HEROES COMPLETE THE NEW FORTY
HOUR COURSE.
WE'VE HAD TWO THOUSAND NINE
HUNDRED AND THIRTEEN OFFICERS
COMPLETE.
THE MANDATED EIGHT OUR FTO
COURSE.
NOW ADDITION TO THE S. B. ELEVEN
S. B. NINE. TWENTY NINE TRAINING
WE'VE HAD THIRTY THOUSAND ONE
HUNDRED AND FIFTY ONE OFFICERS
ATTEND MENTAL HEALTH OR CRISIS
INTERVENTION TRAINING SINCE
AUGUST OF TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN.
WHICH IN TOTALITY YOUR DELIVERY
OF CRISIS INTERVENTION
BEHAVIORAL TRAINING IS FORTY
FIVE THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED AND
SEVENTY ONE OFFICER SINCE AUGUST
THE TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN.
ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADD.
RIGHT SENATOR BILL YOU OF.
TERMS OF THE LOCAL SO. WE SAID
EMCEES CALM.
OF.
I KNOW A LOT OF THOSE NUMBERS
COME FROM.
INCLUDING THE HIGHER PATROLS
ARE CORRECT.
YES DO OKAY SO.
.
I LIKE TO NOAH FROM THOSE LOCAL
ARM.
FIRST AGENCIES SO.
THE PERCENTAGE OF OFFICERS
RECEIVE TRAINING IF YOU COULD.
YEAH MAYBE GIVE ME A FACT SHEET
ON THAT.
OF SO THAT I CAN FOLLOW THROUGH.
WITH QUESTIONS TO ASK ABOUT
WHICH AGENCIES ARE PRODUCING
ALUM.
THE TRAINING IN AN EXPEDITIOUS
MANNER AND WHICH ONES.
ARE NOT PRODUCING THE TRAINING
SO I CAN GET AN UNDERSTANDING
ABOUT.
SO THAT'S KIND OF MY.
BASIC QUESTION NOW. DID YOU
DISCUSS THOUGH.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN S. B. ELEVEN
TRAININGS AS BE TWENTY NINE.
TRAINING AND.
THE CRITERIA FOR THAT THERE'S
TWO DIFFERENT.
TRAINING MODULES ONE FOR.
THE ACADEMY ONE FOR FIELD FIELD
TRAINING.
OF COURSE.
SO I'M I'M HAPPY TO PROVIDE YOU
WITH THE A FACT SHEET BIG ISSUE
ACTUAL DATA IN TERMS OF THE
AGENCIES THAT ARE TURNING OUT
THE LARGEST PROPORTION OF
STUDENTS.
BUT IN LIKE IT OFF THE TOP MAN
I CAN TELL YOU THAT CHP.
LA A SO AN LAPD ARSON THE TOP
PRODUCERS STUDENTS. OF.
PRIMARILY BECAUSE THEY'RE JUST
SUCH A LARGE AGENCIES.
AND AS WHEN YOU HAVE A VERY
LARGE AGENCY LIKE THAT THERE IS.
AN EASIER TIME TO CREATE THE
TRAINING AND DRIVE OFFICERS
THROUGH IT.
THEY DON'T JUST PROVIDE
TRAINING TO THEIR OWN AGENCIES
THOUGH THEY ALSO OPENED UP TO
OTHER AGENCIES.
I'M AND IN JUST A. ANECDOTALLY I
CAN TELL YOU THIS IN THE MORE
REMOTE AGENCIES HAVE A HARDER
TIME DELIVERING THE MENTAL
HEALTH TRAINING.
THE OTHER AGENCIES.
IN TERMS OF THE SENATE BILL
ELEVEN AND SENATE BILL TWENTY
NINE THE DIFFERENCE IN
LEGISLATION. CYNICAL ELEVEN
MANDATED THAT POST CREATE A
THREE HOUR COURSE THERE'S A
THREE. A MINIMUM OF A THREE HOUR
COURSE DIDN'T INCORPORATED
CERTAIN CRITERIA THE THAT TALKED
ABOUT CRISIS INTERVENTION FOR
PEOPLE WITH INTELLECTUAL
DISABILITIES AND MENTALHEALTH
ISSUES AS WELL AS CO OCCURRING
DISORDERS.
I'M IN ORDER TO EAT MEET THAT
MANDATE WHICH WAS ONLY A POST
MANDATE OFFICER FOR MEN TO TAKE
THIS CLASS.
AM I CONDUCTED A WORKSHOP WITH
SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS ACROSS
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. AND WE
CREATED A GUIDE FOR AGENCIES HOW
TO PICK A GOOD INSTRUCTOR FOR A
MENTAL HEALTH COURSE HOW TO
DEVELOP THAT INSTRUCTOR HOW TO
PARTNER WITH YOUR MENTAL HEALTH
GROUPS.
IN ORDER TO DELIVER THE CLASS
AND THEN WECREATED A MINIMUM OF
A FOUR HOUR COURSE. AND PUT
TOGETHER AN EXPANDED COURSE
OUTLINE FOR AGENCIES TO DOWNLOAD
CERTIFY AND CREATE WITHIN THEIR
COMMUNITIES.
AM I HONESTLY WAS A SUPER HAPPY
AT THE SUCCESS OF THOSE.
I AM BECAUSE I THINK IT'S PRETTY
PHENOMENAL THAT A NON MANDATED
COURSE HAS HAD TWO THOUSAND FOUR
HUNDRED AND FIFTY SEVEN OFFICERS
PUT THROUGH IT. THIS IS BUT A
DISEASES THIS IS THE RIGHT THING
TO DO SO LET'S TAKE ON THIS
COURSE.
S. B. TWENTY NINE.
.
THIS BETWEEN NINE MANDATED THAT
WE REALLY LOOK AT WHAT WE
OFFERED IN THE BASIC CORE SNIFF
THE TIME WE OFFERED SIX HOURS OF
TRAINING ON MENTAL HEALTH AND
DISABILITIES.
SO WE'VE PUT TOGETHER WORKSHOPS.
AND.
WE HAD SUBJECT MATTER EXPERTS
ATTEND THIS WORKSHOP ACROSS
CALIFORNIA AND WE LOOKED AT.
THE BASIC COURSE CURRICULUM IN
DEPTH.
AND WHAT WE ENDED UP WITH WAS AN
EXPANDED COURSE OUTLINE THAT
CONTRIBUTED FIFTEEN HOURS TO THE
ACADEMY AS OPPOSED TO SIX.
IT WAS LOW MORALE WELL ROUNDED
CURRICULUM. THERE WAS VERY
SPECIFIC CRITERIA WITHIN THE
LEGISLATION THAT WE MEET.
IT WOULD TALKED ABOUT.
DEVELOPING LANGUAGE AND.
COMMUNICATION TO DEAL WITH
PEOPLE THAT ARE STRESSED.
I.
BEING ABLE TO IDENTIFY THE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITY OR
INTELLECTUAL DISABILITY VERSUS
MENTAL HEALTH OR CO OCCURRING
DISORDERS.
I'M AND ALSO WORKING WITH AND
RESOURCES WITHIN YOUR COMMUNITY.
NOW WITH S. B. TWENTY NINE IT
ALSO SAID OKAY I I THINK OVERALL
THE PURPOSE OF THE BILL WAS
LET'S LOOK AT THE PEOPLE THAT
ARE COMING INTO LAW ENFORCEMENT
IT'S GONNA FROM THE GET GO SO
LET'S AFFECT RECRUITS THAT ARE
IN THE ACADEMY. AND NOW LET'S
TAKE A LOOK AT THE FIELD
TRAINING OFFICERS THE MOST
INFLUENTIAL PERSON THERE.
THROUGHOUT THEIR CAREER WHEN
THEY GRADUATE FROM THE ACADEMY
AND THE GOING TO TRAINING HOW
MUCH TRAINING HAVE THEY HAD.
SO BILL TRAINING OFFICERS WERE
MANDATED TO TAKE EIGHT HOURS A
STANDALONE TRAINING THAT CLEARLY
REFLECTED WAS DELIVERED IN THE
ACADEMY. THERE'S VERY SPECIFIC
CRITERIA WITHIN THAT EIGHT HOURS
THAT WE NEEDED TO ME.
AND THEN ADDITIONALLY THEY WERE
OUT WE ARE ASKED TO PROVIDE THEM
WITH ANOTHER FOUR HOURS WITHIN
THE FORTY HOUR COURSE.
IF YOU'RE NOT FAMILIAR WITH HOW
FIELD TRAINING OFFICER SELECTED
AND TRAINED I'M WE TRY TO KEEP
THE EVIDENCE IS IDENTIFIED THE
BASS OF THE BASS THEY DEFY
OFFICERS HAVE A VERY HIGH WORK
ETHIC. AND THEY REALLY WANT TO
GIVE BACK.
ONCE THEY ARE SELECTED AND
BECOME F. TEO'S THERE SENATOR
FORTY HOUR COURSE WHICH THEY
LEARN HOW TO DELIVER TRAINING
APPROPRIATELY TO TO. RECRUITS
ARE FRESH OUT OF THE ACADEMY
THEY HAVE THE MOST SIGNIFICANT
IMPACT ON PEOPLE TO THAT ARE
GRADUATING FROM THE ACADEMY.
SO THESE AFTER THOSE WERE GIVEN
AN ADDITIONAL FOUR HOURS WITHIN
THE ACADEMY COURSE.
AND THE WAY THAT WE THOUGHT
WOULD BE THE MOST EFFECTIVE
TRAINING ETHOD INSTEAD OF
GIVING HIM A FOUR HOUR BLOCK
BLOCK WITHIN THE ACADEMY.
I'M WE.
CREATED VIDEOS
AND WE CREATED SUBJECT MATTER
THAT WAS WOVEN INTO EVERY TYPE
OF EVERY PIECE OF THE CURRICULUM
THROUGHOUT THE FORTY HOURS FOR
THE F. TEO'S. SO THEY GOT HIT
EVERY SINGLE DAY IN EVERY SINGLE
AREA THIS IS HOW YOU DEAL WITH
THE MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES THAT
YOU'RE RUNNING ROSS IN THE
PEOPLE. YOU ENCOUNTER ON THE
STREETS AND THIS IS HOW YOU
TRAIN YOUR OFFICERS.
TO DEAL WITH THEM IN A MORE
POSITIVE WAY.
WHICH IP SPEAK MORON ANY OF THAT
GOING ON.
DO THE USE THAT AVATAR SYSTEM
YOU KNOW YOU WERE SEEN OUT.
YOU KNOW THEM TALKING ABOUT.
SO WE USE LAKE.
SPAIN OUT OF AVATAR THAT REACTS
TO THE. OFFICER.
.
NEVADA SYSTEM YOUR TALK ABOUT
FORCE OPTIONS WHERE THEY GO IN
AND THEY HAVE A SCREEN AND THEY
PLAY ON A VIDEO RIGHT OKAY. I'M
I DON'T KNOW IF THE INDIVIDUAL
PRISONERS WITHIN THAT THE COURSE
OF THE FORTY HOURS TO THAT REX
THEM AS THEY GO ALONG THAT'S
THAT'S RIGHT. BUT WE HAVE HAD.
THROUGH OUR FILES MACHINES YOU
SHORT VIDEOS WHERE AN OFFICER
COMES AND THEY'RE GIVEN A A GUN
THERE COMMIT THE TIME. THAT
THEY'RE ALLOWED TO CAN USE TO
INTERACT WITH THE SCREEN. AND
THEY HAVE AN OPERATOR WHO HAS
THE OPTION OF BASED ON WHAT SO.
THE OFFICER COMES IN THE VIDEO
STARTS AND IT MIGHT START WITH A
MENTAL SOMEONE HAVING A MENTAL
HEALTH ISSUE THERE IN CRISIS
THEY'RE SCREAMING THERE YELLING
THEY'RE DOING SOMETHING. ABOUT
THIS UNUSUAL BEHAVIOR DEPENDING
ON HOW THE OFFICER REACTS TO
THAT BEHAVIOR THE CONTROLLER CAN
MAKE THIS VIDEO GO OFF INTO
DIFFERENT DIRECTIONS THE.
THE PERSON MIGHT ACROSS AGAINST
THEM THE PERSON MIGHT RETREAT.
THEY MIGHT BRING OUT A WEAPON
SO THE OFFICER CAN FIRE AT THE
SCREEN THEY CAN TAKE THE BATON
AND AND BE ON A DUMMY THIS NEXUS
SCREEN. THEY CAN CHOOSE TO DE
ESCALATE.
I'M WHAT WAS REALLY IT. AWESOME
WAS THE COMPANY THAT MAKES
VIDEOS FOR US SPEND TIME
CREATING A WHOLE SERIES OF NEW
VIDEOS THE HARD TO DO WITH
MENTAL HEALTH AND MENTAL HEALTH
ISSUES. THE COULD BE INTEGRATED
INTO THE FOLLOWS PROGRAM NOT
JUST THAT HARDWARE FTA OWES FOR
FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT IN GENERAL.
I BELIEVE THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE
ASKING ABOUT YOU HAVE A IDEA
ABOUT WHEN WE GET TO A HUNDRED
PERCENT.
OF THE OFFICERS IN CALIFORNIA
TRAIN.
YOU HAVE A PROJECTION. YOU KNOW
THAT THAT'S SOMETHING I THINK
YOUR JOB SHOULD BE USED TO.
I TO GIVE US A. ARE YOU KNOW OF
OF.
A TIMELINE ON WOULD.
WHEN WE CAN GET TO THE HUNDRED
PERCENT LEVEL.
SENATE BILL I THINK THAT'S A
GREAT QUESTION I DON'T HAVE ALL
THE OFFICERS IN CALIFORNIA TRAIN
OBSOLETE THROUGH IT WE HAVE AS
OF THE LAST THREE YEARS FORTY
FIVE THOUSAND OFFICERS HAVE GONE
TO THE TRAINING ASSUMING WE HAVE
A POP.
THE THOUSAND YOU'RE TALKING
FORTY FIVE THOUSAND MORE OFFICE.
HOWEVER THIS IS ONLY A BRIEF
WINDOW THIS IS A THREE EIGHT
THREE YEAR WINDOW WE'VE HAD
SINCE NINETEEN THE NINETEEN
NINETIES. START WITH CRISIS
INTERVENTION TRAINING SAN JOSE
POLICE DEPARTMENT AND MARIN
COUNTY WHERE THE VERY FIRST LAW
ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO BRING THE
FORTY HOUR MEMPHIS COURSE.
OVER TO CALIFORNIA SO EVEN
THOUGH IT YOU LOOK AT THE
NUMBERS FORTY FIVE THOUSAND AT A
NINETY THOUSAND. THAT DOESN'T
INCLUDE ALL THE OFFICERS THAT
HAVE BEEN TRAINED PRIOR TO
AUGUST OF TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN.
SO I COULD DRIVE THOSE STATS AND
SEE HOW MANY PRESENTATIONS ARMY
OFFICERS OF ATTENDED AND YOU GO
I THINK GO.
I. STARTED BEFORE TWENTY FIFTEEN
ALSO.
YES IDEA HILL ROAD CHIEF
LANSDOWNE.
VIA CAME FROM SAN JOSE THAT'S
RIGHT HE DID. WHAT TO?
RICHMOND.
AND A WHAT TO.
ANY AGO.
JUST RETIRED A FEW YEARS AT TWO
YEARS AGO.
IT WAS LIKE SHE FOR AWHILE I'M
RETIRED EARLY APRIL.
VERY CLOSE TO THEM.
DON'T AGREE.
SO.
ONE OF THE LEADERS THOUGH.
CAN FROM THE JO MCNAMARA.
IF MCNAMARA SAN JOSE HAD.
NEW YORK.
HOUSTON BALTIMORE SAN DIEGO
ALWAYS BIG CITIES
THE CAME OUT THE SAN JOSE POLICE
DEPARTMENT WERE.
VERY PROUD OF THAT.
WE ARE FORTUNATE TO HAVE SOME
AMUSING LEADERS THERE.
WE BROWN.
NEW YORK COMMISSION.
BUT OTHER QUESTIONS CAN ANSWER
ó NEXT QUESTION WOULD BE.
POST TRAINING ABOUT THE USE OF
FORCE.
.
WHAT IS THE?
USE OF FORCE TRAINING.
.
AND THIS POST HAVE ANY
INFORMATION ABOUT THE USE OF
FORCE. TRAINING DONE A POLICE
DEPARTMENT SECURE DEPARTMENTS.
AND.
WHETHER WHETHER POST REQUIRES.
TRAINERS TO HAVE SOME KIND OF
ALL.
CERTIFICATION A NATIONAL LEVEL
OR ANY OTHER KIND OF.
CERTIFICATION OR SOME QUESTIONS
THOUGH.
AND.
.
THE USE OF FORCE TRAINING
CERTIFICATION PROCESS.
IN TERMS OF LA WHO ACTUALLY DOES
THE TRAINING.
AND.
WHETHER NOT SO.
THEYARE TRAINING PEOPLE
APPROPRIATELY.
.
ON THE USE OF FORCE IN THIS
COURSE ISN'T RISEN.
ODD DO TO THE.
INCIDENTS SUCH AS WE HAVE AND
HAPPENED IN.
OUR COMMUNITY RIGHT HERE IN
SACRAMENTO OTHER PLACES WHERE.
THERE'S SOME QUESTIONS A NOW
ABOUT THE USE OF FORCE.
TRAINING THAT OF POLICE OFFICERS.
HAVE OF THEM.
AND THEN.
THE OTHER. I MIGHT MENTION.
CONCERN THAT PEOPLE HAVE IS
WHETHER OR NOT THIS CONFLICTS
WITH THE ARM.
THE MENTAL HEALTH TRAINING.
SO I'VE SEEN THE.
.
THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT PEOPLE
THAT.
QUESTION CERTAIN.
USE OF FORCE TRAINING.
THAT'S RECEIVED BY POLICE
OFFICERS. WHAT IS WHAT IS THE?
?
PROCESS YOU USE TO APPROVE.
USE OF FORCE TRAINING TO MAKE
SURE THAT. THE OFFICERS ARE.
TRAINED INAPPROPRIATE MANNER.
OKAY.
UP.
IF YOU THINK.
SO CATHOLIC ARE GOING TO START
SO IF THE. IF THE ACADEMY.
USE OF FORCE INSTRUCTION IS
MANDATED THERE'S A TWELVE HOUR
INSTRUCTION BLOCK IT'S A LITTLE
BIT.
ON.
A. GOOD MY THREE OFTEN IT'S
TWELVE HOURS IT'S INFUSED
THROUGHOUT THE ACADEMY BUT THEY
HAVE A SPECIFIC BLOCK ON USE OF
FORCE THAT IS TWELVE HOURS.
IT'S ONE OF FORTY THREE
LEARNING DOMAINS THAT ARE TAUGHT
AT THE ACADEMY.
THAT LEARNING DOMAIN.
GOOD THE WORKBOOK IS PUBLICLY
AVAILABLE WE JUST HANDED OUT TO.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WEBER YES RATED
CHAIR WEBER. ARM IT WAS.
IT'S IT'S A IT'S INSTRUCTION
MANUAL IT'S CONSTANTLY UPDATE WE
UPDATED PROBABLY THREE TIMES A
YEAR TWO TIMES HERE. WE JUST
UPDATED IT. ABOUT A MONTH AGO.
THE UPDATE WAS DONE IN
COORDINATION OR IN COLLABORATION
SO TO SPEAK WITH THE ACLU WITH
THE END OF EARLY CP WITH LUWAK
WITH IMMIGRATION RIGHTS
ATTORNEYS THAT CAME IN IN A
SERIES OF WORKSHOPS. TO HELP US
RETOOL THAT WORKBOOK.
ARE.
SO THEY ARE TRAINED NOT ONLY IN
THE CLASSROOM BUT THEIR
SCENARIOS THAT THEY ARE MANDATED
THAT THEY HAVE TO PARTICIPATE IN
THAT THEY'RE TESTED ON THROUGH
OUT THE ACADEMY. SO THERE'S
TWELVE HOURS BUT ADDITIONAL
STUFF AT THE ACADEMY.
SOME OF THOSE ORANGE IN THE
COMPANIES THAT ARE HIRED.
OR.
COMPANIES ARE HARD TO TRAIN THE
TRAINERS OR COMPANIES ACTUALLY
DO THE TRAINING. AND WHETHER OR
NOT THOSE COMPANIES AB TRAINING
MODULES THAT ARE INCONSISTENT.
WHAT THE GOALS THAT WE HAVE IN%
CALIFORNIA SO IT POSTS CERTIFIES
A COURSE TO DEPARTMENT OR TO A
PRIVATE COMPANY OR PRIVATE
PRESENTER THEY HAVE TO COME TO
US TO REQUEST THE POST
CERTIFICATION?
WE GO THROUGH THE RESUMES OF
THOSE INSTRUCTORS AND HAVE TO BE
QUALIFIED IF THEY'RE NOT
QUALIFIED THEN WE REJECT THEM.
CERTAIN TYPES OF TRAINING.
THAT POST PUTS ON THEY HAVE TO
GO THROUGH AN INSTRUCTION COURSE
THAT WE PROVIDE I'D I DON'T KNOW
IF WE DO ATTEND SEVENTY COURSED
YOU KNOW JANET FOR A USE OF
FORCE.
IN THE ACADEMY YES
ANY CAL IF IT SPECIFIC SO FOR
ITS DEFENSIVE TOPIC TACTICS IF
IT'S EVOLVED IT IT DEPENDS ON
WHAT HARSHER ASKING ABOUT.
BUT IN TERMS OF I'M INSERVICE
TRAINING SIR.
SO FOR IN SERVICE WHEN. AN
ORGANIZATION OR PRESENTER WANTS
TO TEACH A DEFENSIVE TACTICS
COURSE THEY WANT TO BE POST
CERTIFIED THEY HAVE TO SUBMIT AN
ENTIRE EXPANDED COURSE OUTLINE
HERE'S WHAT WE'RE GOING TO TEACH.
THEY ALSO HAVE TO SUBMIT
INSTRUCTOR RESUMES INSTRUCTORS
HAVE GONE TO POST CERTIFIED
TRAIN THE TRAINER COURSES IN
ORDER TO DELIVER SPECIFIC THINGS
SUCH AS USE OF FORCE. AND SO IF
YOU HAVE BEEN COMMUNITY TO
DEFENSIVE TACTICS COSTS.
THEY HAVE TO HAVE SOME
BACKGROUND ACTIVE TO TRAIN THE
TRAINER COURSE AND THEY HAVE TO
DELIVER. CASE LAW THEY HAVE TO
DELIVER LAWS ON AND. IT IT'S
VERY SPECIFIC THE STANDARDS THAT
THEY HAVE TO MEET IF THEY WANT
THEIR WOVEN INTO THE TRAINING.
CULTURAL COMPETENCY ISSUES.
REGARDING NAM.
NAM.
IMPLICIT BIAS THAT THERE MAY
EXIST.
AND.
.
IS THE USE OF FORCE.
SO YES IT'S A BIG ISSUE YES SO.
ALL OF THOSE CONCEPTS ARE IN A
ROW WOVEN THROUGHOUT USE OF
FORCE TRAINING AT POST.
ARM.
AND YOU TO CERTIFY COMPANIES
THAT ARE TRAINED AND THEY HAVE
ABLE TO.
HAVE.
.
TRAINING MODULES THAT.
SHOW THAT THERE'RE NOT IGNORING
OUT OVER. HOW DO YOU HOW DO YOU
PROVE THE TRAINERS COME AND
TRAIN OUR OFFICERS?
TELL OBVIOUSLY ON THE FRONT END
IS JENNA A JENNA PUT PUT IT AND.
AND I PUT IT WE REVIEW THE
CURRICULUM PRIOR TO THE. TO THE
INSTRUCTION.
THERE ARE PRIVATE PRESENTERS
THAT ARE NON. GOVERNMENT
AGENCIES TO GO OUT AND TRAIN
PRIVATE COMPANY SO TO SPEAK WE
SCRUTINIZE THEM AND PROBABLY
ADMITTEDLY SO PERHAPS A LITTLE
BIT MORE THAN WE WOULD A A
GOVERNMENT AGENCY THAT'S DOING
THE TRAINING.
WHATEVER. WE HAVE A.
WE HAVE A PROGRAM CALLED THE
QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM ONE
THEY'RE REQUIRED TO DO SURVEYS
OF THE COMPLETION OF THE
TRAINING SO WE MONITOR THOSE
SURVEYS. BUT IF WE HAVE AN ISSUE
UNDER THAT THIS QUALITY
ASSURANCE PROGRAM WE SEND FOLKS
OUT TO AUDIT SOME OF THE
TRAINING AND FROM TIME TO TIME
WE HEAR OF HICK UPS SO TO SPEAK
IN TRAINING. AND WE SEND EITHER
OUR STAFF
TO PARTICIPATE AT THE LAST
MINUTE OR WE SEND. INDIVIDUALS
WE HAVE ON CONTRACT TO GO.
REVIEW THE TRAINING AND WRITE A
REPORT TO SEE IF THERE ARE
ISSUES THAT WE DO HAVE A QUALITY
ASSURANCE PROGRAM. GRANTED IT IS
VERY VERY LIMITED.
.
THAT INCLUDES PSYCHOLOGIST AND
OTHER PEOPLE THAT.
REVIEW THE USE OF FORCE TRAINING.
TO MAKE SURE THAT IMPLICIT BIAS
DOES NOT.
INGRAINED INTO THE TRAINING
ACTIONS.
SPEAK THAT I CAN COME IN AND
LIKE TO BACK UP A LITTLE. LIKE
IT'S NOT TO YOUR MOTIONS BECAUSE
I'M MORE. MAYBE MAYBE IT'S
APPROPRIATE MANAGER IF THEY CAN.
COME BACK WITH A REPORT ABOUT.
BECAUSE I THINK DID TO THE USE
OF FORCE.
WHEN THEY HIRE USE OF FORCE SO.
TRAINING.
.
AND WE'RE PAYING FOR THAT
OBVIOUSLY NO WE GIVE MONEY TO
ALL.
SO I I THINK THE.
MIGHT OPINION IS THAT WE ARE A.
FIND OUT IF THERE'S ANY.
NATIONAL STANDARD.
OR CERTIFICATION.
ON A NATIONAL LEVEL. AND THEN.
WHAT DO WE DO IT ALL ON A STATE
LEVEL?
?
IT TEARS OF CERTIFYING.
.
THE TRAINING IS APPROPRIATE.
SENATOR THAT'S MY THAT'S THE
ISSUE I'M TRYING TO RAISE YOUR.
SENATOR BELLIARD BANG.
IMPLICIT BIAS IS A REALLY HOT
TOPIC WITH LAW ENFORCEMENT AND.
BUT I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE WITH
YOU IS.
.
TWO YEARS AGO THE DEPARTMENT
JUSTICE GAVE US A FIVE MILLION
DOLLAR GRANT.
TO TEACH OFFICERS GIVEN TO
DELIVER CERTIFIED TRAINING ON
PROCEDURAL JUSTICE WHICH
INCLUDES IMPLICIT BIAS.
NOW WE'VE BEEN DELIVERING THAT
TRAINING OF THE LAST COUPLE OF
YEARS. AND WITH THE MONEY SO THE
MONEY IS MANDATED TO CREATE
CERTIFIED TRAINING FOR LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. THAT
INCLUDES PROCEDURAL JUSTICE AND
NOW WE'RE LOOKING AT IS HOW DO
WE INTEGRATE THAT TREATING EVEN
FARTHER.
SO WE'VE ALREADY WORKED ON
INTEGRATING IT INTO THE BASIC
COURSE.
THEY HAVE TO PROGRAMS AND WE'RE
MOVING FORWARD UNDER TRAINING
PROGRAM SERVICES INSERVICE LAW
ENFORCEMENT HOW DO WE INTEGRATE
INTO ALL OF OUR TRAINING. WE'RE
LOOKING AT CREATING VIDEOS LIKE
YOU TALKED ABOUT EARLIER WHERE
OFFICERS CAN COME IN AND HOW TO
USE A SOURCE.
SCENARIO IN A VIDEO AND THEY GO
THROUGH THE PROCEDURAL JUSTICE
TENANTS THE FOR TENETS.
IT IT'S
STILL WE HAVE THREE YEARS LEFT
TO DLIVER THOSE. AND I THINK
IT'S A SUPER IMPORTANT TOPIC AND
WE'RE WORKING ON INFUSING IT
THROUGHOUT ALL OF OUR TRAINING
FROM WHEN A PERSON COMES INTO
THE ACADEMY. THEY GET INTO THE
FTO PROGRAM THE LIFE OF THEIR
CAREER MOVING ON TO BEING A
SUPERVISOR AND TO BEING A CHIEF.
AND THOSE ARE THINGS THAT WE
HAVE COOKING RIGHT NOW WITH THAT
GRANT WILL I I LIKE IF YOU COULD
I DON'T WANT TO COULD BE MORE
COMMITTEES TIME.
IF YOU COULD PLEASE SO.
PROVIDE US WITH MORE INFORMATION
ON THAT.
I WOULD APPRECIATE THAT I AM
VERY CONCERNED ABOUT.
.
INAPPROPRIATE TRAINING EXISTING
IN CALIFORNIA.
IN THE PAST AND IN THE FUTURE
ORDERS
IF THERE WAS INAPPROPRIATE
TRAINING IN THE PAST. IT LINGERS
IN THOSE DEPARTMENTS.
SO IF THERE IS AN APPROPRIATE
TRAINING THAT HAPPENED IN THE
PAST.
I THINK SOMETIMES WE HAVE TO GO
BACK AND MAKE CORRECTIONS.
TO THE TRAINING THAT WAS
RECEIVED. EFFORT CORRECTIONS ARE
NEEDED I THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT
TO DO.
SO I. AT THAT'S THAT'S THAT'S
THE ISSUE FOR ME.
IF I NAY MADAM CHAIR.
MARIBEL COULD IT ALSO BE
INADEQUATE IN ADDITION TO
NECESSARILY INAPPROPRIATE.
INAPPROPRIATE ADEQUATE NOT EXIST.
YEAH YOU'RE RIGHT BECAUSE
BECAUSE.
.
I THINK OWE IT USE OF FORCE
THERE'S IS A COMPLICATED SUBJECT
AND.
I DON'T PLAN TO DWELL ON IT
TODAY BUT I THINK.
I THINK YOUR ARM.
IF YOU HAVE A TRAINED IF YOU'RE.
YOU SAID YOU HAD THE OF THE.
.
THE MODULE ALREADY IN THE IN THE
POST TRAINING IS ONE OF THE
FORTY FOUR.
TRAINING I WANNA I WANNA DETECT
WHETHER OR NOT.
THERE'S A PROCESS FOR QUALITY
CONTROL.
YOU KNOW.
WHETHER NOT THERE'S SOME.
QUALITY CONTROL ON THERE ABOUT
WHETHER OR NOT IT'S APPROPRIATE.
AND OR EXISTING. AS A VISITOR
IMPLIED.
THE THANK YOU MET ME I I DON'T
WANT TO TAKE THE COMMITTEE'S
TIME SO IF YOU CATCH ME YES WE
GO BACK AND WE REVIEW THE
ACADEMY EACH ACADEMY EVERY THREE
YEARS AND WE'RE CONSTANTLY. ARM
REVEALING THE WORKBOOKS I FEEL
VERY COMFORTABLE WITH WHAT WE'RE
DOING AT THE ACADEMY'S.
I THINK THERE'S A LITTLE BIT OF
A MISCONCEPTION AS TO WHAT
HAPPENS AFTER THE ACADEMY'S WITH
USE OF FORCE TRAINING. SO WE
HAVE MANDATED TRAINING THAT
THEY'RE REQUIRED TO TAKE THAT
TOM. YEAH I USE OF FORCE IS
WOVEN INTO THOSE ARE TRAINING
SESSIONS
WE HAVE OUTLINES FOR IT EITHER
TAKE OURS ARE THESE ARE OUTLINES
TO DO THAT. THE TRAINING THAT IS
FUNDED BY POST.
NOT ALL AGENCIES ARE REQUIRED TO
COME TO POST TO GET POST
CERTIFICATION FOR THEIR TRAINING.
THEY CAN DO IT ON THEIR OWN. IF
THEY'VE MET THE MANDATES A LOT
OF TIMES THEY'LL JUST DO IT ON
THEIR OWN.
ALSO EVEN IF IT IS POST
CERTIFIED THAT IS NOT THE IT'S
NOT FUNDED BY POST IF LAPD
DECIDES TO PUT ON A USE OF FORCE
CLASS AND WE APPROVE IT.
THEY FUNDED WE DO NOT.
YOU DON'T LOOK AT WHAT THEY'RE
DOING.
WE DO. WE DO WE JUST DON'T
PROVIDE THE FINANCIAL BACKING
FOR IT.
BUT WE DO REVIEW THEIR COURSE IF
IF THEY COME TO POST TO GET
CERTIFIED BY POST.
OKAY SO THEY DON'T ALL DO THAT.
IS WHAT YOU'RE SAYING.
I DON'T HAVE TO DO THAT I WOULD
SAY THE MAJORITY OF THEM DO
WHICH ONES DID IN WHICH
WEDNESDAY
OKAY.
THAT BE INTERESTING AT ALL.
I'D LIKE TO HAVE THAT.
BUT IS THIS WAS AN INFORMATION
ITEM THANK YOU.
.
APPRECIATE IT WE HAVE A SECOND
INFORMATION ITEM. BELIEVE IT'S
INFORMATION.
NO IT'S ACTUALLY ACTION BUT AND
WHAT I WANT TO DO RIGHT NOW IS A
STEPS FORUM. IN GO BACK TOWARD
VOTE ONLY AND THEN WE'LL GO TO
ISSUE ELEVEN.
SO IF YOU COULD CALL THE ROLL.
CENTER SKINNER HERE THINNER
ANDERSON.
CENTRE BELL YOUR.
THEY BELIEVED.
.
BEFORE I DO VOTE ONLY.
THERE ARE FIVE MISTER ALVAREZ I
THINK YOU'RE YOU ARE SPEAKING ON
ITEM ELEVEN AT LEAST I HAVE YOU
RECORDED SO YOU MAY STAY AT THE
TABLE I'D LIKE MOTION YES ON ALL
OF THE VOTE NO TO ME ITEMS WHICH
IS.
FROM FIVE TWO TWO SEVEN TWO.
EIGHT TO OWN ALL THE ITEMS
THERE AND SO ISSUES ONE THROUGH
NINE.
EXCELLENT.
OUTLOOK IS TO ROLL CALL ON THOSE.
CENTER SKINNER.
I SENATOR ANDERSON.
CLARABELLE.
ALRIGHT SOO NOT GOOD ISSUE
ELEVEN WHICH IS THE HATE CRIME
MODEL POLICY AND I HAVE LISTED
THAT IT FIVE MISTER OPERATION
WOULD BE PRESENTING AND ALSO
MISTER BROWN ROUGH.
SO ME PERSONALLY.
THANK YOU AGAIN MY NAME IS MANNY
ALVAREZ ON THE EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR OF POST.
I TO MY RIGHT IS MISTER DAVE ALL
TAUSEN HER FROM PROCEEDS ARE AT
LEGISLATIVE AYE COORDINATOR IN
TO MY LEFT IS MISTER RALPH BROWN.
HE.
HE WOULD BE DOING THE
PRESENTATION.
OKAY.
THANK YOU.
HELLO GOOD MORNING MA'AM CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
OF.
SO WHAT. WE HAVE.
.
JUST LOOK AT ASSEMBLY ROCK SCENE
FOR THE FIRST TIME HERE SO BEAR
WITH ME PLEASE.
.
ACCORDING TO.
RECENT DOJ DATA.
THE NUMBER OF HATE CRIMES HAS
INCREASED.
TWENTY FIFTEEN TO TWENTY
SIXTEEN.
AND.
THAT MOST OF THE INCIDENTS WERE
RELATED TO RACE ETHNICITY.
NATIONAL ORIGIN OR SEXUAL
ORIENTATION.
SINCE TWO THOUSAND SEVEN.
WE HAVE WOULD APPROXIMATELY.
FIFTY EIGHT THOUSAND ATTENDEES.
THROUGH LEARNING TO MAIN FORTY
TWO IN THE ACADEMY WHICH IS.
CULTURAL DIVERSITY.
SOME OF THESE ATTENDEES OF ALSO
COMPLETED ALL OF THEM HAVE
COMPLETED. OR INTIMATE THREE
WHICH IS POLICING THE COMMUNITY.
AND A LEARNING GO MADE THIRTY
SEVEN PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES
SO COLLECTIVELY CONCEIVED A BODY
OF WORK THERE.
POCUS IS ON THE ISSUE.
.
WE'VE PUT A LOT OF PEOPLE
THROUGH OTHER COURSES. AT
STUDENTS AS WELL STUDENTS BEING
A PEACE OFFICERS.
AND THEN AND SHOULD YOU SHOULD
KNOW THAT THAT'S POSSIBLE GOING
ON FOR YEARS.
PUSHING DECADES.
TOM.
FOR THE ORIGINAL. HIZO FOR A
DISCUSSION HERE THE HATE CRIMES
FRAMEWORK WHICH IS THE DOCUMENT
THAT WE MAKE AVAILABLE TO.
EXECUTIVES OF LAW ENFORCEMENT
AGENCIES CHIEF SHERIFFS.
A TO PROVIDE THEM A FRAMEWORK
FOR HOW THEY'RE GOING TO REPORT
ON. A CRIMES.
.
I THINK THE.
.
I PROBABLY OUT OF TURN THIS OVER
TO DEVOLVE THOUSAND BECAUSE HE
EITHER THIS DOCUMENT AND LET HIM
FINISH THIS UP.
WHAT?
ONE OF THE THINGS I'M
INTERESTED IN IS WHETHER.
CLEARLY THE HATE CRIMES.
.
INCLUDING THE HATE CRIMES.
.
TRAINING IN THE POST IS
SOMETHING THAT LEGISLATURE'S
OBVIOUSLY BEEN KEENLY INTERESTED
IN. AND HAS GONE BEYOND EVEN THE
THE. LEGISLATION BY MISTER KING
SO IN PASSED WE KNOW THAT.
WE'VE PROVIDED FUNDING TO POST
TO INCLUDE THE.
.
SIMON WE WEISENTHAL. A.
.
CURRICULUM THAT THEY DEVELOPED
AROUND HATE CRIMES SO PART OF MY.
QUESTION WE ARE GOING TO HOLD
THE SOAP ITEM OPEN BUT IN
ADDITION TO WHATEVER YOU WANT TO
SHARE WITH US.
IS THE FORTY FIVE THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
AUGMENTATION THAT WAS REQUESTED.
ADEQUATE
BOARD MEETING THE INTENT BOTH OF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER STINGS
LEGISLATION AND.
THE ON GOING.
EFFORT THAT THE LEGISLATURE HAS
RECOMMENDED AND POST BE INVOLVED
IN IN TERMS OF THE HATE CRIME
TRAINING. IT.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND
SENATORS.
SO THE TWO THOUSAND EIGHT MODEL
POLICY FRAMEWORK THAT WE HAVE
LOOKED AT TO REVISE.
WOULD REQUIRE A WORKSHOP AND
APPROXIMATELY COST FORTY FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS THAT WE'VE
IDENTIFIED TO UPDATE THAT MODEL
POLICY FRAMEWORK. IN AND OF
ITSELF.
AS TO MR TEAMS BILL I HAVEN'T.
YOU AYE AND ANALYZE THAT BILL TO
GET A FISCAL IMPACT OR A FISCAL
REQUIREMENT FOR IT I'M HAPPY TO
DO SO IN REPORT THAT BACK.
TO YOU ALL.
ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO SHARE
ON THAT ITEM.
I THINK WE I THINK RALPH PRETTY
MUCH COVERED IT I AGAIN
APOLOGIZE FOR THE. DYSFUNCTION
OF OUR PRESENTATION ORI. UP AND
OF COURSE.
MISTER KINGS BILL IS NOT YET
BEEN PASSED BY THE LEGISLATURE
BUT IT.
.
YOU KNOW IT'S GOING TO THE
PROCESS AND I KNOW THE ASSEMBLY
IS HEARING. THERE BUDGET
SUBCOMMITTEE IS HEARING THAT SO.
ONE OF OUR PURPOSES IN BUT.
THERE WAS ALSO INDEPENDENT OF
THAT LEGISLATION THE BCP ASKING
FOR THE FORTY FIVE K.. AT
AUGMENTATION BUT I WANTED TO
MAKE TO DETERRENT FOR HELP
DETERMINE WHETHER IT WAS A
KENNEDY ADEQUATE FOR. THE FULL
ANDINTEREST THAT WE MAY HAVE IN.
ARE MANY NECTARINE.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR AND I
WOULD ADD THAT.
THE BY PREDECESSOR CHEN AMONG
HER THAT HER BEHIND REVIEWS
PRESENTER TALKED ABOUT AS DID
THE DIRECTOR PROCEDURAL JUSTICE
AN IMPLICIT BIAS TRAINING YES
THAT ALSO. CROSS REFERENCES WITH
HATE CRIMES TRAINING THROUGHOUT
THE ACADEMY AND IN OTHER COURSES
THAT WE DO OFFER.
OKAY GOOD ANY QUESTIONS ON.
MY COLLEAGUES.
ALRIGHT THEN. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH YOU AND OUT WE WILL MOVE ON
TO. AND I DON'T.
TWELFTH ISSUE TWELFTH WHICH IS
PERHAPS STATE COMMUNITY
CORRECTIONS.
AND ITS IN RELATIONSHIP TO OUR
CALIFORNIA IOLENCE INTERVENTION
AND PREVENTION GRANT PROGRAM
CALIPHATE. WHICH SOME OF YOU MAY
REMEMBER IT PREVIOUSLY S. CALC
GRIPPED. BUT WE'VE MODIFIED THAT
NAME. I LAST YEAR I BELIEVE.
AT QB BECAUSE INITIALLY THE.
FOCUS WAS GANG INTERVENTION WE
REALIZED OVER TIME THAT THE REAL
THE REALLY PRIDE. INTEREST WAS
VIOLENCE INTERVENTION.
BOTH POLITIES I DIDN'T ASK FOR
PUBLIC COMMENT OF APOLOGIES IF
THERE IS ANY PUBLIC COMMENT ON
THE FIRST TWO ITEMS.
.
I ON THE ITEMS.
THE HATE CRIMES.
IN THE POST TRAINING AYE AIRED
IN.
IT NOT ASKING FOR PUBLIC
COMMENT IF THERE IS ON EITHER OF
THOSE I'M HAPPY TO RECEIVE IT AT
THIS POINT.
FOR ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO
OFFER PUBLIC COMMENT ON EITHER
OF THOSE.
GREAT.
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS JOE MICHAEL
FOR EQUALITY CALIFORNIA I'M WE
DO HAVE PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE
PREVIOUS ITEM AROUND I'M
AUGMENTING.
TRAINING ON HATE CRIMES FOR POST
I.
THE RESPONSE R. OF I AB NINETEEN
EIGHTY FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
TINGS BILL THAT WOULD CREATE THE
POLICY REQUIREMENT FOR UPDATING
THOSE POLICIES AND AT THE LOCAL
LEVEL. AND OUR UNDERSTANDING
FROM OUR CONVERSATION SO FAR I'M
IS THAT AN ADDITIONAL FORTY FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS WHICH I'M KIND
OF FILL THE GAP THAT POST IS
CURRENTLY EXPERIENCING. IN
UPDATING THOSE POLICIES AND AND
BUT FILL THAT IN AND MAKE IT SO
THAT THEY CAN MORE EFFICIENTLY
COMPLETE BACK UPDATE TO BRING
THOSE POLICIES. UP TO LINE WITH
WHAT AB NINETEEN EIGHTY FIVE
REQUIRES JUST A NOTICE AB
NINETEEN EIGHTY FIVE IS NOT
ACTUALLY A FISCAL BILL THAT'S
MOVING THROUGH WITHOUT GOING
THROUGH PREPARATIONS AND THIS IS
A TOTALLY SEPARATE AUGMENTATION
THAT WE THINK WILL. MAKE IT SO
THAT THE POLICY IN AB NINETEEN
EIGHTY FIVE CAN BE ACCOUNT.
I'M SO VERY SUPPORTIVE ACCESS
AND HAPPY TO ENGAGE IN FURTHER
DISCUSSIONS ABOUT WHETHER THE
AMOUNT IS ADEQUATE I'M UP TO
THIS POINT THAT'S THE IMPRESSION
THAT WE'VE GOTTEN AND LEAVE ON.
IT WE URGE YOU ALL TO CONSIDER
THIS REQUEST AND LOOK AT IT I'M
AS THINGS MOVE FORWARD SO THANK
YOU SO MUCH.
INTERFERES WITH THE CALIFORNIA
AND DOUBLY CP AND WE'RE ALSO
WORKING ON. ASSEMBLYMEMBER TINGS
BILL AND DON'T WERE LOOKING
FORWARD TO CONTINUING ON THE
WORK. OF AND WE'VE ALSO WORKED
WITH THE OTHER ORGANIZATIONS AND
WE THINK IT'S GOING. TO BE VERY
POSITIVE.
GETTING A PROPER REPORTS ON
HATE CRIMES AND.
POSTS TRAINEE THANK YOU.
GREG IS HERE WITH THE ARK AND.
UNITED CEREBRAL PALSY
CALIFORNIA COLLABORATION AND WE
ARE.
ALSO ONE OF THE SPONSORS OF OF
THE TING BILL. WOULD WE SEE THIS
AUGMENTATION
SUPPOSED TO BE
JERRY.
IF THE HEATING BILL PASSES WE
ALSO SEE IT UNNECESSARY TING
MILITANT PASSED IT
A VERY IMPORTANT THING
FOR US. ON.
BUT IF THE. OUT OF THE.
CONSIDERATION OF ENTITLED TO SAY
THAT I WAS A. A A SUBJECT MATTER
EXPERT TO DEVELOPING THE CURRENT
POST POLICY AND.
ALSO.
.
LET SUCCESSFULLY TRIED TO WORK
FLEXIBLE IN DEVELOPING THEIR
THEIR POLICY COUPLE YEARS.
AND.
AVAILABLE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS
IF YOU LIKE HOT AND BY ME I'M
ALSO APPEARING TODAY TO ME TO
USE ON BEHALF TO OTHER
ORGANIZATIONS. THE ANTI
DEFAMATION LEAGUE AND THE
CALIFORNIA CHURCH IMPACT BOTH
SUPPORT THIS PROPOSAL.
THANK YOU.
ALRIGHT SO ANY OTHER PUBLIC
COMMENT ON THAT.
AND IF NOT WE WILL THEN RETURN
TO OUR.
I'M BORED OF STATE INCOMMUNICADO
ACTIONS ON THE CALVET PROGRAM SO
KATHLEEN HOW ARE YOU MAY BEGIN
GOOD MORNING.
GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS LIVE VIDEO SHURI WERE
MINUTES ON THE KIDDING HOWARD A
BEHALF THE BE A CC WITH PROVIDED
SOME OF INFORMATION TO THE STAFF
ABOUT THE.
CURRENT
CAL GRANT PROGRAM WHICH IS JUST
ABOUT WRAPPING UP AND THEN THE.
RECENTLY AUTHORIZES MANAGER HAS
JUST STATED CALVET FROM PRIOR
YEAR JUST A FEW POINTS OF
INFORMATION ABOUT WHAT THE BOARD.
CONSIDERED THROUGH ITS.
COMPETITIVE PROCESS AS YOU MAY
RECALL THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES
HAS AND HAD RECEIVED A NON
COMPETITIVE PORTION OF ONE
MILLION DOLLARS ANNUALLY.
FOR THE CALIPHATE GRANTS THAT
WERE JUST APPROVED BY THE BOARD
AT THE APRIL MEETING THIS YEAR
WE HAD A TOTAL OF A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY APPLICATIONS.
THE GRAND TOTAL OF THE ASK WAS
JUST OVER FIFTY FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS AND SO.
TWENTY APPLICATIONS WERE FUNDED.
.
A TOTAL OF TEN TO CITIES AND
TEND TO OUR COMMUNITY BASED
ORGANIZATIONS.
I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE ABOUT THE
PROGRAM.
THE.
THAT BC P. I BELIEVE IN THE
GOVERNOR'S BUDGET HAD A
REDUCTION IN FUNDING ALLOCATION
FOR THE PROGRAMS THAT CORRECT I
DESCRIBE.
AND.
.
MY CITY I KNOW THAT THERE ARE A
NUMBER OF LEGISLATORS WHO
INCLUDING MYSELF WHO HAVE BEEN
ADVOCATING THAT THERE NOT BE A
REDUCTION IN FACT BE AN INCREASE.
AND.
.
OF COURSE WE IN IN.
SWITCHING THIS TITLE TO CALVET
VERSUS CAL GRIPPED IT IS NOT TO
EXCLUDE ANY WORK IN RELATIONSHIP
TO. OUR. GANG RELATED CRIMES BUT
IT IS TO FOCUS ON THE VIOLENCE
REDUCTION WHICH OF COURSE IS THE
AREA THAT OUR COMMUNITIES ARE
MOST CONCERNED AND AND WE HAVE
BEEN FORTUNATE. IN VARIOUS PARTS
OF THE STATE WHERE DIFFERENT%
JURISDICTIONS HAVE BEEN PILOTING
SOME VERY INNOVATIVE PROGRAMS.
AND THE.
WHAT WOULD INDICATE SO FAR IS
THAT IN THOSE COMMUNITIES WHERE
THOSE PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN MOST
ROBUST THERE'S? BEEN AN ACTUAL
VIOLENCE REDUCTION.
IN THE CITY OF RICHMOND IN MY
DISTRICT IS ONE SUCH EXAMPLE
WHICH HAS HAD NOW EXTERNAL
ENTITIES.
OUR RESEARCH IT SO THAT WE'VE
HAD SOME ABILITY SOME DISTANCE
OBVIOUSLY WHEN YOU HAVE A
CIRCUMSTANCE WHERE MURDERS
DROPPED.
QUITE SIGNIFICANTLY AND I
SHOOTING SPECIFICALLY. ARM IN A
COMMUNITY. ONE CAN'T JUST ASSUME
THAT APARTICULAR PROGRAM WAS
THE REASON FOR THAT INTO IT SO
THESE DIFFERENT EXTERNAL
ENTITIES THAT.
ON DID A MULTI YEAR LOOK FOR
EXAMPLE ON THE CITY OF RICHMOND.
THEY WERE ABLE TO CORRELATE A
GOOD AMOUNT OF THAT THOSE DIRECT
HOMICIDES THE SHOOTING
REDUCTIONS TO. THAT PROGRAM
AND SO AND THE INTEREST I KNOW
IN THE LEGISLATORS WHO WOULD
LIKE TO SEE. THE PROGRAM.
THE STATE BUDGET FUND FOR IT
INCREASED IS TO.
ENABLE OTHER COMMUNITIES WHO
MIGHT BE WILLING TO PILOT SUCH
PROGRAMS ARE ENGAGE IN SUCH
PROGRAMS BECAUSE OBVIOUSLY ALL
OF OUR COMMUNITIES WOULD LIKE A
REDUCTION. IN SHOOTINGS
SO.
.
I. WOULD IMAGINE THAT THE BOARD
OF COMMITTEE CORRECTIONS WOULD
NECESSARILY OPPOSE AT SUCH A
PROGRAM FOR IT.
IF YOU HAD ANY COMMENTS I KNOW
YOU JUST DID A ROUND OF GRANTS
AND.
I THINK JUST LIKE TWO WEEKS A
MONTH AGO THAT'S RIGHT MADAM
CHAIR SO AT THE APRIL ON BOARD
MEETING.
THERE WAS A RANKED LIST
PRESENTED TO THE BOARD AND.
TEN CITIES RECEIVED NEW FUNDING
FOR.
A NEW TO YOUR PROGRAM AND TEN
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS.
WE HAVE.
OF OLD GREAT DEAL THERE WAS A
GREAT DEAL OF INTEREST I'M
CERTAINLY EXPRESSED THROUGH THAT
COMPETITIVE BID PROCESS
ON THE AND THE BOARD WITH WHAT
WAS THE TOTAL FUNDING REQUEST
JUST OVER. FIFTY FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS WAS IT WOULD LAST US A
FIFTY FOOT SO. AND WE WERE ABLE
TO FIND YOU KNOW BUT JUST NINE
POINT TWO MILLION SO I
THOUGHTLESSLY YOU KNOW THAT'S
ABOUT WENTY PERCENT OF THE SO
THAT THERE'S CLEARLY A LARGE
YOUR.
AT WORK YOU KNOW WHEN. WHEN CAN
ALWAYS SAY THAT I REQUEST IS
ANALOGOUS TO A NEED BUT
CERTAINLY THE INTEREST IN TRUMP
ANNOUNCED VERY. FAR LARGER THAN
THE AMOUNT THAT WE HAD FUNDED IT
THAT'S RIGHT AND REALLY I'M WE
WERE.
.
PLEASED TO SEE THAT THE INTEREST
EXTENDED ACROSS ACROSS THE STATE
A TOTAL OF A HUNDRED TWENTY
APPLICATIONS.
AND IN PART THAT.
CAME FROM THE.
LEGISLATURE'S ACTION LAST YEAR
TO ALLOW COMMUNITY BASED
ORGANIZATIONS TO APPLY DIRECTLY
SO WE DID.
RECEIVE APPLICATIONS FROM
NINETY CBO'S AND THIRTY CITIES
SO LOT OF INTEREST ACROSS THE
STATE I CAN CERTAINLY AFFIRM
THAT.
VERY.
RIGHT ANY A COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS ON THE PART OF MY
COLLEAGUES.
.
ALRIGHT SO WE ARE.
LEAVING THIS ITEM OPEN AND.
.
HOPEFULLY THE MAY REVISE MIGHT
REFLECT THE GREAT INTEREST THERE
IS IN THIS UP AND DOWN STATE
OTHERWISE.
.
ANYWAY WILL THIS WILL BE A
SENATOR CAN WE CONTINUE TO WORK
TO DISCUSS YES THANK YOU SO MUCH.
GREAT.
A PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM.
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
MICHAEL MAKE LIVELY I'M A SENIOR
STAFF ATTORNEY AT THE GIFFORDS
LAW CENTER. AND ALSO PART OF THE
EXECUTIVE STEERING COMMITTEE FOR
CALVET THE JUST AWARDED THE
GRANTS OR.
I'M ALSO HERE ON BEHALF OF A
LARGER COALITION OF MORE THAN
THIRTY SOCIAL JUSTICE AND
VIOLENCE PREVENTION ORGANIZATION.
VERY AYE SUPPORTIVE AND
INTERESTED IN SEEING THE FUNDING
INCREASE FOR THIS PROGRAM I JUST
VERY QUICKLY FOR CONTACTS THIS
IS THE ONLY STATE LEVEL SOURCE
OF FUNDING FOR EVIDENCE BASED
COMMUNITY DRIVEN STRATEGY IS.
AND CALIFORNIA IS ONE OF JUST
SIX STATES IN THE COUNTRY THAT
IS MAKING THIS INVESTMENT.
I'M A MARYLAND BECAME THE SIX
THEY JUST TWO WEEKS AGO SO MORE
STATES ARE TAKING NOTICE OF WHAT
WE'RE DOING IT ACTUALLY THAT
MARYLAND PROGRAM IS MODELED
AFTER. WHAT WE'RE DOING HERE IN
CALIFORNIA WITH COW THAT WHERE
WE ARE FALLING BEHIND A LITTLE
BIT IS IN THE LEVEL OF OUR
INVESTMENTS OF YOU COMPARISON
MASSACHUSETTS WHICH HAS THE
LOWEST GUN DEATH RATE IN THE
ENTIRE COUNTRY? AND IS INVESTING
THE MOST IN THESE TYPE OF
PROGRAMS
THEY ARE INVESTING ABOUT TWO
DOLLARS PER PERSON AND HERE IN
CALIFORNIA IT'S ONLY TWENTY
THREE CENTS OR A LITTLE BIT
BEHIND THE CURVE IN TERMS OF OUR
COMMITMENT.
THESE PROGRAMS BUT AS WE'VE
TALKED ABOUT THERE IS INCREDIBLE
NEED WE EXPERIENCE MORE THAN
THIRTEEN HUNDRED FATAL SHOOTINGS
IN THE STATE EACH YEAR AND
THOUSANDS MORE NON FATAL
SHOOTINGS. AND AS WE'VE ALREADY
DISCUSSED THE AYE A HUNDRED AND
TWENTY DIFFERENT APPLICATIONS
AND AS SOMEONE WHO WAS ON THE
EXECUTIVE STEERING COMMITTEE I
SAW A NUMBER OF VERY STRONG.
APPLICATIONS THAT COULDN'T
RECEIVE FUNDING BECAUSE OF
BUDGET LIMITATIONS I
PARTICULARLY IS THE CITY OF
SALINAS I THINK IT'S A GOOD
EXAMPLE WHICH WAS RIGHT ON THAT
CUT OFF IN TERMS OF POINTS THEY
HAD A STRONG APPLICATION AND
COULDN'T RECEIVE FUNDING SO. IN
SHORT OUR BROAD COALITION REALLY
ENCOURAGE IT ENCOURAGES THIS
BODY IN THE LEGISLATURE TO
INCREASE FUNDING TO AT LEAST
EIGHT POINT FIVE MILLION TO
ALLOW MORE COMMUNITIES TO EXPAND
THESE PROGRAMS THANK YOU.
I I THINK MANY OF THE
LEGISLATORS REQUEST WAS TO
DOUBLE THE FUNDING.
IN AFTERNOON JANICE COUNTENANCE
DEFENSE FUND A CALIFORNIA. AND
WOULD LIKE TO LINE OUR COMMENTS
WITH OUR PARTNERS.
AT THE GIFFORDS LAW CENTER.
THE CALVET BAZAR CRUCIAL SOURCE
OF FUNDING FOR LOCAL VIOLENCE
PREVENTIVE AN INTERVENTION
INITIATIVES THAT MAKE
CALIFORNIA'S COMMUNITY SAFER.
AND PROTECTING EMPOWER OUR YOUNG
PEOPLE.
WE STRONGLY URGE YOU TO
INVESTING CALVET TO INTERRUPT
THE CYCLES OF VIOLENCE THAT ARE
TEARING COMMUNITIES AND FAMILIES
APART.
WE KNOW THE TOLL OF THIS
VIOLENCE FALLS
DISPROPORTIONATELY ON
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR AND IT IS
OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO FUND THE
VIOLENCE PREVENTION PROGRAMS.
THAT WILL HELP ENSURE THAT ALL
CALIFORNIA CHILDREN AND YOUTH
FEEL SAFE IN THEIR COMMUNITIES
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
I LAURIE JOHNSON ON BEHALF OF
THE CITIES OF SALINAS AS HE
SIGHED IN WATSONVILLE.
WE ARE STRONG SUPPORTERS OF THE
PROGRAM AND THE ING.
PROPOSAL TO INCREASE FUNDING.
HELLO MY NAME IS CHRISTIAN
FRANCO I WORK FOR A NONPROFIT
BASED OUT OF SALINAS MADE BY
MOTIVATED INDIVIDUAL LEADERSHIP
FOR PUBLIC ADVANCEMENT.
I WAS BORN AND RAISED IN
RICHMOND.
SO I A FIRSTHAND HAVE SEEN THE
EFFECTS OF OF THIS PROGRAM THAT
HAS TAKEN PLACE IN RICHMOND.
AND HARM HAS REALLY DRAMATICALLY.
DECREASE THE VIOLENCE IN THE IN
THE CITY I'M TALKING ABOUT
SEVENTY FIVE MURDERS EIGHTY
MURDERS A YEAR DOWN TO TWENTY
FIVE I MEAN THAT'S IT'S VERY
SIGNIFICANT. NOW HAVE TAKEN MY.
.
MY WORK ON TO THE CITY OF
SALINAS AND I'M WORKING THERE I
SEE WHAT'S GOING ON ON THE
GROUND THERE OF THE
ORGANIZATIONS THAT ARE COMING
TOGETHER TO TRY TO STRATEGIZE.
TO REDUCE VIOLENCE.
I REALLY AM APPRECIATIVE OF THE
LANGUAGE CHANGE LAST YEAR ON
FROM THE GAME REDUCTION TO THE
VIOLENCE.
INTERVENTION PREVENTION BECAUSE
YOU YOU SEE OTHER OTHER OTHER
AREAS SUCH AS PROSTITUTION AND
AND AND AND.
DRUG SALES AND THAT DOESN'T
NECESSARILY ALWAYS CORRELATE
WITH GANGS.
.
BUT IT IS NEVER THE LESS
VIOLENCE
ON AND SO IT'S VERY VERY
IMPORTANT THAT LANGUAGE WAS WAS
CHANGED.
WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE
INCREASE OF FUNDS BECAUSE WE SEE
WHAT'S GOING ON IN RICHMOND WE
SEE WHAT'S HAPPENING IN OAKLAND
SEE WHAT THE MAYOR'S OFFICE
STILL IN HERE IN SACRAMENTO. AND
I'M IN SALINAS WE HAVE THE
PEOPLE READY WE HAVE THE
COMPONENTS READY WHICH IS NEED
THE CAPACITY WE NEED THE FUNDING.
TO ALSO ADD TO THE GREAT LIST
OF CITIES THAT ARE REDUCING ON
THEIR VIOLENCE THANK YOU
APPRECIATE.
THANK YOU.
ALRIGHT.
.
ANY OTHER PUBLIC COMMENT ON THAT
ITEM.
RIGHT THEN WE WILL MOVE TO IT.
VARIOUS CERTAINLY GO AHEAD ASSN
MERSHON NOT SURE I UNDERSTAND.
OF.
PROGRAM.
ELIGIBILITY FOR APPLICANTS.
THE SAID INCLUDE DUO.
COUNTIES CITIES.
NO ARM THE LINDA SHORT SO THE
PROGRAM AS IS NOTED IN THE
AGENDA ON THE HAS A FAIRLY LONG
HISTORY IN CALIFORNIA GOING ALL
THE WAY BACK TO TWO THOUSAND
SEVEN AND.
GOVERNOR SCHWARZENEGGER AND AT
THAT POINT WHEN THE PROGRAM WAS
FIRST PUT TOGETHER THE SENSE WAS
THAT CITIES.
NEEDED SOME ADDITIONAL HELP AND
I'M I THINK FROM TIME TO TIME
THAT THAT THE QUESTION HAS COME
UP.
SHOULD THE OF THE.
ELIGIBILITY BE LOOKED AT BUT
JUST HISTORICALLY IT'S ALWAYS
BEEN CITIES AND THEN THE
LEGISLATURE MADE THE MOVE LAST
YEAR TO ALSO ALLOW CBO'S TO.
APPLY DIRECTLY BUT SENATOR BELL
THE CITY LEVEL OF.
GOVERNMENT IS THE ONLY.
ELIGIBLE APPLICANT AT THIS
POINT IN THE PUBLIC THE REASON
I'M ASKING IS.
IF THOUGH.
I OF THE.
.
YOU FOR VIOLENCE TO VIOLENT.
INTERVENTION AND PREVENTION.
YOU'RE STARTING TO GET MORE INTO
THAT COUNTY GOVERNMENTS.
DOMAIN.
TEARS OF LOOK AT VIRUSES A
PUBLIC HEALTH ISSUE. AND I AND I
WONDER A WONDER IF THE.
PROCESS SHOULD BE.
.
I JUST SAID I KNOW WE HAVE A
BILL THAT'S PENDING CORRECT. YES
LEGISLATIVE PROPOSAL.
YES SENATOR ALLEN ALLEN MILKMAN.
.
SO I THINK THERE'S SOMETHING
CONSIDER A FEW GOING TO THE
VIOLENCE PREVENTION MODE.
YOU'RE LOOKING AT VIOLENCE
PREVENTION A SERVE.
TRANSFORMS IT INTO.
.
AREAS THAT ARE IN.
COUNTY GOVERNMENT TO ME.
.
SO YOU MIGHT WANT TO CONSIDER.
EXPANDING WHO COULD APPLY FOR IT.
SURE I WOULD I WOULD JUST SAY
THAT'S A POLICY ISSUE THE
LEGISLATURE MAY OF COURSE WANT
TO GET INTO AND WE HAVE PLENTY
OF EXAMPLES IN THE GRANTS THAT
WE ADMINISTER. WHERE IT COULD BE
OPEN TO ANY PUBLIC AGENCIES SO
IT'S CERTAINLY SOMETHING WE BE
ABLE TO DO IF THAT'S THE
DIRECTION THE LEGISLATURE WANTS
TO GO IN OKAY I'M I'M GOING TO
LOOK AT THAT THE?
DO YOU KNOW WHEN YOU READ TO
FIND A PROGRAM LIKE THAT I THINK
HE'S GOT A LOOK AT.
CITIES DON'T DO VIOLENCE
PREVENTION.
WHEN THEY KNOW THEY DO YOU KNOW
THIS IS BEEN VERY SPECIFIC TO
GUN VIOLENCE AND.
ACTUALLY
CITIES DO GIVEN THAT USUALLY THE
PROGRAM'S ORIENTATION IS
DIRECTLY TO FOLKS WHO ARE
IDENTIFIED.
EITHER AS.
PAST
SHOOTER'S PAST PARTICIPANTS IN
SHOOTING OR.
GANG MEMBERS WHO MAY HAVE BEEN
INVOLVED IN SHOOTINGS AND ALSO
MUCH OF THE PROGRAM HAS BEEN IN
DIFFERENT PLACES WHERE THE
GRANTS HAVE BEEN RECEIVED HAS
BEEN ORIENTED TOWARD STOPPING
REVENGE SHOOTINGS BECAUSE VERY
COMMONLY.
WHAT OCCURS IS A SHOOTING OCCURS
IN THE COMMUNITY AND THEN
THEY'RE THEY'RE SHOOTINGS THERE
AFTER THAT OUR REVENGE SHOOTINGS?
THAT YOU DON'T. YOU JUST DO DO
AYE INADEQUACY OR WHATEVER HUMAN
FLY OFTEN TARGET A PERSON WHO
HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH YOUR
REGIONAL SHOOTING.
I'M SO THE THE FOCUS HAS BEEN
VERY MUCH
FROM THERE THE RECIPIENTS OF THE
GRANTS WERE EITHER. ON.
NOT REALLY DID COMMUNITY BASED
ORGANIZATIONS THIS YEAR BUT I
HAPPEN TO REVIEW A LOT OF THE
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATION
PROPOSALS AND MANY OF THEM WERE.
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS
THAT WERE FOCUSED ON THAT ASPECT
OF REDUCTION IN WHAT'S CALLED
THE VIOLENCE THERE REVENGE
SHOOTING SO IT IS BEEN VERY AND.
SO FAR ANYWAY.
THE.
FUNDING HAS BEEN VERY ORIENTED
TO DATA ASPECT.
IN MY COUNTY THEY DO IT A LITTLE
DIFFERENTLY THAN NOT SO.
THE COUNTY IS.
.
VERY INVOLVED IN THAT SUBJECT
AREA SO.
IT IF IT GUESS IT I GUESS IT
WOULD BE.
FAIR TO SAY THAT TO ALL.
PERHAPS I COULD BE EXAMINED.
THERE'S A DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN.
DIFFERENT AREAS HOW THEY
APPROACH.
I THINK THE.
.
IT'S FOR TO SAY SO I THINK GO.
IT WOULD BE SUBJECT I WOULD LIKE
TO LOOK AT.
RIGHT.
YO YO YOU ARE REALLY NO MORE
MONEY FOR COOKOUT INSPECTED WHAT.
SO WE WILL.
CLEARLY HOLD THIS OPEN AND HAVE
FURTHER DISCUSSION ON IT.
WE'LL NOW GO TO ISSUE THIRTEEN
AIR SURVEILLANCE FOR LOCAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT THERE WAS A SPECIFIC
REQUEST TO.
FOR AND. GENERAL FUND
ALLOCATION TO PURCHASE THE
HELICOPTER FOR THE CITY OF
STOCKTON.
AND.
NOT SURE IF ANYONE IS HERE TO
PRESENT ON THAT.
RATES IT'S NOT BE SEC IT I THINK
WE'D BE.
THE ADMINISTERING THE FUNDING
THAT'S OUR UNDERSTANDING ITS IN
THE FIVE TWO TWO SEVEN BUDGET
ITEM RIGHT.
TIMES WAS A PASTOR RICIN.
YEAH I.
OH OKAY THEN YOU MAY STATES
TABLE PLEASE GO AHEAD THOSE WHO.
YEAH.
GOOD MORNING KIANA ROSS WITH
MANUALS JONES ON BEHALF OF THE
CITY OF STOCKTON WITH A THREE
MILLION DOLLAR GENERAL FUND
REQUEST TO FUND IS UP HELICOPTER
FOR THE CITY. BEAR THE TWELFTH
LARGEST CITY WITHIN TH STATE
THEY DO NOT HAVE ANY KIND OF
HELICOPTER SUPPORT WITHIN THEIR
COMMUNITY NOR WITHIN THE COUNTY.
UPS THEY'RE LOOKING TO TRY AND
AND FULFILL THAT NEED. IT IN THE
CURRENT CIRCUMSTANCE IF THERE IS
AN INCIDENT WITHIN THIS BUT IN
SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY FRANKLY AND
THE CITY OF STOCKTON THEIR ONLY
HELICOPTER SUPPORT IS ABOUT
SIXTY FIVE MILES AWAY THIRTY TWO
MINUTES TO AN HOUR IT'S THE CHP%
FACILITY OUT OF AUBURN.
AND IT'S ONLY AVAILABLE IF
THERE'S NOT AN ONGOING NEED FOR
THAT HELICOPTER FOR CHP.
A THE COUNTY HAS NOT HAD A
HELICOPTER FOR MORE THAN TWENTY
YEARS.
SO THE ONLY SUPPORT THEY HAVE IS
A FIXED WING AIRCRAFT THAT IS.
LIVE MUCH HIGHER IN THE AIR IN
HIS BILL USED FOR OVERLOOKING
LARGE AGRICULTURAL AREAS.
AND THIS IS ABOUT A FOUR YEAR
EFFORT BY THE CITY THEY'VE BEEN
LOOKING AT ALL SORTS OF WAYS TO
TRY TO FIND A BOARD TALK TO
OTHER COMMUNITIES THEY'VE TRIED.
GOING AFTER FUNDING AT THE
FEDERAL AND AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
THEY'VE BEEN UNSUCCESSFUL.
AND SO THEY'RE NOW HERE AT THE
STATE.
MANAGER DAVID JONES ALSO ABOUT
CITY OF STOCKTON OF THIS THIS SO
ARISES OUT OF A VERY TRAGIC
EVENT THAT THE BANK OF THE WEST
OF ROBBERY WHERE THEY TOOK OF.
THREE WOMEN HOSTAGE FROM THE
BANK ARE THEY FIRED OVER SIX
HUNDRED OF ROUNDS OF AMMUNITION
BETWEEN THE. AGE OF FORTY SEVEN
WIELDING PURPOSE AND.
THE STUDY THAT WAS DONE EGGS.
WELL IT REALLY CAME TO A
CONCLUSION THAT AIR SUPPORT WAS
WAS DESPERATELY NEEDED WE ALMOST
LOST A NUMBER OF OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS WHEN.
THE OF PERPETRATORS WENT DOWN IT
ON ON RAMP AND POSITION
THEMSELVES TO OF THE READY TO
AMBUSH THE COPS WERE CHASING
THEM AND WAS ONLY BECAUSE WE HAD
AN OFF DUTY OFFICER THAT HAPPEN
TO BE DRIVING BY.
AND A THE ENGAGE THEM THAT THEY
PACKED BACK UP IN AND LEFT SO
PROPOSAL HAS VERY STRONG
COMMUNITY SUPPORT THE COMMUNITY
IS IS CLAMORING FOR THE US. WE
KNOW THAT THERE'S A DOES SAVE A
LOT OF PUBLIC SAFETY RESOURCES
AND STOCKTON. IS ONE OF THE FIVE
COMMUNITIES WHO HAVE THE HIGHEST
CRIME RATES IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA SO WE ARE VERY
STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS
REQUEST.
SENATOR ANDERSON.
WHEN NAM.
SO.
THE THE HELICOPTER WHEN YOU SAY
AIR SUPPORT WOULD BE LANDING IN
PICKING PEOPLE UP.
OR WHAT. I'M TRYING TO IMAGINE.
WHAT EXACTLY ITS DUTIES ARE
THERE'S A COUPLE DIFFERENT WAYS
OF THINKING THAT THEY WOULD USE
THIS ONE AS POLICE PRESENCE IN
OVER EVENTS THAT COULD FLY AND
MONITOR IF YOU HAD? A BUT THE
POLICE INCIDENT IT COULD FOLLOW
SUSPECT THROUGH THE COMMUNITY
ECONOMIC SO FOLLOW THEM DOWN THE
FREEWAY THEY HAVE NINETY NINE
AND I FIVE ON EITHER SIDE.
THE COMMUNITY IT ALSO COULD HELP
IT.
SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY HAS VERY
HIGH FLOOD RISK AND SO COULD FLY
OVER. YOUR FLOOD BREACHES THINGS
LIKE THAT THEY'VE GOT THREE OR
FOUR STATE A CDC OUR FACILITIES
SO COULD HELP IN THE CASE OF
THAT. WE'VE ALSO GOT A PORT
WHERE IT COULD ALSO HELP THAT
THERE WAS AN INCIDENT. IT CAN
LAND IN THE COMMUNITY IT COULD
ALSO FLY LO AND CIRCLE AND IT
CAN ALSO FLY AT HIGHER LEVELS TO.
A MONITOR.
HAVE YOU CONSIDERED A DRONE.
THEY HAVE CONSIDERED A DRONE
ACTUALLY DRAW WOULD NOT WORK FOR
THEM AND THE REASON WHY THIS
CAME UP IN MEETINGS THROUGHOUT
THE WEEK. UP DRONES CAN FLY THEY
HAVE TO BE WITHIN EYESIGHT AND I
HAVE TO STAY UNDER A BELIEVE
IT'S FIVE HUNDRED FORTY. FOUR
HUNDRED FEET BUT DOESN'T REALLY
WORK WHEN THEY'RE DOING IT
INCIDENT FOR INSTANCE IF YOU'VE
GOT A CAR SPEEDING DOWN A
FREEWAY OR YOU HAVE. ASSEMBLY
DRIVING THROUGH CITY STREETS
THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO FOLLOW AT
DRAWING ONLY WORKS WHEN IT'S IN
WITHIN EYESIGHT SO IT BUT
OPERATOR HOUSE TO BE ABLE TO SEE
THE DRONE OF ALL TIMES.
ARE THERE ARE DRONES AT WORK
OUTSIDE OF MY SITE THOUGH.
I THINK THERE ARE THE ONES THAT
THE CITY HAS LOOKED THAT THEY'VE
BUT THEY CONCLUDED. UP AFTER
MULTIPLE YEARS OF LOOKING AT
EVERY KIND OF POSSIBLE DEVICES
THAT THIS THE DRONE. IS LIMITED
IN ITS CAPACITY AND HELICOPTERS
REALLY THE ONE THING THAT WOULD
BE OF HELP TO THEM.
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER COMMENT REVERSED.
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE SIDE OF.
RIGHT SEWER HOLDING IT OPEN AND
THANK YOU THINK FOR CRUSTACEAN.
OKAY SO WE'RE NOW GOING TO.
ITEM.
.
THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
AND REHABILITATION ISSUE
FOURTEEN THE HEALTH CARE
FACILITY IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM
SPRING LETTER WORD FROM.
.
CCR SPECIALTIES PLANNING
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT DIVISION
RECORD. CHECK JUST. GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
BEING BORDER PRISON FACILITY
PLANNING CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
DIVISION FOR THE DEPARTMENT
CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATION.
TO START WTH I WANT TO GIVE A
LITTLE BACKGROUND ON THE HECK
THE PROGRAM HEALTH CARE FACILITY
IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM OVERALL.
IT WILL BE ADDRESSING.
PRIMARY AND SPECIALTY CARE
CLINIC NEEDS AND RELATED
OUTPATIENT SERVICES THROUGHOUT
OUR SYSTEM.
OVERALL LITTLE ADDRESS ABOUT
SEVEN HUNDRED FIFTY EIGHT
THOUSAND SQUARE FEET BOTH A NEW
CONSTRUCTION AND RENOVATION.
AND IT IS PART OF THE RECEIVERS
TURNAROUND PLAN ACTION THAT WAS.
RE RELEASE OF THE CORN TWO
THOUSAND NINE IDENTIFYING THE
DIFFERENT STEPS THAT NEED TO BE
TAKEN TO IMPROVE HEALTHCARE THE
INFRASTRUCTURE IN WHICH
HEALTHCARE IS BEING PROVIDED IS
CLEARLY ONE OF THOSE ITEMS.
TO DATE WE HAVE ACCOMPLISHED
PARTLY TWENTY TWO PERCENT OF THE
OVERALL CONSTRUCTION THAT WERE
MENTIONING HERE. ABOUT A HUNDRED
SIXTY SEVEN THOUSAND SQUARE FEET
OF NEW AND RENOVATED SPACE
SIXTEEN BRAND NEW CLINICS THAT
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO OPEN UP
DURING THAT PRISON DURING THAT
PERIOD OF TIME.
WE'RE IN A VERY VERY STRONG
CONSTRUCTION STAGE RIGHT NOW
WHERE BETWEEN NOW AND THE END OF
THE YEAR WE ANTICIPATE THAT
TWENTY TWO PERCENT COMPLETION
RATE WILL GROW TO ABOUT SEVENTY
TWO PERCENT COMPLETION RATE.
SO OF THE AND HUNDRED SIXTY
SEVEN SQUARE FEET ALREADY DONE
WILL ADD ABOUT THREE HUNDRED
EIGHTY TWO THOUSAND TO THAT BY
THE END OF THE YEAR. THIRTY TWO
ADDITIONAL CLINICS WILL BE
OPENED UP AND WILL HAVE
COMPLETED CONSTRUCTION AT SEVEN
PRISONS OVERALL DURING THAT
PERIOD OF TIME.
SO WE ARE MAKING PROGRESS BUT AS
HAS BEEN DOCUMENTED IN THE
AUGMENTATION REQUESTS THAT.
WE HAVE COME TO THE LEGISLATURE
FROM THE PUBLIC WORKS BOARD IN
JULY OF TWENTY SEVENTEEN AND IN
MARCH OF TWENTY EIGHTEEN THE
PROGRAM HAS HAD ITS.
DIFFICULTIES.
THEY HAVE LED TO INCREASE COST
DESIGN ERRORS AND OMISSIONS THAT
WE'VE EXPERIENCED.
THROUGHOUT OUR EIGHTY FIRMS AND
ANTICIPATED SITE CONDITIONS BOTH.
WITH FINDING UTILITIES WHERE
THEY WERE ANTICIPATED TO BE AND
ANOTHER SIGNIFICANT IMPACT HAS
BEEN WHEN WE START DEMOLITION
AND OVER IN A BUILDING FINDING
THINGS BEHIND THE WALL IN ABOUT
THE CEILING. THAT WERE NOT BUILD
AS THEY WERE SHOWN ON THE AS
BUILT AND WITH THE FIRE MARSHALL
BEING A PARTNER IN US WITH US ON
THIS. WE NEED TO ADDRESS THOSE
BEFORE WE COULD CLOSE EVERYTHING
UP AND GET OCCUPANCY OF THESE
NEW PLACES.
SO BE IT COST INCREASES HAVE
BEEN DRIVEN BY HARD CONSTRUCTION
DOLLARS.
EXTENDED.
JOB COSTS FOR THE GENERAL
CONTRACTORS BECAUSE THEY THOUGHT
THEY BEEN ON AN EIGHTEEN MONTH
PROJECT THAT NOW A TWENTY FOUR
MONTH OR LONGER PROJECT.
AND SAME COSTS FOR CONSULTANTS
FOR CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
FIRMS.
THIS IS A VERY UNIQUE
APPROPRIATION FOR THE HECK OF IT
PROGRAM AS IDENTIFIED IN THE.
CONSULTANT AT ECHO THE
COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS REPORT AND
THE LA OWES REPORT.
UNLIKE TYPICAL PROJECTS WHEN
THE TWENTY TWELVE BUDGET TRAILER
BILL AUTHORIZED THE FUNDING FOR
HICKS AT. IT AUTHORIZED IT AS A
SINGLE PREPARATION RATHER THAN
INDIVIDUAL CORPORATIONS FOR EACH
PROJECT I ANY APPROPRIATE THE
AUGMENTATION LEVELS LIE AGAINST
THAT FULL APPROPRIATIONS.
TO DATE WE HAVE HAD ABOUT
EIGHTEEN AND A HALF PERCENT OF
THE ALLOWABLE TWENTY PERCENT AND
UNFORTUNATELY WE KNOW ADDITIONAL
AUGMENTATIONS ARE NEEDED TO
COMPLETE PROJECTS.
THAT'S WHAT LEADS US TO THE
ISSUE BEFORE THE COMMITTEE.
THIS FINANCE LETTER WOULD ADD
SEVENTY THREE MILLION DOLLARS TO
THE EXISTING APPROPRIATION FOR
IT FOR.
THIS AUTHORITY WOULD BE
ALLOCATED TO EACH PROJECT AS
NEEDED THROUGH SUBSEQUENT PUBLIC
WORKS BOARD ACTIONS.
THIS IS EXACTLY THE SAME PROCESS
AS HAS BEEN FOLLOWED SINCE
TWENTY TWELVE WITH THE ORIGINAL
EXCEPT APPROPRIATIONS.
THIS REQUEST ALSO ADDS TO
EXISTING OVERSIGHT OF THE EXIT
PROGRAM AND OF THIS FUNDING BY
ADDING NOTIFICATION LANGUAGE.
THAT DID NOT PREVIOUSLY EXIST.
A LEGISLATURE WOULD RECEIVE
REPORTS WHENEVER THIS FUNDING IS
ALLOCATED INDICATING THE REASONS
FOR THE ALLOCATIONS TO EACH
PROJECT AND HOW MUCH OF THE
SEVENTY THREE MILLION DOLLARS
REMAINS ON ALLOCATED.
WITHOUT THE ADDITIONAL FUNDING
THAT WE'VE REQUEST IN THIS
LETTER.
SOMEWHERE BETWEEN FOURTEEN AND
EIGHTEEN PROJECTS WILL NEED TO
HALT CONSTRUCTION DURING THE
TWENTY EIGHTEEN NINETEEN FISCAL
YEAR.
WE WE'VE BEEN ASKED TO TRY TO
PREDICT WHEN THAT WOULD OCCUR
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR AND.
THE REASON WHY WE CANNOT PREDICT
THAT WITH CERTAINTY IS BECAUSE
IT'S NOT A CASH FLOW. ISSUE THIS
ISN'T AN ISSUE WHERE THE
PROJECTS ARE EATING A CERTAIN
BURN RATE EACH MONTH AND YOU CAN
PROJECT THAT THAT BURN RATE WILL
EXPIRE AT A CERTAIN.
IN THE PROCESS.
WE ARE DEALING HERE WITH THE
ABILITY TO DO CAN CHANGE ORDERS.
THROUGH OUR CONSTRUCTION
CONTRACTS AND EACH PROJECT HAS A.
CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT
CONTINGENCY AMOUNT THOSE
AUTHORIZED FOR THAT PROJECT WE
CAN DO CHANGE ORDERS AGAINST
THAT CONTINGENCY AMOUNT.
WHEN THAT CONTINGENCY AMOUNT HAS
BEEN EXHAUSTED BY CHANGE ORDERS
WE CANNOT AUTHORIZE ANY
ADDITIONAL CHANGE ORDERS TO THAT
CONTRACTOR. AND AT THAT POINT IN
TIME THE PROJECT WOULD HAVE TO
HOLD. BECAUSE THESE CHANGE
ORDERS ARE NECESSARY TO COMPLETE
THE BUILDING RECEIVE THE
OCCUPANCY FOR THE FIRE MARSHAL
AND HAVE OUR.
HEALTH CARE STAFF MOVE INTO
THOSE BUILDINGS.
OBVIOUSLY IF WE REACH A POINT
WHERE WE HAVE TO HELP PROJECTS
THAT JUST DRIVES ADDITIONAL COST
INCREASES FOR. DEMOBILIZATION
REMOTE LOCATION OF THE
CONTRACTORS.
SO THIS IS OUR ATTEMPT TO GET
OUT IN FRONT OF THAT AND PROVIDE
THE FUNDING NECESSARY TO KEEP.
THE WHAT WE FEEL THE STRONG.
PHASE OF CONSTRUCTION GOING
FORWARD AND REACHING THE
CONCLUSION OF THESE PROJECTS.
THAT EVERYONE IS SEEKING.
SO I THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK THE
REALIZE IT'S GOING TO BE HELD
OPEN WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
THE COMMITTEE CONSULTANT TO
ADDRESS.
I NEED THE THE ISSUES AND THE
QUESTIONS ARE STILL OUT THERE
AND OF COURSE DIET AFTER OTHER
PEOPLE'S PRESENTATIONS CAN
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS COMMITTEE
HAS.
AMIL ONE OF THE THINGS THAT. AND
I WILL BE ASKING FOR ALEJO'S
COMMENT DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE IF
THEY HAVE SOMETHING.
IS THAT THE ADMINISTRATION HAD
ALREADY REACHED APPROVED IT
AUGMENTATION OF A HUNDRED AND
SIXTY SEVEN MILLION WHICH IS
EIGHTEEN POINT SIX PERCENT OF
THE TOTAL NINE HUNDRED MILLION
AUTHORIZED.
TO COVER. THE COST INCREASES NOW
CLEARLY ANYONE IS GOING TO
CONSTRUCTION PROJECT KNOW THAT
YOU KNOW OFTENTIMES WHEN YOU
KNOW THE WALLS OPEN OR WHATEVER
RELEASE THERE'S ADDITIONAL WORK.
BUT.
AND CLEARLY THAT'S WHY THE
HUNDRED SIXTY SEVEN MILLION.
INCREASES WERE ALLOCATED BUT
WHAT'S BEING ASKED NOW. IS A
KIND MORE WHAT ONE MIGHT
CONSIDER MORE OF A BLANK CHECK.
.
AND.
WITH LESS.
JUSTIFICATION ABOUT WHY AND ALSO.
ON THE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
WOULD COME AFTER THE STATE
PUBLIC WORKS BOARD.
APPROVED THE ALLOCATION RATHER
THAN PRIOR.
SO THOSE ARE SOME OF THE
CONCERNS THAT.
.
THAT I WOULD HAVE IN THIS BUT I
WOULD LIKE TO HEAR FROM THE LA
JOH.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
JONATHAN PETERSON WITH THE LA
THOUGH.
WE RECOMMENDED THAT THE
LEGISLATURE REJECT THE SEVENTY
THREE MILLION DOLLAR PROPOSED
INCREASE IN LEASE REVENUE
AUTHORITY FOR THE SAKE THAT
PROJECTS AND THE REASON BEING
THAT WE'D. BEEN WORKING WITH THE
DEPARTMENT AND I FEEL LIKE
THERE'S ADEQUATE JUSTIFICATION
ON WHAT SPECIFIC. COSTS A WERE
NEEDED TO.
ADDRESS THAT WERE NEEDED TO
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS RAISED AND
HOW MUCH ADDRESSING THOSE
SPECIFIC CONCERNS WOULD COST.
THERE WAS ALSO PART OF THE
REQUEST IS FOR THIRTY MILLION
CONTINGENCY FUNDING AND THERE
WAS AN INFORMATION AVAILABLE AS
TO WHAT SPECIFIC ITEMS THAT
CONTINGENCY FUNDING WOULD
REQUEST OR WHAT KINDS OF ITEMS
HAVE BEEN BROUGHT TO THE
DEPARTMENT'S ATTENTION THAT.
LED TO THAT CALCULATION OF
FUNDING
SO WE RECOMMENDED REJECTING THE
FUNDING AND IN THE EVENT THAT.
OF A FUTURE REQUEST CAME AND WE
WOULD ALSO RECOMMEND REQUIRE ARE
DIRECTING THE DEPARTMENT TO
PROVIDE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.
SUCH AS HOW MUCH EACH PROJECT
WOOD OF WOULD RECEIVE WHAT THE
ADDITIONAL FUNDING WOULD BE USED
FOR.
HOW WHAT KIND OF DATA WOULD
JUSTIFY THE CONTINGENCY FUNDING
REQUESTS?
AND HOW MUCH ADDITIONAL
AUTHORITIES NEEDED TO AVOID THE
DELAYS THAT THE DEPARTMENT
OUTLINED COULD BE POTENTIAL. AYE
IF.
PRODUCT ENOUGH FUNDING AND WHAT
SPECIFIC PROJECTS WOULD BE
DELAYED IF THE FUNDING WAS A
RECEIPT.
ANY QUESTIONS SORRY. RESERVE
CARD TRUCK.
ARCHITECT.
AND WORK FOR THOSE.
PROJECT. IT'S IT'S A VARIETY WE
HAVE BALLOT YOU KNOW SEVEN OR
EIGHT DIFFERENT A NEED FOR I'D
LIKE TO KNOW THE NAMES.
ELECTED WHO IS WHO'S WHO MOVES.
BASICALLY BECAUSE THIS MULTI
YEAR DELAY AT AMATUS AB TO SPEND
ALL THIS MONEY WILL BE YOU KNOW
ACCOUNTABILITY SUPPORT.
WILL PROVIDE THAT INFORMATION
GUY I MEAN YOU KNOW IT IT IT
MIGHT STAFF TO ASK YOU BEFORE
UNIT PROVIDED SO I'D LIKE TO
HAVE PROVIDED NOW.
WE ASK QUESTIONS WE WANTED A
BEFORE THE MEETINGS SILICON.
PROVES DELUDE AND FROM.
BEFORE THE ITEM COMES UP.
OKAY SO.
WE ARE STOOD BEFORE THE MEETING
PROVIDED.
SO I'D LIKE TO HAVE THE
INFORMATION BEFORE THE MEETING.
WILL WE WILL GET THAT GET THAT
INFORMATION A KILEY WRITERS
BIRTH ON TRACTORS AND DOLLAR
AMOUNTS AND.
WHERE THE CHANGE ORDERS ARE
HAPPY LEWTON WHO'S? WHO'S
CAUSING THE CHANGE ORDERS.
THAT WHERE THE CHANGE ORDERS
HAPPENING EITHER.
WHEN THEY WERE SUBMITTED.
HOW CLOSE TO THEIR BID?
WAS THE CHANGE ORDERS SUBMITTED.
I'M.
THOSE WEEKS OF QUESTIONS.
CERTAINLY.
I LIKE TO KNOW ALSO.
WHETHER PROJECTS ARE IN THE
PIPELINE THAT ARE NOT SHOWN IN
THIS REQUEST.
THE QATAR COMING IN THE FUTURE.
OTHER OTHER PROJECTS THAT HAVE
CHANGE ORDERS AND IN COST
INCREASES.
DATA IN ADDITION TO THIS
PARTICULAR OF PROJECT.
WE ARE NOT EXPERIENCING THE SAME
TYPE OF EXPERTS A EXPERIENCE
WITH OUR OTHER CAPITAL OUTLAY
PROJECTS THAT ARE UNDER
CONSTRUCTION RIGHT NOW YES IS
OKAY.
ARE THERE OTHER ARM LIKE IN IN
THE DEPARTMENT.
IN TERMS OF MANAGEMENT OF THE.
CAPITAL OUT LIFE WHO ACT WHO
ACTUALLY MANAGES LE.
PROJECTS SO ARE THE ROAD IS
THERE ANY OTHER OVERSIGHT OVER.
DESTRUCTION MANAGEMENT EXIST.
WHAT FOR PROJECTS WHERE WE HAVE
A CONCERT A A GENERAL CONTRACTOR
IN THE FIELD WE HAVE A
CONSULTANT US IT CONSTRUCTION
MANAGER THAT IS UNDER OUR
CONTRACT? IN THE FIELD ALSO IN
ORDER TO MANAGE THEIR.
OPERATIONS.
WE HAVE A PROGRAM MANAGEMENT
FIRM THAT WE HAVE TO CONTRACTED
WITH TO ASSIST US AT THE
HEADQUARTERS LEVEL WITH
PROCESSING ALL OF THE
INFORMATION THAT WE'RE GETTING
ON
PROJECTS.
SO THEY HAVE A PERSON AND THEN
SEVERAL MANAGERS OF COURSE.
ASSINED TO IT WILL HAVE AN
INDIVIDUAL EMPLOYEE OF PROJECT
DIRECTOR AND THE PROJECT
DIRECTOR WILL HAVE SUPERVISORS.
AND THEN A BRANCH CHIEFS AND
THEN MYSELF AND ARTERIES AS
RECTOR
DESTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
CONSULTANTS
I THINK I CAN PROVIDE THAT%
INFORMATION ALONG WITH THE A
FIRM HOLD. OF THE BEEN THERE A
LONG TIME OF THE.
THE GUY CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
CONSULTANTS THAT ARE MANAGING
THE PROJECT WE HAVE CONTRACT. A
CHANGE ORDER OVER RUNS A MULTI
YEAR DELAYS.
IT'S ALL DOWN THE ROAD.
YOU KNOW THE COUNT ABILITY
ISSUES MY QUESTION.
SO SO WHO WHO.
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
COMPANIES POST TO.
.
PROVIDE TO.
NOTIFICATION IF THERE'S SO.
SOMETHING GOING WRONG OR CHANGE
ORDER IT DISSIPATION DO THEY DO
THAT WHAT'S THE PROCESS FOR
DOING THAT.
WE ARE HAVE FROM MONTH MONTHLY
REPORTS THAT THE MANAGEMENT AND
IS INCLUDED WITH WHERE THE.
CHANGE ORDER LOGS ARE REVIEWED
AND SO THAT'LL SHOW EVERYTHING
THAT'S BEING AND PROCESS IN
ADDITION TO THINGS THAT THEY'VE
ACTUALLY ACTUALLY ARE
NEGOTIATING WITH THE CONTRACTOR.
THERE'S A SEPARATE PAGE OF
ITEMS THAT ARE BEING LOOKED AT
SO IN OTHER WORDS WE HAVEN'T
GOTTEN TO THE BOTTOM LINE YET OF
pCAUSE A CHANGE OR NOT. BUT WE
CAN WE TRACK THE POTENTIAL
EXPOSURE OF THOSE ADDITIONAL
THOUGH IS THERE OTHER THINGS
THAT ARE IN ADDITION.
THIS.
THAT ARE GOING TO COME UP. WITH
THESE PROJECTS IN ADDITION TO
THIS AMOUNT OF MONEY.
ARE WE LOOKING AT.
WHAT'S THE RISKS IN THE FUTURE
FOR OTHER THINGS COMING UP.
THAT'S WHAT WE ATTEMPTED TO
ADDRESS THROUGH THE AMOUNT THAT
THEY ALEJO'S REFERRING TO OF THE
CONTINGENCY AMOUNT SO THE TOTAL
SEVENTY THREE MILLION DOLLARS
THERE'S A FORTY TWO OR FORTY
THREE MILLION THAT HAS BEEN
SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFIED FOR
PROJECT SO FAR. AND THEN THE
ADDITIONAL THIRTY MILLION IS FOR
ITEMS
BEYOND THAT THAT WE DON'T KNOW
YET.
SO LED.
GETTING HOW WE CAME UP WITH
THOSE DOLLAR AMOUNTS THAT ANY
POINT IN TIME WHERE WE SIT DOWN
INTO A FINANCIAL. CHECKUP OF THE
PROJECT WE ARE OPERATIONS ONLY
AS GOOD AS KNOWING ALL OF THE
ISSUES AT THAT TIME AND THERE
ARE ADDITIONAL BECAUSE THESE
PROJECTS. AND WE.
IF THESE PROJECTS ARE BUILDING A
SINGLE BUILDING AT A PRISON BUT
OFTEN WILL BE FIVE OR SIX JOBS
SIDE SIMULTANEOUSLY SOMETIMES
ARE FOLLOWING ONE AFTER ANOTHER.
AND A SPECIAL BECAUSE WE'RE
WORKING IN.
OCCUPIED SPACE THE RENOVATION
SOMETIMES BE TWO THREE FOUR
PHASES WITHIN THAT SPACE
SO THE ISSUE IS UNTIL WE'VE
GOTTEN INTO THE SPACE TO OPEN IT
UP WE MAY NOT KNOW. THAT THOSE
ISSUES ARE THERE YET SO THAT'S
WHY WHEN WE PUT THESE DOLLAR
AMOUNTS TOGETHER IT'S OUR BEST
EFFORT AT THAT MOMENT TO KNOW
WHAT OUR FINANCIAL EXPOSURE IS.
USUALLY WHEN YOU GIVE PHAM.
YOU PUT A CONTINGENCY IN THE
ORIGINAL PRODUCT.
AND IN NEAR YOUR ASKING FOR.
SOME.
ADDITION TO THE CONTINGENCY.
THAT'S KIND OF AWE UNPRECEDENTED.
ALL SEE I THINK IN TERMS OF THE
PROJECT MANAGEMENT SPEAK
PROJECTS.
ISN'T I MEAN THAT'S A GOOD
QUESTION.
MEAN IF THE TO THE GENERAL
SERVICES WAS DOING A PROJECT.
WITH A YOU KNOW JUST KEEP ASKING
FOR MORE CONTINUES THE MONEY SO
THEY COULD.
POTENTIALLY MONEY IS MONEY TO BE
SPENT ON ANYTHING THAT COULD BE
SPENT ON.
WHO KNOWS WHAT WHATEVER THEIR
ARCHITECT BILLS YOU WERE?
SOME OTHER BUILDING YOU GET YOU
CAN SPEND IT ON THAT.
THAT I DON'T USE CAN TO KEEP
SPENDING THE MONEY.
WITHOUT ANY.
CHO TO CONTROL WHEN YOU GIVE
CONTAINS THE MONEY SO.
SO LIKE TO ME TO ME IT'S
IMPORTANT TO IDENTIFY WHERE.
THE SPECIFICS OF THE COST.
OF THE ORIGINAL PROJECT WHAT
SPECIFICALLY IS COSTING MORE.
AND WHY THEY'RE.
DESTRUCTION MANAGEMENT DENT.
TROLLS COST
WELL AS CONVITE INTERVENE THE.
GETTING THE LIST.
BUT IT WOULD BE HELPFUL BECAUSE
THEN IT WOULD ALLOW US TO SEE
WHETHER IT IS.
PERHAPS A FEW FACILITIES WHERE
THESE OVERRUNS
HAVE OCCURRED PURSES ALL OF THEM
IN WHETHER IT'S A FEW
CONTRACTORS OR WHAT AND OR ONLY
ONE OR MORE. WHAT WANTED FEW OF
THE?
MANAGERS THAT WERE USING.
SO THAT HELPFUL TO KNOW BECAUSE.
THEY'RE OBVIOUSLY COULD BE A
SITUATION WHERE.
THE BID FOR PARTICULAR FACILITY
WAS JUST.
REALLY OFF DUE TO. PROP
UNFORESEEN PROBLEMS THAT
FACILITY BUT UNLESS WE HAVE THE
DATA OF WHERE THESE OVERRUNS
OCCURRED. AND WHAT CONTRACTORS
WHAT MANAGERS IT'S HARD TO.
YOU KNOW.
COULD BE SCOPE CREEP RIGHT
WHATEVER THE REASON RIGHT TO
GIVE IT TIMELINE FOR THE CHANGE
ORDERS ON WHAT
SWITCH INTO OTHER WORLDS.
I'M VICE RICHARD QUEST.
BERMAN FINANCE YOU WANNA MAKE
COMMENT.
THANK YOU MADAM SARACENI TAM OUT
THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE WHO I
JUST LIKE TO ADD A LITTLE BIT
MORE ABOUT THE NOTIFICATION
PROCESS INCLUDED IN THE.
PROPOSED TRAILER BILL LANGUAGE.
SO THE RATIONALE FOR INCLUDING
THE NOTIFICATION AFTER THE STATE
PUBLIC WORKS BOARD APPROVAL
REALLY GETS TO SENATOR BELL'S
COMMENT ABOUT HAVING A TIMELY
AND EFFICIENT PROCESS TO CLOSE
OUT THE SICK THAT PROJECTS
INCLUDING BEING ABLE TO.
EFFICIENTLY APPROVED THE CHANGE
ORDERS AND POTENTIAL CHANGE
ORDERS.
AS THEY ARISE AS. WE ALSO KNOW
THAT FOR ITEMS VOICE EFFICIENT
TO A APPROVED AFTER THE MONEY
HAS BEEN SPENT. IT WOULD BE THE
AUTHORITY TO APPROVE AND FOR THE
DEPARTMENT TO GO AND ENTER INTO
NEGOTIATIONS
IMPROVE THE CHANGE ORDERS RIGHT
ARENA.
I'M DOES OVERSIGHT VIA I DON'T
WILL.
AT AT THIS CREAM ON AUTUMN
CURRENT ONE AUDITOR'S DEPARTMENT
OF FINANCE THERE'S STILL A
PUBLIC WORKS WORD PROCESS WHERE
ASAGOE THROUGH BEFORE WE CAN
EVEN AUTHORIZED THAT SO IT
WOULDN'T JUST BE. M. SPENDING
MONEY THAT THERE'S A PROCESS
THROUGH THE PUBLIC WORKS VIRGIN
ITEM.
AND THEN THERE'S THE BOARDING A
PUBLIC HEARING. IN WHICH IT
WOULD HAPPEN BEFORE THE MONEY
WOULD BE AUTHORIZED.
ON.
ANY PROCESS. ANYTHING MORE THE
FOREIGN FINANCE ONE DAD.
THE ADMINISTRATION CONTINUES TO
SUPPORT THE PROPOSAL.
THANK YOU VERY OWN. ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS FROM COLLEAGUES.
OKAY. AND TURNER YES GO AHEAD
ARM GAVE LUIS FROM THE
CALIFORNIA CORRECTIONAL HEALTH
CARE SERVICES.
AND. THE HIT FOR PROBABLY
PROGRAM IS ESSENTIAL TO THE
RECEIVERSHIP AND IN IT IT'S ONE
OF SIX ITEMS THAT WAS I'M CALLED
OUT AS SPECIFICALLY NEEDED TO.
AND THE CALIFORNIA PRISON
RECEIVERSHIP.
JOINTLY BETWEEN THE PLAINTIFFS
THE DEFENDANT'S
AND THE RECEIVER HIMSELF AND WE
CONTINUE TO STRONGLY BE
CONCERNED ABOUT ANYTHING THAT
WOULD DELAY CONSTRUCTION. OF
THESE FACILITIES AS AM AS MR
BOARD POINTED OUT TO THIS WAS
ONE OF THE BASELINE ISSUES THAT
WAS POINTED OUT AS NEEDING TO BE
ADDRESSED BEFORE ON HEALTH CARE
COULD BE. I'M INCREASED TO A
LEVEL THAT WAS ADEQUATE TO THEM
AND TO BE RETURNED TO THE STATE.
SO I DON'T THINK YOU HEAR FROM
THE COMMENTS OF THE MEMBERS.
ANYTHING THAT SAYS WE DO NOT
WANT TO FULFILL WHAT WE ARE
OBJECTING TO IS.
IN APOLOGIES FOR THE USE OF
THIS LANGUAGE BUT BLANK CHECKS
TO AND COST OVER IT SO IF WHAT
YOU'RE STATING IS THAT. THE.
.
YOUR ENTITY HAS HAD A ROLE IN
THE APPROVAL OR THE MANAGEMENT
OF THESE CONTRACTS.
WE DO NOT
OKAY EARNING. WE DO MONITOR US
ALL TO CONSTRUCT OUT COST
OVERRUNS
AS I UNDERSTAND AND AND I'M I'M
NOT SEAKING TO OUT. ALL I'M
SAYING IS AND THAT WE DO MONITOR
THESE PROGRAMS EXTENSIVELY AND
WE WOULD BE CONCERNED ABOUT ANY
ANYTHING THAT WOULD CAUSE
FURTHER DELAYS THE PROGRAM
BECAUSE WE ALSO ARE CONCERNED
ABOUT THAT.
AND JUSTICE AND MONEY. UNDER SET
RANDOMLY FOR AND IF BY THE VERY
COMMUNICATION OF THAT.
IT'S IN EFFECT SAYING TO ANY
CONTRACTOR YOU MAY CONTINUE TO
SPEND MONEY.
I.
IN IT'S JUSTIFIED BECAUSE
SOMEHOW YOU COMMUNICATE THAT
WOULD AVOID DELAYS.
SO WE WANT TO BE CAREFUL
FOREHEAD UNDERVALUED I WANT TO
GET TO PROJECTS COMPLETED ON
YEAH. YES.
YOU DID NOT DO THAT.
RIGHT THERE TWO YEARS BEHIND
MARIE SO DON'T TELL ME I WANT TO
DELAY THE PROJECT I'M NOT THE
ONE THAT WANTS TO DELAY THE
PROJECT. I WANT THIS SYSTEM FIX
SO YOU CAN DELIVER THE PROJECTS
FASTER.
AND YOU'RE ALREADY MAKING
MISTAKES AND BECAUSE IN TWO
YEARS OF DELAY ON THESE PROJECTS.
AND I AGREE WITH YOU THE THE.
WE WANT TO GET OUT FROM OF THE.
THE.
RECEIVERSHIP THAT'S PART OF OUR
OUR GOAL OR MISSION.
BUT.
DON'T SAY THAT WERE CAUSING
DELAY.
WHEN ACTUAL DELAY WAS CAUSED BY.
THE PEOPLE WORKING IN MANAGING
THIS PROJECT
THEY'RE THE ONES THAT CAUSES
DELAYED NOT OF US BUT INTRODUCED
LATER I UNDERSTAND MISS OKAY SO
THAT'S WHICH GET THAT CLEAR.
AND SO WE'RE TRYING TO FIND OUT
WHY THAT HAPPENED.
AND HOW WE CAN KEEP IT FROM
HAPPENING AGAIN.
AND AND WE CONCUR THAT ANY ANY
DELAYS NEED TO BE INVESTIGATED
AND AND YOU TO BE ADDRESSED.
OVERHEAD.
.
I THINK THE FRUSTRATING PART OF
BEING ON THIS.
IT'S HAVING A MEMBER WHO
REQUESTED INFORMATION FOR THE
MEETING THAT WOULD BE PERTINENT
TO THIS MEETING.
AND WE ARE THE LATE.
BECAUSE YOU HAVEN'T OFFERED THE
PROPER INFORMATION AFTER HAVING
REQUESTED.
IF YOU CAN'T GET IT TO OURS
TO COME BACK IN IN FOR THE FIRST
THAT WE'RE DELAYING THIS IN ANY
WAY SHAPE OR FORM.
IS IS INCORRECT.
ANY PUBLIC COMMENT ON THE ITEM.
ALRIGHT THANK YOU WILL NOW MOVE
TO THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.
AND IT'S ISSUE FIFTEEN THE
BUREAU OF ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE.
AND I BELIEVE.
WE HAVE.
.
ANGELES EUROPE.
FROM.
OUR.
DOJ'S OFFICE WHO WILL BE
PRESENTING.
CHIEF ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL.
THANK YOU IN.
GREAT.
MAY JOIN US AT THE TABLE AND.
.
IN YOUR COLLEAGUE CAN ALSO
INTRODUCE THEMSELVES. AND THIS
IS ON THE BUREAU OF
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ISSUE
FIFTEEN.
MARIO DIBERNARDO LEGISLATIVE
ADVOCATE FOR THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL.
GOOD AFTERNOON. ANGELES SIERRA
AND THE CHIEF ASSISTANT ATTORNEY
GENERAL AT THE CALIFORNIA
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE. AND I
OVERSEE OUR PUBLIC RIGHTS
DIVISION. OF MEN AND WITHIN OUR
DIVISION IS BOTH OUR
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SECTION AND
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S.
VERY RECENTLY ESTABLISHED
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE BUREAU.
SO THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR GIVE ME
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY
ABOUT OUR NEW BUREAU IT AND TO
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THAT YOU
MAY HAVE WITH RESPECT TO OF THE
BUDGET REQUEST THAT SENATOR BEEN
WEST SO IN ASSEMBLY MEMBER
EDUARDO GARCIA. HAVE RECENTLY
MET MADE TO SUPPORT AND EXPAND
THE BUREAU.
FACE HAVE SOME BRIEF COMMENTS
AND THEN I'M HERE TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS THAT YOU MAY HAVE.
COME IN CALIFORNIA FAR TOO MANY
FAMILIES HAVE INJURED MY
DISTRICT DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE
OF ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION.
COMMUNITIES WHERE THESE FAMILIES
LIVED TYPICALLY LACK THE
RESOURCES TO INVESTIGATE OR
LITIGATE CASES THAT WOULD
ADDRESS THOSE ENVIRONMENTAL
CONCERNS
AND TO IMPROVE THEIR HEALTH.
THESE ISSUES ARE OFTEN LONG
STANDING THERE COMPLEX.
AND THEY CAN REQUIRE SIGNIFICANT
TIME A RESOURCES TO BOTH
IDENTIFY AND TO ADDRESS THEM.
SO TO HELP BRING JUSTICE TO
THESE COMMUNITIES ATTORNEY
GENERAL HOBBY ARE BUT SERA LAST
FEBRUARY ESTABLISHED OR
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE BUREAU
WITHIN OUR UNBUTTONED VARMINT
LAW SECTION AT THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE.
THE BUREAU'S MISSION IS TO
PROTECT THE COMMUNITIES THAT
ENTER A DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE
OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION
THROUGH INVESTIGATION AND
LITIGATION RELATED TO VIOLATION
OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAW.
THE BUREAU INTENDS TO USE THE
LAW ENFORCEMENT POWERS OF OUR
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO
IDENTIFY AND PURSUE THESE
MATTERS AFFECTING THE
COMMUNITIES THAT ARE ON THE
FRONT LINES OF POLLUTION HERE IN
CALIFORNIA.
AND IN ADDITION WHERE RESOURCES
PERMIT THE ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
BUREAU INTENDS TO WORK
COLLABORATIVELY WITH COMMUNITY
ORGANIZATIONS AND LOCAL AND
STATE AGENCIES.
EMPLOYMENT ADDITIONAL.
ENFORCEMENT DIRECTIVES.
CURRENTLY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
HAS SHIFTED RESOURCES TO BRING A
HANDFUL OF ATTORNEYS TO THE
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE BUREAU.
AS I MENTIONED BOTH SENATOR
BENNETT WEST SO IN ASSEMBLY
MEMBER EDUARDO GARCIA HAVE MADE
BUDGET REQUEST TO SUPPORT AND
EXPAND OUR BUREAU.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL SUPPORTS
THIS EFFORT.
AND WE ASK THAT YOU APPROVE THIS
VERY IMPORTANT BUDGET REQUEST.
AND IF ANY QUESTIONS I'D BE
HAPPY TO ANSWER COAST.
SO.
WAS THERE.
AT.
YEAH.
SO.
I'M ACTUALLY.
YEAH.
ALLEN.
THAT'S CORRECT ON THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL SAW THE NEED ON FOR THE
BUREAU AND IS VERY COMMITTED TO
THIS ISSUE AND SO HE HAD
REDIRECTED EXISTING SOURCES
RESOURCES WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT
OF JUSTICE. TO ESTABLISH THE
BUREAU SO RIGHT NOW IT'S
RELATIVELY. SMALL IS THE
BEGINNING OF THE BUREAU AND THEY
HAVE WE HAVE THREE ATTORNEYS AND
SUPERVISING ATTORNEY SO FOR.
ATTORNEYS IN TOTAL. AND WITH
THE ADDITIONAL. FUNDING IF THE
LEGISLATURE APPROVES IT WE WOULD
BE EXPANDING THE BUREAU TO A
TOTAL OF EIGHT ATTORNEYS SEVEN
LINE ATTORNEYS WITH THE
SUPERVISOR INVESTIGATOR AND A
COMPLEMENT OF SEKITORI
SECRETARIAL STAFF.
AS WELL.
SO I'M.
I A I DON'T HAVE A FUNDAMENTAL.
PROBLEM WITH REQUESTS BUT I.
IT JOB.
WHEN WE LOOKED AT THE AREAS
WHERE ENFORCEMENT ACTION IS
NEEDED. DUE TO EITHER.
TOXIC ISSUES OR A VARIETY OF
OTHER.
.
VIOLATIONS IN TERMS OF OUR
ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS.
KISSED YOU CHIU WHERE MANY OF
THESE TYPE OF FACILITIES ARE
LOCATED. THEY ALMOST ALL ARE
LOCATED IN AREAS THAT FOR.
ALL JUST USE THE CALENDAR BY
ROSE SCREEN WITH THE MOMENT AS
OUR.
.
EACH TENDS TO BE IT IS BEEN USED
BY. MANY ADMIN AND MANY BUREAUS
IN THE STATE OR DEPARTMENTS IN
THE STATE AS THEIR.
LANDS FOR DETERMINING AN
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE AREA I'M
NOT SAYING THAT THAT IS
NECESSARILY THE BEST DETERMINER
OF ALL ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
SERIOUS BUT IS BEEN USED BUT IF
WE LOOK AT.
WHERE? A LOT OF THESE.
.
VIOLATIONS OCCURRED THEY
OVERLAP SO THERE EVEN BEFORE
THERE WAS AN ENVIRONMENTAL
JUSTICE BUREAU. THE AG'S OFFICE
HAD ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITY
AND CLEARLY MOST OF THEIR
ENFORCEMENT WOULD.
HAVE BEEN.
IN THOSE AREAS
SO HOW DID THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE DEAL WITH FULFILLING
THIS BEFORE THE ESTABLISHMENT OF
THIS BUREAU.
WELL THE.
THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT USES
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SECTION YOUR
CRACK IS VERY BROAD MISSION
AND THESE ISSUES DO OVER THEY DO
OVERLAP AS THIS IS A.
RESPONSIBLE USE ONLY FOR
INVESTIGATION ENFORCEMENT OF
AREAS WHERE THERE'S BEEN
VIOLATIONS
AND I'M SURE IF WE. ASK FOR THE
DATA WE WOULD SEE THAT THE VAST
MAJORITY OF VIOLATIONS HAVE ALL.
OCCURRED IN.
THAT IF WE DIDN'T OVERLAP IN A
MAP THAT ON IN WHAT'S ALSO. BE
IN VIRUS SCREEN AREAS.
IT TOOK TO TO SOME EXTENT THERE
IS THERE IS IN THE OVERLAP AND
OUR ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SECTION
HAS ENGAGED IN THIS TYPE OF WORK.
NO MATTERS THAT.
OUR OFFICE HAS REVIEWED AND
INVESTIGATED AND TAKEN A
FORCEFUL ACTIONS IN THE PAST
EVEN PRIOR TO THE STEPS TO MOVE
BUREAU HAVE IMPACTED AND HAVE.
ADDRESSED ISSUES IN COMMUNITIES
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
COMMUNITIES FORESHORE ARM ARE A
BIT OUR ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
SECTION THOUGH OUR OUR. MISSION
FOR THE SECTION IS VERY BROAD
AND WE ALSO ARE.
DOING QUITE A BIT OF WORK THAT
HAS STATEWIDE IMPACT.
AND.
HAS AND WE WANT TO CONTINUE TO
DO THAT TO DO A VAST ARRAY OF
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW PROJECTS AND
ACTIONS AND. ENGAGE ON AMICUS
BRIEFS ON LEGAL ISSUES THAT
IMPACT A VERY BROAD BROAD ISSUES
ENVIRONMENTAL LAW. AND THE IDEA
WITH ESTABLISHING THE BUREAU WAS
PISSED
HAVE YOU MAY BE A KEENER FOCUS
OR A MORE DIRECT FOCUS ON THE
PARTICULAR ISSUES.
ON THE VAT OR AFFECTING
COMMUNITIES THAT DO HAVE A
DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE OF
ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION AND TO
REALLY THINK. ARM AS A BUS LEE
AND CREATIVELY AS TO WHAT TYPE
OF.
ACTIONS WHAT TYPE OF WORK WOULD
BE MOST IMPACTFUL FOR THOSE AREA.
SO WE ARE NOT CHANGING A SAY THE
TYPE OF WORK WE'RE DOING AND
BOTH HER ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
SECTION AND OUR ENVIRONMENTAL
JUSTICE BUREAU WEREN'T FORESEEN
THE STATE AND FEDERAL
ENVIRONMENTAL FOX WE'RE NOT
CHANGING THAT. BUT THE BUREAU IS
GOING TO HAVE IS HAS A SLIGHTLY
DIFFERENT FOCUS AND LOOKING AT
THIS ONE SUBSET
OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT. IN AGAIN ON
DETERMINING.
HOW WE CAN MAKE THE MOST IMPACT
IN THAT AREA?
I JUST HAVE ONE OR TWO MORE
QUESTIONS AND THEN I'LL HAVE
SENATOR BILL. SO ONE OF THE
ISSUES ONGOING OF CONCERN BY THE
PUBLIC IN LEGISLATURES BANG.
FIVE.
DTS SEES.
VARIOUS VIOLATIONS THAT HAVE
OCCURRED THAT DGSE HAS ISSUED
BUT THERE HASN'T NECESSARILY
BEEN ENFORCEMENT ACTION TAKEN
NOW OF COURSE.
THE AG'S OFFICE DOESN'T TAKE
ENFORCEMENT ACTION UNTIL ANY
UNTIL ONE OF OUR AGENCIES BRINGS
IT TO THEM.
AND.
.
SO I'M CURIOUS GOING FORWARD HOW
THE BUREAU INTERACT WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCES
CONTROL.
WELL IN THE.
BUREAU LIKE THE ENTIRE SECTION
WILL BE CONTINUING TO COLLATERAL
COOPERATE AND WORK WITH THE DTS
HE AND OTHER. CLIENT AGENCIES
THAT ENGAGE IN THIS AREA. BUT
THE BUREAU.
AS DOES THE ENVIRONMENT LAS
SECTION WILL BE ALSO VERY MUCH
LOOKING AT INDEPENDENT ATTORNEY
GENERAL.
ACTIONS
AND SO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS
HIS OWN WORRIES DE RETIREES
WOULD NOT TO BE AGAINST
INDEPENDENT ACTIONS BUT BECAUSE.
THERE'S.
MANY COMMUNITIES HAVE BEEN VERY
FRUSTRATED ON THE MULTI MEAN
MULTI MULTI MULTI
YOU'RE EFFORT WHERE. A.
A VIOLATOR IS BEEN IDENTIFIED
THEIR SERIOUS POLLUTION GOING ON
AND NO ACTION IS TAKEN TO REMEDY
IT.
SO I GUESS WHAT I'M RAISING IS
THAT WHILE I CAN SEE AN INTEREST
IN THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE
TO IDENTIFYING OTHER AREAS TO
LOOK AT. I THINK THE.
THE PUBLIC WOULD VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE.
MORE ON STRENGTH IN.
ENFORCE ROUND THOSE AREAS THAT
ARE IDENTIFIED.
AND FOR WHICH FEE PEOPLE FEEL
FRUSTRATED WERE ACTION IS NOT
TAKEN AND I COULD CITE A BUNCH
OF CASES BUT I.
WE'VE AT THAT RIGHT NOW THEIR
WELL KNOWN.
AND THE THE INTENTION FOR THE
BUREAU.
AS WELL AS THE ENTIRE SECTION IS
TO WORK AS CLOSELY AS WE CAN
INTO USE AS MUCH OF THE
INFORMATION THAT IS OUT THERE.
AND TO WORK WITH THESE AGENCIES
ARM AGAIN BECAUSE WE DO WANT TO
ADDRESS THE NEED THERE'S OUT
THEIR FRUSTRATIONS THAT ARE OUT
THERE. SO THAT WE CAN MAKE AN
IMPACT IN YOU KNOW HAVING A UNIT
OR BUREAU DEVOTED TO THIS ISSUE
CAN ONLY. HELP THAT EFFORT AND
ENHANCE IT UP FOR.
I'M SENATOR BELT.
O. SO ARE YOU USING THE
ENVIRONMENT VIRAL SCREEN.
TO DETERMINE.
AREAS THAT HAVE A
DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE.
OF ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION.
OUR YOU DETERMINING THOSE AREAS
WOULD PROCESS.
YOU NO WE HAVE I MEAN WHERE IS
NO ONE PROCESS WE LOOK AT A
VARIETY OF TOOLS AND INFORMATION
THE ENVIRO SEEING OWNER YOU
WONDERED VIRAL SCREEN IS ONE OF
THE. BOSSES ONE AT ONE OF THE
TOOLS PROGRAM ARE LIMITED TO
THAT AND.
ON THEIR VARIETY OF WAYS THAT
OUR OFFICE IN CAN CONSULTING
INTERNALLY AND ANALYZING REAL
HOST WELL YOU NEED IS A.
HE'S BEEN GIVING LISTA HOW TO DO
THAT. I KNOW I DON'T HAVE A REAL
I DON'T HAVE AN EXHAUSTIVE LIST
AND AGAIN WILL BE AS WELL.
YEAH A FEW OF ARMOR.
HE SAID IN VIRAL SCREEN WAS ONE
OF A VIRUS RAIN A LOT OF IT AND
TO THE EXTENT THAT WE DO A LOT
OF POWER REACH WAS STAKEHOLDERS
AND INFORMATION FROM THERE'S.
SCIENTISTS AND OTHER ON SUBJECT
MATTER EXPERTS WITH IN THE STATE
IT AGENCIES AS WELL AS WELL AS
WORKING WITH OUR STAKEHOLDERS IN
MAKING DETERMINATIONS AS TO
WHICH PARTICULAR COMMUNITY IN
WHICH ISSUE WE THINK WE SHOULD
ENGAGE. IS REALLY A CASE BY CASE
ON DETERMINATION AND IS PART OF
OUR INVESTIGATORY PROCESS WHICH
WE ARE WE DON'T TYPICALLY. ON
DISCUSS
PUBLICLY ME WE OBVIOUSLY SOME
THINGS ARE SOME VERY GENERAL
THINGS THAT WE CAN DO AS I
MENTIONED LOOKING UP VIRUS GREEN
OR WORKING WITH STAKEHOLDERS.
BUT WE DON'T LIKE IN VIRAL
SCREEN THAT'S WILL SEE THAT.
THERE WERE NOT MOVEMENT WERE
WERE WERE WHERE THE BAY AREA
FEELS IT DISCRIMINATES.
WE HAVE A CAUCUS POSITION IN THE
VERY CAUCUS THAT.
AND REYES SCREEN DOESN'T WORK.
IT'S OF A NEGATIVE THING WHEN
YOU TALK ABOUT THAT AND.
THE BAY AREA BECAUSE.
ARM.
IT DISCRIMINATES AGAINST THE BAY
AREA.
BASICALLY IT'S UNFAIR
DISCRIMINATION.
SO WE WE REJECT DOT.
AND AGAIN OVER LOOKING AT THE IT
OUT OF SILICON A DIE AND ARE
BECAUSE YES THE WHOLE CAUCUS ALL
THE BAY AREA LEGISLATORS.
THE PURPOSES OF THIS BUREAU
WHERE I KNOW WHAT YOU'RE GOING
TO USE IF YOU'RE GOING TO USE
THAT.
WE WANTYOU TO SAY THAT YOU'RE
GOING TO USE THAT AND IF YOU ARE
GOING TO USE THAT WE WANNA KNOW.
OF FLUID CAN DETERMINE HOW WE
WANT TO ACT ON YOUR MEASURE.
FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS BUREAU
WE'VE REFRAINED FROM USING THE
TERM DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITY ARE
CALAVERAS GREEN AS A RESTRICTOR
IT'S. DEFINITELY A BUT A TOOL
THAT THE STATE HAS USE BUT WE
RECOGNIZE THAT THERE ARE AREAS
OF THE STATE WITH LOW INCOME.
.
THAT.
HAVE A DISPROPORTIONATE.
SHARE OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL
POLLUTION THAT THEY EXPERIENCE
AND THAT'S THE PURPOSE OF THE
BUREAU.
IS SUIT TO FOCUS ON ALL
COMMUNITIES THAT EXPERIENCE THAT.
OKAY SO.
THESE ECONOMIC.
KIND OF VIRUS GREEN IN
INSTITUTES.
LAYERING OF.
ISSUES AND ONE OF THEM IS THE.
THE POVERTY RATE. CONCENTRATION
OF POVERTY IN THAT KIND OF.
AND AND.
AS YOU KNOW THE BAY AREA.
OR THE LAST.
SEVERAL YEARS AND MANY OF THE
BAY AREA THERE'S BEEN ATTEMPT TO.
SCATTER.
.
POVERTY THROUGHOUT COMMUNITIES
ANNIE INTEGRATE.
YOU NO THE DIVERSITY OF THE
COMMUNITY BY.
SCATTERING.
LOW INCOME HOUSING BUSINESS
STRATEGY FOR LIKE FOUR YEARS.
SO WE'VE BEEN SUCCESSFUL ON IT.
OVER WHEN THEY PROPOSED
ENVIRONMENT SCREEN.
WHAT THE RESULT HAS BEEN THAT?
IS.
IT PROMOTES.
.
SERVICES AND PROGRAMS AND STATE
FUNDING AND SO FORTH. IN AREAS
THAT ARE SEGREGATED THAT DID NOT
ATTEMPT TO SCATTER. AND DO
INTEGRATION SO SO THE PEOPLE
THAT THE GOOD STUFF.
GOT PENALIZED IN EFFECT.
BY A.
IT TEMPTING TO INTEGRATE THEIR
COMMUNITIES OF YOU WAS IT THAT
WAY.
OKAY.
I'M JUST YOU KNOW.
I MEAN YOU KNOW OVER FOR BUT IT
TAKES TIME TO DO INTEGRATION.
SO IF YOU LOOK AT.
POPULATION AND.
.
SAN JOSE THERE'S STILL.
VESTIGES OF LOW INCOME AREAS BUT
FOR THE MOST PART.
THE.
LOW INCOME POPULATION OF SAN
JOSE.
IS NOT IN THOSE AREAS IT'S
SPREAD AROUND THE WHOLE CITY.
OKAY.
THAT'S THAT'S THE TRUTH
AUDITOR'S ASSOCIATE KNOWLEDGE
AND I THINK IN A. LOT OF THE
OTHER.
VERY COMMUNITIES THAT'S KIND OF
THE AND IT TOOK A LOT OF WORK TO
DO THAT.
SO OF.
I WANT TO KNOW IF YOU'RE USING
NEW VIRAL STRAIN AT ALL THAT'S.
SO A WE DON'T WE CENTER IN THE
IN THE CREATION OF THE THE
BUREAU THE ATTORNEY GENERAL HAS
BEEN VERY BROAD. AND INTENDS TO.
ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS LOOK AT
WHERE THEIR ENVIRONMENTAL
VIOLATIONS THAT AFFECT
COMMUNITIES.
THAT SHARE A DISPROPORTIONATE.
SHARE OF ENVIRONMENTAL
POLLUTION SO THE RING WITH THEM.
NO WE'RE NOT AGAINST THEM THAT'S
NETWORK THAT'S IMPORTANT.
IF YOU GO IN IN IN IN THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S STATEMENTS ON
AS HE'S BEEN. CLEARED TO FOCUS
ON THE BROADER SENSE OF WHAT AN
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE COMMUNITY
IS AND HAS AN NARROWLY FOCUSED
ON WHAT A TERM.
ART MAY BE ALL ON THIS MATTER.
WE'RE JUST COMMUNICATE WITH YOU
ABOUT.
THERE'S SOME STRONG FEELINGS
ABOUT THOSE.
IN A BAY AREA LIKE.
IN ESSENCE THE POOR PEOPLE IN
THE BAY AREA ARE NOT TREATED THE
SAME AS OTHER OTHER AREAS SIMPLY
BECAUSE ARE SCATTERED AROUND.
AND WE'VE WE'VE RECOGNIZE THAT
INTERNALLY HERE HAVE A LOT OF
POOR PEOPLE THAT ARE SCATTERED
AROUND. THEY'RE NOT.
SEGREGATED LIKE SOME AREAS ARE.
WELL ADDITIONALLY.
.
AND SO I BOTH.
AND GLAD I BROUGHT WITH BUT
NOTHING I SEE THE LOGIC IN
GREATER.
BECAUSE ADDITIONALLY THE OTHER
PERSON IN ADDITION TO THE.
THE SCATTERING AN NOT IT THE
LACK OF A CONCENTRATION IN SOME
CASES THERE'S ALSO. THAT.
ALL THE FACTORS THAT THE ENVIRO
SCREEN USES CAN
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACT SO.
IN.
IN THE BAY AREA THERE ME THERE
IS NOT AN ALL PLACES BUT IN
GENERAL MORE OPEN SPACE BECAUSE
THERE'S BEEN A REAL DEDICATION
TO CREATE.
INVEST IN PUBLIC OPEN SPACE
THERE SAW HIGHER WATER QUALITY.
AND BY AND LARGE AND VARIOUS
THINGS LIKE THAT WHICH THEN
SCORE DOWN. THOSE SAME
COMMUNITIES WHO OTHERWISE ARE
FOR EXAMPLE YET RIGHT NEXT TO A
REFINERY OR RIGHT NEXT TO A
SUPPORT FOR RIGHT NEXT TO A.
VERY POLLUTING INDUSTRY OR IN
ANY NUMBER OF OTHER FACTORS BUT
THEN THEY DON'T GET ADEQUATELY.
COUNTED SO THAT IS THE
SENSITIVITY TOWARDS THE IN VIRUS
SCREEN HELENA'S.
IT'S NOT THIS NOT.
A STATEMENT AGAINST QUORUM
QUOTE AND FIREMEN JUSTICE I
THINK PEOPLE REALIZE THAT HAS TO
BE DONE BUT. I THINK IT'S A.
IT.
WHERE WE WE DON'T WANT POOR
PEOPLE?
THAT NEED ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
THAT HAPPEN TO LIVE IN THE
SCATTERED KIND OF COMMUNITIES TO
BE TREATED.
UNFAIRLY.
YOU KNOW THAT'S.
IT'S KIND OF WHAT I WOULD SAY
SOLELY VIA A YOU KNOW AS LONG AS
YOU'RE.
OF ABLE TO UNDERSTAND OR MAKE
SURE YOU'RE CRITERIA OR WHATEVER.
THAT'S NOT INCLUDED.
AND VIRUS SCREEN I THINK WE'RE
OKAY.
AND I WOULD JUST ADD THAT.
I REALLY HOPE THAT THERE IS IF
THIS EFFORT GOES FORWARD IN THE
FUNNIES THAT THERE IS A MUCH
STRONGER.
INTERACTION WITH OUR REGULATORY
AGENCIES
SO THAT WE GET BETTER
ENFORCEMENT BECAUSE.
WELL I DIDN'T STATE.
A SPECIFIC EXAMPLES ONE CAN JUST
NEEDS TO GOOGLE ELECTRO FORMING
OR EXCITE TECHNOLOGIES OR
CHEMICAL AND PICNIC COMPANY TO
SEE THAT. THERE WERE I MEAN
WE'RE TALING IN SOME CASES TEN
FIFTEEN AND UP TO TWENTY YEARS
OF CITATIONS ON THESE FACILITIES.
AND NO ENFORCEMENT ACTION OR
MINIMAL ENFORCEMENT ACTION EVER
TAKEN SO THE COMMUNITIES NEARBY
AFFECTED WERE IT WAS QUITE
SEVERE.
SO I WOULD HOPE THAT. THIS WOULD
NOT JUST BE.
A.
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS DEAR G.
SOUGHT OUT ON THEIR OWN BUT
THOSE THAT OTHER AGENCIES HAVE
IDENTIFIED. AND.
NOT I'M NOT SAYING THAT THE DOJ
NEEDS TO DO OUR OTHER AGENCIES
WORK BUT PERHAPS A STRONGER
PARTNERSHIP. WOULD.
ADD SOME.
EITHER TEETH OR MOTIVATION TO
THOSE AND.
DEPARTMENTS LIKE DTS SEED THAT
HAVE NOT BEEN AS RESPONSIVE.
ALRIGHT SO PUBLIC COMMENT ON
THIS ITEM.
ALRIGHT.
WE'RE HOLDING IT OPEN. AND.
A LOT OF THE ITEMS THAT WERE
MEMBER REQUESTS WE DID HOLD OPEN
SO THAT AND THAT.
OBVIOUSLY WILL CONTINUE THAT
DISCUSSION AND NOW WILL GO TO
OUR LAST ITEM WHICH IS ISSUE
SIXTEEN.
IT'S DOJ THE CIVIL RIGHTS AND
SEX
EQUITY IN EDUCATION ENFORCEMENT.
GO AHEAD ANGELA.
HILL.
SO.
THIS.
I'M HERE THINK YOU AGAIN.
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT
YOU MAY HAVE WITH RESPECT TO.
AS INTERCESSOR SENATOR
JACKSON'S PROPOSAL.
TO PROVIDE FUNDING THING IN ITS
ONE POINT NINE MILLION DOLLARS
TO THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.
OB TO ADDRESS ISSUES OF SEXUAL
HARASSMENT AND SEXUAL ASSAULT OF
THE GENDER EQUITY ISSUES IN
EDUCATION.
AND.
ARE.
JUST GO AND BRIEF REMARKS ABOUT
THIS.
WORD THE LEGISLATURE TO.
ALLOCATE IMPROVE THIS FUNDING.
ON WE HAVE BEEN THINKING
INTERNALLY AT THE DEPARTMENT
JUSTICE YOU KNOW WAYS THAT WE
COULD MAXIMIZE THE USE OF THIS
OF THIS FUNDING FOR THIS PURPOSE
AGAIN ON THIS ISSUE TO HAVE A.
THAT IMPACT ON THE ISSUE OF WE.
ARM OUR THOUGHTS HORROR THAT IF
THE LEGISLATURE DOES APPROVE
THIS FUNDING IT WOULD BE
PRIMARILY BEING HANDLED BY OUR
CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT SECTION
WHICH IS ALSO PART OF OUR PUBLIC
RIGHTS DIVISION. ON DOES QUITE A
BIT OF.
INDEPENDENT WORK FOR THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL BEHALF OF THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL. AND.
WE IN THE CIVIL RIGHTS
ENFORCEMENT SECTION. ARM
GENERALLY HAVE A VERY BROAD
MISSION. AS TO.
TYPES OF CIVIL RIGHTS ISSUES
THAT WE HAVE ON HOW LONG HISTORY
OF BEING INVOLVED IN.
EDUCATIONAL ISSUES.
IS AMONG THOSE.
WE ALSO HAVE A LONG HISTORY OF
ENGAGING AND.
AND ANTI ATTACKING AN ISSUE IN
A NUMBER OF FRONTS WEATHERED BE
EDUCATION AND OUTREACH
INVESTIGATIONS.
WORKING COLLABORATIVELY WITH
YOU OR YOUR BUSINESS IS OUR
GOVERNMENT ENTITIES TO.
IMPLEMENT AND DESIGN AND
IMPLEMENT REFORMS OR BRING
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS WE NEEDED.
AND THAT ALSO TO ENGAGE IN THE
POLL WERE AMICUS BRIEF ON.
.
IMPORTANT CIVIL RIGHTS ISSUES
SO WERE READ TO.
.
BE PROVIDED WITH THIS ADDITIONAL
FUNDING OF OUR VIEW IS THAT WE
WOULD BE ABLE TO STAFF UP.
AND REALLY TARGET.
SOME OF OUR RESOURCES AND.
PERSPECTIVE ON THIS ISSUE OF
THE SEXUAL HARASSMENT SEXUAL
ASSAULT ON ON OR OFF CAMPUS BUT
THAT ARE BEING.
.
DIRECTED AT STUDENTS.
AND.
THOUGH YOU KNOW WHERE WHERE
THAT.
SP WAS WHEN SIXTEEN NINE WAS.
DOT PASSED LAST YEAR THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL ALREADY HAS ON.
ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY OVER
ISSUES.
THESE ISSUES AND INVESTIGATORY
AUTHORITY IS WELL WHICH WE WOULD
BE ABLE TO TAP INTO.
AND.
WITH THE AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT
IS A PART CURRENTLY BEING
PROPOSED.
WE ARE ANTICIPATING THAT WE
WOULD BE ABLE TO.
HIRE ANOTHER SUPERVISOR TO RE
OR FOUR ATTORNEYS ALMA LEGAL
ANALYST A THREE LEGAL ANALYST AS
WELL AS PROGRAM ANALYST. AND
THEN HAVE THE COMPLEMENT OF
SECRETARIAL ON SUPPORT FOR THAT
STAFFING.
AND.
START LOOKING AT ISSUES ARE
BEING MORE FOCUSED ON ISSUES ON
WITH RESPECT TO OUR. FOR EXAMPLE
UNIVERSITIES.
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS ARE
THEY COMPLYING WITH STING
FEDERAL LAW WITH RESPECT TO THE
POLICIES AND PRACTICES
SURROUNDING BOTH PREVENTION OF
SEXUAL HARASSMENT AND SEXUAL
ASSAULT AS WELL AS. THEIR
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS AND THEIR
INVESTIGATORY REQUIREMENTS ARM
ON THESE ISSUES.
AND YOU WITH THE GOAL OF NOT.
WE WOULDN'T AS THE DEPARTMENT
JUSTICE WE WOULD NOT BE
REPRESENTING INDIVIDUALS ARE
HANDLING INDIVIDUAL CASES.
WE WOULD BE TYPICALLY LOOKING
FOR RECEIVING AND I'M REVIEWING
COMPLAINTS AND THEN DETERMINING
WHEN TO ENGAGE IN LOOKING
PRIMARILY WHERE WE THINK THERE
MAY BE SOME SYSTEMATIC ISSUES.
THAT NO WE CAN HELP TACKLE AND
HELP MAKES AN IMPROVEMENT.
I'M SO MY COMMENT WOULD BE I
KNOW THAT ARE A COLLEAGUE THE
SENATOR FROM SANTA BARBARA HAS.
FOCUSES REQUEST ON HIGHER ED
CERTAINLY TITLE NINE COVERS MORE
THAN HIGHER ED. AND.
WHILE ON THE THE INCIDENTS IN
HIGHER ED GET A LOT OF MEDIA
ATTENTION WE KNOW THAT. THEY ARE
NOT THE ONLY TITLE NINE COVERED
AND ENTITIES THAT HAVE INCIDENTS
SO WE COMMITTEE MIGHT WANT TO
CONSIDER. WHETHER IF WE MOVE
FORWARD ON SUCH REQUEST.
BROADENING SO THAT IS NOT ONLY
HIGHER ED THAT ALL TITLE NINE.
AFFECTED ENTITIES.
RIGHT AND THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
MEDIA BOTH FEEL K. TO TWELVE
HAVE YOU KNOW VERY SIMILAR
REQUIREMENTS
AND. THERE IS NO QUITE A BIT IN
NEED RUN THAT FORMERLY WELL.
ANY OTHER COMMENT OR QUESTION
FROM MY COLLEAGUES WHO HAD
CENTER BELL OKAY ARMS.
MY AREA OF LEGISLATION I'VE
WORKED ON.
ROOM NUMBER YEARS ENTAILS SONG.
THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.
THAT EXISTS.
.
AND NAM THE STATUE LIMITATION
FOR CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE.
INABILITY OF PEOPLE TO FILE
CLAIMS.
ON THE STATUE OF LIMITATIONS SO.
.
AT THE PRESENT TIME A THE OF
STATUTE CALIFORNIA ALLOWS PEOPLE
TO FILE CLAIMS UP UNTIL THEY'RE.
TWENTY SEVENTH BIRTHDAY AND.
SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
IN CALIFORNIA HOWEVER.
HAVE INSTITUTED PROCEDURE.
TO ONLYALLOW PEOPLE TO FILE
CLAIMS.
WERE.
UNDER THE.
NORMAL CLAIMS PROCESS FOR SCHOOL
DISTRICTS.
ON.
CLAIMS AGAINST SCHOOL DISTRICTS
FOR SEXUAL ABUSE OF CHILDREN.
BY SCHOOL EMPLOYEES AND OTHER
PEOPLE OF APPROVED BY THE SCHOOL.
UNDER THE GOVERNMENT CLAIMS ACT
WHICH ONLY ALLOWS A SIX MONTH
PERIOD OF TIME AFTER THE
INCIDENT.
AFTER THE INCIDENT.
TO.
WOW CLAIM SO THE OTHER WORDS.
.
FROM MOM HAS.
.
THE DAUGHTER COMMAND WHEN SHE'S
TWELVE AND SAYS SOME HAPPEN.
SHE FINALLY TELLS MOM.
ONE DAY AFTER THE SIX MONTHS
EXPIRES.
THEY GO HAND THE SCHOOL DISTRICT
WILL REJECT THE CLAIM.
BECAUSE THE CLAIM WOULD BE THE
SIX MONTHS.
PLUS ONE DAY AND THAT'S.
PASSED THE DEADLINE.
SOLANA CLAIMS GET NOT APPROVED
OR DAY DON'T EVEN GET FILE
BECAUSE.
COURSES WE KNOW.
.
MAYBE THE ON THE OLD YOUNG GIRL
DOESN'T EVEN APPLY.
BECAUSE SHE YOU DON'T WANT TO
TALK ABOUT OTHER.
WHATEVER THE REASONS.
SO WE HAVE WE HAVE A BILL S. B.
TENET TEN FIFTY THREE.
THAT SAYS A LOT OF SCHOOLS.
AFTER THE.
.
THOUGH.
CURRENT CHILD ABUSE STATUE
LIMITATIONS
THE CAT LIMIT. THE CLAIMS TO SIX
MONTHS THEY CAN THEY HAVE TO.
ALLOW CLAIMS UP INTO.
THOUGH CURRENT LAW.
WHICH IS.
.
TO THE TWENTY SEVENTH BIRTHDAY.
CENTER SKINNER NINE OTHERS.
TO EXTEND THE TWENTY ASSEMBLY
BIRTDAY TO THE FORTY EIGHTH
YEAR OF SOMEBODY.
AND.
.
SO.
OF.
IT MIGHT BE A WISE THING TO
EXTEND THIS.
TO THE CAKE TWELVE.
SYSTEM BECAUSE OF SOME OF THE.
.
PROCEDURAL THINGS SCHOOL
DISTRICTS.
AND SCHOOLS ARE DOING.
RIGHT NOW AS WE SPEAK DENYING
CLAIMS.
OF OF.
KIDS THERE HAVE BEEN.
SEXUALLY.
.
ABUSED IN THE SCHOOLS.
AND THE CLAIMS HAVE BEEN DENIED.
AND AND.
.
THE BILL PASSED OUT OF THE
SENATE I THINK IT'S THE.
IN HOW MANY NEGATIVE VOTES.
WAS LIKE CO VOTED FOR.
YEAH SO I THINK EVERYBODY VOTED
FOR.
I DON'T BELIEVE.
I THINK WHO WAS UNANIMOUS
CORRECT YEAH MY STEPS AS IT WAS.
THE THE YOU EVERYBODY ATTENDED
SO MAYBE THIRTY EIGHT DID NOT
ZERO.
SO IT'S NOW AN ASSEMBLY BILLS
AND ASSEMBLY SO.
.
THIS AREA OF OF.
CHANGING THERE PROCEDURAL RULES
TO INHIBIT.
FAMILIES FROM FILING CLAIMS.
I THINK IS A.
SYSTEMATIC PROBLEM IN THE SCHOOL
SCHOOL SYSTEM.
N. AND THE THE.
.
WHAT A CALM THE?
THE LEGAL.
INSURANCE.
COMPANY THE INSURERS SCHOOLS.
HAVE ASKED THAT THIS BE
INSTITUTED IN OTHER THE ONE STEP.
HAVE PUSH THOSE FIXED YOUR YOU
CAN FALL THE GOVERNMENT CLAIMS
ACT.
SO SO I I JUST WANTED YOU TO BE
AWARE THIS.
THIS MAJOR PROBLEM THAT EXISTS
IN CALIFORNIA.
SO YOU THIS IS A MAJOR PROBLEM A
LOT OF. A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
GETTING JUSTICE.
A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE GETTING
JUSTICE LA CHILDREN ARE GIVEN TO
US AS THEIR CHILDREN.
SO SO.
I WOULD ASK YOU TO CONSIDER.
CHANGING THIS TO MAY BE APPLIED
TO K. TWELVE.
MAYBE LOOK INTO THAT PARTICULAR
SUBJECT.
ANY MY UNDERSTANDING WITH THIS
IS THAT WE WOULD HAVE A GREAT
AMOUNT OF FLEXIBILITY THAT WE
WOULDN'T BE THAT WE WOULD ONLY
YOU KNOW BE LIMITED TO LOOKING.
APPROACH.
HEARINGS CATIA
AND THAT WE WOULD HAVE A
FLEXIBILITY ABOUT THAT. AND YOU
KNOW TO YOUR POINT. OFTEN IN ARE
CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT SECTION
WHERE WE START OUT WITH A
PARTICULAR YOU NEVER SEEN A
PARTICULAR TYPE OF COMPLAINT YOU
KNOW WE'RE SEEING MULTI
COMPLAINTS IN THE SAME ISSUE.
YOU KNOW ONE OF THE THINGS THAT
WE LOOK AT IS OKAY DO WE DO WE
FEEL THAT IS SUPPORT IS EVIDENCE
SUPPORTING THAT COMPLAINT Y.
ISN'T EVEN HAPPENING OR WHAT IS
THE SYSTEMS IN PLACE. FOR.
BECAUSE YOU SAY WHETHER IT'S
CITIZEN COMPLAINTS OR CLAIMS AND
THEN WHAT IS THE AND WHAT ARE
THE METHODS OF. FOLLOW UP AND
ACCOUNTABILITY SO WE TEND TO
LOOK AT A PROBLEM VERY
HOLISTICALLY AND SO THAT TYPE OF
ISSUE WOULD BE THE TYPE OF THING.
THAT ARE OF CIVIL RIGHTS
ENFORCEMENT SECTION WOULD
TYPICALLY YOU KNOW BE VERY
INTERESTED IN.
YOU KNOW AND IN ULTIMATELY YOU
KNOW WE ARE LOOKING AT ARE THERE
VIOLATIONS OF THE LAW BUT WE CAN
ALSO.
TRIBUTE THAT EVEN IF A
PARTICULAR. MATTER PARTICULAR
METHOD OF OUR PROTOCOL IS A
VIOLATION LA MAYBE SOME BEST
PRACTICE AND THEN WE CAN WORK
WITH. YOU KNOW WHETHER IT'S
GOING TO BE AN ORDINANCE
LEGISLATION OR JUST AN INTERNAL
OUR POLICY WORK WITH.
THE ENTITY THAT WE ARE REVIEWING
TO TRY TO ENHANCE HIS PRACTICE
THIS IS A PROBLEM THAT.
HAS.
BEEN CREATED BY THE STATEWIDE
ORGANIZATION THAT INSURERS WILL
DISTRICTS.
OKAY SO IT'S MORE ABOUT.
AND WE HAVE NO IDEA HOW MANY
CLAIMS.
WOULD HAVE BEEN FILED.
AND HOW MANY KIDS THEIR VIEWS
WOULD HAVE FILED CLAIMS IF THEY
HAVE KNOWN THAT. THEY STILL HAVE
THE RIGHT. TO THEIR TWENTY
SEVENTH BIRTHDAY.
THE FILE PLANE WE DON'T KNOW.
BECAUSE THOSE SCHOOL DISTRICTS
ARE SAYING YOU KNOW FILE AND.
SIX SIX MONTHS.
YOU YOU'RE OUT OF LUCK.
AND SO LIKE.
AKE.
HOW MANY OTHER PEOPLE WOULD
WOULD?
FILE CLAIMS I DON'T KNOW.
BUT BUT.
I THINK IT'S AN ISSUE THAT.
IS A SYSTEMATIC ISSUE.
SO I THINK.
SO WE'RE WE'LL BE LOOKING AT
WAYS TO IMPROVE THE TRAILER BILL
LANGUAGE TO COVER OBVIOUSLY ALL.
I WISH A OFF THE COVER ALL TITLE
NINE ENTITIES.
BUT WE MAY. LOOK AT OTHER THINGS
ADDITIONALLY. THEY WERE GONNA
HOLD THIS ITEM THE CONCERNS OF SENATOR BELL
THOUGH IT MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED
BILL WHERE WE WOULD ADDRESS THE
SCHOOL ISSUE. MEANING THAT TIME
OF CLAIMS BUT WE WOULD CERTAINLY.
ADDRESS.
.
IF WE ALLOCATE FUNDING THAT
WHICH WE WOULD BE DIRECTING THE
A GS OFFICE TO UTILIZE THAT
FUNDING FOR. THE LET'S SEE IF
THERE'S ANY.
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THIS ITEM.
ALRIGHT SEEING NINE I THINK
THAT'S OUR LAST ITEM IT'S SO
HOLD OWN OPEN. PRESHEAF YOUR.
PRESENTATION. AND.
.
THAT WE WILL. ADJOURN OR PUBLIC
SAFETY COMMITTEE BUDGET SUB FIVE