APOLOGIZE ABOUT BEING DELAYED WE
HAVE FOR SEVERAL COMMITTEES
GOING ON ALL AT ONCE AT LET'S
TURN IT OVER TO CENTER BY CASKEY
ON SB THIRTEEN THIRTY THREE IS
FOR SECOND ITEM OF THE DAY WE
WELCOME YOU BACK TO COMMITTEE
SIR.
GOOD AFTERNOON AND NAM I I
REALIZE THERE'S A LOT OF YOUNG
CALIFORNIANS IN THE HALLWAYS
TODAY SO WITH. THE CALIFORNIA
CONSTITUTIONAL AUS CHARTER
CITIES A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT OF
AUTONOMY REGARDING LAND USE
REGULATION.
IN REGARDS TO MUNICIPAL AFFAIRS
CHARTER SEE CITIES OWNER PARA
CHARTER PROVISIONS OUR
ORDINANCES ARE CONTROLLING EVEN
WHEN THERE'S A CONFLICT WITH THE
CALIFORNIA STATE LAW THE
CONSTITUTION. HOWEVER MAKES AN
EXCEPTION FOR THIS ECONOMY WHEN
REGULATION IS A MATTER OF
STATEWIDE CONCERN BECAUSE OF THE
MAGIC WORDS TO STATE WHY
CONCERNS WERE ALL AWARE OF ARE.
THAT HOUSING AFFORDABILITY
CRISIS THAT'S A SPUR. CONTINUES
TO NAG AT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. I'M AND IT'S REACHED
A LEVEL OF STATEWIDE CONCERN SO
EXISTING LAW REQUIRES A CHARTER
CITY TO DEVELOP GENERAL PLAN.
DOESN'T REQUIRE THE CHARTER
CITY.
TO BE CONSISTENT WITH THE
GENERL PLAN SOON SP ONE THREE
THREE THREE CLOSES THIS LOOPHOLE
BY APPLYING STATE PLANNING AND
ZONING LAWS THE CHARTER CITIES
AND INSURERS THE CHARTER CITIES
ZONING ORDINANCES SPECIFIC PLANS
AND DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS ARE
CONSISTENT WITH THEIR PLANS. FOR
BOOK FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
OUTLINED IN THEIR HOUSING
ELEMENT SOME WITH ME IS SUCH A
HARD. TIME WHO'S WITH THE
WESTERN CENTER OF LAW AND
POVERTY OF BRIAN. AUGUSTA WHO IS
WITH THE CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL AND TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE ON THAT
CAN THE COMMISSION VERSUS THE
CITY OF HUNTINGTON BEACH.
OKAY CHAIRMAN WE WELCOME YOU
COMMITTEE THANK YOU FOR BEING
HERE AFTERNOON FOR TO MINUTES.
MY NAME SASHA HARD AND WITH THE
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
POVERTY AND WORK BECAUSE
SPONSORING SB THIRTEEN THIRTY
THREE. THIS BILL WOULD
CORRECTIVE RECENT APPELLATE
DECISION THAT HELD THAT A
CHARTER CITY CAN TAKE
DEVELOPMENT IN ZONING DECISIONS.
THAT ARE INCONSISTENT WITH ITS
ADOPTED HOUSING ELEMENT AND
STATED PLANS FOR ACCOMMODATING
ITS FAIR SHARE OF REGIONAL
HOUSING NEEDS.
THE BILL WOULD ENSURE ALL CITIES
PLAY BY THE SAME RULES WITH
RESPECT TO PLANNING WHILE
PRESERVING THE ABILITY TO TAYLOR
PLANS TO LOCAL CIRCUMSTANCES.
AS COURTS AND LEGISLATURE HAVE
ACKNOWLEDGED THROUGH DEVELOPMENT
OF HOUSING ELEMENT LAWS AND
OTHER PLANNING LAWS.
LOCAL ZONING AND DEVELOPMENT
DECISIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES THAT
REACH FAR BEYOND CITY
BOUNDARIES.
LOCAL DEVELOPMENT.
DECISIONS AFFECT COMPLEX
INTERRELATED REGIONAL SYSTEMS
WITH REGARDS TO TRANSPORTATION.
HOUSING NATURAL RESOURCES PUBLIC
UTILITIES AND THE LIKE.
AND THIS IS MADE ABUNDANTLY
CLEAR IN A RECENT STATE AUDIT
REGARDING HOMELESSNESS.
WHICH FOUND THAT THE STATE HAS
AN IMPORTANT ROLE TO PLAY IN
ADDRESSING NOT GROWING CRISIS
AND MUST DO MORE.
SO GIVEN OUR STATEWIDE HOUSING
SHORTAGE.
AND THE STATE'S INTEREST IN AND
ENSURING PROPER REGIONAL
PLANNING.
WE MUST ENSURE THE CITY'S FULL
UNIFORM PLANNING RULES AND SB
THIRTEEN THIRTY THREE ELIMINATES
AN ANTIQUATED TWO TIER SYSTEM.
WHERE ALL CITIES ARE REQUIRED
TO?
ENACT GENERAL PLANS WITH CERTAIN
ELEMENTS BUT ONLY SOME CITIES
ARE REQUIRED TO MAKE SURE THAT
THEIR DECISIONS ARE CONSISTENT
WITH THOSE PLANS.
SO FOR THAT REASON WE ARE CHEN
AYE VOTE ON SB THIRTEEN THIRTY
THREE THANK YOU.
HARKENS.
MANY OTHER WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
BERNIE GUEST ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IT'S BEEN
WELL STATED BY THE SENATOR. AND
MY COLLEAGUE AS TO THE NEED FOR
THE BILLS ARE JUST URGING AYE
VOTE THANK YOU.
YOU.
DOESN'T MATTER NOT LIGHTHOUSE
PUBLIC AFFAIRS HERE ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIAN. IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL THE.
HER CHILD DISABILITY RIGHTS
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT.
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION.
MANY OF MY COLLEAGUES WHEN A
TIME IN.
NDER Y. BECAUSE GOOD LIKE TO
CLOSE YES I THINK.
SP ONE THREE THREE THREE IS AS
NECESSARY FOR SOME CONSISTENCIES
AND EFFECTIVENESS OF THE HOUSING
OF LEGISLATION THAT WERE PASSING
HERE AND SEE MY.
THE PERFECT TIME I'D.
ACTORS MOTION AND THAT I WOULD
URGE AN AYE VOTE.
KATE WELL THEN.
.
I LET'S WAIT UNTIL WE GET SOME
COMMITTEE MEMBERS TO GET THE
MOTION AND THEN WILL VOTE THANK
YOU. THANK YOU.
BUT AT SAID THAT ZERO ZERO ZERO
ON CALL.
LET'S FIND OUT.
.
JEFF.
I WANNA TALK TO MYSELF I DO THAT
ENOUGH THANKS FOR ASKING
RICHARD.
WHO WERE WAITING FOR?
SENATOR HERTZBERG.
ADRIN YOU WANNA GIVE HIM A CALL.
PLEASE
CLEARLY THIS
.
CRITICS.
PLACE IN GERMANY WERE WELCOME
THE MAN THE MYTH THE LEGEND FROM
ORANGE COUNTY HERE.
WE WILL CONSIDER MORE LOT.
SOONER AT WE WELCOME YOU TO THE
DICE HE'S GOING TO PRISON AND
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN NINETY
FIVE.
IN THEN HE IS ALSO GOING TO BE
WHEN HE STARTS OFF WITH US
SENATE BILL TEN FORTY NINE.
SAID OKAY SO DISCO BY FILERS IN
BILL TEN FORTY NINE ITEM NUMBER
FIVE IN THE IN SENATE BILL
THIRTEEN NINETY FIVE ITEM NUMBER
THIRTEEN. THERMAL OCT FLOORS
WERE SIR THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN THANKS FOR LISTENING TO
ME.
THANK YOU SIR GOOD TO HAVE ONE
PERSON AT LEAST LISTENING
ANNETTE. I APOLOGIZE BUT RUNNING
OUT AS WE HAVE A LARGE BILL
LISTENER GOTTEN INSURANCE TODAY
SO I APOLOGIZE I'VE GOT
INSURANCE AND I GOT HEALTH SOME
HAVE AN OFFENSIVE SORRY.
YOU DID NOT MEAN TO BE RUDE SO
THANK YOU FOR LETTING RELEASED
HAVE A LITTLE.
FUN WITH YOU BECAUSE YOU'RE JUST
AN OUTSTANDING CHAIR AND I'M
REALLY GO. THINKING OF SO SENATE
BILL TEN FORTY NINE SIX TO
ADDRESS WHAT I BELIEVE WAS. BAD
FORM BY SACRAMENTO.
THAT SEEKS TO RIGHT A WRONG.
WE CERTAINLY.
APPRECIATE WHEN WE SEE THINGS
THAT WERE JUST NOT HAPPY ABOUT
AND MAYBE WE COME BACK AND SAY
HEY WE WANNA.
YOU KNOW VOCE OUR OPINION.
CERTAINLY WAS THE CASE A LAST
YEAR.
THIS A.
CAPITAL DID NOT REACT WELL TO
THE ELECTION OF DONALD TRUMP AND
WE CERTAINLY REACTED WITH A LOT
OF.
BILLS IN AND AND AND A LOT OF
OTHER INTERESTING.
WAYS TO ADDRESS PERCEIVED
WRONGS.
A S. B. NINETWENTY TWO
STEINBERG WAS I THINK IT
OVERSTAFFED IT CAN EASILY BE
CHARACTERIZED AS MAYBE BEING
HEAVY HANDED.
BUT I KNOW DARRELL STEINBERG AND
I CONSIDER HIM A FRIEND.
SO I'LL ASSUME IT MUST HAVE
OCCURRED DURING THE STRESSFUL
PERIOD OF TIME HOWEVER CEASING
FUNDING TO A CHARTER CITY. WHOSE
MAJORITY DECIDED TO BAN PROJECT
LABOR AGREEMENTS.
AT THAT JUST SEEMS INAPPROPRIATE
IT SOUNDS LIKE SOMETHING WE
WOULD ASSUME THAT MAYBE
PRESIDENT TRUMP WOULD DO IF HE
REALLY STARTED ACTING UP LIKE WE
THINK HE WOULD OR SOME OF US DO.
BUT SACRAMENTO SHOULDN'T HAVE
DONE THAT SP NINE TWENTY TWO
WENT TOO FAR IN SHOULD BE
REPEALED.
S. B. EIGHT TO NINE WHICH IS
ALSO IN YOUR.
THE BRIEFING WAS ALSO
INAPPROPRIATE. IN ORANGE COUNTY
WE APPROVED PLA'S ENDED UP
CENTER CONSTRUCTION COMMUNITY SO
WE THEN REVERSED IT YEARS LATER.
AND BY UNANIMOUS VOTE OF THE
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS.
THE BOARD REALIZE THAT PLA'S
WERE NO BARGAIN OPEN AND FAIR
COMPETITIONFOR CONSTRUCTION
CONTRACTS WAS PREFERRED.
FOR THE RECORD DATA PLA'S COST
THIRTEEN TO FIFTEEN PERCENT
MORE.
THEY REMOVE THE FREEDOM AN
ELECTED BOARD HAS TO INVITE ALL
QUALIFIED COMERS.
AND THIS FIRMS LOCAL CONTROL
HOPEFULLY CHARTER CITIES WILL
HAVE PROJECTS FOR AFFORDABLE
HOUSING SCHOOL RELATED
CONSTRUCTION.
AND ROAD MAINTENANCE WE NEED TO
LET MANAGERS MANAGE AND PROVIDE
THE PROCUREMENT TOOLS THEY
DESERVE COLLEAGUES SP TEN FORTY
NINE. IS AN ATTEMPT TO REMOVED.
THE.
THE OTHER THAT THE CANDIDATE
BOOTED ACRAMENTO HAS UNUSUALLY
PUT.
UNWISELY PUT ON THE NEXT OF
LOCAL LEADERS AND I RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE AND I HAVE
WITNESSES.
THANK YOU SO MUCH CENTER MORLOCK
ORGAN A WELCOME A WITNESSES IN
SUPPORT IE. SERVICE HE FOR TWO
MINUTES WE WELCOME IF YOU DON'T
MIND THIS CONCERT FOR CELESTE'S
ORGANIZATION THANK YOU FOR
TAKING THE TIME AND IF.
IF YOU DON'T MIND I FORGET THE
SERGEANTS THIS MOVE I'D THE
WINE.
AND. IT'S ALL OVER TO THE RIGHT
TO SORT OUT BLOCKING THE PUBLIC
MICROPHONE SIR I APOLOGIZE FOR
RESOURCES BUT NO PROBLEM.
SENATOR KEVIN DE IN WITH LABOR
SHOE SOLUTIONSLLC ONLINE. A
POLICY IMPLEMENT CHO CONSULTANT
BASED IN MONTEREY CALIFORNIA.
THIS BILL IS ABOUT PRINCIPLES
ABOUT FEDERALISM SUBSIDIARITY.
SEPARATION POLICY OF OUR POWERS
AND CHECKS AND BALANCES.
A.
THIS WHOLE CONTROVERSY BEGAN
AND IS A IN CINEMA COUNTY YOU
KNOW ABOUT PROJECT LABOR
AGREEMENTS BECAUSE THERE WERE
EFFORTS BY THE BORDER SUPER.
AND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA WENT THE
OPPOSITE DIRECTION AND THE BANDS
ON PROJECT LABORAGREEMENTS ON
THE LOCAL LEVEL. THAT BIG BOOK
OF THEM OCCURRED IT WAS
TRIGGERED IN TWO THOUSAND NINE.
WHEN A PROPOSED HOTEL AND
CONVENTION CENTER IN CHULA ISTA
A WAS BEING BLOCKED BY THE.
AGGRESSION OF.
OBJECTIONS TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL
REVIEW AND THIS WAS A TACTIC
BEING USED TO PRESSURE INTO A
PROJECT LABOR AGREEMENT.
AND.
ACTUAL THE STAR IN THE ONE OF
THE BUSINESS COMMITTEE THEIR
RESPONDED BY OPENING A PROJECT
LABOR AGREEMENT THE ON ON THE
BALLOT. AND VOTERS APPROVED IT
HINDLEY AND THEN IT STARTED
MOMENTUM.
WITH THAT NOT ONLY.
GROUPS LIKE THE ORANGE COUNTY
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS.
VOTING OF TO BE AND IT.
BUT THEY'RE ALSO.
PLEBISCITES IN ADDITION TO THAT
YOU WERE THE STAR OF THE AND A
FOR VOTERS THERE IS ALSO THE
COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO. OF THE CITY
OF SAN DIEGO IN THE CITY OF
OCEANSIDE. AND.
THAN THERE WERE SOME EFFORTS
THAT BEGAN IN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA CITY AND COUNTY OF
SACRAMENTO. AT THAT POINT
OBVIOUSLY THE CONSTRUCTION
TRADES COUNCIL HAD AN OFF AND
THEY PASSED US SENATE BILL NINE
TWENTY TWO AND THEN THE
FOLLOWING YEAR SENATE BILL EIGHT
TWENTY NINE.
AND.
THIS BASICALLY NULLIFIED WHAT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS HAD BEEN DOING
AND THE PEOPLE WHO LIVED IN
THESE LOCAL COMMUNITIES A IT
WASN'T UP INAPPROPRIATE TO DO SO
IT WAS ARE WRONG INTERFERENCE OF
THE STATE LEGISLATURE. IN THE
BUSINESS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
IT WAS CLAIMED THAT IT WAS AN
INCENTIVE TO CUT OFF MONEY FOR
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS THAT THE AND
PROJECT LABOR AGREEMENTS. AND
THAT WAS COMPLETELY.
PORTRAYED THE WRONG WAY WHAT IT
ACTUALLY WAS WAS PUNITIVE AND
DID NOT MATCHES EXACTLY WHAT THE
FEAR IS A CALIFORNIA OF WHAT. A
PRESIDENT TRUMP WANTS TO DO WITH
CUTTING OFF FEDERAL MONEY YOU'RE
FOR SANCTUARY CITIES.
OTHERS JUST THAT I LAUGHED WHEN
I HEAR THE COMPLAINTS ABOUT IT I
SAY YOU KNOW THERE'S NO
CONSISTENCY HERE PEOPLE LIKE
FEDERAL IS ON THE.
IT WHEN IT TURNED OUT YOU KNOW
A WAY OF HURT CERTAIN GROUPS AND
THEN THEY.
YOU KNOW TURN AROUND AND FOR
OTHER FAVORED GROUPS THEY MAKE
SURE THAT THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
TO.
ILK SLAPS DOWN LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS FOR WHAT THEY'RE
DOING. SO THAT'S WY THIS BILL
HAS BEEN PROPOSED FOR REPEAL
THIS LANGUAGE SHOULDN'T BE IN
HERE THE STATE NEEDS TO BE
CONSISTENT. IN SAYING A CENTRAL
GOVERNMENT SHOULDN'T BE
INTERFERING IN THE AFFAIRS OF A
SUBSIDIARY GOVERNMENT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH ARE VERY
GRATEFUL FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
TODAY WE THINK THAT A WELCOME
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL IF YOU COULD PLEASE COME
FOR TO THE MICROPHONE.
THREE OF TWO MINUTES THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
I'M I'M DAVE EVERITT I'M WITH
THE.
IN THE GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS
DIRECTOR FOR THE ASSOCIATED
BUILDERS CONTRACTORS SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA AND THAT'S WHAT
APPOINT A COUPLE THINGS ABOUT.
PLA'S AND HOW WE WERE
DEFINITELY SUPPORTING US BEAT
TEN FORTY NINE. I'M.
P. ELEAZAR* ARE.
THE AND OPEN AND FAIR
COMPETITION AND BIDDING ON
PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS. AND.
THEY ACTUALLY BANG AND.
NONUNION APPRENTICES WORKING ON
THIS PROJECT SO.
AS AN ORGANIZATION THAT.
TRAINS APPRENTICES NONUNION
APPRENTICES THAT'S ATTORNEY TO
ASK ALSO THE LESS COMPETITION
AND INEFFICIENT UNION RULES THEY
THEY RAISE THE COSTS AS THE
SENATOR MENTIONED. BUT I AM.
DEPARTMENT LABOR.
POINTS OUT THAT ONLY EIGHTEEN
PERCENT OF CONSTRUCTION
WORKFORCE BELONGS TO A UNION
THEY ACTUALLY YOU KNOW EIGHT OUT
OF TEN CONSTRUCTION WORKERS ARE
BANNING FOR WORKING ON ANY OF
THESE PROJECTS SOUTH.
LOCAL
CITIES THAT THE WRITER TO MAKE
THOSE DECISIONS I'M.
BECOMES A LONG LIST OF OTHER
PROBLEMS AS WELL I PROJECT THAT
WOULD GET TWENTY FIVE THIRTY
BIDS OF AB THE PL A ENDS UP
TYPICALLY GETTING FORTY FIVE
BIDS OUT OF COURSE CHRIS HE
PRICES WELL. IF YOU GO TO.
WELL THE LAKE ON THIS ONE RIGHT
HERE TO DIAL IT TAKES TO BUILD
MORE SCHOOLS DOT COM. THERE'S A
STUDY OF FIVE HUNDRED AND I KNOW
THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
AUCTION.
BUT THAT THE STATS ACTUALLY WORK
OUT VERY WELL IT'S A FIVE
HUNDRED CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
PROJECTS THEY DID A STUDY AND I
AS THE SENATOR MENTIONED WAS
THIRTEEN TO FIFTEEN PERCENT
INCREASE IN COST AND SO. YOU
KNOW YOU'RE LOSING THOSE SCHOOL
BUILDINGS ARE IN AS FAIR AT A
CITY YOU'RE LOSING THAT EXTRA
CITY HALL OR WHATEVER THAT
FACILITY AS.
AND THAT MEANS ALSO THAT IDEALLY
ON THE MERIT SHOP COMPANIES WILL
BE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST
EFFECTIVELY PRICED OUT OF
WORKING ON THE PROJECT. AND IT'S
NOT BECAUSE THEY WON'T PAY UNION
RATES BECAUSE THESE ARE PROJECTS
WITH OUR STATE OR FEDERAL OR
CITY FINDING IT SO BOTH UNION
AND NONUNION HAVE TO PAY WHAT
THEY CALL PREVAILING WAGE THEM.
DOESN'T START FELL.
AND IT'S IT OF ITS OF THE HIGHER
COST IS BECAUSE UNDER P. LA
THE-NINETY COMPANIES HAVE TO PAY
INTO THE UNION HEALTHCARE AND
RETIREMENT FUND. THEN THEY ALSO
HAVE TO PAY INTO THEIR OWN
HEALTHCARE AND RETIREMENT FND.
THE PROBLEM IS BECAUSE IT TAKES
FIVE YEARS TO BE VESTED IN THE
UNION PLAN THAT I DID NOT UNION
WORKERS ARE ABLE TO TO.
GET THAT MONEY HERE ARE GET
THOSE BENEFITS THEY'RE ACTUALLY
PAIN FOR AND SO WHAT THIS THIS
POSTER TRYING TO ILLUSTRATE HIS.
ARE ON A THREE MONTH JOB THEY
LOSE. OVER TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS
ON AND I DON'T. FOLKS ARE
WORKING AT HIGH SPEED RAIL OR
SOMETHING WHERE YOU'RE IT'S
CONSISTENT PROJECT FOR THE WHOLE
YEAR.
YOU KNOW THAT THERE WAS OVER
FORTY ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR
FOR WORKERS ARE THESE THESE THAT
PLA'S ARE SO OFFENSIVE ACTUALLY
TWENTY FOUR STATES HAVE BANNED
THEM AS THE OTHER AYE AS THE
OTHER CHARTS TRYING TO
ILLUSTRATE. AND I'M.
SO IT'S NO SURPRISE THAT
HUNDREDS OF JOHN. MY BRAIN THAT
TIME YOU'VE GOT THIRTY
SECONDS-OKAY WELL I TRY TO POINT
OUT
THAT A COUPLE WEEKS AGO WE HAD
HUNDREDS OF NON UNION WORKERS.
FLOOD THE CAPITAL AND TRY TO
MAKE THIS EXACTS A POINT AND
I'M.
THEY WERE BASICALLY TRYING TO
SHOW THEIR OPPOSITION TO THE PL
A.
.
THE OTHER THING I THOUGHT WOULD
BE IF SHE KNEW YOU FOLKS IS
THAT.
.
PEEL HIS ARE OFTEN USED I SEE
THAT THEY ARE APPEALING
PROPONENTS OFTEN YOU SEE QUIRK
AS A WAY TO LEVERAGE TO GET
PLA'S AND THAT ACTUALLY I A
ROADS LEGITIMATE ENVIRONMENTAL
SUPPORT. WHEN THEY'RE USING JUST
LABOR AGREEMENTS THEY GO I'M A
LABOR AGREEMENT THERE'S NO NEED
FOR THIS ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN
ANYMORE I IT IT MAKES THE PUBLIC
THAT GO WAS THERE REALLY EVER
ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN OR IS THIS
JUST A SHAKE DOWN SOUTH. OFF FOR
ALL THOSE REASONS WE WE WE
OPPOSE PLA'S WAS PART SENATORS
BELT AND FORTY NINE THANK YOU SO
MUCH SIR THANK YOU FOR MAKING
THE TREK NORTH TODAY.
WE'D LIKE TO GET OPEN UP FOR
THOSE WHO RE IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL JUST TO BE RECEIVE FOR SOME
LASSEN ORGANIZATION.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS RICHARD MARX AND ON
BEHALF THE WESTERN ELECTRICAL
CONTRACTORS ASSOCIATION OF
PLUMBING HEATING COOLING
CONTRACTORS OF CALIFORNIA. THE
CALIFORNIA CHAPTERS OF THE
AMERICAN.
OUR SPRINKLER ASSOCIATION A AND
OTHER. MARCH UP CONTRACTOR
GROUPS
A PLEASE RESTORE THE SOVEREIGNTY
OF CHARTER CITIES BY APPROVING
SP TEN FORTY NINE TODAY WORD
STRONG SUPPORT.
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
I HATE DOING OUT ON HALF OF
ASSOCIATED. BUILDERS AND
CONTRACTORS OF NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT WE DO
SUPPORT THE FLEXIBILITY THE
CHARTER CITIES AND. PROJECT
LABOR AGREEMENTS ARE VERY
PROBLEMATIC FOR ABC MEMBERS HAD
EVEN THOUGH THEY CAN
TECHNICALLY.
BIT HAN THE JOBS THEY ARE
PREVENTED FROM USING. THEIR ARM
ALL BUT A HANDFUL OF THEIR OWN
CORE WORKERS WHICH MAKES I'M
DOING THE JOB MUCH MORE.
PROBLEMATIC AND SO WE REALLY
SUPPORT ON THE INTENT OF THE
FLEXIBILITY BEHIND THIS BILL
APPRECIATE.
THE AUTHORS EFFORTS IN MERGER
I'VE OUT INTO SUMMER THANKS FOR
BEING HERE.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO MAY BE
IN SUPPORT LAST CALL.
ALRIGHT IT WORKS FOR FOLKS WITH
ACTIVE ERA MOVED TO A OPPOSITION
PLEASE WELCOME SIR.
WELCOME IF YOU DON'T MIND SENIOR
FOR SLASH ORGANIZATION FIVE PER
OUR COMMUNITY PREFERENCE WHAT
TYPICALLY HAPPENS IS THAT WE
HAVE ONE PRIMARY WITNESS INTO.
POSE
SIR THE FOR RESOURCE.
THANK YOU SENATOR.
.
SENATOR DILLARD TO.
JEREMY SMITH YOUR BEHALF OF THE
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
TRADES COUNCIL
A WE ARE OPPOSED TO THIS
LEGISLATION TODAY WE WITH THE
SPONSORS OF BOTH SB EIGHT TWENTY
NINE AND NINE TWENTY TWO.
AND I THINK THAT IT'S IMPORTANT
TO HAVE FIRST OF ALL LET THE
COMMITTEE KNOW THAT THERE'S A
WHOLE SECTION.
ABOVE TWENTY FIVE OH ONE TWO AND
THREE.
SECTION TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED THE
PUBLIC CONTRACT CODE.
THAT.
FOR.
PUBLIC PLA'S MUST SAYS THAT THIS
SAYS PUBLIC DELAYS MUST INCLUDE
THE FOLLOWING FIVE. THINGS.
UP FOR IT SHOULD EARN AGREEMENT
SHOULD PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION
BASED ON ALL THE USUAL THINGS
RACE AND NATIONAL ORIGIN
RELIGION ALSO.
MEMBERSHIP IN A LABOR
ORGANIZATION IN HIRING OR
DISPATCHING WORKERS TO THE
PROJECT.
THE SECOND THING ALL PUBLIC
PLA'S MUST INCLUDE.
IS AN AGREEMENT THAT ALL
QUALIFIED CONTRACTORS AND
SUBCONTRACTORS
WE'LL BE ABLE TO BID AND BE
AWARDED WORK ON THE PROJECT
WITHOUT REGARD TO WHETHER THEY
ARE PARTY TO A COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING AGREEMENT.
OTHER THREE OTHER THINGS JUST TO
FINISH THE THOUGHT.
WITH EVERY PUBLIC PEELING MUST
HAVE ISN'T AGREEMENT.
AND AGREED UPON PROTOCOL
CONCERNING DRUG TESTING.
AN AGREEMENT THAT GUARANTEES A
NO STRIKES NO LOCKOUTS NO WORK
STOPPAGES.
AND.
.
FIFTH THING IS THERE ANY DISPUTE
THAT ARISES UNDER THE P. LA WILL
BE RESOLVED BY NEUTRAL
ARBITRATOR SO.
PUBLIC DELAYS.
ARE EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE OF
WHAT THE FOLKS THAT CAME BEFORE
ME SAY THEY HAVE TO HAVE ALL
THESE THINGS THEIR PROHIBIT
DISCRIMINATION AGAINST YA
NONUNION. CONTRACTORS NONUNION
WORKERS.
AND.
YOU KNOW WHAT IS THE THE ISSUE
THIS GERMANE TO THIS COMMITTEE
IS THAT THE LEGISLATURE DECIDED
WHEN THEY PASSED A TWENTY NINE
AND TWENTY TWO.
THAT.
THEY BELIEVE THE PROJECT LABOR
AGREEMENTS THEY BELIEVE THE
DATA.
ARE THEY BELIEVE IT.
DOZENS OF THIRD PARTY UNIVERSITY
STUDIES
THAT SHELBY LA SAVE MONEY
PROVIDE FOR MORE ON TIME PROJECT
DELIVERY ETCETERA ETCETERA AND
THEY DECIDED THE LEGISLATURE
DECIDED. TO WITHHOLD STATE FUNDS
FROM CITIES AND COUNTIES.
THAT DECIDED TO NOT EVEN THAT TO
PASS ORDINANCES OR DID YOU
INITIATIVES THAT ARE NOT EVEN OR
A ALLOW THE LOCAL BOARD TO.
CONSIDER PROJECT LABOR AGREEMENT
THAT'S ALL THAT THAT'S ALL OF
THESE BILLS DO. DID THAT'S ALL
THE PUBLIC CONTRACT CODE
SECTIONS DO.
AND A.
IT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER THAT.
P. ALWAYS HAVE BEEN AROUND FOR A
LONG TIME BIZARRE NEW THINGS.
DOZENS AND DOZENS OF PRIVATE
COMPANIES IT HE'S PA'S IN THE
PRIVATE SECTOR WALMART GM TOYOTA
HONDA.
PICK OF OTHER AND A BASKETBALL
ARENA PIC A BASEBALL STADIUM
PROBABLY DONE BY PLO LADIES ARE
EXOTIC NEW THINGS.
SO A FOR THOSE REASONS AND MANY
OTHERS THAT I WON'T GOING TO NOW
IN THE SIDE QUESTIONS A WE ARE
OPPOSE THIS BILL.
STATE TAXPAYER DOLLARS
YOU CONTROL STATE TAXPAYER
DOLLARS IF YOU WANT TO DECIDE. A
WHERE THOSE DOLLARS GO DISEASE
COUNTIES YOU CAN DO THAT. US
AWARE OPPOSE TODAY THANK YOU.
IF YOU MISTER SMITH.
WE KNOW WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME
ANYONE ELSE WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
IF YOU COULD PLEASE ADVANCE THIS
TIME ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL EXCUSE ME OPPOSE.
I GOODNESS GOODNESS MAKSIM
SUPPORT APOLOGIZE.
ANYONE ELSE WHO'S IN OPPOSITION.
ALRIGHT THIS BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY
DISCUSSION.
HEARING NO DISCUSSION I WOULD
WELCOME A MOTION IN YOUR MORE
THAN WELCOME TO BE ABLE TO.
SPRING FOR THE MOTION YOUR OWN
BILLS WILL MISS HIM A LOT.
I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL
ALRIGHT. WE HAVE A.
RADIO AND WE HAVE.
AND THERE YOU GO.
IT BEFORE WE GET TO CLOSING
COMMENTS AT WITH.
WITH.
MISTER IS GOING TO TAKE A
MOMENT TO WELCOME A WERE ABLE TO
SIT DOWN AT LAST WE CAN HAVE A
CONVERSATION IN.
AND WHAT WHAT I ALWAYS
APPRECIATE ABOUT.
A THE GOOD SENATOR IS ALWAYS
WILLING TO BE ABLE TO HAVE A
DISCUSSION WHETHER WE AGREE OR
NOT. ON AND.
GRATEFUL FOR HIS FRIENDSHIP AND
PARTNERSHIP IN THE BELIEVE IT
WORK WITH YEAH I KNOW WE DON'T
SEE EYE TO EYE ON THIS EXACT
ISSUE. BUT WHAT I WANT TO SAY IS
HOW MUCH I APPRECIATE IT WILL AS
WE DON'T HAVE THE DISCUSSION HOW
THE DISCUSSION EARLY ON AND I
KNOW THAT YOU WERE CARD FOR.
THOSE THAT YOU WORK FOR A.
SUMMER LOCK I KNOW YOU KNOW WILL
BE OPPOSED TODAY BUT I'D LIKE TO
OFFER YOU THE ABILITY TO HAVE A
CLOSER REMARKS PLEASE. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR AND AGAIN IT IS A
WONDERFUL WORKING RELATIONSHIP
AND I REALLY APPRECIATE IT.
I THINK ONE OF THE.
INDIVIDUALS THAT SUPPORT THE
BILL SAID THAT LET'S SUPPORT THE
SOVEREIGNTY OF CHARTER CITIES
AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE. TALKING
ABOUT TODAY MISTER CHAIR. IF
APPEAL A IT'S A GREAT OPTION
THEN ALLOW MANAGERS TO MANAGE
AND LET THEM MAKE THAT DECISION
AND LET THEM LOOK AT THE
ALTERNATIVES.
I THINK WITH HOLDING CASH
IS INAPPROPRIATE. AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR KNIVES.
MAKE YOU SO MUCH THAT WE DO HAVE
A MOTION BY CENTER MORE LOCK
THIS IS A DO PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS.
THE SLAIN CHESTER PRO CALL VOTE
PLEASE.
REQUIRE NO WIRE NO WIN.
BELL. BILL NO HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA KNOW LARA NO MORE
LOCKED.
I LIKE GUYS THREE.
WE CURRENTLY HAVE A ONE THREE
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
AND ALLOW MEMBERS TO BE ABLE TO
ADD ON THANK YOU SO MUCH AS WHO
ARE LOCKED.
MEMBERS JUST A QUICK BIT OF
HOUSEKEEPING AND I APPRECIATE
THE INDULGENCE
I'M I'M GONNA BE ACROSS THE
HALL.
.
PRESENTING TO LARGE BILLS ON
INSURANCE IT WITHOUT WITH
MR-DIED. I IF I SCOOT OUT ON AND
TURN THE GAVEL OVER TO SENATOR
LARA WHILE MR MORLOCK IS
PRESENTING THEM ONCE MISTER
MORLOCK IS COMPLETED WILL TURN
THE GAVEL OVER HIM IF I HAVE TO
STEP OUT. BUT IT'S GOING TO BE
IN THE STATE THAT PUBLICLY HERE
MISTER MOORE LOCK. ON AND THEN
AS MR MORLOCK IS ABOUT TO
PRESENT AT HIS NEXT BILL ON
PERSONAL INCOME TAXES
PARTICULARLY ON CORPORATION. TAX
LAW BONUS A ON THE CREDITS WERE
AND SAY HOW MUCH I APPRECIATED
ARE BELIEVED TO BE TO WORK
TOGETHER ON THIS ONE. AYE AND
AMENDMENTS ARE BEING ADVANCED
TODAY ON THIS BILL AND ARE ALSO
HAPPY TO SUPPORT IT. SUMMER LIKE
THE FLOOR IS YOURS THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR AS CERTAINLY.
SOMEONE WHO'S BEEN IN
MANAGEMENT IS OBSERVE.
EMPLOYEE ABUSE.
AND CERTAINLY HAVE.
EXPERIENCED.
FRIENDS AND LOVED ONES THAT
HAVE HAD EMPLOYERS ABUSE THEM.
FORCING NOT TIED TO THE STUDY
EXTENT THAT WE'VE SEEN WITH
SEXUAL ABUSE.
BUT AS WE REACTED TO THE WINE
STEAM.
pREACT TO. OF THE THAT'S THAT
THE
SAD.
STATE OF AFFAIRS.
.
IT WAS ONE OF THOSE THINGS THAT
YOU SAID WHERE HOW DO WE HOW DO
WE KNOW HOW IT'LL AFFECT THIS IS
UNBELIEVABLE IS GOING ON. BUT
WHAT KIND OF INTRIGUED ME THE
MOST IS WE WERE LOOKING AT THE
WHOLE LANDSCAPE WAS THAT
CALIFORNIA PROVIDES A TAX CREDIT
FOR THE MOVIE AND PRODUCERS. AND
SO WE ALL SORT OF CONTRIBUTED IN
SOME AWKWARD WAY TO WHAT WAS
GOING ON IN HOLLYWOOD AND TO A
LOT OF FINE. WOMEN THAT'S WHY
EVEN BROUGHT IT UP LAST WEEK IN
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WITH
BECAUSE SENATOR HOLLY MITCHELL
WHO. JUST WANTED TO ASK I WOULD
BE DOING WHAT THE THAT THE WIND
STEAM TO TOLL BACK KIND AND
NONSENSE IS WE. GIVE AWAY A TAX
CREDITS OR. TAX EXPENDITURES SO
THAT. MISTER CHAIR I I I WANTED
TO SEE WHO'S GETTING TAX CREDITS
AND SO I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR
YOUR AMENDMENTS I ACCEPT THEM. I
WORK WE'VE WE'VE ACTUALLY.
TAKING IT DOWN TO JUST AT
CERTAIN INDUSTRY GROUPS BY
CREDIT. AND TRYING TO AT LEAST
SEE WHAT'S GOING ON AS WE AS A
STATE ENCOURAGE.
THE.
INDUSTRIES IN CALIFORNIA TO.
AVAIL THEMSELVES OF CERTAIN TAX
CREDITS.
THE.
I THINK THE INFORMATION SHOULD
BE PROVIDED TO US I'VE
SACRAMENTO WAS INCENTIVIZING THE
ECONOMY THROUGH THE CREDITS FOR
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT WE ALSO
CALLED OUR INDIE. LOW INCOME
HOUSING A CALIFORNIA COMPETES.
TV IN MOTION PICTURE PRODUCTION
WILL GET THOSE IN AGGREGATE IN
LARGER AMOUNTS NOT IN.
SMALLER. GRANULAR FORM AND SO I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH INTEREST IN
IRAQ WOULD LIKE TO GO TO SEE
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT TO PLEASE
ADVANCE.
LIKE RECEIVE WE OF ANYONE WHO IS
OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
BRING TO BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE WOULD WELCOME ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
OR A MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY MISTER LARA
THIS IS HE DO PASSES AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS BUTTON AND OTHER
ARE SEVERAL MEN INSTEAD MISTER
MORLOCK IS TAKING AGAIN JUST
WANNA SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
SUMMER WALK. THROUGH MORLOCK
CLOSING COMMENTS PLEASE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE HAVE A
MOTION ON THE FLOOR DO PASSES
MINUTES APPROPRIATIONS MISS LANE
JUST A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE.
WIRE AYE WHY I WIN.
WELL. I FELT I HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE
LARA.
LARA AYE MORLOCK NO.
JUST KIDDING I HAVE. COME HOME
AND MARLA PUTS IT OUT.
THE COMMISSION CHAIRED BY ZERO.
SPUR.
WHAT I SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH I
TO SENATOR HURT CITY?
A SENATOR HER T. DOES HAVE ONE
LAST BILL WITH US TODAY.
AND THAT'S SB TWELVE FIFTEEN.
I'M AND WANNA APOLOGIZE ABOUT
THE LATE HOUR.
BUT WE GOTTA GO OKAY IT THAT
MAKE IT FAST ENOUGH WE GET WE
HAVE A MOTION ON THE FLOOR
SENATOR HERTZBERG WE DO HAVE A
MOTION AND IT.
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE YOU'RE
COMFORTABLE WITH THE AMENDMENT I
AM AND I GOT A COUPLE WITNESSES
A LET THEM TALK ABOUT THIS ISSUE
BECAUSE THEY CAME FROM FAR
DISTANCES.
ANY GET.
S. YOU ARE WITNESSES WHO ARE
HERE TODAY THAT GOD THIS STARTED
SO LATE BUT WE WELCOME YOU. YOU.
YEAH.
THERE.
I JUST WISH BUT.
LOOKING ME SIR. IF YOU COULD
JUST GIVE US YOUR FIRST AND LAST
NAME.
IT MY NAME IS A.
BOTH MINIMALIST SO I CAN HEAR
GOOD WHATEVER YOU WANT TO DO
HOME BUT IT'S A LITTLE HE'LL.
BINGO THEY LIVE AT HOME WHEN YOU
THE OTHER DAY. MARTINI TAX.
THEN BLOODY CALIFORNIA.
MY NAME IS A LITTLE HERE AND I
COME FROM AT THE CHECK IN
TULARE.
CALIFORNIA.
.
MANY MORE SO OBISPO YOU'LL THE
BORDER.
BUT NO THEY MUST SO. MISTER THAT
AND I THINK.
WE ASK FOR YOUR HELP WITH
RESPECT OUR WASTE WATER.
BEEN IMMORAL PHONE THOSE MOVIE
THEATER THAT A FELLOW.
BUT.
.
BUT I ESTO.
LET IN MARKETING THAT WHEN THE
CATS THAT PUT OKAY.
P. NONE OF CREATE BOTH MOTHER
AND THIS.
WE ACTUALLY HAVE FUNDS FROM THE
STATE NECESSARY FOR A WASTEWATER
SYSTEM BUT THE CITY OF TULARE.
DOESN'T WANT TO CONNECT US
BECAUSE THEY HAVE PLANS FOR A
BIGGER PROJECT.
OF. KNOW SO DOES THE NAME OF
MORE. MORE TO FIND OUT WHAT'S
AVAILABLE BUT THEY UNDERGONE FOR
MOST OF THE UNITED.
WE HAVE MANY YEARS WE'VE BEEN
BATTLING FOR MANY YEARS ON TO
GET WASTE WATER SERVICE.
E. GET UP EARLIER SO YOU'LL THE
IRAQI DE.
BUT A COUPLE IN ESTA PROPUESTA.
AND I WANT TO ASK FOR YOUR.
HELP BY SUPPORTING THIS
PROPOSAL.
I'M.
LIST OF LETTUCE.
THAT'S IT THANK YOU.
IT'S WORSE I THINK YOU SIR EVEN
BEEN HERE I SINCE THIS MORNING
IN JUST TWENTY HOW GRATEFUL WE
ARE FOR HANGING WITH US HIGH IN
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY WERE VERY
GRATEFUL NO THAT YOU TRAVELED A
LONG DISTANCE BEER JUST WANNA
SAY THANK YOU AND APOLOGIZE.
THAT IT'S TAKEN SO DANG LONGER
TO GET TO THIS IMPORTANT BILL.
THAT'S IS PART OF A NEED ASSUME
OUT WHEN WE GET THAT LUCKY IS
OUR TO WITH THIS BUT THE PROCESS
ALL. THE MOTHERS THE SCHOOL BUS
CARRY THE ASSN THEM WE. ARE.
LOCAL BY THE BOTTOM OF THOSE I
WAS GOOD WITH OF YOU KNOW THIS
AND WE COMPOUND I SEE CARE.
THAT'S HAS FOUR WAS IRAQIS HAVE
PART THAT THERE. THIS SUPERVISOR
MCAFEE KOJA VANESSA.
THEN AGENCIES JUST QUICKLY WE
HAVE A
WORK WITH OFF THEIR POSITION
THERE'S A COUPLE ISSUES WE'D
LIKE TO SEE RESOLVED ON THE
DEFINITIONS. OF IDENTIFYING A
FUNDING SOURCE AND THEN DEALING
WITH THIS.
ISSUE OF THE WHOLE COMMUNITY
BUYING IN.
IN ORDER TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
DON'T HAVE ANY STRANDED ASSETS
WHEN WE DO EXTEND SERVICE OUT SO
AND WILL CONTINUE WORKING WITH
THE SENATOR ON THESE ISSUES AND.
THANK YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH
WELCOME.
IT AFTERNOON CAROLINE WILLIAMS
FROM OF FAIR MEET CALIFORNIA IN
MADERA COUNTY. AND WE HAVE
SIMILAR ISSUES TO TULARE AND I'M
HERE FOR SUPPORT.
I AM SEE YOU AT THE GYM FOR
BEING HERE THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
TAKING.
SITE WE TAUGHT BE APOLOGIZES
TAKEN SO LONG THANK YOU FOR
HANGING WITH US TODAY WELCOME
SIR.
EMINEM'S BUILT ON THE NORTH NONE
THERE'S SOME WITH LEADERSHIP
COUNCIL BUT ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIAN VET AND GARMENTS
JUSTICE ALLIANCE WERE IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL THINKING AND
APOLOGIZE IT'S TAKEN SO LONG TO
GET TO THE BILL TODAY. THANK YOU
FOR APOLOGIZING NO ONE EVER DOES
AND HANNAH AND THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
AND. WOULD LIKE TO RECEIVE THAT
I IF ANYONE ELSE WOULD LIKE TO
BE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL TO SIGN OR IF YOU HAVE
CHALLENGES.
WE NOW WOULD LIKE TO ASK FOLKS
TO ADVANCE WERE OPPOSED TO THE
BILL CAN PLEASE COME FOR.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSITION.
ALRIGHT. MEMBERS WE HAVE A
MOTION BY SENATOR LARA THIS IS A
DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
PREPARATIONS MISTER HERTZBERG.
CLOSING COMMENT SIR.
YOU KNOW A LITTLE BETTER.
ESTATE AUTO.
THANK YOU SO MUCH. A ROLL CALL
VOTE PLEASE MISS LANE CHESTER
MCGUIRE AYE AYE MCGUIRE AYE
NGUYEN AYE NGUYEN AYE BELL.
THEY'LL HIDE HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG
AYE AYE HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
OUR THAT IS A FIVE ZERO MEMBERS
WE'VE BEEN TOLD BY SENATOR NAMED
IS THAT HE'S NOT GONNA BE COMING
BACK
SO WE ARE GOING TO.
CLOSE THE ROLE IN THAT BOAT IN
THAT BILL IS OUT ON A FIVE ZERO
VOTES HAVE THANK YOU SO MUCH.
THANK YOU. FUND IT. THANK YOU SO
MUCH THANK YOU KNOW VERY
GRATEFUL.
MEMBERS WERE GOING TO JUMP BACK
TO ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN THIS IS
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN THIRTY
THREE MR Y. KOWSKI ITEM ELEVEN.
BUT WE DID NOT TAKE A VOTE ON
THIS IS IN REGARDS TO JOURNAL
PLAN ZONING.
PARDON. IS THERE A MOTION TO
APPROVE.
WE HAVE A MOTION BY MISTER LARA
THIS IS A DO PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS MISLAID CHESTER
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE WIRE.
HI REQUIRE AYE NGUYEN.
BELL.
YEAH HE.
YES.
AND HERTZBERG AYE. LARA.
WHERE I MORE LOCKED?
YOU ARE KNOW WE DON'T. KNOW.
YOU HAVE FOUR TO.
MEMBERS THAT IS A FOR TO THAT
BILL IS OUT AND UP FORMALLY
APPROVED WE'RE GONNA CLOSE A
ROLL ON ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN.
FIFTY SO MUCH
AND I THINK CENTER HERTZBERG AS
A TAKE THIRTY SECONDS REAL QUICK
WE'RE GONNA GET ORGANIZED AS A
SENATOR AT DICK'S QUICK PICTURE
WE'RE GONNA GET ORGANIZED SOME
OF AN OPEN UP THE ROLE IN CLOSE
ON THE HEARING
ISRAEL FOR.
I MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO BE.
OPENING UP WITH OUR CONSENT
CALENDAR ARE CONSENT CALENDAR
OUR CONSENT CALENDAR CONSISTS OF
FOUR ITEMS TODAY. FIFTEEN
SIXTEEN SEVENTEEN AND EIGHTEEN
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO
VOTE.
MS LANE CHESSER ROLL CALL
PLEASE.
HERTZBERG FIND HERTZBERG AYE
LARA.
SEVEN ZERO THE CONSENT CALENDAR
PASSES WERE CLOSE IN THE ROLE OF
THE BILL IS OUT.
WE'RE NOW GOING TO START FROM
THE BEGINNING MEMBERS AND WORK
OUR WAY DOWN THE AGENDA THE GAS
YOU BILLS HERE TODAY ITEM NUMBER
ONE S. B. EIGHT THIRTY ONE BYE
WEEK BY KOWSKI. CURRENTLY ENJOYS
A FIVE ZERO VOTE CHAIR VOTING I
MISS LANE CHESTER.
WHEN.
LARA I'M LARA AYE.
SIX ZERO THE BILL IS OUT WERE
CLOSE IN THE ROLE.
THE BILL PASSES THANK YOU.
MEMBERS RENOWNED ITEM NUMBER TWO
S. B. NINE THIRTY CURRENTLY
ENJOYS. A FIVE ZERO FIVE ZERO
VOTE
A MISSING CHESSER LOCAL PLEASE.
NGUYEN.
WE.
LARA.
LARA I.
THAT BILL IS OUT THE BILL PASSES
IN WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE ROLL ON
A SIX TO ONE. WERE NOW MOVING ON
TO ITEM NUMBER HREE SB NINE
SIXTY ONE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A
FOUR ZERO CHAIR VOTING I MISS
LANE CHESSER.
HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA. LARA AYE.
YOU KNOW TO.
WINDOW TO AYE.
ASIAN GERMAN THAT'S A SEVENTY
SAKE AND THERE WE GO.
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ADD THAT
BILL IS OUT IT PASSES IN THE
CLOTHES IN THE ROLE WE'RE NOW
MOVING ON TO SENATE BILL TEN
ZERO SEVEN NO ITEM NUMBER FOUR
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO. A
CHAIR VOTING I MISS LANE CHESTER
WIN. WIN AYE LARA.
I.
SEVEN IS ZERO.
THE BILL IS OUT AND IT PASSES
A SIMILAR SUPPORT THOSE GLASSES
WELL TAKE A LOOK ABOUT HER.
.
I DON'T NUMBER FIVE WE'RE NOW
MOVING TO SENATE BILL TEN FORTY
NINE ITEM NUMBER FIVE AND
BUILDING TEN FORTY NINE CHAIR
VOTING NO.
BROKAW PLEASE.
MISS LANE CHESTER WHEN.
WHEN I.
HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG. HERTZBERG AYE.
LARA.
BY ITEM NUMBER FIVE CHAIR VOTING
NO.
BECAUSE.
YOU'LL HEAR THE HAND YOU GUYS
OKAY.
I DON'T KNOW HERTZBERG. SO YOU
HAVE TO FOR.
I.
YEAH SURE ABSOLUTELY BERMAN THE
ITEMS FAILS.
REQUEST FOR.
RECONSIDERATION GRANTED ON IN
WE'RE GOING TO BE CLOSING THE
ROLE ON THAT ITEM NUMBER FIVE
ITEM SALES BUT YES
RECONSIDERATION GRANTED THANK
pNOW MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER
SIX
BOB I THINK WE MADE WE CLOSE
THIS ONE DOWN I THINK WE DID.
AND WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN SP TWELVE TWENTY
FIVE CHAIR VOTING I CURRENT VOTE
IS FOR ONE MISS LANE CHESTER.
ONE MOMENT MEMBERS.
MEMBERS WERE VOTING ON ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN SP TWELVE TWENTY
FIVE THIS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOR
WINE CHAIR VOTING I MISS LANE
CHESTER.
WHERE?
WITH AYE LARA. LARA AYE.
MEMBERS THAT BILL PASSES IT'S
OUT AND WE'RE CLOSE THE ROLE ON
THE SIX ONE VOTE WE'RE NOW
MOVING ON TO ITEM NUMBER EIGHT
SP TWELVE FORTY ONE CHAIR VOTING
I CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO
MUSLIM CHESTER.
LARA.
I ITEM NUMBER EIGHT TWELVE FORTY
ONE CHAIR VOTING ON A CURRENTLY
ENJOYS OF A FIVE ZERO.
BUT WE THAT IS A SIX ZERO THE
BILL IS OUT IT PASSES OR CLOSING
THE ROLE.
MEMBERS RENOWNED VOTING TO OVEN
NOW MOVING TO ITEM NUMBER NINE
S. B. TWELVE SIXTY CURRENT VOTE
IS FIVE ZERO. CHAIRVOTING I
MISS LANE CHESTER.
WIN. WIN NOW LARA.
LARA I.
THAT VOTE IS A SIX ONE THE BILL
PASSES BILL IS OUT WE'RE CLOSING
THE ROLE. FOR NOW MOVING ON TO
ITEM NUMBER TEN S. B. TWELVE
NINETY SIX CURRENT VOTE FIVE TWO
ZERO. AM CHAIR VOTING I MISS
LANE CHESTER WIN. WIN AYE LARA.
LARA OWNS.
THAT IS A SEVEN ZERO THE BILL IS
OUT WILL CLOSE IN THE ROLE AND
IN THE BILL PASSES THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
WE'RE NOW MOVING ON TO.
ARE TAKING ACTION AYE THIRTEEN
THIRTY THREE WHEN I WHEN I ITEM
TWELVE THIRTEEN EIGHTY FOR ITEM
TWELVE THIRTEEN EIGHTY FOUR.
THIS IS THE CURRENT VOTE IS ONE
TWO ZERO CHAIR VOTING NO CHAIR
BERNIE NO ONE ITEM TWELVE SP
THIRTEEN.
FOR
ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE MISSING
CHESTER NGUYEN.
WHEN I BELL.
BELL NO.
LARA.
LARA KNOW.
HERTZBERG.
FULLER.
TO YOU FOR. PAST WEEK NBATV
SALUTE LEE.
WAS REQUESTED FOR
RECONSIDERATION RECONSIDERATION
IS GRANTED OF COURSE
THE FINAL VOTE ON THIS BILL IS I
DID IS TO TWO FOR THE BILL
FAILS.
GOING TO CLOSE THE ROLE
RECONSIDERATION GRANTED.
I NOW ITEM THIRTEEN S. B.
THIRTEEN NINETY FIVE CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO VOTE.
BUT MISLAID CHESSER BROKE
CULTURE VOTING AYE.
WHEN.
WHEN I.
BUT NO.
GO HAVE A TIGHTLY SO INTERNET
CISCO.
SIX ZERO.
OKAY.
WHEN I DIDN'T KNOW WHAT PAIN AND
.
A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE IT'S.
ROAD I DON'T EVER THIRTEEN SB
THIRTEEN NINETY FIVE.
WHEN THE WINDOW.
THAT IS A FINAL FIVE ONE VOTE
THE BILL IS OUT WERE CLOSING THE
ROLE IT PASSES.
ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN REALLY HAVE
TWO LEFT MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR
YOUR PATIENCE AND NUMBER
FOURTEEN S. B. FOURTEEN SIXTY
NINE CHAIR VOTING I CURRENTLY OF
FOUR ZERO VOTE.
MISSING CHESTER NGUYEN.
HERTZBERG AYE AYE HERTZBERG AYE
LARA AYE FLORA AYE.
SIX ZERO VOTE THAT BILL IS AT
WORK CLOTHES IN THAT ROLE IN THE
BILL PASSES AND FINALLY. ITEM
NUMBER NINETEEN AS CA TWENTY
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO
CHAIR VOTING ON
MISS LANCHESTER ROLL CALL PLEASE
NGUYEN.
LARA.
WHEN I.
LARA I.
AND THE. POOL.
SEVEN ZERO LOOK AT THAT POD THAT
BILL IS OUT HE PASSES WERE
CLOSING THE ROLE.
HERE
THE BILL PAY VERY YOUNG THAT
ALLOTTED.
THE GUYS ARE LIKE THAT.
MEMBERS WE HAVE A NOTHER
HEARING NEXT WEEK PREPARE FOR
ABOUT TWELVE HOURS
SO.
BRING YOUR LUNCH IN LATEST IS
BRINGING A MARGARITA.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE ARE JOURNAL
SEE NEXT WEDNESDAY