ALLEN.
ANDERSON ATKINS BATES.
BELLE. BERRYHILL. BRADFORD.
CANNELLA. DELEON. DOT. FULLER.
GAINES.
GALGIANI. GLAZER HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG. HILL HUESO. JACKSON
LADA.
LEYVA MCGUIRE MENDOZA MITCHELL.
MONNING. MORLOCK.
MORRELL.
NEWMAN. WHEN. NIELSEN. PAN.
PORTANTINO ROTH SKINNER.
STERN.
STONE. BIDAK Y. CASKEY WIENER
WILK.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY A
QUORUM IS PRESENT WITH THE
MEMBERS IN OUR GUESTS BE ON THE
RAIL AND IN THE GALLERY PLEASE
RISE WILL BE LEAD IN PRAYER THIS
AFTERNOON BY OUR CHAPLAIN SISTER
MICHELLE GORMAN. AFTER WHICH
PLEASE REMAIN STANDING A WILL BE
LED IN THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
TO THE FLAG BY SENATOR PAN.
LET US CENTER OURSELVES IN GOD'S
PRESENCE.
GOD OF ALL CREATION.
TO TRUST JOY OF BEING.
ENCOURAGE US TO BE PRESENTS TO
THE GIFTS THAT ARE OURS.
AND LEAD US TO GREATER JOY AND
GRATITUDE.
GRANT US THE COURAGE TO BE OUR
TRUE SELVES.
TO LET GO OF BEING SO CONCERNED
ABOUT WHAT OTHERS THINK.
OR OF HOW SUCCESSFUL WE ARE.
STRENGTHEN OUR INNER FREEDOM SO
THAT REMAINS CELEBRATES ENJOY TO
LIGHTEN AND EMBRACE OUR LIFE IN
ALL ITS MYSTERY.
GUIDE US TO OUR INNER CHILD.
DRAW US TO EUROPE PLAYGROUNDS OF
CREATIVITY GOD IF LIFE.
SO THAT WE WILL LIVE MORE FULLY
EACH DAY AMEN.
TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA.
AND TO.
MISSION.
INDIVISIBLE WITH NKRUMAH.
MEMBERS WE WILL MOVE TO
PRIVILEGES OF THE FLOOR.
MAY HAVE BEEN PRIVILEGES OF THE
FLOOR
SENATOR LAKE OF WHAT PURPOSE YOU
RISE.
TO PRESENT A RESOLUTION MISTER
PRESIDENT THANK YOU SO MUCH
TENER MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE RESOLUTION SEVENTY TWO BY
SENATOR LEYVA RELATIVE TO THE
FORTY FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF THE
ROE V. WADE DECISION.
HERE LEYVA.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT GOOD
AFTERNOON
THE PRESIDENT.
S. R. SEVENTY TWO COMMEMORATES
THE FORTY FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF
ROE VERSUS WADE BY RECOGNIZING
THE CRITICAL IMPORTANCE.
YOU'D ACCESS TO SAFE AND LEGAL
ABORTION
IN NINETEEN SEVENTY THREE ROE V.
WADE DECISION MADE ACCESS TO
ABORTION BULL SAFE AND LEGAL AND
HAS GREATLY IMPROVE THE HEALTH
OF WOMEN AND FAMILIES.
THIS LANDMARK DECISION HAS BEEN
THE CORNERSTONE OF WOMEN'S
EFFORTS TOWARDS EQUALITY. IF
EVERY IT ALLOWS EVERY WOMAN IN
THE UNITED STATES THE RIGHT TO
DECIDE WHEN IF AND WITH WHOM TO
HAVE CHILDREN.
THE REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM THAT
THIS CASE HAS PROVIDED IS
CRITICAL TO WOMAN'S ABILITY TO
PARTICIPATE FULLY IN THE SOCIAL
POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC LIFE OF
OUR STATE AND NATION.
WITH ONE IN FOUR WOMEN OBTAINING
AN ABORTION IN HER LIFETIME.
THE FORTY FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF
ROE VERSUS WADE IS A SIGNIFICANT
HISTORICAL REMINDER OF THE
IMPORTANCE OF SAFE AND MEDICALLY
ACCURATE REPRODUCTIVE AND SEXUAL
HEALTH CARE.
OVER SIXTY NINE PERCENT OF
AMERICANS OPPOSE EFFORTS TO
OVERTURN ROE VERSUS WADE WHICH
WOULD CREATE A PUBLIC HEALTH
CRISIS. BY ONCE AGAIN MAKING
ABORTION ILLEGAL AND UNSAFE.
S. R. SEVENTY TWO IS A CRITICAL
DECLARATION OF SUPPORT IN A TIME
WHEN ABORTION SERVICES AND
ABORTION PROVIDERS BY PLANNED
PARENTHOOD ARE UNDER SERIOUS
FEDERAL ATTACK. FOR PROVIDING
THIS ESSENTIAL HEALTHCARE.
THOUGH PRESIDENT TRUMP MAY
CONTINUE TO THREATEN THE MOST
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT THAT MILLIONS
OF WOMEN ACROSS OUR COUNTRY
DEPEND ON. WE HEARING CALIFORNIA
WILL ALWAYS STAND ALONGSIDE A
WOMAN'S RIGHT TO CHOOSE AND
FIGHT TO PROTECT THAT RIGHT
WITHOUT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH IS THERE ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE WE'RE GONNA
GO TO SENATOR JACKSON AND THEN
TO SENATOR SKINNER.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I TWO ONE A
RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BOTH AS
SAY. A CO AUTHOR AND IS SOMEONE
WHO'S BROUGHT THIS BILL MANY
TIMES BEFORE THIS HOUSE.
ALSO AS SOMEONE WHO REMEMBERS
WHEN THE DECISION OF ROE V. WADE
FIRST CAME DOWN.
I REMEMBER WHAT IT WAS LIKE
BEFORE ROLE CAME DOWN I WAS IN
COLLEGE AND I REMEMBER A COUPLE
OF MY. GIRLFRIENDS IN COLLEGE
WHO FOUND THEMSELVES WITH
UNEXPECTED AND UNWANTED
PREGNANCY EITHER BECAUSE THE
BIRTH CONTROL THAT WAS AVAILABLE
WAS INADEQUATE. WARD FAILED.
THEN I REMEMBERED THE TRAUMA OF
SENDING MY FRIENDS DOWN TO
MEXICO.
A TWO YOU WANNA IN FACT WHERE
THEY WOULD. THE ONLY ACCESS THEY
HAD TO TERMINATING AN UNWANTED
PREGNANCY. AND I HAD ONE FRIEND
WHO CAME BACK.
FOLK WHO BECAME STERILE AS A
RESULT OF A BOTCHED ILLEGAL
UNSAFE AND UNHEALTHY ABORTION.
THE TIMES HAVE CHANGED.
AND YET THERE ARE THOSE WHO
WOULD LIKE TO SEND US BACK TO
THOSE DAYS TO THE BACK ALLEYS
WHERE WOMEN. WERE FINDING
THEMSELVES.
IN A SITUATION WHERE THEY HAD
VERY LITTLE CHOICE AND VERY
LITTLE SAFETY IF THEY EXERCISE
THEIR CHOICE.
I REMEMBER TALKING TO PHYSICIANS
WHO PERFORMED ABORTIONS AND
ASKED THEM WHY THEY DID THAT AND
I REMEMBER ONE DOCTOR SAYING TO
ME. THAT WHEN HE WAS DOING HIS
RESIDENCY.
THERE WAS A WHOLE WING OF THE
HOSPITAL.
DEDICATED TO WOMEN WHO WOULD
COME IN WITH SEPSIS.
FROM BOTCHED ILLEGAL ABORTIONS.
FROM A HEALTH PERSPECTIVE ROE V.
WADE HAS GIVEN WOMEN THE
OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A DECISION
AN INTEGRAL IMPORTANT INTIMATE
DECISION WITHOUT FEAR OF LOSING
THEIR LIVES IN EXERCISING THEIR
DECISION.
I STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS EFFORT I STAND IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF THE NOTION THAT IF
WOMEN DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT TO
CONTROL THEIR REPRODUCTIVE
DESTINIES. THEY WILL NOT HAVE
FREEDOM WHICH IS A FUNDAMENTAL
RIGHT WITHIN OUR CONSTITUTION WE
CANNOT BE SHACKLED TO THOSE
REPRODUCTIVE.
REALITIES WITHOUT A CHOICE OF
WINTER WEATHER AND WITH WHOM
TECH EXERCISE THAT MOST
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT.
OF HAVING A FAMILY.
THIS IS A DECISION A TARD TO
BELIEVE THAT FORTY FIVE YEARS
LATER. WE'RE STILL FIGHTING FOR
THIS RIGHT FORCING IT UNDERMINED
BY PEOPLE WHO DON'T REALLY
NECESSARILY CARE ABOUT LIFE.
BUT WHAT THEY DO WANT IS TO PUT
WOMEN BACK. IN THE KITCHENS AND
BEDROOMS OF AMERICA WITHOUT THE
ABILITY TO COMPETE WITHOUT THE
ABILITY TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS
AND FREQUENTLY WITHOUT THE
ABILITY TO AFFORD THOSE
CHILDREN.
THIS IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT THIS
IS A FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT FOR WOMEN
IN PARTICULAR WE NEED TO BE ABLE
TO MAKE THOSE DECISIONS WITHOUT
POLITICIANS.
THE CITING THOSE MOST INTIMATE
ASPECTS OF OUR LIFE WITH THAT I
STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT. AND
THANK MY GOOD COLLEAGUE FOR
BRINGING THIS MATTER FORWARD.
THANK YOU SENATOR WHEN WE GO TO
SENATOR SKINNER.
WRITTEN.
THANK YOU AND I WANT TO THANK
CAR IN SENATOR FROM CHINO FROM
BRINGING THIS.
RESOLUTION TO S. AND.
.
GIVE KUDOS TO THE COMMENTS BY
OUR COLLEAGUE FROM SANTA
BARBARA.
I'D LIKE MANY OF YOU PROBABLY
WENT TO THE WOMAN'S MARCH.
IN YOUR.
DISTRICT THIS. PAST SATURDAY.
AND I WAS ONCE AGAIN THRILLED TO
SEE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE OF
THEIR.
OF EVERY AGE
OF EVERY SEX.
AND.
THE CREATIVITY OF THEIR SCIENCE.
MANY OF WHICH WERE FOCUSED ON
THIS VERY QUESTION.
A WOMAN'S ABILITY TO CONTROL.
HER REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES.
AND TO MAKE THE DECISIONS ABOUT
HER BODY.
NOW.
WE KNOW THAT IT'S WOMEN.
GOT TO VOTE.
OVER A HUNDRED YEARS AGO.
BUT WE WONDER MANY PEOPLE WONDER
WHY ARE WE STILL.
NOT.
IN THE HALLS OF POWER TO THE
NUMBERS IN OUR POPULATION
INDICATES.
WHY ARE WE NOT IN THE CORPORATE
BOARDROOMS OR THE CEOS TO THE
NUMBER THAT OUR POPULATION
INDICATES?
CLEARLY SOME OF IT IS STUDENT
EXTREME GENDER DISCRIMINATION
AND RULES AND POLICIES. THAT
KEPT US FROM THAT. BUT I WOULD
SUBMIT AND I THINK MOST WOMEN
WOULD AGREE.
THAT ONE OF THE OTHER REASONS
THAT WE WERE NOT ABLE TO ASSERT.
OUR LEGITIMATE ROLE IN THE HALLS
OF POWER.
IT'S BECAUSE WE DID NOT HAVE
FULL REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE.
AND WHEN WE HAD MORE CHILDREN
THAN MET WE MAY HAVE CHOSEN OR
CHILDREN THAT WE MAY NOT HAVE
BEEN ABLE TO AFFORD. OR OTHER
BURDENS THAT.
THAT FAMILY RESPONSIBILITY MAY
HAVE GIVEN THAT WHILE OF COURSE
WE LOVED OUR CHILDREN WAS NOT
NECESSARILY WHAT WE WOULD HAVE
CHOSEN BECAUSE WE DID NOT HAVE
FULL REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE.
IT PREVENTED US FROM EXERCISING
OTHER OPTIONS THAT PREVENTED US
THEN FROM REALLY EXERCISING OUR
POWER.
THAT IS ONE OF THE THINGS WE'VE
ELIMINATED ACCEPTED IS
SO BEING ERODED. IN STATES
ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND BY
DECISIONS SUCH AS THE CUTTING.
OF THE HEALTH MANDATE IN THE
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT.
SO I STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT AND
SOLIDARITY WITH THIS RESOLUTION
AND URGE THE AYE VOTE AND URGE
THAT WE TALK ABOUT THIS
CONTINUALLY AND CONSTANTLY.
THANK YOU SENATOR LET'S GO TO
SENATOR ATKINS.
THANK YOU. MISTER PRESIDENT PRO
TEM I ALSO STAND IN SUPPORT OF
SR SEVENTY TWO.
AND.
AS MY COLLEAGUE FROM CHINO
POINTED OUT.
I THE PASSAGE OF ROE VERSUS WADE
HAS DRASTICALLY REDUCE MATERNAL
MORTALITY RATES IN THIS COUNTRY.
YOU KNOW I WAS TEN YEARS OLD.
WHEN ROE VERSUS WADE.
WAS PASSED IN NINETEEN SEVENTY
THREE. AND SO I'VE HAD THE THE
FORTUNATE ABILITY TO GROW UP
DURING A TIME WHEN I HAD.
PROTECTIONS AND THE SUPPORT.
BUT FROM THE DAY IT PASSED.
BOB UNTIL NOW WE HAVE HAD TO
CONTINUALLY FIGHT TO KEEP THIS
AS A RIGHT.
FOR.
YOUNG WOMEN WOMEN AND FAMILIES.
YEAH I DO REMEMBER THE STORIES
EVEN AS.
IN MY EARLY TWENTIES WHEN I HAD
THE.
ABILITY TO WORK IN A CLINIC THAT
PROVIDED CRITICAL SERVICES
INCLUDING ABORTION SERVICES AS
WELL AS ALL OR ALL REPRODUCTIVE
HEALTH CARE SERVICES FOR WOMEN
AND THEIR FAMILIES.
AND I HEARD THE STORIES AND I
HEARD THE STORIES OF OLDER WOMEN
WHO HAD SUFFERED THROUGH TIMES
WHEN IT WASN'T A A POSSIBILITY
THAT THEY WOULD HAVE THAT HEALTH
CARE.
AND SO. WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE
THOSE OF US HERE TODAY THAT WE
CONTINUE TO SUPPORT THIS AND TO
PROTECT THESE RIGHTS.
SO THAT.
THOSE FOLLOWING US DON'T HAVE
TO SUFFER THE SAME FATE AS THE
WOMEN BEFORE US.
PRIOR TO THIS DECISION ILLEGAL
ABORTIONS ACCOUNTED FOR ABOUT
SEVENTEEN PERCENT OF ALL
REPORTED DEATHS ATTRIBUTABLE TO
PREGNANCY AND CHILDBIRTH IN THE
UNITED STATES.
I WORKED WITH A WOMAN IN THE MID
EIGHTIES WHOSE MOTHER DIED.
BECAUSE OF AN ILLEGAL ABORTION
SHE GREW UP WITHOUT HER MOTHER
AND IT POSSESSED HER TO COME ONE
A WORKING TO SUPPORT. WOMEN WHO
HAD THAT OPPORTUNITY SO HER
MOTHER WAS ONE OF THOSE
STATISTICS.
AND SADLY ENOUGH SHE IS NOT THE
ONLY WOMAN I KNOW.
THAT'S PART OF THOSE GRIM
STATISTICS OF THE REPORTED
DEATHS.
UNFORTUNATELY ABORTION REMAINS
ILLEGAL IN MANY COUNTRIES TODAY
A TRAVESTY THAT LISA THIRTEEN
PERCENT OF GLOBAL MATERNAL
DEATHS ANNUALLY OR THAT'S EIGHT
MATERNAL DEATHS EVERY SINGLE
OUR.
THE STATISTICS CONFIRM THAT ROE
VERSUS WADE HAS BEEN LIFESAVING
FOR WOMEN IN THIS COUNTRY.
SO I WOULD SAY IS WE RECOGNIZE
THIS LANDMARK ACHIEVEMENT OF THE
WOMEN'S MOVEMENT WE MUST ALSO
KEEP LOOKING FORWARD TO CONTINUE
TO ENSURE THAT THERE IS ACCESS
FOR ALL SERVICES AS WELL AS A
WOMAN'S RIGHT TO CHOOSE. SO JOIN
ME AND COMMEMORATING THIS
MONUMENTAL DECISION BY PUBLICLY
CONFIRMING CALIFORNIA STRONG
SUPPORT OF A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO
MAKE OUR OWN REPRODUCTIVE
CHOICES AND DECISIONS. AND
URGING OUR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO
SUPPORT REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE AS
WELL AS ACCESS TO COMPREHENSIVE.
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE
INCLUDING THOSE SERVICES
PROVIDED BY PLANNED PARENTHOOD I
WOULD ASK YOUR AYE VOTE ON SR
SEVENTY TWO.
THANK YOU CENTER ATKINS
SENATE MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MISTER
PRESIDENT I STAND A SHOULDER TO
SHOULDER WITH MY SISTERS ON THE
SENATE FLOOR TODAY ON IN URGING
SUPPORT FOR SR SEVENTY TWO. ON
OTHER I COULD THINK.
QUITE FRANKLY PLANNED
PARENTHOOD IN THE HUNDREDS OF
PEOPLE WHO SHOWED UP TODAY TO
PARTICIPATE IN A RALLY
COMMEMORATED NOT ONLY THE FORTY
FIFTH ANNIVERSARY ROLE THE WAY.
BUT TO REALLY SEND US AS POLICY
MAKERS A STRONG SIGNAL THAT THEY
WANT TO BE HEARD. AND THE MANTRA
THAT WE CHATTED OUT ON THE
CAPITOL STEPS THIS MORNING WAS
WE HEAR YOU.
AND. THAT REMINDED ME OF A SIGN
I THOUGHT THE WOMAN'S MARKS BACK
HERE THAT STILL STICKS WITH ME.
AND WITH THE OLDER WOMAN WHO
CARE TO SIGN THIS AND I CAN'T
BELIEVE IT'S FORTY FIVE YEARS
LATER AND I'M STILL MARCHING ON
THE SAME ISSUES.
AND SO I ONCE AGAIN HAVE TO
AGREE WITH HER THAT I CAN'T
BELIEVE IS FORTY FIVE YEARS
LATER.
ALL AS A WOMAN WITHIN HER
REPRODUCTIVE AGE THAT I'M STILL
SICK HAVING TO STAND UP. IN
RALLIES ON THE SENATE FLOOR AND
JUSTIFY MY ABILITY TO MAKE A
DECISION THAT IS BEST FOR ME AND
MY FAMILY. HOW ABSURD WHEN YOU
THINK ABOUT PUBLIC POLICY
DECISIONS WE'RE CONFRONTED WITH
EVERY DAY THERE AREN'T MANY?
THAT THAT ARE QUITE SO PERSONAL.
THAT PEOPLE WHO DON'T HAVE A
UTERUS WOULD INFERRING THAT I AM
INCAPABLE OF MAKING A DECISION
THAT'S BEST FOR ME IN MY BODY
AND MY LIFE AND MY FAMILY.
AND SO ONCE AGAIN LIKE THE SIGN
SUGGESTED I CAN'T BELIEVE THE
ONCE AGAIN I'M STANDING HERE.
HAVING TO VALIDATE MY CAPACITY
TO MAKE THAT DECISION BUT AS
LONG AS I HAVE TO. TRUST AND
BELIEVE AYE HUESO. AND SO AGAIN
TODAY I STAND ALONGSIDE MY
SISTERS ON THE SENATE. AND THE
MILLIONS OF WOMEN AND
ENLIGHTENED MEN ACROSS THIS
COUNTRY WHO UNDERSTAND THAT ROLE
THE WAY. WAS VALIDATING A BASIC
FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHT.
I SUPPORT SR SEVENTY TWO.
THANK YOU CENTER MITCHELL.
CENTER STONE.
GOOD MORNING MR PRESIDENTE AND
MEMBERS.
I'M GOING TO GIVE US A AN
OPPOSING VIEWPOINT BUT BEFORE I
SAY THAT LET ME SAY THAT I
RESPECT ALL OF YOU THAT IS STOOD
UP.
THIS IS A.
A RESOLUTION THAT WE SEE EVERY
YEAR IF THERE IS AN ISSUE THAT
PROBABLY DIVIDES ARE REPUBLICANS
AND DEMOCRATS THE MOST THIS IS
PROBABLY. ONE OF THOSE.
BUT WHAT COMPELS ME TO TO STAND
UP AS OF THE BROAD BRUSHING TO
SAY THAT THOSE THAT OPPOSE
ABORTION. DON'T BELIEVE IN LIFE.
AND THAT'S JUST REALLY SIMPLY
NOT TRUE.
I DO CARE ABOUT LIFE I CARE
ABOUT THE LIFE OF THE UNBORN
CHILD.
I ALSO CARE ABOUT THE LIFE OF
THE MOTHER.
AND IF THERE'S SITUATION WHERE A
MOTHER'S LIFE IS IN JEOPARDY
BECAUSE OF A PREGNANCY GONE.
WRONG ARE I SUPPORT.
MAKING SURE THAT WHEN WE GET THE
APPROPRIATE SERVICES TO MAKE
SURE THAT SHE LIVES.
.
BUT YOU KNOW WE TALK ABOUT
REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES THAT'S
ANOTHER.
PHRASE IT'S REALLY REALLY
MISINTERPRETED. YOU KNOW THERE'S
GOTTA BE SOME RESPONSIBILITIES
IN LIFE YET NO YOU'RE RIGHT I
DON'T HAVE A UTERUS.
AND SO I CAN UNDERSTAND THE
CRITICISM THAT MAYBE I'M NOT
GOING TO BE AS SENSITIVE AS MANY
OF YOU THAT STOOD UP ON THIS
FLOOR BUT WHEN I TALK ABOUT
REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES.
WE LIVE IN A TIME NOW. WHEN
THERE ARE MANY MODALITIES
AVAILABLE POOL TO BOTH MEN AND
WOMEN.
TO INSURE THAT WHEN THEY HAVE
INTIMATE RELATIONS THAT THERE IS
NO CONCEIVING A OF A CHILD.
YOU CAN GET CONTRACEPTIVES OR
CONTRACEPTIVES IN PHARMACIES
PHARMACISTS SOME PHARMACIES EVEN
ABILITY TO PRESCRIBE THOSE
CONTRACEPTIVES. THERE OVER THE
COUNTER A AIDS IT CAN ALSO A
CERTAINLY HELP.
PROPHYLACTIC.
YES WE ARE STILL IN USE BUT I
THINK OR SOME RESPONSIBILITIES
THAT COME WITH.
BEING A A HUMAN BEING AND AND
PRESERVING LIFE. IF YOU WANT TO
PRESERVE REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS AND
YOU DON'T WANT TO HAVE A CHILD
THAT MAKE THE APPROPRIATE.
PROTECTIONS WHILE YOU'RE
ENJOYING YOR INTIMACY.
WITH YOUR PARTNER IF YOU WANT
TO HAVE A CHILD THEN.
IT'S VERY EASY.
PROCESS TOO. TO TO GO THROUGH I
HAVE TO SAY THAT I'M VERY PROUD
OF MY MY NEPHEW CHASE.
WHO WAS IN THE MILITARY HE?
?
WORKS A ON NUCLEAR SUBS AND DOES
THE THE NUCLEAR POWER ASPECTS OF
IT WHEN TO SPECIAL SCHOOL. AND
HE HAS OF A LOVELY GIRL FRIEND
AND SHE GOT PREGNANT.
NINE MONTHS AGO AND. THEY WERE
FACED WITH SOME VERY DIFFICULT
DECISIONS.
AND I'M VERY PROUD OF CHASE.
THAT.
HE CHOSE.
WITH HIS GIRLFRIEND THEY HAVE
THIS BEAUTIFUL CHILD.
HER NAME IS ELLIE MAKING A MY
SISTER LAURIE A GRANDMOTHER FOR
THE FIRST TIME.
SO. WELL I CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND
AND RESPECT IN DOME VILIFY
ANYBODY STANDING UP TODAY
BECAUSE OF THEIR PERSONAL VIEWS.
ON ABORTION PLEASE DON'T BROAD
BRUSH US.
THAT MAY OPPOSE IT FOR YOUR.
DIFFERENT REASONS.
AND AND PLEASE DON'T DON'T
CLAIM THAT WE ARE AGAINST LIFE.
WHEN WE'RE LOOKING AT LIFE FROM
A DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVE THAT OF
THE UNBORN CHILD. FOR THOSE
REASONS I CAN'T SUPPORT US ARE
SEVENTY TWO.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE THAT'S
GONNA CENTER MONNING SKINNER
STERN AND SENATOR MORALE.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT.
MEMBERS.
AS A FEMINIST MARY TO A FAMILY
PRACTICE PHYSICIAN.
THE FATHER OF TWO DAUGHTERS TWO
GRANDDAUGHTERS.
I JUST WANT TO STAND IN
SOLIDARITY. WITH OUR SISTERS ON
THE FLOOR WHO BROUGHT.
S. R. SEVENTY TWO.
ENTER MINE TO MEMBERS THAT
THERE.
WE'RE LIVING IN AN ERA.
WHERE THERE'S UNFORTUNATELY AND
NEXUS A STRONG NEXUS?
BETWEEN STANDING FOR THE
PROTECTION OF A CONSTITUTIONAL
RIGHT.
AND WHAT WE SEE.
S. SEXIST MISOGYNIST CONDUCT IN
ALL INDUSTRIES.
A.
AFFECTING. WOMEN.
IN OUR INSTITUTION FARM WORKER
WOMEN CUSTODIANS.
PEOPLE IN HOLLYWOOD THERE'S HIGH
PROFILE STORIES.
BUT THERE'S ALSO THE EVERY DAY
STORIES.
AND THE NEXUS BETWEEN THE FIGHT
TO PROTECT A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO
CHOOSE.
AND THE MISOGYNY. THAT ALLOWS
PEOPLE TO TRY TO ENFORCE THEIR
WILL ON OTHERS.
IT IS INDEED CONNECTED.
IN I WOULD SUBMIT IN SUPPORT OF
SR SEVENTY TWO.
THAT THIS IS NOT A WOMEN'S
ISSUE.
IT IS A HUMAN RIGHT IS MY
COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES.
SO APTLY IDENTIFIED. AND I THINK
OUR RESPONSIBILITY IS MEN.
IS TO TEACH SONS AND DAUGHTERS
BUT ESPECIALLY SONS AT AN EARLY
AGE.
THAT EQUALITY MEANS TREATING.
ALL PEOPLE EQUALLY.
AND WITH RESPECT.
AND THE PEOPLE SHOULD EXPECT
CONSEQUENCES WHEN THEY DON'T.
AND I TO LOOK FORWARD TO THE
DAY.
WHEN WE DON'T HAVE TO FIGHT.
FOR THE PROTECTION OF THIS
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT.
THANK YOU BOMB.
MADAM AUTHOR OF SR SEVENTY TWO.
THANK YOU SO MUCH SENATOR THAT'S
GOING TO SENATOR STERN THEN
SENATOR MORALE. AND IN SENATOR
BRADFORD.
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES.
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF AS OUR
SEVENTY TWO AND. I'LL BE BRIEF.
I GREW UP.
TAKING IN MANY WAYS THIS
FREEDOM.
THAT WOMEN IN OUR SOCIETY HAVE
FOR GRANTED.
I WAS NOT BORN INTO A PERIOD
WHERE THERE WAS ANY QUESTION.
ABOUT WHETHER THIS FUNDAMENTAL
RIGHT.
TO HEALTH ACCESS TO CONTROL OVER
YOUR BODY WAS WAS IN JEOPARDY.
THERE'S BEEN REAL LITIGATED OVER
THE YEARS TIME AND TIME AGAIN IN
COURTS ACROSS THIS NATION. ARE
CONGRESS IN IN THIS BODY.
I HOPE THERE IS A DAY WHEN.
MY SON AND DAUGHTER WHO ARE NOT
YET BORN IN THAT FAMILY I DO
WANT TO HAVE AT THE TIME THAT. I
WANT TO HAVE THAT FAMILY WITH A
PARTNER. THAT I CHOOSE TO HAVE
THAT FAMILY WITH.
THEY CAN ALSO GROW UP IN AN ERA
WHERE MAYBE THEY DO TAKE IT FOR
GRANTED.
BUT THEY REALIZE THAT WHEN WE
SLEEP AT THE SWITCH.
THESE FREEDOMS MAY SLIP AWAY.
AND UNFORTUNATELY TODAY ARE
COURT HIS.
LOST TOUCH WITH THE SOCIAL NORMS
THAT DRIVE OUR SOCIETY IN BASIC
STATUS SCIENCE AND THE
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF OUR
CONSTITUTION.
AS OUR HOPE THEY DO THE RIGHT
THING BUT IF THEY DO NOT.
I WOULD CONCUR WITH MY COLLEAGUE
FROM LOS ANGELES THAT.
WE WILL DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO
BACK WOMEN UP WERE TO TAKE THAT
POWER BACK.
SUPPORTERS AS ARE SIMPLY TOO.
THANK YOU.
ETCETERA. YES THANK YOU MEMBERS.
.
THERE THIS IS A TOUCHY SUBJECT
WE ALL NOW.
THE NAME PLANNED PARENTHOOD
THOUGH.
I THINK IF YOU WERE JUST ASK
SOMEBODY WHO WASN'T ACQUAINTED
WITH THAT IT SOUNDS LIKE AN
ORGANIZATION WHO WANTS TO HELP
YOU PLAN FAMILIES BUT THE
REALITYOF IT IS. THEY THEY DO
PROMOTE THE ENDING OF OF LIFE SO
NUMBER ONE THAT NAME A SWORD AND
MISLEADING AND OF COURSE I CAN'T
SUPPORT IT BECAUSE. I BELIEVE
GOD IS THE AUTHOR AND.
.
THE GUY WHO BEGINS LIFE IN THE
ONE WHO TAKES LIFE IN ANYTHING
OTHER THAN THAT I DON'T THINK
POLITICIANS OR ANYBODY ELSE
SHOULD BE REGULATING. TAKEN THE
LIFE OF A HUMAN BEING CREATE AND
I'D SEMIS AND SO. FOR THAT
REASON TELL HE CHANGES HIS MIND
I CAN'T CHANGE MINE AND I WILL
BE ON THOUGH VOTE ON AS THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU
IT'S GOOD SENATOR BRADFORD WHERE
THEY NEED TO GO BACK CENTER
MITCHELL AND THEN CENTER
PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT AND I
STAND HERE TODAY BILL I'M NOT
WHERE MY PEAK IN STRONG
SOLIDARITY OF. A WOMAN'S RIGHT
TO CHOOSE AN END OF PLANNED
PARENTHOOD AS A SIGN OF A NURSE
I KNOW.
ALL TOO THE IMPORTANCE OF WOMEN.
THE REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE AND
NON.
THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE AS AS JUST A
COMMON COMMONSENSE RIGHT FOR
INDIVIDUAL.
I STAND HERE SOMEWHAT BEWILDERED
AT THE SAME INDIVIDUALS WHO
UPHOLDS THIS MEASURE ARE THE
SAME ADVOCATES FOR THE DEATH
PENALTY SO. HOW CAN YOU BE PRO
LIFE ON ONE END AND ANTI LIFE
ANOTHER AND SO I FIND THAT
SOMEWHAT OF THE?
IRONY BUT OF THIS IS COMMON
SENSE ARE DEAD RELATIVES AS A
SMALL KID GROWING UP.
HEARING ABOUT THE HORRORS OF.
BACK ALLEY ABORTIONS THAT
RELATIVES OF MINE HAD TO
EXPERIENCE IN THE FIFTIES AND
EARLY SIXTIES SO.
THIS IS A RIGHT THAT WE SHOULD
NO LONGER BE DEBATING.
A WOMAN HAS THE FULL RIGHT AND
OBLIGATION TO DO WHAT SHE
CHOOSES WITH HER BODY. AND
SOMETIMES.
ONE BECOMING. PREGNANT IT MIGHT
NOT HAVE BEEN THEIR CHOICE.
BECAUSE WOMAN BECOME.
IMPREGNATED BY RAPE INCEST
MOLESTATION ALL THOSE HORRIBLE.
CRIMES AND A WOMAN SHOULD HAVE
THE RIGHT TO DECIDE IF THEY
CARRY THAT CHILD TO TERM.
SO WITH BROWN MUCH MORE DEBATE.
AGAIN A SON OF A NURSE AND HAVE
TWO SISTERS I STAND IN STRONG.
SOLIDARITY OF SR SEVENTY TWO.
THANK YOU WE WELCOME BACK CENTER
MITCHELL.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MISTER PRESIDENT FOR ALONG THE
THE I HAVE A QUESTION OF THE OF
THE AUTHOR IF I MAY.
THEY'RE LIVID YOU SUB QUESTION.
THINK YOU ARE IT WAS REFERENCED
ON THE FLOOR.
SENATOR THAT PERHAPS
ON INDIVIDUAL SHOULD TAKE
RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR ACTIONS
AND AND IT WAS SUGGESTED THAT
CONTRACEPTIVE USE.
COULD PERHAPS PREVENT THE NEED
FOR AN ABORTION. AND I WAS
TRYING TO READ THE RESOLUTION
VERY QUICKLY I'M I'M PROUD TO BE
A CO AUTHOR ON BUT I WAS
WONDERING IF FROM YOUR
PERSPECTIVE OR IF IT'S STATED IN
THAT RESOLUTION BY CHANCE. BUT
CONTRACEPTIVES ARE A HUNDRED
PERCENT FULL PROOF PUBLIC TIME
IF YOU COULD RESPOND TO THAT
FORMAT APPRECIATED.
UNDER I GREATLY APPRECIATE THE
OPPORTUNITY TO RESPOND I HAD A
LITTLE NOTE HERE TO RESPOND TO
MY CLOSING BUT I'LL TAKE THE
OPPORTUNITY NOW. AND.
IT IS.
I THINK PROBABLY FOR ALL OF US
IT IS REALLY.
IRRITATING AT BEST WHEN PEOPLE
ACT LIKE ABORTION IS BIRTH
CONTROL MOST WOMEN THAT I KNOW
WHO HAVE CHOSEN TO HAVE A OF ON
ABORTION IS BECAUSE THEIR
CONTRACEPTIVE FAILED. THEY WERE
TRYING TO BE RESPONSIBLE AND
THEY WERE TRYING TO DO THE RIGHT
THING AND SOMETIMES.
IT HAPPENS IT'S UNEXPECTED AND A
WOMAN SHOULD ALWAYS HAVE THE
RIGHT TO CHOOSE WHEN SHE
INCORPORATES A FAMILY INTO HER
LIFE SO THANK YOU FOR THE
QUESTION. THANK YOU AND IS ALSO
ONE MORE QUESTION THE AUTHOR
FROM MAY THROUGH LEYVA PRESENT I
GUESS THANK YOU I I I RECOGNIZE
THAT THAT THE FOCUS OF THE
RESOLUTION IS TO COMMEMORATE THE
FORTY FIFTH ANNIVERSARY OF THE
SUPREME COURT RULING. AND I KNOW
SOMTIMES WE COMBINED THE ISSUES
AND PLANNED PARENTHOOD.
KIND OF GETS BROUGHT INTO THAT
IT INTO THE FOLD BUT BUT DOES
THE RESOLUTION ALSO TALK ABOUT
ALL OF THE OTHER MYRIAD OF
SERVICES THAT PLANNED
PARENTHOOD.
AUTHORS ARM RECOGNIZING THAT ON
THAT THE MY THE MINORITY THE
SMALL PERCENTAGE IF YOU WILL OF
THE SERVICES THEY PROVIDE ARE
ACTUALLY DIRECT ABORTION
SERVICES.
THE RESOLUTION ACTUALLY DOES AND
AS MOST OF US KNOW PLANNED
PARENTHOOD NINETY SEVEN PERCENT
OF THEIR SERVICES ARE NOT
ABORTION RELATED.
AND SO.
IT JUST IF I MAY MISTER
PRESIDENT WHEN I LOOK AT THE
CURRENT STATISTICS NATIONWIDE
CALIFORNIAN CLUED IT THAT LOOKS
AT THE INCREASE IN
INDUSTRIALIZING THEY FEEL LIKE
UNITED STATES. THE INCREASE IN
THE AFRICAN AMERICAN MATERNAL
MORBIDITY RATE THAT WE'RE
EXPRESS EXPERIENCING ACROSS THIS
COUNTRY TO SUGGEST THAT ANY
HEALTHCARE PROVIDER THAT
ATTEMPTS TO ASSIST WOMEN. IN.
ALL OF THEIR HEALTH CARE
SERVICES INCLUDING REPRODUCTIVE
SHOULD NOT BE SUPPORT IN DOING
SO I THINK IT'S IRRESPONSIBLE AT
BEST THANK YOU FOR CLARIFYING
THOSE POINTS FOR ME. THE COMMAND
CENTER.
MEMBERS RIGOROUS CENTER
PORTANTINO AND THEN TO SENATOR
PAINE.
THANK YOU I MISSPOKE TEMAN OF
MEMBERS OF I RISE TO SUPPORT TO
SCR SEVENTY TWO.
AND I ECHO THE COMMENTS OF MY
COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES.
I'M PROUD THAT THERE IS.
THRIVING.
IMPORTANT FRONTLINE HEALTH CARE
FACILITY IN MY DISTRICT A NUMBER
OF THEM RUN BY PLANNED
PARENTHOOD. PASADENA SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY. AND THE WOMEN AND MEN
WHO SEEK HEALTH CARE IN THOSE
FACILITIES.
OFTENTIMES HAVE NO OTHER CHOICE
FOR. ROUTINE.
SCREENINGS TASKS
AND THINGS MANY OF US WHO HAVE
CADILLAC HEALTH CARE TAKE FOR
GRANTED. AND THE SIGNIFICANT
ROLE THAT THEY PLAY.
IN THOSE COMMUNITIES PROVIDING
HEALTHCARE TO ALL WOMEN AND MEN
WHO NEED IT I IS INVALUABLE.
NO ONE IS PROMOTING ANYTHING
WITH THIS RESOLUTION OTHER THAN
WOMEN'S HEALTH.
AND WOMEN SOVEREIGNTY OVER THEIR
BODY AND THEIR REPRODUCTIVE
RIGHTS AND PRIVILEGES AND SO I
STRONGLY RA OUR RISE TO STRONGLY
SUPPORT SR SEVENTY TWO.
SENATOR PAINE.
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT
SASSANIDS AYE TO RISE AND STRONG
SUPPORT OF THIS RESOLUTION I
THINK MY GOOD FRIEND FROM CHINO
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD.
I AS A PHYSICIAN WILL CONFIRM
WHAT THE AUTHOR HAS SAID THAT
YES CONTRACEPTIVES ARE NOT ONE
HUNDRED PERCENT EFFECTIVE.
I THINK AS MY GOOD FRIEND.
FROM ONCE AND JUST MENTION ALSO
IS UNFORTUNATELY AS MUCH AS WE
HATE TO THINK ABOUT IT.
THEY'RE TOO OFTEN CIRCUMSTANCES
IN WHICH.
WOMAN. AND MAYBE EN HOME WHICH
HE GOT.
.
KING IMPREGNATED IT'S
UNFORTUNATE THREE THEIR VIOLENCE
OR OTHER TYPES OF OUR OUR.
.
THE SECTION OR OTHER WAYS THAT.
MAY NOT HAVE BEEN AFFORDED EVEN
THE OPPORTUNITY FOR PROTECTION.
AS WELL AND AGAIN THIS IS ABOUT
THE FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHT AS
WAS MENTIONED EARLIER. SO I HOPE
WE CAN ALL COME TOGETHER AND
CELEBRATE.
THIS VERY IMPORTANT ANNIVERSARY
AND WHICH SUPREME COURT DECLARED
THAT.
THIS IS A ABORTIONS A A
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT BECAUSE
IT'S FUNDAMENTALLY.
ABOUT A BE ABLE TO.
CONTROL YOUR OWN DESTINY AND
YOUR OWN BODY AND I THINK
HOPEFULLY WE CAN ALL AGREE ON
THAT WE CAN CERTAINLY MAKE OUR
OWN INDIVIDUAL CHOICES.
THERE'S NOTHING IN THAT DECISION
THAT PREVENTS ANY INDIVIDUAL
FROM MAKING THEIR OWN CHOICE.
LOOKING TO THEIR OWN GOD IF THEY
WORSHIP A GOD AYE AND LOOKING AT
THEIR OWN SOUL DECIDING WHAT
THEY WANT TO DO.
AND BUT EACH PERSON.
MAY COME TO A DIFFERENT
DECISION.
AND THEY SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT
TO BE ABLE TO MAKE A DECISION.
ABOUT WHAT'S RIGHT FOR THEM AND
THEIR OWN BODY.
AND THAT SHOULD BE A PRIVATE
DECISION BETWEEN THEMSELVES AND
WHOEVER. THEIR POSITION OTHER
HEALTHCARE PROVIDER WHOEVER ELSE
PROVIDES CARE TO THEM I THINK
THAT'S WHY WE ARE HERE TOGETHER.
TO CELEBRATE THIS ANNIVERSARY
THIS VERY IMPORTANT ANNIVERSARY.
AND SO I CAN THANK MY GOOD
FRIEND FROM TINA FOR BRINGING
THIS RESOLUTION FOR THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER PAN MEMBERS IS
ERNIE DIGITAL DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE FLOOR TO HAVE
ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THE FLOOR.
SENATOR LAKE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE PLEASE YES THANK YOU
MISTER PRESIDENT.
YOU KNOW I RAN FOR OFFICE I RAN
FOR A VARIETY OF REASONS AND
WHEN I GOT HERE TO SACRAMENTO I
LIKE ONE OF MY COLLEAGUES FROM.
MALIBU THOUGHT THAT A WOMAN'S
RIGHT TO CHOOSE WAS DONE AND
OVER WITH AND WASN'T SOMETHING
THAT WE HAD TO FIGHT OVER. I
CAN'T BE MORE PROUD AND I
COULDN'T BE HAPPIER TO GET TO BE
A SENATOR IN THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SENATE TO CONTINUE THIS
FIGHT BECAUSE AS MY OTHER
COLLEAGUES SAID IF WE HAVE TO
CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR THIS
RIGHT.
WE WILL CONTINUE TO FIGHT FOR
THIS RIGHT AND I JUST HAVE TO
GIVE A SHOUT OUT TO PLANNED
PARENTHOOD BECAUSE THESE ARE MEN
AND WOMEN THEY GO TO WORK EVERY
SINGLE DAY. THERE ARE UNDER
ATTACK VILE THINGS ARE SAID TO
THEM AND NINETY SEVEN PERCENT OF
THE SERVICES THAT THEY PROVIDE
OR ACTUALLY FOR THINGS OTHER
THAN ABORTION. THE WOMAN IN
TEXAS WHO WENT TO A PLANNED
PARENTHOOD CLINIC BECAUSE
PRESIDENT OBAMA TOLD HER TO SHE
HEARD HIM SAY IT ON TV. WAS
DIAGNOSED WITH CANCER AND IS
ALIVE TODAY BECAUSE SHE WENT TO
PLANNED PARENTHOOD.
SO LET US NOT FORGET THAT
PLANNED PARENTHOOD DOES SO MUCH
MORE AND PROVIDE SO MANY MORE
SERVICES TO MAINLY WOMEN WOMEN.
BUT MEN TO A ONE THING ALL MY
COLLEAGUES THAT SPOKE OUT IN
SUPPORT OF A WOMAN'S
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT.
TO CHOICE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE.
SURGERY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN. BY ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
DELEON.
AYE DODD. AYE FULLER. NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER. AYE
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL
AYE HUESO.
BY. ISLETA.
LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
I MONNING. I MORE LOCK.
NO MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
AYE STERN. AYE STONE.
NO BIDAK.
NO AYE KATHY. AYE WIENER.
I WILK.
NO.
EYES TWENTY.
SURE MICHIGAN PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS BATES.
NO.
BERRYHILL.
NO.
CANNELLA.
LARA.
MENDOZA. NGUYEN.
EYES TWENTY FIVE KNOWS ELEVEN.
THE RESOLUTION IS ADOPTED.
SENATOR LEYVA FOR WHAT PURPOSE
YOU RISE FOR INTRODUCTIONS
MISTER PRESIDENT PLEASE A FLOOR
IS YOURS IT IS NOW MY PLEASURE
TO INTRODUCE TO WOMEN THAT
BESIDES THEIR DAY JOBS ARE ALSO
FIGHTING FOR WOMEN'S RIGHTS
EVERYDAY. I WOULD LIKE TO
WELCOME ACTRESS ZOE DEUTSCH WHO
HAS STARRED IN SUCH FILMS AS
BEFORE I FAIL BASE THEIR OWN.
OH OKAY I SEE I PRESS.
OKAY.
THANK YOU OF SUCH FILMS AS
BEFORE I FALL EVERYBODY WANTS
SOME AND WHY HIM ZOE IS ALSO A
PASSIONATE ADVOCATE FOR PLANNED
PARENTHOOD AND WOMEN'S HEALTH.
WHEN SHE'S FILMING AND STATES
AROUND THE COUNTRY SO WE OFTEN
VISITS HEALTH CENTERS TO THINK
CLINIC STAFF FOR THEIR IMPORTANT
WORK. IS ALWAYS WHAT ZOE SO WAS
NAMED MY AXE MARA PHASE OF THE
FUTURE OF TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN
BY THE ORGANIZATION WOMEN IN
FILM FOR HER STRONG COMMITMENT
FOR SPEAKING UP FOR SOCIAL
CAUSES. FROM A YOUNG AGE I WOULD
ALSO LIKE TO INTRODUCE ACTRESS
ALLEY LARDER KNOWN FOR HER
COMPLEX POWERFUL FEMALE
CHARACTERS IN SUCH FILMS AS
LEGALLY BLONDE THE MULTIPLE
ROLES OF NIKKI AND JESSICA
SANDERS. AND TRACY STRAWS IN THE
TV SHOWS HEROES SHEEP SHOW
HEROES MOST RECENTLY ALLEY
STARRED IN THE GROUND MAKE
BREAKING TV SERIES PITCH.
ABOUT THE FIRST FEMALE MAJOR
LEAGUE PITCHER YAY. IN ADDITION
TO ACTING LA LOVES BEING A
MOTHER OF TWO AND USING HER
VOICE AS AN ADVOCATE FOR WOMEN'S
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
ALLEN HAS BEEN INCREDIBLE AL I
IN THIS MOVEMENT SPEAKING UP IN
STATES ALL ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
APART DURING WITH PATIENTS TO
ELEVATE THAT THEIR STORIES I
WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME BOTH OF
THE STRONG WOMEN TO THE
CALIFORNIA STATE SENATE. AND
THANK THEM FOR ALL OF THEIR WORK
ADVOCATING FOR WOMEN'S RIGHTS.
MASON GENERALLY CALIFORNIA STATE
SENATE LET'S WELCOME OUR GUESTS
ALRIGHT THEY SEE GENERAL WE'RE
GONNA BE NOW. CENTER PORTANTINO
FOR WHAT
PURPOSE YOU RISE.
FOR THE PURPOSE OF
INTRODUCTIONS NAM.
IT IS MY HONOR THAT TWO OF THE.
YOUNG SPEAKERS TODAY WHERE HIGH
SCHOOL STUDENTS UP FROM PASADENA
HIGH SCHOOL THEY ARE PART OF THE
PLANNED PARENTHOOD PEER
ADVOCATES PROGRAM.
MANY OF YOU ARE OUT THERE SAW
HOW ELOQUENT PASSIONATE DAY
WHERE I HANNAH ALL POLL SIN IN
MY A PER READ WHAT WERE THOSE
TWO.
SPEAKERS THIS MORNING.
IN TRADITION OF OUTSTANDING
YOUNG STUDENTS THEY RUSHED BACK
TO SCHOOL AFTER THEIR SPEECH BUT
I WAS ASKED TO MAKE SURE THAT
THEY WERE PROPERLY INTRODUCED ON
THE FLOOR FOR THEIR EXCELLENT
WORDS THIS MORNING AND SO. I
ASKED THIS BODY AYE IN ABSENTIA
TO SAY WELL DONE.
YOUNG ADVOCATES.
THANK YOU SENATOR PORTANTINO AND
THOSE YOUNG ADVOCATES SPOKE
EARLIER AND DID AN AMAZING JOB
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MEMBERS DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER
PRIVILEGES OF THE FLOOR.
SENATOR DODD DID YOU EVER
PRIVILEGE KNOW ANYONE ELSE HAVE
A PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR.
ALRIGHT WE ARE MOVING ON TO
MESSAGES FROM THE GOVERNOR WHICH
WILL BE DEEMED READ. MESSAGES
FROM THE SET ASSEMBLY WHICH WILL
BE DEEMED READ.
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES WILL BE
DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
ADOPTED. WE'RE NOW MOVING TO
MOTIONS RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES.
THERE ARE FOUR AMENDMENTS AT THE
DESK AND THEY WILL BE DEEMED
ADOPTED.
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE TWENTY
NINE TEN SEE THE FOLLOWING BILLS
ARE RULE REFERRED TO THE RULES
COMMITTEE S. B. SIX SO TO.
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE TWENTY
NINE TEN BE THE FOLLOWING BILLS
ARE REFERRED TO THE RULES
COMMITTEE.
S. B. FOR SIXTY.
WE'LL NOW MOVE TO INTRODUCTION
AND FIRST READING OF BILLS.
CONSIDERATION OF THE DAILY FILE.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL NINE THIRTEEN NINE
FOURTEEN NINE FIFTEEN.
SENATE BILL
I SEVENTY.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY WE
WILL NOW MOVE TO GOVERNOR'S
APPOINTMENTS.
FIRST WE WILL DO THE SECOND
READING FILE MISTER SECRETARY.
SENATE BILL SIX NINETY ONE.
TO FIFTEEN TO TWENTY SEVEN THREE
TWENTY.
FOR SIXTY SEVEN FIFTY NINE
SENATE BILL THREE NINE NINE
WITH.
THE BILL SEVEN OF SEVEN SENATE
BILL ONE SIXTY EIGHT.
THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY.
MR PRO TEM DID YOU WANT TO DO
THE GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENT.
SENATOR CANNELLA.
YES
THE FLOOR IS YOURS.
ALRIGHT GOVERNOR'S APPOINTMENTS
GOES APPOINTMENTS ERECT.
SO FIRST OF FILE I'M FORTY FOUR
ARE ACTUALLY. BOTH THESE ARE UP
THE OF ON BURKE AND JOSEPH
TRAVEL ONLY MEMBER CALIFORNIA
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION.
THE COMMISSION IS RESPONSIBLE
FOR ALLOCATING FUNDING FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION AND IMPROVEMENT OF
HIGHWAY PASSENGER RAIL TRANSIT
ACTIVE TRANSPORTATION
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS. MISS
BURKE HAS A LONG HISTORY. IN
PUBLIC SERVICES COUNTY
SUPERVISOR SO ME NUMBER AND
CONGRESSIONAL REPRESENTATIVE.
MISTER JAVELIN IS BEEN PRESIDENT
OF A FAMILY OWN CONSTRUCTION
BUSINESS AVELLONE CONSTRUCTION
AND DEVELOPMENT THINK SINCE
NINETEEN SIXTY TWO. BOTH WERE
APPROVED ON UNANIMOUS VOTE IN
THE SENATE RULES COMMITTEE
HEARING PASS FOR A VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR CANNELLA.
SO HURT HERTZBERG.
HE JUST VERY BRIEFLY.
MADAM PRESIDENT I JUST WANNA
RISE IN SUPPORT OF US.
SUPERVISOR FORMER MEMBER OF
CONGRESS YVONNE BRATHWAITE
BURKE.
SHE. ADORED THE COVER OF TIME
MAGAZIN IN NINETEEN SEVENTY TWO.
SHE WAS AND CONTINUES TO BE AN
EXTRAORDINARY PIONEER IN THE
FACT THAT SHE AND HER HUSBAND
BILL BURKE WHO SERVED A NUMBER
OF COMMISSIONS CONTINUE TO
SERVE.
CALIFORNIA IS AN EXTRAORDINARY
ADVANTAGE TO ALL OF US AND I
JUST WANT TO STAND IN STRONG
SUPPORT OF SUPERVISOR BURKE.
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG.
ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS
QUESTIONS MR SECRETARY WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
NO ATKINS.
BATES.
NO. BELL.
BY BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
BY CANNELLA AYE DELEON.
DODD.
BY FULLER.
NO. GAINES.
GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL. AYE HUESO AYE JACKSON
AYE LARA.
LEYVA.
I'M ACQUIRE.
BY MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
I'M MORE LOCK.
MORRELL.
NO NEWMAN.
IF I WIN.
NIELSEN.
PAN.
BY PORTANTINO.
I ROTH. AYE SKINNER.
AYE STERN AYE STONE.
BUT ACT.
NO.
BY KATHY.
I WINNER. BY WILK AYE.
ATKINS I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
DALY OWN.
I.
GAINES.
LOTTE.
MENDOZA MORLOCK.
I.
NGUYEN.
I NELSON.
STONE.
EYES THIRTY KNOWS FIVE THE
APPOINTMENTS ARE CONFIRMED THANK
YOU MISTER SECRETARY.
SENATE CANNELLA.
BUT WE.
NO WE DON'T.
WHAT?
I WAS IT
.
MEMBERS HOGAN THE MOVING ON TO
THE SENATE THIRD READING.
SENATOR ANDERSON ITEM NUMBER
FORTY SIX.
EVERYDAY.
OUR YOU PREPARED RIGHT MISTER
SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN TWELVE BY
SENATOR ANDERSON AND THAT KIND
OF VEHICLES.
SENATOR ANDERSON.
MEMBERS NOT TARA NOT EVERYBODY
CAN AFFORD A GARAGE SURE.
OUR APPEAL TO.
.
COVER THE CAR MANY PEOPLE LIKE
JUST TWO BLOCKS FROM THE
CAPITOL.
PEPPERMINTS TO PARK ON THE
STREET AND WE PROVIDE THEM WITH
THE ABILITY TO PROTECT AND
INVESTMENT. BY ALLOWING THEM TO
COMPLETELY COVER THEIR CAR
INCLUDING THEIR LICENSE PLATE.
AS LONG AS LAW ENFORCEMENT THE
ONE THE PARK LEGALLY INTO LAW
ENFORCEMENT IS ABLE TO LIFT.
THE COVER TO SEE THE LICENSE
PLATE.
I.
WITH THEIR WITH THE NEW
TECHNOLOGIES ARE OUT THERE NOW.
MANY PRIVATE COMPANIES ARE
DRIVING AROUND THE NEIGHBORHOODS
COLLECTING THE DATA. IN SELLING
THAT DATA OF WHERE THESE PEOPLE
PARKING.
I BELIEVE THAT THEY DESERVE THE
SAME RIGHTS TO PRIVACY THAT
ANYBODY THAT OWNS A HOME OR OWNS
A GARAGE. IS ABLE TO ACHIEVE.
SO WHAT MY BILL DOES
ESSENTIALLY.
IS IT.
THE CAR MUST BE LEGALLY PARKED.
IT MUST.
ALLOW LAW ENFORCEMENT TO SEE THE
LICENSE PLATE WITH A PHYSICALLY
WANNA SEE IT.
AND.
WHAT IT DOESN'T DO IS IT
DOESN'T ALLOW SOMEONE TO DRIVE
WITH THE LICENSE PLATE COVERED?
JUST LIKE UNDER CURRENT LAW DOES
NOT CHANGE ANY OF THAT
WHATSOEVER.
.
YOU KNOW.
I HAVE BROUGHT MANY. PRIVACY
BILLS BEFORE YOU IN THE PAST
BECAUSE I'M I'M DEEPLY CONCERNED
ABOUT THE EROSION OF OUR CIVIL
LIBERTIES.
YOU KNOW IF EUROPE. DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE.
VICTIMS OR IF YOU'RE BEING
STALKED.
OR IF YOU HAVE RELIGIOUS
AFFILIATIONS ALL THESE THINGS
CAN BE SURVEYED.
IN SEOUL AND I BELIEVE THAT
EVERY CALIFORNIAN DESERVES A
RIGHT TO PRIVACY NOW IF YOU
CHOOSE. NOT TO USE THIS PRIVACY
THAT'S YOUR CHOICE BUT YOUR
PRIVACY SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN FROM
YOU WITHOUT YOUR CHOICE.
MEMBERS AYE URGING AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON THE
SENATOR WIENER.
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH FRONTERA
COLORS I RISE IN SUPPORT. OF
THIS MEASURE ON CIVIC THIS IS A
CLOSE CALL AND I KNOW THAT THERE
ARE THOSE TIME CLUED IN LAW
ENFORCEMENT. ON WHO DO NOT
SUPPORT IT I DO THIS A BILL LOT
OF CONSIDERATION PARTICULAR LAST
YEAR WHEN IT FIRST CAME. OUT TO
THE TRANSPORTATION HOUSING
COMMITTEE ABOUT ULTIMATELY.
I DECIDED THAT ON BALANCE I WAS
WORTHY OF SUPPORT I THINK IT IS.
REALLY IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND
THAT YOU CAN ALREADY AS THE
AUTHOR I HAVE SAID RIGHT NOW
TODAY YOU CAN ALREADY COVER YOUR
LICENSE PLATE WITH THE DUST
COVER. SEEKING TIRED COVER THE
ENTIRE CAR.
INCLUDING LICENSE PLATE BUT YOU
CAN'T JUST COVER THE LICENSE
PLATE.
AND THIS BILL REQUIRES THAT IT
WOULD BE YOU'D BETTER BE
REMOVABLE THAT YOU CAN EASILY
LIFTED UP TO SEE WHAT THIS BILL
WILL DO. BY IS WILL ALLOW PEOPLE
TO OPT OUT OF THE MASS VIDEO
WING. OF LICENSE PLATES
AND WE KNOW THAT.
DOT HAPPENS FOR SOME VERY VALID
REASONS.
IT CAN ALSO HAPPEN.
FOR SOME NOT VERY VALID REASONS
WHAT WE KNOW THAT BODIES
HAS ACTUALLY ISSUED.
ó ON ITS WEBSITE STATES
BETTER WILL CONTRACT FOR THIS
INFORMATION TO HELP IDENTIFY
PEOPLE WHO ARE HERE.
WITHOUT DOCUMENTS ARE WE KNOW
THAT HIGH IN TEXAS OTHER WAS A
SITUATION WHERE I ANTI CHOICE
ACTIVISTS WERE PHOTOGRAPHING
LICENSE PLATES. OUGHT TO TRY TO
HARASS WOMEN WHO ARE SEEKING
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH.
SERVICES AND WE KNOW THAT THERE
ARE PEOPLE WHO CAN ARISE LGBT
PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT OUT OF THE
CLOSET BUT ARE GOING TO GAY
BARS.
SO THERE ARE.
VERY VALID REASONS FOR PEOPLE
WANTING TO PUT A REMOVABLE COVER
ON THEIR PLAY AND AGAIN TO BE
CLEAR. YOU CAN ALREADY DO IT
TODAY BY COVERING YOUR ENTIRE
CAR SO ON BALANCE UNDERSTAND
THAT THERE ARE GOOD ARGUMENTS ON
BOTH SIDES AND I DO SUPPORT THIS
BILL.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER SENATOR
JACKSON.
YES THANK YOU A MAN PRESENT
COLLEAGUES.
.
THE PROLIFERATION OF AUTOMATED
LICENSE PLATE RECOGNITION
SYSTEMS WHICH IS THE FANCY NAME
FOR. A PEOPLE SNOOPING AROUND
YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD AND TAKING
PHOTOGRAPHS OF YOUR CARS.
.
IS A SERIOUS PRIVACY CONCERNS.
I TOTALLY AGREE WITH THAT AND I
KNOW THAT MY GOOD COLLEAGUE FROM
IN THE PARK DOES TO.
BUT THIS BILL IS NOT THE
SOLUTION.
THE SOLUTION IS MORE LIKE
BANNING THOSE COMPANIES FROM
GOING AROUND AND SNOOPING AND
TAKING PICTURES OF YOUR LICENSE
PLATE.
THAT'S A SOLUTION.
BUT THIS BILL. RESTRICTS ACCESS
TO LICENSE PLATE INFORMATION
WHICH DOES PREVENT PUBLIC SAFETY
ISSUES IN BOTH EVERYDAY
SITUATIONS AND EMERGENCY
SCENARIOS WHICH IS WHY LAW
ENFORCEMENT IS SUPPOSED TO THIS.
LAW ENFORCEMENT A BM A HINDERED
IN ITS ABILITY TO ENFORCE BASIC
PARKING ORDINANCES.
WITHOUT ACCESS TO LICENSE PLATE
DATA IMAGINE GOING AROUND AND
FLIPPING UP EVERY LICENSE PLATE.
TO SEE WHETHER OR TO SEE WHETHER
OR NOT IT'S A STOLEN CAR.
OR TO SEE WHETHER OR NOT THE
PERSON WHO'S PARKING IN A
DISABILITY SPOT ACTUALLY HAS THE
RIGHT TO DO SO. WE KNOW LAW
ENFORCEMENT IS NOTHING ELSE TO
DO. THAN THIS KIND OF THING.
WHAT ABOUT THE COMPANY?
HOW ABOUT IF WE PROHIBIT
COMPANIES FROM GOING AROUND AND
ACCESSING THIS INFORMATION
BECAUSE THEY THEN AGGREGATED AND
THEY SELL IT?
WE ARE DOING AS MY MOTHER IS TO
SAY PUTTING THE EMPHASIS ON THE
WRONG SO OBEL HERE.
AND IN THIS CASE THIS BILL IS
DEFINITELY NOT THE ANSWER AND I
AGREE WITH THE AUTHOR THAT
SOMETHING MUST BE DONE TO
PROTECT OUR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT OF
PRIVACY. SIMILAR TO WHAT WE WERE
TALKING ABOUT WITH OUR ROE V.
WADE RESOLUTION WHAT MORE RIGHT
OF PRIVACY IS HERE THAN A
WOMAN'S REPRODUCTIVE DECISION
MAKING. BUT LAST I DIGRESS.
WE NEED LEGISLATION.
THAT ADDRESSES THE WIDESPREAD
COLLECTION OF THIS DATA AND THE
RETENTION AND SALE OF THIS DATA.
THIS TECHNOLOGY IS BEING USED AS
A TOOL TO INVADE OUR CITIZENS
PRIVACY AND MAKE A PROFIT OFF OF
IT.
THIS IS INFORMATION THAT ALSO
CAN BE USED TO SUBSEQUENTLY
TRACKED THE MOVEMENTS OF
VEHICLES.
IN THE MEANTIME THEY'RE SERIOUS
HOLES IN THE SECURITY
REQUIREMENTS FOR HANDLING THIS
INFORMATION AS A CHANGES HANDS
THAT'S THE RIGHT SOLANO BOWL AS
THEY SAY. THEREFORE THIS IS THE
WRONG WAY TO APPROACH A VERY
SERIOUS PROBLEM I AM GOING TO BE
OPPOSING THIS BILL TODAY URGING
THE SAME FROM MY COLLEAGUES BUT
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
CONSTRUCTIVELY TO ADDRESS THIS
VERY REAL PROBLEM. UNDERLYING
THE USE OF THESE EIGHT DEL PR
SYSTEMS WITH THAT I WOULD URGE A
NO VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR JACKSON SOONER
NIELSEN IS YOUR MICROPHONE UP.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS THERE ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE SENATOR ANDERSON
ENJOY TO CLOE I WOULD AS A
MATTER FACT WILL FIRST OF ALL.
.
IT SHOULD HAVE REGULATING WHOLE
INDUSTRY I WAS TRYING TO ALLOW
PEOPLE WHO WANT PRIVACY TO
RECEIVE PRIVACY.
YOU KNOW SOME.
FOLKS GET VANITY PLATES.
THEY HAVE NO CONCERN FOR THEIR
PRIVACY.
AND THEY HAVE CHOSEN TO CHOOSE
THEY'VE CHOSEN TO TRADE THEIR
PRIVACY.
FOR CONVENIENCE
AND THEY SHOULD HAVE A RIGHT TO
DO THAT.
BUT NOT EVERYBODY CAN AS VANITY
PLATES AND NOT EVERYBODY WANTS
TO BE TRACKED IN THIS BILL.
THAT'S THAT FINE LINE THAT
ALLOWS THEM TO PROTECT THEIR
PRIVACY WHILE AT THE SAME TIME.
AND YOU KNOW ARE IN AS TO THE
ISSUE WHETHER THIS IS GOOD OR
BAD FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT.
BLAH ENFORCEMENT HASN'T ONCE IN
ALL THE PUBLICATIONS THEY PASSED
OUT TO US.
SAID THAT COVERING YOUR CAR.
WHICH IS LEGAL.
TODAY IN PARKING IT THE SAUCE IS
PART IN A LEGAL PARKING SPACE
COVER YOUR CAR ENTIRELY.
HURTS THEM. IN ENFORCING LAWS.
HOWEVER.
YOU YOU KNOW AND I'M HAVING A
HARD TIME THINKING.
MEN PRESIDENT.
PERHAPS WE COULD HAVE A
LITTLE QUIET.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I APOLOGIZE
SENATOR INCIDENTS ON THAT LOUD
UP HERE. WELL THANK YOU.
ARE.
HOWEVER IF YOU ONLY COVERED THE
PLATE.
THEY SAY THAT MAKES IT MUCH
WORSE THAN KIDS ARE GONNA BE
KIDNAPPED
CELEBUTANTE.
I CAN SEE THE COLOR OF THE CAR I
CAN SEE THE MAKE THE MODEL THE
YEAR WAS MADE.
I CAN ACTUALLY EVEN SEE INSIDE
THE CAR COULD TOOK NOTICE OF A
CHILD'S BEEN APPREHENDED.
BUT I CAN ALSO SEE A CAR THAT'S
COMPLETELY CLUB.
FROM TOP TO BOTTOM AND YET THEY
SAY THAT'S NOT A THREAT TO
PUBLIC SAFETY.
WE NEED PER THINKING CAPS ON.
WE NEED TO THINK ABOUT THIS IT
DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.
IF YOU CAN FULLY COVER A CAR.
AND WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT AND
I THINK IN THIS ROOM AB ONE OR
TWO PEOPLE ARE GONNA COVER THE
LICENSE PLATE AND MAYBE NOT EVEN
THAT MANY.
BUT FOR THOSE WHO DON'T HAVE THE
OPTION OF PARKING IN THE GARAGE
OR IN SOME SORT OF STRUCTURE.
FOR THOSE PEOPLE DON'T THEY
DESERVE THE SAME RIGHTS AS
EVERYBODY WHO OWNS A GARAGE.
BECAUSE SOME POOR.
DO I NOT HAVE THE SAME RIGHTS TO
PRIVACY IS A RICH PERSON.
BECAUSE I CAN BARELY AFFORD A
CAR. SHOULD I NOT HAVE THE RIGHT
TO CONTROL WHO HAS MY DATA
ANDWHO GETS TO SELL IT AND MAKE
A
PROFIT.
AWFUL WHERE I PARK.
THOUGHT MEMBERS ARE I KNOW THIS
IS A DIFFICULT BUILDER STRONG
ARGUMENTS ON BOTH SIDES.
BUT THE NOTION THAT THIS IS HARD
ARE.
THAT THIS IS GOING TO STOP CRIME
FIGHTING. BECAUSE YOU GET TO SEE
THEM MAKE THE MODEL THE CAR THE
YEAR DOC SEES ME THAT. THE COLOR
IN INSIDE THE CAR.
SOMEHOW MAKES IT A GREATER
THREAT TO PUBLIC SFETY IF YOU
FULLY COVER THE CAR ON A PUBLIC
STREET MAKES NO SENSE AND BY THE
WAY.
IF YOU REALLY A PROFESSIONAL
CRIMINAL.
YOU'VE MOST LIKELY STOLEN
SOMEBODY ELSE'S LICENSE PLATE
AND PUT IT ON YOUR CAR OR IF
TURN AROUND HIM SIMPLY STOLEN A
CAR TO COMMIT THAT CRIME.
BUT YOU'RE NOT GONNA BE GOING
OUT AND RUNNING IN COVERING YOUR
LICENSE PLATE AND BY THE WAY
WHEN YOU MOVE WHEN YOU DRIVE ON
TO THE FREEWAY WHEN YOU DRIVE
THROUGH THE ROADS WERE. THEM
WERE THE MAJORITY OF CRIME AS
CLARK THROUGH LICENSE PLATES.
YOU'RE ALREADY TRAVELING THROUGH
LICENSE PLATE READERS AND YOU
CANNOT COVER.
YOUR LICENSE WHEN YOU'RE
DRIVING.
ARE NOT INCREDIBLE NOT IN THE
FUTURE LAW IF THIS GOES TO THE
GOVERNING IT SIGNED INTO LAW.
SO LET'S JUST.
TO SUMMARIZE IT WILL QUICKLY.
THIS BILL DOES NOTHING MORE THAN
EXCEPT CRIMINAL.
AND SAY THAT YOU DON'T HAVE TO
FULLY COVER YOUR CAR YOU'RE
ALLOWED TO COVER JUST THE
LICENSE PLATE IS LONG AS LAW
ENFORCEMENT.
MAY LIFTED TO SEE IN MAJOR PLATE
IF THERE'S A PARKING VIOLATION.
MEMBERS I URGING AYE VOTE THIS
IS . OUR CONSTITUTIONAL
PROTECTION.
WITH YOUR RICHARD POOR EVERYONE
DESERVES A RIGHT TO PRIVACY.
THANK YOU SENATOR ANDERSON
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
NO ANDERSON.
I ATKINS.
BATES.
I BILL.
I BERRYHILL.
I BRADFORD.
CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
DODD.
NO FULLER.
I GAINES.
I GALGIANI.
NO GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ.
NO HERTZBERG.
HILL.
I HUESO.
JACKSON.
NO.
LARA LEYVA.
NO MCGUIRE.
NO MENDOZA. MITCHELL.
I. MONNING.
NO MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL.
NEWMAN.
NO NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
NO. PAN.
NO PORTANTINO.
NO ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
NO STONE.
BY JACK.
I LIKE COUNTY.
NO WIENER.
I WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ADKINS.
BRADFORD.
DALY OWN.
GLAZER.
NO HERTZBERG.
HUESO.
LOTTE.
MENDOZA.
MORRELL STONE.
SENATOR ANDERSON MOVES A CALL.
YOU'RE WELCOME.
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM FORTY SEVEN SENATOR
JACKSON'S.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL TWO TWENTY FOUR BY
SENATOR JACKSON AND THAT KIND OF
PERSONAL RIGHTS.
SENATOR JACKSON'S IS THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES THE
BASIC RIGHT OF EVERY WOMAN TO
FEEL. OUR TO SAFELY PURSUE
ECONOMIC SECURITY ADVANCEMENT.
AND PROFESSIONAL OPPORTUNITIES
FREE FROM HARASSMENT.
AND ABUSE HAS BEEN CODIFIED IN
CALIFORNIA LAW FOR DECADES.
YET THIS PROHIBITED BEHAVIOR HAS
PERSISTED AND DAMAGE THE LIVES
AND WELL BEING OF FAR TOO MANY
WOMEN FOR FAR TOO LONG.
CALIFORNIA MUST TAKE EVERY STEP
WE CAN TO MAKE IT CLEAR THAT
SEXUAL MISCONDUCT IS NOT A FACT
OF LIFE FOR PROFESSIONAL LIFE
FOR WOMEN.
S. B. TWO TO FOUR AMEND CMU
CIVIL RIGHTS ACT TO ADD
INVESTOR.
ELECTED OFFICIAL.
LOBBYIST DIRECTOR AND PRODUCER.
TO THE LIST OF EXAMPLES OF
RELATIONSHIPS THAT ARE
SPECIFICALLY COVERED UNDER THE
CIVIL CODE SECTION FIFTY ONE
POINT NINE.
THIS SECTION ESTABLISHES CIVIL
LIABILITY FOR SEXUAL HARASSMENT
IN BUSINESS
SERVICE AND PROFESSIONAL
RELATIONSHIPS
AND BY EXPLICITLY INCLUDING
INVESTORS SELECTED OFFICIALS
LOBBYIST DIRECTORS AND
PRODUCERS.
AMONG THOSE LISTED PERSONS WHO
MAY BE LIABLE FOR SEXUAL
HARASSMENT. THIS MEASURE
ADDRESSES THE UNIQUE
RELATIONSHIP THAT EXISTS IN
THESE RELATIONSHIPS AS WELL AS
IN A VARIETY OF OTHER
INDUSTRIES.
WHERE HARASSMENT WE KNOW FROM
WHAT WE HAVE READ IN THE PAPERS
TO THE HORROR OF MOST OF US?
HAS BEEN PERVASIVE.
AND IN INCLUDES THOSE
PROHIBITIONS WITHIN THE ONEROUS
CIVIL RIGHTS ACT.
S. THE ISSUES HAVE EMERGED WE'VE
CONTINUED TO CRAFTING CONSIDER
LANGUAGE FOR THAT THIS BILL THAT
ADDRESSES EXISTING WEAKNESSES IN
OUR LAW. AND WE ARE PLANNING TO
MOVE FORWARD WITH ANTI
RETALIATION LANGUAGE.
TRULY AN ADEQUATELY PROTECT
THOSE WHO HAVE COURAGEOUSLY COME
FORWARD.
AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE LANGUAGE
TO ADDRESS INSTANCES WHEN
PERPETRATORS MISREPRESENT.
DON'T MISREPRESENT THEIR
PROFESSIONAL CAPACITY IN AN
ATTEMPT TO COERCE AND ABUSE
VICTIMS.
WE MUST CHANGE THIS CULTURE
COLLEAGUES AND WE KNOW IT.
AND WE HAVE TO STRENGTHEN OUR
LAWS SO IT'S CLEAR THAT
HARASSMENT AND ABUSE IS NOT
ACCEPTABLE.
AND ANY AND EVERY STAGE IN THESE
RELATIONSHIPS.
THIS MEASURE SEEKS TO DO THAT.
MY UNDERSTANDING IS S. HAS
SUPPORT ON BOTH SIDES OF THE
AISLE AND I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE. PIGGY CENTER
JACKSON MEMBERS IS THERE ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN.
BY ANDERSON.
ATKINS.
I BATES.
BYE BILL. BY BERRYHILL. AYE
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA.
I DID LEóN.
I DODD.
I FULLER. AYE GAINES AYE
GALGIANI.
CLICK. AYE GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ.
AYE HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE
HUESO.
BY JACKSON. AYE LARA.
LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA MITCHELL.
I MONNING.
I'M MORE LOCK.
I'M A REAL.
BY NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
BY PAN. AYE PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
I SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE.
I'VE AYE DECK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
I WINNER.
BY.
WILK BY.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ANDERSON. AYE. LARA MENDOZA.
EYES THIRTY EIGHT N ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING TO FIE ITEM FORTY EIGHT
SENATOR WIENER MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN TWENTY SIX BY
SENATOR WINNER AND ARE GOING TO
TAXATION.
CENTER WIENER. THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR.
COLLEAGUES SIGHING CALIFORNIA
BY EXISTING SALES AND USE TAX
EXEMPTIONS TOTAL OVER TWENTY TWO
BILLION DOLLARS. BY WHICH IS
TWELVE PERCENT OF OUR STATE
BUDGET FOR THE TWENTY SEVENTEEN
TO EIGHTEEN FISCAL YEAR.
CURRENTLY NEITHER THE
LEGISLATURE NOR ANY OTHER STATE
DEPARTMENT REVIEWS THESE TAX
EXPENDITURES ARE MEASURES.
FOR THEIR EFFECTIVENESS EVEN
THOUGH THE FUNDS ARE A
SIGNIFICANT LOSS TO OUR BASIC
TAX STRUCTURE. BY WITHOUT SENATE
BILL SEVEN TWENTY SIX WOULD
REQUIRE THAT ANY BILL INTRODUCED
BY THE LEGISLATURE.
THAT INVOLVES A NEW SALES OR
USE TAX EXEMPTION OF REQUIRES
THAT ALSO INCLUDE REASONING
OFFER THE EXEMPTION AS WELL AS
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS. ISP
SEVEN TWENTY SIX WOULD ONLY
APPLY TO BILLS INTRODUCED ON OR
AFTER JANUARY FIRST TWO THOUSAND
NINETEEN. I THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
BILL THAT BUILDS UPON THE WORK
OF MY PREDECESSORS CENTER LENO
AYE HIS SP THIRTEEN THIRTY FIVE.
WHICH REQUIRED ALL TAX CREDIT
BILLS TO EXPLAIN THE BENEFITS OF
THE CREDIT AND INCLUDE
PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT
STANDARDS. THESE REPORTING
REQUIREMENTS SAW THAT APPLY TO
TAX CREDITS SHOULD ALSO APPLY TO
SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTIONS SO
THEY CAN FACE THE SAME RIGOROUS
ARE REPORTING AND SCRUTINY.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY BOAT.
THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING THAT.
YES.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL. DOWN.
I ANDERSON. AYE ATKINS.
BY BATES.
BUY BILL. AYE BERRYHILL.
I'VE BRADFORD. AYE CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
BYE DOT.
I FULLER. AYE GAINES AYE
GALGIANI AYE GLAZER.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG.
AYE HILL AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
LARA.
LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE.
I MENDOZA. MITCHELL. AYE
MONNING.
I'M MORE LUCK I'M A REAL.
NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
PAN.
OUR I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
I SKINNER.
I STERN.
STONE.
BYE BYE DECK.
AYE WIECKOWSKI. AYE WIENER.
BY WILK.
I.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
GLAZER. AYE.
JACKSON.
I NADA.
MENDOZA MORALE.
I NIELSEN.
I STERN. BY.
EYES THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FORTY NINE SENATOR
PORTANTINO.
PASS ON FILE FILE ITEM FIFTY
SENATOR BELL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE SENATE BILLS FIVE
NINETEEN BY SENATOR BILL AND
EXPLAINED IT SANTA CLARA VALLEY
WATER DISTRICT.
SENATE BILL.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS THIS IS A DISTRICT BILL.
THAT AMENDS THE SANTA CLARA
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT ACT.
TO REQUIRE DISTRICT VACANCY ON
THE BOARD TO BE FILLED BY A
PERSON.
WHO LIVES WITHIN THE BOUNDARIES
OF THE AFFECTED DISTRICT?
HAS NO OPPOSITION ARCH AYE VOTE
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU CENTER BELL MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SINGING HEARING MAN EYES THIRTY
EIGHT KNOWS ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
FILE ITEM FIFTY ONE SENATOR
JACKSON MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE
READ.
SENATE BILL THREE TWENTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR JACKSON AND THAT KIND
INFORMATION PRIVACY.
SENATE JACKSON THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES.
I AM PLEASED TO PRESENT BEFORE
YOU TODAY SB THREE TWENTY SEVEN.
WHICH DIRECTS MANUFACTURERS OF
INTERNET CONNECTED DEVICES SUCH
AS WIRELESS ROUTERS. TELEVISIONS
AND MOBILE PHONES TO EQUIP THEIR
DEVICES WITH REASONABLE SECURITY
FEATURES. NOW RECENT AMENDMENTS
I HAVE TO ADMIT SIGNIFICANTLY
NARROWED THE BILL.
FROM ITS EARLIER FORM BUT I AM
PLEASED THAT THESE AMENDMENTS
HAVE LED TO VIRTUALLY. ALL OF
THE OPPOSITION TO GO NEUTRAL ON
THE BILL I'VE WORKED VERY HARD.
THE CAMANCHE WAS SOMETHING THAT
WILL ACCOMMODATE THE CONCERNS OF
THE INDUSTRY WHILE ALSO
ADDRESSING THE WHOLE ISSUE OF
PRIVACY.
THROUGH SECURITY OF THE
EQUIPMENT THAT IS BEING PRODUCED
OVER I BELIEVE THIRTY FIVE
BILLION PIECES OF INTERNET.
RELATED EQUIPMENT ARE OUT THERE
IN THE WORLD TODAY THERE IS
CLEARLY A NEED FOR GREATER
SECURITY. IN THIS EQUIPMENT SO.
THE CONCERN TO BY THE WAY IS A
PUBLIC CONCERN AND THE PUBLIC IS
GRAVELY WHERE AWARE OF THE
INSECURITY IN THESE DEVICES. IN
FACT IN OCTOBER TWENTY SEVENTEEN
NOW STACK OF SURVEY FOUND THAT
NINETY PERCENT OF CONSUMERS LACK
CONFIDENCE
IN THE SECURITY OF THE INTERNET
OF THINGS. DEVICES NINETY
PERCENT.
AND MOST ORGANIZATIONS AND
CONSUMERS BELIEVE THERE IS A
NEED FOR GREATER SECURITY
REGULATION AND INDEED EVEN WANT
THE GOVERNMENT TO GET INVOLVED.
AND A HACKER CONTROLLING THESE
DEVICES IS THE MOST COMMON
CONCERN FOR CONSUMERS. WHILE SIX
IN TEN CONSUMERS WORRY ABOUT
THEIR DATA BEING STOLEN.
NOW I'M NO TECHNIQUE FOLD I LOVE
MY IPHONE MY IPAD AS MUCH AS
ANYONE I FACED TIME REGULARLY
WITH MY GRANDCHILDREN. AND I'M
AS EXCITED AS THE NEXT PERSON
ABOUT THE NEW TECHNOLOGICAL
ADVANCES.
THAT ALLOW US TO CONNECT IN NEW
WAYS.
AND GIVE US WAYS TO GAIN
INFORMATION AT OUR FINGERTIPS.
BOB I AM CONCERNED AS I BELIEVE
MOST OF YOU ARE IN THIS INDEED
NINETY PERCENT OF THE PUBLIC IS.
WITH THESE ADVANCES PROCEEDING
WITHOUT ADEQUATE SAFEGUARDS.
AND AS AMENDED THIS BILL WOULD
REQUIRE MANUFACTURERS TO EQUIP
THERE INTERNET CONNECTED DEVICES
WITH REASONABLY SECURE FEATURES.
BASED ON THE NATURE OF THE
EQUIPMENT.
SUCH AS THE ABILITY TO CHANGE
PASSWORDS OR DETECT POTENTIAL
HACKERS.
AND GIVEN THE RAPIDLY EVOLVING
NATURE OF TECHNOLOGY WE ARE
LEAVING IT UP TO THE INDUSTRY'S
BEST JUDGMENT. TO DETERMINE WHAT
SECURITY IS REASONABLE FOR EACH
TYPE OF DEVICE.
THERE'S NO QUESTION COLLEAGUES
THE TECHNOLOGY HAS AND CONTINUE
TO REVOLUTIONIZE OUR LIVES BUT
IT IS UP TO US AS POLICY MAKERS
TO ENSURE THE TECHNOLOGY SERVICE
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA. AND
THAT SECURITY IS NOT AN AFTER
THOUGHT BUT RATHER A KEY
COMPONENT OF THE DESIGN PROCESS
WITHOUT. I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
ASK FEAR AYE VOTE BIG YOU CENTER
JACKSON MEMBERS IS THERE ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN.
I ANDERSON.
NO ATKINS.
I BATES.
NOBEL. BY BERRYHILL.
BRADFORD.
I CANNELLA.
I DELEON.
AYE DODD. AYE FULLER.
NO GAINES.
NO GALGIANI.
I GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. AYE
HILL AYE HUESO. AYE JACKSON AYE
LARA. LEYVA. AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
BY MORNING.
BY MORE LOCK.
NO MORRELL. NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I KNOW SON.
NO PAN.
I PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH AYE
SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE.
NO BIDAK NO AYE KOWSKI.
I WINNER.
I WILK BY.
PLEASE COOLEY ABSENT MEMBERS
BERRYHILL.
LARA MENDOZA.
I WAS TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS NINE
THE MEASURE PASSES MOVIE ON THE
FILE ITEM FIFTY TWO SENATOR
BRADFORD.
PASS ON FILE WILL NOW MOVE TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY SIX SENATOR
HILL.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN TWENTY ONE BY
SENATOR HILL AND AQUINNAH
CONTRACTORS
SENATOR HILL THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT THAT THIS BILL
REQUIRES THAT APARTMENT
BUILDINGS CONDOS IN A TRUE WAYS
THAT ARE THREE STORIES OR
HIGHER.
HAVE FIFTEEN PERCENT OF THEIR
BALCONIES INSPECTED EVERY SIX
YEARS BUILDING OWNERS WOULD HAVE
FOUR MONTHS TO GET A PERMIT. AND
SIX MONTHS TO MAKE THE RIVER
REPAIRS.
THIS IS A SERIOUS ISSUE THAT HAS
KILLED PEOPLE THROUGHOUT THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. IF ANY OF
YOU HAVE GONE ON THE LEGISLATIVE
TRIP TO IRELAND IN RECENT YEARS
YOU'VE. YOU'VE LIKELY MET WITH
THE FAMILIES WHOSE CHILDREN WERE
KILLED WHEN A BALCONY COLLAPSED
IN BERKELEY IN TWENTY FIFTEEN.
ALSO IN TWENTY FIFTEEN A
STAIRWELL AT AN APARTMENT
BUILDING IN THE CITY OF FOLSOM
COLLAPSED KILLING A. CAL POLY
MASTERS DIDN'T WHO WAS VISITING
HIS FRIEND.
WE CAN PREVENT THESE TRAGEDIES
WITH REASONABLE STATEWIDE
INSPECTION AND REPAIR STANDARDS
I'VE SPENT THE LAST YEAR
NEGOTIATING WITH STAKEHOLDERS TO
ADDRESS CONCERNS THAT I'VE
REMOVED OPPOSITION FROM THE
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION.
THE APARTMENT ASSOCIATION THE
COMMUNITY MANAGERS ASSOCIATION
AND LOCAL BUILDING OFFICIAL.
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT CONSUMER
PROTECTION BILL THAT SUPPORTED
BY THE CENTER FOR PUBLIC
INTEREST LAW CONSUMER ATTORNEYS
OF CALIFORNIA.
THE CITY OF BERKELEY AND THE
CONSUL GENERAL OF IRELAND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
MEMBERS.
THANK YOU SENATOR HILL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
CENTER SKINNER.
THANK YOU.
I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
AND I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
FOR NEGOTIATING WITH
STAKEHOLDERS TO ADDRESS THE
CONCERNS.
THAT
TRAGIC TRAGIC INCIDENT IN
BERKELEY IN TWENTY FIFTEEN.
WHERE?
IT IS A
IT WAS PRIMARILY IRISH NATIONALS
WHO WERE. IN BERKELEY FOR THE
SUMMER FOR AN EDUCATIONAL COURSE
WHO WERE ALL ON THE BALCONY OF
AN APARTMENT BUILDING. THAT.
WAS CONSIDERED SAFE IT HAD MET
THE INSPECTION STANDARDS THAT
WERE IN EXISTENCE PRIOR TO THIS
BILL. AND YET AFTER THAT TRAGIC
ACCIDENT.
IN THOSE DEATHS.
WE LEARNED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION
WAS INADEQUATE AND THE WAY. OUR
INSPECTIONS WERE CONDUCTED WOULD
NOT HAVE ENABLED THAT
DETERMINATION IN ADVANCE.
SO WE DO NOT.
NEED TO OR WANT TO RISK SUCH
DEATHS AGAIN IN THIS BILL WILL
PREVENT THAT. AND I RISE IN
SUPPORT AND THANK. OUR.
DE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING AFFORD
TO S.
THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER
FURTHER.
THUNDER GAMES
YEAH IF I COULD ASK A QUESTION
THE AUTHOR WE ACCEPT A QUESTION.
YET EVER HELP YES PLEASE PROCEED
CENTER HEALTH YOU COULD CLARIFY
FOR ME.
WHAT WOULD BE DIFFERENT IN
TERMS THE INSPECTION PROCESS
VERSES WHAT?
OF THE GOOD SENATOR FROM
BERKELEY THIS DESCRIBED
APPARENTLY. WITH THE LAST
INCIDENT THERE WAS AN INSPECTION
PRIOR TO THE ACCIDENT OCCURRING.
SO I'M IMAGINING THAT.
YOU'VE CRAFTED THE LEGISLATION
SO THAT WOULD BE.
A.
A MORE EXTENSIVE INSPECTION.
THAT'S CORRECT THE SENATOR
GAINES.
THE.
ISSUE THAT OF WISDOM.
THAT AROSE FROM THE.
THE TRAGEDY IN BERKELEY REALLY
HIGHLIGHTED THE FACT THAT MOST
INSPECTIONS DE ARE. ON THE
OUTSIDE THEY WOULD LOOK AT THE
THE BUILDING EXTERIOR RATHER
THAN AS A AS A PEST CONTROL
INSPECTION WHEN THEY PROB
PRODUCE A PRO BEEN PRIED INTO
THE. THE THE STRUCTURE THEY CAN
DETERMINE IF THERE IS A.
TRY RIDER SOME THE FUNGUS THAT
HAS CAUSED A PROBLEM IN A
STRUCTURAL ISSUE SHOULD THIS
REQUIRES A.
OF INSPECTION VIOLATIONS
ARCHITECT THE LICENSE CIVIL OR
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER OR AN
INDIVIDUAL CERTIFIED AS A
BUILDING INSPECTOR OR BUILDING
OFFICIAL TO LOOK AT THE
STRUCTURE OF THE.
OF THE BALCONY IN THE BUILDING
THE THE STATE OF. BUILDING.
OF THE STATE BUILDING STANDARDS
COMMISSION RECENTLY CHANGED THE
CONSTRUCTION STATUS AND
STRUCTURE. A AND REQUIREMENTS
FOR BALCONIES ON. ON BUILDINGS
THE ELKS EXTERIOR ELEVATED
ELEMENTS NOW HAVE TO BE A OR
CANNOT BE DONE IN A WAY THAT
WOULD HAVE CAUSED INDEED BECAUSE
THE COLLAPSE IN BERKELEY. THEY
HAVE TO BE OF A OF A STRUCTURE A
SUBSTANCE OTHER THAN WOOD AND A
STEEL FRAMING THAT'S NECESSARY
BECAUSE OF THE. THE POSSIBILITY
OF CAPTURING MOISTURE WITHIN
THAT CAVITY AND THE A CAUSING
DRY ROT SO IT'S AN EXTENSIVE
INSPECTION IT'S ON EVERY SIX
YEARS AND.
AND THAT'S.
SHOULD BE ENOUGH TO TO MAKE
SURE THAT THESE ARE SAFE AND AND
STRUCTURALLY SOUND FOR THE
FUTURE RIGHT THANK YOU AND DOC
ADECCO BE ON THE BALCONY COULD
INCLUDE STAIRWELLS.
DIG INTO GEAR INSPECTION WOULD
INCLUDE OTHER STRUCTURAL
ELEMENTS OF THE BUILDING OR
SUGGESTS EXCLUSIVELY ALBANY'S IS
A LOT OF THIS IS FOR ANY THOSE
EXTERIOR.
ELEVATED ELEMENTS THAT ARE
AMONG PART OF A BUILDING ANY
THANK YOU.
TONIGHT I PO. THANK YOU SENATOR
GAINES.
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
THING THEN SENATOR HOW WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE THE CREATION OF A
MEMBER THANK YOU THANK YOU
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN. NO ATKINS.
BY BATES.
BELL.
I BERRYHILL.
BY BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA AYE
DELEON.
HI DOT.
I FULLER.
NO GAINES.
I GALGIANI. AYE GLAZER.
AYE HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG AYE
HILL AYE HUESO. AYE JACKSON.
ISLA.
LEYVA AYE MCGUIRE AYE MENDOZA.
MITCHELL.
MONNING.
MITCHELL I.
MONEY I MORE LOCK.
NO. MORALE.
NO NEWMAN.
I NGUYEN.
I NIELSEN.
NO PAN.
I AYE PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH.
SKINNER.
BY STERN AYE STONE.
NO. BIDAK.
KNOW WHAT COUNTY.
I WIENER. AYE WILK.
I. WOULD CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES.
BY.
LADA.
MENDOZA ROTH.
BY IS THIRTY KNOW SEVEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY SEVEN SENATOR PAN.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVEN EIGHTY THREE
BY SENATOR PAN AND ACT GOING TO
STATE EMPLOYMENT.
CENTER PAN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATORS I SP SEVENTY
THREE ENCOURAGES ADMINISTRATION
CAN YOU TO REDUCE THE STATE'S
LONG TERM LIABILITY FOR EMPLOYEE
LEAVE BALANCES THROUGH
CONSISTENT PROGRAM OF BY BACK
AUTHORIZATIONS.
THIS BILL AUTHORIZES CALLIE
CHART TO MAKE A DETERMINATION
ANNUALLY THAT A BUYBACK OF AND
USE THE CREDIT MAY BE OFFERED
FOR AN AFFABLE PEERLESS TURMAN
BY CAL HR. AND ALLOWS AN
EMPLOYEE INCLUDING MANAGERS AND
SUPERVISORS TO ELECT TO BE PAID
AT HIS OR HER REGULAR RATE OF
PAY FOR UP TO EIGHTY HOURS OF
AND USE THE CREDIT AFTER CAL HR
HAS MADE A DETERMINATION TO BUY
BACK AND USE THAT LEAVE CREDIT.
THIS QUALIFIES EXISTING
REGULATIONS ARE AMENDED INTO
TWENTY SIXTEEN TWENTY SEVENTEEN
ANSWER STATUTORY AUTHORIZATION
SURE THAT THIS PROGRAM IS
AVAILABLE TO FUTURE
ADMINISTRATIONS EXPECT WE ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SENATOR PAN MEMBERS IS
THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION TO USING UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SEEING NONE I IS THIRTY EIGHT NO
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES FILE
ITEM FIFTY EIGHT SENATOR
GALGIANI.
MR SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL SEVEN NINETY FIVE A SENATOR
GALGIANI AND TACKLING TO
ACCOUNTANCY IN MAKING AN
APPROPRIATION THERE FOR.
SENATE OUT JOHNNY THANK YOU
MA'AM CHEN MEMBERS SB SEVEN
NINETY FIVE RELATES TO THE
MOBILITY PROVISIONS OF THE
CALIFORNIA ACCOUNTANCY ACT.
IN TWO THOUSAND TWELVE THE
LEGISLATURE CONFORM TO
CALIFORNIA'S CPA PRACTICE
PRIVILEGE PROVISIONS TO THOSE OF
THE REST OF THE NATION AND EASE
THE BURDEN SEVEN OUR STATE
PRACTICE FOR CERTIFIED PUBLIC
ACCOUNTANTS.
THE MOBILITY PROGRAMS
ESTABLISHED IN TWO THOUSAND AND
TWELVE CONTAINED MANY OF THE
SAME CONSUMER PROTECTION
PROVISIONS AND REQUIRED THE
BOARD OF ACCOUNTANCY TO REPORT
BACK TO THE LEGISLATURE. ON HOW
WELL THE PROVISIONS OF THE LAW
PROTECT THE PUBLIC BEFORE THE
PROVISIONS WOULD SUNSET NEXT
YEAR. SB SEVEN NINETY FIVE WILL
REMOVE THE JANUARY FIRST TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN SUNSET ON
THESE MOBILITY PROVISIONS AND
PUSH THE DATE BACK ONE YEAR THIS
WILL ALLOW STAKEHOLDERS MORE
TIME TO ANALYZE THE BOARD'S
REPORT.
THE BILL HAS NO NO NOT
OPPOSITION AND HAS ENJOYED. A
SPORT BIPARTISAN SUPPORT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE. BIG YOU SENATOR GALGIANI
MEMBERS IS THERE ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE.
SEEING NONE. IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION TO USING UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL.
SEEING AND HEARING THEM EYES
THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES.
FILE ITEM.
GIVE ME ONE MOMENT
ITEM FIFTY NINE SENATOR BATES
MISTER SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
SENATE BILL SEVENTY THE SENATOR
BATES AND ACT IN REAL ESTATE.
CENTER BATES.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I SPS SEVENTY IS A VERY
NARROW BILL THAT SIMPLY ALLOWS
FOR A CLIENT TO SHARE RESTRICT
APPRAISAL. REPORT WAS SPECIFIC
RECIPIENTS RECENT AMENDMENTS
ADDED A SPECIAL DISCLOSURE
PROVISION.
TO CLARIFY THAT THESE RECORDS
ARE SHORTENED WHILE THEY DO NOT
HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION FROM
THE APPRAISERS WORKS FILE
INCLUDE IN THE REPORT THAT IS
AVAILABLE HOWEVER THIS EXEMPTION
WOULD NOT BE ALLOWED FOR A
FEDERALLY RELATED TRANSACTION.
LONER REFINANCE OF RESIDENTIAL
PROPERTY OR A LOAN OF INVESTOR
FUNDS ARRANGED BY MORTGAGE BANK
BROKER. AS SUCH REPORTS WOULD
ONLY BE GOING TO SPECIALIZED
PROFESSIONALS WHO ARE EXPERTS IN
THE FIELD. THIS IS A VERY SMALL
POPULATION THE BILL SPONSORED BY
THE APPRAISAL INSTITUTE. THE
LARGEST APPRAISAL ORGANIZATION
IN THE NATION RASPY SEVENTY
VENTURES THAT MORE CONSUMERS ARE
USING LICENSED APPRAISERS AND
OUT THE SAME TIME LOWERING THE
COST I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE. THE KEY CENTER BATES
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR HILL THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT AND I I RISE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE VIDEO.
THIS SO.
THIS BILL AND THE CONCEPT HAD A
VERY THOROUGH DISCUSSION IN US
SENATE BUSINESS PROFESSIONS AND
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
AND WHAT IT REALLY DOES.
I BELIEVE IS IS FOSTER GOOD
CONSUMER PROTECTION IT OPENS THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR RESTRICTED USE
APPRAISALS.
TO REALLY CALIFORNIA LICENSED
APPRAISERS WHICH WOULD INCREASE
CONSUMER PROTECTION AND OFFER
MORE OPPORTUNITY GREATER
OPPORTUNITY FOR THOSE REQUESTING
THESE APPRAISALS. AND RATHER
THAN HAVING SOMEONE WHO IS
UNLICENSED UNCERTIFIED OR
BASICALLY ANYONE IN THIS ROOM
COULD PROVIDE AN APPRAISAL. YOU
WOULD HAVE SOMEONE WHO IS
LICENSED BY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA PERFORMING THEM AYE
AS FROM AYE VOTE MEMBERS.
THANK YOU CENTER HEALTH FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
SENATE RATES WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU MISTER SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN.
I ENDRESEN.
I ATKINS AYE BATES.
BY BILL AYE BERRYHILL. AYE
BRADFORD AYE CANNELLA. AYE
DELEON.
BYE DOT.
DODD AYE. FULLER.
AYE GAINES. AYE GALGIANI AYE
GLAZER AYE HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG AYE HILL. AYE HUESO.
I JACKSON.
I LADA.
LEYVA.
AYE MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA.
MITCHELL AYE MONNING. BY MORE
LUCK.
MORRELL.
BY NEWMAN.
NGUYEN.
BY NELSON.
I PAN.
NO PORTANTINO.
I ROTH.
SKINNER.
BY STERN. AYE STONE.
I'VE AYE DECK AYE WIECKOWSKI.
NO.
WIENER.
I WILK.
I LEGALLY ABSENT MEMBERS LADA
MENDOZA MORLOCK.
I.
NEWMAN.%
ROTH.
I.
I CERTIFY KNOWS TO THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS WE HAVE ONE BILL
ON CALL WE'RE GOING TO LIFT THE
CALL ON FILE ITEM FORTY SIX. SB
SEVEN TWELVE.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
ATKINS.
BRADFORD.
DELEON.
I.
HERTZBERG.
HUESO.
LARA.
MENDOZA.
MORRELL.
STONE.
BUT.
DELEON I TO KNOW.
I SIXTEEN KNOWS SIXTEEN THE
MEASURE FAILS CENTER ANDERSON
WOULD YOU LIKE RECONSIDERATION
US PLEASE THANK YOU WITHOUT
OBJECTION RECONSIDERATION IS
GRANTED. THIRTY EIGHT AYE KNOWS
ZERO.
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO MOVE TO
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS WITH THE
APPROPRIATE TIME FOR A GERMAN IN
MEMORIES SENATOR JACKSON.
THANK YOU COLLEGE IF IF I COULD
HAVE YOUR ATTENTION PLEASE.
YOU KNOW WE ALL ARE SIT HERE AND
LISTEN OF.
TO.
THE TRIALS AND TRIBULATIONS
WITHIN OUR OWN COMMUNITY.
AND FREQUENTLY SAY THANK GOD
THAT WASN'T MY COMMUNITY.
LISTENING TO THE SITUATION THAT
HAPPENED IN. BERKELEY WITH THE
TRAGEDY ON THE. PATIOS OF
BUILDINGS.
THE PEOPLE WHO DIED IN THE SANTA
ROSA AND THE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
FIRES AND. WE ALL AYE THINKS
SUBCONSCIOUSLY THINKS SAY THANK
GOD THAT WASN'T ME.
AND A COUPLE WEEKS AGO I STOOD
ON THIS FLOOR TO HONOR THE
MEMORY OF A FIREFIGHTER IN AN
OLDER.
A* THE.
ATTORNEY.
WHO ARE THE?
TWO VICTIMS IN THE.
THOMAS FIRE.
WHICH WAS AND IS THE LARGEST
WILDFIRE EVER TO OCCUR IN.
CALIFORNIA.
IN.
DECEMBER EXTRAORDINARY IN AND OF
ITSELF.
IN MY DISTRICT AND I ADJOURNED
AND SAID.
SOMETHING TO THE EFFECT THAT
THIS WAS ALMOST
A MIRACLE THAT ONLY TWO PEOPLE
DIED.
AS.
A GOOD PORTION OF MY DISTRICT
BURNED UP.
WELL I STAND TODAY.
BECAUSE.
THAT MIRACLE.
HAS TURNED INTO A NIGHTMARE.
I'M SURE MANY OF YOU HAVE SEEN.
WHETHER IT'S ON THE OPRAH SHOW
OR IN THE NEWSPAPER.
PHOTOGRAPHS.
WHAT HAPPENED ON THE NIGHT OF
JULY A JANUARY NINTH?
IT'S THREE O'CLOCK IN THE
MORNING.
WHEN THE GOOD PEOPLE OF.
BONTA PSEUDO WHICH IS NOT ONLY
MY DISTRICT BUT THESE ARE MY
NEIGHBORS.
MANY OF THESE PEOPLE WHO LOST
THEIR HOMES.
ARE VERY CLOSE FRIENDS OF MINE.
I KNOW SOME OF THE VICTIMS.
WHO DIED WHO PERISHED THAT
NIGHT?
SO I STAND BEFORE YOU AS NOT
ONLY THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THIS
COMMUNITY NOT ONLY SOMEONE WHO.
STOOD HERE I WON'T SAY IN A
COCKY FASHION BUT WITH GREAT
RELIEF.
ACKNOWLEDGED.
THE TRAGIC PASSING OF A
FIREFIGHTER WHO HELPED TO FIGHT.
THIS TERRIBLE FIRE IN A WOMAN
WHO HAD A TRAGIC DEATH AS A
RESULT.
BUT STAND HERE TODAY.
TO RECITE THE NAMES OF TWENTY
ONE PEOPLE.
WHO WERE LITERALLY SWEPT AWAY?
BY A MUD SLIDE.
THAT OCCURRED WHEN THOSE HILLS.
THERE WERE COMPLETELY DENUDED BY
THIS FIRE JUST A COUPLE WEEKS
BEFORE.
CAME TUMBLING DOWN.
LITERALLY TUMBLING DOWN.
AND SWEPT PEOPLE UP TO THREE
MILES.
ONTO THE FREEWAY.
IN WE THINK EVEN INTO THE OCEAN.
WHILE THEY SLEPT.
WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE?
WHERE THEY WERE PEOPLE WHO LOOK
LIKE YOU AND ME?
THEY WERE HARD WORKING PEOPLE.
WHO WORKED AT LOW PAYING JOBS?
THEY WERE PEOPLE WHO WERE HAND
SURGEONS IN TOWN WHO CHEST THE
MONTH BEFORE ACTUALLY. DONE THE
HAND SURGERY ON MY STEPDAUGHTER.
THEY WERE PEOPLE.
WHO WERE COUSINS OF VERY DEAR
FRIENDS OF MONNING?
THEY WERE PEOPLE WHO WERE.
IMMIGRANTS FROM THAILAND.
WHO HAD COME OVER HERE TO LIVE?
PROMISED WORLD OF WORKING HARD
AND THEY DID.
THE.
THE INCIDENT OCCURRED AND I
DON'T CAUGHT IN INCIDENTS IT'S
WAITES REFERRED TO BY OUR LAW
ENFORCEMENT PEOPLE WHO BY THE
WAY WERE.
STRAORDINARIO.
THIS NIGHT AT THREE O'CLOCK IN
THE MORNING.
THERE WAS A RANGE CELL.
THEY CAME OVER MONTESINOS.
THE FOOD THAT THE THE RANGE UP
UNTIL THEN HAD BEEN DRIZZLE SORT
OF LIKE WHAT WE HAVE IN
SACRAMENTO YESTERDAY SOME PEOPLE
SAID. ALL THE RAIN IS GOING TO
PASS.
AT THREE O'CLOCK IN THE MORNING
RAIN TELLS STOPPED OVER MONA
SETO AND DUMPED HALF AN INCH OF
RAIN. IN FIVE MINUTES.
AND THE HILLS COLLAPSED
SENDING BOULDERS THE SIZE OF
TRUCKS.
DOWN THROUGH THIS SLEEPING
COMMUNITY.
AND IN AN IRRATIONAL WAY AT
LEAST MAYBE NOT TO NATURE BUT TO
THE PEOPLE WHO LIVE THERE
LITERALLY BLEW PEOPLE. OUT OF
THEIR HOMES.
AND INTO THIS MUD HURDLE. THAT
AS I SADLY HAD TO SEE IT I WAS.
WANTING TO RESIST BUT AS IN MY
JOB IT WAS IMPORTANT THAT I
ACTUALLY SEE WHAT'D HAPPEN.
SO THAT AMOUNT OF RAIN.
KUMBLE THE HILLSIDE.
THINK OF A LAVA FLOW IF ANY OF
YOU SEEN PICTURES SOON
RECREATIONS OF WHEN MOUNT
VESUVIUS BLEW. AND THAT LAVA
FLOW CAME THROUGH POMPEII. AND
JUST DESTROYED A WHOLE CITY.
THAT'S WHAT THIS MONTH SLIDE WAS
LIGHT. AND IT LEFT FIFTEEN FEET
OF MUD. ON WHAT WAS ONCE THE
FREEWAY.
FOR A PERIOD OF ABOUT THREE
MILES.
I HAVE A FRIEND.
WHO LEFT HER HOME SEEING BECAUSE
FIRES WERE CREATED BECAUSE?
A GAS PIPES BROKE BY THESE
BOULDERS THAT CAME TUMBLING DOWN
THOUSANDS OF THEM BY THE WAY
THEIR THOUSANDS OF THEM.
pALMOST SWEPT AWAY ON THE
FREEWAY.
SHE WAS.
COLLECTED.
FORTUNATELY BY OUR FIRST
RESPONDERS.
WHO LITERALLY? PICKED UP.
OVER FIFTY PEOPLE.
THEY WERE ABLE TO SAVE AN
AIRLIFT OVER FIFTY PEOPLE AT
THREE O'CLOCK IN THE MORNING I
COULDN'T SEE ANYTHING.
THE WINDS WERE TO FIFTY SIXTY
MILES AN HOUR IT'S POURING RAIN
AND YET THEY WENT OUT AND SAVE.
FIFTY PEOPLE INCLUDING THE DUDE.
WHO LIVES TO MAMACITA?
JEFF BRIDGES.
AND HE WAS INTERVIEWED AND I
WANT TO TRUST.
.
SHARE WITH YOU A COMMENT HE
MADE.
WHEN HE WAS INTERVIEWED THE
OTHER DAY HE. HE SAID YOU KNOW
THIS REMINDS ME OF A LINE FROM A
MOVIE I WAS IN IN NINETEEN
EIGHTY FOUR STAR MAN.
IF YOU EVER SAW THAT MOVIE.
HE SAID.
ONE OF HIS LINES WAS A LINE THAT
HE REMEMBERED CLEARLY AND THAT
WAS YOU KNOW WHAT I LOVE MOST
ABOUT YOU HUMANS.
YOU ARE AT YOUR VERY BEST.
WHEN THINGS ARE AT THEIR WORST.
AND SO THIS COMMUNITY CAME
TOGETHER.
THERE ARE NOW TWENTY EIGHT
PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN IN THE
HOSPITAL.
THERE TWENTY THREE VICTIMS WE
HAVE RECOVERED TWENTY ONE OF
THEM.
THERE STILL A TWO YEAR OLD
MISSING.
AND A SEVENTEEN YEAR OLD BOYS.
AND SO.
WE TAKE A DEEP BREATH I TAKE A
DEEP BREATH THIS HAS BEEN VERY
PERSONAL TO ME.
I SUSPECT MANY OF YOU IN THIS
ROOM.
NO PEOPLE.
WHO LIVED THROUGH THIS
EXPERIENCE OR WHO?
FAILED TO LIVE THROUGH THIS
EXPERIENCE.
AND SO I WANT TO ASK FOR YOUR
INDULGENCE AS I.
CONCLUDE BY READING THE NAMES
AND AGES OF THESE TWENTY ONE
VICTIMS.
AND I KNOW THAT YOU WILL JOIN ME
IN EXTENDING.
YOUR DEEPEST CONDOLENCES TO THE
FAMILIES.
TO THE COMMUNITY OF MONASHEE
DOUGH FOR THESE UNIMAGINABLE
LOSSES.
WE WILL REBUILD.
WE ARE AS HUMAN BEINGS VERY
RESILIENT.
NOT JUST YET.
AND SO I ASK YOU TO.
JOIN WITH ME EXTENDING PRAYERS
TO.
TO THE VICTIMS AND IN PARTICULAR
TO.
THE BENITEZ FAMILY.
WHICH LOS FOUR OF ITS FAMILY
MEMBERS.
TO THE TAILOR.
TO CUT TAPE OF FAMILY WHICH
LOST.
THREE OF THEIR MEMBERS.
IN THE MISSING TWO YEAR OLD IS A
MEMBER. OF THEIR FAMILY.
SO WE WILL REBUILD.
WE WILL COME TOGETHER NO WE HAVE
AS A COMMUNITY AND AS A
REMINDER.
THAT MOTHER NATURE.
EXTENDS HER FURY WHEN SHE IS NOT
HAPPY.
WITH US.
AND AS I'VE REMINDED MY
COMMUNITY. THIS IS THE BEGINNING
OF WINTER.
AND WE HAVE TWO HUNDRED AND
TWENTY THOUSAND ACRES OF LAND
THAT IS WITHOUT BRUSH.
WITHOUT TREES WITHOUT ANY GROUND
COVER TO PROTECT US WHEN THE
NEXT RANGE COM.
SO I A ASK YOU ALL TO JOIN ME IN
A CHURNING IN THE MEMORY.
OF DR MARK MONTGOMERY.
AGE FIFTY FOUR.
CAROLINE MONTGOMERY HIS
DAUGHTER.
AGE TWENTY TWO.
JOSEPH FRANCIS POLITICAL.
AGE EIGHTY SEVEN.
MARTIN CABRERA MOON JOOSS AGE
FORTY EIGHT.
ALICE MITCHELL AGE SEVENTY
EIGHT.
AND HER HUSBAND JAMES MITCHELL
EIGHTY NINE THEY WERE
CELEBRATING HIS BIRTHDAY THAT
NIGHT.
JOHN MCMAHON A GOAL.
AGE SIXTY ONE DEAD OF SIX.
GOOD TENNIS PLAYER FOR MIKE
TENNIS CLUB.
REBEKAH RISKIN AGE SIXTY ONE.
ROY ROTARY EIGHTY FOUR JOSEPHINE
GUY OUR AGE SIXTEEN NINE DAVID
CANTON AGE FORTY NINE.
WHOSE SON IS STILL MISSING.
MORGAN COREY AGE TWENTY FIVE
SAWYER COREY.
AGE TWELVE.
KAYLA BENITEZ AGE THREE.
MARYLAND ROMMEL SAGE TWENTY
SEVEN JHONATHAN BENITO SAGE TEN.
FOR VIOLA BONITOS CALDERON AGE
TWENTY EIGHT WHO NEED TO BLOOM
SU TO TAPER. AGE THIRTY.
PARA WATCHED PASTA SHOULD TAPER
AGE SIX.
GRANDFATHER RICHARD LAUREN
TAYLOR OF THE FAMILY AGE SEVENTY
NINE PETER FLORA AT AGE SEVENTY
THREE.
AND I WANNA THANK THE GOVERNOR
FOR DECLARING TODAY A DAY OF
REMEMBRANCE OF THE MONA SETO.
MUD SLIDE I WANT TO THANK THE
COMMUNITY FOR COMING TOGETHER.
AND I ESPECIALLY WANT TO THANK
OUR FIRST RESPONDERS.
THIS IS GOVERNMENT AT ITS BEST.
WE HAD.
EIGHTY FIVE HUNDRED PEOPLE
STAFFING THAT FIRE WE HAD
HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE COMING
TOGETHER IN THE MIDDLE OF THE
NIGHT. TO TRY TO SAVE OUR
COMMUNITY.
PEOPLE WHO WHO'VE RISKED THEIR
LIVES AND WHO HAVE STAYED OVER
WEEKS.
THE COMFORT THE COMMUNITY TO TRY
TO FIND AND PUT CLOSURE FOR
THOSE WHO LOST LOVED ONES.
AND WHO GAVE THEIR VERY BEST.
TO THE PEOPLE.
OF MY COMMUNITY.
I WOULD ASK YOU TO JOIN ME IN A
JOURNEY.
THANK YOU.
THINK YOU CENTER JACKSON FOR
MAKING SURE THAT WE DON'T FORGET
ANY OF THESE FOLKS WHO SURVIVED
THE FIRES AND HAD THIS TRAGEDY
STRIPE HIS MITCHELL THEIR NAMES
ARE BROUGHT FORWARD.
SENATOR NIELSEN.
MADAM PRESIDENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THE SENATE IT SEEMS TO
BE A YEAR OF. A LOT OF
TRAGEDIES.
WE BEGAN LAST YEAR WITH THE.
OROVILLE.
THEN WE CONCLUDED THE YEAR WITH
THE FRACTURE TO AIM.
THIS IS A VERY SMALL COMMUNITY
IN. SOUTHWESTERN TEHAMA COUNTY.
BUT. FIVE MILES FROM WHERE WE
LIVE UP THERE.
THERE ARE ONE FATEFUL DAY.
CLEARLY UNSTABLE INDIVIDUAL.
DECIDED HE WANTED TO GO ON A
RAMPAGE.
HE MURDERED HIS WIFE.
THE NIGHT BEFORE AND. BARRIER IN
THE FLOORBOARDS UNDER HOUSE.
THE NEXT MORNING HAD GOTTEN A
CAR.
AND BEGAN DRIVING AROUND.
THE COMMUNITY.
SHOOTING PEOPLE AT RANDOM.
WITH ONE EXCEPTION HE DIDN'T
WANT TO GET INTO THE SCHOOL.
AND WOULD BE ASSUMED TO SHOOT
SOME OF OUR CHILDREN.
THAT.
CHILDREN WERE WOUNDED BUT NONE
WERE KILLED AT THE SCHOOL AND
THAT'S DUE TO THE HEROISM OF
PEOPLE THAT TO SCHOOL SOME OF
WHOM I'LL BE INTRODUCING HERE. A
LITTLE BIT LATER.
BUT THIS DERANGED MAN. DID
SUCCEED.
AND KILLING A NUMBER OF PEOPLE.
BEFORE HE TO JUSTICE INDIA'S OWN
HAND.
AND KILLED HIMSELF.
IRIS MCFAYDEN FIFTY FIVE WAS A
MAN AND A WIFE.
A CHILD PROTECTIVE OFFICER.
SHE WORKED WITH TROUBLED YOUTH.
I DIDN'T CONVERSATIONS QUITE
REGULARLY WITH HER HUSBAND WHO
WAS SHOT BUT DID NOT.
DIE.
AND HE CLEARLY IS A MAN WHOSE
LIFE HAS BEEN CHANGED.
JOSEPH EDWARD MCCUE THE THIRD IN
A LOVING FATHER HOPE THE BROTHER
AND SON HE WAS A FARMER WHO CAME
TO CALIFORNIA.
THEN HE WANTED TO FARM HERE.
HE WAS A QUIET MAN BUT A HARD
WORKER.
BOB BRAND GILSON.
THIRTY EIGHT.
LIVED ALONE LEFT HER DOGS.
WORKED IN A PIZZA SHOP.
AVERAGE.
CALIFORNIANS.
DEFINITELY LA TIMES THIRTY EIGHT
THE FATHER TO A SEVEN YEAR OLD
SON.
HE WAS A VERY GENEROUS MAN HE
WAS CALLED ONE OF THOSE WHO
WOULD GIVE THE SHIRT OFF HIS
BACK.
TO ANYONE WITH THE LA AGAIN
ASKING.
AND DANNY'S MOTHER.
DIANA THE STEEL.
A CARING. AND LOVING
GRANDMOTHER.
SUCH TRAGEDIES LIVE LONG IN THE
MEMORY OF. ONE INDIVIDUAL BUT
HONEST FLEX A WHOLE COMMUNITY.
AND I CAN TELL YOU THE WHOLE
COUNTY OF TO HEMA.
WILL NOT LONG AGO WILL LONG
REMEMBER THIS.
TRAGIC EVENT.
ONE OTHER IF I MAY. MADAM
PRESIDENT.
IT'S KIND OF SEPARATE BUT NOT
ENTIRELY.
SHERIFF COREY HONI IS THE
SHERIFF OF BUTTE COUNTY AND.
DID SOME INCREDIBLE HEROISM.
DURING LOCKED LAKE OROVILLE HE
WAS THE ONE WHO HAD TO CALL.
THE EVACUATION.
I WAS ON THE PHONE WITH HIM
ELEVEN O'CLOCK THAT NIGHT
MOMENTS BEFORE HE HAD TO MAKE
THAT CALL I KNOW THE BURDEN HE
PACKED AND HE JUST HAS RETURNED
FROM PIKE PIERCE COUNTY
WASHINGTON.
HIS NEPHEW.
THE DEPUTY SHERIFF LIKE COREY.
SHOT IN THE LINE OF DUTY.
TRYING TO HAPPY HANDICAP OF.
BURGLARS.
THEY AMBUSHED HIM.
HE IS A FAMILY MAN AS A WIFE AND
THREE YOUNG SONS.
I WOULD ASK THAT WE AS WELL.
THE JUROR IN MEMORY OF DEPUTY
DANIEL LOOK.
MCCARTNEY.
OF PIERCE COUNTY WASHINGTON.
THANK YOU THANK YOU SENATOR
NIELSEN PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU
BRING THEIR NAMES FORWARD SO WE
CAN PROPERLY MEMORIALIZE THEM
SENATOR MARLATT WHAT PURPOSE YOU
RISE.
THE GERMAN PLEASE PROCEED.
JUST LIKE TO ADJOURN IN THE
MEMORY OF JACK ALLEN NORTHROP
WAS BORN IN SAN HANNAH.
JULY TWENTY THIRD NINETEEN
TWENTY SIX AND PASSED AWAY IN.
NEWPORT BEACH ON THE EIGHTH OF
JANUARY THE GRIP INTESTINE AND
GRADUATED FROM TESTING UNITED
SCHOOL.
WHERE IS FATHER WAS THE
PRINCIPAL?
JACK ATTENDED THE UNIVERSITY OF
CALIFORNIA AT LOS ANGELES AND
EARNED HIS BA IN PSYCHOLOGY AND
NAVAL SCIENCE IN NINETEEN FORTY
SEVEN. HIS MBA IN NINETEEN FORTY
NINE.
IT A ZEAL FOR MANY THINGS HE
TRAVELED EXTENSIVELY EFT CARS
KNOWN MULTIPLE PLANES BOATS
INNER PEACE.
JACK WAS AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE
BALBOA YACHT CLUB THE BALBOA
ISLAND IMPROVEMENT ASSOCIATION.
AND THE BALBOA ISLAND MUSEUM
WHERE YOU HELD VARIOUS
LEADERSHIP POSITIONS.
A FUN GUY
JUST WANT TO OF.
REMEMBER HIS FAMILY THIS TIME OF
LOS THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
THANK YOU CENTER MORE NOT PLEASE
BRING HIS NAME FORWARD SENATOR
STONE.
IF I MAY FOLLOW SENATOR OR ELSE
PART OF THE STATE ADJOURNMENTS
THINK CERTAINLY SENATOR MORALE.
YES THANK YOU.
MA'AM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SENATOR
STONE FOR YELLING ME. WHY HAS
HAS BEEN A?
DIFFICULT HERE ARE THE DIFFICULT
MONTH
A WE HAD A TRAGEDY IN OUR A
TRAGEDY. IN OUR AREA MICHAEL
ANTHONY CASTING A HOST.
ARE HE WAS A PILLAR OF MENIFEE.
HE SEEM TO BE IN REALLY GOOD
SHAPE BUT HE CAUGHT THE FLU AND
ONE IN THE MORNING HE GOT TO THE
HOSPITAL TOO LATE JUST.
DIED VERY QUICKLY ON A SANTA IT
HIT OUR COMMUNITY BECAUSE HE WAS
A LIKEABLE GUY. I CALLED HIS A
WIFE.
DARCY THEY HAD BEEN MARRIED
THIRTY FOUR YEARS I SPOKE TO HER
LAST WEEK AND I SAID WATER
COUPLE THINGS YOU'D LIKE ME TO
SAY IN. HIS STUFF.
FIRST OF ALL THAT THEY WERE
HAPPILY MARRIED FOR THIRTY FOUR
YEARS THE SECOND THING IS IS HE
HAD A WONDERFUL SMILE AS SILLY
THING I CAN REALLY REMEMBER
ABOUT HIM IS HE JUST WAS A.
PERSON WITH A LOT OF ENTHUSIASM
AND JOY AND AND ALSO HE HAD BEEN
A BANKER BUT WHEN HE RETIRED HE
DONATED.
MUCH OF HIS TIME TO THE
COMMUNITY SO HE WAS NAME.
TAMAR COMMERCE MANNER THE YEAR
AND THEY CALL HIM MR MENIFEE
WHICH IS A TOWN THAT'S ONLY BEEN
INCORPORATED FOR.
I KNOW TEN OR FIFTEEN YEARS BUT
ANYWAY HE'LL BE DEBT DEEPLY
MASSIVE IT'S IT WAS.
IT WAS PRETTY A PRETTY ARE.
NO ONE THOUGHT THAT WOULD HAPPEN
BUT HERE SOME OF THE THINGS
DARCY HIS WIFE ONE AMIRI. THREE
LADY YOU THAT SOME OF HIS
PASSIONS WERE VOLUNTARY AND
CIVIC AND CHARITABLE CAUSES TO
RELAY FOR LIFE.
WHICH HE WAS A CHAIRMAN.
HE ALSO WORKED AT THE LIP BALM
HERB VOLUNTEERED THAT KNIGHTS OF
COLUMBUS AND THE ROTARY CLUB.
THE MENIFEE VALLEY COMMUNITY CUT
BOARD AND SANTA'S WORKSHOP.
Y. CAN MENTION EARLIER HE WAS
CITIZEN OF THE YEAR FOR THE
CHAMBER. HE WAS DEVOTED A
HUSBAND FATHER AND GRANDFATHER
AND VERY LOYAL TO HIS FRIENDS IN
THIS CHURCH BOMB.
AND HE DIED ON JANUARY
FOURTEENTH THEN IT IT ITS SHOCK
TO SAW.
IN SORE HEART GOES OUT TO HIS
WIFE DARCI HIS CHILDREN A COLON
RICHARD THEIR GRANDDAUGHTER. YOU
LESSA AND MIKE'S MOTHER STELLA
AND HIS SISTER IDEA AND SARAH
AND NEPHEW ANTHONY A MEMBERS
THANK YOU FOR. TAKING TIME
LISTEN AND.
SHARON THIS FAMILY'S GRIEF THANK
YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU CENTER
MORAL CENTER STONE.
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT UP
PRIOR TO MY TENURE IN THE IN THE
STATE SENATE I WAS A RIVERSIDE
COUNTY SUPERVISOR. AND AND THEN
WHEN I GOT ELECTED MENIFEE WAS
NOT A EVEN A CITY YET.
BUT WHEN I HELPED AND PARK ON A
MINUTE YOU COMING A CITY HOW
THAT'S WHEN I GOT TO NOTE.
DARCY IN MY CASTING A HOSE.
A WONDERFUL COUPLE.
VERY PATRIOTIC COUPLE IN FACT.
DARCY IN THE YEARS THAT I'VE
KNOWN HER HAS BEEN AN ACTIVE
MILITARY WOMAN AND HAS HAD
MULTIPLE.
TOURS OF WALL HER HUSBAND MIKE
I TOOK CARE OF THE KIDS.
WHILE SHE WAS IN AFGHANISTAN AND
IRAQ OF THE DEFENDING FREEDOM
AND AND FIGHTING FOR LIBERTY.
HA I KNEW MIKE HAS A VERY
PHILANTHROPIC PERSON USED TO
WORK AT A BANK WHERE HE RETIRED
GOT.
AN EDUCATION THAT.
LONG BEACH STATE A BUT HE WAS
INVOLVED IN JUST ABOUT EVERY
CHARITABLE ORGANIZATION.
YOU CAN THINK OF MY MY
WONDERFUL COLLEAGUE FROM.
ASSEMBLY OF COUNTY.
ALLUDED TO MANY THEM HE WAS
PRESIDENT OF THE. OF THE.
ROTARY CLUB HE WAS.
IN THE KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS FOR
USE GRAND NIGHT FOR TWO YEARS.
HE WAS.
ARE HE WAS VOTED THE CITIZENS OF
THE YEAR TWICE BY THE MENIFEE AT
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE.
AND AS MY COLLEAGUE SAID IF I
MAKE SURE PROP. THE MIKE IN THE
ALWAYS WAS SMILING.
BECAUSE HE REALLY WAS LIVING
THE AMERICAN DREAM AND HAVE A
BEAUTIFUL FAMILY.
AND CERTAINLY WE EXTEND OUR OUR
CONDOLENCES TO HIS WIFE OF
THIRTY FOUR YEAR STARTS IN ITS
CHILDREN NICOLE THIRTY ONE
RICHARD TWENTY EIGHT.
GRANDDAUGHTER LISTS ELEVEN AND.
WE NEVER LIKE TO SEE WIN
APPARENT BURIES HER CHILD.
BUT OUR CONDOLENCES TO STELLA
CASTIGATE HOSTS AYE AND HER
SISTER ADA SARAH JOHN AND
NEPHEW.
ANTHONY. THIS HIT HOME FOR A
COUPLE REASONS.
COLLEAGUES ONE BECAUSE I DID
REPRESENT THE AREA AND NEW MIKE
PERSONALLY.
BUT HIS BIRTHDAY. IS FEBRUARY
THE ELEVENTH NINETEEN FIFTY SIX.
MY BIRTH DATE IS JANUARY
THIRTIETH NINETEEN FIFTY SIX I'M
TEN DAYS.
OLDER.
THEN MICHAEL WAS
SO THIS REALLY HITS HOME. ABOUT
WHERE YOU DON'T EXPECT THIS KIND
OF.
.
FATALITY.
THIS WAS THE FLU IT JUST SHOWS
YOU HOW DANGEROUS AND VERA LYNN
THIS FLU IS.
AND I GUESS IF THERE'S A HAVE A
MESSAGE IN MEMORY OF MIKE THAT
WE WANT NO. A GET OUT TO THE
PUBLIC IS IF YOU HAVE THIS FLU.
DON'T WASTE YOUR TIME GET TO A
DOCTOR.
THE SCENE.
AND BY ALL MEANS.
TO GET ON THE APPROPRIATE
MEDICATION SO THAT YOU CAN
PREVENT PROBABLY THE.
NUMBER ONE REASON WHY PEOPLE
ARE DYING FROM THIS FLUID THAT'S
BECAUSE THEY GET TO THE POINT
WHERE. THEY'RE PNEUMONIA IS.
PERVASIVE AND.
BEYOND WHERE.
ANTIBIOTICS CAN TAKE OVER AND
TRY TO.
REDEEM THEM BACK TO LIFE AGAIN
SO.
I WANNA SAY MIKE CUSS LAY HOSTS
A GENTLEMAN.
A FAMILY MAN AND MAY HE REST IN
PEACE.
THINK YOU THINK YOU SENATOR
STONE CENTER MORRELL PLEASE MAKE
SURE YOU BRING HIS NAME FORWARD
THANK YOU.
MEMBERS ARE THERE ANY FURTHER
ADJOURNMENT MEMORIES.
CENTER PORTANTINO.
THANK YOU.
META PRO TEM AND COLLEAGUES
SEVEN. TODAY I RISE TO.
ASHEN WOULD JOIN MEAN
ADJOURNING IN THE MEMORY OF A
SCHOLAR ATHLETE TO WHOSE LIFE
WAS TRAGICALLY.
CUT SHORT TO A TYLER POLANSKI.
TYLER WAS TWENTY ONE YEARS OF
AGE A CLAREMONT RESIDENT AND
FORMER UPLAND HIGH SCHOOL STAR
QUARTERBACK. AND HE WAS IN LINE
TO BE WASHINGTON STATE'S
STARTING QUARTERBACK THIS YEAR
IN TWO THOUSAND EIGHTEEN.
UNFORTUNATELY TYLER PASSED AWAY
LAST WEEK NOW BEFORE JOINING
WASHINGTON STATE'S PROGRAM.
TYLER STARTED AT UPLAND FOR TWO
SEASONS
AS A HIGH SCHOOL JUNIOR IN TWO
THOUSAND THIRTEEN HE WAS NAMED
THE INLAND VALLEY DAILY
BULLETINS OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF
THE YEAR. HE ALSO RECEIVE SECOND
TEAM ALL INLAND VALLEY HNORS AS
A SENIOR IN TWO THOUSAND
FOURTEEN. AND HELPED UPLAND
REACH THE CIF SEMIFINALS HE WAS
AMONG A FAMILY OF QUARTERBACKS.
AND IT'S TIME IN WASHINGTON
STATE. HE APPEARED IN EIGHT
GAMES DURING HIS SOPHOMORE
SEASON AND HIS MOST MEMORABLE
OUTING CAME IN THE SECOND WEEK
OF THE SEASON WHEN HE LED
WASHINGTON STATE FROM A TWENTY
ONE POINT DEFICIT IN THE FOURTH
QUARTER. TO BE BOISE STATE FORTY
SEVEN FORTY FOUR IN TRIPLE
OVERTIME. HE THREW FOR TWO
HUNDRED AND FORTY YARDS AND
THREE TOUCHDOWNS
COMING OFF THE BENCH AND WAS
CARRIED OFF THE FIELD.
IN THE VICTORY CELEBRATION
WASHINGTON STATE'S FOOTBALL
COACH MIKE LEACH
SAID IN A STATEMENT HE WAS AN
INCREDIBLE YOUNG MAN AND
EVERYONE. WHO HAD THE PRIVILEGE
OF KNOWING HIM? WAS BETTER OFF
FOR IT.
DARRYL THOMAS WHO WAS UPLANDS
HIGH SCHOOL'S ASSISTANT
PRINCIPAL AND COACH.
SAID TYLER WAS ALWAYS VERY
COMPETITIVE HE WOULD EAT YOU UP
IF YOU ARE NOT READY TO GO WERE
PREPARED ON THE DEFENSIVE SIDE
OF THE BALL.
HE ALSO SAID THE TYLER DIDN'T
TAKE ANY PLAYS OFF.
OF HIS WORK ETHIC AND HIS WORK
ETHIC WAS TOP NOTCH HE WAS
ALWAYS WORKING.
BE BETTER AND GET BETTER. BUT
TYLER IS SURVIVED BY HIS PARENTS
MARKING KIM HELEN SKINNY AND
BROTHERS KELLY AND RYAN.
.
NO PARENT AS HAS BEEN SAID.
ELOQUENTLY SHOULD LIVE LONGER
THAN THEIR CHILDREN
SHOULD HAVE TO.
SAY GOODBYE TO THEIR CHILDREN
CERTAINLY.
SUICIDE. IS SOMETHING THAT WE
SHOULD ALL CONTINUE TO WORK.
TOWARDS DECREASING IN YOUNG
PEOPLE IT'S AN ISSUE THAT HAS
TOUCHED MY FAMILY.
PERSONALLY AND TO HEAR OF A
YOUNG STAR ATHLETE WHO HAD SO
MUCH TO LIVE FOR. TRAGICALLY
TAKE HIS LIFE.
MY PRAYERS AND I KNOW ALL OF US
SAID NO WELL WISHES TO HIS
FAMILY AND SURVIVING OF
RELATIVES.
AND I JUST PLEASE JOIN ME IN
ADJOURNING IS MEMORY THANK YOU.
THINK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
PLEASE BRING HIS NAME FORWARD.
NO FURTHER ADJOURN A MEMORIES
COMMITTEE ANNOUNCEMENTS WOULD BE
APPROPRIATE.
SENATOR DALY ON METAL PRESENTS
OTHER COLLEAGUES.
WE CAN HAVE A RULES COMMITTEE
HEARING A VERY BRIEF FOR SHORT.
THE.
THIRTY ONE NO EIGHT.
THIRTY ONE NINETY ONE THE ROOM
OVER THERE. THIRTY ONE NIGHT SO
I'M THE FIVE THIRTY ONE NINETY
ONE.
THANK YOU CENTER DAILY. THIRTY
OR MORE LIKE FOR A PURPOSE TO
RISE. LIKE TO SPEAK ON CONDITION
OF THE FILE WITHOUT OBJECTION
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT
RESOLUTION NUMBER TWENTY FIVE
OF.
THE YEAR NINETEEN NINETEEN.
NINETY NINE YEARS AGO DETERMINED
THAT THE OFFICIAL DATE OF THE
DISCOVERY OF GOLD.
BY JAMES W. MARSHALL AT PALOMA
ELDORADO COUNTY IT WAS JANUARY
TWENTY FOUR.
EIGHTEEN FORTY EIGHT THIS WAS A
BIG DEAL BECAUSE THE SIGN SAID
JANUARY NINETEEN.
SO WE HAVE THE OFFICIAL REPORT.
WHICH.
DECLARE JANUARY TWENTY FOURTH
THE DATE OF DISCOVERY AND THAT
HAS HELL TO THIS DAY.
THE REPORT WAS SIGNED BY PHILIP
BALDWIN BACK ART.
WHO ARE REPRESENTED THE PIONEERS
OF CALIFORNIA? IT JUST TURNS OUT
HIS THE GREAT HE WAS THE
GRANDFATHER OF LARA BACK OUR
DEEDS WHO'S ONE OF MY.
CONSTITUENTS IN THE CITY OF
CORONA DEL MAR. AND SERVE WITH
ME ON THE CALIFORNIA SESQUI
CENTENNIAL FOUNDATION BOARD.
WITH THAT. I WISH TO RECOGNIZE
THE HUNDRED AND SEVENTIETH
ANNIVERSARY.
OF THE DISCOVERY OF GOLD ON
JANUARY TWENTY FOURTH THIS WEEK
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT. THANK
YOU SENATOR MORLOCK.
MEMBERS IF THERE IS NO FURTHER
BUSINESS CENTER DAILY ON THE
DESK IS CLEAR.
THANK YOU MUCH ABOUT PRESENT
COLLEAGUES FOR THOSE WHO ARE
MEMBERS RULES COMMITTEE PLEASE.
GO TO THE.
A RULES COMMITTEE HERE RIGHT
NOW UP COLLEAGUES WE WILL A
RECONVENE ON THURSDAY AT NINE
AM.
AT WHICH AT NINE FORTY FIVE A
AND COLLECTIVELY DEMOCRATS
REPUBLICANS TOGETHER WE WILL
WALK OVER TO OF THE ASSEMBLY
FLOOR WITH OUR COLLEAGUES.
TO HEAR THE STATE OF THE STATE
SPEECH AT THE FINAL ONE BUYER
GOVERNOR JERRY BROWN SO WITH
THAT. BOND PRESENT.
LOOK FORWARD WE WILL SEE EACH
OTHER ON THURSDAY NINETY.
THANK YOU CENTER DELEON THE
SENATE WILL BE ADJOURNED WE WILL
RECONVENE THURSDAY AT NINE A. M.
HAVE A GREAT DAY EVERYONE