HELLO SAY HELLO TO THE HOLY
SPIRIT ACADEMY UP IN THE GALLERY
I WILL GIVE HIM SENATE WELCOME.
WELCOME.
PICTURE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN EL DORADO GIL ARCHULETA S.
B. ATKINS BECKER LAKE SUPERIOR
BRADFORD CABALLERO CORTESE DALY
DODD THE RAZA EGGMAN GLAZER
GONZALEZ GROVE- TADO JONES
LAYERED RAMON MCGUIRE. MENJIVAR
MAN. NEWMAN WHEN NIELLO HOTEL
ABOVE BY THE PORTANTINO RAW
RUBIO SEYARTO SKINNER SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS STERN- BURKE WELL HARM
WIENER WILK. MEMBERS A QUORUM IS
PRESENT WHAT OUR MEMBERS IN OUR
GAS BEYOND THE RAIL AND IN THE
GALLERY PLEASE RISE WILL BE LED
IN PRAYER TODAY BY OUR CHAPLAIN
SISTER MICHELLE GORMAN AFTER
WHICH WE'RE GOING TO ASK YOU TO
REMAIN STANDING AND WILL BE LED
IN THE PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE
FLAG BY SENATOR DORADO. THANKS
INTO GOD'S HOLY PRESENCE. G. K.
CHESTERTON SAID WE'RE ALL IN THE
SAME BOAT AND WE OWE EACH OTHER
A TERRIBLE LOYALTY. GRACIOUS GOD
MOTHER AND FATHER OF US ALL IN
THE URGENCY OF OUR WORLD CONTEXT
BELOW THE VIOLENCE AND
TURBULENCE OF THE WEIGHTS HELP
US TO MAKE EVIDENCE ARE
PASSIONATE COMMITMENT TO ADDRESS
THE ISSUES THAT CAUSE
MISUNDERSTANDINGS AND JUDGEMENTS
IN OUR WORLD. MAY OUR GROWING
CONSCIOUSNESS OF THE
INTERDEPENDENCE AMONG US AND
WITH ALL CREATION. GALVANIZE US
INTO LOYALTY THAT WE OWE TO ONE
ANOTHER. A LOYALTY OF FAITH THAT
INTERESTS ARE FIGURES TO THE
GOODNESS OF THOSE WHO LOVE
UNCONDITIONALLY. A LOYALTY OF
HOPE THAT IMPELS US TO WORK FOR
A SUSTAINABLE FUTURE. AND THE
LOYALTY OF LOVE THAT ALLOWS US
TO BE FAITHFUL TO EACH OTHER
REGARDLESS OF PERCEIVED
DIFFERENCES. FOR WINDOWS DOES
YOUR LOVE EXCLUDES NO ONE A MAN
. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE
FLAG. WHICH IS. IT'S A COOL.
ALL RIGHT WE'RE GOING TO
PRIVILEGES FOR. I'LL BE HAPPY
CENTER ALLEN THE CALIFORNIA
SENATE WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME DR
JILL WE SU A MIRAMAR WHO JOINS
US IN THE GALLERY. A LEADER IN
THE DEMOCRACY MOVEMENT DOCTORS
SO WE SU SERVES AS THE UNION
MINISTER OF HEALTH AND EDUCATION
UNDER THEIR DEBT DEMOCRATICALLY
ELECTED NATIONAL UNITY
GOVERNMENT OF MYANMAR IN EXILE.
WELCOME.
NOW REMOVING MESSAGES FROM THE
GOVERNMENT WILL BE DEEMED READ.
MESSAGES FROM THE ASSEMBLY WOULD
BE DEEMED READ REPORTS OF
COMMITTEES WILL BE DEEMED READ
AND AMENDMENTS ADOPTED NOW MOVIE
TO MOTIONS OR RESOLUTIONS AND
NOTICES. ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS
WISHING TO BE RECOGNIZED AT THIS
POINT. C. NINE NOW MOVING ON TO
CONSIDERATION OF DAILY FILE
MOVING TO STE SENATE SECOND
READING FILE SECRETARY PLEASE
RATE SENATE BILL SIX SIXTY SEVEN
. NOW MOVING THE GOVERNOR'S
APPOINTMENTS SENATOR GROW SHE'S
PREPARED WE'LL START WITH FILE
ITEM. TO THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES GOOD MORNING FILE
ITEM TWO IS A CONFIRMATION OF
PATRICIA CASSIDY FOR RE
APPOINTMENT TO THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARINGS- MISS CASSIDY IS
THE COMMISSIONER IT'S HER FIRST
APPOINTMENT TO THE BOARD YES HE
WAS FIRST APPOINTED TO THE BOARD
IN TWO THOUSAND SIXTEEN PRIOR TO
THAT SHE SERVED ON THE BOARD
SEVERAL POSITIONS. IN SINCE
NINETEEN NINETY FIVE INCLUDING
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND THE
CHIEF DEPUTY COMMISSIONER SHE
WAS APPROVED BY THE RULES
COMMITTEE ON MAY SEVENTEENTH BY
UNANIMOUS VOTE RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE. ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
APPOINTMENT. IN NINETY SIX-
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ELLEN HI EL
DORADO GUILT. ARCHULETA HI
ASHLEY HI ATKINS. BACKER I
BELIEVE SPARE. HI BRADFORD. FIVE
HIGH COURT. I DALY. DODD THE
RAZA. HI THANK. HI GLAZER. I
GONZALEZ HI GROVE. GROVE HI HER
TADO. HI JONES. HI LAYERED. HI
LIMÓN. HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA.
BY MEN. I NEWMAN. HI WHEN. I
NEED LOW. HI I'M JOE BUG. BUT
IN. I PORTANTINO. BY ROTH. HI
RUBIO. RUBIO. SEYARTO HI SKINNER
. HI SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI STERN.
HI I'M BURKE. I WILL HA. HI
WIENER. I WILL. I. YOUR GIRL
MOVES CALL. NOW MOVING ON THE
FILE ITEM THREE. THANK YOU
MATTER- MISTER PRESIDENT THANK
YOU MR PRESIDENT FILE ITEM THREE
IS A CONFIRMATION OF LAWRENCE A
YOUNG LADY FOR THE APPOINTMENT
TO THE BOARD OF PAROLE HEARINGS.
AND HE SERVED AS A BOARD HE
SERVED ON THE BOARD SINCE TWENTY
TWENTY ONE AND PREVIOUSLY SERVED
ON THE BOARD OF THE DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER IN THE
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE I KNOW
THERE ARE SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES
ON THIS FLOOR THAT AND- I KNOW
THERE ARE SOME OF. MY COLLEAGUES
ON THIS FLOOR THAT HAVE A HUGE
CONCERN WITH THE RELEASE RATE
THAT THEY APPEAR TO HAVE WITH
MR- YEAH I WAY BUT I WANT YOU TO
KNOW THAT- M. R. JA J. I
APOLOGIZE. I'M ASKING THIS
INDIVIDUAL QUESTIONS. ASKING
THIS INDIVIDUAL QUESTIONS AND
GETTING THE RESPONSES HE CARRIES
A HEAVY WEIGHT AND BURDEN
BECAUSE HE FEELS LIKE THERE IS A
BALANCE THAT THESE COMMISSIONERS
HAVE TO BE ABLE TO GRANT SOMEONE
FREEDOM THAT HAS EARNED FREEDOM
. LIKE A LOT OF SECOND CANCERS-
THAT FRANKLY WORK HERE IN THE
BUILDING WITH US. AND THAT WORK
IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN THAT
BUILD LIVES AFTER THEY'VE SERVED
THEIR TIME IN PRISON HE HAS TO
BALANCE THAT WITH GRANTING
FREEDOM. WITH PROTECTING THE
PUBLIC IN MAKING A MISTAKE OF
RELEASING SOMEBODY THAT WOULD
CAUSE HARM. TO CITIZENS AND HE
CARRIES A GREAT HEAVINESS IN HIS
HEART TO MAKE SURE THAT HE MAKES
THE RIGHT DECISION. AND I
REALIZE AND HE SAID SOMETHING TO
ME THAT HE ALWAYS FOLLOWS UP ON
THOSE THAT HE GRANTS. THIS TO
GIVE OUR FREEDOM TO OF PEOPLE
THAT HE FEELS HAVE MET THE
METRICS AND TAKEN THE CLASSES
AND DONE WHAT THEY'RE REQUIRED
TO DO. IN ORDER TO. EARN THAT
GRANTED FREEDOM HE GOES SO MUCH
TO MEET WITH INDIVIDUALS FIVE
YEARS BEFORE. THEY'RE ACTUALLY
GONNA BE GRANTED PAROLE AND HE
SAYS IF YOU DO NOT MEET THESE
THINGS YOU WILL NOT COME BEFORE
ME OR YOU'LL COME BEFORE ME BUT
YOU WILL BE GRANTED. HE HE TELLS
THEM HOW TO HOW TO. HOW TO GET
THAT FREEDOM BACK THAT THAT WAS
THAT WAS TAKEN FROM THEM FOR THE
RIGHTFUL PURPOSE OF HARMING
ANOTHER HUMAN BEING. BUT I THINK
THAT THIS INDIVIDUAL I'M REALLY
CARRIES WEIGHT. WHEN YOU LOOK AT
THINGS IN THAT SITUATION BECAUSE
WHETHER IT'S GOVERNING WHETHER
IT'S A PRO BOARD HEARING WHETHER
IT'S THE WAY WE REPRESENT ARE
COMMITTED TO OUR CONSTITUENTS.
YOU SHOULD ALL BE ABOUT BALANCE
AND NOT ONE SIDED AND ALTHOUGH
THAT- THERE IS SOME- FEEDBACK
THAT I'VE GOTTEN ABOUT. SPEAKING
PUBLICLY ABOUT THIS INDIVIDUAL I
DON'T CARE I THINK HE'S A GOOD
PERSON AND I THINK HE CARRIES A
LOT OF WEIGHT WHEN HE MAKES
DECISIONS ABOUT PAROLE GRANT
RELEASES. AND THE PUBLIC SAFETY
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
ITEM. THANK YOU ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
ITEM. YOU'RE IN CHINO INSERTED
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN. HI I
WILL RUN AGAIN. HI ARCHULETA. I
SB. HI ATKINS. BAKER BY BLAKE
SPEIR. I BRADFORD. AYE COMING AT
ALL. HI CORTESE. I TELLING. DODD
THE RAZA. I EGGMAN. GLAZER HI
GONZALEZ. A GROVE. HI- TADO. HI
JONES. I LAYERED. HI LIMÓN. I
MCGUIRE. NAME MENJIVAR. HI MEN.
HI NEWMAN. HI WHEN. NILA A SHOW
ABOUT. PADILLA I PORTANTINO. HI
ROB. I RUBIO. HI SEYARTO. HI
SKINNER. HI SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. HI
STERN. HI AMBERG. BY ONE OF. HI
WIENER. I WILL. WE'RE MOVING THE
CALL MEMBERS WERE GOING TO GO
THROUGH THE ROLE ONE TIME ON
EACH ITEM AND I WILL PUT IT ON
CALL SO WE ASK THAT ALL MEMBERS
JOIN IS ON THE FLOOR. NEXT WERE
MOVING NOW TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
FOUR THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES MICHAEL REST AS A RE
APPOINTMENT TO THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARINGS COMMISSIONER
RALF IS SERVED ON THE BOARD
SINCE TWO THOUSAND AND SEVENTEEN
BEFORE JOINING THE BOARD HE
SERVICE SAYS THE DEPARTMENT OF
CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATION
SAID SPECIAL AGENT IN CHARGE OF
DIVISION OF ADULT INSTITUTIONS
HE PREVIOUSLY SERVED THE UNITED
STATES AIR FORCE HE TOOK AN OATH
TO DEFEND THIS COUNTRY AND ITS
CONSTITUTION. AGAINST ALL
ENEMIES FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC HE
HAS THE RIGHT HEART FOR THIS
POSITION AND THE RIGHT- NO
NONSENSE THIS IS THE WAY IT IS
TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT TYPE
ATTITUDE AND- I THOUGHT HE WAS
REALLY GREAT ON THE ON THE
INTERVIEW AND THE QUESTIONS THAT
HE RESPONDED TO AN RESPECTFULLY
ASK PRIVATE. THANK YOU ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
THIS APPOINTMENT. HEARING NONE
SECTOR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN. NUMBER AGAIN. HI
ARCHULETA. HI ASHLEY. I ATKINS
BECKER. I BLAKE'S BEER. I
BRADFORD. AYE COMING INTO. HI
CORTESE. I DALY. I DON. THE RAZA
. HI EGGMAN. AYE GLAZER. HI
GONZALEZ. A GROVE. I OUR TITLE.
HI JONES. I LAYERED. HI THE MON
. I MCGUIRE. MENJIVAR I MEN. HI
NEWMAN. HI WHEN. I NEED A LITTLE
. HI I'M JOE ABOVE. BY THE- TIME
PORTANTINO. I BROUGHT. I RUBIO.
SEYARTO I SKINNER. I SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS I STERN HI NUMBER. HI BOB
I WIENER. HI WILK I. SHOOTER
GIRL MOVES TO CALL NOW MEMBERS
REMOVING THE FILE ITEM FIVE
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT FILE ITEM
FIVE IS THE CONFIRMATION OF MARY
THORNTON A FOR REPORT
APPOINTMENT TO THE BOARD OF
PAROLE HEARINGS COMMISSIONER
THORTON HAS SERVED ON THE BOARD
SINCE TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN
PRIOR TO HER APPOINTMENT TO
SERVING ON THE BOARD AND DEPUTY
COMMISSIONER ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
JUDGE SHE HAS ALSO PREVIOUSLY
SERVED AS A DEPUTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY FOR MADERA COUNTY IN
KINGS COUNTY. AND SHE WAS
APPROVAL BY THE APPROVED BY THE
RULES COMMITTEE ON A FIVE OH
VOTE ON MAY SEVENTEENTH
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE ON THIS APPOINTMENT.
HEARING NONE SECTOR PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN I WOULD RATHER GO
. HI ARCHULETA HI ASHLEY HI
ATKINS BECKER. HI PLEASE BEER. I
BRADFORD. HI CABALLERO. I IN.
AYE DE. DODD DURAS. I EGGMAN.
AYE GLAZER. HI GONZALEZ. HI
GROVE. HI- TADO. JONES I LAYERED
. I LIMÓN. I MCGUIRE. I MEANS OF
OUR- I MEAN. HI NEWMAN. I WHEN.
BY ANY LOW. I AM SHOW ABOVE. I.
TWENTY A- I PORTANTINO. AYE
ROTH. AYE RUBIO. I SEYARTO AYE
SKINNER. A SMALL CUEVAS. A
STERN. BY AMBERG AYE ONE HUB. HI
WIENER. HI WILK I CENTER GROVE
MOVES CALL NUMBER IS REMOVING TO
SENATE THIRD READING WE HAVE
QUITE A FEW ITEMS. OUR FIRST
AUTHOR IS SENATOR MAN IS HE
PREPARED. SINNER MAN ARE YOU
PREPARED HE IS FILE ITEM NINE
SECRETARY PLEASE REACH SENATE
BILL SEVEN FORTY ONE BY SENATOR
MEN AN ACT RELATING TO DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
SB SEVEN FORTY ONE WOULD AMEND
THE DOMESTIC VIOLENCE PREVENTION
ACT TO ALLOW DISCOVERY ONLY IF
SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED BY THE
COURT- WELL THE MYSTIC VIOLENCE
RESTRAINING ORDERS OR D. V. R.
OWES HAVE PROVEN TO BE A
INCREDIBLY EFFECTIVE LEGAL
REMEDY FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
SURVIVORS- LACK OF CLARITY IN
THE DISCOVERY PROCESS HAS TO
FREQUENTLY BEEN EXPLOITED TO
THEIR DETRIMENT. OFTEN AT THE
RESULT OF HARASSMENT AND
INTIMIDATION OF DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE SURVIVORS I CREATING
UNNECESSARY DELAYS THROUGH- DID
THIS ABUSIVE PRACTICE PRACTICE I
INCREASING DELAYS IN THE QUEUE
EDUCATION OF DV ARE- REQUESTS SB
SEVEN FORTY ONE WOULD ENSURE
THAT PARTIES ONLY USE PRE
HEARING DISCOVERY WHEN NECESSARY
AND WITH GOOD CAUSE. I IS COME
TO MY ATTENTION OVER THE PAST
WEEK THAT THE BILL DOES NEED
SOME ADDITIONAL MEASUREMENTS TO
ADDRESS CONCERNS RAISED BY
SEVERAL STAKEHOLDERS AND I WILL
TELL YOU HERE AND I AM COMMITTED
TO WORK ON THESE ISSUES I SHOULD
THIS BILL MAKE IT OVER TO THE
ASSEMBLY. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE. ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION DEBATE ON THIS I
DON'T. HERE NINETEEN NINE.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON FILE
ITEM NINE ALLEN. EVERADO GIL.
ARCHULETA HI ASHLEY. I ATKINS
BECKER. I BLANKS BEER. HI
BRADFORD. AYE CABALLERO. AYE
CORTESE. AYE TELLING. DONE THE
RAZA. I EGGMAN. I GLAZER. HI
GONZALEZ. I GROVE. OUR TARA.
JONES NO LAYERED. BY THE MOON. I
MCGUIRE. HI MENJIVAR. I MIN. AYE
NEWMAN. AYE NGUYEN. NAY LOW. NO-
CHAU ABOVE. HI BY THE- WAY
PORTANTINO. I ROTH. BY RUBIO. HI
SEYARTO. NO SKINNER. BY SMALL
TWELVE US BY STERN. BY BURKE I
LOVE. HI WIENER. BY WILK. I.
SKINNER MA'AM MOVES CALL.
MEMBERS NOW WE'RE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM TWENTY SENATOR LAYERED HE'S
PREPARED SECRETARY MAY READ.
SENATE BILL FIVE AWAY BY CENTER
LAYERED AN ACT RELATING TO
CANNABIS THE EARLIER THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MR PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES THIS BILL IS ABOUT
THE CANNABIS REGULATORY SYSTEM
WHAT WE REALLY WANT TO DO IS WE
WANT TO MAKE THE LEGAL SYSTEM
WORK AND HAVE THAT JUXTAPOSED TO
SIT AGAINST THOSE THAT HAVEN'T
COME IN THE LEGAL SYSTEM YET-
THIS BILL- IS DESIGNED TO FIX
THE PROBLEM A TO MOVE FROM TWO
SEQUEL REVIEWS TO ONE ON THE
SAME PROJECT. IT DOES NOT FIX
THE ENTIRE SYSTEM AND WE HAVE
MOVED PEOPLE TO THE TABLE SO
WE'VE HAD IN THE LAST FEW WEEKS
VERY CONSTRUCTIVE TALKS AND WE
INTEND TO GET TO AN EVEN BETTER
PLACE. IN THE ASSEMBLY I JUST
THE THING ABOUT THIS IS THIS IS
A SUPPORT SUPPORT BILL. AND THE
REASON I WANT TO SPEAK AS I KNOW
THERE ARE FEW MEMBERS THAT ARE
GOING TO WAY OFF- EVEN THOUGH IT
SUPPORT SUPPORT. BUT WE'RE
GETTING TO A GOOD PLACE OF THIS
SOLVES THE PROBLEM I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR ON
FROM. IN FURTHER DISCUSSION
TODAY ON THE SIDE. HE FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE HEARING
THREE NINE CENTER PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL FILE I'M TWENTY ALLEN.
ALL RIGHT AGAIN. HI ARCHULETA.
HI SB I ATKINS AYE BECKER. AYE
BLIX BEAR. I BRADFORD AYE COMING
OUT OF. HIGH CORTESE. HI DALY.
BY DONE. THE RAZA. EGGMAN I
GLAZER. HI GONZALEZ. GROVE. HI-
TADO. HI JONES. FIVE LAYERED. HI
LIMÓN. MCGUIRE MENJIVAR. MCGUIRE
AYE MENDOZA. THE MEN. BYE NEWMAN
. HI WHEN. NERO HI PHOTOBOOK I
BY THE- BY PORTANTINO. HI RON. I
RUBIO. I SAY ARE TOO HIGH
SKINNER. HI SMALLER CUEVAS HI
STERN. BURKE I LOVE. WE WILL
HAVE A AYE WIENER. HI WILK I.
SKINNER LORED MOVES A CALL NOW
LET'S MOVE BACK TO FOLLOW HIM
SEVENTEEN CENTER ARE TO LET IT
IS REPAIRED. SECRETARY MARY.
SENATE BILL EIGHT OH SIX BY
SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
RELATING TO PUBLIC SAFETY CENTER
TO OUR THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
SENATE BILL EIGHT OH SIX MAKES
MINOR CHANGES TO LAST YOUR BILL
ELEVEN ELEVEN SENATE BILL ELEVEN
ELEVEN THE RICK'S BEST SAFETY
ACT WHICH ADDRESSES SAFETY
CONCERNS WITH UNMARKED TRASH
RECEPTACLES ALSO KNOWN AS THAT
THE DUMPSTERS DISOWNED BY
REQUIRING THAT THESE TRASH
CONTAINERS THAT ARE PLACED ON
ROADS CURBS AND ALLEYWAYS HAVE
REFLECTIVE MARKETING ON EACH
SIDE. THE REFLECTED MARKETING
SERVES AN IMPORTANT SAFETY
MEASURE TO PREVENT ACCIDENTS AND
COLLISIONS ESPECIALLY AT NIGHT
AND DURING LOW VISIBILITY AND
FOR THESE REASONS I ASK FOR YOUR
I. BOATS. ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE ON THIS ITEM ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. C.
NINE SECTOR YOU MAY CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN. OBERAMT AGAIN. HI
ARCHULETA. HI ASHLEY. I ATKINS.
BY BECKER. HI LAKE SUPERIOR. BY
BRADFORD. AYE COMING OUT OF.
HIGH CORTESE. I DALY. AYE DUN.
AYE DURAZO. I EGGMAN. I GLAZER.
GONZALEZ HI GROVE. I TIDO. I
JONES. I LAYERED. I LIMÓN. HI
MCGUIRE. HI MENJIVAR. I MEAN. I
NEWMAN. I NGUYEN. I KNEW LOW. HI
OF JOE BURKE. HI BY THE END. HI
PORTANTINO. BY ROTH I RUBIO. I
SAY ARE TO. HI SKINNER. A SMALL
GROUP OF US- A STERN HI AMBERG.
A WELL HUB HI WIENER. HI WILK I
. PLEASE CALL OUT TO MEMBERS
ALLEN.
RIGHT CENTER PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN ALLEN I.
ALL RIGHTS FOR FORTY NO ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES NOW MEMBERS WERE
MOVING ON A FILE ITEM 29% OR
PORTANTINO HE'S REPAIRED
SECRETARY MAY READ SENATE BILL
TWO BY SENATOR PORTANTINO AN ACT
RELATING TO FIREARMS YOUR
PORTANTINO. THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS I RISE TO
PRESENT S. B. TWO. SADLY IN OUR
COUNTRY THERE'VE BEEN FAR FAR
TOO MANY. MASS GUN DEATHS.
CHILDREN FAMILIES. FIRST
RESPONDERS. AVERAGE PEOPLE.
MOVIEGOER'S CHILDREN AT SCHOOL.
AND WE HAVE TO DO BETTER WE HAVE
TO DO MORE TO PROTECT THEM- THE
SUPREME COURT. SAID THAT
CALIFORNIA CAN NO LONGER HAVE.
AN ARBITRARY OR AN STANDARD
NONSTANDARD WAY OF ISSUING
CONCEALED CARRY PERMITS. WE KNOW
THAT THE PROLIFERATION OF GUNS
IN HOUSES LEADS TO DIRE
CONSEQUENCES WE KNOW THAT THERE
ARE SOME FOLKS THAT JUST FRANKLY
SHOULD NOT BE PERMITTED TO HAVE
A WEAPON. AND THE SUPREME COURT
SAYS WE CAN REGULATE THAT AND SO
I WANT TO THANK GOVERNOR NEWSOM
AND ATTORNEY GENERAL BONTA FOR
WORKING COLLABORATIVE LEE TO
COME UP WITH SB TWO. TO SET IN
PLACE A FRAMEWORK THAT BECOME
STATEWIDE. THAT PUTS IN PLACE
CONCRETE REGULATIONS AGAIN
ACCORDING TO WHAT THE SUPREME
COURT SAYS WE CAN AND CAN'T DO
THAT SAYS IF YOU ARE A PERSON
WHO WOULD BE DANGEROUS TO OTHER
PEOPLE IF YOU HAVE A HISTORY OF
VIOLENCE IF YOU HAVE DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE IN YOUR BACKGROUND IF
YOU'VE BEEN POSTING VIOLENT
THINGS IF YOU CAN'T GET PEOPLE
TO VOUCH FOR YOU. YOU SHOULD NOT
HAVE A CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT.
SPRING COURT ALSO SAYS YOU CAN
HAVE PROHIBITED PLACES. SO DO
YOU NEED A WEAPON TO GO TO YOUR
DAUGHTER OR SON'S. AYSO SOCCER
GAME. THE DISNEYLAND. TO A BALL
GAME. I WOULD SUBMIT NOW. AND SO
SB TWO INCLUDES A ROBUST LIST OF
PROHIBITED PLACES. AND AGAIN.
LIKE MANY OF US. I DON'T WANT TO
SEE. SAD STATEMENTS ABOUT TRAGIC
EVENTS THAT DON'T LEAD TO
RESULTS ANYMORE IN THE GUN
DEBATE. WE KNOW STATISTICALLY
THAT THOSE STATES THAT HAVE A
LAX. GUN REGULATIONS. HAVE MORE
DEATHS DUE TO GUN VIOLENCE. WE
KNOW CALIFORNIA IS SAFER
BECAUSE- OF THE LAWS WE PASS IN
THE STATE SENATE. AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
ON SB TWO. TO CONTINUE MAKING
CALIFORNIA AND CALIFORNIANS
SAFER FROM GUN VIOLENCE. THANK
YOU ANY FURTHER DESCRIPTION OF
IT ON THE SIDE I'M CENTER SORRY
ARE TWO. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
AND MEMBERS. TARGETING CZW.
CARRIERS AS THEIR YOU BECAUSE-
OF. THE TRAGIC SHOOTINGS THE
MASS SHOOTINGS. IS PROBABLY THE
WRONG TARGET. BECAUSE STATISTICS
BEAR THAT OUT CZW CARRIERS ARE
NOT THE INSTIGATORS OF THOSE
KIND TYPES OF VIOLENCE. AND THE
INSTIGATORS OF THOSE TYPES OF
VIOLENCE. CAN'T GET A CCW
THROUGH THE PROCESSES THAT WE
ALREADY HAVE. SO IT'S REALLY NOT
DOING ANYTHING TO CURB OUR GUN
VIOLENCE ISSUES. THERE ARE SOME
THINGS WE CAN DO. WE NEED TO
ENFORCE THE LAWS THAT WE ALREADY
HAVE ON THE BOOKS. TO CURB GUN
VIOLENCE. AND WE NEED TO TARGET
THE BACKLOG OF SOME TWENTY THREE
THOUSAND PEOPLE. THAT ARE KNOWN
PROHIBITED PERSONS FELONS THAT
WE KNOW HAVE GUNS. AND YET. WE
DO NOTHING ABOUT IT. IF YOU WANT
TO TAKE GUNS AWAY FROM
IRRESPONSIBLE PEOPLE. WE NEED TO
START TAKING THEM AWAY FROM THE
PEOPLE WE ALREADY KNOW ARE
IRRESPONSIBLE AND ARE ILLEGALLY
CARRYING THEM. BUT WE WON'T DO
THAT. WE WON'T DO THAT. BECAUSE
WHAT DO YOU DO WHEN YOU CATCH
SOMEBODY WHO IS ILLEGALLY
CARRYING A WEAPON. WE HAVE TO DO
SOMETHING WITH THEM AND WE DON'T
WANT TO DO ANYTHING WITH THEM WE
DON'T WANT TO PUT THEM IN PRISON
. WE DON'T WANT TO HOLD THEM
ACCOUNTABLE WE WANT TO TAKE AWAY
THEIR GUN. SURE AND THEN THEY'LL
GO BUY ANOTHER GUN. BECAUSE
THAT'S THE OTHER PART THAT WE
NEED TO WORK ON. AND WE ALREADY
HAVE THE LAWS TO DO IT. WE NEED
TO WORK ON. THE ILLEGAL SALES
AND SMUGGLING OF GUNS. NOT ONLY
INTO OUR COUNTRY BUT IN THE
CALIFORNIA. AND WE'RE DOING
NOTHING ABOUT THAT. THESE
TRAGEDIES THAT WE KEEP HAVING TO
DEAL WITH OVER AND OVER. A LOT
OF THEM CAN BE AVERTED BUT WE'LL
NEVER KNOW BECAUSE WE DON'T
ENFORCE THE GUN LAWS THAT WE
ALREADY HAVE. AND THE PEOPLE.
THAT ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT.
WE CAN MAKE ALL THE RESTRICTIONS
WE WANT ON THEM BECAUSE THEY'RE
NOT THE PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING TO
GO OUT AND DO THIS. SO MEMBERS I
ASKED. YEAH WE START. IN THE
FIRE SERVICE YOU WANT TO PUT OUT
A FIRE YOU PUT THAT YOU AIM THE
HOSE AT THE BASE OF THE FLAMES.
YOU DON'T AIM IT AT THE TOP THE
TOP MAKES A BETTER PICTURE. BUT
IT DOESN'T DO ANYTHING. WE KEEP
AIMING AT THE TOP. WE HAVE SOME
RULES WE HAVE SOME REGULATIONS
THAT WE CAN USE TO STOP THIS. WE
CAN USE IT TO STOP THIS VIOLENCE
. BUT INSTEAD OF PUTTING PEOPLE
IN PRISON WE'RE SHUTTING PRISONS
DOWN. AND WE'RE JUST TAKING AWAY
A GUN THAT THEY'LL EASILY
REPLACE BECAUSE THEY DON'T BUY
IT. ON THE LEGAL MARKET THEY
BITE IN THE ILLEGAL MARKET. THIS
DOES NOTHING. AND MEMBERS I ASK
THAT YOU PLEASE RECOGNIZE THAT.
AND START MAKING EFFORTS TO DO
SOMETHING. AND THAT'S SOMETHING
. IS ENFORCING THE LAWS THAT WE
HAVE ALREADY. AND I'LL BET YOU.
WILL MAKE A DENT. IN THAT GUN
VIOLENCE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
SENATOR GROW. THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT I RESPECTFULLY RISE IN
OPPOSITION HAS AND SB TWO
COLLEAGUES- THIS IS A BILL WHICH
IS AN ATTEMPT TO RESTRICT THE
RIGHTS OF LAWFUL GUN OWNERS AND-
THOSE THAT ARE CONCEALED
CARRIER- PERMIT. ED CARRIERS.
GUN OWNERS USER CCW PERMITS FOR
PROTECTION AND DEFENSE LAW
ABIDING GUN OWNERS HAVE TO JUMP
THROUGH HOOPS IN NUMEROUS HOOPS
TO GET THE RIGHT TO CARRY A
FIREARM- GUN OWNERS LAW ABIDING
GUN OWNERS DON'T USE THEIR GUNS
TO HARM OTHERS AND- BUT LET'S
TALK ABOUT FOR JUST A SECOND.
WHO DOES. GANG MEMBERS CRIMINALS
CARTELS. THAT OPERATE IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA LAST MONTH
THE SHOOTING BROKE OUT BETWEEN
TWO RIVAL FACTIONS IN YUBA CITY
A GROUP OF TWENTY MEN. WITH
FORTY ONE FIRE ARMS. LET'S TALK
ABOUT THAT PER SECOND TWENTY MEN
WITH FORTY ONE FIREARMS. AND
NONE OF THEM REGISTERED WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE NONE OF
THEM REGISTERED OR BOTHERED TO
FILL OUT THEIR PAPERWORK SO THAT
THEY CAN GET THOSE FIREARMS
REGISTERED LIKE LAW ABIDING GUN
OWNERS DO. NONE OF THE FIREARMS
REGISTERED ALL FORTY ONE WERE
CONFISCATED THERE WAS ANOTHER
INCIDENT JUST RECENTLY IN
WILMINGTON THIS PAST WEEK OR
ELEVEN PEOPLE WERE ARRESTED.
THEY WERE IN POSSESSION OF FIFTY
POUNDS OF METH TWENTY THREE
THOUSAND SENTINEL PEELS AND MORE
THAN FIVE POUNDS OF POWDERED FIT
AND ALL IN TWENTY THREE ILLEGAL
FIREARMS HERE IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. NOT ONE OF THESE
PEOPLE ARE THESE CASES THAT I
JUST MENTIONED R. C. C. W.
CARRIERS- HOLDERS. SOME OF THE
FIREARMS WERE MANUFACTURED
ILLEGALLY IN THESE TO ARREST AND
SOME OF THEM WERE GHOST GUNS
AGAIN. THEY DIDN'T REGISTER WITH
THE DOJ THEY DIDN'T GET
FINGERPRINTED THEY DIDN'T FILL
OUT THE INFORMATION THAT
REQUIRES YOU TO HAVE A FIRE ARM
OR CARRY A CCW THEY DIDN'T GO
THROUGH THE EIGHT HOURS TRAINING
THAT YOU'RE REQUIRED TO HAVE.
THEY DIDN'T GET ON THE
FINGERPRINTS TURNED IN AND THEY
DIDN'T DO A TEN DAY WAITING
PERIOD. THEY STRICTLY JUST OWN
THESE FIRE ARMS AND WE'RE NOT
DOING ANYTHING IN THIS BUILDING
TO GO AFTER THOSE PEOPLE BUT YOU
ARE TAKING THE RIGHTS AWAY FROM
LAW ABIDING CITIZENS TO BE ABLE
TO PROTECT. THEIR HOMES THEIR
FAMILIES AND FRANKLY THOSE
AROUND THEM THAT ARE IN DANGER
FROM PERPETRATORS. LIKE I JUST
MENTIONED. AND YOU KNOW. THE
PRESENTER THE AUTHOR SAID DO YOU
REALLY NEED TO CARRY A FIREARM
TO THE A. Y. SO OR DISNEYLAND
FOR THE BALL GAME. GAME IS GOING
ON IN WASHINGTON DC AND A GOOD
GUY WITH A GUN WASN'T THERE TO
STOP THE BAD GUY. THAT MAGAZINE
THAT INDIVIDUAL HAD IN THAT FIRE
I'M GONNA MOW DOWN MORE. ALL OF
OUR SKEWS ME CONGRESSIONAL
MEMBERS. THEN ACTUALLY WERE
WOUNDED IN THAT SITUATION. THAT
GUY THAT HAD THAT GUN WAS NOT A
LAWFUL CCW CARRIER THAT GUY THAT
HAD THAT FIREARM WAS NOT ABIDING
BY THE LAW IN HIS FIREARMS WERE
NOT REGISTERED LIKE THEY'RE
SUPPOSED TO BE. BUT SOMEBODY WHO
HAD A REGISTERED FIREARM IN
THEIR POSSESSION THEY HAD GONE
THROUGH TRAINING. WAS THE PERSON
WHO STOPPED THAT PERPETRATOR
FROM KILLING SOME OF OUR
CONGRESSIONAL COLLEAGUES.
INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH THE DAILY
BREEZE- ARTICLE THAT COVERED THE
STORY THAT I JUST TALKED ABOUT
NOT THE ONE THAT WE JUST TALKED
ABOUT WITH THE- LEGISLATIVE
MEMBERS OF THE CONGRESSIONAL
MEMBERS BUT THE ONE BEFORE THAT.
A QUOTE FROM THE L. A. P. D.
HARBORS DIVISION POLICE CAPTAIN
NOTES AT THE IMPACT OF GETTING
THESE TYPES OF GUNS THESE GHOST
GUNS THESE ILLEGAL GUNS THE ONES
THAT ARE IN POSSESSION.
ILLEGALLY IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THAT WERE DOING
NOTHING ABOUT THOSE SAID HE SAYS
THE GUIDANCE IN THE IMPACT OF
GETTING THESE GUNS AWAY FROM
CRIMINALS HE SAID EACH ONE OF
THESE GUNS WAS DESIGNATED TO GET
INTO THE HANDS OF A VIOLENT
CRIMINAL AND IT'S NO ACCIDENT.
IN THE LOCAL HAVE HARBOR AREA
THAT THEY'VE SEEN A TWENTY THREE
PERCENT. AND REDUCTION IN
SHOOTINGS BECAUSE THEY'RE GOING
AFTER THESE GUNS IN SPITE OF
WHAT THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IS
DOING. I SUPPORT. FULLY SUPPORT
A CRACKDOWN ON ILLEGAL
MANUFACTURERS OF GUNS. I DON'T
HAVE A PROBLEM WITH CRACKING
DOWN ON ILLEGAL OBTAINED
ILLEGALLY OBTAINED FIREARMS AT
ALL IN ANY WAY SHAPE OR FORM.
BUT I CAN TELL YOU PUTTING A
SIGN UP IN FRONT OF OUR SCHOOLS
IT SAYS IS A GUN FREE ZONE OR
DISNEYLAND IS A GUN FREE ZONE.
THAT IS A PERFECT TIME FOR TAKE
INVITATION FOR PEOPLE TO WALK
INTO ANY ONE OF THOSE FACILITIES
LIKE STARBUCKS OR ANYWHERE ELSE.
THAT ARE INTENT ON COMMITTING
HARM THAT AGAIN ARE NOT
REGISTERING THEIR FARMS WITH THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE. NOT
FILLING OUT THE PAPERWORK NOT
GETTING FINGERPRINTED NOT GOING
TO THE TRAINING CLASSES THAT YOU
HAVE TO RENEW EVERY TWO YEARS AS
WELL. NOT DOING ANY OF THAT
THESE PEOPLE ARE NOT DOING THOSE
THINGS THAT YOU REQUIRE ALL OF
US THAT HAVE C. C. W. CARRIERS.
THEIR CCW CARS THAT WERE
REQUIRED TO DO TO MAKE SURE THAT
WE ARE SAFE. NOT ONLY THAT BUT
THE LIABILITY PIECES OF
LEGISLATION TO GO THROUGH THIS
BUILDING REQUIRE CCW CARRIERS.
TO CARRY UMBRELLA POLICIES LIKE
FIVE MILLION DOLLARS IN
INSURANCE TO MAKE SURE THAT IF
THEY GO TO DEFEND SOMEONE THEIR
LIFE. THEIR FAMILY'S LIFE OR
YOUR LIFE IF YOU WERE IN DANGER
AND SOMEONE WITH THAT. A GUN
STEPS IN TO STOP IT LIKE MANY
PEOPLE THAT YOU READ ABOUT IN
THE NEWSPAPER. OR YOU HEAR ABOUT
ON TV THAT THERE WAS A GUN
SHOOTING IN A MALL. AND SOMEONE
STOPPED AT THAT WAS A LAWFUL GUN
CARRIER. THESE PEOPLE ARE THE
ONES THAT ARE BEING PUT THROUGH
THE WRINGER AND THEIR RIGHTS ARE
BEING- INFILTRATED EVERY SINGLE
DAY. IN THIS BUILDING. AGAIN I
DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH
CRACKING DOWN ON ILLEGAL OBTAIN
GUNS BUT WHEN WE CRACK DOWN ON
LAW ABIDING CITIZENS WHO WANT TO
DEFEND THEMSELVES AND THEIR
FAMILIES THAT'S WHERE YOU HAVE
TO DRAW THE LINE. SB TWO
SIGNIFICANT LIMITS WERE KILLED
CONCEALED CARRIERS. CAN USE
THEIR WEAPONS. AGAIN YOU PUT A
SIGN THAT. SAYS NO WEAPONS
ALLOWED THAT'S AN INVITATION FOR
PERPETRATORS TO COME IN BECAUSE
THERE'S NO. FIREARMS ON THAT
FACILITY. YOU TALK ABOUT. SHE
SCHOOLS DO NOT ALLOW FIREARMS ON
CAMPUS IF WE ARMED OUR TEACHERS
THAT ARE QUALIFIED. TO CARRY A
FIREARM THEN THEY WOULDN'T THROW
THEIR BODIES IN THE MIDDLE OF
THE- ACTIVE SHOOTER. THE BILL
THE TAKE DOWN ELIMINATE THAT
ACTIVE SHOOTER TO PROTECT THE
STUDENTS THAT THEY ARE. TEACHING
EVERY SINGLE DAY. AND I KNOW
THAT'S NOT A POPULAR ARGUMENT
BUT THERE ARE TEACHERS FORMER
UNITED STATES MILITARY VETERANS
FORMER LAW ENFORCEMENT. THAT
WOULD DO THAT GLADLY BECAUSE
WHAT THEY DO EVERY DAY IS A
LOCKED A FIREARM IN THEIR CAR.
BEFORE THEY GO TEACHING THAT
CLASS BECAUSE IT'S REQUIRED BY
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAVE A
LOCKED. FIRE ARE YOU HAVE TO
LOCK UP YOUR FIREMAN A SECURE
DEVICE HE CAN'T TAKE IT ON A
SCHOOL CAMPUS. BUT THE MOMENT A
SCHOOL SHOOTER HAPPENED AN
ACTIVE SHOOTER HAPPEN IF THESE
PEOPLE HAVE THEIR FIREARMS IN
THEIR POSSESSION. THE BILL TO
LIMIT THAT ACTIVE FUTURE AND
PROTECT THE LIVES OF STUDENTS.
BECAUSE THERE ARE BAD PEOPLE OUT
THERE. THAT ARE GOING TO
CONTINUE. TO HAVE GUNS EVEN I
DON'T CARE WHAT LAW YOU PASS YOU
LOOK AT CHICAGO'S LAWS. YOU LOOK
AT DC. THERE'S NO FIREARMS
ALLOWED IN DC AND FIREARMS ARE
STRICTLY REGULATED IN THIS IN
THE CITY OF CHICAGO AND THERE
ARE MORE DEATHS. FROM FIREARMS
IN CHICAGO THAN ANY OTHER SEAT
IN IT ANY OTHER CITY IN THE
NATION. WE KNOW THAT DANGEROUS-
WE KNOW THAT DANGEROUS SOMETIMES
PUBLIC TRANSIT SYSTEMS THAT WE
HAVE. ON FEBRUARY TWENTY THIRD
OF THIS YEAR L. A. METRO CHIEF
SAFETY OFFICER RELEASED A REPORT
ON PUBLIC SAFETY THEY SHOWED IN
TWENTY TWENTY TO THEIR A HUNDRED
SIXTY TWO REPORTS. OF ASSAULTS
AGAINST METRO OPERATORS THAT'S
NEARLY ONE IN EVERY DAY. THERE
WERE ONE THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED
THIRTY FIVE INCIDENTS OF ASSAULT
AND ROBBERY AND TWENTY ONE
DEATHS. THIS IS JUST ON ONE
TRANSIT CITY TRANSIT SYSTEM IN
ONE CITY. UNDER THIS BILL CCW
HOLDERS WOULD NOT HAVE THE RIGHT
TO PROTECT THEMSELVES OR OTHERS
WILL BORROWED IN THIS PUBLIC
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM. FOR MANY
PEOPLE THE REASON AND THEY GET
GIVE TO GIVE A CCW IS TO PROTECT
OURSELVES THEIR FAMILIES AND
THOSE AROUND THEM. AND IT'S
FRANKLY THEIR RIGHTS UNDER THE
CONSTITUTION TO BE ABLE TO CARRY
A FIREARM. AND IF THEY SO CHOOSE
I AGREE WITH PROTECTIONS I AGREE
THAT PEOPLE SHOULD KNOW HOW TO
USE A FIREARM I BELIEVE THAT.
AND I AGREE THAT FIREARMS SHOULD
NOT BE IN THE HANDS OF
PERPETRATORS THAT WOULD BE
WILLING TO KILL ANOTHER HUMAN
BEING. AND FOR A DAY FOR A
HORRIBLE IT JUST BEING HORRIBLE
BUT I'M TELLING YOU THE PEOPLE
THAT ARE MAKING THESE ACTIONS
ARE TAKING THESE ACTIONS ARE NOT
INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE CCW
CARRIERS. WORRY TRYING TO
RESTRICT GUN USE FROM THOSE THAT
CAUSE LESS THAN- 1% OF FIREARM
RELATED HOMICIDES. YOU KNOW I
LOOKED AT THERE'S TWENTY TWO
POINT ONE MILLION CCW CARRIES IN
THE UNITED STATES AMERICAN IF WE
WERE THE PROBLEM YOU KNOW IT.
BUT WE'RE NOT THE PROBLEM. THE
PEOPLE THAT YOU ARE NOT
REGULATING ARE THE PROBLEM IF
YOU DON'T CARE TO EVEN DISCUSS
ARE THE PROBLEM. GO AFTER THE
CRIMINALS GO AFTER THE ONES THAT
HAVE ILLEGAL GUNS. THE ONES THAT
SELL DRUGS THE ONES THAT ARE
RESTED ON A DAILY BASIS ON OUR
STREETS IS GOING TO PACHELBEL
TOMORROW WHO'S THE CHIEF OF.
POLICE AND FRESNO COUNTY LOOK AT
HIS INSTAGRAM AS FACEBOOK PAGE
HERE REST CRIMINALS ALL DAY LONG
EVERY DAY WITH FIRE ARMS ILLEGAL
DRUGS. ILLEGAL POSSESSION OF
FIREARMS FIREARMS ILIR LEGAL IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THERE
ARE PROHIBITED GUN LAST. THERE
IN THIS STATE AND WE ARE NOT
GOING AFTER THOSE PEOPLE. BUT
YOU'RE CONSTANTLY GOING AFTER
THE PEOPLE HAVE EVERY RIGHT TO
PROTECT THEMSELVES AND ARE
FOLLOWING EVERY LETTER OF THE
LAW TO DO SO. RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR NO BETTER. CENTER GONZALEZ.
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS AND I- DON'T OFTEN GET
UP ON THESE- ISSUES OF. GUN
REFORM BUT TODAY I FEEL REALLY
COMPELLED AND I WANT TO THANK.
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM- FROM
PASADENA FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD- IT'S HARD WHEN YOU HAVE
A FAMILY MEMBER THAT'S BEEN
KILLED BY GUN VIOLENCE AS I
HAVE. AND THESE LAWS MATTER TO
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF US AND I
UNDERSTAND WHAT MIGHT MY
COLLEAGUES ARE SAYING ABOUT
PERSONAL RIGHTS BUT- AT SOME
POINT WE HAVE TO START GETTING
UP AND START SAYING THIS IS
ABSOLUTELY WRONG. JUST YESTERDAY
WAS THE FIRST YEAR- THAT WE'VE-
CELEBRATED UNFORTUNATELY IN THIS
WAS IN A DIFFERENT STATE YES BUT
NINETEEN CHILDREN AND TWO
TEACHERS. MOVE ALL DAY. AND WE
CAN'T KEEP HAVING THIS. WE
CANNOT. I OFTEN SAY ON MY
TWITTER WHEN ARE WE GONNA START
THINKING ABOUT OUR AMERICAN
CHILDREN FIRST AND FOREMOST
BEFORE OUR GUNS. AND IT'S
PERSONAL BECAUSE WHEN YOU DO
HAVE SOMEBODY THAT HAS BEEN
MURDERED BY GUN VIOLENCE IT'S
VERY PERSONAL. AND SO I IMPLORE
US TO THINK DIFFERENTLY ABOUT
THIS ISSUE. ESPECIALLY HERE IN
CALIFORNIA. CONCEALED CARRY
WEAPONS HAVE BEEN- WEAPON-
USERS. HAVE BEEN FOLKS THAT HAVE
ACTUALLY ENGAGED IN MASS
SHOOTINGS THAT IS A FACT. AND SO
I THINK ABOUT ALL THE PLACES
THAT WERE PROHIBITING HERE
PUBLIC TRANSIT OF COURSE I DON'T
WANT SOMEBODY CARRYING A WEAPON
AT MY SON'S FLAG FOOTBALL- ALL
OF THESE PLACES THAT I THINK
THAT WE KNOW- AND THINK ABOUT
WHEN YOU'RE JUST GOING AND GOING
ABOUT YOUR DAY YOUR DAILY LIFE
THAT WE THINK ABOUT. COULD
SOMEBODY BE SHOOTING COULD
SOMEBODY JUST. NOT BE IN A GOOD
MENTAL STATE TO BE DOING
SOMETHING THAT COULD HURT US.
JUST THE OTHER DAY I HAD A
FRIEND WHO GOT A FACE TIME- FROM
ONE OF HIS DAUGHTERS. AND THE
FIRST THING HE THOUGHT ABOUT
BECAUSE DURING SCHOOL HOURS WAS
A MASS SHOOTING. AND THIS IS IN
OUR STATE THIS WASN'T YOU KNOW
IT SHE WAS JUST SHARING THAT. HE
DID SOME GREAT ART PROJECT BUT
WHY IS THAT THE FIRST THING THAT
PARENTS HAVE TO THINK ABOUT. THE
FIRST DAY WHETHER CALIFORNIA OR
TEXAS OR WHOEVER AND WE HAVE
GREAT GUN LAWS HERE BUT WHY IS
THAT THE FIRST THING. SO I AM
FORCED TO THINK DIFFERENTLY AND
I LOOK FORWARD TO MORE
DISCUSSIONS BUT I THINK THE GOOD
SENATOR FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD AND I WILL. PERSONALLY
CO AUTHOR EVERY SINGLE GUN
REFORM BILL THAT COMES THROUGH.
MY OFFICE AND THROUGH THIS
LEGISLATURE SO THANK YOU.
SENATOR HOWEVER OUT OF GO.
MORNING TODAY I RISE IN
OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL. THIS
BILL. MAKES IT A CRIME TO BRING
A FIREARM WHETHER LOADED OR
UNLOADED. UPON THE GROUNDS. OR
WITHIN THE RESIDENTS. OF ANY
MEMBER OF THE STATE LEGISLATURE
. CALIFORNIA ALREADY HAS THE
MOST RESTRICTIVE RESTRICTIVE GUN
LAWS IN THE COUNTRY. AND NOW.
THIS BILL AIMS TO RESTRICT MY
OWN RIGHTS UNDER THE SECOND
AMENDMENT. SOLELY BECAUSE I AM
AN ELECTED PUBLIC SERVICE.
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. IS SUPPORT
FOR THE GOVERNMENT TO COME INTO
YOUR HOME. INTO MY HOME. AND
BRIG THE HEAVY FIST OF THE LAW.
TO STOP YOU FROM EXERCISING YOUR
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS TO PROTECT
YOUR HOME. YOUR PROPERTY YOUR
FAMILY. YOUR LIFE. FURTHERMORE
THIS BILL CRIMINALIZES ANYONE
THAT COMES INTO YOUR PRIVATE
RESIDENCE CARRYING A LAWFUL.
FIREARM SO I ASK YOU WHAT IS
NEXT. THIS IS A COUNTRY OF
FREEDOM. THIS IS A COUNTRY OF
OPPORTUNITY. THIS IS A COUNTRY
WHERE DEMOCRACY REIGNS AND YET.
THIS BILL REEKS OF BAD POLICY.
THIS BILL WREAKS A DICTATORSHIP
. I ASK FOR YOUR OPPOSITION ON
THIS. SINNER BLOOD SUGAR. THANK
YOU SO I RISE TODAY TO SPEAK ON
THIS ISSUE BECAUSE I THINK THAT
IT IS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT
ISSUES WE'RE DEALING WITH ACROSS
THE COUNTRY AND THAT'S GUN
VIOLENCE AND IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
WE LEVEL SAT AROUND SOME OF THE
STATISTICS RELATED TO GUN
VIOLENCE SO WE ARE THE ONLY
COUNTRY THAT SUFFERS WITH THE
DEATHS AND INJURIES FROM GUN
VIOLENCE. BECAUSE OF OUR GUN
LAWS. GUNS HAVE SURPASSED CARS
AS THE NUMBER ONE KILLER OF
YOUTH IN THIS COUNTRY GUNS HAVE
SURPASSED CARS AS ANOTHER ONE
NUMBER ONE KILLER OF YOUTH I
WANT TO EMPHASIZE HOW IMPORTANT
THAT IS AND WE THINK ABOUT THE
RISKS. EVERY DAY WE HAVE MORE
THAN THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTEEN
PEOPLE WHO WERE SHOT IN THE
UNITED STATES WE ALREADY HAVE
THIS YEAR THIRTEEN THOUSAND NINE
HUNDRED PEOPLE HAVE BEEN KILLED
IN GUN VIOLENCE WE DON'T ALLOW
GUNS IN PLANES FOR GOOD REASON
AND WE SHOULD NOT ALLOW THEM IN
SCHOOLS AND HOSPITALS AND COURT
ROOMS ON THE FLOOR HERE. OTHER
PLACES THAT ARE SENSITIVE WE
NEED WE REALLY NEED TO BE VERY
CONSCIOUS ABOUT OUR DECISION
MAKING AROUND WHERE PEOPLE HAVE
GUNS. YESTERDAY MY NINTH GRADER
IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL WAS UNDER HER
DESK TALKING TO HER TEACHER
DURING A- UNCLEAR WHAT THE
INCIDENT WAS- EVENT THAT
EVERYBODY WAS. ON THE PHONE WITH
THEIR PARENTS THEY WERE SAYING
PARENTS DON'T COME TO THE
SCHOOL. THE KIDS WHEN THAT THIS
WHOLE THING WAS RESOLVED
YESTERDAY MORE THAN HALF THE
SCHOOL WENT HOME BECAUSE OF THE
TRAUMA THEY SENT OUT ALERTS
SAYING IF ANYBODY NEEDS TO BE
DEALING WITH THIS WITH THE
COUNSELOR THEY CAN COME IN. NO
THIS IS THE SOCIETY THAT WE ARE
CREATING BECAUSE OF OUR GUN
LAWS. SO THIS IS A VERY
REASONABLE SB TWO IS A VERY
REASONABLE FROM SENATOR
PORTANTINO IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE
PASS IT. I URGE ALL OF MY
COLLEAGUES TO SUPPORT IT AND
THAT WE ARE MORE FORWARD
THINKING THAT WE ARE MORE
AGGRESSIVE IN WHAT WE DO TO
REDUCE THE HARM TO THE PSYCHE TO
THE PHYSICAL. REALITIES THE
SAFETY OF ALL OF THE PEOPLE IN
THE STATE AND ALSO IN THIS
COUNTRY. THANK YOU. CENTERMAN I
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT I RISE AS
A PROUD CO AUTHOR OF THIS BILL-
WITH RESPECT TO MY COLLEAGUES WE
HAVE A GUN ADDICTION IN THIS
COUNTRY. THERE ARE FOUR HUNDRED
MILLION GUNS UNITED STATES. HAS
MORE GUNS THAN PEOPLE AND THE
RESEARCH IS ABSOLUTELY CLEAR
THAT MORE GUNS LEAD TO MORE GUN
VIOLENCE. NOW I KNOW THERE'S A
LOT OF STATISTICS THAT THE NRA
THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
ASSOCIATION AND THEIR ALLIES
LIKE TO SPOUT. ABOUT HOW SOME OF
SUCH AND SUCH PERCENTAGE OF GUNS
USED IN CRIMES. ARE ILLEGALLY
PROCURED YOU KNOW BASICALLY A
100% OF THOSE GUNS WERE
ORIGINALLY PURCHASED THROUGH A
LEGAL- SELLER OF SOME KIND WE
MAKE IT TOO EASY IN THIS COUNTRY
TO SELL GUNS. THERE'S NO.
QUESTION AS TO WHAT DRIVES GUN
VIOLENCE IS THE FACT THAT IT IS
SO EASY TO HAVE GUNS IN THIS
COUNTRY. AND WE ADD GUNS ANY MIX
WE SEE MORE GUN VIOLENCE. WHEN
YOU HAVE GUNS AT FOOTBALL GAMES
WHEN YOU HAVE GUNS IN BARS WHEN
YOU HAVE GUNS- IN CHURCHES
YOU'RE GOING TO SEE MORE GUN
VIOLENCE THAT'S JUST A ONE TO
ONE FACT A ONE TO ONE
CORRELATION. IT IS RIDICULOUS
RIGHT NOW WE'RE FACING IN THIS
COUNTRY IT'S RIDICULOUS THAT WE
HAVE TO PUT FORWARD THIS BILL
BUT WE HAVE A JUDICIARY THAT IS
OUT OF CONTROL. THEY'VE TAKEN
EXTREMIST VIEW OF THE SECOND
AMENDMENT. HI AND WE HAVE TO IN
THE STATE START RESPONDING WE
CANNOT SIT ON OUR HANDS WHEN WE
SEE GUN VIOLENCE MASSACRE. AFTER
GUN VIOLENCE MASSACRE AFTER GUN
VIOLENCE MASSACRE I'M NOT IS DAM
ENOUGH WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING
WE HAVE THE POWER TO DO
SOMETHING. I WOULD URGE YOU TO
VOTE YES ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU
CENTER WINNER. I THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT I RISE IN STRONG
SUPPORT VESTBY TO AND I WANT TO
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR HIS.
PERSISTENCE AND LEADERSHIP ON
THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE- WHICH HAS
ABOUT SOME VERY BASIC. THAT WE
WANT FEWER PEOPLE TO DIE.
BECAUSE THEIR SHOT. BECAUSE ONE
FEWER CHILDREN TO DIE. BECAUSE
THEIR SHOT. THAT WE DON'T WANT
OUR CHILDREN TO BE SCARED TO GO
TO SCHOOL. THAT'S WHAT THIS IS
ABOUT. THERE'S A LOT OF RHETORIC
ABOUT THIS. IDEOLOGY THAT WE
NEED MORE AND MORE GUNS. AND
WILL SOMEHOW BE SAFER IF WE TOOK
HAVE AN ENDLESS TIDAL WAVE OF
GUNS. BUT WE KNOW FROM THE
ACTUAL FACTS OF THE OPPOSITE IS
TRUE CALIFORNIA HAS A LOW RATE
OF GUN VIOLENCE. PRECISELY
BECAUSE OF OUR GUN SAFETY LAWS.
WE KNOW THAT IN STATES THAT HAVE
EASIER ACCESS TO GUNS. THERE ARE
MORE SHOOTINGS AND MORE PEOPLE
DIED. WE KNOW THAT OTHER
COUNTRIES THAT HAVE FEWER GUNS
HAVE FAR LOWER RATES OF GUN
VIOLENCE. IN THE UNITED STATES.
WE NEED TO BE VERY CLEAR. THAT
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THIS COUNTRY
WITH GUNS AND WITH GUN VIOLENCE
IS NOT NORMAL. THIS IS NOT
NORMAL THIS IS HAPPENING BECAUSE
WE HAVE MADE A POLICY CHOICE. IN
THIS COUNTRY AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL AND IN SO MANY STATES. NOT
TO HAVE STRONG GUN SAFETY
PROTECTION THAT WAS A POLICY
CHOICE AND CHILDREN ARE DYING AS
A RESULT. I WANTED TO THIS KIND
OF BILL MAKES ME PROUD TO BE A
CALIFORNIA. BECAUSE AS IN
CERTAIN OTHER STATES ARE
LITERALLY DEFINING DRAG QUEENS
TO BE A GREATER THREAT TO
CHILDREN AND GUNS ARE. THINK
ABOUT HOW BIZARRE THAT IS. WE'RE
ACTUALLY A KNOWLEDGE IN THE FACT
THAT IT IS GUNS THAT ARE HARMING
AND KILLING OUR CHILDREN I
RESPECT FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK
YOU CENTER JONES. THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT THERE'S SOME PECULIAR-
TOPICS RAISED THIS THIS MORNING.
AND I'LL YOU KNOW THERE'S BEEN A
LOT OF TALK ABOUT GUNS DOING
THIS IN GUNS DURING THAT AND
GUNS CAUSING THIS. WE FORGET
THAT THERE'S SOMEBODY HOLDING
THAT GUN. THE GUN BY ITSELF DOES
NOT CAUSE A CRIME OR AN INJURY
IT'S THE PERSON HOLDING THE GUN
THE CAUSES THAT CRIME OR INJURY
. SO LET'S KEEP THAT IN MIND AS
WE'RE DEBATING ON WHAT TO DO
ABOUT GUNS ALSO WANT TO- I
APPRECIATE AND APPLAUD ALL OF
THE ARGUMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN
RAISED. THIS MORNING ON GUN
CONTROL IN FAVOR OF S. B. TWO. I
WISH WE WERE DEBATING A BILL
THAT THAT THOSE ARGUMENTS
ACTUALLY APPLIED TO. BECAUSE WE
WERE DEBATING A BILL ABOUT THE
ARMED PROHIBITED PERSONS LIST
ALL OF THOSE ARGUMENTS APPLY. IF
WE WERE TALKING ABOUT GETTING
MORE ILLEGAL GUNS OFF THE
STREETS. ALL OF THOSE ARGUMENTS
APPLY. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT CCW
HOLDERS. PERMIT HOLDERS MEANING
THEY HAVE GOTTEN PERMISSION FROM
THE GOVERNMENT. TO CARRY THAT
FIREARM. THOSE DOCTORS VISIBLE
SOME SPECIFIC POINTS THAT WERE
RAISED THIS MORNING YOU'VE ALL
THE HORRIBLE SHOOTING IN TEXAS.
THE DID CLAIM. MANY INNOCENT
LIVES. THAT SCHOOL WAS A GUN
FREE ZONE. ADVERTISED ON THE
FRONT GATES. THERE ARE
LEGITIMATE STATISTICS IN AMERICA
THAT MASS SHOOTERS. ONLY GO. TWO
GUN FREE ZONES BECAUSE GUESS
WHAT. THE MASS SHOOTER DOESN'T
WANT TO BE SHOT BACK AT. BUT I
WILL ASSURE YOU AND STAND BY IT
TODAY THAT IF THERE HAD BEEN A
CCW HOLDER ON THAT CAMPUS ON
THAT DAY. LIVES WOULD HAVE BEEN
SAVED. LIVES WOULD HAVE BEEN
SAVED. THERE'S A GUN ADDICTION
IN A CALIFORNIA AND AMERICA
REALLY A GUN ADDICTION. LET'S
TALK ABOUT THE FINALE DICTION IN
CALIFORNIA. LET'S TALK ABOUT
POLICY AS ONE OF OUR- COLLEAGUES
SAID THAT WE'VE MADE A
DELIBERATE POLICY OF GOING AFTER
GUNS WE MADE A DELIBERATE POLICY
IN THIS PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
IN THIS SENATE AND IN THE
ASSEMBLY COULD NOT DO ANYTHING
ABOUT FIT IN ALL. THERE'S A
HUNDRED CALIFORNIANS DYING A
MONTH OR A WEEK. BECAUSE OF
FENTON ALL. AND YOU STAND ON
THIS FLOOR GET ALL SELF
RIGHTEOUS ABOUT GUN CONTROL BUT
WON'T DO A THING ABOUT FEDERAL
CONTROL ARE YOU KIDDING ME RIGHT
NOW. LET'S GET SERIOUS AND TELL
POLICY DEBATE ON THESE THINGS
THIS IS NOT A SERIOUS DEBATE
THIS MORNING ON S. B. TWO AND C.
C. W.'S BUT THE ARGUMENTS THAT
HAVE BEEN RAISED. I'M REALLY
KIND OF TICKED OFF ABOUT IT
ACTUALLY AND LET'S TALK ABOUT
ONE LAST THING CHURCHES IT WAS
BROUGHT UP NOT TO HAVE GUNS IN
CHURCHES ARE YOU KIDDING ME. IF
YOU'RE A MASS SHOOTER ONE OF THE
FIRST PLACES YOU'RE GONNA TARGET
IS A CHURCH. IT'S HAPPENED IN MY
DISTRICT. AT A SYNAGOGUE. I'M
NOT SHOOTING WAS STOPPED BY
SOMEBODY WITH A FIREARM THEY
DON'T IT LEGALLY. THERE'S BEEN
SHOOTINGS OTHER CHURCHES AND
OTHER CONGREGATIONS AROUND THE
COUNTRY THAT THOSE MASS
SHOOTINGS HAVE BEEN STOPPED BY
SOMEBODY THAT OWNED A CCW AND
TOOK THE TRAINING ON HOW TO USE
IT AND FIRED BACK PROPERLY. AND
STOP THE SHOOTING. AND SAVED
LIVES. SO I AGREE WE NEED TO
HAVE A SERIOUS POLICY DEBATE ON
THIS FLOOR. WE HAVE A SERIOUS
POLICY DEBATE ABOUT GETTING GUNS
AWAY FROM PEOPLE WHO SHOULDN'T
HAVE THEM. AND WE HAVE A SERIOUS
POLICY DEBATE ABOUT GETTING FIT
OFF OUR STREETS SO OUR TEENAGERS
STOP DYING PROMOTE OVERDOSE OF.
ILLICIT DRUGS THAT WE'VE ALLOWED
INTO OUR COUNTRY. AND WE COULD
STOP I ASK FOR NO VOTE. SKINNER
RUBIO. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN OF THE
SENATE I. I KNOW THIS IS A
REALLY HEAVY TOPIC AND I YOU
KNOW FOR THE FIRST HAVE MEANT
THAT IT'S REALLY PASSIONATE IN
BOTH SIDES OF THE ISLAND NIGHT
COULD UNDERSTAND THAT- BUT I
WANNA SPEAK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT
MY PERSONAL VIEW- I KNOW THAT
I'VE BEEN VERY OUT OF IT I MEAN
ADAMANT ABOUT YOU KNOW JUST
BEING A TEACHER AND EXPERIENCING
WHAT WERE SEEN ACROSS OUR NATION
IN TERMS OF. OUR CHILDREN HAVING
TO EXPERIENCE SUCH DEVASTATION I
THINK IT WAS SAID ABOUT YOU
BALDY AND I THINK OF. YOU KNOW
THE LITTLE GIRL FOURTH FOURTH
FOURTH GRADER I BELIEVE SHE'S
NINE YEARS OLD WHO AFTER THE
SHOT OF HER CLASSROOM SHE HAD TO
GO BACK. TAKE BLOOD AWAY FROM
HER LITTLE FRIEND WHO WAS
ALREADY DECEASED TO PUT ALL OVER
HER BODY IN HER FACE. TO PLAY
DEAD ON THE FLOOR OF THAT
CLASSROOM AND I THINK OF THE
CIRCUMSTANCES AND IT'S REALLY
DIFFICULT NOT TO SEE THAT OUR
CHILDREN ARE THE MOST IMPACTED
SOMETIMES AND THEY DON'T HAVE
ANYONE TAKING CARE OF THEM. PER
SE I KNOW THAT EVERY TIME
THERE'S A SHOOTING IN THE
CLASSROOM I GET A BUNCH OF CALLS
FROM FRIENDS AND SAYING YOU KNOW
WE SHOULD GIVE TEACHERS. GUNS SO
THEY CAN DEFEND THEMSELVES. BUT
I CAN TELL YOU AS A TEACHER IN
THE CLASSROOM I DON'T THINK I
COULD TOUCH A GUN IN THE
CLASSROOM I DON'T WANT ANY GUNS
IN ANY CLASSROOM THAT I'M IN.
AND I KNOW MY COLLEAGUES WOULD
STRUGGLE WITH THAT BECAUSE THAT
COMES WITH OTHER RISKS. WE HAD A
LITTLE BOY WHO RECENTLY WHO SIX
YEARS OLD WHO SHOT HIS TEACHER.
IN A SCHOOL SETTING. ME HAVING A
GUN TO DEFEND MYSELF WOULD NOT
HAVE STOPPED A LITTLE BOY FROM
BRINGING A GUN TO SCHOOL AND
SHOOTING HIS TEACHER CELL. I
KNOW THAT IT'S A VERY PASSIONATE
TOPIC ON BOTH WAYS BUT I WANNA
REALLY JUST CONSIDER THE IMPACT
FOR CHILDREN. WHAT THEY'RE
HAVING TO LIVE IN AND I DO KNOW
HOW WE SEE SOME STUDENTS HERE
AND IN THE GALLERY AND- AND I
HAVE TO THINK OF ALL THE LITTLE
FACES THAT WOULD HAVE TO FACE
SOMETHING LIKE THIS SOME DAY AND
I. AND I DON'T WANT TO I THINK
IT'S TIME THAT WE RECOGNIZE IT'S
A CRISIS I THINK THAT WE
RECOGNIZE THAT OUR KIDS. ARE
GROWING UP. EVERY DAY TRYING TO
FIGURE OUT AND HOW THEY'RE GONNA
STAY. IT'S AS- HOW. TEACHERS
HAVING. STRETCH HOW. DO THEY RUN
OUT OF THE CLASSROOM IT'S A
CONSTANT BATTLE. WE USED TO HAVE
EARTHQUAKE DRILLS I WAS THE
COMMON NORM. NOW WE'RE HAVING.
LOCKDOWN DRILLS ALL THE TIME
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT HOW DO WE
STAY SAFE IN THE CLASSROOM AND I
THINK. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH AND I
THINK THAT. YOU KNOW I
UNDERSTAND THE ARGUMENT ON BOTH
SIDES BUT- AT THE END OF THE DAY
WE HAVE TO STAND ON THE SIDE OF
OUR CHILDREN. ARGUES OUR KIDS
BEEN SAVE IN OUR SOCIETY. AND
GROWING UP IN A WORLD WHERE THEY
COULD GO TO SCHOOL AND NOT HAVE
TO WORRY. WHAT THEY'RE GONNA DO
AN AXE. ARE THEY INTERESTING
PART OF SO I HAD DISCUSSIONS
WITH PARENTS WOULD TELL ME THAT
THE LAST THING THEY TELL THEIR
KIDS NOT SO MUCH. I LOVE YOU BUT
IT'S MORE. ABOUT REMEMBER WHAT
WE SAID RIGHT IF THERE'S A
SHOOTER WHAT HE GONNA DO. THAT'S
THE LAST WORD STAY HERE BECAUSE
THEY WANT THEIR KIDS TO
REMEMBER. WHAT TO DO WHEN
THERE'S- SOMEONE IN THEIR
CLASSROOMS SHOOTING SO. WE HAVE
TO THINK OF OUR KIDS OUR
CHILDREN AND I ALSO- AND
STRONGLY SUPPORT THE CELTIC YEAH
. THANK YOU SENATOR SKINNER.
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS
WE FELT VERY PASSIONATE
DISCUSSION OBVIOUSLY ON THIS
BILL I RISE IN SUPPORT. AND IT
IS CLEAR FROM THE COMMENTS OF
MOST OF MY COLLEAGUES. THAT ALL
OF US ARE COMMITTED WE WANT.
LESS GUN. DEATHS AND- I RISE TO
SPEAK TO. THE COMMENTS BY OUR
COLLEAGUE FROM SANTEE. AND YES
HE MADE THE POINT. THAT IT IS
NOT. THE GUN. THAT KILLS THE
PERSON PER SE THE SHOOTER. THERE
HAS TO BE A SHOOTER. HOWEVER
THIS IS A CIRCULAR ARGUMENT THAT
HAPPENS AGAIN AND AGAIN ON OUR
FLOOR. THE DATA SHOWS AND THE
DATA THAT IS IRREFUTABLE. THAT
YOU ARE TO SHOOTER. UNLESS YOU
HAVE A GUN. AT THE VERY PRESENCE
OF A GUN. ON THE PERSON. IN THE
HOME. ON THE FACILITY. LEADS TO.
THE GUN DEATHS IT INCREASES IT.
PROPORTIONATELY
DISPROPORTIONATELY. AND THUS. WE
HAVE TO LIMIT. THE PRESENCE OF
GUNS IF WE HAVE ANY HOPE OF
REDUCING GUN VIOLENCE AND WITH
THAT I ASK THE ARRIVAL. SKINNER
TROUBLE. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
. WOW PRETTY ROBUST DEBATE THIS
MORNING AND LET ME JUST BEGIN BY
STATING THAT I COMMEND THE- THE
SENATOR FROM BURBANK AND WORKING
TO MAKE SURE THAT OUR
COMMUNITIES ARE SAFE. AND THEN
THERE IS NO QUESTION. THAT GUN
VIOLENCE IS AN ISSUE IN THE U.
S. ABSOLUTELY NO QUESTION. THERE
IS BEEN VALID POINTS AND
CONCERNS ON BOTH SIDES- HOWEVER
I WANT TO GO BACK TO THE MERITS
OF THE BILL. WHICH IS TARGETED
AT THE GOOD ACTORS IN OUR
SOCIETY WHO ARE WILLING AND
WANTING TO TAKE- AN OPPORTUNITY
TO EDUCATE THEMSELVES. AND GO
THROUGH THE PERMITTING PROCESS
THAT IS THE SCOPE OF THIS BILL.
IT'S TARGETING THE PEOPLE WHO
ARE WILLING LEE. WANTING TO GO
THROUGH THE LEGAL PROCESS. ABOUT
OF TRAINING. AN ACQUIRING THAT
PARTICULAR BILL. IT'S NOT
ADDRESSING THE NEFARIOUS ACTORS
THAT DO NOT FOLLOW. D. ONE
THOUSAND AND FIFTY PIECES OF
LAW. THAT RELATED TO GUNS IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. LET ME
REPEAT THAT. IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE ONE THOUSAND
AND FIFTY PIECES OF LAWS THAT. I
HAVE TO DO WITH FIREARMS. AND
ACCORDING TO THE VIOLENCE POLICY
CENTER THIS IS A QUESTION THAT I
ASKED MY COLLEAGUE IN COMMITTEE
WITH REGARDS TO THE C. C. W.'S
THAT HE WAS TRYING TO ADDRESS
WHERE HOW MANY OF THEM WERE
RESPONSIBLE FOR VIOLENCE IN THE
IN THE I'M- IN OUR STATE IN THE
US WELL THIS IS WHAT WE FOUND
OUT. SO WE HAVE ABOUT WAS
IMPORTED TWENTY ONE MILLION C.
C. W. CARRIERS IN THE NATION.
BETWEEN TWO THOUSAND AND SEVEN
AND TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY.
THERE WERE. ONE THOUSAND ONE
HUNDRED AND THIRTY FOUR NON SELF
DEFENSE INCIDENTS. AMONG THEM.
THAT'S POINT. 00006% OF ALL C.
C. W.'S PERMIT HOLDERS THAT WERE
RESPONSIBLE FOR GUN RELATED
DEATHS OVER THE THIRTEEN PERIOD.
AB YEAR PERIOD IT NATIONWIDE
NATIONWIDE. FOR COMPARISON.
CALIFORNIA ALONE AVERAGED OVER
THREE THOUSAND FIREARM DEATHS
PER YEAR OVER THAT PARTICULAR
SPAN. THREE THOUSAND. ONCE AGAIN
. I WANT TO GO BACK AND
REITERATE THAT THIS HOUSE TO DO
. THE BILL THE MERITS OF THE
BILL HAS TO DO WITH OUR CCW
HOLDERS NOT THE NEFARIOUS ACTORS
BUT THE ONES WHO WILLFULLY. TAKE
THE INITIATIVE TO GO AND EDUCATE
THEMSELVES TREATING THEMSELVES.
TO BE ABLE TO LEGALLY OWN A GUN
. AND AS A PARENT OF A CHILD
WHO'S STILL IN SCHOOL TWO GIRLS
ARE IN HIGH THAT ARE IN COLLEGE
ONE THAT STILL AND THERE'S
SOMEONE WHO M. KNOWS MANY FAMILY
MEMBERS AND FRIENDS WHO OWN GUNS
I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
AIMING. THE ANGER AND THE
FRUSTRATION IN OUR BEER. TOWARDS
THE RIGHT INDIVIDUALS THAT NEED
TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE. BECAUSE
THERE'S ABSOLUTELY NO QUESTION
BUT GUN VIOLENCE. IT IS AN ISSUE
OF SEVERE CONSEQUENCE IN OUR
COUNTRY I WITHIN OUR COMMUNITIES
NO QUESTION. BUT LET'S MAKE SURE
THAT WE AIM OF THAT CONCERN. TO
THE TARGET AUDIENCE BUT NEED TO
BE ADDRESSED AND NOT TO THE LAW
ABIDING. INDIVIDUALS IN OUR
COMMUNITIES. AND WITH THAT. I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE.
SKINNER WENT. THANK YOU MR
HOUGHTON MISTER PRESIDENT- I. I
FASHION NEVER SHARE THIS STORY.
WHEN I WAS IN MIDDLE SCHOOL. OUR
FAMILY WAS OUR PARENTS WERE
HEADING TO ORANGE COUNTY TO. AND
I WAS LEFT HOME. AND A COUSIN OR
FRIEND CAME BY. AND THE DOOR
KNOCKED ON OUR HOUSE. AND I RAN
OUT AND I GO OH MY GOSH ALARMS
ON. AND SO I REACH TO THE ALARM
TO TURN OFF THE ALARM. RIGHT
WHEN I DID THAT THE DOOR WAS
THROWN AND KICKED. AND THESE
INDIVIDUAL MEN CAME IN. I HAD A
GUN TO MY HEAD. LILY A GUN TO MY
HEAD. WHEN I WAS IN MIDDLE
SCHOOL. THE YOU CAN'T TELL ME
THAT I EIGHT OR SOMEHOW WE
SUPPORT. GUNS SOMEHOW WE SUPPORT
INDIVIDUALS LIKE THAT WILL COME
INTO OUR FAMILY. AND I WOULD
HAVE NOT BEEN HERE. TODAY NO ONE
WAS HOME BESIDES THE TWO OF US
THE FAMILY BEHIND US THEY WENT
TO THE HOSPITAL TO INDIVIDUAL.
THEY RANSACK OR TIRE HOUSE AND
AT THE TIME BACK IN THE EIGHTIES
. IN THE EARLY NINETIES LATE
EIGHTIES EARLY NINETIES WHERE WE
LIVE. AND SAMBAR DINO BECAUSE WE
WERE COMMUNITIES VERY SMALL
REFUGEES. GAINES WERE COMING
INTO OUR NEIGHBORHOODS. AND
KNOWING THAT WE WERE THE MOST
VULNERABLE COMMUNITY COULD SPEAK
ENGLISH WELL. I'VE NEVER
FORGOTTEN THAT EXPERIENCE I'VE
NEVER TALKED ABOUT IT PUBLICLY
ACTUALLY MY STAFF MOST OF THEM
NEVER HEARD OF IT THERE PUT
THEIR HEARING IT RIGHT NOW. WHY
ARE WE ADDRESSING. WE MOVING GOT
ILLEGAL GUNS FROM GANG MEMBERS
FROM THOSE WHO SHOULDN'T HAVE
THEM. THE POLICY COMING FROM
THIS BUILDING TO ALLOW EARLY
RELEASE. AS RANSACKING MY ENTIRE
DISTRICT IT DOESN'T MATTER IF
YOU LIVE IN THE- WEALTHY
NEIGHBORHOOD GATED COMMUNITY OR
NOT. THE COMING IN WITH GUNS
HOLMBERG RISING PEOPLE. WHY ARE
WE TALKING ABOUT THIS AND WHY
ARE WE ADDRESSING THAT. THE
COMMENTS I HEAR IS AS IT'S OUT
OF CONTROL WE'RE SITTING ON OUR
HANDS. CHILDREN ARE WE ARE WE
ARE LETTING CHILDREN DIE WE'RE
LETTING PEOPLE DIE. POLICY
CHOICES HERE. THE POLICY CHOICES
YOU HAVE HERE. IS KILLING A
HUNDRED FOURTEEN CALIFORNIANS
PER WEEK SIX THOUSAND
CALIFORNIANS WILL DIE AT THE END
OF THIS YEAR. I TALKED TO MY
CHILDREN YOU'VE HEARD MY
COMMENTS ABOUT FAT NO. THE
POLICY YOU'RE PUTTING IN PLACE
TODAY. STANDING ON THE SIDELINE
AGAINST THAT NO. AS ALLOW
CALIFORNIANS TO DIE. EVERY WEEK
. EVERY YEAR. AND YOU ALSO NOT
DRESSING PEOPLE WHO ARE LEGALLY
CARRYING GUNS THAT'S PUT A GUN
TO MY HEAD. I WAS ONLY IN MIDDLE
SCHOOL. HOW DARE YOU STAND HERE
AND SAY THAT YOU'RE FOR THE
CHILDREN FOR THE PEOPLE. THERE'S
CHILDREN DYING EVERY DAY ON THAT
NOTE. AND WE'RE SAYING IT'S OK
BECAUSE WE DON'T WANT TO PUNISH
DRUG DEALERS. NOT ONCE HAVE WE
TALKED ABOUT. ADDRESSING THAT
ISSUE. WHEN HAVE WE DONE IT. I'M
CLEAN TO YOU I'M BEGGING YOU
I'LL GO ON MY KNEES OF I HAVE TO
. ADDRESS THE FEDERAL ISSUE
ADDRESSED THE ISSUE OF GETTING
GUNS ILLEGAL GUNS AWAY FROM GANG
MEMBERS THOSE WHO SHOULD NOT
HAVE THEM ASK. THE AG'S OFFICE
TO REMOVE THOSE PEOPLE OFF THE
LIST WE'VE BEEN HAVING THIS
DISCUSSION. THREE GENERATIONS
NOT THREE AGEE'S THEY'LL- SO I'M
ASKING YOU LET'S HAVE A ROBUST
DISCUSSION. KEEP THOSE GUNS AWAY
FROM THOSE INDIVIDUALS DON'T
HAVE THEM. BURKE ALLIES.
FAMILIES BUSINESSES. AS WELL.
LET'S LOOK AT THOSE FAMILIES.
AND LET'S LOOK AT US DEALING
WITH FEDERAL IN THE CRISIS
THAT'S HAPPENING ACROSS THE
STATE AND ACROSS THIS NATION.
YOU HAD A BIPARTISAN BILL. TWO
THIRDS OF THE STATE LET'S SAY
BODIES HAVE SIGNED ON TO IT HE
COULD EVEN GET OUT COMMITTEE. MY
BILL. WOULD HAVE SAVED. MY BILL
TWO KILO GRAM. OF FAT NO. A ONE
KILOGRAM OF FENNEL WOULD HAVE
KILLED TEN THOUSAND PEOPLE OF A
THIRD- FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
PEOPLE IN THAT ROOM WHEN ON THE
MERITS OF THE BILL. AGAIN LET'S
GET TO POLICY THAT TAKES.
ILLEGAL GUNS. AWAY FROM THOSE
WHO ARE TRYING TO HARM EVERYBODY
. SKINNER CORTESE. THANK YOU
THIS PRESIDENT I RISE IN SUPPORT
OF SB TWO BUT I HAVE A LITTLE
BIT OF A DIFFERENT TAKE ON IT
AND I IT. IT DOES CONCERN ME
THAT THE- THE DEBATE THE
DELIBERATION IS TAKEN SOME OF
THE TURN THAT IT HAS. THE BILL
IN MY MIND IS DOING SOMETHING
THAT'S LONG OVERDUE WHICH IS TO
GET A UNIFORM SET OF POLICIES
AROUND CONCEALED KERRY IN ALL
FIFTY EIGHT STATES IN
CALIFORNIA- BY VIRTUE. OF STATE
LEGISLATION- THAT'S NOT BEEN
DONE SUCCESSFULLY IT'S BEEN A
PROBLEM WE HAVE SOME COUNTIES-
LIKE MY OWN WHICH HAVE HAD VERY
PUBLIC- AND- VERY PROBLEMATIC-
IS SHE ISSUANCE. OF CONCEALED
CARRY PERMITS- BASED ON A
DOCUMENTED IN IN COURT DECIDED
POLITICAL FAVORITISM AND OTHER
ISSUES THAT REALLY SHOULDN'T
ENTER IN TO THIS KIND OF A
STATUTORY SCHEME- SO I WANT TO
COMMEND THE AUTHOR FOR. COMING
TO US WITH THE SCHEME THAT'S
UNIFORM ON AND I THINK THAT'S
WHERE THE DEBATE SHOULD BE-
WHETHER OR NOT THIS SCHEME WORKS
IN IN COUNTIES- WHERE CONCEALED
CARRIES WOULD BE ISSUED- I
LOOKED AT THE BILL VERY CLOSELY-
THERE ARE SOME PROVISIONS IN THE
BILL THAT I WOULD ASK THE AUTHOR
TO KEEP LOOKING NOW TO KEEP
WORKING ON ESPECIALLY WITH
REGARD TO TRANSPORT. BECAUSE
WALL THERE'S CROSS REFERENCES IN
THERE THAT SEEM TO PROTECT.
PEOPLE WORSE- TARGET SHOOTERS
AND HUNTERS AND FOLKS WHO
CARRYING LONG GUNS AS SUPPORT AS
OPPOSED TO HAND GUNS THOSE ARE
ALL VERY VERY IMPORTANT. NOT
ONLY SO THAT THE LEGISLATION IS
UP HELD ALTERNATELY ON THE
JUDICIAL SIDE- BUT I THINK FOR
OWN CREDIBILITY AND I JUST WANT
TO ACKNOWLEDGE- I THINK A LOT OF
THE ANGST FROM THIS DEBATE. UP
FRANKLY COMES FROM A LITTLE BIT
OF A DISCONNECT IN A LACK OF
NEXUS BETWEEN- SOME OF OUR
ARGUMENTS IN WHAT'S ACTUALLY ON
THE TABLE TODAY. I DON'T BELIEVE
IN MY OWN COUNTY I CAN'T SPEAK
FOR THE ENTIRE. CITY CALIFORNIA
THAT- THE TWO THREE. OF OUR GUN
. FATALITIES VIRTUALLY EVERY
MONTH ACCORDING TO OUR CORNER
WHICH ARE SELF INFLICTION. WHICH
COME FROM FIRE ARMS BUT ARE SELF
INFLICTED HAVE ANYTHING TO DO
WITH CONCEAL CARRY- I DON'T
THINK THE BTA MASS SHOOTING IN
MY- DISTRICT. HAD ANYTHING TO DO
WITH CONCEALED CARRY PERMITS ONE
WAY OR THE OTHER IN FACT I KNOW
THAT AND I THINK. OF ALL THE
INVESTIGATIONS HAVE SHOWN THAT
MISSILE OFTEN THE CASE THIS
ISSUE AS IMPORTANT AS IT IS FOR
A LOT OF REASONS SOME OF WHICH
HEY. I STATED- IN CAUSE ME TO
VOTE FOR THE BILL- ARE ARE
DIFFERENT REASONS AND DIFFERENT
ISSUES. THAN SOME OF THE OTHER
ISSUES THAT ARE TROUBLING US
RIGHT NOW LIKE MASS SHOOTINGS OR
LIKE THE HIGH RATE OF SUICIDE
SELF INFLICTION WE NEED TO DEAL
WITH THOSE ISSUES SEPARATELY- I
THINK- APPROPRIATELY. I'M
HEARING ACROSS THE AISLE PEOPLE
SAYING THAT LIKE TO DEAL WITH
THOSE ISSUES AS WELL- BUT I
THINK WE CONFLATE- CAUSE AND
EFFECT. ON A BILL LIKE THIS
WHICH IS REALLY JUST TRYING TO
BRING FORWARD- A NEW AND CLEAN
STATUTORY SCHEME WE'RE NOT DOING
OURSELVES ANY FAVORS. I THINK WE
LOSE CREDIBILITY FRANKLY WITH
FOLKS. WHO ARE OUT THERE IN THE
REAL WORLD- WHO ARE HEADING OUT
TO SHOOT CLAY TARGETS OR
SOMETHING LIKE THAT. IN THE
HERE. OF THE KIND OF DEBATE THAT
WE'RE HAVING IN WONDER WHY
THERE'S A LACK OF NEXUS IN THEIR
OWN LIVES IN THEIR OWN LIVES WHY
DOESN'T MAKE SENSE FOR THEM.
WHEN THEY HEAR THE DEBATE THAT
WERE HAVE BEEN HAVING A ROUGH
ABOUT CONCEALED CARRY- IN. YOU
KNOW I JUST WANT TO GET THAT ON
THE FLOOR AGAIN I'LL BE
SUPPORTING THE BILL. A. PART OF
THE AUTHOR FOR. YOU KNOW
TENACITY OCCURS FORWARD WITH AN
INCH TO. AGAIN CREATE SCHEME
THAT UNIFORM SCHEME THAT I'M
GOING TO BE SUPPORTING TODAY.
THANK YOU. FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ON THE SIDE ON. IN CHINO
MIKE'S I ALLOW SENATOR
PORTANTINO TO CLOSE. THANK YOU
MR PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS AND I
WANT TO COMPLIMENT MY COLLEAGUE.
FROM SAN JOSE FOR READING THE
BILL. AND COMMENTING ON THE BILL
ITSELF AND WHAT THE BILL DOES
AND DOESN'T DO- I WANT TO
COMPLIMENT MY COLLEAGUE FROM
LONG BEACH. WHO SHARED HER
FAMILY'S STORY. ABOUT HAVING
SOMEBODY WHO WAS A VICTIM OF GUN
VIOLENCE. AND. THAT'S WHY WE'RE
DOING THIS BILL- MY COLLEAGUE
FROM LONG BEACH BROUGHT UP.
YOU'VE ALL THE AND IF YOU
REMEMBER. LAST YEAR WHEN I
PRESENTED THIS BILL IT WAS.
LITERALLY FIFTEEN MINUTES AFTER
THAT TRAGEDY WAS THE SAME DAY.
AND SO. I ALSO WANT TO. COMMENT
. WHAT PEOPLE DON'T WANT TO
SUPPORT SOMETHING. THEY SAY WELL
IT'S NOT DOOR NUMBER ONE THAT'S
DOOR NUMBER TWO. WE HAVE CAR
ACCIDENTS IN CALIFORNIA THAT
CLAIM PEOPLE'S LIVES. THIS BILL
IS NOT ABOUT CAR ACCIDENTS.
SADLY WE HAVE DRUG OVERDOSES
THAT CLAIM FAR TOO MANY
CHILDREN'S LIVES. THIS BILL IS
NOT ABOUT DRUG OVERDOSES. AS MY
COLLEAGUE FROM SAN JOSE POINTED
OUT THIS BILL IS ABOUT CREATING
A UNIFORM POLICY. OF WHO SHOULD
AND SHOULDN'T BE. GRANTED THE
PRIVILEGE OF CARRYING A WEAPON.
THIS BILL IS NOT AS BEEN SAID
MANY MANY MANY TIMES BY
COLLEAGUES WHO DON'T WANT TO
VOTE FOR IT. THIS BILL DOES NOT
. TARGET LAW ABIDING CITIZENS
THAT. CAN HAVE A CONCEALED CARRY
THIS BILL TARGETS FOLKS WHO FOR
A SET OF CONCRETE RULES. SHOULD
NOT BE GRANTED THAT PRIVILEGE IF
YOU'RE A DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
ABUSER YOU SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED
A CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT. IF
YOU'RE ON SOCIAL MEDIA MAKING
SERIOUS VIOLENT THREATS AGAINST
A NEIGHBOR. YOU SHOULD NOT BE
GIVEN A GUN SO YOU CAN FOLLOW
THROUGH ON THOSE THREATS. IF YOU
CAN'T HAVE THREE PEOPLE VOUCH
FOR YOU AND SAY YOU ARE A LAW
ABIDING CITIZEN AND A PERSON OF
UP STANDING CHARACTER IN A
RESPONSIBLE GUN OWNER. YOU
SHOULD NOT BE GRANTED THAT
PRIVILEGE. THE ARGUMENT THAT
WE'RE TARGETING THE LAW ABIDING
CITIZEN IS THE EXACT OPPOSITE OF
WHAT THIS SEEKS TO DO. THIS
SEEKS TO COME UP WITH CONCRETE
CRITERIA. TO ASSESS. THAT
INDIVIDUALS. WHERE WITH ALL TO
BE EQUAL THAT RESPONSIBILITY.
THAT MAKES SENSE FRANKLY THAT
SHOULD BE BIPARTISAN. WE SHOULD
AGREED THAT THERE ARE CERTAIN
CALIFORNIANS. THAT ARE NOT EQUAL
TO THAT RESPONSIBILITY. AND WE
SHOULD WORK COLLABORATIVELY TO
COME UP WITH THAT CRITERIA
SHOULD BE IN A UNIFORM BASIS
THAT APPLIES TO EVERY. COUNTY
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. THAT'S A VIABLE
IMPORTANT CONVERSATION TO HAVE.
BUT INSTEAD WE GET. YOU'RE
TARGETING LAW ABIDING PEOPLE.
ALL IN ISN'T IT TERRIBLE THAT
SOMEBODY DIED FOR SOME OTHER
REASON. AND BECAUSE YOU WANT TO
DRESS THAT OTHER REASON I'M
GOING TO USE THAT AS A REASON
NOT TO VOTE FOR SB TWO. THAT'S
NOT A GOOD. HEALTHY USE OF OUR
FLOOR TIME. THIS BILL DOES NOT
INFRINGE UPON AN INDIVIDUAL'S
RIGHT. A CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICER
OR LEGISLATOR TO HAVE A
CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT. OR HAVE
SOMEBODY A FAMILY MEMBER WITH
THIS BILL SAYS IS A PERSON
WITHOUT YOUR PERMISSION IF
YOU'RE HAVING YOUR- SON OR
DAUGHTER'S BIRTHDAY PARTY
SOMEONE CAN'T SHOW UP AT THAT
BIRTHDAY PARTY WITHOUT YOUR
PERMISSION WITH A CONCEALED
CARRY PERMIT. THAT'S WHAT THIS
BILL SAYS. THAT'S IMPORTANT.
BECAUSE WE DON'T WANT. THAT
INFORMATION TO BE. MISCONSTRUED
READ THE BILL IT'S THEIR. ON A
PERSONAL NOTE I KNOW WHAT IT'S
LIKE TO HAVE MY DAUGHTER AT THE
MALL AND GET NEW NOTICE THAT
THERE WAS AN ACTIVE SHOOTER. AT
THAT MALL. I KNOW WHAT IT'S LIKE
TO HAVE HER FRIENDS FAMILIES
CALL ME AND SAY WHAT'S GOING ON
. I JUST HEARD ON THE NEWS.
THERE'S A REAL CALL SAID MANY OF
US HAVE HAD TO DEAL WITH. SOME
OF THEM HAVE ENDED IN. TRAGEDY
WE SHOULD NOT BE SENDING OUR
KIDS TO SCHOOL AND WONDERING IF
THEY'RE GOING TO COME HOME SAFE
. WE SHOULD NOT BE GOING TO THE
CONCERT AND WONDERING IF WE'RE
GOING TO GET SHOCKED. AND AS MY
COLLEAGUE. FROM BERKELEY SAID WE
KNOW STATISTICALLY THAT MORE
GUNS MEAN MORE DEATH. WE KNOW
STATISTICALLY THAT CALIFORNIA IS
SAFER BECAUSE OF OUR GUN CONTROL
LAWS. AND WE KNOW STATE CITIES
AND COUNTIES AND STATES THAT
HAVE A LAX GUN CONTROL LAWS HAVE
MORE SHOOTING DEATHS PER CAPITA
THAN THOSE THAT HAVE ROBUST
LAWS. WE KNOW THIS WORKS. AND WE
KNOW WHAT THE ARGUMENTS ARE. BUT
THEY'RE NOT. BECAUSE SOMEONE
ELSE DIED OF SOME OTHER REASON
WE SHOULDN'T VOTE FOR THIS WHAT
BECAUSE WE DIDN'T ADDRESS
SOMEBODY'S PET PEEVE WE
SHOULDN'T VOTE FOR THIS. THOSE
ARE FALSE. SIDESTEPPING
ARGUMENTS AND MAYBE. IT'S
POLLYANNA OF ME BUT MAYBE IF
THERE IS A REAL DESIRE TO HAVE A
CONVERSATION ABOUT WHO SHOULD OR
SHOULDN'T HAVE A GUN. WE HAVE
THAT CONVERSATION. BUT YOU KNOW
WHAT YESTERDAY WE HAD A BILL
THAT SAID IF YOU'RE ALREADY ON
THE PROHIBITED LIST. WE'RE GOING
TO EVALUATE WHETHER YOU COME
OFF. AND YOU DON'T WANT THE SAME
PEOPLE WHO SAID LET'S LOOK AT
WHO SHOULD OR SHOULDN'T HAVE A
GUN VOTED AGAINST THAT BILL TO.
AND WHEN WE HAVE BILLS THAT SAY
SAFELY LOCK UP YOUR GUNS. THE
SAME PEOPLE WHO ARE OPPOSING
THIS. VOTE TO LOCK UP A GUN WHY
SHOULD THAT BE PARTISAN LOCK UP
YOUR GUN. SHOULDN'T BE A
PARTISAN ISSUE. YOU GOT TO BE
TWENTY FIVE TO RENT A CAR.
SHOULD YOU HAVE TO BE TWENTY ONE
TO OWN A GUN. WHY IS THAT A
PARTISAN ISSUE. WHEN WE SAY AT
THREE TWENTY FIVE DURING A CAR
THAT'S BIPARTISAN. SO LET'S CUT
. TO THE CHASE AND GO BACK TO
WHAT THIS BILL DOES AND DOESN'T
DO. IT SAYS LET'S COME UP WITH A
ROBUST CONCRETE CRITERIA OF WHO
SHOULD BE TRUSTED. WITH THE
ABILITY TO KILL THEIR NEIGHBOR.
OR WHO SHOULDN'T BE TRUSTED.
THAT'S WHAT THIS BILL DOES. AND
SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE ON S. B. TWO. THANK YOU ALL
THE BEST SEIZE. DR PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL AND PAULINE IN TWENTY
NINE ALLEN. EL DORADO GIL. NO
ARCHULETA. HI ASHLEY BY ATKINS
AYE BECKER. AYE BLAKE'S BEER. I
BRADFORD BY COMING OUT OF. HIGH
CORTESE AYE DALY NO DODD. HI THE
RAZA. HI EGGMAN I GLAZER. HI
GONZALEZ HI GROVE NO- TADO.
JONES NO LAYERED. I LIVE ALONE.
HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA ARE AYE
MEN. HI NEWMAN. AYE NGUYEN. NO
NERO. NO OF CHAU BUG NO IDEA I
PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH. RUBIO BYE
SEYARTO NO SKINNER. A SMALL
CUEVAS. MADE STERN. HI I'M BURKE
I LOVE. I WIENER AYE WILK NO.
THE CARD PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN. I TADO ROTH.
MARCH TWENTY NINE KNOWS NINE THE
MEASURE PASSES NOW MEMBERS RUTH
RETURNING BACK TO PRIVILEGES OF
THE FLOOR ON BEHALF OF SENATOR
DODD WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME
STUDENTS FROM NORTH. DAVIS
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL WHO ARE
JOINING US TODAY IN THE GALLERY
PLEASE GIVE THEM A WARM CENTER
WELCOME.
NO MEMBERS WERE RETURNING BACK
TO SENATE THIRD READING. NEXT UP
IS FILE ITEM THIRTY NINE. VICE
SENATOR LAW HE'S PREPARED
SECRETARY ME RATE SENATE BILL
THREE NINETY NINE PER CENT OR
ONE OF THE NEXT RELATING TO
EMPLOYMENT. ZERO OFF. THANK YOU
SB THREE NINE NINE CLARIFIES
THAT WORKERS HAVE THE FREEDOM TO
DECLINE MANDATORY MEETINGS OR
COMMUNICATIONS WHERE THEIR
EMPLOYER EXPRESSES PERSONAL
VIEWS ON RELIGIOUS OR POLITICAL
MATTERS INCLUDING POLITICAL
PARTY OR UNION SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION. THESE MEETINGS ARE
OFTEN REFERRED TO AS CAPTIVE
AUDIENCE MEETINGS BECAUSE
ALTHOUGH NOT JOB RELATED WORKERS
ARE NOT PERMITTED TO LEAVE OR
ATTEND OR NOT ATTEND WITHOUT
FACING DISCIPLINE OR ADVERSE
ACTION IN MANY WORKPLACES
EMPLOYEES ARE AT WILL AND CAN BE
FIRED AT ANY TIME FOR ALMOST ANY
REASON IT GIVES EMPLOYERS
TREMENDOUS POWER TO PRESSURE
WORKERS TO DO AS THEY SAY. SO
LET'S IMAGINE THAT YOU ARE AT
WORK IN YOUR BOSS CALLS YOU INTO
A MANDATORY ALL STAFF MEETING AT
THE MEETING THE BOSS ASK YOU TO
VOTE FOR A CANDIDATE OR
PROPOSITION THAT YOU OPPOSE
PERSONALLY YOU TRY TO LEAVE BUT
ARE TOLD YOU WILL BE WRITTEN UP
AND POSSIBLY FIRED IF YOU LEAVE.
THIS IS WHAT WORKERS ARE FACING
TODAY. CALIFORNIA HAS LONG
PRIDED ITSELF ON A SANCTUARY FOR
WORKERS REGARDLESS OF RACE
GENDER SEXUAL ORIENTATION
RELIGION OR POLITICAL LEANING.
IT IS IMPORTANT THAT WORKERS ARE
FREE TO GO TO WORK WITHOUT
FEELING COERCED INTO LISTENING
TO THE POLITICAL OR RELIGIOUS
VIEWS OF THEIR EMPLOYERS AGAINST
THEIR WILL. I ALSO WANT TO
HIGHLIGHT WHEN THERE'S AN
IMBALANCE OF POWER THERE'S MORE
PRESSURE. THIS BILL PROVIDES
EXEMPTION SO EMPLOYERS CAN
COMMUNICATE LEGALLY REQUIRED
INFORMATION ESSENTIAL FOR
WORKERS TO FILL THEIR JOB DUTIES
LIKEWISE NOTHING IN SB THREE
NINE NINE PREVENTS EMPLOYERS
FROM COMMUNICATING THEIR
PERSONAL POLITICAL OR RELIGIOUS
BELIEFS TO THEIR WORKERS IT
SIMPLY CLARIFIES THE CANNOT
REQUIRE WORKERS TO ATTEND.
MEETINGS TO DISCUSS RELIGIOUS OR
POLITICAL MATTERS THAT ARE NOT
GERMANE TO THE WORK THAT THEY DO
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE. BEGINNING FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
ITEM. HEARING TÍNH ON SIR PLEASE
THE ROLL ON FILE ITEM THIRTY
NINE. ALLEN OVER OUT OF GUILT.
ARCHULETA ASHBY. ATKINS I BAKER
. AYE BLINKS BEER. I HI COMING
OUT OF. CORTEZ I DALY. NO DONE.
THE RAZA. HI EGGMAN. AYE GLAZER
. GONZALEZ HI GROVE- TADO. HI
JONES. NO LAYERED. I LOVE MY OWN
. HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA ARE. I
MEAN. HI NEWMAN. HI WHEN. HELLO
NO- CHAU ABOVE. NO IDEA. HI
PORTANTINO. HI ROTH. RUBIO.
SEYARTO NO SKINNER. HI SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS HI STERN- A NUMBER. HI
BOB HI WIENER HI WILK NO THE
CARD PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ELLEN HI NUMBER OUT OF
GUILT ARCHULETA HI ASHLEY.
CABALLERO DODD. GLAZER GROVE.
WHEN NO ROTH. RUBIO RUBIO I.
PRICE TWENTY SIX NOTES SEVEN THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE
GONNA BE MOVING AROUND ON FILE
RIGHT NOW SO NEXT UP IS FILE
ITEM FORTY SIX. BY SENATOR ACHEN
SHE'S PREPARED SECRETARY MARIE
SENATE BILL FIVE NINETEEN BY
SENATOR ATKINS AN ACT RELATING
TO CORRECTIONS INTERACTIVES.
MISTER PRESIDENT THANK YOU SO
MUCH SB FIVE ONE NINE WILL BRING
ADDITIONAL TRANSPARENCY AND
ACCOUNTABILITY TO OUR COUNTY
JAILS SPECIFICALLY AROUND IN
CUSTODY DEATHS IN. TWENTY
TWENTY. CURRENTLY THERE ARE AT
LEAST TEN COUNTY JAILS UNDER
FEDERAL COURT CONSENT DECREE
REGARDING THE TREATMENT AND CARE
OF PEOPLE IN CUSTODY SB FIVE ONE
NINE IS INTENDED TO PROVIDE
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND THE PUBLIC
IMPORTANT INFORMATION IN ORDER
TO HELP ADDRESS THESE ISSUES AT
THE LOCAL LEVEL. TO THAT END SB
FIVE FIVE ONE NINE WOULD ENSURE
THAT FOR REPORTS OF
INVESTIGATIONS RELATING TO IN
CUSTODY DEATHS ARE PUBLICLY
ACCESSIBLE. CONSISTENT WITH A
STATE AUDITOR RECOMMENDATION SB
FIVE ONE NINE ALSO RESTORES
LOCAL CONTROL BY RE AUTHORIZING
A COUNTY A COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS DISCRETION TO
ESTABLISH A LOCAL DEPARTMENT OF
CORRECTIONS HEADED BY AN
EXECUTIVE OFFICER. IF THE
SHERIFF IS UNRESPONSIVE IN
ADDRESSING THE PROBLEMS WITH ITS
COUNTY DETENTION FACILITIES. I
CONTINUE TO AND WILL CONTINUE TO
ENGAGE WITH ALL THE STAKEHOLDERS
ON ON THE ISSUE INCLUDING-
JUSTICE ADVOCATE AND OF COURSE
LAW ENFORCEMENT. TO HELP RESTORE
PUBLIC TRUST AND WITH THE HOPE
OF PREVENTING FUTURE DEATHS. I
WOULD- I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR EYES A- ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
ITEM. INCHING ON SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON FILE
ITEM FORTY SIX ALLEN. HI OVER
OUT OF JAIL. HI ARCHULETA. HI SB
. HI ATKINS. HI BAKER. HI BLIX
BEAR FIVE BRADFORD. HI COMING
OUT OF. A COURTESY HI DALY. DODD
I DURAZO. HI EGGMAN. I GLAZER.
AYE GONZALEZ HI GROVE. OUR TITLE
. HI JONES. LAYERED I LOVE MY
OWN. HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA AYE
MIN. BYE NEWMAN. HI WHEN. NAY
LOW. A JOB OF PUTTING A- I
PORTANTINO. HI RALPH I RUBIO.
RUBIO AYE SEYARTO. SKINNER HI
SMALLER CUEVAS. A STERN. HI
NUMBER. I WANT HOME. I WIENER.
HI WILK. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. DALY GROVE. JONES WHEN
NAY LOW A CHAU ABOVE. SEYARTO
WILK. HIGHS THIRTY TWO KNOWS
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES NOW
MEMBERS WERE MOVING ON THE FILE
ITEM NINETY FOUR SOONER SKINNER
HE'S PREPARED SECRETARY MAY READ
SENATE BILL FIFTY FOUR BY
SENATOR SKINNER AN ACTOR LEADING
TO PROFESSIONS AND VOCATIONS
SOONER SKINNER THANKS SO MUCH
MISTER PRESIDENT MEMBERS
CALIFORNIA'S WE KNOW IT'S THE
STATE THAT IS FAMED FOR
INNOVATION AND MUCH OF THAT
INNOVATION COMES FROM THE RESULT
OF BOLD ENTREPRENEURS. AND WHEN
THOSE ARE INNOVATIVE
ENTREPRENEURS WANT TO BRING
THEIR CONCEPT TO MARKET. START A
NEW ENTERPRISE START A NEW
BUSINESS. IT IS CAPITAL
INVESTMENT PARTICULARLY VENTURE
CAPITAL INVESTMENT THAT IS THEIR
LIFELINE IF YOU ARE A WOMAN OR
BLACK LED STARTUP SUCH
INVESTMENTS JUST DON'T COME YOUR
WAY. REGARDLESS OF YOUR
EXPERTISE YOUR TRACK RECORD OR
THE VIABILITY OF YOUR BUSINESS
PLAN AND DESPITE THE FACT THAT
50% OF ALL NEW COMPANIES ARE.
FORMED BY WOMEN. THE NATION WIDE
LESS THAN 3% OF VENTURE CAPITAL
IS INVESTED IN WOMEN OR BLACK
LED START UPS. WHAT SB FIFTY
FOUR DOES IS SIMPLY ASK OUR
VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTORS IN
CALIFORNIA TO REPORT ON THE
DIVERSITY OF THEIR INVESTMENTS
AND THEY WOULD GIVE THAT
INFORMATION TO OUR STATE CIVIL
RIGHTS DEPARTMENT. THE SAME IN
THE SAME DEPARTMENT THAT POSTS
OUR GENDER PAY THE SALARY PAY
EQUITY INFORMATION SO IT'S
PURELY A TRANSPARENCY MEASURE
THAT'S ALL THAT IT REQUIRES THAT
WE HOPE THAT BY DOING SO. THAT
WE WILL GET IN IMPROVEMENTS IN
THE DIVERSITY OF INVESTMENTS
FROM OUR VENTURE CAPITAL
INVESTORS IN WITHOUT I ASK THE
ARRIVAL. THANK YOU ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION ON THE SCIENCE CENTER
MEANT. I THINK MR PRESIDENT I
RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL AS
VICE CHAIR OF THE API CAUCUS I
JUST WANT TO EMPHASIZE THE
IMPORTANCE OF DIVERSITY AT ALL
LEVELS- WE KNOW IT'S ASSOCIATED
WITH GREATER ECONOMIC RETURNS-
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
IDOL. THANK YOU ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION ON THIS ITEM HERE AND
SEEN ON- SKINNER WHICH OUGHT TO
CLOSE. THANK YOU AYE ASTOR AYE
VOTE SECTOR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ON FILE ITEM NINETY FOUR ALLEN.
HI OVERRUN A GO. ARCHULETA S. B.
HI ATKINS. HI BAKER. LAKE
SUPERIOR. NINE BRADFORD. HI
COMING OUT OF. HIGH CORTESE. BY
TELLING. DODD THE RAZA. I EGGMAN
. GLAZER I GONZALEZ HI GROWS- NO
OUR TITLE. I JONES NO LAYERED.
NINE ONE MON. HI MCGUIRE. HI
MENJIVAR. LINEMEN HI NEWMAN. AYE
NGUYEN. NIELLO NO A CHAU BUG. BY
THE- HI PORTANTINO. HI ROTH. HI
RUBIO. THEY SAY ARE TOO. NO
SKINNER. HI SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. HI
STERN. HI NUMBER. HI BOB. HI
WIENER. I WILL. NO DR PLEASE
CALL ABSENT MEMBERS. EL DORADO
GIL. I ARCHULETA NINE BECKER ON
A DAILY NO DONE I. WHEN. A CHAU
ABOVE. I STARTED TO KNOW SIX THE
MEASURE PASSES NOW MEMBERS
REMOVING THE FILE ITEM ONE
EIGHTEEN. CENTER BACKER ARE YOU
PREPARED. YES SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL THREE OH EIGHT
BY SENATOR BAKER AN ACT RELATING
TO GREENHOUSE GASES CENTER
BECKER. THANK YOU FRIENDS THAT
RIGHTS PRESENT SB THREE AWAIT
LAST YEAR YOU RECALL WE PASSED A
STARK BILL TO SET A GOAL OF
GETTING TO NET ZERO BY TWENTY
FORTY FIVE THIS BILL SB THREE
AWAIT WILL HELP MAKE SURE WE
ACTUALLY GET THERE. LAST YEAR'S
BILL SET A TARGET OF REDUCING
EMISSIONS BY 85% BY TWENTY FORTY
FIVE. BUT THEN WE SIMPLY DO
SOMETHING WITH THE REMAINING 15%
BOB ESTIMATES THAT WILL NEED
ABOUT SEVENTY FIVE MILLION TONS
A YEAR OF CARBON REMOVAL TO
COVER THAT REMAINING 15% I
PERSONALLY TODAY THE STATE HAS
NO PLAN FOR HOW WE'RE GOING TO
DEVELOP THAT MUCH CARBON REMOVAL
CAPACITY IN TIME. THIS BILL
CREATES A PLAN THERE ARE THREE
PARTS FIRST ADDRESS CARP TO
BREAK THE RULES WORKING COUNT AS
NET IN NET ZERO. THIS BILL
INCLUDES IN COURT IMPORTANT
PRINCIPLES SUCH AS REQUIRING
THAT THE CARBON MOVIL IS LONG
LASTING. THAT IS ADDITIONAL TO
WHAT WOULD HAPPEN ANYWAY AT ONLY
THE NET AMOUNT OF CARBON THAT
HAS BEEN REMOVED IS COUNTED
AFTER TAKING ACCOUNT ANY
MISSIONS THAT WERE CAUSED BY THE
CARBON REMOVAL PROCESS ITSELF.
HAVING CLEAR RULES IS IMPORTANT
SO WE GET SCIENTIFICALLY VALID
CARBON REMOVAL AND NOT JUST
PRETEND TO GET TO KNOW ZERO WITH
THE KIND OF QUESTIONABLE CARBON
OFFSETS THAT ARE FREQUENTLY USED
FOR GREENWASHING TODAY. SECOND
THE BILL INCLUDES SAFEGUARDS TO
MAKE SURE ALL THIS CARBON
REMOVAL HAS CO BENEFITS FOR
NEIGHBORING COMMUNITIES AND OUR
WORKFORCE. AND IT DOESN'T RESULT
IN BAD SIDE EFFECTS LIKE AIR
POLLUTION. IT ALSO INCLUDES A
PROVISION THAT PROHIBITS USING
THE REMOVE CARBON DIOXIDE. FROM
SUN. AT JUST LIKE IN LAST YEAR'S
BILL THIRD WE NEED A CLEAR PLAN
FOR HOW TO PAY FOR ALL THIS
CARBON REMOVAL. THIS BILL TAKES
A POLLUTER PAYS APPROACH. WHICH
WHICH LEADS TO SOME OF THE
OPPOSITION IT JUST MAKES SENSE
THAT THOSE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE
POLLUTION SHOULD PAY TO CLEAN IT
UP CORRECT. WOULD WE EXPECT THAT
BURDEN TO PHONE TAXPAYERS
INSTEAD. THIS DOESN'T HAVE TO BE
EXPENSIVE THE BILL FACES THE
OBLIGATIONS FERMENTERS TO
PURCHASE CARBON REMOVAL. START
WITH VERY SMALL AMOUNTS AT
FIRST. ONLY OFF 31% OF EMISSIONS
IN TWENTY THIRTY. AND INCREASING
GRADUALLY UNTIL WE GET TO NET
ZERO TWENTY FORTY FIVE. SO THIS
IS THE APPROACH THAT WE TOOK
VERY SIMILAR INCREDIBLE
PORTFOLIO STANDARD. REQUIRED
UTILITIES START BUYING SMALL
AMOUNTS OF RENEWABLE ENERGY WITH
SOLAR WIND WERE IMMATURE
INEXPENSIVE. AND THEN SCALED UP
THAT AMOUNT WE PURCHASED OVER
TIME. THAT APPROACH LED TO A 90%
DROP IN THE COST OF SOLAR OVER
DECADES. ENTER NORMA'S INCREASES
OR GENERATION NOT JUST HERE IN
CALIFORNIA BUT AROUND THE WORLD.
THIS BILL JUST DOING THE SAME
THING SLOWLY SCALE UP BRING DOWN
THE COST OF CARBON REMOVAL LET
THE ENTREPRENEURS WORK. THAT
COULD BE COST EFFECTIVE PART OF
OUR CLIMATE PLAN THE LAST THING
IT'S IMPORTANT SOME PEOPLE
SUGGESTED THIS IS REGINA WITH
CAP AND TRADE. IT WOULD BE VERY
CLEAR IT IS NOT. CAP AND TRADE
LIMITS THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF
EMISSIONS ACROSS THE STATE.
USING THE MARKET. TO ALLOCATE A
LIMITED NUMBER OF RIGHTS TO
POLLUTE. THIS BILL WITHIN ALSO
REQUIRED THAT THOSE POLLUTERS TO
CLEAN UP A PORTION OF THEIR
POLLUTION. THOSE ARE SEPARATE
AND COMPLEMENTARY IDEAS NOT
REDUNDANT ONCE. SO I KNOW THIS
IS A RELATIVELY NEW TOPIC FOR
ALL OF US AND LEGISLATURE BUT
IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT ONE WE
NEED TO CONTINUE TO PRIORITIZE
EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS. BUT THAT
WON'T BE ENOUGH WE ALSO NEED
COVER MOVIL. AND WE KANTELE
GETTING STARTED BECAUSE IT'S
GONNA TAKE US A LONG TIME TO
SCALE UP AND REDUCE COSTS. JUST
LIKE WE SEE WITH MOBILE ENERGY.
THIS BILL WILL PUT THAT PLAN IN
PLACE AT THE GETS A STARTED
RESPECTFULLY ASK HER AYE VOTE.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
ON THIS ITEM SENATOR DOLLAR.
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS
I. SAW THIS BILL IN COMMITTEE
AND- BUSY I JUST WANT TO MAKE A
COUPLE OF REAL QUICK COMMENTS-
THIS BILL IS. ALLOWING POWER TO.
THE AGENCIES DID TO. BASICALLY
REGULATE. NUMBER ONE NUMBER TWO
WE HAVE A LOT OF OPPOSITION FOR
PEOPLE WHO ALREADY. THE QUESTION
CARBON. AND I THINK THAT THE
REAL OVERARCHING ISSUE ON THIS
BILL IS THAT. WE HAVEN'T REALLY
TAKEN A GOOD LOOK AT THE THINGS
THAT WE HAVE ALREADY. ALLOCATED
AS FAR AS THE GREENHOUSE GAS
REDUCTION FUNDS ARE BEING SPENT.
WE TALKED A LITTLE BIT ABOUT
THIS YESTERDAY. WHEN IT COMES
TO. OFFSHORE WIND BUT THINGS
LIKE. THE BULLET TRAIN. WHERE WE
CONTINUE TO DUMP. LITERALLY
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS A YEAR INTO.
AND WE KNOW FOR A FACT. THAT THE
REDUCTION IN CARBON IS NOT GOING
TO COME FROM. THE ESTIMATES THAT
WERE ORIGINALLY. A SET FORTH.
AND THE COST IS GOING TO BE.
FROM THE TWENTY TWENTY. SPRITES
THAT WAS THAT WAS TWENTY BILLION
AND WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A
HUNDRED THREE BILLION DOLLARS.
SO THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION
DOES IT EXACTLY THE SAME THING
AS THE OTHERS HAVE DONE WE
REALLY NEED TO. ANALYZE THE
CARBON REDUCTIONS- THAT WE KNOW
WE KNOW THAT AS YOU ALL KNOW WE
DON'T COUNT FORCED BUYERS. WHO
ARE MEETING LIKE CRAZY WHEN WE
KNOW WE CAN REDUCE FAR. CARBON
FROM FOREST FIRES BY REDUCING
ACTUALLY A RESIDUE IN THE FOR SO
FOR THOSE REASONS I CAN'T
SUPPORT THIS PIECE OF
LEGISLATION AND I URGE A NO
VOTE. Q. I ABOUT THE COST OF
ENERGY THANK YOU SENATOR GROW.
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT I WASN'T
PREPARED TO SPEAK ON THIS BUT- I
RISE IN OPPOSITION. I RISE IN
OPPOSITION BECAUSE THIS SEVERELY
UNTRUE AND CONTRADICTORY
REMARKS- PRESENTED BY THE AUTHOR
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT. THE AUTHOR
SAYS THAT THIS IS SIMILAR TO THE
SOLAR PROGRAM WHERE WE SKILLED
AT- SLOWLY SO THAT THE MARKET
AND TECHNOLOGY COULD CATCH UP
WITH ITSELF AND NO TAXPAYER
DOLLARS WOULD BE USED. OR
LIMITED TAXPAYER DOLLARS WOULD
BE USED TO FUND THE DIFFERENCE
IN WHAT THEY CONSIDER CLEAN
ENERGY AND THE SOLAR PROGRAMS OR
THE OR THE- WINDMILL PROGRAMS.
AT THE WOULD BE EQUAL AND TELL
TECHNOLOGY CAUGHT UP AND CREATED
A FAIR PRICE. WELL WHEN THIS
STARTED BACK IN TWO THOUSAND AND
TEN WHEN I GOT HERE WITH THE
SOLAR THING THE LEGISLATURE
CREATED THIS THING CALLED ABOVE
MARKET FUNDS. AND SO IF A SOLAR
PROJECT WAS PRICED AT HERE AND
NATURAL GAS AND OIL WAS PRICE
DOWN HERE TAXPAYER DOLLARS WERE
COLLECTED AT THE AT THE RATE
PAYERS EXPENSE ON THEIR ENERGY
BILLS. TO DEPOSIT THOSE
RESOURCES INTO THE ABOVE MARKET
FUNDS ACCOUNT CONTROLLED BY AN
AGENCY AND IN THOSE FUNDS WOULD
BE DISTRIBUTED TO OFFSET THE
COST OF SOLAR AND WIND WHICH
WOULD BRING THE SOLAR AND WIND
COSTS DOWN. SO TAXPAYERS DIDN'T
PAY FOR IT TAXPAYERS ARE STILL
PAYING FOR IT BECAUSE JUST LAST
YEAR THIS BODY AFTER PROMISE
NEVER TO DO IT AGAIN PASSED THE
SOLAR TAX EXCLUSION BILL. WHICH
DOESN'T ALLOW THOUSANDS UPON
THOUSANDS UPON THOUSANDS OF
ACRES OF SOLAR FIELDS ONE IN
PARTICULAR SIX THOUSAND ACRES OF
LAND. TWO MILLION SOLAR BUT-
PANELS DOES NOT PAY AN OUNCE IN
PROPERTY TAXES TO BE ABLE TO
FIND ROADS INFRASTRUCTURE
LIBRARY SCHOOLS AND EVERYTHING
ELSE THAT COMMUNITIES NEED FOR
THEIR CONSTITUENTS. SO TO SAY
THAT TAXPAYERS ARE NOT ON THE
SET FOR THIS BILL AND IT'S GOING
TO BE THE QUOTE UNQUOTE- A PER
DIEM PRODUCERS OF THIS- OF THIS
CARBON EMISSION OR WHAT HE CALLS
THE AUTHOR CALLS POLLUTION IS
NOT A TRUE OR ACCURATE STATEMENT
WE ARE STILL PAYING FOR IT
THROUGH OUR- RATE INCREASES WITH
OUR UTILITY BILLS. ON ANOTHER
NOTE. THE AUTHOR MADE THE
STATEMENT THAT THE INDIVIDUALS
WHO PRODUCE THIS. QUOTE UNQUOTE
POLLUTION SHOULD PAY FOR THIS
AND I AGREE WHOLEHEARTEDLY I
WISH THERE WAS A WAY WE COULD
REGULATED THE DEMOCRATIC
REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO FOR
DESTROYING THEIR ENVIRONMENT AND
CREATING POLLUTION LIKE WE'VE
NEVER SEEN BEFORE. AND PRODUCING
SLAVE LABOR WORTH THOUSANDS UPON
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE AND CHILDREN
ARE BEING FORCED IN TO MINING
SHAFTS FIFTY SIXTY SEVENTY FEET
DEEP TO BRIDGE THE CALL BALK AT
WE NEED FOR THE BATTERY STORAGE
THAT THIS LEGISLATIVE BODY.
DEMANDS I WISH WE COULD PUT SOME
TYPE OF CAPS OR SOME TYPE OF
REGULATORY PROCESS ON CHINA FOR
PRODUCING ECUADORIAN OIL IN THE
RAINFOREST AND SENDING IT HERE
TO CALIFORNIA. ON BUNKER FUEL
SHIPS THAT HIM YOU ADMIT. CONS
AND TIMES MILLIONS OF METRIC
TONS OF CARBON EMISSIONS- TO GET
THAT OIL THAT WE USE- IN
CALIFORNIA RIGHT NOW IT'S ONE
POINT EIGHT MILLION BARRELS
EVERY SINGLE DAY THAT WE CONSUME
THAT WE IMPORT FROM FOREIGN
COUNTRIES. SO YES I AGREE WITH
THE AUTHORS COMMENTS THAT WE
SHOULD. ADDRESS THESE POLLUTERS
ECUADOR SAUDI ARABIA IRAQ CHINA
AND THOSE COUNTRIES THAT ARE
USING US AS A PAWN IN THEIR
SCHEME. TO ADD TO PUSH US. I
DON'T KNOW FOOLISHLY OR
PURPOSELY TO PRODUCE LEGISLATION
THAT DOESN'T ALLOW US TO PRODUCE
THE ENERGY HERE MAKE US ENERGY
INDEPENDENT. AND TO KEEP OUR
PRODUCER'S MEETING THE NEEDS
THAT CALIFORNIA'S SO DOES SO
DESIRE EACH AND EVERY DAY FOR
THE WAY OF LIFE THAT THEY USED
OR THEY IT LIVE. AND IT'S JUST
PRETTY INCREDIBLE TO ME THAT YOU
HAD THE GALL TO SAY THAT
TAXPAYERS ARE PAYING FOR IT
TAXPAYERS BUT BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS INTO THAT ABOVE MARKET
FUND ACCOUNT THAT WAS
DISTRIBUTED TO THE SOLAR AND
WIND COMPANIES TO MAKE THEM
MARKETABLE. OR WITHIN THE MARKET
RANGE OF FOSSIL FUELS THE END OF
THE NATURAL GAS INDUSTRY AND
CALIFORNIA TO AT TAXPAYERS AND
UTILITY PAYERS ARE STILL PAYING
FOR RATE INCREASES ON THEIR
UTILITY BILLS TO COVER THESE.
GREEN SHENANIGANS THINGS THAT
ARE SUPPOSED TO BRING SOME TYPE
OF BALANCE TO THE- ED CARBON
EMISSION ISSUE IN THE IN THE
WORLD AND WE'RE NOT EVEN
ADDRESSING THE FACT THAT THESE
MOST CARBON EMISSIONS COME FROM
OUTSIDE THE STATE RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR A NO VOTE. THANK YOU ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR ASHLEY. THANK YOU BE
VERY BRIEF I APPRECIATE THE
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING FORWARD THIS
BILL IT IS AN IDEA WHOSE TIME
HAS DEFINITELY COME. NEGATIVE
EMISSION CREDITS HAVE A PLACE IN
OUR PROCESS TO REDUCE GREENHOUSE
GASES. THIS INNOVATIVE PROCESS
TO REMOVE CARBON DIOXIDE IS
BEING EXPLORED BY MANY FORWARD
THINKING ENTITIES. INCLUDING
SMUD RIGHT HERE IN THE
SACRAMENTO REGION AND I URGE AN
AYE VOTE ON SB THREE ZERO EIGHT.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
AND DEBATE ON THIS ITEM. SENIOR
MORE LOT MICROPHONE CENTER
BACKWARD TOWARD CLOSE SURE I
THANK YOU I APPRECIATE THE
COMMENTS AND DISCUSSION- I THINK
YOU KNOW SOME OF THAT WAS ABOUT.
YOU KNOW ALSO GOT OTHER ISSUES
AROUND YOU KNOW SOLAR IN THE
TAXES IT PAYS- BUT- I DO
APPRECIATE MY COLLEAGUES. FOR
SACRAMENTO'S CONVERSATION ABOUT-
ABOUT THIS IDEA WE SEE THAT
ENTREPRENEURS ARE NOW STARTING
TO VEST IN THIS WE NEED TO SET
IT SEND A SIGNAL TO THE MARKET.
I DO COMMIT TO KEEP WORKING WITH
THEM ARE NOT JUSTICE GROUPS WE
WANNA MAKE SURE THAT THESE DO
NOT HAVE ADVERSE IMPACTS THAT WE
WERE ACTUALLY SETTING THE
GUARDRAILS. OTHERWISE CARP CAN
DO THIS ON HIS OWN RIGHT NOW
THEY'RE GONNA DO IT SOMEHOW THIS
ACTUALLY SAYS GUARDRAILS ON
THAT. LOOK FOR TO CONTINUE
WORKING WITH THEM I LOOK FOR TO
CONTINUE WORKING WITH INDUSTRY
AS WELL. AS WE THINK ABOUT
COORDINATION- AND THINK ABOUT
HOW IT'S GONNA AFFECT. YOU ANY
OTHER OF THE THINGS THAT
THEY'RE- BEING REGULATED TODAY-
BUT WITH. THAT- I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE. THE YOU
MA'AM SIR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ALLEN HI HOWEVER OUT OF GUILT.
MARCH S. B. HI ATKINS BAKER. I
BLINK SPENT. BY BRADFORD. KAMALA
HI CORTESE. HI DELHI. NO DODD.
THE RAZA. I EGGMAN. GLAZER I
GONZALEZ. HI GROVE. NO OUR TITLE
. JONES NO. LAYERED HI LIMÓN. I
MCGUIRE. HI MENJIVAR. I MEAN.
NEWMAN AYE NGUYEN. NO ME LO NO-
SHOW ABOVE NO IDEA I PORTANTINO
. I ROTH AYE RUBIO. SEYARTO NO
SKINNER. HI SMALLWOOD CUEVAS I
STERN. MY NUMBER. WAHABI WIENER
. I WILK. NO PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. EL DORADO GIL.
NO ARCHULETA. I ATKINS BRADFORD
. DODD EGGMAN- TADO. MAN RUBIO.
AMBERG BOB. I. HIS TWENTY THREE
KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES.
NOW MEMBERS WERE MOVING ON THE
FILE ITEM FIFTY NINE CENTER
STERN ARE YOU PREPARED.
SECRETARY PLEASE RATE SENATE
BILL SEVEN SEVENTEEN BY CENTER
STERN AN ACT RELATING TO MENTAL
HEALTH SERVICES CENTER STERN.
MEMBERS AT IN OUR CALIFORNIA
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH CRISIS WE'RE
EXPERIENCING. A 63% OF ADULTS
WITH MENTAL ILLNESS RECEIVE NO
MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT AND
UNFORTUNATELY IT HAPPENS QUITE
OFTEN- THROUGH OUR COUNTY. A
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM AND ITS
INTERFACE OF THE MENTAL HEALTH
SYSTEM RIGHT NOW IN COURT IF
SOMEONE FOUND TO BE INCOMPETENT
TO STAND TRIAL AND ERROR I'VE
BEEN ACCUSED OF A MISDEMEANOR-
THEY'RE ALLOWED TO BE DIVERTED
INTO MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES IN
LIEU OF CITY AND COUNTY JAIL
WHICH IS PROVED A LIABILITY IN
COUNTY JAILS ACROSS CALIFORNIA
AND PEOPLE ARE DYING IN THEIR
FOR MENTAL HEALTH CRISES. SO WE
KNOW TREATMENT IS A BETTER
OPTION ESPECIALLY DURING THE
PENDENCY OF A CASE HOWEVER IF
THAT CASES THEN DISMISSED.
PEOPLE IN THOSE CASES ARE
OFFERED SERVICES AND THEN THEY
WERE DISMISSED. AND IF YOU'RE
SUFFERING FROM ACUTE
SCHIZOPHRENIA OR PSYCHOTIC
EFFECTIVE DISORDER AND YOU'RE
OFFERED SERVICES. AND THEN
DISMISSED WHAT DO YOU THINK
HAPPENS. THAT IS THE PRISON
HISTORY PIPELINE THAT WE NEED TO
BREAK- IN THIS BILL WOULD SIMPLY
JUST REQUIRE COUNTIES TO
MAINTAIN CONTACT WITH THAT
PERSON. WHILE OFFERING A SERVICE
BUT MAINTAIN CONTACT FOR HUNDRED
EIGHTY DAYS IT'S NOT FAIR THAT
WE PROCESS PEOPLE AND THEN CUT
THEM LOOSE- THIS DOESN'T PUSH
ANYONE INTO A CARE COURT. I THIS
DOESN'T DEAL WITH
CONSERVATORSHIP ISSUES IT
DOESN'T TOUCH ANY OF THAT IT
JUST SIMPLY SAYS. WE NEED TO
KEEP AN EYE ON PEOPLE AND NOT
JUST LET PEOPLE GET LOST IN OUR
SYSTEM AND END UP ON THE STREETS
OR WORSE SO- SEEMS TO BE SOME
BROAD SUPPORT ACROSS. ACROSS THE
STATE AND- WE'RE REALLY HOPING
COUNTY STEP UP IN AND DO THEIR
PART- WE KNOW IT'S EASY TO GET.
STUCK BETWEEN THE CRACKS BUT-
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OF THE RATE ON THIS ITEM.
NINETEEN NINE MEMBERS IS
ELIGIBLE FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ON THE
SITE ON. SCENE NINE OZ THIRTY
NINE NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
. NOW MEMBERS WERE MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM SEVENTY SIX. BY CENTER
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS SHE'S PREPARED
SECRETARY MARIE SENATE BILL
EIGHT SIXTY FOUR BY SMALL QUICK
BY SENATOR SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. AN
ACT RELATING TO WORKFORCE
DEVELOPMENT. THANK YOU MS
INTERNET FOR GEORGE THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT AND GOOD AFTERNOON
COLLEAGUES I AM PLEASED TO
PRESENT S. B. C. S. EIGHT SIXTY
FOUR WHICH WOULD EMPOWER
CALIFORNIA WORKFORCE BY ENSURING
THE JOBSEEKERS. WHO VISIT OUR
CAREER CENTERS. ARE ABLE TO
ADVANCE THEIR EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITIES AND RECEIVE THE
EDUCATION THAT THEY NEED. IN
TERMS OF UNDERSTANDING THEIR
RIGHTS WE HAVE DONE THE WORK OF
CREATING STRONG POWERFUL
WORKPLACE LAWS HERE AT THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA BUT IT IS ONLY
REALIZED WHEN THE WORKER IN FACT
KNOWS. THEIR RIGHTS SPECIFICALLY
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE THE
CALIFORNIA WORKFORCE BOARD TO
PARTNER WITH THE LABOR
COMMISSIONER. AND OTHER SUBJECT
MATTER EXPERTS TO DEVELOP A
WORKPLACE RIGHTS CURRICULUM TO
BE USED BY THEIR COMMUNITIES
LOCAL CAREER CENTERS THIS
CURRICULUM WILL INCLUDE
INFORMATION PERTAINING TO WAIT
STAFF SEXUAL HARASSMENT
DISCRIMINATION- WORKER VOICE.
AND ON THE JOB HEALTH AND SAFETY
PROTECTIONS FREQUENTLY THOSE WHO
UTILIZE SERVICES OF OUR CAREER
CENTERS FINE IN APPOINTMENT
SECTORS WHERE THEY ARE THE MOST
VULNERABLE AND WHERE THESE
RIGHTS ARE CRITICAL TO SAVING
THEIR JOBS. SB EIGHT SIX FOUR IS
CRITICAL TO ENSURING THAT JOB
SEEKERS WILL HAVE THE NECESSARY
TOOLS TO BETTER PROTECT
THEMSELVES AND THEIR COMMUNITIES
FROM JOB LOSS UNPAID WAGES
FINANCIAL INSECURITY. AND OTHER
WORKER VIOLATIONS THEY WOULD
OTHERWISE BE VULNERABLE TO THIS
IS ABOUT KNOWLEDGE THAT EMPOWERS
. AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE. THE FURTHER
DISCUSSION INVADE THE SIDE
SENATOR. PROFESSOR RESPECTFULLY-
ASKS FOR A NO VOTE THAT THE BILL
IN ITSELF IS I DON'T WANT TO SAY
USELESS THAT'S JUST A HORRIBLE
WORD BUT- THE BUILDING ITSELF
EMPLOYERS IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA ARE ALREADY REQUIRED
TO DO TRAINING PROVIDE THEIR
EMPLOYEES WITH AN AYE AYE P. P.
WHICH INCLUDES ALL OF THE RIGHTS
THAT EMPLOYEES HAVE. REGARDING
THE LAWS IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IT ALSO INCLUDES
MILLION RESTAURANTS RESTAURANT
COUNTRY PERIODS CAL OSHA SAFETY
VIOLATIONS- TAG A LOCK OUT TAG
OUT I MEAN YOU JUST GO DOWN THE
LIST AND THERE'S A SERIES OF
THINGS THAT HAVE TO BE COVERED
IN THE I. A. P. P. EACH EMPLOYEE
THAT GOES THROUGH AN EMPLOYEE
SAFETY ORIENTATION. PRIOR TO
THEIR HIRING HAS TO BE ABLE TO
GO THROUGH THIS TRAINING AND
IT'S A GENERAL TRAINING FOR ALL
EMPLOYERS CITE SPECIFIC FOR
OTHERS- LIKE HOSPITALS WOULD
HAVE DIFFERENT SITE SPECIFIC
THAN MAYBE A ROOFING COMPANY.
BUT THE GENERAL SAFETY TRAINING
THAT'S REQUIRED BY THIS BODY IN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA UNDER
CAL OSHA. REQUIRES ALL OF THIS
ALREADY. THE ONLY THING THIS
BILL OFFERS THAT IS NOT REQUIRED
AS OF YET BY THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. IS THE INFORMATION
IN THERE SPECIFICALLY RELATING.
AND TO LET ME SEE IF I CAN FIND
THE EXACT WORDS- HELLO WORKPLACE
ACT. SO TO THE STATE BUT BASS
DOESN'T REQUIRE RIGHT NOW YOU
ARE NOT REQUIRED TO PROVIDE THE
EMPLOYEE WITH- YOU CAN GIVE THEM
THE INFORMATION IT SAYS THEY
HAVE THE RIGHT TO ORGANIZE BUT
YOU DON'T HAVE TO INVITE THE-
LABOR UNIONS INTO PARTICIPATING
IN PLAY ORIENTATION OR HAVE A
NEW HIRE ORIENTATION. OR TO
BRIBE ANY OTHER INFORMATION ON
UNIONIZATION AND TO ME
COLLEAGUES. AND THIS
UNIONIZATION IS THE MOST.
DISCRIMINATORY PROCESS IN OUR
STATE. CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS
WHETHER YOU WORK FOR A UNION OR
PART OF THE UNION ORGANIZATION
OR COMPANY OR YOU DO NOT. AND
EVERY CALIFORNIA TAXPAYER FUNDS
AND PAYS FOR AND- IT'S A
MANDATORY. BUILDING REQUIREMENTS
AND THINGS LIKE THAT THAT ALL
THE THROUGH THIS BUILDING THAT
YOU CAN'T A BILL FOR BILL
HOUSING UNLESS. YOU'RE PART OF A
UNION ORGANIZATION OR SKILLED
AND TRAINED WORKFORCE IS THE
TERM ADOPTED AND I JUST IT'S
JUST. IT TO ME IT SEEMS VERY
VERY DISCRIMINATORY THAT EVERY
TAXPAYER PAYS TAXES AND ONLY
TAXES THAT ARE DUE TO BE DID OUT
OF THIS BUILDING FOR BUILDINGS
FOR HOMELESSNESS FOR ANYTHING
THAT WE DO BUILDINGS FOR NEW
CONSTRUCTION OF OUR CAPITAL. AND
ANY TYPE ANY TIME THAT ANY TYPE
OF- MONEY FROM THE GOVERNMENT IS
ISSUE THAT THAT IT ONLY GOES TO
A UNION CONTRACTOR SO. THAT'S
JUST MY PERSONAL OPINION BUT THE
BOTTOM LINE IS THAT THIS BILL
ALREADY COVERS THAT THE
EVERYTHING IN THIS BILL IS
ALREADY COVERED BY EVERY
EMPLOYER IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IT'S REQUIRED.
REQUIRED TO HAVE YOUR SWIM
PLEASE SIGN OFF INITIAL EACH
PAGE THAT THEY READ EACH PAGE.
IF THEY CAN'T READ ENGLISH YOU
HAVE TO READ IT TO THEM THEY
HAVE TO SIGN IN SPANISH OR
MONGER ANY OTHER LANGUAGE THAT
THEY- SPEAK THAT THEY HAVE BEEN
READ THAT IN THEIR NATIVE
LANGUAGE IF THEY DON'T
UNDERSTAND IT. AND THEN THEY
HAVE TO SIGN AT THE END SAYING
THAT THEY RECEIVE THE WHOLE MENU
AND YOU AFTER WE KEEP THAT
DOCUMENT I BELIEVE FOR SEVEN TO
TEN YEARS- SEVEN YEARS I THINK.
FOR THESE TYPE OF DOCUMENTS TEN
YEARS FOR WAGES. BUT THE ONLY
THING IT DOESN'T INCLUDE IS THE
UNION OF COURSE AND I THINK
ADDING THAT TO THIS IS JUST
ANOTHER ADDITION. OF
DISCRIMINATORY POLICIES AND-
IT'S JUST NOT RIGHT AND
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE. SHE NINE. CENTER
SMALLER QUICKER SHOULD. THE AT
THANK YOU MISTER. AND I WANT TO
BE CLEAR ABOUT WHAT THIS BILL
DOES THIS BILL ENSURES THAT OUR
OBLIGATION IS THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WITH OUR FEDERAL.
FUNDS WHICH FIND OUR WORKFORCE
DEVELOPMENT PREPARATION.
ACTIVITIES THAT WE INVEST IN
PROGRAMS THAT. IN FACT ALLOW
WORKERS TO BETTER UTILIZE
RESOURCES TO BETTER UNDERSTAND
INFORMATION TO WORK WITH OTHERS.
TO UNDERSTAND SYSTEMS RELATED TO
EMPLOYMENT AND TO STRENGTHEN
THEIR EMPLOYABILITY THIS IS
ABOUT ENSURING THAT OUR WORKERS
UNDERSTAND WHAT THEIR RIGHTS ARE
THAT THEY ARE ABLE TO USE THOSE
RIGHTS TO STAY EMPLOYED. TO STAY
SAFE ON THE JOB TO BE ABLE TO
ENGAGE WITH THEIR CO WORKERS AND
THEIR EMPLOYERS AND TO NAVIGATE.
OUR ECONOMY FAR TOO MANY WORKERS
ARE IN LOW WAGE JOBS. WHERE THEY
ARE FACED WITH THESE KINDS OF
CONDITIONS ON VIOLATIONS EVERY
DAY. THE REASON WE ARE PASSING
THESE BILLS TO PROTECT WORKERS
IS SO THAT THEY CAN
OPERATIONALIZE THEIR RIGHTS AND
UNDERSTAND HOW TO PROTECT
THEMSELVES. THAT HAPPENS ONLY
WHEN WE EDUCATE THEM THROUGH OUR
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT SYSTEM IN
WITHOUT I CALLED. FOR AN AYE
VOTE. RATES MA'AM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON FILE
ITEM SEVENTY SIX ELON. I'LL RUN
AGAIN. ARCHULETA HI ASHLEY. HI
ATKINS BAKER. I LIKE. HIGH
BRADFORD. HI COMING OUT OF. A
COURTESY. HI DALY. DODD BY THE
ROSA. EGGMAN I GLAZER. HI
GONZALEZ. HI GROVE. NO OUR TITLE
. JONES NO LAYERED. I LIVE
ALONE. HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA.
AYE MIN. AYE NEWMAN. I NGUYEN.
NILA NO A JOB OF. NO BUT THE- HI
PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH. HI RUBIO.
HI SEYARTO. NO SKINNER. HI
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS HI STERN. HI
AMBERG HI WHAT HUB. I WIENER AYE
WILK HI THERE PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ELLEN I WILL RUN
AGAIN. I ATKINS. DALY. NO THE
RAZA I- TADO I WHEN. NO. HIGHS
THIRTY TWO KNOWS SEVEN THE
MEASURE PASSES NOW WE'RE MOVING
BACK TO FILE ITEM SIXTEEN
SENATOR DODD HE'S PREPARED
SECRETARY PLEASE RATE SENATE
BILL TWO SEVENTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR DODD AN ACT RELATING TO
ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES WIENER DOG.
MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS S. B. TWO
SEVENTY SEVEN WILL ALLOW TYPE
TWENTY LICENSEES THE ABILITY TO
SELL LOW ALCOHOL BY VOLUME
SPIRIT BASED READY TO DRINK
PRODUCTS. AS THE NAME SUGGESTS
READY TO DRINK BEVERAGES OR RTDS
ARE PRE MIX PRE PACKAGE SINGLE
SERVING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES THAT
HAVE BECOME INCREASINGLY POPULAR
FOR THEIR CONVENIENCE QUALITY
AND VARIETY. IN CALIFORNIA
RETAILERS THE WHOLE THE TYPE
TWENTY LICENSE ARE PROHIBITED
FROM SELLING SPIRIT BASED RTDS
EVEN WHEN THOSE PRODUCTS CONTAIN
THE SAME OR LESS AMOUNT OF
ALCOHOL COMPARED TO MALT BASED
FOR WIDE BASED RTDS BOTH OF
WHICH THEY ARE PERMITTED TO SELL
. EVEN WHEN A PERSON WANTS TO
OBTAIN RAFEAL GENERAL LICENSE IN
ORDER TO SELL THESE PRODUCTS
THOSE CAN BE QUITE EXPENSIVE ON
THE OPEN MARKET IN SOMETIMES
IMPOSSIBLE TO OBTAIN BECAUSE OF
THE SCARCITY OF THAT LICENSE.
ALL THIS RESULTS IN CONFUSIONS
BY CUSTOMERS FRUSTRATION FROM
BUSINESSES BECAUSE THE INABILITY
TO SELL THESE POPULAR PRODUCTS
IN LIMITS MANUFACTURE'S ABILITY
TO RESPOND TO CONSUMER DEMAND.
THIS BILL WILL ALLEVIATE THE
COSTLY BURDEN OF SEEKING A
GENERAL LICENSE ALLOWS SMALLER
RETAILERS THE BILL THE ABILITY
TO EVOLVE WITH THE RAPIDLY
GROWING MARKET. IT GIVES
CONSUMERS GREATER CHOICE I WANT
TO REPEAT THAT. THIS BILL WILL
LEVY THE COSTLY BURDEN OF
SEEKING A GENERAL LICENSE ALLOW
SMALLER LOCAL RETAILERS THE
ABILITY TO EVOLVE WITH THE
RAPIDLY GROWING MARKET. AND GIVE
CONSUMERS GREATER CHOICE. I'VE
HAD A NUMBER OF MEETINGS WITH
THE OPPOSITION I'M HOPEFUL WE
CAN COME TO AN AGREEMENT ON A
NUMBER OF ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN
REYES SPECIFICALLY AROUND THE
CONCERNS OF AB LANGUAGE IN
PROVIDING THE DEPARTMENT
ADDITIONAL. AN ADDITIONAL ROLE
HOWEVER I DO WANT TO BE CLEAR IS
CHAIR OF GEO FOR NEARLY SEVEN
YEARS I'VE ALWAYS STRESSED THAT
I'M NOT INTERESTED IN PICKING
WINNERS AND LOSERS. AND DON'T
BELIEVE IT IS OUR ROLE TO STIFLE
COMPETITION IN THE MARKETPLACE.
WITH THAT SAID WE ARE CONTINUING
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
OPPOSITION AND FULLY EXPECT THIS
BILL TO HAVE AMENDMENTS IN THE
ASSEMBLY. AND OF COURSE. WOULD
BE THAT WOULD BE A CONCURRENCE
VOTE THEY WOULD COME BACK ON
THIS FLOOR RESPECTFULLY ASK DR.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
DEBATE SENATOR GLAZERS. THANK
YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS I WANT
TO COMMEND THE AUTHOR FOR HIS
GOOD WORK ON THIS. THIS ISSUE
WHEN I TAKE HIS COMMENTS TO
HEART THAT HE'S NOT TRYING TO.
PICK WINNERS AND LOSERS AND
THAT'S- A MAJOR REASON WHY I'M A
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY. BUT I
DID WANT TO MENTION THAT THIS
DOES CHANGE- THE STANDARDS FOR
MORE THAN FOURTEEN THOUSAND TYPE
TWENTY LICENSES ACROSS THE
STATE- AND THAT'S A SIGNIFICANT
CHANGE AND LOCAL COMMUNITIES
THAT HAVE UNDERSTOOD THAT. AND
FORCE THAT- YOU KNOW THIS IS
GOING TO BE A CHANGE I THE
AUTHOR MENTIONS IN HIS- REMARKS
THAT. ARE SUPPORTING THE
DEPARTMENT OF THE ABC IN THIS
NEW CHANGES IMPORTANCE. IN
ENSURING THAT MIGHT INCLUDE FOR
FUNDING TO MAKE SURE THEY CAN DO
THEIR WORK- IN EDUCATING-
CERTAINLY ALL OF US ARE ARE.
CONCERNED ABOUT THE OVERSIGHT OF
THESE THAT THE STATUS ONCE IT'S
ALCOHOL IN OUR COMMUNITIES WE
WANT TO MAKE SURE THEY'RE- GONNA
CONTINUE TO BE SAFE PLACES- WITH
THAT WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE APPRECIATE THE
AUTHOR'S WORK IN THIS AREA.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE ON THIS ITEM. IN
NINETEEN ON SENATOR DODD TO LOOK
CLOSE. YES MEMBERS IN- TO THE
SENATOR FROM- ARANDA PER SHEET
THOSE COMMENTS OF THOSE
FOURTEENTH OUT THAT IS A CHANGE.
BUT THE OVERSIGHT OF THAT
THERE'S ALREADY PEOPLE
MONITORING THE ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGES THAT ARE BEING SOLD
AND DISTRIBUTED IN ALL TO
FOURTEEN THOUSAND OF THOSE.
OUTLETS IN NONE OF THESE
PRODUCTS WILL HAVE ANY MORE
ALCOHOL BY VOLUME THAN ANY OTHER
PRODUCTS THAT ARE SOLD IN THOSE
STORES RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I.
ABOUT. USE MEMBERS THIS IS
ELIGIBLE FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ON FILE
ITEM SIXTEEN. NINETEEN NINE
HOURS THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO THE
MEASURE PASSES. NEXT UP IS FILE
ITEM ONE OH SIX BY SENATOR
GONZALEZ SECTOR YOU MAY READ.
SENATE BILL TWO FIFTY TWO BY
SENATOR GONZALEZ AN ACT RELATING
TO PUBLIC RETIREMENT SYSTEMS.
GONZALEZ THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
AND MEMBERS- I RISE TODAY WITH A
VERY SIMPLE BILL- THIS IS S. B.
TWO FIFTY TWO WHICH- WE CAME OUT
WITH LAST YEAR BUT ESSENTIALLY
ASKS- THAT WE ENSURE THAT OUR
FOSSIL FUEL INVESTMENTS FOR THE
LARGEST CALPERS ESTHER SYSTEM-
HAS IT HER RIGHT TIME HORIZON-
TO DIVEST. THOSE UP PENSION I'M
SORRY DAY PASSED THOSE FOSSIL
FUEL INVESTMENTS BY TWENTY
THIRTY ONE- WE ALSO HAVE AN
ADDITIONAL FOUR YEAR SHOULD
THERE BE AN ACT OF GOD WAR AT
CETERA SO IT'S FIFTEEN BILLION
DOLLARS BETWEEN THAT TIME.
ESSENTIALLY TWELVE YEAR HORIZON.
AS CALIFORNIA GOES THAT ZERO BY
TWENTY FORTY FIVE WERE
PROHIBITING- INTERNAL COMBUSTION
ENGINES BY TWENTY THIRTY FIVE
AND TWENTY FORTY FIVE MEDIUM
HEAVY DUTY INTERNAL COMBUSTION
ENGINES WE NEED OUR CALIFORNIA
HARD EARNED PENSION DOLLARS
REFLECT THAT TRAJECTORY- THIS
INDUSTRY TO CAPITAL INTENSIVE
FOR US TO SUSTAIN AND WE ALSO
KNOW THE EXTREME HEAT WITHIN THE
NEXT FIVE YEARS. IS GOING TO BE
EVEN WORSE NOT EVEN TEN OR
TWELVE OR TEN OR FIFTEEN YEARS.
AND MANY OF THESE INVESTMENTS
DON'T EVEN HAVE A GOOD JUST
TRANSITION PLAN FOR WORKFORCE
AND LANGUAGE IS SICK EXPLICIT TO
REFRAIN FROM. IMPLEMENTING THE
BILL- SHOULD THE PENSION SYSTEM
KNOWING GOOD FAITH THAT IT WOULD
IMPACT THEIR FIDUCIARY
RESPONSIBILITY. SO WITH THAT I
URGE AN AYE VOTE ON SB TWO FIFTY
TWO. THANK YOU ANY FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
ITEM SENATORS SEYARTO. THANK YOU
MR PRESIDENT- I RISE IN
OPPOSITION. TO SB TWO FIFTY TWO-
THE PENSION FUNDS ARE MANAGED
VERY WELL BY BOARDS AND THEY
ALSO HAVE INVESTMENT MANAGERS.
THAT ARE IN CHARGE OF
DETERMINING WHAT INVESTMENTS WE
SHOULD BE INVESTING IN FOR THE
PENSION SYSTEMS AND WHICH
INVESTMENTS WE SHOULD NOT BE. I
WOULD IMAGINE AS- IF OIL BECOMES
A THEY- OR THAT THE INDUSTRY CAN
YOU GUYS I. SORRY AS THE OIL
INDUSTRY- MAY COMES OFF LINE IS
QUIZ IF WE'RE ABLE TO ACHIEVE
THAT- IT WILL BECOME LESS OF A
GOOD INVESTMENT FOR PENSION
FUNDS. AND THEREFORE THEY WILL
THOSE BOARDS THE BOARD AND THE
INVESTMENT OFFICER- WILL
DETERMINE THAT THAT'S A LESSER
INVESTMENT. BUT RIGHT NOW- DANCE
ONE OF THE INVESTMENTS THAT
ACTUALLY WORKS. THE WAY OUR
PENSION SYSTEMS WORK. IS IF WE
DON'T MAKE SIX POINT 8% ON OUR
PENSIONS. THE PERSONS THAT ARE
GOING TO PAY FOR THAT OUR OUR
OUR CITIZENS SO THIS IS LASHING
OUT AT THE AT THE INDUSTRY THAT
WE FEEL IS SO RESPONSIBLE. FOR
DESTROYING OUR PLANET WELL IT'S
ALSO RESPONSIBLE FOR A LOT OF
THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE HERE
TODAY THAT WE ENJOY TODAY AND
THE LIFESTYLES THAT WE HAVE
TODAY. AND SO IF WE WANT TO
REMOVE THEM AND KEEP THEM TO THE
CURB- YOU KNOW WHAT. YOU CAN GO
DOWN THAT PATH. IF YOU THINK
IT'S GOING TO SOLVE ALL THE
PROBLEMS OF THE ENVIRONMENT GO
DOWN THAT PATH BUT THERE IS A
PROCESS TO DO THAT. AND THAT
PROCESS IF IT'S PUT INTO PLACE
WITH THAT RIGHT NOW OR WITHIN
BETWEEN NOW AND THEN TWENTY
THIRTY ONE. ARTIFICIALLY OUTSIDE
OF THE MARKET LEAVES LESS DO
LESS INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES
THAT CAN HELP BALANCE OUT A
PORTFOLIO SO WE CAN MAKE THAT
SIX POINT 8% RETURN. RATE OF
RETURN ON THE INVESTMENTS THAT
WE NEED TO. SO WHO DOES THIS
REALLY HURT. AND HURT AND IT
DOESN'T HURT THE OIL INDUSTRY AT
ALL BECAUSE GUESS WHAT. IF WE
SELL OFF THOSE INVESTMENTS AND
BY THE WAY THAT'S A HUNDRED AND
FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS OF
TRANSACTION FEES TO SELL THOSE
INVESTMENTS OFF. EVEN IF IT IS
OVER THE NEXT SEVEN YEARS.
THAT'S A LOT. BUT WHAT IT DOES
IS IT IT IT HURTS OUR PENSION
SYSTEM. THEREFORE IT HURTS THE
PEOPLE THAT DEPEND ON THOSE
PENSION SYSTEMS IT PUTS OUR
PENSION SYSTEMS MORE AT RISK
THAN THEY ALREADY ARE. BECAUSE
THEY'VE HAD A BAD YEAR. BY THE
WAY. SO THAT'S TO IT THAT'S ONE
OF THE WITH THE GROUPS THAT
HURTS THE OTHER GROUP THAT HURTS
. ARE THE CITIZENS THAT PAY OUR
TAXES. BECAUSE WHEN THEIR
COMMUNITIES DO GOOD ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT ARE ABLE TO GET
MORE. MORE DOLLARS INTO THE
COFFERS SO THEY CAN PAY FOR
THOSE COMMUNITY PARKS IN THOSE
POLICE IN THOSE FIRE AND ALL
THOSE SERVICES. BUT INSTEAD THAT
MONEY HAS TO BE. MADE THAT MADE
UP THAT THAT MONEY GOES TO
MAKING UP THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
THE SIX POINT 8% AND THEN LIKE
LAST YEAR MINUS SEVEN PERCENT.
THE DAY GOT. ON THEIR RATE OF
RETURN. WE CANNOT MASS. WITH THE
PENSION SYSTEMS. WITH POLITICAL
STATEMENTS. AND THIS IS A
POLITICAL STATEMENT THAT WE
DON'T LIKE OIL. I'M SORRY. BUT
THEY WOULD MEAN A LOT MORE. IF
AT THE END OF THE DAY. IF WE
DON'T LIKE OIL. THEN MAYBE WE
SHOULDN'T BE ORDERING ONE POINT
EIGHT MILLION BARRELS A DAY OF
IT AT THE END OF EVERY SINGLE
DAY. THIS PROBLEM. WILL TAKE
CARE OF ITSELF OVER TIME. IF
WE'RE SUCCESSFUL IN MAKING THAT
CONVERSION IT WILL TAKE CARE OF
ITSELF. BUT WE CANNOT RESTRICT.
WE CANNOT TAKE DECISIONS OUT OF
THE BOARD OF INVESTMENTS PLANNED
FOR CALPERS AND CAL STIRS. THOSE
ARE ALL OUR TEACHERS OUT THERE.
AND PUT THEIR- PENSIONS AT RISK.
BY LIMITING. THE INVESTMENTS
THAT WORK TO OFFSET THE
INVESTMENTS THEY DON'T. THIS IS
COMPLICATED WE SHOULDN'T BE
MESSING WITH IT ESPECIALLY RIGHT
NOW IT'S THE WRONG TIME FOR THIS
TYPE OF THE BILL. IF IN THE
FUTURE WE FIND THAT SOMEHOW
SOMEBODY THEY'LL THEY'LL BE
RESPONSIBLE BECAUSE THEY HAVE
PEOPLE ANSWER TO. THEY WON'T BE
ON THE BOARD ANYMORE THAT'S WHAT
HAPPENS TO OUR PENSIONS. BUT WE
CAN'T LIMIT THEM AND THEN HAVE
THEM SAY WELL. THE LEGISLATURE
LIMITED US SO NOW WE DON'T HAVE
ANY MONEY TO PAY OUR PENSIONS
AND GUESS WHAT ALL YOU
PENSIONERS YOU'RE A LACK. SO I
ASK YOU TO PASS ON THIS BILL
TODAY. BECAUSE I THINK IT'S THE
WRONG TIME. AND IT'S THE WRONG
MESSAGE. IT'S GOING TO HURT THE
WRONG PEOPLE. SO I ASKED HER WHY
ARE YOUR NO VOTE THANK YOU. THE
Q. CENTRE DOLLAR. THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I JUST I RISE
IN IN OPPOSITION AND I WANT TO
SAY WHY. NOT BECAUSE IT'S OIL.
IT COULD BE ANYBODY THAT WE WANT
TO CHOOSE BUT- YOU KNOW THE
AUTHOR JUST A COUPLE OF DAYS AGO
BROUGHT A BILL THE SAID. LOCAL
ELECTED'S SHOULD HAVE A TWO DAY
OUR TO OUR TO A CLASS TO LEARN
ABOUT FINANCES. AND I SUPPORTED
THAT BILL BECAUSE I THINK PEOPLE
SHOULD UNDERSTAND. HOW
GOVERNMENT WORKS AND HOW WE
FINANCES WELL I WANT TO TALK
ABOUT PENSION FUNDS. HOW DO WE
FIND PENSION FUNDS. IS BY
INVESTING AND ACTUALLY MAKING
MONEY. AND WHEN THE STOCK
MARKET'S DOING GREAT. ARE
PENSION FUNDS DO WELL I AM THE
STOCK MARKET DOES NOT DO WELL.
ARE PENSION FUNDS DROPBOX. AND
WHEN THOSE FUNDS DROP OFF WE
STILL HAVE AN OBLIGATION. TO THE
EMPLOYEE THAT WE PROMISED. A
RETIREMENT. TO AND WHEN WE DON'T
HAVE THAT STOCK MARKET FUND.
HEALTHY THE GOVERNMENT HAS TO
STEP IN EITHER EITHER THE CITY
THE COUNTY OR THE STATE AND BACK
FILL OUT OF THE GENERAL FUND
THOSE PENSION FUNDS. SO WE'VE
SEEN THESE TYPES OF BILLS COME
THROUGH BECAUSE WE DON'T LIKE A
CERTAIN INDUSTRY OR WE DON'T
LIKE. I THINK THERE WAS ONE THAT
WE DON'T INVEST IN AMMUNITION
BECAUSE LIKE FIREARMS.
REGARDLESS OF WHAT INDUSTRY YOU
DO OR DO NOT LIKE IN CALIFORNIA
A PENSION FUND IS THERE TO MAKE
MONEY FOR THE RETIREES AND THEIR
HEALTH BENEFITS WHICH IS THE
ISSUE. AND TRUST ME WE HAVE
LITERALLY. BILLIONS IF NOT
TRILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF UNFUNDED
PENSION LIABILITY AS WE SIT ON
THIS FLOOR TODAY IN OUR LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS AND OUR STATE LEVEL
SO. THAT'S WHY I'M OPPOSING THE
BILL AS WE SHOULD NOT BE.
TELLING INVESTORS HOW TO MAKE
MONEY WE SHOULD LET THEM DO
THEIR JOB. IF YOU WANT TO GET
RID OF OIL DO WHAT YOU'RE DOING
YOU'RE GETTING RID OF IT. BUT
DON'T ALLOW PEOPLE WHO DO
INVESTMENTS TO NOT CREATE A
PROFIT FOR THOSE. STATE WORKERS
LOCAL WORKERS THAT WE
DESPERATELY NEED AND WE ALSO
NEED THOSE PENSION FUNDS TO BE
HEALTHY SO THAT. THE PROMISES
THAT THE LEGISLATIVE BODIES HAVE
MADE. TO THOSE EMPLOYEES WHEN
THEY RETIRE WILL BE THERE. AND
I'LL CLOSE WITH THIS. I HAD THE
FIRST CITY. IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. WHO DEFAULTED ON
THEIR PENSION FUNDS AND WE HAD
RETIRED. EMPLOYEES WHO ARE
GETTING FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS A
YEAR AGO FROM FIFTY THOUSAND. TO
EIGHTEEN THOUSAND AND LET ME
TELL YOU SOMETHING. WHEN YOU'RE
ON A FIXED INCOME AND YOU'RE
RETIRED AND YOU CAN'T WORK
ANYMORE. THAT'S A PROBLEM. THIS
BILL. WILL EXACERBATE THAT LET
THE PEOPLE WHO DO THEIR FINANCES
INVEST IN THINGS THAT MAKE MONEY
. AND THEN OUR EMPLOYEES WE'VE
SELF STAY OUT OF THIS BUSINESS
IS A BAD IDEA. AND I THINK THAT
WE'VE WE SET PRECEDENCE IS ON
WHAT THEY CAN AND CANNOT SIT
INVEST IN. WE WILL LOSE MONEY
AND IT WILL BACK FILL WITH
TAXPAYERS DOLLARS AND THAT
DOESN'T WORK FOR THOSE REASONS.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NO VOTE.
THANK YOU ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE ON THIS ITEM. SEENU
MORE MIKE'S SENATOR GONZALEZ
WHICH OUGHT TO CLOSE. YEAH I
STATE THANK YOU TO MY COLLEAGUES
FOR STANDING UP ON THIS A VERY
IMPORTANT ISSUE I WOULD JUST SAY
THAT- OVER THE COURSE OF THE
SEVEN DIVESTMENT POLICIES THAT
HAVE RUN THROUGH THE
LEGISLATURE. EVERY SINGLE ONE OF
THEM EXCEPT FOR ONE HAS HAD A
GOOD RETURN ON INVESTMENT FOR
THIS THIS OF. THIS PORTFOLIO
THESE PORTFOLIOS IN THE SNP'S.
OF FIVE HUNDRED FOSSIL FUEL FREE
TOTAL RETURN INDEX ACTUALLY IS
CONSISTENTLY OUTPERFORM THE S.
AND P. FIVE HUNDRED OVERALL THAT
INCLUDES FOSSIL FUELS SINCE
TWENTY TWELVE. SO IF YOU'RE
LOOKING AT THIS PURELY
ECONOMICALLY THERE IS A BENEFIT
TO DIVESTMENT ESPECIALLY IN AN
ANTIQUATED- IN. AN INDUSTRY THAT
WILL BE PHASED OUT AT SOME POINT
WITHOUT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU SIX
THIRTY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON
FILE ITEM. ONE OF SIX ALLEN. ALL
RIGHT TO GO. NO ARCHULETA. HI
ASHLEY. HI ATKINS BECKER. HI
BLAKE'S. I BRADFORD. KAMIENNA
CORTESE. BY TELLING. NO DONE. NO
THE RAZA. HI EGGMAN. I GLAZER.
GONZALEZ HI GROVE. NO HER TITLE
. NO JONES. NO LAYERED. HI
LIMÓN. HI MCGUIRE. AYE MENDOZA.
AYE MIN. AYE NEWMAN. WHEN NO NEW
LOW. NO OF CHAU ABOVE. NO IDEA.
HI PORTANTINO. AYE ROTH. RUBIO
SEYARTO. NO SKINNER. HI
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS I STERN HI
AMBERG. I LOVE I WIENER AYE WILK
. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN BY ATKINS BRADFORD IBM.
GLAZER ROTH RUBIO NEWMAN. WELL.
HIS TWENTY TWO KNOWS TEN THE
MEASURE PASSES. READ TAKE A
BRIEF RECESS MEMBERS.
MEMBERS RUN ASSET ALL MEMBERS
HERE TO JUST WILL BE LIFTING
CALL SHORTLY.
OUR MEMBERS WERE GONNA LOOK
CALLS WE'RE GONNA START WITH
FILE ITEM TO CENTER PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN HI
ELDORADO GIL I ATKINS DELHI.
DODD. HI BUT CHAU ABOVE. RUBIO
BY OCHO ABOVE HI. DALY. PLEASE
CALL AB TWO MEMBERS ATKINS
TELLING. OUR THIRTY EIGHT NO
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES NOW
MEMBERS REMOVE ON FILE ITEM
NUMBER THREE ACTOR PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL. ATKINS DALY. DODD. HI
EGGMAN. WHEN NIELLO. A CHAU
ABOVE I. WILK. OUR THIRTY FOUR
KNOWS ZERO THE APPOINTMENT IS
CONFIRMED NEXT UP FILE ITEM. FOR
ALLEN. HI ATKINS DODD. HI
MCGUIRE. HI BUT CHAU ABOVE. I IS
THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
APPOINTMENT IS CONFIRMED NOW
MEMBERS MOVE ON FILE ITEM FIVE.
ELLEN BY ATKINS DALY. DODD I ARE
DONALD I. IS THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS
IT ZERO THE APPOINTMENT IS
CONFIRMED NOW MEMBERS OF THE
FILE ITEM NINE. ALLEN BY
ELDORADO GUILT. ATKINS DALY.
DODD. HI GROVE. NO OUR DATA BYE
WHEN. ALL EYES THIRTY TWO KNOWS
FOR THE MEASURE PASSES OUR FINAL
ON CALL ITEM IS FILE ITEM TWENTY
. ALLEN I. DONE I THE RAZA HI
GONZALEZ. HI LIMON. MENJIVAR
WHEN. STERN. ALL EYES THIRTY SIX
KNOWS IT ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
.
MEMBERS NOW'S THE TIME TO REMOVE
ANY ITEM FROM CONSENT OR CONSENT
GALLAGHER.
UNDER MOSES WROTE RESOLUTION
CENTER MENU RECOGNIZE- MISTER
PRESIDENT REQUEST
RECONSIDERATION OF FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINE SB SEVEN FORTY ONE.
OUR THIRTY NINE KNOWS ZERO FOR
RECONSIDERATION IS GRANTED. THE
PERCEPTOR PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
FILE ITEM NINE. ALLEN HI ALL
RIGHT AGAIN HI ARCHULETA HI
ASHLEY HI ATKINS BECKER. HI BLIX
BEER. I BRADFORD HI COMING OUT
OF. MY CORTESE BY TELLING. DODD
I DO RAZA HI EGGMAN. EGGMAN HI
GLAZER HI GONZALEZ HI GROVE-
DONNA I JONES. LAYERED I LOVE MY
OWN. HI MCGUIRE AYE MENDOZA ARE
OF A MAN- NEWMAN AYE NGUYEN
MEELO. NO- CHAU ABOVE HI BY THE
A HI PORTANTINO HI ROTH AYE
RUBIO I SAY ARE TO SKINNER ON A
SMALLWOOD CUEVAS. HI STERN HI
I'M BURKE I LOVE HI WIENER. I
WILK HI. PLEASE CALL ABSENT
MEMBERS ATKINS DELHI. GROWTH.
JONES NO. WHEN SEYARTO. ARE YOU
THIRTY THREE KNOWS TO THE
MEASURE PASSES. NOW MEMBERS OUR
MOTIVES CONSENT CALENDARS OR ANY
MEMBER WISHING TO REMOVE ITEM AT
THIS TIME FROM THE CONSENT
CALENDAR. C. NINE. WHEN.
MEMBERS WERE AT SPECIAL CONSENT
ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS WISHING TO
REMOVE ITEM FROM THE SPECIAL
CONSENT CALENDAR. NUMBER.
TWELVE
CENTER WILL HOP. WHEN. OKAY. I
RISE AS CHAIR OF PUBLIC SAFETY
TO PULL SB FOURTEEN S. B.
NINETEEN S. B. EIGHTY NINE SB
TWO SIXTY EIGHT SB THREE FORTY
SB SEVEN NINETY SIX FOR A LAST
MINUTE OPPOSITION. THREE
FOURTEEN NINETEEN EIGHTY NINE
TWO SIXTY EIGHT THREE FORTY. AND
SEVEN NINE SIX. BORDER TO THIRD
READING.
OUR. ARE MOVING TOO FAST FILE
ITEM TWELVE. FIFTEEN OR PLEASE
READ EVENT. SENATE BILL
1-518-293-8409. 677-576-2232.
TWENTY EIGHT TO THIRTY ONE TO
FORTY TO FORTY SIX TO FIFTY
EIGHT TO EIGHTY TWO TO EIGHTY
THREE THREE OH THREE THREE
ELEVEN THREE EIGHTEEN THREE
NINETEEN THREE TWENTY THREE
THREE TWENTY SEVEN THREE THIRTY
SIX.
THREE FORTY FOUR THREE
SIXTY SEVEN THREE SIXTY NINE
THREE SEVENTY THREE EIGHTY EIGHT
THREE NINETY ONE FOR NINETEEN
FOR THIRTY FOR FOUR FORTY FOUR
FOUR FIFTY SIX FOUR SIXTY FOUR
FOUR SEVENTY FOUR EIGHTY TWO FOR
EIGHTY FOUR FOUR NINETY ONE FIVE
OH TWO FIVE OH SIX FIVE FOURTEEN
FIVE SEVENTEEN FIVE EIGHTEEN
FIVE TWENTY FIVE TWENTY ONE FIVE
THIRTY NINE FIVE FORTY FIVE
FORTY TWO FIVE FORTY EIGHT FIVE
FIFTY EIGHT FIVE SIXTY NINE FIVE
SEVENTY FIVE SEVENTY SEVEN FIVE
SEVENTY EIGHT SIX OH FIVE SIX OH
SIX SIX THIRTEEN. SIX FIFTEEN
SIX TWENTY SIX FORTY ONE SIX
FORTY EIGHT SIX FIFTY SIX FIFTY
SEVEN. SIX SEVENTY ONE SIX
SEVENTY TWO SIX EIGHTY EIGHT SIX
NINETY FOUR. 1-871-671-8720
272-673-1730 475-577-3770
879-980-0805 808-813-8402 EIGHT
FIFTY SIX. EIGHT SIXTY EIGHT
EIGHT SEVENTY TWO. STERN JONES
WHAT PURPOSE IS PRESENT I TO
MAKE A MOTION THAT WE- HOLD THE
CONSENT CALENDAR AND
RECONSIDERED ANOTHER DAY PLEASE
. ONE RENTECH ONE MOMENT PLEASE
HIS BIGGEST PAYMENT.
OUR WE'RE GONNA TAKE A BREAK FOR
A REPUBLICAN CAUCUS. THEY'RE
MOVING THE ROOM TO FIFTEEN FOR
REPUBLICAN CAUCUS.
OUR MEMBERS ARE COMING BACK TO
ORDER.
OUR MEMBERS SECRETARY OF THE
SENATE HAS DETERMINED THE
PULLING OF THE CONSENT CALENDAR
WAS DUE TO AN ADMINISTRATIVE
ERROR SO. CENTER OFF UNDER
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS. THANK
YOU I REQUEST UNANIMOUS CONSENT
TO RE SEND THE MOTION PREVIOUSLY
MADE TO REMOVE THE FOLLOWING
BILLS FROM CONSENT CALENDAR SB
FOURTEEN SB NINETEEN SB EIGHTY
NINE SB TWO SIXTY EIGHT SB THREE
FORTY SB SEVEN NINETY SIX.
WITHOUT OBJECTION SECONDARY
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL.
FOURTEEN NINETEEN EIGHTY NINE TO
SIXTY EIGHT THREE FORTY SEVEN
NINETY SIX. NONSTARTER PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ON THE CONSENT
CALENDAR. ALLEN. HI EL DORADO
GUILT BY ARCHULETA HI S. B. HI
ATKINS HI BAKER. BY BLAKE SPEIR
I BRADFORD- A COPY AND- HI
CORTESE. HI DALY I DON HI THE
RAZA I EGGMAN. HI GLAZER. NAY
GONZALEZ HI GROVE. HI DADA HI
JONES I LAYERED. A LOAN I
MCGUIRE. HI MENJIVAR I MIN AYE
NEWMAN AYE NGUYEN AYE IN THE LOW
I SHOW ABOVE I BY THE- I
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO.
SEYARTO A SKINNER BY SMALLWOOD
CUEVAS- A STERN I AM BURKE- A
ONE HOBBY- A WINNER AYE WILK I.
HIGHS FORTY NO ZERO THE CONSENT
CALENDAR IS APPROVED. NOW
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO COMMITTEE
ANNOUNCEMENTS THIS IS THE TIME
FOR ANY OF OUR COMMITTEE
ANNOUNCEMENTS. SENATOR MENJIVAR
. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT BUDGET
SUB COMMITTEE NUMBER THREE ON
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES WILL
BE MEETING FIFTEEN MINUTES AFTER
SESSION IN ROOM TWELVE HUNDRED.
SUB THREE WILL BE MEETING
FIFTEEN MINUTES AFTER END OF
SESSION IN ROOM TWELVE HUNDRED.
SENATOR BECKER BUT SIMPLY TO
ONLINE RESOURCES AMERICA
PROTECTION ENERGY WILL BE
MEETING TWENTY MINUTES AFTER
SESSION IN ROOM A TWENTY TWO
HUNDRED SUB TO BE WILL BE
MEETING TWENTY MINUTES AFTER
SESSION IN ROOM TWENTY TWO
HUNDRED IN THE SWING SPACE. AND
SENATOR PADILLA THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT A BUDGET SUB NUMBER
FOUR ON STATE ADMINISTRATION
WILL CONVENE TWENTY MINUTES
FOLLOWING RECESS OF THE FLOOR
SESSION IN ROOM TWENTY ONE
HUNDRED. SO FOR WILL BE MEETING
TWENTY MINUTES AFTER THE CAN-
INDIAN OBSESSION IN ROOM TWENTY
ONE HUNDRED IF THERE'S NO OTHER
BUSINESS INTERACTING SUGGESTS
CLEAR MISTER PRESIDENT THANK SO
MUCH COLLEAGUES- THROUGH THE
CONSENT CALENDAR IN THE
LEGISLATION WE HEARD ON THE
FLOOR TODAY WE HAVE DISPENSED
WITH A HUNDRED AND FOUR BILLS.
SO THE WORK TODAY WAS NOT
WITHOUT- A GOOD ENDING- WE GET
TO A GOOD NUMBER OF BILLS AND I
WANT TO THANK MY COLLEAGUES-
ASKED FOR THE WORK TODAY AND
OBVIOUSLY- THIS WAS JUST A TEST
TO PROVE THAT WE ALL NEED TO-
REMEMBER THE PROCEDURES WORK
WITH OUR STAFF. AND WE WILL
ALWAYS HAVE A GOOD OUTCOME- WHEN
WE DO THIS WORK TOGETHER. AND
WORK THROUGH PROBLEMS AND WITH
THAT LET ME THANK ALL THE STAFF
LET ME THANK THE PRESIDING
OFFICER LET ME THANK THE
COLLEAGUES. AND WITH THAT- WE
WILL RECONVENE TOMORROW- FRIDAY
MAY TWENTY FIFTH TWENTY TWENTY
THREE AT NINE AM. THE SENATE
WILL BE RECESSED UNTIL THREE
THIRTY PM TODAY AT WHICH TIME
THE GERMAN MOTION WILL BE MADE
WILL RECONVENE FRIDAY MAY TWENTY
SIXTH AT NINE AM.