CALL THE MEETING TO
ORDER- WE HAVE MULTIPLE
COMMITTEE HEARINGS TODAY SO A
NUMBER OF OUR MEMBERS ARE IN
JUDICIARY ANOTHER COMMITTEE
HEARING SO WE'RE GOING TO START
AS A SUBCOMMITTEE AND WAIT TILL-
WE HAVE A ACCORDING TO. CALL FOR
THE COURT SO- THE SENATE-
CONTINUES TO WELCOME PUBLIC IN
PERSON VIA THE TELECONFERENCES
THEM AS WELL FOR INDIVIDUALS
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC ON
TODAY'S- THE AGENDA THE
PARTICIPANT NUMBERS.
877-226-8163 AND THE ACCESS CODE
IS SEVEN THREE SIX. TWO EIGHT
THREE FOUR I WE'RE HOLDING OUR
COMMITTEE HEARINGS IN THE-
STREET BUILDING I ASK ALL
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE TO BE
PRESENT IN THE ROOM TWELVE
HUNDRED SO WE CAN ESTABLISH
QUORUM TO BEGIN OUR HEARING WE
HAVE SEVENTEEN GOALS ON TODAY'S
AGENDA BEFORE WE HEAR
PRESENTATIONS THAT WE CAN'T. WE
CANNOT ESTABLISH A QUORUM SO
THAT WILL NOT BE- IN ORDER- SO
WE HAVE- CENTER RAMOS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER RAMOS ASSEMBLY MEMBER
WELCOME YOU MAY PRESENT A FILE
ITEM NUMBER ONE AB. THREE FORTY
ONE.
TO GET THAT SET ASSEMBLY MEMBER
. YOU CAN BE AT THE LECTOR RIGHT
UP HERE.
WELL THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS. TODAY I MEAN I AM
PRESENTING AB THREE FORTY ONE. A
BILL THAT HAS BROUGHT TOGETHER A
WORKING GROUP CONSISTING OF CO
SPONSORS FROM CAR CLUBS AND
TRIBAL GOVERNMENTS. THIS WORKING
GROUP SET ASIDE DIFFERENCES TO
WORK ON A COMMON GOAL OF
PRESERVING JOBS ECONOMIC
VITALITY IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL WOULD
ALLOW FOR A MUTUALLY AGREED UPON
GROWTH FOR CAR CLUBS WITH
CURRENTLY TWENTY TABLES ARE LESS
WHILE CREATING A MORATORIUM TO
PROTECT THE ECONOMIC STRING OF
ECONOMIES THAT RELY ON THE
GAMING INDUSTRY. THE HARD WORK
OF COMPROMISED BY THE
COSPONSORED OF THIS BILL SHOWS
THAT WHEN SETTING ASIDE
DISAGREEMENTS. AND FOCUSING ON
AREAS OF AGREEMENT THE ART OF
GIVE AND TAKE TO REACH AGREEMENT
IS POSSIBLE. INTO THEIR
TESTAMENT TO MOVE IN ONE ACCORD
TO PRESENT A BILL OF COMPROMISE
THAT SITS IN FRONT OF YOU TODAY
. THE HARD WORK ON THIS BILL BY
THE WORKING GROUP OF THE BILL'S
CO SPONSORS THE COOLEY A BAND OF
INDIANS HAWAIIAN GARDENS MORONGO
BAND OF MISSION INDIANS COMMERCE
CASINO RECON BAND OF MISSION OF
CELESTE SEGNO INDIANS KINGS CAR
CLUB THE SALMON WELL BAND OF
MISSION INDIANS. SANTA YNEZ BAND
OF CHUMASH INDIANS IN THE SUB
BOBA BAND IN THE SEGNO INDIANS
ALL WORK TOGETHER IN ONE ACCORD
. AND THERE SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN
LIGHTLY. AND REPRESENTS A
RESPONSIBLE AND REASONABLE
APPROACH TOWARDS FUTURE GAMING
EXPANSION IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA. WITH ME TODAY TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IS CHAIRMAN
CHARLES MARTIN FROM THE MORONGO
BAND OF MISSION INDIANS ENJOY A
HARD GENERAL COUNSEL OF THE
COMMERCE CASINO AND HOTEL. GOOD
MORNING CHAIRMAN. MARTIN HOW ARE
YOU SIR GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN
DOUG GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN DODD
MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
CHARLES MARTIN NINE CHAIRMAN
WHILE THE BAND OF MISSION
INDIANS. ASSEMBLY RAMIS MEMBER
RAMOS HAS STATED I'M HERE TODAY
IS ONE OF SIX TRAVEL COSPONSORS
OF AB THREE FORTY ONE. IN
ADDITION TO OUR TRIBES MANY
OTHER TRIBES ARE ALSO IN SUPPORT
OF INCLUDING THE CALIFORNIA
NATIONS INDIAN GAMING
ASSOCIATION WHICH IS COMPRISED
OF FORTY SEVEN OF THE SEVENTY
ONE GAME IN TRACTION CALIFORNIA
AND PASSIN. OUR COALITION CAME
TOGETHER IN THE FALL OF LAST
YEAR IN ORDER TO WORK ON A
COMPRESSED COMPROMISED ON THE
REINSTATEMENT OF CALIFORNIA'S
CARDROOM MORATORIUM. MONGER
DRAFTING BEGIN CIRCULATING DRAFT
IN THE FALL WORKING WAS SEEN
AGAIN TESTED TRIBES ENSURING
THAT ALL TRIBAL MEMBERS ALL
MEMBER TRIBES. HAD AN
OPPORTUNITY FOR INPUT AND
DISCUSSION. ALL BEFORE THE
BILL'S INTRODUCTION ON JANUARY
THIRTIETH TWENTY TWENTY THREE.
YOU ALSO HEAR FROM THE CARDROOM
INDUSTRY WHO WE WORK WITH ON
CREATING THIS COMPROMISE
MEASURES. THE MORATORIUM SHOULD
NEVER HAVE EXPIRED BECAUSE IT
PROVIDED CALIFORNIA'S SENSIBLE
POLICY AS IT RELATES TO CARDROOM
EXPANSION TRAVEL EXCLUSIVITY IN
OVER SATURATING CALIFORNIA'S
GAMING MARKETS. FOR OVER TWENTY
YEARS CALIFORNIA VOTERS HAVE
CONSISTENTLY OPPOSED UNFETTERED
EXPANSION OF GAMING ACROSS
CALIFORNIA AND HAVE STOOD WITH
INDIAN TRIBES IN SUPPORT OF
GAMING. ON FEDERALLY RECOGNIZED
TRIBAL SOVEREIGN LANDS WE
BELIEVE AB THREE FORTY ONE AS A
COMPROMISE TO PROVIDES A
BALANCED BY ALLOWING MEASURE
GROWTH OF THE CARDROOM INDUSTRY.
THAT IS CONSISTENT WITH
CALIFORNIA VOTERS SUPPORT OF
TRAVEL GAME I WOULD LIKE TO
THANK YOU FOR A GIVE ME THE
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY BEFORE
YOU GENTLEMAN AND- AND LADIES-
THIS THIS AFTERNOON OR THIS
MORNING. THANK YOU. DO WE HAVE.
FOR WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A PAUSE
HERE CAN YOU CALL THE ROLL
POLICE. OBSERVED. DOT YOUR
THOUGHT HERE WILK. ALPHARETTA
GILL HERE OF ROADKILL HERE
ARCHULETA YOUR PARTIAL LETTER
HERE ASHBY. ASHBY HERE BRADFORD
GLAZER YEAH GLAZER HERE JONES.
JONES HERE WHEN A CHOI BO FOR
THE F. CARE IDEA HERE
PORTANTINO. ROTH RUBIO SEYARTO.
ZERO HERE. GREAT WE HAVE A
QUORUM. PLEASE. THANK YOU GOOD
MORNING CHAIRMAN DOTTING
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS JOY
HARM. AND IS GENERAL COUNSEL FOR
THE COMMERCE CASINO AND HOTEL I
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE
FORTY ONE THIS MORNING. EIGHTY
THREE FORTY ONE HAS ACCOMPLISHED
BUT ONLY LAST YEAR SEEMED
IMPOSSIBLE. UNIFYING TRIBES AND
CARD ROOMS TO PROTECT AGAINST AN
UNLIMITED EXPANSION OF GAMBLING
WHILE AT THE SAME TIME ALLOWING
MEASURE GROWTH FOR SMALLER CARD
ROOMS AND PROTECTING LOCAL
REVENUES THAT ARE SO CRITICAL TO
OUR HOST CITIES. IT PROVIDES
CERTAINTY FOR TRIBES AND CARD
CLUBS AND AVOIDS THE NEED TO ASK
THE LEGISLATURE TO ENACT
LEGISLATION ON THIS TOPIC EVERY
FEW YEARS. CALIFORNIA CARD ROOMS
ARE FUNDAMENTAL ASSETS IN MANY
LOCAL ECONOMIES SERVING AS THE
SINGLE LARGEST TAX SOURCE FOR
REVENUE FOR SEVERAL CITY GENERAL
FUNDS. CARBON TAX FUND EXCUSE ME
CARD ROOM TAX FUNDS ESSENTIALLY
. USE ME FUND ESSENTIAL PUBLIC
SAFETY AND HEALTH SERVICES
SENIOR NEWS SERVICES INCLUDING
MEAL AND TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS
WHILE ALSO GENERATING
SIGNIFICANT EMPLOYMENT AND
SECONDARY BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. THE
LEGISLATURE HAS AN ESTABLISHED
HISTORY OF LIMITING THE
EXPANSION OF GAMBLING WHILE
ALLOWING FOR PREDICTABLE GROWTH
OF GAMING TABLES OVER A PERIOD
OF TIME. BEGINNING IN NINETEEN
NINETY FIVE THE LEGISLATURE
ENACTED ACTED TO RESTRICT THE
EXPANSION OF EXISTING GAMES.
SINCE THAT TIME MORATORIUMS HAVE
BEEN ENACTED WITHOUT
INTERRUPTION UNTIL LAST FALL. IT
IS TIME TO PUT A MORATORIUM BACK
IN PLACE TO ENSURE THE VIABILITY
OF ALL EXISTING CARD ROOMS. THE
EXACT ECONOMIC SECURITY OF THEIR
CITIES AND TO ALLOW FOR HEALTHY
GROWTH OF OUR SMALLER CARD ROOMS
. AS IT HAS BEEN TEN YEARS SINCE
ANY INCREASE IN THE TABLE NUMBER
OF TABLES IN A LOCAL ORDINANCE
HAS BEEN PERMITTED. IT IS ALSO
TIME TO ALLOW FOR THIS MODEST
GROWTH THAT'S BEEN SET OUT IN AB
THREE FORTY ONE. WITHOUT THIS
WELL REASONED BILL GAMING
THROUGHOUT THE STATE WILL
EXPAND. EIGHTY THREE FORTY ONE
PROVIDE SECURITY TO THOSE IN THE
INDUSTRY AND IS CONSISTENT WITH
PREVIOUS LEGISLATION THAT
PERMITTED INCREMENTAL INCREASES
IN THE NUMBER OF LICENSED
TABLES. SUBJECT TO LOCAL
GOVERNMENT APPROVAL. EIGHTY
THREE FORTY ONE RECOGNIZES THAT
STABILITY IN THE GAMING INDUSTRY
IS IMPORTANT TO CARD ROOMS.
TRIBES AND LOCAL COMMUNITIES
DEPENDENT ON REVENUES AND JOBS
CREATED BY THE INDUSTRY. FOR ALL
THESE REASONS WERE PLEASED TO BE
A CO SPONSOR OF THIS IMPORTANT
LEGISLATION THANK YOU. I WOULD
HEAR FROM MANY OTHER SUPPORT
WITNESSES IN THE ROOM PLEASE
COME FORWARD. WE'RE LOOKING FOR
YOUR NAME AND ORGANIZATION AND
WHETHER USED IN YOUR SUPPORT.
MISTER CHAIRMAN RESTRAINTS
METHOD BEHALF OF ARTICHOKE JOE'S
SUPPORT. YOUR MEMBERS OF
COMMITTEE FRANK MOLINA ON BEHALF
OF THE SITE IS BAD ISSUE
MESSAGES IN SUPPORT. MY NAME IS
BEAU MAJORITY TERM OF THEIR
INCOME BATTLE SAY NEW ENGINES AS
A CO SPONSOR OF THIS BILL WE
DEFINITELY SUPPORT IT WE
DEFINITELY. WORKED HARD AND
COMPROMISE- AND HOPEFULLY AS THE
BILL MOVES FORWARD WE CAN
FINALIZE SOME DIFFERENCES WE MAY
HAVE. I WANT TO MAKE IT CLEAR TO
THE COMMITTEE. BY SUPPORTING
THIS BILL WE DO NOT CONDONE THE
ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES OF GOING OUT
BY THE CARD ROOMS AND THE FACT
THAT THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WILL
NOT ENFORCE A LAW AND WITH THAT
PART OF THE RECORD. BUT WE DO
SUPPORT THIS BILL MOVING FORWARD
THANK YOU THANK YOU CHAIRMAN.
CHARLES RIGHT ON BEHALF OF
SALMON WILL BE IN THE MISSION
INDIANS IN SUPPORT. MARIN PMB
HAVE CALIFORNIA CITY SEARCH FOR
SELF RELIANCE- INTO THE SETTINGS
OF COMPTON CUT A HEY UM HAWAIIAN
GARDENS COMMERCE IN SUPPORT
THANK. MORNING CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
NICK BROKEN BEHALF OF THE AGUA
CALIENTE BAND OF CAHUILLA
INDIANS IN SUPPORT THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MR CHAIRMAN OR SAID
MANNING KP PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF OF HAWAIIAN GARDENS
CASINO AND SPORT. SURE MEMBERS
MILOSEVIC ON BEHALF OF CRYSTAL
CASINO AND OCEAN'S ELEVEN BOTH
IN SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS PAMELA LOPEZ K.
STREET CONSULTING ON BEHALF OF
THE TULE RIVER TRIBE IN SUPPORT
. MORNING HOLLY FOR MANY THIS IS
A LIGHT HOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
BEHALF PARK WEST CASINOS IN
SUPPORT. THIS RETURN MEMBERS
MIKE FOLLOWED ON BEHALF OF CLUB
ONE CASINO IN THE DEUCE LOUNGE
CASINO IN SUPPORT THANK. GOOD
MORNING HEATHER GARENA ON BEHALF
OF SEVEN MILE CASINO AND STONES
GAMBLING HALL WE SUPPORT. GOOD
MORNING JERRY PLANNING TO BE A
CAPITAL CASINO CUSTOMER SAID
CASINO MADERA NASCENT VINE IN
SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING MR
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS BRIAN LONGER
INVOLVE PLASMA DIVISORS ON
BEHALF OF COMMUNITIES FOR
CALIFORNIA CARTOONS IN SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING SUSAN JENSEN
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
CALIFORNIA NATIONS INDIAN GAMING
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. MORNING
RESEARCHER JASON BRYANT ON
BEHALF OF PLAYERS ED SERVICES
KINGS AND WEST LANE CASINOS IN
STOCKTON THANK YOU. AND FRED
JONES ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA
COALITION AGAINST GAMBLING
EXPANSION. THANK YOU TO THOSE
WITNESSES NOW WE'RE GOING TO
MOVE TO LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING
THERE ARE THREE. ADD TOGETHER
YOU'LL GET FOUR MINUTES I'M- OF
THE UNDERSTAND DID YOU WORK THAT
OUT WHO GETS WHAT TIME SO. SOON
AS YOU START. GOOD MORNING
GERMAN DOT TO MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE. I AM HERE TODAY ARE
MY NAME IS CODY MARTINEZ AND I'M
THE TRIBAL CHAIRMAN SYCUAN BAND
OF THE COMMUNICATION SAN DIEGO
CALIFORNIA. I AM HERE TODAY TO
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE ASSEMBLY
BILL THREE FORTY ONE IN ITS
CURRENT FORM ON THE OFFICE OF
QUAN. I THINK WOULD BE HELPFUL
FOR THE COMMITTEE TO UNDERSTAND
WHY SAQUON CHANGE FROM SUPPORT
IF AMENDED TO AN OPPOSE UNLESS
AMENDED POSITION ON THIS BILL.
EARLY IN THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS
A QUORUM WAS ASKED TO REVIEW
DRAFT LANGUAGE FOR A. B. THIRTY
ONE ONCE REVIEWED OUR TRIBAL
COUNCIL VOTED TO SUPPORT THE
LANGUAGE. HOWEVER THE LANGUAGE
THE LEADER CAME OUT OF THE
LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL WAS
DIFFERENT THAN THE WORK PRODUCT
THAT WE WERE ASKED TO REVIEW.
FROM THE TRIBAL CARD ROOM WORK
GROUP. THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE
STATED THIS ORDER SHALL ONLY
APPLY TO A GAMBLING
ESTABLISHMENT THE OPERATE FEWER
THAN TWENTY GAMING TABLES. ONCE
THIS LANGUAGE RETURN IN BILL
FORM IT READ. THIS ORDINANCE
SHALL ONLY APPLY TO GAMING
ESTABLISHMENTS THAT OPERATE
TWENTY OR FEWER GAMING TABLES.
THIS SMALL BUT EXTREMELY
IMPORTANT CHANGE WILL ALLOW ONE
CAR CLUB. OWNER THAT HAS
INTEREST IN MULTIPLE CARD ROOMS.
TO EXPAND IN OUR BACKYARD. I AM
SOMEWHAT CONFUSED BECAUSE THE
INTENT OF THIS MORATORIUM IS TO
EXPAND SMALL CARD CLUBS CARD
CLUBS. ALLOW FOR MODEST GROWTH.
HOWEVER IT SEEMS TO ME THAT THIS
LEGISLATION OPENS THE DOOR TO
EXPANSION THAT IS NOT CONSISTENT
WITH THE INTENT OF THIS
LEGISLATION. I HAVE COMMUNICATED
OUR CONCERNS TO THE AUTHOR. AND
ASKED THAT THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE
REVERT TO THE ORIGINAL VERSION.
THE CURRENTLY WOULD REVERT TO
THE ORIGINAL VERSION EXCUSE ME.
HOWEVER THE CHAIR EXPRESS LAST
MONDAY THAT HE WILL NOT ALLOW
ANY AMENDMENTS TO AB THREE FORTY
ONE. WHICH TO THIS THE QUAN
TRIBE SEEMS TO IMPEDE THE
LEGISLATIVE PROCESS. WE HAVE
BEEN TOLD THAT TRUCK THAT TRIED
TO CAR ROOM TYPES CONCERNS WITH
A PROPOSED AMENDMENT. HOWEVER I
HAVE NEVER HEARD FROM A SINGLE
TREIBER CARBON THAT THEY OPPOSE
A PROPOSED AMENDMENT. IN FACT
EVERY SINGLE TRIED BUT I
PERSONALLY SPOKEN WITH HAVE BEEN
NOTHING BUT SUPPORTIVE OF OUR
EFFORTS. THE SO CALLED TRIBE
HAVE BEEN HONEST BROKERS WILL
CONTINUE TO DO SO BECAUSE THAT
IS WHO WE ARE AS A TRIBE. I
APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE'S TIME
AND THE OPPORTUNITY TO SURE IT'S
A QUALITY CONCERNS WITH YOU. I
LOOK FORWARD TO AN HONEST AND
OPEN DIALOGUE GOING FORWARD ON
THIS BILL. THANK YOU THANK YOU
MR CHAIRMAN. NEXT YOU'VE GOT
ABOUT A MINUTE AND A HALF FOR
BOTH OF YOU THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE MY NAME IS DUSTIN
MURRAY AND I AM THE TITLE
MINISTRY TO FOR THE SHINGLE
SPRINGS BAND OF MIWOK INDIANS WE
ARE OPPOSED AB THREE FOR ONE FOR
TWO PRIMARY REASONS. FIRST THE
DEFINITION OF A SMALL CARD CLUBS
ENTIRELY TOO BROAD IN CREATES
THE GREATEST EXPANSION CARD IN
GAMING CALIFORNIA HISTORY SECOND
THE NUMBER OF CARD ROOMS WITH
TWENTY TABLES ARE LESS ARE
HIGHLY CONCENTRATED. IN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA DIRECTLY AND DIRECTLY
IMPACTING THE CUSTOMER BASE RED
HAWK CASINO FOR THOSE REASONS I
URGE A NO VOTE THANK YOU. THANK
YOU. ACCORDING A GOOD MORNING
CHAIRMAN DON COMMITTEE MEMBERS
MY NAME'S JEFF BUTLER- APARTMENT
THE DENTONS LAW FIRM AND
REPRESENTED YOUR CHEEKY BAND
WINTUN INDIANS- I HAVE TWO
ISSUES TO RAISE A FORCES. AB
THREE FORTY ONES CARVE OUT FOR
THE SAN JOSE CARD ROOMS- AND THE
SECOND IS. ILLEGAL GAMING. THE
AB THREE FOR YOUR CARVE OUT FOR
THE SAN JOSE CARP ROOMS. IS NOT
PROPER. THE CARD IS ALREADY HAVE
. FORTY NINE TABLES EACH. AND IT
CARVE OUT LAWS AND TO GET
FIFTEEN. TABLES THIS IS
CONSISTENTLY CONSISTENT WITH THE
WHOLE PURPOSE OF AB THREE FORTY
ONE THE STATE. AND SECOND THEY
ARE YOU MIGHT SAY WHO CARES
BECAUSE THE CARD WAS PLAYED
LEGAL GAMES. BUT THEY DON'T
REALLY. BOB AND THIS IS NOT JUST
THE TRIBE'S OPINIONS. THE STATE
ATTORNEY GENERAL. RUNS THE
BUREAU OF GAMBLING CONTROL AND
APPEAR AGAIN CONTROL HAS
CONCLUDED. THAT THE CARD ROOMS.
PLAY BLACK JACK WHICH IS
ILLEGAL. AND THAT THE CARD
ROOMS. ALSO DO NOT ROTATE THE
PLAYER DEALER POSITION. WHICH IS
SOMETHING THAT IT MUST DO UNDER.
CALIFORNIA LAW. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU AS WELL. OKAY NOW- WE'RE
GONNA MOVE ON TO. THOSE IN THE
ROOM THAT ARE OPPOSED PLEASE
CAME COME UP AND- STATE YOUR
NAME ORGANIZATION. AND
OPPOSITION. MISTER CHAIRMAN-
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE PUBLIC
TREAT ON BEHALF OF PECHANGA BAND
OF INDIANS AND THE CALUSA
INDIANS- WE'RE TWEETERS SO WE
THINK THE MORATORIUM NEEDS TO GO
BACK ON BUT WE DEFINITELY KNOW
AND SUPPORT THE AMENDMENTS ARE
BEING ASKED FOR. THE BODY ELSE.
OKAY THANK YOU NOW WILL- MOVE ON
TO WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY
VIA THE TELECONFERENCE ORVIS-
THIS INCLUDES ANYONE EITHER
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION. REMINDERS
STATE YOUR NAME AFFILIATION A
POSITION ONLY- I'M LIMITING THE
ME TOOS TO A TOTAL OF TEN. TEN
MINUTES I'M NOT SURE WE'RE GONNA
HAVE THAT MUCH BUT- MODERATOR IF
YOU COULD PLEASE PROP THE
INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION OF AB
THREE FORTY ONE. FEEL FREE TO
OPEN UP THE LINES AND CALL THE
WITNESSES INDIVIDUALLY. THANK
YOU IF YOU'D LIKE TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION OF THIS
BILL IS PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO
AT THIS TIME. IN ONE MOMENT IS
TAKING A SECOND HERE TO QUEUE UP
ONCE AGAIN PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
THEN ZERO. WE DO HAVE A FEW ONE
MOMENT. AND THE FIRST WILL GO TO
OUR ALLY NUMBER. THIRTEEN LINE
THIRTEEN YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
PLEASE ADD ME TO YOUR PHONE OR
PICK UP YOUR HANDSET. WILL MOVE
ON LINE TWELVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN
. BY TWELVE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
WILL MOVE ON. WE'LL GO TO LINE
NUMBER. MY NUMBER. NINE BY
NUMBER NINE YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
LIE NUMBER NINE YOUR LINE IS
OPEN. I'M SORRY WILL MOVE ON
THERE ARE NO OTHERS IN QUEUE AT
THIS TIME. IN MMHM. WHAT WE
DIDN'T JUST FOR FAIRNESS COULD
YOU JUST CALL ONE MORE TIME
OPERATOR- AND LET'S LET'S SEE IF
YEAH PLEASE PLEASE QUEUE UP
AGAIN WHY MEMBERS IF YOU WANT TO
SPEAK IN. OPPOSITION OR SUPPORT
FOR THIS BILL PLEASE PRESS ONE
AND THEN ZERO. I WILL OPEN YOUR
LINES AND ANNOUNCE YOUR NUMBERS
. OKAY SO ONE MOMENT. WE GOT A
FEW EXTRAS THIS TIME. WHAT THE
HELL WHY NUMBER TWELVE. YES THIS
IS MARK ENGLISH WITH FIVE
HUNDRED FOLKS YOU KNOW CLOVIS
SUPPORT. THANK YOU FOR GOING
NEXT JULY NUMBER THIRTEEN. YES
BNC LIMELIGHT CARDROOM CAL PROP
SERVICES IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
WE'LL GO NEXT JULY NUMBER.
PATTON. JOHN MY NUMBER TEN YOUR
LINE IS OPEN. FILER ON BEHALF OF
THE BOARD YOU KNOW IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU WE'LL GO NEXT JULY
NUMBER NINE. CLARK ROSA CAPITAL
GOOD SEEING ALL MADE TO. THANK
YOU L. AND LAST WILL COLLIDE
NUMBER NINETEEN. GOD CONSTAND
THE- YOU KNOW LUCKY LADY CASINO
IN SUPPORT OF AB THREE FORTY ONE
. THANK YOU AND MAKE SURE WE
HAVE NO FURTHER IN QUEUE AT THIS
TIME I THANK YOU PROJECT THE-
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION WITNESSES
WILL NOW BRING IT BACK FOR
DISCUSSION FOR MEMBERS. SURVEYS
ARE FOR. GREAT THANK YOU I'M-
ASSEMBLY MEMBER THANK YOU FOR
ALL THE WORK THAT YOU'VE DONE IN
THIS BASIS IS NOT AN EASY THING
TO NEGOTIATE- AND- I KNOW THAT-
YOU PUT IN A LOT OF TIME AND
COULD WORK TO TRY TO FIND THIS
SWEET SPOT THAT'S THE THAT'S THE
BILL THAT'S BEFORE US TODAY. I
KNOW THAT- THE- CERTAINLY A
BRIGHT LINE FOR ME I'M SURE FOR
YOU IS THIS EXCLUSIVITY OF
GAMING TRIBAL GAMING THAT WAS-
ENACTED IN OUR STATE
CONSTITUTION A FEW DECADES AGO
NOW IT SEEMS BUT- AND I KNOW FOR
ME IT'S A BRIGHT LINE BECAUSE
EVERY BILL THAT THAT TOUCHES THE
SPACES KIND OF EVALUATED IN
THAT. PLACE OF EXCLUSIVITY THAT
PROTECTION OF THE OF THE TRIBAL
GAMING OPTIONS THAT ARE IN OUR
CONTACTS- SO ONE OF THE CONCERNS
THAT HAS BEEN RAISED NOT JUST IN
THIS BILL BUT OVER TIME IT'S
BEEN THIS ISSUE AT THE GALLERY
OF THE GAMES. I WONDER IF YOU
COULD SPEAK TO. THE ISSUE OF THE
LEGALITY OF THE GAMES THAT ARE
CURRENTLY BEING PLAYED AND WOOD
ANYTHING IN THIS LEGISLATION-
RESTRICT- WERE LIMITED ANYWAY
THE CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN.
RAISED ABOUT THE LEGALITY OF
GAMES. CERTAINLY THIS BILL DEALS
STRICTLY WITH THE MORATORIUM
MORE TORMENT TWENTY YEARS. IT
ALLOWS MODEST SOME GROWTH FROM
CAR CLUBS- TO MOVE FORWARD OVER
THAT TWENTY YEAR PERIOD.
CURRENTLY TWENTY TABLES OR LESS
COULD EXPAND BY TEN TABLES THIS
DEALS WITH THAT COMPONENT OF IT
WITH A MORATORIUM THAT EXPIRED
LAST YEAR. THE QUESTION AS FAR
AS THE LEGALITY OF THE GAMES
BEING PLAYED HAS BEEN- LOOKED AT
BY DIFFERENT ATTORNEY GENERAL'S
BUT NO RULING IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA HAS DEEMED THEM
ILLEGAL TO THIS POINT. IF THEY
WERE DEEMED ILLEGAL WE WOULD BE
PUTTING THAT INSIDE THE BILL BUT
CURRENTLY IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA THERE IS NO- THE
GALLERY- SAY THAT THESE GAMES
ARE ILLEGAL AT THIS POINT. WHICH
HAS BEEN GOING ON THE DEBATE HAS
BEEN GOING ON FOR WELL OVER
FIFTEEN YEARS. SO WE WANT TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE SET THE
MORATORIUM. THAT WE CONTINUE TO
WORK WITH- CAR CLUBS AND FIVE
TRIBAL GROUPS TO ENSURE. THAT
MODEST GROWTH AND ALSO TO
PROTECT THE ECONOMY IN THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. DID YOU HAVE ANY
OPINION ABOUT- WHY THAT THAT
ISSUE HASN'T BEEN SETTLED- THAT
WHITES STILL HANG YOU KNOW. IT'S
A IT'S A IT'S A- IT'S A WOMAN
THAT HASN'T BEEN RESOLVED OVER
ALL THESE YEARS ANY ANY OPINIONS
ABOUT WHY- IT HASN'T BEEN. TAKEN
CARE OF WITH THAT THE GAMES ARE
CLEAREST WHO CAN PLAY WHAT AND
WHERE. I THINK THAT OPINION IS
BETTER- RESTING WITH ATTORNEY
GENERAL IN THE GAMBLING CONTROL
COMMISSION. DO YOU HAVE ANY
THOUGHTS ABOUT THE CONCERNS
THAT'S THE SAQUON CHAIR HAS
RAISED IN REGARDS TO THAT THE
NUMBER. CERTAINLY CHAIRMAN
CODY'S BEEN A GOOD FRIEND OF
MINE AND CONTINUES TO BE A GOOD
FRIEND WE HAVE A OF UP MOST
RESPECT FORM. WILL CONTINUE TO-
DISCUSS THOSE COMPONENTS. DO YOU
FEEL THAT HIS CONCERNS ARE AB
MERIT THAT THAT THE NUMBER
SHOULD BE. LESS THAN TWENTY
VERSUS TWENTY OR MORE. I THINK
THAT THE DISCUSSION CONTINUES TO
BE- FURTHER ALONG THE PROCESS
AND WE'RE OPEN TO LOOK AT- THOSE
ISSUES MOVING FORWARD. THANK YOU
AND JUST IN CLOSING I WANT TO
JUST. ACKNOWLEDGE THE HARD WORK
OF CHAIR DIED- IN THIS WHOLE.
EFFORTS I KNOW THAT- ENGAGEMENT
LAST YEAR WAS DIFFICULT FOR
EVERYONE CERTAINLY THAT SHARE OF
OUR COMMITTEE HERE TODAY. BUT I
JUST WANT TO PUT ON THE RECORD
BY RESPECT FOR. HIS EFFORTS IN
DIFFICULT CIRCUMSTANCES SO I
REALLY APPRECIATE THAT AND I
KNOW IT HASN'T BEEN EASY. BUT I
KNOW IT HAS LAID THE FOUNDATION
FOR THE WORK THAT JUST. THAT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER RAMOS IS BROUGHT
TO US TODAY AND I THANK YOU FOR
THAT. EXTENDER SO THERE ARE TWO
ONE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
SOMEBODY MEMBER- I APPRECIATE
YOUR LEADERSHIP IN YOUR
COMMUNITY AND CERTAINLY. WITH
THIS BILL THIS COMPROMISES HIS-
I WISH YOU HAD YOUR NAME ON IT
FOR YEARS PASS AND YOU DIDN'T
EVEN KNOW IT AND IT TOOK YOU AND
SENATOR DODD TO COME TOGETHER
AND- ALONG WITH OTHER MEMBERS.
THAT IT FINALLY REACHES
COMPROMISE AND I'M SO GLAD- IN
MY DISTRICT WE HAVE CASINOS
THAT- CARD CLUBS AND WE SO
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'VE DONE YOUR
HARD WORK AND- WHEN IT'S
APPROPRIATE ALL DOG TO MOVE THE
BILL. THANK YOU. SIR PORTANTINO
. YEAH I JUST OBVIOUSLY ONE ECHO
THE SENTIMENTS OF THE HARD WORK
THAT- THE AUTHOR AND THE
CHAIRMAN PUTTING INTO THIS
CONVERSATION IT'S- IT'S A
DIFFICULT. PLACE TO HAVE THIS
CONVERSATION AND IT'S- YOU KNOW
OBVIOUSLY LONG STANDING ISSUES-
WITH. LOTS OF TRADITION AND LOTS
OF- DISCUSSION AND SO. I
APPRECIATE THE CHAIR ACTION ME
THAT THE AUTHOR REFERENCING
ONGOING CONVERSATIONS. AND MR
CHURCH MY EX BUT MY
UNDERSTANDING IS THAT. THOSE
CONVERSATIONS ARE GOING TO
CONTINUE WITH THE BILL GETS OUT
TODAY AND- THEIR- AND SO- JUST
WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT- MY
UNDERSTANDING IS CORRECT. RIGHT
ALL RIGHT THANK YOU CENTER JONES
. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN I
AND I JUST WANTED TO KIND
UNDERSCORE SOME CONCERNS. THAT I
SHARE WITH US INNER GLAZIER- YOU
KNOW MORE SPECIFICALLY MISTER
BUTLER- EMISSIONS AND THINGS-
SPECIFICALLY. CONSIDERING THE
CONSTITUTIONALITY OF SOME OF THE
GAMES ARE BEING PLAYED. AT THE
CARD ROOMS AND- YOU KNOW WE'VE
GOT TO GET AND I KNOW THAT AND I
APPRECIATE YOUR EXPLANATION ON
THIS BILL THAT'S NOT. BEING
ADDRESSED ON SPECIFICALLY IN
THIS BILL BUT AT SOME POINT TIME
YOU KNOW WE'VE GOT TO MAKE SURE
THAT THE- THE PLAYING. FIELD NO
PUN INTENDED. I IS FAIR AND
UNDERSTOOD- AND I DON'T I DON'T
YOU KNOW SITTING HERE I DON'T
KNOW WHAT THAT WHAT WHAT'S GONNA
TAKE TO GET TO THAT POINT I KNOW
THAT THIS BILL STRIKES AT SOME
VERY IMPORTANT CORE. PRINCIPLES
FOR ME ONE YOU KNOW BEING A FREE
MARKET- PROPONENT. BUT ALSO
BALANCING THAT AGAINST CURRENT
STATE LAW AND CUT IN
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW AND THE RULE
OF LAW- YOU KNOW I DIDN'T.
DECIDING WHAT WHO GETS TO PLAY A
GAME SO YOU KNOW THAT'S THAT'S
KIND OF WHERE I'M AT ON THIS-
YOU KNOW REGARDING SPECIFICALLY
THE CONCERNS RAISED ON THAT THE
NUMBER OF. OF TABLES- I
APPRECIATE THE CHAIR OF
APPROPRIATIONS BRING THAT POINT
UP I APPRECIATE THAT- CHAIR DODD
BRINGING THAT UP I THINK TODAY
I'LL PROBABLY LAY OFF AND SEE.
WHAT HAPPENS BETWEEN HERE AND
APPROPRIATIONS SINCE I'M- ON
APPROPRIATIONS. BUT LOOK FORWARD
IN GENERAL CONCEPT OF THE BILL
I'M SUPPORTIVE I'M JUST HOPING
THAT WE GET THOSE FINAL COUPLE
THINGS WORKED OUT. NOPE SIR
COULD. LOCAL GOVERNMENT THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MR CHAIRMAN I
APPRECIATE THE WORK OF THE
AUTHOR AND APPRECIATE THE
REASSURANCE THAT THE DIALOGUE OF
COURSE WILL WILL CONTINUE. I AM
HAPPY THE TO THE TIME'S
APPROPRIATE TO BE IN SUPPORT OF
MOVING THE BILL FOR BUT I WILL.
JUST PUT A COUPLE COMMENTS IN
FIRST I MEAN THE WHOLE REASON
WE'RE HERE ON THE PREMISES TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE. AN
UNINTENDED SATURATION- THAT- IT
DOESN'T DILUTE WHAT WE'RE
LOOKING AT IN TERMS OF THE
DEMAND ON THE DEMAND SIDE OF THE
MARKET FRANKLY. AND RESPECT THE
LEGAL CONSTRUCT BOTH
CONSTITUTIONALLY AND WHAT THE
LEGISLATURE'S DONE IN RECENT
YEARS. AND THEN THE WHOLE DEBATE
IT SEEMS TO ME ABOUT YOU KNOW
THE DATA AT WHAT POINT IS THAT
TIP IN THE WRONG DIRECTION.
RIGHT NOW THE SIZE OF THE
OPERATIONS A NUMBER OF TABLES
AND THEN THE LEVEL OF GROWTH
THAT WE'RE GONNA PERMIT IN THE
COMING DECADE. I HAVEN'T SEEN
ANYTHING YET THAT SEEMS TO
CONVINCE ME BASED ON THAT SOME
KIND OF CLEAR ANALYSIS. THAT THE
DISCERNMENT BETWEEN THE NINETEEN
THRESHOLD IN TWENTY THRESHOLD IS
GOING TO TIP IT ONE WAY OR THE
OTHER THAT ULTIMATELY IN THE
NET. IS GONNA DISRUPT THAT
BALANCE AND THEN DISRUPT THE
WHOLE STATUTORY PREMISE OF THE
POLICY. WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO
ACHIEVE HERE- INTERESTED TO SEE
SOME OF THAT DATA FRANKLY. ALSO
JUST WANNA PUT IN THE RECORD
THAT- SOME OF THE FOLKS ARE
DIRECTLY AFFECTED BY THIS- AND-
IN SUPPORT OF IT ARE IN MY
DISTRICT AND EMPLOY FOLKS SAID
LEVEL WAGES AND ARE POSITIVE.
CONTRIBUTORS TO MY COMMUNITY SO
I'M HAPPY TO BE IN SUPPORT OF
LIVING FOR BUT ALSO. I DON'T
WANT TO CONTINUE TO ENCOURAGE
PARTIES TO GET CREATIVE TO
ADDRESS. NOT NECESSARILY MAYBE
THE NUMBER BUT THE UNDERLYING
DYNAMIC THAT EVERYONE SEEMS TO
BE MAKING ASSERTIONS ABOUT. SOME
OF WHICH FRANKLY I HAVEN'T
EITHER BEEN APPROACHED BY FOLKS
AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN- AND I
HAVEN'T SEEN ANY DATA THAT SEEMS
TO PROVE THOSE ASSERTIONS OUT IT
WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL. WE'RE
GONNA HAVE A DEBATE- TO HAVE
SOME DATA SEEMS TO BACK THAT UP.
AND I KNOW THE SOME OF THE
OPPOSITION FOLKS WHO ARE HERE
I'M HAPPY TO GET EDUCATED ABOUT
THAT BUT I'M DISAPPOINTED- THAT
THAT WORK HASN'T BEEN DONE. IN
SO WHERE WE ARE HERE MISTER
CHAIRMAN I'M HAPPY TO BE IN
SUPPORT OF MOVING THE BILL
FORWARD AT THE RIGHT TIME. THANK
YOU. THE BILL. THE CENTER OF OUR
LEGAL. THANK YOU CHAIR. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER RAMOS M. YOU KNOW I HOLD
YOU IN HIGH ESTEEM. AND I WAS
SURPRISED TO SEE THIS BILL COME
TO US SO EARLY- AND ADDED SOME-
RESEARCH ON MY OWN- I TO SHARE
CENTER PATILLAS- THOUGHTS THAT.
YOU KNOW I. SEE THAT THE LIST OF
OPPOSITION I MEAN THESE THESE
ARE TRIBES THAT ARE RIGHT IN MY
BACKYARD AND I WOULD HAVE WANTED
THAT. DIRECT CONVERSATION WITH
ME AS WELL- BECAUSE I KNOW THE-
PURPOSE AND I KNOW THAT THE
STRENGTH THAT OUR TRIBAL
COMMUNITY BRINGS- TO MY
DISTRICT. AND PARTLY FOR ME
REPRESENTING THIRTEEN COUNTIES-
I'M BOUND TO HAVE. LEGISLATION
IN FRONT OF ME WHERE I HAVE TO
MAKE TOUGH DECISIONS AND THIS IS
ONE OF THOSE THIS IS ONE THAT I
HAVE TRIBES ON BOTH SIDES OF
SUPPORT. AND OF OPPOSITION- AND
NEITHER SIDE HAD CONVERSATIONS
WITH ME AS WELL- SO IRATE. I AM
ACTUALLY IN A LAYOFF THIS BILL-
AND ENCOURAGE MY- MY DISTRICT
REPRESENTATIVES IN BOTH
OPPOSITION AND SUPPORT. AND TO
HAVE THOSE CONVERSATIONS WITH
ME- SO IF THIS BILL WERE TO MOVE
OUT OF THIS COMMITTEE- IN ORDER
FOR ME TO ALSO BE EDUCATED. HAVE
THOSE CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
SPECIFIC CONCERNS- BUT I THINK
THAT'S GONNA BE MY BEST POSITION
TO SHOW RESPECT- FOR ALL THE-
TROUBLE- TRIBES AND CARDS IN MY
DISTRICT. SEEING THAT NOBODY
ELSE- ASSEMBLY MEMBER MEMBER
ALMOST WOULD YOU LIKE CLOSE
PLEASE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTIONS IN
THIS IS TRULY- COMPROMISE- THAT
HAS COME TOGETHER WE'VE BEEN
ABLE TO PUT. PEOPLE TOGETHER IN
THE SAME ROOM FOR OVER A YEAR.
TO DISCUSS THESE ISSUES THAT
HAVEN'T TRADITIONALLY SAT DOWN.
WITH EACH OTHER FOR OVER THIRTY
YEARS SO THIS IS TRULY A BILL
THAT HAS BEEN WORKED UPON- AND
AT THE END OF SESSION LAST YEAR
I PRESENTED A BILL ON THE
ASSEMBLY SIDE. THAT WOULD HAVE
GRANTED A ONE YEAR EXTENSION TO
THE MORATORIUM THAT WOULD HAVE
BEEN ABLE TO HAVE THIS DIALOGUE
MOVE FORWARD. AND WHAT'S IN
FRONT OF YOU- TODAY IS THE
RESULT OF THAT OF THAT
COMPROMISE IN THAT DISCUSSION
THAT HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR OVER
A YEAR. PRESENTATIONS WERE MADE
ON BEHALF OF THE SPONSORS TO SEE
NIAGARA WHICH IS THE LARGEST-
ASSOCIATION OF TRIBES AND THEY
SUPPORTED IT VOTED TO SUPPORT
TACIT- AGAIN PRESENT THEY VOTED
TO SUPPORT. ON THE CAR CLUB SIDE
YOU SEEN THE MANY THAT STOOD UP
TO SUPPORT. NOW IN THE ART OF
COMPROMISE IT'S NOT A 100% HERE
IN A 100% HERE. WE'RE PROBABLY
AT ABOUT 90% AND 90% AND THAT
SHOWS THAT THE WORK THAT WAS PUT
TOGETHER. IT WAS FRUITFUL AND
VOICES WERE HEARD. WE DO HEAR
THE CONCERNS OF THOSE THAT STOOD
UP AND SPOKE AND WE- ACKNOWLEDGE
THAT AND WE WILL CONTINUE TO
FURTHER- THE DIALOGUE. ON THOSE
ISSUES. THE WORK IN FRONT OF YOU
IS THE RESULT OF THAT HARD WORK
THAT HAS TAKEN PLACE OVER THE
YEAR AND REALLY- OVER THIRTY
YEARS ON THESE AREAS- SO THE ART
OF COMPROMISE. IS BY NATURE. AN
ACTIVE GIVEN TAKE AND THAT'S
EXACTLY WHAT THIS BILL DOES IN
FRONT OF YOU. IS THE COMPROMISE
THAT WAS WORKED OUT BETWEEN
THOSE PARTIES FROM THE CAR CLUBS
IN THE TRIBES TO WORK TO A
COMPROMISE OF WHERE WE'RE AT
TODAY. FOR OVER THIRTY YEARS
WE'VE BEEN TRYING TO GET PEOPLE
TOGETHER TO TALK ABOUT THESE
ISSUES WHAT STANDS IN FRONT OF
YOU TODAY- WITHIN- THIS BILL. IS
THAT ARE A COMPROMISE I ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE TO MOVE THIS BILL
FORWARD SO WE COULD CONTINUE THE
DIALOGUE MOVING FORWARD. I WOULD
ASK FOR YOUR I. BOATS. THANK YOU
SIMPLY MEMBER. I HAD THIS BILL
BEEN MOVED BY CENTER ARE TO LET
OF THE MOTION IS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
GOD I THOUGHT I WILL CRY WILK I
EL DORADO GIL ARCHULETA ALL
RIGHT ARCHULETA ASHBY. ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD. ADVERTISED GLAZER AYE
GLAZER AYE JONES WHEN. OTOBO VIA
I HAVE THE AYE PORTANTINO WITH
THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THE
CONVERSATION WILL CONTINUE IN
THE MOTION WAS IT WAS TO PASS TO
THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE SO
EXPECT THOSE CONVERSATIONS TO
TAKE PLACE. BEFORE IT GETS TO MY
COMMITTEE THANK YOU. I
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH. ROTH AYE
RUBIO. SEYARTO. NINE NINE THE
LAST NIGHT VOTES THAT. BUT WE'LL
PUT THAT ALL CALL FOR ABSENT.
ABSENT MEMBERS WE'RE NOW GOING
TO MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWO. SB. EIGHTEEN YEAH WE'LL DO
THE CONCERT YOU MIGHT MISS.
WE'RE GONNA MOVE TO THE- CONSENT
. ITEMS THIS INCLUDES FILE ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN SB SEVEN NINETY TWO
FILE ITEM NUMBER TEN SB THREE
FORTY SIX. FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWELVE SB EIGHT FORTY FOUR FILE
ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN SB SEVEN
SEVEN ONE FILE ITEM NUMBER
SEVENTEEN S. B. EIGHT EIGHT FOUR
WE HAVE A MOTION ON THE
CALIFORNIA MOTOR DID YOU SAY.
FILE ITEM SEVEN IS ALSO ON
CONSENT. YES I DID OKAY THANK
YOU. MOTION MOTION BY CENTER
ARCHULETA SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL IN THE CONSENT CALENDAR
DODD I THOUGHT I WILL ALL RIGHT
WILK I EL DORADO GIL. ELDORADO
GIL I. AYE ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER AYE GLAZER AYE JONES HI.
I WENT. WHEN I- CHILL ABOUT.
IDEA FOR THE AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH ROTH AYE
RUBIO SEYARTO. EROEI THE BILL
HAS THIRTEEN VOTES WILL PLACE
THAT ALL CALL. OKAY WE'RE GONNA
MOVED OUT OF FILE ITEM NUMBER
TWO SB EIGHTEEN CENTER REQUIRE
GOOD MORNING. HEY GOOD MORNING
MISTER CHAIR IT'S REALLY GOOD TO
SEE YOU IN PERSON FROM US AS
CHAIRMAN SAY THANK YOU- ALONG
WITH YOUR COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
ALL YOUR WORK ON THIS BILL I
ALSO WANT TO THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIR FOR YOUR CO AUTHORSHIP- WE
ARE A PARTNER IN SO MANY WAYS
BOTH. AT HOME AND ON THIS AND
I'M TRULY HONORED TO BE A GUY I
WORK WITH YOU ON THIS THAT'S
ONCE HE THINK YOU TO TRIBAL
LEADERS IN ADVOCATES WHO'VE BEEN
WORKING WITH US ON THIS CRITICAL
BILL. MISTER CHAIR HERE THE
FACTS YET AMERICANS IN
CALIFORNIA ARE
DISPROPORTIONATELY REPRESENTED
AMONG THE STATE'S HOMELESS
POPULATION IN AT HIGHER RATES OF
POVERTY OVERCROWDING AND
SUBSTANDARD HOMES MORE THAN ANY
OTHER POPULATION IN THE GOLDEN
STATE. THE RATES OF TRAVEL
PROPERTY PROPERTIES MORE THAN
TWICE THAT OF THE REST OF
CALIFORNIA'S POPULATION IN
ACCORDING TO CENSUS DATA
APPROXIMATELY 9% OF TRIBES HAVE
HOMES THAT LACK COMPLETE
PLUMBING IN 7% BLACK KITCHENS.
HOMELESSNESS AMONG INDIGENOUS
RESIDENTS UP TO DOUBLE THAT OF
THE GENERAL POPULATION AND
DESPITE THE CLEAR NEED THE
OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF TRIBES
ARE UNABLE TO ACCESS EXISTING
HOUSING PROGRAMS THROUGH THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA BECAUSE THE
CONFLICT THE TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY.
LAWS AND CULTURE THEY ALSO ARE
OFTEN TOO RESTRICTIVE FOR TRIBES
TO MEET THRESHOLD AND COMPLIANCE
REQUIREMENTS AND THEIR
MISMATCHED TO MEET THE NEEDS.
THAT ARE UNIQUE TO TRIBAL LANDS
IN EVEN WHEN THERE IS DEDICATED
MONEY FOR TRIBES WITHIN. THE
STATE IT OFTEN GOES UNSPENT IN
TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN AN EFFORT
TO BETTER ADDRESS THIS ASSEMBLY
BILL WAS PASSED WHICH WERE GREAT
BEFORE ASSEMBLY BILL TEN TEN.
THAT ALLOW TRIBES ELIGIBILITY
FOR MOST OF THE STATE'S HOUSING
PROGRAMS SINCE THAT BILL PASSED
ONLY THIRTEEN. THIRTEEN OF A
HUNDRED NINE TRIBES. HAVE BEEN
AWARDED STATE FUNDS. THIS IS AN
EX. IN WHAT WE KNOW. IS THAT THE
CURRENT STATE PROGRAMS DON'T FIT
THE UNIQUE NEEDS OF TRIBAL
COMMUNITIES THAT'S WHY WE'RE
HERE AT TO ADDRESS THE
CHALLENGES BY CREATING A NEW IN
SEPARATE HOUSING PROGRAM FOR
TRIBES SPECIFIC TO TRIBAL LANDS.
WHICH WILL BE CREATED IN
CONCENTRATE INC IN CONSULTATION
WITH TRIBAL LEADERS AND TAILORED
TO THE NEEDS OF CALIFORNIA'S
TRIBAL COMMUNITIES. IT'S REALLY
SIMILAR TO WHAT WE ARE WE SEE
WITH THE JOE SRNA FIND AT THAT
IS FOCUSED ON FARMWORKER HOUSING
WE'VE ALSO TAKEN A SIMILAR
APPROACH TO THIS IN OTHER POLICY
AREAS SO THERE IS NOW. A SENT A
SEPARATE POT OF FUNDS FOR FORCE
HEALTH IN WILDFIRE FIREFIGHTING
WITH TRIBAL COMMUNITIES THE BILL
WILL SUPPORT THE CONSTRUCTION OF
NEW HOMES AND RENOVATION OF
EXISTING ONES. SIMPLY PUT S. B.
EIGHTEEN IS A HOUSING PROGRAM
DESIGNED BY TRIBES FOR TRIBES I
HAVE WITH US TODAY MISS MCGILL
WHOSE A GRANTS ANALYSTS FROM THE
NORTHERN CIRCLE INDIAN HOUSING
AUTHORITY WANT TO THANK HER. FOR
HER WORK ALONG WITH MISS BROWN
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
HOUSING FOR THE WILTON
RANCHERIA. AT MISTER CHAIR WOULD
RESPECTFULLY. ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE AN APPROPRIATE TIME. THANK
YOU SENATOR- SO WILL MOVE UNDER
LEAD WOULDN'T IN SUPPORT PLEASE
. HI GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS
LEON BROWN. I AM OF MY HOBBY AND
WE WALKED DESCENT I AM A MEMBER
OF THE TWENTY BAD TO ME WALK
INDIANS. I AM THE EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR FOR WILTON RANCHERIA I
AM THANK YOU- SENATORS FOR YOUR
TIME THIS MORNING AND MISTER
MCGUIRE THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING
US IN SUPPORTING THIS BILL. AND
GETTING US HERE SO. I AM JUST A
FEW THINGS- NATIVE AMERICAN
TRIBES AND AREAS HAVE- SOME OF
THE WORST HOUSING IN THE UNITED
STATES. ACROSS THE UNITED STATES
CALIFORNIA- THE TRIBES ARE
PUSHED UP IN THE HILLS AND THE
MOUNTAINS ALONG THE COAST I'M
RUNNING WATER IS ISSUE.
INFRASTRUCTURE IS ANOTHER ISSUE
THAT WE FACE- WE ALSO HAVE
TRIBES WHO ARE SMALLER LARGER
AND A LOT OF FRIENDS THAT THEY
RECEIVE FROM HEAD. AND OTHER
GROUNDS ARE NOT EVEN ENOUGH TO
HAVE CAPACITY FOR STAFF WHICH
MAKES IT A CHALLENGE TO- APPLY
FOR GRANTS. SO I JUST I JUST
WANT TO SAY YOU KNOW HAVING THE
AB TEN TEN AND ALLOWING- THE
TRIBES TO HAVE A PORTION OF
THESE FUNDS. REALLY HELP THE
TRIBES AND IT IS NOT- NOT LOOKED
AT- AT IN A BAD WAY WE'RE
ACTUALLY THANKFUL THAT WE HAVE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO APPLY FOR
THESE GRANTS AND HAVE ACCESS
FUNDING THAT WE CAN HELP. BUILD
THESE TRIBAL HOUSING- THE ISSUE
IS. ONE CAPACITY WE A LOT OF THE
TRIBES JUST DON'T HAVE CAPACITY
MY OFFICE ALONE HAS TO PEOPLE.
AND THAT'S NOT ENOUGH TO DO A
GRANT AT THE SIZE THAT I AM SAY
HOME HE WANTS US TO DO I WAS
LOOKING AT HOME KEY YESTERDAY. I
NEED TO HIRE SOMEBODY TO DO JUST
THAT GRANT AND SOME OF THOSE ARE
SOME OF THE ISSUES SOME OF THE
OTHER ISSUES ARE. THAT THE STATE
RULES AND REGULATIONS DON'T
MATCH WITH HAD RULES AND. I
THINK ROLES THAT WE HAVE TO
FOLLOW WHEN WE HAVE STATE MONEY
AND WE TRY TO COMBINE THEM.
THOSE LAWS CONFLICT WITH EACH
OTHER SO THAT HINDERS A LOT OF
THE PROGRAMS THAT WE HAVE SO
HAVING THIS CHANCE TO BE HERE TO
ASK FOR THIS BILL FOR TRIBES BY
TRIBES TO. PUT IT TO WHERE WE
CAN. UTILIZE THOSE FUNDS SO THAT
WE CAN APPLY. AS A TRIBE AS A
GOVERNMENT. TO THE STATE FUNDING
SO THANK YOU. NEXT WEEK- GOOD
MORNING THANK. GOOD MORNING AT
THANK YOU COMMITTEE FOR THE TIME
TODAY AND THANK YOU SENATOR
MCGUIRE FOR REALLY TAKING CHARGE
AND- HELPING US GET TO THE
HISTORIC MOMENT. I AM RYAN
MCGILL AND I WORKED FOR NORTHERN
CIRCLE INDIAN HOUSING AUTHORITY
WHERE TRIBALLY DESIGNATED
HOUSING ENTITY THAT CARRIES OUT
OF PORTABLE HOUSING ACTIVITIES.
ON BEHALF OF A FEDERALLY
RECOGNIZED TRIBES IN NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA. IN MY NINE YEARS AT
NORTHERN CIRCLE WE ALONE HAVE
APPLIED SIX TIMES. THROUGH FOUR
EIGHT CD PROGRAMS. WE HAVE THREE
AWARDS ONE SIGN STANDARD
AGREEMENT AND NO HOMES BUILT. IN
NINE YEARS NO HOMES BUILT. THE
FACT THAT CALIFORNIA IS IN A
HOUSING CRISIS IS WELL KNOWN.
IT'S DISCUSS THROUGHOUT THE
STATE. BUT THE SEVERITY OF THE
CRISIS IN INDIAN COUNTRY IS
UNDERSTATED. WHILE WAITING FOR
STANDARD AGREEMENTS AND FOR
HOMES TO BE BUILT WE STILL HAVE
INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS.
OVERCROWDED HOUSEHOLDS RENT
BURDENED FAMILIES AND ELDERS WE
HAVE ELDERS DINE ON OUR WAITING
LIST BEFORE THEY CAN GET THE
HOMES THAT THEY DESERVE. WE HAVE
TRIBAL MEMBERS LIVING IN STORAGE
CONTAINERS AND TRAVEL TRAILERS.
NOT ONLY DO WE HAVE ALL OF THIS
BUT WE HAVE A WAITING LIST THAT
STRETCHES AROUND THE BLOCK. OUR
COMMUNITIES HAVE FAILING
INFRASTRUCTURE SUB STANDARD
HOUSING. A LAND THAT IS A
BUILDABLE IF THEY HAVE LANDED
ON. IN TWENTY NINETEEN AB TEN
TEN PASSED IN CHANGES BEGAN WITH
THE REVITALIZATION OF THE
CALIFORNIA INDIAN ASSISTANCE
PROGRAM. AN ADDITIONAL FUNDING
STREAMS THROUGH EACH CITY.
ALTHOUGH THIS LEGISLATION
SPARKED CHANGES WE FOUND THAT
THE FUNDING. THAT THE FUNDING
AND THE PROGRAMS WERE STILL
PLAGUED WITH INCONSISTENCIES AND
DISCREPANCIES THAT CHALLENGE
TRIBAL SOVEREIGNTY AND PUSH
TRIBES BEYOND THEIR CAPACITY.
FROM NOVEMBER OF TWENTY TWENTY
ONE THROUGH EARLY DECEMBER OF
TWENTY TWO EIGHT CD RECEIVED
TWENTY ONE LETTERS. FROM TWELVE
TRIBES REQUESTING TO WAIVE OR
MODIFY SIXTY SECTIONS. WITHIN
THE NOVA SENATE BILL EIGHTEEN OF
PASSED SUPPORTS TRIBES AND
TRIBAL ENTITIES TO MEET THEIR
HOUSING NEEDS FROM CONCEPT TO
OCCUPANCY. PLEASE KNOW THAT THIS
BILL. IS A STARK. THANK IT IS
SOMETHING THAT CAN BE REPLICATED
AND IT STARTS HERE WITH YOUR
GUESTS VOTE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE YOUR- ANYBODY ELSE IN
THE ROOM WISHING TO TESTIFY- THE
END SUPPORT PLEASE STATE YOUR
NAME AND YOUR- ORGANIZATION AND-
SUPPORT PLEASE. PORTING THANK
YOU JOHN MEMBERS GALA DOBBINS
WITH THE CALIFORNIA COALITION
FOR RURAL HOUSING IN SUPPORT.
AND MARK STIVERS OF THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
INTO CS SIX SUPPORT. R. BRIAN
WILLIAMS I'M WITH THE- RENTAL
VALLEY RANCHERIA LITTLE RIVER
BAND OF POMO INDIANS VICE
CHAIRPERSON AND I'M HERE TO
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
THERE ANYBODY IN THE ROOM OR ANY
LEAD WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION TO
THIS BILL. SEEING NONE ANYBODY
IN OPPOSITION NOPE SO WHAT WE'RE
GONNA DO. IS MOVE ON TO WHAT
WITNESSES WAITING TO TESTIFY VIA
THE TELECONFERENCE OR WRIST
MODERATOR COULD YOU KEEP PEOPLE
UP IF ANY. ON THE PHONE IF YOU'D
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
THEN ZERO. WE'LL GO TO LINE.
SEVEN MORNING MY NAME IS
MADELINE WARDEN AFTER THE TRAVEL
COUNCIL MEMBER ON BEHALF OF THE
PEOPLE IN THE RANCHERIA- I'M
ASKING FOR A UNANIMOUS SUPPORT
FOR ENDING HOUSING INSECURITY
WITH THANK YOU UNITY BY MOVING.
EIGHTEEN BILL THANK YOU ONCE
AGAIN JUST YOUR NAME YOUR
ORGANIZATION AND WHETHER YOU
SUPPORT OR OPPOSE THANK YOU.
NEXT OVERLYING. TWENTY EIGHT. HI
THIS IS DAVID QUINTANAR ON
BEHALF OF THE HAVE THEM HELLO OF
UPPER LAKE SUPPORT. THANK YOU
OVER NEXT TO LINE TWENTY SEVEN.
HERNANDEZ THE NATIONAL IN THE
SHORT CALIFORNIA TRUCK THERE AND
WE ARE IN SUPPORT. AND WE HAVE
NO FURTHER KEEP RESEARCHER THANK
YOU MODERATOR. OKAY AT THIS TIME
I'M GONNA BRING THIS BACK TO OUR
MEMBERS ANYBODY HAVE ANY
QUESTIONS. COMMENTS MOTION. THE
BILL CENTER RUBIO. YES THANK YOU
I WILL BE MOVING TO THE BILL
INAPPROPRIATE BUT I THINK IT'S
AN IMPORTANT BILL AND I'M REALLY
GLAD YOU BROUGHT IT UP I THEIR
SO MANY CHALLENGES THAT ARE
SPECIFIC. TO TRIBAL COMMUNITIES
AND NOT ONLY HOUSING I MEAN
THERE'S A SLEW OF THINGS THAT
THEY'RE HAVING CONTENT WITH SELF
I AM HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL AND
I'M HAPPY TO COOPER THE BILL AS
WELL THANK YOU. OKAY SO WE HAVE
A MOTION BY SENATOR RUBIO I
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE THE
SENATE MCGUIRE. THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TIME SECURE RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN I. PHONE THANK YOU-
AS WELL AND CENTER GIVE THE MOVE
MOTIONS TO PASS OF TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE SECTOR
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL DODD I
THOUGHT I'D WILK HI WILK I EL
DORADO GIL. ARCHULETA HI
ARCHULETA I ASHBY ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD. GLAZER BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER. PLEASE R.
I. JONES. JONES I WENT. WHEN I-
CHOI BO. IDEA HI OF THE AYE
PORTANTINO. ROF ROF I RUBIO I
RUBIO I SEE RDO ZERO I TWELVE.
THE TEST TWELVE VOTES WE'RE
GONNA KEEP IT ON CALL FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS. THANK CENTER MCGUIRE.
TO ALLOW. EARLY THIS OFFICE.
BORDERS OF WHEN. THE. THE REAR
WILL NOW MOVE ON TO ITEM FIVE SB
. FOUR NINETY EIGHT CENTER COULD
GIVE ME. FEEL FREE TO BEGIN ONE
READY. K. GOOD MR CHURN. I'M
HERE TODAY TO PRESENT SB NINETY
EIGHT WHICH STRONGER ENFORCEMENT
AND GREATER COMPLIANCE WITH
ALCOHOL BEVERAGE CONTROL
LICENSING REGULATIONS BY
INCREASING THE ALLOWABLE LIMITS
FOR PETITIONS FOR AN OFFER IN
COMPROMISE AS WELL AS INCREASING
THE FINES FOR FURNISHING ALCOHOL
TO A MINOR. TO KEEP UP WITH THE
COST OF LIVING SPECIFICALLY THIS
BILL INCREASES THE FINE FOR
SELLING TO MINORS- FROM ONE
THOUSAND TO THREE THOUSAND
DOLLARS INCREASES THE LIMITS ON
PETITIONS FOR AN OFFER IN
COMPROMISE FROM 300-026-0004 THE
FIRST VIOLATION FROM
600-021-2000 FOR SUBSEQUENT
VIOLATION WITHIN THREE YEARS.
AND FROM TWENTY THOUSAND TO
FORTY THOUSAND FOR A SECOND
VIOLATION THAT OCCURS WITHIN
THIRTY SIX MONTHS OF THE INITIAL
VIOLATION ADDITIONALLY AS BEFORE
NINETY AUTHORIZES ABC WHEN
DETERMINING THE APPROPRIATE
LEVEL OF DISCIPLINE TO CONSIDER
THE OUTCOME OF THE VIOLATION FOR
SELLING ALCOHOL TO A MINOR OR AN
OBVIOUSLY INTOXICATED PERSON.
WITH THIS ENHANCE AUTHORITY A.
B. C. WILL BE ABLE TO AGGRAVATE-
PENALTIES BASED ON WHETHER THERE
IS A SUBSEQUENT DEATH OR GREAT
BODILY INJURY BECAUSE OF THE
MINOR OR ANY OTHER PERSON IN MY
DISTRICT WE HAVE BECOME AWARE OF
MULTIPLE BUSINESSES
UNFORTUNATELY OPENLY BREAKING
THE LAW AND SELLING TO MINORS.
UNFORTUNATELY A TRAGEDY HAD TO
HAPPEN IN ORDER FOR BUSINESS TO
GET THEIR LICENSE SUSPENDED AND
EVENTUALLY REVOKED- THE AWAY TO
FAMILY JOSEPH FREE HAN AND- MORE
WERE KILLED BY AN UNDER AGE
DRIVER WHO IS DRINKING AND
DRIVING BY ALLOWING ABC TO
CONSIDER THE OUTCOME OF
VIOLATIONS SB NINETY FOUR NINETY
EIGHT WILL HELP PREVENT FUTURE
FATALITIES AND TRAGEDIES.
TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF THIS
MEASURE TODAY I HAVE TYLER
BANANA CURLY MANAGER OF
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS FOR THE CITY
OF LONG BEACH. I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH BALLOTS YEAR- FROM
BELIEVE WITNESSES IN SUPPORT.
THE TWO MINUTES. THANK YOU GOOD
MORNING CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS MY NAME IS TYLER BEEN ON
A CURLY I'M THE MANAGER OF
GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS FOR THE CITY
OF LONG BEACH. WE'RE PROUD TO
SUPPORT SENATE BILL FOUR NINETY
EIGHT WHICH AIMS TO BOLSTER
PUBLIC SAFETY AND ADDRESS
CHALLENGES THAT COMMUNITIES
FACE. RELATED TO THE ILLEGAL
SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES TO
MINORS AND INTOXICATED PERSONS.
IN RECENT YEARS AS THE SENATOR
MENTIONED. LONG BEACH ANOTHER
COMMUNITIES ACROSS CALIFORNIA OF
EXPERIENCE THE IMPACTS OF
VIOLATIONS- TO THE ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE CONTROL ACT. LONG BEACH
POLICE DEPARTMENT IS HANDLED
MORE THAN SIX HUNDRED CASES
RELATED TO THE ILLEGAL SALE OF
ALCOHOL TO MINORS SINCE TWO
THOUSAND. AND WE CURRENTLY SEE
AN AVERAGE OF OVER FIFTY CASES
PER YEAR. WE WORK CLOSELY WITH
ABC TO ENFORCE VIOLATIONS AND
ENGAGE IN PROACTIVE EFFORTS TO
REDUCE THE AVAILABILITY OF
ALCOHOL TO MINORS. STATISTICS
HAVE SHOWN. THE MINORS UNDER THE
AGE OF TWENTY ONE HAVE A HIGHER
RATE OF DRUNK DRIVING
FATALITIES. THAN THE GENERAL
ADULT POPULATION. IN TWO
THOUSAND NINETEEN FOR EXAMPLE
AFTER MINOR WAS ILLEGALLY SOLD
ALCOHOL AT A LIQUOR STORE IN
LONG BEACH. THE MINOR- DROVE
UNDER THE INFLUENCE AND FATALLY
STRUCK A FAMILY OF THREE. OUT
WALKING ON HALLOWEEN NIGHT. AND
IN A SEPARATE INCIDENT IN TWO
THOUSAND TWENTY TWO. INVOLVING A
DIFFERENT ALCOHOL ESTABLISHMENT
OFFICERS WERE DISPATCHED TO A
FATAL HIT AND RUN. COLLISION
THAT KILLED TO LONG BEACH
RESIDENTS. DURING THESE ANOTHER
TRAGIC EVENTS ABC HAS LIMITED
AUTHORITY TO EFFECTIVELY ADDRESS
PUBLIC SAFETY CONCERNS THAT
RESULT FROM VIOLATIONS. OF THE
ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE CONTROL ACT.
AS BEFORE NINETY EIGHT WOULD
STRENGTHEN A. B. C.'S
ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW PROCESS.
FOR RETAIL LICENSES ALLOWING FOR
INCREASED ADMINISTRATIVE FINES
OR SUSPENSION. THE BILL
AUTHORIZES THE DEPARTMENT TO
CONSIDER THE OUTCOME OF THE
VIOLATIONS AND SPECIFICALLY
WHETHER THEY RESULTED IN DEATH
OR INJURY. IN DETERMINING THE
LEVEL OF ADMINISTRATIVE FINE-
LICENSE SUSPENSION. THIS IS A
SIMPLE ADMINISTRATIVE FIX BUT
ONE THAT COULD HELP SAVE LIVES
BY PER VM PREVENTING REPEAT
VIOLATIONS AND FOR THESE REASONS
THE CITY OF LONG BEACH IS PROUD
TO SPONSOR. AS BEFORE NINETY
EIGHT AND WE ASK FOR YOUR AYE
BUT THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ARE
THERE ANY OTHER- WITNESS HERE IN
SUPPORT. REPORTER GOOD MORNING.
MORNING MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS
MICHAEL SKIP ON BEHALF OF
ALCOHOL JUSTICE. WE ARE A AGENCY
WHICH MONITORS THE ALCOHOL
INDUSTRY AND WE SUPPORT.
EVIDENCE BASED POLICIES TO
REDUCE HARM. I WOULD JUST LIKE
TO REITERATE THAT. CALIFORNIA IS
IN THE MIDST. OF A STARTLING
EPIDEMIC OF ALCOHOL RELATED
DEATH. ACCORDING TO THE CDC. YES
TO MADE ALCOHOL RELATED
MORTALITY RATE IN THE STATE WAS
AROUND ELEVEN THOUSAND IN TWO
THOUSAND FIFTEEN. TODAY IS OVER
NINETEEN THOUSAND ACCORDING TO
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH. EVERY CHANNEL WE
CAN USE TO STEM CELLS THE
RESULTANT GRIEVOUS OUTCOMES FOR
YOUTH AND OTHER RESIDENTS WE
SHOULD USE WE ASK FOR YOUR FULL
SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU.
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS FRED JONES
ON BEHALF CALIFORNIA COUNCIL
ALCOHOL PROBLEMS AND SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. ARE THERE ANY
WITNESSES IN THE ROOM- IN
OPPOSITION. TWO S. B. FOUR
NINETY EIGHT. SEEING THAT WE'RE
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OTHER CALL
LINE. MODERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE-
PROPPED INDIVIDUALS WAITING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION
SB FOUR NINETY EIGHT. PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
TIME. ALLOWING A FEW MORE A FEW
MOMENTS HERE WE HAVE NO ONE IN
Q. MISTER CHAIR. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH WE'RE GONNA BRING THIS BACK
TO OUR MEMBERS ANYBODY WISHING
TO COMMENT OR QUESTION CENTER
ARCHULETA YEAH. THANK YOU CENTER
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD BUT
YOU KNOW I SHARED WITH THE
MONTEBELLO POLICE DEPARTMENT AND
ACCIDENTS AND YOU OPEN THE DOOR
IN THE BEER BOTTLES FALLOUT
BLOOD FALL FLOWS. AND NOW YOU'RE
GOING RIGHT TO THE SOURCE AND I
APPRECIATE THAT IN THE CITY OF
LONG BEACH YOU EXPRESSED IT WELL
WITH A NUMBER OF TRAGEDIES THAT
HAPPENED THERE. BUT MY
CONDOLENCES TO THE FAMILIES THAT
WERE JUST NAMED AND- THAT WILL
SORRY TO SAY THAT IF IT'S GOING
TO CONTINUE BUT YOU'VE GONE TO
THE SOURCE IN IF THE PROPRIETORS
WE NOW UNDERSTAND. THAT ABC WILL
HAVE THE STRENGTH WE'RE GONNA
LOSE THOSE LICENSE WE'RE GOING
TO- IMPOUND CARS WE'RE GOING TO
FIND WE'RE COMING AFTER IT AND I
PRE WHAT YOU'RE IN I BE A TO BE
A OP. AND ALSO TO MOVE BILL.
EVERYBODY SHOULD REAL QUICK
BECAUSE- CENTER SIRED SO IT- I'M
SUPPORT THE BILL TO B. IT DOES
ATTACK ONE OF IT- BUT THERE IS
ANOTHER PART OF THAT IS
RESPONSIBILITY OF PARENTS AND
THE UNDERAGE MINORS WHO ARE
BUYING ALCOHOL- BECAUSE THERE'S
LOTS OF WAYS TO FOOL- RETAILERS
WITH FAKE LICENSES AND THINGS
LIKE THAT AND- IT IS MUCH
TRAINING IS THERE HAD SOME
PEOPLE REALLY GOOD AT IT- SO- I
. APPRECIATE THAT WE ARE ARE ARE
GOING AFTER THIS SIDE OF IT- BUT
AT THE SAME TIME I WANT TO SEE
LAWS AND EFFORTS TO HOLD OTHER
PEOPLE ACCOUNTABLE THAT ARE
ACTUALLY DOING- ACTUALLY-
COMMITTING- THE- THE- ACTS. ARE
ARE ILLEGAL. AND SO ANYWAY- I
WOULD. I'M I'M BE SPUR THIS BILL
THANK THANK YOU. SO IT IS ALSO
JOINED BECAUSE I WANT TO THANK
MY- FOR SPEAKING UP I WANTED TO
THE CITY OF BEACH A ON BEHALF
OF- OUR CITY PROSECUTOR AND OF
COURSE THE MANY FAMILIES HAVE
BEEN- TRAGICALLY HURT BY THIS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY BOOK.
THANK YOU THE BILL'S BEEN MOVED
BY CENTER ARCH A LOT OF THE
MOTION IS TO PASS. TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE SECTOR
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL DODD I
THOUGHT I WILL ALL RIGHT WILK I
EL DORADO GIL. ARCHULETA ALL
RIGHT ARCHULETA I ASHBY ASHBY
AYE BRADFORD OR- BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER. GLAZER AYE JONES. HI
JONES I WHEN I WHEN I- CHILLAGOE
IDEA. HI THE AYE PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH. ROTH IRA.
HI RUBIO I SEE. I KNOW I. THAT'S
THIRTEEN VOTES WERE KEEP UP BILL
ON CALL. BUT THAT BILL CALL-
LOOKS. SEVEN ZERO. LET'S GET TO
YOU WANTED TO COME ON UP. LIMON
DOWN. FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT SB
EIGHT NO. WHERE ARE WE NOW. A
WILL MOVING SORRY ABOUT THAT. SO
THAT'S FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR- S.
B. TWO SEVENTY NINE. CENTER
WELCOME AND BEGIN. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MISTER CHAIR AND
MEMBERS FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
PRESENT S. B. TWO SEVENTY NINE
WHICH PROVIDES OPPORTUNITIES FOR
THE PUBLIC TO ENGAGE AS- EXCUSE
ME STATE ENTITIES CONSIDER THE
ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THEIR
REGULATIONS. IN TWO THOUSAND
ELEVEN THE LEGISLATURE ENACTED A
NEW PROCESS A STATE AGENT AGENCY
MUST CONDUCT WHEN IT ESTIMATES
THE THAT THE A PROPOSED
REGULATION HAS A NEXT ESTIMATED
IMPACT OF- EXCEEDING FIFTY
MILLION DOLLARS. A STANDARD
REGULATORY IMPACT ANALYSIS OR
MORE SIMPLY SHARIA FOR SHORT WAS
CREATED TO HELP STATE AGENCIES
AND THE PUBLIC DETERMINE WHETHER
A PROPOSED REGULATION IS AN
EFFICIENT AND EFFECTIVE MEANS OF
IMPLEMENTING NEW STATE POLICIES
. CURRENTLY THERE IT REALLY
LACKS A FORMAL OPPORTUNITY FOR
THE PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDERS TO
PROVIDE EXPERT TESTIMONY ON
UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS A STATE
AGENCY OR BOARD UTILIZES WHEN IT
PREPARES A SRI- ANALYSIS. SB TWO
SEVENTY NINE PROVIDES A FORMAL
TWENTY ONE DAY OPPORTUNITY FOR
THE PUBLIC TO PROVIDE INPUT A TO
THE AGENCY FOR THE PROPOSED
REGULATION AND- THEN S. B. TWO
SEVENTY FIVE TO SEVENTY NINE-
THEN AFTER THE AGENCY TURNS ITS
RECOMMENDATION OVER TO THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE. PROVIDES
FOR A THIRTY DAY PUBLIC COMMENT
PERIOD TO ALLOW US STAKEHOLDERS
TO PROVIDE EXPERT TESTIMONY SUCH
AS- ECONOMIC IMPACT STATEMENTS
AND TECHNICAL DATA THAT IS
PERTINENT TO IN CREATING AN
ACCURATE ASSESSMENT.
ADDITIONALLY THE CURRENT PROCESS
IN DETERMINING WHETHER A
PROPOSED REGULATION IS A MAJOR
REGULATION- IS SELF CERTIFYING
THAT IS THE STATE AGENCY GETS TO
DETERMINE ITS OWN REGULATION-
THAT IS PROMULGATING. THAT IS
THE EVIDENCE THAT IT'S
PROMULGATING TO MEET THE
DEFINITION. SB TWO SEVENTY NINE
PROVIDES A WHOLLY APPROPRIATE
FORMAL OPPORTUNITY FOR
STAKEHOLDERS TO PROVIDE US. A
STATE ENTITY FACTS EXPERT
TESTIMONY OR OTHER EVIDENCE TO
DEMONSTRATE AN IMPACT OF ABOVE
FIFTY MILLION DOLLAR THRESHOLD
BEFORE THE DETERMINATION IS MADE
WHETHER THE REGULATION IS MAJOR
. I HAVE TODAY WITH ME MICHAEL
MILLER WITH THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF WHITE WINE GRAPE
GROWERS AND BRUCE WICK WITH THE
HOUSING CONTRACTORS OF
CALIFORNIA TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL. GOOD MORNING THE
BOARD MEMBERS ARE VERY MUCH
ABOUT THE QUALITY. BALANCE OF-
ACTED. YOUR ACT WHICH WAS WE
HAVE THE VOLUME UP POLICE. YEAH
WE DON'T HAVE THOSE THAT ARE
OVER THE. USUALLY WE COULD
REALLY HEAR YOU MICHAEL I'M.
HE'LL GET HE'LL GET IT. OKAY
HOW'S THAT THERE WAS. ALL RIGHT
. I'D STILL BUCKLE BILL WITH THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF WHITE
GRAPE GROWERS AND THANK YOU TO
BE OUT THERE FOR THEY GOT
THROUGH THE BILL IN THE
COMMITTEE FIRST CONSIDERATION OF
THE COMMISSION SOUGHT TO PROVIDE
ANALYSIS- WE BELIEVE THE PUBLIC
ACCESS TO THE EPA IS CRUCIAL TO
EFFECTIVE TRANSPARENT AND
RELIABLE REGULATORY PROCESS- THE
PROBLEM OF THE CURRENT
REGULATORY PROCESSES THAT WOULD
AN AGENCY PROPOSES A REGULATION.
THEY HAVE NO ABILITY TO
CALCULATE THE COST BECAUSE THEY
DON'T HAVE ALL THE COMPLETE
INFORMATION SO THEY DO THE BEST
THEY CAN TO ADDRESS THIS SB TWO
SEVEN NIGHT BRINGS A PUBLIC
COMMENT AT THE BEGINNING OF THAT
PROCESS AND THEREBY SPEEDS
THINGS UP. THIS IS NEEDED TO
AVOID PROBLEMS WITH THE AGENCY
DOES NOT HAVE THE INFORMATION IT
NEEDS FOR EXAMPLE THE
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH
STANDARDS BOARD IN TWENTY
NINETEEN FIRST OUTDOOR
AGRICULTURAL OPERATIONS DURING
HOURS OF DARKNESS REGULATION.
THE BOARD INADVERTENTLY UNDER
ESTIMATED HOW BROADLY THE
PROPOSED REGULATION WOULD BE
APPLIED IN THIS EXAMPLE THE
BOARD WAS FACTUALLY WRONG IN THE
FOLLOWING THREE ASSUMPTIONS ARE
RELIED UPON IN CALCULATING THE
INDUSTRY'S COST. THE BOARD FOUND
THE ONLY ONE THOUSAND SIX
HUNDRED AND FORTY AG BUSINESS
HAVE WORKED OUT AT NIGHT OVER
THE INDEPENDENT REPORTS AND
ANALYSIS BY UC DAVIS SHORT
APPROXIMATELY THIRTY FIVE
THOUSAND AG EMPLOYERS. HAVE
WORKED THOSE DONATE AND FRANKLY
AT LEAST PLAY TWO OR THREE
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE HAVE
MORE THAN ONE THOUSAND SIX
HUNDRED AND WORKERS AND-
EMPLOYERS AT NIGHT. THE BOARD
ALSO COULD THAT THERE HARVEST IS
ONLY TOO MONTHS OF THE YEAR
HOWEVER IS WELL DOCUMENTED THAT
HE CALIFORNIA NAY HARBORS OF
VARIOUS CROPS IS NEARLY YEAR
ROUND. FAMILY THE BOARD FOUND
THAT HARBORS WORK IS ONLY AS THE
ONLY WORK THAT IS DONE THE NIGHT
THIS IS EVEN THOUGH YOU SEE
DAVIS REPORTED AND I QUOTE.
HARVEST EQUIPMENT TRANSPORTATION
SET UP MAINTENANCE AS WELL AS
FEEL PREP AND REPAIRS IRRIGATION
WORK AND PESTICIDE APPLICATION
ARE ALL ACTIVITIES THAT ARE DONE
AT NIGHT. THIS BEES AT THE BOARD
UNDER ESTIMATE THE REGULATORY
COMPLIANCE COSTS BY FOUR
THOUSAND PERCENT. AT LEAST FOUR
THOUSAND PERCENT. BUT BECAUSE
THE PUBLIC WAS NOT AFFORDED AN
OPPORTUNITY TO FORMALLY PROVIDE
INDEPENDENT AND VERIFIABLE
INFORMATION UP FRONT. THE BOARD
HAD TO MOVE FORWARD WITH WHAT IT
HAD. AND FRANKLY IT'S NOT THEIR
FAULT THEY HAD NO CHOICE. WE
BELIEVE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN
THE REGULATORY PROCESS IS NEVER
A WASTE OF TIME AND MONEY. AND
WE MAKE NO APOLOGIES FOR THAT WE
BELIEVE THE PUBLIC HAS AN
ABSOLUTE RIGHT TO BE HEARD.
THAT'S BECAUSE PUBLIC
PARTICIPATION IS ESSENTIAL TO
SECURING A PROTECTED PUBLIC
TRUST IN THE REGULATORY PROCESS.
AGAIN THANKS TO THE AUTHOR.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THAT'S
CHAIRED MEMBERS BRUCE WICK
HOUSING CONTRACTORS IN
CALIFORNIA ARE EXPERIENCE WITH
SHARIA. IS IN RESIDENTIAL FALL
PROTECTION. THE OUTSIDE
CONSULTANT WHO IS DOING IT FOR
CAL OSHA CALLED ME AND SAID I
DON'T REALLY UNDERSTAND
CONSTRUCTION. I TRY TO HELP IN.
HE ISSUED THIS AREA
UNDERESTIMATING RESIDENTIAL FALL
PROTECTION COSTS. BY ONE POINT
TWO BILLION DOLLARS OVER TEN
YEARS. AND THERE WERE FOURTEEN
OTHER. MISTAKES IN HISTORY- I
ONLY FOUND IT BECAUSE THERE WAS
NO ANNOUNCEMENT. I CHECKED THE
D. O. F. WEBSITE ONCE A WEEK. I
SENT A DETAILED LETTER TO D. O.
F. THREE WEEKS LATER THEY
APPROVED THE SHARIA. WITH A ONE
POINT TWO BUT BILLION DOLLAR
MISTAKE THE PROBLEMS WITH THIS
THREE AS WELL AS MICHAEL SAID.
THE ECONOMIC EXPERTS ARE NOT
EXPERTS IN OUR INDUSTRY WE HAVE
TO HAVE. DIALOGUE BACK AND FORTH
SB TWO SEVENTY NINE ALLOWS THAT
IT'S UNFAIR TO BOARD MEMBERS.
WHO ARE VOLUNTEERS APPOINTED BY
THE GOVERNOR AND THEY WANT TO
MAKE A GOOD DECISION THEY NEED
THE INFORMATION. AND TIMING
ISSUE. FROM A ONE TO JUNE THIRTY
DEAL F. IS INUNDATED OBVIOUSLY
WITH BUDGET ISSUES. THE OUR
SERIE A ON RESIDENT FALL
PROTECTION. DATED MARCH IN
TWENTY NINETEEN. GIVEN THE D. O.
F. ME TWENTY NINE A. R. B. LAST
YEAR GAVE FOR SIRI IS TO. THE-
F. IN MAY. FOR THOSE TRYING TO
CIRCUMVENT THE TIMING PROCESS SB
TWO SEVEN NINE ALLOWS THE TIMING
FOR US. TO BE HEARD IN THERE ARE
SOME WHO ARE CONCERNED ABOUT HOW
LONG IT TAKES. THE REGULATORY
PROCESS AND ADDING FIFTY ONE
DAYS. THERE ARE TWO REAL SIMPLE
SOLUTIONS ONE IS THE OUTDOOR
HEAT ILLNESS FOR INSTANCE. THAT
WAS SUPPOSED TO BE FOCUSED ON
WAREHOUSE WORKERS. RESTAURANT
ETCETERA THEY WANTED THEY
EXPANDED IT TO COVER ALL INDOOR
WORKERS IN CALIFORNIA SPENDING
THE TIME THIS REAR. END AS WELL
THE D. I. R. FOR INSTANCE
EMPLOYER SEND THEM ONE POINT
FIVE BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR. TO
FUND ALL THEIR OPERATIONS THEY
COULD FUND A SERIE A UNIT THAT
WOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR
TIMELINESS. AND ACCURACY AND
THEY COULD ALSO FUND THE CALLOUS
OF RESEARCH AND STANDARDS UNIT
WHICH IS A GREAT ROAD BLOCK. TO
PROCESSING. REGULATIONS BECAUSE
THEY WERE UNDER STAFFED
CHRONICALLY SO THANK YOU. THANK
YOU. ANY OTHER WITNESSES WANTING
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IN THE
ROOM. COME FORWARD. THANK YOU
MISTER CHAIR DEVICE WILL COME
WITH THE CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. GOOD
MORNING MR CHAIRMAN BERSUARA
TOPKAPI HALF OF THE ORANGE
COUNTY BUSINESS COUNCIL IN
SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING TIM SMILES
ON BEHALF OF WINE INSTITUTE IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ARE THERE
ANY WITNESSES IN THE ROOM IN
OPPOSITION LEADER OTHERWISE.
SEEING NONE- MODERATOR CAN YOU
PLEASE OPEN UP THE LINES AND-
SEE IF THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION OR
SUPPORT FOR. SB TWO SEVENTY NINE
PLEASE. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME.
FOLLOWING A FEW MOMENTS THERE IS
NO ONE IN Q. MISTER CHAIR EXCUSE
ME YEAH ABOUT LATE. ONE MOMENT.
IN WE'LL GO TO LINE NUMBER
TWENTY NINE. GOOD MORNING. WE
HAVE THE LONG- CHAMBER OF
COMMERCE REPORT. THANK THANK YOU
WE HAVE NO OTHERS AT THIS TIME
THANK YOU MODERATOR PER SHEET-
THAT- WILL NOW MOVE- AND BRING
DISCUSSION BACK TO OUR MEMBERS
ANYBODY WISHING TO. QUESTION OR
COMMENT ON THIS- BILL. IS THERE
A MOTION. A MOTION BY SIX.
SENATOR RUBIO NOW DID YOU WANT
TO SPEAK CENTER WELL NO IT'S
GONNA MOVE THE BILL OKAY JUST A
LITTLE LATE. NO ACTUALLY
FOLLOWED PROCEDURE BY HITTING
THE BUTTON IN. MY COLLEAGUES
JUMPED THE GUN THERE I AM REALLY
AREN'T ANY MOTION I COULD
APPRECIATE THAT IF I HAD A PANEL
IN FRONT OF ME COULD SEE TO SEE
ALL THESE LIGHTS BUT THANK YOU
FOR THAT WONDERFUL COMMENT- WILL
MOVE THAT. BUT CENTER NEIL WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I WOULD LOVE
TO CLOSE SENATOR DODD- HOPEFULLY
READING THAT TEA LEAVES-
ACCURATELY. FOR THIS- HOLY DON
CONTROVERSIAL BILL I. HI I
REQUEST AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH SENATOR THE MOTION IS
TO PASS TO APPROPRIATIONS SECTOR
PLEASE CALL DODD I THOUGHT I
WILL RIGHT WILK AYE ELDORADO
GIL. ARCHULETA ARCHULETA I ASKI
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER PLEASE R. I. JOHNSON
JONES I WENT. WHEN I- CHILLAGOE
. IDEA I HAVE THE I. PORTANTINO
I. ROTH AYE RUBIO HI RUBIO I SEE
RDO SEE OUR- I THE LAST THIRTEEN
VOTE WILL PUT THAT ARE CALL. I
YOU VERY MUCH THANK YOU. FABLE
MOVE TO- I NUMBER SIC. SB SEVEN
THIRTY TWO CENTER MENJIVAR. GOOD
MORNING WELCOME. GOOD MORNING
EVERYONE. LET'S TALK ABOUT BATH
. CALIFORNIA STATE SYMBOLS ARE
SET BY STATE LAW IN CURRENTLY
INCLUDE EMBLEMS LIKE OUR SAY
ANIMAL THE GRIZZLY BEAR OUR
STATE BIRD THE QUAIL OR C. FLOUR
THE GOLDEN POPPY IN EVEN A STATE
DINOSAUR. HOWEVER A STATE THAT
HAS NOT YET BEEN ESTABLISHED SO
SB SEVEN THREE TWO IS LOOKING TO
DESIGNATE THE PALLID BAT AS THE
OFFICIAL STATE BAD OF
CALIFORNIA. MAKING THE PALLID
BAT THE OFFICIAL BOUT OF
CALIFORNIA WILL BRING AWARENESS
TO THE BENEFITS THEY PROVIDE IN
OUR STATE AND WE'RE INSPIRED
FUTURE CONSERVATION EFFORTS FOR
THIS UNDER PROTECTED CATEGORY OF
ANIMALS. WHILE MANY OF US ME
INCLUDED MAY HAVE HAD A NEGATIVE
ASSOCIATION OF BATS THEY PROVIDE
OUR NUMBER THE MIRADA OF
BENEFITS TOWARDS STATE MOST OF
WHICH WERE UNKNOWN TO ME
RECENTLY. HOW DID BALLOTS EAT
MANY PAST SPECIES INCLUDING
THOSE THAT CONTRIBUTE TO HEALTH
RESEARCH OF MOSQUITOES WASPS AND
FLIES MOSQUITOES ALL WHICH WE
KNOW WE HATE IN FACT PROBABLY
BALLOTS ARE SUCH GOOD INSECT
PREDATORS THAT FARMERS RANCHERS
AND VINEYARD OWNERS PLACE BALLOT
BOXES ON THEIR PROPERTY AS A
MEANS OF NATURAL PEST CONTROL.
MISTER CHAIRMAN NO WE NEED TO
PROTECT THOSE VINEYARDS IN YOUR
DISTRICT. ACCORDING TO WILDLIFE
ECOLOGIST DAVE JOHNSTON IN
CALIFORNIA THE BENEFITS BACK TO
PROVIDE TO AGRICULTURE ARE
ESTIMATED TO EQUAL OVER ONE
BILLION DOLLARS THAT'S- YES
THAT'S BE WITH THE BEST BILLION
WITH A B. JUST LAST NIGHT MISTER
CHAIR WITHIN YOUR DISTRICT OFF
OF THE EIGHTY AT THE YOLO BYPASS
WILDLIFE AREA. WHERE I GOT TO
SEE HUNDREDS IF NOT THOUSANDS OF
BALLOTS COME OUT FOR THEIR
NIGHTLY HUNT. AND THEY WERE
FLYING TO THE NEARBY FARMS IN
YOUR VERY DISTRICT AS I
MENTIONED TO ENSURE THAT THEY'RE
KILLING THOSE PASS. I WOULD BE
MORE THAN HAPPY TO SHOW THIS
REALLY AMAZING VIDEO TO ANY
COMMITTEE MEMBER HERE TODAY. I
SEE MISTER BRADFORD IS READY TO
SEE IT. IN ADDITION TO PASS
CONTROL IN SAVING BATS AND THE
SAVINGS ABOUT TO BRING TO OUR
FARMERS PALETTE BATS PROVIDE
WILDLIFE REDUCTION BY EATING
BARK BEETLES AND WOOD. BORERS
WHICH ARE CONTRIBUTORS TO THE
INCREASE OF WILDFIRES IN
CALIFORNIA. SO THEREFORE
ESTABLISHING THE STATE THAT
HONORS CALIFORNIA'S EXTREMELY
DIVERSE NATURAL HISTORY WHILE
EQUALLY HONORING ITS PRICE
ECONOMIC BASE IN AGRICULTURE. SO
HERE WITH ME TO SUPPORT IS THE
MASTERMIND ONE OF THE SMARTEST
LITTLE GIRLS I'VE EVER MET IN MY
LIFE- NAOMI THE LAZIO STUDENT
AND ABOUT. INTO THE ACID.
FOLLOWED BY KIM. AN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
ADVOCATE. GOOD MORNING. GOOD
MORNING. THAT'S ARE IMPORTANT TO
EVERY PART OF CALIFORNIA. BY
CONSUMING INSECT PESTS THEY SAVE
OUR FARMERS BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
WORTH OF CROPS AND PROTECTED
FROM MOSQUITO BORNE DISEASES
SUCH AS ZIKA AND WEST NILE
VIRUSES. THEY ALSO EAT BARK
BEETLES HOPING TO CREATE
HEALTHIER LESS WILD FIRE PRONE
FORESTS. WHILE MOST PEOPLE HAVE
NEVER SEEN ABOUT IN THEIR
NEIGHBORHOOD SCIENTISTS AT THE
NATURAL HISTORY MUSEUM IN LOS
ANGELES TO THE BACKYARD ABOUT
SURVEY AND THAT EVERY SINGLE
SITE THROUGHOUT SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA THE OBSERVED AT LEAST
ONE TYPE OF BACKED. WE'VE LIVED
IN MY HOUSE FOR ALMOST MY ENTIRE
LIFE AND HAVE NEVER SEEN ABOUT.
WHEN WE SET UP A MICROPHONE TO
RECORD BAT CALLS WE HAD FIFTY
FOUR ABOUT FLY BYS FROM FOUR
DIFFERENT SPECIES ON THE VERY
FIRST NIGHT. AND SINCE BAXLEY
FOR DECADES MANY OF THESE EXACT
BATS HAVE PROBABLY BEEN EATING
MOSQUITOES IN MY YARD FOR ALL
LIKE BLUNDER THAN I'VE BEEN
ALIVE. I AM EXCITED THAT WE'VE
CHOSEN THE POWER BACK TO BE OUR
STATE THAT BECAUSE THEY'RE
REALLY AMAZING THEIR GOLDEN FOR
COLOR IS PERFECT FOR GOLDEN
STATE. THEY ARE IMMUNE TO THE
VENOM OF SCORPIONS ONE OF THEIR
FAVORITE SNACKS. AND ALSO THEY
ARE ONE OF THE FEW BACKS IN THE
WORLD THAT ARE OMNIVORES AS THEY
ALSO CONSUME THE FRUIT AND
NECTAR OF CACTI IN CALIFORNIA'S
DESERT'S. THEY ARE VERY SOCIAL
BACKS AND EVEN SPEAK TO EACH
OTHER IN DIFFERENT LANGUAGES
THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY TELL PARK
JUST LIKE CALIFORNIA'S PEOPLE.
DESIGNATING THE POWER BACK AS
THE OFFICIAL STATE BACK WILL
HELP PEOPLE UNDERSTAND THE
IMPORTANCE OF BATS. AND WILL
MAKE THEM WANT TO PROTECT THEM.
THAT POPULATIONS ARE DECLINING
IN CALIFORNIA AND URGENTLY NEED
PROTECTIONS YOUR VOTE TODAY IS A
FIRST STEP TOWARDS THAT. THANK
YOU FOR SUPPORTING CALIFORNIA'S
BATS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WELL
DONE. CHAIRMAN DIED REST
SENATORS THANK YOU FOR HAVING US
TODAY HOW CAN YOU FOLLOW THAT I
MEAN HONESTLY COME ON TWELVE
YEARS OLD. SHE'S GOING TO BE.
ALL YOU KNOW IN FORTY YEARS. NOT
JUST BUT ANYWAY I'M I'M KIMBERLY
RICHARD AND I AM FROM NAPA.
BEAUTIFUL NAPA VALLEY WINERIES
AND- BILL DOT IS MY SENATOR- I'M
AND I AM PLEASED TO SUPPORT SB
SEVEN THREE Q. WHICH WOULD
ESTABLISH THE PALLID BAT AS OUR
STATE AS OUR OFFICIAL. STATE MAP
FOR CALIFORNIA. THE PALLID BAT
THE PACIFIC PALLID BAT IS A
SIGNIFICANT PREDATOR TOO MANY OF
THE INSECTS THAT ARE NUISANCE
AND FEED OFF A CALIFORNIA
PRECIOUS AGRICULTURE SUCH AS
GRAPES WALNUTS ALMONDS AND
AVOCADOS. THESE BATS
SPECIFICALLY THE PACIFIC PALLID
BAT AND BATS IN GENERAL ARE
EARTH NATURAL PESTICIDES WHICH
PLAY A VITAL ROLE IN THE ECO
SYSTEM AND OF OUR CALIFORNIA
LANDS THIS IS WHY I HOPE FOR
YOUR FULL SUPPORT. AND SAYING
YES TO THIS BILL MOVING FORWARD.
ESTABLISHING A STATE BACK HONORS
CALIFORNIA EXTREMELY DIVERSE
NATURAL HISTORY. WINERIES
FARMERS. GROWERS ALIKE
ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS BAT BECAUSE
OF THE ECONOMIC. SAVING OF MONEY
THESE PAT SAY ONE TO THREE
BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR IN
PESTICIDES WHICH IS SOMETHING
THAT IS HARMING OUR ECO SYSTEM
TO THIS DAY. THE PALATE BACK
CONSUMES A WIDE VARIETY OF PEST
INSECTS AND ANTHROPOID.
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA.
CALIFORNIA SENATE PASSED
RESOLUTION NUMBER SEVENTEEN FIVE
TWO NINE SEVEN EIGHT ON THE
TWENTY FIFTH OF JULY TWO
THOUSAND AND SEVENTEEN TO
RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF THE
PACIFIC PALLID BAT TO THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA. THANKS TO MY
SENATOR WHO GOT THAT RESOLUTION
PASSED. AND I'M MOST GRATEFUL
FOR THAT THE PACIFIC PALLID BAT
IS INDIGENOUS TO CALIFORNIA AND
PROVIDES NATURAL PEST CONTROLS
TO FARMERS WILDLIFE MITIGATION
FOR FORT. GROWERS IN SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA CONSIDER THIS BAT ONE
OF THE MOST IMPORTANT TO THEIR
HEALTHY CROPS. IN NAPA VALLEY
MOST OF THE WINERIES HAVE BUILT
. THE SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED
HOTBOX BAT BOXES EXCLUSIVELY FOR
THIS LITTLE BAD ON THEIR
WINERIES BECAUSE THEY KNOW THE
IMPORTANCE THAT THIS BAT. DOES
FOR THE WINERIES IN HEALTHY
GRAPES SO PLEASE I AM ASKING FOR
VOTE YES ON SB SEVEN THREE Q. TO
MOVE TO THE FLOOR FOR A VOTE AND
TO MOVE ON MAKING THE PACIFIC
PALLID BAT OUR STATE BACK AND
LET'S NOT LET TEXAS BEAT US
BECAUSE THEY DO HAVE THEIR OWN
STATE BAT. AND WE'RE BETTER THAN
THAT STATE JUST HAD TO PUT THAT
OUT THERE BECAUSE I'M FROM TEXAS
THAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH SOME
ABOUT THE- NEXT SPEAKER. HE
MICHAEL CHAIRED ON BEHALF THE
CALIFORNIANS TO PROVIDE VERSED
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL THANK
YOU THANK YOU. YOU KNOW THAT I
CANNOT BELIEVE AFTER ALL THAT
THAT THERE'S ANY OPPOSITION IN
THE ROOM. BUT IF THERE IS PLEASE
COME FORWARD AT THIS TIME. WE
ARE NOW. THAT'S QUITE ALRIGHT-
SO AT THIS TIME- MODERATOR COULD
WE PLEASE- CHECK THE LIGHTS TO
SEE IF THERE'S ANY SUPPORTER
OPPOSITION. FOR SB SEVEN THREE
TWO. THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND ZERO AT THIS TIME
. ALLOWING A FEW MOMENTS WE HAVE
NO ONE IN Q. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MODERATOR. THIS TIME I'LL BRING
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE SENATOR
ASHBY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. NAIL
ME I AM SO IMPRESSED AND ALSO I
JUST HAVE TO HOLD TO SPEAK TO
THIS IS THE CUTEST BACK EVER.
BUSY SO CUTE. AT FIRST WHEN
SENATOR MENJIVAR CAME TO TALK TO
ME ABOUT THIS I THOUGHT WE WERE
GONNA GET TO NAME THE BAT AND I
REALLY WANTED TO NAME BRUCE
WAYNE. BUT I SEE THAT HE ALREADY
HAS A NAME WHICH IS ALSO
EXCELLENT I'M I'M REALLY EXCITED
FOR YOU THAT YOU BROUGHT THIS
BILL TO YOUR MEMBER SHE'S MY
FRIEND AND SHE'S BEEN BRAGGING
ABOUT YOU TO ME FOR WEEKS. AND
HOW SMART YOU ARE AND I JUST
TOLD HER TODAY YOU KNOW THIS
BILL YOUR TWELVE RIGHT IN YOUR
BILL NUMBER IS SEVEN THREE TWO
YOU KNOW SEVEN PLUS THREE PLUS
TWO IS TWELVE. AND I THINK THIS
IS JUST MEANT TO BE TODAY FOR
YOU. THIS IS INCREDIBLE AND AT I
TO HAVE BEEN TO THE BAT FLY AWAY
IN YOLO COUNTY MANY TIMES THE
BOY SCOUTS AND GIRL SCOUTS IN
SACRAMENTO THAT'S AN ANNUAL
TRIP. SO MY KIDS HAVE BEEN THERE
MANY TIMES THAT'S A BIG PART OF
IT AND REALLY IMPORTANT
ECOSYSTEM IN THE YELLOW BASE AND
THAT I KNOW CENTER DOGS REALLY
PROUD OF AND I KNOW YOU KNOW
THAT. ASSEMBLYWOMAN CECILIA
AGUILAR CURRY SHE'S ALSO VERY
PROUD OF THAT SPACE AND SO IT IS
WITH GREAT HONOR WHEN IT'S TIME
THAT I WOULD LOVE TO MOVE THIS
BILL. TODAY CHAIRMAN IF THAT'S
OKAY THANK YOU AND NOW WE'RE
GOING TO MOVE TO THE CENTER
JONES. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I
WAS REALLY KIND OF ON THE ON THE
FENCE ON THIS BILL AND- TRYING
TO DECIDE WHICH WAY TO GO-
LAYOFF FOR VOTE NO OR YES- BUT
I'LL JUST I. YOU KNOW THE
TESTIMONY THIS MORNING MOVE ME.
WHEN WE HAVE THE BATS GOLDEN FOR
THE GOLDEN STATE. HOW CAN YOU
SAY NO TO THAT SO I'M GOING TO
VOTE FOR THE BILL TODAY SIR.
THANK YOU SIR PORTANTINO. YEAH
SENATE APPROVES CANDIDATE NO I.
OBVIOUSLY TAKEN BY THE- EXPERT
WITNESS- YOU KNOW THIS IS THE
SAME BAT CHANNEL AND- I HAVE TO
MENTION FOR THE RECORD THAT.
WAYNE MANOR AND THE BATCAVE ARE
BOTH IN MY DISTRICT. AND SO WE
NEED TO HAVE A STATE THAT SO-
HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY.
SENATOR RUBIO. THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN. I THINK YOU CAN HEAR
ME THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR- I YOU
KNOW I JUST WANT TO REITERATE
WHAT. SENATOR ASHLEY WAS
DISCUSSING- CENTER HAS BEEN. AYE
HAVING CONVERSATIONS WITH ALL OF
US AND JUST DISCUSSING HOW
BRIGHT AND HOW. ENTHUSIASTIC YOU
ARE ABOUT THE SUBJECT MATTER IN
I WANTED TO SHARE THAT YOU KNOW
I TOUGHEST SEVENTEEN YEARS AND I
ACTUALLY TODD NO FOURTH GRADERS
AND FIFTH GRADERS IN PUBLIC
SPEAKING SKILLS AND- YOUR
PRESENTATION WAS STELLAR SO I
THINK YOU NEED TO KNOW THAT
THAT'S REALLY. IMPRESSIVE
ESPECIALLY WHEN OF ALL THESE
ADULTS SO I WANT TO COMMEND YOU
AND SO I WILL BE SUPPORTING THE
BILL AS WELL AND I WANT TO THANK
SENATOR MENTOR BAR FOR BRINGING
THIS FAR THANK YOU FOR. ALL OF
COURSE THAT- ARCHULETA COURSE I
GOT A GOOD KNOWLEDGE ARE ARE ARE
AUTHOR THE I'VE GOT FIVE. AND I
DON'T THINK ANY OF MY FIVE KIDS
COULD HAVE DONE WHAT YOU DID YOU
COULD HAVE BROUGHT UP A HORSE A
PUPPY HAD DIED BUT I'VE I'VE
ALLIGATOR ANYTHING. AND WE WERE
TO FALL IN LOVE WITH YOU JUST TO
NAME IT. AFTER YOU AND THAT IS
YOUR BILL AND SO WITH THAT- I
DON'T KNOW IF ANYONE'S GONNA
MOVE BUT I SURELY WILL
CONGRATULATIONS. ON ON THIS AND
HAVE DEFINITELY BE VOTING FOR
THANK YOU OKAY. LOOK AT. THE
AUTHOR AND I THINK ALL THE
WITNESSES KNOW THAT I'VE BEEN
VERY CRANKY ON BILLS. THAT YOU
KNOW WHAT WE'VE GOT SO MUCH
GOING BEFORE THE STATE-
HOMELESSNESS AND EVERYTHING ELSE
THAT DRIVES ME CRAZY IN FACT
MISS RICHARDS. BROUGHT THIS UP.
AND THAT'S WHY DID THE
RESOLUTION FOR HER NOT A BILL.
BUT I WILL SAY THE TESTIMONY
THIS MORNING. THERE'S GOT ME FAR
LESS CRANKY. ED NAOMI YOU DID A
VERY NICE JOB. YET SO- THIS-
WILD AT THAT POINT I WOULD JUST
SAY BUT CENTER MENJIVAR GOOD JOB
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. I
REALLY APPRECIATE THE SUPPORT
COLLEAGUES A CHAIR FOR ALL YOUR
COMMENTS YOU KNOW I THINK. YOU
ARE OUR WHENEVER PURPOSES YES IS
TO ADDRESS THOSE REALLY CRUCIAL
ISSUES RIGHT THEY'RE GONNA.
BRING A DIRECT IMPACT BUT ALSO
WAS TO ELEVATE AND EMPOWER OUR
CONSTITUENTS IN OUR COMMITTEE
MEMBERS. WHEN I WAS ONE THING
WHEN THIS WAS BROUGHT TO MY
ATTENTION I WAS AT AN ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS SWEARING IN AND I
STEPPED ASIDE TO GET A
PRESENTATION BY KNOWING ME- AND
WITH A- DECK COULD PRESENTATION
AND IT WAS VERY VERY ELOQUENT
AND I WAS BLOWN AWAY. AND I'M SO
HONORED TO BE HERE STATE SENATOR
AND I AND I WANTED TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE BROUGHT OVER HER UP HERE
TO SACRAMENTO TO SEE THAT YOU
KNOW SMART AND- SMART KIDS LIKE
THIS. AND SHOULD BE PUT ASIDE
THE SHOULD BE ELEVATED I'M SO
PROUD TO BRING UP THIS BILL AND
SUPPORT HER AND I JUST
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL. THAT'S
AND I ALSO LOVE ALL THE
REFERENCE AND SHE MADE IT. THIS
RICHER TO NEW IT DO BRING MY DE
WRITING THE FOCUS ON THIS BILL
FOR TEACHER- WITH THAT WE HAVE A
MOTION BY SENATOR ASHBY. OF THE
MOTION IS TO PASS- TO THE FLOOR
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
GOD. I THOUGHT I A WILL RIGHT
WILK I EL DORADO GIL. ARCHULETA
ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY. ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD. ATTY BRADFORD I GLAZER
. FIVE GLAZER AYE JONES I JONES
I WENT. WHEN I OTOBO. IDEA
ENTERS THE ETHICALLY I HAD THE
AYE PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO AYE
ROTH ROTH AYE RUBIO HI RUBIO I
SEE RDO. SEE ART- I. THANK YOU
I'M IS A- THAT'S THIRTY WE'RE
GONNA HOLD FOR ABSENT MEMBERS
CONGRATULATIONS THAT BILL WILL
BE OUT THANK YOU SIR. IF YOU'RE
. SHE WOULD ASK ME. SO YES
SENATOR REID SO WE'RE GONNA MOVE
TO YOUR BILL FILE ITEM NUMBER
EIGHT. THAT'S SB. EIGHT TWENTY
TWO. THAT WAS GREAT. I THINK
THAT GIVES A BETTER CHANCE OF
ENDING HIS. RUBBISHES MAUREEN
JOBS. GOOD MORNING PLEASE
PROCEED GOOD MORNING MR CHAU
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND MEMBERS-
BOY BOY. I DO WANNA GIVE MY
PRESENTATION NOW. YEAH. OKAY OF
. UP FIRST- MISTER CHAIR I WANNA
AGREE WITH THE SUGGESTED
AMENDMENT ON PAGE FIVE OF THE
ANALYSIS- AND THIS MEANS THAT
THE- ON'T THIS'LL SUNSET OF THE
INTERAGENCY HIGHROAD TEAM ON
JANUARY FIRST TWENTY THIRTY. SB
EIGHT TWO TWO WILL ESTABLISH
AGREEMENTS BETWEEN STATE
AGENCIES TO ADVANCE HIGHROAD
PROCUREMENT CONTRACTING AND
INCENTIVE PROGRAMS THESE
AGREEMENTS SHALL INCLUDE
POLICIES AND PROGRAMS TO CREATE
SUPPORT HIGH QUALITY JOBS IN THE
ENERGY RESOURCES AND
TRANSPORTATION SECTORS AND
EXPAND EQUITABLE ACCESS TO THOSE
JOBS THROUGH HIGH QUALITY
EDUCATION AND TRAINING. THE BILL
CREATES AN INTERAGENCY HIGH ROAD
TEAM RESPONSIBLE FOR DEVELOPING
EVALUATION METRICS FOR
APPLICANTS SEEKING TO DO
BUSINESS WITH CALIFORNIA. IN
TWENTY TWENTY ARE A REPORT TO
THE LEGISLATURE ENTITLED PUTTING
CALIFORNIA ON THE HIGH ROAD JOBS
AND CLIMATE ACTION PLAN FOR
TWENTY THIRTY ONE KEY
RECOMMENDATION WAS THAT THAT
CALIFORNIA WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
BOARD TO DEVELOP A TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE TEAM. TO HELP
AGENCIES RESPONSIBLE FOR
IMPLEMENTING IN OUR CLIMATE
POLICIES AS THEY SEEK TO
INCORPORATE HIGH ROAD WORKFORCE
INTERVENTIONS. ARE AGENCIES
ADMINISTERING CLIMATE
INVESTMENTS AND POLICIES HAVE
LIMITED EXPERIENCE AND TRAINING
TO ASSESS WHEN WHERE AND HOW TO
INCORPORATE THESE TOOLS. WE ARE
IN THE MIDST OF AN INDUSTRY
CHANGING MOMENT IN
INFRASTRUCTURE MANUFACTURING AND
SUSTAINABILITY YET UNLIKE
PREVAILING WAGE AND PUBLICS
WORKS JOBS PUBLIC INVESTMENT IN
NON CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRIES LACK
THE ADMINISTRATIVE ENFORCEMENT
OUGHT TO MAKE AN IMPACT ON JOB
QUALITY. THE RESEARCH IS CLEAR
CURRENTLY A GREEN JOBS PAY 40%
LESS THAN FOSSIL FUEL JOBS
FOSSIL FUEL OCCUPATIONS PAYING
HOURLY WAGE THAT ALLOWS WORKING
ADULTS WITH LESS THAN A COLLEGE
DEGREE TO PROVIDE FOR THEIR
FAMILIES- NEEDS. THIS IS ABOUT
PROTECTING AND ENHANCING OUR
STATE INVESTMENTS. BUT TODAY I
HAVE A HOST SAID J. B. TANKO
FROM THE BLUEGREEN ALLIANCE- TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. GOOD MORNING
WHAT. GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS
JAY BE TANGO VICE PRESIDENT
STATE AFFAIRS FOR THE BLUEGREEN
ALLIANCE. THE BEEP THE BLUEGREEN
ALLIANCE WAS FOUNDED ON THE IDEA
THAT WE DON'T HAVE TO CHOOSE
BETWEEN CREATING GOOD JOBS AND
PROTECTING THE ENVIRONMENT WE
CAN AND MUST DO BOTH. AND TODAY
B. J. UNITES UNIONS AND THE
NATION'S LARGEST ENVIRONMENTAL
ORGANIZATIONS AT THE FEDERAL AND
STATE LEVEL. TO SOLVE TODAY'S
ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES IN A
WAY THAT CREATES AND MAINTAINS
QUALITY JOBS. ACROSS THE COUNTRY
WE SEE THE USE OF A WELL KNOWN
ECONOMIC FRAMEWORK THE HIGH ROAD
JOBS MODEL TO SERVE AS THE BASIS
FOR A NUMBER OF LAWS SPENDING
PROGRAMS AND STATE PLANNING
FRAMEWORKS. AT ITS CORE AT THE
HIGH ROAD FRAMEWORK ENERGY THREE
DELIVERABLES RELATED TO
ENVIRONMENT EQUITY. CLEAN CUT
CLIMATE AND HIGH QUALITY JOBS IN
OFF IN THE HIGH ROAD APPROACH IS
INSTITUTED VIA LEGISLATION
REQUIRING AGENCIES LIKE THE EPA
OR TRANSPORTATION. TO EMPLOYMENT
GOOD JOB SO THAT THE DEEP
EXPERTISE TO DO SO. WELL ANY
ATTEMPT UNDOUBTEDLY MOVED THE
BALL FORWARD WE ARE IN THE
MIDDLE OF A ONCE IN A GENERATION
MOMENT TO INVEST IN NEW
INFRASTRUCTURE CLEAN
MANUFACTURING AND A CLEAN
ECONOMY. AS WE BUILD THESE NEW
INDUSTRIES SB EIGHT TWENTY TWO
INSURANCE CALIFORNIA'S
COMMITMENT TO WORKER CENTERED
AGRO ECONOMY BY SETTING UP THE
ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPORT TO
DEVELOP AND ENFORCE HIGHROAD
STANDARDS. THROUGHOUT OUR STATE
AGENCIES. ARE STATE AGENCIES BE
TRANSPORTATION AIR BEAT ENERGY
COMMISSION ARE SKILLED AT
ENSURING THAT THE ADDRESS
CLIMATE GOALS ANOTHER POLICY
MANDATES. AND SB EIGHT TWENTY TO
ENSURE IS A DUAL APPROACH TO
BOTH ADDRESS THE CLIMATE
IMPERATIVE. WHILE PROACTIVELY
ENSURING THOSE POLICIES GREAT
HIGH ROAD SHOPS. ON THE OTHER
HAND WITHOUT S. B. EIGHT TWENTY
TWO CALIFORNIA CANNOT ENSURE
THAT OUR NEW INVESTMENTS WILL
LEAD TO A HIGH ROAD MIDDLE CLASS
JOB WITH ACCESS TO ALL. AS WE
FACE ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES
TODAY SB EIGHT TWENTY TWO. EIGHT
TWENTY TO ENSURE THAT WE DON'T
HAVE TO CHOOSE BETWEEN CREATING
GOOD JOBS. AND PROTECTING THE
ENVIRONMENT. RATHER IT LET'S
JUST DO BOTH. FOR THAT REASON WE
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYBODY
ELSE IN THE ROOM WISHING TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF SB EIGHT
TWENTY TWO. SO ANYBODY IN THE
ROOM WISHING TO TESTIFY IN
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE
MODERATOR COULD WE PLEASE- TO GO
TO THE TELECONFERENCE. LINE OPEN
HIM UP SEE IF ANYBODY'S WILLING
OR WISHING TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
OR OPPOSITION. PLEASE PRESS ONE
AND ZERO AT THIS TIME. FOLLOWING
A FEW MOMENTS WE HAVE KNOWN IN
CUBA STRUCTURE. THANK YOU BRING
THIS CONVERSATION BACK TO-
COMMITTEE. EDDIE WISHING TO-
DISCUSS THIS OR HAVE A MOTION.
WE HAVE A MOTION FROM SENATOR
RUBIO- CENTER WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE. I APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND THE URGE
AND I BOTH. OKAY THIS HAS- THIS
BILL SPEND- MOVE BY CENTER
CENTER RUBIO IT'S THE MOTION IS
DUE PASSES AMENDED. TO THE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
DODD. I THOUGHT I WILL NO. WILK
NO ALVOR AUTO KILL. ARCHULETA
ALL RIGHT ARCHULETA I ASHBY.
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD. GLAZER JONES
. JON SNOW WHEN. OTOBO HAVE YES
I HAVE YEAH I PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH ROTH AYE
RUBIO HI RUBIO ICE ZERO. C. R.
O. NO THAT'S IT HAS- SEVEN VOTES
THAT RENO'S AND WE'LL HAVE THAT
BILL ON CALL THANK YOU THANK YOU
SENATOR. NOW WILL MOVE TO FILE
ITEM NUMBER NINE SIR WILK. VICE
CHAIR WILK. FEEL FREE TO BEGIN
WHEN YOU'RE READY.
WE'RE GALA REGALIA FOR MORE.
THESE ROOMS. THANK YOU. THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBER I
PRESENT TO YOU TODAY I TWO SO
WHICH IS A BUILT RESOLVE A SO
PER. BACK IN TWENTY SIXTEEN-
ASSEMBLYMEN TOM DALY AND MYSELF
DID BIPARTISAN LEGISLATION THAT
WOULD PROTECT BARBER SHOPS AND
BEAUTY SALONS FROM SERVING A
COMPLIMENTARY GLASS OF WINE OR
OR BEER SELL THROUGH THE
LEGISLATURE AS IT SHOULD I
REPLY- FACTUALLY CALL THIS
VANESSA'S LAW AFTER MY WIFE WHO
WAS UNBEKNOWNST TO ME BREAKING
THE LAW EVERY TIME SHE WENT TO
THE BEAUTY SHOP. GO TO A- THIS
THIS PAST IN AND- SOME OFFICES
OF A. B. C. CLAIM THAT IT'S VERY
CLEAR IN STATUTE FOR BARBER
SHOPS BUT IT'S UNCLEAR IN BEAUTY
SHOPS AND SO ON BEHALF OF MY
WIFE AND MY MOTHER IN LAW CENTER
PORTANTINO. WE'VE INTRODUCED
THIS TO JUST CLEAN IT UP SO
THERE'S IT'S AN N. B. U. S. THAT
IT APPLIES TO BOTH BEAUTY SHOPS
AND BARBER SHOPS WITH THAT I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
. ATTESTS TO THE ANYBODY IN THE
ROOM IN SUPPORT. ANY OTHER ROOM
IN OPPOSITION. MODERATOR. WE'RE
GOING TO TAKE A LEAP ASSUME
NOBODY WILL BE ON BUT WE HAVE TO
GO THROUGH THE MOTIONS. WHY IS
IT WHY SHOULD IT LAND VERO
PLEASE. WIFE YEP THAT'S THE
OTHER AND SHE'S DRUNK. I HOPE
SHE'S NOT LISTENING SENATOR. BOB
YOU THOUGHT THAT WAS HOW. FREE
WE HAVE NO IN CASE. MODERATOR
THANK YOU MUCH GOOD HE TO- SO-
WE'RE BACK- WE'RE GONNA BRING
THIS BACK TO. WE HAVE JONES YES
YES YOU THERE CENTER DODD- I
JUST WANT THE OTHER KIDS. TO THE
STATUTE OF. ON THIS- I'M PRIOR
VIOLATIONS OF THIS LAW AND IF
THEIR EX IF THEY'RE OVER OR IF
YOU KNOW HOW LONG THOSE AS YET
YEAH ACTUALLY ARE OVER OKAY GOOD
THANK YOU. A MOVE THE BILL
CENTER. I HAVE THE MICROPHONE
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
VICE THE CHAIR RECOGNIZES THE
MOTION OF A CENTER SEYARTO- THE
MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE NO
NO NO NOT IT WILL NOT AMENDED.
YEAH YOU KNOW I'M GOING OFF THE
WRONG UNLESS YOU WANT TO MAKE IT
TWO GLASSES OF WINE TO HELP
YOUR- CONSTITUENT WINERIES. NOW
WE WILL DO THAT. OR WE COULD ASK
MOTIONS YOU HAD- CUTTING
COMMITTEE. SECTOR PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL THAT'S A SOLUTION DODD
I DODD I WILL AYE WILK AYE
ELDORADO GIL. ARCHULETA
ARCHULETA HI ASHBY ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD HE FISCAL. WE EYE LASER
EYE JONES J. I. WOULD BO IDEA I
HAD THE I POURED. WITH THE
UNDERSTANDING THAT THIS BILL IS
GOING TO APPROPRIATIONS AND I
WILL DOUBLE CHECK THAT THE
MOTHER IN LAW IS. BEHIND IT WITH
THAT CONDITION I WILL VOTE ON BY
PORTANTINO AYE. ROTH ROTH AYE
RUBIO. SEYARTO. EXACTLY RUBIO
AYE RUBIO AYE TODAY. SARAH I.
AND ALLOW. AS WELL VOTES BILL ON
CALL. THANK YOU MR CHERRY
MEMBERS THANK YOU SIR. CENTER
ARCHULETA WE HAVE A- FILE ITEM
NUMBER ELEVEN SB THREE EIGHTY
EIGHT. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS. TODAY I'M PRESENTING
SENATE BILL THREE EIGHTY EIGHT
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA BEER
INDUSTRY SB THREE EIGHTY EIGHT
ALLOWS BEER MANUFACTURE TAX
INFORMATION TO BE MADE PUBLIC
UPON REQUEST TO ASSIST THE BEER
INDUSTRY AND PLANNING FOR FUTURE
TRENDS. SENATE BILL THREE EIGHTY
EIGHT IS MODEL AFTER SENATE BILL
FIVE EIGHTEEN BY SENATOR CLEARED
. WHICH PASSED UNANIMOUSLY OUT
OF THE SENATE LAST YEAR TO HELP
CALIFORNIA'S WINE INDUSTRY SB
THREE EIGHTY EIGHT IS A CARBON
COPY OF THAT BILL AND EXTENDS
THE SAME BENEFITS TO OUR STATE'S
BEER INDUSTRY FOR DECADES THE
BOARD OF EQUALIZATION THAT
PROVIDED BEER MANUFACTURES
RETURN AND SCHEDULE INFORMATION
TO THE BEER INDUSTRY. THE DATA
RELEASED BY THE BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION HAS LARGELY BEEN
UNCENSORED INCLUDING SPECIFIC
BUSINESS INFORMATION. HOWEVER
BEGINNING IN TWENTY NINETEEN THE
BOARD OF EQUALIZATION
REEVALUATED THE RELEASE OF THE
DATA AND DETERMINED THAT THEY
DID NOT HAVE SUFFICIENT
STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO PROVIDE
THE DATA UNLESS SPECIFIC
INFORMATION WHAT'S- AND
ADVERSELY REQUESTED. THIS
DECISION HAS SIGNIFICANTLY
LIMITED THE DATA'S USEFULNESS
SENATE BILL THREE EIGHTY EIGHT
DIRECTLY ADDRESSES THIS ISSUE.
AND EQUIP THE BEER INDUSTRY TO
MAKE WELL INFORMED BUSINESS
DECISIONS. THE. THE BREWERS.
GUILDS AND ORGANIZATIONS
THROUGHOUT THE STATE FOR THIS
REASON I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE. AND WITH ME TODAY
IS CHRIS WALKER ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA CRAFT BREWERS
ASSOCIATION HERE IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL AND PREPARED TO
ANSWERING YOUR QUESTIONS YOU
BITE OUT. MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS A
COMMITTEE CHRIS WALKER ON BEHALF
THE CALIFORNIA CRAFT BREWERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL. OF THE TAX INFORMATION
THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT IS
SIMPLY THE PRODUCTION NUMBERS
IT'S NOT. PERSONAL INFOR
INFORMATION THAT WOULD BE
SENSITIVE IN ANYWAY THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ANYBODY WISHING TO.
TESTIFIED SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
COME FORWARD NOW. ANYBODY
WISHING TO TESTIFY OPPOSITION.
SEEING NOW I AM LOOKING TO MOVE
BACK TO- WE'RE GONNA GO TO THE
COP TELECONFERENCE LINE
MODERATOR. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
THEN ZERO. AND WE HAVE NO ONE IN
Q. MISTER CHAIR. OKAY THANK YOU
VERY MUCH WE'RE GOING TO GO BACK
TO- THE COMMITTEE IN THE
DISCUSSION. QUESTIONS WE GOT A
MOTION BY SENATOR GLAZER SAID
ARCHULETA WOULD YOU LIKE CLOTHES
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
. OKAY AGAIN WE HAVE- THE BILL'S
BEEN MOVED BY CENTER GLAZER- THE
MOTIONS TO PASS TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
I THOUGHT I THOUGHT I WILK RIGHT
WILK AYE ELDORADO GIL ARCHULETA
ALL RIGHT ARCHULETA I ASHBY.
ASHBY AYE BRADFORD. GLAZER AYE
GLAZER AYE JONES. JONES WENT.
FOR CHOI BO. VIA I FOR THE AYE
PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO AYE ROTH.
ROTH AYE RUBIO RUBIO I SEE RDO
SEE OUR TO. BECAUSE LOW VOTES
PUT THAT BILL ON CALL. SENATOR
GLAZERS. I REMEMBER THIRTEEN S.
C. R. FORTY SEVEN.
HAVING FUN AT THE SAME TIME.
CENTER PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU
CHAIR DIED THANK YOU YOU AND
YOUR STAFF FOR. ALLOWING ME TO
PRESENT S. C. R. FORTY SEVENS
YOU TO PROVIDE LONG OVERDUE
RECOGNITION FOR THE LOW IS NOT
WORKING THERE WE GO. WELL ALLEY
THANK THIS YEAR AT THE BEGINNING
SO I DON'T REALLY TO REPEAT
THAT. OKAY I'M- MEMBERS SAID
THIS RESOLUTION WITH WOULD
PROVIDE LONG OVERDUE RECOGNITION
TO THE LATE AT CHIEF JUSTICE
ROSE ELIZABETH BIRD- IT WOULD
RECOGNIZE HER MANY CONTRIBUTIONS
TO CALIFORNIA BY NAMING THAT THE
PEACE PLAZA WITHIN THE STATE
CAPITAL WORLD PEACE ROSE GARDEN.
AS CHIEF JUSTICE ROSE ELIZABETH
BIRD JUSTICE FOR ALL PLAZA. I
MANY OF YOU MAY NOT KNOW THAT-
THE CHIEF JUSTICE OR WAS AN
ACCOMPLISHED AT FIRST IN SO MANY
WAYS FOR WOMEN IN IN LAW. SHE
WAS THE FIRST FEMALE LAW CLERK
FOR THE NEVADA STATE SUPREME
COURT. SHE WAS THE FIRST FEMALE
DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDER IN SANTA
CLARA COUNTY. SHE WAS THE FIRST
WOMAN CABINET MEMBER FOR A
CALIFORNIA GOVERNOR THEN
GOVERNOR JERRY BROWN SHE WAS
CERTAINLY THE FIRST WOMAN CHIEF
JUSTICE OF THE STATE SUPREME
COURT. AND SHE WAS THE FIRST
FEMALE CHAIR OF THE JUDICIAL
COUNCIL. AND DESPITE HER
DISTINGUISHED CAREER THERE IS NO
PUBLIC RECOGNITION. OF THE CHIEF
JUSTICES OF THE CHIEF JUSTICE
CENTRAL ERROR FOR ERROR LONG
DEDICATED PUBLIC SERVICE TO OUR
STATE'S JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND HER
PRESS IMPRESSIVE
ACCOMPLISHMENTS. IN BREAKING THE
GLASS CEILING FOR WOMEN IN LAW.
SO S. C. R. FORTY SEVEN WOULD
GIVE AN APPROPRIATE RECOGNITION
TO THE CHIEF JUSTICE. IN THE
STATE CAPITAL WORLD PEACE ROSE
GARDEN PEOPLE FROM ALL OVER
COULD COMMENT LEARN ABOUT HER.
SERVICE TO CALIFORNIA- WITH ME
TODAY IS SYLVIA VIA LOBOS IS THE
CO CREATOR AND PRESIDENT OF THE
INTERNATIONAL. WORLD PEACE ROSE
GARDEN TO TESTIFIED SUPPORT. WHO
. THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY
TO VOICE OUR SUPPORT FOR THIS-
PROJECT. IDEA SYLVIA JUST HAD
TAKEN LOW QUICKER BREAK FOR JUST
A MOMENT SHOULD BE RIGHT BACK
BUT- I KNOW WAIT TIMES OF THE
ESSENCE SLICE ONCE VOICE OUR
SUPPORT I THINK IT'S A CENTER
GLAZER I THINK HE'S SPOT ON.
BECAUSE I THINK THAT YOU KNOW HE
IF YOU. LOOK IN THE STATE
CAPITAL HERE WE HAVE TO EARN
SIXTY THOUSAND CHILDREN COME
FIRST A CAP EVERY YEAR. SO MANY
THE OF THE BUSES THAT PARK RIGHT
FROM THE WORLD PEACE ROSE GARDEN
AND THEY JUST FLOOD THE WORLD
PEACE ROSE DURING THE KIDS LOOKS
LIKE AN INVASION ALMOST. BUT
IT'S AMAZING THE KIDS GO THROUGH
THE READ THE POEMS IN THE GARDEN
THEIR SPELLING THE ROSES JUST
ENJOYED THE EXPERIENCE AND SO
IT'S OF THE AMAZING THING AND
HERE'S AN OPPORTUNITY AND I KNOW
IF I HAD A DAUGHTER I'D WONDERED
LEARN ABOUT JUSTICE BURKE MYSELF
BECAUSE SHE IS A REAL ROLE
MODEL. SO I TOTALLY SUPPORT THIS
I THINK IT'S A GREAT IDEA SO WE
SHOULD GREAT SUCCESS AND WE
WELCOME YOU TO THE WORLD PEACE
ROSE GARDEN AS WELL FOR THE
RECORD YOUR NAME YES I'M TJ
DAVID- THAT WHAT MEAN CELL THE
OTHER CO FOUNDER THE CREATORS OF
THIS GARDEN. THANK WORKING WITH
PART GENERAL SERVICES TO CREATE
SCARRED STATE CAPITOL PARK.
THANK YOU. PLEASE SO VIA LOBOS.
OF INTERNATIONAL WORLD PEACE
ROSE GARDENS. ALONG WITH TJ. AND
I'M NOT SURE ALL WITH TJ SAID
BUT- WE TOTALLY EMBRACE.
HONORING WOMEN IN THE GARDEN.
THAT TRADITIONALLY HAVE NOT HAVE
BEEN EXCLUDED FROM PLACES. AND
SO WE ARE VERY MUCH. FEEL THAT
THIS IS PART OF OUR INTENT. AND
SO WE FULLY SUPPORT. OUT NAY
MEAN. PART OF THE GARDEN FOR.
CHIEF JUSTICE. ROSE BIRD. THANK
YOU. ANYBODY ELSE THE ROOM
WISHING TO EXPRESS SUPPORT.
ANYBODY WISHING TO EXPRESS ANY
OPPOSITION. MODERATOR COULD WE
CHECK THE LIGHTS TO SEE IF
ANYBODY'S ON. ON THE BEACH US
ONE AND- ONE AND THEN ZERO
PLEASE. ALLOWING A FEW MONTHS-
ONE MOMENT WE HAVE A LATE CALLER
. JUST A MOMENT. ALL RIGHT AND
THAT WE WILL. YOUR FROM LINE
THIRTY BLIND. HI MY NAME IS
BORNE JONES I'M PRESIDENT A
WOMAN LAWYER SACRAMENTO AND WE
SUPPORT S. C. R. FORTY SEVEN.
THANK YOU WE HAVE NO FURTHER IN
Q. OKAY WE'RE GONNA BRING THAT
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE- CENTER
ASHBY YEAH THANK YOU SO MUCH AND
THAT SENATOR GLAZERS THANK YOU
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD. NOT
ONLY WHAT I LIKE TO MOVE IT AT
THE APPROPRIATE TIME BUT I'D
LIKE TO BE A CO AUTHOR IF YOU
WOULD HAVE ME I HAVING COME FROM
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT HERE I KNOW
THE CAPITAL BELONGS TO EVERYONE
BUT IT SITS SQUARELY IN THE
MIDDLE OF SACRAMENTO IN. AND
WE'VE TRIED FOR THE LAST FEW
YEARS TO INCREASE THE NAMES OF
PARKS AND TO HONOR WOMEN WITH
STATUES AND- AND I PROBABLY
DON'T HAVE TO TELL YOU THAT TO
IT IS A- GROSSLY UNBALANCED-
SYSTEM RIGHT NOW AND SO I LOVE
THAT YOU ARE HONORING SOMEONE SO
SPECIAL TO THE ENTIRE CITY
CALIFORNIA RIGHT HERE. IN THE
CITY OF SACRAMENTO ON THE
CAPITOL GROUNDS AND I'M GRATEFUL
TO YOU FOR DOING SO THANK YOU.
SENATOR PER DIEM JUST BRIEFLY
MISTER MOORE THANK THE AUTHOR I
THINK IT'S AN IMPORTANT GESTURE
FOR THE STATE AND REFLECTING ON
THIS I DO RECALL. THE INCREDIBLE
PERSONAL VILIFICATION THE FORMER
CHIEF THE LATE CHIEF JUSTICE AND
TOURED- TWEET THIRTY YEARS AGO
OR SO WHEN I MEMBER THAT
CAMPAIGN VERY CLEARLY. AND IT
TURNS OUT OFTEN THE LENS OF
HISTORY UPON REFLECTION GIVES US
A CLEAR PICTURE OF CHARACTER.
AND THE CHIEF JUSTICE WAS WELL
AHEAD OF OUR TIME AND WELL
DESERVING THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
. VIDEO CENTER WILL. I'M GONNA
VOTE I'M GONNA VOTE FOR THIS
TODAY BUT I'M A LITTLE BIT
FRUSTRATED NOT WITH YOU'RE NOT
WITH ANYBODY IN THIS ROOM
BECAUSE NO ONE WAS HERE BUT IN
ANOTHER COMMITTEE. WE'RE HAVING-
DISCUSSING THE CASTE SYSTEM IN
HERE IN THE STATE CAPITAL WE
HAVE A CASTE SYSTEM. AND IT'S
REPUBLICANS AND CONSERVATIVES
THAT. HER IN THE LOWER CAST
BEFORE WE ALL GOT HERE THERE
WAS. A BILL. TO APPROVED- REAGAN
STATUTE. SO THAT HAVE BEFORE WE
ALL GOT HERE MY FIRST YEAR HERE.
THE REGULATE RECALLED ME IN SAID
THE STATUES DONE AND- THE
MAJORITY PARTY DOESN'T WANT TO
PUT IT ANYWHERE. IT LITERALLY
TOOK. EIGHT MONTHS TO NEGOTIATED
BECAUSE THEY WANT TO JUST STICK
THE PRESIDENT OUTSIDE. HE WAS
GOVERNOR HE WAS PRESIDENT HE WON
THE COLD WAR HE DID A LOT OF
OTHER GREAT THINGS AND THEY WANT
TO STICK UP NOW HE'S IN THE
BASEMENT. WHICH WE HAD TO CALL
THE LOWER RETURNED- IN ORDER TO
GET THE LIBRARY TO SIGN OFF ON
IT. SO I'M FINE WITH DOING THIS
BUT I WISH. IT BE MORE
EQUITABLE- BUT IT'S NOT I GUESS
IS THE WITH THE IS THE WINNERS
TO WRITE HISTORY. AND I'M GOING
TO SUPPORT IT BUT I'M I'M A
LITTLE FRUSTRATED THAT WE DON'T
GET THE SAME CONSIDERATION.
OFFERED THINGS THAT WE BELIEVE
IN ALL. OKAY CENTER GLAZER WOULD
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. I JUST TO
ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE
FRUSTRATIONS THAT SOMETIMES
POLITICS PLAY AND THESE
RECOGNITIONS. IT'S BEEN NOT
TWENTY SEVEN YEARS SINCE SHE WAS
OFF THE COURT. CONSIDERABLE
AMOUNT OF TIME- THERE HAVE BEEN
EFFORTS TO TRY TO- PROVIDE
RECOGNITIONS THAT HAVE NOT. BEEN
SUCCESSFUL. AT HAVING THAT. MANY
PEOPLE MAY NOT KNOW THAT I WORK
FOR THE CHIEF JUSTICE. SO I HAD
TO INCIDENT. ANALOGY OF HOW SHE
APPROACHED HER JOB- AND HOW THE
COURAGE THAT SHE HAD TO DO HER
BEST WORK FOR JUSTICE. EVEN WHEN
THINGS WEREN'T POPULAR. AT THE
APPRECIATE YOUR CONSIDERATION
TODAY AT THIS COMMITTEE AND-
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU THE BILL'S
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR ASHBY THE
MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
DODD. GOD I WILL HI WILK AYE
ELDORADO GIL ARCHULETA.
ARCHULETA AYE ASHBY ASHBY AYE
BRADFORD GLAZER. PLEASE R. I.
JONES. JOE NO WAY. OCHO IDEA. HI
OF THE AYE PORTANTINO. ROTH ROTH
AYE RUBIO HI RUBIO ICY ARDO.
BILL HAS- EIGHT VOTES ONE
THOUGH- IN THAT WILL BE ON CALL
- THE REST OF THE BILLS ARE MINE
SO I'M GONNA HAND OVER THE GAVEL
TO VICE CHAIR. WILK. I GUESS
FOR. IT. PRIVACY AGAINST. WAS
ONE STEP AHEAD. I WAS ABLE.
NINETY WELL RIGHT. HE SAID THAT
. THIS CHAIR MEMBERS- S. B.
SEVENTY FOUR PROHIBITS THE
DOWNLOADING AND USING HIGH RISK
SOCIAL MEDIA APPS ON STATE OWNED
DEVICES. I WOULD LIKE TO START
BY ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS ON
PAGE SEVEN OF THE ANALYSIS
PROVIDING EXCEPTION EXEMPTIONS
FROM FOR OFFICIAL STATE
COMMUNICATIONS AND LAW
ENFORCEMENT OR CYBER SECURITY
USE. SOCIAL MEDIA APPS ARE
UBIQUITOUS IN OUR DAILY LIVES
BUT THERE'S A GROWING CONCERN
ABOUT INFORMATION THEFT AND DATA
COLLECTION THAT COMES WITH THEIR
USE ESPECIALLY ON STATE DEVICES
PROHIBITING THESE APPS ON STATE
MOBILE PHONES IS A COMMON SENSE
WAY TO PREVENT EXPOSURE MARC
SENSITIVE MATERIAL IN THE
POSSIBLE TRACKING OF USERS OF
DATA BREACHES. THIS BILL DEFINES
HIGH RISK GAP AS AN APPLICATION
OWNER CONTROLLED BY COUNTRY OF
CONCERN AS LISTED IN FEDERAL LAW
. THIS BILL DOES NOT APPLY TO
ANY PERSONAL MOBILE DEVICE NOR
DOES IT PROHIBIT EMPLOYEES FROM
USING ANY APP ON THEIR PERSONAL
TIME. ACCORDING DEPARTMENT
TECHNOLOGY THERE APPROXIMATELY
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND STATE
ISSUED DEVICES IN CALIFORNIA. SB
SEVENTY FOUR SIMILAR TO ACTIONS
ALREADY TAKEN TO PROTECT
GOVERNMENT DATA IN THE MAJORITY
OF THE STATE'S IT AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL CLEARLY THERE ARE BAD
ACTORS OUT THERE AND WE CAN'T
AFFORD TO LET THEM IN
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU FOR THAT DO WE HAVE
ANY- LEAD WHEN THIS ISN'T
SUPPORT. I LEAVE WITH A SENSE OF
WHAT WORKS ARE YOU ME TO INTO
OUR I'VE- IN FOR THE WATER YES-
IF YOU'RE IN BETWEEN- YOU. KNOW
I'M I'M SUPPORTING THE BILL
OKAY- ROBERT WROTE THE CONSUMER
FEDERATION CALIFORNIA- WE
SUPPORT- CENTER DOGS AFTER HERE
I THINK WHAT'S IMPORTANT TO
POINT OUT TO THE COMMITTEE IS
NUMBER ONE. IT DOES NOT NAME
APPS WE THINK IT'S A MISTAKE TO
NAY MAPS- RATHER THERE'S A
TRIGGER THERE'S A DEFINITIONAL
PROCESS THAT LINKS AS THE CENTER
SAID TO FEDERAL LOTS ULTRA- AT
NUMBER TWO IF YOU LOOK AT THOSE
DEFINITIONS. THERE THERE HAS TO
BE SORT OF A PROCESS- IT THERE'S
A FEW THAT COULD ARGUABLY MEET
THIS FOR IT NOT BEYOND TECH
TALK- ONE COULD ARGUE THE
TELEGRAPH- BECAUSE THEIR
CONNECTION TO THE RUSSIAN
GOVERNMENT SO WE THINK THIS IS A
WISE WAY TO GO. I THINK IT'S
MUCH MORE REASONABLE APPROACH
THEM WITH SOME OTHER STATES HAVE
DONE AND WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU I CENTER
JONES IS A JOINT AUTHORS THIS
BILL AT THE END WOULD YOU LIKE
TO SAY SUB CENTRE JONES. I JUST
WANNA. WAS CHAIRING THIS IN. IT
ONE OF MY SPEECH. OKAY YES I AM
A JOY AUTHORS- WAS GLAD TO ENJOY
THE CENTER DOT ON THIS EVERY
WHEN YOU IT FOR- IN. IN MY
OFFICE MY COMMUNICATIONS ARE UP
DEPARTMENT WE HAD SOME SUCCESS
ON SOME OF THESE APPS- BUT IN
LIGHT OF THE CONCERNS HAVE BEEN
RAISED BOTH AT THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT LEVEL AND THE STATE
GOVERNMENT OF LIGHT TURNED ONE
OF THOSE APPS OFF. AND AND HAVE
COMMUNICATED I'M HOPEFUL THAT
THEY'LL GET TO THE POINT WHERE
THEY CAN SHOW THAT THERE. ARE
RELIABLE AND TRUSTWORTHY. AND
TURN IT BACK ON SO BUT UNTIL
THAT TIME- I THINK THIS BILL IS
NECESSARY- OBVIOUSLY SUPPORTED
AND WOULD LIKE TO MAKE THE
MOTION TO APPROVE IT. AND I KNOW
YOU'RE YOU'RE TOO MODEST TO SAY
THIS BUT YOU ARE ACTUALLY AN
INFLUENCER ON ONE OF THOSE. ONE
OF THOSE PLATFORMS AND SO FOR
YOU TO GIVE THAT UP. AND IT'S
GREAT SERVICE TO YOUR COUNTRY
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT- ANYONE IN
THE ROOM IN A IN OPPOSITION.
SEEING NINE. THIS TRANSITION TO
THE PHONES MODERATOR. PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THAT IS THE ROUTE
THIS TIME. ALLOWING A FEW
MOMENTS WE HAVE NO ONE IN Q.
THANK YOU PULL IT BACK TO THE
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS COMMENTS
CONCERNS. WE HAVE A MOTION FROM
CENTER ASHBY WITH THAT. SENATOR
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. SPECS
WE ASK YOU HAVE A- WELL DONE.
YOU GET A CHANCE IF YOU COULD
CALL THE ROLL. WHAT IS SENATOR
ASHBY HAVE THE MAGICAL ICE I
MOTION BUTTON OVER THERE AT.
THAT SOME OF US ARE GETTING YOU
KNOW JUST OVER HERE ON THE SIDE
OF THE DÍAS ON THE ON THE
MOTIONS. OKAY. YES OKAY CALL THE
ROLL. YOU WERE TALKING BEFORE
YOU HEAR ME. SB SEVENTY FOUR
DEEP PASSES A MANAGING
PREPARATIONS DODD. I THOUGHT I
WILL HI. I EL DORADO GIL.
ARCHULETA ALL RIGHT ARCHULETA
ASHBY. ASHBY AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER AYE LASER
AYE JONES. JONES I WENT. OCHO
ABOUT IDEA FOR THE AYE
PORTANTINO. ROTH ROTH AYE RUBIO
AYE RUBIO I SEE RDO. SEE ART- I
. ELEVEN EYES NO NOSE WILL LEAVE
THAT OPEN FOR OTHER MEMBERS TO
ADD ON NOW WE'RE GOING TO
TRANSITION TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
FIFTEEN S. B. TWO SEVEN SEVEN.
YOU MAY PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE
READY AS CHAIR MEMBERS SB TWO
SEVEN SEVEN WILL ALLOW WHAT TYPE
TWENTY LICENSEES THE ABILITY TO
SELL LOW ALCOHOL BY VOLUME
SPIRIT BASED READY TO DRINK
PRODUCTS. AS THE NAME SUGGESTS.
READY TO DRINK BEVERAGES OR RTDS
ARE PREMIXED. THE PACKAGE SINGLE
SERVE ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES THAT
HAVE BECOME INCREASINGLY POPULAR
FOR THEIR CONVENIENCE QUALITY
AND VARIETY. IN CALIFORNIA
RETAILERS HOLD WHO HOLDS A TYPE
TWENTY LICENSE ARE PROHIBITED
FROM SELLING SPIRIT BASED RTDS
EVEN WHEN THOSE PRODUCTS CONTAIN
THE SAME OR LESS AMOUNT OF
ALCOHOL COMPARED TO MALT BASED
OR Y. BASED RTDS. BOTH OF WHICH
THEY ARE PERMITTED TO SELL. EVEN
WHEN A PERSON WANTS TO OBTAIN
AND OFF SALE GENERAL LICENSE IN
ORDER TO SELL THESE PRODUCTS
THOSE CAN BE QUITE EXPENSIVE ON
THE OPEN MARKET AND SOMETIMES
IMPOSSIBLE TO OBTAIN BECAUSE OF
THE SCARCITY OF THOSE LICENSES.
ALL THIS RESULTS IN CONFUSION BY
CUSTOMER CUT CONSUMERS
FRUSTRATION FROM BUSINESSES
BECAUSE THERE IS INABILITY TO
SELL POPULAR PRODUCTS IN LIMITS
MANY FACTORS ABILITY TO RESPOND
TO CONSUMER DEMAND. THIS BILL
WILL ALLEVIATE THE COSTLY BURDEN
OF SEEKING A GENERAL LICENSE
ALLOW SMALLER LOCAL RETAILERS
THE ABILITY TO EVOLVE WITH THE
RAPIDLY GROWING MARKET IT GIVE
CONSUMERS. GREATER CHOICE.
REPEAT THAT A GIVE CONSUMERS
GREATER CHOICE. I'VE HAD A
NUMBER OF MEETINGS WITH THE
OPPOSITION IN THE LAST COUPLE
WEEKS AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT WE
CAN COME TO AN AGREEMENT ON A
NUMBER OF ISSUES THAT HAVE BEEN
RAISED SPECIFICALLY AROUND THE
CONCERNS REGARDING THE- AB V.
LANGUAGE. PROVIDING THE
DEPARTMENT ABC CAN PLAY AN
ADEQUATE ROLE. HOWEVER I DO WANT
TO BE CLEAR THAT IS CHAIR OF
THIS COMMITTEE FOR NEARLY SEVEN
YEARS I'VE ALWAYS STRESSED THAT
I'M NOT INTERESTED. IN PICKING
WINNERS OR LOSERS AND I DON'T
BELIEVE IT IS THE ROLE OF THIS
COMMITTEE- OR THE- OR IN ANY
COMMITTEE IN THIS. INSTITUTION
TO STIFLE COMPETITION IN THE
MARKETPLACE I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE IN THE ABILITY
TO CONTINUE WORKING ON THIS
ISSUE WITH ME HERE TODAY ARE
ADAM SMITH VICE PRESIDENT
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS WITH THE-
DISTILLED SPIRITS COUNCIL OF THE
UNITED STATES. AND JOHN LATIMER
WITH THE CALIFORNIA RETAILERS
ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU. TWO
MINUTES. THANK YOU MEMBERS ADAM
SMITH DISTILLED SPIRITS COUNCIL
FIRST LIKE TO THANK THE AUTHOR
AND HIS STAFF AND COMMITTEE
STAFF FOR THEIR WORK. ON THIS
ISSUE- THIS LEGISLATION SEEKS TO
OFFER. ADULT DRINKING AGE
CONSUMERS MORE CONVENIENCE WHEN
THEY ARE SHOPPING FOR A LOW
ALCOHOL CONTENT SPIRITS BASED
PRE MADE CONTACT COCKTAIL I KNOW
THAT'S A MOUTHFUL. OF MORE
COMMONLY KNOWN AS AN R. T. D. OR
READY TO DRINK AS A SENATOR
DODD. HAS ALREADY STATED. THESE
LOW ALCOHOL BY VOLUME SPIRITS
PRODUCTS ARE RELATIVELY NEW TO
THE MARKET PLACE AS CONSUMERS
ARE DEMANDING A GENUINE
COCKTAIL. MADE FROM HIGH QUALITY
SPIRITS AND OTHER MIXERS WITH
LOW CALORIES AND A LOW ALCOHOL
CONTENT. AS PREVIOUSLY MENTIONED
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW LOCAL CALL
SPIRITS PRODUCTS TO BE SOLD
ALONGSIDE A BEER OR WINE BASED
PRODUCT WITH THE EXACT OR
SIMILAR ALCOHOL CON. EXCUSE ME
CONTACT AT A TYPE TWENTY
LICENSED RETAILER. THERE'S
ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE IN THE
ALCOHOL CONTENT OF A 5% A. B. V.
BEER. WINE OR SPIRITS BASED RGD.
IT IS ALL ETHANOL. THE BODY ONLY
REACTS TO HOW MUCH YOU DRINK NOT
WHAT YOU DRINK. AS NEW PRODUCTS
INTO THE MARKETPLACE LAW SHOULD
BE UPDATED TO REFLECT THE
EVOLVING PRODUCT OFFERINGS FROM
ALL ALCOHOL MANUFACTURERS. AND
THAT IS WHAT SB TWO SEVENTY
SEVEN WOULD DO. RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR SUPPORT OF SMALL BUSINESSES
CONSUMERS AND FOR SB TWO SEVEN
SEVEN. THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS JOHN LATIMER ON BEHALF
OF DIAGEO AND ALSO CALIFORNIA
RETAILERS ASSOCIATION CONCUR
WITH THE COMMENTS OF MY
COLLEAGUE. I'M AGAIN I THINK WE
JUST SEE THIS AS A MODERNIZATION
OF ALCOHOL LAWS AS NEW PRODUCTS
ARE BEING OFFERED GIVING
CONSUMERS AND RETAILERS AN
OPPORTUNITY TO OFFER OTHER
BEVERAGES. I THINK IT'S
IMPORTANT IT'S REFLECTED IN
ALICE'S BUT THIS THIS PRODUCT
WILL NOT BE AN OUT LIAR IF YOU
WILL WITHIN THE OFFERINGS OF A
TYPE TWENTY LICENSE THEY'RE
ALREADY SELLING QUITE A NUMBER
OF DIFFERENT MALL BASED. AND
WINE BASED. READY TO DRINK
COCKTAILS MIKE'S HARD LEMONADE
TO NAME A FEW MIKE'S HARD
LEMONADE SMIRNOFF ICE JACK
DANIELS COUNTRY COOLER- AND THE
LIST GOES ON. THE POINT IS THIS
IS ANOTHER OFFERING VERY SIMILAR
TO WHAT CONSUMERS ARE FINDING
ALREADY ON CHERYL'S IN IT'S JUST
SIMPLY TRYING TO GIVE- THOSE
RETAILERS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
CARRY. HIM VERY SIMILAR PRODUCTS
SAME LOW ALCOHOL CONTENT BY
VOLUME WE APPRECIATE THE
CONSIDERATION THANK YOU THANK
YOU SIR. ANYONE ELSE IN THERE IN
THE ONE SALUTE- ADDED ME TO IN
TERMS OF SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
THANK YOU TERRY MEMBERS KATE
BALLOT BEHALF OF PRINTER CARDS
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
SEEING NO ONE ELSE DO WE HAVE
ANY LEAD WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION
. THANK YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
TEMAS SLOPER FOR THE CALIFORNIA
BEER AND BEVERAGE DISTRIBUTORS
WHAT I'VE LEARNED FROM THIS BILL
IS DON'T GET OFFER CALL YOU GET
SELECT BE LEAD WITNESS.
REGRETTABLY WE HAVE TO OPPOSE
THE TERMS BILL IT IS A MAJOR
CHANGE IN TIED HOUSE LAW WILL BE
THE FIRST TIME THAT A TYPE
TWENTY APPEARING LICENSEE WOULD
WOULD BE ABLE TO SPEND SELL
DISTILLED PRODUCTS. THAT'S
SYNCED CONVENIENCE STORES GAS
MANY MARKETS MOM AND POP STORES
. BY DOUBLING THESE BY DOING
THIS WE'RE DOUBLING THE LOCATION
SECOND BUY DISTILLED PRODUCTS.
ONE OF THE RETAILER GETS A
LICENSE BEARD OF BEER AND WINE
LICENSE OR JUST A LICENSE THAT
THEY MAKE A COMMITMENT BY THE
POSTING THAT THEY MAKE. THAT
THEY WILL ENFORCE THE LAWS OF
THAT OF THAT LICENSE IN THE CASE
OF BEER AND WINE LICENSES BEER
AND WINE ONLY. AND IN THE CASE
OF DISTILLED SPIRITS IT'S A
COMMITMENT TO THE COMMUNITY THAT
THEY THAT THEY'RE- AWARE OF THE
DIFFERENCE. WE BELIEVE THAT THE
USE CASH SHOULD NOT AND CANNOT
BE CHANGED. THIS THIS ROUTE THIS
BILL ALSO ROUTE IMPACTS
RETAILERS INVESTMENT. BY BY
DOING THIS BILL YOUR THE
COMMITTEE'S ANALYSIS POINTS OUT
THAT A BEER AND WINE LICENSES
WORTH SOMEWHERE AROUND TWO
THOUSAND DOLLARS CENTER AND A
WARRANTED AND OF DISTILLED
SPIRITS WITH WINE. AND LICENCES
WORTH WELL OVER A HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS NOW IF I'M A
SMALL BUSINESSMAN I PROBABLY PUT
PART OF MY LIFE SAVINGS INTO
DOING THIS AND EXPECT TO GET A
RETURN ON MY INVESTMENT WE
BELIEVE. THAT THIS WILL HARM
THOSE PEOPLE THAT HAVE MADE
THOSE THOSE LARGE INVESTMENTS.
I'M NOT AN LAST WEEK. WE BELIEVE
THAT ALSO THIS WILL CREATE. BY
POWER OF THE OF. THE ROOM. THE
DOLLAR WHICH MEANING THAT THE
TURNS WERE HIRED DOLLAR TURN AND
DISTILLED IT WILL IT WILL NOW
CREATE A FIGHT FOR THE COLD BOX
IN THE SHELVES. IN THE BEER AND
WINE LICENSES WITHOUT THEM.
TAKING THE LEAD DOING WHAT THEY
COULD DO AND BY A TYPE TWENTY
ONE LICENSE WITH THOSE REACH FOR
THOSE REASONS WE MUST OPPOSE
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT A
GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS AND MAN
DO I NOT LOOK FORWARD TO EVER
OPPOSING SENATOR DODD'S BILL. AS
A HE'S DAM IS CHAIR OF THE
SELECT COMMITTEE ON ONE- MY
MEMBERS LOOK AT THIS BILL. AND
THEY COME TO A PRETTY SIMPLE
CONCLUSION HERE WERE GOING TO
LOSE SHELF SPACE AND LOSE SALES.
AND WITH THIS BILL OFFICES
FOURTEEN THOUSAND OVER. VENUES
IN CALIFORNIA THAT WOULD BE ABLE
TO DO SO WITHOUT ANY PUBLIC
NOTICE OR ANY ROLE FOR THE ABC
TO DO SO WHERE DID YOU SEE AN
ENTIRE NEW CATEGORY- INTO THESE
RETAILERS. AND WE BELIEVE THAT
THERE SHOULD AB MORE PROCESS
AND- ESPECIALLY SO CONSIDERING
THAT WHEN THESE LICENSES WERE
GRANTED THEY WERE DONE SO WITH
THE IDEA OF BEER AND WINE WITH
NO CONSIDERATION WHATSOEVER. IS
IF THEY SHOULD BE CARING
COCKTAILS SO FOR THESE REASONS
WERE CURRENTLY OPPOSED. THANK
YOU SO MUCH. ANYONE IN THE ROOM
THAT THAT'S GOING TO ADD A ME
TOO IN OPPOSITION. NAME
ORGANIZATION POSITION. GEORGE
MILLER A CALIFORNIA FAMILY BEER
DISTRIBUTORS A POST THANK YOU
SIR. THANK YOU SENATOR SACRIFICE
WITHIN HAUSER BUSH RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSE THANK YOU. GERMAN MEMBERS
THE COMMITTEE CHRIS WALKER ON
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA CRAFT
BREWERS ASSOCIATION OPPOSED
THANK YOU. EMILY PAPPAS FOR
MOLSON COORS RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE
THANK YOU. FRED JONES ON BEHALF
CALIFORNIA COUNCIL ON ALCOHOL
PROBLEMS A POST THANK YOU.
MICHAEL SKIP ON BEHALF OF
ALCOHOL JUSTICE RESPECTFULLY
OPPOSE THANK YOU SIR. ALL RIGHT
LET'S TURN TO THE PHONES.
MODERATOR. THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN
FROM THE PHONES PLEASE PRESS ONE
AND THEN. ZERO BARRING A FEW
MOMENTS WE HAVE NO ONE IN Q.
RIGHT THANK YOU MODERATOR
DENTIST FIND JOB THIS MORNING K.
WILL PULL BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
I'M GOING TO CALL ON SENATOR
ASHBY FOR QUESTION. YEAH I JUST
WANTED TO ASK THE AUTHOR AYE I
KNOW BECAUSE YOU KNOW YOUR STUFF
TOLD US HE DIDN'T HAVE AS MUCH
TIME AS YOU WANTED TO WORK WITH
SOME OF THE OPPONENTS SEN SO I
PLAN ON SUPPORTING IT TODAY BUT
JUST WANTED TO ASK YOU ABOUT
YOUR INTENT TO WORK I KNOW A LOT
OF PEOPLE GOT OF INSPECTOR SOME
OF YOUR- STRONG. A PARTNERS AND
SO I WANTED TO GIVE YOU A CHANCE
TO JUST TALK ABOUT THAT YEAH YOU
KNOW WHAT WE MET THE OTHER DAY I
DON'T KNOW THAT WE'RE GOING TO.
BE ABLE TO AGREE ON EVERYTHING
IT'S GETS KIND OF INTERESTING
BECAUSE MANY OF THE SAME PEOPLE
I HAVE RUN BILLS FOR THEM THE DO
SIMILAR THINGS TO THE TIED
HOUSE. EXEMPTION SO THAT THEIR
CLIENTS. COULD MEET THE MARKET.
IT'S I THINK IT'S REALLY
INTERESTING THAT- LOOK AT AND
EVERYBODY'S GOT TO PROTECT.
THEIR OWN- YOU KNOW PRODUCT PLUS
THEY WORK FOR THESE COMPANIES
THAT- YOU KNOW POTENTIALLY ARE
THAT YOU'LL HAVE SOME- YOU KNOW
CONCERTS. MAY BE LEGITIMATE MAY
BE FAR FETCHED I THINK ON THE-
LIKE ON THE VALUE OF THE
LICENSES. THE VALUE OF THE
LICENSE OF HARD LIQUOR IS IT HAS
NOTHING TO DO WITH THE RTDS. IT
HAS EVERYTHING TO DO WITH. YEAH
JACK DANIELS AND- VICTOR'S ALL
OF THE- DIFFERENT BRUISES AND
EVERYTHING THAT BUT YES I WILL
CONTINUE WORKING GREAT THANK
YOU. GENERAL THANK YOU. SIR I'M
JUST WONDERING IF THERE'S A WAY
TO MOVE THIS FORWARD OBVIOUSLY
I'LL BE SUPPORTING YOU TODAY- TO
ADDRESS THE SHELF SPACE ISSUE I
KNOW IN THE IN THE RETAIL
OPERATIONS WHETHER IT'S- BEER
WINE LIQUOR. MILK OR ANYTHING
ELSE- TENDS TO BE PRETTY
CRITICAL IN SOME SPACES I'M JUST
WONDERING IF THERE'S A WAY TO
ADDRESS THAT ISSUE IN TERMS OF-
PERHAPS LIMITING THE NUMBER OF
THE R. T. THE- PERCENTAGE OF
RTDS. IN A PARTICULAR- IN A
PARTICULAR FACILITY OR OR
ESTABLISHMENT VIS A VIS THE-
BEER AND WINE. FOR PREPARE ME
HAPPY TO DISCUSS THAT WITH THE
OPPOSITION. YET THE ABSOLUTE. IT
WAS AN INTERESTING AMENDMENT-
MAKE ELIMINATE NON FAT MILK AND
THEN OPEN UP THAT SHELF SPACE.
THAT'S A PRETTY GOOD IDEA SAID I
CENTER BRADFORD. YES I APOLOGIZE
FOR THIS QUESTION CAN YOU GIVE
ME EXAMPLE OF A TYPE TWENTY
LICENSE FEE THAT WOULD NOW BE
ABLE TO STE I CAN'T TELL IF THE
DAY THAT WILL BE ALLOWED TO SELL
IT GOING FOR THAT. I CAN'T HEAR
YOU WITH THEM. CITY WIDE
OUTPATIENT SEVEN ELEVENS.
BECAUSE I'VE SEEN SOME OF THESE
MIXED DRINKS BUT I GUESS IT'S ON
THE WIND BASED ON THE ALCOHOL
BASED JOB THAT ARE. WHITE OR
MULTI. ARGUES I'VE GOT TO GO.
CENTER GLAZER. YEAH I WOULD JUST
WHEN I CONCUR WITH SENATOR ROSS
COMMENTS ABOUT THAT. HAPPY TO IT
TO MOVE THE BILL LAST TODAY AND
HOPE THAT YOU CAN WORK WORK
THINGS OUT AND THAT PERCENTAGE.
SIMPLE ARBITRARY BUT WE'RE
TRYING TO FIND SUS SOFT LANDINGS
FOR ALL OF ALL OF THE FOLKS OUT
THERE AND- RESHAPE YOUR
CONTINUED EFFORTS TO LOOK FOR
THAT. THANK YOU. WITH THAT I
BELIEVE WE HAVE A MOTION DO WE
NOT HAVE A MOTION. YEAH WITH
CENTER GLAZER. SO WITH THAT.
PLEASE CLOSE THIS PAGE
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I'VE A- AS
A GREAT. IT MOTION IS DUE PASS
TO APPROPRIATIONS CORRECT. DODD
HI DODD I WILL HI. I EL DORADO
GIL HI ALPHARETTA FEEL AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ASHBY ASHBY AYE BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
JONES JONES I WENT A CHAUVEAU.
IDEA I HAVE YET I PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH. ROTH AYE
RUBIO. RUBIO I SEE ARE NO.
LEADER IN THE HOUSE. WAS THAT.
HOW MANY. TWELVE THE BILL TO A
CALL. OKAY NOW WE'RE GONNA BEGIN
LIFTING CALLS WHAT AND WIENER.
WE YOUR BRING US A BILL. I WAS
ALL EXCITED LIKE WE WERE DONE OR
SOMETHING. OKAY IF WE MUST
CENTER WIENER WELCOME SORRY
ABOUT THAT. WHERE THE HELL. I AM
VERY HARD TO SEE. SO- THAT'S
BEFORE YOU BEGIN JUST FOR THE
STAFF EVERYTHING CENTERS NEED TO
GET IN HERE AFTER CENTER WIENER
IS DONE WE'RE GOING TO BE
LIFTING ALL THE CALLS. THANK YOU
. VACANCY I THANK YOU MR
CHAIRMAN TODAY I'M HERE TO
PRESENT SENATE BILL FIFTY SIX IF
THIS LOOKS FAMILIAR IT WAS
BECAUSE IT WAS IN THIS COMMITTEE
LAST YEAR AS PART OF A DIFFERENT
BILL- I GOT STRIPPED OUT AND
SOMEBODY APPROPRIATIONS AND SO
WE ARE NOW OF VENGEANCE AS A
STANDALONE BILL AND I WANT TO
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT LAST
YEAR ITEM I WANT TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR WORKING WITH US
I'M HAPPY TO ACCEPT THE
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. SB SEVENTY
SIX WILL ALLOW IS A LOCAL
CONTROL BILL THAT ALLOWS LOCAL
JURISDICTIONS IF THEY CHOOSE TO
CREATE DESIGNATED OUTDOOR
ENTERTAINMENTS OWNS- PROBABLY IN
THE FORM OF A STREET FAIR OR A
BLOCK PARTY OR SO OR A FESTIVAL
. TO ENABLE BRICK AND MORTAR
RESTAURANTS AND BARS- TO- SELL-
TAKE OUT ALCOHOL BEVERAGES. TO
PATRONS FOR CONSUMPTION AT IN
THE ENTERTAINMENT SORT OUT THE
STREET FAIR NOT TO TAKE OUTSIDE
OF THEIR- WE TOOK TO BE VERY
CLEAR RIGHT NOW TODAY. CITIES
ARE ALLOWED TO DESIGNATE OPEN
CONTAINERS OWN SAY AT A STREET
FAIR. HOWEVER THE ONLY ALCOHOL
THE CAN BE SOLD THERE IS BY
VENDORS THE COMMENT BASICALLY
FROM THE OUTSIDE ESSENTIALLY
LIKE A EQUIVALENT OF A FOOD
TRUCK. SELLING THAT ALCOHOL. THE
BRICK AND MORTAR RESTAURANTS AND
BARS THAT ARE WITHIN THE
FOOTPRINT OF THE ENTERTAINMENT
ZONE THE LOCAL BUSINESSES THAT
HAVE BEEN SO DECIMATED BY THE
PANDEMIC. CANNOT PARTICIPATE.
YOU CAN IMAGINE THE FRUSTRATION
IF YOU OWN A BAR RESTAURANT AND
YOUR STREET IS SHUT DOWN FOR A
STREET FAIR. AND VENDORS FROM
OUTSIDE MAYBE FROM ANOTHER PART
OF THE STATE COME IN WITH THEIR
TRUCKS AND SELL YOU KNOW BEER
LET'S SAY AND YOU ARE NOT
ALLOWED TO SELL. IT AT ST FOR
THAT'S THE CURRENT STATE LONG
CALIFORNIA. SO WE'RE NOT
CREATING THE IDEA OF AN OPEN
CONTAINERS AND THAT EXISTS
CITIES CAN ALREADY DO THAT
BECAUSE ALREADY ALLOW ALCOHOL
SALES. IN THOSE CONTAINERS ON
WHAT WE'RE SAYING IS LET'S ALLOW
OUR BRICK AND MORTAR LOCAL.
RESTAURANTS AND BARS TO
PARTICIPATE AS WELL THAT'S WHAT
THIS BILL. DOES IT'S COMMON
SENSE. AT WITH THE PANDEMIC NOT
ONLY DO WE NEED TO HELP OUR
LOCAL MOM AND POP BRICK AND
MORTAR RESTAURANTS AND BARS WE
ALSO NEED TO ACTIVATE OUR
DOWNTOWNS IN OUR NEIGHBORHOODS
WE KNOW THAT. A LOT OF CITIES
ARE STILL MAKING THAT RECOVERY
AND WE NEED VIBRANCE
PARTICULARLY IN OUR DOWNTOWN-
AREAS WHETHER A SMALL TOWN OR A
LARGE CITY. AND THIS WILL HELP
US I DO THAT IT'S A WIN WIN-
WE'VE WORKED HARD WITH THE
COMMITTEE AND WITH OTHERS TO
HAVE STRONG- GUARDRAILS ON THE
BILL- INCLUDING THE- AMENDMENTS
WERE TAKEN LAST YEAR AND MEMBERS
FOR TAKING- TODAY- THE BILL
ALSO- HAS. SOME CLEAN UP-
UPDATING- FOR A BILL THAT WE
PASSED THAT THIS COMMITTEE
PASSED AND WAS SIGNED INTO LAW
LAST YEAR- HAVING TO DO WITH
LIVE MUSIC VENUES ALLOWING THEM
TO PERIODICALLY- TINA CATERING-
ALCOHOL. PERMIT ALL RIGHT SO
WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE. AND WITH ME TODAY
TESTIFIED. OUR ALEX TORRES IN
THE BAY COUNTS. AND JIM CORNETTE
- FROM THE CAL K. BY CAL VENUES
. AND THE OWNER OF HARLOW'S HERE
IN SACRAMENTO THANK YOU. HERE
TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE BAY AREA
COUNCIL VERY PROUD COULD SPONSOR
ON BEHALF OF OUR THREE HUNDRED-
EMPLOYER MEMBERS IN THE BAY AREA
UNFORTUNATELY MISTER CORNET HAD
TO STEP OUT SO I'LL BE. ECHOING
SOME OF HIS THOUGHTS AND
COMMENTS IN MY REMARKS TODAY.
THIS COMES AT A PRETTY CRITICAL
TIME IN A TIME THAT I THINK WE
AS A STATE SHOULD BE LOOKING
DEEP INTO YOUR TOOLBOX TO FIGURE
OUT HOW WE REVITALIZE OUR
DOWNTOWNS THE- BAY AREA COUNCIL
ECONOMIC INSTITUTE DID A REPORT
JUST LAST MONTH- EXAMINING COVE
IN NINETEEN RECOVERY. REVIEW AND
ECONOMIC INDEXES FOR MAJOR
METROPOLITAN AREAS THROUGHOUT
THE UNITED STATES IN THE BAY
AREA IS FACING SOME CHALLENGES.
SAN FRANCISCO CAME IN TWENTY
FIFTH OUT OF TWENTY SIX I THINK
WE ONLY BE BALTIMORE. SAN JOSE
SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE AROUND
SIXTEEN SO WE DO IT WELL THIS
MEASURES NOT A PANACEA WE HAVE
TO THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX AND HOW
WE AND REVITALIZE OUR DOWNTOWNS
WE- EMPOWER THE SMALL BUSINESSES
THAT WERE WERE SO IMPACTED
DURING COVE IT. I DO WANT TO
TOUCH A LITTLE BIT MORE. THE ON
THE MUSIC VENUE LICENSE
PROVISIONS THAT SENATOR WIENER
TALKED ABOUT. VARIOUS HOME AS
WELL AS THE CITY CALIFORNIA TO A
LOT OF DIFFERENT BRICK AND
MORTAR VENUES AT THESE VENUES
THAT WERE SHUT DURING COVE IT I
SEE A LOT A LOT OF MEMBERS ON
THE DIESS WHO WERE CRITICAL
CHAMPIONS TO HELP MAKE SURE-
MUSIC VENUES HELPED RECOVER.
AFTER THE PANDEMIC. THIS IS A
MONTH THAT THERE'S PROVISIONS TO
MAKE NEEDED TWEAKS TO THAT TYPE
NINETY LICENSE THAT WE JUST
CREATED LAST YEAR TRADITIONALLY
MUSIC VENUES HAVE THAT ISSUE
FORM BETWEEN A TYPE FORTY SEVEN
OR FORTY EIGHT EITHER A
RESTAURANT. OR A BAR IF YOU'RE
TRYING TO DO ALL AGES SHOWS AND
SELL TICKETS WHICH WHAT WHAT YOU
DO IS A MUSIC VENUE RIGHT-
YOU'RE UNABLE TO. TO STOP RATE
AS A BAR SO YOU HAVE TO HAVE A
KITCHEN. HUGE CAPITAL COST
ASSOCIATED WITH THAT- AND THEN
IF YOUR BAR MEANS YOU CAN ONLY
HAVE TWENTY ONE AND UP SO. THE
NOT TYPE NINETY IS MEANT TO KIND
OF BRIDGE THAT GAP AND MAKE YOU
KNOW HELP MUSIC VENUES OPERATE
JUST AS THAT. AS MUSIC VENUES
AND SO. THERE'S SOME ADDITIONAL
TWEAKS IN THIS BILL- WORKING
HAND IN HAND WITH ABC TO MAKE
SURE THERE'S A TRUE MARKET FIT.
AND I THINK IT'S A REALLY
EXCITING OPPORTUNITY FOR
EXISTING VENUES AS WELL AS
POTENTIALLY NEW VENUES. OUR
COMMUNITIES. REAL CASE STUDIES
CENTER ASHLEY ONE OF OUR BIG
MEMBERS. IT CURE IN THE BAY AREA
OPERATES A LOT OF DIFFERENT-
CONCERT VENUES IS OPENING ONE IN
MID TOWN THEY'RE LOOKING AT THE
TYPE NINETY IS A HUGE. YES THE
POTENTIAL OPPORTUNITY. TO NOT
HAVE TO DO A KITCHEN AND NOT
HAVE TO YOU KNOW DO A BAR AND
THEN ONLY BE ABLE TO LIMIT THE
AMOUNT OF SHOWS THEY CAN SELL.
SO I THINK IT'S A EXCITING
OPPORTUNITY AND CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH ABC AND THEN THE SENATOR'S
OFFICE TO. MAKE SURE IT'S A TRUE
MARKET FIT FOR THAT. YOU ONE
ADDITIONAL PIECE CENTER WINNERS
AYE AYE TRUE HOUSING CHAMPION
THERE'S A NEW YORK TIMES ARTICLE
JUST LAST WEEK THAT TALKED ABOUT
DEVELOPERS. UTILIZING MID SIZE
VENUES SO LIKE CARLOS HERE IN
SACRAMENTO- TO ANCHOR THEIR
PROJECTS THEIR MULTI. THEIR
MIXED USE PROJECTS YOU HAVE IN
MID SIZE VENUE. RETAIL BARS AND
RESTAURANTS- DEVELOPERS ARE
LOOKING AT THE SPACES THEY ARE
UNIQUE RIGHT THERE THIRTY TO
FORTY YEAR TENANTS IN MANY CASES
BECAUSE OF THE- PHYSICAL
COMPONENTS THAT. ARE REQUIRED TO
BE A MUSIC VENUE- AND THEY TALK
ABOUT HOW THESE THESE ARE
POTENTIAL BREAKTHROUGHS FOR
DEVELOPERS TO REVITALIZE THESE
NEIGHBORHOODS THESE BLOCKS AND
SO- YOU KNOW WHO I THOUGHT MUSIC
VENUES AS HOUSING ACCELERATOR
SENATOR WE ARE THAT MIGHT BE AN
IDEA FOR NEXT YEAR PERHAPS BUT-
EXCITED TO SUPPORT THIS MEASURE
HERE TODAY- ALSO YOU KNOW AS I
SAID JIM CORNETTE IS. THE
CAPITAL VENUES COALITION CO
FOUNDER IT IS A UNIFICATION OF
BRICK AND MORTAR VENUES HERE IN
THE SACRAMENTO REGION. ALSO A
LEAD ORGANIZER WITH OUR PROUD
BECAUSE MONSTER THE NATIONAL
INDEPENDENT VENUE ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR A LIFEBOAT THANK YOU. THANK
YOU ANY OTHER OP. ANY OTHER
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT. ACCORDING
GOOD MORNING IS THIS FULLER
SHAHRYAR AND FISH LAWS ARE LYING
ON BEHALF- SAN FRANCISCO MAYOR
LONDON BREED IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU. ANY WITNESSES IN THE ROOM
IN OPPOSITION. MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MICHAEL
SKIP ON BEHALF OF ALCOHOL
JUSTICE. AS WITH MANY BILLS IN
THE LAST THREE YEARS SB SEVENTY
SIX IS INTENDED TO RAISE THE
AMOUNT OF ALCOHOL CONSUMED.
RAISE THE AMOUNT OF ALCOHOL
SOLD. LESS IN THE PUBLIC SPACES
IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE ALCOHOL
SERVICE IS NOT PRESENT. AND
REDUCE THE LIABILITY OF
LICENSEES. FOR THEIR CUSTOMERS.
ALCOHOL JUSTICE SUBMITTED A
LETTER TO YOU OUTLINING IN
DETAIL OUR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
BILL. IF IT BECOMES LAW. HOW
WILL CONTINUE ON MARCH TO HARM
IN THE GUISE OF MARGINAL
ECONOMIC RECOVERY FOR SMALL
BUSINESSES. I WILL NOT REPEAT
THE CONTENTS OF THAT LETTER
WHICH ARE REFLECTED IN THE BILL
ANALYSIS HOWEVER WHAT I WOULD
LIKE TO BRING TO YOUR ATTENTION
SOMETHING I MENTIONED A LITTLE
EARLIER TODAY'S NEW DATA. WHICH
JUST CAME TO OUR ATTENTION FROM
A REPORT ISSUED VERY VERY
QUIETLY BY THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH IN
JANUARY. THE FINDINGS ARE
STARTLING. COMPARED TO TEN
THOUSAND EIGHT HUNDRED AND
ELEVEN ALCOHOL RELATED DEATHS
PER YEAR IN THE CDC'S TWO
THOUSAND ELEVEN TO TWO THOUSAND
FIFTEEN ANALYSIS. ACCORDING TO
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH FROM. TWO THOUSAND
TWENTY TWO THOUSAND TWENTY ONE
THE STATE'S SUFFERED AN AVERAGE
OF NINETEEN THOUSAND THREE
HUNDRED AND THIRTY FIVE ALCOHOL
RELATED DEATHS PER YEAR.
NINETEEN THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED
AND THIRTY FIVE DEATHS. THAT'S
THE ENTIRE POPULATION OF DIXON.
NEXT YEAR IT'S THE POPULATION
OF ROSEDALE. 81% INCREASE IN
ALCOHOL RELATED MORTALITY IN
JUST FIVE YEARS. ALONG WITH THE
QUESTION. IN THE FACE OF THESE
INCREASING LEVELS OF HARM AND
THE CATASTROPHIC COSTS TO THE
STATE. IT'S RESIDENTS AND ITS
VISITORS WHY ARE WE CONSIDERING
MAKING THE PROBLEM WORSE. WITH
SB SEVENTY SIX. I RESPECTFULLY
ASK. THAT YOU PLACE LIVES ABOVE
INCREASED ALCOHOL SALES. AND
VOTE NO ON SB SEVEN SIX THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. MISTER CHAIR
SENATORS FRED JONES ON BEHALF
CALIFORNIA COUNCIL ON ALCOHOL
PROBLEMS A FAITH BASED
ORGANIZATION AND ALSO A CHARTER
MEMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA ALCOHOL
POLICY ALLIANCE BOTH
ORGANIZATIONS AND COALITIONS
OPPOSE- THIS BILL WE'RE WORRIED
ABOUT THE SPLASH OVER AFFECTS
OUTSIDE THESE ZONES BUT ALSO
WITHIN THESE ZONES- MINERS BEAN
IN THESE AREAS. AND A HOST OF
OTHER CONCERNS THIS MANSARD PART
OF SAN FRANCISCO'S PROBLEMS BUT
THIS BILL SETS STATEWIDE- HAVE
STATEWIDE RAMIFICATIONS AND FOR
A LOT OF REASONS- WE MUST OPPOSE
THIS BILL THANK YOU THANK YOU.
OKAY WE'RE GONNA GO TO PHONE
LINES MODERATOR. SEE IF ANYBODY
IS LAST FOUR OR OPPOSITION TO SB
SEVENTY SIX. THANK YOU PLEASE
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. WE HAVE
ONE PERSON ONE MOMENT PLEASE.
AND WE WILL GO TO. LINE. TWENTY
ONE. GOOD MORNING CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS JOVENEL THE ON BEHALF OF
MUSIC BOX SAN DIEGO AND THE
NATIONAL INDEPENDENT VIDEO
SENSATION OF CALIFORNIA IN
SUPPORT OF SB SEVENTY SIX. WE
HAVE NO OTHERS IN Q. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH MODERATOR- WE'RE GONNA
BRING THIS BACK NOW DISCUSSION
FOR MEMBERS- CENTER RUBIO. THANK
YOU I WANT TO THINK THE AUTHOR
HAVE YOU KNOW USUALLY HAVE VERY
SPIRITED DISCUSSIONS AROUND THIS
AND YOU KNOW ALL KIND THESE
TYPES OF ISSUES BUT I WANTED TO
SAY THAT I REALLY APPRECIATE
THAT LOCAL CONTROL ELEMENT WHICH
IS IMPORTANT TO US ONLY AS A
CENTER FOR ME BUT AS A FORMER
COUNCILMEMBER ALLOWING. LOCAL
COMMUNITIES TO MAKE THAT
DECISION FOR THEMSELVES- AND I
CAN ALSO APPRECIATE JUST A
DIFFICULT TIME RETAILERS HAVE
BEEN. THEY JUST BEEN EXPERIENCE
A TERRIBLE TIME TRYING TO
RECOVER FROM THE PANDEMIC AND I
DO BELIEVE THIS WILL JUST
MOBILIZE OUR COMMUNITIES BRING
LIFE BACK INTO THEM AND IN. MANY
WAYS- BRICK AND MORTAR STORES
ARE DISADVANTAGED IN SO MANY
WAYS NOW WITH ONLINE SALES AND
LUNCH AT THINGS GOING ON AND SO
WE WANT TO SUPPORT OUR LOCAL
BUSINESSES SO I WILL BE
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL. THANK YOU
. THANK YOU. I ACTUALLY REALLY
LIKE THIS BILL FOR SENATE
DISTRICT EIGHT HAS SO MUCH
POTENTIAL FOR THE CITY. I COULD
SEE OLD SACK THE DOKO CORRIDOR
ARE ST ALL PARTICIPATING IN THIS
WHAT I LOVE ABOUT IT IS THAT
YOU'RE BRINGING IN THE BRICK AND
MORTAR BUSINESSES THAT HAVE MADE
CRITICAL INVESTMENTS. IN OUR
URBAN CORES SO MAYBE THIS IS MY
BIG CITY BIAS LINING UP WITH YOU
BUT I'D LOVE TO BE A CO AUTHOR
AND SUPPORT YOUR BILL TODAY.
THANK YOU. GOOD DEALS. CENTER OF
OUR GUILT. I WANT TO BRING THE
VOICES SMALL TOWN CALIFORNIA SO-
OFTEN IN IN MY DISTRICT WE SEE
THAT- THE POPULATION CENTERS ARE
IT MORE IN THE COASTAL AREAS AND
NOT SO MUCH IN SOME OF THE
HISTORICAL. MORE AT TOURISTY
AREAS- OF THE EASTERN SIERRA
SIDE SO WOULD YOUR BILL ALLOW
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO CREATE
LIKE DOWNTOWN FAIRS AND PARADES
AND ALLOW THE BRICK AND MORTAR
BUSINESSES TO THEN PARTAKE IN
SOME OF THESE- SALES OF YEAH
ABSOLUTELY I ALSO REPRESENT. A
BIG A BIG CITY BUT THIS IS
ABSOLUTELY SMALL TOWNS COULD
REALLY BENEFIT WHEN I THINK OF
SMALL TOWNS THAT HAVE A TOWN
SQUARE. THEY MAY DECIDE TO HAVE
A FAIR THERE I'LL BE ON THERE
THE ASU I'D I WANT TO. JUST TELL
YOU THE IDEA FOR THIS BILL NOT
GONNA SAY WHO. I CAME FROM A
CENTRAL VALLEY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
REPRESENTING A SMALLER CITY SAME
BY CITY WANTS TO GO TO DO THIS
AND WE CAN'T. DO IT AND CAN YOU
HELP US AND SO THIS. THIS
CENTRAL VALLEY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GAVE ME THE IDEA. NOT THAT WAS
THE GENESIS OF SOMETHING LIKE
THREE OR FOUR YEARS AGO SO THIS
IS GREAT FOR BIG CITY IT'S GOOD
FOR SMALL TOWNS. ALL THE ABOVE
OKAY WONDERFUL IN THE DECISION
MAKING POWER WOULD BE HELD. BY
CITY COUNCIL THE CITY COUNCIL
YEAH AND ALSO- WHOEVER DECIDES
LOCALLY SO IF THERE'S AN
INCORPORATED AREAS WERE THEN GO
TO THE COUNTY. CORRECT OKAY
THANK YOU TO. EVERYBODY ELSE. SO
NOBODY I WOULD LIKE TO. YES
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THAT I'VE
THIS. I DO TO SAY- TERMS SOME OF
THE OP- YOUNG VERY OBVIOUSLY
THERE ARE. WITH WITH OTHER
SUBSTANCES THERE. ANY SUBSTANCE
CAN BE. ABUSED AND TO BE CLEAR
IN THESE FARES. CAN ALREADY.
SELL ALCOHOL. WE'RE JUST SAYING
THAT INSTEAD OF IT JUST BEING
OUTSIDE VENDORS IT'S A LOCAL
BRICK AND MORTAR. AS WELL- AND
SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL.
GROUP WE HAVE A MOTIONS OF. THIS
SO RUBIO MOVE THIS BILL YES OKAY
POSTED BY CENTER RUBIO MANY ON
THE SPOT. UNDER THE- WERE. RIGHT
SO IT'S THIS GOES TO A FOR. TO
DO YOU PASS THE RED OF
APPROPRIATE COMMITTEES PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL. I'D I THOUGHT I
WILL. OVERLOOKING OF ARUNACHAL I
ARCHULETA ALL RIGHT ARCHULETA
AYE ASHLEY ASHLEY I BRADFORD.
BRADFORD AYE GLAZER GLAZER AYE
JONES. JONES I WENT. WHEN I-
CHILLAGOE. IDEA RIGHT AT THE I
PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
. ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE RUBIO AYE
SIERRA. HI THANK YOU COLLEAGUES
. TWO THIRDS. WE START DOING
THEIR WAY TO. YEAH WE'VE. WE'RE
GONNA LIVE THE CALLS THIS THE
SUIT IS THE CENTER OF CHOI BO
GETS HERE SHE IS IN TRANSIT
RIGHT NOW. TO NINE. RIGHT YEP-
WITH WHAT WE'RE WE'RE STARTING
IN THE- OFFICIALS CHAU CHAU
CAPTURE. SO WHY WE DO THAT LET'S
WITH THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
ABSENT MEMBERS OTOBO RUBIO HI
RUBIO HI FOURTEEN ZERO WAITING
ON A SHOW ABOUT. OKAY THOSE WHAT
. FOURTEEN ZERO WE WILL- KEEP
THEIR ON CALL NOW MOVES TO- FILE
ITEM NUMBER ONE AB THREE FORTY
ONE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER RAMOS. DR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALPHARETTA GIL JONES
WHEN. WITH THE ONE. YES. OTOBO
RUBIO HI RUBIO ICY ARDO. ZERO
HOLDING OPEN. TEN ZERO THE
BILLS- STILL ON CALL- THE FILE
ITEM NUMBER TWO S. B. EIGHTEEN
BY CENTER WIRE. ABSENT MEMBERS
EL DORADO GIL. AB RIGHT OF GUILT
I WOULD SHOW AGO. PORTANTINO
PORTANTINO I THE FOURTEENTH-
HOLDEN- FOURTEEN ZERO FOOLS ON
CALL- THE FILE ITEM NUMBER THREE
SB SEVENTY SIX MY CENTER WINNER
. THE ABSENT MEMBERS WELL PHOTO
AGO. ALL THAT OPEN. YEAH IT WILL
MOVE THE FILE ITEM NUMBER- FOR
S. B. TWO SEVENTY NINE BY CENTER
NIELLO. SECTOR OVER THE ROLE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALFREDO GIL HI
EVERADO GILL I- CHILLAGOE.
FOURTEEN ZERO FOURTEEN ZERO THAT
THE BILL'S PHONE CALL PHONE
NUMBER FIVE S. B. FOUR NINETY
EIGHT CENTER GIVES ALL SECTOR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE OBSERVERS
ALPHARETTA AGO OCTOBER. ALFREDO
DEL A TURBO. THANKS COMMITTEE.
THIRTEEN SO CALL- FILE ITEM
NUMBER SIX SB SEVEN THIRTY TWO
BY CENTER MENSCH OF OUR SECTOR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE ABSENT
MEMBERS EL DORADO HILLS YEAH.
ALPHARETTA GIL KNOW A SHOW ABOUT
. THIRTEEN ONE. THIRTEEN WILL
ALSO CALL FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT
S. B. EIGHT TWENTY TWO BY CENTER
DORADO SECTOR PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS EL DORADO
HILLS. BRADFORD BRADFORD AYE
GLAZER. WHEN NO OCHO BIO. IT'S
EIGHT TO FOUR EIGHT FOUR. CLOSE
ON CALL NOW MOVED FILE ITEM
NUMBER NINE S. B. TWO FORTY
SEVEN BUT CENTER WILK. ABSENT
MEMBERS EVERADO GIL HI
ALPHARETTA GUILT I WENT. WHEN I
GO TO A VOTE. BRADFORD OUR-
BRADFORD I. FOR EIGHTEEN. THE
FOURTEENTH. THOSE ARE CALLED
MOVED FILE ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN SB
THREE EIGHT EIGHT BY CENTER
ARCHULETA SECTOR PLEASE OPEN THE
ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS EVERADO GIL
HI OUR WRITERS GUILD I BRADFORD.
BRADFORD I WENT. WHEN I OCHO A
BOW. THOSE FOURTEEN OF ON CALL
WILL NOW MOVE TO- FILE ITEM
NUMBER THIRTEEN S. C. R. FORTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR GLAZERS. MOTION
HERE IS TO BE ADOPTED AND REFER
TO APPROPRIATIONS ABSENT MEMBERS
ALPHARETTA GIL. BRADFORD
BRADFORD AYE WHEN NO SHOW ABOUT-
PORTANTINO. PORTANTINO I SEYARTO
. TEND TO TEND TO- THE FOLLOWING
HER FOURTEEN SB SEVENTY FOUR BY
SENATOR DODD SECTOR PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS ALVA
RADO GIL. ALPHARETTA GILL I WENT
. LIKE WHEN I OTOBO PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO I. FOURTEEN THE FILE
ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN S. B. TWO
SEVEN SEVEN BUZZARD DODD SECTOR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE ABSENT
MEMBERS WENT. WHEN I OTOBO
SEYARTO. THIRTEEN THIRTEEN.
RIGHT NOW WITH THE. UNDER WHICH
USED TO. SEVERAL BOB. WHAT'S
THAT.
THE COMMITTEE WILL BE IN RECESS
IN FOR TEN MINUTES.
OKAY THE COMMITTEE COMES BACK IN
THE ORDER- WE'RE GOING TO LIFT
THE CALLS AND WE'RE GONNA START
WITH THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
SECRETARY WATER LED TO THE
CENTER GET HER BREATH. PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ON THAT CAN SET
OUT. A TURBO HI A TROUBLE I
THAT'S. FIFTEEN ZERO FIFTEEN
ZERO THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM ONE
AB THREE FOUR ONE OF. ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ROB LOS. ABSENT ABSENT
MEMBERS OF ROADKILL JONES WHEN A
CHOKO CHOKO ICE. ZERO ELEVEN
ZERO ZERO THAT BILLS OUT.
BLUETOOTH ITEM NUMBER TWO SB
EIGHTEEN BY CENTER MCGUIRE ADOBO
. HI A TURBO I FIFTEEN ZERO
FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS OUT FILE
ITEM NUMBER THREE SB SEVENTY SIX
BY CENTER WIENER SECTOR OVER THE
ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS WILK ADOBO
HI- CHOKO I. FOURTEEN ZERO FOUR
TWO ZERO. BILLS OUT. FOLLOWING
THE FOR ITS B. TWO SEVENTY NINE
BY CENTER NIELLO I CHAU AYE FOR
TROUBLE I FIFTEEN ZERO FIFTEEN
ZERO THAT FILLED OUT NUMBER TO
FILE ITEM NUMBER FIVE FOUR
NINETY EIGHT BUT SUTTER GONZALEZ
OPEN THE ROLE PLEASE ABSENT
MEMBERS EVERADO GUILT THE CHOKO.
ACCOUNTABLE I FOURTEEN ZERO
FOURTEEN ZERO THAT FILLS OUT.
FILE ITEM SIX S. B. SEVEN TWO BY
CITY MANAGEABLE- OPEN THE ROLE
OF ABOUT. A I FOURTEEN ONE OR
ONE THAT BILL OUT. FOLLOWING
NUMBER EIGHT S. B. EIGHT TWO BY
SENATOR RAZA SECTOR PLEASE OPEN
THE ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS EVERADO
KILL GLAZER OTOBO NO BUT CHAU
BONO. TO EIGHT TO FIVE. THE
BILLS OUT. WE WILL NOW MOVE THE
FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE S. B. TWO
FORTY SEVEN CENTER WILK SECTOR
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE A TURBO HI
THE TROUBLE I FIFTEEN ZERO
FIFTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS OUT.
FILE ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN SB THREE
EIGHTY EIGHT CENTER ARCHULETA
PLEASE OPEN THE ROLE A TURBO.
EIGHT THREE EIGHT EIGHT. SO WHAT
I'M AT ITS- ITEM ELEVEN SB THREE
EIGHT EIGHT SCOTT FOURTEEN OH
ZERO CONSENT. FOURTEENS OR NO
CHARGE AND I. OKAY- BUT I THE
BILL ITSELF. WITH THE MOOD FOR
ITEM THE THIRTEEN S. C. R. FORTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR GLAZER AT THREE
OVER THE ROLE ABSENT MEMBERS OF
ROADKILL OCHO BIO. IT'S TEN TO
THAT BILLS I. FILE ITEM NUMBER
FOUR S. SEVENTY FOUR BY SEN DODD
SECTOR PLEASE HELP THE ROLE OVER
. FOURTEEN ZERO THANK YOU- CHOKE
OUT I. ZERO THAT IS OUT. HELLO
WHO TO ITEM NUMBER. S. B. TWO
SEVENTY SEVEN MY CENTERS DODD
SECTOR PLEASE OVER THE ROLE
OTOBO HI A CHILD I FOURTEEN ZERO
FOURTEEN ZERO THAT BILLS I. WE
HAVE KIND THE AGE FOR TODAY THE
SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
COMMITTEE. IS ADJOURNED.