THANK YOU SENATE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE WILL COME TO ORDER
GOOD AFTERNOON AS WE COULD TO
TAKE PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE ON
GOING COVER NINETEEN RECESS-
CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC
TOWARD HEARING SINCE REVISED
ACCESS TO BOTH IN PERSON
TELECONFERENCE PARTICIPATION
REPUBLIC COMMENT PROVISIONS
WHICH TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COME
WITH TO SPIT TOLL FREE NUMBER AN
AXIS GOES POSTMARK COMMITTEE
WEBSITE WILL BE DISPLAYED ON THE
SCREEN AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT
NOW. TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER
IS. 877-226-8163 AND THE ACCESS
CODE IS. SEVEN THREE SIX TWO
EIGHT THREE FOUR FOR DETAILED
INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW THE TELECOM
SYSTEM WORKS PLEASE REFER THE
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
WEBSITE SO MAINTAIN DECORUM
DURING THE HEARING IS BECAUSE
MANY AN INDIVIDUAL WHOSE
DESTRUCTIVE MAY BE REMOVED THE
REMOTE MEETING SERVICE OR HAVE
THEIR CONNECTIONS MUTED. WE ARE
HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS
HERE IN- ST BUILDING ALSO KNOWN
AS SWING SPACE S. ALL MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE TO COME TO ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED SO INSTEAD OF A
QUORUM AND BEGIN OUR HEARING.
ALL RIGHT. SO I'M GONNA WELCOME
BACK RETURNING MEMBERS SENATOR
WILK THANK YOU VERY MUCH BYE
SECURE WILL THANK YOU WE LOOK
FORWARD TO A PRODUCTIVE YEAR ARE
ALSO SENATORS ALAN ASHBY MEN IN
YELLOW- WE WELCOME ALL OF YOU TO
THE COMMITTEE. WITH THAT- IF WE
COULD CALL IT CALL THE ROLL FOR
PURPOSES DAVISON QUORUM. UMBERG
HERE NUMBER HERE WILK. PRESIDENT
WILL PRESENT ALAN. ALLEN PRESENT
ASHBY HERE ASHLEY HERE COVER
URAL. CABALLERO PRESENT TO
RUSSELL. RUSSELL HERE LAYERED
HERE LAYERED HERE MEN. MAN HERE
IN YELLOW HERE YELLOW HERE STERN
. WIENER YOU HAVE COR ALL RIGHT
THANK YOU- WELL I HOPE THIS
BASICALLY SUCH THAT'S THAT'S THE
NORM FOR COMMITTEE HEARINGS ALL
OF US ARE HERE IN A TIMELY
FASHION IS FANTASTIC. BEFORE WE
BEGIN WITH RESOLUTION
PRESENTATION WE NEED TO ADOPT
COMMITTEE RULES WITHOUT
OBJECTION THE COMMITTEE RULES
ARE ADOPTED. SIGNAL OBJECTION IS
A REMINDER FOR EACH RESOLUTION
WILL OUT TO WITNESSES PER SITE
NEEDS WITNESSES PERMITTED TWO
MINUTES TO TESTIFY. WILL OUT
TOTAL OF FIFTEEN MINUTES PER
SIDE FOR THE MEAT TO WITNESSES
ON THE PHONE LINES ME TOO
WITNESSES THOSE ARE THOSE WHOSE
UP SIMPLY STATE THEIR NAME.
THEIR AFFILIATION IN THEIR
POSITION. CENTER SKINNER IS HERE
I SEE SENATOR SKINNER I DO
ACCEPT THE AMENDMENTS AS
PROPOSED IN THE ANALYSIS ON PAGE
EIGHT COMMENT NUMBER FOUR. YES
YOU DO THANK YOU VERY MUCH ALL
RIGHT. I'LL GO AHEAD SENATOR
SKINNER FLOORS YOURS. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH OUR MEMBERS IN LESS
THAN. A WEEK ON JANUARY TWENTY
SECOND TWO IS THE FIFTIETH
ANNIVERSARY OF THIS SUPREME
COURT'S RULING IN THE ROE V.
WADE CASE WHICH MADE ABORTION
LEGAL ACROSS THE US. THIS
FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY WILL BE
LESS ABOUT CELEBRATION DUE TO
THE DOBBS VERSUS JACKSON
DECISION THAT CAME DOWN LAST
JUNE WHICH REVERSED ROVI WEIGHT
AND HAS NOW PUT THE BODILY
AUTONOMY OF EVERY PERSON WHO HAS
THE CAPACITY TO BECOME PREGNANT.
AT RISK ACROSS THE COUNTRY. NOW
OUR GOOD VOTERS IN CALIFORNIA
PASSED PROPOSITION LAST YEAR TO
PROTECT US AND PUT IT IN THE
CONSTITUTION THAT WE HAD THE
RIGHT TO AN ABORTION AND TO
BIRTH CONTROL. HOWEVER THERE ARE
READY NINETEEN STATES THAT HAVE
ENACTED FULL OR PARTIAL ABORTION
BANS AND THERE ARE OTHER STATES.
COULD ACTIVELY CONSIDERING SUCH
ACTIONS WE KNOW THAT THIS WILL
NOT STOP ABORTIONS. WELL I
HAVEN'T DR RARELY HAVE EVER
BROUGHT UP A RECOMMENDATION TO
WATCH A DOCUMENTARY WHEN I
PERCENT A RESOLUTION. I WOULD
RECOMMEND THAT ANY OF YOU HAVE
NOT SEEN IT SEE THE HBO
DOCUMENTARY CALLED THE JEANS IT
IS ABOUT. US SOME WOMEN IN
CHICAGO WHO BEFORE THE ROE V.
WADE ANNIVERSARY ARRANGED FOR
ABORTIONS FOR WOMEN IN CHICAGO.
AND THEY DID THAT. AND WHAT THEY
DID THAT BECAUSE THEY HAD
FRIENDS AND PEOPLE THAT THEY
KNEW WHO WERE EITHER GRAVELY
INJURED OR DIED AS RESULT OF
EITHER A SELF INFLICTED IN
PORTION OR AN ABORTION. BY A-
LESS THAN- ETHICAL PRACTITIONER
. I'M WHAT WHAT THE DATA SHOWS
IS THAT THERE WERE AT LEAST A
MILLION ABORTIONS A YEAR BEFORE
ROE V. WADE WAS MADE LEGAL. IT
MADE IT LEGAL AND THINK OF THE
POPULATION WAS MUCH SMALLER AT
THAT POINT AND OVER THAT ONE
MILLION A YEAR ABOUT THOUSANDS
OF WOMEN DIED. AND MANY OTHER
WORDS GRAVELY INJURED AND EVEN I
HADN'T THE INABILITY TO
PROCREATE AFTERWARDS WOMEN OF
COLOR WERE DISPROPORTIONATELY AT
RISK BECAUSE CONTRACEPTION WAS
VERY DIFFICULT TO GET. AND SO
NOT ONLY WAS ABORTION LEGAL
CONTRACEPTION WAS ALSO EXTREMELY
LIMITED. SO WHAT THIS RESOLUTION
BEFORE YOU DOES IS MARKS THE
IMPORTANT ANNIVERSARY FIFTIETH
ANNIVERSARY OF THAT SUPREME
COURT DECISION AND THE
IMPORTANCE OF REPRODUCTIVE
JUSTICE AND BODILY AUTONOMY FOR
THOSE OF US WHO CAN GET
PREGNANT. I'M THE S. R. THE
RESOLUTION BEFORE YOU IS
SPONSORED BY BLACK WOMEN FOR
WELLNESS NAY ROLE IN PLANNED
PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
CALIFORNIA AND TO SPEAK IN MY
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT R. SHANNON
HOVIS OF NERAL AND MOLLY MOLLY
ROGOSIN OF PLANNED PARENTHOOD
AFFILIATES OF CALIFORNIA. THE
SERVICE THE PLEASURES THANK YOU
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
SHANNON OLIVIERI HOVIS AND I'M
THE DIRECTOR OF NARAL PRO CHOICE
CALIFORNIA. THE REAL FIGHTS FOR
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM FOR
EVERYBODY POWERED BY OUR FOUR
MILLION MEMBERS NATIONALLY AND
MORE THAN THREE HUNDRED AND
SEVENTY THOUSAND MEMBERS HERE IN
CALIFORNIA. AND WE ARE PROUD TO
SPONSOR SENATE SENATE RESOLUTION
NINE TO COMMEMORATE THE FIFTIETH
ANNIVERSARY OF ROE V. WADE. ON
WHAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN THE
FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY RECOGNIZING
THE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO
ABORTION WE ARE INSTEAD
WITNESSING THE DEVASTATING
IMPACTS OF THE SUPREME COURT'S
DECISION TO STRIP AMERICANS OF
THIS FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOM.
CURRENTLY SEVENTEEN STATES ARE
ENFORCING BANS ON ABORTION WITH
SEVERAL OTHERS TRYING TO ENFORCE
OR PASS ABORTION BANS AND WE ARE
SEEING THE CATASTROPHIC
CONSEQUENCES. ON REAL PEOPLE'S
LIVES. THESE BANDS INTIMIDATE
DOCTORS AND HOSPITALS STOP THEM
FROM FROM PROVIDING CRITICAL
CARE LIKE MISCARRIAGE MANAGEMENT
AND PUT PREGNANT PEOPLE'S LIVES
AND HEALTH IN DANGER. AND THE
THREATS DON'T END THERE. HOUSE
REPUBLICANS HAVE MADE
RESTRICTING ABORTION THEIR TOP
PRIORITY. BUT LET ME BE CLEAR.
THERE IS NO PLACE IN THE COUNTRY
WERE BANS ON ABORTION ARE
POPULAR. IN FACT IN ALL SIX
STATES WHERE ABORTION RIGHTS
WERE SPECIFICALLY ON THE BALLOT
LAST YEAR AMERICANS VOTED TO
PROTECT ACCESS TO ABORTION CARE
. THANKS TO YOUR LEADERSHIP AND
THE LEADERSHIP OF THE WOMEN'S
CAUCUS HERE IN CALIFORNIA WE ARE
FIGHTING TO PROTECT. THIS
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO ABORTION. I
WE MADE HISTORY LAST YEAR BY
PASSING THE MOST COMPREHENSIVE
AND BOLD LEGISLATIVE PACKAGE
ADVANCING ABORTION ACCESS IN THE
COUNTRY. I AM FIVE MONTHS
PREGNANT. AND I FREQUENTLY THINK
ABOUT THE TERROR THAT I WOULD
FEEL IF I LIVED IN A STATE THAT
HAS ENACTED A BAN ON ABORTION.
FOR FEAR THAT IF SOMETHING WENT
WRONG I WOULD BE UNABLE TO
ACCESS THE ESSENTIAL HEALTH CARE
THAT I NEEDED. TO PROTECT MY
LIFE AND ENSURE THAT MY DAUGHTER
HAS A MOTHER TO COME HOME TO.
NEVER I WILL NEVER STOP FIGHTING
FOR A WORLD WHERE ALL OF US HAVE
THE FREEDOM TO MAKE OUR OWN
DECISIONS ABOUT WHETHER TO START
OR GROW A FAMILY. THANK YOU FOR
YOUR ONGOING COMMITMENT TO
ENSURING THAT CALIFORNIA LEADS
AS A REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM STATE.
AND THANK YOU FOR INTRODUCING
THIS MEASURE THIS MEASURE CENTER
SKINNER. AYE OR DRIVE OUT ON S.
R. NINE THANK YOU. THANK YOU
MISS OFFICE. MISS ROBSON. GOOD
AFTERNOON TURN MEMBERS MY NAME
IS MY RIBS AND I'M A LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTOR FOR PLANNED PARENTHOOD
AFFILIATES OF CALIFORNIA.
REPRESENTING OVER A HUNDRED
HEALTH CENTER THE SEVEN
AFFILIATE TO OPERATE OVER A
HUNDRED HEALTH CENTERS IN THE
STATE. I ALSO WANT TO THANK
SENATOR SKINNER AND PRO TEM
ATKINS FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP
AUTHORED THIS RESOLUTION TO
HONOR THE FIFTIETH ANNIVERSARY
OF THE ROE V. WADE SUPREME COURT
DECISION. OF COURSE THIS YEAR'S
ANNIVERSARY IS DIFFERENT. LAST
SUMMER WHEN THE U. S. SUPREME
COURT OVERTURNED THE PROTECTIONS
GRANTED IN ROE V. WADE IN THEIR
RULING ON JOBS FIRST JACKSON'S.
WHOLE WOMAN'S HEALTH THE RIGHT
TO ABORTION WAS LEFT UP TO
INDIVIDUAL STATES. AS YOU'VE
HEARD SEVENTEEN STATES NOW HAVE
FULL OR PARTIAL BANS ON
ABORTION. IMPACTING MILLIONS OF
PEOPLE WHO CAN BECOME PREGNANT
AND FORCING PATIENTS TO FACE
EXTREME BARRIERS JUST TO ACCESS
HEALTH CARE. PLANNED PARENTHOOD
HEALTH CENTERS AN ABORTION
PROVIDERS ACROSS CALIFORNIA HAVE
SEEN A DRAMATIC INCREASE IN
PATIENTS FROM OUT OF STATE SINCE
THE DOBBS DECISION. AS WE
CONTINUE TO GRAPPLE WITH THE
REPERCUSSIONS OF THE DOBBS
DECISION. AND THE LEGAL
LANDSCAPE NATIONALLY CONTINUES
TO SHIFT. PLANNED PARENTHOOD IS
PREPARED TO CONTINUE TO WORK
WITH OUR STATE LEADERS. TO
EXPAND A PROTECT ACCESS TO
ABORTION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
CARE IN OUR STATE. WE'RE PROUD
THAT THE RIGHT TO ABORTION AND
BIRTH CONTROL IS NOW EXPLICITLY
IN THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION.
AND I WANT TO THANK SENATOR
SKINNER FOR HER LEADERSHIP AND
FOR BRINGING. AWARENESS TO THE
HARM CAUSED SENSOR WAS A RETURN
WITH THIS RESOLUTION. PLANNED
PARENTHOOD IS PROUD TO BE HERE
IN SUPPORT AND AS A SPONSOR OF
S. R. NINE. AND ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT COMMITTEE TODAY THANK
YOU. THANK YOU MISS ROBINSON.
ALL RIGHT. ANYONE ELSE HERE ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED WAS TESTIFYING.
IN SUPPORT. OF S. R. NINE. THANK
YOU MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS AARON
EVANS ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA NURSE MIDWIVES
ASSOCIATION. IN SUPPORT OF THIS
IMPORTANT RESOLUTION THANKS
THANK YOU ANYONE ELSE HERE ROOM
TWELVE HUNDRED. SINGH KNOWN
APPROACH THE MICRO LET'S NOW
TURN TO THE PHONES. MODERATOR IF
YOU WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE
IN SUPPORT OF S. R. NINE. THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIR ANYONE WHO
WISHES TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
THIS PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO
AT THIS TIME. IN EIGHTEEN T.
OPERATOR WILL ACCESS YOUR PHONE
LINES OUTSIDE OF THE CONFERENCE
TO PROVIDE YOU WITH FURTHER
INSTRUCTIONS. PLEASE PRESS ONE
ZERO ONLY ONCE. BUT MOMENT FOR
OUR FIRST COMMENT.
AND OUR FIRST COMMENT WILL COME
FROM. OUR FIRST COMMENT WILL
COME FROM LINE. SEVENTEEN TWENTY
SEVENTEEN YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN
. HI GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS A
NUMBER OF YOUR KIANA CALLING ON
BEHALF OF BLACK WOMEN FOR
WELLNESS AND WALKING FORM ACTION
PROJECT. PROUD SPONSORS OF THE
SENATE RESOLUTION. IN SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU. WE WILL NOW
HEAR FROM LINE FOURTEEN LINE
FOURTEEN YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
GOOD AFTERNOON BACK NEAR
STRIDENT SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF
CALIFORNIA LATINAS FOR
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE THANK YOU.
THANK YOU. AND FINAL CALL FROM
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO COMMENT
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO AT
THIS TIME. MISTER CHAIR NO ONE
THE SIGNALED THAT THEY WISH TO
SPEAK ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
MODERATOR- I BELIEVE WE HAVE TO
WITNESSES- ONE ON THE PHONE AND
ONE HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM IN
OPPOSITION SO WE NOW TURN TO THE
OPPOSITION- WE HAVE SUSAN AREN'T
ALL ON THE PHONE. YEAH WE DO
OKAY GOOD MISS ARE NOW THE FLOOR
IS YOURS. THANK YOU MY NAME IS
SUSAN TWIST ARNOLD I AM THE VICE
PRESIDENT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS AT
THE RIGHT TO LIFE LEAGUE
AMERICA'S FIRST PRO LIFE
ORGANIZATION. S. R. NINE IS A
DANGEROUS CULTURAL MARXISM.
PROMOTING THE KILLING OF HUMANS
IN THE WOMB CLOAKED. IN THE
GUISE OF REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM.
S. R. NINE REPRESENTS THE
HEIGHTS OF CALIFORNIA
LEGISLATIVE HYPOCRISY THIS VERY
BODY HAS A HISTORY OF REPEATEDLY
PASSING RESOLUTIONS AND BILLS
THAT IGNORE BOTH THE PRINT COURT
RULINGS AS WELL AS THE FULL
FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE OF THE
U. S. CONSTITUTION. IN TWENTY
TWENTY TWO YOU PASSED BOTH
SENATE RESOLUTION SIXTY THREE
AND HOUSE RESOLUTION SEVENTY
EIGHT BOTH URGED SUPPORT FOR A
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO ABORTION
ON DEMAND EVEN AS OUR SUPREME
COURT CONSIDERED THE FUNDAMENTAL
CONSTITUTIONAL FLAWS. IN ROE
VERSUS WADE WORSE THE CALIFORNIA
LEGISLATURE ACTUALLY PASSED AB
SIXTEEN FIFTY SIX A LAW THAT
IGNORES VALID OUT OF STATE
JUDGMENT. AND ITS COMPANION
PIECE AB TWENTY NINETY ONE WHICH
DEMANDS CALIFORNIA COURTS IGNORE
VALID SUBPOENAS FROM OTHER
JURISDICTIONS BOTH OF THESE LAWS
IGNORE THE FULL FAITH AND CREDIT
CLAUSE OF OUR CONSTITUTION AND
FIGURATIVELY GIVE THE MIDDLE
FINGER TWO JUDGMENTS AND
SUBPOENAS FROM OUR SISTER STATE.
JUST WEEKS AGO SENATOR SKINNER
INTRODUCED YET ANOTHER BILL SB
THIRTY SIX THE DEMANDS OUR STATE
COURTS REFUSE TO ENFORCE VALID
WARRANTS ISSUED BY OTHER STATES
THIS SHOWS A PATTERN OF DEFIANCE
OF BOTH FEDERAL AND STATE LAW.
S. R. NINE LIKE THESE LAWS SHOWS
ABSOLUTE DISDAIN AND DISRESPECT
FOR OUR FEDERAL AND STATE LAWS
S. R. NINE ONCE AGAIN DEMANDS
OUR CONGRESS TO COUNTIES HELP TO
A RADICAL PRO ABORTION
PERSPECTIVE. TO IGNORE BOTH OUR
CONSTITUTION AS WELL AS THE
CLEAR RULING OF THE SUPREME
COURT. TO IMPLEMENT THE KILLING
OF CHILL IN THE- AS A FORM OF
FREEDOM. S. ARE NOT IS MARXISM
OFFERING A TWIST HYPOCRITICAL
DEFINITION OF FREEDOM. BODY
OUGHT TO BE ASHAMED TO PASS A
RESOLUTION THAT CALLED THE
KILLING OF ANOTHER HUMAN
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM ACCORDINGLY
RESOLUTION IS AN IRRESPONSIBLE
AND REPREHENSIBLE WAIT OF
CALIFORNIA'S LEGISLATIVE TIME.
AND RESOURCES VOTE NO THANK YOU
FOR YOUR TIME ALL RIGHT. THE SUN
ALL OUR NEXT I BELIEVE- GREG
BIRD IF YOU'RE HERE GO AHEAD MR
BURT'S BROACHING MICROPHONE.
THANK YOU. OUR MEMBERS MY NAME
IS GREG BURCH I'M WITH THE
CALIFORNIA FAMILY COUNCIL. I
SUSPECT MANY OF YOU WISH PRO
LIFE ADVOCATES LIKE MYSELF WOULD
JUST GIVE IT A REST ESPECIALLY
AFTER LAST YEAR YOU SUCCESSFULLY
PASS THIRTEEN ABORTION BILLS AND
WORK TO PUT ABORTION
PROTECTIONS. IN THE STATE
CONSTITUTION RIGHT UP TO THE
MOMENT OF BIRTH. SO WHY DO
PEOPLE LIKE ME KEEP COMING BACK
TO THE CAPITAL YOU MIGHT ASK
SPEAKING OUT AGAINST ABORTION WE
WHEN WE ARE OBVIOUSLY SO OUT
NUMBER IN CALIFORNIA. OUR
OPPONENTS FALSELY ATTRIBUTE
SINISTER MOTIVES BEHIND OUR
ACTIVISM NO WE ARE NOT EAGER TO
CONTROL WOMEN'S BODIES NOR DO WE
HAVE IN IN THIS TOWARDS WOMEN.
INSTEAD WE ARE MOTIVATED BY SOME
OF THE SAME VALUES THAT I
SUSPECT ANIMATED YOUR ENTRY INTO
PUBLIC SERVICE. A BELIEF IN
PURSUING JUSTICE FOR ALL AN
EAGERNESS TO DEFEND THE DIGNITY
OF EVERY HUMAN BEING NO MATTER
HOW SMALL NO MATTER HOW
POWERLESS. IN A BAR HOW WANTED
OR UNWANTED. WE ALSO MOTIVATED
BY THE WORDS OF JESUS THE-
GOVERNOR NEWSOM QUOTED. TO
PROMOTE ABORTION LAST YEAR HE
CALLED MARK TWELVE THIRTY ONE
WHICH SAYS LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOR AS
YOURSELF THERE IS NO GREATER
COMMANDMENT. BUT WHO IS OUR
NEIGHBOR IS IT NOT THOSE WHO
NEED OUR LOVE AND PROTECTION THE
MOST NO HUMAN BEING IS MORE
VULNERABLE AND WEAK. THAT UNBORN
BABY. I'M ALSO PUT PERSONALLY
MOTIVATED TO SPEAK OUT AGAINST
ABORTION AFTER WITNESSING THE
BIRTH OF MY OWN THREE CHILDREN.
WHAT A MIRACLE THAT WAS THEIR
FINGERS IN THEIR TOES WERE SO
PERFECT THEY WERE SO SMALL AND
NEEDY. I IMMEDIATELY FELT A
DESIRE TO PROTECT THEM. IN A
RESPONSIBILITY TO PROTECT THEM
BUT ABORTION IS THE OPPOSITE OF
PROTECTION AND SLAPPING THE
WORD'S CARE- ONTO ABORTION
DOESN'T TRANSFORM THE HORROR OF
THE ACT INTO SOMETHING BEAUTIFUL
AND KIND. WE NEED TO OFFER WOMEN
WITH UNPLANNED PREGNANCIES WHO
ARE DESPERATE. BILL BE USED IN
POOR SOMETHING BETTER THAN THIS
AND THAT'S WHY WE ARE IN STRONG
OPPOSITION TO S. R. NINE PLEASE
VOTE NO. TO BIRD OKAY ANYONE
ELSE HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM
WHICH TESTIFIED IN OPPOSITION TO
S. R. NINE. SEEING KNOWN
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE
MODERATOR LET'S TURN TO THE
PHONE LINES IF YOU WOULD QUEUE
UP THOSE WHO WERE IN OPPOSITION
TO S. R. NINE. LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN THIS IS YOUR
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION. AND AGAIN WE WILL
STRESS THAT THIS IS NOT FOR
THOSE IN SUPPORT THIS IS ONLY
FOR THOSE IN OPPOSITION AT THIS
TIME. OUR FIRST COMMENT WILL
COME FROM LINE THIRTEEN.
APPENDING HERRINGTON FROM SAN
DIEGO COUNTY IN OPPOSITION. ALL
RIGHT THANK YOU. LINE TWELVE.
THIS IS MALAYSIAN WITH THE
CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE
IN OPPOSITION THANK YOU THANK
YOU. ONCE AGAIN FOR ANYONE WHO
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION
PLEASE PRESS ONE THEN ZERO.
MISTER CHAIR WE HAVE SEVERAL
PEOPLE OF SIGNALED THAT THEY
WISH TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION JUST
A MOMENT.
I'M NOW WE'RE GONNA GO TO LINE
FIFTEEN. YES CAN YOU HEAR ME YES
. THANK YOU I TRACY RESENTED HEY
WE'RE CALIFORNIA MEMBER OF PRO
LIFE SAN FRANCISCO BOTH IN
OPPOSITION THANK YOU RIGHT. AND
PARDON ME MR TERROR JUST ANOTHER
MOMENT.
IT'S GOING TO GO NOW TO LINE
EIGHTEEN YOUR LINE IS NOW OPEN.
MY NAME IS DANA LOESCH AND WITH
THE CAPITOL RESOURCE INSTITUTE
AND I WOULD LIKE TO- TO SAY THAT
I OPPOSED VERY STRONGLY OF FOUR
NINE THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT NEXT.
THE TEACHER THERE IS NO ONE ELSE
OKAY LET'S BRING IT BACK HERE TO
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM
QUESTIONS COMMENTS BY- COMMITTEE
MEMBERS SEEING- CENTER THAT ALSO
MOVES THE BILL. QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS SAYING CENTER MEANT. HI
I WANNA THANK MY COLLEAGUE
SENATOR SKINNER AND PRETEND IN
MY COLLEAGUES AND LEGISLATIVE
WOMEN'S CAUCUS FOR BRINGING THIS
FORWARD- I AM A FATHER THREE
CHILDREN I'M A CHRISTIAN
PRACTICING AND I STRONGLY
SUPPORT S. R. NINE NOW MY THREE
CHILDREN ALSO PRESSURES I
REALLY. APPRECIATED AND LOVED
EVERY MOMENT OF THEIR BIRTH BUT
MY WIFE AND I MADE THAT DECISION
MY WIFE MADE THE DECISION ON
WHEN WE WOULD HAVE THOSE
CHILDREN SHE LET ME BE PART OF
THAT DECISION- WE USE
CONTRACEPTION UNTIL THE TIME
WHEN WE FELT IT WAS APPROPRIATE
TO HAVE KIDS WHEN WE WERE READY
IT WAS OUR CHOICE OUR DECISION.
NOW AS MANY OF YOU MAY KNOW I
WAS A LAW PROFESSOR BEFORE
JOINING THE STATE SENATE I WAS
NOT A CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
PROFESSOR- BUT I KNOW ENOUGH
ABOUT CONSTITUTIONAL LAW TO NOTE
THAT THE DECISION IN DOBBS WAS
OUTRAGEOUS IT WAS DISHONEST. THE
FIVE JUSTICES WHO DRAFTED THIS
OPINION WHO SIGNED ON THIS IS
DANIEL LEADERS DRAFT OPINION I
TALKED ABOUT THE ROLE AS NEUTRAL
ARBITERS AS REFEREES TO CALL
BALLS AND STRIKES- AND YET THEY
LIED. THREE OF THEM EXPRESSLY
SAID UNDER OATH TO THE SENATE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE THAT THEY
RESPECTED THE PRECEDENT SET BY
ROE V. WADE THAT THEY WOULD
FOLLOW IT. AND AS SOON AS THEY
HAD FIVE MEMBERS READY TO
OVERTURN IT. THEY REVERSED THAT
POSITION- THIS IS A DECISION
THAT HAS HAD A HUGE IMPACT ON
OUR SOCIETY WILL HAVE HUGE
IMPACT ON OUR ECONOMY. AND BY
THE WAY I WILL NOTE THAT THE
LOGIC OF THE DECISION DOESN'T
JUST AFFECT WOMEN'S REPRODUCTIVE
RIGHTS. THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY
LIES AT THE ROOT OF MANY MANY
RIGHTS WE TAKE FOR GRANTED
TODAY. INCLUDING INTERRACIAL
MARRIAGE AND I HAVE AN
INTERRACIAL MARRIAGE THIS IS AN
OUTRAGEOUS DECISION IT'S ONE
THAT DEFIES ALL LOGIC ALL
PRECEDENT. IS DISHONEST AND I
THINK THAT WE IN CALIFORNIA NEED
TO DO ALL WE CAN TO DEFEND
PEOPLE'S LIBERTIES. SO I MOVED
THE BILL AS WELL AND I THINK.
THE AUTHOR SERVING IN THIS FOR.
THANK CENTERMAN. SEEING NO
COMMENTS OR- CENTER SKINNER YOU
CARE CLOSE- THANK YOU CHAIR-
THIS RESOLUTION ON LIKE YEARS
PAST. WHERE WE WERE PRIMARILY
MARKING AN ANNIVERSARY THIS
RESOLUTION ALSO INCLUDES IT IS A
COMMUNICATION TO OUR FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT TO THE PRESIDENT
CONGRESS TO ACT. BECAUSE WHAT.
THE DOGS DECISION ON LIKE ONE OF
THE OPPONENTS DESCRIPTION THE
DOGS DECISION. LEFT IT TO THE
STATES. AND SO. IT DIDN'T MAKE
ABORTION PER SE ILLEGAL. ONLY IF
THE STATE ACTED. AND SO GIVEN
THAT STATES ARE ACTING. AND ALSO
THE DOBBS DECISION BASICALLY
SAID. BUT IF CONGRESS WANTS TO
DO OTHERWISE THEY HAVE THE RIGHT
TO. ACT IN TO PUT IN LAW. THE
RIGHT TO AN ABORTION OR
PROTECTIONS FOR ABORTION. AND SO
THAT'S WHAT THIS RESOLUTION DOES
THAT'S WHAT IT ASKS. OUR FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT TO DO IT WITHOUT I
ASK FOR YOUR I. PHONE. THANK YOU
CENTER SKINNER THE BILL'S BEEN
MOVED BY US IN ORDER ALSO. OF
MISTER SINISTER IF YOU'D CALL
THE ROLL. ONE SECTOR COLOSSAL. A
THE MOTION IS THAT THE
RESOLUTION BE ADOPTED AS AMENDED
I'M BURKE. UMBERG I WILK. ALAN
ALLEN I S. B. SB I. CABALLERO.
CABALLERO I TO RUSSELL. RUSSELL
I LAYERED. LAYERED I AM IN. IN I
NEED A LITTLE. NEIL- NO STERN.
STERN AYE WIENER HI WIENER I.
SIX HEY A YOU HAVE NINETY ONE SO
FAR. ALL RIGHT- WE'LL LEAVE THE
ROLE OPEN HERE FOR A MOMENT- YES
I'M SORRY WHO WHO WHO- SYNDROME.
WILK ALL RIGHT WE'LL LEAVE THE
ROLE OPEN OF SIR WILK WISHES TO
RETURN. FOR FIVE MINUTES. SO
BEFORE WILL DEPART THOUGH- I
WANT TO THANK ALL THE
INDIVIDUALS TO STATE PUBLIC
TESTIMONY TODAY IF YOU WERE NOT
ABLE TO TESTIFY PLEASE SUBMIT
YOUR COMMENTS OR SUGGESTIONS IN
WRITING THE SENATE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE AT. S. J. U. D. DOT F.
A. X. AT S. C. N. DOT CA DOT GOP
OR VISIT OUR WEBSITE FOR
INSTRUCTIONS YOUR COMMENTS AND
SUGGESTIONS ARE IMPORTANT TO US
AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE YOUR
TESTIMONY OFFICIAL COMMITTEE
RECORDS THANK YOU AND WE
APPRECIATE YOUR PARTICIPATION.
THANK YOU EVERYONE HERE FOR YOUR
PATIENCE ALL OF A WAIT SENATOR
WILL FOR A FEW MINUTES-
OTHERWISE WE HAVE NO OTHER
BUSINESS TO CONSIDER. RIGHT IT
WOULD. AT.
ALL RIGHT THANKS AT. ONE TWO
THREE FOUR FIVE SIX. OF THE VOTE
IS NINE TWO ONE. ALL RIGHT THE
RESOLUTION PASSES- WITH THAT WE
WILL ADJOURN THANK YOU.