MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA ATKINS
BATES BACKER FORTRESS BRADFORD
CABALLERO PROTESTING DIALING
DODD YOUR BROWSER EGGMAN
GLAZER GONZALEZ GROW HERTZBERG
WESSUN FOR TIGER JONES KAMLAGER
LAYERED LEYVA LIMÓN WIRE
MELENDEZ MEN NEWMAN NIELSEN
A TROUBLED PAN PORTANTINO
ROTH RUBIO SKINNER STERN
AMBERG WHITE HOUSE E.
WIENER WELL
THANK YOU MADAM SECRETARY
A QUORUM IS PRESENT WITH
THE MEMBERS AND OUR GUESTS
BE ON THE RAIL AND IN THE
GALLERY PLEASE RISE WE
WILL BE LED IN PRAYER THIS
AFTERNOON OR THIS MORNING
BY SENATOR GLAZERS AFTER
WHICH PLEASE REMAIN STANDING
WILL BE LED IN THE PLEDGE
OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG BY
SENATOR HUESO SENATOR GLAZERS
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT OUR
THOUGHTS TURN TO MEMBERS OF THE
SENATE FAMILY WHO PASSED AWAY
THIS SESSION THEY WERE PERSONS
WHO POUR THEIR PASSION AND
LOVE FOR CALIFORNIA INTO THEIR
WORK HERE IN THE CAPITAL THEY
WERE OUR FRIENDS AND CO WORKERS
STATE LEADERS OF ENORMOUS
REPUTATION AN ACCOMPLISHMENT
STAFFAN COMMITTEE CONSULTANTS
WHO GUIDED US WITH WISDOM
AND PERSPECTIVE AND FAMILY
MEMBERS WHOSE LOVED THE SIMPLY
IRREPLACEABLE WE REMEMBER
THEM TODAY AND ALWAYS IN
THE JEWISH TRADITION I WILL
OFFER THE MOURNERS KADDISH
BUT FIRST WE REMEMBER
CAPE CASWELL MATT GRAVER MARK
HANSEN RICHARD PAUL TYLER
WILCOX LARRY LUNA HM A SENATOR
TOM BERRYHILL SENATOR JOHN
DUNLAP SENATOR BOB DUTTON
SENATOR GARY HART SENATOR
BETTY CORNET SENATOR ROBERT
LUDLUM ARSINOE SENATOR JAMES
MILLS SENATOR JOE MANTEGNA
SENATOR RICHARD RAINY
THE DAHLE FEET CUT DIE SHOULD
MEHRABAN THE -- MALDIVE
ROCK TODAY THE ON THE MARKET
TODAY THIS IPHONE OF THE ON
THE PHONE WITH A K.
EIGHT ACCOMMODATE THIS RIGHT
NOW I'VE GOT A LOT OF HIS MIND
CARRYING THE IN ROOM ON MAY
HAITIAN NAY RABAH NAY OF OUR
US LEGAL -- ALL MAY ON MY HE
ARRIVED PETER BOTTE B.
R.
B.
REMIND BE NICE SAY HE HAD DIRE
BEAT HALEP THE HALAL SHE MADE
A COULD BE SHOT TO THEY WILL
-- MEAN COAL KUTTA THIS YEAR
OUTSIDE TO SHOULD THE HOT TUB
IN SMI TA THE ON THE RUN WELL
HELLO MY NAME HEY SELAMAT RABAT
MEANS TO MY -- THE HIGH EMAIL A
NEW VEHICLE USE FOR L.
E.
MU AVE A SAY SHALOM DIMOND
WHO YA SE SHALOM ELENA VEHICLE
YISRAEL THE ROOM ON MAIN THE
ONE WHO CREATES HARMONY ON HIGH
IN PEACE AND COMFORT TO ALL
OF US SEQUIN -- LEAVE RUSSIA
ZERO NINE LEAVE RUSSIA BETTER
MEMORY BE A BLESSING THANK YOU
-- CITY -- AND YOU SEE WE --
THE DOLE OWNS THE MOVE THE
LOVE WELL IT'S SO -- DO YOU WE
WELL I LOVE I BELIEVE YOU
CAN WHOSE BROAD STRIPES AND
BRIGHT -- IT'S STRONG LOANS
HE REMOVE IT IS -- HUH ALL THE
RIGHT -- WELL WE WILL WHO'S
SO GOOD -- MOON LEVI'S HE HE
HUGGING THE RALPH CARE IT'S
-- DO YOU
LEAVE ME THROUGH NOW THAT
ALL OF THOSE TO DO HOLES
SAY THOSE LAWS WON'T SPEND
EARN GOULD -- YOU WOOD
HOLD THE LINE -- OWNED
HOMES THROUGH YOU
GOAL LOW BROUGH DO
GOOD MORNING MEMBERS
WELCOME TO OUR LAST DAY
OF SESSION LET ME SAY IT
CENTER GLAZER THANK YOU
SENATOR HUESO THANK YOU BOTH
OF YOU LOVELY WAY TO START
OUR LAST DAY OF SESSION
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS MEMBERS
WE HAVE A VERY SPECIAL
GUEST WITH US TODAY AT THE
BACK OF CHAMBERS ONE OF MY
PERSONAL FAVORITE PEOPLE
SENATOR HOLLY MITCHELL STEP
BY STEP ON THE RED CARPET
WE MISS YOU EVERYDAY HOLLY
MITCHELL ALL RIGHT MEMBERS
WELCOME TO OUR LAST DAY
OF SESSION WE HAVE A BUSY
DAY SO LET'S GET TO IT I
JUST WANT TO SAY -- THIS
IS MY LAST DAY PRESIDING
AND I AM BEEN SO HONORED TO
BE YOUR PRESIDING OFFICER
ALL RIGHT WE ARE GOING TO GO
TO MESSAGES FROM THE GOVERNOR
DEEMED READ MESSAGES FROM THE
ASSEMBLY DEEMED READ REPORTS
OF COMMITTEES DEEMED READ
MOTIONS RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES
MEMBERS THIS WOULD BE THE TIME
YOU WANT TO MOVE ANYTHING TO
THE INACTIVE FILE DOES ANYONE
HAVE ANYTHING UNDER MOTIONS
RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES ALL
RIGHT SEEING AND HEARING NONE
WE WILL MOVE TO CONSIDERATION
OF THE DAILY FILE MEMBERS
WE ARE GOING TO START WITH
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING WE'RE
GOING TO START WITH FILE ITEM
FORTY SENATOR WIENER MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY
BILL NINE THIRTY SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER CARILLO AN
ACT RELATING TO IMMIGRATION
ENFORCEMENT SENATOR WIENER
I THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF
THANK YOU VERY MUCH RENDON
PRESIDENT I COLLEAGUES I
RISE TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL
NINE THIRTY SEVEN THE VISION
ACT ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CARDIO AND IS A PROUD
CO AUTHOR OF THIS BILL AB
NINE THIRTY SEVEN PROTECTS
INCARCERATED REFUGEE AND
IMMIGRANT CALIFORNIANS WHO
ARE ELIGIBLE FOR RELEASED FROM
JAILS AND PRISONS WHO HAVE
BEEN REHABILITATED FROM FACING
ADDITIONAL PUNISHMENT AND THE
IMMIGRATION DETENTION SYSTEM
IN RECENT YEARS A LEGISLATURE
IN CALIFORNIA VOTERS HAVE
COMMITTED TO REFORMING OUR
CRIMINAL LEGAL SYSTEM AND
ENDING MASS INCARCERATION
YEAH FOR IMMIGRANTS WHO HAVE
EARNED RELEASE WHO HAVE PAID
THEIR DEBT TO THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WHO'VE DONE THEIR
TIME WHO'VE BEEN PAROLED
WHO HAVE BEEN DETERMINED
TO HAVE BEEN REHABILITATED
THAT IS NOT THE END OF THEIR
PUNISHMENT BECAUSE THE CDCR
OUR PRISON SYSTEM WHICH IS
UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO DO THIS
VOLUNTARILY TURNS THEM OVER
TO ICE FOR DEPORTATION TO BE
CLEAR THESE INDIVIDUALS KAMALA
CRIME AND THEY PAID THEIR DEBT
TO THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
DID THEIR TIME AND HAVE BEEN
DETERMINED TO BE REHABILITATED
AND NCDC ARE VOLUNTARILY NO
LEGAL OBLIGATION TURNS THEM
OVER TO ICE FOR DEPORTATION
MANY COUNTIES IN CALIFORNIA
HAVE ALREADY DECIDED THAT THIS
IS WRONG THERE'S A WHOLE LIST
OF THEM WHO DECIDED THIS IS
NOT THE WAY TO RUN A CRIMINAL
JUSTICE SYSTEM TO BE CLEAR
THIS WAS NOTHING TO CHANGE THE
CRIMINAL LAW DOESN'T CHANGE
ONCE A CRIME WHAT THE SENTENCES
FOR THE CRIME IT DOESN'T CHANGE
WHEN SOMEONE GETS PAROLED
BUT STILL ALL THE SAME IN
TERMS OF THE TERMINATION OF
REHABILITATION ALL IT DOES IS
SAID THAT CDCR IS NOT GOING TO
VOLUNTARILY TURN THESE PEOPLE
OVER TO ICE FOR DEPORTATION
AFTER THEY'VE BEEN DETERMINED
TO BE REHABILITATED WHY IS
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AFTER
THE DEBT HAS BEEN PAID TO
OUR STATE CONTINUING ABOUT
PUNISHMENT CONSEQUENCES ARE
REAL AS RECENTLY AN INDIVIDUAL
TO CAMBODIA WHO WAS HE DID
HIS TIME OVER TWENTY YEARS
IN PRISON BECAME A MODEL
PRISONER HELPING OTHER AS
INTERNS AND HE WAS PAROLED THE
STATE DETERMINED HE HAD BEEN
REHABILITATED HE HAD COME TO
THIS COUNTRY AT THE AGE OF
FOUR GREW UP HERE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA VOLUNTARILY TURNED
THEM OVER TO ICE GOT DEPORTED
TO CAMBODIA A PLACE TO START
IT'S NOT HIS COUNTRY ANYMORE
THIS IS THIS COUNTRY THIS IS
COMMUNITY IS FAMILY AND YET
THAT'S WHAT CALIFORNIA IS
DOING NOW I WISH THIS BILL
WERE UNNECESSARY WE'VE BEEN
ASKING THE ADMINISTRATION
CDC ARE FOR YEARS STOP DOING
THIS AND THEY WON'T SO IT'S
TIME FOR THE LEGISLATURE ACTS
RECENT AMENDMENTS ALLOW CDCR
TO CONTINUE TO TRANSFERRED
TO ICE AND REPEAT OFFENDERS
COMMITTED VERY SERIOUS CRIMES
UNLESS THAT INDIVIDUAL HAS A
UNIQUE VULNERABILITY TO HARM
LAST YEAR A MAN WAS TAKEN TO
MAKE CLEAR THAT THE STATE CAN
STILL PARTICIPATE IN JOINT TASK
FORCES THAT INCLUDE ICE THE
AUTHOR HAS BEEN REASONABLE AND
LISTENING AND TAKING AMENDMENTS
AND IT'S TIME FOR THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA TO STOP SAYING
YOU'RE REHABILITATED YOU'VE
DONE YOUR TIME RELEASING YOU
OVER JUST WHAT WE'RE GOING TO
TURN OVER TO ICE TO GET YOU
DEPORTED IT'S WRONG IT NEEDS
TO STOP I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN IPO THANK YOU SENATOR
WIENER MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND
DEBATE CENTER GONZALEZ THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I
RISE TODAY AS A PROUD PRINCIPLE
CO AUTHOR AT EIGHTY NINE
THIRTY SEVEN THIS LEGISLATIVE
BODY HAS REALLY DONE SO MUCH
IN THE PAST FEW YEARS TO
ADDRESS MISGUIDED PASS MASS
INCARCERATION POLICIES THAT
HAVE DISPROPORTIONATELY HARMED
BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITIES AND
THAT OFFER MORE INCARCERATED
INDIVIDUAL INDIVIDUALS WHO
HAVE DEMONSTRATED THEIR HURT
REHABILITATION A SECOND TIME
AS MENTIONED BY MY COLLEAGUE
FROM SANFORD FRANCISCO THIS IS
WHAT HAPPENED TO MY CONSTITUENT
HIS NAME A CITY BEEN AND HIS
FAMILY WHILE IN PRISON CITY
FOUND HIS FAITH AND BECAME AN
ORDAINED MINISTER HE WORKED
TIRELESSLY TO SUPPORT HIS
PEERS WHILE INCARCERATED AFTER
EARNING A GRANT OF A PAROLE
CITY SHOULD HAVE GONE HOME
TO HIS FAMILY BUT CDC ARE
CALLED ICE AND WAS TAKEN BACK
TO PRISON -- IN MESA VERDE IN
BAKERSFIELD THIS IS UNFORTUNATE
AND SO MANY OF OUR ADVOCATES
ARE PUSHING TO ENSURE THAT WE
DON'T HAVE THIS DOUBLE JEOPARDY
ESSENTIALLY -- THAT IF THERE
ARE FOLKS THAT ARE ACTUALLY
REHABILITATED THAT THEY HAVE
AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE RE ENTERED
INTO THEIR COMMUNITIES BACK
HOME IN PLACES LIKE LONG
BEACH THAT WILL SUPPORT THEM
SO WITH THAT I ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE AND I THINK ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CARDIO FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD AND SO MANY OF
THE ADVOCATES FOR PUSHING
AND I HOPE THAT ALL OF YOU
CAN CAN VOTE I AS WELL THANK
YOU CENTER GONZALEZ SENATOR
BECKER I THANK YOU ARE TRYING
TO YOU SEE WHY I'M SUPPORTING
THIS MEASURE AN EXAMPLE WAS
COUPLE FRIDAYS AGO I WAS IT SAN
QUENTIN FOR THE GRADUATION OF
A PROGRAM CALLED GRIP GUIDING
RAGE INTO POWER AND I SEE
A LOT OF POWERFUL PROGRAMS
THIS WAS THE MOST POWERFUL
I'VE SEEN INCREDIBLE FIFTY
TWO WEEK PROGRAM THAT THESE
MEN GO THROUGH AND THEY'RE IN
THESE TRIBES TRIED H.
TWO THREE TRIBES SIX TWO SIX
WHAT WHAT IS THAT TRIBE WELL
IT'S THIS IS THE CUMULATIVE
YEARS SERVED BY PEOPLE THE
TWENTY TEN TWENTY THIRTY
PEOPLE IN THAT TRIBE AND IT
WAS SO POWERFUL TO MEET MARINE
CORPS GENERAL WITH US HIS
PARTICIPATION AS AN ADVISOR
HELPS HIM COME TO GRIPS WITH
AND COME TO HEAL WITH WHAT
HE HAD PUT HIS PEOPLE UNDER
HIS COMMAND TO IT IS JUST
INCREDIBLE AND IT WAS THE FIRST
TIME THAT IT IN LANGUAGE ONE
AS WELL SO THERE WAS A A COHORT
A TRIBE OF LATINO MEMBERS
AND THEY WENT THROUGH TO THE
GRADUATION INCREDIBLY POWERFUL
AND AT THE END IT JUST READ
LEAVE AFTER HOURS SOMEONE CAME
UP TO ME AND THEY SAID HEY CAN
YOU HELP THIS PERSON IS WHAT
HE SERVED IN THE NAVY I'M I'M
SEASON HERE HE'S GONNA GET
OUT AND THEN HE'S GONNA GET
DEPORTED AND TO ME THAT'S JUST
A REAL REAL LIFE EXAMPLE LET'S
GO THIS I BELIEVE A POWERFUL
DAY YOU KNOW WE HAD PEOPLE
GET UP AND SAY PEOPLE FROM THE
OUTSIDE WHO DID THE GUY SAID
IN TWENTY SIXTEEN I WAS TOLD
I'D NEVER GET PAROLE HE WENT
TO THIS PROGRAM HE GOT PEOPLE
NOW HE'S COMING BACK IN ITS
FACILITATOR INCREDIBLY POWERFUL
DAY AND THIS GUY RISK RISK
DEPORTATION FOR STORIES LIKE
THAT THAT'S WHY I'M SUPPORTING
THIS BILL TODAY THANK YOU THANK
YOU CENTER BAKER CENTER DORADO
I RISE AS A PROUD CO AUTHOR AND
DOES THE CHAIR OF THE LATINO
CAUCUS BALI ONE OF THE LAST
TIMES I RISE AS CHAIR OF THE
LATINO CAUCUS -- AND I RISE IN
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL BECAUSE
IT WILL PROTECT COMMUNITY
MEMBERS WHO'VE ALREADY DEEMED
ELIGIBLE FOR RELEASE FROM BEING
TRANSFERRED TO IMMIGRATION
DETENTION AND DEPORTATION I
JUST WANT TO SEE A LITTLE BIT
ABOUT MY OWN EXPERIENCE IN LOS
ANGELES THE ISSUE OF SEPARATING
OUT ARE CRIMINALS JUSTICE
SYSTEM FROM A CIVIL SYSTEM
WHICH IS THE IMMIGRATION SYSTEM
THEY'VE BEEN COUPLE THEY BEEN
OVERLAPPED THE BEEN USED THE
CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM HAS
USED A CIVIL ADMINISTRATIVE
SYSTEM IMMIGRATION LAWS THEN
DOUBLE THE PUNISHMENT ON
ANYONE WHO IS NOT A CITIZEN
FORM BORN NOT A CITIZEN DOUBLE
PUNISHMENT FOR WHATEVER CRIME
THEY COMMITTED AND THAT HAS
HAPPENED SO MUCH THAT HAVE A
FOR THE YOU KNOW THE HISTORY OF
OUR COMMUNITIES HAS HAPPENED SO
MUCH THAT THEY'RE THIS DISTRUST
HAS GROWN DEEPER AND DEEPER
ABOUT WHEN AND HOW DO YOU TRUST
LAW ENFORCEMENT BECAUSE WE'LL
NEED LAW ENFORCEMENT BUT AT
THE SAME TIME LAW ENFORCEMENT
WAS USING IMMIGRATION WHICH
HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE
CRIMES COMMITTED USING THE
IMMIGRATION SYSTEM TO CREATE
MORE FEAR TO CREATE SEPARATION
OF FAMILIES OF PERMANENT
SEPARATION OF FAMILIES -- AND
DAMAGE THAT I THINK UNLESS
YOU'RE IN THAT COMMUNITY YOU
REALLY DON'T UNDERSTAND THE
DAMAGE THAT THAT'S CAUSING
SO FOR DECADES WE HAVE IN NOT
ONLY LOS ANGELES BUT IN OTHER
PARTS OF THE STATE AND OTHER
PARTS OF THE COUNTRY SAY HE'S
GOT TO BE A SEPARATION HERE WE
CAN'T HAVE ENTIRE COMMUNITIES
SUBJECT TO TWO SYSTEMS I GET
INTERLOCKED AND GET USED TO --
-- BECAUSE DOUBLE PUNISHMENT
ON THOSE INDIVIDUALS ENDING
THESE TRANSFERS TO ICE IS THE
APPROPRIATE ACTION FOR US TO
TAKE A REFLECTS ON WHO WE ARE
WE BELIEVE IN REHABILITATION
WE BELIEVE THAT MEN AND WOMEN
WE SHOULD BE GIVEN THAT SECOND
OPPORTUNITY AND I JUST WANT
TO FINALLY WE REMIND US THAT
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS THAT
I'M TALKING ABOUT ARE REFUGEES
THAT MEANS THEY'RE HERE IT WERE
HERE LEGALLY LAWFUL PERMANENT
RESIDENTS PARENTS CARETAKERS
AND OTHER ESSENTIAL WORKERS
COLLEAGUES I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR DORADO SENATOR NIELSEN
BUT A PRESENT LAYS DOWN ON THE
SENATE THIS ACTIVITY IS ILLEGAL
IT IS NOT INNOCENT THERE ARE
EXAMPLES OF THOSE WHO HAVE
COME HERE AND BEEN SUCCESSFUL
THE VARIOUS REGIONS BUT MORE
NOW THAN EVER BEFORE DUE TO
FEDERAL IMMIGRATION POLICIES WE
HAVE NO BORDER POURING ACROSS
THOSE BORDERS ARE NOT THE
SWEET INNOCENCE WHO COME HERE
FOR LIBERATION FROM TRAGEDIES
IN THEIR OWN COUNTRIES BUT
THEY'RE COMING HERE FOR
CRIME CARTELS ARE GETTING
PAID MILLIONS OF DOLLARS THE
TRANSFER INDIVIDUALS INTO
THE UNITED STATES AND THOSE
INDIVIDUALS ARE NOT HERE FOR
GOOD PURPOSES WE CANNOT FORGET
THAT DOUBLE JEOPARDY NO DOUBLE
CRIME AND THESE INDIVIDUALS
MANY ARE NOT COMING HERE TO
BE LAW ABIDING CITIZENS THE
COMING HERE TO BRING INSIDIOUS
DRUGS IN GANG ACTIVITY IN
THE PROCESS OF COMING HERE
OPPRESSING THOSE WHO WANT TO
COME HERE EXTORTING TENS OF
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS OUT OF
THOSE INDIVIDUALS LINING THEIR
CRIMINAL POCKETS AND WALKING
AWAY YES THESE SWEET DARLINGS
BRING EVEN KIDS END OF THE
DESERT YOU WALK AWAY AND LEAVE
THEM THERE THEY DON'T WANT TO
BE BOTHERED LAW ENFORCEMENT
IS PURSUING THEM THEY WANT TO
UNBURDEN THEMSELVES FROM THE
RESPONSIBILITY OF SOMEONE WHO
PAID THEM ZERO NOW THIS IS A
CRIME IT SHOULD CONTINUE TO BE
LOOKED AT AS SUCH URGENT OVER
SENATOR NIELSEN SENATOR PAN
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
SENATORS I'M PROUD SUPPORT
EIGHTY NINE THIRTY SEVEN
DIVISION ACT WHICH IS A
PRIORITY BILL FOR THE ASIAN
AMERICAN PACIFIC ISLANDER
LEGISLATIVE CAUCUS IN THIS
CHAIR THAT CAUCUS I WANT
TO SPEAK TO THE IMPORTANCE
AND URGENCY OF ENDING ICE
TRANSFERS FOR ASIAN AND PACIFIC
ISLANDER IMMIGRANTS AND REFUGEE
COMMUNITIES HERE IN CALIFORNIA
WE ARE AT A PIVOTAL TIME
IN WHICH THE ENTIRE COUNTRY
IS FINALLY PAYING ATTENTION
TO VIOLENCE AGAINST ASIAN
AMERICANS AAPI COMMUNITIES
IN PARTICULAR SOUTHEAST ASIAN
REFUGEES HAVE BEEN DEVASTATED
BY ICE TRANSFERS THE VIETNAM
WAR ABOARD THAT COURSE OUR
COUNTRY WAS INVOLVED IN LED
TO VAST MIGRATION OF SELF
FROM SOUTHEAST ASIA FROM LAOS
CAMBODIA AND VIETNAM THESE
REFUGEES WERE MANY OF THEM WERE
FAMILIES WHO AIDED AMERICANS
IN THE WAR THESE REFUGEES WHO
THEN RESETTLED IN THE UNITED
STATES WERE PLACED IN POOR
NEIGHBORHOODS WITH LITTLE TO
NO CULTURALLY COMPETENT IN
LANGUAGE ACCESSIBLE RESOURCES
SO THESE REFUGEES THE SOUTHEAST
ASIAN REFUGEE CHILDREN GREW
UP IN THE UNITED STATES DURING
THE NINETEEN NINETIES A DECADE
MARKETED MARC BY PROLIFERATION
OF LOCAL AND NATIONAL MASS
INCARCERATION POLICIES
INCLUDING MANDATORY MINIMUM
SENTENCES THE WAR ON DRUGS AND
SENTENCING CHILDREN AS ADULTS
IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS NOT
SURPRISINGLY THE RESULT WAS
INCARCERATIONS MANY SOUTH EAST
ASIAN REFUGEES AND PACIFIC
ISLANDERS HERE IN CALIFORNIA
THE LADY CAME OVER AS CHILDREN
ARE INFANTS WHEN SOUTHEAST
ASIAN REFUGEES OF WORKS
HARD TO REHABILITATE DEVELOP
DETAILED UNSTABLE REENTRY
PLANS AND EARNED A RELEASE
FROM THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE
SYSTEM THEY'RE NOW BEING
IMMEDIATELY TRANSFERRED TO ICE
FOR INDEFINITE DETENTION AND
DEPORTATION TO A COUNTRY THAT
MANY OF DON'T EVEN REMEMBER
SO WHAT THE FACTS SHOW WELL
ACTUALLY SOUTHEAST ASIAN
REFUGEES ARE THREE TO FOUR
TIMES MORE LIKELY TO BE
DEPORTED FOR PAST CONVICTIONS
THAN ANY OTHER THAN OTHER
IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES
BETWEEN TWENTY SEVENTEEN
TO TWENTY EIGHTEEN THERE
WAS A TWO HUNDRED SEVENTY
NINE PERCENT SPIKE IN THE
DEPORTATION CAMBODIAN REFUGEES
IN A MARCH TWENTY TWENTY ONE
THE SAME WEEK AS THE HORRIFIC
ATLANTA SHOOTINGS OF ASIAN
WOMEN ASIAN AMERICAN WOMEN
AND DURING PRESENT BY HIS
MORATORIUM OF THE PORTION
DEPORTATIONS THIRTY THREE
VIETNAMESE REFUGEE COMMITTEE
MEMBERS WERE TRAGICALLY
DEPORTED JUST IN TWENTY TWENTY
CALIFORNIA ITSELF TRANSFERRED
TO ETHNIC MINORITY REFUGEES
FROM LAOS KELSEY LEE AND BONE
CHINA TEA A LOT BOTH OF THEIR
FAMILIES AIDED THE U.
S.
MILITARY DURING THE VIETNAM
WAR THEY WERE ALLIES
EACH OF THEM WORKED AS
INCARCERATED FIREFIGHTERS
ON THE FRONT LINES OF WORST
WILDFIRES IN OUR STATE'S
HISTORY THEY HELP PROTECT
CALIFORNIAN HOMES AND LIVES
AND WHILE BOTH COW AND BHUTAN
WE'RE VINCE LEE PARDONED BY
GOVERNOR NEWSOM THEY SPENT MANY
MONTHS IN HORRENDOUS CONDITIONS
IN ICE DETENTION FILL
FACILITIES MCFARLANE CALIFORNIA
LOUISIANA AS A RESULT OF
THE TRANSFER FROM CDC ARE
AND THOSE ARE JUST THE ONLY
TO BECAUSE JUST LAST MONTH WHO
KNEW WITH DEPORTED TO CAMBODIA
A COUNTRY SEE IN THIS FAMILY
FLED DURING THE KHMER ROUGE
GENOCIDE WHEN HE WAS ONLY FOUR
YEARS OLD HE WAS NOT COMING TO
THIS COUNTRY TO COMMIT CRIMES
AND DELIVER DRUGS OR WHATEVER
ELSE HE WAS FOUR YEARS OLD
YEAH HE WAS TRANSFERRED TO ICE
BY PASSING DIVISION ACT
CALIFORNIA CAN PREVENT THE
DETENTION AND DEPORTATION
OF PEOPLE LIKE HOW -- JOHN
SOON AND MANY OTHER ASIANS
AND PACIFIC ISLANDERS YES
THEY MADE MISTAKES AS YOUNG
PEOPLE AND THEY'VE HAD
THEY WERE INCARCERATED AND
PUNISHED BUT IF TRANSFORM TWO
DECADES LATER IT'S TIME TO
END THIS VIOLENCE AGAINST API
COMMUNITIES DIVISION ACT IT'S
CRITICAL TO THAT ESPECIALLY
AS FOR KNIGHTHOODS THANK YOU
SENATOR PAN CENTER EGGMAN
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS -- I WANT TO START
UP OR SAYING OUR IMMIGRATION
SYSTEM IS BROKEN OUR
IMMIGRATION SYSTEM IS BROKEN
IT NEEDS TO BE FIXED WE NEED
TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THAT I
CAN'T DO THAT AT MY LEVEL I
ALSO WANT TO SAY THAT I AM NOT
A SOCIAL WORKER I BELIEVE IN
REDEMPTION AND I THINK I'VE
DEMONSTRATE THAT THROUGH MY
CAREER IN IN TRYING TO REALLY
ADVANCE JUSTICE ADVANCE EQUITY
MY VERY FIRST BILL -- THAT I
PASSED THAT CAME CAME FROM MY
COMMUNITY IN A IN A AGENCY I
WAS ASSOCIATED WITH THAT HELPED
UNDOCUMENTED WOMEN MOSTLY WOMEN
MOSTLY OF LATINO AND AN API
WOMEN WHO HAVE BEEN VICTIMS
OF CRIME BUT WERE UNABLE TO
GET THEIR CRIME REPORTS TO BE
ABLE TO STOP DEPORTATION AND OR
OR ANYTHING ELSE BECAUSE THEY
WEREN'T HERE DOCUMENT WE CHANGE
THAT BILL THEY SHOULD NOT OUR
CRIMINAL SYSTEM SHOULD NOT RE
VICTIMIZE THE VERY PEOPLE IT'S
TRYING TO PROTECT BUT ON THIS
BILL I AM I CANNOT SUPPORT IT
I SUPPORTED THE VALUES ACT AND
I ASKED FOR THIS BILL TO BE
NARROWED SO WE COULD I COULD
FEEL BETTER ABOUT IT BECAUSE AT
THE END OF THE DAY THE JOB I DO
HAVE IS TO ENSURE MY COMMUNITY
A SAFE AND TO DO EVERYTHING I
CAN TO ENSURE THE SAFETY OF MY
CONSTITUENTS WHEN PEOPLE TALK
ABOUT THE BATTLE DAYS WHEN YOU
WERE IN THE LEGISLATURE KNEW
HOW TO MAKE CUTS I WAS ON THE
STOCKTON CITY COUNCIL WE HAD
ALMOST A RECORD OF A HUNDRED
MURDERS WHEN CRIME WAS OUT OF
CONTROL AND WE WERE GOING INTO
BANKRUPTCY AND CUTTING POLICE
AND CUTTING FIRE AND THERE
WAS A PALPABLE FEELING OF FEAR
IN MY COMMUNITY WHEN I FIRST
STARTED HERE I REMEMBER SAYING
I'M NOT TAKING PER DIEM AND
I'M I TEAMS THAT AND I'M LIKE
BUT I GO BACK AND FORTH EVERY
SINGLE DAY BECAUSE I WANT TO
BE ABLE TO HEAR AND EXPERIENCE
OF MY CONSTITUENTS EXPERIENCE
I LIVE IN CENTRAL STOCKTON I
HEAR GUNSHOTS EVERY DAY EVERY
NIGHT YOU LEARN TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT'S A GUNSHOT AND WHAT'S
FIREWORKS AND BUT SOMETHING
ELSE NUMBER MY FAMILY WERE
ALSO IMMIGRANTS I'M A I'M A
PROUD MEMBER LATINO CAUCUS I
REMEMBER THE SEVENTIES WHEN
REALLY WAIT PAST MY MOM IS A
IS A VERY CATHOLIC BUT MEXICAN
AMERICAN WAS PRO CHOICE BECAUSE
SHE'S IT IS NOBODY'S BUSINESS
THAT IT'S NOT THE GOVERNMENT'S
BUSINESS RIGHT ALWAYS BEEN A
VERY PROGRESSIVE FAMILY THIS TO
ME IS TOO FAR BECAUSE ALSO SAY
WELL OUR IMMIGRATION SYSTEM IS
BROKEN OUR CITY OUR SHE BROKE
THE SYSTEM IS BROKEN AND I AM
NOT CONVINCED REHABILITATION
HAPPENS AND I WANT SOMEONE
TO HAVE EYES ON PEOPLE BEFORE
THEY COME BACK OUT INTO THE
COMMUNITY MY COMMUNITY I MEAN
WE'RE FORWARD NARROWING IT
DOWN FOR PRISONS FOR PRISONS
DO I HAVE A FOUR YEAR PUBLIC
UNIVERSITY I DO NOT SEE HASN'T
DEEMED MY AREA WORTHY OF HAVING
A FOUR YEAR HIGHER EDUCATION
PUBLIC UNIVERSITY BUT WE DO
HAVE FOR PRISONS CAN I TELL
YOU DVI IS WHERE A LOT OF
THE MOST HEINOUS GANGS THAT
HAVE PROLIFERATED STARTED IN
TRACY CALIFORNIA MY DISTRICT
AND I HAVE ALSO BEEN TO SAN
QUENTIN AND SAT IN THE GROUPS
AND I WROTE A LETTER FOR THE
GENTLEMAN WHO WAS JUST DEPORTED
BECAUSE I FEEL LIKE HE WAS A
SPECIAL CASE ONE OF MY CLOSE
FRIENDS AS A FACILITATOR SHE
SAID YOU CAN LIVE WITH ME I
WROTE A LETTER THE GOVERNOR
I CALL THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE
AND SADLY HE WAS DEPORTED
DEPORTED AT THE END OF THE
DAY MY RESPONSIBILITY IS TO MY
CONSTITUENTS AND THEIR SAFETY
IF PEOPLE DON'T HAVE EYES ON
PEOPLE COMING OUT OF PRISON
TO BE ABLE TO KNOW THAT THEY
ARE NO LONGER AT RISK AND THAT
IS SOMETHING I CAN SUPPORT I
JUST LOOKED UP SO FOR THIS YEAR
SACRAMENTO HAS HAD TWO HUNDRED
NINETY FIVE GUN INVOLVED
CRIMES STOCKTON HAS HAD
THREE HUNDRED AND FIFTY SEVEN
I DON'T KNOW HOW I GO BACK
AND LOOK AT MY CONSTITUENTS
AND SAY I DIDN'T DO EVERYTHING
I COULD TO KEEP YOU SAFE AND
ADVANCE JUSTICE GOOD I DON'T
THINK THERE'S ANYBODY HERE WHO
HASN'T SAID I REALLY PUT MYSELF
ON THE LINE TO ADVANCE JUSTICE
WHENEVER I FEEL THE NEED THAT
I CAN DO THAT FOR GREATER GOOD
BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY I AM
SENATOR FOR SD FIVE AND THAT
IS WHY I CANNOT SUPPORT THIS
BILL TODAY THANK YOU SENATOR
EGGMAN SENATOR COM LONGER
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS I RISE AS A OUR CO
AUTHOR OF THIS BILL -- AND
I AM HAPPY THAT IS UP ON THE
FLOOR TODAY FOR CONSIDERATION
I -- BELIEVE THAT THE HESITANCY
AROUND THIS BILL IS BECAUSE
OF A FEAR OF BROWN PEOPLE --
AND THAT MAY BE JUST MY OWN
BELIEFS BUT THERE ARE FOLKS
THAT CAME HERE ON THE MAYFLOWER
THEY WERE NOT INVITED THEY
WERE NOT CITIZENS WE HAVE
NOT AND MANY OF THEM HAVE
TOUCHES WITH THE LAW WE'VE
NOT FOUND THEIR DESCENDANTS
TO SEND THEM BACK THERE ARE
FOLKS THAT COME FROM CUBA
FLEEING CASTRO IN THAT REGIME
WE DON'T SEND THEM BACK THEIR
FOLKS COMING FROM UKRAINE AND
OTHER PARTS OF EASTERN EUROPE
WE DON'T SEND THEM BACK
IMMEDIATELY WE AND ALL OF
THESE FOLKS AND OUR OWN
PEOPLE WHO ARE BORN HERE ARE
INVOLVED IN CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR
NO BEHAVIOR IS NOT RELEGATED
TO SOMEONE WHO'S AN IMMIGRANT
OR A REFUGEE OR NOT BORN IN
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
THIS BILL DOES NOT PROHIBIT
THE COMPLIANCE WITH A CRIMINAL
JUSTICE WARRANT I DON'T BELIEVE
THIS IS UNRAVELING CHECKS
AND BALANCES THAT WE HAVE IN
OUR SYSTEM I DO BELIEVE THAT
THIS WILL SEPARATE FAMILIES
PEOPLE WHO HAVE LIVED HERE
FOR DECADES WHERE THIS IS THE
ONLY HOME THEY KNOW BECAUSE TO
MY COLLEAGUE FROM STOCKTON WE
DO HAVE A BROKEN IMMIGRATION
SYSTEM AND WE HAVE A TOOL
SWISS CHEESE CRIMINAL LEGAL
SYSTEM AND GENERALLY THE
PEOPLE WHO FALL THROUGH THE
HOLES OF THAT SWISS CHEESE
ARE BLACK THEY ARE BROWN THEY
ARE FILIPINO THEIR KOREAN THEY
ARE POOR THEY ARE INDIGENOUS
IF THINGS WERE MORE FAIR
AND EQUITABLE IF EVERYONE
WAS FALLING TO THE HOLES OF
THE SWISS CHEESE WE PROBABLY
WOULDN'T BE TRYING TO PUSH A
BILL LIKE AB NINE THREE SEVEN
I'VE TALKED TO FOLKS WHO DID
SOMETHING BAD TO PAY THEIR
TIME DID THEIR TIME HAVE
REHABILITATED HAVE BEEN HERE
AND BECAUSE OF THE SYSTEM
WE HAVE IN PLACE HAVE BEEN
CHASED AND THREATENED BY ICE
DOT NET BEFORE STOKE MOVE LEAVE
AND HAVE THEIR KIDS HERE STOCK
ALONE I DON'T THINK THAT'S
FAIR I DON'T THINK THAT'S
FAIR AND I BELIEVE THAT AB
NINE THREE SEVEN IS TRYING
TO RECONCILE THAT UNFAIRNESS
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR
COM LONGER CENTER MELINDA'S
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT LAYS
IN GERMAN RISE IN OPPOSITION
TO THIS MEASURE -- THIS BILL
PROHIBITS ANY STATE OR LOCAL
AGENCY FROM ASSISTING WITH THE
ARREST CONFINEMENT DETENTION
TRANSFER INTERROGATION OR
DEPORTATION OF AN INDIVIDUAL
FOR IMMIGRATION IMMIGRATION
ENFORCEMENT PURPOSES AND IN
ANY MANNER THIS APPLIES TO --
AN AWFUL LOT OF PEOPLE BECAUSE
THE EXEMPTION IN THEIR TALKS
ABOUT -- IF YOU HAVE RECEIVED
A BASE TERM OF TWENTY YEARS
AND THAT IS A VERY VERY SMALL
GROUP OF PEOPLE WHO ACTUALLY
GET A BASED TERM OF TWENTY
YEARS WE'RE NOT THERE ARE NO
ENHANCEMENTS INVOLVED HERE
NO EXTRA TIME SIR BECAUSE
OF COMMITTING A CRIME IN THE
COMMISSION OF A GUN OR ANYTHING
LIKE THAT THIS IS A BASED
TERM OF TWENTY YEARS AND THERE
ARE NOT THAT MANY PEOPLE WHO
RECEIVE THAT TYPE OF SENTENCE
-- IN ADDITION YOU KNOW WE
TALKED SOME OF THE OTHERS
SPEAKERS TALKED ABOUT SB FIFTY
FOUR WHEN IT WAS PASSED AND IT
WAS ORIGINALLY A DIFFERENT TYPE
OF BILL IT WAS NARROWED DOWN
TO MAKE SURE THAT SERIOUS AND
AND VIOLENT FELONIES OUR NOT
INCLUDING THEIR FOR VERY GOOD
REASONS FOR THAT FOR MANY OF
THE CONCERNS THAT WERE SHARED
HERE TODAY BUT THIS BILL I'M
WOULD ALLOW FOR INSTANCE A
CHILD RAPIST TO BE RELEASED
AND PROTECTED AND GO BACK INTO
THE COMMUNITY FROM WHICH HE
CAME PERHAPS INTO THE LATINO
COMMUNITY IN WHICH GOD BLESS
YOU -- IN WHICH HE TERRORIZED
THIS IS NOT OKAY I THINK I'M I
GUESS I DON'T KNOW OF ANY OTHER
CRIMES THAT ARE COMMITTED IN
THE STATE WHERE THE LEGISLATURE
SWOOPS IN TO PROTECT THOSE
WHO COMMIT THEM IN IN THE WAY
THAT THIS BILL PROPOSES YOU
ALL HAVE CONSTITUENTS IN YOUR
COMMUNITIES WHO ARE FEARFUL
AND PERHAPS YOU HAVE BEEN
VICTIMIZED AND THE LAST THING
THEY WANT IS FOR ANY OF US
TO FURTHER THAT AND ALLOW FOR
FURTHER VICTIMIZATION OF THEIR
DAUGHTER AND THEIR SISTER AND
THEIR MOTHER APPS YOU KNOW
SOMEONE IN THEIR FAMILY THEIR
NEIGHBOR THAT'S NOT WHAT YOUR
CONSTITUENTS WANT SO I WOULD
URGE IN ABOUT THANK YOU CENTER
MELINDA'S CENTER CORTESE
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT -- I
RISE IN SUPPORT OF AB NINE
THIRTY SEVEN HERE AND -- I JUST
WANT TO SPEAK VERY BRIEFLY TO
MY EXPERIENCE IN SANTA CLARA
COUNTY WHERE A SOME YEARS AGO
WE STARTED DOWN THIS PATH BY
BECOMING THE SECOND COUNTY
AFTER COOK COUNTY THE SAME
COUNTY IN THE NATION -- TO
REFUSE TO TO PROCESS CIVIL
DETAINERS NOT ON THE BASIS OF
OF PUBLIC SAFETY PER SE ONE WAY
OR THE OTHER BUT ON THE BASIS
AT ICE WAS SENDING HUNDREDS
AND HUNDREDS AND HUNDREDS OF
EIGHT AND A HALF BY ELEVEN
CIVIL DETAINERS A SOMETIMES
MISTAKENLY -- BASED ON COMMON
LAST NAMES -- SOMETIMES
ACCURATELY BASED ON PEOPLE WHO
DID NOT HAVE DOCUMENTS STATUS
IN THIS COUNTRY -- BUT IN THOSE
DAYS PRIOR TO OUR COUNTY --
DECLINING -- TO THE TECHNOLOGY
DOES OUR HONOR THOSE -- WE
WERE DOING THAT N.
AS WE DID IT -- THERE WAS A
PROBLEM OVER NINETY PERCENT OF
THE TIME ICE DID NOT SHOW UP
THEY DIDN'T ARRIVE IN THAT'S
THE FALSE PREMISE ABOUT THE
ARGUMENTS AGAINST HIS BILL
THAT SOMEHOW THERE'S THIS THIS
MAGICAL WORLD OUT THERE WHERE
THE DANGEROUS FELON IN -- BY
THE WAY THERE'S DOCUMENTED
DANGEROUS FELONS BY THE
THOUSANDS BEING RELEASED BY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY PLEA BARGAINS
IN RELEASED FROM JAIL EVERY
DAY SO WHEN PEOPLE SAY THEY
DON'T WANT DANGEROUS FELONS
RELEASED INTO THEIR COMMUNITY
I THINK WHAT THEY'RE REALLY
SAYING HERE AND ELSEWHERE IS
THEY'RE OKAY WITH DANGEROUS
FELONS BEING RELEASED INTO
THE COMMUNITY BECAUSE WE ALLOW
OUR DJS TO PLAY THEM OUT WE
DON'T WANT UNDOCUMENTED FELONS
RELEASED INTO THE COMMUNITY
IT'S A STATUS QUESTION BUT
BACK TO WHAT I WAS SAYING --
WE BEGAN REALIZING IN HEARING
ABOUT ENDING KNOWN GENE
LAWSUITS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE
COUNTRY FOR COUNTIES THAT THAT
WERE COOPERATING WITH ICE --
THAT WE'RE WE'RE BEING SUED
EFFECTIVELY -- WITH A BECAUSE
OF OF ERRORS OMISSIONS IN THE
PROGRAM AND SO FORTH SO WE
STOP WE CAME BACK A FEW YEARS
LATER THAT WAS DURING THE OBAMA
ADMINISTRATION CAME BACK A FEW
YEARS LATER DURING THE TRUMP
ADMINISTRATION -- AND REVIEWED
THE PROCESS AND MODIFIED THE
LOCAL PROCESS THE OTHER THING
THAT'S NOT BEING DISCUSSES
THE FACT THAT ICE HAS THE FBI
DATABASE THEY HAVE EVERY LAW
ENFORCEMENT DATABASE AVAILABLE
TO THEM IN THE COUNTRY
INCLUDING EACH AND EVERYONE
OF OUR SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENTS
AND POLICE DEPARTMENTS THEY
HAVE THOSE DATABASES THEY KNOW
EXACTLY WHEN SOMEBODY'S GOING
TO BE RELEASED IF THEY WANT
TO SHOW UP THERE'S ABSOLUTELY
NOTHING STOPPING THEM FROM
SHOWING UP RIGHT OUTSIDE THE G.
OVER THE PRISON STORE DOORS
AND TAKING CUSTODY IF THEY
WANT TO BUT AGAIN THE PROBLEM
IS AND THEY WILL TELL YOU
THAT IF YOU ASK THEM STRAIGHT
UP THEY DO NOT HAVE THE
CAPACITY OR THE ABILITY TO TO
INTERVIEW THOSE THAT THEY'RE
INTERESTED IN INTERVIEWING OR
TO RESPOND OR SHOW UP -- SO
THE IDEA THAT A VOTE AGAINST
THIS BILL IS SOMEHOW GOING TO
CREATE A SAFER COMMUNITY OR
ONE TO ONE COOPERATION WITH
ICE THAT SUDDENLY CREATES
A COLLABORATIVE ENVIRONMENT
WHERE THEY'RE SHOWING UP A
HUNDRED PERCENT OF THE TIME
MAKING OUR COMMUNITY SAFER IS
IS IS BEYOND A FALSE PREMISE
IT'S NOT WHAT'S HAPPENING OUT
THERE IN AND I JUST WANT TO
GET THAT ON THE RECORD -- THE
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL --
I'VE WORKED WITH ALL OF THEM
WE WORKS ALL THEM TO CRAFT
A POLICY IN MY OWN COUNTY
BUT THAT I THINK IS WORKING
TODAY I'M IN IS VERY VERY MUCH
ALIGNED CONSISTENT WITH AB NINE
THIRTY SEVEN SO I WOULD URGE
AN AYE VOTE ON THE BILL THANK
YOU CENTER CORTESE MEMBERS
SEEING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE CENTER WE ARE YOU
MAY CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SO I JUST WANT TO
HAVE BEEN A LOT OF STATEMENTS
OF FACT MADE HERE TODAY AYE AYE
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO TALK
ABOUT FACTS YOUR STATEMENTS
MADE ABOUT WHY PEOPLE COME
HERE THAT PEOPLE COME THIS
COUNTRY TO COMMIT CRIMES WE
KNOW THAT OVERWHELMINGLY THAT
IS NOT WHY PEOPLE ARE COMING
TO THIS COUNTRY BEFORE COMING
TO THIS COUNTRY FOR THE SAME
EXACT REASONS THAT MY GREAT
GRANDPARENTS CAME HERE OVER
A HUNDRED YEARS AGO FROM
EASTERN EUROPE FOR ECONOMIC
OPPORTUNITY TO DO RIGHT BY
THEIR FAMILIES AND TO ESCAPE
VIOLENCE THAT'S WHY PEOPLE
ARE COMING TO THIS COUNTRY AND
THIS WHOLE NOTION THAT PEOPLE
JUST COMING HERE BECAUSE IT'S
A GOOD PLACE TO COMMIT CRIMES
THAT'S A SLANDER ITS ABSURD
THIS BILL IS ALSO NOT ONLY
ABOUT UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS
SO MANY OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
GETTING CAUGHT UP IN THE PORTED
THERE QUITE DOCUMENTED THESE
ARE OFTEN LAWFUL PERMANENT
RESIDENTS WHO CAME HERE AS
CHILDREN MAYBE AT THE AGE OF
TWO OR THREE OR FOUR YEARS OLD
AND THEY HAVE ONLY KNOWN LIFE
IN THIS COUNTRY ANOTHER GETTING
SENT BACK TO A COUNTRY WHERE
THEY MAY NOT EVEN SPEAK THE
LANGUAGE OR OF ANY CONNECTIONS
WHATSOEVER THESE ARE AMERICANS
THAT'S WHO'S BEING SENT BACK
ANOTHER INSINUATION THROUGH SO
MANY OF THESE DEBATES IS THAT
IMMIGRANTS ARE MORE LIKELY
TO COMMIT CRIMES WE KNOW THE
OPPOSITE IS TRUE IMMIGRANTS ARE
LESS LIKELY TO COMMIT CRIMES
THAN PEOPLE WHO WERE BORN HERE
I SAW THIS WHOLE STEREO TYPE
THAT THE IMMIGRATION DEBATE IS
ABOUT CRIME IT'S ABOUT SAFETY
THAT IS THAT IS JUST WITH ALL
RESPECT NOT TRUE AND THE PEOPLE
THAT ARE BEING DEBATED HEARING
ALL THE CONVERSATIONS THAT
WE'VE BEEN HAVING FOR A YEAR
ABOUT SHOULD THERE BE SERIOUS
CRIMES THAT ARE EXEMPTED FROM
THIS BILL THE PEOPLE COMMITTED
SERIOUS CRIMES ARE THE ONES
WHO ARE DOING FIFTEEN TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE THIRTY YEARS IN
PRISON FOR THEY ARE PAROLED
BECAUSE THEY'RE DETERMINED
TO HAVE BEEN RE REHABILITATED
THESE ARE THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
NOT ONLY OLDER NOW BUT THEY
ARE THE MOST LIKELY TO BE
REHABILITATED BECAUSE THEY
SPEND SO MUCH TIME IN THE
SYSTEM AND SO THE NOTION THAT
YOU RELEASE SOMEONE IS TO SPEND
TWENTY FIVE YEARS AT SOME POINT
IN AND THEY'RE BEING RELEASED
AND THEY'RE NOT GOING TO GO ON
SOME CRIMES I JUST DON'T BUY
THAT IS A REHABILITATION SYSTEM
PERFECT NO BUT IT IS REAL AND
PEOPLE DO GET REHABILITATED
AND THEY CAN BE PAROLED UNLESS
THEY'VE BEEN REHABILITATED
YOU KNOW IN THE END THIS IS
ALSO WHAT CDC ARE PARTICULAR
IS DOING IS INCREDIBLY ARROGANT
AND I SAY THIS BECAUSE THERE
ARE ONLY TWO GROUPS OF PEOPLE
WHO GET TO DECIDE WHAT THE
SENTENCE IS OUR FOR COMMITTING
CRIMES IT'S US THE HUNDRED
AND TWENTY MEMBERS OF THE
LEGISLATURE PLUS THE GOVERNOR
AND IT'S THE VOTERS AND WE
PASS LAWS AND THE VOTERS PASSED
BALLOT MEASURES TO SET WHAT
THE SENTENCES ARE AND ONCE
YOU HAVE DONE YOUR TIME EITHER
COMPLETED THE SENTENCE OR UNDER
THE LAWS THAT WE HAVE PASSED
YOU HAVE BEEN DETERMINED TO BE
REHABILITATED AND THE APPOINTED
PAROLE COMMISSIONERS HAVE
PAROLED YOU IN THE GOVERNOR
HASN'T OBJECTED YOU HAVE
SATISFIED YOUR SENTENCE AND
YOUR DAD UNDER THE LAW OF THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AS DECIDED
BY THE ACTUAL POLICYMAKERS
THE LEGISLATORS AND THE VOTERS
AND YET CDC ARE IN ITS EXTREME
ARROGANCE HAS DECIDED THAT THEY
DON'T CARE WHAT SENTENCE THE
LEGISLATURE THE VOTERS HAVE
SAT THEY DON'T CARE WHETHER WE
HAVE REHABILITATION POLICIES TO
SAY ONCE YOU'RE REHABILITATED
WE'RE GOING TO INTEGRATE YOU
BACK INTO YOUR COMMUNITY CDCR
IS FLIPPING US THE BIRD WITH
ALL DUE RESPECT BY SAYING WE
DON'T CARE WHAT SENTENCES YOU
THE POLICY MAKERS OF THAT WE'RE
GONNA ADD ON PUNISHMENT JUST
FOR THE HECK OF IT AND GET YOU
THESE PEOPLE DEPORTED AFTER
THEY'VE DONE THEIR SANTA TELL
REGIS WITH ALL RESPECT AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR UNIDO
THANK YOU CENTER WIENER WELCOME
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN ARCHULETA ATKINS AYE
BATES NOPE BAKER I PORCHES NO
BRADFORD ITEM BY ITEM CORTESE
I DALY NO DODD NOPE TO RUSSELL
I EGGMAN GLAZER NOPE GONZALEZ
I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG WESSEL I
HER TADO NOPE JONES NO KAMLAGER
AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN
I REQUIRED HI MELENDEZ NOPE
MANY NEWMAN NIELSEN NO -- CHOI
BOGUE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO
ROTH RUBIO SKINNER I STERN I
AM BURKE BY CAL SKI AYE WIENER
AYE WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN ARCHULETA
CABRERA HERTZBERG MANY NEWMAN
PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO NUMBER
ONE MORE TIME PLEASE
ALLEN ARCHULETA CABALLERO
HERTZBERG MANY NEWMAN
PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO
UMBERG SENATOR MOVES A CALL
EGGMAN NO CENTER MOVES
A CALL OKAY WE HAD SOME
MEMBERS OFF THE FLOOR WE'RE
GOING TO CALL THE ROLL ONE
MORE TIME ALLEN I ARCHULETA
CABALLERO HERTZBERG MANY
NEWMAN PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO
AMBERG SENATOR MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WERE MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY NINE SENATOR ALAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL EIGHTEEN
NINETY SEVEN BY SOME REMEMBER
BOERNER HORVATH AN ACT RELATING
TO SOLID WASTE SENATOR ALAN
MEMBERS THIS IS A VERY SMALL
BILL THAT COMES OUT OF OUR
GREAT SUCCESS ON SB FIFTY FOUR
EARLIER THIS YEAR RELATING
TO PLASTICS -- IT'S SOME
LANGUAGE THAT RELATES TO --
SOME DEFINITIONS OF RECYCLING
AND AND MARKETS THAT WERE
PART OF OUR NEGOTIATED I DEAL
WITH THE BILL I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR NAY VOTE AND I HOPE
WE CAN IMMEDIATELY TRANSMIT
OVER THE FAMILY AFTERWARDS
THANK YOU CENTER ALLEN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
AYE PACKER AYE PORCHES AYE
BRADFORD I HAVE ITEM CORTESE
AYE TALLY AYE DODD I TO
RUSSELL I EGGMAN HI PLEASE
SIR GONZALEZ HI GROWTH I
HERTZBERG WESA I HER TADO JONES
KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED AYE
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE
I MELENDEZ BEEN I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN A TROUBLED I PAN AYE
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH RUBIO AYE
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE WIECKOWSKI I WIENER AYE
WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS CABALLERO I GLAZER I
HERTZBERG HER DAUGHTER I JONES
HI MELENDEZ I NIELSEN I ROTH
I I THIRTY NINE NO ZERO MMHM
PLEASE CALL CALL THE ROLL ONE
MORE TIME HERTZBERG HI HIGHS
FORTY NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING
TO FILE ITEM THIRTY TWO CAN
ASK FOR ME A TRANSITIONAL TO
CHANGE MISSILE TO THE SENATOR
SENATOR -- ALLEN FOR A PURPOSE
TO RISE HI I'D LIKE TO REQUEST
A MUNITIONS MISSILE TO THE --
WE'LL GET WE'LL GET IT DONE
AS SOON AS WE CAN I REALLY
APPRECIATE IT THANK YOU SIR
FILE ITEM THIRTY TWO SENATOR
ARCH ALETTA MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY BILL
SEVEN THIRTY EIGHT ASSEMBLY
MEMBER WHEN AN ACT RELATING
TO MENTAL HEALTH CENTER OUR
CHILLA FILE ITEM THIRTY TWO
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
I RISE TODAY TO PRESENT
ASSEMBLY BILLS SEVEN THIRTY
EIGHT AM BASED ON BEHALF OF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER NGUYEN A.
B.
SEVEN THIRTY EIGHT WOULD
REQUIRE MOUNTIES WITH A
POPULATION GREATER THAN A
HUNDRED THOUSAND TO APPOINT
A VETERAN OR A VETERAN'S
ADVOCATE TO SERVE ON A LOCAL
PUBLIC MENTAL HEALTH BOARD
THIS MEASURE HAS RECEIVED
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AND HAS NO
NO VOTES I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR IDOL THANK YOU CENTER
ARCHULETA MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MEMBERS THIS IS ELIGIBLE
FOR A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE HIGHS FORTY
EIGHT NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM THIRTY FOUR SENATOR
PAN NOT AT HIS DESK BUT
MAYBE WE CAN GET HIM HERE
RIGHT ALL RIGHT WE WILL MOVE
ON TO FILE ITEM THIRTY SEVEN
SENATOR NEWMAN MANY SECRETARY
PLEASE READ WILL COME BACK
TO SENATOR PAN STATUS PEOPLE
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY FOUR
NINETY THREE BY SOME REMEMBER
CHEN AND AFTER RELATING TO
COUNTY EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT
CENTER NEWMAN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I RISE ON BEHALF OF
ASSEMBLY MENTIONED RESENT AB
TWENTY FOUR NINETY THREE WHICH
WILL ENSURE THAT THE FINANCIAL
SECURITY OF RETIRED SWORN PEACE
OFFICERS AND FIREFIGHTERS IS
NOT UNDERMINED AS A RESULT OF
PENSION REPORTING ERRORS FOR
WHICH RETIRED FIRST RESPONDERS
ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE IN RECENT
YEARS SOME FIREFIGHTER RETIREES
HAVE HAD THEIR FINANCES
SECURITY JEOPARDIZED ON THE
BASIS OF A COUNTY OR COUNTY
EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT SYSTEM
MISINTERPRETING THE GUIDELINES
WHICH GOVERN GOVERNED WHETHER
ASPECTS OF THEIR PAY MAY BE
CONSIDERED ARTICLE COMPENSATION
TOWARD THE RETIREMENT
CONTRIBUTION IN THESE INSTANCES
SUCH A DETERMINATION CAN
RESULT IN NOT JUST REDUCTION
IN THEIR PENSION BUT IN THE
SUDDEN CLAWBACK OF PREVIOUSLY
RECEIVED PENSION DISTRIBUTIONS
CREATING IMMENSE CONFUSION AND
ARRESTS FOR THE YOUR AFFECTED
RETIREE BY ENSURING THAT WE'RE
REPORTING ERROR OCCURS THROUGH
NO FAULT OF THE EMPLOYEE THE
OWNERS WILL FOLK WILL FOLLOW
PROPERLY ON THE EMPLOYER TO
ENSURE THAT ANY COMPENSATION
AGREED TO BY THAT EMPLOYER AND
PAID IN BY BOTH THE RETIREE
AND THE EMPLOYER SHALL NOT
BE RETROACTIVELY DEDUCTED
FROM RETIRED RETIRED MEMBERS
PENSION ALLOWANCE THIS IS A
FAIR AND MEASURED MEASURE --
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE TODAY THANK YOU SENATOR
NEWMAN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING THAT
MEMBERS IT'S ALSO QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING THEN EYES FORTY
NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM FORTY
FIVE SENATOR GROWTH MA'AM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY
BILL NINETEEN NINETY EIGHT
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER SMITH AN
ACT RELATING TO COMMUNITY
COLLEGES CENTER GROVE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT -- SMALL
BORDER COLLEGES LIKE THE ONE
IN NEEDLES -- NEEDLE CENTER
ALONG THE CALIFORNIA ARIZONA
STATE LINE IN MY DISTRICT SEVER
FOR IT SUFFER FROM COMPETITIVE
DISADVANTAGE COMPARED TO
NEIGHBORING STATE SCHOOLS AB
NINETEEN NINETY EIGHT WILL
HELP RECTIFY THIS BY ALLOWING
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICTS
WITHIN TEN MILES OF ANOTHER
STATE TO EXIT STUDENTS FROM
PAY NONRESIDENT TUITION FEES
AB NINETEEN NINETY EIGHT WOULD
RESTORE THE COMPETITIVE BALANCE
TO THOSE DISTRICTS THAT LIE
CLOSE TO BORDERING STATES TO
SERVE COMMUNITIES ON BOTH SIDES
OF THE BORDERS AND WILL HELP
OUR COMMUNITY COLLEGES NEXT TO
OUR BORDERS AND THERE'S BEEN
NO OPPOSITION NO NO VOTES NO
VOTES EXCUSE ME ON AB NINETEEN
NINETY EIGHT AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER GROVE MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS IS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS
FORTY NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES WOULD MOVE BACK TO
FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR SENATOR
PAN MEN SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL SIXTEEN
OH EIGHT BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
GIPSON AN ACT RELATING TO
LOCAL GOVERNMENT CENTER PAN --
NO PASSAGE OF THE TAX PASS
ON FILE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
FORTY SIX SENATOR GONZALEZ
PASS ON FILE HAVING TO
FILE ITEM FORTY EIGHT
SENATOR BRADFORD MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY ONE
FORTY THREE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
CARILLO AN ACT RELATING TO
ENERGY CENTER BRADFORD THANK
MADAM PRESIDENT I'M PRESENTING
ON BEHALF OF THIS ASSEMBLY
MEMBER CARILLO AB TWENTY
ONE FORTY THREE WHICH WILL
REQUIRE PREVAILING WAGES FOR
COMMERCIAL SOLAR AND LARGE
SOLAR SCALE WHAT ARE PROJECTS
OVER FIFTEEN COLOR WATCH THAT
POPPED INTO THE NET ENERGY
MEETING MEETING WITH METERING
PROGRAM AS THE LEGISLATURE
DOES THE WORK NECESSARY TO
REDUCE CALIFORNIA'S RELIANCE
ON FOSSIL FUELS AND TRANSITION
TO RENEWABLE ENERGY IS NOT
ONLY IMPORTANT BUT NECESSARY
THAT ALSO MEANS THAT THE WORK
FORCE OUR TRANSITION TO CREATE
A GREEN WORKFORCE HAS TO BE
PART OF THAT SOLUTION THIS
LEGISLATURE SHOULD BE IN THE
BUSINESS OF CREATING MEANINGFUL
LIVING WAGE JOBS AND ENSURING
THE WORKERS DON'T LOSE OUT
IN THE CLEAN ENERGY ECONOMY
THIS BILL ENSURES EQUITY
TRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY ARE
AT THE HEART OF A SUSTAINABLE
CLEAN GREEN ECONOMY AND WHICH
TO CLIMATE CHANGE ENVIRONMENTAL
GOALS AND WORKER PROTECTION GO
HAND IN HAND TO BE CLEAR THIS
DOES NOT CHANGE THE CURRENT
NEOM STRUCTURE AND DOES NOT
TARGET RESIDENTIAL ROOFTOP
SOLAR FOLLOWING OUR RECENT
AMENDMENTS SINGLE FAMILY HOME
SMALLER MULTI FAMILY BUILDINGS
AND MA A MOBILE PARKS ON PARKS
ARE EXCLUDED FROM THIS BILL
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL
THANK YOU CENTER BRADFORD
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MAN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA ATKINS
BATES NOPE BACKER I PORCHES NO
BRADFORD AYE BY OTHER CORTESE
I DALY NO DODD AYE DURAZO AYE
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ I
GROWTH NO HERTZBERG I WESTERN
AYE HURTADO AYE JONES NO
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE FLAVOR
AYE FOR THE MOST I REQUIRE
I MELENDEZ NOPE MEN I NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN HI A SHOW OF BOTH
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH
RUBIO SKINNER I STERN NUMBER
HI MY CASTING FIVE WINNER
WELL NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS NIELSEN I DON'T KNOW
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA I ATKINS
CABRERA I GLAZER ROTH HI RUBIO
I STERN WIENER IS TWENTY SEVEN
KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY
NINE SENATOR RIGHT CAL SKI
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL TWELVE SIXTY TWO
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER CUNNINGHAM
AN ACT RELATING TO INFORMATION
PRIVACY CENTER KELSEY MAN
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS OF THE
SCHOOL OF AB TWELVE SIXTY
TWO SIMPLE IT PUTS CONSUMERS
IN CHARGE OF DECIDING WHAT
HAPPENS WITH THEIR DATA NOW
SMART SPEAKERS ARE UNIQUE IN
THAT THERE INTO IN INTO PARTS
OF OUR LIVES THERE IN OUR
BEDROOMS OUR CHILDREN'S PLAY
SPACES OUR FAMILY ROOMS YOU
GET YOU UNDERSTAND IT MAKES
SENSE THAT CONSUMERS SHOULD
BE AFFIRMATIVELY OPTING IN TO
HAVING THEIR DATA COLLECTED
AND SAVED AND SOLD NOT OPTING
OUT THAT SHOULD NOT BE THE
NORM THE AUTHOR IS WORK WITH
THE OPPOSITION TO ENSURE THE
PRIVACY PROTECTIONS DO NOT
INHIBIT THE FUNCTIONALITY OF
THESE DEVICES AND THE LARGEST
MANUFACTURER THE SPORTS MAKERS
IS NOW NEUTRAL THESE DEVICES
ARE NEARLY EVERY HOME NOW WE
USE THEM FOR VARIOUS PURPOSES
TO MAKE OUR DAY TO DAY LIVES
EASIER IF SOMEONE WANTS TO
OPT IN AND USE THE DEVICE AS
HIS NOTHING WOULD CHANGE JUST
BECAUSE YOU WANT TO HAVE A
CONNECTED HOME OR OR OWN ONE
OF THESE DEVICES YOU SHOULD
NOT HAVE TO HAVE YOUR DATA
MIND AND CONVERSATIONS RECORDED
WITHOUT YOUR INFORMED CONSENT
ALEXA DO NOT MIND MY DAD IF
YOU HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY HAVE
AN OPPORTUNITY TO PUT CONSUMERS
IN CONTROL OF THEIR DATA AND
CREATE A BASELINE OF CONSUMER
PRIVACY PROTECTION WITHOUT
CONSUMERS LOSING ACCESS TO
MODERN TECHNOLOGY I URGE AN
IPHONE THANK YOU SENATOR BY
CAL SKI MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS IS ELIGIBLE FOR
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING THAT THERE IS OBJECTION
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS BATES BACKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD I HAVE A OTHER
CORTESE I DALY I DONT I
TO RUSSELL I EGGMAN AYE
BLAZER GONZALEZ I GROWTH
FIVE HERTZBERG I
REQUEST SOME HI HURTADO
I JONES KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN I REQUIRE
I MELENDEZ MANY I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN THE TROUBLE PAN AYE
PORTANTINO HI ROTH AYE RUBIO
I SKINNER I STERN NUMBER FIVE
CASSIE I WINNER I WILK HI
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ATKINS BATES I FORTUS CUPBEARER
I GLAZER AYE JONES MELENDEZ
I NIELSEN I TROUBLED STERN I
THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES WILL BE ON THE FILE ITEM
FIFTY SENATOR PORTANTINO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY
BILL TWENTY THREE SEVENTEEN BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ALMOST AN ACT
RELATING TO CARE FACILITIES
CENTER PORTANTINO THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
AB TWENTY THREE SEVENTEEN
ONE ESTABLISH A LICENSING
PATH AND ENSURE MUCH NEEDED
FEDERAL FUNDING FOR CHILDREN'S
CRISIS RESIDENTIAL PROGRAMS
IT'S DESPERATELY NEEDED AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS AS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE HIGHS FORTY NO
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES MOVING
ON THE FILE ITEM FIFTY ONE
SENATOR ALAN MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY CONCURRENT
RESOLUTION ONE SEVENTY SEVEN
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER BLOOM
RELATIVE TO THE CHRISTOPHER
COLUMBUS TRANSCONTINENTAL
HIGHWAY SENATOR ALAN
MEMBERS -- THIS IS A RESOLUTION
REQUESTING THAT D.
O.
T.
REMOVE THE CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS
TRANSCONTINENTAL HIGHWAY
DESIGNATION FROM THE RELEVANT
PORTION OF INTERSTATE TEN
IT'S BEEN BROUGHT TO US BY
THE LOCAL ENTITY -- THE SIGNS
ALREADY BEEN TAKEN DOWN BY A
VANDAL AND THEY HAD NO PLANS
OF PUTTING IT UP ANYWAY SO WITH
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
ALLEN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS BATES BAKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD HI COME BY
OTHER CORTEZ HI KELLY DOT HI
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE PLEASER HI
GONZALEZ I'D GROWTH HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HER DAUGHTER
I JONES KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN I REQUIRE
I'D MELENDEZ NO MAN HI NEWMAN
I NIELSEN NO -- TROUBLE PAN
PAN I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH I
RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN HI
AMBERG FIVE AYE CASKEY AYE
WIENER I WILK PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS BATES
OR JUST COME BY OTHER HI
DALY GROVE JONES A TROUBLED
WELL OR JUST NOW HIGHS THIRTY
KNOWS THREE THE MEASURE PASSES
SENATOR PAN ARE YOU READY
ON FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR
YES ACTUALLY THE TIME TO PASS
AND PASS PASSING ON THAT THAT
WAS THE ONE ABOUT YESTERDAY'S
MEETING OKAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH US SENATOR GONZALEZ
WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE UP
FILE ITEM FORTY SIX VERY GOOD
MEMBERS WE ARE JUST RECONCILING
BILLS PLEASE STAY ON THE FLOOR
MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR YOUR
PATIENCE WE ARE GOING TO
MOVE TO CONCURRENCE WE'RE
GOING TO START WITH FILE ITEM
TWENTY ONE SENATOR GONZALEZ
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL ELEVEN THIRTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR GONZALEZ AN
ACT RELATING TO OIL AND GAS
CYLINDER GONZALEZ THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS
I RISE TODAY TO PRESENT SB
ELEVEN THIRTY SEVEN WHICH WILL
PROTECT THE PUBLIC HEALTH OF
OUR FRONT LINE COMMUNITIES BY
MANDATING A THREE THOUSAND TWO
HUNDRED FOOT HEALTH AND SAFETY
BUFFER ZONE BETWEEN NEW AND
REWORKED OIL AND GAS WELLS AND
SENSITIVE LAND USES SENSITIVE
LAND USES ARE HOSPITALS
DAYCARES SCHOOLS UNIVERSITIES
NURSING HOME FACILITIES THAT'S
WHAT WE'RE ASKING HERE WE
KNOW NOW THAT TWO MILLION
CALIFORNIANS CURRENTLY LIVE
WITHIN THREE THOUSAND TWO
HUNDRED FEET OF AN EXISTING
OIL WELL AND OVER THREE HUNDRED
THOUSAND PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA
ARE LIVING PROXIMITY BETWEEN
SIX HUNDRED FEET AND SEVEN
HUNDRED FEET THIS IS A PUBLIC
HEALTH CRISIS MY FRIENDS
WE'VE BEEN HERE BEFORE IT'S A
LONGSTANDING GLARING EXAMPLE OF
ENVIRONMENTAL RACISM RESEARCH
SHOWS THAT OF COURSE THAT
PEOPLE OF COLOR BLACK BROWN
INDIGENOUS PEOPLE SUFFER THE
GREATEST CONSEQUENCES OF THIS
TOXIC PROXIMITY AS THESE ARE
THE SAME COMMUNITIES THAT
HAVE OIL PRODUCTION IN THEIR
BACKYARDS AT A TIME WHEN OIL
COMPANIES ARE MAKING RECORD
PROFITS ON THE BACKS OF SO MANY
WORKERS FEELING EXTREME FIRES
MASSIVE FLOODS AND DEBILITATING
HEAT AND DROUGHT OUR STATE MUST
TAKE ACTION NOW AND WE KNOW
THAT THE CALIFORNIA COUNCIL ON
SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY REVIEWED
EXISTING SCIENTIFIC STUDIES
AND DETERMINED THAT FROM A
PUBLIC HEALTH PERSPECTIVE THE
MOST SIGNIFICANT EXPOSURES TO
TOXIC AIR CONTAMINANTS OCCUR
WITHIN ONE HALF MILE OF A
WELL AND RECOMMENDED THAT THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA DEVELOP A
SCIENCE BACKED NOT POLITICALLY
MOTIVATED BACK SETBACK
REQUIREMENTS FOR WELLS TO LIMIT
EXPOSURES WHAT CHALCOGENS OWN
PUBLIC HEALTH RESEARCHERS HAVE
DETERMINED THAT THERE IS NO
SAFE DISTANCE FROM OIL AND GAS
WELLS FOR HUMANS THREE THOUSAND
TWO HUNDRED FEET WILL AVOID
SOME OF THE WORST EXPOSURE AND
HARM TO OUR CALIFORNIANS SO
IT'S TIME THAT WE DO THAT NOW
NOW THERE ARE A LOT OF FOLKS
HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT OIL
PRODUCTION AND THAT SOMEHOW
THIS UP THIS SB ELEVEN THIRTY
SEVEN WILL SOMEHOW ALLOW MORE
FOR FOREIGN OIL TO COME IN
AND THAT'S JUST NOT TRUE IT'S
AN UNINFORMED UNRELATED --
ARGUMENT WE'RE NOT GOING TO
DO THAT THIS IS ONE TENTH IS
TO IS THE TRAJECTORY OF THE
IMPACT THAT WOULD IT WOULD HAVE
ON CALIFORNIA DOMESTIC OIL AND
WE TALK TO OUR FRIENDS IN THE
TRADE AS WELL THEY'RE ABOUT
TEN THOUSAND JOBS STATEWIDE
THAT WOULD BE IMPACTED HERE BUT
WE ALSO KNOW TOO THAT WE NEED
TO GET SOMETHING DONE THIS IS
BEEN TWO YEARS IN THE MAKING
AND REGULATORY PROCESS FROM
CAL JAM THERE BEEN NEWMAN AT
NUMEROUS COMMUNITY MEETINGS
AND PEOPLE THAT HAVE REALLY
PLEADED WITH SO MANY OF US TO
ENSURE THAT WE GET THIS DONE
AND SO THAT I'M ASKING YOU
TO VOTE I AM AB I'M SORRY SB
ELEVEN THIRTY SEVEN IN ADDITION
THIS PASSED THE ASSEMBLY FOR
WITH FORTY SIX VOTES FORTY
SIX VOTES IT'S SOMETHING THAT
WE CAN DO AND I KNOW WE CAN
DO IN TERMS OF THE LARGER
CLIMATE DISCUSSIONS BUT IT'S
SOMETHING THAT WE MUST DO FOR
OUR COMMUNITY MEMBERS WHEREVER
YOU LIVE WHEREVER YOU REPRESENT
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SO
THAT I AYE OSCAR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER GONZALEZ MEMBERS
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE CENTER
GROVE A SEER HAND WAVERING
CENTER GROVE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I OF COURSE RISE IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL AND
-- I'D LIKE TO JUST SHARE MY
REASONS WHY AND THEN I HAVE A
FEW QUESTIONS OF THE AUTHOR AND
THIS SETBACK LANGUAGE THAT'S
PROVIDED HAS A BEGINNING POINT
BUT NO INDIAN POINT IS VERY
VAGUE -- IT DOESN'T TELL YOU
WHERE YOU GET A MEASURE FROM IT
TELLS YOU WE'RE GONNA MEASURE
THAT DOES TAKE YOU WHERE YOU
GET TO POINT A TO POINT B.
SO IT'S VERY VAGUE LANGUAGE
WHICH IS PROBLEMATIC THE
PROPOSAL FOR MY DISTRICT
WOULD IMPACT FIVE THOUSAND
THREE HUNDRED THIRTY FOUR
ACTIVE PRODUCTION WELLS TWENTY
THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED AND FIFTY
INJECTION WELLS -- THAT PRODUCE
ABOUT TWENTY EIGHT THOUSAND
THREE HUNDRED AND TWENTY FIVE
HUNDRED NINETY FOUR BARRELS
OF OIL ACTUALLY THAT WAS THE
NUMBER THAT WAS PRODUCED IN
TWO THOUSAND AND NINETEEN --
WHEN SHE'S WHEN THE COMMENT WAS
MADE FROM THE AUTHOR ABOUT --
SCIENTIFIC DATA THE SCIENTIFIC
DATA THAT'S USED -- BY THE
NATIONAL AMBIENT AIR QUALITY
STANDARDS WHICH IS A VERY
WELL KNOWN ORGANIZATION THAT
MEASURES AIR QUALITY ISSUES IT
ESTIMATES BETWEEN SEVEN HUNDRED
FIFTEEN TO TWELVE HUNDRED
EIGHTY FEET EIGHTY EIGHT FEET
FROM THE WELL PAD ITSELF COULD
HAVE SOME TYPE OF EXPOSURE IT
DOES NOT SAY THIRTY TWO HUNDRED
FEET OR A LITTLE OVER ONE HALF
MILE THIS IS JUST A LITTLE
OVER ONE HALF MILE WHEN MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE SAYS THAT AND THIS
IS NOT IMPACT OIL PRODUCTION IT
DOES IMPACT OIL PRODUCTION IT
NOT ONLY IMPACTS OIL PRODUCTION
BUT IT IMPACTS SMALL INDIVIDUAL
OPERATOR OIL PRODUCTION IS A
LOT OF THOSE COMMUNITIES THE
SMALL OPERATORS HAVE JUST THE
TWO ACRES OF LAND THAT THEY
OPERATE THEIR OIL LEASE ON OR A
LEASE ON A PIECE OF PROPERTY AT
A RESTAURANT LIKE SIGNAL HILL
IN THE PARKING LOT OF -- THE
FOODS CO OR THE FOOD GROCERY
STORE THAT'S DOWN THERE -- IN
THAT IN THAT AREA I -- IT TAX
THIS BILL SPECIFICALLY IMPACTS
-- THE LIEN HOLDERS OR THE THE
LEASE HOLDERS THEMSELVES THAT
ARE RETIREES THAT LEASE THEIR
PROPERTY TO MINERAL RIGHTS
PRODUCERS ARE MEANT THE DAILY
AND THEY GET PAID THE MINERAL
RIGHTS FOR ROYALTIES AND EASES
THEIR RETIREMENT YOU DID THEY
USE FOR THEIR RETIREMENT IT HAS
IT IMPACTS THAT IT ALSO -- HAS
AN EFFECT ON LIKE I SAID THE
SMALL PRODUCERS THAT YOU GUYS
NEVER HEAR ABOUT THIS SETBACK
DOES NOT CHANGE CALIFORNIA'S
DEMAND ON -- OIL CONSUMPTION
IT DOESN'T CHANGE THE FACT
THAT CALIFORNIANS ARE STILL
USING -- OIL EVERY SINGLE
DAY TO MAKE THEIR LIVES MORE
CONVENIENT AND BETTER -- IT
DOESN'T CHANGE THE FACT THAT
THE RELIANCE ON FOREIGN FOREIGN
AND FOSSIL FUELS IMPORTS WILL
GO AT THE AUTHOR SAYS THAT
IT WON'T TO DISPLACE THESE
BARRELS WILL THEY'LL HAVE TO
COME FROM SOMEPLACE THEY'LL
HAVE TO COME FROM EITHER RUSSIA
WHERE WE PAY RUSSIA FOR FOREIGN
OIL AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU
A PRETTY MATCH THAT RUSSIA
USES THAT RESOURCES THAT WE
GIVE THEM TO FUND THE WAR IN
UKRAINE AGAINST M.
AGAINST UKRAINIAN PEOPLE THERE
ARE I BELIEVE THEM ELEVEN
STATES THAT WE CANNOT TRAVEL
TO AS A BODY IS EXEMPT FROM
TRAVEL AS A BODY WE CAN'T
TRAVEL TO MONTANA THE GOVERNOR
RECENTLY TRAVELED TO MONTANA
AND I WOULD LIKE TO ASK HIM IF
HE FLEW THERE WHICH I'M PRETTY
SURE YOU DID IF YOU DIDN'T FLY
THERE WHAT CHARGING STATIONS
DID HE USE ON THE WAY TO
MONTANA THE REASON I ASK THAT
QUESTION IS BECAUSE WE TALK A
LOT ABOUT THE UTOPIA SOCIETY
OF A DECARBONISATION ON THE
ECONOMY BUT WE DON'T EVER PUT
OUR MONEY WHERE OUR MOUTH IS
AND I SEE THAT TO MY COLLEAGUES
NOT TO BE CALLOUS OR AMGE YOU
KNOW JUDGEMENTAL IT'S JUST WE
DON'T I WAS TALKING TO MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE AND FROM SALINAS
AND SHE SAID THAT AT ONE OF
THE EVENT'S SOMEBODY HAD ASKED
HER ABOUT -- YOU KNOW WHAT IS
SHE GOING TO DO ABOUT CLIMATE
CHANGE AND HER RESPONSE WAS
LIKE WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DO LIKE
WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO START
DRIVING A BATTERY OPERATED CAR
WINNER YOU'RE GONNA TAKE YOUR
-- YOU KNOW A RAIN CHECK YOUR
GARAGE AND GO -- TURN A QUARTER
OF AN INCH YOUR GAS LINE INTO
YOUR HOME AND STOP USING GAS
AND THOSE BENEFITS THAT GAS
BRINGS YOU I THINK ABOUT MY
GOOD QUALITY CALL MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE THAT WE TALKED A LOT
ABOUT ON OIL ISSUES AND SHE'S
VERY MUCH FOR SET BACK SHE'S A
CO AUTHOR IN THIS BILL AND WE
TALK ABOUT -- SANTA BARBARA IN
PLACES LIKE THAT SANTA BARBARA
THEY WANTED TO COULD HAVE TEN
YEARS AGO SAID SAID THEY COULD
HAVE TEN YEARS AGO SAID YOU
KNOW WE'RE GONNA GET RID OF
CARBON EMISSIONS THEY COULD
HAVE ELIMINATED NATURAL GAS
THEY COULD PUT A PLAN IN PLACE
THEY COULD HAVE ALREADY DONE
THAT INSTEAD OF PUNITIVE PERMIT
PUNISHING AND THE COUNTY THAT
PRODUCES SEVENTY PERCENT OF
FOSSIL FUELS THAT THIS IN THIS
SETBACK WILL AFFECT I REALIZE
THAT AFFECTS A LOT OF PEOPLE IN
LOS ANGELES I DON'T REPRESENT
LOS ANGELES I'M HERE TO FIGHT
FOR KERN COUNTY BUT I CAN TELL
YOU THAT KERN COUNTY RESIDENTS
JUST LIKE LOS ANGELES RESIDENTS
IN SANTA BARBARA RESIDENTS IF
THIS BILL PASSES THEIR HOMES
WILL BE DEVALUED BECAUSE YOU'LL
BE PUTTING THEIR HOMES AND WHAT
THEY WHAT YOU GUYS CONSIDER AN
UNSAFE -- UNHEALTHY ZONE AND
THAT WILL DEVALUE THEIR HOMES
AND THEIR PROPERTIES AND PEOPLE
LOSE MONEY ON THAT WHEN YOU
THINK ABOUT ALL THE THINGS THAT
ARE GOING ON WITH THIS SET BACK
BILL IT MAKES ME THINK OF JUST
A FEW THINGS I WANT TO READ THE
LANGUAGE I WAS REALLY KIND OF A
TAD CONFUSED AND THE REASON WHY
I SAY THAT IS BECAUSE M.
THE LEASE SO CANYON NATCH THE
GAS PLANT IN A LEASE OKAY AND
IT'S A GAS PLANT ASSOCIATE
LISA KING IN A LEASE SO
CANYON HAD THE LARGEST LARGEST
METHANE RELEASE IN THE ENTIRE
US HISTORY SO THE GREATEST
METHANE RELEASE IN U.
S.
HISTORY I THINK THAT'S MY GOOD
COLLEAGUES AREA THAT RUNS THE
NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
COMMITTEE I THINK THAT PORTER
RANCH IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN IS MY
GOOD COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES
IN HIS NEW SUPERVISORIAL
SEAT ORDER BRANCH WAS VACATED
AND EVACUATED FOR SIX MONTHS
BECAUSE OF THIS HEALTH RISK
IN A LISO CANYON BUT FOR SOME
REASON A LISA CANYON IS EXEMPT
FROM THIS BILL SO THE QUESTION
OF THE AUTHOR WHY IS A LEASE
SO CANYON EXAMINER WE TAKE A
QUESTION SURE WHY IS A LEASE
SO CANYON EXEMPT FROM THIS BILL
IF SET BACKS FROM TWENTY FIFTH
ARE CONSIDERED A HEALTH RISK
PREVENTION WILL CENTER GONZALEZ
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION
I APPRECIATE THAT SO -- THE
LISA CANYON ISSUE WAS ACTUALLY
DEALT WITH I THINK IT WAS A --
SENATOR PROBABLY BILL BACK IN
TWENTY FIFTEEN THAT ACTUALLY
ALREADY ADDRESSED THE ISSUE
ON A NATURAL GAS FACILITIES
I WOULD SAY HOW THAT M.
W.
SECOND QUESTION THE AUTHOR
THIS IS THE THIS IS THE ISSUE
SOMETIMES I THINK THAT IT'S
BECAUSE YOU KNOW THAT'S WHY
INVITE PEOPLE TO MY DISTRICT
MY COLLEAGUES FROM THE BAY
AREA SAYS WHY YOU ALWAYS
MIGHT THESE PEOPLE OF YOUR
DISTRICT BECAUSE I WANT THEM
TO UNDERSTAND HOW KERN COUNTY
WORKS ON THE FACTORY FLOOR
AND I INVITE PEOPLE AYE BY ALL
OF YOU GUYS TO MY DISTRICT TO
LET YOU LEARN ABOUT HOW THE
OIL PRODUCTION IS REALLY IS
THERE REALLY WERE THE FACTORY
FLOOR AND AND THE REASON WHY
I BRING THAT UP IS BECAUSE --
I DON'T THINK THAT YOU GUYS
GET INPUT FROM WHAT WOULD BE
A DIFFERENT THOUGHT PROCESS
THEN YOUR THOUGHT PROCESS YOU
GUYS GET TOGETHER YOU GUYS
HAVE THE SAME MONTH AGENDA THE
SAME WAY YOU THINK BUT IF YOU
BROUGHT IN A DIFFERENT OPINION
YOU MIGHT THINK WOW I DIDN'T
EVEN KNOW THAT THAT AFFECTED
THE LEASEHOLDERS AND HOW IT
AFFECTS RETIREMENT I WOULDN'T
EVEN EFFECT THAT I WOULD EVEN
THINK ABOUT -- BY EXEMPTING
THIS MAJOR EMITTER AND THIS
ORGANIZATION WHICH IS I BELIEVE
A SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS
INSERTS IN THEM A LEASE OKAY
AGAIN IT HAD THE LARGEST THE
LARGEST EXPOSURE IN U.
S.
HISTORY THEY HAVE THE MOST
HIGHEST PART OF PARTS PER
MILLION OR SKEWS ME THEY HAVE
THE MOST HIGHEST M.
S.
VOLUME OF FLUID THAT GOES
THROUGH THOSE PIPES IN
A CONTINUOUS BASIS THIS
SELLING MISTER K.
HOODS PLANT THAT HAS LIKE THREE
PARTS PER MILLION THESE PEOPLE
ARE OPERATING ON HUNDREDS YOU
KNOW THOUSANDS OF PARTS PER
MILLION IN THIS AREA WHICH
HAS A CONSTANT RISK OF BEING
RELEASED INTO THE COMMUNITY
ATMOSPHERE IF YOU REALLY
CARED ABOUT SETBACKS IN SAVING
SCHOOLS AND ALL OF THOSE THINGS
A LISA CANYON WOULD NEVER EVER
EVER BE EXEMPTED FROM THIS BILL
IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH SOME
BILL THAT PASSED BY SENATOR
PAVLEY YEARS AGO THAT WAS FIXED
THE OTHER THING IS IS THAT --
GOING BACK TO A LEASE SO
CANYON THAT ISSUE HASN'T
BEEN ADDRESSED THEY WERE
FINED THEY WERE PENALIZED
BUT THEY'RE STILL OPERATING
THE SAME WAY THAT THEY DID
PRIOR TO THAT EXPOSURE IN
THESE THESE FACILITIES THAT
ARE THERE HAVE THE GREATEST
HEALTH RISK TO COMMUNITIES
IT'S NOT PEOPLE THAT HAVE A
SINGLE WELL WITH A LOW PRESSURE
VOLUME FOR PARTS FOR MILLION
IT'S JUST ABSURD THAT WE
WOULD DO THIS YOU KNOW MY --
MY COLLEAGUES SAID THAT
SHE SAID THAT -- WHEN SHE
TALKED ABOUT THIS BILL THAT
IT WOULDN'T BE ABOUT OIL
IMPORTS YOU'RE GONNA HAVE TO
GET THE SOIL FROM SOMEPLACE
I TRIED TO GIVE YOU GUYS
A LEFT FILE THAT HAD --
SOME INFORMATION ON IT ABOUT
ECUADOR CALIFORNIA IS THE
NATION'S STATE WHEN IT COMES
TO OIL IMPORTATION AND WE HAVE
STOPPED PRODUCING OIL BECAUSE
OF POLICIES LIKE THIS IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND THE
OTHER POLICIES THAT YOU PASS
AGAIN DISPROPORTIONATELY AFFECT
AFFECTING MY DISTRICT AND WE'VE
IMPORTED MORE FROM ECUADOR
WE IMPORT FOR THE NUMBER ONE
IMPORTER OF ECUADORIAN OIL THE
NUMBER ONE IMPORTER IN THIS
PHOTOGRAPH IN SOME DOCUMENTS
THAT I TRY TO PUT ON YOUR I
PUT ON YOUR GUISES DESK -- IN
JANUARY OF TWENTY NINE TWENTY
TWENTY TWO THERE WERE OVER
AND TWENTY NINE MILLION TWENTY
NINE MILLION BARRELS OF OIL
RELEASED INTO THE ECUADORIAN
OUR RESERVOIRS RIVERS WILDLIFE
AND THE RAIN FOREST TWENTY
NINE MILLION BARRELS OF OIL
WITH NINE HUNDRED THOUSAND
GALLONS IN A FIELD IN THE
MIDDLE OF CIMAREX NO PLACE
IN THE MIDDLE OF KERN COUNTY
DID NOT AFFECT ANYTHING AND
WE ALL EVERYBODY IN THIS
BUILDING THAT THE CIRCLE FOR
THAT HAVING SET BACK BILLS
LIKE THIS THAT STOPS THE SMALL
COMPANIES THE KID MISTER HALL
MR CORTEZ ALL THESE FAMILIES
THAT RELY ON THIS IS THEIR
REGULAR JOB IN THE SETBACKS
AND HAVING THEIR LAND AFFECTED
BUT EXEMPTING THE BIG GUY
WHICH IN HISTORY SHOWS
THERE THE REAL PERPETRATOR
IS COMPLETELY WRONG IS
DISINGENUOUS I USED TO THINK
IT WAS BECAUSE YOU DIDN'T
UNDERSTAND AND THAT'S WHY I
BROUGHT YOU TO MY DISTRICT SO
YOU COULD SEE THINGS BUT IT'S
ACTUALLY VERY HYPOCRITICAL IS
WHAT I'M LEARNING TODAY M.
I ALSO WANT TO TELL YOU THAT M.
WHEN YOU LOOK AT WHERE WE GET
OUR OIL FROM INCLUDING LIKE I
SAID ECUADOR IT'S COMPLETELY
ABSURD THAT WE WOULD STOP THESE
INDIVIDUALS EVEN PRODUCING
THE FEW YOU KNOW TWO HUNDRED
THOUSAND BARRELS THAT THEY
PRODUCE FOR US BECAUSE WE
HAVE TO HAVE IT THIS IS ALSO
A CONSTITUTIONAL TAKING YOU'RE
TELLING THE SMALL INDIVIDUAL
PRODUCER THAT HE COULD NO
LONGER DO REAL ON HIS LAND
IN ANY NEW PERMITS TO PROVIDE
FOR HIS FAMILY THESE ARE SMALL
INDEPENDENT BUSINESS OWNERS
JUST LIKE MICRO BUSINESSES IN
LOS ANGELES THAT ARE THRIVING
THE LEGISLATION WAS PASSED TO
PROTECT THEM BUT YET YOU PUT
THE SMALL BUSINESSES OUT OF
BUSINESS MY MOTHER USED TO HAVE
GOD BLESS HER SOUL SHE SHE DIED
TUESDAY HAVE SHE HAD DIED OF
OLD ALZHEIMER'S SHE SAID THESE
IDIOMS THESE PHRASES YOU KNOW
IF IT WALKS LIKE A DUCK TALKS
LIKE A DECK IF IT TERMS YOU
KNOW IT A PUT ON A SWEATER ON
COLD AS MY FAVORITE OR -- YOU
KNOW YOU'VE MADE YOUR BED NOW
SLEEP IN IT YOU'RE MAKING YOUR
BED WITH THIS BILL AND I REALLY
DO HOPE YOU GUYS SLEEP IN IT I
HOPE THAT THOSE PEOPLE IN M.
PORTER RANCH AND THOSE PEOPLE
THAT WERE AFFECTED BY A LISO
CANYONS EXPOSURE THAT THEY SAY
SOMETHING I HOPE TO GOD THAT
THOSE ARE THOSE MARES IN THE
COASTAL CITIES LIKE BILL BRANDS
THAT ARE VERY CONCERNED ABOUT
THE AREAS THAT THEY REPRESENT
WHERE THE PROMISE WAS MADE
TO ADDRESS ISSUES THAT ARE
AFFECTING COMMUNITIES IN A
REALITY IN ADDRESSING CLIMATE
CHANGE ARE DONE YOU GUYS DON'T
YOU DON'T ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES
AT ALL BUT YOU PICK ON THESE
LITTLE GUYS AND YOU TAKE AWAY
AND YOU AFFECT KERN COUNTY
WHEN KERN COUNTY IS THE SAFEST
PLACE FOR YOU TO PRODUCE OIL
YOU DON'T WANT YOUR DISTRICT
DON'T DO IT IN YOUR DISTRICT
BUT DON'T AFFECT MY DISTRICT IN
THE JOBS THAT COME WITH IT AND
ESPECIALLY MY SMALL INDEPENDENT
OIL PRODUCERS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR A NO VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR GROW SENATOR DOLLY
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I I RISE
IN OPPOSITION OF S.
B.
ONE THIRTY SEVEN WHAT ELEVEN
THIRTY SEVEN I JUST WANT TO
GIVE A LITTLE BIT OF THERE WAS
A COMMENT BY THE THE AUTHOR
ABOUT THIS IS NOT GONNA AFFECT
OIL IT WILL I WANT TO GIVE
YOU SOME FACTS CALIFORNIA IS
AS IT IS TOUTED ON THIS FLOOR
ALMOST EVERY DAY ABOUT WHERE
THE FIFTH LARGEST ECONOMY
IN THE WORLD THAT'S TRUE WE
USE ONE POINT EIGHT MILLION
BARRELS OF OIL EVERY SINGLE DAY
NOW SOME OF THE OIL COMES FROM
CALIFORNIA SOME THAT OIL COMES
FROM OTHER NATIONS THIS BILL
IS LIMITING OIL PRODUCTION IN
CALIFORNIA AND WE KNOW THAT
GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM HAS
TOUTED THAT HE DOESN'T LIKE
OIL ESPECIALLY DOESN'T LIKE
OIL IN CALIFORNIA BUT THE FACT
IS WE ARE GOING TO USE OIL
IN CALIFORNIA ONE POINT EIGHT
MILLION BARRELS AND WE WILL BE
USING A LOT OF IT EVEN UNTIL
TWENTY THIRTY FIVE WHEN THEY'RE
SUPPOSED TO BE NO CARSALES
OF COMBUSTIBLE ENGINES IN
CALIFORNIA MAKE NO MISTAKE WE
WILL BE USING OIL TO FLY OUR
PLANES TO TO RUN OUR -- TRAINS
TO RUN OUR SHIPS BUT WHAT'S
WHAT'S REALLY GONNA HAPPEN
THE OIL WILL COME HERE WHERE'S
IT GONNA COME FROM BECAUSE
CALIFORNIA'S WILL USE OIL WON'T
COME FROM CALIFORNIA WHERE WE
PRODUCE A CLEANER MORE MORE
BY EMILY SAFE THAN ANYWHERE IN
THE WORLD IT'S GONNA COME FROM
PLACES LIKE ECUADOR WHERE RIGHT
NOW FIFTY THREE PERCENT TWO
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FOUR PERCENT
OF OUR OIL TODAY IS COMING FROM
ECUADOR WITH THEIR DOZING DOWN
AND DESTROYING THE RAINFORESTS
AND INDIGENOUS PEOPLE ARE BEING
DISPLACED AND EVEN WHERE OIL
IS GETTING INTO THE AMAZON
RIVER NOW FOR THE FIFTH LARGEST
ECONOMY AND WE'RE TAKING THAT
OIL WE'RE ACTUALLY DESTROYING
THE PLANET AND OTHER PLACES
BECAUSE OF OUR CONSUMPTION OF
OIL IT'S HAPPENING AND WE ARE
PASSING LAWS AND BILLS THAT ARE
SAYING WE'RE SAVING THE PLANET
OUR GOVERNORS ARE TALKING ALL
OVER THE COUNTRY ABOUT HOW
HE'S SAVING THE PLANET WE HAVE
FIVE DOLLAR GALLON GASOLINE AND
A SEVEN DOLLAR GALLON DIESEL
IN CALIFORNIA AND THE COST
OF AN EGG ONE UP THIRTY THREE
PERCENT LAST YEAR IT'S BECAUSE
OF THESE KIND OF POLICIES
NOT TO MENTION THE SHIPS THAT
HAVE TO BRING THIS OIL TO
SAN DIEGO CLOSE TO WHERE THE
AUTHOR OF THIS BILL LIVES AND
IS THOSE SHIPS RATHER ODDLY
YOUR CONSTITUENTS ARE BREEDING
THE CARBON THIS PUT OFF BY THE
SHIPS DO WE TALK ABOUT THAT
NO WE DON'T TALK ABOUT THAT WE
TALK ABOUT KILLING OIL WELLS
IN CALIFORNIA THERE ARE TWELVE
HUNDRED OIL WELLS WAITING TO
BE PERMITTED AT THE DESK OF
KALENJIN LAST YEAR THEY DID
ABOUT TEN WHAT WE PRODUCE IT'S
SAFER AND MORE ENVIRONMENTALLY
THAN ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD THIS
BILL ALSO IS IT AGAIN IMPACT
OUR OUR NATIONAL SECURITY WHEN
WE ARE NOT PRODUCING OIL IN
CALIFORNIA AND INTO AND ACROSS
THIS NATION AND WE'RE RELIANT
ON OTHER COUNTRIES WHAT DO
YOU THINK'S GONNA HAPPEN WHAT
WE SAW WHAT HAPPENED WHEN IT
WHEN RUSSIA INVADED UKRAINE
NATURAL GAS IS WHAT MAKES
FERTILIZER I'M A FARMER THEIR
LIVES ARE NORMALLY TRADES
AROUND FOUR HUNDRED DOLLARS
A TON FOR YOUR RIA IT'S
ABOUT TWO THOUSAND DOLLARS
TO BECAUSE WE DON'T PRODUCE
IT IN AMERICA WE IMPORT IT
SO OUR NATIONAL SECURITY IS
BEING JEOPARDIZED BY PIECE
IS A LEGISLATION JUST LIKE
THIS BECAUSE WE'RE RELYING ON
OTHER COUNTRIES FOR EVERYTHING
BUT WE FEEL REALLY GOOD OR
THIS LEGISLATURE FEELS REALLY
GOOD ABOUT PASSING THESE LAWS
BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT SEEN IN YOUR
BACKYARD BUT WE'RE EXPORTING
OUR JOBS AND THE COMMODITIES
THAT WE USE OUT OF CALIFORNIA
AT THE SAME TIME PAYING A
HIGHER RATE FOR TO COME BACK IN
WE IN CALIFORNIA PRODUCE
ONE PERCENT OF THE
WORLD'S CARBON I'LL PUT
M.
IT WAS THE FIFTH LARGEST
ECONOMY THANK ABOUT THAT WE ARE
WE ARE BRINGING ALL THAT STUFF
AND IT'S COMING SOMEWHERE IF WE
REALLY WANT TO DO SOMETHING FOR
THE ENVIRONMENT LET'S PRODUCE
OUR COMMODITIES THAT WE NEED
HERE IN CALIFORNIA LET'S DO IT
IN A SAFE ENVIRONMENT ANYWAY
QUIT EXPORTING OUR JOBS AND
TELLING AMERICA THAT WE'RE
SAVING THE PLANET WHEN WE'RE
NOT IT'S A LIE THE STRAIGHT
UP LIE IF YOU'RE PRODUCING
FERTILIZER IN UKRAINE WITH NO
ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS AND
USING IT IN CALIFORNIA YOU'RE
MESSING WITH THE ENVIRONMENT
CHINA UKRAINE ECUADOR WE'RE
DESTROYING OUR PLANET ALL
THE WHILE TELLING THE WORLD
WE'RE SAVING IT IT'S VS AND
WE NEED TO FACE THE FACTS
THE FACTS ARE WE'RE THE FIFTH
LARGEST ECONOMY WE USE A LOT OF
PRODUCTS AND WE ARE NOT SAVING
THE ENVIRONMENT ALL RIGHT TO
JUST EXPORTING OUR MISSIONS TO
OTHER PLACES LAST POINT THESE
OIL WELLS WERE THERE BEFORE
THE COMMUNITIES WHERE THERE
MOST PUT MOST OF THEM AND
NOW WE'RE GONNA GO IN AND
REGULATE THOSE ALL OF US
BECAUSE THE COMMUNITY MOVED
INTO WHERE THE OIL WELLS ARE
UNDER THE CONSTITUTION
YOUR MINERAL RIGHTS ARE
PRIVATE PROPERTY RIGHTS
THAT'S A TAKINGS
UNDER THE CONSTITUTION
BUT WE DON'T CALL TAKINGS
ANYMORE WE CALL REGULATION AND
WE'RE HELPING EVERYBODY FOR
THE GOOD OF THE PUBLIC WE CAN
TAKE I PERSONALLY FELT THIS ON
MY OWN LAND WHERE WE'RE WE'RE
REGULATING ME WITH MY BUT MY
TRUCKS THEY CHANGE THE LAW
WHEN I BOUGHT MY TRUCKS THEY
WERE MET MET THE LAW AND THEN
AB THIRTY TWO CAME ALONG AND
THEY CHANGED THE LAW AND MY
TRUCKS WERE NO LONGER THERE AND
I DIDN'T GET COMPENSATED AND
THEY TOOK MY PRIVATE PROPERTY
IF THAT HAPPENED TO YOUR
HOME YOU WOULD TAKE DIFFERENT
ABOUT IT BUT IT DIDN'T HAPPEN
YOUR HOME ONLY HAPPEN TO THE
TRUCKERS AND PEOPLE WHO OWN
THEIR THE UTILITIES MEMBERS
YOU GOT TO GO HOME AND LOOK
IN THE MIRROR AND SAY ARE WE
REALLY SAVING THE PLANET WE'RE
NOT THIS BILL IS GONNA HURT
CALIFORNIA IS GONNA HURT THE
ENVIRONMENT AND IT'S GOING TO
TAKE PRIVATE PROPERTY RIGHTS
AWAY FROM PEOPLE WHO HAVE DONE
IT THE RIGHT WAY I URGE A NO
VOTE ON THIS BILL THANK YOU
CENTER DOLLARS CENTER PORCHES
MY COLLEAGUES IS THAT QUITE
A BIT FIVE I WANT GOING TO
TOO MUCH REITERATION BUT
SOMETIME TODAY WE'RE GOING
TO BE DEALING WITH AN ISSUE
INVOLVING DIABLO CANYON AND THE
REASON WHY BRING DIABLO CANYON
UP IS BECAUSE OF THE ACUITY
OF OUR NEEDS HAVE BECOME SO
PRONOUNCED THAT WE'VE HAD TO
LOOK BACK AT WHAT HAS AMOUNTED
TO A FAILED POLICY WHEN I MEAN
BY A FAILED POLICY IT IS A
POLICY THAT PRECEDES REALITY
WE HAVE A SITUATION HERE WHERE
I I SUSPECT THAT THE HEALTH
IN COMPLIANCE REGULATIONS
SURROUNDING THE EXTRACTION OF
OIL FROM BENEATH US WOULD LOOK
AFTER APPROPRIATELY THOSE --
SENSITIVE AREAS THAT THIS BILL
COVERS WITH A FEW SCHOOLS OR
HEALTH FACILITIES OR WHATNOT WE
HAVE AN ENTIRE BODY OF HEALTH
RELATED LAWS REGULATIONS AND
STATUTES THAT ALL OF THESE
EXTRACTION ENTITIES ARE GOING
TO HAVE TO FOLLOW SO I HAVEN'T
SEEN ANY OF THE DATA THAT
INDICATES THAT THIRTY TWO
HUNDRED FEET IS ALL OF A SUDDEN
SAFE BUT BUT BUT CLOSER THAN
THAT IT'S PRESUMPTIVELY ODD BAD
FOR BAD FOR OUR HEALTH I DON'T
WANT TO REITERATE FURTHER IF
WE LOOK AT DIABLO AS A POLICY
THAT PROCEEDS TO OUR NEEDS IN
REALITIES WOULDN'T THIS ALSO
BE IN THAT SAME MILK THAT WE
ARE WE ARE CREATING POLICY
BUT WE'RE DISREGARDING THE
REALITIES THAT WE'RE STILL IN
WE CAN STILL BE ASPIRATIONAL
CALIFORNIA WILL STILL BE
THE LEADER IN THIS IN THIS
SPACE THE IDEA THOUGH IS ARE
WE CUTTING OFF OUR NOSE TO
SPITE OUR FACE NOW I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY AND I HAVE THE
ABSOLUTE RESPECT FOR THE AUTHOR
I THINK YOU ADVOCATE FOR YOUR
DISTRICT YOU ADVOCATE FOR
CALIFORNIA VERY EFFECTIVELY
BUT I WOULD THROW QUESTION YOUR
WAY IF YOU WANT TO ESTABLISH
A PILOT PROGRAM DISALLOW THE
IMPORTATION OF OIL IN TANKERS
TO LONG BEACH TO LA AND WE'LL
GET AROUND THE -- THE COMMERCE
CLAUSE BY ALLOWING IT TO BE
-- TRANSPORTED TO NEIGHBORING
STATES BUT IF WE REALLY REALLY
WANT TO SEE WHAT IT'S LIKE
WHEN POLICIES THAT AFFECT YOUR
DISTRICT ARE ACTUALLY BEING
PLACED IN BURDEN UPON OUR
DISTRICTS I WOULD CHALLENGE
YOU TO TAKE THAT INVITATION
DISALLOW OIL IMPORTS INTO
LONG BEACH AND I WOULD LIKE TO
SEE HOW YOU'RE ECONOMY REACTS
THANK YOU SENATOR BORCHERS
MEMBERS FOR THE -- CENTER
MELENDEZ AND THEN SENATOR
GROWTH THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT -- SO AS MY COLLEAGUE
FROM BIEBER DID MENTION I
BELIEVE CALIFORNIA HAS I
THINK SOME OF THE LARGEST OIL
RESERVES IN THE NATION YET WE
IMPORT MORE THAN WE PRODUCE AND
WE DO IMPORT ABOUT SIX PERCENT
FROM RUSSIA AND I'M SURE YOU
ARE ALL WELL AWARE OF THE FACT
THAT RUSSIA MOST CERTAINLY
DOES NOT ABIDE BY THE SAME
TYPE OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND
REGULATIONS THAT WE DO HERE IN
CALIFORNIA THAT WE TAKE GREAT
PRIDE IN THEIR NOWHERE EVEN
CLOSE TO THAT THAT'S ONLY SIX
PERCENT FROM RUSSIA BUT THEN
YOU GO ON AND YOU TALK ABOUT UP
THE OIL PRODUCTION FROM ECUADOR
OKAY SEVENTY ROUGHLY SEVENTY
EIGHT PERCENT OF THE AMAZON
IS DEDICATED TO ALL OIL
PRODUCTION AND EXTRACTION
IS THAT HELPING TO SAVE THE
PLANET SO I HAVE A QUESTION
OF THE AUTHOR IF I MAY SENATOR
CONSOLES WE TAKE A QUESTION
NO PLEASE PROCEED
THE WAY M.
OKAY THIS IS GREAT --
IF THE IF WE'RE GOING TO GET
RID OF THIS TYPE OF PRODUCTION
IN THE ENERGY WHERE ARE HOW WE
GOING TO REPLACE IT WHERE WILL
IT COME FROM I MEAN THAT'S A
SIMPLE QUESTION I WOULD THINK
THE AUTHOR WOULD BE ABLE TO
ANSWER THAT CERTAINLY SOMEONE
HAS THOUGHT ABOUT THAT BUT
APPARENTLY NOT -- BUT YOU HAVE
TO ASK YOURSELF WHERE IS IT
GOING TO IT HAS TO COME FROM
SOMEWHERE OKAY WE USE A LOT OF
OIL IN THE STATE NO MATTER HOW
HARD YOU TRY TO PUT EVERYBODY
IN ELECTRIC VEHICLE AND PUT
WINDMILLS EVERYWHERE AND SOLAR
PANELS WE NEED OIL IN THE STATE
SO IF YOU'RE GOING TO GET RID
OF SOME OF THIS PRODUCTION IF
YOU'RE GOING TO REDUCE IT IT
MUST COME FROM SOMEWHERE THAT
SOMEWHERE VERY LIKELY IS GOING
TO BE FROM A COUNTRY -- THAT
YOU PROBABLY DON'T I AGREE WITH
THEIR POLICIES AND STANDARDS
ON NOT ONLY ENVIRONMENTAL
CONCERNS BUT JUST HUMAN RAISE
CONCERNS FOR THAT MATTER SO I
WOULD JUST ASK THAT WE NOT BE
HYPOCRITICAL AND OUR APPROACH
TO SOLVING THIS ISSUE -- AND I
WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER MELINDA'S
AND CENTER GROVE I'M GONNA COME
BACK TO AFTER BRING THE SODAS
AND SPOKEN YET CENTER LIMÓN
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I RISE AS A PROUD
JOIN AUTHOR ON L.
S.
B.
ELEVEN THIRTY SEVEN AND I
WANT TO THANK THE SENATOR FROM
LONG BEACH -- FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD YOU KNOW THERE
WAS A COMMENT MADE THAT IF IT
HAPPENS IN YOUR BACKYARD OR
IN YOUR HOME YOU WOULD THINK
DIFFERENTLY AND I WANT TO TALK
ABOUT MY BACKYARD BECAUSE IT'S
MENTIONED ALL THE TIME THE IT
TURNS OUT THAT WE'VE HAD OIL
EXTRACTION IN MY BACKYARD FOR
US SINCE EIGHTEEN SIXTY SEVEN
WHICH IS OVER A HUNDRED AND
FIFTY YEARS SO WHEN WE COME
BACK AT SOME OF THIS POLICY IT
IS COMING FROM THE PERSPECTIVE
OF HAVING IT IN YOUR BACKYARD
OF WATCHING SPELL AFTER SPELL
AND NOT ONLY KNOWING WHAT ON
SHORE -- DOES BUT TURNS OUT THE
IN MY BACKYARD I HAVE OFF SHORE
WHICH MOST COUNTIES -- ALSO
DON'T KNOW A WHOLE LOT ABOUT
AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO
RECOGNIZE THAT IN THE END ARE
THERE ARE MANY CONSIDERATIONS
THAT WE MAKE AS MEMBERS THERE
ARE MANY THINGS THAT WE CARE
ABOUT BUT AFTER OVER A HUNDRED
AND FIFTY YEARS OF HAVING OIL
EXTRACTION IN THE DISTRICT I
CAN TALK TO YOU ABOUT WHY IT'S
SO IMPORTANT TAKE CARE ABOUT
HEALTH OVER THE BOTTOM LINE OF
COMPANIES BECAUSE IT TURNS OUT
THAT WHEN THESE THINGS HAPPEN
-- WHEN THERE IS A SPILL WHEN
THERE IS A LEAK WHEN THERE IS A
YOU KNOW A PROBLEM ON THE ROAD
WITH THE PIPELINE OR AT A PLANT
ARE YOU NAME IT IMPACTS IT
KILLS NOT JUST THE ENVIRONMENT
NOT JUST ANIMALS IT GETS PEOPLE
SICK AND AFTER SO MANY YEARS
THE PERSPECTIVE THAT I COME
FROM IS NOT ONE WHERE IT FEELS
GREAT TO HAVE THESE DEBATES AS
YOU KNOW WITH COLLEAGUES WHO
WHO WHO CHASTISE US FOR CARING
SO MUCH ABOUT THE HEALTH OF
OUR CONSTITUENTS -- IT IS ONE
THAT COMES WHERE WE KNOW WE
DO HAVE TO ACTUALLY REPRESENT
AND REFLECT OUR DISTRICT WHERE
WE CAN POINT TO A HUNDRED AND
FIFTY YEARS OF PROBLEM AFTER
PROBLEM WHERE I CAN POINT TO
THE FACT THAT I HAVE A THOUSAND
IN FORTY FIVE ABANDONED WELLS
IN MY DAY DISTRICT THAT OUR
PROBLEM SO I AM GLAD THAT WE
ARE BRINGING THIS FORWARD THIS
IS ABOUT NEW WELLS BECAUSE IT
TURNS OUT THAT WE COULD STILL
PERMIT NEW WELLS AND WE'RE
ASKING FOR A SET BACK WE ARE
PRIORITIZING TODAY IN THIS BILL
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA WE
ARE PRIORITIZING THEIR HEALTH
AND THIS IS HARD BUT I CAN ALSO
TELL YOU THAT AS A DISTRICT
THAT HAS BEEN LEFT BANKRUPT
FOR OUR TAXPAYERS TO BEAR THE
BRUNT OF WHAT HAPPENS WHEN ALL
THE JOBS GO AWAY BECAUSE NO
ONE IN MY DISTRICT RIGHT HAD
A HAD A REASON TO DO THAT THEY
GO AWAY PEOPLE GO BANKRUPT
THEY BECOME A DIFFERENT COMPANY
AND TAXPAYERS BEAR THE BRUNT
THESE ARE HARD CONVERSATIONS
THESE ARE HARD DECISIONS BUT
IT TAKES A COURAGEOUS LEADER
LIKE OUR OUR LEADER FROM LONG
BEACH AT TO BRING THIS FORWARD
AND SAY ENOUGH IS ENOUGH
HEALTH HAS TO BE PRIORITIZED
OVER BOTTOM LINES AND WE AS
A STATE HAVE TO LEAD AND YES
IT IS DIFFICULT I ABSOLUTELY
APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION
THAT'S BEEN HAD I'VE BEEN TO
KERN COUNTY TO SEE THE OIL
PRODUCTIONS I HAVE WALKED THERE
I HAVE TALKED TO FOLKS AND I
UNDERSTAND THE COMPLEXITIES
BUT IN THE END WE ARE ELECTED
TO MAKE HARD DECISIONS AND
FOR ME IT IS IMPORTANT THAT
TODAY THE MESSAGE WE SENT TO
CALIFORNIA IS ONE THAT WE WILL
PRIORITIZE HEALTH BUT THAT WE
ALSO STAND IN COMMITMENT TO
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE FOSSIL FUEL
INDUSTRY IS AND MEANS NOT JUST
TO THE STATE BUT TO OUR WHOLE
COUNTRY AND I DON'T DENY THAT
THAT THERE IS A COMPLICATED
INTERSECTION WITH THE ENTIRE
COUNTRY AND WITH THE WORLD
-- IN THE GLOBAL MARKET AS
WELL THE MEMBERS I ASK THAT
WE RESPECTFULLY VOTE AYE ON
THIS BILL THANK YOU CEREMONY
CENTER GROVE THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT JUST TO RESPOND BASED
ON THE COMMENTS AND I REALIZE
THE AUTHOR IS NOT GOING TO
TAKE QUESTIONS -- COMMENTS
AGAIN FOR MY COLLEAGUES FROM
SANTA BARBARA -- I REALLY DO
RESPECT AND LOVE DEARLY --
THEY'RE GONNA PUT HEALTH AND
HUMAN SAFETY HEALTH AND SAFETY
OF THEIR CONSTITUENTS OF
CONSTITUENTS ARE CALIFORNIANS
OVER COMPANIES BOTTOM LINES
-- IF THAT WERE TRUE IN ANY
ELKS IN ANY OUNCE THEN THOSE
GAS PLANTS THAT ARE IN MY
COLLEAGUES FROM SANTA MONICA'S
DISTRICT MY COLLEAGUE FROM
STANISLAUS IS OUR STOCKTON'S
DISTRICT MY COLLEAGUE FROM
SANTA BARBARA'S DISTRICT AND MY
COLLEAGUE FRIEND AT CALABASAS
THOSE GAS PLANTS THOSE HIGH
PRESSURE GAS PLANTS WOULD BE
INCLUDED IN THE SET BACK BILL
BECAUSE THEY ARE YOUR GREATEST
EXPOSURE THEY ARE YOUR GREATEST
EXPOSURE TO HEALTH AND IN
THIS ARENA FOR SEPT AXE IN YOU
EXCLUDE THEM BUT WHAT IT DOES
IS THAT THIS BILL IS ALL ABOUT
SEX LET'S TALK ABOUT THIRTY
TWO HUNDRED FEET A HALF A MILE
WITHIN THE DISTANCE BUT IT
DOESN'T DO ANYTHING EXCEPT TO
EFFECT THE SMALL INDEPENDENT
OIL PRODUCERS IN MY DISTRICT
THERE AROUND LOS ANGELES AND
OTHER LOCATIONS THAT WHERE
THEY OPERATE WITH IN THE
COMMUNITY VERY MINIMAL IMPACT
THIS HAS WITH THOSE SETBACKS
UNLESS YOU INCLUDE THESE MAJOR
ORGANIZATIONS THAT SOMEHOW GOT
THEIR WAY OUT OF THIS BILL AND
THEY HAVE THE GREATER EXPOSURE
NO WHERE IN THE HISTORY OF
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
IN THE ENTIRE HISTORY OF OUR
COUNTRY DID A TOWN HAVE TO BE
COMPLETELY EVACUATED FOR SIX
MONTHS BUT YET VEGAS THEY GET
AN EXEMPTION FROM THIS BILL
NO WHERE IN THE EXPOSURES
THAT WE'VE HAD ON OUR COASTAL
ISSUES WITH THESE GAS PLANTS
OR IN THE CENTRAL VALLEY
HAS THERE BEEN X.
GREATER EXPOSURE WHAT YOU
GUYS CALL HEALTH RISK IS
THERE A LANTERN EXTRA SCHOOL
AND DAYCARE A BUSINESS OR
ALL THESE YOU KNOW AVAILABLE
A COMMUNITIES WHERE PEOPLE
ARE AT WITHIN FIFTEEN HUNDRED
FEET OR TEN FEET OR WHATEVER
IT IS THIRTY CENTER FEEDS A
SETBACK BUT THESE ARE VERY
IN CLOSE PROXIMITY THERE THE
EXPOSURE THAT YOU'VE EXEMPTED
THE GREATEST EXPOSURE IN YOUR
AND WHAT'S LEFT IS THE SMALL
INDEPENDENT PRODUCERS THE DON'T
HAVE THE RESOURCES TO COME UP
AND FIGHT YOU GUYS BUT THEY'RE
PREDOMINANTLY IN MY DISTRICT
THE PREDOMINATELY IN MY
DISTRICT SO I RESPECTFULLY
AGAIN ASKS FOR A NO VOTE AND
THAT BILLS THAT YOU ADDRESS
THAT PROBABLY SO YOU SAID IT
FIX IT FIX ANYTHING THIS IS A
HAVE TO MONITOR THE OUTBREAKS
AND A MONITORED THE CARBON
EMISSIONS AND MONITOR THE
EXPOSURE THAT IS THE ADDRESS
AND NINE HUNDRED THOUSAND
DOLLAR METHANE GAS LEAK THAT
EVACUATED A TOWN FOR SIX MONTHS
IT DOESN'T DO THAT SO THEY HAVE
ANOTHER ONE IN YOU'RE GONNA
MONITOR ENGAGE IT FOR A MILLION
A MILLION AG YOU KNOW GALLONS
OF METHANE OR MILLION METRIC
TONS OF METHANE OR WHATEVER
IT IS HAVE YOU MET MEASURE
MAX METHANE I DON'T KNOW HOW
THAT'S DONE I'M SORRY THANK
YOU THE EXCLUDED THE PEOPLE
WHO POSE THE GREATEST RISK
YOU GUYS HAVE EXCLUDED THE
PEOPLE WHO POSE THE GREATEST
RISK AND YOU STILL KEPT IN
THIS BILL THE SMALL INDEPENDENT
OIL PRODUCERS SO THAT YOU CAN
SAY OH WE DID SETBACKS BUT
THE PEOPLE OF THESE COASTAL
DISTRICTS THE PEOPLE OF THESE
THESE THAT HAVE THESE GAS
OPERATED PLANTS THE PEOPLE OF
THE LEAST SO CANYON THE PEOPLE
OF PORTER RANCH THE PEOPLE OF
STANISLAUS A PEOPLE IN SANTA
MONICA THE PEOPLE IN CALABASAS
THEY NEED TO UNDERSTAND THAT
THIS EXEMPTS THEM FROM THIS
PROTECTION IT ONLY AFFECTS
KERN COUNTY AND SPARKS OF LOS
ANGELES RESPECTFULLY AGAIN ASKS
FOR NOTE THANK YOU CENTER GROVE
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SENATOR STERN
TRY THAT AGAIN SENATOR STERN
PUT THE PHONE DOWN OKAY YOU
GOT ME NO THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SAM BY PRESIDENT
I THINK IT'S GIVEN ONE MORE
SHOT DEFINITELY CHECK ONE OKAY
OKAY THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
EVERY GOVERNMENT PLEASE
PROCEED THURMOND PRESIDENT --
I JUST WANT THE IF IF YOU
YOU KNOW MY DISTRICT BEEN
INVOKED BY PEOPLE WHO OUR
STAND SIMPLY LOOKING OUT FOR
THEM I'M I'M NOT SURE HOW WE
BECAME A TALKING POINT -- FOR
THE OIL INDUSTRY SOMEHOW -- I
JUST RATHER THAN GIVE MY OWN
OPINION ABOUT THIS MEASURE I
JUST WANTED TO START WITH A
STATEMENT I KNOW WE'VE BEEN --
INVOKING THE PEOPLE OF ECUADOR
-- I I RECEIVED THE THE PACKET
THE INFORMATION PACKET FROM
MY COLLEAGUE FROM BAKERSFIELD
-- THE PRINTOUTS OF INDIGENOUS
PEOPLE BY OIL SPILLS AND --
THE OIL INDUSTRY THE CALIFORNIA
OIL INDUSTRY SUDDEN AFFECTION
AND CONCERN FOR FOR THE AMAZON
-- SORRY I REACHED OUT TO --
THE FIRST FEMALE CHIEF OF OF
THE WHILE RONNIE PEOPLE OF
PASTAZA AND AMAZONIAN REGION OF
ECUADOR MONTAIGNE IN CHEMO IT'S
RECOGNIZED BY THE U.
N.
BY THE GOLDMAN PRIZE -- AND
BASICALLY PUT HER LIFE ON THE
LINE LEADING THE INDIGENOUS
PEOPLE OF THE AMAZON AGAINST
CHEVRON -- IN ECUADOR SO I
SENT MY COLLEAGUES IN BAKER
FIELDS -- FACT SHEETS OVER
TO HER -- AND ASKED FOR HER
VIEW BECAUSE IF YOU'RE GONNA
BE SPEAKING ON SOMEONE ELSE'S
BEHALF IT'S USUALLY BETTER
TO HEAR IT FROM THE PERSON
THEMSELVES SO CHIEF THANK
HIM -- RESPONDED IN TO READ
WITHOUT OBJECTION THANK YOU
I AM APPALLED BUT NOT SURPRISED
TO SEE THAT THE OIL INDUSTRY
IS WIELDING ITS HALF CENTURY
TOXIC LEGACY IN THE RIGHT THE
RAIN FORESTS OF THE ECUADORIAN
AMAZON MY PEOPLE'S HOME IN
ORDER TO BLOCK LEGISLATION IN
CALIFORNIA THAT WILL ENSURE
THAT FRONTLINE FAMILIES AND
COMMUNITIES IN CALIFORNIA ARE
PROTECTED FROM ENVIRONMENTAL
AND HUMAN HEALTH IMPACTS OF
OIL DRILLING THE MESSAGE THAT
THE OIL INDUSTRY IS SENDING AS
SIMPLE IF YOU PROTECT BLACK AND
BROWN FAMILIES IN CALIFORNIA
FOR MORE TOXIC PRACTICES THEN
WE WILL JUST GO AND POLLUTE
THE INDIGENOUS PEOPLES OF THE
AMAZON AS AN INDIGENOUS WOMAN
AND LEADER FROM THE FRONT
LINES OF THE AMAZON RAINFOREST
MY MESSAGE BACK TO THE OIL
INDUSTRY IS SIMPLE YOUR TIME
IS COMING TO AN END WE WILL
NOT LET YOU PILLAGE OUR LANDS
AND POISON OUR PEOPLE FOR
PROFIT AND WE WILL NOT LET YOU
GET AWAY WITH YOUR LIES ANY
LONGER THE STAKES ARE TOO HIGH
THE CLIMATE CRISIS IS REAL
AND OUR MOTHER EARTH MATTERS
I'VE ALSO RECEIVED MESSAGES
FROM THE RANCH -- OUR COLLEAGUE
OUR COLLEAGUES LIKE TO SPEAK
ON ON MY COMMUNITIES BEHALF
BUT I THOUGHT -- YOU MIGHT
ALSO WANT TO HEAR FROM THEM
THE BILL THAT I WROTE FOR
SENATOR PAVLEY WHEN I WAS
HERE HIS STAFF REQUIRES THE
GAS INDUSTRY IN CALIFORNIA TO
FAR EXCEED THE STANDARDS SET
FORTH IN THIS MEASURE THEIR
LEAKAGE REDUCTION PLANS THAT
ARE CURRENTLY REQUIRED UNDER
CAL GEMS OVERSIGHT AS WELL AS
AT THE AIRPORT ARE IN FACT THE
MODEL THAT THIS BILL USES FOR
REGULATING EXISTING WELLS SO
THE GAS INDUSTRY'S REGULATIONS
WHICH HAVE BEEN IMPOSED SINCE
THAT LEAK ARE NOW FINALLY GOING
TO APPLY TO OIL FINALLY GOING
TO APPLY TO A BECAUSE IF IT'S
GOOD ENOUGH TO PROTECT THE
PEOPLE OF PORTER RANCH THEN
EVERYONE ELSE IN LONG BEACH
IN MONTEREY AND SANTA BARBARA
IN THE CENTRAL VALLEY SHOULD
BE ENTITLED THOSE PROTECTIONS
TO IT SHOULDN'T JUST BE OUR
COMMUNITY IN THE SAN FERNANDO
VALLEY AND SO I WOULD JUST SAY
JUSTICE IS INDIVISIBLE ENDS TO
INVOKE THESE BURDEN COMMUNITIES
TO ME IS IS PROFANE SO I HOPE
YOU'LL HEAR THE TRUE VOICES
FROM THE GROUND I'M AND MOVE
THIS MOVE THIS MEASURE FORD
THANKS THANK YOU CENTER STERN
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NINE CENTER GONZALEZ YOU MAY
CLOSE THANK YOU SO MUCH I'M
MADAM PRESIDENT AND I JUST
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU ALTHOUGH
I DISAGREE WITH MUCH OF THE
REMARKS MADE FROM MY COLLEAGUES
ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE
I I APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION
BUT -- I JUST DON'T AGREE
WHATSOEVER I THINK WE ARE IN
A SPACE NOW WE CANNOT WAIT FOR
-- PEOPLE WHO LIVE NEAR THESE
WELLS TO BE PROTECTED THREE
THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED FEET IS
ALL WE'RE ASKING THIS DOES NOT
STOP OIL PRODUCTION ALTHOUGH
SOME OF US IN THIS SIDE MIGHT
BE HAPPY ABOUT THAT IT DOES
NOT STOP OIL PRODUCTION IT
JUST ASK FOR A BUFFER BETWEEN
DAYCARES SCHOOLS HOSPITALS
NURSING HOMES AND SENSITIVE
RECEPTORS SO THAT THEY DON'T
INHALE MICHAEL'S LIKE BENZENE
TOLUENE ETHYLBENZENE FILENE'S
HEXANE FORMALDEHYDE SO WE'RE
OKAY WITH THAT BUT WE'RE NOT
OKAY WITH TELLING THE GAS AND
OIL INDUSTRY THAT WHERE DOES
THAT THE TIME IS UP AND THAT
WERE ALSO INSURING THAT WE'RE
PROTECTING OUR OUR RESIDENTS
ARE CALIFORNIANS THAT NEED
THE MOST PROTECTION MOSTLY
LOWER INCOME MOSTLY PEOPLE
OF COLOR THAT DEFINITELY NEED
US TO STAND UP AND SO I KNOW
THAT SOMETIMES IT MIGHT BE
HARD TO MAKE DECISIONS ON
THIS MATTER BUT THE PEOPLE
OF CALIFORNIA ARE WATCHING
US WE HAVE SO MUCH POWER HERE
STATE SENATORS AND THE PEOPLE
OF CALIFORNIA ARE WATCHING US
AND THEY WANT US TO ACT NOW
TO WITH THAT I THANK YOU FOR
THE DEBATE AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR NAY VOTE THANK
YOU SENATOR GONZALEZ MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA ATKINS
I FACE NO FACTOR I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD KAMALA CORTESE
DALLY NO DODD THE RUSSELL AYE
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ
I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG WESSEL
HURTADO JONES NO KAMLAGER FIVE
THIRTY FIVE LEYVA AYE SIMONE
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ NOPE
MEN NEWMAN NIELSEN A TROUBLED
PAN AYE PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE CASKEY AYE WIENER AYE WILK
NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ARCHULETA BRADFORD
CUT BY OTHER FOR TAXIS HI DODD
GLAZER HERTZBERG WESSEL HER
TADO NO MANY HI NEWMAN NIELSEN
A CHOI BOGUE NO PORTANTINO
ROTH RUBIO AMBERG PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CABALLERO DODD GLAZER
HERTZBERG WESSEL NEWMAN NIELSEN
PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO NUMBER
SENATOR MOVES THE CALL WE
HAVE SOME MEMBERS THIS IS
WHY WE ALL NEED TO STAY ON
THE FLOOR PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ONE MORE TIME ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CABALLERO DODD GLAZER
HERTZBERG WESSEL NEWMAN NIELSEN
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH RUBIO
NUMBER SENATOR MOVES THE CALL
NIELSEN NO
MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR
YOUR PATIENCE MEMBERS WE
INADVERTENTLY PUT FILE ITEM
EIGHTY FIVE AB SEVENTEEN NINETY
FOUR ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR
SO WE WITHOUT OBJECTION WE'RE
PULLING IT OFF OF THE CONSENT
CALENDAR AND SENATOR CORTESE
WILL PERCENT MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY BILL
SEVENTEEN NINETY FOUR BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER GIPSON AND
ACTIVELY TO CHILD WELFARE
CENTRE CORTESE THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT IN COLLEAGUES ARISE
RESENT AB SEVENTEEN NINETY
FOUR BEHALF ASSEMBLY MEMBER
GIPSON THE BILL ALLOWS CHILDREN
YOUNG ADULTS IN THE FOSTER CARE
SYSTEM ACCIONES TO SAFELY STAY
CONNECTED TO THEIR FAMILIES
AND COMMUNITIES AS WE KNOW
OFTEN WHEN PARENTAL RIGHTS
TERMINATED IN CHILD WELFARE
CASES THE ADOPTED CHILD LOSES
ALL FAMILIAL TIES INCLUDING
WITH SIBLINGS THIS BILL LOOKS
TO ADDRESS INCONSISTENCIES
IN CURRENT LAW REGARDING
SIBLINGS WERE OR WHO ARE
BEING SEPARATED BY ADOPTION
BY PROMOTING ONGOING CONTACT
BETWEEN SIBLINGS ADDITIONALLY
IN CASES WHERE CHILD IS RE
ESTABLISH A RELATIONSHIP
WITH THE BIOLOGICAL PARENTS
AFTERNOON DOBSON'S FIELD THIS
BILL WOULD PROVIDE A PATHWAY
FOR THESE FAMILIES TO REUNITE
THE CERTAIN CONDITIONS ARE MET
THE BILL HAS ENJOYED BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT IN RECENT AMENDMENTS
REMOVE ALL OPPOSITION I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER CORTESE
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA I ATKINS
BATES AYE BACKER AYE FORTUS AYE
BRADFORD CABALLERO AYE CORTESE
AYE TALLY AYE DODD AYE TO RAZA
I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER HI GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH HERTZBERG WESTERN
HER TADO JONES I KAMLAGER AYE
FLARED AYE FLAVOR AYE FOR THE
MONTH I MCGUIRE I'VE MELENDEZ
AYE MIN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
AYE A SHOW OF BOTH AYE PAN
AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
PREVIA AYE SKINNER I STERN
AYE AMBER AYE FORECASTING
AYE WIENER AYE WILK PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN
HI ATKINS I BRADFORD WITH
GROWTH HERTZBERG HI HI HER
TADO FIVE WILK HI IS THIRTY
EIGHT ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING
TO LIFT THE CALL ON
FILE ITEM TWENTY ONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BRADFORD HAVE I EVER
DODD GLAZER HERTZBERG
WESTERN NEWMAN ROTH
RUBIO I'M BURKE
SENATOR MOOSE CALL
MEMBERS ARE GETTING
OUR ACT TOGETHER UP
HERE JUST ONE MOMENT
MEMBERS IT IS TWELVE THIRTEEN
WE'RE GOING TO BREAK FOR
THIRTY FIVE MINUTES PLEASE BE
BACK ON THE FLOOR AT TWELVE
FORTY EIGHT AND YOU NO ONE IS
ALLOWED TO LEAVE THE CAPITAL
SO PLEASE STAY HERE BREAK FOR
THIRTY FIVE MINUTES AND WE'LL
SEE YOU AT TWELVE FORTY EIGHT
MEMBERS TELL YOUR FRIENDS COME
ON BACK TO THE SENATE FLOOR
IF YOU HAPPEN TO BE THE
SEATMATE OF SENATOR DODD
TEXT HIM CALL HIM TELL HIM
WE NEED HIS PRESENCE ON THE
FLOOR MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR
COMING BACK ON ON TIME WE
ARE GOING TO TAKE UP THE
CONSENT CALENDAR WE ARE JUST
WAITING FOR SENATOR DODD
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
THE CONSENT CALENDAR TWENTY
FOUR EIGHT ASSEMBLY BILLS
TWENTY FOUR EIGHTY EIGHTEEN
FIFTY SIX TWENTY SEVEN SEVENTY
FOUR SEVENTEEN THIRTY FIVE
TWENTY FIVE OH NINE TWENTY
FIVE TEN TWENTY THREE TWENTY
THREE OF SIX ONE OF TWO NINE
TWENTY THREE SIXTEEN FIFTY FIVE
SEVENTEEN OH FOUR TWENTY SIX
SEVENTY THREE EIGHTEEN TWENTY
TWENTY NINE SIXTY FOUR THIRTEEN
FIFTY FIVE EIGHTEEN SIXTY THREE
TWENTY ONE NINETEEN EIGHTY
TWO SEVEN NINETEEN EIGHTEEN
NINETY SIX THIRTY TWO EIGHTEEN
TWENTY THREE TWENTY TWO THIRTY
EIGHT TWENTY THREE FIFTY TWO
TWENTY TWO NINETY EIGHT TWENTY
TO SEVENTY FIVE TWENTY FIVE
NINETY SIX THREE OH FIVE TWENTY
SIX SIXTY EIGHT TEN FIFTY ONE
TWELVE NINETY AND ASSEMBLY
BILL NINETEEN FORTY TWO THANK
YOU MADAM SECRETARY MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES AYE BAKER I PORCHES
I BRADFORD AYE CABRERA AYE
CRITICIZING AYE TALLY AYE DODD
AYE FULLER AWESOME I EGGMAN AYE
PLACER AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH
I HERTZBERG AYE WESSON AYE
FURTADO AYE JONES I KAMLAGER
I PREPARED BY LEYVA AYE LIMÓN
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ AYE
MIN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN A
CHOI BOGUE I PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE NUMBER FIVE
QUAKE OWSKI AYE FLEENER AYE
WILK HI PLEASE NIELSEN HI
THANK YOU IS FORTINOS ZERO THE
SPECIAL CONSENT CALENDAR HAS
BEEN ADOPTED MEMBERS WE ARE
GOING TO MOVE TO -- UNFINISHED
BUSINESS WHICH ARE ARE BILLS
THAT ARE BACK HERE ON THE
CONCURRENCE WE'RE GOING TO
START WITH FILE ITEM TO SENATOR
BRADFORD MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL THREE
NINETY SIX BY SENATOR BRADFORD
AN ACT RELATED TO FORESTRY
THERE BRADFORD NO THAT'S FINE
WE'RE GONNA PASS ON FILE
WE'RE GOING TO GO TO FILE
ITEM FOR SENATOR OCHO A BLOKE
MAN SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TWELVE SEVENTY
NINE BY SENATOR CHAU OF BOTH
AN ACT RELATING TO GUARDIANS
AD LITEM CENTER CHOKE MADAM
SPEAKER MEMBERS SENATE BILL
TWELVE SEVENTY NINE IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE AND WILL STRENGTHEN
THE CODIFY SEVERAL ASPECTS
OF GUARDIAN ADLAI ITEM ALSO
REFERRED TO AS G.
A.
L.
APPOINTMENTS THAT OFTEN OCCUR
INFORMALLY OR WITHOUT CLEAR
GUIDANCE FOR LITIGANTS AND
THEIR LAWYERS THIS BILL WILL
ENSURE THAT ONLY THOSE WHO
TRULY REQUIRED A JET G.
A.
L.
OR GAL WILL BE APPOINTED
ONE AND PROVIDES ESSENTIAL
PROTECTIONS FOR THESE
POPULATIONS BY INCREASING
TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
FOR GUARDIAN ADLAI ITEM
APPOINTMENTS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
SIR AND -- CHAU BOGUE MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS THIS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SINGER NINE ICE FORTY NO ZERO
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
EIGHT SENATOR BATES MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL THIRTEEN FORTY TWO BY
SENATOR BATES AN ACT RELATING
TO AGING CENTER BATES THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I AM
PLEASED TO PRESENT S.
B.
-- THIRTEEN FORTY TWO TO CONCUR
IN THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE THE
BILL WOULD AUTHORIZE COUNTIES
TO CREATE MULTI DISCIPLINARY
TEAMS FOR OLDER ADULTS WHICH
WILL ALLOW THE EXPERTS AND
PROGRAMS TO WORK TOGETHER TO
BETTER SERVE OUR AGING ADULT
POPULATION AND THE CARE GIVERS
TO OVERSEE THEM THE AMENDMENTS
OUT THE STATE LONG TERM CARE
OMBUDSMAN TO THE LIST OF
ENTITIES THAT CAN PARTICIPATE
IN THE MULTI DISCIPLINARY TEAM
THE BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION
HAS RECEIVED NO NO VOTES
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR IDOL TO CONCUR WITH THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS THANK YOU
THANK YOU CENTER BATES MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS THIS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
HEARING AND SEEING NONE IS
FORTY NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED IN
FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE CENTER
PORTANTINO AM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL NINE EIGHTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR PORTANTINO
AN ACT RELATING TO MEDICAL
CENTER PORTANTINO THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I
RISE TO PRESENT THE CONCURRENT
AMENDMENTS FOR SB NINE EIGHT
SEVEN THE CANCER CARE EQUITY
ACT -- THE -- AMENDMENTS
FURTHER DEFINE -- CANCER
INSTITUTE COMPREHENSIVE CARE
CENTER AND THE QUALIFYING
ACADEMIC CANCER CENTER --
THIS WILL HELP PEOPLE AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE THIS ALSO QUALIFIES FOR
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE IS FORTY NO ZERO
THE MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON
THE FILE ITEM ELEVEN SENATOR
ALAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FORTY
FOUR BY SENATOR ALAN AN ACT
RELATING TO JOINT POWERS CENTER
ALAN MEMBERS WE SEEN SUCCESSFUL
REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST AROUND
OUR STATE INCLUDING THE SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY THIS CREATES
A SIMILAR REGIONAL HOUSING
TRUST FOR THE SOUTH BAY TO
HELP CREATE MORE TOOLS FOR
THE CONSTRUCTION OF A MUCH
NEEDED HOUSING IN OUR IN OUR
REGION IT HAS STRONG VOTE IN
SENATE GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
YESTERDAY AND I RESPECT FASHION
OF A THANK YOU CENTER ALLEN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
BATES BAKER I PORCHES BRADFORD
MICROBIOTA AYE CORTESE AYE
TALLY DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
EGGMAN GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ HI
GROWTH HERTZBERG HI PRESIDENT
HI HER TADO I JONES NO KAMLAGER
AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA I FOR THE
MOST HI WIRE I'VE MELENDEZ MANY
AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO --
CHOI BOGUE PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
I STERN AYE AMBERG AYE FOR
CASKEY FIVE WIENER AYE WILK
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ATKINS BATES PORCHES DALLYING
EGGMAN GROVE MELENDEZ A
TROUBLED WILK IS TWENTY NINE
KNOWS TO THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM TWELVE
SENATOR WIENER MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL ONE
OH SEVEN BY SENATOR WIENER
AN ACT RELATING TO HEALTH
CARE CENTER WE KNOW THANK YOU
VERY MUCH I'M NOT A PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES SENATE BILL ONE OF
SEVEN IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
-- I HAD NOT INTENDED TO
INTRODUCE AS LEGISLATION WHEN
OURS SESSION CONVENED AT THE
BEGINNING OF THE YEAR -- BUT
THIS PAST SPRING I'M STARTING
IN TEXAS WE SAW A SERIES OF
EXECUTIVE ORDERS -- AND LAWS
BEING PASSED ARE TARGETING
TRANSGENDER CHILDREN AND THEIR
FAMILIES ARE SPECIFICALLY --
CRIMINALIZING THE PARENTS --
AND PROVIDING THAT IF A PARENT
ALLOWS THEIR TRANSGENDER CHILD
TO RECEIVE GENDER AFFIRMING
CARE OTHER PARENT WOULD BE
GUILTY OF A FELONY I IN THE
CASE OF ALABAMA THE PARENT GOES
TO JAIL THE STATE PRISON FOR
TEN YEARS -- THE CHILD WITH ME
TAKEN AWAY AND PUT IN FOSTER
CARE -- AND THE PHYSICIAN
WOULD ALSO BE PUT IN PRISON
EVEN THOUGH THE PHYSICIAN IS
PROVIDING PROVIDING CARE --
THAT IS WITHIN THE STANDARDS
OF CARE -- WE -- THEN PUT
TOGETHER THIS LEGISLATION WITH
A BROAD COALITION -- TO MAKE
CLEAR THAT IF IF THE FAMILIES
OF TRANS CHILDREN DO NOT FEEL
SAFE IN THEIR STATES IF THEY'RE
BEING FRIENDS THEY CAN COME
TO CALIFORNIA AND WE WILL DO
WHAT WE CAN TO PROTECT THEM
AND TO GIVE THEM REFUGE HERE
SO IN THAT SPIRIT ON THE BILL
PROHIBITS THE ENFORCEMENT OF
THE LAW OF ANOTHER STATE --
THAT -- GOES IN THIS DIRECTION
IN TERMS OF CRIMINALIZING OUR
FAMILIES RELATING TO GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE -- THE --
THE BILL ALSO -- BARS HEALTH
CARE PROVIDERS AND OTHERS
FROM COMPLYING WITH SUBPOENAS
REQUIRING THE DISCLOSURE
MEDICAL INFORMATION RELATING
TO GENDER AFFIRMING HEALTH CARE
-- IF IT WOULD INTERFERE WITH
A PERSON'S RIGHT -- TO CONSENT
TO THEIR CHILD RECEIVING THAT
CARE OF THE BILL ALSO PREVENTS
CALIFORNIA LAW ENFORCEMENT FROM
COOPERATING WITH ANY INDIVIDUAL
OR OUT OF STATE AGENCY -- TO --
IN FORESTS ARE THESE LAWS AND
THE BILL WOULD ALSO PREVENT LAW
ENFORCEMENT PARTICIPATION IN A
RESTAURANT EXPEDITION -- TO THE
EXTENT ALLOWED BY THE U.
S.
CONSTITUTION -- SO COLLEAGUES
ARE THIS IS A LAW THAT WILL PUT
CALIFORNIA CLEARLY ON RECORD
AS SAYING THAT WE ARE THERE
ARE FOR THESE FAMILIES -- AND
THEY WERE NOT GOING TO BE A
PARTY TO WARN FORCE THESE VILE
LAWS ARE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
WINNER MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE CENTER BELINDA'S
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
PLEASE IN GERMAN I RISE IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL FOR
NUMBER OF REASONS -- FIRST OF
ALL I'D I'M TRYING TO THINK
OF SOME OTHER SITUATION IN
WHICH CALIFORNIA THINKS IT'S
OKAY TO INTERFERE BETWEEN THE
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN A PARENT
AND A CHILD THIS BILL SAYS
THAT IF A MERRY COUPLE IN
PIC-A-STATE -- FLORIDA GEORGIA
WHEREVER -- ONE PARENT SAYS
THEY THINK IT'S OKAY FOR THEIR
CHILD TO GO THROUGH GENDER
TRANSITION THE OTHER PARENT
SAYS NO ABSOLUTELY NOT THE ONE
PARENT COULD BRING THAT CHILD
TO CALIFORNIA IN SEEK THAT
TYPE OF SURGERY OR MEDICAL --
CARE FOR THEIR CHILD WITHOUT
THE PERMISSION OF THE OTHER
PARENT IN CALIFORNIA WOULD
SAY WE'RE OKAY WITH THAT
IF YOU HAD A CHILD OF YOUR
OWN THEN YOU KNOW THE LINKS
YOU WILL GO TO TO PROTECT YOUR
CHILD AND KEEP THEM FROM HARM
INTO THE VERY BEST YOU CAN
TO KEEP THEM SAFE AND MAKING
SURE THAT THEY'RE NOT MAKING
DECISIONS THAT WOULD CAUSE THEM
HARM LATER ON IN LIFE THIS TYPE
OF -- TREATMENT SOME OF IT IS
IRREVERSIBLE IF YOU'RE TALKING
ABOUT SURGERY THERE IS NO
GOING BACK FROM THAT DURING THE
HEARING FOR THIS BILL THERE WAS
-- A YOUNG PERSON YOU TESTIFIED
ABOUT GOING THROUGH THIS
TRANSITION AND THE REGRET THAT
SHE HAD FROM DOING SO SHE WAS
YOUNG SHE WAS IMPRESSIONABLE
SHE GOT CAUGHT UP IN THE
MOVEMENT SHE GOT CAUGHT UP IN
THE FACT THAT SHE WAS AWKWARD
AS A CHILD HAD DIFFICULTY
MAKING FRIENDS AND FOUND A
SUBGROUP ON THE INTERNET THAT
SEEMS TO BE VERY ACCEPTING
OF HER AND THE CHALLENGES SHE
WAS FACING AND SHE GOT SWEPT
UP IN IT AND SHE WENT THROUGH
WITH THESE CHANGES SHE WENT
THROUGH HAVING BOTH OF HER
BREASTS REMOVED AND YOU'RE NOT
GETTING IT YOU DON'T GO BACK
FROM THAT IF YOU ARE -- A YOUNG
MAN TRANSITIONING TO A FEMALE
YOUR GENITALIA IS REMOVED
YOU DON'T GET TO PUT THAT
BACK SO IF YOU'RE FOURTEEN
AND YOU GO THROUGH THIS TYPE
OF SURGERY AND LATER ON YOU
DISCOVERED THAT IT'S SOMETHING
YOU REGRET YOU CAN'T CHANGE
IT YOU'RE YOU'RE NOT GOING TO
FATHER CHILDREN LATER ON IN
YOUR LIFE BECAUSE OF THE THINGS
THAT YOU DID AND IT DOES HAPPEN
I KNOW THAT THE SUPPORTERS
OF THIS BILL THE TALK ABOUT
-- IT THE TRYING TO SUGGEST
THAT THOSE OF US WHO DISAGREE
WITH THIS BILL THAT SOMEHOW
WE WANT TO KEEP THESE KIDS
WHO ARE GOING THROUGH -- THIS
IN THEIR LIVES THAT WE WANT
TO MAKE THEM INVISIBLE THAT
IS NOT THE CASE IT'S NOT THE
CASE WHAT I HAVE SEEN IN THESE
COMMITTEE HEARINGS IS THOSE WHO
SUPPORT THIS BILL TRIED TO MAKE
INVISIBLE THOSE TEENS WHO HAVE
COME FORWARD TO SAY IT WAS A
MISTAKE WHAT I DID I WISH THE
ADULTS IN MY LIFE HAD STOPPED
ME I WISH THE ADULTS IN MY LIFE
HADN'T ENCOURAGED ME TO DO THIS
I WISH THE ADULTS IN MY LIFE
WOULD HAVE DUG A LITTLE DEEPER
TO FIND OUT WHAT WAS BEHIND
THESE FEELINGS AND HELP ME WORK
THROUGH THAT RATHER THAN ALLOW
ME TO GO FORWARD WITH SURGERY
YOU READY BLOCKERS A WHOLE HOST
OF THINGS THAT ONE CAN DO SOME
OF WHICH ARE IRREVERSIBLE I
HAVE FIVE KIDS MANY OF YOU HAVE
CHILDREN OF YOUR OWN AND SO YOU
KNOW IF YOU THINK BACK TO WHEN
THEY WERE YOUNGER THEY HAVE A
LOT OF DIFFERENT IDEAS ABOUT
THINGS THEY WANT TO DO ONE DAY
THEY WANT TO BE A TEACHER THE
NEXT DAY THEY WANT TO BE AN
OLYMPIC SWIMMER ANOTHER DAY
THEY WANT TO DO SOMETHING ELSE
ONE DAY THERE YOU KNOW AND LOVE
WITH THIS PARTICULAR THING THE
NEXT DAY THEY'RE NOT THEY'RE
THEY'RE CHANGING THEIR EVOLVING
AND TO ALLOW THEM TO GO THROUGH
WITH SOME OF THE MEDICAL
PROCEDURES -- THAT ARE BEING
SUGGESTED HERE WITHOUT A PARENT
BEING ABLE TO INTERVENE IS
WRONG AND THAT'S WHAT THIS BILL
WILL ALLOW I DON'T DISAGREE
THAT WE SHOULD MAKE SURE THAT
KIDS IN IN IN THIS CATEGORY
ARE PROTECTED -- AND NOT
BULLIED AND NOT HARASSED AND
PROVIDED SOME UNDERSTANDING AND
CERTAINLY ANY MEDICAL ATTENTION
MENTAL HEALTH WISE THAT THEY
MAY NEED BUT I DON'T THINK THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA SHOULD BE
STEPPING IN AND FACILITATING
THAT THAT'S NOT OUR PLACE IF
A CHILD IN ANOTHER STATE IF
THEIR PARENTS BROUGHT THEM TO
CALIFORNIA FOR ANY OTHER REASON
TO HAVE THEM DO SOMETHING ELSE
THAT THE OTHER PARENT DIDN'T
AGREE WITH WE WOULD NEVER
SAY WELL WE WILL PROTECT THE
PARENT WHO'S GOING AGAINST THE
OTHER PARENTS' WISHES BECAUSE
IT'S NOT OUR PLACE AND THIS IS
VERY SERIOUS SO IT'S NOT THAT
-- DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT THIS
CAN BE A DIFFICULT TIME FOR A
YOUNG PERSON AND THE PARENTS
FRANKLY BUT UNTIL D.
YOU'VE HAD A CHILD YOURSELF
AND YOU YOU'VE WATCHED THEM
MATURE AND YOU WATCH THEM GROW
AND YOU WATCH THEM GO THROUGH
ALL THE CHANGES THAT THEY GO
THROUGH AS AN ADOLESCENT YOU
CAN NEVER UNDERSTAND WHAT
IT'S LIKE TO BE THE PARENT
TO SAYS I DON'T THINK THIS
IS THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR MY
CHILD INSTEAD OF CALIFORNIA
I DON'T WANT YOU TO STEP IN
AND GET IN THE WAY OF ME DOING
WHAT'S BEST WHAT I THINK IS
BEST FOR MY CHILD AND HELP
ME HELPING MY OWN CHILD IT'S
NOT THE JOB OF ANY SENATOR IN
HERE TO DO THAT AND CERTAINLY
NOT THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
I'M AGAIN I
I HOPE THAT YOU'VE DONE
YOUR RESEARCH ON THIS ISSUE
OBVIOUSLY SOME OF THE MEASURES
TAKEN AREN'T AS EXTREME AS
REMOVAL OF GENITALIA BUT SOME
ARE BUT THERE'S A WHOLE HOST OF
THINGS AND IF YOU LOOK AT THE
OTHER COUNTRIES WHO ARE TAKING
A STEP BACK NOW AND SAYING YOU
KNOW WE ACTUALLY THINK THIS
THIS CAN BE VERY HARMFUL FOR
KIDS IN THE LONG RUN IN THE
END BECAUSE THERE THERE IS NO
GOOD DATA TO SAY THAT THE USE
OF THESE TYPES OF THINGS LIKE
PUBERTY BLOCKERS AND THINGS
LIKE THAT THERE THERE'S NO GOOD
LONG TERM SCIENTIFIC STUDIES
THAT SAY THAT THIS DOES NOT
CAUSE LONG TERM DAMAGE I AM
CERTAIN SOMEONE IS GOING TO
STAND UP AND TRY TO REFUTE THAT
BUT I WOULD URGE YOU TO GOOGLE
IT YOURSELF AND YOU WILL SEE
THIS IS THE EXACT REASON WHY
SOME OF THESE OTHER COUNTRIES
ARE TAKING A PAUSE AND SAYING
WE ACTUALLY DON'T THINK THIS
IS THE BEST THING TO DO FOR
KIDS WE REALLY NEED TO -- YOU
KNOW PISCIS ISSUE SO YOU CAN BE
SYMPATHETIC AND UNDERSTANDING
TO THOSE WHO ARE HAVING --
THOUGHTS ABOUT TRANSITIONING IN
IN THE PARENTS WHO ARE TRYING
TO HELP THEIR KIDS YOU CAN BE
SYMPATHETIC TO THAT BUT ALSO BE
SYMPATHETIC TO THE PARENTS WHO
ARE RAISING THEM AND THEIR ROLE
IN THEIR CHILD'S LIFE AND NOT
INTERFERE IN THAT RELATIONSHIP
BETWEEN THE PARENT AND THE
CHILD WITHOUT ORIGINAL ABOUT I
THINK YOU MEANT A NO VOTE BUT
WILL TAKE AN AYE VOTE ALL RIGHT
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATOR PAN THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT SENATORS -- I
STAND IN SUPPORT OF THE CURRENT
WITH ASSEMBLY MEN MINSAN S.
B.
ONE OF SEVEN -- HOWEVER I THINK
IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WHEN WE
DEBATE THE ISSUES HERE THAT --
WE ACTUALLY NOT EXAGGERATE AND
TALK ABOUT THE FACTS SO I AM A
PARENT RAISING -- TO HAVE ONE'S
TEENAGER WANTS A PRETEEN SO I
KNOW MANY OF YOU HERE PARENTS
SOME ALSO PEDIATRICIAN HIS
JOB IS TO HELP ASSIST PARENTS
IN -- AND ADVISE THEM AND TO
ADVISE THEM ON THEIR HEALTH
AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT
WE TALK ABOUT THE FACTS SO
FIRST OF ALL -- THIS ACTUALLY
-- WHEN IT COMES TO SURGERY
BECAUSE THAT WAS MENTIONED --
THERE'S NO RECOMMENDATIONS FOR
SURGERY -- ESSENTIALLY BEFORE
THE CHILD IS NO LONGER A CHILD
IS NOW THE AGE MAJORITY WHERE
THEY CAN MAKE DECISIONS ON
THEIR OWN SO -- THAT IS NOT
-- WHAT'S RECOMMENDED BY THE
MEDICAL PROFESSION AND I THINK
IT'S IMPORTANT NOT TO ACTUALLY
EXAGGERATE ABOUT THAT WE
ACTUALLY HAD -- UNFORTUNATELY
ARE PEOPLE WHO -- HAVE DONE
THAT ON SOCIAL MEDIA THAT'S LED
TO ACTUALLY A BOMB THREATS AT A
CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL RECENTLY SO
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
SHARE ACCURATE INFORMATION AND
NOT IN SIGHT -- THESE TYPES OF
ACTIONS BASED ON MISINFORMATION
I ALSO MAKE NOTE THERE ACTUALLY
IS RESEARCH AND STUDIES LONG
TERM STUDIES LOOKING AT --
PUBERTY BLOCKERS -- WE ALSO
KNOW THAT THERE'S RESEARCH
SHOWING THAT -- YOUTH WHO
ARE QUESTIONING THEIR GENDER
IDENTITY -- THAT FIRST OF ALL
-- MANY OF THEM DON'T CHANGE
OUR MINDS NOT SAYING NEVER
HAPPENS BUT BY THE WAY MOST OF
THE TREATMENTS THAT WE PROVIDE
TO YOUTH AT THAT AGE IT ART
IS REVERSIBLE SAMPLE PUBERTY
BLOCKERS RIGHT -- IN THAT THE
NILE OF THOSE TREATMENTS HAVE
LONG TERM AND SIGNIFICANT
CONSEQUENCES -- INCLUDING
-- YOU KNOW DEPRESSION AND
SUICIDALITY AND WE KNOW THAT
THE RATES OF SUICIDE IN THESE
YOUTH IS HIGHER THAN IT IS
AND OTHER USE -- ESPECIALLY
IF -- THEY ARE NOT ACCEPTED SO
WHEN IT COMES TO -- WHAT
OUR ROLE IS HERE AND TRYING
TO PROTECT THE PEOPLE OF
CALIFORNIA INCLUDING ARGUES
WE WANT TO BE SURE THAT WE
NOT JUST GOOGLE BUT ACTUALLY
TALK TO EXPERTS PEOPLE IN
THE FIELD -- ACTUALLY WORK ON
THESE ISSUES -- I'D SAY EVERY
DAY BUT AT LEAST FREQUENTLY
WHO ACTUALLY SPEND TIME
INVESTIGATING THESE ISSUES
AND LEARN THE FACTS AND USE
THOSE FACTS MAKE OUR DECISIONS
SO I REALIZE PEOPLE MAY COME
TO DIFFERENT CONCLUSIONS BUT
LET'S AT LEAST START OFF WITH
WHAT IS ACTUALLY TRUE AND NOT
MAKE OUR DECISIONS BASED ON
EXAGGERATIONS OR INACCURACIES
I RESPECTFULLY ASK NIGHT THANK
YOU CENTER PAN CENTERMAN THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I I RISE
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL I I
HAVE A NEPHEW WHO'S TRANCERS
ABOUT TWELVE YEARS OLD -- AND
I ECHO THE CONCERNS RAISED BY
MY COLLEAGUE FROM SAN FRANCISCO
I IT'S UNFORTUNATE THAT WE
NEED THIS BILL BUT THE FACT IS
THAT THERE'S A LOT OF BALLING
HAPPENING RIGHT NOW THERE'S
A LOT OF BULLIES OUT THERE
IN ELECTED POSITIONS THAT ARE
PASSING LAWS DESIGNED TO TRY
TO PUNISH AND INTIMIDATE PEOPLE
JUST BECAUSE THEY'RE DIFFERENT
THAN THE MAJORITY AND SO WE
LIVE IN AN ERA UNFORTUNATELY
WHERE WE IN THIS STATE WITH
OUR PROGRESSIVE INCLUSIVE
VALUES NEED TO DEMONSTRATE
THAT THAT WE ARE GOING TO BE
A CENTURY THAT THESE TYPES
OF PUNITIVE AND I WOULD ARGUE
UNCONSTITUTIONAL LAWS WILL NOT
BE ABIDED BY A RESPECTED IN
THE STATE SO -- I I HEAR THE
CONCERNS MY COLLEAGUE FROM LIKE
US IN OUR BUT BUT I THINK WE
IN THE STATE HAVE A MISSION WE
HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY TO TRY TO
UPHOLD THE RIGHTS OF EVERYONE
AGAINST THOSE WHO TRY TO
BULLY AND INTIMIDATE THEM SO I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU SENATOR MAN CENTER
DOLLY THE MEN PRESENT MEMBERS
THAT QUESTION THE AUTHOR THE
MAN WHEN WE TAKE A QUESTION
YEAH PLEASE PROCEED WHAT IS
THE AGE OF WHAT'S THE AGE OF
THIS THAT YOU CAN ACTUALLY MAKE
THAT DECISION WHAT IT WHAT IS
IT WE'RE TRYING TO FIND IT HERE
IN THE TAXED SO PLEASE RECEIVED
THANK YOU YOU KNOW IT'S REALLY
INTERESTING -- WITH ALL RESPECT
TO MY COLLEAGUES ON THE OTHER
SIDE OF AN AISLE V.
I.
O.
WHO WERE FRANKLY DEBATING
A DIFFERENT BILL TO SOME OF
THE GROSS DISTORTIONS THAT
WE'VE HEARD ABOUT THIS BILL
-- ARTIST FRANKLY ON OVER THE
TOP AND SO -- AND IN TERMS OF
GENDER AFFIRMING CARE THAT IS A
MEDICAL ISSUE THAT IS A MEDICAL
ISSUE DETERMINED BY HEALTH CARE
PROVIDERS UNDER STANDARDS OF
PROFESSIONAL HEALTH CARE --
CENTERS OF A PERSONAL HEALTH
CARE THIS BILL DOES NOT WRITE
WHAT THE MEDICAL STANDARDS
ARE FOR GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
THERE ARE THERE ARE BODIES
THAT SET THOSE STANDARDS THEIR
PEER REVIEWED STUDIES AND WE
CAN GO THROUGH I'M NOT GONNA
DO IT TODAY ALL THE PEER
REVIEWED SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE
ABOUT GENDER AFFIRMING CARE
HAS SO MANY BENEFITS FOR
THESE TRANSCRIPTS AND SO WE
HAVE AGES OF CONSENT -- IT
IN CALIFORNIA PARENTS CAN
ALSO CONCERNED I THINK IT'S
ALSO REALLY IMPORTANT OF THE
STANDS WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE
WHAT IS IN THIS BILL ARE AND
THAT IS THAT PARENTS ARE BEING
CRIMINALIZED IN OTHER STATES
FOR CONSENTING TO HEALTH CARE
FOR THEIR CHILDREN SO THESE ARE
CHILDREN AND THE PARENTS ARE
CONSENTING THIS WHOLE NOTION
BUT THIS IS GETTING BETWEEN A
CAN THEIR PARENTS IS IS BOGUS
PARENTS ARE CONSENTING AND
THEN BEING TOLD YOU'RE A FELON
FOR CONSENTING TO THAT GENDER
AFFIRMING CARE FOR TRANS CHILD
THANK YOU FOR CALLING MADAM
PRESIDENT TO I DIDN'T HEAR
AN ANSWER IN THAT OTHER THAN
THE FACT THAT THERE IS NO
AGE BASICALLY THEY AGE CAN
BE DETERMINED BY A PANEL OF
PEOPLE OR SOME SCIENTIFIC DATA
THAT'S OUT THERE BUT THAT'S
THE SAID JUST REALLY BOIL IT
DOWN HERE THIS IS ABOUT IF
YOU HAVE A SITUATION WHERE
YOU HAVE ONE PARENT SAY THEIR
SPLIT UP AND THEY HAVE A CHILD
AND ONE PARENTS FOR AND THE
OTHERS AGAINST IT -- THE STATE
NOW WILL BE IN THE MIDDLE OF
THAT DECISION BETWEEN THOSE
PARENTS AND I THINK THAT'S A
VERY UNFORTUNATE SITUATION THAT
THIS BILL WOULD PUT THOSE TWO
PARENTS IN AND THE CHILD AT THE
SAME TIME AS A FATHER OF THREE
CHILDREN -- THIS THIS BILL IS
BASICALLY PUTTING THE STATE
IN YOUR HOME IT WE'VE HEARD SO
MUCH ABOUT HOW YOU KNOW WHAT
WHAT IS THE AGE APPROPRIATE
FOR FOR IN PRISON SOMEBODY
OR LEADING SOMEBODY OUT OR OR
THERE WAS A BILL JUST RECENTLY
ABOUT A LAST YEAR ABOUT -- THE
A TWENTY FIVE YEAR OLD REALLY
DID KNOW THEY'RE DOING SO THEY
SHOULD BE LET OUT OF PRISON FOR
THEIR YOUNGER CRIMES AND HOW
DOES THAT RELATE TO THIS BILL
THIS RELATES THIS BILL BECAUSE
THERE IS NO AGE APPARENTLY
THERE'S NO AGE THAT YOU CAN DO
GENDER AFFIRMING TREATMENTS ON
A CHILD WHERE ARE THE PARENTS
MAY DISAGREE ON THAT SO I JUST
THINK IT'S TIME FOR CALIFORNIA
TO YOU KNOW GET OUT OF THE
WAY OF PARENTS AND LET THEM
WORK WITH THEIR CHILDREN AND
LOOK IF THEY'RE AN ADULT BUT
I MAKE THE DECISION I HAVE
NO PROBLEM THAT THEY WANT TO
MAKE THAT DECISION AT ALL BUT
AS WE'VE HEARD IN THOSE OF US
WHO RAISE CHILDREN THEY REALLY
DON'T KNOW WHAT THEIR IDENTITY
IS IT MAY CHANGE MANY TIMES IN
THERE YOU ALL OF US PROBABLY
WENT TO THAT OURSELVES I KNOW
CERTAINLY I DID IN TRYING TO
FIGURE OUT WHAT MY VALUES WE'RE
GOING TO BE AND WHAT WHAT THE
FUTURE LOOK LIKE FOR ME AND
IT CHANGED MANY TIMES IT WILL
AND IN MY CHILDREN'S LIVES
AND AS A PARENT I WANT TO COME
ALONGSIDE THEM I DON'T WANT TO
BE DIVIDED UP BY SPLIT HOMES
OR THE GOVERNMENT DECIDING
WHO'S GONNA DO WHAT WITH
MY CHILD SO FOR THOSE
REASONS I OPPOSE -- S.
B.
ONE OH SEVEN THANK YOU CENTER
DOLLY CENTER MELINDA'S THANK
YOU I HAVE JUST A COUPLE
MORE QUICK POINTS TO MAKE --
THE AUTHOR TALKED ABOUT THE
DEPRESSION IN THE ANXIETY AND
THE STRESS THAT THESE KIDS
GO THROUGH -- BUT WE DIDN'T
TALK ABOUT WAS THE ANXIETY
AND STRESS AND DEPRESSION
THAT MANY OF THEM GO THROUGH
AFTER THEY'VE GONE THROUGH
-- THIS TYPE OF SURGERY THIS
TYPE OF TRANSITION AND THAT
IS VERY REAL AND YOU CANNOT
DENY THAT AND YOU CANNOT SAY
THAT THOSE KIDS WHO NOW REGRET
THEIR DECISION ARE INVISIBLE
THE SECOND THING I WOULD
LIKE TO POINT OUT IS JUST
A SOMETHING I WAS THINKING
ABOUT A FRIEND OF MINE WHO
IS SEPARATED FROM HER CHILD'S
FATHER AND SHE WANTS TO BE
ABLE TO TAKE HER CHILD TO SEE
A PSYCHOLOGIST HE'S HAVING SOME
ISSUES NOT GENDER RELATED OR
JUST SOME ISSUES AND SHE CANNOT
DO THAT WITHOUT THE PERMISSION
OF HER EX HUSBAND SHE CANNOT
GET THAT CHILD THE MEDICAL
TREATMENT THAT SHE THINKS IS
PROPER FOR HER KID WITHOUT THE
PERMISSION FROM THE HUSBAND
BUT THIS BILL IS SAYING THAT
IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE BECAUSE
OF THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE IF
YOU'RE COMING FROM OUT OF STATE
YOU CAN DO THAT IN CALIFORNIA
AND NO ONE WILL INTERFERE WITH
YOU IT DOES NOT SQUARE WITH
ME AGAIN I REGION ABOUT THANK
YOU CENTER MELINDA'S MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NINE CENTER
WINNER YOU MAY CLOSE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT YOU KNOW I
KNOW THAT -- LIFE FRIENDS THE
OTHER SIDE OF THE ISLAND THERE
AND THEIR POLITICAL PARTY --
-- IS REALLY INTO THE CULTURE
WARS AROUND TRANS KIDS AND
USE OF SOME SORT OF WINNING
POLITICAL ISSUE -- AND WE
SEE ON FOR UNFORTUNATELY THIS
PARTY THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY --
TRYING TO SCORE CHEAP POLITICAL
POINTS ON THE BACKS OF THESE
CHILDREN I UNDERSTAND YOU
CAN AND WE CAN HAVE WHATEVER
CULTURE WARS -- THAT WE WANT
TO HAVE -- AND PEOPLE CAN --
I'M SORRY BEDFORD I AM
SPEAKING VERY MUCH OF THE
BILL YES YEAH AND P.
AND WE CAN AND WHAT WE SEE IN
THE ARGUMENTS TODAY IS TRYING
TO PLAY INTO THIS CULTURE WAR
IN DELEGITIMIZING AND RACING
TRANSCAT AND THAT'S WHAT THIS
IS ABOUT AND ARE DEBATING NOT
EVEN WHAT THIS BILL ACTUALLY
IS WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT THIS
BILL DOES THIS STILL DOESN'T
PUT THE STATE INTO PEOPLE'S
HOMES WHAT'S PUTTING THE STATE
IN THE PEOPLE'S HOMES IS ONE
OTHER STATES LIKE TEXAS AND
ALABAMA ARE SAYING THAT IF
YOU ALLOW YOUR TRANS KIDS GOT
HEALTH CARE YOU'RE A CRIMINAL
AND WE'RE GOING TO PUT YOU IN
STATE PRISON THAT'S GETTING IN
BETWEEN A PARENT AND A CHILD
THAT'S WHAT THIS BILL IS TRYING
TO PROTECT AGAINST THERE'S BEEN
A DISTORTION OF WHAT THE COURTS
IN CALIFORNIA TIENEN CAN'T DO
ALL THIS BILL DOES IS ALLOWS
CALIFORNIA COURTS TO MAKE THAT
CUSTODY DETERMINATION THIS
DOESN'T PREVENT IF ONE PARENT
IS COMMITTING A CRIME OR IS
ACTING BADLY THE CUSTODY COURT
CAN TAKE THAT INTO ACCOUNT SO
THE BILL THAT'S BEING DEBATED
ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE AISLE
WITH ALL DUE RESPECT IS SO
DISTORTED TERMS OF WHAT THIS
BILL ACTUALLY DOES THIS IS
ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT THE
TRANS KIDS AND THEIR FAMILIES
ARE NOT BEING CRIMINALIZED AND
TORN APART BY OTHER STATES AND
THAT CALIFORNIA IS NOT GOING
TO ENFORCE THESE VILE HATEFUL
LAWS AND THAT IF THEY FEEL
UNSAFE AND FEEL THE NEED TO
COME TO CALIFORNIA TO BE SAFE
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE THEIR BACKS
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER WIENER
INTEREST REMINDER MEMBERS CAN
CLOSE IN THE WAY IN WHICH THEY
SEE FIT -- MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
ARCHULETA I ATKINS BATES NOW
BAKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
AYE CABRERA AYE CRITICIZING
AYE DALY NO DODD AYE TERASA AYE
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
WESTERN I HER DAUGHTER I JONES
NO KAMLAGER HI THERE I LEYVA HI
THE MON HI WIRE I MELENDEZ NO
MAN HI NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO --
TROUBLE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO
I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER I
STERN AYE AMBER AYE FORECASTING
AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN
I ATKINS HI HERTZBERG AT FIVE
THIRTY NEWS NINE THE MEASURE
PASSED EXCUSE ME THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS WERE GONNA SKIP FILE
ITEM THIRTEEN RIGHT NOW WE'RE
GONNA GO TO SENATE SENATOR
DODD WITH FILE ITEM FOURTEEN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL SEVEN SEVENTEEN
BY SENATOR DODD AND ACTUALLY
THE COMMUNICATIONS CENTER DOG
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I RISE TO PRESENT S.
B.
SEVEN ONE SEVEN ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S RECAST SB
SEVEN ONE SEVEN TO EXAMINE THE
BARRIERS TO BROADBAND ACCESS
POINTS IT PROVIDES CONCRETE
RECOMMENDATIONS ON HOW TO
ACCELERATE THE DEPLOYMENT
OF WIRELINE MOBILE AND FIXED
WIRELESS INFRASTRUCTURE TO
INCREASE CONNECTIVITY FOR
ALL CALIFORNIANS RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR DODD MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS IS ELIGIBLE
FOR A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NO NICE THIRTY NINE NO
ZERO THE MEASURE PASS X.
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
FIFTEEN SENATOR ROTH MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOURTEEN THIRTY THREE BY
SENATOR ROTH AN ACT RELATING
TO PRIVATE POST SECONDARY
EDUCATION AND MAKING A
PERFORATION THEREFORE CENTER
ROTH THURMOND PRESIDENT
OF COLLEAGUES SENATE BILL
FOURTEEN THIRTY THREE IS BACK
ON CONCURRENCE THIS IS THE
SUNSET BILL FOR THE BUREAU
FOR PRIVATE POSTSECONDARY
EDUCATION ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
REFLECT CONTINUED DISCUSSIONS
THAT WE'VE HAD IN A VARIETY
OF SENATE SENATE POLICY
COMMITTEES THE FOR THE DEAL
WITH THE SUBJECT SENATE AND
ASSEMBLY AND SPECIFICALLY
THIS BILL AND THE AMENDMENTS
EXTEND THE BUREAU'S OPERATIONS
IN THE ACT FOR FOUR YEARS
AUTHORIZED ANOTHER STATE PUBLIC
INSTITUTION TO BE REGULATED
BY THE BUREAU SPECIFY WHAT
CONSTITUTES PHYSICAL PRESENCE
IN THE STATE FOR PURPOSES OF
THE BUREAU CLARIFY ACTIONS
FOR APPROVED INSTITUTIONS THAT
LOSE ACCREDITATION AND FOR
DEGREE GRANTING INSTITUTIONS
SEEKING ACCREDITATION SPECIFY
CERTAIN PROHIBITED PRACTICES
AND PROVIDE PROVIDE SOME
ENFORCEMENT ENHANCEMENTS
OBVIOUSLY AS YOU KNOW WITHOUT
THIS BILL THE BUREAU AND
PRIVATE POSTSECONDARY EDUCATION
ACT WILL EXPIRE SO WE NEED
TO VOTE AYE TO EXTEND IT SO
I RESPECTFULLY AS FOR NOW
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER ROTH
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
BATES AYE PACKER AYE PORCHES
AYE BRADFORD AYE CABRERA AYE
CORTESE AYE TALLY AYE DODD
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER HI
GONZALEZ I GROWTH I HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES I KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE LEYVA I FOR THE MOST
AYE WIRE AYE BELINDA'S AYE
MEN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
I TROUBLED AYE PAN AYE
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
AYE SKINNER I STERN AYE AMBER
AYE FORECASTING AYE WIENER
WELL HI PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN I DODD
I WIENER HI IS FORTY NEW ZERO
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM
SIXTEEN SENATOR PAN MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOR TWENTY TWO BY SENATOR
PAN AND ACT RELATING TO STATE
EMPLOYMENT CENTER PAM THANK
YOU MATTER PRESENCE UNDER SIGN
PLEASE PRESENT U.
S.
B.
FOUR TWENTY TWO SECOND
CONCURRENCE -- WHICH EXTENDS
WORK FOR SIX FLEXIBILITY CIVIL
SERVICE MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS
AMENDMENTS WERE TAKEN AND
SOMEBODY TO NARROW THE SCOPE
THE BILL TO IMPROVE AND
IMPLEMENT A PROOF OF CONCEPT
WILL CONTINUE TO PATIENT CARE
ESPECIALLY AS WHEN I THAT
THANK YOU CENTER PAM MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE M.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA I ATKINS
I BATES NO PACKER I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD I HAVE A A I
CORTES HE AYE DALY NO DODD I
DORADO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
HI WESTERN I HER DAUGHTER I
JONES NOW KAMLAGER HI LARRY I
LEYVA I FOR THE MOST BY REQUIRE
I MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- CHAU VOGUE
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
FROST AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER I
STERN AYE AMBERG AYE VACANCY
I WIENER AYE WILK NOW IT'S
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN
HI I THIRTY ONE KNOWS NINE
THE MEASURE PASSES MOVING THE
FILE ITEM SEVENTEEN SENATOR
CABALLERO MA'AM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL FOUR
NINETY BY SENATOR CABALLERO AN
ACT RELATING TO AGRICULTURAL
FOOD PRODUCTS CENTER CABALLERO
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I'M
PLEASED TO PRESENT SB FOUR
NINETY WHICH INCLUDES THE
CONTENT OF A BILL THAT YOU
ALL HEARD EARLIER IN THE YEAR
WHICH SUPPORTS CALIFORNIA'S
AGRICULTURAL INDUSTRY AND
PROTECTS CALIFORNIA JOBS BY
CLARIFYING AND STRENGTHENING
THE BUY AMERICAN POLICIES FOR
PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND COLLEGE
MEAL PROGRAMS SB FOUR NINETY
WOULD IMPROVE THE QUALITY
AND SAFETY OF ST PROVIDED
NUTRITION PROGRAMS PROTECT
CALIFORNIA WORKERS AND REWARD
CALIFORNIA'S AGRICULTURAL
INDUSTRY THE BILL ENJOYED BY
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN BOTH
HOUSES AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
CABALLERO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS IS ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL THERE
THERE IS OPPOSITION TO ANY
ANIMUS ROLL CALL PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES AYE PACKER
AYE PORCHES AYE BRADFORD
AYE CABRERA AYE CORTESE AYE
TALLY AYE DODD HI TO RAZA
EGGMAN AYE PLEASER AYE
GONZALEZ I GROWTH I HERTZBERG
I PUESTO AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES I KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE FLAVOR I FOR THE MONTH I
REQUIRE HI MELENDEZ AYE MIN
AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN HI --
TROUBLE I PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH HI RUBIO I SKINNER
STERN SKINNER AYE
STERN AYE AMBERG AYE
FORECASTING AYE WIENER
FIVE WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN NO TORONTO
HI I THIRTY NINE KNOWS ONE
THE MEASURE PASSES FILE ITEM
EIGHTEEN SENATOR JONES MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL EIGHT NINETY FOUR BY
SENATOR JONES AN ACT RELATING
TO BE A COST CENTER JONES THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
SENATE BILL EIGHT NINETY FOUR
IS NOT DIABLO CANYON OR OIL
WILL SET BACKS BUT STILL IS
A VERY IMPORTANT BILL THE
THOUSANDS OF CALIFORNIANS THAT
LIVE IN ALL OF OUR DISTRICTS
SENATE BILL EIGHT NINETY FOUR
CREATES A PROGRAM TO REQUIRE
COMPETITION OFF HIGHWAY
VEHICLES TO BE REGISTERED IN
ORDER TO WRITE ON PUBLIC LANDS
IN CALIFORNIA ASSEMBLY MEMBER
IT'S MADE A SIMPLE CHANGE IN
DELAYING THE IMPLEMENTATION
TO TWENTY TWENTY SEVEN AT THE
REQUEST OF DMV THIS MEASURE
HAS HAD NO REGISTRADAS ISSHIN
AND HAS IT WIDE TO MARTYRS WIDE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN FACT I
WANT TO THANK ALL OF YOU FOR
VOTING I ON THIS BILL IN MAY
WHEN IT WAS ON CONSENT I ALSO
WANT TO FURTHER THANK THE
CHAIRS OF THE COMMITTEES THAT
THIS BILL HAS SEEN THE CHAIRS
OF TRANSPORTATION NATURAL
RESOURCES AQ AND A PROBES AND
ALL OF THEIR STAFFS THEY'VE
BEEN VERY INSTRUMENTAL IN
HELPING TO CRAFT THIS BILL IT'S
ALSO BEEN A TO S.
SENATE TEAM SPORT PROJECT I
WANT TO THANK MY CO CHAIRS
ARCHULETA HUESO HER TADO RUBIO
WILK AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER GRAY
MEMBERS THANK YOU ALL VERY
MUCH FOR THIS VERY IMPORTANT
BILL I THANK YOU FOR YOUR
SUPPORT AND ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE ASSEMBLY CONCURRENCE THANK
YOU CENTER JONES MEMBERS THIS
IS QUALIFIES OURS DISCUSSION
DEBATE SEEN HERNANDEZ QUALIFIES
FOR A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE HIGHS FORTY
YES SEVENTH ON THE FLOOR EYES
FORTY NO ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES US SENATOR JONES YOUR
BACK UP WITH FILE ITEM TWENTY
MINUTES SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TEN TWENTY FOUR
BY SENATOR JONES AN ACT
RELATING TO PROFESSIONAL
FIDUCIARIES CENTER JONES THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
THIS BILL ESTABLISHES A
PROCESS FOR COURTS TO APPOINT
A PROFESSIONAL FIDUCIARY
PRACTICE ADMINISTRATOR TO
SERVE AS TEMPORARY SUCCESSOR
WHEN A LICENSED PROFESSIONAL
FIDUCIARY BECOMES INCAPACITATED
OR DIES IN CREATES MULTIPLE
VACANCIES I ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE ON ASSEMBLY CONCURRENCE
THANK YOU CENTER JONES MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING THEN THIS ALSO
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE HIGHS
FORTY ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING TO FILE ITEM TWENTY TWO
CENTER BECKER BUT I'M SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL ELEVEN
FIFTY EIGHT BY SENATOR BAKER
AN ACT RELATING TO ELECTRICITY
CENTER BAKER I THANK YOU MADAM
CHAIR BUT THIS IS A LIVE FIFTY
EIGHT YOU REMEMBER THIS IS OUR
A WONKY BILL WILL HAVE A HUGE
IMPACT ON OUR WAY TO TWENTY
FOUR SEVEN CLEAN ENERGY BY
HAVING HOURLY ACCOUNTING SO
WE CAN TRACK IT FOR MEETING
OUR EACH LOAD SERVING ENTITIES
MEETING IS GHG TARGETS THE
CHANGES DO A FEW THINGS ONE
THE MORE DISCRETION TO SEE
SEATED FROM THE DETAILS FOR HOW
LECTURES THE SUPPLIER SUPPLIED
EVENTUALITIES REPORTED TO GIVE
CREDIT FOR THE GHG EMISSIONS
ARE AVOIDED WHEN ELECTRICITY
SUPPLIER PRICE MORE CLEAN
ENERGY TO THE GRID AND THEY
NEED THEMSELVES DURING OUR
EXAMS FOR A SMALL SUPPLIERS
A CLEAR PRICE IS NOT THE
INTENDED THIS BILL TO CREATE
A NEW PROCUREMENT OBLIGATION
FOR ELECTRICITY SUPPLIERS I
ALSO ADDRESSES CHAPTER NOT
ISSUES AMONG OTHER CHANGES I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER BAKER
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN OUR TWO OTHER AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES NOPE BAKER
HI FORTUS NO BRADFORD I HAVE A
OTHER I CORTES E.
I.
TALLY NO DODD I TORONTO I
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG AYE
WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE JONES NO
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE LEYVA
AYE FROM AMONG I MCGUIRE I FOR
ONE DOES NOPE MANY AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN A CHOI BOGUE NO PAN
I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
AYE SKINNER I STERN AYE AMBERG
HI WHITE HOUSE YOU AYE WIENER
AYE WILK PLEASE WELCOME NOW
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN NIELSEN IS THIRTY KNOWS
EIGHT THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM TWENTY THREE SENATOR
HUESO MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL TWELVE OH
EIGHT BY SENATOR WESSON AN ACT
RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES
CENTER HUESO THANK YOU IN
A PRISON SENATORS SB TWELVE
WEEKS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
THIS IS A BILL THAT INTENDS
TO HELP THE MOST VULNERABLE
RESIDENTS BY SUPPORTING THE
DEVELOPMENT OF A STREAMLINED
UNIVERSAL APPLICATION PROCESS
FOR THE LOW INCOME ASSISTANCE
PROGRAMS THAT ARE OVERSEEN
BY THE CPUC OF ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS REQUIRE THE CPUC
IS LOW INCOME OVERSIGHT BOARD
TO DEVELOP A REPORT BY JUNE
THIRTIETH TWENTY TWENTY THREE
THAT PROVIDES RECOMMENDATIONS
TO THE LEGISLATURE REGARDING
THE OPPORTUNITIES TO UTILIZE
A THIRD PARTY ELIGIBILITY
VERIFICATION SYSTEM SUCH AS
THE ONE USED FOR THE LIFELINE
PHONE SERVICE I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE TODAY
ON THIS BILL THE SENATE HUESO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
IS QUALIFIED FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE
YEAH
IT WAS ON THE FLOOR EYES FORTY
NO ZERO MEASURE PASSES AT THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM TWENTY FOUR CENTER
-- BURKE MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
THIRTY EIGHT BY SENATOR UMBERG
AND ASKED FOR THE NEW COURTS
CENTER AMONG THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS OF HERE
FOR CONCURRENCE IS S.
B.
THIRTEEN THIRTY EIGHT CHARLIE
AUTHORED BY SENATOR EGGMAN
AND ME IT'S THE GOVERNORS CARE
COURT LEGISLATION THIS IS AN
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT INITIATIVE
TO ENSURE THAT CALIFORNIA
FOCUSES UPON THOSE WHO ARE
CHRONICALLY HOMELESS THOSE WITH
SCHIZOPHRENIA SCHIZOPHRENIA
LIKE CONDITIONS WE PROVIDE
THE SUPPORT SYSTEM THE
STABILIZATION SO THAT THEY CAN
GET BETTER SO THEY CAN RETURN
TO BEING PRODUCTIVE CITIZENS
IT'S FOCUSED UPON THOSE WHO
ARE AS I SAID THOSE WHO ARE
FLICKED WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA
SKITS FOR ANY LIKE CONDITIONS
MAYBE THERE'S ONLY TWELVE
THOUSAND OF THOSE FOLKS THAT
WERE FOCUSED FUND BUT THERE ARE
THOUSANDS UPON THOUSANDS WHO
ARE THE LOVED ONES THE FAMILY
MEMBERS WHO CARE AND CARE FOR
THOSE INDIVIDUALS THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE ARE QUITE
EXTENSIVE AND I REVIEW A FEW
OF THEM -- IMPORTANTLY THE BILL
IT'S IMPLEMENTATION IS PHASE SO
THE TOWNIES CARE AND BASICALLY
DEVELOP AND TO BE ABLE TO
EXECUTE ON THAT INFRASTRUCTURE
IT SPECIFIES THE COUNTIES
IN THE FIRST COHORT IT MAKES
CLEAR THAT FAMILY PRACTITIONERS
ARE PETITIONERS HAVE A ROLE
IN THE INITIAL HEARING ON
THE MERITS OF REVAMPS THE
SUPPORTER ROLE -- EXISTENCE
TIME FRAMES FOR INVESTIGATION
OF VALUATION CLARIFIES THAT MH
AS A FUNDS CAN BE UTILIZED FOR
CARE COURTS IT PROVIDES MORE
ASSURANCES FOR HOUSING FUNDING
AN OPPORTUNITY AND IT ALSO IT
IT PROVIDES FROM MY PERSPECTIVE
IMPORTANTLY TRAINING FOR JUDGES
THERE ARE SEVERAL POINTS THAT
ARE REALLY IMPORTANT ONE IS
STABILIZATION TENS OF HOUSING
ALSO IN TERMS OF CREATING THE
REQUISITE NUMBER OF BEHAVIORAL
HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS AND
MAKING SURE THAT THE JUDGES
WHO ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE
EXECUTION IMPLEMENTATION IN
THE ACCOUNTABILITY ARE PROPERLY
TRAINED AND AND HAVE THE
REQUISITE -- INTEREST IN IN
BEING CARE COURT JUDGES WITH
THAT -- I ASKED FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR UMBERG
SENATOR EGGMAN THANK YOU VERY
BUT SHERMAN PRESIDENT MEMBERS
I'D JUST ONE UP JUST TO BE ABLE
TO STAND AND SAY THANK CENTER
-- BURKE FOR HIS LEADERSHIP
TO THANK THE GOVERNOR AND MOST
PACIFIC THE DOCTOR GALLEY I
THINK WAS REALLY LEANED INTO
THIS I WE HAVE A LOT OF WORK TO
DO -- AND THIS IS THIS IS A A
NEW GOOD BEGINNING A NEW PATH
FORWARD TO BE ABLE TO SERVE
-- SOME OF THE MOST VULNERABLE
CALIFORNIANS AND AND I JUST
WANT TO DRESS PEOPLE TALKED A
LOT ABOUT YOU KNOW ABOUT RACIAL
DISPARITIES -- THIS IS MOVING
PEOPLE TO THE FRONT OF THE LINE
VERSES THOSE MOST HARD TO TREAT
ARE NEGLECTED AND AT THE BACK
OF THE LINE AND NEVER EVEN GET
IN THE LINE -- SO THIS REALLY
WILL PRIORITIZE BEING ABLE TO
PROVIDE THAT KIND OF WRAPAROUND
CARE AND SUPPORT OF CARE --
THAT PEOPLE DESPERATELY NEED
AND THEN I OUR OUR SOCIETY
NEEDS -- -- WE LOOK BACK IN
TIME I SAW SOMEBODY THAT WAS
OPPOSE THE BILL UNTIL WE LOOK
BACK INTO ME SO WHY DON'T WE
STOP THAT IN TWENTY YEARS A
LOOK BACK AND MY RESPONSIBLE
WHAT WE LOOK BACK IN TWENTY
YEARS AND SAY WHY DON'T WE DO
MORE WHY DON'T WE DO SOMETHING
LIKE THE SOONER WE HAVE A
CRISIS AND EVERYBODY KNOWS
IT IS NO SECRET FROM ANYBODY
AND THIS IS YET ONE MORE WAY
TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS IT --
WITH TRUE PROFESSIONALS AND
EVERYBODY ENGAGED AT THE TABLE
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
EGGMAN SENATOR JONES THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
I ALSO RISE IN SUPPORT OF
SB THIRTEEN THIRTY EIGHT AND
-- YOU KNOW IT IT'S IT'S NOT
HUMANE TO CONTINUE LETTING
PEOPLE LIVE ON THE STREETS
OR ON THE FREEWAY OFF RAMPS
ARE IN OUR PUBLIC PARKS IT'S
NOT FAIR TO NEIGHBORS SMALL
BUSINESSES OUR SCHOOLS HAVE
TENTS AND THEIR FRONT DOORS OR
THE WALKWAYS IT'S NOT SAFE TO
HAVE TEN CAMPAIGNS ENCAMPMENTS
RIGHT NEXT TO THE HIGHWAYS
SIDEWALKS BIKE LANES PARKS
SCHOOLS OR DAY CARE CENTERS FOR
TOO LONG THE STATE HAS PRETTY
MUCH JUST THROWN BIG BOX AT THE
HOMELESS PROGRAM PROBLEM WITH
NO COURSE SPENT A CORRESPONDING
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR RESULTS THIS
MEASURE I BELIEVE IS THE FIRST
TRULY BIPARTISAN ATTEMPT TO
COMPASSIONATE CLEAR HOMELESS
ENCAMPMENTS OFF OUR STREETS
SIDEWALKS AND HIGHWAYS TO
ASSESS THE HEALTH BEHAVIOR AND
NEEDS OF HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS
AND PUT TOGETHER AN ACTUAL PLAN
TO STOP THE DOWNWARD DOWNWARD
SPIRAL THAT MANY HOMELESS
INDIVIDUALS HAVE SO LONG BEEN
ON THIS IS A HUMANE FAIR AND
SAFE APPROACH TO TACKLING THE
HOMELESS PROBLEM PROBLEM HERE
IN OUR STATE AND I ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER JONES
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS -- WOULD YOU
LIKE TO CLOSE CENTER OF BURKE
THANK YOU JUST URGENT I WROTE
THANK YOU SIR THIS QUALIFIES
FOR A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE IS FORTY
NINE ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MOVING TO FILE ITEM TWENTY
FIVE SENATORS ALONE MA'AM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL THIRTEEN EIGHTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR LIMÓN AND AFTER LEADING
TO STATE GOVERNMENT CERTAINLY
WON'T THINK THANK YOU MA'AM A
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS SB THIRTY
EIGHT THIRTEEN EIGHTY SEVEN
IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE AND IT
DEALS WITH GOVERNOR'S BOARDS
AND COMMISSIONS I RESPECTFULLY
IF A NAY VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
LIMÓN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I HAVE I
GOTTEN AYE CORTESE AYE TALLY
DOT I'D DORADO AYE EGGMAN AYE
GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG I PUESTO AYE
FURTADO AYE JONES I KAMLAGER
AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE
FOR THE MONTH HI MCGUIRE HI
MELENDEZ NOPE MANY I NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- CHOI BOGUE
PAN I PORTANTINO I'VE ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
AYE AMBERG AYE BY KASKI I'VE
WIENER I WILK HI PLEASE MEMBERS
ALLEN HI BATES DALY FIVE THIRTY
THREE NEWS FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
TWENTY SIX SENDER JONES MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE BY
CENTER JONES AN ACT RELATING
TO HOMELESSNESS CENTER JONES
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SB
FOURTEEN TWENTY ONE IMPROVES
THE COUNCIL'S PERSPECTIVE BY
ADDING A CURRENT OR FORMALLY
HOMELESS INDIVIDUAL WITH A
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITY TO THE
CALIFORNIA INTERAGENCY COUNCIL
ON HOMELESSNESS ADVISORY
COMMITTEE I ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER JONES
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
THIS QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL IS THERE ANY
OBJECTION SEEING AND HEARING
NONE IS FORTY ZERO ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM TWENTY SEVEN SENATOR STERN
AND I'M SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FORTY
SIX BY SENATOR STERN AN ACT
RELATING TO BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
CENTER CERTAIN THANK ABOUT
PRESIDENT -- MEMBERS WE JUST
VOTED ON UNANIMOUSLY FOR -- THE
CARE COURTS PROPOSAL -- BUT THE
OVERWHELMING THE OVERWHELMING
FEEDBACK WE RECEIVED THROUGHOUT
THE SESSION FROM BOTH SIDES
OF THE AISLE IS THAT WITHOUT
SOME GUARANTEE THAT THERE
WILL BE HOUSING AND TREATMENT
TO GO ALONG WITH THIS CARE
COURTS FRAMEWORK IS NOT GOING
TO WORK WHERE THAT HOUSING
AND TREATMENT COMES FROM AND
WHO PAYS IS A MATTER OF SOME
CONTROVERSY I COUNTIES DOING
ENOUGH WE THINK THEY CAN DO
MORE THE STATE DOING ENOUGH WE
THINK THEY CAN DO MORE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT CERTAINLY HAS A ROLE
TO PLAY HERE TOO WHETHER IT'S
MEDICARE OUR REFORM OUR MEETING
YOU MENTAL HEALTH STANDARDS
THIS BILL WOULD ASK THIS
ADMINISTRATION TO PUSH ITS ROLE
IN THIS PROCESS THROUGH THE
DEPARTMENT HEALTHCARE SERVICES
AND THAT THE LEADERSHIP OF
SECRETARY GOLLY I'M WE THINK
THAT CONSIDERING THAT GUARANTEE
IN THE CONTEXT OF A CARE COURT
IS WHAT'S GOING TO ACTUALLY
BRING PEOPLE IN TO THE PROCESS
AND MAKE THEM WANT TO SUBJECT
THEMSELVES TO THAT TREATMENT
SO YOU'RE NOT JUST RECYCLED
THROUGH THE SYSTEM OVER AND
OVER AND OVER AGAIN THAT'S
WHAT'S COSTING OUR GOVERNMENT
MONEY ONLY FIFTY ONE FIFTY
SOMEBODY AND PUT THEM BACK
ON THE STREET WHEN SOMEONE'S
INCARCERATED WHO HAS ACUTE
PSYCHOTIC DISORDERS AND THEN
THEY'RE STUCK IN THE A SYSTEM
AND THEN THEY'RE SENT BACK TO
THE STREET THEY NEVER END UP IN
THAT TREATMENT WE ARE KICKING
THE CAN DOWN THE ROAD UNLESS WE
STEP UP AND SEND A SIGNAL AND
I THINK THIS BILL WILL DO THAT
SO TO ME THIS IS A CRITICAL
COROLLARY TO VOTE WE JUST TOOK
AND I HOPE -- HOPE WE CAN WE
CAN ACHIEVE THIS RESULT BECAUSE
EVERYONE SHOULD HAVE A RIGHT
TO MENTAL HEALTH CARE THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA RESPECTFULLY ASK
RIVAL THANK YOU SENATOR MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEN
HEARING NONE MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
BAKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
AYE COMPARING AYE CRITICIZING
AYE TALLY DODD I TO RUSSELL HI
EGGMAN FIVE GLAZER HI GONZALEZ
I GROWTH HERTZBERG WESSEL
I HER DAUGHTER I JONES NO
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE FLAVOR
AYE THURMOND I REQUIRE RIGHT
I MELENDEZ NO MAN HI NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NIELSEN NO WHICH
PROVOKE PAN AYE PORTANTINO I
ROTH AYE REVEAL AYE SKINNER
I STERN HI NUMBER I THANK
HOUSEKI AYE CLEANER AYE WELL
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
BATES DALY NO GROSS HERTZBERG
A TROUBLED WELL NO BATES NOW
AS THIRTY NO SEVENTY SEVEN
WOMEN'S ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM TWENTY EIGHT CENTER ALAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN EIGHTY
TWO BY SENATOR ALAN AN ACT
RELATING TO BUILDING STANDARDS
CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS THIS
BILL IS AN IMPORTANT PART OF
OUR CLIMATE PACKAGE IT HAS
TO DO WITH TRYING TO INCREASE
ACCESS TO ELECTRIC VEHICLE
CHARGING INFRASTRUCTURE IN NEW
MULTI FAMILY DWELLING UNITS
THAT ARE BUILT THE SENTIMENTS
INDICATE THAT THE C.
A.
C.
D.
MAY PROPOSES CENTERS NOT
SHALL PROPOSE -- SO IT MAKES
IT PERMISSIVE OF THE GRESTY
CD I WOULD ALSO ALLOW FOR
POSSIBLE LIMITED EXCEPTIONS
FOR CIRCUMSTANCE THE CAUSE
UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP -- AS
THEY SAY -- FOR US TO MAKE
OUR THE ROLL OUT OF THE VIS
POSSIBLE WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO
EXPAND ACCESS TO CHARGING THAT
INCLUDES AN EQUITY LENS WHICH
INVOLVES MAKING SURE THAT FOLKS
LIVE IN MULTI FAMILY UNITS ARE
ABLE TO BETTER ACCESS CHARGING
IN THEIR GARAGES AND WITHOUT
OUR SUCCESSFUL ABOUT THANK YOU
SENATOR ALAN CENTER LAYERED ON
THE AMENDMENTS THANK YOU VERY
MUCH MADAM PRESIDENT I JUST
WANT TO NOTE THAT THERE ARE
ELEVEN BILLS FROM THE SENATE
CLIMATE WORKING GROUP MOVING
HERE AT THE END OF SESSION
INSISTS THIS HOPEFULLY IN A
MOMENT WILL BE THE TENTH THAT
WE SEND TO THE GOVERNOR OF
THOSE ELEVEN AND THE IMPORTANT
THING IS A AND IT'S REFLECTED
BY THE AMENDMENTS IS THAT
EQUITY WAS AN IMPORTANT PIECE
OF BALANCING EVERYTHING OUT AND
MAKING SURE ELECTRIC VEHICLES
ARE ASSESSABLE TO ANYBODY IN A
MULTI FAMILY DWELLING UNIT IS A
KEY PART OF THAT BECAUSE THEIR
ELECTRICITY ISLANDS AND ISLANDS
THAT MAKE IT HARDER FOR US TO
MOVE TO ELECTRIC CARS IN THE
SENATE THIS BILL WILL ADDRESS
THAT I'M HAPPY TO SUPPORT THE
CONCURRENCE IN THE AMENDMENTS
THANK YOU CENTER WHERE MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE ADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES NOPE BAKER I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD CABALLERO AYE
CORTESE AYE TALLY NOPE DODD
AYE TERASA AYE EGGMAN AYE
GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO
HERTZBERG WESSEL I HER TADO I
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE FLAVOR HI LIMÓN I HAVE FIRE
HI MELENDEZ NOPE MEN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- CHOI BOGUE
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH
AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN
AYE AMBERG AYE FORECASTING
AYE WIENER WIENER AYE WILK
NO AND PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BRADFORD I HERTZBERG
HI FIVE THIRTY ONE NEWS NINE
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM TWENTY
NINE DECEMBER CABALLERO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOURTEEN NINETY SIX BY THE
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE
AND FINANCE AND ACTIVATING
TO TAXATION SENDER CABALLERO
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SB
FOURTEEN NINETY SIX IS THE
SENATE GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
COMMITTEES ANNUAL TECHNICAL TAX
OMNIBUS BILL AND IS BACK FOR
CONCURRENCE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
FOR TECHNICAL IN NATURE THE
MEASURE HAS NO OPPOSITION
AND JOY ENJOYS UNANIMOUS
SUPPORT ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS THANK YOU CENTER
CABALLERO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE MEMBERS THIS IS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS
FORTY NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMONS ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS WERE GOING BACK IN
THE FILE TO FILE ITEM THIRTEEN
CENTER LEYVA WILL BE PRESENTING
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FIVE TWENTY THREE BY
SENATOR LEYVA AN ACT RELATING
TO REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CENTER
LABOR YOU'RE RECOGNIZED THANK
YOU MR PRESIDENT GOOD AFTERNOON
MEMBERS SB FIVE TWENTY THROUGH
THREE THE CONTRACEPTIVE
EQUITY ACT OF TWENTY TWENTY
TWO IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
FROM THE ASSEMBLY AND I ASKED
FOR AN AYE VOTE MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
ITEM ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES BAKER I PORCHES NO
BRADFORD HI BYRON HIGH COURT
HAS HE HI TALLY NO DODD AYE
TERRAZZO AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
AYE GONZALEZ HIGH GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG I REQUEST
I HER TADO HI JONES NO
KAMLAGER I FLARED FIVE LEYVA
LEYVA FIVE MONTHS I'VE MCGUIRE
AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN
HI NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED NO PAN
AYE PORTANTINO I'VE ROTH FIVE
REVIEW AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
AYE AMBERG AYE FORECASTING AYE
WIENER AYE WILK NO CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS PLEASE BATES
NOW IS THIRTY ONE IT KNOWS NINE
IN THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
WE'RE CONTINUING BACKWARDS IN
THE FILE TO FILE ITEM SEVEN
WE ARE GOING TO BE TAKING UP
SB SIX SEVENTY NINE BY SENATOR
COM LONGER CENTER KUMAR IS
READY SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL SIX SEVENTY NINE BY
SENATOR KAMLAGER AN ACT RELATED
HOUSING CENTER CALORIES GOT THE
FLOOR THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
I AM PLEASED TO PRESENT SB
SIX SEVEN NINE WHICH WILL
CREATE THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SOLUTIONS
AGENCY ALSO KNOWN AS LA CASA I
WANT TO FIRST THANK THE P.
T.
THE MAJORITY LEADER THE
MAJORITY LEADER EMERITUS MY
STAFF BALK HE'S AYE ONE AND
THE HUNDREDS OF ADVOCATES
WHO WORK TIRELESSLY ON THIS
BILL THIS AGENCY REPRESENTS A
SINGLE ACCOUNTABLE INDEPENDENT
APPROACH TO HOUSING FOR LOS
ANGELES COUNTY IT WILL SUPPORT
LOW INCOME RENTERS -- OF
HOUSING THAT IS AFFORDABLE AND
INNOVATE NEW WAYS TO CREATE
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN EVERY
COMMUNITY BECAUSE TOO MANY
PEOPLE ARE BEING PUSHED OUT AND
LEFT BEHIND WE HAVE SPENT THE
LAST YEAR BUILDING CONSENSUS
AND SUPPORT FOR THIS PROPOSAL
AT THE LOCAL LEVEL BECAUSE
WE WERE LED BY LOCALS AND NOT
JUST BY SACRAMENTO AND AS A
RESULT THIS BILL IS STRONGER
THAN WHERE WE STARTED WE WERE
MOTIVATED TO KEEP WORKING EVEN
AFTER THE SETBACK OF LAST YEAR
AND HAVING THIS BILL STALLED
BECAUSE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
IS THE LARGEST COUNTY IN THE
NATION IN THE NATION AND RANKS
LAST IN THE NATION AND HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY OVERCROWDING
AND UNSHELTERED HOMELESSNESS
IT RANKS LAST MORE THAN HALF
OF THE PEOPLE IN LOS ANGELES
COUNTY ARE RENT BURDENED MORE
THAN HALF OF THE SINGLE WOMEN
IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY ARE RENT
BURDENED THE COST OF HOUSING
IS CRASHING AND TODAY'S VOTE IS
ABOUT REDUCING THAT BURDEN IT
IS ABOUT HELPING FAMILIES SPEND
THEIR PRECIOUS DOLLARS ON THEIR
CHILDREN NOT ON THEIR RENT I
AM SO PROUD TO BE PART OF THE
LOS ANGELES COUNTY DELEGATION
WHICH HAS BEEN WORKING HARD TO
FIND SOLUTIONS TO OUR CRISIS
THIS IS ONE OF THOSE SOLUTIONS
AND IT IS WHY NO MEMBER OF THE
LOS ANGELES COUNTY DELEGATION
VOTED AGAINST THE BILL IN THE
ASSEMBLY I'D LIKE TO ADDRESS
SOME OF THE MISCONCEPTIONS
AND CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN
RAISED ABOUT THIS BILL AND TO
CLEAR THEM UP THE BEAUTY AND
THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS IS THAT
EVERYONE IS IN IT TOGETHER THAT
IS WHY OPTING IN WAS NEVER AN
OPTION THE POWER OF SOLUTION
AND ACCOUNTABILITY COME
FROM EVERYONE PARTICIPATING
SAN GABRIEL VALLEY ASKED FOR
SOME SIGNIFICANT AMENDMENTS
WHICH WE WORKED HARD ON WHICH
INCLUDE ENSURING THAT THE SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY HOUSING TRUST
HAS A GUARANTEED AMOUNT OF
ANNUAL FUNDING THAT IT CAN
SELF ADMINISTER THAT IS IN THE
BILL THE LEGISLATION APPROVED
BY THE SENATE LAST YEAR HAD
TWO SEATS FOR THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY SUBREGION AND ONE SEAT
EACH FOUR OTHER BIG SUBREGIONS
GATEWAY CITIES SOUTH BAY CITIES
AND SAN FERNANDO PLUS THE NORTH
VALLEY WE ACTUALLY WORKED TO
KEEP THIS BREAKDOWN IN THE
ASSEMBLY WE WERE LED BY THAT
BUT IT BECAME CLEAR THAT THERE
WAS NOT SIGNIFICANT SUPPORT
FROM THE ASSEMBLY OR FRANKLY
FROM THE LOCALS AND THE REST OF
THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY CITIES
THE SOLUTION NEGOTIATED OVER
THE LAST TWELVE MONTHS IN LOS
ANGELES BY CITIES AND BY COUNTY
REPRESENTATIVES AND WHICH
IS IN THE CURRENT BILL WAS
TO ALLOCATE ONE C.
PER REGION PLUS AN ADDITIONAL
AT LARGE SEAT THAT ROTATES
BETWEEN THE REGION'S EVERY
FOUR YEARS WE ALSO ADDED
AN ADDITIONAL AT LARGE SEAT
FOR CITY'S UNDER ONE HUNDRED
THOUSAND PEOPLE AND WHICH ARE
IN THE TOP HALF OF HOUSING
BURDEN WITH THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY HAVING THE SEAT FIRST
FOR FOUR YEARS AS STIPULATED
IN THE LETTER TO THE JOURNAL
THIS IS A GOOD FAIR SOLUTION
AND YES IT REQUIRES COMPROMISE
THAT IS CONCURRENT IT IS ALSO
ABOUT FAIRNESS ESPECIALLY IN
A COUNTY THAT HOUSES MILLIONS
OF PEOPLE AND IS BUCKLING
UNDER THE CRITIQUE OF BEING
SEGREGATED IN COHERENT AND
OF NOT WORKING TOGETHER TO
ADDRESS OUR HOUSING CRISIS
THIS BILL IS A STRONG FAIR
COMPROMISE SUPPORTED ACROSS THE
COUNTY AT AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
THERE BEEN CLAIMS THAT
I COMMITTED A JAILBREAK
SO YOU KNOW I'M A BLACK WOMAN
AND JAILBREAK IN BLACK WOMAN
DO NOT GO TOGETHER THIS BILL
STALLED IN THE ASSEMBLY LIKE
SO MANY OTHER HOUSING BILLS AND
ONCE IT GARNERED THE SUPPORT
THAT IT NEEDED OVER THERE IT
WENT TO THE FLOOR AND CAME
HERE AND UNDERWENT THE NORMAL
PROCESS THROUGH WHICH BILLS
ARE CONSIDERED AND REFERRED
THERE HAVE BEEN SUGGESTIONS
THAT THIS WAIT ANOTHER YEAR
WE CAN'T PLANT THIS ANOTHER
YEAR TWENTY TWENTY THREE
IS THE YEAR TO CREATE THE
AGENCY'S STRATEGIC BUSINESS
PLAN AND DRAFT THE BALLOT
MEASURE TWENTY TWENTY FOURS
WHEN SIGNATURES ARE GATHERED
WAITING KILLS THE ABILITY TO
PREPARE FOR THE BALLOT YEAR
JUST LIKE WAITING AND HAVING
IT STALLED OUT LAST YEAR
STALLED THIS EFFORT TO HAVE
THAT HAPPEN IN TWENTY TWENTY TO
IT IS NOT EVERY DAY THAT
WE SEE A COALITION OF LABOR
SMALL CITIES AND LARGE CITIES
THE COUNTY HOUSING JUSTICE
ADVOCATE BUSINESSES ALL COMING
TOGETHER TO SAY YES BUT TODAY
IS THAT DAY I KNOW THERE'VE
ALSO BEEN QUESTIONS RAISED
ABOUT MY INTEGRITY AND THAT'S
BEEN CALLED INTO QUESTION
AND I'M SORRY THAT THERE ARE
SOME PEOPLE THAT ARE UNHAPPY
ESPECIALLY AFTER ALL OF THE
COLLABORATIVE WORK THAT HAS
BEEN DONE LED BY LOCALS AND
QUITE FRANKLY INFORMED BY
LOCALS AND FACILITATED BY THE
CHAIR OF THE LOS ANGELES BOARD
OF SUPERVISORS SUPERVISOR HOLLY
MITCHELL WHO FACILITATED THESE
DISCUSSIONS OVER THE COURSE
OF THIS YEAR HER OFFICE AND
OTHER OFFICES AT THE BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS ACTIVELY ENGAGED
BUILDING CONSENSUS ANSWERING
QUESTIONS AND BEING LED
BY FAIRNESS SO I WOULD ASK
THAT WE REFOCUS BACK TO THE
INTEGRITY OF THE PEOPLE WHO
NEED THIS BILL WHO ARE RENT
BURDENED WHO SUFFER FROM NOT
HAVING ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE
HOUSING ALL WITHIN LOS ANGELES
COUNTY WHO ARE STRUGGLING
AND WHO ARE ASKING US TO BE
RIGHTEOUS IN PUTTING THEM FIRST
I APPRECIATE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
HOLDEN WHO CHAIRS THE ASSEMBLY
APPROPRIATIONS AND REPRESENTS
A PORTION OF THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY AND HELP GET IT OVER
TO THE SENATE I APPRECIATE
AND THANK MY SEVEN SENATE
COLLEAGUES FROM LOS ANGELES
COUNTY WHO HAVE BEEN STRONG CO
AUTHORS I ONCE AGAIN WANT TO
APPRECIATE SUPERVISOR MITCHELL
WHO WAS HERE TODAY WHO NOT
ONLY SUPPORTS THIS BILL BUT WAS
VERY INVOLVED IN NEGOTIATING
THE GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE OF IT
AND I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE
THANK YOU SENATOR KAMLAGER
SENATOR GONZALEZ THANK YOU
MR PRESIDENT -- AND MEMBERS
I RAISES A PROUD CO AUTHOR
OF SB SIX SEVENTY NINE WHICH
WILL CREATE AS MENTIONED BY
MAY THE GOOD SENATOR FROM LOS
ANGELES MY COLLEAGUE WHICH
PROVIDES CRITICAL RESOURCES --
FOR CITIES ACROSS L.
A.
COUNTY I REPRESENT LONG BEACH
IN SOUTHEAST LOS ANGELES AND
THIS BILL HAS BEEN SUPPORTED BY
THEM AS WELL BOTH A LARGE CITY
IN A SMALLER SMALLER CITIES
IF CURRENT HOUSING PRODUCTION
RATES CONTINUE WOULD CREATE
ONLY THIRTY THOUSAND UNITS OF
AFFORDABLE TO LOW INCOME AND
VERY LOW INCOME -- FOR FOR
HOUSEHOLDS IN CALIFORNIA AND
IN IN LOS ANGELES PARTICULARLY
SB SIX SEVENTY NINE TAKES THIS
ISSUE HEAD ON OF COURSE BY
PROVIDING TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
AND CAPACITY FUNDING FOR SMALL
CITIES LIKE THE SOUTH THE
CITIES THAT I REPRESENT AND
TO ALLOW THEM TO UPDATE THEIR
GENERAL PLANS I THINK THE
LATEST AMENDMENTS ARE PRETTY
FAIR THE ENSURE THAT THE FOUR
LARGEST REGIONS IN THE COUNTY
WILL EACH HAVE ONE DEDICATED
SEE AN ADDITIONAL ROTATING AT
LARGE SEAT TO SHARE AND THE
SMALLER CITIES I THINK THAT'S
ANOTHER CREDIBLE -- COMPROMISES
WELL FOR SMALLER CITIES UNDER
ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND POPULATION
WHO ARE PARTICULARLY IMPACTED
BY HOUSING COSTS HAVE A SEAT
AT THE TABLE AS WELL AND I WILL
SAY -- AS THE THE SENATOR FROM
LOS ANGELES MANSION THERE BEEN
HUNDREDS OF HOW THAT HOUSING
ADVOCATES IN THE LARGEST COUNTY
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THAT HAVE COME TOGETHER I HEAR
EVERY DAY ABOUT THIS ISSUE
ON SIX SEVENTY NINE AND HOW
MUCH WE HAVE TO SUPPORT IT WE
CANNOT WAIT ANY LONGER -- AND
SO FOR THAT REASON THE MORE I
WILL CERTAINLY SUPPORT THE BILL
AND I ASK MY COLLEAGUES TO DO
THE SAME THING WE NEED TO LET
HOUSING SOLUTIONS NOW WE CANNOT
WAIT ANY LONGER THANK YOU THANK
YOU CENTER GONZALEZ RUN GO TO
SENATOR CORTESE FOLLOWED BY
SENATOR RUBIO SENATOR CORTEZ
HE YOUR RECOGNIZE THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT AND OPEN COLLEAGUES
ARISES SUPPORTIVE SB SIX
SEVENTY NINE AND RUNNING WHY
-- THE CENTER FROM THE BAY
AREA IS -- RISING TO SPEAK
ON THE BILL THAT'S LARGELY
-- IMPACTING THE COUNTY OF
LOS ANGELES I'LL EXPLAIN THAT
IN JUST A SECOND FIRST AND
FOREMOST SAYS LOS ANGELES GOES
IN TERMS OF HOUSING PRODUCTION
THERE GOES THE REST OF THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND I
WOULD SAY OF THE BAY AREA --
FOLLOWS AS A CLOSE SECOND IF
YOU THE BACKGROUND ANALYSIS
THIS BILL YOU SEE THAT -- OR
TO BE REMINDED FOR MOST OF
YOU BECAUSE MOST OF YOU WERE
HERE I WASN'T BUT IN TWENTY
NINETEEN ASSEMBLY MEMBER CHIU
INTRODUCED A BILL THAT WAS
SIGNED INTO LAW THAT CREATED
-- BAY FIVE OR BOFFA DEPEND
HOW YOU AND PRONOUNCE IT -- THE
BAY AREA HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY
-- IN THAT TO SOME DEGREE HAS
BECOME A TEMPLATE FOR THIS
BILL IN LET ME JUST IF I MAY
READ FROM THE ANALYSIS DIRECTLY
WITHOUT IT ONCE THANK YOU ONE
SENTENCE JUST ONE SENTENCE
SPECIFICALLY THAT BILL PROVIDED
THE ASSOCIATION OF BAY AREA
GOVERNMENTS IN THE METROPOLITAN
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
ACTING AS BAY FOR WITH NEW
TOOLS TO RAISE BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS TO FUND THE PRODUCTION
PRESERVATION AND PROTECTION
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT'S
WHAT'S BEING ATTEMPTED HERE
IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY THAT'S
WHAT WE'VE BEEN FIGHTING SO
FAR HARD FOR OVER THE LAST
RECESSION THE FIRST YEAR THIS
SESSION IN THIS SESSION -- IN
FRANKLY WE'VE BEEN APPLAUDED
FOR MAKING THE DIFFICULT CALLS
IN VOTING ON THE TOUGH BILLS
TO GET HOUSING PRODUCTION
GOING THIS IS AS IMPORTANT AS
ANY OTHER HOUSING PRODUCTION
BILLS FAR AS I'M CONCERNED --
THAT WE'VE TAKEN UP OVER THIS
TWO YEAR SESSION AGAIN WHAT'S
THEN MY PERSPECTIVE IF I MAY
WHERE I WAS WAS NOT HERE BUT I
WAS ON THE MITCHELL BILL MITCH
FONG TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
HAD BEEN SERVING TWO YEARS AS
THE CHAIR OF THEIR TO MORE OF
OUR COLLEAGUES IN THE SENATE
WHO SERVED AND PARTICIPATED
IN THAT PROCESS GOVERNANCE
IS ALWAYS AN ISSUE LET'S FACE
AND WE HAVE TO DO A GOVERNANCE
ISSUES NINETY NINE PERCENT
OF OUR PROBLEMS WOULD GO AWAY
THAT'S ALWAYS AN ISSUE AND
THAT SHOULDN'T HOLD UP A BILL
LIKE THIS BECAUSE THIS BILL IS
ENABLING LEGISLATION AND THAT
HAS TO COME FIRST IF YOU DON'T
ENABLE IF YOU DON'T ENABLE
STANDING UP OF FINANCE HE JUST
SEEM LIKE THIS THE REST OF THE
CONVERSATION CAN HAPPEN NOBODY
CAN DO THE WORK TO GO OUT AND
RAISE REVENUE NO ONE CAN PUT
ANYTHING ON THE BALLOT NOBODY'S
GOING TO EXPEND THE ENERGY WHAT
THEY SAY DOWN THERE LOS ANGELES
IS WHY SHOULD WE DO THAT
WHEN THE LEGISLATURE HASN'T
EVEN GIVEN US IN EVEN THE
LEGISLATION PUT THIS FORWARD
THAT'S WHAT HAPPENED IN THE
BAY AREA AND ONCE WE REALIZED
THAT PEOPLE CAME TOGETHER
AND SAID LET'S SUPPORT THIS
LEGISLATION WE COULD'VE KILLED
AS A BAY AREA LET'S SUPPORT
THIS LEGISLATION -- LET'S
GET THE AUTHORITY TO STAND
UP THIS AGENCY AND THEN WILL
COME TOGETHER LIKE WE ALWAYS
HAVE TO WORK OUT THE FINAL
GOVERNANCE ISSUES -- TO FIGURE
OUT WHO'S GOING TO RUN THE
CAMPAIGNS TO BRING THE REVENUE
IN -- AND AS YOU CAN READ FROM
THE ANALYSIS IN THIS BILL THAT
HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL IF WE CAN
BE SUCCESSFUL IN THE BAY AREA
LOS ANGELES COUNTY CAN BE
SUCCESSFUL WITH THE SAME MODEL
AND I WOULD URGE STRONGLY URGE
AN AYE VOTE ON THIS BILL THANK
YOU SENATOR CORTEZ THE SENATOR
RUBIO THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
I AS A STRONG ADVOCATE FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SOLUTIONS
I RICE WITH HEAVY HARD TO
OPPOSE THIS MEASURE AS AMENDED
IN THE ASSEMBLY WE ALL AGREE
THAT WE NEED HOUSING TO HELP
OUR COMMUNITIES WE ALL AGREE
THAT MORE NEEDS TO BE DONE TO
PROTECT AND CREATE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA IN LOS
ANGELES THAT'S NOT IN QUESTION
TO ADDRESS THE AMENDMENTS AND
HOW THEY IMPACT MY DISTRICT
I PERSONALLY WORK WITH ALL
MY CITIES TO CREATE A SINGLE
VALLEY REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST
SWEAT AND LAST AND FOR YEARS
HAS HELPED CREATE OVER FIVE
HUNDRED AND FIFTY AFFORDABLE
HOUSING UNITS PROVIDED A
HUNDRED AND FIVE BEDS OF
HOMELESS HOUSING HAS COMPLETED
THREE TINY HOME SITES WHERE
THE ON HEALTH GET THREE MEALS
A DAY A WARM BED AND WRAPAROUND
SERVICES SO I UNDERSTAND THAT
IT'S VERY DIFFERENT FROM FOR
EVERYONE ELSE ON THIS FLOOR --
MY COLLEAGUES AND ALLIES AND
LOS ANGELES COUNTY WHO I WORK
CLOSELY WITH RESPECT AND CARE
ABOUT I WAS NOT ORIGINALLY
OPPOSED TO THIS BILL IT WAS A
MATTER OF SITTING DOWN WITH THE
AUTHOR TO DISCUSS HOW THIS BILL
MOVES FORWARD WHILE RESPECTING
THE COMMUNITIES LIKE MINE
THAT ALREADY HAD A SUCCESSFUL
HOUSING TRUST THAT THEY PAID
INTO AND JUST TO BE CLEAR A LOT
OF MY CITIES AND THE CENTRAL
VALLEY HAVE BEEN CALLING ME
ASKING ME NOT TO SUPPORT THIS
BILL INCLUDING MEMBERS OF THE
SINGER VALLEY REGIONAL HOUSING
TRUST AND THE COG WHEN THE BILL
WAS IN TROUBLE AND IT WAS AND
THERE WAS URGENCY BECAUSE THEY
NEEDED TO GET THIS BUILT ON
OUR SIDE ABOUT THE NEED TO WORK
ON THE BALLOT MEASURE WE DID
JUST THAT WE SAT DOWN WITH THE
AUTHOR TO DISCUSS HOW CAN WE
BE SUPPORTIVE HOW DO WE PUT OUR
ENERGY TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS
IS SUCCESSFUL AND WE DID SIT
DOWN AND THERE WAS COMMITMENTS
MADE AND WHAT WE DID TO HELP
EXPEDITE THE BILL DESPITE
MY CONCERNS AND MY DISTRICT
OPPOSITION I PUT MY NAME BEHIND
THAT BASED ON COMMITMENTS THAT
WERE MADE TO ME THAT I CAN
TAKE BACK TO MY COMMUNITY BUT
HERE WE ARE WITH A DIFFERENT
VERSION THAT LEFT THE SENATE
THE EXPLICIT COMMITMENTS TO
ME AND TO THE APPROPRIATIONS
CHAIR TO GET THE BILL OUT TO
HELP MEET THE NOVEMBER BALLOT
WAS THAT IT WOULD NOT MOVE
AND THOSE COMMITMENTS WERE
NOT HONORED AND WHY ARE THESE
COMMITMENTS IMPORTANT TO MY
DISTRICT RESPECTFULLY THE
CENTRAL VALLEY HAS HISTORICALLY
BEEN UNDERSERVED BY COUNTY
WHITE HOUSING POLICIES THIS IS
NOT NEW I WAS A COUNCIL MEMBER
FOR NINE YEARS AND I SAW THAT
HAPPEN WHEN LOS ANGELES COUNTY
PASSED MEASURE H.
TAX THANK TAXED ALL OUR
SMALL CITIES TO RAISE FUNDING
TO ADDRESS HOUSING AND
HOMELESSNESS IT FELT TO DELIVER
ON ITS PROMISE WE'RE STILL HERE
WITH THE SAME ISSUE HOUSING
AND HOMELESSNESS AND THIS IS
WHERE MY REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST
ALONG WITH ARE CALLED AFTER IT
CAME TO BE BECAUSE OUR ISSUES
WERE NOT BEING RESOLVED SO WE
DECIDED THAT WE NEEDED TO TAKE
MATTERS INTO HER OWN HANDS AND
CREATE A HOUSING TRUST THAT
WAS GOING TO HELP US DIRECTLY
AND THIS IS JUST MANY ONE
OF MANY EXAMPLES OF HOW WE
ALWAYS TRY TO HELP L.
A.
COUNTY WE COLLABORATE WE HELP
WE PAY TAXES BUT NOT ALWAYS
DO WE GET WHAT WE DESERVE IN
RETURN OUR REGIONAL HOUSING
TRUST WHICH IS NOW THE TWENTY
TWO CITIES MEMBERS NOT JUST
OF MY CITY TWENTY TWO CITIES
ACROSS FOR SENATE DISTRICTS
IS PART OF THIS COALITION OF
INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE ALREADY
HELPING TO SOLVE THE HOMELESS
CRISIS NO OTHER COMMUNITY
REPRESENTED ON THIS FLOOR SO
I UNDERSTAND HOW ARE FEELING
NO OTHER COMMUNITY ON THIS
FLOOR HOUSE I TRUST THAT
ALREADY BEEN SUCCESSFUL WITHOUT
THE COMMITMENTS MADE TO MY
DISTRICT BY THE AUTHOR TO ME
IN THE APPROPRIATIONS CHAIR TO
HELP THE BILL GET OUT I DON'T
THINK WE WOULD BE HAVING THIS
CONVERSATION MEASURE H.
FAILED TO DELIVER ON ITS
PROMISE THIS HAS THE POTENTIAL
TO FAIL TO DELIVER ON ITS
PROMISE AND I HAVE TO GO
BACK TO MY DISTRICT WHO NEVER
WANTED THIS TO BEGIN WITH WITH
SOME PROMISES I MADE BASED
ON THOSE COMMITMENTS AND I
CANNOT DO THAT I AM CHOOSING
TO STAND WITH THE SAME GIRL
DOLLY MY DISTRICT MY CITIES
OR ADAM MEDIAPOST YES THERE'S
SOME BAD DO YOU WANT IT BUT
THAT'S EVERYONE INDIVIDUALLY
FROM WHAT I HEARD MY DISTRICT
DOESN'T WANT IT AND I'M STILL
HERE WILLING TO BE SUPPORTIVE
BUT I EXPECT COMMITMENTS TO BE
MADE AND KEPT A COMMITMENT IS
A COMMITMENT THERE IS NO SUCH
THING AS A PARTIAL COMMITMENT
HALF A COMMENCEMENT AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK ALL OF YOU
COLLEAGUES FOR AN AYE VOTE
CAN WE RECOGNIZE SENATOR
RUBIO'S MICROPHONE ONE MORE
TIME PLEASE THANK YOU I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE
THANK YOU MEMBERS THANK YOU
SENATOR RUBIO CENTER PORTANTINO
WILL BE FOLLOWED BY SENATOR
BRADFORD CENTER PORTANTINO
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS -- LIKE MY COLLEAGUE
FROM THE SINGER VALLEY I RISE
WITH A HEAVY HEART THIS IS ONLY
THE SECOND TIME IN MY TWELVE
YEARS IN THE LEGISLATURE THAT
I'VE HAD TO RISE ON AN ISSUE IN
THIS VEIN WHEN I WAS A FRESHMAN
ASSEMBLY MEMBER -- THERE WAS
A MORE SEASONED COLLEAGUES
WHO MADE A COMMITMENT DURING
THE COMMITTEE PROCESS AND THEN
DIDN'T KEEP THAT COMMITMENT
I PUT MY MICROPHONE UP WHEN
I WAS IN THE ASSEMBLY AND I
SAID OUR COMMITMENT WAS MADE A
COMMITMENT WASN'T FOLLOWED AND
I ASK THE BODY TO SUPPORT --
THE INTEGRITY OF THE COMMITMENT
AND LO AND BEHOLD ABOUT SEVENTY
FIVE OF THE EIGHTY MEMBERS
SUPPORTED THE PROCESS AND LAID
OFF THE BILL -- WE'RE HERE
TODAY FRANKLY BECAUSE MANY OF
US HELPED GET THIS BILL OUT OF
THIS HOUSE BASED ON A SERIES OF
COMMITMENTS -- IT DID NOT HAVE
A HEARING IN ITS CURRENT FORM
IN THE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BECAUSE OF A PROCEDURAL MATTER
IT WENT TO THE GOVERNMENT AND
FINANCE COMMITTEE AND WE IN THE
APPROPRIATIONS THAT WE DIDN'T
HAVE A CHANCE TO END PUT THE
AMENDMENTS WE SIGNED OFF I
SIGNED OFF ON THOSE AMENDMENTS
WITH THE UNDERSTANDING THAT
THOSE WOULD BE IRON CLAD
COMMITMENTS AND AMENDMENTS
MAY SAY THAT AGAIN WHEN THE
GOVERNOR FINANCE COMMITTEE
CHAIR CAME AND SAID THIS IS
WHAT WE NEEDED TO DO SO WE CAN
GET IT ON THE NOVEMBER BALLOT I
AGREED TO THOSE COMMITMENTS AND
I AGREED TO THOSE AMENDMENTS SO
THIS IS A JAILBREAK FROM THAT
COMMITMENT THIS IS A VIOLATION
OF THAT COMMITMENT THERE CAN
BE NO MISTAKE THERE CAN BE NO
DISAGREEMENT ABOUT THAT THAT
IS THE ONLY REASON WHY THIS
BILL MOVED AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE
I'M RAISING MY MICROPHONE IN
SUPPORT OF MY COLLEAGUE FROM
BALDWIN PARK WHO NEGOTIATED
THOSE AMENDMENTS NOW SUBSEQUENT
TO THAT ORIGINAL COMMITMENT
THERE WERE AT LEAST SIX OTHER
LET ME SAID AGAIN SIX OTHER
TIMES WHERE WE WERE TOLD IN
NO UNCERTAIN TERMS THAT UNLESS
THE BILL REFERRED IT BACK TO
ITS ORIGINAL FORM IT WOULD
NOT EVEN COME UP FOR A VOTE ON
THIS HOUSE IT WOULD NOT EVEN
COME UP FOR A VOTE SO NUMBER
ONE WE ALL SUPPORT THE NEED
FOR HOUSING IN LOS ANGELES
COUNTY WE ALL RALLIED BEHIND
THE NOTION OF PUTTING THIS
ON THE NOVEMBER BALLOT SO WE
COULD HAPPEN THAT IS NO LONGER
GERMANE WE HAVE THE TIME TO
COME BACK IN JANUARY TO CRAFT
SOMETHING THAT WILL BE DOABLE
FOR THE ENTIRE L.
A.
COUNTY AND GET IT ON THE NEXT
BALLOT SO THIS IDEA THAT WE
CAN'T DO THAT THAT'S FALSE
THE IDEA THAT THERE WAS
NO COMMITMENT THAT'S FALSE
THERE WAS SO THE OTHER THING
THAT I WANT TO ADDRESS IS
HOW WE DO WHAT WE DO IS JUST
AS IMPORTANT AS WHAT WE DO
FRANCIS HASSLE BUYING WHO
LEAD THE GIRL SCOUTS ONCE
HER HER LECTURE HEY WE SPEND
MOST OF OUR TIME LEARNING
HOW TO DO THINGS BUT NOT HOW
TO BE THIS IS OUR MOMENT IN
THE STATE SENATE OF HOW TO
BE THIS IS OUR MOMENT IN THE
STATE SENATE TO SAY THERE ARE
NO SMALL COMMITMENTS THERE'S
JUST COMMITMENTS IF WE ALLOW A
PROCESS TO CONTINUE IF WE ALLOW
SOMETHING TO PROGRESS BASED
ON COMMITMENTS THAT ARE NOT
CAPPED THIS INSTITUTION DOESN'T
FUNCTION WE JUST CAME TO A TIME
WHERE WE ALL TALKED WONDERFULLY
ABOUT THE INSTITUTION IN THE
SENATE WE ALL TALKED ABOUT
HOW WE'RE DIFFERENT AND HOW
THE INTEGRITY OF THE HOUSE AND
HOUSE SPECIAL WE ARE WELL IF
DURING THE COMMITTEE PROCESS
WE MAKE COMMITMENTS AND THOSE
COMMITMENTS ARE CAPPED AND
WE STILL SAY IT'S OKAY AND
THAT TAKES A LITTLE BIT OF A
SHINE OFF OF THIS PLACE AND
I'M NOT WILLING TO DO THAT
LET ME SPEAK TO THE JAILBREAK
SITUATION MANY OF YOU HAVE
COME TO ME WHEN APPROPRIATIONS
HAS PUT AMENDMENTS INTO A BILL
THAT YOU MAY NOT OF LIKE AND
YOU'VE COME TO ME AND SAY HEY
CAN YOU AUTHORIZE A JAILBREAK
AND IN ALMOST EVERY SINGLE
INSTANCE I'VE SAID NOW BECAUSE
HOW DO I LOOK YOU IN THE EYE
AND SAY YES AND THEN SAY NO
TO SOMEBODY ELSE HOW DO I
ACCEPT THIS JAILBREAK TODAY
AND THEN TURN AROUND TO ONE
OF MY COLLEAGUES FROM NORTHERN
OR SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA AND SAY
NO TO THEM I HAVE TRIED TO BE
EVEN KEEL AND CONSISTENT IN HOW
WE INSTITUTE THE NORMS IN THE
STANDARDS OF THE APPROPRIATIONS
PROCESS THIS GOES BEYOND THAT
BECAUSE OF THE COMMITMENTS
THAT WERE NEGOTIATED AND
MADE THIS CONSTITUTES A
JAILBREAK FROM WHAT WAS
AGREED TO TO GET IT OUT OF
THE APPROPRIATIONS PROCESS
THIS IS AN EASY HAVING MEMBERS
ON OPPOSITE SIDES OF AN ISSUE
THAT'S NOT EASY THE POLICY
DISCUSSION IT'S LAUDABLE IT'S
IMPORTANT WE NEED IT BUT WE
ALSO NEED TO STAND BEHIND OUR
COMMITMENTS WE ALSO NEED TO
STAND BEHIND WHAT IT MEANS
TO BE ON THIS FOR AND LOOK
SOMEBODY IN THE EYE AND SAY
THIS IS WHAT I'M GONNA DO AND
MANY OF YOU COME TO ME AFTER
COMMITTEE HEARINGS AND SAY
SOMEONE SO MADE A COMMITMENT
SO AND SO MADE A COMMITMENT
TRY TO ENFORCE IT AND I DO
THE BEST I CAN TO DO THAT
IF WE DON'T ENFORCE IT ON
THIS FLOOR AND COLLEAGUES
IF WE ALLOW SIX SEVEN NINE
TO MOVE OFF THIS FLOOR WE
ARE FUNDAMENTALLY ST THAT
COMMITMENTS DON'T MATTER GOING
FORWARD WE ARE FUNDAMENTALLY ST
THAT YOU CAN SAY WHATEVER
YOU WANT TO THAT THE ENDS
JUSTIFY THE MEANS AND THERE'S
A BIBLE CLOSE QUOTE THIS
IS WHAT PROFITS A MAN IF HE
INHERITS THE WHOLE WORLD BUT
LOSES THEIR SOUL IF WE LET
SIX SEVENTY NINE OFFICE FLOOR
WE'RE GOING TO LOSE A LITTLE
PIECE OF PARCEL WE HAVE THE
TIME IN JANUARY I'M COMMITTED
TO WORKING ON THIS ISSUE
TO BRINGING THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY TOGETHER TO BRINGING
THOSE HOUSING TRUST TOGETHER
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE PROGRESS
SOMETHING THAT'S FAIR THAT
BUILDS HOUSING THAT SOLVES THE
PROBLEM WHAT I'M NOT WILLING
TO DO IS SIT QUIETLY WHEN MY
COLLEAGUE FROM THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY NEGOTIATED TO DEALING
GOOD FAITH PUT HER REPUTATION
ON THE LINE HER COMMITMENT
ON THE LINE AND HELPED MOVE
THIS BILL OUT OF THIS HOUSE
I'M NOT WILLING TO LET THAT
GET PUSHED ASIDE I'M NOT
WILLING TO LET THOSE COMMISSION
COMMITMENTS GO BY THE WAYSIDE
THIS IS TOO IMPORTANT NOT TO
DO ACCORDING TO THE STANDARDS
AND PRACTICES OF THIS HOUSE
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOU
ALL TO LAY OFF SB SIX SEVEN
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
CENTER BRADFORD THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT AND I RISE AS CO
AUTHOR IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS MEASURE AND I'M SOMEWHAT
MIFFED THAT DESCRIPTION OF
THIS BEING A JAIL BREAK WHEN
MUCH OF WHAT WE DO THROUGHOUT
MY TWELVE YEARS -- WE CAN
PRETTY MUCH CATEGORIZE TWENTY
PERCENT OF THE STUFF WE DO
AS JOE BREAKS BECAUSE THEY
CHANGED DRASTICALLY FROM THE
ORIGINAL INTENT OF THE BILL
BUT THIS IS HONORING WHAT WAS
DISCUSSED -- THE L.
A.
COUNTY DELEGATION WHEN WE START
TALKING ABOUT HOUSING EARLIER
THIS YEAR AND AS WE ALL KNOW
MUCH OF WHAT WE VOTING FOR
OVER THE NEXT THREE DAYS OR
THE LAST THREE DAYS A LOT HAS
CHANGED A LOT WE HAVEN'T SEEN
IN GREAT DETAIL BUT WE WERE
WILLING TO MOVE FORWARD AND
AND VOTE ON IT -- OUR COLLEAGUE
FROM LA HAS NEGOTIATED IN GOOD
FAITH -- -- WITH GREAT PASSION
FOR TRYING TO COME UP WITH
A MEASURE THAT WORKS IS IT
PERFECT DOES IT SOLVE ALL THE
DETAILS AND CHALLENGES THAT
WE FACE IN HOUSING NO BUT IT'S
A STEP THAT NEEDED IT'S LONG
OVER DUE I'VE BEEN HERE FOR
TWELVE YEARS AND WE HAVE NOT
FIX THE HOUSING CRISIS IT'S
ONLY GOTTEN WORSE AND HERE'S
OPPORTUNITY TO ALLOW THE VOTERS
TO DECIDE TO MOVE FORWARD IN A
MEASURE THAT IS INCLUSIVE THAT
IS THOUGHTFUL AND IT'S NEEDED
AND AGAIN TO DESCRIBE IT AS
A SOME RADICAL YOU KNOW JOE
BREAK IS YOU KNOW I I TOTALLY
DISAGREE AND ALL THE MOMENTS IN
THAT BILL WERE AGREED UPON AND
STRONGLY SUPPORTED BY L.
A.
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
AS WELL AND I'M PRETTY SURE
IF IT WASN'T WE WOULD HEARD
FROM THEM SO IT MAINTAINS
INTEGRITY OF HOW WE STARTED
IT YES SIR SOME CHANGES
HERE BUT I'D STRONGLY SHIPS
PASS FOR I VOTER THANK YOU
SENATOR BRADFORD CENTER EGGMAN
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT AND
MEMBERS I I JUST HAVE I HAVE
AN ACTUAL QUESTION -- I DON'T
HAVE A HOUSING TRUST AND I
DON'T HAVE A DOG IN THIS FIGHT
NECESSARY I'M I'M I'M WEAPONS
DOCUMENT WE HAVE OUR OWN SET
OF CRISES ALL THE TIME BUT DOES
THIS ON OVER TO THE AUTHOR OR
TO THE THE SENATOR FROM SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY BUT IT WILL
WILL THIS THEN SUBSUME THE SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY HOUSING TRUST
OR WILL PEOPLE BE TAXED TWICE
OR NOT CAN YOU DESCRIBE TO ME
HOW THAT WORKS CENTER EGGMAN
WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADDRESS
THAT TO THE AUTHOR YES OUR
CENTER EGGMAN WHICH TAKE OUR
CENTER CALLING WOULD YOU TAKE
A QUESTION CAN I JUST IN MY
CLOTHES THAT I LIKE IT THAT AS
A QUESTION OF THE SENATE FOR
HAVING A DAILY THAT THE SAN
GABRIEL HOUSING AUTHORITY IS
NOT A TAXING AUTHORITY HEY --
AND SO THEY WOULD NOT BE DOUBLE
TAXED THEY HAVE ASKED FOR MONEY
IN THE BUDGET -- AND I BELIEVE
THAT WAS IN THE BUDGET THEY'VE
ALSO BECAUSE OF THEIR REQUEST
-- BEEN GIVEN A CERTAIN SET
ASIDE TO GO SPECIFICALLY TO
THEIR TRUST ADDITIONAL FUNDING
TO HELP THEM SELF ADMINISTER
SO THEY WOULD BE ALLOWED TO
SELF ADMINISTER THEIR TRUST
IS NOT DOESN'T GO AWAY NO
AND IN FACT WE EXPANDED THE
LANGUAGE THROUGH THE COURSE OF
NEGOTIATIONS WITH CITIES ACROSS
THE COUNTY AND THE COUNTY SO
THAT THERE WOULD BE FUNDING SET
ASIDE FOR EACH HOUSING TRUST
THAT IS EITHER IN EXISTENCE
OR THAT CROPS UP SO THAT THEY
WOULD ALSO BE ABLE TO SELF
ADMINISTER THOSE FUNDS THIS
IS ABOUT A HIGH TIDE RISING
ALL BOATS AND COLLECTIVELY IF
THE HALF AND THE WEIGHT OF THE
COUNTY AND ALL OF THE CITIES
THAT REPRESENT THE COUNTY
CAN FINANCE MONEY PRIVATELY
OR PUBLICLY TO ALLOW FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO BE BUILT
BILLIONS MORE MONEY BECAUSE
OF THE SIZE OF THE AUTHORITY
THAT IS FAR GREATER THAN ALL
OF THESE LITTLE CITIES WORKING
HAPHAZARDLY -- INCOHERENTLY
OR DOING ONE OFFS TO TRY TO
RAISE FROM A MUCH SMALLER
TAX BASE BECAUSE WE'VE SEEN
THAT WE'VE SEEN IT HAPPEN
AND IT HASN'T BEEN SUCCESSFUL
OKAY I MEAN IS A LARGE CENTER
EGGMAN YOUR STILL RECOGNIZED
ON THE FLOOR IT'S YOUR YOUR
RECOGNITION YOU MAY CONTINUE
TO ANSWER THANK YOU VERY MUCH
-- SO THAT I MEAN THAT THAT IS
HELPFUL AND AND I UNDERSTAND
THEM THE POINT MORE SO BECAUSE
I I AGAIN I I REPRESENT THE
CITY OF STOCKTON WHICH IS
YOU KNOW THE BIGGEST CITY IN
THREE COUNTIES AROUND US TO
COUNTIES RECOUNTED HELLO --
AND SO IT AYE AYE SO THEN I
UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE THEN FROM
THE PERSPECTIVE OF A PEOPLE
FROM WEAPON OR ESCALON THAT
THEY FEEL LIKE STOCKTON IS
GOING TO GET IT ALL BECAUSE
THEY HAVE THE BIGGEST NEED AND
THE SMALLER CITIES WON'T GET
AS MUCH SO OKAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU CENTER EGGMAN
CENTER PORTANTINO YOUR WEIGHT
WAITING TO BE RECOGNIZED THE
WE HAVEN'T CYCLED THROUGH
EVERYBODY THAT SPOKEN ONCE
ALREADY SO -- ACCORDING TO
THE SENATE -- TRADITIONS WILL
RECOGNIZE YOU SECOND TIME AFTER
BUT HE'S BEEN RECOGNIZED FOR
THE FIRST TIME SENATOR DRAWS ON
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT L.
A.
COUNTY IS NOT ONLY THE LARGEST
COUNTY IN THE COUNTRY L.
A.
COUNTY IS LARGER THAN
FORTY ONE STATE K.
LARGER THAN FORTY ONE STATES
IN ORDER FOR US TO DEAL WITH
THE HOUSING ISSUES IS NO
WAY OF DOING THAT WITHOUT A
CENTRALIZED COORDINATED SMART
INNOVATIVE BODY REPRESENTING
THE VARIOUS PARTS OF THAT
COUNTY I I DON'T SEE ANY
OTHER WAY OF ADDRESSING THAT
WE HAVE HOUSING CRISIS ISSUES
ACROSS THE COUNTY THERE IS
NOT A SINGLE AREA MALL MAYBE
BEVERLY HILLS I DON'T KNOW OF
SAN MARINO BEVERLY HILLS BUT
FOR THE MOST PART EVERYBODY
COULD CLAIM SOME VERSION AND
THE MORE YOU ARE IN THE IN THE
MIDDLE THE MORE SERIOUS AND
THE AND -- -- MORE DRAMATIC
IS THE CRISIS THAT THAT WE'RE
FACING SO TO ME THAT'S THE
THAT'S THE ISSUE COME ON THAT'S
THE ISSUE WE HAVE TO BE GIVEN
THE OPPORTUNITY TO ADDRESS
THAT IN A WAY IN A SIMILAR WAY
TO THOUGH -- TRANSPORTATION
THERE'S A REGIONAL
TRANSPORTATION THEY BEEN THEY
FUNCTION TOGETHER THERE'S SOME
REPRESENTATION NOT EVERY CITY
HAS THE SAME REPRESENTATION
THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE THERE EIGHTY
EIGHT CITIES IN THE COUNTY
OF LOS ANGELES EIGHTY EIGHT
CITIES NOT EVERY CITY IS
GOING TO GET THE SAME KIND OF
REPRESENTATION ON THE BOARD
THERE HAS TO BE A SMART WAY OF
GIVING REPRESENTATION WITHOUT
EVERY CITY GETTING EVERYTHING
THAT THEY DESERVE I DON'T I
DON'T ARGUE WITH THAT BUT WE
HAVE TO FIND A DIFFERENT WAY OF
ADDRESSING OUR HOUSING CRISIS
AND THAT IS WHAT SHOULD MATTER
YOU KNOW ALL THE OTHER THINGS
THAT HAPPEN HERE -- AMONGST
THE SENATE ARE RULES I SEE
RULES CHANGING ALL THE TIME I
SEE HOW WE ADDRESS THOSE RULES
HAPPEN DIFFERENTLY ALL THE
TIME BECAUSE WE HAVE TO KEEP
MOVING FORWARD AND I JUST WANT
TO THANK THE AUTHOR BECAUSE
SHE HAS SPENT ALMOST TWO YEARS
COMMITTED AND DEVOTED TO THIS
AND NOBODY ELSE HAS DONE THAT
FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
-- WITH THE COUNTY OF LOS
ANGELES NOBODY ELSE HAS DONE
THAT A HUNDRED ORGANIZATIONS
FROM THE BUSINESS CENTRAL CITY
ASSOCIATION TO CHRYSALIS ACE
WHICH IS PROBABLY PICKETED AND
MARCHED IN FRONT OF EVERYBODY'S
OFFICE ACROSS LOS ANGELES
THIS IS AN EXTRAORDINARY
COALITION EFFORT OF A HUNDRED
COMMUNITY BASED ORGANIZATIONS
ARE WE GONNA HAVE BUMPS IN THE
ROAD YES BUT MY GOD THE MOST
IMPORTANT THING THAT SHOULD
MATTER IN MAKING THIS DECISION
IS WHAT HOW ARE WE GOING TO
SOLVE THE HOUSING ISSUES THE
CRISIS THE HOMELESSNESS THE
ON THE EDGE OF HOMELESSNESS
THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD BE THAT
SHOULD BE FOREMOST IN MAKING
A DECISION ON THIS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR DORADO
SENATOR PORTANTINO THANK YOU
MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS I RISE --
THERE'S NOTHING HAPHAZARD ABOUT
THE TWENTY TWO CITY HOUSING
TRUST IN THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY
THERE'S NOTHING HAPHAZARD ABOUT
THE THREE CITY BURBANK GLENDALE
PASADENA HOUSING TRUST THAT
WAS CREATED THIS YEAR THROUGH
LEGISLATION THESE ARE EARNEST
CITIES TRYING TO SOLVE THE
HOUSING CRISIS MY COLLEAGUE
FROM BALDWIN PARK IS ALREADY
CRAFTING LEGISLATION TO GIVE
THESE HOUSING TRUST TAXING
AUTHORITY SAID THE ANSWER THAT
QUESTION OR TO RESPOND TO IT
THIS WOULD CREATE A SITUATION
WHERE THOSE CITIES WOULD
BE TAXED TWICE THAT IS NOT
ACCEPTABLE AND TO LISTEN TO
SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES SUGGEST
THAT THE ENDS JUSTIFY THE MEANS
AND THAT INTEGRITY AND HOW
WE DO THINGS DOESN'T MATTER
BECAUSE THE END GAME IS ALL
THAT MATTERS I DON'T KNOW MY
WIDOWED MOTHER IN NEW JERSEY
DIDN'T TEACH ME TO THINK THAT
WE SHOULD HAVE SITUATIONAL
ETHICS AND WHEN I WENT THROUGH
THE CAMPAIGN PROCESS AND FOLKS
ASK ME TO MAKE COMMITMENTS
AND I MADE COMMITMENTS THEY
EXPECTED ME TO KEEP MY WORK
WE HAVE A SYSTEM THAT IS
BUILT ON KEEPING OUR WORD
AND IF WE DON'T A POX ON US
SENATOR RUBIO
THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN AND I KNOW
THIS MAY BE A LITTLE CONFUSING
TO THOSE THAT ARE NOT FROM OUR
AREA AND DON'T UNDERSTAND JUST
THE DISPARITY IN MY OPINION
OF WHAT LA IS THE ACTUAL CITY
OF LOS ANGELES VERSUS A SMALL
CITY LIKE MINE BOLLIN PARK
AND SO JUST TO BE CLEAR NO
ONE IS OPPOSING THEM CREATING
A HOUSING TRUST IN FACT I
WAS NOT OPPOSED TO CREATING
A HOUSING TRUST THAT'S WHY I
SAY THAT WITH SEVERAL SENATORS
TO GET SOME COMMITMENTS WAS
GETTING COMMITMENTS AND HERE
WE ARE DISCUSSING WHY DOES
COMMITMENTS WERE BROKEN BUT I
WANT TO CLARIFY ONE OTHER THING
YOU KNOW THE AUTHORS SAID THAT
NO MEMBER OF THE L.
THE DELEGATION VOTED AGAINST
THIS SO I WILL SHOW VERY
CLEARLY AND SPECIFICALLY THEY
THOUGHT IT WAS THE DEAL THAT
WAS GIVEN INCLUDING MY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER AND THE BILL PASSED WITH
FORTY TWO VOTES I ASK YOU FORTY
TWO BUCKS INCLUDING MY ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS WHO THOUGHT THAT THE
DEAL WAS REACHED AND THAT'S
WHAT WE WERE HONORING SO I JUST
WANNA MAKE SURE AGAIN BECAUSE
I RESPECT MY LA COLLEAGUES
AND I ALSO SAT WITH MANY OF
THEM WHEN THEY WERE ASKING ME
HOW I DID IT WILL WEAR THAT
THE PROS AND THE CONS I SAT
HOURS WITH SO MANY TRYING TO
GET MY INPUT ON HOW OURS WAS
SUCCESSFUL I DID IT BECAUSE I
WANT ALLEY HOUSING UP TO US TO
BE SUCCESSFUL THAT'S WHAT I WAS
TRYING TO TO TO REACH A PLACE
WHERE WE CAN WORK TOGETHER
HELP ELLIE BE SUCCESSFUL AND I
WAS WILLING TO BE PART OF THAT
DESPITE THE OPPOSITION FROM MY
DISTRICT SO WANTED TO BE CLEAR
BECAUSE I KNOW THAT PEOPLE
DON'T UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCE
BETWEEN ALI AND MY CITY SO
MANY GIVE YOU ONE EXAMPLE I
TALKED ABOUT MEASURE H.
WHERE WE GET TAXED IN A GOES
TO LOS ANGELES COUNTY ONES
CITY TWO POINT TWO MILLION
DOLLARS ONE OF MY SMALL CITIES
TWO POINT TWO MILLION DOLLARS
AND THEY ONLY GOT SIXTY NINE
THOUSAND DOLLARS BACK TO SOLVE
HOUSING AND HOMELESS YES I
WANT YOU TO CONSIDER THAT
SIXTY NINE THOUSAND DOESN'T
DO ANYTHING AFTER THEY PUT
TWO POINT TWO MILLION AND NOT
JUST ONE CITY RIGHT NOW WE
HAVE TWENTY TWO CITIES AND
THIS WILL TAKE OUR ABILITY
TO CREATE OUR OWN A FUNDING
STREAM AND AGAIN FOR THE RECORD
THIS IS NOT IN OPPOSITION TO A
CREATING DOT HOUSING TRUST IT
WAS JUST A MATTER OF FOLLOWING
THROUGH WITH THOSE COMMITMENTS
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK
YOU SENATOR RUBIO SINGH NO
OTHER SENATORS WISHING TO BE
RECOGNIZED CENTER KAMLAGER
YOU CAN CLOSE THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT -- I I DON'T HAVE
ANY VERSES ARE PROS BUT I DO
WANT TO RESTATE SOME FACTS
-- THAT THERE ARE NO EXISTING
LOCAL TAX DOLLARS FLOWING INTO
THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY TRUST
SO THEY WOULDN'T BE DOUBLE
TAXED I WANT TO REITERATE
THAT THIS IS SUPPORTED BY
THE CHAIR OF THE SAN GABRIEL
VALLEY REGIONAL HOUSING TRUST
I WANT TO REITERATE THAT THE
SAN GABRIEL VALLEY COG WAS
ACTIVELY INVOLVED IN AT THE
TABLE EVERY STEP OF THE WAY I
WANT TO REITERATE THAT THOSE
DISCUSSIONS WERE FACILITATED
BY THE CHAIR OF THE LOS
ANGELES BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
WHO IS HERE ON THE FLOOR
TODAY TO VALIDATE THE TRUTH
OF THAT STATEMENT TO VALIDATE
THE TRUTH OF THAT STATEMENT
I WANNA SAY THAT I'M NOT A
LIAR THAT THE COMMITMENTS
THAT WERE MADE WORK TWO WEEKS
FOR THE SAN GABRIEL VALLEY
DEDICATED FUNDING TO THE TRUST
AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND
THOSE ARE ALL IN THE BILL
THE SECOND SEAT ROTATES WITH
ALL OF THE SUBREGIONS OF THE
CITIES THAT REPRESENT THE
COUNTY BECAUSE EVERYONE WANTS
AN ADDITIONAL SEAT AT THE TABLE
BECAUSE EVERYONE IS SUFFERING
PORTABLE HOUSING SAN
GABRIEL VALLEY IS GETTING
ITS FIRST FOR FOUR YEARS
THREE COMMITMENTS THERE WAS
NEVER A COMMITMENT TO NOT MOVE
THE BAIL IF THERE HAD BEEN
OTHER COMMITMENTS WE WANT EVERY
INTRODUCED IT THIS YEAR BECAUSE
YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT INSTALLED
LAST YEAR IF THINGS REALLY
BROKEN DOWN WE WOULD HAVE
GONE TO COURT WE WOULD HAVE
GONE BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD
BUT HUNDREDS OF ORGANIZATIONS
CHURCHES CITIES THE SENATOR
FROM LOS ANGELES MANSION THE
CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS THEY
SUPPORT IT WE NEED THIS BECAUSE
WE ALL NEED IT AND WE CAN'T DO
IT ALONE AND IT'S NOT WORKING
WHEN WE DO IT BY OURSELVES
AS IS PART OF THIS I THOUGHT
WHEN A BILL GOES TO THE
OTHER SIDE I'VE NEVER HAD A
BILL THAT HAS BEEN PURE AND
THAT HAS REMAINED THE SAME
FROM THE POINT OF INCEPTION
SO WHEN IT IS PASSED ON AND
DELIVERED TO THE GOVERNOR
I'VE NEVER HAD THAT HAPPEN
AND IT DIDN'T HAPPEN
THIS TIME BUT WE
WE WENT SAN GABRIEL VALLEY
BEFORE GATEWAY CITIES BEFORE
THE SOUTH BAY BEFORE THE VALLEY
WE DID ALL WE COULD TO GET
THOSE THREE THINGS THAT WERE
DISCUSSED THIS IS NOT MEASURE
EIGHT THIS IS NOT MEASURE H.
I'M NOT GOING TO SPEAK TO
MEASURE EIGHT I'M SPEAKING
TO THE LOS ANGELES REGIONAL
HOUSING AUTHORITY AND THE
HUNDREDS OF FOLKS WHO SPEND
THOUSANDS OF HOURS ON A WEEKLY
BASIS WITH LOS ANGELES CITY
IN THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
TO COME TO AN AGREEMENT
THAT WOULD HELP EVERYONE
I WANNA SAY THAT'S THE
ORIGIN STORY OF THIS BILL
THE ORIGIN STORY OF THIS BILL
IS THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DELEGATION FIVE YEARS AGO THIS
DELEGATION DECIDED TO COME
BACK TOGETHER AND IT TOOK US
AWHILE TO GET ORGANIZED AND WE
BEGAN TO HOLD RETREATS AND IN
ONE OF OUR RETREATS NOT LONG
AGO WE SAT TOGETHER IN PERSON
AND THEN ON AS SOON AND WE
SAID LET'S BE BOLD LET'S BE
UNIFIED THERE ARE A FEW ISSUES
THAT ARE IMPACTING ALL OF OUR
CITIES AND THE COUNTY AND LET'S
FIGHT TOGETHER ON THEM MIDDLE
HEALTH WAS ONE HOMELESSNESS
WAS ONE AND HOUSING
THEN WE SAID LET'S BE
ASPIRATIONAL AND IT WON'T BE
ABOUT MY DISTRICT IT WON'T
BE ABOUT MY MUNICIPALITY
IT WON'T BE ABOUT SOMEONE
ELSE'S MUNICIPALITY IT WILL
BE ABOUT THE WHOLE REGION THE
CITY'S LOS ANGELES CITY AND
THE COUNTY THAT'S THE ORIGIN
STORY OF THIS BILL NOT ME
NOT ONE PERSON FROM SOUTH GATE
NOT ONE PERSON FROM PARAMOUNT
EVERYONE COMING TOGETHER
BECAUSE EVERY DAY PEOPLE IN
LOS ANGELES ARE NOT THINKING
ABOUT US AND THEY ARE NOT
THINKING ABOUT THEIR POLITICS
THEY ARE THINKING ABOUT THE
FACT THAT THERE HOUSING OPTIONS
ARE SLIMMING AND THEY'RE
HOUSING COSTS ARE RISING
AND THEY'RE ASKING US TO DO
BETTER ON THEIR BEHALF FROM
PARAMOUNT TO PASADENA FROM
WEST HOLLYWOOD TO WEST COVINA
FROM LANCASTER TO LAKE WOULD
TO LAWNDALE FROM CENTURY
CITY COLAVITA IN COMPTON
THAT IS WHAT THEY ARE ASKING
FROM SANTA MONICA TO SIERRA
MADRE THEN WE CAN PUT THIS
AND PUT IT OFF BECAUSE WE'RE
FIGHTING FOR THE THING THAT
WE WANT WHAT WE CAN STEP INTO
THE FUTURE AND RISE ABOVE THE
MELEE AND DO WHAT'S RIGHT FOR
THE MILLIONS OF PEOPLE ACROSS
ALL OF LOS ANGELES COUNTY WHO
ARE ASKING US TO SAY YES TO
THIS BILL THERE IS A REASON
WHY THE LOS ANGELES TIMES HAS
BEEN TRACKING THIS BILL AND
WRITING ABOUT IT ON MULTIPLE
OCCASIONS AND CALLING IT A
DISAPPOINTMENT WHEN IT WASN'T
PASSED LAST YEAR AND A TRAVESTY
IF IT DIES THIS TIME BECAUSE
THE EXISTENTIAL THREAT IN LOS
ANGELES IN ALL OF THE COUNTY
OF LOS ANGELES IS HOUSING
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND THIS WILL ALLOW
US TO RAISE FUNDING TO FINANCE
A HUNDRED PERCENT AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND THAT IS THE TRUTH
AND MY COMMITMENT MY COMMITMENT
WAS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE PASSED
SOMETHING THAT WORKED FOR THE
FOLKS WHO NEED IT THE MOST
THOSE WHO ARE ON HOUSE AND
BURDENED BY THE COST OF HOUSING
ACROSS THE COUNTY OF LOS
ANGELES I RESPECTFULLY HUMBLY
GRATEFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR KAMLAGER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN ARCHULETA ATKINS WICKS
NOPE BACKER FORTUS NO BRADFORD
AYE BY OTHER COURSE HAS HE I W.
HI DODD THE RUSSELL I EGGMAN
GLAZER GONZALEZ I GROWTH
HERTZBERG HI WESSEL HURTADO
JONES NO KAMLAGER HI THERE
LEYVA I FOR THE MOST MCGUIRE
I MELENDEZ MANY NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN I TRIED BOTH PAN
PORTANTINO NO ROTH RUBIO
NO SKINNER STERN AYE NUMBER
BY CASKEY I WIENER AYE
WILK WE'LL CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ONE TIME PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN HI
ARCHULETA ATKINS HI BAKER
CUPBEARER DODD EGGMAN GLAZER
GROVE WESSEL HER TADO WHERE
DO I LIMÓN HI MELENDEZ MANY
NIELSEN BUT CHOI BOGUE CAN
ROTH SKINNER I NUMBER BUT WILK
THANK YOU WILL TRY ONE MORE
TIME TO CALL THE ROLL FOR THE
ABSENT MEMBERS SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ARCHULETA BAKER
CUPBEARER DODD EGGMAN I LATER
GROVE WESTERN HURTADO MELENDEZ
IN NIELSEN I TRIED BOTH PAN
ROTH I'M BURKE WILK CENTER COME
LONGER MOVES THE CALL MEMBERS
GOOD NEWS IT IS TWO FORTY TO
FIFTY NOW IN THE AFTERNOON
WE'RE GONNA TAKE A TEN MINUTE
RECESS RECESS FOR TEN MINUTES
BUT -- WE ARE STAYING IN THE
CAPITOL BUILDING DURING THAT
RECESS TEN MINUTE RECESS
WE CAN TAKE UP WE'RE GONNA
START WITH FILE ITEM FIFTY
FIVE SENATOR ALAN MEN SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY BILL
NINE TWENTY BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
AGUIAR-CURRY AND ACTIVATING
TO ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AND
DECLARING THE URGENCY THERE
ABSTRACT MERELY CENTER ALAN
THANK YOU SO MUCH MISS MADAM
PRESIDENT -- -- THIS BILL
ALLOWS CALIFORNIA'S CRAFT
DISTILLERS TO CONTINUE TO SHIP
THEIR PRODUCTS DIRECTLY TO
CONSUMERS FOR ONE ADDITIONAL
YEAR -- THERE WAS DURING THE
COVERAGE PERIOD THE DEPARTMENT
OF ALCOHOL THE ALCOHOL BEVERAGE
CONTROL ALLOWED CRAFTED
STILL TO SHIP THEIR PRODUCTS
DIRECTLY TO CONSUMERS -- UP
UNTIL MARCH TWENTY TWENTY TWO
WINE AND BEER COURSE ALREADY
HAVE THIS PRIVILEGE BUT THIS
REDDITOR RELIEF ENDED IN
MARCH AND CRAFT DISTILLERS ARE
STATE OF ALREADY FACE LAYOFFS
AND CLOSURES AS A RESULT
SO THIS IS CRITICAL -- AND
GOVERNOR NEWSOM IN ABC'S
AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT
TO CONSUMER SHIPPING FOR
CALIFORNIA CHRYSLER'S BEEN
A LIFELINE -- AND I ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS
CRITICAL LEGISLATION TO
ALLOW THIS GROWING INDUSTRY
TO CONTINUE TO GROW THANK
YOU SENATOR ALAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS THIS
IS ELIGIBLE FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE
HIGHS FORTY NO ZERO ON THE
URGENCY AS FOR THE FORTY
NINE ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
TRANSLUCENT OKAY PROCEDURE ALL
RIGHT WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM THIRTY NINE THE SENATOR
NEWMAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY ONE
OH SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
FLORA AN ACT RELATING TO
CLINICAL LABORATORIES AND
ACQUIRING THE URGENCY THERE
I'VE CHECKED IMMEDIATELY CENTER
NEWMAN AT THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT RISE ON BEHALF OF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER FLORA TO RESENT
AB TWENTY ONE OH SEVEN WHICH
ALLOW LABORATORY PERSONNEL WHO
ARE CURRENTLY LICENSED TO COOK
OF CONDUCT MOLECULAR TESTING
FOR HUMAN GENETICS TO ALSO TEST
FOR INFECTIOUS DISEASES UNDER
CURRENT LAW GENETIC MOLECULAR
BIOLOGIST MICROBIOLOGIST
MILLION CAJUN OR SUPERVISE
OTHERS ENGAGED IN TEST RELEVANT
TO THEIR SPECIFIC LICENSE TYPE
HOWEVER DURING THE PANDEMIC
AN ALLOWANCE WAS MADE UP FOR
THEM TO DO BOTH AB TWENTY ONE
OH SEVEN SENSIBLY CODIFIES
THE PROVISION OF THE RELEVANT
EXECUTIVE ORDER INTO LAW TO
ENSURE THE CALIFORNIA CAN COUNT
ON APPROPRIATE WORKFORCE FOR
CONDUCTING ONGOING TESTING
WHILE ENSURING AN ONGOING
SURVEILLANCE CAPACITY TO
PREVENT FUTURE OUTBREAKS OF
COMMUNICABLE DISEASES ON BEHALF
OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER FLORA I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE TODAY THANK YOU SENATOR
NEWMAN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MEMBERS THIS ALSO IS ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE HIGHS FORTY
NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
EXCUSE ME IS FORTINO ZERO ON
THE URGENCY IS EYES FORTY NO
ZERO AND THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY SEVEN SENATOR LEE
MON MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL TWELVE TWELVE
SEVENTY NINE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
MURATSUCHI AN ACT RELATING
TO GREENHOUSE GASES GENERALLY
MON THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS TODAY I RISE TO PRESENT
AB TWELVE SEVENTY NINE ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
MURATSUCHI AND CRISTINA GARCIA
AB TWELVE SEVENTY NINE AS
AMENDED WOULD CODIFY GOAL TO
REACH EMISSIONS NEUTRALITY
AS SOON AS POSSIBLE BUT NO
LATER THAN TWENTY FORTY FIVE
A NET NEGATIVE EMISSIONS THERE
AFTER THIS BILL WOULD ALSO
REQUIRE REDUCING GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSIONS BY EIGHTY FIVE
PERCENT FROM NINETEEN NINETY
LEVELS BY TWENTY FORTY FIVE
BEGIN TO PLAN FOR AND WORK
TOWARDS EMISSIONS NEUTRALITY AS
SOON AS POSSIBLE IS CRITICALLY
IMPORTANT THE LATEST SCIENCE
TELLS US THAT IN ORDER TO AVERT
THE MOST CATASTROPHIC IMPACTS
OF CLIMATE CHANGE WE MUST LIMIT
AT ATMOSPHERIC WARMING TO ONE
POINT FIVE DEGREES CELSIUS
WHICH NECESSITATES CALIFORNIA
REACHING NET ZERO EMISSIONS BY
MID CENTURY ROUTINE EMISSIONS
YOUR TROLLEY ON ITS OWN MEANS
NOTHING IF WE DO NOT INSURE
THAT WE DON'T LEAVE BEHIND OUR
MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES
AB TWELVE SEVENTY NINE NOT
ONLY ESTABLISHES A GOAL FOR
NEUTRALITY IT PRIORITIZES
EMISSION REDUCTIONS TO ENSURE
PROTECTION FOR COMMUNITIES
AND THE ENVIRONMENT CALIFORNIA
HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED AS A
GLOBAL LEADER IN ADVANCING
CLIMATE POLICY AND EIGHTY
TWELVE SEVENTY NINE IS AN
IMPORTANT OPPORTUNITY TO
CONTINUE THIS LEADERSHIP
AND PROP OTHER STATES AND
COUNTRIES TO ADOPT SIMILAR
MEASURES THAT RESPONSIBLE
CLIMATE DISASTER WITH URGENCY
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE ON THIS MEASURE THE USER
AND ALONE MEMBERS DISCUSSION
AND DEBATE SENATOR HERTZBERG
THIS IS A -- THIRTY EXTREME ASK
BUT IT'S AN EXTREME MASKS TO
DEAL WITH EXTREME CIRCUMSTANCES
I DON'T KNOW YOU KNOW EVERY
TIME I TURN ON THE TELEVISION
AND OR OR THIS WEEKEND IT JUST
MY NIECE JUST HAD A -- STREAM
HEAT CIRCUMSTANCE OF THE SCHOOL
AND THE SCHOOLS BEING CANCELED
I DON'T KNOW WHAT IS RIGHT BUT
I KNOW IF WE DON'T ACT IT WILL
BE WRONG THIS IS A BIG MEASURE
IT IS AN IMPORTANT MEASURE AND
I JUST WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO
STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT BECAUSE
I THINK WE'VE REALLY GOT
TO TAKE ACTION N.
THIS IS GONNA BE TOUGH IS GOING
TO BE CHALLENGES THEY'LL BE
PEOPLE MAKING A LOT OF NOISE
BUT YOU SHOULD HEAR FROM ME
LATER AS I SPEAK ON ANOTHER
MEASURE I SEEN THIS OVER MANY
YEARS AND I'VE SEEN US RISE
TO THE CHALLENGE AND I WANT TO
TELL YOU THAT I STRANDED STRONG
SUPPORTERS MEASURE I THANK THE
AUTHOR FOR BRING IT FORWARD
THANK YOU SENATOR HERTZBERG
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE CENTER DOLLY THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS THAT I
HAVE TO RISE IN OPPOSITION AND
YOU WONDER WHY WOULD I NOT WANT
TO SEE US REDUCE OUR CARBON
BY EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT BELOW
NINETEEN NINETY I WOULD LOVE
TO SEE THAT BUT I ASK YOU WHERE
IN THIS PIECE OF LEGISLATION IS
THERE ANY DETAIL OF HOW WE'RE
ACTUALLY GOING TO ACHIEVE THAT
ZERO WE'VE DONE AB THIRTY TWO
IN TWO THOUSAND SIX WE DON'T
SB THREE FIFTY WE'VE DONE ALL
THESE GOALS AND WHAT HAVE WE
ACHIEVED WE SAW LAST YEAR THE
YEAR BEFORE CAN'T REMEMBER
WHAT IT WAS BUT THE CALIFORNIA
AIR RESOURCES BOARD DID THE
ANALYSIS OF HOW MUCH CARBON
REDUCTION WE ACTUALLY ACHIEVED
AND THERE WAS NOT MUCH IF ANY
FOR THE AMOUNT OF MONEY AND
AMOUNT OF REGULATIONS WE PUT
ON CALIFORNIANS M.
FOR THEIR BUSINESSES AND LIKES
AND YOU KNOW I CONTINUALLY GO
BACK AND TALK ABOUT FOREST FIRE
I DID A BILL TO ACTUALLY COUNT
AND QUANTIFY THE EMISSIONS
FOR FORCE FIRE IT DIED IN
EQ BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT TO
COUNT WE DON'T EVEN COUNT THE
LARGEST EMITTER OF CARBON WHICH
IS FORCE FIRE THE DIXIE FIRE
LAST YEAR BURNED NINE HUNDRED
EIGHTY THOUSAND ACRES THE
LARGEST FIRE IN THE HISTORY
THE STATE ONE SINGLE FIRE WE
CANNOT THAT EMISSIONS NO BUT
WE PASSED A LOT OF LEGISLATION
ON COMBUSTIBLE ENGINES AND
WE NEED TO RAISE AND LAWN
MOWERS AND WEED BLOWERS AND
GENERATORS SOMETHING THAT
A LOT OF CALIFORNIANS ARE
GONNA NEED THIS WEEKEND TO
KEEP THE REFRIGERATOR ON IS A
COMBUSTIBLE ENGINE RUNNING A
GENERATOR BECAUSE THE POWER'S
GOING TO GO OUT WE'RE GONNA
BE TO FLEX ALERT SO SETTING
GOALS IS ONE THING AND THEN
DOING A VICTORY LAP ABOUT
SETTING A GOAL IS AWESOME BUT
HOW ARE YOU CAN ACHIEVE IT
WHAT'S THE COST HOW MANY JOBS
ARE WE GONNA SHIP AND HOW MANY
OF OUR PRODUCTION IS GONNA
GO TO OTHER COUNTRIES WHO
HAVE MET THAT'S THE QUESTION
HERE NEVER GETS ANSWERED
WHAT A LOT OF PEOPLE TALK BUT
DON'T DELIVER AT THE SAME TIME
IT'S DESTROYING CALIFORNIA
BUSINESSES SO FOR THOSE REASONS
I CAN'T SUPPORT IT BECAUSE
WE'VE SEEN THIS TIME AND TIME
AGAIN IT'S JUST ANOTHER WAY
TO SHOW THE WORLD THAT WE CAN
SET A GOAL WITHOUT ACHIEVING
IT OR GIVE US A REASON OR
THE WAY WE'RE GOING TO GET
THERE PASS FOR NO VOTE ON AB
TWELVE SEVENTY NINE THANK YOU
CENTER DOLLY CENTER BECKER
THANK YOU COLLEAGUES I
TRIED TO THE RISE M.
WITH MY COLLEAGUE FROM BEAVER
I THINK HE'S I THINK IS RIGHT
AND WHAT THE SENSE THAT IF
WE IF WE SET TARGETS AND
DON'T HAVE THE MAKINGS DID
SHE THEN THEN THEN WHAT ARE
WE DOING THAT WE DO HAVE A
FEW BILLS ON TARGETS IN THE
PASSING YES I THINK THE GOOD
NEWS HERE THOUGH IS THAT WE
ARE DOING THE UNDERLYING WORK
AS WELL YOU KNOW IS PROUD TO
WORK WITH HIM AND OTHERS ON A
TRANSMISSION BILL IN WITH OTHER
TRANSMISSION BILL FROM THE M.
FOR CALLING -- JUST BROKE MY
LEG TO GET THAT THE ENERGY FROM
WHERE IT'S PRODUCED TO WHERE
IT'S NEEDED ACROSS THE STATE
BEEN BEEN BEEN REALLY JUST
HAPPY TO WORK WITH INDUSTRY
ON THE CEMENT INDUSTRY TO GET
TO A NET ZERO TARGET WORKING
WITH THEM BUT TO GET TO DOES
YOUR TARGET BY TWENTY FORTY
FIVE THAT WE NOW HAVE AS PART
OF OUR LAW HERE IN CALIFORNIA
WORK WITH THE CONCRETE INDUSTRY
GET THE CONCRETE INDUSTRY TO
SIGN A LETTER WITH ENERGY SEE
ABOUT THEIR INTENTION AND HOW
THEY CAN HELP MEET THESE GOALS
SO -- I I DO AGREE WITH YOU
YOU CAN'T JUST BE GOALS BUT
I THINK THE GOOD NEWS NOW IS
THAT WE ARE DOING THE HARD
WORK WITH THAT WITH THE THROUGH
THE BUDGET WHETHER THROUGH
A SET OF ALL THE OTHER BILLS
WITH ITS YOU KNOW CHARGING IN
MULTI FAMILY WHETHER IT'S YOU
KNOW COMMUNITY SOLAR WHETHER
IT'S THIS OR THAT IT PUT OUT
THERE ALL THESE PIECES WITH
THIS THE WORK WE'RE DOING ON
BUILDING DECARBONIZATION NOW
AND LETTING PEOPLE FINANCE
IT ON THEIR ON THEIR UTILITY
BILLS ALL THOSE PIECES I THINK
ARE CRITICAL BUT I AGREE WE
WE HAVE TO PUT THOSE POLICIES
IN PLACE TO GET THERE I THINK
THE GOOD NEWS THOUGH IS THAT
WE'RE DOING IT AND THAT THIS
GOES ACTUALLY AGAIN WITH THAT
TRADE OFF PROTECT EMISSIONS
AND OFFSETS WE'RE GOING TO
SEE THAT'S WHY MY GOVERNMENT
AS YOUR BILL WILL YOU KNOW
WE'LL SEE WHAT THE RIGHT TRADE
OFFICE WITH THE GOVERNMENT
WILL HAVE TO REACH OUR STATE
GOVERNMENT HAVE TO REACH THE
DECISION BETWEEN TWENTY THIRTY
FIVE I WANT TO SEE WHAT THAT
TRADE OFFICE IN CAN WE GET
SOME HIGH QUALITY OFFSETS THE
GOOD NEWS THAT CARBON CAPTURE
IS INCLUDED AS AN EMISSIONS
REDUCTION IN THIS BILL ACTUALLY
SO I THINK THERE ARE THE PATH
TO GET THERE AND -- AND WITH
THAT AND AND AND THE IMPORTANCE
HAS BEEN STRESS ARE SPECIALLY
ASPIRIN I VOTE THANK YOU
CENTER BAKER CENTER NIELSEN
THAT ARE PRESENT LADIES AND
GENTLEMEN OF THE SENATE THE
THE CRISES WILL NEVER END NO
MATTER WHAT THE GOAL SETTING
HOW MANY BILLS THAT WE PASS
THE CRISIS WILL NEVER END
THERE WILL ALWAYS BE A CRISIS
BECAUSE SOME PARTIES THRIVE ON
A CRISIS THAT'S THE BUSINESS
TO HAVE CRISES THAT WE HAVE TO
REACT TO DID THESE PRICES ARE
THEY MEASURED THAT DO WE HAVE
PROGRESS MADE WELL ACCORDING
TO THE CONTINUING CRISES NO WE
HAVE NOT MADE ANY PROGRESS ARE
WE UNDERSEA WATER RIGHT NOW
WELL NOT YET DO WE GET THERE
WELL I DON'T KNOW BUT I DON'T
THINK THESE DEEP THINKERS IN
THE IVORY TOWERS OF ANY GOOD
ANSWERS TO IT AND I'M GETTING
A LITTLE WARY OF LISTENING
TO THEM THE DOOMSAYERS OF
TODAY AND WHILE OUR ECONOMY
AND THE PROSPECTS OF OUR
CHILDREN AND GRANDCHILDREN
FINDING GAINFUL EMPLOYMENT
HAPPY LIVES IN THE STATE
OUR DAILY DIMINISHING
INTERLEAVING AND I DON'T
BLAME THOUGH IT HURTS BECAUSE
I'VE LOST SOME OF MY OWN
FAMILY TWO OTHER STATES THAT
ARE NOW NOT SO INHOSPITABLE
THERE ARE MORE OPEN MINDED AND
PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS ORIENTED
I'M TIRED TO LISTENING TO THE
RHETORIC THE HOLLOW RHETORIC
IN THE DREAMERS I CANNOT
SUPPORT THIS LEGISLATION THANK
YOU CENTER NIELSEN MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR GROWTH THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT I TO RISE IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL AND NO
SURPRISE HOW WANT TO TAKE YOU
BACK TO I BELIEVE TWO THOUSAND
AND NINE WHEN THE PROMO VIDEO
CAME OUT ON THE HIGH SPEED RAIL
AND THEY PROMISED BY TWENTY
TWENTY YOU CAN GET ON IT IN
LOS ANGELES AND WRITE IT TO
SAN FRANCISCO IN AN HOUR AND
TWENTY MINUTES AND THAT IS
NON EXISTENT TWO YEARS LATER
WE DON'T EVEN HAVE ONE TRACK
LAID THE REASON I SAY THAT IS
BECAUSE THERE WERE SOME BIG
FANTASY THAT WE COULD ACHIEVE
THAT THEY'VE INVESTED BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS INTO THE HIGH SPEED
RAIL AND IT'S NOT EXISTENCE
THE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS BEING
SPENT ON ON THIS ENERGY GREEN
ENERGY UTOPIA BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS TAXPAYER DOLLARS BEING
SPENT ON THIS IS GOING TO END
UP JUST LIKE THE HIGH SPEED
RAIL THERE IS NO PLAN IN PLACE
YOU CANNOT DO WITHOUT FOSSIL
FUELS YOU CANNOT DO IT WITHOUT
HYDRO ENERGY YOU CAN'T DO
IT WITHOUT GAS POWERED POWER
PLANTS WHICH IS EXACTLY WHY
THE GOVERNOR FLIPPED AND WE HAD
THAT BILL THAT WAS A TRAITOR
BILL JUST LAST MONTH OR MONTH
AND A HALF AGO SO THAT THEY
COULD BE OPERATING IN ONLY
BE THE DECISION TO BE MADE BY
THE CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES
BOARD OF THE DEPARTMENT WATER
RESOURCES WE RELEGATED THAT
A TORTILLA DOWN TO AN AGENCY
THAT HAS NO ACCOUNTABILITY
TO THE VOTERS THERE IS NO WAY
THIS CAN BE ACHIEVED AND THE
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS THAT YOU
ARE INVESTING IN THIS IS JUST
COMPLETELY ABSURD AND WHEN
YOU MAKE STATEMENTS LIKE THIS
SOME POLICIES GET PASS JUST
LIKE WHEN THE GOVERNOR MADE A
STATEMENT ABOUT NO INJECTION
PERMITS LAST YEAR COMPANIES
LOST THIRTY MILLION DOLLARS
OVERNIGHT IN THE STOCK MARKET
WHEN WE MAKE POLICY LIKE
THIS IT CREATES AN INVESTMENT
PROBLEM HERE IN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA WHICH AFFECTS OUR
BUSINESSES ESPECIALLY ENERGY
BUSINESSES WHERE WE NEED TO
REMAIN ENERGY INDEPENDENT IF
YOU LOOK AT WHAT'S GOING ON IN
EUROPE IF YOU LOOK AT EVEN ARE
CAL AYSO THE REPORT ON THE FLEX
ALERT THE CAME OUT YESTERDAY
FOR THE HEAT BULLETIN THE
BOTTOM OF THAT ALERT SAYS THE
TOP THREE CONCERT FROM CAL AYSO
THE TOP THREE CONSERVATION ACT
ACTIONS YOU HAVE TO SET YOUR
THERMOSTAT TO SEVENTY EIGHT
DEGREES OR HIGHER NO SEVENTY
DEGREE COOL HOUSES BECAUSE IT
INERGY GIVE GREAT CAN'T TAKE
IT IT SAYS DON'T USE LARGE
APPLIANCES TRANSLATE UNPLUG
YOUR DAMN REFRIGERATOR SECOND
AND THE THIRD ONE CHARGING
ELECTRIC VEHICLES DO NOT CHARGE
ELECTRIC VEHICLES BECAUSE WE
CAN'T SUSTAIN IT IN YOU TAKE
IN THE ENERGY GRID TO REDUCE
THIS TIME FRAME IN THIS GOAL
IS IRRESPONSIBLE AND DOES NOT
ALLOW IT IS IRRESPONSIBLE AND
DOES NOT ALLOW FOR THE PRIVATE
BUSINESS INDUSTRY OR THE
INDUSTRY ITSELF TO TRY TO MAKE
ADJUSTMENTS TO EVEN HALFWAY
ACHIEVE THE GOALS THAT YOU GUYS
HAVE SET AND THEN LET'S TALK
ABOUT THE GOALS THAT YOU DO SET
AND THEN YOU HAVE COUNTIES LIKE
MINE THAT HELP YOU ACHIEVE THAT
GOAL WITH FIFTY THREE PERCENT
OF THE STATE'S RENEWABLE
ENERGY AND THEN YOU GET SCREWED
BECAUSE YOU HAVE SOLAR TAX
EXCLUSIONS WHERE WE DON'T EVEN
HAVE OUR COUNTY GET THE REVENUE
FOR IT WE HAVE CARBON CAPTURE
FIELDS WE HAVE THE FIRST IN
THE COUNTRY ELECTRIC CHARGING
STATION ALL OF THAT STUFF THAT
WE TRIED TO DO TO HELP YOU
AND YOU TURN AROUND JUST STAB
PEOPLE IN THE BACK WITH WHAT'S
GOING ON WITH THE POLICIES
THAT COME TO THIS BUILDING
YOU ARE STABBING INDUSTRY IN
THE BACK THAT IS TRYING TO
HELP YOU THERE IS NO WAY YOU
CAN ACHIEVE THIS GREEN UTOPIA
FROM CARBON DECARBONISATION OF
BUILDINGS AND EVERYTHING ELSE
I MEAN MY GOD YOUR OWN CAL I SO
CAN DISTRIBUTE THE ENERGY THAT
WE HAVE AND KEEP THE LIGHTS
ON RIGHT NOW NEXT WEEK YOU'RE
GOING TO HAVE A HUNDRED TEN
DEGREES HERE IN SACRAMENTO AND
IT'S GOING TO CONTINUE TO HAVE
A RISK CAN GET A TEN YOU HAVE
THE PROBLEM AND YOU CONTINUE TO
ADMIT CARBON EMISSIONS IN THE
AIR BY NOT DEALING WITH ENERGY
RESPONSIBLE AGAIN AND AGAIN
MY COLLEAGUE FROM BIEBER HAS
SAID IT YOU BRING OIL HERE ON
TANKERS FROM FOREIGN COUNTRIES
AND TWENTY SEVEN MILLION METRIC
TONS OF CARBON IS EMITTED WHEN
ONE TANKER SHIP COMES HERE
JUST ONE JUST ONE IF YOU REALLY
CARED ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE AND
IF THE GUY ON THE TENTH FLOOR
REALLY CARED ABOUT CLIMATE
CHANGE WITH HIS ADVENTUROUS
LOOK INTO THE FUTURE IN
TWENTY TWENTY FOUR HE WOULD
MAKE DECISIONS THAT PROTECT
THE ENVIRONMENT NOT HURT THE
ENVIRONMENT AND IT WOULD ALSO
MAKE DECISIONS THAT WERE WISE
AND NOT PUSH CLIMATE POLICY
LIKE THIS THAT IS ABSOLUTELY
POSITIVELY GONNA HURT NOT ONLY
CALIFORNIA BUT THE REST OF
THE NATION I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR A NO VOTE THE CENTER GROVE
CENTER WIENER THANK YOU VERY
MUCH MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE
IN SUPPORT IN THIS BILL I'M
GONNA BE HONEST I WISH IS GOING
FURTHER AND I KNOW IT'S NOT A
CRITIQUE OF THE AUTHOR OF THIS
IS COMPLICATED POLITICS THIS
IS ACHIEVING THIS GOAL TWENTY
THREE YEARS FROM NOW YOU THINK
BACK TWENTY THREE YEARS AGO
AND THE WORLD THAT WE WERE AN
TWENTY THREE YEARS TO GET THERE
THANK YOU WE NEED TO BE BOXES
WAITING UNTIL TWENTY FORTY FIVE
TO DO THIS WE NEED TO BE TAKING
ACTION NOW BECAUSE THE WORLD IS
BURNING WE SEE THE CATASTROPHIC
BUT WE'RE WILDFIRE SEASON IS
ALMOST TWELVE MONTHS A YEAR NOW
THAT'S NOT NORMAL THE FAMINE
THAT WE'RE SEEING AROUND THE
WORLD THE FACT THAT WE'RE GONNA
THAT WE'RE HAVING TO SPEND MORE
AND MORE MONEY THE ENDS IN THE
CENTRE FROM NAPA'S DISTRICT
TO CREATE A TOLL ROAD FOR A
HIGHWAY THAT'S THAT'S GOING
TO HAVE TO BE ELEVATED BECAUSE
GETTING FLOODED BARTON UNION
SAN FRANCISCO AND OUR MARKET
THERE ARE GONNA BE FLOODED
WE'RE GONNA SEE SOME ARE MAJOR
EMPLOYERS IN SILICON VALLEY
BEING FLOODED WE'RE SEEING
DISPLACEMENT OF PEOPLE THIS
IS ABOUT THE FUTURE SURVIVAL
OF THE PLANET I'M NOT GONNA
PRETEND FOR A SECOND THAT
IT'S EASY TO HAVE AN ENERGY
TRANSITION OR FOR PEOPLE
TO MAYBE HAVE TO DO THINGS
DIFFERENTLY IN THEIR LIVES
THAT IS HARD I TOTALLY AGREE
IT IS HARD TO BUT WHAT IS THE
ALTERNATIVE THE ALTERNATIVE IS
A CONTINUED CLIMATE DISASTER
AND AT SOME POINT IT GETS TO
THE POINT WHERE WE CAN'T GO
BACK IT'S NOT TOO LATE SOME
PEOPLE ARE CLIMATE THE FETUS
IT IS NOT TOO LATE WE CAN
TURN AROUND BUT WE NEED TO
TAKE ACTION NOW NOT WAIT UNTIL
TWENTY FORTY FIVE IT'S GREAT
TO HAVE YOU KNOW A REALLY
STRONG LEGAL GOAL BUT BUT WE
NEED TO BE TAKING FIRM ACTION
NOW THANK YOU SENATOR WIENER
CENTER BY CAL SKI MAN PRESIDENT
MY COLLEAGUE AND GOOD FRIEND
WHOSE -- I CAME INTO THE
LEGISLATURE FROM BAKERSFIELD
MAKES SOME VERY GOOD POINTS IF
WE FAIL TO CHANGE THE POLICIES
OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AND CONTINUE THE COURSE WE
WILL FAIL WE WILL NOT MAKE THE
EIGHTY FIVE PERCENT REDUCTION
AS SET FORTH IN AB TWELVE
SEVENTY NINE MY COLLEAGUES IN
SAN FRANCISCO IS RIGHT WE HAVE
TWENTY THREE YEARS TO MEET
THAT GOAL REALLY HAVE SEVEN
YEARS TO TRY TO GET OUR HANDS
AROUND THE CARBON PROBLEM THAT
WE HAVE I HAVE BIG MEMBERS
OF THIS CHAMBER AND OF THE
OTHER CHAMBER TO MAKE SURE TO
TO MAKE THE INVESTMENTS NOW
WITH THIS THIS BILL IS DOUBLE
DOUBLE JOIN WITH SB NINE OH
FIVE WHICH IS A BABY STEP IN
THE IN THE CARBON CAPTURE BOB
ARENA WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO DO
MORE THIS LEGISLATURE IS GOING
TO COME BACK AND WE'RE GONNA
HAVE TO YOU WERE GOING TO HAVE
FIVE HAVE DO ANYTHING HAVE HAVE
TO TO FACE THE THE THE REALITY
THAT WERE AS PRESIDENT OBAMA
SAID WE HAVE TO DO ALL OF THE
ABOVE THIS IS NOT A PICK AND
CHOOSE YOU WANT TO PICK AND
CHOOSE RIGHT NOW WHEN WE SET
THIS GOAL AND WE COMMIT TO
CITY CALIFORNIA TEN EIGHTY FIVE
PERCENT REDUCTION THOSE LITTLE
PREFERENCES THAT WE HAVE HAVE
TO BE PUT ASIDE WE'RE GONNA
HAVE TO TAKE WE'RE GONNA HAVE
TO WORK TOGETHER TO DO ALL
THE ABOVE AND I WISH YOU ALL
GOOD LUCK I URGE AN AYE VOTE
ON THIS BECAUSE IT BECAUSE
IT'S COME TO JESUS TIME IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN IN THE
WORLD AS FAR AS FIGHTING CARBON
AND WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN
IS WE SET THIS EIGHTY FIVE
PERCENT REDUCTION GOAL WHICH
IS AMBITIOUS CONGRATULATIONS
BUT THEN WE HAVE TO GET TO
WORK NEXT SESSION AND I URGE
EACH AND EVERYONE OF YOU TO
PUT SOME OF YOUR BIASES ASIDE
AND TO REALIZE WE'RE ALL IN
THIS TOGETHER WE DO NOT AS
MY COLLEAGUE FROM BAKERSFIELD
INTIMATED IF WE DON'T WORK
TOGETHER WE'RE GONNA FAIL
AND I URGE AN AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER WHITE HOUSE KEEP
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING THEM
SENDING THE MON YOU MAY CLOSE
THANK YOU THANK YOU MEMBERS
AND IF YOU THINK THAT THIS BILL
REALLY SETS OUR TARGET FOR THE
DIRECTION THAT WE SHOULD GO
AND I'M IT'S BEEN SAID THAT
THIS DOESN'T HAVE THE DETAIL
BUT IN THE LANGUAGE OF THIS
BILL YOU WILL SEE THAT IT DOES
ASK THE AIR RESOURCE BOARD
TO WORK WITH STATE AGENCIES
TO DEVELOP THE FRAMEWORK OF
IMPLEMENTATION TO REDEVELOP
THE HOUSE WE AS A LEGISLATIVE
BODY ARE TELLING OUR AGENCIES
WHERE WE WOULD LIKE THEM
TO GO AND WE'RE GIVING THEM
THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK WITH
STAKEHOLDERS TO HELP US GET
THERE ADDITIONALLY THERE'S
ONE UNIQUE PIECE -- THAT WAS
MENTIONED THAT THIS BILL IS
TIED TO A BILL WITH DIRECT
EMISSION REDUCTION OPPORTUNITY
CCS WHICH MANY OF YOU HAVE BEEN
TALKING ABOUT AND PROBABLY WILL
GO UP ON IT SO I THINK IT'S
IMPORTANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT
WE ARE DOING SOME OF THE WORK
WE ARE ENSURING THAT WE TRY TO
IDENTIFY THOSE OPPORTUNITIES
FOR DIRECT EMISSION REDUCTION
BUT ALSO SETTING THE GOAL
FOR THE DIRECTION ON WHERE
WE WOULD LIKE OUR SEATS AGO
SO WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK
YOU SIR REALLY MOAN BEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN I ARCHULETA ATKINS AYE
BATES BAKER I PORCHES FOR JUST
NO BRADFORD CABALLERO I CORTES
HE DALY NO DODD AYE DERISIVE
AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH NO HERTZBERG AYE
WESSON AYE HER DAUGHTER NO
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE
AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN
NIELSEN NO -- SHOWBOAT NO PAN
I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE NUMBER
BY KELSEY I WIENER AYE WILK
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA BASIS NO BRADFORD
CORTESE I GLAZER I NEWMAN
RUBIO NUMBER I AS TWENTY SIX
KNOWS TEN THE MEASURE PASSES
EXCELLENT DAY ALL RIGHT MEMBERS
YOU HAVE IN FRONT OF YOU A
SUPPLEMENTAL FILE WE'RE GOING
TO START WITH WE'RE NOT CONCERT
WITH NINETY THREE CENTER LABOR
WILL DO THAT LATER RESEARCH
FILE ITEM NINETY FOUR SENATOR
HERTZBERG MA'AM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TWO
FIVE TWENTY NINE BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG AN ACT RELATING TO
ELECTRICITY CENTER HERTZBERG
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MADAM
PRESIDENT -- WITH OTHER THIS IS
BACK IN CONCURRENCE OF COURSE
IT WAS SIGNIFICANTLY AMENDED
THE OTHER HOUSE TO ADDRESS
CALIFORNIA'S UNPRECEDENTED
NEED FOR RENEWABLE ENERGY
-- CALIFORNIA NOT ONLY NEEDS
MORE CLEAN POWER WE NEED
MODERN TRANSMISSION SYSTEMS
CAN ACTUALLY DELIVER TO EVERY
COMMUNITY THE CAL AYE SO
GENERALLY IDENTIFIES TWO GROUPS
-- MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
OF TRANSMISSION WORK IN ITS
ANNUAL TRANSMISSION PLAN NEW
LINES AND NEW PASS AND THE
EXTENSION EXPANSION UPGRADE
OF OTHER MODIFICATIONS OF
EXISTING ELECTRICAL FACILITIES
BOTH TYPES OF CONSTRUCTIONS
ARE SUBJECT TO FULL NEEDS
ANALYSIS THIS BILL CLARIFIES
THAT LANGUAGE ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE I
AM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES NOPE BECKER I
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I KERR BY
OTHER CORTESE I TALLY NO DOT
AYE TERASA AYE EGGMAN GLAZER
HI GONZALEZ ALL RIGHT GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG HI HI QUESTION
I HER DAUGHTER HI JONES NO
KAMLAGER I COMPARED I LEYVA AYE
AYE FOR THE MONTH HI WIRE I'VE
MELENDEZ NOPE MEN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- CHAU VOGUE
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH
AYE RUBIO I SKINNER I STERN
AYE NUMBER AYE FORECASTING
AYE WIENER AYE WILK NOW IT'S
CALLED THE ABSENT MEMBERS
CABALLERO I EGGMAN HI I THIRTY
ONE KNOWS NINE THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED IN
FILE ITEM NINETY FIVE SENDER
TO RASO MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL SIX SEVENTY
FOUR BY SENATOR ALSO AN ACT
RELATING TO PUBLIC CONTRACTS
CENTER DURAZO THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT THESE AMENDMENTS
REFLECT TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
FROM THE ADMINISTRATION AND
IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES AS
AMENDED SB SIX SEVENTY FOUR
WOULD CREATE A HIGH ROAD JOBS
FRAMEWORK INCLUDING MINIMUM
LABOR STANDARDS AND NARROW THE
BILL TO ZERO EMISSION TRANSIT
VEHICLES AND ELECTRIC VEHICLE
INFRASTRUCTURE I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER DORADO MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NINE AM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS I FACE NO
PACKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
I HAVE A OUT OF AYE PROTESTING
AYE DALY NO DODD AYE DERISIVE
AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ
I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG AYE
WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
NO KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
LEYVA I FOR THE MOST I HAVE
BUYER I'VE MELENDEZ NOPE MEN
AYE NEWMAN I NIELSEN NO -- CHAU
BOTH NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO I
ROTH I RUBIO I SKINNER I STERN
HI NUMBER I BURKE OWSKI AYE
WIENER AYE WILK NOW PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS LASER
FIVE THIRTY KNOWS NINE THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN MEMBERS MOVING TO FILE ITEM
NINETY SIX SENATOR HUESO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL SIX EIGHTY FOUR BY SENATOR
WESSEL INACTIVATING TO PUBLIC
FOR SECONDARY EDUCATION SENATE
HUESO THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
MEMBERS ARE SB SIX CITY FORCED
BACK ON CONCURRENCE IT'S A
BILL THAT WILL ALLOW THE CSU
SYSTEM ARE PROVIDED DOCTORATE
IN PUBLIC HEALTH PROGRAM
THIS IS AN AREA THAT HAS --
YEAH ROUTE A GROWING NEED FOR
FOR -- FOR CREDIT ATION IN
THE STATE THERE IS THERE ARE
CURRENTLY NO DRPH PROGRAMS
IN THE CSU SYSTEM THE ONLY
PUBLIC OPTION RELEASED WHEN
ROLLING STUDENTS UC BERKELEY'S
WHICH IS NOT MEANT TO DEVELOP
THE WORKFORCE NEEDS A RECENT
ANALYSIS EVALUATED EMPLOYMENT
DATA AND THE WORKFORCE NEEDS IN
THE PUBLIC HEALTH SECTOR FOUND
THAT EMPLOYMENT AND PUBLIC
HEALTH JOBS REQUIRE BACHELOR'S
MASTER'S AND DOCTORAL DEGREES
IS EXPECTED TO GROW ACROSS
ALL REGIONS OF THE STATE AN
OLD AGREE AREAS OVER THE NEXT
TEN YEARS THE DEMAND FOR MORE
PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONALS
AS LONG LIKELY TO EXCEED EVEN
THE PROJECTED GROWTH GROWTH
DUE TO THE ONGOING PANDEMIC
-- THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO
SUPPORT OUR VIBRANCY ISSUE
SYSTEM I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE ON THE AMENDMENTS
THANK YOU -- ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE IS FORTY KNOWS
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
NINETY NINE SENATOR ALLEN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FIVE OH TWO BY
SENATOR ALAN AN ACT RELATING
TO HAZARDOUS MATERIALS
I MISSED IT WILL GO BACK CENTER
ALLEN GOOD AFTERNOON THIS BILL
IMPLEMENTS RECOMMENDATIONS
FROM THE PUBLIC HEALTH
INSTITUTES ANALYSIS FROM THE
DGSE GREEN CHEMISTRY PROGRAM
TO IMPROVE ACCOUNTABILITY
AND TRANSPARENCY STREAMLINE
INFORMAL RESOLUTION APPEALS
PROCESSES GIVE TEDIOUS THE
AUTHORITY TO COLLECT ESSENTIAL
PRODUCT INGREDIENT DATA MEMBERS
YOU KNOW FOLKS SAID WHY IS THE
GREEN CHEMISTRY PROGRAM NOT
WORKING THERE'S A WHOLE REPORT
DONE THIS BILL IMPLEMENTS THE
KEY ASPECTS OF THE REPORT TO
MAKE SURE THAT IT'S REAL --
THE ASSEMBLYMEMBERS RETIRED
ON TERRIFYING NATURE AND
ASK FOR A VOTE THINKCENTRE
ALLEN MADAM SECRETARY EXCUSE
ME ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
THING IN HER NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES BAKER FORTUS BRADFORD
AYE CUPBEARER AYE CORTEZ'S
AYE TALLY DODD I DIRECTOR AYE
EGGMAN AYE PLACER AYE GONZALEZ
I GROWTH HERTZBERG HI WESTERN
I HER DAUGHTER I JONES NO
KAMLAGER I FLARED I LEYVA I FOR
THE MOST AYE MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ
MANY AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO
A TROUBLED PAN AYE PORTANTINO
I ROTH I'VE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE AMBERG AYE FOR
CASKEY HI WIENER I WILK NO
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
FACE BAKER PORGES DALY GROVE
NO MELENDEZ A TROUBLED BAKER I
I THIRTY ONE DOES FOR THE
ASSEMBLY MOMENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM NINETY SEVEN
SENATOR SKINNER MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL SEVEN
FORTY SIX BY SENATOR SKINNER AN
ACT RELATING TO THE POLITICAL
REFORM ACT OF NINETEEN SEVENTY
FOUR CENTER SKINNER THANK YOU
SEVEN FOUR SIX BACK ON PLEASE
CURRENTS THE AMENDMENTS IN
THE ASSEMBLY REMOVED ALL THE
OPPOSITION AND THE BILL MOVED
IT ALSO TO BEING UNDER THE F.
PPC'S JURISDICTION HAS NO
OPPOSITION NOW I ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES AYE PACKER GORGEOUS
I BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO WHAT'S
HOUSING I DALY DODD BALLY
DOT YOUR BROWSER AYE EGGMAN
AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ I WROTE
AYE HERTZBERG AYE PUESTO
I HER DAUGHTER I JONES I
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
LEYVA AYE THE MOM I AM A WIRE
HI MELENDEZ MAN I NEWMAN
NEWMAN I NIELSEN BUT TROUBLED
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
AYE AMBERG AYE LIKE HUSKY
I WIENER AYE WILK HI PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS AFTER
I COME BY OTHER DALY I DOT
GLAZER HI MELENDEZ NIELSEN BUT
CHAU BOTH I I THIRTY SIX NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMINTA ARE
CONCURRED IN MOVING TO FILE
ITEM ONE HUNDRED SENATOR HUESO
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FIVE NINETY NINE BY
SENATOR WESSEL AN ACT RELATING
TO PUBLIC UTILITIES SENATE
HUESO PRESIDENT'S B.
FIVE NINE NINE SPEC ON
CONCURRENCE IT IS A BILL
THAT PROVIDES CLARIFYING AND
CODE CLEANUP TO CPEC RELATED
STATUTES I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
CENTER HUESO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS ALSO QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE IS THIRTY NINE NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEHMET'S ARE
CONCURRED IN A SKIP ONE OF ONE
FOR THE MOMENT -- ONE OH TO
SENATOR GLAZER MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL SEVEN
EIGHTY FIVE BY SENATOR GLAZER
AN ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC FOR
SECONDARY EDUCATION CENTER
LASER THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION OF
THE CHANGES IN THIS MEASURE
UNTIL THE TWENTY TWENTY THREE
TWENTY FOUR ACADEMIC YEAR THAT
RESPECTFULLY ASTRONOMICAL THANK
YOU CENTER GLAZER MEMBERS ANY
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS
AS QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEN HEARING NONE HIGHS THIRTY
NINE NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN MOVING THE FILE ITEM
ONE OF THREE SENATOR EGGMAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL EIGHT FORTY
TWO BY SENATOR DODD AN ACT
RELATING TO HEALTH CARE EGGMAN
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MA'AM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS TAKING THE
ASSEMBLY WERE I WERE AT THE
REQUEST OF THE DEPARTMENT
OF REHAB TO ADD FLEXIBILITY
TO THE PILOT PROGRAM A TO
AID THE IMPLEMENTATION AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE ON BEHALF OF CENTER
DOT THANK YOU CENTER EGGMAN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MEMBERS IS ALSO IS ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SINGING
HEARING THEN I IS THIRTY NINE
NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
ONE OH FOUR SENATOR NEWMAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL EIGHT FIFTY FIVE BY
SENATOR NEWMAN AN ACT RELATING
TO RECREATIONAL SAFETY CENTER
NEWMAN -- THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I I RISE TO RISEN
SB EIGHT FIFTY FIVE WHICH IS
BACK IN CONCURRENCE AMENDMENTS
DELAY THE START DATE OF THE
PILOT PROGRAM IT JUST THE
REQUIRED REPORTS ACCORDINGLY
AND CHANGE HOW THE PROGRAM
WILL BE FUNDED THROUGH CITY
PH I RESPECTFULLY ASTRONOMICAL
THANK YOU SENATOR NEWMAN
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MEMBERS THIS IS ALSO ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE IS THIRTY NINE
NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
OF FIVE SENATOR RIGHT CASKEY
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL EIGHT NINETY SEVEN
BY SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI AN
ACT RELATING TO LAND USE SENATE
WHITE HOUSE DE MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS THIS IS CITY DO YOU
BILL IT DOES NOT AMENDMENTS IN
THE ASSEMBLY DID NOT ALLOW FOR
A THREE STORY EIGHTY YOU CAN BE
BUILT NEAR NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOR'S
BACKYARD THEY WERE NARROWING
A LITTLE HAIR CUT AND WE ALSO
DEALT WITH SOME CHAPTER HAVE
A MISCARRIAGE AND I FELT THANK
YOU CENTER BY CAL SKI MEMBERS
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THAN MEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN PARTULA I ATKINS BASS
NO PACKER I PORCHES BRADFORD
MICROBIOTA PROTESTING I DALY
NOPE DONT THE RUSSELL I EGGMAN
AYE GLAZER NO GONZALEZ I GROWTH
HERTZBERG BROKE NOW HERTZBERG
WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
NO KAMLAGER AYE PLAYER AYE
FLAVOR AYE LIMÓN I REQUIRE
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN NO -- CHOI BOGUE NO
PAN AYE PORTANTINO ROTH HI
RUBIO SKINNER I STERN HI I'M
BURKE I'D LIKE OWSKI AYE WIENER
AYE WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN ATKINS I
GORGEOUS NO CABALLERO DODD AYE
HERTZBERG MCGUIRE PORTANTINO
RUBIO BAKER I DON'T KNOW
SKULLCAPS THE NUMBERS ONE MORE
TIME ALLEN CUPBEARER HERTZBERG
MCGUIRE PORTANTINO RUBIO HIS
TWENTY THREE KNOWS ELEVEN
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
WE'RE GOING TO FILE ITEM ONE
OF SIX SENATOR PORTANTINO
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL THIRTEEN FIFTY EIGHT
BY SENATOR PORTANTINO AN ACT
RELATING TO STAKE CLAIMS MAKING
APPROPRIATIONS AIRPORT AND
ACQUIRERS THE BARRACKS EXPECT
MEDIALLY SENATOR PORTANTINO
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT S.
S.
B.
THIRTEEN FIFTY EIGHT IS ONE
OF THE ANNUAL BILLS TO MAKE
PAYMENTS FOR CLAIMS AND
SETTLEMENTS ENTERED INTO
BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
IT'S BACK IN THE SENATE FOR
CONCURRENCE AFTER WAS AMENDED
IN THE ASSEMBLY TO APPROPRIATE
AN ADDITIONAL TWO HUNDRED
FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS FROM
THE GENERAL FUND TO PAY FOR
SETTLEMENT FOR AN ATTORNEY'S
FEES IN THE CASE OF INSTITUTE
FOR FREE SPEECH FIRST BONTA
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION TO USING
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ON THIS
ITEM SEEING NO OBJECTION THE
MAJOR AYE AYES ARE THIRTY NINE
NO ZERO ON THE URGENCY I JUST
THIRTY NINE IT KNOWS AS ZERO
ON THAT MEASURE THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS WERE MOVING TO
FILE ITEM NINETY THREE SENATOR
LABOR SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FOR TEN BY CENTER
LEYVA AN ACT RELATING TO
PUBLIC POST SECONDARY EDUCATION
SENATOR LEYVA THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT GOOD AFTERNOON
MEMBERS SENATE BILL FOR
TEN IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS REQUIRE THE
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY TO
IMPLEMENT A NINE STEP SALARY
STEP SYSTEM FOR ALL NON FACULTY
EMPLOYEES I I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU SIR
ELEVEN IN DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR -- TO -- CHAU VOTE
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS
-- I DO HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE
AUTHOR CENTER LEVEL WOULD YOU
LIKE TO TAKE A QUESTION WELL OF
COURSE I WOULD THANK YOU CENTER
LEYVA -- SOONER -- OCHO A BOOK
THANK YOU MISTER PRESIDENT M.
SO I HAVE CONCERNS THAT THIS
BILL WILL BE A VERY LARGE
FINANCIAL BURDEN TO THE CSU
AND ULTIMATELY ADVERSELY HAVE
AN IMPACT ON STUDENTS WHEN THE
COURAGE CORE COURSES ARE CUT
SERVICES ARE REDUCE INCIDENTS
COSTS GO UP QUESTION WHAT IS
THE FORECASTED COSTS FOR THIS
BILL FOR CSU'S I DON'T HAVE
THE FORECAST THE COST RIGHT IN
FRONT OF ME I CAN LOOK IT UP
AND GET IT FOR YOU WE DO KNOW
THAT THERE'S A COST ASSOCIATED
-- BUT WE KNOW THAT THE C.
ISSUES OF HAD TWENTY NINE YEARS
TO PREPARE FOR THIS LAST YEAR
I -- SHELVE THE BILL TO EXCUSE
ME TWO YEARS AGO I SHELVE THE
BILL IT WAS EXACTLY LIKE THIS
AND THIS ISSUES ELSE THAT WE DO
A STUDY TO SEE IF THEY IN FACT
WERE BEHIND ON THEIR SALARY
STEPS THE STUDIES CAME BACK
AND SAID THAT THEY WERE THERE
OBVIOUSLY IS A COST INVOLVED
I DON'T HAVE IT RIGHT HERE IN
FRONT OF ME BUT I CAN GET IT
FOR YOU THANK YOU CENTER LEYVA
THANK YOU CENTER CHOI BOGUE
SENATOR GLAZERS THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I WOULD NOTE
THAT THIS IS A GUT AND AMEND IT
IS YOUR CONTRACT AND -- SORRY
SIX GRAYSON BECAUSE YOU HAVE
WORK OR THANK YOU -- THAT -- WE
HAVE A A UNION REPRESENTING THE
EMPLOYEES AT THE CSU THEY'VE
JUST COMPLETED THEIR CONTRACT
NEGOTIATIONS THIS IS AN ITEM
THAT TYPICALLY BE DISCUSSED
AND RESOLVED IN COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING -- OUR ACTIONS TODAY
TO MAKE THIS CHANGE DOESN'T
COME WITH ANY NEW MONEY FAR AS
I KNOW AND MAYBE IN THE CLOSE
THE -- THE AUTHOR COULD SPEAK
TO WHETHER THERE'S FUNDING
THAT WE'RE GOING TO PROVIDED
THE SYSTEM SO WE CAN GET A
SET AMOUNT OF MONEY EVERY YEAR
AND IF WE PUT NEW REQUIREMENTS
ON THEM AND THE MONEY HAS TO
COME FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE AND I
DON'T HAVE ANY IDEA WHERE THAT
IMPACT WOULD BE ON EMPLOYEES
AND OR AT ANY OTHER OPERATIONS
OF THE SYSTEM SO WE'VE WE'VE
ARGUE VERY HARD ON OUR SIDE
OF THE AISLE FOR COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING -- BUT THEN MEASURES
LIKE THIS ARE END RUNS AROUND
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AREN'T
AREN'T PRODUCTIVE AND HEALTHY
AND FOR THOSE REASONS THAT
WILL BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
TODAY THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZER
MEMBERS ANYMORE DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE ANY OTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING NONE CENTER
LEYVA YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
MR PRESIDENT YES THE COLLECTIVE
BARGAINING PROCESS IS THERE
FOR A REASON AND I AM ALWAYS SO
GLAD TO HEAR CENTER GLAZER THAT
YOU'RE SO -- SUCH SUPPORTER
OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING THEY
HAVE HAD TWENTY NINE YEARS
OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AND
OTHERWISE TO REINSTATE THESE
STEPS FOR THE LOWEST PAID
WORKERS ON THESE CAMPUSES AND
THEY HAVEN'T DONE IT THAT'S
WHAT MAKES OUR JOB SO AWESOME
IS WE CAN SAY HEY THESE ARE
THE LOWEST PAID WORKERS WE
ALLOCATE MONEY EVERY YEAR FROM
THE BUDGET TO SEE ISSUES IF
THEY'RE NOT GOING TO DO THE
RIGHT THING THEN LET'S REQUIRE
THAT THEY DO THE RIGHT THING
THIS BILL WILL MAKE SURE THAT
THE LOWEST PAID WORKERS THE
FOLKS WHO KEEP THE LIGHTS ON
WHO MAKE SURE THE GRASS IS CUT
WHO MAKE SURE THE CAFETERIAS
ARE RUNNING WILL MAKE SURE
THAT THEY ACTUALLY GET A LIVING
WAGE INCREASE SO THAT THEY CAN
FEED THEIR FAMILIES SO YES OF
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING DOESN'T
WORK THEN HOW COOL IS IT THAT
WE ACTUALLY GET TO HELP MAKE
IT WORK MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE TO HELP
ALL OF THESE WORKERS WHO HAVE
BEEN UNDER PAID FOR DECADES
THANK YOU THANK YOU SENATOR
LABOR THAT IS VERY COOL
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN ARCHULETA I ATKINS
AYE BATES BACK NO BETTER
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I HAVE
ITEM OR HAS HE I W.
NO DODD THEY'RE AWESOME I
EGGMAN I GLAZER NOPE GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
WESSEL NO HER TADO I JONES NO
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE LEYVA
AYE THURMOND AYE MCGUIRE I
MELENDEZ NO MAN NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED PAN AYE
PORTANTINO I ROTH I'VE RUBIO
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE NUMBER
AYE FORECASTING AYE WIENER
AYE WILK NO ONE MORE TIME
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN BAKER HI BYRON DODD I
HERTZBERG HI MANY I TROUBLED
RUBIO HI IS TWENTY SIX KNOWS
TEN THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
ARE CONCURRED IN MEMBERS WE ARE
GOING TO GO TO FILE ITEM ONE NO
ONE SENATE BILL SIX FORTY FOUR
CENTER LEYVA SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL SIX FORTY FOUR
BY CENTER LEYVA INACTIVITY INTO
HEALTH CARE COVERAGE SENATOR
LEYVA THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
SB SIX FORTY FOUR IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE IT WILL ALLOW THE
CALIFORNIA TO -- EMPLOYMENT
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT EDT TO
SHARE INFORMATION WITH COVERED
CALIFORNIA FOR THE PURPOSE OF
OUTRAGE ON HEALTH CARE COVERAGE
OPTIONS ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
OR CLARIFYING AND TECHNICAL
IN THIS BILL HAS RECEIVED UNIT
NOT UNANIMOUS BUT BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR LEVIN IN DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ANY
OBJECTION TO USING UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL THE SILENCING NO
OBJECTION ISER THIRTY NINE
AT NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING BACK
TO THE REGULAR FILE WE'RE
GOING TO FILE ITEM FORTY TWO
WHICH IS --
DR PAN CENTER PAN SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY BILL SEVEN
SEVENTY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
MCCARTY AN ACT RELATING TO
STATE PROPERTY CENTER PAN THANK
YOU MR PRESIDENT CENTERS ON
BEHALF OF THE CENTRE MCCARTY
RICE PERCENT EIGHTY SEVEN
SEVEN SEVEN EIGHT DISTRICT BILL
RELATED TO A SOON TO BE SURPLUS
THE PROPERTY AND STUDENT
HOUSING THIS BILL ADDRESSES
TO HIGH PROFILE ISSUES FOR
THE STATE AND MY DISTRICT ONE
INCREASED COLLEGE ENROLLMENT
IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING THE UC
DAVIS MEDICAL CENTER LOCATED
HERE IN SACRAMENTO IT HAS
PLANS UNDERWAY TO EXPAND
ITS ACADEMIC PROGRAMS THIS
BILL WOULD TRANSFER EIGHT
DEPARTMENT JUSTICE PROPERTY
NEAR THE CAMPUS TO UC DAVIS
TWENTY BECOME SURPLUS FOR THE
PURPOSE OF BUILDING STUDENT
HOUSING AND STUDENT SUPPORT
OF SUPPORT OF STUDENT SERVICES
OFF SITE CENTERS LIKE THE UC
DAVIS SACRAMENTO CAMPUS ALLOWS
OUR PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES GROWN
ROMAN SERVE MORE CALIFORNIA
STUDENTS BY PROVIDING HOUSING
TO SUPPORT ENROLLMENT GROWTH
THIS BILL WOULD HELP US ACHIEVE
OUR HIGHER EDUCATION GOALS IN
THE REGION THE STATE AND MEET
HOUSING NEEDS IN OUR COMMUNITY
THREE SEVEN MONTHS FURTHER
CLARIFIED THAT UNIVERSITY
HOUSING IS A PRIORITY AND
THAT'S A SKILLED AND TRAINED
WORKFORCE RECOUP WORKFORCE
REQUIREMENTS THIS BILL IS
SUPPORTED BY THE STATE PIPE
TRADES THE STATE ASSOCIATION
ELECTRICAL WORKERS AND SHEET
METAL WORKERS ESPECIALLY
ASPIRIN I MODES THANK YOU
SENATOR PAN MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEN SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
ARCHULETA I CAN SEE BASED I
BAKER I PORCHES BRADFORD I
HAVE I EVER PROTECTING AYE
TALLY AYE DODD THERE WASN'T
AYE EGGMAN I GLAZER HI GONZALEZ
I DROVE HERTZBERG WESTERN I
HER DAUGHTER I JONES KAMLAGER
I FLARED I LEYVA AYE LEMOND
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
MANY NEWMAN NIELSEN NO --
TROUBLED PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO I SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE AMBER AYE AYE
CASKEY AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ALLEN I ARCHULETA ATKINS
PORCHES CABRERA DODD I GROVE
HERTZBERG JONES HI MELINDA'S
WHEN I NEWMAN BY A CHOI BOGUE
NIELSEN NOTIFY I THIRTY
ONE KNOWS ONE UP SORRY TO
SOMEONE ELSE STE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA I ATKINS FORTUS
CABALLERO GROVE HERTZBERG
MELENDEZ OF CHARRED BOTH
I THIRTY TWO KNOWS
ONE THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS TO LEAVE BUT WE'RE
GONNA PAUSE FOR JUST A MOMENT
I MEMBERS FIND YOUR
SEAT MATE AND HAVE THEM
COME ON BACK WE'RE ABOUT
READY TO GET STARTED
MEMBERS WELCOME BACK WE
ARE GOING TO START WITH A
COUPLE BILLS ON THE SIMPLY
THIRD READING FILE IN FORTY
ONE SENATOR GONZALEZ MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY
BILL TWENTY NINETY ONE BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER MIA BONTA AN
ACT RELATING TO INFORMATION
DISCLOSURE AND DECLARING THEIR
TO SEE THEIR UP TO EXPECT TO BE
DEALING SENATOR GONZALEZ THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
I RISE TODAY TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY NINETY ONE ON BEHALF
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA AS YOU
KNOW EARLIER THIS SUMMER THE
UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT
COURT OVERTURN ROE V.
WADE BY DOING THIS DISTRICT
BURNING PEOPLES ACROSS THE
COUNTRY HAVE A LIFE CHANGING
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT -- TEXAS
ANTI ABORTION LAW ENCOURAGES
PRIVATE CITIZENS TO ACT AS
BOUNTY HUNTERS TO SEEK OUT AND
SUE THOSE WHO PROVIDED ANY FORM
OF SUPPORT TO PEOPLE SEEKING
AN ABORTION NO ONE SHOULD BE
ABLE TO MANIPULATE CALIFORNIA'S
LEGAL SYSTEM TO TARGET AND
PUNISH PEOPLE WHO SEE CARE
HERE AB TWENTY NINETY ONE WILL
ENSURE OUT OF STATE SUBPOENAS
WHICH SEEK INFORMATION RELATED
TO A PATIENT WHO RECEIVED
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE HERE
IN CALIFORNIA ARE NOT GRANTED
THINKING I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
GONZALEZ MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES NO PACKER I
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I COME BY
OTHER CORTESE I TALLY NO DODD I
TRUST THEM EGGMAN AYE PLACER HI
GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
HI WESSEL I HER DAUGHTER I
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE FLARED
AYE LEYVA AYE THURMOND I
MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ NO MAN
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO --
TROUBLE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO
I ROTH FIVE REVIEW I SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE AMBERG AYE
FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE
WILK NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS CABALLERO TORONTO FIVE
MIN I IS THIRTY KNOWS NINE ON
THE URGENCY AS THIRTY KNOWS
NINE THE MEASURE PASSES MOVING
TO FILE ITEM FORTY THREE CENTER
COM WALKER BEN SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY SIX
TWENTY SIX BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
CALDERON AN ACT RELATING TO
HEALING ARTS AND DECLARING THE
URGENCY THERE UP TO CONVICT ME
LIKE CENTCOM LONGER THANK YOU
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I RISE TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY SIX TWENTY SIX ON BEHALF
OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER CALDERON
THIS WILL PROHIBIT CALIFORNIA
PROFESSIONAL BOARDS FROM
REVOKING OR SUSPENDING THE
LICENSE OF A HEALTH PROVIDER
WHO WAS PUNISHED IN ANOTHER
STATE SOLELY FOR PROVIDING
ABORTION CARE TO PATIENTS
BY CODIFYING PROTECTIONS
FOR ABORTION PROVIDERS AB
TWENTY SIX TWENTY SIX WILL
SAFEGUARD RIGHT TO PRIVACY
FOR PATIENTS SEEKING CARE AND
ALLOW HEALTH PRACTITIONERS
TO PROVIDE CARE WITHOUT FEAR
OF PUNISHMENT AGAINST THEIR
LICENSE THIS IS A PRIORITY
FOR THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE
WOMEN'S CAUCUS AND FOR THE
CALIFORNIA COMMISSION ON THE
STATUS OF WOMEN AND GIRLS
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER CAMARGO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA ATKINS
AYE BATES NO FACTOR I PORCHES
BRADFORD I KERR BY OTHER
COURTESY HI SALLY NO DODD HI
TO RAZA EGGMAN I GLAZER HI
GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
I PUESTO I HER DAUGHTER I
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED
HI LEYVA I LIMON I REQUIRE
AYE HERNANDEZ NO MAN NEWMAN
AYE AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER STERN AYE
AMBERG AYE FORECASTING AYE
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA I
PURCHASE NO CABALLERO RUSSELL
TORONTO I MANY HI A CHOI
BOGUE NO SKINNER I IS THIRTY
KNOWS NINE ON THE URGENCY
IS THIRTY KNOWS NINE THE
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
ARE NOW GOING TO MOVE TO OUR
OWN UNFINISHED BUSINESS FILE
ITEM THREE SENATOR HER TADO
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TEN EIGHTY FOUR
BY SENATOR HER TADO AN ACT
RELATING TO PROPERTY AND THE
CLAIM THERE TO SEE THEIR OF
TAKE TO TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY
CENTER HER TADO I THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE TODAY
TO PRESENT SB TEN TEN EIGHTY
FOR THE FOOD AND FARM SECURITY
ACT WHICH IS BACK FROM THE
ASSEMBLY ON CONCURRENCE SB TEN
EIGHTY FOUR PUTS CALIFORNIA
IN CONTROL OF ITS FOOD SUPPLY
CHAIN BY PREVENTING FOREIGN
GOVERNMENTS FROM PURCHASING
AGRICULTURAL LAND AND REQUIRING
THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF
FOOD AND AGRICULTURE TO ISSUE
AN ANNUAL REPORT ON FORM OR
OWNERSHIP OF CALIFORNIA'S
RESOURCES ASSEMBLY MEMBERS HAVE
AT LEAST INTO THE PROHIBITION
IN THE BILL CLOSING THE
LOOPHOLE AND ADDED AN URGENCY
CLAUSE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU SAID HER
TADO DIDN'T DISCUSSION DEBATE
SENATOR GROWTH FIRST THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I TO HER
RISE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF SB
TEN EIGHTY FOUR AND THIS YEAR
WE'VE SEEN WHAT HAPPENS IS ME
DID YOU RECEIVE WHAT HAPPENS
WHEN THERE'S A DISRUPTION IN
GLOBAL ENERGY SUPPLY WITH A
RUSSIAN INVASION OF UKRAINE
AND I'VE HIGHLIGHTED MANY TIMES
THE IMPORTANCE OF CALIFORNIA'S
DOMESTIC PRODUCTION TO ASSURE
OUR OWN ENERGY SECURITY MEMBERS
FOOD SECURITY IS EQUALLY
IMPORTANT AND THE CALIFORNIA
AGRICULTURAL INDUSTRY -- HELPS
FEED NOT ONLY OUR STATE BUT
THE NATION IN THE WORLD I HAVE
THE TOP THREE FOOD PRODUCING
COUNTIES IN THE WORLD IN MY
DISTRICT -- I HAVE THE HONOR
REPRESENT TWO OF THE THREE
AGRICULTURE PRODUCING COUNTIES
CLEAR CLEARING KERN I'M WORKING
ON FRESNO -- CALIFORNIA GROWS
FOUR HUNDRED FOOD AND FIBER
PRODUCTS INCLUDING A THIRD OF
THE COUNT COUNT A COUNTRY'S
VEGETABLES AND TWO THIRDS
OF THE NATION'S FRUITS AND
NUTS THE GOLDEN STATE IS
ALSO THE ONLY PRODUCER OF
MANY COMMODITIES INCLUDING
ARTICHOKES OLIVES PISTACHIOS
ALMONDS JUST TO NAME A FEW
THAT'S WHY IT'S VERY IMPORTANT
WE GET WATER BECAUSE NO ONE
ELSE IN THE WORLD GROWS THESE
PRODUCTS AND FURTHER WE LEAD
THE NATION IN THE SUPPLIED
ABOUT SEVENTY FIVE TOTAL FOODS
SUCH AS BROCCOLI MANDARINS
CARROTS CORN STRAWBERRIES AND
MORE THAT'S WHY WE DESPERATELY
WATER TO GROW THIS FOOD AND
THAT'S WHY I'M SUPPORTING THIS
BILL AND WE NEED TO PROHIBIT
DEACTIVATION OF CALIFORNIA
AGRICULTURE LANDS BY FOREIGN
ENTITIES SUCH AS CHINA SOME OF
THESE LAND ACQUISITIONS COULD
POSE A SIGNIFICANT NATIONAL
SECU OF SECURITY RISKS WITH
FOOD SECURITY ISSUES CURRENTLY
IN NORTH DAKOTA THERE IS
A CONTROVERSY OVER CHINESE
COMPANY WITH TIES TO THE
GOVERNMENT BUYING FARMLAND JUST
TWELVE MILES FROM GRAND FORKS
AIRFORCE BASE AND -- WE HAVE
A LOT OF AGRICULTURAL LAND OUR
LAND HERE IN CALIFORNIA AROUND
OUR MILITARY BASES AND IT IT
MAKES SENSE TO JUST SAY NO TO
FOREIGN OWNERSHIP IN GENERAL
IT'S NEVER BEEN MORE IMPORTANT
TO ENSURE THAT PRIORITIZING THE
PROTECTION OF OUR FARMLAND AND
FOOD SECURITY IS AN ISSUE S.
SPECIFICALLY HERE IN THE STATE
AND FOR THE GREAT UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA AND PLUG THE AUTHOR
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD
THANK YOU CENTER GROVE MEMBERS
IF WE CAN JUST STICK TO THE
AMENDMENTS WE ARE BACK ON
CONCURRENCE THAT WOULD BE GREAT
SENATOR NIELSEN YOU'RE UP NEXT
THE AMENDMENTS DO NOT IMPROVE
THE MEASURE WHAT WOULD IMPROVE
THE MEASURE IS TO NOT ALLOW
FOREIGN NATIONS AND INTEREST
TO ACQUIRE MORE OF OUR LAND
AGRICULTURAL LAND THIS IS
GETTING TO BE A VERY SERIOUS
ISSUE AND WE BETTER WAKE UP
AND PAY ATTENTION TO IT THANK
YOU SENATOR NELSON SENATOR
ALAN MEMBERS CENTER TADO IS
ALL VALLEY HIGHER TONIGHT VOTE
THANK YOU SENATOR ALAN MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
SEEING THEN SENT HER TOPIC
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I THINK
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NAY VOTE
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT WE'RE GOING
TO DO A ROLL CALL VOTE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES AYE PACKER
AYE PORCHES AYE BRADFORD HI
COME BY OTHER CORTESE AYE
TALLY AYE DODD AYE TO RUSSELL
I EGGMAN AYE PLACER AYE
GONZALEZ I GROWTH I HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES I KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED
AYE FLAVOR AYE FOR THE MONTH
I REQUIRE I'VE MELENDEZ I
HAVE MANY NEWMAN I NIELSEN
AYE A TROUBLED AYE PAN AYE
PORTANTINO I ROTH FIVE RUBIO
I SKINNER AYE STERN AYE
AMBERG AYE BY KASKI HI WIENER
WELL HI PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS COME
BY OTHER MEN WIENER
THIRTY SEVEN NO ZERO ON THE
URGENCY IS THIRTY SEVEN NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
ANSAR CONCURRED IN MOVING
TO FILE ITEM FIVE SENATOR
NEWMAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL ELEVEN
THIRTY ONE BY SENATOR NEWMAN
AN ACT RELATING TO ADDRESS
CONFIDENTIALITY AND DECLARING
THE URGENCY THERAPISTS TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY CENTER
NEWMAN THANK YOU MADAM PESAR
RICE RESENT THIRTEEN ELEVEN
THIRTY ONE WHICH IS BACK IN
CONCURRENCE AMENDMENTS TAKE IN
THE ASSEMBLY EXPAND ELIGIBILITY
AND CALIFORNIA'S SAFE AT
HOME PROGRAM TO ALL PUBLIC
EMPLOYEES AND OTHERS PERFORMING
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTED WORK WHO
FIND THEMSELVES THE SUBJECT
OF CREDIBLE THREATS ARISING
FROM THAT WORK THIS IS AN
URGENCY MEASURE TO ALLOW
US TO IMPLEMENT THESE MUCH
NEEDED PROVISIONS IMMEDIATELY
I RESPECTFULLY ASK HER AYE
VOTE TODAY THANK YOU SENATOR
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES BAKER I PORCHES
BRADFORD I HAVE A ADAM CORTESE
HI TALLY DODD HI TORONTO I
EGGMAN HI GLAZER GLAZER HI
GONZALEZ I BROKE HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HER DAUGHTER I
JONES KAMLAGER I DECLARED AYE
FLAVOR AYE THE MON I REQUIRE
HI MELENDEZ NOPE MEN NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
PAN I PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN
AYE AMBERG AYE WAKE AYE SKI
AYE WIENER I WILK NO PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS BATES
PORCHES CABALLERO DALY GROVE
JONES MANY HI A TROUBLED
IS THIRTY KNOWS THREE ON THE
URGENCY IS THIRTY KNOWS THREE
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN MOVING TO FILE
ITEM NUMBER TEN SENATOR COM
LONGER MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
SEVENTY THREE BY SENATOR
KAMLAGER AN ACT RELATING TO
LAND USE AND DECLARING THEIR
TO SEE THEIR OF STICKER TO
MEDIALLY CENTCOM WATER GOOD
AFTERNOON MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS SB THIRTEEN SEVENTY
THREE WAS AMENDED IN THE
ASSEMBLY TO NARROW THE BILL
THE ONLY THE CITY OF LA THE
SPECIFIC ISSUE WAS THE TERM
LOCAL AGENCY WHICH CAN BE
CONSTRUED TO INCLUDE NON
CITY ENTITIES THAT MEET THE
POPULATION THRESHOLD BEYOND
CITY OF LA THE DEPARTMENT
OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
SUGGESTED THESE AMENDMENTS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS THANK YOU CENTER
COM LONGER MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE M.
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES BAKER I PORCHES
BRADFORD I COME BY OTHER COURTS
HAS HE AYE TALLY DODD I TO
RUSSELL AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES HI KAMLAGER I FLARED I
LEYVA I FOR THE MOST HI MCGUIRE
HI MELENDEZ MANY AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN A TROUBLED AYE PAN
AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH I RUBIO
I SKINNER I STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE
WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BATES PORGES CABALLERO
DALY GROVE MELENDEZ NIELSEN
I THIRTY THREE NO ZERO ON THE
URGENCY I'M SORRY THREE NO ZERO
ON CONCUR THE ASSEMBLY MEMINTA
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS ARE MOVING
TO FILE ITEM NINETEEN SENATOR
HER TADO MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL NINE
TEN BY SENATOR HER TADO AN ACT
RELATING TO TRIBAL GAMING AND
ACQUIRING THE URGENCY THERE
OF ITS STATE TO TAKE EFFECT
IMMEDIATELY CENTER TUNNEL
PASS ON FILE MEMBERS
WE ARE WORKING ON AN
ADDITIONAL SUPPLEMENTAL
FINAL SO HANG TIGHT
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO GO BACK
TO FILE ITEM NINETEEN SENATOR
HER TADO MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL NINE
TEN VICE UNDER HER TADO AN
ACT RELATING TO TRIBAL GAMING
AND DECLARING THEIR DISEASE'S
URGENCY BARRACKS TO ACCEPT
ME DEALING CENTER HER TITLE
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
SENATE BILL NINE TEN AS A
VEHICLE TO RATIFY THE TRIBAL
STATE GAMING COMPACT BETWEEN
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND
THE TEN HOME INDIAN TRIBE THE
PROPOSED RESORT CASINO HOTEL
SUCCEEDED WITH THIS COMPACT
WOULD BE THE FIRST AND ONLY
TRIBAL GAMING PROJECT IN KERN
COUNTY CREATING NEARLY FIVE
THOUSAND NEW JOBS MOSTLY LOCAL
MANY UNIONIZE FOR THE REGION
INCLUDING THREE THOUSAND THREE
HUNDRED PERMANENT JOBS AND
ONE THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED SIX
HUNDRED FORTY CONSTRUCTION JOBS
FOR THIS ECONOMICALLY DEPRESSED
AREA THE PROJECT IS UNANIMOUSLY
SUPPORTED BY THE KERN COUNTY
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS LOCAL LAW
ENFORCEMENT LOCAL CHAMBERS OF
COMMERCE AND THE KERN COUNTY
DELEGATION OF THE CALIFORNIA
STATE SENATE THE CALIFORNIA
STATE ASSEMBLY AND THE US
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
LABOR UNIONS REMAIN SOLIDLY
IN SUPPORT OF A COMPACT THE
BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION ON
FILE AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR NAY VOTE THE CENTER HER
TADO MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR A UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE HI SIR HI SIR
NINE ON THE URGENCY I THREE
NINE ZERO ON THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS OF THE SUPPLEMENTAL
FILE WILL BE READY SHORTLY
SO STAY WHERE YOU ARE PLEASE
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS YOU SHOULD
ALL HAVE YOUR SUPPLEMENTAL
FILE IN FRONT OF YOU IF YOUR
SEAT MATE IS NOT SITTING NEXT
TO YOU FIND THEM AND BRING
THEM BACK TO THE FLOOR PLEASE
--
TO THE
MEMBERS ARE GONNA START
WITH FILE ITEM ONE OH SEVEN
CENTER PORTANTINO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOUR FIFTY SEVEN BY
SENATOR PORTANTINO AND
AFTER THAT IT'S TAXATION
AND MAKING A PERFORATION
THEREFORE CENTER PORTANTINO
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS -- SB FOUR FIVE SEVEN
IT'S COME BACK ON CONCURRENCE
YOU KNOW WE SPENT AN AWFUL
AMOUNT OF TIME -- YOU KNOW I
DRIVE MY CAR I RIDE MY BICYCLE
-- -- WE SPEND A LOT OF TIME
CONCERNED ABOUT HOW WE GET TO
WORK AND HELPING THOSE HARD
WORKING CALIFORNIANS -- AND
I SUPPORT HELPING THEM PAY
FOR THEIR GAS AND LOWERING
GAS PRICES IN HELPING AS
WE CAN BUT WE SHOULD ALSO
RECOGNIZE THAT THERE ARE FOLKS
WHO USE ALTERNATIVE MODES
OF TRANSPORTATION RIDE THEIR
BICYCLES WALK AND WE SHOULD
TRY TO FIND AN INCENTIVE TO
HELP THEM -- AND SO THIS BILL
CREATES A THOUSAND DOLLAR
REFUNDABLE TAX CREDIT FOR
THOSE FOLKS TO GIVE UP THEIR
CAR OR DON'T USE THEIR CAR
RELATIVE TO THEIR FAMILY SIZE
SO LET'S INCENTIVIZE ALTERNATE
TRANSPORTATION AND VOTE AYE
ON THIS BEFORE FIVE SEVEN
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
CENTER MELINDA'S THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT -- WE DON'T
GIVE A BREAK IN TAXES WHEN IT
COMES TO GAS TO CALIFORNIANS
WE DON'T DO THAT THE TAXES
KEEP GOING UP WE DON'T GIVE
A BREAK TO PEOPLE WHO CAN'T
GET SOME SORT OF HYBRID OR
ELECTRIC VEHICLE WHO HAVE TO
DRIVE A REGULAR FULL SIZE BAGEL
HEAVY DUTY VEHICLE WE DON'T
GIVE THEM A BREAK AND LOTS OF
PEOPLE THEY NEED TO DO THAT
FOR THEIR JOBS FOR THE FAMILIES
DEPENDING ON WHERE WE LIVE
WE DO NOT GIVE THOSE PEOPLE
BREAK SO HOW ABOUT THIS HOW
ABOUT WE MAKE THIS EQUITABLE
SINCE WE LET THAT WORD FOR
EVERYONE AND GIVE EVERYONE A
BREAK BEFORE WE START SINGLING
OUT CERTAIN GROUPS WE HAPPEN
TO LIKE MORE THAN THE OTHERS
THANK YOU SENATOR MELINDA'S
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SENATOR NIELSEN MADAM
PRESIDENT THIS IS NOT UNCOMMON
PARTICULARLY THIS TIME OF YEAR
IT'S THE NORM NOT THE EXCEPTION
THAT I UNDERSTAND THIS BILL
DID NOT HAVE A COMMITTEE HERE
I WOULD VOTE NO FOR THAT REASON
ALONE THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN
MEMBERS FOR THE SENATOR JONES
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I'M GONNA SUPPORT AS
BEFORE FIFTY SEVEN -- YOU KNOW
WITH IT WHENEVER WE CAN GIVE
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS SOME MONEY
BACK I WOULD SUPPORT THAT I
WOULD ALSO ENCOURAGES BODY TO
CONSIDER THAT AS THE GOVERNOR
IS CONSIDERING -- TAX REBATES
BASED ON CAR REGISTRATION
IN HOMES IN THIS BILL DEALS
WITH HOMES THAT DON'T HAVE
REGISTERED CARS WE MIGHT ALSO
WANT TO THINK ABOUT HOW WE CAN
SUPPORT OUR MILITARY PERSONNEL
THAT LIVE IN SERVING CALIFORNIA
BUT HAVE THEIR AUTOMOBILES
REGISTERED IN THEIR HOME STATES
AND -- YOU KNOW THEY'RE LEFT
OUT ON THIS REBATE PROGRAM
SO LET'S SEE IF WE CAN FIND
A WAY TO HELP THEM TO THANK
YOU THANK YOU CENTER JONES
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEN HEARING NINE CENTER
PORTANTINO WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE YES FOR AN AYE VOTE
MENTAL SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD I COME BEARING
COURTESY DALY I DOT HI THE
RUSSELL AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES I KAMLAGER LAYERED I
FAVOR I FOR THE MOST MCGUIRE
AYE MELENDEZ MANY AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- TROUBLED
AYE PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE AMBERG AYE
FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE WILK
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
FORTUS CABALLERO CORTEZ I GROVE
KAMLAGER HI LIMÓN I MELENDEZ
WELL I THIRTY THREE KNOWS
WANT THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
ARE CONCURRED IN MOVING TO
FILE ITEM ONE OH EIGHT CENTER
HERTZBERG MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL
NINE EIGHTY NINE BY SENATOR
HERTZBERG AN ACT RELATING TO
TAXATION AND DECLARING THEIR
TO SEE THEIR UPSTATE TO TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY CENTER
HERTZBERG THANK YOU VERY MUCH
PROPOSITION NINETEEN WAS PASSED
OVERWHELMINGLY BY THE VOTERS TO
PREVENT A MASSIVE TAX INCREASE
WHEN HOMEOWNERS MOVE THERE
WAS A CHALLENGE WITH RESPECT
TO HOW THE MECHANICS WORKED
-- IN THIS -- THE EFFORT HERE
WAS TO MAKE SURE THE TAXPAYERS
THAT DON'T PAY -- WELL THE
ASSESSORS ARE TRYING TO MAKE
A DETERMINATION ON OF THE NEW
TAXES APPLIES TO LOS ANGELES
COUNTY OTHER COUNTIES CAN OFTEN
ASK THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEN MA'AM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS BATES AYE BECKER AYE
FORTUS AYE BRADFORD AYE CUP
AYE OTHER CORTESE AYE DOUBLY
AYE DODD AYE TO RUSSELL I
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH HERTZBERG I
QUESTION AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES I KAMLAGER HI THERE
I'D LEYVA ICE LIMÓN HI WIRE
MELENDEZ AYE MIN I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN A CHOI BOGUE AYE PAN
AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN AYE
AMBERG HI WHITE HOUSE V.
I.
WE -- I WILK PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ATKINS BYE BYE EVER GROVE
MCGUIRE AYE NIELSEN WELCOME
I THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO ON THE
URGENCY I CITY FIVE KNOWS
ZERO ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN THE FILE ITEM
ONE OH NINE SENATOR PAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE SENATE BILL FOURTEEN
SEVENTY THREE BY SENATOR PAN
AN ACT RELATING TO HEALTH
CARE COVERAGE AND THE CURRENT
DECLARING THE URGENCY THERE
OF TO TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY
CENTER PAM THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATORS SB FOURTEEN
SEVENTY THREE IS BACK IN THE
SENATE AND THIS IS A BILL IF
REQUESTED THE ADMINISTRATION
TO ENSURE THAT COVERT NINETEEN
TESTING CONTINUES TO BE COVERED
BENEFIT AS WELL AS TREATMENTS
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS UPDATE
SB FIVE TEN FROM LAST YEAR
RELATED TO HEALTH INSURANCE
COVERAGE FOR COVERT NINETEEN
TESTS VACCINATIONS INCLUDE
THERAPEUTICS EXTENDS THE OUT
OF NETWORK COVERAGE WITHOUT
COST SHARING TO SIX MONTHS
FOR TESTING VACCINES AND
THERAPEUTICS AFTER A PUBLIC
HEALTH EMERGENCY PROHIBITS
PROVIDER SINCE ANY PATIENTS
TO COLLECTIONS AND PROTECTS
PLANTS FROM CRIMINAL LIABILITY
FOR TRANSACTIONS THAT OCCURRED
DURING TO RESPECTIVELY PERIOD
AND INDICATE SERVICES RELAY
THE COVER NINETEEN DIAGNOSTIC
AND SCREENING TESTING DOES
NOT INCLUDE BONUS PAYMENTS FOR
USE A SPECIALIZED EQUIPMENT
EXPEDITED PROCESSING THIS IS
HELP FACILITATE ACCESS TO TREAT
PROGRAMS THE AMENDMENTS HAVE
REMOVED OPPOSITION FROM THE
HEALTH PLANS ESPECIALLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY MINUTES THANK YOU
FOR A NEW MORNING ALL OF
THE AMENDMENTS FOR US --
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MA'AM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
BATES BAKER BAKER I PORCHES
BRADFORD AYE CABRERA COURTESY
BALLY DOT I TO RUSSELL I EGGMAN
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
GROWTH HERTZBERG I REQUEST SO
I HER DAUGHTER I JONES KAMLAGER
AYE FLARED AYE FLAVOR AYE
SIMONE I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
MANY I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN A
TROUBLED AYE PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH FIVE RUBIO I SKINNER I
STERN AYE AMBERG AYE BY CASKEY
I WINNER I WILK PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS SPACE
VERGES CABRERA CORTESE I
DALY GROVE JONES MELENDEZ
NIELSEN WILK HI I CITY ONE
NO ZERO ON THE URGENCY I CITY
ONE KNOWS ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM ONE TEN SENATOR DODD
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FIVE SIXTY ONE BY
SENATOR DODD AN ACT RELATING
TO HOUSING SENATOR DODD THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TO CODIFY THE
GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER
WHICH DIRECTED DGS THE C.
D.
TO ID EXISTE PRONE PROPERTY
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECTS
THERE'S NO OPPOSITION THE
BILL RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
CONCURRENCE THE SENATE DOT
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS EIGHT BAKER I PORCHES I
BRADFORD CABALLERO BRADFORD AYE
CABALLERO PROTESTING HI DOLLY
DODD AYE DERISIVE AYE EGGMAN
EGGMAN I GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
I GROWTH HERTZBERG I REQUEST
SO I HER DAUGHTER I JONES NO
KAMLAGER I FLARED I LEYVA AYE
LIMÓN I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
MANY AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN A
TROUBLED I PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN I AM BURKE AYE
FORECASTING AYE WIENER WELL
I WIENER AYE WILK NOW PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS
BATES CABALLERO DALY NO GROWTH
NO MELENDEZ NO NIELSEN NO I
THIRTY ONE OH SIX ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN MOVING
TO FILE ITEM ONE ELEVEN SENATOR
MEN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL EIGHT SIXTY THREE
BY SENATOR MAN AN ACT RELATING
TO DOMESTIC VIOLENCE CENTERMAN
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT S.
THIS BILL -- EXPANDS THE SCOPE
OF THAT DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
THAT THREE TEAMS TO INCLUDE
NEAR DEATH ADJOURNMENTS IN
THE ASSEMBLY WERE TECHNICAL
SUPPORT SUPPORT I RESPECTFULLY
ASK YOUR IDOL THINKCENTRE
MEN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS IS ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE I THIRTY NINE
KNOWS ZERO ASSEMBLY MEMBER
ANSAR CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
ONE TWELVE SENATOR PORTANTINO
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE RE
SENATE BILL EIGHT SEVENTY
BY SENATOR PORTANTINO AND I
FOR LEADING TO DEVELOPMENTAL
SERVICES CENTER PORTANTINO
SB EIGHT SEVENTY IS BACK
ON CONCURRENCY DEALS WITH
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES
AND THE CONCURRENT ITEMS
ADDED CO AUTHORS THANK YOU
CENTER PORTANTINO MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING THEM MEMBERS
THIS IS ALSO ELIGIBLE FOR
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS THERE
ANY OBJECTION HEARING AND
SEEING NONE I THIRTY NINE NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTEEN SENATOR EGGMAN MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL EIGHT SEVENTY SEVEN
BY SENATOR EGGMAN AND AFTER
RELATING TO CRIME VICTIMS
AND MAKING AN APPROPRIATION
THEREFORE CENTER EGGMAN THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS
SB EIGHT SEVENTY SEVEN IS THE
VICTIMS COMPENSATION FUND THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ADDRESS
CHAPTER IN HIS SHOES I ASK FOR
YOUR ABOUT THANK YOU SENATOR
EGGMAN MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS IS ALSO
ELIGIBLE FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL ANY OBJECTION SEEING
NONE IS THIRTY NINE NO ZERO
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
FIFTEEN ALSO SENATOR EGGMAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL NINE TWENTY NINE BY
SENATOR EGGMAN AN ACT RELATING
TO MENTAL HEALTH CENTER EGGMAN
THANK YOU VERY MUCH -- BEEN A
PRESIDENT AGAIN S.
B.
NINE TWENTY NINE IS -- ONE
OF OUR DATA COLLECTION ON
FOR MENTAL HEALTH THIS --
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ADDED
IN SOME OF DR WOODS -- BEEN
WHILE DATA COLLECTION BILLS
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR EGGMAN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEN
MEMBERS THIS IS ALSO ELIGIBLE
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING THEN I IS THIRTY
NINE NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM ONE SIXTEEN SENATOR PAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL NINE FORTY FOUR BY
SENATOR PAN AN ACT RELATING TO
THE CALIFORNIA HEALTH BENEFIT
EXCHANGE SENATOR PAM THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SENATORS
SB FIVE NINE FOUR FOUR IS
BACK TO SENATE ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS REQUIRES
COVERED CALIFORNIA TO REDUCE
COST SHARING IT FUNDED THROUGH
APPROPRIATION THE BUDGET ACT
WHICH WE HAVE THREE HUNDRED
MILLION I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
CONCURRENCE ON ASSEMBLY MINUTES
THANK YOU CENTER PAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING THEM MA'AM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS BATES NO
BAKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD AYE
BY OTHER COURTS HAVE SEEN HI
KELLY NO DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
GROVE NO HERTZBERG AYE WESSEL
AYE HURTADO AYE JONES NO
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE LEYVA
AYE LEMOND AYE MCGUIRE HI
MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN AYE
NUMBER HI FI CASKET I WISH I
FELT PLEASE WELL THE UP PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS
CABALLERO GONZALEZ I TRIED BOTH
WILK NO THIS IS TWENTY EIGHT
KNOWS EIGHTY ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
SEVENTEEN SENATOR LEE MONNING
IS SHE CLOSE BY ALL RIGHT
WE'RE GOING TO SKIP HER FOR
A MOMENT AND GO TO FILE ITEM
ONE EIGHTY ONE EIGHTEEN CENTER
PORTANTINO MEN SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL NINE SEVENTY
FOUR BY SENATOR PORTANTINO
AND ACTIVISTS NATURALLY OCCUR
COVENS THE SENATOR PORTANTINO
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
BILL FOR ME -- THAT WAS
BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION BY A
CONSTITUENT WHO -- FACE THE
DAUNTING DECISION OF WHETHER
TO PAY OUT OF POCKET FOR FOLLOW
UP IMAGING OR TO FORGO GETTING
THAT DIAGNOSTIC TREATMENT SHE
NEEDED TO HELP SAVE HER LIFE
AND SO IT'S BACK ON CONCURRENCE
THERE'S BEEN SOME DEDUCTIBLE
HEALTH PLAN -- LANGUAGE ADDED
AND -- I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
THEN MEMBERS THIS IS CORDLESS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEN
HEARING NONE I SAY NINE NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MOMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
NINETEEN CENTER ARCH ALETTA MEN
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE EIGHTY FOUR BY SEVEN
ARCHULETA AND ACTUALLY TO
MILITARY SERVICE CENTER TO LET
IT THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
I RISE TO PRESENT SENATE BILL
NINETY FOUR WHICH IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE THIS BILL IS IN
SUPPORT OF OUR NATIONAL GUARD
STATE EMPLOYEES AND IT'LL
HELP THEIR FAMILIES WHEN IT
PERTAINS TO THEIR LEAD TIME
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
DUTY ARE YOUR THANK YOU CENTER
ARCHULETA MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
THEN MEMBERS HAS ALSO QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE IS THIRTY
NINE NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM ONE TWENTY SENATOR ALAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
THE BILL TEN IF SEVENTY
EIGHT BY SENATOR ALAN AN ACT
RELATING TO COASTAL RESOURCES
CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS THIS
IS A BILL THAT IS IN GREATER
ENTIRELY PERMISSIVE REVOLVING
LOAN PROGRAM AND IT'S ENJOY
A GREAT RANGE OF BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT THE ASSEMBLYMEMBERS
TRIGGERED IMPLEMENTATION OF
THIS PROGRAM WHEN THREE LETTERS
REQUESTING IN OUR RECEIVE
FROM LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
AND I SAID FASHIONABLE THANK
YOU CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE THEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
SORRY SENATOR WILL TO I MISS
YOU ARE YOU SURE ALL RIGHT
I WANT TO MAKE SURE YOU GET
EVERYTHING OUT YOU NEED TO
GET OUT UNLESS SAYS SESSION
OKAY MEN SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS BATES
BAKER I FOR JUST BRADFORD I
CABALLERO COURTS HAD HI KELLY
NO DODD I DORADO I EGGMAN I
GLAZER I GONZALEZ I GROWTH
HERTZBERG I WESTERN I HER
DAUGHTER I JONES NO KAMLAGER
WHERE I'D LEYVA I FOR THE MONTH
I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN
AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A
CHOI BOGUE PAN I PORTANTINO
I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN I AM BURKE I WHITE
HOUSE HE AYE FLEENER AYE
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS BATES
FOR JUST CABALLERO GROVE NO
KAMLAGER HI A TRUCK BROKE
I TWENTY NINE NO SIX THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY ONE
SENATOR PORTANTINO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL ELEVEN THIRTY SIX BY
SENATOR PORTANTINO AN ACT
RELATING TO ENVIRONMENTAL
QUALITY CENTER PORTANTINO
-- SB ELEVEN THIRTY SIX IS
A BACK ON CONCURRENCE THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS CLARIFY
THE MEASURE AND NARROW ITS
SCOPE AND RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEN HEARING NONE
MEMBERS IS ALSO QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL ANY
OBJECTION SITTING IN HEARING
NONE HIGHS THIRTY NINE NO ZERO
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
TWENTY TWO SENATOR ALAN MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL TWELVE OH FIVE BY SENATOR
ALAN AN ACT FOR LINDA WATER
CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS THIS
BILL CALLS ON THE STATE WATER
BOARD TO DEVELOP REGULATIONS
ESTABLISHING A METHODOLOGY
TO ACCOUNT FOR THE EFFECTS
OF CLIMATE CHANGE AND THAT WE
STILL HAVE ON WATER RESOURCES
THE BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION
I'D ENJOY SUPPORT FROM AQUA
AND ALSO THE ENVIRONMENT
COMMUNITY -- THE AMENDMENTS
CLARIFY THE WATER BOARD'S
CRAFTING -- IT'S REGULATION
CONSIDERING HOW CLIMATE CHANGE
IS AFFECTING WATER RATES
AVAILABILITY PERMIT DECISIONS
MOTHER DURING THAT THEY WON'T
HOLD UP CURRENT PENDING WATER
RIGHTS APPLICATIONS AND WITH
THAT OUR SUCCESSFUL THANK
YOU CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
BATES BAKER I PORCHES BRADFORD
HI CABALLERO CORTEZ HE DALY
DODD AYE TORONTO AYE EGGMAN
I GLAZER I GONZALEZ I GROWTH
HERTZBERG AYE WESSEL AYE HER
TADO JONES I KAMLAGER HI THERE
I LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE
I MELENDEZ MANY I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN BUT CHOI BOGUE AYE PAN
AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO
I SKINNER I STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE BY CASKEY FIVE WIENER
I WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ATKINS BATES I
PORCHES CABALLERO OR TESTING
DALY GROSS HURTADO MELENDEZ
NIELSEN I I THIRTY TWO KNOWS
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMINTA
ARE CONCURRED AND MOVING BACK
TO FILE ITEM ONE SEVENTEEN
SENATOR LIMON BENHAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL NINE
SIXTY SIX BY SENATOR LIMÓN
AN ACT RELATING TO MEDICAL
CENTRE LIMÓN THANK YOU MEMBERS
SB NINE SIX SIX IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE AND DEALS WITH OUR
HEALTH CARE ISSUE RELATED TO
RURAL CLINICS I RESPECTFULLY
ASK HER TO HAVE A THANK
YOU CENTER LIMÓN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING THEM MEMBERS THIS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
SEEING AND HEARING NONE I SEE
NINE NINE ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEHMET'S ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS ARE GOING TO FILE
ITEM ONE FOURTEEN CENTER LEYVA
MEMBERS OF WE CAN HAVE YOUR
ATTENTION ON THE FLOOR PLEASE
SECRETARY PLEASE READ MORE
SENATE BILL NINE SIXTEEN
BY CENTER LEFT AN ACT
RELATING TO SEXUAL ASSAULT
LEYVA YOU'RE RECOGNIZED THANK
YOU MISTER PRESIDENT SB NINE
SIXTEEN IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
SB NINE SIXTEEN AIMS TO FURTHER
EMPOWER SURVIVORS OF SEXUAL
ASSAULT ACROSS CALIFORNIA
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
WERE TECHNICAL IN CLARIFYING
THIS BILL HAS RECEIVED NO NO
VOTES AND HAS NO OPPOSITION
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
LEYVA MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE ON THIS ITEM SEEING
NO DISCUSSION DEBATE THIS
ITEM QUALIFIES UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL SENATE JACKSON UNANIMOUS
ROLL CALL SEEING NONE ISER
FORTY NO ZERO MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS WE ARE GIVING THINGS
BACK IN ORDER UP HERE JUST
GIVE US A MINUTE PLEASE
DO NOT LEAVE THE FLOOR
MEMBERS I HAVE SOME AMAZING
NEWS WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A
THIRTY FIVE MINUTE BREAK PLEASE
BE BACK HERE IN CHAMBERS AT
SIX OH FIVE THANK YOU SO MUCH
WE NEED ALL MEMBERS
ON THE FLOOR PLEASE
SENATOR HERTZBERG WE
ARE LOOKING FOR YOU
WE'RE GOING TO YOU FIRST
RIGHT MEMBERS WE'RE STARTING
WITH FILE ITEM FORTY SEVEN
SENATOR HERTZBERG MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY TWELVE
TWELVE TWENTY SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS LEVINE AN ACT
RELATING TO FIREARMS MAKING A
PERFORATION THEREFORE INDECLINE
THERE'S A SIERRA STICK
ACCUMULATE CENTER HERTZBERG
THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MADAM PRESIDENT SINCE THE --
BEGINNING OF COVERT NINETEEN
PAYMENT PANDEMIC THERE'S BEEN A
ON PRESIDENT'S SURGEON FIREARMS
AMMUNITION SALES ACROSS THIS
COUNTRY THE SURGEON FIREARMS
AMMUNITION SALES AND PROFITS
HAS OCCURRED ALONGSIDE AN
UNPRECEDENTED NATIONWIDE SPIKE
IN SHOOTING AND GUN HOMICIDES
IN MAY THIS YEAR JUST IN
MAY THIS YEAR THE CENTER FOR
DISEASE CONTROL REPORTED THAT
FARM HARBORSIDE HAVE INCREASED
BY THIRTY FIVE PERCENT IN
TWENTY TWENTY ADDITIONALLY
MEMBERS DATA HAS SHOWN A GUN
DEALERS ARE LEADING SOURCE OF
FIREARMS TRAFFICKING TO ILLEGAL
MARKETS HAS GUNS WILL OFTEN
GO UNACCOUNTED THROUGH STRAW
PURCHASES THEFT AND NEGLIGENT
LOSSES PORT BY THE FEDERAL
BUREAU OF ALCOHOL TOBACCO
AND FIREARMS EXPLOSIVES FOUND
THAT FROM TWENTY SIXTEEN TO
TWENTY NINETEEN ALONE LICENSED
DEALERS IN CALIFORNIA REPORTED
LOSING TRACK OF NEARLY THIRTEEN
HUNDRED FIREARMS FROM THEIR
INVENTORIES NOT INCLUDING
FARMS REPORTED AS STOLEN WE
ALL KNOW THAT GUN VIOLENCE
IMPOSES IN IMMEASURABLE TOLL
ON HUMAN MENTAL HEALTH WITH
IMPACTED COMMUNITIES A REPORT
BY EVERYTOWN FOR GUN VIOLENCE
GUN SAFETY ON THE GUN DEATHS
AND INJURIES COST CALIFORNIA
IF YOU CAN BELIEVE THIS
FORTY ONE POINT NINE BILLION
DOLLARS EACH YEAR OF WHICH
ONE POINT ONE BILLION DOLLARS
IS PAID FOR BY TAXPAYERS
THIS MEASURE INITIATES A LONG
TERM CONSISTENT INVESTMENT
IN REDUCING THESE HARMS
ACROSS CALIFORNIA THIS BILL
ESTABLISHES AN EXCISE TAX
TEN PERCENT FOR THE SALE
OF HANDGUNS ELEVEN PERCENT
FOR THE SALE OF LONG GUNS
AND AMMUNITION THE FUND
THE GUN VIOLENCE PREVENTION
HEALING AND RECOVERY FUND
HALF OF THE FUN MEMBERS WILL
BE ALLOCATED TOWARDS STATE
VIOLENCE INTERVENTION AND
PREVENTION GRANT PROGRAM AND
HALF WILL BE APPROPRIATED BY
THE LEGISLATURE TOWARD GUN
VIOLENCE PREVENTION PROGRAMS
AND RESEARCH BASED ON NEED THE
BILL MIRRORS A LONGSTANDING
FEDERAL EXCISE TAX ON FIREARMS
AND AMMUNITION AND ENSURE
SUSTAIN REVENUES FOR PROGRAMS
TO REMEDIATE THE DEVASTATING
EFFECTS OF THESE PRODUCTS HE
WAS RECENTLY AMENDED MEMBERS
IS VERY IMPORTANT TO EXEMPT
THE TAX FROM A PURCHASE OF
A LONG GUN AND A LONG GUN
AMMUNITION WHEN THE CUSTOMER
PRESENTS A VALID LICENSE TO
HUNT IN CALIFORNIA MEMBERS
I ASK FOR YOUR RIVAL THANK
YOU CENTER HERTZBERG MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
NIELSEN THAT ARE PRESENT
LEDGES GENTLE THE SENATE
MAYBE THIS IS THE LAST TIME
I'M GONNA HAVE TO RISE AGAINST
THE DISARMAMENT INDUSTRY AND
IT'S A DANG INDUSTRY TAKE
OUR GUNS AWAY DISARM AMERICA
-- WHAT WE'RE GONNA REDUCE
CRIME YOU SURELY HAVE BY
LETTING CRIMINALS OUT AND
NOT PUTTING THEM BACK IN
LOT OF THE SAME FOLKS WHO
CRIED TO DISARM TAKE OUR
GUNS AWAY FROM THIS MAKE IT
HARDER THEY MAKE IT EASIER FOR
THE CRIMINALS HAVE ACCESS TO
THE GUNS I DEBATED THIS FOR
YEARS WHAT IS THE LEGISLATURE
DONE AND EVEN THE PEOPLE IN
THERE IT A LIST OF SUCH THINGS
AS PROP THIRTY SIX AND FORTY
SEVEN AND FIFTY SEVEN REMOVE
THE CONSEQUENCES FOR CRIMINAL
OFFENDERS YOU SEE IT IN THE
THE GUNS DON'T PULL THEIR OWN
TRIGGERS THEY'RE NOT AUTOMATIC
SOMEBODY HAS TO DO THAT
AND THE CRIMINALS DON'T GO TO
THE GUN SHOWS IN THAT IT WOULD
OF THE GUN SHOPS TO ACQUIRE
THE WEAPONS THE TO USE IN THE
COMMISSION OF THE CRIME SO I
THINK WE'VE KIND OF GOT IT ALL
BACKWARDS HERE WHY DON'T WE FOR
A CHANGE AS A LEGISLATURE PAY A
LITTLE BIT OF ATTENTION TO THE
CRIMINALS THAT WE HAVE UTTERLY
AND ABSOLUTELY GONE SOFT ON
NOW IT WILL CHANGE LADIES
AND GENTLEMAN IT'S STARTING
TO SLIDE I OFTEN COMMENT HOW
I THINK PEOPLE LIKE ME WILL
ULTIMATELY PREVAIL IN STOPPING
THIS DISARMAMENT OF AMERICANS
IN CALIFORNIA IT'S AND THEY SAY
WHY AND SAID WELL I GOT PEOPLE
CAMPAIGNING TWENTY FOUR SEVEN
FOR MY POSITION WHOA WHO'S
DOING THAT THE CRIMINALS THEY
DON'T STOP TWENTY FOUR SEVEN
AND THE FOLKS YOU REPRESENT
AND I REPRESENT PAID THE
PRICE OF THIS LEGISLATURE'S
SHORT SIGHTEDNESS I URGE A
NO VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR
NELSON MEMBERS DISCUSSION
AND DEBATE CENTRO CHAU BOOK
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
SO IN THIS BILL M.
IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE WHEN
I READ IT AND IT IT TALKS ABOUT
YOU KNOW INCREASING M.
THE SERVER ARE TALKING ABOUT
THE RIGHT RIGHT BILL --
INCREASE OF TEN PERCENT OF OF
THE GROSS RECEIPTS FROM THE
RETAIL SALE OF A NEW HANDGUN
ELEVEN PERCENT OF THE GROUT
GROSS RECEIPTS FROM THE RETAIL
SELL A LONG LONG GONE FIVE
RIFLES FIREARM PRECURSOR PART
IN AMMUNITION IT'S INTERESTING
BECAUSE WHEN I THINK OF MY
DISTRICT AND I THINK OF THE
PEOPLE THAT I KNOW THAT I
REPRESENT WHICH ARE LEGAL
HANDGUN OWNERS THESE ARE PEOPLE
WHO ARE LAW ABIDING USUALLY
AND -- THEY GO WHEN THEY BUY
SOMETHING OUT LEGALLY THEY DO
EVERYTHING THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO
DO TO BE ABLE TO HAVE THESE FOR
PERSONAL SAFETY FOR FOR HOBBIES
-- AS COLLECTORS WHATEVER IT
MAY BE I FEEL I FEEL THE FACT
THAT WHY ARE WE TAXING THESE
LAW ABIDING PEOPLE THEY'RE
THE ONES ARE GOING TO LEGALLY
GO GO AND BUY IN PURCHASE
ACCOUNTING HERE WERE TAX THEM
AS IF THEY WERE CRIMINALS I CAN
SEE AN INCENTIVE IS A SET OF
PUBLIC SAFETY AND I SEE MANY
OF THE BILLS ARE GOING WE'RE
TRYING TO BE VERY CONSIDERATE
AND VERY RESPECTFUL AND VERY
COMPASSIONATE TOWARDS PEOPLE
WHO HAVE COMMITTED CRIMES
MANY OF WHICH HAVE USED
ILLEGALLY ACQUIRED GUNS SO
WE'RE TARGETING PEOPLE THEY'RE
LAW ABIDING NOT PEOPLE THEY
ARE ACTUALLY COMMITTING THE
CRIMES ON THIS MEASURE AND
I I DON'T THINK THAT THIS IS
THE RIGHT WAY TO GO -- AND IT
IN ONCE AGAIN I'M THINKING OF
THE CONSTITUENTS THAT I KNOW
THAT OUR FAMILY MEMBERS THAT
ARE -- HOBBY I AB THE THE THE
COLLECTORS THEY THEY SEE THESE
AT THINGS AS SOMETHING THAT
HAVE HISTORICAL VALUE FOR SOME
OF THE GUNS THAT THEY PURCHASED
BUT ARE WE REALLY TRYING TO
FIX THE ISSUE WITH TAXING THE
LAW ABIDING INDIVIDUALS SO I
I WANT I WANT TO JUST AS TO
RETHINK HOW WE'RE TRYING TO --
DISSENTER VICE PURCHASED OF THE
GUIDE I'M NOT SURE THAT THIS IS
THE RIGHT PLACE AND THE RIGHT
MEANS BY WHICH WE SHOULD BE
ADDRESSING THE ISSUE M.
ONCE AGAIN I'M JUST THINKING
OF THOSE PEOPLE THAT ARE
LAW ABIDING PEOPLE WHO ARE
PURCHASING GUNS LEGALLY
FOLLOWING THE PROCESSES THAT
WE HAVE IN PLACE RIGHT NOW
AND WHAT IS THAT GOING TO DO
TOO MANY OF THESE PEOPLE WHO
ARE NOT GOING TO TRY TO FIND
A WAY TO SAY OH WELL IT'S
GOING TO COST ME A LITTLE
BIT MORE TO PURCHASE A GUN IN
CALIFORNIA SO THEY RUN THEIR
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES OF
THIS BILL IS SOMETHING THAT
I WOULD ALSO CAUTION THIS
LEGISLATURE ON THE USER AND
-- CHAU BROKE SENATOR EGGMAN
I THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS TO GET UP AND AND
SPEAK ON GUN BILLS LIKE HI
I REPRESENT AT SEVERAL AREA
URBAN AREA IT'S A VERY MIXED
AREA WE JUST JUST WANT TO MAKE
THE POINT -- IT'S NOT ALL I
MEAN IT'S NOT JUST ALL PEOPLE
COME CRIMINALS WHO HAVE GUNS
BY THE MOST THE MASS SHOOTINGS
WE'VE SEEN RECENTLY HAVE BEEN
BY GUNS PURCHASED LATELY AND
EVERY SIXTEEN HOURS SO SINCE
WE'VE BEEN IN THIS SESSION
LAST COUPLE DAYS AT LEAST FOUR
WOMEN HAVE BEEN SHOT AND KILLED
SO IT'S NOT JUST LAW ABIDING
PEOPLE THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
IT IS NOT JUST CRIMINALS THAT
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT WE HAVE
TOO MANY DAMN GUNS DOMESTIC
VIOLENCE THE MAJORITY OF PEOPLE
WOMEN WHO WERE KILLED IT IS
BY A LOVED ONE MORE WOMEN
ARE KILLED BY THEIR INTIMATE
PARTNER THAN ARE KILLED BY
ANYBODY ELSE AND THE CHANCES OF
A WOMAN BEING MURDERED CHILDREN
BEING MURDERED INCREASES
TENFOLD IF THERE'S A GUN IN
THE HOUSE THAT'S ALL I WANNA
SAY THANK YOU SENATOR EGGMAN
CENTER MELINDA'S THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT -- WITH ALL
DUE RESPECT TO MY COLLEAGUE
FROM STOCKTON I DISAGREE
WHOLEHEARTEDLY I DON'T THINK
THEY'RE ENOUGH GUNS OUT THERE
I THINK IF MORE WOMEN WERE
ARMED AND BETTER ABLE TO
PROTECT THEMSELVES THEN MAYBE
WE WOULD HAVE FEWER WOMEN WHO
GET SHOT AND KILLED BY THEIR
HUSBANDS -- SECONDLY THIS
LEGISLATURE HAS MY GOODNESS
PASSED SO MANY GUN CONTROL
PILLS AND SO MANY DIFFERENT
BILLS TO KEEP PEOPLE FROM
BEING ABLE TO PURCHASE GUNS AND
HOW THEY ARE ABLE TO PURCHASE
THE ACCESSIBILITY AND YET WE
STILL HAVE GUN VIOLENCE THIS
BILL CLAIMS THAT THE MONEY'S
GOING TO GO TOWARDS EDUCATION
OKAY IT'S GOING TO GO TOWARDS
PREVENTION OUR RATE IS NOT
GOING TO DO ANY OF THAT IT'S
JUST GONNA BE ANOTHER MONEY
STOCK FROM THE PEOPLE BECAUSE
IT'S A LOW HANGING FRUIT IT'S
EASY BECAUSE YOUR PARTY HATES
GUNS IT'S NOT GONNA CHANGE
ANYTHING IT'S LIKE YOUR YOUR
KIDS WHEN THEY HAVE A MEAL IN
FRONT OF THEM THAT THEY DON'T
ONE EVENING JUST MOVE IT ALL
AROUND THE PLATE MAKE IT LOOK
LIKE THEY DID SOMETHING THAT'S
WHAT THIS DOES AYE YOU'RE CHEN
ABOUT THANK YOU CENTER MELENDEZ
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE AND IT CENTER CORTESE
THANK YOU -- BETTER
PRESIDENT -- I RISE ACTUALLY
IN OPPOSITION AB TWELVE
TWENTY SEVEN AND MAYBE THAT
CONTRADICTS THE WOULD --
ONE OF OUR COLLEAGUES --
JUST MENTION IN TERMS OF
PARTISANSHIP AROUND THESE KIND
OF ISSUES AND I JUST WANT TO
CLARIFY VERY SPECIFICALLY IN
TECHNICALLY WHY FIRST FLIGHT
PRESHEAF THE AMENDMENTS --
THAT THE -- MY CAR COLLEAGUES
UP FROM LOS ANGELES POINTED
OUT -- AND I I WANT TO THANK
THE AUTHOR PUBLICLY FOR THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WERE TAKEN
BECAUSE -- THOSE WERE TAKEN
AS I UNDERSTAND IT TO TRY TO
ACCOMMODATE OUTDOORS PERSON
SOME FOLKS WHO CAN PRESENT A
HUNTING LICENSE IN DEMONSTRATE
THROUGH THIS BILL THAT THEY
SHOULD BE EXEMPT FROM THE
EXCISE TAX -- AND YOU HEARD
THAT -- IN THE PRESENTATION OF
THE QUESTION THEN BECAME AS I
WAS TALKING TO THE AUTHOR AND
HIS STAFF -- HOW ARE YOU GOING
TO DEFINE HOW ARE YOU GOING
TO DEFINE WHAT A LONG RIFLE IS
BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT IS EXEMPT
IN THE BILL -- IF YOU HAVE A
HUNTING LICENSE AND THERE WAS
A LOT OF DIFFICULTY WITHOUT
UNTIL FINALLY ESSENTIALLY A
FEDERAL DEFINITION OF SIX A
SIXTEEN INCH BARREL WAS USE
-- WE'RE ALMOST THERE AND
THEN I SAID NOW YOU JUST NEED
TO DO THE SAME THING ON THE
AMMUNITION SIDE IT AND I DON'T
EXPECT EVERYONE TO SUPPORT
THIS APPROACH LET ME JUST SAY
THAT BUT I THOUGHT THIS WAS A
FAIR APPROACH A COMPROMISE IT
PERHAPS DOESN'T PUT AN UNDUE
BURDEN AN EXTRA TAX ON FOLKS
WHO FRANKLY OFTENTIMES ARE
WORKING STIFFS THE WORKING
PEOPLE WHO ARE COMING IN AND
YOU KNOW REALLY GET HIT WITH
A REGRESSIVE TAX BASICALLY
ON SOMETHING THAT -- IT CAN
DOESN'T HAVE ANY NEXUS TO THE
ACTIVITY THAT THEY'RE DOING
WHICH IS HUNTING OR SPORTING
TYPE ACTIVITIES -- BUT AGAIN
THE ALMOST THERE HOW YOU
GONNA DEAL WITH AMMUNITION
AND THE RESPONSE CAME BACK
WE'RE JUST GOING TO EXEMPTS
-- AMMUNITION FOR LONG GUNS
PROBLEM AND I JUST WANNA BE
CLEAR THAT I APPOINT THIS OUT
WE HAD THIS CONVERSATION THERE
WAS OPPORTUNITY -- I THINK
BEFORE THE BILL DEADLINE TO
TO AMENDING AND CLEAR THIS UP
BUT -- THE ANSWER WAS THAT I
SALUTE THE PROBLEM IS YOU DO
NOT HAVE THE DISTINCTION IN
AMMUNITION BETWEEN WHAT IS
FOR LONG RIFLES WERE SIXTEEN
INCH BARRELS AND WHAT IS FOR
HANDGUNS OR FOR SHORTER BARREL
FARMS YOU CAN'T USE THE SAME
DEFINITION WHY DO I MENTION
ALL THAT IT'S BECAUSE THERE
WILL BE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES
IN THAT WAS BROUGHT UP BY ONE
OF THE PREVIOUS SPEAKERS ONE
OF OUR COLLEAGUES BECAUSE NOW
IF THIS BILL PASSES AND IF
IT SIGNED INTO LAW SOMEBODY
WILL GO PRESENT THEIR LICENSE
TO A PURCHASE THAT LONG RIGHT
FOR THAT SHOT GUN AS A SPORTS
PERSON IN THE BE EXEMPTED FROM
THE TAX A FEW WEEKS LATER --
THAT PERSON WILL COME IN TO BUY
AMMUNITION IN PRESENT THE SAME
HUNTING LICENSE AND SAY I WANT
TO BE EXEMPTED FROM THE TAX
-- AND THERE'S GOING TO BE --
COMPLETE CHAOS AT THE COUNTER
AT THAT POINT AS TO WHETHER
OR NOT THAT TAX APPLIES HOW DO
YOU KNOW IF IT APPLIES ASSEMBLY
SOMEWHAT TWENTY TWO CALIBER
AMMUNITION IN THE QUESTION IS
GOING TO BE A HOW DO I KNOW
THIS FOR A LONG RIFLE OR A FOR
HAND GUN HOW DOES ANYBODY KNOW
THE BILL IS LACKS DEFINITION
INDICATE LACK DEFINITION LIKE
THAT IN A TAX MEASURE YOU CAN
EXPECT -- EVERY OF MINIMUM
WAGE THE CLERK AT THE COUNTER
TO BE THE ARBITER THE REFEREE
IN TERMS OF OF THAT ISSUE IT
WILL CREATE CHAOS OF PRESUMABLY
TO CREATE A LAWSUIT AND SOME
KIND OF A DECLARATORY RULING
THAT SAYS IT'S IT'S AMBIGUOUS
AND VAGUE IN A CAMP IN FORCE
BUT I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD
LEASE FOR MY PART OF THE VOTING
FOR BILLS THAT WE KNOW IN
ADVANCE OF BIG A BIG U.
S.
WHEN IT COMES TO LEGAL
ENFORCEMENT LEGAL STANDING
SO THANK YOU FOR BEARING WITH
ME ON A LENGTHY EXPLANATION
AS TO MY VOTE ON THIS BILL
-- BUT UNFORTUNATELY FOR ME
IT'S IT'S FLAWED A TWO DEGREE
-- THAT THAT WON'T ALLOW ME
TO SUPPORT IT THANK YOU THANK
YOU CENTER CORTESE MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE CENTER
HURTS FOR YOU MAY CLOSE THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT A COUPLE
OF THOUGHTS TO SHARE WITH THE
MEMBERS OF THIS TEAM SENATE
FIRST MY UNDERSTANDING IN GET
GIVEN THE CHALLENGES THAT WILL
RAISE BOND WHICH YOU JUST HAVE
TO SHOW HUNTING LICENSE AND
THAT THE REAL PURPOSE WAS TO
MAKE SURE THAT FOLKS THAT WE'RE
GONNA BE HUNTERS I DIDN'T HAVE
TO PAY THIS EXCISE TAX AND AS
LONG AS THE -- M.
INITIAL FEDERAL INTO SUCH A
A LONG GUN THAT IT'S IT BY
DEFINITION SHOULDN'T BE A
PROBLEM IT'S REALLY THE LICENSE
TO AVOID THE CONFUSION SO IF
YOU GO TO THE CLERK YOU SHOW
ME HUNTING LICENSE YOU WANT
TO BUY THIS AMMUNITION THAT IT
SHOULDN'T BE A PROBLEM NUMBER
ONE NUMBER TWO IS ON IN THE
BILLS THAT WE HAD BEFORE SO
JUST BE VERY BRIEF WE TALKED
ABOUT ALL OF THE VARIOUS GUN
BILLS WE'VE HAD IN CALIFORNIA
OVER THE YEARS THE TIME IT WAS
A HUNDRED AND SEVEN AND THE
FACT THAT ARE THE NUMBER OF
GUN DEATHS IN CALIFORNIA ARE
DOWN DRAMATICALLY ANYWHERE FROM
TWENTY FIVE TO FIFTY PERCENT
COMPARED TO OTHER JURISDICTIONS
OF THE POINT IS THAT THEY WORK
THE THIRD POINT IS I THINK
IT'S A FAIR OBSERVATION ABOUT
THE TAX BUT THE TAX PIECE AND
I I THINK THE IDEA THAT WAS
MENTIONED THE QUITE IMPACTFUL
POINT ABOUT DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
AND WHERE THE IMPACT OF GUN
VIOLENCE IS BECAUSE THE WEAPON
AND WE HAVE ALL SORTS OF --
APPROACHES IN GOVERNMENT WHERE
WE HAVE FEES ON MATTRESSES OR
TIRES AND ALL SORTS OF THINGS
WHERE WE TRIED TO IMPOSE THE
OBLIGATION ON THE USER OF
THAT SERVICE TO TO PROVIDE
THE VALUES SO I I DO THINK IT
HAS SOME CONSISTENCY WITH THE
LARGER -- APPROACH TO HOW WE
WE OF THE TACK OF FUN THINGS
IN CALIFORNIA AND -- I'VE WITH
THAT I ASK YOUR RIVAL THANK
YOU CENTER HERTZBERG MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA ATKINS AYE
BATES NO PACKER I PORCHES NO
BRADFORD CABALLERO CORTESE
NOPE DALY NO DODD DERISIVE I
EGGMAN AYE LASER AYE GONZALEZ
I GROWTH HERTZBERG I QUESTION
HER TADO NOPE JONES NOW
KAMLAGER WHERE DO I LEYVA
HI FOR THE MONTH I REQUIRE
HI MELENDEZ NO MAN HI NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
NO PAN I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
RUBIO SKINNER HI STERN HI
NUMBER BY CASTING AYE WIENER
AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BRADFORD
BYRON DODD GROVE NO QUESTION
KAMLAGER ROTH RUBIO I'M BURKE
THIS CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ONE MORE TIME ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CAN I GET A DODD
WESTERN KAMLAGER RUBIO
UMBERG SENATOR MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WERE GOING TO LIVE
THE CALL ON FILE ITEM SEVEN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA BAKER
COME BY OTHER DOT GLAZER GROWTH
WESTERN HURTADO MELENDEZ MAN I
WHAT
SENATOR MEN YOU YOU CAN'T DO
THAT SENATOR MAN YOU MAY CHANGE
YOUR VOTE FROM I DON'T KNOW
MAN I DON'T KNOW THE GROWTH
NOW WHAT WE'RE GOING THROUGH
THE ROLE NIELSEN HOW TROUBLED
PAN ROTH NUMBER WELL NOW THIS
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS OVER
TIME ARCHULETA BAKER HI MY
OTHER DODD GLAZER WESSEL HER
DAUGHTER MELENDEZ NIELSEN
NO BUT TROUBLED PAN RALPH
I AMBERG
MELENDEZ NOW PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ONE
MORE TIME ARCHULETA BAKER
BY OTHER DODD GLAZER WESA
HURTADO A TROUBLED PAN AMBERG
SENATE APPROVES THE CALL
REMEMBER YOU SHOULD HAVE
RECEIVED FOR OF FILES
SUPPLEMENTAL FILE THREE
SHOULD HAVE THAT ON YOUR
DESK WE'RE GOING TO START
WITH FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY
THREE SENATOR HER TADO
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL FIVE FIFTY NINE
BY SENATOR HER TADO AN ACT
RELATING TO TRIBAL GAMING
AND DECLARING THERE'S EITHER
OF STATE FOR TO BE DEALING
CENTRE HER TADO THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT SENATE BILL FIVE FIVE
NINE IS A VEHICLE TO RATIFY
THE TRIBAL STATE GAMING COMPACT
BETWEEN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
AND THE SANTA ROSA RENTERIA
TOUCHY TRIBE THE LANGUAGE IN
THE COMPACT TO SUBSTANTIALLY
THE SAME AS RECENT COMPACTS AND
IS BEFORE YOU AGAIN REFLECTING
NECESSARY CHANGES TO THE
AGREEMENT FOR FEDERAL APPROVAL
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER HER TADO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE BETTER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES HI PARKER HI PORGES
I BRADFORD I HAVE I EVER THE
COURTS HAVING AYE CABALLERO AYE
DALY AYE DODD I TO RUSSELL I
EGGMAN I PLEASE -- HI GONZALEZ
I BROKE AYE HERTZBERG I
WESTERN AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
I KAMLAGER I FLARED I LEYVA AYE
THURMOND AYE MCGUIRE MCGUIRE
I MELENDEZ AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN I A TROUBLED AYE
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO I SKINNER I STERN HI
NUMBER I BY CASTING I WIENER
AYE WILK HI HIGHS FORTY NEW
ZERO ON THE URGENCY HIGHS FORTY
KNOWS ARE ZERO AND THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED IN
MOVING TO FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY
FIVE SENATOR PORTANTINO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE FIFTY NINE BY SENATOR
PORTANTINO AND AFTER RELATING
TO SURPLUS FOR PROPERTY CENTER
PORTANTINO THANK YOU MADAM
MEMBERS -- THAT I HOPE THIS
IS THE FINAL SEVEN TEN FREEWAY
BILL I EVER HAVE TO PRESENT
IN MY LIFE THE CONCURRENT
I I MEMONS HELP THE CITY OF
PASADENA CREATE MORE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE BEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
AYE PACKER AYE PORCHES
I BRADFORD HI COME BY OTHER
WHAT HAS HE AYE TALLY AYE
DODD TORONTO EGGMAN HI
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ ALL
RIGHT GROWTH HER I HERTZBERG
WESTERN I HER TADO HI JONES
I KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
LEYVA AYE FOR THE MONTH I
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ AYE MIN
AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN I A
TROUBLED AYE PAN AYE PORTANTINO
HI RALPH HI RUBIO I SKINNER I
STERN AYE NUMBER HI BY COUNTY
HI GREENER I WILK HI PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS UP
SENATOR MOVES A CALL FILE
ITEM ONE TWENTY SIX SENATOR
MEN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ SENATE BILL TEN OH ONE BY
SENATOR MEN AN ACT RELATING TO
CONSUMER PROTECTION CINNAMON
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
THIS BILL LOOKS ASK HOW SICK
TO PREPARE A REPORT ON MULTI
FACTOR REPORTING WHEN IT COMES
TO CONSUMER PROTECTION IDENTITY
THEFT SOMETHING AMENDMENTS
ONE MINOR EXTEND THE REPORT
DEADLINE BY YEAR I RESPECTFULLY
ASK RIVAL THANK YOU SENATOR MEN
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MEN
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN I ARCHULETA I ATKINS
AYE BATES AYE PEPPER AYE
PORCHES AYE BRADFORD I
HAVE EITHER I PROTECTING
AYE TALLY AYE DODD DERISIVE
EGGMAN AYE PLACER AYE GONZALEZ
AYE GROVE AYE HERTZBERG AYE
PUESTO AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
HI KAMLAGER I GLARED HI LEYVA
I FOR THE MOST AYE MCGUIRE
MELENDEZ MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
AYE TRIBERG AYE PAN AYE
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE VISCOUNTCY AYE WIENER FIVE
WILK HI SENATOR MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING OUT OF
FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY EIGHT
SENATOR BECKER IS HE HASN'T
CENTER MAN OKAY OKAY I CAN'T
SEE CENTER BAKER CENTER BAKER
IS AT HIS DESK AND I'M SICK
WHAT YOU'RE RIGHT LET'S DO
ONE TWENTY SEVEN FIRST CENTER
PORTANTINO MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TEN
OH TWO BY SENATOR PORTANTINO
AN ACT RELATED TO WORKERS
COMPENSATION CENTER PORTANTINO
SENATE SENATE BILL ONE THOUSAND
TWO IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
TECHNICAL AND WERE PROVIDED BY
THE DEPARTMENT RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE ON ONE THOUSAND
TWO THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEM MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES AYE PEPPER AYE
PORGES AYE BRADFORD I HAVE A
OTHER AYE CORTESE AYE TALLY
HI TODD -- AWESOME EGGMAN
AYE PLEASER AYE GONZALEZ I
GROWTH I HERTZBERG D.
WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE JONES I
KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE LEYVA
AYE FOR THE MONTH HI MCGUIRE
I MELENDEZ AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN AYE CHOI BOGUE AYE
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN AYE
AMBERG AYE BY CASKEY HI WIENER
I WILK HI SEN REMOVES THE
CALL MEMBERS LET'S WELCOME OUR
ESTEEMED ATTORNEY GENERAL TO
THE SENATE FLOOR WELCOME MISTER
ATTORNEY GENERAL ROB BONTA
ALL RIGHT WELL WE ARE GREETING
OUR ATTORNEY GENERAL LET'S MOVE
TO FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY EIGHT
SENATOR BECKER MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TWELVE
TWENTY THREE BY SENATOR BAKER
AN ACT RELATING TO CRIMINAL
PROCEDURE CENTER BECKER I THANK
YOU -- BECAUSE THIS MEASURES
BACK ON CONCURRENCE THE MEMBERS
WERE TECHNICAL IN NATURE
I SPENT THE LAST THREE AYE
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR BAKER
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING THEM MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN I ARCHULETA I ATKINS
AYE BATES BASED NO BACKER I
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I HAVE A
ADAM HIGH COURT HAS HE HI KELLY
NO DODD THE RUSSELL EGGMAN
AYE PLEASER AYE GONZALEZ I
GROWTH NO HERTZBERG I REQUEST
SO I HER DAUGHTER JONES NOPE
KAMLAGER HI THERE HI LEYVA HI
THE MOM HI MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
NOPE MEN I NEWMAN HI NIELSEN
A TROUBLED
PAN I PORTANTINO I ROTH I RUBIO
I SKINNER
SKINNER I STERN AYE NUMBER
HE HI FI CASKEY HI WIENER
I WILK NO SENATOR MOVES TO
CALL MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON
TO FILE ITEM OF ONE TWENTY
NINE SENATOR PAN AM AND
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FIFTEEN HUNDRED BY THE
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
AN ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC
HEALTH CENTER PAN THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT CENTER SENATE
BILL FIFTEEN HUNDRED WHICH
IS THE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
BILLS BACK IN CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IT'S NEAR THE
PROVISIONS RELATED BIOLOGIC
DRUGS AND EXTEND SUNSET
DATE ON THE PROVISION OF LAW
REGARDING HOME MEDICAL DEVICE
RETAILERS RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE ON CONCURRENCE
THANK YOU CENTER PAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING THEM MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
ATKINS AYE BATES AYE PACKER
AYE PORCHES AYE BRADFORD AYE
BYRON AYE CRITICIZING AYE
TALLY AYE DODD THEY'RE AWESOME
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
HIGH GROWTH I HERTZBERG AYE
WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
I KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN I MCGUIRE I
MELENDEZ AYE MIN I NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN AYE A TROUBLED AYE PAN
I PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO
I SKINNER I STERN HI I'M BURKE
AYE FORECASTING AYE WIENER
AYE WILK HI SENATOR MUSICAL
GREAT JOB MEMBERS HANG IN THERE
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA MOVE
BACK IN THE SUPPLEMENTAL
FILE TO FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY
FOUR SENATOR CABALLERO MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL NINE OH FIVE BY SENATOR
CABALLERO AN ACT RELATING TO
CARBON SEQUESTRATION CENTER
CABALLERO THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I'M GONNA LET MY --
CO AUTHOR START FIRST -- --
SENATOR SKINNER AND I WORKED
ON THIS REALLY HARD TOGETHER
VERY GOOD THANK YOU CENTER
CABALLERO SENATOR SKINNER THANK
YOU MEMBERS SB NINE OH FIVE
BEGAN AS A BILL UNDER MY NAME
THAT WOULD HAVE ALLOWED US TO
PERMIT CARBON SEQUESTRATION
FROM OUR CEMENT INDUSTRY CEMENT
IS ONE OF THE MOST CARBON
INTENSIVE PROCESS SEES THAT WE
DO AND WE HAVE MULTIPLE CEMENT
PLANTS IN CALIFORNIA AND WE'RE
DEPENDENT ON CEMENT FOR OUR
ROADS FOR BRIDGES FOR A MINUTE
MUCH OF OUR CONSTRUCTION AND
SO RECOVERING CARBON WHICH IS
A PROCESS EMISSIONS FROM CEMENT
MAKES SENSE IF WE WANT TO BRING
DOWN THE CARBON INTENSITY OF
CEMENT AND WHAT WE HAVE NOT
BEEN ARE WE NOT REALLY SET UP
THE RULES AND REGULATIONS FOR
IS THEN HOW TO STORE IT HE A
LOGICALLY SO MY ORIGINAL BILL
WOULD HAVE ALLOWED US TO DO
THAT WITH CEMENT IT WOULD HAVE
ALLOWED US TO SET UP THE RULES
FOR GEOLOGICAL SEQUESTRATION
OF THAT CARBON NOW MY BILL
WAS ORIGINALLY NARROWED OR
ORIGINALLY CONTAINED TO CEMENT
ONLY BUT IN FACT WE HAVE
MANY OTHER CARBON INTENSIVE
INDUSTRIES AND WE ALSO HAVE THE
ABILITY TO DO WHAT IS CALLED
DIRECT AIR CAPTURE OF CARBON
BUT EITHER WAY WE STILL HAVE
TO LEARN AND SPEAK HAVE THE
RULES FOR GEOLOGIC STORAGE OF
IT SO NOW WITH THE GOVERNOR'S
REQUEST FOR THE FIVE PILLARS
WE HAVE EXPANDED THE BILL
AND THE SENATOR FROM SALINAS
AND I PARTNERED BECAUSE SHE
ORIGINALLY HAD A BILL THAT
DID EXCUSE ME FOR MERCED SHE
POLITICS SHE WAS MY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER FROM SALINAS ORIGINALLY
BUT NOW SHE'S THE SENATOR FOR
MERCED ANYWAY SHE BEGAN WITH
A BILL THAT DEALT WITH THAT
BIGGER PICTURE OF CAPTURING
CARBON AND ALLOWING FOR ITS
GEOLOGIC SEQUESTRATION THERE
ARE SOME FOLKS WHO FELT THAT
PERHAPS THERE WERE NOT ENOUGH
PROTECTIONS AND BY MERGING OUR
BILLS AND WORKING TOGETHER WITH
MANY MANY MANY STAKEHOLDERS
WE BUILT IN SOME VERY SMART
PROTECTIONS BUT ALSO ENOUGH
ROOM FOR INDUSTRY TO BE ABLE
WELL FIRST OFF FOR REGULATORY
AGENCIES TO BE ABLE TO SET UP
RULES AND FOR INDUSTRY TO BE
ABLE TO DO THIS VERY IMPORTANT
WORK OF CAPTURING CARBON
AND STORING IT AND I WILL
NOW TURN IT OVER TO MY GREAT
JOINT AUTHORS THANK YOU CENTER
SKINNER CENTER CABALLERO THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MISTER MADAM
PRESIDENT I WANT TO THANK MY
CO AUTHOR FROM BERKELEY FOR
HER HARD WORK AND A COMMITMENT
IN THIS AREA -- AND I WANT
TO ALSO RECOGNIZE AND THINK
THAT CLIMATE CHANGE WORKING
GROUP IN THE SENATE WHO WORK
SO HARD TO CRAFT SOLUTIONS
AND PARTICULARLY MADAM PRO
TEM FOR CONVENING THE GROUP
-- WE DID A LOT OF WORK IN
THIS AREA AND I DON'T THINK
WE WOULD HAVE GOTTEN THIS FAR
WITHOUT WITH ALL THAT WILL
WORK THE AMENDMENTS TAKEN THE
AND IN THE ASSEMBLY REMOVE THE
ESTABLISHMENT AS MY CO AUTHOR
SAID OF THE DECARBONIZE CEMENT
GEOLOGIC CARBON SEQUESTRATION
DEMONSTRATION ACT I'M IN IT AND
ESTABLISH THE CARBON CAPTURE
REMOVAL UTILIZATION AND STORAGE
PROGRAM UNDER THE CALIFORNIA
AIR OR AIR RESOURCES BOARD
CARB HAS DETERMINED THAT WE
CAN NOT MEET OUR GHG REDUCTION
GOALS WITHOUT CARBON CAPTURE
SO THE BILL NOW DIRECTS CARB
TO DEVELOP A FRAMEWORK TO
FACILITATE THE DEVELOPMENT
AND DEPLOYMENT OF CARBON
CAPTURE REMOVAL UTILIZATION
AND SEQUESTRATION R.
C.
R.
U.
S.
I'M SURE SOMEBODY WILL COME
UP WITH A FANCY NAME FOR THAT
IN ORDER TO HELP CALIFORNIA
MEET ITS REDUCTION GOALS AS
WE KNOW CARBON NEUTRALITY
BY TWENTY FORTY FIVE AND NET
NEGATIVE EMISSIONS THEREAFTER
WILL REQUIRE A MULTITUDE OF
CLIMATE CHANGE INITIATIVES
AND THIS IS ONE OF THEM THE
SENTIMENT IS SHARED WITH OUR
FEDERAL PARTNERS SO THERE
IS SIGNIFICANT FEDERAL FUNDS
AVAILABLE IN ORDER FOR US TO
-- DEPLOY CARBON SEQUESTRATION
-- AND EXPERTS AGREED TO
CALIFORNIA'S XCELERATED
MISH EMISSION REDUCTIONS
GOAL IS -- DOES C.
C.
R.
U.
S.
IS IN THE NECESSARY M.
M.
COMPONENT SO WHAT WHAT WHAT
THESE PROJECTS WILL DO A
PROBE IS PROVIDE GOOD JOBS FOR
CALIFORNIANS WITH SKILL SETS
THAT LACK THAT WILL LACK DEMAND
IN THE TRANSITION TO CLEAN
ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES SUCH AS
IRON WORKERS WELDERS CARPENTERS
AND PIPE LINE WORKERS IT
IT COULD THE BILL CREATES
GUIDELINES AND IS STREAMED
STREAMLINED PROCESS PURSUE C.
R.
U.
S.
PROJECTS WITH A STATE REGULATED
REGULATED FRAMEWORK SO IT HAS
THREE MAIN MAIN COMPONENTS
VERY QUICKLY IT DIRECTS CARD
TO WORK WITH OTHER RELEVANT
STATE AGENCIES TO ESTABLISH
STRICT ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH
AND SAFETY STANDARDS FOR
CARBON CAPTURE PROJECTS TO
INCLUDE PRIORITIZING PROJECTS
THAT REDUCE EMISSIONS AND
AND TO MAKE SURE THEY DON'T
HAVE ANY ADVERSE IMPACTS
ON LOCAL COMMUNITY SECOND
THE BILL WILL DEVELOP BY
JANUARY TWENTY TWENTY FIVE
A STREAMLINED PERMITTING
PROCESS TO FACILITATE C.
C.
U.
R.
S.
PROJECTS -- IN THE STATE
THROUGH A PUBLIC WORKSHOP
PROCESS TO ENSURE STAKEHOLDER
FEEDBACK AND THREE THE BILL
CREATES REPORTING MECHANISMS
TO EVALUATE PROJECT IF IT
EFFICACIES AS WELL AS RELATED
AREAS OF STUDY TO INCLUDE
REPORTS ON SEISMIC ACTIVITY
PIPELINE MAINTENANCE AND
SUITABLE WELL LOCATIONS THERE
THE BILL REQUIRES REPORTS
TO BE MADE TO THE CALIFORNIA
LEGISLATURE BEGINNING IN TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE AND EVERY TWO YEARS
THERE AFTER SB NINE OH FIVE
PAVE THE WAY FOR CALIFORNIA TO
BECOME A GLOBAL LEADER IN C.
C.
R.
U.
S.
DEVELOPMENT AND CREATES THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR INVESTMENT IN
NEW AND INNOVATIVE INNOVATIVE
TECHNOLOGIES WHILE PROTECTING
PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY
AND THE ENVIRONMENT AND
CREATE GOOD PAYING JOBS I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS ON CONCURRENCE THANK YOU
SENATOR CABALLERO A DISCUSSION
AND DEBATE CENTER BY CAL
SKI MAN PRESIDENT -- I URGE
MEMBERS TO VOTE IN SUPPORT OF
SB NINE OH FIVE WELL I DON'T
AGREE WITH ALL THE DETAILS
OF THE BILL I KNOW THIS IS A
-- A COMPROMISE I WOULD HAVE
PREFERRED TO HAVE THIS -- AGENT
THE AGENCY AT THE CALIFORNIA
ENERGY COMMISSION THE AGENCY
THAT SINCE THEY DO THE CITING
OF THE WHAT ARE PLACES I HAVE
NO CAL CHAMP IS INTRICATELY
INVOLVED IN THE CITING OF OIL
PRODUCTION AND NATURAL GAS
IT'S A NATURAL THE TAKE A WIN
THURSDAY ADMINISTRATION --
ELEMENT THERE THAT THEY'RE
EXPOSED TO WORK TOGETHER --
AND I HOPE THAT THAT WILL GET
WORKED OUT AND THIS SHOULD
BE SEEN AS THE FIRST STEP IN
CALIFORNIA WORKING TO DEVELOP
A ROBUST CARBON CAPTURE -- --
INDUSTRY HERE WHERE WE HAVE
PEOPLE MANAGING CARBON AND
COLLECTING IT AND I WOULD URGE
MEMBERS TO SUPPORT THE BILL
THANK YOU CENTER RIGHT KELSEY
MEMBERS FOR THE DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NINE
CENTER COVER OR CENTER SKINNER
WOULD WANT TO BE LIKE CLOSE I
THINK MY A GOOD COLLEAGUE FOR
-- HIS COMMENTS AND RE REBOOT
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
ABOUT THANK YOU MA'AM MA'AM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES NOPE BAKER
FORTUS NO BRADFORD CAN I GET
A HIGH COURT HAS HE HI DOLLY
NO DOT I TO RAZA EGGMAN GLAZER
GONZALEZ GROSS HERTZBERG
WESTERN RETARDER NO JONES
NO KAMLAGER LAYERED I LEYVA
AYE THE MON MCGUIRE MELENDEZ
NO MAN I NEWMAN I NIELSEN
NO -- TROUBLE NO PAN AYE
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
NUMBER FIVE CASSIE I WINNER
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN BAKER BRADFORD
THEY'RE ALSO EGGMAN GLAZER
GONZALEZ ROVE HERTZBERG WESSEL
KAMLAGER LIMON MCGUIRE STERN
WIENER THEN REMOVE THE CALL
BY MEMBERS WE HAVE COMPLETED
OUR THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL FILE
AND WE'RE WORKING ON THE
NEXT ACTION ITEMS FOR YOU
MEMBERS WERE GONNA LET THE
CALL ON FILE ITEM TWENTY ONE
SENATE BILL ELEVEN THIRTY
SEVEN CENTER GONZALEZ SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ARCHULETA
I BRADFORD CABALLERO I DODD
GLAZER HERTZBERG WESO NEWMAN
ROTH RUBIO AMBERG PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS BRADFORD
DODD HI GLAZER HERTZBERG FIVE
WESSEL NEWMAN OFF RUBIO AMBERG
HIS TWENTY THREE KNOWS TEN THE
I'M BURKE AYE BRADFORD AYE
IS TWENTY FIVE KNOWS
TEN THE MEASURE PASSES
WELL IF THEY CALL AN ITEM
ONE TWENTY FOUR SB NINE OH
FIVE BY SENATOR CABALLERO
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ALLEN I BAKER HI BRADFORD
I THEY'RE AWESOME EGGMAN
THEY'RE ALSO I'D EGGMAN I LASER
GONZALEZ HI GROVE HERTZBERG HI
WESSEL KAMLAGER HI LIMÓN AYE
MCGUIRE AYE STERN AYE WIENER
HI MEMBERS WILL GO THROUGH ONE
MORE TIME PLEASE LET THE ROLE
GLAZER AYE GROVE WESO IS TWENTY
NINE IT KNOWS NINE AND ASSEMBLY
MEMBER SIR CONCURRED IN
WELL IF THE CALL
ON FILE ITEM SEVEN
SENATE BILL SIX SEVENTY
NINE BY CENTER KAMLAGER
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL ARCHULETA BAKER CABALLERO
DODD GLAZER WESA HURTADO NO
BUT TROUBLED PAN I'M BURKE
I DALLY I TO KNOW PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BAKER CABALLERO DODD GLAZER
WESA I TROUBLED PAN NUMBER
THERE WAS A CALL
STAND BY MEMBERS THANK YOU SIR
MEMBERS WERE MOVING TO FILE
ITEM FIFTY EIGHT SENATOR
PACKARD MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL SEVENTEEN
FIFTY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
CRISTINA GARCIA AN ACT
RELATING TO GREENHOUSE GASES
CENTER BECKER THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I RISE ON BEHALF
OF ASSEMBLY MEMBERS CRISTINA
GARCIA AND ROBERT RIVAS AND
NUMEROUS CO AUTHORS TO PRESENT
AB SEVENTEEN FIFTY SEVEN WHICH
IS PART OF THE NEGOTIATED
CLIMATE PACKAGE THE IPCC
REPORT FINDS IT WE MUST DO MORE
THAN CUT A ROOM EMISSIONS IN
HALF BUT ALSO JOE DOWN DRAW
DOWN ONE TRILLION TONS A PAST
MISSIONS WORLDWIDE BY TWENTY
THIRTY TO SECURE SAFE AND
LIVABLE FUTURE NATURAL CARBON
REMOVAL IS A PROVEN METHOD OF
CARBON REMOVAL THAT PROVIDES
A HOST OF OTHER CO BENEFITS
THAT HELP US BOTH MITIGATE AND
ADAPT TO THE CLIMATE CRISIS AB
SEVENTEEN FIFTY SEVEN REQUIRES
A CALIFORNIA NATURAL RESOURCES
AGENCY AND THE AIR RESOURCES
BOARD AMONG OTHER AGENCIES TO
ESTABLISH A RANGE OF AMBITIOUS
AND ACHIEVABLE TARGETS FOR
NATURAL CARBON SEQUESTRATION
AND EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS UNDER
NATURAL WORKING LANDS FOR
TWENTY THIRTY TWENTY THIRTY
EIGHT AND TWENTY FORTY FIVE IT
ESTABLISHES AN EXPERT ADVISORY
COMMITTEE MADE RESEARCHERS
PRACTITIONERS TECHNICAL
ADVISORS ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
AND INDIGENOUS REPRESENTATIVES
TO ADVISE THE STATE AGENCIES
AND BOARDS OF MODELING CARBON
ACCOUNTING AND IMPLEMENTATION
STRATEGIES SETTING TARGETS FOR
NATURAL CARBON SEQUESTRATION
AND EMISSION REDUCTIONS ON
OUR NATURAL WORKING LANDS IS
NECESSARY TO HELP MEET OUR
CLIMATE GOALS AND RESTORE
THE HEALTH OF OUR SOILS
INCREASE WATER EFFICIENCY ON
AGRICULTURAL LANDS ENHANCE
FOOD SECURITY AND INCREASE
RESILIENCE TO WORSEN EXTREMES
SUCH AS DROUGHT HEAT WILDFIRES
AND FLOODS AS WE SAW OTHER
LANDMARK PIECES OF LEGISLATION
LIKE AB IN SB THIRTY TWO
AND THE RENEWABLE PORTFOLIO
STANDARD THE TARGETS DEVELOPED
UNDER THIS BILL WILL SPUR
THE WIDER ADOPTION OF NATURAL
CARBON SEQUESTRATION PRACTICES
ACROSS CALIFORNIA WILL
CREATE SIGNIFICANT WORKFORCE
DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES ALLOW
THE STATE TO REAP THE MYRIAD
OF COKE BENEFITS ASSOCIATE
WITH MORE RESILIENT NATURAL
AND WORKING LANDS FOR THESE
REASONS I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU THANK
YOU SENATOR BAKER DISCUSSION
AND DEBATE CENTER NIELSEN
BETTER PRESIDENT LAYS DOWN ON
THE SENATE I HAVE THE HIGHEST
RESPECT FOR THIS AUTHOR THUS
THE -- MISSION THAT I'M GOING
TO ACKNOWLEDGE I DO NOT A
TRIBUTE TO HIM BUT OF OTHER
INTERESTS THIS ADVISORY ENTITY
WHATEVER IT WILL BE DOES NOT
INCLUDE ANYONE FROM AGRICULTURE
OR RESOURCE I HAVE TO BELIEVE
THAT THAT'S A PURPOSEFUL
OMISSION AND THOSE ARE CRITICAL
INDUSTRIES TO THE STATE
CRITICAL INDUSTRIES THAT HAVE
HAD TO SUFFER AT THE HANDS OF
CERTAIN INTERESTS WHO I GUESS
WOULD JUST AS SOON SEE THOSE
INDUSTRIES GO OUT OF EXISTENCE
CERTAINLY THE REGULATORY
AGENCIES FAME DISPOSAL THE
DECADES TO REGULATE THEM NOT
OUT OF EXISTENCE TWO DIMINISHED
EXISTENCE SO I WOULD URGE A
NO VOTE BASED ON THE CRITICAL
DEFICIENCIES OF THIS COMMITTEE
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN SAID
WRIGHT CAL SKI IN PRISON I
RISE IN SUPPORT OF THE MEASURE
OF THE CRITICISMS BY THE
GENTLEMAN FROM TO HAMMER ARE
NOT WITHSTANDING THE AND I
UNDERSTAND WITH THE CRITICISMS
COMES BECAUSE FARMERS SHOULD
BE ON THE BOARD AND PEOPLE
THERE IN THE LUMBER RESOURCES
SHOULD BE ON THE BOARD AND
SHOULD BE ADVISING THIS IS THE
START TO SET UP A PROGRAM BUT
THE GENTLEMAN FROM TO HEMA IN
TWENTY SIXTEEN SAT ON BUDGET
SUB TO HE SAID MINORITY MEMBERS
THERE IN IN TWENTY SIXTEEN IN
THE CAP AND TRADE PROGRAM WE
PUT IN SEVEN POINT FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS FOR HEALTHY SOILS
WE PUT A TWENTY FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS FOR HEALTHY FORCE WE
DIDN'T CALL IT NATURAL WORKING
LANDS BUT WE GAVE THE MONEY
WOULD LIKE THAT DEEPTHROAT
IN ALL THE PRESIDENT'S MEN
FOLLOW THE MONEY ANY TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN THE GENTLEMAN
FROM TO HAMMER SERVED ON THE
BUDGET COMMITTEE AND WE WE
PUT FIVE MILLION DOLLARS IN
THE HEALTHY SOILS BECAUSE
WE REALIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF
MAKING OUR FARMLAND HEALTH
YOU'RE RESTORING IT THERE WAS
A HUNDRED AND SIXTY MILLION
DOLLARS INTO HEALTHY FORESTS
TWENTY MILLION DOLLARS INTO
REGIONAL FORCE MANAGEMENT
BECAUSE YOU REALIZE YOU KNOW
THE STATE GOVERNMENT DOESN'T
DO IT ALL AND WE PUT FIVE
MILLION DOLLARS IN THIS THING
CALLED WETLANDS WE DIDN'T CALL
IT NATURAL WORKING LAST WEEK
CALLED WETLANDS TODAY WE'RE
SUPPOSED TO BRINK OF PASSING
A BUDGET THAT WOULD PUT IN ONE
POINT ONE BILLION DOLLARS IN
NATURE BASED SOLUTIONS WE ARE
ALREADY DOING THE WORK OF THIS
AGENCY OR THIS PROGRAM THIS
COULD BE SET UP THAT'S WITHIN
THE NATURE BASED SOLUTIONS
WITHIN THE DROUGHT PROGRAM WE
HAVE A BILLION DOLLARS THIS
YEAR OR IF A BILLION DOLLARS
FROM LAST YEAR FIVE HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS IN THIS YEAR
ON NATURE BASED SOLUTIONS AND
WATERSHED RESILIENCE IN THE
CAP AND TRADE PROGRAM WE HAVE A
HUNDRED AND FIFTY FIVE MILLION
DOLLARS IN SEA LEVEL RISE THAT
IS WITH THE GENTLEMAN FROM
NAPA WHO'S VERY CONCERNED ABOUT
ROUTE THREE THIRTY SEVEN AROUND
THE BAY OR IN THE OR IN THE
CENTRAL VALLEY WE'RE RESTORING
WETLANDS SO IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
THE IN THE NATURAL RESOURCES
AGENCY UNDER THIS BILL
DETERMINES WHAT WILL BE THE
AMBITIOUS RANGE WE KNOW FROM
THE LIVERMORE LABS AT THE FLOOR
JOCKEY ABOUT QUARTER FROM THE
IPP PCC WEBER TWENTY FIFTEEN
EIGHTY PERCENT OF THE CARBON
IT'S GONNA BE CAPTURED X.
IS COMING FROM THEIR NATURAL
LANDS AND I THINK IT'S GOOD
THAT THE AIRPORT IS GOING
TO QUANTIFY TO MAKE SURE THE
PEOPLE DON'T DOUBLE COUNT AND
THAT'S THAT'S AND THAT'S GOOD
BUT YOU FOLKS YOU SENATORS
AND THE ASSEMBLY ARE DO HAVE
ALREADY DONE MADE THE IMPORTANT
DECISIONS TO MAKE THIS A
SUCCESS I REGION AYE VOTE THANK
YOU SAID A WHITE CAL SCHEME
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SENATOR DOLLY
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS IT'S IT'S ALL I CAN DO
TO JUST CONTROL MYSELF RIGHT
NOW AS A FARMER THE ONLY FARMER
ON THE SENATE FLOOR WHO SAID
ON SUB TO WITH MY GOOD FRIEND
FROM FREMONT SEE THE PROBLEM
IS HE JUST SPOUTED OFF WHAT
GAVIN NEWSOM ALWAYS DOES ALL
THE MONEY YOU'RE PUTTING OUT
THERE MONEY EVERYWHERE BUT IT'S
THE POLICY THIS LACKS ENGAGE
IN I'M A FARMER I CAN'T LIVE
IN THE STADIUM I'M I'M LOOKING
AT A WAY TO SAVE MY FARM NINETY
TWO YEARS OF THE DALITS FARMING
A CALIFORNIA I HAVE NEIGHBORS
WHO SOLD THEIR LAND AND LEFT
BECAUSE OF THE REGULATIONS
THAT ALL THIS CLIMATE CHANGE
STUFF IS SUPPOSED TO BE DOING
AND IT'S NOT DOING IS DRIVING
UP THE COST OF EVERYTHING
THAT WE DO AND WE'RE COMPETING
AGAINST OTHER STATES AND OTHER
NATIONS YOU DON'T KNOW ANYTHING
ABOUT FARMING I'M TO TELL
YOU THAT RIGHT NOW YOU DON'T
KNOW MUCH ABOUT THE FORCE BUT
YOU'RE ALL BEEN EDUCATED BY
SOMEBODY WHO HASN'T LIVED OUT
THERE AND DONE IT I'M SORRY
I I'M I I CAN'T BELIEVE HOW
LONG ARE WE GOING TO JUST
CONTINUE TO SET TARGETS WITH
NO GOOD DETAIL AND JUST THROW
MONEY AT IT AND GET NO RESULT
THE GOVERNOR PUT A BILLION
DOLLARS IN THE FOREST
WHOOP DE DO WE TREATED
SIXTY THOUSAND ACRES
THE PRIVATE PEOPLE THE PEOPLE
THAT ACTUALLY OWN PORCELAIN
TREATED A HALF A MILLION ACRES
AND YOU KNOW WHAT THE NOW TO
RESOURCE AC COUNTED THAT IN
THERE TREATMENT NEEDED SPEND
ONE CENT ON IT ACTUALLY PAID
MONEY TO THE NATURIST OR HIS
AGENCY TO DO THE WORK ON THEIR
OWN LANDS THEY WERE TAXED THIS
IS A JOKE THIS IS A TOTAL JOKE
IF YOU WANT TO KEEP FARMERS IN
CALIFORNIA LEAVE US THE HELL
ALONE LET US PRODUCE A PRODUCT
IN FEED AMERICA WE DO A GOOD
JOB I MEAN THAT'S ANOTHER GOAL
WE'VE WE JUST HAD THE MAYOR
SUIT YOU BILL WHICH IS THE GOAL
WE'VE HAD ALL THESE GOALS AND
WHAT WE GETTING FOR MILLION
ACRE FIRE DIXIE FIRE IN THE
LAST TEN YEARS SINCE I'VE BEEN
HERE WE'VE SET GOALS AND I'VE
STOOD UP AND I SAID THAT'S
A GOAL BUT HOW YOU GONNA GET
THERE AGAIN WE THROW MONEY
AT IT CALIFORNIANS TAXPAYER
MONEY AND CARBON MONEY MY GOOD
FRIEND FROM FREMONT TALKS ABOUT
THE AUCTION THAT JUST WENT
OFF THE OTHER DAY WE ALMOST
CREATED A BILLION DOLLARS
WORTH THE BILLION DOLLARS COME
FROM DOES ANYBODY KNOW WHY DO
TWENTY TWO CENTS FROM EVERY
GALLON OF GASOLINE AND DIESEL
THAT SOLD IS A CARBON TAX ON
THE FRONT END THEY GETS PAID
FOR THAT BILLION DOLLARS SO
THAT'S A TAX THAT YOU DON'T
SEE IN YOUR GALLON THE GAS
THAT'S WHY YOU CAN'T AFFORD
TO RUN YOUR TRACTOR CALIFORNIA
OF A TRACTOR IT'S FOUR HUNDRED
FIFTY HORSEPOWER YEAH BIRDS
TWELVE GALLONS OF DIESEL IN OUR
IN THE LAST SIX MONTHS THE
COST TO DRIVE THAT TRACTOR HAS
DOUBLED IT TAKES THREE HUNDRED
GALLONS A DAY SIXTEEN HUNDRED
DOLLARS A DAY JUST TO PUT
DIESEL IN IT SO CALIFORNIANS
CAN EAT I'M COMPETING GETS A
GUY IN OREGON NEVADA ARIZONA
WHO'S PAYING THREE DOLLARS A
GALLON LESS THAN I AM BECAUSE
YOU DON'T KNOW ALL THE TAXES
ON AND REGULATORY STUFF SO
AT THE END OF THE DAY THIS IS
ALL NOT GOING TO WORK WE'RE
ALWAYS IN A CRISIS WHAT WE'RE
TREATING THE CRISIS YOU KNOW
I'M THE FIRST GUY THAT WANTS
TO GO OUT AND THEN THE FORCED
SO IT DOESN'T BURN I'M TAKING
YOU ON TOURS AND SHOWED YOU
WHERE WITHIN THE POOREST AND
WHEN THE FIRE COMES THROUGH
AND WE DIDN'T FORCES COMPLETELY
BLACK ON ONE SIDE AND THERE'S
LIVE TREES SEQUESTERING CARBON
ALIVE FOR SEQUESTERS CARBON A
DEAD FORCED EMITS CARBON AND
DESTROYS WATERSHEDS FOR FIFTY
YEARS YOU KNOW WHAT INTEL WE
PUT POLICY AND GOOD POLICY AND
THOUGHTFUL POLICY BEHIND AND
GET PEOPLE OUT OF THE WAY LOS
ACTUALLY TREAT THE LANDS THESE
GOALS WILL DO NOTHING WITH ALL
DUE RESPECT I WOULD VOTE FOR
IT BECAUSE IT'S NOT GOING TO DO
ANYTHING IT'S JUST GOING TO RUN
THE RATES UP AND CALIFORNIANS
ARE SUFFERING GO TO THE
GROCERY STORE EVERYTHING'S
GOING UP WHY BECAUSE
EVERYTHING GETS MOVED BY FUEL
ASKED FOR NO VOTE I DON'T
KNOW WHAT ELSE TO SAY TO
CONVINCE I YOU KNOW I HOPE
THE CALIFORNIANS WAKE UP AND
REALIZE THAT THESE POLICIES
DO NOTHING BUT SPEND THEIR
MONEY AND GET NO RESULT
THANK YOU CENTER DOLLY MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEN HEARING MEANT CENTER BAKER
YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU MR
PRESIDENT SO I WAS HAPPY SHOULD
THE PASSION OF MY COLLEAGUE
FROM THE BEAVER ON THIS
ISSUE PARTICULARLY ON FOREST
MANAGEMENT AND ON FARMING --
AND I KNOW THAT MANY OF YOU
HAVE DONE A LOT OF WORK LAST
COUPLE YEARS I'M HAPPY TO BE
PART OF IT AROUND FORCE IN ITS
IT AND WORKING ON ISSUES LIKE
ANY NOW AND PRESCRIBED BURNS
AND OTHER ISSUES BUT THIS BILL
DOESN'T SPEAK SPECIFICALLY TO
THAT I'M FORCE MANAGEMENT WHAT
DOES IT COST FOR STATE AGENCIES
SET TARGETS FOR SEQUESTRATION
DOES NOT PRESCRIBE PACIFIC
MANSION PRACTICES AND FORCE OR
OTHER HABITATS IS REALLY AND I
SO WANT TO GO FOR MY COLLEAGUE
FROM TO HEMA WHAT IT SAYS
PRACTITIONERS AND I APPRECIATE
THAT POINT VERY MUCH OF FARMERS
AND RANCHERS ARE COVERED UNDER
PRACTITIONER SO I VERY MUCH
APPRECIATE THAT POINT THAT WAS
RAISED BUT DOES INCLUDE FARMERS
AND RANCHERS BUT THIS IS
REALLY AROUND MOTIVATING FARMAN
FARMING CARBON SEQUESTRATION
PRACTICES I'VE BEEN ON CALLS
WITH THE CLIMATE CENTER AND
THEY'RE ALL VERY PRACTICAL
CALLS THEIR CALLS WITH FARMERS
TALK ABOUT WHAT THEY DID HOW
THEY DID IT HOW THEIR ANY
MONEY BECAUSE WITH THE RESOURCE
CONSERVATION AGENCIES I'VE BEEN
ON MANY OF THESE CALLS NOW AND
ITS FARMERS THEMSELVES BEING
PUT FROM THE CENTER TO TALK
ABOUT THESE PRACTICES BECAUSE
IT'S NOT OPEN STANDARD RIGHT
THIS WHOLE AREA OF SAYING HEY
GREAT HOW DO WE DO REGENERON
CULTURE HOW DO WE DO A FARMING
YOU KNOW HOW DO WE WILL TREAT
OUR LANDS TO SEQUESTER CARBON
SOME OF THIS IS A NEW WORK AND
NEW INNOVATIONS BEING DONE SO
BECAUSE I'VE BEEN HAVE BEEN
LED BY FARMERS ON THIS WORKING
SO IN A PREVIOUS VERSION OF
THIS BILL HAD A VERY SPECIFIC
A VERY HIGH LEVEL TARGET AT
THIS BILL DOESN'T HAVE THAT
THIS BILL IS A HAVE THAT THIS
BILL AS I MENTIONED EARLIER
IS REALLY ABOUT THAT NATURAL
RESOURCE AGENCIES AND AIR
RESOURCES BOARD AMONG OTHERS
WORKING TOGETHER WITH THESE
EXPERTS TO SET THOSE TARGETS
SO THAT WE CAN REALLY JUMPSTART
THIS PART OF OF OF OUR EFFORTS
OVERALL TO SUCK CARBON OUT OF
THE ATMOSPHERE SO WITH THAT
I APPRECIATE THE SPUR DEBATE
AS SUCH WE ASK FOR OUR VOTE
THANK YOU CENTER BAKER MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA ATKINS AYE
BATES NO FACTOR I PORCHES NO
BRADFORD CABALLERO CORTEZ THE
I DALY NO DODD THERE ARE SOME
I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ
GROSS NO HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
I REQUEST I HER TADO NOPE
JONES NO KAMLAGER WHERE DO I
LEYVA AYE THE MOST MCGUIRE AYE
MELENDEZ NOPE MANY AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN NO -- CHOI BOGUE
NO PAN I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
AYE RUBIO SKINNER AYE STERN
HI I'M BURKE I LIKE HOUSEKI
I WIENER WIENER AYE WILK
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA HI BRADFORD CABALLERO
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO I
DODD I GLAZER HI GONZALEZ
KAMLAGER HI LIMÓN RUBIO
RUBIO AYE WILK BY TWENTY EIGHT
KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
WE ARE RECONCILING THE
FILES AND WE WILL BANKS
BE BACK WITH YOU SHORTLY
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO MOVE
TO MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
THIS WOULD BE THE PROPER
TIME TO MOVE BILLS TO THE
INACTIVE FILE OR LETTERS TO
THE JOURNAL SENATOR ALAN I
REQUEST UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO
SUBMIT THIS LETTER THE JOURNAL
RELATING TO SB FIFTY FOUR WE'VE
GOT APPROVAL FROM EVERYBODY AT
THE DESK WILL NOTE THANK YOU
VERY MUCH PLEASE BRING IT ON UP
SENATOR PAN I THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT CENTERSET TWO ITEMS
SO FIRST OF ALL AT THE REQUEST
OF THE AUTHOR I LIKE TO DO FILE
ITEM NUMBER THIRTY FOUR EIGHTY
SIX YOU KNOW EIGHT BY SUMMER
GIPSON TODAY AN ACTIVE FILE
THANK YOU VERY MUCH THE DESK
WILL NOTE A SECOND OF ALL
-- I WOULD LIKE TO PRESENT
A LETTER TO THE JOURNAL FOR
UNANIMOUS FOR UNANIMOUS CONSENT
TO CLARIFY FUNDING ALLOCATED
TO THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO TO
ADDRESS HOMELESSNESS IN CAPITOL
PARK IS PROVIDED IN SB EIGHTY
ONE SEVENTY NINE PURSUANT
TO SUBPARAGRAPH C.
A PARAGRAPH
THREE A SUBDIVISION H.
IN SECTION NINETEEN POINT FIVE
SIX -- IT'S BEEN APPROVED BY
BOTH SIDES BELIEVE ESPECIALLY
ASPIRIN I AM CONSENT FOR
ARRIVAL ON -- SUBMISSION THIS
LETTER ABSOLUTELY BRING IT
FORWARD THANK YOU SENATOR PAN
CENTER STERN ONE HUNDRED CENTER
STREET THANK YOU MATT SORRY
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AT
THE REQUEST THE AUTHOR I'D
LIKE TO MOVE FILE ITEM NUMBER
THIRTY FIVE AB NINETY NINE
SUMMER OR WINTER THE ENACTED
FIVE THANK YOU SIR THE DESK
WILL NOTE SENATOR WIENER I
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT --
I RISE HAS UNANIMOUS CONSENT
TO SUBMIT A LETTER TO THE
JOURNAL LETTER WHICH IS SIGNED
BY ME AND SENATORS LEHRMAN'S
RASO CLARIFIES THE INTENT OF
SENATE BILL EIGHT EIGHT SIX AS
IT RELATES TO THE CALIFORNIA
STUDENT HOUSING REVOLVING FUND
ACT OF TWENTY TWENTY TWO THE
LETTER HAS BEEN CLEARED BY BOTH
SIDES OF THE AISLE THANK YOU
WITHOUT OBJECTION PLEASE BRING
THE LETTER FORWARD CENTER BAKER
I THANK YOU MA'AM PRESENT I ASK
FOR UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO SUBMIT
A LETTER TO THE JOURNAL FIND
SB EIGHT EIGHT SEVEN HI THIS
THIS LETTER HAS BEEN CLEARED
BY BOTH SIDES YEAH CENTER BAKER
-- WITHOUT OBJECTION IN PLEASE
BRING FORWARD CENTER CABALLERO
-- THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT --
I REQUEST UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO
PRESENT A LETTER TO THE JOURNAL
REGARDING -- THE INTENT OF SB
NINE OH FIVE CARBON CAPTURE
THANK YOU WITHOUT OBJECTION
PLEASE BRING IT FORWARD CENTER
BRADFORD OKAY HOLD ON SIR
BRADFORD ARE YOU OBJECTING NO
MANAGER I JUST LIKE TO THANK
THE AUTHOR FOR SUBMITTING THE
LETTER ON THE INTENT OF NINE OH
FIVE AND I REALLY DO APPRECIATE
HER OF HER DILIGENCE ON THIS
ISSUE VERY GOOD THANK CENTER
GROVE CENTER BRADFORD THANK YOU
AT THE REQUEST OF THE AUTHOR
PLEASE REMOVE A MOVE FILE ITEM
ONE EIGHTY FOUR AB TWO SEVEN
SEVEN FOUR FROM THE SPECIAL
CONSENT CALENDAR TO THEN
ACT TO FILE THANK YOU CENTER
THE DESK WILL NOTE MEMBERS
ANYTHING AT CENTER PORTANTINO
YES MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE
TO SUBMIT A LETTER TO THE
JOURNAL RELATED TO S.
B.
THIRTEEN OH TWO IT'S BEEN
APPROVED BY BOTH SIDES THANK
YOU WITHOUT OBJECTION PLEASE
BRING THE LETTER FORWARD
MEMBERS ANYTHING ELSE UNDER
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS THAT
WAS VERY PRODUCTIVE GOOD JOB
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO LIFT
THE CALL ON FILE ITEM SEVEN
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA BAKER
HI CABALLERO DODD
GLAZER WESA THE TROUBLE
PAN AYE NUMBER IS
TWENTY ONE KNOWS TO WHAT
BAKER UP THE NECK -- I DON'T
KNOW CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA CABALLERO DODD
GLAZER WESSEL A TROUBLED I'M
BURKE SENATOR MOVES A CALL
MEMBERS ARE MOVING THE FILE
ITEM FORTY FOUR SENATOR
GONZALEZ MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY SEVEN
NINETY EIGHT BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
FONG AND ACT RELIGIOUS LAND
USE AND DECLARING THEIR TO SEE
THEIR ABSENT FROM THE MEDIA
CENTER GONZALEZ THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE TODAY TO
PRESENT AB TWENTY SEVEN NINETY
EIGHT ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
MEMBER FONG WHICH WILL HELP TO
PROVIDE AN IMMEDIATE SOLUTION
AND DRESSING CONGESTION AT
CALIFORNIA PORTS AB TWENTY
SEVEN NINETY EIGHT WILL ALLOW
TEMPORARY USE PERMITS TO MOVE
FORWARD SO THAT DEVELOPERS
CAN IMMEDIATELY COMMENCE SHORT
TERM FREIGHT TRANSPORTATION
USES THESE PERMITS MUST BE
CONSISTENT STILL WITH LOCAL
PLANNING AND ZONING ORDINANCES
AND ARE LIMITED TO SHORT TERM
FREIGHT TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS
-- THE MEASURE IS LIMITED IN
SCOPE AS WELL TO IMMEDIATELY
ADDRESS THE UNIQUE NEEDS OF
THE STATE'S SUPPLY CHAIN CRISIS
THINKING I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
GONZALEZ MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING NONE IS FORTINOS
ZERO ON THE URGENCY IS FORTY
NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS ARE WAITING FOR
SOME BILLS TO COME BACK FROM
THE ASSEMBLY AND WE'RE ALSO
GETTING READY TO DO SOME
BUDGET BILL SO HANG TIGHT
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS THANK YOU
FOR YOUR PATIENCE WE ARE GOING
TO BE TAKING UP BUDGET BILLS
WERE STARTING WITH FILE ITEM
FIFTY TWO SENATOR SKINNER
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
ASSEMBLY BILL ONE SEVENTY
TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER TING
AN ACT RELATING TO THE
STATE BUDGET AND MAKING AN
APPROPRIATION THEREFORE TAKE
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY BUDGET
BELL CENTER SKINNER THANK
YOU VERY MUCH MEMBERS AB ONE
SEVENTY NINE IS OUR BUDGET
BILL JUNIOR TRAILER BILL
AND THE MAJOR PROVISIONS ARE
NINE HUNDRED AND FIFTY NINE
MILLION APPROPRIATION FOR
ENERGY THREE HUNDRED AND FIFTY
FIVE MILLION TO ADDRESS DROUGHT
WATER ISSUES HUNDRED MILLION
FOR WILDFIRE RESILIENCE SIX
HUNDRED NINETY FOUR MILLION
FOR NATURE BASED SOLUTIONS
HUNDRED AND FIFTY MILLION TO
ADDRESS AND ADAPT TO EXTREME
HEAT HUNDRED MILLION FOR PARKS
AND THEY ARE OUTDOOR ACCESS
THERE'S TWO HUNDRED MILLION OF
THE GREENHOUSE GAS REDUCTION
FUND FOR THE CAP AND TRADE
DISCRETIONARY SPENDING PLAN
MONEY TO SUPPORT THE ZERO
EMISSION VEHICLE PACKAGE THE
WATERSHED CLIMATE RESILIENCE
SEA LEVEL RISE AND FOR STATE
CONSERVANCY'S FOR WILD FIRE
RESISTANCE ADDITIONALLY IT
PROVIDES THE MONEY FOR OUR
CLINIC WORKFORCE RETENTION
PAYMENTS UNDER NEW GENERAL
FUND ALLOCATION TO HELP
OUR DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
HEALTH DEAL WITH M.
PARKS AND LASTLY THE FIRST
YEAR OF A MULTI YEAR PACKAGE
FOR OUR BEVERAGE CONTAINER
RECYCLING FINDING WITHOUT I
ASK FOR YOUR RIVALS THANK YOU
CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
NONE MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
BAKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD AYE
CUP AYE GOTTA AYE CRITICIZING
AYE TALLY NO DODD AYE TO
RUSSELL EGGMAN FIVE GLAZER HI
GONZALEZ I CROAK NO HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED
AYE LEYVA HEIGHTS AMONG
LIMON HI WIRE I'VE MELENDEZ
NOPE MANY I NEWMAN HIS
NIELSEN NO -- CHOI BOGUE
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH FIVE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
AYE NUMBER I REQUEST PEOPLE AYE
WIENER FIVE WELL PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS BATES NO THE
RAZA I A TROUBLED WILK I THIRTY
ONE NO SEVEN SEVEN THE MEASURE
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY THREE SENATORS
SKINNER MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWO OH
NINE BY THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE
ON BUDGET AND ACTUALLY
INTO ENERGY AND MAKING IT A
PERFORATION THEREFORE TAKE
A COMPLETELY BILL RELATED TO
THE BUDGET SENATOR SKINNER
MEMBERS AB TWO OH NINE IS
THE ENERGY TRAILER BILL
ESTABLISHING PROGRAMS TO
SUPPORT DECARBONISATION
ACTIVITIES AND INCREASE ENERGY
RELIABILITY ADDITIONALLY
TWO OH NINE AUTHORIZES
OUR ENERGY COMMISSION TO
ESTABLISH A PROGRAM TO SUPPORT
OFFSHORE WIND INFRASTRUCTURE
IMPROVEMENTS IN WITH THAT I ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THE CENTER
SKINNER MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
MEN MEN SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD I HAVE ITEM
AYE PROTESTING AYE TALLY DODD
AYE DERISIVE AYE EGGMAN AYE
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG AYE WESSEL AYE
HURTADO AYE JONES NO KAMLAGER
AYE FLARED AYE LEYVA I FOR
THE MOST I MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ
NOPE MEN AYE NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN NO -- TROUBLED PAN I
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
AYE SKINNER AYE STERN I AMBERG
I WHITE HOUSE THESE AYE WIENER
WILK PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS BATES NO OR JUST
DALY NO A TROUBLED WIENER I
WILK I CITY ONE NO SIX THE
MEASURE PASSES MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM FIFTY FOUR CENTER
SKINNER MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ ASSEMBLY BILL TWO
ELEVEN BY THE ASSEMBLY FOR
THE ON BUDGET AN ACT RELATING
TO PUBLIC YOU RESOURCES AND
MAKING OPERATION THEREFORE
SIGNIFICANTLY BUILDINGS
THE BUDGET SINCE THE INNER
BEFORE I DESCRIBE AB TWO
ELEVEN I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE
THAT WE HAVE THREE A BUDGET
COMMITTEE MEMBERS WHO WILL
BE GIVING US IN LEAVING THEIR
POSITIONS AS BUDGET COMMITTEE
MEMBERS -- AND THEY HAVE
BEEN A LONG SERVING BUDGET
COMMITTEE MEMBERS INCLUDING
OUR VICE CHAIR SENATOR NIELSEN
OUR SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIR FOR
RESOURCES SENATOR Y.
CASKEY AND OUR FORMER HEALTH
SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIR BUT LONG
TERM MEMBER OF THE BUDGET
SENATOR PAN SOMEONE DID
ACKNOWLEDGE THEM AND GIVE US
GIVE THEM OUR APPRECIATION
FOR THEIR SERVICE AND ALSO I
WANTED TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
ACKNOWLEDGE STAFF STAFF IN THE
BUDGET COMMITTEE STAFF IN THE
OTHER HOUSE TO ASSIST THEIR
MEMBERS IN THE ANALYSIS AND OF
COURSE OUR PRO TEM STAFF AND
ALL OF YOUR PERSONAL STAFF THAT
WEIGH IN ON THE BUDGET -- THIS
WAS NOT ONLY THE LARGEST BUDGET
IN CALIFORNIA'S HISTORY BUT THE
LARGEST BUDGET IN U.
S.
HISTORY AND WITH THAT I WILL
DESCRIBE TO ELEVEN IT IS THE
RESOURCES TRAILER BILL AND IT
AUTHORIZES IT MAKES VARIOUS
AUTHORIZATIONS FOR CAL JIM
IT EXTENDS THE SUNSET FROM
JANUARY FIRST TWENTY TWENTY
THREE JANUARY FIRST TWENTY
TWENTY EIGHT FOR THE SEQUEL
EXEMPTION RELATED TO SPECIFIC
TYPES OF WILDFIRE PREVENTION
SUCH AS PRESCRIBED BY YOUR
THINNING AND FUEL REDUCTION
AND IT ESTABLISHES THE
COMMUNITY RESILIENCE CENTER
PROGRAM PLUS VARIOUS TECHNICAL
CLEANUP PROVISIONS AND WITHOUT
I ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS THANK CENTER SKINNER
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR DOLLY THANK YOU
AMERIPRISE MEMBERS I JUST WANT
TO POINT OUT THAT THERE IS A
LOT IN THIS BUDGET TRAILER BILL
BUT THERE'S A LOT THERE'S NO
FUNDING FOR WATER RESERVOIRS
THERE AND I KNOW THAT THAT THAT
WE HAD PROP ONE A FEW YEARS
BACK AND -- WE ALLOCATED MONEY
IN PROP ONE BUT WE'RE SITTING
ON A HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS
WE SHOULD ALLOCATED MONEY
TO ACTUALLY GET THIS PROJECT
SITES RATHER A BORE OFF THE
GROUND AND GOING WE ARE IN A
DROUGHT WE'RE GONNA HAVE MORE
DROUGHTS WE'RE NOT FLOODS AND
WE TO BE CAPTURED THAT WATER
TO BE A GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO
DO THAT AND IT WAS NOT IN THIS
BUDGET WE BROUGHT IT UP IN
SUB TO AND ALL THE WAY THROUGH
BUT -- NOT MONEY MUCH MONEY
HERE FOR -- STORAGE OF WATER
THANK YOU SENATOR ALEXANDER
EGGMAN THANK YOU A MAN A
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS -- I I
ALSO WANT TO THANK THE STAFF
AND EVERYBODY FOR ALL THEIR
HARD WORK ON THIS AND AND WE
HAVE ONE OF OUR STAFF LEFT
DURING THIS TIME EVER NEED
TO WORK ON THE HEALTH WE SHOW
HER APPRECIATION OF COURSE A
DOCTOR PAN WHO HAS JUST BEEN
PHENOMENAL AND AGAIN I I ALSO
JUST WANT TO TREATMENT FOR
THE RECORD I THINK IS A GREAT
BUDGET VERY EXCITING BUT I
JUST AGAIN FOR THE RECORD TO
TO EVER TO ALL OF US NEXT YEAR
WE REALLY HAVE TO PUT UP MORE
MONEY FOR LEVEES WE HAVE A
SERIOUS PROBLEM WITH OUR BIRTH
OUR LEVEE SYSTEM WOULD PUT VERY
LITTLE INTO IT FLOODS ARE GONNA
COME WE KNOW THEY'RE GOING TO
COME AND WE NEED TO BE PREPARED
I ASK FOR THEIR AYE VOTE
THOUGH IT'S VERY GOOD BILL THE
CENTER EGGMAN MEMBERS FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE TEEN HEARING THAT
MADAM SECRETARY WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE CENTER SKINNER THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT HI -- THERE
WE HAVE AN ADDITIONAL BUDGET
MEMBER WHO WHILE AS SERVING
NOT TO AS LONG AS THE OTHER
MEMBER SITE MENTIONED DID TAKE
OVER BEING THE SUB COMMITTEE
CHAIR FOR ONE OF OUR KEY BUDGET
SUBCOMMITTEES THIS SESSION AND
WE WILL NOT BE SEEING HER NEXT
YEAR AND I WANT TO THANK HER
FOR HER SERVICE ALSO SENATOR
COM LOCKER AND WITHOUT AYE
US FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
YOU CENTER SKINNER MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS I FACE BAKER I PORCHES
BRADFORD AYE CUP AYE GOTTA
AYE PROTESTING AYE TALLY DODD
AYE TO RUSSELL I EGGMAN ALL
RIGHTS RESERVED HI GONZALEZ
I GROWTH HERTZBERG AYE WESA
AYE HURTADO AYE JONES KAMLAGER
AYE FLARED AYE FLAVOR AYE
THE MOST LIMÓN I REQUIRE
MCGUIRE MELENDEZ MANY I NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN THE TROUBLE PAN
AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN HI
I'M BURKE AYE FORECASTING AYE
WIENER I WILK PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS WICKS PORCHES
TALLY GROVE JONES MCGUIRE HI
MELENDEZ NIELSEN A TROUBLED
WILK FIVE THIRTY ONE NO ZERO
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
YOU HAVE SUPPLEMENTAL FILE IN
FRONT OF YOU PLEASE PULL IT
OUT WE ARE GOING TO FILE ITEM
ONE THIRTY SENATOR PORTANTINO
NOT AT HIS DESK ALL RIGHT
LET'S GO TO FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTY ONE SENATOR LEE MON
MADAM SET WILL GO TO SET
CENTER PORTANTINO WILL COME
BACK TO SENATOR MON MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL TEN FORTY SEVEN BY SENATOR
LIMÓN AND ACT FOR LEADING TO
EARLY LEARNING AND CARE SAN
RAMON THANK YOU VERY MUCH SB
TEN FORTY SEVEN IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCE I EIGHT PROVIDES
A PATHWAY TO STREAMLINED
HEALTHCARE SERVICES IN A
CD CALIFORNIA THROUGH THE
APPLICATION I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR NEIGHBORHOOD THANK YOU
CENTER LIMÓN MEMBERS DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING
THEM MEMBERS THIS QUALIFIES
FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS
THERE ANY OBJECTION SEEING AND
HEARING NONE IS FORTY KNOWS
ZERO ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM ONE
THIRTY SENATOR PORTANTINO MEN
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL EIGHT FIFTY ONE BY SENATOR
PORTANTINO AN ACT RELATING TO
TAXATION SIX IMMEDIATELY TAX
LEVY CENTER PORTANTINO THANK
YOU ARE MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS
SB EIGHT FIFTY ONE CORRECT A
DRAFTING ERROR IN SB ONE ONE
THREE A BUDGET TRAILER BILL
WHICH PASSED IN FEBRUARY THE
LANGUAGE OF THIS BILL WAS
DEVELOPED IN CAREFUL CONSULT
CONSULTATION WITH THE F.
T.
B.
AND LEGISLATIVE STAFFS IT IS
SUPPORTED BY THE ACCOUNTING
PROFESSION IN STATE CONTROLLER
BETTY AND I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE ON THE
CONCURRENCE OF ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NONE MEMBERS IT'S ALSO
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL SIR ANY OBJECTION SEEING
AND HEARING THEM ON ICE FORTY
EIGHT NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY TWO
SENATOR ATKINS MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TEN
THIRTEEN BY SENATOR ATKINS
AN ACT RELATING TO RECYCLING
AND MAKING AN APPROPRIATION
THEREFORE CENTER ATKINS MADAM
PRESIDENT THANK YOU SO MUCH
OUR COLLEAGUES SB TEN THIRTEEN
IS BACK FOR CONCURRENCE THE
BILL EXPANDS THE STATE'S BOTTLE
BILL PROGRAM TO INCLUDE WINE
AND DISTILLED SPIRITS THE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS TO THE
FOLLOWING BEGIN C.
EXPANSION COMMENCING JANUARY
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
CREATES GRANT PROGRAMS TO HELP
ADDRESS GLASS CONTAMINATION
AND RECYCLING ISSUES PROVIDES
FUNDS TO SIMULATE THE USE OF
CLASS CALL IT IN MAKING NEW
GLASS BEVERAGE CONTAINERS
ASSIST PILOT PROGRAMS THAT
WOULD COLLECT EMPTY GLASS
BOTTLES FROM RESTAURANTS AND
RETAILERS AND FACILITATES USE
OF RAIL TRANSPORT INTO GLASS
BOTTLES THE GLASS PROCESSING
FACILITIES THROUGHOUT THE
STATE EXAM SMALL DEALERS
FROM REDEMPTION REQUIREMENTS
EXPANDS CONVENIENCE OWNS AND
EFFECTIVE JANUARY FIRST TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE REMOVES THE OPTION
FOR DEALERS TO PAY A HUNDRED
DOLLARS A DAY IN LIEU FEE FOR
NOT PROVIDING IN STORE TAKE
BACK AND INSTEAD GIVES DEALERS
THE OPTION OF JOINING A DEALER
COOPERATION A COOPERATIVE
PARDON ME AND THEN IT'S ALSO
HELP MODERNIZE THE BOTTOM BILL
PROGRAM BY PROVIDING NEEDED
FUNDING AUTHORIZATIONS AND
TECHNICAL CHANGES NECESSARY
TO ENSURE SUCCESS OF THE
PROGRAM YOU CAN SEE THERE
WERE SOME AMENDMENTS LASTLY
I WANT TO THANK THE SENATOR
FROM NAPA FOR COLLABORATING
WITH ME ON THIS MEASURE HIS
ESTABLISHED RELATIONSHIPS
WITH THIS INDUSTRY HAVE BEEN
OF GREAT VALUE AS WE PURSUE
THIS LEGISLATION I ALSO WANT
TO THANK THE SENATOR FROM
FREMONT FOR HIS TIRELESS
ADVOCACY TO IMPROVE THE BOTTLE
BILL PROGRAM THANK YOU AND
WITH THAT I WOULD ASK FOR
YOUR AYE VOTE ON THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS IN CONCURRENCE
THANK YOU MATTER PRO TEM
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES AYE PACKER AYE FORGES
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
COURTESY AYE TALLY AYE DODD
AYE TERASA AYE EGGMAN AYE
GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH I
HERTZBERG I PUESTO AYE HURTADO
AYE JONES I HI KAMLAGER AYE
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE THE
MON I REQUIRE I MELENDEZ
MANY I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN AYE
ULTRABOOK AYE PAN I PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
I STERN AYE AMBER AYE AYE
CASKEY AYE WIENER AYE WILK
HI PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS GORGEOUS MELENDEZ
IS THIRTY EIGHT ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY MOMENTS ARE CONCURRED
IN FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY
THREE SENATOR GLAZERS MAN
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL FOURTEEN THIRTY NINE BY
SENATOR GLAZERS AND ACTUALLY
INTO THE POLITICAL REFORM
ACT OF NINETEEN SEVENTY FOUR
SENATOR GLAZERS THANK YOU MADAM
-- PRESIDENT AND -- MEMBERS
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS REMOVED
PROVISIONS RELATING TO A SPOUSE
OF A PARTY OR PARTICIPANT --
IT ALSO -- CREATED ABILITY
TO CURE IF YOU ACCEPT A
PROHIBITED CONTRIBUTION AND
AN EX CLARIFYING CHANGES --
AND MEMBERS JUST A QUICK NOTE
OF HISTORY AND OBSERVATION ON
THIS BILL THE HISTORY IS THAT
IN NINETEEN EIGHTY TWO THAT
IS SELLING THEN MEL LEVINE --
PASSED A A CONFLICT OF INTEREST
PROVISIONS -- AFTER MUCH
CHALLENGING STRUGGLE THAT ONLY
APPLY TO APPOINTED OFFICIALS IN
CALIFORNIA AND NOW FORTY YEARS
LATER WE ARE ON THE VERGE OF
OF TAKING THAT PROVISION AND
AND DO IT AT A HUNDRED DEATHS
BY APPLYING IT TO EVERY CITY
COUNCIL ELECTED CITY COUNCIL
MEMBER SUPERVISORS SPECIAL
DISTRICT MEMBER -- AND IT'S
PROBABLY THE MOST SIGNIFICANT
POLITICAL REFORM THAT WE HAVE
SEEN IN MANY MANY DECADES AND
FINALLY I WANT TO SAY THANK
YOU FOR THE SUPPORT THAT YOU
PROVIDED TO THIS BILL THROUGH
THE PROCESS -- I THINK OUT OF
OUR WORK TODAY WE'RE GOING TO
IMPROVE CONFIDENCE AND TRUST
IN GOVERNMENT SUCH AN IMPORTANT
THING THAT WE DO THAT THE
DECISIONS THAT ARE MADE AT
ALL LEVELS I ENJOY THE TRUST
AND SUPPORT OF THE PEOPLE BY
MAKING IT CLEAR THAT CONFLICT
OF INTEREST PAY TO PLAY IS NOT
PART OF OUR NARRATIVE FOR WHAT
WE WANT OUR DEMOCRACY BUT TO BE
ABOUT AND WITH THAT I THANK YOU
FOR YOUR ACCOMPLISHMENTS TODAY
ON SO MANY THINGS INCLUDING
THIS BILL TODAY AND ASKED FOR
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
GLAZER MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER FOR
JUST BRADFORD AYE CUPBEARER AYE
PROTESTING AYE TALLY DODD I TO
RUSSELL I EGGMAN AYE PLACER AYE
GONZALEZ HI GROWTH HERTZBERG I
WESTERN AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
KAMLAGER I LAYERED HIS LEYVA
I FOR THE MONTH I'VE MCGUIRE
AYE MELENDEZ MANY AYE NEWMAN
AYE NIELSEN I TROUBLED AM I
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE
SKINNER I STERN STERN HI I'M
BURKE HI FOR CASCADE HI WIENER
I WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS BASED ON BAKER
HI OR JUST OKAY THANK YOU DALY
GROVE JONES MELENDEZ NIELSEN
A CHOI BOTH HIGHS THIRTY
TWO KNOWS ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS WITH THEM MA'AM
SECRETARY WE'RE GONNA LIFT
THE CALL ON THE CALLS ON
FILE ITEM SEVEN MEMBERS FILE
ITEM SEVEN MA'AM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA CABALLERO DODD
GLAZER WESA HI -- TROUBLED
AMBER EYES TWENTY ONE KNOWS
THIRTEEN THE MEDIA ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ARE CONCURRED IN
CENTERS ARE MOVING TO MOTIONS
AND RESOLUTIONS SENATOR
GONZALEZ PRESS THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT I'D LIKE TO
MOVE A FILE ITEM THE FORTY
SIX AB TWENTY NINE TEN BY
ASSEMBLY MEMBER SANTIAGO
TO THE AN ACTIVE FILE THANK
YOU THE DESK WILL NOTE
MEMBERS THANK YOU SO
MUCH FOR YOUR PATIENCE WE
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
FIFTY SIX SENATOR BECKER
OKAY I HAVE BAD INFORMATION
SENATOR HERTZBERG MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ HE TOLD
ME TO CLEAR THAT ASSEMBLY
BILL TWENTY ONE THIRTY
THREE BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
QUIRK AN ACT RELATING TO
GREENHOUSE EMISSIONS GAS
EMISSIONS CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS OF YOUR ATTENTION
IMPORTANT MEASURE CENTER BACKER
THANK YOU MEMBERS HI RISE
TONIGHT FOR THE LAST TIMES I
WILL RISE AS A MEMBER OF THIS
HOUSE REPRESENTING THE GREAT
SAN FERNANDO VALLEY IS A PLACE
MEMBERS WHERE FOR THE MOST
PART CLIMATE CHANGE IS NOT ON
THE TOP OF MIND KEEPING A ROOF
OVER YOUR HEAD HOLDING DOWN
A JOB OR EVEN TO KEEPING YOUR
KIDS SAFE IN SCHOOL THAT TENDS
TO BE FIRST BUT THE SIMPLE
FACT MEMBERS IS OUR ONLY HOME
IS THIS PLANET OUR ONLY HOME
IS THIS PLANET THERE ARE NO
OTHER JOBS THERE ARE NO JOBS
ON EARTH RENDERED UNLIVABLE
BY CLIMATE CHANGE AND OUR
CHILDREN NEVER BE SAFE IN A
WORLD CONTINUALLY DEVASTATED
BY HE DRIVEN FIRE CENTER STERN
FLOOD UNDER CURRENT LAW WE MUST
ACHIEVE A STATEWIDE GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSION REDUCTION OF
AT LEAST FORTY PERCENT NO
LATER THAN DECEMBER THIRTY
ONE TWENTY THIRTY IN THE
SIMPLEST TERMS THIS MEASURE
BEFORE US TODAY INCREASES
OUR CALIFORNIA GREENHOUSE GAS
EMISSION REDUCTION TARGET TO
FIFTY FIVE PERCENT IT'S A VERY
SHORT FEW SENTENCES BILL BUT
IT'S IMPACTS ARE EXTRAORDINARY
AND THE BILL STILL RAISES A
NUMBER OF QUESTIONS I WANT TO
START MEMBERS WITH HISTORICAL
CONTEXT HISTORICAL CONTEXT
THE OPPONENTS OF THIS BILL
WILL TELL YOU WERE MOVING THE
GOAL POST AND EVERYBODY THERE
IS ABSOLUTELY CORRECT WE ARE
BUT LET'S START WITH A BIT OF
THIS HISTORICAL CONTEXT WHEN
THE LEGISLATURE FACED SIMILAR
MEASURES IN TWO THOUSAND AND
TWO ALMOST TWENTY YEARS AGO
TO THIS VERY DAY WE CONSIDERED
BYRON SHEARS SB TEN SEVENTY
EIGHT WHICH TOLD UTILITIES
AND THEY NEEDED TO ACHIEVE A
TWENTY PERCENT OF THEIR ENERGY
FROM RENEWABLES YOU COULD
THE EXACT SAME OPPOSITION
THAT WE SEE TODAY THAT THIS
MEASURE WE SAW THEN TWENTY
YEARS AGO BECAUSE I WAS HERE
THE ARGUMENTS WERE MADE IN THE
HALLS OF THESE BUILDINGS AND
I'M TELLING YOU THEY WERE THE
SAME IMPOSSIBLE HUGE IMPACT
TO CONSUMERS JOBS WILL BE
EXPORTED AND GUESS WHAT THE
ECONOMY GREW AND THE GOALS
WE MET FOUR YEARS EARLIER
IN TWO THOUSAND TO THE ASSEMBLY
WHAT WOMAN PAVLEY FRAN PAVLEY
WE PASSED AB FOURTEEN NINETY
THREE WHICH CREATED NEW AND
AMBITIOUS TAIL PIPE EMISSION
STANDARDS AND GUESS WHAT
OPPONENTS AT THAT TIME SAID
OF THIS MEASURE THE BILL BOOK
PLANE THAT WILL PRODUCE NO
HEALTH BENEFITS AND I QUOTE
FROM THE OPPOSITION IN THE
ANALYSIS THAT CARBON DIOXIDE
IS HARMLESS INERT GAS IT'S ONE
OF LIFE'S BUILDING BLOCKS ONE
OF LIFE'S BUILDING BLOCKS THEY
SAID AND NOW WE KNOW BETTER
AND NOW CAR COMPANIES ARE
NOT JUST COMPLYING WITH OUR
STANDARDS BUT THEY'RE DOING
SO ON A NATIONAL LEVEL WE ARE
LEADING THE WAY IN TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN FORMER SENATE PRO TEM
KEVIN DE LEÓN PASSED SB ONE
HUNDRED OFF OF THIS VERY FLOOR
UNDER SIMILAR CIRCUMSTANCES THE
LAST THING WE NEEDED SAID IN
THE ANALYSIS IN OPPOSITION IS
ONEROUS REGULATION THAT WILL
PUSH ENERGY COSTS EVEN HIGHER
MEMBERS AND CONVENIENCE THAT
COULD CONVINCE COMPANIES TO
TAKE THEIR JOBS ELSEWHERE GUESS
WHAT IT HAS NOT HAPPENED THERE
ARE LESSONS TO BE LEARNED THE
OPPONENTS WILL ALWAYS TELL YOU
THAT WILL NEVER GET THERE THAT
IT'S IMPOSSIBLE BUT THERE ARE
MORE IMPORTANT LESSONS THAT
CALIFORNIA HAS A PRETTY GOOD
TRACK RECORD OF KNOCKING THE
IMPOSSIBLE ON ITS TOP THIS
CHALLENGES THE MOST IMPORTANT
LAW THAT WE DEAL WITH HERE
IN THIS CHAMBER IS THE LAW OF
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES WILL
THIS MEASURE HURT THE ECONOMY
WILL WE LOSE JOBS WILL WE
EXPECT EXPORT JOBS TO OTHER
STATES LEGITIMATE THE PORTANT
QUESTIONS THAT WE ASK EACH
TIME ACHIEVING SUCH AMBITIOUS
REDUCTIONS WILL REQUIRE AN
ENERGY INDUSTRY TRANSITION OF
UNPRECEDENTED BEATON'S COKE
THESE CHALLENGES ARE NOT TO
BE UNDERESTIMATED BUT I'LL
TELL YOU EVERYBODY LADIES
AND GENTLEMAN IT IS POSSIBLE
REMARKABLE TECHNOLOGIES
INNOVATIONS THAT OPEN NEW
WAYS AND NEW POSSIBILITIES
FOR CLEAN ENERGY I HAVE SEEN
IT PERSONALLY WHEN I LEFT
THE LEGISLATURE LAST TIME I
TRAVEL THE WORLD I SAW A NEW
WAVE TECHNOLOGIES THAT TAKE
POWER FOR THE OCEANS I'VE SEEN
HOW WIND TURBINES AND NOW IN
THE OCEAN EIGHTEEN MEGAWATTS
WE WERE LUCKY TO GET ONE
MEGAWATT BACK IN THOSE DAYS
THAT WAS A BIG DEAL I SEE
SOLAR ENERGY COSTS REDUCED
BY NINETY NINE PERCENT I'VE
SEEN THE EFFICIENCIES GO UP
BY DRAMATIC NUMBERS BUT WE
HAVE TO ENGAGE WE HAVE TO RISK
OUR SUCCESS WILL HINGE ON THE
ENGINE INNOVATIONS HATCHED IN
CALIFORNIA LABS AND FABRICATED
IN CALIFORNIA SHOP FLOORS WITH
HIGH WAGE LABOR THAT'S WHAT
WE NEED TO DO TO CREATE THOSE
JOBS HERE YOU'RE FREE TO CHOOSE
TO ADOPT THIS NEW PERCENTAGE
SENATORS IT WILL SIGNAL A NEW
LEVEL OF COMMITMENT AND SPUR
OTHERS TO STRENGTHEN THEIR
DECARBONISATION PROGRAMMES
WE HAVE SEEN ACROSS THE GLOBE
AND THIS FIFTY FIVE PERCENT
REDUCTION SCENARIO MEMBERS IS
ESTIMATED TO CREATE HUNDREDS
OF THOUSANDS OF JOBS OVERALL
INCLUDING TENS OF THOUSANDS
OF JOBS IN MANUFACTURING
CONSTRUCTION SECTORS BUT
THAT'S WRONG LET'S SAY YOU WERE
WRONG ABOUT THE G.
IMPACTS ON JOBS IT'S POSSIBLE
WHAT WERE THE LEGISLATURE
WE HAVE THE POWER TO COURSE
CORRECT THAT'S WHAT WE DO WE
CAN INTRODUCE LEGISLATION THE
FUTURE TO BE ABLE TO FIX THOSE
THINGS AND WE DID SOME YEARS
AGO WHEN WE ELIMINATED IT MAYBE
I THINK IT'S UNDER PARIAH WE
SAID YOU CAN'T HAVE COAL AS A
SOURCE OF ENERGY AND WE STOP
THOSE JOBS FROM COMING INTO
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WE'RE
CREATED FOR BADGES IF WE CAN
FIGURE IT OUT CALIFORNIA IS NOT
ALONE IN TRYING TO MEET THESE
AGGRESSIVE STANDARDS IN FACT
WE'VE ALREADY FALLEN BEHIND
OF THE STATE'S THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT FIFTY PERCENT MAINE
MASSACHUSETTS RHODE ISLAND
IN WASHINGTON ALL HAVE MORE
AGGRESSIVE GOALS IN REDUCING
GHGS BY TWENTY THIRTY BUT WE
ALSO AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO
NOTE HAVE INFLUENCE GLOBALLY
I HAVE SEEN IT FIRST HAND IN
THE MANY COP CON A CONFERENCES
I'VE ATTENDED WAS SENT TO
ACCOUNTS HE AND OTHERS HERE
ON THIS FLOOR AND AS A PRIVATE
SECTOR WHERE PEOPLE COME WHAT'S
CALIFORNIA DOING WE WANT THE
GUIDANCE WE WANT TO LEARN AND
SO YES IT WAS MENTIONED EARLIER
ON THIS FLOOR THAT WE ONLY
PRODUCE A VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE
OF THE GHGS GLOBALLY BUT WE
HAVE AN OUTSIZED IMPACT ON THE
REST OF THE GLOBE THEY LOOK
TO US HOW MANY TIMES HAVE WE
SEEN DELEGATIONS FROM AROUND
THE WORLD FROM OTHER STATES
COMING HERE TO LEARN TO LISTEN
TO WHAT WE'RE DOING THERE'S A
VALUE IN LEADING IN THIS IS IT
HARD YES IS IT RISKY YES COULD
WE MAKE A MISTAKE YES BUT WE
COURSE CORRECT THAT'S WHAT YOU
DO IN BOLD LEADERSHIP I HAVE
WORKED IN THIS SPACE FOR MANY
YEARS IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR
I HAVE SEEN HOW PRICE SIGNALS
AND GOVERNMENT POLICY IS
DRIVEN IN A WRITTEN A VACATION
AS I SUGGESTED REDUCE COSTS
COLLEAGUES WERE RAISING THE
BAR FOR ONE SIMPLE REASON THE
SCIENCE SAYS SO PERIOD END OF
ISSUE FOR ALL OF OUR WORK THUS
FAR AND FOR ALL CALIFORNIA'S
LEADERSHIP TO DATE THE EXPERTS
TELL US THE ONLY WAY TO AVOID
CATASTROPHE IS TO DO EVEN MORE
AND TO TELL THE MOST IMPORTANT
AND TO ME THE MOST IMPORTANT
QUESTION IS IT AGAIN IT FOR
GETTING IT WRONG THAT WERE NOT
ACTING FAST ENOUGH WE HAVE TO
TRY EVERY OPTION AND AS I SAID
IN MY OPENING OUR ONLY HOME
IS THIS PLANET WE'RE BEGINNING
TO SEE THE CONSEQUENCES OF
CLIMATE CHANGE ALL OF US IN
OUR COMMUNITIES EXTREME HEAT
THE SAN FERNANDO VALLEY IN
IN IN IN THE PAKISTAN IF YOU
LOOK AT THE HEADLINES ON THE
FLOODS JACKSON MISSISSIPPI
WE SEE IT IN THE SANFORD OF
ALEXANDER STERN I REPRESENT
CYNICAL MONICA MOUNTAINS IT'S
IT'S UNBELIEVABLE MY DAUGHTER
WHO'S WE'RE GOING TO IT TO
YOUR BIRTHDAY PARTY FOR HER ON
SATURDAY WE HAD TO CANCEL WE
HAD TO CANCEL THAT OUR VISIT
TO THE GENTLE BARN IN THE SAN
FERNANDO VALLEY SINCE CENTER
STERN'S DISTRICT BECAUSE IT'S
A HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN DEGREES
IT'S A HUNDRED AND FIFTEEN
DEGREES SO I'VE BEEN OLDER
KIDS BUT HAVING SOMEBODY WHO'S
TWO YEARS OLDER DAUGHTER NEVER
HAD A DAUGHTER ONLY BROTHERS
AND SONS CHANGE YOUR LIFE
AS MUCH AS I WAS ENGAGED IN
THIS DISCUSSION BEFORE THE
DISCUSSIONS WE HAVE THE HOME
IS ABOUT THE FUTURE AND WE HAVE
TO TRY I GET IT'S HARD I GET
ALL THE ARGUMENTS I'VE BEEN
LISTENING TO HIM FOR DECADES
AND I'VE BEEN BLOWING THROUGH
ROOM AND WE HAVE BEEN MAKING
CHANGE AND THAT'S WHAT WE NEED
TO DO AND THAT'S WHY WE NEED
THE VISION OF THIS BILL THAT'S
WHY SENATORS COURTS MEASURE
NEEDS TO PASS YOUR TODAY IT
IS SO IMPORTANT THAT WE VOTE
FOR THIS MEMBERS I HUMBLY AND
PASSIONATELY ASK YOUR RIVALS
THANK YOU CENTER HERTZBERG
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE SENATOR DOLLY
BUSH
ALL DUE RESPECT TO MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE -- GOT WHERE DO I
START AGAIN HERE WE ARE HERE
WE ARE NOW WE'RE CHANGING THE
THE BAR FROM TWENTY THIRTY BY
FORTY PERCENT TO TWENTY THIRTY
BY FIFTY PERCENT FIVE PERCENT
THE FLOOR JOCKEY TALKS ABOUT
BEING BOLD THIS IS BOLD WE WE
HEARD LAST WEEK I THINK IT WAS
THAT THE DIG THE CALIFORNIA
AIR RESOURCES BOARD IS GOING
TO BE IMPLEMENTED WE'RE GONNA
HAVE A LUXURY CARS BY TWENTY
NO DID WE CAN WILL BE ABLE
TO BUY A COMBUSTIBLE ENGINE
CAR BY TWENTY THIRTY FIVE IN
CALIFORNIA THERE ARE THIRTY
MILLION CARS IN CALIFORNIA
THEY'RE A LITTLE OVER A MILLION
AND A HALF CARS THAT ARE EV'S
SO WE HAVE AGREED THAT IN
THE NEXT TWO DAYS IS ON THE
VERGE OF MAYBE NOT KEEPING
THE POWER ON A CALIFORNIA JUST
GOT A NOTE FROM THE GOVERNOR'S
OFFICE THAT WE'RE GONNA AND
WE NEED TO CONSERVE POWER
AND TURN YOUR AIR CONDITIONER
DOWN DON'T CHARGER CAR
AND BY TWENTY THIRTY FIVE A
MERE THIRTEEN YEARS FROM NOW
WE ARE GONNA BE ALL ELECTRIC
IN CALIFORNIA AGAIN I SAID
EARLIER WE WE USE A ONE POINT
EIGHT MILLION BARRELS OF OIL
EVERY DAY IN CALIFORNIA THE
FIFTH LARGEST ECONOMY IN THE
WORLD AND WHAT WE GETTING FIVE
DOLLAR GALLON GASOLINE TODAY IT
WENT AS HIGH AS SEVEN DOLLARS
A GALLON COST OF LIVING IS
SKYROCKETING CALIFORNIA IF
YOU'RE ON A FIXED INCOME OR
YOU'RE AN HOURLY WAGE -- YOU
CAN'T EVEN LIVE IN CALIFORNIA
YOU CANNOT FIGHT FOR TO BUY A
HOME WE HAVE LEAVE CERTIFIED
GREEN BUILDING WE HAVE ALL
THE REGULATIONS VEHICLE MILES
TRAVELED ALL THOSE THINGS PUT
INTO WHY WE CAN'T HAVE A HOME
IN CALIFORNIA AND WE TALK ABOUT
OUR CHILDREN IN THE FUTURE
I WAS TRAVELING HOME THE
OTHER DAY TALKING TO MY SON
REAGAN HE DOESN'T BELIEVE
HE'LL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
TO BUY A HOME IN CALIFORNIA
HOW SAD IS THAT A TWENTY
YEAR OLD YOUNG MAN THINKING
AND NONE OF HIS FRIENDS BY
THE WAY EITHER BECAUSE THE
CALIFORNIA WAY AS THE GREAT
GOVERNOR GAVIN NEWSOM WOULD SAY
IS DRIVING PEOPLE OUT OF
CALIFORNIA COST OF LIVING AND
ENERGY GRID THAT IS CATCHING
OUR STATE ON FIRE WHICH IS
NOT ADEQUATE THAT'S WHAT ALL
THESE REGULATIONS HAVE GIVEN
US IS THE HIGHEST COST OF
LIVING IN CALIFORNIA HIGHEST
POVERTY RATE IN THE NATION
EVEN THOUGH THERE IS BEEN
PLENTY MONEY DAUGHTER TALKED
ABOUT YEAH THERE'S TWENTY MANY
GOVERNMENT MONEY WE HAD PROP
THIRTY WHICH TAXED CALIFORNIANS
WERE SUPPOSED TO BE SHORT
TERM AND WE EXTENDED THAT TAX
AND WE PAY THE HIGHEST TAXES
IN THE NATION AND DRIVING
BUSINESSES OUT OF CALIFORNIA
I JUST WANT TO SAY THIS MARK MY
WORDS TEN YEARS FROM NOW WE'LL
LOOK BACK OR THIRTEEN YEARS
NOW WILL LOOK BACK AT THIS
MOMENT WHERE WE SET ANOTHER
TARGET AND WHAT WE GET FOR
WE'LL HAVE PROBABLY POWER ARE
YOU PROBABLY HAVE WHEN BILLS
IN THE OCEAN TWELVE SOLAR
PANELS ALL OVER OUR OUR LANDS
AND WE WON'T HAVE A SOURCE OF
POWER THAT REALLY IS GONNA WORK
FOR CALIFORNIA THEY'LL BE NO
OIL LEFT IN THE B.
NO JOBS IN CALIFORNIA IT'S
JUST CRAZY AGAIN NO DETAIL OF
HOW WE'RE GOING TO GET THERE
WE SET A TARGET IT'S CREATING
CRISIS WE'RE IN A CRISIS MODE
WE ARE TO DROUGHT WE HAVE NO
WATER WHY BECAUSE WE DIDN'T
BUILD THE STORAGE NO PLAN EVEN
THOUGH WE PASSED THE WATER
BOND TO GET GET THOSE RESOURCES
THOSE ARE THE PROBLEMS WITH
THESE BILLS YOU WANT TO BE
BOLD PUT A PLAN TOGETHER THAT
ACTUALLY DRIVES THE COST DOWN
AND KEEPS CALIFORNIANS IN
CALIFORNIA AND ALLOWS US TO
TO LIVE THE CALIFORNIA DREAM
WHICH IF YOU'RE A BUSINESS
OWNER HAS BEEN A NIGHTMARE
RECENTLY SO FOR THAT REASON I
HAVE A AND MANY OTHER REASONS
ASK FOR NO VOTE AGAIN ON A
BILL THAT JUST SIMPLY SETS A
TARGET YOU TAKE A BRICK VICTORY
LAP WAVE YOUR MAGIC WAND
SPRINKLE A LITTLE PIXIE DUST
ON IT AND NOTHING'S GONNA
HAPPEN OTHER THAN THE COST
OF EVERYTHING IS GOING TO
GO UP IN CALIFORNIA AND THE
CALIFORNIA'S I REPRESENT ARE
ARE VERY MUCH FRUSTRATED AND
CAN'T AFFORD TO LIVE HERE I'M
HEARING FROM THEM EVERY DAY
ASK FOR NO VOTE ON AB TWO ONE
THREE THREE THANK YOU SENATOR
HOLLINGS SENATOR MELINDA'S
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT --
I'M JUST WONDERING HOW MANY
LOST JOBS IS ENOUGH HOW MANY
WILL IT TAKE FOR YOU TO FEEL
LIKE YOU'VE REACHED YOUR GOAL
HOW MANY JOBS HAVE TO LEAD THE
STATE HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE TO
LOSE THEIR FORM OF EMPLOYMENT
FOR US TO SAY OKAY WE'VE DONE
ENOUGH BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT
THIS BILL IS GOING TO DO WE
KEEP SINCE I'VE BEEN IN THIS
LEGISLATURE TEN YEARS THE GOAL
POSTS KEEP MOVING EVERYBODY
HAS TO OUTDO THE LAST PERSON
WHO INTRODUCED A BILL LIKE THIS
AND IT JUST KEEPS CHANGING AND
CHANGING AND CHANGING MAKING
IT HARDER AND HARDER AND PEOPLE
MAKING IT MORE EXPENSIVE THE
LOSS OF JOBS THE INCREASE IN
THE COST OF SO MANY THINGS
IN CALIFORNIA AND IT'S NEVER
ENOUGH NEVER SO I JUST WANT
TO KNOW HOW MANY LOST JOBS
IS ENOUGH I REGION ABOUT
PICKCENTER MELINDA'S CENTER
GROVE MADAM PRESIDENT I TO
RISE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL
YOU HAVE COLLEAGUES IF YOU'RE
DONE AND FINISHED WITH CARBON
FUELS IN THIS STATE THEN JUST
GO COLD TURKEY JUST DO IT I
MEAN STOP USING THE RESOURCE
PUT DOWN YOUR IPHONES OR
IPADS STOP USING PLASTICS TAKE
THE FOOTBALL AWAY FROM YOUR
CHILDREN STOP USING THOUSANDS
OF EVERYDAY PRODUCT THAT MAKE
OUR LIVES CONVENIENT STOP USING
INVISALIGN YEAH FOR THOSE OF
YOU THAT STRAIGHTEN YOUR TEETH
WITH INVISALIGN DON'T GAG YOU
HAVE A PETROLEUM BY PRODUCTS
IN YOUR MOUTH STOP USING
PLANES TO FLY BACK AND FORTH TO
SACRAMENTO ALMOST ALL OF YOU ON
THIS FLOOR USE PETROCHEMICALS
-- PATRICK PETROLEUM AND JET
FUEL WHEN YOU GET ON THAT PLANE
STOP USING GAS POWERED VEHICLES
I PARK IN THE SAME GARAGE YOU
DO ON THE TENTH STREET AND
YOU GUYS ALL DRIVE GAS PARA
VEHICLES EXCEPT FOR MAYBE JUST
MAYBE TEN PERCENT OF YOU SO I
JUST ASK YOU COLLEAGUES THAT IF
YOU ARE SO DONE WITH THE FOSSIL
FUEL INDUSTRY AND YOU ARE SO
DONE WITH CARBON THEN PUT YOUR
MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS AND
STOP IMPOSING ON POLICIES THAT
HURT OUR COMMUNITIES CREATE
MORE POVERTY IN THE STATE AND
STOP USING THE FOSSIL FUELS
THAT YOU USE EVERY SINGLE DAY
TO MAKE YOUR LIFE BETTER I
LOOK AROUND THIS ROOM AND I
SEE GLASSES GLASSES GLASSES
GLASSES GLASSES ALL OF THAT IS
A PETROCHEMICAL AND YOU CAN'T
HAVE IT WITHOUT IT SO WHEN YOU
THINK ABOUT IT JUST STOP STOP
USING THE CONVENIENCE THESE
CONVENIENCES THAT THE ENERGY
INDUSTRY FOR FOSSIL FUELS GIVES
YOU ON A DAILY BASIS AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE
THANK YOU CENTER GROVE MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SENATOR STERN I THANK YOU
MADAM PRESIDENT JUST THOUGHT
WORTH NOTING FOR THE FOR THE
RECORD HERE -- THERE'S BEEN
SOME CONCERNS ABOUT WHAT THE
FUTURE WILL LOOK LIKE IN TEN
YEARS A RECENT ECONOMIC MODELS
RELEASED ON HOW THIS BILL WOULD
OPERATE IN CALIFORNIA BY THE
SAME FIRM THAT DID ALL THE WORK
FOR THE INFLATION REDUCTION
ACT -- ANALYZING THE MANSION
AMENDMENTS -- AND ALL THE OTHER
-- YOU KNOW I WON'T HELP MY
COLLEAGUES ON THE OTHER SIDE OF
THE AISLE CERTAINLY BUT IF IT'S
GOOD ENOUGH FOR THE U.
S.
CONGRESS I WOULD HOPE TO BE
GOOD ENOUGH FOR US -- TWO
HUNDRED THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND
JOBS PREDICTED TO BE CREATED
ACROSS MULTIPLE SECTORS WITH
THIS TARGET TWO HUNDRED THIRTY
FIVE THOUSAND NEW JOBS FIFTY
NINE THOUSAND THOSE WILL BE
IN MANUFACTURING CONSTRUCTION
AND THE PREDICTION IS THAT
AROUND FIFTY FIVE POINT FOUR
BILLION DOLLARS WILL BE ADDED
TO CALIFORNIA'S GROSS DOMESTIC
PRODUCT SO IF WE WANT TO MAKE
A A BET ON WHAT THE FUTURE
WILL LOOK LIKE IN TEN YEARS --
MY BET IS THAT IT LOOKS A LOT
BRIGHTER TODAY THERE ARE SEVEN
FIREFIGHTERS IN A HOSPITAL
RIGHT NOW DOWN IN SANTA CLARITA
BECAUSE THERE'S A WILDFIRE
TEARING ACROSS THE I.
FIVE FREEWAY THE POWER GRIDS
VULNERABLE RIGHT NOW ON TALK
ABOUT THE FUTURE WE NEED TO
BE INVESTING IN THE GRADE
NOW IT'S OFF AS WE SPEAK IN
BAKERSFIELD THE LIGHTS ARE
OUT RIGHT THEIR BACKYARD WHY
DON'T WHY ARE THESE PROJECTIONS
IN THERE WHY WHY DO WE THINK
THIS BILL ACTUALLY GREAT JOBS
HYDROGEN CARBON CAPTURE I
KNEW INVESTED THOSE ARE THE
PIECES THAT THE AIRPORT IS
CURRENTLY NOT CONTEMPLATING
IN THEIR PLANS SO THEIR PLANS
TO HIT FORTY PERCENT DON'T
INCLUDE A MASSIVE INCREASE IN
HYDROGEN PRODUCTION THEY DON'T
INCLUDE NEAR TERM SCALING OF
CARBON CAPTURE AND STORAGE
AND THEY DON'T CONTEMPLATE
THE INVESTMENTS COMING FROM
WASHINGTON OR IN OUR BUDGET
THIS YEAR THAT'S WHY WE'RE
UNDER SHOOTING OUR TARGET
RIGHT NOW SO UNLESS WE WANT
TO DEFERRED THOSE REDUCTIONS
AND SAY LET'S KICK ALL THIS
DOWN THE ROAD LET'S GO LOOK
AT TWENTY FORTY AND STARTED
JUST SIT TIGHT FOR THE NEXT
DECADE THAT'LL MEAN NONE OF
THAT INNOVATION TAKES PLACE
NONE OF THOSE HYDROGEN JOBS
ARE HAPPENING THE REFINING
SECTOR THE CEMENT SECTOR THE
GLASS SECTOR ALL ALL INDUSTRIAL
SECTORS THAT ACTUALLY WANT TO
REVITALIZED THAT WE WANT TO
MAKE THINGS IN CALIFORNIA NOT
JUST GLASSES BUT TO REFINED
FUELS BUT NOT FROM ECUADOR OR
ALL THESE OTHER PLACES THAT
THEY'RE ALL THESE CONCERNS
ABOUT HOW WAS INDUSTRY GOING
TO HAVE THOSE TOOLS UNLESS
WE DOUBLE DOWN THIS DECADE SO
COLLEAGUES I KNOW THERE'S A LOT
OF THIS INFORMATION OUT THERE
BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE FACTS
THIS BILL IS A JOB CREATORS
THIS JOB THIS BILL WILL BE GOOD
FOR CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY AND
WE CAN WAIT I LET OTHERS RACE
AHEAD IN THE INNOVATION GAME
CHINA CAN BEAT US TO THE PUNCH
IN ELECTRIFY INPUTS HYDROGEN
WE CAN WAIT ON THE REST OF
THIS COUNTRY ACT OR WE CAN BE
CALIFORNIANS AND WE CAN LEAD
I THINK IS THAT MOMENT I THINK
WE TAKE THAT LEADERSHIP MANTLE
AND THAT'S WHAT I RESPECTFULLY
ASKING DRIVER THANK YOU
CENTER STERN MEMBERS FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING NINE CENTER HERTZBERG
YOU MAY CLOSE I WANT TO STRESS
WHAT THE SENATOR FROM SAN
FERNANDO VALLEY SAID AND THAT
IS WHICH UNDERLIE UNDERLINES
THE ENTIRE POINT OF WHAT I WAS
TRYING TO MAKE IN MY OPENING
THAT WE STILL HAVE THE CARBON
VANCE CLEAN CARS TO RULING WE
STILL HAVE THE THE INVESTMENT
FROM THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
WHICH TWO OF THE MONEY THAT ARE
WE'VE INVESTED OUR STATE BUDGET
I'M JUST TELLING YOU I'VE SEEN
OVER THE LAST NUMBER OF DECADES
AS WE'VE MOVED AWAY WHEN HE AB
THIRTY TWO WAS PASSED IN TWO
THOUSAND AND SIXTEEN IT'S WHAT
WE CALLED AND I IN THE BEHOLDER
BUILT BECAUSE PEOPLE DIDN'T
KNOW ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE
PEOPLE DIDN'T UNDERSTAND IT
WHO SAID LET'S JUST GIVE THE
RESPONSIBILITY TO THIS AGENCY
AND WE'LL TRY TO FIGURE IT
OUT AND IT WAS PASSED BUT NOW
THE WORLD'S CHANGED I THINK
THAT THE DYNAMIC ABOUT CLIMATE
CHANGE EXTREME HEAT ALL OF THE
CHALLENGES THAT WE'RE FACING
A REAL AND WE SEE IT EVERY DAY
IN OUR LIVES AND OUR FAMILIES
AND WE HAVE TO THINK BIGGER
I'M NOT SAYING THIS IS EASY
I'M NOT SAYING IT'S NOT PERFECT
BUT WHAT I'M SAYING IS THAT
WE'RE LEGISLATURE WE WRITE THE
LAW WE HAVE A RESPONSIBILITY
TO MONITOR THE JOBS I WANT TO
MAKE SURE I THOUGHT SOMEBODY'S
EARLIER BILLS BECAUSE I DON'T
BELIEVE WE SHOULD THROW PEOPLE
OUT OF WORK BECAUSE OF CLIMATE
CHANGE IT BECAUSE OF SOME OF
THESE POLICIES I FIGHT FOR
THE WORKING FOLKS AND I WANT
TO KEEP THEM IN JOBS AND TAKE
CARE OF THEM AND I THINK WE
CAN DO IT I'M NOT IT BECAUSE
I'VE SEEN IT I'VE WITNESSED IT
AND WE'VE EXPERIENCED HERE IN
CALIFORNIA I ASK THE ARRIVAL
THANK YOU SENATOR HERTZBERG
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN HI ARCHULETA
ATKINS AYE BATES NO PACKER I
PORCHES NO BRADFORD CABALLERO
CORTESE DALY NO DOT THERE ARE
SO EGGMAN AYE GLAZER GONZALEZ
I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG HI WESA
HURTADO JONES NO KAMLAGER I
FIRED FIVE LEYVA I FOR THE MOST
MCGUIRE
LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
NO MAN NEWMAN NIELSEN A TRUCK
NIELSEN NO -- CHAU BOTH NO PAN
I PORTANTINO FIVE ROTH RUBIO
AYE SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AYE
AMBERG WHITE HOUSE SPEED AYE
WIENER I WILK NO PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CABALLERO CORTEZ'S I
DOT THE RUSSELL GLAZER WESSEL
HER TADO MANY NEWMAN ROTH
NUMBER SENATOR MOVES THE CALL
MEMBERS WE HAVE ABOUT SIX BILLS
THAT WE PUT ON CALL EARLIER
TODAY SO WE ARE GETTING OUR
LIST READY AND WE'RE GOING
TO LIVE CALLS AND -- SHUT
THOSE VOTES DOWN SO PLEASE
MAKE SURE YOU ARE READY TO
VOTE ON ANYTHING YOU MISSED
OUR MEMBERS WE ARE LIFTING
THE CALL ON FILE ITEM ONE
TWENTY FIVE MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
CABALLERO OKAY DODD HI
DERISIVE
TORONTO I HERTZBERG HI
SENATE CABALLERO HI CABALLERO
AYE AYES FORTY NEW ZERO THE
ASSEMBLY MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED
IN MOVING TO FILE ITEM
ONE TWENTY SIX S.
B.
ONE ZERO ZERO ONE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
DODD I TORONTO AYE AYES FORTY
NO ZERO THE ASSEMBLY MEMINTA
CONCURRED IN MOVING THE
FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY SEVEN
ONE ZERO ZERO TWO PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
DODD HI THERE AWESOME HI
HERTZBERG HI HIGHS FORTY
NEWS ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
FILE ITEM ONE TWENTY EIGHT
SB ONE TWO TWO THREE PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS DODD
THERE ARE SO I HER TADO NIELSEN
NO A TROUBLED PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS DODD HI
HURTADO A TROUBLED HIGHS THIRTY
KNOWS EIGHTY ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
ONE TWENTY NINE S.
B.
FIFTEEN HUNDRED PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS DODD
HI THERE ARE SO HI GUYS
FORTINOS ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
MOVING TO FILE ITEM FIFTY
SIX -- NO -- YEP THOSE ARE
THE ONLY ONES THANK YOU
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING BACK
TO MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
SENATOR COM LONGER FOR WHAT
PURPOSE YOU RISE HIGH RISE TO
REQUEST UNANIMOUS CONSENT TO
SUBMIT A LETTER TO THE JOURNAL
EXPLAINING THE INTENT ON SB
SIX SEVEN NINE THIS LETTER HAS
BEEN REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY
BOTH SIDES IN THE SECRETARY OF
THE SENATE WITHOUT OBJECTION
PLEASE BRING IT FORWARD SENATOR
LIMÓN THANK YOU I'D LIKE TO PUT
AB THIRTEEN NINETY FIVE ON THE
NECK TO FILE PLEASE THE DESK
WILL NOTE SENATOR DODD YES MAN
A PRESIDENT I REQUEST UNANIMOUS
CONSENT TO SUBMIT A LETTER
TO THE JOURNAL ON BEHALF OF
PRESIDENT PRO TEM ATKINS OF ME
REGARDING ALLOWING EARLY OFTEN
FOR NEWLY ADDED CONTAINERS
UNDER SENATE BILL TEN THIRTEEN
THE DESK WILL NOTE -- ACTUALLY
WITH THAT WITHOUT OBJECTION
PLEASE BRING THE LETTER
FORWARD MEMBERS ANYTHING ELSE
UNDER MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
SENATE HEARING THEN THANK YOU
I CAN'T HEAR YOU SIT DOWN
ACTUALLY THE MOTION IS OUT
OF ORDER BECAUSE WE HAVE
BILLS ON CALL NICE TRY
MEMBERS I'D MORE GREAT NEWS
YOU GET A TEN MINUTE RECESS
DO NOT LEAVE THE CAPITAL DO
NOT LEAVE BUT YOU CAN LEAVE
THIS AREA GO TO THE BATHROOM
BUT BE BACK IN TEN MINUTES
AT TEN AT NINE THIRTY PLEASE
COME ONE COME ALL
OUR MEMBERS WE ARE LIFTING
CALLS PLEASE RETURN TO THE
CHAMBERS IF YOUR SEAT MATE
IS NOT THERE FIND THEM IF
THE PERSON IN FRONT OF YOU
IS OUT THERE FIND THEM THE
PERSON BEHIND YOU IS NOT THERE
FIND THEM NICE WORK NEWMAN
EXCELLENT EXAMPLE TO ALL OF US
MEMBERS WE ARE LIFTING THE
CALL ON FILE ITEM FIFTY SIX
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ON FILE
ITEM FIFTY SIX ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CUPBEARER DODD AYE
THE RUSSELL GLAZER WESTERN
HURTADO NO MANY NEWMAN ROF HI
I'M BURKE IS TWENTY ONE KNOWS
TEN THE MEASURE PASSES YEAH
STAY TUNED MEMBERS WE'RE
WORKING ON A SUPPLEMENTAL
FILE DON'T GO FAR
RIGHT MEMBERS WE ARE PASSING
OUT THE SUPPLEMENTAL FILE
THANK YOU YEAH I GOT MINE
AGAIN FIND YOUR SEAT
MATE HELP THEM OUT
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO MOTIONS
AND RESOLUTIONS THE FOLLOWING
WILL BILLS WILL BE MOVED
ORDERED TO THE INACTIVE FILE
FILE ITEM THIRTY AB SIXTEEN
FIFTY SIX FILE ITEM THIRTY
ONE ACA THREE FILE ITEM THIRTY
THREE AB THIRTEEN TWENTY
EIGHT FILE ITEM THIRTY SIX
AB SIXTEEN NINETY ONE FILE
ITEM NINETY EIGHT SB ONE
SEVENTY NINE WITHOUT OBJECTION
I HAD SOMETHING ON THE MOTIONS
ORIGINAL -- SENATOR ARMS CENTER
BEDROOM SORRY DID NOT SEE HER
MY DAUGHTER OFF PLEASE PROCEED
BETTER PRESIDENT I WOULD ASK
THAT YOU REMOVED FILE ITEM Q.
SB THREE NINETY SORRY
SIX AND MOVED TO THE
INACTIVE FONG THANK YOU
SIR THE DESK WILL NOTE
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO START
WITH FILE ITEM ONE THIRTY
FOUR IN YOUR SUPPLEMENTAL
FILE THE ONE THIRTY FOUR IS
SENATOR ALAN MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL FOR
FIFTY NINE BY SENATOR ALAN
AND ACT REALLY RELATING TO
THE POLITICAL REFORM ACT OF
NINETEEN SEVENTY FOUR -- ALLEN
MEMBERS THIS BILL IS BACK ON
CONCURRENCY GIVES THE PUBLIC
PRESS AND LAWMAKERS MORE
TIMELY AND USEFUL INFORMATION
ABOUT THE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
SPENT INFLUENCING THE FATE
OF LEGISLATION IN CALIFORNIA
AMENDMENTS IN THE ASSEMBLY
HAVE HELPED TO REDUCE BURDENS
FOR FILERS AND GOT US A LOT OF
THE OPPOSITION NEARLY ALL OF
IT DROPPED WITHOUT EVER SINCE
YESTERDAY BUT THANK YOU SENATOR
ALLEN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN HI ARCHULETA
ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER HI
FOR JUST BRADFORD CABALLERO
I PROTECTING I DALY DODD AYE
TORONTO AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
I GONZALEZ I GROWTH HERTZBERG
I REQUEST SO I HER TADO I JONES
NO KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
LEYVA HI THE MOST I MCGUIRE I
MELENDEZ MANY AYE NEWMAN AYE
NIELSEN A TRUCK BOTH I PAN I
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
AYE BY CASKEY I WIENER WELL
FIVE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ARCHULETA HI BATES
FORTUS BRADFORD HI DALY GROWTH
NO MELENDEZ NIELSEN WIENER
HIGHS THIRTY TWO TO CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
EIGHT FORTUS DALLY MELENDEZ NO
NIELSEN NO WIENER I I THIRTY
THREE NEWS FOR THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN FILE
ITEM ONE THIRTY FIVE SENATOR
PORTANTINO MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL
FIVE SIXTY TWO BY SENATOR
PORTANTINO AN ACT RELATING TO
HEALTH CARE COVERAGE CENTER
PORTANTINO THANK YOU I RISE
TO PRESENT FIVE SIXTY TWO
ON CONCURRENCE THE ASSEMBLY
AMENDMENTS DESCRIBE EVIDENCE
BASED BEHAVIOR INTERVENTIONS
PROGRAM AND REVISE OTHER
DEFINITIONS ON PROFESSIONALS
AND PARA PROFESSIONALS AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
PORTANTINO MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE MEMBERS THIS
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION
TO UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL SEEING
AND HEARING NONE IS FORTY NO
ZERO THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
ONE THIRTY SIX SENATOR PAN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TWELVE THIRTY
FOUR BY SENATOR PAN AN ACT
RELATING TO HEALTH CARE CENTER
PAN THANK YOU MATT PRESENT
CENTERS -- PLEASE VISIT MY
LAST BILL -- BEFORE I LEAVE
THE LIGHTS THE SENATE AND
-- THIS IS A APPROPRIATELY A
BILL ABOUT PUBLIC HEALTH AND
HEALTH CARE COVERAGE SENATE
BILL TWELVE THIRTY FOUR -- IS
ABOUT FAMILY PACK TO COVER STI
SCREENINGS ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
TO LEAD COST CAP PROVISIONS
IN REQUIREMENT THE DETAILS
PUBLISHED INFORMATION THAT'S
WEBSITE THE FUNDING FOR THE
POPULATION SERVE THIS BILL AND
HAS CHAPARRAL LANGUAGE AS WELL
-- THIS BILL SAID BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE IN CONCURRENCE
WITH ASSEMBLY MINUTES THANK
YOU CENTER PAN MEMBERS
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
HEARING THEN MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
HI ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
BATES NOPE BECKER I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD I HAVE I EVER AYE
PROTESTING AYE TALLY NO DODD
AYE DERISIVE AYE EGGMAN AYE
PLACER AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG AYE WESSEL AYE
FURTADO AYE JONES NO KAMLAGER
AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE THE
MON I PROVIDER HI MELENDEZ
NO MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
NO -- CHOI BOGUE PAN AYE
PORTANTINO I ROTH I RUBIO I
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE NUMBER
I'VE BY CASKEY I PUT WIENER
AYE WILK NOW HIGHS THIRTY ONE
KNOWS EIGHTY ASSEMBLY MEMBERS
ARE CONCURRED IN FILE ITEM
ONE THIRTY SEVEN SENATOR LIMÓN
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL TWELVE NINETY FIVE
BY CENTER LIMÓN AN ACT RELATING
TO OIL AND GAS SIMILARLY MON
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SB TWELVE
NINETY BACK TWELVE NINETY
FIVE IS BACK ON CONCURRENCE
ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS CLARIFY
LABOR PORTIONS OF THE BILL
RETAIN THE REQUIREMENTS FOR
SKILLED AND TRAINED LABOR
AMENDMENTS ALSO SPECIFIED
THE CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THIS
INDUSTRY I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN AYE VOTE THE USER EARLY
MON DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
CENTER LAYERED THANK YOU VERY
MUCH -- MADAM PRESIDENT I JUST
WANT TO SAY THAT THIS BILL
HAPPENS TO BE A GREAT BILL A
DEAL WAS MADE IN THE ASSEMBLY
THAT REMOVE SUBSTANTIAL
AMOUNT OF THE OPPOSITION BUT
AS I SAID IN A FLOOR SPEECH
YESTERDAY ON THE CLIMATE BILL
WE HAD ELEVEN BILLS MOVING
IN THE SENATE PACKAGE AND
THIS IS THE ELEVENTH BILL WE
PASS THIS WE SEND THE ENTIRE
SENATE PASSAGE PACKAGE TO
THE GOVERNOR I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN IPHONE THANK
YOU CENTER LAYERED MEMBERS
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES NO PACKER I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD AYE CUP AYE ADAM
HIGH COURT HAS THE I TALLY NO
DODD AYE DURACELL AYE EGGMAN
AYE GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG AYE WESSEL AYE
FURTADO JONES NO KAMLAGER
KAMLAGER WHERE I'D LEYVA
KAMLAGER I LEYVA I FOR THE
MONTH LIMON I REQUIRE I
MELENDEZ NO MAN HI NEWMAN
NIELSEN NO -- TROUBLED NO PAN
PORTANTINO I BROUGHT I RUBIO
SKINNER I STERN HI I'M BURKE
I FOR CASCADE AYE WIENER AYE
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS HER TADO NEWMAN I PAM
YES
PAN RUBIO AYE AYES TWENTY
NINE KNOWS NINE THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
MEMBERS WE WILL BE DOING
MORE BILLS WE ARE WAITING
FOR A FEW MORE TO COME FROM
THE ASSEMBLY SO STAY TUNED
MEMBERS MOST OF YOU ARE IN
YOUR SEATS BUT IF YOUR SEAT
MATE IS NOT WITH YOU FIND
YOUR SEATMATE IN ABOUT FIVE
MINUTES MATT APPROACH HIM HAS
SOMETHING SHE WANTS TO SHARE
WITH THAT SO SENIOR SEAT IF
YOU'RE THERE FOR SEATMATE
ISN'T THERE FIND YOU SEE ME
I MEMBERS I'M STILL HOPING THAT
PEOPLE CAN GET TO THEIR SEATS
FIND YOUR SEATMATE WE'RE READY
TO HEAR FROM MATT I'M PRO TEM
ALRIGHT PRAYER FROM HERE
FROM THE PRO TEM WE DO HAVE
ANOTHER BILL TO TAKE UP
A FAIR ONE CAN TAKE THEIR
SEATS CENTERS FOR WHERE ARE
YOU WE'RE DOING ALL CALL ON
SENATOR HERTZBERG IF HE'S YOUR
SEATMATE CALL AND TEXT HIM
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS WE'RE GOING
TO WAR SB SEVEN SEVEN FOUR
WITHOUT OBJECTION SEEING NONE
SENATOR ALAN YOU MAY PRESENT
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL SEVEN SEVENTY
FOUR BY SENATOR HERTZBERG AN
ACT RELATING TO VULNERABLE
POPULATIONS THANK YOU CENTER
ALLEN PLEASE PROCEED MEMBERS
IS A BEAUTIFUL BILL THAT SPEECH
TO CENTER HERTZBERG A CONCERN
OVER AT SOME OF THE CHALLENGES
OF HOMELESSNESS ESPECIALLY
WHEN IT COMES TO FOLKS --
THEIR ANIMALS RIGHT PEOPLE WHO
NEED EMOTIONAL SUPPORT DOGS
THAT EXEMPTS INDIVIDUALS ARE
VERIFIED TO BE HOMELESS FROM
A REQUIREMENT UNDER EXISTING
LAW THAT INDIVIDUALS HAVE TO
HAVE THIS THIRTY DAY EXISTING
RELATIONSHIP WITH A HEALTHCARE
PRACTITIONER BEFORE BEING
ABLE TO OBTAIN A CERTIFICATION
FOR AN EMOTIONAL SUPPORT DOG
SO AS FROM ABOUT THANK YOU
SENATOR ALAN MEMBERS ANY
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE BEN SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN AYE
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
AYE FACTOR I PORCHES I BRADFORD
AYE CUPBEARER AYE CORTESE
AYE TALLY DOT I TO RUSSELL I
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ
I WROTE HERTZBERG WHEN I HER
DAUGHTER I JONES KAMLAGER AYE
FARED AYE FLAVOR AYE FOR THE
MONTH I REQUIRE I'VE MELENDEZ
AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
I -- CHAU BOTH AYE PAN I
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
AYE SKINNER HI STERN AYE NUMBER
HI MY COUNTY I WIENER I WILK
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
DALLY I GROVE HI HERTZBERG
JONES HI WELL I PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL MORE TIME HERTZBERG
FIVE THIRTY NINE
THE MOVE A CALL
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS TWENTY TWENTY
TWO IT HAS BEEN AN AMAZING
YEAR WE'VE HEARD ABOUT A
LOT OF AMAZING BILLS THAT WE
HAVE PASSED OFF OF OUR FLOOR
THAT WE HAVE HEARD FROM THE
ASSEMBLY SIDE AND IT'S BEEN
NICE THE END OF SESSION MOST
OF US ARE WITHOUT MASK WE
KNOW WHAT IT WAS LIKE AT THE
END OF SESSION TWO YEARS AGO
IN TWENTY TWENTY SO LET'S ALL
GIVE OURSELVES A LITTLE ROUND
OF APPLAUSE FOR A GREAT YEAR
WE HAVE SURVIVED A MOVIE INTO
THE SWING SPACE IT IS DIFFERENT
BUT IT IS WORKING -- AND I
WILL COME BACK AND VISIT ALL
OF YOU AND SEE HOW IT'S WORKING
IN THREE OR FOUR FIVE OR SIX
YEARS IF YOU WERE STILL THERE
-- BUT WE'D LIKE TO TAKE A FEW
MOMENTS TO HAVE A FEW OF THE
FOLKS WHO HAVE BEEN WITH US
-- THE LONGEST AND SERVE THE
LONGEST IF YOU DEPARTING WORDS
WE'RE GONNA START WITH YOU
MISTER NIELSEN R.
DEAN OF THE SENATE -- WE
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SERVICE AND
EVERYTHING YOU'VE DONE AND I
PERSONALLY JUST THANK YOU FOR
ALWAYS BEING SUCH A GENTLEMAN
BUT IF YOU'D LIKE TO SAY A
FEW WORDS PLEASE PROCEED THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THANK YOU
PHOTO NAPKINS FOR ALLOW ME A
FEW MOMENTS AND A FEW MOMENTS
ONLY TO REFLECT WHEN I CAME
HERE FORTY FOUR YEARS AGO AND
WHAT REALLY IMPRESSED ONE OF
MY DAUGHTERS AFTER THE SWEARING
IN I CAME BACK DOWN THAT MIDDLE
AISLE AND SHE GAVE ME A BIG
HUG AND SHE SAID DAD YOU ARE IN
GEORGE WASHINGTON'S HOUSE THAT
PORTRAIT THAT THE WHOLE WORLD
TO HER THAT THERE WAS SOMETHING
SPECIAL ABOUT BEING HERE LADIES
AND GENTLEMEN THE SENATE THERE
IS SOMETHING SPECIAL ABOUT
BEING HERE NOT MANY HAVE EVER
HAD THE OPPORTUNITY THAT YOU
ARE HAVING THE SERVE THE PEOPLE
BUT KEEP THAT IN MIND IT'S
KIND OF A PARTING OBSERVATION
FOR ALL OTHER REASONS PUBLIC
INPUT HAS DIMINISHED SOMEONE
EVEN BEEN DISSED BOB SECURED
AND SUCH THINGS AS EMERGENCY
POWERS EMERGENCY DECLARATIONS
HAVE CONTRIBUTED THAT NOT
ON OUR PART THAT WOULD BE
GOVERNORS AND PRESIDENTS BUT
EVEN HERE OUR PROCEDURES HAVE
DIMINISHED PUBLIC INPUT I'M
NOT GOING TO GET INTO A WHOLE
LOT OF A SPELL IT AGAIN I
AM NOT GOING TO GET INTO A
WHOLE LOT OF IT BUT I WILL
GIVE THE OF JOB OBSERVATION
THE PUBLIC COMMENT I DO NOT
CONSIDER THE WAY WE DO IT NOW
THIS PUBLIC COMMENT WHEN ALL
ANYONE IS ALLOWED TO DO IS
SAY I'M JIM I LIKE ADAM JOAN
I DON'T LIKE IT THAT'S NOT
PUBLIC INPUT WE SHOULD CHANGE
THE RULES AND SIMPLY HAVE THE
MODERATORS TAKE A TALLY TEN
FOR TEN AGAINST LET IT GO AT
THAT DON'T WASTE EVERYBODY'S
TIME KEEP IN MIND YOU'RE NOT
SIMPLY THE REPRESENTATIVES OF
ONE MILLION PEOPLE THAT IS THE
MOST IMPORTANT OF YOUR TASKS
TOO MANY FORGET THAT TOO MANY
COMMAND THANK THE SUN RISES
AND SETS ON THIS INSTITUTION
THAT DOESN'T THE SON OF ONE
MILLION PEOPLE THAT WE ARE
VERY PRIVILEGED TO REPRESENT
AND KEEP THEM ON YOUR MINDS
ALL OF THE TIME IT'S ABOUT
THEM IT'S NOT ABOUT US IT IS
ABOUT RESPECT FOR EACH OTHER
END FOR THE INSTITUTION AND
THE RULES OF THE INSTITUTION
THEN I WOULD ENCOURAGE ALL OF
THE TO PAY AS MUCH RESPECT AS
YOU CAN TO INSTITUTIONAL RULES
THIS IS KIND OF A TIME TO TALK
ABOUT THAT END OF SESSION ARE
ALWAYS INTERESTING I'LL BE
NO MORE CRITICAL THAN THAT
BUT STEP TO SAY THIS YEAR I
HAD HIGH HOPES WE WOULD NOT
DESCENDED THE LAST MOMENTS
IN THE CHAOS THAT WE ARE FOR
SEEMING TO FALL INTO IT AGAIN
LET THE GAMES BEGIN IT DOES NOT
HAVE TO BE THAT WAY LASTLY I'D
LIKE TO USE ONE OF MY FAVORITE
QUOTATIONS I USE IT OFTEN
PARTICULARLY WITH YOUTH ABOUT
AN INSTRUCTIVE ENCOURAGEMENT
DO IS SHAKESPEARE
AND THAT BOOK BRUTUS AND
CASSIUS OR TALKING ABOUT HOW
THEY'RE GOING TO DEAL WITH
THE INVADING ARMY COMING AT
THEM AND HOW WILL THEY RESPOND
WELL BRITISH THANKS
THAT THEY SHOULD ATTACK
THE QUOTE THOUGH IS A BEAUTIFUL
ONE AND A GREAT MESSAGE THERE
IS A TIDE IN THE AFFAIRS OF MEN
WE WILL NOT A WOMAN NET WOMEN
NOW TIDE IN THE AFFAIRS OF MEN
AND WOMEN WHICH IF TAKEN AT THE
FLOOD LEADS TO FORTUNE OMITTED
ALL THE VOYAGE OF YOUR LIVES
SHALL BE BOUND IN THE SHALLOWS
AND IN MISERIES NO I OFFERED
THAT THAT MEANS IN CONTEMPORARY
LANGUAGE GO FOR IT THE ALL THAT
YOU CAN DO AND BE TAKE LIFE AT
THE FLOOD THE NOT BOUND IN THE
SHALLOWS IN THE MYSTERIES AND
DO NOT LET THE INSTITUTION SO
DESCENDERS WELL THE SENATE IS
A SPECIAL PLACE I'M SURE SOME
THE DIAPERS SENATORIAL COURTESY
IT'S A DIFFERENT HOUSE THERE
ARE SOME GOOD REASONS WHY IT
IS DIFFERENT I'M NOT DEMEANING
THE OTHER HOUSE BUT I WAS NEVER
COMFORTABLE THE SHORT TIME I
SERVED THERE I NEVER FELT AT
HOME BUT I DO FEEL AT HOME HERE
AND YOU SHOULD FEEL AT HOME AND
YOU SHOULD FEEL SPECIAL WITH
SPECIALIST KNOWLEDGE MINT THE
CITIZENS THAT YOUR PRIVILEGE
TO REPRESENT EVEN WHEN THEY
CALL IN AND ARE RUDE TO YOU THE
MOST SIGNIFICANT THING THAT YOU
WILL TAKE FROM HERE THERE'S NOT
SOME WONDERFUL BILLS THAT YOU
CARRY EVEN LANDMARK LEGISLATION
BUT THE THOUSANDS OF CONTACTS
YOU AND YOUR WONDERFUL STAFF
HAVE HAD WITH THE PEOPLE YOU
REPRESENT ASSISTING THEM THOSE
CITIZENS WITH THE AGENCIES
OF GOVERNMENT WHO ARE LARGELY
NOT FRIENDLY SOMETIMES EVEN
ANTAGONISTIC AND IN FACT THE
ENEMY I ALWAYS LOOKED AT THAT
AS OUR MOST IMPORTANT TASK IS
TO ADVOCATE AND SOLVE PROBLEMS
ON BEHALF OF THE PEOPLE THAT
WE REPRESENT NOW I'VE OFFERED
THAT I'M NOT GONNA RIDE OFF
INTO THE SUNSET I'M GONNA RIDE
OFF INTO THE SUNRISE SO I WILL
BE A PRESENCE IN AROUND AS
LONG AS THE LORD ALLOWS YOU TO
LEVIN SERVED AND I WOULD LIKE
YOU TO CONSIDER ME A PERSONAL
FRIEND AN ADVOCATE THE TWO
BITS WORTH OF WISDOM ACCRUED
WHEN I CAME BACK I REALIZED
A COUPLE THINGS THE I NEW
WHERE THE BONES WERE BURIED
BUT FURTHER HELL TO RATTLE
THE BONES THOSE ARE THE SUBTLE
THINGS THAT YOU'LL LEARN AND
YOU WILL BECOME MORE EFFECTIVE
HERE ON BEHALF OF YOUR
CONSTITUENTS IN YOURSELVES AS
YOU LEARN THOSE NUANCES MOST
IMPORTANT WORDS LOYALTY AND
RESPECT THANK YOU LADIES AND
GENTLEMAN FROM A PRIVILEGE AND
HONOR OF KNOWING THE AND YOUR
FRIEND AND SERVING WITH YOU W.
OFF
SENATOR NELSON WE THANK YOU
FOR YOUR SERVICE TO THE SENATE
THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE AND
THE CONSTITUENTS OF THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA THANK YOU NOW
I'D LIKE TO TURN OVER TO OUR
FEARLESS LEADER MADAM PRO TEM
TAKE IT AWAY MADAM PRESIDENT
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND -- TO
THE GREAT SENATOR R.
DEAN I WANT TO SAY NOT ONE
PERSON IN THIS ROOM IS GOING TO
HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SERVE
THE WAY THAT YOU HAVE SERVED
IN THE LEGISLATURE SO IT WAS
RIGHT THAT YOU WOULD LEAD TO
SOFTEN SOME COMMENTS TO CNN
AND I THANK YOU FOR THAT SO
COLLEAGUES -- AS WE APPROACH
THE END OF OUR SESSION MANY OF
YOU KNOW SOME INS OF SESSION
IT'S SO LATE AND IT'S BEEN
SO DIFFICULT THAT YOU REALLY
WANT TO THANK THE PEOPLE YOU
NEED TO THANK BUT EVERYBODY'S
EXHAUSTED EVERYBODY'S TIRED
AND READY TO GO WE HAVE THE
REAL BENEFIT TONIGHT -- AS WE
LOOK AT THE CLOCK AND WE KNOW
WE STILL GOT A LITTLE BIT OF
WORK LEFT TO DO BUT WE HAVE
A LITTLE BIT OF TIME TO SAY
THANK YOU IN A WAY THAT IS MORE
APPROPRIATE -- TO THOSE WHO'VE
HELPED US GET TO THIS NIGHT
AND SO I AM GOING TO DO THIS
AND AND ACKNOWLEDGE AND THANK
A FEW FOLKS ON BEHALF OF ALL OF
YOU SO TO SPEAK ABOUT FEARLESS
TO THE INCREDIBLE SECRETARY
OF THE SENATE ERICA CONTRARIUS
TRULY FROM OVERSEEING OUR
PANDEMIC RESPONSE TO HER
TIRELESS EFFORTS IMPROVING THE
CULTURE IN OUR CAPITAL TO A MAY
SEEM TO HAVE BEEN THE HARDEST
JOB OF ALL MOVING US ACROSS THE
STREET ERICA YOU CONTINUE TO
INSPIRE US WITH YOUR EXCELLENCE
AND YOUR EMPATHY WE THANK
YOU SO I INTO CHIEF ASSISTANT
SECRETARY BERNADETTE MCNULTY
YEAR AFTER YEAR I WATCH BERNIE
INACTION ESPECIALLY DURING
THE TOUGH DEADLINE TOM'S AND
I THINK I'VE FINALLY FIGURED
IT OUT SHE'S A JET I THERE'S
NO OTHER EXPLANATION FOR HOW
SOMEONE COULD BE SO EXTREMELY
CAPABLE AND CONSISTENTLY
CALM AND I KNOW WE ESPECIALLY
APPRECIATE THOSE QUALITIES
RIGHT NOW WHEN WE'RE ABOUT
TO JUMP TO LIGHT SPEED NOW
SEE THAT WAS GOING TO BE A
COMMENT THAT WAS MADE AS WE
WERE APPROACHING MIDNIGHT OR
AFTER SO WE DON'T HAVE TO MAKE
THAT COMMENT BUT I WILL TELL
YOU -- SOMEONE WHO HAS SERVED
OUR COUNTRY I REMEMBER WHEN I
GOT TO THE ASSEMBLY MY MENTOR
SENATOR KIKO BROUGHT ME OVER
BECAUSE SHE WANTED ME TO MEET
YOU AND SHE MADE SURE TO TELL
ME THAT YOU WERE TO THE KEY
TO THE SENATE BEING ABLE TO
OPERATE AND SO WE THANK YOU
AND I CAN'T THANK YOU WITHOUT
ACKNOWLEDGING AND THANKING YOUR
INCREDIBLE TEAM OUR DESK STAFF
HERE BEFORE WE GET HERE HERE
AFTER WE GO IF YOU DIDN'T RUN
THE TRAPS AS CONSCIENTIOUSLY
AS YOU ALL DO OUR BIG IDEAS
WOULD NEVER BECOME STATE LAW
THE CARE THAT YOU SHOW IN
YOUR WORK IN THE CONSIDERATION
YOU SHOW EVERYONE WHO NEEDS
YOUR HELP IS NOTICED AND
APPRECIATED TO YOUR ENTIRE TEAM
TO THE DESK STAFF THANK YOU
AND I WILL SAY THE FACT THAT
YOU KNOW ARE VERY VOICES
FROM HERE THERE AND YONDER IS
AMAZING TO ME SO IT'S A SKILL
SO TO OUR LEAD COUNSEL KEROGEN
CONSENT TO GAPE HEADACHE R.
L.
A.
O.
AND THEIR TEAMS ARE REALLY
BEHIND THE SCENES ARE HAVING TO
DO ALL THOSE AMENDMENTS HAVING
TO PROCESS ALL THOSE THINGS
AND FURTHER GUIDANCE THROUGH
THE AMAZING BILLS AND BUDGET
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO PASS THIS
YEAR WE APPRECIATE THEM IN
THEIR FRANK ADVICE AND THEY'RE
PROBABLY NOT HAVING TO LISTEN
TO US TONIGHT I DON'T KNOW BUT
I HOPE THEY UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH
WE APPRECIATE THEM THE CAPITAL
SET THOUSANDS OF VISITORS
AND JUST THESE PAST FEW DAYS
ACTUALLY AS WE HAVE RETURNED
MORE AND MORE TO NORMAL
ADVOCATES PROTESTERS TOURIST
AND THAT'S THE THAT'S BEEN TRUE
THROUGHOUT THE YEAR SO I WANT
TO THANK OUR CHIEF SERGEANT
KATRINA RODRIGUEZ I WANT
TO THANK ALL OF OUR AMAZING
SENATE SERGEANTS THE CALIFORNIA
HIGHWAY PATROL OUR INCREDIBLE
CAPITAL SECURITY STAFF
THE C.
S.
PLEASE FOR THEIR
DEDICATED SERVICE
AND ALL OF THEM THROUGHOUT
THIS BUILDING WHO MAY NOT BE
ABLE TO BE IN THE ROOM AS WERE
SAYING THANK YOU LET'S MAKE
SURE THEY HEAR IT FROM US AS WE
EXIT I HAVE TO SAY THANK YOU TO
JENNIFER HATFIELD LUKE STARBUCK
HE HAS THE GREATEST NAME TONY
AND THE TEAM AT CAPITAL HEALTH
SERVICES VARIANCE MAY KEEP
COMING BUT THERE IS DEFINITELY
ONE CONSTANT THEIR EXPERTISE
PROFESSIONALISM AND REASSURING
MANNER WHEN THEY HAVE TO REACH
US AT ALL HOURS OF THE DAY
AND NIGHT SO WE THANK THEM
TWO DGS AND HOUSEKEEPING'S
STAFF I WANT TO THANK THEM FOR
THEIR DAILY EFFORT THAT KEEPS
THE BUILDING RUNNING BUILDINGS
I SHOULD SAY ESPECIALLY SINCE
THEY HAVE A NEW ONE TO CARE
FOR I WANT TO THANK THEM IN
PARTICULAR FOR THE DILIGENCE
THEY'VE SHOWN AS WE CONTINUE
WORKING TO KEEP PEOPLE SAFE
FROM COVERT NINETEEN AND
ESPECIALLY THE LAST DAYS
OF SESSION WHEN WE CREATE
MESSES THAT OUR MOTHERS WOULD
NEVER LET US DO AT HOME SO
I WANT TO THANK HIM FOR ALL
OF THEM THROUGHOUT THE YEAR
I AM ALMOST DONE BUT
WE ARE WAITING ON THE
ASSEMBLY I MIGHT SET
I WANT TO THANK OUR LEGISLATIVE
DATA CENTER THE CALL MODERATORS
AND ALL WHO HELPED US EXPAND
THE PUBLIC'S ABILITY TO
INTERACT WITH THEIR GOVERNMENT
AND WHO HELPED US FIGURE OUT
HOW TO USE TECHNOLOGY LOOK
WHEN WE WHEN WE HAD TO SHUT
THINGS DOWN YOU KNOW FOR
SOMEONE MANY OF YOU COME OUT A
LOCAL GOVERNMENT WHERE PEOPLE
ACTUALLY YOU LIVE IN THE
COMMUNITY THAT COME TO CITY
COUNCIL THEY COME TO THE BOARD
OF SUPERVISORS THEY COME TO
THE SCHOOL BOARDS TO THE WATER
BOARD THEY GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT
I THINK WE REALLY AND AGAIN
I GOT I THINK THE SECRETARY
AND AND MANY OF OUR COM STAFF
PEOPLE WHO FIGURED OUT HOW WE
COULD LET PEOPLE MAKE THEIR
VOICES HEARD AND TO HEAR
THEIR NAMES EVEN WITH YOUR DUE
RESPECT IN YOUR RECOMMENDATIONS
-- SENATOR ODD TO OUR DEAN
IT IT WAS REALLY IMPORTANT WE
FOUND A WAY TO LET PUBLIC HAVE
A VOICE EVEN IF IT'S THEIR NAME
WHERE THEY LIVE AND YES OR NO
AND CREATIVE PEOPLE FOUND A
WAY TO SAVE A LITTLE MORE BUT
THAT IS DEMOCRACY AND WE SHOULD
BE PRIVILEGED AND HONORED THAT
WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SIT
AND HEAR FROM THEM PRIVILEGED
AND HONORED I DON'T KNOW ABOUT
YOU SOME DAYS I -- I FORGET I
GET CAUGHT UP IN IN THE ANGST
IN THE DIFFICULT WORK IN THE
WHATEVER AND I'M MOMENTARILY
FORGET WHAT IT MEANS TO WALK
INTO THIS BUILDING REGARDLESS
OF WHERE YOU COME FROM
GEOGRAPHICALLY REGARDLESS OF
YOUR PHILOSOPHICAL OUTLOOK
REGARDLESS WE ARE PRIVILEGED
WE ARE PRIVILEGED AND SO
TO GET TO HEAR FROM THESE
CONSTITUENTS IS AN INCREDIBLE
THING AND SO THAT TECHNOLOGY
AND THE WORK THAT YOU DID TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE COULD HAVE
REMOTE PARTICIPATION IS REALLY
IMPORTANT I HAVE TO THANK ALL
OF OUR COMMITTEE STAFF WHO'VE
WORKED AROUND THE CLOCK THIS
YEAR WE HAD MORE BILLS REMEMBER
WEEK LESSENED OUR BILL LOAD
AND THEN WE RAMP IT BACK UP
AND WE WERE SO AFRAID WE WERE
GOING TO BE HERE -- IT MIDNIGHT
IS IS YOU KNOW THE DEADLINE
BUT THAT COMMITTEE STAFF RAMPS
BACK UP WORKED AROUND THE CLOCK
ON A RECORD NUMBER OF BILLS
THEIR ANALYSIS IS CRITICAL
TO THE WORK THAT WE DO IN
ORDER FOR US TO ENACT POLICIES
THAT BENEFIT THE PEOPLE OF
CALIFORNIA SO I ALSO WANT TO
THANK ALL OF OUR STAFF BOTH
CAPITAL IN THE DISTRICTS THE
ONE TO HELP US NAVIGATE BILLS
FROM DRAFTING DESIGNING AND
THOSE WHO HELPED THE PUBLIC AND
THE PRESS AND MEDIA UNDERSTAND
WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO AND
THOSE STAFF IN OUR DISTRICTS
WHO SERVED AS CASE WORKERS
THIS LAST YEAR IN ADDITION TO
EVERYTHING ELSE THEY DID IN
ADDITION TO ALL OF THE ZUNE
MEETINGS THEY WENT TO ON OUR
BEHALF ALL OF THEM THE CAPITAL
STAFF AND OUR DISTRICT STAFF
I ALSO WANNA FRANKLY LET ME
SAY HOW ENJOYABLE IT IS TO
HAVE MEMBERS OF THE PRESS WITH
US TO SEE A FAIRLY CALM DID
SOMEONE SAY BOO NO THEY DID I
MEAN TO SEE A FAIRLY CALM END
OF SESSION THUS FAR ALTHOUGH
IT'S CERTAINLY A STILL IT'S
STILL COULD GO DOWNHILL BUT I
I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
BECAUSE YOU CONTINUE TO DO
YOUR JOB HOLD US ACCOUNTABLE
MAKE SURE THE PUBLIC HAD
INFORMATION AND ACCESS AND YOU
HAD TO DO IT REMOTELY YOU HAD
TO TAKE TURNS COMING INTO THE
BUILDING IT WAS NOT AN EASY
THING FOR YOU SO I THINK WE DO
HAVE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE MEDIA
AND THE PRESS FOR BEING HERE
WITH US TONIGHT YOU CAN CLASS
AND BEFORE I TURN IT OVER TO
MY -- MY INCREDIBLE COLLEAGUES
AT THE REPUBLICAN LEADER I AM
GOING TO DO ONE THING IS THE
PRO TEM AND TAKE A A MOMENT
OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE AND
THANK MY INCREDIBLE LEADERSHIP
TEAM AND STAFF IN MY OFFICE
BECAUSE YOU KNOW SOMETIMES
THEY SERVICE YOUR STAFF
REPUBLICAN DEMOCRAT THEY SOLVE
PROBLEMS NOT JUST MINE -- SO
I I REALLY AM GOING TO THANK
MY LEADERSHIP TEAM -- THAT
INCLUDES MY CHIEF OF STAFF I'M
A LIST ON NICK HARTMAN -- MY
DISTRICT DIRECTOR PAM ISON WHO
HAS TO BE ME IN THE DISTRICT
WHEN I END UP HERE LONGER I
AND I DON'T GET TO GO HOME
AND AND SHE'S INCREDIBLE AND
MY WHOLE DISTRICT TEAM IS BUT
ALSO DIANNE CHRISTMAS KIMBERLY
RODRIGUEZ CHRIS WOODS NIECE OF
FRENCH AND HER ENTIRE COM STEAM
AND NIKOLINA WOODS -- I REALLY
DO THINK I COULDN'T DO THE JOB
I DO WITHOUT THEIR INCREDIBLE
SUPPORT AND HELP -- AND AGAIN
ALL THE STAFF BUT I I DID
WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THEM AND
THANK YOU
I WAS GONNA SAY IT'S TYPICAL
MY CHIEF OF STAFF DUCKED OUT
ON THE APPRECIATION PART --
BUT NOW I WANT TO -- TURN IT
OVER TO SOMEONE THAT I RESPECT
A GREAT DEAL YOU KNOW IT'S
SO INTERESTING PEOPLE PEOPLE
LIKE TO FOCUS ON THE FACT
THAT DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS
DON'T SEEM TO GET ALONG --
WE HAVE OUR DIFFERENCES OF
OPINION BUT FRANKLY WE ALL
HAVE DIFFERENCES OF OPINION
YOU GOT TO WITNESS SOME OF THAT
A LITTLE EARLIER TODAY BUT --
I JUST WANT TO AS I TURN IT
OVER TO THE REPUBLICAN LEADER
-- I JUST WANT TO SAY THANK
YOU TO HIM -- FOR THE ROLE
HE HAS PLAYED AND LET ME TURN
IT OVER TO REPUBLICAN LEADER
SCOTT WILL TO SAY SOME COMMENTS
TAKING THAT APPROACH HIM BEFORE
START I'VE GOT A TEXT HERE FROM
MY CHIEF OF STAFF I LEAN RECUR
I DO SENATOR I APOLOGIZE THAT
YOUR SPEECH IS NOT AS ELOQUENT
OR AS COMPREHENSIVE AS THE P.
T.'S SO OR LETTER OFF THE HOOK
BECAUSE I'M A NICE GUY ANYWAY
REALLY HONORED HONORED TO BE
HERE TO SERVE IN THE SENATE
WITH ALL OF YOU AND WE'RE HERE
WE ARE WRAPPING UP A LOT OF
WORK OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS
NOW YOU GUYS THINK THROUGH YOUR
POLICIES THAT YOU'RE HELPING
PEOPLE FULFILL THE CALIFORNIA
DREAM OUR SIDE FOR THE MOST
PART WE THINK IT'S FOLLY AND
ULTIMATELY HISTORY WILL DECIDE
SO TONIGHT I THINK WE SHOULD
JUST CELEBRATE BEING TOGETHER
AND WORKING -- WORKING HARD
SO I THINK WE CLAP TO THAT
FIRST I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE
YOUR CONCERNS AND THE THING
I LOVE ABOUT ERICA SHE
APPLIES THE LAW TO EVERYONE
YOU GUYS AGREED THAT YOU
GUYS HAVE AS MUCH PROBLEMS
WITH THERE IS WE DO RIGHT
IT'S LIKE YES SHE ALL TOUCH
WITH THE MEMBERS ON THE OTHER
SIDE DON'T LIKE ME ANYMORE THAN
YOUR MEMBERS DO SO BUT YOU'VE
BEEN VERY GOOD TO ME SO THAT'S
ALL THAT MATTERS TO ME SO THANK
YOU ERICA AND AND AGAIN JUST
THE WITH THE WORK DONE ON COVE
IT -- I REALLY THOUGHT WE BE
RAVAGED MUCH MORE THAN THEN WE
THEN WE WE WERE SO THANK YOU
FOR THAT AND THEN OF COURSE
SUSAN -- DELLA FORTE I WOULD
HAVE MISSED SO MANY KOBE TEST
ON SUNDAY IF I DIDN'T GET THAT
WAS -- THOSE EMAILS FROM HER SO
WE REALLY APPRECIATE THAT AND
THEY COME OUT ALL YOU KNOW YEP
CAN THE CODE AND THE CODE
NOTICES LIKE HE SHOULD JUST
STOP I MEAN WE GET ONE EVERY
DAY SO YOU KNOW NOTHING
ABOUT THAT AND THEN BERNIE
MCNULTY JUST UNBELIEVABLE
JOB YOU AND YOUR STAFF AND
AND HE IS SHODDY
YOU YOU HEAR OUR NAMES AT NIGHT
WHEN YOU'RE SLEEPING LIKE THAT
HAVE YOU GO TO SLEEP OUR TO
LEAD A ALLEN NO YOU KNOW ALAN'S
ALWAYS BONTA VÌ ARCHULETA
PORGES YEAH ALLEN'S ALWAYS
SOMEWHERE DOING SOMETHING
ANYWAY JUST APPRECIATE YOU GUYS
AND THEN AGAIN THE THE THE THE
SERGEANTS -- JUST SPECTACULAR
JOB AND YOU KNOW WHEN I FIRST
GOT ELECTED TO THIS TO THE
STATE LEGISLATURE I REALLY
POO POOHED -- SECURITY I DON'T
THINK WE'LL HAVE A REALLY BIG
DEAL UNTIL I GOT A SERIOUS
DEATH THREAT AND THE GUY GOT
FIFTY ONE FIFTIES AND SO HE'S
FIFTY ONE FIFTY AND NEVER HEARD
WHAT HAPPENED AND THEN THEY
GOT PUT AWAY AND THEN SO I MEAN
MY ASSEMBLY OFFICE ONE DAY NO
XP PATCH STORE IN THIS GUY'S
TALKING TO MY UNPAID COLLEGE
INTERN IN HERE IN THE STORE
IN GOING THIS SOUNDS KIND OF
FAMILIAR GOES WELL YEAH BECAUSE
I MEAN YOU GUYS PUT CAMERAS UP
IN YOUR DISTRICT OFFICE LIKE
ALL MY GOSH THAT'S THE KILLER
SO SO I YOU KNOW I WANT TO SAY
ME RIGHT SO I GET THE F.
NINE BUTTON -- SECURITY COMES
IN THEY SIT DOWN AND THEN HE
LEAVES AND THEY WALK OUT AND
I DIDN'T HAVE A RESTRAINING
ORDER SO HE LEGALLY COULD
BE THERE BUT HE HAD AN ANKLE
BRACELET ON SO I'M UPSET
BECAUSE LIKE UNPAID INTERN
ARGUED SHE SHOULDN'T HAVE TO
TAKE A BULLET FOR ME SO I WENT
ON TO COMPLAIN TO MR PAYING
AND LIKE YOU KNOW I WAS UPSET
AND HE GOES WELL HE WALKED IN
AND THE CHP OFFICERS SAW THAT
HE HAD AN ANKLE BRACELET DID
CALL UP TO US AND I GO YOU
DON'T STOP MEDICAL BRACELET HE
GOES WELL WE HAVE SIX ASSEMBLY
STAFFERS WITH ANKLE BRACELETS
I SAID HOW MANY MEMBERS HE
SAID NINE CURRENTLY THAT WOULD
NEVER HAPPEN IN THE SENATE SO
THANK YOU TO ALL THE SECURITY
STAFF VERTICALLY WHAT SOME OF
YOUR GUYS IS BAD BOTH PEOPLE
REALLY DON'T LIKE YOU KNOW YOU
GOT A LOT OF MOMS REALLY ANGRY
AT YOU AND I ALWAYS TELL THEM
THAT YOU REALLY ARE GOOD PEOPLE
USE THINK DIFFERENTLY AND THIS
SWINGS IN THE SWING SPACE THAT
WAS JUST REALLY UNBELIEVABLE
WORK -- AND THEN I'VE GOT A
CONFESSION TO MAKE SO WE GOT
A CALL ON A THURSDAY AND WE'RE
ALREADY BACK HOME SAYING THAT
WE HAD TO MOVE OUT OF MY OFFICE
ON FRIDAY WE COULD MOVE A LOT
OF STUFF IN THIS ME SPACE SO
MY STAFF MOVED IT OVER INTO MY
PARTNER WHICH IS FINE WHAT THEY
MOVED WITH HIS BEAUTIFUL BUSTER
RONALD REAGAN WHICH IS NOT MINE
IS THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SO
IT WAS THERE FOR A FEW WEEKS
IS IT BACK SAFELY IN THE SWING
SPACE BUT DID YOU SEE THE STATE
OF CALIFORNIA YOU KNOW THING
ON THE BOTTOM BUT ANYWAY WE
GOT THAT OVER AND -- AND I'VE
ONLY BEEN SECOND ELEVATOR TWICE
ONCE WITH SENATOR DODD WHICH
WAS A PLEASURE IN THE ONCE BY
MYSELF AND THE LIGHTS WENT OFF
AND THE LIGHTS WENT OFF AND
I'VE NEVER BEEN CAT -- THE CARD
CLAUSTROPHOBIC BEFORE BUT I
DID NOT LIKE THAT BUT THAT'S
SUPPOSEDLY GOOD AND THEN THE
MIKE MCGUIRE I MEAN I'VE KNOWN
BOB HERTZBERG SPREE POLITICS
SINCE NINETEEN NINETY FIVE
GREAT GUYS IT PROFESSION DOES A
WONDERFUL JOB BUT MIKE MCGUIRE
YOU ARE YOU ARE CUSTOMER DRIVEN
AND IT'S REALLY UNBELIEVABLE
YOU AND YOUR TEAM AND I KNOW
YOU KNOW OUR TEAM WE ALWAYS
MEET BEFORE SESSION IS T.
R.
CAUCUS JR BRIAN JONES AND THEN
-- PAT BATES -- BECAUSE OUR
FLOOR WITH AND WE WE WE ONE
WE HAVE A GREAT TIME IN THE
AND YOU'RE VERY GOOD YOU'RE
YOU'RE YOU TRANSPARENT AND
WE HAVE QUESTIONS OR WHATEVER
YOU'RE JUST PHENOMENAL
ABOUT GETTING BACK TO US AND
REALLY APPRECIATE THAT YEP
THEN I LEAN PUT ANYTHING IN
HERE ABOUT MY WIFE BUT MY
WIFE IS YOU KNOW IT'S BEEN
GONE ALL SUMMER IN CAPE COD
SHE'S IN SLEEPING SO I'M NOT
GONNA MENTION MY WIFE BECAUSE
SHE'S NOT SHE'S NOT HERE SO WE
MOVE ON TO MY PERSONAL STAFF
SO I HIGHLY RECOMMEND CHIEF
OF STAFF TO USE PHENOMENA I
KNOW A LOT OF YOU PEOPLE KNOW
BECAUSE SHE'S BEEN HERE FOR
A LONG TIME IN THE COURSE ARE
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR BALTAR'S
OUR CORE NAIL IN MY SCHEDULER
AMY QUIST AND WHO WHO DOES A
GREAT JOB AND THEN OUR CHIEF
OUR POCKETS CHIEF OF STAFF JOHN
BULL DAY BECAUSE A CO THAT I
DIDN'T SEE FOR A YEAR SO THAT
WAS WE ARE DOING THAT AND THEN
FINALLY OUR OUR CAUCUS STAFF
IS UNBELIEVABLE YOU KNOW YOU
GUYS SET THE AGENDA WE HAVE
TO REACT TO THE J.
AND AND THE WAY THAT THEY
ARE ABLE TO TURN THE STUFF
AROUND SUCH A TIMELY MANNER
I CAN NUMBER TIMES TODAY WE
WERE GETTING OUR INDEXES IN
OUR SUPPLEMENTAL BEFORE IT
YOU KNOW IF YOU CAME OUT SO
ONE OF RECOGNIZED -- GREG MA
IN -- KIRK FEELINGS NOT HERE
DOES BUDGET AND THEN MAXI
HOLMGREN DOUGLAS WHO DOES OUR
CONSTANT THEY DO WONDERFUL
JOB YEAH WE SHOULD DO THAT
I'M THRILLED THAT I JUST I
JUST COUPLE CLOSING COMMENTS
IT'S BEEN AN HONOR TO SERVE
YOU WITH YOU CENTER NIELSEN TO
ME YOU'RE LIKE THE LAST REAL
SENATOR INTERESTING FACTS I
DON'T KNOW IF IT MAKES ME FEEL
BETTER HIM FEEL BETTER MAYBE
NEITHER OF ITS HE WAS THE
SENATE REPUBLICAN LEADER WHEN I
WAS IN COLLEGE NOT A LONG TIME
AGO -- OKAY WELL I MEAN AS A
LONG TIME AGO NINETEEN EIGHTY
THREE LONG TIME AGO RIGHT BUT
I MEAN YOU'VE JUST BEEN ONE
JUST YET YOU'RE YOU'RE JUST
SUCH A A ROLE MODEL FOR FOR
ALL OF US IN ON BOTH ON BOTH
SIDES OF THE ON JUST REALLY
REALLY APPRECIATE YOU AND I
REALLY HOPE YOU IN MARYLAND
DO GO OFF INTO THE SUNRISE
ENJOY YOUR RETIREMENT AND THEN
YOU YOUNG MAN FORGES WE'RE
GONNA WE'RE GONNA MISS YOUR
MIND THE ONE THING I REALLY
LIKE ABOUT YOU YOU'VE BEEN
HERE FOR YEARS NOW YOU STILL
THINK IT'S LOCAL GOVERNMENT
YOU KNOW WHAT I'M SAYING WHEN
I SAY THAT RIGHT NOW I COULD
VOTE FOR THE BILL IF YOU'D
LIKE THEY DON'T CARE MAN THEY
GOT THE VOTES REALLY TWENTY
ONE BABY RULE TWENTY ONE BUT
AND AND YOU'RE GONNA BE BUT I
MEAN I KNOW YOU CAN DEFINITELY
LIKE JIM STAY ENGAGED IN SO I
EXPECT TO SEE YOU DOING BIGGER
AND BETTER THINGS AS WE GO
ON AND THEN LIKE A DOROTHY
CENTER BATES YOU KNOW MY FOR
MY FAVORITE OF ALL YOU'RE
ONE TOUGH GRANDMA ANYBODY
WHO UNDERESTIMATES YOU GETS
CUT WHICH IS WHICH IS WHICH
IS GREAT YOU WOULD BE BEEN
YOU'VE BEEN A GOOD FRIEND AND
SUPPORTER AND AND RAINY AND
WHEN I NEED TO BE REINED IN
EARLY SHE TRY AND I REALLY
LOVE YOU AND RESPECT YOU IN
IN APPRECIATE YOU I JUST ALL
MY COLLEAGUES SO MANY DO YOU
HAVE THIS JOB BEFORE YOU KNOW
HOW MUCH IT SUCKS AND I'M
SO LOOKING FORWARD TO NOT
HAVING TO DO IT AGAIN I'LL
LISTEN THANK YOU YOUR LEAVING
WHERE YOU ARE WHEN YOU TAKE
OVER MY TWITTER ACCOUNT WHEN
YOU LEAVE -- FALL SIR WHO
FOLLOWS HER ON TWITTER MY WIFE
ALL TIME WAY CAN'T YOU BE MORE
LIKE -- MELISSA MELENDEZ ON
TWITTER WHEN I DON'T HAVE FIVE
KIDS WHICH GIVES YOU GREAT
STORIES IN A LITTLE BIT MORE
TO THE MIDDLE THAN YOU ARE
BUT WHATEVER OKAY SAME TEAM
ANYWAY WITHOUT IT HAD A GREAT
TWO YEARS I HOPE EVERYBODY
REALLY ENJOYS HER TIME OFF I
KNOW A LOT OF IT'S GOING TO
BE OUT CAMPAIGNING BUT THAT'S
GOOD YOU KNOW I DON'T KNOW
ABOUT YOU I FIND IT ENERGIZING
YOU KNOW ACTUALLY GOING OUT
IN INTERFACING WITH YOU KNOW
AVERAGE CALIFORNIANS THAT
WE THAT WE REPRESENT I KNOW
I YOU MAY SHARE THE SAME --
FEELING IS LIKE WHAT WE DO
HERE SO IMPORTANT AND I THINK
WHAT WE DO HERE IS ACTUALLY
MORE IMPORTANT THAN WHAT THEY
DO IN WASHINGTON DC RIGHT TO
EDUCATION OUR CHILDREN DRANK
GRANDCHILDREN GET THERE THE
ROADS THEY DRIVE ON THE AIR
THEY BREATHE THE WATER THEY
DRINK THOSE ARE CITIZENS
ARE MADE HERE AND AND ARGUS
SEARCHES DON'T KNOW NOTHING
ABOUT IT SO I ENCOURAGE YOU
TO TO GO OUT THERE PRESS THE
FLASH SHARE YOUR VISION AND
MAYBE EVEN MORE IMPORTANTLY
YOU LISTEN TO THEM AND I THINK
YOU COME BACK WITH MAYBE BETTER
IDEAS SO YOU COMMUNITIES NEXT
YEAR THAT MAKES THE LIVES OF
AVERAGE CALIFORNIA'S BETTER
ANYWAY WITHOUT HONOR TO SERVE
WITH ALL OF YOU IT'S IS BASIS
PICRIC TWO YEARS AND -- LOOKING
FORWARD TO THE FALL GOOD NIGHT
THANK YOU SENATOR
WELCOME MEMBER TIM
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
-- I DID WANT TO ALSO
ACKNOWLEDGE LAURIE SHELLEY
FOR THESE INCREDIBLE
S.
IS THIS IS AN INCREDIBLE YES
TO EACH OF THE SENATORS BECAUSE
NUMBER ONE SHE REFLECTS THE
BEST OF US IN HERE THEY LOOK
GOOD SHE MAKES US LOOK GOOD
AND VERY THOUGHTFUL -- IN TERMS
OF WHAT YOU HAVE PUT TOGETHER
TO HELP US REMEMBER THE BEST
OF TIMES AND -- YOU KNOW AS
I LOOK AROUND THE ROOM TO MY
COLLEAGUES WE ACTUALLY REALLY
DO LIKE EACH OTHER A LOT --
WE HAVE OUR MOMENTS IT IS LIKE
A FAMILY IT THE SENATE FAMILY
AND YOU KNOW WE'LL SEE WILL
WRAP UP A LITTLE BIT LATER
TONIGHT BUT I DO WANT TO SAY TO
THE THESE INCREDIBLE SENATORS
THAT ARE DEPARTING US YOU
KNOW YOU ALWAYS HAVE A HOME
IN A PLACE ON THE RED CARPET
AND WITH THAT I HAVE ONE LESS
THING TO DO MADAM -- PRESIDENT
AND THAT IS -- HARMON JORDAN
LEADERS WHO RUNS INCREDIBLE
FLOOR TEAM WITH THE DEMOCRATS
AND THE REPUBLICANS THANK YOU
REPUBLICAN LEADER FOR KNOWLEDGE
AND THAT THAT PROCESS WE HAVE
ONE -- PRESIDING OFFICER THAT
WILL NOT BE RETURNING SHE IS
RETIRING AND SO I WANTED TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE THANK YOU
YOU'VE BEEN DOING AN INCREDIBLE
JOB TODAY -- THE MAJORITY
LEADER HAS FLOWERS FOR YOU
AND I WILL I WILL GIVE MADAM
PRESIDENT THE LAST WORD AND
THEN WE WILL HOPEFULLY HAVE
A BILL OR TWO COMING BACK OUR
WAY BUT MADAM PRESIDENT BACK
TO YOU THANK YOU MADAM PRO
TEM THANK YOU MISTER MAJORITY
LEADERS IS VERY UNEXPECTED
YOU GUYS KNOW I LOVE PRESIDING
YOU GUYS KNOW I LOVE TRYING TO
MOVE US ALONG KEEP EVERYBODY
IN LINE I WILL MISS DOING
THAT I WILL MISS SEEING ALL
OF YOU BUT DON'T WORRY YOU
CAN'T GET RID OF ME THAT
EASILY I'LL COME BACK THANK
YOU VERY MUCH I'M VERY ATTACHED
AND YES WE'RE WAITING ON
SOME HER BILL SO STATE BUT
MEMBERS WE ARE GOING TO
TAKE A TEN MINUTE RECESS
BUT PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE
STAY CLOSE BECAUSE AFTER TEN
MINUTES WE WILL HAVE SOME
MORE WORK TO DO THANK YOU
RIGHT MEMBERS ARE IF YOU
CAN TAKE YOUR SEAT PLEASE
WE ARE GOING TO WHARF
ELEVEN FIFTY SEVEN WITHOUT
OBJECTION IT IS A SENATOR
HERTZBERG BILL BUT SENATOR
EGGMAN IS GOING TO PRESENT
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
SENATE BILL ELEVEN FIFTY
SEVEN BY SENATOR HERTZBERG AN
ACT RELATING TO WATER CENTER
EGGMAN THANK YOU VERY MUCH
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS FIRST
SB ELEVEN FIFTY SEVEN IS BACK
FOR CONCURRENCE ON BEHALF
SENATOR HERTZBERG I'M GOING
TO ASK MEMBERS FOR YOU TO
PAUSE IN YOUR THINKING FOR A
MOMENT AS WE CAN KERR IN THESE
AMENDMENTS WHICH REMOVED A
SIGNIFICANT THIRTY TO BE EXACT
NUMBER OF WATER AGENCIES THAT
WERE IN OPPOSITION WHO ARE NO
LONGER IN OPPOSITION MEMBERS
I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE IN
CONCURRING IN THE AMENDMENTS
ON SB ELEVEN FIFTY SEVEN THANK
YOU SENATOR EGGMAN MEMBERS IS
THERE ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES NO PACKER I PORCHES
NO BRADFORD AYE CUP AYE ADAM
CORTESE HI KELLY NO DODD
AYE TORONTO I EGGMAN
I GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROWTH
NO HERTZBERG WESTERN I HER
TADO NO JONES NOPE KAMLAGER AYE
FLARED AYE LEYVA AYE FOR THE
MONTH AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
NO MAN NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO --
CHOI BOGUE NO PAN I PORTANTINO
I ROTH AYE RUBIO I SKINNER I
STERN AYE NUMBER HI MY COUNTY I
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS COME
BY OTHER I HERTZBERG MEN IS
TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS TEN THAT
THE ASSEMBLY AMENDMENTS ARE
CONCURRED IN MEMBERS WE ARE
MOVING FILE ITEM SIX TO THE
AN ACTIVE FILE AND WE ARE NOW
GOING TO LIVE CALLS ON A COUPLE
ITEMS WE'RE GOING TO START WITH
FILE ITEM FORTY MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA
HAVE I EVER HERTZBERG MANY
NEWMAN PORTANTINO RALPH RUBIO
AMBERG ALL THE ROLE ONE MORE
TIME PLEASE ARCHULETA HAVE
I EVER HERTZBERG MANY NEWMAN
PORTANTINO OFF RUBIO I'M BURKE
CENTER MOVES THE CALL MOVING
THE FILE ITEM FORTY SEVEN
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA BRADFORD HAVE I EVER
DODD QUESTION KAMLAGER RALPH
RUBIO AMBERG PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
ARCHULETA BRADFORD CABRERA DODD
WESSON KAMLAGER RALPH RUBIO
AMBERG CENTER MOVES THE CALL
YEAH HERTZBERG
IS OKAY THANK GOD
WE'RE GONNA LIFT THE
CALL ON YEP NO PROBLEM
OKAY EVERYBODY STAY PUT
WE'VE GOT A FEW MORE VOTES
WE NEED TO TAKE THANK
YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO LIFT
THE CALL ON FILE ITEM ELEVEN
FIFTY SEVEN MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
HERTZBERG AYE MIN IS TWENTY
NINE KNOWS TEN ASSEMBLY
MEMBER ARE CONCURRED IN WE
ARE NOW GOING TO LIFT THE
CALL ON SB SEVEN SEVEN FOUR
HERTZBERG AYE AYES
FORTINOS ZERO THE ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS ARE CONCURRED IN
WHAT WE GOT
MEMBERS WE HAVE TWO
BILLS THAT WE ARE GOING
TO LIFT THE CALLS ON
WE'RE GOING TO START
WITH A FILE ITEM FORTY
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
HAVE I EVER HERTZBERG MANY
NEWMAN PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO
AMBERG PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS AGAIN ARCHULETA COME
BY OTHER HERTZBERG MANY NEWMAN
PORTANTINO OFF RUBIO I'M BURKE
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ONE MORE TIME ARCHULETA COME
BY OTHER HERTZBERG MANY NEWMAN
PORTANTINO RALPH RUBIO AMBERG
I EIGHTEEN KNOWS THIRTEEN
THE MEASURE FAILS MEMBERS WE
ARE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
FORTY SEVEN MADAM SECRETARY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ARCHULETA BRADFORD CABALLERO
DODD WESSEL KAMLAGER RALPH
RUBIO I'M BURKE PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ARCHULETA
BRADFORD CABALLERO DODD
DODD NO
WESSEL KAMLAGER ROTH RUBIO
NUMBER CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME PLEASE
ARCHULETA BRADFORD CABALLERO
WESSEL KAMLAGER RUBIO AMBERG
IS TWENTY KNOWS TWELVE THE
URGENCY CLAUSE IS REFUSED
ADOPTION AND IS TWENTY KNOWS
TWELVE THE MEASURE FAILS
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO
MOTIONS AND RESOLUTIONS
IF EVERYONE COULD TAKE
THEIR SEATS PLEASE
SENATOR STERN YOU ARE
RECOGNIZED WHEN YOU ARE READY
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT --
MEMBERS I REQUEST UNANIMOUS
CONSENT TO SUBMIT A LETTER
TO THE JOURNAL ON ASSEMBLY
BILL TWO ZERO FIVE THANK YOU
SENATOR JONES THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT WE CERTAINLY SUPPORT
CENTER STERN AND HIS ABILITY TO
SUBMIT A LETTER BY THE THERE'S
JUST A COUPLE OF POINTS IN THE
LETTER THAT WERE OBJECTIONABLE
TO AND ASK FOR A ROLL CALL
VOTE IN AN ENCOURAGING ROUTE
REPUBLICANS JUST TO ABSTAIN
OR VOTE NO VERY GOOD THANK
YOU WE WILL DO A ROLL CALL
VOTE CENTER STREET IS ASKING
FOR AN AYE VOTE SENATOR JONES
IS ASKING FOR NO VOTE MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
AYE BATES BATES BAKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD I CUT BY
OTHER CORTESE I HAVE A OTHER
AYE PROTESTING AYE DALY DODD
I TO RAZA I EGGMAN HI GLAZER
GONZALEZ I DROVE HERTZBERG
WESTERN I HER TADO I JONES
KAMLAGER HI THERE HI LEYVA HI
THE MON HI MCGUIRE HI MELENDEZ
MAN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
NIELSEN I TROUBLED PAN I
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
SKINNER I STERN HI I'M BURKE
I'D LIKE HOUSEKI WIENER I
WILK PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS ALLEN I BATES FORTUS
TALLY GLAZER I GROVE HERTZBERG
AYE JONES MELENDEZ NIELSEN
BUT CHOI BOGUE WHITE HOUSE
SKI WELL IS THIRTY NO ZERO
THE MOTION CARRIES A SENDER
JONES FOR PURPOSE TO RISE HOPE
CENTER WORK FOR A PURPOSE TO
RISE I'M TAKING ARE PRESENT
REPUBLICAN CAUCUS IN ROOM
TO FIFTEEN ABOUT LIKE NOW
REPUBLICAN CAUCUS RIGHT NOW
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS DEMOCRATIC
CAUCUS WE ARE GOING TO TAKE
A LITTLE BREAK -- BUT DO
NOT LEAVE THE SENATE FLOOR
US SENATOR RUBIO WOULD LIKE
EVERYONE TO COME TO THE FRONT
OF THE ROSTRUM TO TAKE A END
OF SESSION PHOTO THIS WOULD BE
THE APPROPRIATE TIME TO DO THAT
SINCE WE ARE ON A LITTLE BREAK
EVERYONE IS
MEMBERS THANK YOU FOR BEING
HERE AND -- ANYONE WHO IS
NOT HERE FIND YOUR SEAT
MATE GET THEM TO THE FLOOR
-- WE ARE GETTING THE FILE
READY AND WE WILL BE BOLD OF
VOTING SHORTLY SO GET READY
ALL RIGHT MEMBERS WE ARE
READY IF YOUR SEATMATE IS NOT
WITH YOU FIND THEM WE'RE WAR
FIGHTING OVER FILE ITEM -- S.
B.
EIGHT FORTY SIX WITHOUT
OBJECTION SENATOR DODD MADAM
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
BILL EIGHT FORTY SIX BY
SENATOR DODD AN ACT RELATING TO
ENERGY MAKING AN APPROPRIATION
THEREFORE AND DECLARING THERE'S
AND SEE THEIR AT SIGNIFICANTLY
SENATOR DODD MADAM PRESIDENT
COLLEAGUES I RISE TO PRESENT S.
B.
EIGHT FORTY SIX SB A FORTY
SIX WILL GIVE US AN ESSENTIAL
TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX TO PREVENT
WIDESPREAD ROLLING BLACKOUTS
IN AVOID SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASE
ELECTRICITY PRICES FROM
DIRTY CARBON EMITTING OUT OF
STATE ROUTE SOURCES THIS BILL
AUTHORIZES THE EXTENSION OF
DYEABLE CANYON POWER PLANT
SUNSET DATE BY UP TO FIVE
ADDITIONAL YEARS IN SEEKS TO
MAKE THE POWER PLANT ELIGIBLE
FOR FEDERAL FUNDING TOWARDS
THAT END THE BILL ALLOWS A
THREE HUNDRED FIFTY MILLION
DOLLAR LOAN TO THE PLANT'S
OPERATOR TO CONTINUE OPERATIONS
OF THE PLANT AN ADDITIONAL
TWO HUNDRED FIFTY MILLION
DOLLARS AVAILABLE THROUGH
THE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE
PROCESS THE LOAN IS CONTINGENT
UPON CALIFORNIA QUALIFYING
IT RECEIVING REIMBURSEMENT
BY THE US DEPARTMENT OF
ENERGY GRANT PROVIDING
A CLEAR PATHWAY FOR LOAN
REPAYMENT THE BILL CONTAINS
SIGNIFICANT PROTECTIONS FOR
TAXPAYERS AND RATEPAYERS
INCLUDING PROHIBITING ANY
USE OF STATE PHONE LOT STATE
LOAN FUNDS TO PAY P.
JEANNIE SHOULD SHAREHOLDERS
REQUIRED IN THE P.
JEANNIE AND PG&AMP;E INVEST
PAYMENTS IT GETS FROM SELLING
DYEABLE GUINEA POWER INTO
ACCELERATING OUR TRANSITION
TO RENEWABLE AND ZERO CARBON
ENERGY NOT SHAREHOLDER PROFITS
CREDITING MARKET REVENUES BACK
TO RATE PAYERS ENSURING ROBUST
REGULATORY OVERSIGHT OF THE
PLAN IT ALSO PUTS THE STATE
ON TRACK WITH RENEWABLE ENERGY
PROCUREMENT SUPERCHARGING THAT
TRANSITION BY INVESTING ONE
BILLION DOLLARS TO SUPPORT
A CLEAN ENERGY RELIABILITY
INVESTMENT PLAN THAT WILL
ACCELERATE DEPLOYMENT OF
CLEAN ENERGY RESOURCES DEMAND
RESPONSE REPAIR ASSISTANCE
AND RELIABILITY IMPROVEMENTS
MEMBERS DIABLE CANYON SUPPLIES
APPROXIMATELY SEVENTEEN PERCENT
OF CALIFORNIANS ZERO CARBON
ELECTRICITY AND MORE THAN
EIGHT PERCENT OF THE STATE'S
TOTAL ELECTRICITY CALIFORNIA'S
CURRENT CLEAN ENERGY GENERATION
AND STORAGE SYSTEM IS NOT
YET ABLE TO ADEQUATELY BACK
FILL THE ENERGY PRODUCTION --
FROM DIAB OKAY ANY POWERFUL
AT SCRAMBLING TO BUY COSTLY
IN DIRTY OUT OF STATE POWER
ISN'T THE ANSWER IT WILL
HAMMER REPAIRS AND WORSEN
CLIMATE CHANGE THIS BILL IS
NECESSARY BLACKOUTS ARE REAL
THREAT IMPOSED ECONOMIC HEALTH
AND SAFETY RISK ESPECIALLY
FOR THE MOST VULNERABLE
CALIFORNIANS IN A HEATWAVE THAT
REQUIRES HIGH ENERGY DEMAND
FOR COOLING LOSING POWER CAN
QUITE LITERALLY COST LIVES
THIS BILL ALSO PAVE THE WAY
FOR GREATER INVESTMENT IN CLEAN
RENEWABLE SOURCES WEANING US
OF ANY POTENTIAL NEED FOR THE
DIAVEL CANNY POWER PLANTS IF
CALIFORNIANS ABLE TO SECURE
SUFFICIENT RENEWABLE AND ZERO
CARBON ENERGY WITHOUT DYEABLE
CANYON BEING OPERATIONAL THIS
BILL PROVIDES THERE WON'T
BE ANY EXTENSION OF ITS PRE
EXISTING CLOSURE DATE BUT WE
NEED TO BE PROACTIVE WE NEED
TO HAVE THE OPTION AVAILABLE
TO KEEP THE LIGHTS ON AND
KEEP MAKING PROGRESS TOWARDS
NET ZERO CARBON EMISSIONS THE
RISKY CALIFORNIANS ARE TOO
GREAT TO CHANCE IT IN ADEQUATE
ENERGY SUPPLY THANK YOU AND
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER DODD
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
CENTER LAYERED THANK YOU VERY
MUCH MADAM PRESIDENT OF THE
HOUR IS LATE I DID INTENDED TO
GIVE REALLY LONG REMARKS BUT IT
DID SLICE AND DICE THIS ISSUE
WHAT THERE ARE FEW THINGS THAT
NEED TO BE CALLED OUT ABOUT
THIS AND CLEAR FOR PEOPLE THAT
ARE WATCHING AND FOR THE RECORD
AND -- BASICALLY THERE'S BEEN
SOME CONFUSION BECAUSE WE HAVE
A FLEX ALERT NOW THIS IS ABOUT
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE THIS IS NOT ABOUT
THE NEXT THREE YEARS THIS IS
ABOUT WHERE WE WOULD BE FROM
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE TO TWENTY
THIRTY AND MANY OF ASKED WHY DO
WE HAVE TO DO THIS NOW WHAT Y.
ON SHORT NOTICE END OF SESSION
DO WE HAVE TO DO THIS AND AS
WAS MENTIONED -- THE ANSWERS IT
FROM THE ADMINISTRATION IS THAT
THERE'S A DEADLINE TO APPLY FOR
FEDERAL FUNDS THAT WILL PASS
IN THE NEXT WEEK AND WITHOUT
THOSE FUNDS THE EXTENSION IS
NOT POSSIBLE WITHOUT A SUBSIDY
FROM THE GENERAL FUND OR THE
RATE PAYERS SO IN SHORT WE
HAVE A SMALL WINDOW TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THE ONE TIME
FUNDING THERE ARE A WHOLE
LITANY OF ISSUES THE TIMING
OF THIS THE NECESSITY WHO PAYS
THE DATE CERTAIN FOR CLOSURE
HOW THE PERMITTING WOULD BE
DONE THE COMMUNITY TRANSITION
FUNDING THAT THIS BODY ADOPTED
IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN EIGHTEEN
SENATORS ON THIS FOR VOTED
FOR THAT SEISMIC SAFETY ISSUE
THE DISPOSITION OF THE TWELVE
THOUSAND ACRES OF DIABLO LANDS
AROUND THE PLANT AND WHAT I
HAVE CALLED THE MARSHALL PLAN
BECAUSE EITHER WAY EITHER WAY
WHETHER DAM BLOW WAS CONTINUED
OR NOT CONTINUE TO WORK HERE
BECAUSE THERE WAS NOT ENOUGH
PLANNING OR RENEWABLE ENERGY
BROUGHT ONLINE WE NEED THAT
WHETHER DAY OUT BLOW WAS
APPROVED TONIGHT WE NEED IT
WHETHER IT IS NOT EITHER WAY
WE NEED A MARSHALL PLAN OF
RENEWABLE ENERGY SO IF YOU LOOK
AT THIS BILL I I I I BELIEVE
THAT ALMOST ALL THE ISSUES ARE
LINED OUT AT THE END OF AUGUST
TWELFTH WORKSHOP WERE SEVEN
HUNDRED PEOPLE ATTENDED MOST OF
THEM CONSTITUENTS OF MINE ARE
SPLIT VERY DRAMATICALLY ON THIS
ISSUE -- I WAIT OUT THE ISSUES
THAT NEEDED TO BE ADDRESSED
IN THIS BILL AND THE MAYBE A
LITTLE TO MY AMAZEMENT ALMOST
EVERY SINGLE ONE IS ADDRESS
THOSE CONCERNS HAVE SHAPED THIS
BILL THE PROPOSAL ONLY DOES
THE MINIMUM THINGS NECESSARY
RIGHT NOW TO PROCEED IT DOES
THE -- PROVES THAT LONG FOR
THE APPLICATION AND APPROVES
AND DIRECTS THE P.
YOU SEE FOR A FIVE YEAR WINDOW
OF PLANNING TO BE ABLE TO
CONTINUE DIABLO CANYON THERE
ARE THIS BILL PROVIDES FOR
REGULAR ENERGY RELIABILITY
REPORTS SO THAT WE CAN JUDGE ON
AN ONGOING BASIS WHETHER OR NOT
WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE GRID
MEETS OUR NEEDS AND WE CAN PLAN
ACCORDINGLY THERE ARE REPORTS
THAT DON'T EXIST OTHERWISE THE
BILL ALLOWS FOR AN EXTENSION
OF UP TO FIVE YEARS THAT IS
VERY SIGNIFICANT BECAUSE IF
THE OFFSHORE WIND THAT IS
TARGETED OFF THE COAST OF SAN
LUIS OBISPO COMES ONLINE AND
IT'S PROJECTED TWENTY TWENTY
NINE OR TWENTY THIRTY THE
TRANSMISSION FROM THE DIAB LOW
CANYON NUCLEAR POWER PLANT IS
REALLY COUNTED ON TO PUT THAT
OFFSHORE WIND ONTO THE GRID AND
THE EXTENDED PLANT CAN'T GET
IN THE WAY OF THAT THIS BILL
LIMITED TO UP TO FIVE YEARS
SO THAT THAT TRANSITION TO
OFFSHORE WIND WILL BE THERE THE
ONE POINT FOUR BILLION DOLLAR
LOAN WHICH WAS RELEASED IN
LANGUAGE BY THE ADMINISTRATION
A FEW WEEKS AGO WAS SUBJECT OF
A LOT OF DISCUSSION AND THAT
LOAN IN THIS BILL IS SCORED
WITH AN EQUAL AMOUNT OF REVENUE
SO IF THERE'S A ONE POINT FOUR
BILLION DOLLAR LOAN THAT IS
RECEIVED IT WILL BE SCORED
WITH ONE POINT FOUR BILLION
DOLLARS OF REVENUE AND THERE
WILL BE NO RISK TO THE RATE
PAYER OR TO THE TAXPAYERS AND
HOW THAT'S DONE NOT ONLY THAT
THIS BILL SAYS ONLY APPROPRIATE
IN THE YEAR WHAT IS NECESSARY
FOR THE FIRST STRUCTURE OF
THAT LOAN THREE HUNDRED AND
FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS WITH SOME
FROM FLEXIBILITY TO GO PAST
IT IN CASE IT'S MORE RATHER
THAN THE FULL ONE POINT FOUR
BILLION THAT IS PART OF JUST
DOING WHAT WE NEED TO DO RIGHT
NOW TO SEE WHERE WE ARE IN
JANUARY AND SEE IF IN FACT THE
ELIGIBILITY IS GRANTED FOR THIS
LONG THERE WAS ALSO A PROVISION
HERE THAT SAYS THAT -- NO
PROCEEDS FROM THE LONG CAN
GO TO PG&AMP;E SHAREHOLDERS THAT
IT IS PROTECTED FROM MAKING
A PROFIT OFF ALONE THAT IS IN
THIS BILL AND IN THAT BILL ONE
TWENTY EIGHTEEN THAT EIGHTEEN
PEOPLE ON THIS FLOOR VOTED FOR
IT IT ACCEPTED THE SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT TO WHICH P.
JEANNIE NEGOTIATED IN TWENTY
SIXTEEN AND THAT SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT WHICH LED TO THE
CLOSURE DATE OF TWENTY TWENTY
FIVE MANY STAKEHOLDERS AND THAT
PROCESS DIDN'T WANT THE PLANT
TO STAY OPEN THAT LONG BUT
THEY MADE MAJOR CONCESSIONS TO
ACCEPT THE TWENTY TWENTY FIVE
DAY THAT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
WAS ENSHRINED BY THAT LAW
BUT IT ALSO APPROPRIATED OVER
EIGHTY MILLION DOLLARS IN
TRANSITION FONG SAID IS GONE
TO WORKERS AND ENTITIES IN
SAN LUIS OBISPO COUNTY THERE'S
A QUESTION ABOUT NOW THAT IT
MIGHT BE EXTENDED WEATHER THAT
HAS TO BE PAID BACK THIS BILL
CLARIFIES THAT IT SAYS IT DOES
NOT HAVE TO BE PAID BACK AND AT
THE SAME TIME THIS IS A WOULD
BE REFUNDED AT A LATER DATE
WHEN THE PLANT ACTUALLY D.
COMMISSIONS -- ALSO THERE
WAS A BIG CONCERN ABOUT THE
REGULATORY AGENCIES IN THIS
IN PARTICULAR THE COASTAL
COMMISSION THE GOVERNOR'S
FIRST PROPOSAL WOULD HAVE
OVERRIDDEN THE LAND USE
REGULATIONS PARTICULARLY WITH
OUR COASTAL COMMISSION AND
WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS -- I
TALKED IN THAT WORKSHOP ABOUT
THE FACT THAT THERE'S A FINE
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN OUR OVER
RIDING AN AGENCY AND SPEEDING
UP THE PROCESS THIS BILL
DOES NOT OVERRIDE THE COASTAL
COMMISSION'S AUTHORITY BUT
GIVES IT A PERIOD OF TIME
IN WHICH THAT ACT THAT IS
THREADING THE NEEDLE IN THE
CORRECT WAY AND THERE ARE REAL
CONCERNS THE LEGISLATURE PASSED
A BILL FIFTEEN YEARS AGO THAT
SAID THERE HAD TO BE MORE WORK
DONE ON SEISMIC SAFETY WITH
NO FAULTS BEING DISCOVERED
NEAR THIS A PLAN WIND BOTH
THE DEFERRED MAINTENANCE AND
THE SEISMIC SAFETY WORK WAS
NOT FULLY ACCEPTED BECAUSE
THE POINT WAS GOING TO CLOSE
IN TWENTY TWENTY FIVE IT AND
THOSE ARE REAL CONCERNS AND SO
NOW WE'RE SPECIALLY WITH THE
FORTY YEAR LIFE OF A PLANT SO
NOW THIS BILL SAYS THAT THERE
WILL BE INDEPENDENT WORKED ON
ON SEISMIC SAFETY ON DEFERRED
MAINTENANCE THOSE REPORTS WILL
COME AND THEY'LL BE DECISION
ABOUT WHETHER WORK HAS TO BE
DONE -- BECAUSE OF THAT IN
THIS BILL ADDITIONALLY THERE
WERE WORKERS THAT WERE MAKING
THEIR DECISIONS ON RETIREMENT
WHAT TO DO BASED ON A TWENTY
TWENTY FIVE CLOSER RETIREMENTS
OF STARTED OTHERS ARE PLANNED
AND THIS BILL CONTINUES THE
DIFFERENTIAL TO WORKERS TO
INCENT THEM TO STAY TILL THE
END OF THE LIFE OF THE PLANT
IT ADDRESSES THAT ISSUE OF THE
WORKERS AND THERE IS TWELVE
THOUSAND ACRES OF SOME OF THE
MOST BEAUTIFUL ECOLOGICALLY
SENSITIVE UNDEVELOPED LAND
IN THE CALIFORNIA COAST
SURROUNDING TABLEAU CANYON
THIS BILL SETS UP A PROCESS
FOR MAKING SURE THAT PERMANENT
PROTECTION OF THAT PLANT
POSSIBLE EASEMENT A CAN BE
PUT ON IT IN THE ONCE THROUGH
COOLING PLANT THAT ONCE TO
COOLING PART OF THIS PAYS
MITIGATION FEES THIS BILL
WILL EXTEND THE MITIGATION
FEES RAISE THEM FOR FIVE YEARS
AND EVEN THOUGH IT SLIPPED
OUT AT THE LAST MINUTE AND
THE GOVERNOR'S COMMITTED TO
PUT FIX THIS IN JANUARY THERE
WAS AN AGREEMENT THAT THE
ADDITIONAL MITIGATION MONIES
OVER THE CURRENT LEVEL WOULD
GO TO HELP WITH THE PURCHASE
AND PROTECTION OF THOSE DAY
ARE BLOWN LANDS WE WILL FIX
THAT IN JANUARY BUT THAT WAS
IN AGREEMENT AS PART OF THIS
BILL BUT I THINK OVER ALL
THE REAL IMPORTANT THING HERE
IS THAT THIS BILL I CRY AS
I MENTIONED EARLIER I HAVE
CALLED FOR A MARSHALL PLAN OF
RENEWABLE ENERGY WE NEED IT
WHETHER DAY ABLOH CONTINUES
OR NOT THIS BILL CONTAINS OVER
ONE POINT ONE BILLION DOLLARS
TO KICKSTART ALTERNATIVE
ENERGY IN CALIFORNIA AND IT
THIS DELEGATES THE ENERGY
COMMISSION TO RETURN WITH A
PLAN ON HOW THAT ONE POINT ONE
BILLION WILL BE EXTENDED AND
WE KNOW THAT THEY NEED TO TAKE
INTO ACCOUNT WHAT CAN PRODUCE
THE MOST ENERGY WHAT CAN BE
BROUGHT ON QUICKEST WHAT MIGHT
GENERATE A MATCHING FUNDS IN A
WAY THAT WHAT PEOPLE SAID AND
I JUST LISTEN TO THE ASSEMBLY
DEBATE ABOUT WHAT WE HAVE NOT
DONE THIS BILL WILL INCENTIVE
WHAT WE NEED TO DO SO I THINK
THEY'RE STILL SIGNIFICANT TASKS
WE HAVE TO SEE WHERE WE STAND
IN JANUARY WITH THESE MEASURES
THAT AREN'T THE COMPLETE
MEASURES WE HAVE TO MAYBE HAVE
HEARINGS IN THE FALL WHEN WE'RE
NOT UNDER THE GUN ON RENEWABLE
ENERGY AND AND WHAT THE STATUS
IS AND TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE
THE REPORTS THAT ARE REQUIRED
BY THE BY THIS BILL BUT BASED
ON ALL THIS I'M ONLY DOING
WHAT IS NECESSARY NOW DOING OUR
BEST TO PROTECT TAXPAYERS AND
RATEPAYERS ASSESSMENT SEISMIC
SAFETY AND DEFERRED MAINTENANCE
ADDRESSING THE LOCAL CONCERN
ON A HOST OF ISSUES AND MAKING
A STRONG INITIAL INVESTMENT
ON A MARSHALL PLAN FOR NOBLE
ENERGY IS THE REASON WHY I
WILL CAST IN HIGH VOTE IN A
VERY TROUBLED ISSUE AND I KNOW
THIS WILL CONCERN A LOT OF
MY CONSTITUENTS WHO DISAGREE
BUT OUR I HAVE WORKED HARD
TO LISTEN TO THEM AND I THINK
WE WILL CONTINUE TO LISTEN
TO THEM AS WE SEE HOW THIS
PROCESS UNFOLDS THANK YOU
CENTER LAYERED CENTER DOLLY
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
MEMBERS I KNOW IT'S
VERY LATE IN THE EVENING
AND I KNOW THAT --
THAT WE DON'T HAVE A DEADLINE
THIS BILL IS AFTER THE TWELVE
O'CLOCK AND I I WANT TO START
OUT BY GIVING A LITTLE BIT
OF HISTORY I KNOW MY GOOD
FRIEND THE CENTER FROM CENTER
NOT VALLEY TALKED ABOUT THIS
EARLIER SO WE'RE GONNA DO A
LITTLE WALK AROUND HISTORY
LANE HERE IN TWO THOUSAND SIX
WE HAD AB THIRTY TWO WHICH WAS
THE FAMILY BILL WHICH CREATED
THE GREENHOUSE GAS LEVELS TO
NINETEEN NINETY IT AND THAT
WAS MOVING US FORWARD TO SET
THE STAGE FOR THE WORLD IN
TWO THOUSAND EIGHT WE HAD
PROPOSITION ONE WHICH WAS THE
HIGH SPEED RAIL BOND WHICH
WAS NINE BILLION DOLLARS
APPROVED BY THE VOTERS TO
REDUCE CARBON IN CALIFORNIA
WE HAVE NOT LAID ONE FOOT A
TRACK FOR THIS HIGH SPEED RAIL
IT WAS ESTIMATED TO BE THIRTY
THREE MILLION DOLLARS AND NOW
SAYS THAT SB TO BE A HUNDRED
AND FIVE MILLION DOLLARS AND IT
WILL NOT AT THE END OF THE DAY
REDUCING CARBON IN TWO THOUSAND
FIFTEEN WE HAD SB THREE
FIFTY DALY ON WHICH MY GOOD
FRIEND TALKED ABOUT EARLIER
THE RP A STANDARD TO REQUIRE
FIFTY PERCENT RETAIL SALES
OF ELECTRICITY FROM ELIGIBLE
RENEWABLE ENERGY FOR SOURCES
BY DECEMBER TWENTY THIRTY
IN TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN ARE
THEN GOVERNOR WAS LIEUTENANT
GOVERNOR AND HE WAS HEAD OF
THE COASTAL COMMISSION AND
WE STARTED TALKING ABOUT
DECOMMISSIONING DIABLO CANYON
BECAUSE WHY NOT BECAUSE IT
WASN'T GREEN POWER BECAUSE
IT WAS NUCLEAR POWER SOME OF
US SAID MAYBE WE SHOULD KEEP
THAT GOING AND TAKE OFF THE
LINE OF GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS
CALIFORNIA BUT NO THE GOVERNOR
ONE TO MOVE FORTH BECAUSE THE
LANDS COMMISSION TALKED ABOUT
ONCE THROUGH COOLING I KNOW
THIS IS GETTING IN THE WEEDS
A LITTLE BIT BUT DIABLO CANYON
IS ONCE THROUGH COOLING ALONG
WITH GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS IN
CALIFORNIA SO IN TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN PG&AMP;E ANNOUNCES THEY'RE
NOT GOING TO RENEW DAY ABA
CANYON THE RATE PAYERS KEEP
IN MIND THE RATEPAYERS CAUSES
A TEAM HERE FOUR AND A HALF
BILLION DOLLARS IN RATES TO
DECOMMISSION DIABLO IN TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN WE HAD THE
MORNING BILL WHICH MY GOOD
FRIEND FROM SANTA CRUZ TALKED
ABOUT AND WE MADE SURE WE
TOOK CARE OF THE COMMUNITY
BECAUSE THEY'RE GOING TO
DECOMMISSION DIABLO AND WE
SPENT EIGHTY MILLION DOLLARS
MAKING SURE THE WORKERS WERE
TAKEN CARE OF AND THE COMMUNITY
CPUC ANNOUNCES THAT WE'RE GONNA
SHUT DIABLO CANYON DOWN IN TWO
THOUSAND AND SIXTEEN SB THIRTY
TWO PAVLEY REDUCES GREENHOUSE
GASES BY FORTY PERCENT BELOW
THE NINETEEN NINETY LEVELS BY
TWENTY THIRTY AGAIN ANOTHER
TARGET WHAT'S THE THEME HERE
WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT
TARGETS WE'VE BEEN TALKING
ABOUT HOW WE'RE GONNA GET THERE
IN TWENTY TWENTY TWO SB TEN
TWENTY LAYERED NINETY PERCENT
RENEWABLE ENERGY AND ZERO
COVERED BY TWENTY THIRTY FIVE
I NINETY FIVE PERCENT
BLOW TWENTY FORTY LEVELS
AND A HUNDRED PERCENT OF
ELECTRICITY IN CALIFORNIA
BY TWENTY FORTY FIVE
JUST TONIGHT WE HAD S.
B.
-- YEAH S.
B.
TWENTY ONE THIRTY THREE
-- AB CORK DID YOU FIFTY
FIVE THANK GOD IT DIED YES
DEBT OVER THE OTHER HOUSE
WE HAVE BUDGET TRAILER BILL
TO REOPEN POWER PLANTS JUST A
COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO BECAUSE
WE HAVE AN ENERGY SHORTAGE
WILL BE DEBT WHAT WE'VE BEEN
DOING FOR THE LAST SIXTEEN
YEARS BESIDES SETTING GOALS AND
DESTROYING RATES IN CALIFORNIA
THAT'S WHAT WE'VE BEEN DOING
NOW I KNOW THIS LATE IN THE
NIGHT AND CALIFORNIANS ARE
SLEEPING AND THEY DON'T KNOW
WHAT'S GOING ON IN THIS HOUSE
BUT WHAT WE GOT OVERALL WHAT
ARE THE REALLY CHEAP WE'VE
CHANGED NOTHING OTHER THAN
HIGHER RATES AND CALIFORNIA'S
GOALS WE WE SET GOALS WE SPEND
MONEY ON TARGETS AND WE FAIL
THIS IS A TOTAL FAILURE AND
NOW WE'RE IN A CRISIS WHY
BECAUSE IN TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
THE POWER PLANT IS GOING TO BE
SHUT DOWN SO WE HAVE CREATED
THIS CRISIS BY NO PLANNING A
THEME I'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT
TONIGHT ON EVERY SINGLE BILL
AND WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN PG&AMP;E
IS PUT THE GOVERNOR IN A BOX
WHAT THEY'RE GONNA GET THEIR
MONEY THEY PUT HIM IN A BOX
AND HE HAS TO DO SO THE BECAUSE
IN TWENTY TWENTY FOUR WHEN THE
CROWD WENT NUTS DOWN AND IT'S
EIGHT POINT NINE PERCENT OF
CALIFORNIA'S ENERGY THERE'S
NOT GONNA BE ENERGY ON HAS
NOTHING TO DO IT TODAY THAT'S
TO DO WITH TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
AND IT HAS TO DO WITH PGA
ALLOWING TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
THE RATE PAYERS ONCE AGAIN I
NOT ONLY JUST PG&AMP;E CUSTOMERS
THIS TIME BUT EVERYONE OF YOU
WHO IS IN ANOTHER I OWE YOU
OR OR A MUNICIPALITY IS GOING
TO PAY THE RATES ARE GOING UP
ON CALIFORNIANS AND I DON'T
KNOW ABOUT YOU BUT THE COST
ACROSS OUR STATE IS SEVENTY
SIX PERCENT HIGHER THAN ANY
OTHER STATE SO WHAT IT WHAT
IS HAPPENED WHAT BOXED IN AND
WHAT IS HE DONE HE'S PAID OFF
HE'S BOUGHT OFF ALL THE MEMBERS
THAT DON'T LIKE NUCLEAR GIVING
YOU SOMETHING FOR YOUR DISTRICT
PROMISING YOU SOMETHING THAT
HE WILL NEVER DELIVER YOU'RE
NOT GONNA HAVE NGUYEN IN TEN
YEARS ON THE OCEAN GUARANTEED
YOU CAN GET TO THE PREP PROCESS
AND IT WON'T HAPPEN THIS CRISIS
IS CREATED BY A GOVERNOR AND
A LEGISLATURE THAT HAS NO PLAN
SORRY FOR YELLING AT YOU BUT
FOR GOD'S SAKE LET'S HAVE A
PLAN AND NOW WE'RE CRAZY WHAT'S
HAPPENING TO CALIFORNIANS
THEY'RE GETTING DESTROYED
BECAUSE THEIR ENERGY RATES ARE
HIGH THEY'RE LEAVING CALIFORNIA
AND WE'RE SUPPOSED TO SET THE
MODEL FOR THE WORLD WE'VE BEEN
TALKING ABOUT IT ALL NIGHT WITH
ALL THESE GOALS AND NOW YOU
WANT ME TO COME AND BAIL OUT
THE GOVERNOR NO WE DON'T HAVE
TO DO THIS IN ANY TIME THAT
POWER PLANTS ON YOUR SET UP
FOR TWO YEARS NOBODY'S GONNA
LOSE THEIR JOB WHAT'S GOING TO
HAPPEN THOUGH IS THE P.
JEANNIE AND THE RATE THEY'RE
GONNA LEVERAGE THE GOVERNOR
WHICH THEY'RE DOING RIGHT NOW
THEY'LL GO THAT THEY CAN GO
FILE THAT REPORT WITHOUT ANY
LEGISLATION THEY CAN TURNOUT
PLANT BACK ON SEPTEMBER
SIX WHY WOULD DAY WHY WOULD
THEY DO THAT WHEN THEY CAN
LEVERAGE YOU TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
THIS LEGISLATURE GET BECAUSE
WE'RE WE DON'T DO A GOOD
JOB OF BREAKING A PLAN WE'RE
SHUTTING DOWN ASSETS WE NEED
IN CALIFORNIA WE HAVE ENERGY
SHORTAGE AND YOU'RE YOU'RE ON
THE HOOK FOR NO I'M NOT GONNA
DO THAT I'M NOT GOING TO RAISE
THE RATES ON CALIFORNIANS
ACROSS THE BOARD NOT JUST P.
JEANNIE HONORE'S RATES
I'M NOT GOING TO BILL THE
GOVERNOR OUT WE HAVE TIME
TWO YEARS BEFORE THAT PLANT
SHUTDOWN BUT HERE WE ARE AT
ONE O'CLOCK IN THE MORNING
ON THE LAST NIGHT OF SESSION
AFTER WE JUST GOT HIS WHOLE
CLIMATE PLAN WITH NO PLAN PUT
OUT AND YOU'RE GOING TO BAIL
HIM OUT AND YOU'RE GONNA MAKE
CALIFORNIANS STOPPER AS HIGHER
RATES AS AND ALL RIGHT -- YEAH
WELL BY THE WAY P.
GINNY INVESTORS ARE GOING TO
GET ANY BENEFIT FROM IT VS
THEY GET FIFTEEN PERCENT OF
ALL ELECTRICITY GOES THROUGH
THEIR WHEN THEY CUT A TREE DOWN
THEY CHARGE FIFTEEN PERCENT
TO MAKE NO MISTAKE CALIFORNIA
RATEPAYERS WERE ARE GOING TO
PAY AND YOU'RE GONNA BELUM OUT
YOU'RE GONNA GET THE GOVERNOR
PASSED BECAUSE HE WANT TO SHUT
THIS THING DOWN IN TWO THOUSAND
SIXTEEN AND TALK ABOUT HOW
YOU SAVE THE CLIMATE WE'RE NOT
SAVING THE CLIMATE NO I LOVE
THE WORKERS THERE MY BROTHER
IN LAW WAS IN THE GALLERY TO
DIE HE'S A WORKER AT THAT PLANT
NOT ABOUT THE WORKERS THEY'RE
GONNA WORK THAT PLANT WILL
NOT SHUT DOWN IT CAN'T SHUT
DOWN BECAUSE CALIFORNIA
WOULD BE ALL THE POWER
AND YOU'LL BE OUT OF A JOB
HEY IT'S TIME IT'S ONE O'CLOCK
IN THE MORNING THIS IS NOT
OUR CRISIS WE DID NOT CREATE
THIS CRISIS SOMEBODY ELSE
TO SET TARGETS THE CRISIS
AND YOU'RE GONNA BAIL HIM
OUT NOT ME AND YOU'LL ALSO
GET A BILL ABOUT THE RATE
PAYERS OF CALIFORNIA AND OUR
CONSTITUENTS NOT ON MY WATCH
I KNOW I'M GONNA STRONG TONIGHT
AND I KNOW YOU'RE SHAKING YOUR
HEAD OVER THERE SAY NO THAT'S
NOT TRUE IT'S TRUE WE HAVE NO
PLAN FOR RENEWABLE EACH YEAR
WE JUST SET TARGETS WE DO A
VICTORY LAP AND THEN THE DAY
CALIFORNIANS ARE SUFFERING AND
WE'RE NOT LEAVING THE WORLD
WE'RE JUST COST SHIFTING ALL OF
OUR STUFF TO SOME OTHER COUNTRY
WHERE THEY POLLUTE THE WORLD
THEY TAKE THEY DON'T TAKE CARE
OF THEIR WORKERS ALL THE THINGS
WE CARE ABOUT DO THE RIGHT
THING LET'S PUT THIS OFF THIS
MAKE PG&AMP;E STEP TO THE PLATE
LET'S HAVE A PLAN SO CALIFORNIA
RATES CAN GO DOWN I'M NOT
GONNA VOTE FOR THIS BILL
TONIGHT I'M A LAY OFF BECAUSE
I THINK WE NEED TO SPEND THE
TIME NOT AT ONE O'CLOCK IN THE
MORNING ON THE LAST NIGHT OF
SESSION ABOUT GAVIN NEWSOM'S
POOR PLANNING FOR THE STATE
THANK YOU MEMBERS THANK YOU
CENTER DOLLARS CENTER BORDERS
MY COLLEAGUE MADE AN
IMPASSIONED SPEECH WE CERTAINLY
RIGHT ONE O'CLOCK IN THE
MORNING SEPTEMBER FIRST AND
WE'RE EXHAUSTED ALL OF US WANT
TO GET HOME ALL OF US WANT
TO GET BACK TOWARD DISTRICTS
TOMORROW I'M BEFUDDLED THAT
WE HAVE A A MATTER OF SUCH
IMPORTANCE COMING AT US AT THIS
LATE HOUR AT THIS LATE DATE SO
I HAVE TO ASK MYSELF YOU KNOW
THERE'S A TRUISM FOR THOSE
OF YOU WHO SERVED IN LOCAL
POLITICS AT THE CITY OR THE
COUNTY LEVEL THAT BAD POLICY
IS MADE TO WIN LEGISLATORS
LEGISLATE FROM A POSITION OF
FEAR AND I'M CONCERNED THAT WE
ARE IN A POSITION NOT ONLY OF
EXHAUSTION BUT OUR FEAR AND OUR
LEGISLATING ON A VERY IMPORTANT
ISSUE WE HAVE TO ASK OURSELVES
WHAT EXACTLY ARE WE VOTING
ON IN WHICH ENTITIES ARE MOST
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE ACTIVITIES
THAT NEED TO BE ARE ARE DECIDED
UPON FOR A CONSEQUENCE THAT
LOOKS AFTER OUR RATE PAYERS IN
OUR STATE AS A WHOLE I'M GOING
TO FINISH UP THIS COMMENTARY
FAIRLY QUICKLY COLLEAGUES I'M
TIRED SO WERE YOU BUT I DO WANT
TO MAKE MAKE A FEW IMPORTANT
POINTS IF DIABLO CANYON IS NOT
GOING TO SHUTTER FOR A NUMBER
OF YEARS OVER TO AT THIS POINT
WHY ARE WE NECESSARILY DOING
IT ON SEPTEMBER FIRST AT ONE IN
THE MORNING COULD THIS NOT BE
PART OF A PROCESS THAT ALLOWS
US TO REVISIT THIS IN THE
NORMAL LEGISLATIVE CYCLE PROP
POSSIBLY STARTING IN JANUARY
NOW I HAVE HEARD THAT THERE
IS A DEADLINE OF SEPTEMBER OR
THE END OF IT -- SOMETIME THIS
MONTH THAT WE HAVE THE FILE
THIS PAPERWORK WHO FILES HIS
PAPERWORK MY UNDERSTANDING IS
THAT PG&AMP;E IS THE ENTITY MOST
RESPONSIBLE FOR FILING THIS
PAPERWORK IT'S NOT THE GOVERNOR
IT'S NOT THE PRO TEN IT'S NOT
THE LEGISLATURE IT'S NOT THE
SENATE OR THE ASSEMBLY BUT PG&AMP;E
PG&AMP;E ALSO MY UNDERSTANDING IS
THAT PG&AMP;E HAS THE AUTHORITY TO
FILE THIS RIGHT NOW ALL ON ITS
OWN SO THE QUESTION IS WHY ARE
WE DOING THIS RIGHT NOW ARE
THEY WAITING FOR A POLITICAL
ACTION TO GIVE THEM -- THE
OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE FORWARD
MY UNDERSTANDING IS NOW AND
THE REASON WHY I'M USING MY
UNDERSTANDING SO FREQUENTLY IS
BECAUSE THIS IS A LAST MINUTE
ITEM BROUGHT FOR WITH THE SENSE
OF URGENCY AND I WOULD VENTURE
TO SAY MOST IF NOT ALL OF US
HAVE A LOCKER CLARITY ON THIS
ISSUE NOT TO MENTION THE TIME
THE THE THE TIME TODAY SO IF
THIS IS IF THIS CANYON TO THE
DIABLO CAN CONTINUE TO OPERATE
UNTIL TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE
I'M HARD PRESSED TO BELIEVE
THAT ON SEPTEMBER FIRST AT
ONE AM WE MUST MAKE A DECISION
THAT SECOND I DON'T BELIEVE WE
ARE WE ARE AT THE END OF THE
MOST RESPONSIBLE FOR SUBMITTING
THIS APPLICATION -- THAT PG&AMP;E
IS THE ENTITY THAT CAN MAKE IT
HAPPEN THIRDLY THERE SOMETHING
THAT I HAVEN'T GONE BROUGHT
MY MY BRAIN AROUND COMPLETELY
IS THE FACT THAT -- DIABLO
CURRENTLY OPERATES AT A NET
PROFIT APPARENTLY A HUNDRED AND
FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS ANNUALLY
AND AN ALTERNATIVE REGION
HOWEVER MUST BE CONSTRUCTED TO
ENABLE DIABLO TO APPLY TO THIS
TO THE CIVIL NUCLEAR CREDIT
PROGRAMME BUT THEY CAN'T DO IT
UNLESS THEY'RE OPERATING IN A
NET LOSS IN THAT NEST NOT NET
DEBT NET LOSS IS WHAT IS THE
NAY BILLING THEM THE JUSTICE
LEGAL JUSTIFICATION TO SHUT
IT DOWN AND THEN BE ELIGIBLE
FOR SIX HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR
AMOUNT I'M SORRY COLLEAGUES
LET ME GET THIS STRAIGHT ITS
OPERATING AT A PROFIT BUT
IN ORDER FOR US TO QUALIFY
FOR FEDERAL FINANCING AND WE
MUST MANUFACTURE A DEFICIT
SO WE BORROWED THE MONEY TO
MANUFACTURE DEFICIT THAT ALLOWS
US TO CONTINUE TO EXPAND IT
INTO TWENTY FOUR OF TWENTY
FIVE AND BEYOND THIS IS I CAN
TELL YOU THIS IS PRETTY THIS
IS PRETTY INTERESTING AND AND
REMARKABLE THAT WE HAVE TO
OPERATE AT A FINANCIAL LOSS TO
DEMONSTRATE OUR CAPABILITIES
OF BEING ELIGIBLE FOR FOR
THESE DOLLARS WHICH GETS BACK
TO MY ULTIMATE POINT IS IT'S
ONE AFTER ONE IN THE MORNING
THERE IS NO REASON THAT I
HAVE HEARD AND MAYBE THERE
WILL BE SUBSEQUENT SPEAKERS
BUT THERE'S NO REASON I HAVE
HEARD THAT WE MUST MAKE THIS
DECISION NOW AND THAT WE ARE
THE ENERGY MOST RESPONSIBLE TO
MOVE THE APPLICATION FORWARD
IN THIS TIMELINE AND THAT THIS
TIMELINE WOULD DISALLOW US TO
APPLY AND SUBMIT IN SUBSEQUENT
MONTHS SO COLLEAGUES NONE OF
US WANT TO HAVE BLACKOUTS IN
OUR IN OUR COMMUNITY WE HAVE
UNDERSTOOD THAT UKRAINE AND
OUR OUR EXUBERANCE TOWARD
ALTERNATIVE ENERGIES HAS
CAUGHT HAVE OF CAUGHT US FLAT
FOOTED IN OUR ABILITY TO DEAL
WITH THE REALITY NOW WE WANT
TO ELECTRIFY WE WANT TO --
TO INVEST IN IN -- IN ALL
SORTS OF ALTERNATIVE ENERGY
WE'RE JUST NOT THERE YET SO
WE HAVE TO DEFAULT TO WHAT
IS AVAILABLE NOW IN A CLOSE
TO NINE OR TEN PERCENT OF
OUR INFRASTRUCTURE ENERGY IS
COMING FROM HERE SO WE GOT TO
GO BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD
BUT IF THAT'S THE CASE WHAT
IS THE URGENCY COLLEAGUES
THANK YOU CENTER BORDERS
SENATOR JONES THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT MEMBERS SENATE
BILL EIGHT FORTY SIX DOES
TWO THINGS IT EXTENDS THE
LIFE OF THE ABA CANYON AND IT
RAISES RATE PAYER RATES FOR
ELECTRICITY AND IT'S REALLY A
SHAME THAT THE BEST SOLUTION
WE COULD COME UP WITH THE SAME
DIABLO CANYON IS TO INCREASE
ELECTRICITY RATES STATEWIDE
IN THE MIDST OF A RECESSION WE
NEED DIABLO CANYON THERE'S NO
DOUBT ABOUT THAT IT PRODUCES
RELIABLE AFFORDABLE AND CLEAN
ENERGY THAT GENERATES OVER
EIGHT PERCENT OF CALIFORNIA'S
ELECTRICITY INCLUDING SEVENTEEN
PERCENT OF THE STATE'S CARBON
FREE ELECTRICITY WE OFTEN
LOOK TO EUROPE FOR THEIR
CLIMATE FRIENDLY POLICIES WHEN
WORK CRAFTING OUR POLICIES
HERE IN CALIFORNIA DID
YOU KNOW THAT THE E.
U.
HAS ONE HUNDRED AND THREE
NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS IT
GENERATE TWENTY FIVE PERCENT
OF THEIR TOTAL ELECTRICITY
PRODUCED ME SAY THAT AGAIN THE
EUROPEAN UNION HAS ONE HUNDRED
AND THREE NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS
IT'S CLEAR NUCLEAR POWER IS THE
ANSWER TO MANY OF OUR PROBLEMS
RELATED TO EMISSIONS AND GRID
CAPACITY BUT WHAT HAPPENS IN
THE FORTHCOMING YEARS MONTHS
AND YEARS AFTER DIABLO CANYON
IS SHUT DOWN BUT WE HAVE AN
EXAMPLE TO LOOK AT ACTUALLY
WHAT THE SENATE -- FREE SHUT
DOWN IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
STANFORD DID UP THE -- YEAH
AFTER TWO THOUSAND TWELVE SHUT
DOWN STANFORD DID A RESEARCH
PROJECT ON SENATE -- FREE HENRY
REPORTED THAT NINE MILLION
TONS OF CARBON DIOXIDE PER
YEAR WERE RELEASED INTO THE
ATMOSPHERE FROM GAS POWER
PLANTS STRUGGLING TO KEEP UP
WITH THE POWER THAT CENTENO
FREE PRODUCE IMMEDIATELY
FOLLOWING THE SHUTDOWN OF SANTA
NO FREE THERE WAS THREE HUNDRED
AND FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS OF
INCREASING COSTS TO SWITCH
TO NATURAL GAS THERE WAS A
WAVE OF HIGHER ENERGY BILLS
ACROSS SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
UP UNTIL TWO THOUSAND TWELVE
EMISSIONS IN CALIFORNIA HAD
BEEN ON A STEADY DECLINE AFTER
TWO THOUSAND TWELVE AND FOR
THE NEXT FOUR YEARS THERE
WAS AN INCREASE OF EMISSIONS
GENERATED BY THE ADDITIONAL
ELECTRICAL GENERATION TO MAKE
UP FOR SENATE -- FREE THIRTY
SEVEN MILLION TONS OF CARBON
DIOXIDE IN FOUR YEARS FOLLOWING
THE SHUTDOWN OF SENATE -- FREE
THIRTY THREE PERCENT DROP IN
CLEAN ENERGY GENERATION FIVE
BILLION DOLLARS SO FAR IN
THE TEAR DOWN AND CLEAN UP OF
SENATE -- FREE AND GUESS WHAT'S
HAPPENING TODAY GAS POWER
PLANTS RUN GAS POWER PLANTS RUN
BUT THE WAY THIS BILL IS
WRITTEN DIABLO CANYON CAN
STAY OPEN AT THE EXPENSE OF
STRUGGLING CALIFORNIANS TRYING
TO MAKE ENDS MEET IN THE MIDST
OF A RECESSION CALIFORNIA
HAS ALMOST A BILLION DOLLARS
SURPLUS INSTEAD OF INCREASING
COSTS FOR CALIFORNIANS WE
COULD USE A SMALL FRACTION OF
OUR SURPLUS THE KEEP DIABLO
CANYON OPEN WITHOUT AFFECTING
REPAIRS IN ADDITION TO OUR
SURPLUS CONGRESS HAS PROVIDED
SIX BILLION DOLLARS IN FUNDING
TO PREVENT THE NATION'S
REMAINING NUCLEAR PAT PLANTS
FROM CLOSING AS ONE OF THE
LARGEST STATES IN THE COUNTRY
THERE IS NO REASON WHY WE CAN'T
LEVERAGE SOME OF THESE FUNDS
TO KEEP DOUBLE CANYON OPEN I
SUPPORT DIABLO CANYON I THINK
IT SHOULD STAY OPEN I THINK WE
SHOULD KEEP GENERATING CLEAN
ENERGY FROM DIABLO CANYON
BUT I CAN'T SUPPORT A RATE
HIKE ON MY CONSTITUENTS IN
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA WHO ALREADY
PAY THE HIGHEST ELECTRICAL
RATES IN THE COUNTRY TELL ME
ASK YOU THIS COLLEAGUES AS
YOU'RE MAKING YOUR DECISION
TO SUPPORT THIS BILL OR NOT
SUPPORT THIS BILL AS I SAID
IT DOES TWO THINGS HEY KIDS
KEEPS DIABLO CANYON OPEN AND IT
RAISES ENERGY RATES IF YOU'RE
A DISTRICT AND I UNDERSTAND
THAT THERE'S A HANDFUL OF
DISTRICTS IN CALIFORNIA THAT
SUPPORT SHUTTING DOWN DIABLO
CANYON LET'S CALL THOSE ANTI
NUCLEAR DISTRICTS IF YOU
REPRESENT AN ANTI NUCLEAR
DISTRICT AND YOU VOTE FOR
THIS BILL DO YOU TELL YOUR
CONSTITUENTS I VOTED TO KEEP
NUCLEAR GOING IN CALIFORNIA
FOR SOME OF US REPRESENT
STRUGGLING ECONOMICALLY
STRUGGLING DISTRICTS THEY'RE
ALREADY HAVING A HARD TIME
PAYING THEIR ELECTRIC BILLS
THIS IS IMPACTING MY MY I HAVE
A SIX HUNDRED DOLLAR ELECTRIC
BILL THIS SUMMER AT MY HOUSE
CAN YOU VOTE FOR THIS BILL AND
INCREASE THEIR RATES HOW DO YOU
GO BACK TO YOUR CONSTITUENTS
AND SAY I HAVE YOUR BEST
INTERESTS IN MIND WHEN I'M
VOTING FOR THESE ISSUES
AND CALIFORNIA I UNDERSTAND
IS THE CATCH TWENTY TWO
BEST SOME OF OUR LIVES PRIOR
SPEAKERS HAVE MENTIONED WE'RE
NOT THE ONES THAT PUT OURSELVES
IN THIS SITUATION MEMBERS I
ASKED FOR A NO VOTE THANK YOU
SENATOR JOHNSON -- STERN THANK
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I I HAPPEN
TO REPRESENT ONE OF THOSE
ANTI NUCLEAR DISTRICTS MMHM
WHERE WHERE THE HOME IN IN
THE SIMI VALLEY AREA TO ONE OF
THE LARGEST NUCLEAR MELTDOWNS
IN STATE HISTORY THE SANTA
SUSANA FIELD LABORATORY WE'VE
HAD PEOPLE DIRECTLY INJURED
BY MISMANAGED RADIATION
I THINK WE NEED TO PASS THIS
LEGISLATION TONIGHT TO OBVIATE
THE NEED TO RE OPEN THE OUTLOOK
TO MOVE OURSELVES FASTER TO
RETIRING THIS BILL DOES NOT
REQUIRE THE DIABLO BE EXTENDED
TO REOPEN IT OFFERS A CHALLENGE
TO CALIFORNIA A RACE IF YOU
WILL TO SEE WHAT CAN FILL
THE GAP MY MONEY IS ON CLEAN
ENERGY WE'VE ADDED IN THE LAST
TWO YEARS THREE NUCLEAR POWER
PLANTS WORTH OF ENERGY STORAGE
THAT ARE LITERALLY ON RIGHT NOW
KEEPING THE GREAT A LOT BATTERY
STORAGE ONLINE NOW THREE
NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS WORTH IN
THE LAST TWO YEARS IF YOU WANT
TO BET AGAINST INNOVATION AND
ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN THAT GROWTH
IF WE KEEP UP THAT PACE WE WILL
NOT NEED DIABLO OR GAS PLANTS
BUT I BELIEVE IN THE FRAMEWORK
IN THIS LEGISLATION THAT MY
COLLEAGUE FROM SANTA CRUZ SO
ABLY DESCRIBED BECAUSE THE
OFF RAMPS THAT HAVE BEEN BUILT
INTO THIS BILL ARE VERY REAL
NOW READ YOU DIRECTLY FROM THE
LEGISLATION IF THE COMMISSION
DETERMINES THAT NEW RENEWABLE
ENERGY IN ZERO CARBON RESOURCES
ARE ADEQUATE TO SUBSTITUTE
FOR DIABLO CANYON POWER PLANT
THE COMMISSION THEY REVERT TO
THE ORIGINAL RETIREMENT DATE
WE CANNOT AFFORD TO WAIT IN
THAT RACE THE BILLION DOLLARS
MORE THAT'S BEING PUT TOWARDS
THIS MARSHALL PLAN AND THE
RACE TO FILL THAT GAP WITH
NON NUCLEAR MEANS THAT'S
IN THIS BILL TO YES IT DOES
PRESERVE THE OPTION THAT
WE BORROW FEDERAL DOLLARS
NOT ON THE RATE BASE BUT WE
USE FEDERAL DOLLARS TO KEEP
DIABLO ONLINE BUT I THINK THEY
CALIFORNIA'S INNOVATION IS
GOING TO OBVIATE THAT NEEDS
THE QUARTERLY REPORTS THAT
START THIS YEAR THEY WERE
NEGOTIATING THIS BILL AND
WE'RE GONNA BE HEARING FROM THE
ENERGY COMMISSION THE PUBLIC
UTILITIES COMMISSION I WE
HOPE WE'RE GOING TO BE HOLDING
HEARINGS ON I THINK WE'RE GOING
TO HEAR VERY GOOD NEWS FIVE
HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE MEGAWATTS
TWO WEEKS AGO CONNECTED TO
THE GRID CLEAN ENERGY ON
FEDERAL LAND IN CALIFORNIA
THREE HUNDRED FIFTY MEGAWATTS
THE WEEK BEFORE THAT THAT'S
ALMOST A GIGAWATT OF CLEAN
ENERGY IN THE LAST TWO WEEKS
SO IF YOU'RE BETTING AGAINST
INNOVATION AND YOU WANT TO
BET AGAINST CALIFORNIA GO
AHEAD THAT PESSIMISTIC VIEW
OF OUR FUTURE YOU'RE ENTITLED
BUT I AM OPTIMISTIC I WHAT I
LIKE ABOUT THIS LEGISLATION
AND WHY I'M COMFORTABLE EVEN
AS SOMEONE WHO REPRESENTS A
QUOTE ANTI NUCLEAR DISTRICTS
SOMEONE NEW WHO DOESN'T WANT
TO SEE DIABLO EXTENDED I
FEEL COMFORTABLE SUPPORTING
THIS LEGISLATION BECAUSE IT
JUMPSTART'S THAT CLEAN ENERGY
RACE I PUTS US ON A PATH TO
RESILIENCE RELIABILITY THEY
CAN SUSTAIN US FOR DECADES TO
COME SO WITH THAT PERSPECTIVE
I'LL BE CASTING MY VOTE AND I
HOPE YOU DO THE SAME THANK YOU
CENTER STERN MEMBERS FURTHER
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING
AND HEARING NONE SENATOR
JOHN WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
YES I I APPRECIATE THAT THE
DEBATE YEAH THE FACT THAT IT'S
LATE IS OF NO CONSEQUENCE AS
WE'VE KNOWN THIS WAS COMING
OUR WAY NOT FOR A LONG TIME
BUT WE KNOW THAT THIS COMING
OUR WAY FOR THREE OR FOUR WEEKS
IT'S REALLY INTERESTING THAT
WE HEAR THERE'S NO PLAN BUT YET
I'VE READ THE PLAN AND I HAVE
THE PLAN IN MY HEAD I READ IT
MY TALKING POINTS THERE IS A
PLAN THE GOVERNOR'S STAFF IS
LAID OUT HE'S LETTER THAT LAID
OUT TO THE DEMOCRATIC CAUCUS
HE'S LAID IT OUT TO IT IS
STAFF TO THE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS
PGD NEEDS AUTHORIZATION TO
HAVE THIS DONE SO I'M SORRY
TO THE SENATOR FROM FRESNO WHO
ASSERTS THEY CAN DO THIS ON
THEIR OWN I'M SORRY THEY CANNOT
THERE WE TALK ABOUT INCREASED
RATES FOR CALIFORNIANS THAT'S
VERY INTERESTING TO ME BECAUSE
YOU'VE ALL HAD THIS PIECE
OF PAPER YOU'VE ALL HAD THE
INFORMATION IN THE RATES EVEN
FOR PG&AMP;E PLAYERS IT'S LIKE
THE MAXIMUM INCREASE WOULD
BE FIFTY SEVEN CENTS A MONTH
INCREASE TWO OF FIVE DOLLARS
AND FORTY THREE FIVE DOLLARS
AND FORTY THREE CENT DECREASE
DEPENDING UPON LOAD AND HOW
MUCH IS SOLD YOU ON THE SYSTEM
SO THOSE ARE GREAT TALKING
POINTS FOR -- FOR THE FOLKS ON
THE OTHER SIDE GREAT TALKING
POINTS BUT I WOULD LIKE TO
POINT OUT DO YOU THE TALKING
POINTS FOR REPUBLICANS IN THE
ASSEMBLY WERE SIXTEEN ADDED
NINETEEN REPUBLICANS STOOD
UP IN VOTING YES ON THIS BILL
WHAT'S MORE TAKING CARE OF
CUSTOMERS THEN TALKING POINTS
THAT SUGGEST THAT RATE PAYERS
ARE GOING TO PAY MORE AND
FALSELY -- YOU KNOW CREATING
THOSE TALKING POINTS YOU KNOW
FOR -- YOU KNOW FOR POLITICAL
GAIN SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK
YOUR AYE VOTE THIS IS SOMETHING
THAT'S VERY VERY IMPORTANT
FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
I APPRECIATE OUR LEADERSHIP
FOR A -- ALLOWING THIS BILL
TO BE ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS THANK YOU SIR DODD
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
PORCHES BRADFORD I HAVE I HAVE
A CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING
AYE TALLY DODD AYE DURAZO
AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
GONZALEZ I WROTE HERTZBERG
AYE WESSEL AYE HURTADO AYE
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE FARED
AYE FLAVOR AYE THE MOM
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ MANY AYE
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN A TROUBLED
PAN I PORTANTINO I ROTH
AYE RUBIO TO START SKINNER
RUBIO AYE SKINNER STERN HI
NUMBER I HAVE A CASKEY I WINNER
I WILK PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS SPACE PORGES DALY
GROVE LIMÓN MELENDEZ NIELSEN
A CHOI BOTH SKINNER HI WELL I
HIGHS THIRTY ONE DOES ONE ON
THE URGENCY HIGHS THIRTY ONE
KNOWS ONE THE MEASURE PASSES
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO MOTIONS
AND RESOLUTIONS SENATOR DODD
--
HELLO HOLD HOLD ON SENATOR DODD
OKAY TRY AGAIN THANK YOU MADAM
PRESIDENT I REQUEST UNANIMOUS
CONSENT TO SUBMIT A LETTER
TO THE JOURNAL PERTAINING
TO SB EIGHT FORTY SIX THE
LETTERS BEEN APPROVED BY
BOTH SIDES THANK YOU THANK
YOU CENTER DODSON -- JONES
I'M STAFF MEMBERS INSIDE
THERE'S A MISUNDERSTANDING
ACTUALLY IS NOT APPROVED
AND -- I WOULD LIKE A ROLL
CALL VOTE YEP NO PROBLEM AND
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
PORCHES I BIRD AYE COMPARED
AYE FOR TESTING HI DOLLY
DODD AYE TERASA AYE EGGMAN
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
GROWTH HERTZBERG WESTERN I
HER DAUGHTER HI JONES KAMLAGER
HI THERE HI LEYVA I FOR THE
MOST MCGUIRE HI MELENDEZ
MEN HI NEWMAN I NIELSEN
A CHOI BOGUE PAN AYE PORTANTINO
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
AYE STERN AYE AMBER AYE
WIECKOWSKI HI WIENER I WILK
LIMÓN HI IS THIRTY NO ZERO THE
MOTION CARRIES MEMBERS IF THERE
IS NO FURTHER BUSINESS CENTER
ATKINS THE DESK IS CLEAR MATTER
SENATE PRESIDENT THANK YOU SO
MUCH -- COLLEAGUES HAVING SAID
ARE APPROPRIATE -- COMMENTS
EARLIER WE WILL ADJOURN SINE
DIE AND I WILL SEE MOST OF
YOU ON MONDAY DECEMBER FIFTH
TWENTY TWENTY TWO AT NOON THE
SENATE IS ADJOURNED WE WILL
RECONVENE MONDAY DECEMBER
FIFTH TWENTY TWENTY TWO AT NOON