PLEASE CALL SOME MEMBERS IF
WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM WILL
START AS A SUBCOMMITTEE GET
TESTIMONY OUT OF THE WAY TINA
HAS A LOT TO DO TODAY WE WANT
TO MAKE SURE I WANT TO MAKE
SURE SHE GETS BACK TO MR ALLAN
OKAY PERFECT
WHAT
WE
YEAH WHAT DO YOU GOT FOR
FORTY FIVE OKAY IT'S JUST
THAT HE'S ONE SHE SAID JUST
FOR THE MOST
YEAH YEAH RIGHT NOW
YEAH
THIS IS YOUR HELLO ALL
RIGHT ARE WE READY TO GO ON
CAMERA OKAY THIS COMMITTEE
ON APPROPRIATIONS WILL COME
TO ORDER AS A SUB COMMITTEE
GOOD AFTERNOON -- OBVIOUSLY
WE TAKE OUR COVA NINETEEN
PRECAUTIONS SERIOUSLY AND WE
WELCOME THE PUBLIC TO BE BOTH
IN PERSON ON TELECONFERENCE
FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING TO
PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT VIA
TELECONFERENCE SERVICE THE
PARTICIPANT TOLL FREE NUMBER
AND ACCESS CODE IS POSTED ON
OUR WEBSITE -- AND IT'LL BE
DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN AND
OBVIOUSLY I'LL ANNOUNCE IT NOW
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN TWO TWO SIX
EIGHT ONE SIX THREE THAT'S
EIGHT SEVEN SEVEN TWO TWO SIX
EIGHT ONE SIX THREE AND THE
ACCESS CODE IS EIGHT TWO FOUR
FIVE NINE NINE ONE OBVIOUSLY
I MAINTAIN DECORUM AS IS
CUSTOMARY IN ANYBODY BEING
DESTRUCTIVE WILL BE REMOVED
FROM THE ROPE REMOTE MEETING
OR HAVE THEIR CONNECTION MUTED
WE'RE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
IN THE -- STREET BUILDING
OBVIOUSLY WHAT ALL MEMBERS
TO COME ON DOWN ROOM TWENTY
TWO HUNDRED TO HAVE A SHARK
QUORUM WE HAVE ONE BILL I AB
EIGHT EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
FIVE BOERNER HORVATH -- DUE
TO CONSTRAINTS IN HERE WE'RE
GONNA LIMIT OUR TESTIMONY TO
FIVE MINUTES FOR OUR PRIMARY
TESTIMONY ALL OF THE WITNESSES
WILL BE CONFINED TO A ME TOO
WHICH IS NAME ORGANIZATION AND
POSITION AND WE ARE GOING TO
-- GO RIGHT TO TESTIMONY AND
OPEN UP AS A SUB COMMITTEE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER IF YOU COULD
TELL US ABOUT EIGHTEEN NINETY
SEVEN YES THANK YOU VERY MUCH
-- AB EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
IS A VERY SIMPLE BILL THAT
CONTAINS JUST THREE MINOR
TECHNICAL FIXES TO SB FIFTY
FOUR THE LANDMARK PLASTICS AND
PACKAGING BILL APPROVED IN JUNE
THE CHANGES INCLUDE CLARIFYING
THE DEFINITION OF RECYCLING
TO SPECIFY THAT IT'S THE
RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PRODUCER
RESPONSIBILITY ORGANISATION OR
PRO TO ENSURE COVER MATERIAL
MEETS THE RECYCLING CREATURE
THAT WILL BE ESTABLISHED AT
CAL RECYCLE WE ALSO AMENDED THE
DEFINITION OF RESPONSIBLE AND
MARKETS TO BETTER ARTICULATE
THAT THE IN MARKET IS THE
DESTINATION WHERE MATERIAL IS
RECLAIMED AND RECONSTITUTED
INTO NEW MATERIAL LASTLY THE
BILL ADDS CLARIFYING DETAIL
AROUND THE DISPUTE RESOLUTION
PROCESS BETWEEN THE PRODUCER
RESPONSIBILITY ORGANISATION
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS BY
EMPOWERING THE ADVISORY BOARD
TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
THE PARTIES AND GIVING EITHER
PARTY'S ABILITY TO PURSUE
ARBITRATION MEMBERS THERE IS
ARE MINOR BUT CRITICAL FIXES
NECESSARY TO ENSURE THAT THE
WASTE HAULING INDUSTRY CAN DO
ITS PART TO HELP CALIFORNIA
MEET THE AMBITIOUS CLIMATE
GOALS WE SET OUT IN SB FIFTY
FOUR IT'S ESSENTIAL THAT WE
MAKE THESE CORRECTIONS NOW
AS SB FIFTY FOUR RECORDS BOTH
PRODUCERS AND CAL RECYCLE TO
BEGIN WORK TOWARDS IMPLEMENTING
THE PROGRAM RIGHT AWAY IN FACT
THE FIRST DEADLINES COME AT THE
END OF TWENTY TWENTY THREE I
HAVE WITH ME TODAY JOHN MOFFETT
WITH WASTE MANAGEMENT AND HEIDI
SANBORN WAS ON THE PHONE WITH
NATIONAL STEWARDSHIP ACTION
COUNCIL TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR YOUR IPHONE ALL RIGHT
GO AHEAD GOOD EVENING MISTER
CHAIR MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE
JOHN MOFFETT ON BEHALF OF
WASTE MANAGEMENT IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL WE APPRECIATE THE
COMMITTEES FISCAL ANALYSIS
ON THE BILL -- IT MAY BE A
SLIGHT DEVIATION FROM ONE OF
THE COMMENTS OF THE BILL WITH
RESPECT TO -- MAY BE COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THE REGULATIONS
THAT WOULD GO TO IMPLEMENT
THE BILL BEING REIMBURSED BY
THE PRODUCER ORGANIZATIONS
I JUST WANT TO POINT OUT THE
LANGUAGE IN THE UNDERLYING
LAW WHICH WAS OBVIOUSLY PASSED
AND GOES INTO EFFECT JANUARY
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY THREE THAT
REQUIRES THESE P.
R.
L.
TO FULLY FUND THE PLAN AND
ALL OTHER COSTS ASSOCIATED
WITH IMPLEMENTING THE PLAN
INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO
ALL OF THE FOLLOWING AND THE
THIRD THING ON THAT LIST IS
REIMBURSING COSTS INCURRED BY
THE DEPARTMENT IN THIS CASE
CAL RECYCLE AND THE CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND FEE
ADMINISTRATION THE THING
ALTERNATELY THE BILL REALLY HAS
NO -- NO -- ONGOING FISCAL COST
OR NEW OR ADDITIONAL COSTS TO
CARRY CYCLE THAT WOULD NOT BE
REIMBURSED ULTIMATELY BY THE
PRO AND FOR THOSE REASONS WE
ASK FOR AYE VOTE ALL RIGHT ANY
OTHER WITNESS THAT WOULD SIT
THERE AND ONE ON THE PHONE WE
HAVE A NUMBER I DON'T HAVE THIS
ONE ON THE PHONE NOPE THAT'S
IT AREN'T OTHERS IN SUPPORT
COME ON UP AND OFFER YOUR ME
TO USE THIS FEATURE -- MISPRINT
OF CORVETTE THANK YOU -- THIS
IS MARK PRAYER I'M HERE ON
BEHALF OF REPUBLIC SERVICES
WE ASK FOR YOUR I.
BOATS
MISTER CHAIR COURTNEY JOHNSON
ON BEHALF OF CALCHAMBER
IN SUPPORT ALL RIGHT WE'LL
GO TO THE PHONE LINE FOR
ANYBODY ELSE IN SUPPORT
OF EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
IF YOU ARE A PART OF
EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO
THERE'S NO ONE IN QUEUE AT
THIS TIME ALL RIGHT WE'LL
COME BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
ROOM FOR OPPOSITION IS
THERE ANY LEAD WITNESSES IN
OPPOSITION TO EIGHTEEN NINETY
SEVEN THANK NO ONE COME TO
THE MICROPHONE MODERATORS
ANYONE ON THE PHONE LINE
OPPOSED EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
WE ARE CLOSE TO EIGHTEEN
NINETY SEVEN PLEASE
PRESS ONE SEND GIRLS
THERE IS NO ONE IN Q.
WE'VE TAKEN SUPPORT OPPOSITION
WE'RE GONNA GO TO FINANCE BUT
DID MILLIE DID YOU KNOW THAT
IN EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN THE
BOSTON MARATHON WAS FIRST HELD
FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME DID
YOU KNOW THAT EIGHTEEN NINETY
SEVEN I DID NOT KNOW THAT AND
DID YOU KNOW THAT SAN DIEGO
STATE OPENED IN EIGHTEEN NINETY
SEVEN TELL US THAT EITHER SO
IN KEEPING WITH OUR TRADITION
IN THIS HOUSE I THOUGHT I WOULD
AND OUR FINAL HEARING WITH
TWO VERY IMPORTANT FACTOIDS
SO MILLION NOW TELL US ABOUT
EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN SINCE WE
KNOW MORE ABOUT THE YEAR THANK
YOU AND GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
PORTANTINO AND APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MILLION WITH
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE WE HAVE
NO FILE ON THIS BILL NO FILE
BUT TO FAX ALL RIGHT WE MISS
BATES MY BY SHOULD YOU HAVE
ANY QUESTIONS THEN WE HAVE NO
QUESTIONS OF WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL
FANTASTIC SO WE WILL WAIT TO WE
HAVE A QUORUM AND THEN WE WILL
TAKE ACTION ON THIS FINE BILL
WE SHALL GO INTO WILL WE
NEVER ACTUALLY WELL WELL
RECESSED TO HAVE A FORM I
GUESS SO WE CAN CUT THE CAMERA
RON TV WERE UP MISTER CHIEF
CONSULTANT DO STYLISH A QUORUM
CENTER PORTANTINO I'M HERE
PORTANTINO HERE CENTER BREWERY
IS ENDING NOW PLEASE HANG UP
BATES HERE CENTER BRADFORD
SENATOR JONES JONES HERE CENTER
KAMLAGER KAMLAGER HERE CENTER
LAYERED SONORA CASKEY WE HAVE
FOUR MEMBERS PRESENT SO WE HAVE
A QUORUM HERE BUT THERE'S Y.
CASKEY IS HERE SO WE HAVE A
QUORUM WHITE HOUSE UNVEILS
A AB EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
WE'VE ALREADY HEARD TESTIMONY
SO FAR TO GO -- YOU KNOW IT
WAS REALLY REALLY RIVETING
COMPELLING COMPELLING --
UPRATED A GOOD JOB -- AND
WE LEARNED THAT THE BOSTON
MARATHON HAD ITS FIRST RUNNING
IN NINETEEN NINETY SEVEN AND
SAN DIEGO STATE HELD ITS FIRST
CLASS IN NINETEEN NINETY SEVEN
AND WILLIAM MCKINLEY WAS THE
PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES
IN EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN --
IT WAS A PRESENCE IN A STATE
NO WAIT FOR THE NEXT IN THE
UNITED STATES SO WITH THAT I
WILL AND IF THE MOTION IS TO
PASS I WILL ENTERTAIN ENTERTAIN
A MOTION ON AB EIGHTEEN NINETY
SEVEN SOME OF THE MOTION
MISTER CHIEF CONSULT WHICH
YOU CALL THE ROLL ASSEMBLY
GO EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN THE
MOTION IS TO PASS TO THE SENATE
FLOOR SENATOR PORTANTINO AYE
PORTANTINO AYE SENATOR BATES
STREETS BY SENATOR BRADFORD
SENATOR JONES HI JONES I
SENATOR KAMLAGER KAMLAGER I
SENATOR LAYERED CENTER WHAT
KASKY FOR CASKEY I HAVE FIVE
VOTES FIVE VOTES I WILL KEEP
THE ROLE OPEN FOR FIVE MINUTES
OKAY EARLIER THIS YEAR'S
LET'S OPEN THE ROLE MOTION
IS US ASSEMBLY BY EIGHTEEN
NINETY SEVEN MOTIONS TO PASS
THE SENATE FOR CHAIR AND
VICE CHAIR BOTH FLOATING ICE
CENTER LAYERED LAYERED HI
CENTER BRADFORD SO WE HAVE
SIX VOTES NOW HAVE SIX VOTES
WILL LEAVE THE ROLE OPEN FOR
SENATOR BRADFORD SERGEANTS
IF YOU COULD FIND OUT WHERE
SENATOR BRADFORD IS AND WILL
GIVE HIM A COUPLE MINUTES
WE WILL TAKE A RECESS UNTIL
CENTER BRADFORD SHOWS UP
MISTER CHIEF CONSULTANT IF
HE'D CALL THE ROLL ASSEMBLY
BILL EIGHTEEN NINETY SEVEN
THE MOTION IS TO PASS THE
SENATE FLOOR CHAIR AND VICE
CHAIR BOTH VOTING HI CENTER
BRADFORD BRADFORD I HAD SEVEN
VOTES ALL RIGHT THE BILL IS
OUT IN THIS COMMITTEE HERE IF
YOU HAVEN'T HAD YOUR COMMENTS
HERDER YOU WISH TO CONTACT US
YOU CAN USE THE EMAIL FOR THE
STATE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE -- AND SO PLEASE FEEL
FREE TO DO THAT AND WITH THAT
WE WILL ADJOURN THIS MEETING