WEBVTT
00:00:15.181 --> 00:00:16.850
GOING TO CALL TO ORDER THE
00:00:16.916 --> 00:00:17.984
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING. WE
00:00:18.051 --> 00:00:20.453
ARE DO NOT HAVE A QUORUM YET, SO
00:00:20.520 --> 00:00:24.057
WE'LL BEGIN. AS A SUBCOMMITTEE.
00:00:24.124 --> 00:00:26.359
UM I WANT TO JUST MENTIONED A
00:00:26.426 --> 00:00:28.528
FEW THINGS. FIRST OF ALL. ITEM
00:00:28.595 --> 00:00:31.564
NUMBER 18 25 97 BY
00:00:31.631 --> 00:00:34.167
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM HAS BEEN
00:00:34.234 --> 00:00:36.770
REMOVED FROM THE AGENDA AT THE
00:00:36.836 --> 00:00:37.904
REQUEST OF THE AUTHOR. IN
00:00:37.971 --> 00:00:42.308
ADDITION, FOUR OF OUR ITEMS ITEM
00:00:42.375 --> 00:00:45.612
THREE ITEM 89 10 AND 13 OR
00:00:45.678 --> 00:00:48.314
EXCUSE ME FIVE ITEMS OR ON OUR
00:00:48.381 --> 00:00:51.251
CONSENT CALENDAR FILE ITEM. SIX
00:00:51.317 --> 00:00:52.385
WE THOUGHT WAS UNCONSENTED
00:00:52.452 --> 00:00:53.686
THAT'S GOING TO BE PRESENTED.
00:00:53.753 --> 00:00:58.191
UM, WE ALSO HAVE TO AH, SPECIAL
00:00:58.258 --> 00:00:59.793
ORDERS. TODAY WE'LL START WITH
00:00:59.859 --> 00:01:01.528
THE ITEM WHEN WE START WITH THE
00:01:01.594 --> 00:01:04.130
ITEM NUMBER ONE A B 23 05 THAT
00:01:04.197 --> 00:01:04.731
WILL BE TESTIMONY. ONLY THAT
00:01:04.798 --> 00:01:05.765
COMMITTEE WILL NOT BE HOLDING A
00:01:05.832 --> 00:01:07.734
VOTE ON THE BILL, BUT WE WILL
00:01:07.801 --> 00:01:10.537
RECEIVE TESTIMONY AND DISCUSSED
00:01:10.603 --> 00:01:11.805
THE BILL, AND THEN THAT WILL BE
00:01:11.871 --> 00:01:15.542
FOLLOWED BY ITEM NUMBER TWO A B
00:01:15.608 --> 00:01:16.743
2011 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS,
00:01:16.810 --> 00:01:18.178
AND THEN WE'LL GO AND FILE ORDER
00:01:18.244 --> 00:01:22.982
FROM FROM THERE. UM I WANT TO
00:01:23.049 --> 00:01:24.184
JUST NOTE THAT FOR MEMBERS OF
00:01:24.250 --> 00:01:26.286
THE PUBLIC WHO ARE CALLING IN
00:01:26.352 --> 00:01:27.854
THE PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
00:01:27.921 --> 00:01:33.026
8442916. FOUR AND THE ACCESS
00:01:33.092 --> 00:01:38.665
CODE IS 5768138. UM AS ALWAYS
00:01:38.731 --> 00:01:41.034
WILL MAINTAIN DECORUM. UH, AND
00:01:41.100 --> 00:01:42.735
ANYONE WHO'S DISRUPTIVE MAY BE
00:01:42.802 --> 00:01:44.571
REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE MEETING
00:01:44.637 --> 00:01:46.239
SERVICE OR HAVE THEIR CONNECTION
00:01:46.306 --> 00:01:51.644
MUTED. UM. OKAY AS NOTED, WE DO
00:01:51.711 --> 00:01:53.079
NOT YET HAVE A QUORUM. HOPEFULLY
00:01:53.146 --> 00:01:55.815
WE WILL SHORTLY AND WE WILL
00:01:55.882 --> 00:01:58.818
BEGIN SO START WITH ITEM NUMBER
00:01:58.885 --> 00:02:00.253
ONE A. B 23 05 BY
00:02:00.320 --> 00:02:01.321
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON AGAIN
00:02:01.387 --> 00:02:02.555
THIS WILL BE TESTIMONY ONLY. AH,
00:02:02.622 --> 00:02:08.928
SOME REMEMBER WELCOME. THANK
00:02:08.995 --> 00:02:10.029
YOU, MR CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
00:02:10.096 --> 00:02:12.599
MEMBERS AND I FIRST WANT TO
00:02:12.665 --> 00:02:14.934
START BY STATING MR CHAIR. THANK
00:02:15.001 --> 00:02:16.936
YOU AND COMMITTEE STAFF FOR YOUR
00:02:17.003 --> 00:02:19.239
ENGAGEMENT PATIENTS AND LONG
00:02:19.305 --> 00:02:20.673
SUFFERING. AND SO HERE WE ARE
00:02:20.740 --> 00:02:23.543
TODAY, TESTIMONY ONLY. AND
00:02:23.610 --> 00:02:25.111
SENATORS. I AM PLEASED TO
00:02:25.178 --> 00:02:26.613
PRESENT TO YOU. ASSEMBLY BILL 23
00:02:26.679 --> 00:02:28.715
05, WHICH WOULD ESTABLISH A
00:02:28.781 --> 00:02:30.183
COORDINATED HOUSING FINANCE
00:02:30.250 --> 00:02:31.784
COMMITTEE TO ALLOCATE STATE
00:02:31.851 --> 00:02:32.752
CONTROLLED RESOURCES FOR
00:02:32.819 --> 00:02:35.188
AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING. AS
00:02:35.255 --> 00:02:37.924
I'M SURE YOU ARE ALL AWARE OF
00:02:37.991 --> 00:02:38.925
CALIFORNIA'S AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:02:38.992 --> 00:02:40.927
FINANCE SYSTEM IS COMPRISED OF
00:02:40.994 --> 00:02:42.428
FOUR SEPARATE ENTITIES, WHICH
00:02:42.495 --> 00:02:43.997
ADMINISTER A VARIETY OF
00:02:44.063 --> 00:02:45.698
FINANCIAL RESOURCES, INCLUDING
00:02:45.765 --> 00:02:46.833
LOANS, TAX CREDITS AND TAX
00:02:46.900 --> 00:02:49.536
EXEMPT BONDS. TO HOUSING
00:02:49.602 --> 00:02:51.037
DEVELOPERS WHO BUILD AND
00:02:51.104 --> 00:02:52.539
REHABILITATE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:02:52.605 --> 00:02:54.674
FOR LOW LOWER INCOME HOUSEHOLDS
00:02:54.741 --> 00:02:57.143
. AND AS I'M SURE YOU'RE ALSO
00:02:57.210 --> 00:02:59.212
AWARE OF THE SYSTEM IS NOT
00:02:59.279 --> 00:03:00.280
RUNNING AS EFFICIENTLY AS IT
00:03:00.346 --> 00:03:02.315
SHOULD OR COULD. MUCH TO THE
00:03:02.382 --> 00:03:04.250
DETRIMENT OF WORKING FAMILIES UP
00:03:04.317 --> 00:03:05.351
AND DOWN THE STATE WHO
00:03:05.418 --> 00:03:06.419
DESPERATELY NEED AFFORDABLE
00:03:06.486 --> 00:03:08.755
HOUSING. THE STATE'S LACK OF
00:03:08.821 --> 00:03:10.256
COORDINATED HOUSING PLAN IS
00:03:10.323 --> 00:03:12.025
EVIDENT IN THE FOUR AGENCIES
00:03:12.091 --> 00:03:14.193
MISALIGNED AND INCONSISTENT
00:03:14.260 --> 00:03:14.827
REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AFFORDABLE
00:03:14.894 --> 00:03:15.828
HOUSING PROGRAMS THEY
00:03:15.895 --> 00:03:18.531
ADMINISTER. THE RESULTING
00:03:18.598 --> 00:03:19.933
APPROVAL PROCESS FOR THE
00:03:19.999 --> 00:03:22.101
PROGRAM'S FINANCIAL RESOURCES IS
00:03:22.168 --> 00:03:23.903
CUMBERSOME FOR DEVELOPERS WHO
00:03:23.970 --> 00:03:26.739
NEED STATE RESOURCES TO SUPPORT
00:03:26.806 --> 00:03:28.541
THEIR PROJECTS BECAUSE THESE
00:03:28.608 --> 00:03:30.543
DEVELOPERS MUST OFTEN USE
00:03:30.610 --> 00:03:31.811
MULTIPLE RESOURCES OF FUNDING
00:03:31.878 --> 00:03:32.845
FOR THEIR DEVELOPMENTS TO BE
00:03:32.912 --> 00:03:35.181
FINANCIALLY FEASIBLE. THE
00:03:35.248 --> 00:03:37.183
MISALIGNED REQUIREMENTS CAN SLOW
00:03:37.250 --> 00:03:38.785
DEVELOPMENT AND INCREASED
00:03:38.851 --> 00:03:40.920
PROJECT COST ANOTHER FACTOR THAT
00:03:40.987 --> 00:03:42.789
CAN INTERFERE WITH THE STATE
00:03:42.855 --> 00:03:43.923
BETTER MEETING ITS GOALS FOR
00:03:43.990 --> 00:03:46.926
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THESE ARE
00:03:46.993 --> 00:03:47.827
NOT MY WORDS. THESE ARE THE
00:03:47.894 --> 00:03:49.262
WORDS OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
00:03:49.329 --> 00:03:51.998
AUDITOR, ONE WHO HAS NO STAKE IN
00:03:52.065 --> 00:03:54.300
THE OUTCOME OF THIS LEGISLATION
00:03:54.367 --> 00:03:55.068
. THE ONLY INTEREST OF THE
00:03:55.134 --> 00:03:57.337
AUDITOR IS IN PROVIDING
00:03:57.403 --> 00:03:58.838
OBJECTIVE EVALUATIONS THAT
00:03:58.905 --> 00:03:59.739
ENHANCE TRANSPARENCY,
00:03:59.806 --> 00:04:01.841
ACCOUNTABILITY AND PERFORMANCE
00:04:01.908 --> 00:04:03.476
OF CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT FOR THE
00:04:03.543 --> 00:04:04.611
PEOPLE. IT SERVES AS THE
00:04:04.677 --> 00:04:06.145
AUDITORS, WEBSITE NOTES. IN ITS
00:04:06.212 --> 00:04:09.782
MISSION STATEMENT. IN 2020, THE
00:04:09.849 --> 00:04:12.051
AUDITOR FOUND THAT THE LACK OF
00:04:12.118 --> 00:04:12.652
COORDINATION AMONG THESE
00:04:12.719 --> 00:04:13.620
ENTITIES HAS REDUCED THE
00:04:13.686 --> 00:04:14.921
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE STATE'S
00:04:14.988 --> 00:04:16.556
RESPONSE TO OUR HOUSING
00:04:16.623 --> 00:04:18.625
AFFORDABLE CRISIS. DEVELOPERS
00:04:18.691 --> 00:04:19.792
INTERVIEWED FOR THE AUDIT
00:04:19.859 --> 00:04:21.794
EXPRESSED THE NEED FOR A SYSTEM
00:04:21.861 --> 00:04:22.662
THAT CONSOLIDATES AND
00:04:22.729 --> 00:04:24.197
COORDINATES MULTIPLE HOUSING
00:04:24.263 --> 00:04:25.331
RESOURCES INTO ONE CENTRALIZED
00:04:25.398 --> 00:04:28.668
PROCESS. THE REPORT CONCLUDED
00:04:28.735 --> 00:04:29.602
THAT A STANDARD SET OF
00:04:29.669 --> 00:04:31.037
REQUIREMENTS, CONSISTENT
00:04:31.104 --> 00:04:32.538
DEADLINES AND A SINGLE
00:04:32.605 --> 00:04:34.707
APPLICATION PROCESS FOR MULTI
00:04:34.774 --> 00:04:36.409
FAMILY HOUSING PROGRAMS WOULD
00:04:36.476 --> 00:04:37.910
NOT ONLY REDUCE THE LIKELIHOOD
00:04:37.977 --> 00:04:39.545
OF DELAYS FOR APPLICANTS, BUT
00:04:39.612 --> 00:04:41.347
COULD ALSO INCREASE THE STATE
00:04:41.414 --> 00:04:43.316
SUPPLY OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
00:04:43.383 --> 00:04:44.784
THE FINDINGS OF THE STATE
00:04:44.851 --> 00:04:46.285
AUDITOR HAVE SINCE BEEN IN
00:04:46.352 --> 00:04:47.987
ECHOED IN NUMEROUS DIFFERENT
00:04:48.054 --> 00:04:50.390
FORMS. MORE RECENTLY, THE LITTLE
00:04:50.456 --> 00:04:51.724
HOOVER COMMISSION RELEASED A
00:04:51.791 --> 00:04:53.693
REPORT ON BARRIERS TO AFFORDABLE
00:04:53.760 --> 00:04:54.727
HOUSING PRODUCTION, WHICH FOUND
00:04:54.794 --> 00:04:57.563
THE CURRENT ARRANGEMENT. IS ANY
00:04:57.630 --> 00:04:58.598
EFFICIENT, RESULTING IN
00:04:58.665 --> 00:05:00.533
CONFUSION OVER RESPONSIBILITIES
00:05:00.600 --> 00:05:01.834
, SERVICE GAPS AND THE
00:05:01.901 --> 00:05:03.536
DISCONNECT BETWEEN STATE GOALS
00:05:03.603 --> 00:05:06.539
AND POLICIES. IT'S CDS 2022
00:05:06.606 --> 00:05:08.808
STATEWIDE HOUSING PLAN FOUND
00:05:08.875 --> 00:05:10.576
THAT THE BACKLOG OF PROJECTS
00:05:10.643 --> 00:05:12.612
THAT APPLIED FOR BUT DID NOT
00:05:12.679 --> 00:05:14.080
RECEIVE PUBLIC FINANCING
00:05:14.147 --> 00:05:16.082
ASSISTANCE OVER THE PAST FEW
00:05:16.149 --> 00:05:16.983
YEARS SHOWS US THAT WE MUST
00:05:17.050 --> 00:05:18.151
CAREFULLY MANAGE AFFORDABLE
00:05:18.217 --> 00:05:20.286
HOUSING INVESTMENTS. AND THAT
00:05:20.353 --> 00:05:22.422
THERE ARE PROBLEMATIC BARRIERS
00:05:22.488 --> 00:05:24.724
WITHIN HOUSING FINANCE SYSTEMS.
00:05:24.791 --> 00:05:26.693
LAST FALL, I HAD THE PRIVILEGE
00:05:26.759 --> 00:05:29.195
OF EMBARKING ON A STATEWIDE TOUR
00:05:29.262 --> 00:05:30.697
. IT WAS A LISTENING TOUR WITH
00:05:30.763 --> 00:05:32.331
MANY OF THE MEMBERS ON THIS
00:05:32.398 --> 00:05:34.200
COMMITTEE AT ALMOST EVERY STOP
00:05:34.267 --> 00:05:36.436
ON THE TOUR. WE HEARD FROM
00:05:36.502 --> 00:05:38.004
AFFORDABLE DEVELOPERS THAT THE
00:05:38.071 --> 00:05:39.906
LACK OF COORDINATION BETWEEN THE
00:05:39.972 --> 00:05:40.740
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
00:05:40.807 --> 00:05:42.308
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT THAT'S HC
00:05:42.375 --> 00:05:44.410
D CALIFORNIA TAX CREDIT
00:05:44.477 --> 00:05:45.912
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE, PEACOCK
00:05:45.978 --> 00:05:47.447
AND CALIFORNIA DEBT LIMIT
00:05:47.513 --> 00:05:49.882
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE. SEDLAK AND
00:05:49.949 --> 00:05:51.317
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING FINANCE
00:05:51.384 --> 00:05:54.921
AGENCY. CAL H OF A WAS A SERIOUS
00:05:54.987 --> 00:05:57.290
IMPEDIMENT TO THE PRODUCTION OF
00:05:57.356 --> 00:05:58.257
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN RESPONSE
00:05:58.324 --> 00:05:59.592
TO THE OVERWHELMING CONSENSUS ON
00:05:59.659 --> 00:06:01.394
THE NEED FOR REFORM. I
00:06:01.461 --> 00:06:05.031
INTRODUCED A B 23 05. THIS BILL
00:06:05.098 --> 00:06:05.898
WILL CREATE A COORDINATED
00:06:05.965 --> 00:06:07.433
HOUSING FINANCE COMMITTEE, WHICH
00:06:07.500 --> 00:06:08.901
WILL ALLOCATE STATE CONTROLLED
00:06:08.968 --> 00:06:10.470
RESOURCES FOR THE FOR FINANCE OF
00:06:10.536 --> 00:06:12.238
AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING.
00:06:12.305 --> 00:06:14.674
THROUGH A SINGLE PROCESS AND
00:06:14.741 --> 00:06:16.242
COMPETITION AND WILL ALLOW AN
00:06:16.309 --> 00:06:17.677
APPLICANT TO OBTAIN ALL
00:06:17.744 --> 00:06:19.812
NECESSARY STATE ASSISTANCE AT
00:06:19.879 --> 00:06:20.847
ONE TIME WITH A SINGLE
00:06:20.913 --> 00:06:23.116
APPLICATION. IMPORTANTLY THE
00:06:23.182 --> 00:06:24.550
CREATION OF THE COMMITTEE WILL
00:06:24.617 --> 00:06:26.219
NOT ALTER OR TRANSFER ANY OF THE
00:06:26.285 --> 00:06:28.321
AUTHORITIES CURRENTLY ENJOYED BY
00:06:28.387 --> 00:06:29.756
THE FOUR AGENCIES AND TO
00:06:29.822 --> 00:06:30.890
CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS WHO
00:06:30.957 --> 00:06:31.891
OVERSEE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:06:31.958 --> 00:06:34.827
POLICY IN THE STATE. RATHER THE
00:06:34.894 --> 00:06:36.162
COMMITTEE WILL PROVIDE A FOCAL
00:06:36.229 --> 00:06:38.297
POINT FOR CONVERSATION AND
00:06:38.364 --> 00:06:39.999
COORDINATION AMONG THE VARIOUS
00:06:40.066 --> 00:06:42.201
ACTORS. TO PARAPHRASE THE LITTLE
00:06:42.268 --> 00:06:43.202
HOOVER COMMISSIONS, RATIONALE
00:06:43.269 --> 00:06:45.371
FOR REFORM. THE GOAL IS NOT TO
00:06:45.438 --> 00:06:46.172
CRITIQUE THE RELATIONSHIP
00:06:46.239 --> 00:06:48.407
BETWEEN ANY OF THE STATE
00:06:48.474 --> 00:06:49.809
OFFICEHOLDERS. IT IS SIMPLY TO
00:06:49.876 --> 00:06:51.177
IMPROVE ON A STRUCTURE THAT IS
00:06:51.244 --> 00:06:53.045
DIFFICULT UNDER THE BEST OF
00:06:53.112 --> 00:06:55.248
CIRCUMSTANCES. AS THE COMMISSION
00:06:55.314 --> 00:06:57.183
ASTUTELY RECOGNIZES, NO MATTER
00:06:57.250 --> 00:06:58.684
HOW GOOD THE RELATIONSHIP
00:06:58.751 --> 00:07:00.153
BETWEEN THE GOVERNOR AND STATE
00:07:00.219 --> 00:07:01.888
TREASURE VOTERS CAN CHANGE
00:07:01.954 --> 00:07:04.190
EITHER OR BOTH OF THOSE OFFICES
00:07:04.257 --> 00:07:05.458
OFFICEHOLDERS EVERY FOUR YEARS,
00:07:05.525 --> 00:07:08.895
SO THUS FAR. YOU HAVE HEARD THE
00:07:08.961 --> 00:07:10.363
NEED FOR THIS SENSIBLE POLICY
00:07:10.429 --> 00:07:11.430
FROM THE STATE AUDITOR AND THE
00:07:11.497 --> 00:07:13.299
LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION, BOTH
00:07:13.366 --> 00:07:15.067
OF WHOM HAVE NO STAKE IN THE
00:07:15.134 --> 00:07:16.702
OUTCOME OF THIS MEASURE, WITH
00:07:16.769 --> 00:07:17.970
THEIR ONLY INTEREST, BEING
00:07:18.037 --> 00:07:18.871
BETTER EFFICIENCY AND
00:07:18.938 --> 00:07:21.174
TRANSPARENCY IN GOVERNMENT. AND
00:07:21.240 --> 00:07:23.910
LET ME SHARE ONE MORE VOICE, THE
00:07:23.976 --> 00:07:25.011
MISSION OF THE TURNER CENTER OF
00:07:25.077 --> 00:07:26.045
HOUSING INNOVATION AT THE
00:07:26.112 --> 00:07:27.847
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA,
00:07:27.914 --> 00:07:30.349
BERKELEY, IT IS TO FORMULATE
00:07:30.416 --> 00:07:32.318
BOLD STRATEGIES TO HOUSE
00:07:32.385 --> 00:07:33.886
FAMILIES, FAMILIES FROM ALL
00:07:33.953 --> 00:07:35.354
WALKS OF LIFE AND VIBRANT,
00:07:35.421 --> 00:07:37.323
SUSTAINABLE AND AFFORDABLE HOMES
00:07:37.390 --> 00:07:38.791
AND COMMUNITIES ESTABLISHED IN
00:07:38.858 --> 00:07:41.694
2015, THE TURNER CENTER. HAS
00:07:41.761 --> 00:07:43.029
QUICKLY BECOME A LEADING VOICE
00:07:43.095 --> 00:07:44.730
AND IDENTIFYING, DEVELOPING AND
00:07:44.797 --> 00:07:46.599
ADVANCING, INNOVATIVE PUBLIC AND
00:07:46.666 --> 00:07:47.700
PRIVATE SECTOR SOLUTIONS TO THE
00:07:47.767 --> 00:07:51.037
NATION'S MOST INTRACTABLE
00:07:51.103 --> 00:07:52.772
HOUSING CHALLENGES. AS A MATTER
00:07:52.839 --> 00:07:55.308
OF FACT, THERE WORK PROVIDES
00:07:55.374 --> 00:07:56.309
TIMELY ANALYSIS AND DATA DRIVEN
00:07:56.375 --> 00:07:58.544
RESEARCH TO SUPPORT POLICY AND
00:07:58.611 --> 00:08:00.079
INNOVATION FOR POLICYMAKERS,
00:08:00.146 --> 00:08:01.881
PRACTITIONERS AND ADVOCATES AND
00:08:01.948 --> 00:08:04.016
ADDRESSING WITH URGENCY, THE
00:08:04.083 --> 00:08:05.451
MULTIPLE LAYERED CRISIS OF
00:08:05.518 --> 00:08:06.986
HOUSING AFFORDABILITY,
00:08:07.053 --> 00:08:08.387
ENTRENCHED INEQUITIES AND
00:08:08.454 --> 00:08:10.156
CLIMATE CHANGE. THE TURNER
00:08:10.223 --> 00:08:11.457
CENTER AIMS TO PROVIDE
00:08:11.524 --> 00:08:13.559
ACTIONABLE PRAGMATIC PATH. THAT
00:08:13.626 --> 00:08:15.695
ARE BASED ON EVIDENCE AND CAN
00:08:15.761 --> 00:08:17.230
BRING TOGETHER A COALITION TO
00:08:17.296 --> 00:08:19.398
MAKE CHANGE. HERE'S WHAT THEY
00:08:19.465 --> 00:08:21.200
HAD TO SAY ABOUT THE STATUS QUO.
00:08:21.267 --> 00:08:22.168
PERMISSION TO READ FROM THE
00:08:22.235 --> 00:08:25.304
CHAIR. THANK YOU SO MUCH. IN OUR
00:08:25.371 --> 00:08:27.139
RECENT RESEARCH, WE HAVE FOUND
00:08:27.206 --> 00:08:28.641
THAT THE LACK OF ALIGNMENT OF
00:08:28.708 --> 00:08:30.710
DEADLINES AMONG KEY FUNDING
00:08:30.776 --> 00:08:32.478
SOURCES IS A CONTRIBUTOR TO LONG
00:08:32.545 --> 00:08:34.413
TIMELINES AND COST INCREASES.
00:08:34.480 --> 00:08:36.182
EACH ADDITIONAL CAPITAL SOURCE
00:08:36.249 --> 00:08:37.416
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:08:37.483 --> 00:08:39.051
DEVELOPMENT IS ASSOCIATED WITH
00:08:39.118 --> 00:08:42.855
AN INCREASE OF ROUGHLY $6500 OR
00:08:42.922 --> 00:08:45.892
1.7% PER HOME WITH 80% OF
00:08:45.958 --> 00:08:47.460
PROJECTS SURVEYED IN THE PAST
00:08:47.526 --> 00:08:49.495
DECADE, UTILIZING 4 TO 8
00:08:49.562 --> 00:08:50.496
SEPARATE FINANCING SOURCES AND
00:08:50.563 --> 00:08:52.798
THEIR CAPITAL STACK. THIS
00:08:52.865 --> 00:08:54.901
CORRELATION IS CONCERNING
00:08:54.967 --> 00:08:56.903
REDUCING THE CURRENT COMPLEXITY
00:08:56.969 --> 00:08:59.305
OF DIFFERENT TIMELINES, LEVELS
00:08:59.372 --> 00:09:00.907
OF TRANSPARENCY AND REQUIREMENTS
00:09:00.973 --> 00:09:02.608
ACROSS GOVERNMENT SOURCES IS
00:09:02.675 --> 00:09:03.776
LIKELY TO RESULT IN MORE
00:09:03.843 --> 00:09:05.678
AFFORDABLE HOMES GETTING BUILT.
00:09:05.745 --> 00:09:08.047
OUR RESEARCH SPOTLIGHTED THAT
00:09:08.114 --> 00:09:10.182
THE NOT INFREQUENT SCENARIO
00:09:10.249 --> 00:09:11.784
WHERE A PROJECT RECEIVES STATE
00:09:11.851 --> 00:09:14.420
FUNDING FROM H C D, BUT THEN
00:09:14.487 --> 00:09:15.755
STALLS OUT WHILE IT PURSUES TAX
00:09:15.821 --> 00:09:17.757
CREDITS DUE TO A LACK OF STATE
00:09:17.823 --> 00:09:19.692
COORDINATION. CALIFORNIA
00:09:19.759 --> 00:09:20.693
INDIANS, LONG TERM HOUSING
00:09:20.760 --> 00:09:22.762
SOLUTIONS AND TO ACHIEVE THAT WE
00:09:22.828 --> 00:09:24.397
NEED A FINANCING STRUCTURE THAT
00:09:24.463 --> 00:09:26.299
ENABLES LONG TERM POLICY
00:09:26.365 --> 00:09:28.801
COORDINATION, IN FACT, EVEN
00:09:28.868 --> 00:09:30.536
GOVERNOR NEWSOM SAID THE
00:09:30.603 --> 00:09:31.570
FOLLOWING WHEN DISCUSSING OUR
00:09:31.637 --> 00:09:34.040
STATE'S HOUSING ENTITIES I'VE
00:09:34.106 --> 00:09:36.742
JUST HAD ENOUGH OF T CÁC, SEDLAK
00:09:36.809 --> 00:09:38.611
AND O P. R S AND CALVE. IT'S CAL
00:09:38.678 --> 00:09:42.081
VETS AND H C. D S AND CAL H F A
00:09:42.148 --> 00:09:43.649
S SIX OF YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT THE
00:09:43.716 --> 00:09:46.118
HELL? I JUST SAID. NO ONE ELSE
00:09:46.185 --> 00:09:47.687
DOES, AND THAT'S THE POINT. THIS
00:09:47.753 --> 00:09:49.255
MEASURE ENJOYS BIPARTISAN
00:09:49.322 --> 00:09:50.690
SUPPORT IS SPONSORED BY STATE
00:09:50.756 --> 00:09:52.925
CONTROLLER BETTY YEE AND IS
00:09:52.992 --> 00:09:54.460
SUPPORTED BY THE LITTLE HOOVER
00:09:54.527 --> 00:09:55.094
COMMISSIONED THE TURNER CENTER
00:09:55.161 --> 00:09:56.796
FOR HOUSING INNOVATION AT BURKE
00:09:56.862 --> 00:09:58.097
, <c.cyan>/C. BERKELEY AND THE</c>
00:09:58.164 --> 00:09:59.465
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
00:09:59.532 --> 00:10:01.000
, ALONG WITH THE NUMBER OF
00:10:01.067 --> 00:10:02.001
HOUSING ORGANIZATIONS AROUND THE
00:10:02.068 --> 00:10:04.670
STATE. WITH ME TO TESTIFY TO THE
00:10:04.737 --> 00:10:05.972
CHAIR IS STATE CONTROLLER BETTY
00:10:06.038 --> 00:10:10.109
YEE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM
00:10:10.176 --> 00:10:17.149
CONTROLLER. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:10:17.216 --> 00:10:17.783
. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON. GOOD
00:10:17.850 --> 00:10:18.751
AFTERNOON. MR CHAIRMAN AND
00:10:18.818 --> 00:10:20.987
MEMBERS, UM, APPRECIATE THE
00:10:21.053 --> 00:10:22.922
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY ON A B 23
00:10:22.989 --> 00:10:24.790
05 THIS AFTERNOON AS YOUR
00:10:24.857 --> 00:10:26.692
CONTROLLER. I DO SERVE AS A
00:10:26.759 --> 00:10:28.027
BOARD MEMBER OF T AND SAID BLACK
00:10:28.094 --> 00:10:30.229
AND HAVE SEEN FIRSTHAND HOW WE
00:10:30.296 --> 00:10:32.264
ARE, IN OUR OWN WAY WHEN IT
00:10:32.331 --> 00:10:33.132
COMES TO FUNDING AND BUILDING
00:10:33.199 --> 00:10:34.133
DESPERATELY NEEDED AFFORDABLE
00:10:34.200 --> 00:10:36.302
HOUSING IN OUR STATE. WE
00:10:36.369 --> 00:10:37.603
CURRENTLY REQUIRE THOSE SEEKING
00:10:37.670 --> 00:10:38.904
STATE SUPPORT TO FINANCE
00:10:38.971 --> 00:10:41.307
CONSTRUCTION. EXCUSE ME OF
00:10:41.374 --> 00:10:42.108
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECTS IN
00:10:42.174 --> 00:10:43.743
OUR STATE TO WORK THEIR WAY
00:10:43.809 --> 00:10:45.478
THROUGH A GAUNTLET OF PROCESSES
00:10:45.544 --> 00:10:46.579
AND REQUIREMENTS FROM NO LESS
00:10:46.645 --> 00:10:48.781
THAN FOUR STATE DEPARTMENTS.
00:10:48.848 --> 00:10:51.183
DOES SOUND PLEASED TO SPONSOR A
00:10:51.250 --> 00:10:52.184
B 23 05, WHICH WILL STREAMLINE
00:10:52.251 --> 00:10:54.186
THIS PROCESS AND ENSURE WE
00:10:54.253 --> 00:10:56.355
DEPLOY PUBLIC RESOURCE SUPPORT
00:10:56.422 --> 00:10:57.289
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING. MORE
00:10:57.356 --> 00:10:59.625
EFFECTIVELY. UH ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:10:59.692 --> 00:11:01.060
GRAYSON STATED. IT DOES CREATE A
00:11:01.127 --> 00:11:03.195
ONE STOP SHOP FOR AFFORDABLE
00:11:03.262 --> 00:11:03.963
MULTI FAMILY HOUSING DEVELOPERS
00:11:04.030 --> 00:11:05.464
TO OBTAIN TAX EXEMPT BONDS,
00:11:05.531 --> 00:11:07.033
STATE AND FEDERAL TAX CREDITS AS
00:11:07.099 --> 00:11:09.035
WELL AS STATE SUBSIDY LOANS.
00:11:09.101 --> 00:11:10.636
THIS BILL I SHOULD CLARIFY WILL
00:11:10.703 --> 00:11:12.271
ONLY ADDRESS THE FUNCTIONS OF
00:11:12.338 --> 00:11:13.205
THOSE ENTITIES THAT ALLOCATES
00:11:13.272 --> 00:11:15.007
SUBSIDY FUNDS TO AFFORDABLE
00:11:15.074 --> 00:11:16.108
MULTI FAMILY HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
00:11:16.175 --> 00:11:18.310
, SO IT DOES NOT INCLUDE CALORIE
00:11:18.377 --> 00:11:20.046
ALIGNING THE ALLOCATION OF THESE
00:11:20.112 --> 00:11:21.313
FUNDS UNDER A SINGLE ENTITY AND
00:11:21.380 --> 00:11:23.315
PROCESS WILL HAVE THREE MAJOR
00:11:23.382 --> 00:11:25.284
BENEFITS. ONE REDUCE THE TIME
00:11:25.351 --> 00:11:25.951
AND COST TO STAKEHOLDERS
00:11:26.018 --> 00:11:27.086
APPLYING FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:11:27.153 --> 00:11:29.021
FUNDING FROM THE STATE.
00:11:29.088 --> 00:11:30.556
CURRENTLY PROJECTS MUST GO
00:11:30.623 --> 00:11:32.224
THROUGH A MULTI YEAR PROCESS TO
00:11:32.291 --> 00:11:33.626
RECEIVE AWARDS FROM H C D. SAID
00:11:33.692 --> 00:11:35.928
BLACK AND PEACOCK IF A PROJECT
00:11:35.995 --> 00:11:38.197
IS UNSUCCESSFUL IN ANY ONE OF
00:11:38.264 --> 00:11:39.632
THESE COMPETITIONS, THEY HAVE TO
00:11:39.698 --> 00:11:41.167
REAPPLY OFTEN MULTIPLE TIMES,
00:11:41.233 --> 00:11:42.201
SLOWING THE TIMELINE AND
00:11:42.268 --> 00:11:44.403
INCREASING DEVELOPMENT COSTS.
00:11:44.470 --> 00:11:46.038
LAST YEAR, YOU SEIZE TURNER
00:11:46.105 --> 00:11:47.440
CENTER FOR HOUSING INNOVATION,
00:11:47.506 --> 00:11:48.941
ISSUED A REPORT ON THE
00:11:49.008 --> 00:11:50.309
COMPLEXITY OF THE TAX CREDIT
00:11:50.376 --> 00:11:50.810
PROGRAM, INCLUDING THIS
00:11:50.876 --> 00:11:51.844
RECOMMENDATION TO CREATE A ONE
00:11:51.911 --> 00:11:54.680
STOP SHOP APPROACH. UNDER THIS
00:11:54.747 --> 00:11:56.182
APPROACH, AN APPLICANT APPLIES
00:11:56.248 --> 00:11:57.750
FOR ALL STATE FUNDING SOURCES AT
00:11:57.817 --> 00:11:59.051
ONCE, SHORTENING THE STATE
00:11:59.118 --> 00:12:00.753
FINANCING TIMELINE TO LESS THAN
00:12:00.820 --> 00:12:02.788
A YEAR. IN EACH APPLICATION
00:12:02.855 --> 00:12:04.356
CYCLE WITH THE PROJECT IS
00:12:04.423 --> 00:12:05.791
AWADED IT WILL RECEIVE ENOUGH
00:12:05.858 --> 00:12:07.560
FUNDS TO COMPLETE THE PROJECT
00:12:07.626 --> 00:12:08.794
WITHOUT HAVING TO APPLY FOR ANY
00:12:08.861 --> 00:12:10.362
OTHER STATE FUNDING PROGRAMS.
00:12:10.429 --> 00:12:11.997
AND I SHOULD SAY THIS IS NOT A
00:12:12.064 --> 00:12:14.500
NEW IDEA. THIS HAS BEEN AROUND
00:12:14.567 --> 00:12:15.534
FOR DECADES. BUT GIVEN THE
00:12:15.601 --> 00:12:16.902
HISTORIC COMMITMENT OF STATE AND
00:12:16.969 --> 00:12:17.803
FEDERAL DOLLARS TO AFFORDABLE
00:12:17.870 --> 00:12:20.106
HOUSING. THIS IS JUST REALLY THE
00:12:20.172 --> 00:12:23.042
TIME THAT CALLS FOR THIS CHANGE
00:12:23.109 --> 00:12:24.176
IN HOW WE AWARD OUR OUR
00:12:24.243 --> 00:12:27.513
FINANCING. SECONDLY THIS
00:12:27.580 --> 00:12:28.747
APPROACH WILL REDUCE DUPLICATIVE
00:12:28.814 --> 00:12:30.082
WORK THAT CURRENTLY HAS BEEN
00:12:30.149 --> 00:12:30.783
COMPLETED BY MULTIPLE STATE
00:12:30.850 --> 00:12:33.085
DEPARTMENTS. EACH CD KELLY TO
00:12:33.152 --> 00:12:35.187
FACE SEDLAK STICK A CALL REVIEW
00:12:35.254 --> 00:12:36.689
APPLICATIONS, ENSURE PROGRAM
00:12:36.755 --> 00:12:38.124
COMPLIANCE AND MAKE FUNDING
00:12:38.190 --> 00:12:39.058
AWARDS INDEPENDENTLY OF ONE
00:12:39.125 --> 00:12:41.760
ANOTHER. AND I CAN SAY YOU KNOW,
00:12:41.827 --> 00:12:44.029
AS I MY DEPUTY. LOOK AT THESE
00:12:44.096 --> 00:12:44.797
PROJECTS THAT COME BEFORE TIKA
00:12:44.864 --> 00:12:46.532
CONSIDERED LOCK. WE WOULD LOVE
00:12:46.599 --> 00:12:47.833
TO BE ABLE TO SEE THE ENTIRETY
00:12:47.900 --> 00:12:50.236
OF THE FINANCING FOR PROJECTS TO
00:12:50.302 --> 00:12:51.537
BE SURE THAT WE ARE GETTING THE
00:12:51.604 --> 00:12:52.638
BROADEST PUBLIC BENEFIT FROM
00:12:52.705 --> 00:12:53.873
EACH OF THESE PROJECTS THAT ARE
00:12:53.939 --> 00:12:55.374
BEING DEVELOPED. 2021 REPORT BY
00:12:55.441 --> 00:12:57.243
THE STATE AUDITOR IN THE MARCH,
00:12:57.309 --> 00:12:58.310
2022 REPORTS THAT SOMEONE MEMBER
00:12:58.377 --> 00:12:59.278
GRAYSON REFERRED TO BY THE
00:12:59.345 --> 00:13:00.946
LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION. BOTH
00:13:01.013 --> 00:13:02.214
IDENTIFY THE STATES THIS JOINT,
00:13:02.281 --> 00:13:03.349
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FINANCE
00:13:03.415 --> 00:13:05.751
STRUCTURE AS AN IMPEDIMENT. TO
00:13:05.818 --> 00:13:07.052
MAKE CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING SUPPLY
00:13:07.119 --> 00:13:09.188
GOALS IF WE CAN CENTRALIZE
00:13:09.255 --> 00:13:11.390
SCORING AND REVIEWS, THAT'S ONE
00:13:11.457 --> 00:13:12.892
OF MANY STEPS WE CAN TAKE ALONG
00:13:12.958 --> 00:13:14.026
THE HOUSING FINANCE TIMELINE
00:13:14.093 --> 00:13:14.827
WHERE THE STATE CAN ACTUALLY
00:13:14.894 --> 00:13:16.896
SAVE TIME AND MONEY. BY
00:13:16.962 --> 00:13:18.964
CONSOLIDATING OUR PROCESSES AND
00:13:19.031 --> 00:13:21.367
THEN THIRD. THIS ALLOWS FOR MORE
00:13:21.433 --> 00:13:21.967
EFFICIENT AND TIMELY
00:13:22.034 --> 00:13:22.601
DISTRIBUTION OF STATE CONTROLLED
00:13:22.668 --> 00:13:25.704
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUNDS IN 2019
00:13:25.771 --> 00:13:26.906
, THE SYD LAX PRIVATE ACTIVITY,
00:13:26.972 --> 00:13:27.873
BON AWARD PROCESS BECAME
00:13:27.940 --> 00:13:30.075
OVERSUBSCRIBED. WE NOW HAVE TO
00:13:30.142 --> 00:13:31.610
BE HAVE TO BETTER COORDINATE OUR
00:13:31.677 --> 00:13:34.313
PROGRAMS TO MAKE THE MOST OF OUR
00:13:34.380 --> 00:13:35.681
LIMITED HOUSING RESOURCES. MANY
00:13:35.748 --> 00:13:36.916
PROJECTS HAVE RECEIVED FUNDING
00:13:36.982 --> 00:13:38.684
FROM HCG IN THE LAST SEVERAL
00:13:38.751 --> 00:13:40.052
YEARS HAVE NOT BEEN BUILT
00:13:40.119 --> 00:13:40.920
BECAUSE THEY'RE STILL WAITING ON
00:13:40.986 --> 00:13:42.221
COMPETITIVE WORDS FROM SEDLAK
00:13:42.288 --> 00:13:43.289
AND T TO FINALIZE THEIR
00:13:43.355 --> 00:13:45.891
FINANCING STRUCTURE. FOR EXAMPLE
00:13:45.958 --> 00:13:46.759
, THE LEGISLATURE ASKED HIM
00:13:46.825 --> 00:13:49.061
VOTERS APPROVED $3 BILLION IN
00:13:49.128 --> 00:13:50.930
GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS IN 2000
00:13:50.996 --> 00:13:53.332
AND 18. BUT THESE FUNDS ARE
00:13:53.399 --> 00:13:53.966
TAKING LONGER THAN ANTICIPATED
00:13:54.033 --> 00:13:54.967
TO BE UTILIZED TO THESE PROCESS
00:13:55.034 --> 00:13:57.903
INEFFICIENCIES. A CENTRALIZED
00:13:57.970 --> 00:13:58.804
SYSTEM WOULD ENSURE THAT THE
00:13:58.871 --> 00:14:00.439
STATE'S HOUSING PRIORITIES ARE
00:14:00.506 --> 00:14:01.740
BETTER REFLECTED IN THE PROJECTS
00:14:01.807 --> 00:14:02.741
THAT ARE AWARDED STATE
00:14:02.808 --> 00:14:04.810
CONTROLLED FUNDS. NOW MANY
00:14:04.877 --> 00:14:07.046
STAKEHOLDERS HAVE UNDER THE
00:14:07.112 --> 00:14:07.880
CURRENT PROCESS OF MASTERED HOW
00:14:07.947 --> 00:14:08.914
TO BENEFIT FROM THE CURRENT
00:14:08.981 --> 00:14:10.883
FINANCING STRUCTURE. BUT THE
00:14:10.950 --> 00:14:11.650
STRUCTURE DOESN'T WORK TO
00:14:11.717 --> 00:14:12.651
OFFICIALLY PRODUCE THE
00:14:12.718 --> 00:14:13.586
AFFORDABLE HOUSING THAT
00:14:13.652 --> 00:14:17.022
CALIFORNIA NEEDS. THE GOVERNOR
00:14:17.089 --> 00:14:17.656
AND THE LEGISLATURE RIGHTFULLY
00:14:17.723 --> 00:14:19.191
SO HAVE MADE CRITICAL
00:14:19.258 --> 00:14:20.059
INVESTMENTS IN AFFORDABLE
00:14:20.125 --> 00:14:21.560
HOUSING OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS
00:14:21.627 --> 00:14:23.262
, BUT WITHOUT A MORE EFFICIENT
00:14:23.329 --> 00:14:24.697
ALLOCATION SYSTEM. MUCH OF THIS
00:14:24.763 --> 00:14:26.599
THIS THIS NEW FUNDING IS WASTED
00:14:26.665 --> 00:14:27.600
THROUGH DELAYS AND THEN
00:14:27.666 --> 00:14:29.301
UNNECESSARY BUREAUCRACY. WE
00:14:29.368 --> 00:14:30.636
BELIEVE THIS BILL IS THE FIRST
00:14:30.703 --> 00:14:32.938
STEP IN GETTING OUR OWN HOUSE IN
00:14:33.005 --> 00:14:33.906
ORDER WITHIN STATE GOVERNMENT TO
00:14:33.973 --> 00:14:35.307
MEET THE NEEDS OF MILLIONS OF
00:14:35.374 --> 00:14:36.208
UNHAPPINESS AND RUN BURDEN.
00:14:36.275 --> 00:14:38.043
CALIFORNIANS AND I DON'T BELIEVE
00:14:38.110 --> 00:14:39.311
THERE'S ANY REASON A WAY TO
00:14:39.378 --> 00:14:39.878
IMPLEMENT THIS COMMON SENSE
00:14:39.945 --> 00:14:42.014
PROPOSAL THAT WILL INCREASE THE
00:14:42.081 --> 00:14:43.082
SPEED AND THE AMOUNT OF
00:14:43.148 --> 00:14:44.016
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN
00:14:44.083 --> 00:14:45.551
CALIFORNIA. AND SO, MR CHAIRMAN
00:14:45.618 --> 00:14:47.152
, I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:14:47.219 --> 00:14:48.520
STALWART LEADERSHIP AND JUST
00:14:48.587 --> 00:14:50.122
IMPROVING HOUSING POLICY HERE IN
00:14:50.189 --> 00:14:51.624
CALIFORNIA. I APPRECIATE THE
00:14:51.690 --> 00:14:53.225
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY HERE
00:14:53.292 --> 00:14:54.927
AGAIN. THIS IS NOT A NEW IDEA
00:14:54.994 --> 00:14:57.029
LONG TIME IN THE MAKING, AND
00:14:57.096 --> 00:14:58.597
ALSO APPRECIATE THE WORK OF THE
00:14:58.664 --> 00:15:00.566
COMMITTEE STAFF AND ENGAGING US
00:15:00.633 --> 00:15:01.567
ON THIS ISSUE. THANK YOU. THANK
00:15:01.634 --> 00:15:04.903
YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANY, UH
00:15:04.970 --> 00:15:07.373
, ANYONE IN THE HEARINGROOM WHO
00:15:07.439 --> 00:15:10.709
WANTS TO TESTIFY AND FAVOR OF
00:15:10.776 --> 00:15:14.446
MAYBE. SORRY, 23 05. QUÊ SAYING
00:15:14.513 --> 00:15:16.181
NOW AND WHAT WILL COME FORWARD,
00:15:16.248 --> 00:15:21.687
PLEASE? MR CHAIR BOB NAYLOR,
00:15:21.754 --> 00:15:23.088
REPRESENTING FIELDS DEAD IN
00:15:23.155 --> 00:15:25.291
COMPANY OWNED BY HOWARD AHMANSON
00:15:25.357 --> 00:15:26.492
JR AND ORANGE COUNTY
00:15:26.558 --> 00:15:28.394
PHILANTHROPIST AND INTERESTED IN
00:15:28.460 --> 00:15:29.828
HOUSING POLICY STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:15:29.895 --> 00:15:31.063
ANYONE ELSE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:15:31.130 --> 00:15:35.301
AND SUPPORT. OKAY WE'LL GO TO
00:15:35.367 --> 00:15:36.568
THE PHONE LINES. OH, I'M SORRY.
00:15:36.635 --> 00:15:40.406
PART. WE'RE SLOWLY LETTING US IN
00:15:40.472 --> 00:15:41.974
RAND MARTIN ON BEHALF OF THE
00:15:42.041 --> 00:15:43.008
AIDS HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION, AND
00:15:43.075 --> 00:15:44.076
IT'S HEALTHY HOUSING FOUNDATION
00:15:44.143 --> 00:15:45.110
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
00:15:45.177 --> 00:15:47.613
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. IS THERE
00:15:47.680 --> 00:15:49.214
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT OF PUBLIC
00:15:49.281 --> 00:15:52.284
COMMENT AND THE HEARING ROOM?
00:15:52.351 --> 00:15:54.887
OKAY I THINK SEEING NONE. WE'LL
00:15:54.953 --> 00:15:56.555
GO TO THE PHONE LINES.THE
00:15:56.622 --> 00:15:58.390
MODERATOR, PLEASE QUEUE UP ANY
00:15:58.457 --> 00:16:01.894
SUPPORT TESTIMONY. THANK YOU. IF
00:16:01.960 --> 00:16:03.162
YOU ARE IN SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS
00:16:03.228 --> 00:16:05.064
ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO AT THIS
00:16:05.130 --> 00:16:06.598
TIME ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO. TO
00:16:06.665 --> 00:16:09.335
EXPRESS SUPPORT AND WE WILL GO
00:16:09.401 --> 00:16:10.636
TO LIGHT 1 32, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:16:10.703 --> 00:16:18.911
1 32. IS READY AND I LOOK AT, UM
00:16:18.977 --> 00:16:20.279
, EXPRESSED MY SUPPORT TO THIS
00:16:20.346 --> 00:16:24.350
STUFF. UM I THINK WE NEED TO
00:16:24.416 --> 00:16:25.551
STREAMLINE AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:16:25.617 --> 00:16:26.719
DEVELOPMENT AND MAKE IT EASIER
00:16:26.785 --> 00:16:29.355
FOR DEVELOPERS TO GET THE
00:16:29.421 --> 00:16:34.560
PORTABLE HAVING ANY. THANK YOU.
00:16:34.626 --> 00:16:35.761
NEXT WE WILL LINE 176 YOU ARE
00:16:35.828 --> 00:16:49.041
OPEN. 1 76, PLEASE GO AHEAD. ONE
00:16:49.108 --> 00:16:52.911
MORE SHOT. 1 76, ARE YOU MUTED?
00:16:52.978 --> 00:16:54.480
MOVING ALONG. WE'LL GO TO LINE 1
00:16:54.546 --> 00:17:02.488
65, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 1 65.
00:17:02.554 --> 00:17:07.659
WOULD YOU LIKE TO TESTIFY?
00:17:07.726 --> 00:17:15.534
RIGHT? BY 92. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:17:15.601 --> 00:17:16.735
FOR CIRCULATE SAN DIEGO AND
00:17:16.802 --> 00:17:17.936
SILICON VALLEY AT HOME, ALL IN
00:17:18.003 --> 00:17:21.407
STRONG SUPPORT. BY 1 40. YOU ARE
00:17:21.473 --> 00:17:26.345
OPEN. FRANCISCO MARTINEZ
00:17:26.412 --> 00:17:28.414
HAPPENS, LOCAL 22. I'M IN
00:17:28.480 --> 00:17:32.885
SUPPORT OF A B 2011. BUYING 1
00:17:32.951 --> 00:17:39.358
68, PLEASE GO AHEAD. LINE 1 68,
00:17:39.425 --> 00:17:48.901
YOU ARE OPEN. ONE MORE SHOT.
00:17:48.967 --> 00:17:50.135
WOULD YOU LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:17:50.202 --> 00:17:54.106
SUPPORT LINE? 1 68. ALL RIGHT.
00:17:54.173 --> 00:17:55.974
MOVING ALONG. WE'LL GO TO LINE 1
00:17:56.041 --> 00:18:02.481
19, PLEASE GO AHEAD. PLANE. 119
00:18:02.548 --> 00:18:10.389
YOU ARE OPEN. AND THEY'RE NOT
00:18:10.456 --> 00:18:11.990
RESPONDING EITHER. I THINK A LOT
00:18:12.057 --> 00:18:13.759
OF THESE PEOPLE MR CHAIR HAD
00:18:13.826 --> 00:18:14.860
ALREADY QUEUED UP. MAYBE,
00:18:14.927 --> 00:18:15.894
PERHAPS FOR ANOTHER BILL. I'M
00:18:15.961 --> 00:18:19.531
NOT SURE. BUT WE HAVE NO OTHER
00:18:19.598 --> 00:18:21.300
PARTICIPANTS QUEUED UP AT THIS
00:18:21.366 --> 00:18:23.302
TIME IN 19. I QUEUED UP FOR
00:18:23.368 --> 00:18:26.071
ANOTHER BILL. SORRY THANK YOU.
00:18:26.138 --> 00:18:29.274
UM OKAY. WE WILL NOW GO TO
00:18:29.341 --> 00:18:30.609
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL AND OUR
00:18:30.676 --> 00:18:39.051
MADAME TREASURER. THANK YOU VERY
00:18:39.117 --> 00:18:40.986
MUCH. MR CHAIR. I'M SORRY. WE'RE
00:18:41.053 --> 00:18:42.921
A LOT. WE'RE HERE IN THE HEARING
00:18:42.988 --> 00:18:45.524
ROOM, NOT ON THE PHONE LINES.
00:18:45.591 --> 00:18:48.026
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. UM, AND TO
00:18:48.093 --> 00:18:49.928
THE AUTHOR RESPECTFULLY. I AM
00:18:49.995 --> 00:18:52.097
HERE AGAIN TO OPPOSE THIS BILL,
00:18:52.164 --> 00:18:55.534
AS I DID, AND UM, REGARDING
00:18:55.601 --> 00:18:58.604
MAYBE 11 35 LAST TIME. UM, I GOT
00:18:58.670 --> 00:19:01.840
ELECTED AS STATE TREASURER, UM,
00:19:01.907 --> 00:19:04.843
STARTED IN JANUARY. 2019 AND AS
00:19:04.910 --> 00:19:06.745
CHAIR OF BOTH SEDLAK AND T I
00:19:06.812 --> 00:19:10.916
HAVE PERSONALLY CHAIR 29. TAKE
00:19:10.983 --> 00:19:13.318
AT MEETINGS AND 36 SEDLAK
00:19:13.385 --> 00:19:17.523
MEETINGS. I AM ACTIVELY ENGAGED
00:19:17.589 --> 00:19:19.691
IN EVERYTHING THAT IS HAPPENING
00:19:19.758 --> 00:19:21.426
AT MY TWO AGENCIES BECAUSE
00:19:21.493 --> 00:19:23.128
HOUSING IS SO CRITICAL TO THE
00:19:23.195 --> 00:19:25.697
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THE
00:19:25.764 --> 00:19:27.833
GOVERNOR AND I SAT ON THE SAME
00:19:27.900 --> 00:19:29.268
FRANCISCO BORDER SUPERVISORS IN
00:19:29.334 --> 00:19:31.770
2000 AND TWO CAME FROM SAN
00:19:31.837 --> 00:19:33.805
FRANCISCO. AS DID YOU, MR CHAIR
00:19:33.872 --> 00:19:34.973
? WE UNDERSTAND, UM, THE HOUSING
00:19:35.040 --> 00:19:38.477
NEEDS. HOW DIFFICULT IT IS TO
00:19:38.544 --> 00:19:40.846
BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THE
00:19:40.913 --> 00:19:43.815
CRISIS WE ARE IN. AND I
00:19:43.882 --> 00:19:47.152
RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE WITH
00:19:47.219 --> 00:19:48.186
PREVIOUS SPEAKERS THAT THINGS
00:19:48.253 --> 00:19:51.924
AREN'T WORKING. THE AUDITOR WHEN
00:19:51.990 --> 00:19:53.025
THEY PERFORMED THE AUDIT. THEY
00:19:53.091 --> 00:19:55.060
DID IT BEFORE WE BOTH STARTED
00:19:55.127 --> 00:19:56.929
BEFORE THE GOVERNOR AND I
00:19:56.995 --> 00:19:58.397
STARTED AND, YES, THINGS WERE
00:19:58.463 --> 00:20:05.170
DISJOINTED WERE NOT ALIGNED. UM. NOT TRANSPARENT AS IT IS TODAY
00:20:05.237 --> 00:20:07.306
, BUT IF YOU FOLLOW WHAT'S BEEN
00:20:07.372 --> 00:20:08.840
HAPPENING THE LAST 3.5 YEARS,
00:20:08.907 --> 00:20:10.742
YOU WILL SEE AT LEAST THREE OF
00:20:10.809 --> 00:20:13.545
THE FOUR AGENCIES CÁC SEDLAK.
00:20:13.612 --> 00:20:15.380
COLLEGE FAA. WE HAVE MONTHLY
00:20:15.447 --> 00:20:18.050
MEETINGS. WE HAVE AGENDAS THAT
00:20:18.116 --> 00:20:19.017
ARE POSTED TIMELY. WE HAVE
00:20:19.084 --> 00:20:19.952
MINUTES OF THE MEETING.
00:20:20.018 --> 00:20:22.020
SOMETIMES THERE ARE 50 PAGES OF
00:20:22.087 --> 00:20:24.323
MINUTES. UM, WE HAVE HAD THE
00:20:24.389 --> 00:20:26.425
BENEFIT OF ZOOM SO THAT HUNDREDS
00:20:26.491 --> 00:20:28.927
OF PEOPLE CAN ACTUALLY ATTEND
00:20:28.994 --> 00:20:30.929
AND WATCH AND ALSO GIVE PUBLIC
00:20:30.996 --> 00:20:33.332
COMMENT AND WE HAVE BEEN
00:20:33.398 --> 00:20:34.633
STREAMLINING. WE HAVE DEVELOPED
00:20:34.700 --> 00:20:35.867
A JOINT APPLICATION PROCESS
00:20:35.934 --> 00:20:39.438
BETWEEN T CÁC SEDLAK. AND UM,
00:20:39.504 --> 00:20:43.308
AND COLLECT F A, UH WE HAVE
00:20:43.375 --> 00:20:45.911
CREATED A 30% ACTIVE WORKING
00:20:45.978 --> 00:20:46.411
STAKEHOLDER GROUP. WHO?
00:20:46.478 --> 00:20:51.216
ACTIVELY, UM ADVISES US EDUCATES
00:20:51.283 --> 00:20:54.686
US AND WEIGHS IN ON ART
00:20:54.753 --> 00:20:56.188
REGULATIONS AND OUR TIMELINES
00:20:56.254 --> 00:20:57.656
AND DEADLINES TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:20:57.723 --> 00:21:02.694
THEY ARE ABLE. TO FULFILL THEIR
00:21:02.761 --> 00:21:05.130
MISSIONS AND BE ABLE TO, UM YOU
00:21:05.197 --> 00:21:06.565
KNOW, TO BUILD MORE AFFORDABLE
00:21:06.632 --> 00:21:08.700
HOUSING. WE HAVE ALLOCATED A
00:21:08.767 --> 00:21:11.937
HISTORIC $1 BILLION IN NEW 4%
00:21:12.004 --> 00:21:13.138
LOW INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDITS
00:21:13.205 --> 00:21:15.307
FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION. MADE
00:21:15.374 --> 00:21:16.808
POSSIBLE BY THE GOVERNOR'S
00:21:16.875 --> 00:21:20.412
APPROVAL OF A B ONE. OH, ONE. WE
00:21:20.479 --> 00:21:22.547
HAVE CREATED A BOND RECYCLING
00:21:22.614 --> 00:21:24.049
PROGRAM TO MAKE MORE EFFICIENT
00:21:24.116 --> 00:21:27.919
USE OF SYD LAX BONDS. WE HAVE
00:21:27.986 --> 00:21:29.321
ENSURED ALL PRIOR CARRY FORWARDS
00:21:29.388 --> 00:21:31.890
ARE UTILIZED BEFORE CURRENT YEAR
00:21:31.957 --> 00:21:35.027
ALLOCATION IS AWARDED, UM IN
00:21:35.093 --> 00:21:41.133
2020 WE HAVE SEEN 144% INCREASE
00:21:41.199 --> 00:21:42.701
IN THE PRODUCTION FOR NEW
00:21:42.768 --> 00:21:44.970
CONSTRUCTION UNITS. AND IN
00:21:45.037 --> 00:21:47.039
ADDITION, THANKS TO CONGRESSMAN
00:21:47.105 --> 00:21:50.342
MIKE THOMPSON, UM, WHO ALLOCATED
00:21:50.409 --> 00:21:53.145
ADDITIONAL $98 MILLION IN
00:21:53.211 --> 00:21:55.313
FEDERAL PERCENT LOW INCOME
00:21:55.380 --> 00:21:56.481
HOUSING TAX CREDITS TO HELP
00:21:56.548 --> 00:22:00.052
FINANCE THOSE HOUSES THAT HAVE
00:22:00.118 --> 00:22:01.653
BEEN DEVASTATED BY THE FIRES IN
00:22:01.720 --> 00:22:04.523
13 COUNTIES. WE ROLLED THOSE OUT
00:22:04.589 --> 00:22:06.858
TIMELY AND EFFICIENTLY AND THEN
00:22:06.925 --> 00:22:08.760
CONGRESSMAN PANETTA GOT US
00:22:08.827 --> 00:22:11.963
ANOTHER $80 MILLION IN 9% LOW
00:22:12.030 --> 00:22:13.565
INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDITS SO
00:22:13.632 --> 00:22:15.667
THAT WE COULD FUND 22 MORE
00:22:15.734 --> 00:22:16.902
COUNTIES THAT WERE DEVASTATED BY
00:22:16.968 --> 00:22:20.172
THE FIRES. WE HAD WE HAVE HIRED
00:22:20.238 --> 00:22:22.708
NEW LEGAL COUNSEL AND MOST
00:22:22.774 --> 00:22:24.676
IMPORTANTLY, I HAVE CONSOLIDATED
00:22:24.743 --> 00:22:27.045
SEDLAK AND T INTO ONE AGENCY
00:22:27.112 --> 00:22:29.214
WITH ONE COMMON EXECUTIVE
00:22:29.281 --> 00:22:30.949
DIRECTOR. AND SO NOW REGULATION
00:22:31.016 --> 00:22:33.852
TERMS ARE ALIGNED. DEADLINES ARE
00:22:33.919 --> 00:22:36.221
ALIGNED. TIMELINES ARE ALIGNED.
00:22:36.288 --> 00:22:38.924
AND IF YOU NOTICE WHO CALLED IN
00:22:38.990 --> 00:22:40.292
NO AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPER
00:22:40.358 --> 00:22:41.727
HAS CALLED IN BECAUSE THE
00:22:41.793 --> 00:22:45.030
SYSTEMS ARE WORKING. WE ARE
00:22:45.097 --> 00:22:47.065
TRANSPARENT. WE ARE EFFICIENT.
00:22:47.132 --> 00:22:49.801
WE ARE WORKING TOGETHER AND THIS
00:22:49.868 --> 00:22:51.536
BILL WOULD CREATE ANOTHER LAYER
00:22:51.603 --> 00:22:53.305
OF BUREAUCRACY. IT'LL COST
00:22:53.371 --> 00:22:55.540
ADDITIONAL MONEY TO CREATE THIS
00:22:55.607 --> 00:22:57.375
NEW COMMITTEE THAT'S GOING TO
00:22:57.442 --> 00:22:58.577
OVERSEE. UM WHAT WE'RE ALREADY
00:22:58.643 --> 00:23:01.980
DOING. AND IT'S NOT GOING TO
00:23:02.047 --> 00:23:04.282
INCREASE EFFICIENCY. IT'S NOT
00:23:04.349 --> 00:23:06.451
GOING TO INCREASE TIMELINESS.
00:23:06.518 --> 00:23:07.986
IT'S NOT GOING TO MAKE IT EASIER
00:23:08.053 --> 00:23:09.621
OR LESS COSTLY FOR DEVELOPERS TO
00:23:09.688 --> 00:23:12.224
GET THROUGH THE SYSTEM. SO I
00:23:12.290 --> 00:23:15.260
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT WE, YOU
00:23:15.327 --> 00:23:17.562
KNOW, CONTINUE TO TALK ABOUT
00:23:17.629 --> 00:23:20.298
WHAT IS NEEDED, UM, TO CREATE
00:23:20.365 --> 00:23:23.001
ADDITIONAL EFFICIENCIES, UM,
00:23:23.068 --> 00:23:23.869
MOVING FORWARD, BUT THIS BILL IS
00:23:23.935 --> 00:23:25.737
NOT NEEDED AT THIS TIME. THANK
00:23:25.804 --> 00:23:30.675
YOU. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY, UH
00:23:30.742 --> 00:23:31.710
, ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION HERE IN
00:23:31.777 --> 00:23:35.914
THE HEARING ROOM? FIXING THEM
00:23:35.981 --> 00:23:37.883
WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES. OH,
00:23:37.949 --> 00:23:40.719
I'M SORRY. COME FORWARD. AND IF
00:23:40.786 --> 00:23:41.920
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION, YOU
00:23:41.987 --> 00:23:44.923
CAN COME FORWARD NOW. GOOD
00:23:44.990 --> 00:23:47.058
AFTERNOON, BEN BARKER WITH THE
00:23:47.125 --> 00:23:47.626
CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL FINANCE
00:23:47.692 --> 00:23:48.960
AUTHORITY WERE ONE OF THE
00:23:49.027 --> 00:23:50.529
LARGEST AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:23:50.595 --> 00:23:51.029
ISSUERS IN THE STATE OF
00:23:51.096 --> 00:23:52.497
CALIFORNIA, AND WE OPPOSE THE
00:23:52.564 --> 00:23:56.034
BILL. OKAY SEEING NO ADDITIONAL
00:23:56.101 --> 00:23:57.569
OPPOSITION AND HEARING ROOM.
00:23:57.636 --> 00:23:59.271
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES. MR.
00:23:59.337 --> 00:24:00.939
MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE QUEUE
00:24:01.006 --> 00:24:04.042
UP OPPOSITION? THANK YOU, MR
00:24:04.109 --> 00:24:04.910
CHAIR. IF YOU ARE IN OPPOSITION
00:24:04.976 --> 00:24:07.345
TO A B 2011 PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
00:24:07.412 --> 00:24:11.683
THIS TIME ONE FOLLOWED BY ZERO.
00:24:11.750 --> 00:24:12.818
A COUPLE OF QUEUING UP ONE
00:24:12.884 --> 00:24:16.755
MOMENT. TO BE WITH US
00:24:16.822 --> 00:24:18.256
MOMENTARILY FOR ANYBODY ELSE. GO
00:24:18.323 --> 00:24:19.758
AND HIT 10 IF YOU ARE AN
00:24:19.825 --> 00:24:22.460
OPPOSITION TO A B 2011, WE'LL
00:24:22.527 --> 00:24:24.396
START WITH LINE 1 68. THAT'S THE
00:24:24.462 --> 00:24:32.170
WRONG BILL. IT'S 23 05. OH, I'M
00:24:32.237 --> 00:24:35.607
SORRY. I APOLOGIZE. 23 05. AND
00:24:35.674 --> 00:24:37.075
EVERYBODY ELSE. GO AND HIT 10.
00:24:37.142 --> 00:24:39.311
TAKE YOURSELF. THANK YOU TO THE
00:24:39.377 --> 00:24:41.313
AUDIENCE FOR BEING SO ATTENTIVE
00:24:41.379 --> 00:24:42.681
AND FOR HELPING ME OUT. SORRY
00:24:42.747 --> 00:24:43.882
ABOUT SORRY ABOUT IT'S ALL TEAM
00:24:43.949 --> 00:24:49.955
SPORTS. AYE. I HEARD ONE OF
00:24:50.021 --> 00:24:51.256
THEM. PARTICIPANTS SAY THAT SO
00:24:51.323 --> 00:24:52.724
THAT'S WHY I WAS REPEATING. I
00:24:52.791 --> 00:24:54.392
THOUGHT WE WERE WORRIES. PLEASE
00:24:54.459 --> 00:24:56.261
TAKE YOURSELF OUT OF CUBA.
00:24:56.328 --> 00:24:57.662
PRICING 10 AGAIN. AND IF YOU DID
00:24:57.729 --> 00:25:01.600
YOU ARE. AND WE'RE GOING TO GO
00:25:01.666 --> 00:25:02.801
TO LINE 200. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:25:02.868 --> 00:25:05.804
200. YES MY NAME IS PAMELA. GIVE
00:25:05.871 --> 00:25:08.240
BERMAN I LIVE IN PANORAMA CITY,
00:25:08.306 --> 00:25:11.710
AND I AM OPPOSED TO 2011. IT IS
00:25:11.776 --> 00:25:13.311
ONE SIZE FITS ALL PLANNING THAT
00:25:13.378 --> 00:25:14.846
TAKES AWAY OUR RIGHTS AT THE
00:25:14.913 --> 00:25:17.315
LOCAL LEVEL. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:25:17.382 --> 00:25:18.583
. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IT'S A
00:25:18.650 --> 00:25:19.885
WRONG BILL, BUT WE WILL NOTE
00:25:19.951 --> 00:25:22.520
THAT FOR THE NEXT BILL. WE'LL
00:25:22.587 --> 00:25:24.422
LET YOU KEPT SAYING 2011. THAT
00:25:24.489 --> 00:25:28.059
WAS MY FAULT. AH ALL RIGHT,
00:25:28.126 --> 00:25:29.728
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU ARE
00:25:29.794 --> 00:25:31.930
TESTIFYING FOR 2011, PLEASE
00:25:31.997 --> 00:25:33.465
PRESS 10 AT THE TIME TO TAKE
00:25:33.531 --> 00:25:35.033
YOURSELF OUT OF QUÊ. IT'LL TELL
00:25:35.100 --> 00:25:37.435
YOU JUST TO BE JUST TO BE CLEAR.
00:25:37.502 --> 00:25:38.370
WE ARE TAKING UP POSITION
00:25:38.436 --> 00:25:40.739
TESTIMONY. ON A B 23 05 BY
00:25:40.805 --> 00:25:42.941
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON. IF
00:25:43.008 --> 00:25:43.875
YOU'RE HERE FOR THE NEXT BILL,
00:25:43.942 --> 00:25:45.810
IF YOU COULD JUST HOLD BACK AND
00:25:45.877 --> 00:25:47.078
WE'LL GET TO YOU SHORTLY. ALL
00:25:47.145 --> 00:25:50.548
RIGHT. AGAIN I APOLOGIZE. THERE
00:25:50.615 --> 00:25:52.651
WAS SO MANY PEOPLE SAYING THAT
00:25:52.717 --> 00:25:53.919
THAT I THOUGHT WERE DIFFERENT.
00:25:53.985 --> 00:25:55.954
ALL RIGHT. WE'LL GO TO LINE 1
00:25:56.021 --> 00:26:04.129
68, YOU ARE OPEN. 0.1 68. OKAY
00:26:04.195 --> 00:26:08.566
WE'LL MOVE ALONG TO LINE 1 61.
00:26:08.633 --> 00:26:12.671
YES. CAN YOU HEAR ME? WE CAN.
00:26:12.737 --> 00:26:15.206
YES THIS IS ED REYES IRONWORKERS
00:26:15.273 --> 00:26:17.008
. LOCAL 3 77 STRONG OPPOSED TO
00:26:17.075 --> 00:26:22.113
THE BILL. 2011 OKAY. I HATE TO
00:26:22.180 --> 00:26:24.549
DO THIS, BUT I THINK WE'RE GOING
00:26:24.616 --> 00:26:25.817
TO, UH, GONNA GIVE IT ONE MORE
00:26:25.884 --> 00:26:27.118
SHOT. AND IT HAPPENS, THINKING
00:26:27.185 --> 00:26:28.186
I'M GONNA TERMINATE PHONE PUBLIC
00:26:28.253 --> 00:26:30.422
COMMENT ON THE SPILL. SO, UH,
00:26:30.488 --> 00:26:32.290
DON'T WE TRY ONE MORE TIME? WHAT
00:26:32.357 --> 00:26:38.263
A B 23 05. LIKE THE CHAIR SAID,
00:26:38.330 --> 00:26:40.932
IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B 20
00:26:40.999 --> 00:26:43.335
OPPOSITION OPPOSITION, THE A B
00:26:43.401 --> 00:26:45.170
23 05, PLEASE PRESS 101 FALL BY
00:26:45.236 --> 00:26:49.040
ZERO. AND WE'RE GONNA GO TO LINE
00:26:49.107 --> 00:26:59.784
1 65. FIND 200. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:26:59.851 --> 00:27:01.453
ALREADY CALLED ON ME. I'M IN
00:27:01.519 --> 00:27:04.689
OPPOSITION TO ANOTHER BILL. OH,
00:27:04.756 --> 00:27:07.692
OKAY. I THINK WE'RE GOING TO
00:27:07.759 --> 00:27:09.160
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:27:09.227 --> 00:27:13.064
NOW. SO THANK YOU TO THE AUTHOR
00:27:13.131 --> 00:27:13.965
FOR AGREEING TO MAKE THIS
00:27:14.032 --> 00:27:16.267
TESTIMONY ONLY SO WE COULD
00:27:16.334 --> 00:27:17.335
START, YOU KNOW, AIRING THE
00:27:17.402 --> 00:27:20.138
ISSUES AND LOOK TOWARDS THE
00:27:20.205 --> 00:27:21.539
FUTURE. AND I WANT TO WANT TO
00:27:21.606 --> 00:27:24.809
THANK BOTH THE CONTROL AROUND
00:27:24.876 --> 00:27:27.312
TODAY AND FOR THE WORK THAT THAT
00:27:27.379 --> 00:27:29.114
YOU DO, AND AS I'VE EXPRESSED TO
00:27:29.180 --> 00:27:31.649
BOTH OF YOU INTO THE AUTHOR, UM
00:27:31.716 --> 00:27:33.151
OUR HOUSING COMMITTEE STAFF WILL
00:27:33.218 --> 00:27:35.520
BE AVAILABLE OVER THE FALL
00:27:35.587 --> 00:27:37.789
RECESSED IF WE CAN BE HELPFUL IN
00:27:37.856 --> 00:27:39.724
ANY WAY TO HELP CONVENE AND
00:27:39.791 --> 00:27:42.127
FACILITATE DISCUSSIONS. I THINK
00:27:42.193 --> 00:27:44.429
WE ALL HAVE THE SAME GOAL OF
00:27:44.496 --> 00:27:45.997
HAVING THE MOST EFFICIENT AND
00:27:46.064 --> 00:27:47.432
EFFECTIVE SYSTEM OF FUNDING
00:27:47.499 --> 00:27:49.768
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. I KNOW THERE
00:27:49.834 --> 00:27:51.369
ARE SOME DISPUTES BUT WERE
00:27:51.436 --> 00:27:55.040
AVAILABLE TO HELP IF THAT WOULD
00:27:55.106 --> 00:27:57.809
BE HELPFUL. SO AGAIN, THANK YOU,
00:27:57.876 --> 00:28:00.045
THE AUTHOR, AND IF YOU WANT TO
00:28:00.111 --> 00:28:00.745
MAKE SOME CLOSING REMARKS, I
00:28:00.812 --> 00:28:01.780
WOULD WELCOME THEM. THANK YOU,
00:28:01.846 --> 00:28:03.982
MR CHAIR, AND IT KIND OF SOUNDS
00:28:04.049 --> 00:28:05.216
LIKE WE KNOW THE PREVIEW OF
00:28:05.283 --> 00:28:07.118
WHICH YOUR NEXT BILL IS GOING TO
00:28:07.185 --> 00:28:09.220
BE SO UH, WITH THAT, I'LL BE
00:28:09.287 --> 00:28:10.488
SURE TO MY CLOSING STATEMENTS. I
00:28:10.555 --> 00:28:12.223
DO WANT TO STATE THAT OVER 22
00:28:12.290 --> 00:28:13.558
NIGHTS ON THE ROAD LAST FALL,
00:28:13.625 --> 00:28:15.160
DOING A HOUSING WORKING GROUP
00:28:15.226 --> 00:28:16.795
TOUR FROM CHICO ALL THE WAY TO
00:28:16.861 --> 00:28:18.563
SAN DIEGO AND EVERY SINGLE STOP
00:28:18.630 --> 00:28:20.498
THIS ISSUE THAT MAY BE 23
00:28:20.565 --> 00:28:21.633
MODERATOR. COULD YOU PLEASE MUTE
00:28:21.699 --> 00:28:25.003
THE LINES? THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
00:28:25.070 --> 00:28:29.174
MR CHAIR. THIS ISSUE THAT D<c.cyan></c>
00:28:29.240 --> 00:28:33.711
ALRIGHT, I'LL FIND HIM. OKAY,
00:28:33.778 --> 00:28:40.885
THERE IS ONE MOMENT. ONE MOMENT,
00:28:40.952 --> 00:28:51.262
PLEASE. SORRY. GREAT SORRY. ALL
00:28:51.329 --> 00:28:52.864
RIGHT. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. I
00:28:52.931 --> 00:28:54.699
JUST WANTED TO STATE THAT EVERY
00:28:54.766 --> 00:28:57.902
SINGLE STOP THAT WE DID THIS
00:28:57.969 --> 00:29:00.071
LISTENING TO HER. THIS ISSUE
00:29:00.138 --> 00:29:02.307
THAT A B 23 05 ADDRESSES WAS IN
00:29:02.373 --> 00:29:04.242
THE TOP THREE CONSISTENTLY IN
00:29:04.309 --> 00:29:06.778
EVERY SINGLE STOP. SO AFFORDABLE
00:29:06.845 --> 00:29:08.680
HOUSING DEVELOPERS HAVE THEIR
00:29:08.746 --> 00:29:10.048
REASONS WHY THEY MAY NOT WANT TO
00:29:10.115 --> 00:29:11.816
COME OUT PUBLICLY IN A SETTING
00:29:11.883 --> 00:29:13.051
LIKE THIS AND STATE THEIR
00:29:13.118 --> 00:29:14.853
POSITION, BUT I DO WANT TO JUST
00:29:14.919 --> 00:29:17.355
SIMPLY SAY O HELP THE STATE
00:29:17.422 --> 00:29:18.356
CRAFT BETTER, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:29:18.423 --> 00:29:19.491
STRATEGY AND IMPROVE OPERATIONS.
00:29:19.557 --> 00:29:20.925
CALIFORNIA SHOULD CONSOLIDATE
00:29:20.992 --> 00:29:22.694
HOUSING FUNCTIONS. THE STATE
00:29:22.760 --> 00:29:24.395
SHOULD ALSO CONSIDER FORMALIZING
00:29:24.462 --> 00:29:26.331
A STRATEGIC WORKING RELATIONSHIP
00:29:26.397 --> 00:29:28.366
EITHER BY THE LEGISLATURE OR
00:29:28.433 --> 00:29:29.601
THROUGH MOU IS AMONG THE
00:29:29.667 --> 00:29:30.735
AGENCIES SO IT'S MY SINCERE
00:29:30.802 --> 00:29:32.937
HOPE. THAT WE LISTEN TO THE
00:29:33.004 --> 00:29:35.306
VOICES OF HOUSING FINANCE REFORM
00:29:35.373 --> 00:29:36.174
IN THE FUTURE, AND I REALLY
00:29:36.241 --> 00:29:38.409
APPRECIATE YOU AND ALLOWING THIS
00:29:38.476 --> 00:29:40.745
TESTIMONY HEARING AND THE STAFF
00:29:40.812 --> 00:29:42.046
AS WELL. WANT TO RECOGNIZE THE
00:29:42.113 --> 00:29:43.915
GREAT WORK OF BOTH OUR TREASURE?
00:29:43.982 --> 00:29:46.050
CALIFORNIA STATE TREASURER AND
00:29:46.117 --> 00:29:46.951
OUR CONTROLLER. BOTH ARE GREAT
00:29:47.018 --> 00:29:48.019
INDIVIDUALS DOING GOOD WORK.
00:29:48.086 --> 00:29:50.788
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:29:50.855 --> 00:29:53.291
OKAY TESTIMONY ONLY SO THAT WILL
00:29:53.358 --> 00:29:56.261
END THIS ITEM. WE WILL NOW GO TO
00:29:56.327 --> 00:29:58.496
ITEM NUMBER TWO. JUST A TINY
00:29:58.563 --> 00:30:02.400
LITTLE BILL. UM A B 2011
00:30:02.467 --> 00:30:04.068
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WORKS WELCOME.
00:30:04.135 --> 00:30:10.275
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. AND.
00:30:10.341 --> 00:30:11.442
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE BY THE
00:30:11.509 --> 00:30:15.346
SOUNDS OF THE VOICES ON THE
00:30:15.413 --> 00:30:17.048
PHONE. THIS IS NOT GOING TO BE A
00:30:17.115 --> 00:30:18.750
CONSENT. I TAKE IT, HUH? UM
00:30:18.816 --> 00:30:21.219
MAYBE NOT THIS TIME. YEAH I
00:30:21.286 --> 00:30:24.556
WANNA TALK ABOUT A B 2011. THE
00:30:24.622 --> 00:30:26.024
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND HIGH
00:30:26.090 --> 00:30:27.525
ROADS JOBS ACT, A BILL SPONSORED
00:30:27.592 --> 00:30:29.160
BY THE CARPENTERS, UNION AND
00:30:29.227 --> 00:30:31.196
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPERS
00:30:31.262 --> 00:30:32.730
WITH SUPPORT FROM A WIDE ARRAY
00:30:32.797 --> 00:30:34.332
OF LABOR ORGANIZATIONS, SOCIAL
00:30:34.399 --> 00:30:35.833
JUSTICE GROUPS, BUSINESS GROUPS,
00:30:35.900 --> 00:30:36.434
UNION CONTRACTORS,
00:30:36.501 --> 00:30:37.435
TRANSPORTATION ADVOCATES,
00:30:37.502 --> 00:30:39.537
ENVIRONMENTALISTS. HOUSING
00:30:39.604 --> 00:30:41.439
DEVELOPERS, CIVIC GROUPS AND
00:30:41.506 --> 00:30:43.541
FAITH BASED ORGANIZATIONS.
00:30:43.608 --> 00:30:45.243
BEFORE I TELL YOU ABOUT THE
00:30:45.310 --> 00:30:46.644
DETAILS OF THE BILL, I WANT TO
00:30:46.711 --> 00:30:48.613
TALK TO YOU ABOUT WHY? I THINK
00:30:48.680 --> 00:30:50.448
THIS BILL IS SO IPORTANT. WE
00:30:50.515 --> 00:30:51.549
HAVE A HOUSING CRISIS THAT IS
00:30:51.616 --> 00:30:52.817
OUT OF CONTROL. I KNOW THAT THAT
00:30:52.884 --> 00:30:55.353
TALKING POINT IS REFERENCED MANY
00:30:55.420 --> 00:30:56.487
TIMES IN THIS COMMITTEE AS WELL
00:30:56.554 --> 00:30:57.555
AS IN MY COMMITTEE AND THE
00:30:57.622 --> 00:31:00.024
ASSEMBLY. BUT IT'S TRUE AND IT'S
00:31:00.091 --> 00:31:01.259
A MORAL IMPERATIVE THAT WE
00:31:01.326 --> 00:31:02.760
REALLY TACKLE THIS ISSUE. WE
00:31:02.827 --> 00:31:03.928
HAVE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:31:03.995 --> 00:31:05.730
PEOPLE SLEEPING ON THE STREETS,
00:31:05.797 --> 00:31:06.898
80% OF LOW INCOME TENANTS CAN
00:31:06.965 --> 00:31:08.800
ONLY PAY THEIR RENT IF THEY
00:31:08.866 --> 00:31:10.335
SACRIFICE OTHER BASIC
00:31:10.401 --> 00:31:10.802
NECESSITIES LIKE FOOD,
00:31:10.868 --> 00:31:12.670
EDUCATION, HEALTH CARE. THE
00:31:12.737 --> 00:31:14.072
MEDIAN PRICE OF BUYING A HOUSE
00:31:14.138 --> 00:31:16.207
IN CALIFORNIA IS NOW OVER 100
00:31:16.274 --> 00:31:18.776
NOW OVER $800,000, MEANING THE
00:31:18.843 --> 00:31:20.511
AMERICAN DREAM OF HOME OWNERSHIP
00:31:20.578 --> 00:31:21.512
IS ONLY AVAILABLE TO THE RICHEST
00:31:21.579 --> 00:31:23.314
CALIFORNIANS. POLLING
00:31:23.381 --> 00:31:24.515
CONTINUOUSLY SHOWS THAT HOUSING
00:31:24.582 --> 00:31:25.516
AND HOMELESSNESS ARE
00:31:25.583 --> 00:31:27.685
CALIFORNIA'S TOP TWO CONCERNS.
00:31:27.752 --> 00:31:29.854
AT THE SAME TIME, WE NEED TO
00:31:29.921 --> 00:31:30.722
BUILD OUR CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE
00:31:30.788 --> 00:31:32.490
BACK IN THE SEVENTIES, EIGHTIES
00:31:32.557 --> 00:31:33.258
AND NINETIES, WE REGULARLY BUILT
00:31:33.324 --> 00:31:35.260
MORE THAN 200,000 UNITS A YEAR.
00:31:35.326 --> 00:31:36.794
BACK THEN, THOSE WERE HIGH HIGH
00:31:36.861 --> 00:31:38.496
WAGE JOBS THAT WERE INCREDIBLE
00:31:38.563 --> 00:31:39.530
PATHWAY TO THE MIDDLE CLASS
00:31:39.597 --> 00:31:41.933
LIFE. NOW WE REGULARLY BUILD
00:31:42.000 --> 00:31:43.468
FEWER THAN 100,000 UNITS PER
00:31:43.534 --> 00:31:45.036
YEAR AND UNLESS YOU ARE
00:31:45.103 --> 00:31:45.937
FORTUNATE ENOUGH TO BE WORKING
00:31:46.004 --> 00:31:48.139
ON A PUBLIC, UH ON A PUBLIC WORK
00:31:48.206 --> 00:31:49.340
OR UNIONIZED CONSTRUCTION JOB,
00:31:49.407 --> 00:31:51.476
IT'S LIKELY YOU ARE WORKING IN
00:31:51.542 --> 00:31:52.610
LOW WAGES AND POTENTIALLY BEING
00:31:52.677 --> 00:31:54.946
EXPLOITED. FINALLY WE HAVE TO
00:31:55.013 --> 00:31:56.147
TALK ABOUT HOW THIS RELATES TO
00:31:56.214 --> 00:31:58.983
CLIMATE CHANGE. AS THE MOTHER OF
00:31:59.050 --> 00:32:00.285
TWO YOUNG DAUGHTERS. I'M
00:32:00.351 --> 00:32:00.985
TERRIFIED OF WHAT THE FUTURE
00:32:01.052 --> 00:32:03.154
HOLDS FOR THEM. I NEED TO BE
00:32:03.221 --> 00:32:05.056
ABLE TO LOOK THEM IN THE EYE AND
00:32:05.123 --> 00:32:06.858
TELL THEM AS SOMEONE WHO WAS IN
00:32:06.924 --> 00:32:08.426
A POSITION OF LEADERSHIP THAT IS
00:32:08.493 --> 00:32:10.495
ABLE TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE THAT I
00:32:10.561 --> 00:32:11.596
DID EVERYTHING IN MY POWER WHEN
00:32:11.663 --> 00:32:13.097
THERE WAS STILL TIME TO DO SO.
00:32:13.164 --> 00:32:15.533
WHEN I WAS TELLING MY FIVE YEAR
00:32:15.600 --> 00:32:16.200
OLD DAUGHTER ABOUT THIS BILL AND
00:32:16.267 --> 00:32:17.869
COMMITTEE TODAY, SHE ASKED ME TO
00:32:17.935 --> 00:32:19.304
WEAR THE BRACELET SHE MET MADE
00:32:19.370 --> 00:32:21.239
ME THAT SAYS MAMA ON IT, AND SHE
00:32:21.306 --> 00:32:23.007
SAID, GOOD LUCK, MAMA, GO PAST
00:32:23.074 --> 00:32:24.942
THE BILL. SO WITH JOJO SUPPORT
00:32:25.009 --> 00:32:25.777
AND AS THE CHAIR OF THE HOUSING
00:32:25.843 --> 00:32:28.112
COMMITTEE, WHAT I CAN DO IS
00:32:28.179 --> 00:32:28.680
INTRODUCE BOLD LEGISLATION
00:32:28.746 --> 00:32:29.447
FORCING NECESSARY BUT SOMETIMES
00:32:29.514 --> 00:32:30.381
UNCOMFORTABLE CONVERSATIONS TO
00:32:30.448 --> 00:32:31.449
PROMOTE THE HOUSING OF THE
00:32:31.516 --> 00:32:34.986
FUTURE. HOUSING NEAR JOBS AND
00:32:35.053 --> 00:32:36.120
TRANSPORTATION THAT ALLOWS US TO
00:32:36.187 --> 00:32:38.523
SLASH OUR CARBON EMISSIONS. THIS
00:32:38.589 --> 00:32:39.824
BILL AIMS TO ADDRESS ALL OF
00:32:39.891 --> 00:32:40.825
THESE PROBLEMS WHEN MAKING IT
00:32:40.892 --> 00:32:42.827
EASIER TO BUILD HOUSING AT SCALE
00:32:42.894 --> 00:32:43.761
IN CLIMATE FRIENDLY LOCATIONS,
00:32:43.828 --> 00:32:45.363
USING HIGH ROAD LABOR STANDARDS
00:32:45.430 --> 00:32:45.930
THAT PROTECT AND UPLIFT OUR
00:32:45.997 --> 00:32:47.365
EXISTING WORKERS, WHILE
00:32:47.432 --> 00:32:48.232
SIMULTANEOUSLY GROWING A WHOLE
00:32:48.299 --> 00:32:49.901
NEW GENERATION. OF HIGHLY
00:32:49.967 --> 00:32:52.036
TRAINED WOMEN AND MEN. HOW WILL
00:32:52.103 --> 00:32:53.271
WE DO THAT BY MAKING AFFORDABLE
00:32:53.338 --> 00:32:55.073
AND MIXED INCOME, MULTI FAMILY
00:32:55.139 --> 00:32:56.207
HOUSING A USE BY RIGHT AND AREAS
00:32:56.274 --> 00:32:57.809
THAT ARE APPROPRIATE FOR HOUSING
00:32:57.875 --> 00:32:58.976
, BUT WHERE IT IS CURRENTLY
00:32:59.043 --> 00:32:59.977
DIFFICULT OR IMPOSSIBLE TO
00:33:00.044 --> 00:33:01.846
BUILD. BY BEING BY RIGHT
00:33:01.913 --> 00:33:03.681
DEVELOPERS CAN MOVE FORWARD
00:33:03.748 --> 00:33:04.849
WITHOUT THIS SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT
00:33:04.916 --> 00:33:06.718
OF RED TAPE THAT INCREASED COSTS
00:33:06.784 --> 00:33:08.353
AND KILLS MANY VIABLE PROJECTS
00:33:08.419 --> 00:33:09.654
OR TAKES THEM YEARS AND YEARS
00:33:09.721 --> 00:33:11.689
AND YEARS TO EVEN BREAK GROUND.
00:33:11.756 --> 00:33:14.025
WE'RE TAKING THE COST SAVINGS BY
00:33:14.092 --> 00:33:14.759
ALLOWING HOUSING BY RIGHT AND
00:33:14.826 --> 00:33:16.728
GIVING IT BACK IN THE FORM OF
00:33:16.794 --> 00:33:17.729
MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND%
00:33:17.795 --> 00:33:19.097
BETTER PAY FOR THE CONSTRUCTION
00:33:19.163 --> 00:33:20.932
WORKFORCE FOR 100% AFFORDABLE
00:33:20.998 --> 00:33:22.867
PROJECTS. BRINGING DOWN THE COST
00:33:22.934 --> 00:33:24.068
MEANS THAT OUR MONEY OUR PUBLIC
00:33:24.135 --> 00:33:25.670
MONEY GOES FURTHER. FOR ALL
00:33:25.737 --> 00:33:27.071
THEIR PROJECTS. WE'RE REQUIRING
00:33:27.138 --> 00:33:29.040
THAT 15% OF THE UNITS WOULD NEED
00:33:29.107 --> 00:33:30.908
TO BE AFFORDABLE TO LOWER INCOME
00:33:30.975 --> 00:33:32.076
HOUSEHOLDS OR 30% MATTER INCOME
00:33:32.143 --> 00:33:34.178
FOR HOMEOWNERSHIP. THIS
00:33:34.245 --> 00:33:35.780
REQUIREMENT COULD RESULT IN AN
00:33:35.847 --> 00:33:37.048
EXTRAORDINARY AMOUNT OF NEW
00:33:37.115 --> 00:33:37.849
AFFORDABLE UNITS WITHOUT
00:33:37.915 --> 00:33:39.984
REQUIRING PUBLIC SUBSIDIES. AS
00:33:40.051 --> 00:33:42.220
FOR WHERE THE HOUSING CAN GO, IT
00:33:42.286 --> 00:33:43.121
WOULD NEED TO BE LOCATED IN
00:33:43.187 --> 00:33:44.722
AREAS THAT CURRENTLY ALLOW
00:33:44.789 --> 00:33:45.690
RETAIL OFFICE BUILDINGS OR
00:33:45.757 --> 00:33:47.592
PARKING LOTS. FURTHERMORE MIXED
00:33:47.658 --> 00:33:49.160
INCOME HOUSING WOULD BE LIMITED
00:33:49.227 --> 00:33:50.027
TO COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS.
00:33:50.094 --> 00:33:53.097
AESTHETICALLY THOSE STREETS UH,
00:33:53.164 --> 00:33:55.066
THOSE STREETS THAT IN MOST
00:33:55.133 --> 00:33:55.633
CITIES ARE LINED WITH STRIP
00:33:55.700 --> 00:33:57.435
MALLS. CURRENTLY THOSE STREETS
00:33:57.502 --> 00:34:00.071
UM UH, IN MOST CITIES ARE LINED
00:34:00.138 --> 00:34:02.039
WITH STRIP MALLS AND LOTS OF
00:34:02.106 --> 00:34:03.141
PARKING THE PERFECT PLACE TO
00:34:03.207 --> 00:34:04.542
ALLOW A LOT OF HOUSING. BECAUSE
00:34:04.609 --> 00:34:05.643
THE SITES NEED TO ALLOW
00:34:05.710 --> 00:34:07.278
COMMERCIAL USE. WE ARE DIRECTING
00:34:07.345 --> 00:34:08.946
ANY NEW HOUSING AWAY FROM SINGLE
00:34:09.013 --> 00:34:10.314
FAMILY NEIGHBORHOODS, AND I KNOW
00:34:10.381 --> 00:34:12.150
THAT THAT ISSUE IS A POLITICALLY
00:34:12.216 --> 00:34:14.285
CHALLENGED ONE IN IN BOTH OF OUR
00:34:14.352 --> 00:34:16.821
BODIES. I ALSO WANT TO SAY THAT
00:34:16.888 --> 00:34:18.289
THE LABOR STANDARDS IN THIS BILL
00:34:18.356 --> 00:34:19.957
ARE DESIGNED TO CREATE TENS OF
00:34:20.024 --> 00:34:21.426
THOUSANDS OF HIGH ROAD HIGH
00:34:21.492 --> 00:34:23.294
PAYING JOBS. ALL WORKERS WILL BE
00:34:23.361 --> 00:34:24.695
PAID PREVAILING WAGE, ENABLING
00:34:24.762 --> 00:34:26.264
OUR HARD WORKING MEN AND WOMEN
00:34:26.330 --> 00:34:28.566
TO LEAD A MIDDLE CLASS LIFE ALL
00:34:28.633 --> 00:34:29.600
WORKERS WHERE WE WOULD BE
00:34:29.667 --> 00:34:30.802
PROTECTED FROM WAGE THEFT. WHICH
00:34:30.868 --> 00:34:33.037
AS WE KNOW, IN THE INDUSTRY AND
00:34:33.104 --> 00:34:33.571
THE HOUSING CONSTRUCTION
00:34:33.638 --> 00:34:34.939
INDUSTRY, IT IS THERE
00:34:35.006 --> 00:34:36.707
SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGES AND THESE
00:34:36.774 --> 00:34:38.042
WORKERS GET EXPLOITED EVERY
00:34:38.109 --> 00:34:40.378
SINGLE DAY, SO THIS WOULD BE THE
00:34:40.445 --> 00:34:41.379
STRONGEST WAGE THEFT PRODUCTIONS
00:34:41.446 --> 00:34:42.914
IN THE COUNTRY. IF A PROJECT IS
00:34:42.980 --> 00:34:44.015
50, OR MORE UNITS, THEY WOULD
00:34:44.081 --> 00:34:45.149
NEED TO BRING IN APPRENTICESHIPS
00:34:45.216 --> 00:34:47.018
TO HELP BUILD THE PROJECT AND
00:34:47.084 --> 00:34:48.186
GROW THE NEXT GENERATION OF
00:34:48.252 --> 00:34:49.287
SKILLED CRAFTSPEOPLE.
00:34:49.353 --> 00:34:50.721
ESSENTIALLY THIS BILL MEANS THAT
00:34:50.788 --> 00:34:52.590
A RISING TIDE LIFTS ALL BOATS.
00:34:52.657 --> 00:34:54.559
THIS IS A BOLD BILL, BUT I THINK
00:34:54.625 --> 00:34:56.294
A VERY PRACTICAL ONE THE STATUS
00:34:56.360 --> 00:34:57.929
QUO WE KNOW ISN'T WORKING. WE
00:34:57.995 --> 00:34:58.596
NEED TO DO EVERYTHING WE
00:34:58.663 --> 00:35:01.098
POSSIBLY CAN RIGHT NOW TO HOUSE
00:35:01.165 --> 00:35:01.732
OUR HOMELESS GROW OUR MIDDLE
00:35:01.799 --> 00:35:04.702
INCOME WORKFORCE CREATE BETTER
00:35:04.769 --> 00:35:07.572
PAYING JOBS AND HOUSES ARE FOLKS
00:35:07.638 --> 00:35:09.140
THAT ARE CURRENTLY LIVING ON
00:35:09.207 --> 00:35:10.441
THEIR STREETS. AND I THINK THIS
00:35:10.508 --> 00:35:12.310
BILL IS A WIN WIN WIN AND MANY
00:35:12.376 --> 00:35:13.811
REGARDS AND I ALSO WANT TO SAY
00:35:13.878 --> 00:35:16.147
I'VE HAD ONGOING CONVERSATIONS
00:35:16.214 --> 00:35:16.747
WITH THE OPPOSITION. I WELCOME
00:35:16.814 --> 00:35:17.915
THOSE I'VE SPOKEN TO EVERY
00:35:17.982 --> 00:35:18.850
MEMBER ON THIS COMMITTEE. I
00:35:18.916 --> 00:35:20.318
ELCOME THOSE CONVERSATIONS. I'M
00:35:20.384 --> 00:35:21.285
NOT TRYING TO MAKE PERFECT ENEMY
00:35:21.352 --> 00:35:22.753
OF THE GOOD. I'M TRYING TO
00:35:22.820 --> 00:35:24.222
CREATE A GOOD BILL AS HOUSING
00:35:24.288 --> 00:35:25.823
CHAIR OF THE ASSEMBLY. I DON'T
00:35:25.890 --> 00:35:28.226
WANT TO PRESIDE OVER A NURSE OR
00:35:28.292 --> 00:35:28.893
STATUS QUO. I WANT TO GET SOME
00:35:28.960 --> 00:35:30.962
STUFF DONE TO TAKE CARE OF OUR
00:35:31.028 --> 00:35:33.164
CONSTITUENTS. AND I KNOW WE ALL
00:35:33.231 --> 00:35:34.398
SHARE THAT COMMON GOAL WITH ME
00:35:34.465 --> 00:35:36.167
HERE TO TESTIFY AS J. BRADSHAW
00:35:36.234 --> 00:35:37.301
EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF THE
00:35:37.368 --> 00:35:37.935
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CARPENTER'S
00:35:38.002 --> 00:35:38.569
UNION. AND MARINA WHITE, WHO'S
00:35:38.636 --> 00:35:39.770
VP OF GOVERNMENT AFFAIRS FOR THE
00:35:39.837 --> 00:35:40.705
HOUSING, CALIFORNIA'S IN
00:35:40.771 --> 00:35:44.075
CONSORTIUM. YOU MAKE IT
00:35:44.141 --> 00:35:47.345
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR
00:35:47.411 --> 00:35:48.179
MARINA WHITE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:35:48.246 --> 00:35:49.814
HOUSING CAN SOURCE HIM. CHC IS A
00:35:49.881 --> 00:35:51.349
NONPARTISAN ADVOCATE FOR THE
00:35:51.415 --> 00:35:52.717
PRODUCTION AND PRESERVATION OF
00:35:52.783 --> 00:35:53.684
HOUSING AFFORDABLE TO LOW AND
00:35:53.751 --> 00:35:55.786
MODERATE INCOME HOUSEHOLDS AND
00:35:55.853 --> 00:35:57.421
COMMITTED TO THE GOAL THAT EVERY
00:35:57.488 --> 00:35:58.356
CALIFORNIA HAVE A SAFE,
00:35:58.422 --> 00:35:59.390
AFFORDABLE PLACE TO CALL HOME.
00:35:59.457 --> 00:36:00.758
DESPITE THE LEGISLATURES CAN
00:36:00.825 --> 00:36:01.759
DEMONSTRATED COMMITMENT TO
00:36:01.826 --> 00:36:03.227
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. CALIFORNIA
00:36:03.294 --> 00:36:04.629
CONTINUES TO FACE A SHORTFALL OF
00:36:04.695 --> 00:36:06.130
OVER ONE MILLION HOMES
00:36:06.197 --> 00:36:07.598
AFFORDABLE TO THE STATES LOWEST
00:36:07.665 --> 00:36:09.700
INCOME HOUSEHOLDS OVER THE PAST
00:36:09.767 --> 00:36:10.835
TWO YEARS, CHC HAS WORKED
00:36:10.902 --> 00:36:12.737
CLOSELY WITH MEMBERS AND OTHER
00:36:12.803 --> 00:36:13.504
STAKEHOLDERS TO TRY TO DEVELOP
00:36:13.571 --> 00:36:14.705
SOLUTIONS THAT MATCH THE SCALE
00:36:14.772 --> 00:36:15.740
OF OUR STATE'S HOUSING
00:36:15.806 --> 00:36:17.308
CHALLENGES. WE HAVE REPEATEDLY
00:36:17.375 --> 00:36:18.242
COMMITTED TO FINDING
00:36:18.309 --> 00:36:19.544
COLLABORATIVE SOLUTIONS THAT
00:36:19.610 --> 00:36:21.112
SIGNIFICANTLY EXPAND ACCESS TO
00:36:21.178 --> 00:36:22.813
WELL PAYING JOBS FOR WORKERS ALL
00:36:22.880 --> 00:36:24.649
OVER THE STATE, WHILE ALSO AT
00:36:24.715 --> 00:36:25.883
THE SAME TIME, INCREASING
00:36:25.950 --> 00:36:26.584
HOUSING PRODUCTION FOR
00:36:26.651 --> 00:36:28.920
CALIFORNIA'S MOST VULNERABLE IN
00:36:28.986 --> 00:36:30.488
THESE CONVERSATIONS, WE HAVE
00:36:30.555 --> 00:36:31.856
NOTED TWO CRITICAL ISSUES FOR
00:36:31.923 --> 00:36:33.057
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROVIDERS. WE
00:36:33.124 --> 00:36:34.025
BELIEVE DEVELOPMENTS RECEIVING
00:36:34.091 --> 00:36:35.693
NEW LAND USE BENEFITS SHOULD
00:36:35.760 --> 00:36:37.695
CREATE STEADY, WELL PAYING JOBS
00:36:37.762 --> 00:36:38.796
AND HELP BUILD THE MIDDLE CLASS
00:36:38.863 --> 00:36:40.064
CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE EVERY
00:36:40.131 --> 00:36:41.666
COMMUNITY NEEDS AND WE ALSO
00:36:41.732 --> 00:36:42.733
RECOGNIZE THE PROJECTS CAN'T
00:36:42.800 --> 00:36:44.235
MOVE FORWARD IF CONSTRUCTION
00:36:44.302 --> 00:36:45.670
WORKERS ARE NOT AVAILABLE, A
00:36:45.736 --> 00:36:46.737
REAL AND GROWING CHALLENGE IN
00:36:46.804 --> 00:36:48.706
MANY PARTS OF THE STATE. IN OUR
00:36:48.773 --> 00:36:50.841
VIEW, A B 2011 FINALLY STRIKES
00:36:50.908 --> 00:36:52.410
THIS RIGHT BALANCE. AND FOR THAT
00:36:52.476 --> 00:36:53.945
REASON I'M HONORED TO BE HERE
00:36:54.011 --> 00:36:55.813
TODAY AS A CO SPONSOR OF THIS
00:36:55.880 --> 00:36:56.380
IMPORTANT LEGISLATION, MAYBE
00:36:56.447 --> 00:36:59.250
2011 PAIRS THE ABILITY TO BUILD
00:36:59.317 --> 00:36:59.750
HOUSING ON UNDERUTILIZED
00:36:59.817 --> 00:37:00.751
COMMERCIAL SITES WITH STRONG
00:37:00.818 --> 00:37:02.386
LABOR STANDARDS THAT ENSURE ALL
00:37:02.453 --> 00:37:03.254
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS AND
00:37:03.321 --> 00:37:04.455
PREVAILING WAGES AND RECEIVE
00:37:04.522 --> 00:37:06.624
HEALTH BENEFITS. THE BILL ALSO
00:37:06.691 --> 00:37:08.292
INCLUDES WORKABLE OFF RAMPS. IT
00:37:08.359 --> 00:37:09.060
GIVES WORKERS AND STATE APPROVED
00:37:09.126 --> 00:37:10.328
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS THE
00:37:10.394 --> 00:37:11.963
FIRST SHOT AT THOSE JOBS, BUT IF
00:37:12.029 --> 00:37:14.231
AND WHEN THEY ARE NOT READILY
00:37:14.298 --> 00:37:15.299
AVAILABLE, IT ALLOWS THESE VITAL
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:17.301
PROJECTS TO PROCEED. THE BILL
00:37:17.368 --> 00:37:18.235
HAS THE POTENTIAL TO OPEN
00:37:18.302 --> 00:37:19.437
THOUSANDS OF NEW SITES,
00:37:19.503 --> 00:37:20.438
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND TO
00:37:20.504 --> 00:37:21.939
RAPIDLY ACCELERATE HOUSING
00:37:22.006 --> 00:37:23.341
PRODUCTION ALL INCOME LEVELS,
00:37:23.407 --> 00:37:24.442
PARTICULARLY FOR LOW LOWER
00:37:24.508 --> 00:37:28.779
INCOME CALIFORNIANS. A B 2011 IS
00:37:28.846 --> 00:37:29.914
CRITICAL TO HELPING US CLOSE OUR
00:37:29.981 --> 00:37:31.816
TREMENDOUS AFFORDABILITY GAP AND
00:37:31.882 --> 00:37:32.917
ENSURE THE LOWER INCOME
00:37:32.984 --> 00:37:34.285
CALIFORNIANS HAVE ACCESS TO
00:37:34.352 --> 00:37:35.186
SAFE, STABLE, AFFORDABLE PLACES
00:37:35.252 --> 00:37:37.021
TO CALL HOME IN EVERY COMMUNITY
00:37:37.088 --> 00:37:38.255
ACROSS THE STRAIT. AND FOR THESE
00:37:38.322 --> 00:37:40.124
REASONS, I URGE YOUR SUPPORT
00:37:40.191 --> 00:37:43.527
TODAY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:37:43.594 --> 00:37:45.563
MUCH, AND I BELIEVE J.
00:37:45.630 --> 00:37:49.667
BRADSHAW'S ON THE CARPENTERS.
00:37:49.734 --> 00:37:51.068
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND CO
00:37:51.135 --> 00:37:52.803
CHAIR. IT'S AN HONOR TO BE HERE
00:37:52.870 --> 00:37:54.171
TODAY. J. BRADSHAW EXECUTIVE
00:37:54.238 --> 00:37:56.207
OFFICER FOR THE NORTH AL
00:37:56.273 --> 00:37:56.941
CARPENTER'S UNION, REPRESENTING
00:37:57.008 --> 00:37:57.808
38,000, HARDWORKING MEN AND
00:37:57.875 --> 00:38:00.544
WOMEN IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA.
00:38:00.611 --> 00:38:01.946
UH, I WANT TO BRING JUST SOME
00:38:02.013 --> 00:38:03.714
VERY BASIC STUFF HERE TODAY AND
00:38:03.781 --> 00:38:05.750
WHY WE ARE HONORED TO CO SPONSOR
00:38:05.816 --> 00:38:08.619
THIS BILL. MAINLY WORKING CLASS
00:38:08.686 --> 00:38:10.254
FOLKS THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA ARE
00:38:10.321 --> 00:38:12.189
BEING CRUSHED BY THE HOUSING
00:38:12.256 --> 00:38:13.824
CRISIS, AND I KNOW THAT GETS
00:38:13.891 --> 00:38:15.993
TALKED ABOUT A LOT AND I THINK
00:38:16.060 --> 00:38:16.460
EVERYONE'S LOOKING FOR
00:38:16.527 --> 00:38:17.962
SOLUTIONS, BUT WHAT THAT REALLY
00:38:18.029 --> 00:38:19.730
MEANS. FOR US FROM THE CARBON
00:38:19.797 --> 00:38:21.232
SENIOR PERSPECTIVE IS THAT THE
00:38:21.298 --> 00:38:23.534
THOUSANDS OF WORKERS PRODUCING
00:38:23.601 --> 00:38:25.036
HOUSING NUMBER ONE OR GETTING
00:38:25.102 --> 00:38:27.371
HYPER EXPLOITED ON THOSE JOBS,
00:38:27.438 --> 00:38:28.806
WE BELIEVE IN REALLY LAYING OUT
00:38:28.873 --> 00:38:30.841
THE TRUTH FROM HOW WE SEE IT TO
00:38:30.908 --> 00:38:33.277
LOOK FOR REAL SOLUTIONS WITH OUR
00:38:33.344 --> 00:38:34.812
PARTNERS 90. OF HOUSING
00:38:34.879 --> 00:38:35.312
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS ARE
00:38:35.379 --> 00:38:38.916
UNORGANIZED ARE NONUNION. OUR
00:38:38.983 --> 00:38:41.085
APPROACH TO THIS IS WE NEED YOUR
00:38:41.152 --> 00:38:42.553
HELP, AND WE NEED TO HELP FROM
00:38:42.620 --> 00:38:43.054
OUR REPRESENTATIVES AND
00:38:43.120 --> 00:38:44.422
GOVERNMENT TO RAISE THE
00:38:44.488 --> 00:38:46.957
STANDARDS OF THOSE WORKERS. TRUE
00:38:47.024 --> 00:38:49.026
PREVAILING WAGES, HEALTHCARE,
00:38:49.093 --> 00:38:50.027
APPRENTICESHIP, OPPORTUNITY AND
00:38:50.094 --> 00:38:52.396
MOST IMPORTANTLY, ENFORCEMENT.
00:38:52.463 --> 00:38:54.598
TO HELP THOSE FOLKS OUT. UM WE
00:38:54.665 --> 00:38:56.934
CERTAINLY SUPPORT APPRENTICESHIP
00:38:57.001 --> 00:38:59.070
AND SKILLED AND TRAINED WORKERS
00:38:59.136 --> 00:39:00.705
AND ALL OF THAT, HOWEVER, WHEN
00:39:00.771 --> 00:39:03.140
YOU LOOK OVER A 20 YEAR RUN ALL
00:39:03.207 --> 00:39:04.275
BUILDING TRADES ONLY GRADUATED.
00:39:04.341 --> 00:39:07.845
ABOUT 122,000 WORKERS, SO THE
00:39:07.912 --> 00:39:10.181
WORKFORCE NEEDS TO BE ORGANIZED
00:39:10.247 --> 00:39:11.749
. IN ADDITION FOR WORKING PEOPLE
00:39:11.816 --> 00:39:12.650
, THE LACK OF HOUSING IS
00:39:12.717 --> 00:39:13.784
CREATING EVERY SOCIAL ILL
00:39:13.851 --> 00:39:16.520
WORKING CLASS PEOPLE ARE FACING.
00:39:16.587 --> 00:39:17.755
IT'S REALLY CREATED AND
00:39:17.822 --> 00:39:19.223
EXACERBATED THE TRANSPORTATION
00:39:19.290 --> 00:39:20.458
CRISIS FOR CONSTRUCTION WORKERS
00:39:20.524 --> 00:39:21.792
THAT HAVE TOO OFTEN TRAVEL TWO
00:39:21.859 --> 00:39:23.828
OR THREE HOURS TO THE JOBS HAS
00:39:23.894 --> 00:39:26.263
ALSO LED TO THE AFFORDABILITY
00:39:26.330 --> 00:39:27.264
AND THE CHILDCARE CRISIS. SO AT
00:39:27.331 --> 00:39:28.733
EVERY ANGLE, IT'S ROOTED IN THE
00:39:28.799 --> 00:39:29.967
HOUSING AND THE LACK OF
00:39:30.034 --> 00:39:31.135
PRODUCTION FOR HOUSING FOR
00:39:31.202 --> 00:39:32.937
WORKERS AND ACTUALLY FOLKS OF
00:39:33.003 --> 00:39:34.939
ALL INCOME LEVELS. WE BELIEVE
00:39:35.005 --> 00:39:36.907
THIS IS A PLATFORM TO NOT ONLY
00:39:36.974 --> 00:39:38.075
BRING A RAISE AND HELP THOSE
00:39:38.142 --> 00:39:40.911
WORKERS STAND UP AND GET MORE IN
00:39:40.978 --> 00:39:42.513
THE HOUSING AND WE HAVE EVERY
00:39:42.580 --> 00:39:44.415
INTENTION TO GO OUT AND SUPPORT
00:39:44.482 --> 00:39:46.283
THAT. AND TO DO THE JOB WE'RE
00:39:46.350 --> 00:39:47.918
SUPPOSED TO DO AS A UNION AND WE
00:39:47.985 --> 00:39:50.287
WILL ORGANIZE THEM. WE NEED YOU
00:39:50.354 --> 00:39:50.821
ALL TO HELP US LEVEL THAT
00:39:50.888 --> 00:39:53.491
PLAYING FIELD. WE WILL TAKE CARE
00:39:53.557 --> 00:39:54.158
OF THE ORGANIZING THE WORKERS IN
00:39:54.225 --> 00:39:56.060
THAT PROCESS THE HUNDREDS OF
00:39:56.127 --> 00:39:56.727
THOUSANDS OF WORKERS WE NEED IN
00:39:56.794 --> 00:39:58.262
CONSTRUCTION, THEIR SKILLS AND
00:39:58.329 --> 00:39:59.730
TRAINING HOUSING. WE WILL BE
00:39:59.797 --> 00:40:01.732
ABLE TO GET THAT DONE WITH THIS
00:40:01.799 --> 00:40:02.633
PLATFORM. SO AGAIN, WE THINK
00:40:02.700 --> 00:40:04.902
IT'S THE RIGHT SOLUTION. ON THE
00:40:04.969 --> 00:40:06.437
RIGHT PARTNERSHIP, AND WE HAVE
00:40:06.504 --> 00:40:07.805
TO DO SOMETHING BECAUSE IT'S
00:40:07.872 --> 00:40:09.306
CRUSHING CALIFORNIA AS A WHOLE
00:40:09.373 --> 00:40:10.808
AND ITS CRUSHING WORKING CLASS
00:40:10.875 --> 00:40:11.876
PEOPLE IN PARTICULAR WHO ARE
00:40:11.942 --> 00:40:13.077
FALLING OFF THE ROLLS AND
00:40:13.144 --> 00:40:14.845
BECOMING THE UNHAPPY HOUSED AS
00:40:14.912 --> 00:40:17.281
WELL. SO WE ASK YOU TO SUPPORT
00:40:17.348 --> 00:40:19.350
AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
00:40:19.416 --> 00:40:20.417
BILL, AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR
00:40:20.484 --> 00:40:22.153
TIME TODAY. THANKS. THANK YOU,
00:40:22.219 --> 00:40:24.221
MR. BRADSHAW UM, OKAY, SO IF
00:40:24.288 --> 00:40:25.723
THERE ARE OTHERS THAT IT LOOKS
00:40:25.790 --> 00:40:27.324
LIKE THERE ARE OTHERS IN THE
00:40:27.391 --> 00:40:28.759
ROOM IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL,
00:40:28.826 --> 00:40:30.494
PLEASE COME FORWARD AND PLEASE
00:40:30.561 --> 00:40:31.462
STATE YOUR NAME, YOUR
00:40:31.529 --> 00:40:33.397
AFFILIATION OF ANY AND THE FACT
00:40:33.464 --> 00:40:36.300
OF YOUR SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:40:36.367 --> 00:40:37.935
, PETE RODRIGUEZ, SOUTHWEST
00:40:38.002 --> 00:40:39.503
REGIONAL COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS
00:40:39.570 --> 00:40:41.438
FROM THE EXECUTIVE SECRETARY
00:40:41.505 --> 00:40:43.941
TREASURER REPRESENTING 60,000
00:40:44.008 --> 00:40:45.843
MEMBERS. WE STAND IN STRONG
00:40:45.910 --> 00:40:51.715
SUPPORT FOR A B 2000 AND 11.
00:40:51.782 --> 00:40:53.417
PIERRE WIENER VICE CHAIR BATES
00:40:53.484 --> 00:40:54.552
BOB NAYLOR, REPRESENTING FUELS
00:40:54.618 --> 00:40:59.256
THEIR IN COMPANY IN SUPPORT. MR
00:40:59.323 --> 00:41:00.424
CHAIRMAN, MEMBERS ALEX TORRES
00:41:00.491 --> 00:41:01.458
WITH THE BARRIER COUNSEL AND
00:41:01.525 --> 00:41:04.228
SUPPORT THANK YOU. MARKS THE
00:41:04.295 --> 00:41:05.596
HOURS OF THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
00:41:05.663 --> 00:41:06.497
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT. THANK
00:41:06.564 --> 00:41:09.233
YOU. RON ROULETTE NOR CAL
00:41:09.300 --> 00:41:11.969
CARPENTER'S UNION IN SUPPORT.
00:41:12.036 --> 00:41:13.871
AND AS YOU CAN YOU HOLD ON ONE
00:41:13.938 --> 00:41:15.439
SECOND TO THE MODERATOR. I'M
00:41:15.506 --> 00:41:17.308
GETTING SOME FEEDBACK THAT THERE
00:41:17.374 --> 00:41:19.176
ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE ON THE LINE
00:41:19.243 --> 00:41:21.078
WHO ARE GETTING KICKED OFF OF
00:41:21.145 --> 00:41:23.347
THE LINE. I DON'T KNOW WHAT'S
00:41:23.414 --> 00:41:24.582
GOING ON. WE HAVE LIMITS TO HOW
00:41:24.648 --> 00:41:25.683
MANY PEOPLE CAN BE ON THE LINE
00:41:25.749 --> 00:41:27.852
AT ONCE. UM BUT CAN YOU JUST
00:41:27.918 --> 00:41:29.787
CHECK INTO WHETHER THERE'S SOME
00:41:29.854 --> 00:41:30.921
SORT OF TECHNICAL ISSUE? I WANT
00:41:30.988 --> 00:41:32.857
TO MAKE SURE PEOPLE ARE ABLE TO
00:41:32.923 --> 00:41:34.658
CALL IN ABSOLUTELY. WE ARE LIKE,
00:41:34.725 --> 00:41:35.793
RIGHT AROUND 100 RIGHT NOW, SO
00:41:35.860 --> 00:41:39.263
OKAY. WHAT DO YOU SAY? WE'LL
00:41:39.330 --> 00:41:41.065
HAVE IT AT THE MAXIMUM. WE CAN.
00:41:41.131 --> 00:41:42.533
I KNOW, BUT THERE WAS SOME
00:41:42.600 --> 00:41:43.734
PEOPLE REPORTING THAT THEY'RE
00:41:43.801 --> 00:41:45.236
GETTING KICKED OFF. I WANT TO
00:41:45.302 --> 00:41:47.471
MAKE SURE WE DON'T HAVE TIME TO
00:41:47.538 --> 00:41:48.606
QUESTION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:41:48.672 --> 00:41:50.441
UM OKAY. GO AHEAD AT THE MAX.
00:41:50.507 --> 00:41:51.041
OKAY? CHRISTOPHER MARTIN ON
00:41:51.108 --> 00:41:51.942
BEHALF OF HOUSING, CALIFORNIAN
00:41:52.009 --> 00:41:55.913
SUPPORT. DEBORAH CARLSON, THE
00:41:55.980 --> 00:41:56.914
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
00:41:56.981 --> 00:42:01.452
AND SUPPORT. DAVID KIRSCH.
00:42:01.518 --> 00:42:02.219
CARPENTERS, CONTRACTORS
00:42:02.286 --> 00:42:02.820
COOPERATION COMMITTEE. STRONG
00:42:02.887 --> 00:42:08.125
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON. MR
00:42:08.192 --> 00:42:08.959
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS, TRACEY
00:42:09.026 --> 00:42:11.161
STEPHENS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:42:11.228 --> 00:42:11.629
CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYERS
00:42:11.695 --> 00:42:12.329
ASSOCIATION, ALSO IN STRONG
00:42:12.396 --> 00:42:16.834
SUPPORT. ABRAM DIAZ WITH THE
00:42:16.901 --> 00:42:17.968
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION,
00:42:18.035 --> 00:42:24.341
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH
00:42:24.408 --> 00:42:25.276
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
00:42:25.342 --> 00:42:26.744
BEHALF OF THE BLACK LEADERSHIP
00:42:26.810 --> 00:42:28.045
COUNCIL. CIVIC WELL SPUR MID
00:42:28.112 --> 00:42:29.246
PEN, HOUSING AND SANDHILL
00:42:29.313 --> 00:42:35.419
PROPERTIES AND SUPPORT. RICK
00:42:35.486 --> 00:42:37.321
SALAS, CARPENTERS, LOCAL TO 17
00:42:37.388 --> 00:42:42.693
CEMETERY, COUNTY AND SUPPORT.
00:42:42.760 --> 00:42:44.295
GOOD AFTERNOON MATTLAGE, A ON
00:42:44.361 --> 00:42:45.496
BEHALF OF STU, CALIFORNIA AND
00:42:45.562 --> 00:42:52.703
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON. FIDEL
00:42:52.770 --> 00:42:53.837
CHAVEZ, PROUD MEMBER OF NORTH
00:42:53.904 --> 00:42:56.941
CAL CARPENTER'S UNION. AND WE'RE
00:42:57.007 --> 00:42:59.043
HAPPY TO STAND HERE IN FRONT OF
00:42:59.109 --> 00:43:00.978
YOU AND SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK
00:43:01.045 --> 00:43:06.216
YOU. COLLECTING WITH THE SILICON
00:43:06.283 --> 00:43:07.217
VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP IN
00:43:07.284 --> 00:43:13.724
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME
00:43:13.791 --> 00:43:15.726
IS JOSE AMADOR FROM THE
00:43:15.793 --> 00:43:16.360
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL COUNCIL OF
00:43:16.427 --> 00:43:18.095
CARPENTERS. LOCAL 7 21, WHITTIER
00:43:18.162 --> 00:43:19.129
, CALIFORNIA AND I STRONGLY
00:43:19.196 --> 00:43:25.102
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU. 20
00:43:25.169 --> 00:43:26.003
MINUTES SOUTHWEST REGIONAL
00:43:26.070 --> 00:43:28.105
COUNCIL, THE CARPENTERS OUT OF
00:43:28.172 --> 00:43:28.906
LOCAL TWO AND THREE REPRESENTING
00:43:28.973 --> 00:43:29.940
ALMOST 7000 MEMBERS, AND WE'RE
00:43:30.007 --> 00:43:35.846
IN SUPPORT. JOSHUA CHRISTENSEN,
00:43:35.913 --> 00:43:36.847
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL COUNCIL OF
00:43:36.914 --> 00:43:42.353
CARPENTERS HERE IN SUPPORT.
00:43:42.419 --> 00:43:43.687
COREY SMITH WITH THE HOUSING
00:43:43.754 --> 00:43:44.722
ACTION, COALITION AND COALITION
00:43:44.788 --> 00:43:49.460
MEMBERS AND STRONG SUPPORT. DOUG
00:43:49.526 --> 00:43:50.894
HIGGS, SOUTHWEST REGIONAL
00:43:50.961 --> 00:43:52.296
COUNCIL CARPENTERS, LOCAL 619
00:43:52.363 --> 00:43:54.231
OUT OF SAN DIEGO HERE IN STRONG
00:43:54.298 --> 00:43:59.670
SUPPORT. CHUCK POWELL, SOUTHWEST
00:43:59.737 --> 00:44:01.071
REGIONAL COUNCIL CARPENTERS,
00:44:01.138 --> 00:44:02.373
LOCAL 661. SOME ARE STRONGLY
00:44:02.439 --> 00:44:10.481
SUPPORT. CHRISTINE CARRASCO,
00:44:10.547 --> 00:44:11.482
LOCAL 661 CINEMA, CALIFORNIA
00:44:11.548 --> 00:44:18.722
STRONG SUPPORT. NICOLA RAGES
00:44:18.789 --> 00:44:20.090
WITH THE SOUTHWEST ORIGINAL
00:44:20.157 --> 00:44:21.125
COUNCIL CARPENTERS FROM SYLMAR,
00:44:21.191 --> 00:44:22.126
CALIFORNIA, LOCAL 661 STRONGLY
00:44:22.192 --> 00:44:28.198
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON, RAY
00:44:28.265 --> 00:44:30.167
LAWSON LOCAL 562 FROM THE
00:44:30.234 --> 00:44:30.868
BEAUTIFUL CITY OF LONG BEACH,
00:44:30.934 --> 00:44:36.840
CALIFORNIA STRONG SUPPORT. SUSAN
00:44:36.907 --> 00:44:39.009
RODRIGUEZ, LOCAL 152 NORTH CAL
00:44:39.076 --> 00:44:42.546
CARPENTERS, SUPPORT OF A B 2011
00:44:42.613 --> 00:44:48.252
FROM STOCKTON, CALIFORNIA.
00:44:48.318 --> 00:44:51.221
AUGUST INDIA'S LOCAL 1968 L
00:44:51.288 --> 00:44:52.990
DRIVER LATTER'S SUPPORT OF 2011
00:44:53.057 --> 00:45:00.230
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME. CLAUDIA
00:45:00.297 --> 00:45:04.401
REVERSE CARPENTER 46. THANK YOU
00:45:04.468 --> 00:45:05.436
FOR LISTENING TO US. I'M
00:45:05.502 --> 00:45:11.809
SUPPORTED ABC. THANK YOU. JESSE
00:45:11.875 --> 00:45:13.911
PROWLS CARPENTERS, LOCAL 7 13,
00:45:13.977 --> 00:45:14.778
REPRESENTING NORTH KOREA,
00:45:14.845 --> 00:45:15.979
CARPENTERS AND WE'RE IN FAVOR OF
00:45:16.046 --> 00:45:20.884
MAYBE 2011. THANK YOU. MARIA
00:45:20.951 --> 00:45:22.286
CORONADO, SOUTHWEST REGIONAL
00:45:22.352 --> 00:45:24.054
COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS, LOCAL 661
00:45:24.121 --> 00:45:25.255
CITY OF BURBANK. WE STRONGLY
00:45:25.322 --> 00:45:30.627
SUPPORT MAYBE 2011 THANK YOU.
00:45:30.694 --> 00:45:42.106
NAZARIO MURANO LOCAL. NOT IT 109. DURING CHÁVEZ TWO FROM LOW
00:45:42.172 --> 00:45:52.649
RIGHT AND I SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:45:52.716 --> 00:45:56.553
HELLO. I'M ROSALIE O HARA. FROM
00:45:56.620 --> 00:45:58.222
HAYWARD, LOCAL 7 13 CARPENTERS.
00:45:58.288 --> 00:46:01.425
AND I SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK
00:46:01.492 --> 00:46:08.165
YOU. JOSH GARCIA, NORTH CAL
00:46:08.232 --> 00:46:09.533
CARPENTERS, APOLLO DRIVERS,
00:46:09.600 --> 00:46:15.572
LOCAL 34 SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
00:46:15.639 --> 00:46:17.741
SAMUEL MUNOZ, CARPENTERS, LOCAL
00:46:17.808 --> 00:46:20.310
405 AND SAN JOSE STRONGLY AND
00:46:20.377 --> 00:46:22.212
SUPPORT A OF A B 2011. THANK
00:46:22.279 --> 00:46:27.651
YOU. EUGENE MORRIS CARPETED
00:46:27.718 --> 00:46:29.419
LOCAL 1 52, REPRESENTING
00:46:29.486 --> 00:46:31.155
STANISLAS SAN JOAQUIN MERCED,
00:46:31.221 --> 00:46:33.223
MARIPOSA, TUOLUMNE CALIBERS AND
00:46:33.290 --> 00:46:34.625
AMADOR COUNTY. AND WE'RE IN
00:46:34.691 --> 00:46:39.596
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
00:46:39.663 --> 00:46:41.398
JONATHAN DURAN WITH THE
00:46:41.465 --> 00:46:42.399
SOUTHWEST REGION OF THE
00:46:42.466 --> 00:46:43.367
CARPENTERS. NEWBURY PARK,
00:46:43.433 --> 00:46:44.568
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 805 STRONGEST
00:46:44.635 --> 00:46:50.040
SUPPORT THIS BILL. MAINLY
00:46:50.107 --> 00:46:51.742
MAINTENANCE SOUTHWEST REGIONAL
00:46:51.808 --> 00:46:53.610
COUNCIL OF CARPENTERS FROM SANTA
00:46:53.677 --> 00:46:56.246
MARIA, CALIFORNIA LOCAL 805
00:46:56.313 --> 00:46:57.414
CARPENTERS AND STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:46:57.481 --> 00:47:02.119
A B 2011. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:47:02.186 --> 00:47:03.954
AFTERNOON. ALEX PEREZ, SOUTHWEST
00:47:04.021 --> 00:47:05.489
REGIONAL COUNCIL CARPENTERS
00:47:05.556 --> 00:47:07.291
LOCALLY, DON'T FIVE AND I
00:47:07.357 --> 00:47:08.492
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK
00:47:08.559 --> 00:47:11.762
YOU FOR YOUR TIME. HOW WE DOING
00:47:11.828 --> 00:47:13.297
TODAY? MY NAME IS JOSEPH FUCHS.
00:47:13.363 --> 00:47:15.365
I LIVE IN THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
00:47:15.432 --> 00:47:17.401
AREA. I'M A MEMBER OF CARPENTERS
00:47:17.467 --> 00:47:19.736
LOCAL 661 FOR 34 YEARS AND I
00:47:19.803 --> 00:47:25.609
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011. SHAWN
00:47:25.676 --> 00:47:27.611
REESE FROM REDDING, CALIFORNIA
00:47:27.678 --> 00:47:28.779
CARPENTERS LOCAL 15 99, AND I
00:47:28.845 --> 00:47:35.252
STRONGLY SUPPORT 2011. AND TONY
00:47:35.319 --> 00:47:36.887
LEVIES LOCAL 22 OUT OF SAN
00:47:36.954 --> 00:47:38.655
FRANCISCO AND I AM IN STRONG
00:47:38.722 --> 00:47:44.394
SUPPORT OF 2011. THANK YOU. YES.
00:47:44.461 --> 00:47:45.996
MY NAME IS 14 0 MANAEA FROM
00:47:46.063 --> 00:47:49.900
LOCAL 1 52. AND I'M HERE TO
00:47:49.967 --> 00:47:56.006
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU.
00:47:56.073 --> 00:47:57.441
AFTERNOON ED EVANS, CARPENTERS,
00:47:57.507 --> 00:47:59.276
LOCAL TO 17 AND FOSTER CITY,
00:47:59.343 --> 00:48:01.011
CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:48:01.078 --> 00:48:06.016
A B 2011. WHEN I STARTED THE
00:48:06.083 --> 00:48:08.118
NUMBER OF YEARS AND SO IT IS
00:48:08.185 --> 00:48:09.486
ANDY OH, CALIFORNIA YESTERDAY
00:48:09.553 --> 00:48:10.988
TELL THIS PARDO DELL PROJECTOR
00:48:11.054 --> 00:48:16.627
ASSEMBLY MILLONES DE GRACIAS.
00:48:16.693 --> 00:48:18.228
APRIL ATKINS LOCAL 22 SAN
00:48:18.295 --> 00:48:19.529
FRANCISCO STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011
00:48:19.596 --> 00:48:25.736
BUSINESS AGENT. MICHAELA BRUNO,
00:48:25.802 --> 00:48:27.137
SOUTHWEST REGIONAL COUNCIL,
00:48:27.204 --> 00:48:29.306
CARPENTERS, SAN DIEGO LOCAL 619
00:48:29.373 --> 00:48:35.245
AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:48:35.312 --> 00:48:36.980
PRACTICE COPING TO SOUTHWEST
00:48:37.047 --> 00:48:39.116
REGIONAL COUNCILOR CARPENTERS
00:48:39.182 --> 00:48:40.784
SAN DIEGO LOCAL 619 STRONGLY IN
00:48:40.851 --> 00:48:48.091
SUPPORT OF THE A B 2011. VICTOR
00:48:48.158 --> 00:48:49.359
DIAZ FROM SANYO, CALIFORNIA
00:48:49.426 --> 00:48:51.128
LOCAL 619 STRONG SUPPORT A B
00:48:51.194 --> 00:48:57.801
2011. GÓMEZ LOS ANGELES,
00:48:57.868 --> 00:48:59.403
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 7 21 STRONGLY
00:48:59.469 --> 00:49:05.242
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU.
00:49:05.309 --> 00:49:07.377
GOOD AFTERNOON. ANTONIO MUNOZ
00:49:07.444 --> 00:49:08.345
CORPORATIONS LOCAL 7 13,
00:49:08.412 --> 00:49:09.446
REPRESENTING ALAMEDA COUNTY IN
00:49:09.513 --> 00:49:14.618
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011. GOOD
00:49:14.685 --> 00:49:15.986
AFTERNOON. GOOD AFTERNOON. JOSE
00:49:16.053 --> 00:49:17.120
MARTINEZ. GOVERNORS LOCAL 152
00:49:17.187 --> 00:49:23.460
HERE TO SUPPORT MAYBE 2011. GOOD
00:49:23.527 --> 00:49:24.895
AFTERNOON, STEPHANIE ESTRADA
00:49:24.961 --> 00:49:25.929
WITH CRUZ STRATEGIES ON BEHALF
00:49:25.996 --> 00:49:27.230
OF THE CALIFORNIA FORWARD ACTION
00:49:27.297 --> 00:49:33.203
FUND AND SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:49:33.270 --> 00:49:34.705
IS ROB VILLA LOCAL 7 13, ALAMEDA
00:49:34.771 --> 00:49:35.806
COUNTY AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:49:35.872 --> 00:49:41.545
THIS BILL. GOOD AFTERNOON,
00:49:41.611 --> 00:49:42.913
DANIEL GREG CARPENTERS, LOCAL 20
00:49:42.979 --> 00:49:48.618
TO 36 STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:49:48.685 --> 00:49:50.420
HELLO CASSIE MANCINI ON BEHALF
00:49:50.487 --> 00:49:52.422
OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
00:49:52.489 --> 00:49:52.956
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
00:49:53.023 --> 00:49:57.361
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON. GRACIE
00:49:57.427 --> 00:49:58.862
LEGACY. LOKEREN'S HERE ON BEHALF
00:49:58.929 --> 00:50:00.630
OF CALIFORNIA. UM, BE SILICON
00:50:00.697 --> 00:50:02.065
VALLEY AT HOME ACTION FUND, ALL
00:50:02.132 --> 00:50:03.900
HOME AND THE MAYORS OF THE CITY
00:50:03.967 --> 00:50:05.001
OF BERKLEY IN THE CITY OF
00:50:05.068 --> 00:50:09.673
OAKLAND. THANK YOU. HELLO I'M
00:50:09.740 --> 00:50:11.742
EMMETT CROMWELL FROM MY
00:50:11.808 --> 00:50:14.144
SAMMARTINO, CALIFORNIA LOCAL 16
00:50:14.211 --> 00:50:16.646
OH, SEVEN AND STRONGLY SUPPORT A
00:50:16.713 --> 00:50:18.749
B 2011 AND I PLEASE WOULD LIKE A
00:50:18.815 --> 00:50:22.085
YES FOR YOUR VOTE. GOOD
00:50:22.152 --> 00:50:27.157
AFTERNOON, KYLE PATTERSON. MY
00:50:27.224 --> 00:50:30.827
CITY IS HYSTERIA, CALIFORNIA. MY
00:50:30.894 --> 00:50:32.429
LOCAL LIST LOCAL 909, AND WE
00:50:32.496 --> 00:50:40.203
SUPPORT THIS BILL. HOW YOU DOING
00:50:40.270 --> 00:50:41.371
TODAY? TELL SEAN MCCLELLAND
00:50:41.438 --> 00:50:45.041
LOCAL 909. UH AND SUPPORT OF A B
00:50:45.108 --> 00:50:51.248
2011. THANK YOU. HELLO JUAN LUNA
00:50:51.314 --> 00:50:52.949
OUT OF LOCAL TWO AND THREE LOS
00:50:53.016 --> 00:50:54.885
ANGELES. I SUPPORT LOCAL I
00:50:54.951 --> 00:50:59.890
SUPPORT A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:50:59.956 --> 00:51:00.824
TURNED MEMBERS TIFFANY FAN ON
00:51:00.891 --> 00:51:02.225
BEHALF OF BRIDGE, HOUSING AND
00:51:02.292 --> 00:51:03.226
NONPROFIT ROLE OF HOUSING
00:51:03.293 --> 00:51:04.761
DEVELOPER BASED HEADQUARTERS IN
00:51:04.828 --> 00:51:05.996
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT OF A B
00:51:06.062 --> 00:51:10.934
2011. THANK YOU. OMAR KOBE AND
00:51:11.001 --> 00:51:12.502
OUT OF RIVERSIDE COUNTY, LOCAL
00:51:12.569 --> 00:51:18.141
951 AND FULL SUPPORT OF 2011.
00:51:18.208 --> 00:51:20.277
DID ANY. MY NAME IS CARLOS WARNS
00:51:20.343 --> 00:51:22.245
WITH CARBONS LOCAL 7 51 IN SANTA
00:51:22.312 --> 00:51:23.447
ROSA AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:51:23.513 --> 00:51:27.451
2011. THANK YOU. OR HEAVY RAIN.
00:51:27.517 --> 00:51:29.352
MONTEZ SAN DIEGO LOCAL 619
00:51:29.419 --> 00:51:30.554
STRONG SUPPORT FOR A B 2011.
00:51:30.620 --> 00:51:36.993
THANK YOU. DAVID ROSS, NAPA
00:51:37.060 --> 00:51:39.463
COUNTY, CALISTOGA, CALIFORNIA
00:51:39.529 --> 00:51:41.264
DRIVER LOCAL 34 I'M A PROPONENT
00:51:41.331 --> 00:51:49.272
OF A B 2011. FRANCISCO GARCIA,
00:51:49.339 --> 00:51:51.641
LOCAL 60 A L I'M SUPPORTING A V
00:51:51.708 --> 00:51:58.682
2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:51:58.748 --> 00:52:01.885
MANNY SALCIDO. LOCAL 213. I LIVE
00:52:01.952 --> 00:52:03.053
IN THE CITY OF COVINA,
00:52:03.119 --> 00:52:04.821
CALIFORNIA IN A STRONGLY SUPPORT
00:52:04.888 --> 00:52:11.361
A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
00:52:11.428 --> 00:52:12.796
NAME IS JOHN ANTOLINI FROM
00:52:12.863 --> 00:52:13.697
PLACERVILLE. I'M A MEMBER OF
00:52:13.763 --> 00:52:15.699
1968 IN OAKLAND, AND I
00:52:15.765 --> 00:52:20.637
PASSIONATELY SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:52:20.704 --> 00:52:22.172
JAMES RODRIGUEZ NORCAL
00:52:22.239 --> 00:52:23.507
CARPENTERS MILL, WRITES LOCAL
00:52:23.573 --> 00:52:25.242
ONE. OH, TWO STRONG SUPPORTER, A
00:52:25.308 --> 00:52:30.647
B 2011. METRO VINSON GUARA FROM
00:52:30.714 --> 00:52:32.115
AMADOR COUNTY. I WORK OUT OF
00:52:32.182 --> 00:52:34.084
LOCAL 2 TO 36 IN OAKLAND, AND I
00:52:34.150 --> 00:52:40.223
SUPPORT 2011. THANK YOU. NO
00:52:40.290 --> 00:52:43.460
OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA LOCAL C C A
00:52:43.527 --> 00:52:48.732
I CAN TO SUPPORT 2011. GOOD
00:52:48.798 --> 00:52:50.634
AFTERNOON. COUNSEL KENNETH DOES
00:52:50.700 --> 00:52:53.670
LOCAL 9144. I LIVE IN SAN JOSE,
00:52:53.737 --> 00:52:55.839
SANTA CLARA COUNTY AND I SUPPORT
00:52:55.906 --> 00:53:01.912
A B 2011. MY NAME IS STEVE
00:53:01.978 --> 00:53:04.314
HARRIS. LOCAL 7 51 CENTER ROSA.
00:53:04.381 --> 00:53:09.786
NICE STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:53:09.853 --> 00:53:12.255
GOOD AFTERNOON AS JOE TOSCANO
00:53:12.322 --> 00:53:14.157
FROM LOCAL 7 13 AND IN
00:53:14.224 --> 00:53:15.258
CALIFORNIA, AND I STRONGLY
00:53:15.325 --> 00:53:18.828
SUPPORTED B 2011. THANK YOU.
00:53:18.895 --> 00:53:20.363
BEEN A ROSCOE LOCAL SYMPHONY
00:53:20.430 --> 00:53:22.265
WENT OUT OF SANTA ROSA IN STRONG
00:53:22.332 --> 00:53:27.137
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2011. ETHAN
00:53:27.203 --> 00:53:29.005
KRIEGER OUT OF 7 51. SANTA ROSA,
00:53:29.072 --> 00:53:31.341
CALIFORNIA AND I SUPPORT A B
00:53:31.408 --> 00:53:38.315
2011. HELLO, MR SANCHEZ, LOCAL
00:53:38.381 --> 00:53:40.350
1960 A L CALIFORNIA AND I
00:53:40.417 --> 00:53:47.657
SUPPORT A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:53:47.724 --> 00:53:49.392
. MY NAME IS CHRIS MORE PROUD
00:53:49.459 --> 00:53:50.160
AND GRATEFUL. MEMBER OF PILE
00:53:50.226 --> 00:53:51.728
DRIVERS LOCAL 34 IN OAKLAND,
00:53:51.795 --> 00:53:53.430
CALIFORNIA AND I'M HERE IN
00:53:53.496 --> 00:53:57.767
SUPPORT OF THE 2011. THANK YOU.
00:53:57.834 --> 00:53:58.835
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS
00:53:58.902 --> 00:54:00.737
ONASSIS MCFARLANE, MEMBER OF
00:54:00.804 --> 00:54:01.905
CANADA'S LOCAL ONE LADY IN
00:54:01.972 --> 00:54:03.740
SOLANO COUNTY. IN SUPPORT OF
00:54:03.807 --> 00:54:08.244
MAYBE 2011. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:54:08.311 --> 00:54:10.347
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS AARON HAS
00:54:10.413 --> 00:54:12.115
THIS MEMBER OF LOCAL 7 51, A
00:54:12.182 --> 00:54:13.249
STRONG SUPPORTER OF A B 2011?
00:54:13.316 --> 00:54:20.090
THANK YOU. MY NAME IS KEVIN. MAX
00:54:20.156 --> 00:54:21.758
MAN. I WORK OUT AT THE LOCAL 751
00:54:21.825 --> 00:54:23.560
IN SANTA ROSA. I'M SUPPORTIVE.
00:54:23.627 --> 00:54:27.998
MAYBE 2011 THANK YOU. MY NAME IS
00:54:28.064 --> 00:54:30.033
ROBERT PLANT. I'M A MEMBER OF
00:54:30.100 --> 00:54:31.801
LOCAL 91 OH, NINE, SACRAMENTO.
00:54:31.868 --> 00:54:33.069
AND I'M HERE TO SUPPORT 2011.
00:54:33.136 --> 00:54:38.775
THANK YOU. CAMERON HEART MEMBER
00:54:38.842 --> 00:54:43.079
OF 91 ON NINE HERE IN SACRAMENTO
00:54:43.146 --> 00:54:45.181
AND ALSO A LOCAL RESIDENT.
00:54:45.248 --> 00:54:46.282
SUPPORT OF 2011, PLEASE. THANK
00:54:46.349 --> 00:54:54.124
YOU. HELLO MY NAME IS CARLOS
00:54:54.190 --> 00:54:56.526
CHAVEZ COMING FROM LOCAL 7 13
00:54:56.593 --> 00:55:04.801
AND I SUPPORT 2011. THANK YOU.
00:55:04.868 --> 00:55:07.303
HELLO. MY NAME IS RENE GONZALEZ.
00:55:07.370 --> 00:55:10.306
IT CAME FROM 68. OUR LOGO WE
00:55:10.373 --> 00:55:20.116
SUPPORT 28 G 2011. MY NAME IS ED
00:55:20.183 --> 00:55:22.452
GABLE. I AM FROM MILL, WRITES
00:55:22.519 --> 00:55:24.054
102. I REPRESENT OVER 1700
00:55:24.120 --> 00:55:25.121
MEMBERS IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
00:55:25.188 --> 00:55:29.959
AND WE SUPPORT THIS MEASURE.
00:55:30.026 --> 00:55:30.994
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:55:31.061 --> 00:55:32.829
STEPHEN SHARGA TÌM APOLOGIZE
00:55:32.896 --> 00:55:33.863
OVER TO OAKLAND LOCAL 34. I
00:55:33.930 --> 00:55:39.235
SUPPORT 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
00:55:39.302 --> 00:55:41.371
NAME IS AARON CONTRERAS FROM LOS
00:55:41.438 --> 00:55:42.639
ANGELES. LOCAL 213 AND STRONG
00:55:42.706 --> 00:55:47.610
SUPPORT ASSEMBLY BILL 2011. GOOD
00:55:47.677 --> 00:55:48.845
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS COREY
00:55:48.912 --> 00:55:51.047
CROCKER HAM LIVE IN SANTA MARIA,
00:55:51.114 --> 00:55:52.182
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 661 AND I
00:55:52.248 --> 00:55:57.687
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS A B 2011.
00:55:57.754 --> 00:55:59.155
GOOD AFTERNOON ON MARCEL MORE
00:55:59.222 --> 00:56:00.290
FROM SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA
00:56:00.356 --> 00:56:02.325
LOCAL 46 CARPENTER AND I
00:56:02.392 --> 00:56:07.931
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011. GOOD
00:56:07.997 --> 00:56:09.065
AFTERNOON CHIP GUYS NOW
00:56:09.132 --> 00:56:11.067
MILLWRIGHT LOCAL 16. OH SEVEN
00:56:11.134 --> 00:56:12.135
OUT OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, AND
00:56:12.202 --> 00:56:15.905
I STRONGLY SUPPORT. GOOD
00:56:15.972 --> 00:56:18.074
AFTERNOON. TIMOTHY RIFE,
00:56:18.141 --> 00:56:20.043
CARPENTERS, LOCAL 22 FIELD REP.
00:56:20.110 --> 00:56:22.045
I'M IN FULL SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
00:56:22.112 --> 00:56:26.382
THANK YOU. KURT VOSS, KILL
00:56:26.449 --> 00:56:27.584
CARPENTER 7 13, AND WE SUPPORT
00:56:27.650 --> 00:56:34.657
2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. RUDOLFO
00:56:34.724 --> 00:56:35.892
CASTRO, MEMBER OF LATTER 68. OH,
00:56:35.959 --> 00:56:40.764
AND WE'RE FULL SUPPORT. DAVE
00:56:40.830 --> 00:56:42.932
MARTINEZ 1968 IN OAKLAND, AND
00:56:42.999 --> 00:56:44.868
I'M FULL SUPPORT OF THIS TO 11.
00:56:44.934 --> 00:56:49.606
THANK YOU. I AM HAVING MCCOWEN
00:56:49.672 --> 00:56:52.809
I'M A MEMBER OF CARPENTERS,
00:56:52.876 --> 00:56:53.276
LOCAL 7 13, AND I ALSO
00:56:53.343 --> 00:56:58.615
WHOLEHEARTEDLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
00:56:58.681 --> 00:57:00.583
GOOD AFTERNOON. DAN CALLIMACHI,
00:57:00.650 --> 00:57:01.618
CARPENTERS LOCAL 22 FROM SAN
00:57:01.684 --> 00:57:07.223
FRANCISCO IN SUPPORT. GOOD
00:57:07.290 --> 00:57:09.425
AFTERNOON, EDWARD AMERICANO FROM
00:57:09.492 --> 00:57:10.894
DRYWALL GATHERS LOCAL 68 OUT OF
00:57:10.960 --> 00:57:12.061
OAKLAND. AND I AM IN FULL
00:57:12.128 --> 00:57:17.700
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:57:17.767 --> 00:57:18.802
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS JORGE
00:57:18.868 --> 00:57:19.702
QUINTERO. HIM SALARY,
00:57:19.769 --> 00:57:22.238
CALIFORNIA. LOCAL 562 HERE IN
00:57:22.305 --> 00:57:23.339
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2011. THANK
00:57:23.406 --> 00:57:29.846
YOU. HI MY NAME IS ANDREW
00:57:29.913 --> 00:57:30.880
CASANOVA. ANTIOCH CALIFORNIA
00:57:30.947 --> 00:57:32.715
LOCAL 34. I'M IN FULL SUPPORT OF
00:57:32.782 --> 00:57:39.422
A B 22. I MEAN, MY NAME'S
00:57:39.489 --> 00:57:41.324
NICHOLAS. RUN THIS I CAN TOO
00:57:41.391 --> 00:57:44.227
UGLY CALIFORNIA. MY LOCAL IS 1,
00:57:44.294 --> 00:57:51.301
52 AND SUPPORT 2011. HI. MY NAME
00:57:51.367 --> 00:57:53.703
IS CARLOS VALDES FROM SACRAMENTO
00:57:53.770 --> 00:57:55.405
FROM LOCAL 46. I SUPPORT A B
00:57:55.471 --> 00:58:02.846
2011. HELLO MY NAME IS ANDREW
00:58:02.912 --> 00:58:04.347
DOT KINS. I'M OUT OF SACRAMENTO
00:58:04.414 --> 00:58:06.049
, CALIFORNIA. I'M OUT OF THE
00:58:06.115 --> 00:58:07.183
CARPENTERS LOCAL 46. I FULLY
00:58:07.250 --> 00:58:12.922
SUPPORT I B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:58:12.989 --> 00:58:14.524
. MY NAME IS CHRIS ALLEN FROM
00:58:14.591 --> 00:58:16.492
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA LOCAL 619
00:58:16.559 --> 00:58:18.461
. AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
00:58:18.528 --> 00:58:23.066
2011. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
00:58:23.132 --> 00:58:24.467
, TONY VELASQUEZ FROM ORANGE
00:58:24.534 --> 00:58:25.435
COUNTY, CALIFORNIA LOCAL 714.
00:58:25.501 --> 00:58:27.270
AND WE FULLY SUPPORT MAYBE 2011.
00:58:27.337 --> 00:58:30.974
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON,
00:58:31.040 --> 00:58:32.508
LEONARD DELAROSA. SIMILARLY NO
00:58:32.575 --> 00:58:34.544
COUNTY LOCAL 909. WE'RE IN
00:58:34.611 --> 00:58:36.479
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
00:58:36.546 --> 00:58:40.116
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON,
00:58:40.183 --> 00:58:43.219
JIMMY, ALREADY RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
00:58:43.286 --> 00:58:44.721
LOCAL 95, 1, CARPENTERS AND
00:58:44.787 --> 00:58:45.688
STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011. THANK
00:58:45.755 --> 00:58:51.828
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON. BRIAN
00:58:51.895 --> 00:58:53.830
FARKAS, VICTORVILLE, CALIFORNIA
00:58:53.897 --> 00:58:54.797
LOCAL 909. AND WE'RE STRONG
00:58:54.864 --> 00:59:00.036
SUPPORT OF A B 2011. THANK YOU.
00:59:00.103 --> 00:59:02.839
GOOD AFTERNOON. LEO VEGA PILE
00:59:02.906 --> 00:59:03.940
DRIVERS LOCAL 34. WE'RE IN
00:59:04.007 --> 00:59:08.945
STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011. ALBERTO
00:59:09.012 --> 00:59:10.947
91 44 FROM ZERO CALIFORNIA
00:59:11.014 --> 00:59:17.854
STRONGLY SUPPORT THAT 2011. HI
00:59:17.921 --> 00:59:19.422
I'M NEIL FONSO STARLING FROM
00:59:19.489 --> 00:59:20.924
MILPITAS, CALIFORNIA LOCAL FOUR
00:59:20.990 --> 00:59:22.792
OR FIVE AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT A
00:59:22.859 --> 00:59:28.831
B 11. HI. MY NAME IS I'M MARTY
00:59:28.898 --> 00:59:30.300
AGAIN FROM SANTA CRUZ,
00:59:30.366 --> 00:59:31.034
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 505, AND WE
00:59:31.100 --> 00:59:38.207
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011. HELLO
00:59:38.274 --> 00:59:39.676
MY NAME IS JERRY SENT RP FROM
00:59:39.742 --> 00:59:40.910
ROSEVILLE, CALIFORNIA MEMBER OF
00:59:40.977 --> 00:59:42.879
LOCAL 46. I STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
00:59:42.946 --> 00:59:48.584
2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:59:48.651 --> 00:59:50.286
NEIL JOHN JOHN SHAH'S FROM MALE
00:59:50.353 --> 00:59:51.888
GROWTH CALIFORNIA LOCAL 46 WHEN
00:59:51.955 --> 00:59:56.826
THEY STRONGLY SUPPORTED B 2011.
00:59:56.893 --> 00:59:58.127
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:59:58.194 --> 00:59:59.629
UMBERTO NAVA FROM SOUNDS, A
00:59:59.696 --> 01:00:00.730
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 91 44 STRONGLY
01:00:00.797 --> 01:00:07.270
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU. MM
01:00:07.337 --> 01:00:08.838
DANIEL PUENTES FROM SAN JOSE,
01:00:08.905 --> 01:00:10.073
CALIFORNIA LOCAL FOUR OR FIVE.
01:00:10.139 --> 01:00:16.913
YES, 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
01:00:16.980 --> 01:00:19.015
NAME IS CAL QUAD SKI. I LIVE IN
01:00:19.082 --> 01:00:20.216
RIPPING LOCAL ONE. OH, TWO MIL
01:00:20.283 --> 01:00:24.854
RIGHTS AND I SUPPORT A B 2011.
01:00:24.921 --> 01:00:26.422
GOOD AFTERNOON. JIM SMITH WRITES
01:00:26.489 --> 01:00:28.391
LOCAL ONE. OH, TWO. TRACY
01:00:28.458 --> 01:00:29.392
CALIFORNIA STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
01:00:29.459 --> 01:00:33.329
2011. THANK YOU. MARIO SANTA
01:00:33.396 --> 01:00:35.264
CRUZ. STARTING CALIFORNIA MIL
01:00:35.331 --> 01:00:36.499
REIS LOCAL ONE. OH, TWO STRONG
01:00:36.566 --> 01:00:42.205
SUPPORT OF 2011. MARCO GONZALEZ
01:00:42.271 --> 01:00:43.639
, CARPENTERS, LOCAL 1 52, AND
01:00:43.706 --> 01:00:50.079
I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF A V 2011.
01:00:50.146 --> 01:00:51.614
GOOD AFTERNOON. NOEL VARELA MILL
01:00:51.681 --> 01:00:53.449
WRITES LOCAL WINDOW TO MANTECA,
01:00:53.516 --> 01:01:01.891
CALIFORNIA. I SUPPORT A B 2011.
01:01:01.958 --> 01:01:04.193
I SELL PRISSY MILL WRITES LOCAL
01:01:04.260 --> 01:01:05.828
ONE. OH, TO LIVERMORE, AND I
01:01:05.895 --> 01:01:06.829
STRONGLY SUPPORT 2011. THANK
01:01:06.896 --> 01:01:12.502
YOU. HI GOOD AFTERNOON. JUAN
01:01:12.568 --> 01:01:13.870
BARBOZA LOCAL SIX OR FIVE
01:01:13.936 --> 01:01:15.471
BOUNDARY COUNTY. I LIVE IN
01:01:15.538 --> 01:01:17.707
SALINAS, UM SALINAS, CALIFORNIA
01:01:17.774 --> 01:01:19.375
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF A V 2011.
01:01:19.442 --> 01:01:26.115
THANK YOU. FOR LOCAL 46.
01:01:26.182 --> 01:01:27.150
SACRAMENTO CALIFORNIA ON THE
01:01:27.216 --> 01:01:32.055
SUPPORT OF A B 2011. THANK YOU.
01:01:32.121 --> 01:01:33.923
HI I'M DOUGLAS HACKETT. I'M A
01:01:33.990 --> 01:01:35.324
BERKLEY RESIDENT. I REPRESENT
01:01:35.391 --> 01:01:36.993
THE 7 13 OUT OF HAYWARD
01:01:37.060 --> 01:01:38.494
CARPENTERS, AND I'M A PROUD
01:01:38.561 --> 01:01:42.365
SUPPORTER OF A B 2011. MY NAME
01:01:42.432 --> 01:01:47.103
IS A TOURIST. UM LOCAL FORTIFIES
01:01:47.170 --> 01:01:49.705
AND JOSE, CALIFORNIA SUPPORT
01:01:49.772 --> 01:01:56.512
1011. HI MY NAME IS MINERAL.
01:01:56.579 --> 01:01:59.682
ROSA'S AH, MY LOCAL IS FULL. IF
01:01:59.749 --> 01:02:03.252
I COME TO TOWN CALLED CALIFORNIA
01:02:03.319 --> 01:02:10.426
, AND I SUPPORT ABC. 2011.
01:02:10.493 --> 01:02:12.095
MCGRAW'S MELATONIN WILLIS FOUR
01:02:12.161 --> 01:02:14.964
OR FIVE CALIFORNIA THAT'S RIGHT.
01:02:15.031 --> 01:02:20.470
AND THEN B M CHARACTER. GOOD
01:02:20.536 --> 01:02:21.904
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS PATRICIA
01:02:21.971 --> 01:02:24.006
RAMIREZ. I'M AT A LOCAL FOUR OR
01:02:24.073 --> 01:02:25.908
FIVE FROM SAN JOSE. AND I
01:02:25.975 --> 01:02:30.813
SUPPORT MAYBE 2011. GOOD
01:02:30.880 --> 01:02:32.181
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS MICHELLE
01:02:32.248 --> 01:02:34.517
FLORES OUT OF LOCAL 34 IN
01:02:34.584 --> 01:02:36.152
OAKLAND, AND I'M IN STRONG
01:02:36.219 --> 01:02:41.858
SUPPORT OF ABBY TO ANY 11. HELLO
01:02:41.924 --> 01:02:43.326
DANIEL BRATTON, DRYWALL
01:02:43.392 --> 01:02:44.627
LAUGHTER'S LOCAL 9109 HERE IN
01:02:44.694 --> 01:02:51.767
STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011. JACOB AT
01:02:51.834 --> 01:02:53.503
TRD, CARPENTERS LOCAL 7 13
01:02:53.569 --> 01:02:54.137
HAYWARD, CALIFORNIA AND STRONG
01:02:54.203 --> 01:03:00.576
SUPPORT OF A B 2011. GOOD
01:03:00.643 --> 01:03:02.712
AFTERNOON. MATT KELLY COPPERS
01:03:02.778 --> 01:03:04.680
LOCAL 46 HERE IN SACRAMENTO, AND
01:03:04.747 --> 01:03:06.549
I AM STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF A B
01:03:06.616 --> 01:03:12.488
2011. GOOD AFTERNOON RICH GÓMEZ
01:03:12.555 --> 01:03:14.557
OUT OF ORANGE COUNTY LOCAL 714,
01:03:14.624 --> 01:03:16.359
AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
01:03:16.425 --> 01:03:21.430
2011. THANK YOU. RAFAEL PIMENTEL
01:03:21.497 --> 01:03:22.865
OUT OF LONG BEACH, CALIFORNIA
01:03:22.932 --> 01:03:24.534
WITH CARPENTERS LOCAL 562 AND WE
01:03:24.600 --> 01:03:30.373
STAND IN SUPPORT OF A B 2011. 11
01:03:30.439 --> 01:03:32.341
YEARS ALL THE WAY FROM RIVERSIDE
01:03:32.408 --> 01:03:33.009
, CALIFORNIA STRONG SUPPORTER OF
01:03:33.075 --> 01:03:34.544
MAYBE 2011, CARPENTERS, LOCAL
01:03:34.610 --> 01:03:40.383
951. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON,
01:03:40.449 --> 01:03:42.318
ANTONIO SABATO AT A LOCAL 46.
01:03:42.385 --> 01:03:43.452
SACRAMENTO. I STRONGLY SUPPORT
01:03:43.519 --> 01:03:49.692
MAYBE 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON CRISP
01:03:49.759 --> 01:03:51.427
ALAMO OUT OF LEO, CALIFORNIA AND
01:03:51.494 --> 01:03:53.329
LOCAL 1 80. I STRONGLY SUPPORT A
01:03:53.396 --> 01:03:58.100
B 2011. MY NAME'S SETH HOWARD
01:03:58.167 --> 01:04:01.070
CARPENTER, MEMBER OF LOCAL 17 89
01:04:01.137 --> 01:04:02.572
OF SOUTH LAKE TAHOE, CALIFORNIA
01:04:02.638 --> 01:04:09.445
I STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
01:04:09.512 --> 01:04:10.713
HELLO. MY NAME IS ALEXANDER
01:04:10.780 --> 01:04:11.547
HAMPTON. I'M FROM SACRAMENTO,
01:04:11.614 --> 01:04:13.449
CALIFORNIA LOCAL 46 SRONGLY
01:04:13.516 --> 01:04:19.455
SUPPORTED A B 2011. GOOD
01:04:19.522 --> 01:04:20.690
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS JULIO
01:04:20.756 --> 01:04:22.458
FLOREZ OUT OF CARPENTER'S UNION,
01:04:22.525 --> 01:04:23.960
LOCAL 95 1 OUT OF RIVERSIDE
01:04:24.026 --> 01:04:25.127
COUNTY, AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
01:04:25.194 --> 01:04:31.267
A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
01:04:31.334 --> 01:04:33.402
NAME IS MIKE MADRID. LOCAL 909,
01:04:33.469 --> 01:04:34.503
ONTARIO, CALIFORNIA CERTAINLY
01:04:34.570 --> 01:04:42.945
SUPPORT A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:04:43.012 --> 01:04:45.081
. MY NAME IS KOBE JOE L A LOGO
01:04:45.147 --> 01:04:47.416
TO 13. AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT A
01:04:47.483 --> 01:04:51.854
B 2011. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:04:51.921 --> 01:04:52.888
AFTERNOON, EVERYBODY. MY NAME IS
01:04:52.955 --> 01:04:55.725
ANDREW MELLING. MEMBER OUT OF
01:04:55.791 --> 01:04:57.193
LOCAL 951. RIVERSIDE CALIFORNIA
01:04:57.260 --> 01:05:03.833
STRONG SUPPORT. MAYBE 2011. GOOD
01:05:03.899 --> 01:05:05.234
AFTERNOON. JOSE CABRERA. CARBON
01:05:05.301 --> 01:05:06.736
IS LOCAL 405 FROM SAN JOSE,
01:05:06.802 --> 01:05:08.404
CALIFORNIA AND WE STRONGLY
01:05:08.471 --> 01:05:13.976
SUPPORT MAYBE TO 2011. GOOD
01:05:14.043 --> 01:05:15.611
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS JUAN
01:05:15.678 --> 01:05:16.646
ESPINOZA. I'M A MEMBER OF
01:05:16.712 --> 01:05:19.515
CARPENTER'S UNION. LOCAL 2 17,
01:05:19.582 --> 01:05:20.650
AND I'M HEARING STRONG SUPPORT
01:05:20.716 --> 01:05:25.988
OF MAYBE 2011. THANK YOU. HELLO.
01:05:26.055 --> 01:05:27.757
MY NAME IS DON HOOK IT ON THE
01:05:27.823 --> 01:05:33.062
LOCAL £34 DRIVER. FROM NORTHERN
01:05:33.129 --> 01:05:34.130
CALIFORNIA, CORDELIA AND I
01:05:34.196 --> 01:05:39.602
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011.
01:05:39.669 --> 01:05:41.070
HELLO. MY NAME IS LEONARD HUESO
01:05:41.137 --> 01:05:44.106
CO. UM MEMBER OF LOCAL 1 80.
01:05:44.173 --> 01:05:47.310
VALLEJO, CALIFORNIA. AND I'M
01:05:47.376 --> 01:05:48.511
HERE IN SUPPORT OF 2011 A B
01:05:48.577 --> 01:05:54.717
2011. THANK YOU. JAMES TALLIS.
01:05:54.784 --> 01:05:55.918
LOCAL 22. SAN FRANCISCO STRONGLY
01:05:55.985 --> 01:06:03.225
SUPPORT A B 2011. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:06:03.292 --> 01:06:04.527
. I'M PHILIPPA SAAVEDRA.
01:06:04.593 --> 01:06:05.895
CARPENTERS. LOCAL 46. SACRAMENTO
01:06:05.961 --> 01:06:09.965
STRONGLY SUPPORT 2011. THANK YOU
01:06:10.032 --> 01:06:11.067
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANY
01:06:11.133 --> 01:06:12.001
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PUBLIC
01:06:12.068 --> 01:06:14.470
COMMENT IN THE ROOM? OKAY SEEING
01:06:14.537 --> 01:06:17.873
NONE. UM WE'RE GONNA DO THINGS A
01:06:17.940 --> 01:06:18.874
LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY,
01:06:18.941 --> 01:06:21.077
PREDICTING THAT ON THE PHONE
01:06:21.143 --> 01:06:22.678
LINES, WE MIGHT NOT HAVE A NEAT
01:06:22.745 --> 01:06:23.779
DIVISION BETWEEN SUPPORT AND
01:06:23.846 --> 01:06:26.315
OPPOSE. SO WE'RE GOING TO FIRST
01:06:26.382 --> 01:06:30.419
DO IN PERSON, UM, OPPOSITION. UM
01:06:30.486 --> 01:06:34.223
AND THEN WE ARE GOING TO DO, UH
01:06:34.290 --> 01:06:36.225
, THE PHONE LINES. WE'RE GONNA
01:06:36.292 --> 01:06:37.693
JUST DO SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION
01:06:37.760 --> 01:06:39.962
TOGETHER BECAUSE OTHERWISE HAVE
01:06:40.029 --> 01:06:41.330
SEEN THIS MOVIE MULTIPLE TIMES.
01:06:41.397 --> 01:06:43.366
IT ALL GETS MIXED TOGETHER, AND
01:06:43.432 --> 01:06:45.334
WE SPEND ALL OUR TIME. BEGGING
01:06:45.401 --> 01:06:47.503
PEOPLE TO PLUG IN AT THE RIGHT
01:06:47.570 --> 01:06:49.305
TIME. I WANT TO ALSO SAY TO
01:06:49.372 --> 01:06:51.173
PEOPLE IN THE PHONE LINE WERE
01:06:51.240 --> 01:06:53.409
CAPPED OUT AT 100 PEOPLE WHO CAN
01:06:53.476 --> 01:06:55.077
BE ON AT ANY ONE TIME. SO WHEN
01:06:55.144 --> 01:06:56.679
WE GET TO THE PHONE LINES, AND
01:06:56.746 --> 01:06:58.314
I'LL REPEAT THIS AGAIN WHEN WE
01:06:58.381 --> 01:06:59.548
GET THERE
01:06:59.615 --> 01:07:01.317
ON THE PHONE LINE, PLEASE, I
01:07:01.384 --> 01:07:02.718
WILL ASK YOU TO HANG UP SO THAT
01:07:02.785 --> 01:07:05.087
YOU CAN MAKE ROOM FOR SOMEONE
01:07:05.154 --> 01:07:07.223
ELSE WHO IS ABLE TO CALL IT. SO
01:07:07.289 --> 01:07:08.691
WE WILL NOW GO TO OUR LEAD.
01:07:08.758 --> 01:07:13.929
OPPOSITION. WITNESS. UM ONE
01:07:13.996 --> 01:07:21.303
MOMENT. WHO IS CAROL KIM FROM
01:07:21.370 --> 01:07:23.406
THE SAN DIEGO BUILDING TRADES
01:07:23.472 --> 01:07:24.974
COUNCIL. WELCOME AND I
01:07:25.040 --> 01:07:26.175
UNDERSTAND THAT YOU'RE THE
01:07:26.242 --> 01:07:27.343
YOU'RE THE ONLY LEAD OPPOSITION
01:07:27.410 --> 01:07:29.478
WHEN IT'S GOING TO BE ONE. OH,
01:07:29.545 --> 01:07:30.780
NO, I'M SORRY. MY APOLOGIES.
01:07:30.846 --> 01:07:33.182
YEAH. APOLOGIES. EDUARDO. UM, MR
01:07:33.249 --> 01:07:37.686
GARCIA. OKAY GO AHEAD. THANK YOU
01:07:37.753 --> 01:07:38.654
. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR WIENER
01:07:38.721 --> 01:07:39.889
AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME
01:07:39.955 --> 01:07:42.191
IS CAROL KIM AND I'M THE%
01:07:42.258 --> 01:07:42.758
BUSINESS MANAGER OF THE SAN
01:07:42.825 --> 01:07:43.793
DIEGO COUNTY BUILDING AND
01:07:43.859 --> 01:07:45.227
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL AS
01:07:45.294 --> 01:07:46.929
WELL AS THE CEO OF THE BUILDING
01:07:46.996 --> 01:07:48.364
TRADES SAN DIEGO COUNTY BUILDING
01:07:48.431 --> 01:07:49.632
AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
01:07:49.698 --> 01:07:51.400
FAMILY HOUSING CORPORATION. WE
01:07:51.467 --> 01:07:53.536
OWN AND OPERATE 23 ACRES WITH
01:07:53.602 --> 01:07:55.871
456 UNITS OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
01:07:55.938 --> 01:07:58.073
IN SAN DIEGO COUNTY AND ARE IN
01:07:58.140 --> 01:07:58.908
THE PROCESS OF REDEVELOPING THAT
01:07:58.974 --> 01:08:01.110
PROPERTY TO INCREASE DENSITY UP
01:08:01.177 --> 01:08:02.745
TO THE 1100 UNITS FOR WHICH WE
01:08:02.812 --> 01:08:04.847
ARE NOW ZONED, WHICH WILL ALLOW
01:08:04.914 --> 01:08:06.315
US TO EVENTUALLY HOUSED
01:08:06.382 --> 01:08:07.349
THOUSANDS MORE THAN THE 1700
01:08:07.416 --> 01:08:09.018
TENANTS. WE ALREADY HAVE. SO I
01:08:09.084 --> 01:08:10.519
COME BEFORE YOU NOT JUST AS A
01:08:10.586 --> 01:08:12.188
WORKER ADVOCATE BUT ALSO AS A
01:08:12.254 --> 01:08:13.489
HOUSING DEVELOPER AND LANDLORD
01:08:13.556 --> 01:08:15.224
WHO IS IMPACTED BY THE LAWS YOU
01:08:15.291 --> 01:08:16.592
PASS HERE IT IS POSSIBLE TO
01:08:16.659 --> 01:08:18.227
BUILD HOUSING WITH STRONGER JOB
01:08:18.294 --> 01:08:18.894
QUALITY STANDARDS. AND I
01:08:18.961 --> 01:08:20.796
STRONGLY URGE YOU TO OPPOSE A B
01:08:20.863 --> 01:08:23.232
2011 TODAY. NO ONE DENIES THAT
01:08:23.299 --> 01:08:25.100
CALIFORNIA HAS A HOUSING CRISIS
01:08:25.167 --> 01:08:26.502
. WE ALL AGREE THAT WE NEED MORE
01:08:26.569 --> 01:08:27.736
HOUSING STOCK BUILT ACROSS THE
01:08:27.803 --> 01:08:29.672
STATE, BUT WE SEEM TO DISAGREE
01:08:29.738 --> 01:08:30.506
THAT HOUSING STOCK SHOULD
01:08:30.573 --> 01:08:32.074
TRANSLATE INTO HOMES BECAUSE IF
01:08:32.141 --> 01:08:33.509
THIS BILL WERE SERIOUS ABOUT
01:08:33.576 --> 01:08:35.177
THAT, AND THERE WOULD BE A MUCH
01:08:35.244 --> 01:08:35.878
HIGHER, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
01:08:35.945 --> 01:08:37.646
REQUIREMENT BUILT INTO IT, AS
01:08:37.713 --> 01:08:38.747
WELL AS INCOME RESTRICTIONS FOR
01:08:38.814 --> 01:08:41.083
MORE MODERATE IN MY HOMES.
01:08:41.150 --> 01:08:42.585
INSTEAD THIS BILL PROVIDES AN
01:08:42.651 --> 01:08:44.053
EMBARRASSINGLY LOW REQUIREMENT
01:08:44.119 --> 01:08:45.521
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS AND
01:08:45.588 --> 01:08:46.655
THE AUTHOR HAS REFUSED TO ACCEPT
01:08:46.722 --> 01:08:48.157
AMENDMENTS TO INCREASE THAT
01:08:48.224 --> 01:08:49.391
PERCENTAGE BECAUSE WHAT IT'S
01:08:49.458 --> 01:08:51.026
REALLY INTENDED TO DO IS CREATE
01:08:51.093 --> 01:08:53.128
A STATEWIDE RIGHT TO DEVELOP
01:08:53.195 --> 01:08:54.530
MOSTLY MARKET RATE AND LUXURY
01:08:54.597 --> 01:08:56.165
HOUSING WITHOUT BASIC COMMUNITY
01:08:56.232 --> 01:08:56.966
PROTECTIONS, INCLUDING THE
01:08:57.032 --> 01:08:58.434
REQUIREMENT TO USE SKILLED AND
01:08:58.501 --> 01:08:59.735
TRAINED WORKFORCE WHILE PAYING
01:08:59.802 --> 01:09:02.171
THE AREA PREVAILING WAGES. THE
01:09:02.238 --> 01:09:03.439
MARKET RATE. RESIDENTIAL HOUSING
01:09:03.506 --> 01:09:05.708
INDUSTRY IS ONE OF THE MOST
01:09:05.774 --> 01:09:06.375
PREDATORY AND ABUSIVE SECTORS OF
01:09:06.442 --> 01:09:07.309
THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY IN
01:09:07.376 --> 01:09:08.911
EXISTENCE TODAY, AND WHILE THIS
01:09:08.978 --> 01:09:10.412
BILL CLAIMS TO INCLUDE WORKER
01:09:10.479 --> 01:09:11.714
PROTECTIONS, THEY'RE NOT NEARLY
01:09:11.780 --> 01:09:13.249
STRONG ENOUGH TO OVERCOME WHAT
01:09:13.315 --> 01:09:13.949
WILL ESSENTIALLY BE THE WILD
01:09:14.016 --> 01:09:16.352
WEST SINCE 80 2011 WILL MEAN
01:09:16.418 --> 01:09:17.953
THAT DEVELOPERS CAN BUILD HOMES
01:09:18.020 --> 01:09:19.355
BY RIGHT EXEMPTED FROM
01:09:19.421 --> 01:09:20.923
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW OR ANY
01:09:20.990 --> 01:09:22.258
SCRUTINY BY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
01:09:22.324 --> 01:09:24.927
ADDRESS LOCAL NEEDS. HOW CAN WE
01:09:24.994 --> 01:09:25.895
TAKE THE WORKER PROTECTION
01:09:25.961 --> 01:09:27.196
SERIOUSLY, WHEN THE PROPONENTS
01:09:27.263 --> 01:09:28.597
REFUSED TO AMEND THE BILL TO USE
01:09:28.664 --> 01:09:30.900
DEFINED LABOR CODE REFERENCES,
01:09:30.966 --> 01:09:31.767
THE CLAIMS THAT THIS BILL
01:09:31.834 --> 01:09:33.369
INCLUDES HEALTHCARE PROVISION
01:09:33.435 --> 01:09:34.470
FOR WORKERS ARE GROSSLY
01:09:34.537 --> 01:09:36.005
DISINGENUOUS. SINCE THOSE
01:09:36.071 --> 01:09:37.473
HEALTHCARE REQUIREMENTS HAVE
01:09:37.540 --> 01:09:39.074
BEEN MADE SEVERAL BALLIN THE
01:09:39.141 --> 01:09:40.242
CURRENT VERSION BEFORE YOU
01:09:40.309 --> 01:09:41.510
TODAY, EVIDENCE THAT POINTS TO
01:09:41.577 --> 01:09:43.178
THE FACT THAT PROPONENTS EXPECT
01:09:43.245 --> 01:09:44.246
THE HEALTHCARE REQUIREMENT TO BE
01:09:44.313 --> 01:09:45.548
INVALIDATED AND SEVERED. AND
01:09:45.614 --> 01:09:47.082
MOSTLY, POSSIBLY MOST
01:09:47.149 --> 01:09:49.084
PROBLEMATIC. THIS BILL HAS NO
01:09:49.151 --> 01:09:50.719
SUNSET DATE, SO THE COST TO THE
01:09:50.786 --> 01:09:52.121
STATE MANIFEST AS WE BELIEVE
01:09:52.187 --> 01:09:53.188
THEY WILL AND THE BENEFITS TO
01:09:53.255 --> 01:09:55.157
OUR COMMUNITIES FAILED TO APPEAR
01:09:55.224 --> 01:09:56.158
. IT WILL BE THAT MUCH HARDER TO
01:09:56.225 --> 01:09:57.459
COURSE CORRECT AND SHAPE,
01:09:57.526 --> 01:09:58.060
HEALTHIER AND MORE EFFECTIVE
01:09:58.127 --> 01:09:59.862
POLICY TO ADDRESS OUR COLLECTIVE
01:09:59.929 --> 01:10:02.531
HOUSING NEEDS. A B 2011 IS NOT
01:10:02.598 --> 01:10:04.133
THE SOLUTION OUR STATE AND
01:10:04.199 --> 01:10:05.534
COMMUNITIES ARE LOOKING FOR IS A
01:10:05.601 --> 01:10:07.102
TROJAN HORSE CLAIMING TO BE A
01:10:07.169 --> 01:10:08.337
GIFT TO STRUGGLING CALIFORNIANS
01:10:08.404 --> 01:10:10.072
DESPERATELY IN NEED OF HOMES BUT
01:10:10.139 --> 01:10:11.140
WILL LIKELY BE THE INTEREST
01:10:11.206 --> 01:10:13.008
TREATMENT OF GENTRIFICATION. THE
01:10:13.075 --> 01:10:14.009
PROLIFERATION OF HOUSING
01:10:14.076 --> 01:10:15.411
INVECTIVE INVESTORS THAT LOCKE
01:10:15.477 --> 01:10:16.912
WORKING FAMILIES OUT OF THE
01:10:16.979 --> 01:10:17.813
HOUSING MARKET AND THE
01:10:17.880 --> 01:10:19.348
BALLOONING OF CORPORATE PROFITS
01:10:19.415 --> 01:10:21.150
AT THE EXPENSE OF WORKING PEOPLE
01:10:21.216 --> 01:10:22.384
, AND WE HAVE URGED TO OPPOSE IT
01:10:22.451 --> 01:10:24.253
TODAY, AND I JUST WANT TO NOTE
01:10:24.320 --> 01:10:25.487
THAT I FIGHT FOR MY CARPENTER,
01:10:25.554 --> 01:10:26.689
BROTHERS AND SISTERS ALL THE
01:10:26.755 --> 01:10:28.724
TIME IN SAN DIEGO. WE WORKED
01:10:28.791 --> 01:10:30.192
REALLY HARD TO INCREASE THE
01:10:30.259 --> 01:10:30.926
STANDARD OF LIVING FOR ALL OF
01:10:30.993 --> 01:10:33.128
THEM, SO I'M NOT OPPOSED TO WHAT
01:10:33.195 --> 01:10:34.163
THEY'RE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH,
01:10:34.229 --> 01:10:36.231
BUT WE CAN DO BETTER AND WE
01:10:36.298 --> 01:10:37.366
SHOULD ASK FOR AND EXPECT
01:10:37.433 --> 01:10:39.535
BETTER. THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT
01:10:39.602 --> 01:10:41.236
EDUARDO MARTINEZ FROM THE
01:10:41.303 --> 01:10:43.272
CALIFORNIA LABOR FEDERATION.
01:10:43.339 --> 01:10:45.240
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR, UM MARTINEZ
01:10:45.307 --> 01:10:46.275
, ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:10:46.342 --> 01:10:47.710
LABOR FEDERATION WERE STANDING
01:10:47.776 --> 01:10:48.911
IN SOLIDARITY WITH THE STATE
01:10:48.978 --> 01:10:49.945
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
01:10:50.012 --> 01:10:51.614
COUNCIL IN OPPOSING MAYBE 2011
01:10:51.680 --> 01:10:53.682
TODAY UNLESS IT'S AMENDED. OUR
01:10:53.749 --> 01:10:55.317
CONTINUED OPPOSITION STEMS FROM
01:10:55.384 --> 01:10:56.719
THE LACK OF STRONG LABOR
01:10:56.785 --> 01:10:58.187
PROTECTIONS CONTAINED IN A B
01:10:58.253 --> 01:10:59.855
2011 AS MY SISTER FROM THE
01:10:59.922 --> 01:11:01.256
BUILDING TRADES JUST MENTIONED,
01:11:01.323 --> 01:11:02.758
WE BELIEVE THE LACK OF A
01:11:02.825 --> 01:11:03.659
REQUIREMENT FOR CONTRACTORS TO
01:11:03.726 --> 01:11:05.461
SUPPORT APPRENTICESHIPS BY USING
01:11:05.527 --> 01:11:06.562
BY UTILIZING A SKILLED AND
01:11:06.629 --> 01:11:08.097
TRAINED WORKFORCE. MEANS
01:11:08.163 --> 01:11:10.466
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS, UM, FOR
01:11:10.532 --> 01:11:11.700
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS IS
01:11:11.767 --> 01:11:13.335
EXTREMELY PROBLEMATIC. THESE
01:11:13.402 --> 01:11:14.370
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS WHO WERE
01:11:14.436 --> 01:11:15.704
DEEMED ESSENTIAL THROUGHOUT THE
01:11:15.771 --> 01:11:17.673
COVID 19 PANDEMIC ARE ONCE AGAIN
01:11:17.740 --> 01:11:20.175
LATER LEFT OUT OF THE EQUATION.
01:11:20.242 --> 01:11:21.744
WE ACKNOWLEDGE THE NEED TO BUILD
01:11:21.810 --> 01:11:24.146
MORE HOUSING. NO ONE IN THIS
01:11:24.213 --> 01:11:25.614
ROOM DISPUTES THE NATURE OF THE
01:11:25.681 --> 01:11:27.316
CRISIS WE FIND OURSELVES IN FEW
01:11:27.383 --> 01:11:28.083
WILL DISPUTE THE NEED TO BUILD
01:11:28.150 --> 01:11:29.485
MORE HOUSING FOR ALL INCOME
01:11:29.551 --> 01:11:31.887
LEVELS. HOWEVER WE MUST REJECT
01:11:31.954 --> 01:11:33.722
THE FALSE CHOICE AT A B 2011
01:11:33.789 --> 01:11:35.424
PRESENTS TO YOU TODAY THAT THE
01:11:35.491 --> 01:11:37.493
ONLY WAY TO SOLVE THIS CRISIS IS
01:11:37.559 --> 01:11:39.294
ON THE BACKS OF BLUE COLLAR
01:11:39.361 --> 01:11:39.895
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS. TO THE
01:11:39.962 --> 01:11:41.030
BENEFIT OF HOUSING DEVELOPERS
01:11:41.096 --> 01:11:43.399
WHO STAND TO BENEFIT FROM THE
01:11:43.465 --> 01:11:44.433
GENEROUS BY RIGHT APPROVAL
01:11:44.500 --> 01:11:45.668
PROCESSES AFFORDED IN THIS BILL.
01:11:45.734 --> 01:11:47.202
WE URGE THE AUTHOR IN THE
01:11:47.269 --> 01:11:48.971
SPONSORS TO CONTINUE TO WORK TO
01:11:49.038 --> 01:11:51.073
ENSURE THIS BILL WORKS FOR THE
01:11:51.140 --> 01:11:51.907
WORKING MEN AND WOMEN OF THE
01:11:51.974 --> 01:11:52.908
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
01:11:52.975 --> 01:11:54.476
TRADES. UNTIL THEN, WE REMAIN
01:11:54.543 --> 01:11:56.278
OPPOSED UNLESS ADMITTED TO ADD
01:11:56.345 --> 01:11:57.479
STRONGER WORK PROTECTIONS.
01:11:57.546 --> 01:11:58.781
INCLUDING THE REQUIREMENT TO
01:11:58.847 --> 01:12:00.516
UTILIZE THE SKILLED AND TRAINED
01:12:00.582 --> 01:12:01.850
WORKFORCE. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
01:12:01.917 --> 01:12:03.485
THANK YOU, MR MARTINEZ. OKAY
01:12:03.552 --> 01:12:05.621
WE'RE NOW ADDITIONAL WITNESSES.
01:12:05.688 --> 01:12:07.489
PLEASE PLEASE, STATE YOUR NAME
01:12:07.556 --> 01:12:08.657
AFFILIATION AND, UH, THE FACT OF
01:12:08.724 --> 01:12:11.760
YOUR OPPOSITION. THANK YOU, MR
01:12:11.827 --> 01:12:13.729
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:12:13.796 --> 01:12:14.863
MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE JEREMY
01:12:14.930 --> 01:12:16.832
SMITH HERE ON BEHALF OF THE HALF
01:12:16.899 --> 01:12:17.866
A MILLION MEMBERS THAT WE
01:12:17.933 --> 01:12:19.034
REPRESENT THE STATE BUILDING
01:12:19.101 --> 01:12:20.035
TRADES, INCLUDING OUR 72,000
01:12:20.102 --> 01:12:21.036
APPRENTICES OPPOSING THE BILL IS
01:12:21.103 --> 01:12:22.938
WRITTEN. AND WE'LL CONTINUE TO
01:12:23.005 --> 01:12:24.807
TEMPORARY COMPROMISE, BUT NO
01:12:24.873 --> 01:12:25.908
COMPROMISE IS POSSIBLE WITHOUT
01:12:25.974 --> 01:12:27.810
THE MOVEMENT OF SB SIX AS WELL.
01:12:27.876 --> 01:12:31.447
THANK YOU. MR CHAIRMAN AND
01:12:31.513 --> 01:12:32.948
MEMBER SCOTT WISH ON BEHALF OF
01:12:33.015 --> 01:12:34.116
THE 35,000 MEMBERS OF THE
01:12:34.183 --> 01:12:35.184
CALIFORNIA STATE PIE TRADES
01:12:35.250 --> 01:12:37.553
COUNCIL. THE 100,000 MEMBERS OF
01:12:37.619 --> 01:12:38.287
THE STATE ASSOCIATION OF
01:12:38.353 --> 01:12:40.089
ELECTRICAL WORKERS, THE 55,000
01:12:40.155 --> 01:12:41.123
MEMBERS OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:12:41.190 --> 01:12:43.492
COALITION FUTILITY EMPLOYEES.
01:12:43.559 --> 01:12:45.427
THE 29,000 MEMBERS OF THE
01:12:45.494 --> 01:12:46.528
WESTERN STATES COUNCIL OF SHEET
01:12:46.595 --> 01:12:49.131
METAL WORKERS. IN OPPOSITION TO
01:12:49.198 --> 01:12:51.333
THIS BILL, AND LIKE ALL OF THE
01:12:51.400 --> 01:12:52.468
CARPENTERS HERE TODAY, I TOO,
01:12:52.534 --> 01:12:54.369
AND BEING PAID TO BE HERE. THANK
01:12:54.436 --> 01:13:00.576
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON. HONORABLE
01:13:00.642 --> 01:13:02.845
CHAIR COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME
01:13:02.911 --> 01:13:04.713
IS CHRIS HANAN WITH THE LOS
01:13:04.780 --> 01:13:07.649
ANGELES IN ORANGE COUNTY IS
01:13:07.716 --> 01:13:09.218
BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TRADES
01:13:09.284 --> 01:13:10.853
COUNCIL I STAND IN SOLIDARITY
01:13:10.919 --> 01:13:11.887
WITH THE STATE BUILDING
01:13:11.954 --> 01:13:12.888
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL OF
01:13:12.955 --> 01:13:17.760
CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU, MR
01:13:17.826 --> 01:13:18.727
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MATT
01:13:18.794 --> 01:13:20.596
CREMINS HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
01:13:20.662 --> 01:13:21.764
CALIFORNIA ABOUT A CONFERENCE OF
01:13:21.830 --> 01:13:22.564
OPERATING ENGINEERS. WE ARE
01:13:22.631 --> 01:13:23.565
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED UNLESS
01:13:23.632 --> 01:13:24.600
AMENDED AND WOULD URGE A
01:13:24.666 --> 01:13:25.768
COMPROMISE ON THE BILL. THANK
01:13:25.834 --> 01:13:28.871
YOU. THANK YOU, MR CHAIRMAN
01:13:28.937 --> 01:13:30.205
MEMBERS JAMES, THOROUGH ACTOR
01:13:30.272 --> 01:13:30.839
WITH THE CALIFORNIA STATE
01:13:30.906 --> 01:13:31.840
COUNCIL OF LABORERS AND ON
01:13:31.907 --> 01:13:34.042
BEHALF OF THE 60,000 MEN AND
01:13:34.109 --> 01:13:35.244
WOMEN STATEWIDE. WE ALSO OPPOSE
01:13:35.310 --> 01:13:39.848
UNLESS AMENDED. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:13:39.915 --> 01:13:41.650
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:13:41.717 --> 01:13:42.651
AND THE RESTAURANT MIRA'S ON
01:13:42.718 --> 01:13:44.119
BEHALF OF THE TRI VALLEY CITIES
01:13:44.186 --> 01:13:45.788
DUBLIN, LIVERMORE PLEASANT IN
01:13:45.854 --> 01:13:47.990
SAN RAMON IN DANVILLE, AS WELL
01:13:48.056 --> 01:13:48.824
AS THE CITY OF FREMONT AND
01:13:48.891 --> 01:13:50.292
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THE
01:13:50.359 --> 01:13:51.693
BILL, BUT WANT TO THANK THE
01:13:51.760 --> 01:13:52.795
AUTHORS OFFICE AND HER STAFF FOR
01:13:52.861 --> 01:13:54.296
ENGAGING IN SOME THOUGHTFUL
01:13:54.363 --> 01:13:55.330
DIALOGUE AROUND SUGGESTIONS WE
01:13:55.397 --> 01:13:59.368
HAVE. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:13:59.434 --> 01:14:00.836
, CHAIRMAN WIENER. MY NAME IS
01:14:00.903 --> 01:14:02.337
CHAD BOHO AND I'M, A COUNCIL
01:14:02.404 --> 01:14:03.539
REPRESENTATIVE OF THE LOS
01:14:03.605 --> 01:14:04.673
ANGELES AND ORANGE COUNTY
01:14:04.740 --> 01:14:05.774
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
01:14:05.841 --> 01:14:08.110
COUNCIL. WE ARE JOINING WITH THE
01:14:08.177 --> 01:14:08.644
STATE BUILDING TRADES IN
01:14:08.710 --> 01:14:09.678
OPPOSITION TO SB 2011. THANK
01:14:09.745 --> 01:14:14.783
YOU. THANK YOU. MR CHAIR, KEITH
01:14:14.850 --> 01:14:16.618
DOWN ON BEHALF OF THE DISTRICT
01:14:16.685 --> 01:14:17.619
COUNCIL OF IRONWORKERS AND
01:14:17.686 --> 01:14:21.023
OPPOSITION. MR CHAIR. MATT
01:14:21.089 --> 01:14:22.591
BROUGHT ON BEHALF OF THE
01:14:22.658 --> 01:14:23.592
TEAMSTERS UNITE HERE IN
01:14:23.659 --> 01:14:27.429
MACHINISTS AND OPPOSITION. MR
01:14:27.496 --> 01:14:29.898
CHAIR MARK MULLEN, OR YOU, A
01:14:29.965 --> 01:14:31.867
LOCAL UNION. 2 TO 8 MEMBER IN
01:14:31.934 --> 01:14:36.972
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. FRANK
01:14:37.039 --> 01:14:38.707
ZAVALA WITH THE LABORS. LOCAL
01:14:38.774 --> 01:14:43.512
300 OPPOSED 2011. QUÊ. IS THERE
01:14:43.579 --> 01:14:45.113
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION HERE
01:14:45.180 --> 01:14:49.251
IN THE ROOM? CASING NINE WILL
01:14:49.318 --> 01:14:51.486
NOW GO TO THE PHONE LINES, AND
01:14:51.553 --> 01:14:52.988
AS I INDICATED EARLIER, WE'RE
01:14:53.055 --> 01:14:54.256
NOT GOING TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN
01:14:54.323 --> 01:14:57.426
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION. UM SO IF
01:14:57.492 --> 01:14:59.127
YOU HAVE A POSITION ON THE BILL
01:14:59.194 --> 01:15:01.196
THAT YOU WANT TO STAY AGAIN
01:15:01.263 --> 01:15:01.864
STANDING CHEST YOUR NAME
01:15:01.930 --> 01:15:04.132
AFFILIATION, IF ANY, AND WHETHER
01:15:04.199 --> 01:15:07.236
YOU SUPPORT OR OPPOSE ANALYSIS.
01:15:07.302 --> 01:15:09.271
TIME TO DO IT. AS I INDICATED A
01:15:09.338 --> 01:15:10.873
FEW MINUTES AGO. WE ONLY HAVE
01:15:10.939 --> 01:15:13.108
SPACE FOR 100 ON THE PHONE LINES
01:15:13.175 --> 01:15:14.743
, AND SO WHEN YOU ARE DONE
01:15:14.810 --> 01:15:16.411
GIVING YOUR TESTIMONY, PLEASE, I
01:15:16.478 --> 01:15:18.380
WOULD ASK THAT YOU HANG UP SO
01:15:18.447 --> 01:15:19.581
THAT YOU MAKE ROOM FOR OTHER
01:15:19.648 --> 01:15:23.852
PEOPLE, UM AND WE WILL. AND AT
01:15:23.919 --> 01:15:24.753
THIS POINT, I'M NOT PLACING A
01:15:24.820 --> 01:15:28.223
TIME LIMIT ON ON THE PHONE LINES
01:15:28.290 --> 01:15:29.491
. WE MAY REVISIT THAT LATER. BUT
01:15:29.558 --> 01:15:31.560
MY PREFERENCE IS NOT TO HAVE TO
01:15:31.627 --> 01:15:34.229
PUT A TIME LIMIT. UM SO, MR
01:15:34.296 --> 01:15:35.797
MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE QUEUE
01:15:35.864 --> 01:15:36.932
UP TESTIMONY AGAIN SUPPORT OR
01:15:36.999 --> 01:15:41.370
OPPOSITION? THANK YOU TO STATE
01:15:41.436 --> 01:15:42.838
YOUR OPINION ON THIS BILL. MAYBE
01:15:42.905 --> 01:15:45.908
2011 PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. IF
01:15:45.974 --> 01:15:47.209
YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY DONE SO
01:15:47.276 --> 01:15:48.911
AGAIN, THAT'S ONE FOLLOWED BY
01:15:48.977 --> 01:15:50.445
ZERO. WE'LL GO FIRST TO LINE
01:15:50.512 --> 01:15:56.118
153. MY NAME IS BRAD EWING,
01:15:56.184 --> 01:15:57.085
REPRESENTING SAM. UNCLE POURED
01:15:57.152 --> 01:15:58.120
VIRGINIA STRONGLY SUPPORT 2011.
01:15:58.186 --> 01:16:02.557
THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE TO
01:16:02.624 --> 01:16:08.463
24. HELLO MANY, MR OGILVIE. I'M
01:16:08.530 --> 01:16:10.332
A MEMBER OF THE EAST INDIA
01:16:10.399 --> 01:16:12.100
CHAPTER OF THE N B ACTION AND
01:16:12.167 --> 01:16:13.735
STRONG SUPPORT OF THE OAKLAND
01:16:13.802 --> 01:16:15.270
UNION MEMBERS TODAY IN SUPPORT
01:16:15.337 --> 01:16:19.074
OF A B 2011. NEXT WAVE LINE, 2
01:16:19.141 --> 01:16:24.313
TO 2. I CAN YOU HEAR ME? ALISON
01:16:24.379 --> 01:16:27.883
SHALL ALERT AND LOS ANGELES, THE
01:16:27.950 --> 01:16:28.817
SINGLE FAMILY HOME OWNER AND
01:16:28.884 --> 01:16:31.553
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE
01:16:31.620 --> 01:16:38.060
2 29. TOBY MORE SHINING FROM LOS
01:16:38.126 --> 01:16:39.361
ANGELES ON BEHALF OF WESTSIDE
01:16:39.428 --> 01:16:41.196
FOR EVERYONE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:16:41.263 --> 01:16:47.202
LINE 1 36. DOESN'T GOOD
01:16:47.269 --> 01:16:48.770
AFTERNOON, ADRIAN THIS CHAMPAGNE
01:16:48.837 --> 01:16:50.005
WITH THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN, VOTERS
01:16:50.072 --> 01:16:50.973
OF CALIFORNIA AND STRONG
01:16:51.039 --> 01:16:57.612
SUPPORT. NEXT WE HAVE 2 35. MY
01:16:57.679 --> 01:16:58.914
NAME IS PAUL BICKMORE FROM HERE
01:16:58.981 --> 01:17:02.184
IN OAKLAND AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:17:02.250 --> 01:17:07.422
BUYING 2 13 213. HI. THIS IS
01:17:07.489 --> 01:17:09.191
ROBERT RUCKMAN ON BEHALF OF SAN
01:17:09.257 --> 01:17:11.426
FRANCISCO AND BE SOUTH B AND B
01:17:11.493 --> 01:17:13.462
AND SUNRISE, SILICON VALLEY AND
01:17:13.528 --> 01:17:21.069
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 79. YES
01:17:21.136 --> 01:17:22.537
GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND
01:17:22.604 --> 01:17:24.072
MEMBERS KAREEM GREASY ON BEHALF
01:17:24.139 --> 01:17:25.540
OF THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:17:25.607 --> 01:17:27.642
REALTORS. CR WILL SUPPORT THE
01:17:27.709 --> 01:17:29.578
2011 1 SPORTS COMING AUTHORS.
01:17:29.644 --> 01:17:30.846
AMENDMENTS ARE IN PRINT, AND WE
01:17:30.912 --> 01:17:31.813
WISH TO APPLAUD THE AUTHOR,
01:17:31.880 --> 01:17:34.583
SPONSORS AND STAFF FOR THEIR
01:17:34.649 --> 01:17:35.484
ONGOING EFFORTS TO CREATE THE
01:17:35.550 --> 01:17:36.585
MOST POWERFUL PROPOSAL POSSIBLE.
01:17:36.651 --> 01:17:44.192
THANK YOU SO MUCH. FLYING 1 85.
01:17:44.259 --> 01:17:46.194
MOLINA WIH DRYWALL LATTER'S
01:17:46.261 --> 01:17:48.697
LOCAL 90 68 I SUPPORT 80 2011.
01:17:48.764 --> 01:17:55.203
THANK YOU. LINE 108. GOOD
01:17:55.270 --> 01:17:57.205
AFTERNOON. LEWIS HUNTER BARRELS
01:17:57.272 --> 01:17:58.807
FROM SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA AS THE
01:17:58.874 --> 01:18:00.442
COMMISSIONER ON THE CALIFORNIA
01:18:00.509 --> 01:18:02.244
APPRENTICESHIP COUNCIL AND THE
01:18:02.310 --> 01:18:03.211
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
01:18:03.278 --> 01:18:04.713
SOUTHWEST CARPENTERS TRAINING
01:18:04.780 --> 01:18:06.214
FUND. I STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
01:18:06.281 --> 01:18:14.289
2011. LINE 1 97. HI. THIS IS
01:18:14.356 --> 01:18:16.324
LISA DAN'S I WASN'T PRIMA AND I
01:18:16.391 --> 01:18:25.100
SUPPORT A B 2011. LINE 1 32.
01:18:25.167 --> 01:18:33.575
ONE. MY NAME IS. AND I HAD LIKE
01:18:33.642 --> 01:18:43.418
TO SUPPORT. PLANE TO 19 TO 19.
01:18:43.485 --> 01:18:45.587
GOOD AFTERNOON. KERRY GUFFMAN.
01:18:45.654 --> 01:18:49.524
I'M UH, IN STRONG SUPPORT OF 2
01:18:49.591 --> 01:18:51.460
11. I'M A MEMBER OF CULVERTS
01:18:51.526 --> 01:18:55.230
CITY FROM OUR HOMES. AND RETIRED
01:18:55.297 --> 01:18:57.132
UNION ORGANIZER WITH APPS, ME
01:18:57.199 --> 01:19:01.570
AND A SINGLE FAMILY HOME OWNER.
01:19:01.636 --> 01:19:08.076
LINE 1 13 113. HI. MY NAME IS
01:19:08.143 --> 01:19:09.077
TIFFANY GOLDBLATT. AND I'M WITH
01:19:09.144 --> 01:19:10.846
THE LOCAL, UH 710 WOMEN'S
01:19:10.912 --> 01:19:15.250
AUXILIARY. OUT OF LONG BEACH,
01:19:15.317 --> 01:19:16.318
CALIFORNIA AND I STRONGLY
01:19:16.384 --> 01:19:23.892
SUPPORT 2011. LINE 2 40. IS
01:19:23.959 --> 01:19:24.960
WARREN WELLS, RENTER IN
01:19:25.026 --> 01:19:26.027
BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA AND STRONG
01:19:26.094 --> 01:19:33.502
SUPPORT. 2 38. HAPPENING IN ROME
01:19:33.568 --> 01:19:35.137
OF ANOTHER COLLEAGUE OF EAST BAY
01:19:35.203 --> 01:19:36.671
AND BE STRONG SUPPORTER, BABY TO
01:19:36.738 --> 01:19:46.114
11 AND STAY COOL UP. 2 43. HI
01:19:46.181 --> 01:19:47.582
SIDDHARTH SKODA PATTY RENTER
01:19:47.649 --> 01:19:50.085
FROM JOSE, CALIFORNIA CALLING
01:19:50.152 --> 01:19:51.319
AND STRONG SUPPORT FOR A 2011.
01:19:51.386 --> 01:19:59.194
THANK YOU. LINE 1 38. GOOD
01:19:59.261 --> 01:20:00.562
AFTERNOON SHARING MEMBERS. THIS
01:20:00.629 --> 01:20:02.531
IS EDWIN BARBONE ON BEHALF OF
01:20:02.597 --> 01:20:03.698
THE CITY OF ONTARIO IN
01:20:03.765 --> 01:20:06.201
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. LINE 1
01:20:06.268 --> 01:20:11.473
11. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR
01:20:11.540 --> 01:20:13.141
KAREN ROSS ON BHALF OF THE
01:20:13.208 --> 01:20:14.576
CITIES OF BURBANK, GLENDALE
01:20:14.643 --> 01:20:16.444
SOLANA BEACH TOWN OF TRUCKEE AND
01:20:16.511 --> 01:20:17.779
THE MARIN COUNTY COUNCIL OF
01:20:17.846 --> 01:20:18.680
AMERICAN COUNCIL MEMBERS, ALL IN
01:20:18.747 --> 01:20:23.785
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. BUYING 1
01:20:23.852 --> 01:20:28.456
30. MY NAME IS MAY LINK. STEPHAN
01:20:28.523 --> 01:20:30.258
REPRESENTING SUNNYVALE,UNITED
01:20:30.325 --> 01:20:33.495
NEIGHBORS IN STRONG OPPOSITION.
01:20:33.562 --> 01:20:35.964
I DON'T THINK I EXPECT TO
01:20:36.031 --> 01:20:37.132
COMBINE OPPOSITION AND SUPPORT.
01:20:37.199 --> 01:20:38.300
THANK YOU. VERY MUCH SUPPORT
01:20:38.366 --> 01:20:46.007
WILL. AIRLINES TO 45. GOOD
01:20:46.074 --> 01:20:47.509
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS THERE,
01:20:47.576 --> 01:20:49.077
TURN AROUND THE HALF OF THE CITY
01:20:49.144 --> 01:20:51.213
OF DOWNEY AND TOWN OF APPLE
01:20:51.279 --> 01:20:51.713
VALLEY. RESPECTFULLY AND
01:20:51.780 --> 01:20:53.215
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. LINE 2
01:20:53.281 --> 01:20:58.587
46. GOOD AFTERNOON. SHE
01:20:58.653 --> 01:21:00.188
REMEMBERS DANA HUTCHINGS,
01:21:00.255 --> 01:21:02.157
REPRESENTING THE CITIES OF EAST
01:21:02.224 --> 01:21:03.992
VAIL CORONA RENDER PALOS VERDE
01:21:04.059 --> 01:21:05.093
SANTA ROSA IN OPPOSITION. THANK
01:21:05.160 --> 01:21:12.434
YOU. 1 94. HI THIS IS MANNY
01:21:12.500 --> 01:21:14.302
PANERO, MONNING BANKERS COUNTY
01:21:14.369 --> 01:21:15.403
BUILDING DESTRUCTION TRADES
01:21:15.470 --> 01:21:16.338
COUNCIL STATE BUILDING TRADES
01:21:16.404 --> 01:21:24.512
WERE OPPOSED TO 2011. LINE 94.
01:21:24.579 --> 01:21:26.581
YES SIR. ON BEHALF OF THE CITY
01:21:26.648 --> 01:21:27.849
OF AUSTRALIA IN OPPOSITION TO A
01:21:27.916 --> 01:21:35.390
B 2011 LINE 100. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:21:35.457 --> 01:21:36.625
. DAVID AZEVEDO WITH AARP,
01:21:36.691 --> 01:21:40.528
CALIFORNIA IN STRONG SUPPORT. 1
01:21:40.595 --> 01:21:49.304
67. GALGIANI IT IS. PLEASE GO
01:21:49.371 --> 01:21:54.643
AHEAD. OKAY. SORRY HI. GOOD
01:21:54.709 --> 01:21:56.344
SO BUSINESS AGENT AND LOCAL 16.
01:21:56.411 --> 01:21:57.679
HE FROST INSULATORS, AND WE
01:21:57.746 --> 01:21:59.281
STAND WITH STATE BUILDING TRADES
01:21:59.347 --> 01:22:00.982
AND STRONG OPPOSITION TO SB
01:22:01.049 --> 01:22:09.257
2011. THANK YOU. LINE 1 81. GOOD
01:22:09.324 --> 01:22:10.225
AFTERNOON, EVERYONE. MY NAME IS
01:22:10.292 --> 01:22:11.793
TONY DE TRINIDAD WITH THE
01:22:11.860 --> 01:22:14.162
PAINTERS NOW TRADES COUNCIL 36.
01:22:14.229 --> 01:22:15.630
ON BEHALF 10,000 MEMBERSHIPS
01:22:15.697 --> 01:22:17.599
HERE IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. WE
01:22:17.666 --> 01:22:18.767
OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU VERY
01:22:18.833 --> 01:22:26.107
MUCH. 1 29. RICK HALL WITH
01:22:26.174 --> 01:22:27.142
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA. WE STRONGLY
01:22:27.208 --> 01:22:34.416
OPPOSE THIS BILL. 2 18. GOOD
01:22:34.482 --> 01:22:35.784
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:22:35.850 --> 01:22:37.419
JORDAN GRIMES, REPRESENTING THE%
01:22:37.485 --> 01:22:38.453
GREENBELT ALLIANCE AND STRONG
01:22:38.520 --> 01:22:50.265
SUPPORT. 1 10. 110 YOU MAY BE ON
01:22:50.332 --> 01:22:55.470
MUTE. CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES, WE
01:22:55.537 --> 01:22:57.472
CAN. THANK YOU. MY NAME IS BART
01:22:57.539 --> 01:22:59.574
BONTE. REPRESENTING THE SAN
01:22:59.641 --> 01:23:00.975
MATEO COUNTY BUILDING AND
01:23:01.042 --> 01:23:02.043
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL IN
01:23:02.110 --> 01:23:05.146
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL TO 11
01:23:05.213 --> 01:23:08.383
UNLESS AMENDED. THANK YOU. NEXT
01:23:08.450 --> 01:23:12.420
WE HAVE LINED 1 15. GOOD
01:23:12.487 --> 01:23:13.822
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS JONATHAN
01:23:13.888 --> 01:23:15.290
DRESCHER FROM CARPENTERS LOCAL 7
01:23:15.357 --> 01:23:16.725
13, REPRESENTING ALAMEDA COUNTY
01:23:16.791 --> 01:23:17.592
, AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
01:23:17.659 --> 01:23:26.434
2011. 1 55. MY NAME IS JASON
01:23:26.501 --> 01:23:27.369
PIERCE. I'M A MEMBER OF
01:23:27.435 --> 01:23:29.637
CARPENTERS, LOCAL 7 51, AND I
01:23:29.704 --> 01:23:37.912
STRONGLY SUPPORT 80 2011. 1 57.
01:23:37.979 --> 01:23:41.583
FRANCISCO IN STRONG OPPOSITION.
01:23:41.649 --> 01:23:47.222
LINE ONE OR THREE. THIS IS DAN
01:23:47.288 --> 01:23:48.623
WISMA DIEGO IRONWORKERS STANDING
01:23:48.690 --> 01:23:57.298
IN OPPOSITION. 209. THIS IS RYAN
01:23:57.365 --> 01:23:58.633
O'CONNELL AND AFFILIATION WITH
01:23:58.700 --> 01:23:59.901
NAPA SOLANO FOR EVERYONE IN
01:23:59.968 --> 01:24:07.041
STRONG SUPPORT. 1 69. DOWN HERE
01:24:07.108 --> 01:24:09.344
. THIS IS DAVID JOHNSON. LOCAL
01:24:09.411 --> 01:24:10.478
29 IRONWORKERS WERE STRONGLY IN
01:24:10.545 --> 01:24:14.215
OPPOSITION OF A B 2011. THANK
01:24:14.282 --> 01:24:21.589
YOU. LINE 2 17. MELANIE MORALES
01:24:21.656 --> 01:24:23.024
ON BEHALF OF THE GREEN LINE.
01:24:23.091 --> 01:24:24.259
INTERESTED WITH SUPPORT FROM
01:24:24.325 --> 01:24:25.360
CONCEPT OFFICIAL THANK YOU. LINE
01:24:25.427 --> 01:24:33.301
202. THIS IS KENNY LAVENDER WITH
01:24:33.368 --> 01:24:34.602
THE CARPENTERS LOCAL 11 09 AND
01:24:34.669 --> 01:24:35.703
VISALIA, CALIFORNIA. STRONGLY
01:24:35.770 --> 01:24:46.514
SUPPORT A B 11 ONLY. LINE 1 73.
01:24:46.581 --> 01:24:49.517
HELLO THIS IS ALFRED TO IS FOR
01:24:49.584 --> 01:24:50.919
EVERYONE. WE ARE IN STRONG
01:24:50.985 --> 01:24:56.357
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 200.
01:24:56.424 --> 01:24:58.493
PAMELA GIVE BERMAN AND PANAMA
01:24:58.560 --> 01:25:00.995
CITY. I'M STILL STRONGLY OPPOSED
01:25:01.062 --> 01:25:04.532
TO 2011 YOU CIRCUMVENT SEQUA AND
01:25:04.599 --> 01:25:06.468
UM, ARE GOING TO TARGET
01:25:06.534 --> 01:25:08.903
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR FOR UH,
01:25:08.970 --> 01:25:11.139
SPECULATION AND TO DESTROY THE
01:25:11.206 --> 01:25:14.342
NATURE OF THEIR COMMUNITY. LOCAL
01:25:14.409 --> 01:25:15.443
SUPPORT, NOT SACRAMENTO. USER
01:25:15.510 --> 01:25:21.015
PATIENT. THANK YOU. WE HAVE LINE
01:25:21.082 --> 01:25:26.287
1 52. GOOD AFTERNOON, GRETCHEN
01:25:26.354 --> 01:25:28.022
NEWSOME ON BEHALF OF I B W LOCAL
01:25:28.089 --> 01:25:29.557
569 AND OR 3400 UNION
01:25:29.624 --> 01:25:31.226
ELECTRICIANS IN SAN DIEGO AND
01:25:31.292 --> 01:25:32.594
IMPERIAL COUNTY HAS BEEN
01:25:32.660 --> 01:25:33.895
OPPOSITION TO 2011 AND IN
01:25:33.962 --> 01:25:35.096
SOLIDARITY OF THE STATE BUILDING
01:25:35.163 --> 01:25:41.503
TREES. 93. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
01:25:41.569 --> 01:25:42.937
NAME IS RAYMOND DAVIS. I'M AN
01:25:43.004 --> 01:25:45.173
IRONWORKER FROM LOCAL 1 18 IN
01:25:45.240 --> 01:25:46.241
SACRAMENTO AND I OPPOSE A B
01:25:46.307 --> 01:25:54.883
2011. LINE 98. GOOD AFTERNOON.
01:25:54.949 --> 01:25:56.684
MY NAME IS MARTINEZ. YOU KNOW
01:25:56.751 --> 01:25:57.552
THE JUNIOR MEMBER LOOK. £34
01:25:57.619 --> 01:25:59.287
DRIVERS REPRESENTING 46 COUNTIES
01:25:59.354 --> 01:26:01.155
IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA, AND I AM
01:26:01.222 --> 01:26:03.258
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
01:26:03.324 --> 01:26:09.397
LINE 89. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
01:26:09.464 --> 01:26:10.765
CHAIRMAN, VICE CHAIR AND
01:26:10.832 --> 01:26:12.066
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
01:26:12.133 --> 01:26:14.068
NICOLE TOVAR OUT OF LONG BEACH.
01:26:14.135 --> 01:26:16.638
LOCAL 5 62. I AM THE PRESIDENT
01:26:16.704 --> 01:26:17.906
OF WOMEN'S AUXILIARY 7 10, PART
01:26:17.972 --> 01:26:20.308
OF THE SOUTHWEST REGIONALS.
01:26:20.375 --> 01:26:22.043
CARPENTER'S UNION AND I STRONGLY
01:26:22.110 --> 01:26:31.753
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU. 203. GOOD AFTERNOON, EVERYONE. MY
01:26:31.819 --> 01:26:33.655
NAME IS CLOVER COMMONWEALTH. I
01:26:33.721 --> 01:26:34.689
LIVE IN SOME BERNARDINO,
01:26:34.756 --> 01:26:36.724
CALIFORNIA. I AM A MEMBER OF THE
01:26:36.791 --> 01:26:38.426
LOS ANGELES SWIMMING'S ARTILLERY
01:26:38.493 --> 01:26:40.695
EURO 07. AND I STRONGLY SUPPORT
01:26:40.762 --> 01:26:48.503
A B 2011. THANK YOU. LINE 1 70.
01:26:48.570 --> 01:26:50.672
YES GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
01:26:50.738 --> 01:26:52.206
BEN LOPEZ FROM AUSTRALIA.
01:26:52.273 --> 01:26:54.676
CARPENTERS 11 09, AND I AM
01:26:54.742 --> 01:26:56.644
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011.
01:26:56.711 --> 01:27:04.652
THANK YOU. 2 27 227. THIS IS
01:27:04.719 --> 01:27:06.220
DAVID BARBOZA ON BEHALF OF
01:27:06.287 --> 01:27:08.089
ABUNDANT HOUSING LÀ WE SUPPORT A
01:27:08.156 --> 01:27:15.697
B 2011. LINE 1 48. GOOD
01:27:15.763 --> 01:27:17.131
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR. MY NAME IS
01:27:17.198 --> 01:27:18.666
CHRISTOPHER BURNETT, GLASER BY
01:27:18.733 --> 01:27:20.034
TRADE AND A MEMBER OF SAN
01:27:20.101 --> 01:27:22.503
FRANCISCO LOCAL UNION 718 AND A
01:27:22.570 --> 01:27:24.505
DELEGATE TO THE SAN FRANCISCO
01:27:24.572 --> 01:27:25.440
BUILDING, CONSTRUCTION AND TRADE
01:27:25.506 --> 01:27:26.741
COUNCIL AND ALSO A CONSTITUENT
01:27:26.808 --> 01:27:28.476
OF YOUR HOME DISTRICT. 11, MR
01:27:28.543 --> 01:27:31.145
CHAIR. I AM IN STRONG OPPOSITION
01:27:31.212 --> 01:27:33.915
TO A B 2011 AS WRITTEN WORKER
01:27:33.982 --> 01:27:35.984
PROTECTIONS MUST BE STRENGTHENED
01:27:36.050 --> 01:27:37.185
BEFORE MOVING FORWARD WITH THIS
01:27:37.251 --> 01:27:39.087
BILL, IT NEEDS TO BE AMENDED.
01:27:39.153 --> 01:27:46.060
THEY 1 92. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS
01:27:46.127 --> 01:27:47.462
IS LAURA KING TAMIA,
01:27:47.528 --> 01:27:48.830
REPRESENTING AMERICA COMMUNITY
01:27:48.896 --> 01:27:49.931
CAPITAL. WE ARE IN STRONG
01:27:49.998 --> 01:27:53.201
SUPPORT OF A B 2011 MERIT IS A
01:27:53.267 --> 01:27:54.402
MISSION BASED INVESTOR IN
01:27:54.469 --> 01:27:56.971
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. EXCLUSIVELY
01:27:57.038 --> 01:27:58.640
FOCUSED ON CALIFORNIA, AND WE
01:27:58.706 --> 01:28:00.708
KNOW A B 2011 WILL MAKE A
01:28:00.775 --> 01:28:01.576
MEANINGFUL DIFFERENCE. THANK YOU
01:28:01.643 --> 01:28:03.745
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:28:03.811 --> 01:28:04.846
VERY MUCH. AND AGAIN. THIS IS
01:28:04.912 --> 01:28:06.781
JUST NAME AFFILIATION AND YOUR
01:28:06.848 --> 01:28:09.584
SUPPORTER OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
01:28:09.651 --> 01:28:17.592
2 33. I AM THE MARSHALL THINGS
01:28:17.659 --> 01:28:19.027
THAT PARLIAMENT STRONG SUPPORT
01:28:19.093 --> 01:28:22.363
FROM YOUR LEVEL. THANK YOU. LINE
01:28:22.430 --> 01:28:32.507
ONE OR FOUR. 104 YOUR LINE IS
01:28:32.573 --> 01:28:43.384
OPEN. WILL MOVE TO LIE IN 1 24.
01:28:43.451 --> 01:28:45.753
OUR GIRL CARPENTERS, LOCAL 11 09
01:28:45.820 --> 01:28:50.491
AND SUPPORTED A B 2011. WE HAVE
01:28:50.558 --> 01:28:56.597
1 63. YES SO VIELMA AGAIN FROM
01:28:56.664 --> 01:28:58.132
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES WOMAN'S
01:28:58.199 --> 01:29:00.168
AUXILIARY LOCAL. THERE ARE 07
01:29:00.234 --> 01:29:03.838
AND STRONGLY SUPPORTED A B 2 11.
01:29:03.905 --> 01:29:11.946
LINE 82. YES, THIS IS ONE.
01:29:12.013 --> 01:29:15.450
DOMINGUEZ. CARPENTER'S LOCAL SO
01:29:15.516 --> 01:29:17.585
NO. ONE AND I'M IN SUPPORT OF A
01:29:17.652 --> 01:29:27.028
B 2011. 1 65. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
01:29:27.095 --> 01:29:28.629
NAME IS DAN WATSON OUT OF
01:29:28.696 --> 01:29:31.132
CARPENTERS, LOCAL 17 89 AND I
01:29:31.199 --> 01:29:33.868
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU. 2
01:29:33.935 --> 01:29:40.341
47. GOOD AFTERNOON. CHAIRMAN MY
01:29:40.408 --> 01:29:42.343
NAME IS RANDY WITMER IRONWORKERS
01:29:42.410 --> 01:29:45.680
LOCAL 4, 16 LOS ANGELES. WE
01:29:45.747 --> 01:29:49.383
STAND IN SOLIDARITY OPPOSING A B
01:29:49.450 --> 01:29:50.985
2011 WITH STATE BUILDING TRADES.
01:29:51.052 --> 01:30:01.395
THANK YOU. 1 96. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:30:01.462 --> 01:30:03.397
. THIS IS JAMES ASHCROFT
01:30:03.464 --> 01:30:04.532
IRONWORKERS. LOCAL 3 78 OUT OF
01:30:04.599 --> 01:30:06.868
OAKLAND WERE JOINING THE STATE
01:30:06.934 --> 01:30:08.002
BUILDING TRADES AND OPPOSITION
01:30:08.069 --> 01:30:15.676
TO THE A. B 2011. 1 27. GOOD
01:30:15.743 --> 01:30:16.978
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS CHUCK
01:30:17.044 --> 01:30:18.246
KNAUER, REPRESENTING CARPENTERS.
01:30:18.312 --> 01:30:20.982
LOCAL 15 99 READING CALIFORNIA
01:30:21.048 --> 01:30:24.485
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THE B 2011.
01:30:24.552 --> 01:30:34.462
2 52. LINE TO 52. PLEASE GO
01:30:34.529 --> 01:30:37.698
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
01:30:37.765 --> 01:30:39.333
CHAIRMAN, MEMBERS OF THE
01:30:39.400 --> 01:30:39.967
COMMITTEE PAULSON'S OFFICE ON
01:30:40.034 --> 01:30:41.469
BEHALF OF THE CITIES OF CHINO,
01:30:41.536 --> 01:30:43.704
CUPERTINO. FAIRFIELD BOWMORE.
01:30:43.771 --> 01:30:46.040
PANDORA INDIAN WELLS, LA MORADA
01:30:46.107 --> 01:30:48.376
LÀ POINT THEY WERE GOING TO
01:30:48.442 --> 01:30:49.677
HILLS LAKEWOOD, PALMDESERT,
01:30:49.744 --> 01:30:51.145
PARAMOUNT, ROSEMEAD, 1000 OAKS
01:30:51.212 --> 01:30:53.247
TORRENTS AND WHETHER YOU'RE IN
01:30:53.314 --> 01:30:53.848
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. THANK
01:30:53.915 --> 01:30:59.787
YOU. 2 51, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:30:59.854 --> 01:31:01.289
AFTERNOON. THIS IS JASON LINDSAY
01:31:01.355 --> 01:31:02.456
. I'M A MEMBER OF IRONWORKERS,
01:31:02.523 --> 01:31:05.026
LOCAL 3 78, AND WE'RE STANDING
01:31:05.092 --> 01:31:05.760
WITH THE STATE BUILDING TRADES
01:31:05.827 --> 01:31:07.829
AND OPPOSED TO 2011 UNLESS IT'S
01:31:07.895 --> 01:31:15.169
AMENDED. THANK YOU. 1 98. GOOD
01:31:15.236 --> 01:31:16.704
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBER SINCE
01:31:16.771 --> 01:31:18.139
CASTILLO ON BEHALF OF WESTERN
01:31:18.206 --> 01:31:19.707
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY WITH A
01:31:19.774 --> 01:31:22.043
BIT OF A TWEENER WHILE WE'RE
01:31:22.109 --> 01:31:23.444
SUPPORTIVE OF THE GOAL OF SPRING
01:31:23.511 --> 01:31:24.145
PRODUCTION OF MACHINE HOUSING
01:31:24.212 --> 01:31:24.979
WERE CONCERNED THE BILL MAY HAVE
01:31:25.046 --> 01:31:25.947
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES OF
01:31:26.013 --> 01:31:26.881
FEELING DISPLACEMENT AMONGST LOW
01:31:26.948 --> 01:31:28.516
INCOME RENTERS. WERE IN
01:31:28.583 --> 01:31:30.484
CONVERSATION TO ENSURE THE BILL
01:31:30.551 --> 01:31:31.552
SUPPORTS LOCAL POLICIES IS USING
01:31:31.619 --> 01:31:33.087
THE APPROPRIATE GEOGRAPHIC AREAS
01:31:33.154 --> 01:31:34.388
AND INCREASE ITS AFFORDABILITY
01:31:34.455 --> 01:31:35.690
REQUIREMENTS. WE LOOK FORWARD TO
01:31:35.756 --> 01:31:36.791
CONTINUED COLLABORATION THANKS
01:31:36.858 --> 01:31:44.265
SO MUCH. LINE 1 50. EDNA
01:31:44.332 --> 01:31:46.434
RODRIGUEZ WITH WOMEN AUXILIARY
01:31:46.500 --> 01:31:47.568
WANT NO. ONE CAMARILLO,
01:31:47.635 --> 01:31:48.903
CALIFORNIA AND I STRONGLY
01:31:48.970 --> 01:31:51.405
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU.
01:31:51.472 --> 01:31:57.245
ONE. OH, TWO. LET'S BLOW. THIS
01:31:57.311 --> 01:31:58.813
IS NICK MORE LOCAL AID ELEVATORS
01:31:58.880 --> 01:32:01.048
UNION, WHEREAS WE RECOGNIZE THE
01:32:01.115 --> 01:32:02.950
HOUSING CRISIS THAT WE'RE HAVING
01:32:03.017 --> 01:32:03.951
IN CALIFORNIA. WE MUST STAND
01:32:04.018 --> 01:32:05.620
WITH THE BUILDING TRADES. WE
01:32:05.686 --> 01:32:17.064
OPPOSED A B 2011. 1 68. 1 68,
01:32:17.131 --> 01:32:24.805
MAYBE ON MUTE. WILL MOVE TO LINE
01:32:24.872 --> 01:32:30.044
2 49. AFTERNOON THIS IS KEVIN MÀ
01:32:30.111 --> 01:32:31.812
WITH MOUNTAIN MUSEUM BE WE ARE
01:32:31.879 --> 01:32:34.015
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011. LINE
01:32:34.081 --> 01:32:40.421
1 49. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
01:32:40.488 --> 01:32:41.989
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
01:32:42.056 --> 01:32:43.324
TONY. OTHER FROM CORPORATE LOCAL
01:32:43.391 --> 01:32:46.027
605 MONTEREY COUNTY, CALIFORNIA
01:32:46.093 --> 01:32:47.228
AND I'M FULL SUPPORT OF A BEACH
01:32:47.295 --> 01:32:55.770
2011. 83. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
01:32:55.836 --> 01:32:57.305
NAME IS ANTONIO VASQUEZ WITH
01:32:57.371 --> 01:32:59.040
LOCAL 11 09 OUT OF I STARTED
01:32:59.106 --> 01:33:00.942
CALIFORNIA AND I'M IN SUPPORT OF
01:33:01.008 --> 01:33:07.114
A B 2011. 1 43. DAVE KIRK,
01:33:07.181 --> 01:33:09.150
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CONSTRUCTION
01:33:09.216 --> 01:33:10.217
AND BUILDING TRADES AND
01:33:10.284 --> 01:33:11.552
SOLIDARITY WITH STATE BUILDING
01:33:11.619 --> 01:33:13.487
TRADES AND OPPOSITION OF A B
01:33:13.554 --> 01:33:20.795
2011 2 53. HELLO THIS IS JOSHUA
01:33:20.861 --> 01:33:22.797
HAN,RESIDENT OF ALAMEDA,
01:33:22.863 --> 01:33:23.898
CALIFORNIA AND MEMBER OF THE
01:33:23.965 --> 01:33:25.032
PAPER. EVERYONE IN SUPPORT OF
01:33:25.099 --> 01:33:30.738
21. ONE. OH, ONE. HI THIS IS
01:33:30.805 --> 01:33:34.275
STEVE BELL. I AM, UH LOCAL 1, 52
01:33:34.342 --> 01:33:35.776
CARPENTERS AND REPRESENTING
01:33:35.843 --> 01:33:37.578
CONTRA COSTA COUNTIES. SAN
01:33:37.645 --> 01:33:39.680
JOAQUIN AMADOR, CALIPARI'S
01:33:39.747 --> 01:33:41.449
PTOLEMY, MARIPOSA, MERCED AND
01:33:41.515 --> 01:33:45.419
STANISLAS AND WE I AM IN FULL
01:33:45.486 --> 01:33:47.855
SUPPORT OF A B 2011. THANK YOU.
01:33:47.922 --> 01:33:53.227
85. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
01:33:53.294 --> 01:33:55.096
DAVE REEVES. I'M A MEMBER OF
01:33:55.162 --> 01:33:56.297
DRYWALL LADDERS. LOCAL 90 83
01:33:56.364 --> 01:33:58.299
FROM FRESNO, AND WE STRONGLY
01:33:58.366 --> 01:34:00.334
SUPPORT A B 2011. THANK YOU. 2
01:34:00.401 --> 01:34:07.141
58. ALRIGHT THIS IS ADAM
01:34:07.208 --> 01:34:10.011
PREVLAKA. I'M A CITIZEN IN SAN
01:34:10.077 --> 01:34:11.545
FRANCISCO WHO'S SEEN HIS FRIENDS
01:34:11.612 --> 01:34:14.048
PICK KICKED OUT OF THE CITY, THE
01:34:14.115 --> 01:34:14.682
HIGHEST HOUSING COSTS. I'M IN
01:34:14.749 --> 01:34:18.686
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2011. 2
01:34:18.753 --> 01:34:25.493
56. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS
01:34:25.559 --> 01:34:28.029
HIMSELF, UH, CALLING AND STRONG
01:34:28.095 --> 01:34:30.664
SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF THE NBA
01:34:30.731 --> 01:34:33.501
ACTION, AND, UH, CHAPPED LOCAL
01:34:33.567 --> 01:34:34.668
CHAPTER SENATE FOR THE N B. EAST
01:34:34.735 --> 01:34:40.741
BEIJING BE PEOPLE FOR HOUSING. 2
01:34:40.808 --> 01:34:47.815
71. WHICH IS. I WAS SEVEN.
01:34:47.882 --> 01:34:52.219
WELCOME. MY NAME IS FRANCISCO
01:34:52.286 --> 01:34:54.722
MARTINEZ CARBONS LOCAL 20 TO 36
01:34:54.789 --> 01:34:56.590
. I'M A STRONG SUPPORT FOR THE
01:34:56.657 --> 01:35:00.561
80 2011 BEFORE WE GO. THE NEXT
01:35:00.628 --> 01:35:01.896
ONE. I'M NOT LET EVERYONE KNOW
01:35:01.962 --> 01:35:03.664
I'M I'M FINALLY NOT ALONE. I'M
01:35:03.731 --> 01:35:04.799
REALLY HAPPY TO HAVE COMPANY AND
01:35:04.865 --> 01:35:06.500
THE COMMITTEE. UM BUT I'M GONNA
01:35:06.567 --> 01:35:07.902
I NEED TO HEAD OVER TO THE
01:35:07.968 --> 01:35:10.071
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE BRIEFLY
01:35:10.137 --> 01:35:11.839
TO VOTE. SENATOR SKINNER WILL
01:35:11.906 --> 01:35:13.307
CONTINUE TO FACILITATE THIS
01:35:13.374 --> 01:35:14.642
HEARING. I'LL BE BACK SHORTLY.
01:35:14.708 --> 01:35:19.747
YOU CAN CONTINUE. MR CHAIR. NEXT
01:35:19.814 --> 01:35:24.452
WE'RE GONNA LINE TO 65. GOOD
01:35:24.518 --> 01:35:26.754
AFTERNOON. NINA LABOR ON BEHALF
01:35:26.821 --> 01:35:28.656
OF THE CITY OF SOUTHEND, OX AND
01:35:28.722 --> 01:35:35.830
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. 2 25.
01:35:35.896 --> 01:35:37.765
SERIES STARTS IN IT AND A SIDE
01:35:37.832 --> 01:35:44.071
IN STRONG OPPOSITION. 2 72.
01:35:44.138 --> 01:35:46.240
HELLO SENATOR SKINNER AND
01:35:46.307 --> 01:35:48.375
SENATOR WEINER. THIS IS BOB
01:35:48.442 --> 01:35:50.077
HARROW ON BEHALF OF THE SOUTHERN
01:35:50.144 --> 01:35:51.245
CALIFORNIA DISTRICT COUNCIL OF
01:35:51.312 --> 01:35:52.646
PAINTERS. NUMBER 36. IN
01:35:52.713 --> 01:35:59.386
OPPOSITION. LINE 2 77
01:35:59.453 --> 01:36:00.554
ESTABLISHED A QUORUM SO WE CAN
01:36:00.621 --> 01:36:03.657
WE CAN TAKE IT. VOEPEL BREASTON
01:36:03.724 --> 01:36:05.292
WITH SOUTH PASADENA RESIDENTS
01:36:05.359 --> 01:36:07.428
RESPONSIBLE GROWTH WE ARE IN
01:36:07.495 --> 01:36:14.835
STRONG SUPPORT OF 2011. 2 75.
01:36:14.902 --> 01:36:16.036
THIS IS CAROL KELLY WITH
01:36:16.103 --> 01:36:17.104
NEIGHBORLY SANTA CRUZ COLLEAGUE
01:36:17.171 --> 01:36:22.943
AND TRUMP SUPPORTERS. 9 TO 63.
01:36:23.010 --> 01:36:24.211
HI GOOD AFTERNOON. ANTONIO
01:36:24.278 --> 01:36:27.314
SANCHEZ ON BEHALF OF I B W LOCAL
01:36:27.381 --> 01:36:29.316
11 AND LOS ANGELES AND OUR
01:36:29.383 --> 01:36:32.153
12,000 MEMBERS. UH WE DO NOT
01:36:32.219 --> 01:36:38.559
SUPPORT 2011. THANK YOU. 2 81.
01:36:38.626 --> 01:36:41.262
I'LL BET ARRUTI CREEK AND MEMBER
01:36:41.328 --> 01:36:43.097
OF CALIFORNIA IN THE STRONGEST
01:36:43.164 --> 01:36:51.405
SUPPORT PLAYING 109. KINETIC
01:36:51.472 --> 01:36:53.240
ARCIA WOMEN'S AUXILIARY LOCAL,
01:36:53.307 --> 01:36:55.276
91, RIVERSIDE, CALIFORNIA I
01:36:55.342 --> 01:37:03.751
STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2011. 2 84.
01:37:03.817 --> 01:37:06.453
HI MY NAME IS DAN NUNCIO AND I'M
01:37:06.520 --> 01:37:08.923
WITH CARPENTERS. LOCAL 701 OUT
01:37:08.989 --> 01:37:09.790
OF FRESNO, CALIFORNIA STRONGLY
01:37:09.857 --> 01:37:17.731
SUPPORT 2011. THANK YOU. 1 77.
01:37:17.798 --> 01:37:20.534
BRIAN AUSTIN WITH INCLUSIVE
01:37:20.601 --> 01:37:21.569
SANTA MONICA COLLEGE AND
01:37:21.635 --> 01:37:33.447
CONSTABLE. 2 89. 289 YOUR LINE
01:37:33.514 --> 01:37:45.626
IS OPEN. WE'LL GO TO 2 92. YES
01:37:45.693 --> 01:37:47.394
DAVID QUINTANA WOULD BUILD
01:37:47.461 --> 01:37:48.696
AFFORDABLE FASTER IN SUPPORT.
01:37:48.762 --> 01:37:56.870
291. HI. THIS IS JOHN BELL
01:37:56.937 --> 01:37:57.972
CARILLO WITH CARPENTERS, LOCAL 1
01:37:58.038 --> 01:38:00.274
80 CALLING AND STRONG SUPPORT. 2
01:38:00.341 --> 01:38:06.413
93. YES MY NAME IS JEFF HUNTER
01:38:06.480 --> 01:38:09.016
LOCK WITH THE HUMBLE DYLAN OR
01:38:09.083 --> 01:38:09.950
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
01:38:10.017 --> 01:38:12.353
TRADES. WE'RE JOINING THE STATE
01:38:12.419 --> 01:38:14.622
BUILDING TRADES AND OPPOSITION
01:38:14.688 --> 01:38:27.868
TO MAYBE. 2 94. 294 YOUR LINE IS
01:38:27.935 --> 01:38:42.750
OPEN. PROMOTED TO 96. 296 ARE
01:38:42.816 --> 01:38:47.087
YOU ON MUTE? CAN YOU HEAR ME
01:38:47.154 --> 01:38:50.924
NOW? YES. MY NAME IS PATRICK
01:38:50.991 --> 01:38:51.825
DAVIDSON, INTERNATIONAL
01:38:51.892 --> 01:38:53.661
EUROPEANS AND ALLIED TRADES AND
01:38:53.727 --> 01:38:54.728
, YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA LOCAL 13
01:38:54.795 --> 01:38:59.166
99. BY STRONGLY OPPOSED 82,011.
01:38:59.233 --> 01:39:02.236
THANK YOU. MODERN SEVEN.
01:39:02.303 --> 01:39:03.604
MODERATOR, CAN YOU TELL ME HOW
01:39:03.671 --> 01:39:05.439
MANY CALLERS ARE LEFT IN THE
01:39:05.506 --> 01:39:09.143
QUEUE? WE HAVE FIVE IN CUBA AT
01:39:09.209 --> 01:39:10.644
THIS TIME. OKAY GREAT. LET'S
01:39:10.711 --> 01:39:14.548
KEEP GOING. LET'S WRAP IT UP.
01:39:14.615 --> 01:39:18.752
LINE 2 97, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:39:18.819 --> 01:39:20.554
FIRST LOOK YOU CALLING ON BEHALF
01:39:20.621 --> 01:39:22.489
OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS AND
01:39:22.556 --> 01:39:23.057
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION. THANK
01:39:23.123 --> 01:39:28.362
YOU. 2 99. FAMILIAR POLITO WITH
01:39:28.429 --> 01:39:30.531
GOVERNORS. LOCAL 701 OUT OF
01:39:30.597 --> 01:39:33.367
FRESNO, UM, IN A STRONG SUPPORT
01:39:33.434 --> 01:39:39.073
OF A V 2011. THANK YOU. 300.
01:39:39.139 --> 01:39:40.741
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS JASON RYAN,
01:39:40.808 --> 01:39:42.242
LEAD CALIFORNIA CITIES AS
01:39:42.309 --> 01:39:43.644
DRAFTED. WE ARE OPPOSED.
01:39:43.711 --> 01:39:45.012
HOWEVER, WE GREATLY APPRECIATE
01:39:45.079 --> 01:39:47.181
THE AUTHORS WILLINGNESS TO WORK
01:39:47.247 --> 01:39:48.282
WITH JOHN LIMITS AND WE WILL
01:39:48.349 --> 01:39:54.588
CONTINUE TO DO SO. FINE, 77.
01:39:54.655 --> 01:39:55.889
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS SEAN
01:39:55.956 --> 01:39:57.458
MCGARY OF CARPENTER'S UNION,
01:39:57.524 --> 01:39:59.727
LOCAL 22 HERE IN SYDNEY, TOMMY
01:39:59.793 --> 01:40:01.929
FRANCISCO ON BEHALF OF OUR 4000
01:40:01.995 --> 01:40:02.830
MEMBERS. WE STRONGLY SUPPORT A B
01:40:02.896 --> 01:40:06.767
2011. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
01:40:06.834 --> 01:40:16.343
WE HAVE 2 62. 262. ARE YOU ON
01:40:16.410 --> 01:40:28.455
MEAL? AND AT THIS TIME WE'VE HAD
01:40:28.522 --> 01:40:29.223
ADDITIONAL LINES JOIN. DO YOU
01:40:29.289 --> 01:40:31.358
WANT TO STOP NOW? OR TAKE THOSE
01:40:31.425 --> 01:40:33.861
IN? Q? YOU CAN TAKE HOW MANY
01:40:33.927 --> 01:40:37.164
OTHERS JOINED IT LOOKS. IT LOOKS
01:40:37.231 --> 01:40:39.233
LIKE JUST ONE OTHER. OKAY? GO
01:40:39.299 --> 01:40:44.605
AHEAD. WE'LL GO TO LINE 1 19.
01:40:44.671 --> 01:40:53.714
HAVE YOU DONE A B 1 18 50. WE'RE
01:40:53.781 --> 01:40:59.720
ON 2011. OH, SORRY. THANK YOU
01:40:59.787 --> 01:41:01.588
WITH THAT ALTERNATIVE LINE BACK
01:41:01.655 --> 01:41:05.325
OVER THE CHAIR AT THIS TIME.
01:41:05.392 --> 01:41:09.229
THANK YOU. UM WE'RE GONNA LEAVE
01:41:09.296 --> 01:41:10.764
THIS HEARING ON THIS BILL. MAYBE
01:41:10.831 --> 01:41:14.768
2011 OPEN FOR CHAIR WIENER TO
01:41:14.835 --> 01:41:16.670
RETURN AND OF COURSE, I WOULD
01:41:16.737 --> 01:41:18.005
NORMALLY TURN TO OTHER MEMBERS
01:41:18.071 --> 01:41:20.140
AND ASK THEM FOR QUESTIONS OR
01:41:20.207 --> 01:41:26.113
COMMENTS. HOWEVER UH, WE, UM.
01:41:26.180 --> 01:41:28.382
UH, THAT'S NOT POSSIBLE YET, AND
01:41:28.449 --> 01:41:30.818
I KNOW THAT IF THE OTHER MEMBERS
01:41:30.884 --> 01:41:32.486
WHO PRIMARILY ITS MEMBERS THAT
01:41:32.553 --> 01:41:34.721
ARE IN, UM JUDICIARY NOW WE'RE
01:41:34.788 --> 01:41:36.824
HERE. I'M SURE THEY WOULD HAVE
01:41:36.890 --> 01:41:38.225
SOME COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. AH!
01:41:38.292 --> 01:41:54.475
UM. APOLOGIES. UM. WHILE WE ARE
01:41:54.541 --> 01:41:56.610
WAITING FOR SENATOR WIENER. I'M
01:41:56.677 --> 01:41:58.312
GOING TO LOOK AT MY NOTES
01:41:58.378 --> 01:42:00.113
BECAUSE I MAY HAVE SOME
01:42:00.180 --> 01:42:01.548
QUESTIONS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:42:01.615 --> 01:42:03.317
WICKS, SO LET ME JUST LOOK AT MY
01:42:03.383 --> 01:42:19.466
NOTES.
01:44:29.429 --> 01:44:32.466
SENATOR CORTEZ E. WE'RE ON, UH,
01:44:32.532 --> 01:44:36.470
THE SECOND BILL, MAYBE 2011 AND
01:44:36.536 --> 01:44:37.638
WE HAVE NOT ESTABLISHED QUORUM
01:44:37.704 --> 01:44:40.474
YET. WE'VE NOT HAD VOTES. AND
01:44:40.540 --> 01:44:42.109
THE CHAIR. SENATOR WEINER WILL
01:44:42.175 --> 01:44:44.144
BE BACK IN A FEW MOMENTS. WE'VE
01:44:44.211 --> 01:44:45.946
JUST CONCLUDED ALL THE TESTIMONY
01:44:46.013 --> 01:44:47.247
ON ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS BILL,
01:44:47.314 --> 01:44:50.884
MAYBE 2011 BUT CERTAINLY IF YOU
01:44:50.951 --> 01:44:52.786
HAD QUESTIONS RELATED TO THE
01:44:52.853 --> 01:44:55.856
BILL WOULD BE FREE TO, UM, ASK
01:44:55.922 --> 01:44:58.992
THEM NOW, IF YOU SO DESIRE.
01:44:59.059 --> 01:45:01.695
EARTH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:45:01.762 --> 01:45:10.003
MADAM CHAIR. I AM. I'VE GOTTEN
01:45:10.070 --> 01:45:11.271
MOST OF MY QUESTIONS ANSWERED UP
01:45:11.338 --> 01:45:14.908
TO THIS POINT. UM SO I DON'T
01:45:14.975 --> 01:45:17.310
WANT TO REPEAT ANY THAT ARE PUT
01:45:17.377 --> 01:45:18.345
THE AUTHOR OR HER WITNESSES
01:45:18.412 --> 01:45:19.613
THROUGHOUT THE QUESTIONS. I'VE
01:45:19.680 --> 01:45:23.016
ALREADY ASKED. I HAVE EXPRESSED
01:45:23.083 --> 01:45:26.720
SOME CONCERNS ABOUT A COUPLE OF
01:45:26.787 --> 01:45:28.588
PROVISIONS IN THE BILL THAT I
01:45:28.655 --> 01:45:31.158
THINK STILL NEED WORK. AND I
01:45:31.224 --> 01:45:33.393
GUESS I WILL SAY THAT WHILE I
01:45:33.460 --> 01:45:34.494
HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY HERE AND
01:45:34.561 --> 01:45:35.962
MAYBE SAVE SOME TIME LATER ON,
01:45:36.029 --> 01:45:37.197
IF THAT'S THAT'S OKAY WITH
01:45:37.264 --> 01:45:40.467
EVERYBODY. UM I DO BELIEVE THAT
01:45:40.534 --> 01:45:45.238
THERE'S SIGNIFICANT. WORK TO DO
01:45:45.305 --> 01:45:50.510
TO GET THE BILL. BASED ON ITS
01:45:50.577 --> 01:45:52.412
CURRENT FORM, UM, YOU KNOW, INTO
01:45:52.479 --> 01:45:55.348
BETTER BETTER FORM IN TERMS OF
01:45:55.415 --> 01:46:00.487
THE WORKFORCE. PROVISION AND I
01:46:00.554 --> 01:46:02.756
ALSO HAVE A LITTLE BIT OF
01:46:02.823 --> 01:46:03.957
CONCERN, WHICH I'VE TALKED TO
01:46:04.024 --> 01:46:05.192
THE AUTHOR IN HER OFFICE ABOUT
01:46:05.258 --> 01:46:07.260
WITH REGARD TO HOW THE
01:46:07.327 --> 01:46:09.362
INTERACTION BETWEEN THE OBJECT
01:46:09.429 --> 01:46:11.364
OF HIS OWNING STANDARDS YOU KNOW
01:46:11.431 --> 01:46:11.965
AT THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT LEVEL
01:46:12.032 --> 01:46:18.438
WILL WORK. WITH REFERENCE TO UM. THE REST OF THE BILL. GIVEN
01:46:18.505 --> 01:46:19.573
THAT WE'RE FOCUSED PRIMARILY ON
01:46:19.639 --> 01:46:22.275
COMMERCIAL PROPERTY. MOVING
01:46:22.342 --> 01:46:23.376
THROUGH THE PROCESS TO
01:46:23.443 --> 01:46:24.144
RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY. UNDERSTAND
01:46:24.211 --> 01:46:26.680
THERE'S A PLAN FOR THAT, AND I
01:46:26.747 --> 01:46:27.814
LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING MORE
01:46:27.881 --> 01:46:28.882
ABOUT THAT, AS BILL GOES
01:46:28.949 --> 01:46:32.753
FORWARD. I SEE THAT PRIMARILY
01:46:32.819 --> 01:46:34.020
BECAUSE I WANT TO, YOU KNOW,
01:46:34.087 --> 01:46:37.224
MAKE IT CLEAR THAT WHATEVER
01:46:37.290 --> 01:46:40.627
HAPPENS TODAY, IT WOULD BE
01:46:40.694 --> 01:46:43.263
PIVOTAL, PIVOTAL FOR ME TO GET
01:46:43.330 --> 01:46:44.397
THOSE QUESTIONS RESOLVED. YOU
01:46:44.464 --> 01:46:45.799
KNOW, BEFORE WE ULTIMATELY SEE
01:46:45.866 --> 01:46:48.835
THE BILL ON THE FLOOR. AGAIN
01:46:48.902 --> 01:46:51.037
BECAUSE I'M CONCERNED ENOUGH
01:46:51.104 --> 01:46:55.542
ABOUT. BUT THOSE TWO AREAS RIGHT
01:46:55.609 --> 01:46:58.545
NOW THAT IT WOULD IT WOULD KEEP
01:46:58.612 --> 01:46:59.813
ME OFF THE BILL ON THE FLOOR.
01:46:59.880 --> 01:47:03.049
BUT AS FOR TODAY AGAIN, I
01:47:03.116 --> 01:47:04.518
APPRECIATE VERY MUCH THE TIME
01:47:04.584 --> 01:47:06.353
SPENT, INCLUDING SOME WEEKEND
01:47:06.419 --> 01:47:07.320
TIME HEARING FROM FROM THE
01:47:07.387 --> 01:47:08.622
AUTHOR AND OTHERS INVOLVED WITH
01:47:08.688 --> 01:47:11.958
THE BILL. AND I APPRECIATE THE
01:47:12.025 --> 01:47:12.993
OPPORTUNITY, MADAM CHAIR TO USE
01:47:13.059 --> 01:47:15.395
THE TIME WE HAVE RIGHT NOW, TOO.
01:47:15.462 --> 01:47:16.763
TO MAKE THOSE COMMENTS. THANK
01:47:16.830 --> 01:47:20.734
YOU. SOMEBODY MEMBER WORKS
01:47:20.801 --> 01:47:22.969
BEFORE I TURN THE GAVEL OVER TO
01:47:23.036 --> 01:47:25.038
THE CHAIR. IF YOU WANTED TO
01:47:25.105 --> 01:47:26.039
RESPOND AT ALL, YOU'RE WELCOME
01:47:26.106 --> 01:47:28.074
TO SURE JUST WANT TO APPRECIATE
01:47:28.141 --> 01:47:29.009
SENATOR CORTEZ'S REMARKS HAPPY
01:47:29.075 --> 01:47:31.945
TO HAVE CONTINUED CONVERSATION,
01:47:32.012 --> 01:47:32.913
HIS LEADERSHIP AND KNOWLEDGE AND
01:47:32.979 --> 01:47:34.648
KNOW HOW IN THIS SPACE. I
01:47:34.714 --> 01:47:35.916
WELCOME HIM TO THE CONVERSATION.
01:47:35.982 --> 01:47:37.884
I KNOW HE'S LIVED AND BREATHED
01:47:37.951 --> 01:47:39.152
IT. THROUGHOUT HIS CAREER. UM
01:47:39.219 --> 01:47:41.188
YOU KNOW, I'M TRYING TO THREAD A
01:47:41.254 --> 01:47:41.955
NEEDLE HERE AND CREATE THE
01:47:42.022 --> 01:47:44.057
STRONGEST POSSIBLE BILL THAT WE
01:47:44.124 --> 01:47:45.358
CAN, UM WITH THE STRONGEST LABOR
01:47:45.425 --> 01:47:46.626
PROTECTIONS THAT WE CAN THAT
01:47:46.693 --> 01:47:47.561
ALSO ENABLES US TO BUILD THE
01:47:47.627 --> 01:47:49.930
HOUSING THAT WE NEED TO I CAN.
01:47:49.996 --> 01:47:51.832
I'M EAGER TO CONTINUE TO WORK
01:47:51.898 --> 01:47:52.966
WITH STAKEHOLDERS, BOTH THAT ARE
01:47:53.033 --> 01:47:54.000
SUPPORTING AND OPPOSING THE BILL
01:47:54.067 --> 01:47:55.902
BECAUSE I THINK IT MAKES US
01:47:55.969 --> 01:47:57.170
STRONGER. BILL WHEN WE TAKE INTO
01:47:57.237 --> 01:47:58.471
ACCOUNT ALL THESE THINGS, I
01:47:58.538 --> 01:47:59.139
DON'T WANT ANY UNINTENDED
01:47:59.206 --> 01:48:00.140
CONSEQUENCES AND LOOKING FORWARD
01:48:00.207 --> 01:48:08.915
TO MORE CONVERSATIONS. GREAT SO
01:48:08.982 --> 01:48:10.183
FIRST OF ALL, I WANT TO THANK
01:48:10.250 --> 01:48:13.119
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
01:48:13.186 --> 01:48:14.354
BILL FORWARD AND FOR DIVING
01:48:14.421 --> 01:48:18.558
HEADFIRST INTO OR CAN BE A VERY
01:48:18.625 --> 01:48:19.593
CHALLENGING DEBATE. AND I THINK
01:48:19.659 --> 01:48:21.661
WE'VE HEARD FROM PUBLIC COMMENT
01:48:21.728 --> 01:48:23.463
HERE TODAY. EVEN THOUGH I THINK
01:48:23.530 --> 01:48:25.665
THAT THE LABOR PIECE OF IT HAS
01:48:25.732 --> 01:48:28.068
GENERATED THE MOST DISCUSSION
01:48:28.134 --> 01:48:29.269
AND DEBATE AND DISAGREEMENT AS
01:48:29.336 --> 01:48:30.103
WE HEARD FROM PUBLIC COMMENT,
01:48:30.170 --> 01:48:32.706
THERE'S A LOT OF OTHER NON LABOR
01:48:32.772 --> 01:48:35.375
RELATED DISPUTES THAT WE SEE A
01:48:35.442 --> 01:48:36.643
RISE IN ALL OF THESE HOUSING
01:48:36.710 --> 01:48:37.777
BILLS AS WELL AROUND WITH THE
01:48:37.844 --> 01:48:40.046
CITY'S WITH SOME OF THE
01:48:40.113 --> 01:48:41.348
NEIGHBORHOOD GROUPS, UM HOUSING
01:48:41.414 --> 01:48:42.949
ACTIVISTS AND SO FORTH, UM AND
01:48:43.016 --> 01:48:45.018
SO FORTH. AND SO IT'S A TOUGH
01:48:45.085 --> 01:48:46.920
ISSUE, BUT, UM, AS CHALLENGING
01:48:46.987 --> 01:48:50.690
AS THIS ISSUE IS WE HAVE TO
01:48:50.757 --> 01:48:52.859
FIGURE IT OUT BECAUSE PEOPLE ARE
01:48:52.926 --> 01:48:55.462
LITERALLY, UM, LEAVING THE STATE
01:48:55.528 --> 01:48:57.364
LIVING IN CARS LIVING INTENSELY
01:48:57.430 --> 01:49:00.433
OVERCROWDED. CONDITIONS WE ARE
01:49:00.500 --> 01:49:04.504
THE STATE WE ARE BECAUSE OF 50
01:49:04.571 --> 01:49:06.072
YEARS OF BAD HOUSING POLICY,
01:49:06.139 --> 01:49:07.207
WHERE WE HAVE MADE IT
01:49:07.274 --> 01:49:08.275
PROGRESSIVELY HARDER AND HARDER
01:49:08.341 --> 01:49:10.410
TO BUILD HOUSING. WE REALLY SHOT
01:49:10.477 --> 01:49:12.345
OURSELVES IN THE FOOT AS A
01:49:12.412 --> 01:49:13.580
STATE, AND WE'RE AT RISK OF
01:49:13.647 --> 01:49:15.482
LOSING OUR STATUS AS THIS THIS
01:49:15.548 --> 01:49:18.885
DIVERSE, INNOVATIVE STATE THAT'S
01:49:18.952 --> 01:49:20.020
AN ECONOMIC POWERHOUSE AND
01:49:20.086 --> 01:49:23.657
HOUSING. IS AT THE INTERSECTION
01:49:23.723 --> 01:49:26.059
OF SO MANY OF THE PROBLEMS THAT
01:49:26.126 --> 01:49:27.527
THE STATE HAS. AND SO I
01:49:27.594 --> 01:49:29.529
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
01:49:29.596 --> 01:49:30.530
BILL. I ALSO JUST WANT TO
01:49:30.597 --> 01:49:32.098
ACKNOWLEDGE, UM, BUT BOTH THE
01:49:32.165 --> 01:49:34.167
SUPPORTERS AND THE OPPOSITION, I
01:49:34.234 --> 01:49:36.002
THINK ON. I THINK THERE'S A LOT
01:49:36.069 --> 01:49:37.904
OF THE OPPOSITION THAT WANTS TO
01:49:37.971 --> 01:49:39.105
BUILD. MORE HOUSING. IN FACT,
01:49:39.172 --> 01:49:40.974
THEIR EMPLOYMENT DEPENDS ON IT.
01:49:41.041 --> 01:49:43.109
BUT THEY HAVE A DIFFERENT
01:49:43.176 --> 01:49:43.677
PERSPECTIVE IN TERMS OF THE
01:49:43.743 --> 01:49:46.780
LABOR PROTECTIONS. AND SO I KNOW
01:49:46.846 --> 01:49:49.582
THAT THAT IF THE BILL GETS OUT
01:49:49.649 --> 01:49:51.484
OF THE COMMITTEE TODAY, AND I'M
01:49:51.551 --> 01:49:53.920
SUPPORTING THE BILL, AND I'LL BE
01:49:53.987 --> 01:49:56.056
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE. I
01:49:56.122 --> 01:49:57.090
THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO
01:49:57.157 --> 01:50:00.760
CONTINUE THAT DIALOGUE AND IT
01:50:00.827 --> 01:50:02.128
CAN SEEM A LITTLE CHAOTIC AT
01:50:02.195 --> 01:50:03.229
TIMES THESE CONVERSATIONS BUT
01:50:03.296 --> 01:50:07.467
OUT OF CHAOS. WILK COMES ORDER
01:50:07.534 --> 01:50:10.203
AND I THINK WE HAVE A REAL
01:50:10.270 --> 01:50:11.204
POSSIBILITY AND OPPORTUNITY THIS
01:50:11.271 --> 01:50:16.209
YEAR. TO STRIKE A DEAL AROUND
01:50:16.276 --> 01:50:19.245
LABOR PROTECTIONS SO THAT WE ARE
01:50:19.312 --> 01:50:21.514
MAKING SURE HOUSING GETS BUILT,
01:50:21.581 --> 01:50:22.282
MAKING SURE THAT CONSTRUCTION
01:50:22.349 --> 01:50:23.216
WORKERS ARE NOT LIVING IN
01:50:23.283 --> 01:50:26.086
POVERTY. I AM OPTIMISTIC THAT
01:50:26.152 --> 01:50:27.387
WE'RE GOING TO DO SOMETHING GOOD
01:50:27.454 --> 01:50:29.222
THIS SUMMER. I'VE BEEN WRONG
01:50:29.289 --> 01:50:31.891
BEFORE, BUT I AM OPTIMISTIC AND
01:50:31.958 --> 01:50:33.893
I LOOK FORWARD TO THOSE
01:50:33.960 --> 01:50:35.562
CONTINUING CONVERSATIONS OVER
01:50:35.628 --> 01:50:37.330
THE NEXT FEW MONTHS BEFORE THE
01:50:37.397 --> 01:50:40.467
END OF SESSION. SO WE HAVE YET
01:50:40.533 --> 01:50:43.169
TO ESTABLISH QUORUM SO WE CAN'T
01:50:43.236 --> 01:50:46.673
TAKE THEM A MOTION. WE'RE CLOSE.
01:50:46.740 --> 01:50:47.841
WE'RE ONE SHORT AND I THINK
01:50:47.907 --> 01:50:48.842
EVERYBODY'S CHAIR WILL BE BACK
01:50:48.908 --> 01:50:50.443
FROM PRESENTING A BILL SHORTLY
01:50:50.510 --> 01:50:52.479
SO I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION ONCE
01:50:52.545 --> 01:50:53.079
WE HAVE ESTABLISHED A QUORUM.
01:50:53.146 --> 01:50:54.681
AND WITH THAT, YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:50:54.748 --> 01:50:56.816
JUST OBVIOUSLY. CHAIR WINNER
01:50:56.883 --> 01:50:58.718
WANT TO THANK YOU FOR YOUR GOOD
01:50:58.785 --> 01:51:00.153
WORK IN THIS SPACE AND EVERYONE
01:51:00.220 --> 01:51:02.055
ON THIS COMMITTEE, UM, FOR THEIR
01:51:02.122 --> 01:51:03.256
WORK IN THE SPACE. I THINK WE'RE
01:51:03.323 --> 01:51:04.691
ALL TRYING TO TACKLE THIS ISSUE.
01:51:04.758 --> 01:51:07.160
WE'RE ALL TRYING TO DO THE BEST
01:51:07.227 --> 01:51:07.927
WE CAN. I GENUINELY WELCOME
01:51:07.994 --> 01:51:09.195
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
01:51:09.262 --> 01:51:10.163
OPPOSITION BECAUSE I DO BELIEVE
01:51:10.230 --> 01:51:12.065
WE ALL HAVE THE SAME INTENT. UM,
01:51:12.132 --> 01:51:13.266
AND AS SOMEONE WHO WORKED IN THE
01:51:13.333 --> 01:51:14.501
LABOR MOVEMENT, AND YOU KNOW,
01:51:14.567 --> 01:51:17.037
UM, HAS SUCH ENORMOUS RESPECT.
01:51:17.103 --> 01:51:18.605
FOR FOLKS IN THE BUILDING TRADES
01:51:18.671 --> 01:51:20.006
AND OUR LOCAL CITIES, SOME OF
01:51:20.073 --> 01:51:21.641
WHOM ARE OPPOSING THE BILL. I
01:51:21.708 --> 01:51:22.876
WANT TO MAKE IT THE STRONGEST
01:51:22.942 --> 01:51:24.744
BILL POSSIBLE, AND I THINK THAT
01:51:24.811 --> 01:51:25.945
INVOLVES A LOT OF CONVERSATION.
01:51:26.012 --> 01:51:27.714
BUT WE I THINK, AND I VOTE TODAY
01:51:27.781 --> 01:51:29.549
WILL BE MOVING THE BILL AND THE
01:51:29.616 --> 01:51:30.617
CONVERSATION FORWARD SO WE CAN
01:51:30.683 --> 01:51:31.951
HAVE THIS CONTINUED
01:51:32.018 --> 01:51:32.952
CONVERSATIONS. AND LOOK FORWARD
01:51:33.019 --> 01:51:34.087
TO THAT RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
01:51:34.154 --> 01:51:35.922
VOTE. WHEN THE TIME WHEN YOU
01:51:35.989 --> 01:51:37.123
DON'T HAVE A QUORUM, THANKS.
01:51:37.190 --> 01:51:38.058
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:51:38.124 --> 01:51:40.727
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S OKAY, WE'RE NOW
01:51:40.794 --> 01:51:46.266
GOING TO GO TO, UM, NUMBER. SIX.
01:51:46.332 --> 01:51:48.134
ITEM NUMBER SIX AND I SEE THAT
01:51:48.201 --> 01:51:49.302
OUR NEWEST COLLEAGUE IN THE
01:51:49.369 --> 01:51:52.839
LEGISLATURE ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
01:51:52.906 --> 01:51:54.908
SOME REMEMBER KINER IS HERE. SO
01:51:54.974 --> 01:51:58.511
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CONGRATULATIONS
01:51:58.578 --> 01:52:01.047
. WELCOME TO THE LEGISLATURE AND
01:52:01.114 --> 01:52:02.549
TO THE SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE
01:52:02.615 --> 01:52:04.217
AND YOU'LL BE PRESENTING A B 17
01:52:04.284 --> 01:52:14.094
43 SO WELCOME. GOOD AFTERNOON.
01:52:14.160 --> 01:52:18.064
MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I WOULD
01:52:18.131 --> 01:52:19.599
LIKE TO BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE
01:52:19.666 --> 01:52:21.067
AMENDMENTS NOTED IN THE
01:52:21.134 --> 01:52:22.836
COMMITTEE ANALYSTS AS AUTHOR
01:52:22.902 --> 01:52:23.903
AMENDMENTS AND THANK THE
01:52:23.970 --> 01:52:25.071
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR WORK ON THIS
01:52:25.138 --> 01:52:29.476
BILL. SENATORS A B 17 43 WOULD
01:52:29.542 --> 01:52:30.910
REQUIRE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
01:52:30.977 --> 01:52:33.646
REPORT THE ACTUAL NUMBER OF
01:52:33.713 --> 01:52:35.048
HOUSING UNITS THAT WERE PRODUCED
01:52:35.115 --> 01:52:36.149
AND OCCUPIED IN THE PREVIOUS
01:52:36.216 --> 01:52:39.185
YEAR. THIS BILL ASKED. LOCAL
01:52:39.252 --> 01:52:40.386
GOVERNMENTS IS VERY, VERY
01:52:40.453 --> 01:52:43.556
SIMPLE, BUT IMPORTANT QUESTION.
01:52:43.623 --> 01:52:44.991
AFTER ALL THE WORK OF THE
01:52:45.058 --> 01:52:46.593
LEGISLATURE, THE GOVERNMENT AND
01:52:46.659 --> 01:52:48.995
OUR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS OVER THE
01:52:49.062 --> 01:52:50.830
PAST SEVERAL YEARS TO ADDRESS
01:52:50.897 --> 01:52:52.332
THE HOUSING CRISIS, HOW MUCH
01:52:52.398 --> 01:52:54.334
HOUSING WAS ACTUALLY PRODUCED?
01:52:54.400 --> 01:52:58.438
AS WE CONTINUE OUR WORK. EXCUSE
01:52:58.505 --> 01:53:00.940
ME TO MAKE SURE CALIFORNIA HAS A
01:53:01.007 --> 01:53:03.076
SAFE AND AFFORDABLE PLACE TO
01:53:03.143 --> 01:53:04.777
CALL HOME. THE INFORMATION
01:53:04.844 --> 01:53:07.747
PROVIDED BY A B 17 43 WILL GIVE
01:53:07.814 --> 01:53:09.616
THE PUBLIC AND POLICYMAKERS AND
01:53:09.682 --> 01:53:12.085
IMPORTANT METRIC NECESSARY TO
01:53:12.152 --> 01:53:13.553
GUIDE OUR WORK IN THE FUTURE.
01:53:13.620 --> 01:53:15.722
THIS MEASURE HAS NO OPPOSITION
01:53:15.788 --> 01:53:16.856
I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I
01:53:16.923 --> 01:53:19.692
VOTE. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
01:53:19.759 --> 01:53:24.864
MUCH. KENNY. I'M TRYING TO
01:53:24.931 --> 01:53:26.166
REMEMBER BACK TO WHEN I
01:53:26.232 --> 01:53:28.201
PRESENTED MY FIRST BILL SO LONG
01:53:28.268 --> 01:53:33.806
TIME AGO, UM. UH SO, UH, DO WE
01:53:33.873 --> 01:53:37.544
HAVE ANY SUPPORT? UH, HERE IN
01:53:37.610 --> 01:53:39.812
THE HEARING ROOM FOR A B 17 43
01:53:39.879 --> 01:53:44.050
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S KENNER. THE
01:53:44.117 --> 01:53:45.585
SEEING? NONE WILL GO TO THE
01:53:45.652 --> 01:53:47.720
PHONE LINES. MR MODERATOR, CAN
01:53:47.787 --> 01:53:49.455
YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP ANY SUPPORT
01:53:49.522 --> 01:53:53.826
FOR THE BILL? THANK YOU TO
01:53:53.893 --> 01:53:55.295
EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL,
01:53:55.361 --> 01:53:57.197
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO
01:53:57.263 --> 01:53:59.065
AGAIN. THAT'S ONE AND THEN THERE
01:53:59.132 --> 01:54:02.869
ON YOUR TELEPHONE. WE'LL GO TO
01:54:02.936 --> 01:54:13.246
LINE 1 86. 28. NO, THEY'VE
01:54:13.313 --> 01:54:19.085
DISCONNECTED. WE'LL GO TO 3 14.
01:54:19.152 --> 01:54:21.154
3 14. DID YOU WANT TO SPEAK ON A
01:54:21.221 --> 01:54:30.496
B? 17 43? MOVE THE LINE TO 86.
01:54:30.563 --> 01:54:36.703
GOOD AFTERNOON. HELLO. GO AHEAD.
01:54:36.769 --> 01:54:42.275
YOU CAN HEAR YOU. OKAY ROBERT
01:54:42.342 --> 01:54:43.543
SMITH, PAINTERS AND ALLIED TRACE
01:54:43.610 --> 01:54:45.578
DISTRICT COUNCIL 36.
01:54:45.645 --> 01:54:47.247
CONGRATULATIONS TO OUR NEW
01:54:47.313 --> 01:54:49.182
MEMBER AND I SUPPORT HER. BILL.
01:54:49.249 --> 01:54:54.654
THANK YOU. THANK YOU KNOW, OTHER
01:54:54.721 --> 01:54:56.623
THAN LIONS IN Q AT THIS TIME.
01:54:56.689 --> 01:54:57.790
GREAT. THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY
01:54:57.857 --> 01:54:59.626
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL IN THE
01:54:59.692 --> 01:55:01.294
HEARING ROOM? SEEING NONE WILL
01:55:01.361 --> 01:55:03.196
MOVE TO THE PHONE LINES. CAN YOU
01:55:03.263 --> 01:55:07.800
CUE UP ANY OPPOSITION? SPEAKING
01:55:07.867 --> 01:55:08.835
OPPOSITION PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO
01:55:08.901 --> 01:55:15.041
AT THIS TIME. WE HAVE NO LINES
01:55:15.108 --> 01:55:18.044
QUEUING UP. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:55:18.111 --> 01:55:19.846
OKAY, WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
01:55:19.912 --> 01:55:20.847
COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY
01:55:20.913 --> 01:55:21.948
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THIS
01:55:22.015 --> 01:55:27.887
BILL? DO WE. WE DO NOT HAVE A
01:55:27.954 --> 01:55:29.088
QUORUM SO WE CAN'T MOVE THE
01:55:29.155 --> 01:55:31.724
BILL. OKAY I SAID, REMEMBER,
01:55:31.791 --> 01:55:33.559
WE'LL TAKE ENTERTAINING MOTION
01:55:33.626 --> 01:55:35.662
ONCE WE HAVE A QUORUM. UM BUT WE
01:55:35.728 --> 01:55:36.896
APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENTATION AND
01:55:36.963 --> 01:55:38.531
YOU'RE WELCOME TO CLOSE. THANK
01:55:38.598 --> 01:55:40.533
YOU. WONDERFUL. THANK YOU SO
01:55:40.600 --> 01:55:46.139
MUCH. OKAY DO WE HAVE WE DO NOT
01:55:46.205 --> 01:55:47.240
HAVE ANOTHER AUTHOR AT THE
01:55:47.307 --> 01:55:49.575
MOMENT? UM YEAH, WE'RE GOING TO
01:55:49.642 --> 01:55:59.619
TRY TO SOME AUTHORS. YEAH. IF
01:55:59.686 --> 01:56:00.887
SENATOR SKINNER WORKS HERE, SHE
01:56:00.953 --> 01:56:02.789
WOULD HAVE PUT EVERYTHING IN THE
01:56:02.855 --> 01:56:05.124
SHAPE A LONG TIME AGO, SO I FEEL
01:56:05.191 --> 01:56:06.225
VERY INADEQUATE RIGHT NOW. UM
01:56:06.292 --> 01:56:22.375
OKAY?
01:57:32.078 --> 01:57:34.447
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD COME UP TO
01:57:34.514 --> 01:57:35.648
THE PODIUM WILL BE WITH YOU IN
01:57:35.715 --> 01:57:52.565
JUST A SECOND.
01:57:53.499 --> 01:57:59.639
WAIT TILL THEY GET AHOLD. AH WE
01:57:59.705 --> 01:58:01.040
CAN ESTABLISH DECORUM. OKAY WHO?
01:58:01.107 --> 01:58:17.757
JUST TALK.
01:58:23.463 --> 01:58:27.433
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD OPEN. MAKE
01:58:27.500 --> 01:58:29.101
YOUR FIRST STATEMENT ON IT. AND
01:58:29.168 --> 01:58:30.937
THEN AS SOON AS THE CHAIR WALKS
01:58:31.003 --> 01:58:31.871
IN, WELL ESTABLISHED QUORUM,
01:58:31.938 --> 01:58:33.940
OKAY, YOU'RE A B 18 50 GO AHEAD
01:58:34.006 --> 01:58:35.041
. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I'M
01:58:35.107 --> 01:58:37.076
HERE TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL 18
01:58:37.143 --> 01:58:38.511
50, WHILE PUBLIC ACQUISITION OF
01:58:38.578 --> 01:58:40.880
HOUSING CAN BE A BENEFICIAL TOOL
01:58:40.947 --> 01:58:41.848
TO INCREASE THE SUBJECT SUPPLY
01:58:41.914 --> 01:58:43.182
OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THE
01:58:43.249 --> 01:58:45.117
CURRENT USE OF THIS MODEL BY
01:58:45.184 --> 01:58:46.118
JOINT POWERS AUTHORITIES AND
01:58:46.185 --> 01:58:47.019
THEREFORE PROFIT PARTNERS.
01:58:47.086 --> 01:58:48.621
SOMETIMES FAILS TO PROVIDE THE
01:58:48.688 --> 01:58:50.423
PUBLIC BENEFIT COMMENSURATE WITH
01:58:50.490 --> 01:58:51.858
THE PUBLIC SUBSIDY. NOW THE
01:58:51.924 --> 01:58:54.060
DOZENS OF TRANSACTIONS THAT HAVE
01:58:54.126 --> 01:58:55.528
OCCURRED TO DATE ARE NOT SUBJECT
01:58:55.595 --> 01:58:56.462
TO FIRM AFFORDABILITY
01:58:56.529 --> 01:58:58.664
REQUIREMENTS OFFER RENTS THAT
01:58:58.731 --> 01:59:00.566
REMAIN ABOVE THE MARKET AVERAGE
01:59:00.633 --> 01:59:02.201
PAYOUT EXORBITANT FEES TO THE
01:59:02.268 --> 01:59:04.003
INVESTORS AND ARE NOT ADEQUATELY
01:59:04.070 --> 01:59:05.872
MONITORED BY A PUBLIC ENTITY.
01:59:05.938 --> 01:59:07.473
THESE TRANSACTIONS DO NOT
01:59:07.540 --> 01:59:09.041
PROVIDE PUBLIC BENEFIT
01:59:09.108 --> 01:59:10.810
PROPORTIONATE WITH THE LOST TAX
01:59:10.877 --> 01:59:12.778
REVENUE AND INHERENTLY OR RISKY
01:59:12.845 --> 01:59:14.413
VENTURES AT HIGH RISK OF DEFAULT
01:59:14.480 --> 01:59:15.882
AND PAYOUT. EXORBITANT FEES TO
01:59:15.948 --> 01:59:18.784
INVESTORS. NOW A B A. B 18 50
01:59:18.851 --> 01:59:20.486
WOULD SET MINIMUM STANDARDS OF
01:59:20.553 --> 01:59:21.821
OWNERSHIP FOR WHEN PUBLIC
01:59:21.888 --> 01:59:22.822
ENTITIES ACQUIRE MIDDLE INCOME
01:59:22.889 --> 01:59:24.390
HOUSING TO ENSURE THAT FUTURE
01:59:24.457 --> 01:59:25.525
TRANSACTIONS ARE EQUITABLE FOR
01:59:25.591 --> 01:59:28.761
TENANTS. THE LOCAL JURISDICTION
01:59:28.828 --> 01:59:30.363
AND OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WHO
01:59:30.429 --> 01:59:31.797
WOULD OTHERWISE LOSE PROPERTY
01:59:31.864 --> 01:59:34.166
TAX REVENUE. THIS WILL ALLOW JPS
01:59:34.233 --> 01:59:36.302
AND PRIVATE FOR PROFIT INTEREST
01:59:36.369 --> 01:59:37.803
TO ENTER INTO MUTUALLY
01:59:37.870 --> 01:59:38.871
BENEFICIAL AGREEMENTS THAT WILL
01:59:38.938 --> 01:59:40.473
SECURE AFFORDABLE AND MIDDLE
01:59:40.540 --> 01:59:42.642
INCOME HOUSING FOR THE RESPECTED
01:59:42.708 --> 01:59:44.710
, RESPECTED, RESPECTED
01:59:44.777 --> 01:59:46.279
COMMUNITIES. NOW, I'D LIKE TO
01:59:46.345 --> 01:59:47.380
PRESENT WITNESSES AND SUPPORTED
01:59:47.446 --> 01:59:49.015
THE BILL. MARK SURVIVORS
01:59:49.081 --> 01:59:50.783
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
01:59:50.850 --> 01:59:51.784
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AND LARRY
01:59:51.851 --> 01:59:52.351
FLOREN, REPRESENTING BURBANK
01:59:52.418 --> 01:59:54.787
HOUSING. GOOD AFTERNOON MARKS.
01:59:54.854 --> 01:59:55.755
DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:59:55.821 --> 01:59:58.491
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. WE ALL
01:59:58.558 --> 01:59:59.926
SHARE AN INTEREST IN MEETING
01:59:59.992 --> 02:00:01.661
AFFORDABLE HOUSING NEEDS AT ALL
02:00:01.727 --> 02:00:02.295
INCOME LEVELS. OPPONENTS OF THIS
02:00:02.361 --> 02:00:03.829
BILL WILL SAY THAT THEY THAT
02:00:03.896 --> 02:00:05.131
THEY ARE PROVIDING AFFORDABLE
02:00:05.197 --> 02:00:05.932
HOUSING TO MIDDLE INCOME
02:00:05.998 --> 02:00:06.666
HOUSEHOLDS WITH NO PUBLIC
02:00:06.732 --> 02:00:07.533
SUBSIDY. UNFORTUNATELY, NEITHER
02:00:07.600 --> 02:00:09.535
IS TRUE. FIRST, LET'S TALK ABOUT
02:00:09.602 --> 02:00:12.605
THE SUBSIDY. IDENTITY JP
02:00:12.672 --> 02:00:14.106
OWNERSHIP. THESE DEVELOPMENTS
02:00:14.173 --> 02:00:15.608
RECEIVE PROPERTY TAX BREAKS IN
02:00:15.675 --> 02:00:17.043
THE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS PER YEAR
02:00:17.109 --> 02:00:18.978
WITH MOST OF THE HIT TAKEN BY
02:00:19.045 --> 02:00:20.246
COUNTY SCHOOLS AND INDIRECTLY
02:00:20.313 --> 02:00:22.114
THE STATE WHO HAVE NO SAY IN THE
02:00:22.181 --> 02:00:23.783
MATTER. IN ADDITION, THE BUYERS
02:00:23.849 --> 02:00:26.352
OF THE BONDS, FINANCING THE
02:00:26.419 --> 02:00:26.986
PURCHASE OR NOT PAYING TAXES ON
02:00:27.053 --> 02:00:28.020
THEIR INTEREST EARNINGS. AS FOR
02:00:28.087 --> 02:00:29.422
AFFORDABILITY IN THE LARGE
02:00:29.488 --> 02:00:30.623
MAJORITY OF CASES, THE RENTS
02:00:30.690 --> 02:00:32.425
THESE DEVELOPMENTS CHARGE REMAIN
02:00:32.491 --> 02:00:34.160
WELL ABOVE THE HEAD DETERMINED,
02:00:34.226 --> 02:00:35.661
FAIR MARKET RENT FOR THE ZIP
02:00:35.728 --> 02:00:37.930
CODE KNOWN AS A SMALL AREA FAIR
02:00:37.997 --> 02:00:39.098
MARKET RENT, WHICH CONSIDERS ALL
02:00:39.165 --> 02:00:41.067
RENTAL UNITS. OF THE 21 J. P A
02:00:41.133 --> 02:00:42.668
DEVELOPMENT FOR WHICH WE HAVE
02:00:42.735 --> 02:00:45.071
RENT DATA. 80% AMI RENTS WERE
02:00:45.137 --> 02:00:47.440
WERE BELOW THE HEAD BUNCH. THE
02:00:47.506 --> 02:00:48.941
HUD BENCHMARK IN ONLY EIGHT
02:00:49.008 --> 02:00:50.977
DEVELOPMENTS. THE 100% AMY RENTS
02:00:51.043 --> 02:00:52.878
WERE BELOW THE HUD BENCHMARK AND
02:00:52.945 --> 02:00:54.747
ONLY FIVE CASES. AND ONLY THREE
02:00:54.814 --> 02:00:56.682
CASES WITH 120% AMY RENTS BELOW
02:00:56.749 --> 02:00:58.918
THE BENCHMARK THE RED
02:00:58.985 --> 02:01:00.353
CALCULATION SHEET THAT THE
02:01:00.419 --> 02:01:01.854
SURGEON JUST HANDED OUT TO YOU
02:01:01.921 --> 02:01:04.290
ILLUSTRATES THE SON OF PHIL AND
02:01:04.357 --> 02:01:04.890
AFFORDABILITY FOR PARTICULAR
02:01:04.957 --> 02:01:06.525
DEVELOPMENT IN SANTA ROSA. THE
02:01:06.592 --> 02:01:08.027
RENT SAVINGS THE OPPONENTS CLAIM
02:01:08.094 --> 02:01:09.528
ARE ONLY IN COMPARISON TO CLASS
02:01:09.595 --> 02:01:10.863
. A LUXURY APARTMENTS ARE VERY
02:01:10.930 --> 02:01:11.964
SMALL SUBSET OF THE OVERALL
02:01:12.031 --> 02:01:14.467
MARKET. WHEREAS WORKING FAMILIES
02:01:14.533 --> 02:01:16.202
NEED A SOLID CAMERAS TO GET TO
02:01:16.268 --> 02:01:17.336
WORK. THESE DEVELOPMENTS ARE
02:01:17.403 --> 02:01:20.406
OFFERING DISCOUNTS ON A FERRARI.
02:01:20.473 --> 02:01:21.974
MOREOVER THE FOR PROFIT
02:01:22.041 --> 02:01:23.409
ADMINISTRATORS ARE RECEIVING
02:01:23.476 --> 02:01:24.210
EXCESSIVE COMPENSATION,
02:01:24.276 --> 02:01:25.911
ESPECIALLY WHEN ONE CONSIDERS
02:01:25.978 --> 02:01:26.846
THAT THEY ARE MERELY BUYING AND
02:01:26.912 --> 02:01:28.147
MANAGING AN EXISTING DEVELOPMENT
02:01:28.214 --> 02:01:29.448
, NOT DEVELOPING SORELY NEEDED
02:01:29.515 --> 02:01:32.818
NEW HOUSING. THEY'RE RECEIVING
02:01:32.885 --> 02:01:34.787
UPFRONT FEES AS MUCH AS $2
02:01:34.854 --> 02:01:36.288
MILLION OR MORE, THEY GET AN
02:01:36.355 --> 02:01:38.190
ANNUAL ADMINISTRATOR FEE IN THE
02:01:38.257 --> 02:01:39.592
$700,000 RANGE, AND BY WAY OF
02:01:39.659 --> 02:01:41.727
COMPARISON, HCG THAT OUR
02:01:41.794 --> 02:01:43.229
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING LIMITS
02:01:43.295 --> 02:01:43.829
ASSET MANAGER FEES AND TRUE
02:01:43.896 --> 02:01:44.664
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO $37,000
02:01:44.730 --> 02:01:47.867
PER YEAR. LASTLY THEY ARE
02:01:47.933 --> 02:01:50.036
BENEFICIARIES OF A SO CALLED B
02:01:50.102 --> 02:01:51.804
BOND, A DEBT TO THE PROPERTY
02:01:51.871 --> 02:01:53.806
OFTEN OF $5 MILLION ACCRUING
02:01:53.873 --> 02:01:56.442
INTEREST AT 10% PER YEAR. THE
02:01:56.509 --> 02:01:57.810
SECOND DOCUMENT I HANDED OUT
02:01:57.877 --> 02:01:59.478
SHOWS TWO EXAMPLES. LASTLY THE
02:01:59.545 --> 02:02:00.413
OPPONENTS WHO BENEFIT GREATLY
02:02:00.479 --> 02:02:01.714
FROM THE STATUS QUO WILL ARGUE
02:02:01.781 --> 02:02:03.582
THAT THE BILL KILLS THE ENTIRE
02:02:03.649 --> 02:02:06.118
JP MODEL. AS MR FLORIN WILL
02:02:06.185 --> 02:02:07.486
TESTIFY. THE NONPROFIT COMMUNITY
02:02:07.553 --> 02:02:08.554
FINDS THE MODEL STILL WORKABLE
02:02:08.621 --> 02:02:11.157
WITH THE BILL. AND THE TURNER
02:02:11.223 --> 02:02:12.658
CENTER AT UC BERKELEY AND SPUR
02:02:12.725 --> 02:02:13.859
WHO TOGETHER CONVENED A WORKING
02:02:13.926 --> 02:02:15.795
GROUP OF PARTNERS INTERESTED IN
02:02:15.861 --> 02:02:17.797
MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING. ALSO FIND
02:02:17.863 --> 02:02:19.165
THE BILL WORKABLE. THE LARGE
02:02:19.231 --> 02:02:20.800
MAJORITY OF STAKEHOLDERS FIND
02:02:20.866 --> 02:02:22.334
STABILITY, A REASONABLE BALANCE.
02:02:22.401 --> 02:02:23.436
IN OTHER WORDS, THE PROVERBIAL
02:02:23.502 --> 02:02:26.138
SWEET SPOT. IN SOME, IF THE
02:02:26.205 --> 02:02:27.339
PUBLIC IS GOING TO PROVIDE A
02:02:27.406 --> 02:02:27.907
SUBSIDY, THE PUBLIC SHOULD
02:02:27.973 --> 02:02:30.042
RECEIVE A COMMENSURATE PUBLIC
02:02:30.109 --> 02:02:32.111
BENEFIT. A B 18 50 ENSURES AN
02:02:32.178 --> 02:02:33.045
APPROPRIATE BALANCE AND ALSO
02:02:33.112 --> 02:02:34.213
ENSURES THE LONG TERM
02:02:34.280 --> 02:02:35.147
FEASIBILITY OF THESE
02:02:35.214 --> 02:02:36.916
DEVELOPMENTS. TO PROTECT AGAINST
02:02:36.982 --> 02:02:38.818
FUTURE DISPLACEMENT OF TENANTS.
02:02:38.884 --> 02:02:40.686
THE BILL SUPPORTS THE PROVISION
02:02:40.753 --> 02:02:42.421
OF MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING WITH
02:02:42.488 --> 02:02:43.089
APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS TO ENSURE
02:02:43.155 --> 02:02:43.823
THAT TENANTS NOT JUST THE
02:02:43.889 --> 02:02:44.990
PROGRAM ADMINISTRATORS RECEIVE
02:02:45.057 --> 02:02:46.425
ADEQUATE BENEFIT. THANK YOU VERY
02:02:46.492 --> 02:02:53.399
MUCH. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:02:53.466 --> 02:02:55.468
MEMBERS. LARRY FLOREN ON THE CEO
02:02:55.534 --> 02:02:57.069
OF BURBANK HOUSING WHERE A
02:02:57.136 --> 02:02:58.037
NONPROFIT AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:02:58.104 --> 02:02:59.538
DEVELOPMENT COMPANY BASED IN
02:02:59.605 --> 02:03:00.606
SANTA ROSA, CALIFORNIA, WE'VE
02:03:00.673 --> 02:03:02.908
BEEN AROUND SINCE THE 1919 80 WE
02:03:02.975 --> 02:03:05.745
BUILT OVER 5000 HOMES. WE ARE IN
02:03:05.811 --> 02:03:07.179
INTEGRAL PART OF THE NORTH
02:03:07.246 --> 02:03:08.314
BERWICK COMMUNITY AND WE WERE
02:03:08.380 --> 02:03:09.782
ASKED BY A NUMBER OF LOCAL
02:03:09.849 --> 02:03:11.183
JURISDICTIONS THAT WERE BEING
02:03:11.250 --> 02:03:13.919
PRESENTED WITH PROPOSALS FOR
02:03:13.986 --> 02:03:15.488
SELLING JOINT POWERS AUTHORITY
02:03:15.554 --> 02:03:16.822
BONDS ON BEHALF OF PRIVATE
02:03:16.889 --> 02:03:19.158
DEVELOPERS. BROKERS FINANCING
02:03:19.225 --> 02:03:20.693
COMPANIES TO ACQUIRE EXISTING
02:03:20.760 --> 02:03:22.795
COMPANY TO EXISTING PROPERTIES
02:03:22.862 --> 02:03:24.563
TO LOOK INTO THE WHAT WAS BEING
02:03:24.630 --> 02:03:27.233
PRESENTED TO THEM. MANY OF THE
02:03:27.299 --> 02:03:28.000
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS JUST DIDN'T
02:03:28.067 --> 02:03:29.568
HAVE THE LEVEL OF SOPHISTICATION
02:03:29.635 --> 02:03:31.137
TO BE ABLE TO EVALUATE WHAT THEY
02:03:31.203 --> 02:03:33.205
WERE BEING ASKED TO DO. UM WHAT
02:03:33.272 --> 02:03:34.673
WE FOUND WAS A LITTLE BIT
02:03:34.740 --> 02:03:35.641
APPALLING. WE FOUND OUT THAT
02:03:35.708 --> 02:03:38.511
THESE BONDS THE PROPERTIES THAT
02:03:38.577 --> 02:03:39.912
WERE BEING SOLD AS AFFORDABLE
02:03:39.979 --> 02:03:43.516
HOUSING WERE IN FACT, UM BEING
02:03:43.582 --> 02:03:45.217
OVER LIVERED THE PRICES THAT
02:03:45.284 --> 02:03:46.152
WERE BEING PAID TO ACQUIRE THEM
02:03:46.218 --> 02:03:48.420
AWAY ABOVE MARKET AND THAT THE
02:03:48.487 --> 02:03:49.688
FEES THAT WERE BEING COLLECTED
02:03:49.755 --> 02:03:52.057
BY THE BROKERS, DEVELOPERS AND
02:03:52.124 --> 02:03:54.226
FINANCING GROUPS WHO WAY OVER
02:03:54.293 --> 02:03:55.795
THE MARKET NORMS AND SO ON
02:03:55.861 --> 02:03:59.465
BEHALF OF THE UM CITY MANAGERS
02:03:59.532 --> 02:04:01.400
AND THE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. UM
02:04:01.467 --> 02:04:03.035
WE'VE WORKED TOGETHER TO PROPOSE
02:04:03.102 --> 02:04:04.637
A SERIES OF REGULATIONS THAT ARE
02:04:04.703 --> 02:04:06.305
REFLECTED IN THIS BUILDING. WANT
02:04:06.372 --> 02:04:08.073
TO THANK THE ASSEMBLYMAN FOR
02:04:08.140 --> 02:04:09.542
MOVING THIS BILL FORWARD? WE DO
02:04:09.608 --> 02:04:11.043
NOT BELIEVE AS A DEVELOPMENT
02:04:11.110 --> 02:04:12.578
COMPANY THAT THESE BILLS WILL
02:04:12.645 --> 02:04:14.146
PREVENT NEW DEVELOPMENT OR
02:04:14.213 --> 02:04:15.881
ACQUISITION FROM GOING FORWARD.
02:04:15.948 --> 02:04:18.083
IN FACT, WE ARE WORKING WITH TWO
02:04:18.150 --> 02:04:19.451
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS RIGHT NOW. TO
02:04:19.518 --> 02:04:21.720
ACQUIRE BUILDINGS BASED ON THESE
02:04:21.787 --> 02:04:23.622
NEW REGULATIONS, AND WHAT'S EVEN
02:04:23.689 --> 02:04:25.124
MORE EXCITING. WE'RE LOOKING TO
02:04:25.191 --> 02:04:26.826
TRY TO BREAK GROUND ON NEW
02:04:26.892 --> 02:04:29.028
WORKFORCE HOUSING USING THESE JP
02:04:29.094 --> 02:04:31.063
A BONDS WITH THE NEW REGULATIONS
02:04:31.130 --> 02:04:32.331
IN PLACE. WE BELIEVE THEY'RE
02:04:32.398 --> 02:04:33.732
REASONABLE AND THAT THEY WERE
02:04:33.799 --> 02:04:34.900
GOOD COMPROMISE AND WE URGE YOUR
02:04:34.967 --> 02:04:36.569
SUPPORT FR THEM. THANK YOU.
02:04:36.635 --> 02:04:38.037
LET'S SEE IF THERE'S ANY OTHER
02:04:38.103 --> 02:04:39.638
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF A B 18
02:04:39.705 --> 02:04:42.408
50 IN THE ROOM. IF SO, PLEASE
02:04:42.474 --> 02:04:44.310
COME UP TO THE MIC, AND IT'S A
02:04:44.376 --> 02:04:50.616
ME TOO, OKAY? A ROOM DEALS WITH
02:04:50.683 --> 02:04:51.584
THE NONPROFIT HOUSING
02:04:51.650 --> 02:04:52.218
ASSOCIATION, NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
02:04:52.284 --> 02:04:56.021
AND SUPPORT YOU KNOW WHAT WITH
02:04:56.088 --> 02:04:56.488
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
02:04:56.555 --> 02:04:57.556
CONSORTIUM. WE ARE SUPPORTIVE,
02:04:57.623 --> 02:04:59.258
AMENDED POSITION TO DEAL WITH
02:04:59.325 --> 02:05:02.061
THE B BOND ISSUE AND JUST TO
02:05:02.127 --> 02:05:03.696
ENSURE THAT IT IS ADMINISTERED
02:05:03.762 --> 02:05:05.331
BLE ON THE RENT CALCULATION
02:05:05.397 --> 02:05:09.635
PIECE. THINK THE SUPPORT. CHRIS
02:05:09.702 --> 02:05:11.570
MARTIN WITH HOUSE IN CALIFORNIA
02:05:11.637 --> 02:05:12.705
AND SUPPORT RIGHT ANYONE ELSE IN
02:05:12.771 --> 02:05:14.540
THE ROOM AND SUPPORT IF NOT
02:05:14.607 --> 02:05:16.108
MODERATOR, QUÊ UP ANY ON THE
02:05:16.175 --> 02:05:18.143
PHONE LINE IN SUPPORT OF ABBY 18
02:05:18.210 --> 02:05:22.181
50. TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT. PRESS
02:05:22.248 --> 02:05:25.584
ONE, THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE
02:05:25.651 --> 02:05:27.653
HAVE A LINE QUEUED UP MINE. 3 15
02:05:27.720 --> 02:05:32.324
GO AHEAD, PLEASE. AUTHOR
02:05:32.391 --> 02:05:33.559
AMENDMENTS OUTLET TO THE
02:05:33.626 --> 02:05:34.026
ANALYSIS AND HAVE ONE
02:05:34.093 --> 02:05:35.628
OUTSTANDING. I AM LEFT TO WORK
02:05:35.694 --> 02:05:41.667
ONE. THANK YOU. LINE 3 42. THAT
02:05:41.734 --> 02:05:43.135
WAS ABOUT GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
02:05:43.202 --> 02:05:43.969
CHAIR. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE,
02:05:44.036 --> 02:05:46.205
PAUL GUNS, ALWAYS SOMEBODY HALF
02:05:46.272 --> 02:05:47.206
OF THE CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL
02:05:47.273 --> 02:05:49.141
FINANCE AUTHORITY. THERE YOU GO.
02:05:49.208 --> 02:05:51.477
SUPPORT PHONE WITH WORDS. LINE
02:05:51.543 --> 02:05:58.951
81. BEALL. LINE 81. YOUR LINE IS
02:05:59.018 --> 02:06:08.694
OPEN. DOING NOTHING WILL MOVE ON
02:06:08.761 --> 02:06:09.828
TO THE NEXT LINE. ONE MOMENT,
02:06:09.895 --> 02:06:11.563
PLEASE. WHILE WE PROVIDE THEIR
02:06:11.630 --> 02:06:15.534
LINE NUMBER LINE. 87 GO AHEAD,
02:06:15.601 --> 02:06:27.479
PLEASE. LINE 87. YOUR LINE IS
02:06:27.546 --> 02:06:34.420
OPEN. WE HAVE NO FURTHER LINES
02:06:34.486 --> 02:06:40.025
IN QUÊ. OF THE SPORT. YEAH OKAY
02:06:40.092 --> 02:06:43.662
. OKAY GREAT. WE WILL NOW GO TO
02:06:43.729 --> 02:06:46.632
OPPOSITION. DO WE HAVE OUR LEAD?
02:06:46.699 --> 02:06:47.666
LET'S ESTABLISH A CHOIR IN
02:06:47.733 --> 02:06:49.435
PERSON. FINALLY WE HAVE A
02:06:49.501 --> 02:06:53.339
QUORUM. OKAY UM, CAN YOU PLEASE
02:06:53.405 --> 02:06:55.908
CALL THE ROLL? SENATOR WIENER
02:06:55.975 --> 02:06:57.876
PRESENT PRESENT. BATES. BATES
02:06:57.943 --> 02:07:02.681
PRESENT ORTEZ E. ORTEZ PRESENT.
02:07:02.748 --> 02:07:07.052
CAMERO MCGUIRE PHùBUG RAF
02:07:07.119 --> 02:07:08.087
PRESENT SCANNER SCANNER PRESENT
02:07:08.153 --> 02:07:13.759
HAMBURG. OKAY, WE HAVE A QUORUM.
02:07:13.826 --> 02:07:15.527
OKAY WELL, NOW MOVE TO
02:07:15.594 --> 02:07:17.696
OPPOSITION. WE HAVE SEAN ROSSEN
02:07:17.763 --> 02:07:18.964
FROM WHATEVER PROPERTY COMPANY
02:07:19.031 --> 02:07:22.134
TESTIFYING IN OPPOSITION. GOOD
02:07:22.201 --> 02:07:23.602
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
02:07:23.669 --> 02:07:25.404
. THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME TODAY
02:07:25.471 --> 02:07:27.172
I'M SEAN ROSS AND THE CO FOUNDER
02:07:27.239 --> 02:07:28.574
OF WATERFORD PROPERTY COMPANY.
02:07:28.640 --> 02:07:30.209
WATERFORD IS A MISSION DRIVEN
02:07:30.275 --> 02:07:31.744
COMPANY THAT SPECIALIZES IN THE
02:07:31.810 --> 02:07:32.845
PRODUCTION OF MARKET RATE MIXED
02:07:32.911 --> 02:07:34.346
INCOME. AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN
02:07:34.413 --> 02:07:37.750
CALIFORNIA. I'M HERE TODAY TO
02:07:37.816 --> 02:07:40.052
STRONGLY OPPOSE A B 18 50 AS
02:07:40.119 --> 02:07:42.187
DRAFTED BECAUSE IT WILL CREATE A
02:07:42.254 --> 02:07:44.623
DEFACTO MORATORIUM OF THE J P. A
02:07:44.690 --> 02:07:45.457
ESSENTIAL HOUSING PROGRAM
02:07:45.524 --> 02:07:48.360
PROGRAM AT A TIME WHEN INFLATION
02:07:48.427 --> 02:07:49.194
AND HOUSING COSTS HAVE REACHED
02:07:49.261 --> 02:07:51.363
RECORD HIGHS. CALIFORNIA'S LOW
02:07:51.430 --> 02:07:52.598
INCOME AND MIDDLE INCOME
02:07:52.664 --> 02:07:53.532
FAMILIES ARE EXPECTED
02:07:53.599 --> 02:07:55.768
EXPERIENCING EXTREME LEVELS OF
02:07:55.834 --> 02:07:57.736
HOUSING INSECURITY. NEARLY TWO
02:07:57.803 --> 02:07:59.438
THIRDS OF THESE FAMILIES SPEND
02:07:59.505 --> 02:08:01.173
OVER 40% OF THEIR MONTHLY INCOME
02:08:01.240 --> 02:08:02.641
ON HOUSING, WHICH LEADS TO
02:08:02.708 --> 02:08:03.675
DEVASTATING EFFECTS, SUCH AS
02:08:03.742 --> 02:08:06.512
POOR STUDENT PERFORMANCE. MENTAL
02:08:06.578 --> 02:08:08.580
ANXIETY AND HEALTH PROBLEMS TO
02:08:08.647 --> 02:08:09.681
SOLVE CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING
02:08:09.748 --> 02:08:11.150
CRISIS. HOUSING LEADERS MUST
02:08:11.216 --> 02:08:12.718
COME TOGETHER IN A UNIFIED
02:08:12.785 --> 02:08:14.586
FASHION TO CREATE RESOURCES THAT
02:08:14.653 --> 02:08:15.587
WILL PRODUCE MORE AFFORDABLE
02:08:15.654 --> 02:08:18.057
HOUSING. AT ALL INCOME LEVELS.
02:08:18.123 --> 02:08:19.658
THIS IS NOT THE TIME TO PICK
02:08:19.725 --> 02:08:21.927
WINNERS AND LOSERS. BUT THAT IS
02:08:21.994 --> 02:08:24.063
EXACTLY WHAT A BEE 18 50 DOES.
02:08:24.129 --> 02:08:26.598
AS DRAFTED. A B 18 50 WILL
02:08:26.665 --> 02:08:27.933
ELIMINATE THE FINANCIAL
02:08:28.000 --> 02:08:30.269
FEASIBILITY OF JP A CENTRAL
02:08:30.335 --> 02:08:31.670
HOUSING PROJECTS AND TELL OUR
02:08:31.737 --> 02:08:32.805
STATE'S PUBLIC SAFETY EMPLOYEES
02:08:32.871 --> 02:08:35.674
, TEACHERS, CIVIL SERVANTS.
02:08:35.741 --> 02:08:37.543
NONPROFIT EMPLOYEES AND MEMBERS
02:08:37.609 --> 02:08:39.812
OF LABEL LABOR THAT THEY ARE NOT
02:08:39.878 --> 02:08:41.680
A PRIORITY. YESTERDAY'S L A
02:08:41.747 --> 02:08:43.182
TIMES HAD AN ARTICLE TITLED
02:08:43.248 --> 02:08:45.284
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA
02:08:45.350 --> 02:08:47.453
NOW ROUTINELY TOPS $1 MILLION
02:08:47.519 --> 02:08:49.855
PER PER UNIT TO BUILD. THE
02:08:49.922 --> 02:08:52.024
ARTICLE DISCUSSED THAT IS NOW
02:08:52.091 --> 02:08:53.659
COMMON FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:08:53.725 --> 02:08:55.561
PROJECTS TO COST NEARLY $1
02:08:55.627 --> 02:08:58.230
MILLION PER UNIT, 14% OF WHICH
02:08:58.297 --> 02:08:59.531
GOES TOWARDS HOUSING CONSULTANT
02:08:59.598 --> 02:09:00.666
FEES AND SOFT COSTS AND CAN
02:09:00.732 --> 02:09:03.669
OFTEN TAKE FOUR YEARS TO BUILD.
02:09:03.735 --> 02:09:05.771
YET IN TWO YEARS THE JPS CENTRAL
02:09:05.838 --> 02:09:08.040
HOUSING PROGRAM HAS CREATED OVER
02:09:08.107 --> 02:09:11.043
14,000 UNITS AT A COST AVERAGING
02:09:11.110 --> 02:09:15.581
575,000 PER UNIT, 10% WHICH GOES
02:09:15.647 --> 02:09:16.648
TO CONSULTANTS AND SOFT CARS,
02:09:16.715 --> 02:09:17.950
WHICH IS LESS THAN TRADITIONAL,
02:09:18.016 --> 02:09:20.152
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECTS. AN
02:09:20.219 --> 02:09:21.920
ADDITIONAL. IN ADDITION, CENTRAL
02:09:21.987 --> 02:09:24.089
HOUSING PROJECTS DO NOT COMPETE
02:09:24.156 --> 02:09:25.591
FOR TAX CREDITS OR OTHER
02:09:25.657 --> 02:09:27.359
FINANCING SOURCES USED TO CREATE
02:09:27.426 --> 02:09:28.827
COMMUNITIES FOR LOW INCOME
02:09:28.894 --> 02:09:31.063
FAMILIES THAT JP A CENTRAL
02:09:31.130 --> 02:09:32.498
HOUSING PROGRAM HAS ATTRACTED
02:09:32.564 --> 02:09:34.700
OVER $8 BILLION OF ADDITIONAL
02:09:34.766 --> 02:09:36.135
INVESTMENT TO CALIFORNIA'S
02:09:36.201 --> 02:09:37.736
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS FOR
02:09:37.803 --> 02:09:39.404
MUNICIPAL BOND INVESTORS THAT
02:09:39.471 --> 02:09:40.739
PREVIOUSLY HAD NOT INVESTED IN
02:09:40.806 --> 02:09:43.308
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN OUR STATE.
02:09:43.375 --> 02:09:45.811
THE LEGISLATURE PASSES A B 18 50
02:09:45.878 --> 02:09:47.513
AS DRAFTED AND ENACTS AN
02:09:47.579 --> 02:09:49.281
ESSENTIAL HOUSING MORATORIUM. IT
02:09:49.348 --> 02:09:50.682
IS LIKELY THAT THESE INVESTORS
02:09:50.749 --> 02:09:51.817
WILL INVEST IN AFFORDABLE
02:09:51.884 --> 02:09:52.651
HOUSING IN OTHER STATES INSTEAD
02:09:52.718 --> 02:09:56.421
OF CALIFORNIA. THIS WOULD BE A
02:09:56.488 --> 02:09:57.556
TRAVESTY TO HIGHLIGHT THE
02:09:57.623 --> 02:09:59.224
SUCCESS OF THE PROGRAM AND LIKE
02:09:59.291 --> 02:10:00.859
TO PROVIDE DETAILS OF OUR
02:10:00.926 --> 02:10:02.294
HOUSING PORTFOLIO SINCE STARTING
02:10:02.361 --> 02:10:05.164
IN THE PROGRAM IN 2021 SINCE 20
02:10:05.230 --> 02:10:06.999
JANUARY, 2021 WE HAVE ACQUIRED
02:10:07.065 --> 02:10:09.735
4014 MARKET RATE UNITS AND
02:10:09.801 --> 02:10:10.869
CONVERTED THEM TO INCOME
02:10:10.936 --> 02:10:11.837
RESTRICTED ESSENTIAL HOUSING
02:10:11.904 --> 02:10:14.239
UNITS. THE WEIGHTED AVERAGE
02:10:14.306 --> 02:10:15.407
RENTAL DISCOUNT ACROSS THE
02:10:15.474 --> 02:10:18.610
PORTFOLIO IS 24% AND THE AVERAGE
02:10:18.677 --> 02:10:21.813
HOUSEHOLD SAVINGS IS 8800 PER
02:10:21.880 --> 02:10:23.482
YEAR. CRITICS OF THE ESSENTIAL
02:10:23.549 --> 02:10:25.050
HOUSING PROGRAM LIKE TO SAY THAT
02:10:25.117 --> 02:10:26.985
PUBLIC BENEFITS OF THE PROGRAM
02:10:27.052 --> 02:10:28.253
OR YET TO BE DETERMINED MY
02:10:28.320 --> 02:10:30.556
RESPONSE TO THIS IS TO SPEAK TO
02:10:30.622 --> 02:10:32.724
THE 7000 TENANTS LIVING IN OUR
02:10:32.791 --> 02:10:34.893
COMMUNITIES. AS DRAFTED A B 18
02:10:34.960 --> 02:10:37.496
50 WOULD PREVENT ALL OF THE
02:10:37.563 --> 02:10:39.398
PROJECTS THAT WE ACQUIRED IN THE
02:10:39.464 --> 02:10:40.566
PROGRAM SO FAR IN PROVIDING
02:10:40.632 --> 02:10:42.801
MEANINGFUL RENTAL DISCOUNTS TO
02:10:42.868 --> 02:10:44.236
SHOW THEIR SUPPORT FOR ESSENTIAL
02:10:44.303 --> 02:10:46.271
HOUSING. OUR TENANTS STARTED A
02:10:46.338 --> 02:10:48.240
TENANT GROUP CALLED CALIFORNIANS
02:10:48.307 --> 02:10:49.241
FOR ESSENTIAL HOUSING, SEE A DOT
02:10:49.308 --> 02:10:52.711
FOR ESSENTIAL HOUSING .COM. THIS
02:10:52.778 --> 02:10:53.845
WEEK ALONE, NEARLY 600
02:10:53.912 --> 02:10:56.081
INDIVIDUALS SIGN UP PETITION. I
02:10:56.148 --> 02:10:58.083
WISH I HAD MORE TIME TO DISCUSS
02:10:58.150 --> 02:10:58.684
THE INDIVIDUAL STORIES OF OUR
02:10:58.750 --> 02:10:59.952
TENANTS, AND NOW THE ESSENTIAL
02:11:00.018 --> 02:11:01.153
HOUSING IS PROGRAM HAS IMPACTED
02:11:01.220 --> 02:11:02.788
THEM. BUT I BELIEVE SOME MAY
02:11:02.854 --> 02:11:04.623
SPEAK DURING PUBLIC COMMENTS.
02:11:04.690 --> 02:11:06.325
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:11:06.391 --> 02:11:07.326
SPEAK TODAY. AND MORE THAN HAPPY
02:11:07.392 --> 02:11:08.794
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU
02:11:08.860 --> 02:11:11.029
MAY HAVE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:11:11.096 --> 02:11:12.798
IS THERE ANY OTHER OPPOSITION
02:11:12.864 --> 02:11:14.132
TESTIMONY HERE ON THE CHAIRMAN
02:11:14.199 --> 02:11:15.534
MEMBERS? DUNCAN MCF ENTRIES
02:11:15.601 --> 02:11:17.135
REPRESENTING CATALYST HOUSING,
02:11:17.202 --> 02:11:19.304
REGRETTABLY IN OPPOSITION TO THE
02:11:19.371 --> 02:11:21.807
BILL, AND SEAN SAID IF
02:11:21.873 --> 02:11:23.175
PROVISIONS OF THIS BILL MOVE
02:11:23.242 --> 02:11:25.611
FORWARD, YOU WILL NOT BE ABLE TO
02:11:25.677 --> 02:11:27.112
SEE THESE PROJECTS BE
02:11:27.179 --> 02:11:29.348
UNDERWRITTEN OR GET A CLEAN BAND
02:11:29.414 --> 02:11:30.482
COUNCIL OPINION. UM, FOR THOSE
02:11:30.549 --> 02:11:34.219
REASONS WE OPPOSE THANK YOU.
02:11:34.286 --> 02:11:35.053
ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION, PLEASE.
02:11:35.120 --> 02:11:35.887
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR
02:11:35.954 --> 02:11:39.157
AFFILIATION. ENBERG MADISON WITH
02:11:39.224 --> 02:11:40.125
THE CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
02:11:40.192 --> 02:11:42.728
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION. ANY
02:11:42.794 --> 02:11:43.695
ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION TESTIMONY
02:11:43.762 --> 02:11:46.965
IN THE HEARING ROOM. SAYING THAT
02:11:47.032 --> 02:11:49.401
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES WITH
02:11:49.468 --> 02:11:50.469
THE MODERATOR. PLEASE OPEN THE
02:11:50.535 --> 02:11:53.171
PHONE LINES FOR OPPOSITION. TO
02:11:53.238 --> 02:11:54.840
SPEAKING UP POSITION BREAST ONE
02:11:54.906 --> 02:11:57.743
THAN ZERO AT THIS TIME. WE'LL GO
02:11:57.809 --> 02:11:59.745
FIRST TO LINE 1 19 GO AHEAD,
02:11:59.811 --> 02:12:04.116
PLEASE. ONE MOMENT, PLEASE.
02:12:04.182 --> 02:12:05.617
THEY'RE TAKING THEMSELVES OUT OF
02:12:05.684 --> 02:12:09.454
Q WILL GO TO LINE 87 GO AHEAD.
02:12:09.521 --> 02:12:11.423
HI MY NAME IS MARGARITA ROCHA
02:12:11.490 --> 02:12:15.961
AND I AM IN SUPPORT OF A B 1850.
02:12:16.028 --> 02:12:21.333
LINE 3 27. HELLO MY NAME IS
02:12:21.400 --> 02:12:22.367
ARMANDO SANCHEZ. I'M THE
02:12:22.434 --> 02:12:23.602
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
02:12:23.669 --> 02:12:24.836
HOUSING ENDOWMENT AND REGIONAL
02:12:24.903 --> 02:12:26.471
TRUST OF SAN MATEO COUNTY.
02:12:26.538 --> 02:12:27.906
OTHERWISE KNOWN AS HARD WE ARE
02:12:27.973 --> 02:12:30.542
BOTH A J P A VIPER, ONE C THREE
02:12:30.609 --> 02:12:32.544
NONPROFIT AGENCY. WE OPPOSE THIS
02:12:32.611 --> 02:12:33.945
BILL UNLESS AMENDED TO ALLOW
02:12:34.012 --> 02:12:36.114
HARD TO IMPLEMENT MORE EFFECTIVE
02:12:36.181 --> 02:12:36.715
GUIDELINES AND THOSE THAT ARE
02:12:36.782 --> 02:12:38.817
BEING PROPOSED IN THE BILL. THAT
02:12:38.884 --> 02:12:40.085
WOULD BE MORE THAN HAPPY TO
02:12:40.152 --> 02:12:41.219
SHARE MORE INFORMATION, BUT I
02:12:41.286 --> 02:12:43.422
REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR TIME.
02:12:43.488 --> 02:12:48.860
LINE 3 38. MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS,
02:12:48.927 --> 02:12:50.062
ALEX TORRES WITH THE BARRIER
02:12:50.128 --> 02:12:51.897
COUNCIL, REGRETTABLY OPPOSED AT
02:12:51.963 --> 02:12:53.131
THIS POINT IN TIME, A LINER
02:12:53.198 --> 02:12:54.266
COMMENTS WITH CATALYST. THANK
02:12:54.333 --> 02:13:01.073
YOU. LINE 3 25. HI. MY NAME IS
02:13:01.139 --> 02:13:02.607
RACHEL MANNER AND I AM A
02:13:02.674 --> 02:13:04.643
RESIDENT IN ROWAN APARTMENTS AND
02:13:04.710 --> 02:13:06.511
ESCONDIDO, CALIFORNIA AND I'M
02:13:06.578 --> 02:13:08.547
OPPOSED TO 18 50 BECAUSE OF
02:13:08.613 --> 02:13:11.083
THIS, UM THIS HOUSING ALLOWANCE
02:13:11.149 --> 02:13:12.417
. I WAS ABLE TO FINALLY AFFORD
02:13:12.484 --> 02:13:14.419
SOMEWHERE TO LIVE THAT WAS
02:13:14.486 --> 02:13:16.588
ACTUALLY SAFE. WHERE IT BROUGHT
02:13:16.655 --> 02:13:17.923
DOWN THE WRENCH JUST ENOUGH TO
02:13:17.989 --> 02:13:19.324
WHERE I COULD STILL GO GROCERY
02:13:19.391 --> 02:13:21.493
SHOPPING AND TAKE CARE OF MY
02:13:21.560 --> 02:13:22.661
LIFE. SO WITHOUT IT, I DON'T
02:13:22.728 --> 02:13:24.629
KNOW WHERE I WOULD BE RIGHT NOW.
02:13:24.696 --> 02:13:31.136
LINE 1 87. HELLO MY NAME IS THE
02:13:31.203 --> 02:13:31.770
LAUNDRY. GONZALEZ AND I LIVE AT
02:13:31.837 --> 02:13:32.971
THE PARALLEL, COMPLEX INTERNET
02:13:33.038 --> 02:13:34.806
HYPE. I HAVE BENEFITED FROM THE
02:13:34.873 --> 02:13:36.108
CENTRAL HOUSING PROGRAM IN THE
02:13:36.174 --> 02:13:37.909
FOLLOWING WAYS AS A STUDENT IN A
02:13:37.976 --> 02:13:38.777
MASTER'S PROGRAM PURSUING A
02:13:38.844 --> 02:13:40.112
CAREER AND HEALTHCARE. ONLY
02:13:40.178 --> 02:13:41.179
MYSELF IS ABLE TO FINANCIALLY
02:13:41.246 --> 02:13:43.281
SUPPORT US. AS WE SAW WITH THE
02:13:43.348 --> 02:13:44.316
COVID CRISIS, HEALTH CARE
02:13:44.383 --> 02:13:45.650
PRACTITIONERS ARE ESSENTIAL TO
02:13:45.717 --> 02:13:47.319
THE WELL BEING OF SOCIETY,
02:13:47.386 --> 02:13:48.820
THEREFORE, BEING ABLE TO GO TO
02:13:48.887 --> 02:13:49.654
SCHOOL FULL TIME AND AFFORD
02:13:49.721 --> 02:13:50.856
HOUSING NEAR MY SCHOOL HAS
02:13:50.922 --> 02:13:52.591
ALLOWED ME TO FOCUS ON MY
02:13:52.657 --> 02:13:53.725
STUDIES AND TO HOPEFULLY THEIR
02:13:53.792 --> 02:13:55.060
SERVICE THAT PEOPLE IN THE NEW
02:13:55.127 --> 02:13:56.728
YORK FUTURE IN THIS TIMES
02:13:56.795 --> 02:13:57.863
EXTREME ECONOMIC OUR KIDS DO TO
02:13:57.929 --> 02:13:59.664
THE RAMPANT INFLATION. MODERATOR
02:13:59.731 --> 02:14:01.199
MODERATOR, THIS IS ME TO ONLY
02:14:01.266 --> 02:14:03.235
EXCUSE ME. THIS IS ME TO ONLY
02:14:03.301 --> 02:14:04.369
WE'VE ALREADY HEARD FROM THE
02:14:04.436 --> 02:14:06.671
PRIMARY. WITNESSES MR MODERATE.
02:14:06.738 --> 02:14:08.173
IF PEOPLE ARE GOING ON, WE
02:14:08.240 --> 02:14:10.108
SHOULD MOVE ON TO THE NEXT ONE.
02:14:10.175 --> 02:14:16.615
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, LION 3 42.
02:14:16.681 --> 02:14:17.916
GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR MEMBERS
02:14:17.983 --> 02:14:18.817
OF THE COMMITTEE, PAULSON'S
02:14:18.884 --> 02:14:20.852
OFFICE ON BEHALF OF THE
02:14:20.919 --> 02:14:21.420
CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL FINANCE
02:14:21.486 --> 02:14:23.355
ASSOCIATION IN OPPOSITION. LINE
02:14:23.422 --> 02:14:28.960
1 44. HI. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
02:14:29.027 --> 02:14:30.529
NAME IS CHRISTINA MARIE AND I
02:14:30.595 --> 02:14:32.164
LIVE AT THE PARALLEL APARTMENTS
02:14:32.230 --> 02:14:33.198
IN ANAHEIM AND I HAVE BENEFITED
02:14:33.265 --> 02:14:34.599
FROM THE CENTRAL HOUSING PROGRAM
02:14:34.666 --> 02:14:36.668
TO ONLY YES OR NO. ARE YOU IN
02:14:36.735 --> 02:14:39.604
SUPPORT OR OPPOSE? OPPOSED
02:14:39.671 --> 02:14:40.472
MODERATOR NEXT. THANK YOU,
02:14:40.539 --> 02:14:49.080
MODERATOR. BUYING 81. BY NATIVE
02:14:49.147 --> 02:14:59.191
ONE YEAR LINE IS OPEN. I LIVE AT
02:14:59.257 --> 02:15:01.159
THE ALCOHOL OF COMMUNITY IN THE
02:15:01.226 --> 02:15:03.395
CITY. I HAVE BENEFITED. EXCUSE
02:15:03.462 --> 02:15:05.397
ME, PLEASE. JUST OPPOSITION OR
02:15:05.464 --> 02:15:07.098
SUPPORT MODERATOR NEXT I OPPOSE.
02:15:07.165 --> 02:15:15.807
OKAY. NEXT. LINE 1 19. MY NAME
02:15:15.874 --> 02:15:17.275
IS CHERYL ROBINSON. I LIVED AT
02:15:17.342 --> 02:15:19.377
THE WESTGATE APARTMENTS IN THE
02:15:19.444 --> 02:15:21.379
CITY OF PASADENA. AND I OPPOSE
02:15:21.446 --> 02:15:28.487
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 1 31.
02:15:28.553 --> 02:15:30.088
HELLO. MY NAME IS TREASURIES.
02:15:30.155 --> 02:15:31.523
ARTS IN ENGLISH TEACHER FROM
02:15:31.590 --> 02:15:33.692
LONG BEACH,CALIFORNIA I URGE
02:15:33.758 --> 02:15:35.827
YOU TO OPPOSE A B 18 50 AS
02:15:35.894 --> 02:15:38.163
DRAFTED. THANK YOU SO MUCH. LINE
02:15:38.230 --> 02:15:46.905
3 24. IS THAT ME? YES. GO AHEAD.
02:15:46.972 --> 02:15:48.573
ESTABLISHED GIVEN A NUMBER.
02:15:48.640 --> 02:15:49.941
SORRY ABOUT THAT. MY NAME IS
02:15:50.008 --> 02:15:51.142
ELIZABETH HENRY FROM LAFAYETTE,
02:15:51.209 --> 02:15:56.515
CALIFORNIA. UM I OPPOSED 18. A
02:15:56.581 --> 02:16:01.753
18 50 AS AS UM, UNLESS AMENDED.
02:16:01.820 --> 02:16:07.726
LINE 3 29. HI. THIS IS A PROUD
02:16:07.792 --> 02:16:08.627
GREG'S PARTNER OPPORTUNITY
02:16:08.693 --> 02:16:11.429
HOUSING GROUP. I WILL STRONGLY
02:16:11.496 --> 02:16:13.431
SAID THAT WE WANT TO POSE A B 18
02:16:13.498 --> 02:16:20.839
50. LINE 3 30. TIME MY NAME IS
02:16:20.906 --> 02:16:22.774
CHARLES ROBINSON, RESIDENT AT
02:16:22.841 --> 02:16:24.309
WESTGATE APARTMENTS IN PASADENA
02:16:24.376 --> 02:16:29.114
. I OPPOSE 18 50. THERE ARE NO
02:16:29.180 --> 02:16:31.216
FURTHER LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME.
02:16:31.283 --> 02:16:32.751
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL BRING
02:16:32.817 --> 02:16:35.787
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:16:35.854 --> 02:16:36.755
COLLEAGUES. ARE THERE ANY
02:16:36.821 --> 02:16:38.256
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FOR THE
02:16:38.323 --> 02:16:40.892
AUTHOR? SENATOR COURTESY JUST A
02:16:40.959 --> 02:16:44.396
QUESTION FOR THE AUTHOR. IF HE'S
02:16:44.462 --> 02:16:47.232
WILLING TO ANSWER, JUST, UM,
02:16:47.299 --> 02:16:48.700
INTERESTED IN HEARING MORE OF A
02:16:48.767 --> 02:16:51.770
RESPONSE IF YOU HAVE ONE TO THE
02:16:51.836 --> 02:16:52.871
OPPOSITION, PARTICULARLY I WAS
02:16:52.938 --> 02:16:54.005
LISTENING CLOSELY, PARTICULARLY
02:16:54.072 --> 02:16:57.676
THOSE WHO ARE ASKING FOR
02:16:57.742 --> 02:16:58.843
AMENDMENTS. I DON'T KNOW WHAT
02:16:58.910 --> 02:17:00.712
THAT NEGOTIATIONS LOOKED LIKE,
02:17:00.779 --> 02:17:02.047
OR HOW MUCH HAS GONE BACK TO
02:17:02.113 --> 02:17:04.182
FORTH BACK AND FORTH IF AT ALL.
02:17:04.249 --> 02:17:06.918
I DID HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY. BUT
02:17:06.985 --> 02:17:10.322
YOU KNOW, TO HEAR FROM, FOLKS UM
02:17:10.388 --> 02:17:12.557
A FEW WEEKS BACK REGARDING THE
02:17:12.624 --> 02:17:14.593
BILL, I DO HAVE CONCERNS. UM,
02:17:14.659 --> 02:17:18.163
MAYBE A LITTLE BIT. SKEWED
02:17:18.229 --> 02:17:21.166
BECAUSE OF YOU KNOW MY PAST
02:17:21.232 --> 02:17:22.734
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE AND ON
02:17:22.801 --> 02:17:24.703
THE BUILDING SIDE WITH, YOU
02:17:24.769 --> 02:17:25.837
KNOW, KILLING THE MODEL OR
02:17:25.904 --> 02:17:26.938
HURTING THE MODEL, WHICH IS
02:17:27.005 --> 02:17:30.008
ESSENTIALLY YOU KNOW THE
02:17:30.075 --> 02:17:31.242
OPPOSITION ALLEGATION IN TERMS
02:17:31.309 --> 02:17:33.812
WE JUST HEARD INTERMS OF WHAT
02:17:33.878 --> 02:17:34.779
WOULD HAPPEN WITHOUT AMENDMENTS.
02:17:34.846 --> 02:17:36.548
BUT I DON'T KNOW HOW REALLY
02:17:36.615 --> 02:17:39.484
INQUIRY INTO VIEW IS TOO. UM HOW
02:17:39.551 --> 02:17:41.286
MUCH SPACE YOU HAVE LEFT TO WORK
02:17:41.353 --> 02:17:44.923
WITH THEM TO TRY TO COME TO
02:17:44.990 --> 02:17:46.057
PERHAPS A BETTER OUTCOME, YOU
02:17:46.124 --> 02:17:48.593
KNOW, FROM THEIR PERSPECTIVE.
02:17:48.660 --> 02:17:50.128
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION,
02:17:50.195 --> 02:17:51.663
SENATOR. I REALLY APPRECIATE THE
02:17:51.730 --> 02:17:52.998
COMMITTEE'S ANALYSIS, AND I
02:17:53.064 --> 02:17:53.965
NEGLECTED TO MENTION IN MY
02:17:54.032 --> 02:17:55.967
OPENING. DRAW YOUR ATTENTION TO
02:17:56.034 --> 02:17:57.569
PAGE EIGHT. THERE ARE A SERIES
02:17:57.636 --> 02:17:58.970
OF ABOUT 14 AMENDMENTS THAT WILL
02:17:59.037 --> 02:17:59.471
PROVIDE SOME TECHNICAL
02:17:59.537 --> 02:18:01.106
IMPROVEMENTS THAT WILL REALLY
02:18:01.172 --> 02:18:03.608
MEET A LOT OF THE ISSUES THAT
02:18:03.675 --> 02:18:04.743
HAVE BEEN RAISED. THESE HAVE
02:18:04.809 --> 02:18:06.311
BEEN DONE IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
02:18:06.378 --> 02:18:09.848
OUR MEAN CO SPONSORS, AS WELL AS
02:18:09.914 --> 02:18:11.216
THE TURNER CENTER AND OTHERS
02:18:11.282 --> 02:18:13.351
STAKEHOLDERS AS WELL. THOSE
02:18:13.418 --> 02:18:15.854
ADDRESS, UH, A GOOD NUMBER OF
02:18:15.920 --> 02:18:17.222
THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS THAT
02:18:17.288 --> 02:18:18.189
WILL RESOLVE ISSUES, INCLUDING
02:18:18.256 --> 02:18:19.758
ADDRESSING SOME OF THE ISSUES
02:18:19.824 --> 02:18:22.360
AROUND BEBAN CAPS. THAT WAS, UM
02:18:22.427 --> 02:18:24.929
BROUGHT UP BY ONE OF OUR TEST IF
02:18:24.996 --> 02:18:26.197
IRS IN THE SUPPORT OF AMENDED
02:18:26.264 --> 02:18:28.733
POSITION WE HAVE RECEIVED A SET
02:18:28.800 --> 02:18:30.702
OF REQUESTED AMENDMENTS FROM I
02:18:30.769 --> 02:18:32.270
THINK WATERFORD WAS THE SOURCE,
02:18:32.337 --> 02:18:33.238
AND I APPRECIATE THEIR
02:18:33.304 --> 02:18:34.739
THOUGHTFULNESS AND THERE AS WELL
02:18:34.806 --> 02:18:39.210
HAPPY TO SAY THAT A NUMBER OF
02:18:39.277 --> 02:18:39.778
THESE WERE ALREADY ADDRESSED
02:18:39.844 --> 02:18:40.645
THROUGH THE PROPOSED STRUCTURE
02:18:40.712 --> 02:18:41.813
OF AMENDMENTS THAT WE INTEND TO
02:18:41.880 --> 02:18:43.715
TAKE BEFORE, IF AND BEFORE THIS
02:18:43.782 --> 02:18:46.284
BILL REACHED THE NEXT COMMITTEE,
02:18:46.351 --> 02:18:47.952
HOWEVER, THERE ARE A FEW THAT WE
02:18:48.019 --> 02:18:49.621
THINK ARE JUST GOING TO
02:18:49.688 --> 02:18:50.188
FUNDAMENTALLY BE BAD PUBLIC
02:18:50.255 --> 02:18:51.823
POLICY. WE'RE NOT GOING TO BE
02:18:51.890 --> 02:18:52.991
ABLE TO TAKE AN AMENDMENT THAT'S
02:18:53.058 --> 02:18:54.759
GOING TO REMOVE A REQUIREMENT
02:18:54.826 --> 02:18:55.794
FOR AFFORDABILITY. THAT'S THE
02:18:55.860 --> 02:18:56.961
WHOLE POINT OF THIS THAT THERE'S
02:18:57.028 --> 02:18:57.962
GOING TO BE NO TENANT
02:18:58.029 --> 02:18:58.963
PROTECTIONS. THAT'S THE WHOLE
02:18:59.030 --> 02:19:00.932
POINT OF THIS THAT THERE ARE NO
02:19:00.999 --> 02:19:01.966
CAPS ON GPA OR PROJECT
02:19:02.033 --> 02:19:03.435
ADMINISTRATOR COMPENSATION
02:19:03.501 --> 02:19:04.102
AGAIN. THAT'S THE WHOLE POINT OF
02:19:04.169 --> 02:19:06.805
THIS. SO WE BELIEVE WITH PLENTY
02:19:06.871 --> 02:19:07.806
OF OTHER, UH INDIVIDUALS WITH
02:19:07.872 --> 02:19:11.276
DEVELOPMENT EXPERTISE. THESE
02:19:11.342 --> 02:19:12.377
AMENDMENTS ARE WORKABLE. THESE
02:19:12.444 --> 02:19:13.745
PROJECTS CAN MOVE FORWARD BUT
02:19:13.812 --> 02:19:15.747
WILL FULFILL THE GUARDRAILS THE
02:19:15.814 --> 02:19:17.916
INTENT OF THIS BILL SO THAT
02:19:17.982 --> 02:19:19.384
CITIES PARTICULARLY ARE SMALLER
02:19:19.451 --> 02:19:20.919
CITIES ACROSS CALIFORNIA OR
02:19:20.985 --> 02:19:22.587
GETTING A FAIR DEAL FOR THOSE
02:19:22.654 --> 02:19:23.888
CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS THAT DECIDE
02:19:23.955 --> 02:19:25.056
TO APPROVE A PROJECT AND ENTER
02:19:25.123 --> 02:19:29.294
INTO A J P A. THANK YOU THROUGH
02:19:29.360 --> 02:19:32.664
THE CHAIR. LET ME JUST SAY, UM
02:19:32.731 --> 02:19:34.632
I'LL DO A BETTER REVIEW OF THIS
02:19:34.699 --> 02:19:36.901
SECTION REFERRED TO AS FUTURE
02:19:36.968 --> 02:19:38.036
AUTHOR AMENDMENTS APPRECIATE
02:19:38.103 --> 02:19:41.573
THAT. AND I WOULD ENCOURAGE
02:19:41.639 --> 02:19:43.942
CONTINUED WORKING WITH THE
02:19:44.008 --> 02:19:45.777
OPPOSITION. UM AGAIN, IT'S MY
02:19:45.844 --> 02:19:48.947
MIND IS MORE FIXATED ON
02:19:49.013 --> 02:19:50.982
PRODUCTION RIGHT NOW AND ALL THE
02:19:51.049 --> 02:19:52.817
WORK WE'RE TRYING TO DO TO MAKE
02:19:52.884 --> 02:19:54.419
SURE WE DON'T UPSET THE APPLE
02:19:54.486 --> 02:19:55.954
CART IN THAT REGARD, SO I WOULD
02:19:56.020 --> 02:19:58.389
RESERVE THE RIGHT TO STAY OFF.
02:19:58.456 --> 02:19:59.557
BUT I'LL BE SUPPORTIVE TODAY TO
02:19:59.624 --> 02:20:00.925
GET IT OUT OF COMMITTEE SO YOU
02:20:00.992 --> 02:20:02.494
CAN KEEP WORKING ON IT. IF
02:20:02.560 --> 02:20:04.562
INDEED MY VOTE HELPS IN THAT
02:20:04.629 --> 02:20:06.164
REGARD. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
02:20:06.231 --> 02:20:07.232
OKAY, ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR
02:20:07.298 --> 02:20:10.135
COMMENTS? OKAY SAYING THAT, UM
02:20:10.201 --> 02:20:12.070
SO SOME OF OUR FIRST VOTE SINCE
02:20:12.137 --> 02:20:14.005
I WAS NOT HERE AT THE VERY
02:20:14.072 --> 02:20:15.140
BEGINNING, AND YOU INDICATED AND
02:20:15.206 --> 02:20:17.776
AMENDMENTS AND COMMENT. 10
02:20:17.842 --> 02:20:19.344
YOU'LL BE TAKING THE NEXT
02:20:19.411 --> 02:20:19.978
COMMITTEE AS AUTHOR AMENDMENT
02:20:20.044 --> 02:20:23.848
COMMITTEE. YES. GREAT I WANT TO
02:20:23.915 --> 02:20:26.184
THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK ON THIS
02:20:26.251 --> 02:20:27.952
BILL. THIS I KNOW THIS IS A SORT
02:20:28.019 --> 02:20:30.121
OF AUTHORITY ONE AND I KNOW THAT
02:20:30.188 --> 02:20:31.422
YOU AND YOUR SPONSORS HAVE BEEN
02:20:31.489 --> 02:20:33.258
WORKING. WITH THE OPPOSITION AND
02:20:33.324 --> 02:20:34.392
I WOULD JUST ENCOURAGE YOU TO
02:20:34.459 --> 02:20:35.660
CONTINUE TO I'LL WORK WITH HIM.
02:20:35.727 --> 02:20:38.429
I DO SUPPORT THIS BILL. AND WITH
02:20:38.496 --> 02:20:40.031
THAT, I WILL ENTERTAIN A MOTION
02:20:40.098 --> 02:20:42.734
WE CAN ACTUALLY DO EMOTION. AND
02:20:42.801 --> 02:20:44.035
YOU, AND THEN WE'LL LET YOU
02:20:44.102 --> 02:20:48.339
CLOSE. SO IS THERE A MOTION OKAY
02:20:48.406 --> 02:20:49.841
. MOTION BY SIMON SKINNER. YOU
02:20:49.908 --> 02:20:51.609
MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU. SENATORS
02:20:51.676 --> 02:20:53.077
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, HIGHLY
02:20:53.144 --> 02:20:53.878
TECHNICAL BILL, BUT I THINK VERY
02:20:53.945 --> 02:20:56.548
IMPORTANT TO BE ABLE TO ACHIEVE
02:20:56.614 --> 02:20:57.081
THE INTENSE THAT WE ARE
02:20:57.148 --> 02:20:57.649
PROMISING OUR MUTUAL
02:20:57.715 --> 02:20:59.551
CONSTITUENTS THAT WE'RE GOING TO
02:20:59.617 --> 02:21:01.386
DELIVER IN THE FORMS OF MIDDLE
02:21:01.452 --> 02:21:02.387
INCOME HOUSING. I RESPECTFULLY
02:21:02.453 --> 02:21:02.987
ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE. OKAY. WE
02:21:03.054 --> 02:21:04.756
HAVE MOTION BY SENATOR SKINNER
02:21:04.823 --> 02:21:07.692
AND WILL CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS
02:21:07.759 --> 02:21:09.627
IT, SONNY BILL 18 50 BY SOME
02:21:09.694 --> 02:21:11.196
MEMBER AWARD. THE MOTION IS DUE
02:21:11.262 --> 02:21:12.730
PAST BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
02:21:12.797 --> 02:21:13.932
THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT AND
02:21:13.998 --> 02:21:15.099
FINANCE. SENATOR WIENER WIENER.
02:21:15.166 --> 02:21:19.938
AYE, BATES.NÚMERO CORTEZ E.
02:21:20.004 --> 02:21:21.606
CORTESI AYE, MCGUIRE PATROL BUG
02:21:21.673 --> 02:21:25.410
ROTH ROUGH. I SKINNER SKINNER I
02:21:25.476 --> 02:21:29.614
HAMBURG. OKAY. I WILL PUT THAT
02:21:29.681 --> 02:21:34.319
BILL ON CALL. THANK YOU REMEMBER
02:21:34.385 --> 02:21:34.986
? THANK YOU, SENATOR. AND I ALSO
02:21:35.053 --> 02:21:37.455
WANTED TO THANK YOU AS WELL FOR
02:21:37.522 --> 02:21:38.790
PLACING 18 1978 ON CONSENT. I
02:21:38.857 --> 02:21:39.724
THINK THAT'S GOING TO BE VERY
02:21:39.791 --> 02:21:41.693
HELPFUL FOR HUD TO GET FUNDS
02:21:41.759 --> 02:21:42.794
DOWN TO LOCAL COMMUNITIES
02:21:42.861 --> 02:21:45.296
FASTER. FANTASTIC SO BEFORE WE
02:21:45.363 --> 02:21:46.698
GO TO THE NEXT BILL, WE DO HAVE
02:21:46.764 --> 02:21:47.966
TWO BILLS THAT WERE PRESENTED
02:21:48.032 --> 02:21:49.868
BUT NOT VOTED ON SO WELL.
02:21:49.934 --> 02:21:52.871
ENTERTAIN MOTIONS SO FIRST AND
02:21:52.937 --> 02:21:54.539
FOR THOSE WHO AREN'T HERE ON
02:21:54.606 --> 02:21:56.107
ITEM ONE, MAYBE 23 05 WITH
02:21:56.174 --> 02:21:58.610
TESTIMONY ONLY SO WE'LL GO TO
02:21:58.676 --> 02:22:01.279
ITEM NUMBER TWO. A B 2011 BY
02:22:01.346 --> 02:22:02.146
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS IS OUR
02:22:02.213 --> 02:22:05.183
EMOTION. MOVE MOVE BY SENATOR
02:22:05.250 --> 02:22:08.152
ROTH AND WILL CALL THE ROLL.
02:22:08.219 --> 02:22:09.787
THIS IS ASSEMBLY BILL 2011 BY
02:22:09.854 --> 02:22:11.089
SOME MEMBER WICKS. THE MOTIONS
02:22:11.155 --> 02:22:12.757
DO PASS. BUT FIRST HE REFERRED
02:22:12.824 --> 02:22:13.958
THE COMMITTEE AND GOVERNANCE AND
02:22:14.025 --> 02:22:15.960
FINANCE SENATOR WIENER WIENER.
02:22:16.027 --> 02:22:18.897
AYE BATES. YES, I JUST LIKE TO
02:22:18.963 --> 02:22:20.098
MAKE A COMMENT BECAUSE I MISS
02:22:20.164 --> 02:22:22.567
THE DISCUSSION. THAT I AM GOING
02:22:22.634 --> 02:22:25.003
TO OPPOSE IT TODAY. I THINK IT'S
02:22:25.069 --> 02:22:27.472
A GOOD IDEA ACTUALLY TO BE USING
02:22:27.538 --> 02:22:28.273
COMMERCIALLY HIS OWN LAND THAT I
02:22:28.339 --> 02:22:28.907
DO THINK THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENT
02:22:28.973 --> 02:22:29.908
NEEDS A LITTLE MORE
02:22:29.974 --> 02:22:31.976
RESPONSIBILITY AND HELD OUT. IS
02:22:32.043 --> 02:22:34.078
DONE, AND CERTAINLY A LITTLE
02:22:34.145 --> 02:22:35.580
MORE FEW MORE INCENTIVES SO I
02:22:35.647 --> 02:22:38.383
WILL OPPOSE TODAY, BUT I HAVE AN
02:22:38.449 --> 02:22:41.152
OPEN MIND. THANK YOU. BATES
02:22:41.219 --> 02:22:44.756
SNOW, VERY REAL. CORTEZ E.
02:22:44.822 --> 02:22:51.362
MCGUIRE PHð BUG. ROUGH. ROUGH I
02:22:51.429 --> 02:22:56.567
SKINNER SKINNER I HAMBURG. OKAY
02:22:56.634 --> 02:22:58.937
WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON CALL. AND
02:22:59.003 --> 02:23:02.573
THEN, UM, ITEM NUMBER SIX A. B
02:23:02.640 --> 02:23:05.443
17 43. IT'S LISTED AS MEDINA.
02:23:05.510 --> 02:23:06.110
BUT IT WAS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:23:06.177 --> 02:23:09.914
MAKIN, ER. IS THERE A MOTION?
02:23:09.981 --> 02:23:13.618
OKAY, I'LL CALL THE ROLL. THIS
02:23:13.685 --> 02:23:15.853
IS SOMETHING BILL 17 43 BY SOME
02:23:15.920 --> 02:23:17.622
MEMBER MEDINA. THE MACHINES DO
02:23:17.689 --> 02:23:19.590
PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMEND
02:23:19.657 --> 02:23:21.893
AND WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
02:23:21.960 --> 02:23:22.560
ON APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WIENER
02:23:22.627 --> 02:23:24.028
WIENER. AYE, BATES. CALDERON.
02:23:24.095 --> 02:23:29.434
ORTEZ. PRETTY EASY. I MCGUIRE
02:23:29.500 --> 02:23:32.370
PATROL BUG. ROTH ROTH I SKINNER
02:23:32.437 --> 02:23:36.007
SKINNER I HAMBURG. OKAY. WE'LL
02:23:36.074 --> 02:23:39.577
PUT THAT BILL ON CALL. AND THEN
02:23:39.644 --> 02:23:41.012
WE'LL DO THE CONSENT AGENDA AND
02:23:41.079 --> 02:23:46.517
THE CONSENT AGENDA. IS. ITEM
02:23:46.584 --> 02:23:48.720
THREE A B 16 15 BY SOME REMEMBER
02:23:48.786 --> 02:23:52.290
TING FILE ITEM EIGHT A B 1978 BY
02:23:52.357 --> 02:23:54.625
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD. FILE
02:23:54.692 --> 02:23:57.261
ITEM NINE A. B 1961 BY
02:23:57.328 --> 02:23:59.864
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GABRIEL. FILE
02:23:59.931 --> 02:24:01.866
ITEM 10, MAYBE 2000 AND SIX BY
02:24:01.933 --> 02:24:03.101
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BERMAN AND FILE
02:24:03.167 --> 02:24:06.270
ADAM 13 21 39. BY
02:24:06.337 --> 02:24:08.873
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GALLAGHER. IS
02:24:08.940 --> 02:24:11.142
THERE. A MOTION MOTION BY
02:24:11.209 --> 02:24:12.210
SENATOR SKINNER WILL CALL THE
02:24:12.276 --> 02:24:15.546
ROLL. ON THE CONCERNED CALENDAR
02:24:15.613 --> 02:24:17.382
, WHICH CONSISTS OF FILE ADAMS,
02:24:17.448 --> 02:24:19.017
389, 10 AND 13. SENATOR WIENER
02:24:19.083 --> 02:24:22.653
WIENER. AYE, BATES. BATES
02:24:22.720 --> 02:24:26.524
KABAROLE ORTEZ MAGUIRE, WHICH
02:24:26.591 --> 02:24:29.427
PILL BUG ROTH ROTH. I SKINNER
02:24:29.494 --> 02:24:33.664
SKINNER I HAMBURG. OKAY WE WILL
02:24:33.731 --> 02:24:35.733
PUT THE CONTENT CALENDAR ON CALL
02:24:35.800 --> 02:24:38.803
. UM SO NEXT WOULD BE
02:24:38.870 --> 02:24:39.904
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO, BUT
02:24:39.971 --> 02:24:42.407
HE HAS GRACIOUSLY DEFERRING TO
02:24:42.473 --> 02:24:45.076
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY TO GO
02:24:45.143 --> 02:24:46.811
FIRST. SO SOME REMEMBER LEE THIS
02:24:46.878 --> 02:24:50.415
WILL BE ITEM 11 A B 205 SOME
02:24:50.481 --> 02:24:54.552
REMEMBER YOU MAY PRESENT THANK
02:24:54.619 --> 02:24:55.753
YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS SO
02:24:55.820 --> 02:24:57.989
TODAY I'M PRESENTING TO YOU A B
02:24:58.056 --> 02:25:00.825
2053 TO SOCIAL HOUSING ACT OF
02:25:00.892 --> 02:25:05.663
CALIFORNIA THIS BILL WERE
02:25:05.730 --> 02:25:08.332
PRODUCING PRESERVE AFFORDABLE
02:25:08.399 --> 02:25:15.306
HOUSING ACROSS.
02:25:15.373 --> 02:25:16.441
COME UNITS THROUGH RENT,
02:25:16.507 --> 02:25:18.576
SOLIDARITY AND ALLOW HOUSING
02:25:18.643 --> 02:25:20.445
DEVELOPMENTS BE REVENUE NEUTRAL
02:25:20.511 --> 02:25:22.513
OVER THE LONG TERM. THIS MODEL
02:25:22.580 --> 02:25:24.182
HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL BOTH
02:25:24.248 --> 02:25:24.782
INTERNATIONALLY AND IN OTHER
02:25:24.849 --> 02:25:26.684
PARTS OF THE COUNTRY OF THE
02:25:26.751 --> 02:25:28.453
PICTURES. I'M SURE YOU. THIS IS
02:25:28.519 --> 02:25:31.856
THE MOST FAMOUS EGGS. OF SOCIAL
02:25:31.923 --> 02:25:37.862
, WHICH IS VIENNA. IN THE US,
02:25:37.929 --> 02:25:40.865
WHICH IS THIS PICTURE? THE
02:25:40.932 --> 02:25:42.366
MONTGOMERY COUNTY HOUSING
02:25:42.433 --> 02:25:43.634
OPPORTUNITIES COMMISSION IN
02:25:43.701 --> 02:25:45.169
MARYLAND HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY
02:25:45.236 --> 02:25:46.737
BUILDING HOUSING INSPIRED BY
02:25:46.804 --> 02:25:48.406
SOCIAL HOUSING MODELS FROM
02:25:48.473 --> 02:25:50.208
VIENNA AND SINGAPORE AND
02:25:50.274 --> 02:25:52.176
ELSEWHERE. THEY PLAN TO BUILD
02:25:52.243 --> 02:25:53.511
OVER 5000 UNITS, USING A SIMILAR
02:25:53.578 --> 02:25:55.213
APPROACH TO WHAT IS PROPOSED IN
02:25:55.279 --> 02:25:56.314
ARBIL. MEANWHILE IN CALIFORNIA
02:25:56.380 --> 02:25:58.950
OVER 97% OF CITIES AND COUNTIES
02:25:59.016 --> 02:26:00.218
HAVE NOT PRODUCED IN AFFORDABLE
02:26:00.284 --> 02:26:02.120
HOUSING. AND CALIFORNIA'S ARE
02:26:02.186 --> 02:26:02.987
BURDENED. BY HOUSING. COSTS,
02:26:03.054 --> 02:26:04.989
WITH ONE IN FIVE HOUSEHOLDS OVER
02:26:05.056 --> 02:26:05.790
HALF OF THEIR INCOME ON HOUSING,
02:26:05.857 --> 02:26:08.059
SO IT'S CLEAR THAT HOUSING NEED
02:26:08.126 --> 02:26:08.626
CALIFORNIA NEEDS ADDITIONAL
02:26:08.693 --> 02:26:09.594
TOOLS, HELP SOLVE THE HOUSING
02:26:09.660 --> 02:26:10.862
SHORTAGE AND SOCIAL HOUSING. THE
02:26:10.928 --> 02:26:14.398
CRITICAL MISSING PIECE. THIS IS
02:26:14.465 --> 02:26:16.501
A TOOL TO ENABLE CALIFORNIA BE
02:26:16.567 --> 02:26:18.603
IN THE PUBLIC DEVELOPMENT SPACE
02:26:18.669 --> 02:26:19.737
TO TRULY UILD HOUSING AS A
02:26:19.804 --> 02:26:24.442
HUMAN. FINANCIERS WERE NOT
02:26:24.509 --> 02:26:26.177
BUILDERS IN OUR OWN RIGHT. AND
02:26:26.244 --> 02:26:26.978
THIS IS WHAT WILL CHANGE THE
02:26:27.044 --> 02:26:29.347
DYNAMIC RESPECTFULLY AFTER I
02:26:29.413 --> 02:26:30.314
VOTE, AND TODAY TESTIFYING WITH
02:26:30.381 --> 02:26:32.216
ME WILL BE SCOTT WENT FROM THE
02:26:32.283 --> 02:26:33.518
CALIFORNIA STATE PIPES TRADE
02:26:33.584 --> 02:26:36.554
COUNCIL HERE IN PERSON AND DAVID
02:26:36.621 --> 02:26:37.588
BARBOZA FROM ABUNDANT HOUSING
02:26:37.655 --> 02:26:39.323
REMOTELY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
02:26:39.390 --> 02:26:40.992
MR. WATCH MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
02:26:41.058 --> 02:26:42.226
ACTUALLY SCOTT WESTON BIRTH. THE
02:26:42.293 --> 02:26:43.194
CALIFORNIA STATE PATRIOTS
02:26:43.261 --> 02:26:44.362
COUNSEL AND THE STATE
02:26:44.428 --> 02:26:45.396
ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL
02:26:45.463 --> 02:26:46.964
WORKERS. IN THE WESTERN STATES
02:26:47.031 --> 02:26:48.933
COUNCIL OF SHEET METAL ORDERS.
02:26:49.000 --> 02:26:50.401
WE SUPPORT THE BILL AGAINST AN
02:26:50.468 --> 02:26:52.837
INNOVATIVE APPROACH TO CREATING
02:26:52.904 --> 02:26:55.473
HOUSING SPECIFICALLY TO THE
02:26:55.540 --> 02:26:57.341
AMENDMENTS OF THE OTHERS TAKEN
02:26:57.408 --> 02:26:58.342
REGARDING THE SKILLED AND
02:26:58.409 --> 02:27:00.511
TRAINED WORKFORCE. WE SUPPORT
02:27:00.578 --> 02:27:02.480
THAT INCLUSION, INCLUDING THE
02:27:02.547 --> 02:27:05.283
INCLUSION OF TWO BITTER LANGUAGE
02:27:05.349 --> 02:27:07.785
, WHICH BASICALLY REQUIRES THAT
02:27:07.852 --> 02:27:08.853
IF YOU HAVE A SKILLED AND
02:27:08.920 --> 02:27:10.788
TRAINED REQUIREMENT, AND YOU
02:27:10.855 --> 02:27:12.089
DON'T GET AT LEAST TWO QUALIFIED
02:27:12.156 --> 02:27:13.457
BIDDERS THAN THE REQUIREMENT
02:27:13.524 --> 02:27:16.561
DOESN'T APPLY. UM WE SUPPORT
02:27:16.627 --> 02:27:17.795
THAT FOR A NUMBER OF REASONS.
02:27:17.862 --> 02:27:21.899
FIRST. UM WE HAVE BITTER
02:27:21.966 --> 02:27:23.868
LANGUAGE IN MANY, MANY, MANY
02:27:23.935 --> 02:27:25.536
AGREEMENTS THAT WE'VE NEGOTIATED
02:27:25.603 --> 02:27:27.939
OURSELVES. SO I COULDN'T STAND
02:27:28.005 --> 02:27:28.940
HERE IN GOOD CONSCIENCE AND NOT
02:27:29.006 --> 02:27:31.108
SUPPORT. UM, PROVISIONS THAT WE
02:27:31.175 --> 02:27:33.211
HAVE IN OUR OWN AGREEMENTS.
02:27:33.277 --> 02:27:35.713
NUMBER TWO. MY CLIENTS BELIEVE
02:27:35.780 --> 02:27:37.748
THAT IF YOU APPLY A SKILLED AND
02:27:37.815 --> 02:27:39.717
TRAINED WORKFORCE, AND WE'RE NOT
02:27:39.784 --> 02:27:42.153
ABLE TO MUSTER THE REQUISITE
02:27:42.220 --> 02:27:43.487
CONTRACTORS TO BID ON THOSE
02:27:43.554 --> 02:27:45.756
PROJECTS, THEN YOU KNOW, THAT'S
02:27:45.823 --> 02:27:47.959
POX IN OUR HEALTH. WE SHOULD DO
02:27:48.025 --> 02:27:49.460
A BETTER JOB OF ORGANIZING OUR
02:27:49.527 --> 02:27:50.895
INDUSTRY. AND SO FOR THOSE
02:27:50.962 --> 02:27:52.597
REASONS, WE THINK THAT THIS BILL
02:27:52.663 --> 02:27:53.598
DESERVES TO MOVE FORWARD AND WE
02:27:53.664 --> 02:27:56.367
WOULD URGE AND I VOTE. THANK YOU
02:27:56.434 --> 02:27:57.702
VERY MUCH. AND SO NOW WE HAVE
02:27:57.768 --> 02:28:03.608
DAVID BARBOZA BY PHONE. GOOD
02:28:03.674 --> 02:28:05.243
AFTERNOON SHARE WIENER AND
02:28:05.309 --> 02:28:06.844
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE HOUSING
02:28:06.911 --> 02:28:08.246
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS DAVID
02:28:08.312 --> 02:28:10.381
BARBOZA ON THE DIRECTOR OF
02:28:10.448 --> 02:28:11.582
POLICY AND RESEARCH FOR ABUNDANT
02:28:11.649 --> 02:28:12.650
HOUSING LÀ. WE'RE PLEASED TO
02:28:12.717 --> 02:28:13.718
SUPPORT THE BILL, MAYBE 2053
02:28:13.784 --> 02:28:17.521
SOCIAL HOUSING ACT. THE BILL
02:28:17.588 --> 02:28:18.856
WOULD FORM THE CALIFORNIA
02:28:18.923 --> 02:28:20.891
HOUSING AUTHORITY, OR CH, WHICH
02:28:20.958 --> 02:28:22.226
WOULD BE CHARGED WITH CREATING
02:28:22.293 --> 02:28:23.527
PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE MIXED
02:28:23.594 --> 02:28:25.429
INCOME. SOCIAL HOUSING. NEW
02:28:25.496 --> 02:28:27.431
CONSTRUCTION OF ACQUISITION
02:28:27.498 --> 02:28:28.666
BUILDING ON A MODEL SUCCESSFULLY
02:28:28.733 --> 02:28:29.900
DEPLOYED AROUND THE WORLD.
02:28:29.967 --> 02:28:31.636
CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING SHORTAGE IS
02:28:31.702 --> 02:28:33.704
THE PRIMARY CAUSE OF OUR STATES
02:28:33.771 --> 02:28:34.705
RISING AND UNSUSTAINABLE HOUSING
02:28:34.772 --> 02:28:37.041
COSTS. YOU, TOO, WILL SUPPLEMENT
02:28:37.108 --> 02:28:38.643
BUT NOT REPLACE PRIVATE HOME
02:28:38.709 --> 02:28:39.944
BUILDING IN CALIFORNIA BY
02:28:40.011 --> 02:28:41.445
TARGETING PUBLIC INVESTMENT IN
02:28:41.512 --> 02:28:42.380
COMMUNITIES THAT ARE FALLING
02:28:42.446 --> 02:28:44.115
SHORT ON THEIR HOUSING
02:28:44.181 --> 02:28:46.217
PRODUCTION GOALS. SOCIAL HOUSING
02:28:46.284 --> 02:28:47.451
DEVELOPMENTS WILL INCORPORATE A
02:28:47.518 --> 02:28:48.919
RANGE OF AFFORDABILITY LEVELS.
02:28:48.986 --> 02:28:50.621
THE REVERSE HISTORICAL PATTERNS
02:28:50.688 --> 02:28:52.757
OF SEGREGATION AND ALLOW ON
02:28:52.823 --> 02:28:54.558
SUBSIDIZED TO CROSS SUBSIDIZE
02:28:54.625 --> 02:28:57.295
THE AFFORDABLE HOMES. AND SOCIAL
02:28:57.361 --> 02:28:57.962
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS WLL BE
02:28:58.029 --> 02:28:59.730
PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE, IN
02:28:59.797 --> 02:29:01.198
CONTRAST TO EXISTING FINANCING
02:29:01.265 --> 02:29:02.366
MODELS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING,
02:29:02.433 --> 02:29:04.302
WHICH TYPICALLY INVOLVES 55 YEAR
02:29:04.368 --> 02:29:06.203
AFFORDABILITY GOVERNMENTS, WHICH
02:29:06.270 --> 02:29:07.538
REQUIRE ADDITIONAL POLICIES TO
02:29:07.605 --> 02:29:08.673
PREVENT CONVERSION TO MARKET
02:29:08.739 --> 02:29:11.075
RATES. MAYBE 2053 AIMS FOR
02:29:11.142 --> 02:29:12.510
REVENUE NEUTRALITY THROUGH THE
02:29:12.576 --> 02:29:14.045
CROSS SUBSIDY FINANCING MODEL,
02:29:14.111 --> 02:29:15.546
BUT ALSO ALLOWS THE STATE TO
02:29:15.613 --> 02:29:17.014
SUPPLEMENT THIS FINANCING WITH
02:29:17.081 --> 02:29:18.816
DIRECT SUBSIDIES, RESULTING IN
02:29:18.883 --> 02:29:20.284
MORE AFFORDABLE HOMES AT DEEPER
02:29:20.351 --> 02:29:22.720
LEVELS OF AFFORDABILITY. BY
02:29:22.787 --> 02:29:23.988
MAINTAINING FLEXIBILITY AND
02:29:24.055 --> 02:29:26.190
FINANCING. EACH DAY TAKES IN ONE
02:29:26.257 --> 02:29:27.758
OF THE KEY LESSONS OF US PUBLIC
02:29:27.825 --> 02:29:29.527
HOUSING, WHICH IS THAT ADEQUATE
02:29:29.593 --> 02:29:30.594
FUNDING MUST BE AVAILABLE FOR
02:29:30.661 --> 02:29:32.663
MAINTENANCE. MAYBE 2053 RESPONSE
02:29:32.730 --> 02:29:35.032
TO CONCERNS ABOUT GENTRIFICATION
02:29:35.099 --> 02:29:36.467
BY REQUIRING AN ANNUAL REPORT ON
02:29:36.534 --> 02:29:38.636
OUR ACTIVITIES AFFECT THE ISSUE
02:29:38.703 --> 02:29:40.204
ALONGSIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
02:29:40.271 --> 02:29:41.639
PUBLIC INPUT. HAVING THIS
02:29:41.706 --> 02:29:44.075
ANALYSIS WILL HELP GOD IS
02:29:44.141 --> 02:29:44.675
PLANNING AND ENSURE THAT IT IS
02:29:44.742 --> 02:29:47.111
OPERATING EQUITABLY. HOUSING IS
02:29:47.178 --> 02:29:49.280
A HUMAN RIGHT AND SOCIAL HOUSING
02:29:49.347 --> 02:29:50.481
IS AN IMPORTANT TOOL TO REALIZE
02:29:50.548 --> 02:29:51.982
THAT RIGHT IN PRACTICE THE
02:29:52.049 --> 02:29:54.318
PUBLIC SECTOR HAS A DUTY NOT
02:29:54.385 --> 02:29:55.119
JUST TO CREATE THE CONDITIONS
02:29:55.186 --> 02:29:56.220
FOR SUFFICIENT HOUSING TO BE
02:29:56.287 --> 02:29:57.888
BUILT AT ALL INCOME LEVELS, BUT
02:29:57.955 --> 02:29:59.623
ALSO THE PARTICIPATE DIRECTLY IN
02:29:59.690 --> 02:30:01.025
THE DEVELOPMENT OF THAT HOUSING.
02:30:01.092 --> 02:30:04.462
WE RESPECTFULLY URGENT I VOTE.
02:30:04.528 --> 02:30:06.897
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
02:30:06.964 --> 02:30:07.998
ADDITIONAL SUPPORTIVE PUBLIC
02:30:08.065 --> 02:30:13.537
COMMENT HERE IN THE ROOM? MR
02:30:13.604 --> 02:30:15.139
CHAIR AND MEMBERS RAND MARTIN ON
02:30:15.206 --> 02:30:17.241
BEHALF OF THE AIDS HEALTHCARE
02:30:17.308 --> 02:30:17.842
FOUNDATION, AND IT'S HEALTHY
02:30:17.908 --> 02:30:18.709
HOUSING FOUNDATION. VERY STRONG
02:30:18.776 --> 02:30:19.810
SUPPORT OF THIS IMPORTANT, BILL.
02:30:19.877 --> 02:30:24.815
THANK YOU. HELLO MR CHAIR AND
02:30:24.882 --> 02:30:26.951
MEMBERS RYAN JOY ON BEHALF OF
02:30:27.017 --> 02:30:27.852
CALIFORNIA AND BE WE ARE PROUD
02:30:27.918 --> 02:30:29.587
TO GO SPONSOR A B 2053
02:30:29.653 --> 02:30:30.621
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
02:30:30.688 --> 02:30:34.759
VOTE. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:30:34.825 --> 02:30:36.460
, MR CHAIR AND SENATORS ROSANNA
02:30:36.527 --> 02:30:37.094
CARPACCIO ELLIOTT ON BEHALF OF
02:30:37.161 --> 02:30:38.863
THE CITY OF ALAMEDA IN SUPPORT.
02:30:38.929 --> 02:30:42.533
THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON, COREY
02:30:42.600 --> 02:30:43.701
SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING
02:30:43.768 --> 02:30:48.539
ACTION COALITION AND SUPPORT.
02:30:48.606 --> 02:30:49.840
HELLO, CASSIE MONSIGNOR ON
02:30:49.907 --> 02:30:51.142
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
02:30:51.208 --> 02:30:51.909
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
02:30:51.976 --> 02:30:57.047
SUPPORT. AMBER MADISON FROM THE
02:30:57.114 --> 02:30:57.681
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
02:30:57.748 --> 02:31:00.918
AND SUPPORT ANY ADDITIONAL
02:31:00.985 --> 02:31:01.952
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE
02:31:02.019 --> 02:31:04.855
HEARING ROOM. SAYING THAT AND
02:31:04.922 --> 02:31:06.924
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
02:31:06.991 --> 02:31:08.025
MODERATOR WILL YOU PLEASE QUEUE
02:31:08.092 --> 02:31:11.662
UP SUPPORT TESTIMONY? THANK YOU
02:31:11.729 --> 02:31:13.164
TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL
02:31:13.230 --> 02:31:14.799
, PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO ON
02:31:14.865 --> 02:31:16.767
YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD. YOU HAVE
02:31:16.834 --> 02:31:18.736
NOT ALREADY DONE SO THAT'S ONE
02:31:18.803 --> 02:31:21.572
FOLLOWED BY THE ZERO, PLEASE.
02:31:21.639 --> 02:31:23.307
WE'LL GO FIRST TO LINE 2 22,
02:31:23.374 --> 02:31:28.245
PLEASE GO AHEAD. BY ALISON SHALL
02:31:28.312 --> 02:31:30.714
ALERT AND HOLLYWOOD CALLING AND
02:31:30.781 --> 02:31:32.116
STRONG SUPPORT. SINGLE FAMILY
02:31:32.183 --> 02:31:36.120
HOME OWNER HAVE A GOOD DAY. 3 54
02:31:36.187 --> 02:31:44.261
354. THIS IS KEVIN MÀ WITH
02:31:44.328 --> 02:31:45.429
MOUNTAIN VIEW. UM BE IN SUPPORT
02:31:45.496 --> 02:31:54.238
OF A B 2053. LINE 3 55. HELLO.
02:31:54.305 --> 02:31:55.973
MY NAME IS LAURA HAIDER
02:31:56.040 --> 02:32:02.313
SUPPORTIVE 2053. PRESIDENT,
02:32:02.379 --> 02:32:03.247
PRESIDENT. OH, AND SEND MY
02:32:03.314 --> 02:32:11.789
HOMELESSNESS. LINE 3 41. GOOD
02:32:11.856 --> 02:32:12.890
AFTERNOON SHARE MEMBERS ON THE
02:32:12.957 --> 02:32:14.225
RAMOS ON BEHALF OF PUBLIC
02:32:14.291 --> 02:32:16.293
ADVOCATES AND HOUSING. NOW WE
02:32:16.360 --> 02:32:17.795
WERE INCORRECTLY LISTED IN THE
02:32:17.862 --> 02:32:18.696
BILL ANALYSIS OF BEING IN
02:32:18.762 --> 02:32:20.898
SUPPORT, ALONG WITH THE OTHER 30
02:32:20.965 --> 02:32:21.832
HOUSING JUSTICE ORGANIZATIONS
02:32:21.899 --> 02:32:24.768
LISTED IN OUR JUNE 15TH LETTER.
02:32:24.835 --> 02:32:26.270
WE ACTUALLY DON'T HAVE A FORMAL
02:32:26.337 --> 02:32:26.971
POSITION THAT WE ARE VERY
02:32:27.037 --> 02:32:28.606
SUPPORTIVE IN CONTEXT, BUT WE
02:32:28.672 --> 02:32:30.174
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THE
02:32:30.241 --> 02:32:30.808
AUTHOR'S OFFICE TO RESOLVE OUR
02:32:30.875 --> 02:32:32.643
CONCERNS AND HOPEFULLY REACH A
02:32:32.710 --> 02:32:34.612
SUPPORT POSITION. THANK YOU. 2
02:32:34.678 --> 02:32:41.252
75. THIS IS CARL KELLEY FROM
02:32:41.318 --> 02:32:42.419
BEVERLY SANTA CRUZ CALLING AND
02:32:42.486 --> 02:32:50.194
STRONG SUPPORT. 2 24. SCARED
02:32:50.261 --> 02:32:52.530
OVER BEAN AND VOTER IN OAKLAND
02:32:52.596 --> 02:32:53.931
AND A MEMBER OF EAST INDIAN
02:32:53.998 --> 02:32:56.734
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 2053. 3
02:32:56.800 --> 02:33:05.209
61. THIS IS JOSHUA BRAXTON WITH
02:33:05.276 --> 02:33:06.110
RESPONSIBLE GROWTH, STRONG
02:33:06.176 --> 02:33:13.417
SUPPORT. 3 63. SAVING CHAIR OF
02:33:13.484 --> 02:33:14.685
MEMBERS ZACH BOWLING
02:33:14.752 --> 02:33:15.719
REPRESENTING EAST JUND, CALLING
02:33:15.786 --> 02:33:18.622
HIM STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 3
02:33:18.689 --> 02:33:24.061
64. I DROVE LOEWENSTEIN FROM
02:33:24.128 --> 02:33:25.496
BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA, WITH CMB
02:33:25.563 --> 02:33:27.431
AND EAST BAY FOR EVERYONE IN
02:33:27.498 --> 02:33:34.104
STRONG SUPPORT. THANKS. 3 65.
02:33:34.171 --> 02:33:35.639
GOOD AFTERNOON ROLE MODEL TOMATO
02:33:35.706 --> 02:33:37.808
, ANOTHER REPRESENTATIVE OF THE
02:33:37.875 --> 02:33:39.443
STRONGLY SUPPORTING ÁP CHOOSER
02:33:39.510 --> 02:33:45.516
FACTORY. THANK YOU. 3 56. MY
02:33:45.583 --> 02:33:47.251
NAME IS LISA DANCE AND WHICH
02:33:47.318 --> 02:33:48.519
PRIMA FOR EVERYONE, AND WE
02:33:48.586 --> 02:33:55.926
SUPPORT A B 2053. 2 56. IT'S A
02:33:55.993 --> 02:33:57.962
GOOD AFTERNOON DEPARTMENT HELD
02:33:58.028 --> 02:34:01.031
ON BEHALF OF, UH OH, SPONSOR CAN
02:34:01.098 --> 02:34:03.167
BE ACTION. UH STRONG SUPPORT AS
02:34:03.233 --> 02:34:05.936
WELL AS CHAPTER ORGANIZATIONS.
02:34:06.003 --> 02:34:08.205
STANDING WITH ABOUT 40 MB AND
02:34:08.272 --> 02:34:09.607
OCCURS THE N B SOUTH, A MB
02:34:09.673 --> 02:34:10.674
PENINSULA FOR EVERYONE IN SAN
02:34:10.741 --> 02:34:18.616
FRANCISCO AND 3 62. HI THERE,
02:34:18.682 --> 02:34:19.917
TORN FROM OAKLAND FROM THE OTHER
02:34:19.984 --> 02:34:30.227
ONE IN STRONG SUPPORTER. 2 29. 2
02:34:30.294 --> 02:34:37.868
TO 9. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. UM,
02:34:37.935 --> 02:34:43.140
SORRY. A DO YOU HEAR ME? YES. AH
02:34:43.207 --> 02:34:44.208
SOMETHING MORE CHYNA CALLING
02:34:44.274 --> 02:34:46.343
FROM LOS ANGELES ON BEHALF OF
02:34:46.410 --> 02:34:47.077
WESTSIDE FOR EVERYONE IN STRONG
02:34:47.144 --> 02:34:51.348
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 3 59. THAT'S
02:34:51.415 --> 02:34:52.449
A GOOD CALIFORNIA. UM, BEES
02:34:52.516 --> 02:34:59.723
SUPPORT 209. BRIAN O'CONNELL,
02:34:59.790 --> 02:35:00.758
NAPA SOLANO FOR EVERYONE IN
02:35:00.824 --> 02:35:08.132
STRONG SUPPORT. 3 57. HAVING
02:35:08.198 --> 02:35:09.266
BEEN OFTEN SAN DIEGO UMBC
02:35:09.333 --> 02:35:17.341
SUPPORT 1 73. THIS ALFRED TO IS
02:35:17.408 --> 02:35:18.609
FOR EVERYONE. STRONG SUPPORT.
02:35:18.676 --> 02:35:25.582
THANK YOU. 3 67. HIâU NORTH
02:35:25.649 --> 02:35:27.451
DAKOTA PARTY FROM SAN JOSE,
02:35:27.518 --> 02:35:28.585
CALIFORNIA CALLING IN STRONG
02:35:28.652 --> 02:35:34.692
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 304. YES
02:35:34.758 --> 02:35:36.894
HELLO. MY NAME IS FRANCESCA.
02:35:36.960 --> 02:35:39.363
WANDA. I AM IN SACRAMENTO WITH
02:35:39.430 --> 02:35:40.964
INDIVIDUAL CALIFORNIA STATE
02:35:41.031 --> 02:35:43.300
STRONG INDIVIDUAL, SACRAMENTO,
02:35:43.367 --> 02:35:44.968
INDIVISIBLE SAN FRANCISCO AND
02:35:45.035 --> 02:35:47.871
<c.red>NDIVISIBLE YOLO. ALL IN STRONG</c>
02:35:47.938 --> 02:35:57.014
SUPPORT OF TWO OH 53. 3 53. HI
02:35:57.081 --> 02:35:57.514
THIS IS JOHN MAYNARD CO
02:35:57.581 --> 02:35:59.216
EXECUTIVE PAY FOR EVERYONE
02:35:59.283 --> 02:36:01.051
LOCATED. I'M LOCATED IN STANLEY
02:36:01.118 --> 02:36:02.186
ANDRO ORGANIZATION IS AN ARTIST
02:36:02.252 --> 02:36:10.327
SUPPORT. 3 28. CAN YOU HEAR ME?
02:36:10.394 --> 02:36:14.765
YES. PLEASE GO AHEAD. ANDREW
02:36:14.832 --> 02:36:16.834
LEWIS. WHAT'S WITH VILLAGE
02:36:16.900 --> 02:36:18.635
ABUNDANT HOUSING L. A NORTHWEST
02:36:18.702 --> 02:36:19.803
WOULD NEVER COUNSELED STRONG
02:36:19.870 --> 02:36:21.472
SUPPORT FOR THE CALIFORNIA
02:36:21.538 --> 02:36:22.573
SOCIAL, I THINK. THANK YOU. 1
02:36:22.639 --> 02:36:29.179
77. BRIAN AUSTIN MEMBER OF
02:36:29.246 --> 02:36:30.514
INCLUDING SANTA MONICA IN
02:36:30.581 --> 02:36:31.648
CALIFORNIA. JIM BEATS CONSTABLE.
02:36:31.715 --> 02:36:41.425
2 19. HELLO. GARY HOFFMAN WITH
02:36:41.492 --> 02:36:43.460
COVER CITY FOR MORE HOMES IN
02:36:43.527 --> 02:36:44.094
CALIFORNIA AGAIN GMB AND STRONG
02:36:44.161 --> 02:36:57.274
SUPPORT OF 2053. 2 86. 286. ARE
02:36:57.341 --> 02:37:06.116
YOU ON MUTE? WE'LL GO TO 3 40.
02:37:06.183 --> 02:37:08.352
HELLO THIS IS ERIN WILLEY ON
02:37:08.418 --> 02:37:09.052
BEHALF OF SIERRA CLUB,
02:37:09.119 --> 02:37:18.495
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT 3 48. HI
02:37:18.562 --> 02:37:21.431
THIS IS SHANE LARIMER WITH SAN
02:37:21.498 --> 02:37:22.399
DIEGO. UM, B AND I'M PROBABLY
02:37:22.466 --> 02:37:27.337
SUPPORTING 370. HI THIS IS ADAM
02:37:27.404 --> 02:37:28.939
PAVEL, AKA RESIDENT OF SAN
02:37:29.006 --> 02:37:30.174
FRANCISCO, WHO'S SEEN TOO MANY
02:37:30.240 --> 02:37:32.109
FRIENDS BELIEVED THE CITY DUE TO
02:37:32.176 --> 02:37:33.277
HOUSING. I'M CALLING IN STRONG
02:37:33.343 --> 02:37:40.984
SUPPORT OF A B 2053. 1 53. MY
02:37:41.051 --> 02:37:43.253
NAME IS BRAD DOING CALLING ON
02:37:43.320 --> 02:37:44.388
BEHALF OF SAN MONICA FORD STRONG
02:37:44.454 --> 02:37:51.528
SUPPORTING THIS BILL. TO 76.
02:37:51.595 --> 02:37:53.096
THANK YOU. MATTHEW LEWIS,
02:37:53.163 --> 02:37:54.698
SECRETARY OF THE BERKELEY TENANT
02:37:54.765 --> 02:37:55.532
STUDENTS STEERING COMMITTEE
02:37:55.599 --> 02:37:56.733
MEMBER FOR THE BERKELEY
02:37:56.800 --> 02:37:58.435
PROGRESSIVE ALLIANCE AND MEMBER
02:37:58.502 --> 02:38:00.304
OF OUR REVOLUTION. EAST BAY, AS
02:38:00.370 --> 02:38:00.838
MENTIONED BY THE PREVIOUS
02:38:00.904 --> 02:38:02.840
SPEAKER, MULTIPLE DOZENS OF
02:38:02.906 --> 02:38:03.807
ORGANIZATIONS INCLUDING OUR OWN
02:38:03.874 --> 02:38:10.914
WERE FALSELY LIFT. OUR ORG,
02:38:10.981 --> 02:38:12.783
WHILE OTHERS ON THE LIST ARE IN
02:38:12.850 --> 02:38:13.917
FACT OPPOSING NONE OF THE ORGAN.
02:38:13.984 --> 02:38:16.119
HAVE ENDORSED, UM, WE SIGNED A
02:38:16.186 --> 02:38:18.222
LETTER OF CONCERN. UM, WE ARE
02:38:18.288 --> 02:38:19.389
REALLY DISAPPOINTED THAT WE WERE
02:38:19.456 --> 02:38:21.091
FALSELY LISTEN TO SUPPORTING US
02:38:21.158 --> 02:38:22.759
. WE DEMAND THAT THE BILL
02:38:22.826 --> 02:38:24.061
ANALYSIS BE CORRECTED AND
02:38:24.127 --> 02:38:26.129
REPUBLISHED TO REFLECT THAT. UM
02:38:26.196 --> 02:38:30.634
AND WE ALSO CALL ON THE AUTHORS
02:38:30.701 --> 02:38:32.135
TO WORK WITH LOW INCOME PENDANT
02:38:32.202 --> 02:38:33.937
GROUPS TO ADDRESS OUR CONCERNS.
02:38:34.004 --> 02:38:34.471
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT SOCIAL
02:38:34.538 --> 02:38:35.706
HOUSING, BUT CAN'T SUPPORT IT
02:38:35.772 --> 02:38:37.107
WITHOUT THE AMENDMENTS
02:38:37.174 --> 02:38:44.214
NECESSARY. THANK YOU. 3 74. HI
02:38:44.281 --> 02:38:46.750
MY NAME IS BRIANNA EGAN. UM I'M
02:38:46.817 --> 02:38:48.785
FROM REDONDO BEACH, CALIFORNIA
02:38:48.852 --> 02:38:51.588
AND ALSO BASED IN REDLANDS AS
02:38:51.655 --> 02:38:54.191
WELL. UM, I'M A MEDICAL STUDENT
02:38:54.258 --> 02:38:56.493
. UM AD I AM INVOLVED WITH
02:38:56.560 --> 02:38:58.762
ABUNDANT HOUSING L A AND I'M IN
02:38:58.829 --> 02:38:59.897
STRONG SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2053.
02:38:59.963 --> 02:39:07.838
THANK YOU. 3 75. HI THIS IS
02:39:07.905 --> 02:39:08.939
ROBERT STUTMAN WITH SAN
02:39:09.006 --> 02:39:10.274
FRANCISCO. INDY IN SUPPORT.
02:39:10.340 --> 02:39:16.146
THANK YOU. 3 76. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:39:16.213 --> 02:39:17.681
, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS JORDAN
02:39:17.748 --> 02:39:18.882
GRIMES ON BEHALF OF GREENBELT
02:39:18.949 --> 02:39:20.984
ALLIANCE AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
02:39:21.051 --> 02:39:22.286
80 2053. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
02:39:22.352 --> 02:39:26.823
BREATHE, 77. HELLO THIS IS
02:39:26.890 --> 02:39:28.525
JOSHUA HAN, REPRESENTING COMMON
02:39:28.592 --> 02:39:29.860
GROUND, CALIFORNIA IN STRONG
02:39:29.927 --> 02:39:31.495
SUPPORT OF A B 2053. THANK YOU.
02:39:31.561 --> 02:39:38.335
3 73. HELLO. THIS IS NEIL
02:39:38.402 --> 02:39:40.003
WILLIAMS IN SAN FRANCISCO. AND
02:39:40.070 --> 02:39:41.805
I'M IN THE STRONG SUPPORT OF A B
02:39:41.872 --> 02:39:44.041
2053. THANK YOU. NO FURTHER
02:39:44.107 --> 02:39:48.745
LINES IN QUEUE FOR SUPPORT.
02:39:48.812 --> 02:39:50.480
OKAY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH WHEN I
02:39:50.547 --> 02:39:52.349
GO TO OPPOSITION. UM FOR LEAD
02:39:52.416 --> 02:39:57.454
OPPOSITION. THEM. MR SMITH. ARE
02:39:57.521 --> 02:40:00.857
YOU LEADING OPPOSITION OR ARE
02:40:00.924 --> 02:40:02.960
YOU A TWEENER? KINDA NEED TO
02:40:03.026 --> 02:40:04.628
REMOVE OUR SPONSORSHIP, SO I
02:40:04.695 --> 02:40:06.063
DON'T KNOW IF I'M LEAD
02:40:06.129 --> 02:40:08.198
OPPOSITION, BUT I KNOW IT'S JUST
02:40:08.265 --> 02:40:09.333
MAKE A BRIEF STATEMENT. OKAY.
02:40:09.399 --> 02:40:10.901
THANKS JEREMY SMITH HERE ON
02:40:10.968 --> 02:40:12.135
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING AND
02:40:12.202 --> 02:40:14.638
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL. UM
02:40:14.705 --> 02:40:16.273
RESPECTFULLY HERE TODAY TO
02:40:16.340 --> 02:40:20.243
REMOVE OUR SUPPORT OF THE BILL
02:40:20.310 --> 02:40:22.312
AND OUR CO SPONSORSHIP OF THE
02:40:22.379 --> 02:40:23.780
BILL HERE IN COMMITTEE. WE HAVE
02:40:23.847 --> 02:40:25.015
, UM, ENGAGE IN CONVERSATIONS
02:40:25.082 --> 02:40:26.917
WITH MR LEE. HE'S AWARE OF THIS.
02:40:26.984 --> 02:40:28.852
THIS ISN'T A SURPRISE TO HIM. UM
02:40:28.919 --> 02:40:29.853
AND UNFORTUNATELY, THE BILL
02:40:29.920 --> 02:40:33.023
MOVED OUT OF THE ASSEMBLY. WITH
02:40:33.090 --> 02:40:34.658
THIS STRONG WORKFORCE PROTECTION
02:40:34.725 --> 02:40:36.259
LANGUAGE THAT WE ASKED FOR, AND
02:40:36.326 --> 02:40:38.228
THAT WAS IN THE BILL STRIPPED
02:40:38.295 --> 02:40:40.731
OUT. UH, NO EXPLANATION GIVEN TO
02:40:40.797 --> 02:40:42.899
US AS TO WHY, UM AND
02:40:42.966 --> 02:40:43.900
UNFORTUNATELY IS HERE TODAY
02:40:43.967 --> 02:40:46.436
BEFORE YOU IN A WAY THAT WE
02:40:46.503 --> 02:40:47.471
DON'T BELIEVE PROTECTS WORKERS.
02:40:47.537 --> 02:40:49.272
UM WITH RESPECT TO AN EARLIER
02:40:49.339 --> 02:40:50.240
SPEAKER, WE DON'T BELIEVE
02:40:50.307 --> 02:40:52.009
AMENDMENTS DEALING WITH THE
02:40:52.075 --> 02:40:53.844
NUMBER OF CONTRACTORS THAT MIGHT
02:40:53.910 --> 02:40:55.445
OR MIGHT NOT BE AVAILABLE TO BE
02:40:55.512 --> 02:40:57.447
, UM, CHOSEN FOR A PROJECT
02:40:57.514 --> 02:40:58.315
ADEQUATELY PROTECTS WORKERS
02:40:58.382 --> 02:41:00.317
EITHER STATEWIDE FOR ALL OF OUR
02:41:00.384 --> 02:41:02.319
OTHER UNIONS. THESE TYPES OF
02:41:02.386 --> 02:41:04.054
PROJECTS TRADITIONALLY BEEN, UM
02:41:04.121 --> 02:41:06.423
PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS AND
02:41:06.490 --> 02:41:08.025
COVERED WITH SPICE SCOTLAND
02:41:08.091 --> 02:41:08.925
TRAIN STATUTES. WE BELIEVE THOSE
02:41:08.992 --> 02:41:11.061
ARE THE STATUTES THAT SHOULD BE
02:41:11.128 --> 02:41:12.896
IN THE BILL. WE HOPE THAT MR LEE
02:41:12.963 --> 02:41:13.897
WILL WORK WITH US.
02:41:13.964 --> 02:41:14.898
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY WILL WORK
02:41:14.965 --> 02:41:16.133
WITH US. TO GET THAT LANGUAGE
02:41:16.199 --> 02:41:18.201
PUT BACK INTO THE BILL AS IT
02:41:18.268 --> 02:41:20.704
MOVES TO THE SENATE. THANK YOU.
02:41:20.771 --> 02:41:22.139
FIORENTINA'S THANK YOU, MR
02:41:22.205 --> 02:41:23.673
SIMILAR COMMENTS EDUARDO
02:41:23.740 --> 02:41:25.675
MARTINEZ WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:41:25.742 --> 02:41:26.843
LABOR FEDERATION. ALSO, WE HAVE
02:41:26.910 --> 02:41:29.279
TO REMOVE OUR CO SPONSORSHIP OF
02:41:29.346 --> 02:41:30.213
THE BILL FOR THE REASONS
02:41:30.280 --> 02:41:34.184
PREVIOUSLY STATED. MR CHAIR BOB
02:41:34.251 --> 02:41:36.119
NAYLOR, REPRESENTING FIELDS DEAD
02:41:36.186 --> 02:41:37.754
IN COMPANY WERE OPPOSED TO THE
02:41:37.821 --> 02:41:40.791
BILL UNLESS AMENDED TO TAKE OUT
02:41:40.857 --> 02:41:42.692
THE POWER OF EMINENT DOMAIN TO
02:41:42.759 --> 02:41:43.760
PURCHASE PROPERTY FOR THIS
02:41:43.827 --> 02:41:45.929
PURPOSE. WE THINK IT'S
02:41:45.996 --> 02:41:47.764
INAPPROPRIATE FOR A STATE
02:41:47.831 --> 02:41:50.000
HOUSING AGENCY TO GET INTO THE
02:41:50.067 --> 02:41:51.501
BUSINESS OF PURCHASING LOCAL
02:41:51.568 --> 02:41:53.804
PROPERTY AND GIVEN THESE LONG
02:41:53.870 --> 02:41:56.073
HISTORY OF ABUSES OF EMINENT
02:41:56.139 --> 02:41:57.407
DOMAIN, ESPECIALLY IN THE CHAIR
02:41:57.474 --> 02:41:59.409
IS CITY OF SAN FRANCISCO. WE
02:41:59.476 --> 02:42:00.577
OPPOSE THE BILL, UNLESS THAT'S
02:42:00.644 --> 02:42:05.415
TAKEN OUT. THANK YOU. ANY
02:42:05.482 --> 02:42:08.185
ADDITIONAL POSITION, COMMENTS
02:42:08.251 --> 02:42:09.853
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM, SAYING
02:42:09.920 --> 02:42:12.022
NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
02:42:12.089 --> 02:42:13.123
MODERATOR, WILL YOU PLEASE QUEUE
02:42:13.190 --> 02:42:16.359
UP OPPOSITION? THANK YOU TO
02:42:16.426 --> 02:42:19.963
EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO A B 2053.
02:42:20.030 --> 02:42:21.465
I MEAN, PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
02:42:21.531 --> 02:42:23.300
ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. THAT'S ONE
02:42:23.366 --> 02:42:24.568
AND THEN ZERO. WILL GO TO LINE 1
02:42:24.634 --> 02:42:29.473
57. EILEEN BROKEN SAN FRANCISCO
02:42:29.539 --> 02:42:37.414
OPPOSING THIS AMENDED LINE 80.
02:42:37.481 --> 02:42:38.815
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS
02:42:38.882 --> 02:42:40.283
VANESSA CHAVEZ WITH THE
02:42:40.350 --> 02:42:41.785
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
02:42:41.852 --> 02:42:43.954
REALTORS. WE HAVE A AN OPPOSED
02:42:44.020 --> 02:42:45.155
POSITION ON THE BILL FOR THE
02:42:45.222 --> 02:42:46.189
REASONS ENUMERATED IN OUR
02:42:46.256 --> 02:42:52.529
LETTER. THANK YOU. 3 24.
02:42:52.596 --> 02:42:54.364
ELIZABETH HENRY LAFAYETTE,
02:42:54.431 --> 02:42:56.700
CALIFORNIA ON BEHALF OF STABLE
02:42:56.766 --> 02:42:57.801
OFF YET LIVEABLE CALIFORNIA
02:42:57.868 --> 02:43:00.704
UNITED NEIGHBORS. STRONGLY
02:43:00.770 --> 02:43:02.706
OPPOSED 2053. IT IS A GUYS TO
02:43:02.772 --> 02:43:07.577
FORCE UH, CITIES TO CREATE BOND
02:43:07.644 --> 02:43:08.712
FUNDS TO SUBSIDIZE WEALTHY
02:43:08.778 --> 02:43:16.920
DEVELOPERS. 305. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:43:16.987 --> 02:43:18.722
. AMY SURE WITH THE COMMUNITY
02:43:18.788 --> 02:43:20.891
GROUP EIGHT, SPEAKING ON BEHALF
02:43:20.957 --> 02:43:23.727
OF EIGHT TENANTS TOGETHER POLICY
02:43:23.793 --> 02:43:26.096
LINK, COURAGE, CAMPAIGN AND THE
02:43:26.163 --> 02:43:28.865
OTHER 28 ORGANIZATIONS THAT WERE
02:43:28.932 --> 02:43:30.133
INCORRECTLY LISTED AS IN
02:43:30.200 --> 02:43:33.470
SUPPORT. WE HAVE NOT TAKEN A
02:43:33.537 --> 02:43:35.705
POSITION. EIGHTH CANNOT SUPPORT
02:43:35.772 --> 02:43:38.842
THE BILL AS CURRENTLY WRITTEN.
02:43:38.909 --> 02:43:41.545
BECAUSE IT FAILS TO PROTECT LOW
02:43:41.611 --> 02:43:43.180
INCOME COMMUNITIES OF COLOR FROM
02:43:43.246 --> 02:43:46.216
POTENTIAL INDIRECT DISPLACEMENT.
02:43:46.283 --> 02:43:48.351
AND IT IS NOT PRIORITIZING OR
02:43:48.418 --> 02:43:52.722
DOES NOT. UM COMMIT TO A
02:43:52.789 --> 02:43:54.758
PERCENTAGE OF UNITS FOR LOW
02:43:54.824 --> 02:43:57.093
INCOME FOLKS. WE NEED A STATE
02:43:57.160 --> 02:43:57.894
AGENCY, BUT WE NEEDED TO
02:43:57.961 --> 02:43:59.596
PRIORITIZE AND DO MORE FOR THE
02:43:59.663 --> 02:44:03.967
MOST VULNERABLE. THANK YOU. LYON
02:44:04.034 --> 02:44:09.773
3 83 80. HI MY NAME IS SCOTT
02:44:09.839 --> 02:44:10.674
O'NEILL. I QUEUED UP FOR
02:44:10.740 --> 02:44:12.976
SUPPORT. BUT MY CALL DROPPED, SO
02:44:13.043 --> 02:44:14.411
I GOT INTO LATE, BUT I'M CALLING
02:44:14.477 --> 02:44:18.315
THE SUPPORT. THANK YOU. NO
02:44:18.381 --> 02:44:20.383
FURTHER LINES IN QUÊ, MR. CHAIR
02:44:20.450 --> 02:44:21.985
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL BRING
02:44:22.052 --> 02:44:23.086
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
02:44:23.153 --> 02:44:24.387
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
02:44:24.454 --> 02:44:29.659
COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHOR? MR
02:44:29.726 --> 02:44:31.761
CHAIR. I'VE HAD PRETTY EXTENSIVE
02:44:31.828 --> 02:44:33.263
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR
02:44:33.330 --> 02:44:34.731
REGARDING SOME OF THE ISSUES
02:44:34.798 --> 02:44:36.566
THAT HAVE COME UP UNDER THE
02:44:36.633 --> 02:44:40.170
OPPOSITION TODAY AND I'M GOING
02:44:40.237 --> 02:44:40.770
TO BE STAYING OFF THE BILL IN
02:44:40.837 --> 02:44:42.872
COMMITTEE TODAY, BUT WITH THE
02:44:42.939 --> 02:44:44.474
HOPE THAT IN MY OWN COOPERATION
02:44:44.541 --> 02:44:46.876
AND EFFORT TO TRY TO IF THE BILL
02:44:46.943 --> 02:44:51.381
GOES FORWARD TODAY TO TRY TO GET
02:44:51.448 --> 02:44:54.184
THE AMENDMENTS NEEDED TO TAKE TO
02:44:54.251 --> 02:44:56.052
TAKE THE OPPOSITION BACK OFF THE
02:44:56.119 --> 02:44:57.887
BILL. THAT'S THE ONLY COMMENT
02:44:57.954 --> 02:44:59.356
RIGHT HERE. TANK YOU. OKAY
02:44:59.422 --> 02:45:00.690
THANK YOU. UM, AND DO WE HAVE A
02:45:00.757 --> 02:45:05.428
MOTION? ON THE BILL. EMOTION.
02:45:05.495 --> 02:45:09.899
THANK YOU, SENATOR. YES SO, UM,
02:45:09.966 --> 02:45:12.569
I WANNA COMMEND THE AUTHOR FOR
02:45:12.636 --> 02:45:14.571
TAKING ON THIS ISSUE, AND I WANT
02:45:14.638 --> 02:45:16.106
TO MAKE A FEW COMMENTS HERE
02:45:16.172 --> 02:45:17.774
FIRST OF ALL IN TERMS OF THE
02:45:17.841 --> 02:45:21.444
LABOR ISSUE. UM THIS THE DISPUTE
02:45:21.511 --> 02:45:23.146
HERE TODAY IS NOT OF THE
02:45:23.213 --> 02:45:25.115
AUTHOR'S MAKING. THE AUTHOR, AS
02:45:25.181 --> 02:45:26.149
YOU HEARD EARLIER, INTRODUCED A
02:45:26.216 --> 02:45:29.586
BILL THIS THESE ARE PUBLIC WORKS
02:45:29.653 --> 02:45:31.087
. THIS IS CALLED SOCIAL HOUSING
02:45:31.154 --> 02:45:32.922
USED TO CALL PUBLIC HOUSING IS
02:45:32.989 --> 02:45:34.324
PUBLICLY BUILT AND OWNED HOUSING
02:45:34.391 --> 02:45:38.695
PUBLIC WORKS. AS OF THE AUTHOR.
02:45:38.762 --> 02:45:40.030
INTRODUCED THE BILL WITH SKILLED
02:45:40.096 --> 02:45:42.766
WORKFORCE AND AT I SIGNED ON AS
02:45:42.832 --> 02:45:44.634
A CO AUTHOR TO THAT, AND I FULLY
02:45:44.701 --> 02:45:46.169
SUPPORTED THE INCLUSION OF THAT
02:45:46.236 --> 02:45:48.438
LANGUAGE THAT MOVED THROUGH ITS
02:45:48.505 --> 02:45:49.272
POLICY COMMITTEES IN THE
02:45:49.339 --> 02:45:50.707
ASSEMBLY. AND THEN WHEN THE BILL
02:45:50.774 --> 02:45:53.243
CAME OFF OF SUSPENSE. IN THE
02:45:53.310 --> 02:45:55.345
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. IT
02:45:55.412 --> 02:45:57.380
CAME OFF WITH THAT LANGUAGE WAS
02:45:57.447 --> 02:45:58.982
REMOVED. WE KNOW THAT THAT
02:45:59.049 --> 02:46:00.617
HAPPENS COMING FOR BILLS COMING
02:46:00.684 --> 02:46:02.285
OFFICES SPEND SOME TIME AND THE
02:46:02.352 --> 02:46:04.154
AUTHOR HAS NO CONTROL OVER IT.
02:46:04.220 --> 02:46:06.189
AND OFTEN DOESN'T EVEN KNOW IT'S
02:46:06.256 --> 02:46:08.191
HAPPENING UNTIL IT HAPPENS TO
02:46:08.258 --> 02:46:10.093
THE AUTHOR WAS PUT. I THINK IN A
02:46:10.160 --> 02:46:12.796
VERY DIFFICULT POSITION. BECAUSE
02:46:12.862 --> 02:46:14.064
COMING OVER THE SENATE AND THEN
02:46:14.130 --> 02:46:15.065
PUTTING THAT EXACT SAME
02:46:15.131 --> 02:46:17.334
LANGUAGE. BACK IN CAN BE
02:46:17.400 --> 02:46:20.370
CONSTRUED AS A JAILBREAK, AND
02:46:20.437 --> 02:46:21.104
THAT COULD BE THE DEATH WARRANT
02:46:21.171 --> 02:46:23.340
FOR THE BILL WHEN IT RETURNS AND
02:46:23.406 --> 02:46:25.642
CONCURRENCE. TO THE ASSEMBLY. IF
02:46:25.709 --> 02:46:27.243
THE SENATE INSTITUTIONALLY WOULD
02:46:27.310 --> 02:46:29.979
EVEN ALLOW THAT TO HAPPEN. SO
02:46:30.046 --> 02:46:32.449
THE AUTHOR, I THINK IN EARNEST
02:46:32.515 --> 02:46:35.819
WORKED WITH, UH, SEVERAL OF THE
02:46:35.885 --> 02:46:38.121
OF THE SUB CRAFTS THAT ARE
02:46:38.188 --> 02:46:39.489
WITHIN THE BUILDING TRADE ON
02:46:39.556 --> 02:46:41.057
THIS ALTERNATIVE LANGUAGE, WHICH
02:46:41.124 --> 02:46:42.559
I KNOW THE BUILDING TRADES DON'T
02:46:42.625 --> 02:46:44.427
SUPPORT SO I WANT TO BE VERY
02:46:44.494 --> 02:46:46.296
CLEAR THAT THE AUTHOR DID NOT
02:46:46.363 --> 02:46:47.897
CREATE THIS SITUATION. THE
02:46:47.964 --> 02:46:49.966
AUTHOR WAS PUT IN THIS SITUATION
02:46:50.033 --> 02:46:52.068
I THINK TRIED TO MAKE THE BEST
02:46:52.135 --> 02:46:55.505
OF A BAD SITUATION. UM, I AND SO
02:46:55.572 --> 02:46:57.607
I WANT TO JUST MAKE THAT REALLY
02:46:57.674 --> 02:46:59.843
CLEAR. THIS IS NOT AUTHOR WHO
02:46:59.909 --> 02:47:01.478
YOU KNOW, I DECIDED I'M GOING TO
02:47:01.544 --> 02:47:02.879
FIGHT WITH THE BUILDING TRADES
02:47:02.946 --> 02:47:04.347
ABOUT YOU KNOW ABOUT THIS ISSUE
02:47:04.414 --> 02:47:07.617
. UM AND SO I THINK THIS IS AN
02:47:07.684 --> 02:47:09.085
IMPORTANT BILL AND I WOULD LIKE
02:47:09.152 --> 02:47:11.087
TO SEE IT. MOVE OUT OF THIS
02:47:11.154 --> 02:47:13.923
COMMITTEE. I ALSO WANT TO SAY IN
02:47:13.990 --> 02:47:15.592
TERMS OF SOME OF THE OPPOSITION
02:47:15.658 --> 02:47:19.496
. UM UH, WHO ARE THE OPPOSITION
02:47:19.562 --> 02:47:21.898
? THE PEOPLE WHO ARE CALLING
02:47:21.965 --> 02:47:23.133
WITH CONCERNS BECAUSE THEY
02:47:23.199 --> 02:47:23.967
WANTED TO SEE SOME CHANGES TO
02:47:24.033 --> 02:47:25.502
LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES AND SO
02:47:25.568 --> 02:47:28.872
FORTH. UM, YOU KNOW, THIS BILL
02:47:28.938 --> 02:47:32.609
IS A IT'S LIKE A THE BEGINNING
02:47:32.675 --> 02:47:35.011
OF THE FOUNDATION. I WISH WE
02:47:35.078 --> 02:47:36.212
COULD GET SOCIAL HOUSING BUILT
02:47:36.279 --> 02:47:38.047
LIKE NEXT YEAR IN CALIFORNIA. I
02:47:38.114 --> 02:47:39.649
DON'T SEE THAT NECESSARILY
02:47:39.716 --> 02:47:41.951
HAPPENING. THIS IS A START. JUST
02:47:42.018 --> 02:47:44.487
PUTTING AN INITIAL STRUCTURE IN
02:47:44.554 --> 02:47:46.489
PLACE THAT WE CAN BUILD ON IN
02:47:46.556 --> 02:47:49.058
THE FUTURE. AND I'M GOING TO BET
02:47:49.125 --> 02:47:50.760
MY LUNCH THAT WHEN WE EVENTUALLY
02:47:50.827 --> 02:47:52.162
BUILD SOCIAL HOUSING DOWN THE
02:47:52.228 --> 02:47:54.364
ROAD IN CALIFORNIA. I BET YOU
02:47:54.431 --> 02:47:56.433
IT'S GOING TO LOOK, THINGS ARE
02:47:56.499 --> 02:47:57.667
GOING TO LOOK A LOT DIFFERENT.
02:47:57.734 --> 02:47:59.269
THEN IN THIS BILL, NOT BECAUSE
02:47:59.335 --> 02:48:01.271
THE BILLS BAD OR ANYTHING, BUT
02:48:01.337 --> 02:48:03.873
BECAUSE AS TIME GOES ON, IT'S
02:48:03.940 --> 02:48:04.741
GOING TO EVOLVE AND THERE'S
02:48:04.808 --> 02:48:06.676
GONNA BE A LOT OF VOICES
02:48:06.743 --> 02:48:08.178
INVOLVED, INCLUDING THE FOLKS
02:48:08.244 --> 02:48:09.312
WHO ARE EXPRESSING CONCERNS
02:48:09.379 --> 02:48:10.847
BECAUSE THEY WANT TO SEE CHANGES
02:48:10.914 --> 02:48:11.948
TO THE BILL. AND I THINK FOR
02:48:12.015 --> 02:48:14.150
THIS BILL NOT TO MOVE FORWARD
02:48:14.217 --> 02:48:15.985
WOULD BE A REAL SETBACK FOR OUR
02:48:16.052 --> 02:48:18.354
EFFORTS TO TRY TO GET MOMENTUM.
02:48:18.421 --> 02:48:19.556
TOWARDS SOCIAL HOUSING. SO I
02:48:19.622 --> 02:48:21.991
UNDERSTAND THE LABOR CONCERNS. I
02:48:22.058 --> 02:48:23.927
UNDERSTAND SOME OF THE CONCERNS
02:48:23.993 --> 02:48:25.562
, UH, THAT HAVE BEEN EXPRESSED
02:48:25.628 --> 02:48:27.630
FROM THE NON LABOR. UM FOLKS
02:48:27.697 --> 02:48:28.631
EXPRESSING CONCERN THAT I
02:48:28.698 --> 02:48:31.501
RESPECT ALL THOSE CONCERNS. BUT
02:48:31.568 --> 02:48:34.604
THE AUTHOR IS TRYING TO DO IN A
02:48:34.671 --> 02:48:36.206
VERY GOOD FAITH EARNEST WAY TO
02:48:36.272 --> 02:48:38.641
MOVE FORWARD THE BEGINNINGS OF A
02:48:38.708 --> 02:48:39.709
FOUNDATION AND IT WOULD BE
02:48:39.776 --> 02:48:41.711
TRAGIC IF THAT WERE TO COME TO
02:48:41.778 --> 02:48:44.481
AN END TODAY, AND SO I'M GOING
02:48:44.547 --> 02:48:45.548
TO BE VOTING I ON THIS BILL, I'M
02:48:45.615 --> 02:48:47.484
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE. ON
02:48:47.550 --> 02:48:49.118
THIS BILL, WE HAVE A MOTION BY
02:48:49.185 --> 02:48:52.856
SENATOR ROTH. AND MR LEE, YOU
02:48:52.922 --> 02:48:54.757
MAY CLOSE. WELL THERE'S A VERY
02:48:54.824 --> 02:48:55.925
REAL PUT SENATOR. I THANK YOU
02:48:55.992 --> 02:48:57.894
FOR THOSE GREAT COMMENTS AND TO
02:48:57.961 --> 02:48:58.928
RADIATE YES, THIS IS NOT A
02:48:58.995 --> 02:49:00.363
SITUATION OF MY OWN VOLUNTARY
02:49:00.430 --> 02:49:01.965
DOING.YOU KNOW, THERE'S A LOT
02:49:02.031 --> 02:49:03.032
OF INTERESTING LEGISLATIVE
02:49:03.099 --> 02:49:04.133
THINGS THAT CAN HAPPEN DURING
02:49:04.200 --> 02:49:05.902
THE PROCESS. BUT I ALSO WANT TO
02:49:05.969 --> 02:49:06.736
SAY THAT YOU KNOW, WHEN IWAS
02:49:06.803 --> 02:49:09.439
LOCKED IN 2020. I HAD THIS AS AN
02:49:09.506 --> 02:49:11.040
IDEA. AND I STARTED THIS BILL
02:49:11.107 --> 02:49:12.575
ESSENTIALLY FROM SCRATCH. I
02:49:12.642 --> 02:49:13.142
REACHED OUT TO THE BUILDING
02:49:13.209 --> 02:49:14.878
TRADES. I REACHED OUT TO OUR
02:49:14.944 --> 02:49:17.380
FOCUS ON OUR FRIENDS IN LABOR
02:49:17.447 --> 02:49:17.947
FOLKS CHATTER, FOLKS THAT
02:49:18.014 --> 02:49:18.715
HOUSING HOUSING ADVOCATES WAS
02:49:18.781 --> 02:49:20.083
JUST ADVOCATES AND I SAID WHAT
02:49:20.149 --> 02:49:20.884
ARE YOUR IDEAS ABOUT THIS
02:49:20.950 --> 02:49:21.784
TOGETHER BECAUSE IT WAS A
02:49:21.851 --> 02:49:24.053
CONCEPT WE HAVE NOT EVER IN
02:49:24.120 --> 02:49:24.954
CALIFORNIA HAD OBVIOUSLY SOCIAL
02:49:25.021 --> 02:49:26.155
HOUSING BILL OR EVEN A SELECT
02:49:26.222 --> 02:49:27.524
COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL HOUSING,
02:49:27.590 --> 02:49:29.392
WHICH I NOW CHAIR UNTIL
02:49:29.459 --> 02:49:30.560
RECENTLY. THESE ARE ALL SLIGHTLY
02:49:30.627 --> 02:49:31.661
NEW THINGS, BUT REALLY THEY'RE
02:49:31.728 --> 02:49:33.496
ADAPTING. WHAT ARE SUCCESSFUL
02:49:33.563 --> 02:49:35.532
MODELS IN OUR GLOBAL PEERS IN
02:49:35.598 --> 02:49:37.200
EUROPE AND IN ASIA, THEY HAVE
02:49:37.267 --> 02:49:38.201
BEEN DOING PUBLIC HOUSING OR
02:49:38.268 --> 02:49:38.902
SOCIAL HOUSING, MUNICIPAL
02:49:38.968 --> 02:49:40.970
HOUSING, WHATEVER THEY CALL IT
02:49:41.037 --> 02:49:42.705
FOR, WELL OVER 100 YEARS, AND IT
02:49:42.772 --> 02:49:45.575
IS A POLICY CHOICES THAT THEY
02:49:45.642 --> 02:49:46.776
HAVE MADE ALONG THE WAY THAT
02:49:46.843 --> 02:49:47.744
HAVE PAID FOR US A PATH TO DO
02:49:47.810 --> 02:49:49.812
IT. AND CERTAINLY JUST LIKE A
02:49:49.879 --> 02:49:51.781
LOT OF BILLS YOU HEARD TODAY AND
02:49:51.848 --> 02:49:53.716
THOSE ARE GOING TO BE HEARING
02:49:53.783 --> 02:49:55.118
TODAY LIKE THIS VOTE, TOO. VOTE
02:49:55.184 --> 02:49:56.853
FOR THIS BILL TODAY IS TO
02:49:56.920 --> 02:49:58.388
CONTINUE THAT CONVERSATION. IT
02:49:58.454 --> 02:49:59.522
IS MY STRONGEST INTENT TO HAVE
02:49:59.589 --> 02:50:01.591
UNIONIZED WORKFORCE BUILD. THE
02:50:01.658 --> 02:50:03.126
DEVELOPMENT OF THE FUTURE OF
02:50:03.192 --> 02:50:03.860
SOCIAL HOUSING BECAUSE WE WANT
02:50:03.927 --> 02:50:05.628
TO BUILD QUALITY. WANT TO MAKE
02:50:05.695 --> 02:50:07.096
SURE THESE THINGS ARE BUILT TO
02:50:07.163 --> 02:50:09.132
LAST ARE SAFER FOR FOLKS AND
02:50:09.198 --> 02:50:10.199
ESPECIALLY AS POSSIBLY THERE WAS
02:50:10.266 --> 02:50:11.701
A RECESSION LOOMING. AND THE
02:50:11.768 --> 02:50:13.069
LAST TIME THERE WAS A SESSION,
02:50:13.136 --> 02:50:14.137
PRIVATE HOUSING PRODUCTION
02:50:14.203 --> 02:50:15.905
PLUMMETED PLUMMETED BECAUSE THAT
02:50:15.972 --> 02:50:17.373
IS THE PROBLEM ESSENTIALLY WHEN
02:50:17.440 --> 02:50:18.808
WE RELY ON PRIVATE CAPITAL AND
02:50:18.875 --> 02:50:20.343
PRIVATE PRODUCTION THAT GOES
02:50:20.410 --> 02:50:21.844
WITH THE ABSENT FLOWS OF THE
02:50:21.911 --> 02:50:23.613
MARKET IF WE ARE ABLE TO HAVE A
02:50:23.680 --> 02:50:24.514
STABLE SOCIAL HOUSING,
02:50:24.581 --> 02:50:26.249
PRODUCTION AND EVEN
02:50:26.316 --> 02:50:28.785
PRESERVATION, JUST LIKE IN OUR
02:50:28.851 --> 02:50:29.485
DEVELOPED PEERS, THEY CAN
02:50:29.552 --> 02:50:30.820
WEATHER THOSE STORMS WHEN WE
02:50:30.887 --> 02:50:32.155
NEED AFFORDABLE HOUSING THE MOST
02:50:32.221 --> 02:50:33.756
SOCIAL HOUSING CAN BE THERE. AND
02:50:33.823 --> 02:50:35.325
BECAUSE THESE THINGS TAKE TIME,
02:50:35.391 --> 02:50:35.925
AND THESE THINGS COULD TAKE
02:50:35.992 --> 02:50:37.927
YEARS. WE NEED TO GET A START AS
02:50:37.994 --> 02:50:39.028
SOON AS POSSIBLE. I WANT TO
02:50:39.095 --> 02:50:40.930
PROTECT UNION JOBS. I WANT TO
02:50:40.997 --> 02:50:42.065
PROTECT PEOPLE, HOMES. I WANT TO
02:50:42.131 --> 02:50:43.933
MAKE SURE PEOPLE HAVE THE
02:50:44.000 --> 02:50:45.034
ABILITY TO CALL CALIFORNIA HOME
02:50:45.101 --> 02:50:47.070
AND WE NEED TO HAVE THIS FIRST
02:50:47.136 --> 02:50:48.037
MAJOR STEP AND SAID THE
02:50:48.104 --> 02:50:48.905
FOUNDATION FOR SOCIAL HOUSING
02:50:48.972 --> 02:50:50.006
CALIFORNIA SO TODAY I
02:50:50.073 --> 02:50:51.541
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I VOTE SO I
02:50:51.608 --> 02:50:53.042
CAN CONTINUE WORKING ON THIS AND
02:50:53.109 --> 02:50:55.411
IS GOING TO GO TO ANOTHER
02:50:55.478 --> 02:50:56.546
COMMITTEE AFTER THIS IF IT WERE
02:50:56.613 --> 02:50:57.647
TO PASS OUT OF HOUSING TODAY, SO
02:50:57.714 --> 02:50:59.582
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:50:59.649 --> 02:51:00.950
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR ROTH
02:51:01.017 --> 02:51:03.386
AND WE WILL CALL THE ROLL. THIS
02:51:03.453 --> 02:51:03.953
IS SOMETHING BUILT 2053 BY
02:51:04.020 --> 02:51:05.555
SOMETHING, BEVERLY. THE MOTION
02:51:05.622 --> 02:51:07.123
IS DUE PASS. BUT FIRST, HE
02:51:07.190 --> 02:51:08.024
REFERRED THE COMMITTEE ON
02:51:08.091 --> 02:51:08.992
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. SENATOR
02:51:09.058 --> 02:51:11.561
WIENER. AYE. BATES BATES, NO,
02:51:11.628 --> 02:51:14.631
CABALLERO. ORTEZ. MCGUIRE PHð
02:51:14.697 --> 02:51:19.969
CABALLERO. ORTEZ. MCGUIRE PHð-BUG. ROSS ROUGH I. SKINNER
02:51:20.036 --> 02:51:24.407
SKINNER I HAMBURG. OKAY WE'LL
02:51:24.474 --> 02:51:27.410
PUT THAT ON CALL. UM I HAVE TO
02:51:27.477 --> 02:51:28.845
GO TO ASSEMBLY HEALTH COMMITTEE
02:51:28.911 --> 02:51:30.513
TO PRESENT A BILL AND SO I WILL
02:51:30.580 --> 02:51:31.714
HAND THE GAVEL OVER TO THE VICE
02:51:31.781 --> 02:51:36.586
CHAIR. I'LL BE BACK SHORTLY. AND
02:51:36.653 --> 02:51:40.890
NEXT WILL DO TO BOTH OF SOME OF
02:51:40.957 --> 02:51:42.358
THEM WERE SANTIAGO'S BILL 16, 95
02:51:42.425 --> 02:51:47.296
AND 26 53. FOLLOWED BY SOME
02:51:47.363 --> 02:51:48.631
MEMBER FRIEDMAN AND THEN
02:51:48.698 --> 02:51:49.265
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA BE
02:51:49.332 --> 02:51:58.641
BRIEF. NO, YOU'RE FINE. WITH THE
02:51:58.708 --> 02:52:00.276
CHAIR. BE OKAY IF I START OFF
02:52:00.343 --> 02:52:03.146
WITH FILE ITEM FOUR. THANKS
02:52:03.212 --> 02:52:06.015
THANK YOU. CHAIR MEMBERS. A B 16
02:52:06.082 --> 02:52:07.083
95 WOULD ENCOURAGE THE
02:52:07.150 --> 02:52:08.084
PRODUCTION OF COST EFFECTIVE
02:52:08.151 --> 02:52:09.519
HOUSING THAT IS AFFORDABLE TO
02:52:09.585 --> 02:52:10.687
LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS.
02:52:10.753 --> 02:52:11.688
SPECIFICALLY THIS BILL WOULD
02:52:11.754 --> 02:52:13.423
RECORD THAT ANY NOTICE OF
02:52:13.489 --> 02:52:15.358
FUNDING OF IT. AVAILABILITY FOR
02:52:15.425 --> 02:52:16.359
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, MULTI FAMILY
02:52:16.426 --> 02:52:17.660
HOUSING LOAN AND GRANT PROGRAMS
02:52:17.727 --> 02:52:21.531
TO STATE. BE USED FOR ADAPTED
02:52:21.597 --> 02:52:22.832
SORRY. BE ELIGIBLE FOR ADAPTIVE
02:52:22.899 --> 02:52:25.635
REUSE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
02:52:25.702 --> 02:52:27.503
CALIFORNIA'S HOME TO ABOUT A
02:52:27.570 --> 02:52:28.638
QUARTER OF THE HOMELESS
02:52:28.705 --> 02:52:29.639
POPULATION IN OUR NATION,
02:52:29.706 --> 02:52:31.174
NUMBERING OVER 101, 161,000
02:52:31.240 --> 02:52:35.178
FAMILIES AND INDIVIDUAL. SO WE
02:52:35.244 --> 02:52:36.879
BELIEVE IT IS VITAL FOR ADAPTIVE
02:52:36.946 --> 02:52:38.114
REUSE TO BECOME FREQUENTLY A
02:52:38.181 --> 02:52:39.782
FREQUENTLY USED TOOL FOR AN
02:52:39.849 --> 02:52:41.417
ONGOING LOAN AND GRANT HOUSING
02:52:41.484 --> 02:52:42.118
PROGRAMS ADMINISTERED BY THE
02:52:42.185 --> 02:52:43.252
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
02:52:43.319 --> 02:52:44.220
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT TO ADDRESS
02:52:44.287 --> 02:52:45.822
THE INCREASING COST OF BUILDING
02:52:45.888 --> 02:52:50.660
HOUSING. AH WITH ME. I HAVE AND
02:52:50.727 --> 02:52:52.695
, UH, RESPECTFULLY TO ASK FOR MY
02:52:52.762 --> 02:52:54.931
VOTE WITH ME. I HAVE ONE WITNESS
02:52:54.997 --> 02:52:56.199
RAND MARTIN FROM THE HEALTH CARE
02:52:56.265 --> 02:52:58.201
FOUNDATION. THANK YOU GONNA TAKE
02:52:58.267 --> 02:52:59.302
MY MASK OFF? THAT'S OKAY,
02:52:59.368 --> 02:53:01.170
BECAUSE IT'S STICKING TO ME.
02:53:01.237 --> 02:53:02.638
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS RAND
02:53:02.705 --> 02:53:04.073
MARTIN ON BEHALF OF THE AIDS
02:53:04.140 --> 02:53:04.907
HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION AND HIS
02:53:04.974 --> 02:53:06.576
HEALTHY HOUSING FOUNDATION
02:53:06.642 --> 02:53:07.977
DIVISION. OVER LAST FIVE YEARS
02:53:08.044 --> 02:53:09.846
AGE F HAS DEVELOPED 13 PROJECTS
02:53:09.912 --> 02:53:10.747
IN THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES.
02:53:10.813 --> 02:53:14.317
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. WITH OVER
02:53:14.383 --> 02:53:15.585
1400 UNITS FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE
02:53:15.651 --> 02:53:17.420
EXTREMELY AND VERY LOW INCOME.
02:53:17.487 --> 02:53:18.654
WE HAVE DONE IT ALL THROUGH
02:53:18.721 --> 02:53:21.023
ADAPTIVE REUSE, WHICH HAS BEEN
02:53:21.090 --> 02:53:22.091
THE REHABILITATION AND
02:53:22.158 --> 02:53:23.159
REPURPOSING OF HOTELS AND
02:53:23.226 --> 02:53:26.662
MOTELS. FROM SKID ROW ALL THE
02:53:26.729 --> 02:53:28.131
WAY OUT TO THE VALLEY. UM
02:53:28.197 --> 02:53:30.032
SOMETHING WE WANT TO DO IN THE
02:53:30.099 --> 02:53:31.501
REST OF THE STATE AS WELL. BUT
02:53:31.567 --> 02:53:32.869
WE'VE STARTED IN OUR HOME OUR
02:53:32.935 --> 02:53:35.071
HOME COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES. WHAT
02:53:35.138 --> 02:53:35.905
WE HAVE FOUND OVER THE YEARS IS
02:53:35.972 --> 02:53:37.607
THAT THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAS
02:53:37.673 --> 02:53:40.009
NOT HAD AS ROBUST AND ATTENTION
02:53:40.076 --> 02:53:41.010
TO ADAPTIVE REUSE AS AN
02:53:41.077 --> 02:53:43.579
APPROPRIATE POLICY. RELATIVE TO
02:53:43.646 --> 02:53:45.248
WHICH FUNDING OF LOANS AND
02:53:45.314 --> 02:53:46.682
GRANTS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:53:46.749 --> 02:53:48.284
DEVELOPMENT. AND WHILE THE
02:53:48.351 --> 02:53:49.585
ADMINISTRATION RECENTLY HAS
02:53:49.652 --> 02:53:51.888
TAKEN A MORE ROBUST POSITION
02:53:51.954 --> 02:53:53.289
RELATIVE TO ADAPTIVE REUSE, WE
02:53:53.356 --> 02:53:54.457
THINK IT'S APPROPRIATE TO PUT
02:53:54.524 --> 02:53:56.793
SOMETHING INTO THE DEPARTMENT OF
02:53:56.859 --> 02:53:58.060
HOSING COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
02:53:58.127 --> 02:53:59.829
POLICIES THAT SAYS THAT ADAPTIVE
02:53:59.896 --> 02:54:02.899
REUSE ISN'T APPROPRIATE USE OF
02:54:02.965 --> 02:54:04.500
LOANS AND GRANTS FOR MULTI
02:54:04.567 --> 02:54:06.035
FAMILY HOUSING. AND THAT'S WHAT
02:54:06.102 --> 02:54:06.903
THIS BILL WOULD DO VERY SIMPLY,
02:54:06.969 --> 02:54:08.905
AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT
02:54:08.971 --> 02:54:10.406
FOR THE BILL TODAY. THANK YOU.
02:54:10.473 --> 02:54:11.774
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY OR
02:54:11.841 --> 02:54:14.076
ANYONE ELSE HERE IN THIS ROOM
02:54:14.143 --> 02:54:15.178
WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY AND
02:54:15.244 --> 02:54:19.649
SUPPORT OF A B 16 95. IMBERT
02:54:19.715 --> 02:54:20.850
MADISON FROM THE CALIFORNIA
02:54:20.917 --> 02:54:21.651
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION AND
02:54:21.717 --> 02:54:27.023
SUPPORT. COREY SMITH WITH THE
02:54:27.089 --> 02:54:28.024
HOUSING ACTION COALITION AND
02:54:28.090 --> 02:54:34.330
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. MADAM. CHAIR
02:54:34.397 --> 02:54:35.665
JEREMY SMITH, HERE ON BEHALF OF
02:54:35.731 --> 02:54:36.833
THE STATE BUILDING AND
02:54:36.899 --> 02:54:37.867
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL WERE
02:54:37.934 --> 02:54:40.136
IN A TWEENER POSITION. I HOPE
02:54:40.203 --> 02:54:41.504
IT'S OKAY IF I DO THIS RIGHT NOW
02:54:41.571 --> 02:54:42.672
WE HAVE NEGOTIATED AND SPOKE TO
02:54:42.738 --> 02:54:43.773
MR SANTIAGO, SEPTEMBER SANTIAGO
02:54:43.840 --> 02:54:45.708
LAST YEAR OVER THIS OTHER BILL.
02:54:45.775 --> 02:54:47.243
AND WE'VE TALKED TO THE SPONSORS
02:54:47.310 --> 02:54:49.011
OF THIS BILL TODAY AS LATE AS
02:54:49.078 --> 02:54:52.315
TODAY AND EARLIER LAST WEEK, UM
02:54:52.381 --> 02:54:53.749
WE KNOW THIS IS A WORK IN
02:54:53.816 --> 02:54:55.551
PROGRESS. WE LOOK FORWARD TO
02:54:55.618 --> 02:54:56.319
ENGAGING IN THE CONVERSATIONS
02:54:56.385 --> 02:54:57.620
ABOUT ADAPTIVE REUSE, WHICH WE
02:54:57.687 --> 02:54:59.121
THINK IS A GOOD IDEA AND
02:54:59.188 --> 02:54:59.956
ENSURING THAT THE WORKERS THAT
02:55:00.022 --> 02:55:02.491
MIGHT BE DOING THE WORK ON THE
02:55:02.558 --> 02:55:04.126
DEPTH OF REUSE PROJECTS THAT ARE
02:55:04.193 --> 02:55:04.727
FUNDED THROUGH THE STATE. ARE
02:55:04.794 --> 02:55:06.562
PROTECTED IN WAYS THAT I KNOW
02:55:06.629 --> 02:55:08.097
THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER AGREES WITH
02:55:08.164 --> 02:55:10.166
AND THE SPONSORS AGREE WITH, UM
02:55:10.233 --> 02:55:10.733
SO WE'RE NOT HEARING SUPPORT
02:55:10.800 --> 02:55:11.801
OPPOSITION TODAY WE'RE TWEENER,
02:55:11.868 --> 02:55:13.736
BUT JUST WANTED TO GET OUR
02:55:13.803 --> 02:55:14.837
THOUGHTS ON THE RECORD. THANK
02:55:14.904 --> 02:55:17.907
YOU. THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE? AND
02:55:17.974 --> 02:55:20.443
I DON'T SEE THAT THERE'S A LEAD
02:55:20.509 --> 02:55:22.178
OPPOSITION, SO WE'LL GO TO THIS
02:55:22.245 --> 02:55:23.679
ROOM AS ANYONE PRESENT WHO WOULD
02:55:23.746 --> 02:55:25.248
LIKE TO OPPOSE HE CAN OPPOSITION
02:55:25.314 --> 02:55:31.187
TO A B 16 95. SEE ANYBODY.
02:55:31.254 --> 02:55:32.455
DEANNA WILL GO TO THE PHONES AND
02:55:32.521 --> 02:55:38.194
SEE SORRY. AND WE GO TO THE
02:55:38.261 --> 02:55:39.195
PHONES FOR SUPPORT. I'M SORRY I
02:55:39.262 --> 02:55:41.564
SKIPPED OVER THAT. ANYONE WHO IS
02:55:41.631 --> 02:55:42.932
ON TELECONFERENCE THAT WOULD
02:55:42.999 --> 02:55:44.200
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT, MR
02:55:44.267 --> 02:55:45.668
MODERATOR. ANYONE QUEUING UP.
02:55:45.735 --> 02:55:50.706
THANK YOU. IF YOU'D LIKE TO
02:55:50.773 --> 02:55:51.941
EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THE BILL,
02:55:52.008 --> 02:55:53.709
YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
02:55:53.776 --> 02:55:54.944
DO HAVE TWO LINES IN Q VERSUS
02:55:55.011 --> 02:56:03.552
LINE, 88 OH, IT'S ZERO. DID YOU
02:56:03.619 --> 02:56:05.454
HAVE A POSITION OF SUPPORT FOR
02:56:05.521 --> 02:56:08.691
THIS BILL? SORRY I'M GONNA
02:56:08.758 --> 02:56:09.692
POSITION OF OPPOSING WAS
02:56:09.759 --> 02:56:20.569
COMMANDED. THANK YOU. MADAM
02:56:20.636 --> 02:56:21.904
CHAIR. WE DO HAVE ANOTHER LINE.
02:56:21.971 --> 02:56:23.539
IT'S LINE 1 29. YOUR LINE IS
02:56:23.606 --> 02:56:27.743
OPEN. THIS IS RICK HALL WITH
02:56:27.810 --> 02:56:29.979
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
02:56:30.046 --> 02:56:36.018
AND FINALLY TO 24. SARAH
02:56:36.085 --> 02:56:36.485
OGILVY'S FROM OAKLAND,
02:56:36.552 --> 02:56:40.723
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. NO
02:56:40.790 --> 02:56:41.824
FURTHER LINES IN QUEUE FOR
02:56:41.891 --> 02:56:45.394
SUPPORT. VERY GOOD. I DID NOT
02:56:45.461 --> 02:56:47.630
SEE ANYONE COME FORWARD WHEN I
02:56:47.697 --> 02:56:49.799
CALLED OPPOSITION OUT OF ORDER.
02:56:49.865 --> 02:56:51.600
THERE'S NO ONE IN THIS ROOM THAT
02:56:51.667 --> 02:56:53.369
WHICH IS TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
02:56:53.436 --> 02:56:55.438
THEN WE WILL GO TO THE PHONES,
02:56:55.504 --> 02:56:57.173
MR MODERATOR AND PLEASE QUEUE UP
02:56:57.239 --> 02:56:59.008
ANY OF THOSE WHO ARE ON THE
02:56:59.075 --> 02:57:01.310
PHONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:57:01.377 --> 02:57:04.280
OPPOSITION. TO A B 16 95. IF
02:57:04.347 --> 02:57:05.648
YOU'D LIKE TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION
02:57:05.715 --> 02:57:06.782
TO THIS BUILDING MAY PRESS ONE,
02:57:06.849 --> 02:57:09.085
FOLLOWED BY ZERO AND WE'LL GO TO
02:57:09.151 --> 02:57:13.422
LINE 3 71. HELLO MY NAME IS
02:57:13.489 --> 02:57:15.624
MAILING STEPHAN, RESIDENT OF
02:57:15.691 --> 02:57:17.193
SUNNYVALE, ACTUALLY IN SUPPORT
02:57:17.259 --> 02:57:20.730
OF THE BILL. THINK YOU WILL GO
02:57:20.796 --> 02:57:24.300
TO LINE 80. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
02:57:24.367 --> 02:57:26.102
AND MEMBERS CHÁVEZ WITH THE
02:57:26.168 --> 02:57:27.169
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
02:57:27.236 --> 02:57:29.138
REALTORS. WE HAVEN'T OPPOSED
02:57:29.205 --> 02:57:30.740
COMMENDED POSITION ON THE BILL
02:57:30.806 --> 02:57:32.475
UNTIL IT IS AMENDED TO INCLUDE
02:57:32.541 --> 02:57:33.676
BOTH RENTAL AND OWNERSHIP
02:57:33.743 --> 02:57:37.380
HOUSING. THANK YOU. BILL FOR
02:57:37.446 --> 02:57:39.749
THEIR LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME
02:57:39.815 --> 02:57:41.117
WILL BRING IT BACK TO THE
02:57:41.183 --> 02:57:42.818
DIOCESE TO ANY COMMENTS FROM
02:57:42.885 --> 02:57:44.020
MEMBERS LIKE TO ASK A QUESTION
02:57:44.086 --> 02:57:48.491
OR. MANAGER QUESTIONS. YES THANK
02:57:48.557 --> 02:57:50.226
YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I'M GOIG TO
02:57:50.292 --> 02:57:52.528
BE SUPPORTING THE BILL. A
02:57:52.595 --> 02:57:54.797
RESPECT WHAT I HEARD FROM THE
02:57:54.864 --> 02:57:56.332
OPPOSITION. I JUST THINK THAT'S
02:57:56.399 --> 02:57:57.733
PROBABLY A DIFFERENT BILL RIGHT
02:57:57.800 --> 02:57:59.702
NOW, AND THIS IS FOCUSED ON ONE
02:57:59.769 --> 02:58:00.903
PARTICULAR AREA OF HOUSING, AND
02:58:00.970 --> 02:58:02.905
I'D BE HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL
02:58:02.972 --> 02:58:05.674
WITH THE APPROPRIATE TIME. MANY
02:58:05.741 --> 02:58:07.977
OTHERS. AND WE'LL TAKE THAT AS A
02:58:08.044 --> 02:58:09.612
MOTION AND THEY WILL GO BACK TO,
02:58:09.678 --> 02:58:11.080
UH, SOMEBODY MEMBERS. SANTIAGO,
02:58:11.147 --> 02:58:13.949
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? YES AND
02:58:14.016 --> 02:58:15.051
I DO WANNA ADDRESS THAT. THE
02:58:15.117 --> 02:58:16.685
REASON WE DIDN'T PUT IT IN THERE
02:58:16.752 --> 02:58:19.155
IS BECAUSE THE DOLLARS FROM OUR
02:58:19.221 --> 02:58:20.289
UNDERSTANDING FROM H CD. R FOR
02:58:20.356 --> 02:58:22.992
RENTAL UNITS. THE REMEMBER HAPPY
02:58:23.059 --> 02:58:24.026
TO PUT THE AMENDMENT IN THERE,
02:58:24.093 --> 02:58:26.062
BUT IT WOULD MAKE NO SENSE
02:58:26.128 --> 02:58:26.962
BECAUSE MY UNDERSTANDING IS, UH
02:58:27.029 --> 02:58:30.266
IF THE DOLLARS ARE MEANT FOR
02:58:30.332 --> 02:58:31.367
RENTAL THAN THOSE DOLLARS
02:58:31.434 --> 02:58:31.967
WOULDN'T BE ELIGIBLE FOR UNITS
02:58:32.034 --> 02:58:34.336
THAT ARE FOR SALE, AND THAT'S
02:58:34.403 --> 02:58:35.137
REALLY THE ISSUE HAVE NO PROBLEM
02:58:35.204 --> 02:58:37.339
PHILOSOPHICALLY WITH THE SALE OF
02:58:37.406 --> 02:58:39.542
UNIT THAT'S NOT WHAT THE DOLLARS
02:58:39.608 --> 02:58:40.076
ARE ALLOCATED FOR FROM MY
02:58:40.142 --> 02:58:40.776
UNDERSTANDING, BUT HCG THAT
02:58:40.843 --> 02:58:43.112
REALLY IS JUST IT. UM TÌM
02:58:43.179 --> 02:58:44.180
RESPECTFULLY WOULD ASK FOR MY
02:58:44.246 --> 02:58:47.283
VOTE. THANK YOU, MAN. NOW WE'LL
02:58:47.349 --> 02:58:52.021
HAVE THE R CONSULTANT COLORABLE.
02:58:52.088 --> 02:58:55.224
THIS IS A FAMILY BILL 16 95 BY
02:58:55.291 --> 02:58:55.858
SOME MEMBER SANTIAGO. THE MOTION
02:58:55.925 --> 02:58:57.493
IS DUE PASS. BUT FIRST WE
02:58:57.560 --> 02:58:58.561
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:58:58.627 --> 02:58:59.662
APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WIENER.
02:58:59.728 --> 02:59:00.996
BATES. NOT VOTING. CABALLERO
02:59:01.063 --> 02:59:04.834
CORTEZ E. ORTEZ AYE MCGUIRE PHð
02:59:04.900 --> 02:59:08.304
CORTEZ E. ORTEZ AYE MCGUIRE PHð-BUG ROSS BROTH. I SKINNER
02:59:08.370 --> 02:59:12.475
SKINNER I HAMBURG. FAMILY.
02:59:12.541 --> 02:59:19.348
SORRY. OKAY, THEN WE'LL PUT THAT
02:59:19.415 --> 02:59:20.616
BEALL ON CALL TOLD THEIR MEMBERS
02:59:20.683 --> 02:59:23.919
ARRIVED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
02:59:23.986 --> 02:59:24.987
MADAM CHAIRMAN PROCEED ON THE
02:59:25.054 --> 02:59:27.857
SECOND BILL. THANK YOU KNOW, I'D
02:59:27.923 --> 02:59:30.392
LIKE TO PRESENT ON A B 26 53
02:59:30.459 --> 02:59:32.394
THAT WOULD ALLOW A TV TO REJECT
02:59:32.461 --> 02:59:33.996
THE ANNUAL PLANNING REPORTS IF
02:59:34.063 --> 02:59:35.431
THERE ARE NOT SUBSTANTIALLY
02:59:35.498 --> 02:59:36.232
COMPLIANT WITH THE REQUIREMENTS
02:59:36.298 --> 02:59:39.001
OF LAW, UH, SO THE 18 COULD DO
02:59:39.068 --> 02:59:40.703
SO THEY WOULD NEED TO PROVIDE
02:59:40.769 --> 02:59:41.971
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT IN WRITING
02:59:42.037 --> 02:59:43.139
FOR THE REASONS THAT REPORTED
02:59:43.205 --> 02:59:44.406
INCONSISTENT. CURRENTLY THEY
02:59:44.473 --> 02:59:46.342
DON'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO
02:59:46.408 --> 02:59:47.810
THAT THEY RECEIVED A REPORT.
02:59:47.877 --> 02:59:50.346
THEY CAN'T DEEM IT NOT COMPLIANT
02:59:50.412 --> 02:59:52.348
AND WHAT THIS WOULD DO IF THEY
02:59:52.414 --> 02:59:53.716
COULD DEEM IT IN COMPLIANCE,
02:59:53.782 --> 02:59:55.417
ALLOW CITIES AND MUNICIPALITIES
02:59:55.484 --> 02:59:56.485
TO RECEIVE INFORMATION BACK AS
02:59:56.552 --> 02:59:58.921
TO WHY THEY'RE NOT COMPLIANT.
02:59:58.988 --> 03:00:00.823
AND IT WILL BE WILL BE ABLE TO
03:00:00.890 --> 03:00:02.358
TRAVEL WOULD BE ABLE TO TRACK
03:00:02.424 --> 03:00:03.859
THEIR PROGRESS AND THEIR
03:00:03.926 --> 03:00:04.860
IMPLEMENTATION. THEIR HOUSING
03:00:04.927 --> 03:00:08.063
ELEMENTS. UM UH AND, UH, THIS
03:00:08.130 --> 03:00:09.198
BILL'S AUTHOR SPONSORS. THANK
03:00:09.265 --> 03:00:12.935
YOU. AND RESPECTFULLY AS WHEN I
03:00:13.002 --> 03:00:15.004
VOTE WITH ME. WE HAVE IN PERSON,
03:00:15.070 --> 03:00:17.139
MARINA WYATT. FROM THE
03:00:17.206 --> 03:00:18.541
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM
03:00:18.607 --> 03:00:19.808
AHEAD. I'M CHEER AGAIN, SO GO
03:00:19.875 --> 03:00:21.343
AHEAD, MARINA. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:00:21.410 --> 03:00:22.311
MARINA. WHY IT WITH THE
03:00:22.378 --> 03:00:25.548
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM.
03:00:25.614 --> 03:00:27.716
AS PART OF THE HOUSING ELEMENT
03:00:27.783 --> 03:00:28.217
APPROVAL PROCESS, LOCAL
03:00:28.284 --> 03:00:29.285
GOVERNMENTS ARE REQUIRED TO
03:00:29.351 --> 03:00:30.686
SUBMIT A REPORT ANNUALLY
03:00:30.753 --> 03:00:31.787
DETAILING THEIR PROGRESS ON
03:00:31.854 --> 03:00:32.888
IMPLEMENTATION INCLUDED IN THE
03:00:32.955 --> 03:00:36.258
REPORT. IS ALSO A RANGE OF
03:00:36.325 --> 03:00:37.726
INFORMATION ABOUT THE STATUS OF
03:00:37.793 --> 03:00:38.561
PROPOSED HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS
03:00:38.627 --> 03:00:40.796
WITHIN THE JURISDICTION. A PRS
03:00:40.863 --> 03:00:42.264
FROM THE STATES, CITIES AND
03:00:42.331 --> 03:00:44.400
COUNTIES SERVE AS A CRUCIAL TOOL
03:00:44.466 --> 03:00:44.967
IN HIGHLIGHTING DEVELOPMENT
03:00:45.034 --> 03:00:45.768
TRENDS AND INFORMING POLICY
03:00:45.834 --> 03:00:48.103
MAKING. HOWEVER HCG DOES NOT
03:00:48.170 --> 03:00:49.438
HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO REJECT A
03:00:49.505 --> 03:00:50.940
PRS THAT ARE INCOMPLETE OR
03:00:51.006 --> 03:00:54.276
SUBSTANDARD, AND THIS BILL WOULD
03:00:54.343 --> 03:00:54.944
IMPROVE THIS DATA COLLECTION AND
03:00:55.010 --> 03:00:56.312
STATE OVERSIGHT. UM BY DOING
03:00:56.378 --> 03:00:57.880
THAT, AND SO, FOR THOSE REASONS,
03:00:57.947 --> 03:01:00.382
I URGE YOUR SUPPORT TODAY. THANK
03:01:00.449 --> 03:01:01.317
YOU. DID YOU HAVE ANOTHER
03:01:01.383 --> 03:01:04.286
PRIMARY WITNESSES? OKAY GREAT.
03:01:04.353 --> 03:01:05.854
LET'S SEE. IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN
03:01:05.921 --> 03:01:07.056
THE ROOM AND SUPPORT OF THIS
03:01:07.122 --> 03:01:08.991
BILL. YOU CAN COME UP FOR THE ME
03:01:09.058 --> 03:01:10.859
TOO. ANYONE IN THE ROOM SEEING
03:01:10.926 --> 03:01:12.761
NONE. TELEPHONE MODERATOR,
03:01:12.828 --> 03:01:14.763
PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE ON THE
03:01:14.830 --> 03:01:19.268
PHONES AND SUPPORT OF A B 16 95.
03:01:19.335 --> 03:01:22.004
NOR DO I GET THE WRONG SAID THE
03:01:22.071 --> 03:01:24.940
RIGHT SECOND. YEAH, I SAID THE
03:01:25.007 --> 03:01:29.812
WRONG NUMBER 26 59 53. TO
03:01:29.878 --> 03:01:31.847
EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL.
03:01:31.914 --> 03:01:33.916
PRESS ONE FOLLOWED BY ZERO ON
03:01:33.983 --> 03:01:36.318
YOUR TELEPHONE. WE HAVE LION 1
03:01:36.385 --> 03:01:40.189
98. GOOD AFTERNOON ON BEHALF OF
03:01:40.256 --> 03:01:41.624
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW, POVERTY
03:01:41.690 --> 03:01:45.961
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
03:01:46.028 --> 03:01:48.631
NO FURTHER LINES IN. Q OKAY,
03:01:48.697 --> 03:01:52.301
GREAT. UM LET'S HAVE, UH I
03:01:52.368 --> 03:01:54.503
DIDN'T SEE THAT YOU HAD ANY KEY
03:01:54.570 --> 03:01:59.708
OPPOSITION. NO SO WE HAVE NO
03:01:59.775 --> 03:02:02.011
LEAD OPPOSITION. SO LET ME SEE
03:02:02.077 --> 03:02:02.845
IF THERE'S ANYONE IN OPPOSITION
03:02:02.911 --> 03:02:07.116
TO A B 26 53 IN THE ROOM.
03:02:07.182 --> 03:02:09.351
ALRIGHT MODERATOR, COULD YOU SEE
03:02:09.418 --> 03:02:10.719
IF THERE'S ANYONE ON THE PHONE
03:02:10.786 --> 03:02:12.621
LINES IN OPPOSITION TO A B 26
03:02:12.688 --> 03:02:17.459
53? TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THE
03:02:17.526 --> 03:02:19.461
BILL. YOU MAY PRESS ONE,
03:02:19.528 --> 03:02:20.095
FOLLOWED BY ZERO ON YOUR
03:02:20.162 --> 03:02:21.930
TELEPHONE. THAT'S ONE AND THEN
03:02:21.997 --> 03:02:29.872
ZERO. POLICE. THANK YOU KNOW
03:02:29.938 --> 03:02:32.341
LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME, SO WE
03:02:32.408 --> 03:02:34.543
HAVE NO IN OPPOSITION. SO MANY
03:02:34.610 --> 03:02:36.779
HAND IT BACK TO VICE CHAIR BATES
03:02:36.845 --> 03:02:38.580
. BUT OBVIOUSLY THIS IS THE TIME
03:02:38.647 --> 03:02:39.348
WHERE MEMBERS CAN MAKE ANY
03:02:39.415 --> 03:02:41.517
COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. MEMBERS.
03:02:41.583 --> 03:02:48.357
THE BILL. CLOSE RESPECTFULLY
03:02:48.424 --> 03:02:51.460
WOULD ASK FOR MY VOTE MAN CHAIR.
03:02:51.527 --> 03:02:52.428
CONSULTANT. WOULD YOU PLEASE
03:02:52.494 --> 03:02:55.364
CALL THE ROLL? THANK YOU. THIS
03:02:55.431 --> 03:02:57.633
IS ASSEMBLY BILL 26 53 BY SOME
03:02:57.700 --> 03:02:59.301
MEMBERS. SANTIAGO THE MOTION IS
03:02:59.368 --> 03:03:00.836
DUE PASS, BUT FIRST PEOPLE
03:03:00.903 --> 03:03:01.837
REFERRED THE COMMITTEE ON
03:03:01.904 --> 03:03:03.238
APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WIENER
03:03:03.305 --> 03:03:08.277
BATES. NO SNOW CABALLERO. ORTEZ.
03:03:08.344 --> 03:03:09.411
PRETTY EASY, MCGUIRE CHILL BUG,
03:03:09.478 --> 03:03:13.148
ROTH. BROTH I SKINNER SKINNER I
03:03:13.215 --> 03:03:18.687
HAMBURG. 3211 THEN WE WILL LEAVE
03:03:18.754 --> 03:03:20.155
THE ROAD OPEN UNTIL OTHER
03:03:20.222 --> 03:03:21.924
MEMBERS ARE HERE. THANK YOU,
03:03:21.990 --> 03:03:24.460
MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU MEMBERS.
03:03:24.526 --> 03:03:28.130
I THINK WE. GO TO
03:03:28.197 --> 03:03:40.409
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN. THANK
03:03:40.476 --> 03:03:41.243
YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
03:03:41.310 --> 03:03:42.878
WHILE THIS COMMITTEE IS NOT
03:03:42.945 --> 03:03:45.114
ASKING ME TO ACCEPT ANY
03:03:45.180 --> 03:03:45.714
AMENDMENTS, I WANT YOU TO KNOW
03:03:45.781 --> 03:03:47.716
ABOUT THE AMENDMENTS THAT I
03:03:47.783 --> 03:03:48.584
ACCEPTED IN THE LAST COMMITTEE
03:03:48.650 --> 03:03:49.685
GOVERNMENT. IN FACT, GOVERNANCE
03:03:49.752 --> 03:03:50.953
AND FINANCE AND THAT COMMITTEE I
03:03:51.019 --> 03:03:54.423
AMENDMENTS. UM HONEY WITH A
03:03:54.490 --> 03:03:56.792
POPULATION OF 600,000 OR MORE.
03:03:56.859 --> 03:03:58.360
NO PARKING MINIMUM IF THE PARCEL
03:03:58.427 --> 03:03:59.661
IS LOCATED WITHIN ONE HALF MILE
03:03:59.728 --> 03:04:01.029
OF MAJOR TRANSIT STOP AS
03:04:01.096 --> 03:04:02.731
SPECIFIED IN A CITY WITH A
03:04:02.798 --> 03:04:05.067
POPULATION OF 75,000, OR MORE
03:04:05.134 --> 03:04:06.502
THAT IS LOCATED IN THE COUNTY OF
03:04:06.568 --> 03:04:08.537
LESS THAN 600,000 RESIDENTS. NO
03:04:08.604 --> 03:04:10.973
PARKING MINIMUM IF THE PARCEL IS
03:04:11.039 --> 03:04:12.141
LOCATED WITHIN ONE QUARTER MILE
03:04:12.207 --> 03:04:14.176
OF PUBLIC TRANSIT AS SPECIFIED.
03:04:14.243 --> 03:04:15.911
AUTHORIZED A CITY WITH A
03:04:15.978 --> 03:04:17.946
POPULATION OF LESS THAN 75,000
03:04:18.013 --> 03:04:20.182
OR A COUNTY WITH A POPULATION OF
03:04:20.249 --> 03:04:22.651
600,000, OR LESS TO ADOPT AN
03:04:22.718 --> 03:04:23.752
ORDINANCE OR RESOLUTION THAT
03:04:23.819 --> 03:04:24.853
APPLIES THE PROHIBITION OF NOTED
03:04:24.920 --> 03:04:26.822
ABOVE. IN OTHER WORDS, IT'S AN
03:04:26.889 --> 03:04:27.723
OPT IN FOR THOSE SMALLER
03:04:27.790 --> 03:04:30.859
COMMUNITIES. MANY CITIES IN
03:04:30.926 --> 03:04:32.361
CALIFORNIA, ALTHOUGH NOT ALL AT
03:04:32.428 --> 03:04:33.695
THIS POINT, REQUIRE NEW
03:04:33.762 --> 03:04:34.630
RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL
03:04:34.696 --> 03:04:36.899
DEVELOPMENTS TO PROVIDE ON SITE
03:04:36.965 --> 03:04:38.534
PARKING SPACES. THIS IS A ONE
03:04:38.600 --> 03:04:39.868
SIZE FITS ALL APPROACH ACROSS
03:04:39.935 --> 03:04:40.969
CITIES AND ACROSS STATES. THAT
03:04:41.036 --> 03:04:45.841
IS ALSO M A BARRIER FOR A LOT OF
03:04:45.908 --> 03:04:46.909
DIFFERENT THINGS. AND FIRST OF
03:04:46.975 --> 03:04:48.877
ALL, LET ME SAY THAT THIS BILL
03:04:48.944 --> 03:04:49.978
HAS RECEIVED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
03:04:50.045 --> 03:04:51.146
AND COMMITTEES BECAUSE AT ITS
03:04:51.213 --> 03:04:52.381
HEART, IT IS A PROPERTY RIGHTS
03:04:52.448 --> 03:04:54.216
MEASURE. NOW I'LL JUST GIVE YOU
03:04:54.283 --> 03:04:56.251
A FEW EXAMPLES FROM MY OWN CITY
03:04:56.318 --> 03:04:57.686
SEVERAL YEARS AGO. WE HAVE WE
03:04:57.753 --> 03:04:59.121
HAVE IN MY COMMUNITY OF GLENDALE
03:04:59.188 --> 03:05:00.656
AND OLD INDUSTRIAL AND
03:05:00.722 --> 03:05:02.191
MANUFACTURING AREA THAT HAS A
03:05:02.257 --> 03:05:03.392
LOT OF OLDER INDUSTRIAL
03:05:03.459 --> 03:05:04.960
BUILDINGS. WHAT I DISCOVERED
03:05:05.027 --> 03:05:06.228
WHEN I WAS ON THE GLENDALE CITY
03:05:06.295 --> 03:05:08.197
COUNCIL WAS THAT MANY OF THESE
03:05:08.263 --> 03:05:08.864
BUILDINGS REMAIN VACANT, AND THE
03:05:08.931 --> 03:05:11.066
ONLY REASON THEY WERE VACANT IS
03:05:11.133 --> 03:05:11.733
BECAUSE FOR ANYTHING NEW TO MOVE
03:05:11.800 --> 03:05:13.569
INTO THESE BUILDINGS AND USES
03:05:13.635 --> 03:05:14.870
EXISTING BUILDINGS. THE CITY
03:05:14.937 --> 03:05:18.373
REQUIRED THE BUSINESSES TO MEET
03:05:18.440 --> 03:05:20.042
PARKING STANDARDS THAT WERE
03:05:20.108 --> 03:05:22.010
IMPOSSIBLE TO MEET BY TODAY'S
03:05:22.077 --> 03:05:24.446
STANDARDS BY TODAY'S CODE, AND
03:05:24.513 --> 03:05:25.347
YET THEY WERE HANDICAPPING THE
03:05:25.414 --> 03:05:28.083
ABILITY OF ANY NEW USES IN THOSE
03:05:28.150 --> 03:05:29.084
BUILDINGS WITHOUT REQUIRING A
03:05:29.151 --> 03:05:29.785
DEMOLITION OF THOSE BUILDINGS
03:05:29.852 --> 03:05:30.819
AND THE BUILDING OF NEW SPACES
03:05:30.886 --> 03:05:33.355
THAT BUSINESSES DIDN'T NEED.
03:05:33.422 --> 03:05:34.022
NEEDLESS TO SAY, WE WERE ABLE TO
03:05:34.089 --> 03:05:35.824
CHANGE THAT. AND WHAT ENDED UP
03:05:35.891 --> 03:05:38.460
WAS THAT LOTS OF NEW BUSINESSES
03:05:38.527 --> 03:05:40.195
MOVING IN NO PARKING PROBLEMS AT
03:05:40.262 --> 03:05:41.830
ALL, BECAUSE OUR CITY RAN BUSSES
03:05:41.897 --> 03:05:43.565
WHEN THEY NEEDED TO RUN BUSSES
03:05:43.632 --> 03:05:44.833
AND OUR IN OUR DOWNTOWN AREA
03:05:44.900 --> 03:05:46.935
WHERE WE DID THIS, WE BUILT A
03:05:47.002 --> 03:05:47.936
COUPLE OF MUNICIPAL PARKING LOTS
03:05:48.003 --> 03:05:50.539
THAT WE BONDED TO BUILD AND NOW
03:05:50.606 --> 03:05:52.341
ARE CASH COWS FOR THE CITY OF
03:05:52.407 --> 03:05:53.942
GLENDALE. SO ANY IMPACT THAT YOU
03:05:54.009 --> 03:05:55.844
MIGHT HEAR FROM ANYBODY IS FULLY
03:05:55.911 --> 03:05:56.745
MITIGATE HERBAL BY CITIES DOING
03:05:56.812 --> 03:05:59.515
EXACTLY WHAT WE WANT. IN OUR
03:05:59.581 --> 03:06:01.216
DOWNTOWNS IN OUR URBAN CORES IN
03:06:01.283 --> 03:06:02.918
THE AREAS WHERE WE HAVE US AS A
03:06:02.985 --> 03:06:04.319
STATE HAVE INVESTED BILLIONS OF
03:06:04.386 --> 03:06:06.021
DOLLARS AND EXPENSIVE MASS
03:06:06.088 --> 03:06:08.090
TRANSIT, WHICH IS TO MAKE MASS
03:06:08.156 --> 03:06:09.758
TRANSIT MORE AVAILABLE TO PEOPLE
03:06:09.825 --> 03:06:12.194
BY TO RUN THOSE BUSSES TO MEET
03:06:12.261 --> 03:06:14.463
UP WITH THE TRAINS THAT THESE
03:06:14.530 --> 03:06:18.033
THAT THIS REQUIREMENT WOULD, UM
03:06:18.100 --> 03:06:19.935
IMPACT SO THAT WE ACTUALLY
03:06:20.002 --> 03:06:22.237
ENCOURAGE THE USE OF OUR PUBLIC
03:06:22.304 --> 03:06:23.672
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM AND AT THE
03:06:23.739 --> 03:06:25.774
SAME TIME USE LAND BETTER AND
03:06:25.841 --> 03:06:29.444
SMARTER. IN THESE AREAS ALLOW
03:06:29.511 --> 03:06:31.179
FOR COMMUTE FOR LAND USE THAT
03:06:31.246 --> 03:06:32.614
ALLOWS PEOPLE TO WALK AND BIKE
03:06:32.681 --> 03:06:34.783
WITHOUT HAVING TO WALK PAST
03:06:34.850 --> 03:06:36.318
GIANT OPEN AIR PARKING LOT TO
03:06:36.385 --> 03:06:38.253
ASK CITIES TO LOOK AT EXISTING
03:06:38.320 --> 03:06:39.121
PARKING THAT'S ALREADY IN THESE
03:06:39.187 --> 03:06:40.155
COMMUNITIES AND AGAIN,
03:06:40.222 --> 03:06:42.190
ANECDOTALLY MY DISTRICT OFFICES
03:06:42.257 --> 03:06:43.959
IN DOWNTOWN BURBANK. IT SHARES A
03:06:44.026 --> 03:06:45.260
PARKING STRUCTURE WITH ANOTHER
03:06:45.327 --> 03:06:46.762
OFFICE BUILDING. WE HAVE TWO BIG
03:06:46.828 --> 03:06:47.963
OFFICE BUILDINGS, AND EVEN
03:06:48.030 --> 03:06:49.798
BEFORE COVID THAT PARKING
03:06:49.865 --> 03:06:51.700
STRUCTURE WAS EMPTY. THE BOTTOM
03:06:51.767 --> 03:06:53.702
FLOOR OF IT HAS A FEW CARS. THE
03:06:53.769 --> 03:06:55.604
REST OF IT IS COMPLETELY EMPTY.
03:06:55.671 --> 03:06:57.205
AND YET ANY NEW BUSINESS MOVING
03:06:57.272 --> 03:06:58.607
IN ANY NEW APARTMENT BUILDING
03:06:58.674 --> 03:07:00.142
MOVING IN IN THAT AREA, RIGHT
03:07:00.208 --> 03:07:01.944
THERE IN THE DOWNTOWN WOULD HAVE
03:07:02.010 --> 03:07:03.845
TO PROVIDE HUNDREDS OF PARKING
03:07:03.912 --> 03:07:06.281
SPACES WHEN WE ALREADY HAVE AN
03:07:06.348 --> 03:07:06.848
UNKNOWN BUT AMPLE AMOUNT OF
03:07:06.915 --> 03:07:09.084
PARKING IN OUR DOWNTOWNS. NOW
03:07:09.151 --> 03:07:10.619
SEVERAL CITIES HAVE ALREADY
03:07:10.686 --> 03:07:11.954
REMOVED PARKING REQUIREMENTS AND
03:07:12.020 --> 03:07:12.988
THEIR DOWNTOWNS AND IN THEIR
03:07:13.055 --> 03:07:14.890
TRANSIT AREAS, INCLUDING SAN
03:07:14.957 --> 03:07:16.358
DIEGO, SO WE KNOW FROM REAL
03:07:16.425 --> 03:07:17.826
WORLD EXAMPLES. WHAT HAPPENS
03:07:17.893 --> 03:07:19.428
WHEN THIS IS DONE? WHAT HAPPENS
03:07:19.494 --> 03:07:20.596
IS MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING GETS
03:07:20.662 --> 03:07:23.098
BUILT. ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
03:07:23.165 --> 03:07:24.700
HAPPENS AND PEOPLE USE THAT
03:07:24.766 --> 03:07:26.368
TRANS PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION WHEN
03:07:26.435 --> 03:07:27.769
YOU DON'T MAKE A FREE AND
03:07:27.836 --> 03:07:29.738
AVAILABLE PARKING SO AVAILABLE,
03:07:29.805 --> 03:07:30.772
ENTICING FOR PEOPLE, THEY USE
03:07:30.839 --> 03:07:35.611
THOSE OTHER OPTIONS. SO.
03:07:35.677 --> 03:07:38.080
BUILDING FOR THE MISSING MIDDLE
03:07:38.146 --> 03:07:38.780
WE KNOW IS SOMETHING THAT'S
03:07:38.847 --> 03:07:39.781
REALLY HARD IN THIS STATE,
03:07:39.848 --> 03:07:41.617
BECAUSE OFTEN BECAUSE OF COSTS,
03:07:41.683 --> 03:07:42.851
I WAS ON A SELECT COMMITTEE
03:07:42.918 --> 03:07:44.286
ABOUT BUILDING FOR THE MISSING
03:07:44.353 --> 03:07:45.120
MIDDLE AND BUILDING COSTS WERE
03:07:45.187 --> 03:07:47.155
ONE OF THE BIGGEST REASONS WHY
03:07:47.222 --> 03:07:48.423
PROJECTS WALK AWAY. WHY
03:07:48.490 --> 03:07:49.458
DEVELOPERS WALK AWAY FROM
03:07:49.524 --> 03:07:50.959
PROJECTS AND PARKING IS A BIG
03:07:51.026 --> 03:07:53.362
PART OF THAT. NOW. WE ALSO KNOW
03:07:53.428 --> 03:07:53.962
FROM AREAS THAT HAVE DONE THIS
03:07:54.029 --> 03:07:55.631
LIKE SAN DIEGO THAT GUESS WHAT
03:07:55.697 --> 03:07:57.065
DEVELOPERS ARE STILL BUILDING
03:07:57.132 --> 03:07:59.434
PARKING, BUT WHAT THEY ARE DOING
03:07:59.501 --> 03:08:01.436
IS THEY ARE RIGHT, SIZING THE
03:08:01.503 --> 03:08:02.337
PARKING FOR THEIR PARTICULAR USE
03:08:02.404 --> 03:08:03.805
OR THEIR TENANT BASE OR FOR
03:08:03.872 --> 03:08:05.273
THEIR CLIENTS IF THERE ARE
03:08:05.340 --> 03:08:06.975
COMMERCIAL BUSINESS THEY ARE
03:08:07.042 --> 03:08:08.243
DOING THINGS LIKE EXPERIMENTING,
03:08:08.310 --> 03:08:09.511
ALLOWING TANDEM PARKING,
03:08:09.578 --> 03:08:11.613
OFFERING A BUILDING A UNIT.
03:08:11.680 --> 03:08:13.615
LET'S SAY WITH ONE SPACE INSTEAD
03:08:13.682 --> 03:08:14.783
OF TWO FOR PEOPLE WHO DO SHARE A
03:08:14.850 --> 03:08:17.653
CAR OR WANT TO USE THEIR BIKE TO
03:08:17.719 --> 03:08:18.787
GET AROUND OR USE PUBLIC
03:08:18.854 --> 03:08:19.921
TRANSPORTATION. SO THIS BILL HAS
03:08:19.988 --> 03:08:21.590
GOTTEN A LOT OF ATTENTION. IN
03:08:21.657 --> 03:08:23.692
FACT, IT WAS WRITTEN ABOUT IN
03:08:23.759 --> 03:08:24.626
THE NEW YORK TIMES RECENTLY
03:08:24.693 --> 03:08:25.560
BECAUSE CITIES ACROSS THE
03:08:25.627 --> 03:08:27.162
COUNTRY ARE LOOKING AT THIS. AND
03:08:27.229 --> 03:08:28.797
LASTLY, I'LL SAY BEFORE WE MOVE
03:08:28.864 --> 03:08:30.632
TO OUR SPONSORS, AND TO TALK
03:08:30.699 --> 03:08:33.235
ABOUT WHO'S SUPPORTING THIS IS
03:08:33.301 --> 03:08:33.902
THAT WE ARE NOT LONG FROM
03:08:33.969 --> 03:08:35.637
AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES AND ALREADY
03:08:35.704 --> 03:08:37.005
NOW YOUNGER PEOPLE ARE SHIFTING
03:08:37.072 --> 03:08:39.307
TO USING MORE RIDESHARING USING
03:08:39.374 --> 03:08:41.143
UBER AND LYFT AND OWNING LESS
03:08:41.209 --> 03:08:43.211
CARS, SO THE FACT THAT WE STILL
03:08:43.278 --> 03:08:45.981
REQUIRE CONCRETE TO BE POURED
03:08:46.048 --> 03:08:47.516
HOLES TO BE DUG, EXPENSIVE
03:08:47.582 --> 03:08:49.718
PARKING TO BE BUILT, WHICH IS
03:08:49.785 --> 03:08:51.153
PASSED ON DIRECTLY TO TENANTS
03:08:51.219 --> 03:08:52.854
DIRECTLY, WHO MAY OR MAY NOT
03:08:52.921 --> 03:08:55.190
EVEN WANT THAT SPACE IS REALLY
03:08:55.257 --> 03:08:57.659
VERY IS NOT IN KEEPING WITH NOT
03:08:57.726 --> 03:09:02.064
ONLY OUR GOALS ARE HOUSING GOALS
03:09:02.130 --> 03:09:02.698
AND OUR CLIMATE GOALS, BUT NOT
03:09:02.764 --> 03:09:03.699
EVEN KEEPING UP WITH SORT OF
03:09:03.765 --> 03:09:04.800
SCIENTIFIC. ADVANCE. IN THE
03:09:04.866 --> 03:09:06.034
FIELD. THIS BILL IS BEING
03:09:06.101 --> 03:09:06.835
SPONSORED BY CALIFORNIA UM BE
03:09:06.902 --> 03:09:08.870
SPUR ABUNDANT HOUSING L. A THE
03:09:08.937 --> 03:09:09.971
COUNCIL OF INFO BUILDERS IN THE
03:09:10.038 --> 03:09:11.840
BAY AREA COUNCIL. IT'S BEING
03:09:11.907 --> 03:09:12.874
SUPPORTED BY THE CALIFORNIA
03:09:12.941 --> 03:09:14.276
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION,
03:09:14.342 --> 03:09:15.744
THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO, THE
03:09:15.811 --> 03:09:17.212
SILICON VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP,
03:09:17.279 --> 03:09:19.481
THE ASIAN BUILDERS ASSOCIATION,
03:09:19.548 --> 03:09:21.016
THE SIERRA CLUB, THE LH CHAMBER
03:09:21.083 --> 03:09:22.284
OF COMMERCE. AND I LOVE SAYING
03:09:22.350 --> 03:09:24.319
THAT HOW MANY BILLS DO YOU GET
03:09:24.386 --> 03:09:25.454
THE CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND
03:09:25.520 --> 03:09:26.788
THIS YEAR A CLUB TO SUPPORT THE
03:09:26.855 --> 03:09:27.889
SIERRA BUSINESS COUNCIL, THE
03:09:27.956 --> 03:09:29.624
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
03:09:29.691 --> 03:09:31.927
AND TRANSFORM TESTIFYING AND
03:09:31.993 --> 03:09:33.261
SUPPORT TODAY OR LOUIS MERANTI,
03:09:33.328 --> 03:09:34.229
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR WITH KELLY
03:09:34.296 --> 03:09:36.098
MB. AND ME A KING, THE SENIOR
03:09:36.164 --> 03:09:37.165
VICE PRESIDENT WITH RELATED
03:09:37.232 --> 03:09:38.700
CALIFORNIA AND THE DIRECTOR OF
03:09:38.767 --> 03:09:42.204
THE COUNCIL OF INFILL BUILDERS.
03:09:42.270 --> 03:09:44.039
AND WE SHOW US THE LEAD WITNESS
03:09:44.106 --> 03:09:45.207
. LEWIS MERANTI, CALIFORNIA. UM,
03:09:45.273 --> 03:09:48.443
BE IT'S NOT THE LEAD WITNESS
03:09:48.510 --> 03:09:51.513
TODAY. THEY'RE BOTH HERE. MS.
03:09:51.580 --> 03:09:52.948
CAME TO SPEED. THANK YOU. GOOD
03:09:53.014 --> 03:09:56.218
AFTERNOON. UH MADAM CHAIR AND
03:09:56.284 --> 03:09:58.353
SENATORS. MY NAME IS MIA KONG. I
03:09:58.420 --> 03:10:00.222
AM ONE OF A PROUD SPONSORS OF
03:10:00.288 --> 03:10:01.423
WITH THE COUNCIL OF INFILL
03:10:01.490 --> 03:10:03.058
BUILDERS, AND WE'RE HERE TODAY
03:10:03.125 --> 03:10:05.560
TO STRONGLY SUPPORT A B 2097.
03:10:05.627 --> 03:10:06.928
I'VE BEEN DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE
03:10:06.995 --> 03:10:08.864
HOUSING FOR THE LAST 25 YEARS IN
03:10:08.930 --> 03:10:10.565
RURAL URBAN AND SUBURBAN
03:10:10.632 --> 03:10:11.700
COMMUNITIES AND THE NUMBER ONE
03:10:11.767 --> 03:10:13.235
THING THAT IS IN COMMON WITH
03:10:13.301 --> 03:10:13.835
EVERY SINGLE NEW DEVELOPMENT
03:10:13.902 --> 03:10:16.071
I'VE EVER PROPOSED AS I'VE HAD
03:10:16.138 --> 03:10:16.705
TO REDUCE PARKING REQUIREMENTS.
03:10:16.772 --> 03:10:18.106
EXCESSIVE MINIMUM REQUIRED
03:10:18.173 --> 03:10:19.574
PARKING REQUIREMENTS REALLY
03:10:19.641 --> 03:10:21.843
RENDERS NEW DEVELOPMENT MUCH
03:10:21.910 --> 03:10:22.844
MORE EXPENSIVE AND CHALLENGING
03:10:22.911 --> 03:10:25.747
THE COST OF ON SITE PARKING ADS,
03:10:25.814 --> 03:10:28.583
YOU KNOW, ON AVERAGE $35,000 PER
03:10:28.650 --> 03:10:30.385
SPACE IF IT'S A SIMPLE STRUCTURE
03:10:30.452 --> 03:10:32.521
, BUT A LOT OF COMPLEXITIES, AND
03:10:32.587 --> 03:10:33.922
IT LIMITS HOW MUCH WALK ABILITY
03:10:33.989 --> 03:10:35.690
AND HOW MUCH HOUSING YOU CAN
03:10:35.757 --> 03:10:36.725
PRODUCE. MINIMUM PARKING
03:10:36.792 --> 03:10:38.727
REQUIREMENTS REALLY ARE THE MOST
03:10:38.794 --> 03:10:40.128
IMPORTANT DRIVER OF NEW HOUSING
03:10:40.195 --> 03:10:42.631
COSTS IN CALIFORNIA TODAY, AND
03:10:42.697 --> 03:10:44.299
IT REALLY RENDERS PROJECTS
03:10:44.366 --> 03:10:44.933
INFEASIBLE AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S.
03:10:45.000 --> 03:10:47.235
FRIEDMAN DESCRIBED BY
03:10:47.302 --> 03:10:48.203
ELIMINATING MINIMUM PARKING
03:10:48.270 --> 03:10:50.272
REQUIREMENTS. WE CAN CUT TENS OF
03:10:50.338 --> 03:10:51.706
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS OFF THE
03:10:51.773 --> 03:10:54.009
COST OF NEW HOUSING AND THE VERY
03:10:54.075 --> 03:10:54.976
AREAS THAT WE NEED HOUSING
03:10:55.043 --> 03:10:56.978
PRODUCED. IT WILL LOWER THE COST
03:10:57.045 --> 03:10:58.647
NOT ONLY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT BUT
03:10:58.713 --> 03:11:00.448
ALSO FOR THE END USERS
03:11:00.515 --> 03:11:01.716
RESIDENTS, ACCORDING TO 2020
03:11:01.783 --> 03:11:04.386
CENSUS. WE'VE HAD MORE THAN 52%
03:11:04.452 --> 03:11:06.288
OF ALL. CALIFORNIA RENTERS OAN
03:11:06.354 --> 03:11:07.923
ZERO OR ONE CAR YET IT'S ILLEGAL
03:11:07.989 --> 03:11:09.291
TO BUILD HOUSING FOR FOLKS THAT
03:11:09.357 --> 03:11:13.228
DON'T OWN CARS. UM THIS BILL A B
03:11:13.295 --> 03:11:15.697
NINETIES, 2097 WOULD UNLOCK THE
03:11:15.764 --> 03:11:17.365
POTENTIAL FOR UNDERUTILIZED AND
03:11:17.432 --> 03:11:18.800
ADAPTIVE RE USE BUILDINGS, JUST
03:11:18.867 --> 03:11:20.769
AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. FREEMAN
03:11:20.836 --> 03:11:23.171
DESCRIBED MANY EMPTY RETAIL
03:11:23.238 --> 03:11:25.507
SPACES ARE EMPTY BECAUSE USERS
03:11:25.574 --> 03:11:28.443
CANNOT FIND PARKING TO MEET THE
03:11:28.510 --> 03:11:30.011
GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR EVERY
03:11:30.078 --> 03:11:31.947
SINGLE AREA SO BY PROVIDING MORE
03:11:32.013 --> 03:11:33.381
FLEXIBILITY SO THAT DEVELOPERS
03:11:33.448 --> 03:11:36.484
CAN RIGHT SIZE. PARKING WE CAN
03:11:36.551 --> 03:11:38.587
PRIORITIZE HOUSING FOR PEOPLE
03:11:38.653 --> 03:11:40.455
OVER HOUSING FOR CARS. WE CAN
03:11:40.522 --> 03:11:42.057
ALSO REDUCE GREENHOUSE GAS
03:11:42.123 --> 03:11:43.458
EMISSIONS AND CREATE MORE
03:11:43.525 --> 03:11:45.093
WALKABLE COMMUNITIES IN WHICH
03:11:45.160 --> 03:11:46.428
BUSINESSES AND RESIDENTS CAN
03:11:46.494 --> 03:11:48.029
ENJOY A BETTER QUALITY OF LIFE.
03:11:48.096 --> 03:11:49.197
WE CAN REVITALIZE OUR COMMERCIAL
03:11:49.264 --> 03:11:51.566
CORRIDORS. AND REALLY ENCOURAGE
03:11:51.633 --> 03:11:53.768
NEW BUSINESSES TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
03:11:53.835 --> 03:11:55.904
OF, YOU KNOW THE SUCCESSFUL
03:11:55.971 --> 03:11:57.205
ENTREPRENEURS THAT HAVE BEEN
03:11:57.272 --> 03:11:59.107
TAKING OVER WITH COVID, WHERE WE
03:11:59.174 --> 03:12:00.542
HAVE MANY EMPTY PARKING SPACES
03:12:00.609 --> 03:12:01.610
TRANSFORMED INTO LIVELY NEW
03:12:01.676 --> 03:12:04.746
COMMERCIAL SPACES. A B 2097
03:12:04.813 --> 03:12:06.248
WOULD WOULD ELIMINATE MINIMUM
03:12:06.314 --> 03:12:07.482
PARKING REQUIREMENTS IN THE VERY
03:12:07.549 --> 03:12:08.850
TRANSIT RICH AREAS THAT OUR
03:12:08.917 --> 03:12:10.285
COMMUNITY NEEDS. WE STRONGLY
03:12:10.352 --> 03:12:11.753
URGES COMMITTEE SUPPORT AND
03:12:11.820 --> 03:12:13.455
THANK YOU FOR OUR STRONG
03:12:13.521 --> 03:12:15.290
LEADERSHIP OF OUR SPONSOR. THANK
03:12:15.357 --> 03:12:21.863
YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON,
03:12:21.930 --> 03:12:23.331
MADAM VICE CHAIR AND MEMBERS. MY
03:12:23.398 --> 03:12:24.833
NAME IS LOUIS BRANCH AND THE
03:12:24.900 --> 03:12:25.767
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR FOR
03:12:25.834 --> 03:12:27.102
CALIFORNIA AND BE ONE OF THE
03:12:27.168 --> 03:12:28.803
SPONSORS AND STRONG SUPPORTERS
03:12:28.870 --> 03:12:30.038
OF THIS BILL. I THINK MY
03:12:30.105 --> 03:12:30.805
COLLEAGUE IN THE
03:12:30.872 --> 03:12:32.474
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HAVE DONE VERY
03:12:32.540 --> 03:12:33.141
WELL IN ADDRESSING WHAT THE BILL
03:12:33.208 --> 03:12:34.943
DOES AND WHY THE BILL IS GOOD,
03:12:35.010 --> 03:12:36.878
SO I THOUGHT I WOULD JUST SPEND
03:12:36.945 --> 03:12:38.280
A COUPLE OF MINUTES ADDRESSING
03:12:38.346 --> 03:12:39.114
SOME OF THE COUNTER ARGUMENTS TO
03:12:39.180 --> 03:12:41.149
THE BILL THAT YOU MIGHT HEAR
03:12:41.216 --> 03:12:43.385
TODAY AND WHY WE STILL STAND BY
03:12:43.451 --> 03:12:44.185
THE BILL. DESPITE THOSE COUNTER
03:12:44.252 --> 03:12:44.819
ARGUMENTS, THERE IS AN ARGUMENT
03:12:44.886 --> 03:12:46.388
OUT THERE THAT BY REDUCING
03:12:46.454 --> 03:12:47.389
PARKING MINIMUMS, WE
03:12:47.455 --> 03:12:49.257
DISINCENTIVIZE THE USE OF THE
03:12:49.324 --> 03:12:51.526
STATE'S DENSITY BONUS LAW, ONE
03:12:51.593 --> 03:12:52.327
OF THE MOST IMPORTANT ELEMENTS
03:12:52.394 --> 03:12:53.561
OF STATE LAW ENCOURAGING, BUT
03:12:53.628 --> 03:12:54.796
THE PRODUCTION OF HOUSING
03:12:54.863 --> 03:12:55.330
GENERALLY AND AFFORDABLE
03:12:55.397 --> 03:12:59.534
HOUSING. THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO
03:12:59.601 --> 03:13:01.803
IN 2019 ABOLISHED ITS PARKING
03:13:01.870 --> 03:13:03.738
MINIMUMS NEAR TRANSIT IN MUCH
03:13:03.805 --> 03:13:06.274
THE SAME WAY THAT THIS BILL
03:13:06.341 --> 03:13:06.908
PROPOSES TO DO STATEWIDE. WHAT
03:13:06.975 --> 03:13:09.010
SAN DIEGO FOUND, THOUGH, WAS A
03:13:09.077 --> 03:13:10.145
FIVEFOLD INCREASE IN BOTH THE
03:13:10.211 --> 03:13:12.914
NUMBER OF PROJECTS AND THE
03:13:12.981 --> 03:13:13.949
AMOUNT OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:13:14.015 --> 03:13:15.150
BEING CREATED THROUGH THE
03:13:15.216 --> 03:13:16.184
DENSITY BONUS LAW IN THOSE
03:13:16.251 --> 03:13:18.386
PROJECTS IN THE FOLLOWING YEAR
03:13:18.453 --> 03:13:19.654
IN 2020, NOT A GREAT YEAR FOR
03:13:19.721 --> 03:13:21.556
DEVELOPMENT. WE FEEL STRONGLY
03:13:21.623 --> 03:13:22.691
THAT THIS BILL WILL ACTUALLY
03:13:22.757 --> 03:13:23.992
INCREASE ACCELERATE THE
03:13:24.059 --> 03:13:25.794
PRODUCTION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:13:25.860 --> 03:13:26.895
THROUGH THE STATE'S DENSITY
03:13:26.962 --> 03:13:28.063
BONUS LAW RATHER THAN DECREASE
03:13:28.129 --> 03:13:31.299
IT. ONE OF THE THINGS YOU HAVE
03:13:31.366 --> 03:13:32.834
TO KEEP IN MIND ABOUT PARKING IS
03:13:32.901 --> 03:13:34.436
THAT PARKING IS AN AMENITY. IT'S
03:13:34.502 --> 03:13:35.837
SOMETHING THAT BOTH COST MONEY
03:13:35.904 --> 03:13:37.105
TO CREATE, AND THE DEVELOPERS
03:13:37.172 --> 03:13:38.440
CAN CHARGE MONEY TO PROVIDE. AND
03:13:38.506 --> 03:13:39.874
BECAUSE THE DEVELOPERS IN THIS
03:13:39.941 --> 03:13:41.142
CASE WON'T BE PROVIDING PARKING
03:13:41.209 --> 03:13:42.110
THAT THEY'RE NOT BUILDING
03:13:42.177 --> 03:13:42.711
THEY'RE NECESSARILY GOING TO
03:13:42.777 --> 03:13:45.547
HAVE TO TARDES OF LESS AMOUNT
03:13:45.613 --> 03:13:47.449
THAN COMMENSURATE UNITS THAT DO
03:13:47.515 --> 03:13:49.985
INCLUDE PARKING. SO STRONGLY IN
03:13:50.051 --> 03:13:51.453
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL, IT'S GOING
03:13:51.519 --> 03:13:53.088
TO REDUCE HOUSING COSTS, REDUCED
03:13:53.154 --> 03:13:55.390
HOUSING, CONSTRUCTION COSTS AND
03:13:55.457 --> 03:13:56.224
MOVE CALIFORNIA IN THE RIGHT
03:13:56.291 --> 03:13:57.759
DIRECTION IN THE DIRECTION IS
03:13:57.826 --> 03:13:58.994
ALREADY MOVING ON THE
03:13:59.060 --> 03:13:59.861
ENVIRONMENT STRONGLY SUPPORT.
03:13:59.928 --> 03:14:01.162
MAYBE 2097 URGE YOUR SUPPORT FOR
03:14:01.229 --> 03:14:04.265
TODAY AS WELL. THANK YOU. THANK
03:14:04.332 --> 03:14:06.868
YOU, ANY OTHERS WHO ARE HERE WHO
03:14:06.935 --> 03:14:08.970
WISH TO ADD THEIR VOICE TO THE
03:14:09.037 --> 03:14:14.709
SUPPORT. GOOD AFTERNOON, ABIGAIL
03:14:14.776 --> 03:14:16.578
MAIL ON BEHALF OF NRDC ACTION
03:14:16.644 --> 03:14:22.217
FUND AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
03:14:22.283 --> 03:14:23.918
ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH LIGHTHOUSE
03:14:23.985 --> 03:14:25.220
PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF
03:14:25.286 --> 03:14:26.955
HABITAT FOR HUMANITY. CALIFORNIA
03:14:27.022 --> 03:14:28.223
CIVIC WELL MID PEN, HOUSING AND
03:14:28.289 --> 03:14:33.561
SANDHILL PROPERTIES IN SUPPORT.
03:14:33.628 --> 03:14:35.263
LOW OF ELECTING WITH THE SILICON
03:14:35.330 --> 03:14:36.598
VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP. WE WANT
03:14:36.664 --> 03:14:37.899
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING
03:14:37.966 --> 03:14:39.667
THIS BILL FORWARD. SO WE'RE IN
03:14:39.734 --> 03:14:43.438
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. COREY SMITH
03:14:43.505 --> 03:14:44.539
. HOUSING ACTION COALITION AND
03:14:44.606 --> 03:14:48.576
SUPPORT THANK YOU. SILVIO
03:14:48.643 --> 03:14:49.811
FERRARI ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA
03:14:49.878 --> 03:14:50.612
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
03:14:50.678 --> 03:14:54.049
AND SUPPORT. IMPORT MEDICINE,
03:14:54.115 --> 03:14:54.949
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
03:14:55.016 --> 03:14:59.521
AND SUPPORT. MARK FOCUS, WHICH
03:14:59.587 --> 03:15:01.356
ON BEHALF OF STREETS FOR ALL IN
03:15:01.423 --> 03:15:05.226
SUPPORT. DON'T SEE ANY OTHER
03:15:05.293 --> 03:15:06.494
SUPPORT COMING FORWARD AND THEN
03:15:06.561 --> 03:15:09.197
LET'S GO TO THE PHONE LINES. MR
03:15:09.264 --> 03:15:10.932
MODERATOR, DO WE HAVE ANYONE
03:15:10.999 --> 03:15:12.233
QUEUING UP ON THE PHONE WISHING
03:15:12.300 --> 03:15:14.069
TO ADD THERE? VOICE. TWO SUPPORT
03:15:14.135 --> 03:15:21.142
OF A B 2097. THANK YOU. IF YOU
03:15:21.209 --> 03:15:23.111
HAVE NOT ALREADY DONE SO, BUT
03:15:23.178 --> 03:15:24.946
WISH TO PRESS ONE THAN ZERO TO
03:15:25.013 --> 03:15:27.048
EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THE BILL MAY
03:15:27.115 --> 03:15:28.516
DO SO AT THIS TIME. WE'LL START
03:15:28.583 --> 03:15:32.020
WITH LYING. 3 45. MICHAEL
03:15:32.087 --> 03:15:33.254
LANGUISH FOR A PROUD CO SPONSOR
03:15:33.321 --> 03:15:40.662
AND STRONG SUPPORT. 3 34. GOOD
03:15:40.728 --> 03:15:42.030
AFTERNOON, STEVE BULLOCK ON
03:15:42.097 --> 03:15:44.299
BEHALF OF THE FOREIGN COMMENTS
03:15:44.365 --> 03:15:45.333
LIKE THERE'S YOUR SUPPORT BREAK
03:15:45.400 --> 03:15:46.468
BETWEEN 97, THE ALAMEDA COUNTY.
03:15:46.534 --> 03:15:47.802
TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION, THE
03:15:47.869 --> 03:15:48.736
ALAMEDA CONTRA COSTA TRANSIT
03:15:48.803 --> 03:15:50.271
DISTRICT, THE NAPA VALLEY
03:15:50.338 --> 03:15:51.005
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY IN THE
03:15:51.072 --> 03:15:52.173
CALIFORNIA BICYCLE, WHOLE ISSUE
03:15:52.240 --> 03:15:59.814
SUPPORT THANKS. 3 18. GOOD
03:15:59.881 --> 03:16:01.349
AFTERNOON. LAWRENCE A VALENCIA,
03:16:01.416 --> 03:16:02.584
REPRESENTING THE AMERICAN
03:16:02.650 --> 03:16:03.418
PLANNING ASSOCIATION, AND
03:16:03.485 --> 03:16:11.893
SUPPORT 3 57. I GET MY, UH,
03:16:11.960 --> 03:16:15.497
DROPPING OFF SENTIMENT. SURPRISE
03:16:15.563 --> 03:16:17.632
I THINK REDUCING APARTMENT
03:16:17.699 --> 03:16:19.234
RESULTS IN MORE, UM ONE
03:16:19.300 --> 03:16:20.468
DEVELOPMENT, MORE HOUSING
03:16:20.535 --> 03:16:21.636
DEVELOPMENT THAT WE NEED. THANK
03:16:21.703 --> 03:16:29.244
YOU. 3 83. HI. THIS IS SCOTT
03:16:29.310 --> 03:16:30.378
O'NEILL AND COLORADO CALLING AND
03:16:30.445 --> 03:16:37.619
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 1 53.
03:16:37.685 --> 03:16:39.220
HOUSES BRAD EWING CALLING ON
03:16:39.287 --> 03:16:40.889
BEHALF OF SANTA MONICA FORD
03:16:40.955 --> 03:16:41.389
STRONGLY SUPPORTING THIS
03:16:41.456 --> 03:16:47.395
BUILDING. THANK YOU. 3 54. THIS
03:16:47.462 --> 03:16:49.531
IS TOMORROW WITH MY MEDIUM B AND
03:16:49.597 --> 03:16:51.633
STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 29 7. 3
03:16:51.699 --> 03:16:57.472
98. HI. THIS IS BOBBY GARRITY
03:16:57.539 --> 03:16:58.840
FROM CALIFORNIA AND BE CALLING
03:16:58.907 --> 03:17:06.247
IN SUPPORT OF A B 2097. 2 50.
03:17:06.314 --> 03:17:08.082
PRICES OF NET SOFTWARE CALLING
03:17:08.149 --> 03:17:09.384
ON BEHALF OF THE SANTA MONICA
03:17:09.450 --> 03:17:10.518
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND SUPPORT.
03:17:10.585 --> 03:17:16.824
THANK YOU. 2 24. SARAH, OVERLY
03:17:16.891 --> 03:17:18.726
CAR FREE RESIDENT AND VOTER IN
03:17:18.793 --> 03:17:19.894
OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA,
03:17:19.961 --> 03:17:22.130
REPRESENTING EAST AND STRONG
03:17:22.197 --> 03:17:30.471
SUPPORT OF 80 2097. 363. HUSING
03:17:30.538 --> 03:17:32.040
CHAIR MEMBERS. ZACH BOWLING IS
03:17:32.106 --> 03:17:34.108
BMB CALLING AND STRONG SUPPORT
03:17:34.175 --> 03:17:39.847
OF 2097. THANK YOU. 400. MR
03:17:39.914 --> 03:17:41.983
CHAIR AND MEMBERS AND ALEX
03:17:42.050 --> 03:17:42.817
TORRES WITH BARRY COUNCIL IN
03:17:42.884 --> 03:17:43.952
STRONG SUPPORT SPONSOR THANK YOU
03:17:44.018 --> 03:17:51.826
SO MUCH. 3 61. DR BURTON, SOUTH
03:17:51.893 --> 03:17:52.293
PASADENA RESIDENTS FOR
03:17:52.360 --> 03:17:53.194
RESPONSIBLE GROWTH. WE ARE
03:17:53.261 --> 03:18:00.735
STRONG SUPPORT. 3 96. HELLO THIS
03:18:00.802 --> 03:18:01.736
IS JOSHUA HAN, REPRESENTING
03:18:01.803 --> 03:18:03.338
COMMON GROUND, CALIFORNIA IN
03:18:03.404 --> 03:18:05.240
SUPPORT OF A B 2097. THANK YOU.
03:18:05.306 --> 03:18:10.345
FOR THREE. GOOD AFTERNOON, KIM
03:18:10.411 --> 03:18:11.813
DELFINO, REPRESENTING THE
03:18:11.879 --> 03:18:13.281
CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY
03:18:13.348 --> 03:18:14.682
, DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE AND
03:18:14.749 --> 03:18:15.917
INDEED, AND THE ENDANGERED
03:18:15.984 --> 03:18:17.652
HABITATS LEAGUE AND SUPPORT. 3
03:18:17.719 --> 03:18:23.157
99. GOOD AFTERNOON. ALICE IS
03:18:23.224 --> 03:18:25.126
STILL HIGH CLOWN BEHALF OF THE
03:18:25.193 --> 03:18:26.127
CITY OF REDWOOD CITY, OFTEN
03:18:26.194 --> 03:18:31.332
SUPPORT THANK YOU. 3 56. MY NAME
03:18:31.399 --> 03:18:33.334
IS LISA DANCE AND WITH FREMONT
03:18:33.401 --> 03:18:34.535
FOR EVERYONE, AND WE SUPPORT A B
03:18:34.602 --> 03:18:41.909
2097. 2 35. HI. MY NAME IS PAUL
03:18:41.976 --> 03:18:43.044
BICKMORE CALLING FROM OAKLAND
03:18:43.111 --> 03:18:49.651
AND STRONG SUPPORT. 2 29. WILL
03:18:49.717 --> 03:18:50.952
BE MORE RATIONAL FROM LOS
03:18:51.019 --> 03:18:51.819
ANGELES, CALLING ON BEHALF OF
03:18:51.886 --> 03:18:53.521
WESTSIDE FOR EVERYONE AND STRONG
03:18:53.588 --> 03:18:58.826
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 3 28. ANDREW
03:18:58.893 --> 03:18:59.927
LEWIS 3 50 ACTION STRONG
03:18:59.994 --> 03:19:16.277
SUPPORT. 209. 209 ARE YOU ON ME?
03:19:16.344 --> 03:19:18.112
YES SORRY. THIS IS RYAN
03:19:18.179 --> 03:19:20.081
O'CONNELL FROM NAPA, SOLANO FOR
03:19:20.148 --> 03:19:21.249
EVERYONE CALLING AND STRONG
03:19:21.316 --> 03:19:26.054
SUPPORT. 3 40. HELLO. THIS IS
03:19:26.120 --> 03:19:27.255
AARON WILLIAM, BEHIND THIS
03:19:27.322 --> 03:19:28.256
THEORY CLUB, CALIFORNIA AND
03:19:28.323 --> 03:19:34.395
SUPPORT 3 31. AFTERNOON DAVID
03:19:34.462 --> 03:19:36.030
AZEVEDO WITH AARP, CALIFORNIA IN
03:19:36.097 --> 03:19:42.503
STRONG SUPPORT. 3 76. GOOD
03:19:42.570 --> 03:19:43.638
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS
03:19:43.705 --> 03:19:45.406
JORDAN GRIMES ON BEHALF OF
03:19:45.473 --> 03:19:46.808
GREENBELT ALLIANCE AND STRONG
03:19:46.874 --> 03:19:48.876
SUPPORT OF A B 2097. FOR ALL
03:19:48.943 --> 03:19:55.983
ONE. HI THIS IS SHANE MY ARMOR
03:19:56.050 --> 03:19:57.118
WITH SAN DIEGO. UM B AND STRONG
03:19:57.185 --> 03:20:04.225
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. 3 88. HI.
03:20:04.292 --> 03:20:05.693
THIS IS RYAN COMPTON WITH
03:20:05.760 --> 03:20:06.728
CALIFORNIA COMMON GROUND IN LONG
03:20:06.794 --> 03:20:14.769
BEACH AND SUPPORT. 2 19. GARY
03:20:14.836 --> 03:20:15.870
GUTHMAN WITH CULLIVER CITY FOR
03:20:15.937 --> 03:20:18.439
MORE HOMES AND STRONG SUPPORT. 3
03:20:18.506 --> 03:20:24.178
91. THIS IS DAVID BARBOZA ON
03:20:24.245 --> 03:20:26.047
BEHALF OF ABUNDANT HOUSING L A.
03:20:26.114 --> 03:20:27.849
WE'RE PROUD TO SUPPORT AND
03:20:27.915 --> 03:20:33.388
SPONSORING B 2097. 3 59. SO
03:20:33.454 --> 03:20:35.623
THAT'S A HOMEOWNER IN WALNUT
03:20:35.690 --> 03:20:37.091
CREEK, LIVING CLOSE TO THE BART
03:20:37.158 --> 03:20:43.331
STATION IN STRONG SUPPORT. 3 89.
03:20:43.398 --> 03:20:44.899
SECULAR ROMERO ON BEHALF OF THE
03:20:44.966 --> 03:20:46.734
LOS ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF
03:20:46.801 --> 03:20:47.802
COMMERCE AND STRONG SUPPORT. 3
03:20:47.869 --> 03:20:53.808
74. HI. MY NAME IS BRIANNA EGAN
03:20:53.875 --> 03:20:55.710
. UM I'M FROM REDONDO BEACH,
03:20:55.777 --> 03:20:57.912
CALIFORNIA, UM, CALLING ON
03:20:57.979 --> 03:20:59.781
BEHALF OF EVERYONE AND ABUNDANT
03:20:59.847 --> 03:21:01.416
HOUSING L A, UM, AND STRONG
03:21:01.482 --> 03:21:07.422
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 2097 MAINLY FOR
03:21:07.488 --> 03:21:08.956
HELPING TO BRING DOWN THE COST
03:21:09.023 --> 03:21:10.558
OF HOUSING AND ENCOURAGING
03:21:10.625 --> 03:21:11.893
TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT,
03:21:11.959 --> 03:21:12.994
WHICH ARE THINGS THAT WE
03:21:13.060 --> 03:21:14.061
DESPERATELY NEED IN THE LOS
03:21:14.128 --> 03:21:22.503
ANGELES AREA. THANK YOU. 3 93.
03:21:22.570 --> 03:21:24.138
THIS IS WARREN WELLS WITH MARIN
03:21:24.205 --> 03:21:25.273
COUNTY FAISAL COALITION TRUNK
03:21:25.339 --> 03:21:33.347
SUPPORT. 1 77. SINCE RYAN OLSON
03:21:33.414 --> 03:21:34.882
WITH INCLUDED IN SANTA MONICA
03:21:34.949 --> 03:21:35.683
AND CALIFORNIA, AMBIEN STRONG
03:21:35.750 --> 03:21:43.090
SUPPORT. 2 75. THIS IS CARL
03:21:43.157 --> 03:21:44.292
TELLY, WITH NEIGHBORLY SANTA
03:21:44.358 --> 03:21:46.727
CRUZ CALLING AND STRONG SUPPORT.
03:21:46.794 --> 03:21:52.333
OR OH, FOUR. HI THIS IS ADAM
03:21:52.400 --> 03:21:54.969
PREVLAKA, RESIDENT OF SAN
03:21:55.036 --> 03:21:56.771
FRANCISCO, CALLING IN STRONG
03:21:56.838 --> 03:22:00.041
WITH STRONG SUPPORT FOR A B 2097
03:22:00.107 --> 03:22:01.642
. WE NEED TO BRING DOWN THE COST
03:22:01.709 --> 03:22:03.611
OF HOUSING TO MAKE IT AFFORDABLE
03:22:03.678 --> 03:22:08.349
FOR ALL 3 53. HELLO. CAN YOU
03:22:08.416 --> 03:22:14.555
HEAR ME? YES PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:22:14.622 --> 03:22:16.157
I'M SORRY. I DIDN'T HEAR MY
03:22:16.224 --> 03:22:18.092
NUMBER OF JOHN MINUTE. HE STAYED
03:22:18.159 --> 03:22:19.260
FOR EVERYONE. WE ARE IN STRONG
03:22:19.327 --> 03:22:24.866
SUPPORT. 2 22. TRY IT OUT. SEND
03:22:24.932 --> 03:22:27.001
SHALLOTS IN LOS ANGELES AND
03:22:27.068 --> 03:22:28.636
HOLLYWOOD CALLING AND STRONG
03:22:28.703 --> 03:22:33.140
pOWNER AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
03:22:33.207 --> 03:22:44.952
USER. THANK YOU. 402. SORRY MY
03:22:45.019 --> 03:22:46.521
NAME IS ROBERT FUTTERMAN WITH
03:22:46.587 --> 03:22:48.289
SAN FRANCISCO. UM, BE IN STRONG
03:22:48.356 --> 03:22:53.394
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LINE 407.
03:22:53.461 --> 03:22:55.029
THIS IS ALFRED TO IN BERKELEY,
03:22:55.096 --> 03:22:58.933
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. THANK
03:22:59.000 --> 03:23:00.101
YOU. NO FURTHER LINES IN QUEUE
03:23:00.167 --> 03:23:05.706
FOR SUPPORT. AND WE WILL GO TO
03:23:05.773 --> 03:23:07.508
NOW TO THE OPPOSITION. THERE'S
03:23:07.575 --> 03:23:08.643
NO LEAD OPPOSITION ANYONE
03:23:08.709 --> 03:23:11.412
PRESENT IN THE ROOM THAT WOULD
03:23:11.479 --> 03:23:12.613
LIKE TO SPEAK IN UP OPPOSITION.
03:23:12.680 --> 03:23:18.319
TO A B. 2097 YES, SIR. THANK
03:23:18.386 --> 03:23:19.754
YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
03:23:19.820 --> 03:23:20.655
COMMITTEE JEREMY SMITH, YOU ON
03:23:20.721 --> 03:23:22.623
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING
03:23:22.690 --> 03:23:23.391
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL, UM,
03:23:23.457 --> 03:23:26.327
IN OPPOSITION TO THE BILL TODAY
03:23:26.394 --> 03:23:27.461
, I'VE HAD JUST HAD A NICE
03:23:27.528 --> 03:23:28.529
CONVERSATION WITH THE AUTHOR.
03:23:28.596 --> 03:23:29.931
WE'VE HAD A COUPLE CONVERSATIONS
03:23:29.997 --> 03:23:33.000
ABOUT THIS BILL. UM IT IS ONE
03:23:33.067 --> 03:23:34.535
THAT WE ARE CONCERNED WITH
03:23:34.602 --> 03:23:36.237
SPECIFICALLY FOR OUR MEMBERSHIP.
03:23:36.304 --> 03:23:39.507
OUR MEMBERS ARE. CONSTRUCTION
03:23:39.574 --> 03:23:43.945
WORKERS. THEY. FOR THE MOST PART
03:23:44.011 --> 03:23:45.913
DRIVE TO AND FROM THEIR JOBS.
03:23:45.980 --> 03:23:48.416
THEY DON'T TAKE PUBLIC TRANSIT.
03:23:48.482 --> 03:23:52.019
UM, I WON'T SAY THEY DON'T. THEY
03:23:52.086 --> 03:23:53.554
MAINLY DON'T TAKE PUBLIC TRANSIT
03:23:53.621 --> 03:23:54.522
BECAUSE THEIR JOBS REQUIRE A
03:23:54.589 --> 03:23:58.993
GREAT AMOUNT OF EQUIPMENT. AND
03:23:59.060 --> 03:24:00.928
PROCESSES AND THINGS THEY NEED
03:24:00.995 --> 03:24:02.597
TO GET THROUGH THEIR WORKDAY. UM
03:24:02.663 --> 03:24:04.098
AND SO ELIMINATING PARKING
03:24:04.165 --> 03:24:07.335
MINIMUMS, UH, EVEN LIMITED IN
03:24:07.401 --> 03:24:10.571
SCOPE IT IN THE BILL. LIKE IT
03:24:10.638 --> 03:24:13.374
LIKE IT IS A CONCERN FOR US FOR
03:24:13.441 --> 03:24:15.176
OUR MEMBERS AND HOW THEY GET TO
03:24:15.242 --> 03:24:17.912
WORK AND DO THEIR JOBS. UM WE
03:24:17.979 --> 03:24:19.113
LOOK FORWARD TO LOOKING AT
03:24:19.180 --> 03:24:20.181
AMENDMENTS OUT OF COMMITTEE
03:24:20.247 --> 03:24:21.916
TODAY WHEN THEY'RE IN PRINT. IN
03:24:21.983 --> 03:24:23.651
LOOKING AT THE BILL CLOSELY AS
03:24:23.718 --> 03:24:25.319
WE HAVE, BUT FOR TODAY, WE DO
03:24:25.386 --> 03:24:26.387
REMAIN IN OPPOSITION
03:24:26.454 --> 03:24:30.091
RESPECTFULLY. AND MAYBE LOOK
03:24:30.157 --> 03:24:30.791
FORWARD TO LOOKING AT THE
03:24:30.858 --> 03:24:33.461
BUILDING OVER DECEMBER TO SEE IF
03:24:33.527 --> 03:24:34.695
WE CAN WHAT WE CAN DO. THANK
03:24:34.762 --> 03:24:37.031
YOU. THANK YOU. AND LET'S GO TO
03:24:37.098 --> 03:24:38.165
THE PHONES AND SEE IF THERE'S
03:24:38.232 --> 03:24:40.334
ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
03:24:40.401 --> 03:24:44.705
IN OPPOSITION TO A B 2097. THANK
03:24:44.772 --> 03:24:46.474
YOU TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION PRESS
03:24:46.540 --> 03:24:48.409
ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS TIME
03:24:48.476 --> 03:24:49.777
AGAIN, THAT'S ONE AND ZERO WILL
03:24:49.844 --> 03:24:54.115
GO FIRST TO LINE 3 23. GOOD
03:24:54.181 --> 03:24:55.583
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS DANA
03:24:55.650 --> 03:24:57.785
HUTCHINGS CALLING ON BEHALF OF
03:24:57.852 --> 03:24:58.986
THE CITY OF CARLSBAD, CORONA,
03:24:59.053 --> 03:25:00.021
EAST VAIL AND RANCHO PALOS
03:25:00.087 --> 03:25:12.400
VERDE. IN OPPOSITION. 1 98. GOOD
03:25:12.466 --> 03:25:14.001
AFTERNOON, TEARING MEMBERS. THIS
03:25:14.068 --> 03:25:16.237
IS BEHALF OF WESTERN CENTER ON
03:25:16.303 --> 03:25:17.672
LONG POVERTY AND CALIFORNIA
03:25:17.738 --> 03:25:18.372
RURAL LEGAL ASSISTANCE
03:25:18.439 --> 03:25:19.840
FOUNDATION. WE HAVE BEEN
03:25:19.907 --> 03:25:21.275
COMMUNICATING WITH THE MEMBER'S
03:25:21.342 --> 03:25:22.410
OFFICE ON AMENDMENTS TO ADDRESS
03:25:22.476 --> 03:25:23.511
VARIOUS EQUITY CONCERNS.
03:25:23.577 --> 03:25:24.578
UNFORTUNATELY THE LATEST ROUND
03:25:24.645 --> 03:25:25.946
OF AMENDMENTS DO NOT INCORPORATE
03:25:26.013 --> 03:25:27.581
THE PROTECTIONS REQUESTED AND
03:25:27.648 --> 03:25:29.817
THAT WE'RE GOING TO BLEED. MOVE
03:25:29.884 --> 03:25:31.185
US IN OPPOSING LESS CEMENT
03:25:31.252 --> 03:25:31.819
IMPORTS POSITION GOING FORWARD.
03:25:31.886 --> 03:25:32.820
WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
03:25:32.887 --> 03:25:33.788
THE CONVERSATION WITH THE
03:25:33.854 --> 03:25:34.889
AUTHOR'S OFFICE ON THE CHANGES
03:25:34.955 --> 03:25:36.290
REQUESTED THAT CONNECT BETWEEN
03:25:36.357 --> 03:25:38.159
97 TO THE CURRENT DENSITY BONUS
03:25:38.225 --> 03:25:43.798
FRAMEWORK. THANK YOU. 3 95.
03:25:43.864 --> 03:25:45.299
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS, SARAH
03:25:45.366 --> 03:25:46.801
FLOCKS REPRESENTING UNITE HERE
03:25:46.867 --> 03:25:49.036
LOCAL 11, THE UNION THAT
03:25:49.103 --> 03:25:50.871
REPRESENTS WORKERS IN HOTELS AND
03:25:50.938 --> 03:25:53.541
SPORTS ARENAS IN LOS ANGELES,
03:25:53.607 --> 03:25:55.209
AND WE'RE ALSO A BIT OF A
03:25:55.276 --> 03:25:56.510
TWEENER. WE APPRECIATE THE WORK
03:25:56.577 --> 03:25:58.212
THAT THE AUTHOR HAS DONE ON THE
03:25:58.279 --> 03:26:00.347
BILL, AND WE DO SUPPORT POLICIES
03:26:00.414 --> 03:26:01.348
THAT ADDRESS BOTH THE HOUSE
03:26:01.415 --> 03:26:03.217
AGAINST CLIMATE CRISIS. BUT WE
03:26:03.284 --> 03:26:05.686
ARE OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED
03:26:05.753 --> 03:26:07.888
SIMPLY TO EXEMPT HOTELS AND
03:26:07.955 --> 03:26:09.390
EVENT CENTERS FROM THE
03:26:09.457 --> 03:26:11.392
REQUIREMENTS OF THE BILL TO
03:26:11.459 --> 03:26:16.497
PROTECT WORKERS AND AFFORDABLE-HOUSING AT THE SAME TIME, AND WE
03:26:16.564 --> 03:26:17.064
CAN LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE
03:26:17.131 --> 03:26:18.065
WORKING WITH THE AUTHOR. THANK
03:26:18.132 --> 03:26:22.670
YOU. 1 57. EILEEN, BROKEN SAN
03:26:22.737 --> 03:26:28.676
FRANCISCO IN OPPOSITION. 200.
03:26:28.743 --> 03:26:31.078
PAMELA GIVE BERMAN IN PANORAMA
03:26:31.145 --> 03:26:33.547
CITY. I OPPOSE BABY 2097. THANK
03:26:33.614 --> 03:26:40.621
YOU. 3 92. GOOD AFTERNOON TO A
03:26:40.688 --> 03:26:42.089
MEMBERS HERE. ROSS ON BEHALF OF
03:26:42.156 --> 03:26:43.791
THE CITIES OF STAN MARCUS AND
03:26:43.858 --> 03:26:44.692
THE MARIN COUNTY COUNCIL OF
03:26:44.759 --> 03:26:46.393
MAYORS AND COUNCIL MEMBERS, BUT
03:26:46.460 --> 03:26:48.095
THANKFUL FOR THE AMENDMENTS THAT
03:26:48.162 --> 03:26:48.963
REMAIN OPPOSED TO THIS TIME. 1
03:26:49.029 --> 03:26:55.436
29. RECALL SAN FRANCISCO LIVABLE
03:26:55.503 --> 03:26:58.773
CALIFORNIA STRONGLY OPPOSED. 3
03:26:58.839 --> 03:27:04.478
37. HI. MARIANNE KING CALLING
03:27:04.545 --> 03:27:07.081
FROM CITY OF LOS ANGELES STILL
03:27:07.148 --> 03:27:09.016
CONFLICTS WITH OUR TOC PROGRAM,
03:27:09.083 --> 03:27:10.484
WHICH IS MORE STRINGENT SET
03:27:10.551 --> 03:27:11.786
ASIDE FOR VERY LOW INCOME AND
03:27:11.852 --> 03:27:13.788
LOW INCOME FOR THAT REASON, I AM
03:27:13.854 --> 03:27:20.294
OPPOSED. OR OH, FIVE. HEY THIS
03:27:20.361 --> 03:27:22.463
IS VERY MADISON AND SOUTH AWAY
03:27:22.530 --> 03:27:25.466
WITH LIVABLE CALIFORNIA OPPOSED
03:27:25.533 --> 03:27:26.967
TO THE SPELL IN THE POST TO THE
03:27:27.034 --> 03:27:28.102
INEQUITABLE AMENDMENTS BEING PUT
03:27:28.169 --> 03:27:35.009
FORWARD. THANK YOU. 3 24.
03:27:35.075 --> 03:27:35.509
ELIZABETH HENRY LOVETT,
03:27:35.576 --> 03:27:39.246
CALIFORNIA. LIVABLE CALIFORNIA
03:27:39.313 --> 03:27:40.214
STABLE LAFAYETTE AND UNITED
03:27:40.281 --> 03:27:43.984
NEIGHBORS. UM THE AUTHOR
03:27:44.051 --> 03:27:46.787
MENTIONED THAT THE ISSUE OF
03:27:46.854 --> 03:27:49.824
PARKING IS, UH, ONE SIZE FITS
03:27:49.890 --> 03:27:51.792
ALL AND NOW SHE'S GONE TO THE
03:27:51.859 --> 03:27:55.162
OTHER EXTREME TO SAY. THAT ONE
03:27:55.229 --> 03:27:57.798
SIZE FITS ALL FOR NO PARKING SO
03:27:57.865 --> 03:27:58.933
STRONGLY OPPOSED THIS FOR THAT
03:27:58.999 --> 03:28:08.576
REASON. 3 71. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
03:28:08.642 --> 03:28:11.011
NAME IS MAILING STEPHAN ON
03:28:11.078 --> 03:28:12.246
BEHALF OF SUNNYVALE, UNITED
03:28:12.313 --> 03:28:15.950
NEIGHBORS IN OPPOSITION. LET
03:28:16.016 --> 03:28:17.051
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND
03:28:17.117 --> 03:28:19.386
COMMUNITIES DECIDE WHAT IS BEST
03:28:19.453 --> 03:28:21.522
AND APPROPRIATE TO CHILDREN.
03:28:21.589 --> 03:28:25.025
TAKE OVER. EXCUSE ME. WE JUST
03:28:25.092 --> 03:28:26.093
NEED TO HEAR YOUR OPPOSITION.
03:28:26.160 --> 03:28:30.331
YOU ARE OPPOSED. SO THANK YOU. 3
03:28:30.397 --> 03:28:37.738
97. BUT I CAN, UM, CHAIR MEMBERS
03:28:37.805 --> 03:28:40.040
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF BEVERLY
03:28:40.107 --> 03:28:41.108
HILLS IN RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION.
03:28:41.175 --> 03:28:44.144
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NO FURTHER
03:28:44.211 --> 03:28:48.115
LINES IN Q AT THIS TIME. THANK
03:28:48.182 --> 03:28:50.517
YOU. THEN WE WILL GO BACK TO OUR
03:28:50.584 --> 03:28:51.285
DIAPHANOUS ASK WERE COMMENTS
03:28:51.352 --> 03:28:53.854
FROM EDITOR IRAQ. THANK YOU,
03:28:53.921 --> 03:28:59.226
MADAM CHAIR. SOME REMEMBERS. YOU
03:28:59.293 --> 03:29:00.461
KNOW, I REPRESENT A DISTRICT IN
03:29:00.527 --> 03:29:04.231
INLAND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. MM.
03:29:04.298 --> 03:29:06.533
AND AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW, WE
03:29:06.600 --> 03:29:08.302
DON'T FRANKLY HAVE RELIABLE OR
03:29:08.369 --> 03:29:12.006
FREQUENT PUBLIC TRANSIT. FROM
03:29:12.072 --> 03:29:16.076
HOMES OR APARTMENTS WHERE I AM.
03:29:16.143 --> 03:29:18.245
TO WORK IN ORANGE COUNTY OR LOS
03:29:18.312 --> 03:29:19.480
ANGELES, LOS ANGELES COUNTY,
03:29:19.546 --> 03:29:23.918
WHERE MANY OR MOST OF OUR JOBS
03:29:23.984 --> 03:29:25.052
ARE LOCATED. THAT'S JUST
03:29:25.119 --> 03:29:27.922
HISTORICALLY THE WAY IT'S BEEN.
03:29:27.988 --> 03:29:29.356
LAND HAS BEEN PLENTIFUL,
03:29:29.423 --> 03:29:31.959
PLENTIFUL USED TO BE CHEAP TO
03:29:32.026 --> 03:29:32.960
BUILDAFFORDABLE HOUSING. SO
03:29:33.027 --> 03:29:35.663
WORKERS LIVE WHERE I LIVE AND
03:29:35.729 --> 03:29:36.764
WORK. AND THOSE ARE THE
03:29:36.830 --> 03:29:39.733
CONSTITUENTS. I REPRESENT. SO IN
03:29:39.800 --> 03:29:41.735
MANY CASES, CARS CONTINUE TO BE
03:29:41.802 --> 03:29:43.003
REQUIRED IN ORDER TO MOVE PEOPLE
03:29:43.070 --> 03:29:45.539
FROM HOMES. TWO JOBS AND LOTS OF
03:29:45.606 --> 03:29:47.808
HOMES. AND, FRANKLY, LOTS OF
03:29:47.875 --> 03:29:52.579
JOBS. AND EVEN THOUGH WE.
03:29:52.646 --> 03:29:53.480
EVENTUALLY HOPE, HOPEFULLY
03:29:53.547 --> 03:29:56.650
SOONER RATHER THAN LATER.THAT
03:29:56.717 --> 03:29:58.752
WE CAN LINK NEW JOBS WITH THE
03:29:58.819 --> 03:30:00.020
HOUSING THAT WE HAVE IN SOUTHERN
03:30:00.087 --> 03:30:02.623
CALIFORNIA. AND WE'RE CERTAINLY
03:30:02.690 --> 03:30:04.525
WORKING ON IT AND TRYING TO PUSH
03:30:04.591 --> 03:30:07.161
A LINK. TO HOUSING TO GO
03:30:07.227 --> 03:30:09.763
BUSINESS AND JOB CREATION SO
03:30:09.830 --> 03:30:11.799
THAT WE CAN BRING JOBS OUT WHERE
03:30:11.865 --> 03:30:13.801
THE HOUSES ARE. WE'RE NOT HERE
03:30:13.867 --> 03:30:16.704
THAT WE'RE NOT. WE'RE NOT THERE.
03:30:16.770 --> 03:30:20.007
YET, SO I'M JUST WONDERING. IF
03:30:20.074 --> 03:30:22.977
YOUR BILL UM ADDRESSES THIS
03:30:23.043 --> 03:30:28.983
REGIONAL ISSUE. WHERE WE
03:30:29.049 --> 03:30:31.085
ELIMINATE PARKING REQUIREMENTS.
03:30:31.151 --> 03:30:34.722
FOR HOUSING WHERE PEOPLE. TAKE
03:30:34.788 --> 03:30:36.390
THE HOUSES BECAUSE THEY'RE
03:30:36.457 --> 03:30:37.891
AFFORDABLE BUT STILL HAVE TO
03:30:37.958 --> 03:30:40.794
TRANSIT TO JOBS AND, FRANKLY,
03:30:40.861 --> 03:30:42.329
IT'S VIRTUALLY IMPOSSIBLE TO
03:30:42.396 --> 03:30:44.331
TAKE THE TRAIN ON A FREQUENT OR
03:30:44.398 --> 03:30:47.334
RELIABLE BASIS. FROM EVEN THE
03:30:47.401 --> 03:30:48.602
CITY OF RIVERSIDE WITH 350,000
03:30:48.669 --> 03:30:51.705
PEOPLE. TO LOS ANGELES. AND LET
03:30:51.772 --> 03:30:55.075
ALONE TO GET THAT LAST OR FINAL
03:30:55.142 --> 03:30:58.178
MILE. OR MORE FROM THE TRAIN
03:30:58.245 --> 03:30:59.313
STATION, TWO JOBS. I THINK IT'S
03:30:59.380 --> 03:31:01.982
A PROBLEM. AND I'M JUST
03:31:02.049 --> 03:31:04.151
WONDERING IF THERE WAS ANY IF
03:31:04.218 --> 03:31:07.621
THERE'S ANY THOUGHT TO MAYBE
03:31:07.688 --> 03:31:11.458
MODIFYING THE BILL, TOO. PROVIDE
03:31:11.525 --> 03:31:13.894
SOME TIME FOR THOSE AREAS SUCH
03:31:13.961 --> 03:31:15.662
AS THE AREAS THAT I'M PRIVILEGED
03:31:15.729 --> 03:31:18.165
TO REPRESENT TO SORT OF CATCH UP
03:31:18.232 --> 03:31:19.600
WITH THE COASTAL URBAN AREAS
03:31:19.666 --> 03:31:21.568
WHEN IT COMES TO THE METRO OR
03:31:21.635 --> 03:31:24.438
BART. WELL OR OTHER PUBLIC
03:31:24.505 --> 03:31:30.611
TRANSIT. THANK YOU FOR THE
03:31:30.677 --> 03:31:32.513
QUESTION THAT CONCERN SO FIRST
03:31:32.579 --> 03:31:33.981
OF ALL, THE BILL ONLY LIFTS THE
03:31:34.048 --> 03:31:37.684
PARKING REQUIREMENTS. DIRECTLY
03:31:37.751 --> 03:31:39.887
ADJACENT TO HIGH QUALITY TRANSIT
03:31:39.953 --> 03:31:41.355
. SO IF YOU'RE IN A COMMUNITY
03:31:41.422 --> 03:31:43.157
LIKE I THINK WE HEARD ONE AT ONE
03:31:43.223 --> 03:31:44.458
OPPOSITION CALL FROM RANCHO
03:31:44.525 --> 03:31:47.261
PALOS VERDE IS I DON'T KNOW THE
03:31:47.327 --> 03:31:48.295
COMMUNITY THAT WELL, BUT I DON'T
03:31:48.362 --> 03:31:50.164
THINK THEY HAVE ANY HIGH QUALITY
03:31:50.230 --> 03:31:51.231
TRANSIT. IN THAT COMMUNITY, IT
03:31:51.298 --> 03:31:52.699
COULD BE WRONG. BY UNLESS YOU
03:31:52.766 --> 03:31:55.135
HAVE A TRAIN STOP OR A BUS STOP
03:31:55.202 --> 03:31:57.337
THAT HAS MULTIPLE BUS LINES.
03:31:57.404 --> 03:31:58.872
COMING TOGETHER AT VERY HIGH
03:31:58.939 --> 03:32:00.674
FREQUENCIES. WHAT MADE YOUR BUS
03:32:00.741 --> 03:32:01.809
STOP? NOT THE WHOLE ROUTE. BUT
03:32:01.875 --> 03:32:04.244
JUST THE STOP. THE BILL DOESN'T
03:32:04.311 --> 03:32:04.878
AFFECT YOU AT ALL. SO FOR YOUR
03:32:04.945 --> 03:32:07.014
COMMUNITY, THE ONLY AREAS THAT
03:32:07.081 --> 03:32:08.582
WE BE AFFECTED OR ONES NEXT TO
03:32:08.649 --> 03:32:10.384
METRO LINK I BELIEVE, AND MAYBE
03:32:10.451 --> 03:32:11.885
NEXT TO AN AMTRAK. IF YOU HAVE
03:32:11.952 --> 03:32:13.787
AN AMTRAK, STOP, WE HAVE A WE
03:32:13.854 --> 03:32:16.123
HAVE A WE HAVE A METROLINK, THE
03:32:16.190 --> 03:32:18.358
METROLINK. IT WOULD BE IMPACTED
03:32:18.425 --> 03:32:20.294
. YOU'D HAVE TO LOOK AT THE PIE.
03:32:20.360 --> 03:32:21.995
I DON'T KNOW ALL OF THE
03:32:22.062 --> 03:32:22.596
POPULATION THRESHOLDS BECAUSE
03:32:22.663 --> 03:32:24.765
THERE'S ALSO A QUARTER MILE IN
03:32:24.832 --> 03:32:26.800
THE SMALLER CITIES, AS OPPOSED
03:32:26.867 --> 03:32:28.235
TO THE HALF MILE, WHICH IS IN
03:32:28.302 --> 03:32:30.170
THE LARGER CITIES IN THAT
03:32:30.237 --> 03:32:31.038
QUARTER MILE IS VERY SMALL. IF
03:32:31.105 --> 03:32:33.073
YOU LOOK AT IT, SO YOU'RE
03:32:33.140 --> 03:32:34.208
TALKING ABOUT IN TOTAL LANDMASS
03:32:34.274 --> 03:32:34.741
OF DEVELOPMENT LAND. W'RE
03:32:34.808 --> 03:32:35.943
TALKING ABOUT A MINUSCULE AREA
03:32:36.009 --> 03:32:37.644
WHERE THIS WOULD GO INTO EFFECT
03:32:37.711 --> 03:32:39.213
RIGHT AROUND THOSE TRAINS,
03:32:39.279 --> 03:32:40.647
CHOPS, NOT THE WHOLE CITY. SO
03:32:40.714 --> 03:32:41.648
WHAT THAT WOULD ALLOW IS THAT
03:32:41.715 --> 03:32:43.684
THOSE RESIDENTS WHO ACTUALLY ARE
03:32:43.750 --> 03:32:44.952
USING THAT METRO LINK TO GET TO
03:32:45.018 --> 03:32:47.121
DOWNTOWN L. A. IT WILL GIVE THEM
03:32:47.187 --> 03:32:48.188
THE CHANCE OF RENTING AN
03:32:48.255 --> 03:32:49.590
APARTMENT. WALKING DISTANCE FROM
03:32:49.656 --> 03:32:51.291
THE METROLINK STOP THAT THEY ARE
03:32:51.358 --> 03:32:52.659
USING, BECAUSE A LOT OF PEOPLE
03:32:52.726 --> 03:32:55.562
STILL ARE USING IT AT LESS OF A
03:32:55.629 --> 03:32:56.630
PRICE THAN IF THEY WENT JUST A
03:32:56.697 --> 03:32:57.931
LITTLE FURTHER AWAY THAT
03:32:57.998 --> 03:32:58.699
APARTMENT A LITTLE FURTHER AWAY
03:32:58.765 --> 03:33:00.934
OUT OF THAT QUARTER, MILE OR
03:33:01.001 --> 03:33:01.435
HALF MILE. DEPENDING THE
03:33:01.502 --> 03:33:03.237
POPULATION THAT IS ALL THE
03:33:03.303 --> 03:33:03.804
PARKING REQUIREMENTS STILL
03:33:03.871 --> 03:33:04.471
INTACT. THEY WOULD SELF SELECT
03:33:04.538 --> 03:33:06.240
ONE OF THOSE IF THEY REALLY
03:33:06.306 --> 03:33:07.808
NEEDED A CAR, BUT THERE ARE
03:33:07.875 --> 03:33:09.176
PEOPLE WHO LIVE ALL AROUND NEAR
03:33:09.243 --> 03:33:10.410
METRO STATIONS WHO ACTUALLY DO
03:33:10.477 --> 03:33:11.845
USE THEM TO GET TO WORK. THOSE
03:33:11.912 --> 03:33:13.714
PEOPLE RIGHT NOW ARE PAYING FOR
03:33:13.780 --> 03:33:14.882
A SPOT WHETHER THEY USE IT OR
03:33:14.948 --> 03:33:16.717
NOT. THE OTHER THING IS A LOT OF
03:33:16.783 --> 03:33:18.652
THE CITIES THAT HAVE THOSE JOB
03:33:18.719 --> 03:33:19.820
DESTINATIONS HAVE DONE A LOT
03:33:19.887 --> 03:33:21.622
WITH THAT FIRST MILE LAST MILE
03:33:21.688 --> 03:33:23.257
ISSUE. METRO RIGHT NOW HAS METRO
03:33:23.323 --> 03:33:24.558
ON DEMAND. I THINK IT'S CALLED,
03:33:24.625 --> 03:33:25.792
OR I CAN'T REMEMBER WHAT IT'S
03:33:25.859 --> 03:33:27.027
CALLED WHERE THEY'LL TAKE YOU
03:33:27.094 --> 03:33:28.061
ANYWHERE WITHIN THAT SERVICE
03:33:28.128 --> 03:33:31.265
AREA FOR I THINK IT'S $1. ON
03:33:31.331 --> 03:33:32.866
DEMAND LIKE A RIDE SHARE SERVICE
03:33:32.933 --> 03:33:35.002
THAT YOU CAN CALL ON YOUR PHONE.
03:33:35.068 --> 03:33:37.137
IT'S AN APP AND THEY COME AND
03:33:37.204 --> 03:33:38.572
THEY GET YOU AND THEY TAKE YOU
03:33:38.639 --> 03:33:39.907
WITHIN THAT LARGE ZONE TO WORK
03:33:39.973 --> 03:33:41.742
TO SOLVE EXACTLY THAT PROBLEM,
03:33:41.808 --> 03:33:42.943
BUT I'LL TELL YOU AS SOMEONE WHO
03:33:43.010 --> 03:33:44.711
REPRESENTS A CITY. THAT GROWS BY
03:33:44.778 --> 03:33:46.046
100,000 PEOPLE EVERY DAY. ONE OF
03:33:46.113 --> 03:33:48.148
THE CITY'S I REPRESENT 100,000
03:33:48.215 --> 03:33:49.383
PEOPLE AT NIGHT AND 100,000
03:33:49.449 --> 03:33:50.484
PEOPLE WHO COME TO WORK EVERY
03:33:50.551 --> 03:33:52.886
DAY. FORCING THOSE PEOPLE ARE
03:33:52.953 --> 03:33:54.154
ENCOURAGING THOSE PEOPLE TO
03:33:54.221 --> 03:33:55.923
DRIVE IN FROM RIVERSIDE FROM
03:33:55.989 --> 03:33:57.491
OTHER PLACES EVERY DAY WHEN WE
03:33:57.558 --> 03:33:58.926
HAVE METROLINK THAT WE'VE ALL
03:33:58.992 --> 03:34:00.260
INVESTED BILLIONS ON AND WHEN WE
03:34:00.327 --> 03:34:02.129
HAVE THE PARKING NEAR THOSE
03:34:02.196 --> 03:34:02.663
METROLINK STATIONS FURTHER
03:34:02.729 --> 03:34:04.631
REMOTE REALLY NOT ONLY PUNISHES
03:34:04.698 --> 03:34:07.334
EVERYBODY ON THE HIGHWAY AND
03:34:07.401 --> 03:34:07.935
LEADS TO MORE CONGESTION BUT
03:34:08.001 --> 03:34:08.969
REALLY PUNISHES THE PEOPLE IN
03:34:09.036 --> 03:34:10.871
THOSE COMMUNITIES TO WHEN WE
03:34:10.938 --> 03:34:12.239
HAVE ALL DECIDED TO SPEND
03:34:12.306 --> 03:34:13.340
BILLIONS AND BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
03:34:13.407 --> 03:34:15.409
AS A STATE. ON THOSE METROLINK
03:34:15.475 --> 03:34:17.211
TRAINS. SO FOR THE PEOPLE WHO
03:34:17.277 --> 03:34:18.745
AND I UNDERSTAND THAT THE
03:34:18.812 --> 03:34:20.414
SERVICE ISN'T ALWAYS THERE ALL
03:34:20.480 --> 03:34:21.748
THE TIME. BUT THAT'S WHY WE NEED
03:34:21.815 --> 03:34:23.817
TO GET MORE. WE NEED TO GET THE
03:34:23.884 --> 03:34:25.118
RIDERSHIP UP TO. IT'S A CHICKEN
03:34:25.185 --> 03:34:26.954
AND THE EGG PROBLEM. THE PROBLEM
03:34:27.020 --> 03:34:28.188
WE HAVE, OF COURSE. IS WE SHARE
03:34:28.255 --> 03:34:30.357
THE SHARE THE RAIL LINE WITH THE
03:34:30.424 --> 03:34:33.293
FREIGHT LINE. AND SO I TOOK IT
03:34:33.360 --> 03:34:34.761
FAIRLY FREQUENTLY IN THE LOS
03:34:34.828 --> 03:34:36.663
ANGELES YOU HAD ABOUT THREE
03:34:36.730 --> 03:34:38.298
CHOICES IN THE MORNING.AND
03:34:38.365 --> 03:34:40.534
AFTER 8 30 YOU COULDN'T GET IN.
03:34:40.601 --> 03:34:44.204
YOU HAD LIMITED CHOICES IF YOU
03:34:44.271 --> 03:34:45.706
MISSED THE 12 30 TRAIN COMING
03:34:45.772 --> 03:34:47.874
BACK EAST. YOU WENT TO WAIT
03:34:47.941 --> 03:34:49.576
UNTIL 4 30 IF YOU MISSED THE 6
03:34:49.643 --> 03:34:52.379
25 TRAIN OUT OF UNION STATION.
03:34:52.446 --> 03:34:55.048
YOU COULDN'T GET BACK AT ALL. SO
03:34:55.115 --> 03:34:57.384
THOSE OF YOU WHO LIVE IN L, A
03:34:57.451 --> 03:34:58.585
COUNTY OR LIVING IN A DIFFERENT
03:34:58.652 --> 03:35:00.153
WORLD. AND I THINK YOU NEED TO
03:35:00.220 --> 03:35:02.456
UNDERSTAND THOSE OF US WHO LIVE
03:35:02.522 --> 03:35:03.924
A LITTLE BIT EAST OF YOU THAT
03:35:03.991 --> 03:35:06.226
IT'S NOT QUITE THE SAME
03:35:06.293 --> 03:35:07.361
TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS FROM A
03:35:07.427 --> 03:35:08.962
PUBLIC STANDPOINT ARE VERY
03:35:09.029 --> 03:35:10.163
LIMITED AND THERE'S VIRTUALLY NO
03:35:10.230 --> 03:35:12.833
WAY TO TAKE A BUS. BECAUSE
03:35:12.899 --> 03:35:14.801
BUSSES CROSS COUNTY LINES AND
03:35:14.868 --> 03:35:16.470
YOU CAN'T TAKE A BUS FROM
03:35:16.536 --> 03:35:17.938
RIVERSIDE RELIABLY TO GET TO
03:35:18.005 --> 03:35:20.440
WORK IN LOS ANGELES DOWNTOWN OR
03:35:20.507 --> 03:35:22.142
ANYWHERE IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY,
03:35:22.209 --> 03:35:26.079
SO I GUESS I HAVE ONE QUESTION.
03:35:26.146 --> 03:35:27.814
DO YOU HAVE? AND I'VE BEEN OFF
03:35:27.881 --> 03:35:30.217
THIS COMMITTEE FOR A WHILE AND
03:35:30.284 --> 03:35:31.451
I'M JUST SUBSTITUTING TODAY. AND
03:35:31.518 --> 03:35:32.753
I SHOULD HAVE STARTED OUT BY
03:35:32.819 --> 03:35:33.954
SAYING I'M CERTAINLY GOING TO
03:35:34.021 --> 03:35:35.722
SUPPORT THIS CONCEPT AND MOVE
03:35:35.789 --> 03:35:37.124
THIS BILL OUT OF THIS COMMITTEE.
03:35:37.190 --> 03:35:38.759
BUT IT DOES BOTHER ME WHEN WE
03:35:38.825 --> 03:35:41.161
HAVE A ONE SIZE FITS ALL
03:35:41.228 --> 03:35:42.229
APPROACH TO THESE ISSUES. WHAT
03:35:42.296 --> 03:35:44.264
WORKS IN LOS ANGELES COUNTY
03:35:44.331 --> 03:35:46.066
SIMPLY DOES NOT WORK IN PARTS OF
03:35:46.133 --> 03:35:48.635
INLAND SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA. AND
03:35:48.702 --> 03:35:50.137
IT HURTS ME THAT IT DOESN'T
03:35:50.203 --> 03:35:51.638
BECAUSE I CERTAINLY SUPPORT THE
03:35:51.705 --> 03:35:53.407
CONCEPT, AND I CERTAINLY HOPE
03:35:53.473 --> 03:35:55.742
THAT AS THE BILL MOVES FORWARD
03:35:55.809 --> 03:35:56.910
YOU'LL TAKE ANOTHER LOOK AT AT
03:35:56.977 --> 03:36:01.181
FOLKS WHERE I LIVE. MAYBE IN
03:36:01.248 --> 03:36:02.449
PAST ITERATIONS OF THE HOUSING
03:36:02.516 --> 03:36:03.517
COMMITTEE WHEN WE'VE HAD THESE
03:36:03.583 --> 03:36:06.086
BILLS THAT I'VE ALSO SUPPORTED
03:36:06.153 --> 03:36:08.155
UM, THERE'S BEEN SOME MAPPING
03:36:08.221 --> 03:36:09.323
DONE. AND MAYBE YOU HAVE SOME
03:36:09.389 --> 03:36:11.758
MAPPING THAT OF AREAS AND IN THE
03:36:11.825 --> 03:36:12.592
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA THAT WILL
03:36:12.659 --> 03:36:14.528
ILLUSTRATE EXACTLY WHAT YOU'RE
03:36:14.594 --> 03:36:15.696
TALKING ABOUT. IN TERMS OF THE
03:36:15.762 --> 03:36:18.398
LIMITED CIRCUMFERENCE OF THE
03:36:18.465 --> 03:36:21.435
CIRCLE AROUND THE METRO STATION.
03:36:21.501 --> 03:36:24.004
OR HIGH FREQUENCY BUS STOP WHICH
03:36:24.071 --> 03:36:26.606
WE SINCE WE DON'T HAVE VERY
03:36:26.673 --> 03:36:28.208
EFFECTIVE BUS SERVICE. I SUSPECT
03:36:28.275 --> 03:36:29.676
DEPENDING ON THE DEFINITION OF
03:36:29.743 --> 03:36:31.645
HIGH FREQUENCY, WE DON'T HAVE
03:36:31.712 --> 03:36:34.214
THAT AND I WOULD LIKE TO LOOK AT
03:36:34.281 --> 03:36:34.948
THAT TO SEE THE IMPACT. I'M
03:36:35.015 --> 03:36:37.084
GOING TO SUPPORT YOUR BILL.
03:36:37.150 --> 03:36:38.185
THANK YOU FOR WORKING ON THIS.
03:36:38.251 --> 03:36:43.123
IT'S AN IMPORTANT CONCEPT. RIGHT
03:36:43.190 --> 03:36:44.157
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, SENATOR
03:36:44.224 --> 03:36:45.325
COURTESY. YOU KNOW, I JUST WANT
03:36:45.392 --> 03:36:50.897
TO, UM. I WANT TO SAY FIRST OF
03:36:50.964 --> 03:36:53.433
ALL, THANK YOU TO THE AUTHOR AND
03:36:53.500 --> 03:36:54.101
THANK YOU FOR SPENDING AN AWFUL
03:36:54.167 --> 03:36:55.502
LOT OF TIME WITH ME. UM, GIVEN
03:36:55.569 --> 03:36:57.337
THAT I'M JUST ONE. LEGISLATOR
03:36:57.404 --> 03:37:00.073
COMMITTEE MEMBER ON YOU KNOW, ON
03:37:00.140 --> 03:37:01.742
SOME, I WOULDN'T CALL THEM
03:37:01.808 --> 03:37:03.243
NUANCES, BUT ON SOME DISTRICT,
03:37:03.310 --> 03:37:06.546
UM SPECIFIC STUFF THAT I HAVE TO
03:37:06.613 --> 03:37:07.814
DEAL WITH HALF OF THE DISTRICT
03:37:07.881 --> 03:37:12.486
THAT I REPRESENT. MM ABOUT 80%
03:37:12.552 --> 03:37:13.854
OF THE DISTRICT IS THE CITY OF
03:37:13.920 --> 03:37:15.889
SAN JOSE. IN ABOUT HALF OF THAT
03:37:15.956 --> 03:37:17.023
IS WHAT WE CALL THE SAN JOSE
03:37:17.090 --> 03:37:19.226
WHICH IS ACTUALLY WHERE I LIVE.
03:37:19.292 --> 03:37:25.699
BUT AND THE HIGHER. AREAS OF
03:37:25.766 --> 03:37:28.368
POVERTY IN EAST SAN JOSE, OR
03:37:28.435 --> 03:37:29.302
SIGNIFICANT AS ANYWHERE ELSE IN
03:37:29.369 --> 03:37:31.138
THE STATE. WE HAVE A MAJORITY
03:37:31.204 --> 03:37:33.407
GANG AFFILIATED NEIGHBORHOODS
03:37:33.473 --> 03:37:36.109
AND WE DID THE RIGHT THING. WE
03:37:36.176 --> 03:37:38.178
SAID WE HAVE A TRANSIT DEPENDENT
03:37:38.245 --> 03:37:39.446
NEIGHBORHOOD LARGELY BECAUSE OF
03:37:39.513 --> 03:37:40.080
THE PROPERTY, SO WE'RE GOING TO
03:37:40.147 --> 03:37:44.317
RUN. HIGH SPEED. UM DEDICATED
03:37:44.384 --> 03:37:45.952
CORRIDOR FOR BUS RAPID TRANSIT A
03:37:46.019 --> 03:37:48.555
LITTLE BIT CHEAPER THAN BEEN
03:37:48.622 --> 03:37:50.023
LIGHT RAIL, AND THAT'S WHAT
03:37:50.090 --> 03:37:52.292
WE'RE GONNA DO RIGHT DOWN THE
03:37:52.359 --> 03:37:54.728
MIDDLE THROUGH THAT AREA. UM SO
03:37:54.795 --> 03:37:56.797
WITH THAT CREATES IS THE VERY
03:37:56.863 --> 03:38:00.434
CHALLENGING ISSUE WHEN I LOOK AT
03:38:00.500 --> 03:38:01.635
GOVERNMENT FINANCE COMMITTEE
03:38:01.701 --> 03:38:04.204
AMENDMENTS, YOU KNOW, B. I LOOK
03:38:04.271 --> 03:38:06.273
AT THAT ENVIOUSLY BECAUSE IT
03:38:06.339 --> 03:38:07.808
SAYS, YOU KNOW THE POPULATION
03:38:07.874 --> 03:38:09.709
75,000 OR MORE THAT'S IN THE
03:38:09.776 --> 03:38:10.944
COUNTY OF LESS THAN 600,000
03:38:11.011 --> 03:38:12.045
RESIDENTS, YOU KNOW, GETS A
03:38:12.112 --> 03:38:14.514
QUARTER MILE STOP. WHICH IS IN
03:38:14.581 --> 03:38:16.616
THOSE KIND OF NEIGHBORHOODS
03:38:16.683 --> 03:38:18.518
WHICH, BY THE WAY IS IT IS IT
03:38:18.585 --> 03:38:20.320
IS, I THINK, PROBABLY. NO I'M
03:38:20.387 --> 03:38:22.255
NOT TALKING ABOUT AN AREA OF TWO
03:38:22.322 --> 03:38:23.323
OR THREE BLOCKS OR YOU KNOW A
03:38:23.390 --> 03:38:24.991
FEW 1000 SQUARE FEET OF
03:38:25.058 --> 03:38:25.826
RESIDENTIAL AND TALKING ABOUT
03:38:25.892 --> 03:38:28.195
WHAT IS PROBABLY ABOUT 30% OF
03:38:28.261 --> 03:38:30.230
THE CITY OF SAN JOSE, ALL OF
03:38:30.297 --> 03:38:34.100
WHICH I REPRESENT. HE YOU KNOW,
03:38:34.167 --> 03:38:35.936
I CAN'T GO INTO THOSE REDLINED
03:38:36.002 --> 03:38:39.372
NEIGHBORHOODS. SUPPORTING THE
03:38:39.439 --> 03:38:43.743
HALF MILE. THE HALF MILE
03:38:43.810 --> 03:38:44.811
RELATIONSHIP TO THE TRANSIT
03:38:44.878 --> 03:38:46.580
STOPS REGARDING PARKING. YOU
03:38:46.646 --> 03:38:47.647
KNOW, WITH ANY KIND OF
03:38:47.714 --> 03:38:50.884
CONSCIENCE OR JOY. THAT SAID
03:38:50.951 --> 03:38:52.652
WE'VE TALKED ABOUT IT. I HOPE
03:38:52.719 --> 03:38:55.322
THAT YOU KNOW YOU'RE THIS IS
03:38:55.388 --> 03:38:57.357
COMPASSIONATE AS YOU'VE BEEN AS
03:38:57.424 --> 03:38:58.859
AN AUTHOR ABOUT THAT ISSUE IN,
03:38:58.925 --> 03:39:00.794
YOU KNOW, I KNOW YOUR DESIRE IS
03:39:00.861 --> 03:39:02.729
NOT HAVE ANY KIND OF A NEGATIVE
03:39:02.796 --> 03:39:05.065
IMPACT ON NEIGHBORHOODS SET
03:39:05.131 --> 03:39:06.132
UNFORTUNATELY, BECAUSE OF THE
03:39:06.199 --> 03:39:09.402
HOUSING CRISIS BECAUSE ALSO HAVE
03:39:09.469 --> 03:39:11.505
THE STIGMA THAT I HAVE IN MY
03:39:11.571 --> 03:39:15.308
COMMUNITY. WHICH IS VERY, VERY
03:39:15.375 --> 03:39:16.910
PERTINENT TO THIS COMMITTEE IS
03:39:16.977 --> 03:39:18.478
THAT WE HAVE THE HIGHEST RENTAL
03:39:18.545 --> 03:39:20.146
HOUSING COSTS IN THE STATE. THE
03:39:20.213 --> 03:39:22.282
HIGHEST MEDIAN HOUSING PRICES IN
03:39:22.349 --> 03:39:24.951
THE STATE. AND SO WE HAVE WHAT
03:39:25.018 --> 03:39:26.686
WERE REDLINED NEIGHBORHOODS,
03:39:26.753 --> 03:39:28.688
WHICH ARE NOW 4 TO 5 FAMILIES IN
03:39:28.755 --> 03:39:32.659
A RENTAL UNIT. PARKING CARS.
03:39:32.726 --> 03:39:33.860
DOUBLE PARKED IN, YOU KNOW ON
03:39:33.927 --> 03:39:37.197
WANDS AND I MEAN, YOU GOTTA YOU
03:39:37.264 --> 03:39:38.298
GOTTA COMMUNITY MEETING AT
03:39:38.365 --> 03:39:39.799
SOMEBODY AT A NEIGHBOR'S HOUSE
03:39:39.866 --> 03:39:41.501
AND LITERALLY DOESN'T MATTER OF
03:39:41.568 --> 03:39:42.903
YOUR STATE SENATOR CITY COUNCIL
03:39:42.969 --> 03:39:44.371
MEMBER. WHATEVER YOU CAN'T YOU
03:39:44.437 --> 03:39:45.939
CAN'T FIND A PLACE TO PARK. YOU
03:39:46.006 --> 03:39:47.207
CAN TAKE THE TRANSPORTATION
03:39:47.274 --> 03:39:49.643
LINE. BUT YOU FUNDAMENTALLY AND
03:39:49.709 --> 03:39:50.844
I'M NOT EXAGGERATING, WOULD NEED
03:39:50.911 --> 03:39:54.147
TO HAVE SECURITY WITH YOU IF
03:39:54.214 --> 03:39:56.082
YOU'RE GOING TO WALK MORE THAN
03:39:56.149 --> 03:39:58.318
ABOUT A BLOCK, SO THESE ARE
03:39:58.385 --> 03:40:00.253
THINGS I HVE TO WEIGH OUT IN,
03:40:00.320 --> 03:40:02.556
AND I JUST WANTED TO SEE THOSE
03:40:02.622 --> 03:40:03.757
ON THE RECORD, NOT AS ANY KIND
03:40:03.823 --> 03:40:07.394
OF BADGERING OF THE AUTHOR AT
03:40:07.460 --> 03:40:08.695
ALL. BUT TO SAY THAT THE AUTHOR
03:40:08.762 --> 03:40:12.933
IS VERY GRACIOUSLY TAKEN THAT
03:40:12.999 --> 03:40:14.601
ALL IN INTO CONSIDERATION IN
03:40:14.668 --> 03:40:17.971
TERMS OF MOVING FORWARD. AND OF
03:40:18.038 --> 03:40:19.839
COURSE, AS THE BILL MOVES
03:40:19.906 --> 03:40:20.974
FORWARD, I'M GOING TO HAVE TO
03:40:21.041 --> 03:40:23.009
KEEP MYEYE. YOU KNOW, AS WE ALL
03:40:23.076 --> 03:40:26.012
DO TO THE NO, THE SITUATION IN
03:40:26.079 --> 03:40:27.881
MY OWN DISTRICT AND WHATEVER I
03:40:27.948 --> 03:40:29.215
FEEL MY RESPONSIBILITY IS TO
03:40:29.282 --> 03:40:30.750
THOSE NEIGHBORHOODS THAT ARE
03:40:30.817 --> 03:40:32.519
CURRENTLY VERY DISADVANTAGED
03:40:32.586 --> 03:40:35.522
RELATIVE TO ALL THIS SO I
03:40:35.589 --> 03:40:36.723
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY
03:40:36.790 --> 03:40:39.059
COMMENTS AND WE HAD A LONG
03:40:39.125 --> 03:40:39.826
COMMITTEE MEETING AND I DON'T
03:40:39.893 --> 03:40:40.894
USUALLY MAKE LENGTHY COMMENTS,
03:40:40.961 --> 03:40:43.196
BUT IT'S AN IMPORTANT BILL. I
03:40:43.263 --> 03:40:45.398
LOVE THE COMMERCIAL PART OF IT
03:40:45.465 --> 03:40:46.933
TO DEATH. I LOVE IT. IT'S JUST
03:40:47.000 --> 03:40:49.002
THIS ONE AREA. I DESCRIBED THIS
03:40:49.069 --> 03:40:50.003
VERY CHALLENGING FOR ME. THANK
03:40:50.070 --> 03:40:51.738
YOU. YES, GO AHEAD. IT'S YOUR
03:40:51.805 --> 03:40:57.477
SKINNER. ALL RIGHT. I FEEL LIKE
03:40:57.544 --> 03:40:59.613
I'M EVER IN A DEJA VU CARRIED A
03:40:59.679 --> 03:41:00.814
BILL VERY COMPARABLE TO THIS IN
03:41:00.880 --> 03:41:04.884
2010. HAD THAT BILL PASSED, WE
03:41:04.951 --> 03:41:06.853
WOULD HAVE FAR MORE UNITS OF
03:41:06.920 --> 03:41:08.088
HOUSING TODAY, 12 YEARS LATER
03:41:08.154 --> 03:41:11.157
THAN WE DO, BECAUSE THE
03:41:11.224 --> 03:41:12.592
REQUIREMENT OF PARKING MAKES
03:41:12.659 --> 03:41:16.997
HOUSING MORE EXPENSIVE. AND. THE
03:41:17.063 --> 03:41:19.165
IRONY HERE, I THINK IS THAT IN
03:41:19.232 --> 03:41:23.403
THOSE NEIGHBORHOODS WHERE THE
03:41:23.470 --> 03:41:28.908
BUILDER OF THE HOUSING. REALIZES
03:41:28.975 --> 03:41:31.845
THAT THAT HOUSING WILL NOT BE
03:41:31.911 --> 03:41:33.980
FEASIBLE, MEANING THEY WON'T
03:41:34.047 --> 03:41:35.115
EITHER BE ABLE TO RENT IT OR
03:41:35.181 --> 03:41:37.083
SELL IT. IF IT DOESN'T HAVE
03:41:37.150 --> 03:41:38.084
HOUSING, THEY WILL INCLUDE
03:41:38.151 --> 03:41:40.086
HOUSING. NOW LET ME JUST MAKE
03:41:40.153 --> 03:41:41.221
SURE THAT OUR PARKING SORRY.
03:41:41.287 --> 03:41:42.589
SORRY THEY WILL. MAKE SURE THAT
03:41:42.656 --> 03:41:45.959
THAT HOUSING INCLUDES PARKING SO
03:41:46.026 --> 03:41:46.826
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. CAN YOU
03:41:46.893 --> 03:41:50.563
CLARIFY THIS BILL PROHIBITS THE
03:41:50.630 --> 03:41:51.898
LOCAL GOVERNMENT FROM REQUIRING
03:41:51.965 --> 03:41:54.267
IT. IT DOES NOT PROHIBIT THE
03:41:54.334 --> 03:41:56.236
BUILDER OF THE DEVELOPER FROM
03:41:56.302 --> 03:41:57.337
FROM PUTTING HOUSING FROM
03:41:57.404 --> 03:41:59.839
PUTTING THE PARKING IN CORRECT.
03:41:59.906 --> 03:42:01.174
ABSOLUTELY AND FROM CITIES THAT
03:42:01.241 --> 03:42:02.942
HAVE DONE THIS, THEY ARE STILL
03:42:03.009 --> 03:42:05.578
BUILDING PARKING. OKAY, SO I
03:42:05.645 --> 03:42:09.683
GUESS FOR, UM NOT TOO. MAKE MY
03:42:09.749 --> 03:42:11.384
COLLEAGUE FROM SAN JOSE MEAN HE
03:42:11.451 --> 03:42:12.719
KNOWS HIS NEIGHBORHOODS FAR
03:42:12.786 --> 03:42:13.853
BETTER THAN MINE, BUT I THINK
03:42:13.920 --> 03:42:15.622
MANY OF THE NEIGHBORHOODS THAN I
03:42:15.689 --> 03:42:16.690
DO THEN MANY OF THE
03:42:16.756 --> 03:42:17.891
NEIGHBORHOODS YOU'RE DESCRIBING
03:42:17.957 --> 03:42:19.159
I DON'T HAVE ANYBODY TRYING TO
03:42:19.225 --> 03:42:20.894
BUILD MULTI FAMILY HOUSING RIGHT
03:42:20.960 --> 03:42:23.563
NOW. UNFORTUNATELY, AND FOR MOST
03:42:23.630 --> 03:42:25.865
OF OUR VARIOUS FOUR DOBLE UNITS
03:42:25.932 --> 03:42:28.101
, THEY VERY THEY VERY MUCH WORK
03:42:28.168 --> 03:42:29.369
WITH THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT TO
03:42:29.436 --> 03:42:31.004
REDUCE THE HOUSING REQUIREMENT
03:42:31.071 --> 03:42:32.405
THAT PARKING REQUIREMENT BECAUSE
03:42:32.472 --> 03:42:36.076
THEY CANNOT MAKE IT PENCIL. THEY
03:42:36.142 --> 03:42:39.879
CANNOT DO THE YOU KNOW 40% OR
03:42:39.946 --> 03:42:42.248
50% OF AM I IF THEY REQUIRE THE
03:42:42.315 --> 03:42:44.117
HOUSING WE JUST THERE WAS JUST
03:42:44.184 --> 03:42:46.152
AN ARTICLE TODAY. THAT WE'RE NOW
03:42:46.219 --> 03:42:49.422
SEEING THE COST EVEN OF THE MOST
03:42:49.489 --> 03:42:50.523
AFFORDABLE UNITS IS COMING UP TO
03:42:50.590 --> 03:42:52.992
A MILLION DOLLARS A UNIT. SO WHY
03:42:53.059 --> 03:42:55.929
WE WOULDN'T DO EVERYTHING WE CAN
03:42:55.995 --> 03:42:58.364
TO MAKE HOUSING MORE AFFORDABLE
03:42:58.431 --> 03:42:59.966
AND CLEARLY, ALL THIS DOES IS
03:43:00.033 --> 03:43:01.568
REMOVED THE REQUIREMENT IT DOES
03:43:01.634 --> 03:43:04.704
NOT PROHIBIT. THE CONTRACTOR,
03:43:04.771 --> 03:43:07.040
THE BUILDER, THE DEVELOPER FROM
03:43:07.107 --> 03:43:09.976
IF PARKING IS NECESSARY FOR THAT
03:43:10.043 --> 03:43:13.046
HOUSING TO WORK FROM HAVING
03:43:13.113 --> 03:43:14.314
HOUSING IN THE THEIR APPLICANT
03:43:14.380 --> 03:43:15.815
OR HAVING PARKING IN THEIR
03:43:15.882 --> 03:43:19.419
APPLICATION. SO UM, IT WAS
03:43:19.486 --> 03:43:20.820
INTERESTING. ONE OF THE KEY
03:43:20.887 --> 03:43:22.422
WITNESSES WAS ALSO LIKE KEY
03:43:22.489 --> 03:43:23.957
WITNESS. WHAT? I CARRIED THIS
03:43:24.023 --> 03:43:26.292
BILL BACK THEN. I WISH WE HAD IT
03:43:26.359 --> 03:43:27.894
WAS A BIT DIFFERENT, BUT YOU
03:43:27.961 --> 03:43:29.496
KNOW, IT DOESN'T MATTER. IT WAS
03:43:29.562 --> 03:43:30.563
STILL A VARIATION ON TRYING TO
03:43:30.630 --> 03:43:35.702
REDUCE THE REQUIREMENT OF
03:43:35.769 --> 03:43:37.203
PARKING, NOT ELIMINATE PARKING
03:43:37.270 --> 03:43:40.039
BUT REDUCE THE REQUIREMENT. SO
03:43:40.106 --> 03:43:43.343
WITH THAT I WILL MOVE THE BILL.
03:43:43.409 --> 03:43:44.911
AND I KNOW THAT THE BILL HAD THE
03:43:44.978 --> 03:43:47.514
COMMITTEE'S HOW'D AMENDMENTS AND
03:43:47.580 --> 03:43:48.481
YOU'RE TAKING THE COMMITTEE'S
03:43:48.548 --> 03:43:50.283
AMENDMENTS RIGHT, SO I WILL MOVE
03:43:50.350 --> 03:43:51.451
THE BILL WITH THE COMMITTEE'S
03:43:51.518 --> 03:43:54.988
AMENDMENTS. AND.
03:43:55.054 --> 03:43:55.622
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN. WOULD
03:43:55.688 --> 03:43:59.492
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I REALLY
03:43:59.559 --> 03:44:00.927
APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS AND I
03:44:00.994 --> 03:44:01.928
DON'T TAKE ANY OF THEM LIGHTLY.
03:44:01.995 --> 03:44:03.863
AND THERE'S TRUTH TO EVERYTHING
03:44:03.930 --> 03:44:05.532
THAT YOU ALL SAY, AND WE ARE
03:44:05.598 --> 03:44:07.167
DOING OUR BEST AS THE BILL MOVES
03:44:07.233 --> 03:44:08.735
THROUGH TO ADDRESS WHATEVER WE
03:44:08.802 --> 03:44:10.103
CAN ADDRESS, AND I WOULD JUST
03:44:10.170 --> 03:44:11.538
SAY THAT FOR THOSE WHO HAVE
03:44:11.604 --> 03:44:12.739
CONCERNS TO LOOK AT HOW THIS IS
03:44:12.806 --> 03:44:13.773
ACTUALLY PLAYED OUT IN
03:44:13.840 --> 03:44:16.109
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE DONE IT.
03:44:16.176 --> 03:44:17.143
WHERE DEVELOPERS ARE BEING
03:44:17.210 --> 03:44:17.710
CREATIVE ABOUT PARKING. WHEN
03:44:17.777 --> 03:44:18.912
THEY NEED TO PROVIDE PARKING.
03:44:18.978 --> 03:44:20.814
THEY DO IT, BUT WE HEAR MORE AND
03:44:20.880 --> 03:44:21.748
MORE, ESPECIALLY FROM YOUNGER
03:44:21.815 --> 03:44:23.349
RESIDENTS, BUT THEY DON'T WANT
03:44:23.416 --> 03:44:25.151
TO PAY FOR PARKING SPACE. THEY
03:44:25.218 --> 03:44:26.052
CAN'T PAY FOR PARKING SPACE THEY
03:44:26.119 --> 03:44:28.188
DON'T USE AND WE ARE ONLY ASKING
03:44:28.254 --> 03:44:29.556
FOR IN AREAS RIGHT NEXT TO
03:44:29.622 --> 03:44:30.723
TRANSIT TO NOT ONLY GIVE THAT
03:44:30.790 --> 03:44:33.526
TRANSIT A CHANCE TO BE USED TO
03:44:33.593 --> 03:44:34.027
GIVE THE DEVELOPERS THE
03:44:34.093 --> 03:44:35.195
FLEXIBILITY TO RIGHT SIZE THE
03:44:35.261 --> 03:44:35.829
PARKING REQUIREMENTS FOR THEIR
03:44:35.895 --> 03:44:38.164
TENANTS WHEN WE'RE IN THE MIDDLE
03:44:38.231 --> 03:44:38.731
OF SUCH AN INTENSE HOUSING
03:44:38.798 --> 03:44:40.600
CRISIS, WHERE I THINK FOR A LOT
03:44:40.667 --> 03:44:41.734
OF THESE FOLKS, IF YOU SAID
03:44:41.801 --> 03:44:43.970
WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE THE UNIT?
03:44:44.037 --> 03:44:45.939
OR HAVE A UNIT WITH TWO PIECES
03:44:46.005 --> 03:44:47.307
TWO PARKING SPACES THAT YOU
03:44:47.373 --> 03:44:48.408
CAN'T AFFORD. THEY GO FOR
03:44:48.474 --> 03:44:49.542
PUTTING THAT ROOF OVER THEIR
03:44:49.609 --> 03:44:51.277
HEAD RIGHT NOW AND A LOT OF
03:44:51.344 --> 03:44:52.579
THESE BUILDINGS ARE ALLOWING FOR
03:44:52.645 --> 03:44:54.147
SHARED PARKING, TANDEM PARKING.
03:44:54.214 --> 03:44:55.548
CREATIVE SOLUTIONS THAT ARE
03:44:55.615 --> 03:44:57.851
CODES ARE ONE SIZE FITS ALL CITY
03:44:57.917 --> 03:45:00.753
CODES DON'T ALLOW. SO I, YOU
03:45:00.820 --> 03:45:02.288
KNOW WE HAVE REAL WORLD
03:45:02.355 --> 03:45:03.756
EXPERIENCE WITH THIS. THE SKY
03:45:03.823 --> 03:45:05.291
HASN'T FALLEN, BUT WHAT HAS
03:45:05.358 --> 03:45:06.893
HAPPENED IS THAT MORE UNITS HAVE
03:45:06.960 --> 03:45:08.328
GOTTEN BUILT AND THOSE WHO ARE
03:45:08.394 --> 03:45:10.864
SELF SELECTING TO USE THAT. THAT
03:45:10.930 --> 03:45:12.065
EXCELLENT PUBLIC TRANSIT DO IT,
03:45:12.131 --> 03:45:14.000
AND THE MORE THEY USE IT, THE
03:45:14.067 --> 03:45:16.302
BETTER THE SERVICE WILL GET, YOU
03:45:16.369 --> 03:45:17.704
KNOW, AND IF WE KEEP SAYING NO,
03:45:17.770 --> 03:45:19.372
NO, NO DRIVE DRIVE DRIVE
03:45:19.439 --> 03:45:20.573
EVERYWHERE. THEY'RE NEVER GOING
03:45:20.640 --> 03:45:22.508
TO IMPROVE THE TRANSIT. SO YOU
03:45:22.575 --> 03:45:24.110
KNOW SOMETHING'S GOTTA GIVE
03:45:24.177 --> 03:45:25.712
HERE. BUT WHAT WE HAVE NOW IS
03:45:25.778 --> 03:45:27.247
NOT JUST NOT USTAINABLE. IT'S
03:45:27.313 --> 03:45:28.581
NOT HUMANE, AND WE'VE GOTTA
03:45:28.648 --> 03:45:31.784
PRIORITIZE BEDS FOR HEADS OVER
03:45:31.851 --> 03:45:33.152
PARKING FOR CARS. WE JUST HAVE
03:45:33.219 --> 03:45:34.787
TO MAKE THAT POLICY CHOICE RIGHT
03:45:34.854 --> 03:45:35.855
NOW. SO AGAIN. I APPRECIATE THE
03:45:35.922 --> 03:45:38.558
VOTE TO LET ME GET IT OUT TODAY.
03:45:38.625 --> 03:45:40.426
I'LL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH YOU
03:45:40.493 --> 03:45:42.095
AND I HEAR YOU. THANK YOU SO
03:45:42.161 --> 03:45:42.629
MUCH. THANK YOU. AWESOME
03:45:42.695 --> 03:45:45.064
REMEMBER, AND I MUST ECHO THE
03:45:45.131 --> 03:45:48.001
COMMENTS OF THOSE WHO MENTIONED
03:45:48.067 --> 03:45:49.636
THE PROBLEM OF THE COOKIE CUTTER
03:45:49.702 --> 03:45:51.170
APPROACH. IT REALLY IS VERY
03:45:51.237 --> 03:45:52.472
IMPACTFUL IN MY COMMUNITY. ALL
03:45:52.538 --> 03:45:54.507
YOU NEED TO DO IS LOOK AT THE
03:45:54.574 --> 03:45:55.675
CARS THAT ARE PARKED ALL OVER
03:45:55.742 --> 03:45:58.444
THE STREETS. AND WHAT WENT ON IN
03:45:58.511 --> 03:45:59.445
THE NIGHT. TIME ACTUALLY 19
03:45:59.512 --> 03:46:01.214
EIGHTIES WHEN THERE WAS
03:46:01.281 --> 03:46:02.949
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND INCLUSION
03:46:03.016 --> 03:46:04.384
AREA ZONING COMING. THE BORDER
03:46:04.450 --> 03:46:06.586
SUPERVISORS DID CUT THE PARKING
03:46:06.653 --> 03:46:08.121
REQUIREMENTS AND AS A RESULT OF
03:46:08.187 --> 03:46:10.390
THAT MANY OF THE MULTI FAMILY
03:46:10.456 --> 03:46:11.524
DON'T HAVE A PLACE TO PARK AND
03:46:11.591 --> 03:46:12.592
THEY'RE ALL BY SCHOOLS AND
03:46:12.659 --> 03:46:15.028
THINGS THAT HAVE REALLY IMPACTED
03:46:15.094 --> 03:46:16.029
ON PUBLIC SAFETY AND MY
03:46:16.095 --> 03:46:18.197
COMMUNITY SO THAT I THINK YOU'RE
03:46:18.264 --> 03:46:19.499
WORKING IN IN THE DIRECTION WITH
03:46:19.565 --> 03:46:21.067
THE AMENDMENTS AND THAT'S A
03:46:21.134 --> 03:46:23.269
LAUDABLE BECAUSE I THINK WE HAVE
03:46:23.336 --> 03:46:25.171
TO GET THERE. BUT I'M NOT SURE
03:46:25.238 --> 03:46:26.439
THAT THE RUSH TO ELIMINATE
03:46:26.506 --> 03:46:28.541
PARKING IS REALLY THE WAY TO GO
03:46:28.608 --> 03:46:30.410
AT THE MOMENT. BUT ANYWAY, LET'S
03:46:30.476 --> 03:46:33.112
CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS ASSEMBLY
03:46:33.179 --> 03:46:34.781
BILL 2097 BY SOME MEMBER OF
03:46:34.847 --> 03:46:36.950
FRIEDMAN. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
03:46:37.016 --> 03:46:37.984
AS AMENDED, BUT FOR CEMENT AND
03:46:38.051 --> 03:46:40.453
WE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:46:40.520 --> 03:46:41.054
APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WIENER
03:46:41.120 --> 03:46:45.491
BATES SNOW, CAMEROON. ORTEZ.
03:46:45.558 --> 03:46:46.125
CORTESI. AYE MCGUIRE, THE CHILL
03:46:46.192 --> 03:46:49.762
BUG BROTH. BROTH I SKINNER
03:46:49.829 --> 03:46:56.102
SKINNER I HAMBURG. 321. 321 AND
03:46:56.169 --> 03:46:57.570
WE'LL HOLD THAT OPEN. SOMEBODY
03:46:57.637 --> 03:46:59.505
MEMBER FRIEDMAN FOR THE OTHER
03:46:59.572 --> 03:47:05.011
MEMBERS THOUGHT RETURN.
03:47:05.078 --> 03:47:05.745
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRKS. STILL
03:47:05.812 --> 03:47:10.350
THAT WELCOME CANNED. YEAH, SEE,
03:47:10.416 --> 03:47:15.621
YOU HAVE TO BY ITEM 14. MAYBE 20
03:47:15.688 --> 03:47:16.856
TO 33 YOU WANT TO START WITH
03:47:16.923 --> 03:47:20.460
THAT NGUYEN? YES, I DO. GET
03:47:20.526 --> 03:47:22.395
AFTER OR ACTUALLY GETTING CLOSE
03:47:22.462 --> 03:47:24.464
TO GOOD EVENING MEMBERS AND
03:47:24.530 --> 03:47:25.631
MADAM CHAIR. I WANT YOU TO
03:47:25.698 --> 03:47:27.400
NOTICE MY ORANGE COUNTY. ADDRESS
03:47:27.467 --> 03:47:31.938
THE ORANGES THERE. ALRIGHT ON A
03:47:32.005 --> 03:47:33.573
MORE SERIOUS NOTE TODAY I'M
03:47:33.639 --> 03:47:36.609
PRESENTING A B 2 TO 33, WHICH
03:47:36.676 --> 03:47:38.745
SEEKS TO CODIFY AN EXECUTIVE
03:47:38.811 --> 03:47:41.114
ORDER AND IMPLEMENT THE STATE
03:47:41.180 --> 03:47:43.383
AUDITOR'S RECOMMENDATIONS ON
03:47:43.449 --> 03:47:45.485
STATE SURPLUS PROPERTIES IN
03:47:45.551 --> 03:47:47.553
ORDER TO ADD MORE AFFORDABLE
03:47:47.620 --> 03:47:48.688
HOUSING, WHICH ARE STATE IS
03:47:48.755 --> 03:47:52.125
DESPERATELY LACKING. IN 2019
03:47:52.191 --> 03:47:53.726
GOVERNOR NEWSOM ISSUED AN
03:47:53.793 --> 03:47:55.628
EXECUTIVE ORDER IN WHICH HE
03:47:55.695 --> 03:47:56.929
ORDERED THE DEPARTMENT OF
03:47:56.996 --> 03:47:59.198
GENERAL SERVICES AND THE
03:47:59.265 --> 03:48:00.600
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
03:48:00.666 --> 03:48:02.068
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND THE
03:48:02.135 --> 03:48:03.136
CALIFORNIA HOUSING FINANCE
03:48:03.202 --> 03:48:06.539
AGENCY. TO IDENTIFY AND
03:48:06.606 --> 03:48:08.274
PRIORITIZE STATE SURPLUS
03:48:08.341 --> 03:48:09.609
PROPERTIES FOR COST EFFECTIVE
03:48:09.675 --> 03:48:13.413
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS. WELL THE
03:48:13.479 --> 03:48:14.313
DEPARTMENTS WERE ABLE TO
03:48:14.380 --> 03:48:17.950
IDENTIFY OVER 44,000 PARCELS.
03:48:18.017 --> 03:48:19.519
ONLY A FEW OF THESE PARCELS WERE
03:48:19.585 --> 03:48:21.888
DEEMED SUITABLE FOR HOUSING, AND
03:48:21.954 --> 03:48:23.389
IT WAS UNCLEAR WHAT THE PLANS
03:48:23.456 --> 03:48:25.458
WERE, FOR MANY OF THEM
03:48:25.525 --> 03:48:27.026
HIGHLIGHTING AND NEED FOR AN
03:48:27.093 --> 03:48:29.362
AUDIT, WHICH I REQUESTED. THE
03:48:29.429 --> 03:48:30.830
STATES NEED FOR AFFORDABLE
03:48:30.897 --> 03:48:32.498
HOUSING IS SIGNIFICANTLY
03:48:32.565 --> 03:48:34.534
OUTPACING ITS PRODUCTION, WHICH
03:48:34.600 --> 03:48:36.502
IS NEGATIVELY AFFECTING
03:48:36.569 --> 03:48:39.806
CALIFORNIANS, ACCORDING TO 2021
03:48:39.872 --> 03:48:40.940
REPORT BY THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
03:48:41.007 --> 03:48:45.344
PARTNERSHIP. 1.4 MILLION LOW
03:48:45.411 --> 03:48:47.513
INCOME CALIFORNIA HOUSEHOLDS
03:48:47.580 --> 03:48:48.548
LACKED ACCESS TO AFFORDABLE
03:48:48.614 --> 03:48:52.118
HOUSING. DESPITE THE NEED FOR
03:48:52.185 --> 03:48:53.553
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, THE STATE
03:48:53.619 --> 03:48:56.456
HAS FALLEN OVER 100 UNITS SHORT
03:48:56.522 --> 03:48:59.959
ANNUALLY ON ITS GOAL OF CREATING
03:49:00.026 --> 03:49:02.161
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. THE RAPID
03:49:02.228 --> 03:49:03.696
CREATION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:49:03.763 --> 03:49:05.665
IS CRITICAL, AND THE REPURPOSING
03:49:05.731 --> 03:49:08.067
OF STATE PROPERTIES IS JUST ONE
03:49:08.134 --> 03:49:10.169
OF THE MANY STEPS NECESSARY TO
03:49:10.236 --> 03:49:12.605
REACH OUR GOAL WITH ME TODAY TO
03:49:12.672 --> 03:49:14.640
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IS
03:49:14.707 --> 03:49:16.008
MARKS DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:49:16.075 --> 03:49:19.278
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP CORPORATION.
03:49:19.345 --> 03:49:21.414
AND I BELIEVE OR REPRESENT A
03:49:21.481 --> 03:49:22.181
REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE
03:49:22.248 --> 03:49:23.049
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
03:49:23.116 --> 03:49:26.986
ASSOCIATION. GOOD EVENING MARKS.
03:49:27.053 --> 03:49:27.954
DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:49:28.020 --> 03:49:29.155
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP, THE
03:49:29.222 --> 03:49:30.490
GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER ON
03:49:30.556 --> 03:49:32.024
EXCESS SITES HAS BEEN A
03:49:32.091 --> 03:49:34.327
RESOUNDING SUCCESS SUCCESS. 19
03:49:34.393 --> 03:49:35.895
PROPERTIES HAVE BEEN OFFERED TO
03:49:35.962 --> 03:49:37.864
DATE AND THERE IS A POTENTIAL
03:49:37.930 --> 03:49:39.198
FOR 32,000 MORE AFFORDABLE HOMES
03:49:39.265 --> 03:49:41.934
THAT COULD BE DEVELOPED. AND
03:49:42.001 --> 03:49:43.035
MAKING THIS EXECUTIVE ORDER
03:49:43.102 --> 03:49:43.703
PERMANENT AND INSTITUTIONALIZING
03:49:43.769 --> 03:49:46.139
IT WILL ONLY MAGNIFY THE IMPACT.
03:49:46.205 --> 03:49:48.541
81 SURE THAT THE CURRENT
03:49:48.608 --> 03:49:50.042
EXECUTIVE WORK EXTENDS BEYOND
03:49:50.109 --> 03:49:50.977
THE CURRENT GOVERNOR.
03:49:51.043 --> 03:49:52.378
FURTHERMORE FURTHER REVIEW WILL
03:49:52.445 --> 03:49:54.413
INCREASE THE NUMBER OF SITES AND
03:49:54.480 --> 03:49:55.515
HOMES THAT WE CAN MAKE
03:49:55.581 --> 03:49:57.917
AVAILABLE. MEETING THE NEEDS OF
03:49:57.984 --> 03:49:59.785
CALIFORNIA REQUIRES A LONG TERM
03:49:59.852 --> 03:50:00.653
COMMITMENT AND CONTINUALLY
03:50:00.720 --> 03:50:02.788
REASSESSING AND OFFERING XSD
03:50:02.855 --> 03:50:03.789
PROPERTIES IS AN INTEGRAL PART
03:50:03.856 --> 03:50:04.824
OF THAT EFFORT. WE URGE YOUR
03:50:04.891 --> 03:50:06.792
SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 20 TO 33 THANK
03:50:06.859 --> 03:50:08.494
YOU VERY MUCH. CUTE. NEXT. WE
03:50:08.561 --> 03:50:13.799
HAVE, MR MADISON. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:50:13.866 --> 03:50:14.767
, AMBER MADISON FROM THE
03:50:14.834 --> 03:50:16.269
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
03:50:16.335 --> 03:50:17.069
. I WANT TO FIRST THANK THE
03:50:17.136 --> 03:50:18.271
AUTHOR FOR AUTHORING THIS VERY
03:50:18.337 --> 03:50:21.541
IMPORTANT BILL. MAYBE 20 TO 33
03:50:21.607 --> 03:50:23.142
CREATES A DYNAMIC APPROACH TO
03:50:23.209 --> 03:50:24.610
UTILIZE STATE RESOURCES TO
03:50:24.677 --> 03:50:26.212
INCREASE OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
03:50:26.279 --> 03:50:27.647
SUPPLY BY REQUIRING THE
03:50:27.713 --> 03:50:29.315
DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES
03:50:29.382 --> 03:50:31.584
TO CONSISTENTLY EVALUATE STATE
03:50:31.651 --> 03:50:32.985
OWNED PARCELS FOR THEIR
03:50:33.052 --> 03:50:33.886
SUITABILITY FOR AFFORDABLE
03:50:33.953 --> 03:50:35.955
HOUSING SITES. GOVERNOR NEWSOM'S
03:50:36.022 --> 03:50:37.690
2019 EXECUTIVE ORDER WAS THE
03:50:37.757 --> 03:50:39.825
FIRST STEP WE NEEDED TO IDENTIFY
03:50:39.892 --> 03:50:40.860
AND INVENTORY STATE OWNED EXCESS
03:50:40.927 --> 03:50:45.097
PROPERTY. MAYBE 20 TO 33 TAKES
03:50:45.164 --> 03:50:46.832
THE NEXT STEP TO SYSTEMATIZE HOW
03:50:46.899 --> 03:50:48.401
DGS CAN WORK TO TURN THESE
03:50:48.467 --> 03:50:49.235
PROPERTIES INTO AFORDABLE
03:50:49.302 --> 03:50:50.203
HOUSING THAT OUR STATE
03:50:50.269 --> 03:50:54.907
DESPERATELY NEEDS. THANK YOU.
03:50:54.974 --> 03:50:57.543
ANY OTHERS IN THE ROOM HERE, HE
03:50:57.610 --> 03:50:59.378
WOULD LIKE TO COME FORWARD IN
03:50:59.445 --> 03:51:05.384
SUPPORT. UH, MAYBE 20 TO 33.
03:51:05.451 --> 03:51:06.619
CHRIS MARTIN AND I HAVE A HOUSE
03:51:06.686 --> 03:51:10.690
IN CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. NOT
03:51:10.756 --> 03:51:11.924
SEE ANY OTHERS APPROACHING, SO
03:51:11.991 --> 03:51:15.294
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONES. OPEN THE
03:51:15.361 --> 03:51:17.263
PHONE LINES, MR MODERATOR AND
03:51:17.330 --> 03:51:18.464
CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
03:51:18.531 --> 03:51:21.701
SUPPORT OF A B 20 TO 33. THANK
03:51:21.767 --> 03:51:24.470
YOU TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR THE
03:51:24.537 --> 03:51:25.605
BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND THEN
03:51:25.671 --> 03:51:27.573
ZERO. AGAIN USING YOUR TELEPHONE
03:51:27.640 --> 03:51:29.275
KEYPAD. THAT'S ONE PROBLEM BASIS
03:51:29.342 --> 03:51:34.013
ZERO. WE'LL GO FIRST TO LINE 1
03:51:34.080 --> 03:51:36.849
29, PLEASE GO AHEAD. RECALL
03:51:36.916 --> 03:51:43.956
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
03:51:44.023 --> 03:51:45.224
WE HAVE ANOTHER LINING. QUÊ JUST
03:51:45.291 --> 03:51:51.831
A MOMENT, PLEASE. LINE 4 13,
03:51:51.897 --> 03:51:55.568
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES, MOTHER
03:51:55.635 --> 03:51:59.672
GOING TO RESIDENTS IN SUPPORT.
03:51:59.739 --> 03:52:00.840
THANK YOU. NO OTHER LINES IN
03:52:00.906 --> 03:52:04.443
CUBA AT THIS TIME. THEN WE'LL GO
03:52:04.510 --> 03:52:06.379
TO THOSE WHO MIGHT BE WISHING TO
03:52:06.445 --> 03:52:08.614
OPPOSE A B 20 TO 33. PLEASE COME
03:52:08.681 --> 03:52:13.319
FORWARD. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
03:52:13.386 --> 03:52:14.086
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE JEREMY
03:52:14.153 --> 03:52:16.255
SMITH HERE ON BEHALF OF THE
03:52:16.322 --> 03:52:17.423
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
03:52:17.490 --> 03:52:18.658
TRADES COUNCIL. UM HERE IN
03:52:18.724 --> 03:52:20.092
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THIS
03:52:20.159 --> 03:52:22.261
BILL, WE HAVE ENGAGED THE AUTHOR
03:52:22.328 --> 03:52:24.263
OVER THE LAST SEVERAL MONTHS IN
03:52:24.330 --> 03:52:26.465
THIS BILL, AND EVEN JUST AN HOUR
03:52:26.532 --> 03:52:28.200
HALF AGO, WE WERE SITTING HERE
03:52:28.267 --> 03:52:29.502
TALKING ABOUT IT, AND, UM, I
03:52:29.568 --> 03:52:31.170
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH HER
03:52:31.237 --> 03:52:32.638
ON THIS BILL. IF MOVES OUT OF
03:52:32.705 --> 03:52:34.473
THIS COMMITTEE TODAY TO CLARIFY
03:52:34.540 --> 03:52:36.976
A COUPLE OF ISSUES, FIRST OF ALL
03:52:37.043 --> 03:52:39.111
THAT PREVAILING WAGE WILL BE
03:52:39.178 --> 03:52:41.047
TRIGGERED ON EXCESS STATE LAND
03:52:41.113 --> 03:52:42.748
UNDER THIS BILL THAT GETS
03:52:42.815 --> 03:52:43.983
CONVEYED TO DEVELOPERS. UM WE,
03:52:44.050 --> 03:52:49.355
UM WE HAVE BEEN TOLD BY, UH THE
03:52:49.422 --> 03:52:50.823
AUTHOR AND HER STAFF THAT SIMPLY
03:52:50.890 --> 03:52:52.925
HOUSING COMMITTEE EXPRESSED TO
03:52:52.992 --> 03:52:55.828
HER THEIR BELIEF THAT THE
03:52:55.895 --> 03:52:56.962
PREVAILING WAGE WOULD BE
03:52:57.029 --> 03:52:58.364
TRIGGERED ON THESE PROPERTIES.
03:52:58.431 --> 03:52:59.999
UM WITH RESPECT TO THE
03:53:00.066 --> 03:53:02.134
HARDWORKING MEN AND WOMEN AT THE
03:53:02.201 --> 03:53:03.135
ASSEMBLY HOUSING COMMITTEE, A
03:53:03.202 --> 03:53:04.303
COUPLE OF WHOM I CONSIDER
03:53:04.370 --> 03:53:05.471
FRIENDS. THAT IS NOT THEIR
03:53:05.538 --> 03:53:06.505
POLICY JURISDICTION. THE LABOR
03:53:06.572 --> 03:53:08.007
CODE IS OTHER POLICY
03:53:08.074 --> 03:53:10.643
JURISDICTION. FURTHERMORE, I'M
03:53:10.710 --> 03:53:12.545
HERE. THE LABOR MOVEMENT EXISTS
03:53:12.611 --> 03:53:17.350
AND EMPLOYS ME BECAUSE WE DON'T. SOMETIMES BILLS PASSED THIS
03:53:17.416 --> 03:53:19.485
LEGISLATURE THAT AREN'T CLEAR.
03:53:19.552 --> 03:53:22.521
AND EMPLOYERS IN ANY SETTING,
03:53:22.588 --> 03:53:24.957
WHETHER IT'S DEVELOPERS OR
03:53:25.024 --> 03:53:26.625
WORKERS AT MANUFACTURING
03:53:26.692 --> 03:53:29.362
FACILITIES, OR, UM, GROCERY
03:53:29.428 --> 03:53:30.596
WORKERS. EMPLOYERS LOOK FOR ANY
03:53:30.663 --> 03:53:33.999
SLIVER OF DAYLIGHT, TOO. UM
03:53:34.066 --> 03:53:36.235
EXPLOIT WORKERS AND NOT PAY THEM
03:53:36.302 --> 03:53:37.703
IN THIS CASE, THE WAGES THEY
03:53:37.770 --> 03:53:38.804
DESERVE ON PUBLIC PROPERTY THAT
03:53:38.871 --> 03:53:41.240
CONVEYS TO DEVELOPERS. SO WE'RE
03:53:41.307 --> 03:53:43.309
LOOKING FOR SOME LANGUAGE IN THE
03:53:43.376 --> 03:53:45.244
BILL. SOME OF ITS THE BILL THAT
03:53:45.311 --> 03:53:47.012
WE'VE PROVIDED TO CLARIFY
03:53:47.079 --> 03:53:48.147
PREVAILING, WHICH COVERAGE ON,
03:53:48.214 --> 03:53:51.250
UM LAND THAT CONVEYS UNDER THIS
03:53:51.317 --> 03:53:53.319
BILL TO DEVELOPERS, AND THEN
03:53:53.386 --> 03:53:54.620
THERE'S ALSO THE OUTSTANDING
03:53:54.687 --> 03:53:56.322
ISSUE OF A SKILLED AND TRAINED
03:53:56.389 --> 03:53:57.757
WORKFORCE. WHICH WE KNOW HOVERS
03:53:57.823 --> 03:53:58.691
OVER EVERYTHING AND HOUSING IN
03:53:58.758 --> 03:54:00.459
THIS SPACE. WE WOULD. WE'RE ALSO
03:54:00.526 --> 03:54:02.294
ASKING FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE
03:54:02.361 --> 03:54:03.996
BILL FOR THAT, UM WE BELIEVE
03:54:04.063 --> 03:54:05.765
THAT IS PART OF THE SAME
03:54:05.831 --> 03:54:07.366
CONVERSATION. ALTHOUGH SEPARATE
03:54:07.433 --> 03:54:08.734
, WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
03:54:08.801 --> 03:54:10.236
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE ASSEMBLY
03:54:10.302 --> 03:54:12.405
MEMBER AND HER STAFF. LIKE I
03:54:12.471 --> 03:54:13.873
SAID, WE HAD A NICE CONVERSATION
03:54:13.939 --> 03:54:15.641
TODAY, HOPING WE CAN GET TO A
03:54:15.708 --> 03:54:16.842
RESOLUTION ON BOTH OF THESE
03:54:16.909 --> 03:54:17.943
ISSUES AS THE BILL MOVES
03:54:18.010 --> 03:54:20.479
FORWARD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:54:20.546 --> 03:54:22.214
DON'T SEE ANY OTHERS IN THE ROOM
03:54:22.281 --> 03:54:24.283
THAT WISH TO OPPOSE AND LET US
03:54:24.350 --> 03:54:27.586
GO TO THE PHONE LINES. MODERATOR
03:54:27.653 --> 03:54:28.821
GONNA TEE UP THOSE WHO MAY WISH
03:54:28.888 --> 03:54:34.960
TO OPPOSE TO A B 20 TO 33. THANK
03:54:35.027 --> 03:54:36.328
YOU TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO THE
03:54:36.395 --> 03:54:38.063
BILL PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
03:54:38.130 --> 03:54:40.065
ZERO. HOUSTON, YOUR TELEPHONE
03:54:40.132 --> 03:54:41.834
KEYPAD ONE AND THEN ZERO AT THIS
03:54:41.901 --> 03:54:47.973
TIME. THANK YOU, COLONEL. MINDS
03:54:48.040 --> 03:54:50.276
IN. Q THANK YOU. WE'LL BRING IT
03:54:50.342 --> 03:54:52.011
BACK TO THE DIAPHANOUS TO
03:54:52.077 --> 03:54:53.012
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. ANY QUESTIONS
03:54:53.078 --> 03:54:58.851
OR COMMENTS. WE HAVE EMOTION.
03:54:58.918 --> 03:54:59.852
REMEMBER QUIRK-SILVA. WOULD YOU
03:54:59.919 --> 03:55:05.491
LIKE TO CLOSE? I WOULD, UM, JUST
03:55:05.558 --> 03:55:07.293
LIKE TO SAY WE WILL CONTINUE TO
03:55:07.359 --> 03:55:09.128
WORK ON CLARIFYING LANGUAGE AND
03:55:09.195 --> 03:55:12.498
WOULD APPRECIATE AND I VOTE. MAY
03:55:12.565 --> 03:55:13.999
I ASK A QUICK QUESTION REGARDING
03:55:14.066 --> 03:55:15.034
THE MARKET VALUE OF THE
03:55:15.100 --> 03:55:17.002
PROPERTIES. I THINK THAT IS
03:55:17.069 --> 03:55:18.571
ALWAYS A QUESTION. WHEN WE ARE
03:55:18.637 --> 03:55:20.573
WE HAVE PUBLIC LANDS THAT HAVE
03:55:20.639 --> 03:55:23.342
BEEN PAID FOR BY TAXPAYERS. AND
03:55:23.409 --> 03:55:25.411
ARE YOU CONSIDERING ENSURING
03:55:25.478 --> 03:55:26.946
THAT THAT IS PART OF THIS? AND I
03:55:27.012 --> 03:55:28.147
BELIEVE THE AUDITOR HAD A
03:55:28.214 --> 03:55:30.850
COMMENT ABOUT THAT. ALSO. YES
03:55:30.916 --> 03:55:32.485
AND THE RECOMMENDATIONS. THEY
03:55:32.551 --> 03:55:34.587
HAD SEVERAL RECOMMENDATIONS. WE
03:55:34.653 --> 03:55:36.856
DIDN'T INCLUDE THAT IN THIS PART
03:55:36.922 --> 03:55:39.024
. WE JUST WANTED TO GET STARTED
03:55:39.091 --> 03:55:40.259
. ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WAS
03:55:40.326 --> 03:55:42.094
NOTED IN THE TESTIMONY IS THERE
03:55:42.161 --> 03:55:45.431
ARE 19PROPERTIES UNDER, UM,
03:55:45.498 --> 03:55:48.534
MOVING FORWARD, BUT THESE
03:55:48.601 --> 03:55:50.236
PROPERTIES FROM THE STATE HAVE
03:55:50.302 --> 03:55:51.537
TAKEN QUITE A LONG TO EVEN GET
03:55:51.604 --> 03:55:52.671
THOSE UP AND RUNNING. AND SO OUR
03:55:52.738 --> 03:55:55.174
HOPE IS TO TRY TO MOVE FORWARD
03:55:55.241 --> 03:55:56.909
THIS PART AND THEN WE CERTAINLY
03:55:56.976 --> 03:55:58.477
COULD COME BACK WITH ADDITIONAL
03:55:58.544 --> 03:56:01.647
, UM, PARTS OF THE BILL LATER.
03:56:01.714 --> 03:56:04.383
THANK YOU. I ASSUME THAT THAT
03:56:04.450 --> 03:56:06.018
WOULD BE A CORE PRINCIPLE IN THE
03:56:06.085 --> 03:56:06.886
OVERALL APPROACH TO THAT SO
03:56:06.952 --> 03:56:07.987
WITHOUT WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL
03:56:08.053 --> 03:56:12.124
THE ROLL? THIS IS ASSEMBLY BILL
03:56:12.191 --> 03:56:14.426
20 TO 33 BY SOME MEMBER
03:56:14.493 --> 03:56:15.060
QUIRK-SILVA. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:56:15.127 --> 03:56:17.096
PASS. BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO
03:56:17.162 --> 03:56:18.264
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:56:18.330 --> 03:56:21.400
SENATOR WIENER BATES. ALRIGHT
03:56:21.467 --> 03:56:25.704
CAMERA COURTESY, MCGUIRE. PHð
03:56:25.771 --> 03:56:29.008
CAMERA COURTESY, MCGUIRE. PHð-BUG. ROTH I. SKINNER SKINNER. I
03:56:29.074 --> 03:56:33.112
AM BERG. THAT SUPPORT A ZERO. SO
03:56:33.178 --> 03:56:35.147
THAT HAS FOUR VOTES AND WILL
03:56:35.214 --> 03:56:36.315
HOLD THE ROLL. OPEN. CELLO,
03:56:36.382 --> 03:56:37.683
OTHERS RETURN. THANK YOU. THANK
03:56:37.750 --> 03:56:41.353
YOU HAVE ANOTHER ONE. I DO RIGHT
03:56:41.420 --> 03:56:45.491
HERE. THAT'S 27 05. YES THANK
03:56:45.558 --> 03:56:47.526
YOU. I'M PLEASED TO PRESENT A B
03:56:47.593 --> 03:56:52.264
27 05 AND I WANT TO, UH, THANK
03:56:52.331 --> 03:56:53.632
THE COMMITTEE STAFF AS WE KNOW
03:56:53.699 --> 03:56:56.101
THAT THIS ISSUE NOT JUST WITH MY
03:56:56.168 --> 03:56:58.971
BILL, BUT LEGISLATION RELATED TO
03:56:59.038 --> 03:57:01.941
WILD FIRE AND SAFETY HAS BEEN A
03:57:02.007 --> 03:57:04.243
MAJOR TOPIC IN THE LAST SEVERAL
03:57:04.310 --> 03:57:05.411
YEARS, AND WE KNOW IT WILL
03:57:05.477 --> 03:57:08.581
CONTINUE TO BE SO WE KNOW THAT
03:57:08.647 --> 03:57:11.951
THIS BILL IS A STEP FORWARD, BUT
03:57:12.017 --> 03:57:15.054
WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
03:57:15.120 --> 03:57:17.156
COMMITTEE CHAIRS, ALSO,
03:57:17.222 --> 03:57:19.124
ESPECIALLY SENATOR CABALLERO,
03:57:19.191 --> 03:57:20.993
AND THANK HER FOR HER WORK ON
03:57:21.060 --> 03:57:23.629
THIS, AND I ALSO WANT TO THINK
03:57:23.696 --> 03:57:26.365
SENATOR C
03:57:26.432 --> 03:57:29.868
RTNERSHIP AND COLLABORATION AS
03:57:29.935 --> 03:57:32.171
A JOINT AUTHOR ON THIS BILL
03:57:32.237 --> 03:57:36.075
ASSEMBLY BILL 27 05 WILL REQUIRE
03:57:36.141 --> 03:57:38.777
ADDITIONAL ROBUST WILDFIRE
03:57:38.844 --> 03:57:40.379
PROTECTION REQUIREMENTS FOR
03:57:40.446 --> 03:57:42.014
FUTURE MASTER PLANNED
03:57:42.081 --> 03:57:43.983
COMMUNITIES THAT INCORPORATE
03:57:44.049 --> 03:57:44.984
UPDATED MODERN BUILDING
03:57:45.050 --> 03:57:47.886
STANDARDS. ACCORDING TO THE
03:57:47.953 --> 03:57:49.989
RECENT ANALYSIS OF PROPERTY LOST
03:57:50.055 --> 03:57:51.724
DATA FROM THE OFFICE OF THE
03:57:51.790 --> 03:57:54.493
STATE FIRE MARSHAL ON THE
03:57:54.560 --> 03:57:56.128
AVERAGE FOR THE NINE WORSE
03:57:56.195 --> 03:57:58.931
PROPERTY LOSS WILDFIRES
03:57:58.998 --> 03:58:00.833
APPROXIMATELY 1% OF THE HOMES
03:58:00.899 --> 03:58:03.168
AND APARTMENTS DESTROYED.
03:58:03.235 --> 03:58:05.237
DAMAGED OR AFFECTED OR NEW
03:58:05.304 --> 03:58:08.207
DWELLING UNITS THOSE BUILT AFTER
03:58:08.273 --> 03:58:11.877
JANUARY 1ST 2010 IN ORDER TO
03:58:11.944 --> 03:58:13.345
ADDRESS CALIFORNIA'S HOUSING
03:58:13.412 --> 03:58:15.881
SHORTAGE, REDUCE INEQUITIES AND
03:58:15.948 --> 03:58:17.816
HOME OWNERSHIP RATES, REDUCE
03:58:17.883 --> 03:58:19.485
HOMELESSNESS AND PROTECT
03:58:19.551 --> 03:58:21.420
HOMEOWNERS FROM CLIMATE CHANGE.
03:58:21.487 --> 03:58:22.588
CALIFORNIA NEEDS TO BUILD MORE
03:58:22.655 --> 03:58:26.125
HOUSING. ACROSS ALL LEVELS OF
03:58:26.191 --> 03:58:28.761
AFFORDABILITY. WE NEED OPTIONS
03:58:28.827 --> 03:58:31.864
TO BUILD A MODERN, RESILIENT
03:58:31.930 --> 03:58:34.533
HOMES, INCLUDING INCREASING OUR
03:58:34.600 --> 03:58:36.235
AFFORDABLE HOUSING STOCK BY ALSO
03:58:36.301 --> 03:58:37.903
MAKING SURE THOSE WHO LIVE AND
03:58:37.970 --> 03:58:39.505
WORK IN OUR COMMUNITIES ARE
03:58:39.571 --> 03:58:42.908
PROTECTED IN STATE AND SAVE AS
03:58:42.975 --> 03:58:46.078
MANY OF US KNOW, UH, WE HAVE HAD
03:58:46.145 --> 03:58:47.579
MANY COMMUNITIES WHO HAVE BEEN
03:58:47.646 --> 03:58:49.615
IMPACTED BY THE SEVERE FIRE
03:58:49.682 --> 03:58:52.885
DANGERS, AND WE CAN EXPECT MORE.
03:58:52.951 --> 03:58:55.521
TO HAPPEN WITHOUT NEW HOMES
03:58:55.587 --> 03:58:58.524
HAVING SPECIFIC SAFETY MEASURES
03:58:58.590 --> 03:59:00.526
INCLUDED IN BUILDING WITH ME
03:59:00.592 --> 03:59:02.628
TODAY TO PROVIDE TESTIMONY AND
03:59:02.695 --> 03:59:03.729
SUPPORT AND ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
03:59:03.796 --> 03:59:05.731
FROM THE COMMITTEE ARE MR RUBEN.
03:59:05.798 --> 03:59:11.003
GREAT, HAVE ALLAH KABBALAH. THAT
03:59:11.070 --> 03:59:12.905
FORMER CALIFORNIA STATE FIRE
03:59:12.971 --> 03:59:15.507
MARSHAL AND FORMER DIRECTOR OF
03:59:15.574 --> 03:59:18.911
CAL FIRE AND ALSO MR SILVIO
03:59:18.977 --> 03:59:21.080
FERRARI WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:59:21.146 --> 03:59:22.681
BUILDING INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
03:59:22.748 --> 03:59:27.986
AND SPONSORS OF A B 27 05. VERY
03:59:28.053 --> 03:59:29.288
GOOD. GOOD EVENING, SENATORS. MY
03:59:29.354 --> 03:59:31.824
NAME IS REUBEN GRIJALVA. I
03:59:31.890 --> 03:59:32.991
REPRESENT FIVE POINT I HAVE 36
03:59:33.058 --> 03:59:36.562
YEARS. EXPERIENCE IN THE FIRE
03:59:36.628 --> 03:59:38.831
SERVICE SERVED AS A STATE FIRE
03:59:38.897 --> 03:59:39.832
MARSHAL, CALIFORNIA FOR THREE
03:59:39.898 --> 03:59:42.201
YEARS. I SERVED AS THE DIRECTOR
03:59:42.267 --> 03:59:44.470
OF CAL FIRE FOR THREE YEARS. I
03:59:44.536 --> 03:59:45.637
ALSO HAVE 30 YEARS IN LOCAL
03:59:45.704 --> 03:59:48.440
GOVERNMENT. 14 YEARS WITH THE
03:59:48.507 --> 03:59:49.208
CITY OF SUNNYVALE AND WHERE I
03:59:49.274 --> 03:59:51.009
WAS THE FIRE MARSHAL FOR FIVE
03:59:51.076 --> 03:59:54.113
YEARS AND 16 YEARS WITH THE CITY
03:59:54.179 --> 03:59:56.215
OF PALO ALTO, IN WHICH I WAS THE
03:59:56.281 --> 03:59:58.450
FIRE CHIEF FOR 10 YEARS. SO I
03:59:58.517 --> 03:59:59.084
HAVE LOCAL AND STATE EXPERIENCE
03:59:59.151 --> 04:00:01.320
RESPONDING TO ALL KINDS OF FIRES
04:00:01.386 --> 04:00:01.820
AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS
04:00:01.887 --> 04:00:05.257
INCIDENTS. I ALSO SERVED AS THE
04:00:05.324 --> 04:00:06.692
PAST CHAIR OF THE CALIFORNIA
04:00:06.759 --> 04:00:08.927
FIRE SAFE COUNCIL. THE REASON I
04:00:08.994 --> 04:00:10.329
BRING THIS UP IS BECAUSE I HAVE
04:00:10.395 --> 04:00:12.064
SPENT MORE THAN HALF MY LIFE.
04:00:12.131 --> 04:00:13.232
WORKING ON FIRE PREVENTION AND
04:00:13.298 --> 04:00:15.801
FIRE PROTECTION ISSUES. AND
04:00:15.868 --> 04:00:17.035
THAT'S WHY I'M HERE TO ASK FOR
04:00:17.102 --> 04:00:20.606
YOUR SUPPORT FOR 27 05. IT IS A
04:00:20.672 --> 04:00:21.840
BILL THAT HAS ALL THE FIRE
04:00:21.907 --> 04:00:24.076
PREVENTION MEASURES NECESSARY.
04:00:24.143 --> 04:00:25.177
TO BUILD HOMES SAFELY IN A
04:00:25.244 --> 04:00:28.647
WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE. WE
04:00:28.714 --> 04:00:29.882
HEAR ABOUT WILDFIRES IN HOMES IN
04:00:29.948 --> 04:00:32.885
THE NEWS ALL THE TIME. ONE THING
04:00:32.951 --> 04:00:34.887
THEY FAILED TO MENTION IS THERE
04:00:34.953 --> 04:00:36.855
HAS NOT BEEN A SINGLE LOSS OF A
04:00:36.922 --> 04:00:39.158
SINGLE HOME IN A MASTER PLANNED
04:00:39.224 --> 04:00:42.327
COMMUNITY BUILT AFTER 20,010.
04:00:42.394 --> 04:00:44.329
USING THE STANDARDS THAT WE
04:00:44.396 --> 04:00:45.697
ADOPTED WHEN I WAS STATE FIRE
04:00:45.764 --> 04:00:46.732
MARSHAL CALIFORNIA WE ADOPTED
04:00:46.799 --> 04:00:49.835
CHAPTER SEVEN A AND WE BROUGHT
04:00:49.902 --> 04:00:52.137
TOGETHER. EXPERTS SCIENTISTS,
04:00:52.204 --> 04:00:53.772
BUILDING OFFICIALS, FIRE
04:00:53.839 --> 04:00:54.873
OFFICIALS, PUBLIC AND BUSINESS
04:00:54.940 --> 04:00:57.976
INTERESTS. AND WE DEVELOPED FOR
04:00:58.043 --> 04:00:59.211
THE FIRST TIME, A SCIENTIFICALLY
04:00:59.278 --> 04:01:01.213
BASED METHOD. FOR BUILDING
04:01:01.280 --> 04:01:02.247
MATERIALS, WHICH ARE IGNITION
04:01:02.314 --> 04:01:06.151
RESISTANT. AND MOST OF YOU KNOW
04:01:06.218 --> 04:01:07.386
THAT MOST FIRES ARE SPREAD THESE
04:01:07.452 --> 04:01:10.155
DAYS BY EMBERS. AND SO THESE
04:01:10.222 --> 04:01:12.324
HOMES ARE THE FIRST TIME THAT
04:01:12.391 --> 04:01:13.826
HOMES CAN BE MADE EMBER
04:01:13.892 --> 04:01:18.730
RESISTANT. AND SO IN A MASTER
04:01:18.797 --> 04:01:19.898
PLANNED COMMUNITY IN A HIGH FIRE
04:01:19.965 --> 04:01:21.633
SEVERITY ZONE. COMBINED WITH THE
04:01:21.700 --> 04:01:24.703
DEFENSIBLE SPACE COMBINED WITH
04:01:24.770 --> 04:01:26.805
GOOD WATER SUPPLY. GOOD FIRE
04:01:26.872 --> 04:01:29.875
ACCESS, GREEN BELTING AND ALL
04:01:29.942 --> 04:01:31.343
THE MEASURES THAT ARE CONTAINED
04:01:31.410 --> 04:01:34.346
IN 27 05 HOMES CAN WITHSTAND AND
04:01:34.413 --> 04:01:35.514
SURVIVE A WILDLAND FIRE THAT
04:01:35.581 --> 04:01:39.084
HAVE BEEN HOMES BUILT TO THE
04:01:39.151 --> 04:01:39.918
STANDARDS IN MASTER PLANNED
04:01:39.985 --> 04:01:40.986
COMMUNITIES THAT HAVE BEEN
04:01:41.053 --> 04:01:43.021
THREATENED BY FIRES ALREADY. AND
04:01:43.088 --> 04:01:45.591
NONE HAVE HAD A SINGLE LOSS. SO
04:01:45.657 --> 04:01:48.093
WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE PRE
04:01:48.160 --> 04:01:50.762
20,010 HOMES THAT 99% OF ALL THE
04:01:50.829 --> 04:01:53.198
HOMES THAT HAVE BURNT SINCE
04:01:53.265 --> 04:01:57.102
2010. HAVE INVOLVED. AND FROM A
04:01:57.169 --> 04:01:59.771
FROM A PERSONAL BASIS. IF I WAS
04:01:59.838 --> 04:02:01.540
STILL FIRE CHIEF, I WOULDN'T
04:02:01.607 --> 04:02:03.275
MIND USING A MASTER PLANNED
04:02:03.342 --> 04:02:04.943
COMMUNITY BUILT TO THE STANDARDS
04:02:05.010 --> 04:02:07.412
AS AN AREA OF REFUGE FOR MOVING
04:02:07.479 --> 04:02:09.214
PEOPLE OUT OF THE PRE 2010
04:02:09.281 --> 04:02:11.116
HOMES. TO EVACUATE THEM TO FOR
04:02:11.183 --> 04:02:12.618
SAFETY OR FOR SETTING UP A
04:02:12.684 --> 04:02:14.753
COMMAND POST FOR FIRE TO USE
04:02:14.820 --> 04:02:17.022
WHEN FIGHTING WILDFIRES THESE
04:02:17.089 --> 04:02:18.523
HOMES, THESE MASTER PLANNED
04:02:18.590 --> 04:02:20.092
COMMUNITIES ARE ALL DESIGNED FOR
04:02:20.158 --> 04:02:21.293
GOOD EVACUATION. YOU CAN HAVE
04:02:21.360 --> 04:02:23.195
EVACUATION AND FIRE ATTACK AT
04:02:23.262 --> 04:02:25.631
THE SAME TIME. WHICH HAS BEEN A
04:02:25.697 --> 04:02:26.798
HUGE PROBLEM FOR MANY OF THE
04:02:26.865 --> 04:02:28.667
LARGE WILDFIRES THAT WE FACED IN
04:02:28.734 --> 04:02:30.068
CALIFORNIA. AND FINALLY, ON A
04:02:30.135 --> 04:02:32.004
PERSONAL BASIS, YOU KNOW, I
04:02:32.070 --> 04:02:34.006
WOULD BE WILLING TO MOVE MY OWN
04:02:34.072 --> 04:02:36.575
FAMILY. INTO A MASTER PLANNED
04:02:36.642 --> 04:02:37.075
COMMUNITY BUILT TO THE
04:02:37.142 --> 04:02:39.845
STANDARDS. I CAN'T SAY ANY MORE
04:02:39.912 --> 04:02:43.115
THAN THAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:02:43.181 --> 04:02:45.584
GREAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND
04:02:45.651 --> 04:02:49.521
I'M SORRY AND RORY MR CHAIRMAN
04:02:49.588 --> 04:02:50.856
MEMBERS SILVIO FERRARI ON BEHALF
04:02:50.923 --> 04:02:52.257
OF CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
04:02:52.324 --> 04:02:54.026
ASSOCIATION SPONSORS THE BILL,
04:02:54.092 --> 04:02:55.594
SO IN VERY STRONG SUPPORT. I
04:02:55.661 --> 04:02:57.496
REALLY DON'T THINK I CAN ADD
04:02:57.562 --> 04:02:59.665
MUCH TO THE POLICY THAT THE A B
04:02:59.731 --> 04:03:02.000
27 05 GOES AFTER AFTER WHAT
04:03:02.067 --> 04:03:03.268
TREAT CHIEF GIRL ROJAVA JUST
04:03:03.335 --> 04:03:05.971
SAID SO I WOULD JUST SAY. FROM
04:03:06.038 --> 04:03:07.506
CBI. I WOULD LIKE TO REAFFIRM
04:03:07.572 --> 04:03:09.074
OUR COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE TO
04:03:09.141 --> 04:03:11.543
WORK ON THIS BILL. THIS IS YEARS
04:03:11.610 --> 04:03:13.578
LONG IN THE MAKING, AND WE
04:03:13.645 --> 04:03:15.681
CERTAINLY HAVE A NEED A DESIRE
04:03:15.747 --> 04:03:17.683
AND A GREAT TEMPLATE IN 27 05 TO
04:03:17.749 --> 04:03:18.951
GET THAT DONE WITH ENCOURAGE
04:03:19.017 --> 04:03:20.018
YOUR SUPPORT AND KEEP THIS
04:03:20.085 --> 04:03:23.855
MOVING. THANK YOU. GREAT ANY
04:03:23.922 --> 04:03:25.590
OTHER SUPPORT IN THE ROOM.
04:03:25.657 --> 04:03:32.631
PLEASE COME FORWARD. IN BIRD
04:03:32.698 --> 04:03:33.765
MEDICINE FROM THE CALIFORNIA
04:03:33.832 --> 04:03:34.666
APARTMENT ASSOCIATION AND STRONG
04:03:34.733 --> 04:03:41.073
SUPPORT. SCUSE ME AFTER HAPPENS
04:03:41.139 --> 04:03:42.975
TO ME ALL THE TIME. MY GLASSES
04:03:43.041 --> 04:03:45.944
OFF. AFTERNOON MR CHAIR,
04:03:46.011 --> 04:03:47.412
REMEMBERS LUIS MONTI WITH
04:03:47.479 --> 04:03:48.847
CALIFORNIA AND BE IN A
04:03:48.914 --> 04:03:50.682
SUPPORTIVE, AMENDED POSITION TO
04:03:50.749 --> 04:03:52.784
INCLUDE SOME OF THE RENO
04:03:52.851 --> 04:03:53.785
DISCUSSIONS THAT WE'VE BEEN
04:03:53.852 --> 04:03:54.953
HAVING INTO THIS BILL AS WELL,
04:03:55.020 --> 04:03:58.056
THANKS. ANY OTHER SUPPORT IN THE
04:03:58.123 --> 04:03:59.091
HEARING ROOM, SEEING THAT WILL
04:03:59.157 --> 04:04:00.826
OPEN THE PHONE LINES FOR
04:04:00.892 --> 04:04:05.330
SUPPORT. THANK YOU TO EXPRESS
04:04:05.397 --> 04:04:07.199
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL. PRESS
04:04:07.265 --> 04:04:09.001
ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO USING YOUR
04:04:09.067 --> 04:04:10.936
TELEPHONE. THAT'S ONE AND THEN
04:04:11.003 --> 04:04:12.137
ZERO. PLEASE WILL GO FIRST TO
04:04:12.204 --> 04:04:16.775
LINE 95. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
04:04:16.842 --> 04:04:18.744
MEMBERS REX W HI. I'M I'LL BE
04:04:18.810 --> 04:04:19.311
HAPPY. CALIFORNIA BUSINESS
04:04:19.378 --> 04:04:20.045
PROPERTIES ASSOCIATION IN
04:04:20.112 --> 04:04:27.085
SUPPORT. TO 65. GOOD EVENING.
04:04:27.152 --> 04:04:29.354
THIS IS NINA LABOR ON BEHALF OF
04:04:29.421 --> 04:04:30.589
THE CITY OF 1000 OAKS AND STRONG
04:04:30.655 --> 04:04:36.028
SUPPORT. 1 29. RECALL LIVABLE
04:04:36.094 --> 04:04:38.830
CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
04:04:38.897 --> 04:04:39.998
THANK YOU. NO FURTHER LINES IN
04:04:40.065 --> 04:04:43.702
QUÊ. OKAY IS THERE ANY
04:04:43.769 --> 04:04:45.537
OPPOSITION IN THE HEARING ROOM?
04:04:45.604 --> 04:04:48.340
SO PLEASE COME FORWARD. CASING
04:04:48.407 --> 04:04:49.474
AND WHAT OPENED THE PHONE LINES
04:04:49.541 --> 04:04:54.546
FOR OPPOSITION. TO EXPRESS
04:04:54.613 --> 04:04:55.614
OPPOSITION TO THE BUILDING. WE
04:04:55.680 --> 04:04:58.016
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO ON YOUR
04:04:58.083 --> 04:04:59.151
TELEPHONE KEYPAD AND AS ONE
04:04:59.217 --> 04:05:07.125
FOLLOWED BY ZERO, PLEASE. WE
04:05:07.192 --> 04:05:08.360
HAVE ONE LINE WITH AN OPERATOR.
04:05:08.427 --> 04:05:16.868
ME JUST A MOMENT. TWO I'M SORRY.
04:05:16.935 --> 04:05:21.540
4 22, PLEASE GO AHEAD. DID
04:05:21.606 --> 04:05:23.075
AFTERNOON. SINCE THERE WASN'T
04:05:23.141 --> 04:05:25.410
ANY OPPOSITION SPOKEN. MAY I
04:05:25.477 --> 04:05:27.479
HAVE TWO MINUTES TO JUST SPEAK
04:05:27.546 --> 04:05:28.046
IN OPPOSITION? YES, YOU MAY
04:05:28.113 --> 04:05:31.183
OKAY. THANK YOU SO MUCH. GOOD
04:05:31.249 --> 04:05:33.218
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS KIM
04:05:33.285 --> 04:05:33.819
DELFINO AND I'M SPEAKING ON
04:05:33.885 --> 04:05:34.986
BEHALF OF DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE,
04:05:35.053 --> 04:05:36.421
CALIFORNIA NATIVE PLANT SOCIETY
04:05:36.488 --> 04:05:37.789
AND THE ENDANGERED HABITATS
04:05:37.856 --> 04:05:39.324
LEAGUE AND OPPOSITION TO THIS
04:05:39.391 --> 04:05:40.792
BILL, MAYBE 27 05 CONTINUES TO
04:05:40.859 --> 04:05:41.993
PERPETRATE A DANGEROUS
04:05:42.060 --> 04:05:43.328
PROPOSITION THAT WE CAN CONTINUE
04:05:43.395 --> 04:05:45.831
TO SPRAWL INTO VERY HIGH. FIRE
04:05:45.897 --> 04:05:46.965
SEVERITY ZONES AND WE CAN
04:05:47.032 --> 04:05:48.133
ELIMINATE THIS RISK FOR BUILDING
04:05:48.200 --> 04:05:50.435
STANDARDS. AND, IN FACT, 80 27
04:05:50.502 --> 04:05:52.737
05 STATES THAT IT IS IMPERATIVE
04:05:52.804 --> 04:05:54.406
THAT CALIFORNIA PROMOTE NEW
04:05:54.473 --> 04:05:55.407
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT THAT
04:05:55.474 --> 04:05:56.408
REQUIRE RESILIENT AND CLIMATE
04:05:56.475 --> 04:05:58.343
RESILIENT. THAT'S DEVELOPMENT
04:05:58.410 --> 04:05:59.911
REDUCES WILDFIRE RISK BY
04:05:59.978 --> 04:06:00.846
ESTABLISHING VIABLE WILDFIRE
04:06:00.912 --> 04:06:01.746
REDUCTION REQUIREMENTS FOR NEW
04:06:01.813 --> 04:06:03.782
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
04:06:03.849 --> 04:06:06.852
UNFORTUNATELY 80 27 OH FIRES
04:06:06.918 --> 04:06:08.220
FIVE FIRE REDUCTION STANDARDS DO
04:06:08.286 --> 04:06:09.654
NOT SIGNIFICANTLY IMPROVE ON
04:06:09.721 --> 04:06:11.456
EXISTING PRACTICES, AND WE
04:06:11.523 --> 04:06:13.158
APPRECIATE THAT THERE IS A
04:06:13.225 --> 04:06:14.359
FRAMEWORK NOTED IN THE ANALYSIS
04:06:14.426 --> 04:06:16.261
TO IMPROVE STANDARDS. BUT WE
04:06:16.328 --> 04:06:18.063
WANT TO POINT OUT THAT
04:06:18.130 --> 04:06:19.197
UNFORTUNATELY, THIS IGNORES THIS
04:06:19.264 --> 04:06:20.332
CONTINUES TO IGNORE THE
04:06:20.398 --> 04:06:21.366
FUNDAMENTAL QUESTION ABOUT LAND
04:06:21.433 --> 04:06:23.535
USE. SUCH AS WHETHER DEVELOPMENT
04:06:23.602 --> 04:06:24.636
SHOULD BE CONCENTRATED IN AREAS
04:06:24.703 --> 04:06:26.738
WITH LOW FIRE RISK. WITHIN A
04:06:26.805 --> 04:06:28.707
JURISDICTION, AND INSTEAD, THE
04:06:28.773 --> 04:06:30.108
BILL FOCUSES ON MEASURES THAT
04:06:30.175 --> 04:06:31.676
APPLY TO DEVELOPMENTS IN THE
04:06:31.743 --> 04:06:32.944
THEY'RE VERY HIGH FIRE SEVERITY
04:06:33.011 --> 04:06:34.913
DON'T AFTER THE SITE FOR
04:06:34.980 --> 04:06:36.381
DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN CHOSEN.
04:06:36.448 --> 04:06:37.449
BASICALLY, THE BILL IS BASED ON
04:06:37.516 --> 04:06:39.117
AN ASSUMPTION THAT WE ARE GOING
04:06:39.184 --> 04:06:40.118
TO DO GOOD PLANNING, AND WE'RE
04:06:40.185 --> 04:06:42.154
GOING TO TRY TO AVOID EXPANDING
04:06:42.220 --> 04:06:43.555
INTO THE WILD AND WE'RE GOING TO
04:06:43.622 --> 04:06:44.756
AVOID. WE'RE GOING TO TRY TO
04:06:44.823 --> 04:06:47.125
AVOID EXPANDING INTO THE WILD
04:06:47.192 --> 04:06:48.026
AND URBAN INTERFACE WHERE
04:06:48.093 --> 04:06:48.793
THERE'S SEVERE FIRE RISK, AND
04:06:48.860 --> 04:06:51.263
INSTEAD WHAT WE'RE GOING TO DO
04:06:51.329 --> 04:06:53.365
IS JUST JUMP TO WHERE WE PICK
04:06:53.431 --> 04:06:54.533
HIGH FIRE RISK AREAS THAT WILL
04:06:54.599 --> 04:06:56.034
INEVITABLY BURN. WE WOULD ARGUE
04:06:56.101 --> 04:06:57.435
THAT UNLESS PLANNING IS
04:06:57.502 --> 04:06:59.004
INCORPORATED INTO THIS BILL,
04:06:59.070 --> 04:07:01.406
THERE'S NO REASON FOR THIS TO
04:07:01.473 --> 04:07:02.307
MOVE FORWARD SO WEWOULD URGE
04:07:02.374 --> 04:07:04.009
THAT WE LOOK AT THE ARENA PIECE
04:07:04.075 --> 04:07:06.545
THAT WAS IN F B 12 AND WORK TO
04:07:06.611 --> 04:07:08.046
INCORPORATE THAT INTO THIS BILL.
04:07:08.113 --> 04:07:09.281
IF THIS BILL IS GOING TO MOVE
04:07:09.347 --> 04:07:13.852
FORWARD, THANK YOU. OKAY. IS
04:07:13.919 --> 04:07:14.986
THERE ANY OTHER OPPOSITION ON
04:07:15.053 --> 04:07:17.155
THE PHONE LINE? NO OTHER LINES
04:07:17.222 --> 04:07:21.126
IN CUBA AT THIS TIME. OKAY WE'LL
04:07:21.193 --> 04:07:22.093
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
04:07:22.160 --> 04:07:23.795
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
04:07:23.862 --> 04:07:27.265
COMMENTS MOTION BY SENATOR ROTH.
04:07:27.332 --> 04:07:29.634
OKAY UM, I WANT TO THANK YOU FOR
04:07:29.701 --> 04:07:30.735
BEING THIS FORWARD. I SUPPORT
04:07:30.802 --> 04:07:32.003
THIS BILL, AND I'M RECOMMENDING
04:07:32.070 --> 04:07:34.839
AN IBO. UM, THIS IS IT'S A LONG
04:07:34.906 --> 04:07:37.709
LINEAGE. I THINK SENATOR JACKSON
04:07:37.776 --> 04:07:39.878
WORKED ON A SENATE. MCGUIRE
04:07:39.945 --> 04:07:41.146
WORKED ON IT. NOW THIS BILL, AND
04:07:41.213 --> 04:07:42.948
ALL THE BILLS HAVE BEEN A LITTLE
04:07:43.014 --> 04:07:44.082
BIT DIFFERENT OR SIGNIFICANTLY
04:07:44.149 --> 04:07:46.318
DIFFERENT IN SOME WAYS. BUT
04:07:46.384 --> 04:07:47.852
THEY'RE ALL TRYING TO GET OUT
04:07:47.919 --> 04:07:49.588
THE BROADER ISSUE OF HOW DO WE
04:07:49.654 --> 04:07:51.656
DEAL WITH THE FIRE ZONES AND THE
04:07:51.723 --> 04:07:53.325
FACT THAT FRANKLIN WE HAVE
04:07:53.391 --> 04:07:55.460
GROWING WILD FIRE ZONES IN TERMS
04:07:55.527 --> 04:07:57.562
OF THE HIGH RISK AND THE VERY
04:07:57.629 --> 04:07:58.863
HIGH OR THE HIGH SEVERITY? VERY
04:07:58.930 --> 04:08:00.765
HIGH SEVERITY. AND WE'RE I KNOW
04:08:00.832 --> 04:08:01.933
WE'RE EXPECTING NEW CAL FIRE
04:08:02.000 --> 04:08:05.237
MAPS SOON. AND I WE EXPECTED THE
04:08:05.303 --> 04:08:08.106
ZONES ARE GOING TO GROW. AND SO
04:08:08.173 --> 04:08:09.808
WE HAVE A REAL ISSUE ON OUR
04:08:09.874 --> 04:08:11.943
HANDS. AND I THINK IF WE TAKE AN
04:08:12.010 --> 04:08:13.578
APPROACH, LIKE HUGE SWATHS OF
04:08:13.645 --> 04:08:15.914
THE STATE ARE OFF LIMITS TO NEW
04:08:15.981 --> 04:08:17.749
HOUSING. WE'RE REALLY SHOOTING
04:08:17.816 --> 04:08:19.451
OURSELVES IN THE FOOT, AND WE
04:08:19.517 --> 04:08:21.886
HAVE MILLIONS OF NEW HOMES AND I
04:08:21.953 --> 04:08:23.855
KNOW IN A VACUUM, IT'S EASIER TO
04:08:23.922 --> 04:08:25.824
SAY. THAT TO RISK YOUR THAT'S A
04:08:25.890 --> 04:08:27.492
RISKIER AREA FOR WILDFIRES.
04:08:27.559 --> 04:08:28.660
THEREFORE WE SHOULDN'T BE
04:08:28.727 --> 04:08:31.663
BUILDING IN IT, AND I THINK WE
04:08:31.730 --> 04:08:33.398
HAVE TO TAKE A MORE NUANCED
04:08:33.465 --> 04:08:35.734
APPROACH THAN THAT. I THINK THAT
04:08:35.800 --> 04:08:37.802
THIS BILL REALLY IS AN EFFORT TO
04:08:37.869 --> 04:08:39.804
DO THAT. UM I ALSO I JUST WANT
04:08:39.871 --> 04:08:42.540
TO SO WHAT? ONE OF THE THINGS
04:08:42.607 --> 04:08:43.642
THAT'S VERY FRUSTRATING TO ME
04:08:43.708 --> 04:08:45.277
ABOUT THESE CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
04:08:45.343 --> 04:08:47.245
WILDFIRE ZONES AND WHETHER WE
04:08:47.312 --> 04:08:49.047
SHOULD BE BUILDING OR TO WHAT
04:08:49.114 --> 04:08:50.148
EXTENT WHICH WE BUILDING IN
04:08:50.215 --> 04:08:52.217
THESE ZONES. IS IT ALL? IT'S
04:08:52.284 --> 04:08:54.986
ALWAYS DECOUPLED FROM OKAY. IF
04:08:55.053 --> 04:08:56.388
YOU'RE NOT GOING TO BUILD HERE,
04:08:56.454 --> 04:08:58.590
THEN WHERE ARE WE GONNA BUILD?
04:08:58.657 --> 04:09:01.059
SO THAT YOU KNOW AGAIN AS WE
04:09:01.126 --> 04:09:02.494
TALKED ABOUT EARLIER TODAY, YOU
04:09:02.560 --> 04:09:04.129
KNOW ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO ARE
04:09:04.195 --> 04:09:05.964
HAVING TO LEAVE CALIFORNIA OR
04:09:06.031 --> 04:09:07.332
SLEEPING CARS OR HAVE 10 PEOPLE
04:09:07.399 --> 04:09:08.767
LIVING IN A SINGLE HOME. WHERE
04:09:08.833 --> 04:09:11.002
ARE WE GOING TO BUILD? AND SOME
04:09:11.069 --> 04:09:12.637
OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE JUST TO BE
04:09:12.704 --> 04:09:14.139
BLUNT, WHO ADVOCATE THE MOST
04:09:14.205 --> 04:09:15.840
VOCIFEROUSLY NOT TO BUILD AND
04:09:15.907 --> 04:09:18.043
WILDFIRE ZONES. ARE ALSO THE
04:09:18.109 --> 04:09:20.779
PEOPLE WHO ARE ACTIVELY OPPOSING
04:09:20.845 --> 04:09:21.880
GOOD FAITH EFFORTS TO HAVE MORE
04:09:21.946 --> 04:09:26.084
HOUSING DENSITY. IN PLACES THAT
04:09:26.151 --> 04:09:27.819
ARE NOT AT HIGH RISK OF
04:09:27.886 --> 04:09:29.154
WILDFIRE. WHETHER IT'S A SAN
04:09:29.220 --> 04:09:30.622
FRANCISCO OR PARTS OF SILICON
04:09:30.689 --> 04:09:33.658
VALLEY OR PARTS OF WEST L A OR
04:09:33.725 --> 04:09:36.227
OR ELSEWHERE. SO WE HAVE PEOPLE
04:09:36.294 --> 04:09:37.395
SAYING DON'T BUILD HERE BUT ALSO
04:09:37.462 --> 04:09:40.498
HOW DARE YOU? PUT ANY MORE
04:09:40.565 --> 04:09:42.867
DENSITY HERE, AND YOU CAN'T HAVE
04:09:42.934 --> 04:09:46.137
IT BOTH WAYS, AND IF WE'RE GOING
04:09:46.204 --> 04:09:47.405
TO NOT DO ANYTHING AND SOME OF
04:09:47.472 --> 04:09:50.342
THESE ZONES BETTER AT HIGH RISK
04:09:50.408 --> 04:09:53.378
OF WILDFIRES ARE HIGHER RISK.
04:09:53.445 --> 04:09:54.813
AND WE'RE GOING TO ACTUALLY
04:09:54.879 --> 04:09:55.747
BUILDING UP HOMES AND WE'RE
04:09:55.814 --> 04:09:57.248
GOING TO HAVE EXTRA SUPER DUPER
04:09:57.315 --> 04:09:59.217
DENSITY IN PLACES LIKE SAN
04:09:59.284 --> 04:10:01.119
FRANCISCO, SO I THINK WE NEED TO
04:10:01.186 --> 04:10:04.589
TAKE A GLOBAL VIEW OF THIS. AND
04:10:04.656 --> 04:10:05.924
I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD JUST BE
04:10:05.990 --> 04:10:08.159
SHUTTING DOWN DEVELOPMENT.
04:10:08.226 --> 04:10:10.929
INVEST SWATHS OF CALIFORNIA I
04:10:10.995 --> 04:10:12.797
THINK THIS BILL AGAIN IS A GOOD
04:10:12.864 --> 04:10:14.799
FAITH EFFORT TO GET AT THE
04:10:14.866 --> 04:10:15.734
ISSUE, AND I APPRECIATE THAT
04:10:15.800 --> 04:10:16.701
UNDERSTANDING. THERE WILL BE
04:10:16.768 --> 04:10:17.669
CONTINUING CONVERSATIONS MOVING
04:10:17.736 --> 04:10:18.737
FORWARD, SO I'M RECOMMENDING AN
04:10:18.803 --> 04:10:24.476
AYE VOTE. AND I THINK WE HAVE A
04:10:24.542 --> 04:10:25.977
MOTION BY SENATOR ROTH. AND SO
04:10:26.044 --> 04:10:30.281
YOU MAY CLOSE. I WANT TO THANK
04:10:30.348 --> 04:10:32.684
THE CHAIR FOR THOSE CLOSING
04:10:32.751 --> 04:10:34.953
COMMENTS AS THAT'S VERY MUCH IN
04:10:35.019 --> 04:10:37.222
LINE WITH WHAT I WOULD ADD TO
04:10:37.288 --> 04:10:39.257
THIS. I WOULD JUST SIMPLY ADD
04:10:39.324 --> 04:10:43.161
THAT DOING NOTHING. UH REGARDING
04:10:43.228 --> 04:10:45.363
BUILDING ACROSS OUR STATE IS
04:10:45.430 --> 04:10:46.965
MUCH OF THE REASON THAT YOU HAVE
04:10:47.031 --> 04:10:48.900
SPENT ALL DAY HEARING ABOUT
04:10:48.967 --> 04:10:50.235
HOUSING PRODUCTION. AND WHEN WE
04:10:50.301 --> 04:10:54.038
DO NOTHING WE CAN EXPECT EXACTLY
04:10:54.105 --> 04:10:56.341
WHERE WE ARE HERE IN CALIFORNIA
04:10:56.408 --> 04:10:59.511
, WHICH IS SIMPLY MORE AND MORE
04:10:59.577 --> 04:11:00.979
CALIFORNIANS NOT HAVING AN
04:11:01.045 --> 04:11:03.381
OPPORTUNITY TO LIVE NOT ONLY IN
04:11:03.448 --> 04:11:05.817
A HOME OR A RENTAL AND LEAVING
04:11:05.884 --> 04:11:07.752
OUR STATE, SO WITH THAT I WOULD
04:11:07.819 --> 04:11:11.122
ASK FOR MY VOTE. THANK YOU. WE
04:11:11.189 --> 04:11:13.024
HAVE A MOTION AND WILL CALL THE
04:11:13.091 --> 04:11:16.127
ROLL. THIS IS ASSEMBLY BILL 27
04:11:16.194 --> 04:11:18.596
05 BY SOME NUMBER QUIRK-SILVA.
04:11:18.663 --> 04:11:20.298
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST
04:11:20.365 --> 04:11:22.033
BE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:11:22.100 --> 04:11:23.201
APPROPRIATIONS SENATOR WIENER
04:11:23.268 --> 04:11:27.806
WIENER. AYE, BATES. BATES CAMERO
04:11:27.872 --> 04:11:29.974
, CABRERO, CORTEZ CORTEZ E
04:11:30.041 --> 04:11:32.677
MCGUIRE, PH<c.cyan>UG BROTH BROTH I.</c>
04:11:32.744 --> 04:11:40.285
SKINNER. HAMBURG. 5 TO 0. WE'LL
04:11:40.351 --> 04:11:42.587
PUT THAT BILL ON CALL, SO THANK
04:11:42.654 --> 04:11:45.056
YOU MEMBERS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S UM
04:11:45.123 --> 04:11:46.825
, ECSTASY THAT SOMEONE MEMBER
04:11:46.891 --> 04:11:48.193
RIVAS THIS YEAR SO YOU MAY
04:11:48.259 --> 04:11:59.304
PRESENT ITEM 16, MAYBE 20 TO 34.
04:11:59.370 --> 04:12:00.505
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. SENATOR IS
04:12:00.572 --> 04:12:05.443
GOOD TO SEE EVERYBODY. MR BLOOM.
04:12:05.510 --> 04:12:07.579
I THINK THIS IS THE SECOND WEEK
04:12:07.645 --> 04:12:08.780
I SEE MR BLOOM ON THE SCREEN
04:12:08.847 --> 04:12:10.715
INSIDE NOW TO RUSH DOWN HERE
04:12:10.782 --> 04:12:12.851
BECAUSE MY BILLS BEFORE HIS GOOD
04:12:12.917 --> 04:12:15.086
AFTERNOON. IT'S GREAT TO SEE
04:12:15.153 --> 04:12:16.054
EVERYBODY IN THIS BILL. UH THIS
04:12:16.120 --> 04:12:18.323
THIS LEGISLATION ASSEMBLY BILL
04:12:18.389 --> 04:12:21.459
22346 TO CREATE STANDARDS FOR
04:12:21.526 --> 04:12:22.060
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO APPROVE
04:12:22.126 --> 04:12:23.294
WHAT'S CALLED POST ENTITLEMENT
04:12:23.361 --> 04:12:25.797
RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS. UM
04:12:25.864 --> 04:12:27.131
AND TO BE CLEAR THIS LEGISLATION
04:12:27.198 --> 04:12:29.000
ONLY AFFECTS PERMITS THAT ARE
04:12:29.067 --> 04:12:30.935
ISSUED AFTER THE PROJECT HAS
04:12:31.002 --> 04:12:32.670
BEEN APPROVED BY THE LOCAL
04:12:32.737 --> 04:12:34.172
GOVERNMENT AGENCY AND AFTER ANY
04:12:34.239 --> 04:12:36.608
SEQUA REVIEW. CURRENTLY THERE'S
04:12:36.674 --> 04:12:37.976
NO STANDARDIZED PROCESS FOR THE
04:12:38.042 --> 04:12:39.143
APPROVAL OF HOME BUILDING
04:12:39.210 --> 04:12:40.979
PERMITS, AND AS A RESULT, THE
04:12:41.045 --> 04:12:41.779
ABILITY FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
04:12:41.846 --> 04:12:43.982
RECEIVE A PROVEN EXECUTE HOME
04:12:44.048 --> 04:12:45.350
BUILDING PERMITS IN A TIMELY
04:12:45.416 --> 04:12:46.885
MANNER. IT VARIES FROM
04:12:46.951 --> 04:12:47.852
JURISDICTION JURISDICTION ACROSS
04:12:47.919 --> 04:12:49.954
OUR STATE, AND UNFORTUNATELY
04:12:50.021 --> 04:12:50.889
SOME JURISDICTIONS MANY PROJECTS
04:12:50.955 --> 04:12:52.724
SPEND MONTHS OR EVEN YEARS,
04:12:52.790 --> 04:12:53.858
WAITING FOR THE APPROVAL AND
04:12:53.925 --> 04:12:54.959
EXECUTION OF HIS BUILDING
04:12:55.026 --> 04:12:57.462
PERMITS. IN THIS IS AGAIN AFTER
04:12:57.529 --> 04:12:58.630
THE PROJECT ITSELF HAS BEEN
04:12:58.696 --> 04:12:59.697
REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY THE
04:12:59.764 --> 04:13:02.867
LOCAL GOVERNMENT. AND SO, THESE
04:13:02.934 --> 04:13:04.302
ADMINISTRATIVE UH, THIS
04:13:04.369 --> 04:13:06.437
PERMITTING, UM THESE DELAYS THEY
04:13:06.504 --> 04:13:08.006
INCREASE PROJECT COSTS. THEY
04:13:08.072 --> 04:13:10.241
AFFECT HOUSING AFFORDABILITY.
04:13:10.308 --> 04:13:11.376
THEY SLOW OVERALL CRITICAL
04:13:11.442 --> 04:13:14.345
HOUSING PRODUCTION AND YOU KNOW
04:13:14.412 --> 04:13:16.080
IN OBVIOUSLY THIS IS AT A TIME
04:13:16.147 --> 04:13:17.382
WHEN OUR HOUSING CRISIS
04:13:17.448 --> 04:13:19.851
CONTINUES TO WORSEN, AND SO THIS
04:13:19.918 --> 04:13:21.319
LEGISLATION WILL GO A LONG WAY
04:13:21.386 --> 04:13:22.520
TO IMPROVE TRANSPARENCY,
04:13:22.587 --> 04:13:23.288
PREDICTABILITY AND CREATE
04:13:23.354 --> 04:13:25.456
EFFICIENCIES. FOR BOTH HOME
04:13:25.523 --> 04:13:27.225
BUILDERS AND LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
04:13:27.292 --> 04:13:28.393
. WHEN PROCESSING THESE POSE
04:13:28.459 --> 04:13:29.027
ENTITLEMENT BUILDING PERMITS,
04:13:29.093 --> 04:13:31.329
AND IT DOES SO BY FIRST
04:13:31.396 --> 04:13:32.730
INFORMATION POSTING BY REQUIRING
04:13:32.797 --> 04:13:33.231
THAT LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
04:13:33.298 --> 04:13:35.233
PUBLISHED AN ONLINE CHECKLIST
04:13:35.300 --> 04:13:36.367
THAT THAT DETAILS THE
04:13:36.434 --> 04:13:37.368
INFORMATION REQUIRED FROM ANY
04:13:37.435 --> 04:13:40.204
APPLICANT. A SECOND WOULD
04:13:40.271 --> 04:13:41.706
ESTABLISH A TIMEFRAME UNDER
04:13:41.773 --> 04:13:42.707
WHICH LOCAL JURISDICTIONS MUST
04:13:42.774 --> 04:13:44.175
DETERMINE WHETHER AN APPLICATION
04:13:44.242 --> 04:13:46.711
IS COMPLETE AND THIRD,
04:13:46.778 --> 04:13:48.012
ESTABLISHING A SUBSTANTIVE
04:13:48.079 --> 04:13:49.847
REVIEW TIMEFRAME. THAT REQUIRES
04:13:49.914 --> 04:13:51.349
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO REVIEW
04:13:51.416 --> 04:13:52.850
BUILDING PERMITS WITHIN 30 TO 60
04:13:52.917 --> 04:13:55.887
DAYS, ALL DEPENDING ON THE SIZE
04:13:55.954 --> 04:13:58.423
OF THE PROJECTS, AND YOU GOT
04:13:58.489 --> 04:13:59.057
AGAIN ALTOGETHER. THESE
04:13:59.123 --> 04:14:01.059
PROVISIONS WILL GO A LONG WAY TO
04:14:01.125 --> 04:14:03.161
REDUCING THESE DELAYS. IN THE
04:14:03.227 --> 04:14:04.462
BUILDING PERMIT PROCESS AND WITH
04:14:04.529 --> 04:14:06.998
US THIS AFTERNOON OR THIS EARLY
04:14:07.065 --> 04:14:09.567
EVENING TO TESTIFY HIS KOI SMITH
04:14:09.634 --> 04:14:11.369
, WHO IS THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF
04:14:11.436 --> 04:14:12.437
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION,
04:14:12.503 --> 04:14:14.706
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. EVENING
04:14:14.772 --> 04:14:16.307
CHAIR AND MEMBERS COREY SMITH
04:14:16.374 --> 04:14:16.975
WITH THE HOUSING ACTION
04:14:17.041 --> 04:14:18.610
COALITION. WE'RE MEMBER
04:14:18.676 --> 04:14:19.377
SUPPORTED NONPROFIT THAT
04:14:19.444 --> 04:14:20.712
ADVOCATES FOR THE CONSTRUCTION
04:14:20.778 --> 04:14:22.680
OF NEW HOMES AT ALL LEVELS OF
04:14:22.747 --> 04:14:23.715
AFFORDABILITY ACROSS THE STATE
04:14:23.781 --> 04:14:26.551
OF CALIFORNIA. OUR MEMBERS AND
04:14:26.618 --> 04:14:27.986
MANY OTHER HOMEBUILDERS ACROSS
04:14:28.052 --> 04:14:29.988
THE STATE HAVE WATCHED ALL OF
04:14:30.054 --> 04:14:32.056
YOU SPENT THE LAST FEW YEARS
04:14:32.123 --> 04:14:32.890
WORKING ON A NUMBER OF BILLS
04:14:32.957 --> 04:14:33.791
RELATED TO THE ENTITLEMENT
04:14:33.858 --> 04:14:35.560
PROCESS AND SEE AN OPPORTUNITY
04:14:35.627 --> 04:14:37.495
TO IMPROVE THE POST ENTITLEMENT
04:14:37.562 --> 04:14:38.296
BUILDING PERMIT ACQUISITION
04:14:38.363 --> 04:14:41.065
PROCESS. MAYBE 2 TO 34 CREATES A
04:14:41.132 --> 04:14:42.467
FRAMEWORK FOR DEVELOPERS AND
04:14:42.533 --> 04:14:43.901
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO PROCESS
04:14:43.968 --> 04:14:44.969
THESE RESIDENTIAL BUILDING
04:14:45.036 --> 04:14:46.471
PERMITS MORE EFFECTIVELY AND
04:14:46.537 --> 04:14:48.473
COST EFFICIENTLY. IN REALITY,
04:14:48.539 --> 04:14:50.375
THERE'S A NUMBER OF REASONS THAT
04:14:50.441 --> 04:14:51.509
THESE PERMITS DO NOT GET
04:14:51.576 --> 04:14:53.945
REVIEWED ANY TIMELY MANNER. FOR
04:14:54.012 --> 04:14:54.979
EXAMPLE, MANY PROJECT
04:14:55.046 --> 04:14:56.581
APPLICATIONS DO NOT PROVIDE THE
04:14:56.648 --> 04:14:57.982
SUFFICIENT INFORMATION A CITY
04:14:58.049 --> 04:14:58.916
NEEDS IN ORDER TO ACTUALLY
04:14:58.983 --> 04:15:00.618
REVIEW THE APPLICATION AND BY
04:15:00.685 --> 04:15:02.520
REQUIRING A SIMPLE CHECKLIST
04:15:02.587 --> 04:15:04.222
PROJECTS WILL KNOW WHAT NEEDS TO
04:15:04.288 --> 04:15:05.857
BE SUBMITTED. SOMETIMES IT IS A
04:15:05.923 --> 04:15:06.991
STAFFING CAPACITY ISSUE AND BY
04:15:07.058 --> 04:15:08.860
REQUIRING MODEL PERMITS. HIGHER
04:15:08.926 --> 04:15:10.361
QUALITY APPLICATIONS WILL GET
04:15:10.428 --> 04:15:11.329
SUBMITTED BECAUSE THE PROJECT
04:15:11.396 --> 04:15:13.464
TEAM WILL UNDERSTAND HOW A CITY
04:15:13.531 --> 04:15:14.332
WANTS TO RECEIVE THAT
04:15:14.399 --> 04:15:15.333
INFORMATION, AND THIS WILL
04:15:15.400 --> 04:15:17.402
REDUCE THE OVERALL STAFF HOURS
04:15:17.468 --> 04:15:18.870
NEEDED TO DO THE REVIEW.
04:15:18.936 --> 04:15:20.972
SOMETIMES AND THIS IS VERY RARE
04:15:21.039 --> 04:15:22.640
. IT IS ACTUALLY A CITY ACTING
04:15:22.707 --> 04:15:23.808
IN BAD FAITH, TRYING TO SLOW
04:15:23.875 --> 04:15:24.842
DOWN THE PRODUCTION OF NEW
04:15:24.909 --> 04:15:26.144
HOUSING. REGARDLESS OF THE
04:15:26.210 --> 04:15:27.912
REASON THE PERMITTING PROCESS
04:15:27.979 --> 04:15:28.946
CAN UNNECESSARILY TAKE UP TO
04:15:29.013 --> 04:15:30.048
THREE YEARS IN CERTAIN
04:15:30.114 --> 04:15:33.351
SITUATIONS. AND IT COULD BE
04:15:33.418 --> 04:15:34.185
MONTHS BEFORE AN APPLICATION IS
04:15:34.252 --> 04:15:35.053
EVEN ACKNOWLEDGED BY LOCAL
04:15:35.119 --> 04:15:37.155
JURISDICTION REQUIRING
04:15:37.221 --> 04:15:39.223
REASONABLE TIMELINES FOR REVIEW
04:15:39.290 --> 04:15:41.259
PROJECTS ARE NO LONGER GOING TO
04:15:41.325 --> 04:15:42.460
HAVE TO WAIT ENDLESSLY TO GET
04:15:42.527 --> 04:15:43.594
THEIR PERMITS APPROVED. THIS
04:15:43.661 --> 04:15:44.829
BILL IS GOING TO BE PARTICULARLY
04:15:44.896 --> 04:15:46.431
IMPACTFUL FOR 100% SUBSIDIZED,
04:15:46.497 --> 04:15:48.066
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, AS MANY OF
04:15:48.132 --> 04:15:49.901
YOU KNOW, FINANCING THESE TYPES
04:15:49.967 --> 04:15:51.536
OF PROJECTS ARE IS INCREDIBLY
04:15:51.602 --> 04:15:52.704
DIFFICULT IN DUE TO A COMPLEX
04:15:52.770 --> 04:15:55.373
TAX CREDIT SYSTEM. MANY PROJECTS
04:15:55.440 --> 04:15:57.909
FACE VERY TIGHT TIME FRAMES IN
04:15:57.975 --> 04:15:59.043
ORDER TO ACQUIRE THE PERMITS TO
04:15:59.110 --> 04:16:00.812
ACTUALLY SECURE THEIR FUNDING.
04:16:00.878 --> 04:16:02.146
WE BELIEVE THIS IS A COMMON
04:16:02.213 --> 04:16:03.648
SENSE APPROACH TO CREATING A
04:16:03.715 --> 04:16:05.016
BETTER PROCESS FOR PROJECT
04:16:05.083 --> 04:16:06.117
TEAMS, CITIES AND COMMUNITIES AS
04:16:06.184 --> 04:16:07.552
WE HOPEFULLY SEE MORE HOUSING
04:16:07.618 --> 04:16:08.653
BUILT ACROSS THE STATE. THANK
04:16:08.720 --> 04:16:09.987
YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU, MR
04:16:10.054 --> 04:16:18.563
SMITH. MR STIVERS. SPORT. MARK
04:16:18.629 --> 04:16:19.630
STIVERS OF THE CALIFORNIA
04:16:19.697 --> 04:16:25.870
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT.
04:16:25.937 --> 04:16:27.105
JENNIFER MENTAL WITH THE
04:16:27.171 --> 04:16:28.272
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM
04:16:28.339 --> 04:16:32.210
AND SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. AMBER
04:16:32.276 --> 04:16:33.144
MADISON, CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
04:16:33.211 --> 04:16:37.849
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT. HARD ON
04:16:37.915 --> 04:16:39.016
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIAN B AND
04:16:39.083 --> 04:16:43.121
SUPPORT. COLLECTING WITH THE
04:16:43.187 --> 04:16:44.188
SILICON VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP
04:16:44.255 --> 04:16:50.628
IN SUPPORT. ADRIAN MOHAMMED WITH
04:16:50.695 --> 04:16:51.963
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
04:16:52.029 --> 04:16:53.431
BEHALF OF HABITAT FOR HUMANITY.
04:16:53.498 --> 04:16:55.133
CALIFORNIA CIVIC WELL MADE PEN,
04:16:55.199 --> 04:16:56.267
HOUSING AND PHIL, SUDDEN COMPANY
04:16:56.334 --> 04:16:58.936
AND SUPPORT CHRIS MARTIN ON
04:16:59.003 --> 04:17:00.671
BEHALF OF HOUSE IN CALIFORNIA
04:17:00.738 --> 04:17:04.776
AND SUPPORT TIFFANY FAN, AND WE
04:17:04.842 --> 04:17:05.843
HAVE A BRIDGE, HOUSING AND
04:17:05.910 --> 04:17:07.645
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ANY
04:17:07.712 --> 04:17:09.013
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN THE
04:17:09.080 --> 04:17:11.149
HEARING ROOM, SAYING NONE WILL
04:17:11.215 --> 04:17:12.316
GO TO THE PHONE LINES FOR
04:17:12.383 --> 04:17:17.021
SUPPORT. TOOK EXPRESS SUPPORT
04:17:17.088 --> 04:17:18.856
FOR THE BILL. PRESS ONE FOLLOWED
04:17:18.923 --> 04:17:20.725
BY ZERO ON YOUR PHONE ONE AND
04:17:20.792 --> 04:17:22.760
THEN ZERO, PLEASE. WE'LL GO TO 3
04:17:22.827 --> 04:17:26.664
18. MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS LAUREN
04:17:26.731 --> 04:17:27.865
DAVID LINDSAY, REPRESENTING THE
04:17:27.932 --> 04:17:28.466
AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION
04:17:28.533 --> 04:17:35.973
AND SUPPORT 400. MR CHAIR AND
04:17:36.040 --> 04:17:38.276
MEMBERS ALEX TORRES WITH THE
04:17:38.342 --> 04:17:39.010
BARRIER COUNCIL LIKE TO THANK
04:17:39.076 --> 04:17:40.645
OUR FRIENDS AT THE HOUSING
04:17:40.711 --> 04:17:41.946
ACTION COALITION AND
04:17:42.013 --> 04:17:42.547
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LUZ RIVAS FOR
04:17:42.613 --> 04:17:44.148
ALL THE HARD WORK. THANK YOU.
04:17:44.215 --> 04:17:48.352
406. MICHAEL AND WHISPER AND
04:17:48.419 --> 04:17:55.159
STRONG SUPPORT. 4 26. HAVE HIM
04:17:55.226 --> 04:18:02.433
GET NPH INSTRUCTIONS. 4 25.
04:18:02.500 --> 04:18:04.735
MIMIC CLEARLY WITH KG GLOBAL
04:18:04.802 --> 04:18:06.037
SOLUTIONS REPRESENTING TH
04:18:06.103 --> 04:18:08.873
HOUSING AND SUPPORT THANK YOU.
04:18:08.940 --> 04:18:22.420
NO FURTHER LINES AND CUTE.
04:18:22.486 --> 04:18:24.355
OKAY IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION
04:18:24.422 --> 04:18:25.556
HERE IN THE ROOM? PLEASE COME
04:18:25.623 --> 04:18:30.061
FORWARD. GOOD EVENING. GOOD
04:18:30.127 --> 04:18:31.062
EVENING CHAIR MEMBERS BRADY
04:18:31.128 --> 04:18:32.997
GARDEN ON BEHALF OF THE
04:18:33.064 --> 04:18:34.065
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS IN
04:18:34.131 --> 04:18:35.633
RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION TO THIS
04:18:35.700 --> 04:18:37.602
BILL. WE'VE HAD GREAT
04:18:37.668 --> 04:18:38.502
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHORS
04:18:38.569 --> 04:18:40.271
AND SPONSORS ON THE BILL AND ARE
04:18:40.338 --> 04:18:42.406
HOPEFUL THAT THE AMENDMENTS WE
04:18:42.473 --> 04:18:43.507
RECOMMENDED IN OUR LETTER WILL
04:18:43.574 --> 04:18:44.842
BE ACCEPTED. JUST A LOT OF
04:18:44.909 --> 04:18:47.211
CONCERNS WITH THE TIMELINES OF,
04:18:47.278 --> 04:18:48.713
YOU KNOW, BUILDING DEPARTMENTS
04:18:48.779 --> 04:18:50.214
ALREADY UNDERFUNDED AND
04:18:50.281 --> 04:18:52.350
UNDERSTAFFED. A LOT OF CONCERN
04:18:52.416 --> 04:18:53.885
THAT THEY CAN'T DO THAT, YOU
04:18:53.951 --> 04:18:54.886
KNOW, TALK ABOUT TRYING TO REACH
04:18:54.952 --> 04:18:55.887
THESE TIMELINES. THERE OULD BE
04:18:55.953 --> 04:18:57.722
SOME ISSUES WHERE YOU'RE GONNA
04:18:57.788 --> 04:18:58.823
HAVE TO GO TO AN OUTSIDE
04:18:58.890 --> 04:19:00.191
CONTRACTOR AND PAY SOME MORE
04:19:00.258 --> 04:19:01.692
MONEY TO THEM. THAT'S I'M GOING
04:19:01.759 --> 04:19:03.594
TO GO ON THE DEVELOPERS AND THE
04:19:03.661 --> 04:19:04.695
HOMEOWNER, SO WE HAVE SOME
04:19:04.762 --> 04:19:06.163
CONCERNS THERE. SO AS A MORE
04:19:06.230 --> 04:19:07.565
REASONABLE APPROACH. WE BROUGHT
04:19:07.632 --> 04:19:09.300
SOME TIERED SYSTEM FOR THIS BILL
04:19:09.367 --> 04:19:12.069
TO AS OPPOSED TO, YOU KNOW, THE
04:19:12.136 --> 04:19:12.904
TIME LIMITS ALREADY ESTABLISHED
04:19:12.970 --> 04:19:14.472
, INCLUDING 45 BUSINESS DAYS FOR
04:19:14.538 --> 04:19:17.942
25 UNITS ARE FEWER. 26 TO 50
04:19:18.009 --> 04:19:19.443
UNITS ARE FEWER HAD 60 BUSINESS
04:19:19.510 --> 04:19:23.347
DAYS AND 50 TO 100 UNITS, UH,
04:19:23.414 --> 04:19:25.483
WOULD BE 90 BUSINESS DAYS. NOW.
04:19:25.549 --> 04:19:27.051
THE REASON BEING IS WE HAVE
04:19:27.118 --> 04:19:28.686
WE'RE CAPPING OUT. WE WOULD LIKE
04:19:28.753 --> 04:19:30.888
IT TO BE CAPPED AT 100 UNITS IS
04:19:30.955 --> 04:19:31.822
BECAUSE WE DON'T WANT HIGH RISE
04:19:31.889 --> 04:19:33.357
RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS TO HAVE
04:19:33.424 --> 04:19:34.625
THE TIME CLOCKS. YOU KNOW, WE'VE
04:19:34.692 --> 04:19:35.593
ALSO RECOMMENDED SPECIFYING IN
04:19:35.660 --> 04:19:36.694
THE LEGISLATION BASED OFF OF
04:19:36.761 --> 04:19:38.763
CURRENT STATUTE. THAT HIGH RISE
04:19:38.829 --> 04:19:40.064
RESIDENTIAL WOULD BE EXEMPTED
04:19:40.131 --> 04:19:41.866
FROM THIS AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO
04:19:41.933 --> 04:19:42.900
THOSE CONTINUED CONVERSATIONS
04:19:42.967 --> 04:19:44.101
WITH THE AUTHOR'S OFFICE WANTED
04:19:44.168 --> 04:19:45.937
TO BRING THOSE ATTENTIONS TO YOU
04:19:46.003 --> 04:19:47.905
ALL TODAY, AND I APPRECIATE THE
04:19:47.972 --> 04:19:49.073
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK AND AGAIN,
04:19:49.140 --> 04:19:51.275
WE'LL LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
04:19:51.342 --> 04:19:52.043
WITH THE AUTHORS AND SPONSORS ON
04:19:52.109 --> 04:19:54.478
THIS BUILD UP TO FIND SOME MORE
04:19:54.545 --> 04:19:55.646
COMMON GROUND AND HOPEFULLY GETS
04:19:55.713 --> 04:19:57.381
A GET OUR AMENDMENTS IN. SO
04:19:57.448 --> 04:19:58.082
THANK YOU. ANY ADDITIONAL
04:19:58.149 --> 04:19:58.950
OPPOSITION TESTIMONY IN THE
04:19:59.016 --> 04:20:03.587
ROOM. SAYING THAT WE WILL GO TO
04:20:03.654 --> 04:20:05.589
THE PHONE LINES. CAN YOU CURE UP
04:20:05.656 --> 04:20:07.291
ANY OPPOSITION TESTIMONY? THANK
04:20:07.358 --> 04:20:10.861
YOU. STATE OPPOSITION TO THE
04:20:10.928 --> 04:20:12.697
BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED
04:20:12.763 --> 04:20:13.998
BY THE ZERO AGAIN, THAT'S ONE
04:20:14.065 --> 04:20:22.173
AND THEN ZERO. WE DO HAVE A LINE
04:20:22.239 --> 04:20:23.240
WITH AN OPERATOR. BE JUST A
04:20:23.307 --> 04:20:39.423
MOMENT.
04:20:41.459 --> 04:20:42.660
WELL, GET IN LINE FOR 24. PLEASE
04:20:42.727 --> 04:20:45.463
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON SHARING
04:20:45.529 --> 04:20:47.064
MEMBERS. CHRIS LEE ON BEHALF OF
04:20:47.131 --> 04:20:48.666
THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION
04:20:48.733 --> 04:20:50.034
OF COUNTIES. WE ALSO HAVE AN
04:20:50.101 --> 04:20:52.069
OPPOSING LESS AMENDED POSITION
04:20:52.136 --> 04:20:52.870
BASED ON THE CONCERNS
04:20:52.937 --> 04:20:55.039
ARTICULATED BY CALVO AS WELL AS
04:20:55.106 --> 04:20:56.507
TALKING ABOUT THE COST AND THE
04:20:56.574 --> 04:20:57.641
OPPORTUNITY TO DELAY PERHAPS A
04:20:57.708 --> 04:20:59.777
LITTLE BIT. THE IMPLEMENTATION
04:20:59.844 --> 04:21:01.112
OF THE ONLINE PERMITTING
04:21:01.178 --> 04:21:02.313
REQUIREMENTS BUT HOPE TO RESOLVE
04:21:02.380 --> 04:21:04.281
THIS. THANK YOU. NO FURTHER
04:21:04.348 --> 04:21:09.086
LINES IN QUÊ. OKAY, WE'LL BRING
04:21:09.153 --> 04:21:10.588
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
04:21:10.654 --> 04:21:12.023
COLLEAGUES ANY QUESTIONS OR
04:21:12.089 --> 04:21:13.090
COMMENTS EMOTION BY SENATOR
04:21:13.157 --> 04:21:17.361
ROTH. UM, I KNOW I SAID THIS IN
04:21:17.428 --> 04:21:18.529
THE LAST COMMITTEE SOMETHING BUT
04:21:18.596 --> 04:21:20.364
I WANT TO THANK YOU AGAIN FOR
04:21:20.431 --> 04:21:21.732
BRINGING THIS BILL. IT'S LONG,
04:21:21.799 --> 04:21:23.901
LONG, LONG OVERDUE, AND WE'VE
04:21:23.968 --> 04:21:28.272
HAD A LOT OF FOCUS ON REFORMING
04:21:28.339 --> 04:21:29.473
THE ENTITLEMENT PROCESS, BUT
04:21:29.540 --> 04:21:30.775
POST ENTITLEMENT IS ALSO
04:21:30.841 --> 04:21:31.642
IMPORTANT. SO THANK YOU FOR
04:21:31.709 --> 04:21:33.778
DOING IT. AND WITH THAT WE HAVE
04:21:33.844 --> 04:21:34.779
EMOTION. YOU MAY CLOSE. OKAY
04:21:34.845 --> 04:21:36.881
WELL, I AND I SHOULD HAVE
04:21:36.947 --> 04:21:37.848
MENTIONED THIS IN MY OPENING.
04:21:37.915 --> 04:21:39.817
BUT YOU KNOW, BASED ON OUR LAST
04:21:39.884 --> 04:21:41.118
COMMITTEE, WHICH WAS IN SENATE
04:21:41.185 --> 04:21:42.887
MM. GOVERNMENT FINANCE. WE DID
04:21:42.953 --> 04:21:44.188
ACCEPT AMENDMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN
04:21:44.255 --> 04:21:45.923
CROSSED AND SO THEY HAVE BEEN
04:21:45.990 --> 04:21:47.925
INCLUDED. IT'S STATED IN PAGE
04:21:47.992 --> 04:21:48.793
SIX OF THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS,
04:21:48.859 --> 04:21:49.827
WHICH SHOULD ADDRESS SOME OF THE
04:21:49.894 --> 04:21:52.530
CONCERNS. THERE HAVE BEEN
04:21:52.596 --> 04:21:54.165
EXPRESSED WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
04:21:54.231 --> 04:21:55.533
WITH OPPOSITION. BUT BUT BUT
04:21:55.599 --> 04:21:57.201
CERTAINLY AROUND THE TIME FRAMES
04:21:57.268 --> 04:21:57.935
THAT HAVE BEEN BUILT INTO THIS
04:21:58.002 --> 04:21:59.537
LEGISLATION. IT OFFERS MAXIMUM
04:21:59.603 --> 04:22:00.671
FLEXIBILITY YOU KNOW, EXPRESSLY
04:22:00.738 --> 04:22:04.675
ALLOWS FOR PARTIES TO AGREE THAT
04:22:04.742 --> 04:22:05.576
SOME DIFFERENT TERMS AND
04:22:05.643 --> 04:22:07.311
TIMELINES I COME FROM LOCAL
04:22:07.378 --> 04:22:08.379
GOVERNMENT UNDERSTAND THE
04:22:08.446 --> 04:22:09.647
COMPLEXITY A LOT OF THESE
04:22:09.713 --> 04:22:11.682
PROJECTS AND IT'S BEST TO HANDLE
04:22:11.749 --> 04:22:14.418
THIS STUFF BETWEEN STAKEHOLDERS
04:22:14.485 --> 04:22:15.219
IN BETWEEN THESE PARTIES RATHER
04:22:15.286 --> 04:22:17.088
THAN UM, UH, YOU KNOW, IN OUR
04:22:17.154 --> 04:22:19.190
COURT SYSTEM, SO WE'VE OFFERED
04:22:19.256 --> 04:22:19.857
THAT MAXIMUM FLEXIBILITY, BUT WE
04:22:19.924 --> 04:22:21.826
WILL CONTINUE TO ENGAGE AND WORK
04:22:21.892 --> 04:22:23.127
WITH OPPOSITION AND RESPECTFULLY
04:22:23.194 --> 04:22:24.895
ASK FOR MY VOTE. THANK YOU, MR
04:22:24.962 --> 04:22:28.499
CHAIR. OKAY, WE HAVE EMOTION AND
04:22:28.566 --> 04:22:31.702
WILL CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS
04:22:31.769 --> 04:22:33.704
ASSEMBLY BILL 20 TO 34 BY SOME
04:22:33.771 --> 04:22:35.706
MEMBER ROBERT RIVAS. THE MOTION
04:22:35.773 --> 04:22:37.274
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED, BUT
04:22:37.341 --> 04:22:38.742
FIRST AMEND AND WE REFER TO THE
04:22:38.809 --> 04:22:40.211
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
04:22:40.277 --> 04:22:42.713
SENATOR WIENER. AYE, BATES.
04:22:42.780 --> 04:22:45.516
BATES CABALLERO CABALLERO,
04:22:45.583 --> 04:22:48.219
COURTESY I MCGUIRE PHð BUG,
04:22:48.285 --> 04:22:51.956
ROSS. ROUGH I SKINNER HAMBURG.
04:22:52.022 --> 04:22:56.994
HAMBURG. AYE. 6 TO 0. OKAY,
04:22:57.061 --> 04:23:00.397
WE'LL PUT THAT BILL ON CALL.
04:23:00.464 --> 04:23:03.567
WELL NOW GO TO ITEM 17 A B 2095
04:23:03.634 --> 04:23:06.670
WELCOME. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM.
04:23:06.737 --> 04:23:11.308
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. AND WE'RE
04:23:11.375 --> 04:23:13.577
AS I JUST TOLD HIM WERE TAKEN MR
04:23:13.644 --> 04:23:14.845
RIVAS UP OUR HOLIDAY CARD LIST.
04:23:14.912 --> 04:23:18.916
UH, BUT I AM PLEASED TO BE HERE
04:23:18.983 --> 04:23:21.752
TO PRESENT A B 22 95 A MEASURE
04:23:21.819 --> 04:23:23.220
TO HELP ADDRESS THE TEACHER
04:23:23.287 --> 04:23:24.855
SHORTAGE IN CALIFORNIA WHILE
04:23:24.922 --> 04:23:25.823
PROVIDING POTENTIALLY COPIOUS
04:23:25.890 --> 04:23:30.995
AMOUNTS OF. AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
04:23:31.061 --> 04:23:34.865
UM UH, WE HAVE TAKEN AMENDMENTS
04:23:34.932 --> 04:23:36.400
IN GOVERNMENT AND FINANCE AND
04:23:36.467 --> 04:23:37.801
ARE GOING TO PROCESS THOSE IN
04:23:37.868 --> 04:23:39.870
THIS COMMITTEE. IF IT GETS OUT.
04:23:39.937 --> 04:23:44.441
SO THE PRESSURE IS ON. RECENT
04:23:44.508 --> 04:23:46.443
DATA SHOWS THAT ONE IN 10 SCHOOL
04:23:46.510 --> 04:23:49.013
DISTRICTS ARE LOSING 1/4 OF
04:23:49.079 --> 04:23:51.182
THEIR TEACHERS, SKYROCKETING
04:23:51.248 --> 04:23:52.850
HOUSING PRICES AND SALARIES THAT
04:23:52.917 --> 04:23:54.718
DON'T KEEP UP HAVE MADE IT MORE
04:23:54.785 --> 04:23:55.819
DIFFICULT FOR TEACHERS TO LIVE
04:23:55.886 --> 04:23:56.921
IN THE COMMUNITIES WHERE THEY
04:23:56.987 --> 04:23:59.723
TEACH AND TO TACKLE THIS ISSUE
04:23:59.790 --> 04:24:02.493
46 OF OUR LARGEST SCHOOL
04:24:02.560 --> 04:24:04.528
DISTRICTS IN CALIFORNIA HAVE
04:24:04.595 --> 04:24:05.763
EXPRESSED INTEREST IN BUILDING
04:24:05.829 --> 04:24:07.598
EDUCATIONAL WORKFORCE HOUSING TO
04:24:07.665 --> 04:24:09.967
RECRUIT AND RETAIN STAFF.
04:24:10.034 --> 04:24:11.669
UNFORTUNATELY THE AVERAGE
04:24:11.735 --> 04:24:13.137
EDUCATIONAL WORKFORCE HOUSING
04:24:13.204 --> 04:24:15.472
PROJECT TAKES MORE THAN SEVEN
04:24:15.539 --> 04:24:17.841
YEARS TO COMPLETE, WHICH I THINK
04:24:17.908 --> 04:24:19.810
WE CAN ALL AGREE AS AN
04:24:19.877 --> 04:24:21.011
UNACCEPTABLE TIME LINE DURING
04:24:21.078 --> 04:24:23.614
HOUSING CRISIS. LOCAL RESISTANCE
04:24:23.681 --> 04:24:25.115
, RESTRICTIVE ZONING AND
04:24:25.182 --> 04:24:26.116
COMPLICATED BUREAUCRATIC
04:24:26.183 --> 04:24:28.185
PROCESSES HAVE ADDED YEARS TO
04:24:28.252 --> 04:24:29.486
THE CONSTRUCTION PROCESS
04:24:29.553 --> 04:24:32.089
INCREASED COSTS. AND HINDERED
04:24:32.156 --> 04:24:33.357
EFFORTS TO HOUSE CALIFORNIA'S
04:24:33.424 --> 04:24:35.659
EDUCATIONAL WORKFORCE. TO DATE,
04:24:35.726 --> 04:24:37.394
ONLY THREE SCHOOL DISTRICTS HAVE
04:24:37.461 --> 04:24:38.696
SUCCESSFULLY BUILT HOUSING
04:24:38.762 --> 04:24:39.597
PROJECTS ON PROPERTIES THAT THEY
04:24:39.663 --> 04:24:44.969
OWN. WE CAN DO BETTER. A B 22 95
04:24:45.035 --> 04:24:46.670
WILL HELP SCHOOL DISTRICTS BUILD
04:24:46.737 --> 04:24:48.472
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON SURPLUS
04:24:48.539 --> 04:24:49.940
SCHOOL PROPERTY BY MAKING
04:24:50.007 --> 04:24:52.343
HOUSING AND ALLOWABLE USE.
04:24:52.409 --> 04:24:54.912
HOUSING PROJECTS MUST MEET THE
04:24:54.979 --> 04:24:56.380
HEIGHT DENSITY AND AFFORDABLE
04:24:56.447 --> 04:24:58.148
HOUSING REQUIREMENTS. THEY'RE
04:24:58.215 --> 04:25:00.150
LAID OUT IN THE BILL AND SCHOOL
04:25:00.217 --> 04:25:02.286
DISTRICTS WOULD BE REQUIRED TO
04:25:02.353 --> 04:25:03.887
OFFER DEED RESTRICTED AFFORDABLE
04:25:03.954 --> 04:25:06.624
UNITS FIRST TO THEIR TEACHERS.
04:25:06.690 --> 04:25:09.126
AND STAFF. FURTHERMORE THE ONE
04:25:09.193 --> 04:25:12.696
YEAR DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION THAT
04:25:12.763 --> 04:25:13.697
WE'VE AGREED TO IN THE
04:25:13.764 --> 04:25:14.932
AMENDMENTS WILL GIVE LOCAL
04:25:14.999 --> 04:25:17.868
AGENCIES MORE TIME TO ESTABLISH.
04:25:17.935 --> 04:25:19.970
OBJECTIVE DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS
04:25:20.037 --> 04:25:22.640
. SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN CALIFORNIA
04:25:22.706 --> 04:25:26.210
OVER 75,000 ACRES OF LAND THAT
04:25:26.277 --> 04:25:27.478
ARE POTENTIALLY SUITABLE FOR
04:25:27.544 --> 04:25:30.648
HOUSING. AND I KNOW IT'S A
04:25:30.714 --> 04:25:33.083
STRETCH THAT WE WOULD USE ALL OF
04:25:33.150 --> 04:25:34.585
THAT FOR HOUSING. BUT IF WE DID
04:25:34.652 --> 04:25:36.787
BUILD 30 UNITS PER ACRE ON THAT
04:25:36.854 --> 04:25:39.790
75,000 ACRES PER LAND THAT
04:25:39.857 --> 04:25:41.425
EQUATES TO 2.3 MILLION UNITS OF
04:25:41.492 --> 04:25:45.796
HOUSING VIRTUALLY ELIMINATING
04:25:45.863 --> 04:25:47.031
THE HOUSING SHORTAGE IN THE IN
04:25:47.097 --> 04:25:52.903
THE STATE. AND OF COURSE, MORE
04:25:52.970 --> 04:25:54.238
THAN ENOUGH TO MEET THE HOUSING
04:25:54.305 --> 04:25:55.306
NEEDS OF OUR EDUCATIONAL
04:25:55.372 --> 04:25:57.141
WORKFORCE. AND ENSURE THAT WE
04:25:57.207 --> 04:25:58.375
KEEP QUALITY TEACHERS AND STAFF
04:25:58.442 --> 04:26:00.978
IN THE CLASSROOM. TESTIFYING AND
04:26:01.045 --> 04:26:03.113
SUPPORT TODAY. OUR DANA CUFF THE
04:26:03.180 --> 04:26:04.848
DIRECTOR OF CITY LAB AT U. C, L
04:26:04.915 --> 04:26:07.051
. A AND CHRIS REEF, REPRESENTING
04:26:07.117 --> 04:26:08.118
THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARD
04:26:08.185 --> 04:26:11.188
ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU. AND I
04:26:11.255 --> 04:26:13.457
UNDERSTAND THEY'RE BOTH ON THE
04:26:13.524 --> 04:26:14.358
PHONE. I THINK SO. THE
04:26:14.425 --> 04:26:15.492
MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE HAVE
04:26:15.559 --> 04:26:23.701
THEM. OPEN UP THE LINES. CAN YOU
04:26:23.767 --> 04:26:28.405
HEAR ME? YES, YOU CAN PROCEED.
04:26:28.472 --> 04:26:29.907
THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THE
04:26:29.973 --> 04:26:32.476
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY ON BEHALF
04:26:32.543 --> 04:26:36.046
OF A B 22 95. MY NAME IS DANA
04:26:36.113 --> 04:26:37.848
CALF. I'M A PROFESSOR AT U C L A
04:26:37.915 --> 04:26:39.450
WHERE I RUN THE RESEARCH CENTERS
04:26:39.516 --> 04:26:42.820
CITY LAB AND WITH PARTNERS AT
04:26:42.886 --> 04:26:44.621
BERKELEY'S TURNER CENTER CENTER
04:26:44.688 --> 04:26:46.223
FOR CITIES AND SCHOOLS AND THE
04:26:46.290 --> 04:26:47.057
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
04:26:47.124 --> 04:26:48.158
ASSOCIATION. WE'VE SPENT THE
04:26:48.225 --> 04:26:51.128
LAST TWO YEARS TRYING TO FIGURE
04:26:51.195 --> 04:26:52.796
OUT HOW TO HELP SCHOOL DISTRICTS
04:26:52.863 --> 04:26:54.098
BUILD THIS HOUSING THAT THEY SO
04:26:54.164 --> 04:26:56.800
DESPERATELY NEED. AS
04:26:56.867 --> 04:26:58.802
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM MENTIONED
04:26:58.869 --> 04:26:59.870
, THERE'S DEMAND ACROSS THE
04:26:59.937 --> 04:27:01.872
STATE AND OUR MOST RECENT
04:27:01.939 --> 04:27:03.507
INDICATION OF THAT IS THAT WE'RE
04:27:03.574 --> 04:27:04.908
GOING TO RUN A WORKSHOP FOR
04:27:04.975 --> 04:27:05.809
SCHOOL DISTRICTS WHO ARE
04:27:05.876 --> 04:27:06.877
STRUGGLING TO BUILD THIS
04:27:06.944 --> 04:27:09.046
HOUSING. WE WANTED TO GET FOUR
04:27:09.113 --> 04:27:10.781
DISTRICTS TO SIGN UP, ALMOST 50
04:27:10.848 --> 04:27:15.919
APPLIED. 2 8022 95 MINUTES OF
04:27:15.986 --> 04:27:17.421
TREMENDOUS NEED IT REMOVED
04:27:17.488 --> 04:27:19.289
BARRIERS WHILE KEEPING LOCAL
04:27:19.356 --> 04:27:20.257
OBJECTIVE PLANNING REVIEW IN
04:27:20.324 --> 04:27:23.761
PLACE. IT GUARANTEES THAT
04:27:23.827 --> 04:27:24.728
SCHOOLS CAN BUILD UP TO THREE
04:27:24.795 --> 04:27:26.764
STORIES AT REASONABLE DENSITIES
04:27:26.830 --> 04:27:28.198
. IT PERMITS HOUSING ON SCHOOL
04:27:28.265 --> 04:27:31.201
ON PROPERTY WITHOUT RESUMING IT
04:27:31.268 --> 04:27:32.803
REMOVES OTHER TIME CONSUMING AND
04:27:32.870 --> 04:27:35.806
COMPLICATED PROCESSES. AND ALL
04:27:35.873 --> 04:27:37.441
THE HOUSING IS FAMILY MEMBERS
04:27:37.508 --> 04:27:38.876
MENTION WILL GO TO EDUCATION
04:27:38.942 --> 04:27:40.444
WORKFORCE AND THEN PUBLIC
04:27:40.511 --> 04:27:43.046
EMPLOYEES THAT HOUSING STAYS
04:27:43.113 --> 04:27:47.217
AFFORDABLE FOR 55 YEARS. WITH A
04:27:47.284 --> 04:27:50.421
B 22 95, CALIFORNIA EDUCATION
04:27:50.487 --> 04:27:52.589
STAFF WILL BE STABILIZED. THIS
04:27:52.656 --> 04:27:56.326
HOUSING WILL HELP TO GUARANTEE
04:27:56.393 --> 04:27:58.028
QUALITY EDUCATION FOR FUTURE
04:27:58.095 --> 04:27:59.663
GENERATIONS OF CALIFORNIANS. I
04:27:59.730 --> 04:28:01.465
URGE YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU VERY
04:28:01.532 --> 04:28:03.801
MUCH. GREAT AND THEIR NEXT
04:28:03.867 --> 04:28:09.740
WITNESS. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
04:28:09.807 --> 04:28:11.475
MEMBERS. CHRIS REFUND BEHALF.
04:28:11.542 --> 04:28:12.676
THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
04:28:12.743 --> 04:28:13.644
ASSOCIATION LATE IS THE HOUR SO
04:28:13.710 --> 04:28:16.580
I WILL BE BRIEF. THIS IS
04:28:16.647 --> 04:28:17.614
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT LEGISLATION
04:28:17.681 --> 04:28:18.949
. WE THINK THE SOME OF THE
04:28:19.016 --> 04:28:21.151
AUTHORS REMEMBER BLOOM FOR
04:28:21.218 --> 04:28:23.487
MOVING IT FORWARD ON. THIS IS AN
04:28:23.554 --> 04:28:25.255
INCREDIBLE OPTION FOR SCHOOL
04:28:25.322 --> 04:28:26.356
DISTRICTS TO HELP IMPROVE AND
04:28:26.423 --> 04:28:28.225
INCREASE THE NUMBER OF HOUSING
04:28:28.292 --> 04:28:29.793
UNITS THAT CAN BE AVAILABLE FOR
04:28:29.860 --> 04:28:30.627
OUR EDUCATIONAL WORKFORCE. THAT
04:28:30.694 --> 04:28:32.029
TIME WHEN WE'RE IN SUCH GREAT
04:28:32.095 --> 04:28:33.831
NEED STRONGLY ASKED HER. I VOTE.
04:28:33.897 --> 04:28:39.803
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GREAT IS
04:28:39.870 --> 04:28:40.904
THERE ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT?
04:28:40.971 --> 04:28:42.139
PUBLIC COMMENT HERE IN THE ROOM?
04:28:42.206 --> 04:28:48.212
PLEASE COME FORWARD. GOOD
04:28:48.278 --> 04:28:50.080
EVENING. SHARON MEMBERS. SASHA
04:28:50.147 --> 04:28:51.114
HORWITZ WATCHING ANGELES UNIFIED
04:28:51.181 --> 04:28:55.953
SCHOOL DISTRICT IN SUPPORT.
04:28:56.019 --> 04:28:57.788
ADRIAN MOHAMMED, WITH LIGHTHOUSE
04:28:57.855 --> 04:28:58.956
PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF PHIL
04:28:59.022 --> 04:29:03.894
SAID, AND COMPANY AND SUPPORT
04:29:03.961 --> 04:29:04.862
COREY SMITH HOUSING ACTION
04:29:04.928 --> 04:29:10.267
COALITION AND SUPPORT. ANYONE
04:29:10.334 --> 04:29:11.502
ELSE IN SUPPORT, SAYING NORMAL
04:29:11.568 --> 04:29:12.636
GO TO THE PHONE LINES FOR
04:29:12.703 --> 04:29:16.874
SUPPORT. TO EXPRESS SUPPORT OF
04:29:16.940 --> 04:29:17.908
THE BILL. YOU MAY PRESS ONE
04:29:17.975 --> 04:29:19.877
FOLLOWED BY ZERO AGAIN ON YOUR
04:29:19.943 --> 04:29:21.245
TELEPHONE ONE AND THEN ZERO.
04:29:21.311 --> 04:29:24.648
WE'LL GO TO LINE 4 27. MICHAEL
04:29:24.715 --> 04:29:25.649
LANE WAS SPURRING STRONG
04:29:25.716 --> 04:29:33.490
SUPPORT. 4 29. GOOD AFTERNOON
04:29:33.557 --> 04:29:35.626
CHAIR MEMBERS CALLING ON BEHALF
04:29:35.692 --> 04:29:37.327
OF THE CALIFORNIA FACULTY
04:29:37.394 --> 04:29:38.328
ASSOCIATION IN STRONG SUPPORT.
04:29:38.395 --> 04:29:44.535
THANK YOU. 2 75. ALRIGHT THIS IS
04:29:44.601 --> 04:29:45.035
KYLE KELLEY, PARENT AND
04:29:45.102 --> 04:29:46.904
SENATORS. THREE KIDS. IN PUBLIC
04:29:46.970 --> 04:29:54.745
SCHOOLS. STRONG SUPPORT. 200.
04:29:54.811 --> 04:29:56.880
FAMILY GIVE BERMAN AND PANORAMA
04:29:56.947 --> 04:29:59.249
CITY AND RETIRED UNITED TEACHERS
04:29:59.316 --> 04:30:00.817
LOS ANGELES MEMBER VERY STRONGLY
04:30:00.884 --> 04:30:03.987
IN SUPPORT OF THIS. THANK YOU.
04:30:04.054 --> 04:30:08.725
NO FURTHER LINES AND QUÊ. OKAY
04:30:08.792 --> 04:30:10.727
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
04:30:10.794 --> 04:30:17.134
ROOM? PLEASE COME FORWARD. THANK
04:30:17.200 --> 04:30:18.735
YOU AGAIN, MR. CHAIR MEMBER OF
04:30:18.802 --> 04:30:19.736
THE COMMITTEE, JEREMY SMITH.
04:30:19.803 --> 04:30:21.138
YOU'RE ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
04:30:21.204 --> 04:30:22.239
BUILDING. CONSTRUCTION TRADES
04:30:22.306 --> 04:30:26.310
COUNCIL. UM. FIRST WE HAVEN'T
04:30:26.376 --> 04:30:27.744
SEEN THE AMENDMENTS ARE THE LAST
04:30:27.811 --> 04:30:28.845
COMMITTEE THEY AREN'T PRINT YET.
04:30:28.912 --> 04:30:30.847
NOT SURE. I'M SURE THAT'S NOT
04:30:30.914 --> 04:30:32.049
YOUR FAULT OR ANYBODY ELSE
04:30:32.115 --> 04:30:33.717
FATHERS THAT WE HAVEN'T SEEN THE
04:30:33.784 --> 04:30:34.718
MOST RECENT AMENDMENTS OUT OF
04:30:34.785 --> 04:30:36.119
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. UM AND
04:30:36.186 --> 04:30:37.788
WE LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING THOSE
04:30:37.854 --> 04:30:39.790
IN PRINT AND THESE BUT WE FOR
04:30:39.856 --> 04:30:41.458
THOSE REASONS. WE NEED TO REMAIN
04:30:41.525 --> 04:30:43.226
IN OPPOSITION AND JUST FOR A
04:30:43.293 --> 04:30:44.328
COUPLE OF REASONS FIRST. WE
04:30:44.394 --> 04:30:45.896
AGREE WITH THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:30:45.963 --> 04:30:47.798
ASSERTION THAT THERE'S A LOT OF
04:30:47.864 --> 04:30:50.167
DATA OUT THERE THAT SHOWS A LOT
04:30:50.233 --> 04:30:51.802
OF LAND THAT'S AVAILABLE AT
04:30:51.868 --> 04:30:52.936
ELIA'S FOR SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
04:30:53.003 --> 04:30:56.540
AND SUPPORT THE IDEA. OF
04:30:56.607 --> 04:30:58.308
WORKFORCE HOUSING FOR TEACHERS.
04:30:58.375 --> 04:31:00.277
IN FACT, WE HAVE A PIECE OF
04:31:00.344 --> 04:31:01.979
LEGISLATION WITH THE CHAIR. SB
04:31:02.045 --> 04:31:06.516
886 TO DO. JUST THAT PROVIDE
04:31:06.583 --> 04:31:08.885
WORKFORCE HOUSING FOR, UM, AND
04:31:08.952 --> 04:31:10.988
STUDENT HOUSING ON COLLEGES AND
04:31:11.054 --> 04:31:11.989
UNIVERSITIES AND COMMUNITY
04:31:12.055 --> 04:31:12.789
COLLEGE CAMPUSES, SO WE SHARE
04:31:12.856 --> 04:31:14.925
THE IDEA IN THE IN THE IN THE IN
04:31:14.992 --> 04:31:16.560
THE GOAL HERE WITH THE S A
04:31:16.627 --> 04:31:18.428
MEMBER. UNFORTUNATELY UNLIKE SB
04:31:18.495 --> 04:31:21.398
886, THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS
04:31:21.465 --> 04:31:23.467
BILL THAT PROTECTS AGAIN TO
04:31:23.533 --> 04:31:24.901
SOUND LIKE A BROKEN RECORD. THE
04:31:24.968 --> 04:31:25.502
CONSTRUCTION WORKERS BUILDING
04:31:25.569 --> 04:31:28.605
THIS HOUSING WE HAVE SHARED
04:31:28.672 --> 04:31:29.740
AMENDMENTS WITH THE ASSEMBLY
04:31:29.806 --> 04:31:32.843
MEMBER AND HIS STAFF HAD MANY
04:31:32.909 --> 04:31:34.277
GOOD CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM ON
04:31:34.344 --> 04:31:35.112
THIS BILL AND SEVERAL OTHERS
04:31:35.178 --> 04:31:37.014
OVER THE YEARS, UM, HAVEN'T BEEN
04:31:37.080 --> 04:31:39.650
ABLE TO CRACK THIS PARTICULAR
04:31:39.716 --> 04:31:41.118
NOT THOUGH, UNFORTUNATELY, AND
04:31:41.184 --> 04:31:43.020
THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE TODAY, UM
04:31:43.086 --> 04:31:44.688
, ON THIS BILL AND OTHER BILLS.
04:31:44.755 --> 04:31:46.023
IT'S TO PROTECT THE CONSTRUCTION
04:31:46.089 --> 04:31:47.457
WORKERS BUILDING THIS HOUSING TO
04:31:47.524 --> 04:31:49.493
ENSURE THAT THEY ARE PAID THE
04:31:49.559 --> 04:31:50.927
LIVING WAGES UNDER THE PAVILION
04:31:50.994 --> 04:31:53.030
WAGE AND ENSURE THAT THEY ARE
04:31:53.096 --> 04:31:55.165
GRADUATES OF CALIFORNIA STATE OF
04:31:55.232 --> 04:31:56.266
THE PROVINCIAL PROGRAMS AND ARE
04:31:56.333 --> 04:31:58.001
SKILLED AND TRAINED. UM THOSE
04:31:58.068 --> 04:31:59.102
ARE THE AMENDMENTS. WE'VE ASKED
04:31:59.169 --> 04:32:00.237
THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S PUT INTO
04:32:00.303 --> 04:32:02.272
HIS BILL MANY OF YOUR BILLS.
04:32:02.339 --> 04:32:04.374
MANY OF YOU HAVE TAKEN THOSE
04:32:04.441 --> 04:32:06.243
AMENDMENTS IN YOUR BILLS. UM IT
04:32:06.309 --> 04:32:06.977
IS LANGUAGE THAT WORKS. WE'VE
04:32:07.044 --> 04:32:08.311
HAD A VERY ROBUST CONVERSATION
04:32:08.378 --> 04:32:10.013
TODAY ON THIS ISSUE ON SOME
04:32:10.080 --> 04:32:12.482
OTHER LEGISLATIONS. ALL STOPPED
04:32:12.549 --> 04:32:13.283
THERE ON SKILLED AND TRAINED,
04:32:13.350 --> 04:32:14.985
BUT WE DO AGAIN SUPPORT THE IDEA
04:32:15.052 --> 04:32:18.288
HERE OF BUILDING HOUSING ON
04:32:18.355 --> 04:32:21.458
SCHOOL SITES. UH AS EVIDENCED BY
04:32:21.525 --> 04:32:22.926
OUR OUR BILL WITH THE WITH THE
04:32:22.993 --> 04:32:24.895
WITH THE CHAIRMAN OF THIS
04:32:24.961 --> 04:32:25.962
COMMITTEE, UM AND WE WOULD HOPE
04:32:26.029 --> 04:32:27.564
THAT AS THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD
04:32:27.631 --> 04:32:28.832
, AND WE ACTUALLY SEE THE
04:32:28.899 --> 04:32:29.966
AMENDMENTS IN PRINT AND CAN GET
04:32:30.033 --> 04:32:31.802
AN IDEA WHERE THE BILL IS GOING
04:32:31.868 --> 04:32:33.737
NOW. THAT WE CAN ENGAGE, KEEP
04:32:33.804 --> 04:32:34.604
ENGAGING CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
04:32:34.671 --> 04:32:37.374
AUTHOR TO AMEND THE BILL. UH AS
04:32:37.441 --> 04:32:38.642
WE'VE REQUESTED, FOR NOW THAT WE
04:32:38.709 --> 04:32:40.644
HAVE TO BE A POST THANK YOU.
04:32:40.711 --> 04:32:41.845
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY
04:32:41.912 --> 04:32:43.013
ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION IN THE
04:32:43.080 --> 04:32:47.017
HEARING ROOM? OKAY THINK NONE.
04:32:47.084 --> 04:32:50.120
WE WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
04:32:50.187 --> 04:32:51.221
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION ON THE
04:32:51.288 --> 04:32:54.691
PHONES? TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION ON
04:32:54.758 --> 04:32:56.760
THE PHONE PRESS ONE FOLLOWED BY
04:32:56.827 --> 04:32:58.662
ZERO AGAIN. THAT'S ONE AND THEN
04:32:58.729 --> 04:33:03.900
ZERO. WE'LL GO TO LYON 3 78.
04:33:03.967 --> 04:33:05.168
GOOD EVENING TURN MEMBERS,
04:33:05.235 --> 04:33:06.636
MADELINE COOPER WITH NIELSEN
04:33:06.703 --> 04:33:08.238
MERKSAMER ON BEHALF OF CONTRA
04:33:08.305 --> 04:33:10.540
COSTA COUNTY. UM WE REMAIN IN
04:33:10.607 --> 04:33:12.142
OPPOSING MANY POSITIONS AND LOOK
04:33:12.209 --> 04:33:14.044
FORWARD TO SEEING THE MOST
04:33:14.111 --> 04:33:15.112
RECENT AMENDMENTS IN PRINT. UM,
04:33:15.178 --> 04:33:16.146
WHEN THEY'RE AVAILABLE, THANK
04:33:16.213 --> 04:33:22.219
YOU. TO 65. GOOD EVENING, MINA
04:33:22.285 --> 04:33:24.921
LABOR ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
04:33:24.988 --> 04:33:25.922
1000 OAKS AND RESPECTFUL
04:33:25.989 --> 04:33:28.225
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. NO
04:33:28.291 --> 04:33:33.163
FURTHER LINES IN QUÊ. OKAY WE'LL
04:33:33.230 --> 04:33:34.631
BRING IT BACK TO THE MIDDLE TO
04:33:34.698 --> 04:33:36.333
THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES. ARE
04:33:36.399 --> 04:33:38.702
THERE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
04:33:38.769 --> 04:33:40.804
, SENATOR QUOTAS? JUST JUST
04:33:40.871 --> 04:33:41.972
COMMENTS NOT MAKING BRIEF, UM
04:33:42.038 --> 04:33:45.842
AGAIN. SO MANY OF THESE BILLS. I
04:33:45.909 --> 04:33:47.043
HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TO
04:33:47.110 --> 04:33:50.046
THE AUTHORS ABOUT IN AND ALL OF
04:33:50.113 --> 04:33:51.615
THEM WERE GENEROUS WITH THEIR
04:33:51.681 --> 04:33:52.883
TIME. SO ANYWAY, I SAID THAT
04:33:52.949 --> 04:33:54.951
ABOUT A COUPLE BILLS EARLIER BUT
04:33:55.018 --> 04:33:57.821
BECAUSE THAT I DON'T WANT TO DO
04:33:57.888 --> 04:33:59.523
THE SAME HALF HOUR CONVERSATION
04:33:59.589 --> 04:34:02.125
HERE TODAY THAT THAT I HAD WITH
04:34:02.192 --> 04:34:05.195
THE AUTHOR, BY ANY MEANS, UM I
04:34:05.262 --> 04:34:06.663
FIND THIS BILL TO BE
04:34:06.730 --> 04:34:08.165
EXTRAORDINARILY IMPORTANT IN
04:34:08.231 --> 04:34:09.766
TERMS OF WHAT IT'S SETTING OUT
04:34:09.833 --> 04:34:14.571
TO DO. LAST YEAR. UM, ONE OF MY
04:34:14.638 --> 04:34:16.907
BILLS WAS SIGNED INTO WAR, WHICH
04:34:16.973 --> 04:34:18.875
DIRECTS H C D TO PROVIDE
04:34:18.942 --> 04:34:20.877
ASSISTANCE TO ALL LOCAL AGENCIES
04:34:20.944 --> 04:34:23.880
OF SURPLUS LAND. THERE ARE
04:34:23.947 --> 04:34:25.415
MULTIPLE SCHOOL DISTRICTS ALONE
04:34:25.482 --> 04:34:27.217
THAT HAVE SURPLUS LAND IN MY
04:34:27.284 --> 04:34:30.187
DISTRICT IN LARGE ACREAGE. SOME
04:34:30.253 --> 04:34:31.888
OF IT RIGHT ON THE LIGHT RAIL
04:34:31.955 --> 04:34:33.190
LINES AND OTHER TRANSIT
04:34:33.256 --> 04:34:34.891
FACILITIES. THEY WANT TO DEVELOP
04:34:34.958 --> 04:34:36.760
IT. THEY DON'T HAVE THE CAPACITY
04:34:36.827 --> 04:34:38.061
TO THAT. THEY DON'T KNOW HOW TO
04:34:38.128 --> 04:34:40.063
DO IT. OF COURSE, SCHOOL DISHES
04:34:40.130 --> 04:34:41.164
AREN'T BUILT WITH THAT KIND OF
04:34:41.231 --> 04:34:43.200
CAPACITY THEMSELVES. THE LAND IS
04:34:43.266 --> 04:34:45.802
TYPICALLY FREE AND CLEAR. AND WE
04:34:45.869 --> 04:34:47.704
RECEIVE OPPOSITION ON OTHER
04:34:47.771 --> 04:34:50.507
LEGISLATION FROM FOLKS WHO ARE
04:34:50.574 --> 04:34:52.075
IN THE NONPROFIT HOUSING FIELD
04:34:52.142 --> 04:34:54.144
SAYING, WELL, WE CAN'T PENCIL
04:34:54.211 --> 04:34:55.345
OUT OF PROJECT YOU KNOW, WITH
04:34:55.412 --> 04:34:57.414
LABOR STANDARDS IN IT. UM ON THE
04:34:57.480 --> 04:34:58.481
SURPLUS PROPERTY. WELL, IF YOU
04:34:58.548 --> 04:35:00.951
CAN PENCIL OUT OF PROJECT ON
04:35:01.017 --> 04:35:02.819
SURPLUS PROPERTY THAT'S FREE AND
04:35:02.886 --> 04:35:04.654
CLEAR. WITH LABOR STANDARDS IN
04:35:04.721 --> 04:35:05.922
IT, YOU NEED TO BE IN ANOTHER
04:35:05.989 --> 04:35:07.023
BUSINESS OTHER THAN BUILDING
04:35:07.090 --> 04:35:10.961
REAL ESTATE BECAUSE THAT IS THE
04:35:11.027 --> 04:35:11.761
MOST LEVERAGED POSITION YOU
04:35:11.828 --> 04:35:13.964
COULD POSSIBLY BE IN. I KNOW ON
04:35:14.030 --> 04:35:15.198
THE AUTHOR RECOGNIZES ALL THAT
04:35:15.265 --> 04:35:17.334
AND I KNOW THERE'S OTHER
04:35:17.400 --> 04:35:18.168
CONSTRAINTS ON GETTING LANGUAGE
04:35:18.235 --> 04:35:21.605
IN AND OUT OF THESE BILLS, BUT
04:35:21.671 --> 04:35:22.939
THIS HAS BEEN A RECURRING THEME
04:35:23.006 --> 04:35:24.741
ALL DAY. THIS ISN'T THE LABOR
04:35:24.808 --> 04:35:25.208
COMMITTEE THIS HOUSING
04:35:25.275 --> 04:35:27.177
COMMITTEE. BUT WE'VE HAD
04:35:27.244 --> 04:35:28.879
ANYWHERE FROM NO LABOR STANDARDS
04:35:28.945 --> 04:35:31.214
TODAY TO VERSION A OF LABOR
04:35:31.281 --> 04:35:33.650
STANDARDS TO VERSION B OF LABOR
04:35:33.717 --> 04:35:34.684
STANDARDS TO VERSION SEE OF
04:35:34.751 --> 04:35:37.220
LABOR STANDARDS. AND IF YOU I
04:35:37.287 --> 04:35:38.822
THINK AT SOME POINT IF WE'RE
04:35:38.889 --> 04:35:40.790
RATIFYING ALL OF THAT, AS WE GO
04:35:40.857 --> 04:35:43.593
FORWARD, WE ARE CREATING A
04:35:43.660 --> 04:35:45.562
COMPLETE MESS IN BASICALLY THE
04:35:45.629 --> 04:35:47.397
KIND OF TRAIN WRECK THAT ENDS UP
04:35:47.464 --> 04:35:49.532
CONFUSING MATTERS AND PERHAPS
04:35:49.599 --> 04:35:51.935
GETTING ABSOLUTELY WHAT WE DON'T
04:35:52.002 --> 04:35:54.004
WANT IS NOTHING DONE. NOTHING
04:35:54.070 --> 04:35:56.606
DONE, BUT I JUST WANT TO, YOU
04:35:56.673 --> 04:35:57.607
KNOW, ENCOURAGE THE AUTHOR TO
04:35:57.674 --> 04:36:01.211
KEEP, UM TO THE EXTENT POSSIBLE
04:36:01.278 --> 04:36:02.445
TO EXTEND YOUR WILLING TO KEEP
04:36:02.512 --> 04:36:05.582
WORKING ON YOU KNOW THE RIGHT
04:36:05.649 --> 04:36:09.819
VERSION OF MM OF WORKFORCE
04:36:09.886 --> 04:36:11.888
STANDARDS IN THESE BILLS ON THE
04:36:11.955 --> 04:36:13.456
EAST SIDE HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT
04:36:13.523 --> 04:36:14.691
WHERE I SERVED, WHICH IS THE
04:36:14.758 --> 04:36:16.526
LARGEST HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT IN
04:36:16.593 --> 04:36:17.527
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA, 25,000
04:36:17.594 --> 04:36:20.797
STUDENTS UM YOU KNOW THAT
04:36:20.864 --> 04:36:22.165
DISTRICT HAS ONE OF THE BEST
04:36:22.232 --> 04:36:23.400
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS IN THE
04:36:23.466 --> 04:36:25.902
STATE IN THE DISTRICT. AND AS A
04:36:25.969 --> 04:36:28.004
SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER WITH YOU
04:36:28.071 --> 04:36:28.872
WHEN I WAS THERE A LONG TIME
04:36:28.939 --> 04:36:33.310
AGO, WE ACTUALLY INSTALLED UM.
04:36:33.376 --> 04:36:35.312
WHICH IS LEGAL NOW UNDER STATE
04:36:35.378 --> 04:36:38.014
LAW BECAME WE GOT A LONG TIME
04:36:38.081 --> 04:36:41.685
AGO IS AS OLD AS I AM. IT BECAME
04:36:41.751 --> 04:36:44.821
LEGIT FOR US TO ALLOW STUDENTS
04:36:44.888 --> 04:36:46.523
TO GO OUT AND DO APPRENTICESHIP
04:36:46.590 --> 04:36:47.791
PROGRAMS THAT WORK ON THOSE
04:36:47.857 --> 04:36:49.059
SITES. HAMMER NAILS DO WHATEVER
04:36:49.125 --> 04:36:51.061
THEY WERE GOING TO DO FOR HIGH
04:36:51.127 --> 04:36:52.128
SCHOOL CREDIT. TO GET THEIR
04:36:52.195 --> 04:36:54.698
DIPLOMAS SO IF THERE WAS ANY
04:36:54.764 --> 04:36:56.700
PLACE THAT YOU EVER WANT TO GO
04:36:56.766 --> 04:36:58.802
IN AND CREATE THOSE KIND OF
04:36:58.868 --> 04:37:00.303
RELATIONSHIPS LIKE YOU SEE IN
04:37:00.370 --> 04:37:01.671
SCHOOLS AND TRAIN LANGUAGE, IT
04:37:01.738 --> 04:37:03.239
WOULD BE ON THESE UNENCUMBERED
04:37:03.306 --> 04:37:04.975
FREE AND CLEAR. PUBLICLY OWNED
04:37:05.041 --> 04:37:06.109
PROPERTIES SUBSIDIZED BY EACH
04:37:06.176 --> 04:37:10.780
CD. UM WHERE YOU HAVE YOU
04:37:10.847 --> 04:37:11.915
ACTUALLY HAVE THE APPRENTICE
04:37:11.982 --> 04:37:13.783
WORKFORCE. STANDING RIGHT NEXT
04:37:13.850 --> 04:37:18.421
DOOR, SO UM, I KNOW NOT EVERYONE
04:37:18.488 --> 04:37:21.057
AGREES WITH THAT. BUT YOU KNOW,
04:37:21.124 --> 04:37:23.226
I HAVE TO PICK AND CHOOSE A FEW
04:37:23.293 --> 04:37:25.128
SPOTS ON THIS AGENDA WITH 21
04:37:25.195 --> 04:37:27.197
BILLS ON IT TO MAKE THESE POINTS
04:37:27.263 --> 04:37:30.400
BECAUSE ON THE COMMITTEE I
04:37:30.467 --> 04:37:32.402
CHAIR. IT'S NOT GOING TO BE
04:37:32.469 --> 04:37:33.570
SUSTAINABLE TO HAVE FOLKS COMING
04:37:33.636 --> 04:37:35.505
IN. WITH FOUR OR FIVE DIFFERENT
04:37:35.572 --> 04:37:36.873
TYPES OF WORKFORCE STANDARDS
04:37:36.940 --> 04:37:38.641
THAT ARE ALL COMPETING WITH EACH
04:37:38.708 --> 04:37:39.909
OTHER HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH
04:37:39.976 --> 04:37:41.711
YOU, THE AUTHOR. IT'S A BROADER
04:37:41.778 --> 04:37:42.712
STATEMENT. THAT WE'RE HEADED
04:37:42.779 --> 04:37:45.915
FOR. I THINK, YOU KNOW, IMPASSE
04:37:45.982 --> 04:37:47.050
HERE PRETTY QUICKLY IF WE DON'T
04:37:47.117 --> 04:37:48.618
STRAIGHTEN THAT PART OUT, SO
04:37:48.685 --> 04:37:50.820
THANK YOU FOR TALKING TO ME AND
04:37:50.887 --> 04:37:52.655
WORKING THROUGH MY CONCERNS, AND
04:37:52.722 --> 04:37:53.890
I KNOW YOU'RE VERY SYMPATHETIC
04:37:53.957 --> 04:37:55.892
TO MUCH OF WHAT I JUST SAID. AS
04:37:55.959 --> 04:37:58.361
AN AUTHOR, AND I THINK THE
04:37:58.428 --> 04:37:59.562
SHERIFF OR INDULGE ME IN A FEW
04:37:59.629 --> 04:38:04.968
MINUTES OF COMMENT. GREAT THANK
04:38:05.035 --> 04:38:05.935
YOU. IF THERE ARE OTHER
04:38:06.002 --> 04:38:08.304
COMMENTS, UM I THANK YOU FOR
04:38:08.371 --> 04:38:10.740
THIS BILL TO A NEW AND CREATIVE
04:38:10.807 --> 04:38:14.711
APPROACH, YOU KNOW, AND I AGREE
04:38:14.778 --> 04:38:16.246
WITH MY COLLEAGUE FROM SAN JOSE
04:38:16.312 --> 04:38:18.014
THAT WE ARE, I THINK GOING
04:38:18.081 --> 04:38:19.983
THROUGH AN AWKWARD PERIOD IN
04:38:20.050 --> 04:38:21.251
TERMS OF LABOR STANDARDS AND
04:38:21.317 --> 04:38:23.520
HOUSING BILLS, AND THERE ARE NOW
04:38:23.586 --> 04:38:24.888
UM FOUR FOUR DIFFERENT IN THE
04:38:24.954 --> 04:38:25.922
LEGISLATURE. THERE ARE FOUR
04:38:25.989 --> 04:38:29.959
DIFFERENT TYPES OF LABOR
04:38:30.026 --> 04:38:31.294
LANGUAGE IN PRINT RIGHT NOW AND
04:38:31.361 --> 04:38:34.764
DIFFERENT BILLS. UM BRILLIANT
04:38:34.831 --> 04:38:36.800
WAGE THE CARPENTERS PREVAILING
04:38:36.866 --> 04:38:41.204
WAGE. PLUS, AH! APPROACH SKILLED
04:38:41.271 --> 04:38:43.640
WORKFORCE AND THEN THE
04:38:43.706 --> 04:38:45.108
ALTERNATIVE TO BID SKILLED
04:38:45.175 --> 04:38:45.942
WORKFORCE. SO IT'S FOUR
04:38:46.009 --> 04:38:46.976
DIFFERENT VERSIONS. AND THERE'S
04:38:47.043 --> 04:38:49.746
1/5 1, WHICH IS A P O A OFF RAMP
04:38:49.813 --> 04:38:50.747
TO SKILLED AND TRAINED, WHICH
04:38:50.814 --> 04:38:52.715
PERHAPS COULD WORK ON A BILL
04:38:52.782 --> 04:38:53.917
LIKE THIS, BUT IT'S FIVE. THAT'S
04:38:53.983 --> 04:38:57.120
A LOT AND IN A WAY IT IS AND I
04:38:57.187 --> 04:38:59.355
KNOW MY GENERAL APPROACH IN THIS
04:38:59.422 --> 04:39:02.592
COMMITTEE. UM, IS NOT TO DICTATE
04:39:02.659 --> 04:39:04.727
THE AUTHORS. THIS ISSUE I
04:39:04.794 --> 04:39:07.097
AUTHORS MAKE THAT DECISION ON
04:39:07.163 --> 04:39:08.865
THEIR OWN, AND THEN THEY WORK
04:39:08.932 --> 04:39:10.733
THEY DEAL WITH WHATEVER SUPPORT
04:39:10.800 --> 04:39:12.335
OR OPPOSITION COMES ALONG WITH
04:39:12.402 --> 04:39:14.904
THAT. I DO WANT TO SEE US GET TO
04:39:14.971 --> 04:39:17.273
RESOLUTION. WHERE? INSTEAD OF
04:39:17.340 --> 04:39:18.741
HAVING FIVE DIFFERENT KINDS WE
04:39:18.808 --> 04:39:22.212
HAVE MAYBE ONE OR TWO AND WE'RE
04:39:22.278 --> 04:39:26.082
NOT THERE YET. BUT, UM MY HOPE
04:39:26.149 --> 04:39:26.950
IS THAT OVER THE COURSE OF
04:39:27.016 --> 04:39:29.285
SUMMER, AS I SAID EARLIER THAT
04:39:29.352 --> 04:39:30.587
MAYBE WE GET THERE OR GET A
04:39:30.653 --> 04:39:32.322
LITTLE BIT CLOSER. SO I AM
04:39:32.388 --> 04:39:34.357
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE ON THIS
04:39:34.424 --> 04:39:35.558
BILL, AND IF THERE'S NO OTHER
04:39:35.625 --> 04:39:37.560
QUESTIONS A MOTION BY SENATOR
04:39:37.627 --> 04:39:39.529
ROTH AND YOU MAY CLOSE. THANK
04:39:39.596 --> 04:39:42.565
YOU, UM AND THANK YOU FOR BOTH
04:39:42.632 --> 04:39:44.434
OF YOUR COMMENTS ON THE
04:39:44.501 --> 04:39:45.869
IMPORTANT LABOR ISSUES. THERE'S
04:39:45.935 --> 04:39:48.138
NOTHING I WOULD LIKE MORE THAN
04:39:48.204 --> 04:39:49.372
TO GET THOSE ISSUES RESOLVED,
04:39:49.439 --> 04:39:51.274
HAVE BEEN WORKING ON THEM FOR
04:39:51.341 --> 04:39:53.042
SEVERAL YEARS. UH I HAD THE
04:39:53.109 --> 04:39:56.279
PRECURSOR BILL TO THE ASSEMBLY.
04:39:56.346 --> 04:39:59.282
UH HOUSING COMMITTEE CHAIRS BILL
04:39:59.349 --> 04:40:00.917
THAT YOU HEARD TODAY AND IT'S
04:40:00.984 --> 04:40:02.986
BEEN A GOOD DEAL OF TIME WITH I
04:40:03.052 --> 04:40:07.223
SPENT TWO OR THREE YEARS.
04:40:07.290 --> 04:40:09.359
THEREABOUTS WORKING ON WORKING
04:40:09.425 --> 04:40:10.994
ON THAT BILL AND WASN'T ABLE TO
04:40:11.060 --> 04:40:12.695
GET IT ACROSS THE FINISH LINE
04:40:12.762 --> 04:40:14.898
BECAUSE OF THE LABOR ISSUES.
04:40:14.964 --> 04:40:19.536
THIS IS ALL WASTED TIME. I MEAN
04:40:19.602 --> 04:40:21.638
, IT'S NOT. IT'S NOT WASTED IN
04:40:21.704 --> 04:40:24.040
TERMS OF THE VALUE OF HAVING
04:40:24.107 --> 04:40:26.743
LABOR STANDARDS, BUT IT'S TIME
04:40:26.809 --> 04:40:28.645
THAT A BETTER WAY OF PUTTING IT
04:40:28.711 --> 04:40:30.113
IS IT'S TIME THAT WE'RE LOSING
04:40:30.180 --> 04:40:33.116
TO ADDRESS ONE OF CALIFORNIA'S
04:40:33.183 --> 04:40:35.351
REALLY THE ONE OF THE WORLD'S
04:40:35.418 --> 04:40:36.953
GREATEST ISSUES RIGHT NOW, WHICH
04:40:37.020 --> 04:40:38.888
IS THE RISING COST OF HOUSING
04:40:38.955 --> 04:40:41.257
THAT IS AFFECTING NEARLY
04:40:41.324 --> 04:40:45.628
EVERYONE. UM, UH, WHO WAS. A
04:40:45.695 --> 04:40:48.331
WORKER IN THIS STATE WHO LIVES
04:40:48.398 --> 04:40:49.966
IN POVERTY IN THIS STATE. IT'S
04:40:50.033 --> 04:40:54.037
AFFECTING THEIR ABILITY TO HAVE
04:40:54.103 --> 04:40:57.273
A QUALITY STANDARD OF LIVING.
04:40:57.340 --> 04:41:00.076
BECAUSE NO MATTER THE PRICE OF
04:41:00.143 --> 04:41:02.378
HOUSING KEEPS GOING UP. WAGES
04:41:02.445 --> 04:41:03.913
ARE GOING UP NOW, WHICH IS A
04:41:03.980 --> 04:41:05.181
GREAT THING, BUT EVERYONE OF
04:41:05.248 --> 04:41:09.385
THOSE DOLLARS IS GOING TO PAY
04:41:09.452 --> 04:41:11.254
FOR HOUSING COSTS. SO EVEN
04:41:11.321 --> 04:41:13.423
THOUGH YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO
04:41:13.489 --> 04:41:15.058
AFFORD A PLACE TO LIVE, YOUR
04:41:15.124 --> 04:41:17.293
STANDARD OF LIVING IS NOT GOING
04:41:17.360 --> 04:41:19.729
UP HERE IN CALIFORNIA, SO I KNOW
04:41:19.796 --> 04:41:22.332
YOU DON'T WANT TO HEAR ME. I
04:41:22.398 --> 04:41:24.400
KNOW. WE ALL AGREE ON THIS. SO
04:41:24.467 --> 04:41:26.936
SORRY JUST PROPERLY. UM FEELING
04:41:27.003 --> 04:41:29.405
LIKE I HAD TO SAY SOMETHING. UM
04:41:29.472 --> 04:41:30.506
I HAVE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
04:41:30.573 --> 04:41:32.575
I VOTE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT
04:41:32.642 --> 04:41:34.811
THING I COULD SAY. THANK YOU FOR
04:41:34.877 --> 04:41:36.546
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSES AMENDED
04:41:36.613 --> 04:41:38.848
, BUT FOR US TO MEN, AND WE
04:41:38.915 --> 04:41:40.083
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:41:40.149 --> 04:41:43.086
APPROPRIATIONS. THEY CALL THE
04:41:43.152 --> 04:41:45.588
ROLE. SENATOR WIENER WIENER? AYE
04:41:45.655 --> 04:41:46.656
BATES BATES? NO CABALLERO.
04:41:46.723 --> 04:41:52.395
ORTEZ. MCGUIRE PHð BUG. ROUGH I
04:41:52.462 --> 04:41:58.635
SCANNER. HAMBURG. AMBER GUY 321.
04:41:58.701 --> 04:42:00.603
IT WILL PUT THAT BILL ON CALL.
04:42:00.670 --> 04:42:01.904
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:42:01.971 --> 04:42:03.940
I SEE THAT AS SOME MEMBER BANTA
04:42:04.007 --> 04:42:11.014
IS HERE. ADAM NUMBER 1980 23 19.
04:42:11.080 --> 04:42:17.920
WAS POOR. THANK YOU. CHAIR AND
04:42:17.987 --> 04:42:20.957
MEMBERS. MAYBE 23 19 IS A
04:42:21.024 --> 04:42:22.058
DISTRICT BILL SEEKING A SIMPLE
04:42:22.125 --> 04:42:23.793
FIX WITHIN A COMPLICATED ISSUE
04:42:23.860 --> 04:42:26.629
AREA. THE SURPLUS LAND ACT IN
04:42:26.696 --> 04:42:28.865
1997. THE ALAMEDA NAVAL AIR
04:42:28.931 --> 04:42:30.333
STATION WAS CLOSED AS PART OF
04:42:30.400 --> 04:42:31.801
THE BASE REALIGNMENT AND CLOSURE
04:42:31.868 --> 04:42:33.770
PROCESS. IN THE FOLLOWING YEARS
04:42:33.836 --> 04:42:35.305
. THE LAND NOW KNOWN AS ALAMEDA
04:42:35.371 --> 04:42:37.040
POINT WAS CONVEYED TO THE CITY
04:42:37.106 --> 04:42:38.308
OF ALAMEDA IN ACCORDANCE WITH A
04:42:38.374 --> 04:42:40.410
FEDERALLY APPROVED REUSE PLAN.
04:42:40.476 --> 04:42:42.078
ADDITIONALLY THE CITY OF ALAMEDA
04:42:42.145 --> 04:42:44.013
ENTERED INTO A LEGAL SETTLEMENT
04:42:44.080 --> 04:42:47.083
IN 2000 AND ONE TO DEDICATE 25%
04:42:47.150 --> 04:42:47.717
OF THE HOUSING ON ALAMEDA POINT
04:42:47.784 --> 04:42:48.951
AS PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE TO
04:42:49.018 --> 04:42:52.055
VERY LOW LOW AND MODERATE INCOME
04:42:52.121 --> 04:42:53.890
FAMILIES. UNFORTUNATELY WHILE
04:42:53.956 --> 04:42:55.024
THE DEVELOPMENT DEBT ALAMEDA
04:42:55.091 --> 04:42:56.793
POINT HAS OVERCOME LITIGATION
04:42:56.859 --> 04:42:59.662
AND A LOCAL BALLOT MEASURE AS
04:42:59.729 --> 04:43:00.630
THE LITTLE ENGINE THAT COULD,
04:43:00.697 --> 04:43:02.131
THE LATEST ROADBLOCK HAS BEEN
04:43:02.198 --> 04:43:02.999
THE WELL INTENTIONED AMENDMENTS
04:43:03.066 --> 04:43:06.035
TO THE SURPLUS LAND ACT IN 2019.
04:43:06.102 --> 04:43:08.137
APPLYING THE SURPLUS LAND ACT TO
04:43:08.204 --> 04:43:09.939
ALAMEDA POINT HAS CAUSED FURTHER
04:43:10.006 --> 04:43:11.474
DELAYS TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS
04:43:11.541 --> 04:43:13.209
AND HAS CREATED UNCERTAINTY FOR
04:43:13.276 --> 04:43:14.577
BUILDINGS LEASED OUT FOR
04:43:14.644 --> 04:43:17.080
COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES. A B 23
04:43:17.146 --> 04:43:18.448
19 WOULD PROVIDE A NARROW
04:43:18.514 --> 04:43:20.149
EXEMPTION TO THE SURPLUS LAND
04:43:20.216 --> 04:43:22.085
ACT. FOR ALAMEDA POINT AND IN
04:43:22.151 --> 04:43:24.454
DOING SO PROVIDE CLARITY AND A
04:43:24.520 --> 04:43:25.021
PATH FORWARD FOR AFFORDABLE
04:43:25.088 --> 04:43:25.688
HOUSING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
04:43:25.755 --> 04:43:28.558
FOR THE CITY OF ALAMEDA. I PLAN
04:43:28.624 --> 04:43:30.193
TO TAKE AMENDMENTS FROM THE
04:43:30.259 --> 04:43:30.793
AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMUNITY,
04:43:30.860 --> 04:43:32.261
WHICH REAFFIRMED THE 2000 AND
04:43:32.328 --> 04:43:33.396
ONE SETTLEMENT AND THE
04:43:33.463 --> 04:43:34.397
COMMITMENT TO 25% AFFORDABLE
04:43:34.464 --> 04:43:38.634
HOUSING. ADDITIONALLY I BELIEVE
04:43:38.701 --> 04:43:40.670
WE HAVE AN AGREEMENT IN CONCEPT
04:43:40.737 --> 04:43:42.905
BETWEEN THE CITY OF ALAMEDA. THE
04:43:42.972 --> 04:43:45.108
ALAMEDA COUNTY TRADES AND THE
04:43:45.174 --> 04:43:46.709
STATE TRADE TO REAFFIRM THE
04:43:46.776 --> 04:43:48.778
ALAMEDA EXISTING PROJECTS
04:43:48.845 --> 04:43:49.278
STABILIZATION AGREEMENT
04:43:49.345 --> 04:43:49.912
REGARDING PROJECT LABOR
04:43:49.979 --> 04:43:53.750
AGREEMENTS. THANK YOU. AND AS A
04:43:53.816 --> 04:43:55.084
WITNESS ON THE PHONE TODAY, I
04:43:55.151 --> 04:43:56.085
HAVE LISA MAXWELL FROM THE
04:43:56.152 --> 04:43:57.019
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, THE
04:43:57.086 --> 04:43:58.321
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR
04:43:58.388 --> 04:44:00.490
FOR THE CITY OF ALAMEDA, AND
04:44:00.556 --> 04:44:01.090
DOUG BIGGS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
04:44:01.157 --> 04:44:05.328
OF ALAMEDA POINT COLLABORATIVE.
04:44:05.395 --> 04:44:06.996
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE WILL GO
04:44:07.063 --> 04:44:08.965
TO THE PHONE LINES FOR THE TWO
04:44:09.031 --> 04:44:15.438
LEAD WITNESSES. HELLO. THIS IS
04:44:15.505 --> 04:44:21.444
LISA MAXWELL. GOOD EVENING CHAIR
04:44:21.511 --> 04:44:22.945
AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
04:44:23.012 --> 04:44:24.614
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY AND
04:44:24.680 --> 04:44:27.517
SUPPORT OF AMY 23 19. MY NAME IS
04:44:27.583 --> 04:44:28.985
LISA MAXWELL ON THE COMMUNITY
04:44:29.051 --> 04:44:29.986
DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR FOR THE
04:44:30.052 --> 04:44:32.221
CITY OF ALAMEDA. ELEVATOR WAS
04:44:32.288 --> 04:44:33.723
HOME TO THE NAVAL AIR STATION
04:44:33.790 --> 04:44:36.025
FROM 1940 TO 1997 REFERRED TO IT
04:44:36.092 --> 04:44:39.195
AS ALAMEDA POINT. ON THE CLOSURE
04:44:39.262 --> 04:44:40.897
OF THE BASE ALAMEDA AND
04:44:40.963 --> 04:44:42.198
NEGOTIATED WITH THE NAVY AND
04:44:42.265 --> 04:44:44.233
CREATED THE BASE REUSED PLAN.
04:44:44.300 --> 04:44:46.169
THIS PATRIS PANTS PLAN REMAINS
04:44:46.235 --> 04:44:47.670
EFFECTIVE TODAY AND GOVERN THE
04:44:47.737 --> 04:44:49.439
USE OF THE ALAMEDA PROPERTY.
04:44:49.505 --> 04:44:51.941
IT'S A TENDS TO BE A MIXED USE
04:44:52.008 --> 04:44:53.476
DEVELOPMENT WITH HOUSING,
04:44:53.543 --> 04:44:54.410
COMMERCIAL OPEN SPACE AND
04:44:54.477 --> 04:44:57.447
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. AS NOTED
04:44:57.513 --> 04:45:00.450
THE 2019 SURPLUS LANDS ACT WAS
04:45:00.516 --> 04:45:01.984
AMENDED AND HAD UNINTENDED,
04:45:02.051 --> 04:45:03.453
UNINTENDED AND MATERIAL
04:45:03.519 --> 04:45:04.620
CONSEQUENCE ON THE ALAMEDA POINT
04:45:04.687 --> 04:45:08.157
DEVELOPMENT. THE LAND WAS
04:45:08.224 --> 04:45:09.392
TRANSFERRED TO THE CITY FROM THE
04:45:09.459 --> 04:45:10.893
NAVY, AND IT'S NOT SURPLUS. AND
04:45:10.960 --> 04:45:12.829
THE CITY HAS A USE FOR THIS
04:45:12.895 --> 04:45:15.331
LAND. HAS SAID THE ELEMENT OF
04:45:15.398 --> 04:45:16.799
THE POINT LAND IS ALREADY
04:45:16.866 --> 04:45:17.800
SUBJECT TO A LEGALLY BINDING
04:45:17.867 --> 04:45:19.402
AGREEMENT WITH THE NAVY SINCE
04:45:19.469 --> 04:45:22.004
2000 AND PLAN FOR USE IS
04:45:22.071 --> 04:45:23.139
CONSISTENT WITH THE BASE RHEE'S
04:45:23.206 --> 04:45:25.641
PLAN BREVITY GENERATED BY SALES
04:45:25.708 --> 04:45:27.043
AND LEASING AT ALAMEDA POINT
04:45:27.109 --> 04:45:29.445
ALLOWS FOR CONTINUED DEVELOPMENT
04:45:29.512 --> 04:45:30.246
. THEIR MEMBER OF THE SURPLUS
04:45:30.313 --> 04:45:32.482
LANDS THAT CUSTOMER MATIC LEE
04:45:32.548 --> 04:45:33.082
STALLED SALES AND LEASING. IN
04:45:33.149 --> 04:45:35.952
FACT, SINCE THE AMENDMENT AND
04:45:36.018 --> 04:45:38.921
32,020. NO BUILDINGS IN ALAMEDA
04:45:38.988 --> 04:45:40.056
POINT WERE SOLD AND LEASING
04:45:40.122 --> 04:45:42.291
ACTIVITY WITH MINIMAL IT'S
04:45:42.358 --> 04:45:43.860
IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT ALL
04:45:43.926 --> 04:45:44.927
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT AND ALAMEDA
04:45:44.994 --> 04:45:47.163
POINT MUST INCLUDE A 25%
04:45:47.230 --> 04:45:48.898
AFFORDABILITY RECORD MUST MEET
04:45:48.965 --> 04:45:50.233
AT 25% AFFORDABILITY REQUIREMENT
04:45:50.299 --> 04:45:51.367
AND WE'VE BEEN CONSISTENTLY
04:45:51.434 --> 04:45:53.769
APPEARING TO THIS. JUST
04:45:53.836 --> 04:45:57.173
REQUIREMENT EVER SINCE 82 319
04:45:57.240 --> 04:45:59.342
CREATES A VERY NARROW EXEMPTION
04:45:59.408 --> 04:46:00.309
THAT ALLOWS DEVELOPMENT TO
04:46:00.376 --> 04:46:01.878
CONTINUE WITHOUT DELAY IN THE
04:46:01.944 --> 04:46:04.080
CITY OF ALAMEDA AT ALAMEDA POINT
04:46:04.146 --> 04:46:05.481
THE CITY'S CONTRACTUALLY
04:46:05.548 --> 04:46:08.084
OBLIGATED TO HERE TO THE BASE
04:46:08.150 --> 04:46:09.852
FOR USED PLAN WITH THE BABY AND
04:46:09.919 --> 04:46:10.453
PURSUED DEVELOPMENT. WITHOUT
04:46:10.520 --> 04:46:12.188
THIS NARROW EXEMPTION, THE CITY
04:46:12.255 --> 04:46:13.656
MUST CHOOSE BETWEEN VIOLATING
04:46:13.723 --> 04:46:15.224
ITS CONTRACT WITH THE FEDERAL
04:46:15.291 --> 04:46:16.292
GOVERNMENT OR VIOLATING STATE
04:46:16.359 --> 04:46:17.393
LAW, NEITHER OF WHICH IS AN
04:46:17.460 --> 04:46:19.395
APPEALING OF FOR THESE REASONS.
04:46:19.462 --> 04:46:20.830
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR A
04:46:20.897 --> 04:46:23.366
VOTE TODAY ON A B 2319. THANK
04:46:23.432 --> 04:46:27.904
YOU. GOOD EVENING. MY NAME IS
04:46:27.970 --> 04:46:29.338
DOUG BIGGS. I'M THE EXECUTIVE
04:46:29.405 --> 04:46:30.907
DIRECTOR OF THE ALAMEDA POINT
04:46:30.973 --> 04:46:31.774
COLLABORATIVE, SPEAKING IN FAVOR
04:46:31.841 --> 04:46:34.777
OF A B 23 19, A PC WAS CREATED
04:46:34.844 --> 04:46:36.012
OUT OF THE CLOSURE AND SURPLUSES
04:46:36.078 --> 04:46:38.014
OF THE ALAMEDA NAVAL AIR STATION
04:46:38.080 --> 04:46:40.082
IN THE MID NINETIES. THE FEDERAL
04:46:40.149 --> 04:46:41.517
PROCESS WE WENT THROUGH AT THAT
04:46:41.584 --> 04:46:42.652
TIME ENSURED THE LONG TERM
04:46:42.718 --> 04:46:44.053
PLANNING AND REUSE OF BASED
04:46:44.120 --> 04:46:45.521
PROPERTIES MET LOCAL ECONOMIC
04:46:45.588 --> 04:46:46.756
DEVELOPMENT AND HOMELESSNESS,
04:46:46.822 --> 04:46:47.690
COMBINATIONS OF THE COMMUNITY
04:46:47.757 --> 04:46:50.593
AND SURROUNDING REGIONS. BASED
04:46:50.660 --> 04:46:52.228
ON THAT PROCESS, WE CREATED AN
04:46:52.295 --> 04:46:54.430
AMAZING COMMUNITY. 500 FORMERLY
04:46:54.497 --> 04:46:55.932
HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS, INCLUDING
04:46:55.998 --> 04:46:57.833
ALMOST 200 CHILDREN, WE PROVIDE
04:46:57.900 --> 04:46:58.868
SAFE, SUPPORTIVE HOUSING,
04:46:58.935 --> 04:47:01.370
WRAPAROUND SERVICES LIFE SKILLS.
04:47:01.437 --> 04:47:02.972
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES USING
04:47:03.039 --> 04:47:04.974
OLD NAVY HOUSING FACILITIES, BUT
04:47:05.041 --> 04:47:07.209
IT'S TIME TO REBUILD POWER
04:47:07.276 --> 04:47:08.477
OUTAGES WATER AND TO REMAIN
04:47:08.544 --> 04:47:09.545
FAILURES ARE ALL TOO COMMON IN
04:47:09.612 --> 04:47:11.180
ALABAMA POINT. THE COLLABORATIVE
04:47:11.247 --> 04:47:12.815
IS WORKING WITH THE CITY TO
04:47:12.882 --> 04:47:13.683
REBUILD THE EXISTING TUTORED
04:47:13.749 --> 04:47:15.751
UNITS AND ADD AN ADDITIONAL 190
04:47:15.818 --> 04:47:17.553
UNITS OF POSITIVE HOMELESS AS
04:47:17.620 --> 04:47:19.088
PART OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
04:47:19.155 --> 04:47:20.723
THE OVERALL BASE REUSE PLAN. THE
04:47:20.790 --> 04:47:21.757
REVISED SLH, HOWEVER
04:47:21.824 --> 04:47:22.224
SIGNIFICANTLY DELAYED
04:47:22.291 --> 04:47:26.095
DEVELOPMENT. OF ALAMEDA POINT.
04:47:26.162 --> 04:47:27.930
SIX TO IMPOSE A DO OVER ON THE
04:47:27.997 --> 04:47:29.065
ATTENTIVE, SETTLE PROCESS. WE
04:47:29.131 --> 04:47:31.500
ENGAGED IN TO ESTABLISH A B C
04:47:31.567 --> 04:47:32.835
AND IMPACT QUALITY OF LIFE THAT
04:47:32.902 --> 04:47:33.903
THE COLLABORATIVE CAN OFFER OUR
04:47:33.970 --> 04:47:36.038
ROADS. FOR THESE REASONS, WE
04:47:36.105 --> 04:47:37.239
STRONGLY SUPPORT THE SWIFT
04:47:37.306 --> 04:47:39.342
ENACTMENT OF A B 23 19 TO
04:47:39.408 --> 04:47:40.743
EXAMPLE, ALAMEDA POINT FROM THE
04:47:40.810 --> 04:47:42.645
S L. A SO THAT THE DEVELOPMENT
04:47:42.712 --> 04:47:43.846
COULD CONTINUE AND WITH THE
04:47:43.913 --> 04:47:45.781
COLLABORATIVE INVESTOR OF
04:47:45.848 --> 04:47:46.282
ALAMEDA, MOST VULNERABLE
04:47:46.349 --> 04:47:46.949
COMMUNITY MEMBERS THANK YOU VERY
04:47:47.016 --> 04:47:50.987
MUCH. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
04:47:51.053 --> 04:47:52.955
THERE ANY OTHER ANY SUPPORTERS
04:47:53.022 --> 04:47:54.724
IN THE HEARING ROOM WHO WOULD
04:47:54.790 --> 04:47:58.661
LIKE TO SPEAK? UM SEEING NON
04:47:58.728 --> 04:48:01.097
WILL GO BACK TO THE PHONE LINES
04:48:01.163 --> 04:48:02.632
TO SEE IF THERE ARE ANY
04:48:02.698 --> 04:48:03.599
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT OF PUBLIC
04:48:03.666 --> 04:48:07.903
COMMENTS. TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR
04:48:07.970 --> 04:48:09.472
THIS BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE,
04:48:09.538 --> 04:48:10.706
FOLLOWED BY wO
04:48:10.773 --> 04:48:11.807
THEN ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE
04:48:11.874 --> 04:48:20.282
KEYPAD. WE HAVE A COMMENT FROM
04:48:20.349 --> 04:48:23.886
LINE 4 26, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
04:48:23.953 --> 04:48:26.022
ADRIAN NOT PROPERLY HOUSE
04:48:26.088 --> 04:48:28.057
ASSOCIATION OR CALIFORNIA
04:48:28.124 --> 04:48:30.059
EXPRESS THAT TO THE AUTHOR FOR
04:48:30.126 --> 04:48:31.460
ADDRESSING OUR CONCERNS,
04:48:31.527 --> 04:48:35.097
LANGUAGE, GREAT STAFF AND. THIS
04:48:35.164 --> 04:48:36.699
MEASURE HAPPY TO BE WORKING
04:48:36.766 --> 04:48:38.067
TOGETHER TO PROTECT THAT DELAY
04:48:38.134 --> 04:48:39.135
IN FINDING REASONABLE WAYS TO
04:48:39.201 --> 04:48:41.003
MOVE FORWARD ON THIS PARTICULAR
04:48:41.070 --> 04:48:42.071
PROJECT. WE DON'T HAVE AN
04:48:42.138 --> 04:48:44.373
ESTABLISHED TRADITION AS A WAY
04:48:44.440 --> 04:48:45.441
TO INTERFERE LANGUAGE THAT THE
04:48:45.508 --> 04:48:46.909
AUTHOR REFERRED TO REGARDING
04:48:46.976 --> 04:48:48.844
LIKE ALL OF THE BILL, BUT WE
04:48:48.911 --> 04:48:49.879
HAVE FULLY WORKING WITH
04:48:49.945 --> 04:48:54.050
APPRECIATE HER. THANK YOU. NO
04:48:54.116 --> 04:48:55.818
FURTHER LINES IN QUEUE FOR
04:48:55.885 --> 04:48:58.521
SUPPORT. OKAY, WELL, NOW GO TO
04:48:58.587 --> 04:48:59.855
OPPOSITION. IS THERE ANY
04:48:59.922 --> 04:49:01.023
OPPOSITION IN THE HEARING ROOM?
04:49:01.090 --> 04:49:04.527
PLEASE COME FORWARD. THANK YOU,
04:49:04.593 --> 04:49:05.661
MR CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE,
04:49:05.728 --> 04:49:07.196
JEREMY SMITH. HERE WITH THE
04:49:07.263 --> 04:49:08.397
STATE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
04:49:08.464 --> 04:49:09.065
TRADES COUNCIL. MORE BETWEEN ER,
04:49:09.131 --> 04:49:10.466
UM, THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S, I
04:49:10.533 --> 04:49:13.069
THINK CHARACTERIZED IT AS AN
04:49:13.135 --> 04:49:14.070
AGREEMENT CONCEPT BETWEEN THE
04:49:14.136 --> 04:49:14.970
LOCAL TRADES OURSELVES AND THE%
04:49:15.037 --> 04:49:17.173
CITY. I WOULD AGREE WITH THAT.
04:49:17.239 --> 04:49:19.241
OVER THE LAST 48 HOURS. WE'VE
04:49:19.308 --> 04:49:21.343
GOTTEN BOGGED DOWN ON JUST A
04:49:21.410 --> 04:49:23.179
COUPLE LITERALLY. JUST A COUPLE
04:49:23.245 --> 04:49:24.413
OF WORDS. UH, AS IN A PROPOSED
04:49:24.480 --> 04:49:26.982
AMENDMENT. TO THE BILL. UM WE
04:49:27.049 --> 04:49:29.518
HOPE TO GET TO THE BOTTOM OF
04:49:29.585 --> 04:49:30.486
THAT. I THINK WE'RE GOING TO BUT
04:49:30.553 --> 04:49:31.721
WE DO STILL HAVE A LITTLE
04:49:31.787 --> 04:49:33.089
CONCERNED ABOUT THIS BILL TO
04:49:33.155 --> 04:49:34.790
MAKE SURE THAT IT WORKS FOR THE
04:49:34.857 --> 04:49:36.058
WORKERS OF ALAMEDA CONSTRUCTION
04:49:36.125 --> 04:49:37.693
WORKERS OF ALAMEDA, AND I THINK
04:49:37.760 --> 04:49:38.994
WE'RE GOING TO GET THERE.
04:49:39.061 --> 04:49:39.862
BRITISH WANT TO LET THE
04:49:39.929 --> 04:49:42.098
COMMITTEE KNOW WE ARE. WE DO
04:49:42.164 --> 04:49:43.332
STILL HAVE SOME CONCERNS AND ARE
04:49:43.399 --> 04:49:44.834
IN THIS TWITTER POSITION. THANK
04:49:44.900 --> 04:49:46.268
YOU. GREAT ANY ADDITIONAL
04:49:46.335 --> 04:49:47.236
OPPOSITION AND THE HEARING ROOM.
04:49:47.303 --> 04:49:49.138
SEEING THEM WILL GO TO THE PHONE
04:49:49.205 --> 04:49:53.442
LINES. TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION
04:49:53.509 --> 04:49:55.411
OVER THE PHONE, PLEASE PRESS ONE
04:49:55.478 --> 04:49:56.712
AND THEN ZERO AGAIN. THAT'S ONE
04:49:56.779 --> 04:50:03.219
FOLLOWED BY THE ZERO. THANK YOU.
04:50:03.285 --> 04:50:07.089
THERE ARE NO LINES IN QUÊ. OKAY
04:50:07.156 --> 04:50:09.191
UM, WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
04:50:09.258 --> 04:50:10.292
COMMITTEE. IT'S IN A ROTH
04:50:10.359 --> 04:50:12.394
SENATOR ROTH MOVES THE BILL. ANY
04:50:12.461 --> 04:50:13.329
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
04:50:13.395 --> 04:50:18.234
COLLEAGUES. GOOD UM,
04:50:18.300 --> 04:50:19.435
RECOMMENDING IT. I VOTE AND WE
04:50:19.502 --> 04:50:20.536
HAVE EMOTION AND YOU MAKE
04:50:20.603 --> 04:50:23.272
CLOTHES. THANK YOU AND CHAIR AND
04:50:23.339 --> 04:50:26.008
MEMBERS DON'T KNOW. I HOPE THAT
04:50:26.075 --> 04:50:27.042
YOU COME TO VISIT THE CITY OF
04:50:27.109 --> 04:50:29.111
ALAMEDA AND CAN COME TO VISIT
04:50:29.178 --> 04:50:29.912
THIS BEAUTIFUL SPACE THAT HAS
04:50:29.979 --> 04:50:31.080
TAKEN LITERALLY THREE DECADES TO
04:50:31.147 --> 04:50:34.450
BE ABLE TO DEVELOP. UM AND I AM
04:50:34.517 --> 04:50:35.518
CERTAIN THAT WITH THIS
04:50:35.584 --> 04:50:37.486
LEGISLATION, WE WILL BE ABLE TO
04:50:37.553 --> 04:50:39.955
ENSURE THAT THE CITY OF ALAMEDA
04:50:40.022 --> 04:50:41.023
CONTINUES TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE
04:50:41.090 --> 04:50:42.558
AFFORDABLE HOUSING CRISIS THAT
04:50:42.625 --> 04:50:44.426
WE HAVE AS WELL AS ENSURE OUR
04:50:44.493 --> 04:50:46.061
ABILITY TO HAVE A THRIVING
04:50:46.128 --> 04:50:49.865
ECONOMIC BASE ON THE BEST. THANK
04:50:49.932 --> 04:50:51.367
YOU WITH THAT. I RESPECTFULLY
04:50:51.433 --> 04:50:54.236
REQUEST YOUR I VOTE. UM THE
04:50:54.303 --> 04:50:56.739
MOTION BY SENATOR ROTH HAS DO
04:50:56.806 --> 04:50:58.507
PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST, UM
04:50:58.574 --> 04:51:00.242
AND THEN WE REFER TO THE
04:51:00.309 --> 04:51:01.443
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WILL
04:51:01.510 --> 04:51:04.013
CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR WIENER
04:51:04.079 --> 04:51:09.118
BATES BUREAU. CORTEZ E. COURTESY
04:51:09.185 --> 04:51:11.921
I MCGUIRE PHð BUG ROTH I
04:51:11.987 --> 04:51:14.657
SCANNER. HAMBURG HAMBURG. I
04:51:14.723 --> 04:51:18.427
SUPPORTED ZERO OKAY. WE'LL PUT
04:51:18.494 --> 04:51:19.995
THAT ON CALL FOR THE ABSENT
04:51:20.062 --> 04:51:22.231
MEMBERS. THANK YOU. OKAY. NEXT
04:51:22.298 --> 04:51:22.998
UP. UM, I SEE THAT
04:51:23.065 --> 04:51:25.901
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S REYES IS HERE.
04:51:25.968 --> 04:51:27.937
ITEM 28 B 28 17 MADAM MAJORITY
04:51:28.003 --> 04:51:33.509
LEADER. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR
04:51:33.576 --> 04:51:39.915
MEMBERS. MAYBE 21. I'M SORRY. A
04:51:39.982 --> 04:51:40.983
B 28 17. THE CALIFORNIA
04:51:41.050 --> 04:51:43.719
HOMELESSNESS ASSISTANCE ACT IS A
04:51:43.786 --> 04:51:45.654
BILL THAT WOULD HELP IN HOUSED
04:51:45.721 --> 04:51:47.256
CALIFORNIANS MEAT. THE HIGH COST
04:51:47.323 --> 04:51:49.091
OF HOUSING BY PROVIDING RENTAL
04:51:49.158 --> 04:51:52.027
SUBSIDIES. TO QUICKLY MOVE THEM
04:51:52.094 --> 04:51:53.128
OFF THE STREETS AND INTO
04:51:53.195 --> 04:51:55.698
HOUSING. IN RECENT YEARS, THE
04:51:55.764 --> 04:51:57.132
GOVERNOR AND STATE LEGISLATURE
04:51:57.199 --> 04:51:58.234
HAVE TAKEN TREMENDOUS STEPS TO
04:51:58.300 --> 04:52:01.503
COMBAT THE ONGOING HOMELESSNESS
04:52:01.570 --> 04:52:03.606
CRISIS, WHICH HAS ONLY WORSENED
04:52:03.672 --> 04:52:05.841
WITH THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC.
04:52:05.908 --> 04:52:07.109
DESPITE THESE HISTORIC
04:52:07.176 --> 04:52:09.011
INVESTMENTS, THE IMPACTS OF THIS
04:52:09.078 --> 04:52:10.212
CRISIS HAS LEFT HUNDREDS OF
04:52:10.279 --> 04:52:12.181
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE ON THE
04:52:12.248 --> 04:52:13.382
STREETS, MOST OF WHOM ARE PEOPLE
04:52:13.449 --> 04:52:16.085
OF COLOR. DATA FROM THE NATIONAL
04:52:16.151 --> 04:52:17.620
LOW INCOME HOUSING COALITION
04:52:17.686 --> 04:52:18.254
SHOWS THAT CALIFORNIA'S SEVERE
04:52:18.320 --> 04:52:20.623
LACK OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
04:52:20.689 --> 04:52:22.825
DRIVES ARE HOMELESSNESS CRISIS
04:52:22.892 --> 04:52:23.993
WHERE A PERSON WOULD HAVE TO
04:52:24.059 --> 04:52:28.898
MAKE $31 AN HOUR TO AFFORD A ONE
04:52:28.964 --> 04:52:32.234
BEDROOM APARTMENT. RESEARCH
04:52:32.301 --> 04:52:33.068
SHOWS THAT DIRECT RENTAL
04:52:33.135 --> 04:52:35.871
SUBSIDIES ARE ONE OF THE MOST
04:52:35.938 --> 04:52:36.438
EFFECTIVE INTERVENTIONS FOR
04:52:36.505 --> 04:52:37.840
REDUCING HOMELESSNESS AND THE
04:52:37.907 --> 04:52:39.375
SUBSIDIES HAVE BEEN SUCCESSFUL
04:52:39.441 --> 04:52:40.342
ACROSS SEVERAL STATES AND
04:52:40.409 --> 04:52:45.080
NATIONWIDE. A B 28 17 WILL PUT
04:52:45.147 --> 04:52:46.148
THIS RESEARCH INTO ACTION BY
04:52:46.215 --> 04:52:47.116
PROVIDING DIRECT RENTAL
04:52:47.182 --> 04:52:47.783
ASSISTANCE. TO PEOPLE
04:52:47.850 --> 04:52:51.020
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS. AND
04:52:51.086 --> 04:52:52.288
PROVIDE GRANTS TO LOCAL
04:52:52.354 --> 04:52:54.089
JURISDICTIONS AND SERVICE
04:52:54.156 --> 04:52:55.190
PROVIDERS TO CONNECT PEOPLE TO
04:52:55.257 --> 04:52:57.826
HOUSING AND RENTAL ASSISTANCE.
04:52:57.893 --> 04:53:00.095
FURTHER A B 28 17 ENSURES
04:53:00.162 --> 04:53:02.264
ACCOUNTABILITY AND ENABLES
04:53:02.331 --> 04:53:03.866
FUTURE PLANNING BY REQUIRING
04:53:03.933 --> 04:53:06.135
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO REPORT ON
04:53:06.201 --> 04:53:07.503
HOW THE SUCCESS OF THESE FUNDS
04:53:07.569 --> 04:53:11.240
IS REDUCING HOMELESSNESS. HERE
04:53:11.307 --> 04:53:12.808
TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OUR CHRIS
04:53:12.875 --> 04:53:14.777
MARTIN FROM HOUSING, CALIFORNIA.
04:53:14.843 --> 04:53:15.878
AND FAITH CONNOLLY FROM L. A
04:53:15.945 --> 04:53:19.048
COUNTY. OKAY. YOU MAY COME
04:53:19.114 --> 04:53:24.420
FORWARD. GOOD EVENING CHAIR AND
04:53:24.486 --> 04:53:26.722
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS CHRIS MARTIN
04:53:26.789 --> 04:53:27.623
ON THE POLICY DIRECTOR AT
04:53:27.690 --> 04:53:29.692
HOUSING CALIFORNIA WE ARE A
04:53:29.758 --> 04:53:31.226
NONPROFIT THAT ADVOCATES TO
04:53:31.293 --> 04:53:32.394
PREVENT AND HOMELESSNESS AND
04:53:32.461 --> 04:53:33.729
INCREASE THE SUPPLY OF SAFE,
04:53:33.796 --> 04:53:35.731
STABLE AND AFFORDABLE HOMES.
04:53:35.798 --> 04:53:37.299
HOUSE IN CALIFORNIA IS PROUD TO
04:53:37.366 --> 04:53:40.436
SPONSOR A B 28 17 FROM THE
04:53:40.502 --> 04:53:41.236
MAJORITY LEADER, WHICH WOULD
04:53:41.303 --> 04:53:43.172
CREATE THE STATE'S FIRST PROGRAM
04:53:43.238 --> 04:53:44.606
SPECIFICALLY FOR THE PURPOSE OF
04:53:44.673 --> 04:53:45.541
ADMINISTERING RENTAL ASSISTANCE
04:53:45.607 --> 04:53:48.811
FOR A HOUSED PEOPLE. FACING AN
04:53:48.877 --> 04:53:51.013
UNPRECEDENTED CRISIS. CALIFORNIA
04:53:51.080 --> 04:53:52.247
MUST ACT WITH URGENCY AND
04:53:52.314 --> 04:53:54.116
RESPOND WITH SOLUTIONS AT SCALE
04:53:54.183 --> 04:53:56.752
. MAYBE 28 17 WOULD DO JUST THAT
04:53:56.819 --> 04:53:58.120
, BASED ON THE SUCCESSFUL,
04:53:58.187 --> 04:53:59.121
FLEXIBLE HOUSING SUBSIDY POLE
04:53:59.188 --> 04:54:02.157
MODEL. A B 28 17 WOULD CREATE A
04:54:02.224 --> 04:54:03.359
PROGRAM THAT WOULD UTILIZE
04:54:03.425 --> 04:54:04.893
FLEXIBLE HOUSING SUBSIDIES
04:54:04.960 --> 04:54:07.029
PAIRED WITH SERVICES TO IDENTIFY
04:54:07.096 --> 04:54:08.230
AND SECURE HOUSING PLACEMENTS TO
04:54:08.297 --> 04:54:10.232
HOUSE OVER 50,000 PEOPLE IN THE
04:54:10.299 --> 04:54:12.801
COURSE OF A YEAR. THIS MODEL HAS
04:54:12.868 --> 04:54:14.136
BEEN RECOGNIZED AS A NATIONAL
04:54:14.203 --> 04:54:15.838
BEST PRACTICE AND HAS BEEN
04:54:15.904 --> 04:54:16.805
REPLICATED IN COMMUNITIES
04:54:16.872 --> 04:54:18.173
THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND COUNTRY
04:54:18.240 --> 04:54:19.341
, INCLUDING SAN DIEGO, SAN
04:54:19.408 --> 04:54:21.276
FRANCISCO AND EVEN NAPA INTO
04:54:21.343 --> 04:54:23.712
LARRY COUNTY. THE WAY THIS POLL
04:54:23.779 --> 04:54:25.347
WORKS IS LANDLORD ENGAGEMENT
04:54:25.414 --> 04:54:26.015
TEAMS SUPPLIED WITH FLEXIBLE
04:54:26.081 --> 04:54:27.649
RENT SUBSIDIES, SECURE CONTROL
04:54:27.716 --> 04:54:29.618
OF UNITS, CREATING A POOL OR
04:54:29.685 --> 04:54:31.854
INVENTORY OF APARTMENT HOMES.
04:54:31.920 --> 04:54:32.788
TENDENCY SUPPORT STAFF CAN THEN
04:54:32.855 --> 04:54:34.757
MATCH CLIENTS WITH A UNIT THAT
04:54:34.823 --> 04:54:36.859
IS RIGHT FOR THEM. WHEN FULLY
04:54:36.925 --> 04:54:38.794
OPERATIONAL PEOPLE TRANSITION
04:54:38.861 --> 04:54:40.529
FROM HOMELESSNESS TO PERMANENT
04:54:40.596 --> 04:54:42.131
HOUSING IN THE MATTER OF WEEKS
04:54:42.197 --> 04:54:43.499
BECAUSE NO ONE IS SENT OFF TO
04:54:43.565 --> 04:54:44.133
NAVIGATE CALIFORNIA'S FIERCELY
04:54:44.199 --> 04:54:44.900
COMPETITIVE HOUSING MARKET ON
04:54:44.967 --> 04:54:47.936
THEIR OWN. ADDITIONALLY THE
04:54:48.003 --> 04:54:48.871
FLEXIBLE MODEL PROVIDES
04:54:48.937 --> 04:54:51.774
DOCUMENTED COST SAVINGS.
04:54:51.840 --> 04:54:52.975
INVESTING IN FLEXIBLE RENT
04:54:53.042 --> 04:54:54.543
SUBSIDIES AND TENDENCY SUPPORTS
04:54:54.610 --> 04:54:56.779
HAS BEEN PROVEN TO REDUCE HEALTH
04:54:56.845 --> 04:54:58.247
CARE IN EMERGENCY COSTS. FOR
04:54:58.313 --> 04:54:58.747
THESE REASONS. HOUSING
04:54:58.814 --> 04:54:59.782
CALIFORNIA IS PROUD TO SPONSOR A
04:54:59.848 --> 04:55:02.418
B 28 17. WE APPRECIATE THE
04:55:02.484 --> 04:55:03.952
MAJORITY LEADER'S WORK ON THIS
04:55:04.019 --> 04:55:04.953
CRITICAL ISSUE AND RESPECTFULLY
04:55:05.020 --> 04:55:10.359
URGE YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU.
04:55:10.426 --> 04:55:12.027
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
04:55:12.094 --> 04:55:12.995
FAITH CONNOLLY WITH THE L. A
04:55:13.062 --> 04:55:14.063
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS.
04:55:14.129 --> 04:55:17.266
I'LL KEEP THIS BRIEF TO THE TIME
04:55:17.332 --> 04:55:17.966
OF EVENING. WE'RE IN IN L. A
04:55:18.033 --> 04:55:19.368
COUNTY OF THE LAST FOUR YEARS
04:55:19.435 --> 04:55:21.003
WITH RESPECT TO OUR OWN MEASURE
04:55:21.070 --> 04:55:22.938
AGE, AS WELL AS SOME ONE TIME
04:55:23.005 --> 04:55:24.873
STATE INVESTMENTS. WE HAVE BEEN
04:55:24.940 --> 04:55:26.542
ABLE TO HOUSE MORE THAN 75,000
04:55:26.608 --> 04:55:28.177
PEOPLE IN PERMANENT HOUSING AND
04:55:28.243 --> 04:55:30.746
OVER 100,000 IN INTERIM HOUSING
04:55:30.813 --> 04:55:32.915
, BUT DESPITE THOSE AND VARIOUS
04:55:32.981 --> 04:55:34.383
OTHER INVESTMENTS, WE CONTINUE
04:55:34.450 --> 04:55:36.618
TO SEE AN INCREASE IN THE NUMBER
04:55:36.685 --> 04:55:37.586
OF FOLKS FALLING INTO
04:55:37.653 --> 04:55:38.787
HOMELESSNESS. WE NEED TO BETTER
04:55:38.854 --> 04:55:40.622
LEVERAGE THE MARKET RATE HOUSING
04:55:40.689 --> 04:55:43.358
THAT ALREADY EXISTS. A B 2017
04:55:43.425 --> 04:55:44.593
PROPOSES TO DO THIS WITH THE
04:55:44.660 --> 04:55:45.594
HOUSE CALIFORNIA CHALLENGE
04:55:45.661 --> 04:55:48.163
PROGRAM. THE LARGE INFUSION OF
04:55:48.230 --> 04:55:49.498
RENTAL ASSISTANCE WOULD MAKE
04:55:49.565 --> 04:55:51.233
TENS OF THOUSANDS OF MARKET RATE
04:55:51.300 --> 04:55:52.534
UNITS IN L A AFFORDABLE BY
04:55:52.601 --> 04:55:54.903
SUBSIDIZING RENT FOR THOSE UNITS
04:55:54.970 --> 04:55:57.039
, ALLOWING THE COUNTY TO BEGIN
04:55:57.106 --> 04:55:57.706
CLOSING OUR CURRENT SHORTFALL OF
04:55:57.773 --> 04:55:58.740
OVER 500,000 AFFORDABLE HOUSING
04:55:58.807 --> 04:56:03.178
UNITS. A B 28 17 WILL HELP LA
04:56:03.245 --> 04:56:04.746
COUNTY BUILD UPON OUR INITIAL
04:56:04.813 --> 04:56:05.914
HOUSING SUCCESSES AND I RESPECT
04:56:05.981 --> 04:56:11.320
YOUR SUPPORT TODAY. THANK YOU.
04:56:11.386 --> 04:56:12.554
IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
04:56:12.621 --> 04:56:15.390
IN THE HEARING ROOM? QUÊ SAYING,
04:56:15.457 --> 04:56:17.226
NO, WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
04:56:17.292 --> 04:56:22.364
FOR SUPPORT. TO EXPRESS SUPPORT
04:56:22.431 --> 04:56:23.999
ON THE TELEPHONE PRESS ONE
04:56:24.066 --> 04:56:25.934
FOLLOWED BY ZERO AGAIN, THAT'S
04:56:26.001 --> 04:56:27.069
ONE AND THEN ZERO. OVER THE
04:56:27.136 --> 04:56:32.875
LINE, 79. GOOD EVENING, MR CHAIR
04:56:32.941 --> 04:56:34.343
AND MEMBERS CREAM GREASY ON
04:56:34.409 --> 04:56:35.777
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
04:56:35.844 --> 04:56:36.945
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS AND
04:56:37.012 --> 04:56:38.113
SUPPORT RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING
04:56:38.180 --> 04:56:43.085
EYES. THANK YOU. WE DO HAVE AN
04:56:43.152 --> 04:56:48.123
ADDITIONAL LINE 3 28. YES ANDREW
04:56:48.190 --> 04:56:51.927
LEWIS. WHAT'S THE VILLAGE SPORT?
04:56:51.994 --> 04:56:56.165
NO FURTHER LINES IN QUÊ. OKAY.
04:56:56.231 --> 04:56:57.366
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
04:56:57.432 --> 04:57:01.270
HEARING ROOM? GO TO THE PHONE
04:57:01.336 --> 04:57:06.275
LINES FOR OPPOSITION. TO EXPRESS
04:57:06.341 --> 04:57:08.310
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
04:57:08.377 --> 04:57:09.811
THEN ZERO AGAIN. THAT'S ONE
04:57:09.878 --> 04:57:16.118
FOLLOWED BY ISRAEL, PLEASE.
04:57:16.185 --> 04:57:18.120
THERE ARE NO LINES IN Q AT THIS
04:57:18.187 --> 04:57:21.790
TIME. OKAY WE'LL BRING IT BACK
04:57:21.857 --> 04:57:23.058
TO THE COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS
04:57:23.125 --> 04:57:23.892
OR COLLEGE OR COMMENTS
04:57:23.959 --> 04:57:24.793
COLLEAGUES MOTION BY SENATOR
04:57:24.860 --> 04:57:28.830
ROTH. OKAY. THANK YOU FOR
04:57:28.897 --> 04:57:29.798
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. I'M
04:57:29.865 --> 04:57:31.600
RECOMMENDING I VOTE AND, UH, YOU
04:57:31.667 --> 04:57:35.704
MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
04:57:35.771 --> 04:57:37.539
HOMELESSNESS, AS WE KNOW IS A
04:57:37.606 --> 04:57:40.609
STATEWIDE PROBLEM. WE'VE GOT TO
04:57:40.676 --> 04:57:41.777
FIND A COMPREHENSIVE SOLUTION TO
04:57:41.843 --> 04:57:44.646
MEET THE SCALE OF NEED. A B 28
04:57:44.713 --> 04:57:46.648
17 PROVIDES AN INNOVATIVE
04:57:46.715 --> 04:57:49.051
RESEARCH BASED SOLUTION TO MOVE
04:57:49.117 --> 04:57:51.019
ON HOUSED CALIFORNIANS TO
04:57:51.086 --> 04:57:52.087
HOUSING AND ENSURE ONGOING
04:57:52.154 --> 04:57:55.157
STABILITY. AND WITH THAT, I
04:57:55.224 --> 04:57:56.191
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
04:57:56.258 --> 04:57:59.528
VOTE. THANK YOU. THE MOTION IS
04:57:59.595 --> 04:58:01.897
DUE PASS, BUT FIRST, WE WILL BE
04:58:01.964 --> 04:58:02.831
RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:58:02.898 --> 04:58:04.266
HUMAN SERVICES WILL CALL THE
04:58:04.333 --> 04:58:08.570
ROLL SENATOR WIENER BATES. K<c.cyan></c>
04:58:08.637 --> 04:58:12.674
HERO, ORTEZ E Z. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE
04:58:12.741 --> 04:58:16.144
AYE COBURG ROTH ROTH I SKINNER.
04:58:16.211 --> 04:58:20.048
HAMBURG. HAMBURG. AYE. 5 TO 0.
04:58:20.115 --> 04:58:22.017
PUT THAT ON CALL. THANK YOU.
04:58:22.084 --> 04:58:24.519
THANK YOU. AND THEN OUR FINAL
04:58:24.586 --> 04:58:26.888
BILL PRESENTATION OF THE EVENING
04:58:26.955 --> 04:58:29.024
. I REMEMBER 21 28 63
04:58:29.091 --> 04:58:36.531
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WILSON WELCOME.
04:58:36.598 --> 04:58:38.700
WELL. GOOD EVENING, MR CHAIR AND
04:58:38.767 --> 04:58:40.836
FELLOW SENATORS TODAY. I'M HERE
04:58:40.902 --> 04:58:43.905
TO PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL 28 63.
04:58:43.972 --> 04:58:46.508
A B 28 63 DIRECTS THE STATE
04:58:46.575 --> 04:58:48.043
BUILDING STANDARDS COMMISSION
04:58:48.110 --> 04:58:49.177
AND THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
04:58:49.244 --> 04:58:50.612
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT TO
04:58:50.679 --> 04:58:52.914
STUDY AND PROPOSE MINIMUM
04:58:52.981 --> 04:58:54.283
BICYCLE PARKING REQUIREMENTS AND
04:58:54.349 --> 04:58:57.052
BOTH NONRESIDENTIAL AND
04:58:57.119 --> 04:58:59.154
RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS. CURRENTLY
04:58:59.221 --> 04:59:00.656
EXISTING BIKE PARKING
04:59:00.722 --> 04:59:01.690
REGULATIONS ARE TIED TO THE
04:59:01.757 --> 04:59:03.692
NUMBER OF VEHICLE SPACES,
04:59:03.759 --> 04:59:05.560
HOWEVER, AND SOME INSTANCES
04:59:05.627 --> 04:59:07.596
CERTAIN BUILDINGS MIGHT NOT
04:59:07.663 --> 04:59:09.164
INCLUDE CAR PARKING, WHICH WOULD
04:59:09.231 --> 04:59:10.866
RESULT IN LITTLE TO NO REQUIRED
04:59:10.932 --> 04:59:15.037
BIKE PARKING. A B 28 63 WILL
04:59:15.103 --> 04:59:16.505
PROVIDE MORE BIKE INFRASTRUCTURE
04:59:16.571 --> 04:59:18.874
, REDUCE OUR EMISSIONS AND HELP
04:59:18.940 --> 04:59:20.409
CALIFORNIA ACHIEVE ITS CLIMATE
04:59:20.475 --> 04:59:22.711
GOALS BECAUSE THESE UPDATES ARE
04:59:22.778 --> 04:59:23.979
BEING MANDATED TO OCCUR AT THE
04:59:24.046 --> 04:59:26.114
NEXT TRIENNIAL UPDATES. OF THE
04:59:26.181 --> 04:59:27.549
CALIFORNIA GREEN BUILDING
04:59:27.616 --> 04:59:29.584
STANDARDS CODE. THE COST
04:59:29.651 --> 04:59:30.619
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS BILL ARE
04:59:30.686 --> 04:59:33.188
CONSIDERED MINOR AND ABSORBABLE
04:59:33.255 --> 04:59:34.790
. THIS SPILL HAS NO KNOWN
04:59:34.856 --> 04:59:35.891
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. AND I
04:59:35.957 --> 04:59:36.992
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I
04:59:37.059 --> 04:59:40.062
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
04:59:40.128 --> 04:59:41.697
THERE ARE THERE ANY SUPPORT
04:59:41.763 --> 04:59:44.066
WITNESSES IN THE HEARING ROOM?
04:59:44.132 --> 04:59:45.300
SAYING NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE
04:59:45.367 --> 04:59:49.237
LINE FOR SUPPORT. EXPRESS
04:59:49.304 --> 04:59:50.672
SUPPORT ON THE PHONE AND THEN
04:59:50.739 --> 04:59:52.741
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO
04:59:52.808 --> 04:59:54.543
AGAIN. THAT'S ONE AND THEN ZERO
04:59:54.609 --> 04:59:58.280
AND YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD. THANK
04:59:58.347 --> 05:00:01.416
YOU KNOW LINES IN QUÊ. OKAY. IS
05:00:01.483 --> 05:00:02.551
THERE ANY OPPOSITION IN THE
05:00:02.617 --> 05:00:04.720
HEARING ROOM? SEEING THEM WILL
05:00:04.786 --> 05:00:09.391
GO TO THE PHONE LINES. TO
05:00:09.458 --> 05:00:10.592
EXPRESS OPPOSITION ON THE BILL.
05:00:10.659 --> 05:00:12.094
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO AGAIN,
05:00:12.160 --> 05:00:16.565
THAT'S ONE FOLLOWED BY A ZERO
05:00:16.631 --> 05:00:20.569
THERE ARE NO LINES IN QUÊ. BRING
05:00:20.635 --> 05:00:22.037
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE.
05:00:22.104 --> 05:00:23.905
SENATOR ROTH MOVES THE BILL AND
05:00:23.972 --> 05:00:25.841
HE COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS SEEING
05:00:25.907 --> 05:00:27.642
NONE. YOU MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU,
05:00:27.709 --> 05:00:29.044
AS WAS STATED IN THE ANALYSIS.
05:00:29.111 --> 05:00:30.579
THIS BILL AIMS TO MAKE BIKE
05:00:30.645 --> 05:00:31.980
PARKING, INDEPENDENT OF VEHICLE
05:00:32.047 --> 05:00:33.915
PARKING SO THAT REDUCTIONS IN
05:00:33.982 --> 05:00:34.883
PARKING REQUIREMENTS WOULD NOT
05:00:34.950 --> 05:00:36.284
DISCOURAGE BIKING. WITH THAT? I
05:00:36.351 --> 05:00:39.554
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
05:00:39.621 --> 05:00:42.591
THANK YOU AND THE MOTION IS DUE
05:00:42.657 --> 05:00:44.726
PAST BUT FIRST WE WILL BE
05:00:44.793 --> 05:00:46.495
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
05:00:46.561 --> 05:00:47.129
APPROPRIATIONS, UM, RECOMMENDING
05:00:47.195 --> 05:00:48.196
AN I VOTE. YOU MAY CALL THE
05:00:48.263 --> 05:00:52.634
ROLL. SENATOR WIENER WIENER. AYE
05:00:52.701 --> 05:00:55.837
BATES. COME ON, GIRL, ORTEZ.
05:00:55.904 --> 05:00:59.007
COURTESY I MCGUIRE REQUIRE I O
05:00:59.074 --> 05:01:01.676
BUG. RUFF, RUFF, I SKINNER
05:01:01.743 --> 05:01:06.281
HAMBURG. AYE. 5 TO 0. OKAY WE'LL
05:01:06.348 --> 05:01:09.184
PUT THAT ON CALL. WE ARE SENATOR
05:01:09.251 --> 05:01:11.620
BATES IS NOT RETURNING. SO WE
05:01:11.686 --> 05:01:12.687
ARE JUST WAITING FOR SENATOR
05:01:12.754 --> 05:01:14.189
SKINNER AND CABRERA TO RETURN IF
05:01:14.256 --> 05:01:15.624
THAT'S GOING TO BE IMMINENT.
05:01:15.690 --> 05:01:27.536
WILL WAIT. OTHERWISE I DON'T. UM
05:01:27.602 --> 05:01:28.837
WELL, THEN OPEN THE ROLL SO WE
05:01:28.904 --> 05:01:45.954
CAN LET OTHER MEMBERS GO.
05:05:58.139 --> 05:06:02.977
OKAY WE HAVE A FULL COMPLEMENT.
05:06:03.044 --> 05:06:05.980
SO WE'RE GOING TO START JUST GO
05:06:06.047 --> 05:06:06.981
STRAIGHT DOWN, STARTING WITH
05:06:07.048 --> 05:06:09.484
ITEM TO, UM AND WE'LL LIFT THE
05:06:09.551 --> 05:06:13.488
CALLS. SO WE'RE GOING TO ITEM
05:06:13.555 --> 05:06:15.790
NUMBER TWO, MAYBE 2011 BY
05:06:15.857 --> 05:06:17.092
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WORKS, PLEASE
05:06:17.158 --> 05:06:22.497
CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS.
05:06:22.564 --> 05:06:27.068
CABALLERO COURTESY. MCGUIRE THE
05:06:27.135 --> 05:06:28.203
WIRE. I PH<c.cyan>UG HAMBURG.</c>
05:06:28.269 --> 05:06:31.940
HAMBURG. AYE. 6 TO 1. THAT BILL
05:06:32.006 --> 05:06:36.578
IS OUT. WE ALL GO TO THE
05:06:36.644 --> 05:06:39.647
CONSENT. CALENDAR WHICH IS ITEM
05:06:39.714 --> 05:06:46.855
THREE. AH! I'M SORRY I AM THREE
05:06:46.921 --> 05:06:52.927
ITEMS 389, 10 AND 13. OKAY? AH
05:06:52.994 --> 05:06:56.231
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:06:56.297 --> 05:06:59.234
CABALLERO ZERO. I MCGUIRE
05:06:59.300 --> 05:07:00.435
MCGUIRE. I CHOSE BUG HAMBURG.
05:07:00.502 --> 05:07:05.473
HAMBURG. AYE. 8 TO 0 CONSENT
05:07:05.540 --> 05:07:15.083
CALENDAR IS APPROVED. ONE SECOND. OKAY SO THE NEXT ONE WILL GO
05:07:15.150 --> 05:07:17.886
TO ITEM NUMBER FOUR A. B 16 95
05:07:17.952 --> 05:07:18.920
WHERE SOME MEMBERS SANTIAGO,
05:07:18.987 --> 05:07:21.256
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:07:21.322 --> 05:07:23.858
SENATOR WIENER WIENER? AYE
05:07:23.925 --> 05:07:25.160
BATES, CABALLERO CABALLERO HIGH
05:07:25.226 --> 05:07:28.797
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I, JOE BUG
05:07:28.863 --> 05:07:34.569
HAMBURG. HAMBURG. AYE. 7 TO 0.
05:07:34.636 --> 05:07:37.472
THAT BILL IS OUT. ITEM NUMBER 5
05:07:37.539 --> 05:07:40.775
25 EXCUSE ME, MAYBE 26 53 BY
05:07:40.842 --> 05:07:42.076
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO.
05:07:42.143 --> 05:07:43.244
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:07:43.311 --> 05:07:46.347
SENATOR WIENER WIENER BY
05:07:46.414 --> 05:07:49.751
CABALLERO CABALLERO. I MCGUIRE.
05:07:49.818 --> 05:07:51.219
MCGUIRE I CHOSE BUG. HAMBURG.
05:07:51.286 --> 05:07:58.459
HAMBURG. AYE. 721 IS OUT. ITEM
05:07:58.526 --> 05:08:00.795
NUMBER SIX A B 17 43 BY
05:08:00.862 --> 05:08:01.763
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MEDINA. PLEASE
05:08:01.830 --> 05:08:03.531
CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS.
05:08:03.598 --> 05:08:04.933
SENATOR BATES CABALLERO.
05:08:04.999 --> 05:08:09.804
CABALLERO. IS I'M SORRY. THAT
05:08:09.871 --> 05:08:11.005
WAS BY SOME REMEMBER MAKIN ER MY
05:08:11.072 --> 05:08:14.375
APOLOGIES. CHOIR. MCGUIRE. I PH<c.cyan></c>
05:08:14.442 --> 05:08:21.950
BUG HAMBURG. LIMBURG? AYE. 70.
05:08:22.016 --> 05:08:22.984
OKAY, THAT BILL BY
05:08:23.051 --> 05:08:23.985
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MAKIN ER IS
05:08:24.052 --> 05:08:27.789
OUT. UM MEXICO TO ITEM SEVEN. A
05:08:27.856 --> 05:08:28.890
B 18 50 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
05:08:28.957 --> 05:08:30.758
AWARD. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
05:08:30.825 --> 05:08:32.961
MEMBERS. BATES. CABALLERO.
05:08:33.027 --> 05:08:36.264
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I MACHO BUG.
05:08:36.331 --> 05:08:42.437
HAMBURG. 5 TO 0. THAT BILL IS
05:08:42.503 --> 05:08:49.844
OUT WILL NOW GO TO ITEM 11. A B. 2053 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY
05:08:49.911 --> 05:08:51.079
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
05:08:51.145 --> 05:09:00.521
EURO. ORTEZ. 20 I SEE. MCGUIRE.
05:09:00.588 --> 05:09:06.427
MCGUIRE I SHOW BUG HAMBURG. 5 TO
05:09:06.494 --> 05:09:09.397
1. THAT BILL IS OUT. UM ITEM
05:09:09.464 --> 05:09:12.367
NUMBER 12 A B 2097 BY SOME
05:09:12.433 --> 05:09:13.968
MEMBER OF FRIEDMAN. PLEASE CALL
05:09:14.035 --> 05:09:15.136
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. SENATOR
05:09:15.203 --> 05:09:17.238
WIENER WIENER, I CABALLERO
05:09:17.305 --> 05:09:20.008
CABALLERO HIGH, MCGUIRE.
05:09:20.074 --> 05:09:24.946
MCGUIRE. I PHð BUG HAMBURG. 6 TO
05:09:25.013 --> 05:09:28.716
1. THAT BILL IS OUT. I WILL NOW
05:09:28.783 --> 05:09:32.020
GO TO ITEM 14, MAYBE 20 TO 33 BY
05:09:32.086 --> 05:09:33.288
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA.
05:09:33.354 --> 05:09:34.856
PLEASE CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS
05:09:34.923 --> 05:09:35.857
. SENATOR WIENER WIENER. AYE
05:09:35.924 --> 05:09:39.761
CABALLERO. CABALLERO. I MCGUIRE
05:09:39.827 --> 05:09:41.729
MCGUIRE. I CHILL BUG HAMBURG.
05:09:41.796 --> 05:09:46.100
HAMBURG BY. 8 TO 0. THAT BILL IS
05:09:46.167 --> 05:09:51.973
OUT. NEXT IS ITEM 15 A B 27 05
05:09:52.040 --> 05:09:53.207
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA.
05:09:53.274 --> 05:09:54.275
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS,
05:09:54.342 --> 05:09:57.011
SENATOR MCGUIRE. A TROLL BUG.
05:09:57.078 --> 05:10:03.251
HAMBURG. HAMBURG. AYE. 6 TO 0.
05:10:03.318 --> 05:10:07.255
THAT BILL IS OUT NEXT ITEM 16 82
05:10:07.322 --> 05:10:09.390
TO 34 BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER ROBERT
05:10:09.457 --> 05:10:10.491
REVIS. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
05:10:10.558 --> 05:10:14.062
MEMBERS. SENATOR MCGUIRE.
05:10:14.128 --> 05:10:16.998
MCGUIRE I PHùBUG SKINNER. AYE.
05:10:17.065 --> 05:10:22.837
8 TO 0. THAT BILL WAS OUT NEXT
05:10:22.904 --> 05:10:25.173
ITEM. 17 82 295 BY
05:10:25.239 --> 05:10:26.140
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM PLEASE
05:10:26.207 --> 05:10:26.975
CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS.
05:10:27.041 --> 05:10:30.244
SENATOR CABALLERO. CABALLERO
05:10:30.311 --> 05:10:33.147
HIGH ORTEZ MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE, I
05:10:33.214 --> 05:10:37.719
MACHO BUG SKITTER. SKINNER. AYE.
05:10:37.785 --> 05:10:41.889
6 TO 1 BILL IS OUT. ITEM NUMBER
05:10:41.956 --> 05:10:44.625
1980 23 19 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
05:10:44.692 --> 05:10:46.060
BANTA PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
05:10:46.127 --> 05:10:59.307
MEMBERS. 18.
05:10:59.374 --> 05:11:02.844
SENATOR BATES. CABALLERO.
05:11:02.910 --> 05:11:07.215
CABALLERO. I MCGUIRE. REQUIRE
05:11:07.281 --> 05:11:11.185
MACHO BUG. SKINNER SKINNER. AYE.
05:11:11.252 --> 05:11:14.455
7 TO 0. THAT BILL IS OUT ITEM
05:11:14.522 --> 05:11:17.425
NUMBER 20 A B 28 17 BY
05:11:17.492 --> 05:11:18.526
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S REYES, PLEASE
05:11:18.593 --> 05:11:19.193
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. SENATE
05:11:19.260 --> 05:11:23.831
DEBATES. CABALLERO. CABALLERO
05:11:23.898 --> 05:11:28.336
HI<c.cyan> BUG. SKINNER SKINNER. AYE.</c>
05:11:28.403 --> 05:11:30.805
7 TO 0. THAT BILL IS OUT AND
05:11:30.872 --> 05:11:33.741
THEN FINALLY ITEM 21 A B 28 63
05:11:33.808 --> 05:11:35.610
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WILSON.
05:11:35.676 --> 05:11:37.678
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS,
05:11:37.745 --> 05:11:38.813
SENATOR BATES CABALLERO
05:11:38.880 --> 05:11:42.250
CABALLERO HI<c.cyan> BUG. SKINNER</c>
05:11:42.316 --> 05:11:45.720
SKINNER, I 7 TO 0. THAT BILL IS
05:11:45.787 --> 05:11:51.859
OUT, ALLISON. OKAY GREAT. I WANT
05:11:51.926 --> 05:11:53.761
TO THANK EVERYONE, UM, MEMBERS
05:11:53.828 --> 05:11:54.996
OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS OF PUBLIC
05:11:55.063 --> 05:11:57.398
FOR BEING HERE. TODAY WAS A LONG
05:11:57.465 --> 05:11:58.900
AGENDA, BUT A PRODUCTIVE ONE,
05:11:58.966 --> 05:11:59.934
AND WE'VE COMPLETED OUR
05:12:00.001 --> 05:12:01.302
BUSINESS. SO THE COMMITTEE IS
05:12:01.369 --> 05:12:17.518
ADJOURNED.