WEBVTT
00:00:10.009 --> 00:00:11.711
THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON
00:00:11.778 --> 00:00:12.812
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WILL COME
00:00:12.879 --> 00:00:15.115
TO ORDER. GOOD MORNING TO
00:00:15.181 --> 00:00:16.683
EVERYONE. WE CONTINUE TO TAKE
00:00:16.750 --> 00:00:18.418
SOME PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE THE
00:00:18.485 --> 00:00:21.087
ONGOING COVID 19 RISKS AND THE
00:00:21.154 --> 00:00:22.789
SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE
00:00:22.856 --> 00:00:23.990
PUBLIC AND HAS PROVIDED ACCESS
00:00:24.057 --> 00:00:25.759
TO BOTH. IN PERSON AND
00:00:25.825 --> 00:00:27.026
TELECONFERENCE PARTICIPATION FOR
00:00:27.093 --> 00:00:29.796
PUBLIC COMMENT. FOR INDIVIDUALS
00:00:29.863 --> 00:00:31.431
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
00:00:31.498 --> 00:00:32.799
COMMENT VIA THE TELECONFERENCE
00:00:32.866 --> 00:00:35.101
SERVICE. THE PARTICIPANT TOLL
00:00:35.168 --> 00:00:37.537
FREE NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:37.604 --> 00:00:38.938
POSTED ON OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE.
00:00:39.005 --> 00:00:40.807
AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT NOW.
00:00:40.874 --> 00:00:41.775
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
00:00:41.841 --> 00:00:49.315
877. 22681. AND THE ACCESS CODE
00:00:49.382 --> 00:00:54.921
IS 533. 8635. I WILL MAINTAIN
00:00:54.988 --> 00:00:56.656
THE QUORUM DURING THE HEARING AS
00:00:56.723 --> 00:00:58.558
AN AS IS CUSTOMARY IN ANY
00:00:58.625 --> 00:01:00.593
INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE MAY
00:01:00.660 --> 00:01:02.095
BE REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE
00:01:02.162 --> 00:01:03.596
MEETING SERVICE OR HAVE THEIR
00:01:03.663 --> 00:01:04.597
CONNECTIONS MUTED. WE HAVEN'T
00:01:04.664 --> 00:01:07.467
HAD TO DO THAT SO FAR, AND SO I
00:01:07.534 --> 00:01:08.835
DON'T EXPECT TO HAVE TO DO THAT
00:01:08.902 --> 00:01:10.770
AGAIN, BUT IT THAT THAT IS THE
00:01:10.837 --> 00:01:11.871
PROCESS. WE ARE HOLDING OUR
00:01:11.938 --> 00:01:13.473
COMMITTEE HEARINGS HERE IN ROOM
00:01:13.540 --> 00:01:15.909
2200 OF THE OLD STREET BUILDING,
00:01:15.975 --> 00:01:18.077
AND I ASK ALL MEMBERS OF THE
00:01:18.144 --> 00:01:19.479
COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT SO WE
00:01:19.546 --> 00:01:20.814
CAN ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM AND
00:01:20.880 --> 00:01:25.285
BEGIN OUR HEARING. SO WE HAVE 17
00:01:25.351 --> 00:01:26.419
BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA, WITH
00:01:26.486 --> 00:01:29.022
FOUR BILLS PROPOSED FOR CONSENT.
00:01:29.088 --> 00:01:30.089
THE CONSENT ITEMS ARE FILE ITEM
00:01:30.156 --> 00:01:33.793
NUMBER THREE. A B 22 16 BY
00:01:33.860 --> 00:01:37.530
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IRWIN. ITEM
00:01:37.597 --> 00:01:39.933
NUMBER SEVEN A. B 17 OH, SEVEN.
00:01:39.999 --> 00:01:40.366
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:01:40.433 --> 00:01:44.404
BOERNER HORVATH. ITEM NUMBER
00:01:44.471 --> 00:01:47.006
EIGHT A. B 17 65 BY
00:01:47.073 --> 00:01:48.975
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S NAZARIAN AND
00:01:49.042 --> 00:01:51.244
ITEM NUMBER 17 A B 26 25 BY
00:01:51.311 --> 00:01:57.050
ASSEMBLY MEMBER TING. SO WE DO
00:01:57.116 --> 00:01:58.351
NOT HAVE A CORN RIGHT NOW. SO
00:01:58.418 --> 00:02:00.286
WE'LL WAIT UNTIL WE HAVE, UM,
00:02:00.353 --> 00:02:01.287
WE'RE GONNA START AS A
00:02:01.354 --> 00:02:04.891
SUBCOMMITTEE. AND WE'RE READY TO
00:02:04.958 --> 00:02:06.659
HEAR FROM OUR FIRST AUTHOR
00:02:06.726 --> 00:02:08.428
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVINE. THANK
00:02:08.495 --> 00:02:12.699
YOU FOR BEING FIRST HERE WERE
00:02:12.765 --> 00:02:13.867
EXCITED. YOU'RE HERE THIS
00:02:13.933 --> 00:02:16.936
MORNING. WE'RE FRESH. SO IT'S UM
00:02:17.003 --> 00:02:18.438
IT'S A GOOD TIME TO PRESENT. I
00:02:18.505 --> 00:02:20.440
KNOW HOW LONG THESE DAYS CAN BE
00:02:20.507 --> 00:02:22.809
. AND SO I'M GLAD TO BE HELPFUL
00:02:22.876 --> 00:02:23.943
IN THE EFFICIENCY OF YOUR
00:02:24.010 --> 00:02:27.447
COMMITTEE. AND I'M REALLY
00:02:27.514 --> 00:02:28.248
GRATEFUL. FIRST OF ALL, MADAM
00:02:28.314 --> 00:02:30.817
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. GOOD MORNING
00:02:30.884 --> 00:02:32.986
AND THANK YOU. AND I'D LIKE TO
00:02:33.052 --> 00:02:34.888
SAY THANK YOU TO BOTH YOU AND
00:02:34.954 --> 00:02:35.889
YOUR STAFF FOR YOUR
00:02:35.955 --> 00:02:36.823
THOUGHTFULNESS AND CONSIDERING
00:02:36.890 --> 00:02:38.525
THIS BILL AND I WANT TO MAKE IT
00:02:38.591 --> 00:02:39.526
VERY CLEAR THAT I ACCEPT THE
00:02:39.592 --> 00:02:41.261
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS AND AGAIN
00:02:41.327 --> 00:02:42.462
. I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR THE
00:02:42.529 --> 00:02:44.564
THOUGHTFULNESS TOWARDS THEM. GUN
00:02:44.631 --> 00:02:45.698
SALES AND INCIDENTS OF GUN
00:02:45.765 --> 00:02:46.733
VIOLENCE HAVE INCREASED
00:02:46.799 --> 00:02:48.568
DRAMATICALLY. SINCE THE
00:02:48.635 --> 00:02:49.469
BEGINNING OF THE COVID 19
00:02:49.536 --> 00:02:51.237
PANDEMIC. IN THE FIRST SIX
00:02:51.304 --> 00:02:52.372
MONTHS OF 2022, THERE HAVE BEEN
00:02:52.438 --> 00:02:54.641
AT LEAST 240 MASS SHOOTINGS IN
00:02:54.707 --> 00:02:56.476
THE UNITED STATES AND IN MAY
00:02:56.543 --> 00:02:57.911
2022, THE FEDERAL CENTERS FOR
00:02:57.977 --> 00:02:59.112
DISEASE CONTROL REPORTED THAT
00:02:59.178 --> 00:03:01.614
THE FIREARM HOMICIDE RATE
00:03:01.681 --> 00:03:03.483
INCREASED BY 35% SINCE THE COVID
00:03:03.550 --> 00:03:07.220
19 PANDEMIC. CALIFORNIA IS NOT
00:03:07.287 --> 00:03:08.388
IMMUNE TO THIS VIOLENCE.
00:03:08.454 --> 00:03:09.822
ACCORDING TO THE GUN VIOLENCE
00:03:09.889 --> 00:03:11.624
ARCHIVE, 2022 COULD BE ONE OF
00:03:11.691 --> 00:03:13.860
THE HIGHEST YEARLY RATES OF GUN
00:03:13.927 --> 00:03:14.994
RELATED DEATHS IN THE STATE'S
00:03:15.061 --> 00:03:16.863
HISTORY. EVEN LICENSED SALES OF
00:03:16.930 --> 00:03:18.331
FIREARMS, AMMUNITION AND
00:03:18.398 --> 00:03:19.966
PRECURSOR PARTS CONTRIBUTE TO
00:03:20.033 --> 00:03:21.367
HIGH RATES OF GUN VIOLENCE
00:03:21.434 --> 00:03:22.869
THROUGH STRAW PURCHASES,
00:03:22.936 --> 00:03:23.937
TRAFFICKING TO ILLICIT MARKETS,
00:03:24.003 --> 00:03:27.073
THEFT OR OTHER NEGLIGENT LOSSES.
00:03:27.140 --> 00:03:28.575
GUN PREVALENCE NOT ONLY IMPOSES
00:03:28.641 --> 00:03:30.810
AN IMMEASURABLE TOLL ON HUMAN
00:03:30.877 --> 00:03:32.445
LIVES, IT ALSO CREATES ITS OWN
00:03:32.512 --> 00:03:34.380
ECONOMIC BURDENS. CURRENTLY
00:03:34.447 --> 00:03:34.914
TAXPAYERS ARE EFFECTIVELY
00:03:34.981 --> 00:03:36.749
SUBSIDIZING THE COST OF GUN
00:03:36.816 --> 00:03:39.352
VIOLENCE. BE IT THROUGH THE USE
00:03:39.419 --> 00:03:40.687
OF LAW ENFORCEMENT, COURT
00:03:40.753 --> 00:03:41.454
EXPENSES, MEDICAL CARE AND OTHER
00:03:41.521 --> 00:03:42.655
RESOURCES THAT GUN INCIDENTS
00:03:42.722 --> 00:03:45.925
STRAIN. A B 12 27 CREATES AN
00:03:45.992 --> 00:03:47.727
IMPORTANT LONG TERM INVESTMENT
00:03:47.794 --> 00:03:48.828
IN REDUCING THESE HARMS ACROSS
00:03:48.895 --> 00:03:51.564
CALIFORNIA. THIS BILL
00:03:51.631 --> 00:03:52.565
ESTABLISHES THE GUN VIOLENCE%
00:03:52.632 --> 00:03:54.467
PREVENTION HEALING RECOVERY FUND
00:03:54.534 --> 00:03:56.035
, WHICH WILL BE USED FOR GUN
00:03:56.102 --> 00:03:57.337
VIOLENCE, EDUCATION RESEARCH AND
00:03:57.403 --> 00:04:00.640
PREVENTION PROGRAMS. A B 12 27
00:04:00.707 --> 00:04:01.975
GENERATES FUNDS BY IMPOSING A
00:04:02.041 --> 00:04:04.344
MODEST EXCISE TAX AT THE RETAIL
00:04:04.410 --> 00:04:06.579
LEVEL OF 10% FOR THE SALE OF
00:04:06.646 --> 00:04:08.615
HANDGUNS AND 11% FOR THE SALE OF
00:04:08.681 --> 00:04:10.583
LONG GUNS AND AMMUNITION. THIS
00:04:10.650 --> 00:04:12.352
BILL MIRRORS A LONGSTANDING
00:04:12.418 --> 00:04:14.120
FEDERAL EXCISE TAX AND FIREARM
00:04:14.187 --> 00:04:15.722
AND AMMUNITION PRODUCERS THAT
00:04:15.788 --> 00:04:17.924
WAS ESTABLISHED TO REMEDIATE THE
00:04:17.991 --> 00:04:19.092
EFFECTS OF GUNS ON WILDLIFE
00:04:19.158 --> 00:04:21.361
POPULATIONS. SIMILARLY THIS BILL
00:04:21.427 --> 00:04:22.996
ENSURES A SUSTAINED REVENUE FOR
00:04:23.062 --> 00:04:24.364
PROGRAMS THAT SPECIFICALLY
00:04:24.430 --> 00:04:25.231
REMEDIATE THE DEVASTATING
00:04:25.298 --> 00:04:27.200
EFFECTS THESE PRODUCTS CAUSE
00:04:27.266 --> 00:04:28.267
FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES ACROSS
00:04:28.334 --> 00:04:31.604
THE STATE. WITH THE COMMITTEE
00:04:31.671 --> 00:04:32.639
AMENDMENTS. HALF OF THE REVENUES
00:04:32.705 --> 00:04:34.474
GENERATED WILL GO TO THE STATE
00:04:34.540 --> 00:04:35.141
VIOLENCE INTERVENTION PREVENTION
00:04:35.208 --> 00:04:36.542
GRANT PROGRAM IN HALF WILL BE
00:04:36.609 --> 00:04:37.944
RESERVED FOR APPROPRIATIONS BY
00:04:38.011 --> 00:04:38.978
THE LEGISLATURE TO GUN VIOLENCE,
00:04:39.045 --> 00:04:39.612
PREVENTION PROGRAMS AND RESEARCH
00:04:39.679 --> 00:04:42.982
BASED ON NEED. SENATORS WE MUST
00:04:43.049 --> 00:04:45.084
TAKE RESPONSIBLE ACTION TO END
00:04:45.151 --> 00:04:46.052
THE PUBLIC HEALTH CRISIS THAT IS
00:04:46.119 --> 00:04:48.087
GUN VIOLENCE IN OUR STATE AND
00:04:48.154 --> 00:04:50.456
NATION. AS WE SEE MORE AND MORE
00:04:50.523 --> 00:04:51.257
INCIDENTS OF GUN VIOLENCE, WE
00:04:51.324 --> 00:04:52.325
MUST BE REMINDED THAT WE ARE
00:04:52.392 --> 00:04:55.895
NEITHER HELPLESS NOR HOPELESS.
00:04:55.962 --> 00:04:56.996
TO THE END OF THE CARNAGE
00:04:57.063 --> 00:04:58.698
OCCURRING IN CALIFORNIA AND
00:04:58.765 --> 00:04:59.832
ACROSS THE UNITED STATES ARE
00:04:59.899 --> 00:05:00.800
RESPECTFULLY ASKED FOR AN I
00:05:00.867 --> 00:05:05.905
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, UM SO
00:05:05.972 --> 00:05:07.607
DUE TO THE CONSTRAINTS REGARDING
00:05:07.674 --> 00:05:08.708
THE LENGTH OF THE HEARING AND
00:05:08.775 --> 00:05:11.310
TECHNOLOGY CONSIDERATIONS, WE
00:05:11.377 --> 00:05:13.646
HEAR INSTITUTE TIME LIMITS ON
00:05:13.713 --> 00:05:15.081
TESTIMONY, EACH SIDE WILL BE
00:05:15.148 --> 00:05:16.416
PERMITTED IN EQUAL AMOUNT OF
00:05:16.482 --> 00:05:19.285
TIME TO BE DETERMINED BY ME AND
00:05:19.352 --> 00:05:20.453
WHAT WE TRADITIONALLY DO IS TO
00:05:20.520 --> 00:05:22.388
TWO MINUTES. REACH, UM, LEAD
00:05:22.455 --> 00:05:24.791
WITNESS. AND THEN ALL OTHERS
00:05:24.857 --> 00:05:26.526
WISHING TO TESTIFY, LIMIT THEIR
00:05:26.592 --> 00:05:28.695
COMMENTS TO NAME AFFILIATION AND
00:05:28.761 --> 00:05:30.930
POSITION ON THE MEASURES, SO
00:05:30.997 --> 00:05:32.331
WE'RE GOING TO START WITH YOUR
00:05:32.398 --> 00:05:36.002
LEAD. SUPPORT WITNESS AND I HAVE
00:05:36.069 --> 00:05:38.771
NONE IS THAT CORRECT? I DON'T
00:05:38.838 --> 00:05:40.273
BELIEVE SO. OKAY VERY GOOD.
00:05:40.339 --> 00:05:41.908
WELL, WE'RE GOING TO SEE IF
00:05:41.974 --> 00:05:43.943
THERE ARE ANY INDIVIDUALS HERE
00:05:44.010 --> 00:05:45.778
IN ROOM 2200. THEY WOULD LIKE TO
00:05:45.845 --> 00:05:47.046
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. IF SO,
00:05:47.113 --> 00:05:52.051
PLEASE COME FORWARD. THINK. YES
00:05:52.118 --> 00:05:53.820
ACTUALLY, THAT'S A GOOD IDEA IF
00:05:53.886 --> 00:05:55.888
EXCUSE ME JUST FOR A MINUTE AS
00:05:55.955 --> 00:05:58.157
WE, UM TAKE THE ROLE FOR A
00:05:58.224 --> 00:06:01.527
QUARRYMEN. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:06:01.594 --> 00:06:04.764
SENATORS CABALLERO HERE.
00:06:04.831 --> 00:06:06.232
CABALLERO PRESENT NIELSEN TO
00:06:06.299 --> 00:06:08.835
RUSSELL. DURACELL PRESENT.
00:06:08.901 --> 00:06:12.672
HERTZBERG. WIENER WIENER
00:06:12.739 --> 00:06:16.275
PRESENT. YOU HAVE A QUORUM.
00:06:16.342 --> 00:06:17.577
QUORUM IS PRESENT. THANK YOU SO
00:06:17.643 --> 00:06:19.512
MUCH. AND THANK YOU FOR THE
00:06:19.579 --> 00:06:22.548
REMINDER. WE'RE MOVING ON TO THE
00:06:22.615 --> 00:06:23.616
TELECONFERENCE LINE TO, UM UM
00:06:23.683 --> 00:06:29.222
YEAH. MR OR MADAM. MODERATOR IF
00:06:29.288 --> 00:06:30.089
YOU COULD CHECK THE
00:06:30.156 --> 00:06:31.157
TELECONFERENCE LINE TO SEE IF
00:06:31.224 --> 00:06:32.258
THERE'S ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE
00:06:32.325 --> 00:06:34.060
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE
00:06:34.127 --> 00:06:37.497
BILL. IT ISN'T GENTLEMEN, IF YOU
00:06:37.563 --> 00:06:39.632
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B
00:06:39.699 --> 00:06:41.400
12 27. PLEASE PRESS 10 ON YOUR
00:06:41.467 --> 00:06:50.476
PHONE. THAT IS 10 ON YOUR
00:06:50.543 --> 00:06:58.151
TELEPHONE. AND I HAVE NO ONE IN
00:06:58.217 --> 00:06:59.585
. Q. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE
00:06:59.652 --> 00:07:01.420
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION.
00:07:01.487 --> 00:07:03.856
WE HAVE ONE LEAD OPPOSITION
00:07:03.923 --> 00:07:05.158
WITNESS ROY GRIFFITH FROM THE
00:07:05.224 --> 00:07:06.192
CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
00:07:06.259 --> 00:07:12.431
ASSOCIATION. WELCOME, SIR. MADAM
00:07:12.498 --> 00:07:13.900
CHAIR SENATORS FOR THE RECORD.
00:07:13.966 --> 00:07:15.134
ROY GRIFFITHS, SPEAKING ON
00:07:15.201 --> 00:07:16.169
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE
00:07:16.235 --> 00:07:17.603
AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION, ARE
00:07:17.670 --> 00:07:19.105
MEMBERS ROCK, CALIFORNIA WE
00:07:19.172 --> 00:07:21.741
STAND IN STRONG SUPPORT WITH LAW
00:07:21.808 --> 00:07:23.142
ENFORCEMENT TO MAKE OUR
00:07:23.209 --> 00:07:24.544
COMMUNITIES SAFE. WE CONSTANTLY
00:07:24.610 --> 00:07:25.745
SUPPORT LEGISLATION THAT AIMS AT
00:07:25.812 --> 00:07:27.713
GETTING OUR CRIMINALS OFF OUR
00:07:27.780 --> 00:07:28.881
STREETS AND KEEPING FIREARMS IN
00:07:28.948 --> 00:07:31.484
THE HANDS OF RESPONSIBLE. FOLKS
00:07:31.551 --> 00:07:33.719
THIS IS NO SUCH PIECE OF
00:07:33.786 --> 00:07:35.421
LEGISLATION. I WANT TO TALK AS
00:07:35.488 --> 00:07:36.189
MUCH ABOUT THIS LEGISLATION ITS
00:07:36.255 --> 00:07:39.392
MERITS AS HOW IT GOT HERE. THIS
00:07:39.458 --> 00:07:41.427
IS A GUT AND AMEND THAT COULDN'T
00:07:41.494 --> 00:07:43.563
EVEN GET OFF THE ASSEMBLY SIDE.
00:07:43.629 --> 00:07:44.697
THREE YEARS. THIS BILL HAS COME
00:07:44.764 --> 00:07:46.599
UP IN THREE YEARS WE'VE FOUGHT.
00:07:46.666 --> 00:07:48.034
IT REQUIRES A TWO THIRDS VOTE.
00:07:48.100 --> 00:07:48.701
THIS CURRENT BILL VERBATIM SHORT
00:07:48.768 --> 00:07:51.270
OF THE AMENDMENTS PROPOSED HERE.
00:07:51.337 --> 00:07:52.738
COULD NOT EVEN GET OFF THE
00:07:52.805 --> 00:07:54.006
ASSEMBLY SIDE. THIS LAST SESSION
00:07:54.073 --> 00:07:56.542
IS A B 12 23. THAT LANGUAGE WAS
00:07:56.609 --> 00:07:58.544
STUCK INTO A GREENHOUSE. CLEAN
00:07:58.611 --> 00:08:00.947
ENERGY, YOU KNOW, MAKE OUR ROOFS
00:08:01.013 --> 00:08:02.481
LESS SOLAR REFLECTIVE BILL THAT
00:08:02.548 --> 00:08:04.450
WE THE PEOPLE HAD NOT EVEN HAD
00:08:04.517 --> 00:08:05.818
AN OPPORTUNITY TO VIEW. ON THE
00:08:05.885 --> 00:08:07.620
ASSEMBLY SIDE. SO BEFORE YOU
00:08:07.687 --> 00:08:08.688
SENATORS IS A PIECE OF
00:08:08.754 --> 00:08:10.756
LEGISLATION THAT COULDN'T EVEN
00:08:10.823 --> 00:08:11.457
GET PAST THE GOOD
00:08:11.524 --> 00:08:12.992
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S OAN MEMBERS ON
00:08:13.059 --> 00:08:15.862
HIS SIDE WITH A SUPERMAJORITY.
00:08:15.928 --> 00:08:17.230
TAXATION LIKE THIS IS
00:08:17.296 --> 00:08:19.866
IRRESPONSIBLE. WE YOU KNOW
00:08:19.932 --> 00:08:21.234
RESPONSIBLE GUN OWNERS PAY OUR
00:08:21.300 --> 00:08:23.069
PART THROUGH COMMUNITY TAXES OF
00:08:23.135 --> 00:08:24.704
10% AND MORE IN MANY COMMUNITIES
00:08:24.770 --> 00:08:25.538
THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA AND
00:08:25.605 --> 00:08:26.739
THROUGH HIS AS THE ASSEMBLYMAN
00:08:26.806 --> 00:08:30.076
MENTIONED. AN EXCISE TAX PITTMAN
00:08:30.142 --> 00:08:31.811
ROBINSON ACT, WHICH GOES TO
00:08:31.878 --> 00:08:32.511
GREAT THINGS IN CALIFORNIA,
00:08:32.578 --> 00:08:34.714
WILDLIFE CONSERVATION EDUCATION
00:08:34.780 --> 00:08:36.949
, UM, OVER $40 MILLION A YEAR
00:08:37.016 --> 00:08:38.251
COMES INTO CALIFORNIA FEDERALLY
00:08:38.317 --> 00:08:40.486
EACH YEAR OFF THE BACKS OF
00:08:40.553 --> 00:08:41.821
RESPONSIBLE GUN OWNERS. AND NOW
00:08:41.888 --> 00:08:43.256
WE'RE GOING TO TAX THEM FOR WHAT
00:08:43.322 --> 00:08:45.224
CRIMINALS DO THIS SMALL FRACTION
00:08:45.291 --> 00:08:47.126
OF OUR SOCIETY THAT CHOOSES TO
00:08:47.193 --> 00:08:48.327
USE A FIREARM IRRESPONSIBLY
00:08:48.394 --> 00:08:51.731
ILLEGALLY. WE CANNOT STAND FOR
00:08:51.797 --> 00:08:53.366
THAT. WE NEED TO GET OUR
00:08:53.432 --> 00:08:54.267
CRIMINALS OFF OUR STREETS. WE
00:08:54.333 --> 00:08:56.302
HAVE OVER 24,000 ARMED
00:08:56.369 --> 00:08:57.703
PROHIBITED FELONS THAT THIS
00:08:57.770 --> 00:09:00.006
STATE KNOWS ABOUT AND YET WE'RE
00:09:00.072 --> 00:09:01.107
TAXING THIS DOJ ASIANS WITH
00:09:01.173 --> 00:09:03.576
GOING OUT. AND CHASING DOWN, YOU
00:09:03.643 --> 00:09:05.044
KNOW TO MAKING SURE PEOPLE ARE
00:09:05.111 --> 00:09:06.612
NOW GOING TO BE PAYING THIS TAX
00:09:06.679 --> 00:09:09.248
. SO AGAIN, WE STAND WITH LAW
00:09:09.315 --> 00:09:11.117
ENFORCEMENT. WE C R B G R P A
00:09:11.183 --> 00:09:13.052
WANTS TO MAKE OUR COMMUNITY SÜ
00:09:13.119 --> 00:09:15.221
BUT WE CAN'T STAND BY AND SEE A
00:09:15.288 --> 00:09:16.756
TAX THAT GOES AGAINST THE
00:09:16.822 --> 00:09:19.258
CONSTITUTION GOES AGAINST THE
00:09:19.325 --> 00:09:20.626
RIGHTS. YOU KNOW, WE CAN'T TAX
00:09:20.693 --> 00:09:22.728
FOLKS TAKE THOSE MONIES AND USE
00:09:22.795 --> 00:09:24.163
THEM FOR SOMETHING OTHER THAN
00:09:24.230 --> 00:09:26.299
WHAT THE FUNDS WERE RECEIVED
00:09:26.365 --> 00:09:27.333
FOR. SO, WITH ALL DUE RESPECT,
00:09:27.400 --> 00:09:29.168
WE STAND IN STRONG OPPOSITION TO
00:09:29.235 --> 00:09:30.403
THIS MEASURE. THANK YOU VERY
00:09:30.469 --> 00:09:33.673
MUCH, SIR. APPRECIATE IT. IS
00:09:33.739 --> 00:09:35.308
THERE ANYONE ELSE THAT WOULD
00:09:35.374 --> 00:09:37.143
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT IN
00:09:37.209 --> 00:09:39.178
ROOM 2200? MORNING MORNING, GREG
00:09:39.245 --> 00:09:41.314
TURNER ON BEHALF OF SAFARI CLUB
00:09:41.380 --> 00:09:42.148
INTERNATIONAL CALIFORNIA
00:09:42.214 --> 00:09:43.883
COALITION AND WERE OPPOSED FOR
00:09:43.950 --> 00:09:45.418
ALL THE REASONS THAT WE'RE JUST
00:09:45.484 --> 00:09:46.485
SEDATED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:09:46.552 --> 00:09:50.923
VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR DEAN REED
00:09:50.990 --> 00:09:51.958
WITH THE NATIONAL RIFLE
00:09:52.024 --> 00:09:53.225
ASSOCIATION, ALSO HERE FOR GUN
00:09:53.292 --> 00:09:54.460
OWNERS OF CALIFORNIA. STRONG
00:09:54.527 --> 00:09:55.861
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:09:55.928 --> 00:09:57.964
IS THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM
00:09:58.030 --> 00:10:01.667
2200. SITTING THEN WE'LL MOVE ON
00:10:01.734 --> 00:10:03.135
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
00:10:03.202 --> 00:10:04.770
MADAM MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE
00:10:04.837 --> 00:10:06.405
QUEUE UP ANY INDIVIDUALS THAT
00:10:06.472 --> 00:10:07.573
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:10:07.640 --> 00:10:11.277
OPPOSITION TO A B 12 27? YES.
00:10:11.344 --> 00:10:13.279
THANK YOU. IN ORDER TO TESTIFY
00:10:13.346 --> 00:10:14.313
AN OPPOSITION, PLEASE. PRESS
00:10:14.380 --> 00:10:17.883
ONE, THEN ZERO. AND WE WILL
00:10:17.950 --> 00:10:19.885
START WITH LINE. 66, PLEASE GO
00:10:19.952 --> 00:10:23.322
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:10:23.389 --> 00:10:25.658
STEVE ROD ON A MEMBER OF THE
00:10:25.725 --> 00:10:27.426
CALIFORNIA RIGHT. SOC ATION LIFE
00:10:27.493 --> 00:10:28.794
MEMBER OF THE NATIONAL RIFLE
00:10:28.861 --> 00:10:29.462
ASSOCIATION IN U. S. NAVY
00:10:29.528 --> 00:10:31.697
VETERAN AND I'M STRONGLY URGING
00:10:31.764 --> 00:10:34.133
THE COMMITTEE TO VOTE NO ON THIS
00:10:34.200 --> 00:10:36.035
EGREGIOUS BILL. A B 12 27. THANK
00:10:36.102 --> 00:10:38.304
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH AGAIN.
00:10:38.371 --> 00:10:39.505
NEXT WAVE LINE. 27, PLEASE GO
00:10:39.572 --> 00:10:44.310
AHEAD. BED AND CHAIR. MY NAME IS
00:10:44.377 --> 00:10:45.378
BILL GAINES, SPEAKING TODAY ON
00:10:45.444 --> 00:10:46.979
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAPTER
00:10:47.046 --> 00:10:49.115
OF THE WILD, CHEAP FOUNDATION,
00:10:49.181 --> 00:10:50.616
THE ROCKY MOUNTAIN FOUNDATION,
00:10:50.683 --> 00:10:52.685
THE CALIFORNIA DEAR ASSOCIATION
00:10:52.752 --> 00:10:53.285
, THE CALIFORNIA HOCKING CLUB,
00:10:53.352 --> 00:10:54.186
CALIFORIA HOUSEMAN FOR
00:10:54.253 --> 00:10:57.056
CONSERVATION. HILLARY BASIN
00:10:57.123 --> 00:10:58.724
WETLANDS ASSOCIATION. ASSUME
00:10:58.791 --> 00:11:00.593
RESOURCE CONSERVATION DISTRICT,
00:11:00.659 --> 00:11:02.028
CALIFORNIA BOWMAN HUNTER STATE
00:11:02.094 --> 00:11:03.095
ARCHERY ASSOCIATION OF BLACK
00:11:03.162 --> 00:11:05.765
BRANT GROUP. PART OF
00:11:05.831 --> 00:11:07.566
INTERNATIONAL SAN FRANCISCO BAY
00:11:07.633 --> 00:11:08.701
AREA CHAPTER, THE COWL OR
00:11:08.768 --> 00:11:11.203
WETLANDS AND WATERFOWL COUNCIL.
00:11:11.270 --> 00:11:12.405
CALIFORNIA STATE CHAPTER, THE
00:11:12.471 --> 00:11:13.806
NATIONAL WILD TURKEY FEDERATIONS
00:11:13.873 --> 00:11:15.307
AND DIEGO COUNTY WILDLIFE
00:11:15.374 --> 00:11:17.209
FEDERATION IN THE GOLDEN GATE
00:11:17.276 --> 00:11:18.711
CHAPTER AS FAR AS INTERNATIONAL
00:11:18.778 --> 00:11:20.846
AND STRONG OPPOSITION TO A B 12
00:11:20.913 --> 00:11:24.283
27. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT.
00:11:24.350 --> 00:11:25.418
WE HAVE LINES 67, PLEASE GO
00:11:25.484 --> 00:11:29.655
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND
00:11:29.722 --> 00:11:31.157
MEMBERS MICHELE FULLER WITH
00:11:31.223 --> 00:11:32.858
AARON REID AND ASSOCIATES. AND I
00:11:32.925 --> 00:11:34.460
AM CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE
00:11:34.527 --> 00:11:35.628
PEACE OFFICERS RESEARCH
00:11:35.694 --> 00:11:36.429
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA PORK
00:11:36.495 --> 00:11:37.663
AND PORK ISIN OPPOSITION TO
00:11:37.730 --> 00:11:41.834
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:11:41.901 --> 00:11:43.069
NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 73, PLEASE GO
00:11:43.135 --> 00:11:47.940
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. THIS IS
00:11:48.007 --> 00:11:50.443
JOHN HICKMAN. I AM THE CHAIRMAN
00:11:50.509 --> 00:11:52.611
OF THE NEVADA COUNTY GUN OWNERS
00:11:52.678 --> 00:11:54.180
AND MEMBER OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:11:54.246 --> 00:11:56.582
RIFLE AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION.
00:11:56.649 --> 00:11:58.117
NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION AND
00:11:58.184 --> 00:11:59.351
THE NATIONAL STUDENT SHOOTING
00:11:59.418 --> 00:12:02.188
SPORTS FOUNDATION. WE ARE
00:12:02.254 --> 00:12:08.160
STRONGLY OPPOSED TO A B 12 27.
00:12:08.227 --> 00:12:09.361
NEXT IS LINE 65, PLEASE GO
00:12:09.428 --> 00:12:13.999
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:12:14.066 --> 00:12:16.302
DARREN BEDWELL. I AM A MEMBER OF
00:12:16.368 --> 00:12:17.436
THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
00:12:17.503 --> 00:12:19.205
ASSOCIATION AND RESIDENT HERE IN
00:12:19.271 --> 00:12:20.840
SACRAMENTO COUNTY, TAKING A TIME
00:12:20.906 --> 00:12:22.108
OUT OF MY BUSY MORNING TO URGE
00:12:22.174 --> 00:12:23.209
OPPOSITION TO HB 12 27. THANK
00:12:23.275 --> 00:12:27.513
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. EXTRA
00:12:27.580 --> 00:12:28.614
SPECIAL LINE. 54, PLEASE GO
00:12:28.681 --> 00:12:33.886
AHEAD. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING,
00:12:33.953 --> 00:12:35.521
MRS ARLENE ELLIS. I'M A MEMBER
00:12:35.588 --> 00:12:36.355
OF THE CALIFORNIA LIFELINE
00:12:36.422 --> 00:12:39.225
FISCAL ASSOCIATION, THE N R A
00:12:39.291 --> 00:12:40.326
AND I'M A COMPETITIVE PISTOL
00:12:40.392 --> 00:12:42.862
SHOOTER AND I AM IN STRONG
00:12:42.928 --> 00:12:44.997
OPPOSITION TO 12 27. THANK YOU.
00:12:45.064 --> 00:12:48.000
VERY MUCH. NIXES LINE. 30,
00:12:48.067 --> 00:12:52.738
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR AND
00:12:52.805 --> 00:12:54.707
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE, MARK
00:12:54.773 --> 00:12:55.608
HENLEY WITH CALIFORNIA WATERFALL
00:12:55.674 --> 00:12:57.710
ASSOCIATION ON BEHALF OF DUCK
00:12:57.776 --> 00:12:59.044
HUNTERS ACROSS CALIFORNIA. WE
00:12:59.111 --> 00:13:00.146
ARE STRONGLY OPPOSED TO THIS
00:13:00.212 --> 00:13:04.450
BILL. THANK YOU. NEXT LINE. 71,
00:13:04.517 --> 00:13:09.455
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS
00:13:09.522 --> 00:13:11.023
PAUL CAT. I'M A TAXPAYER IN
00:13:11.090 --> 00:13:12.958
VENTURA COUNTY, AND I'M IN
00:13:13.025 --> 00:13:14.994
STRONG OPPOSITION TO A B 12 27.
00:13:15.060 --> 00:13:19.532
THANK YOU. NEXT LINE. 6 36,
00:13:19.598 --> 00:13:24.336
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES, MADAM
00:13:24.403 --> 00:13:26.038
CHAIR. I'M TIM MCMAHON. I'M THE
00:13:26.105 --> 00:13:27.306
CHAIR OF THE SOUTH SACRAMENTO
00:13:27.373 --> 00:13:28.874
CHAPTER OF THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE
00:13:28.941 --> 00:13:30.276
AND PISTOL ASSOCIATION AND
00:13:30.342 --> 00:13:35.814
MEMBER IN STRONG OPPOSITION.
00:13:35.881 --> 00:13:37.049
NEXT TO HIS LINE. 51, PLEASE GO
00:13:37.116 --> 00:13:41.487
AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS JACOB
00:13:41.554 --> 00:13:43.088
PICKET AND I AM A CITIZEN AND
00:13:43.155 --> 00:13:44.823
NASA COUNTY AND I AM STRONG
00:13:44.890 --> 00:13:45.824
OPPOSITION. THIS IS ATTACKED.
00:13:45.891 --> 00:13:47.927
THAT WILL JUST NOT NOCTURNAL
00:13:47.993 --> 00:13:49.461
ACTIVITY AND PUT AN UNDUE BURDEN
00:13:49.528 --> 00:13:51.397
ON HUNTERS LIKE ME WHO FEED THE
00:13:51.463 --> 00:13:52.698
FAMILY OF WILD GAME AND ENJOY
00:13:52.765 --> 00:13:54.300
RECREATIONAL SHOOTING. THERE'S
00:13:54.366 --> 00:13:56.001
NOTHING TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM AT
00:13:56.068 --> 00:13:57.803
HAND. THANK YOU. NEXT LINE. 69,
00:13:57.870 --> 00:14:03.709
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING T
00:14:03.776 --> 00:14:04.743
. J JUNIOR FROM SOUTHERN
00:14:04.810 --> 00:14:06.946
CALIFORNIA. I'M A LIFE MEMBER
00:14:07.012 --> 00:14:10.249
AND ARE A CRP, A MEMBER ALSO ARE
00:14:10.316 --> 00:14:12.218
POOR ACT MEMBER AND SAYS I HEARD
00:14:12.284 --> 00:14:13.619
THEM SPEAK EARLIER. I'M A
00:14:13.686 --> 00:14:16.589
CURRENT F F L HOLDER AS WELL AND
00:14:16.655 --> 00:14:19.625
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THE BILL. A B
00:14:19.692 --> 00:14:25.264
1227. NEXT TO A BLIND 61. PLEASE
00:14:25.331 --> 00:14:28.634
GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS ROBERT S
00:14:28.701 --> 00:14:32.471
KG. I'M A RESIDENT. LAFAYETTE
00:14:32.538 --> 00:14:35.241
CALIFORNIA I'M A LIFE HUNTER,
00:14:35.307 --> 00:14:37.209
ADVOCATE OF SAFARI CLUB
00:14:37.276 --> 00:14:38.277
INTERNATIONAL, A MEMBER OF THE
00:14:38.344 --> 00:14:40.679
NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION. A
00:14:40.746 --> 00:14:42.081
NAVY VETERAN AND ALSO THE
00:14:42.147 --> 00:14:43.582
PRESIDENT OF THE MISSOURI SAFARI
00:14:43.649 --> 00:14:45.517
CLUB, AND WE ADAMANTLY OPPOSED A
00:14:45.584 --> 00:14:48.087
B 1227. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:14:48.153 --> 00:14:52.458
VERY MUCH. NEXT LINE. 22, PLEASE
00:14:52.524 --> 00:14:57.663
GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME IS CHARLES
00:14:57.730 --> 00:14:59.231
WHITLAM AND WITH HOWL FOR
00:14:59.298 --> 00:15:01.567
WILDLIFE, AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE
00:15:01.634 --> 00:15:06.438
A B 1 TO 7. THANK YOU. NEXT
00:15:06.505 --> 00:15:11.310
FIFTH LINE. 68, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:15:11.377 --> 00:15:13.279
HI. MY NAME IS DAN SCHULTZ. I'M
00:15:13.345 --> 00:15:16.815
A MEMBER OF C R P A AND N R A
00:15:16.882 --> 00:15:17.716
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSED MAYBE Ó.
00:15:17.783 --> 00:15:21.453
1227 I FEEL IT. ADDS MORE TAXES
00:15:21.520 --> 00:15:26.959
ON TWO LÀ ABIDING CITIZENS IN
00:15:27.026 --> 00:15:28.794
WITH INFLATION AND GAS PRICES
00:15:28.861 --> 00:15:29.561
AND EVERYTHING ELSE GOING ON
00:15:29.628 --> 00:15:31.463
RIGHT NOW. LAST THING WE NEED IS
00:15:31.530 --> 00:15:33.032
BE PAYING MORE MONEY FOR
00:15:33.098 --> 00:15:33.932
SOMETHING THAT'S A
00:15:33.999 --> 00:15:34.900
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT FOR US.
00:15:34.967 --> 00:15:38.304
THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE
00:15:38.370 --> 00:15:42.308
70, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MM MY NAME
00:15:42.374 --> 00:15:45.177
IS JIM WESTFALL, MEMBER MEMBER
00:15:45.244 --> 00:15:48.414
OF CRP, A ALAMEDA COUNTY, UH,
00:15:48.480 --> 00:15:50.816
AIR FORCE VETERAN AND MEMBER OF
00:15:50.883 --> 00:15:52.184
VAN RAY AND THE CALIFORNIA GUN
00:15:52.251 --> 00:15:54.720
OWNERS. I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS
00:15:54.787 --> 00:15:59.058
FILM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. NEXT.
00:15:59.124 --> 00:16:00.192
WE HAVE LINE 62, PLEASE GO
00:16:00.259 --> 00:16:05.564
AHEAD. RUSSELL BOWLER CALEDONIA
00:16:05.631 --> 00:16:08.167
WILDLIFE ASSOCIATION STRONGLY
00:16:08.233 --> 00:16:13.672
OPPOSED A B 1227. NEXT. WE HAVE
00:16:13.739 --> 00:16:17.943
LINE 64, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
00:16:18.010 --> 00:16:18.944
MY NAME IS MICHAEL LINEBACKER.
00:16:19.011 --> 00:16:20.179
I'M A RESIDENT OF SACRAMENTO
00:16:20.245 --> 00:16:22.648
COUNTY AND MEMBER OF C R P A.
00:16:22.715 --> 00:16:23.615
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSED. UM BILL
00:16:23.682 --> 00:16:28.754
1227. THANK YOU. WE HAVE A
00:16:28.821 --> 00:16:30.589
COUPLE MORE, WHICH IS GETTING
00:16:30.656 --> 00:16:37.863
LINE NUMBERS. NEXT WAVE LINE.
00:16:37.930 --> 00:16:42.234
83, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME
00:16:42.301 --> 00:16:43.902
IS SARAH HUME. I'M EXACTLY KELLY
00:16:43.969 --> 00:16:48.707
AND I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:16:48.774 --> 00:16:49.942
THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE LINE 84,
00:16:50.008 --> 00:16:52.978
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO, MANZIEL
00:16:53.045 --> 00:16:56.014
HUMAN FATHER, TOO. UH SECOND
00:16:56.081 --> 00:16:59.818
PRESIDENT ALSO OPPOSES POPE.
00:16:59.885 --> 00:17:07.059
THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE. EXCUSE
00:17:07.126 --> 00:17:12.431
ME. NEXT WAY OF LINE. 86, PLEASE
00:17:12.498 --> 00:17:18.670
GO AHEAD. MICHAEL FINLEY WITH
00:17:18.737 --> 00:17:19.705
THE NATIONAL SHOOTING SPORTS
00:17:19.772 --> 00:17:20.305
FOUNDATION. STRONG OPPOSITION.
00:17:20.372 --> 00:17:26.445
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
00:17:26.512 --> 00:17:32.017
IS ALL I HAVE IN QUÊ. THANK YOU
00:17:32.084 --> 00:17:34.153
THE ISSUE BACK TO COMMITTEE ANY
00:17:34.219 --> 00:17:37.689
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS? UM
00:17:37.756 --> 00:17:39.825
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVINE. THIS IS
00:17:39.892 --> 00:17:41.693
A REALLY DIFFICULT BUILT BILL,
00:17:41.760 --> 00:17:42.661
AND I KNOW YOU WOULDN'T HAVE
00:17:42.728 --> 00:17:45.364
TAKEN IT ON IF IT WASN'T, UH
00:17:45.431 --> 00:17:46.432
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT TO YOU, SO
00:17:46.498 --> 00:17:50.102
I APPRECIATE THAT. UM I DON'T
00:17:50.169 --> 00:17:51.703
YOU KNOW, FRANKLY, I DON'T THINK
00:17:51.770 --> 00:17:52.971
THIS IS THE TIME TO INCREASE
00:17:53.038 --> 00:17:54.773
TAXES ON CALIFORNIANS. FOR ALL
00:17:54.840 --> 00:17:56.775
OF THE REASONS THAT IF YOU TAKE
00:17:56.842 --> 00:17:59.411
A LOOK AT THE AT THE ECONOMY FOR
00:17:59.478 --> 00:18:01.480
ALL OF THE REASONS THAT ARE THAT
00:18:01.547 --> 00:18:02.815
ARE OUT THERE, BUT, UM SO IF
00:18:02.881 --> 00:18:04.716
WE'RE GOING TO ASK CALIFORNIANS,
00:18:04.783 --> 00:18:07.586
UM TO PAY MORE FOR SOMETHING
00:18:07.653 --> 00:18:08.821
THAT MONEY SHOULD GO INTO
00:18:08.887 --> 00:18:10.289
PROGRAMS THAT ACTUALLY HAVE A
00:18:10.355 --> 00:18:13.192
PROVEN RECORD TRACK RECORD. UM
00:18:13.258 --> 00:18:15.294
OF REDUCING VIOLENCE REACHING
00:18:15.360 --> 00:18:16.795
YOUNG PEOPLE IN REDUCING
00:18:16.862 --> 00:18:17.863
VIOLENCE BEFORE THEY COMMIT
00:18:17.930 --> 00:18:19.798
CRIMES. AND THE ONLY WAY TO DO
00:18:19.865 --> 00:18:23.535
THAT IS THROUGH TRIED AND TRUE
00:18:23.602 --> 00:18:25.404
PROGRAMS, WHICH IS WHY I
00:18:25.471 --> 00:18:27.239
SUGGESTED THE CALVI VIP PROGRAM
00:18:27.306 --> 00:18:29.508
BECAUSE IT'S BEEN AROUND FOR A
00:18:29.575 --> 00:18:31.276
SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF TIME. AND
00:18:31.343 --> 00:18:32.311
SO I THANK YOU FOR ACCEPTING THE
00:18:32.377 --> 00:18:35.814
AMENDMENT. UM TO ALLOCATE 50% OF
00:18:35.881 --> 00:18:37.349
THE FUNDS FROM THE TEXT TO THAT
00:18:37.416 --> 00:18:41.854
PROGRAM. UM AND, UM AND AS I
00:18:41.920 --> 00:18:43.555
SAID, IT REALLY IS THE ONLY
00:18:43.622 --> 00:18:44.957
PROGRAM WITH THE TWO PROVEN
00:18:45.023 --> 00:18:48.494
TRACK RECORD WITH THAT SAID, IF
00:18:48.560 --> 00:18:50.395
THIS IS AN ACTED, I WANT TO
00:18:50.462 --> 00:18:52.598
ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONSIDER OTHER
00:18:52.664 --> 00:18:53.298
PROGRAMS THAT HAVE A PROVEN
00:18:53.365 --> 00:18:56.735
TRACK RECORD. AND I AM. UM, I DO
00:18:56.802 --> 00:19:03.308
THINK THE. THE SUGGESTION OF
00:19:03.375 --> 00:19:05.077
USING RESOURCES FOR THE ARMED
00:19:05.143 --> 00:19:06.645
AND PROHIBITED FELON PROGRAM
00:19:06.712 --> 00:19:08.647
THAT IS A PROGRAM THAT NEEDS TO
00:19:08.714 --> 00:19:09.748
BE NEEDS TO RECEIVE MORE
00:19:09.815 --> 00:19:12.951
FUNDING. AND THAT WOULD MAKE. I
00:19:13.018 --> 00:19:14.419
THINK A TREMENDOUS DIFFERENCE IN
00:19:14.486 --> 00:19:16.421
VIOLENCE IN OUR COMMUNITY WITH
00:19:16.488 --> 00:19:17.656
THAT SAID I'M GOING TO SUPPORT
00:19:17.723 --> 00:19:19.291
THE BILL TODAY. UM, BUT I WANT
00:19:19.358 --> 00:19:20.459
TO CONTINUE TO HAVE DISCUSSIONS
00:19:20.526 --> 00:19:24.830
ABOUT UM, ABOUT IT. UM, BECAUSE
00:19:24.897 --> 00:19:28.667
I STILL FEEL THAT IT IT'S GOT
00:19:28.734 --> 00:19:31.069
SOME SOME ISSUES WITH IT, BUT
00:19:31.136 --> 00:19:33.038
WITH THAT I ALLOW YOU TO
00:19:33.105 --> 00:19:35.173
CONCLUDE WHEN WE HAVE A QUORUM
00:19:35.240 --> 00:19:36.575
WILL SEE IF WE HAVE A MOTION
00:19:36.642 --> 00:19:40.345
AND, UM TO MOVE ON IT. SO YOU
00:19:40.412 --> 00:19:47.953
MAY CONCLUDE. OH SO WE CAN TAKE
00:19:48.020 --> 00:19:49.454
UP. OKAY, GREAT. VERY GOOD. O
00:19:49.521 --> 00:19:51.623
THERE IS A MOTION SENATOR DRAWS
00:19:51.690 --> 00:19:53.258
A MOVED THE BELL WILL ALLOW YOU
00:19:53.325 --> 00:19:55.427
TO CONCLUDE. THANK YOU VERY
00:19:55.494 --> 00:19:57.396
MUCH. MADAM CHAIR AND SENATORS
00:19:57.462 --> 00:19:57.896
REALLY APPRECIATE THAT
00:19:57.963 --> 00:19:58.997
THOUGHTFUL CONVERSATION ABOUT
00:19:59.064 --> 00:20:01.600
THIS ALSO JUST THINKING ABOUT
00:20:01.667 --> 00:20:04.469
HOW WE REDUCE HARM, UH, FROM
00:20:04.536 --> 00:20:06.305
GUNS TO SOCIETY. IT'S SOMETHING
00:20:06.371 --> 00:20:09.241
THAT WE'RE STRUGGLING WITH. HERE
00:20:09.308 --> 00:20:12.244
IN CALIFORNIA NATIONALLY, SEEMS
00:20:12.311 --> 00:20:14.246
LIKE WE'RE STRUGGLING ON A ON A
00:20:14.313 --> 00:20:15.347
DAILY AND WEEKLY BASIS, SO SADLY
00:20:15.414 --> 00:20:17.883
AND SO TRAGICALLY CONTINUING TO
00:20:17.950 --> 00:20:19.318
DO THIS THROUGH THE YEARS, NEVER
00:20:19.384 --> 00:20:22.321
SEEMING TO FIND A WAY. TO SOLVE
00:20:22.387 --> 00:20:24.423
THIS PROBLEM, BUT HERE WE HAVE
00:20:24.489 --> 00:20:25.557
SOMETHING THAT WE KNOW CAUSES
00:20:25.624 --> 00:20:30.329
HARM. AND WE FOUND A WAY. TO TAX
00:20:30.395 --> 00:20:33.031
AND CREATE FEES ON OTHER THINGS
00:20:33.098 --> 00:20:34.099
THAT CREATE HARM, BUT SOMEHOW
00:20:34.166 --> 00:20:35.067
AREN'T AS SENSATIONALIZED THINGS
00:20:35.133 --> 00:20:40.038
LIKE MATTRESSES, TIRES,
00:20:40.105 --> 00:20:41.106
BATTERIES, CIGARETTES AND
00:20:41.173 --> 00:20:45.644
ALCOHOL HERE, WE KNOW HOW AWFUL
00:20:45.711 --> 00:20:47.045
. THE HARM IS FROM GUNS AND
00:20:47.112 --> 00:20:48.714
AMMUNITION, AND WE HAVE AN
00:20:48.780 --> 00:20:50.482
OPPORTUNITY TO DO SOMETHING HERE
00:20:50.549 --> 00:20:51.583
IN CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU SO
00:20:51.650 --> 00:20:53.452
MUCH. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
00:20:53.518 --> 00:20:54.953
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:20:55.020 --> 00:20:59.925
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MOTION IS
00:20:59.992 --> 00:21:01.560
DUE PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST,
00:21:01.627 --> 00:21:03.729
A MEANT IN RE REFERRED TO THE
00:21:03.795 --> 00:21:04.930
COMMITTEE AND PUBLIC SAFETY
00:21:04.997 --> 00:21:06.632
SENATORS CABALLERO ZERO I
00:21:06.698 --> 00:21:10.469
NIELSEN SO. SO I HERZBERG
00:21:10.535 --> 00:21:17.643
WIENER. VOTERS 2 TO 0. WE'RE
00:21:17.709 --> 00:21:18.910
GOING TO PUT THAT ON CALL AND,
00:21:18.977 --> 00:21:21.113
UM, CATCH UP WITH THE MISSING
00:21:21.179 --> 00:21:22.347
MEMBERS. SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:21:22.414 --> 00:21:24.983
THANK YOU. APPRECIATE IT. NEXT
00:21:25.050 --> 00:21:26.718
ON OUR AGENDA IS FILE ITEM
00:21:26.785 --> 00:21:30.088
NUMBER FIVE A B 2012 88 BY
00:21:30.155 --> 00:21:30.589
SENATE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:21:30.656 --> 00:21:37.396
QUIRK-SILVA WELCOME. GOOD
00:21:37.462 --> 00:21:47.506
MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBER. I'M HERE TO PRESENT A B 12 88
00:21:47.572 --> 00:21:48.974
. FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS, THE
00:21:49.041 --> 00:21:50.175
STATE BUDGET HAS INCREASED ITS
00:21:50.242 --> 00:21:52.077
INVESTMENT IN LOW INCOME HOUSING
00:21:52.144 --> 00:21:54.413
TAX CREDIT PROGRAM BY $500
00:21:54.479 --> 00:21:57.315
MILLION PER YEAR. A B 12 88
00:21:57.382 --> 00:21:59.951
GIVES US A BIGGER BANG FOR THE
00:22:00.018 --> 00:22:01.319
BUCK AND MAXIMIZES OUR
00:22:01.386 --> 00:22:03.555
PRODUCTION OF AFFORDABLE HOMES
00:22:03.622 --> 00:22:05.190
BY ALLOWING THE TAX CREDIT
00:22:05.257 --> 00:22:07.426
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE TO PAIR THE
00:22:07.492 --> 00:22:09.494
STATE TAX CREDITS WITH EITHER A
00:22:09.561 --> 00:22:13.832
4% OR 9% FEDERAL CREDITS AS
00:22:13.899 --> 00:22:15.867
CONDITIONS BEST DICTATE, AND
00:22:15.934 --> 00:22:18.103
2019, CALIFORNIA PAIRED THE
00:22:18.170 --> 00:22:20.839
STATE CREDITS WITH 4% FEDERAL
00:22:20.906 --> 00:22:22.641
CREDITS BECAUSE THE 4% FEDERAL
00:22:22.708 --> 00:22:24.042
CREDIT WERE UNDERSUBSCRIBED. AT
00:22:24.109 --> 00:22:29.314
THAT TIME. YET THINGS HAVE
00:22:29.381 --> 00:22:32.217
DRAMATICALLY CHANGED AS WE KNOW
00:22:32.284 --> 00:22:35.487
NOW. 4% FOR FEDERAL CREDITS ARE
00:22:35.554 --> 00:22:38.123
NOW OVER SUBSCRIBED. 321 AND
00:22:38.190 --> 00:22:39.424
FEDERAL RULES DO NOT ALLOW US TO
00:22:39.491 --> 00:22:42.227
EXPAND THAT PROGRAM. HOWEVER
00:22:42.294 --> 00:22:44.429
THERE IS NO FEDERAL BARRIER TO
00:22:44.496 --> 00:22:47.332
EXPANDING THE 9% FEDERAL CREDIT
00:22:47.399 --> 00:22:50.335
PROGRAM. THEREFORE IF UNDER THE
00:22:50.402 --> 00:22:51.336
THESE CONDITIONS REPAIR THE
00:22:51.403 --> 00:22:52.604
STATE CREDITS WITH 9% FEDERAL
00:22:52.671 --> 00:22:55.540
CREDITS WE CAN FUND ADDITIONAL
00:22:55.607 --> 00:22:59.711
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. I'LL JUST
00:22:59.778 --> 00:23:01.346
PAUSE HERE TO LET YOU KNOW THAT
00:23:01.413 --> 00:23:04.449
AS WE HAVE SPENT QUITE A LONG
00:23:04.516 --> 00:23:05.817
TIME TALKING ABOUT OUR HOUSING
00:23:05.884 --> 00:23:10.355
CRAP. CRISIS THIS IS ACTUALLY
00:23:10.422 --> 00:23:12.090
ONE SOLUTION TO GETTING MORE
00:23:12.157 --> 00:23:16.361
AFFORDABLE HOMES ONLINE. A B 12
00:23:16.428 --> 00:23:17.696
88 DOES NOT INCREASE TAXES AND
00:23:17.763 --> 00:23:19.397
ANYWAY BECAUSE THE AMOUNT OF
00:23:19.464 --> 00:23:21.500
CREDITS IS FIXED IN THE BUDGET
00:23:21.566 --> 00:23:24.936
EACH YEAR. THIS BILL SIMPLY IS
00:23:25.003 --> 00:23:27.405
MORE EFFECTIVE AND IMPACTFUL WAY
00:23:27.472 --> 00:23:29.841
FOR CALIFORNIA TO PLAY TO DEPLOY
00:23:29.908 --> 00:23:31.343
ITS SCARCE, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:23:31.409 --> 00:23:34.179
RESOURCES WITH ME TODAY TO SPEAK
00:23:34.246 --> 00:23:35.347
IN SUPPORT OF A B 12 88 IS
00:23:35.413 --> 00:23:39.117
MEGAN. TOKEN NAGA HOUSING
00:23:39.184 --> 00:23:40.986
FINANCE SPECIALIST WITH THE
00:23:41.052 --> 00:23:41.586
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
00:23:41.653 --> 00:23:45.624
CORPORATION. YOU VERY MUCH.
00:23:45.690 --> 00:23:50.395
MEGAN TOKUNAGA WELCOME. JUST LET
00:23:50.462 --> 00:23:52.731
ME ASK IS YOUR SECOND LEAD
00:23:52.798 --> 00:23:54.366
WITNESS IN SUPPORT GOING TO
00:23:54.432 --> 00:23:57.602
TESTIFY TODAY? NO, OKAY. WELCOME
00:23:57.669 --> 00:23:59.638
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:23:59.704 --> 00:24:00.739
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS MEGAN
00:24:00.806 --> 00:24:01.406
TOKUNAGA ME HOUSING FINANCE
00:24:01.473 --> 00:24:02.974
SPECIALIST ON THE FINANCIAL
00:24:03.041 --> 00:24:03.942
CONSULTING TEAM OF THE
00:24:04.009 --> 00:24:04.676
CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA HOUSING
00:24:04.743 --> 00:24:05.644
PARTNERSHIP, AND WE'RE PROUD
00:24:05.710 --> 00:24:08.013
SPONSOR OF THIS MEASURE. AND
00:24:08.079 --> 00:24:09.514
FEDERAL AND STATE LAW INCOME
00:24:09.581 --> 00:24:10.882
HOUSING TAX CREDITS ARE THE
00:24:10.949 --> 00:24:12.284
BASIC BUILDING BLOCKS WITH WHICH
00:24:12.350 --> 00:24:14.019
MOST AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING
00:24:14.085 --> 00:24:16.488
IS FINANCED. A B 12 88 INCREASES
00:24:16.555 --> 00:24:17.689
THE EFFICIENCY OF THE TAX CREDIT
00:24:17.756 --> 00:24:19.991
PROGRAM IN A NUMBER OF WAYS.
00:24:20.058 --> 00:24:22.093
FIRST IT MAXIMIZES THE NUMBER OF
00:24:22.160 --> 00:24:23.128
NEW, AFFORDABLE HOMES THAT CAN
00:24:23.195 --> 00:24:24.596
BE BUILT WITH THE ADDITIONAL 500
00:24:24.663 --> 00:24:26.398
MILLION IN STATE TAX CREDITS
00:24:26.464 --> 00:24:27.666
THAT LEGISLATURE HAS AUTHORIZED
00:24:27.732 --> 00:24:30.869
SINCE 2019. IT ALLOWS THESE
00:24:30.936 --> 00:24:32.671
CREDITS TO PAIR WITH EITHER THE
00:24:32.737 --> 00:24:35.140
9% OR 4% FEDERAL PROGRAM AS THE
00:24:35.207 --> 00:24:35.640
CONDITIONS BEST DICTATE,
00:24:35.707 --> 00:24:37.175
PROVIDING THE BEST BANG FOR THE
00:24:37.242 --> 00:24:39.644
BUCK. SECOND IT ALLOWS INVESTORS
00:24:39.711 --> 00:24:41.413
WHO BY THE STATE CREDITS TO
00:24:41.479 --> 00:24:42.781
BEGIN CLAIMING THEM IN THE YEAR
00:24:42.848 --> 00:24:44.349
THAT THE DEVELOPMENT IS OCCUPIED
00:24:44.416 --> 00:24:45.917
, WHICH INCREASES THE PRICE THAT
00:24:45.984 --> 00:24:47.986
INVESTORS WILL PAY AND REDUCES
00:24:48.053 --> 00:24:49.120
THE AMOUNT OF CREDITS THAT EACH
00:24:49.187 --> 00:24:49.754
PROJECT NEEDS. THIS IS
00:24:49.821 --> 00:24:50.922
CONSISTENT WITH THE RULES FOR
00:24:50.989 --> 00:24:53.592
THE FEDERAL TAX CREDITS. FINALLY
00:24:53.658 --> 00:24:55.126
IT GRANTS THE TAX CREDIT
00:24:55.193 --> 00:24:56.094
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE, THE
00:24:56.161 --> 00:24:58.763
AUTHORITY TO SET AND REVISED
00:24:58.830 --> 00:25:00.065
DEADLINES FOR CONSTRUCTION TO
00:25:00.131 --> 00:25:00.599
BETTER ACCOUNT FOR MARKET
00:25:00.665 --> 00:25:04.836
CONDITIONS AND DISASTERS. 12 88
00:25:04.903 --> 00:25:05.704
WILL MAKE A CRITICAL, AFFORDABLE
00:25:05.770 --> 00:25:07.272
HOUSING PROGRAM EVEN MORE
00:25:07.339 --> 00:25:08.240
EFFICIENT, TRANSPARENT AND
00:25:08.306 --> 00:25:10.275
EFFECTIVE WITH THAT I THANK YOU
00:25:10.342 --> 00:25:11.343
AND HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
00:25:11.409 --> 00:25:12.944
QUESTIONS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:25:13.011 --> 00:25:13.979
APPRECIATE YOUR TESTIMONY HERE
00:25:14.045 --> 00:25:16.348
TODAY. AND TO SEE IF THERE IS
00:25:16.414 --> 00:25:18.550
ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2200 THAT
00:25:18.617 --> 00:25:22.120
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY. SEEING
00:25:22.187 --> 00:25:23.054
THEN WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:25:23.121 --> 00:25:25.423
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS
00:25:25.490 --> 00:25:26.925
THERE ANY BUDDY ON THE
00:25:26.992 --> 00:25:28.493
TELECONFERENCE LINE THAT WOULD
00:25:28.560 --> 00:25:30.395
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A
00:25:30.462 --> 00:25:34.532
B 12 88? TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
00:25:34.599 --> 00:25:36.534
A B 12 88, PLEASE PRESS ONE,
00:25:36.601 --> 00:25:42.374
THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. AND
00:25:42.440 --> 00:25:48.613
SKIN THAT IS 10 ON YOUR PHONE.
00:25:48.680 --> 00:25:50.949
AND I HAVE NO ONE IN. Q. THANK
00:25:51.016 --> 00:25:51.983
YOU VERY MUCH HAVE ONE PERSON
00:25:52.050 --> 00:26:09.334
WHO JUST QUEUED UP ONE MOMENT.
00:26:09.401 --> 00:26:27.218
AND FIRST WE WILL GO TO. T<c.cyan>.</c>
00:26:27.285 --> 00:26:30.655
WE'LL GO TO LINE 95. AND THEY
00:26:30.722 --> 00:26:33.959
REMOVED THEMSELVES FROM QUÊ.
00:26:34.025 --> 00:26:36.861
LIKE 95. IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN
00:26:36.928 --> 00:26:37.929
SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
00:26:37.996 --> 00:26:46.705
ZERO. I HAVE NO ONE IN QUÊ. VERY
00:26:46.771 --> 00:26:48.239
GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:26:48.306 --> 00:26:50.342
OPPOSITION AND WE HAVE NO LEAD
00:26:50.408 --> 00:26:52.510
OPPOSITION WITNESSES LISTED SO
00:26:52.577 --> 00:26:53.445
WE'LL CHECK AND SEE IF THERE'S
00:26:53.511 --> 00:26:55.213
ANYBODY IN ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD
00:26:55.280 --> 00:26:56.314
LIKE AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK IN
00:26:56.381 --> 00:27:03.221
OPPOSITION. SAYING THAT.
00:27:03.288 --> 00:27:04.489
APOLOGIES WERE TESTIFIED, THREW
00:27:04.556 --> 00:27:06.257
ME OFF COREY SMITH ON BEHALF OF
00:27:06.324 --> 00:27:07.792
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION IN
00:27:07.859 --> 00:27:09.828
SUPPORT OF 12 88. THANK YOU VERY
00:27:09.894 --> 00:27:10.962
MUCH. THANK YOU. IS THERE
00:27:11.029 --> 00:27:12.797
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
00:27:12.864 --> 00:27:16.368
IN OPPOSITION? OPPOSITION SEEING
00:27:16.434 --> 00:27:17.802
NONE WILL CHECK THE
00:27:17.869 --> 00:27:19.270
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:27:19.337 --> 00:27:20.905
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
00:27:20.972 --> 00:27:22.107
LANE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:27:22.173 --> 00:27:25.310
IN OPPOSITION? TO SPEAK IN
00:27:25.377 --> 00:27:27.145
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL. PLEASE
00:27:27.212 --> 00:27:28.913
PRESS ONE DÂN ZERO ON YOUR
00:27:28.980 --> 00:27:30.949
PHONE. AND ONE MOMENT WHILE WE
00:27:31.016 --> 00:27:42.994
GET LINE NUMBERS.
00:27:43.061 --> 00:27:44.295
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO THE
00:27:44.362 --> 00:27:46.998
BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE, THEN 01
00:27:47.065 --> 00:27:58.376
TIME. AND I HAVE NO ONE IN QUÊ.
00:27:58.443 --> 00:28:00.478
VERY GOOD WILL BRING THE MATTER
00:28:00.545 --> 00:28:02.614
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE. UM
00:28:02.680 --> 00:28:04.349
WELCOME, SENATOR NIELSEN. IS%
00:28:04.416 --> 00:28:05.750
THERE ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
00:28:05.817 --> 00:28:12.190
ON THIS BILL? VERY GOOD. THERE
00:28:12.257 --> 00:28:14.959
IS A MOTION BY SENATOR DURAZO.
00:28:15.026 --> 00:28:18.997
ASSEMBLY MEMBER. UH. I
00:28:19.064 --> 00:28:19.964
UNDERSTAND YOU'RE GOING TO BE
00:28:20.031 --> 00:28:21.666
TAKING THE AMENDMENT IN REGARDS
00:28:21.733 --> 00:28:23.835
TO INSERTING A FIVE YEAR STATUTE
00:28:23.902 --> 00:28:25.837
OF LIMITATIONS. OKAY, VERY GOOD.
00:28:25.904 --> 00:28:27.672
AND SO THE MOTION IS WITH THE
00:28:27.739 --> 00:28:33.511
AMENDMENT. CORRECT. OKAY? SO
00:28:33.578 --> 00:28:36.247
THERE IS A MOTION DO PASS AS
00:28:36.314 --> 00:28:37.849
AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMENDMENT WE
00:28:37.916 --> 00:28:39.250
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:28:39.317 --> 00:28:39.751
APPROPRIATIONS. YOU MAY
00:28:39.818 --> 00:28:43.621
CONCLUDE. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:28:43.688 --> 00:28:45.590
AN I VOTE. VERY GOOD. PLEASE
00:28:45.657 --> 00:28:47.425
CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
00:28:47.492 --> 00:28:52.764
CABALLERO. CABALLERO I. NILSSON
00:28:52.831 --> 00:28:56.234
NILSSON. I DURAZO. SO I HERZBERG
00:28:56.301 --> 00:29:03.007
WIENER. THE BILL HAS SUFFICIENT
00:29:03.074 --> 00:29:04.843
VOTES, BUT WE'RE GOING TO PUT IT
00:29:04.909 --> 00:29:05.977
ON COUGH FOR THE MISSING
00:29:06.044 --> 00:29:07.712
MEMBERS. SO WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
00:29:07.779 --> 00:29:09.380
ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER SIX,
00:29:09.447 --> 00:29:10.615
WHICH IS, UH, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:29:10.682 --> 00:29:12.650
QUIRKS OF BILL AS WELL. A B 27
00:29:12.717 --> 00:29:16.921
05. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:29:16.988 --> 00:29:19.257
MEMBERS FIRST. I DO WANT TO
00:29:19.324 --> 00:29:20.859
THANK THE COMMITTEE AND THE
00:29:20.925 --> 00:29:22.894
CHAIR FOR WORKING DILIGENTLY
00:29:22.961 --> 00:29:25.296
WITH US ON THIS BILL, AND WE ARE
00:29:25.363 --> 00:29:26.364
COMMITTED TO WORKING WITH THE
00:29:26.431 --> 00:29:29.400
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE ON THE
00:29:29.467 --> 00:29:30.502
PROPOSED AMENDMENT. FRAMEWORK
00:29:30.568 --> 00:29:34.506
ASSEMBLY BILL 27 05 WILL REQUIRE
00:29:34.572 --> 00:29:36.774
ADDITIONAL ROBUST WILDFIRE
00:29:36.841 --> 00:29:39.010
PROTECTIONS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR
00:29:39.077 --> 00:29:41.112
FUTURE MASTER PLANNED
00:29:41.179 --> 00:29:42.413
COMMUNITIES THAT INCORPORATE
00:29:42.480 --> 00:29:42.914
UPDATED MODERN BUILDING
00:29:42.981 --> 00:29:47.018
STANDARDS. ACCORDING TO A RECENT
00:29:47.085 --> 00:29:49.254
ANALYSIS OF PROPERTY LOST DATA
00:29:49.320 --> 00:29:50.788
FROM THE OFFICE OF THE STATE
00:29:50.855 --> 00:29:52.957
FIRE MARSHAL ON AN AVERAGE FOR
00:29:53.024 --> 00:29:55.360
THE NINE WORST PROPERTY LOSS.
00:29:55.426 --> 00:29:58.396
WILDFIRES APPROXIMATELY 1% OF
00:29:58.463 --> 00:29:59.998
THE HOMES AND APARTMENTS
00:30:00.064 --> 00:30:01.900
DESTROYED, DAMAGED OR AFFECTED
00:30:01.966 --> 00:30:03.334
WERE NEW DWELLING UNITS. THOSE
00:30:03.401 --> 00:30:09.574
BUILT AFTER JANUARY 1ST 2010. IN
00:30:09.641 --> 00:30:10.875
ORDER TO ADDRESS CALIFORNIANS
00:30:10.942 --> 00:30:13.745
HOW HOUSING SHORTAGE WE NEED TO
00:30:13.811 --> 00:30:15.046
REDUCE INEQUITIES AND
00:30:15.113 --> 00:30:16.281
HOMEOWNERSHIP RATES, REDUCE
00:30:16.347 --> 00:30:17.315
HOMELESSNESS AND PROTECT THE
00:30:17.382 --> 00:30:20.885
HOME OWNERS FOR FROM CLIMATE
00:30:20.952 --> 00:30:22.854
CHANGE. CALIFORNIA NEEDS TO
00:30:22.921 --> 00:30:24.355
BUILD MORE HOUSING ACROSS ALL
00:30:24.422 --> 00:30:26.891
LEVELS OF AFFORDABILITY. WE NEED
00:30:26.958 --> 00:30:28.459
OPTIONS TO BUILD MODERN,
00:30:28.526 --> 00:30:30.328
RESILIENT HOMES, INCLUDING
00:30:30.395 --> 00:30:31.796
INCREASING OUR AFFORDABLE
00:30:31.863 --> 00:30:33.831
HOUSING STOCK BY ALSO MAKING
00:30:33.898 --> 00:30:35.633
SURE THOSE WHO LIVE AND WORK IN
00:30:35.700 --> 00:30:36.868
OUR COMMUNITIES ARE PROTECTED
00:30:36.935 --> 00:30:40.071
AND SAFE. WITH ME TODAY TO
00:30:40.138 --> 00:30:41.506
PROVIDE TESTIMONY AND SUPPORT
00:30:41.573 --> 00:30:43.474
AND TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS FROM
00:30:43.541 --> 00:30:45.977
THE COMMITTEE. IS MR MICHAEL
00:30:46.044 --> 00:30:48.646
GUNNING, SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT
00:30:48.713 --> 00:30:49.681
OF THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
00:30:49.747 --> 00:30:52.083
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION. AND
00:30:52.150 --> 00:30:54.886
SPONSORS OF A B 27 05 AND MR
00:30:54.953 --> 00:30:59.857
RUBIN. GRILL HAVE A HELL OF
00:30:59.924 --> 00:31:03.127
SORRY. I SHOULD KNOW THAT FORMER
00:31:03.194 --> 00:31:04.562
CALIFORNIA STATE FIRE MARSHAL
00:31:04.629 --> 00:31:08.032
AND FORMER DIRECTOR OF CAL FIRE
00:31:08.099 --> 00:31:09.067
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH IF
00:31:09.133 --> 00:31:12.971
WE COULD HAVE MR GUNNING OR MR
00:31:13.037 --> 00:31:14.272
JEHOVAH, WHICH WHOEVER YOU WOULD
00:31:14.339 --> 00:31:18.176
LIKE TO THE FIRST GOOD MORNING.
00:31:18.243 --> 00:31:22.146
MY NAME'S RUBEN GROVER. AND I'M
00:31:22.213 --> 00:31:23.314
WITH FIRE CHIEF .COM LLC,
00:31:23.381 --> 00:31:26.551
REPRESENTING FIVE POINT I AM THE
00:31:26.618 --> 00:31:27.685
FORMER CALIFORNIA STATE FIRE
00:31:27.752 --> 00:31:28.620
MARSHAL AND DIRECTOR OF
00:31:28.686 --> 00:31:31.289
HELLFIRE. BACK WHEN I WAS STATE
00:31:31.356 --> 00:31:33.157
FIRE MARSHAL, WE FORMED AN
00:31:33.224 --> 00:31:35.026
ADVISORY COMMITTEE. BUILDING AND
00:31:35.093 --> 00:31:38.062
FIRE OFFICIALS, SCIENTISTS AND
00:31:38.129 --> 00:31:38.496
BUSINESS AND PUBLIC
00:31:38.563 --> 00:31:42.400
STAKEHOLDERS. AND WE DEVELOPED
00:31:42.467 --> 00:31:43.468
FOR THE FIRST TIME,
00:31:43.534 --> 00:31:46.004
SCIENTIFICALLY BASED CRITERIA.
00:31:46.070 --> 00:31:46.537
FRUSTRATIONS BUILT IN THE
00:31:46.604 --> 00:31:49.440
WILDLAND URBAN INTERFACE. IN
00:31:49.507 --> 00:31:50.541
CHAPTER SEVEN A OF THE
00:31:50.608 --> 00:31:54.345
CALIFORNIA BUILDING CODE. IT WAS
00:31:54.412 --> 00:31:55.480
THE FIRST TIME THERE WERE
00:31:55.546 --> 00:31:56.547
STANDARDS FOR IGNITION RESISTANT
00:31:56.614 --> 00:31:59.384
EXTERIORS. AND WE ALSO ADDRESS
00:31:59.450 --> 00:32:00.485
ISSUES SUCH AS WINDOWS EVE,
00:32:00.551 --> 00:32:03.454
CITING AND DECKING IT WAS ALSO
00:32:03.521 --> 00:32:05.290
THE FIRST TIME ACTUALLY THAT
00:32:05.356 --> 00:32:06.924
MEMBERS WERE ADDRESSED. AND
00:32:06.991 --> 00:32:09.394
MEMBERS IS BY FAR THE LARGEST
00:32:09.460 --> 00:32:10.828
REASON THAT FIRES DO SPREAD IN A
00:32:10.895 --> 00:32:13.498
WHILE AND URBAN INTER FIX. WHEN
00:32:13.564 --> 00:32:15.333
I WAS DIRECTOR OF CAL FIRE, WE
00:32:15.400 --> 00:32:16.768
INCREASE DEFENSIBLE SPACE
00:32:16.834 --> 00:32:20.271
REQUIREMENTS FROM 50 TO 100 FT.
00:32:20.338 --> 00:32:21.906
SO NOW WE HAD A COMBINATION OF
00:32:21.973 --> 00:32:23.908
SPACE AND DEFENSIBLE SPACE.
00:32:23.975 --> 00:32:27.745
PROTECTS THE SPREAD OF FIRE FROM
00:32:27.812 --> 00:32:28.880
DIRECT FLAME IMPINGEMENT FROM
00:32:28.946 --> 00:32:31.249
RADIANT HEAT AND SO FORTH. BUT
00:32:31.316 --> 00:32:33.284
THE STRUCTURE ITSELF HAS TO BE
00:32:33.351 --> 00:32:34.152
PROTECTED FROM MEMBERS, WHICH
00:32:34.218 --> 00:32:36.187
CAN FLY A MILE IN HIGH FIRE
00:32:36.254 --> 00:32:43.294
THINGS. SO UM 27 05. INCLUDES
00:32:43.361 --> 00:32:45.797
ALL THE FIRE PROTECTION MEASURES
00:32:45.863 --> 00:32:46.431
NECESSARY TO SURVIVE WILDFIRES
00:32:46.497 --> 00:32:50.401
IN A MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY.
00:32:50.468 --> 00:32:51.969
THE STATE FIRE MARSHAL'S OFFICE
00:32:52.036 --> 00:32:53.971
OWNED STATISTICS HAS SHOWN AND
00:32:54.038 --> 00:32:55.173
THIS IS NOT REPORTED IN THE NEWS
00:32:55.239 --> 00:32:57.475
VERY OFTEN. BIT OF ALL THE FIRES
00:32:57.542 --> 00:32:59.310
THAT HAVE OCCURRED, AND YOU SEE
00:32:59.377 --> 00:33:01.112
HIM IN THE NEWS LIKE EVERY YEAR.
00:33:01.179 --> 00:33:02.847
THERE HAS NOT BEEN A SIGNIFICANT
00:33:02.914 --> 00:33:04.749
OR AN ISSUE IN A SINGLE LOSS OF
00:33:04.816 --> 00:33:06.551
THE STRUCTURE. IN A MASTER
00:33:06.617 --> 00:33:08.252
PLANNED COMMUNITY BUILT TO THE
00:33:08.319 --> 00:33:09.420
STANDARDS OF 27 05. CHAPTER
00:33:09.487 --> 00:33:14.058
SEVEN A 27 OH, FIVE GOES FARTHER
00:33:14.125 --> 00:33:15.193
THAN CHAPTER SEVEN AM DEFENSIBLE
00:33:15.259 --> 00:33:18.663
SPACE. BY PROVIDING PROVISIONS
00:33:18.730 --> 00:33:20.665
FOR GREEN BUILDING. GOOD FIRE
00:33:20.732 --> 00:33:21.566
ACCESS GOOD WATER SUPPLY GOOD
00:33:21.632 --> 00:33:26.671
EVACUATION MEASURES. UM. SO
00:33:26.738 --> 00:33:28.072
MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITIES BUILT
00:33:28.139 --> 00:33:30.441
TO CHAPTER 2 27 05 STANDARDS ARE
00:33:30.508 --> 00:33:32.677
FIRE SAFE THEY CAN ACTUALLY
00:33:32.744 --> 00:33:34.912
SERVE AS AREAS OF REFUGE FOR
00:33:34.979 --> 00:33:36.247
HOMES THAT ARE ALREADY IN THE
00:33:36.314 --> 00:33:37.415
AREA WHERE PEOPLE ARE BEING
00:33:37.482 --> 00:33:38.149
EVACUATED. AND THEY'RE LOOKING
00:33:38.216 --> 00:33:41.886
FOR A PLACE OF SAFETY. AS A AS
00:33:41.953 --> 00:33:43.121
AN INCIDENT COMMANDER. I
00:33:43.187 --> 00:33:43.988
WOULDN'T HAVE ANY PROBLEMS,
00:33:44.055 --> 00:33:45.690
SETTING UP A COMMAND POST IN THE
00:33:45.757 --> 00:33:46.858
MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY BUILT A
00:33:46.924 --> 00:33:50.061
CHAPTER 78. INTO PERSONALIZE IT
00:33:50.128 --> 00:33:52.597
EVEN MORE AS A PERSON WITH 36
00:33:52.663 --> 00:33:53.464
YEARS OF FIRE EXPERIENCE,
00:33:53.531 --> 00:33:54.298
INCLUDING WILD LAND
00:33:54.365 --> 00:33:57.435
FIREFIGHTING. I WOULD ONLY BE
00:33:57.502 --> 00:34:00.638
WILLING TO MOVE MY FAMILY. INTO
00:34:00.705 --> 00:34:01.773
A MASTER PLANNED COMMUNITY BUILT
00:34:01.839 --> 00:34:03.508
TO THE STANDARDS OF 27 05. THANK
00:34:03.574 --> 00:34:09.647
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:34:09.714 --> 00:34:11.349
MORNING MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
00:34:11.416 --> 00:34:12.717
MICHAEL GUNNING WITH THE
00:34:12.784 --> 00:34:13.551
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
00:34:13.618 --> 00:34:15.286
ASSOCIATION. IT'S HARD TO FOLLOW
00:34:15.353 --> 00:34:17.255
THE CHIEF. HE KIND OF LAID OUT
00:34:17.321 --> 00:34:19.724
ALL THE IDEAS THERE THAT ARE IN
00:34:19.791 --> 00:34:20.558
THE BILL, BUT CERTAINLY WANT TO
00:34:20.625 --> 00:34:22.660
COMMEND YOU AND THE STAFF ARE
00:34:22.727 --> 00:34:23.428
WORKING WITH US. WE DO BELIEVE
00:34:23.494 --> 00:34:25.963
THAT C B A AND HOUSING FOR ALL
00:34:26.030 --> 00:34:27.765
AND THAT MEANS YOU KNOW WHETHER
00:34:27.832 --> 00:34:29.734
IT'S SHELTER HOUSING WITH SOME
00:34:29.801 --> 00:34:30.868
OF OUR MEMBERS BUILD OR THE
00:34:30.935 --> 00:34:32.036
FIRST TIME HOUSING OR CUSTOM
00:34:32.103 --> 00:34:33.671
HOUSING. AND SO WITH 27. OH,
00:34:33.738 --> 00:34:35.239
FIVE. WE REALLY LOOKED TO
00:34:35.306 --> 00:34:36.741
INCREASE WHERE AND HOW WE CAN
00:34:36.808 --> 00:34:38.709
BUILD AND WE THINK IS RUBEN IS
00:34:38.776 --> 00:34:40.611
OUTLINED THAT WITH THESE MASTER
00:34:40.678 --> 00:34:41.813
PLANNED COMMUNITIES, WE CAN
00:34:41.879 --> 00:34:43.548
BUILD RESILIENT FIRE SAFE
00:34:43.614 --> 00:34:46.050
COMMUNITIES IN THESE AREAS WHICH
00:34:46.117 --> 00:34:46.684
CAN ALLOW FOR HOUSING FOR ALSO
00:34:46.751 --> 00:34:48.953
WITH THAT. URGENT. I VOTE AND
00:34:49.020 --> 00:34:51.823
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:34:51.889 --> 00:34:53.090
IS THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM
00:34:53.157 --> 00:34:55.693
2200 THAT WOULD LIKE AN
00:34:55.760 --> 00:34:56.227
OPPORTUNITY TO TESTIFY AND
00:34:56.294 --> 00:34:57.628
SUPPORT. SEEING NONE WILL MOVE
00:34:57.695 --> 00:34:59.464
ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
00:34:59.530 --> 00:35:00.932
MADAM MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
00:35:00.998 --> 00:35:02.333
CHECK TO SEE IF THE IF ANYONE IS
00:35:02.400 --> 00:35:04.235
ON THE LINE TO TESTIFY AND
00:35:04.302 --> 00:35:08.272
SUPPORT OKAY, TESTIFY AND
00:35:08.339 --> 00:35:10.842
SUPPORT OF A B 27 05, PLEASE
00:35:10.908 --> 00:35:14.045
PRESS 10 ON YOUR PHONE. WE WILL
00:35:14.111 --> 00:35:15.947
START WITH LINE. 95, PLEASE GO
00:35:16.013 --> 00:35:20.451
AHEAD. MORE MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
00:35:20.518 --> 00:35:22.086
OF THE COMMITTEE ADAM RAGA ON
00:35:22.153 --> 00:35:23.120
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER
00:35:23.187 --> 00:35:24.288
OF COMMERCE AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:35:24.355 --> 00:35:28.526
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:35:28.593 --> 00:35:30.995
THANK YOU. AND NEXT, WE WILL GO
00:35:31.062 --> 00:35:38.603
TO WE'RE GETTING LINE NUMBERS.
00:35:38.669 --> 00:35:39.804
NEXT WE WILL GO TO LINE 97.
00:35:39.871 --> 00:35:43.774
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
00:35:43.841 --> 00:35:45.109
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS ASHLEY
00:35:45.176 --> 00:35:49.080
JOHN HAPPENED WITH ME AND STRONG
00:35:49.146 --> 00:35:50.281
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. CONFERENCE
00:35:50.348 --> 00:35:56.621
LINE. AND NEXT WE HAVE LINE 23,
00:35:56.687 --> 00:36:01.225
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MADAMCHAIR AND
00:36:01.292 --> 00:36:03.160
MEMBERS VANESSA CHAVEZ ON BEHALF
00:36:03.227 --> 00:36:04.295
OF THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:36:04.362 --> 00:36:05.329
WELL, TOURISM SUPPORT. THANK
00:36:05.396 --> 00:36:15.439
YOU. GIVE YOU AND NEXT WE HAVE.
00:36:15.506 --> 00:36:20.111
BRIAN 31, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
00:36:20.177 --> 00:36:21.512
YOURSELF A CHECKER WITH THE LOS
00:36:21.579 --> 00:36:23.314
ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
00:36:23.381 --> 00:36:30.688
AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU, AND THAT
00:36:30.755 --> 00:36:32.557
IS ALL THAT I HAVE IN. Q VERY
00:36:32.623 --> 00:36:36.561
GOOD. THERE IT WAS LATE SUPPORT
00:36:36.627 --> 00:36:37.762
OUTSIDE OF THE CONFERENCE ROOM.
00:36:37.828 --> 00:36:39.664
SO I WANT TO INVITE YOU TO
00:36:39.730 --> 00:36:42.133
PLEASE COME UP. THANK YOU SO
00:36:42.199 --> 00:36:44.101
MUCH LIKE I SEE UKRAINE'S HERE
00:36:44.168 --> 00:36:45.202
ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA. UM, BE
00:36:45.269 --> 00:36:47.772
IN SUPPORT IF AMENDED TO
00:36:47.838 --> 00:36:52.677
INCREASE THE ACTUAL. INPUT THAT
00:36:52.743 --> 00:36:54.478
THAT WE CAN HAVE IN THE ARENA
00:36:54.545 --> 00:36:56.113
PROCESS. I KNOW THAT THAT'S A
00:36:56.180 --> 00:36:57.348
CONVERSATION THAT'S GOING TO
00:36:57.415 --> 00:36:58.082
CONTINUE. WE REALLY APPRECIATE
00:36:58.149 --> 00:36:59.350
THE AUTHOR FOR ALL THE WORK THAT
00:36:59.417 --> 00:37:01.752
SHE'S DOING. WE'VE HAD GREAT
00:37:01.819 --> 00:37:02.620
CONVERSATIONS WITH BOTH HER
00:37:02.687 --> 00:37:03.554
OFFICE AND THE SPONSORS AND LOOK
00:37:03.621 --> 00:37:04.589
FORWARD TO ADDITIONAL
00:37:04.655 --> 00:37:05.222
DISCUSSIONS. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:37:05.289 --> 00:37:07.124
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE
00:37:07.191 --> 00:37:11.896
IN ROOM 2200. OKAY WE'RE GOING
00:37:11.963 --> 00:37:13.464
TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION. WE DO
00:37:13.531 --> 00:37:15.299
NOT HAVE ANY LEAD, OPPOSITION
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:17.368
NOTED. IS THERE ANYONE IN ROOM
00:37:17.435 --> 00:37:19.370
2200 THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:37:19.437 --> 00:37:23.040
OPPOSITION. SAYING THEN WE'LL
00:37:23.107 --> 00:37:24.709
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:37:24.775 --> 00:37:25.309
LINE. MADAM MODERATOR, IF YOU
00:37:25.376 --> 00:37:26.644
COULD PROMPT THOSE THAT WOULD
00:37:26.711 --> 00:37:30.214
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION.
00:37:30.281 --> 00:37:32.116
JUST TRY AND OPPOSITION. PLEASE
00:37:32.183 --> 00:37:33.250
PRESS ONE THAN ZERO ON YOUR
00:37:33.317 --> 00:37:35.753
TELEPHONE. AND ONE MOMENT WHILE
00:37:35.820 --> 00:37:49.300
WE GET LINE NUMBERS.
00:37:49.367 --> 00:37:50.568
AND WE HAVE LINE NUMBER ONE. OH,
00:37:50.635 --> 00:37:54.939
THREE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:37:55.006 --> 00:37:56.440
AFTERNOON OR GOOD MORNING, KIM
00:37:56.507 --> 00:37:58.042
DELFINO, REPRESENTING THE
00:37:58.109 --> 00:37:58.843
PLANNING AND CONSERVATION
00:37:58.909 --> 00:38:00.144
LEAGUE. DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE,
00:38:00.211 --> 00:38:01.846
CALIFORNIA NEED A PLANT SOCIETY
00:38:01.912 --> 00:38:03.314
AND ENDANGERED HABITATS. LEAK
00:38:03.381 --> 00:38:04.415
WE'RE CURRENTLY IN OPPOSITION OF
00:38:04.482 --> 00:38:07.985
80 27 05. UM THE BILL.
00:38:08.052 --> 00:38:11.389
ORIGINALLY, UM BILL ASKED. I'M
00:38:11.455 --> 00:38:12.790
SORRY. AM I ABLE TO ACTUALLY
00:38:12.857 --> 00:38:14.325
GIVE A LITTLE ADDITIONAL? YES I
00:38:14.392 --> 00:38:16.694
WILL ALLOW YOU TO DO THAT. YES I
00:38:16.761 --> 00:38:18.729
WILL ALLOW YOU TO DO THAT SINCE
00:38:18.796 --> 00:38:19.930
THERE WAS NO LEAD, OPPOSITION
00:38:19.997 --> 00:38:22.233
NOTED. OKAY I REALLY APPRECIATE
00:38:22.299 --> 00:38:25.202
THAT. THANK YOU. SO UM, THE MAIN
00:38:25.269 --> 00:38:26.871
THRUST WITH THE CURRENT VERSION
00:38:26.937 --> 00:38:29.140
OF THE BILL, UM, THAT WE HAVE A
00:38:29.206 --> 00:38:30.808
PROBLEM WITH IS THAT IT
00:38:30.875 --> 00:38:34.145
ESSENTIALLY ADDS THE STATE'S
00:38:34.211 --> 00:38:35.946
POLICY THAT WE CAN DEVELOP
00:38:36.013 --> 00:38:37.048
WITHIN VERY HIGH FIRE SEVERITY
00:38:37.114 --> 00:38:40.051
AREAS. A PARTICULARLY STRONG ALL
00:38:40.117 --> 00:38:42.386
IN PHIL'S. ANOTHER ISSUE OR
00:38:42.453 --> 00:38:44.088
UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THIS BILL
00:38:44.155 --> 00:38:45.623
IS GETTING AMENDED SIGNIFICANTLY
00:38:45.690 --> 00:38:47.158
. WE WOULD VERY MUCH LIKE TO
00:38:47.224 --> 00:38:49.293
PARTICIPATE IN THAT DISCUSSION
00:38:49.360 --> 00:38:50.594
AND SIMILAR TO THE COMMENT MADE
00:38:50.661 --> 00:38:53.864
BY GRACIELA. EARLIER FOR THE, UM
00:38:53.931 --> 00:38:55.466
BEES. WE BELIEVE THAT IF THERE
00:38:55.533 --> 00:38:56.934
IS ANY DISCUSSION AROUND THIS,
00:38:57.001 --> 00:38:58.335
WE NEED TO BE DISCUSSING ALSO
00:38:58.402 --> 00:38:59.170
THE RENA PROCESS AND
00:38:59.236 --> 00:39:00.771
INCORPORATION OF THAT IN LOOKING
00:39:00.838 --> 00:39:03.340
AT FUTURE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT.
00:39:03.407 --> 00:39:05.276
WE THINK THAT THERE IS A WAY TO
00:39:05.342 --> 00:39:07.244
BE DEVELOPING AND REDUCE SUPPORT
00:39:07.311 --> 00:39:09.580
DEVELOPING HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA
00:39:09.647 --> 00:39:11.782
. OF COURSE, I MEAN, WE HAVE A
00:39:11.849 --> 00:39:12.583
HOUSING CRISIS. WE'RE NOT IMMUNE
00:39:12.650 --> 00:39:14.285
TO THAT. AND WE KNOW THAT THAT
00:39:14.351 --> 00:39:15.720
NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED AND WHAT
00:39:15.786 --> 00:39:17.955
WE'RE SEEING VERY HARD TO
00:39:18.022 --> 00:39:18.956
ADDRESS IT THROUGH INFILL
00:39:19.023 --> 00:39:19.423
DEVELOPMENT AND HEART
00:39:19.490 --> 00:39:19.924
DEVELOPMENT. BUT FURTHER
00:39:19.990 --> 00:39:21.859
DEVELOPMENT OUT INTO VERY HIGH
00:39:21.926 --> 00:39:23.360
FIRE SEVERITY ZONES, NO MATTER
00:39:23.427 --> 00:39:25.229
HOW WELL DESIGNED YOU BACK THE
00:39:25.296 --> 00:39:27.932
HOUSE STILL SIGNIFICANT RISK
00:39:27.998 --> 00:39:29.366
THAT WE SHOULD TRY TO AVOID. AND
00:39:29.433 --> 00:39:31.936
FOR THOSE REASONS WE CONTINUE TO
00:39:32.002 --> 00:39:33.037
OPPOSE THIS, BILL. THANK YOU.
00:39:33.104 --> 00:39:38.542
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU
00:39:38.609 --> 00:39:40.978
AND I HAVE NO ONE ELSE IN. Q
00:39:41.045 --> 00:39:42.246
GOOD. UM WE'RE GOING TO BRING
00:39:42.313 --> 00:39:44.415
THE MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:39:44.482 --> 00:39:49.086
FOR COMMENTS QUESTIONS CONCERNS.
00:39:49.153 --> 00:39:50.321
SENATOR RUSSELL. THANK YOU.
00:39:50.387 --> 00:39:51.322
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:39:51.388 --> 00:39:56.393
FOR THE TRYING TO COME UP WITH
00:39:56.460 --> 00:39:57.728
WAYS ON HOW WE DO MORE, UM,
00:39:57.795 --> 00:39:59.997
BUILDING BUT THERE WERE SOME OF
00:40:00.064 --> 00:40:01.665
THE OPPOSITION COMMENTS IF YOU
00:40:01.732 --> 00:40:03.768
COULD ADDRESS THOSE, AND THERE
00:40:03.834 --> 00:40:06.737
WAS ONE EXAMPLE THAT WAS GIVEN
00:40:06.804 --> 00:40:12.710
HOW THIS BILL WEAKENS. UM AH!
00:40:12.777 --> 00:40:14.445
YOU KNOW THE REQUIREMENTS FOR
00:40:14.512 --> 00:40:15.846
LARGER DEVELOPMENTS SAYS TO HAVE
00:40:15.913 --> 00:40:20.951
WILDFIRE BUFFERS. UM 3200 FT
00:40:21.018 --> 00:40:23.254
WHEN EXISTING LIVES THAT THEY'RE
00:40:23.320 --> 00:40:25.256
100 FT, SO THAT'S JUST ONE
00:40:25.322 --> 00:40:28.292
EXAMPLE OF THE OVERALL I THINK.
00:40:28.359 --> 00:40:31.028
CRITICISM OF WEAKENING AND
00:40:31.095 --> 00:40:34.365
ESPECIALLY AT A TIME WHEN WE'RE
00:40:34.431 --> 00:40:36.100
SO PRONE TO FIRES AND THE
00:40:36.167 --> 00:40:38.035
DROUGHT, SO IF YOU COULD ADDRESS
00:40:38.102 --> 00:40:40.771
THOSE ISSUES OR SOMEONE NO,
00:40:40.838 --> 00:40:44.341
THANK YOU. AND I DO TAKE THOSE
00:40:44.408 --> 00:40:47.511
CONCERNS. SERIOUSLY WE CERTAINLY
00:40:47.578 --> 00:40:51.015
DON'T WANT TO DO. UM SOME TYPE
00:40:51.081 --> 00:40:52.817
OF OUTLANDISH BUILDING AND AREAS
00:40:52.883 --> 00:40:57.087
OF CONCERN. WE ALSO DON'T WANT
00:40:57.154 --> 00:40:59.156
TO TAKE LARGE SWATHS OF
00:40:59.223 --> 00:41:02.159
CALIFORNIA OUT OF AN OPTION TO
00:41:02.226 --> 00:41:03.694
BUILD. AND THAT'S THE INTENT OF
00:41:03.761 --> 00:41:05.529
THIS BILL BILL, WHICH IS TO SAY
00:41:05.596 --> 00:41:08.833
WHAT THE PROPER TYPE OF BUILDING
00:41:08.899 --> 00:41:11.569
STANDARDS AND CODES THAT WE CAN
00:41:11.635 --> 00:41:14.872
DO THIS SAFELY. UM I UNDERSTAND
00:41:14.939 --> 00:41:17.441
. CERTAINLY WE'VE HAD MANY MORE
00:41:17.508 --> 00:41:19.510
WILD FIRES THEN AND WE CAN ALSO
00:41:19.577 --> 00:41:21.679
ASSUME THERE WILL BE MORE IN THE
00:41:21.745 --> 00:41:26.784
FUTURE, BUT AS FAR AS THE BUFFER
00:41:26.851 --> 00:41:27.384
, WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE TO
00:41:27.451 --> 00:41:29.987
WORK ON THE LANGUAGE AS FAR AS,
00:41:30.054 --> 00:41:32.756
UM LOOKING IN THE RAIN A WORLD
00:41:32.823 --> 00:41:35.626
CONTINUE TO LOOK ON THAT, BUT I
00:41:35.693 --> 00:41:37.127
THINK ONE OF THE, UM, ISSUES
00:41:37.194 --> 00:41:39.230
HERE FOR CALIFORNIA IS MANY
00:41:39.296 --> 00:41:42.967
TIMES WE HEAR ABOUT INFILL. OR
00:41:43.033 --> 00:41:45.302
AN URBAN AREAS, AND YOU AND I
00:41:45.369 --> 00:41:46.871
HAVE SEEN WHAT THAT MEANS. IT
00:41:46.937 --> 00:41:49.807
MEANS TO PUT A HUGE AMOUNT OF
00:41:49.874 --> 00:41:51.976
DENSITY AND SOMETIMES AREAS THAT
00:41:52.042 --> 00:41:54.144
DON'T HAVE ALL THE SUPPORT
00:41:54.211 --> 00:41:55.045
WHETHER IT'S TRANSPORTATION,
00:41:55.112 --> 00:41:57.481
WHETHER IT'S JOBS AND THEN TO,
00:41:57.548 --> 00:41:59.149
IN ESSENCE, PROTECT OTHER AREAS
00:41:59.216 --> 00:42:02.353
. UM, WHETHER IT'S A COAST
00:42:02.419 --> 00:42:06.056
WHETHER IT'S NOW FOR HABITAT FOR
00:42:06.123 --> 00:42:07.558
MOUNTAIN LIONS. I'M NOT SURE IF
00:42:07.625 --> 00:42:09.894
YOU SAW THAT THERE WAS A CITY
00:42:09.960 --> 00:42:11.362
THAT SAID, OH, WE CAN'T BUILD
00:42:11.428 --> 00:42:12.563
HERE BECAUSE IT'S MOUNTAIN LION
00:42:12.630 --> 00:42:15.966
HABITAT. AND AGAIN WITH
00:42:16.033 --> 00:42:18.302
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE BUILT IN
00:42:18.369 --> 00:42:20.871
PLACES BEFORE AND WE HAVE SEEN
00:42:20.938 --> 00:42:22.840
DIRE CONSEQUENCES WITHOUT THE
00:42:22.907 --> 00:42:23.941
CORRECT PROTECTIONS SO WE WILL
00:42:24.008 --> 00:42:27.211
CONTINUE TO WORK. UM NOT ONLY
00:42:27.278 --> 00:42:28.979
WITH THE CHAIR ON ADDITIONAL
00:42:29.046 --> 00:42:31.782
AMENDMENTS, BUT I THINK ONE OF
00:42:31.849 --> 00:42:34.018
THE GOALS FOR US IS TO NOT JUST
00:42:34.084 --> 00:42:38.389
DO A BLANKET. OF ZONING THAT WE
00:42:38.455 --> 00:42:41.292
CAN'T BUILD IN CERTAIN AREAS WE
00:42:41.358 --> 00:42:43.027
CAN BUILD IF IT'S DONE CORRECTLY
00:42:43.093 --> 00:42:44.528
, UM AND AGAIN, WE CERTAINLY
00:42:44.595 --> 00:42:47.531
DON'T WANT TO REPEAT OF PARIS OR
00:42:47.598 --> 00:42:49.900
ANY OF THESE OTHER PLACES, BUT
00:42:49.967 --> 00:42:51.201
THERE HAS BEEN BUILDING
00:42:51.268 --> 00:42:52.503
THROUGHOUT THE DECADES IN
00:42:52.569 --> 00:42:53.637
CALIFORNIA, AND IT CAN BE DONE
00:42:53.704 --> 00:42:58.409
CORRECTLY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:42:58.475 --> 00:42:59.810
WELL, I APPRECIATE THE WORK THAT
00:42:59.877 --> 00:43:03.013
YOU'VE DONE AND THE COMMITMENT
00:43:03.080 --> 00:43:06.183
TO. TO WORKING ON THE FRAMEWORK
00:43:06.250 --> 00:43:07.785
THAT THAT WE'VE BEEN DISCUSSING
00:43:07.851 --> 00:43:09.486
THAT THAT I THINK SHOULD TAKE
00:43:09.553 --> 00:43:10.788
CARE OF SOME OF THE ISSUES THAT
00:43:10.854 --> 00:43:13.090
HAVE BEEN RAISED ALSO, UM, THIS
00:43:13.157 --> 00:43:14.525
WILL GO TO HOUSING, WHICH IS
00:43:14.591 --> 00:43:16.627
WHERE THE DISCUSSION ABOUT RINA
00:43:16.694 --> 00:43:19.897
MORE APPROPRIATELY LIES AND
00:43:19.964 --> 00:43:21.332
SENATOR WEINER AND I HAVE HAD
00:43:21.398 --> 00:43:24.001
DISCUSSIONS ABOUT THAT. AND UM
00:43:24.068 --> 00:43:25.669
THERE WILL BE FOLLOW UP ON IT.
00:43:25.736 --> 00:43:27.338
SO I APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE WHAT
00:43:27.404 --> 00:43:28.572
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO HERE. THIS
00:43:28.639 --> 00:43:29.807
IS REALLY CRITICALLY IMPORTANT
00:43:29.873 --> 00:43:32.142
THAT WE DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO,
00:43:32.209 --> 00:43:37.281
UM PROTECT, UM. RESIDENTS THAT
00:43:37.348 --> 00:43:39.583
LIVE IN THESE AREAS AND IF WE'RE
00:43:39.650 --> 00:43:40.617
GOING TO BE REBUILDING THAT THEY
00:43:40.684 --> 00:43:42.619
BE REBUILT TO THE STANDARDS THAT
00:43:42.686 --> 00:43:43.554
ARE GOING TO ENSURE THAT WE
00:43:43.620 --> 00:43:45.522
DON'T SEE THE KINDS OF WILDFIRES
00:43:45.589 --> 00:43:46.256
THAT WE'VE SEEN IN THE PAST. AND
00:43:46.323 --> 00:43:50.294
THAT, UM WE DO WHAT WE NEED TO
00:43:50.361 --> 00:43:54.531
DO TO ENSURE THAT THE FOREST
00:43:54.598 --> 00:43:55.532
SURROUNDING THE AREA IS
00:43:55.599 --> 00:43:57.001
APPROPRIATELY MANAGED AS WELL.
00:43:57.067 --> 00:43:58.535
SO I DO APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE
00:43:58.602 --> 00:44:01.071
TRYING TO DO. UM AND I WILL BE
00:44:01.138 --> 00:44:03.574
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL TODAY. AND
00:44:03.640 --> 00:44:06.043
WE'LL SEE YOU IN HOUSING. WHEN
00:44:06.110 --> 00:44:06.610
I'M GOING TO GET OVER THERE,
00:44:06.677 --> 00:44:08.078
I'LL ENTERTAIN A MOTION ON THIS
00:44:08.145 --> 00:44:13.384
BILL. SENATOR DURAZO MOVES THE
00:44:13.450 --> 00:44:15.486
BILL DO PASS. BUT FIRST WE RE
00:44:15.552 --> 00:44:16.787
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:44:16.854 --> 00:44:20.357
HOUSING. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:44:20.424 --> 00:44:21.959
MOTION IS STUPID PASS, BUT FIRST
00:44:22.026 --> 00:44:23.460
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE AND
00:44:23.527 --> 00:44:25.162
HOUSING SENATORS CABALLERO
00:44:25.229 --> 00:44:27.464
CABALLERO, I, NIELSEN. NIELSEN.
00:44:27.531 --> 00:44:30.934
I DURAZO. SO I'M HERZBERG
00:44:31.001 --> 00:44:35.439
WIENER. THE BILL HAS SUFFICIENT
00:44:35.506 --> 00:44:36.573
VOTES, BUT WE'RE GOING TO PUT IT
00:44:36.640 --> 00:44:38.409
ON CALL. FOR THE MISSING
00:44:38.475 --> 00:44:42.212
MEMBERS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:44:42.279 --> 00:44:44.014
SIMPLE ASSEMBLY MEMBER, IRWIN,
00:44:44.081 --> 00:44:47.951
UM. YOU'RE YOU'RE YOU'RE UP ON
00:44:48.018 --> 00:44:56.493
THE AGENDA. A B FOR 11. YES
00:44:56.560 --> 00:44:58.896
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:44:58.962 --> 00:45:01.331
MEMBERS BEFORE 11 ENACTS THE
00:45:01.398 --> 00:45:02.666
VETERAN HOUSING AND HOMELESS
00:45:02.733 --> 00:45:04.268
PREVENTION BOND ACT TO AUTHORIZE
00:45:04.334 --> 00:45:05.502
THE ISSUANCE OF BONDS TO PROVIDE
00:45:05.569 --> 00:45:07.905
ADDITIONAL FUNDING. FOR THE
00:45:07.971 --> 00:45:09.406
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE MULTI
00:45:09.473 --> 00:45:10.808
FAMILY HOUSING WITH SUPPORTIVE
00:45:10.874 --> 00:45:13.410
SERVICES FOR VETERANS IN 2014,
00:45:13.477 --> 00:45:15.879
CALIFORNIA VOTERS APPROVED PROP
00:45:15.946 --> 00:45:17.147
41 TO FUND MULTIFAMILY,
00:45:17.214 --> 00:45:19.883
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR VETERANS.
00:45:19.950 --> 00:45:22.453
CREATING VHP THE PROPOSITION
00:45:22.519 --> 00:45:24.388
ALLOWED FOR 600 MILLION IN BONDS
00:45:24.455 --> 00:45:26.156
TO BE ISSUED OVER SIX ROUNDS OF
00:45:26.223 --> 00:45:27.724
FUNDING VHP HAS RESULTED IN
00:45:27.791 --> 00:45:31.462
NEARLY 6000 UNITS. THERE IS NOW
00:45:31.528 --> 00:45:36.033
ABOUT $100 MILLION LEFT IN THIS
00:45:36.100 --> 00:45:38.435
, UH, IN THE FUND FOR THIS VERY
00:45:38.502 --> 00:45:41.038
SUCCESSFUL PROGRAM, A B 4 11
00:45:41.105 --> 00:45:43.707
ASKED PROPOSALS TO ASK VOTERS IN
00:45:43.774 --> 00:45:44.541
2024 TO CONTINUE FUNDING THE
00:45:44.608 --> 00:45:48.445
PROGRAM. WITH ANOTHER 600. UH
00:45:48.512 --> 00:45:49.446
MILLION DOLLARS. THERE ARE AN
00:45:49.513 --> 00:45:51.381
ESTIMATED 11,000 HOMELESS
00:45:51.448 --> 00:45:52.883
VETERANS IN CALIFORNIA AND EVEN
00:45:52.950 --> 00:45:54.952
MORE EXPERIENCING VETERAN OR
00:45:55.018 --> 00:45:56.253
HOUSING INSECURITY OR STRUGGLING
00:45:56.320 --> 00:45:57.354
TO MAKE END MEET IN THE
00:45:57.421 --> 00:46:01.525
TRANSITION. 84 11 WILL ASSIST
00:46:01.592 --> 00:46:03.727
VETERANS WHO ARE HOMELESS OR WHO
00:46:03.794 --> 00:46:04.895
NEED AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING
00:46:04.962 --> 00:46:05.896
TO SECURE HOUSING AND SERVICES
00:46:05.963 --> 00:46:12.836
FOR THEMSELVES AND VERY GOOD. UM
00:46:12.903 --> 00:46:15.472
WE'RE GOING TO YOU HAVE YOUR AS
00:46:15.539 --> 00:46:17.708
YOUR LEAD WITNESS IN SUPPORT
00:46:17.774 --> 00:46:18.375
CHARLES RIGHT FROM THE
00:46:18.442 --> 00:46:18.909
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:46:18.976 --> 00:46:19.743
VETERANS SERVICE AGENCIES
00:46:19.810 --> 00:46:22.980
WELCOME. THANK YOU, MADAM. CHAIR
00:46:23.046 --> 00:46:24.148
CHARLES, RIGHT, REPRESENTING THE
00:46:24.214 --> 00:46:25.382
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:46:25.449 --> 00:46:26.783
VETERANS SERVICES AGENCIES, ALSO
00:46:26.850 --> 00:46:28.552
KNOWN AS CALVES. CALVES IS IN
00:46:28.619 --> 00:46:31.021
STRONG SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY. MITT
00:46:31.088 --> 00:46:32.589
BILL 411 THAT PLACES THE
00:46:32.656 --> 00:46:33.891
VETERANS HOUSING AND HOMELESS
00:46:33.957 --> 00:46:35.826
PREVENTION BOND ACT OF 2022 ON
00:46:35.893 --> 00:46:38.795
THE MARCH 2024 STATEWIDE BALLOT.
00:46:38.862 --> 00:46:41.932
84 1 WORN WHEN IF PASSED BY THE
00:46:41.999 --> 00:46:42.599
LEGISLATURE, AND THE VOTERS WILL
00:46:42.666 --> 00:46:44.067
ESSENTIALLY EXTEND THE VETERANS
00:46:44.134 --> 00:46:45.969
HOUSING AND HOMELESSNESS PROGRAM
00:46:46.036 --> 00:46:49.573
WITH THE ISSUANCE OF 600 OBLIGATION BONDS. THE
00:46:49.640 --> 00:46:50.841
VETERANS HOUSING AND
00:46:50.908 --> 00:46:52.309
HOMELESSNESS PROGRAM FUND HAS
00:46:52.376 --> 00:46:54.578
BEEN USED TO PRODUCE OVER 88
00:46:54.645 --> 00:46:56.046
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS
00:46:56.113 --> 00:46:57.881
, PRODUCING ROUGHLY 5600 UNITS
00:46:57.948 --> 00:46:59.016
FOR VETERANS AND NON VETERANS
00:46:59.082 --> 00:47:00.951
SINCE 2014 HOWEVER, THESE FANS
00:47:01.018 --> 00:47:02.619
WILL BE EXHAUSTED LATER THIS
00:47:02.686 --> 00:47:05.422
YEAR. THE FUNDING FOR THESE
00:47:05.489 --> 00:47:06.590
PROJECTS HAS BEEN AND CONTINUE
00:47:06.657 --> 00:47:08.158
TO BE GEOGRAPHICALLY TARGETED TO
00:47:08.225 --> 00:47:09.526
ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
00:47:09.593 --> 00:47:11.228
VETERAN HOUSING AND REGIONS WITH
00:47:11.295 --> 00:47:12.963
HIGH CONCENTRATIONS OF
00:47:13.030 --> 00:47:13.530
CALIFORNIA'S MOST VULNERABLE
00:47:13.597 --> 00:47:15.966
VETERANS. THE VETERANS, HOUSING
00:47:16.033 --> 00:47:16.533
AND HOMELESSNESS PROGRAM HAS
00:47:16.600 --> 00:47:18.202
SHOWN TO BE AN EFFECTIVE AND
00:47:18.268 --> 00:47:19.469
EFFICIENT SYSTEM FOR THE
00:47:19.536 --> 00:47:21.572
CONSTRUCTION OF VETERANS HOUSING
00:47:21.638 --> 00:47:22.139
. THEREFORE, THE CALIFORNIA
00:47:22.206 --> 00:47:23.640
ASSOCIATION OF VETERANS SERVICES
00:47:23.707 --> 00:47:24.841
AGENCIES STRONGLY ENCOURAGES
00:47:24.908 --> 00:47:27.110
SUPPORT OF A B 411. THANK YOU,
00:47:27.177 --> 00:47:27.711
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. THANK YOU
00:47:27.778 --> 00:47:31.481
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANYBODY IN
00:47:31.548 --> 00:47:32.616
ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:47:32.683 --> 00:47:37.721
JUST FIND SUPPORT. MORNING COREY
00:47:37.788 --> 00:47:38.755
SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING
00:47:38.822 --> 00:47:40.057
ACTION COALITION IN SUPPORT.
00:47:40.123 --> 00:47:43.160
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SAYING NO
00:47:43.227 --> 00:47:44.561
FURTHER MOVEMENT WILL CHECK THE
00:47:44.628 --> 00:47:45.929
TELETEXT TELECONFERENCE LINE.
00:47:45.996 --> 00:47:47.164
MADAM MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD
00:47:47.231 --> 00:47:49.600
HEWITT WITNESSES AND SUPPORT.
00:47:49.666 --> 00:47:57.241
THANK YOU. GO AHEAD. SORRY UM,
00:47:57.307 --> 00:47:59.276
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B FOR
00:47:59.343 --> 00:48:01.078
11, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
00:48:01.144 --> 00:48:03.213
YOUR PHONE AND WE WILL START
00:48:03.280 --> 00:48:07.451
WITH BLIND 13. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:48:07.517 --> 00:48:11.088
HELLO THIS IS JOE LUPUS. I AM A
00:48:11.154 --> 00:48:12.589
MEMBER OF THE ASSOCIATED
00:48:12.656 --> 00:48:13.824
BUILDERS AND CONTRACTORS OF
00:48:13.890 --> 00:48:14.791
CALIFORNIA, NORTHERN CALIFORNIA
00:48:14.858 --> 00:48:17.561
CHAPTER. AND I AM CALLING TO
00:48:17.628 --> 00:48:20.330
SUPPORT A B. 411 THANK YOU.
00:48:20.397 --> 00:48:24.434
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.
00:48:24.501 --> 00:48:26.336
NEXT IN LINE. 109, PLEASE GO
00:48:26.403 --> 00:48:29.706
AHEAD. MORNING MADAM TERRY
00:48:29.773 --> 00:48:31.141
MEMBERS, MADELINE COOPER FROM
00:48:31.208 --> 00:48:32.676
NIELSEN MERKSAMER ON BEHALF OF
00:48:32.743 --> 00:48:33.377
THE ASSOCIATED BUILDERS AND
00:48:33.443 --> 00:48:34.311
CONTRACTORS. CALIFORNIAN
00:48:34.378 --> 00:48:39.182
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:48:39.249 --> 00:48:40.417
THANK YOU. AND I HAVE NO ONE
00:48:40.484 --> 00:48:43.487
ELSE. THANK YOU. VERY GOOD.
00:48:43.553 --> 00:48:45.856
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
00:48:45.922 --> 00:48:47.124
OPPOSITION. WE HAVE NO LEAD.
00:48:47.190 --> 00:48:48.892
OPPOSITION WITNESSES LISTED SO
00:48:48.959 --> 00:48:50.894
WHEN TO CHECK AND SEE IF THERE'S
00:48:50.961 --> 00:48:52.462
ANYBODY IN ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD
00:48:52.529 --> 00:48:53.997
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
00:48:54.064 --> 00:48:55.766
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE TO THE
00:48:55.832 --> 00:48:57.234
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:48:57.301 --> 00:48:59.436
ANYBODY ON THE LINE THAT WOULD
00:48:59.503 --> 00:49:00.671
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO
00:49:00.737 --> 00:49:04.541
411? TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO A
00:49:04.608 --> 00:49:06.343
B 411 PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO
00:49:06.410 --> 00:49:12.816
ON YOUR PHONE. THAT'S WHEN THEN
00:49:12.883 --> 00:49:20.490
ZERO. AND I HAVE NO WINNING QUÊ.
00:49:20.557 --> 00:49:21.658
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WILL BRING
00:49:21.725 --> 00:49:23.493
THE MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:49:23.560 --> 00:49:27.364
FOR COMMENTS QUESTIONS. UM THIS
00:49:27.431 --> 00:49:28.632
IS A TERRIFIC PROGRAM AND, UM SO
00:49:28.699 --> 00:49:32.903
THANK YOU FOR THE EXTENSION FOR
00:49:32.969 --> 00:49:35.839
THE BILL TO EXTEND IT AND I'M
00:49:35.906 --> 00:49:37.074
GOING TO BE SUPPORTING IT TODAY
00:49:37.140 --> 00:49:38.308
. I THINK IT DOES REALLY GOOD
00:49:38.375 --> 00:49:39.943
WORK, SO APPRECIATE APPRECIATE
00:49:40.010 --> 00:49:45.048
YOU. YOUR WORK ON THIS. AH! YES
00:49:45.115 --> 00:49:46.283
THERE IS A MOTION BY SENATOR
00:49:46.350 --> 00:49:50.220
DURAZO, YOU MAY CONCLUDE. UH
00:49:50.287 --> 00:49:51.988
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR I VOTE
00:49:52.055 --> 00:49:53.223
TO CONTINUE THIS VERY SUCCESSFUL
00:49:53.290 --> 00:49:54.391
PROGRAM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:49:54.458 --> 00:49:58.061
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. MOTION IS
00:49:58.128 --> 00:50:00.197
TO PASS BUT FIRST BE RE REFERRED
00:50:00.263 --> 00:50:01.465
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:50:01.531 --> 00:50:01.965
APPROPRIATIONS. SENATORS
00:50:02.032 --> 00:50:04.634
CABALLERO BY CABALLERO, I.
00:50:04.701 --> 00:50:08.271
NILSSON NILSSON. I SO. DORA SO I
00:50:08.338 --> 00:50:12.976
HERZBERG WIENER. BILL HAS
00:50:13.043 --> 00:50:13.610
SUFFICIENT VOTES WERE GOING TO
00:50:13.677 --> 00:50:15.078
WAIT FOR THE ABSENT MEMBERS, SO
00:50:15.145 --> 00:50:16.613
WE'RE GOING TO PUT IT ON CALL.
00:50:16.680 --> 00:50:19.049
MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO
00:50:19.116 --> 00:50:20.851
A. B 18 63 AGAIN
00:50:20.917 --> 00:50:23.887
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IRWIN IN 2015.
00:50:23.954 --> 00:50:25.021
OUR STATE ESTABLISHED THE
00:50:25.088 --> 00:50:25.589
CALIFORNIA EARNED INCOME TAX
00:50:25.655 --> 00:50:28.458
CREDIT PROGRAM WITH THE
00:50:28.525 --> 00:50:30.293
BIPARTISAN GOAL OF PUTTING MONEY
00:50:30.360 --> 00:50:32.062
BACK INTO THE POCKETS OF WORKING
00:50:32.129 --> 00:50:34.164
CALIFORNIANS. DESPITE YEARS OF
00:50:34.231 --> 00:50:35.031
OUTREACH, MANY ELIGIBLE
00:50:35.098 --> 00:50:36.566
TAXPAYERS ARE STILL NOT CLAIMING
00:50:36.633 --> 00:50:40.203
THEIR EI C CREDIT. A B 18 63 AS
00:50:40.270 --> 00:50:41.972
A PILOT PROGRAM THAT WILL DIRECT
00:50:42.038 --> 00:50:44.641
ELIGIBLE CALLIE EITC RECIPIENTS
00:50:44.708 --> 00:50:45.609
TO CLAIM THE CREDIT EITHER
00:50:45.675 --> 00:50:47.711
THROUGH THE STATES FREE TAX
00:50:47.778 --> 00:50:49.880
FILING OPTION, CAL FILE OR THE
00:50:49.946 --> 00:50:51.181
VITA PROGRAM BY DIRECTING
00:50:51.248 --> 00:50:53.650
ELIGIBLE RECIPIENTS TO THESE
00:50:53.717 --> 00:50:55.152
FILING OPTIONS. THIS BILL WILL
00:50:55.218 --> 00:50:56.586
MITIGATE FILING BURDENS THAT
00:50:56.653 --> 00:50:58.155
PREVENT TAXPAYERS FROM CLAIMING
00:50:58.221 --> 00:51:00.023
THE CREDIT WITH ME HERE TODAY
00:51:00.090 --> 00:51:02.292
AND SUPPORT IS JENNIFER TAN HILL
00:51:02.359 --> 00:51:03.560
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:51:03.627 --> 00:51:04.127
SOCIETY OF ENROLLED AGENTS.
00:51:04.194 --> 00:51:08.465
PRETTY GOOD. I UNDERSTAND SHE IS
00:51:08.532 --> 00:51:10.400
ON THE PHONE, LET'S CHECK AND
00:51:10.467 --> 00:51:13.570
SEE IF SHE'S AVAILABLE. GOOD
00:51:13.637 --> 00:51:15.005
MORNING CHAIRWOMAN AND MEMBERS
00:51:15.071 --> 00:51:17.107
JENNIFER TANNEHILL WITH AARON
00:51:17.174 --> 00:51:19.142
REID AND ASSOCIATES ON BEHALF OF
00:51:19.209 --> 00:51:20.143
THE CALIFORNIA SOCIETY OF
00:51:20.210 --> 00:51:23.580
ENROLLED AGENT. CSC A HAS A LONG
00:51:23.647 --> 00:51:24.481
STANDING POLICY OF SUPPORTING
00:51:24.548 --> 00:51:25.916
LEGISLATION THAT'S INTENDED TO
00:51:25.982 --> 00:51:26.750
EASE TAXPAYER BURDEN AND
00:51:26.817 --> 00:51:27.851
COMPLYING WITH STATE TEXT
00:51:27.918 --> 00:51:32.155
BLOCKS. MAYBE 18 63 INTENDS TO
00:51:32.222 --> 00:51:34.257
EAT, UH, COMPLIANCE THROUGH
00:51:34.324 --> 00:51:35.959
NOTIFYING CALIFORNIANS OF THE F
00:51:36.026 --> 00:51:38.195
T B PAPERLESS FILING OPTIONS AND
00:51:38.261 --> 00:51:39.329
TO INCREASE AWARENESS OF THE
00:51:39.396 --> 00:51:42.899
CALI I T C INCREASING AWARENESS
00:51:42.966 --> 00:51:43.967
OF THESE OPTIONS COULD REDUCE
00:51:44.034 --> 00:51:45.869
TIME AND POTENTIALLY THE COST OF
00:51:45.936 --> 00:51:46.937
FILING RETURNS FOR THOSE
00:51:47.003 --> 00:51:49.206
TAXPAYERS. ADDITIONALLY, A B 18
00:51:49.272 --> 00:51:51.408
63 AS AMENDED REQUIRES THE FTV
00:51:51.475 --> 00:51:54.211
TO REPORT ON THE COST. EFFICACY
00:51:54.277 --> 00:51:56.046
AND SAVINGS ASSOCIATED WITH THIS
00:51:56.112 --> 00:51:57.948
EFFORT, WHICH WILL INFORM THE
00:51:58.014 --> 00:51:58.982
LEGISLATURE IS TO THE
00:51:59.049 --> 00:52:00.517
EFFECTIVENESS OF THIS OUTRAGE TO
00:52:00.584 --> 00:52:03.887
TAXPAYERS. CSC A IS A READY
00:52:03.954 --> 00:52:05.388
RESOURCE TO PROVIDE PRACTICAL
00:52:05.455 --> 00:52:07.090
INSIGHT AND PERSPECTIVE FROM THE
00:52:07.157 --> 00:52:08.625
TAX COMMUNITY TO HELP ENSURE
00:52:08.692 --> 00:52:10.160
ADMINISTRATION OF THIS PROGRAM
00:52:10.227 --> 00:52:12.195
IS SUCCESSFUL. WE REQUEST YOUR I
00:52:12.262 --> 00:52:13.263
VOTE AND THANK YOU FOR
00:52:13.330 --> 00:52:14.998
CONSIDERING OUR POSITION. THANK
00:52:15.065 --> 00:52:17.000
YOU VERY MUCH, AND ALSO THANK
00:52:17.067 --> 00:52:19.202
YOU FOR, UM, YOUR COMMITMENT TO
00:52:19.269 --> 00:52:21.638
MAKING SURE TAXPAYERS GET THE
00:52:21.705 --> 00:52:22.873
MONEY THEY DESERVE AND THAT IT'S
00:52:22.939 --> 00:52:24.808
EASY TO BE ABLE TO FILE THEIR
00:52:24.875 --> 00:52:26.309
RETURNS. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON
00:52:26.376 --> 00:52:28.345
AND SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN
00:52:28.411 --> 00:52:30.113
ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:52:30.180 --> 00:52:31.581
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. SEEING NONE.
00:52:31.648 --> 00:52:32.849
WE COULD CHECK THE TELE
00:52:32.916 --> 00:52:35.185
TELECONFERENCE LINE. UH,
00:52:35.252 --> 00:52:37.120
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF A B 18
00:52:37.187 --> 00:52:41.992
63. SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 18
00:52:42.058 --> 00:52:44.160
63, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
00:52:44.227 --> 00:52:54.638
YOUR PHONE. PLEASE PRESS 10. AND
00:52:54.704 --> 00:52:57.941
I HAVE NO ONE IN THE QUEUE. VERY
00:52:58.008 --> 00:52:59.643
GOOD. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
00:52:59.709 --> 00:53:00.877
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. WE HAVE
00:53:00.944 --> 00:53:03.480
NONE LISTED AS LEAD, SO WE'LL
00:53:03.547 --> 00:53:05.282
CHECK AND SEE IF ANYONE IN ROOM
00:53:05.348 --> 00:53:06.449
2200 WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:53:06.516 --> 00:53:09.119
OPPOSITION. SEEING NONE WILL
00:53:09.185 --> 00:53:10.620
CHECK THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
00:53:10.687 --> 00:53:12.188
ANYONE WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK
00:53:12.255 --> 00:53:17.127
IN OPPOSITION TO A B 18 63.
00:53:17.193 --> 00:53:19.296
SPEAKING OPPOSITION TO A B 18 63
00:53:19.362 --> 00:53:24.601
, PLEASE PRESS 10 ON YOUR PHONE.
00:53:24.668 --> 00:53:28.672
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO I HAVE NO
00:53:28.738 --> 00:53:32.442
WEDDING QUÊ. VERY GOOD WILL
00:53:32.509 --> 00:53:34.044
BRING THE MATTER BACK TO THE
00:53:34.110 --> 00:53:36.212
COMMITTEE FOR A MOTION OR
00:53:36.279 --> 00:53:37.447
COMMENTS. YES, SENATOR DRIESELL
00:53:37.514 --> 00:53:41.518
QUESTION TO THE HONOR AUTHOR UM
00:53:41.585 --> 00:53:43.153
, I KNOW IT'S NOT THAT I'M
00:53:43.219 --> 00:53:44.721
SUPPORTIVE OF THANK YOU VERY
00:53:44.788 --> 00:53:46.156
MUCH FOR BRINGING IT. I'M JUST
00:53:46.222 --> 00:53:47.924
CURIOUS IF IN THE PROCESS OF
00:53:47.991 --> 00:53:53.096
RAISING THIS IF ANY INFORMATION
00:53:53.163 --> 00:53:55.231
HAS BEEN BROUGHT TO YOU ABOUT
00:53:55.298 --> 00:53:58.335
WHY WE'RE STILL NOT GETTING TO
00:53:58.401 --> 00:54:00.670
THE POPULATIONS TO THE PEOPLE
00:54:00.737 --> 00:54:02.439
THAT NEED IT, THE MOST ANY
00:54:02.505 --> 00:54:05.275
INSIGHT THAT YOU COULD PROVIDE
00:54:05.342 --> 00:54:07.544
WELL, THAT'S IF WE IF WE HAD THE
00:54:07.611 --> 00:54:08.979
ANSWER TO THAT. THAT WOULD BE,
00:54:09.045 --> 00:54:11.982
UH, YOU KNOW, THAT'S KIND OF THE
00:54:12.048 --> 00:54:12.582
MILLION DOLLAR QUESTION RIGHT
00:54:12.649 --> 00:54:14.317
NOW. SO THIS IS RIGHT NOW
00:54:14.384 --> 00:54:16.586
TAXPAYERS REALLY HAVE TO BE MUCH
00:54:16.653 --> 00:54:17.454
MORE BETTER ELIGIBLE HAVE TO BE
00:54:17.520 --> 00:54:20.056
MUCH MORE PROACTIVE AND GO TO
00:54:20.123 --> 00:54:21.124
THE WEBSITE AND THIS IS
00:54:21.191 --> 00:54:22.659
TARGETED. IN REACHING OUT TO
00:54:22.726 --> 00:54:24.294
TAXPAYERS THAT ARE ELIGIBLE. WE
00:54:24.361 --> 00:54:26.529
ARE ALSO PLANNING ON DOING AN
00:54:26.596 --> 00:54:29.499
OVERSIGHT HEARING TO SEE IF
00:54:29.566 --> 00:54:31.167
THERE ARE OTHER THINGS THAT WE
00:54:31.234 --> 00:54:32.335
AS A LEGISLATURE COULD BE DOING
00:54:32.402 --> 00:54:34.571
TO. REACH OUT TO THOSE WORKERS.
00:54:34.638 --> 00:54:36.906
IT'S OBVIOUSLY A VERY IMPORTANT
00:54:36.973 --> 00:54:38.575
PROGRAM TO PUT MONEY DIRECTLY
00:54:38.642 --> 00:54:40.810
INTO THE POCKETS OF BASICALLY
00:54:40.877 --> 00:54:43.079
THE WORKING POOR, AND WE WANT TO
00:54:43.146 --> 00:54:44.581
MAKE SURE THAT IT'S FULLY
00:54:44.648 --> 00:54:45.649
UTILIZED, SO WE'LL CONTINUE IN
00:54:45.715 --> 00:54:50.620
THAT EFFORT. I JUST SAY THAT, UM
00:54:50.687 --> 00:54:53.390
WITH ONE OF THE TWO QUALIFY, WON
00:54:53.456 --> 00:54:54.557
THE QUALIFICATION SPEAKING
00:54:54.624 --> 00:54:55.659
LIMITED ENGLISH I KNOW IN ALL
00:54:55.725 --> 00:55:02.265
THE AH! WHEN THE CENSUS ISSUE
00:55:02.332 --> 00:55:04.768
CAME UP, AND I WAS ON THE BUDGET
00:55:04.834 --> 00:55:06.102
COMMITTEE FOR THAT WE JUST HAD
00:55:06.169 --> 00:55:07.270
TO KEEP PUSHING THE LANGUAGE.
00:55:07.337 --> 00:55:10.340
UH, THE LANGUAGE AVAILABILITY TO
00:55:10.407 --> 00:55:13.910
GET THAT INFORMATION OUT EVEN TO
00:55:13.977 --> 00:55:16.646
REALLY HARD TO REACH COMMUNITIES
00:55:16.713 --> 00:55:18.214
. LANGUAGE ALWAYS SEEMED TO BE
00:55:18.281 --> 00:55:20.517
AN ISSUE SO, HOWEVER, WE CAN
00:55:20.583 --> 00:55:23.086
CONTINUE IT HANDLE THAT. I KNOW
00:55:23.153 --> 00:55:24.320
WE WOULD BE VERY SUPPORTIVE AND
00:55:24.387 --> 00:55:25.388
WORK WITH YOU ON THAT. SO I
00:55:25.455 --> 00:55:27.557
MOVED THE BILL AND THAT IS
00:55:27.624 --> 00:55:30.427
ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL. WE'VE GONE
00:55:30.493 --> 00:55:32.796
AND WATCHED THE EDA AGENTS IN
00:55:32.862 --> 00:55:34.464
ACTION AND THEY DEFINITELY, YOU
00:55:34.531 --> 00:55:37.767
KNOW. FIRST AND FOREMOST, MAKE
00:55:37.834 --> 00:55:38.668
SURE THAT THEY HAVE AGENTS THAT
00:55:38.735 --> 00:55:40.904
ARE SPEAKING SPANISH. SO UM,
00:55:40.970 --> 00:55:42.972
ANYTHING THAT WE LOOK AT? WE
00:55:43.039 --> 00:55:44.074
NEED TO MAKE SURE THAT IT'S THAT
00:55:44.140 --> 00:55:45.408
THAT WE HAVE MULTIPLE LANGUAGES
00:55:45.475 --> 00:55:48.111
TO PUSH THAT INFORMATION. YEAH
00:55:48.178 --> 00:55:49.746
THE ISSUE IS ACTUALLY MUCH MORE
00:55:49.813 --> 00:55:52.382
COMPLICATED THAN IT SEEMS. I DID
00:55:52.449 --> 00:55:54.951
A BILL ON THE E I T C BECAUSE
00:55:55.018 --> 00:55:56.619
THE UPTAKE IS SO SLOW, SO SLOW.
00:55:56.686 --> 00:55:58.888
AND WE'RE SPENDING MILLIONS.
00:55:58.955 --> 00:56:01.091
ADVERTISING AND SO I'D RATHER GO
00:56:01.157 --> 00:56:02.625
INTO THE POCKETS OF FAMILIES AS
00:56:02.692 --> 00:56:06.296
OPPOSED TO ADVERTISERS AND, UM.
00:56:06.362 --> 00:56:08.865
AND THE QUESTION THAT WE ASKED
00:56:08.932 --> 00:56:10.400
IF TB TO LOOK AT IS, ARE THERE
00:56:10.467 --> 00:56:13.470
OTHER PROGRAMS? THAT COULD COME
00:56:13.536 --> 00:56:15.105
ALONGSIDE AND GIVE US
00:56:15.171 --> 00:56:16.406
INFORMATION SO THAT WE COULD DO
00:56:16.473 --> 00:56:19.909
AUTOMATIC PAYMENTS. UM IF YOU'RE
00:56:19.976 --> 00:56:21.478
ON IF YOU'RE RECEIVING FOOD
00:56:21.544 --> 00:56:23.747
STAMPS, FOR EXAMPLE, YOU OUGHT
00:56:23.813 --> 00:56:25.515
TO BE ELIGIBLE. AND THE ANSWER
00:56:25.582 --> 00:56:27.650
IS, UM, IS THAT THERE'S A WAY TO
00:56:27.717 --> 00:56:28.818
DO IT. BUT EVERYTHING IS
00:56:28.885 --> 00:56:30.286
COMPLICATED BY PRIVACY ISSUES
00:56:30.353 --> 00:56:32.155
AND THEN ALSO BY THE FACT THAT
00:56:32.222 --> 00:56:34.057
THAT WE REQUIRE THEM TO DO
00:56:34.124 --> 00:56:37.227
SOMETHING. AND THE DOING
00:56:37.293 --> 00:56:39.362
SOMETHING IS THE PIECE THAT
00:56:39.429 --> 00:56:41.531
BECOMES VERY DIFFICULT BECAUSE
00:56:41.598 --> 00:56:43.733
MANY MANY PEOPLE DON'T TRUST
00:56:43.800 --> 00:56:46.136
GOVERNMENT OR THEY DON'T TRUST
00:56:46.202 --> 00:56:48.972
PROGRAMS AND, UM AND THEN THEIR
00:56:49.038 --> 00:56:50.140
LANGUAGE ISSUES AS YOU SAID, SO
00:56:50.206 --> 00:56:52.475
IT'S I THINK THE MORE THAT WE
00:56:52.542 --> 00:56:53.676
CAN FIGURE OUT HOW TO MAKE THIS
00:56:53.743 --> 00:56:56.246
EASIER FOR PEOPLE TO DO, AND THE
00:56:56.312 --> 00:56:58.314
FACT THAT WE HAVE FORMED AT ALL
00:56:58.381 --> 00:56:59.949
THEY HAVE TO DO IS PUT
00:57:00.016 --> 00:57:01.117
INFORMATION AND SIGN THEIR NAMES
00:57:01.184 --> 00:57:03.353
IS CAN BE REALLY HELPFUL. SO I
00:57:03.419 --> 00:57:05.255
DO APPRECIATE YOUR WORK IN THIS
00:57:05.321 --> 00:57:06.923
AREA AND UM, ALLOW YOU TO
00:57:06.990 --> 00:57:08.158
CONCLUDE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:57:08.224 --> 00:57:12.095
EITHER. VERY GOOD. WE DO HAVE A
00:57:12.162 --> 00:57:13.429
MOTION. THE MOTION IS DO PASS
00:57:13.496 --> 00:57:15.398
AND RE REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:57:15.465 --> 00:57:16.399
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
00:57:16.466 --> 00:57:19.469
ROLL. SENATORS CABALLERO
00:57:19.536 --> 00:57:23.506
CABALLERO, I. NILSSON NILSSON. I
00:57:23.573 --> 00:57:28.878
DURAZO SO I'M HERZBERG WIENER.
00:57:28.945 --> 00:57:32.782
THE BILL IS IT HAS PASSED, BUT
00:57:32.849 --> 00:57:33.917
WE'RE GOING TO WAIT FOR THE
00:57:33.983 --> 00:57:35.351
ABSENT MEMBERS, TOO. JOIN US SO
00:57:35.418 --> 00:57:39.155
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. SO THE
00:57:39.222 --> 00:57:41.424
NEXT ITEM IS ON FILE ITEM NUMBER
00:57:41.491 --> 00:57:44.027
THREE IS ON OUR CONSENT. WE HAVE
00:57:44.093 --> 00:57:45.762
THREE ITEMS. ITEM NUMBER THREE
00:57:45.829 --> 00:57:47.463
NUMBER SEVEN NUMBER EIGHT AND
00:57:47.530 --> 00:57:49.599
NUMBER 17, SO I'LL ENTERTAIN A
00:57:49.666 --> 00:57:51.701
MOTION ON THOSE ON THE CONSENT.
00:57:51.768 --> 00:57:52.902
Mí
00:57:52.969 --> 00:57:57.373
THE ROLL. MOTION IS TO ADOPT THE
00:57:57.440 --> 00:57:58.842
CONTENT CALENDAR. SENATORS
00:57:58.908 --> 00:58:02.679
CABALLERO CABALLERO, I. NILSSON
00:58:02.745 --> 00:58:04.614
NILSSON. I RUSSELL I'M HERTZBERG
00:58:04.681 --> 00:58:10.153
WIENER. WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL
00:58:10.220 --> 00:58:11.287
AS WELL. AND I JUST RECEIVED
00:58:11.354 --> 00:58:14.290
NOTICE THAT FILE ITEM NUMBER 16.
00:58:14.357 --> 00:58:17.927
E A B 23 57 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:58:17.994 --> 00:58:20.063
TING HAS BEEN PULLED SO WE WILL
00:58:20.129 --> 00:58:21.965
NOT BE HEARING IT TODAY AND NEXT
00:58:22.031 --> 00:58:25.768
UP IS FILE ITEM NUMBER NINE. A B
00:58:25.835 --> 00:58:28.671
19 OH, TWO BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:58:28.738 --> 00:58:30.340
AGUIAR-CURRY AND I THANK YOU FOR
00:58:30.406 --> 00:58:31.774
YOUR PATIENCE. YOU'VE BEEN
00:58:31.841 --> 00:58:32.609
WAITING HERE FOR A LONG TIME.
00:58:32.675 --> 00:58:34.110
THAT'S FINE. UM GOOD MORNING,
00:58:34.177 --> 00:58:36.212
MADAM. CHAIR AND MEMBERS. THANK
00:58:36.279 --> 00:58:38.014
YOU TO THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR
00:58:38.081 --> 00:58:39.916
ALL THE WORK ON THIS AND THE
00:58:39.983 --> 00:58:41.517
ANALYSIS ON THIS BILL. A B 19
00:58:41.584 --> 00:58:43.920
OH, TWO MODERNIZES THE RESOURCE
00:58:43.987 --> 00:58:45.722
CONSERVATION DISTRICT LAW TO
00:58:45.788 --> 00:58:47.090
REFLECT CURRENT PRACTICES AND TO
00:58:47.156 --> 00:58:49.058
HIGHLIGHT THE IMPORTANT ROLE OUR
00:58:49.125 --> 00:58:49.792
RESOURCE CONSERVATION DISTRICTS
00:58:49.859 --> 00:58:50.894
ARE PLAYING IN CONDUCTING
00:58:50.960 --> 00:58:51.861
PROJECTS. RELATED TO CLIMATE
00:58:51.928 --> 00:58:56.132
CHANGE. IT ALSO STRENGTHENS
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:57.634
THEIR RELATIONSHIP, THE
00:58:57.700 --> 00:58:58.668
DEPARTMENT OF CONSERVATION AND
00:58:58.735 --> 00:59:01.537
OTHER STATE AGENCIES. RESOURCE
00:59:01.604 --> 00:59:03.039
CONSERVATION DISTRICTS ARE
00:59:03.106 --> 00:59:04.540
SPECIAL DISTRICTS THAT WERE
00:59:04.607 --> 00:59:06.175
FORMED, FIRST FORMED IN THE 19
00:59:06.242 --> 00:59:09.145
THIRTIES TO SERVE AS THE LOCAL
00:59:09.212 --> 00:59:10.046
CONNECTION TO STATE AND FEDERAL
00:59:10.113 --> 00:59:10.980
CONSERVATION PROGRAMS. IN
00:59:11.047 --> 00:59:13.917
RESPONSE TO THE DUST BOWL. SINCE
00:59:13.983 --> 00:59:15.285
THEN, THEIR WORK HAS EXPANDED
00:59:15.351 --> 00:59:17.320
WIDELY TO MEET THE NEEDS OF THE
00:59:17.387 --> 00:59:18.488
RURAL, URBAN AND SUBURBAN
00:59:18.554 --> 00:59:21.157
COMMUNITIES THEY SERVE. HOWEVER
00:59:21.224 --> 00:59:22.759
THE LAW HAS NOT BEEN UPDTED TO
00:59:22.825 --> 00:59:24.093
REFLECT THE CRITICAL OPERATIONS
00:59:24.160 --> 00:59:27.563
AND MANAGEMENT OF OUR CDS TODAY.
00:59:27.630 --> 00:59:29.065
OUR CDS ARE IMPLEMENTING
00:59:29.132 --> 00:59:30.833
PROGRAMS AND PROJECTS THAT ARE
00:59:30.900 --> 00:59:32.101
INCREASING CALIFORNIA'S
00:59:32.168 --> 00:59:34.237
RESILIENCE TO CLIMATE CHANGE.
00:59:34.304 --> 00:59:35.672
MANY ARE WORKING TO IMPROVE
00:59:35.738 --> 00:59:37.006
PROVED FOREST HEALTH SUPPORT.
00:59:37.073 --> 00:59:38.041
HOMEOWNERS CREATE DEFENSIBLE
00:59:38.107 --> 00:59:40.910
SPACES. IMPROVED WATER
00:59:40.977 --> 00:59:42.745
EFFICIENCY WORK TO REDUCE
00:59:42.812 --> 00:59:43.813
FLOODING AND TO RESTORE
00:59:43.880 --> 00:59:46.049
ENDANGERED SPECIES HABITATS.
00:59:46.115 --> 00:59:48.051
PASSING A B 19. OH, TWO WILL
00:59:48.117 --> 00:59:50.286
ENSURE OUR C D S CAN MORE
00:59:50.353 --> 00:59:51.788
EFFECTIVELY PERFORM THEIR WORK
00:59:51.854 --> 00:59:53.756
TO COMBAT AND ADAPT TO CLIMATE
00:59:53.823 --> 00:59:55.758
CHANGE AND MAKE CLEAR THAT THESE
00:59:55.825 --> 00:59:56.526
EXISTING ACTIVITIES ARE
00:59:56.592 --> 00:59:57.460
EXPLICITLY AUTHORIZED IN
00:59:57.527 --> 01:00:01.264
STATUTE. WITH ME TODAY TO
01:00:01.331 --> 01:00:03.066
TESTIFY ON THE PHONE IS KAREN
01:00:03.132 --> 01:00:04.734
BERG, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
01:00:04.801 --> 01:00:07.170
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF RCD S
01:00:07.236 --> 01:00:08.438
. AND I ALSO HAVE MARK FINCHAM
01:00:08.504 --> 01:00:11.407
FINSTER MAKER. FROM THE PACIFIC
01:00:11.474 --> 01:00:13.242
POLICY GROUP TO HEAR THE ANSWER
01:00:13.309 --> 01:00:15.044
QUESTIONS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:00:15.111 --> 01:00:17.747
WE'RE GONNA TURN THE MIC OVER TO
01:00:17.814 --> 01:00:23.553
KAREN BURR. GREAT. THANK YOU SO
01:00:23.619 --> 01:00:24.387
MUCH. I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU
01:00:24.454 --> 01:00:26.155
CARRYING THIS BILL TOMORROW AT
01:00:26.222 --> 01:00:29.025
THIS THIS MORNING. SORRY WE ARE
01:00:29.092 --> 01:00:31.060
PROUD TO SPONSOR MAYBE 19 YEAR
01:00:31.127 --> 01:00:31.461
VERY THANKFUL TO
01:00:31.527 --> 01:00:32.061
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AGUIAR-CURRY
01:00:32.128 --> 01:00:35.098
FOR OFFERING THIS BILL. COME AS
01:00:35.164 --> 01:00:36.599
YOU KNOW. THE 95 ARTICULATION
01:00:36.666 --> 01:00:38.101
ESTATE IMPLEMENT LOCAL PROJECTS
01:00:38.167 --> 01:00:39.202
AT THE INTERSECTION OF
01:00:39.268 --> 01:00:40.603
CONSERVATION, AGRICULTURE AND
01:00:40.670 --> 01:00:41.504
COMMUNITY AND LOCALLY
01:00:41.571 --> 01:00:44.374
APPROPRIATE WAYS. HAND ARE
01:00:44.440 --> 01:00:45.508
EITHER THE FRONT LINE OF
01:00:45.575 --> 01:00:47.110
IMPLEMENTING PROJECTS TO COMBAT
01:00:47.176 --> 01:00:48.311
CLIMATE CHANGE AND ARE CRITICAL
01:00:48.378 --> 01:00:50.079
TO THE FUTURE OF CALIFORNIA.
01:00:50.146 --> 01:00:52.315
RPGS ARE CRUCIAL TO MANY OF THE
01:00:52.382 --> 01:00:53.216
STATE'S EFFORTS, INCLUDING CAL
01:00:53.282 --> 01:00:54.650
FIRES FOREST HEALTH WORK
01:00:54.717 --> 01:00:56.152
CLIMATE, SMART AGRICULTURE. 30
01:00:56.219 --> 01:00:59.155
BY 30. W L. THE NATURAL LOOKING
01:00:59.222 --> 01:01:00.123
LINES IMPLEMENTATION PLANNING,
01:01:00.189 --> 01:01:02.225
AND THAT JUST MEANS A FEW OF THE
01:01:02.291 --> 01:01:03.226
EFFORTS THAT WERE REALLY
01:01:03.292 --> 01:01:04.527
CRITICAL TO DIVISION NOT AS A
01:01:04.594 --> 01:01:06.729
FORMATIVE CODE, AND IT HASN'T
01:01:06.796 --> 01:01:07.930
BEEN UPDATED IN ANY SIGNIFICANT
01:01:07.997 --> 01:01:09.565
WAY IN OVER 30 YEARS. THE CREATE
01:01:09.632 --> 01:01:10.600
SEVERAL STRUCTURAL CHALLENGES
01:01:10.666 --> 01:01:11.601
BARRIERS BETWEEN OUR TVS AND
01:01:11.667 --> 01:01:14.737
RESOURCES. AND OFTEN LEADS TO
01:01:14.804 --> 01:01:16.072
CONFUSION, AND ARTIE B<c.cyan></c>
01:01:16.139 --> 01:01:17.273
INCLUDED IN LEGISLATION THAT
01:01:17.340 --> 01:01:18.441
FUNDS WORK WITH OUR CBS ARE
01:01:18.508 --> 01:01:21.911
AUTHORIZED TO DO MAYBE 1990
01:01:21.978 --> 01:01:23.413
MODERNIZES OUR CITY, ENABLING
01:01:23.479 --> 01:01:24.680
STATUTE TO REFLECT HOW
01:01:24.747 --> 01:01:26.549
CONSERVATION SERVICES OUR CITIES
01:01:26.616 --> 01:01:28.351
ARE PROVIDING HAVE HAD TO ADAPT
01:01:28.418 --> 01:01:31.187
THE REALITIES OF CLIMATE CHANGE.
01:01:31.254 --> 01:01:33.456
MOREOVER 19 OH TWO ALSO IMPROVE
01:01:33.523 --> 01:01:35.458
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN OUR TVS
01:01:35.525 --> 01:01:36.959
AND THE DEPARTMENT OF
01:01:37.026 --> 01:01:37.460
CONSERVATION, AND MOST
01:01:37.527 --> 01:01:38.561
IMPORTANTLY, IT PROVIDES THE
01:01:38.628 --> 01:01:39.462
DEPARTMENT WITH ADDITIONAL TOOLS
01:01:39.529 --> 01:01:41.297
TO ASSIST OUR CBS THAT WE KNOW
01:01:41.364 --> 01:01:43.566
WE NEED. AS THE COMMITTEE
01:01:43.633 --> 01:01:45.101
ANALYSIS. ATHLETE POINTS OUT,
01:01:45.168 --> 01:01:46.736
MOST RPGS RECEIVED VERY LITTLE
01:01:46.803 --> 01:01:48.071
REGULAR FUNDING FOR LOCAL
01:01:48.137 --> 01:01:49.772
TAXATION AND RELY HEAVILY ON
01:01:49.839 --> 01:01:50.807
COMPETITIVE GRANTS AND OTHER
01:01:50.873 --> 01:01:53.576
TYPES OF 18 19. OH, TWO WILL
01:01:53.643 --> 01:01:54.644
BETTER POSITION OUR TVS TO
01:01:54.710 --> 01:01:56.345
RECEIVE THOSE STATE RESOURCES.
01:01:56.412 --> 01:02:00.249
UM 18 19. OH, TWO WILL
01:02:00.316 --> 01:02:01.684
STRENGTHEN ABILITIES OF RCD
01:02:01.751 --> 01:02:03.186
SERVICES TO SERVE THEIR
01:02:03.252 --> 01:02:04.620
COMMUNITIES HAVE ACCESS TO
01:02:04.687 --> 01:02:06.255
RESOURCES AND BETTER IMPLEMENT
01:02:06.322 --> 01:02:07.824
PROJECTS THAT ARE CRITICAL TO
01:02:07.890 --> 01:02:09.392
THE NEEDS OF THE STATE CLIMATE,
01:02:09.459 --> 01:02:10.393
AGRICULTURE AND NATURAL RESOURCE
01:02:10.460 --> 01:02:12.562
CONSERVATION OBJECTIVES. I
01:02:12.628 --> 01:02:14.297
REALLY THANK YOU FOR THE TIME
01:02:14.363 --> 01:02:15.398
THIS MORNING AND SECONDLY,
01:02:15.465 --> 01:02:17.233
REQUESTING I VOTE ON 18 19 OH,
01:02:17.300 --> 01:02:19.869
TWO. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU VERY
01:02:19.936 --> 01:02:21.070
MUCH. WE'RE GONNA CHECK AND SEE
01:02:21.137 --> 01:02:23.439
IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM 2200
01:02:23.506 --> 01:02:25.308
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
01:02:25.374 --> 01:02:27.210
SUPPORT. YES. GOOD MORNING,
01:02:27.276 --> 01:02:29.545
MADAM. CHAIR MARK FINSTER MAKER
01:02:29.612 --> 01:02:30.046
REGISTERING SUPPORT FOR
01:02:30.113 --> 01:02:30.713
SUSTAINABLE CONSERVATION. THANK
01:02:30.780 --> 01:02:31.547
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
01:02:31.614 --> 01:02:35.918
THERE ANYONE ELSE? SEEING THEN
01:02:35.985 --> 01:02:36.385
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
01:02:36.452 --> 01:02:37.220
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IF YOU
01:02:37.286 --> 01:02:38.454
COULD PLEASE QUEUE UP.
01:02:38.521 --> 01:02:39.689
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:02:39.755 --> 01:02:44.260
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:02:44.327 --> 01:02:46.596
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT,
01:02:46.662 --> 01:02:47.730
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO AT
01:02:47.797 --> 01:02:49.799
THIS TIME. IN ONE MOMENT WHILE
01:02:49.866 --> 01:03:06.182
WE GET LINE NUMBERS.
01:03:11.721 --> 01:03:13.189
FIRST WE HAVE LINE NUMBER ONE.
01:03:13.256 --> 01:03:18.327
OH, EIGHT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. UM.
01:03:18.394 --> 01:03:19.529
HI. I JUST WANTED TO STRONGLY
01:03:19.595 --> 01:03:25.001
SUPPORT. UM. UM A B 19 OH, TWO.
01:03:25.067 --> 01:03:26.269
I'M ELIZABETH HENRY FROM
01:03:26.335 --> 01:03:28.104
LAFAYETTE, CALIFORNIA AND
01:03:28.171 --> 01:03:30.273
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA. UM, SAY
01:03:30.339 --> 01:03:34.177
BLOCK YET. AND THAT'S IT.
01:03:34.243 --> 01:03:35.678
STRONG, STRONGLY SUPPORT. THANK
01:03:35.745 --> 01:03:41.751
YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU. AND THAT
01:03:41.817 --> 01:03:45.054
IS ALL THAT I HAVE IN QUÊ. VERY
01:03:45.121 --> 01:03:47.123
GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
01:03:47.190 --> 01:03:49.192
THE LEAD OPPOSITION. THE WITNESS
01:03:49.258 --> 01:03:51.661
IS REBECCA MARCUS FROM THE
01:03:51.727 --> 01:03:53.329
GUADALUPE COYOTE RESOURCE
01:03:53.396 --> 01:03:54.363
CONSERVATION DISTRICT, AND SHE'S
01:03:54.430 --> 01:03:57.700
IN PERSON WELCOME. GOOD MORNING
01:03:57.767 --> 01:03:59.268
SHARON MEMBERS REBECCA MARCUS ON
01:03:59.335 --> 01:04:01.404
BEHALF OF SEVERAL R. C. D S,
01:04:01.470 --> 01:04:02.505
INCLUDING THE GUADALUPE COYOTE,
01:04:02.572 --> 01:04:04.340
RIVERSIDE, CORONA, LOMA PRIETA
01:04:04.407 --> 01:04:06.008
AND SAN JOAQUIN. OUR CDS THAT
01:04:06.075 --> 01:04:07.276
ARE LOCATED ACROSS THE STATE AND
01:04:07.343 --> 01:04:08.277
REPRESENTED DIVERSITY OF
01:04:08.344 --> 01:04:08.711
LANDOWNERS AND OTHER
01:04:08.778 --> 01:04:11.280
CONSTITUENTS. WE HAVE AN OPPOSED
01:04:11.347 --> 01:04:14.083
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION ON 19029
01:04:14.150 --> 01:04:15.651
1ST LIKE TO BEGIN BY THANKING
01:04:15.718 --> 01:04:17.086
THE AUTHOR AND HER STAFF ON
01:04:17.153 --> 01:04:18.754
WORKING WITH THESE ARE CDS AND
01:04:18.821 --> 01:04:21.057
AGREEING TO THE MAJORITY OF THE
01:04:21.123 --> 01:04:22.158
AMENDMENTS PROPOSED AS REFLECTED
01:04:22.225 --> 01:04:23.292
IN THE CURRENT VERSION OF THE
01:04:23.359 --> 01:04:24.594
BILL. OPPOSITION IS NARROWLY
01:04:24.660 --> 01:04:26.395
FOCUSED ON THE CONCERN THAT A B
01:04:26.462 --> 01:04:29.165
19 OH TWO DOES NOT ADEQUATELY
01:04:29.232 --> 01:04:30.633
ADEQUATELY ENSURE ALL OUR CDS
01:04:30.700 --> 01:04:31.968
HAVE EQUITABLE ACCESS TO THE
01:04:32.034 --> 01:04:33.135
STATE FUNDING THAT IS DESCRIBED
01:04:33.202 --> 01:04:35.338
IN THE BILL. INDIVIDUAL OUR CDS
01:04:35.404 --> 01:04:36.839
ARE FUNDED DIFFERENTLY. SOME
01:04:36.906 --> 01:04:38.341
RECEIVE VARYING PERCENTAGES OF
01:04:38.407 --> 01:04:39.842
LOCAL PROPERTY TAXES, WHEREAS
01:04:39.909 --> 01:04:41.510
OTHERS RELY ON GRANT FUNDING AND
01:04:41.577 --> 01:04:43.846
FEES FOR SERVICE. AS A RESULT,
01:04:43.913 --> 01:04:44.313
THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT
01:04:44.380 --> 01:04:44.814
DISCREPANCIES AND FUNDS
01:04:44.880 --> 01:04:47.583
INDIVIDUAL RCD S HAVE ON HAND.
01:04:47.650 --> 01:04:48.818
TO SUPPORT THEIR RESPECTIVE
01:04:48.884 --> 01:04:50.453
PROGRAMS TO THE EXTENT THAT
01:04:50.519 --> 01:04:51.854
PROPOSED LEGISLATION CONSISTENT
01:04:51.921 --> 01:04:53.623
CONDITIONS ACCESS TO STATE FUNDS
01:04:53.689 --> 01:04:55.157
ON CRITERIA THAT ARE DEPENDENT
01:04:55.224 --> 01:04:57.860
ON ALREADY HAVING FUNDS ON HAND
01:04:57.927 --> 01:04:59.528
. THE RESULT MAY WILL BE TO CUT
01:04:59.595 --> 01:05:01.230
OFF FUNDING TO THE RCD S THAT
01:05:01.297 --> 01:05:03.566
MAY NEED IT MOST AND THAT ARE
01:05:03.633 --> 01:05:04.800
MOST LIKELY TO REPRESENT
01:05:04.867 --> 01:05:05.301
HISTORICALLY UNDERSERVED
01:05:05.368 --> 01:05:06.636
CONSTITUENCIES. FURTHER THE
01:05:06.702 --> 01:05:08.170
CURRENT VERSION OF ABBY 19. OH,
01:05:08.237 --> 01:05:09.839
TWO, DOES NOT CONSIDER OR
01:05:09.905 --> 01:05:10.439
ADDRESS WHETHER THE EMERGING
01:05:10.506 --> 01:05:11.607
PRACTICE OF STATE AGENCIES
01:05:11.674 --> 01:05:13.242
ALLOCATING STATE FUNDS EARMARKED
01:05:13.309 --> 01:05:14.443
FOR OUR CDS VIA BLOCK GRANTS
01:05:14.510 --> 01:05:17.346
PROVIDED DIRECTLY TO CALIFORNIA
01:05:17.413 --> 01:05:18.648
, OUR CITY INTERFERES WITH THE
01:05:18.714 --> 01:05:19.615
GOAL OF ENSURING ALL RCD
01:05:19.682 --> 01:05:21.584
STATEWIDE ARE ABLE TO PERFORM
01:05:21.651 --> 01:05:23.152
THEIR WORK EFFECTIVELY. WE LOOK
01:05:23.219 --> 01:05:24.520
FORWARD TO OUR CONTINUED
01:05:24.587 --> 01:05:25.588
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE AUTHOR'S
01:05:25.655 --> 01:05:26.555
OFFICE. WE'RE ACTUALLY MEETING
01:05:26.622 --> 01:05:29.091
LATER THIS WEEK. AND ONCE AGAIN
01:05:29.158 --> 01:05:30.092
THANK THE MEMBER FOR
01:05:30.159 --> 01:05:31.260
INCORPORATING MANY OF OUR
01:05:31.327 --> 01:05:32.862
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. THANK YOU.
01:05:32.928 --> 01:05:34.797
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
01:05:34.864 --> 01:05:36.265
ANYONE ELSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:05:36.332 --> 01:05:37.333
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION IN ROOM
01:05:37.400 --> 01:05:40.136
2200? SEEING THEN WE'LL MOVE ON
01:05:40.202 --> 01:05:41.637
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS
01:05:41.704 --> 01:05:42.738
THERE ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
01:05:42.805 --> 01:05:44.540
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION ON THE
01:05:44.607 --> 01:05:48.611
TELECONFERENCE LINE? TO SPEAK IN
01:05:48.678 --> 01:05:49.645
OPPOSITION. PLEASE PRESS ONE,
01:05:49.712 --> 01:05:52.581
THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. IN ONE
01:05:52.648 --> 01:05:53.649
MOMENT WHILE WE GET LINE
01:05:53.716 --> 01:06:09.832
NUMBERS.
01:06:11.000 --> 01:06:12.401
MHM FIRST WE HAVE LINE 1 15,
01:06:12.468 --> 01:06:17.440
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS
01:06:17.506 --> 01:06:19.408
SARAH LOCAL BE REGISTERED VOTER
01:06:19.475 --> 01:06:21.410
IN SENATE-DISTRICT. NINE, AND I
01:06:21.477 --> 01:06:23.079
AGREE WITH THE OPPOSITION.
01:06:23.145 --> 01:06:24.080
UNLESS AMENDED POSITION. THANK
01:06:24.146 --> 01:06:31.587
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. CUTE
01:06:31.654 --> 01:06:34.990
AND THAT IS ALL I HAVE IN. Q
01:06:35.057 --> 01:06:35.658
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE GONNA
01:06:35.725 --> 01:06:37.893
BRING THIS BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:06:37.960 --> 01:06:42.598
FOR COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS. UM
01:06:42.665 --> 01:06:44.066
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S I, THE
01:06:44.133 --> 01:06:45.668
OPPOSITION RAISES ARE THE
01:06:45.735 --> 01:06:48.337
OPPOSITION IF AMENDED, RAISES A
01:06:48.404 --> 01:06:50.139
GOOD POINT, AND I AND I KNOW
01:06:50.206 --> 01:06:51.340
THAT, UM YOU'RE VERY SENSITIVE
01:06:51.407 --> 01:06:56.412
TO THE PLIGHT OF INEQUALITIES IN
01:06:56.479 --> 01:06:57.713
OUR SYSTEM. I REALLY LIKE THIS
01:06:57.780 --> 01:07:01.384
BELL. IT'S UM I HAD NOT REALIZED
01:07:01.450 --> 01:07:06.489
THAT WE THAT THAT THAT. THAT WE
01:07:06.555 --> 01:07:08.691
REALLY HAVEN'T SET IT UP TO BE
01:07:08.758 --> 01:07:11.060
ABLE TO BE AS, UM, BROAD AND
01:07:11.127 --> 01:07:13.095
EXPANSIVE IN ITS CONSERVATION
01:07:13.162 --> 01:07:16.198
GOALS AS WE NEED TO BE, AND SO I
01:07:16.265 --> 01:07:17.933
DO APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
01:07:18.000 --> 01:07:19.668
FORWARD, BUT I AM SENSITIVE TO
01:07:19.735 --> 01:07:21.137
THE TO THE ISSUES RELATED TO TWO
01:07:21.203 --> 01:07:24.540
FUNDS. AND I'M HOPING THAT
01:07:24.607 --> 01:07:26.041
YOU'LL MAKE THE COMMITMENT TO
01:07:26.108 --> 01:07:27.743
CONTINUE WORKING ON THAT BECAUSE
01:07:27.810 --> 01:07:28.911
I KNOW THAT'S IMPORTANT TO YOU
01:07:28.978 --> 01:07:31.113
AS WELL. AND THE FACT THAT EACH
01:07:31.180 --> 01:07:32.314
DISTRICT HAS A DIFFERENT WAY OF
01:07:32.381 --> 01:07:35.584
FUNDING THEMSELVES. UM WE MAY
01:07:35.651 --> 01:07:37.820
WANT TO LOOK AT SOME TIME DOWN
01:07:37.887 --> 01:07:39.021
THE ROAD FIXING THAT. SO THERE'S
01:07:39.088 --> 01:07:43.025
A UH, SOURCE, A CONSISTENCY AND
01:07:43.092 --> 01:07:44.360
A SOURCE OF REVENUE THAT HELPS
01:07:44.427 --> 01:07:47.029
THEM TO MEET THE NEEDS BECAUSE
01:07:47.096 --> 01:07:48.531
BECAUSE IT'S PRETTY HARD TO DO
01:07:48.597 --> 01:07:49.098
SOMETHING WHEN YOU HAVE NO
01:07:49.165 --> 01:07:51.066
MONEY, SO I APPRECIATE THAT. SO
01:07:51.133 --> 01:07:52.902
IF YOU COULD ADDRESS THAT, I'M
01:07:52.968 --> 01:07:54.470
I'M PREPARED TO SUPPORT THIS
01:07:54.537 --> 01:07:55.704
TODAY. I THINK IT'S A REALLY
01:07:55.771 --> 01:07:58.441
GOOD BILL. ABSOLUTELY, UM UM, SO
01:07:58.507 --> 01:08:00.009
WE HAVE TRIED TO INCLUDE EVERY
01:08:00.075 --> 01:08:02.011
STAKEHOLDER IN THIS BILL PROCESS
01:08:02.077 --> 01:08:03.612
, AND CALIFORNIA RCD, THE
01:08:03.679 --> 01:08:05.281
SPONSOR OF THIS BILL ENCOMPASSES
01:08:05.347 --> 01:08:07.283
82 OF THE ESTIMATED 85 OUR
01:08:07.349 --> 01:08:08.451
CITIES IN THE STATE, AND
01:08:08.517 --> 01:08:10.386
OBVIOUSLY NOT EVERYTHING. WE
01:08:10.453 --> 01:08:11.821
DON'T WANT TO LEAVE ANYBODY
01:08:11.887 --> 01:08:13.389
BEHIND. IT'S NEVER MY INTENTION
01:08:13.456 --> 01:08:14.890
TO DO SO. I WILL CONTINUE TO
01:08:14.957 --> 01:08:17.126
WORK WITH THEM. AND WE DO HAVE A
01:08:17.193 --> 01:08:18.828
MEETING SET UP AS THE OPPOSITION
01:08:18.894 --> 01:08:20.963
HAS STATED, SO I WILL CONTINUE
01:08:21.030 --> 01:08:22.765
TO WORK WITH THEM. BUT ISN'T IT
01:08:22.832 --> 01:08:24.300
AMAZING THAT AFTER 30 YEARS
01:08:24.366 --> 01:08:25.701
WE'RE FINALLY REALIZING THE RC
01:08:25.768 --> 01:08:27.403
DAYS HAVE NOT BEEN FUNDED AND WE
01:08:27.470 --> 01:08:29.338
ASKED SO MUCH OF THEM, AND I
01:08:29.405 --> 01:08:31.540
THINK THIS IS A REALLY GOOD BILL
01:08:31.607 --> 01:08:32.708
UP AND DOWN THE STATE OF
01:08:32.775 --> 01:08:34.143
CALIFORNIA. I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:08:34.210 --> 01:08:35.444
FOR YOUR I VOTE. THANK YOU SO
01:08:35.511 --> 01:08:37.213
MUCH, SO I'LL ENTERTAIN A
01:08:37.279 --> 01:08:40.449
MOTION. SENATOR GRASSO MOVES THE
01:08:40.516 --> 01:08:41.917
MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
01:08:41.984 --> 01:08:43.853
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:08:43.919 --> 01:08:44.487
NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER. UM,
01:08:44.553 --> 01:08:49.091
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
01:08:49.158 --> 01:08:51.894
CABALLERO CAVALLERO. AYE NILSSON
01:08:51.961 --> 01:08:56.031
. NILSSON. I DO SO YOU'RE A SO I
01:08:56.098 --> 01:08:59.702
HERZBERG WIENER. YOU HAVE
01:08:59.768 --> 01:09:00.603
SUFFICIENT VOTES, BUT WE'RE
01:09:00.669 --> 01:09:02.304
GOING TO PUT IT ON CALL. THANK
01:09:02.371 --> 01:09:03.372
YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU
01:09:03.439 --> 01:09:04.273
APPRECIATE IT. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:09:04.340 --> 01:09:08.511
FRIEDMAN. WE'RE ON TO FILE ITEM
01:09:08.577 --> 01:09:11.614
NUMBER 10, WHICH IS A B 2097
01:09:11.680 --> 01:09:13.716
WELCOME. THANK YOU SO MUCH. AND
01:09:13.782 --> 01:09:15.384
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR FOR YOUR
01:09:15.451 --> 01:09:17.653
WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH ME ON
01:09:17.720 --> 01:09:18.821
THIS BILL AND YOUR STAFF AS
01:09:18.888 --> 01:09:20.389
WELL. THIS IS A BILL THAT HAS
01:09:20.456 --> 01:09:21.824
RECEIVED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN
01:09:21.891 --> 01:09:25.828
THE ASSEMBLY. AND, UM IT IS A
01:09:25.895 --> 01:09:28.130
BILL THAT IS DESIGNED TO HELP US
01:09:28.197 --> 01:09:29.999
WITH THE PRODUCTION OF HOUSING
01:09:30.065 --> 01:09:31.734
AS WELL AS TO REVITALIZE
01:09:31.800 --> 01:09:32.868
COMMERCIAL AREAS. THE AMENDMENTS
01:09:32.935 --> 01:09:34.637
THAT WE ARE TAKING IN THIS
01:09:34.703 --> 01:09:37.506
COMMITTEE WILL ARE BASED ON THE
01:09:37.573 --> 01:09:39.542
CHAIRS FEELING THAT WE NEEDED TO
01:09:39.608 --> 01:09:41.911
PROVIDE MORE FLEXIBILITY TO
01:09:41.977 --> 01:09:43.112
RURAL AREAS AND SMALLER
01:09:43.178 --> 01:09:44.246
COMMUNITIES AND WE ARE VERY
01:09:44.313 --> 01:09:46.148
HAPPY TO DO THAT. THESE
01:09:46.215 --> 01:09:47.516
AMENDMENTS SAY THAT WITHIN A
01:09:47.583 --> 01:09:48.717
COUNTY OF A POPULATION OF
01:09:48.784 --> 01:09:50.486
600,000, OR MORE NO PARKING
01:09:50.553 --> 01:09:52.488
MINIMUM IF THE PARCEL IS LOCATED
01:09:52.555 --> 01:09:53.656
ONE HALF MILE OF MAJOR TRANSIT
01:09:53.722 --> 01:09:55.624
STOP AS SPECIFIED IN A CITY WITH
01:09:55.691 --> 01:09:58.127
A POPULATION OF 75,000, OR MORE
01:09:58.193 --> 01:09:59.595
THAT IS LOCATED IN THE COUNTY OF
01:09:59.662 --> 01:10:01.997
LESS THAN 600,000 RESIDENTS. NO
01:10:02.064 --> 01:10:02.698
PARKING MINIMUM OF THE PARKING
01:10:02.765 --> 01:10:04.500
IS THE PARCEL IS LOCATED WITHIN
01:10:04.567 --> 01:10:05.734
ONE QUARTER MILE OF PUBLIC
01:10:05.801 --> 01:10:08.003
TRANSIT IS SPECIFIED AND A CITY
01:10:08.070 --> 01:10:09.838
WITH A POPULATION OF LESS THAN
01:10:09.905 --> 01:10:10.873
75,000, OR COUNTY WITH A
01:10:10.940 --> 01:10:13.642
POPULATION OF 600,000. OTHER OR
01:10:13.709 --> 01:10:16.045
LOWER TO ADOPT AN ORDINANCE OR
01:10:16.111 --> 01:10:17.246
RESOLUTION THAT APPLIES THE
01:10:17.313 --> 01:10:19.348
PROVISIONS, AS NOTED ABOVE, UM
01:10:19.415 --> 01:10:20.516
AT THE DISCRETION OF THAT
01:10:20.583 --> 01:10:23.719
MUNICIPALITY. SO WHAT IS THIS
01:10:23.786 --> 01:10:25.054
BILL ABOUT THIS BILL IS ABOUT
01:10:25.120 --> 01:10:27.056
PROPERTY RIGHTS AT ITS CORE AND
01:10:27.122 --> 01:10:28.524
MAKING SURE THAT DEVELOPERS ARE
01:10:28.591 --> 01:10:29.692
ABLE TO PROVIDE THE AMOUNT OF
01:10:29.758 --> 01:10:31.093
PARKING THAT THEY FEEL THAT
01:10:31.160 --> 01:10:32.261
THEIR PROPERTY NEEDS RATHER THAN
01:10:32.328 --> 01:10:33.662
A ONE SIZE FITS ALL REQUIREMENT
01:10:33.729 --> 01:10:36.231
FROM THE MUNICIPALITY. MANY
01:10:36.298 --> 01:10:37.766
CITIES IN CALIFORNIA REQUIRE NEW
01:10:37.833 --> 01:10:38.467
RESIDENTIAL OR COMMERCIAL
01:10:38.534 --> 01:10:39.602
DEVELOPMENT TO PROVIDE ON SITE
01:10:39.668 --> 01:10:42.738
PARKING SPACES. OFTEN APARTMENT
01:10:42.805 --> 01:10:44.607
MUST INCLUDE ONE OR TWO PARKING
01:10:44.673 --> 01:10:46.141
SPOTS PER UNIT, AND COMMERCIAL
01:10:46.208 --> 01:10:47.810
PROPERTIES MUST PROVIDE ONE
01:10:47.876 --> 01:10:49.712
SPACE FOR EVERY 100 TO 200
01:10:49.778 --> 01:10:51.547
SQUARE FEET, FREQUENTLY, CAUSING
01:10:51.614 --> 01:10:52.781
MORE SPACE TO BE PROVIDED FOR
01:10:52.848 --> 01:10:54.516
PARKING AND FOR THE BUSINESS
01:10:54.583 --> 01:10:56.118
ITSELF. IN OUR COMMUNITY. WE'VE
01:10:56.185 --> 01:10:57.620
HAD SITUATIONS WHERE OLDER
01:10:57.686 --> 01:10:58.587
BUILDINGS THAT DIDN'T HAVE A LOT
01:10:58.654 --> 01:11:00.122
OF PARKING SAT VACANT BECAUSE
01:11:00.189 --> 01:11:01.457
THE CITY WOULDN'T ALLOW ANYONE
01:11:01.523 --> 01:11:02.424
NEW TO MOVE IN BECAUSE THEY
01:11:02.491 --> 01:11:04.426
COULDN'T HAVE ENOUGH PARKING. SO
01:11:04.493 --> 01:11:06.595
WE CHANGED THAT ORDINANCE IN
01:11:06.662 --> 01:11:07.396
GLENDALE. IT DIDN'T LEAD TO ANY
01:11:07.463 --> 01:11:09.665
ISSUES, BUT IT DID ALLOW FOR
01:11:09.732 --> 01:11:10.366
THAT COMMERCIAL SPACE TO BE
01:11:10.432 --> 01:11:12.635
UTILIZED. NOW, THESE ONE SIZE
01:11:12.701 --> 01:11:14.370
FITS ALL MANDATES ARE OFTEN
01:11:14.436 --> 01:11:15.871
IMPOSED EVEN IN AREAS THAT ARE
01:11:15.938 --> 01:11:17.306
CLOSE TO HIGH QUALITY TRANSIT,
01:11:17.373 --> 01:11:19.408
HIGH QUALITY BEING TRAINED STOPS
01:11:19.475 --> 01:11:21.276
LIGHT RAIL OR MAJOR BUST OFFS
01:11:21.343 --> 01:11:23.212
THAT HAVE MULTIPLE BUS LINES.
01:11:23.278 --> 01:11:24.480
MANDATORY PARKING REQUIREMENTS
01:11:24.546 --> 01:11:26.248
HAVE LED TO AN OVERSUPPLY OF
01:11:26.315 --> 01:11:27.750
PARKING SPACES. LOS ANGELES
01:11:27.816 --> 01:11:29.852
COUNTY ALONE HAS AN ASTONISHING
01:11:29.918 --> 01:11:33.222
18.6 MILLION PARKING SPACES THAT
01:11:33.288 --> 01:11:34.523
IS TWO PARKING SPACES FOR EVERY
01:11:34.590 --> 01:11:37.726
RESIDENT. WE DON'T HAVE THAT
01:11:37.793 --> 01:11:39.228
MANY APARTMENTS FOR ALL OF OUR
01:11:39.294 --> 01:11:40.329
PEOPLE ARE THAT MANY BEDS FOR
01:11:40.396 --> 01:11:42.264
ALL OF OUR PEOPLE, AND YET WE DO
01:11:42.331 --> 01:11:44.833
HAVE THE SPACE FOR CARS IN L, A
01:11:44.900 --> 01:11:46.669
COUNTY ALONE PARKING MAN AND
01:11:46.735 --> 01:11:48.837
HAVE LED TO AN ASTONISHING 200
01:11:48.904 --> 01:11:51.240
MILES OF SQUARE PARKING. 200
01:11:51.306 --> 01:11:52.741
MILES SQUARE MILES OF PARKING,
01:11:52.808 --> 01:11:54.343
WHICH IS FOUR TIMES AS MUCH LAND
01:11:54.410 --> 01:11:55.911
AS THE ENTIRE CITY OF SAN
01:11:55.978 --> 01:11:57.346
FRANCISCO. WHERE ARE OUR
01:11:57.413 --> 01:11:59.615
PRIORITIES? THIS POLICY
01:11:59.682 --> 01:12:00.716
ENCOURAGES CAR DEPENDENCE AND
01:12:00.783 --> 01:12:01.717
DISCOURAGES MASS TRANSIT USAGE.
01:12:01.784 --> 01:12:02.685
INCREASING VEHICLE MILES
01:12:02.751 --> 01:12:06.355
TRAVELED. MANDATORY PARKING
01:12:06.422 --> 01:12:07.356
REQUIREMENTS ALSO WORSEN
01:12:07.423 --> 01:12:08.724
CALIFORNIA SEVERE HOUSING
01:12:08.791 --> 01:12:10.392
SHORTAGE BY RAISING THE COST OF
01:12:10.459 --> 01:12:11.894
HOUSING PRODUCTION. ON AVERAGE,
01:12:11.960 --> 01:12:14.163
A GARAGE COSTS BETWEEN 24,000
01:12:14.229 --> 01:12:15.731
AND 34,000 PER SPACE TO BUILD
01:12:15.798 --> 01:12:17.566
AND CAN EVEN BE HIGHER THAN
01:12:17.633 --> 01:12:19.201
THAT. AND THAT COST IS PASSED ON
01:12:19.268 --> 01:12:21.303
DIRECTLY TO HOUSEHOLDS OR TO
01:12:21.370 --> 01:12:22.471
RENTERS, WHETHER OR NOT THEY OWN
01:12:22.538 --> 01:12:25.607
A CAR. ADDITIONALLY ON SITE
01:12:25.674 --> 01:12:26.909
PARKING TAKES UP SPACES THAT
01:12:26.975 --> 01:12:28.110
COULD OTHERWISE BE USED FOR
01:12:28.177 --> 01:12:29.078
ADDITIONAL PARKING UNITS.
01:12:29.144 --> 01:12:31.180
ADDITIONAL APARTMENT UNITS NOW
01:12:31.246 --> 01:12:32.781
SAN DIEGO ELIMINATED MINIMUM
01:12:32.848 --> 01:12:33.682
PARKING REQUIREMENTS IN TRANSIT
01:12:33.749 --> 01:12:38.120
PRIORITY ZONES IN 2019. IN 2020
01:12:38.187 --> 01:12:39.822
, THE CITY SAW MORE THAN FOUR
01:12:39.888 --> 01:12:41.323
TIMES INCREASE IN AFFORDABLE
01:12:41.390 --> 01:12:42.424
HOUSING UNITS PRODUCED IN THAT
01:12:42.491 --> 01:12:48.097
AREA. NOW UNDER A B 2097 FOR A
01:12:48.163 --> 01:12:49.698
PROJECT TO QUALIFY FOR THIS
01:12:49.765 --> 01:12:51.133
ELIMINATION OF THE MINIMUMS, THE
01:12:51.200 --> 01:12:53.202
PROJECT MUST EITHER BE NO MORE
01:12:53.268 --> 01:12:55.804
THAN 40 UNITS OF HOUSING. OR AT
01:12:55.871 --> 01:12:59.975
LEAST 11% VERY LOW INCOME OR 20%
01:13:00.042 --> 01:13:01.276
LOW INCOME OR 40% MODERATE
01:13:01.343 --> 01:13:04.046
INCOME. HOUSING UNITS RESTRICTED
01:13:04.113 --> 01:13:07.750
FOR AT LEAST 55 YEARS. THE BUILD
01:13:07.816 --> 01:13:08.650
IS NOT WAIVE ANY LOCAL
01:13:08.717 --> 01:13:10.252
INCLUSIONARY OR AFFORDABLE
01:13:10.319 --> 01:13:11.053
HOUSING IMPACT FEES IMPLIED BY
01:13:11.120 --> 01:13:14.623
JURISDICTIONS. THE BILL DOES NOT
01:13:14.690 --> 01:13:15.724
PREVENT PARKING OWNERS FROM
01:13:15.791 --> 01:13:17.059
PROVIDING AS MUCH ON SITE
01:13:17.126 --> 01:13:18.761
PARKING AS THEY FEEL THEY NEED.
01:13:18.827 --> 01:13:20.195
AND IN SAN DIEGO, WE SAW THAT
01:13:20.262 --> 01:13:21.130
INDEED, THESE BUILDINGS DID
01:13:21.196 --> 01:13:22.364
PROVIDE PARKING, BUT THEY WERE
01:13:22.431 --> 01:13:25.067
ABLE TO RIGHT SIZE THEM AND IN
01:13:25.134 --> 01:13:26.168
MANY CASES OFFER UNITS FOR
01:13:26.235 --> 01:13:27.736
PEOPLE WHO DIDN'T HAVE CARS FOR
01:13:27.803 --> 01:13:28.704
LESS MONEY. THE BILL CONTINUES
01:13:28.771 --> 01:13:29.671
TO REQUIRE PARKING FOR THE
01:13:29.738 --> 01:13:31.640
DISABLED AND FOR ELECTRIC CARS.
01:13:31.707 --> 01:13:33.108
THE MEASURE WOULD REDUCE CAR
01:13:33.175 --> 01:13:34.610
DEPENDENCE, LOWER CARBON
01:13:34.676 --> 01:13:35.511
EMISSIONS AND ENCOURAGE MORE
01:13:35.577 --> 01:13:37.646
HOUSING PRODUCTION NEAR TRANSIT
01:13:37.713 --> 01:13:39.181
AND ALSO GIVE OUR MASS MASS
01:13:39.248 --> 01:13:41.049
TRANSIT WHICH WE HAVE ALL
01:13:41.116 --> 01:13:42.117
INVESTED BILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN
01:13:42.184 --> 01:13:44.486
THE STATE. A BETTER CHANCE OF
01:13:44.553 --> 01:13:47.756
BEING UTILIZED AND USED A B 2097
01:13:47.823 --> 01:13:49.758
IS SPONSORED BY THE CALIFORNIA
01:13:49.825 --> 01:13:51.393
UM BE SUPER ABUNDANT HOUSING L A
01:13:51.460 --> 01:13:52.494
AND THE COUNCIL OF INFO
01:13:52.561 --> 01:13:55.097
BUILDERS. IT IS SUPPORTED BY THE
01:13:55.164 --> 01:13:56.765
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
01:13:56.832 --> 01:13:58.133
ASSOCIATION, THE CITY OF SAN
01:13:58.200 --> 01:13:59.401
DIEGO, THE SILICON VALLEY
01:13:59.468 --> 01:14:00.602
LEADERSHIP GROUP, THE BARRIER
01:14:00.669 --> 01:14:01.937
COUNCIL, THE ASIAN BUSINESS
01:14:02.004 --> 01:14:04.039
ASSOCIATION, SIERRA CLUB, THE
01:14:04.106 --> 01:14:05.407
LOS ANGELES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:14:05.474 --> 01:14:06.308
, THE CALIFORNIA APARTMENT
01:14:06.375 --> 01:14:09.011
ASSOCIATION AND TRANSFORM
01:14:09.077 --> 01:14:11.146
TESTIFYING TODAY AND SUPPORT OUR
01:14:11.213 --> 01:14:12.147
COUNCIL MEMBER ZACH HILTON FROM
01:14:12.214 --> 01:14:14.316
GILROY AND ME, A KING, SENIOR
01:14:14.383 --> 01:14:15.684
VICE PRESIDENT WITH RELATED
01:14:15.751 --> 01:14:17.286
CALIFORNIA AND DIRECTOR OF THE
01:14:17.352 --> 01:14:18.453
COUNCIL OF INFILL BOAT BUILDERS,
01:14:18.520 --> 01:14:20.255
WHO WAS HERE IN PERSON. I WOULD
01:14:20.322 --> 01:14:21.490
ASK YOU TO VOTE AYE. ON THIS
01:14:21.557 --> 01:14:24.259
IMPORTANT POLICY. VERY GOOD. LET
01:14:24.326 --> 01:14:26.862
US START, UM, WITH EITHER ME A
01:14:26.929 --> 01:14:29.164
KING OR ZACH HILTON. ACTUALLY
01:14:29.231 --> 01:14:30.332
WHY DON'T WE START WITH MAKING
01:14:30.399 --> 01:14:32.067
SHE'S HERE IN PERSON, AND THEN
01:14:32.134 --> 01:14:34.069
WE'LL GO TO ZACK. THANK YOU.
01:14:34.136 --> 01:14:36.271
CHAIR ME A KING WITH THE COUNCIL
01:14:36.338 --> 01:14:37.105
OF INFILL BUILDERS, ONE OF THE
01:14:37.172 --> 01:14:40.409
PROUD SPONSORS OF A V, UH, 2097
01:14:40.475 --> 01:14:41.610
. THIS IS THE TIME TO MAKE
01:14:41.677 --> 01:14:46.114
PARKING. NOT A REQUIREMENT, BUT
01:14:46.181 --> 01:14:48.283
LET IT BE MARKET DRIVEN. WE ARE
01:14:48.350 --> 01:14:50.285
AT A TIME NOW WHERE WE HAVE A
01:14:50.352 --> 01:14:51.420
HOUSING CRISIS AND WE HAVE A
01:14:51.486 --> 01:14:53.722
CLIMATE CRISIS AND BOTH OF THOSE
01:14:53.789 --> 01:14:55.791
SIMILARITIES. WE RELY ON THE
01:14:55.858 --> 01:14:57.459
FACT THAT WE HAVE SINGLE USE
01:14:57.526 --> 01:14:58.727
CARS, AND WE HAVE A POLICY THAT
01:14:58.794 --> 01:15:00.929
INCREASES HOW MUCH DEPENDENCY WE
01:15:00.996 --> 01:15:02.631
HAVE ON CARS BY FREE PARKING
01:15:02.698 --> 01:15:04.032
THAT'S ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN
01:15:04.099 --> 01:15:05.601
TALKED ABOUT IN IN LOS ANGELES
01:15:05.667 --> 01:15:07.135
OR SEVEN PARKING SPACES FOR
01:15:07.202 --> 01:15:08.670
EVERY SINGLE CAR IN L. A A
01:15:08.737 --> 01:15:10.806
SINGLE PARKING SPACES OVER 200
01:15:10.873 --> 01:15:12.908
SQUARE FEET. THE SORROWS THAT
01:15:12.975 --> 01:15:14.409
WE'RE BUILDING RIGHT NOW OR 250
01:15:14.476 --> 01:15:16.211
SQUARE FEET. IT'S NOW TIME THAT
01:15:16.278 --> 01:15:18.146
WE PRIORITIZE BUILDING HOUSING
01:15:18.213 --> 01:15:19.281
FOR PEOPLE OVER BUILDING HOUSING
01:15:19.348 --> 01:15:22.751
FOR CARS THAT FRANKLY, THE
01:15:22.818 --> 01:15:24.119
MILLENNIALS AND SENIORS ARE
01:15:24.186 --> 01:15:25.888
HAVING LESS OWNERSHIP OF CARS SO
01:15:25.954 --> 01:15:28.423
IN, ACCORDING TO THE SURVEY, THE
01:15:28.490 --> 01:15:32.294
LAST 2020 SURVEY CALIFORNIA
01:15:32.361 --> 01:15:34.596
SURVEY 2052% OF ALL CALIFORNIA
01:15:34.663 --> 01:15:36.899
RENTERS OAN ZERO OR ONE CAR, WE
01:15:36.965 --> 01:15:39.067
ARE NOT ABLE TO BUILD HOUSING
01:15:39.134 --> 01:15:40.769
FOR THE VERY FOLKS WHO NEED
01:15:40.836 --> 01:15:42.271
HOUSING THAT DON'T ALSO OWN CARS
01:15:42.337 --> 01:15:44.306
BECAUSE THE COST AS A DEVELOPER
01:15:44.373 --> 01:15:46.475
TO BUILD A PARKING SPACE CAN BE
01:15:46.541 --> 01:15:48.777
UP TO $75,000 PER SPACE. WHEN
01:15:48.844 --> 01:15:49.311
YOU'RE BUILDING STRUCTURED
01:15:49.378 --> 01:15:50.512
PARKING ON TINY INFO, LOTS THAT
01:15:50.579 --> 01:15:53.148
ARE WITHIN TRANSIT. WILL BE NO
01:15:53.215 --> 01:15:55.651
TRANSIT WRITERS ARE NOT OFTEN
01:15:55.717 --> 01:15:57.185
OWNING TWO CARS PER HOUSEHOLD.
01:15:57.252 --> 01:15:58.387
YET WE ARE REQUIRED IN MANY
01:15:58.453 --> 01:15:59.755
CASES TO BUILD THEM BY
01:15:59.821 --> 01:16:00.822
ELIMINATING MINIMUM PARKING
01:16:00.889 --> 01:16:02.157
REQUIREMENTS. WE WILL UNLOCK
01:16:02.224 --> 01:16:03.358
COMMERCIAL CORRIDORS THAT ARE
01:16:03.425 --> 01:16:04.660
NEAR TRANSIT, WHEREAS
01:16:04.726 --> 01:16:05.928
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN STATED
01:16:05.994 --> 01:16:07.229
EARLIER. WE HAVE EMPTY BUILDINGS
01:16:07.296 --> 01:16:09.631
BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE PARKING
01:16:09.698 --> 01:16:10.766
ASSOCIATED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT
01:16:10.832 --> 01:16:12.367
AND THERE ISN'T A STANDARD THAT
01:16:12.434 --> 01:16:13.869
ALLOWS FOR THIS STANDARD WILL
01:16:13.936 --> 01:16:15.370
UNLOCK COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT.
01:16:15.437 --> 01:16:16.838
WE WILL ALLOW BUSINESSES TO
01:16:16.905 --> 01:16:18.273
CONTINUE TO USE THEIR OUTDOOR
01:16:18.340 --> 01:16:20.776
PARKING SPACES THAT ARE UNUSED
01:16:20.842 --> 01:16:22.778
FOR OPEN SHOPS OR RESTAURANTS OR
01:16:22.844 --> 01:16:24.313
EATING AND DINING. THIS HAS THE
01:16:24.379 --> 01:16:25.847
ABILITY FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
01:16:25.914 --> 01:16:27.749
AND HOUSING PRODUCTION, ALSO FOR
01:16:27.816 --> 01:16:29.184
THE MISSING MIDDLE AND THE 40
01:16:29.251 --> 01:16:30.419
UNITS OR LESS IS A GREAT
01:16:30.485 --> 01:16:31.687
AMENDMENT THAT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:16:31.753 --> 01:16:32.988
FREEMAN WORKED ON THAT ALLOWS
01:16:33.055 --> 01:16:34.289
FOR PROJECTS MISSING MIDDLE
01:16:34.356 --> 01:16:37.025
HOUSING THAT WOULD TALKING ABOUT
01:16:37.092 --> 01:16:41.263
100 120% 80 TO 150% WE CAN BEGIN
01:16:41.330 --> 01:16:43.432
TO LOOK AT SMALLER DUPLEXES.
01:16:43.498 --> 01:16:45.100
FOUR PLEX IS WITHOUT HAVING TO
01:16:45.167 --> 01:16:46.568
OVERBURDEN THE SMALL PARCELS
01:16:46.635 --> 01:16:48.136
WITH PARKING. WE STRONGLY URGE
01:16:48.203 --> 01:16:49.571
THIS COMMITTEE SUPPORT OF THIS
01:16:49.638 --> 01:16:51.039
BILL. WE THINK IT'S SO IMPORTANT
01:16:51.106 --> 01:16:52.441
. WE THINK IT'S SO TIMELY AND WE
01:16:52.507 --> 01:16:53.542
REALLY THINK, AND, UH,
01:16:53.608 --> 01:16:54.977
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN FOR
01:16:55.043 --> 01:16:56.878
ALL OF HER WORK. THANK YOU.
01:16:56.945 --> 01:16:58.080
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE GONNA
01:16:58.146 --> 01:16:59.915
MOVE ON TO ZACH HILTON, WHO IS
01:16:59.982 --> 01:17:01.984
ON THE PHONE. HELLO. COMMITTEE
01:17:02.050 --> 01:17:02.918
CHAIR MEMBERS STAFF IN THE
01:17:02.985 --> 01:17:05.687
PUBLIC. AND JACK HOLDEN,
01:17:05.754 --> 01:17:07.055
RESIDENT OF GILROY, CALIFORNIA
01:17:07.122 --> 01:17:08.557
AND YOUR CITY COUNCIL MEMBER
01:17:08.623 --> 01:17:10.158
CITIES ACROSS CALIFORNIA HAVE
01:17:10.225 --> 01:17:11.760
MANY EXAMPLES OF PROPERTIES
01:17:11.827 --> 01:17:12.461
WHERE WE USED TO NOT REQUIRE
01:17:12.527 --> 01:17:14.563
ARKING MANY DECADES AGO BEFORE
01:17:14.629 --> 01:17:16.798
MAJORITY OF ZONING CODES HAVE
01:17:16.865 --> 01:17:17.899
BEEN ADOPTED THAT REQUIRE MORE
01:17:17.966 --> 01:17:19.768
LAND TO BE DEVELOPED. WITH THE
01:17:19.835 --> 01:17:21.136
RECENT IMPLEMENTATION OF VEHICLE
01:17:21.203 --> 01:17:23.372
MILES TRAVELED. WE LOOK TOWARDS
01:17:23.438 --> 01:17:24.773
INCREASING ALTERNATIVE OPTIONS
01:17:24.840 --> 01:17:26.341
TO THE SINGLE OCCUPANT VEHICLE
01:17:26.408 --> 01:17:27.576
AND CREATIVE SOLUTIONS LIKE A B
01:17:27.642 --> 01:17:29.745
2097 2. CAN YOU DO PUSH UPS
01:17:29.811 --> 01:17:31.413
SUPPORT OFF FORWARD? THEY'RE
01:17:31.480 --> 01:17:33.515
RESPONSIVE PANDEMIC AND THE
01:17:33.582 --> 01:17:34.449
CLOSURE OF RESTAURANTS AND SMALL
01:17:34.516 --> 01:17:35.717
SHOPS. LOCAL GOVERNMENTS HAVE
01:17:35.784 --> 01:17:37.052
ALLOWED BUSINESSES TO EXPAND
01:17:37.119 --> 01:17:39.221
INTO ON SITE AND STREET PARKING
01:17:39.287 --> 01:17:40.455
SPACES TO ALLOW FOR SAFE OUTDOOR
01:17:40.522 --> 01:17:43.158
DINING AND SHOPPING. THESE NEW
01:17:43.225 --> 01:17:44.326
AND MORE PRODUCTIVE USES OF
01:17:44.393 --> 01:17:46.128
PARKING SPACES HAVE SHOWN US THE
01:17:46.194 --> 01:17:48.030
WAY FORWARD TO CREATE MORE
01:17:48.096 --> 01:17:48.497
INVITING A SUSTAINABLE
01:17:48.563 --> 01:17:49.097
NEIGHBORHOODS AND ALLOW SMALL
01:17:49.164 --> 01:17:50.832
BUSINESSES TO THRIVE. AND IN
01:17:50.899 --> 01:17:53.635
SOME CASES UM, IN SOME CASES
01:17:53.702 --> 01:17:56.638
SURVIVE. WITH THE RECENT
01:17:56.705 --> 01:17:58.140
ADOPTION OF GALLERIES GENERAL
01:17:58.206 --> 01:17:59.841
PLAN 2040. WE CALL FOR BOLD
01:17:59.908 --> 01:18:00.509
ACTIONS THAT INCLUDED CONTINUING
01:18:00.575 --> 01:18:01.476
TO PROMOTE CLEANER MODES OF
01:18:01.543 --> 01:18:02.511
TRANSPORTATION. BE ENCOURAGED
01:18:02.577 --> 01:18:05.714
EXISTING AND PROPOSED.
01:18:05.781 --> 01:18:07.149
DEVELOPMENT TO INCORPORATE
01:18:07.215 --> 01:18:08.650
TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT
01:18:08.717 --> 01:18:10.685
MEASURES SUCH AS CAR SHARING,
01:18:10.752 --> 01:18:11.853
TRANSIT PASSES AND UN BUNDLING
01:18:11.920 --> 01:18:14.389
OF PARKING. WE HAVE PLANS FOR
01:18:14.456 --> 01:18:15.390
PROJECTS LIKE THIS AND HOW THE
01:18:15.457 --> 01:18:17.459
RESOURCES IN 2022 TO MASON TO
01:18:17.526 --> 01:18:18.860
MAKE THEM SUCCESSFUL AT THE
01:18:18.927 --> 01:18:20.562
LOCAL LEVEL. RECENTLY THE CITY
01:18:20.629 --> 01:18:22.197
OF GILROY TV T, A AND
01:18:22.264 --> 01:18:22.931
TRANSPORTATION AGENCY FOR
01:18:22.998 --> 01:18:24.800
MONTEREY COUNTY, SIGNED AN MOU
01:18:24.866 --> 01:18:26.401
FOR REAL IMPROVEMENT. OF THE
01:18:26.468 --> 01:18:27.736
MONTEREY COUNTY RAIL EXTENSION
01:18:27.803 --> 01:18:29.938
PROJECT TO INCLUDE BAY AREA
01:18:30.005 --> 01:18:30.572
CALTRAIN SERVICE CONNECTIONS TO
01:18:30.639 --> 01:18:33.842
GIL, RIGHT. INSULIN. GUILLORY
01:18:33.909 --> 01:18:36.111
LIKE SALINAS IS BUILDING FUTURE
01:18:36.178 --> 01:18:37.245
FUTURE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
01:18:37.312 --> 01:18:39.448
OPTIONS WITHIN OUR DOWNTOWN
01:18:39.514 --> 01:18:41.183
PARKING LOT, ESPECIALLY EMPTY
01:18:41.249 --> 01:18:42.417
ONES, DO NOTHING AT THE LOCAL
01:18:42.484 --> 01:18:43.652
LEVEL TO MAXIMIZE OUR COLLECTION
01:18:43.718 --> 01:18:45.821
OF PROPERTY TAX. AND A MIXED USE
01:18:45.887 --> 01:18:46.988
PROJECT WILL GENERATE
01:18:47.055 --> 01:18:47.923
SIGNIFICANT PROPERTY AND SALES
01:18:47.989 --> 01:18:50.258
TAX. WE'LL CHANGE IT. RIDERS
01:18:50.325 --> 01:18:51.827
SHIFT THEIR MODE INTO GETTING TO
01:18:51.893 --> 01:18:53.395
TRANSIT BY WALK, BIKE RIDE,
01:18:53.462 --> 01:18:55.764
SHARE CARPOOL, THEY WILL VISIT
01:18:55.831 --> 01:18:56.865
AND SPEND MORE MONEY MORE
01:18:56.932 --> 01:18:58.733
LOCALLY. WERE TRADING MORE
01:18:58.800 --> 01:18:59.768
WALKABLE, BANKABLE PLACES TO
01:18:59.835 --> 01:19:01.503
LIVE THAT DON'T REQUIRE YOU TO
01:19:01.570 --> 01:19:04.172
OWN A CAR. WHILE PROVIDING MUCH
01:19:04.239 --> 01:19:06.007
NEEDED HOUSING FOR OUR
01:19:06.074 --> 01:19:06.641
GRADUATING HIGH SCHOOL SENIORS,
01:19:06.708 --> 01:19:07.175
TEACHERS CITY EMPLOYEES IN
01:19:07.242 --> 01:19:09.144
COLLEGE GRADS TO COME HOME TO
01:19:09.211 --> 01:19:10.779
LASTLY, AT THE STATE, WE ARE
01:19:10.846 --> 01:19:12.247
ACTIVELY EMBRACING ADVANCING
01:19:12.314 --> 01:19:13.648
IDEAS AND PROJECTS THAT PROMOTE
01:19:13.715 --> 01:19:15.150
THE CONCEPT OF FREE RANGE PEOPLE
01:19:15.217 --> 01:19:16.718
WE ADVOCATE FOR BUILDING AND
01:19:16.785 --> 01:19:18.587
PLANNING THAT CONSIDERS FUTURE
01:19:18.653 --> 01:19:19.688
GENERATIONS AS WELL AS CURRENT
01:19:19.754 --> 01:19:21.656
RESIDENTS WHO DON'T OWN CARS. A
01:19:21.723 --> 01:19:24.259
B 2097 SUPPORTS THE VISION OF A
01:19:24.326 --> 01:19:25.760
HEALTHY CALIFORNIA AND ENHANCES
01:19:25.827 --> 01:19:27.362
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY AND
01:19:27.429 --> 01:19:29.464
LIVABILITY. THANK YOU, AND IN
01:19:29.531 --> 01:19:30.465
CONCLUSION, I RESPECTFULLY AFTER
01:19:30.532 --> 01:19:33.401
YEAR I'VE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:19:33.468 --> 01:19:35.036
FOR PARTICIPATING TODAY. WE'RE
01:19:35.103 --> 01:19:36.404
GOING TO MOVE ON TO SEE IF
01:19:36.471 --> 01:19:38.373
THERE'S ANYONE ELSE IN THE
01:19:38.440 --> 01:19:38.974
COMMITTEE ROOM THAT WOULD LIKE
01:19:39.040 --> 01:19:40.542
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT. PLEASE
01:19:40.609 --> 01:19:45.747
INVITE YOU TO COME FORWARD.
01:19:45.814 --> 01:19:46.815
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS ALEX
01:19:46.882 --> 01:19:48.016
TORRES WITH THE BAY AREA COUNCIL
01:19:48.083 --> 01:19:49.718
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:19:49.784 --> 01:19:51.486
YOU. MADAM SHE REMEMBERS LAUREN
01:19:51.553 --> 01:19:52.187
DAY VALENCIA, REPRESENTING THE
01:19:52.254 --> 01:19:53.155
AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION,
01:19:53.221 --> 01:19:56.258
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. GOOD
01:19:56.324 --> 01:19:57.359
MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:19:57.425 --> 01:19:59.060
LICCARDO MARROW ON BEHALF OF
01:19:59.127 --> 01:20:00.061
NRDC ACTION FUNDING SUPORT.
01:20:00.128 --> 01:20:03.732
THANK YOU. NICK CAMERA ON BEHALF
01:20:03.798 --> 01:20:04.766
OF CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
01:20:04.833 --> 01:20:05.767
ASSOCIATION. ALSO IN SUPPORT.
01:20:05.834 --> 01:20:09.804
THANK YOU. UNLESS IT'S ALL HIGH
01:20:09.871 --> 01:20:11.072
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF REDWOOD
01:20:11.139 --> 01:20:14.609
CITY AND SUPPORT COREY SMITH ON
01:20:14.676 --> 01:20:16.378
BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
01:20:16.444 --> 01:20:18.747
COALITION AND SUPPORT HOLLY FOR
01:20:18.813 --> 01:20:20.382
MANY DAYS SINCE THE LIGHTHOUSE
01:20:20.448 --> 01:20:21.149
PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON BEHALF OF
01:20:21.216 --> 01:20:23.251
CIVIC WELL HAVE A TOUGH HUMANITY
01:20:23.318 --> 01:20:23.752
CALIFORNIA AND SANDHILL
01:20:23.818 --> 01:20:24.686
PROPERTIES AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
01:20:24.753 --> 01:20:29.024
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE?
01:20:29.090 --> 01:20:30.525
NOW WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
01:20:30.592 --> 01:20:32.027
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS
01:20:32.093 --> 01:20:32.494
THERE ANYBODY ON THE
01:20:32.561 --> 01:20:33.395
TELECONFERENCE LINE THAT WOULD
01:20:33.461 --> 01:20:37.766
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT? YOU
01:20:37.832 --> 01:20:39.768
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT PRESSED
01:20:39.834 --> 01:20:46.274
ABUNDANT ZERO. ALL RIGHT. FIRST
01:20:46.341 --> 01:20:47.409
WE HAVE LINE 98, PLEASE GO
01:20:47.475 --> 01:20:56.885
AHEAD. TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION
01:20:56.952 --> 01:20:57.953
, THE NAPA VALLEY TRANSPORTATION
01:20:58.019 --> 01:20:58.553
AUTHORITY AND CAL BIKER FROM
01:20:58.620 --> 01:21:02.057
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 9
01:21:02.123 --> 01:21:05.927
38, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MIKE PLANT
01:21:05.994 --> 01:21:13.768
BIRD RESPONSE. FINE. WON 11 GO
01:21:13.835 --> 01:21:26.381
AHEAD. HELLO. YOU HEAR ME? CAN'T. HI. UM ANDREW LEWIS, UH, BEARS
01:21:26.448 --> 01:21:28.083
3 50 ACTION IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
01:21:28.149 --> 01:21:31.886
2097. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. GIVE
01:21:31.953 --> 01:21:36.391
MINE 1 22, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:21:36.458 --> 01:21:38.159
THANK YOU. CHAIR MEMBERS. ZACH
01:21:38.226 --> 01:21:39.961
BULLYING REPRESENTING EAST BAY,
01:21:40.028 --> 01:21:40.962
INDIA, CALLING IN STRONG
01:21:41.029 --> 01:21:43.665
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. IN 1 23.
01:21:43.732 --> 01:21:48.470
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS
01:21:48.536 --> 01:21:49.838
BOBBY GUARANTEE FROM CALIFORNIA
01:21:49.904 --> 01:21:51.506
AND BE CALLING IN SUPPORT OF
01:21:51.573 --> 01:21:57.646
2097. 91 18, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:21:57.712 --> 01:21:59.147
HI. THIS IS ADAM. BOOK FINDER
01:21:59.214 --> 01:22:00.649
FOR THE NBA, NBA ACTION URBAN
01:22:00.715 --> 01:22:01.950
ENVIRONMENT WITH PEOPLE FOR
01:22:02.017 --> 01:22:02.217
HOUSING,
01:22:02.284 --> 01:22:08.156
ORANGE-COUNTY-REGISTER-TOO-SOON-COUNTY-VOTE-CENTERS. AGAIN FRANCISCO UNIT NORTHERN
01:22:08.223 --> 01:22:09.324
NEIGHBORS HAVE FRANCISCO
01:22:09.391 --> 01:22:11.192
CONGRESS NOTED VALLEY SO, UM, BE
01:22:11.259 --> 01:22:12.394
VIEWING AND BE PENINSULA FOR
01:22:12.460 --> 01:22:14.095
EVERYONE STEP SIDE FORWARD AND
01:22:14.162 --> 01:22:15.096
SUNRISE SILICON VALLEY SUPPORT
01:22:15.163 --> 01:22:18.266
80 2097. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:22:18.333 --> 01:22:23.838
TÌM 1 27, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:22:23.905 --> 01:22:25.106
THOMAS IRWIN, AND IT'S DANGEROUS
01:22:25.173 --> 01:22:26.107
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF THE
01:22:26.174 --> 01:22:33.648
MEASURE. 91 29, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:22:33.715 --> 01:22:37.252
WITH PENINSULA FOR EVERYONE.
01:22:37.319 --> 01:22:38.486
FEMALE STATE AREA AND FRIENDS OF
01:22:38.553 --> 01:22:42.924
CALTRAIN IN SUPPORT. TIME. 1 33,
01:22:42.991 --> 01:22:48.730
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THERE. THIS IS
01:22:48.797 --> 01:22:49.998
JOEL COHEN FROM BURLINGAME,
01:22:50.065 --> 01:22:50.865
CALIFORNIA I'M CALLING IN
01:22:50.932 --> 01:22:53.868
SUPPORT OF THE MEASURE. Q 1 24
01:22:53.935 --> 01:22:58.740
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS JOE
01:22:58.807 --> 01:22:59.841
LOWENSTEIN, SOME BERKELEY AND
01:22:59.908 --> 01:23:01.943
CALIFORNIA AND BE CALLING IN A
01:23:02.010 --> 01:23:04.379
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:23:04.446 --> 01:23:08.616
SAYING 1 30, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:23:08.683 --> 01:23:10.118
EVERYONE THIS IS MARK FOLKS
01:23:10.185 --> 01:23:11.753
CEVICHE CALLING FROM THE
01:23:11.820 --> 01:23:12.387
CUSTOMER CELL LINES FOR BETTER
01:23:12.454 --> 01:23:14.055
STREETS IN ORANGE COUNTY IN
01:23:14.122 --> 01:23:15.156
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS GREAT
01:23:15.223 --> 01:23:18.293
LAND USE POLICY. THANK YOU. I'M
01:23:18.360 --> 01:23:22.797
1 37, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:23:22.864 --> 01:23:24.866
MORNING, JEREMY LEVINE HERE FROM
01:23:24.933 --> 01:23:26.034
LAFAYETTE IN CONTRA COSTA
01:23:26.101 --> 01:23:28.536
COUNTY. I'M CALLING IN ON THE
01:23:28.603 --> 01:23:29.971
CONTRA COSTA YOUNG DEMOCRATS AND
01:23:30.038 --> 01:23:31.106
INCLUSIVE LAFAYETTE IN STRONG
01:23:31.172 --> 01:23:38.246
SUPPORT. 91 39, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:23:38.313 --> 01:23:39.481
HI. CRAIG LYNN WITH ABUNDANT
01:23:39.547 --> 01:23:42.650
HOUSING L A CALLING IN SUPPORT.
01:23:42.717 --> 01:23:48.390
9 25, PLEASE GO AHEAD. ADRIANA
01:23:48.456 --> 01:23:50.291
CHAMPAGNE WITH THE LEGAL WOMEN
01:23:50.358 --> 01:23:51.426
VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA AND STRONG
01:23:51.493 --> 01:23:53.328
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. TIME WHEN I
01:23:53.395 --> 01:23:57.732
WAS SEVEN, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:23:57.799 --> 01:23:59.067
THIS IS KEVIN BURKE WITH EAST
01:23:59.134 --> 01:24:01.836
BAY FOR EVERYONE IN SUPPORT. 28,
01:24:01.903 --> 01:24:06.808
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HEY, THIS IS
01:24:06.875 --> 01:24:08.943
DAVID BARBOZA ON BEHALF OF
01:24:09.010 --> 01:24:10.478
ABUNDANT HOUSING LÀ. WE'RE PROUD
01:24:10.545 --> 01:24:14.115
TO SUPPORT IN CO SPONSOR 2097.
01:24:14.182 --> 01:24:19.387
1917, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
01:24:19.454 --> 01:24:20.588
LISA DANCE WITH FREE MONEY FOR
01:24:20.655 --> 01:24:21.723
EVERYONE IN SUPPORT OF MAYBE
01:24:21.790 --> 01:24:29.130
2097. AND 1 28 GO AHEAD. HI.
01:24:29.197 --> 01:24:30.465
THIS IS MARCOS IVANOVIC,
01:24:30.532 --> 01:24:31.433
PRESIDENT ALAMEDA IN STRONG
01:24:31.499 --> 01:24:40.275
SUPPORT. 9 90, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:24:40.341 --> 01:24:41.543
THANK YOU. METS OFFER ON BEHALF
01:24:41.609 --> 01:24:43.411
OF THESANTA MONICA CHAMBER OF
01:24:43.478 --> 01:24:46.047
COMMERCE. 91 31, PLEASE GO
01:24:46.114 --> 01:24:51.586
AHEAD. FROM WALNUT CREEK AND FOR
01:24:51.653 --> 01:24:55.657
CALIFORNIA INDIE STRONG SUPPORT.
01:24:55.723 --> 01:25:00.128
I HAD 56. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:25:00.195 --> 01:25:01.763
MORNING MICHAEL SHOW SOON WITH
01:25:01.830 --> 01:25:03.097
CENTRAL CITY ASSOCIATION OF LOS
01:25:03.164 --> 01:25:04.966
ANGELES IN SUPPORT OF A BETWEEN
01:25:05.033 --> 01:25:10.939
97 AND 44. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:25:11.005 --> 01:25:12.941
MORNING, DAVID AZEVEDO WITH AARP
01:25:13.007 --> 01:25:17.412
, CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
01:25:17.479 --> 01:25:25.286
15, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 91 15 YEAR
01:25:25.353 --> 01:25:30.959
LINE IS OPEN. HELLO MY NAME IS
01:25:31.025 --> 01:25:32.627
SARAH OGILVY AND THE NUMBER OF
01:25:32.694 --> 01:25:35.396
EAST INDIA CHAPTER BND ACTION
01:25:35.463 --> 01:25:36.564
BETWEEN STRONG SUPPORT FOR THIS
01:25:36.631 --> 01:25:40.001
BILL. THANK YOU. DID YOU LIKE
01:25:40.068 --> 01:25:45.073
72, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GRANDCHILD
01:25:45.139 --> 01:25:46.407
CULPRIT. COMMUNITY BUILDERS IN
01:25:46.474 --> 01:25:49.844
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. TIME.
01:25:49.911 --> 01:25:55.450
1 35, PLEASE GO AHEAD. ABOUT THE
01:25:55.517 --> 01:25:56.784
FISH FROM THE STREETS FOR ALL IN
01:25:56.851 --> 01:25:58.553
STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE,
01:25:58.620 --> 01:26:00.755
THANK YOU. THEN WENT 32. PLEASE
01:26:00.822 --> 01:26:05.727
GO AHEAD. HIæN HUSBAND AND
01:26:05.793 --> 01:26:07.061
BARELY DID IN CALIFORNIA AND
01:26:07.128 --> 01:26:07.996
PENINSULA FOR EVERYONE AND
01:26:08.062 --> 01:26:14.135
SUPPORT. 9 31, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:26:14.202 --> 01:26:16.271
HIGHEST OVER CHECKER WITH THE
01:26:16.337 --> 01:26:17.438
LOS ANGELES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:26:17.505 --> 01:26:21.009
IN SUPPORT. TIME. 1 38, PLEASE
01:26:21.075 --> 01:26:26.648
GO AHEAD. STEVE MARZO CULLING
01:26:26.714 --> 01:26:28.249
WITH SOUTH SIDE FORWARD AND
01:26:28.316 --> 01:26:32.487
CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT. I'M
01:26:32.554 --> 01:26:36.457
87. PLEASE GO AHEAD. NEXT.
01:26:36.524 --> 01:26:37.592
SNYDER ON BEHALF OF GET AROUND
01:26:37.659 --> 01:26:42.030
AND SUPPORT. FIND 1 12, PLEASE
01:26:42.096 --> 01:26:46.501
GO AHEAD. THIS IS JON BENET ON
01:26:46.568 --> 01:26:48.469
BEHALF OF EAST BAY FOR EVERYONE
01:26:48.536 --> 01:26:51.105
IN STRONG SUPPORT. FIND 1 36,
01:26:51.172 --> 01:26:55.343
PLEASE GO AHEAD. ZOE SIEGEL ON
01:26:55.410 --> 01:26:57.178
BEHALF OF GREENOUGH LIONS IN
01:26:57.245 --> 01:27:01.015
STRONG SUPPORT. AND 1 42, PLEASE
01:27:01.082 --> 01:27:05.687
GO AHEAD. KOBE MORRISON IS FROM
01:27:05.753 --> 01:27:07.088
LOS ANGELES ON BEHALF OF
01:27:07.155 --> 01:27:08.222
WESTSIDE FOR EVERYONE AND STRONG
01:27:08.289 --> 01:27:15.530
SUPPORT. 91 34, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:27:15.597 --> 01:27:17.098
BRIAN JOY ON BEHALF OF
01:27:17.165 --> 01:27:18.333
CALIFORNIA AND BE WE ARE PROUD
01:27:18.399 --> 01:27:20.368
CO SPONSORS OF A B 2097 CALLING
01:27:20.435 --> 01:27:23.972
EXPORT. THANK YOU. 91 45, PLEASE
01:27:24.038 --> 01:27:28.776
GO AHEAD. THIS IS MARVIN NORMAN.
01:27:28.843 --> 01:27:36.884
YOU KNOW? BYE BYE. 91 46, PLEASE
01:27:36.951 --> 01:27:41.556
GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. SHARON
01:27:41.623 --> 01:27:43.124
MEMBERS, JORDAN'S GRIMES ON
01:27:43.191 --> 01:27:45.193
BEHALF OF THE PENINSULA. YOUNG
01:27:45.259 --> 01:27:45.760
DEMOCRATS FOR EVERYONE IN
01:27:45.827 --> 01:27:46.761
SENATE-DISTRICT TEAM IN STRONG
01:27:46.828 --> 01:27:51.199
SUPPORT. LINE 1 44, PLEASE GO
01:27:51.265 --> 01:28:00.041
AHEAD. AND 1 44 YEAR LINE IS
01:28:00.108 --> 01:28:19.894
OPEN. 91 44.
01:28:19.961 --> 01:28:21.896
I GUESS I HAVE NO ONE ELSE IN
01:28:21.963 --> 01:28:24.999
QUÊ. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU. TO
01:28:25.066 --> 01:28:26.734
EVERYBODY WHO TESTIFIED WE'RE
01:28:26.801 --> 01:28:28.636
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OUR
01:28:28.703 --> 01:28:31.639
OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO LEAD.
01:28:31.706 --> 01:28:32.507
OPPOSITION WITNESS NOTED SOME
01:28:32.573 --> 01:28:34.308
GONNA CHECK AND SEE IF THERE'S
01:28:34.375 --> 01:28:35.510
ANYBODY IN ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD
01:28:35.576 --> 01:28:38.146
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
01:28:38.212 --> 01:28:39.313
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
01:28:39.380 --> 01:28:42.116
TELECONFERENCE LAND. YOU COULD
01:28:42.183 --> 01:28:43.317
QUEUE UP ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE
01:28:43.384 --> 01:28:47.555
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. TO
01:28:47.622 --> 01:28:48.623
SPEAKING UP POSITION, PLEASE
01:28:48.690 --> 01:28:53.027
PRESS 10. START WITH LINE 24,
01:28:53.094 --> 01:28:59.901
PLEASE GO AHEAD. I'M ACTUALLY IN
01:28:59.967 --> 01:29:01.169
SUPPORT, DISMISSIVE LIKE THE
01:29:01.235 --> 01:29:04.038
FATHER. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
01:29:04.105 --> 01:29:06.641
APPRECIATE IT. AND I'M ONE OF
01:29:06.708 --> 01:29:11.479
FIVE PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES.
01:29:11.546 --> 01:29:12.480
CERTAINLY THERE WERE UNITED
01:29:12.547 --> 01:29:13.347
NEIGHBORS IN OPPOSITION. THANK
01:29:13.414 --> 01:29:18.352
YOU. PLANE. 1 16, PLEASE GO
01:29:18.419 --> 01:29:23.424
AHEAD. TÌM NAME IS CHRISTIE
01:29:23.491 --> 01:29:24.492
MILLER WITH UNITE HERE, LOCAL
01:29:24.559 --> 01:29:28.629
11. UNITE HERE. LOCAL 11 OPPOSES
01:29:28.696 --> 01:29:30.832
THIS BILL UNLESS AMENDED TO
01:29:30.898 --> 01:29:33.568
pAND OTHER TRANSIENT OCCUPANCY
01:29:33.634 --> 01:29:37.872
USES. THANK YOU. THEN WENT 25.
01:29:37.939 --> 01:29:51.886
PLEASE GO AHEAD. THAT FAILED AND. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. FIND 108.
01:29:51.953 --> 01:29:57.291
PLEASE GO AHEAD. A LITTLE BIT.
01:29:57.358 --> 01:29:59.660
HENRY LAFAYETTE, CALIFORNIA ON
01:29:59.727 --> 01:30:00.828
BEHALF OF LIVABLE CALIFORNIA
01:30:00.895 --> 01:30:03.998
STATE, LAFAYETTE. UNLESS
01:30:04.065 --> 01:30:08.536
AMENDED. THIS BILL IS A ONE SIZE
01:30:08.603 --> 01:30:10.104
FITS ALL BILL AND SHOULD BE A
01:30:10.171 --> 01:30:13.574
MUNICIPAL GOVERNANCE AFFAIR. SO
01:30:13.641 --> 01:30:14.709
IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK
01:30:14.776 --> 01:30:18.646
YOU MUCH. LINE 16 LINES 16,
01:30:18.713 --> 01:30:23.751
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:30:23.818 --> 01:30:26.020
. MY NAME IS MARY ANN KING.
01:30:26.087 --> 01:30:28.022
RESIDENTS OF THE NORTHWEST SAN
01:30:28.089 --> 01:30:29.590
FERNANDO VALLEY AND STRONG
01:30:29.657 --> 01:30:32.727
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL. IT
01:30:32.794 --> 01:30:34.095
SEVERELY UNDERMINES THAT
01:30:34.162 --> 01:30:36.497
DIRECTLY CONFLICT AND UNDERMINES
01:30:36.564 --> 01:30:38.699
OUR SUCCESSFUL, TRANSMIT
01:30:38.766 --> 01:30:41.035
ORIENTED COMMUNITY. UM, PROGRAMS
01:30:41.102 --> 01:30:42.303
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND THE
01:30:42.370 --> 01:30:46.741
WE NEED EXTREMELY LOW, VERY LOW
01:30:46.808 --> 01:30:49.210
AND LOW INCOME HOUSING DIRECTLY
01:30:49.277 --> 01:30:51.379
UNDERMINES OUR EFFORTS TO DO
01:30:51.445 --> 01:30:53.614
THAT. THIS IS A ONE SIDE TO CALL
01:30:53.681 --> 01:30:54.615
BILL AND IT SHOULD NOT BE, UM
01:30:54.682 --> 01:30:56.717
FIND LIKE THIS. THANK YOU. THANK
01:30:56.784 --> 01:30:59.220
YOU VERY MUCH. BEEN 100, PLEASE
01:30:59.287 --> 01:31:03.991
GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
01:31:04.058 --> 01:31:06.194
MEMBERS PENURY SALAS WITH THE
01:31:06.260 --> 01:31:07.428
WESTERN CENTER ON LAW AND
01:31:07.495 --> 01:31:09.063
PROPERTY, AS WELL AS THE
01:31:09.130 --> 01:31:09.530
CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
01:31:09.597 --> 01:31:11.132
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION.
01:31:11.199 --> 01:31:12.200
UNFORTUNATELY WE ARE OPPOSED
01:31:12.266 --> 01:31:15.303
UNLESS AMEND WE HAVE BEEN IN
01:31:15.369 --> 01:31:16.370
COMMUNICATION WITH THE AUTHOR'S
01:31:16.437 --> 01:31:18.239
OFFICE ON THE AMENDMENTS TO
01:31:18.306 --> 01:31:19.640
ADDRESS VARIOUS EQUITY CONCERNS
01:31:19.707 --> 01:31:21.242
WITH THE LATEST ROUND OF
01:31:21.309 --> 01:31:22.210
AMENDMENTS DID NOT INCORPORATE
01:31:22.276 --> 01:31:24.212
THE PROTECTIONS WE'VE REQUESTED
01:31:24.278 --> 01:31:25.379
. WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
01:31:25.446 --> 01:31:26.747
THE CONVERSATION WITH THE
01:31:26.814 --> 01:31:29.116
AUTHOR'S OFFICE ON THE CHANGES.
01:31:29.183 --> 01:31:30.318
AND THEY COMMITTED TO MAKE FOR
01:31:30.384 --> 01:31:32.253
OUR CLIENTS. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
01:31:32.320 --> 01:31:34.622
THANK YOU. BLIND BLIND WHEN 40
01:31:34.689 --> 01:31:39.393
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS IDEA
01:31:39.460 --> 01:31:41.128
MADISON WITH LIVABLE CALIFORNIA
01:31:41.195 --> 01:31:42.196
AND SOUTH LOS ANGELES AND
01:31:42.263 --> 01:31:43.231
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK
01:31:43.297 --> 01:31:49.737
YOU. 9 26, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:31:49.804 --> 01:31:51.939
MORNING. THIS IS DAVID JONES AND
01:31:52.006 --> 01:31:53.307
A HALF OF THE CITIES OF SAN
01:31:53.374 --> 01:31:54.475
MARCOS AND THE MARIN COUNTY
01:31:54.542 --> 01:31:55.643
COUNCILS OF MAYORS AND COUNCIL
01:31:55.710 --> 01:31:57.144
MEMBERS WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
01:31:57.211 --> 01:31:59.080
AUTHOR FOR TAKING THEM THAT ON
01:31:59.146 --> 01:32:00.748
BEHALF OF THE TOWN OF TRUCKEE
01:32:00.815 --> 01:32:01.849
WITH SNOW REMOVAL ISSUES, THANK
01:32:01.916 --> 01:32:02.483
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 1977,
01:32:02.550 --> 01:32:09.857
PLEASE GO AHEAD. 9 77. YOUR LINE
01:32:09.924 --> 01:32:15.730
IS OPEN. GOOD MORNING. CHAIR
01:32:15.796 --> 01:32:17.798
MEMBERS MIKE WEST ON BEHALF OF
01:32:17.865 --> 01:32:19.000
THE STATE BUILDING AND
01:32:19.066 --> 01:32:21.135
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL. WE
01:32:21.202 --> 01:32:22.536
NEED TO REVIEW THE AMENDED
01:32:22.603 --> 01:32:24.038
LANGUAGE DICUSSED TODAY BUT ARE
01:32:24.105 --> 01:32:25.406
STILL OPPOSED AND BELIEVE THAT
01:32:25.473 --> 01:32:27.341
2097 SHOULD BE AMENDED TO MIRROR
01:32:27.408 --> 01:32:28.376
SENATOR PORTANTINO'S SP ATTEND
01:32:28.442 --> 01:32:33.514
67. THANK YOU. 91 49, PLEASE GO
01:32:33.581 --> 01:32:38.886
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
01:32:38.953 --> 01:32:40.221
AND MEMBERS ANDREW ANTWI HERE
01:32:40.288 --> 01:32:41.322
TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
01:32:41.389 --> 01:32:44.258
BEVERLY HILLS. AND THE CITY
01:32:44.325 --> 01:32:45.459
COUNTY ASSOCIATION OF
01:32:45.526 --> 01:32:46.661
GOVERNMENTS OF SAN MATEO COUNTY,
01:32:46.727 --> 01:32:49.664
BOTH IN OPPOSITION. WE WILL TAKE
01:32:49.730 --> 01:32:50.798
TIME TO REVIEW THE COMMITTEE
01:32:50.865 --> 01:32:51.699
AMENDMENTS BUT WANTED TO
01:32:51.766 --> 01:32:55.002
REGISTER THAT. THANK YOU. SO I
01:32:55.069 --> 01:33:00.274
WANT 50. PLEASE GO AHEAD. I
01:33:00.341 --> 01:33:03.644
UNDERSTAND WELL, MALDONADO, BMB
01:33:03.711 --> 01:33:05.146
AND I'M CALLING IN SUPPORT FOR U
01:33:05.212 --> 01:33:10.384
2097. THANK YOU. I'LL BE THERE.
01:33:10.451 --> 01:33:15.256
AND I HAVE NO ONE ELSE IN QUÊ.
01:33:15.323 --> 01:33:17.491
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. UM WE'RE
01:33:17.558 --> 01:33:19.527
GOING TO BRING THIS MATTER BACK
01:33:19.593 --> 01:33:21.629
TO THE COMMITTEE FOR COMMENTS.
01:33:21.696 --> 01:33:22.563
QUESTIONS CONCERNS, SENATOR
01:33:22.630 --> 01:33:27.368
WIENER. YEAH I JUST WANNA I WANT
01:33:27.435 --> 01:33:29.437
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR HER
01:33:29.503 --> 01:33:31.806
LEADERSHIP AND PERSISTENCE IN
01:33:31.872 --> 01:33:34.208
THE IN THIS AREA. WE KNOW THAT
01:33:34.275 --> 01:33:36.243
MAN MANDATED PARKING MINIMUMS,
01:33:36.310 --> 01:33:40.281
WHICH ARE OFTEN ARBITRARY. OR A
01:33:40.348 --> 01:33:42.483
MAJOR OBSTACLE TO BUILDING MORE
01:33:42.550 --> 01:33:45.219
HOUSING. UM NOT ONLY DOES IT
01:33:45.286 --> 01:33:46.387
DRAMATICALLY INCREASE THE COST
01:33:46.454 --> 01:33:48.055
OF HOUSING THE LAST ESTIMATE I
01:33:48.122 --> 01:33:49.557
HEARD IN SAN FRANCISCO, WHICH IS
01:33:49.623 --> 01:33:50.658
PROBABLY OUTDATED. IT'S PROBABLY
01:33:50.725 --> 01:33:52.493
HIGHER NOW. WAS THAT EACH
01:33:52.560 --> 01:33:55.162
PARKING SPOT, ADDS $50,000 IN
01:33:55.229 --> 01:33:57.465
SAN FRANCISCO TO THE COST OF A
01:33:57.531 --> 01:34:01.402
HOME AND SO THAT IS A DIRECTLY
01:34:01.469 --> 01:34:03.437
GOES INTO THE COST OF JUST
01:34:03.504 --> 01:34:04.772
HAVING HOUSING. MAYBE IT MAKES
01:34:04.839 --> 01:34:08.009
HOUSING MUCH MORE EXPENSIVE. THE
01:34:08.075 --> 01:34:10.778
OTHER THING. UM THE OTHER THING
01:34:10.845 --> 01:34:14.248
THAT IT DOES, IS IT YOU ONLY
01:34:14.315 --> 01:34:15.816
HAVE A CERTAIN NUMBER OF CERTAIN
01:34:15.883 --> 01:34:17.251
NUMBER OF SQUARE FEET THAT YOU
01:34:17.318 --> 01:34:18.386
CAN BUILD BASED ON HEIGHT,
01:34:18.452 --> 01:34:20.221
LIMITS AND SETBACKS AND
01:34:20.287 --> 01:34:22.156
EVERYTHING ELSE. AND SO WHEN YOU
01:34:22.223 --> 01:34:24.625
MANDATE A HUGE AMOUNT OF
01:34:24.692 --> 01:34:26.027
PARKING, THAT MEANS THAT YOU'RE
01:34:26.093 --> 01:34:28.496
BUILDING FEWER UNITS. OFHOUSING
01:34:28.562 --> 01:34:30.131
, AND SO THESE MANDATED PARKING
01:34:30.197 --> 01:34:31.866
MINIMUMS. UH PRIORITIZED CARS
01:34:31.932 --> 01:34:36.003
OVER PEOPLE. IT'S MORE IMPORTANT
01:34:36.070 --> 01:34:38.005
TO HOUSE CARS AND IS TO HOUSE
01:34:38.072 --> 01:34:40.841
PEOPLE. AND SO I THINK IT'S
01:34:40.908 --> 01:34:42.143
REALLY IMPORTANT THAT WHEN
01:34:42.209 --> 01:34:43.911
SOMEONE IS BUILDING HOUSING THAT
01:34:43.978 --> 01:34:45.579
THEY HAVE THE FLEXIBILITY TO
01:34:45.646 --> 01:34:46.747
DECIDE HOW MUCH PARKING IS
01:34:46.814 --> 01:34:51.152
APPROPRIATE. BASED ON THE THAT
01:34:51.218 --> 01:34:52.953
COMMUNITY BASED ON THE TYPE OF
01:34:53.020 --> 01:34:53.988
HOUSING BASED ON WHO THEY
01:34:54.055 --> 01:34:57.425
ANTICIPATE. LIVING THERE.
01:34:57.491 --> 01:34:59.493
DEVELOPER IS NOT GOING TO UNDER
01:34:59.560 --> 01:35:00.628
BUILD PARKING, IF IT MEANS THAT
01:35:00.694 --> 01:35:02.463
THAT NO ONE'S GONNA WANT TO LIVE
01:35:02.530 --> 01:35:03.497
THERE BECAUSE IT'S IN A
01:35:03.564 --> 01:35:05.399
LOCATION. WHERE PEOPLE NEED TO
01:35:05.466 --> 01:35:06.600
DRIVE THAT'S NOT IN ANY
01:35:06.667 --> 01:35:10.471
DEVELOPERS INTEREST. AND SO
01:35:10.538 --> 01:35:11.472
HAVING THAT FLEXIBILITY IS
01:35:11.539 --> 01:35:14.909
REALLY, REALLY IMPORTANT. UM WE
01:35:14.975 --> 01:35:16.610
GOT RID OF MANDATORY. WE GOT RID
01:35:16.677 --> 01:35:18.479
OF ALL PARKING MINIMUMS IN SAN
01:35:18.546 --> 01:35:21.415
FRANCISCO ABOUT THREE YEARS AGO
01:35:21.482 --> 01:35:22.650
FOR FOUR YEARS AGO. FIVE YEARS
01:35:22.716 --> 01:35:24.785
AGO, UM AND THE SKY DIDN'T FALL
01:35:24.852 --> 01:35:26.787
. IT'S ALL IT'S ALL GOOD. UM AND
01:35:26.854 --> 01:35:28.923
, UH, THIS IS A BILL WHOSE TIME
01:35:28.989 --> 01:35:30.758
HAS COME. I SUPPORTED SENATOR
01:35:30.825 --> 01:35:31.625
PORTANTINO'S BILL, I SUPPORT
01:35:31.692 --> 01:35:33.594
THIS BILL. UM AND I'M HAPPY TO
01:35:33.661 --> 01:35:37.364
MOVE THE BILL. THERE IS A MOTION
01:35:37.431 --> 01:35:38.899
. OTHER COMMENTS. SENATOR
01:35:38.966 --> 01:35:42.136
HERZBERG APOLOGIZE, MADAM CHAIR
01:35:42.203 --> 01:35:44.772
AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AND I, I
01:35:44.839 --> 01:35:45.773
WAS IN ANOTHER COMMITTEE
01:35:45.840 --> 01:35:48.943
PRESENTING BILLS. I LOVE TO
01:35:49.009 --> 01:35:50.444
CHANGE THE RULES AROUND HERE, SO
01:35:50.511 --> 01:35:51.312
WE DIDN'T HAVE SOMEBODY
01:35:51.378 --> 01:35:53.314
COMMITTEES TO SIT ON. BUT SO BE
01:35:53.380 --> 01:35:55.182
IT. I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE I
01:35:55.249 --> 01:35:56.517
KNOW THAT THERE WAS SOME COMMENT
01:35:56.584 --> 01:35:58.486
IN THIS REGARD. I JUST WANT SOME
01:35:58.552 --> 01:35:59.587
CLARITY THAT SENATOR PORTANTINO
01:35:59.653 --> 01:36:02.056
HAD A MEASURE. SB 10 67 AND THAT
01:36:02.123 --> 01:36:04.091
THOSE THOSE CONSIDERATIONS WERE
01:36:04.158 --> 01:36:05.459
INCLUDED IN THIS BILL. THAT IS
01:36:05.526 --> 01:36:06.560
THAT ACCURATE AND THE AMENDMENTS
01:36:06.627 --> 01:36:08.729
BECAUSE IT SAYS THE THIS WAS
01:36:08.796 --> 01:36:09.930
AMENDED. I JUST HAVE A CHANCE TO
01:36:09.997 --> 01:36:14.001
LOOK AT IT. THAT ACCURATE. THE
01:36:14.068 --> 01:36:15.402
AMENDMENTS ARE A LITTLE BIT
01:36:15.469 --> 01:36:16.036
DIFFERENT, BUT THEY'RE
01:36:16.103 --> 01:36:19.039
ESSENTIALLY THE SAME. THE SAME
01:36:19.106 --> 01:36:20.074
PORTANTINO'S AMENDMENTS HAD TO
01:36:20.141 --> 01:36:21.742
DO WITH THE CITIES THAT WOULD BE
01:36:21.809 --> 01:36:23.677
INCLUDED IN IN THIS INSTANCE. IT
01:36:23.744 --> 01:36:25.212
HAS TO DO WITH POPULATION AND
01:36:25.279 --> 01:36:30.017
HIGH TRANSIT AREAS. WHICH WHICH
01:36:30.084 --> 01:36:31.652
WHICH BASICALLY SAYS IT'S THE
01:36:31.719 --> 01:36:33.954
BIG CITIES, BIG CITIES THAT HAVE
01:36:34.021 --> 01:36:34.522
THE INFRASTRUCTURE IN PLACE,
01:36:34.588 --> 01:36:41.295
OKAY? THANK YOU. YEAH, THERE IS
01:36:41.362 --> 01:36:43.864
A ONE THERE IS A 11 CHEATER AND
01:36:43.931 --> 01:36:46.567
APPRECIATE YOU. SENATOR ROSS.
01:36:46.634 --> 01:36:47.635
DID YOU HAVE A QUESTION OR
01:36:47.701 --> 01:36:50.738
COMMENT? CONCERN YEAH. WHEN THIS
01:36:50.804 --> 01:36:54.041
CAME UP LAST YEAR, I RAISED, UM
01:36:54.108 --> 01:36:55.843
ISSUES SIMILAR TO I THINK THE
01:36:55.910 --> 01:36:56.944
WESTERN CENTER ON LAND POVERTY
01:36:57.011 --> 01:37:01.148
SO I, UM I THINK THERE'S A
01:37:01.215 --> 01:37:04.118
DIFFERENT IMPACT. UM AND THERE'S
01:37:04.185 --> 01:37:05.386
SOME ADVOCATES WHO UNDERSTAND
01:37:05.452 --> 01:37:07.755
THIS MUCH BETTER THAN I DO. BUT
01:37:07.821 --> 01:37:08.556
THERE IS A DIFFERENT IMPACT ON
01:37:08.622 --> 01:37:12.593
OUR LOW INCOME. COMMUNITIES THAT
01:37:12.660 --> 01:37:17.031
HAVE, UH, A LOT OF UM,
01:37:17.097 --> 01:37:18.165
OVERCROWDED NOUS, BUT THEY'RE
01:37:18.232 --> 01:37:21.669
THEY'RE TRYING TRYING TO USE THE
01:37:21.735 --> 01:37:23.204
PUBLIC TRANSIT SYSTEM. IT'S NOT
01:37:23.270 --> 01:37:25.573
QUITE THERE THE WAY THAT THEY
01:37:25.639 --> 01:37:27.107
NEEDED TO BE TO BE ABLE TO GET
01:37:27.174 --> 01:37:29.577
AROUND, SO I CONTINUE TO BE VERY
01:37:29.643 --> 01:37:32.513
CONCERNED ABOUT THE BILL. I WILL
01:37:32.580 --> 01:37:34.281
COMMIT TO SITTING DOWN IN
01:37:34.348 --> 01:37:36.417
PARKING TO SOME MORE ABOUT THAT
01:37:36.483 --> 01:37:38.452
. THERE'S SOME CONCERN THAT I
01:37:38.519 --> 01:37:39.787
THINK HAVE LEGITIMATELY BEEN
01:37:39.853 --> 01:37:41.855
BROUGHT UP BY THE WESTERN CENTER
01:37:41.922 --> 01:37:43.891
AND I WOULD LIKE TO SEE YOU GO
01:37:43.958 --> 01:37:45.960
MORE IN THE DIRECTION? UM, TODAY
01:37:46.026 --> 01:37:49.029
I WILL SUPPORT IT. BUT I RESERVE
01:37:49.096 --> 01:37:50.030
THE RIGHT UH, IN THE FUTURE,
01:37:50.097 --> 01:37:53.500
TOO. TO WITHDRAW BASED ON THOSE
01:37:53.567 --> 01:37:58.072
CONCERNS. AND I THINK THAT THERE
01:37:58.138 --> 01:38:00.507
YOU KNOW, THERE ARE THINGS THAT
01:38:00.574 --> 01:38:01.675
MAKE ME FEEL A LITTLE
01:38:01.742 --> 01:38:04.044
UNCOMFORTABLE. I KNOW THAT, UM
01:38:04.111 --> 01:38:06.547
ELECTRIC VEHICLES, UM, PARKING
01:38:06.614 --> 01:38:08.182
FOR ELECTRIC VEHICLES IS
01:38:08.249 --> 01:38:10.784
PROVIDED FOR, UM, SO WHO CAN
01:38:10.851 --> 01:38:11.452
AFFORD ELECTRIC VEHICLES? RIGHT?
01:38:11.518 --> 01:38:16.790
UM, I MEAN, THAT THAT EXCEPTION
01:38:16.857 --> 01:38:21.395
IS MADE, BUT. BUT NOT FOR OTHER
01:38:21.462 --> 01:38:23.297
VEHICLES. OKAY I GET IT. YOU
01:38:23.364 --> 01:38:25.366
LOOK VEHICLES ARE CLEAN, BUT
01:38:25.432 --> 01:38:28.369
STILL NOT VERY MANY POOR PEOPLE
01:38:28.435 --> 01:38:29.403
AFFORD CAN AFFORD ELECTRIC
01:38:29.470 --> 01:38:32.373
VEHICLES, SO THE HIGHER YOU
01:38:32.439 --> 01:38:33.907
KNOW, INCOME YOU ARE. YOU'RE
01:38:33.974 --> 01:38:36.076
GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE
01:38:36.143 --> 01:38:37.678
YOUR CAR RIGHT UNDERNEATH YOUR
01:38:37.745 --> 01:38:38.712
APARTMENT BUILDING OR IN YOUR
01:38:38.779 --> 01:38:42.316
AREA SO ANYWAY. JUST JUST AN
01:38:42.383 --> 01:38:43.384
EXAMPLE. BUT I THINK MORE
01:38:43.450 --> 01:38:47.054
IMPORTANTLY, IS THE ISSUE OF
01:38:47.121 --> 01:38:48.222
MORE HOUSING, MORE AFFORDABLE
01:38:48.289 --> 01:38:51.792
HOUSING, SO I JUST WANT TO MAKE
01:38:51.859 --> 01:38:52.893
THOSE COMMENTS AND FOR TODAY,
01:38:52.960 --> 01:38:58.265
BUT THIS CONVERSATION. VERY GOOD
01:38:58.332 --> 01:39:00.601
. WHY I WANNA THANK THE AUTHOR
01:39:00.668 --> 01:39:01.802
FOR HER PERSISTENCE IN THIS
01:39:01.869 --> 01:39:05.272
AREA. I THINK IT'S A IT IS. THIS
01:39:05.339 --> 01:39:07.775
IS A THIS IS A REAL IMPORTANT
01:39:07.841 --> 01:39:09.009
MOVE BUT NEEDS TO BE DONE
01:39:09.076 --> 01:39:11.912
CAREFULLY. AND I THINK, UM UH,
01:39:11.979 --> 01:39:14.348
SENATOR DURAZO ARTICULATED. I
01:39:14.415 --> 01:39:16.417
WAS WONDERING IF YOU COULD. UM I
01:39:16.483 --> 01:39:17.318
APPRECIATE YOU TAKING THE
01:39:17.384 --> 01:39:19.386
AMENDMENTS. THEY WILL BE TAKEN
01:39:19.453 --> 01:39:20.521
IN THE NEXT COMMITTEE. AND SO,
01:39:20.587 --> 01:39:23.490
UM, APPRECIATE THAT. UM COULD
01:39:23.557 --> 01:39:24.958
YOU ADDRESS THE ISSUE THAT WAS
01:39:25.025 --> 01:39:27.895
RAISED BY UNITED HERE IN REGARDS
01:39:27.961 --> 01:39:30.130
TO HOTELS AND ALSO, UM, I
01:39:30.197 --> 01:39:31.298
BELIEVE THERE'S IT'S A
01:39:31.365 --> 01:39:36.003
MISUNDERSTANDING. UM. TO SAY
01:39:36.070 --> 01:39:37.571
THAT IT'S IT FLIES IN THE FACE
01:39:37.638 --> 01:39:39.640
OF TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT
01:39:39.707 --> 01:39:41.408
BECAUSE I THINK IT REALLY
01:39:41.475 --> 01:39:43.410
COMPLEMENTS IT. SO COULD YOU
01:39:43.477 --> 01:39:45.946
ADDRESS THAT? AND, UM AND I AND
01:39:46.013 --> 01:39:47.448
ALSO I HOPE YOU'LL MAKE THE
01:39:47.514 --> 01:39:48.615
COMMITMENT TO CONTINUE WORKING
01:39:48.682 --> 01:39:50.384
WITH THE WESTERN CENTER IN
01:39:50.451 --> 01:39:51.452
SIERRA LEONE BECAUSE I LIKE
01:39:51.518 --> 01:39:57.024
SENATOR DURAZO, UM. IN IN MANY
01:39:57.091 --> 01:39:58.592
OF OUR COMMUNITIES BECAUSE OF
01:39:58.659 --> 01:39:59.259
THE OVERCROWDED HOUSING
01:39:59.326 --> 01:40:01.695
SITUATION. THE NUMBER OF CARS UM
01:40:01.762 --> 01:40:03.364
IS REALLY HAS AN IMPACT ON THE
01:40:03.430 --> 01:40:08.268
NEIGHBORHOOD. AND, UM AND I. AND
01:40:08.335 --> 01:40:09.770
YOU TOOK THE AMENDMENTS THAT I
01:40:09.837 --> 01:40:11.205
WAS CONCERNED ABOUT, WHICH IS
01:40:11.271 --> 01:40:12.673
THAT WE DON'T HAVE THE
01:40:12.740 --> 01:40:13.574
INFRASTRUCTURE IN RURAL
01:40:13.640 --> 01:40:15.576
CALIFORNIA FOR PEOPLE TO BE ABLE
01:40:15.642 --> 01:40:16.710
TO TAKE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
01:40:16.777 --> 01:40:18.579
AND AS MUCH AS PEOPLE WANT TO
01:40:18.645 --> 01:40:20.881
GET OUT OF THEIR CARS IF THEY
01:40:20.948 --> 01:40:22.783
HAVE TO DRIVE 30 MINUTES TO AN
01:40:22.850 --> 01:40:24.251
HOUR TO GET TO WORK. THEY HAD TO
01:40:24.318 --> 01:40:25.452
FIND SOME PLACE TO PARK AND SO,
01:40:25.519 --> 01:40:28.155
UM, UNTIL WE MAKE THE COMMITMENT
01:40:28.222 --> 01:40:29.723
TO INTO THE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR
01:40:29.790 --> 01:40:31.291
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION SO THAT
01:40:31.358 --> 01:40:33.394
IT'S MORE ROBUST. I THINK IT'S
01:40:33.460 --> 01:40:34.361
THESE KINDS OF THINGS ARE
01:40:34.428 --> 01:40:36.296
DIFFICULT. SO YOUR AMENDMENTS
01:40:36.363 --> 01:40:38.232
DEAL WITH THAT AND I WANT TO. I
01:40:38.298 --> 01:40:40.267
WANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT AND THANK
01:40:40.334 --> 01:40:41.235
YOU FOR THAT. I'M GOING TO
01:40:41.301 --> 01:40:43.504
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY, BUT I
01:40:43.570 --> 01:40:44.972
WAS WONDERING IF YOU COULD
01:40:45.038 --> 01:40:46.306
ADDRESS THE ISSUES YOU SURE? AND
01:40:46.373 --> 01:40:47.374
IF I MISS ONE, PLEASE REMIND ME
01:40:47.441 --> 01:40:49.143
FIRST OF ALL TO OTHER AMENDMENTS
01:40:49.209 --> 01:40:51.512
THAT WE HAVE TAKEN. ONE IS TO
01:40:51.578 --> 01:40:53.180
LIMIT THIS TO PROJECTS THAT ARE
01:40:53.247 --> 01:40:55.182
40 UNITS IN BELOW, SO IT'S NOT
01:40:55.249 --> 01:40:56.717
THE VERY LARGE BUILDINGS.
01:40:56.784 --> 01:40:59.953
SECONDLY TO MAKE SURE THAT
01:41:00.020 --> 01:41:01.021
HOSPITALITY THAT THAT HOTELS AND
01:41:01.088 --> 01:41:02.856
CONVENTION CENTERS HAVE TO
01:41:02.923 --> 01:41:03.557
PROVIDE PARKING FOR THEIR
01:41:03.624 --> 01:41:06.126
EMPLOYEES SO THAT WE DON'T HAVE
01:41:06.193 --> 01:41:08.128
LOW INCOME EMPLOYEES, YOU KNOW,
01:41:08.195 --> 01:41:10.297
STRANDED THERE LATE AT NIGHT
01:41:10.364 --> 01:41:11.298
WITH WITHOUT ACCESS TO GOOD
01:41:11.365 --> 01:41:12.566
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION THAT DOES
01:41:12.633 --> 01:41:14.034
NOT ADDRESS ALL OF UNITED HEAR
01:41:14.101 --> 01:41:16.637
THEIR CONCERNS. THEY
01:41:16.703 --> 01:41:18.772
FUNDAMENTALLY FEEL THAT HOTELS
01:41:18.839 --> 01:41:21.442
ARE IN COMPETITION WITH LOW
01:41:21.508 --> 01:41:22.676
INCOME HOUSING, AND THAT THIS
01:41:22.743 --> 01:41:24.812
WILL HELP HOTELS BUILD NOW I
01:41:24.878 --> 01:41:26.713
WOULD ARGUE THAT CITIES OFTEN
01:41:26.780 --> 01:41:28.248
WILL ZONE HOUSING FOR HOUSING
01:41:28.315 --> 01:41:30.451
AND HER HOTELS FOR HOTELS AND
01:41:30.517 --> 01:41:32.052
HAVE A WHOLE BUNCH OF
01:41:32.119 --> 01:41:34.054
DISCRETIONARY APPROVALS THEY
01:41:34.121 --> 01:41:35.255
USUALLY HAVE TO GIVE BEFORE THEY
01:41:35.322 --> 01:41:37.124
APPROVE HOTEL PROJECTS. SO
01:41:37.191 --> 01:41:38.559
THERE'S MANY WAIT TIMES WHEN
01:41:38.625 --> 01:41:40.194
SOMEONE CAN COME UP AND ARGUE
01:41:40.260 --> 01:41:41.862
THAT THE LAND SHOULD BE ZONED
01:41:41.929 --> 01:41:43.664
FOR HOUSING, OR IT SHOULD BE
01:41:43.730 --> 01:41:45.332
HOUSING AND NOT A HOTEL. BUT I
01:41:45.399 --> 01:41:46.166
FEEL THAT THE PARKING
01:41:46.233 --> 01:41:47.835
REQUIREMENTS SHOULDN'T BE USED
01:41:47.901 --> 01:41:49.503
AS KIND OF A TOOL TO, UM YOU
01:41:49.570 --> 01:41:51.171
KNOW, TO KIND OF FORCE THAT, UM,
01:41:51.238 --> 01:41:52.806
BUT WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
01:41:52.873 --> 01:41:54.775
WORKERS UNTIL WE EITHER HAVE
01:41:54.842 --> 01:41:55.909
ADDED THE AMENDMENT OR WE WILL
01:41:55.976 --> 01:41:57.544
ADD THE AMENDMENT. FOR THE
01:41:57.611 --> 01:41:59.046
EMPLOYEE PARKING AND WE'RE HAPPY
01:41:59.112 --> 01:42:01.014
TO MAKE THAT MORE ROBUST, IF
01:42:01.081 --> 01:42:02.082
THAT'S THE CONCERN TO MAKE SURE
01:42:02.149 --> 01:42:03.116
THAT HOTELS ACTUALLY WILL HVE
01:42:03.183 --> 01:42:04.551
TO DO THAT, BECAUSE WE ALSO
01:42:04.618 --> 01:42:06.420
DON'T WANT TO LEAVE ANYONE
01:42:06.487 --> 01:42:07.421
STRANDED. I WILL SAY THAT WHEN
01:42:07.488 --> 01:42:08.255
IT COMES TO PUBLIC
01:42:08.322 --> 01:42:10.457
TRANSPORTATION, WE HAVE A BIT OF
01:42:10.524 --> 01:42:11.358
A CHICKEN AND THE EGG PROBLEM,
01:42:11.425 --> 01:42:13.160
AND ONE OF THE PROBLEMS IS THAT
01:42:13.227 --> 01:42:14.361
IF YOU ONTINUE TO PROVIDE AMPLE
01:42:14.428 --> 01:42:16.396
PARKING NEAR TRANSIT PEOPLE TEND
01:42:16.463 --> 01:42:17.598
TO USE THAT PARKING AND DRIVE.
01:42:17.664 --> 01:42:20.167
EVEN IF THEY HAVE OTHER OPTIONS.
01:42:20.234 --> 01:42:22.269
EVEN IF THEY HAVE A BUS. THAT'S
01:42:22.336 --> 01:42:24.371
THAT'S CONVENIENT BUS, YOU KNOW,
01:42:24.438 --> 01:42:26.206
LEADING TO A TRAIN STATION, THEY
01:42:26.273 --> 01:42:27.307
WILL OFTEN DRIVE INTO THOSE
01:42:27.374 --> 01:42:30.143
AREAS. AND IF YOU DISINCENTIVIZE
01:42:30.210 --> 01:42:32.045
THAT PARKING PEOPLE TEND TO USE
01:42:32.112 --> 01:42:33.413
THE TRANSIT MORE, AND WE KNOW
01:42:33.480 --> 01:42:35.048
THAT FROM EVERY STUDY THAT'S
01:42:35.115 --> 01:42:36.383
EVER BEEN DONE SO TO GIVE THE
01:42:36.450 --> 01:42:38.418
TRANSIT A FAIR CHANCE TO WORK,
01:42:38.485 --> 01:42:40.454
WE HAVE TO MAKE IT THE PREFERRED
01:42:40.521 --> 01:42:41.555
MODE OF TRANSPORTATION TO WHERE
01:42:41.622 --> 01:42:42.956
IT'S MORE CONVENIENT. BUT ALSO
01:42:43.023 --> 01:42:44.558
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AREAS THAT
01:42:44.625 --> 01:42:46.059
ARE VERY CLOSE TO MAJOR TRANSIT
01:42:46.126 --> 01:42:47.661
. SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AREAS
01:42:47.728 --> 01:42:48.762
THAT WE HAVE ALREADY IDENTIFIED.
01:42:48.829 --> 01:42:50.564
AS WHAT WE WANT TO HAVE A
01:42:50.631 --> 01:42:52.065
DOWNTOWN AREA. WE WANT TO HAVE A
01:42:52.132 --> 01:42:53.634
CITY CENTER, AND THOSE CITY
01:42:53.700 --> 01:42:55.135
CENTERS DON'T WORK WHEN PEOPLE
01:42:55.202 --> 01:42:56.303
ARE WALKING PAST LARGE, OPEN AIR
01:42:56.370 --> 01:42:58.071
PARKING LOTS. THEY DON'T WORK
01:42:58.138 --> 01:42:59.673
WHEN IT'S SO EXPENSIVE FOR
01:42:59.740 --> 01:43:00.908
STORES TO OPEN THAT THEY PROVIDE
01:43:00.974 --> 01:43:02.776
ALL THE PARKING THAT THEY JUST
01:43:02.843 --> 01:43:03.911
CAN'T OPERATE, AND IT ALSO
01:43:03.977 --> 01:43:05.512
DOESN'T WORK TO CREATE THE
01:43:05.579 --> 01:43:07.414
HOUSING THAT WE NEED. SO THIS
01:43:07.481 --> 01:43:09.316
ALSO HELPS TO CHANGE THE LAND
01:43:09.383 --> 01:43:11.485
USE PATTERNS THAT ALLOW FOR
01:43:11.552 --> 01:43:12.286
THOSE MORE OLD FASHIONED
01:43:12.352 --> 01:43:15.022
WALKABLE DOWNTOWN MAIN STREETS.
01:43:15.088 --> 01:43:16.757
MOST OF THOSE MAIN STREETS THAT
01:43:16.823 --> 01:43:17.424
MY COMMUNITY LOVES BRAND
01:43:17.491 --> 01:43:18.492
BOULEVARD IN MY COMMUNITY
01:43:18.559 --> 01:43:22.062
MONTROSE YOU COULD NEVER BUILD.
01:43:22.129 --> 01:43:23.697
THOSE OF ALL OF THOSE BUSINESSES
01:43:23.764 --> 01:43:25.065
HAD TO PROVIDE THEIR OWN PARKING
01:43:25.132 --> 01:43:26.567
. AND WHEN THERE'S WHEN THERE'S
01:43:26.633 --> 01:43:27.734
NOT ENOUGH PARKING. WHAT OUR
01:43:27.801 --> 01:43:29.436
CITIES HAVE DONE IN MANY CITIES
01:43:29.503 --> 01:43:30.537
HAVE DONE IS THEY BUILD A
01:43:30.604 --> 01:43:31.405
MUNICIPAL PARKING LOT? YES, THAT
01:43:31.471 --> 01:43:33.440
COSTS MONEY, BUT THOSE OFTEN
01:43:33.507 --> 01:43:34.074
PROVIDE REVENUE FOR MANY YEARS
01:43:34.141 --> 01:43:35.275
FOR THOSE CITIES, SO THERE ARE
01:43:35.342 --> 01:43:37.978
WAYS THAT CITIES CAN HANDLE. ANY
01:43:38.045 --> 01:43:40.213
ANY OF THE MOBILITY NEEDS. THE
01:43:40.280 --> 01:43:42.282
BEST ONE IS TO PROVIDE TRANSIT
01:43:42.349 --> 01:43:43.283
AND AGAIN. WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
01:43:43.350 --> 01:43:44.618
AREAS THAT ALREADY HAVE MAJOR
01:43:44.685 --> 01:43:45.586
TRANSIT AND CITIES SHOULD BE
01:43:45.652 --> 01:43:47.487
DOUBLING DOWN BY PROVIDING THE
01:43:47.554 --> 01:43:49.790
CONNECTING TRANSIT TO THAT THAT
01:43:49.856 --> 01:43:51.925
WE NEED, SO IT'S A BIT OF A
01:43:51.992 --> 01:43:53.160
CHICKEN AND EGG PROBLEM, AND I
01:43:53.226 --> 01:43:54.928
WOULD CONTEND THAT THIS NEEDS TO
01:43:54.995 --> 01:43:56.396
GO FIRST. NOW WE HAVE REAL WORLD
01:43:56.463 --> 01:43:57.998
. EXAMPLES OF HOW THIS WORKS.
01:43:58.065 --> 01:44:00.067
SAN DIEGO IS A GREAT EXAMPLE.
01:44:00.133 --> 01:44:01.668
MAYBE NOT AS URBAN AS SAN
01:44:01.735 --> 01:44:03.070
FRANCISCO. YOU KNOW, I WOULD
01:44:03.136 --> 01:44:04.838
LOVE TO POINT OUT SAN FRANCISCO,
01:44:04.905 --> 01:44:05.739
BUT MAYBE DIFFERENT LAND, YOU
01:44:05.806 --> 01:44:07.541
KNOW, SORT OF TRADITIONAL LAND
01:44:07.608 --> 01:44:08.842
USE PATTERNS. BUT WHEN SAN DIEGO
01:44:08.909 --> 01:44:10.777
DID THIS AND BUFFALO, NEW YORK
01:44:10.844 --> 01:44:11.945
HAS DONE THIS AS WELL AND THEIR
01:44:12.012 --> 01:44:13.313
ENTIRE CITY. THEY FOUND SOME
01:44:13.380 --> 01:44:14.648
INTERESTING THINGS. NUMBER ONE
01:44:14.715 --> 01:44:16.149
PEOPLE STILL PROVIDED PARKING
01:44:16.216 --> 01:44:17.751
HOUSING DEVELOPERS OFTEN STOOD.
01:44:17.818 --> 01:44:19.386
Mí
01:44:19.453 --> 01:44:20.887
PROVIDED PARKING, BUT THEY RIGHT
01:44:20.954 --> 01:44:22.489
SIZED IT. MORE IMPORTANTLY, THE
01:44:22.556 --> 01:44:23.924
AMOUNT OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING
01:44:23.991 --> 01:44:26.026
THAT WAS BUILT AND WE HAVE OUR
01:44:26.093 --> 01:44:27.294
PEOPLE THAT ARE HERE TODAY,
01:44:27.361 --> 01:44:28.662
SPEAKING AND OUR SPONSORS ARE
01:44:28.729 --> 01:44:29.863
ARE DEVELOPERS WHO BUILD 100%
01:44:29.930 --> 01:44:33.533
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. TAKE IT FROM
01:44:33.600 --> 01:44:35.135
THE LIPS OF SOMEONE WHO KNOWS
01:44:35.202 --> 01:44:36.670
AND LIVES AND BREATHES THIS.
01:44:36.737 --> 01:44:38.505
THEY NEED THIS DESPERATELY TO
01:44:38.572 --> 01:44:40.140
PROVIDE AFFORDABLE UNITS
01:44:40.207 --> 01:44:42.342
AFFORDABLE UNITS CITY OF SAN
01:44:42.409 --> 01:44:44.444
DIEGO SAW A FOUR TIMES INCREASE
01:44:44.511 --> 01:44:45.412
IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUILT
01:44:45.479 --> 01:44:48.715
UNDER DENSITY BONUS. WE HAVE HAD
01:44:48.782 --> 01:44:49.516
PEOPLE THAT WE'VE INTERACTED
01:44:49.583 --> 01:44:51.118
WITH WHO WEREN'T PART OF THIS
01:44:51.184 --> 01:44:52.419
WHO JUST MENTIONED THINGS LIKE
01:44:52.486 --> 01:44:54.221
OH, YOU KNOW, WE HAD ONE PERSON
01:44:54.287 --> 01:44:56.256
WHO WAS IN THE OFFICE FOR A
01:44:56.323 --> 01:44:57.357
COMPLETELY DIFFERENT ISSUE, HE
01:44:57.424 --> 01:44:58.592
SAID. YOU KNOW, I LIVE. I CAN'T
01:44:58.659 --> 01:45:00.661
REMEMBER WHERE THEY LIVE. THEY
01:45:00.727 --> 01:45:02.396
SAID I WAS ABLE TO RENT A UNIT.
01:45:02.462 --> 01:45:03.563
FOR $400 LESS THAN EVERYONE ELSE
01:45:03.630 --> 01:45:05.332
IN THE BUILDING BECAUSE I DON'T
01:45:05.399 --> 01:45:07.334
OWN A CAR AND I TOOK A UNIT
01:45:07.401 --> 01:45:08.735
WITHOUT A CAR. THERE WAS PERFECT
01:45:08.802 --> 01:45:10.437
FOR ME, AND I WAS SO GLAD I
01:45:10.504 --> 01:45:12.406
WASN'T FORCED TO PAY FOR A
01:45:12.472 --> 01:45:14.141
PARKING SPOT THAT I DON'T USE.
01:45:14.207 --> 01:45:15.909
THIS ALLOWS FOR PEOPLE WHO WANT
01:45:15.976 --> 01:45:16.476
TO TAKE TRANSIT, WHOSE SELF
01:45:16.543 --> 01:45:17.711
SELECT TO LIVE NEXT TO TRANSIT.
01:45:17.778 --> 01:45:19.246
THE ABILITY TO NOT HAVE TO PAY
01:45:19.312 --> 01:45:21.281
FOR MAYBE TWO SPACES WHEN THEY
01:45:21.348 --> 01:45:22.449
HAVE ONE CAR OR IF THEY RIDE
01:45:22.516 --> 01:45:24.451
THEIR BIKE, NO SPACES, SO IT
01:45:24.518 --> 01:45:25.652
DOES ALLOW FOR FLEXIBILITY FOR
01:45:25.719 --> 01:45:26.720
DEVELOPERS. IT ALLOWS FOR THE
01:45:26.787 --> 01:45:28.622
VERY SMALL DEVELOPERS TO ADD AN
01:45:28.689 --> 01:45:29.956
EXTRA UNIT. FOR INSTANCE, AS
01:45:30.023 --> 01:45:31.725
WE'VE HEARD MANY PEOPLE WHO ARE
01:45:31.792 --> 01:45:33.026
FOUR PLEX IS SAY THEY WANT TO DO
01:45:33.093 --> 01:45:34.628
WITHOUT HAVING TO ADD THAT
01:45:34.695 --> 01:45:35.529
BURDENSOME PARKING REQUIREMENT
01:45:35.595 --> 01:45:36.897
ON SITE SO WE HAVE REAL WORLD
01:45:36.963 --> 01:45:39.099
EXAMPLES. IT'S BEEN POSITIVE. IT
01:45:39.166 --> 01:45:40.967
HASN'T LED TO THE DIRE IMPACTS
01:45:41.034 --> 01:45:43.036
THAT WE'VE HEARD WORRIES ABOUT.
01:45:43.103 --> 01:45:44.371
FOR WESTERN CENTER. I WOULD SAY
01:45:44.438 --> 01:45:46.206
WE TOOK THE AMENDMENT 40 UNITS
01:45:46.273 --> 01:45:47.441
TO HELP YOU KNOW TO ADDRESS
01:45:47.507 --> 01:45:49.743
THEIR CONCERNS. BUT THE CITY OF
01:45:49.810 --> 01:45:51.044
SAN DIEGO SHOWS THAT THEIR
01:45:51.111 --> 01:45:53.313
CONCERNS ARE UNFOUNDED. DENSITY
01:45:53.380 --> 01:45:56.216
BONUS USE WENT UP, NOT DOWN. WE
01:45:56.283 --> 01:45:58.185
DON'T KNOW HOW TO PROVE IT. YOU
01:45:58.251 --> 01:45:59.319
KNOW, THERE'S REALLY NOTHING
01:45:59.386 --> 01:46:00.454
ELSE THAT WE CAN SAY, EXCEPT
01:46:00.520 --> 01:46:02.989
LOOK AT WHERE THIS HAS BEEN
01:46:03.056 --> 01:46:03.557
DONE. DOWNTOWN SAN DIEGO.
01:46:03.623 --> 01:46:05.625
VIBRANT DEVELOPMENT HAPPENING
01:46:05.692 --> 01:46:06.226
ECONOMICALLY, MORE AFFORDABLE
01:46:06.293 --> 01:46:09.863
HOUSING BEING BUILT. WE THINK
01:46:09.930 --> 01:46:11.465
THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT. AND I
01:46:11.531 --> 01:46:13.400
WILL SAY THAT. HOW OFTEN DO YOU
01:46:13.467 --> 01:46:14.234
GET THE CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE
01:46:14.301 --> 01:46:16.069
SUPPORTING US AT THE SAME BILL
01:46:16.136 --> 01:46:17.204
THAT THIS YEAR A CLUB IS
01:46:17.270 --> 01:46:19.673
SUPPORTING? YOU KNOW, THIS IS A
01:46:19.740 --> 01:46:21.241
BILL THAT HAS HAD BIPARTISAN
01:46:21.308 --> 01:46:22.809
SUPPORT THAT WE THINK IS VERY
01:46:22.876 --> 01:46:24.244
IMPORTANT AND WE WOULD LOVE TO
01:46:24.311 --> 01:46:25.278
GET THE BILL THROUGH THE
01:46:25.345 --> 01:46:26.713
COMMITTEE AND WE WILL CONTINUE
01:46:26.780 --> 01:46:28.715
TO TALK TO EVERYONE WHO HAS
01:46:28.782 --> 01:46:29.816
CONCERNS AND MAKE SURE THAT WE
01:46:29.883 --> 01:46:31.985
DO OUR BEST TO ADDRESS THEM.
01:46:32.052 --> 01:46:32.919
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SENATOR
01:46:32.986 --> 01:46:34.588
HERZBERG. I'M SORRY. I JUST I
01:46:34.654 --> 01:46:36.957
TOOK A LOOK AT THE AMENDMENTS. I
01:46:37.023 --> 01:46:38.325
WANT TO. I'M GOING TO VOTE FOR
01:46:38.391 --> 01:46:40.127
TODAY. BUT I WANT TO RESERVE AS
01:46:40.193 --> 01:46:41.495
DID SENATOR ALSO MY VOTE
01:46:41.561 --> 01:46:42.996
SUBSEQUENTLY, CAUSE I WANT TO
01:46:43.063 --> 01:46:45.132
REVIEW THIS AGAINST SB 10 67 AND
01:46:45.198 --> 01:46:46.800
TRY TO MEASURE THAT JUST HAVING
01:46:46.867 --> 01:46:49.102
A CHANCE TO TAKE A LOOK AT THAT.
01:46:49.169 --> 01:46:50.237
SO I'D APPRECIATE THIS WANTED TO
01:46:50.303 --> 01:46:51.304
MAKE THAT ON THE RECORD. THANK
01:46:51.371 --> 01:46:53.740
YOU. VERY GOOD. SO YOU'VE HEARD
01:46:53.807 --> 01:46:55.175
THE COMMITTEE COMMENTS? UM ALLOW
01:46:55.242 --> 01:46:56.710
YOU TO CONCLUDE IF YOU HAVE
01:46:56.777 --> 01:46:58.812
ANYTHING MORE. I WILL TAKE THAT
01:46:58.879 --> 01:46:59.813
AS MY CONCLUSION, BUT ABSOLUTELY
01:46:59.880 --> 01:47:02.082
WE WILL CONTINUE TO WORK ON THIS
01:47:02.149 --> 01:47:03.150
IMPORTANT POLICY. THANKS. VERY
01:47:03.216 --> 01:47:03.784
GOOD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. SO
01:47:03.850 --> 01:47:05.452
THERE IS A MOTION THE MOTION IS
01:47:05.519 --> 01:47:07.587
DUE PASS. BUT FIRST BE WE
01:47:07.654 --> 01:47:08.755
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:47:08.822 --> 01:47:10.023
HOUSING AND AMENDMENTS WOULD BE
01:47:10.090 --> 01:47:11.258
TAKEN IN THAT COMMITTEE. PLEASE
01:47:11.324 --> 01:47:16.263
CALL THE ROLL. AS SENATORS
01:47:16.329 --> 01:47:18.965
CAVALLERO, Hí
01:47:19.032 --> 01:47:24.805
DURAZO. SO I HERZBERG HERZBERG.
01:47:24.871 --> 01:47:30.110
AYE WIENER WINNER. I 5 TO 0.
01:47:30.177 --> 01:47:32.379
WE'RE ALL HERE SO THAT THAT HAS
01:47:32.445 --> 01:47:35.248
THAT IS CONCLUDED 5 TO 0
01:47:35.315 --> 01:47:37.784
MEASURES OUT. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
01:47:37.851 --> 01:47:39.486
FILE ITEM NUMBER 11.
01:47:39.553 --> 01:47:40.587
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GABRIEL A B 21
01:47:40.654 --> 01:47:57.504
42. WELCOME. FLOOR IS YOURS.
01:47:57.571 --> 01:47:58.371
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
01:47:58.438 --> 01:48:00.407
MEMBERS. I EXPECT THIS TO BE A
01:48:00.473 --> 01:48:02.509
SIGNIFICANTLY BRIEFER BUT
01:48:02.576 --> 01:48:04.077
PLEASED TODAY TO PRESENT A B 21
01:48:04.144 --> 01:48:05.345
42. THIS IS A BILL THAT WOULD
01:48:05.412 --> 01:48:08.515
REESTABLISH AH, THE EXEMPTION
01:48:08.582 --> 01:48:10.884
FROM GROSS INCOME FOR CERTAIN
01:48:10.951 --> 01:48:12.853
WATER CONSERVATION REBATES THAT
01:48:12.919 --> 01:48:13.486
ARE PROVIDED BY LOCAL AGENCIES
01:48:13.553 --> 01:48:14.921
FOR THINGS LIKE DROUGHT TOLERANT
01:48:14.988 --> 01:48:16.423
LANDSCAPE IN AND DRIP DRIP
01:48:16.489 --> 01:48:19.292
IRRIGATION. OBVIOUSLY THE ISSUES
01:48:19.359 --> 01:48:20.560
OF DROUGHT AND WATER
01:48:20.627 --> 01:48:22.562
CONSERVATION ON TOP OF MIND FOR
01:48:22.629 --> 01:48:23.897
PEOPLE ACROSS THE STATE OF
01:48:23.964 --> 01:48:24.598
CALIFORNIA. AND THESE REBATES
01:48:24.664 --> 01:48:26.399
ARE A PROVEN COST EFFECTIVE TOOL
01:48:26.466 --> 01:48:27.400
FOR INCREASING PARTICIPATION IN
01:48:27.467 --> 01:48:28.935
WATER CONSERVATION AND TAXING
01:48:29.002 --> 01:48:30.437
THOSE REBATES IS A DISINCENTIVE
01:48:30.503 --> 01:48:32.806
AND UNDERMINES THEIR ADVOCACY,
01:48:32.873 --> 01:48:35.809
SO THIS WOULD JUST RE RESTORE
01:48:35.876 --> 01:48:37.911
WHAT WAS THE PRACTICE UP UNTIL
01:48:37.978 --> 01:48:40.247
2019 WOULD HELP US TO BUILD
01:48:40.313 --> 01:48:41.248
RESILIENCY AND REDUCE WATER
01:48:41.314 --> 01:48:43.550
CONSUMPTION. AND THINK IT COULD
01:48:43.617 --> 01:48:44.384
GO A LONG WAY TOWARDS DOING
01:48:44.451 --> 01:48:45.652
THAT. SO WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:48:45.719 --> 01:48:47.454
FOR YOUR VOTE AT THE APPROPRIATE
01:48:47.520 --> 01:48:49.289
TIME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH I HAVE
01:48:49.356 --> 01:48:51.858
LISTED HERE. JULIA BISHOP HALL,
01:48:51.925 --> 01:48:53.493
WHO IS HERE IN PERSON FROM THE
01:48:53.560 --> 01:48:54.361
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA WATER
01:48:54.427 --> 01:48:55.495
AGENCIES IS ONE OF THE LEAD
01:48:55.562 --> 01:48:58.398
WITNESSES WELCOME. QUÊ GOOD
01:48:58.465 --> 01:48:59.432
MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS. MY NAME
01:48:59.499 --> 01:49:00.667
IS JULIA HALL WITH THE
01:49:00.734 --> 01:49:01.668
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA WATER
01:49:01.735 --> 01:49:03.503
AGENCIES, AND WE'RE ONE OF THE
01:49:03.570 --> 01:49:06.473
PROUD SPONSORS OF A B 21 42 AS A
01:49:06.539 --> 01:49:08.275
SOME OF THEM ARE JUST SAID THIS
01:49:08.341 --> 01:49:08.708
BILL WOULD REINSTATE
01:49:08.775 --> 01:49:10.343
CALIFORNIA'S TAX EXEMPTION FOR
01:49:10.410 --> 01:49:10.911
TERP REPLACEMENT REBATES IN
01:49:10.977 --> 01:49:11.711
CALIFORNIA, WHICH WERE ALLOWED
01:49:11.778 --> 01:49:14.381
TO SUNSET IN 2019. THESE REBATE
01:49:14.447 --> 01:49:16.082
PROGRAMS ARE MORE CRITICAL THAN
01:49:16.149 --> 01:49:17.250
EVER AS THE STATE IS IN ITS
01:49:17.317 --> 01:49:19.085
SECOND SEVERE DROUGHT WITHIN A
01:49:19.152 --> 01:49:20.654
DECADE. THE FURTHER. THE
01:49:20.720 --> 01:49:21.688
GOVERNOR RECENTLY MOVED TO BAN
01:49:21.755 --> 01:49:23.056
THE IRRIGATION OF COMMERCIAL
01:49:23.123 --> 01:49:24.591
NONFUNCTIONAL TURPIN, THE STATE
01:49:24.658 --> 01:49:26.693
TO RESPOND TO THE DROUGHT. 18 21
01:49:26.760 --> 01:49:28.295
42 RECOGNIZES THAT CLIMATE
01:49:28.361 --> 01:49:29.829
CHANGE IS INCREASING. THE
01:49:29.896 --> 01:49:30.697
FREQUENCY AND SEVERITY OF
01:49:30.764 --> 01:49:31.531
DROUGHT AND ADAPTATION IS
01:49:31.598 --> 01:49:32.599
UNNECESSARY AND CRITICAL, LONG
01:49:32.666 --> 01:49:36.536
TERM GOAL. FURTHER THE STATE HAS
01:49:36.603 --> 01:49:37.871
MADE A COMMITMENT TO MAKING
01:49:37.938 --> 01:49:38.471
CONSERVATION OF CALIFORNIA WAY
01:49:38.538 --> 01:49:39.940
OF LIFE IN CALIFORNIA. THE
01:49:40.006 --> 01:49:41.041
ADMINISTRATION IS IN THE PROCESS
01:49:41.107 --> 01:49:42.375
OF ESTABLISHING A WATER USE
01:49:42.442 --> 01:49:43.343
OBJECTIVE THAT WILL CREATE
01:49:43.410 --> 01:49:44.477
NUMERICAL THAT AGENCIES MUST
01:49:44.544 --> 01:49:45.578
MEET, INCLUDING AN OUTDOOR WATER
01:49:45.645 --> 01:49:48.348
USE COMPONENTS. IT'S CRITICAL TO
01:49:48.415 --> 01:49:49.282
INCENTIVIZE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION
01:49:49.349 --> 01:49:53.186
IN THESE GOALS. 18 21 42 AT A
01:49:53.253 --> 01:49:54.654
LINE TURF REBATE PROGRAMS WITH
01:49:54.721 --> 01:49:56.122
OTHER PERMANENTLY EXEMPTED WATER
01:49:56.189 --> 01:49:57.624
EFFICIENCY. REBATES FOR TOILETS
01:49:57.691 --> 01:49:59.225
AND WASHING MACHINES.
01:49:59.292 --> 01:50:00.660
REPLACEMENT PROGRAMS LIKE THESE
01:50:00.727 --> 01:50:02.429
OTHER REBATES, PLAY AN IMPORTANT
01:50:02.495 --> 01:50:03.530
ROLE AND CONTINUED WATER
01:50:03.596 --> 01:50:04.497
EFFICIENCY AND CONSERVATION
01:50:04.564 --> 01:50:06.933
EFFORTS. EVEN WITH INCENTIVES,
01:50:07.000 --> 01:50:08.735
MOST HOUSEHOLDS WILL NEED TO
01:50:08.802 --> 01:50:09.936
INVEST THEIR OWN INCOME TO
01:50:10.003 --> 01:50:10.971
REPLACE LAWNS WITH DROUGHT
01:50:11.037 --> 01:50:12.672
TOLERANT LANDSCAPING. TAXING
01:50:12.739 --> 01:50:13.506
THESE REBATES IS ESPECIALLY
01:50:13.573 --> 01:50:15.075
SIGNIFICANT ARRIER FOR LOW
01:50:15.141 --> 01:50:17.110
INCOME HOUSEHOLDS. FOR EXAMPLE,
01:50:17.177 --> 01:50:18.445
ONE OF OUR MEMBER AGENCIES HAD A
01:50:18.511 --> 01:50:19.479
PROGRAM THAT WAS DESIGNED
01:50:19.546 --> 01:50:20.714
SPECIFICALLY FOR LOW INCOME
01:50:20.780 --> 01:50:22.215
HOUSEHOLDS, AND MANY WITHDREW
01:50:22.282 --> 01:50:23.984
FROM THE PROGRAM WHEN THEY
01:50:24.050 --> 01:50:25.018
REALIZED THAT THESE REBATES
01:50:25.085 --> 01:50:26.019
WOULD BE CONSIDERED TAXABLE
01:50:26.086 --> 01:50:27.554
INCOME. FOR THESE REASONS. AQUA
01:50:27.620 --> 01:50:29.723
SUPPORTS 21 42. WE ENCOURAGE THE
01:50:29.789 --> 01:50:30.790
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE
01:50:30.857 --> 01:50:32.492
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY. THANK
01:50:32.559 --> 01:50:35.228
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. I ALSO
01:50:35.295 --> 01:50:36.896
HAVE LISTED CATHERINE VIA TELE
01:50:36.963 --> 01:50:38.298
WHO'S ALSO HERE. IMPORTANT IN
01:50:38.365 --> 01:50:42.068
PERSON. WELCOME. THANK YOU,
01:50:42.135 --> 01:50:43.703
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
01:50:43.770 --> 01:50:45.438
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS KATHY VIA
01:50:45.505 --> 01:50:46.406
TELE AND I'M WITH METROPOLITAN
01:50:46.473 --> 01:50:47.340
WATER DISTRICT OF SOUTHERN
01:50:47.407 --> 01:50:48.975
CALIFORNIA AND WE ARE PLEASED TO
01:50:49.042 --> 01:50:51.144
SUPPORT A B 21 42. WE WISH TO
01:50:51.211 --> 01:50:52.579
THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GABRIEL
01:50:52.645 --> 01:50:54.781
FOR AUTHORING 21 42, WHICH WOULD
01:50:54.848 --> 01:50:55.849
REINSTATE THE TAX EXEMPTION FOR
01:50:55.915 --> 01:50:58.785
TURF. REPLACEMENT REBATES. THIS
01:50:58.852 --> 01:51:00.820
BILL IS TIMELY AND IT'S VERY
01:51:00.887 --> 01:51:02.589
IMPORTANT BECAUSE OF THE DROUGHT
01:51:02.655 --> 01:51:03.223
. YOU'VE HEARD THE STATISTICS,
01:51:03.289 --> 01:51:04.591
WE HAVE WITNESSED THE DRIEST
01:51:04.657 --> 01:51:05.992
THREE YEARS ON RECORD AND THE
01:51:06.059 --> 01:51:07.160
THREE DRIVERS CONSECUTIVE
01:51:07.227 --> 01:51:08.061
MONTHS, JANUARY, FEBRUARY AND
01:51:08.128 --> 01:51:10.430
MARCH. AND THE STATE WATER
01:51:10.497 --> 01:51:11.464
PROJECT TO DELIVERIES, WHICH
01:51:11.531 --> 01:51:12.332
MAKE UP 30% OF SOUTHERN
01:51:12.399 --> 01:51:13.400
CALIFORNIA'S WATER SUPPLY HAS
01:51:13.466 --> 01:51:15.635
BEEN DRASTICALLY CUT. AND
01:51:15.702 --> 01:51:17.203
YESTERDAY AT A HEARING ON THE
01:51:17.270 --> 01:51:18.805
COLORADO RIVER, WHICH IS ANOTHER
01:51:18.872 --> 01:51:20.140
IMPORTANT SOURCE OF WATER FOR
01:51:20.206 --> 01:51:22.108
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, THE BUREAU
01:51:22.175 --> 01:51:24.177
OF RECLAMATION TOLD CONGRESS
01:51:24.244 --> 01:51:25.712
THAT LARGE CUTS TO WATER
01:51:25.779 --> 01:51:26.679
DELIVERIES ARE NEEDED TO PROTECT
01:51:26.746 --> 01:51:28.548
CRITICAL LEVELS AT LAKE POWELL
01:51:28.615 --> 01:51:30.316
AND LAKE MEAD. UP TO 2 TO 4
01:51:30.383 --> 01:51:33.386
MILLION ACRE FEET. FROM THE
01:51:33.453 --> 01:51:34.954
SEVEN BASIN STATES AND TO PUT
01:51:35.021 --> 01:51:36.956
THAT INTO CONTEXT, CALIFORNIA'S
01:51:37.023 --> 01:51:39.325
ALLOTMENT IS 4.4 MILLION ACRE
01:51:39.392 --> 01:51:40.927
FEET, AND THE COLORADO RIVER
01:51:40.994 --> 01:51:42.896
MAKES UP ABOUT 25% OF SOUTHERN
01:51:42.962 --> 01:51:44.164
CALIFORNIA'S WATER SUPPLY, SO
01:51:44.230 --> 01:51:46.666
THE SITUATION IS VERY SERIOUS.
01:51:46.733 --> 01:51:48.268
WE MUST SAVE WATER NOW AND THE
01:51:48.334 --> 01:51:49.536
BEST PLACE TO DO THAT IS
01:51:49.602 --> 01:51:50.904
OUTDOORS. OUR TURF REBATES,
01:51:50.970 --> 01:51:52.305
ENCOURAGE HOUSEHOLDS TO REMOVE
01:51:52.372 --> 01:51:53.907
THEIR LAWNS AND CONVERT THEM TO
01:51:53.973 --> 01:51:55.308
BEAUTIFUL WATER SAVING
01:51:55.375 --> 01:51:56.910
LANDSCAPES AND RESIDENTS AND
01:51:56.976 --> 01:51:58.078
BUSINESSES THAT PARTICIPATE IN
01:51:58.144 --> 01:51:59.145
OUR CONSERVATION PROGRAMS
01:51:59.212 --> 01:52:01.548
SHOULDN'T BE TAXED. AND TURF
01:52:01.614 --> 01:52:02.582
REBATES. THEY, LIKE OTHER
01:52:02.649 --> 01:52:03.983
CONSERVATION REBATES, PROVIDED
01:52:04.050 --> 01:52:06.086
PUBLIC BENEFIT CONSERVATION
01:52:06.152 --> 01:52:07.587
IMPROVES OUR WATER SUPPLY
01:52:07.654 --> 01:52:08.755
RELIABILITY, AND IT HELPS
01:52:08.822 --> 01:52:10.190
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA REDUCE ITS
01:52:10.256 --> 01:52:12.058
RELIANCE ON IMPORTED WATER.
01:52:12.125 --> 01:52:14.260
REINSTATING THE TAX EXCLUSION
01:52:14.327 --> 01:52:15.462
FOR TARIFF REBATES WILL ENSURE
01:52:15.528 --> 01:52:17.564
CONSISTENCY AND HOW WE MANAGE.
01:52:17.630 --> 01:52:19.766
CONSERVATION PROGRAMS AND AVOID
01:52:19.833 --> 01:52:21.134
CONFUSION AMONG THE PUBLIC. Y
01:52:21.201 --> 01:52:22.168
SOME REBATES ARE TAXED AND
01:52:22.235 --> 01:52:24.237
OTHERS NOT FOR THESE REASONS.
01:52:24.304 --> 01:52:25.371
METROPOLITAN SUPPORTS A B 21 42.
01:52:25.438 --> 01:52:27.207
WE RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED THANK
01:52:27.273 --> 01:52:30.877
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
01:52:30.944 --> 01:52:32.745
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2200
01:52:32.812 --> 01:52:33.880
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
01:52:33.947 --> 01:52:37.584
SUPPORT. MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OR
01:52:37.650 --> 01:52:38.918
AUSTRALIA, CORTEZ CAPELLA ON
01:52:38.985 --> 01:52:40.320
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
01:52:40.386 --> 01:52:41.321
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION, ALSO IN
01:52:41.387 --> 01:52:45.058
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR
01:52:45.125 --> 01:52:46.693
MEMBERS, BETH ALLISON ON BEHALF
01:52:46.759 --> 01:52:47.527
OF THE INLAND EMPIRE UTILITIES
01:52:47.594 --> 01:52:48.661
AGENCY IN CUCAMONGA VALLEY WATER
01:52:48.728 --> 01:52:52.398
DISTRICT AND SUPPORT QUÊ GOOD
01:52:52.465 --> 01:52:54.601
MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:52:54.667 --> 01:52:55.401
MARIA RICH DOONEY ON BEHALF OF
01:52:55.468 --> 01:52:56.636
THE SANTA CLARA VALLEY WATER
01:52:56.703 --> 01:52:58.404
DISTRICT IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:52:58.471 --> 01:53:00.373
THANK YOU. HI ALYSSA, STILL HIGH
01:53:00.440 --> 01:53:02.242
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA
01:53:02.308 --> 01:53:04.711
ROSA, ALSO IN SUPPORT. YOU VERY
01:53:04.777 --> 01:53:08.081
MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE?
01:53:08.148 --> 01:53:09.782
SEEING THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
01:53:09.849 --> 01:53:10.917
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
01:53:10.984 --> 01:53:11.951
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
01:53:12.018 --> 01:53:13.853
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
01:53:13.920 --> 01:53:17.957
AND SUPPORT? TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
01:53:18.024 --> 01:53:19.392
OF THE BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE
01:53:19.459 --> 01:53:22.395
AND ZERO ON YOUR PHONE AND FIRST
01:53:22.462 --> 01:53:24.430
WE WILL START WITH 9 49, PLEASE
01:53:24.497 --> 01:53:28.134
GO AHEAD. JULIE NO, NO SKIP ALL
01:53:28.201 --> 01:53:28.735
ON BEHALF OF THE INTERCOSTAL
01:53:28.801 --> 01:53:32.705
WATER DISTRICT IN SUPPORT. ZAIN
01:53:32.772 --> 01:53:37.377
26, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU,
01:53:37.443 --> 01:53:39.345
DAVID JONES AND HAVE TO SEE IT
01:53:39.412 --> 01:53:41.614
FOR BANKING, STRONG SUPPORT. 91
01:53:41.681 --> 01:53:46.085
53, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:53:46.152 --> 01:53:48.188
MORNING, JAMIE MINOR ON BEHALF
01:53:48.254 --> 01:53:49.255
OF EASTERN MUNICIPAL WATER
01:53:49.322 --> 01:53:50.590
DISTRICT, IN ADDITION TO WEST
01:53:50.657 --> 01:53:51.791
BASIN MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT,
01:53:51.858 --> 01:53:55.128
THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU. 91
01:53:55.195 --> 01:54:00.166
54, PLEASE GO AHEAD. DANIEL
01:54:00.233 --> 01:54:01.834
PLASTERED HAYDN WITH CALIFORNIA
01:54:01.901 --> 01:54:02.468
MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSOCIATION
01:54:02.535 --> 01:54:05.738
AND SUPPORT 91 56, PLEASE GO
01:54:05.805 --> 01:54:10.343
AHEAD. MADAM CHAIR AND SENATORS
01:54:10.410 --> 01:54:12.078
ANTHONY MOLINA ON BEHALF OF MESA
01:54:12.145 --> 01:54:13.846
WATER DISTRICT AND THE SANTA
01:54:13.913 --> 01:54:14.914
CLARITA VALLEY WATER DISTRICT
01:54:14.981 --> 01:54:16.916
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. 91 41,
01:54:16.983 --> 01:54:22.555
PLEASE GO AHEAD. URGENT MCGOWAN
01:54:22.622 --> 01:54:23.790
ON BEHALF OF RANCHO CALIFORNIA
01:54:23.856 --> 01:54:24.757
WATER DISTRICT AND SUPPORT.
01:54:24.824 --> 01:54:26.793
THANK YOU. 9 18, PLEASE GO
01:54:26.859 --> 01:54:31.431
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
01:54:31.497 --> 01:54:32.899
CHAIR. REMEMBER LINDA BOW WITH
01:54:32.966 --> 01:54:34.534
THE CALIFORNIA WATER EFFICIENCY
01:54:34.601 --> 01:54:35.735
PARTNERSHIP WHERE A PROUD
01:54:35.802 --> 01:54:38.972
SPONSOR OF 80 21 42 URGE YOUR
01:54:39.038 --> 01:54:40.073
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL. THANK
01:54:40.139 --> 01:54:46.779
YOU. AND THAT IS ALL THAT I HAVE
01:54:46.846 --> 01:54:50.049
IN QUÊ. VERY GOOD. WE'RE GONNA
01:54:50.116 --> 01:54:52.752
MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION. WE HAVE
01:54:52.819 --> 01:54:55.622
NO LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESSES SO
01:54:55.688 --> 01:54:58.024
WE WILL CHECK TO SEE IF THERE'S
01:54:58.091 --> 01:54:59.092
ANYBODY WHO WOULD LIKE TO
01:54:59.158 --> 01:55:00.159
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION IN ROOM
01:55:00.226 --> 01:55:03.162
2200. SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON
01:55:03.229 --> 01:55:04.364
TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. IF
01:55:04.430 --> 01:55:09.702
YOU COULD QUEUE UP OPPOSITION.
01:55:09.769 --> 01:55:11.437
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF THE
01:55:11.504 --> 01:55:19.846
BILL, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO. PLEASE PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO ON
01:55:19.912 --> 01:55:25.318
YOUR PHONE. I HAVE NO ONE N
01:55:25.385 --> 01:55:29.355
KILL. VERY BUT VERY GOOD. WE'LL
01:55:29.422 --> 01:55:31.658
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:55:31.724 --> 01:55:32.292
FOR COMMENTS, QUESTIONS,
01:55:32.358 --> 01:55:35.261
CONCERNS OR EMOTION. SENATOR
01:55:35.328 --> 01:55:36.929
DURAZO MOVES THE BELL. WOULD YOU
01:55:36.996 --> 01:55:41.567
LIKE TO CONCLUDE? YEAH I JUST
01:55:41.634 --> 01:55:43.102
WANT TO THANK ALL THE SUPPORTERS
01:55:43.169 --> 01:55:44.837
. I THINK, AS WE ALL UNDERSTAND
01:55:44.904 --> 01:55:46.105
THAT DEALING WITH THESE ISSUES
01:55:46.172 --> 01:55:47.273
IS GOING TO BE A SIGNIFICANT
01:55:47.340 --> 01:55:49.008
POLICY CONCERN FOR THE STATE IN
01:55:49.075 --> 01:55:50.243
THE COMING YEARS. AND I THINK
01:55:50.310 --> 01:55:52.111
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT PART OF THE
01:55:52.178 --> 01:55:52.645
SOLUTION. WE RESPECTFULLY
01:55:52.712 --> 01:55:54.380
REQUEST AND I VOTE. THANK YOU
01:55:54.447 --> 01:55:56.716
VERY MUCH. UM THERE IS A MOTION.
01:55:56.783 --> 01:55:58.017
THE MOTION IS DO PASS AND RE
01:55:58.084 --> 01:55:59.786
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:55:59.852 --> 01:56:00.787
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
01:56:00.853 --> 01:56:03.990
OLL. SENATORS CABALLERO HIGH,
01:56:04.057 --> 01:56:07.427
CABALLERO, I. NILSSON NILSSON. I
01:56:07.493 --> 01:56:12.732
DURAZO SO I'M HERTZBERG. WIENER.
01:56:12.799 --> 01:56:14.200
THE BILL HAS THREE VOTES WERE
01:56:14.267 --> 01:56:15.568
GOING TO WAIT AND KEEP THE
01:56:15.635 --> 01:56:17.236
PAROLE OPEN FOR THE MISSING
01:56:17.303 --> 01:56:18.604
MEMBERS AND MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM
01:56:18.671 --> 01:56:22.075
NUMBER 12 WHICH IS A B 20 TO 34.
01:56:22.141 --> 01:56:23.943
I SAW ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RIVAS
01:56:24.010 --> 01:56:30.283
WELCOME. MADAM CHAIR. THE FLOOR
01:56:30.350 --> 01:56:32.118
IS YOURS. ALWAYS GREAT TO SEE
01:56:32.185 --> 01:56:34.887
YOU AND WHAT AND SO I'D LIKE TO
01:56:34.954 --> 01:56:36.456
FIRST START BY THANKING THE
01:56:36.522 --> 01:56:37.523
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR WORK
01:56:37.590 --> 01:56:39.459
ON THIS BILL AND NOTE THAT I'LL
01:56:39.525 --> 01:56:40.760
BE ACCEPTING THE COMMUNITY
01:56:40.827 --> 01:56:41.961
AMENDMENTS AND THIS LEGISLATION.
01:56:42.028 --> 01:56:42.562
ASSEMBLY BILL 22346 TO CREATE
01:56:42.628 --> 01:56:46.332
STANDARDS FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
01:56:46.399 --> 01:56:47.800
TO APPROVE POST ENTITLED POST
01:56:47.867 --> 01:56:48.868
ENTITLEMENT RESIDENTIAL BUILDING
01:56:48.935 --> 01:56:50.903
PERMITS AND TO BE CLEAR THIS
01:56:50.970 --> 01:56:52.872
LEGISLATION ONLY AFFECTS THESE
01:56:52.939 --> 01:56:55.341
PERMITS THAT ARE ISSUED AFTER A
01:56:55.408 --> 01:56:56.342
PROJECT HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THE
01:56:56.409 --> 01:56:57.477
LOCAL GOVERNMENT AGENCY AND
01:56:57.543 --> 01:56:59.812
AFTER ANY TYPE OF SEQUEL REVIEW.
01:56:59.879 --> 01:57:00.880
CURRENTLY THERE'S NO
01:57:00.947 --> 01:57:01.981
STANDARDIZED PROCESS FOR THE
01:57:02.048 --> 01:57:02.915
APPROVAL OF HOME BUILDING
01:57:02.982 --> 01:57:05.685
PERMITS, AND AS A RESULT, THE
01:57:05.752 --> 01:57:06.819
ABILITY FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
01:57:06.886 --> 01:57:07.553
RECEIVE APPROVAL EXECUTE HOME
01:57:07.620 --> 01:57:09.389
BUILDING PERMITS IN A TIMELY
01:57:09.455 --> 01:57:11.958
MATTER. THEY VARY FROM
01:57:12.024 --> 01:57:13.259
JURISDICTION TO JURISDICTION AND
01:57:13.326 --> 01:57:15.995
SOME LOCAL JURISDICTIONS, UM OR
01:57:16.062 --> 01:57:18.131
IN IN SOME LOCAL JURISDICTIONS.
01:57:18.197 --> 01:57:20.099
MANY PROJECTS SPEND MONTHS OR
01:57:20.166 --> 01:57:21.234
EVEN YEARS, WAITING FOR THE
01:57:21.300 --> 01:57:22.235
APPROVAL AND EXECUTION OF
01:57:22.301 --> 01:57:24.103
BUILDING PERMITS. AND THIS IS
01:57:24.170 --> 01:57:26.239
AGAIN AFTER THE PROJECT ITSELF
01:57:26.305 --> 01:57:28.174
HAS BEEN REVIEWED AND APPROVED.
01:57:28.241 --> 01:57:29.642
THESE ADMINISTRATIVE PERMITTING
01:57:29.709 --> 01:57:30.910
THESE DELAYS INCREASED PROJECT
01:57:30.977 --> 01:57:31.978
COSTS THEY AFFECT HOUSING
01:57:32.044 --> 01:57:35.348
AFFORDABILITY. THEY SLOW OVERALL
01:57:35.415 --> 01:57:36.949
CRITICAL HOUSING PRODUCTION, AND
01:57:37.016 --> 01:57:39.385
THIS IS AMONG YOU KNOW OUR
01:57:39.452 --> 01:57:41.721
STATE'S WORSENING HOUSING CRISIS
01:57:41.788 --> 01:57:44.223
, SO THIS LEGISLATION WILL GO A
01:57:44.290 --> 01:57:44.657
LONG WAY TO IMPROVE
01:57:44.724 --> 01:57:45.591
TRANSPARENCY, PREDICTABILITY.
01:57:45.658 --> 01:57:46.993
CREATE EFFICIENCIES,
01:57:47.059 --> 01:57:48.227
EFFICIENCIES FOR BOTH HOME
01:57:48.294 --> 01:57:50.096
BUILDERS AND LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
01:57:50.163 --> 01:57:51.431
WHEN PROCESSING THESE POST
01:57:51.497 --> 01:57:52.799
ENTITLEMENT BUILDING PERMITS,
01:57:52.865 --> 01:57:55.401
AND IT DOES SO IN IN IN IN
01:57:55.468 --> 01:57:56.402
SEVERAL KEY WAYS. FIRST
01:57:56.469 --> 01:57:58.337
INFORMATION POSTING BY REQUIRING
01:57:58.404 --> 01:57:59.806
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO PUBLISH
01:57:59.872 --> 01:58:01.808
AN ONLINE CHECKLISTS THAT
01:58:01.874 --> 01:58:02.842
DETAILS THE INFORMATION REQUIRED
01:58:02.909 --> 01:58:05.845
FROM ANY APPLICANT SECOND
01:58:05.912 --> 01:58:06.446
ESTABLISHES A TIMEFRAME UNDER
01:58:06.512 --> 01:58:07.580
WHICH LOCAL JURISDICTIONS MUST
01:58:07.647 --> 01:58:08.648
DETERMINE WHETHER AN APPLICATION
01:58:08.714 --> 01:58:13.085
IS COMPLETE. AND FINALLY
01:58:13.152 --> 01:58:15.121
ESTABLISHING A SUBSTANTIVE
01:58:15.188 --> 01:58:16.989
REVIEW TIMEFRAME THAT REQUIRES
01:58:17.056 --> 01:58:18.291
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO REVIEW
01:58:18.357 --> 01:58:21.260
BUILDING PERMITS WITHIN 30 TO 60
01:58:21.327 --> 01:58:22.395
BUSINESS DAYS, DEPENDING ON THE
01:58:22.462 --> 01:58:24.330
SIZE OF THE PROJECT, YOU KNOW
01:58:24.397 --> 01:58:25.231
AGAIN ALTOGETHER, THESE
01:58:25.298 --> 01:58:26.199
PROVISIONS WILL GO A LONG WAY.
01:58:26.265 --> 01:58:28.100
TO REDUCING THESE DELAYS IN THE
01:58:28.167 --> 01:58:29.702
BUILDING PERMIT PROCESS. UM WITH
01:58:29.769 --> 01:58:31.804
ME HERE TO TESTIFY AS COY SMITH,
01:58:31.871 --> 01:58:33.840
WHO IS THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF
01:58:33.906 --> 01:58:34.841
THE HOUSING ACTION COALITION.
01:58:34.907 --> 01:58:36.676
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. VERY
01:58:36.742 --> 01:58:39.011
GOOD. WELCOME THANK YOU VERY
01:58:39.078 --> 01:58:40.146
MUCH CHAIR AND MEMBERS COREY
01:58:40.213 --> 01:58:41.347
SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING
01:58:41.414 --> 01:58:42.748
ACTION COALITION, REMEMBER
01:58:42.815 --> 01:58:43.816
SUPPORTED NONPROFIT THAT
01:58:43.883 --> 01:58:45.251
ADVOCATES FOR HOMES AT ALL
01:58:45.318 --> 01:58:46.953
INCOME LEVELS AND WE'RE PROUD CO
01:58:47.019 --> 01:58:49.222
SPONSORS OF ASSEMBLY BILL 2234.
01:58:49.288 --> 01:58:50.456
THE LAST FEW YEARS, THE
01:58:50.523 --> 01:58:51.858
LEGISLATURE HAS PASSED A NUMBER
01:58:51.924 --> 01:58:52.992
OF BILLS RELATED TO THE
01:58:53.059 --> 01:58:54.494
ENTITLEMENT PROCESS, WITH THE
01:58:54.560 --> 01:58:56.395
HOPES THAT IT WOULD INCREASE
01:58:56.462 --> 01:58:56.896
HOUSING PRODUCTION AND
01:58:56.963 --> 01:58:58.264
AFFORDABILITY ACROSS THE ENTIRE
01:58:58.331 --> 01:59:00.366
STATE. HOWEVER OUR MEMBERS AND
01:59:00.433 --> 01:59:01.367
MANY OTHER HOMEBUILDERS ACROSS
01:59:01.434 --> 01:59:02.668
THE STATE HAVE ALSO IDENTIFIED
01:59:02.735 --> 01:59:03.703
AN OPPORTUNITY TO IMPROVE THE
01:59:03.769 --> 01:59:06.472
POST ENTITLEMENT. BUILDING
01:59:06.539 --> 01:59:08.474
PERMIT ACQUISITION PROCESS.
01:59:08.541 --> 01:59:10.209
MAYBE 2 TO 34 WILL CREATE A
01:59:10.276 --> 01:59:11.544
FRAMEWORK FOR DEVELOPERS AND
01:59:11.611 --> 01:59:14.013
LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO PROCESS
01:59:14.080 --> 01:59:14.580
RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS
01:59:14.647 --> 01:59:15.214
MORE EFFICIENTLY AND COST
01:59:15.281 --> 01:59:18.284
EFFECTIVELY. IN REALITY, THERE'S
01:59:18.351 --> 01:59:20.286
A NUMBER OF REASONS PERMITS DO
01:59:20.353 --> 01:59:21.120
NOT GET REVIEWED ANY TIMELY
01:59:21.187 --> 01:59:22.722
MANNER. FOR EXAMPLE, MANY
01:59:22.788 --> 01:59:24.257
PROJECT APPLICATIONS DO NOT
01:59:24.323 --> 01:59:25.391
PROVIDE THE SUFFICIENT
01:59:25.458 --> 01:59:26.492
INFORMATION THAT A CITY NEEDS IN
01:59:26.559 --> 01:59:30.096
ORDER TO REVIEW. REQUIRING A
01:59:30.162 --> 01:59:31.931
SIMPLE CHECKLIST PROJECTS WILL
01:59:31.998 --> 01:59:33.966
KNOW WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE IN
01:59:34.033 --> 01:59:35.101
ORDER TO HAVE THAT REVIEW.
01:59:35.167 --> 01:59:36.669
SOMETIMES IT IS A STAFFING
01:59:36.736 --> 01:59:38.337
CAPACITY ISSUE AND BY REQUIRING
01:59:38.404 --> 01:59:39.772
MODEL PERMITS. HIGHER QUALITY
01:59:39.839 --> 01:59:41.240
APPLICATIONS WILL GET SUBMITTED
01:59:41.307 --> 01:59:42.608
BECAUSE THE PROJECT TEAM
01:59:42.675 --> 01:59:44.010
UNDERSTANDS HOW A CITY WANTS TO
01:59:44.076 --> 01:59:45.778
RECEIVE THAT INFORMATION. AND
01:59:45.845 --> 01:59:46.913
THIS WILL REDUCE THE NEEDED
01:59:46.979 --> 01:59:49.115
STAFF TIME TO DO THE REVIEW.
01:59:49.181 --> 01:59:51.217
SOMETIMES AND THIS IS VERY RARE
01:59:51.284 --> 01:59:52.451
. IT IS A CITY ACTUALLY ACTING
01:59:52.518 --> 01:59:54.253
IN BAD FAITH, TRYING TO SLOW
01:59:54.320 --> 01:59:55.321
DOWN THE PRODUCTION OF NEW
01:59:55.388 --> 01:59:56.222
HOUSING. REGARDLESS OF THE
01:59:56.289 --> 01:59:57.623
REASON THE PERMITTING PROCESS
01:59:57.690 --> 01:59:59.792
CAN UNNECESSARILY TAKE UP TO
01:59:59.859 --> 02:00:00.593
THREE YEARS IN CERTAIN
02:00:00.660 --> 02:00:02.628
SITUATIONS, AND IT COULD BE
02:00:02.695 --> 02:00:03.763
MONTHS BEFORE THE APPLICATION IS
02:00:03.829 --> 02:00:04.830
EVEN ACKNOWLEDGED BY A LOCAL
02:00:04.897 --> 02:00:06.966
JURISDICTION. BY REQUIRING
02:00:07.033 --> 02:00:09.302
REASONABLE TIMELINES FOR REVIEW
02:00:09.368 --> 02:00:10.736
PROJECTS ARE NOT GOING TO WAIT
02:00:10.803 --> 02:00:12.138
ENDLESSLY TO GET THEIR PERMITS.
02:00:12.204 --> 02:00:13.606
THIS BILL IS GOINGTO BE
02:00:13.673 --> 02:00:14.740
PARTICULARLY IMPACTFUL FOR 100%
02:00:14.807 --> 02:00:16.742
SUBSIDIZED, AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
02:00:16.809 --> 02:00:18.144
AS MANY OF YOU KNOW, FINANCING
02:00:18.210 --> 02:00:19.912
100% AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS
02:00:19.979 --> 02:00:21.914
INCREDIBLY DIFFICULT AND DUE TO
02:00:21.981 --> 02:00:24.050
THE COMPLEX TAX CREDIT SYSTEM,
02:00:24.116 --> 02:00:26.018
MANY PROJECTS FACE VERY TIGHT
02:00:26.085 --> 02:00:28.120
TIME FRAMES IN ORDER TO THE
02:00:28.187 --> 02:00:29.388
ACQUIRE THE PERMITS TO ACTUALLY
02:00:29.455 --> 02:00:32.091
SECURE THEIR FUNDING. WE BELIEVE
02:00:32.158 --> 02:00:33.893
THIS IS A COMMON SENSE APPROACH
02:00:33.960 --> 02:00:35.094
TO CREATING A BETTER PROCESS FOR
02:00:35.161 --> 02:00:36.996
PROJECT TEAMS, CITIES IN
02:00:37.063 --> 02:00:38.965
COMMUNITIES AS WE HOPEFULLY SEE
02:00:39.031 --> 02:00:39.565
MORE HOUSING BUILT ACROSS THE
02:00:39.632 --> 02:00:40.499
STATE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:00:40.566 --> 02:00:46.739
THANK YOU. I HAVE HERE LISTED
02:00:46.806 --> 02:00:47.640
BACKUP WITNESS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:00:47.707 --> 02:00:51.510
REVIS, UM. SHOULD I CALL ON
02:00:51.577 --> 02:00:55.815
JONAH? OKAY. VERY GOOD. SO I'M
02:00:55.881 --> 02:00:59.852
GONNA UH, ASK IF THERE'S ANYBODY
02:00:59.919 --> 02:01:01.754
HERE IN THE ROOM THAT WOULD LIKE
02:01:01.821 --> 02:01:02.922
TO TEST FRANCE SUPPORT. PLEASE
02:01:02.989 --> 02:01:05.157
COME FORWARD. GOOD MORNING,
02:01:05.224 --> 02:01:06.726
MADAM CHAIR LOUIS BRONTE WITH
02:01:06.792 --> 02:01:08.861
CALIFORNIA AND BE HERE IN STRONG
02:01:08.928 --> 02:01:10.062
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:01:10.129 --> 02:01:11.297
ALEX TORRES WITH THE BAY AREA
02:01:11.364 --> 02:01:14.800
COUNCIL IN SPORT. THANK YOU. THE
02:01:14.867 --> 02:01:15.801
LAWRENCE, A VALENCIA,
02:01:15.868 --> 02:01:16.335
REPRESENTING THE AMERICAN
02:01:16.402 --> 02:01:18.638
PLANNING ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT
02:01:18.704 --> 02:01:20.706
THANK YOU FOR MANY DAYS IS
02:01:20.773 --> 02:01:21.841
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS WITH
02:01:21.907 --> 02:01:22.775
HABITAT FOR HUMANITY CALIFORNIA
02:01:22.842 --> 02:01:26.212
AND SUPPORT. YOU VERY MUCH.
02:01:26.278 --> 02:01:27.980
JENNIFER MENTAL WITH THE
02:01:28.047 --> 02:01:28.581
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM
02:01:28.648 --> 02:01:33.219
AND STRONG SUPPORT. VERY GOOD.
02:01:33.285 --> 02:01:34.387
WE'RE GOING TO GO ONTO THE
02:01:34.453 --> 02:01:36.856
TELECONFERENCE LINE. CAN YOU
02:01:36.922 --> 02:01:38.457
PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WOULD
02:01:38.524 --> 02:01:40.326
LIKE TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF A
02:01:40.393 --> 02:01:46.699
B 20 TO 34. TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:01:46.766 --> 02:01:47.833
, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
02:01:47.900 --> 02:01:51.003
YOUR PHONE. AND FIRST WE HAVE
02:01:51.070 --> 02:01:53.139
LINED 1 57, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:01:53.205 --> 02:01:54.273
MICHAEL LANE WHISPER AND STRONG
02:01:54.340 --> 02:01:58.277
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. IF YOU'RE
02:01:58.344 --> 02:02:02.615
BLIND 42, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS
02:02:02.682 --> 02:02:04.417
IS BOB NEYLAND FOR FIELDS THAT
02:02:04.483 --> 02:02:09.021
IN COMPANY. UM PHILANTHROPIST
02:02:09.088 --> 02:02:10.890
HOWARD AHMANSON JR IN STRONG
02:02:10.956 --> 02:02:14.026
SUPPORT. FIND THE 87. PLEASE GO
02:02:14.093 --> 02:02:20.866
AHEAD. MAKES LATER ON BEHALF OF
02:02:20.933 --> 02:02:24.837
META AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU. 91
02:02:24.904 --> 02:02:29.875
51, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
02:02:29.942 --> 02:02:30.976
MEGAN TOKUNAGA WITH THE
02:02:31.043 --> 02:02:31.911
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIPS
02:02:31.977 --> 02:02:39.985
AND SUPPORT 57, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:02:40.052 --> 02:02:41.220
HEY, THIS IS COLLECTING
02:02:41.287 --> 02:02:43.656
COSPONSOR OF THE BILL FROM
02:02:43.723 --> 02:02:44.657
SILICON VALLEY LEADERSHIP GROUP
02:02:44.724 --> 02:02:49.662
IN SUPPORT. AND THAT IS ALL THAT
02:02:49.729 --> 02:02:51.964
I HAVE IN. Q VERY GOOD. WE'RE
02:02:52.031 --> 02:02:53.866
GONNA MOVE ON NOW TO OPPOSITION
02:02:53.933 --> 02:02:55.401
WITNESSES. WE HAVE NO LEAD.
02:02:55.468 --> 02:02:56.736
OPPOSITION WITNESSES NOTED
02:02:56.802 --> 02:02:58.838
SOMEONE TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
02:02:58.904 --> 02:03:01.841
IN ROOM 2200. WELCOME. GOOD
02:03:01.907 --> 02:03:03.242
MORNING. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
02:03:03.309 --> 02:03:04.510
MEMBERS BRADY GARDEN ON BEHALF
02:03:04.577 --> 02:03:05.444
OF THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
02:03:05.511 --> 02:03:07.413
OFFICIALS. FIRST OF ALL I WANTED
02:03:07.480 --> 02:03:08.881
TO THANK THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND
02:03:08.948 --> 02:03:10.750
THE SPONSORS OF THE BILL. WE'VE
02:03:10.816 --> 02:03:11.350
HAD ACTIVE CONVERSATIONS. WE
02:03:11.417 --> 02:03:12.985
STILL HAVE A RESPECTFUL OPPOSED
02:03:13.052 --> 02:03:14.053
POSITION OF PUZZLE IS AMENDED.
02:03:14.120 --> 02:03:16.355
EXCUSE ME. IN OUR LETTER, WE
02:03:16.422 --> 02:03:17.890
LAID OUT SOME MORE TIERED SYSTEM
02:03:17.957 --> 02:03:19.358
. WE HAVE SOME CONCERNS WITH
02:03:19.425 --> 02:03:20.860
THOSE TIME WORKS BEING A LITTLE
02:03:20.926 --> 02:03:22.695
SMALL AND THEN ALSO THE DISTANCE
02:03:22.762 --> 02:03:24.196
THE NUMBER OF UNITS. THERE'S
02:03:24.263 --> 02:03:25.397
SOME CONCERNS THERE BECAUSE
02:03:25.464 --> 02:03:26.899
THESE LONGER HIGH RISE BUILDINGS
02:03:26.966 --> 02:03:28.400
WITH 100 UNITS OR MORE WILL TAKE
02:03:28.467 --> 02:03:29.635
A LOT LONGER, SO WE'VE GOT SOME
02:03:29.702 --> 02:03:31.403
CONCERNS THERE AS WELL. WE'RE
02:03:31.470 --> 02:03:32.304
HOPEFUL THAT THE PROPOSED
02:03:32.371 --> 02:03:33.272
AMENDMENTS WE BROUGHT FORWARD
02:03:33.339 --> 02:03:34.607
WILL BE ACCEPTED AS WELL AS
02:03:34.673 --> 02:03:36.075
SPECIFYING SOME OF THE SPECIFICS
02:03:36.142 --> 02:03:38.177
ON WHEN THESE PERMIT TIME CLOCKS
02:03:38.244 --> 02:03:39.311
WILL WILL BE FROZEN. AS WELL.
02:03:39.378 --> 02:03:41.280
SOME OTHER THINGS, YOU KNOW, WE
02:03:41.347 --> 02:03:42.414
JUST WANT TO MAKE IT MORE
02:03:42.481 --> 02:03:44.650
FEASIBLE FOR DEPARTMENTS AND
02:03:44.717 --> 02:03:45.217
MAKE SURE IT'S COMPATIBLE
02:03:45.284 --> 02:03:45.818
BECAUSE WE UNDERSTAND THAT
02:03:45.885 --> 02:03:47.086
THERE'S A HOUSING CRISIS AND
02:03:47.153 --> 02:03:48.387
PART OF THAT IS NOT BEING ABLE
02:03:48.454 --> 02:03:50.456
TO GET THROUGH IT. YOU KNOW, OUR
02:03:50.523 --> 02:03:51.190
BUILDING OFFICIALS ARE
02:03:51.257 --> 02:03:51.791
DEFINITELY UNDER UNDERSTAFFED
02:03:51.857 --> 02:03:52.825
AND UNDERFUNDED, BUT WE'RE
02:03:52.892 --> 02:03:54.260
HOPEFUL THAT WE CAN GET SOME
02:03:54.326 --> 02:03:55.561
FEASIBLE WORK WORKABLE TIMELINES
02:03:55.628 --> 02:03:57.363
SO THEY CAN COMPLY WITH THE LAW.
02:03:57.429 --> 02:03:58.364
SO WE APPRECIATE THE
02:03:58.430 --> 02:03:59.365
CONVERSATIONS WILL LOOK FORWARD
02:03:59.431 --> 02:04:00.900
TO MORE OF THOSE, AND RIGHT NOW.
02:04:00.966 --> 02:04:01.700
WE'RE BEINGRESPECTFUL
02:04:01.767 --> 02:04:03.035
OPPOSITION, SO THANK YOU. THANK
02:04:03.102 --> 02:04:04.236
YOU VERY MUCH APPRECIATED. IS
02:04:04.303 --> 02:04:08.107
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2200.
02:04:08.174 --> 02:04:09.942
SAYING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
02:04:10.009 --> 02:04:11.443
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASK IF
02:04:11.510 --> 02:04:13.879
YOU COULD QUEUE UP. MEMBERS OF
02:04:13.946 --> 02:04:15.314
THE PUBLIC WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
02:04:15.381 --> 02:04:18.384
IN OPPOSITION. SPEAKING
02:04:18.450 --> 02:04:19.451
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
02:04:19.518 --> 02:04:22.321
ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. FIRST WE
02:04:22.388 --> 02:04:24.356
WILL GO TO LINE 1 17, PLEASE GO
02:04:24.423 --> 02:04:27.326
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING CHAIR
02:04:27.393 --> 02:04:28.794
NUMBERS. CHRISLEY ON BEHALF OF
02:04:28.861 --> 02:04:30.229
THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION
02:04:30.296 --> 02:04:31.864
OF COUNTIES, ALSO WITH AN
02:04:31.931 --> 02:04:33.799
OPPOSING LESS AMENDED POSITION,
02:04:33.866 --> 02:04:35.367
BASED ON THE ISSUES DISCUSSED BY
02:04:35.434 --> 02:04:37.203
CALVO ONCE HAVE RAISED ONE
02:04:37.269 --> 02:04:38.370
ADDITIONAL POINT. WE UNDERSTAND
02:04:38.437 --> 02:04:39.371
THERE MIGHT BE COMMITTEE
02:04:39.438 --> 02:04:42.641
AMENDMENT. TO PROVIDE MORE TIME
02:04:42.708 --> 02:04:45.211
FOR SMALL CITIES UNDER 75,000 TO
02:04:45.277 --> 02:04:46.412
MEET THE TECHNOLOGY MANDATE.
02:04:46.478 --> 02:04:48.714
WE'D LIKE TO ASK FOR PARITY FOR
02:04:48.781 --> 02:04:49.715
SMALL COUNTIES IN THE
02:04:49.782 --> 02:04:51.116
UNINCORPORATED AREAS. WITH
02:04:51.183 --> 02:04:53.152
POPULATIONS THAT ARE SIMILAR.
02:04:53.219 --> 02:04:54.854
FINALLY I'VE ALSO BEEN ASKED TO
02:04:54.920 --> 02:04:55.988
SHARE THE SAME OPPOSING LESS
02:04:56.055 --> 02:04:57.623
AMENDED POSITION ON BEHALF OF
02:04:57.690 --> 02:04:59.892
CALIFORNIA CITIES, YOU KNOW, YOU
02:04:59.959 --> 02:05:00.359
KNOW URBAN COUNTIES IN
02:05:00.426 --> 02:05:01.861
CALIFORNIA AND THE RURAL COUNTY
02:05:01.927 --> 02:05:02.461
REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIA
02:05:02.528 --> 02:05:05.831
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:05:05.898 --> 02:05:06.899
NEXT. PLEASE 26, PLEASE GO
02:05:06.966 --> 02:05:11.537
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, DAVID JONES
02:05:11.604 --> 02:05:12.304
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SAN
02:05:12.371 --> 02:05:16.342
MARCOS IN OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
02:05:16.408 --> 02:05:17.509
THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL I
02:05:17.576 --> 02:05:20.946
HAVE IN QUÊ. VERY GOOD. THANK
02:05:21.013 --> 02:05:22.147
YOU VERY MUCH. WE'LL BRING IT
02:05:22.214 --> 02:05:23.349
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
02:05:23.415 --> 02:05:26.752
COMMENTS QUESTIONS. SENATOR
02:05:26.819 --> 02:05:30.089
WIENER? NO I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
02:05:30.155 --> 02:05:31.724
THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
02:05:31.790 --> 02:05:32.491
BILL. I CAN'T REMEMBER IF I
02:05:32.558 --> 02:05:34.493
MACAW THER. IF I'M NOT. I WOULD
02:05:34.560 --> 02:05:37.329
LIKE TO BE, UM NEED TO KEEP
02:05:37.396 --> 02:05:39.398
TRACK OF THOSE THINGS. UM THIS
02:05:39.465 --> 02:05:41.867
IS, UH, YOU KNOW, I THINK WE'VE
02:05:41.934 --> 02:05:43.269
THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF FOCUS AND
02:05:43.335 --> 02:05:44.770
IN ADDRESSING OUR HOUSING CRISIS
02:05:44.837 --> 02:05:45.704
HERE IN THE LEGISLATURE ON THE
02:05:45.771 --> 02:05:47.139
ENTITLEMENT PROCESS ON ACTUALLY
02:05:47.206 --> 02:05:48.941
GETTING THE PERMIT TO BUILD
02:05:49.008 --> 02:05:51.110
HOUSING, AND THAT'S EXTREMELY
02:05:51.176 --> 02:05:52.778
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT
02:05:52.845 --> 02:05:55.581
CAN TAKE YEARS. UH TO GET THAT
02:05:55.648 --> 02:05:57.850
PERMIT, BUT WE HAVE NOT. WE'VE
02:05:57.917 --> 02:05:59.985
NEGLECTED THE POST ENTITLEMENT
02:06:00.052 --> 02:06:01.754
PROCESS AND WE'VE ALL WELL AWARE
02:06:01.820 --> 02:06:04.623
PROJECT BIGGER. PLANNING
02:06:04.690 --> 02:06:05.357
COMMISSIONER CITY COUNCIL
02:06:05.424 --> 02:06:07.726
APPROVES THE PROJECT, AND THEN
02:06:07.793 --> 02:06:08.627
IT GETS STUCK IN THIS WEIRD
02:06:08.694 --> 02:06:09.929
LIMBO, SOMETIMES FOR YEARS
02:06:09.995 --> 02:06:11.664
BETWEEN THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT
02:06:11.730 --> 02:06:12.998
AND THE FIRE DEPARTMENT AND
02:06:13.065 --> 02:06:14.733
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND
02:06:14.800 --> 02:06:17.136
IT'S I'VE SEEN SITUATIONS IN SAN
02:06:17.202 --> 02:06:18.737
FRANCISCO, WHERE THEY'RE LIKE
02:06:18.804 --> 02:06:19.772
SIX DIFFERENT DEPARTMENTS
02:06:19.838 --> 02:06:20.839
INVOLVED. THEY'RE NOT TALKING TO
02:06:20.906 --> 02:06:21.807
EACH OTHER OR THEIR
02:06:21.874 --> 02:06:22.408
CONTRADICTING EACH OTHER, AND
02:06:22.474 --> 02:06:25.945
ONE OF THEM MANDATES JUST LIKE
02:06:26.011 --> 02:06:26.946
MAKES YOUR HEAD EXPLODE
02:06:27.012 --> 02:06:28.414
SOMETIMES, AND SO I THINK,
02:06:28.480 --> 02:06:31.383
PUTTING JUST BASIC TIMELINES ON
02:06:31.450 --> 02:06:34.253
IS A GOOD GOVERNMENT. UM MEASURE
02:06:34.320 --> 02:06:35.387
AND I'M I RESPECT THE
02:06:35.454 --> 02:06:37.356
OPPOSITION, THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
02:06:37.423 --> 02:06:39.692
GROUPS, BUT I THINK THIS WILL
02:06:39.758 --> 02:06:42.695
FRANKLY SPUR SOME INTROSPECTION
02:06:42.761 --> 02:06:44.396
AND SOME INTERNAL STREAMLINING
02:06:44.463 --> 02:06:46.765
AND REFORMS SO THAT WE CAN MAKE
02:06:46.832 --> 02:06:48.000
IT HAPPEN, SO I'M HAPPY TO MOVE
02:06:48.067 --> 02:06:49.501
THE BILL. MOTION HAS BEEN MADE
02:06:49.568 --> 02:06:53.872
ANY OTHER COMMENTS. SO ON THERE
02:06:53.939 --> 02:06:55.407
, THE AUTHOR HAS COMMITTED TO
02:06:55.474 --> 02:06:57.209
MAKE MAKE AMENDMENTS. MAYBE YOU
02:06:57.276 --> 02:06:58.610
CAN ADDRESS THOSE IN YOUR
02:06:58.677 --> 02:07:00.713
CLOSING IN AND THEY WILL BE
02:07:00.779 --> 02:07:02.848
TAKEN IN THE NEXT COMMITTEE. I
02:07:02.915 --> 02:07:05.417
DO APPRECIATE THAT, BUT ALSO UM
02:07:05.484 --> 02:07:07.619
I BELIEVE IT TAKES INTO
02:07:07.686 --> 02:07:09.154
CONSIDERATION THE SMALL COUNTIES
02:07:09.221 --> 02:07:13.125
AS WELL, UM SO, UM, ONCE I THINK
02:07:13.192 --> 02:07:14.226
THEY GET THEM IN PRINT, I THINK
02:07:14.293 --> 02:07:18.931
THERE'LL BE. A LITTLE HAPPIER TO
02:07:18.998 --> 02:07:20.466
THE EXTENT THAT THAT IT'S ALWAYS
02:07:20.532 --> 02:07:22.167
HARD TO HAVE THESE LIMITS IN
02:07:22.234 --> 02:07:23.602
PLACE, BUT I WANT TO AGREE WITH
02:07:23.669 --> 02:07:25.771
THE SENATOR WIENER. SOME OF
02:07:25.838 --> 02:07:26.939
THEIR THEIR THEIR INSTANCES I
02:07:27.006 --> 02:07:28.907
WAS GOING TO SAY WHEN HE WAS
02:07:28.974 --> 02:07:30.809
HAVING SAYING IT. MAKES YOUR
02:07:30.876 --> 02:07:31.377
HEAD EXPLODED. THAT'S WHAT
02:07:31.443 --> 02:07:33.545
MAYORS ARE FOR WHEN YOU COME IN
02:07:33.612 --> 02:07:35.581
, AND YOU START, UM PUSHING THAT
02:07:35.647 --> 02:07:37.383
FOR THINGS TO HAPPEN A LOT
02:07:37.449 --> 02:07:41.053
FASTER. TO ALLOW YOU TO SUPPORT
02:07:41.120 --> 02:07:42.521
YOUR BILL TODAY. I THINK IT'S A
02:07:42.588 --> 02:07:44.590
REALLY GOOD BILL AND ALLOW YOU
02:07:44.656 --> 02:07:45.424
TO CLOSE. I APPRECIATE THE
02:07:45.491 --> 02:07:47.526
COMMENTS AND YES, WE YOU KNOW,
02:07:47.593 --> 02:07:48.527
HAVE ACCEPTED THE COMMITTEE
02:07:48.594 --> 02:07:50.729
MEMBERS HAVE BEEN PROPOSED. AND
02:07:50.796 --> 02:07:52.398
AS WE HAVE FROM DAY, ONE WILL
02:07:52.464 --> 02:07:54.967
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH OPPOSITION
02:07:55.034 --> 02:07:55.634
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK TO ADDRESS
02:07:55.701 --> 02:07:57.503
BECAUSE THIS YOU KNOW, AS HAS
02:07:57.569 --> 02:07:58.370
BEEN MENTIONED, AS YOU KNOW
02:07:58.437 --> 02:07:59.638
AGAIN THIS TO CREATE, YOU KNOW,
02:07:59.705 --> 02:08:00.706
WE'RE SEEKING TO CREATE
02:08:00.773 --> 02:08:01.573
STANDARDS FOR THESE LOCAL
02:08:01.640 --> 02:08:02.408
GOVERNMENTS TO CREATE
02:08:02.474 --> 02:08:03.642
INEFFICIENCY. THAT'S GOING TO BE
02:08:03.709 --> 02:08:05.811
BEST FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS CAN
02:08:05.878 --> 02:08:07.179
BE BEST FOR THIS HOUSING CRISIS
02:08:07.246 --> 02:08:08.213
THAT WE'RE EXPERIENCING, AND
02:08:08.280 --> 02:08:09.515
IT'S GOING TO BE BEST FOR, UM
02:08:09.581 --> 02:08:11.216
OUR BUILDERS AS WELL. THESE
02:08:11.283 --> 02:08:13.252
THESE DELAYS THAT SENATOR WIENER
02:08:13.318 --> 02:08:16.522
ALLUDED TO THEY ARE, UH, YOU
02:08:16.588 --> 02:08:17.756
KNOW, WE COULD DO SOMETHING
02:08:17.823 --> 02:08:18.891
ABOUT IT. IT'S PREVENTABLE. AND
02:08:18.957 --> 02:08:20.726
SO THIS IS WHAT WE'RE ATTEMPTING
02:08:20.793 --> 02:08:22.728
TO DO. APPRECIATE THAT AND I MY
02:08:22.795 --> 02:08:24.830
APOLOGY. THERE WERE A COUPLE OF
02:08:24.897 --> 02:08:25.664
CLARIFYING AMENDMENTS ON PAGE
02:08:25.731 --> 02:08:30.369
FIVE. I WON'T ASK YOU TO UM,
02:08:30.436 --> 02:08:31.837
TAKE THEM THEIR LANGUAGE ISSUES
02:08:31.904 --> 02:08:33.472
. IF YOU COULD TAKE A LOOK AT
02:08:33.539 --> 02:08:34.606
HIM, AND WE'LL BE DEALING WITH
02:08:34.673 --> 02:08:36.542
THEM AND IN THE IN THE HOUSING
02:08:36.608 --> 02:08:38.444
COMMITTEE IF IT GETS OUT OF THIS
02:08:38.510 --> 02:08:40.112
COMMITTEE IN ANY CASE, AND SO UM
02:08:40.179 --> 02:08:42.147
APPRECIATE IT. AND SO WE DO HAVE
02:08:42.214 --> 02:08:44.083
A MOTION THE MOTION. THIS DO
02:08:44.149 --> 02:08:45.250
PASS BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
02:08:45.317 --> 02:08:46.785
THE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING. UM
02:08:46.852 --> 02:08:50.856
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATORS
02:08:50.923 --> 02:08:54.493
CABALLERO CABALLERO, I. NILSSON
02:08:54.560 --> 02:08:57.563
NILSSON. I DO RUSSELL. SO I
02:08:57.629 --> 02:08:59.965
HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE WIENER.
02:09:00.032 --> 02:09:04.403
WIENER. I 50. MOTIONS EITHER
02:09:04.470 --> 02:09:08.073
MEASURES OUT 5 TO 0. WE'RE GOING
02:09:08.140 --> 02:09:10.008
TO MOVE ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:09:10.075 --> 02:09:11.210
13 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM A B 22
02:09:11.276 --> 02:09:19.718
95 WELCOME. THANK YOU, MADAM
02:09:19.785 --> 02:09:24.423
CHAIR. GOOD MORNING. I WANT TO
02:09:24.490 --> 02:09:26.692
BEGIN BY THANKING YOU, MADAM
02:09:26.758 --> 02:09:28.026
CHAIR AND YOUR STAFF ARE WORKING
02:09:28.093 --> 02:09:29.595
WITH ME ON THE AGREED UPON
02:09:29.661 --> 02:09:32.631
AMENDMENTS TO A B 22 95. I'M
02:09:32.698 --> 02:09:34.166
HAPPY TO MAKE THOSE CHANGES IN
02:09:34.233 --> 02:09:36.201
THE NEXT COMMITTEE, WHICH, AS
02:09:36.268 --> 02:09:37.769
YOU JUST REFERENCED WILL BE THE
02:09:37.836 --> 02:09:38.737
HOUSING COMMITTEE. VERY GOOD.
02:09:38.804 --> 02:09:40.939
THANK YOU. I'M PLEASED TO
02:09:41.006 --> 02:09:43.108
PRESENT A B 22 95, WHICH IS A
02:09:43.175 --> 02:09:44.510
MEASURE TO HELP ADDRESS THE
02:09:44.576 --> 02:09:47.112
TEACHER SHORTAGE IN CALIFORNIA.
02:09:47.179 --> 02:09:49.114
RECENT AND THE HOUSING SHORTAGE%
02:09:49.181 --> 02:09:51.416
. RECENT DATA SHOWS THAT ONE
02:09:51.483 --> 02:09:52.851
INTENDS SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE
02:09:52.918 --> 02:09:55.787
LOSING 1/4 OF THEIR TEACHERS,
02:09:55.854 --> 02:09:56.588
SKYROCKETING HOUSING PRICES AND
02:09:56.655 --> 02:09:59.658
SALARIES THAT DON'T KEEP UP.
02:09:59.725 --> 02:10:01.727
HAVE MADE IT MORE DIFFICULT FOR
02:10:01.793 --> 02:10:02.427
TEACHERS TO LIVE IN THE
02:10:02.494 --> 02:10:04.229
COMMUNITIES WHERE THEY TEACH TO
02:10:04.296 --> 02:10:07.166
TACKLE THIS ISSUE 46 OF OUR
02:10:07.232 --> 02:10:08.467
LARGEST SCHOOL DISTRICTS IN
02:10:08.534 --> 02:10:10.035
CALIFORNIA HAVE EXPRESSED
02:10:10.102 --> 02:10:10.903
INTEREST IN BUILDING EDUCATIONAL
02:10:10.969 --> 02:10:13.005
WORKFORCE HOUSING TO RECRUIT AND
02:10:13.071 --> 02:10:17.342
RETAIN STAFF. UNFORTUNATELY THE
02:10:17.409 --> 02:10:18.977
AVERAGE EDUCATIONAL WORKFORCE
02:10:19.044 --> 02:10:20.179
HOUSING PROJECT TAKES MORE THAN
02:10:20.245 --> 02:10:23.382
SEVEN YEARS TO COMPLETE. AND
02:10:23.448 --> 02:10:24.683
UNACCEPTABLE TIMELINE DURING THE
02:10:24.750 --> 02:10:28.086
HOUSING CRISIS. LOCAL RESISTANCE
02:10:28.153 --> 02:10:29.087
, RESTRICTIVE ZONING AND
02:10:29.154 --> 02:10:30.489
COMPLICATED BUREAUCRATIC
02:10:30.556 --> 02:10:31.890
PROCESSES HAVE ADDED YEARS TO
02:10:31.957 --> 02:10:34.126
THE CONSTRUCTION PROCESS.
02:10:34.193 --> 02:10:36.228
INCREASED COST AND ULTIMATELY
02:10:36.295 --> 02:10:37.229
HINDERED EFFORTS TO HOUSE
02:10:37.296 --> 02:10:39.264
CALIFORNIA'S EDUCATIONAL
02:10:39.331 --> 02:10:41.466
WORKFORCE. TO DATE, ONLY THREE
02:10:41.533 --> 02:10:42.334
SCHOOL DISTRICTS HAVE
02:10:42.401 --> 02:10:43.468
SUCCESSFULLY BUILT HOUSING
02:10:43.535 --> 02:10:44.736
PROJECTS ON PROPERTIES THAT THEY
02:10:44.803 --> 02:10:49.107
OWN. WE CAN DO BETTER. MAYBE 22
02:10:49.174 --> 02:10:51.476
95 WILL HELP SCHOOL DISTRICTS
02:10:51.543 --> 02:10:52.744
BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON
02:10:52.811 --> 02:10:54.213
SURPLUS SCHOOL PROPERTY BY
02:10:54.279 --> 02:10:55.214
MAKING HOUSING AND ALLOWABLE
02:10:55.280 --> 02:10:59.351
USE. HOUSING PROJECTS MUST MEET
02:10:59.418 --> 02:11:00.419
THE HEIGHT DENSITY AND
02:11:00.485 --> 02:11:02.354
AFFORDABLE HOUSING REQUIREMENTS
02:11:02.421 --> 02:11:04.823
THAT ARE LAID OUT IN THE BILL
02:11:04.890 --> 02:11:06.225
AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS WOULD BE
02:11:06.291 --> 02:11:06.959
REQUIRED TO OFFER DEED
02:11:07.025 --> 02:11:08.460
RESTRICTED AFFORDABLE UNITS
02:11:08.527 --> 02:11:09.861
FIRST TO THEIR TEACHERS AND
02:11:09.928 --> 02:11:13.498
STAFF. THE CHAIR AND I HAVE ALSO
02:11:13.565 --> 02:11:14.733
AGREED UPON LANGUAGE TO PROTECT
02:11:14.800 --> 02:11:16.702
AGAINST URBAN SPRAWL AND GIVE
02:11:16.768 --> 02:11:18.203
LOCAL AGENCIES MORE TIME TO
02:11:18.270 --> 02:11:19.938
ESTABLISH OBJECTIVE DEVELOPMENT
02:11:20.005 --> 02:11:20.906
STANDARDS. IN ADDITION TO A
02:11:20.973 --> 02:11:23.742
COUPLE OF OTHER ITEMS. SCHOOL
02:11:23.809 --> 02:11:25.444
DISTRICTS IN CALIFORNIA, AN
02:11:25.510 --> 02:11:27.579
OVER 75,000 ACRES OF LAND THAT
02:11:27.646 --> 02:11:28.814
ARE POTENTIALLY SUITABLE FOR
02:11:28.880 --> 02:11:32.251
HOUSING. AS APTLY NOTED IN THE
02:11:32.317 --> 02:11:33.452
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS, ASSUMING AND
02:11:33.518 --> 02:11:37.789
IT'S LIKELY IT WOULD ONLY BE A
02:11:37.856 --> 02:11:38.790
FRACTION OF THIS. BUT ASSUMING
02:11:38.857 --> 02:11:41.760
WE COULD BUILD 30 UNITS PER ACRE
02:11:41.827 --> 02:11:43.061
THAT EQUATES TO 2.3 MILLION
02:11:43.128 --> 02:11:46.932
UNITS OF HOUSING MORE THAN
02:11:46.999 --> 02:11:48.900
ENOUGH TO NOT ONLY MEET THE
02:11:48.967 --> 02:11:50.068
HOUSING NEEDS OF TEACHERS AND
02:11:50.135 --> 02:11:53.538
STAFF. BUT ALSO THE CLOSING THE
02:11:53.605 --> 02:11:55.607
GAP ALMOST COMPLETELY IN TERMS
02:11:55.674 --> 02:11:56.875
OF THE AMOUNT OF HOUSING THAT
02:11:56.942 --> 02:11:59.344
WERE BEHIND IN CALIFORNIA. AND
02:11:59.411 --> 02:12:01.780
IT WOULD NOT SURE THAT WE KEEP
02:12:01.847 --> 02:12:02.848
QUALITY TEACHERS AND STAFF IN
02:12:02.914 --> 02:12:04.816
THE CLASSROOM. TESTIFYING IN
02:12:04.883 --> 02:12:06.351
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL TODAY, OUR
02:12:06.418 --> 02:12:08.754
DANA CUFF THE DIRECTOR, DIRECTOR
02:12:08.820 --> 02:12:11.823
OF CITY LAB AT UCLA, AND CHRIS
02:12:11.890 --> 02:12:12.758
REEF, REPRESENTING HE
02:12:12.824 --> 02:12:13.692
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARD
02:12:13.759 --> 02:12:17.362
ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
02:12:17.429 --> 02:12:18.163
. WE HAVE THEM BOTH ON THE
02:12:18.230 --> 02:12:20.432
PHONE. SO IF WE COULD CALL ON
02:12:20.499 --> 02:12:22.467
DANA CUFF FROM CITY LAB AT U. C
02:12:22.534 --> 02:12:34.112
L. A TO TESTIFY FIRST.
02:12:34.179 --> 02:12:35.647
CHECKING WITH THE MODERATOR TO
02:12:35.714 --> 02:12:37.683
SEE IF DANA DANA CUFF IS ON THE
02:12:37.749 --> 02:12:41.286
PHONE. CAN YOU HEAR ME? WE CAN
02:12:41.353 --> 02:12:46.692
YEP. OKAY I'M DANA CUFF
02:12:46.758 --> 02:12:48.293
PROFESSOR AT U. C L. A AND
02:12:48.360 --> 02:12:50.395
DIRECTOR OF THE RESEARCH CENTERS
02:12:50.462 --> 02:12:52.364
CITY LAB. THE RESEARCH BEHIND
02:12:52.431 --> 02:12:53.498
THE BILL THAT ASSEMBLYMAN BLOOM
02:12:53.565 --> 02:12:56.702
HAS JUST PRESENTED COMES FROM
02:12:56.768 --> 02:12:58.904
COLLABORATIONS WITH L. A CITY
02:12:58.970 --> 02:13:01.373
PLANNER JAMES BLUMENFELD.
02:13:01.440 --> 02:13:02.941
BERKELEY COLLEAGUES AND THE
02:13:03.008 --> 02:13:04.343
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARD
02:13:04.409 --> 02:13:05.377
ASSOCIATION WITH ITS 1000
02:13:05.444 --> 02:13:08.847
DISTRICTS. I JUST WANT TO ADD
02:13:08.914 --> 02:13:10.682
THAT I MYSELF I'M A PRODUCT OF
02:13:10.749 --> 02:13:12.718
THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF CALIFORNIA
02:13:12.784 --> 02:13:15.020
FROM KINDERGARTEN THROUGH MY PHD
02:13:15.087 --> 02:13:15.620
AND HENCE MY PERSONAL CONCERN
02:13:15.687 --> 02:13:17.723
ABOUT OUR PUBLIC. COOL TEACHERS
02:13:17.789 --> 02:13:21.793
AND THEIR STAFF. I THINK THE
02:13:21.860 --> 02:13:23.528
ISSUE IS ONE THAT IS VERY WELL
02:13:23.595 --> 02:13:25.630
KNOWN. THE HOUSING CRISIS IN
02:13:25.697 --> 02:13:28.433
CALIFORNIA HAS GIVEN US 50% OF
02:13:28.500 --> 02:13:31.370
OUR RENTERS AS RENT BURDEN BUT
02:13:31.436 --> 02:13:32.738
THE SPECIFIC ISSUES RELATED TO
02:13:32.804 --> 02:13:33.972
OUR EDUCATION WORKFORCE OR EVEN
02:13:34.039 --> 02:13:38.110
MORE DIRE IN 2021 HOUSING PRICES
02:13:38.176 --> 02:13:41.380
IN CALIFORNIA WENT UP 12.3.
02:13:41.446 --> 02:13:44.149
22.3% IN SACRAMENTO AND OTHER
02:13:44.216 --> 02:13:46.351
SMALLER METRO AREAS, BUT
02:13:46.418 --> 02:13:48.253
TEACHERS SALARIES ONLY WENT UP
02:13:48.320 --> 02:13:52.224
1.6. THIS HAS CREATED A SERIOUS
02:13:52.290 --> 02:13:53.225
PROBLEM WITH RECRUITMENT AND
02:13:53.291 --> 02:13:56.628
RETENTION. 75% OF CALIFORNIA
02:13:56.695 --> 02:13:57.629
DISTRICT IMPORT RECRUITING
02:13:57.696 --> 02:14:00.232
DIFFICULTY AND ONE OF THE MOST
02:14:00.298 --> 02:14:01.733
COMMON REASONS CITED BY
02:14:01.800 --> 02:14:03.802
PROSPECTIVE TEACHERS AS WELL AS
02:14:03.869 --> 02:14:06.171
THOSE LEAVING OUR SCHOOLS. IS
02:14:06.238 --> 02:14:08.240
THE HIGH COST OF HOUSING. THIS
02:14:08.306 --> 02:14:09.875
IS SPECIALLY TRUE FOR THE ENTRY
02:14:09.941 --> 02:14:11.610
LEVEL TEACHERS. WE FEEL BADLY
02:14:11.676 --> 02:14:15.213
NEED. OUR RESEARCH, WHICH TOOK
02:14:15.280 --> 02:14:17.716
PLACE OVER TWO YEARS HAS SHOWN
02:14:17.783 --> 02:14:20.652
THAT THE 75,000 ACRES OF
02:14:20.719 --> 02:14:22.888
SUITABLY SUITABLE LAND IS IN
02:14:22.954 --> 02:14:26.691
EVERY COUNTY OF OUR STATE. WE
02:14:26.758 --> 02:14:28.360
KNOW ALSO THAT SCHOOLS NEED AND
02:14:28.427 --> 02:14:32.230
WANT THIS KIND OF HOUSING. ONLY
02:14:32.297 --> 02:14:33.832
FIVE DEVELOPMENTS TOTAL HAVE
02:14:33.899 --> 02:14:35.367
BEEN BUILT IN THE THREE
02:14:35.434 --> 02:14:36.835
DIFFERENT DISTRICTS, BUT ALL
02:14:36.902 --> 02:14:38.069
FIVE OF THOSE HAVE LONG WAITING
02:14:38.136 --> 02:14:40.739
LIST. ITH HEALTHCARE IN SCHOOL
02:14:40.806 --> 02:14:43.141
BOARD ASSOCIATION. WE'VE AS A
02:14:43.208 --> 02:14:45.310
RESULT, ORGANIZED WORKSHOPS FOR
02:14:45.377 --> 02:14:46.912
INTERESTED DISTRICTS WHO WANT TO
02:14:46.978 --> 02:14:48.280
BUILD EDUCATION, WORKFORCE
02:14:48.346 --> 02:14:50.248
HOUSING. WE HOPE TO GET 4 TO 6
02:14:50.315 --> 02:14:52.150
DISTRICTS TO SIGN UP FOR THE
02:14:52.217 --> 02:14:55.387
WORKSHOP. 50 DISTRICTS APPLIED A
02:14:55.454 --> 02:14:57.789
B 22 95, PARTICULARLY WITH THE
02:14:57.856 --> 02:14:59.925
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE MADE IN
02:14:59.991 --> 02:15:01.760
RESPONSE TO YOUR CONCERNS, MADAM
02:15:01.827 --> 02:15:03.862
HERE KEEP THE PRIORITY ON LOCAL
02:15:03.929 --> 02:15:04.830
CONTROL AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT
02:15:04.896 --> 02:15:08.967
WHILE REMOVING BARRIERS. TO THE
02:15:09.034 --> 02:15:10.735
DEVELOPMENT THAT HAS MADE THESE
02:15:10.802 --> 02:15:12.370
KINDS OF HOUSING PROJECTS TAKES
02:15:12.437 --> 02:15:15.040
A LONG AND BE SO INSURMOUNTABLE
02:15:15.106 --> 02:15:16.942
FOR OUR SCHOOL BOARDS AND
02:15:17.008 --> 02:15:17.542
SUPERINTENDENT GUARANTEES THAT
02:15:17.609 --> 02:15:19.311
SCHOOLS CAN BUILD UP THE STREET
02:15:19.377 --> 02:15:22.414
STORIES. REASONABLE DENSITIES.
02:15:22.481 --> 02:15:24.382
IT PERMITS HOUSING ON SCHOOL
02:15:24.449 --> 02:15:26.751
PROPERTY WITHOUT RESULTING
02:15:26.818 --> 02:15:27.886
HEALTHY FIRST EDUCATION
02:15:27.953 --> 02:15:28.954
WORKFORCE AND THEN PUBLIC
02:15:29.020 --> 02:15:33.291
EMPLOYEES. IT'S A MINIMUM OF 50%
02:15:33.358 --> 02:15:34.326
AFFORDABLE GUARANTEED FOR 55
02:15:34.392 --> 02:15:38.230
YEARS. MORE TEACHER AND STUFF
02:15:38.296 --> 02:15:40.031
HOUSING CALIFORNIA'S EDUCATION
02:15:40.098 --> 02:15:42.133
AND THAT'S ITS FUTURE WILL BE
02:15:42.200 --> 02:15:44.503
STABILIZED AND QUALITY EDUCATION
02:15:44.569 --> 02:15:46.872
MUCH BETTER INSURED. I ASK FOR
02:15:46.938 --> 02:15:48.139
YOUR SUPPORT AND THEN HAPPY TO
02:15:48.206 --> 02:15:50.475
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS. THANK YOU.
02:15:50.542 --> 02:15:52.677
THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT WEEK.
02:15:52.744 --> 02:15:53.879
WE'D LIKE TO HEAR FROM CHRIS
02:15:53.945 --> 02:15:54.813
REEF. CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARDS
02:15:54.880 --> 02:15:59.751
ASSOCIATION. THANK YOU, MADAM
02:15:59.818 --> 02:16:00.886
CHAIR AND MEMBERS THE
02:16:00.952 --> 02:16:03.221
OPPORTUNITY CHRIS REEVE. WITH
02:16:03.288 --> 02:16:04.356
THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARD
02:16:04.422 --> 02:16:05.590
ASSOCIATION ON BEHALF OF OUR
02:16:05.657 --> 02:16:06.758
NEARLY 1000 SCHOOL DISTRICTS
02:16:06.825 --> 02:16:09.561
ACROSS THE STATE. AS MANY OF YOU
02:16:09.628 --> 02:16:11.796
WILL KNOW. WE ARE FACING DIRE
02:16:11.863 --> 02:16:12.864
TIMES WITH OUR CURRENT
02:16:12.931 --> 02:16:15.200
ADDITIONAL WORKFORCE SHORTAGES.
02:16:15.267 --> 02:16:16.301
WE FACE SHORTAGES ACROSS THE
02:16:16.368 --> 02:16:20.071
BOARD IN ALL POSITIONS. AND EVEN
02:16:20.138 --> 02:16:21.540
PRIOR TO THE PANDEMIC. THIS WAS
02:16:21.606 --> 02:16:23.642
A ONGOING CRISIS THAT HAS NOW
02:16:23.708 --> 02:16:24.643
BEEN EXACERBATED BY THE
02:16:24.709 --> 02:16:27.879
PANDEMIC. UM IN PRIOR TO THE
02:16:27.946 --> 02:16:29.214
PANDEMIC. THERE WAS A SURVEY
02:16:29.281 --> 02:16:32.083
CONDUCTED BUT ABOUT NEARLY TWO
02:16:32.150 --> 02:16:33.685
THIRDS OF DISTRICTS AND WITH
02:16:33.752 --> 02:16:34.653
THIS TRIBUTARY DEMONSTRATED WAS
02:16:34.719 --> 02:16:38.723
THAT NEARLY 40% OF ALL TEACHERS
02:16:38.790 --> 02:16:41.293
BEGINNING TEACHERS DON'T MAKE
02:16:41.359 --> 02:16:42.761
ENOUGH MONEY TO AFFORD ONE
02:16:42.827 --> 02:16:44.930
BEDROOM RENT AND ONE BEDROOM
02:16:44.996 --> 02:16:47.899
APARTMENT IN CALIFORNIA. AND YOU
02:16:47.966 --> 02:16:51.469
KNOW, MORE THAN A QUARTER. UH
02:16:51.536 --> 02:16:52.971
THOSE DISTRICTS EVEN THE HIGHEST
02:16:53.038 --> 02:16:54.773
PAID TEACHERS STRUGGLED TO PAY
02:16:54.839 --> 02:16:58.243
RENT FOR A THREE BEDROOM HOUSE.
02:16:58.310 --> 02:17:00.345
AND SO WE ARE IN A PLACE WHERE
02:17:00.412 --> 02:17:02.814
MANY TEACHERS ARE LEAVING THE
02:17:02.881 --> 02:17:03.982
PROFESSION BECAUSE OF THE COST
02:17:04.049 --> 02:17:05.550
OF LIVING BECAUSE OF THE COST OF
02:17:05.617 --> 02:17:07.118
HOUSING IN OUR DISTRICTS ARE
02:17:07.185 --> 02:17:08.820
LOOKING FOR ALL ALTERNATIVES TO
02:17:08.887 --> 02:17:10.755
HELP. PRODUCE WORKFORCE HOUSING
02:17:10.822 --> 02:17:12.757
SO THAT WE CAN RETAIN QUALIFIED
02:17:12.824 --> 02:17:14.859
WORKFORCE. AND SO WE'RE GRATEFUL
02:17:14.926 --> 02:17:16.761
FOR EVERY 22 95. WE'RE GRATEFUL
02:17:16.828 --> 02:17:17.429
FOR THE WORKING WITH THE
02:17:17.495 --> 02:17:19.197
COMMITTEE STAFF AND WITH THE
02:17:19.264 --> 02:17:21.466
CHAIR TO ADDRESS THE COMMITTEE'S
02:17:21.533 --> 02:17:23.768
CONCERNS TO TRY TO COME TO A
02:17:23.835 --> 02:17:24.869
MUTUALLY AGREEABLE RESOLUTION,
02:17:24.936 --> 02:17:26.137
AND I THINK WE HAVE THAT WITH
02:17:26.204 --> 02:17:27.872
THE AMENDMENTS. AND SO WE REALLY
02:17:27.939 --> 02:17:28.740
STRONGLY ENCOURAGED THE
02:17:28.807 --> 02:17:31.376
COMMITTEE. UM TO VOTE AYE ON
02:17:31.443 --> 02:17:32.410
THIS BILL AND PROVIDE DISTRICTS
02:17:32.477 --> 02:17:34.479
ADDITIONAL AUCTION, WHERE THEY
02:17:34.546 --> 02:17:35.614
CAN FURTHER STREAMLINED AND
02:17:35.680 --> 02:17:36.648
PROVIDE MUCH NEEDED EDUCATIONAL
02:17:36.715 --> 02:17:39.117
WORKFORCE HOUSING. UM OR ITS
02:17:39.184 --> 02:17:40.151
TEACHERS AND STAFF. THANK YOU
02:17:40.218 --> 02:17:43.355
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:17:43.421 --> 02:17:45.390
TESTIMONY GOING TO MOVE ON TO
02:17:45.457 --> 02:17:46.591
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
02:17:46.658 --> 02:17:50.729
IN ROOM 2200. COREY SMITH.
02:17:50.795 --> 02:17:51.763
HOUSING ACTION COALITION AND
02:17:51.830 --> 02:17:55.734
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:17:55.800 --> 02:17:57.602
SATA HORWITZ, LOS ANGELES
02:17:57.669 --> 02:17:58.737
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT AND
02:17:58.803 --> 02:18:00.639
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
02:18:00.705 --> 02:18:02.707
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2200?
02:18:02.774 --> 02:18:04.376
SEEING THEN WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
02:18:04.442 --> 02:18:05.910
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
02:18:05.977 --> 02:18:06.778
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
02:18:06.845 --> 02:18:08.580
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
02:18:08.647 --> 02:18:13.018
AND SUPPORT? TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:18:13.084 --> 02:18:13.618
OF THE BILL. PLEASE PRY PRESS
02:18:13.685 --> 02:18:16.821
ONE, THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. WE
02:18:16.888 --> 02:18:18.056
WILL START WITH LINE 1 61,
02:18:18.123 --> 02:18:19.991
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MICHAEL
02:18:20.058 --> 02:18:21.026
LANGUAGE, FERN STRONG SUPPORT.
02:18:21.092 --> 02:18:25.730
THANK YOU. TÌM 42, PLEASE GO
02:18:25.797 --> 02:18:30.835
AHEAD. BOB NAYLOR WITH FUELED
02:18:30.902 --> 02:18:32.871
STUDYING COMPANY HOWARD AHMANSON
02:18:32.937 --> 02:18:34.105
JR. ORANGE COUNTY
02:18:34.172 --> 02:18:35.006
PHILANTHROPISTS IN STRONG
02:18:35.073 --> 02:18:38.576
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. I'M CLIMBING
02:18:38.643 --> 02:18:42.480
87, PLEASE GO AHEAD. NEXT NEIDER
02:18:42.547 --> 02:18:44.115
ON BEHALF OF META AND SUPPORT.
02:18:44.182 --> 02:18:48.787
THANK YOU. LINE 1 64, PLEASE GO
02:18:48.853 --> 02:18:53.625
AHEAD. MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS.
02:18:53.692 --> 02:18:54.592
THIS IS EXTENDABLE WITH PATH.
02:18:54.659 --> 02:18:55.894
PEOPLE ASSISTING THE HOMELESS.
02:18:55.960 --> 02:18:57.696
MORE HOUSING IS ALWAYS GOOD FOR
02:18:57.762 --> 02:18:58.363
OUR HOUSING AND HOMES. THIS
02:18:58.430 --> 02:19:00.732
CRISIS SO WE'RE IN STRONG
02:19:00.799 --> 02:19:01.833
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:19:01.900 --> 02:19:05.737
THANK YOU. AND I JUST SAW THAT I
02:19:05.804 --> 02:19:07.372
HAVE IN. Q VERY GOOD. WE'RE
02:19:07.439 --> 02:19:08.807
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION.
02:19:08.873 --> 02:19:10.642
WE HAVE NO LEAD OPPOSITION
02:19:10.709 --> 02:19:12.410
WITNESSES, SO WE'RE GOING TO
02:19:12.477 --> 02:19:13.678
CHECK AND SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
02:19:13.745 --> 02:19:15.714
IN ROOM 2200. I WOULD LIKE TO
02:19:15.780 --> 02:19:20.085
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION. MADAM CHAIR
02:19:20.151 --> 02:19:21.553
MEMBERS MIKE WEST ON BEHALF OF
02:19:21.619 --> 02:19:22.353
THE STATE BUILDING AND
02:19:22.420 --> 02:19:24.522
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL WILL
02:19:24.589 --> 02:19:25.523
TAKE A LOOK AT THE AMENDMENTS
02:19:25.590 --> 02:19:27.292
ONCE THEY'RE IN PRINT, BUT WE
02:19:27.358 --> 02:19:28.393
STILL REMAIN OPPOSED. THANK YOU.
02:19:28.460 --> 02:19:29.360
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
02:19:29.427 --> 02:19:32.964
ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2200. SEEING
02:19:33.031 --> 02:19:34.733
NONE MOVE ON TO THE
02:19:34.799 --> 02:19:36.501
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
02:19:36.568 --> 02:19:37.669
ANYONE IN OPPOSITION ON THE
02:19:37.736 --> 02:19:41.940
TELECONFERENCE LANE? TO SPEAK IN
02:19:42.006 --> 02:19:43.208
OPPOSITION. PLEASE PRESS ONE,
02:19:43.274 --> 02:19:45.443
THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. ONE
02:19:45.510 --> 02:19:46.544
MINUTE WHILE WE GIVE LINE
02:19:46.611 --> 02:20:00.125
MEMBERS.
02:20:00.191 --> 02:20:04.462
91 52, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:20:04.529 --> 02:20:05.830
MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
02:20:05.897 --> 02:20:07.132
MADELINE COOPER FROM THE ULSTER
02:20:07.198 --> 02:20:08.833
MARKSMAN ON BEHALF OF COUNTRY
02:20:08.900 --> 02:20:10.268
COST A COUNTY. WE RESPECTFULLY
02:20:10.335 --> 02:20:11.236
REMAIN IN IMPOSING LESS
02:20:11.302 --> 02:20:12.837
COMMITTED POSITION AND WE'LL
02:20:12.904 --> 02:20:14.038
LOOK AT THE AMENDMENT. THANK
02:20:14.105 --> 02:20:19.377
YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL
02:20:19.444 --> 02:20:21.813
I HAVE IN. Q VERY GOOD. WE'RE
02:20:21.880 --> 02:20:23.648
GOING TO BRING THE BILL BACK TO
02:20:23.715 --> 02:20:24.883
THE COMMITTEE. ANY COMMENTS,
02:20:24.949 --> 02:20:29.220
QUESTIONS CONCERNS MOTIONS.
02:20:29.287 --> 02:20:30.889
QUESTION YEAH, I RAISED
02:20:30.955 --> 02:20:35.360
ASSEMBLYMAN ABOUT, UM A COUPLE
02:20:35.426 --> 02:20:36.995
OF THINGS AND CONCERNED ABOUT
02:20:37.061 --> 02:20:38.863
BUT MOSTLY IS ABOUT THE SKILLED
02:20:38.930 --> 02:20:41.266
AND TRAINED, UM, NOT BEING
02:20:41.332 --> 02:20:43.835
INCLUDED IN THE BILL. UM JUST TO
02:20:43.902 --> 02:20:45.370
GIVE AN IDEA WHEN UM SLASH LAST
02:20:45.436 --> 02:20:48.573
YEAR. I HAD A BILL FOR THE
02:20:48.640 --> 02:20:50.441
COMMUNITY COLLEGES TO BE ABLE TO
02:20:50.508 --> 02:20:52.377
USE THEIR LAND. BECAUSE OF THE
02:20:52.443 --> 02:20:54.279
SAME ISSUES THAT YOU BRING RIGHT
02:20:54.345 --> 02:20:57.048
THERE. THE WORKFORCE, INCLUDING
02:20:57.115 --> 02:20:58.716
THE TEACHERS, AS WELL AS THE
02:20:58.783 --> 02:21:01.052
STUDENTS IS BEING ABLE TO USE
02:21:01.119 --> 02:21:05.190
THAT LAND TO BUILD HOUSING. UM
02:21:05.256 --> 02:21:08.426
AND FOUND IN THAT THAT NOT ALL
02:21:08.493 --> 02:21:10.995
OF THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES WOULD
02:21:11.062 --> 02:21:12.897
HAVE HAD THOSE LABOR STANDARDS
02:21:12.964 --> 02:21:15.033
IN THERE. AND SO WE MADE IT. LOS
02:21:15.099 --> 02:21:17.769
ANGELES BECAUSE WE KNOW IN LOS
02:21:17.836 --> 02:21:19.103
ANGELES, THEY HAVE THOSE THAT
02:21:19.170 --> 02:21:22.140
LABOR STANDARDS INCLUDED. SO I
02:21:22.207 --> 02:21:24.375
WOULD REALLY LIKE TO SEE THAT I
02:21:24.442 --> 02:21:26.611
THINK THAT WHEN THE LAND IS PUT
02:21:26.678 --> 02:21:29.180
UP, UM AND THEN YOU KNOW LOCAL,
02:21:29.247 --> 02:21:30.315
UM, INVOLVEMENT IS NOT ALLOWED
02:21:30.381 --> 02:21:33.585
FOR IF WE DON'T DEAL WITH THE
02:21:33.651 --> 02:21:37.121
LABOR STANDARDS, THEN IT'S NOT
02:21:37.188 --> 02:21:38.823
LIKELY IN MANY PLACES THROUGHOUT
02:21:38.890 --> 02:21:40.258
CALIFORNIA AND NOT LIKELY TO BE
02:21:40.325 --> 02:21:43.127
INCLUDED. SO I HOPE YOU RETURN
02:21:43.194 --> 02:21:45.363
TO THAT AND RECONSIDER THE
02:21:45.430 --> 02:21:48.099
INCLUSION OF SKILLED AND TRAINED
02:21:48.166 --> 02:21:50.335
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. I MIGHT
02:21:50.401 --> 02:21:52.637
RESPOND. YES, AND PRACTICE
02:21:52.704 --> 02:21:54.172
NEARLY EVERY AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:21:54.239 --> 02:21:55.473
PROJECT AND SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
02:21:55.540 --> 02:21:56.507
PROJECT IS BUILT WITH UNION
02:21:56.574 --> 02:21:59.744
LABOR. AND THIS IS A COMBINATION
02:21:59.811 --> 02:22:02.280
OF THE TWO AND TO MY KNOWLEDGE
02:22:02.347 --> 02:22:03.214
OF SCHOOL DISTRICTS PAY
02:22:03.281 --> 02:22:04.449
PREVAILING WAGE. THAT DOESN'T
02:22:04.515 --> 02:22:07.585
MEAN THAT WE CAN'T DO BETTER, UM
02:22:07.652 --> 02:22:10.622
HOWEVER, IN IN IN THIS
02:22:10.688 --> 02:22:12.323
PARTICULAR WITH THIS PARTICULAR
02:22:12.390 --> 02:22:14.492
ISSUE, COMING TO A COMPROMISE
02:22:14.559 --> 02:22:16.327
HAS PROVEN PARTICULARLY
02:22:16.394 --> 02:22:19.797
DIFFICULT AND CHALLENGING. I'M
02:22:19.864 --> 02:22:21.733
UP FOR CONTINUING TO WORK ON
02:22:21.799 --> 02:22:23.001
THAT AND YOU HAVE MY COMMITMENT
02:22:23.067 --> 02:22:26.871
THAT I WILL PRETTY GOOD. UM WE
02:22:26.938 --> 02:22:29.274
DO HAVE MADE A MOTION RIGHT? OR
02:22:29.340 --> 02:22:31.009
YOU DIDN'T MAKE THE MOTIONS.
02:22:31.075 --> 02:22:32.744
OKAY JUST DIDN'T REMEMBER. IT'S
02:22:32.810 --> 02:22:34.279
A IT'S A LOW BLOD SUGAR. IT'S
02:22:34.345 --> 02:22:36.514
GETTING CLOSE TO NEW. I THINK
02:22:36.581 --> 02:22:38.216
THAT'S THE ISSUE RAISED BY
02:22:38.283 --> 02:22:40.418
SENATOR ASO IS A REAL ISSUE. UM,
02:22:40.485 --> 02:22:43.021
WE'RE IN IN THE PROCESS OF
02:22:43.087 --> 02:22:44.088
TRYING TO NEGOTIATE SOME
02:22:44.155 --> 02:22:45.657
AGREEMENTS ON A NUMBER OF BILLS
02:22:45.723 --> 02:22:47.425
AND SO HOPEFULLY WE CAN ACHIEVE
02:22:47.492 --> 02:22:50.962
THAT.KIND OF AGREEMENT AND WE
02:22:51.029 --> 02:22:53.031
CAN USE THEM IN THE BILLS MOVING
02:22:53.097 --> 02:22:54.766
FORWARD SO THAT WE'RE MAKING
02:22:54.832 --> 02:22:56.100
SURE WE'RE PROTECTING THE
02:22:56.167 --> 02:22:58.469
WORKERS AS WELL AS UM, PRODUCING
02:22:58.536 --> 02:23:00.371
A GOOD PRODUCT. SO I APPRECIATE
02:23:00.438 --> 02:23:01.506
, UM, COMMENTS WE'VE HAD ABOUT
02:23:01.572 --> 02:23:03.441
THAT. AND I DO APPRECIATE THE
02:23:03.508 --> 02:23:04.342
AMENDMENTS THAT YOU'VE THAT
02:23:04.409 --> 02:23:06.811
YOU'VE TAKEN TO, UM, MAKE SURE
02:23:06.878 --> 02:23:07.879
THAT THERE'S LOCAL CONTROL AND
02:23:07.946 --> 02:23:10.615
THAT THERE'S A WAY TO BE ABLE TO
02:23:10.682 --> 02:23:11.849
BUILD A HOUSING THAT REALLY, UM
02:23:11.916 --> 02:23:15.320
UM WORKS WELL WITHIN THE
02:23:15.386 --> 02:23:16.721
COMMUNITY THAT IT'S BEING BUILT
02:23:16.788 --> 02:23:18.990
IN AND SO APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR
02:23:19.057 --> 02:23:20.725
WORK ON THAT AND THANK YOU FOR
02:23:20.792 --> 02:23:22.660
THAT THOSE AMENDMENTS WILL BE
02:23:22.727 --> 02:23:23.995
TAKEN IN THE NEXT COMMITTEE WHEN
02:23:24.062 --> 02:23:25.863
WE WHEN WE GET THERE, SO I NEED
02:23:25.930 --> 02:23:27.065
EMOTION IF NOBODY'S WILLING TO
02:23:27.131 --> 02:23:30.034
MAKE IT NO, I'LL MAKE IT MYSELF
02:23:30.101 --> 02:23:32.136
, MADAM CHAIR OF YOUR SUPPORTIVE
02:23:32.203 --> 02:23:33.905
I WILL DO IT OUT OF DESPITE
02:23:33.972 --> 02:23:37.208
UNDERSTAND ISI TO YOU. UM OF
02:23:37.275 --> 02:23:39.277
COURSE TO THE INTENT OF THE
02:23:39.344 --> 02:23:41.145
OFFICE, SO I WILL MOVE WITH THAT
02:23:41.212 --> 02:23:42.981
CLEAR UNDERSTANDING FOR A FUTURE
02:23:43.047 --> 02:23:44.983
VOTES. THANKS THANK YOU. SO
02:23:45.049 --> 02:23:45.583
THERE IS A MOTION BY SENATOR
02:23:45.650 --> 02:23:49.988
DURAZO. UM. HAVE WE ALLOWED YOU
02:23:50.054 --> 02:23:53.625
TO CONCLUDE? I RESPECTFULLY ASK
02:23:53.691 --> 02:23:54.792
FOR YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU SO
02:23:54.859 --> 02:23:57.595
MUCH. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:23:57.662 --> 02:24:00.631
MOTION AS DO PASS, BUT FIRST BE
02:24:00.698 --> 02:24:01.599
RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:24:01.666 --> 02:24:03.634
HOUSING SENATORS CABALLERO
02:24:03.701 --> 02:24:05.536
CABALLERO. I NIELSEN THE BILL
02:24:05.603 --> 02:24:11.175
TODAY BUT RESERVED JUDGMENT.
02:24:11.242 --> 02:24:15.246
NELSON I DURAZO HERZBERG.
02:24:15.313 --> 02:24:19.250
WIENER. WIENER? AYE. BILL HAS
02:24:19.317 --> 02:24:20.785
FOUR VOTES WILL LEAVE IT ON
02:24:20.852 --> 02:24:22.387
CALL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
02:24:22.453 --> 02:24:28.626
MUCH SIMILAR MEMBER BONTA. AND.
02:24:28.693 --> 02:24:29.827
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THANK YOU SO%
02:24:29.894 --> 02:24:31.696
MUCH FOR YOUR PATIENTS. I KNOW
02:24:31.763 --> 02:24:33.031
YOU'VE BEEN SITTING THERE FOR A
02:24:33.097 --> 02:24:34.665
LONG TIME. THANK YOU APPRECIATE
02:24:34.732 --> 02:24:36.768
IT, AND I DIDN'T KNOW YOU NEEDED
02:24:36.834 --> 02:24:38.436
TO GET OUT OF HERE. SO WE'RE
02:24:38.503 --> 02:24:39.604
GONNA MAKE THIS AS EFFICIENT AS
02:24:39.670 --> 02:24:41.205
POSSIBLE. WE'LL START WITH FILE
02:24:41.272 --> 02:24:43.241
ADAM NUMBER 14 WHICH IS A B 23
02:24:43.307 --> 02:24:47.678
19. THANK YOU SO MUCH, MADAM
02:24:47.745 --> 02:24:51.282
CHAIR AND, UH, AND MEMBERS
02:24:51.349 --> 02:24:52.116
ACCEPT THE COMMITTEE'S
02:24:52.183 --> 02:24:55.186
AMENDMENTS. FIRST OFF A B 23 19
02:24:55.253 --> 02:24:56.521
IS A DISTRICT BILL SEEKING A
02:24:56.587 --> 02:24:57.789
SIMPLE FIX WITHIN A COMPLICATED
02:24:57.855 --> 02:25:01.225
ISSUE AREA. THE SURPLUS LAND ACT
02:25:01.292 --> 02:25:03.428
IN 1997. THE ALAMEDA NAVAL AIR
02:25:03.494 --> 02:25:05.363
STATION WAS CLOSED AS PART OF
02:25:05.430 --> 02:25:06.864
THE BASE REALIGNMENT AND CLOSURE
02:25:06.931 --> 02:25:08.733
PROCESS. IN THE FOLLOWING YEARS
02:25:08.800 --> 02:25:10.334
. GLENN NOW KNOWN AS ALAMEDA
02:25:10.401 --> 02:25:12.336
POINT WAS CONVEYED TO THE CITY
02:25:12.403 --> 02:25:13.738
OF ALAMEDA IN ACCORDANCE WITH
02:25:13.805 --> 02:25:14.505
THE FEDERALLY APPROVED REUSE
02:25:14.572 --> 02:25:17.175
PLAN. ADDITIONALLY THE CITY OF
02:25:17.241 --> 02:25:18.776
ALAMEDA ENTERED INTO ILLEGAL
02:25:18.843 --> 02:25:20.878
SETTLEMENT IN 2001 TO DEDICATE
02:25:20.945 --> 02:25:23.347
25% OF THE HOUSING ON ALAMEDA
02:25:23.414 --> 02:25:25.249
POINT AS PERMANENTLY AFFORDABLE
02:25:25.316 --> 02:25:26.517
TO VERY LOW, LOW AND MODERATE
02:25:26.584 --> 02:25:29.720
INCOME FAMILIES. UNFORTUNATELY
02:25:29.787 --> 02:25:31.255
WHILE THE DEVELOPMENT OF ALAMEDA
02:25:31.322 --> 02:25:33.624
POINT HAS OVERCOME LITIGATION
02:25:33.691 --> 02:25:35.726
AND A LOCAL BALLOT MEASURE
02:25:35.793 --> 02:25:36.461
RESEMBLING THE LITTLE ENGINE
02:25:36.527 --> 02:25:39.630
THAT COULD THE LATEST ROADBLOCK
02:25:39.697 --> 02:25:40.765
WAS THE WELL INTENTIONED
02:25:40.832 --> 02:25:42.333
AMENDMENTS TO THE SURPLUS LAND
02:25:42.400 --> 02:25:46.237
ACT IN A B 14 86 OF 2019.
02:25:46.304 --> 02:25:48.706
APPLYING THE SURPLUS LAND ACT TO
02:25:48.773 --> 02:25:49.507
ALAMEDA POINT HAS CAUSED FURTHER
02:25:49.574 --> 02:25:51.709
DELAYS TO PLANNED DEVELOPMENTS
02:25:51.776 --> 02:25:53.211
AND HAS CREATED UNCERTAINTY WITH
02:25:53.277 --> 02:25:55.179
REGARDS TO THE BUILDINGS LEASED
02:25:55.246 --> 02:25:57.248
OUT FOR COMMERCIAL ENTERPRISES.
02:25:57.315 --> 02:25:59.851
A B 23 19 WOULD PROVIDE A VERY
02:25:59.917 --> 02:26:01.986
NARROW EXEMPTION TO THE SURPLUS
02:26:02.053 --> 02:26:03.888
LAND ACT FOR ALAMEDA POINT AND
02:26:03.955 --> 02:26:05.389
IN SO DOING WOULD PROVIDE
02:26:05.456 --> 02:26:06.924
CLARITY AND A PATH FORWARD FOR
02:26:06.991 --> 02:26:07.558
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND ECONOMIC
02:26:07.625 --> 02:26:09.327
DEVELOPMENT FOR THE CITY OF
02:26:09.393 --> 02:26:12.096
ALAMEDA. I RECENTLY RECEIVED
02:26:12.163 --> 02:26:13.631
FEEDBACK FROM AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:26:13.698 --> 02:26:15.099
DEVELOPERS WHO WORK WITH REUNION
02:26:15.166 --> 02:26:16.834
HOPE, AND WE ARE CONSIDERING
02:26:16.901 --> 02:26:17.768
THEIR AMENDMENTS FOR SENATE
02:26:17.835 --> 02:26:20.104
HOUSING. ADDITIONALLY WE HAVE
02:26:20.171 --> 02:26:21.839
HAD PROMISING CONVERSATIONS WITH
02:26:21.906 --> 02:26:24.108
LABOR ON REAFFIRMING ALAMITOS
02:26:24.175 --> 02:26:25.610
EXISTING PROJECT STABILIZATION
02:26:25.676 --> 02:26:26.811
AGREEMENT ORDINANCE, WHICH
02:26:26.878 --> 02:26:27.945
ALREADY REQUIRES A PROJECT LABOR
02:26:28.012 --> 02:26:30.848
AGREEMENT. AND ONCE WE HAVE
02:26:30.915 --> 02:26:31.883
COMPLETED STAKEHOLDER CHECK INS
02:26:31.949 --> 02:26:33.751
. WE ARE ALSO CONSIDERING THE
02:26:33.818 --> 02:26:35.153
LANGUAGE FOR SENATE HOUSING.
02:26:35.219 --> 02:26:36.521
THANK YOU. AND AS WITNESSES ON
02:26:36.587 --> 02:26:38.756
THE PHONE TODAY, I HAVE LISA
02:26:38.823 --> 02:26:39.257
MAXWELL FROM COMMUNITY
02:26:39.323 --> 02:26:41.159
DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR FROM THE
02:26:41.225 --> 02:26:42.460
CITY OF ALAMEDA, AND DOUG BIGGS
02:26:42.527 --> 02:26:43.494
, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF ALAMEDA
02:26:43.561 --> 02:26:46.164
POINT COLLABORATIVE. VERY GOOD,
02:26:46.230 --> 02:26:49.267
UM, LEAST IF WE COULD START WITH
02:26:49.333 --> 02:26:50.334
LISA MAXWELL, WHO IS ON THE
02:26:50.401 --> 02:26:52.170
PHONE ACTUALLY BOTH ON THE
02:26:52.236 --> 02:26:54.172
PHONE, BUT WE'LL START WITH MISS
02:26:54.238 --> 02:26:55.173
MAXWELL FROM THE CITY OF
02:26:55.239 --> 02:26:59.610
ALAMEDA. THANK YOU. THIS IS LISA
02:26:59.677 --> 02:27:00.745
MAXWELL. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
02:27:00.811 --> 02:27:03.447
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR
02:27:03.514 --> 02:27:04.849
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY
02:27:04.916 --> 02:27:07.285
AND SUPPORT OF A B 2319 AS
02:27:07.351 --> 02:27:09.253
NOTICED. MY NAME IS LISA MAXWELL
02:27:09.320 --> 02:27:10.288
AND THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
02:27:10.354 --> 02:27:12.757
DIRECTOR OF THE CITY OF ALAMEDA.
02:27:12.823 --> 02:27:14.792
ELEMENT IT'S A SMALL ISLAND
02:27:14.859 --> 02:27:15.526
COMMUNITY IN THE SAN FRANCISCO
02:27:15.593 --> 02:27:17.428
BAY AREA THAT WAS HOME TO ENABLE
02:27:17.495 --> 02:27:20.164
STATION FROM 1940 TO 1997 THAT
02:27:20.231 --> 02:27:23.701
WE REFER TO AS ALAMEDA POINT.
02:27:23.768 --> 02:27:25.836
UPON THE CLOSURE OF THE NAVAL
02:27:25.903 --> 02:27:26.604
BASE. ALAMEDA ENTERED INTO
02:27:26.671 --> 02:27:28.739
NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE US MAYBE
02:27:28.806 --> 02:27:30.241
TO DETERMINE HOW THE LAND WOULD
02:27:30.308 --> 02:27:32.376
BE USED IF IT WERE TRANSFERRED
02:27:32.443 --> 02:27:33.945
TO THE CITY. THE RESULTS OF
02:27:34.011 --> 02:27:35.613
THESE NEGOTIATIONS FOR THE BASE
02:27:35.680 --> 02:27:37.815
WAS THE BASE REUSE PLAN THAT WAS
02:27:37.882 --> 02:27:38.616
APPROVED BY THE NAVY AND
02:27:38.683 --> 02:27:39.550
INCORPORATED INTO THE CONVEYANCE
02:27:39.617 --> 02:27:41.219
AGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE NAVY AND
02:27:41.285 --> 02:27:43.321
THE CITY. THE BASE FOR YOUTH
02:27:43.387 --> 02:27:45.256
PLANT REMAINS EFFECTIVE TODAY
02:27:45.323 --> 02:27:47.158
AND GOVERN ALAMEDA POINT
02:27:47.225 --> 02:27:49.827
PROPERTY. THE BASE REUSE PLAN TO
02:27:49.894 --> 02:27:51.629
REQUIRE ALAMEDA POINT PROPERTY
02:27:51.696 --> 02:27:53.130
TO BE USED TO CREATE A MIXED
02:27:53.197 --> 02:27:55.132
DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS, INCLUDING
02:27:55.199 --> 02:27:57.268
HOUSING COMMERCIAL USES TO SPUR
02:27:57.335 --> 02:27:58.903
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND OPEN
02:27:58.970 --> 02:28:00.571
SPACE. THE CITY HAS BEEN WORKING
02:28:00.638 --> 02:28:02.673
DILIGENTLY OF THE LAST 20 YEARS
02:28:02.740 --> 02:28:04.242
TO IMPLEMENT THE BASE FOR YOU TO
02:28:04.308 --> 02:28:06.644
PLAN AND DEVELOP ELEVATOR POINT.
02:28:06.711 --> 02:28:09.680
IN 2019 SURPLUS LANDS ACT IS
02:28:09.747 --> 02:28:11.115
AMENDED AS AN UNINTENDED
02:28:11.182 --> 02:28:13.517
CONSEQUENCE OF THIS AMENDMENT,
02:28:13.584 --> 02:28:15.620
THE FORMER NAVY MILITARY BASIS
02:28:15.686 --> 02:28:17.154
LIKE ALAMEDA POINT REMAINS
02:28:17.221 --> 02:28:18.823
SUBJECT TO THE SURPLUS LANDS ACT
02:28:18.889 --> 02:28:20.358
REQUIRING THE CITY THE POLICE
02:28:20.424 --> 02:28:22.260
ALAMEDA POINT PERSONAL THROUGH A
02:28:22.326 --> 02:28:24.128
TIME CONSUMING SURPLUS PROCESS.
02:28:24.195 --> 02:28:25.696
BEFORE FURTHER DEVELOPMENT CAN
02:28:25.763 --> 02:28:27.331
OCCUR. THE UNINTENDED
02:28:27.398 --> 02:28:29.634
CONSEQUENCE IS MATERIALS BECAUSE
02:28:29.700 --> 02:28:30.401
THE LAND THAT WAS TRANSFERRED TO
02:28:30.468 --> 02:28:32.370
THE CITY FROM THE NAVY IS NOT
02:28:32.436 --> 02:28:34.272
SURPLUS LAND OR WHICH THE CITY
02:28:34.338 --> 02:28:37.008
HAS NO USE. INSTEAD THE ALAMEDA
02:28:37.074 --> 02:28:38.576
POINT LAND IS ALREADY SUBJECT TO
02:28:38.643 --> 02:28:40.177
A LEGALLY BINDING AGREEMENT WITH
02:28:40.244 --> 02:28:42.780
THE NAVY IN PLACE AND THE YEAR
02:28:42.847 --> 02:28:44.048
2000 AND PLAN FOR USE CONSISTENT
02:28:44.115 --> 02:28:46.884
WITH THE BASE THREE. REVIEWS
02:28:46.951 --> 02:28:48.019
PLAIN AND IN FURTHERANCE OF
02:28:48.085 --> 02:28:50.855
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT. REVENUE
02:28:50.921 --> 02:28:52.490
GENERATED BY SALES AND LEASING
02:28:52.556 --> 02:28:53.924
AN ELEMENT OF POINT ALLOWS FOR
02:28:53.991 --> 02:28:55.459
CONTINUED DEVELOPMENT. THE
02:28:55.526 --> 02:28:57.161
AMENDMENT OF THE SURPLUS LANDS
02:28:57.228 --> 02:28:57.762
ACT HAS DRAMATICALLY SOLVED
02:28:57.828 --> 02:28:58.863
SALES AND LEASING AN ALAMEDA
02:28:58.929 --> 02:29:02.099
POINT. THUS DERAILING THE CITY'S
02:29:02.166 --> 02:29:04.435
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT EFFORT. IN
02:29:04.502 --> 02:29:06.537
FACT, AMENDMENT OF THE SURPLUS
02:29:06.604 --> 02:29:09.540
LANDS BACK AND DURING 2020 NO
02:29:09.607 --> 02:29:10.975
BUILDINGS AT ALAMEDA POINT FOR
02:29:11.042 --> 02:29:12.143
ASSAULT AND LEASING ACTIVITY WAS
02:29:12.209 --> 02:29:14.879
MINIMAL. IT'S IMPORTANT TO NOTE
02:29:14.945 --> 02:29:16.480
THAT ALL HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS
02:29:16.547 --> 02:29:18.215
THAT WILL BE A POINT MUST
02:29:18.282 --> 02:29:19.317
INCLUDE A TOTAL OF 25%
02:29:19.383 --> 02:29:21.719
AFFORDABLE UNITS. THIS
02:29:21.786 --> 02:29:23.254
REQUIREMENT HAS BEEN IN HERE TO
02:29:23.321 --> 02:29:24.722
CONSISTENTLY SINCE THE
02:29:24.789 --> 02:29:26.757
DEVELOPMENT BEGAN. THE TESTIMONY
02:29:26.824 --> 02:29:28.259
HAVE DONE THINGS FOR THE
02:29:28.326 --> 02:29:29.126
ELEVATOR POINT COLLABORATIVE
02:29:29.193 --> 02:29:31.362
WILL PROVIDE JUST ONE EXAMPLE OF
02:29:31.429 --> 02:29:32.263
THE NEGATIVE IMPACT OF THIS
02:29:32.330 --> 02:29:35.499
LEGISLATION. LEGISLATIVE CHANGE.
02:29:35.566 --> 02:29:37.435
THAT HAD ON THE HOUSING NEEDS OF
02:29:37.501 --> 02:29:37.935
RESIDENTS, PARTICULARLY
02:29:38.002 --> 02:29:40.738
VULNERABLE RESIDENTS OF ALAMEDA.
02:29:40.805 --> 02:29:43.507
MAYBE 2 TO 319 CREATES A VERY
02:29:43.574 --> 02:29:45.209
NARROW ASSUMPTION IN THE SURPLUS
02:29:45.276 --> 02:29:46.744
LANDS BACK TO ADDRESS THESE
02:29:46.811 --> 02:29:49.080
ISSUES SOLELY FOR THE CITY OF
02:29:49.146 --> 02:29:50.448
ALAMEDA. NARROW EXCEPTION IS
02:29:50.514 --> 02:29:51.882
NECESSARY FOR THE DEVELOPMENT.
02:29:51.949 --> 02:29:53.017
ALAMEDA POINT CONTINUE
02:29:53.084 --> 02:29:54.085
UNHAMPERED AND WITHOUT FURTHER
02:29:54.151 --> 02:29:57.455
DELAY. AS NOTED THE CITY IS
02:29:57.521 --> 02:29:58.923
CONTRACTUALLY OBLIGATED TO
02:29:58.989 --> 02:30:00.491
ADHERE TO THE BASIC REUSED
02:30:00.558 --> 02:30:02.727
PLANNED WITH THE NAVY AND TO
02:30:02.793 --> 02:30:03.594
PURSUE DEVELOPMENT AND ELEVATED
02:30:03.661 --> 02:30:05.162
POINT. WITHOUT THIS NARROW
02:30:05.229 --> 02:30:07.264
EXEMPTION, THE CITY MUST CHOOSE
02:30:07.331 --> 02:30:08.532
BETWEEN VIOLATING ITS CONTRACT
02:30:08.599 --> 02:30:09.667
WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT OR
02:30:09.734 --> 02:30:12.269
VIOLATING STATE LAW. NEITHER OF
02:30:12.336 --> 02:30:14.372
WHICH IS AN APPEALING OPTION.
02:30:14.438 --> 02:30:15.740
FOR THESE REASONS. I
02:30:15.806 --> 02:30:16.941
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR A VOTE
02:30:17.007 --> 02:30:20.344
ON A B 2319. THANK YOU. THANK
02:30:20.411 --> 02:30:21.712
YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
02:30:21.779 --> 02:30:23.414
. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO DOUG
02:30:23.481 --> 02:30:25.383
DOUG BIGGS, WHO IS THE ELEMENT?
02:30:25.449 --> 02:30:26.417
ALAMEDA POINT COLLABORATIVE. LET
02:30:26.484 --> 02:30:30.821
ME JUST SAY THAT, UM AH, THE
02:30:30.888 --> 02:30:32.356
THIS ENJOYS AND I
02:30:32.423 --> 02:30:34.725
RECOMMENDATIONS AND THE
02:30:34.792 --> 02:30:36.293
TESTIMONY FROM LISA MAXWELL WAS
02:30:36.360 --> 02:30:38.996
PRETTY THOROUGH. UM SO I DON'T
02:30:39.063 --> 02:30:40.398
WANT TO DISCOURAGE YOU. I KNOW
02:30:40.464 --> 02:30:42.266
YOU'VE BEEN WAITING ON THE LINE,
02:30:42.333 --> 02:30:44.168
BUT I JUST WANT TO, UM, MAKE
02:30:44.235 --> 02:30:45.736
SURE THAT I CAN GET THE ASSEMBLY
02:30:45.803 --> 02:30:47.872
MEMBER MOVING ON HER WAY. SHE'S
02:30:47.938 --> 02:30:48.873
GOT ANOTHER BILL AS WELL. SO,
02:30:48.939 --> 02:30:53.644
UM, DOUG BAGS. THANK YOU VERY
02:30:53.711 --> 02:30:56.113
MUCH, MADAM CHAIR AND COMMITTEE-MEMBERS. MY NAME STUD BIG
02:30:56.180 --> 02:30:57.381
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
02:30:57.448 --> 02:30:59.216
ALAMEDA POINT COLLABORATIVE, AND
02:30:59.283 --> 02:31:00.418
JUST IN THE INTEREST OF TIME
02:31:00.484 --> 02:31:02.286
INTO SOME OF ABC IS SUPPORTIVE
02:31:02.353 --> 02:31:03.687
HOUSING PROGRAMS. THAT WAS
02:31:03.754 --> 02:31:06.357
CREATED OUT OF THE CLOSURE OF
02:31:06.424 --> 02:31:07.491
THE NAVAL AIR FACING BACK IN THE
02:31:07.558 --> 02:31:09.627
MID NINETIES. UM WE HAVE BUILT A
02:31:09.693 --> 02:31:11.162
NURTURING COMMUNITY SERVING 500
02:31:11.228 --> 02:31:11.829
, FORMERLY HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS,
02:31:11.896 --> 02:31:15.466
ALL NAVY HOUSING. AND FACILITIES
02:31:15.533 --> 02:31:17.735
, BUT IT'S TIME TO REBUILD POWER
02:31:17.802 --> 02:31:19.203
OUTAGES. WATER AND THROUGH
02:31:19.270 --> 02:31:20.905
REMAIN FAILURES ARE ALL TOO
02:31:20.971 --> 02:31:21.505
COMMON WITH ALAMEDA POINT. WE
02:31:21.572 --> 02:31:23.941
BELIEVE ALLEN AND, UM BECAUSE OF
02:31:24.008 --> 02:31:30.614
THE SLR AMENDMENT. UM. THE
02:31:30.681 --> 02:31:31.348
CARVING DELAYS, THE QUALITY OF
02:31:31.415 --> 02:31:33.117
LIFE OF THE COLLABORATIVE COULD
02:31:33.184 --> 02:31:34.452
OFFER THE HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS.
02:31:34.518 --> 02:31:36.387
IS IMPACTED AS THE OLD HOUSING
02:31:36.454 --> 02:31:38.155
CONTINUED TO DETERIORATE AND
02:31:38.222 --> 02:31:38.722
CONSTRUCTION OF NEIGHBORING
02:31:38.789 --> 02:31:41.192
SERVICES AND RETAIL TO SERVE AN
02:31:41.258 --> 02:31:42.927
EMPLOYER RESIDENTS IS NOW
02:31:42.993 --> 02:31:44.195
STALLED. FOR THESE REASONS. WE
02:31:44.261 --> 02:31:45.529
STRONGLY SUPPORT THE SWIFT
02:31:45.596 --> 02:31:47.798
ENACTMENT OF A B 23 19. TO
02:31:47.865 --> 02:31:49.300
EXEMPT ALAMEDA POINT FROM THE S
02:31:49.366 --> 02:31:51.402
L A SO THAT DEVELOPMENT CAN
02:31:51.469 --> 02:31:52.970
CONTINUE WITH THE COLLABORATIVE
02:31:53.037 --> 02:31:54.805
, THE BEST SERVE ALAMEDA.
02:31:54.872 --> 02:31:55.406
VULNERABLE COMMUNITY MEMBERS.
02:31:55.473 --> 02:31:56.974
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE TIME
02:31:57.041 --> 02:31:58.709
TODAY. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:31:58.776 --> 02:32:00.244
TESTIMONY. APPRECIATE IT VERY
02:32:00.311 --> 02:32:01.812
MUCH TO SEE IF THERE ARE
02:32:01.879 --> 02:32:03.380
WITNESSES IN SUPPORT OF THIS
02:32:03.447 --> 02:32:06.283
BILL IN ROOM 2200. IF SO, PLEASE
02:32:06.350 --> 02:32:07.451
COME FORWARD AND STATE YOUR NAME
02:32:07.518 --> 02:32:10.654
FOR THE RECORD. MADAM CHAIR AND
02:32:10.721 --> 02:32:12.723
MEMBERS MIKE WEST ON BEHALF OF
02:32:12.790 --> 02:32:13.591
THE STATE BUILDING AND
02:32:13.657 --> 02:32:14.992
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL WERE
02:32:15.059 --> 02:32:15.860
ALSO ENCOURAGED BY THE RECENT
02:32:15.926 --> 02:32:17.394
DIALOGUE BETWEEN THE MEMBER AND
02:32:17.461 --> 02:32:19.530
THE BUILDING TRADES. WE LOOK
02:32:19.597 --> 02:32:20.164
FORWARD TO SEEING THOSE
02:32:20.231 --> 02:32:21.732
AMENDMENTS IN PRINT, AT WHICH
02:32:21.799 --> 02:32:23.000
TIME WE WOULD REMOVE OUR
02:32:23.067 --> 02:32:23.567
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. VERY
02:32:23.634 --> 02:32:25.069
GOOD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OR
02:32:25.135 --> 02:32:28.005
ANYONE ELSE. IS WE'RE GOING TO
02:32:28.072 --> 02:32:29.840
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
02:32:29.907 --> 02:32:31.575
LINE AND ASK IF THERE'S ANYBODY
02:32:31.642 --> 02:32:33.944
IN SUPPORT OF THE OF THE BILL ON
02:32:34.011 --> 02:32:37.414
THE LINE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT,
02:32:37.481 --> 02:32:38.549
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
02:32:38.616 --> 02:32:49.627
YOUR PHONE. PRESS ONE AND ZERO.
02:32:49.693 --> 02:32:52.096
I HAVE NO ONE IN Q. VERY GOOD.
02:32:52.162 --> 02:32:53.564
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO
02:32:53.631 --> 02:32:54.431
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. THERE ARE
02:32:54.498 --> 02:32:56.567
NO LEAD OPPOSITION WITNESSES ON
02:32:56.634 --> 02:32:58.869
THIS BILL. WE'LL SEE IF THERE'S
02:32:58.936 --> 02:32:59.970
ANYBODY IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM
02:33:00.037 --> 02:33:01.071
THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:33:01.138 --> 02:33:02.573
OPPOSITION. SEEING THEN WE'LL
02:33:02.640 --> 02:33:04.475
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
02:33:04.542 --> 02:33:05.843
LINE. IF YOU COULD CHECK AND SEE
02:33:05.910 --> 02:33:07.678
IF THERE'S ANYBODY ON THE
02:33:07.745 --> 02:33:08.746
CONFERENCE LINE THAT WANTS TO
02:33:08.812 --> 02:33:11.282
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. SPEAKING
02:33:11.348 --> 02:33:12.249
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS ONE,
02:33:12.316 --> 02:33:17.922
THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. PRESS
02:33:17.988 --> 02:33:25.996
ONE AND ZERO. AND THAT HAVE NO
02:33:26.063 --> 02:33:28.065
ONE IN Q. VERY GOOD. WE'RE GOING
02:33:28.132 --> 02:33:29.567
TO BRING THIS BACK TO THE
02:33:29.633 --> 02:33:31.001
COMMITTEE AND SEE IF THERE ARE
02:33:31.068 --> 02:33:32.570
ANY QUESTIONS. UM I DON'T SEE
02:33:32.636 --> 02:33:34.338
ANY OF FRANKLY, I THINK THAT A
02:33:34.405 --> 02:33:35.406
BROADER EXCEPTION FOR ALL OF
02:33:35.472 --> 02:33:38.075
THEM REUSED. BASIS PROBABLY MADE
02:33:38.142 --> 02:33:40.244
A LOT OF SENSE, BUT I APPRECIATE
02:33:40.311 --> 02:33:42.046
WHAT YOU'RE DOING HERE AND UM,
02:33:42.112 --> 02:33:44.515
IT'S TOO BAD THAT IT GOT CAUGHT
02:33:44.582 --> 02:33:48.619
UP IN THIS, UM, SURPLUS LAND.
02:33:48.686 --> 02:33:50.721
THESE BASE REUSES REQUIRED HAVE
02:33:50.788 --> 02:33:52.122
A WHOLE BUNCH OF REQUIREMENTS
02:33:52.189 --> 02:33:53.824
WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, SO
02:33:53.891 --> 02:33:56.860
TO ADD A LAYER OF STATE UM,
02:33:56.927 --> 02:33:59.730
OVERSIGHT AND REQUIREMENTS WHEN
02:33:59.797 --> 02:34:01.465
THEY ALSO INCLUDE AFFORDABLE
02:34:01.532 --> 02:34:04.268
HOUSING DOESN'T SEEM TO MAKE A
02:34:04.335 --> 02:34:05.369
LOT OF SENSE. SO I REALLY
02:34:05.436 --> 02:34:06.604
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
02:34:06.670 --> 02:34:08.339
FORWARD. AND UM THIS THIS
02:34:08.405 --> 02:34:09.306
PROJECT IS A REALLY IMPORTANT
02:34:09.373 --> 02:34:10.374
PROJECT FOR ALAMEDA. SO I DO
02:34:10.441 --> 02:34:13.877
APPRECIATE THAT. UM WHAT? I NEED
02:34:13.944 --> 02:34:16.747
TO WAIT UNTIL WE GET SOME OF IT.
02:34:16.814 --> 02:34:17.948
UM SENATOR NIELSEN. ARE YOU
02:34:18.015 --> 02:34:20.117
WILLING TO MAKE THE MOTION HE
02:34:20.184 --> 02:34:21.452
WILL MAKE THE MOTION. THANK YOU
02:34:21.518 --> 02:34:24.555
SO MUCH. UM THE MOTION IS DUE
02:34:24.622 --> 02:34:26.690
PASS, BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
02:34:26.757 --> 02:34:27.524
THE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND
02:34:27.591 --> 02:34:29.159
THAT'S WHERE YOU'LL TAKE THAT
02:34:29.226 --> 02:34:29.693
ANY AMENDMENTS. TECHNICAL
02:34:29.760 --> 02:34:31.195
AMENDMENTS. SO THANK YOU SO
02:34:31.261 --> 02:34:37.735
MUCH. UM, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:34:37.801 --> 02:34:39.803
OH I THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
02:34:39.870 --> 02:34:42.806
THIS IS A GEM OF A PROJECT AND
02:34:42.873 --> 02:34:44.908
WILL REALLY ENABLE THE CITY OF
02:34:44.975 --> 02:34:46.110
ALAMEDA TO MEET ITS AFFORDABLE
02:34:46.176 --> 02:34:48.579
HOUSING. GOALS AND I VERY MUCH
02:34:48.646 --> 02:34:51.181
APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR COMMENTS
02:34:51.248 --> 02:34:52.616
ABOUT THE NEED TO MORE BROADLY
02:34:52.683 --> 02:34:54.418
REFORM THIS SURPLUS LAND ACT.
02:34:54.485 --> 02:34:55.853
THANK YOU SO MUCH. PLEASE CALL
02:34:55.919 --> 02:34:59.757
THE RULE. MOTION IS PASSED, BUT
02:34:59.823 --> 02:35:01.291
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:35:01.358 --> 02:35:03.661
COMMITTEE ON HOUSING CAVALLERO,
02:35:03.727 --> 02:35:06.597
Hí
02:35:06.664 --> 02:35:10.901
SO I HERTZBERG WIENER. BILL HAS
02:35:10.968 --> 02:35:14.038
THREE VOTES AND WILL KEEP THE
02:35:14.104 --> 02:35:17.241
ROLE OPEN FOR THE MISSING.
02:35:17.307 --> 02:35:20.110
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FILE ITEM
02:35:20.177 --> 02:35:23.747
NUMBER 15 A B 28 80 YES, 28 80.
02:35:23.814 --> 02:35:29.586
UM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TH<c.cyan> ME.</c>
02:35:29.653 --> 02:35:31.822
PROCEED THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
02:35:31.889 --> 02:35:33.290
AND MEMBERS. I WOULD LIKE TO
02:35:33.357 --> 02:35:34.324
START BY ACCEPTING THE
02:35:34.391 --> 02:35:36.260
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS. A B 28
02:35:36.326 --> 02:35:37.761
80 WILL PROVIDE IMPORTANT
02:35:37.828 --> 02:35:38.762
SUPPLEMENTAL FUNDING FOR CAL
02:35:38.829 --> 02:35:41.365
GRANTS. BY USING VOLUNTARY
02:35:41.432 --> 02:35:42.900
CONTRIBUTIONS AND STATE TAX
02:35:42.966 --> 02:35:46.103
CREDITS SPECIFICALLY, 28 80
02:35:46.170 --> 02:35:47.538
WOULD EXTEND THE COLLEGE ACCESS
02:35:47.604 --> 02:35:48.872
TAX CREDIT FUNDS. SUNSET DATE
02:35:48.939 --> 02:35:52.042
FROM 2023 TO 2028 ALLOW THE
02:35:52.109 --> 02:35:53.377
CALIFORNIA EDUCATIONAL
02:35:53.444 --> 02:35:54.878
FACILITIES AUTHORITY TO CONDUCT
02:35:54.945 --> 02:35:56.447
OUTREACH AND MARKETING TO
02:35:56.513 --> 02:35:57.548
INCREASE SUBSCRIPTION TO MAKE
02:35:57.614 --> 02:35:59.750
THE PROGRAM WORKS IS SUCCESSFUL.
02:35:59.817 --> 02:36:01.819
THE FUND ALLOWS INDIVIDUALS,
02:36:01.885 --> 02:36:02.820
INSURANCE COMPANIES AND
02:36:02.886 --> 02:36:05.155
BUSINESSES TO CLAIM A TAX CREDIT
02:36:05.222 --> 02:36:07.257
EQUAL TO 50% OF THEIR CHARITABLE
02:36:07.324 --> 02:36:09.693
CONTRIBUTIONS MADE TO THE FUND
02:36:09.760 --> 02:36:10.761
CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FUND. GO
02:36:10.828 --> 02:36:12.262
TOWARDS CALGARY. AUNT BEE WHICH
02:36:12.329 --> 02:36:14.164
CAN BE USED BY STUDENTS TO HELP
02:36:14.231 --> 02:36:14.898
COVER LIVING EXPENSES,
02:36:14.965 --> 02:36:17.201
TRANSORTATION COSTS, SUPPLIES
02:36:17.267 --> 02:36:19.269
AND BOOKS, EXTENDING THE SUNSET
02:36:19.336 --> 02:36:20.738
DATE FOR THE CALIPH COLLEGE
02:36:20.804 --> 02:36:21.805
ACCESS TAX CREDIT FUND MEANS
02:36:21.872 --> 02:36:23.807
MORE TIME FOR TAXPAYERS TO LEARN
02:36:23.874 --> 02:36:25.576
ABOUT THE FUND. AND STUDENTS
02:36:25.642 --> 02:36:27.144
WILL BE ABLE TO RECEIVE HIGHER
02:36:27.211 --> 02:36:29.413
CALDERON DOLLARS AWARDS. THANK
02:36:29.480 --> 02:36:30.948
YOU. AND AS WITNESSES WITH ME
02:36:31.014 --> 02:36:32.483
TODAY, I HAVE CONNIE CHAN,
02:36:32.549 --> 02:36:33.350
TESTIFYING WITH THE OFFICE OF
02:36:33.417 --> 02:36:35.619
STATE TREASURER FIONA MÀ. A
02:36:35.686 --> 02:36:37.254
SPONSOR OF THE BILL, AND FRANK
02:36:37.321 --> 02:36:38.422
MOORE, THE DIRECTOR OF
02:36:38.489 --> 02:36:40.157
CALIFORNIA EDUCATIONAL
02:36:40.224 --> 02:36:41.425
FACILITIES. AUTHORITIES IS
02:36:41.492 --> 02:36:42.860
AVAILABLE FOR TECHNICAL
02:36:42.926 --> 02:36:44.294
ASSISTANCE SHOULD WE NEED IT?
02:36:44.361 --> 02:36:45.429
AND IF THE COMMITTEE HAS ANY
02:36:45.496 --> 02:36:46.797
QUESTIONS ABOUT THE PROGRAM
02:36:46.864 --> 02:36:48.599
THANK YOU VERY MUCH WELCOME.
02:36:48.665 --> 02:36:51.401
HELLO MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
02:36:51.468 --> 02:36:52.669
THE COMMITTEE. I AM CONNIE CHAN,
02:36:52.736 --> 02:36:53.637
LEGISLATIVE ANALYST FOR THE
02:36:53.704 --> 02:36:56.006
STATE TREASURER. SPONSORS OF
02:36:56.073 --> 02:36:57.608
THIS LEGISLATION IN OUR CAPACITY
02:36:57.674 --> 02:36:59.243
AS THE CHAIR OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:36:59.309 --> 02:37:00.144
EDUCATION FACILITIES AUTHORITY
02:37:00.210 --> 02:37:03.914
BOARD, ALSO KNOWN AS CIFA. SB 1
02:37:03.981 --> 02:37:08.252
74 AND SB 7 98 CHAPTERS IN 2014
02:37:08.318 --> 02:37:09.453
AUTHORIZED A STATE TAX CREDIT
02:37:09.520 --> 02:37:11.889
BASED ON A PERCENTAGE OF A
02:37:11.955 --> 02:37:12.890
TAXPAYERS CONTRIBUTION TO THE
02:37:12.956 --> 02:37:15.759
CALIPH TO THE COLLEGE ACCESS TAX
02:37:15.826 --> 02:37:18.162
CREDIT FUND TO OFFSET EVER
02:37:18.228 --> 02:37:20.297
INCREASING COLLEGE INTUITION.
02:37:20.364 --> 02:37:22.666
THEN IN 2017 84 90 EXTENDED THIS
02:37:22.733 --> 02:37:23.967
TAX CREDIT THROUGH TAXABLE YEAR.
02:37:24.034 --> 02:37:27.604
2022 COW GRANTS ARE AWARDED TO
02:37:27.671 --> 02:37:28.872
STUDENTS PURSUING UNDERGRADUATE
02:37:28.939 --> 02:37:31.408
VOCATIONAL OR CAREER TRAINING.
02:37:31.475 --> 02:37:33.343
QUALIFYING CALIFORNIA COLLEGE OF
02:37:33.410 --> 02:37:34.511
FAMILY INCOME AND ASSETS BELOW
02:37:34.578 --> 02:37:38.282
SET MINIMUM. LEVELS.
02:37:38.348 --> 02:37:41.084
SPECIFICALLY THE FINE GOES TO
02:37:41.151 --> 02:37:42.753
CAL GRANT BE ACCESS AWARDS AND
02:37:42.820 --> 02:37:43.620
CAL GRANTS INCLUDE BOTH
02:37:43.687 --> 02:37:44.555
ENTITLEMENT AND COMPETITIVE
02:37:44.621 --> 02:37:49.059
AWARDS. IN TAXABLE YEAR 2018 AS
02:37:49.126 --> 02:37:51.028
A RESULT OF FEDERAL TAX CODE
02:37:51.094 --> 02:37:52.029
CHANGES. CONTRIBUTIONS ROSE
02:37:52.095 --> 02:37:54.164
DRAMATICALLY AS TAXPAYERS SOUGHT
02:37:54.231 --> 02:37:55.933
TO GET THEIR APPLICATIONS IN
02:37:55.999 --> 02:37:57.367
BEFORE THE LAW MADE IT MORE
02:37:57.434 --> 02:37:58.535
DIFFICULT TO CLAIM A DEDUCTION
02:37:58.602 --> 02:38:00.804
FOR CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS. IN
02:38:00.871 --> 02:38:02.739
TAXABLE YEARS, 2019
02:38:02.806 --> 02:38:04.107
CONTRIBUTIONS FELT ABRUPTLY, BUT
02:38:04.174 --> 02:38:06.009
SINCE THAT YEAR HAS STEADILY
02:38:06.076 --> 02:38:09.813
INCREASED THE FINAL DEADLINE TO
02:38:09.880 --> 02:38:12.349
SUBMIT APPLICATIONS IS GENEROUS
02:38:12.416 --> 02:38:16.987
. 2ND 2023 ON DECEMBER 1ST 2023
02:38:17.054 --> 02:38:19.389
. THE PROGRAM WILL BE REPEALED.
02:38:19.456 --> 02:38:20.991
THIS BILL EXTENDS THE PROGRAM
02:38:21.058 --> 02:38:21.792
FOR ANOTHER FIVE YEARS TO
02:38:21.859 --> 02:38:25.462
DECEMBER. 1ST 2028 WITH THE
02:38:25.529 --> 02:38:26.530
AMENDMENTS GIVES FIFA THE
02:38:26.597 --> 02:38:27.798
ABILITY TO CONDUCT OUTREACH FOR
02:38:27.865 --> 02:38:31.368
THE PROGRAM. AS WE CONTINUE TO
02:38:31.435 --> 02:38:32.836
SEE THE FINANCIAL RAMIFICATIONS
02:38:32.903 --> 02:38:34.171
FROM THE PANDEMIC, WE MUST
02:38:34.238 --> 02:38:35.973
ENSURE THAT WE NOT ONLY HAVE
02:38:36.039 --> 02:38:37.608
EVERY TOOLKIT AT OUR DISPOSAL TO
02:38:37.674 --> 02:38:38.642
HELP STUDENTS ACHIEVE THEIR
02:38:38.709 --> 02:38:40.711
HIGHER EDUCATION ASPIRATIONS.
02:38:40.777 --> 02:38:42.846
STRENGTHEN THE TOOLS THAT WE DO
02:38:42.913 --> 02:38:44.014
HAVE TO ACHIEVE MAXIMUM
02:38:44.081 --> 02:38:46.383
POTENTIAL SUCCESS FOR THESE
02:38:46.450 --> 02:38:47.851
REASONS. THE TREASURER'S
02:38:47.918 --> 02:38:49.186
PRACTICE SPONSOR 28 80, AND
02:38:49.253 --> 02:38:52.723
THINK THAT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:38:52.789 --> 02:38:54.858
BANTA FOR THEIR LEADERSHIP WITH
02:38:54.925 --> 02:38:57.027
ME IS FRANK MORE CIFA, EXECUTIVE
02:38:57.094 --> 02:38:58.395
DIRECTOR FOR TECHNICAL AND
02:38:58.462 --> 02:38:59.863
PROGRAMMING QUESTIONS. THANKS
02:38:59.930 --> 02:39:01.632
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
02:39:01.698 --> 02:39:04.301
SO IT FOR TECHNICAL QUESTIONS. I
02:39:04.368 --> 02:39:05.702
HOPE SOMEBODY HAS SOME REALLY
02:39:05.769 --> 02:39:07.271
GOOD TECHNICAL QUESTIONS TO ASK
02:39:07.337 --> 02:39:09.539
YOU. BUT IF YOU'D LIKE TO SAY A
02:39:09.606 --> 02:39:11.508
FEW WORDS, PLEASE. NOTHING TO
02:39:11.575 --> 02:39:12.609
ADD OTHER THAN I BELIEVE THAT
02:39:12.676 --> 02:39:14.645
THE ABILITY FOR US TO CONDUCT
02:39:14.711 --> 02:39:15.679
OUTREACH AND MARKETING WILL
02:39:15.746 --> 02:39:16.680
GREATLY INCREASE THE FUND
02:39:16.747 --> 02:39:18.749
BALANCE FOR THIS FUND. GREAT.
02:39:18.815 --> 02:39:20.517
THANK YOU SO MUCH. SO WE'RE
02:39:20.584 --> 02:39:21.718
GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY
02:39:21.785 --> 02:39:23.320
ELSE IN ROOM 2200 THAT WOULD
02:39:23.387 --> 02:39:24.488
LIKE TO TESTIFY. INTO PART OF
02:39:24.554 --> 02:39:27.891
THE BILL. SEEING NONE WILL MOVE
02:39:27.958 --> 02:39:29.259
ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE LINE.
02:39:29.326 --> 02:39:30.961
IF YOU COULD PROMPT ANYONE WHO
02:39:31.028 --> 02:39:32.296
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
02:39:32.362 --> 02:39:38.735
OF A B 28 28 80. THANK YOU TO
02:39:38.802 --> 02:39:40.504
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF ÁP 28 88,
02:39:40.570 --> 02:39:42.406
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
02:39:42.472 --> 02:39:50.414
YOUR PHONE. PLEASE PRESS ONE
02:39:50.480 --> 02:39:58.622
THAN ZERO. AND I HAVE NO ONE IN
02:39:58.689 --> 02:40:01.191
Q. VERY GOOD. WE'LL MOVE ON TO
02:40:01.258 --> 02:40:02.859
OPPOSITION. WE HAVE NO LEAD
02:40:02.926 --> 02:40:04.695
OPPOSITION WITNESSES LISTED TO
02:40:04.761 --> 02:40:05.896
SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM
02:40:05.963 --> 02:40:07.998
2200 THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
02:40:08.065 --> 02:40:10.500
OPPOSITION OF THIS BILL. SAYING
02:40:10.567 --> 02:40:11.835
NO ONE WILL MOVE TO THE
02:40:11.902 --> 02:40:13.770
TELECONFERENCE LINE TO SEE IF
02:40:13.837 --> 02:40:14.871
THERE'S ANYONE THAT WOULD LIKE
02:40:14.938 --> 02:40:18.308
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. TO
02:40:18.375 --> 02:40:19.843
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. PLEASE
02:40:19.910 --> 02:40:21.745
PRESS 10 ON YOUR PHONE AT THIS
02:40:21.812 --> 02:40:31.621
TIME. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO.
02:40:31.688 --> 02:40:35.325
AND I HAVE NO ONE IN QUÊ. VERY
02:40:35.392 --> 02:40:37.995
GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO BRING IT
02:40:38.061 --> 02:40:39.062
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
02:40:39.129 --> 02:40:43.734
COMMENTS QUESTIONS. A MOTION.
02:40:43.800 --> 02:40:47.704
THEIR SENATOR DURAZO MOVES. BY
02:40:47.771 --> 02:40:49.339
NO. THAT WOULD BE VERY, VERY
02:40:49.406 --> 02:40:51.775
DIFFICULT. OBVIOUSLY THE MOTION
02:40:51.842 --> 02:40:54.745
IS DO DO PASS AS AMENDED, BUT
02:40:54.811 --> 02:40:57.214
FIRST AMENDED AND RE REFERRED TO
02:40:57.280 --> 02:40:58.148
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
02:40:58.215 --> 02:41:00.350
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS
02:41:00.417 --> 02:41:02.719
BEFORE WORD. IT'S IMPORTANT, UM,
02:41:02.786 --> 02:41:07.591
AND SUPPORT IT, AND, UH, WOULD.
02:41:07.657 --> 02:41:08.759
WITH THAT I'D ALLOW YOU TO
02:41:08.825 --> 02:41:12.229
CONCLUDE. THANK YOU SO MUCH,
02:41:12.295 --> 02:41:14.197
MADAM CHAIR THIS WOULD ALLOW FOR
02:41:14.264 --> 02:41:15.665
OUR CONTINUED ABILITY TO ENSURE
02:41:15.732 --> 02:41:17.768
THAT STUDENTS HAVE THE ABILITY
02:41:17.834 --> 02:41:19.336
TO FALL FUND THE FULL COST OF
02:41:19.403 --> 02:41:20.804
ATTENDANCE OF COLLEGE AS WE
02:41:20.871 --> 02:41:22.439
SHOULD BE DOING IN THE STATE OF
02:41:22.506 --> 02:41:23.473
CALIFORNIA. AND WITH THAT, I
02:41:23.540 --> 02:41:24.474
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I
02:41:24.541 --> 02:41:26.777
VOTE. THANK YOU SO MUCH AGAIN.
02:41:26.843 --> 02:41:28.378
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSES
02:41:28.445 --> 02:41:29.679
AMENDED, BUT FIRST AMENDED AND
02:41:29.746 --> 02:41:30.947
RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:41:31.014 --> 02:41:31.915
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
02:41:31.982 --> 02:41:35.118
ROLL. SENATORS CABALLERO
02:41:35.185 --> 02:41:38.855
CABALLERO, I, NILSSON NILSSON. I
02:41:38.922 --> 02:41:44.161
SO I HERZBERG WIENER. WE HAVE
02:41:44.227 --> 02:41:45.295
THREE VOTES ON THAT WE'RE GOING
02:41:45.362 --> 02:41:47.297
TO PUT IT ON CALL. AND SO IF I
02:41:47.364 --> 02:41:50.133
COULD WE ARE NOW AT THE END OF
02:41:50.200 --> 02:41:51.568
OUR HEARING, AND WE HAVE BILLS
02:41:51.635 --> 02:41:53.637
ON CALL, SO I WANT TO ADVISE ALL
02:41:53.703 --> 02:41:55.872
THE MEMBERS. PLEASE RETURN SO
02:41:55.939 --> 02:41:56.873
THAT WE CAN IMMEDIATELY FINISHED
02:41:56.940 --> 02:41:58.742
LIFTING THE CALLS WITHOUT ANY
02:41:58.809 --> 02:42:15.025
FURTHER DELAY.
02:44:58.154 --> 02:45:11.368
SO WE'RE NO PROBLEM. RIGHT? SO
02:45:11.434 --> 02:45:13.570
WE'RE GOING. WE HAVE A NUMBER OF
02:45:13.637 --> 02:45:15.505
BILLS ON CALLS, SO WE'RE GOING
02:45:15.572 --> 02:45:17.374
TO START WITH FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:45:17.440 --> 02:45:18.775
FOUR, WHICH IS A B 12 27 BY
02:45:18.842 --> 02:45:21.011
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVINE. PLEASE
02:45:21.077 --> 02:45:26.683
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION
02:45:26.750 --> 02:45:28.752
IS TO PASS THIS AMENDED BUT
02:45:28.818 --> 02:45:30.353
FIRST CEMENT AND WE REFERRED TO
02:45:30.420 --> 02:45:31.254
THE COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC SAFETY.
02:45:31.321 --> 02:45:34.758
CURRENT VOTE IS 2 TO 0. NILSSON
02:45:34.824 --> 02:45:37.060
NILSSON. NO HERZBERG HERZBERG.
02:45:37.127 --> 02:45:40.630
AYE, WIENER. WIENER. AYE. 4 TO
02:45:40.697 --> 02:45:44.868
1. THAT BILL IS OUT 4 TO 1. NOW
02:45:44.934 --> 02:45:46.503
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON TO FILE
02:45:46.569 --> 02:45:48.505
ITEM NUMBER ONE. WE'LL GO RIGHT
02:45:48.571 --> 02:45:51.508
DOWN THE LIST AND THIS IS A B
02:45:51.574 --> 02:45:53.276
FOR 11 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:45:53.343 --> 02:45:54.344
MEMBER, IRWIN, PLEASE CALL THE
02:45:54.411 --> 02:45:59.082
ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION IS TO
02:45:59.149 --> 02:46:00.784
PASS. BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO
02:46:00.850 --> 02:46:02.619
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
02:46:02.686 --> 02:46:03.853
. HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE,
02:46:03.920 --> 02:46:07.090
WIENER. WIENER. AYE. BY 20. THAT
02:46:07.157 --> 02:46:12.062
BILL IS OUT 5 TO 0. THANK YOU.
02:46:12.128 --> 02:46:16.433
THANK YOU, SIR. MOVING ON TO
02:46:16.499 --> 02:46:19.402
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO. IT'S A B
02:46:19.469 --> 02:46:22.005
18 63 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IRWIN.
02:46:22.072 --> 02:46:24.874
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:46:24.941 --> 02:46:27.243
MOTION IS TO PASS BY FIRST RE
02:46:27.310 --> 02:46:28.345
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:46:28.411 --> 02:46:29.679
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
02:46:29.746 --> 02:46:31.748
THROUGH THE ZERO HERZBERG
02:46:31.815 --> 02:46:33.683
HERZBERG. AYE WIENER WIENER. I
02:46:33.750 --> 02:46:38.722
FIGHT A ZERO THAT IS OUT 5 TO 0.
02:46:38.788 --> 02:46:40.056
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:46:40.123 --> 02:46:46.863
FIVE. THAT IS UM, A B 12 88 BY
02:46:46.930 --> 02:46:48.098
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK-SILVA.
02:46:48.164 --> 02:46:51.234
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:46:51.301 --> 02:46:53.803
MOTION IS TO PASS US AMENDED,
02:46:53.870 --> 02:46:54.504
BUT FIRST A MEANT AND WE
02:46:54.571 --> 02:46:56.606
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:46:56.673 --> 02:46:57.340
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
02:46:57.407 --> 02:46:59.409
3 TO 0 HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE
02:46:59.476 --> 02:47:04.214
WIENER. WIENER. I 50 5 TO 0.
02:47:04.280 --> 02:47:06.383
THAT BILL IS OUT WILL BE ON FILE
02:47:06.449 --> 02:47:08.618
ITEM NUMBER SIX, WHICH IS A B 27
02:47:08.685 --> 02:47:11.388
05 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:47:11.454 --> 02:47:15.158
QUIRK-SILVA. AH NO, THAT THOSE
02:47:15.225 --> 02:47:18.228
ARE. LET ME SEE. NO, WE JUST
02:47:18.294 --> 02:47:22.665
DID. 5 16 COOL. FOLLOWING NUMBER
02:47:22.732 --> 02:47:30.740
16. WE'RE ON NUMBER SIX. AND SO
02:47:30.807 --> 02:47:33.610
IN SOME OF THESE ARE GOING TO BE
02:47:33.676 --> 02:47:35.311
ON CONSENT, AND SO WE'LL WE'LL.
02:47:35.378 --> 02:47:36.312
WE'LL GET THEM. WE'LL PICK THEM
02:47:36.379 --> 02:47:40.417
UP. FILE ITEM NUMBERS SIX IS A B
02:47:40.483 --> 02:47:44.154
27 05 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:47:44.220 --> 02:47:44.954
QUIRK-SILVA. PLEASE CALL THE
02:47:45.021 --> 02:47:48.057
ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION IS TO
02:47:48.124 --> 02:47:50.393
PASS BY FIRST RE REFERRED TO THE
02:47:50.460 --> 02:47:50.994
COMMITTEE AND HOUSING CURRENT
02:47:51.060 --> 02:47:53.129
VOTE IS 3 TO 0. HERZBERG
02:47:53.196 --> 02:47:54.431
HERZBERG. AYE WIENER WIENER. I
02:47:54.497 --> 02:47:59.602
TRIED TO ZERO THAT BELL IS OUT 5
02:47:59.669 --> 02:48:01.671
TO 0. LET ME GRAB ALL THE ONES
02:48:01.738 --> 02:48:03.773
ON THE CONSENT. VERY QUICKLY SO
02:48:03.840 --> 02:48:10.013
THAT WE. TO THEM MY LIST. CAN'T
02:48:10.079 --> 02:48:15.585
LICK MY FINGERS WITH THIS. WE
02:48:15.652 --> 02:48:16.853
HAVE FOUR ITEMS ON CONSENT ITEM
02:48:16.920 --> 02:48:20.256
NUMBER THREE. ITEM NUMBER SEVEN.
02:48:20.323 --> 02:48:23.593
NUMBER EIGHT AND NUMBER 17.
02:48:23.660 --> 02:48:28.264
PLEASE CALL THE CONSENT. MOTION
02:48:28.331 --> 02:48:29.899
IS TO ADOPT THE CONTENT
02:48:29.966 --> 02:48:31.301
CALENDAR. CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0
02:48:31.367 --> 02:48:33.336
HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE, WIENER
02:48:33.403 --> 02:48:36.773
WIENER. I FIGHT TO ZERO. THE
02:48:36.840 --> 02:48:39.843
CONSENT CALENDAR IS ABOUT 5 TO 0
02:48:39.909 --> 02:48:41.077
. NEXT UP IS FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:48:41.144 --> 02:48:46.382
NINE. THAT IS A B 19 TO BUY
02:48:46.449 --> 02:48:49.853
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AGUIAR CURRY.
02:48:49.919 --> 02:48:52.922
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:48:52.989 --> 02:48:54.824
MOTION IS TO PASS. BUT FIRST WE
02:48:54.891 --> 02:48:56.159
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:48:56.226 --> 02:48:57.594
NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER.
02:48:57.660 --> 02:48:59.295
CURRENT VOTE IS THROUGH THE ZERO
02:48:59.362 --> 02:49:01.898
HERZBERG, PITTSBURGH I WIENER
02:49:01.965 --> 02:49:03.733
WIENER. I FIGHT A ZERO THAT BILL
02:49:03.800 --> 02:49:06.870
IS UP 5 TO 0. MOVING ON TO FILE
02:49:06.936 --> 02:49:15.345
ITEM NUMBER 11. THAT IS A B. 21
02:49:15.411 --> 02:49:18.114
42 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GABRIEL.
02:49:18.181 --> 02:49:21.351
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:49:21.417 --> 02:49:23.920
MOTION IS PASSED. BUT FIRST WE
02:49:23.987 --> 02:49:24.621
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:49:24.687 --> 02:49:26.122
APPROPRIATIONS. CURRENT VOTE IS
02:49:26.189 --> 02:49:28.892
3 TO 0 HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE
02:49:28.958 --> 02:49:31.761
WIENER WIENER. I FIGHT A ZERO
02:49:31.828 --> 02:49:33.596
AND BUILD US UP 5 TO 0. MOVING
02:49:33.663 --> 02:49:39.035
ON TO FILE ITEM NUMBER. 13.
02:49:39.102 --> 02:49:41.971
THAT'S A B 22 95 BY
02:49:42.038 --> 02:49:43.006
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM. PLEASE
02:49:43.072 --> 02:49:46.276
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION
02:49:46.342 --> 02:49:47.810
IS PASSED. BUT FIRST WE REFERRED
02:49:47.877 --> 02:49:49.679
TO THE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING.
02:49:49.746 --> 02:49:52.649
CURRENT VOTE IS FOR 20 HERZBERG
02:49:52.715 --> 02:49:55.451
. HERZBERG I BY 20. THAT BILL IS
02:49:55.518 --> 02:49:57.520
ABOUT 5 TO 0. MOVING ON TO FILE
02:49:57.587 --> 02:50:01.457
ITEM NUMBER 14. A B 23 19 BY UM
02:50:01.524 --> 02:50:04.761
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BONTA. PLEASE
02:50:04.827 --> 02:50:06.896
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. MOTION
02:50:06.963 --> 02:50:08.464
IS TO PASS. BUT FIRST WE
02:50:08.531 --> 02:50:09.732
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:50:09.799 --> 02:50:11.601
HOUSING. CURRENT VOTE IS 3 TO 0.
02:50:11.668 --> 02:50:13.369
HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE WIENER
02:50:13.436 --> 02:50:16.973
WIENER. I FIGHT A ZERO THAT BILL
02:50:17.040 --> 02:50:19.208
IS OUT 5 TO 0. FOLLOWING ITEM
02:50:19.275 --> 02:50:21.210
NUMBER 16 WAS PULLED BY THE
02:50:21.277 --> 02:50:22.912
ASSEMBLY MEMBER, SO IT'S LEFT IS
02:50:22.979 --> 02:50:30.486
15. NUMBER 16 A MISSED 15. WE
02:50:30.553 --> 02:50:33.256
NEED 15 OKAY. FILE ITEM NUMBER
02:50:33.323 --> 02:50:35.158
15 AB 28 80 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:50:35.224 --> 02:50:39.262
BONTA. MOTION IS TO PASS THIS
02:50:39.329 --> 02:50:40.630
AMENDED BUT FOR CEMENT AND WE
02:50:40.697 --> 02:50:42.865
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:50:42.932 --> 02:50:43.766
APPROPRIATIONS CURRENT VOTE IS 3
02:50:43.833 --> 02:50:46.002
TO 0. HERZBERG HERZBERG. AYE,
02:50:46.069 --> 02:50:48.037
WIENER. WIENER I FIGHT A ZERO
02:50:48.104 --> 02:50:51.774
THAT BILL IS OUT 5 TO 0. THAT
02:50:51.841 --> 02:50:53.743
SHOULD CONCLUDE LAST MORE THAN
02:50:53.810 --> 02:50:57.246
YET THING WAS CONSIDERED. YEAH
02:50:57.313 --> 02:50:58.481
THE OTHER AND THE OTHER ONE WAS
02:50:58.548 --> 02:51:02.118
CONSENT. CORRECT. UM THANK YOU
02:51:02.185 --> 02:51:04.087
TO ALL THE INDIVIDUALS WHO
02:51:04.153 --> 02:51:05.154
PARTICIPATED IN THE PUBLIC
02:51:05.221 --> 02:51:06.889
TESTIMONY TODAY. IF YOU WERE NOT
02:51:06.956 --> 02:51:08.491
ABLE TO TESTIFY TODAY, PLEASE
02:51:08.558 --> 02:51:09.892
SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS OR
02:51:09.959 --> 02:51:11.628
SUGGESTIONS IN WRITING TO THE
02:51:11.694 --> 02:51:12.895
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE COMMITTEE
02:51:12.962 --> 02:51:14.998
OR VISIT OUR WEBSITE. YOUR
02:51:15.064 --> 02:51:16.499
COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS ARE
02:51:16.566 --> 02:51:17.734
IMPORTANT TO US, AND WE WANT TO
02:51:17.800 --> 02:51:19.602
INCLUDE YOUR TESTIMONY IN THE
02:51:19.669 --> 02:51:20.903
OFFICIAL HEARING RECORDS. THANK
02:51:20.970 --> 02:51:23.006
YOU. AND WE APPRECIATE YOUR
02:51:23.072 --> 02:51:23.973
PARTICIPATION. THANK YOU TO
02:51:24.040 --> 02:51:25.341
EVERYONE FOR YOUR PATIENCE AND
02:51:25.408 --> 02:51:27.510
COOPERATION. WE HAVE CONCLUDED
02:51:27.577 --> 02:51:29.612
THE AGENDA AND I WANT TO THANK
02:51:29.679 --> 02:51:30.279
THE MODERATOR IF SHE'S STILL ON
02:51:30.346 --> 02:51:32.081
THE LINE FOR HER ASSISTANCE
02:51:32.148 --> 02:51:34.250
TODAY. THE SENATE COMMITTEE ON
02:51:34.317 --> 02:51:35.251
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE IS
02:51:35.318 --> 02:51:51.467
ADJOURNED.