WEBVTT
00:00:10.410 --> 00:00:12.679
ALRIGHT WE'RE GONNA WE'RE GONNA
00:00:12.746 --> 00:00:14.614
BEGIN HERE SHORTLY AS A
00:00:14.681 --> 00:00:17.350
SUBCOMMITTEE, UM I WOULD INVITE
00:00:17.417 --> 00:00:18.685
ALL MEMBERS OF THE SENATE
00:00:18.752 --> 00:00:20.353
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE TO APPEAR IN
00:00:20.420 --> 00:00:24.858
ROOM 2100. UM SO WE HAVE 50% OF
00:00:24.924 --> 00:00:26.559
THE REPUBLICAN COMPONENT. WHO IS
00:00:26.626 --> 00:00:34.534
PRESENT. SO UM. WE'RE GOING TO
00:00:34.601 --> 00:00:37.470
COME TO ORDER AS A SUBCOMMITTEE.
00:00:37.537 --> 00:00:40.106
UM GOOD MORNING AS WE CONTINUE
00:00:40.173 --> 00:00:41.007
TO TAKE SOME PRECAUTIONS TO
00:00:41.074 --> 00:00:42.942
MANAGE ONGOING COVID 19 RISK.
00:00:43.009 --> 00:00:43.676
THE SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME
00:00:43.743 --> 00:00:45.345
THE PUBLIC TO OUR HEARINGS AND
00:00:45.412 --> 00:00:46.613
HAS PROVIDED ACCESS TO BOTH IN
00:00:46.679 --> 00:00:47.814
PERSON AND TELECONFERENCE
00:00:47.881 --> 00:00:48.615
PARTICIPATION FOR PUBLIC
00:00:48.681 --> 00:00:50.483
COMMENT. PROBLEM INDIVIDUALS
00:00:50.550 --> 00:00:51.384
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
00:00:51.451 --> 00:00:52.986
COMMENT. THE PARTICIPANT TOLL
00:00:53.052 --> 00:00:54.988
FREE NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:55.054 --> 00:00:55.722
POSTED ON OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE
00:00:55.789 --> 00:00:56.923
WILL BE DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN
00:00:56.990 --> 00:00:59.092
THAT WILL ANNOUNCE IT NOW.
00:00:59.159 --> 00:01:01.060
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
00:01:01.127 --> 00:01:06.599
8772 TO 6. 8163 AND THE ACCESS
00:01:06.666 --> 00:01:10.470
CODE IS 648862. FOR DETAILED
00:01:10.537 --> 00:01:11.304
INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW THE
00:01:11.371 --> 00:01:12.472
TELECONFERENCE SYSTEM WORKS.
00:01:12.539 --> 00:01:14.274
PLEASE REFER TO THE SENATE AND
00:01:14.340 --> 00:01:15.608
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE WEBSITE. I
00:01:15.675 --> 00:01:16.876
WILL MAINTAIN THE QUORUM DURING
00:01:16.943 --> 00:01:18.478
THE HEARING, AS IS CUSTOMER IN
00:01:18.545 --> 00:01:19.779
ANY INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE
00:01:19.846 --> 00:01:21.281
MAY BE REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE
00:01:21.347 --> 00:01:22.515
MEETING SERVICE OR HAVE THEIR
00:01:22.582 --> 00:01:23.783
CONNECTIONS MUTED. WE'RE HOLDING
00:01:23.850 --> 00:01:26.486
OUR COMMITTEE HEARINGS HERE IN
00:01:26.553 --> 00:01:27.987
THE OFF STREET BUILDING ALSO
00:01:28.054 --> 00:01:29.489
KNOWN AS THE SWING SPACE. I ASK
00:01:29.556 --> 00:01:31.991
THAT ALL MEMBERS OF THE
00:01:32.058 --> 00:01:32.992
COMMITTEE COME TO ROOM 2100 SO
00:01:33.059 --> 00:01:34.527
WE CAN ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM AND
00:01:34.594 --> 00:01:41.734
BEGIN THE HEARING. UM. WE ARE
00:01:41.801 --> 00:01:42.802
LACKING THREE MEMBERS FOR A
00:01:42.869 --> 00:01:46.272
QUORUM. LET ME ANNOUNCE WHAT IS
00:01:46.339 --> 00:01:49.709
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR. WHICH
00:01:49.776 --> 00:01:50.810
WILL BE TAKEN UP ONCE WE
00:01:50.877 --> 00:01:53.680
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. UH THE
00:01:53.746 --> 00:01:55.748
FOLLOWING ITEMS ON THE CONSENT
00:01:55.815 --> 00:01:56.649
COUNTER FILING NUMBER SIX A. B
00:01:56.716 --> 00:01:59.619
18 65 BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER BENNETT
00:01:59.686 --> 00:02:01.387
FILING NUMBER SEVEN A. B 29 12
00:02:01.454 --> 00:02:03.490
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BERMAN FILE
00:02:03.556 --> 00:02:06.359
, UM, NUMBER 11 A B 1467 BY SOME
00:02:06.426 --> 00:02:08.127
OF THE MEMBERS CERVANTES WITH
00:02:08.194 --> 00:02:09.863
AMENDMENTS FILE THEM NUMBER 12 A
00:02:09.929 --> 00:02:12.265
B 29 60 BY ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY
00:02:12.332 --> 00:02:15.335
COMMITTEE FILE NUMBER 13 29 61,
00:02:15.401 --> 00:02:17.103
ALSO BY THE ASSEMBLY JUDICIARY
00:02:17.170 --> 00:02:18.838
COMMITTEE FILE NUMBER 17 81 355
00:02:18.905 --> 00:02:22.742
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THE LEVIN
00:02:22.809 --> 00:02:24.544
FILING NUMBER 1980 23 70, ALSO
00:02:24.611 --> 00:02:27.347
BY SOMEBODY MEMBER, LEVINE.
00:02:27.413 --> 00:02:30.450
PILOT NUMBER 21 A B 7 40 BY SOME
00:02:30.517 --> 00:02:31.451
OF THEM. RICCARDI FILE HIM
00:02:31.518 --> 00:02:34.988
NUMBER 22 A B 2495 BY SEVEN
00:02:35.054 --> 00:02:36.389
MEMBER PATERSON WITH AMENDMENTS
00:02:36.456 --> 00:02:38.825
FILING NUMBER 23 A B 22 80 BY
00:02:38.892 --> 00:02:40.360
SOME OF THEM ARREST FILE NUMBER
00:02:40.426 --> 00:02:43.229
24 23 26 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:02:43.296 --> 00:02:46.266
FILE NUMBER 25 A B 20 TO 60 BY
00:02:46.332 --> 00:02:47.834
SOME OF THE MEMBER RODRIGUEZ
00:02:47.901 --> 00:02:49.402
FINALLY, FILING NUMBER 26, MAYBE
00:02:49.469 --> 00:02:51.938
26 55 BY SOME OF THE MEMBER
00:02:52.005 --> 00:02:59.345
BLANCA RUBIO. ALL RIGHT. THE
00:02:59.412 --> 00:03:00.513
FIRST BILL WE'RE GOING TO TAKE
00:03:00.580 --> 00:03:03.917
UP IS THIS IS A B 22 23 BY
00:03:03.983 --> 00:03:06.352
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS, UM,
00:03:06.419 --> 00:03:09.322
FOLLOWED BY A B 2777 BY
00:03:09.389 --> 00:03:11.257
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS. UM AS IS
00:03:11.324 --> 00:03:16.262
CUSTOMARY. WE WILL TAKE, UM,
00:03:16.329 --> 00:03:19.232
SUPPORT IN OPPOSITION SUPPORT.
00:03:19.299 --> 00:03:20.867
THERE WILL BE TWO PRIMARY
00:03:20.934 --> 00:03:22.235
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT EACH WILL
00:03:22.302 --> 00:03:24.103
HAVE TWO MINUTES. OPPOSITION
00:03:24.170 --> 00:03:25.305
WILL HAVE THE EXACT SAME AMOUNT
00:03:25.371 --> 00:03:26.472
OF TIME TWO MINUTES FOR EACH.
00:03:26.539 --> 00:03:28.174
WHO WISHES TO EACH OF THE TWO
00:03:28.241 --> 00:03:29.576
PRIMARY WITNESSES WHO WISH
00:03:29.642 --> 00:03:31.811
TESTIFYING OPPOSITION. THEN
00:03:31.878 --> 00:03:33.646
WE'LL TAKE THOSE WHO ARE HERE IN
00:03:33.713 --> 00:03:35.214
THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM TO
00:03:35.281 --> 00:03:36.849
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE AND GIVE
00:03:36.916 --> 00:03:38.051
US THEIR NAME THEIR AFFILIATION
00:03:38.117 --> 00:03:39.619
IN THEIR POSITION. AND THEN WE
00:03:39.686 --> 00:03:41.220
WILL TURN TO THE PHONE. UM, WE
00:03:41.287 --> 00:03:42.722
WILL FIRST TAKE SUPPORT AND THEN
00:03:42.789 --> 00:03:45.024
WE WILL TAKE OPPOSITION. SOME
00:03:45.091 --> 00:03:46.459
MEMBER WICKS. UM, I SEE YOU'RE
00:03:46.526 --> 00:03:47.760
HERE. YOU'VE BEEN PATIENTLY
00:03:47.827 --> 00:03:50.196
WAITING. A B 22 TO 3 FLOOR IS
00:03:50.263 --> 00:03:52.899
YOURS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MR
00:03:52.966 --> 00:03:54.367
CHAIR, AND MEMBERS OF THE
00:03:54.434 --> 00:03:56.836
COMMITTEE ALSO WANT TO THANK THE
00:03:56.903 --> 00:03:57.604
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR ALL OF THEIR
00:03:57.670 --> 00:04:00.607
HELP ON THIS BILL. IN THE PAST
00:04:00.673 --> 00:04:01.140
TWO DECADES, AT LEAST 1300
00:04:01.207 --> 00:04:01.674
PREGNANT PEOPLE HAVE BEEN
00:04:01.741 --> 00:04:03.142
CRIMINALLY PROSECUTED FOR HAVING
00:04:03.209 --> 00:04:03.743
MISCARRIAGES OR STILLBIRTHS OR
00:04:03.810 --> 00:04:06.245
SELF MANAGING AN ABORTION.
00:04:06.312 --> 00:04:07.847
CALIFORNIA IS NOT EXEMPT FROM
00:04:07.914 --> 00:04:09.716
THIS, DESPITE CLEAR LAW THAT
00:04:09.782 --> 00:04:11.584
ENDING OR LOSING A PREGNANCY IS
00:04:11.651 --> 00:04:13.219
NOT A CRIME. PROSECUTORS IN THIS
00:04:13.286 --> 00:04:14.654
STATE HAVE CHARGED PEOPLE WITH
00:04:14.721 --> 00:04:15.655
HOMICIDE OFFENSES FOR PREGNANCY
00:04:15.722 --> 00:04:18.658
LOST. TWO EXAMPLES ARE THE CASES
00:04:18.725 --> 00:04:19.959
OF CHELSEA BECKER AND ADORA
00:04:20.026 --> 00:04:21.928
PEREZ TO CALIFORNIA WOMEN WHO
00:04:21.995 --> 00:04:23.096
ARE RECENTLY PROSECUTED AND
00:04:23.162 --> 00:04:23.896
IMPRISONED FOR THEIR
00:04:23.963 --> 00:04:26.099
STILLBIRTHS. THE SAME GROUP
00:04:26.165 --> 00:04:27.033
ATTACKING ABORTIONS. RIGHT
00:04:27.100 --> 00:04:28.601
ABORTION RIGHTS HAVE SPREAD
00:04:28.668 --> 00:04:30.136
DISINFORMATION ABOUT THIS BILL.
00:04:30.203 --> 00:04:31.738
THEREFORE I WANT TO BE CLEAR
00:04:31.804 --> 00:04:32.905
ABOUT WHAT THE SPILL DOES AND
00:04:32.972 --> 00:04:34.741
DOES NOT DO. TO PROTECT PEOPLE'S
00:04:34.807 --> 00:04:35.441
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM AND
00:04:35.508 --> 00:04:37.744
DECISION MAKING A B 22 23 WILL
00:04:37.810 --> 00:04:39.112
REINFORCE EXISTING STATE
00:04:39.178 --> 00:04:40.647
PROTECTIONS TO ENSURE THAT NO
00:04:40.713 --> 00:04:41.381
ONE IN CALIFORNIA WILL BE
00:04:41.447 --> 00:04:42.482
PROSECUTED FOR ENDING A
00:04:42.548 --> 00:04:43.583
PREGNANCY OR EXPERIENCING
00:04:43.650 --> 00:04:45.818
PREGNANCY LOSS. THIS BILL
00:04:45.885 --> 00:04:47.887
PROTECTS AGAINST PROSECUTION OF
00:04:47.954 --> 00:04:48.755
PREGNANCY OUTCOMES, INCLUDING
00:04:48.821 --> 00:04:50.289
ABORTION, MISCARRIAGE,
00:04:50.356 --> 00:04:52.325
STILLBIRTH AND PERINATAL DEATH
00:04:52.392 --> 00:04:55.161
DUE TO CAUSES THAT OCCURRED IN
00:04:55.228 --> 00:04:55.728
UTERO. HERE'S WHAT THE BILL
00:04:55.795 --> 00:04:58.031
WON'T DO. A B 22 23 WILL NOT
00:04:58.097 --> 00:04:59.565
PREVENT AUTHORITIES FROM BEING
00:04:59.632 --> 00:05:02.201
ABLE TO INVESTIGATE THE FACTS OF
00:05:02.268 --> 00:05:03.403
A NEWBORN NEWBORN CHILD'S DEATH,
00:05:03.469 --> 00:05:04.937
INCLUDING WHETHER THE CHILD WAS
00:05:05.004 --> 00:05:06.439
BORN. LIVING THIS BILL ONLY
00:05:06.506 --> 00:05:08.107
PREVENT FURTHER INVESTIGATION OF
00:05:08.174 --> 00:05:09.342
THE PREGNANT PERSON IN THE EVENT
00:05:09.409 --> 00:05:10.543
THAT THE DEATH WAS DETERMINED TO
00:05:10.610 --> 00:05:11.711
BE A PREGNANCY RELATED CAUSE
00:05:11.778 --> 00:05:13.780
THAT OCCURRED IN UTERO. IT IS
00:05:13.846 --> 00:05:15.782
DESIGNED TO PROTECT PARENTS WHO
00:05:15.848 --> 00:05:16.449
EXPERIENCED THE TRAUMA OF LOSING
00:05:16.516 --> 00:05:17.617
A CHILD FROM BEING RE
00:05:17.684 --> 00:05:18.985
TRAUMATIZED BY UNWARRANTED
00:05:19.052 --> 00:05:21.988
INVESTIGATIONS. TO BE CLEAR THIS
00:05:22.055 --> 00:05:23.322
BILL WILL NOT PREVENT POLICE
00:05:23.389 --> 00:05:24.090
FROM INVESTING INTO FETAL DEATH.
00:05:24.157 --> 00:05:26.259
THAT OCCURRED AS A RESULT OF A
00:05:26.325 --> 00:05:27.760
CRIME COMMITTED AGAINST A
00:05:27.827 --> 00:05:28.428
PREGNANT PERSON AGAIN. THIS BILL
00:05:28.494 --> 00:05:30.329
WAS DESIGNED TO STOP ROGUE
00:05:30.396 --> 00:05:31.397
PROSECUTORS FROM USING PEOPLE'S
00:05:31.464 --> 00:05:32.965
PREGNANCIES AGAINST THEM. IN
00:05:33.032 --> 00:05:34.500
ADDITION, THIS BILL DOES NOT
00:05:34.567 --> 00:05:36.636
DIMINISH OR CHANGE THE ABILITY
00:05:36.703 --> 00:05:37.236
OF THE STATE TO INTERVENE TO
00:05:37.303 --> 00:05:38.604
PROTECT A LIVING CHILD AND
00:05:38.671 --> 00:05:40.506
INSTANCES OF ABUSE OR NEGLECT OR
00:05:40.573 --> 00:05:42.642
FROM INVESTIGATION INVESTIGATING
00:05:42.709 --> 00:05:45.078
AN INFANT DEATH THAT OCCURRED AS
00:05:45.144 --> 00:05:46.312
A RESULT OF AN ACTOR MISSION
00:05:46.379 --> 00:05:47.447
THAT TOOK PLACE AFTER DELIVERY.
00:05:47.513 --> 00:05:48.614
IT IS ONLY FOCUSED ON PREGNANCY
00:05:48.681 --> 00:05:50.483
OUTCOMES AND THE EVENTS THAT
00:05:50.550 --> 00:05:51.884
OCCURRED IN UTERO. HERE'S WHAT A
00:05:51.951 --> 00:05:54.620
B 22 23 WILL DO. THIS BILL WILL
00:05:54.687 --> 00:05:55.188
REMOVE OUTDATED PROVISIONS
00:05:55.254 --> 00:05:56.322
REQUIRING CORNERS TO INVESTIGATE
00:05:56.389 --> 00:05:58.357
CERTAIN PREGNANCY LOSSES.
00:05:58.424 --> 00:05:59.859
CLARIFY THAT THE REPRODUCTIVE
00:05:59.926 --> 00:06:00.860
PRIVACY ACT PROTECTS
00:06:00.927 --> 00:06:02.295
CRIMINALIZATION OF PREGNANCY,
00:06:02.361 --> 00:06:03.262
LOSS OF PREGNANCY, PREGNANCY
00:06:03.329 --> 00:06:05.298
OUTCOMES AND CREATE A PRIVATE
00:06:05.364 --> 00:06:06.299
RIGHT OF ACTION FOR PEOPLE WHOSE
00:06:06.365 --> 00:06:08.468
RIGHTS HAVE BEEN VIOLATED. THIS
00:06:08.534 --> 00:06:10.603
BILL IS SPONSORED BY A NUMBER OF
00:06:10.670 --> 00:06:11.871
ORGANIZATIONS AND SUPPORTED BY
00:06:11.938 --> 00:06:12.739
NUMBER OF REPUTABLE
00:06:12.805 --> 00:06:15.108
ORGANIZATIONS, INCLUDING A C L U
00:06:15.174 --> 00:06:16.709
CALIFORNIA ACTION. BLACK WOMAN
00:06:16.776 --> 00:06:18.144
FOR WELLNESS ACTION PROJECT.
00:06:18.211 --> 00:06:18.845
CALIFORNIA LATINAS FOR
00:06:18.911 --> 00:06:20.079
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE, IF WHEN,
00:06:20.146 --> 00:06:21.180
HOW LAURIER LAWYERING FOR
00:06:21.247 --> 00:06:23.750
REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE. NARAL
00:06:23.816 --> 00:06:25.251
PLANNED PARENTHOOD. OUR DOCTORS
00:06:25.318 --> 00:06:26.819
, OUR NURSES ARE MIDWIVES AND
00:06:26.886 --> 00:06:29.122
MANY OTHER GREAT ORGANIZATIONS
00:06:29.188 --> 00:06:30.523
ALSO WANT TO ADD THAT THIS BILL
00:06:30.590 --> 00:06:32.825
WILL ENSURE THAT IF SOMEONE IS
00:06:32.892 --> 00:06:33.960
SEEKING AN ABORTION FROM OUT OF
00:06:34.026 --> 00:06:35.928
STATE THAT THEIR RIGHTS WILL BE
00:06:35.995 --> 00:06:37.096
PROTECTED HERE IN CALIFORNIA.
00:06:37.163 --> 00:06:38.931
WITNESSES WHO WILL BE TESTIFYING
00:06:38.998 --> 00:06:41.701
OVER THE PHONE. UM ARE FARAH
00:06:41.768 --> 00:06:44.737
DIAZ TAYO OF IF ONE HOW
00:06:44.804 --> 00:06:45.738
LAWYERING FOR REPRODUCTIVE
00:06:45.805 --> 00:06:47.340
JUSTICE, AND SAMANTHA LEE OF THE
00:06:47.406 --> 00:06:47.974
NATIONAL ADVOCATES FOR PREGNANCY
00:06:48.040 --> 00:06:54.113
WOMEN FOR PREGNANT WOMEN. UM.
00:06:54.180 --> 00:06:58.251
MISS TELLO. IF YOU'RE ON THE
00:06:58.317 --> 00:06:59.418
PHONE IF YOU WOULD ANNOUNCE
00:06:59.485 --> 00:07:01.287
YOURSELF HI. I'M HERE. GOOD
00:07:01.354 --> 00:07:06.492
MORNING. GOOD MORNING. GO AHEAD
00:07:06.559 --> 00:07:08.928
, SARAH DÍAS, IF ONE HOW WE ARE
00:07:08.995 --> 00:07:11.898
PROUD SPONSORS OF MAYBE 22 23
00:07:11.964 --> 00:07:12.698
INSTEAD OF INSTEAD OF SPEAKING
00:07:12.765 --> 00:07:14.333
TO YOU TODAY AS A LAWYER WHO
00:07:14.400 --> 00:07:15.668
CONTENDS WITH THE
00:07:15.735 --> 00:07:16.536
CRIMINALIZATION OF PRESIDENCY
00:07:16.602 --> 00:07:17.804
DAILY, I WOULD LIKE TO YIELD MY
00:07:17.870 --> 00:07:19.605
TIME TO THE WORDS JESSICA TEBOW.
00:07:19.672 --> 00:07:21.340
LIVING IN GLENDALE IN 2000 AND
00:07:21.407 --> 00:07:22.975
NINE WHEN SHE EXPERIENCED
00:07:23.042 --> 00:07:24.177
FIRSTHAND WHAT HAPPENS IN LAW
00:07:24.243 --> 00:07:24.777
ENFORCEMENT INTERFERENCE WITH
00:07:24.844 --> 00:07:27.880
PREGNANCY LOSSES. IN HER WORDS.
00:07:27.947 --> 00:07:29.682
THERE HAVE BEEN A HEARTBEAT AT
00:07:29.749 --> 00:07:30.416
EIGHT WEEKS. BUT SOMETHING
00:07:30.483 --> 00:07:32.485
WASN'T RIGHT. THEY SENT ME TO A
00:07:32.552 --> 00:07:33.586
SPECIALIST A 10 WEEKS AND THAT'S
00:07:33.653 --> 00:07:35.421
WHEN WE KNEW IT WAS OVER. FOR
00:07:35.488 --> 00:07:37.290
SOME PEOPLE. THIS WOULD HAVE
00:07:37.356 --> 00:07:38.491
BEEN VERY SIMPLE, BUT I HAD BEEN
00:07:38.558 --> 00:07:39.992
PASSIONATELY PRO LIFE 18 YEARS
00:07:40.059 --> 00:07:41.828
AND HEARD ALL THE STORIES OF
00:07:41.894 --> 00:07:43.629
MIRACLES. A WEEK LATER, IT
00:07:43.696 --> 00:07:44.797
STARTED TO GET ILL AND MY DOCTOR
00:07:44.864 --> 00:07:46.399
IS WORRIED THAT THE TISSUE THAT
00:07:46.465 --> 00:07:48.367
HAD ONCE BEEN FILLED WITH HOPES
00:07:48.434 --> 00:07:49.368
AND DREAMS WAS CAUSING AN
00:07:49.435 --> 00:07:50.636
INFECTION. IT WAS ONLY AFTER I
00:07:50.703 --> 00:07:51.637
UNDERSTOOD THAT THE INFECTION
00:07:51.704 --> 00:07:53.606
MIGHT HINDER MY ABILITY TO HAVE
00:07:53.673 --> 00:07:54.774
FUTURE CHILDREN, BUT I RELENTED
00:07:54.841 --> 00:07:57.743
AND TELL I LABORED AND DELIVERED
00:07:57.810 --> 00:07:59.045
THAT LITTLE EMBRYO AND TRIED TO
00:07:59.111 --> 00:08:00.947
SEE THAT WITH AS MUCH GRACE AND
00:08:01.013 --> 00:08:02.515
THE PERSON CAN I KNEW I WANTED
00:08:02.582 --> 00:08:03.516
TO HAVE IT TESTED FOR GENETIC
00:08:03.583 --> 00:08:04.350
ABNORMALITIES. AND MORE
00:08:04.417 --> 00:08:06.085
IMPORTANTLY, I WANTED TO AGREE
00:08:06.152 --> 00:08:07.920
THAT PRIVATELY WITH SOME SORT OF
00:08:07.987 --> 00:08:09.488
CEREMONY SO ON FRIDAY NIGHT WITH
00:08:09.555 --> 00:08:10.590
NO CHANCE OF DROPPING THE TISSUE
00:08:10.656 --> 00:08:12.525
AT THE HOSPITAL WITH MY DOCTOR,
00:08:12.592 --> 00:08:13.726
I WRAP THAT LITTLE EMBRYO
00:08:13.793 --> 00:08:15.361
CAREFULLY AND DID THE ONLY THING
00:08:15.428 --> 00:08:16.963
I COULD PRESERVE WHAT WAS LEFT
00:08:17.029 --> 00:08:18.097
AND ALLOW MYSELF CLOSURE FROZE
00:08:18.164 --> 00:08:20.867
IT. AFTER A WEEKEND OF SHARED
00:08:20.933 --> 00:08:21.801
GRIEF. MY HUSBAND CALLED THE
00:08:21.868 --> 00:08:23.669
NEAREST FUNERAL HOME AND ASKED
00:08:23.736 --> 00:08:25.605
IF WE COULD PAY FOR SOME SORT OF
00:08:25.671 --> 00:08:26.606
CREMATION PROCESS. BUT THEN
00:08:26.672 --> 00:08:27.740
SOMETHING UNEXPECTED HAPPENED.
00:08:27.807 --> 00:08:29.442
HE HAS TOLD THE TWO ENGAGES
00:08:29.508 --> 00:08:31.510
FUNERAL HOME SERVICES. WE NEEDED
00:08:31.577 --> 00:08:32.678
A DEATH CERTIFICATE AND TO CHECK
00:08:32.745 --> 00:08:33.880
WITH THE FIRE DEPARTMENT. MY
00:08:33.946 --> 00:08:35.681
HUSBAND WAS THEN TOLD THAT HE
00:08:35.748 --> 00:08:36.849
NEEDED TO CONTACT THE CORONER,
00:08:36.916 --> 00:08:39.018
AND HE DID. I WOULD BACK AT WORK
00:08:39.085 --> 00:08:40.620
AND STARTING TO FEEL BETTER WHEN
00:08:40.686 --> 00:08:41.787
I GOT THE CALL. IT WAS A
00:08:41.854 --> 00:08:42.922
DETECTIVE FROM THE GLENDALE
00:08:42.989 --> 00:08:44.223
POLICE DEPARTMENT. HE WANTED TO
00:08:44.290 --> 00:08:46.926
QUESTION ME ABOUT THE BABY I HAD
00:08:46.993 --> 00:08:48.127
PUT IN THE FREEZER. I WAS BEING
00:08:48.194 --> 00:08:50.162
ACCUSED OF MURDER. I POINTED OUT
00:08:50.229 --> 00:08:51.264
THAT IT WAS WITHIN MY LEGAL
00:08:51.330 --> 00:08:52.431
RIGHTS TO LET GO OF THE
00:08:52.498 --> 00:08:53.532
PREGNANCY THAT HAS ACTUALLY
00:08:53.599 --> 00:08:55.334
ENDED IN WEEK EIGHT. HE INSTEAD
00:08:55.401 --> 00:08:56.602
INTIMATED THAT I WAS A LIAR WHO
00:08:56.669 --> 00:08:59.005
MURDERED MY BABY. I TOLD HIM
00:08:59.071 --> 00:09:00.539
THERE WAS NO BABY, JUST A LITTLE
00:09:00.606 --> 00:09:03.175
TINY EMBRYO AND HE WENT ON. THEY
00:09:03.242 --> 00:09:04.310
COULDN'T FIND BABY. SO WHERE HAD
00:09:04.377 --> 00:09:06.412
HIDDEN IT? AND AT THAT MOMENT I
00:09:06.479 --> 00:09:08.481
WAS FILLED WITH TERROR. NOT ONLY
00:09:08.547 --> 00:09:09.882
HAD I LOST ALL THE LOVE AND
00:09:09.949 --> 00:09:11.584
HOPES OF WHO THIS LITTLE DREAM
00:09:11.651 --> 00:09:12.718
MIGHT HAVE BECOME, BUT I
00:09:12.785 --> 00:09:14.954
pCERTAINTY THAT THEY HAD TAKEN
00:09:15.021 --> 00:09:16.489
THE TISSUE ITSELF. HAD STOLEN
00:09:16.555 --> 00:09:18.524
WHAT LITTLE BITS REMAINED. I WAS
00:09:18.591 --> 00:09:19.692
GOING TO CARRY BACK TO KANSAS
00:09:19.759 --> 00:09:21.928
AND GRIEVED PROPERLY. THIS MAN
00:09:21.994 --> 00:09:22.828
AND A HOST OF OTHER OFFICERS
00:09:22.895 --> 00:09:24.830
WERE IN MY HOUSE TALKING TO MY
00:09:24.897 --> 00:09:26.065
BELONGINGS TAIL IF YOU COULD
00:09:26.132 --> 00:09:30.503
WRAP IT UP, PLEASE. SURE. I
00:09:30.569 --> 00:09:32.238
GUESS HE LOST HIS HEARTBREAKING
00:09:32.305 --> 00:09:33.673
BUT IT IS ALSO PART OF THE
00:09:33.739 --> 00:09:34.874
NATURAL ORDER BEING VIOLATED
00:09:34.941 --> 00:09:35.875
BASED ON SYSTEMIC
00:09:35.942 --> 00:09:36.809
CRIMINALIZATION. CONTROL OF
00:09:36.876 --> 00:09:38.010
PREGNANCY IS ANOTHER STORY
00:09:38.077 --> 00:09:39.712
ALTOGETHER. NO WOMAN SHOULD EVER
00:09:39.779 --> 00:09:41.314
FACED SUCH BRUTALITY, ESPECIALLY
00:09:41.380 --> 00:09:43.182
NOT WITHOUT THE POSSIBILITY.
00:09:43.249 --> 00:09:44.216
ALRIGHT, THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:09:44.283 --> 00:09:47.153
VERY MUCH, UM LET'S NOW TURN TO
00:09:47.219 --> 00:09:48.287
MISS SAMANTHA LEE, IF YOU'RE
00:09:48.354 --> 00:09:52.291
AVAILABLE. YES THANK YOU. I'M A
00:09:52.358 --> 00:09:53.793
STAFF ATTORNEY AT NATIONAL
00:09:53.859 --> 00:09:54.694
ADVOCATES FOR PREGNANT WOMEN
00:09:54.760 --> 00:09:56.629
WHERE WE WORK TO ENSURE THAT NO
00:09:56.696 --> 00:09:58.064
ONE IS ARRESTED, SHAMED OR
00:09:58.130 --> 00:09:59.532
DENIED CONSTITUTIONAL INSTRUMENT
00:09:59.598 --> 00:10:00.399
RIGHTS BECAUSE THEY HAVE THE
00:10:00.466 --> 00:10:02.468
CAPACITY FOR PREGNANCY. ARE
00:10:02.535 --> 00:10:04.470
PREGNANT FOR BECAUSE OF ANY%
00:10:04.537 --> 00:10:05.504
OUTCOME OF THEIR PREGNANCY,
00:10:05.571 --> 00:10:06.572
INCLUDING FIRST MR SILVER FOR
00:10:06.639 --> 00:10:09.742
ABORTION. AND WE WERE SOME OF
00:10:09.809 --> 00:10:11.143
THE ATTORNEYS WHO REPRESENTED
00:10:11.210 --> 00:10:11.877
CHELSEA BECKER AGAINST MURDER
00:10:11.944 --> 00:10:14.613
MURDER CHARGES FOR HER SHE LOST
00:10:14.680 --> 00:10:16.215
IN HANFORD, CALIFORNIA, SO I
00:10:16.282 --> 00:10:17.783
WOULD LIKE TO READ FOR THE
00:10:17.850 --> 00:10:18.684
COMMITTEE STATEMENT FROM
00:10:18.751 --> 00:10:21.587
INSPECTOR ABOUT HER EXPERIENCE.
00:10:21.654 --> 00:10:23.456
MY NAME IS CHELSEA BECKER. I WAS
00:10:23.522 --> 00:10:25.658
INCARCERATED IN COUNTY JAIL FOR
00:10:25.725 --> 00:10:27.126
MORE THAN A YEAR FROM NOVEMBER
00:10:27.193 --> 00:10:30.763
6TH 2019 UNTIL MARCH 10TH 2021
00:10:30.830 --> 00:10:31.764
WHILE I WAS AWAITING TRIAL FOR
00:10:31.831 --> 00:10:32.965
FIRST DEGREE MURDER AFTER
00:10:33.032 --> 00:10:34.200
EXPERIENCING A SILVER ADDICTED
00:10:34.266 --> 00:10:37.436
TO METHAMPHETAMINE. I HAVE READ
00:10:37.503 --> 00:10:39.205
THE PROPOSED AMENDED BILL. AND
00:10:39.271 --> 00:10:40.339
BASED ON MY EXPERIENCE, I
00:10:40.406 --> 00:10:41.407
BELIEVE IT SHOULD BE PASSED.
00:10:41.474 --> 00:10:44.210
EXPERIENCING THE LOSS OF MY BABY
00:10:44.276 --> 00:10:45.444
ALONE, CAUSE A LOT OF TRAUMA FOR
00:10:45.511 --> 00:10:47.646
ME, AND WHILE I WAS IN CUSTODY,
00:10:47.713 --> 00:10:48.848
I WAS UNABLE TO RECEIVE THE
00:10:48.914 --> 00:10:50.583
PROPER COUNSELING TO HELP ME
00:10:50.649 --> 00:10:51.350
WITH THE GRIEF PROCESS. EVEN
00:10:51.417 --> 00:10:52.718
WITH THE COUNSELORS AT THE JAIL.
00:10:52.785 --> 00:10:54.520
I WAS AFRAID ANYTHING I MIGHT
00:10:54.587 --> 00:10:56.589
HAVE SAID TO THEM WOULD BE USED
00:10:56.655 --> 00:10:57.623
AGAINST YOU IN COURT, SO I
00:10:57.690 --> 00:10:59.692
SUFFERED ALONE. WHILE I WAS IN
00:10:59.759 --> 00:11:01.761
JAIL. MY YOUNGEST LIVING SON,
00:11:01.827 --> 00:11:02.695
WHOM I HAD CUSTODY OF UP UNTIL
00:11:02.762 --> 00:11:03.896
THIS TIME, HAD BEEN TAKEN INTO
00:11:03.963 --> 00:11:06.098
TPS AND WAS LATER ADOPTED. AT
00:11:06.165 --> 00:11:08.267
THE HOSPITAL HAS NEVER INVOLVED
00:11:08.334 --> 00:11:09.869
ENFORCEMENT DUE TO THE SILVERS
00:11:09.935 --> 00:11:11.637
HAPPENING. I WOULD STILL HAVE
00:11:11.704 --> 00:11:13.973
CUSTODY OF MY SON. THE CHARGE
00:11:14.040 --> 00:11:15.875
WAS DISMISSED UNTIL MAY 2021.
00:11:15.941 --> 00:11:17.043
BUT THEN THE ADOPTION HAD BEEN
00:11:17.109 --> 00:11:19.979
FINALIZED MONTHS PRIOR.
00:11:20.046 --> 00:11:21.147
EXPERIENCE WITH THE JUSTICE
00:11:21.213 --> 00:11:23.082
SYSTEM IN CHAINS, COUNTY WAS
00:11:23.149 --> 00:11:24.250
DETRIMENTAL TO MY MENTAL HEALTH,
00:11:24.316 --> 00:11:26.085
AND I FEEL THAT I WOULD FAILED
00:11:26.152 --> 00:11:27.787
PEOPLE. IF THIS BILL IS PASSED,
00:11:27.853 --> 00:11:29.488
IT WOULD PREVENT OTHER PEOPLE
00:11:29.555 --> 00:11:30.856
FROM EXPERIENCING WHAT I DID AND
00:11:30.923 --> 00:11:31.924
BEING PROSECUTED AND PUNISHED
00:11:31.991 --> 00:11:33.025
FOR SOMETHING THAT COULD HAVE
00:11:33.092 --> 00:11:35.227
HAPPENED TO ANYBODY. I HOPE THAT
00:11:35.294 --> 00:11:36.529
IN THE FUTURE NO WOMAN WILL EVER
00:11:36.595 --> 00:11:38.264
BE PROSECUTED FOR LOSING A
00:11:38.330 --> 00:11:40.699
PREGNANCY. AND I DELETE WOULD
00:11:40.766 --> 00:11:41.767
LIKE TO EMPHASIZE TO THE
00:11:41.834 --> 00:11:43.569
COMMITTEE THAT ABOUT 15% OF ALL
00:11:43.636 --> 00:11:44.570
KNOWN PREGNANCIES END IN
00:11:44.637 --> 00:11:46.405
PREGNANCY LAW. THIS IS A FACT OF
00:11:46.472 --> 00:11:48.507
BIOLOGY, NOT BEHAVIOR.
00:11:48.574 --> 00:11:50.109
METHAMPHETAMINE DID NOT POSITIVE
00:11:50.176 --> 00:11:51.143
SPEAKERS. PREGNANCY LOST, NOR
00:11:51.210 --> 00:11:53.446
COULD IT HAS PREGNANCY LOSS IS
00:11:53.512 --> 00:11:54.914
SO TRAUMATIC ALREADY AND IT
00:11:54.980 --> 00:11:56.115
TASTES LIKE MISS BECKER
00:11:56.182 --> 00:11:56.982
MULTIPLIES THAT TRAUMA
00:11:57.049 --> 00:11:58.851
EXPONENTIALLY. EVEN AS SHE
00:11:58.918 --> 00:12:00.252
ULTIMATELY WON HER CASE AND
00:12:00.319 --> 00:12:01.353
REGAINED HER FREEDOM. SHE SPENT
00:12:01.420 --> 00:12:02.855
16 MONTHS IN JAIL DURING COVID.
00:12:02.922 --> 00:12:04.356
SHE FOUGHT THE CHARGES FOR 19
00:12:04.423 --> 00:12:06.292
MONTHS, AND SHE LOST HER OLDER
00:12:06.358 --> 00:12:08.294
CHILD TO THE SYSTEM. IN ORDER TO
00:12:08.360 --> 00:12:10.029
PREVENT THIS FROM HAPPENING TO
00:12:10.096 --> 00:12:11.197
ANYONE ELSE IN CALIFORNIA. WE
00:12:11.263 --> 00:12:12.765
STRONGLY URGE THE COMMITTEE TO
00:12:12.832 --> 00:12:13.532
GIVE IT FULL SUPPORT TO THE
00:12:13.599 --> 00:12:14.567
SPILL TO FURTHER CLARIFY THE
00:12:14.633 --> 00:12:16.402
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MISS LEE,
00:12:16.469 --> 00:12:19.738
IF YOU COULD WRAP IT UP YES. AND
00:12:19.805 --> 00:12:22.108
UM, THAT THIS BILL WILL ALIGN
00:12:22.174 --> 00:12:23.642
WITH THE ORIGINAL INTENT OF THE
00:12:23.709 --> 00:12:24.443
LAW, WHICH WAS TO PROTECT
00:12:24.510 --> 00:12:25.744
PREGNANT PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA.
00:12:25.811 --> 00:12:27.279
THANK THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:12:27.346 --> 00:12:30.216
ALRIGHT LET'S NOW TURN TO, UM
00:12:30.282 --> 00:12:34.854
SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM 2100. IF
00:12:34.920 --> 00:12:35.621
YOU'RE IN SUPPORT IF YOU
00:12:35.688 --> 00:12:36.922
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE, GIVE US
00:12:36.989 --> 00:12:38.624
YOUR NAME, YOUR AFFILIATION AND
00:12:38.691 --> 00:12:40.726
YOUR POSITION. MR CHAIRMAN
00:12:40.793 --> 00:12:42.328
MEMBERS. I'M AARON EVANS ON
00:12:42.394 --> 00:12:44.029
BEHALF OF NARAL PRO CHOICE,
00:12:44.096 --> 00:12:45.998
CALIFORNIA, A COSPONSOR OF THIS
00:12:46.065 --> 00:12:47.399
MEASURE, AS WELL AS THE
00:12:47.466 --> 00:12:48.534
CALIFORNIA NURSE MIDWIVES
00:12:48.601 --> 00:12:49.535
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT THANK
00:12:49.602 --> 00:12:53.906
YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING,
00:12:53.973 --> 00:12:54.707
MOLLY ROBSON WITH PLANNED
00:12:54.773 --> 00:12:55.708
PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
00:12:55.774 --> 00:12:57.476
CALIFORNIA, WHERE A CO SPONSOR
00:12:57.543 --> 00:12:58.878
AND STRONG SUPPORT HAVE ALSO
00:12:58.944 --> 00:13:00.779
BEEN ASKED TO PROVIDE A SUPPORT
00:13:00.846 --> 00:13:01.780
ON BEHALF OF EQUALITY,
00:13:01.847 --> 00:13:05.251
CALIFORNIA THANK YOU. CINDY
00:13:05.317 --> 00:13:06.719
HILLARY ON BEHALF OF THE
00:13:06.785 --> 00:13:07.820
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
00:13:07.887 --> 00:13:11.257
IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
00:13:11.323 --> 00:13:12.791
GOOD MORNING, GENESIS GONZALEZ
00:13:12.858 --> 00:13:13.993
ON BEHALF OF THE TENANT
00:13:14.059 --> 00:13:14.894
GOVERNOR, LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR
00:13:14.960 --> 00:13:16.095
LENNY COULD BLOCK IS IN SUPPORT.
00:13:16.162 --> 00:13:19.365
THANK YOU. ALRIGHT OTHERS HERE
00:13:19.431 --> 00:13:21.634
IN ROOM 2100 SEEING NO ONE ELSE
00:13:21.700 --> 00:13:22.768
PRESENT MODERATE IF WE TURN TO
00:13:22.835 --> 00:13:28.440
THE PHONE. THANK YOU. YES LADIES
00:13:28.507 --> 00:13:29.808
AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU WISH TO
00:13:29.875 --> 00:13:31.343
SPEAK IN SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS
00:13:31.410 --> 00:13:39.218
ONE AND ZERO AT THIS TIME. AND
00:13:39.285 --> 00:13:40.419
FIRST WE'LL HEAR FROM LINE 68,
00:13:40.486 --> 00:13:43.522
PLEASE GO AHEAD. I'M SORRY THEY
00:13:43.589 --> 00:13:47.726
DROPPED THEMSELVES. IF YOU STILL
00:13:47.793 --> 00:13:50.796
WISH TO SPEAK, PLEASE PRESS 10.
00:13:50.863 --> 00:13:53.999
AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 37.
00:13:54.066 --> 00:13:58.437
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING.
00:13:58.504 --> 00:14:01.106
TURN MEMBERS. MY NAME IS LAUREN
00:14:01.173 --> 00:14:03.275
LATINAS FOR REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE
00:14:03.342 --> 00:14:04.410
, SPONSOR AND SUPPORT OF A B 22
00:14:04.476 --> 00:14:09.982
23. THANK YOU. AND NEXT, WE HAVE
00:14:10.049 --> 00:14:13.152
LINE 38, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:14:13.219 --> 00:14:14.753
MORNING. MY NAME IS CARLOS
00:14:14.820 --> 00:14:16.589
ROMERO, RESIDENT OF LOS ANGELES
00:14:16.655 --> 00:14:17.523
, CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:14:17.590 --> 00:14:22.161
18 22 23. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:14:22.228 --> 00:14:24.063
NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 27, PLEASE GO
00:14:24.129 --> 00:14:27.967
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, SYLVIA
00:14:28.033 --> 00:14:29.902
CASTILLO WITH ESSENTIAL ACCESS,
00:14:29.969 --> 00:14:31.537
HEALTH AND STRONG SUPPORT AND
00:14:31.604 --> 00:14:33.038
ALSO EXPRESSING SUPPORT ON
00:14:33.105 --> 00:14:35.040
BEHALF OF THE AND THE EPIDEMICS
00:14:35.107 --> 00:14:37.876
COALITION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:14:37.943 --> 00:14:39.745
. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 40, PLEASE
00:14:39.812 --> 00:14:43.849
GO AHEAD. HELLO. YES. GO AHEAD,
00:14:43.916 --> 00:14:48.754
GO AHEAD. HI MY NAME'S WILLIAM
00:14:48.821 --> 00:14:50.990
BED IN COURT. I'M A MEMBER OF
00:14:51.056 --> 00:14:52.091
NARROW APPROACHING CALIFORNIA. I
00:14:52.157 --> 00:14:53.192
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS BILL.
00:14:53.259 --> 00:14:55.995
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANKS FOR
00:14:56.061 --> 00:14:59.465
YOUR FINE. 63. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:14:59.531 --> 00:15:02.701
GOOD MORNING SALON. THIS ACTION
00:15:02.768 --> 00:15:04.770
PROJECT ABOUT THEM SPONSOR AND
00:15:04.837 --> 00:15:05.938
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY
00:15:06.005 --> 00:15:09.208
MUCH. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE
00:15:09.275 --> 00:15:12.478
LINES 78, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:15:12.544 --> 00:15:13.879
MORNING, MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
00:15:13.946 --> 00:15:15.047
CURTISS FLYING WITH THE
00:15:15.114 --> 00:15:16.081
CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION IN
00:15:16.148 --> 00:15:17.216
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
00:15:17.283 --> 00:15:19.852
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 19,
00:15:19.918 --> 00:15:23.622
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING.
00:15:23.689 --> 00:15:25.090
THIS IS LAURA JIMENEZ, EXECUTIVE
00:15:25.157 --> 00:15:26.892
DIRECTOR AT CALIFORNIA, LATINAS
00:15:26.959 --> 00:15:27.459
TO REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE AND
00:15:27.526 --> 00:15:28.661
RESIDENT OF SENATE-DISTRICT 18
00:15:28.727 --> 00:15:29.928
IN BURBANK IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:15:29.995 --> 00:15:33.432
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. NEGATIVE
00:15:33.499 --> 00:15:38.237
LINE. 41, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
00:15:38.304 --> 00:15:39.938
GOOD MORNING, CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
00:15:40.005 --> 00:15:40.706
MY NAME IS MARICELA. I'M A
00:15:40.773 --> 00:15:42.908
RESIDENT OF NORTH ORANGE COUNTY
00:15:42.975 --> 00:15:44.043
. AND I'M STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS
00:15:44.109 --> 00:15:45.844
STUFF. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE
00:15:45.911 --> 00:15:52.084
LINE 31, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:15:52.151 --> 00:15:53.719
COMMITTING TO OUR MEMBERS, OFTEN
00:15:53.786 --> 00:15:55.254
WITH HULU CALIFORNIA ACTION,
00:15:55.321 --> 00:15:56.822
CALLING IN STRONG SUPPORT AND
00:15:56.889 --> 00:15:58.023
OTHER TOPICS. I WANT TO THANK
00:15:58.090 --> 00:16:00.526
YOU. THANK YOU. MAY PROVE LINE
00:16:00.592 --> 00:16:05.764
34, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MORNING
00:16:05.831 --> 00:16:06.765
SHARON MEMBERS. THIS IS ASHLEY
00:16:06.832 --> 00:16:08.834
LOPEZ, AND I'M, A RESIDENT IN
00:16:08.901 --> 00:16:10.536
LOS ANGELES IN SUPPORT OF THIS,
00:16:10.602 --> 00:16:14.673
BILL, THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
00:16:14.740 --> 00:16:18.077
JUST LINE 70, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:16:18.143 --> 00:16:19.611
GOOD MORNING. THIS IS MARIANNE
00:16:19.678 --> 00:16:21.613
CHERRY. I'M IN LOS ANGELES, A
00:16:21.680 --> 00:16:23.716
MEMBER OF NARAL PRO CHOICE
00:16:23.782 --> 00:16:24.783
CALIFORNIA AND I'M VERY
00:16:24.850 --> 00:16:28.253
EMOTIONAL SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
00:16:28.320 --> 00:16:29.421
NEXT JUST LINE 28, PLEASE GO
00:16:29.488 --> 00:16:34.460
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:16:34.526 --> 00:16:36.595
MARTA PENA. I AM A RESIDENT IN
00:16:36.662 --> 00:16:38.931
EAST L A. AND I'M STRONG SUPPORT
00:16:38.997 --> 00:16:43.602
OF 20 TO 26. HERE. NEXT WE HAVE
00:16:43.669 --> 00:16:47.239
LINE 76, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:16:47.306 --> 00:16:48.674
MORNING, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:16:48.741 --> 00:16:51.110
KATHY VAN OSTEN, REPRESENTING
00:16:51.176 --> 00:16:52.378
THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF
00:16:52.444 --> 00:16:54.346
UNIVERSITY WOMEN, CALIFORNIA
00:16:54.413 --> 00:16:55.681
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 22 23. THANK
00:16:55.748 --> 00:16:59.551
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 82,
00:16:59.618 --> 00:17:06.291
PLEASE GO AHEAD. PRIVATE HUNT,
00:17:06.358 --> 00:17:07.860
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF PEACH AND
00:17:07.926 --> 00:17:10.095
SUPPORT OF A D 22 TO 3. THANK
00:17:10.162 --> 00:17:14.133
YOU. THANK YOU. AND LAST WE HAVE
00:17:14.199 --> 00:17:17.870
LINED 49. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:17:17.936 --> 00:17:19.605
MORNING. MY NAME IS LEE. OSAMA
00:17:19.671 --> 00:17:20.939
AND I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
00:17:21.006 --> 00:17:22.608
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES AND THE
00:17:22.674 --> 00:17:23.742
STRONGER CALIFORNIA AT THE HITS
00:17:23.809 --> 00:17:25.110
THEM IN STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
00:17:25.177 --> 00:17:29.014
YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT WAS ALL
00:17:29.081 --> 00:17:30.916
WE HAD IN Q. RIGHT NOW, LET'S
00:17:30.983 --> 00:17:33.352
TURN THE OPPOSITION AND THE
00:17:33.419 --> 00:17:38.090
PROPONENTS, UM. WENT OVER A BIT
00:17:38.157 --> 00:17:39.892
. UH THEY TOOK FIVE MINUTES AND
00:17:39.958 --> 00:17:41.927
15 SECONDS AND SO IN ORDER TO
00:17:41.994 --> 00:17:45.597
PROVIDE EQUAL TREATMENT. THE
00:17:45.664 --> 00:17:47.366
OPPONENTS WILL BE AFFORDED THE
00:17:47.433 --> 00:17:49.334
SAME FIVE MINUTES AND 15 SECONDS
00:17:49.401 --> 00:17:51.470
. ALRIGHT UM IN TERMS OF PRIMARY
00:17:51.537 --> 00:17:54.139
WITNESSES IN OPPOSITION. AH, WE
00:17:54.206 --> 00:18:02.714
HAVE. SUSAN ARNELL IN MATTHEW
00:18:02.781 --> 00:18:04.316
MCREYNOLDS HERE IN OPPOSITION TO
00:18:04.383 --> 00:18:07.519
A B 22 23. MISS DARNELL. I SEE
00:18:07.586 --> 00:18:09.721
YOU AT THE MICROPHONE. GO AHEAD.
00:18:09.788 --> 00:18:11.457
THANK YOU. MY NAME IS SUSAN
00:18:11.523 --> 00:18:13.025
ARNEL. I AM A CALIFORNIA
00:18:13.091 --> 00:18:14.259
ATTORNEY AND THE VICE PRESIDENT
00:18:14.326 --> 00:18:16.128
OF LEGAL AFFAIRS FOR THE RIGHT
00:18:16.195 --> 00:18:18.096
TO LIFE LEAGUE, AMERICA'S FIRST
00:18:18.163 --> 00:18:20.632
PRO LIFE ORGANIZATION, ALTHOUGH
00:18:20.699 --> 00:18:23.335
THIS BILL'S STATED PURPOSE IS TO
00:18:23.402 --> 00:18:25.204
SHIELD PREGNANT MOTHERS FROM
00:18:25.270 --> 00:18:27.372
PROSECUTION FOR PREGNANCY LOSS A
00:18:27.439 --> 00:18:30.409
B 22 23 IS A HORRIFIC ATTACK ON
00:18:30.476 --> 00:18:33.879
LIFE AND WOMEN'S HEALTH SECTION
00:18:33.946 --> 00:18:36.882
78 OF THE BILL OVERRIDES ALL
00:18:36.949 --> 00:18:38.517
EXISTING RESTRICTIONS ON
00:18:38.584 --> 00:18:40.486
ABORTIONS BY GRANTING TOTAL
00:18:40.552 --> 00:18:42.454
CIVIL AND CRIMINAL IMMUNITY TO
00:18:42.521 --> 00:18:43.822
MOTHERS NO MATTER HOW THEY
00:18:43.889 --> 00:18:44.890
CHOOSE TO OBTAIN THEIR
00:18:44.957 --> 00:18:47.593
ABORTIONS. SEVEN B WILL GIVE
00:18:47.659 --> 00:18:50.229
TOTAL CIVIL AND CRIMINAL
00:18:50.295 --> 00:18:53.398
IMMUNITY TO ALL COOPERATORS FOR
00:18:53.465 --> 00:18:55.334
ANY ACTIONS THEY DO LEGAL OR
00:18:55.400 --> 00:18:58.470
ILLEGAL UP TO AND BEYOND BIRTH.
00:18:58.537 --> 00:19:00.839
SO LONG AS THE MOTHER CONSENTS
00:19:00.906 --> 00:19:02.975
COOPERATORS COULD BE LICENSED
00:19:03.041 --> 00:19:05.978
ABORTIONISTS OR ANYONE WHO HELPS
00:19:06.044 --> 00:19:07.513
BRING ABOUT A PREGNANCY OUTCOME
00:19:07.579 --> 00:19:09.414
, REGARDLESS OF THEIR LACK OF
00:19:09.481 --> 00:19:11.950
TRAINING OR LACK OF LICENSE.
00:19:12.017 --> 00:19:13.185
SECTION SEVEN B IS BROAD GRANT
00:19:13.252 --> 00:19:16.588
OF IMMUNITY. WILL POTENTIALLY
00:19:16.655 --> 00:19:19.091
REMOVE STATE LICENSING AND
00:19:19.157 --> 00:19:21.093
OVERSIGHT OF PREGNANCY OUTCOMES
00:19:21.159 --> 00:19:22.728
, INCLUDING ABORTION, AND IT
00:19:22.794 --> 00:19:24.396
WILL EVISCERATE EXISTING HEALTH
00:19:24.463 --> 00:19:25.964
REGULATIONS DESIGNED TO PROTECT
00:19:26.031 --> 00:19:29.701
PREGNANT WOMEN. SECTION NINE
00:19:29.768 --> 00:19:30.802
WILL PROVIDE A PENALTY OF
00:19:30.869 --> 00:19:33.605
$25,000 PLUS ATTORNEY'S FEES
00:19:33.672 --> 00:19:36.008
AGAINST LAW ENFORCEMENT OR
00:19:36.074 --> 00:19:38.043
ANYONE WHO THREATENS TO
00:19:38.110 --> 00:19:39.177
INVESTIGATE A MOM OR A
00:19:39.244 --> 00:19:41.980
COOPERATOR. THIS INCLUDES
00:19:42.047 --> 00:19:44.082
MANDATED REPORTERS, PRACTICALLY
00:19:44.149 --> 00:19:47.019
SPEAKING, THAT MEANS NO ONE WILL
00:19:47.085 --> 00:19:48.086
DARE INVESTIGATE ANY INFANT
00:19:48.153 --> 00:19:51.490
DEATH WHATSOEVER. WHEN COUPLED
00:19:51.557 --> 00:19:52.991
WITH SCHNUR, THE ABORTION
00:19:53.058 --> 00:19:54.126
AMENDMENT TO THE STATE
00:19:54.192 --> 00:19:57.596
CONSTITUTION. A B 22 23 WILL
00:19:57.663 --> 00:19:59.865
LEGALIZE ABORTION ON DEMAND
00:19:59.932 --> 00:20:02.100
PERFORMED BY ANYONE, REGARDLESS
00:20:02.167 --> 00:20:03.035
OF MEDICAL MEDICAL
00:20:03.101 --> 00:20:06.038
QUALIFICATIONS. FROM THE MOMENT
00:20:06.104 --> 00:20:07.439
OF CONCEPTION TO DELIVERY AND
00:20:07.506 --> 00:20:11.176
BEYOND. TAKE A LOOK AT THE
00:20:11.243 --> 00:20:12.744
LANGUAGE OF THE BILL. IT IS SO
00:20:12.811 --> 00:20:14.446
POORLY WRITTEN, IT NEEDS TO BE
00:20:14.513 --> 00:20:16.515
GUTTED, OR IT WILL PUT WOMEN AT
00:20:16.582 --> 00:20:17.983
RISK IF THE TRUE PURPOSE OF THE
00:20:18.050 --> 00:20:19.985
BILL IS TO PROTECT MOTHERS FROM
00:20:20.052 --> 00:20:21.019
PROSECUTION FOR PREGNANCY
00:20:21.086 --> 00:20:22.521
OUTCOMES. THE BILL HAS FAILED
00:20:22.588 --> 00:20:25.490
MISERABLY. 22 23 WILL ABSOLUTELY
00:20:25.557 --> 00:20:26.491
NOT PROTECT WOMEN. IT WILL
00:20:26.558 --> 00:20:27.492
ENDANGER THEM. PLEASE VOTE. NO,
00:20:27.559 --> 00:20:31.029
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MR
00:20:31.096 --> 00:20:36.234
MCREYNOLDS IS HERE. MR CHAIRMAN
00:20:36.301 --> 00:20:37.869
. ACTUALLY MY NAME IS MILTON
00:20:37.936 --> 00:20:38.604
MATCH CHECK AND THE STAFF
00:20:38.670 --> 00:20:39.638
ATTORNEY WITH PACIFIC JUSTICE
00:20:39.705 --> 00:20:41.073
INSTITUTE. MR MCDONALD'S HAS THE
00:20:41.139 --> 00:20:42.908
YEAR LATEST TIME TO ME. THERE
00:20:42.975 --> 00:20:44.343
WAS WE TRIED TO COMMUNICATE THAT
00:20:44.409 --> 00:20:45.811
WITH THE COMMITTEE, BUT THIS
00:20:45.877 --> 00:20:46.912
DIDN'T HAPPEN. GO AHEAD, SIR.
00:20:46.979 --> 00:20:48.614
THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING,
00:20:48.680 --> 00:20:50.616
SENATORS. THANK YOU FOR HEARING
00:20:50.682 --> 00:20:51.717
ME ON THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE
00:20:51.783 --> 00:20:53.986
BEFORE YOU TODAY AS I SAID, MY
00:20:54.052 --> 00:20:55.120
NAME IS MILTON DATUK I'M
00:20:55.187 --> 00:20:56.288
CURRENTLY A STAFF ATTORNEY WAS
00:20:56.355 --> 00:20:57.356
PACIFIC JUSTICE INSTITUTE. I'M A
00:20:57.422 --> 00:20:59.725
RETIRED PROSECUTOR OF 18.5 YEARS
00:20:59.791 --> 00:21:01.393
EXPERIENCE AS A DEPUTY, D A FOR
00:21:01.460 --> 00:21:03.328
A SMALL CALIFORNIA COUNTY D A S
00:21:03.395 --> 00:21:05.230
OFFICE. PROSECUTORS AND LAW
00:21:05.297 --> 00:21:07.232
ENFORCEMENT IN GENERAL ARE
00:21:07.299 --> 00:21:08.800
TASKED WITH THE DUTY TO
00:21:08.867 --> 00:21:09.468
INVESTIGATE AND PROSECUTE CRIMES
00:21:09.534 --> 00:21:10.535
AGAINST THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE
00:21:10.602 --> 00:21:12.771
OF CALIFORNIA. WITHIN THAT DUTY
00:21:12.838 --> 00:21:14.506
THERE TO PROTECT THE MOST
00:21:14.573 --> 00:21:17.209
VULNERABLE. AMONG THOSE
00:21:17.275 --> 00:21:18.243
VULNERABLE ARE PREGNANT WOMEN
00:21:18.310 --> 00:21:19.444
AND THE UNBORN CHILD WITHIN THE
00:21:19.511 --> 00:21:21.913
WOMB. THIS BILL UNDER THE GUISE
00:21:21.980 --> 00:21:23.415
OF REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH, WHICH
00:21:23.482 --> 00:21:24.983
THEREFORE DEALS WITH HUMAN
00:21:25.050 --> 00:21:27.252
BEINGS IN THE WOMB LIMITS CHILLS
00:21:27.319 --> 00:21:28.520
AND EVEN TRIES TO PERSUADE
00:21:28.587 --> 00:21:29.554
AGAINST THE PROSECUTION OF
00:21:29.621 --> 00:21:30.856
POTENTIAL CRIMES. AGAINST WOMEN
00:21:30.922 --> 00:21:33.725
AND THEIR UNBORN CHILD.
00:21:33.792 --> 00:21:36.094
ESPECIALLY WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF
00:21:36.161 --> 00:21:38.397
D A S. THERE ARE ALREADY ETHICAL
00:21:38.463 --> 00:21:39.931
STANDARDS IN PLACE TO GUARD
00:21:39.998 --> 00:21:40.766
AGAINST PROSECUTORIAL
00:21:40.832 --> 00:21:42.901
MISCONDUCT. AND THE BRINGING OF
00:21:42.968 --> 00:21:43.902
CHARGES AGAINST THE BLATANTLY
00:21:43.969 --> 00:21:46.805
INNOCENT. WHY GIVE SOMEONE TO
00:21:46.872 --> 00:21:48.073
WRITE TO SUE A PROSECUTOR FOR
00:21:48.140 --> 00:21:51.610
SIMPLY DOING THEIR JOB? A B 22
00:21:51.677 --> 00:21:53.445
TO 3 SEEMS TO DO MORE TO PROTECT
00:21:53.512 --> 00:21:55.347
THE SPECIAL INTERESTS AND THE
00:21:55.414 --> 00:21:57.015
CRIMINAL OFFENDERS RATHER THAN
00:21:57.082 --> 00:21:58.083
THE VULNERABLE WOMEN AND THE
00:21:58.150 --> 00:22:00.986
UNBORN CHILD. PLEASE DO DO YOUR
00:22:01.053 --> 00:22:02.387
DUTY TO PROTECT THE MOST
00:22:02.454 --> 00:22:03.955
VULNERABLE OF HUMAN BEINGS. AND
00:22:04.022 --> 00:22:06.024
DO NOT LET A BE 2 TO 3 OUT OF
00:22:06.091 --> 00:22:09.394
COMMITTEE. THIS BILL. A B 2223
00:22:09.461 --> 00:22:12.798
IS A SWORD AND A SHIELD. BUT
00:22:12.864 --> 00:22:13.965
THIS IT SHIELDS THE CRIMINAL
00:22:14.032 --> 00:22:17.602
OFFENDER. NOT THE INNOCENT AND
00:22:17.669 --> 00:22:19.805
IS A SWORD AGAINST THOSE WHO ARE
00:22:19.871 --> 00:22:21.840
ENTRUSTED WITH PROTECTING THE
00:22:21.907 --> 00:22:22.908
INNOCENT AND PROSECUTING THE
00:22:22.974 --> 00:22:26.111
CRIMINALLY GUILTY. IT DOES THE
00:22:26.178 --> 00:22:28.046
EXACT OPPOSITE OF WHAT IT IS
00:22:28.113 --> 00:22:31.483
PROPOSED TO BE DOING. PENAL CODE
00:22:31.550 --> 00:22:32.984
. 1 87, FOR EXAMPLE, DEFINES
00:22:33.051 --> 00:22:34.486
MURDER IS THE UNLAWFUL KILLING
00:22:34.553 --> 00:22:36.354
OF A HUMAN BEING OR A FETUS WITH
00:22:36.421 --> 00:22:38.090
MALICE AFORETHOUGHT. SO WHAT IF
00:22:38.156 --> 00:22:39.624
LAW ENFORCEMENT SUSPECTS THAT
00:22:39.691 --> 00:22:40.525
THERE MAY BE THE POSSIBILITY OF
00:22:40.592 --> 00:22:42.694
A MURDER OF AN UNBORN CHILD AS A
00:22:42.761 --> 00:22:44.496
RESULT OF, SAY, AND UNLAWFUL,
00:22:44.563 --> 00:22:45.697
AIDING AND ABETTING OF ABORTION?
00:22:45.764 --> 00:22:48.333
WILL THEY BE CHILLED? MAYBE EVEN
00:22:48.400 --> 00:22:49.334
FRIGHTENED EVEN FROM
00:22:49.401 --> 00:22:50.736
INVESTIGATING OR PROSECUTING
00:22:50.802 --> 00:22:52.170
BECAUSE OF FEAR OF RETALIATORY
00:22:52.237 --> 00:22:55.006
LAWSUITS AGAINST HIM, WHICH ARE
00:22:55.073 --> 00:22:57.943
ENCOURAGED BY A B 2223. IF THERE
00:22:58.009 --> 00:22:59.344
IS A POSSIBILITY OF, SAY,
00:22:59.411 --> 00:23:01.113
CRIMINAL NEGLIGENCE OR MEDICAL
00:23:01.179 --> 00:23:02.013
MALPRACTICE, CRIMINAL
00:23:02.080 --> 00:23:06.618
NEGLIGENCE. INVOLVED IN THE
00:23:06.685 --> 00:23:09.121
DEATH OF AN UNBORN CHILD. WILL
00:23:09.187 --> 00:23:10.122
ANY INVESTIGATION OR PROSECUTION
00:23:10.188 --> 00:23:11.957
BE DENIED? AND THAT CRIMINAL
00:23:12.023 --> 00:23:14.493
NEGLIGENCE BE PROTECTED BECAUSE
00:23:14.559 --> 00:23:15.927
OF THE PROTECTIONS AFFORDED THE
00:23:15.994 --> 00:23:16.862
OFFENDER OUTLINED WITHIN THIS
00:23:16.928 --> 00:23:21.199
BILL. A B 22 TO 3 CHILLS,
00:23:21.266 --> 00:23:24.102
PROSECUTORIAL DISCRETION, CHILLS
00:23:24.169 --> 00:23:26.838
VALID LEGAL LAW ENFORCEMENT
00:23:26.905 --> 00:23:28.106
INVESTIGATIONS OF DEATHS OF THE
00:23:28.173 --> 00:23:32.911
UNBORN. AND LIMITS THEIR ABILITY
00:23:32.978 --> 00:23:34.780
TO USE CERTAIN EVIDENCE, SUCH AS
00:23:34.846 --> 00:23:36.748
CORONER'S REPORT TO DECDE
00:23:36.815 --> 00:23:38.483
WHETHER A CRIME IF YOU COULD
00:23:38.550 --> 00:23:41.086
WRAP IT UP. YES THANK YOU AGAIN.
00:23:41.153 --> 00:23:42.020
I STRONGLY URGE FROM
00:23:42.087 --> 00:23:43.088
PROSECUTORIAL. I AM A RETIRED
00:23:43.155 --> 00:23:45.757
PROSECUTOR. BUT AFTER SPENDING
00:23:45.824 --> 00:23:47.859
18.5 YEARS IN THERE, I STRONGLY
00:23:47.926 --> 00:23:50.529
URGE YOU TO VOTE. NO AGAINST
00:23:50.595 --> 00:23:51.630
THIS, BILL. THANK YOU. THANK
00:23:51.696 --> 00:23:54.099
YOU. ALL RIGHT. UM OTHERS IN
00:23:54.166 --> 00:23:56.001
ROOM 2100 WHO WISH TO TESTIFY IN
00:23:56.067 --> 00:23:59.538
OPPOSITION TO A B 22 TO 3,
00:23:59.604 --> 00:24:01.006
PLEASE APPROACH MICROPHONE AND
00:24:01.072 --> 00:24:02.207
STATE YOUR NAME YOUR AFFILIATION
00:24:02.274 --> 00:24:04.109
YOUR POSITION. JAMES COOK,
00:24:04.176 --> 00:24:05.177
PASTOR, LIGHTHOUSE BAPTIST
00:24:05.243 --> 00:24:06.178
CHURCH AND CONQUERED. I ALSO
00:24:06.244 --> 00:24:10.682
REPRESENT UM, PROJECT TRUTH. AND
00:24:10.749 --> 00:24:12.284
I AM STRONG OPPOSITION OF THIS
00:24:12.350 --> 00:24:14.052
BILL, AND YOU OUGHT TO BE
00:24:14.119 --> 00:24:18.557
ASHAMED OF YOURSELVES. THIS IS
00:24:18.623 --> 00:24:19.724
DIFFERENT. GABRIELLE INGRAM,
00:24:19.791 --> 00:24:21.092
FOUNDER OF STANDARD SACRAMENTO
00:24:21.159 --> 00:24:23.261
COUNTY. WE OPPOSE THIS BILL.
00:24:23.328 --> 00:24:24.362
EVEN WITH THE AMENDMENT. THANK
00:24:24.429 --> 00:24:28.667
YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING. MY
00:24:28.733 --> 00:24:30.569
NAME IS TERRY. HEY, COBIAN. I AM
00:24:30.635 --> 00:24:32.470
HERE ON BEHALF OF ROCK HARBOR
00:24:32.537 --> 00:24:34.105
CHURCH, BAKERSFIELD, AS WELL AS
00:24:34.172 --> 00:24:36.875
CALVARY. VISALIA VISALIA. UM
00:24:36.942 --> 00:24:38.610
CHAPTERS I AM WITH THREE
00:24:38.677 --> 00:24:39.744
DIFFERENT COALITIONS TO LARRY
00:24:39.811 --> 00:24:42.647
COUNTY FREEDOM. UH HUH.
00:24:42.714 --> 00:24:45.584
BLESSINGS OF LIBERTY AS WELL AS
00:24:45.650 --> 00:24:48.587
, UM, TO LARRY, UM, COALITION.
00:24:48.653 --> 00:24:51.156
WE ARE STANDING ALL OF US IN
00:24:51.223 --> 00:24:53.458
VIOLENT OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL
00:24:53.525 --> 00:24:54.960
, REGARDLESS OF THE AMENDMENTS,
00:24:55.026 --> 00:24:56.661
IT IS MURDER. THANK YOU FOR
00:24:56.728 --> 00:25:01.833
LISTENING. HELLO MY NAME IS LEE
00:25:01.900 --> 00:25:02.767
ANDREW LUCK. I WORK WITH
00:25:02.834 --> 00:25:03.501
CALIFORNIA FAMILY COUNCIL AND I
00:25:03.568 --> 00:25:05.503
STRONGLY OPPOSE A B 22 23. THANK
00:25:05.570 --> 00:25:08.740
YOU. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. GOOD
00:25:08.807 --> 00:25:10.876
MORNING PASHA WILLIAMS ON BEHALF
00:25:10.942 --> 00:25:11.810
OF JAMES P. BRADLEY AND LADIES
00:25:11.877 --> 00:25:13.612
OF LIBERTY. WE STRONGLY OPPOSE
00:25:13.678 --> 00:25:17.749
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:25:17.816 --> 00:25:19.317
GREG BURKE WITH THE CALIFORNIA
00:25:19.384 --> 00:25:20.785
FAMILY COUNSELING OPPOSITION.
00:25:20.852 --> 00:25:21.386
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ALRIGHT,
00:25:21.453 --> 00:25:22.454
MODERATOR, LET'S TURN TO THE
00:25:22.520 --> 00:25:26.558
PHONE. UM IF THOSE WHO ARE IN
00:25:26.625 --> 00:25:27.692
OPPOSITION TO 22 23 COULD BE
00:25:27.759 --> 00:25:30.328
QUEUED UP. IN STATE, THEIR NAME
00:25:30.395 --> 00:25:31.329
THEIR AFFILIATION IN THEIR
00:25:31.396 --> 00:25:35.233
POSITION. MODERATOR. THANK YOU
00:25:35.300 --> 00:25:37.235
IN ORDER TO SPEAK, PLEASE PRESS
00:25:37.302 --> 00:25:40.972
10 AT THIS TIME. AND WE WILL
00:25:41.039 --> 00:25:42.941
START WITH BUYING 68. PLEASE GO
00:25:43.008 --> 00:25:47.679
AHEAD. 68 IS THAT ME? THERE WAS
00:25:47.746 --> 00:25:49.347
SOME ISSUES WITH THE PHONE. CAN
00:25:49.414 --> 00:25:50.615
I BE HEARD IN SENATE JUDICIARY
00:25:50.682 --> 00:25:54.719
YOU'RE ON. EXCELLENT I AM
00:25:54.786 --> 00:25:57.322
CALLING TO REPRESENT, SUCH AS
00:25:57.389 --> 00:26:00.759
MYSELF MILLIONS OF PRO CHOICE.
00:26:00.825 --> 00:26:03.795
CALIFORNIANS I HAVE HAD TWO
00:26:03.862 --> 00:26:05.297
ABORTIONS. THANK YOU. COULD YOU
00:26:05.363 --> 00:26:06.364
AGAINST THIS BILL IN YOUR
00:26:06.431 --> 00:26:11.469
POSITION? MY AFFILIATION IS A
00:26:11.536 --> 00:26:13.538
CALIFORNIAN WHO HAS HAD TWO
00:26:13.605 --> 00:26:15.974
ABORTIONS AND I AM AGAINST THIS
00:26:16.041 --> 00:26:19.144
BILL. NEXT CALLER. NEXT WE HAVE
00:26:19.210 --> 00:26:25.784
LINE 81, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO
00:26:25.850 --> 00:26:27.085
IS THIS LINE 81? YOU LOVE THE
00:26:27.152 --> 00:26:30.989
SENSORS WORK. YOUR PHONES. DON'T
00:26:31.056 --> 00:26:33.858
WORK WITH YOUR YOUR NAME YOUR ON
00:26:33.925 --> 00:26:35.060
YOUR NAME YOUR AFFILIATION IN
00:26:35.126 --> 00:26:36.161
YOUR POSITION. FACE THAT PEOPLE
00:26:36.227 --> 00:26:40.865
WERE. ALL RIGHT. NEXT CALLER,
00:26:40.932 --> 00:26:46.571
PLEASE SUPPORTING THEM. NEXT
00:26:46.638 --> 00:26:49.975
CALLER. YOU HEAR ME? YES WE CAN
00:26:50.041 --> 00:26:52.978
HEAD. MY NAME IS VERONICA. I AM
00:26:53.044 --> 00:26:54.512
A RESIDENT OF THE COUNTY AND I
00:26:54.579 --> 00:26:56.948
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED A V 22 TO
00:26:57.015 --> 00:26:59.184
3. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK
00:26:59.250 --> 00:27:00.352
YOU. NEXT. WE HAVE LINE 58,
00:27:00.418 --> 00:27:04.723
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS TONY
00:27:04.789 --> 00:27:06.591
ROBLES WITH CAPITAL RESOURCE
00:27:06.658 --> 00:27:07.692
INSTITUTE IN OPPOSITION FOR A V
00:27:07.759 --> 00:27:10.962
22 23. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:27:11.029 --> 00:27:12.797
NEXT MOVE LINE. 12, PLEASE GO
00:27:12.864 --> 00:27:16.234
AHEAD. YES MY NAME IS PATRICIA
00:27:16.301 --> 00:27:17.869
HUBERT AND CALLING FROM
00:27:17.936 --> 00:27:19.604
PRESIDENT CALIFORNIA AND I
00:27:19.671 --> 00:27:21.806
STRONGLY OPPOSED THIS BILL AS A
00:27:21.873 --> 00:27:23.775
MOM WHO HAS SUFFERED A
00:27:23.842 --> 00:27:26.378
MISCARRIAGE. THANK YOU. THIS
00:27:26.444 --> 00:27:28.079
BILL, THANK YOU. AND NEXT WE
00:27:28.146 --> 00:27:29.781
HAVE LINED 70 AIRLINE 85, PLEASE
00:27:29.848 --> 00:27:36.621
GO AHEAD. BY AN 85. YOUR LINE IS
00:27:36.688 --> 00:27:43.294
OPEN. HELLO. YES. GO AHEAD. HI.
00:27:43.361 --> 00:27:45.363
MY NAME IS ELIZABETH FUEL, AND
00:27:45.430 --> 00:27:47.232
I'M A RESIDENT OF ELDORADO
00:27:47.298 --> 00:27:48.400
COUNTY, AND I STRONGLY OPPOSED
00:27:48.466 --> 00:27:52.437
THIS BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:27:52.504 --> 00:27:53.671
NEXT. WE HAVE LINES. 71, PLEASE
00:27:53.738 --> 00:28:00.311
GO AHEAD. 9 71. YOUR LINE IS
00:28:00.378 --> 00:28:07.585
OPEN. YES. THIS IS VICKY RAIN
00:28:07.652 --> 00:28:09.754
KEY TALAVERA COUNTY RESIDENT AND
00:28:09.821 --> 00:28:12.490
I AM OPPOSED TO 2 TO 3. THANK
00:28:12.557 --> 00:28:14.659
YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 25, PLEASE
00:28:14.726 --> 00:28:20.865
GO AHEAD. SHEILA GREEN WITH THE
00:28:20.932 --> 00:28:21.800
CALIFORNIA LIFE COUNCIL AND
00:28:21.866 --> 00:28:24.502
OPPOSITION TO ASSEMBLY BILL 22.
00:28:24.569 --> 00:28:27.705
23 THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND LAST
00:28:27.772 --> 00:28:29.574
WE HAVE LINE 47, PLEASE GO
00:28:29.641 --> 00:28:36.081
AHEAD. CAN YOU HEAR ME? CAN.
00:28:36.147 --> 00:28:37.515
THIS ISJENNIFER KLEPTO,
00:28:37.582 --> 00:28:39.884
RIVERSIDE COUNTY WITH FAITH,
00:28:39.951 --> 00:28:41.553
FAMILY AND LIFE COALITION. WE
00:28:41.619 --> 00:28:42.954
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK
00:28:43.021 --> 00:28:48.560
YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL
00:28:48.626 --> 00:28:50.328
I HAD IN.Q ALRIGHT, LET'S BRING
00:28:50.395 --> 00:28:51.830
IT BACK HERE TO COMMITTEE
00:28:51.896 --> 00:28:53.765
HEARING ROOM QUESTIONS, COMMENTS
00:28:53.832 --> 00:28:54.632
BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS. NO
00:28:54.699 --> 00:28:58.369
QUESTIONS, ALRIGHT. UM. THIS IS
00:28:58.436 --> 00:29:00.105
A SUBCOMMITTEE. SO WHEN THE
00:29:00.171 --> 00:29:01.172
QUARANTINE AQUARIUM IS
00:29:01.239 --> 00:29:02.273
ESTABLISHED, AND FULL COMMITTEE
00:29:02.340 --> 00:29:03.341
APPEARS, I EXPECT THERE'LL BE
00:29:03.408 --> 00:29:04.275
EMOTION. SEVEN MEMBER WEEKS. YOU
00:29:04.342 --> 00:29:07.846
CARE TO CLOSE AND I VOTE. THANK
00:29:07.912 --> 00:29:09.080
YOU. ALL RIGHT. NEXT UP. YOU
00:29:09.147 --> 00:29:14.953
HAVE A B 2777 AND JUST AS AN
00:29:15.019 --> 00:29:16.955
ANNOUNCEMENT HOUSEKEEPING MATTER
00:29:17.021 --> 00:29:19.357
, UM S CHN SENATE CONSTITUTIONAL
00:29:19.424 --> 00:29:21.526
MEMBER 10 WILL BE HEARD AT 1 30
00:29:21.593 --> 00:29:24.329
THIS AFTERNOON. BUT AFTER
00:29:24.395 --> 00:29:25.897
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS PRESENTS
00:29:25.964 --> 00:29:30.502
A B 2777, WE WILL THEN TURN TO
00:29:30.568 --> 00:29:34.272
REMEMBER FOUR A B 16 66 AND ITEM
00:29:34.339 --> 00:29:37.742
NUMBER FIVE A B 25 71.
00:29:37.809 --> 00:29:39.577
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS. GO AHEAD
00:29:39.644 --> 00:29:41.479
. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR
00:29:41.546 --> 00:29:46.251
AND COMMITTEE MEMBER A B 22 77 6
00:29:46.317 --> 00:29:48.019
TO ACCOUNT FOR THE NATURAL DELAY
00:29:48.086 --> 00:29:49.320
THAT OCCURS AFTER A TRAUMATIC
00:29:49.387 --> 00:29:50.355
EXPERIENCE LIKE SEXUAL ASSAULT
00:29:50.421 --> 00:29:52.023
OR HARASSMENT. BY CREATING A
00:29:52.090 --> 00:29:53.458
PATHWAY FOR SURVIVORS TO BRING
00:29:53.525 --> 00:29:54.692
THEIR CASE TO COURT WHEN THEIR
00:29:54.759 --> 00:29:55.660
CLAIMS WOULD HAVE OTHERWISE BEEN
00:29:55.727 --> 00:29:57.495
BARRED SOLELY BECAUSE THE TIME
00:29:57.562 --> 00:29:58.863
HAS RUN OUT. THIS INCLUDES
00:29:58.930 --> 00:30:00.098
CLAIMS AGAINST THE DEFENDANT
00:30:00.165 --> 00:30:01.833
ENTITY WHO HAS ENGAGED IN A
00:30:01.900 --> 00:30:04.102
COVER UP OF A PRIOR INCIDENT OF
00:30:04.169 --> 00:30:06.237
SEXUAL ABUSE OR MISCONDUCT. THE
00:30:06.304 --> 00:30:07.672
LANGUAGE OF THIS BILL IS NOT NEW
00:30:07.739 --> 00:30:10.074
AND FOLLOWS THE SAME DISTINCTIVE
00:30:10.141 --> 00:30:10.708
AND FEASIBLE FRAMEWORK SURVIVORS
00:30:10.775 --> 00:30:11.609
ACROSS THE STATE AND IN OTHER
00:30:11.676 --> 00:30:13.444
STATES AND IN THIS LEGISLATIVE
00:30:13.511 --> 00:30:14.445
BODY HAS ALREADY SHOWN TO
00:30:14.512 --> 00:30:16.314
SUPPORT AND TRUST NOTHING IN
00:30:16.381 --> 00:30:17.549
THIS BILL CHANGES OR SHIFTS THE
00:30:17.615 --> 00:30:20.518
BURDEN OF PROOF. SURVIVORS AND
00:30:20.585 --> 00:30:21.686
THEIR COUNSEL STILL MUST PROVE
00:30:21.753 --> 00:30:23.588
ALL THE ELEMENTS OF THEIR CLAIM.
00:30:23.655 --> 00:30:25.356
WITH ME TO TESTIFY ABOUT THE
00:30:25.423 --> 00:30:26.658
IMPORTANCE OF COURT ACCESS FOR
00:30:26.724 --> 00:30:28.126
SURVIVORS IS SAMANTHA MALONEY,
00:30:28.193 --> 00:30:29.594
WHO IS A SURVIVOR AND BRIAN
00:30:29.661 --> 00:30:30.929
WILLIAMS OF LEGAL RESOURCES AND
00:30:30.995 --> 00:30:31.963
VOLUNTEER FOR VICTIM POLICY
00:30:32.030 --> 00:30:35.466
INSTITUTE. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU
00:30:35.533 --> 00:30:37.168
. UM MISS MALONEY, IF YOU'RE ON
00:30:37.235 --> 00:30:39.404
THE PHONE IN ONE MOMENT. OH,
00:30:39.470 --> 00:30:40.972
THERE WE GO. I'M SORRY. UM
00:30:41.039 --> 00:30:43.975
ALRIGHT, SO SAME GROUND RULES
00:30:44.042 --> 00:30:45.310
TWO MINUTES EACH FOR PRIMARY
00:30:45.376 --> 00:30:46.678
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT TWO
00:30:46.744 --> 00:30:48.112
MINUTES EACH FOR PRIMARY
00:30:48.179 --> 00:30:48.846
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION. THEN
00:30:48.913 --> 00:30:50.848
WE'LL TURN TO THOSE IN THE
00:30:50.915 --> 00:30:52.050
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. BOTH
00:30:52.116 --> 00:30:53.885
STARTING WITH SUPPORT AND THEN
00:30:53.952 --> 00:30:55.086
FOLLOWED BY OPPOSITION. ALRIGHT
00:30:55.153 --> 00:30:56.821
MISS MALONEY, GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:30:56.888 --> 00:30:57.889
MORNING CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
00:30:57.956 --> 00:31:01.526
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS SAMANTHA
00:31:01.593 --> 00:31:04.729
MALONEY IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
00:31:04.796 --> 00:31:06.231
I AM A CLASSICALLY TRAINED
00:31:06.297 --> 00:31:08.766
PERCUSSIONIST WHO STUDIED MUSIC
00:31:08.833 --> 00:31:10.001
AT NEW YORK CITY'S PREMIER MUSIC
00:31:10.068 --> 00:31:12.704
AND ARTS HIGH SCHOOL. A SCHOOL
00:31:12.770 --> 00:31:13.905
YOU MAY HAVE HEARD OF REFERRED
00:31:13.972 --> 00:31:17.375
TO AS FAME. I WORKED IN THE
00:31:17.442 --> 00:31:18.910
MUSIC INDUSTRY FOR OVER 30
00:31:18.977 --> 00:31:22.213
YEARS. I WAS A DRUMMER WITH
00:31:22.280 --> 00:31:25.083
WHOLE MOTLEY CRUE. BILLY RAY
00:31:25.149 --> 00:31:27.085
CYRUS AND ON HANS ZIMMER'S SCORE
00:31:27.151 --> 00:31:30.722
OF BLACK HAWK DOWN. AFTER 20
00:31:30.788 --> 00:31:32.423
YEARS I MOVED TO THE BUSINESS
00:31:32.490 --> 00:31:34.292
SIDE OF THE MUSIC INDUSTRY AS
00:31:34.359 --> 00:31:35.526
VICE PRESIDENT AT WARNER BROTHER
00:31:35.593 --> 00:31:39.964
RECORDS. WOMAN SOON BECAME
00:31:40.031 --> 00:31:41.866
COMING TO ME WITH THEIR STORIES
00:31:41.933 --> 00:31:43.101
OF THE SEXUAL PREDATORS WORKING
00:31:43.167 --> 00:31:45.470
FOR THE RECORD LABEL. ONE ARTIST
00:31:45.536 --> 00:31:49.607
TOLD ME OF AN ATTEMPTED RAPE. I
00:31:49.674 --> 00:31:52.043
THOUGHT THE BEST WAY FORWARD TO
00:31:52.110 --> 00:31:53.278
PROTECT HER WAS TO REPORT IT TO
00:31:53.344 --> 00:31:57.715
MY BOSSES. HE DID. THEY DROPPED
00:31:57.782 --> 00:31:58.850
THE FEMALE ARTIST AND KEPT THE
00:31:58.916 --> 00:32:01.352
MALE PREDATOR. THEN. IT WAS MY
00:32:01.419 --> 00:32:07.992
TURN. IN 2017, A SONG I CO
00:32:08.059 --> 00:32:09.594
PRODUCED WAS UP FOR A GRAMMY.
00:32:09.661 --> 00:32:10.862
AND IT WAS THE HIGHEST EARNER
00:32:10.928 --> 00:32:14.399
FOR THE LABEL. AS IT HAS BEEN
00:32:14.465 --> 00:32:15.466
REPORTED BY NATIONAL NEWS
00:32:15.533 --> 00:32:16.634
PUBLICATIONS. AT THE GRAMMYS
00:32:16.701 --> 00:32:21.205
THAT YEAR. ONE OF THE TOP THREE
00:32:21.272 --> 00:32:23.608
MOST POWERFUL CEO S IN THE
00:32:23.675 --> 00:32:27.045
INDUSTRY. CONGRATULATED ME. BUT
00:32:27.111 --> 00:32:30.081
AFTER SOME SMALL TALK HE'S
00:32:30.148 --> 00:32:31.049
SEXUALLY PROPOSITIONED ME FOR
00:32:31.115 --> 00:32:32.984
THREE WAY. WITH HIM AND HIS
00:32:33.051 --> 00:32:38.222
ESCORT. MY STOMACH SANK. AFTER I
00:32:38.289 --> 00:32:39.424
SHARED WHAT HAPPENED WITH MY
00:32:39.490 --> 00:32:42.760
BOSS. I WAS LET GO. IT IS NOW
00:32:42.827 --> 00:32:47.198
2022. AND I HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE
00:32:47.265 --> 00:32:48.599
TO FIND WORK WITH ANY RECORD
00:32:48.666 --> 00:32:53.571
LABEL. YET. AS REPORTED EARLIER
00:32:53.638 --> 00:32:54.772
THIS YEAR IN AN EXPOSE BY
00:32:54.839 --> 00:32:57.175
ROLLING STONE. THE COMPANY
00:32:57.241 --> 00:33:00.111
CONTINUES TO EMPLOY THESE MEN.
00:33:00.178 --> 00:33:02.680
FULLY AWARE THAT THEY ARE
00:33:02.747 --> 00:33:04.449
HABITUAL SEXUAL PREDATORS. THANK
00:33:04.515 --> 00:33:08.419
YOU FOR YOUR TIME. THANK YOU.
00:33:08.486 --> 00:33:14.392
ALL RIGHT. UM. MR WILLIAMS AS MR
00:33:14.459 --> 00:33:15.426
WILLIAMS PRESIDENT AND THE
00:33:15.493 --> 00:33:16.861
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM.
00:33:16.928 --> 00:33:18.730
UNDERSTANDING YOU'RE ON THE
00:33:18.796 --> 00:33:20.331
PHONE. ALL RIGHT. AND YOUR DID
00:33:20.398 --> 00:33:21.466
YOU WISH DID YOU WISH TO
00:33:21.532 --> 00:33:24.736
TESTIFY? GOOD MORNING, BRIAN
00:33:24.802 --> 00:33:26.237
WILLIAMS, SERVING AS A LEGAL
00:33:26.304 --> 00:33:27.805
RESOURCE AND VOLUNTEER FOR
00:33:27.872 --> 00:33:29.374
VICTIM POLICY INSTITUTE. I'M
00:33:29.440 --> 00:33:31.142
HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS,
00:33:31.209 --> 00:33:33.344
ALL RIGHT. THAT CONCLUDES THE
00:33:33.411 --> 00:33:35.146
PRIMARY WITNESS IN SUPPORT.
00:33:35.213 --> 00:33:37.081
THOSE HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM
00:33:37.148 --> 00:33:39.751
IN SUPPORT OF A B 2777 IF YOU
00:33:39.817 --> 00:33:41.352
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE AND GIVE
00:33:41.419 --> 00:33:42.487
US YOUR NAME, YOUR AFFILIATION
00:33:42.553 --> 00:33:46.691
AND YOUR POSITION GOOD MORNING,
00:33:46.758 --> 00:33:47.325
MOLLY ROBSON ON BEHALF OF
00:33:47.392 --> 00:33:48.559
PLANNED PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
00:33:48.626 --> 00:33:50.027
CALIFORNIA WERE IN SUPPORT.
00:33:50.094 --> 00:33:51.562
THANK YOU, UH, SAYING NO ONE
00:33:51.629 --> 00:33:52.663
ELSE IN THE COMMITTEE HEARING
00:33:52.730 --> 00:33:54.399
ROOM, LET'S TURN TO THE PHONE
00:33:54.465 --> 00:33:55.633
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP
00:33:55.700 --> 00:34:00.104
THOSE AND SUPPORT OF A B 2777
00:34:00.171 --> 00:34:01.939
THANK YOU, LEE. JOE MISS. WE
00:34:02.006 --> 00:34:04.842
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B.
00:34:04.909 --> 00:34:09.347
2777 PLEASE. PRESS STARS. SORRY
00:34:09.414 --> 00:34:15.686
PLEASE PRESS ZERO, THEN ONE. I
00:34:15.753 --> 00:34:16.788
SAID THAT BACKWARDS, PLEASE.
00:34:16.854 --> 00:34:20.558
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO. WE'LL
00:34:20.625 --> 00:34:21.726
START WITH LINE. 49, PLEASE GO
00:34:21.793 --> 00:34:26.798
AHEAD. MY NAME IS LEAH SANDLER
00:34:26.864 --> 00:34:28.065
AND I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
00:34:28.132 --> 00:34:29.100
EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES AND
00:34:29.167 --> 00:34:35.239
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. AND
00:34:35.306 --> 00:34:37.508
ONCE AGAIN IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
00:34:37.575 --> 00:34:38.576
IN SUPPORT, PLEASE PRESS ONE
00:34:38.643 --> 00:34:42.814
THAN ZERO. AND I HAVE NO ONE
00:34:42.880 --> 00:34:47.118
ELSE IN QUÊ. AH THANK YOU,
00:34:47.185 --> 00:34:48.052
MODERATOR. ALRIGHT BEFORE WE
00:34:48.119 --> 00:34:49.587
TURN THE OPPOSITION, LET ME JUST
00:34:49.654 --> 00:34:50.421
CLARIFY SOME ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:34:50.488 --> 00:34:51.956
WICKS. DID YOU ACCEPT THE
00:34:52.023 --> 00:34:53.024
AMENDMENTS AS PROPOSED IN THE
00:34:53.090 --> 00:35:07.872
ANALYSIS?
00:35:07.939 --> 00:35:13.377
WRECKED ANSWERS YET. BELIEVE
00:35:13.444 --> 00:35:14.412
THERE WERE AMENDMENTS FROM THE
00:35:14.479 --> 00:35:18.449
COMMITTEE. ALRIGHT WE CAN. WHY
00:35:18.516 --> 00:35:19.517
DON'T WE DOUBLE CHECK THAT? I
00:35:19.584 --> 00:35:21.552
WANT TO MAKE SURE WE'RE SO DO I.
00:35:21.619 --> 00:35:23.955
OKAY ALRIGHT. ALRIGHT THANK YOU.
00:35:24.021 --> 00:35:26.891
WE WILL COME BACK TO THAT IN A
00:35:26.958 --> 00:35:28.092
MOMENT. LET'S TURN TO OPPOSITION
00:35:28.159 --> 00:35:33.231
NOW. UM OPPOSITION WITNESSES. WE
00:35:33.297 --> 00:35:35.366
HAVE JOY BOWMAN AND, UH, JAMIE
00:35:35.433 --> 00:35:37.401
HUFF. YOU APPROACH THE
00:35:37.468 --> 00:35:42.673
MICROPHONE. ALRIGHT THERE, MR
00:35:42.740 --> 00:35:43.908
CHAIR MEMBERS. GOOD MORNING,
00:35:43.975 --> 00:35:46.244
JAMIE. HALF ON BEHALF OF C. JACK
00:35:46.310 --> 00:35:47.979
AND WE'RE TRYING TO LOCATE OUR
00:35:48.045 --> 00:35:49.947
OUR OTHER WITNESS. WE ARE
00:35:50.014 --> 00:35:51.482
ADDRESSING THE COMMITTEE TODAY
00:35:51.549 --> 00:35:54.986
WITH CONCERNS ABOUT A B 2777. I
00:35:55.052 --> 00:35:56.854
WANT TO START OFF BY SAYING THAT
00:35:56.921 --> 00:35:58.856
WE HAVE NOTHING BUT THE HIGHEST
00:35:58.923 --> 00:36:01.559
REGARD FOR SURVIVORS AND WHAT
00:36:01.626 --> 00:36:03.561
THEY HAVE BEEN THROUGH AT THIS
00:36:03.628 --> 00:36:04.762
CONCERN THAT WE HAVE IN TERMS OF
00:36:04.829 --> 00:36:06.597
OUR OPPOSITION. IS REALLY
00:36:06.664 --> 00:36:08.900
FOCUSED ON THE BROAD DRAFTING OF
00:36:08.966 --> 00:36:10.101
THE BILL AND THE UNEVEN
00:36:10.167 --> 00:36:11.669
APPLICATION BETWEEN PRIVATE AND
00:36:11.736 --> 00:36:13.437
PUBLIC ENTITIES. THE BILL
00:36:13.504 --> 00:36:16.607
REVIVES AN EXTREMELY BROAD RANGE
00:36:16.674 --> 00:36:18.743
OF CLAIMS THAT ARE VAGUELY
00:36:18.809 --> 00:36:20.611
DEFINED, OPENING THE DOOR TO
00:36:20.678 --> 00:36:21.812
LAWSUITS AGAINST BUSINESSES AND
00:36:21.879 --> 00:36:23.915
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS ALLEGING
00:36:23.981 --> 00:36:24.949
NOT ONLY SEXUAL ASSAULT, BUT
00:36:25.016 --> 00:36:25.950
ANYTHING THAT MIGHT BE
00:36:26.017 --> 00:36:28.753
CONSIDERED. INAPPROPRIATE
00:36:28.819 --> 00:36:30.288
CONDUCT COMMUNICATION OR
00:36:30.354 --> 00:36:32.557
ACTIVITY, NO MATTER HOW LONG AGO
00:36:32.623 --> 00:36:35.359
THE INCIDENT OCCURRED. STATUTE
00:36:35.426 --> 00:36:37.361
OF LIMITATIONS EXIST IN OUR
00:36:37.428 --> 00:36:39.230
CIVIL SYSTEM TO FUNCTION
00:36:39.297 --> 00:36:41.599
PROPERLY TO ALLOW JUDGES AND
00:36:41.666 --> 00:36:42.733
JURIES TO DECIDE LIABILITY WHEN
00:36:42.800 --> 00:36:44.969
THE BEST EVIDENCE IS AVAILABLE.
00:36:45.036 --> 00:36:46.604
WHEN WE ARE IN. WE HAVE
00:36:46.671 --> 00:36:48.339
WITNESSES THAT CAN TESTIFY WHEN
00:36:48.406 --> 00:36:50.575
RECORDS ARE STILL AVAILABLE WHEN
00:36:50.641 --> 00:36:52.677
WE KNOW THE CONTEXT FOR WHEN
00:36:52.743 --> 00:36:53.978
THINGS ARE HAPPENING, WE
00:36:54.045 --> 00:36:55.479
SHOULDN'T DISREGARD A KEY
00:36:55.546 --> 00:36:57.014
ELEMENT OF THE CIVIL JUSTICE
00:36:57.081 --> 00:36:57.848
SYSTEM THAT PROTECTS THAT
00:36:57.915 --> 00:36:59.550
ACCURACY AND THE RELIABILITY OF
00:36:59.617 --> 00:37:01.886
DECISIONS. ANOTHER TROUBLING
00:37:01.953 --> 00:37:03.421
ASPECT OF THIS BILL IS THAT IT
00:37:03.487 --> 00:37:06.223
DOES NOT APPLY THE SAME BETWEEN
00:37:06.290 --> 00:37:08.492
PUBLIC ENTITIES AND PRIVATE. THE
00:37:08.559 --> 00:37:09.493
INTENT OF THE MEASURE IS TO
00:37:09.560 --> 00:37:11.362
PROTECT SURVIVORS PROVIDE THEM
00:37:11.429 --> 00:37:12.964
WITH RECOURSE, SO THERE'S NO
00:37:13.030 --> 00:37:14.665
REASON TO TREAT THOSE SURVIVORS
00:37:14.732 --> 00:37:15.766
WHO VISITED OR WORKED FOR A
00:37:15.833 --> 00:37:17.134
PRIVATE ENTITY. DIFFERENT THAN A
00:37:17.201 --> 00:37:20.004
PUBLIC ONE. HAVE A LONGER PERIOD
00:37:20.071 --> 00:37:21.606
IS NEEDED FOR SURVIVORS OF
00:37:21.672 --> 00:37:23.608
SEXUAL ABUSE TO FILE CLAIMS.
00:37:23.674 --> 00:37:25.610
OTHER THAN THE 10 YEAR PERIOD
00:37:25.676 --> 00:37:26.811
THAT ALREADY EXISTS UNDER
00:37:26.877 --> 00:37:27.845
CALIFORNIA LAW, THEN WE SHOULD
00:37:27.912 --> 00:37:28.980
CONSIDER EXTENDING THAT PERIOD
00:37:29.046 --> 00:37:31.816
RESPECTIVELY. SEE JACK IN THE
00:37:31.882 --> 00:37:33.851
COALITION WILL REMOVE OPPOSITION
00:37:33.918 --> 00:37:35.586
TO THE BILL WITH THE ELIMINATION
00:37:35.653 --> 00:37:37.254
OR NARROWING OF THAT BROAD
00:37:37.321 --> 00:37:39.123
LANGUAGE CONTAINED AND THE FAIR
00:37:39.190 --> 00:37:40.157
APPLICATION TO BOTH PRIVATE AND
00:37:40.224 --> 00:37:43.494
PUBLIC ENTITIES. THESE CONCERNS
00:37:43.561 --> 00:37:45.329
ARE ALSO IN LINE WITH COMMENTS
00:37:45.396 --> 00:37:46.497
THAT OTHER MEMBERS OF THE
00:37:46.564 --> 00:37:47.565
LEGISLATURE HAVE MADE TO THE
00:37:47.632 --> 00:37:48.833
AUTHOR PREVIOUSLY. AND WITH
00:37:48.899 --> 00:37:51.202
THOSE CHANGES, WE WOULD REMOVE
00:37:51.268 --> 00:37:52.336
OUR OPPOSITION, BUT FOR NOW
00:37:52.403 --> 00:37:54.639
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED. THANK YOU.
00:37:54.705 --> 00:38:01.112
THANK YOU, MS HOFF. ALRIGHT, UM. JOY BOWMAN. IF YOU'RE PRESENT
00:38:01.178 --> 00:38:06.717
EITHER HERE OR ON THE PHONE.
00:38:06.784 --> 00:38:09.120
APPARENTLY NOT ALL RIGHT, UM
00:38:09.186 --> 00:38:10.655
OTHERS WHO ARE IN OPPOSITION TO
00:38:10.721 --> 00:38:13.624
A B 27 77 WHO ARE IN THE
00:38:13.691 --> 00:38:15.226
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM IF YOU
00:38:15.292 --> 00:38:16.227
WOULD APPROACH THE MICROPHONE,
00:38:16.293 --> 00:38:17.294
SEEING NO ONE APPROACHING THE
00:38:17.361 --> 00:38:18.095
MICROPHONE. LET'S TURN TO THE
00:38:18.162 --> 00:38:20.031
PHONES MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
00:38:20.097 --> 00:38:20.998
QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE IN
00:38:21.065 --> 00:38:26.003
OPPOSITION TO A B 27 77. THANK
00:38:26.070 --> 00:38:27.538
YOU IN ORDER TO SPEAK IN
00:38:27.605 --> 00:38:30.408
OPPOSITION OF A B 27 77 PLEASE
00:38:30.474 --> 00:38:36.747
PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME. THAT IS
00:38:36.814 --> 00:38:44.755
ONE THAN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. AND
00:38:44.822 --> 00:38:47.391
I HAVE NO ONE IN. Q THANK YOU.
00:38:47.458 --> 00:38:48.993
MODERATOR BACK TO YOU.
00:38:49.060 --> 00:38:50.628
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS ON PAGE
00:38:50.695 --> 00:38:51.862
SEVEN OF THE ANALYSIS THERE'S
00:38:51.929 --> 00:38:53.464
SUGGESTED AMENDMENT IS WHETHER
00:38:53.531 --> 00:38:56.333
IT'S YOURS OR OURS OR WHOMEVER.
00:38:56.400 --> 00:38:57.968
YOU ACCEPT THE AMENDMENT
00:38:58.035 --> 00:39:00.604
IRRESPECTIVE OF THE SOURCE.
00:39:00.671 --> 00:39:01.605
ALRIGHT. ALRIGHT. GREAT. THANK
00:39:01.672 --> 00:39:05.976
YOU. OKAY WE HAVE CONCLUDED
00:39:06.043 --> 00:39:06.944
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION QUESTIONS
00:39:07.011 --> 00:39:10.481
BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS. SEEING
00:39:10.548 --> 00:39:13.718
NONE. UM SAME AS TRUE AS THE
00:39:13.784 --> 00:39:14.518
PREVIOUS BILL. WHEN THERE'S A
00:39:14.585 --> 00:39:15.886
QUORUM, I EXPECT THERE'LL BE A
00:39:15.953 --> 00:39:17.888
MOTION, SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:39:17.955 --> 00:39:18.956
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY VOTE.
00:39:19.023 --> 00:39:21.492
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. UM
00:39:21.559 --> 00:39:24.328
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BAUER-KAHAN. IF
00:39:24.395 --> 00:39:26.597
YOU ARE HERE, I DON'T SEE YOU
00:39:26.664 --> 00:39:27.631
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE HEARING
00:39:27.698 --> 00:39:29.133
ROOM IF YOU WOULD PRESENT
00:39:29.200 --> 00:39:30.935
YOURSELF OR ANY OTHER AUTHOR WHO
00:39:31.001 --> 00:39:32.103
WISHES THEIR BILL TO BE HEARD.
00:39:32.169 --> 00:39:34.105
FIRST COME FIRST SERVE AT THIS
00:39:34.171 --> 00:39:50.254
POINT.
00:40:07.138 --> 00:40:11.308
ALRIGHT UH, ASSEMBLY MEMBER. AH
00:40:11.375 --> 00:40:14.211
BRIAN ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S KOREA, UM
00:40:14.278 --> 00:40:17.615
FRIEDMAN. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JOAN
00:40:17.681 --> 00:40:33.798
SAWYER.
00:41:29.453 --> 00:41:29.854
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVIN
00:41:29.920 --> 00:41:33.958
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MAN SHINE. UM.
00:41:34.024 --> 00:41:37.294
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SUHARTO. AH
00:41:37.361 --> 00:41:42.499
SOME REMEMBER TING OR WARD. IF I
00:41:42.566 --> 00:41:43.767
SKIP THE SIMILAR MEMBER, LEE,
00:41:43.834 --> 00:41:45.769
THEN CALLING ON ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:41:45.836 --> 00:42:09.426
EARLY AS WELL. YEAH.
00:44:21.959 --> 00:44:22.393
ALRIGHT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:44:22.459 --> 00:44:27.998
CARILLO. UM. ITEM NUMBER 10, ABC
00:44:28.065 --> 00:44:34.938
748. I SEE YOU CAME IN BEFORE
00:44:35.005 --> 00:44:42.413
SOMEBODY MEMBER WARD SO AH! FOR
00:44:42.479 --> 00:44:44.181
THOSE WHO ARE FOLLOWING ON THEIR
00:44:44.248 --> 00:44:46.150
PROGRAM. THIS IS ITEM NUMBER 10
00:44:46.216 --> 00:45:02.733
, ABC 748.
00:45:02.800 --> 00:45:03.500
WHENEVER YOU'RE READY,
00:45:03.567 --> 00:45:04.334
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CARILLO. THANK
00:45:04.401 --> 00:45:07.604
YOU, MR CHAIR. PROUD TO PRESENT
00:45:07.671 --> 00:45:09.807
A SEMI BILL 748. I WILL BE
00:45:09.873 --> 00:45:12.009
ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS, WHICH
00:45:12.076 --> 00:45:13.410
WOULD REQUIRE CALIFORNIA'S
00:45:13.477 --> 00:45:14.978
MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOLS TO
00:45:15.045 --> 00:45:15.512
DISPLAY A POSTER MAKING
00:45:15.579 --> 00:45:16.246
INFORMTION AVAILABLE TO
00:45:16.313 --> 00:45:19.116
STUDENTS ABOUT COMMON. ADVERSE
00:45:19.183 --> 00:45:20.050
MENTAL HEALTH SYMPTOMS TO LOOK
00:45:20.117 --> 00:45:21.652
OUT FOR COPING STRATEGIES AND
00:45:21.718 --> 00:45:22.653
SCHOOL SITE MENTAL HEALTH
00:45:22.719 --> 00:45:24.488
RESOURCES AVAILABLE TO THEM.
00:45:24.555 --> 00:45:26.890
EVEN BEFORE THE PANDEMIC, THE
00:45:26.957 --> 00:45:28.492
BIANNUAL CALIFORNIA HEALTHY KIDS
00:45:28.559 --> 00:45:29.693
SURVEY FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF
00:45:29.760 --> 00:45:30.761
EDUCATION AND DEPARTMENT OF
00:45:30.828 --> 00:45:31.795
HEALTH CARE SERVICES NOTED THAT
00:45:31.862 --> 00:45:34.398
THERE WAS AND HAS BEEN A
00:45:34.465 --> 00:45:36.867
INCREASE IN DEPRESSION, ANXIETY
00:45:36.934 --> 00:45:38.469
AND OTHER ADVERSE MENTAL HEALTH
00:45:38.535 --> 00:45:39.736
SYMPTOMS AMONGST CALIFORNIA
00:45:39.803 --> 00:45:40.938
MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
00:45:41.004 --> 00:45:44.341
SINCE 2015 THE SURVEY ALSO NOTES
00:45:44.408 --> 00:45:45.576
THAT STUDENTS OF COLOR ARE MORE
00:45:45.642 --> 00:45:48.512
LIKELY TO BE AFFECTED. THIS YEAR
00:45:48.579 --> 00:45:49.947
, WE WILL RECEIVE THE RESULTS OF
00:45:50.013 --> 00:45:50.747
THE FIRST CALIFORNIA HEALTH KIDS
00:45:50.814 --> 00:45:54.518
SURVEY CONDUCTED IN 2019 SINCE
00:45:54.585 --> 00:45:56.386
2019 AND THE RESULTS ARE SURE TO
00:45:56.453 --> 00:45:59.022
BE TROUBLING. LAST OCTOBER, THE
00:45:59.089 --> 00:46:00.157
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
00:46:00.224 --> 00:46:01.191
AND SEVERAL OTHER ORGANIZATIONS
00:46:01.258 --> 00:46:03.727
THAT REPRESENT PRACTITIONERS
00:46:03.794 --> 00:46:04.795
DESCRIBE THE SITUATION AS A
00:46:04.862 --> 00:46:05.829
MENTAL HEALTH STATE OF
00:46:05.896 --> 00:46:08.365
EMERGENCY. AMONG OTHER
00:46:08.432 --> 00:46:10.834
INDICATORS, THERE WAS MORE THAN
00:46:10.901 --> 00:46:13.804
50% SPIKE AND VISITS FOR
00:46:13.871 --> 00:46:15.973
SUSPECTED SUICIDE ATTEMPTS TO
00:46:16.039 --> 00:46:17.141
EMERGENCY ROOMS AMONG TEEN GIRLS
00:46:17.207 --> 00:46:19.176
IN EARLY 2021. COMPARED TO THE
00:46:19.243 --> 00:46:23.013
SAME PERIOD IN 2019. AS STUDENTS
00:46:23.080 --> 00:46:24.581
COME BACK TO CAMPUS. NOW IS THE
00:46:24.648 --> 00:46:25.716
TIME TO OFFER MEANINGFUL
00:46:25.782 --> 00:46:26.884
INTERVENTIONS AND HELP THOSE
00:46:26.950 --> 00:46:29.086
THAT NEEDED TO GET BACK ON
00:46:29.153 --> 00:46:30.254
TRACK. RESEARCH SHOWS THAT THE
00:46:30.320 --> 00:46:31.321
AVERAGE TIME BETWEEN WHEN A
00:46:31.388 --> 00:46:33.490
PERSON BEGINS TO EXPERIENCE
00:46:33.557 --> 00:46:35.058
ADVERSE MENTAL HEALTH SYMPTOMS
00:46:35.125 --> 00:46:37.027
AND WHEN THEY SEEK TREATMENT
00:46:37.094 --> 00:46:38.162
FROM A CLINICIAN IS ABOUT A
00:46:38.228 --> 00:46:40.964
DECADE. RESEARCH ALSO SHOWS THAT
00:46:41.031 --> 00:46:42.533
COMMON MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES SUCH
00:46:42.599 --> 00:46:44.067
AS DEPRESSION, ANXIETY AND
00:46:44.134 --> 00:46:46.370
SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS
00:46:46.436 --> 00:46:47.871
GENERALLY EMERGED DURING
00:46:47.938 --> 00:46:50.774
ADOLESCENCE, MAKING OUR STUDENTS
00:46:50.841 --> 00:46:52.476
AWARE OF WHAT TO LOOK OUT FOR
00:46:52.543 --> 00:46:53.610
AND HOW TO ADVOCATE FOR
00:46:53.677 --> 00:46:55.946
THEMSELVES. AND SEEK HELP AS KEY
00:46:56.013 --> 00:46:57.915
AND THAT IS WHAT THIS BILL AIMS
00:46:57.981 --> 00:47:01.084
TO DO. AVAILABLE TO TESTIFY AND
00:47:01.151 --> 00:47:02.986
TALK MORE ON HOW THIS WOULD
00:47:03.053 --> 00:47:03.720
HELP. CALIFORNIA'S YOUNG PEOPLE
00:47:03.787 --> 00:47:05.756
ARE STUDENT LEADERS ESTHER KIM
00:47:05.822 --> 00:47:07.925
AND CATHERINE SUE WITH THE
00:47:07.991 --> 00:47:08.592
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
00:47:08.659 --> 00:47:10.460
STUDENT COUNCILS, AND BEFORE WE
00:47:10.527 --> 00:47:12.429
GO TO THEM, I WOULD JUST SAY
00:47:12.496 --> 00:47:14.898
THAT WE CONVENED IN EARLY 2018
00:47:14.965 --> 00:47:16.900
WHEN I FIRST CAME TO THE
00:47:16.967 --> 00:47:18.435
LEGISLATURE, A GROUP OF MIDDLE
00:47:18.502 --> 00:47:19.603
SCHOOL AND HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
00:47:19.670 --> 00:47:22.372
IN OUR DISTRICT UM, AND THEIR
00:47:22.439 --> 00:47:23.607
NUMBER ONE CONCERN, WHICH IS
00:47:23.674 --> 00:47:26.109
INCREDIBLY, UM, RELEVANT IN
00:47:26.176 --> 00:47:28.145
TODAY'S CONVERSATION WHERE
00:47:28.212 --> 00:47:29.846
SCHOOL SHOOTINGS THE ANXIETY
00:47:29.913 --> 00:47:30.981
THAT STUDENTS HAVE FELT AND
00:47:31.048 --> 00:47:33.383
FEELING SAFE AT SCHOOL. MENTAL
00:47:33.450 --> 00:47:34.918
HEALTH CHALLENGES THAT AROSE
00:47:34.985 --> 00:47:36.420
BECAUSE OF THAT, AND THE LAST
00:47:36.486 --> 00:47:37.821
FEW YEARS THAT WE'VE BEEN
00:47:37.888 --> 00:47:39.489
THROUGH A PANDEMIC IN WHICH MANY
00:47:39.556 --> 00:47:41.491
YOUNG PEOPLE ACROSS THE STATE OF
00:47:41.558 --> 00:47:42.859
CALIFORNIA HAVE SEEN AND HAVE
00:47:42.926 --> 00:47:44.695
SUFFERED FROM THE PANDEMIC AND
00:47:44.761 --> 00:47:47.364
HAVE LOST APPARENT LOVED ONE OR
00:47:47.431 --> 00:47:50.367
A RELATIVE RELATED TO COVID AND
00:47:50.434 --> 00:47:52.135
HOW YOUNG PEOPLE ARE GOING TO
00:47:52.202 --> 00:47:54.104
MANAGE AND COPE WITH MENTAL
00:47:54.171 --> 00:47:55.172
HEALTH IS SOMETHING THAT THE
00:47:55.239 --> 00:47:57.007
STATE SHOULD ABSOLUTELY INVEST
00:47:57.074 --> 00:47:59.243
IN THIS MAKES IT INCREDIBLY EASY
00:47:59.309 --> 00:48:00.611
FOR THOSE RESOURCES TO BE
00:48:00.677 --> 00:48:01.778
AVAILABLE, AND ONE FINAL THING
00:48:01.845 --> 00:48:03.347
THAT I WOULD ADD WHEN I WAS
00:48:03.413 --> 00:48:05.449
GOING TO HIGH SCHOOL WHAT WE HAD
00:48:05.515 --> 00:48:06.817
AND WHERE THIS IDEA DEVELOPED
00:48:06.883 --> 00:48:07.851
FROM WHERE HIV AND AIDS POSTERS
00:48:07.918 --> 00:48:10.087
AWARENESS OF WHAT THAT WAS BACK
00:48:10.153 --> 00:48:12.122
IN THE NINETIES. NOW WE HAVE AN
00:48:12.189 --> 00:48:13.223
OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE THE
00:48:13.290 --> 00:48:14.258
CONVERSATION AROUND MENTAL
00:48:14.324 --> 00:48:16.026
HEALTH. SOMETHING THAT IS AN
00:48:16.093 --> 00:48:17.227
EVERYDAY CONVERSATION AND THE
00:48:17.294 --> 00:48:20.030
SEEKING HELP. SHOULDN'T BE AN
00:48:20.097 --> 00:48:21.398
EMBARRASSING THING FOR A YOUNG
00:48:21.465 --> 00:48:23.467
PERSON. THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO
00:48:23.533 --> 00:48:25.269
MUCH FOR CARILLO ARE. UM, MRS
00:48:25.335 --> 00:48:27.404
OOH. MISS KIM, FATHER OF YOU ON
00:48:27.471 --> 00:48:28.672
THE PHONE IF YOU WOULD IDENTIFY
00:48:28.739 --> 00:48:32.542
YOURSELVES. GOOD MORNING. MY
00:48:32.609 --> 00:48:35.846
NAME IS KATHERINE SHOE. AND I'M
00:48:35.912 --> 00:48:38.015
A STUDENT AT WESTLAKE HIGH
00:48:38.081 --> 00:48:39.116
SCHOOL. MCNALL VALUE TO FIGHT
00:48:39.182 --> 00:48:41.385
SCHOOL DISTRICT. AS A LOT OF
00:48:41.451 --> 00:48:42.953
MANY STUDENTS WHO STRUGGLE TO
00:48:43.020 --> 00:48:44.888
NAVIGATE THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC
00:48:44.955 --> 00:48:46.890
AND THE RETURN THAT IN PERSON
00:48:46.957 --> 00:48:48.125
LEARNING, I'VE CONTINUED TO
00:48:48.191 --> 00:48:49.793
STRUGGLE WITH MY OWN MENTAL
00:48:49.860 --> 00:48:53.030
HEALTH. THEY'RE A BIG MOMENTS
00:48:53.096 --> 00:48:54.531
WHEN I FELT LOST, CHALLENGED
00:48:54.598 --> 00:48:56.733
ANXIOUS IN THE PRESS, THESE
00:48:56.800 --> 00:48:59.036
INSTANCES OF FEELING DOWN HAD
00:48:59.102 --> 00:49:00.504
COME WITH GREAT CONSEQUENCES,
00:49:00.570 --> 00:49:02.939
SUCH AS THE LOSS OF IT OF
00:49:03.006 --> 00:49:03.473
MOTIVATION AND DEPRESSIVE
00:49:03.540 --> 00:49:06.376
EPISODES. I STRUGGLE WITH
00:49:06.443 --> 00:49:10.414
pIT AFFECTS ME ON A CONDITIONAL
00:49:10.480 --> 00:49:11.415
BASIS IMPACTING ME DURING THE
00:49:11.481 --> 00:49:13.383
WINTER MONTHS. THE CIRCUMSTANCES
00:49:13.450 --> 00:49:15.686
HAVE FROM TIME TO TIME AFFECT MY
00:49:15.752 --> 00:49:16.787
PERFORMANCE IN SCHOOL AND MY
00:49:16.853 --> 00:49:19.489
BEHAVIOR THROUGHOUT THOSE MONTHS
00:49:19.556 --> 00:49:21.858
. I SPEAK NOT JUST FOR MYSELF,
00:49:21.925 --> 00:49:23.493
BUT FOR MY SOUL STUDENTS IN
00:49:23.560 --> 00:49:25.529
PIERCE, WHO SIMULTANEOUSLY
00:49:25.595 --> 00:49:27.264
STRUGGLED WITH THEIR OWN MENTAL
00:49:27.331 --> 00:49:29.399
HEALTH AT VARIOUS LEVELS. I'VE
00:49:29.466 --> 00:49:30.867
KNOWN BRANDS WHO SUFFERED FROM
00:49:30.934 --> 00:49:32.636
DEPRESSION AND NOT REACH OUT FOR
00:49:32.703 --> 00:49:35.405
ANY SUPPORT AND HELP UNTIL LATER
00:49:35.472 --> 00:49:36.573
WHEN THEIR MENTAL HEALTH KIDS TO
00:49:36.640 --> 00:49:39.509
SEVERE LEVELS. THIS ISSUE
00:49:39.576 --> 00:49:41.378
AFFECTS ME PERSONALLY AND IT
00:49:41.445 --> 00:49:44.281
HITS ME. UM, REALLY CLOSE TO
00:49:44.348 --> 00:49:48.885
HOME. WE HAD A COUPLE INFLUENCES
00:49:48.952 --> 00:49:50.954
IN MY HOMETOWN LIKE THE
00:49:51.021 --> 00:49:52.589
BORDERLINE TRAGEDY, THE
00:49:52.656 --> 00:49:54.224
BORDERLINE SHOOTING THAT REALLY
00:49:54.291 --> 00:49:56.426
AFFECTED STUDENTS MENTAL HEALTH
00:49:56.493 --> 00:49:58.028
. UM AND I THINK A LOT OF
00:49:58.095 --> 00:49:59.463
STUDENTS WERE SO LOST AFTER
00:49:59.529 --> 00:50:01.498
THAT, AND DIDN'T REALLY HAVE
00:50:01.565 --> 00:50:03.033
LIKE ANY RESOURCES OR LIKE
00:50:03.100 --> 00:50:06.336
AWARENESS OF THE RESOURCES. THAT
00:50:06.403 --> 00:50:07.504
WERE OFFERED TO HELP COPE WITH
00:50:07.571 --> 00:50:10.540
THAT TRAGEDY. ACCORDING TO THE
00:50:10.607 --> 00:50:11.608
NATIONAL LINES FROM MENTAL
00:50:11.675 --> 00:50:16.613
ILLNESS. THE U. S. 16.5% OF AGES
00:50:16.680 --> 00:50:18.749
BETWEEN 6 TO 17 EXPERIENCE A
00:50:18.815 --> 00:50:21.518
MENTAL HEALTH DISORDER IN 2016
00:50:21.585 --> 00:50:23.220
AND, ACCORDING TO THE AMERICAN
00:50:23.286 --> 00:50:24.054
ASSOCIATION OF SCHOOLS,
00:50:24.121 --> 00:50:26.890
PSYCHOLOGIST ANXIETY BASED SCORE
00:50:26.957 --> 00:50:28.959
. REFUSAL AFFECTS 2 TO 5% OF
00:50:29.025 --> 00:50:32.996
SCHOOL AGE CHILDREN. THESE DIARY
00:50:33.063 --> 00:50:34.131
NUMBERS PICKED THE RABBIT ISSUE
00:50:34.197 --> 00:50:36.400
OF DECLINING MENTAL HEALTH BY
00:50:36.466 --> 00:50:37.801
IMPLEMENTING POSTERS THAT
00:50:37.868 --> 00:50:39.302
CONTAIN RESOURCES FOR YOUTH.
00:50:39.369 --> 00:50:40.904
THESE POSTERS WILL ENCOURAGE AND
00:50:40.971 --> 00:50:41.471
PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR
00:50:41.538 --> 00:50:42.639
STUDENTS WHO HAVE MENTAL HEALTH
00:50:42.706 --> 00:50:46.243
ISSUES. TO REACH OUT FOR HELP.
00:50:46.309 --> 00:50:47.911
STUDENTS WILL HAVE THE NECESSARY
00:50:47.978 --> 00:50:49.346
INFORMATION TO RECOGNIZE SIGNS
00:50:49.413 --> 00:50:50.781
OF DECLINING MENTAL HEALTH IN
00:50:50.847 --> 00:50:53.784
THEMSELVES AND IN THEIR PEERS.
00:50:53.850 --> 00:50:54.418
THERE'S STILL WILL HELP ENSURE
00:50:54.484 --> 00:50:55.452
THAT STUDENTS HAVE RESOURCES
00:50:55.519 --> 00:50:57.387
THAT ARE READILY AVAILABLE.
00:50:57.454 --> 00:50:59.089
WHILE ALSO DEMONSTRATING THEM
00:50:59.156 --> 00:51:00.090
ALREADY. THANK YOU, MISS MISS
00:51:00.157 --> 00:51:03.727
YOU IF YOU WOULD WRAP IT UP.
00:51:03.794 --> 00:51:05.562
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU
00:51:05.629 --> 00:51:08.131
FOR YOUR TESTIMONY. AH, MISS
00:51:08.198 --> 00:51:11.535
KIM, ARE YOU AVAILABLE? GOOD
00:51:11.601 --> 00:51:14.571
MORNING. MY NAME IS TIM AND I AM
00:51:14.638 --> 00:51:16.573
A STUDENT IN HIGH SCHOOL IN THE
00:51:16.640 --> 00:51:18.608
VALLEY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT.
00:51:18.675 --> 00:51:21.611
I'M HERE TO STAY REPRESENTING
00:51:21.678 --> 00:51:24.147
TEACHERS COUNCILS AS THE TALKERS
00:51:24.214 --> 00:51:25.382
POLICY DIRECTOR TO DEMONSTRATE
00:51:25.449 --> 00:51:27.150
OR SUPPORT IN SPONSORING THIS
00:51:27.217 --> 00:51:30.620
BILL. ASK, YOU ALL KNOW. OF THE
00:51:30.687 --> 00:51:33.857
21ST CENTURY. AND ONE OF OUR
00:51:33.924 --> 00:51:37.327
YOUTH MOST MEANS. TO COMBAT THE
00:51:37.394 --> 00:51:38.895
STUDENT MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS.
00:51:38.962 --> 00:51:40.464
EDUCATIONAL LEADERS AND
00:51:40.530 --> 00:51:41.865
LEGISLATORS LIKE YOU HAVE TAKEN
00:51:41.932 --> 00:51:44.067
INITIATIVE STUDENTS WITH MENTAL
00:51:44.134 --> 00:51:45.202
HEALTH RESOURCES SPEND THE MOST
00:51:45.268 --> 00:51:49.005
TIME TO SCHOOL. RECENT
00:51:49.072 --> 00:51:51.475
LEGISLATION SUCH AS THE 14,
00:51:51.541 --> 00:51:53.510
WHICH EXCUSES MENTAL HEALTH IS
00:51:53.577 --> 00:51:55.445
UNDER LOCK PROVIDES STUDENTS
00:51:55.512 --> 00:51:56.580
WITH STRUCTURAL SUPPORT TO
00:51:56.646 --> 00:51:58.648
PROTECT THEIR WELL BEING. MY
00:51:58.715 --> 00:51:59.983
SCHOOL HAS TAKEN EXTRAORDINARY
00:52:00.050 --> 00:52:01.117
MEASURES TO COMBAT THE STUDENT
00:52:01.184 --> 00:52:04.020
HEALTH CRISIS. SOME MPS
00:52:04.087 --> 00:52:05.355
INSTITUTE INTERVENTION SYSTEMS
00:52:05.422 --> 00:52:06.223
READILY AVAILABLE COUNSELING
00:52:06.289 --> 00:52:09.493
SERVICES. HOWEVER I WAS
00:52:09.559 --> 00:52:11.061
COMPLETELY UNAWARE OF ANY OF
00:52:11.127 --> 00:52:13.029
THESE RESOURCES FOR THE FIRST
00:52:13.096 --> 00:52:14.264
TWO YEARS OF MY HIGH SCHOOL
00:52:14.331 --> 00:52:15.365
EXPERIENCE. ALTHOUGH IT WENT
00:52:15.432 --> 00:52:16.433
THROUGH STRUGGLES WITH PANDEMIC
00:52:16.500 --> 00:52:18.268
PRESSURES AND SELF IMAGE THAT
00:52:18.335 --> 00:52:20.403
FAMILY IMPACTED MY MENTAL HEALTH
00:52:20.470 --> 00:52:22.339
. NO ONE INFORMED ME THAT OUR
00:52:22.405 --> 00:52:23.940
SCHOOL HAD THREE CONTRACTS AND
00:52:24.007 --> 00:52:24.908
COUNSELING PROGRAM OR WELLNESS
00:52:24.975 --> 00:52:26.810
CENTER. AND TOTALLY BECAME A
00:52:26.877 --> 00:52:28.512
STATE OF BOARD MEMBER AND
00:52:28.578 --> 00:52:29.713
STARTED REACHING OUT TO ADVOCATE
00:52:29.779 --> 00:52:30.780
FOR RESOURCES THAT WERE ALREADY
00:52:30.847 --> 00:52:33.884
IN PLACE. I LATER FOUND OUT THAT
00:52:33.950 --> 00:52:35.218
TEACHERS AND COUNSELORS WOULD
00:52:35.285 --> 00:52:36.953
RECOMMEND STRUGGLING STUDENTS TO
00:52:37.020 --> 00:52:38.455
THESE RESOURCES, BUT BECAUSE I
00:52:38.522 --> 00:52:40.123
WASN'T PHYSICALLY DISCUSSED. I
00:52:40.190 --> 00:52:41.358
WASN'T DIRECTLY TO THE RESOURCES
00:52:41.424 --> 00:52:42.859
THAT I DESPERATELY NEEDED. I AM
00:52:42.926 --> 00:52:47.964
NOT ALONE EXPERIENCE. MY SPORT
00:52:48.031 --> 00:52:49.533
IS ONE OF OVER THOUSANDS IN THE
00:52:49.599 --> 00:52:51.468
STATES THAT STUDENTS GRADES 6 TO
00:52:51.535 --> 00:52:54.337
12. STUDENTS ARE UNABLE TO
00:52:54.404 --> 00:52:55.772
UTILIZE MENTAL HEALTH MEETING
00:52:55.839 --> 00:52:57.674
WITH AT SCHOOL BECAUSE OF A LACK
00:52:57.741 --> 00:52:58.141
OF PUBLICLY AVAILABLE
00:52:58.208 --> 00:53:01.011
INFORMATION. OTHER POSTERS MAKE
00:53:01.077 --> 00:53:02.479
SUBSTANTIAL ADDITIONS TO AN
00:53:02.546 --> 00:53:04.614
EXISTING PROVERBS SUPPORT SYSTEM
00:53:04.681 --> 00:53:06.416
. THERE ARE CRUCIAL IN ENSURING
00:53:06.483 --> 00:53:07.517
THAT ALL STUDENTS ARE AWARE OF
00:53:07.584 --> 00:53:11.521
THE SUPPORT. CALIFORNIA HAS
00:53:11.588 --> 00:53:12.689
TAKEN LEAPS AND BOUNDS TO
00:53:12.756 --> 00:53:13.657
PROVIDE STUDENTS WITH MENTAL
00:53:13.723 --> 00:53:15.992
HEALTH RESOURCES, BUT OFTENTIMES
00:53:16.059 --> 00:53:17.394
SIMPLY DON'T KNOW WHERE TO FIND
00:53:17.460 --> 00:53:19.296
THEM, AND IT IS OUR GOVERNMENT'S
00:53:19.362 --> 00:53:21.331
RESPONSIBILITY. TO ENSURE THAT
00:53:21.398 --> 00:53:23.366
OUR YOUTH FEW COULD WRAP IT UP.
00:53:23.433 --> 00:53:27.270
PLEASE HELP. FOR THOSE REASONS
00:53:27.337 --> 00:53:29.372
TO CALIFORNIA THESIS COUNCIL
00:53:29.439 --> 00:53:31.608
SUPPORT WRITTEN BILLS. THANK YOU
00:53:31.675 --> 00:53:32.742
ALL FOR YOUR TIME AND YOUR
00:53:32.809 --> 00:53:33.877
CONSIDERATION. ALL RIGHT. THANK
00:53:33.944 --> 00:53:35.745
YOU, MR KIM FOR YOUR TESTIMONY,
00:53:35.812 --> 00:53:37.547
ALL RIGHT? OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF
00:53:37.614 --> 00:53:39.649
A B 748 WHO ARE HERE IN THE
00:53:39.716 --> 00:53:42.118
COMMITTEE ROOM. GOOD MORNING,
00:53:42.185 --> 00:53:42.953
MOLLY ROBSON WITH PLANNED
00:53:43.019 --> 00:53:43.820
PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
00:53:43.887 --> 00:53:44.921
CALIFORNIA WERE IN SUPPORT.
00:53:44.988 --> 00:53:47.924
THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING POLIO ON
00:53:47.991 --> 00:53:48.558
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
00:53:48.625 --> 00:53:50.493
ASSOCIATION OF PSYCHIATRISTS AND
00:53:50.560 --> 00:53:52.629
SUPPORT THANK YOU OTHERS HERE IN
00:53:52.696 --> 00:53:54.130
ROOM, 2100 SAYING NO ONE
00:53:54.197 --> 00:53:55.031
APPROACHED THE MICROPHONE. MY
00:53:55.098 --> 00:53:56.299
MODERATE IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP
00:53:56.366 --> 00:54:01.371
THOSE IN SUPPORT OF A B 748.
00:54:01.438 --> 00:54:02.872
THANK YOU TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
00:54:02.939 --> 00:54:05.642
A B 748 PLEASE PRESS 10 ON YOUR
00:54:05.709 --> 00:54:10.380
PHONE. IN WE'LL START WITH LINE
00:54:10.447 --> 00:54:13.984
67, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THE MORNING
00:54:14.050 --> 00:54:15.518
. SIMON BUMI HAS THE CALIFORNIA
00:54:15.585 --> 00:54:16.886
COUNCIL OF COMMUNITY BEHAVIOR,
00:54:16.953 --> 00:54:17.887
HEALTH AGENCIES AND SUPPORT
00:54:17.954 --> 00:54:23.426
THANK YOU. THANK YOU IN ONE
00:54:23.493 --> 00:54:33.236
MOMENT WHILE WE GET MY NUMBERS.
00:54:33.303 --> 00:54:35.271
NEXT WE HAVE LINE 102. PLEASE GO
00:54:35.338 --> 00:54:40.610
AHEAD. NAME OF WORK K<c.cyan> BHD A</c>
00:54:40.677 --> 00:54:45.982
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
00:54:46.049 --> 00:54:47.951
YOU. AND THAT IS ALL I HAVE IN
00:54:48.018 --> 00:54:50.820
QUÊ. ALL RIGHT, LET'S TURN THE
00:54:50.887 --> 00:54:52.255
OPPOSITION. UM I SEE THAT THERE
00:54:52.322 --> 00:54:53.757
ARE NO IDENTIFIED PRIMARY
00:54:53.823 --> 00:54:55.425
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION IF YOU
00:54:55.492 --> 00:54:57.827
ARE IN OPPOSITION TO A B 748
00:54:57.894 --> 00:54:59.462
PLEASE APPROACH MICROPHONE,
00:54:59.529 --> 00:55:00.497
SAYING NO ONE APPROACHED THE
00:55:00.563 --> 00:55:01.998
MICROPHONE MODERATE IF YOU WOULD
00:55:02.065 --> 00:55:03.767
QUEUE UP THOSE IN OPPOSITION TO
00:55:03.833 --> 00:55:07.837
SEVEN A B 748. THANK YOU TO
00:55:07.904 --> 00:55:10.874
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF A B 748.
00:55:10.940 --> 00:55:12.008
PLEASE PRESS ONE DÂN ZERO ON
00:55:12.075 --> 00:55:20.417
YOUR PHONE. THAT'S ONE, THEN
00:55:20.483 --> 00:55:28.758
ZERO ON YOUR TELEPHONE KEYPAD.
00:55:28.825 --> 00:55:30.627
AND I HAVE NO ONE IN Q. ALL
00:55:30.694 --> 00:55:32.595
RIGHT. THANK YOU. BACK TO THE
00:55:32.662 --> 00:55:34.264
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
00:55:34.330 --> 00:55:37.434
MEMBERS SEEING. MM YES, SENATOR.
00:55:37.500 --> 00:55:38.635
THE RUSSELL. THANK YOU, MR
00:55:38.702 --> 00:55:40.570
CHAIR. I JUST WANNA THANK THE
00:55:40.637 --> 00:55:41.404
AUTHOR THINK THIS IS A
00:55:41.471 --> 00:55:44.808
EXTRAORDINARILY. IT'S I'M
00:55:44.874 --> 00:55:46.743
LEARNING MORE AND MORE, UM
00:55:46.810 --> 00:55:50.547
IMPORTANT, UM ISSUE FOR
00:55:50.613 --> 00:55:52.082
ESPECIALLY OUR YOUNGER AND
00:55:52.148 --> 00:55:53.216
YOUNGER AND YOUNGER PEOPLE, AND
00:55:53.283 --> 00:55:55.118
IT'S SAD. BUT I'M GLAD YOU'RE
00:55:55.185 --> 00:55:56.953
TAKING IT TO WHERE THEY'RE AT
00:55:57.020 --> 00:55:58.555
THEIR LEVEL. AND I HOPE THEIR
00:55:58.621 --> 00:56:00.290
CREATIVITY COMES SHOWS THROUGH
00:56:00.356 --> 00:56:01.424
WITH THESE MATERIALS AND
00:56:01.491 --> 00:56:04.127
POSTERS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:56:04.194 --> 00:56:07.163
OTHER QUESTIONS. COMMENTS. UH.
00:56:07.230 --> 00:56:09.299
WE DON'T HAVE A QUORUM. SO AS
00:56:09.365 --> 00:56:11.534
SOON AS WE DO, I EXPECT THERE'LL
00:56:11.601 --> 00:56:12.702
BE A MOTION. WOULD YOU CARE
00:56:12.769 --> 00:56:15.472
CLOSE? THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. THE
00:56:15.538 --> 00:56:16.740
BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION HAS
00:56:16.806 --> 00:56:18.508
RECEIVED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT, AND
00:56:18.575 --> 00:56:21.044
I JUST I'M SO GRATEFUL FOR OUR
00:56:21.111 --> 00:56:22.245
WITNESS TESTIMONY OVER THE PHONE
00:56:22.312 --> 00:56:23.747
. THEY'RE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS
00:56:23.813 --> 00:56:25.482
WHO HAD BEEN ADVOCATING FOR WHAT
00:56:25.548 --> 00:56:27.617
THEY NEED RIGHT AT THE LOCATIONS
00:56:27.684 --> 00:56:28.685
WHERE THEY'RE AT, AND I'M
00:56:28.752 --> 00:56:29.919
THANKFUL. TO THE CALIFORNIA
00:56:29.986 --> 00:56:31.755
ASSOCIATION OF STUDENT COUNCILS
00:56:31.821 --> 00:56:32.956
FOR THEIR WORK AND ADVOCACY ON
00:56:33.022 --> 00:56:34.991
THIS ISSUE, AND WE DO HAVE
00:56:35.058 --> 00:56:35.658
QUORUM. RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND
00:56:35.725 --> 00:56:37.761
I VOTE. THANK YOU. UM I ECHO
00:56:37.827 --> 00:56:40.296
YOUR ACCOLADES TO MISS YOU AND
00:56:40.363 --> 00:56:42.398
MISS KIM. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
00:56:42.465 --> 00:56:44.834
UM MR WARD WAS HERE. SOME
00:56:44.901 --> 00:56:47.203
REMEMBER WARD WAS HERE, BUT HE
00:56:47.270 --> 00:56:48.304
SEEMED TO HAVE LEFT, BUT
00:56:48.371 --> 00:56:49.072
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN IS
00:56:49.139 --> 00:56:50.006
HERE. SO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:56:50.073 --> 00:56:54.878
FRIEDMAN THIS WOULD BE ITEM
00:56:54.944 --> 00:56:58.581
NUMBER 14 A B 23 09. YES, GO
00:56:58.648 --> 00:57:03.052
AHEAD, MR FRIEDMAN. YOU AND YOUR
00:57:03.119 --> 00:57:04.888
STAFF FOR WORKING WITH US ON THE
00:57:04.954 --> 00:57:06.823
BILL, AND I'M HAPPY TO ACCEPT
00:57:06.890 --> 00:57:08.057
THE AMENDMENTS OUTLINED ON PAGES
00:57:08.124 --> 00:57:10.026
SIX AND SEVEN OF THE ANALYSIS A
00:57:10.093 --> 00:57:11.995
B 23 09 STRENGTHENS EXISTING
00:57:12.061 --> 00:57:13.196
JUVENILE COURT PROCEDURES AND TO
00:57:13.263 --> 00:57:16.065
ORDER GUARDIANSHIP. INSTEAD OF
00:57:16.132 --> 00:57:18.134
FOSTER CARE PLACEMENT IN THE
00:57:18.201 --> 00:57:19.035
EARLY STAGES OF A DEPENDENCY
00:57:19.102 --> 00:57:20.703
COURT CASE IN THE DAYS AND WEEKS
00:57:20.770 --> 00:57:23.273
AFTER A CHILD IS REMOVED FROM
00:57:23.339 --> 00:57:24.974
THEIR PARENTS CARE ARE CRITICAL.
00:57:25.041 --> 00:57:26.442
THESE EARLY COURT HEARINGS
00:57:26.509 --> 00:57:27.610
DETERMINE WHERE A CHILD WILL
00:57:27.677 --> 00:57:29.479
LIVE AND WHAT SERVICES THE
00:57:29.546 --> 00:57:31.181
FAMILY WILL RECEIVE FOR THE
00:57:31.247 --> 00:57:32.348
MONTHS AND SOMETIMES FOR THE
00:57:32.415 --> 00:57:34.517
YEARS AHEAD. IT'S ALSO AT THE
00:57:34.584 --> 00:57:36.252
THIS EARLY STAGE THAT A
00:57:36.319 --> 00:57:38.054
DISPROPORTIONATE NUMBER OF
00:57:38.121 --> 00:57:42.959
FAMILIES, UH UM WELL, A
00:57:43.026 --> 00:57:44.394
DISPROPORTIONATE AMOUNT OF
00:57:44.460 --> 00:57:45.895
REPRESENTATION STARTS TO APPEAR
00:57:45.962 --> 00:57:47.397
SOMETIMES FOR THESE IMPACTED
00:57:47.463 --> 00:57:49.132
FAMILIES. COURTS ALREADY HAVE
00:57:49.199 --> 00:57:51.000
DISCRETION UNDER THE WELFARE
00:57:51.067 --> 00:57:52.902
INSTITUTIONS CODE TO ORDER A
00:57:52.969 --> 00:57:54.604
SAFE AND PERMANENT PLAN OF
00:57:54.671 --> 00:57:55.605
GUARDIANSHIP AS AN ALTERNATIVE
00:57:55.672 --> 00:57:56.673
TO FOSTER CARE PLACEMENT. IN
00:57:56.739 --> 00:57:58.107
OTHER WORDS, GUARDIANSHIP WITH
00:57:58.174 --> 00:57:59.242
DISTANT FAMILY MEMBER WITH A
00:57:59.309 --> 00:58:01.778
GRANDPARENT WITH A FAMILY FRIEND
00:58:01.845 --> 00:58:02.979
INSTEAD OF GOING INTO THE FOSTER
00:58:03.046 --> 00:58:04.747
CARE SYSTEM. HOWEVER
00:58:04.814 --> 00:58:05.715
STAKEHOLDERS REPORT THAT
00:58:05.782 --> 00:58:07.750
GUARDIANSHIPS IN LIEU OF FOSTER
00:58:07.817 --> 00:58:08.718
CARE ARE OFTEN NOT EVEN
00:58:08.785 --> 00:58:10.753
CONSIDERED, EVEN WHEN THAT
00:58:10.820 --> 00:58:11.955
OPTION WOULD BE IN THE BEST
00:58:12.021 --> 00:58:13.790
INTERESTS OF THE CHILD AND THE
00:58:13.857 --> 00:58:15.558
FAMILY. COURTS ARE NOT REQUIRED
00:58:15.625 --> 00:58:16.893
TO CONSIDER THE PARENT'S CHOICE
00:58:16.960 --> 00:58:18.628
OF GUARDIAN AND TYPICALLY DO NOT
00:58:18.695 --> 00:58:19.963
CONSIDER GUARDIANSHIP UNTIL THE
00:58:20.029 --> 00:58:22.498
DISPOSAL HEARING JUST POSITIONAL
00:58:22.565 --> 00:58:24.601
HEARING AFTER THE CHILD HAS BEEN
00:58:24.667 --> 00:58:25.235
DETAINED, SOMETIMES IN FOSTER
00:58:25.301 --> 00:58:26.002
CARE SETTINGS, SOMETIMES FOR
00:58:26.069 --> 00:58:29.339
MONTHS OR LONGER. 23 09 WOULD
00:58:29.405 --> 00:58:30.874
PROMOTE FAMILY DECISION MAKING
00:58:30.940 --> 00:58:32.242
AND MINIMIZE THE CHILD'S
00:58:32.308 --> 00:58:34.644
EXPOSURE TO THE FOSTER CARE
00:58:34.711 --> 00:58:35.378
SYSTEM, WHICH CAN BE VERY
00:58:35.445 --> 00:58:37.747
DISRUPTIVE. VERY TRAUMATIC. ONLY
00:58:37.814 --> 00:58:40.049
IN CASES, HOWEVER, WHERE THERE
00:58:40.116 --> 00:58:41.251
IS A SAFE AND A PERMANENT
00:58:41.317 --> 00:58:42.518
GUARDIAN AVAILABLE. SO, OF
00:58:42.585 --> 00:58:44.520
COURSE, WE'RE NOT GOING TO PUT
00:58:44.587 --> 00:58:45.788
CHILDREN INTO UNSAFE CONDITIONS
00:58:45.855 --> 00:58:47.490
. BUT IF A PARENT SAYS I CAN'T
00:58:47.557 --> 00:58:49.125
PARENT FOR WHATEVER REASON, BUT
00:58:49.192 --> 00:58:50.627
THERE'S SOMEONE IN MY FAMILY WHO
00:58:50.693 --> 00:58:52.595
IS WILLING TO AND THAT CHILD CAN
00:58:52.662 --> 00:58:54.464
THEN STAY WITH THEIR SUPPORT
00:58:54.530 --> 00:58:55.131
SYSTEM WITH THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS
00:58:55.198 --> 00:58:57.066
WITHIN WHAT THEY KNOW THE COURT
00:58:57.133 --> 00:58:57.634
. THE COURT SHOULD AT LEAST
00:58:57.700 --> 00:58:59.469
CONSIDER THAT, AND THAT'S WHAT
00:58:59.535 --> 00:59:01.738
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE. THE
00:59:01.804 --> 00:59:02.605
BILL ALSO REQUIRES THE
00:59:02.672 --> 00:59:04.774
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES TO
00:59:04.841 --> 00:59:05.541
COLLECT DATA ON CHILDREN LIVING
00:59:05.608 --> 00:59:07.844
WITH RELATIVE CAREGIVERS WHO ARE
00:59:07.911 --> 00:59:09.245
THE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE MOST
00:59:09.312 --> 00:59:10.480
LIKELY TO BECOME THE CARETAKERS
00:59:10.546 --> 00:59:13.249
UNDER THIS BILL? WITH THAT I
00:59:13.316 --> 00:59:14.751
WOULD URGE AND I VOTE TESTIFYING
00:59:14.817 --> 00:59:16.586
IN SUPPORT BY PHONE. WE HAVE
00:59:16.653 --> 00:59:17.987
SABRINA FORT FROM THE ALLIANCE
00:59:18.054 --> 00:59:19.455
OF CHILDREN'S RIGHTS AND JACKIE
00:59:19.522 --> 00:59:20.957
RUFFIER FROM THE CALIFORNIA
00:59:21.024 --> 00:59:22.258
ALLIANCE OF CAREGIVERS. ALRIGHT.
00:59:22.325 --> 00:59:27.297
AH, THIS IS IT, FORTE. OR MR
00:59:27.363 --> 00:59:31.768
HAUSER. EITHER OF YOU AVAILABLE
00:59:31.834 --> 00:59:33.002
ON THE PHONE IF YOU IDENTIFY
00:59:33.069 --> 00:59:41.911
YOURSELF. ALL RIGHT. UM I
00:59:41.978 --> 00:59:43.746
REALIZED THAT WE'RE GOING A BIT
00:59:43.813 --> 00:59:44.914
OUT OF ORDER SO WE WILL COME
00:59:44.981 --> 00:59:46.582
BACK TO THEM IF THEY IDENTIFY
00:59:46.649 --> 00:59:47.517
THEMSELVES, BUT IN THE MEANTIME,
00:59:47.583 --> 00:59:49.485
WHY DON'T WE TAKE ANY SUPPORT
00:59:49.552 --> 00:59:50.620
HERE IN ROOM 2100? IF YOU
00:59:50.687 --> 00:59:54.023
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE. AH
00:59:54.090 --> 00:59:55.758
SEEING NO ONE APPROACHING MY
00:59:55.825 --> 00:59:56.859
PHONE SUPPORT ON THE PHONE
00:59:56.926 --> 00:59:58.995
LINES. MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
00:59:59.062 --> 01:00:01.130
QUEUE UP THOSE AND SUPPORT OF A
01:00:01.197 --> 01:00:05.635
B 23 09 YES. THANK YOU AND
01:00:05.702 --> 01:00:08.137
SUPPORTIVE AB 23 09. PLEASE
01:00:08.204 --> 01:00:12.442
PRESS ONE AND ZERO. AND FIRST WE
01:00:12.508 --> 01:00:16.879
HAVE LINE 31, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:00:16.946 --> 01:00:19.082
GOOD MORNING. CALIFORNIA ACTION
01:00:19.148 --> 01:00:20.016
CALLING SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:00:20.083 --> 01:00:25.288
THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND ONE
01:00:25.355 --> 01:00:26.489
MOMENT WHILE WE GET ADDITIONAL
01:00:26.556 --> 01:00:37.900
LINE NUMBERS.
01:00:37.967 --> 01:00:39.202
AND NEXT WE HAVE LINE 30, PLEASE
01:00:39.268 --> 01:00:43.272
GO AHEAD. OKAY FROM PASADENA,
01:00:43.339 --> 01:00:44.307
CALIFORNIA SUPPORTERS 23 09.
01:00:44.374 --> 01:00:53.583
THANK YOU. AND NEXT. WE HAVE
01:00:53.649 --> 01:00:58.988
LINE 1 16, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:00:59.055 --> 01:01:00.690
HELLO MY NAME IS BRIAN 10. I'M
01:01:00.757 --> 01:01:02.425
AN ATTORNEY WITH A NON PROFIT
01:01:02.492 --> 01:01:03.993
ORGANIZATION AND THEIR WAY OF
01:01:04.060 --> 01:01:05.194
LIFE FOR ENTRY PROJECTS IN
01:01:05.261 --> 01:01:06.195
STRONG SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
01:01:06.262 --> 01:01:09.599
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:01:09.665 --> 01:01:12.402
AND THAT IS ALL I HAD IN QUÊ.
01:01:12.468 --> 01:01:14.303
ALRIGHT UM AND ONCE AGAIN IF
01:01:14.370 --> 01:01:16.272
MISS FORTE RODENHAUSER, THEY
01:01:16.339 --> 01:01:17.473
APPEAR ON THE PHONE LINE WILL
01:01:17.540 --> 01:01:19.776
COME BACK TO THEM. BUT LET'S
01:01:19.842 --> 01:01:21.411
TURN TO THE OPPOSITION. I SEE
01:01:21.477 --> 01:01:22.645
THAT THERE ARE NO PRIMARY
01:01:22.712 --> 01:01:24.580
WITNESSES LISTED IN OPPOSITION.
01:01:24.647 --> 01:01:25.648
ARE THERE ANY WITNESSES IN
01:01:25.715 --> 01:01:26.783
OPPOSITION HERE IN THE HEARING
01:01:26.849 --> 01:01:27.850
OF APPROACHED THE MICROPHONE.
01:01:27.917 --> 01:01:30.019
SEEING NO ONE APPROACHING THE
01:01:30.086 --> 01:01:30.653
MICROPHONE. LET'S CUE UP THOSE
01:01:30.720 --> 01:01:31.654
IN OPPOSITION MODERATOR. ON THE
01:01:31.721 --> 01:01:36.526
PHONE LINE. THANK YOU. YOU WISH
01:01:36.592 --> 01:01:37.593
TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION, PLEASE
01:01:37.660 --> 01:01:46.135
PRESS 10. THAT IS ONE THAN ZERO
01:01:46.202 --> 01:01:52.408
ON YOUR TELEPHONE. I HAVE NO ONE
01:01:52.475 --> 01:01:56.412
IN QUÊ. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. UM
01:01:56.479 --> 01:01:58.648
LET'S BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE
01:01:58.714 --> 01:01:59.649
QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS
01:01:59.715 --> 01:02:03.119
SAYING YES, SENATOR CABALLERO.
01:02:03.186 --> 01:02:05.855
HMM I DON'T HAVE A QUESTION, BUT
01:02:05.922 --> 01:02:08.024
I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT, UM THAT
01:02:08.091 --> 01:02:10.193
I REALLY LIKE THIS BILL. UM IT
01:02:10.259 --> 01:02:12.261
IS UNBELIEVABLE. I DID A LOT OF
01:02:12.328 --> 01:02:16.432
WORK IN THE 300. UM UM. WELFARE
01:02:16.499 --> 01:02:17.767
AND INSTITUTIONS CALLED BOTH IN
01:02:17.834 --> 01:02:19.969
TERMS OF BEING APPOINTED AS A
01:02:20.036 --> 01:02:21.404
AND ATTORNEY TO REPRESENT
01:02:21.471 --> 01:02:23.406
PARENTS AND THE KIDS. UM, AND
01:02:23.473 --> 01:02:24.507
IT'S UNBELIEVABLE TO ME THAT
01:02:24.574 --> 01:02:27.777
GUARDIANSHIPS MAY NOT HAVE BEEN
01:02:27.844 --> 01:02:30.012
A PRIORITY AND IN SOME AREAS AND
01:02:30.079 --> 01:02:34.884
THE LEAST DISRUPTIVE. ACTION
01:02:34.951 --> 01:02:37.887
THAT WE CAN TAKE IS TO REMOVE A
01:02:37.954 --> 01:02:40.790
CHILD AND ARE A TEEN AND PLACE
01:02:40.857 --> 01:02:42.458
THEM WITH SOMEONE THAT THEY KNOW
01:02:42.525 --> 01:02:43.960
YOU KNOW, DURING A REALLY,
01:02:44.026 --> 01:02:46.229
REALLY TRAUMATIC TIME IN THEIR
01:02:46.295 --> 01:02:47.663
LIVES, AND SO I'M GOING TO
01:02:47.730 --> 01:02:49.665
SUPPORT THE BILL. I'LL MOVE THE
01:02:49.732 --> 01:02:51.000
BILL WHEN IT'S APPROPRIATE, AND
01:02:51.067 --> 01:02:52.735
I'D LIKE TO BE ADDED AS A CO
01:02:52.802 --> 01:02:53.936
AUTHOR, IF YOU'D BE SO INCLINED.
01:02:54.003 --> 01:02:55.471
WILL BE OUR HONOR. THANK YOU.
01:02:55.538 --> 01:02:58.508
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT, UM OTHER
01:02:58.574 --> 01:02:59.709
QUESTIONS. COMMENTS WE ARE
01:02:59.775 --> 01:03:01.944
SUBCOMMITTEE POINT IN TIME. WHEN
01:03:02.011 --> 01:03:03.112
WE HAVE A QUORUM, I EXPECT
01:03:03.179 --> 01:03:04.347
THERE'LL BE A MOTION. SOME OF
01:03:04.413 --> 01:03:05.615
THE MEMBER FRIEDMAN. WOULD YOU
01:03:05.681 --> 01:03:07.049
CARE CLOSE? JUST I REALLY
01:03:07.116 --> 01:03:08.417
APPRECIATE THE COOPERATION
01:03:08.484 --> 01:03:10.253
AUTHORSHIP OFFERS. WE'RE VERY
01:03:10.319 --> 01:03:12.421
PROUD TO HAVE YOU BOTH. AND THE
01:03:12.488 --> 01:03:13.756
BILL I BELIEVE HAS WELL, THERE'S
01:03:13.823 --> 01:03:15.491
NO KNOWN OPPOSITION. IT'S GOTTEN
01:03:15.558 --> 01:03:17.326
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. SO THANK YOU
01:03:17.393 --> 01:03:20.429
VERY MUCH. ALL OF YOU APOLOGIZE
01:03:20.496 --> 01:03:21.931
TO APOLOGIES TO MISS FORTE AND
01:03:21.998 --> 01:03:23.766
RUTH HOUSE OR NO DOUBT THEY'RE
01:03:23.833 --> 01:03:26.102
TRYING TO FIND US AT THIS POINT.
01:03:26.169 --> 01:03:28.004
SO ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. UM
01:03:28.070 --> 01:03:29.338
OTHER ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WHO ARE
01:03:29.405 --> 01:03:35.945
PRESENT SEEING NONE. SOMEBODY IS
01:03:36.012 --> 01:03:44.153
WALKING OVER HERE, OKAY? SO THIS
01:03:44.220 --> 01:03:49.058
IS A RARE OPPORTUNITY. UM. FOR
01:03:49.125 --> 01:03:50.459
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TO HAVE THEIR
01:03:50.526 --> 01:03:52.261
BUILDS. HEARD FIRST COME FIRST
01:03:52.328 --> 01:03:53.396
SERVE AS I MENTIONED A WHILE
01:03:53.462 --> 01:03:58.267
AGO. NOT A RARE OPPORTUNITY OF
01:03:58.334 --> 01:04:00.069
THEIR BILLS HER BUT JUST THE
01:04:00.136 --> 01:04:01.170
RARE OPPORTUNITY OF THEIR BILLS
01:04:01.237 --> 01:04:11.080
HEARD EARLY. RIGHT? HE'S GOING
01:04:11.147 --> 01:04:25.861
TO GAVEL DOWN.
01:04:25.928 --> 01:04:27.830
AND I SAW ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD
01:04:27.897 --> 01:04:33.002
HERE POKED HIS HEAD IN. THAT'D
01:04:33.069 --> 01:04:34.604
BE REAL COOL FOR HIM BECAUSE
01:04:34.670 --> 01:04:50.720
HE'S ITEM NUMBER 29. TRUE.
01:04:50.786 --> 01:04:55.491
YES, UM. WE'RE GOING TO RECESS
01:04:55.558 --> 01:04:58.694
AT NOON FOR 90 MINUTES AND THEN
01:04:58.761 --> 01:05:00.396
COME BACK, AND THERE'LL BE A
01:05:00.463 --> 01:05:17.513
SPECIAL ORDER AT 1 30 SCHNUR.
01:05:17.580 --> 01:05:33.663
YEAH.
01:08:28.437 --> 01:08:29.772
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SARTO. LET'S
01:08:29.839 --> 01:08:35.911
SEE. YOU ARE ITEM NUMBER 27. SO. WELCOME WELCOME TO SENATE
01:08:35.978 --> 01:08:36.912
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ITEM NUMBER
01:08:36.979 --> 01:08:41.083
27 A B 17 11. UM SOME OF THEM
01:08:41.150 --> 01:08:43.018
OVER CR CR TOE. THE FLOOR IS
01:08:43.085 --> 01:08:46.088
YOURS. WELL THANK YOU SO MUCH
01:08:46.155 --> 01:08:47.256
FOR HEARING THIS THIS MORNING.
01:08:47.323 --> 01:08:50.125
I'M HERE TO PRESENT 17 11. FIRST
01:08:50.192 --> 01:08:50.960
I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE
01:08:51.026 --> 01:08:52.795
COMMITTEE FOR THEIR ROBUST
01:08:52.862 --> 01:08:54.597
DISCUSSION. I'M WITH MY STAFF ON
01:08:54.663 --> 01:08:57.099
THIS BILL. UNDER CURRENT LAW IF
01:08:57.166 --> 01:08:59.068
A PERSON OR BUSINESS SUFFERS A
01:08:59.134 --> 01:09:01.070
DATA BREACH THE REPORT IS
01:09:01.136 --> 01:09:02.371
SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF
01:09:02.438 --> 01:09:04.073
JUSTICE AND THE BUSINESS POSTS A
01:09:04.139 --> 01:09:06.041
REPORT OF THE BREACH ON THEIR
01:09:06.108 --> 01:09:09.512
WEBSITE. PEOPLE WHO MAY HAVE HAD
01:09:09.578 --> 01:09:10.479
THEIR DATA EXPOSED AND THEN
01:09:10.546 --> 01:09:11.780
NOTIFIED BY PHONE, MAIL OR OTHER
01:09:11.847 --> 01:09:15.251
ELECTRONIC MEANS, LIKE EMAIL.
01:09:15.317 --> 01:09:16.952
THE SAME PROCESS IS USED WHEN A
01:09:17.019 --> 01:09:18.521
STATE AGENCY SUFFERS A DATA
01:09:18.587 --> 01:09:20.756
BREACH. HOWEVER CURRENT LAW IS
01:09:20.823 --> 01:09:22.758
VAGUE WHEN COMPANIES THAT ARE
01:09:22.825 --> 01:09:23.592
ACTUALLY WORKING WITH THE
01:09:23.659 --> 01:09:24.693
GOVERNMENT SYSTEMS SUFFER THAT
01:09:24.760 --> 01:09:28.364
SAME DATA BREACH. IN THESE
01:09:28.430 --> 01:09:29.865
INSTANCES, THE COMPANIES
01:09:29.932 --> 01:09:32.101
GENERALLY POST THE REPORT OF THE
01:09:32.167 --> 01:09:33.903
DATA BREACH RATHER THAN THE
01:09:33.969 --> 01:09:36.071
STATE AGENCY. THIS METHOD OF
01:09:36.138 --> 01:09:37.573
REPORTING DOES NOT INFORM THE
01:09:37.640 --> 01:09:38.908
PUBLIC THAT THEIR INFORMATION
01:09:38.974 --> 01:09:40.543
WAS BEING HANDLED BY THIRD
01:09:40.609 --> 01:09:43.379
PARTY. THE PURPOSE OF THESE
01:09:43.445 --> 01:09:44.947
REPORTING MECHANISMS IS TO
01:09:45.014 --> 01:09:46.382
PROVIDE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
01:09:46.448 --> 01:09:47.950
WOULD TRANSPARENCY OF HOW THEIR
01:09:48.017 --> 01:09:49.585
PRIVATE INFORMATION IS HANDLED
01:09:49.652 --> 01:09:50.986
BY THE GOVERNMENT. THIS IS
01:09:51.053 --> 01:09:53.255
ESSENTIAL IN TODAY'S DIGITAL AGE
01:09:53.322 --> 01:09:54.757
, AS THIS INFORMATION QUITE
01:09:54.823 --> 01:09:56.959
LITERALLY PRESENTS THE KEYS TO
01:09:57.026 --> 01:09:58.460
PEOPLE'S LIVES AND LIVELIHOOD IF
01:09:58.527 --> 01:10:00.863
IT FALLS INTO THE WRONG HANDS.
01:10:00.930 --> 01:10:02.731
IDENTITY THEFT IS BECOMING MORE
01:10:02.798 --> 01:10:05.334
AND MORE COMMON SO MUCH MORE
01:10:05.401 --> 01:10:07.870
THAT IN IT IS NOW THE MOST
01:10:07.937 --> 01:10:08.871
COMMON REASON FOR DATA BREACHES
01:10:08.938 --> 01:10:11.607
SINCE 2016 AND ACCOUNTS FOR 59%
01:10:11.674 --> 01:10:14.043
OF ALL DATA BREACHES GLOBALLY.
01:10:14.109 --> 01:10:15.010
FURTHERMORE BECAUSE OF THE
01:10:15.077 --> 01:10:17.012
WIDESPREAD USE OF PHISHING
01:10:17.079 --> 01:10:19.114
SCHEMES, MANY PEOPLE OFTEN
01:10:19.181 --> 01:10:20.616
ASSUME THAT THESE REAL
01:10:20.683 --> 01:10:23.052
NOTIFICATIONS ARE FRAUD BECAUSE
01:10:23.118 --> 01:10:23.619
THEY'RE NOT COMING FROM THE
01:10:23.686 --> 01:10:24.553
GOVERNMENT, AND THEY ARE NOT
01:10:24.620 --> 01:10:28.324
FAMILIAR WITH THE AGENTS ARE THE
01:10:28.390 --> 01:10:29.525
BUSINESS THAT IS SENDING THEM
01:10:29.592 --> 01:10:32.861
THAT THAT LETTER OR THAT EMAIL.
01:10:32.928 --> 01:10:34.363
IT'S UNDERSTANDABLE, CONSIDERING
01:10:34.430 --> 01:10:35.864
THAT ALL THESE NOTIFICATIONS MAY
01:10:35.931 --> 01:10:37.366
COME FROM A COMPANY AS A THIRD
01:10:37.433 --> 01:10:39.001
PARTY CONTROL CONTRACTOR, AND
01:10:39.068 --> 01:10:40.402
THE INDIVIDUAL HAS NEVER HAD ANY
01:10:40.469 --> 01:10:43.372
INTERACTIONS WITH THEM BEFORE.
01:10:43.439 --> 01:10:44.873
CALIFORNIANS SHOULD BE FULLY
01:10:44.940 --> 01:10:45.975
INFORMED ABOUT WHO WAS
01:10:46.041 --> 01:10:47.109
RESPONSIBLE FOR HANDLING THEIR
01:10:47.176 --> 01:10:49.178
PRIVATE INFORMATION. THIS IS
01:10:49.244 --> 01:10:50.346
ESSENTIAL TO MAINTAIN
01:10:50.412 --> 01:10:52.748
ACCOUNTABILITY, TRANSPARENCY AND
01:10:52.815 --> 01:10:53.616
CONFIDENCE THAT SENSITIVE
01:10:53.682 --> 01:10:54.516
INFORMATION IS HANDLED
01:10:54.583 --> 01:10:58.220
RESPONSIBLY. A B 17 11 WOULD
01:10:58.287 --> 01:10:59.688
REQUIRE GOVERNMENT AGENCIES TO
01:10:59.755 --> 01:11:02.024
REPORT DATA BREACHES OF ENTITIES
01:11:02.091 --> 01:11:04.126
WHO ARE WORKING ON OR WITH
01:11:04.193 --> 01:11:06.295
GOVERNMENT SYSTEMS. IN ADDITION
01:11:06.362 --> 01:11:07.696
TO THE REPORTS POSTED BY THOSE
01:11:07.763 --> 01:11:09.598
ENTITIES, THIS WILL PROVIDE THE
01:11:09.665 --> 01:11:10.799
PUBLIC WITH A MORE INFORMED
01:11:10.866 --> 01:11:12.835
UNDERSTANDING AND CLARITY OF HOW
01:11:12.901 --> 01:11:14.169
THEIR INFORMATION IS HANDLED AND
01:11:14.236 --> 01:11:15.270
ALLOW THEM TO RESPOND.
01:11:15.337 --> 01:11:20.042
ACCORDINGLY. THANK YOU. UM I
01:11:20.109 --> 01:11:21.343
SEE. NO NO WITNESSES LISTED IN
01:11:21.410 --> 01:11:24.647
SUPPORT. NÓI ALRIGHT. BRING
01:11:24.713 --> 01:11:26.115
WITNESSES TODAY. ALRIGHT WELL,
01:11:26.181 --> 01:11:27.883
LET'S TAKE WITNESSES AND SUPPORT
01:11:27.950 --> 01:11:30.185
HERE IN ROOM 2100. IF YOU'RE IN
01:11:30.252 --> 01:11:31.253
SUPPORT, PLEASE APPROACH THE
01:11:31.320 --> 01:11:33.188
MICROPHONE. SAYING NO ONE
01:11:33.255 --> 01:11:34.923
APPROACHES MY PHONE QUEUE UP
01:11:34.990 --> 01:11:39.895
THOSE IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 11.
01:11:39.962 --> 01:11:44.099
TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 11
01:11:44.166 --> 01:11:46.035
, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
01:11:46.101 --> 01:11:53.876
YOUR PHONE. AND FIRST WE HAVE
01:11:53.942 --> 01:12:00.149
LINE 30. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:12:00.215 --> 01:12:01.183
GARY WITH THE OPEN PRIVACY AND
01:12:01.250 --> 01:12:08.390
SUPPORTED A B 17 11. THANK YOU.
01:12:08.457 --> 01:12:09.558
THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL I
01:12:09.625 --> 01:12:12.728
HAVE IN QUÊ. ALRIGHT LET'S GO TO
01:12:12.795 --> 01:12:16.231
OPPOSITION. UM I HAVE ERIN AVERY
01:12:16.298 --> 01:12:17.266
AND DOROTHY JOHNSON AND
01:12:17.332 --> 01:12:22.638
OPPOSITION TO A B 17 11. GOOD
01:12:22.705 --> 01:12:24.840
MORNING, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
01:12:24.907 --> 01:12:25.607
THE COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS ERIN
01:12:25.674 --> 01:12:26.608
AVERY WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:12:26.675 --> 01:12:28.510
SPECIAL DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION
01:12:28.577 --> 01:12:30.045
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED UNLESS THE
01:12:30.112 --> 01:12:31.447
BILL IS AMENDED TO ADDRESS THE
01:12:31.513 --> 01:12:32.948
CONCERNS SET FORTH IN THE LETTER
01:12:33.015 --> 01:12:35.250
THAT WE SUBMITTED TO COMMITTEE I
01:12:35.317 --> 01:12:36.719
FIRST WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
01:12:36.785 --> 01:12:38.053
AND HIS STAFF FOR THEIR
01:12:38.120 --> 01:12:39.188
WILLINGNESS TO DISCUSS THIS
01:12:39.254 --> 01:12:40.422
ABILITY. HERE ARE CONCERNS.
01:12:40.489 --> 01:12:41.623
HOWEVER WE UNFORTUNATELY HAVE
01:12:41.690 --> 01:12:43.459
NOT BEEN ABLE TO MAKE PROGRESS
01:12:43.525 --> 01:12:45.427
ON KEY ASPECTS OF THE BILL. WELL
01:12:45.494 --> 01:12:47.096
THE AUTHORS GOAL OF CREATING A
01:12:47.162 --> 01:12:47.830
CONNECTION IN THE MIND OF
01:12:47.896 --> 01:12:49.531
RECIPIENT OF A THIRD PARTIES. I
01:12:49.598 --> 01:12:51.900
E VENDORS NOTICE OF A DATA
01:12:51.967 --> 01:12:53.802
BREACH IN THE AGENCY THEY WERE
01:12:53.869 --> 01:12:55.771
WORKING WITH IS A LAUDABLE THIS
01:12:55.838 --> 01:12:57.005
BILL SEEKS TO ACHIEVE IT THROUGH
01:12:57.072 --> 01:12:58.073
AN INEFFICIENT AND BURDENSOME
01:12:58.140 --> 01:13:00.142
MECHANISM. THE OBJECTIVE OF THIS
01:13:00.209 --> 01:13:02.144
BILL CAN CAN INSTEAD BE ACHIEVED
01:13:02.211 --> 01:13:03.912
BY SIMPLY REQUIRING THAT WHEN A
01:13:03.979 --> 01:13:06.014
VENDOR DISCLOSES A DATA BREACH
01:13:06.081 --> 01:13:07.950
THAT NOTICE ALSO STATE, THE NAME
01:13:08.016 --> 01:13:09.151
OF THE PUBLIC AGENCY, THE VENDOR
01:13:09.218 --> 01:13:10.953
WAS CONTRACTING WITH THAT IS THE
01:13:11.019 --> 01:13:12.020
PRIMARY AMENDMENT THAT WE ARE
01:13:12.087 --> 01:13:14.456
SEEKING. IN ADDITION TO
01:13:14.523 --> 01:13:15.958
ELIMINATING THE TAXPAYER COSTS
01:13:16.024 --> 01:13:18.093
ASSOCIATED WITH THIS BILL, ARE
01:13:18.160 --> 01:13:19.128
PROPOSED AMENDMENT WOULD AVOID
01:13:19.194 --> 01:13:20.129
OTHER SIGNIFICANT PROBLEMS WITH
01:13:20.195 --> 01:13:22.931
THE BILL. FOR EXAMPLE, CSD AS
01:13:22.998 --> 01:13:24.533
MEMBERS PROVIDE A WIDE RANGE OF
01:13:24.600 --> 01:13:26.735
CRITICAL SERVICES RANGING FROM
01:13:26.802 --> 01:13:28.203
FIRE PROTECTION TO WATER AND
01:13:28.270 --> 01:13:30.139
OTHER PUBLIC UTILITIES. THIS
01:13:30.205 --> 01:13:30.873
OFTEN NECESSITATES A LARGE
01:13:30.939 --> 01:13:34.143
AMOUNT OF SERVICE CRITICAL DATA.
01:13:34.209 --> 01:13:35.878
TO BE LISTED ON HOMEPAGES,
01:13:35.944 --> 01:13:37.746
ADDING ADDITIONAL MANDATED
01:13:37.813 --> 01:13:39.882
HOMEPAGE DATA CLUTTERS THESE
01:13:39.948 --> 01:13:42.885
HOMEPAGES AND DETRACTS FROM THIS
01:13:42.951 --> 01:13:44.286
SERVICE CRITICAL DATA THAT
01:13:44.353 --> 01:13:44.887
MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC EXPECT.
01:13:44.953 --> 01:13:48.624
WHEN THEY WALK IN. WE'RE ALSO
01:13:48.690 --> 01:13:50.259
CONCERNED THAT WE'RE ABOUT BY
01:13:50.325 --> 01:13:51.026
REQUIRING THIS PUBLICLY
01:13:51.093 --> 01:13:53.262
AVAILABLE WEBSITE LINK AND MAYBE
01:13:53.328 --> 01:13:54.663
CREATING OPPORTUNITIES FOR BAD
01:13:54.730 --> 01:13:56.298
ACTORS TO BECOME AWARE OF
01:13:56.365 --> 01:13:57.299
VULNERABILITIES AND TO EXPLOIT
01:13:57.366 --> 01:14:00.502
THEM. AS NOTED IN THE ASSEMBLY
01:14:00.569 --> 01:14:02.104
PRIVACY COMMITTEE ANALYSIS OF
01:14:02.171 --> 01:14:03.639
THIS BILL, IT'S NOT EVEN CLEAR
01:14:03.705 --> 01:14:05.507
HOW MUCH EXPOSURE THESE NOTICES
01:14:05.574 --> 01:14:06.708
ON THESE PUBLIC AGENCY WEBSITES
01:14:06.775 --> 01:14:09.211
WILL RECEIVE. WITH A SIMPLE
01:14:09.278 --> 01:14:11.013
CHANGE TO CURRENT LAW THROUGH
01:14:11.079 --> 01:14:12.581
THE AMENDMENT. WE SEEK WE CAN
01:14:12.648 --> 01:14:14.383
ENSURE THAT THE PUBLIC GETS THE
01:14:14.449 --> 01:14:15.751
NOTICE THAT THEY DESERVE MORE
01:14:15.818 --> 01:14:17.386
DIRECTLY AND AT FAR LESS COST
01:14:17.452 --> 01:14:19.087
AND RISK TO THE PUBLIC. FOR
01:14:19.154 --> 01:14:20.088
THESE REASONS, WE RESPECTFULLY
01:14:20.155 --> 01:14:21.790
ASK FOR A NO VOTE UNLESS THE
01:14:21.857 --> 01:14:23.225
BILL IS AMENDED. THANK YOU.
01:14:23.292 --> 01:14:26.862
THANK YOU. MISS JOHNSON. GOOD
01:14:26.929 --> 01:14:28.197
MORNING, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:14:28.263 --> 01:14:29.364
DOROTHY JOHNSON WITH THE
01:14:29.431 --> 01:14:30.365
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
01:14:30.432 --> 01:14:31.266
ADMINISTRATORS REPRESENTING
01:14:31.333 --> 01:14:33.402
PRINCIPALS AND SUPERINTENDENTS
01:14:33.468 --> 01:14:35.003
AND LINING THE MAJORITY OF MY
01:14:35.070 --> 01:14:35.637
COMMENTS WITH MY COLLEAGUE BUT
01:14:35.704 --> 01:14:37.439
WNTEDTO EMPHASIZE THAT THIS
01:14:37.506 --> 01:14:39.374
BILL IS SEEKING TO USE LOCAL
01:14:39.441 --> 01:14:40.876
PUBLIC RESOURCES FOR AN UNPROVEN
01:14:40.943 --> 01:14:42.578
METHOD OF NOTIFICATION, SORT OF
01:14:42.644 --> 01:14:44.446
THE PANACEA OF PUT IT ON THE
01:14:44.513 --> 01:14:45.681
WEBSITE AND THAT WILL SOLVE ALL
01:14:45.747 --> 01:14:47.382
THE PROBLEMS. BUT FOR OUR
01:14:47.449 --> 01:14:49.084
SCHOOLS, THESE ARE OPERATIONAL
01:14:49.151 --> 01:14:50.185
DOLLARS THAT ARE BEING TAKEN
01:14:50.252 --> 01:14:51.486
AWAY FROM THE CLASSROOM.
01:14:51.553 --> 01:14:53.622
FURTHERMORE AND ONLINE POSTING
01:14:53.689 --> 01:14:55.224
OF THIS NATURE COULD SET OFF AN
01:14:55.290 --> 01:14:56.558
ALARM FOR STUDENTS, PARENTS,
01:14:56.625 --> 01:14:57.392
TEACHERS, OTHER COMMUNITY
01:14:57.459 --> 01:15:00.529
MEMBERS. THOSE THAT AREN'T EVEN
01:15:00.596 --> 01:15:03.532
IMPACTED BY THE BREACH. AND THIS
01:15:03.599 --> 01:15:06.268
IS IN LARGE FONT AND CONTRAST
01:15:06.335 --> 01:15:07.402
AND COLORS. THE FIRST THING
01:15:07.469 --> 01:15:08.537
THEY'RE GOING TO SEE WHEN THEY
01:15:08.604 --> 01:15:10.239
GET TO THEIR HOMEPAGE. OUR
01:15:10.305 --> 01:15:11.440
SCHOOLS HAVE BEEN THE FRONT LINE
01:15:11.506 --> 01:15:12.741
FOR THE PANDEMIC AND REGRETTABLY
01:15:12.808 --> 01:15:15.143
TRAGIC RECENT EVENTS. WE BELIEVE
01:15:15.210 --> 01:15:17.579
THAT THIS TYPE OF BOLD
01:15:17.646 --> 01:15:18.280
NOTIFICATION ON THE HOMEPAGE
01:15:18.347 --> 01:15:21.149
RESERVED FOR OTHER RESOURCES, UM
01:15:21.216 --> 01:15:22.751
, THAT WOULD IMPACT ALL OF THE
01:15:22.818 --> 01:15:25.520
COMMUNITY MEMBERS ACCESSING IT.
01:15:25.587 --> 01:15:26.855
AND THEN, FINALLY, MANY OF THE
01:15:26.922 --> 01:15:28.123
STATEMENTS SHARED THROUGHOUT
01:15:28.190 --> 01:15:29.258
THIS BILL'S REVIEW HAS BEEN
01:15:29.324 --> 01:15:30.626
ABOUT STATE AGENCIES AND THE
01:15:30.692 --> 01:15:31.627
APPLICATION OF THE STATE
01:15:31.693 --> 01:15:33.161
INFORMATION MANAGEMENT MANUAL
01:15:33.228 --> 01:15:35.163
FOR STATE DOCUMENTS. WE BELIEVE
01:15:35.230 --> 01:15:36.265
THIS IS AN INAPPROPRIATE
01:15:36.331 --> 01:15:37.532
APPLICATION TO SCHOOLS AND OTHER
01:15:37.599 --> 01:15:39.067
LOCAL AGENCIES AND FOR THOSE
01:15:39.134 --> 01:15:40.302
REASONS REMAIN OPPOSED UNLESS
01:15:40.369 --> 01:15:41.770
AMENDED. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:15:41.837 --> 01:15:43.205
MISS JOHNSON. OTHERS IN
01:15:43.272 --> 01:15:44.473
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM 2100 IF
01:15:44.539 --> 01:15:45.674
YOU APPROACH THE MICROPHONE,
01:15:45.741 --> 01:15:46.742
SEEING NO ONE APPROACHING THE
01:15:46.808 --> 01:15:48.377
MICROPHONE. LET'S TURN TO THE
01:15:48.443 --> 01:15:50.646
PHONE LINES. UM MODERN IF YOU
01:15:50.712 --> 01:15:51.747
WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN
01:15:51.813 --> 01:15:55.817
OPPOSITION TO A B 17 11. THANK
01:15:55.884 --> 01:15:58.120
YOU AND OPPOSITION OF A B 17 11.
01:15:58.186 --> 01:16:03.592
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND FIRST WE
01:16:03.659 --> 01:16:08.864
HAVE LINE 1 25, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:16:08.931 --> 01:16:10.732
I BELIEVE THEY HIT ONE AND ZERO
01:16:10.799 --> 01:16:13.869
AND THEY REMOVE THEMSELVES. IF
01:16:13.936 --> 01:16:15.404
YOU STILL WISH TO SPEAK, PLEASE
01:16:15.470 --> 01:16:27.516
PRESS 101. AND I OKAY LINE 11
01:16:27.582 --> 01:16:32.354
25, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THAT MEANS
01:16:32.421 --> 01:16:38.493
YES. YES, I'M I'M. I WOULD HOPE
01:16:38.560 --> 01:16:41.730
THEY WOULD VOTE NO ON THIS.
01:16:41.797 --> 01:16:43.598
CALLING INTO ABOUT KNOWING. ALL
01:16:43.665 --> 01:16:44.766
RIGHT, THANK YOU THEM TO VOTE
01:16:44.833 --> 01:16:49.972
NOW. ON S BI<c.cyan>. THANK YOU. THANK</c>
01:16:50.038 --> 01:16:58.080
YOU. AND THAT IS ALL. I HAVEN'T
01:16:58.146 --> 01:17:02.050
YOU, OKAY? AH! LET'S RETURN HERE
01:17:02.117 --> 01:17:03.752
TO THE COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM
01:17:03.819 --> 01:17:06.388
QUESTIONS. SENATOR ROSCOE
01:17:06.455 --> 01:17:07.489
QUESTION. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
01:17:07.556 --> 01:17:10.859
IF THE AUTHOR UM COULD. I'M
01:17:10.926 --> 01:17:12.694
SORRY, NOT THE AUTHOR. IS IT
01:17:12.761 --> 01:17:14.830
POSSIBLE TO HAVE MISS JOHNSON OR
01:17:14.896 --> 01:17:16.131
THE AUTHOR RESPOND TO MISS
01:17:16.198 --> 01:17:21.536
JOHNSON'S ISSUES AND UM, YEAH.
01:17:21.603 --> 01:17:23.872
YES, I'D BE GLAD TO AND OTHER
01:17:23.939 --> 01:17:26.074
ISSUES CURRENTLY, THERE ARE
01:17:26.141 --> 01:17:27.809
ALREADY REQUIRED TO DO THIS WHEN
01:17:27.876 --> 01:17:29.711
THEY'RE THE ONES WHO DO THE DATA
01:17:29.778 --> 01:17:32.147
BREACH. THIS JUST REQUIRES THEM
01:17:32.214 --> 01:17:34.249
TO BE ABLE TO DO THE SAME THING
01:17:34.316 --> 01:17:35.550
WHEN THEY'RE DEALING WITH THE
01:17:35.617 --> 01:17:37.319
THIRD PARTY, EVEN THOUGH THE
01:17:37.386 --> 01:17:38.453
THIRD PARTY IS REQUIRED TO DO
01:17:38.520 --> 01:17:40.489
THAT, AND I CAN KIND OF PUT THIS
01:17:40.555 --> 01:17:43.625
INTO REAL LIFE. UM AS IS IN THIS
01:17:43.692 --> 01:17:46.028
AFFECTS A LOT OF SENIOR CITIZENS
01:17:46.094 --> 01:17:46.628
BECAUSE THEY'RE GOING THROUGH
01:17:46.695 --> 01:17:48.997
THEIR TON OF EMAILS THAT THEY
01:17:49.064 --> 01:17:50.365
GET IN. A LOT OF THEM ARE
01:17:50.432 --> 01:17:51.500
PHISHING SCAMS AND WHEN THEY
01:17:51.566 --> 01:17:54.669
WHEN THEY'RE TRYING TO FIGURE
01:17:54.736 --> 01:17:56.405
OUT WHICH ONES ARE LEGITIMATE
01:17:56.471 --> 01:17:58.140
AND WHICH ONES AREN'T UM, WHEN
01:17:58.206 --> 01:18:00.442
THEY SEE A NOTIFICATION FROM A
01:18:00.509 --> 01:18:01.610
COMPANY THAT THEY HAVE NEVER,
01:18:01.676 --> 01:18:04.946
EVER DEALT WITH. AS OPPOSED TO A
01:18:05.013 --> 01:18:07.382
NOTIFICATION FROM A GOVERNMENT
01:18:07.449 --> 01:18:08.950
AGENCY THAT THEY KNOW THEY HAVE
01:18:09.017 --> 01:18:10.719
DEALT WITH THEIR. THEY'RE MORE
01:18:10.786 --> 01:18:14.856
APT TO YOU TO OPEN THAT. UM AND
01:18:14.923 --> 01:18:16.591
CHECK IT OUT. UM THE PHISHING
01:18:16.658 --> 01:18:18.126
SCHEMES THEMSELVES. ONCE YOU'VE
01:18:18.193 --> 01:18:19.494
OPENED UP AN EMAIL, YOU HAVE
01:18:19.561 --> 01:18:21.763
OPENED UP YOUR COMPUTER TO FRAUD
01:18:21.830 --> 01:18:25.567
AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO
01:18:25.634 --> 01:18:28.070
BATTLE AGAINST IS TRYING TO GIVE
01:18:28.136 --> 01:18:30.839
PEOPLE WHO ARE AH, BEING
01:18:30.906 --> 01:18:33.642
SUBJECTED TO DATA BREACHES. UH
01:18:33.708 --> 01:18:35.177
WHAT THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO GET,
01:18:35.243 --> 01:18:36.645
WHICH IS NOTIFICATION FROM THE
01:18:36.711 --> 01:18:38.513
GOVERNMENT AGENCY, WHETHER IT'S
01:18:38.580 --> 01:18:39.848
OUT SPECIAL DISTRICT OF SCHOOL,
01:18:39.915 --> 01:18:41.116
YOU KNOW SCHOOL DISTRICTS OR
01:18:41.183 --> 01:18:42.884
YOUR STATE AGENCIES OR LOCAL
01:18:42.951 --> 01:18:46.121
AGENCIES. AH THE NOTIFICATIONS
01:18:46.188 --> 01:18:47.022
THAT THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO GET
01:18:47.089 --> 01:18:52.294
FROM THEM. AND SO, UH, AS I'VE
01:18:52.360 --> 01:18:53.662
SAID, THEY'VE ALREADY THEY'RE
01:18:53.728 --> 01:18:55.097
ALREADY REQUIRED TO DO THAT ON
01:18:55.163 --> 01:18:57.399
ONES THAT THEY'RE NOT USING
01:18:57.466 --> 01:18:58.433
THIRD PARTY. THIS JUST REQUIRES
01:18:58.500 --> 01:19:00.435
THEM TO DO THAT. WITH THE THIRD
01:19:00.502 --> 01:19:01.503
PARTY. IT DOES NOT AS
01:19:01.570 --> 01:19:05.607
PREVAILING. AS TO CREATE THIS,
01:19:05.674 --> 01:19:08.710
UH, THIS FIRESTORM OF ACTIVITY.
01:19:08.777 --> 01:19:10.445
BUT IT JUST HELPS PROTECT THE
01:19:10.512 --> 01:19:14.116
CONSUMER TO IDENTIFY WHEN THEIR
01:19:14.182 --> 01:19:16.251
DATA HAS BEEN BREACHED AND GIVE
01:19:16.318 --> 01:19:17.352
THEM OTHER MEANS TO IDENTIFY
01:19:17.419 --> 01:19:19.454
THAT. ALREADY. THANK YOU. YES,
01:19:19.521 --> 01:19:24.493
SENATOR BARREIRO. THANK YOU SO
01:19:24.559 --> 01:19:27.362
MUCH, UM, FOR, UM, THAT
01:19:27.429 --> 01:19:29.131
EXPLANATION. I THINK THAT THE
01:19:29.197 --> 01:19:31.399
CHALLENGE I HAVE IS IN YOUR
01:19:31.466 --> 01:19:33.034
YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. THERE'S
01:19:33.101 --> 01:19:34.469
A WHOLE BUNCH OF REASONS PEOPLE
01:19:34.536 --> 01:19:36.304
DON'T WANT TO OPEN EMAILS. I'M
01:19:36.371 --> 01:19:39.508
JUST STRUGGLING WITH HOW THERE'S
01:19:39.574 --> 01:19:41.076
BEEN A DATA BREACH. MY
01:19:41.143 --> 01:19:43.011
INFORMATION HAS BEEN STOLEN. I
01:19:43.078 --> 01:19:46.615
GET A TEXT. FROM THE THIRD PARTY
01:19:46.681 --> 01:19:49.017
VENDOR. I'M NOT GOING TO OPEN IT
01:19:49.084 --> 01:19:51.520
. SO HOW DO I KNOW TO GO TO THE
01:19:51.586 --> 01:19:52.654
WEBSITE? I MEAN, AND THAT'S
01:19:52.721 --> 01:19:54.523
THAT'S MY CHALLENGE, AND I'M
01:19:54.589 --> 01:19:56.358
WONDERING WHY WE DON'T JUST SAY.
01:19:56.424 --> 01:19:58.894
BECAUSE I LIKE WHAT YOU'RE
01:19:58.960 --> 01:20:00.295
TRYING TO DO. I JUST THINK IT'S
01:20:00.362 --> 01:20:01.863
THE WRONG SOLUTION. BUT WHY
01:20:01.930 --> 01:20:03.965
DON'T WE JUST SAY YOU HAVE TO
01:20:04.032 --> 01:20:05.367
SEND IT OUT? THE THIRD PARTY
01:20:05.433 --> 01:20:07.903
VENDOR CAN WRITE UP THE NOTICE,
01:20:07.969 --> 01:20:09.905
BUT THEN THE PUBLIC AGENCY
01:20:09.971 --> 01:20:10.972
SHOULD BE SENDING OUT THE
01:20:11.039 --> 01:20:13.575
INFORMATION. BECAUSE IT'S AT
01:20:13.642 --> 01:20:15.010
THEIR BEQUESTS THAT THE
01:20:15.076 --> 01:20:16.711
INFORMATION WAS RECEIVED OR
01:20:16.778 --> 01:20:18.980
COLLECTED. UH THEY'RE THE ONES
01:20:19.047 --> 01:20:19.514
THAT HIRED THE THIRD PARTY
01:20:19.581 --> 01:20:21.516
VENDOR. WHY NOT JUST DO IT THAT
01:20:21.583 --> 01:20:24.386
WAY SO THAT UM, IT'S NOT
01:20:24.452 --> 01:20:26.521
SOMETHING THAT I GOT TO GO ON A
01:20:26.588 --> 01:20:28.123
WEB PAGE AND SEARCH FOR, UM WHEN
01:20:28.190 --> 01:20:29.791
I DON'T KNOW, AND I HAVEN'T
01:20:29.858 --> 01:20:33.895
OPENED AN ADVISEMENT. RIGHT I
01:20:33.962 --> 01:20:35.363
WOULD BELIEVE THAT WOULD TAKE A
01:20:35.430 --> 01:20:38.366
CHANGE IN THE LAW TO, UH, NOT
01:20:38.433 --> 01:20:40.435
HAVE THAT THIRD PARTY VENDOR BE
01:20:40.502 --> 01:20:41.870
RESPONSIBLE FOR DOING THAT
01:20:41.937 --> 01:20:44.005
THEY'D HAVE TO BE TAKEN OUT OF
01:20:44.072 --> 01:20:45.407
THE LAW TO BE ABLE TO DO THAT.
01:20:45.473 --> 01:20:49.711
THIS JUST TRIES TO COVER ALL THE
01:20:49.778 --> 01:20:51.880
BASES SO THAT PEOPLE HAVE EVERY
01:20:51.947 --> 01:20:53.582
OPPORTUNITY. THEY'RE NOT ALWAYS
01:20:53.648 --> 01:20:55.417
GOING TO TAKE IT, BUT THEY'RE
01:20:55.483 --> 01:20:56.818
THEY HAVE EVERY OPPORTUNITY. TO
01:20:56.885 --> 01:20:58.186
GET THE INFORMATION THAT THEIR
01:20:58.253 --> 01:20:59.688
DATA HAS BEEN BREACHED AND TO
01:20:59.754 --> 01:21:01.122
TAKE THE NECESSARY ACTIONS THAT
01:21:01.189 --> 01:21:04.025
THEY NEED TO PROTECT THEMSELVES
01:21:04.092 --> 01:21:05.727
. SO I GET IT TAKES A CHANGE OF
01:21:05.794 --> 01:21:08.063
THE LAW. BUT THIS IS TE CHANGE
01:21:08.129 --> 01:21:09.364
OF THE LAW GOING TO CHANGE IT.
01:21:09.431 --> 01:21:11.132
WHY? WHY DON'T WE CHANGE IT SO
01:21:11.199 --> 01:21:12.367
THAT THEY ACTUALLY GET THE
01:21:12.434 --> 01:21:13.735
NOTICE? I MEAN, I STILL MIGHT.
01:21:13.802 --> 01:21:15.604
IF IT'S A PUBLIC AGENCY, I STILL
01:21:15.670 --> 01:21:17.038
MIGHT NOT OPEN IT. THERE'S SOME
01:21:17.105 --> 01:21:18.773
WEIRD STUFF OUT THERE. THAT
01:21:18.840 --> 01:21:21.376
ABSOLUTELY AGREE WOULDN'T EVEN
01:21:21.443 --> 01:21:22.544
BOTHER OPENING IT. BUT AT LEAST
01:21:22.611 --> 01:21:25.380
THAT'S MY CHOICE, AND I DECLINED
01:21:25.447 --> 01:21:28.450
TO OPEN IT RIGHT THAN SETTING UP
01:21:28.516 --> 01:21:30.785
A WEBSITE THAT I THINK HAS SOME
01:21:30.852 --> 01:21:32.988
CHALLENGES. AND SO I DO
01:21:33.054 --> 01:21:34.055
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
01:21:34.122 --> 01:21:35.991
DO. AND I JUST THINK THERE'S A
01:21:36.057 --> 01:21:38.093
SOMETIMES THE SOLUTION IS TO IS,
01:21:38.159 --> 01:21:43.632
UM. IS TO FIGURE OUT IF THERE'S
01:21:43.698 --> 01:21:46.434
A WAY TO DO IT THAT DOESN'T SET
01:21:46.501 --> 01:21:48.036
IT MORE LIABILITY, AND WE'VE
01:21:48.103 --> 01:21:49.137
TRIED TO EXPLORE SOME OF THOSE.
01:21:49.204 --> 01:21:51.139
BUT THIS SEEMED TO BE THE
01:21:51.206 --> 01:21:52.340
EASIEST WAY TO BE ABLE TO ENACT
01:21:52.407 --> 01:21:53.341
SOMETHING THAT WOULD HELP
01:21:53.408 --> 01:21:54.876
PROTECT CONSUMERS. AND IT'S NOT
01:21:54.943 --> 01:21:57.012
AS ONEROUS ON GOVERNMENT
01:21:57.078 --> 01:21:59.147
AGENCIES OR PUBLIC AGENCIES AS
01:21:59.214 --> 01:22:02.150
PEOPLE MAKE IT SOUND. ALL IT IS
01:22:02.217 --> 01:22:04.552
, IS JUST GIVING THAT PERSON THE
01:22:04.619 --> 01:22:05.320
OPPORTUNITY TO SEE SOMETHING
01:22:05.387 --> 01:22:06.921
THEY'RE FAMILIAR WITH AND SAYING
01:22:06.988 --> 01:22:08.023
YES, I REMEMBER DEALING WITH
01:22:08.089 --> 01:22:10.692
THESE YOU KNOW THIS, BUT THIS
01:22:10.759 --> 01:22:11.926
ISSUE IN THE GOVERNMENT AGENCY
01:22:11.993 --> 01:22:13.795
IS TELLING ME THERE'S AN ISSUE.
01:22:13.862 --> 01:22:15.697
I'M GOING TO LOOK AT THAT. AND
01:22:15.764 --> 01:22:18.333
BECAUSE I DO THIS FOR FRIENDS
01:22:18.400 --> 01:22:20.502
AND RELATIVES OF MINE GO THROUGH
01:22:20.568 --> 01:22:22.370
THEIR EMAILS TO MAKE SURE
01:22:22.437 --> 01:22:24.306
THEY'RE NOT OPENING THINGS THAT
01:22:24.372 --> 01:22:26.074
ARE GOING TO BE BAD FOR THEIR
01:22:26.141 --> 01:22:27.976
COMPUTERS. AND YOU SEE A LOT OF
01:22:28.043 --> 01:22:31.546
THIS. SO ALL RIGHT, UM, BUT THAT
01:22:31.613 --> 01:22:33.915
I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I VOTE.
01:22:33.982 --> 01:22:35.016
OKAY WE'RE SUBCOMMITTEE WHEN WE
01:22:35.083 --> 01:22:38.520
OKAY. REACH QUORUM WILL LIKELY
01:22:38.586 --> 01:22:39.654
BE EMOTION. ALRIGHT. APPRECIATE
01:22:39.721 --> 01:22:40.722
IT. THANK YOU. SO REMEMBER, ALL
01:22:40.789 --> 01:22:54.102
RIGHT. SOME MEMBER BARAKEH ON.
01:22:54.169 --> 01:22:59.607
GOOD ALMOST AFTERNOON. YES UM
01:22:59.674 --> 01:23:05.046
AND YOU HAVE A B 1666 ITEM
01:23:05.113 --> 01:23:06.514
NUMBER FOUR AND THEN ITEM NUMBER
01:23:06.581 --> 01:23:10.485
FIVE A B 2571. ALSO PRESENTING A
01:23:10.552 --> 01:23:13.254
B 2091 FROM PONTA. ALRIGHT ALSO
01:23:13.321 --> 01:23:15.623
2091 FOR MISS BONTA, SO LET'S
01:23:15.690 --> 01:23:16.558
BEGIN WITH ITEM NUMBER FOUR.
01:23:16.624 --> 01:23:18.626
PERFECT MAYBE 16 66. THANK YOU,
01:23:18.693 --> 01:23:22.330
MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. A B 16 66
01:23:22.397 --> 01:23:23.865
IS THE BILL TO PROTECT ABORTION
01:23:23.932 --> 01:23:26.101
CARE HERE IN CALIFORNIA LAWS
01:23:26.167 --> 01:23:27.001
ACROSS THE COUNTRY ARE MAKING
01:23:27.068 --> 01:23:29.938
ABORTION, A CRIME OR PROVIDING A
01:23:30.004 --> 01:23:32.040
CIVIL PENALTY OFTEN THAT COMES
01:23:32.107 --> 01:23:32.941
WITH TENS OF THOUSANDS OF
01:23:33.007 --> 01:23:34.743
DOLLARS IN PENALTIES FOR BOTH
01:23:34.809 --> 01:23:36.244
PATIENTS AND PROVIDERS. THE
01:23:36.311 --> 01:23:38.380
SUPREME COURT, AS WE KNOW IS
01:23:38.446 --> 01:23:41.383
POISED TO OVERTURN ROE V. WADE
01:23:41.449 --> 01:23:42.884
WHICH WOULD AFFECT MANY OF THESE
01:23:42.951 --> 01:23:45.053
LAWS AND THE LIABILITY THAT
01:23:45.120 --> 01:23:46.221
WOULD BE PUT ONTO PATIENTS
01:23:46.287 --> 01:23:47.756
PROVIDERS THROUGHOUT THE NATION.
01:23:47.822 --> 01:23:48.990
THE QUESTION IS NOT WHETHER
01:23:49.057 --> 01:23:50.458
ABORTIONS WILL HAPPEN. WE KNOW
01:23:50.525 --> 01:23:52.060
THEY WILL CONTINUE TO HAPPEN.
01:23:52.127 --> 01:23:53.495
THE QUESTION IS WHETHER WE WISH
01:23:53.561 --> 01:23:55.563
RISK AND RUIN THE LIVES OF THOSE
01:23:55.630 --> 01:23:57.432
WHO NEED THEM, OR WE PROTECT
01:23:57.499 --> 01:23:58.867
THOSE INDIVIDUALS. WHETHER
01:23:58.933 --> 01:24:00.368
ABORTION WILL BE SAFE OR
01:24:00.435 --> 01:24:02.470
DANGEROUS, WHETHER CHOICE WILL
01:24:02.537 --> 01:24:04.506
BE LEGAL OR FINANCIALLY RUINOUS
01:24:04.572 --> 01:24:06.374
. WITH ABORTION LEFT UP TO THE
01:24:06.441 --> 01:24:07.776
STATES, IT IS UP TO STATES LIKE
01:24:07.842 --> 01:24:09.444
CALIFORNIA TO STAND UP FOR THE
01:24:09.511 --> 01:24:11.246
RIGHT TO CHOOSE TO STAND UP FOR
01:24:11.312 --> 01:24:12.480
OUR PATIENTS AND TO STAND UP FOR
01:24:12.547 --> 01:24:15.617
OUR PROVIDERS. A B 16 66 WILL
01:24:15.683 --> 01:24:17.252
PROACTIVELY PROTECT CALIFORNIANS
01:24:17.318 --> 01:24:19.487
FROM CIVIL LIABILITY FOR THEIR
01:24:19.554 --> 01:24:21.523
ACTIONS TO RECEIVE PROVIDE AID
01:24:21.589 --> 01:24:23.892
IN ABORTION CARE? MAYBE 16 66
01:24:23.958 --> 01:24:26.027
SIMPLY DECLARES ANY CIVIL ACTION
01:24:26.094 --> 01:24:27.262
FOR AIDING IN OR RECEIVING
01:24:27.328 --> 01:24:28.463
ABORTION TO BE CONTRARY TO THE
01:24:28.530 --> 01:24:30.432
PUBLIC POLICY OF CALIFORNIA. AND
01:24:30.498 --> 01:24:31.433
THEREFORE UNENFORCEABLE IN OUR
01:24:31.499 --> 01:24:36.004
COURTS. I WANT TO BE VERY CLEAR
01:24:36.070 --> 01:24:37.572
THAT WE HAVE ENSURED AND WE ARE
01:24:37.639 --> 01:24:39.007
CONTINUING TO WORK ON LANGUAGE
01:24:39.073 --> 01:24:39.908
THAT WILL MAKE SURE THAT
01:24:39.974 --> 01:24:41.443
MALPRACTICE IS STILL SUBJECT TO
01:24:41.509 --> 01:24:42.944
CIVIL LIABILITY HERE IN
01:24:43.011 --> 01:24:44.512
CALIFORNIA ANYTHING IT IS
01:24:44.579 --> 01:24:45.380
CURRENTLY ILLEGAL UNDER
01:24:45.447 --> 01:24:47.182
CALIFORNIA LAW WILL REMAIN SO
01:24:47.248 --> 01:24:50.351
UNDER THIS. LOSS. AS AN ATTORNEY
01:24:50.418 --> 01:24:51.886
MYSELF, AND I KNOW I HAVE MANY
01:24:51.953 --> 01:24:53.455
SITTING BEFORE ME AS WELL. WE
01:24:53.521 --> 01:24:55.523
KNOW THE POWER OF THE FULL FAITH
01:24:55.590 --> 01:24:56.524
AND CREDIT CLAUSE, THE PUBLIC
01:24:56.591 --> 01:24:57.392
COLLEAGUES THE EXEMPTION OF THE
01:24:57.459 --> 01:24:58.860
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE
01:24:58.927 --> 01:25:00.495
STATES THAT IT DOES NOT REQUIRE
01:25:00.562 --> 01:25:01.796
ONE STATE TO APPLY ANOTHER
01:25:01.863 --> 01:25:03.164
STATE'S LAW THAT VIOLATES ITS
01:25:03.231 --> 01:25:04.999
OWN LEGITIMATE PUBLIC POLICY.
01:25:05.066 --> 01:25:06.768
CALIFORNIA HAS NO OBLIGATION TO
01:25:06.835 --> 01:25:08.269
ENFORCE THE CIVIL PENALTIES THAT
01:25:08.336 --> 01:25:09.671
VIOLATE ABORTION RIGHTS
01:25:09.737 --> 01:25:10.605
PROTECTED IN OUR OWN
01:25:10.672 --> 01:25:12.407
CONSTITUTION WHEN A PREGNANT
01:25:12.474 --> 01:25:13.475
PERSON'S CHOICE ABOUT THEIR OWN
01:25:13.541 --> 01:25:16.311
BODY IS QUESTIONED. THE LIVES OF
01:25:16.377 --> 01:25:18.146
ALL PREGNANT PEOPLE ARE AT STAKE
01:25:18.213 --> 01:25:19.347
IN CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN CLEAR ON
01:25:19.414 --> 01:25:20.882
WHERE WE BELIEVE WE STAND ON
01:25:20.949 --> 01:25:22.951
THAT A B 16 66 CREATES THE
01:25:23.017 --> 01:25:24.385
PROTECTIONS TO MAKE CALIFORNIA
01:25:24.452 --> 01:25:26.221
ILLEGAL SANCTUARY FOR
01:25:26.287 --> 01:25:28.389
REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE WITH ME
01:25:28.456 --> 01:25:30.458
TODAY IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL ARE
01:25:30.525 --> 01:25:32.660
SELENA SANDOVAL, O B. G Y N AND
01:25:32.727 --> 01:25:34.295
PROVIDER, A UC SAN DIEGO AND
01:25:34.362 --> 01:25:35.663
LISA MATSUBARA, GENERAL COUNSEL
01:25:35.730 --> 01:25:37.165
AND VICE PRESIDENT OF POLICY AT
01:25:37.232 --> 01:25:38.366
PLANNED PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
01:25:38.433 --> 01:25:40.869
CALIFORNIA. AND I BELIEVE LISA'S
01:25:40.935 --> 01:25:42.070
HERE IN PERSON. BUT SELINA
01:25:42.136 --> 01:25:44.239
SANDOVAL IS ON THE PHONE. ALL
01:25:44.305 --> 01:25:45.406
RIGHT. WHY DON'T WE START WITH
01:25:45.473 --> 01:25:51.412
MISS MATSUBARA? GOOD MORNING,
01:25:51.479 --> 01:25:53.515
CHAIRPERSON NUMBER GANG MEMBERS
01:25:53.581 --> 01:25:54.482
. I'M LISA MATSUBARA FROM
01:25:54.549 --> 01:25:55.450
PLANNED PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
01:25:55.517 --> 01:25:57.352
CALIFORNIA, REPRESENTING THE
01:25:57.418 --> 01:25:58.486
SEVEN AFFILIATES IN THE STATE
01:25:58.553 --> 01:25:59.521
OPERATING OVER 100 HEALTH
01:25:59.587 --> 01:26:01.356
CENTERS. THE CONSTITUTIONAL
01:26:01.422 --> 01:26:03.024
PROTECTIONS UNDER ROE VERSUS
01:26:03.091 --> 01:26:04.359
WADE, OR NO LONGER ENSURING
01:26:04.425 --> 01:26:05.593
ACCESS TO ABORTION ACROSS THE
01:26:05.660 --> 01:26:07.495
NATION AND ARE LIKELY TO BE
01:26:07.562 --> 01:26:09.397
RAISED IN THE COMING WEEKS. ANY
01:26:09.464 --> 01:26:10.832
DAY. NOW THE U. S. SUPREME COURT
01:26:10.899 --> 01:26:12.700
IS POET POISED TO RULE ON A
01:26:12.767 --> 01:26:14.502
DIRECT CHALLENGE TO ROE. IT IS
01:26:14.569 --> 01:26:16.004
ALREADY UPHELD. TEXAS SENATE
01:26:16.070 --> 01:26:17.539
BILL EIGHT, AND IT'S DELIBERATE
01:26:17.605 --> 01:26:18.640
LEGAL SCHEME TO CIRCUMVENT
01:26:18.706 --> 01:26:19.641
JUDICIAL REVIEW OF AN
01:26:19.707 --> 01:26:22.744
UNCONSTITUTIONAL LAW. THE TEXAS
01:26:22.810 --> 01:26:23.912
ABORTION BAN HAS BEEN IN EFFECT
01:26:23.978 --> 01:26:27.115
FOR OVER NINE MONTHS. HAS
01:26:27.181 --> 01:26:28.283
FOLLOWED SUIT, ADOPTING THE SAME
01:26:28.349 --> 01:26:29.484
MECHANISM TO EFFECTIVELY BAN
01:26:29.551 --> 01:26:32.654
MOST ABORTIONS. AT THE SAME TIME
01:26:32.720 --> 01:26:33.721
, ANTI ABORTION LAWMAKERS HAVE
01:26:33.788 --> 01:26:34.656
INTRODUCED OVER 500 RESTRICTIONS
01:26:34.722 --> 01:26:38.993
IN 42 STATES THIS YEAR. IN OTHER
01:26:39.060 --> 01:26:40.495
STATES, LIKE MISSOURI, LAWMAKERS
01:26:40.562 --> 01:26:42.497
ARE TAKING EVEN MORE EVEN MORE
01:26:42.564 --> 01:26:44.165
AGGRESSIVE APPROACH, ATTEMPTING
01:26:44.232 --> 01:26:45.066
TO BURN RESIDENTS FROM LEAVING
01:26:45.133 --> 01:26:46.734
THE STATE TO ABORT. OBTAIN AN
01:26:46.801 --> 01:26:48.903
ABORTION IS ESTIMATED THAT IN
01:26:48.970 --> 01:26:50.338
THE NEXT FEW WEEKS OVER 36
01:26:50.405 --> 01:26:51.506
MILLION PEOPLE FOCUS AND OVER
01:26:51.573 --> 01:26:53.675
HALF OF THE STATES WILL LOSE
01:26:53.741 --> 01:26:55.510
ACCESS TO ABORTION IN THEIR HOME
01:26:55.577 --> 01:26:58.212
STATE. WE KNOW THE KINDS OF
01:26:58.279 --> 01:27:00.081
HARMS THESE LAWS CAUSE AND ARE
01:27:00.148 --> 01:27:01.382
PROUD OF THE WORK THAT
01:27:01.449 --> 01:27:03.251
CALIFORNIA IS DOING TO ENSURE
01:27:03.318 --> 01:27:03.885
ALL PEOPLE CAN ACCESS ABORTION
01:27:03.952 --> 01:27:06.254
HERE, BUT WE MUST DO MORE AT
01:27:06.321 --> 01:27:07.255
PLANNED PARENTHOOD AFFILIATE
01:27:07.322 --> 01:27:08.756
HEALTH CENTERS. CLINICIANS
01:27:08.823 --> 01:27:09.824
PROVIDE HIGH QUALITY CARE TO
01:27:09.891 --> 01:27:11.359
EVERY PERSON WHO NEEDS IT. NO
01:27:11.426 --> 01:27:14.862
MATTER WHAT NO ONE WHO PROVIDES
01:27:14.929 --> 01:27:16.698
A RECEIVED ABORTION CARE IN
01:27:16.764 --> 01:27:17.665
CALIFORNIA SHOULD BE PENALIZED
01:27:17.732 --> 01:27:18.833
FOR DOING SO CONSISTENT WITH THE
01:27:18.900 --> 01:27:21.436
LAWS OF THE STATE. A B 16 66
01:27:21.502 --> 01:27:24.272
DECLARES THAT THE LAWS AND OTHER
01:27:24.339 --> 01:27:24.772
STATES THAT PENALIZE THE
01:27:24.839 --> 01:27:25.773
PROVISION OF ABORTION CARE ARE
01:27:25.840 --> 01:27:27.442
CONTRARY TO THE PUBLIC POLICY OF
01:27:27.508 --> 01:27:29.377
CALIFORNIA AND PROTECTS ABORTION
01:27:29.444 --> 01:27:31.079
PROVIDERS AND OTHERS WHO COULD
01:27:31.145 --> 01:27:32.380
BE SUBJECT TO CIVIL SUIT. UNDER
01:27:32.447 --> 01:27:34.515
ANOTHER STATE'S LAW PENALIZING
01:27:34.582 --> 01:27:35.683
ABORTION BY PROHIBITING THE
01:27:35.750 --> 01:27:36.818
SEIZURE OF THEIR FINANCIAL
01:27:36.884 --> 01:27:40.521
ASSETS HERE IN CALIFORNIA. WE
01:27:40.588 --> 01:27:42.290
THANK THIS COMMITTEE FOR THEIR
01:27:42.357 --> 01:27:43.324
THOROUGH ANALYSIS AND
01:27:43.391 --> 01:27:45.159
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BARRICADE HAM
01:27:45.226 --> 01:27:46.260
FOR CARRYING THIS IMPORTANT
01:27:46.327 --> 01:27:47.762
BILL, SO CALIFORNIA PROVIDERS
01:27:47.829 --> 01:27:48.963
CAN CONTINUE TO PROVIDE HIGH
01:27:49.030 --> 01:27:50.331
QUALITY ABORTION CARE TO THOSE
01:27:50.398 --> 01:27:52.333
WHO SEEK IT IN OUR STATE. THANK
01:27:52.400 --> 01:27:54.502
YOU. THANK YOU. UM DOCTOR
01:27:54.569 --> 01:27:55.603
SANDOVAL. IF YOU'RE AVAILABLE BY
01:27:55.670 --> 01:27:59.374
PHONE IF YOU IDENTIFY YOURSELF
01:27:59.440 --> 01:28:00.508
YES, THIS IS UNDERSTANDABLE.
01:28:00.575 --> 01:28:05.513
ALREADY GO AHEAD. PERFECT. THANK
01:28:05.580 --> 01:28:07.248
YOU, MR CHAIR AND THE MEMBERS OF
01:28:07.315 --> 01:28:08.616
THIS COMMITTEE FOR A LOT OF
01:28:08.683 --> 01:28:10.518
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT TESTIMONY
01:28:10.585 --> 01:28:11.719
TODAY AGAIN. MY NAME IS DR ELENA
01:28:11.786 --> 01:28:12.854
SANDOVAL. I'M A BOARD CERTIFIED
01:28:12.920 --> 01:28:15.089
OB. JOANNE MY FAMILY PLANNING
01:28:15.156 --> 01:28:16.157
SPECIALISTS AND MEMBER OF THE
01:28:16.224 --> 01:28:17.258
CALIFORNIA FUTURE OF ABORTION
01:28:17.325 --> 01:28:18.259
COUNCIL. I'M TESTIFYING TODAY
01:28:18.326 --> 01:28:19.761
REPRESENTING DISTRICT NINE IN
01:28:19.827 --> 01:28:20.528
THE AMERICAN CONGRESS THAT
01:28:20.595 --> 01:28:22.630
SECTOR COLLEGE ISTS WHO ARE CO
01:28:22.697 --> 01:28:25.733
SPONSORING AT SOME OF THE 16 66.
01:28:25.800 --> 01:28:28.136
ASSEMBLY BILL 16 66 PROVIDES
01:28:28.202 --> 01:28:29.637
PROTECTION TO ABORTION PATIENTS
01:28:29.704 --> 01:28:30.571
AND CLINICIANS BY PROHIBITING
01:28:30.638 --> 01:28:31.873
CIVIL ACTIONS FROM ANY OTHER
01:28:31.939 --> 01:28:33.708
STATE LAW FROM BEING APPLIED TO
01:28:33.775 --> 01:28:35.243
THOSE IN CALIFORNIA. AS
01:28:35.309 --> 01:28:36.744
EFFICIENT POSITION WHO PROVIDES
01:28:36.811 --> 01:28:38.513
FULL SPECTRUM ABORTION CARE. I
01:28:38.579 --> 01:28:39.747
CAN SAY WITH CERTAINTY THAT
01:28:39.814 --> 01:28:41.416
THESE PROTECTIONS ARE ABOUT MOST
01:28:41.482 --> 01:28:42.917
IMPORTANT AS YOU ALL KNOW, THE
01:28:42.984 --> 01:28:44.318
CURRENT POLITICAL CLIMATE IS
01:28:44.385 --> 01:28:45.553
ALLOWING FOR UNPRECEDENTED
01:28:45.620 --> 01:28:47.255
AMOUNTS OF LEGISLATION ATTACKING
01:28:47.321 --> 01:28:48.222
REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS IN
01:28:48.289 --> 01:28:50.258
CALIFORNIA. MY COLLEAGUES AND I
01:28:50.324 --> 01:28:51.726
ARE SEEING PATIENTS TRAVELING
01:28:51.793 --> 01:28:52.727
FROM TEXAS AND OKLAHOMA
01:28:52.794 --> 01:28:54.929
FREQUENTLY DID TAKE CARE. IN MY
01:28:54.996 --> 01:28:56.464
CAREER. I PROVIDED ABORTION CARE
01:28:56.531 --> 01:28:57.598
THROUGHOUT THE UNITED STATES,
01:28:57.665 --> 01:28:59.067
INCLUDING CALIFORNIA, KANSAS,
01:28:59.133 --> 01:29:00.802
MINNESOTA AND IOWA. I'VE SEEN
01:29:00.868 --> 01:29:02.236
FIRSTHAND THE EFFECTS OF
01:29:02.303 --> 01:29:03.538
LIMITING ACCESS TO ABORTION
01:29:03.604 --> 01:29:04.572
PATIENTS ARE FORCED TO DELAY
01:29:04.639 --> 01:29:05.907
THEIR CARE TRAVEL HUNDREDS, IF
01:29:05.973 --> 01:29:07.675
NOT THOUSANDS OF MILES AND FACE
01:29:07.742 --> 01:29:08.943
FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES. JUST
01:29:09.010 --> 01:29:10.378
UNDERGO A SIMPLE AND SAFE
01:29:10.445 --> 01:29:12.013
MEDICAL PROCEDURE, AND
01:29:12.080 --> 01:29:13.414
UNFORTUNATELY, THESE PATIENTS
01:29:13.481 --> 01:29:14.549
ARE THE LUCKY ONES, THE ONES
01:29:14.615 --> 01:29:16.384
WITH THE PRIVILEGE AND THE MEANS
01:29:16.451 --> 01:29:17.552
TO TRAVEL. PERHAPS EVEN MORE
01:29:17.618 --> 01:29:18.519
CONCERNING IS THE PREVIOUSLY
01:29:18.586 --> 01:29:19.520
PROPOSED LEGISLATION OUT OF
01:29:19.587 --> 01:29:21.089
MISSOURI THAT WOULD HAVE
01:29:21.155 --> 01:29:22.190
SUPPORTED CIVIL SUITS AGAINST
01:29:22.256 --> 01:29:23.224
ANYONE PERFORMING AN ABORTION ON
01:29:23.291 --> 01:29:25.026
HIM IS VERY REDMAN. I TAKE MY
01:29:25.093 --> 01:29:26.360
PATIENTS AT THESE VALUES. THEY
01:29:26.427 --> 01:29:28.396
COME TO ME WITH THE NEED FOR A
01:29:28.463 --> 01:29:29.430
SERVICE THAT I CAN PROVIDE, AND
01:29:29.497 --> 01:29:30.531
I WILL NEVER INTERROGATED
01:29:30.598 --> 01:29:31.466
PATIENTS ABOUT THEIR STATE OF
01:29:31.532 --> 01:29:33.634
ORIGIN. I KNOW MY COLLEAGUES
01:29:33.701 --> 01:29:34.569
TREAT THEIR PATIENTS WITH THE
01:29:34.635 --> 01:29:35.770
SAME RESPECT AND WE KNOW THAT
01:29:35.837 --> 01:29:37.538
LEGISLATION SUCH AS THIS WILL
01:29:37.605 --> 01:29:39.140
CONTINUE TO BE PRESENTED AND
01:29:39.207 --> 01:29:39.874
WILL BE SUCCESSFUL. THIS IS NO
01:29:39.941 --> 01:29:42.143
LONGER THEORETICAL AND
01:29:42.210 --> 01:29:42.744
LEGISLATION LIKE THIS PUTS OUR
01:29:42.810 --> 01:29:44.011
CALIFORNIA PROVIDERS AT RISK.
01:29:44.078 --> 01:29:45.513
ABORTIONIS ESSENTIAL HEALTHCARE
01:29:45.580 --> 01:29:46.981
CALIFORNIA IS BECOMING A SAFE
01:29:47.048 --> 01:29:48.316
HAVEN AND DESTINATION STATE FOR
01:29:48.382 --> 01:29:49.684
PROTECTING REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS.
01:29:49.751 --> 01:29:51.486
I'M HONORED TO SERVE MY PATIENTS
01:29:51.552 --> 01:29:52.820
, BUT I CAN ONLY CONTINUE TO DO
01:29:52.887 --> 01:29:54.555
THIS SAFELY WITH THE APPROPRIATE
01:29:54.622 --> 01:29:55.823
PROTECTION. PLEASE ALLOW MY
01:29:55.890 --> 01:29:57.258
COLLEAGUES AND I THE PEACE OF
01:29:57.325 --> 01:29:59.060
MIND TO FOCUS ON THE PATIENTS
01:29:59.127 --> 01:30:00.628
SITTING IN FRONT OF US EVERY DAY
01:30:00.695 --> 01:30:01.562
HELP US PROTECT ABORTION ACCESS
01:30:01.629 --> 01:30:03.197
IN CALIFORNIA BY VOTING ION
01:30:03.264 --> 01:30:04.398
ASSEMBLY BILL 16 66 THANK YOU.
01:30:04.465 --> 01:30:06.834
THANK YOU ALL RIGHT, OTHERS IN
01:30:06.901 --> 01:30:08.936
SUPPORT OF A B 16 66 THAT ARE
01:30:09.003 --> 01:30:10.438
HERE IN THE HEARING ROOM. IF YOU
01:30:10.505 --> 01:30:11.606
HAD APPROACHED THE MICROPHONE,
01:30:11.672 --> 01:30:12.573
GIVE US YOUR NAME YOUR
01:30:12.640 --> 01:30:15.009
AFFILIATION IN YOUR POSITION.
01:30:15.076 --> 01:30:17.411
CINDY HILLARY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:30:17.478 --> 01:30:18.012
CALIFORNIA MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
01:30:18.079 --> 01:30:21.516
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. HELLO
01:30:21.582 --> 01:30:23.084
GENESIS GONZALEZ ON BEHALF OF
01:30:23.151 --> 01:30:24.152
LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR. ELENI
01:30:24.218 --> 01:30:28.723
KALLAKIS IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
01:30:28.790 --> 01:30:30.525
AARON EVANS ON BEHALF OF NARAL
01:30:30.591 --> 01:30:33.094
PRO CHOICE CALIFORNIA AND THE
01:30:33.161 --> 01:30:34.061
CALIFORNIA NURSE MIDWIVES
01:30:34.128 --> 01:30:35.062
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT. THANK
01:30:35.129 --> 01:30:39.934
THANK YOU. ALRIGHT SAYING NO ONE
01:30:40.001 --> 01:30:42.537
ELSE HERE IN ROOM 2100. LET'S
01:30:42.603 --> 01:30:43.371
TURN TO THE PHONE LINES
01:30:43.437 --> 01:30:44.639
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP
01:30:44.705 --> 01:30:49.877
THOSE IN SUPPORT OF A B 16 66
01:30:49.944 --> 01:30:52.413
YES. SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 16
01:30:52.480 --> 01:30:54.348
66, PLEASE PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO
01:30:54.415 --> 01:30:57.752
AND YOUR PUNK AND WE WILL START
01:30:57.819 --> 01:30:59.620
WITH BLIND WITHIN 32, PLEASE GO
01:30:59.687 --> 01:31:04.859
AHEAD. HI MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS
01:31:04.926 --> 01:31:06.994
KATHY VAN, OFTEN ON BEHALF OF
01:31:07.061 --> 01:31:08.396
THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF
01:31:08.462 --> 01:31:10.464
UNIVERSITY WOMEN, CALIFORNIA AND
01:31:10.531 --> 01:31:11.666
DRUNK SUPPORT WERE ALSO SPONSOR
01:31:11.732 --> 01:31:15.603
ON THE BILL. THANK YOU. THANK
01:31:15.670 --> 01:31:17.538
YOU. NEXT LINE. 1 15, PLEASE GO
01:31:17.605 --> 01:31:21.242
AHEAD. FRANK SPENCER ON BEHALF
01:31:21.309 --> 01:31:22.510
OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF O B.
01:31:22.577 --> 01:31:24.745
G Y N SPONSORS OF THE BILL AND
01:31:24.812 --> 01:31:27.148
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:31:27.215 --> 01:31:30.251
LINE 1 33, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:31:30.318 --> 01:31:31.519
CURTIS PLAYING WITH THE
01:31:31.586 --> 01:31:32.653
CALIFORNIA NURSES ASSOCIATION IN
01:31:32.720 --> 01:31:33.788
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:31:33.855 --> 01:31:37.458
YOU. ONLINE. 1 34, PLEASE GO
01:31:37.525 --> 01:31:42.330
AHEAD. TOMMY MARTIN ON BEHALF OF
01:31:42.396 --> 01:31:43.297
EQUALITY, CALIFORNIA COSPONSOR
01:31:43.364 --> 01:31:44.599
OF THE BILL IN STRONG SUPPORT.
01:31:44.665 --> 01:31:47.802
THANK YOU. I WON 35 PLEASE GO
01:31:47.869 --> 01:31:52.206
AHEAD. REBECCA GONZALES WITH THE
01:31:52.273 --> 01:31:54.175
NATIONALIST SOC ATION AS SOCIAL
01:31:54.242 --> 01:31:55.243
WORKERS CALIFORNIA CHAPTER IN
01:31:55.309 --> 01:31:57.678
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. AND 1 27,
01:31:57.745 --> 01:32:03.651
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
01:32:03.718 --> 01:32:05.753
SYLVIA KFT OR WITH ESSENTIAL
01:32:05.820 --> 01:32:06.888
ACCESS HEALTH IN STRONG SUPPORT
01:32:06.954 --> 01:32:09.290
OF THIS STUFF. LINE. 30, PLEASE
01:32:09.357 --> 01:32:13.995
GO AHEAD. WITH OAKLAND PRIVACY
01:32:14.061 --> 01:32:19.166
AND SUPPORTED 16 66. THANK YOU.
01:32:19.233 --> 01:32:24.038
LINES. 51, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:32:24.105 --> 01:32:26.140
MORNING. SHARON MEMBERS. AMY ALI
01:32:26.207 --> 01:32:27.642
, LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR WITH THE
01:32:27.708 --> 01:32:29.176
OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL,
01:32:29.243 --> 01:32:31.045
ROB BONTA, WHO IS PROUD TO
01:32:31.112 --> 01:32:35.516
SUPPORT 80. 16 66. THANK YOU.
01:32:35.583 --> 01:32:37.351
THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL THAT
01:32:37.418 --> 01:32:38.819
I HAVEN'T YOU ALL RIGHT, LET'S
01:32:38.886 --> 01:32:40.955
TURN TO OPPOSITION. WE HAVE TWO
01:32:41.022 --> 01:32:43.024
WITNESSES LISTED IN PRIMARY
01:32:43.090 --> 01:32:44.825
OPPOSITION, MISS ARNELLE AND MR
01:32:44.892 --> 01:32:50.231
MCREYNOLDS. YES OR NO. THANK YOU
01:32:50.298 --> 01:32:51.999
. MY NAME IS SUSAN ARNEL. I AM
01:32:52.066 --> 01:32:53.267
AN ATTORNEY AND THE VICE
01:32:53.334 --> 01:32:54.936
PRESIDENT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS AT
01:32:55.002 --> 01:32:55.603
THE RIGHT TO LIFE LEAGUE,
01:32:55.670 --> 01:32:56.871
AMERICA'S FIRST PRO LIFE
01:32:56.938 --> 01:33:00.007
ORGANIZATION. A B 16 66 IS THE
01:33:00.074 --> 01:33:00.841
EQUIVALENT OF A LEGISLATIVE
01:33:00.908 --> 01:33:04.612
TEMPER TANTRUM. IT BLATANTLY
01:33:04.679 --> 01:33:06.747
VIOLATES THE FULL FAITH AND
01:33:06.814 --> 01:33:07.882
CREDIT CLAUSE OF THE UNITED
01:33:07.949 --> 01:33:08.449
STATES CONSTITUTION. CHERRY
01:33:08.516 --> 01:33:11.252
PICKING WHICH OUT OF STATE
01:33:11.319 --> 01:33:13.020
JUDGMENTS CALIFORNIA WILL
01:33:13.087 --> 01:33:14.422
RECOGNIZE THIS IS VIRTUE,
01:33:14.488 --> 01:33:15.256
SIGNALING DRESSED UP IN AN
01:33:15.323 --> 01:33:17.925
UNCONSTITUTIONAL BILL. IN THE
01:33:17.992 --> 01:33:19.994
CASE. BAKER BY THOMAS VERSUS
01:33:20.061 --> 01:33:22.863
GENERAL MOTORS CORP. THE SUPREME
01:33:22.930 --> 01:33:24.999
COURT CLEARLY STATES THAT THERE
01:33:25.066 --> 01:33:28.002
IS ABSOLUTELY NO PUBLIC POLICY
01:33:28.069 --> 01:33:29.704
EXCEPTION WHEN IT COMES TO
01:33:29.770 --> 01:33:30.705
HONORING THE FINAL JUDGMENTS OF
01:33:30.771 --> 01:33:35.076
ANOTHER STATE YET. A B 16 66 AT
01:33:35.142 --> 01:33:38.112
SECTION TWO B. SAYS
01:33:38.179 --> 01:33:40.514
UNEQUIVOCALLY THAT CALIFORNIA
01:33:40.581 --> 01:33:42.616
QUOTE SHALL NOT ENFORCE OR
01:33:42.683 --> 01:33:43.818
SATISFY A CIVIL JUDGMENT
01:33:43.884 --> 01:33:46.921
RECEIVED FROM ANOTHER STATE. THE
01:33:46.988 --> 01:33:49.056
COURT IN BAKER SAID QUOTE A
01:33:49.123 --> 01:33:51.092
COURT MAY BE GUIDED BY THE FORUM
01:33:51.158 --> 01:33:52.827
STATES PUBLIC POLICY IN
01:33:52.893 --> 01:33:55.029
DETERMINING THE LAW APPLICABLE
01:33:55.096 --> 01:33:56.597
TO A CONTROVERSY, BUT OUR
01:33:56.664 --> 01:34:00.034
DECISIONS SUPPORT NO ROVING
01:34:00.101 --> 01:34:02.036
PUBLIC POLICY EXCEPTION TO THE
01:34:02.103 --> 01:34:03.170
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT DO
01:34:03.237 --> 01:34:08.109
JUDGMENTS. A B 16 66 CLEARLY
01:34:08.175 --> 01:34:08.642
VIOLATES COURT ESTABLISHED
01:34:08.709 --> 01:34:10.144
PRECEDENT AND WILL FALL WHEN
01:34:10.211 --> 01:34:13.514
CHALLENGED. LET'S SAY CALIFORNIA
01:34:13.581 --> 01:34:15.883
ENACTS A LAW PROTECTING LGBT Q
01:34:15.950 --> 01:34:18.252
PERSONS AND SOMEONE VIOLATES
01:34:18.319 --> 01:34:19.587
THOSE LAWS IS SUED AND GETS A
01:34:19.653 --> 01:34:21.389
$14 MILLION FINAL JUDGMENT ON
01:34:21.455 --> 01:34:24.725
THEM. BUT THE ONLY PLACE THAT
01:34:24.792 --> 01:34:26.861
THE PERSON OWNS PROPERTY IS
01:34:26.927 --> 01:34:29.363
TEXAS. LET'S SAY TEXAS HAS JUST
01:34:29.430 --> 01:34:31.399
PASSED A BILL EXACTLY LIKE A B
01:34:31.465 --> 01:34:34.368
16 66, WHICH REFUSES TO ENFORCE
01:34:34.435 --> 01:34:35.603
A JUDGMENT BASED ON LAWS
01:34:35.669 --> 01:34:37.738
PROTECTING LGBT Q PERSONS. DO
01:34:37.805 --> 01:34:40.608
YOU SEE THE PROBLEM? FOR VERY
01:34:40.674 --> 01:34:43.110
GOOD REASONS. STATES CANNOT PICK
01:34:43.177 --> 01:34:45.312
AND CHOOSE WHICH FINAL JUDGMENTS
01:34:45.379 --> 01:34:46.847
THEY WILL OR WILL NOT ENFORCE.
01:34:46.914 --> 01:34:50.951
NOW DO ABORTION. THE GOAL AND
01:34:51.018 --> 01:34:52.486
HUBRIS OF THIS BILL ARE AN
01:34:52.553 --> 01:34:54.889
EMBARRASSING SHAMED AT THE STATE
01:34:54.955 --> 01:34:56.023
OF CALIFORNIA. WE MUST RESPECT
01:34:56.090 --> 01:34:57.691
FINAL VALID JUDGMENTS OF OTHER
01:34:57.758 --> 01:34:59.460
STATES, WHETHER WE LIKE THEM OR
01:34:59.527 --> 01:35:02.263
NOT. THIS BILL DISRESPECTS OTHER
01:35:02.329 --> 01:35:03.864
STATE LAWS NOT OUT OF ANY
01:35:03.931 --> 01:35:06.033
CONCERN FOR THE LAW, BUT RATHER
01:35:06.100 --> 01:35:08.102
FOR A VULGAR POLITICAL PURPOSE
01:35:08.169 --> 01:35:09.904
TO THANK YOU. WRAP UP MODEL.
01:35:09.970 --> 01:35:12.073
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT.
01:35:12.139 --> 01:35:20.047
THANK YOU. MR MCREYNOLDS. THEIR
01:35:20.114 --> 01:35:23.617
10 YEAR, RIGHT? YOU'RE GOOD. ALL
01:35:23.684 --> 01:35:26.387
RIGHT. GOOD MORNING. UH PERHAPS
01:35:26.454 --> 01:35:28.756
AFTERNOON CHAIR. MEMBERS OF THE
01:35:28.823 --> 01:35:30.257
COMMITTEE. MATTHEW MCREYNOLDS
01:35:30.324 --> 01:35:31.725
HERE, SENIOR STAFF ATTORNEY WITH
01:35:31.792 --> 01:35:32.827
THE PACIFIC JUSTICE INSTITUTE
01:35:32.893 --> 01:35:35.663
CENTER FOR PUBLIC POLICY. I'D
01:35:35.729 --> 01:35:37.998
LIKE TO ECHO WHAT MY COLLEAGUE
01:35:38.065 --> 01:35:40.835
IS. ARNOLD WAS EXPRESSING ABOUT
01:35:40.901 --> 01:35:42.403
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE.
01:35:42.470 --> 01:35:43.537
THERE CERTAINLY ARE SOME SERIOUS
01:35:43.604 --> 01:35:47.875
PROBLEMS THERE. UM I SYMPATHIZE
01:35:47.942 --> 01:35:51.078
WITH THE TASK OF THE COMMITTEE
01:35:51.145 --> 01:35:52.913
STAFF AND TRYING TO UNPACK AND
01:35:52.980 --> 01:35:56.250
UNRAVEL THAT IT IS A LONG AND
01:35:56.317 --> 01:35:58.252
COMPLICATED CASE HISTORY AT LAST
01:35:58.319 --> 01:36:01.822
CHECK. THERE WERE JUST SHY OF
01:36:01.889 --> 01:36:04.959
40,000 PRECEDENTS. UM THAT TURN
01:36:05.025 --> 01:36:06.327
UP IN LEXUS WHEN YOU LOOK FOR
01:36:06.393 --> 01:36:08.028
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT, SO THIS
01:36:08.095 --> 01:36:10.764
IS AN EXTRAORDINARY, COMPLICATED
01:36:10.831 --> 01:36:13.200
AREA OF THE LAW THAT THE AUTHOR
01:36:13.267 --> 01:36:16.504
HAS GLOSSED OVER. QUITE A BIT
01:36:16.570 --> 01:36:19.874
AND MASKED. UH QUITE A NUMBER OF
01:36:19.940 --> 01:36:22.877
THE UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES THAT
01:36:22.943 --> 01:36:24.912
THAT WOULD RESULT JUST JUST A
01:36:24.979 --> 01:36:26.113
FEW ADDITIONAL EXAMPLES THAT
01:36:26.180 --> 01:36:29.049
COME TO MIND. FULL FAITH AND
01:36:29.116 --> 01:36:31.018
CREDIT HAS BEEN AT THE CENTER OF
01:36:31.085 --> 01:36:32.753
DISPUTES BETWEEN CALIFORNIA AND
01:36:32.820 --> 01:36:34.288
OTHER STATES INVOLVING THINGS
01:36:34.355 --> 01:36:37.258
LIKE TAX COLLECTION IN SPECIFIC
01:36:37.324 --> 01:36:39.160
TO THE PUBLIC POLICY ARGUMENTS
01:36:39.226 --> 01:36:40.995
IN THE DEBATE OVER WHETHER OR
01:36:41.061 --> 01:36:45.132
NOT PUBLIC POLICY ALLOWS THOSE
01:36:45.199 --> 01:36:46.233
OTHER STATES TO IGNORE JUDGMENTS
01:36:46.300 --> 01:36:51.639
HERE. WITH THE EXODUS OF
01:36:51.705 --> 01:36:52.873
CALIFORNIANS AND CALIFORNIA
01:36:52.940 --> 01:36:55.876
BUSINESSES TO OTHER STATES. YOU
01:36:55.943 --> 01:36:58.212
COULD VERY WELL WHEN THE BATTLE
01:36:58.279 --> 01:37:01.048
AND LOSE THE WAR ON THIS IF YOU
01:37:01.115 --> 01:37:05.119
DID SUCCEED. IN HAVING A STATUTE
01:37:05.186 --> 01:37:07.988
LIKE THIS UPHELD AND EXPANDING
01:37:08.055 --> 01:37:10.257
THE REACH OF MORE RATHER
01:37:10.324 --> 01:37:11.492
DIMINISHING THE EFFECTS OF FULL
01:37:11.559 --> 01:37:14.628
FAITH AND CREDIT AS IT WOULD
01:37:14.695 --> 01:37:17.631
SEEK TO DO THAT COULD ACTUALLY
01:37:17.698 --> 01:37:19.733
END UP VERY BADLY FOR
01:37:19.800 --> 01:37:21.268
CALIFORNIA'S TAX COLLECTION
01:37:21.335 --> 01:37:24.805
AUTHORITIES. UM AND THAT TENS OF
01:37:24.872 --> 01:37:25.973
THOUSANDS OF OTHER LITIGANTS WHO
01:37:26.040 --> 01:37:26.840
REPRESENTED BY BY THE
01:37:26.907 --> 01:37:30.144
PRESIDENT'S JUST ONE OTHER THING
01:37:30.211 --> 01:37:34.014
I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT. THANK YOU
01:37:34.081 --> 01:37:34.782
, MR MCREYNOLDS. IF YOU'D WRAP
01:37:34.848 --> 01:37:37.518
UP AGREE WITH THE AUTHOR, THERE
01:37:37.585 --> 01:37:40.020
ARE SOME SERIOUS DRAFTING
01:37:40.087 --> 01:37:41.522
CONCERNS BECAUSE THE CURRENT
01:37:41.589 --> 01:37:44.258
VERSION DOES OPEN THE DOOR FOR
01:37:44.325 --> 01:37:48.128
MALPRACTICE TYPES OF SUITS. AND
01:37:48.195 --> 01:37:50.231
TO BE SHIELDED, SO I WOULD URGE
01:37:50.297 --> 01:37:52.499
THE COMMITTEE TO TAKE A CLOSER
01:37:52.566 --> 01:37:53.801
LOOK AT THIS POINT. YOU HAVE TO
01:37:53.867 --> 01:37:56.503
BILL THANK YOU, MR THANK YOU, MR
01:37:56.570 --> 01:37:58.639
MCREYNOLDS, OTHERS HERE IN THE
01:37:58.706 --> 01:37:59.640
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM IN
01:37:59.707 --> 01:38:03.777
OPPOSITION. YOUR NAME, YOUR
01:38:03.844 --> 01:38:05.279
AFFILIATION AND YOUR POSITION.
01:38:05.346 --> 01:38:07.014
MY NAME IS LEE ANDREW LEFT HIM
01:38:07.081 --> 01:38:08.249
WITH CALIFORNIA FAMILY COUNCIL.
01:38:08.315 --> 01:38:09.850
AND I OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK
01:38:09.917 --> 01:38:12.786
YOU. GREG BURKE WITH THE
01:38:12.853 --> 01:38:13.854
CALIFORNIA FAMILY COUNCIL AND
01:38:13.921 --> 01:38:17.524
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:38:17.591 --> 01:38:19.126
MORNING, TERRY JACOBEAN ON
01:38:19.193 --> 01:38:20.527
BEHALF OF ROCK HARBOR CHURCH,
01:38:20.594 --> 01:38:21.762
BAKER FLOW PREDICTING AND BARNES
01:38:21.829 --> 01:38:23.530
AND BORN CALVARY CHAPEL SEARCH
01:38:23.597 --> 01:38:24.932
VISALIA PROTECTING THE UNBORN
01:38:24.999 --> 01:38:26.066
HILLARY COLLISION FOR FREEDOM IN
01:38:26.133 --> 01:38:28.736
THE LIFE OF THE UNBORN. I DIDN'T
01:38:28.802 --> 01:38:30.137
ASK TERRY COUNTY STOP THE MURDER
01:38:30.204 --> 01:38:31.739
OF THE SILENT BLESSINGS OF
01:38:31.805 --> 01:38:32.339
LIBERTY, PORTERVILLE, PROTECT
01:38:32.406 --> 01:38:34.608
THIS THE YOUNG AND SPEAK UP FOR
01:38:34.675 --> 01:38:35.709
THE UNBORN IN VIOLENT
01:38:35.776 --> 01:38:36.677
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU, SIR.
01:38:36.744 --> 01:38:40.314
THANK YOU. RUSSIA WILLIAMS ON
01:38:40.381 --> 01:38:42.116
BEHALF OF JAMES P. BRADLEY AND
01:38:42.182 --> 01:38:43.884
LADIES FOR LIBERTY IN OPPOSITION
01:38:43.951 --> 01:38:45.753
. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT, LET'S
01:38:45.819 --> 01:38:46.954
TURN TO THE PHONE. OTHERS WHO
01:38:47.021 --> 01:38:51.625
ARE IN OPPOSITION. FOR THOSE IN
01:38:51.692 --> 01:38:54.061
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS ZERO OR
01:38:54.128 --> 01:38:55.929
MODERATOR ONE MORE HERE IN THE
01:38:55.996 --> 01:38:58.365
COMMITTEE HEARING ROOM. SORRY
01:38:58.432 --> 01:38:59.933
KIDS IN BATHROOM. GABRIELLE
01:39:00.000 --> 01:39:00.968
INGRAHAM I OPPOSE. THANK YOU.
01:39:01.035 --> 01:39:04.705
THANK YOU. ALRIGHT UM MODERATE.
01:39:04.772 --> 01:39:06.507
NOW WE CAN TURN TO THE PHONE
01:39:06.573 --> 01:39:10.244
LINE. THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN,
01:39:10.311 --> 01:39:14.381
PLEASE PRESS 10 TO SPEAK. AND WE
01:39:14.448 --> 01:39:16.717
WILL START WITH LINE 1 38.
01:39:16.784 --> 01:39:21.355
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO COMMITTEE
01:39:21.422 --> 01:39:23.524
. MY NAME IS ROBERT BYRD. I AM A
01:39:23.590 --> 01:39:25.059
CONSTITUENT AND, UH,
01:39:25.125 --> 01:39:26.960
SENATE-DISTRICT 11 AND I URGE
01:39:27.027 --> 01:39:28.962
YOU TO VOTE NO ON THIS BILL
01:39:29.029 --> 01:39:33.367
ALREADY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:39:33.434 --> 01:39:34.535
AND NEXT, WE HAVE LINE 93,
01:39:34.601 --> 01:39:40.641
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO I MISSED
01:39:40.708 --> 01:39:42.743
THE SUPPORT. IT DIDN'T GO
01:39:42.810 --> 01:39:44.411
THROUGH. SO I'M MY NAME IS JULIA
01:39:44.478 --> 01:39:46.680
HEMLO. I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
01:39:46.747 --> 01:39:47.748
WOMEN FOR AMERICAN VALUES AND
01:39:47.815 --> 01:39:51.118
ETHICS. AND WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
01:39:51.185 --> 01:39:54.488
BUILT A B 16 66 PROTECT WOMEN'S
01:39:54.555 --> 01:39:55.556
RIGHTS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:39:55.622 --> 01:40:00.527
NEXT. THANK GOODNESS WE HAVE
01:40:00.594 --> 01:40:07.735
LINE 1 41, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:40:07.801 --> 01:40:18.178
PLANE. 1 41 YEAR LINE IS OPEN.
01:40:18.245 --> 01:40:20.347
OKAY NEXT WE HAVE LION 1 36,
01:40:20.414 --> 01:40:24.785
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO I'M GERRI
01:40:24.852 --> 01:40:25.886
SHELAGH BUTLER FROM OAKLAND,
01:40:25.953 --> 01:40:27.254
CALIFORNIA AND I OPPOSED THIS.
01:40:27.321 --> 01:40:34.828
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT
01:40:34.895 --> 01:40:36.764
WE HAVE LINE 1 41, PLEASE GO
01:40:36.830 --> 01:40:41.568
AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS EMMA CRAIG
01:40:41.635 --> 01:40:43.303
WITH PRO LIFE MEMBERS. CISCO,
01:40:43.370 --> 01:40:44.972
PLEASE VOTE NO ON A B 1666.
01:40:45.038 --> 01:40:49.543
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
01:40:49.610 --> 01:40:51.478
IS ALL THAT I HAVE BEEN QUÊ.
01:40:51.545 --> 01:40:52.579
ALRIGHT, LET'S BRING IT BACK TO
01:40:52.646 --> 01:40:53.781
THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY
01:40:53.847 --> 01:40:56.617
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. SEEING WE'RE
01:40:56.683 --> 01:41:00.354
SO, UM NO QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
01:41:00.421 --> 01:41:04.258
UM SO WE ARE A SUBCOMMITTEE AT
01:41:04.324 --> 01:41:05.659
THIS POINT, ALTHOUGH IF TWO MORE
01:41:05.726 --> 01:41:07.961
MEMBERS APPEAR WE WILL BE A
01:41:08.028 --> 01:41:10.898
COMMITTEE WILL REACH QUORUM, UM
01:41:10.964 --> 01:41:13.066
AND FOR HOUSEKEEPING PURPOSES.
01:41:13.133 --> 01:41:14.535
THIS IS GOING TO BE THE LAST
01:41:14.601 --> 01:41:15.803
BILL THAT WE HEAR BEFORE WE
01:41:15.869 --> 01:41:19.873
BREAK FOR, UM, CAUCUS. AND SO
01:41:19.940 --> 01:41:22.409
AFTER WE RETURN, WE WILL HEAR
01:41:22.476 --> 01:41:24.912
ITEM NUMBER FIVE AND THEN ITEM
01:41:24.978 --> 01:41:26.113
NUMBER EIGHT. UM THERE'LL BE A
01:41:26.180 --> 01:41:27.781
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS. UM SC
01:41:27.848 --> 01:41:32.019
8 10 AT 1 30, ALRIGHT. UM NO
01:41:32.085 --> 01:41:32.820
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
01:41:32.886 --> 01:41:33.821
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BAR CAM, YOU
01:41:33.887 --> 01:41:39.359
CARE TO CLOSE. CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:41:39.426 --> 01:41:40.461
. I APPRECIATE YOUR
01:41:40.527 --> 01:41:41.261
THOUGHTFULNESS AND THE
01:41:41.328 --> 01:41:42.729
INCREDIBLE ANALYSIS BY YOUR
01:41:42.796 --> 01:41:44.164
COMMITTEE ON THIS THAT ADDRESSES
01:41:44.231 --> 01:41:45.866
MANY OF THE CONCERNS OF THE
01:41:45.933 --> 01:41:47.534
OPPOSITION. WE BELIEVE THAT THIS
01:41:47.601 --> 01:41:48.702
IS INCREDIBLY GOOD AND VALID
01:41:48.769 --> 01:41:51.505
LAW. THESE ARE NOT LAWS THAT WE
01:41:51.572 --> 01:41:54.374
WOULD EVER PASS NOR ENFORCE HERE
01:41:54.441 --> 01:41:55.809
IN CALIFORNIA. IF THEY WERE OUR
01:41:55.876 --> 01:41:57.644
OWN, THEY WILL NEVER BE OUR OWN.
01:41:57.711 --> 01:41:59.613
AND SO WE DO NOT BELIEVE IT IS
01:41:59.680 --> 01:42:01.648
WITHIN. UM THE LAW THAT WE WOULD
01:42:01.715 --> 01:42:02.783
HAVE TO ENFORCE OUT OF STATE
01:42:02.850 --> 01:42:05.018
LAWS THAT ARE OUTSIDE BOTH THE
01:42:05.085 --> 01:42:05.953
PUBLIC POLICY EXCEPTION OF THE
01:42:06.019 --> 01:42:06.854
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE, AS
01:42:06.920 --> 01:42:09.556
WELL AS AS NOTED IN THE ANALYSIS
01:42:09.623 --> 01:42:10.624
. WE ALSO BELIEVE IT FALLS UNDER
01:42:10.691 --> 01:42:12.025
THE PENAL EXCEPTION, WHICH GIVES
01:42:12.092 --> 01:42:13.494
US TWO GROUNDS ON WHICH WE
01:42:13.560 --> 01:42:14.795
BELIEVE THIS TO BE BOTH
01:42:14.862 --> 01:42:16.296
CONSTITUTIONAL AND GOOD POLICY
01:42:16.363 --> 01:42:17.865
FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WITH
01:42:17.931 --> 01:42:18.932
THAT, I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I
01:42:18.999 --> 01:42:19.967
VOTE ALREADY. THANK YOU,
01:42:20.033 --> 01:42:22.035
COUNCILOR. AH LET'S SEE IF WE'RE
01:42:22.102 --> 01:42:25.105
GOING TO HAVE ANY CHANCE WE'RE
01:42:25.172 --> 01:42:27.140
GOING TO MORE MEMBERS APPEAR, UH
01:42:27.207 --> 01:42:29.009
, IN THE NEXT FEW MOMENTS, I SEE
01:42:29.076 --> 01:42:31.278
HEAD SHAKING AND THE NEGATIVE,
01:42:31.345 --> 01:42:34.715
SO ALL RIGHT. WE WERE GOING TO
01:42:34.781 --> 01:42:36.984
RECESS HERE UNTIL 1 30. AT THAT
01:42:37.050 --> 01:42:39.019
TIME, WE WILL HAVE A SPECIAL OR
01:42:39.086 --> 01:42:41.788
BUSINESS. AND I'M HOPING QUORUM
01:42:41.855 --> 01:42:45.392
. SO THANK YOU. ALL SO I SHOULD
01:42:45.459 --> 01:42:46.493
RETURN AFTER THE SPECIAL ORDER
01:42:46.560 --> 01:42:48.262
OF BUSINESS FOR MY OWN. WE'RE
01:42:48.328 --> 01:42:50.664
GOING TO 1 30. WE HAVE A SPECIAL
01:42:50.731 --> 01:42:51.832
OR BUSINESS AND WHENEVER THAT'S
01:42:51.899 --> 01:42:54.001
CONCLUDED, AND, UM WE WILL BEGIN
01:42:54.067 --> 01:42:55.302
BACK AGAIN AND FILE ORDER.
01:42:55.369 --> 01:42:57.037
AWESOME. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR.
01:42:57.104 --> 01:43:13.253
THANK YOU.
01:43:36.810 --> 01:43:38.211
WE'RE GONNA WE'RE GONNA WHAT?
01:43:38.278 --> 01:43:40.147
ONE SECOND ONE SECOND WE'RE
01:43:40.213 --> 01:43:42.049
GOING TO. WE'RE GOING TO UM,
01:43:42.115 --> 01:43:44.117
WE'RE GOING TO RECONVENE HERE
01:43:44.184 --> 01:43:45.419
FOR PURPOSE OF ESTABLISHING A
01:43:45.485 --> 01:43:47.454
QUORUM AND WE WILL VOTE ON THE
01:43:47.521 --> 01:43:50.290
CONSENT CALENDAR. UM ALL RIGHT,
01:43:50.357 --> 01:43:52.459
AND I SEE SOME OF THE
01:43:52.526 --> 01:43:53.126
EMBARKATION HERE, SO WE'LL TAKE
01:43:53.193 --> 01:43:55.329
A VOTE ON HER BILL AS WELL.
01:43:55.395 --> 01:43:56.330
ALRIGHT SO LET'S GO AHEAD AND
01:43:56.396 --> 01:43:58.098
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. THEN WE'LL
01:43:58.165 --> 01:44:00.000
VOTE ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
01:44:00.067 --> 01:44:03.637
AND ON, UM, ITEM NUMBER FOUR A B
01:44:03.704 --> 01:44:04.905
16 66, AND THEN WE WILL RECESS,
01:44:04.972 --> 01:44:09.176
ALL RIGHT. SO LET'S ESTABLISH A
01:44:09.242 --> 01:44:10.711
QUORUM. MADAM SECRETARY IF YOU
01:44:10.777 --> 01:44:14.014
WOULD CALL THE ROLL. HAMBURG.
01:44:14.081 --> 01:44:15.582
I'M OUT OF HERE BEFORE GIS
01:44:15.649 --> 01:44:19.353
COMING 00 HERE, DORIS Ó. DURAZO
01:44:19.419 --> 01:44:20.354
HERE. GONZALEZ GONZALEZ HERE,
01:44:20.420 --> 01:44:24.524
HERTZBERG JONES LAYERED STERN
01:44:24.591 --> 01:44:28.362
STERN HERE, WIECKOWSKI WIENER.
01:44:28.428 --> 01:44:30.197
WIENER PRESENT. YOU HAVE A
01:44:30.263 --> 01:44:32.065
QUORUM. ALRIGHT UM IS THERE A
01:44:32.132 --> 01:44:33.500
MOTION ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR?
01:44:33.567 --> 01:44:35.068
ALL RIGHT, SENATOR COVER HE
01:44:35.135 --> 01:44:36.903
REMOVES THE CONSENT CALENDAR. IF
01:44:36.970 --> 01:44:38.171
YOU CALL THE RULE ON THE CONSENT
01:44:38.238 --> 01:44:41.742
CALENDAR, MADAM SECRETARY
01:44:41.808 --> 01:44:42.609
HAMBURG, HAMBURG, GORGEOUS
01:44:42.676 --> 01:44:46.446
CABALLERO. D<c.cyan>!I DURAZO. H</c>
01:44:46.513 --> 01:44:50.217
NZALES. GONZALES. I HERZBERG
01:44:50.283 --> 01:44:55.188
JONES LAYERED STERN STERN. I
01:44:55.255 --> 01:44:59.159
WIECKOWSKI WIENER WIENER. AYE. 6
01:44:59.226 --> 01:45:01.595
TO 0 WITH MEMBERS MISSING BILL
01:45:01.662 --> 01:45:03.630
IS WE'LL PUT THE BILL BACK ON
01:45:03.697 --> 01:45:05.298
CALL. ALRIGHT ALRIGHT, LET'S
01:45:05.365 --> 01:45:06.800
LET'S JUST DO ITEM NUMBER FOUR A
01:45:06.867 --> 01:45:07.668
B 16 66 SINCE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:45:07.734 --> 01:45:11.304
BARAK KHAN IS HERE. SO MADAM
01:45:11.371 --> 01:45:12.906
SECRETARY, IF YOU WOULD CALL THE
01:45:12.973 --> 01:45:14.875
ROLE AND THEN OTHER MATTERS WELL
01:45:14.941 --> 01:45:16.710
, WE WILL HOLD THEM IN A BALANCE
01:45:16.777 --> 01:45:18.211
UNTIL AFTER WE WERE RETURNED AT
01:45:18.278 --> 01:45:21.148
1 30. OKAY WE NEED A MOTION,
01:45:21.214 --> 01:45:22.416
SENATOR. CAVALLERO UH, OK. THANK
01:45:22.482 --> 01:45:27.320
YOU REMOVES THE BILL. OKAY? UM
01:45:27.387 --> 01:45:31.792
HUM, BERG BERG. OH THE MOTION IS
01:45:31.858 --> 01:45:35.162
DUE PASS HAMBURG. GORGEOUS
01:45:35.228 --> 01:45:36.029
CABALLERO. COUPLE EURO, I
01:45:36.096 --> 01:45:40.434
DURAZO. YOU'RE A SO I GONZALEZ.
01:45:40.500 --> 01:45:42.002
GONZALEZ I HERZBERG JONES
01:45:42.069 --> 01:45:46.640
LAYERED STERN. STERN I
01:45:46.707 --> 01:45:49.743
WIECKOWSKI WIENER WIENER. I 6 TO
01:45:49.810 --> 01:45:51.912
0 TO PUT THAT BILL ON CALL.
01:45:51.978 --> 01:45:54.114
WE'LL SEE EVERYONE AGAIN AT 1 30
01:45:54.181 --> 01:45:56.316
13 30 FOR YOUR MILITARY TYPES.
01:45:56.383 --> 01:46:13.200
ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU.
01:46:14.434 --> 01:46:16.503
ALRIGHT UM, ASSEMBLY. EXCUSE ME.
01:46:16.570 --> 01:46:21.374
THAT WAS FRIDAY AND. THE SENATE
01:46:21.441 --> 01:46:23.744
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY. WE WILL
01:46:23.810 --> 01:46:26.480
RECONVENE. UM WE HAVE SET AS A
01:46:26.546 --> 01:46:30.784
SPECIAL ORDER. UM SC 8 10. TO BE
01:46:30.851 --> 01:46:35.021
HEARD. AND MADAM PRO TEM. ALL
01:46:35.088 --> 01:46:41.228
RIGHT. UM WE HAVE A BIT OF A
01:46:41.294 --> 01:46:44.131
DIFFERENT PROCESS FOR, UM S CHN
01:46:44.197 --> 01:46:47.501
, UH, WILL BE A TOTAL OF 10
01:46:47.567 --> 01:46:50.237
MINUTES FOR PRIMARY WITNESSES
01:46:50.303 --> 01:46:51.805
AND SUPPORT AND 10 MINUTES FOR
01:46:51.872 --> 01:46:53.874
PRIMARY WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION
01:46:53.940 --> 01:46:55.308
. EACH SIDE WILL HAVE THREE
01:46:55.375 --> 01:46:56.343
PRIMARY WITNESSES. UM, AFTER
01:46:56.409 --> 01:47:00.046
THAT. ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
01:47:00.113 --> 01:47:02.516
PROVIDE THEIR NAME. THEIR
01:47:02.582 --> 01:47:04.484
AFFILIATION IN THEIR POSITION
01:47:04.551 --> 01:47:05.619
MAY APPROACH THE MICROPHONE.
01:47:05.685 --> 01:47:06.686
THEN WE'LL TAKE SUPPORTING
01:47:06.753 --> 01:47:09.356
OPPOSITION ON THE PHONE. SO UM,
01:47:09.422 --> 01:47:14.094
MADAM PRO TEM FLOOR IS YOURS. MR
01:47:14.161 --> 01:47:15.529
CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU, COLLEAGUES
01:47:15.595 --> 01:47:17.531
. THANK YOU. I'M HERE TODAY TO
01:47:17.597 --> 01:47:18.498
PRESENT SENATE CONSTITUTIONAL
01:47:18.565 --> 01:47:22.736
AMENDMENT 10. WE'RE ON THE BRINK
01:47:22.803 --> 01:47:24.104
OF THE U. S. SUPREME COURT
01:47:24.171 --> 01:47:25.205
DECISION THAT WE HAVE EVERY
01:47:25.272 --> 01:47:26.873
REASON TO BELIEVE WILL TOPPLE
01:47:26.940 --> 01:47:28.942
ROE VERSUS WADE AND ERODE THE
01:47:29.009 --> 01:47:29.776
RIGHT TO ABORTION THAT WAS
01:47:29.843 --> 01:47:32.479
SECURED NEARLY 50 YEARS AGO.
01:47:32.546 --> 01:47:33.980
ALTERING REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM IN
01:47:34.047 --> 01:47:36.716
AMERICA AS WE KNOW IT. IN
01:47:36.783 --> 01:47:39.486
CALIFORNIA. WE CANNOT STAND BY
01:47:39.553 --> 01:47:40.620
AS WOMEN AND FAMILIES ARE LEFT
01:47:40.687 --> 01:47:42.622
VULNERABLE AS OUR HIGHEST COURT
01:47:42.689 --> 01:47:43.757
MOVES TO STRIP AWAY OUR RIGHTS
01:47:43.824 --> 01:47:45.525
AND PUT COUNTLESS PEOPLE IN
01:47:45.592 --> 01:47:48.128
HARM'S WAY. ALONGSIDE SPEAKER
01:47:48.195 --> 01:47:50.030
RENDON AND SO MANY OF OUR
01:47:50.096 --> 01:47:51.665
COLLEAGUES. WE'VE INTRODUCED
01:47:51.731 --> 01:47:53.800
SCHNUR ENSURE THAT THE
01:47:53.867 --> 01:47:55.669
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO CHOOSE TO
01:47:55.735 --> 01:47:56.803
HAVE AN ABORTION AND TO USE
01:47:56.870 --> 01:47:59.272
CONTRACEPTION. IS PROTECTED IN
01:47:59.339 --> 01:48:00.340
CALIFORNIA NOW AND FOR
01:48:00.407 --> 01:48:03.543
GENERATIONS TO COME. ABORTION IS
01:48:03.610 --> 01:48:05.612
HEALTHCARE, PLAIN AND SIMPLE.
01:48:05.679 --> 01:48:07.280
AND LIKE MANY IMPORTANT MEDICAL
01:48:07.347 --> 01:48:08.715
DECISIONS, IT'S A DISCUSSION
01:48:08.782 --> 01:48:10.450
BETWEEN THE PATIENT AND THEIR
01:48:10.517 --> 01:48:13.019
HEALTH CARE PROVIDER. NO JUDGE.
01:48:13.086 --> 01:48:14.754
NO POLITICIAN SHOULD BE IN THAT
01:48:14.821 --> 01:48:17.090
ROOM OR MAKING THIS DECISION.
01:48:17.157 --> 01:48:18.592
THESE ARE DEEPLY PERSONAL
01:48:18.658 --> 01:48:20.126
CHOICES THAT SHOULD BE GROUNDED
01:48:20.193 --> 01:48:21.728
IN SCIENTIFIC FACTS AND NOT
01:48:21.795 --> 01:48:24.865
ANYONE'S POLITICAL AGENDA. WHEN
01:48:24.931 --> 01:48:27.334
THE ABILITY TO ACCESS SAFE LEGAL
01:48:27.400 --> 01:48:28.501
ABORTION IS TAKEN AWAY. THINGS
01:48:28.568 --> 01:48:31.671
GET GRIM. AND DANGEROUS AND I
01:48:31.738 --> 01:48:33.607
ASSURE YOU I'VE ACTUALLY SEEN IT
01:48:33.673 --> 01:48:35.709
FIRSTHAND. DURING MY TIME
01:48:35.775 --> 01:48:37.110
PROVIDING CLINIC SERVICES THAT
01:48:37.177 --> 01:48:39.746
WOMEN'S HEALTH CENTER I MET A
01:48:39.813 --> 01:48:41.448
DISTRAUGHT MOTHER WHOSE DAUGHTER
01:48:41.514 --> 01:48:43.283
DIED AFTER AN ILLEGAL ABORTION
01:48:43.350 --> 01:48:45.151
IN ANOTHER STATE. HER STORY HAS
01:48:45.218 --> 01:48:47.153
NEVER LEFT ME. IT HAUNTS ME EVEN
01:48:47.220 --> 01:48:49.389
TODAY. I HELD THE HAND OF A
01:48:49.456 --> 01:48:51.892
WOMAN IN THE NAVY WHO HAD BEEN
01:48:51.958 --> 01:48:53.293
INCORRECTLY LED TO BELIEVE SHE
01:48:53.360 --> 01:48:54.427
COULD NOT SAFELY DELIVER HER
01:48:54.494 --> 01:48:58.031
BABY. BECAUSE SHE HAD AN STD
01:48:58.098 --> 01:48:59.966
SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASE.
01:49:00.033 --> 01:49:01.534
SHE CAME TO US BECAUSE SHE
01:49:01.601 --> 01:49:03.637
COULDN'T GET AN ABORTION IN THE
01:49:03.703 --> 01:49:05.538
NAVAL HOSPITAL WHERE SHE WAS SHE
01:49:05.605 --> 01:49:06.606
SERVED IN THE NAVY. SHE WAS
01:49:06.673 --> 01:49:07.674
SCARED, CONFUSED AND SHE WAS
01:49:07.741 --> 01:49:11.611
ALONE. AND SHE WAS MISINFORMED.
01:49:11.678 --> 01:49:13.680
WE HELPED HER UNDERSTAND ALL OF
01:49:13.747 --> 01:49:15.749
HER OPTIONS AND THAT SHE COULD
01:49:15.815 --> 01:49:16.917
DELIVER A HEALTHY BABY DESPITE
01:49:16.983 --> 01:49:20.987
HAVING AN STD. SHE WENT HOME.
01:49:21.054 --> 01:49:22.756
SHE HAD A BABY LATER, AND SHE,
01:49:22.822 --> 01:49:25.458
UH, HAD A DOCTOR THAT INFORMED
01:49:25.525 --> 01:49:27.360
HER OF ALL OF HER OPTIONS, AND
01:49:27.427 --> 01:49:29.195
SHE MADE THAT CHOICE. THIS IS
01:49:29.262 --> 01:49:31.131
WHAT'S AT RISK, REAL FAMILIES,
01:49:31.197 --> 01:49:32.732
REAL LIVES AND REAL OPTIONS, SO
01:49:32.799 --> 01:49:35.936
I RESPECTFULLY ASKED YOU TO
01:49:36.002 --> 01:49:38.772
CONSIDER PASSING SCHNOOR TODAY I
01:49:38.838 --> 01:49:40.874
HAVE A NUMBER OF EXPERT
01:49:40.941 --> 01:49:42.609
WITNESSES WITH ME AND WE STAND
01:49:42.676 --> 01:49:44.110
READY TO TAKE YOUR QUESTIONS AND
01:49:44.177 --> 01:49:45.111
COMMENTS. THANK YOU, MR
01:49:45.178 --> 01:49:46.346
CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU, MADAM PRO
01:49:46.413 --> 01:49:50.083
TEM. MISS HICKS. THANK YOU. GOOD
01:49:50.150 --> 01:49:51.718
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:49:51.785 --> 01:49:53.687
OF THE COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS
01:49:53.753 --> 01:49:55.455
JODY HICKS CURRENTLY SERVES AS
01:49:55.522 --> 01:49:57.524
THE PRESIDENT AND CEO OF PLANNED
01:49:57.590 --> 01:49:58.191
PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
01:49:58.258 --> 01:50:00.593
CALIFORNIA, REPRESENTING SEVEN
01:50:00.660 --> 01:50:01.461
AFFILIATES IN OVER 100 HEALTH
01:50:01.528 --> 01:50:04.531
CENTERS THROUGHOUT CALIFORNIA.
01:50:04.597 --> 01:50:06.366
I'M ALSO HERE AS A MEMBER OF THE
01:50:06.433 --> 01:50:07.734
STEERING COMMITTEE OF THE
01:50:07.801 --> 01:50:09.169
CALIFORNIA FUTURE OF ABORTION
01:50:09.235 --> 01:50:11.972
CUNCIL, REPRESENTING FOR OVER
01:50:12.038 --> 01:50:14.374
40 ORGANIZATIONS WORKING
01:50:14.441 --> 01:50:15.642
TOGETHER SINCE SEPTEMBER TO
01:50:15.709 --> 01:50:16.643
REALLY PREPARE CALIFORNIA FOR
01:50:16.710 --> 01:50:20.113
THE CRISIS. AT HAND AND ENSURING
01:50:20.180 --> 01:50:21.614
THAT CALIFORNIA'S ABORTION
01:50:21.681 --> 01:50:23.516
NETWORK IS READY FOR WHAT? WE'RE
01:50:23.583 --> 01:50:26.353
FACING THIS COMING YEAR. AND
01:50:26.419 --> 01:50:27.854
WELL, I WISH YOU WERE HERE UNDER
01:50:27.921 --> 01:50:29.990
BETTER CIRCUMSTANCES, BUT GIVEN
01:50:30.056 --> 01:50:33.126
THE ONGOING ATTACKS ON ABORTION
01:50:33.193 --> 01:50:34.160
NATIONWIDE, I AM GRATEFUL FOR
01:50:34.227 --> 01:50:37.230
THE CONTINUED LEADERSHIP. OF OUR
01:50:37.297 --> 01:50:39.399
CALIFORNIA POLICYMAKERS,
01:50:39.466 --> 01:50:42.102
INSURING IN THIS MOMENT TO
01:50:42.168 --> 01:50:43.269
ROTECT AND REALLY EXPAND ACCESS
01:50:43.336 --> 01:50:47.974
TO ABORTION. STHN. WILL AMEND
01:50:48.041 --> 01:50:49.909
OUR STATE'S CONSTITUTION TO
01:50:49.976 --> 01:50:50.844
PROTECT ABORTION AND
01:50:50.910 --> 01:50:54.481
CONTRACEPTION. AND IT'S NOT JUST
01:50:54.547 --> 01:50:56.249
WHAT IS NEEDED RIGHT NOW TO MEET
01:50:56.316 --> 01:50:57.884
THIS MOMENT, BUT IT'S REALLY
01:50:57.951 --> 01:51:00.120
IMPORTANT THAT WE ENSURE ACCESS
01:51:00.186 --> 01:51:01.588
TO ESSENTIAL SEXUAL AND
01:51:01.654 --> 01:51:02.355
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE IN OUR
01:51:02.422 --> 01:51:04.491
STATE FOR PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA
01:51:04.557 --> 01:51:06.259
NOW AND CERTAINLY FOR OUR FUTURE
01:51:06.326 --> 01:51:09.996
GENERATIONS. AND LET ME BE CLEAR
01:51:10.063 --> 01:51:11.765
THE RIGHT TO ABORTION AND THE
01:51:11.831 --> 01:51:14.534
RIGHT TO PRIVACY ARE AT RISK.
01:51:14.601 --> 01:51:16.269
LIKE NEVER BEFORE. JUST LAST
01:51:16.336 --> 01:51:18.471
MONTH, WE ALL SAW A LEAKED DRAFT
01:51:18.538 --> 01:51:21.408
DECISION. AND WE SAW FOR THE
01:51:21.474 --> 01:51:23.376
FIRST TIME JUST HOW MUCH THE
01:51:23.443 --> 01:51:24.244
RIGHT TO ABORTION AND
01:51:24.310 --> 01:51:25.745
ULTIMATELY, THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY
01:51:25.812 --> 01:51:27.547
IS UNDER ATTACK BY A HANDFUL OF
01:51:27.614 --> 01:51:29.182
REALLY EXTREME CONSERVATIVE
01:51:29.249 --> 01:51:30.316
JUSTICES ON OUR NATION'S HIGHEST
01:51:30.383 --> 01:51:34.954
COURT. AND SEEM TO BE PUT THEIR
01:51:35.021 --> 01:51:35.755
EXPLICITLY BECAUSE OF THEIR
01:51:35.822 --> 01:51:37.257
HOSTILITY AND OPPOSITION TO ROE
01:51:37.323 --> 01:51:39.893
V. WADE SO SIMPLY PUT THE RIGHT
01:51:39.959 --> 01:51:43.463
TO PRIVACY IS JUST NOT ENOUGH.
01:51:43.530 --> 01:51:45.865
STHN IN ADDITION TO THE
01:51:45.932 --> 01:51:46.733
LEGISLATIVE PACKAGE BROUGHT
01:51:46.800 --> 01:51:47.934
FORWARD BY THE LEGISLATIVE
01:51:48.001 --> 01:51:50.970
WOMEN'S CAUCUS IS ESSENTIAL IN
01:51:51.037 --> 01:51:53.139
SHOWING CALIFORNIA'S VALUES AS A
01:51:53.206 --> 01:51:55.208
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM STATE.
01:51:55.275 --> 01:51:56.643
SHOWING THAT CALIFORNIA
01:51:56.709 --> 01:51:58.311
RECOGNIZES NO MATTER WHAT THE
01:51:58.378 --> 01:52:00.380
SUPREME COURT DECIDES HEALTHCARE
01:52:00.447 --> 01:52:01.414
, INCLUDING ABORTION IS A
01:52:01.481 --> 01:52:04.818
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT. ABORTION IS A
01:52:04.884 --> 01:52:06.319
PERSONAL DECISION AND PEOPLE
01:52:06.386 --> 01:52:07.887
SHOULD BE ABLE TO MAKE THEIR OWN
01:52:07.954 --> 01:52:09.856
MEDICAL DECISIONS WITH THEIR
01:52:09.923 --> 01:52:12.192
HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS. AND THE
01:52:12.258 --> 01:52:13.159
REALITY IS WE'RE FACING A
01:52:13.226 --> 01:52:14.928
SUPREME COURT DECISION IN IN
01:52:14.994 --> 01:52:17.197
JUST A FEW WEEKS. IMPACTING OVER
01:52:17.263 --> 01:52:19.299
HALF THE COUNTRY AND WE ARE
01:52:19.365 --> 01:52:21.234
TALKING ABOUT 26 STATES, WHERE
01:52:21.301 --> 01:52:23.269
ABORTION SERVICES ARE EITHER
01:52:23.336 --> 01:52:25.305
SEVERE, SEVERELY RESTRICTED OR
01:52:25.371 --> 01:52:26.739
BANNED COMPLETELY, WHERE PEOPLE
01:52:26.806 --> 01:52:27.941
HAVE TO TRAVEL OUTSIDE OF THE
01:52:28.007 --> 01:52:29.676
STATE THAT THEY CURRENTLY LIVE
01:52:29.742 --> 01:52:31.211
IN. IN ORDER TO GET HEALTHCARE
01:52:31.277 --> 01:52:32.879
AND WE ARE SHOCKED, TALKING
01:52:32.946 --> 01:52:36.382
ABOUT OVER 35 MILLION PEOPLE. SO
01:52:36.449 --> 01:52:37.884
WE NEED TO PROTECT PEOPLE'S
01:52:37.951 --> 01:52:39.185
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS RIGHTS TO
01:52:39.252 --> 01:52:41.488
CONTROL THEIR OWN BODY TO ENSURE
01:52:41.554 --> 01:52:43.089
THAT EVERYONE HAS OPTIONS WHEN
01:52:43.156 --> 01:52:44.557
IT COMES TO MAKING DECISIONS
01:52:44.624 --> 01:52:45.058
ABOUT THEIR REPRODUCTIVE
01:52:45.125 --> 01:52:48.962
HEALTHCARE. AND THE L 10 STHN
01:52:49.028 --> 01:52:50.497
WILL CONTINUE TO ALLOW
01:52:50.563 --> 01:52:52.165
INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES THE
01:52:52.232 --> 01:52:55.101
FREEDOM TO DECIDE IF AND WHEN TO
01:52:55.168 --> 01:52:56.469
HAVE CHILDREN, EMPOWERING PEOPLE
01:52:56.536 --> 01:52:57.403
WITH THE ABILITY TO PLAN THEIR
01:52:57.470 --> 01:53:00.874
LIVES. AND REALLY TO ACHIEVE
01:53:00.940 --> 01:53:03.476
THEIR GOALS AND THEIR DREAMS. SO
01:53:03.543 --> 01:53:05.545
WE NEED TO ACT NOW TO ENSURE
01:53:05.612 --> 01:53:07.147
ABORTION REMAINS SAFE AND LEGAL
01:53:07.213 --> 01:53:08.815
HERE IN CALIFORNIA THAT
01:53:08.882 --> 01:53:10.750
IMPORTANT HEALTH CARE DECISIONS
01:53:10.817 --> 01:53:12.919
ARE LEFT TO A PERSON AND THEIR
01:53:12.986 --> 01:53:14.053
PROVIDERS WITH THE BACKING OF
01:53:14.120 --> 01:53:17.757
SCIENCE. EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE
01:53:17.824 --> 01:53:20.593
AND NOT A POLITICAL AGENDA. THIS
01:53:20.660 --> 01:53:21.995
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT SENDS A
01:53:22.061 --> 01:53:23.730
CLEAR SIGNAL ACROSS THE COUNTRY
01:53:23.796 --> 01:53:25.265
THAT NOT ONLY IS ABORTION CARE,
01:53:25.331 --> 01:53:26.366
LEGAL AND AVAILABLE IN
01:53:26.432 --> 01:53:28.868
CALIFORNIA, BUT WE AS A STATE
01:53:28.935 --> 01:53:30.003
CARE ABOUT YOU, AND WE WILL
01:53:30.069 --> 01:53:31.971
FIGHT FOR YOU. IT IS ANOTHER
01:53:32.038 --> 01:53:33.540
STEP THAT POLICYMAKERS ARE
01:53:33.606 --> 01:53:34.707
TAKING TO ENSURE THAT ACROSS
01:53:34.774 --> 01:53:37.944
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE THE ABILITY
01:53:38.011 --> 01:53:39.812
TO MAKE THE BEST DECISION FOR
01:53:39.879 --> 01:53:42.749
EVERYONE WINNER IF THEY WANT TO
01:53:42.815 --> 01:53:44.317
START A FAMILY AND HOW BEST TO
01:53:44.384 --> 01:53:46.052
DO SO. IT'S CRUCIAL THAT PEOPLE
01:53:46.119 --> 01:53:48.755
FEEL SAFE, ESPECIALLY RIGHT NOW
01:53:48.821 --> 01:53:49.389
, WHEN IT'S ACT, ACCESSING THE
01:53:49.455 --> 01:53:50.423
ESSENTIAL HEALTH CARE THEY WANT
01:53:50.490 --> 01:53:52.525
AND NEED. THROUGHOUT THEIR
01:53:52.592 --> 01:53:56.362
PREGNANCY AND BEYOND. THIS
01:53:56.429 --> 01:53:58.464
EFFORT PROVIDES THEM MUCH NEEDED
01:53:58.531 --> 01:54:00.433
REASSURANCE IN THIS TIME OF
01:54:00.500 --> 01:54:01.668
UNCERTAINTY, AND THANK YOU AND I
01:54:01.734 --> 01:54:04.337
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU.
01:54:04.404 --> 01:54:05.605
MISSHICKS WAS ABOUT SIX MINUTES
01:54:05.672 --> 01:54:11.477
LEFT, DR GUPTA. GOOD AFTERNOON
01:54:11.544 --> 01:54:12.512
CHAIR. HAMBURG AND COMMITTEE
01:54:12.579 --> 01:54:14.614
MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR HAVING
01:54:14.681 --> 01:54:15.582
ME. MY NAME IS DR PETIT MMA
01:54:15.648 --> 01:54:17.617
GUPTA. I'M A BOARD CERTIFIED
01:54:17.684 --> 01:54:19.752
OBSTETRICIAN GYNECOLOGIST AND
01:54:19.819 --> 01:54:21.221
MEMBER OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE
01:54:21.287 --> 01:54:21.654
OF OBSTETRICIANS AND
01:54:21.721 --> 01:54:22.589
GYNECOLOGISTS DISTRICT NINE,
01:54:22.655 --> 01:54:25.725
ALSO KNOWN AS A CALM WELL, MAYBE
01:54:25.792 --> 01:54:27.327
HARD TO BELIEVE. BASED ON MY
01:54:27.393 --> 01:54:28.461
YOUTHFUL APPEARANCE. I'VE BEEN A
01:54:28.528 --> 01:54:30.263
PROVIDER OF ABORTION CARE FOR
01:54:30.330 --> 01:54:32.332
OVER 20 YEARS. I PROBABLY WORKED
01:54:32.398 --> 01:54:34.033
ALL OVER OUR GLORIOUS GOLDEN
01:54:34.100 --> 01:54:35.735
STATE FOR MY MEDICAL SCHOOL AND
01:54:35.802 --> 01:54:38.338
RESIDENCY IN LOS ANGELES TO A
01:54:38.404 --> 01:54:39.872
FELLOWSHIP AND FAMILY PLANNING
01:54:39.939 --> 01:54:41.608
AND MASTERS IN PUBLIC HEALTH IN
01:54:41.674 --> 01:54:43.076
THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA. AND
01:54:43.142 --> 01:54:44.510
I CURRENTLY RESIDE AND WORK IN
01:54:44.577 --> 01:54:45.845
SAN DIEGO AT UCSD AND PLANNED
01:54:45.912 --> 01:54:46.779
PARENTHOOD, WHERE I ALSO
01:54:46.846 --> 01:54:48.548
TRAVELED TO A MORE RURAL CENTERS
01:54:48.615 --> 01:54:51.284
TO IMPROVE ACCESS TO CARE. AS AN
01:54:51.351 --> 01:54:53.353
OBSTETRICIAN GYNECOLOGIST. I
01:54:53.419 --> 01:54:54.921
SUPPORT THE HEALTH SAFETY AND
01:54:54.988 --> 01:54:56.556
WELL BEING OF OUR PATIENTS BY
01:54:56.623 --> 01:54:57.257
PROVIDING PROVIDING
01:54:57.323 --> 01:54:59.492
COMPREHENSIVE MEDICAL CARE,
01:54:59.559 --> 01:55:01.060
WORKING TO ENSURE THAT ALL
01:55:01.127 --> 01:55:02.462
PATIENTS CAN ACCESS THE FULL
01:55:02.528 --> 01:55:05.431
SPECTRUM OF MATERNAL SEXUAL AND
01:55:05.498 --> 01:55:06.733
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE
01:55:06.799 --> 01:55:08.301
OPTIONS, INCLUDING ABORTION AND
01:55:08.368 --> 01:55:10.370
BY PROVIDING INCLUSIVE, PATIENT
01:55:10.436 --> 01:55:12.105
CENTERED CARE WITH AN EMPHASIS
01:55:12.171 --> 01:55:12.905
ON JUSTICE, RESPECT, COMPASSION
01:55:12.972 --> 01:55:17.243
AND DIGNITY. AND IN THAT CONTEXT
01:55:17.310 --> 01:55:19.078
, I'M HERE TODAY. SPEAKING IN
01:55:19.145 --> 01:55:20.813
SUPPORT OF CHN, WHICH AMENDS OUR
01:55:20.880 --> 01:55:22.615
STATE CONSTITUTION TO PROTECT
01:55:22.682 --> 01:55:24.217
ABORTION AND CONTRACEPTION AS
01:55:24.284 --> 01:55:25.585
ESSENTIAL COMPONENTS OF
01:55:25.652 --> 01:55:26.152
COMPREHENSIVE EVIDENCE BASED
01:55:26.219 --> 01:55:29.355
HEALTH CARE. ACCESS TO CARE
01:55:29.422 --> 01:55:31.491
SHOULD NOT DEPEND ON YOUR ZIP
01:55:31.557 --> 01:55:32.925
CODE QUESTIONS ABOUT WHETHER AND
01:55:32.992 --> 01:55:34.727
WHEN TO ACCESS ABORTION CARE
01:55:34.794 --> 01:55:36.029
SHOULD BE REMOVED FROM THE
01:55:36.095 --> 01:55:37.697
POLITICAL CONTEXT AND RETURN TO
01:55:37.764 --> 01:55:38.798
PATIENTS AND HEALTHCARE
01:55:38.865 --> 01:55:42.101
PROFESSIONALS LIKE ME. LAST
01:55:42.168 --> 01:55:43.736
WEEK, I SAW A YOUNG ASIAN WOMAN
01:55:43.803 --> 01:55:45.271
I STILL REMEMBER HER PINK
01:55:45.338 --> 01:55:47.607
SPARKLY PHONE CASE WHO, AFTER
01:55:47.674 --> 01:55:49.242
CONSULTATION WITH HER MOTHER AND
01:55:49.309 --> 01:55:50.243
HER PARTNER, DECIDED TO
01:55:50.310 --> 01:55:52.712
TERMINATE HER PREGNANCY. I
01:55:52.779 --> 01:55:53.780
PERFORMED HER ABORTION PROVIDED
01:55:53.846 --> 01:55:55.415
THE BIRTH CONTROL THAT SHE
01:55:55.481 --> 01:55:57.650
WANTED. WE SHOULD BE PROVIDED
01:55:57.717 --> 01:55:59.052
PROUD OF THIS KAREN, CALIFORNIA
01:55:59.118 --> 01:56:00.853
BECAUSE THIS IS HOW IT SHOULD
01:56:00.920 --> 01:56:04.090
WORK. OUR PATIENTS NEED US AS
01:56:04.157 --> 01:56:05.124
THEIR TRUSTED MEDICAL
01:56:05.191 --> 01:56:06.492
INFORMATION GUIDES MORE THAN
01:56:06.559 --> 01:56:08.761
EVER. NOW IF SOMEONE CALLS ME
01:56:08.828 --> 01:56:09.362
SEEKING AN ABORTION, IT'S NOT
01:56:09.429 --> 01:56:11.898
ENOUGH FOR ME TO SAY HERE'S THE
01:56:11.964 --> 01:56:13.032
NUMBER OF YOUR NEAREST CLINIC. I
01:56:13.099 --> 01:56:14.734
NEED TO SAY HERE'S THE CLINIC.
01:56:14.801 --> 01:56:15.568
HERE'S THE NUMBER OF AN ABORTION
01:56:15.635 --> 01:56:16.469
FUND. SHOULD YOU HAVE ANY
01:56:16.536 --> 01:56:18.304
FINANCIAL ISSUES? HERE'S A
01:56:18.371 --> 01:56:18.771
HOTLINE FOR EMOTIONAL
01:56:18.838 --> 01:56:20.039
CONSULTATIONS AND A PATIENT
01:56:20.106 --> 01:56:22.275
NAVIGATOR. PEOPLE SHOULD BE ABLE
01:56:22.342 --> 01:56:23.576
TO ACCESS THE HEALTH CARE THEY
01:56:23.643 --> 01:56:24.711
NEED WITHOUT MEDICALLY
01:56:24.777 --> 01:56:25.178
UNNECESSARY BARRIERS.
01:56:25.244 --> 01:56:27.313
RESTRICTIONS. AND HEALTH CARE
01:56:27.380 --> 01:56:28.948
PROVIDERS LIKE MYSELF SHOULD BE
01:56:29.015 --> 01:56:31.250
ABLE TO OFFER THAT CARE WITHOUT
01:56:31.317 --> 01:56:32.418
INTERFERENCE OR FEAR OF BEING
01:56:32.485 --> 01:56:33.353
CRIMINALIZED OR OTHERWISE
01:56:33.419 --> 01:56:35.588
PUNISHED. IT'S CRITICAL THAT
01:56:35.655 --> 01:56:37.924
CALIFORNIA ACT NOW TO PROTECT
01:56:37.990 --> 01:56:39.992
THE SACRED PATIENT CLINICIAN
01:56:40.059 --> 01:56:41.461
RELATIONSHIP IN THE PROVISION OF
01:56:41.527 --> 01:56:43.129
ABORTION CARE, AND TO ENSURE
01:56:43.196 --> 01:56:44.397
THAT NO PERSON IN CALIFORNIA IS
01:56:44.464 --> 01:56:46.232
EVER DENIED THE ABILITY TO MAKE
01:56:46.299 --> 01:56:48.134
DECISIONS. WITH THEIR HEALTH
01:56:48.201 --> 01:56:50.002
CARE PROVIDER ABOUT WHETHER AND
01:56:50.069 --> 01:56:51.738
WHEN TO SEEK AND OBTAIN
01:56:51.804 --> 01:56:54.107
ESSENTIAL HEALTHCARE. THIS
01:56:54.173 --> 01:56:54.874
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT SENDS A
01:56:54.941 --> 01:56:56.109
CLEAR SIGNAL TO PATIENTS THAT
01:56:56.175 --> 01:56:58.010
ABORTION CARE IS LEGAL. AND
01:56:58.077 --> 01:56:59.445
AVAILABLE IN CALIFORNIA AND
01:56:59.512 --> 01:57:01.047
PROVIDES MUCH NEEDED REASSURANCE
01:57:01.114 --> 01:57:02.515
AT THIS CRITICAL TIME TO
01:57:02.582 --> 01:57:04.884
PATIENTS AND PROVIDERS ALIKE. I
01:57:04.951 --> 01:57:07.019
ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT CHN.
01:57:07.086 --> 01:57:08.621
THANK YOU FOR TIME AND FOR NOT
01:57:08.688 --> 01:57:10.523
FOR BEING NOT ONLY LEADERS IN
01:57:10.590 --> 01:57:11.724
CALIFORNIA, BUT TRAILBLAZERS.
01:57:11.791 --> 01:57:13.893
THANK YOU, DR GUPTA. ALRIGHT I
01:57:13.960 --> 01:57:15.862
BELIEVE KERRY FRANKLIN IS ON THE
01:57:15.928 --> 01:57:18.197
PHONE. OH, I'M SORRY. YES, THANK
01:57:18.264 --> 01:57:24.904
YOU. GO AHEAD, MISS FRANKLIN. MY
01:57:24.971 --> 01:57:26.472
NAME IS CARRIE FRANKLIN. I AM
01:57:26.539 --> 01:57:27.774
THE MCDONALD'S RIGHT CHAIR OF
01:57:27.840 --> 01:57:29.442
LAW AT U C L. A LAW SCHOOL WHERE
01:57:29.509 --> 01:57:31.577
I TEACH CONSTITUTIONAL LAW. I AM
01:57:31.644 --> 01:57:32.512
ALSO THE FACT THAT THE DIRECTOR
01:57:32.578 --> 01:57:34.180
OF YOUTH CENTER ON REPRODUCTIVE
01:57:34.247 --> 01:57:36.649
HEALTH PLANS POLICY AS YOU KNOW
01:57:36.716 --> 01:57:38.151
, THE SUPREME COURT WILL SOON
01:57:38.217 --> 01:57:40.386
ISSUE A DECISION IN A CASE THAT
01:57:40.453 --> 01:57:41.821
INVOLVES A DIRECT CHALLENGE TO
01:57:41.888 --> 01:57:43.022
CONSTITUTIONAL PROTECTION FOR
01:57:43.089 --> 01:57:44.424
ABORTION THAT HAVE BEEN IN PLACE
01:57:44.490 --> 01:57:46.759
SINCE 1973. THE WEAK DRAFT
01:57:46.826 --> 01:57:48.161
DECISION INDICATES THAT THE
01:57:48.227 --> 01:57:49.796
COURT IS PREPARED TO ASSIST
01:57:49.862 --> 01:57:50.763
AERATE THE CONSTITUTIONAL
01:57:50.830 --> 01:57:52.298
PRIVACY RIGHTS, PROTECTED AND
01:57:52.365 --> 01:57:54.033
ROW AND SEND PARENT HAD BEEN
01:57:54.100 --> 01:57:55.868
CASEY, THEREBY ALLOWING STATES
01:57:55.935 --> 01:57:57.470
TO BAR ACCESS TO SAFE AND LEGAL
01:57:57.537 --> 01:57:59.038
ABORTIONS, CRIMINALIZED PATIENTS
01:57:59.105 --> 01:58:00.173
AND PROVIDERS AND CREATE
01:58:00.239 --> 01:58:02.208
INSURMOUNTABLE BARRIERS. FOR
01:58:02.275 --> 01:58:03.142
PEOPLE ATTEMPTING TO ACCESS TO
01:58:03.209 --> 01:58:06.112
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE. EVEN
01:58:06.179 --> 01:58:07.580
WITH THOSE PROTECTIONS IN PLACE
01:58:07.647 --> 01:58:10.116
FEDERAL RESTRICTIONS SUCH AS THE
01:58:10.183 --> 01:58:10.750
HYDE AMENDMENT, WHICH PROHIBITS
01:58:10.817 --> 01:58:12.285
FEDERAL FUNDING TO BE USED FOR
01:58:12.351 --> 01:58:13.753
ABORTION SERVICES HAVE HAD A
01:58:13.820 --> 01:58:14.854
TERRIBLE, DISPARATE IMPACT ON
01:58:14.921 --> 01:58:16.756
WOMEN AND PREGNANT PEOPLE WHO
01:58:16.823 --> 01:58:18.724
ARE LOW INCOME. WHO ARE MEMBERS
01:58:18.791 --> 01:58:20.226
OF HISTORICALLY SUBORDINATED
01:58:20.293 --> 01:58:21.861
RACIAL GROUPS AND ALREADY FACING
01:58:21.928 --> 01:58:23.863
MULTIPLE BARRIERS TO HEALTHCARE.
01:58:23.930 --> 01:58:25.598
AT THE SAME TIME, ANTI ABORTION
01:58:25.665 --> 01:58:27.200
LEGISLATORS AND STATES HAVE
01:58:27.266 --> 01:58:28.601
PASSED INCREASINGLY RESTRICTIVE
01:58:28.668 --> 01:58:30.736
LAWS. THEY'RE NOT WRITTEN IN
01:58:30.803 --> 01:58:31.504
SCIENCE THAT ARE DESIGNED SOLELY
01:58:31.571 --> 01:58:32.672
MAKE IT DIFFICULT FOR PEOPLE TO
01:58:32.738 --> 01:58:35.274
OBTAIN ABORTIONS. THE U. S.
01:58:35.341 --> 01:58:37.143
SUPREME COURT HAS RECENTLY PAVED
01:58:37.210 --> 01:58:38.578
THE WAY FOR SUCH RESTRICTIONS BY
01:58:38.644 --> 01:58:40.680
ENABLING ILLEGAL SCHEME DESIGNED
01:58:40.746 --> 01:58:42.281
TO CIRCUMVENT JUDICIAL AUTHORITY
01:58:42.348 --> 01:58:42.849
TO ENFORCE CONSTITUTIONALLY
01:58:42.915 --> 01:58:45.585
PROTECTED ABORTION RIGHTS. THIS
01:58:45.651 --> 01:58:47.720
HAS ALLOWED ABORTION FANS TO GO
01:58:47.787 --> 01:58:48.621
INTO EFFECT IN TEXAS AND
01:58:48.688 --> 01:58:50.857
OKLAHOMA, SURPRISING MILLIONS OF
01:58:50.923 --> 01:58:52.258
AMERICANS OF FUNDAMENTAL
01:58:52.325 --> 01:58:54.060
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS, AND THE
01:58:54.126 --> 01:58:55.361
LEAGUE'S OPINIONS SUGGESTS THE
01:58:55.428 --> 01:58:57.029
EROSION OF RIGHTS MAY NOT STOP
01:58:57.096 --> 01:58:58.664
HERE. MANY OF THE HARD WON
01:58:58.731 --> 01:59:01.000
RIGHTS TO FALL INTO THE RIGHT TO
01:59:01.067 --> 01:59:01.767
PRIVACY, INCLUDING RIGHT RELATED
01:59:01.834 --> 01:59:03.035
TO THE USE OF CONTRACEPTION,
01:59:03.102 --> 01:59:03.936
SEXUAL INTIMACY, MARRIAGE
01:59:04.003 --> 01:59:06.372
EQUALITY ARE ALSO AT RISK.
01:59:06.439 --> 01:59:08.741
CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY HAS ROBUST
01:59:08.808 --> 01:59:10.309
STATUTORY PROTECTIONS FOR
01:59:10.376 --> 01:59:12.645
ABORTION. SDA 10 WILL SAFEGUARD
01:59:12.712 --> 01:59:14.247
THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE AN ABORTION
01:59:14.313 --> 01:59:15.281
OR USE CONTRACEPTION, REGARDLESS
01:59:15.348 --> 01:59:17.383
OF WHO'S IN POWER IN THE FUTURE.
01:59:17.450 --> 01:59:18.918
IT WILL ENSHRINE THESE RIGHTS IN
01:59:18.985 --> 01:59:20.152
THE CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION.
01:59:20.219 --> 01:59:22.121
EXPLICITLY IT WILL ENUMERATE
01:59:22.188 --> 01:59:24.223
THEM BY NAME FOR THE FIRST TIME
01:59:24.290 --> 01:59:25.758
, ENSURING THESE RIGHTS ARE
01:59:25.825 --> 01:59:26.392
CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED UNDER
01:59:26.459 --> 01:59:27.360
CALIFORNIA LAW FOR GENERATIONS
01:59:27.426 --> 01:59:31.230
TO COME. CAN ALSO UNDERSCORES
01:59:31.297 --> 01:59:32.598
HOW STATE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS
01:59:32.665 --> 01:59:34.100
TO PRIVACY EQUAL PROTECTION ARE
01:59:34.166 --> 01:59:35.735
TIED TO A PERSON'S REPRODUCTIVE
01:59:35.801 --> 01:59:38.504
FREEDOM IN SO DOING IT, ALONG
01:59:38.571 --> 01:59:39.539
WITH OTHER LEGISLATIVE EFFORTS
01:59:39.605 --> 01:59:41.507
BY THE BODY WILL HELP TO ENSURE
01:59:41.574 --> 01:59:42.909
THAT PEOPLE HAVE THE BASIC
01:59:42.975 --> 01:59:43.943
FREEDOM TO ACCESS TO
01:59:44.010 --> 01:59:45.511
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE AND THE
01:59:45.578 --> 01:59:46.846
LIBERTY AND EQUALITY TO MAKE
01:59:46.913 --> 01:59:48.414
THEIR OWN DECISIONS ABOUT IF AND
01:59:48.481 --> 01:59:49.515
WHEN TO GROW THEIR FAMILIES.
01:59:49.582 --> 01:59:53.686
THANK YOU SO MUCH. THANK YOU, MR
01:59:53.753 --> 01:59:55.588
FRANKLIN. ALL RIGHT, UM, JUST
01:59:55.655 --> 01:59:56.989
UNDER THE 10 MINUTE. MARK
01:59:57.056 --> 01:59:58.958
APPRECIATE THAT. NOW I SEE OF
01:59:59.025 --> 02:00:00.326
SOME GATHERED HERE IN THE
02:00:00.393 --> 02:00:01.861
HEARING ROOM 2100 IF YOU WOULD
02:00:01.928 --> 02:00:03.596
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE. STATE
02:00:03.663 --> 02:00:04.764
YOUR NAME YOUR AFFILIATION IN
02:00:04.830 --> 02:00:05.965
YOUR POSITION. THIS IS THE
02:00:06.032 --> 02:00:11.671
SUPPORT. FOR GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
02:00:11.737 --> 02:00:13.139
CHAIR AND MEMBERS LINDSEY GOLA
02:00:13.205 --> 02:00:14.607
HORN WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:00:14.674 --> 02:00:15.074
ASSOCIATION FOR NURSE
02:00:15.141 --> 02:00:15.975
PRACTITIONERS AND SUPPORT. THANK
02:00:16.042 --> 02:00:21.714
YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON ADRIANA
02:00:21.781 --> 02:00:22.848
CHAMPAGNE ZAMORA WITH THE LEAGUE
02:00:22.915 --> 02:00:24.617
OF WOMEN, VOTERS OF CALIFORNIA
02:00:24.684 --> 02:00:28.220
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:00:28.287 --> 02:00:30.289
MR TURN MEMBERS. I'M AARON EVANS
02:00:30.356 --> 02:00:32.725
ON BEHALF OF NARAL PRO CHOICE,
02:00:32.792 --> 02:00:33.859
CALIFORNIA, PROUD CO SPONSOR OF
02:00:33.926 --> 02:00:36.629
THIS MEASURE AND UM, STEERING
02:00:36.696 --> 02:00:38.097
COMMITTEE MEMBER OF THE FUTURE
02:00:38.164 --> 02:00:40.199
OF ABORTION COUNCIL. SECONDLY IN
02:00:40.266 --> 02:00:41.434
SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF THE
02:00:41.500 --> 02:00:43.135
CALIFORNIA NURSE MIDWIVES
02:00:43.202 --> 02:00:45.304
ASSOCIATION, ALSO A MEMBER OF
02:00:45.371 --> 02:00:46.472
THE FUTURE OF ABORTION COUNCIL.
02:00:46.539 --> 02:00:49.208
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AFTER THE
02:00:49.275 --> 02:00:50.142
INTERIM MEMBERS MOLLY ROBSON
02:00:50.209 --> 02:00:50.810
WITH PLANNED PARENTHOOD
02:00:50.876 --> 02:00:51.811
AFFILIATES OF CALIFORNIA WHERE
02:00:51.877 --> 02:00:53.012
CO SPONSORING STRONG SUPPORT.
02:00:53.079 --> 02:00:55.982
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD
02:00:56.048 --> 02:00:57.750
AFTERNOON GENESIS GONZALEZ ON
02:00:57.817 --> 02:00:59.118
BEHALF OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR,
02:00:59.185 --> 02:01:00.419
LENNY KALLAKIS AS A PROUD CO
02:01:00.486 --> 02:01:02.154
SPONSOR. AN URGENT IVO. THANK
02:01:02.221 --> 02:01:07.893
YOU. CINDY HILLARY ON BEHALF OF
02:01:07.960 --> 02:01:08.861
THE CALIFORNIA MEDICAL
02:01:08.928 --> 02:01:09.862
ASSOCIATION IN STRONG SUPPORT.
02:01:09.929 --> 02:01:14.333
THANK YOU. FRANK SPENCER ON
02:01:14.400 --> 02:01:15.801
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE
02:01:15.868 --> 02:01:16.936
OF OBGYN. WOMEN'S DISTRICT NINE
02:01:17.003 --> 02:01:22.908
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. HERE ON
02:01:22.975 --> 02:01:25.077
BEHALF OF ALL OF US ARE NOT IN
02:01:25.144 --> 02:01:29.115
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ALYSSA MORE
02:01:29.181 --> 02:01:31.851
BE HERE BEHALF OF ALL OF US, OR
02:01:31.917 --> 02:01:32.985
NONE AS WELL IN FULL SUPPORT.
02:01:33.052 --> 02:01:34.587
THANK YOU. ALRIGHT SEEING NO ONE
02:01:34.654 --> 02:01:37.590
ELSE IN ROOM 2100. LET'S TURN TO
02:01:37.657 --> 02:01:39.158
THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR, IF
02:01:39.225 --> 02:01:40.326
YOU WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN
02:01:40.393 --> 02:01:42.061
SUPPORT OF SCHNURR, THEY CAN
02:01:42.128 --> 02:01:43.095
PROVIDE THEIR NAME THEIR
02:01:43.162 --> 02:01:45.731
AFFILIATION IN THEIR POSITION.
02:01:45.798 --> 02:01:48.200
THANK YOU TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT,
02:01:48.267 --> 02:01:49.235
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO ON
02:01:49.301 --> 02:01:51.804
YOUR PHONE. AND WE WILL START
02:01:51.871 --> 02:01:56.208
WITH LINE 1 64, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:01:56.275 --> 02:01:57.309
TOMMY MARTIN ON BEHALF OF
02:01:57.376 --> 02:01:58.277
EQUALITY, CALIFORNIA AND
02:01:58.344 --> 02:02:02.581
SUPPORT. ACCUSED LINE 1 77,
02:02:02.648 --> 02:02:07.520
PLEASE GO AHEAD. K<c.cyan> VANGUARD</c>
02:02:07.586 --> 02:02:08.554
HEALTH ACCESS CALIFORNIA AND
02:02:08.621 --> 02:02:13.059
SUPPORT. THANK YOU FIND 1. 93,
02:02:13.125 --> 02:02:17.129
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GET UP IN THE
02:02:17.196 --> 02:02:18.764
CHAIR MEMBERS MARQUEE SEADRILL
02:02:18.831 --> 02:02:19.565
ON BEHALF OF THE LOST ANGELES
02:02:19.632 --> 02:02:20.633
COUNTY BOARD SUPERVISORS AND
02:02:20.700 --> 02:02:24.003
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:02:24.070 --> 02:02:29.208
LINE 1 86, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:02:29.275 --> 02:02:30.776
AFTERNOON, KATHY VAN AUSTIN ON
02:02:30.843 --> 02:02:31.644
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN
02:02:31.711 --> 02:02:33.512
ASSOCIATION OF UNIVERSITY,
02:02:33.579 --> 02:02:34.480
WOMEN, CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT.
02:02:34.547 --> 02:02:37.717
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, LYNN. 1
02:02:37.783 --> 02:02:42.254
91, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HIGH FLOOR
02:02:42.321 --> 02:02:43.856
HANDS ON BEHALF OF TEACHER
02:02:43.923 --> 02:02:44.557
TRAINING. EARLY ABORTIONS.
02:02:44.623 --> 02:02:46.225
COMPREHENSIVE HEALTHCARE, ALSO
02:02:46.292 --> 02:02:47.426
PART OF THE STEERING COMMITTEE
02:02:47.493 --> 02:02:48.527
OF THE FUTURE OF ABORTION,
02:02:48.594 --> 02:02:51.363
COUNSELING, SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:02:51.430 --> 02:02:52.598
THANK YOU LINE 1 68, PLEASE GO
02:02:52.665 --> 02:02:57.503
AHEAD. ON BEHALF OF THE
02:02:57.570 --> 02:02:58.604
CALIFORNIA ACTION IN SUPPORT.
02:02:58.671 --> 02:03:01.574
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LINE 1 66,
02:03:01.640 --> 02:03:06.712
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
02:03:06.779 --> 02:03:08.214
. SILVIA CASTILLO WITH ESSENTIAL
02:03:08.280 --> 02:03:09.882
ACCESS HEALTH, WHERE A PROUD
02:03:09.949 --> 02:03:12.184
POST SPONSOR AND FEATURE OF
02:03:12.251 --> 02:03:13.152
ABORTION COUNCIL STEERING
02:03:13.219 --> 02:03:14.086
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. THANK YOU.
02:03:14.153 --> 02:03:17.656
THANK YOU. IN LINE 1 99, PLEASE
02:03:17.723 --> 02:03:23.129
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
02:03:23.195 --> 02:03:24.897
SHARON MEMBERS, SONIA MUGICA WAS
02:03:24.964 --> 02:03:26.265
BLACK WOMEN FOR WELLNESS ACTION
02:03:26.332 --> 02:03:28.901
PROJECT PROBLEM MEMBER OF THE
02:03:28.968 --> 02:03:29.869
CALIFORNIA ABORTION COUNCIL
02:03:29.935 --> 02:03:30.636
STEERING COMMITTEE AND CO
02:03:30.703 --> 02:03:31.804
SPONSORS AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:03:31.871 --> 02:03:35.241
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU.
02:03:35.307 --> 02:03:39.879
LINE 1 84, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:03:39.945 --> 02:03:41.380
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS LEAH
02:03:41.447 --> 02:03:42.481
CHANDLER AND I'M CALLING ON
02:03:42.548 --> 02:03:44.917
BEHALF OF EQUAL RIGHTS ADVOCATES
02:03:44.984 --> 02:03:47.386
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:03:47.453 --> 02:03:51.991
IN LINE WHEN 62 PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:03:52.057 --> 02:03:53.125
GOOD AFTERNOON SHARING MEMBERS,
02:03:53.192 --> 02:03:54.260
MADELINE COOPER FROM NIELSEN
02:03:54.326 --> 02:03:55.628
MARKSMAN ON BEHALF OF THE COUNTY
02:03:55.694 --> 02:03:57.830
OF SAN DIEGO IN SUPPORT. THANK
02:03:57.897 --> 02:04:00.366
YOU. THANK YOU. TÌM 1 69, PLEASE
02:04:00.432 --> 02:04:04.570
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS
02:04:04.637 --> 02:04:06.138
IS CLAIRE LOOK SHELTER WITH THE
02:04:06.205 --> 02:04:08.107
NATIONAL COUNCIL OF JEWISH WOMEN
02:04:08.174 --> 02:04:09.308
, CALIFORNIA AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:04:09.375 --> 02:04:13.546
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
02:04:13.612 --> 02:04:15.714
IS ALL THAT I HAVE IN. Q THANK
02:04:15.781 --> 02:04:16.982
YOU, MADAM MODERATOR. NOW LET'S
02:04:17.049 --> 02:04:18.551
TURN TO THE OPPOSITION
02:04:18.617 --> 02:04:20.419
OPPOSITION. UM WE HAVE, MR
02:04:20.486 --> 02:04:23.856
DARNELL, MISS. UH, DOMINGO AND
02:04:23.923 --> 02:04:25.558
MISS BRADFORD. I BELIEVE ALL OF
02:04:25.624 --> 02:04:26.625
YOU ARE HERE IN THE HEARING
02:04:26.692 --> 02:04:28.227
ROOM. YOU'LL HAVE 10 MINUTES, SO
02:04:28.294 --> 02:04:29.428
I SEE MISS DARNELL AT THE
02:04:29.495 --> 02:04:31.297
MICROPHONE. GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS
02:04:31.363 --> 02:04:32.832
SUSAN ARNOLD. I'M IN A
02:04:32.898 --> 02:04:34.233
CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY AND THE VICE
02:04:34.300 --> 02:04:35.801
PRESIDENT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS FOR
02:04:35.868 --> 02:04:36.635
THE RIGHT TO LIFE LEAGUE,
02:04:36.702 --> 02:04:38.070
AMERICA'S FIRST PRO LIFE
02:04:38.137 --> 02:04:40.873
ORGANIZATION. WE REPRESENT 54
02:04:40.940 --> 02:04:41.473
PRO LIFE ORGANIZATIONS ACROSS
02:04:41.540 --> 02:04:42.575
THE STATE AND VOTERS ALL AROUND
02:04:42.641 --> 02:04:46.612
THE STATE. THE CALIFORNIA
02:04:46.679 --> 02:04:49.715
CONSTITUTION DECLARES THAT QUOTE
02:04:49.782 --> 02:04:52.918
A PERSON MAY NOT BE DEPRIVED OF
02:04:52.985 --> 02:04:56.088
LIFE WITHOUT DUE PROCESS OF LAW.
02:04:56.155 --> 02:05:00.593
OR EQUAL PROTECTION OF THE LAWS.
02:05:00.659 --> 02:05:02.161
10 THE ABORTION AMENDMENT
02:05:02.228 --> 02:05:04.363
DIRECTLY CONTRADICTS THOSE
02:05:04.430 --> 02:05:06.599
FUNDAMENTAL, INALIENABLE RIGHTS
02:05:06.665 --> 02:05:07.466
TO LIFE AND LIBERTY PROCLAIMED
02:05:07.533 --> 02:05:10.903
IN OUR STATE CONSTITUTION. THE
02:05:10.970 --> 02:05:12.304
ABORTION AMENDMENTS. DISORDERED
02:05:12.371 --> 02:05:14.039
APPROACH GRANTS A CONSTITUTIONAL
02:05:14.106 --> 02:05:16.942
RIGHT TO DESTROY ANOTHER LIFE BY
02:05:17.009 --> 02:05:19.545
PLACING A SUBORDINATE RIGHT THE
02:05:19.612 --> 02:05:21.313
RIGHT TO PRIVACY AHEAD OF AN
02:05:21.380 --> 02:05:22.314
INDIVIDUAL'S FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT
02:05:22.381 --> 02:05:25.751
TO EXIST. THIS IS A CIVIL RIGHTS
02:05:25.818 --> 02:05:27.219
VIOLATION OF MONUMENTAL
02:05:27.286 --> 02:05:29.722
PROPORTIONS. YOU ARE WEAPONIZING
02:05:29.788 --> 02:05:31.857
OUR CONSTITUTION TO STRIP AWAY
02:05:31.924 --> 02:05:33.425
THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF PEOPLE
02:05:33.492 --> 02:05:35.728
WHO CAN'T SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES.
02:05:35.794 --> 02:05:37.029
THE MOST VULNERABLE THE MOST
02:05:37.096 --> 02:05:41.100
UNDERSERVED THE UNBORN. GAS
02:05:41.166 --> 02:05:42.601
PRICES AND INFLATION ARE HITTING
02:05:42.668 --> 02:05:44.169
ALL TIME HIGHS INSTEAD OF
02:05:44.236 --> 02:05:46.272
HELPING STRUGGLING FAMILIES.
02:05:46.338 --> 02:05:48.874
CALIFORNIA WILL SPEND $125
02:05:48.941 --> 02:05:52.278
MILLION OF TAXPAYER MONEY. TO
02:05:52.344 --> 02:05:54.980
FUND THE ABORTION INDUSTRY. YOUR
02:05:55.047 --> 02:05:56.482
SPENDING POLICIES ARE LITERALLY
02:05:56.548 --> 02:05:58.117
FORCING MOTHERS TO MAKE
02:05:58.183 --> 02:05:59.718
DESPERATE CHOICES BETWEEN HAVING
02:05:59.785 --> 02:06:02.021
A BABY OR PAYING RENT. THE
02:06:02.087 --> 02:06:03.989
GUTTMACHER INSTITUTE RESEARCH
02:06:04.056 --> 02:06:07.059
SHOWS THAT APPROXIMATELY 75% OF
02:06:07.126 --> 02:06:09.061
ABORTIONS ARE OBTAINED BY WOMEN
02:06:09.128 --> 02:06:10.329
AT OR BELOW THE FEDERAL POVERTY
02:06:10.396 --> 02:06:11.931
LEVEL. THESE WOMEN ARE
02:06:11.997 --> 02:06:14.166
FINANCIALLY DESPERATE. THEY DO
02:06:14.233 --> 02:06:15.501
NOT WANT TO ABORT THEIR BABY.
02:06:15.567 --> 02:06:16.635
THEY FEEL LIKE THEY HAVE NO
02:06:16.702 --> 02:06:18.570
OTHER CHOICE. THIS ABORTION
02:06:18.637 --> 02:06:20.706
AMENDMENT WORKS TOGETHER WITH
02:06:20.773 --> 02:06:23.108
MANY OTHER BILLS TO EXCLUSIVELY
02:06:23.175 --> 02:06:25.210
FAVOR THE ABORTION INDUSTRY OVER
02:06:25.277 --> 02:06:26.245
OTHER LIFE, GIVING REPRODUCTIVE
02:06:26.312 --> 02:06:29.848
ALTERNATIVES. INSTEAD OF RAISING
02:06:29.915 --> 02:06:31.784
THE LEVEL OF MEDICAL CARE FOR
02:06:31.850 --> 02:06:33.218
WOMEN, YOU ARE SLASHING
02:06:33.285 --> 02:06:35.120
STANDARDIZED PROCEDURES AND
02:06:35.187 --> 02:06:37.222
PHYSICIAN OVERSIGHT FOR ABORTION
02:06:37.289 --> 02:06:40.259
. THAT'S SB 13 75 AND FAST
02:06:40.326 --> 02:06:40.826
TRACKING ABORTION LICENSES.
02:06:40.893 --> 02:06:44.763
THAT'S A B 6 57. INSTEAD OF
02:06:44.830 --> 02:06:46.732
RESPECTING OUR CONSTITUTION, YOU
02:06:46.799 --> 02:06:48.300
ARE CREATING A SAFE HAVEN FOR
02:06:48.367 --> 02:06:50.069
HUMAN TRAFFICKERS. THAT'S A B
02:06:50.135 --> 02:06:53.839
16, 66 AND 2091. INSTEAD OF
02:06:53.906 --> 02:06:56.241
PROTECTING BABIES BORN ALIVE,
02:06:56.308 --> 02:06:58.610
YOU ARE DECRIMINALIZING
02:06:58.677 --> 02:07:01.113
INFANTICIDE WITH A B 22 23
02:07:01.180 --> 02:07:04.216
INSTEAD OF FUNDING BABY FORMULA.
02:07:04.283 --> 02:07:06.251
YOU WERE FUNDING FREE ABORTION.
02:07:06.318 --> 02:07:07.453
SB 2 45, WHICH HAS ALREADY
02:07:07.519 --> 02:07:10.723
PASSED INSTEAD OF FUNDING
02:07:10.789 --> 02:07:13.158
HOUSING FOR HOMELESS MOTHERS.
02:07:13.225 --> 02:07:14.026
YOU ARE FUNDING ABORTION
02:07:14.093 --> 02:07:17.062
CLINICS. THAT'S A B 12 45.
02:07:17.129 --> 02:07:19.365
INSTEAD OF FUNDING ALL BIRTHING
02:07:19.431 --> 02:07:21.200
OPTIONS. YOU ARE FUNDING
02:07:21.266 --> 02:07:24.737
ABORTION TOURISM WITH SB 11 42.
02:07:24.803 --> 02:07:26.872
INSTEAD OF FUNDING MATERNAL CARE
02:07:26.939 --> 02:07:27.873
. YOU ARE FUNDING ABORTION
02:07:27.940 --> 02:07:31.210
SERVICES WITH A B 21 34. INSTEAD
02:07:31.276 --> 02:07:34.480
OF TAKING CARE OF MOTHERS. YOU
02:07:34.546 --> 02:07:36.382
ARE TAKING CARE OF THE ABORTION
02:07:36.448 --> 02:07:38.784
CARTEL AND USING OUR MONEY TO DO
02:07:38.851 --> 02:07:40.419
IT, AND INSTEAD OF FUNDING
02:07:40.486 --> 02:07:42.087
ADOPTION SERVICES, YOU ARE
02:07:42.154 --> 02:07:43.122
FUNDING ABORTION SCHOLARSHIPS
02:07:43.188 --> 02:07:47.226
WITH A B 1918. WITH AN ALMOST
02:07:47.292 --> 02:07:50.295
$100 BILLION STATE SURPLUS. IT
02:07:50.362 --> 02:07:52.231
IS TIME TO PROVIDE THE FINANCIAL
02:07:52.297 --> 02:07:53.832
RESOURCES THAT WOMEN NEED TO
02:07:53.899 --> 02:07:55.234
CHOOSE LIFE, NOT SIMPLY
02:07:55.300 --> 02:07:56.735
PROMOTING AGENDA, USING TEXT
02:07:56.802 --> 02:07:58.203
DOLLARS TO TRAMPLE THE CIVIL
02:07:58.270 --> 02:07:59.304
RIGHTS OF UNBORN CHILDREN. THANK
02:07:59.371 --> 02:08:08.480
YOU. MR. MINGLE? UM. YES GO
02:08:08.547 --> 02:08:09.748
AHEAD, GO AHEAD AND APPROACHED
02:08:09.815 --> 02:08:13.352
THE MICROPHONE. HELLO MY NAME IS
02:08:13.419 --> 02:08:14.420
KELLY BRADFORD. SORRY, MISS
02:08:14.486 --> 02:08:18.924
BRADFORD. I'M 43 YEARS OLD WAS
02:08:18.991 --> 02:08:20.893
BORN AND RAISED IN SAN FRANCISCO
02:08:20.959 --> 02:08:22.194
AND I HAVE BEEN IN SACRAMENTO
02:08:22.261 --> 02:08:24.329
FOR THE PAST 18 YEARS. I AM
02:08:24.396 --> 02:08:26.432
BLESSED TO BE THE MOTHER OF TWO
02:08:26.498 --> 02:08:27.866
DAUGHTERS AFTER EXPERIENCING
02:08:27.933 --> 02:08:28.901
FIVE ABORTIONS, STARTING FROM
02:08:28.967 --> 02:08:30.903
THE AGE OF 15 TO 28 YEARS OF
02:08:30.969 --> 02:08:32.938
AGE. I FIRST LEARNED OF
02:08:33.005 --> 02:08:34.173
ABORTIONS THROUGH SCHOOL AND
02:08:34.239 --> 02:08:35.274
FRIENDS. I WAS ABLE TO SEE A
02:08:35.340 --> 02:08:37.876
DOCTOR ON MY OWN. WITHOUT MY
02:08:37.943 --> 02:08:38.877
PARENTS' CONSENT OR KNOWLEDGE.
02:08:38.944 --> 02:08:39.878
AND SCHEDULE AN ABORTION
02:08:39.945 --> 02:08:43.782
PROCEDURE. IT WAS EASY TO DO
02:08:43.849 --> 02:08:45.017
WITHOUT GETTING ANYONE INVOLVED
02:08:45.084 --> 02:08:46.185
AND BECAME A METHOD OF BIRTH
02:08:46.251 --> 02:08:48.620
CONTROL AFTER THE SECOND TIME. I
02:08:48.687 --> 02:08:49.988
KNOW OTHER WOMEN THAT HAVE
02:08:50.055 --> 02:08:52.357
GOTTEN 7 10 OR EVEN MORE
02:08:52.424 --> 02:08:53.492
ABORTIONS IN THEIR LIFETIME AND
02:08:53.559 --> 02:08:54.393
SOME NO LONGER ABLE TO HAVE
02:08:54.460 --> 02:08:58.063
CHILDREN. UNFORTUNATELY IT IS
02:08:58.130 --> 02:08:59.498
MORE COMMON IN THE MINORITY
02:08:59.565 --> 02:09:01.266
COMMUNITY, AS MANY OF US ARE
02:09:01.333 --> 02:09:03.569
BEING RAISED BY SINGLE MOTHERS.
02:09:03.635 --> 02:09:05.237
I REMEMBER WANTING TO HAVE THE
02:09:05.304 --> 02:09:07.005
CHILD AND BECOME A MOTHER. BUT
02:09:07.072 --> 02:09:08.340
BEING TOLD BY MY BOYFRIEND THAT
02:09:08.407 --> 02:09:10.442
IT WASN'T A GOOD TIME OR THAT
02:09:10.509 --> 02:09:12.344
WAS JUST TOO YOUNG BY MY OWN
02:09:12.411 --> 02:09:14.246
FAMILY. SO WHETHER OR NOT I
02:09:14.313 --> 02:09:15.948
WANTED TO GO FORWARD WITH IT, I
02:09:16.014 --> 02:09:18.150
FELT PUSHED AND OBLIGATED TO GET
02:09:18.217 --> 02:09:19.885
THE ABORTION BECAUSE I DIDN'T
02:09:19.952 --> 02:09:21.086
HAVE ANY SUPPORT. BEING FACED
02:09:21.153 --> 02:09:22.521
WITH AN UNPLANNED PREGNANCY. IS
02:09:22.588 --> 02:09:26.892
TERRIFYING. SO WHEN YOU GO AND
02:09:26.959 --> 02:09:28.894
SPEAK WITH AN ABORTION COUNSELOR
02:09:28.961 --> 02:09:31.763
THEY SELL IT TO YOU AS A WAY TO
02:09:31.830 --> 02:09:33.098
GET YOUR LIFE BACK TO NORMAL.
02:09:33.165 --> 02:09:34.566
THEY RARELY EVEN DISCUSSED THE
02:09:34.633 --> 02:09:37.136
NEGATIVE EFFECTS THAT IT HAS ON
02:09:37.202 --> 02:09:37.636
YOUR LIFE, LET ALONE THE
02:09:37.703 --> 02:09:38.237
COMPLICATIONS THAT CAN GO ON
02:09:38.303 --> 02:09:41.206
DURING THE PROCESS. YOU ARE MADE
02:09:41.273 --> 02:09:43.108
TO QUICKLY READ POTENTIAL SIDE
02:09:43.175 --> 02:09:45.010
EFFECTS ON A PIECE OF PAPER AND
02:09:45.077 --> 02:09:48.947
SIGN IT. I WAS TOLD THAT MY
02:09:49.014 --> 02:09:50.883
UNBORN BABY WAS A FETUS AND NOT
02:09:50.949 --> 02:09:52.584
ACTUALLY A LIFE. ALSO HE OR SHE
02:09:52.651 --> 02:09:54.119
WOULDN'T BE HURT BY THE ABORTION
02:09:54.186 --> 02:09:55.721
. I WAS LIED TO REGARDING WHAT
02:09:55.787 --> 02:09:57.656
ABORTION REALLY IS, AS ARE SO
02:09:57.723 --> 02:10:00.092
MANY PEOPLE ALL OVER CALIFORNIA.
02:10:00.159 --> 02:10:02.127
LEGISLATORS IN THIS ROOM ARE
02:10:02.194 --> 02:10:03.228
CONTINUING TO TELL THOSE LIES
02:10:03.295 --> 02:10:05.797
EVEN TODAY. DURING THE PANDEMIC.
02:10:05.864 --> 02:10:06.398
I HEARD A TESTIMONIAL FROM A
02:10:06.465 --> 02:10:07.533
FORMER ABORTION DOCTOR THAT
02:10:07.599 --> 02:10:10.569
SHOCKED ME. THIS ABORTIONIST
02:10:10.636 --> 02:10:11.970
EXPLAINED TO ME FOR THE FIRST
02:10:12.037 --> 02:10:13.105
TIME WHAT ABORTION WAS REALLY
02:10:13.172 --> 02:10:15.741
LIKE. THE UNBORN BABY IS NOT
02:10:15.807 --> 02:10:17.576
JUST VACUUMED OUT AS WE ARE
02:10:17.643 --> 02:10:18.844
TOLD, BUT SOMETIMES IT JUST
02:10:18.911 --> 02:10:21.013
PULLED OUT IN PIECES BY LIMBS
02:10:21.079 --> 02:10:22.181
AND BODY PARTS AND SOMETIMES
02:10:22.247 --> 02:10:22.781
STILL ALIVE. I WAS ABSOLUTELY
02:10:22.848 --> 02:10:27.486
REPULSED. HERE IN CALIFORNIA HAS
02:10:27.553 --> 02:10:29.087
BEEN MADE SO EASY AND COMMON
02:10:29.154 --> 02:10:30.622
PRACTICE TO GO OUT AND GET AN
02:10:30.689 --> 02:10:31.523
ABORTION THROUGH PLANNED
02:10:31.590 --> 02:10:32.991
PARENTHOOD. THAT WOMAN, MANY
02:10:33.058 --> 02:10:34.560
WOMEN DON'T EVEN KNOW WHERE TO
02:10:34.626 --> 02:10:36.595
GO TO GET SUPPORT IF THEY WANT
02:10:36.662 --> 02:10:38.730
TO HAVE THEIR BABY. MOST OF THE
02:10:38.797 --> 02:10:39.898
WOMEN GOING INTO AN ABORTION
02:10:39.965 --> 02:10:41.366
CLINIC TODAY ARE MINORITIES,
02:10:41.433 --> 02:10:42.401
YOUNG, AFRAID AND DON'T KNOW
02:10:42.467 --> 02:10:45.604
WHAT TO DO. IF THEY DON'T WANT
02:10:45.671 --> 02:10:46.872
TO GET AN ABORTION. THEY WALK
02:10:46.939 --> 02:10:48.106
THROUGH THOSE DOORS. THEY'RE
02:10:48.173 --> 02:10:49.208
TURNED AWAY WITHOUT ANY
02:10:49.274 --> 02:10:49.875
INFORMATION OR SUPPORT AVAILABLE
02:10:49.942 --> 02:10:52.211
TO THEM. IT'S LIKE THEY DON'T
02:10:52.277 --> 02:10:57.382
EVEN CARE. GOD THANK GOD. THERE
02:10:57.449 --> 02:10:58.784
ARE PEOPLE OUT ON THE SIDEWALK
02:10:58.850 --> 02:11:00.986
THERE THAT DIRECT THEM TO A
02:11:01.053 --> 02:11:02.120
LOCAL PREGNANCY PRO LIFE CARE
02:11:02.187 --> 02:11:03.956
CENTER. WHERE THEY CAN BE
02:11:04.022 --> 02:11:06.425
SUPPORTED AND TAUGHT HOW TO LOVE
02:11:06.491 --> 02:11:08.227
THROUGH GOING THEIR FAMILIES AND
02:11:08.293 --> 02:11:11.463
NOT DESTROY THEM. PUTTING THE
02:11:11.530 --> 02:11:12.564
RIGHT TO AN ABORTION INTO THE
02:11:12.631 --> 02:11:14.900
STATE CONSTITUTION IS NOT GOING
02:11:14.967 --> 02:11:16.068
TO HELP THE MINORITY COMMUNITY
02:11:16.134 --> 02:11:16.635
WHATSOEVER. ABORTION IS NOT
02:11:16.702 --> 02:11:20.939
HEALTH CARE. IT HAS LEFT ME AND
02:11:21.006 --> 02:11:22.241
MILLIONS OF WOMEN BROKEN,
02:11:22.307 --> 02:11:23.942
REGRETFUL, ASHAMED, DEPRESSED
02:11:24.009 --> 02:11:27.379
AND SOME EVEN SUICIDAL. IT'S A
02:11:27.446 --> 02:11:28.413
TEMPORARY SOLUTION TO A MUCH
02:11:28.480 --> 02:11:31.483
DEEPER PROBLEM. YOU WERE LYING
02:11:31.550 --> 02:11:33.885
TO PEOPLE WHEN YOU HOLD ABORTION
02:11:33.952 --> 02:11:35.754
OUT AS AN EASY ANSWER TO A
02:11:35.821 --> 02:11:37.055
COMPLEX PROBLEM. ABORTION IS
02:11:37.122 --> 02:11:40.959
DEVASTATING PEOPLE'S LIVES. CHN
02:11:41.026 --> 02:11:42.561
IS GOING TO MAKE THE PROBLEM.
02:11:42.628 --> 02:11:45.464
EVEN WORSE. THANK YOU. ALRIGHT
02:11:45.530 --> 02:11:47.199
UM, NEXT, MISS DOMINGO, MISS
02:11:47.266 --> 02:11:50.736
DOMINGOS PRESENT. THANK YOU.
02:11:50.802 --> 02:11:52.271
GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
02:11:52.337 --> 02:11:54.206
KATHLEEN DOMINGO I'M, THE
02:11:54.273 --> 02:11:55.207
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR THE
02:11:55.274 --> 02:11:56.608
CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE.
02:11:56.675 --> 02:11:57.643
THE CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC
02:11:57.709 --> 02:11:59.611
CONFERENCE VEHEMENTLY OPPOSES
02:11:59.678 --> 02:12:01.113
SENATE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
02:12:01.179 --> 02:12:02.881
10, WHICH LOOKS TO ENSHRINE THE
02:12:02.948 --> 02:12:03.849
MOST EXTREME FORMS OF ABORTION
02:12:03.915 --> 02:12:04.816
INTO THE CALIFORNIA
02:12:04.883 --> 02:12:07.552
CONSTITUTION. WE BELIEVE IN
02:12:07.619 --> 02:12:09.421
PROTECTING LIFE AND EVERY AGE
02:12:09.488 --> 02:12:10.689
AND EVERY STAGE INCLUDING UNBORN
02:12:10.756 --> 02:12:13.358
HUMAN LIFE. WE ARE EXTREMELY
02:12:13.425 --> 02:12:15.494
TROUBLED BY THE LANGUAGE OF CHN
02:12:15.560 --> 02:12:17.863
, WHICH IS SO BROAD AND
02:12:17.929 --> 02:12:18.664
UNRESTRICTED THAT IT WOULD
02:12:18.730 --> 02:12:20.098
ENCOURAGE AND PROTECT EVEN LATE
02:12:20.165 --> 02:12:20.766
TERM ABORTIONS, WHICH MOST
02:12:20.832 --> 02:12:23.969
CALIFORNIANS CONTINUE TO OPPOSE.
02:12:24.036 --> 02:12:26.371
WE ALSO FEAR THE BOUNDLESS SCOPE
02:12:26.438 --> 02:12:27.906
OF THIS PROPOSED AMENDMENT,
02:12:27.973 --> 02:12:28.807
WHICH ASSERTS A NEW
02:12:28.874 --> 02:12:30.142
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO
02:12:30.208 --> 02:12:31.510
REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM, BUT NOT
02:12:31.576 --> 02:12:34.713
DOES NOT DEFINE WHAT THAT MEANS.
02:12:34.780 --> 02:12:35.981
THIS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT,
02:12:36.048 --> 02:12:37.482
AS WRITTEN, WILL LEGALIZE AND
02:12:37.549 --> 02:12:39.251
PROTECT ABORTION UP TO THE POINT
02:12:39.318 --> 02:12:41.520
JUST PRIOR TO DELIVERY. IT IS
02:12:41.586 --> 02:12:43.121
DISTRESSING THAT SO MANY
02:12:43.188 --> 02:12:44.489
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATORS WOULD
02:12:44.556 --> 02:12:46.124
SIGN THEIR NAMES TO LEGISLATION
02:12:46.191 --> 02:12:47.192
THAT ALLOWS THE TAKING OF A
02:12:47.259 --> 02:12:50.095
HUMAN LIFE MOMENTS BEFORE BIRTH.
02:12:50.162 --> 02:12:51.463
IN THIS REGARD. SCHNUR MORE
02:12:51.530 --> 02:12:53.832
CLOSELY ALIGNED CALIFORNIA WITH
02:12:53.899 --> 02:12:55.600
EXTREME ABORTION POLICIES OF
02:12:55.667 --> 02:12:57.269
ONLY A FEW COUNTRIES, RATHER
02:12:57.336 --> 02:12:59.838
THAN THOSE OF THE MAJORITY OF
02:12:59.905 --> 02:13:00.839
WESTERN DEMOCRACIES, WHICH DO
02:13:00.906 --> 02:13:02.040
NOT ALLOW LATE TERM ABORTIONS.
02:13:02.107 --> 02:13:05.977
SCHNUR UNNECESSARY. THE SAD
02:13:06.044 --> 02:13:07.512
REALITY IS THAT CALIFORNIA
02:13:07.579 --> 02:13:09.014
ALREADY HAS SOME OF THE MOST
02:13:09.081 --> 02:13:10.248
ACCOMMODATING ABORTION LAWS AND
02:13:10.315 --> 02:13:12.851
SERVICES IN THE NATION. ALREADY
02:13:12.918 --> 02:13:14.353
IN CALIFORNIA. THE REPRODUCTIVE
02:13:14.419 --> 02:13:15.954
PRIVACY ACT DECLARES THE
02:13:16.021 --> 02:13:17.356
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO CHOOSE TO
02:13:17.422 --> 02:13:18.623
BEAR A CHILD OR CHOOSE AND
02:13:18.690 --> 02:13:20.592
OBTAIN AN ABORTION. THERE IS NO
02:13:20.659 --> 02:13:22.361
LACK OF ABORTION ACCESS IN
02:13:22.427 --> 02:13:24.496
CALIFORNIA. THE STATE ALREADY
02:13:24.563 --> 02:13:26.498
FUNDS THROUGH FUNDS ABORTION
02:13:26.565 --> 02:13:27.532
THROUGH TAX DOLLARS WITH OVER
02:13:27.599 --> 02:13:29.501
400 FACILITIES, PERFORMING
02:13:29.568 --> 02:13:31.470
ABORTION AND ABORTION OFFERED BY
02:13:31.536 --> 02:13:32.471
NURSE PRACTITIONERS. NURSE
02:13:32.537 --> 02:13:34.373
MIDWIVES PHYSICIAN ASSISTANCE.
02:13:34.439 --> 02:13:35.907
VIA TELEHEALTH ON COLLEGE
02:13:35.974 --> 02:13:37.008
CAMPUSES AND THROUGH A DOZEN
02:13:37.075 --> 02:13:40.812
SOURCES BY MAIL. S C. A 10 IS
02:13:40.879 --> 02:13:43.115
DANGEROUS. THE VAGUE LANGUAGE
02:13:43.181 --> 02:13:44.216
CREATES A CONSTITUTIONALLY
02:13:44.282 --> 02:13:45.317
PROTECTED RIGHT THAT IS NOT
02:13:45.384 --> 02:13:48.420
ADEQUATELY DEFINED. MOST
02:13:48.487 --> 02:13:49.721
CALIFORNIANS SUPPORT COMMON
02:13:49.788 --> 02:13:51.990
SENSE LIMITS ON ABORTION, NOT
02:13:52.057 --> 02:13:53.592
THE OPEN ENDED CREATION OF A NEW
02:13:53.658 --> 02:13:55.127
RIGHT WITHOUT ANY OVERSIGHT OR
02:13:55.193 --> 02:13:56.962
LIMITS FOR MINORS OR FOR
02:13:57.028 --> 02:14:00.465
GESTATIONAL AGE OF THE FETUS. BY
02:14:00.532 --> 02:14:02.033
PROVIDING EXTENSIVE FUNDING FOR
02:14:02.100 --> 02:14:03.568
ABORTION SERVICES WITHOUT ANY
02:14:03.635 --> 02:14:05.504
CORRESPONDING EQUITABLE FUNDING
02:14:05.570 --> 02:14:07.205
FOR PREGNANT WOMEN AND MOTHERS.
02:14:07.272 --> 02:14:08.540
THE STATE EXERCISES A
02:14:08.607 --> 02:14:09.775
DESTRUCTIVE, COERCIVE POWER IN
02:14:09.841 --> 02:14:13.111
FAVOR OF ENDING INNOCENT LIVES.
02:14:13.178 --> 02:14:14.246
ENSHRINING THIS AMENDMENT
02:14:14.312 --> 02:14:15.814
LANGUAGE INTO THE CONSTITUTION
02:14:15.881 --> 02:14:17.249
WILL EXTEND THE DANGER OF
02:14:17.315 --> 02:14:18.483
COERCIVE ABORTION. TWO BABIES
02:14:18.550 --> 02:14:22.154
WITH UNQUESTIONED VIABILITY. THE
02:14:22.220 --> 02:14:23.288
CALIFORNIA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE
02:14:23.355 --> 02:14:26.224
IS ACTIVELY OPPOSING SB 8 10 AND
02:14:26.291 --> 02:14:27.726
IS INSTEAD LOOKING TO PARTNER
02:14:27.793 --> 02:14:29.494
WITH PEOPLE OF FAITH AND
02:14:29.561 --> 02:14:30.395
GOODWILL WHO SUPPORT WOMEN,
02:14:30.462 --> 02:14:33.131
CHILDREN AND FAMILIES. WE WORK
02:14:33.198 --> 02:14:34.666
TO EXPAND PAID FAMILY LEAVE
02:14:34.733 --> 02:14:36.368
PRIORITY HOUSING FOR PREGNANT
02:14:36.435 --> 02:14:38.236
AND PARENTING, WOMEN, WORKPLACE
02:14:38.303 --> 02:14:39.738
ACCOMMODATIONS AND OTHER SAFETY
02:14:39.805 --> 02:14:41.540
NET SERVICES THAT ALLOW OUR MOST
02:14:41.606 --> 02:14:43.842
VULNERABLE CALIFORNIA PARENTS.
02:14:43.909 --> 02:14:45.377
TO SUCCESSFULLY RAISED CHILDREN
02:14:45.444 --> 02:14:48.013
IN CALIFORNIA WITHOUT FEELING
02:14:48.079 --> 02:14:49.114
PRESSURED INTO CHOOSING ABORTION
02:14:49.181 --> 02:14:50.615
AS THEIR ONLY OPTION. PLEASE
02:14:50.682 --> 02:14:52.651
VOTE NO ON C A 10. ALRIGHTY.
02:14:52.717 --> 02:14:56.588
THANK YOU, MR MINGO. ALRIGHT. UH
02:14:56.655 --> 02:14:58.089
NOW WE'LL TAKE OTHERS IN
02:14:58.156 --> 02:14:59.591
OPPOSITION WHO ARE PRESENT IN
02:14:59.658 --> 02:15:02.194
ROOM. 2100 APPROACHED THE
02:15:02.260 --> 02:15:03.228
MICROPHONE. PROVIDE YOUR NAME
02:15:03.295 --> 02:15:05.130
YOUR AFFILIATION IN YOUR
02:15:05.197 --> 02:15:06.331
POSITION. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY
02:15:06.398 --> 02:15:08.133
NAME IS HARRISON. I'M HERE ON
02:15:08.200 --> 02:15:10.135
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN COUNCIL
02:15:10.202 --> 02:15:11.436
AND WE ARE IN OPPOSITION TO SEE
02:15:11.503 --> 02:15:14.105
A 10. THANK YOU. GREG, BUT WITH
02:15:14.172 --> 02:15:15.440
THE CALIFORNIA FAMILY COUNSELING
02:15:15.507 --> 02:15:20.879
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. LEANDRA
02:15:20.946 --> 02:15:21.913
LEFT WITH CALIFORNIA FAMILY
02:15:21.980 --> 02:15:23.014
COUNCIL. I OPPOSE THIS BILL.
02:15:23.081 --> 02:15:27.319
THANK YOU. CARE MUELLER AND I
02:15:27.385 --> 02:15:29.087
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK
02:15:29.154 --> 02:15:31.723
YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS MILTON
02:15:31.790 --> 02:15:32.891
MATT CHECK REPRESENTING PACIFIC
02:15:32.958 --> 02:15:33.925
JUSTICE INSTITUTE CENTER FOR
02:15:33.992 --> 02:15:35.760
PUBLIC POLICY. AND WE OPPOSE
02:15:35.827 --> 02:15:38.630
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. AH! LET'S
02:15:38.697 --> 02:15:41.867
TURN NOW TO THE PHONES. MATTER
02:15:41.933 --> 02:15:43.935
IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN
02:15:44.002 --> 02:15:46.872
OPPOSITION TO SEE A 10. TO THE
02:15:46.938 --> 02:15:48.473
BIGGEST STATE, THEIR NAME THEIR
02:15:48.540 --> 02:15:51.843
AFFILIATION IN THEIR POSITION.
02:15:51.910 --> 02:15:54.012
THANK YOU TO SPEAKING OF
02:15:54.079 --> 02:15:55.080
POSITION, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
02:15:55.146 --> 02:15:58.350
ZERO. AND WE'LL START WITH LINE.
02:15:58.416 --> 02:16:06.725
2 12, PLEASE GO AHEAD. I'M SORRY
02:16:06.791 --> 02:16:08.760
THEY REMOVED THEMSELVES TO 12.
02:16:08.827 --> 02:16:09.928
IF YOU STILL WISH TO SPEAK,
02:16:09.995 --> 02:16:12.097
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO AGAIN.
02:16:12.163 --> 02:16:14.032
WE'LL GO TO LINE 205, PLEASE GO
02:16:14.099 --> 02:16:17.569
AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS HOCA
02:16:17.636 --> 02:16:19.437
VETTORI'S I'M A STUDENT AT UC
02:16:19.504 --> 02:16:21.940
BERKELEY. AND I'M ALSO PART OF
02:16:22.007 --> 02:16:23.041
PRO LIFE. SAN FRANCISCO AND I
02:16:23.108 --> 02:16:26.044
OPPOSED THE BILL. THANK YOU.
02:16:26.111 --> 02:16:28.046
NEXT WAY OF LINE TO 11. PLEASE
02:16:28.113 --> 02:16:31.016
GO AHEAD. PENNY HARRINGTON FROM
02:16:31.082 --> 02:16:35.220
SANYO COUNTY STRONGLY OPPOSED.
02:16:35.287 --> 02:16:36.521
THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE LINED 1
02:16:36.588 --> 02:16:39.858
98, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
02:16:39.925 --> 02:16:41.026
TONY ROBLES WITH CAPITAL
02:16:41.092 --> 02:16:41.993
RESOURCE INSTITUTE IN
02:16:42.060 --> 02:16:45.997
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU NEXT YEAR
02:16:46.064 --> 02:16:48.733
OF LINE. 204, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:16:48.800 --> 02:16:50.001
GOOD AFTERNOON JENELLE UPON A
02:16:50.068 --> 02:16:51.736
MOTHER OF THREE IN STRONG
02:16:51.803 --> 02:16:55.273
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU TWO. OH,
02:16:55.340 --> 02:16:59.277
ONE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS
02:16:59.344 --> 02:17:00.412
ROBERT BYRD DISTRICT 11
02:17:00.478 --> 02:17:03.582
RESIDENTS. AND ORGANIZER WITH
02:17:03.648 --> 02:17:04.983
PRO LIFE SAN FRANCISCO AND I
02:17:05.050 --> 02:17:09.220
URGE YOU TO VOTE NO. ON SCHNUR.
02:17:09.287 --> 02:17:10.522
THANK YOU. NEXT WAVE LINE TO 15.
02:17:10.589 --> 02:17:13.992
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY NAME IS
02:17:14.059 --> 02:17:15.594
RAQUEL HOGAN FROM OVERSIGHT
02:17:15.660 --> 02:17:17.529
COUNTY. I REPRESENT CATHOLIC
02:17:17.596 --> 02:17:18.530
FAMILIES FOR FREEDOM AND WE
02:17:18.597 --> 02:17:22.100
STRONGLY OPPOSE. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:17:22.167 --> 02:17:23.935
WAVE LINE TO 17. PLEASE GO
02:17:24.002 --> 02:17:26.071
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. I'M
02:17:26.137 --> 02:17:30.542
SORRY. I'M IN SUPPORT. UM I'M
02:17:30.609 --> 02:17:31.843
FROM THE NATIONALS ASSOCIATION
02:17:31.910 --> 02:17:33.478
OF SOCIAL WORKERS. CALIFORNIA
02:17:33.545 --> 02:17:34.746
CHAPTER DILLONLIAM SHAPE AND WE
02:17:34.813 --> 02:17:35.847
STRONGLY UPPORT THIS BILL.
02:17:35.914 --> 02:17:41.152
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANKS FOR
02:17:41.219 --> 02:17:42.320
YOUR BLANK TO 14. PLEASE GO
02:17:42.387 --> 02:17:55.900
AHEAD. 23-14. GO AHEAD. MY NAME
02:17:55.967 --> 02:18:01.706
IS BONNIE WENT SLOW. I AM TIRED
02:18:01.773 --> 02:18:02.874
. RN 50 PLUS YEARS IN THE
02:18:02.941 --> 02:18:06.411
MEDICINE FIELD. AND I STRONGLY
02:18:06.478 --> 02:18:08.246
OPPOSED THE BILL FOR MEDICAL
02:18:08.313 --> 02:18:12.384
REASONS. 24 THANK YOU VERY MUCH
02:18:12.450 --> 02:18:14.252
. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE LINED
02:18:14.319 --> 02:18:19.824
TO SEVEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY
02:18:19.891 --> 02:18:21.826
NAME IS WILL CHRIS BORGHESE? I'M
02:18:21.893 --> 02:18:23.094
WITH PELLETS. SAN FRANCISCO AND
02:18:23.161 --> 02:18:25.363
I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS FILM.
02:18:25.430 --> 02:18:27.298
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT WAY
02:18:27.365 --> 02:18:30.001
OF LINE TO 20. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:18:30.068 --> 02:18:32.437
HELLO MY NAME IS MARSHALL A
02:18:32.504 --> 02:18:34.506
BUTLER, MY BRAND NEW MOTHER OF
02:18:34.572 --> 02:18:35.607
ONE AND FROM OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA
02:18:35.674 --> 02:18:36.574
AND I'M AFFILIATED WITH
02:18:36.641 --> 02:18:38.476
FRANCISCO FOR LIFE AND I OPPOSE
02:18:38.543 --> 02:18:40.879
THIS BILL. THAN YOU. THANK YOU
02:18:40.945 --> 02:18:42.914
. WE HAVE LINE TO 10. PLEASE GO
02:18:42.981 --> 02:18:46.351
AHEAD. YES MY NAME IS TERESA
02:18:46.418 --> 02:18:48.720
BRENNAN. AND I'M THE PRESIDENT
02:18:48.787 --> 02:18:49.521
AND EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
02:18:49.587 --> 02:18:51.923
RIGHT TO LIFE SLEEK AND WE
02:18:51.990 --> 02:18:54.259
STRONGLY OPPOSED THIS AMENDMENT.
02:18:54.325 --> 02:18:55.927
THANK YOU. THANKS FOR EVELYN 1.
02:18:55.994 --> 02:19:00.231
60, PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES. MY
02:19:00.298 --> 02:19:01.533
NAME IS LINDA FLEMING. I'M WITH
02:19:01.599 --> 02:19:03.835
ANGLICANS FOR LIFE, AND I
02:19:03.902 --> 02:19:04.302
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS.
02:19:04.369 --> 02:19:07.972
LEGISLATION. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:19:08.039 --> 02:19:12.410
LINE TO 24. PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY
02:19:12.477 --> 02:19:13.645
NAME IS EILEEN O'NEAL WITH 40
02:19:13.712 --> 02:19:15.847
DAYS FOR LIFE. FROM DANVILLE,
02:19:15.914 --> 02:19:20.585
CALIFORNIA. I STRONGLY OPPOSED.
02:19:20.652 --> 02:19:21.853
THANK YOU. AND THAT IS ALL THAT
02:19:21.920 --> 02:19:33.498
I HAVE IN QUÊ. ONE MOMENT LINE.
02:19:33.565 --> 02:19:36.501
202 PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES THANK
02:19:36.568 --> 02:19:38.603
YOU. MY NAME IS PRESIDENT TURNER
02:19:38.670 --> 02:19:39.571
. I'M THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF
02:19:39.637 --> 02:19:40.772
BULLETIN FRANCISCO. I'M A
02:19:40.839 --> 02:19:42.107
LIFELONG CALIFORNIA AND I'M AN
02:19:42.173 --> 02:19:44.342
ATHEIST FEMINIST. AND I STRONGLY
02:19:44.409 --> 02:19:50.381
OPPOSED FDA TAN THANK YOU. AND
02:19:50.448 --> 02:19:52.550
THAT IS NOW THE LAST I HAD IN. Q
02:19:52.617 --> 02:19:54.119
ALRIGHT, MODERATE. CAN YOU DO
02:19:54.185 --> 02:19:55.653
ONE LAST CHECK AND THEN WE'LL
02:19:55.720 --> 02:19:56.921
CLOSE OUT THE OPPOSITION COMMENT
02:19:56.988 --> 02:20:00.925
TELEPHONICALLY. THANK YOU,
02:20:00.992 --> 02:20:01.693
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, ONCE AGAIN
02:20:01.760 --> 02:20:03.595
IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN
02:20:03.661 --> 02:20:05.497
OPPOSITION, PLEASE PRESS 10 ON
02:20:05.563 --> 02:20:12.337
YOUR PHONE. ALL RIGHT MOMENT
02:20:12.403 --> 02:20:29.687
WHILE WE GET THE LINE NUMBER.
02:20:29.754 --> 02:20:30.822
MADAM MORODER. IS THERE ANYBODY
02:20:30.889 --> 02:20:34.592
ELSE ON THE LINE? I HAVE THREE
02:20:34.659 --> 02:20:36.461
ON THE LINE HERE VERSUS LINE TO
02:20:36.528 --> 02:20:42.267
25. PLEASE GO AHEAD. PLANE TO
02:20:42.333 --> 02:20:49.140
20. 9 TO 25. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:20:49.207 --> 02:20:52.277
HELLO. MY NAME IS DAPHNE HEWITT.%
02:20:52.343 --> 02:20:53.878
I'M A RESIDENT OF CALIFORNIA AND
02:20:53.945 --> 02:20:55.046
I REPRESENT CATHOLIC FAMILIES
02:20:55.113 --> 02:20:57.215
FOR FREEDOM, CALIFORNIA AND I
02:20:57.282 --> 02:21:01.352
STRONGLY OPPOSED THIS BILL.
02:21:01.419 --> 02:21:03.121
THANK YOU. NEXT WAVE LINE TO 26.
02:21:03.188 --> 02:21:07.992
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
02:21:08.059 --> 02:21:09.727
IS SHERRY FOSTER BERRY. I'M A
02:21:09.794 --> 02:21:11.663
CATHOLIC AND A MOTHER AND I
02:21:11.729 --> 02:21:14.566
STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK
02:21:14.632 --> 02:21:16.501
YOU. NEXT WE HAVE LINE 1 85,
02:21:16.568 --> 02:21:19.337
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME
02:21:19.404 --> 02:21:21.606
IS TRICIA AB ANNOUNCING A. I'M
02:21:21.673 --> 02:21:24.475
WITH CORONA. RACHEL, OUR LOVE
02:21:24.542 --> 02:21:26.744
LIFE I WAS WITH RIGHT TO LIFE IN
02:21:26.811 --> 02:21:28.513
THE EIGHTIES AND I STRONGLY
02:21:28.580 --> 02:21:29.581
OPPOSE THIS BILL. IT WILL
02:21:29.647 --> 02:21:33.718
DESTROY LIKE YOU. AND NEXT WE
02:21:33.785 --> 02:21:35.653
HAVE LINE TO 23. PLEASE GO
02:21:35.720 --> 02:21:40.058
AHEAD. HELLO. HELLO. YOUR LINE
02:21:40.124 --> 02:21:43.962
IS OPEN. HELLO. THANK YOU. MY
02:21:44.028 --> 02:21:45.964
NAME IS DEBBIE MUNTER. I'M A
02:21:46.030 --> 02:21:49.534
NURSING MESSAGES. CATHOLIC. AND
02:21:49.601 --> 02:21:50.702
I STRONGLY OPPOSED THIS BILL.
02:21:50.768 --> 02:21:55.540
IT'S WRONG. THANK YOU. AND THAT
02:21:55.607 --> 02:21:58.843
IS ALL WE HAVE IN KUNA. UM OUR
02:21:58.910 --> 02:22:00.945
FEARLESS LEADER HAS RETURNED IN
02:22:01.012 --> 02:22:02.146
THE GAVEL HAS BEEN RETURNED TO
02:22:02.213 --> 02:22:06.317
HIM. ALREADY THANK YOU. SENATOR
02:22:06.384 --> 02:22:09.254
BORDERS, MR VICE CHAIR. AH I
02:22:09.320 --> 02:22:10.355
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO GO
02:22:10.421 --> 02:22:11.589
AND VOTE AND VETS COMMITTEE.
02:22:11.656 --> 02:22:14.259
ALRIGHT NEXT WE'LL BRING IT BACK
02:22:14.325 --> 02:22:14.859
TO THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS OF
02:22:14.926 --> 02:22:15.460
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I SEE
02:22:15.527 --> 02:22:16.561
SENATOR GONZALEZ SENATOR
02:22:16.628 --> 02:22:18.863
GONZALEZ, THEN SENATOR WIENER.
02:22:18.930 --> 02:22:20.398
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. I JUST WANT
02:22:20.465 --> 02:22:22.500
TO THANK WHOLEHEARTEDLY ARE PRO
02:22:22.567 --> 02:22:23.635
TEM, THE SPEAKER IN THE ASSEMBLY
02:22:23.701 --> 02:22:27.739
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD. UM I
02:22:27.805 --> 02:22:29.340
THINK YOU KNOW, HEARD A LOT OF
02:22:29.407 --> 02:22:31.476
DEBATE ON THIS REALLY BOGGLES MY
02:22:31.542 --> 02:22:32.343
MIND THAT WE'RE STILL HAVING
02:22:32.410 --> 02:22:34.312
THESE DISCUSSIONS IN 2022. AND
02:22:34.379 --> 02:22:36.414
WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THIS ISSUE,
02:22:36.481 --> 02:22:37.916
IT'S NOT ABORTIONIST. WE'RE
02:22:37.982 --> 02:22:39.350
TALKING ABOUT WOMEN AND PREGNANT
02:22:39.417 --> 02:22:40.618
PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA. IT'S NOT
02:22:40.685 --> 02:22:41.786
AN INDUSTRY THEIR HEALTHCARE
02:22:41.853 --> 02:22:45.123
PROVIDERS. AND WE'RE SAFE HAVEN
02:22:45.189 --> 02:22:46.624
. WE'VE ALREADY ANNOUNCED
02:22:46.691 --> 02:22:48.159
OURSELVES AS A SAFE HAVEN IN
02:22:48.226 --> 02:22:50.528
CALIFORNIA TO ENSURE THAT
02:22:50.595 --> 02:22:51.763
EVERYONE HAS ACCESS AND IT PAINS
02:22:51.829 --> 02:22:54.032
ME TO KNOW THAT PEOPLE OF COLOR
02:22:54.098 --> 02:22:56.401
IN PARTICULAR HAVE BORE THE
02:22:56.467 --> 02:22:58.036
BURDEN OF HEALTHCARE AND
02:22:58.102 --> 02:22:59.270
EQUITIES, AND ESPECIALLY WITH
02:22:59.337 --> 02:23:01.940
ABORTION RESTRICTIONS. SO
02:23:02.006 --> 02:23:03.341
ENABLING THIS CONSTITUTIONAL
02:23:03.408 --> 02:23:05.543
AMENDMENT TO MOVE FORWARD NOT
02:23:05.610 --> 02:23:08.112
ONLY ALLOWS PEOPLE OF COLOR HERE
02:23:08.179 --> 02:23:09.414
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WOMEN
02:23:09.480 --> 02:23:11.182
IN PREGNANT PEOPLE OF ALL
02:23:11.249 --> 02:23:12.317
DIFFERENT COLORS AND ORIGINS TO
02:23:12.383 --> 02:23:14.285
BE ABLE TO HAVE ACCESS BUT
02:23:14.352 --> 02:23:15.520
PEOPLE ACROSS THE COUNTRY THIS
02:23:15.586 --> 02:23:17.889
IS A BOLD STATEMENT. AGAIN. I
02:23:17.956 --> 02:23:19.390
WANT TO THANK OUR PRO TEM FOR
02:23:19.457 --> 02:23:20.692
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. I WILL
02:23:20.758 --> 02:23:22.193
CONTINUE TO SUPPORT LEGISLATION
02:23:22.260 --> 02:23:24.429
LIKE THIS. AND I WANT TO THANK
02:23:24.495 --> 02:23:25.496
OUR STAKEHOLDERS FOR BEING HERE
02:23:25.563 --> 02:23:28.166
AS WELL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
02:23:28.232 --> 02:23:29.067
SENATOR GONZALEZ. ALRIGHT,
02:23:29.133 --> 02:23:30.401
CENTER WIENER. MAYBE THEY CAN
02:23:30.468 --> 02:23:37.976
TURN THAT OFF. SPEAK UP AHEAD.
02:23:38.042 --> 02:23:39.811
CENTER WIENER. THANK YOU, MR
02:23:39.877 --> 02:23:40.445
CHAIRMAN. I ALSO WANT TO THANK
02:23:40.511 --> 02:23:43.114
MADAM PRO TEM AND MR SPEAKER
02:23:43.181 --> 02:23:44.048
FOR, UH, FOR BRINGING THIS
02:23:44.115 --> 02:23:45.149
IMPORTANT MEASURE FORWARD, I
02:23:45.216 --> 02:23:49.887
THINK GIVEN THE DISASTER. THE
02:23:49.954 --> 02:23:51.489
TRAIN WRECK THAT SEEMS TO BE
02:23:51.556 --> 02:23:53.891
UNFOLDING AND THE U. S. SUPREME
02:23:53.958 --> 02:23:54.826
COURT. CALIFORNIA NEEDS TO ACT
02:23:54.892 --> 02:23:56.728
NOW THIS YEAR, NOT NEXT YEAR
02:23:56.794 --> 02:24:00.198
NOW. TO MAKE CRYSTAL CLEAR THAT
02:24:00.264 --> 02:24:03.601
WE VALUE REPRODUCTIVE CHOICE
02:24:03.668 --> 02:24:05.403
THAT WE VALUE THE CIVIL RIGHTS
02:24:05.470 --> 02:24:08.606
OF MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY. UH
02:24:08.673 --> 02:24:10.742
AND THIS WILL MOVE US IN THAT
02:24:10.808 --> 02:24:12.010
DIRECTION. SO I'M REALLY
02:24:12.076 --> 02:24:13.044
APPRECIATIVE FOR THE QUICK
02:24:13.111 --> 02:24:14.512
LEADERSHIP IN RESPONSE TO PART
02:24:14.579 --> 02:24:18.449
TWO. WHAT'S HAPPENING? NDC YOU
02:24:18.516 --> 02:24:20.752
KNOW, I ALSO, UM WANTED TO SAY
02:24:20.818 --> 02:24:25.656
THAT I WISH THAT SOME LEADERS.
02:24:25.723 --> 02:24:28.960
IN THE ANTI ABORTION MOVEMENT.
02:24:29.027 --> 02:24:30.728
WOULD SPEND LESS TIME TRYING TO
02:24:30.795 --> 02:24:31.662
MICROMANAGE PEOPLE'S
02:24:31.729 --> 02:24:34.298
REPRODUCTIVE CHOICES. AND MORE
02:24:34.365 --> 02:24:36.367
TIME DOING THINGS LIKE ENSURING
02:24:36.434 --> 02:24:37.969
THAT ALL CHILDREN HAVE
02:24:38.036 --> 02:24:39.604
NUTRITIOUS FOOD AND THAT
02:24:39.670 --> 02:24:41.406
CHILDREN CAN ATTEND SCHOOL
02:24:41.472 --> 02:24:42.607
WITHOUT BEING SHOT UP BY WEAPONS
02:24:42.673 --> 02:24:46.411
OF WAR. UNFORTUNATELY AND THIS
02:24:46.477 --> 02:24:48.312
IS NOT TRUE OF EVERYONE IN THE
02:24:48.379 --> 02:24:50.815
ANTI ABORTION MOVEMENT. BUT TOO
02:24:50.882 --> 02:24:52.483
FAR TOO MANY OF THE MOST VOCAL
02:24:52.550 --> 02:24:56.187
LEADERS AND PARTICULARLY ON THE
02:24:56.254 --> 02:24:57.021
POLITICAL ARENA, WHO ARE DOING
02:24:57.088 --> 02:24:58.790
EVERYTHING IN THEIR POWER. TO
02:24:58.856 --> 02:25:01.692
BAN ABORTION. OR THE SAME
02:25:01.759 --> 02:25:05.897
PEOPLE. WHO HAVE WORKED FOR
02:25:05.963 --> 02:25:09.500
YEARS IN CONGRESS. TO DENY
02:25:09.567 --> 02:25:13.204
ACCESS TO FOOD BENEFITS. WHICH
02:25:13.271 --> 02:25:14.439
WE KNOW THAT WHEN YOU REDUCE
02:25:14.505 --> 02:25:16.607
FOOD BENEFITS, IT'S CHILDREN.
02:25:16.674 --> 02:25:17.809
THAT SUFFER THE MOST THE SAME
02:25:17.875 --> 02:25:21.579
PEOPLE. THE SAME PEOPLE WHO HAVE
02:25:21.646 --> 02:25:24.515
BEEN WORKING FOR YEARS TO DENY
02:25:24.582 --> 02:25:26.350
ACCESS TO ABORTION OR SOME OF
02:25:26.417 --> 02:25:27.385
THE SAME PEOPLE WHO'VE BEEN
02:25:27.452 --> 02:25:29.454
MAKING IT IMPOSSIBLE. TO HAVE
02:25:29.520 --> 02:25:33.458
MEANINGFUL GUN SAFETY REFORMS SO
02:25:33.524 --> 02:25:34.759
THAT THOSE SAME SO CHILDREN CAN
02:25:34.826 --> 02:25:37.728
GO TO SCHOOL. WITHOUT HAVING TO
02:25:37.795 --> 02:25:38.863
BE CONCERNED THAT SOMEONE'S
02:25:38.930 --> 02:25:40.131
GOING TO WALK INTO THE
02:25:40.198 --> 02:25:42.867
CLASSROOM. AND SHOOT THEM.
02:25:42.934 --> 02:25:45.136
UNFORTUNATELY TOO MANY OF THESE
02:25:45.203 --> 02:25:46.504
LEADERS APPEAR TO BE TOO BUSY
02:25:46.571 --> 02:25:49.407
HAVING MORAL PANIC ABOUT DRAG
02:25:49.474 --> 02:25:50.675
QUEENS STORY HOUR OR TRANS KIDS
02:25:50.741 --> 02:25:53.845
PLAYING SPORTS. BEEN ACTUALLY
02:25:53.911 --> 02:25:55.113
MAKING SURE THAT THESE CHILDREN
02:25:55.179 --> 02:25:57.081
HAVE FOOD AND CAN GO TO SCHOOL
02:25:57.148 --> 02:26:00.885
SAFELY. AND SO I JUST WANT TO
02:26:00.952 --> 02:26:03.888
SAY THAT WE NEED TO FOCUS ON THE
02:26:03.955 --> 02:26:06.657
HEALTH AND SAFETY AND VITALITY
02:26:06.724 --> 02:26:08.392
OF OUR CHILDREN. AND I HOPE THAT
02:26:08.459 --> 02:26:10.394
WE CAN DO THAT, UM AND STOP WITH
02:26:10.461 --> 02:26:13.498
THIS MICROMANAGEMENT. OF
02:26:13.564 --> 02:26:15.733
PEOPLE'S VERY PERSONAL
02:26:15.800 --> 02:26:16.801
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CHOICES, SO
02:26:16.868 --> 02:26:19.737
I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL.
02:26:19.804 --> 02:26:20.671
THANK YOU, SENATOR. WIENER.
02:26:20.738 --> 02:26:22.473
ALRIGHT CONSIDER WIECKOWSKI.
02:26:22.540 --> 02:26:25.109
THANK YOU, MR. THANK YOU, MR
02:26:25.176 --> 02:26:26.144
CHAIR. I HAVE A QUESTION BECAUSE
02:26:26.210 --> 02:26:28.846
I WANT TO BE SURE. THAT
02:26:28.913 --> 02:26:30.214
EVERYBODY UNDERSTANDS WHAT'S IN
02:26:30.281 --> 02:26:32.250
FRONT OF US, AND WE'RE THE STATE
02:26:32.316 --> 02:26:34.785
OF THE LAW IS IN CALIFORNIA.
02:26:34.852 --> 02:26:35.620
SOMETIMES I FEEL LIKE AN EIGHTH
02:26:35.686 --> 02:26:37.655
GRADE CIVICS TEACHER BECAUSE
02:26:37.722 --> 02:26:40.858
PAGE SEVEN OF OUR STAFF REPORT
02:26:40.925 --> 02:26:43.628
LAYS OUT SORT OF THE 53 YEAR
02:26:43.694 --> 02:26:46.998
HISTORY OF CALIFORNIA. WE IN
02:26:47.064 --> 02:26:49.000
PEOPLE VERSUS BILLOWS. WE
02:26:49.066 --> 02:26:52.003
RECOGNIZE A WOMAN'S FUNDAMENTAL
02:26:52.069 --> 02:26:53.037
RIGHT TO HAVE AN ABORTION AN
02:26:53.104 --> 02:26:54.805
THAT WAS A JUDICIAL DECISION
02:26:54.872 --> 02:26:57.441
THAT WAS MADE 53 YEARS AGO. WE
02:26:57.508 --> 02:27:01.546
THEN CODIFIED THAT IN THE UM,
02:27:01.612 --> 02:27:03.848
REPRODUCTIVE PRIVACY ACT THAT
02:27:03.915 --> 02:27:05.550
BECAME A STATE LAW AND AS THE
02:27:05.616 --> 02:27:06.918
OPPOSITION HAS POINTED OUT, WE
02:27:06.984 --> 02:27:10.321
CAN EITHER GIVE MORE ACCESS TO
02:27:10.388 --> 02:27:11.756
THAT PROVIDE MORE FUNDING AND
02:27:11.822 --> 02:27:13.391
CHANGE THOSE STATE LAWS. AND
02:27:13.457 --> 02:27:14.859
THEN WE KNOW THAT GOVERNOR
02:27:14.926 --> 02:27:17.495
NEWSOM IN 2019 MADE AN EXECUTIVE
02:27:17.562 --> 02:27:19.764
ORDER THAT SAID, AS LONG AS I'M
02:27:19.830 --> 02:27:20.898
GOVERNOR, I'M GOING. WE HAVE A
02:27:20.965 --> 02:27:23.467
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT. AND WHAT PART
02:27:23.534 --> 02:27:25.002
OF AND I THOUGHT THE OPPOSITION
02:27:25.069 --> 02:27:26.404
WAS WAS ELOQUENT BECAUSE THEY
02:27:26.470 --> 02:27:29.373
TALKED ABOUT THOSE STATUTORY AND
02:27:29.440 --> 02:27:30.875
JUDICIAL DECISIONS THAT CAN BE
02:27:30.942 --> 02:27:33.077
CHANGED BY DIFFERENT CHORD OR BY
02:27:33.144 --> 02:27:35.746
A DIFFERENT LEGISLATURE. AND I'M
02:27:35.813 --> 02:27:38.115
DON'T BELIEVE THAT THE ALITO
02:27:38.182 --> 02:27:41.786
DECISION WILL HAVE ANY EFFECT ON
02:27:41.852 --> 02:27:43.454
THE CALIFORNIA LAW AS IT IS
02:27:43.521 --> 02:27:45.456
RIGHT NOW. IT ALLOWS STATES TO
02:27:45.523 --> 02:27:47.792
CHANGE IT AND SAY ROE V. WADE IS
02:27:47.858 --> 02:27:49.660
NOW LONGER TO STATE, THIS STATE
02:27:49.727 --> 02:27:53.231
OF THE LAW. OR IN BUT IF WE
02:27:53.297 --> 02:27:54.131
DIDN'T DO ANYTHING, CALIFORNIA
02:27:54.198 --> 02:27:57.235
ALONG WITH STILL BE AS IT IS.
02:27:57.301 --> 02:27:58.636
BUT THIS IS A CONSTITUTIONAL
02:27:58.703 --> 02:28:00.771
AMENDMENT AND ONE OF THE
02:28:00.838 --> 02:28:02.340
OPPOSITION POINTED OUT THAT THEY
02:28:02.406 --> 02:28:04.542
THOUGHT THAT CURRENTLY WE HAVE A
02:28:04.609 --> 02:28:06.277
PRIVATE RIGHT TO PRIVACY IN THIS
02:28:06.344 --> 02:28:08.246
IN THIS CALIFORNIA STATUTE, WE
02:28:08.312 --> 02:28:09.413
TALKED ABOUT THAT ALL THE TIME,
02:28:09.480 --> 02:28:10.581
AND THEY WERE TALKING ABOUT
02:28:10.648 --> 02:28:13.384
THIS. DUE PROCESS AND EQUAL
02:28:13.451 --> 02:28:14.518
PROTECTION THEY'RE GUARANTEED TO
02:28:14.585 --> 02:28:17.822
INDIVIDUALS. AND THAT THEY
02:28:17.888 --> 02:28:19.724
SOMEHOW THAT THE STATUTORY AND
02:28:19.790 --> 02:28:23.494
JUDICIAL AND EXECUTIVE LAWS WERE
02:28:23.561 --> 02:28:25.096
SUBORDINATE RIGHTS, EVEN THOUGH
02:28:25.162 --> 02:28:26.931
WE PROCLAIMED IT AS A STATUTORY
02:28:26.998 --> 02:28:30.268
UM, AS A PROTECTION AND BUT WE
02:28:30.334 --> 02:28:32.603
DIDN'T EXPLICITLY SAY THE RIGHT
02:28:32.670 --> 02:28:35.539
TO PRIVACY INCLUDES THE RIGHT
02:28:35.606 --> 02:28:37.208
FOR A WOMAN TO HAVE REPRODUCTIVE
02:28:37.275 --> 02:28:42.813
RIGHTS. SO AYE. MY UNDERSTANDING
02:28:42.880 --> 02:28:45.249
THAT IF WE DO THIS IF WE MOVE
02:28:45.316 --> 02:28:46.751
THIS STATUE CONSTITUTIONAL
02:28:46.817 --> 02:28:48.753
AMENDMENT AND EXPLICITLY SAY
02:28:48.819 --> 02:28:51.155
THAT THE WOMAN HAS A FUNDAMENTAL
02:28:51.222 --> 02:28:52.223
CUT PRIVACY BUT REPRODUCTIVE
02:28:52.290 --> 02:28:55.793
RIGHTS. THEN WHAT WE'RE DOING IS
02:28:55.860 --> 02:28:57.528
PROTECTING THAT WOMAN'S RIGHT
02:28:57.595 --> 02:28:59.630
FROM SUBSEQUENT CALIFORNIA
02:28:59.697 --> 02:29:01.732
LEGISLATURES AND CALIFORNIA
02:29:01.799 --> 02:29:04.135
GOVERNORS AND CALIFORNIA SUPREME
02:29:04.201 --> 02:29:05.636
COURTS THAT MAY WANT TO SAY THAT
02:29:05.703 --> 02:29:08.773
OH, NO, THIS IS JUST SOME
02:29:08.839 --> 02:29:10.374
EXECUTIVE ORDER THAT THE GUY
02:29:10.441 --> 02:29:13.144
MADE 1920 19 OR A STATUTE. IS
02:29:13.210 --> 02:29:16.380
THAT YOUR UNDERSTANDING? SENATOR
02:29:16.447 --> 02:29:19.417
ATKINS. I'M SO PROUD TO BE
02:29:19.483 --> 02:29:21.052
LOOKING AT A JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
02:29:21.118 --> 02:29:23.087
OF EIGHT ATTORNEYS ASKING THE
02:29:23.154 --> 02:29:24.955
NON ATTORNEY BUT THAT IS MY
02:29:25.022 --> 02:29:26.090
UNDERSTANDING. I THOUGHT THE
02:29:26.157 --> 02:29:29.126
REPORT LAID IT OUT WELL. AND WE
02:29:29.193 --> 02:29:30.895
HAVE AN ATTORNEY ON THE LINE. A
02:29:30.961 --> 02:29:32.063
CONSTITUTIONAL ATTORNEY. THAT IS
02:29:32.129 --> 02:29:36.734
MY UNDERSTANDING. UM WELL, SAID.
02:29:36.801 --> 02:29:38.235
LET ME JUST SPEAK FOR AN AVERAGE
02:29:38.302 --> 02:29:41.238
WOMAN WHO HAS WORKED IN THIS
02:29:41.305 --> 02:29:45.109
FIGHT FOR ALL WELL, 40 YEARS OF
02:29:45.176 --> 02:29:46.277
MY 60 YEARS ON THIS EARTH AS A
02:29:46.344 --> 02:29:50.014
WOMAN I'M GLAD THERE ARE
02:29:50.081 --> 02:29:51.682
ATTORNEYS THAT CAN OPEN AND TELL
02:29:51.749 --> 02:29:53.651
US THIS. I WANT TO KNOW FOR
02:29:53.718 --> 02:29:57.121
SURE. I WANT TO KNOW FOR SURE.
02:29:57.188 --> 02:29:58.923
THAT THAT RIGHT IS PROTECTED,
02:29:58.989 --> 02:30:00.324
AND I THINK THAT'S WHAT THIS IS
02:30:00.391 --> 02:30:02.126
TODAY THAT WE ARE PROTECTING
02:30:02.193 --> 02:30:03.728
OURSELVES FROM FUTURE COURTS.
02:30:03.794 --> 02:30:05.096
AND FUTURE. UM POLITICIANS IF
02:30:05.162 --> 02:30:09.734
YOU WILL. AND SO WE THINK THIS
02:30:09.800 --> 02:30:11.836
IS ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY. AND AS
02:30:11.902 --> 02:30:12.636
AN INDIVIDUAL WOMAN WHO HAS
02:30:12.703 --> 02:30:14.538
FACED THIS WITH FRIENDS AND
02:30:14.605 --> 02:30:17.875
FAMILY. UM THAT'S MY PERSPECTIVE
02:30:17.942 --> 02:30:18.776
, AND THAT'S WHY I'M DOING THIS
02:30:18.843 --> 02:30:20.511
AND I'M GLAD THAT WE HAVE ALL OF
02:30:20.578 --> 02:30:22.313
YOU GREAT ATTORNEYS TO ADVISE
02:30:22.380 --> 02:30:24.548
US. MR CHAIR. IT'S MY
02:30:24.615 --> 02:30:25.750
UNDERSTANDING OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:30:25.816 --> 02:30:27.351
CONSTITUTIONAL PROCESS THAT
02:30:27.418 --> 02:30:29.887
SHOULD THIS MEASURE MOVE FROM
02:30:29.954 --> 02:30:31.522
HERE AND ON THE FLOOR. THEN IT
02:30:31.589 --> 02:30:33.791
WOULD GO TO A VOTE OF THE PEOPLE
02:30:33.858 --> 02:30:35.593
WHO WOULD HAVE TO MAKE SURE THAT
02:30:35.659 --> 02:30:38.429
THEY WEIGH IN THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
02:30:38.496 --> 02:30:39.563
LIVING IN CALIFORNIA IN 2022,
02:30:39.630 --> 02:30:41.966
WHETHER THEY AGREE WITH THE
02:30:42.032 --> 02:30:43.200
LEGISLATURE ON THIS
02:30:43.267 --> 02:30:43.768
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. IF
02:30:43.834 --> 02:30:46.003
THAT, IF THE IF THE AUTHOR COULD
02:30:46.070 --> 02:30:47.405
ANSWER THAT. IT'S JUST GOING TO
02:30:47.471 --> 02:30:49.507
A VOTE OF THE PEOPLE. IT IS
02:30:49.573 --> 02:30:52.576
SENATOR AND I'M GRATEFUL THAT IT
02:30:52.643 --> 02:30:53.711
IS THIS IS THIS IS A VERY
02:30:53.778 --> 02:30:55.579
IMPORTANT ISSUE, WHICH IS WHY
02:30:55.646 --> 02:30:56.580
IT'S A CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT.
02:30:56.647 --> 02:30:58.482
WE WANT. THE VOTERS IN
02:30:58.549 --> 02:31:00.918
CALIFORNIA TO REAFFIRM THAT THEY
02:31:00.985 --> 02:31:03.487
BELIEVE EXACTLY THIS AND THAT IT
02:31:03.554 --> 02:31:04.688
WILL CONTINUE TO BE A RIGHT IN
02:31:04.755 --> 02:31:07.291
CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT
02:31:07.358 --> 02:31:08.826
, SENATOR BORDERS THEN. AH,
02:31:08.893 --> 02:31:09.894
SENATOR HERZBERG, THEN SENATOR
02:31:09.960 --> 02:31:11.829
LARRY. THANK YOU. THIS IS A
02:31:11.896 --> 02:31:16.767
REALLY INTERESTING QUESTION.
02:31:16.834 --> 02:31:17.902
BECAUSE IT'S CONSTITUTIONAL
02:31:17.968 --> 02:31:20.905
QUESTION. IT'S YOU KNOW, WE'VE
02:31:20.971 --> 02:31:23.274
HEARD FOLKS DISCUSSES ON MORAL
02:31:23.340 --> 02:31:24.442
GROUNDS WE'VE HEARD DISCUSSED ON
02:31:24.508 --> 02:31:26.710
POLITICAL GROUNDS. BUT HERE IN
02:31:26.777 --> 02:31:27.812
JUDICIARY, THIS IS ILLEGAL
02:31:27.878 --> 02:31:30.948
ISSUE. THE CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUE.
02:31:31.015 --> 02:31:32.516
AND THE REASON WHY I FIND IT.
02:31:32.583 --> 02:31:37.555
INTERESTING. IS BECAUSE AS FAR
02:31:37.621 --> 02:31:39.690
AS I'M AWARE CALIFORNIA
02:31:39.757 --> 02:31:40.691
CONSTITUTION AND IN SOME
02:31:40.758 --> 02:31:41.725
INSTANCES, THE NATIONAL
02:31:41.792 --> 02:31:43.594
CONSTITUTION WE DO NOT HAVE A
02:31:43.661 --> 02:31:48.933
RIGHT EUTHANASIA. WE DO NOT HAVE
02:31:48.999 --> 02:31:52.703
A RIGHT TO FOOD. DO NOT HAVE A
02:31:52.770 --> 02:31:55.573
RIGHT TO HEALTH CARE. AND WE DID
02:31:55.639 --> 02:31:57.408
NOT HAVE A CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT
02:31:57.475 --> 02:31:58.742
TO UNIVERSITY EDUCATION. SO I
02:31:58.809 --> 02:31:59.877
THINK WHAT WE'RE ASKING
02:31:59.944 --> 02:32:02.546
OURSELVES HERE. ARE WE ELEVATING
02:32:02.613 --> 02:32:05.115
ONE PARTICULAR ISSUE? WHEN OTHER
02:32:05.182 --> 02:32:09.019
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS. ACKNOWLEDGED
02:32:09.086 --> 02:32:11.021
BY THE U. N AND THE GLOBAL
02:32:11.088 --> 02:32:13.591
COMMUNITY GLOBAL COMMUNITY. IF
02:32:13.657 --> 02:32:16.794
THEY HAVE NOT ELEVATED THIS.
02:32:16.861 --> 02:32:18.028
WHAT ARE WE TRYING TO ACCOMPLISH
02:32:18.095 --> 02:32:22.099
HERE? AND I KNOW THAT THE
02:32:22.166 --> 02:32:24.869
NATIONAL DEBATE HAS CREATED AN
02:32:24.935 --> 02:32:26.003
ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF CONTROVERSY
02:32:26.070 --> 02:32:30.007
OVER THIS ISSUE. BUT I DIDN'T
02:32:30.074 --> 02:32:31.976
KNOW IF THE AUTHOR WISHED TO
02:32:32.042 --> 02:32:33.644
COMMENT ON IF WE DON'T HAVE THE
02:32:33.711 --> 02:32:37.915
RIGHT TO DIE. OR TO FOOD.
02:32:37.982 --> 02:32:41.385
COLLEGE EDUCATION OR HEALTHCARE.
02:32:41.452 --> 02:32:42.853
DOES IT SEEM LIKE WE'RE MISS
02:32:42.920 --> 02:32:45.122
PRIORITIZING WHAT SHOULD BE
02:32:45.189 --> 02:32:46.390
CONSIDERED A CONSTITUTIONAL
02:32:46.457 --> 02:32:48.292
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT IN CALIFORNIA.
02:32:48.359 --> 02:32:52.429
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION. I
02:32:52.496 --> 02:32:53.797
KNOW THAT THERE ARE COLLEAGUES
02:32:53.864 --> 02:32:56.033
THAT WORK TO ENSHRINE ALL KINDS
02:32:56.100 --> 02:32:57.635
OF RIGHTS THE RIGHT TO DIE WITH
02:32:57.701 --> 02:32:59.603
DIGNITY. THAT'S BEEN A PIECE OF
02:32:59.670 --> 02:33:01.472
LEGISLATION HERE RIGHT TO FOOD,
02:33:01.539 --> 02:33:03.440
THE RIGHT TO HOUSING. WE DEBATE
02:33:03.507 --> 02:33:05.075
THESE THINGS ALL THE TIME IN THE
02:33:05.142 --> 02:33:06.110
LEGISLATURE, AND WE WOULD
02:33:06.176 --> 02:33:08.812
ELEVATE ANY OF THESE ISSUES,
02:33:08.879 --> 02:33:10.381
FOOD SECURITY, THE RIGHT TO
02:33:10.447 --> 02:33:12.449
EDUCATION. THERE ARE ANY NUMBER
02:33:12.516 --> 02:33:13.417
OF US THAT WOULD ELEVATE THOSE
02:33:13.484 --> 02:33:15.319
RIGHTS AND ENSHRINE IT IN OUR
02:33:15.386 --> 02:33:17.221
CONSTITUTION. I BELIEVE IF WE
02:33:17.288 --> 02:33:18.889
COULD, AND WE COULD GET THE
02:33:18.956 --> 02:33:20.824
VOTES AND PUT THIS BEFORE THE
02:33:20.891 --> 02:33:24.261
PEOPLE. ON THIS ISSUE. THIS HAS
02:33:24.328 --> 02:33:25.329
BEEN A RIGHT THAT WE HAVE
02:33:25.396 --> 02:33:27.298
ENJOYED FOR 50 YEARS AND TO
02:33:27.364 --> 02:33:31.035
QUOTE ONE OF THE SPEAKERS. AN
02:33:31.101 --> 02:33:32.202
EASY ANSWER TO A COMPLEX
02:33:32.269 --> 02:33:32.770
PROBLEM. HARDLY THIS IS NOT
02:33:32.836 --> 02:33:36.807
EASY. THIS IS NOT AN EASY OPTION
02:33:36.874 --> 02:33:38.609
THAT PEOPLE CHOOSE, BUT IT
02:33:38.676 --> 02:33:41.612
SHOULD BE. I PERCEIVE THIS AS A
02:33:41.679 --> 02:33:43.447
CIVIL RIGHTS ISSUE FOR PREGNANT
02:33:43.514 --> 02:33:44.682
PEOPLE AND WOMEN. WHO SHOULD
02:33:44.748 --> 02:33:47.084
HAVE THE OPTION. TO MAKE THE
02:33:47.151 --> 02:33:51.922
CHOICE OF WHETHER TO UM, MOVE
02:33:51.989 --> 02:33:53.457
FORWARD AND HAVE A FAMILY AND
02:33:53.524 --> 02:33:55.659
HAVE A CHILD OR TO MAKE THE
02:33:55.726 --> 02:33:57.995
DECISION. THE DECISION NOT TO
02:33:58.062 --> 02:33:59.930
AND IT HAS BEEN IN OUR
02:33:59.997 --> 02:34:02.900
CONSTITUTION AND SEEING THAT WAY
02:34:02.967 --> 02:34:04.768
, INTERPRETED THAT WAY UNDER THE
02:34:04.835 --> 02:34:07.438
RIGHT TO PRIVACY FOR 53 YEARS.
02:34:07.504 --> 02:34:09.640
NOW IT'S BEING THREATENED TO BE
02:34:09.707 --> 02:34:11.675
TAKEN AWAY. VERY LIKELY WILL BE
02:34:11.742 --> 02:34:13.310
. AND SO IT'S URGENT THAT WE DO
02:34:13.377 --> 02:34:15.446
THIS NOW NOT TO TAKE A RIGHT
02:34:15.512 --> 02:34:17.781
AWAY THAT PEOPLE FOUGHT TO GAIN.
02:34:17.848 --> 02:34:20.584
SO IF YOU'RE ASKING ME IF I
02:34:20.651 --> 02:34:22.953
ELEVATE THIS ABOVE OTHER THINGS
02:34:23.020 --> 02:34:25.022
, I DON'T PRIORITIZE. I THINK
02:34:25.089 --> 02:34:26.590
MANY ISSUES ARE IMPORTANT. THIS
02:34:26.657 --> 02:34:27.424
ONE IS UNDER ATTACK. RIGHT NOW.
02:34:27.491 --> 02:34:29.226
THAT'S WHY THIS ISSUE IS BEFORE
02:34:29.293 --> 02:34:31.996
US NOW. I APPRECIATE. I
02:34:32.062 --> 02:34:33.797
APPRECIATE THAT. THOSE COMMENTS
02:34:33.864 --> 02:34:36.133
I THINK NO ONE IS UNDER ANY
02:34:36.200 --> 02:34:39.169
IMPRESSION THAT CALIFORNIA AH,
02:34:39.236 --> 02:34:40.237
LEGISLATION IS UNDER THREAT IN
02:34:40.304 --> 02:34:43.440
THIS DOMAIN. I THINK WE ARE
02:34:43.507 --> 02:34:48.445
STAND ALONE. UH, STATE AS A
02:34:48.512 --> 02:34:49.580
LEADER IN THIS IN THIS SPACE,
02:34:49.647 --> 02:34:53.584
UH, ACKNOWLEDGING, UM ROE V.
02:34:53.651 --> 02:34:54.752
WADE AND THE PROTECTIONS THAT
02:34:54.818 --> 02:34:55.886
HAVE GONE ALONG WITH THAT. UM,
02:34:55.953 --> 02:34:59.556
I'M JUST CONCERNED THAT AS I
02:34:59.623 --> 02:35:01.291
MENTIONED THAT WE ARE
02:35:01.358 --> 02:35:04.795
UNNECESSARILY TAKING THIS ISSUE.
02:35:04.862 --> 02:35:06.497
AND INCORPORATING INTO THE
02:35:06.563 --> 02:35:07.765
SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT DOCUMENT
02:35:07.831 --> 02:35:09.466
THAT WE HAVE IN THE STATE OF
02:35:09.533 --> 02:35:11.301
CALIFORNIA. WHEN I WOULD SUBMIT
02:35:11.368 --> 02:35:13.404
TO YOU AND TO OTHERS THAT IF WE
02:35:13.470 --> 02:35:14.705
WERE TO DEVISE A CONSTITUTIONAL
02:35:14.772 --> 02:35:18.275
AMENDMENT I WOULD LOVE TO SEE
02:35:18.342 --> 02:35:19.576
THE OTHER ESSENTIAL COMPONENTS.
02:35:19.643 --> 02:35:24.014
OF OUR. OF OUR OF OUR HUMAN
02:35:24.081 --> 02:35:26.216
CONDITION BE RESPECTED AS WELL,
02:35:26.283 --> 02:35:26.784
INCLUDING EDUCATION, HEALTH
02:35:26.850 --> 02:35:30.621
CARE. FOOD AND WATER. UM AND I
02:35:30.688 --> 02:35:33.791
THINK TO IGNORE THAT, I THINK IS
02:35:33.857 --> 02:35:35.993
MISSING AN OPPORTUNITY. UM BUT I
02:35:36.060 --> 02:35:41.165
WILL SAY THIS I HAVE A LONG
02:35:41.231 --> 02:35:43.834
TRACK RECORD AT THE LOCAL LEVEL.
02:35:43.901 --> 02:35:45.536
I END AT THE STATE LEVEL, EVEN
02:35:45.602 --> 02:35:46.770
ON ISSUES THAT I MAY DISAGREE
02:35:46.837 --> 02:35:50.874
WITH. IF IT IS BEING SUBMITTED
02:35:50.941 --> 02:35:52.576
TO THE VOTERS. LIKE CALIFORNIANS
02:35:52.643 --> 02:35:57.314
DECIDE. AND I THINK THAT IS
02:35:57.381 --> 02:36:00.818
ULTIMATELY WHERE THIS HAS TO GO.
02:36:00.884 --> 02:36:02.820
AND LET CALIFORNIANS DICTATE THE
02:36:02.886 --> 02:36:07.391
WAY THAT CALIFORNIA UH, LAWS AND
02:36:07.458 --> 02:36:08.358
CONSTITUTIONAL AUTHORITIES BE
02:36:08.425 --> 02:36:10.394
WRITTEN. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
02:36:10.461 --> 02:36:14.565
GORGEOUS SENATE, HERTZBERG. I
02:36:14.631 --> 02:36:16.300
STARTED OUT. I APOLOGIZE. MADAM
02:36:16.366 --> 02:36:19.069
PRO TEM AND MR CHAIR. IF THE
02:36:19.136 --> 02:36:19.837
EXTENT I SAY SOMETHING STUPID
02:36:19.903 --> 02:36:20.971
NATIVE BECAUSE I WAS JUGGLING A
02:36:21.038 --> 02:36:22.706
BUNCH OF OTHER COMMITTEES. I'M
02:36:22.773 --> 02:36:24.875
SO SORRY ABOUT THAT. BUT YOU
02:36:24.942 --> 02:36:26.110
KNOW, WE HAVE SO MANY COMPLEX
02:36:26.176 --> 02:36:27.878
DOCUMENTS BEFORE US ALL THE
02:36:27.945 --> 02:36:29.747
TIME. IN LAWS THAT ARE PAGES AND
02:36:29.813 --> 02:36:31.548
PAGES WITH CROSS REFERENCES AND
02:36:31.615 --> 02:36:33.217
THAT EVEN THOUGH I'VE BEEN A
02:36:33.283 --> 02:36:35.285
LAWYER FOR A LONG TIME, HALF THE
02:36:35.352 --> 02:36:36.487
TIME I UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY
02:36:36.553 --> 02:36:37.621
MEAN. THIS IS PRETTY CLEAR. IT'S
02:36:37.688 --> 02:36:39.056
BASICALLY ONE SENTENCE AND I
02:36:39.123 --> 02:36:41.125
WANT TO READ IT. I WANT TO READ
02:36:41.191 --> 02:36:42.559
INTO THE RECORD. THE STATE SHALL
02:36:42.626 --> 02:36:44.862
NOT DENY OR INTERFERE WITH AN
02:36:44.928 --> 02:36:45.395
INDIVIDUAL'S REPRODUCTIVE
02:36:45.462 --> 02:36:48.298
FREEDOM. IN THEIR MOST INTIMATE
02:36:48.365 --> 02:36:49.967
DECISIONS, WHICH INCLUDES THEIR
02:36:50.033 --> 02:36:51.902
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO CHOOSE TO
02:36:51.969 --> 02:36:53.003
HAVE AN ABORTION AND THEIR
02:36:53.070 --> 02:36:55.038
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT TO CHOOSE OR
02:36:55.105 --> 02:36:56.540
REFUSE CONTRACEPTIVES. IT'S
02:36:56.607 --> 02:36:59.977
BASICALLY ONE SENTENCE.
02:37:00.043 --> 02:37:02.246
CONSTITUTIONS ARE ABOUT ONE
02:37:02.312 --> 02:37:03.514
SENTENCES IN BASIC PRINCIPLES OF
02:37:03.580 --> 02:37:05.916
WHO WE ARE AS A SOCIETY. I DO
02:37:05.983 --> 02:37:10.354
THINK THAT WHERE WE HAVE HAD, AS
02:37:10.420 --> 02:37:13.323
THE AUTHOR HAS ARTICULATED. A
02:37:13.390 --> 02:37:15.492
WHAT THE RULE OF LAW HAS BEEN
02:37:15.559 --> 02:37:17.227
FOR THE UNITED STATES AND FOR
02:37:17.294 --> 02:37:18.262
CALIFORNIA'S SENATOR, MAKOWSKI
02:37:18.328 --> 02:37:20.931
SAID. AS A RESULT OF OCCASION,
02:37:20.998 --> 02:37:22.366
69 AS A RESULT OF ALL THESE
02:37:22.432 --> 02:37:24.001
INTERPRETATIONS AS TO RESULT OF
02:37:24.067 --> 02:37:26.670
WHAT THE IDEA OF THE RIGHT OF
02:37:26.737 --> 02:37:27.738
PRIVACY MEANS RIGHT OF PRIVACY,
02:37:27.805 --> 02:37:28.639
NOT THE CONSTITUTION. IT WAS
02:37:28.705 --> 02:37:30.374
UNDER THE NUMBER OF THE BILL OF
02:37:30.440 --> 02:37:31.575
RIGHTS, AS DEFINED IN THE
02:37:31.642 --> 02:37:33.343
GRISWOLD GATES BY JUSTICE
02:37:33.410 --> 02:37:34.178
WILLIAM DOUGLAS. DIDN'T EXIST.
02:37:34.244 --> 02:37:38.182
AND SO THE MESSAGE HERE, AND IT
02:37:38.248 --> 02:37:39.716
IS, AS YOU SUGGESTED SENATOR
02:37:39.783 --> 02:37:41.485
WIECKOWSKI THAT WE'RE TAKING
02:37:41.552 --> 02:37:43.020
THIS TO THE VOTERS THAT WE HAVE
02:37:43.086 --> 02:37:45.222
TO MAKE THIS IRONCLAD THAT THERE
02:37:45.289 --> 02:37:47.257
CANNOT BE A DOUBT THERE CANNOT
02:37:47.324 --> 02:37:50.194
BE ANY COURT JUDGE OR JUSTICE OR
02:37:50.260 --> 02:37:51.962
ANYBODY ELSE OR ANY ELECTED
02:37:52.029 --> 02:37:53.430
OFFICIAL THAT FUNDAMENTALLY
02:37:53.497 --> 02:37:54.631
CHANGES THE WILL OF THE PEOPLE
02:37:54.698 --> 02:37:56.366
THAT WILL BE ON THE BALLOT. SO I
02:37:56.433 --> 02:37:57.568
JUST WANTED TO JOIN IN.
02:37:57.634 --> 02:37:59.203
OBVIOUSLY IN SUPPORTERS IT CO
02:37:59.269 --> 02:38:01.872
AUTHOR OF THIS MEASURE, BUT ALSO
02:38:01.939 --> 02:38:02.406
TO MAKE THE POINT IN THE
02:38:02.472 --> 02:38:04.241
SIMPLEST TERMS ABOUT WHAT IT
02:38:04.308 --> 02:38:05.375
SAYS IT'S NOT ANYTHING THAT'S
02:38:05.442 --> 02:38:06.777
COMPLICATED, AND IT IS SOMETHING
02:38:06.844 --> 02:38:09.580
THAT JUST IN ITS MOST
02:38:09.646 --> 02:38:11.048
FUNDAMENTAL SENSE, JUST
02:38:11.114 --> 02:38:13.016
REAFFIRMED HIS ALWAYS BEEN THE
02:38:13.083 --> 02:38:14.852
LAW OF THE LAND SINCE MOST OF MY
02:38:14.918 --> 02:38:18.555
LIFE AND I WOULD ASK FOR AN I
02:38:18.622 --> 02:38:19.623
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, AND
02:38:19.690 --> 02:38:21.625
THANK YOU FOR INTRODUCING THIS
02:38:21.692 --> 02:38:22.693
MEASUREMENT IN PRO TEM ALONG
02:38:22.759 --> 02:38:23.660
WITH THE SPEAKER OF THE
02:38:23.727 --> 02:38:24.695
ASSEMBLY. ALRIGHTY. THANK YOU,
02:38:24.761 --> 02:38:25.963
SENATOR HERTZBERG. SENATOR
02:38:26.029 --> 02:38:30.601
LAIRD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
02:38:30.667 --> 02:38:36.340
CHAIR. IF YOU MM. LOOK AT
02:38:36.406 --> 02:38:38.709
TODAY'S NEWSPAPERS WHERE IT SAYS
02:38:38.775 --> 02:38:40.744
WHAT HAPPENED ON THIS DATE 55
02:38:40.811 --> 02:38:42.079
YEARS AGO TODAY RONALD REAGAN
02:38:42.145 --> 02:38:46.850
SIGNED. THE FIRST ABORTION LAW
02:38:46.917 --> 02:38:48.485
IN CALIFORNIA 55 YEARS AGO.
02:38:48.552 --> 02:38:52.422
TODAY IT WAS A DEMOCRATIC AH
02:38:52.489 --> 02:38:53.423
LEGISLATURE AND A REPUBLICAN
02:38:53.490 --> 02:38:57.094
GOVERNOR. AND WHAT WE'RE TALKING
02:38:57.160 --> 02:38:58.695
ABOUT, AND SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES
02:38:58.762 --> 02:38:59.730
HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT IS THE
02:38:59.796 --> 02:39:01.298
PROGRESSION. WHEN I WAS IN THE
02:39:01.365 --> 02:39:04.902
ASSEMBLY. THERE WAS A THREAT ON
02:39:04.968 --> 02:39:07.104
ROE V. WADE AH, WITH THE GEORGE
02:39:07.170 --> 02:39:10.407
BUSH COURT. AND AS A RESULT,
02:39:10.474 --> 02:39:12.676
SENATOR SHEILA KUEHL RECOGNIZED
02:39:12.743 --> 02:39:15.312
THAT THE LAW THAT WAS IN PLACE
02:39:15.379 --> 02:39:17.247
WAS THE LAW THAT WAS SIGNED BY
02:39:17.314 --> 02:39:18.315
RONALD REAGAN. AND SO THE
02:39:18.382 --> 02:39:20.617
LEGISLATURE ENACTED A DEMOCRATIC
02:39:20.684 --> 02:39:21.652
LEGISLATURE AND A REPUBLICAN
02:39:21.718 --> 02:39:25.522
GOVERNOR SIGNED AND UPDATE TO
02:39:25.589 --> 02:39:27.391
THAT LAW THAT BROUGHT IT MORE
02:39:27.457 --> 02:39:29.660
INTO WHERE WE ARE NOW. WITH
02:39:29.726 --> 02:39:34.264
REPRODUCTIVE PRACTICES. AND IF
02:39:34.331 --> 02:39:36.233
YOU LOOK AT WHERE WE ARE THIS
02:39:36.300 --> 02:39:41.238
MOMENT UM, YES, THIS IS A RIGHT
02:39:41.305 --> 02:39:42.839
THAT MIGHT BE ENSHRINED IN THE
02:39:42.906 --> 02:39:44.908
CONSTITUTION, BUT WE HAVE BY
02:39:44.975 --> 02:39:46.643
STATUTE SAID THE RIGHT TO DIE
02:39:46.710 --> 02:39:48.679
AND IT IS SURVIVED THE QUARTET
02:39:48.745 --> 02:39:50.347
EST. IT IS NOT AT RISK. WE HAVE
02:39:50.414 --> 02:39:52.015
SAID BY STATUTE THE RIGHT TO
02:39:52.082 --> 02:39:54.251
CLEAN WATER AND THAT HAS NOT
02:39:54.318 --> 02:39:57.187
BEEN CHALLENGED AND IS NOT
02:39:57.254 --> 02:39:59.356
SUBJECT TO IT RIGHT NOW. WE HAVE
02:39:59.423 --> 02:40:00.857
THE RIGHT TO NON DISCRIMINATION
02:40:00.924 --> 02:40:02.726
AND THAT SURVIVED THINGS AND IT
02:40:02.793 --> 02:40:05.128
HAS NOT BEEN ENSHRINED IN THE
02:40:05.195 --> 02:40:06.196
CONSTITUTION AND YET RIGHT NOW
02:40:06.263 --> 02:40:08.665
CIRCUMSTANCE THIS ISSUE HAS BEEN
02:40:08.732 --> 02:40:09.866
ELEVATED. NOT BY US. IT'S BEEN
02:40:09.933 --> 02:40:12.202
ELEVATED BY CIRCUMSTANCE.
02:40:12.269 --> 02:40:14.271
BECAUSE THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY IS
02:40:14.338 --> 02:40:15.439
NOT ENOUGH TO THE FEDERAL
02:40:15.505 --> 02:40:18.942
SUPREME COURT. AND IF YOU LOOK
02:40:19.009 --> 02:40:20.444
AT THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY HERE,
02:40:20.510 --> 02:40:21.845
WHICH IS GUARANTEED THIS
02:40:21.912 --> 02:40:22.846
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT WOULD
02:40:22.913 --> 02:40:27.484
MAKE SURE THAT THAT IT IS MORE
02:40:27.551 --> 02:40:29.286
THAN THAT IN PROTECTING THIS
02:40:29.353 --> 02:40:34.191
RIGHT? SO I THINK THE ONE
02:40:34.257 --> 02:40:37.561
ADDITIONAL THING TO SAY HE IS
02:40:37.627 --> 02:40:39.363
THAT AS SOMEBODY THAT WAS VERY
02:40:39.429 --> 02:40:41.965
ACTIVE AT THE OUTBREAK OF AIDS
02:40:42.032 --> 02:40:44.968
AND HIV THERE WEREN'T MANY
02:40:45.035 --> 02:40:46.937
PEOPLE STANDING WITH US WHEN
02:40:47.004 --> 02:40:48.105
THAT HAPPENED, AS A MATTER OF
02:40:48.171 --> 02:40:50.407
FACT, IS SOMETHING LIKE 37 OR
02:40:50.474 --> 02:40:52.275
38. YEARS AGO, SOMEBODY WAS
02:40:52.342 --> 02:40:55.912
FIRED. IN SANTA CRUZ FOR
02:40:55.979 --> 02:40:58.215
VOLUNTEERING AT THE AIDS SERVICE
02:40:58.281 --> 02:41:00.283
AGENCY, WHERE I WAS ONE OF THE
02:41:00.350 --> 02:41:01.918
FOUNDERS AND EVENTUALLY AN
02:41:01.985 --> 02:41:02.552
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, AND ABOUT
02:41:02.619 --> 02:41:03.653
THE ONLY ORGANIZATION THAT STOOD
02:41:03.720 --> 02:41:05.355
UP FOR US WHEN THAT HAPPENED.
02:41:05.422 --> 02:41:09.059
WAS PLANNED PARENTHOOD. AND I
02:41:09.126 --> 02:41:12.596
THINK MANY OF US FROM THAT TIME.
02:41:12.662 --> 02:41:14.698
RECOGNIZED THAT THE IMPORTANT
02:41:14.765 --> 02:41:16.600
THING AND I AM SO HAPPY THAT THE
02:41:16.666 --> 02:41:18.368
MEN ON THIS COMMITTEE HAVE
02:41:18.435 --> 02:41:23.440
SPOKEN UP. BECAUSE IT IS PEOPLE
02:41:23.507 --> 02:41:25.409
THAT AREN'T THE ONES THAT ARE
02:41:25.475 --> 02:41:27.210
MOST IMMEDIATELY AT RISK THAT
02:41:27.277 --> 02:41:29.379
NEED TO STAND WITH THOSE THAT
02:41:29.446 --> 02:41:30.914
RISK IN A TIME OF CHALLENGE LIKE
02:41:30.981 --> 02:41:34.885
THIS, AND SO THIS IS ABOUT
02:41:34.951 --> 02:41:36.920
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI SAID. THIS IS
02:41:36.987 --> 02:41:39.222
ABOUT LETTING THE PEOPLE DECIDE.
02:41:39.289 --> 02:41:40.991
REALLY LETTING THE PEOPLE DECIDE
02:41:41.058 --> 02:41:42.592
. WE BELIEVE THIS SHOULD BE
02:41:42.659 --> 02:41:43.827
ELEVATED. WE BELIEVE THIS
02:41:43.894 --> 02:41:45.429
PROTECTION IS THERE, BUT IT'S
02:41:45.495 --> 02:41:47.731
ABOUT PUTTING IT IN FRONT OF THE
02:41:47.798 --> 02:41:48.698
PEOPLE AND LETTING THEM MAKE THE
02:41:48.765 --> 02:41:50.834
ULTIMATE CHOICE OF THEY, AS THEY
02:41:50.901 --> 02:41:52.736
HAVE HAD FOR EVERY SECTION OF
02:41:52.803 --> 02:41:55.739
OUR CONSTITUTION. SO I REALLY
02:41:55.806 --> 02:41:57.707
APPRECIATE THIS BEING BROUGHT TO
02:41:57.774 --> 02:41:59.810
US. I REALLY APPRECIATE THIS
02:41:59.876 --> 02:42:01.111
DEBATE AND LOOK FORWARD TO
02:42:01.178 --> 02:42:02.979
VOTING I ON THIS CONSTITUTIONAL
02:42:03.046 --> 02:42:04.681
AMENDMENT. ALRIGHT. OTHER YES.
02:42:04.748 --> 02:42:09.219
SENATOR RUSSELL. THANK YOU, MR
02:42:09.286 --> 02:42:12.355
CHAIR, AND I ALSO THANK, UM, PRO
02:42:12.422 --> 02:42:14.591
TEM AND SPEAKER FOR BRINGING
02:42:14.658 --> 02:42:16.393
THIS FOURTH. THIS IS, UM YOU
02:42:16.460 --> 02:42:19.963
KNOW, THE DECISION THAT A WOMAN
02:42:20.030 --> 02:42:23.600
FACES AH! IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT,
02:42:23.667 --> 02:42:27.971
SOMETIMES. BUT I SEE THIS AS A
02:42:28.038 --> 02:42:29.573
HEALTH CARE ISSUE. AND THE RIGHT
02:42:29.639 --> 02:42:34.878
TO CHOOSE. TO BE IN A POSITION
02:42:34.945 --> 02:42:36.746
TO HAVE THE RESOURCES TO HAVE
02:42:36.813 --> 02:42:38.448
EVERYTHING THAT YOU NEED TO
02:42:38.515 --> 02:42:40.484
RAISE A FAMILY WHEN YOU WANT TO
02:42:40.550 --> 02:42:41.585
RAISE A FAMILY. IN THE MOST
02:42:41.651 --> 02:42:46.089
DIGNIFIED WAY. UM, AND
02:42:46.156 --> 02:42:48.825
HEALTHCARE ACCESS IS PART OF THE
02:42:48.892 --> 02:42:49.960
MOST ESSENTIAL THINGS THAT HUMAN
02:42:50.026 --> 02:42:52.662
BEINGS NEED. 20% OF CALIFORNIANS
02:42:52.729 --> 02:42:58.201
ARE LATINA WOMEN. SIGNIFICANT
02:42:58.268 --> 02:43:00.036
NUMBER OF THEM ARE POOR. A
02:43:00.103 --> 02:43:03.140
SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OF THEM DON'T
02:43:03.206 --> 02:43:04.341
HAVE THE RESOURCES THAT THEY
02:43:04.407 --> 02:43:05.442
NEED, AND THEY DESERVE. THE UTNE
02:43:05.509 --> 02:43:07.210
NOT BEFORE SOURCED. TO BE A
02:43:07.277 --> 02:43:10.514
PARENT WHEN THEY DON'T WANT TO,
02:43:10.580 --> 02:43:14.017
OR THEY CAN'T. THE ART TO BE
02:43:14.084 --> 02:43:18.321
ABLE TO HAVE A CHILD. WHEN. THEY
02:43:18.388 --> 02:43:20.757
CAN AND WHEN THEY WANT, AND TO
02:43:20.824 --> 02:43:23.660
ME, THAT'S WHAT THIS IS ABOUT IS
02:43:23.727 --> 02:43:24.828
PROTECTING THAT BASIC. RIGHT SO
02:43:24.895 --> 02:43:25.962
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MADAM
02:43:26.029 --> 02:43:29.866
PROTEST. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
02:43:29.933 --> 02:43:33.036
ALSO OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS.
02:43:33.103 --> 02:43:36.106
SEEING NONE. MADAM PRO TEM. YOU
02:43:36.173 --> 02:43:39.209
CARE CLOSE VERY QUICKLY. I THINK
02:43:39.276 --> 02:43:40.277
MY COLLEAGUES HAVE SAID A LOT OF
02:43:40.343 --> 02:43:41.511
WONDERFUL THINGS. AND I WANT TO
02:43:41.578 --> 02:43:43.513
THANK YOU FOR THAT. UM I WANT TO
02:43:43.580 --> 02:43:47.517
THANK PLANNED PARENTHOOD. ALL OF
02:43:47.584 --> 02:43:49.085
THE SPONSORS. THE HEALTH
02:43:49.152 --> 02:43:51.988
ADVOCATES THE FUTURE OF ABORTION
02:43:52.055 --> 02:43:53.056
COUNCIL WHO UNDERSTOOD WHAT WAS
02:43:53.123 --> 02:43:56.259
AT STAKE. RIGHT YOU CAN HAVE.
02:43:56.326 --> 02:43:57.627
BUT IF YOU DON'T HAVE THE
02:43:57.694 --> 02:44:00.197
SERVICES AVAILABLE TO YOU, IF
02:44:00.263 --> 02:44:01.865
YOU DON'T HAVE THE PROVIDERS
02:44:01.932 --> 02:44:04.034
AVAILABLE TO YOU, THEN IS IT
02:44:04.100 --> 02:44:05.235
REALLY A WRITER? AN OPTION THAT
02:44:05.302 --> 02:44:07.571
YOU HAVE? SO I REALLY WANT TO
02:44:07.637 --> 02:44:09.639
THANK THEM FOR THE WORK THAT
02:44:09.706 --> 02:44:10.907
THEY'VE DONE. I WANT TO THANK
02:44:10.974 --> 02:44:12.075
THE DOCTORS IN PARTICULAR WHO
02:44:12.142 --> 02:44:13.810
ARE ON THE FRONT LINES. DESPITE
02:44:13.877 --> 02:44:15.879
THE OPPOSITION AND EMOTION
02:44:15.946 --> 02:44:17.047
AROUND THIS ISSUE WHO CONTINUE
02:44:17.113 --> 02:44:19.082
TO PROVIDE SERVICES FOR THEIR
02:44:19.149 --> 02:44:22.519
PATIENTS. REGARDLESS. SO I WANT
02:44:22.586 --> 02:44:24.921
TO THANK YOU FOR THIS. THIS IS
02:44:24.988 --> 02:44:25.589
VERY IMPORTANT. I WANT TO THANK
02:44:25.655 --> 02:44:28.558
ALL OF YOU FOR SUPPORTING, UH,
02:44:28.625 --> 02:44:29.492
THIS CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
02:44:29.559 --> 02:44:30.727
THAT WE CAN PUT BEFORE THE
02:44:30.794 --> 02:44:32.862
PEOPLE AND THEY CAN REAFFIRM
02:44:32.929 --> 02:44:34.898
THEIR BELIEF THAT THIS IS HEALTH
02:44:34.965 --> 02:44:35.966
CARE, AND PEOPLE SHOULD HAVE
02:44:36.032 --> 02:44:37.767
THIS RIGHT. I ASK FOR YOUR
02:44:37.834 --> 02:44:40.036
SUPPORT AND YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU
02:44:40.103 --> 02:44:41.004
, MADAM PRO TEM MADAM SECRETARY
02:44:41.071 --> 02:44:42.305
. OH MOVED BY SENATOR WIENER. I
02:44:42.372 --> 02:44:43.873
BELIEVE, UM MADAM SECRETARY, IF
02:44:43.940 --> 02:44:46.910
YOU WOULD CALL THE ROLL. THE
02:44:46.977 --> 02:44:48.445
MOTION IS BE ADOPTED. BUT FIRST
02:44:48.511 --> 02:44:50.113
WE RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
02:44:50.180 --> 02:44:51.648
ON ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL
02:44:51.715 --> 02:44:52.449
AMENDMENTS. AMERICA. HAMBURG.
02:44:52.515 --> 02:44:57.287
I'VE GORGEOUS. CABALLERO. THE
02:44:57.354 --> 02:44:59.522
EURO. I DO RUSSELL LARA. SO I
02:44:59.589 --> 02:45:03.393
GONZALES. GONZALEZ I HERZBERG
02:45:03.460 --> 02:45:07.797
HERZBERG. I JONES JON SNOW,
02:45:07.864 --> 02:45:12.369
LAIRD, I STERN STERN. I
02:45:12.435 --> 02:45:13.637
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE
02:45:13.703 --> 02:45:20.076
WIENER. WIENER? AYE. YOU HAVE 9
02:45:20.143 --> 02:45:21.711
TO 1 WITH ALL MEMBERS HERE
02:45:21.778 --> 02:45:23.246
ALREADY. THANK YOU, UM,
02:45:23.313 --> 02:45:24.347
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT, 10 IS
02:45:24.414 --> 02:45:30.053
OUT. ALL RIGHT. AH! WE'RE GOING
02:45:30.120 --> 02:45:31.321
TO COME BACK TO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:45:31.388 --> 02:45:39.362
BY BAUER-KAHAN. AND NEXT WE HAVE
02:45:39.429 --> 02:45:48.238
ITEM NUMBER FIVE A B 25 71. MHM.
02:45:48.305 --> 02:45:51.941
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
02:45:52.008 --> 02:45:54.978
TODAY I AM PRESENTING A B 25 71
02:45:55.045 --> 02:45:56.346
A BILL THAT PROTECTS
02:45:56.413 --> 02:45:56.913
IMPRESSIONABLE CHILDREN FROM
02:45:56.980 --> 02:45:57.547
DANGEROUS FIREARM
02:45:57.614 --> 02:46:00.684
ADVERTISEMENTS. GUN VIOLENCE IS
02:46:00.750 --> 02:46:02.385
AT ITS MOST DEVASTATING WHEN IT
02:46:02.452 --> 02:46:04.888
THREATENS OUR CHILDREN IN 2021.
02:46:04.954 --> 02:46:07.223
THERE WERE APPROXIMATELY 259
02:46:07.290 --> 02:46:08.425
UNINTENTIONAL SHOOTINGS BY
02:46:08.491 --> 02:46:10.226
CHILDREN, RESULTING IN 104
02:46:10.293 --> 02:46:13.530
DEATHS AND 168 INJURIES. WEAPONS
02:46:13.596 --> 02:46:14.764
USED BY CHILDREN HAVE PUT OTHER
02:46:14.831 --> 02:46:18.268
CHILDREN AT RISK. 91% OF THE
02:46:18.335 --> 02:46:19.736
VICTIMS IN THE SHOOTINGS BY
02:46:19.803 --> 02:46:20.670
CHILDREN ARE ALSO CHILDREN,
02:46:20.737 --> 02:46:24.841
OFTEN SIBLINGS. IN CALIFORNIA
02:46:24.908 --> 02:46:26.543
GUN VIOLENCE IS THE THIRD
02:46:26.609 --> 02:46:27.944
LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH FOR
02:46:28.011 --> 02:46:30.347
CHILDREN AND TEENS. THE EPIDEMIC
02:46:30.413 --> 02:46:31.915
OF DEADLY VIOLENCE IS FUELED BY
02:46:31.981 --> 02:46:33.083
AN INDUSTRY THAT OCCURRED URGES
02:46:33.149 --> 02:46:35.151
CHILDREN TO HOLD A GUN AS SOON
02:46:35.218 --> 02:46:36.653
AS THEY CAN WALK. GUN
02:46:36.720 --> 02:46:38.855
MANUFACTURERS. TARGETS ARE KIDS
02:46:38.922 --> 02:46:39.356
WITH SLICK ADVERTISING,
02:46:39.422 --> 02:46:42.525
INCLUDING CHILDREN'S BOOKS. THE
02:46:42.592 --> 02:46:44.527
ADVERTISING FOR THESE WEAPONS IS
02:46:44.594 --> 02:46:46.629
SHAMELESS CHILDREN IN CALIFORNIA
02:46:46.696 --> 02:46:48.164
ARE NOT ALLOWED TO BUY A GUN.
02:46:48.231 --> 02:46:49.866
AND YET THEY ARE ADVERTISED,
02:46:49.933 --> 02:46:51.234
ADVERTISED TO ACROSS ALL FORMS
02:46:51.301 --> 02:46:52.469
OF MEDIA WITH CARTOONS, VIDEO
02:46:52.535 --> 02:46:55.372
GAMES AND SOCIAL MEDIA. MAYBE 25
02:46:55.438 --> 02:46:57.407
71 WILL PROHIBIT A PERSON OR
02:46:57.474 --> 02:46:59.843
ENTITY FROM PUBLISHING MATERIALS
02:46:59.909 --> 02:47:00.910
THAT ADVERTISE OR MARKET,
02:47:00.977 --> 02:47:02.245
FIREARMS OR WEAPONS TO ANYONE
02:47:02.312 --> 02:47:04.547
UNDER THE AGE OF 18. THE BILL
02:47:04.614 --> 02:47:05.849
WOULD ALLOW THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
02:47:05.915 --> 02:47:07.951
DISTRICT OR COUNTY ATTORNEY OR
02:47:08.017 --> 02:47:09.619
COUNTY COUNCIL TO BRING A CIVIL
02:47:09.686 --> 02:47:10.387
ACTION AGAINST EACH VIOLATION
02:47:10.453 --> 02:47:13.523
FOR UP TO $25,000 WITH ME TODAY
02:47:13.590 --> 02:47:14.924
IN PERSON IS CRYSTAL LOBE. ALITO
02:47:14.991 --> 02:47:16.659
FROM THE MOMS DEMAND ACTION AND
02:47:16.726 --> 02:47:17.827
BY PHONE, ALEXA BROWNING FROM
02:47:17.894 --> 02:47:20.430
MARCH FOR OUR LIVES. MS LABELLE
02:47:20.497 --> 02:47:26.369
ITO. GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
02:47:26.436 --> 02:47:28.605
CRYSTAL, OPAL OTTO AND THE MOM
02:47:28.671 --> 02:47:29.706
LIVING IN THE BAY AREA AND A
02:47:29.773 --> 02:47:30.640
VOLUNTEER LEADER WITH THE
02:47:30.707 --> 02:47:31.841
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER OF MOMS
02:47:31.908 --> 02:47:33.810
DEMAND ACTION FOR GUN SENSE. IN
02:47:33.877 --> 02:47:35.378
THAT ROLE I CONNECT WITH PARENTS
02:47:35.445 --> 02:47:36.679
AND OTHER CONCERNED COMMUNITY
02:47:36.746 --> 02:47:37.814
MEMBERS ALL AROUND THE STATE WHO
02:47:37.881 --> 02:47:39.716
WANT TO SEE CALIFORNIA LEAD THE
02:47:39.783 --> 02:47:40.784
WAY ON GUN VIOLENCE PREVENTION.
02:47:40.850 --> 02:47:41.751
I HAVE A DAUGHTER ENTERING
02:47:41.818 --> 02:47:43.653
KINDERGARTEN THIS YEAR. THAT
02:47:43.720 --> 02:47:45.321
MILESTONE BRINGS EXCITEMENT OVER
02:47:45.388 --> 02:47:47.090
NEW FRIENDS AND NEW LEARNING
02:47:47.157 --> 02:47:49.192
OPPORTUNITIES. BUT FOR PARENTS
02:47:49.259 --> 02:47:50.760
RIGHT NOW, IT ALSO BRINGS NEW
02:47:50.827 --> 02:47:52.195
WORRIES OVER HOW TO EXPLAIN
02:47:52.262 --> 02:47:54.330
ACTIVE SHOOTER DRILLS AND HOW TO
02:47:54.397 --> 02:47:55.131
EVENTUALLY EXPLAINED THAT
02:47:55.198 --> 02:47:56.499
SOMETIMES KIDS WHO SHOULDN'T
02:47:56.566 --> 02:47:58.735
HAVE ACCESS TO GUNS. DO YOU GET
02:47:58.802 --> 02:47:59.903
ACCESS AND BRING THOSE DEADLY
02:47:59.969 --> 02:48:01.838
WEAPONS TO SCHOOL? AS WE PLAN
02:48:01.905 --> 02:48:03.373
FOR PLAYDATES AFTER RECORD
02:48:03.440 --> 02:48:05.375
SPIKES AND NEW FIREARM PURCHASES
02:48:05.442 --> 02:48:07.377
. PART OF MY JOB AS A MOM NOW
02:48:07.444 --> 02:48:08.812
REQUIRES ASKING OTHER PARENTS,
02:48:08.878 --> 02:48:10.113
WHETHER ANY FIREARMS THEY OWN
02:48:10.180 --> 02:48:12.482
ARE STORED SECURELY. AND MAKING
02:48:12.549 --> 02:48:14.083
SURE MY KID UNDERSTANDS THAT
02:48:14.150 --> 02:48:15.752
GUNS ARE NOT TOYS WHEN SHE
02:48:15.819 --> 02:48:17.587
VISITS FRIENDS AND FAMILY WHO
02:48:17.654 --> 02:48:20.223
OWN FIREARMS. ADVERTISING GUNS
02:48:20.290 --> 02:48:21.624
TO MINORS BY USING STUFFED
02:48:21.691 --> 02:48:23.326
ANIMALS AND CARTOON CHARACTERS
02:48:23.393 --> 02:48:25.028
COMPLICATES OUR ABILITY TO MAKE
02:48:25.094 --> 02:48:26.362
THAT CLEAR DISTINCTION TO YOUNG
02:48:26.429 --> 02:48:28.498
KIDS THAT GUNS ARE NOT TOYS.
02:48:28.565 --> 02:48:29.699
THAT IMPORTANT MESSAGE IS
02:48:29.766 --> 02:48:31.000
UNDERMINED WHEN THE STATE ALLOWS
02:48:31.067 --> 02:48:32.402
GUNS TO BE ADVERTISED IN WAYS
02:48:32.469 --> 02:48:34.204
DESIGNED TO APPEAL TO CHILDREN.
02:48:34.270 --> 02:48:35.371
ALLUDING IN ONE INSTANCE WITH
02:48:35.438 --> 02:48:37.307
THE USE OF A PACIFIER IN THE
02:48:37.373 --> 02:48:39.476
LOGO. MAYBE 25 71 WOULD PROHIBIT
02:48:39.542 --> 02:48:40.677
ADVERTISING, FIREARMS AND
02:48:40.743 --> 02:48:42.245
MATERIALS DIRECTED TO CHILDREN
02:48:42.312 --> 02:48:44.180
AND PROHIBIT PUBLICATION OF
02:48:44.247 --> 02:48:44.747
FIREARMS ADVERTISEMENTS OR
02:48:44.814 --> 02:48:45.548
MARKETING MATERIALS THAT ARE%
02:48:45.615 --> 02:48:48.051
ATTRACTIVE TO MINORS ARE STATE
02:48:48.117 --> 02:48:49.052
LAWS ALREADY ACKNOWLEDGED TWO
02:48:49.118 --> 02:48:50.653
TRUTHS. ONE FIREARMS ARE
02:48:50.720 --> 02:48:51.588
ESPECIALLY DANGEROUS IN THE
02:48:51.654 --> 02:48:53.890
HANDS OF MINORS AND TWO WE HAVE
02:48:53.957 --> 02:48:55.658
A RESPONSIBILITY TO REGULATE THE
02:48:55.725 --> 02:48:57.494
MARKETING OF DANGEROUS PRODUCTS
02:48:57.560 --> 02:49:00.230
TO MINORS. 25 71 BUILDS A BRIDGE
02:49:00.296 --> 02:49:01.397
BETWEEN THOSE TWO CONCEPTS AND
02:49:01.464 --> 02:49:03.933
CLOSES THE GAP IN OUR STATE LAW.
02:49:04.000 --> 02:49:05.001
BY REGULATING THE MARKETING OF
02:49:05.068 --> 02:49:07.237
FIREARMS TO CHILDREN. ALLOWING
02:49:07.303 --> 02:49:08.605
FIREARM ADVERTISEMENTS THAT ARE
02:49:08.671 --> 02:49:09.305
DESIGNED TO BE ATTRACTIVE TO
02:49:09.372 --> 02:49:10.773
KIDS PROMOTES A GUNS EVERYWHERE
02:49:10.840 --> 02:49:12.542
CULTURE THAT TRAGICALLY RESULTS
02:49:12.609 --> 02:49:13.776
IN SOME KIDS GETTING ACCESS TO
02:49:13.843 --> 02:49:15.478
GUNS AND HARMING THEMSELVES OR
02:49:15.545 --> 02:49:16.513
OTHERS. WE SHOULDN'T ALLOW FOR
02:49:16.579 --> 02:49:18.348
PROFIT COMPANIES TO INUNDATE OUR
02:49:18.414 --> 02:49:20.116
KIDS WITH ADS SUGGESTING THAT
02:49:20.183 --> 02:49:21.584
DEADLY WEAPONS ARE DESIRABLE. OY
02:49:21.651 --> 02:49:23.720
WE URGE YOUR I VOTE ON TV 25 71
02:49:23.786 --> 02:49:26.656
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. UM AND DO
02:49:26.723 --> 02:49:28.658
WE HAVE, UM ALEX BROWNING ON THE
02:49:28.725 --> 02:49:36.065
PHONE? YES. GO AHEAD. HELLO MY
02:49:36.132 --> 02:49:37.367
NAME IS ALEXIA BROWNING AND I'M
02:49:37.433 --> 02:49:39.269
ON THE POLICY TEAM AT MARCH FOR
02:49:39.335 --> 02:49:40.570
ALLIES. MATERIALIZES FOUNDED IN
02:49:40.637 --> 02:49:42.539
2018 AFTER THE TRAGIC SCHOOL
02:49:42.605 --> 02:49:43.706
SHOOTING AT MARJORY STONEMAN
02:49:43.773 --> 02:49:45.275
DOUGLAS HIGH SCHOOL IN PARKLAND
02:49:45.341 --> 02:49:47.176
, FLORIDA ORGANIZATION IS YOUTH
02:49:47.243 --> 02:49:48.511
DRIVEN, AND OUR GOAL IS TO
02:49:48.578 --> 02:49:49.579
CREATE SAFE AND HEALTHY
02:49:49.646 --> 02:49:51.614
COMMUNITIES. FOR GUN VIOLENCE IS
02:49:51.681 --> 02:49:53.917
POLICE MARCH FOR OUR LIVES IS
02:49:53.983 --> 02:49:54.984
UNEQUIVOCALLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS
02:49:55.051 --> 02:49:57.120
BILL. CURRENT LAWS, RESTRICT
02:49:57.186 --> 02:49:58.321
CONTENT, PLACEMENT OF
02:49:58.388 --> 02:49:59.522
ADVERTISING AND PROMOTIONAL
02:49:59.589 --> 02:50:01.624
MARKETING FOR ALCOHOL, CANNABIS
02:50:01.691 --> 02:50:03.593
AND TOBACCO IN ORDER FOR TO
02:50:03.660 --> 02:50:05.328
PROTECT MINORS. THIS PREVENTS
02:50:05.395 --> 02:50:07.230
POTENTIALLY HARMFUL SUBSTANCES.
02:50:07.297 --> 02:50:08.698
FROM GETTING IN THE HANDS OF
02:50:08.765 --> 02:50:10.266
YOUNG PEOPLE. IT'S TIME WE DO
02:50:10.333 --> 02:50:12.068
THE SAME WHEN IT COMES TO
02:50:12.135 --> 02:50:13.069
PROTECTING MINORS FROM GUN
02:50:13.136 --> 02:50:16.339
GLORIFICATION. FIREARMS OF THE
02:50:16.406 --> 02:50:17.807
LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH FOR
02:50:17.874 --> 02:50:19.509
CHILDREN AND TEENS IN THE UNITED
02:50:19.576 --> 02:50:20.543
STATES AND THE THIRD LEADING
02:50:20.610 --> 02:50:22.912
CAUSE OF DEATH FOR CHILDREN AND
02:50:22.979 --> 02:50:24.013
TEENS IN CALIFORNIA AT A VERY
02:50:24.080 --> 02:50:25.982
EARLY AGE. YOUNG PEOPLE HAVE
02:50:26.049 --> 02:50:27.383
BEEN FACED WITH SCHOOL SHOOTING
02:50:27.450 --> 02:50:29.052
DRILLS, LOSING A LOVED ONE TO
02:50:29.118 --> 02:50:30.753
DEATH BY FIREARMS AND ANXIOUSLY
02:50:30.820 --> 02:50:31.854
LOOKING FOR EXITS AT CONCERTS
02:50:31.921 --> 02:50:34.657
AND MOVIE THEATERS. YOUNG PEOPLE
02:50:34.724 --> 02:50:36.693
ARE EXPERIENCING TRAUMA DUE TO
02:50:36.759 --> 02:50:38.561
GUN VIOLENCE THAT'S UNIQUE AND
02:50:38.628 --> 02:50:40.830
DEVASTATING TO OUR GENERATION.
02:50:40.897 --> 02:50:42.765
MY GENERATION IS SICK AND TIRED
02:50:42.832 --> 02:50:44.634
OF BEING AFRAID WERE SO FED UP
02:50:44.701 --> 02:50:47.670
THAT THIS PAST SATURDAY, 450
02:50:47.737 --> 02:50:48.771
PLUS MARCHES WERE HELD
02:50:48.838 --> 02:50:50.807
APPROXIMATION TO CALL ON OUR
02:50:50.873 --> 02:50:53.009
LEGISLATORS TO TAKE ACTION ON
02:50:53.076 --> 02:50:53.910
GUN VIOLENCE PREVENTION
02:50:53.977 --> 02:50:57.380
LEGISLATION JUST LIKE A B +2571.
02:50:57.447 --> 02:50:59.983
HOWEVER DESPITE THE EVERY LIMIT
02:51:00.049 --> 02:51:00.883
GUN VIOLENCE WE SEE FIREARM
02:51:00.950 --> 02:51:01.851
MANUFACTURERS MARKETING TO
02:51:01.918 --> 02:51:05.555
MINORS. WE'RE SEEING COMPANIES
02:51:05.622 --> 02:51:07.890
COME OUT WITH THEIR 15 STYLE
02:51:07.957 --> 02:51:08.891
GUNS FOR CHILDREN AND MARKETING
02:51:08.958 --> 02:51:11.961
THEM TO MINORS BY INCLUDING-CARTOON CHARACTERS AND SAYING
02:51:12.028 --> 02:51:13.863
THAT GUNS SHOOT, JUST LIKE MOM
02:51:13.930 --> 02:51:16.666
AND DAD'S DONE. YET COMPLETELY.
02:51:16.733 --> 02:51:18.201
THEY DISREGARD THE HARM THAT
02:51:18.267 --> 02:51:19.302
FIREARMS CAN CAUSE TO YOUNG
02:51:19.369 --> 02:51:21.771
PEOPLE. MARCH FOR LIFE PIECES
02:51:21.838 --> 02:51:23.539
BILL AS A CHANCE TO HOLD THE GUN
02:51:23.606 --> 02:51:25.108
INDUSTRY ACCOUNTABLE AND KEEP
02:51:25.174 --> 02:51:27.210
YOUNG PEOPLE SAFE. CALIFORNIA IS
02:51:27.276 --> 02:51:29.278
A LEADER WHEN IT COMES TO GUN
02:51:29.345 --> 02:51:30.346
REFORM, AND WE SHOULD CONTINUE
02:51:30.413 --> 02:51:32.315
TO SHOW THE REST OF THE COUNTRY
02:51:32.382 --> 02:51:33.383
HOW IMPORTANT IT IS TO RESTRICT
02:51:33.449 --> 02:51:34.584
THE ADVERTISEMENT OF FIREARMS TO
02:51:34.651 --> 02:51:37.220
MINORS BY PASSING A B 2571.
02:51:37.286 --> 02:51:41.658
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
02:51:41.724 --> 02:51:45.495
OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF A B 25 71
02:51:45.561 --> 02:51:46.262
THE PRESENT HERE IN THE
02:51:46.329 --> 02:51:47.830
COMMITTEE ROOM. GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:51:47.897 --> 02:51:49.065
AFTERNOON, REBECCA MARCUS,
02:51:49.132 --> 02:51:50.299
REPRESENTING THE BRADY CAMPAIGN
02:51:50.366 --> 02:51:52.402
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:51:52.468 --> 02:51:53.603
THANK YOU. OTHERS IN SUPPORT
02:51:53.670 --> 02:51:55.238
HERE IN ROOM TWENTY ONE HUNDRED
02:51:55.304 --> 02:51:58.007
SIX Ó. GO AHEAD. CASSANDRA WEB
02:51:58.074 --> 02:51:59.776
STONE. I'M A VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS
02:51:59.842 --> 02:52:00.943
DEMAND ACTION FROM FOLSOM AND
02:52:01.010 --> 02:52:02.745
I'M IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
02:52:02.812 --> 02:52:05.548
THANK YOU. EMILY ALL AMONG
02:52:05.615 --> 02:52:06.649
DEMAND ACTION VOLUNTEER FROM
02:52:06.716 --> 02:52:08.651
DAVIS AND I'M IN SUPPORT OF THIS
02:52:08.718 --> 02:52:10.153
BILL. THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE
02:52:10.219 --> 02:52:11.621
HERE IN ROOM 2100 SEEING NO ONE
02:52:11.688 --> 02:52:12.789
ELSE PRESENT. ALRIGHT, LET'S
02:52:12.855 --> 02:52:13.956
TURN TO THE PHONE LINES FOR
02:52:14.023 --> 02:52:17.660
THOSE IN SUPPORT OF A B 25 71
02:52:17.727 --> 02:52:18.795
MODERATOR, IF YOU WOULD QUEUE
02:52:18.861 --> 02:52:22.031
THEM UP, PLEASE. YES. IF YOU'RE
02:52:22.098 --> 02:52:23.666
IN SUPPORT OF A B 25 71, PLEASE
02:52:23.733 --> 02:52:28.237
PRESS ONE THAN ZERO. AND WE WILL
02:52:28.304 --> 02:52:30.239
START WITH LINE TO 37. PLEASE GO
02:52:30.306 --> 02:52:33.476
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND
02:52:33.543 --> 02:52:35.111
MEMBERS NICOLE KENYANS ON BEHALF
02:52:35.178 --> 02:52:37.146
OF EVERY TOWN FOR GUN SAFETY AND
02:52:37.213 --> 02:52:38.247
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
02:52:38.314 --> 02:52:41.484
YOU. NEXT LINE. 1 95, PLEASE GO
02:52:41.551 --> 02:52:46.355
AHEAD. CHRIS MEYERS WITH THE
02:52:46.422 --> 02:52:46.923
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
02:52:46.989 --> 02:52:50.626
ASSOCIATION AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:52:50.693 --> 02:52:51.894
NEXT TO SIGN 2 39, PLEASE GO
02:52:51.961 --> 02:52:56.065
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON. THIS IS
02:52:56.132 --> 02:52:58.134
JIM LINDBERG ON BEHALF OF THE
02:52:58.201 --> 02:52:59.535
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON LEGISLATION
02:52:59.602 --> 02:53:00.737
TO CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
02:53:00.803 --> 02:53:03.573
YOU. THANK YOU. THE NEXUS LINE.
02:53:03.639 --> 02:53:11.781
1 62, PLEASE GO AHEAD. AND 1 62
02:53:11.848 --> 02:53:16.953
YEAR MINUS OPEN. HI. GOOD
02:53:17.019 --> 02:53:18.554
AFTERNOON. TURN MEMBERS JAVELIN
02:53:18.621 --> 02:53:19.589
. COOPER FROM NIELSEN BIRK
02:53:19.655 --> 02:53:21.557
SUMMER ON BEHALF OF THE COUNTY
02:53:21.624 --> 02:53:23.960
OF INDIEGOGO AND SUPPORT AND
02:53:24.026 --> 02:53:25.528
CUTE. NEXT DESIGN. 17, PLEASE GO
02:53:25.595 --> 02:53:30.032
AHEAD. YOU KNOW, AFTERNOON. MY
02:53:30.099 --> 02:53:31.667
NAME IS DYLAN IN THE SHADE FROM
02:53:31.734 --> 02:53:32.635
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
02:53:32.702 --> 02:53:34.937
SPECIAL WORKERS CHAPTER AND I'M
02:53:35.004 --> 02:53:36.506
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF 25 71.
02:53:36.572 --> 02:53:40.710
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT
02:53:40.777 --> 02:53:45.782
SLIDE. 1 73, PLEASE GO AHEAD. MY
02:53:45.848 --> 02:53:47.283
NAME IS RAYMOND POLLUTION
02:53:47.350 --> 02:53:49.719
CALLING FROM CLAREMONT, AND I'M
02:53:49.786 --> 02:53:51.087
A VOLUNTEER WITH MOM DEMANDS
02:53:51.154 --> 02:53:52.388
THEIR MOMS DEMAND ACTION AND
02:53:52.455 --> 02:53:54.524
VERY TOWN FOR GUN SAFETY. AND
02:53:54.590 --> 02:53:57.627
FAMILIAR. INTIMATELY THANK YOU,
02:53:57.693 --> 02:54:00.363
SIR. NEXT PLACE. HELLO. THANK
02:54:00.429 --> 02:54:05.034
YOU. OKAY. GOODBYE BUT WE HAVE
02:54:05.101 --> 02:54:09.405
LINES. I WASN'T ABLE TO WAS
02:54:09.472 --> 02:54:10.673
INTERRUPTED. I WASN'T ABLE TO
02:54:10.740 --> 02:54:12.675
FINISH. YES THAT WAS INTENTIONAL
02:54:12.742 --> 02:54:13.810
SUPPORTED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
02:54:13.876 --> 02:54:16.179
ALRIGHT. NEXT. THANK YOU. MIX OF
02:54:16.245 --> 02:54:20.516
LINE 2 42, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:54:20.583 --> 02:54:21.984
BLOOD WITH CAFFREY IN SUPPORT.
02:54:22.051 --> 02:54:26.222
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
02:54:26.289 --> 02:54:27.824
IS ALL THAT I HAVE BEEN QUÊ.
02:54:27.890 --> 02:54:29.792
ALRIGHT LET'S NOW TURN TO
02:54:29.859 --> 02:54:31.794
OPPOSITION. UM I'M I'M NOT AWARE
02:54:31.861 --> 02:54:33.396
OF ANY OPPOSITION WITNESSES WHO
02:54:33.462 --> 02:54:35.398
ARE HERE OR WISH TO TESTIFY AND
02:54:35.464 --> 02:54:37.366
PRIMARY OPPOSITION. IF ANYONE IS
02:54:37.433 --> 02:54:40.536
IN OPPOSED TO A B 25 71 HERE IN
02:54:40.603 --> 02:54:42.104
ROOM 2100 PLEASE APPROACH
02:54:42.171 --> 02:54:43.339
MICROPHONE, SAYING NONE
02:54:43.406 --> 02:54:44.907
MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP
02:54:44.974 --> 02:54:47.910
THOSE WHO ARE OPPOSED TO A B 25
02:54:47.977 --> 02:54:48.978
71 ON THE PHONE. THAT WOULD BE
02:54:49.045 --> 02:54:51.781
GREAT. THANK YOU IF YOU'RE
02:54:51.848 --> 02:54:54.050
OPPOSED TO A B 25 71, PLEASE
02:54:54.116 --> 02:55:01.224
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO. AND ONE
02:55:01.290 --> 02:55:02.291
MOMENT WHILE WE GET LINE
02:55:02.358 --> 02:55:18.474
NUMBERS.
02:55:24.881 --> 02:55:26.249
WE'LL START WITH THE LINE TO 38.
02:55:26.315 --> 02:55:30.686
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS
02:55:30.753 --> 02:55:31.587
SAM PERATIS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
02:55:31.654 --> 02:55:33.122
OF GUN OWNERS OF CALIFORNIA AND
02:55:33.189 --> 02:55:35.024
ON BEHALF OF THE NATIONAL RIFLE
02:55:35.091 --> 02:55:35.791
ASSOCIATION AND THE NATIONAL
02:55:35.858 --> 02:55:37.226
SHOOTING SPORTS FOUNDATION. WE
02:55:37.293 --> 02:55:39.061
ARE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL.
02:55:39.128 --> 02:55:43.966
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
02:55:44.033 --> 02:55:47.536
IS ALL THAT I HADN'T QUÊ ALRIGHT
02:55:47.603 --> 02:55:49.939
. BRING IT BACK NOW TO COMMITTEE
02:55:50.006 --> 02:55:51.040
QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE MEMBER
02:55:51.107 --> 02:55:56.178
SENATOR BORDERS. SO I HAVE 22
02:55:56.245 --> 02:55:58.147
LITTLE BOYS. UM AND I'M PAYING
02:55:58.214 --> 02:56:01.884
ATTENTION. TO THESE THINGS MORE
02:56:01.951 --> 02:56:04.287
THAN I THINK I DID BEFORE. AND
02:56:04.353 --> 02:56:06.155
CERTAINLY MODERATOR 11 2ND
02:56:06.222 --> 02:56:07.189
CENTERBOARD, JUST MODERATOR IF
02:56:07.256 --> 02:56:10.860
YOU COULD CUT OFF THE PHONE LINE
02:56:10.927 --> 02:56:12.995
YES, I AM TRYING, SIR. THANK YOU
02:56:13.062 --> 02:56:13.896
. ALL RIGHT, SENATOR BOARD. JUST
02:56:13.963 --> 02:56:16.265
GO AHEAD. AND, UH UM OBVIOUSLY
02:56:16.332 --> 02:56:17.466
WHAT HAS HAPPENED, UH, WITH HIS
02:56:17.533 --> 02:56:21.704
SCHOOL VIOLENCE HAS BROUGHT THIS
02:56:21.771 --> 02:56:24.240
TO A HEAD. MAYBE YOU CAN WALK ME
02:56:24.307 --> 02:56:26.309
THROUGH SOME OF THE BASICS,
02:56:26.375 --> 02:56:28.077
THOUGH, BECAUSE I THINK THE IDEA
02:56:28.144 --> 02:56:30.579
IS YOU WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE AND
02:56:30.646 --> 02:56:31.147
RESPECT THE CONSTITUTIONAL
02:56:31.213 --> 02:56:35.918
RIGHTS? UM OF SPEECH. WE ALSO
02:56:35.985 --> 02:56:37.753
NEED TO FIGURE OUT WAYS TO
02:56:37.820 --> 02:56:38.888
PROTECT PUBLIC SAFETY. THERE'S
02:56:38.955 --> 02:56:42.925
ALWAYS A BALANCE WITH THAT. SO.
02:56:42.992 --> 02:56:44.560
JUST KIND OF RAPID FIRE. DOES
02:56:44.627 --> 02:56:47.330
THIS PERTAIN TO, UH RECREATIONAL
02:56:47.396 --> 02:56:48.597
GUNS LIKE BB GUNS AND STUFF LIKE
02:56:48.664 --> 02:56:55.571
THAT. MY MICHAEL. THERE WE GO.
02:56:55.638 --> 02:56:57.673
YOU COULDN'T HEAR ME. UM O THIS
02:56:57.740 --> 02:57:01.344
WOULD APPLY TO ALL, UM, GUNS
02:57:01.410 --> 02:57:02.378
MANUFACTURED? I DON'T KNOW IF
02:57:02.445 --> 02:57:04.313
WE'VE LOOKED AT THE QUESTION OF
02:57:04.380 --> 02:57:05.514
BB GUNS. I HAVE BEEN ASKED THAT
02:57:05.581 --> 02:57:07.984
QUESTION BEFORE CENTER FOR JUST
02:57:08.050 --> 02:57:09.986
SO I'D HAVE TO TAKE A LOOK AT
02:57:10.052 --> 02:57:10.586
THAT ADDED TO YOUR LIST. OKAY,
02:57:10.653 --> 02:57:13.356
UM ALSO SO WE HAVE, UM, LAWFUL,
02:57:13.422 --> 02:57:16.559
UM, ADVERTISEMENTS THAT AREN'T
02:57:16.625 --> 02:57:18.461
SENSATIONALIZING, BUT OUR
02:57:18.527 --> 02:57:20.396
ADVERTISING PRODUCTS, YOU KNOW,
02:57:20.463 --> 02:57:22.498
LET'S SAY YOU HAVE YOU HAVE
02:57:22.565 --> 02:57:24.033
YOUNG HUNTERS, FOR EXAMPLE.
02:57:24.100 --> 02:57:25.267
WOULD WOULD THIS BE CONSIDERED
02:57:25.334 --> 02:57:28.170
IN ADVERTISEMENT? THAT WOULD
02:57:28.237 --> 02:57:29.772
FALL WITHIN THE JURISDICTION OF
02:57:29.839 --> 02:57:31.841
THIS OF THIS PIECE OF
02:57:31.907 --> 02:57:33.175
LEGISLATION THAT WOULD DISALLOW
02:57:33.242 --> 02:57:35.678
AN ADVERTISEMENT FOR LET'S SAY,
02:57:35.745 --> 02:57:37.413
UM, SHOOTING RIFLE IF YOU'RE A
02:57:37.480 --> 02:57:42.284
YOUNG HUNTER. SO IN CALIFORNIA
02:57:42.351 --> 02:57:45.421
AS YOU I'M SURE WELL AWARE IS
02:57:45.488 --> 02:57:46.956
INDIVIDUALS UNDER 18 CANNOT
02:57:47.023 --> 02:57:49.091
PURCHASE MOST WEAPONS AS YOU
02:57:49.158 --> 02:57:50.259
KNOW, RIGHT THOSE BUT THEY CAN
02:57:50.326 --> 02:57:52.428
GET IT FROM, YOU KNOW.
02:57:52.495 --> 02:57:54.196
INSTRUCTED WITH INSTRUCTIONS
02:57:54.263 --> 02:57:55.664
RIGHT AND WE THIS DOES NOT
02:57:55.731 --> 02:57:57.900
RELATE TO THE ADVERTISING OF AN
02:57:57.967 --> 02:58:00.036
INSTRUCTIONAL PROGRAM IF YOU
02:58:00.102 --> 02:58:01.604
WILL, RIGHT, SO I THINK MAYBE
02:58:01.670 --> 02:58:03.072
THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE GETTING AT.
02:58:03.139 --> 02:58:04.874
BUT IF THEY WERE TO BE
02:58:04.940 --> 02:58:05.975
ADVERTISING THE WEAPON TO A
02:58:06.042 --> 02:58:07.977
CHILD THAT IT WOULD INCLUDE THAT
02:58:08.044 --> 02:58:09.545
BUT NOT A PROGRAM, SO IT ONLY
02:58:09.612 --> 02:58:10.946
APPLIES TO GUN MANUFACTURERS.
02:58:11.013 --> 02:58:12.782
RIGHT LOGGED. IMAGINE YOU'RE YOU
02:58:12.848 --> 02:58:14.250
HAVE A CATALOG LOOKING THROUGH
02:58:14.316 --> 02:58:15.484
THE CATALOG. LET'S SAY IT'S A
02:58:15.551 --> 02:58:17.720
HUNTER'S CATALOG. WHATEVER. AND
02:58:17.787 --> 02:58:19.321
YOU'RE LOOKING AT IT, AND IT'S
02:58:19.388 --> 02:58:22.992
CLEARLY A SMALL WINCHESTER RED
02:58:23.059 --> 02:58:26.695
RIDER BY DATING MYSELF HERE
02:58:26.762 --> 02:58:28.898
TALKING ABOUT, THOUGH I MUST BE
02:58:28.964 --> 02:58:30.933
THE SAME CHRISTMAS STORY. YES
02:58:31.000 --> 02:58:32.501
SOMETHING SOMETHING LIKE THAT.
02:58:32.568 --> 02:58:34.336
THAT IS IN A CATALOG THAT THAT
02:58:34.403 --> 02:58:36.906
APPLIES TO EVERYONE. MOSTLY
02:58:36.972 --> 02:58:38.574
ADULT PURCHASERS, BUT IT COULD
02:58:38.641 --> 02:58:40.843
BE VIEWED BY BY YOUNGSTERS.
02:58:40.910 --> 02:58:42.344
THERE'S SOMETHING LIKE THAT FALL
02:58:42.411 --> 02:58:43.846
WITHIN THIS, SO IF YOU LOOK AT
02:58:43.913 --> 02:58:45.548
THE BILL, NOW THAT I UNDERSTAND
02:58:45.614 --> 02:58:46.882
WHAT YOU'RE ASKING TRYING TO
02:58:46.949 --> 02:58:48.350
YES, YES, YES, SO IT REALLY
02:58:48.417 --> 02:58:49.752
REQUIRES WHEN LOOKING AT WHETHER
02:58:49.819 --> 02:58:50.853
THE MARKETING OR ADVERTISING IS
02:58:50.920 --> 02:58:52.221
TARGETED TO A CHILD RIGHT?
02:58:52.288 --> 02:58:54.390
BECAUSE THERE'S ALSO THIS YOU
02:58:54.457 --> 02:58:56.425
KNOW, I HAVE A 12 YEAR OLD
02:58:56.492 --> 02:58:57.293
MYSELF RIGHT AND ADVERTISING
02:58:57.359 --> 02:58:58.627
THAT IS TARGETED TO ME. HE'S
02:58:58.694 --> 02:59:00.963
OFTEN ATTRACTED TO RIGHT. SO IF
02:59:01.030 --> 02:59:02.531
THE BILL IS VERY CLEAR THAT IT
02:59:02.598 --> 02:59:05.167
HAS TO USE CARICATURES. YOU KNOW
02:59:05.234 --> 02:59:06.735
THAT REASONABLY APPEAR TO BE
02:59:06.802 --> 02:59:08.170
MINORS OR CARTOON CHARACTERS
02:59:08.237 --> 02:59:09.872
RIGHT? IT TALKS ABOUT OFFERING
02:59:09.939 --> 02:59:11.474
STUFFED ANIMALS RIGHT, SO IT
02:59:11.540 --> 02:59:12.875
REALLY DOES DELINEATE WHAT THE
02:59:12.942 --> 02:59:14.276
COURTS ARE SUPPOSED TO LOOK AT,
02:59:14.343 --> 02:59:16.512
UM, DEPICTIONS OF MINORS IN THE
02:59:16.579 --> 02:59:18.080
ADVERTISING RIGHT? AND SO THAT
02:59:18.147 --> 02:59:19.882
LIST THAT'S IN THE LEGISLATION
02:59:19.949 --> 02:59:20.816
REALLY GIVES THE COORDINATOR
02:59:20.883 --> 02:59:22.351
STANDING OF WHAT WE'RE LOOKING
02:59:22.418 --> 02:59:23.586
FOR, AND THESE ARE
02:59:23.652 --> 02:59:24.453
ADVERTISEMENTS THAT WOULD BE
02:59:24.520 --> 02:59:25.354
TARGETED DIRECTLY TO CHILDREN.
02:59:25.421 --> 02:59:27.089
THAT WOULD NOT BE SOMETHING THAT
02:59:27.156 --> 02:59:28.424
IS TARGETED TO YOU. IF YOU WILL.
02:59:28.491 --> 02:59:30.326
I MEAN, THESE ARE THE DELINEATED
02:59:30.392 --> 02:59:31.560
STATUTE, I THINK IS CLEAR ON
02:59:31.627 --> 02:59:33.395
WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. OKAY
02:59:33.462 --> 02:59:36.298
SO A JUNIOR OLYMPICS SPONSORED
02:59:36.365 --> 02:59:39.401
AYE, ADVERTISEMENT THAT THAT
02:59:39.468 --> 02:59:42.571
THAT IDENTIFIES, UM SHOOTING AS
02:59:42.638 --> 02:59:44.473
ONE OF THE ONE OF THE OLYMPIC
02:59:44.540 --> 02:59:48.978
EVENTS. DESIGNED TO BE READ BY
02:59:49.044 --> 02:59:53.716
THAT AGE GROUP WOULD BE INCLUDED
02:59:53.782 --> 02:59:55.784
IN THIS BECAUSE THE BILL ALSO
02:59:55.851 --> 02:59:57.319
APPLIES. SORRY INTERACTED. YOU
02:59:57.386 --> 02:59:58.821
GO AHEAD. GO AHEAD APPLIESTO
02:59:58.888 --> 03:00:00.322
FIREARM INDUSTRY MEMBERS, WHICH
03:00:00.389 --> 03:00:02.725
IS DEFINED AS MANUFACTURING,
03:00:02.791 --> 03:00:03.592
DISTRIBUTION, IMPORTATION,
03:00:03.659 --> 03:00:05.327
MARKETING, WHOLESALE OR RETAIL
03:00:05.394 --> 03:00:06.462
SALE OF FIREARMS PRODUCTS, SO
03:00:06.529 --> 03:00:07.363
THE SPECIAL OLYMPICS WOULD NOT
03:00:07.429 --> 03:00:11.433
FALL UNDER THAT. OKAY, UM I AM
03:00:11.500 --> 03:00:13.569
SHOCKED AT HOW VIDEO GAMES ARE
03:00:13.636 --> 03:00:16.472
AND SOMETHING LIKE THAT. IS THAT
03:00:16.539 --> 03:00:17.940
ALSO INCLUDED IN THIS BECAUSE
03:00:18.007 --> 03:00:19.842
WOULD IT HAVE TO BE OF A
03:00:19.909 --> 03:00:22.545
SUFFICIENT? LEVEL OF DETAIL SO
03:00:22.611 --> 03:00:25.281
THAT A VIDEO GAME PLAYER COULD
03:00:25.347 --> 03:00:28.851
ASSOCIATE A STYLE OF WEAPON. SO
03:00:28.918 --> 03:00:30.986
AGAIN, THE BILL ONLY APPLIES TO
03:00:31.053 --> 03:00:33.022
THE MANUFACTURER OR SOMEONE WHO
03:00:33.088 --> 03:00:35.457
SELLS FIREARMS RIGHT, SO VIDEO
03:00:35.524 --> 03:00:37.059
GAME MANUFACTURER WOULD NOT BE
03:00:37.126 --> 03:00:38.327
CAPTURED IN THIS AT ALL. BUT IF
03:00:38.394 --> 03:00:40.396
THEY IF IT WAS A VIDEO GAME MADE
03:00:40.462 --> 03:00:42.131
BY A GUN MANUFACTURER THAT WAS
03:00:42.198 --> 03:00:43.432
TARGETED TO CHILDREN, THEN ARE
03:00:43.499 --> 03:00:44.934
THEY IF THEY ADVERTISED THEIR
03:00:45.000 --> 03:00:46.835
SPECIFIC GUN IN THE GAME ITSELF?
03:00:46.902 --> 03:00:48.003
YES THEN THAT WOULD QUALIFY,
03:00:48.070 --> 03:00:51.574
OKAY? ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU
03:00:51.640 --> 03:00:52.541
ANSWERED YOUR QUESTIONS. ALL
03:00:52.608 --> 03:00:53.742
RIGHT. THANK YOU. OTHER COMMENTS
03:00:53.809 --> 03:00:59.348
QUESTIONS. SEEING NONE. JUST ONE
03:00:59.415 --> 03:01:00.950
COMMENT. I THINK FIREARM IS A
03:01:01.016 --> 03:01:02.451
DEFINED TERM IN THE LAW. BUT IF
03:01:02.518 --> 03:01:04.787
IT IS NOT A DEFINED TERM, UM
03:01:04.853 --> 03:01:06.422
THEN THEN PERHAPS WE NEED TO
03:01:06.488 --> 03:01:08.057
DEFINE IT. I DON'T BELIEVE
03:01:08.123 --> 03:01:09.291
PELLET GUN OR AIR RIFLE OR THE
03:01:09.358 --> 03:01:13.329
RED WRITER. WOULD FAULT WOULD.
03:01:13.395 --> 03:01:14.897
WELL IT'S NOT NOT THAT THEY'RE
03:01:14.964 --> 03:01:16.398
NOT DANGEROUS. IT'S ONLY THAT
03:01:16.465 --> 03:01:18.734
THAT IF THE BILL FOCUSED ON
03:01:18.801 --> 03:01:21.437
FIREARMS, THEN IF NOT A DEFINED
03:01:21.503 --> 03:01:22.738
TERM THAT I WOULD SUGGEST WE DO
03:01:22.805 --> 03:01:24.506
DEFINE AGREE, MR CHAIR, ALL
03:01:24.573 --> 03:01:27.076
RIGHT. OH ALRIGHT. OKAY UM,
03:01:27.142 --> 03:01:28.911
CHIEF COUNSEL TELLS ME IT IS IN
03:01:28.978 --> 03:01:30.613
THE BILL. ALRIGHT GREAT. THANK
03:01:30.679 --> 03:01:33.449
YOU. OKAY, UM ANY OTHER
03:01:33.515 --> 03:01:34.550
QUESTIONS. CONCERNS COMMENTS. IS
03:01:34.617 --> 03:01:37.820
THERE A MOTION SENATOR STERN
03:01:37.886 --> 03:01:39.822
MOVES THE BILL. ALRIGHT, YOU
03:01:39.888 --> 03:01:41.590
CARE TO CLOSE SIMILAR MEMBER
03:01:41.657 --> 03:01:44.126
BARKAN RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR I
03:01:44.193 --> 03:01:45.327
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:01:45.394 --> 03:01:46.428
ALRIGHT MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU
03:01:46.495 --> 03:01:55.604
WOULD CALL THE ROLL. THIS IS A B
03:01:55.671 --> 03:02:00.175
25 71 HAMBURG. SORRY THE MOTION
03:02:00.242 --> 03:02:01.844
IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
03:02:01.910 --> 03:02:02.945
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:02:03.012 --> 03:02:04.413
APPROPRIATIONS. UMBERG GORGEOUS.
03:02:04.480 --> 03:02:08.684
CABALLERO. CABALLERO, I DURAZO.
03:02:08.751 --> 03:02:15.424
GONZALES. HERTZBERG. JONES.
03:02:15.491 --> 03:02:18.594
JONES NO, LAIRD, I STERN STERN.
03:02:18.661 --> 03:02:24.767
I WIECKOWSKI WIENER. I HAVE 41
03:02:24.833 --> 03:02:28.570
SO FAR MISSING CALL. ALL RIGHT,
03:02:28.637 --> 03:02:29.438
AND I BELIEVE YOU WERE GOING TO
03:02:29.505 --> 03:02:31.774
PRESENT A B 2091 BY A SIMILAR
03:02:31.840 --> 03:02:33.542
MEMBER ME A BAN TO ASSUME IT'S
03:02:33.609 --> 03:02:37.179
MIA BANTA? YES. ROBIN HAS NO
03:02:37.246 --> 03:02:39.415
LONGER ALLOWED LEGISLATION. UM
03:02:39.481 --> 03:02:41.884
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. I WANT TO
03:02:41.950 --> 03:02:43.752
THANK ON BEHALF OF SOMEBODY
03:02:43.819 --> 03:02:45.154
AROUND MONT. I WANT TO EXPRESS
03:02:45.220 --> 03:02:46.221
HER APPRECIATION TO THE
03:02:46.288 --> 03:02:47.323
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR YOUR TIME
03:02:47.389 --> 03:02:48.724
WORKING ON THIS BILL. IN THE
03:02:48.791 --> 03:02:50.225
PAST YEAR, MULTIPLE STATES HAVE
03:02:50.292 --> 03:02:51.593
RAMPED UP THEIR ANTI ABORTION
03:02:51.660 --> 03:02:52.928
EFFORTS AND PASSED LAWS
03:02:52.995 --> 03:02:54.430
TARGETING OUR CONSTITUTIONAL
03:02:54.496 --> 03:02:55.464
RIGHT TO AN ABORTION THAT'S
03:02:55.531 --> 03:02:56.865
BEEN THE TOPIC OF CONVERSATION
03:02:56.932 --> 03:02:58.634
ON MANY BILLS TODAY. LAST YEAR
03:02:58.701 --> 03:03:01.070
ALONE, 108 ABORTION RESTRICTIONS
03:03:01.136 --> 03:03:02.805
WERE ENACTED IN 19 STATES. THIS
03:03:02.871 --> 03:03:04.306
INCLUDES TEXAS, WHERE THEY'RE
03:03:04.373 --> 03:03:05.607
MOST RECENT ANTI ABORTION LAW
03:03:05.674 --> 03:03:07.209
ENCOURAGES PRIVATE CITIZENS TO
03:03:07.276 --> 03:03:08.777
ACT AS BOUNTY HUNTERS TO SEEK
03:03:08.844 --> 03:03:10.746
OUT AND SUE THOSE WHO PROVIDE
03:03:10.813 --> 03:03:11.914
ANY FORM OF SUPPORT TO PEOPLE
03:03:11.980 --> 03:03:13.682
SEEKING AN ABORTION. INCLUDING
03:03:13.749 --> 03:03:15.117
THEIR DOCTOR, THEIR NURSE, A
03:03:15.184 --> 03:03:17.019
FRIEND WHO TALKED TO HIM ABOUT
03:03:17.086 --> 03:03:18.320
WHETHER TO GET AN ABORTION OR
03:03:18.387 --> 03:03:20.155
EVEN THE PERSON WHO DROVE THEM
03:03:20.222 --> 03:03:20.823
TO THEIR APPOINTMENT. STATES ARE
03:03:20.889 --> 03:03:22.524
CONTINUING TO FOLLOW TEXAS LEAD
03:03:22.591 --> 03:03:24.126
JUST THIS PAST MONTH, OKLAHOMA'S
03:03:24.193 --> 03:03:26.061
GOVERNOR SIGNED INTO LAW A BILL
03:03:26.128 --> 03:03:27.796
THAT OUTRIGHT OUTRIGHT BANS
03:03:27.863 --> 03:03:29.431
ABORTIONS AND LEAVES ENFORCEMENT
03:03:29.498 --> 03:03:30.366
UP TO PRIVATE CITIZENS VIA CIVIL
03:03:30.432 --> 03:03:33.035
SUITS. WITH THE UNITED STATES
03:03:33.102 --> 03:03:34.570
SUPREME COURT LIKELY TO OVERTURN
03:03:34.636 --> 03:03:36.538
ROE V. WADE BY THE END OF JUNE.
03:03:36.605 --> 03:03:37.773
IT'S ESSENTIAL THAT WE IMPROVE
03:03:37.840 --> 03:03:38.941
ABORTION CCESS AND STRENGTHEN
03:03:39.007 --> 03:03:40.175
PRIVACY PROTECTIONS FOR THOSE
03:03:40.242 --> 03:03:42.444
SEEKING SENSITIVE SERVICES.
03:03:42.511 --> 03:03:43.846
PEOPLE ALREADY ARE AND WILL
03:03:43.912 --> 03:03:45.247
CONTINUE TO COME TO CALIFORNIA
03:03:45.314 --> 03:03:46.715
FOR REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE.
03:03:46.782 --> 03:03:48.350
HOWEVER THE CONCERN IS THAT OUT
03:03:48.417 --> 03:03:50.085
OF STATE, PRIVATE CITIZENS AND
03:03:50.152 --> 03:03:51.854
ACTORS WILL DEMAND THE MEDICAL
03:03:51.920 --> 03:03:53.055
RECORDS OF THOSE WHO SEEK CARE
03:03:53.122 --> 03:03:54.656
HERE IN CALIFORNIA. TO PUNISH
03:03:54.723 --> 03:03:56.425
THEM FOR EXERCISING THEIR
03:03:56.492 --> 03:03:58.327
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS IN CALIFORNIA
03:03:58.394 --> 03:03:59.528
. NO ONE SHOULD BE ABLE TO
03:03:59.595 --> 03:04:01.063
MANIPULATE CALIFORNIA'S LEGAL
03:04:01.130 --> 03:04:02.798
SYSTEM TO TARGET AND PUNISH
03:04:02.865 --> 03:04:03.999
PEOPLE WHO SEEK CARE AND REFUGE
03:04:04.066 --> 03:04:06.769
HERE. MAYBE 2091 WILL ENSURE
03:04:06.835 --> 03:04:08.370
THAT OUT OF STATE SUBPOENAS,
03:04:08.437 --> 03:04:09.705
WHICH SEEK INFORMATION RELATED
03:04:09.772 --> 03:04:11.106
TO A PATIENT WHO RECEIVED
03:04:11.173 --> 03:04:12.541
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTHCARE HERE IN
03:04:12.608 --> 03:04:15.444
CALIFORNIA ARE NOT GRANTED. BY
03:04:15.511 --> 03:04:16.478
DOING THIS. CALIFORNIA WILL
03:04:16.545 --> 03:04:18.480
PROTECT THE MEDICAL PRIVACY OF
03:04:18.547 --> 03:04:19.982
THOSE PATIENTS WHO MAY BE
03:04:20.048 --> 03:04:21.083
TARGETED BY HOSTILE LAWS AND
03:04:21.150 --> 03:04:23.685
OTHER STATES. A B 2091 ALSO
03:04:23.752 --> 03:04:25.220
ENSURES THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF
03:04:25.287 --> 03:04:26.455
INSURANCE CAN ENFORCE VIOLATIONS
03:04:26.522 --> 03:04:28.023
OF THE RELEASE OF MEDICAL
03:04:28.090 --> 03:04:29.091
RECORDS RELATED TO SENSITIVE
03:04:29.158 --> 03:04:31.894
SERVICES. MAYBE 2091 CONTINUES
03:04:31.960 --> 03:04:33.462
TO LEGISLATORS WORK OF
03:04:33.529 --> 03:04:34.930
PROTECTING PRIVACY AND
03:04:34.997 --> 03:04:36.265
CONFIDENTIALITY OF LGBTQ, PLUS
03:04:36.331 --> 03:04:37.366
PEOPLE AND THEIR MEDICAL
03:04:37.433 --> 03:04:40.702
INFORMATION. THE LGBTQ PLUS
03:04:40.769 --> 03:04:42.571
COMMUNITY IS DIRECTLY IMPACTED
03:04:42.638 --> 03:04:44.106
BY LAWS THAT UNDERMINE ABORTION
03:04:44.173 --> 03:04:45.507
CARE, WHICH COMPOUND
03:04:45.574 --> 03:04:46.542
LONGSTANDING BARRIERS TO
03:04:46.608 --> 03:04:47.709
INCLUSIVE CARE AND EXACERBATE
03:04:47.776 --> 03:04:50.379
NEGATIVE HEALTH DISPARITIES.
03:04:50.446 --> 03:04:51.847
CALIFORNIA MUST PROACTIVELY
03:04:51.914 --> 03:04:53.182
PROTECTCONFIDENTIALITY OF
03:04:53.248 --> 03:04:55.751
MEDICAL RECORDS OF EVERYONE AS
03:04:55.818 --> 03:04:57.052
WE SEE STATES AROUND THE COUNTRY
03:04:57.119 --> 03:04:58.720
, PAVING THE WAY TO USE THOSE
03:04:58.787 --> 03:04:59.988
RECORDS TO ENFORCE THEIR OWN
03:05:00.055 --> 03:05:02.057
STATES. ANTI ABORTION LAWS. AS
03:05:02.124 --> 03:05:04.126
WITNESSES TODAY I HAVE LEADS
03:05:04.193 --> 03:05:05.494
LISA MATSUBARA WITH PLANNED
03:05:05.561 --> 03:05:06.195
PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
03:05:06.261 --> 03:05:08.130
CALIFORNIA, THE CO SPONSOR OF
03:05:08.197 --> 03:05:08.730
THE BILL. ALREADY. THANK YOU,
03:05:08.797 --> 03:05:13.101
MISS MATSUBARA. GOOD AFTERNOON,
03:05:13.168 --> 03:05:15.137
CHAIRPERSON ON BERRIEN MEMBERS
03:05:15.204 --> 03:05:16.438
AT LEAST AMOUNT TO BORROW FROM
03:05:16.505 --> 03:05:18.040
PLANNED PARENTHOOD AFFILIATES OF
03:05:18.106 --> 03:05:18.907
CALIFORNIA, REPRESENTING THE
03:05:18.974 --> 03:05:19.508
SEVEN AFFILIATES IN THE STATE
03:05:19.575 --> 03:05:20.476
OPERATING OVER 100 HEALTH
03:05:20.542 --> 03:05:23.579
CENTERS. AS I MENTIONED IN MY
03:05:23.645 --> 03:05:24.580
TESTIMONY EARLIER TODAY, THE
03:05:24.646 --> 03:05:26.415
CONSTITUTION CONSTITUTIONAL
03:05:26.482 --> 03:05:27.850
PROTECTIONS UNDER ROE VERSUS
03:05:27.916 --> 03:05:30.419
WADE ARE LIKELY TO BE ERASED IN
03:05:30.486 --> 03:05:31.053
THE COMING WEEKS PROTECTIONS IN
03:05:31.119 --> 03:05:32.588
THEIR OWN, CASEY HAVE ACTUALLY
03:05:32.654 --> 03:05:33.755
NOT STOPPED ANTI ABORTION
03:05:33.822 --> 03:05:34.790
LAWMAKERS FROM SEVERELY
03:05:34.857 --> 03:05:37.125
RESTRICTING ACCESS. OR
03:05:37.192 --> 03:05:39.294
EFFECTIVELY BANNING ABORTIONS IN
03:05:39.361 --> 03:05:41.230
MANY STATES AS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:05:41.296 --> 03:05:42.698
BAUER-KAHAN JUST MENTIONED. THIS
03:05:42.764 --> 03:05:44.166
INCLUDES TEXAS AND OKLAHOMA WHO
03:05:44.233 --> 03:05:45.801
HAVE ACT ENACTED LAWS THAT
03:05:45.868 --> 03:05:46.668
DEPUTIZE PRIVATE CITIZENS TO
03:05:46.735 --> 03:05:49.571
ENFORCE ABORTION BANS.
03:05:49.638 --> 03:05:50.939
EMBOLDENED BY THE IMPENDING
03:05:51.006 --> 03:05:52.441
SUPREME COURT DECISION TO
03:05:52.508 --> 03:05:54.076
OVERTURN ROE, COMPLETELY, STATES
03:05:54.142 --> 03:05:55.611
HAVE INTRODUCED MORE AND MORE
03:05:55.677 --> 03:05:56.879
RESTRICTIONS AIMED AT HOLDING
03:05:56.945 --> 03:05:59.515
ABORTION PROVIDERS, PATIENTS AND
03:05:59.581 --> 03:06:00.549
THOSE THAT HELPED THEM
03:06:00.616 --> 03:06:01.884
CRIMINALLY AND CIVILLY LIABLE.
03:06:01.950 --> 03:06:03.685
IT IS LIKELY THAT IN THE NEXT
03:06:03.752 --> 03:06:05.587
FEW WEEKS, FOLKS AND OVER HALF
03:06:05.654 --> 03:06:06.655
THE STATES ABOUT 36 MILLION
03:06:06.722 --> 03:06:07.923
PEOPLE WILL LOSE ACCESS TO
03:06:07.990 --> 03:06:09.892
ABORTION IN THEIR HOME STATE.
03:06:09.958 --> 03:06:11.126
THESE BANDS DENY PEOPLE TIMELY
03:06:11.193 --> 03:06:14.096
ACCESS TO CARE. HARM PEOPLE WHO
03:06:14.162 --> 03:06:15.264
ARE ALREADY FACING SYSTEMIC
03:06:15.330 --> 03:06:17.533
BARRIERS IN THE HEALTH SYSTEM IN
03:06:17.599 --> 03:06:18.467
FORCE PEOPLE TO FLEE THEIR HOME
03:06:18.534 --> 03:06:20.969
STATES TO GET THE CARE THEY NEED
03:06:21.036 --> 03:06:22.004
AND DESERVE. FOR PLANNED
03:06:22.070 --> 03:06:23.972
PARENTHOOD. PROTECTING PATIENT
03:06:24.039 --> 03:06:25.641
CONFIDENTIALITY IS AT THE CORE
03:06:25.707 --> 03:06:27.876
OF THE SERVICES PROVIDED BY OUR
03:06:27.943 --> 03:06:33.815
AFFILIATES PATIENTS. I'M SORRY.
03:06:33.882 --> 03:06:34.950
I'M SORRY, MODERATOR. SOMEHOW
03:06:35.017 --> 03:06:38.086
WE'RE GETTING, UM FEEDBACK. SO
03:06:38.153 --> 03:06:41.456
GO AHEAD. MISS MATT'S BORROW.
03:06:41.523 --> 03:06:42.357
FOR PLANNED PARENTHOOD
03:06:42.424 --> 03:06:43.225
PROTECTING PATIENT
03:06:43.292 --> 03:06:45.360
CONFIDENTIALITY IS THE IS AT THE
03:06:45.427 --> 03:06:47.963
CORE OF THE SERVICES PROVIDED BY
03:06:48.030 --> 03:06:48.630
OUR AFFILIATES. A PATIENT'S
03:06:48.697 --> 03:06:49.932
MEDICAL RECORDS SHOULD NEVER BE
03:06:49.998 --> 03:06:51.066
USED TO PUNISH SOMEONE FOR
03:06:51.133 --> 03:06:52.701
OBTAINING AN ABORTION. A RATE
03:06:52.768 --> 03:06:53.635
THAT IS EXPLICITLY PROTECTED
03:06:53.702 --> 03:06:57.239
UNDER OUR STATE LAWS. MAYBE 2091
03:06:57.306 --> 03:06:58.774
ESTABLISHES SAFEGUARDS IN THE
03:06:58.840 --> 03:06:59.708
LAW TO PROTECT THE MEDICAL
03:06:59.775 --> 03:07:01.343
RECORDS OF ABORTION PATIENTS TO
03:07:01.410 --> 03:07:02.911
ENSURE THIS INFORMATION IS NOT
03:07:02.978 --> 03:07:05.781
USED AS EVIDENCE IN AND OUT F
03:07:05.847 --> 03:07:06.949
STATE CASE TO PENALIZE A PATIENT
03:07:07.015 --> 03:07:08.584
WHO SEEKS CARE IN OUR STATE. IT
03:07:08.650 --> 03:07:09.484
WOULD SIMILARLY PROTECT THOSE
03:07:09.551 --> 03:07:10.719
WHO PROVIDE ABORTIONS OR ASSIST
03:07:10.786 --> 03:07:12.154
PATIENTS TO ACCESS ABORTION CARE
03:07:12.220 --> 03:07:14.590
IN CALIFORNIA. WE THANK THIS
03:07:14.656 --> 03:07:15.924
COMMITTEE AND TWO
03:07:15.991 --> 03:07:16.658
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BONTA AND
03:07:16.725 --> 03:07:17.693
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BAUER-KAHAN
03:07:17.759 --> 03:07:18.760
TODAY FOR CARRYING THIS
03:07:18.827 --> 03:07:20.529
IMPORTANT BILL SO THAT THOSE WHO
03:07:20.596 --> 03:07:23.198
SEEK ABORTION CARE IN OUR STATE
03:07:23.265 --> 03:07:24.299
CAN BE ASSURED OF
03:07:24.366 --> 03:07:24.833
CONFIDENTIALITY AND THEIR
03:07:24.900 --> 03:07:26.134
MEDICAL RECORDS. THANK YOU.
03:07:26.201 --> 03:07:28.804
THANK YOU. UM OTHERS IN SUPPORT
03:07:28.870 --> 03:07:29.805
HERE IN ROOM 2100. APPROACH THE
03:07:29.871 --> 03:07:34.042
MICROPHONE. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:07:34.109 --> 03:07:35.744
AGAIN. GENESIS GONZALEZ ON
03:07:35.811 --> 03:07:36.812
BEHALF OF LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR,
03:07:36.878 --> 03:07:37.779
LENNY KALLAKIS AND SUPPORT.
03:07:37.846 --> 03:07:38.380
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. OTHERS,
03:07:38.447 --> 03:07:45.954
OTHERS IN SUPPORT. MR CHAIRMAN
03:07:46.021 --> 03:07:47.489
MEMBERS, AARON EVANS ON BEHALF
03:07:47.556 --> 03:07:49.491
OF NARAL PRO CHOICE CALIFORNIA
03:07:49.558 --> 03:07:50.425
AS WELL AS THE CALIFORNIA
03:07:50.492 --> 03:07:51.760
CERTIFIED NURSE MIDWIVES
03:07:51.827 --> 03:07:53.395
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT. THANK
03:07:53.462 --> 03:07:54.763
YOU. THANK YOU ALL RIGHT, SAYING
03:07:54.830 --> 03:07:55.897
NO ONE ELSE APPROACHING THE
03:07:55.964 --> 03:07:57.399
MICROPHONE. MODERATOR IF YOU
03:07:57.466 --> 03:07:59.601
WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE ON THE
03:07:59.668 --> 03:08:05.107
PHONE IN SUPPORT OF A B 29 TO 1.
03:08:05.173 --> 03:08:06.808
THANK YOU WHO WISH TO SPEAK IN
03:08:06.875 --> 03:08:08.577
SUPPORT OF A B 2091? PLEASE
03:08:08.644 --> 03:08:14.383
PRESS 10 ON YOUR PHONE. WE WILL
03:08:14.449 --> 03:08:16.618
START WITH LINE TO 30. PLEASE GO
03:08:16.685 --> 03:08:20.255
AHEAD. TOMMY MARTIN ON BEHALF OF
03:08:20.322 --> 03:08:21.223
EQUALITY, CALIFORNIA COSPONSOR
03:08:21.289 --> 03:08:22.491
OF THE BILL IN STRONG SUPPORT.
03:08:22.557 --> 03:08:27.496
THANK YOU. NEXT PHASE LINE TO 17
03:08:27.562 --> 03:08:28.764
. PLEASE GO AHEAD. THEY'RE
03:08:28.830 --> 03:08:31.366
CALLING ON ME NOW. ALREADY
03:08:31.433 --> 03:08:34.503
YOU'RE ON MY NAME IS FROM THE
03:08:34.569 --> 03:08:36.038
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL
03:08:36.104 --> 03:08:38.173
WORKERS STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
03:08:38.240 --> 03:08:42.344
BILL. THANK YOU. NEXT WE HAVE
03:08:42.411 --> 03:08:46.982
LINE 1 70, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:08:47.049 --> 03:08:49.017
AFTERNOON SHARING MEMBERS. JAMIE
03:08:49.084 --> 03:08:50.619
ALLEY, LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR WITH
03:08:50.686 --> 03:08:51.420
THE OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY
03:08:51.486 --> 03:08:53.655
GENERAL, ROB CONTEST TWO IS
03:08:53.722 --> 03:08:56.024
PROUD TO SUPPORT A B 2091. THANK
03:08:56.091 --> 03:08:58.960
YOU. THANK YOU. HERE NEXT
03:08:59.027 --> 03:09:00.962
SEVERAL LINE 1 71, PLEASE GO
03:09:01.029 --> 03:09:04.166
AHEAD. HI DADDY WITH OAKLAND
03:09:04.232 --> 03:09:05.467
PRIVACY AND SUPPORTERS. 2091.
03:09:05.534 --> 03:09:09.805
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
03:09:09.871 --> 03:09:12.641
IS THAT I HAVE IN QUÊ. ALREADY
03:09:12.708 --> 03:09:14.342
THANK YOU. LET'S NOW TURN TO THE
03:09:14.409 --> 03:09:16.578
OPPOSITION. MR NELL. I SEE YOU
03:09:16.645 --> 03:09:18.413
HERE AND I SEE MR MCQUARRY. MR
03:09:18.480 --> 03:09:21.516
MCREYNOLDS IS ALSO HERE NOW.
03:09:21.583 --> 03:09:23.418
THANK YOU. YOU KNOW ME BY NOW.
03:09:23.485 --> 03:09:25.353
MY NAME IS SUSAN ARNEL. I'M AN
03:09:25.420 --> 03:09:26.455
ATTORNEY AND VICE PRESIDENT OF
03:09:26.521 --> 03:09:29.591
LEGAL AFFAIRS AT THE RIGHT TO
03:09:29.658 --> 03:09:30.692
LIFE LEAGUE, AMERICA'S FIRST PRO
03:09:30.759 --> 03:09:34.329
LIFE ORGANIZATION LIKE A B 16 66
03:09:34.396 --> 03:09:37.232
A B 2091 ALSO BLATANTLY VIOLATES
03:09:37.299 --> 03:09:39.201
THE FULL FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE
03:09:39.267 --> 03:09:40.902
OF THE U. S CONSTITUTION. CHERRY
03:09:40.969 --> 03:09:42.471
PICKING WHICH OUT OF STATE
03:09:42.537 --> 03:09:44.139
SUBPOENAS, CALIFORNIA WILL
03:09:44.206 --> 03:09:46.675
RECOGNIZE THE FULL FAITH AND
03:09:46.742 --> 03:09:47.776
CREDIT CLAUSE ENSURES OTHER
03:09:47.843 --> 03:09:50.545
STATES RECOGNIZE VALID COURT
03:09:50.612 --> 03:09:51.847
ORDERS LIKE RESTRAINING ORDERS,
03:09:51.913 --> 03:09:53.048
SUBPOENAS OR OTHER LEGAL
03:09:53.115 --> 03:09:57.753
PROCEEDINGS. SECTION FIVE B OF A
03:09:57.819 --> 03:09:59.688
B 2091 VIOLATES THE U. S
03:09:59.755 --> 03:10:02.257
CONSTITUTION BY FORBIDDING
03:10:02.324 --> 03:10:03.959
ISSUANCE OF A CALIFORNIA
03:10:04.025 --> 03:10:05.360
SUBPOENA IF THE OUT OF STATE
03:10:05.427 --> 03:10:09.131
ACTION QUOTE RELATES TO A
03:10:09.197 --> 03:10:10.565
FOREIGN PENAL CIVIL ACTION
03:10:10.632 --> 03:10:14.636
CONCERNING ABORTION. THIS IS A
03:10:14.703 --> 03:10:16.338
RIDICULOUS ATTEMPT TO SKIRT THE
03:10:16.404 --> 03:10:18.073
FULL FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE.
03:10:18.140 --> 03:10:20.609
SOMEHOW THE BILL ANALYSIS DOES
03:10:20.675 --> 03:10:23.678
NOT EXPLAIN HOW BUT SOMEHOW A
03:10:23.745 --> 03:10:25.614
LAWFUL SUBPOENA DEMANDING
03:10:25.680 --> 03:10:27.949
RECORDS FOR USE IN A FOREIGN
03:10:28.016 --> 03:10:29.785
COURT, NOT A CALIFORNIA COURT.
03:10:29.851 --> 03:10:31.086
COULD BE IGNORED BY CALIFORNIA
03:10:31.153 --> 03:10:34.589
LAW. THE BILL ANALYSIS ARGUES
03:10:34.656 --> 03:10:37.592
THAT THERE MAY BE A PENAL
03:10:37.659 --> 03:10:39.461
EXCEPTION TO JUSTIFY DOING SO.
03:10:39.528 --> 03:10:41.496
AND YET IN THE VERY SAME
03:10:41.563 --> 03:10:42.664
PARAGRAPH, THE BILL ANALYSIS
03:10:42.731 --> 03:10:46.034
ADMITS THAT THE SUPREME COURT
03:10:46.101 --> 03:10:48.236
HAS NEVER UPHELD A PENAL
03:10:48.303 --> 03:10:50.672
EXCEPTION. NOT EVEN ONCE SINCE
03:10:50.739 --> 03:10:54.209
18 92, NOT EVEN IN THE VERY CASE
03:10:54.276 --> 03:10:56.978
CITED BY THE BILL ANALYSIS. A B
03:10:57.045 --> 03:10:59.247
2091 IS AN ATTEMPT TO BRUSH
03:10:59.314 --> 03:11:00.549
ASIDE WELL ESTABLISHED
03:11:00.615 --> 03:11:02.083
CONSTITUTIONAL REQUIREMENTS AND
03:11:02.150 --> 03:11:03.685
REPLACE THEM WITH ILLEGAL
03:11:03.752 --> 03:11:05.520
FANTASY OF THEORETICAL PENAL
03:11:05.587 --> 03:11:06.521
EXCEPTION THAT HAS NEVER
03:11:06.588 --> 03:11:09.191
EXISTED. BUT COULD POSSIBLY
03:11:09.257 --> 03:11:10.759
EXIST IN SUPREME COURT
03:11:10.826 --> 03:11:13.128
JURISPRUDENCE. THIS IS THE
03:11:13.195 --> 03:11:15.530
EQUIVALENT OF A STUBBORN TWO
03:11:15.597 --> 03:11:17.833
YEAR OLD REFUSING TO GO TO BED
03:11:17.899 --> 03:11:19.100
BY SAYING I DON'T WANT TO AND
03:11:19.167 --> 03:11:20.635
YOU CAN'T MAKE ME IT IS
03:11:20.702 --> 03:11:21.837
EMBARRASSING. IN ITS COMMITMENT
03:11:21.903 --> 03:11:23.605
TO PROTECT THE ABORTION INDUSTRY
03:11:23.672 --> 03:11:26.842
AT ALL COSTS. 2091 DISREGARDS
03:11:26.908 --> 03:11:28.443
THE CLEAR PROVISIONS OF THE FULL
03:11:28.510 --> 03:11:29.644
FAITH AND CREDIT CLAUSE. IF
03:11:29.711 --> 03:11:30.745
ANYTHING, THE BILL ANALYSIS
03:11:30.812 --> 03:11:33.815
ITSELF MAKES IT CLEAR. THAT THE
03:11:33.882 --> 03:11:35.183
BILL WILL ABSOLUTELY BE STRUCK
03:11:35.250 --> 03:11:37.052
DOWN AFTER EXTENSIVE LITIGATION
03:11:37.118 --> 03:11:39.054
AT TAXPAYERS EXPENSE. THANK YOU,
03:11:39.120 --> 03:11:41.857
MR ARNELLE. ALL RIGHT. MR
03:11:41.923 --> 03:11:54.703
MCREYNOLDS.
03:11:54.769 --> 03:12:00.976
T. THANKS. SO GOOD AFTERNOON,
03:12:01.042 --> 03:12:03.011
AGAIN CHAIR AND HONORABLE
03:12:03.078 --> 03:12:04.613
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MATTHEW
03:12:04.679 --> 03:12:05.614
MCREYNOLDS, SENIOR STAFF
03:12:05.680 --> 03:12:06.548
ATTORNEY PACIFIC JUSTICE
03:12:06.615 --> 03:12:07.549
INSTITUTE CENTER FOR PUBLIC
03:12:07.616 --> 03:12:11.052
POLICY. JUST WENT OUT OF FEW
03:12:11.119 --> 03:12:13.154
OTHER THOUGHTS. IN ADDITION TO
03:12:13.221 --> 03:12:16.291
WHAT MR ARNEL HAD TO SAY,
03:12:16.358 --> 03:12:17.559
STIRRING WITH THE FULL FAITH AND
03:12:17.626 --> 03:12:19.261
CREDIT CLAUSE ISSUE, I THINK
03:12:19.327 --> 03:12:22.230
IT'S NOTEWORTHY. SOMETHING THAT
03:12:22.297 --> 03:12:25.000
WAS WAS BROUGHT OUT IN THE PRIOR
03:12:25.066 --> 03:12:26.101
HEARING ON THE SIMILAR
03:12:26.167 --> 03:12:29.537
LEGISLATION FOR A B 16 66 ABOUT
03:12:29.604 --> 03:12:31.840
THE PUBLIC POLICY EXCEPTION, OR
03:12:31.907 --> 03:12:33.842
PERHAPS WE SHOULD CALL IT THE SO
03:12:33.909 --> 03:12:35.844
CALLED EXCEPTIONS. TWO FULL
03:12:35.911 --> 03:12:37.078
FAITH AND CREDIT. UM, DURING THE
03:12:37.145 --> 03:12:41.349
INTERIM I HAD TO JOG MY MEMORY
03:12:41.416 --> 03:12:44.486
AS TO WHERE THAT PHRASE CAME
03:12:44.552 --> 03:12:46.788
FROM, AND HIS HOUSE AND ONE OF
03:12:46.855 --> 03:12:48.890
THE MOST IMPORTANT PLACES THAT
03:12:48.957 --> 03:12:50.425
THAT HAS BEEN EXPLAINED AS IN
03:12:50.492 --> 03:12:51.593
THE SUPREME COURT'S DECISION,
03:12:51.660 --> 03:12:56.264
NEVADA VERSUS HALL. 1979 THERE.
03:12:56.331 --> 03:12:57.966
THERE IS A PUBLIC POLICY
03:12:58.033 --> 03:12:58.934
EXCEPTION RECOGNIZED BY THE
03:12:59.000 --> 03:13:02.304
SUPREME COURT. THE PROBLEM IS
03:13:02.370 --> 03:13:03.838
THAT NEVADA VERSUS HALL WAS
03:13:03.905 --> 03:13:05.740
OVERRULED BY THE SUPREME COURT
03:13:05.807 --> 03:13:08.310
IN 2019 AND DECISION THAT
03:13:08.376 --> 03:13:10.145
ACTUALLY FAVORED STATE OF
03:13:10.211 --> 03:13:11.079
CALIFORNIA IN THAT PARTICULAR
03:13:11.146 --> 03:13:12.747
INSTANCE IN THE FRANCHISE TAX
03:13:12.814 --> 03:13:17.218
BOARD. THE POINT HERE I THINK IS
03:13:17.285 --> 03:13:19.587
THAT THERE HAVE BEEN THERE'S
03:13:19.654 --> 03:13:21.623
BEEN A LARGE BODY OF SUPREME
03:13:21.690 --> 03:13:22.857
COURT PRESSED IN THE LAST FEW
03:13:22.924 --> 03:13:24.993
DECADES DEALING WITH FULL FAITH.
03:13:25.060 --> 03:13:27.128
AND CREDIT. THE COMMITTEE
03:13:27.195 --> 03:13:29.297
ANALYSIS JUST STARTED TO SCRATCH
03:13:29.364 --> 03:13:31.466
THE SURFACE OF THAT, AND
03:13:31.533 --> 03:13:34.069
UNFORTUNATELY, UM, WAS NOT ABLE
03:13:34.135 --> 03:13:36.838
TO ADDRESS THE LAST MANY
03:13:36.905 --> 03:13:38.340
PRESIDENTS THE LAST SEVERAL
03:13:38.406 --> 03:13:40.575
DECADES THAT HAVE VERY
03:13:40.642 --> 03:13:43.011
PARTICULAR BEARING ON ON WHAT
03:13:43.078 --> 03:13:44.512
THE COMMITTEE IS WRESTLING WITH
03:13:44.579 --> 03:13:46.581
TODAY. ONE OTHER THING I WANTED
03:13:46.648 --> 03:13:48.283
TO POINT OUT THAT IS DIFFERENT
03:13:48.350 --> 03:13:50.251
FROM A B 16 66. SO WE DISCUSSED
03:13:50.318 --> 03:13:52.787
EARLIER. YES, THE DEGREE TO
03:13:52.854 --> 03:13:57.225
WHICH A B 2091 TALKS ABOUT NOT
03:13:57.292 --> 03:13:58.727
RECOGNIZING SUBPOENAS RELATED TO
03:13:58.793 --> 03:13:59.961
OTHER STATES LAWS THAT WOULD
03:14:00.028 --> 03:14:02.597
INTERFERE. WITH THE RIGHT TO
03:14:02.664 --> 03:14:07.669
ABORTION. THE PROBLEM. UH WITH
03:14:07.736 --> 03:14:09.270
THIS, THIS PHRASEOLOGY, IT GOES
03:14:09.337 --> 03:14:12.374
WELL BEYOND THE IMPETUS FOR THE
03:14:12.440 --> 03:14:14.042
BILL IN TEXAS SENATE BILL EIGHT,
03:14:14.109 --> 03:14:17.045
UM OTHER STATES LAWS THAT
03:14:17.112 --> 03:14:21.282
INTERFERE WITH ABORTION AND THAT
03:14:21.349 --> 03:14:23.318
COULD EVEN AFFECT OUR OWN
03:14:23.385 --> 03:14:25.286
NEIGHBORS COULD AFFECT LAWS IN
03:14:25.353 --> 03:14:28.356
STATES LIKE NEVADA OR ARIZONA.
03:14:28.423 --> 03:14:31.059
THEY MAY NOT GO AS FAR AS OUR
03:14:31.126 --> 03:14:35.030
STATE DOES TO EITHER SHIELD. UM
03:14:35.096 --> 03:14:36.064
ABORTION PROVIDERS, MR
03:14:36.131 --> 03:14:38.033
MCREYNOLDS, IF YOU WOULD WRAP IT
03:14:38.099 --> 03:14:40.568
UP, CERTAINLY. SHOW WOULD JUST
03:14:40.635 --> 03:14:42.404
URGE THE COMMITTEE TO TAKE A
03:14:42.470 --> 03:14:45.240
MUCH CLOSER LOOK AND
03:14:45.306 --> 03:14:46.474
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSED A B 2091.
03:14:46.541 --> 03:14:49.577
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:14:49.644 --> 03:14:52.514
ANYONE ELSE HERE IN ROOM 2100,
03:14:52.580 --> 03:14:54.115
WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY IN
03:14:54.182 --> 03:14:56.184
OPPOSITION TO A B 2091
03:14:56.251 --> 03:14:58.386
APPROACHED THE MICROPHONE.
03:14:58.453 --> 03:14:59.921
SEEING NO ONE HERE APPROACHING
03:14:59.988 --> 03:15:01.256
THE MICROPHONE. LET'S TURN TO
03:15:01.322 --> 03:15:02.991
THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR IF YOU
03:15:03.058 --> 03:15:04.592
WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE WHO ARE IN
03:15:04.659 --> 03:15:09.164
OPPOSITION TO A B 2091. YES.
03:15:09.230 --> 03:15:10.465
THANK YOU. IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
03:15:10.532 --> 03:15:12.300
IN OPOSITION OF A B 2091,
03:15:12.367 --> 03:15:19.340
PLEASE PRESS 10 ON YOUR PHONE.
03:15:19.407 --> 03:15:20.542
AND WHEN MOMENT IF WE GET LINE
03:15:20.608 --> 03:15:35.790
NUMBERS.
03:15:35.857 --> 03:15:37.659
FIRST WE WILL GO TO LINE 2 48,
03:15:37.725 --> 03:15:41.763
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YES THIS IS
03:15:41.830 --> 03:15:43.665
THERESA BRENNAN, PRESIDENT AND
03:15:43.731 --> 03:15:44.599
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE RIGHT
03:15:44.666 --> 03:15:49.637
POLITELY AND STRONG OPPOSITION.
03:15:49.704 --> 03:15:51.372
ALREADY WE HAVE LINE TO 49.
03:15:51.439 --> 03:15:55.777
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI. MY NAME IS
03:15:55.844 --> 03:15:56.811
JENNY. SHOOT I'M IN STRONG
03:15:56.878 --> 03:15:58.580
OPPOSITION TO A B 2091 16 66 AND
03:15:58.646 --> 03:16:05.120
22 23. THANK YOU. NEXT, WE WILL
03:16:05.186 --> 03:16:07.055
GO TO LINE 2 46, PLEASE, PLEASE
03:16:07.122 --> 03:16:16.131
GO AHEAD. LINE 2 46. YOUR LINE
03:16:16.197 --> 03:16:26.941
IS OPEN. ALRIGHT NEXT WE WILL GO
03:16:27.008 --> 03:16:31.246
TO LINE 2 47, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
03:16:31.312 --> 03:16:32.480
GREG BURKE FROM THE CALIFORNIA
03:16:32.547 --> 03:16:33.848
FAMILY COUNCIL IN OPPOSITION.
03:16:33.915 --> 03:16:39.254
THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND LINE TO
03:16:39.320 --> 03:16:40.688
46 TO. IT'S JUST SPEAK, PLEASE.
03:16:40.755 --> 03:16:49.731
ONE, THEN ZERO. I HAVE FELT LINE
03:16:49.797 --> 03:16:54.335
TO 46. PLEASE GO AHEAD. YEAH HI.
03:16:54.402 --> 03:16:56.337
MY NAME IS JIM EDMONDS AND
03:16:56.404 --> 03:16:57.572
BUSINESS OWNER AND THAT STRONGLY
03:16:57.639 --> 03:16:58.573
OPPOSED THE BILL. THANK YOU.
03:16:58.640 --> 03:17:03.845
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND I HAVE
03:17:03.912 --> 03:17:05.280
NO ONE ELSE. THANK YOU. ALRIGHT
03:17:05.346 --> 03:17:06.581
UM, LET'S BRING IT BACK TO
03:17:06.648 --> 03:17:07.615
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS, COMMENTS
03:17:07.682 --> 03:17:11.319
SEEING NONE. SENATOR CABALLERO
03:17:11.386 --> 03:17:14.255
MOVES THE BILL. ALL RIGHT?
03:17:14.322 --> 03:17:16.157
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BARKING AND YOU
03:17:16.224 --> 03:17:18.092
CARE CLOTHES ON BEHALF OF
03:17:18.159 --> 03:17:19.561
REMOVABLE ANTI RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:17:19.627 --> 03:17:20.862
FOR ANOTHER. ALL RIGHT. THANK
03:17:20.929 --> 03:17:21.930
YOU, MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU
03:17:21.996 --> 03:17:26.935
WOULD CALL THE ROLL. THE MOTION
03:17:27.001 --> 03:17:28.836
IS DO YOU PASS BUT FIRST BE
03:17:28.903 --> 03:17:30.438
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:17:30.505 --> 03:17:31.472
HEALTH. HAMBURG HAMBURG I
03:17:31.539 --> 03:17:33.508
GORGEOUS. GORGEOUS. NO,
03:17:33.575 --> 03:17:36.744
CABALLERO. CABALLERO DURAZO.
03:17:36.811 --> 03:17:42.850
GONZALES. HERTZBERG. JONES.
03:17:42.917 --> 03:17:45.520
GLARED I STERN STERN, I
03:17:45.587 --> 03:17:49.624
WIECKOWSKI WIENER. YOU HAVE FOR
03:17:49.691 --> 03:17:51.593
THE ONE WITH MEMBERS MISSING.
03:17:51.659 --> 03:17:53.928
ALRIGHT, WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
03:17:53.995 --> 03:17:59.767
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. NEXT.
03:17:59.834 --> 03:18:04.706
SURE, SENATOR STERN. OOPS I'M
03:18:04.772 --> 03:18:07.141
SORRY, ASSEMBLY MEMBER JOHN
03:18:07.208 --> 03:18:09.477
SAWYER IS BEEN HERE ON A COUPLE
03:18:09.544 --> 03:18:13.948
OCCASIONS SO PATIENTLY. YES.
03:18:14.015 --> 03:18:18.486
THANK YOU. YEAH IT MIGHT HAVE
03:18:18.553 --> 03:18:20.388
BEEN IMPATIENT, BUT HE WAS HERE
03:18:20.455 --> 03:18:24.225
NEVERTHELESS. ALRIGHT, FLOOR IS
03:18:24.292 --> 03:18:29.097
YOURS. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:18:29.163 --> 03:18:32.066
CHAIR MEMBERS TODAY I PRESENT A
03:18:32.133 --> 03:18:34.502
B 22 96 BILL THAT WILL EXTEND
03:18:34.569 --> 03:18:35.903
THE SUNSET DATE FOR THE
03:18:35.970 --> 03:18:36.638
CALIFORNIA REPARATIONS TASK
03:18:36.704 --> 03:18:38.773
FORCE TO ALLOW THE TASK FORCE AN
03:18:38.840 --> 03:18:39.974
ADDITIONAL YEAR. THOROUGHLY
03:18:40.041 --> 03:18:43.778
COMPLETE ITS VITAL WORK. IN 2020
03:18:43.845 --> 03:18:46.180
, CALIFORNIA ENACTED A B 31 21
03:18:46.247 --> 03:18:48.449
BECOMING THE VERY FIRST STATE IN
03:18:48.516 --> 03:18:49.784
THE NATION TO ESTABLISH A
03:18:49.851 --> 03:18:50.785
GOVERNMENT BODY TO STUDY
03:18:50.852 --> 03:18:51.619
INSTITUTION OF FOURTH HUMAN
03:18:51.686 --> 03:18:54.789
SLAVERY IN THE UNITED STATES.
03:18:54.856 --> 03:18:56.357
THAT LAW DIRECTED THE TASK FORCE
03:18:56.424 --> 03:18:58.359
TO GATHER AND SYNTHESIZE THE
03:18:58.426 --> 03:19:00.361
BREATH OF DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE
03:19:00.428 --> 03:19:01.896
OF SLAVERY AND ITS ONGOING
03:19:01.963 --> 03:19:03.998
LEGACY IN OUR STATE. THAT CHARGE
03:19:04.065 --> 03:19:06.434
IS NOT BEING TAKEN LIGHTLY WITH
03:19:06.501 --> 03:19:07.835
WITH THE ASSISTANCE OF THE
03:19:07.902 --> 03:19:09.904
INCREDIBLE TEAM IN THE CIVIL
03:19:09.971 --> 03:19:10.405
RIGHTS DIVISION OF THE
03:19:10.471 --> 03:19:11.572
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, THE TASK
03:19:11.639 --> 03:19:13.808
FORCE HAS WEIGHED COUNTLESS
03:19:13.875 --> 03:19:14.776
SUBMISSIONS FROM HISTORIANS AND
03:19:14.842 --> 03:19:16.110
ACADEMICS AND HER DOZENS OF
03:19:16.177 --> 03:19:18.846
HOURS OF TESTIMONY. WITH THIS
03:19:18.913 --> 03:19:20.415
EVIDENCE, THE TASK FORCE HAS
03:19:20.481 --> 03:19:21.849
ISSUED ITS INITIAL REPORT
03:19:21.916 --> 03:19:24.385
PRELIMINARY FINDINGS AND PLANS
03:19:24.452 --> 03:19:25.787
TO ISSUE ITS FINAL REPORT AND
03:19:25.853 --> 03:19:27.822
RECOMMENDATIONS NEXT YEAR. A B
03:19:27.889 --> 03:19:29.424
22 96 WILL PROVIDE THE TASK
03:19:29.490 --> 03:19:31.526
FORCE WITH AN EXPANDED TIMELINE
03:19:31.592 --> 03:19:33.895
TO THOROUGHLY EXECUTE ITS VAST
03:19:33.961 --> 03:19:35.496
SCOPE OF DUTIES AND DEVELOPED
03:19:35.563 --> 03:19:36.130
THOUGHTFUL RECOMMENDATIONS WITH
03:19:36.197 --> 03:19:37.131
THE CAREFUL SCREEN FEDERATION
03:19:37.198 --> 03:19:40.101
THEY DESERVE. AS SECRETARY OF
03:19:40.168 --> 03:19:42.203
STATE. SHIRLEY WEBER OFTEN SAYS
03:19:42.270 --> 03:19:43.504
400 YEARS OF OPPRESSION WILL NOT
03:19:43.571 --> 03:19:46.541
BE SOLVED IN 400 DAYS. THANK
03:19:46.607 --> 03:19:47.375
YOU, AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
03:19:47.442 --> 03:19:49.577
YOUR I VOTE ALREADY. THANK YOU.
03:19:49.644 --> 03:19:52.013
UM I SEE THERE'S NO PRIMARY
03:19:52.080 --> 03:19:53.414
WITNESSES AND SUPPORT ANYONE
03:19:53.481 --> 03:19:55.616
HERE IN ROOM 2100, WHICH TESTIFY
03:19:55.683 --> 03:19:57.018
AND SUPPORT PLEASE APPROACH THE
03:19:57.085 --> 03:20:05.493
MIC. SO NO. ONE. THE MÀ. 96. YES
03:20:05.560 --> 03:20:07.862
THANK YOU. IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
03:20:07.929 --> 03:20:09.530
IN SUPPORT OF A B 22 96, PLEASE
03:20:09.597 --> 03:20:11.332
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO ON YOUR
03:20:11.399 --> 03:20:13.501
PHONE. ALRIGHT MODERATOR. WHILE
03:20:13.568 --> 03:20:14.635
YOU'RE QUEUING THEM UP. I SEE
03:20:14.702 --> 03:20:16.270
THAT AT LEAST SOME PERSONS HAVE
03:20:16.337 --> 03:20:17.805
APPEARED IN THE HEARING ROOM
03:20:17.872 --> 03:20:19.273
WHICH TESTIFY AND SUPPORT IF YOU
03:20:19.340 --> 03:20:20.441
WISH TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT,
03:20:20.508 --> 03:20:23.077
PLEASE APPROACH THE MICROPHONE.
03:20:23.144 --> 03:20:25.546
YOU DOING A GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
03:20:25.613 --> 03:20:27.248
SAWYER. WE'RE HERE TO SUPPORT MY
03:20:27.315 --> 03:20:29.450
NAME IS HENRY 30, SOME WITH ALL
03:20:29.517 --> 03:20:30.518
OF US SOON ON SACRAMENTO
03:20:30.585 --> 03:20:31.419
COMMUNITY HEALERS. THANK YOU
03:20:31.486 --> 03:20:32.987
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE
03:20:33.054 --> 03:20:36.624
IN SUPPORT AHEAD. CORONA MCGILL
03:20:36.691 --> 03:20:37.558
ARE HERE ON BEHALF OF LEGAL
03:20:37.625 --> 03:20:39.093
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS AND
03:20:39.160 --> 03:20:40.728
CHILDREN, AND ALL OF US ARE NONE
03:20:40.795 --> 03:20:43.164
IN SUPPORT OF MAYBE 20 TO 96.
03:20:43.231 --> 03:20:47.335
THANK YOU. HIGHER ROBINSON, UH,
03:20:47.402 --> 03:20:49.070
WITH ALL OF US OR NONE,
03:20:49.137 --> 03:20:52.840
SACRAMENTO AND WE'RE IN SUPPORT.
03:20:52.907 --> 03:20:54.375
MELISSA MOORE WITH LEGAL
03:20:54.442 --> 03:20:55.743
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS WITH
03:20:55.810 --> 03:20:57.745
CHILDREN. ALL OF US ARE NONE AND
03:20:57.812 --> 03:20:58.813
WE'RE IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
03:20:58.880 --> 03:21:00.448
ALRIGHT MODERATOR NOW IF WE
03:21:00.515 --> 03:21:01.682
COULD TURN TO THOSE ON THE PHONE
03:21:01.749 --> 03:21:04.952
LINE THANK YOU ONCE AGAIN,
03:21:05.019 --> 03:21:07.989
PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO AND WE
03:21:08.055 --> 03:21:09.657
WILL START WITH LYING TO 51.
03:21:09.724 --> 03:21:12.727
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:21:12.794 --> 03:21:14.462
. CHAIR MEMBERS WOULD ALSO ON
03:21:14.529 --> 03:21:15.897
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA ACADEMY
03:21:15.963 --> 03:21:16.731
OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT
03:21:16.798 --> 03:21:19.967
PSYCHIATRY IN SUPPORT. MHM.
03:21:20.034 --> 03:21:21.836
THANK YOU. AND NEXT WE HAVE LINE
03:21:21.903 --> 03:21:27.241
TO 45. PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
03:21:27.308 --> 03:21:28.876
JUST TO BE SURE WE'RE ON THE
03:21:28.943 --> 03:21:30.311
RIGHT, BILL. THIS IS YOUR LINE
03:21:30.378 --> 03:21:33.948
IS OPEN MODERATOR. THIS IS A B.
03:21:34.015 --> 03:21:38.019
OKAY B 22 96. APPARENTLY WE'VE,
03:21:38.085 --> 03:21:40.688
UH RIGHT. WE'VE SOMEHOW ACCESS
03:21:40.755 --> 03:21:47.361
TO PARTY. RIGHT? WHICH IS MAKES
03:21:47.428 --> 03:21:51.332
SEVERAL OF US JEALOUS, RIGHT? SO
03:21:51.399 --> 03:21:54.168
THIS IS PHIL. UM, NUMBER 15 A B
03:21:54.235 --> 03:21:55.736
22 96 BY SOMEBODY MEMBER JOINT,
03:21:55.803 --> 03:22:05.279
JONES SAWYER. ONCE AGAIN IF YOU
03:22:05.346 --> 03:22:10.017
WISH TO SPEAK ON A B 2296.
03:22:10.084 --> 03:22:20.828
PLEASE PRESS ONE THAN ZERO. AND
03:22:20.895 --> 03:22:22.930
I HAVE NO ONE IN Q. ALL RIGHT.
03:22:22.997 --> 03:22:24.665
LET'S TURN TO OPPOSITION. ANYONE
03:22:24.732 --> 03:22:27.902
HERE, UH, IN THE HEARING ROOM IN
03:22:27.969 --> 03:22:30.204
OPPOSITION TO A B 22 96 SEEING
03:22:30.271 --> 03:22:32.206
NO ONE APPROACHES MICROPHONE.
03:22:32.273 --> 03:22:33.574
LET'S NOW TURN TO THE PHONE
03:22:33.641 --> 03:22:36.210
LINES MODERATE IF YOU WOULD
03:22:36.277 --> 03:22:37.712
QUEUE UP THOSE IN OPPOSITION TO
03:22:37.778 --> 03:22:44.585
A B 22 9 296, PLEASE PRESS ONE,
03:22:44.652 --> 03:22:54.128
THEN ZERO. THAT IS ONE, THEN
03:22:54.195 --> 03:22:57.532
ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. AND I HAVE
03:22:57.598 --> 03:23:01.135
NO ONE IN QUÊ. ALRIGHT BRING IT
03:23:01.202 --> 03:23:02.703
BACK TO COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY
03:23:02.770 --> 03:23:04.272
COMMITTEE MEMBERS SEEING NO
03:23:04.338 --> 03:23:06.874
QUESTIONS. UM, IS THERE A MOTION
03:23:06.941 --> 03:23:08.609
AH, SENATOR CABALLERO MOVES THE
03:23:08.676 --> 03:23:11.245
BILL. UH SOME OF THE MEMBER JOHN
03:23:11.312 --> 03:23:13.281
SAWYER CARE CLOSE, RESPECTIVELY
03:23:13.347 --> 03:23:15.349
. ASTRAY I VOTE. ALL RIGHT.
03:23:15.416 --> 03:23:16.617
WELL, THANK YOU FOR WAITING,
03:23:16.684 --> 03:23:17.518
WHETHER IT WAS PATIENTLY OR
03:23:17.585 --> 03:23:19.253
IMPATIENTLY APPRECIATE IT.
03:23:19.320 --> 03:23:20.254
ALRIGHT MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU
03:23:20.321 --> 03:23:39.307
WOULD CALL THE ROLL.
03:23:39.373 --> 03:23:40.908
THE MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST
03:23:40.975 --> 03:23:42.443
WE RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
03:23:42.510 --> 03:23:45.446
ON APPROPRIATIONS HAMBURG. I
03:23:45.513 --> 03:23:47.014
BORE GIS CABALLERO CABALLERO, I
03:23:47.081 --> 03:23:49.817
DO RUSSELL. GONZALES. HERTZBERG
03:23:49.884 --> 03:23:55.990
JONES. LAIRD I STERN AND I
03:23:56.057 --> 03:23:59.427
WIECKOWSKI WIENER. YOU HAVE 4 TO
03:23:59.493 --> 03:24:01.162
0 WITH MEMBERS MISSING, ALL
03:24:01.228 --> 03:24:02.730
RIGHT? WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
03:24:02.797 --> 03:24:03.698
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. NEXT,
03:24:03.764 --> 03:24:05.933
WE'RE GOING TO TURN TO, UM
03:24:06.000 --> 03:24:09.003
FILLEM NUMBER NINE A. B 21 59 TO
03:24:09.070 --> 03:24:10.771
BE PRESENTED BY SENATOR STERN.
03:24:10.838 --> 03:24:13.741
UM AFTER THAT, UM WE HAVE FILM
03:24:13.808 --> 03:24:16.577
NUMBER 16 BY SOME REMEMBER LEE A
03:24:16.644 --> 03:24:20.014
B 2031. UM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:24:20.081 --> 03:24:23.684
LEVIN. SOME REMEMBER MAN SHINE
03:24:23.751 --> 03:24:26.220
AH, SO REMEMBER TING AND
03:24:26.287 --> 03:24:27.154
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD. THAT'S
03:24:27.221 --> 03:24:29.056
THE ORDER. OR WHOEVER SHOWS UP.
03:24:29.123 --> 03:24:32.093
ALL RIGHT. SENATOR STERN ON
03:24:32.159 --> 03:24:36.163
BEHALF OF AH ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:24:36.230 --> 03:24:38.699
BRIAN FLOOR'S YOURS. THANK YOU
03:24:38.766 --> 03:24:40.768
VERY MUCH, MR CHAIR MEMBERS
03:24:40.835 --> 03:24:43.704
PRESENTING A B 21 59 A BILL THAT
03:24:43.771 --> 03:24:45.039
WOULD STOP PERMANENT FAMILY
03:24:45.106 --> 03:24:46.173
SEPARATION AND THE CHILD WELFARE
03:24:46.240 --> 03:24:47.508
SYSTEM. FROM PARENTS WHO ARE
03:24:47.575 --> 03:24:51.412
PRETRIAL. IN OUR STATE WE HAVE
03:24:51.479 --> 03:24:53.814
OVER 60,000 FOSTER YOUTH, CHILD
03:24:53.881 --> 03:24:55.182
PROTECTIVE SERVICES CASES OPEN
03:24:55.249 --> 03:24:56.784
AND A CHILD IS PLACED IN FOSTER
03:24:56.851 --> 03:24:58.819
CARE. CHILD PROTECTIVE SERVICES
03:24:58.886 --> 03:25:00.488
IS REQUIRED TO ASSESS THE
03:25:00.554 --> 03:25:01.889
ELIGIBILITY OF ALL PARENTS ARE
03:25:01.956 --> 03:25:04.625
REUNIFICATION SERVICES REQUIRED
03:25:04.692 --> 03:25:05.993
TO BEGIN ASSISTING THE PARENT
03:25:06.060 --> 03:25:07.128
WITH THE PROCESS FOR UNITING
03:25:07.194 --> 03:25:09.330
WITH THEIR CHILD. FOR PARENTS IN
03:25:09.397 --> 03:25:10.498
CUSTODY. THIS COULD INCLUDE
03:25:10.564 --> 03:25:11.432
INVESTIGATING WHAT SERVICES ARE
03:25:11.499 --> 03:25:14.101
AVAILABLE. FOR THEIR PARENTS AT
03:25:14.168 --> 03:25:15.169
THE PLACE OF IN CAR
03:25:15.236 --> 03:25:18.406
INCARCERATION. SUCH AS A OR
03:25:18.472 --> 03:25:20.708
ANGER MANAGEMENT LIFE SKILLS AND
03:25:20.775 --> 03:25:21.609
HELPING THE PARENT ENROLLING
03:25:21.676 --> 03:25:23.144
THOSE COURSES OR MAILING A
03:25:23.210 --> 03:25:23.744
PARENT SPECIALIZED INSTRUCTION
03:25:23.811 --> 03:25:24.679
MATERIALS, WHICH THEY CAN
03:25:24.745 --> 03:25:27.748
COMPLETE MAIL BACK. WITHIN 60
03:25:27.815 --> 03:25:29.216
DAYS OF THE FILING OF A CHILD
03:25:29.283 --> 03:25:30.751
WELFARE CASE, THE JUVENILE
03:25:30.818 --> 03:25:31.619
DEPENDENCY COURT MUST DECIDE
03:25:31.686 --> 03:25:33.788
WHETHER THEY'RE GOING TO ORDER
03:25:33.854 --> 03:25:34.755
THE PARENT INTO REUNIFICATION
03:25:34.822 --> 03:25:37.091
SERVICES OR IF THE SHOULD BE
03:25:37.158 --> 03:25:38.693
BYPASSED BECAUSE THEY FIT INTO
03:25:38.759 --> 03:25:40.761
ONE OF THE CRITERIA TO BE DENIED
03:25:40.828 --> 03:25:42.329
REUNIFICATION. IF BOTH PARENTS
03:25:42.396 --> 03:25:43.964
ARE BYPASSED, THE COURT WAS SET
03:25:44.031 --> 03:25:45.633
A HEARING TO MAKE A PERMANENT
03:25:45.700 --> 03:25:47.968
PLAN FOR THE CHILD, WHICH COULD
03:25:48.035 --> 03:25:48.569
LEAD DETERMINATION OF PARENTAL
03:25:48.636 --> 03:25:50.071
RIGHTS. THE PROBLEM IS BILL
03:25:50.137 --> 03:25:51.505
FIXES A PROVISION THAT CURRENTLY
03:25:51.572 --> 03:25:53.607
STATES THAT IF YOU ARE A PARENT
03:25:53.674 --> 03:25:54.842
WHO IS INCARCERATED BUT NOT
03:25:54.909 --> 03:25:57.144
CONVICTED OF A CRIME AGAIN, NOT
03:25:57.211 --> 03:25:59.080
CONVICTED OF A CRIME, YOU COULD
03:25:59.146 --> 03:26:00.748
STILL BE BYPASSED FOR FAMILY
03:26:00.815 --> 03:26:02.283
REUNIFICATION SERVICES SIMPLY
03:26:02.349 --> 03:26:04.018
BECAUSE YOU'RE IN CUSTODY AT THE
03:26:04.085 --> 03:26:05.686
TIME. TO GIVE TESTIMONY TODAY
03:26:05.753 --> 03:26:07.421
I'M JOINED BY JULIE HANNIGAN AND
03:26:07.488 --> 03:26:08.789
TERNI WITH DEPENDENCY LEGAL
03:26:08.856 --> 03:26:10.357
SERVICES, AND STEPHANIE JEFFCOAT
03:26:10.424 --> 03:26:12.259
, AN ORGANIZER WITH ALL OF US OR
03:26:12.326 --> 03:26:15.763
NONE THE BILL YET THE BILL ALSO
03:26:15.830 --> 03:26:17.631
HAS NO OPPOSITION SO I'D
03:26:17.698 --> 03:26:18.632
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
03:26:18.699 --> 03:26:19.834
ALRIGHT MISS JEFFCOAT FLOOR IS
03:26:19.900 --> 03:26:22.870
YOURS. ARE YOU ON THE PHONE? YES
03:26:22.937 --> 03:26:25.573
I'M HERE. ALL RIGHT. GO AHEAD.
03:26:25.639 --> 03:26:27.241
GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS
03:26:27.308 --> 03:26:28.743
. WE ARE ALL AWARE THAT MASS
03:26:28.809 --> 03:26:30.010
INCARCERATION HAS BEEN SOMETHING
03:26:30.077 --> 03:26:31.779
THAT HAS PLAGUED OUR COMMUNITIES
03:26:31.846 --> 03:26:33.547
FOR DECADES. THROUGHOUT THE
03:26:33.614 --> 03:26:35.349
YEARS WE HAVE SEEN FAMILIES TORN
03:26:35.416 --> 03:26:37.651
APART. THEY FIRST STARTED WITH
03:26:37.718 --> 03:26:39.353
OUR BLACK AND BROWN MEN BEING
03:26:39.420 --> 03:26:40.521
RIPPED OUT OF OUR COMMUNITIES,
03:26:40.588 --> 03:26:42.323
AND IN THE YEARS TO FOLLOW, WE
03:26:42.389 --> 03:26:43.557
STARTED SEEING OUR WOMEN BECOME
03:26:43.624 --> 03:26:44.825
THE FASTEST GROWING INCARCERATED
03:26:44.892 --> 03:26:48.028
POPULATION. WE KNOW THE HARMFUL
03:26:48.095 --> 03:26:49.563
EFFECTS AND TRAUMA THAT CAN HAVE
03:26:49.630 --> 03:26:51.532
ON A CHILD BEING SEPARATED FROM
03:26:51.599 --> 03:26:52.967
THEIR BIOLOGICAL PARENT. AND
03:26:53.033 --> 03:26:54.235
BEING FORCED TO LIVE WITH
03:26:54.301 --> 03:26:55.302
STRANGERS OR OTHER FAMILY
03:26:55.369 --> 03:26:57.571
MEMBERS. WHEN A CHILD IS TAKEN
03:26:57.638 --> 03:26:58.606
INTO CUSTODY OF CHILDREN
03:26:58.672 --> 03:27:00.608
PROTECTIVE SERVICES, THE PARENT
03:27:00.674 --> 03:27:01.842
IS GIVEN A REUNIFICATION PLAN
03:27:01.909 --> 03:27:03.911
AND A TIMELINE TO COMPLETE IT.
03:27:03.978 --> 03:27:05.880
OFTENTIMES THESE TIMELINES ARE
03:27:05.946 --> 03:27:07.581
STRICT AND HARD TO COMPLETE
03:27:07.648 --> 03:27:09.183
WITHOUT THE RIGHT SUPPORT.
03:27:09.250 --> 03:27:10.818
CURRENTLY THE COURTS ARE ABLE TO
03:27:10.885 --> 03:27:14.188
USE WIG SECTION 3 61.5 TO BYPASS
03:27:14.255 --> 03:27:15.589
PARENTS WHO ARE INCARCERATED
03:27:15.656 --> 03:27:16.690
EVEN BEFORE THEY HAVE BEEN
03:27:16.757 --> 03:27:20.027
CONVICTED OF A CRIME. WE KNOW
03:27:20.094 --> 03:27:21.262
THAT SOMETIMES A PERSON CAN BE
03:27:21.328 --> 03:27:22.830
IN CUSTODY AND FIGHTING THEIR
03:27:22.897 --> 03:27:23.998
CASE. SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY CANNOT
03:27:24.064 --> 03:27:26.901
AFFORD TO BE BAILED OUT. I KNOW
03:27:26.967 --> 03:27:27.968
PEOPLE WHO HAVE BEEN
03:27:28.035 --> 03:27:29.837
INCARCERATED FOR OVER A YEAR AND
03:27:29.904 --> 03:27:31.405
ARE STILL AWAITING TRIAL. IN
03:27:31.472 --> 03:27:33.574
CASES LIKE THAT WE'RE A PERSON
03:27:33.641 --> 03:27:34.275
IS TECHNICALLY INNOCENT UNTIL
03:27:34.341 --> 03:27:36.010
PROVEN GUILTY. THEY SHOULD NOT
03:27:36.076 --> 03:27:37.945
BE ABLE TO BE BYPASSED JUST ON
03:27:38.012 --> 03:27:39.513
THE GROUND THAT THEY ARE UNABLE
03:27:39.580 --> 03:27:40.614
TO AFFORD BAIL, UNLIKE THEIR
03:27:40.681 --> 03:27:42.416
COUNTERPARTS WHO ARE WEALTHIER
03:27:42.483 --> 03:27:43.617
DURING MY LAST TIME OF
03:27:43.684 --> 03:27:45.886
INCARCERATION, WHICH WAS ONLY
03:27:45.953 --> 03:27:46.887
SIX MONTHS MY DAUGHTER WAS
03:27:46.954 --> 03:27:49.290
ADOPTED. HAD I BEEN ABLE TO BAIL
03:27:49.356 --> 03:27:50.925
OUT I WOULD HAVE HAD A BETTER
03:27:50.991 --> 03:27:53.093
CHANCE OF BEING ABLE TO COMPLETE
03:27:53.160 --> 03:27:54.228
MY REUNIFICATION PLAN. SINCE MY
03:27:54.295 --> 03:27:56.230
RELIEF, I HAVE COMPLETELY TURNED
03:27:56.297 --> 03:27:57.898
MY LIFE AROUND. I WORKED AT A
03:27:57.965 --> 03:27:59.800
NON PROFIT ORGANIZATION HELPING
03:27:59.867 --> 03:28:00.701
OTHER FORMERLY INCARCERATED
03:28:00.768 --> 03:28:02.937
PEOPLE. I HAVE MY OTHER THREE
03:28:03.003 --> 03:28:05.306
CHILDREN BACK IN MY LIFE. I HAVE
03:28:05.372 --> 03:28:06.307
JUST GRADUATED WITH FIVE
03:28:06.373 --> 03:28:07.508
ASSOCIATE DEGREES. AND HAVE
03:28:07.575 --> 03:28:09.643
DECIDED TO GO TO LAW SCHOOL TO
03:28:09.710 --> 03:28:10.678
HELP OTHER PARENTS NOT HAVE TO
03:28:10.744 --> 03:28:11.946
EXPERIENCE THE SAME TRAUMA YET.
03:28:12.012 --> 03:28:14.148
STILL I HAVE NOT BEEN AFFORDED
03:28:14.215 --> 03:28:15.115
THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE MY
03:28:15.182 --> 03:28:17.151
DAUGHTER BACK IN MY LIFE. A B 21
03:28:17.218 --> 03:28:19.286
59 WILL ALLOW FOR PARENTS WHO
03:28:19.353 --> 03:28:20.921
ARE INCARCERATED WHO HAVE NOT
03:28:20.988 --> 03:28:22.690
BEEN CONVICTED TO HAVE A CHANCE
03:28:22.756 --> 03:28:23.691
OF REUNIFIED WITH THEIR
03:28:23.757 --> 03:28:26.026
CHILDREN. MAKING THE DECISION TO
03:28:26.093 --> 03:28:27.528
PERMANENTLY SEVER THE BOND
03:28:27.595 --> 03:28:29.096
BETWEEN A CHILD AND A PARENT IS
03:28:29.163 --> 03:28:31.131
ONE OF THE MOST INTRUSIVE
03:28:31.198 --> 03:28:32.132
VIOLATIONS OF FAMILY CAN
03:28:32.199 --> 03:28:34.568
EXPERIENCE. SAYING THAT APART A
03:28:34.635 --> 03:28:35.636
PARENT SHOULD NEVER HAVE THE
03:28:35.703 --> 03:28:37.705
RIGHT TO SEE THEIR CHILD AGAIN,
03:28:37.771 --> 03:28:39.206
NO MATTER HOW THE CIRCUMSTANCES
03:28:39.273 --> 03:28:41.609
MAY CHANGE IS SAYING THAT WE ARE
03:28:41.675 --> 03:28:43.510
A COUNTRY THAT IS NOT BELIEVE IN
03:28:43.577 --> 03:28:45.312
SECOND CHANCES. A B 21 59,
03:28:45.379 --> 03:28:47.114
GIVING FAMILIES THE OPPORTUNITY
03:28:47.181 --> 03:28:48.682
TO INTERRUPT THE GENERALIZATION
03:28:48.749 --> 03:28:51.352
OF TRAUMA OF FAMILY SEPARATION
03:28:51.418 --> 03:28:53.020
AND MASS INCARCERATION. FOR
03:28:53.087 --> 03:28:54.121
THESE REASONS, I REQUESTED A
03:28:54.188 --> 03:28:56.490
VOTE TODAY. ALL RIGHT. THANK
03:28:56.557 --> 03:28:58.359
YOU, MR JEFFCOAT. UM MISS
03:28:58.425 --> 03:28:59.393
HANNIGAN. IF YOU'RE ON THE
03:28:59.460 --> 03:29:02.429
PHONE, PLEASE IDENTIFY YOURSELF.
03:29:02.496 --> 03:29:04.732
YES THANK YOU TO THE COMMITTEE
03:29:04.798 --> 03:29:06.967
CHAIR, ITS MEMBERS AND HONORED
03:29:07.034 --> 03:29:08.802
GUESTS. MY NAME IS JULIE
03:29:08.869 --> 03:29:09.570
HANNIGAN AND I AM POLICY
03:29:09.637 --> 03:29:12.740
DIRECTOR FOR DEPENDENCY LEGAL.
03:29:12.806 --> 03:29:14.842
WHILE PREPARING TO ADDRESS THIS
03:29:14.909 --> 03:29:16.510
COMMITTEE. I SPOKE TO ONE OF OUR
03:29:16.577 --> 03:29:17.945
CONTRACT ATTORNEYS WHO TOLD ME
03:29:18.012 --> 03:29:19.847
ABOUT HIS CLIENT AIRBOAT.
03:29:19.914 --> 03:29:20.848
SEVERAL MONTHS AGO, AMBER
03:29:20.915 --> 03:29:22.549
THOUGHT SHE WAS GOING ON A DATE
03:29:22.616 --> 03:29:24.084
WITH HER BOYFRIEND. SHE KNEW
03:29:24.151 --> 03:29:25.719
THIS MAN AS HE WAS THE FATHER OF
03:29:25.786 --> 03:29:27.454
HER TWO CHILDREN, BUT SHE DID
03:29:27.521 --> 03:29:28.622
NOT KNOW THAT ON THIS PARTICULAR
03:29:28.689 --> 03:29:30.624
DAY HER BOYFRIEND WAS GOING TO
03:29:30.691 --> 03:29:32.359
COMMIT SERIOUS FELONY. GIVEN
03:29:32.426 --> 03:29:33.460
THAT AMBER WAS IN THE CAR, SHE,
03:29:33.527 --> 03:29:35.863
TOO, WAS CHARGED WITH THE SAME
03:29:35.930 --> 03:29:37.231
FELONY CRIMINAL COURT IS HOLDING
03:29:37.298 --> 03:29:38.399
HER WITHOUT FAIL, AND CPS HAS
03:29:38.465 --> 03:29:40.801
REMOVED BOTH HER CHILDREN. AS WE
03:29:40.868 --> 03:29:42.069
SIT HERE TODAY, AMBER IS
03:29:42.136 --> 03:29:44.805
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY.
03:29:44.872 --> 03:29:45.973
CRIMINAL CHARGES ARE PENDING AND
03:29:46.040 --> 03:29:48.709
MAY NOT BE RESOLVED FOR MONTHS.
03:29:48.776 --> 03:29:50.945
AMBER IS ALSO A PERSON OF COLOR
03:29:51.011 --> 03:29:52.813
AS MANY OF THE CLIENTS THAT WE
03:29:52.880 --> 03:29:53.714
SERVE. HOWEVER NO MATTER THE
03:29:53.781 --> 03:29:55.482
OUTCOME OF WHAT HAPPENS IN
03:29:55.549 --> 03:29:56.717
CRIMINAL COURT. A JUVENILE
03:29:56.784 --> 03:29:57.918
DEPENDENCY JUDGE HAS ALREADY
03:29:57.985 --> 03:29:59.586
TOLD AMBER THAT SHE WILL NOT BE
03:29:59.653 --> 03:30:01.889
GIVEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO GET OUR
03:30:01.956 --> 03:30:02.756
KIDS BACK BECAUSE SHE WAS
03:30:02.823 --> 03:30:04.325
INCARCERATED. CURRENT LAW
03:30:04.391 --> 03:30:06.527
PROVIDES GPS IN THE COURT HAVE
03:30:06.593 --> 03:30:07.995
THE ABILITY TO MAKE THIS
03:30:08.062 --> 03:30:08.896
DECISION AND I THINK SO WITH
03:30:08.963 --> 03:30:10.965
GREAT FREQUENCY. THIS WILL,
03:30:11.031 --> 03:30:13.067
HOWEVER, WILL ENSURE THAT COURTS
03:30:13.133 --> 03:30:14.068
CANNOT DENY FAMILIES THE
03:30:14.134 --> 03:30:17.438
OPPORTUNITY TO UNIFY. UNLESS OR
03:30:17.504 --> 03:30:20.107
UNTIL THE PARENT IS CONVICTED OF
03:30:20.174 --> 03:30:21.875
THE CRIME FOR WHICH THEY ARE IN
03:30:21.942 --> 03:30:23.844
CARSON. FOR AMBER. THIS BILL
03:30:23.911 --> 03:30:25.546
WILL BE TOO LATE. THE COURT HAS
03:30:25.612 --> 03:30:26.647
ALREADY STUDIED HEARING IN JULY
03:30:26.714 --> 03:30:27.715
TO TERMINATE HER PARENTAL
03:30:27.781 --> 03:30:29.483
RIGHTS. IF CHARGES ARE DROPPED
03:30:29.550 --> 03:30:30.918
OR NEGOTIATED. AN AMBER IS
03:30:30.985 --> 03:30:33.287
RELEASED BEFORE THEN SHE WILL
03:30:33.354 --> 03:30:34.855
STILL HAVE TO PROVE WHY IT'S IN
03:30:34.922 --> 03:30:36.790
HER CHILDREN'S BEST INTEREST TO
03:30:36.857 --> 03:30:38.025
BE GIVEN EVEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO
03:30:38.092 --> 03:30:39.793
BRING IN A FIGHT. AND HONESTLY,
03:30:39.860 --> 03:30:41.762
IT'S LIKELY THAT OUR COURTS WILL
03:30:41.829 --> 03:30:43.130
DENY HER HEARING. UM, BEFORE YOU
03:30:43.197 --> 03:30:47.434
SAYING NO. THE CHARGES ARE
03:30:47.501 --> 03:30:48.969
DROPPED, OR SHE HAS RELEASED IN
03:30:49.036 --> 03:30:50.037
AUGUST OR AFTERWARDS FOR
03:30:50.104 --> 03:30:51.405
CHILDREN WILL ALREADY HAVE BEEN
03:30:51.472 --> 03:30:53.874
FREED FOR ADOPTION, AND SHE WILL
03:30:53.941 --> 03:30:55.342
HAVE NO LEGAL RECENT COURT. ARE
03:30:55.409 --> 03:30:57.077
CALIFORNIA STATE SUPREME COURT
03:30:57.144 --> 03:30:58.312
ONCE WROTE TO JAIL. WE JUST WRAP
03:30:58.379 --> 03:31:08.322
IT UP. MHM. UM. AT 80 2018 21 59
03:31:08.389 --> 03:31:10.057
WILL GO A LONG WAY, GIVING
03:31:10.124 --> 03:31:11.058
FAMILIES A FAIR OPPORTUNITY TO
03:31:11.125 --> 03:31:12.292
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE DIFFERENCE
03:31:12.359 --> 03:31:13.594
IS DESIGNED TO HELP THEM. WE ARE
03:31:13.660 --> 03:31:15.362
ASKING FOR YOUR VOTE TODAY.
03:31:15.429 --> 03:31:17.865
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
03:31:17.931 --> 03:31:19.900
ALRIGHT OTHERS AND SUPPORT HERE
03:31:19.967 --> 03:31:21.435
IN THE HEARING ROOM. IF YOU
03:31:21.502 --> 03:31:22.669
APPROACH THE MICROPHONE, PROVIDE
03:31:22.736 --> 03:31:23.670
YOUR NAME YOUR AFFILIATION YOUR
03:31:23.737 --> 03:31:26.940
POSITION. YES, HEAD ANYMORE. GIL
03:31:27.007 --> 03:31:28.342
OUR POLICY ANALYSTS WITH LEGAL
03:31:28.409 --> 03:31:29.643
SERVICES FOR PRISONERS WITH
03:31:29.710 --> 03:31:31.211
CHILDREN, ALSO A PROUD MEMBER OF
03:31:31.278 --> 03:31:33.247
ALL OF US ARE KNOWN IN STRONG
03:31:33.313 --> 03:31:37.618
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:31:37.684 --> 03:31:38.952
REBECCA MARCUS, REPRESENTING THE
03:31:39.019 --> 03:31:40.921
CHILDREN'S ADVOCACY INSTITUTE AT
03:31:40.988 --> 03:31:43.023
THE U. S D. SCHOOL OF LAW AND
03:31:43.090 --> 03:31:46.493
SUPPORT. THANK THANK YOU. HENRY
03:31:46.560 --> 03:31:48.095
ORTIZ WITH LEGAL SERVICES FOR
03:31:48.162 --> 03:31:49.563
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN AND ALL
03:31:49.630 --> 03:31:51.131
OF US OR NONE AND STRONG SUPPORT
03:31:51.198 --> 03:31:52.599
OUT OF SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA.
03:31:52.666 --> 03:31:56.003
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LITTLE
03:31:56.070 --> 03:31:56.937
MORE WITH LEGAL SERVICES FOR
03:31:57.004 --> 03:31:57.938
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN AND
03:31:58.005 --> 03:31:59.073
STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU. ALL
03:31:59.139 --> 03:32:01.909
RIGHT. MATTER IF YOU WOULD QUEUE
03:32:01.975 --> 03:32:03.544
UP THOSE ON THE PHONE SUPPORT OF
03:32:03.610 --> 03:32:06.780
A B 21 59, WE'D BE GRATEFUL.
03:32:06.847 --> 03:32:08.015
THANK YOU TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
03:32:08.082 --> 03:32:15.522
A B. 20 I'M SORRY, 21 59. 21 59,
03:32:15.589 --> 03:32:19.093
PLEASE PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO. WE
03:32:19.159 --> 03:32:22.062
WILL START WITH LINE TO 45.
03:32:22.129 --> 03:32:25.699
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI, SAMMY.
03:32:25.766 --> 03:32:31.105
YEAH. GET AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
03:32:31.171 --> 03:32:33.240
PIANO LEWIS. I AM A PRIVACY
03:32:33.307 --> 03:32:35.409
FELLOW AT LEGAL SERVICES FOR
03:32:35.476 --> 03:32:37.144
PRIMITIVE, WITH CHILDREN CALLING
03:32:37.211 --> 03:32:40.147
IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A V 21 59.
03:32:40.214 --> 03:32:44.618
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT WE
03:32:44.685 --> 03:32:46.487
HAVE LINED TO 56. PLEASE GO
03:32:46.553 --> 03:32:50.257
AHEAD. HELLO MY NAME IS MARVIN
03:32:50.324 --> 03:32:52.793
GALGIANI WITH LEGAL SERVICES FOR
03:32:52.860 --> 03:32:54.428
PRISONERS WITH CHILDREN AND I
03:32:54.495 --> 03:32:55.729
SUPPORT THIS, BILL. THANK YOU.
03:32:55.796 --> 03:32:59.967
THANK YOU. NEXT HIS LINE 1 75,
03:33:00.033 --> 03:33:04.104
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO. MY NAME
03:33:04.171 --> 03:33:06.473
IS BRIAN PAN. I'M AN ATTORNEY
03:33:06.540 --> 03:33:07.341
WITH THE NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
03:33:07.407 --> 03:33:08.242
A NEW WAY APPLIED FOR ENTRY
03:33:08.308 --> 03:33:09.443
PROJECT IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL.
03:33:09.510 --> 03:33:14.515
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND THAT
03:33:14.581 --> 03:33:16.350
IS ALL THAT I HAVE IN QUÊ.
03:33:16.416 --> 03:33:17.951
ALRIGHT LET'S NOW TURN TO
03:33:18.018 --> 03:33:19.720
OPPOSITION. I HAVE NO KNOWN
03:33:19.786 --> 03:33:21.321
OPPOSITION WITNESSES. UH IF
03:33:21.388 --> 03:33:23.290
YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION TO A B 21
03:33:23.357 --> 03:33:24.324
59 IF YOU'D APPROACHED THE
03:33:24.391 --> 03:33:25.893
MICROPHONE, SAYING NO ONE HERE
03:33:25.959 --> 03:33:28.162
IN ROOM, 2100 APPROACHED THE
03:33:28.228 --> 03:33:29.396
MICROPHONE. LET'S TURN TO THE
03:33:29.463 --> 03:33:30.264
PHONE LINE MODERATOR, PLEASE
03:33:30.330 --> 03:33:31.932
QUEUE UP THOSE IN OPPOSITION TO
03:33:31.999 --> 03:33:35.769
A B 21 59. TO SPEAK IN
03:33:35.836 --> 03:33:38.071
OPPOSITION OF A B 21 59, PLEASE
03:33:38.138 --> 03:33:39.540
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO AND YOUR
03:33:39.606 --> 03:33:48.182
PHONE. PLEASE PRESS ONE AND
03:33:48.248 --> 03:33:55.622
ZERO. AND I HAVE NO ONE IN Q.
03:33:55.689 --> 03:33:57.324
ALRIGHT THANKS. LET'S BRING IT
03:33:57.391 --> 03:33:58.292
BACK TO COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY
03:33:58.358 --> 03:34:00.661
COMMITTEE MEMBERS THEIR MOTION.
03:34:00.727 --> 03:34:02.829
SENATOR GRASSO MOVES THE BILL.
03:34:02.896 --> 03:34:05.032
ALRIGHT, CLOSE SENATOR STERN ON
03:34:05.098 --> 03:34:05.866
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BRIAN
03:34:05.933 --> 03:34:07.901
TO PRESENT THIS BILL TODAY.
03:34:07.968 --> 03:34:12.673
STILL PLENTY OF. THE COURTS CAN
03:34:12.739 --> 03:34:15.075
CONSIDER IN TERMS OF BYPASSING
03:34:15.142 --> 03:34:17.010
FAMILY REUNIFICATION SERVICES,
03:34:17.077 --> 03:34:18.178
BUT SOLELY PURPOSES OF
03:34:18.245 --> 03:34:20.380
INCARCERATION SHOULD NOT BE ONE
03:34:20.447 --> 03:34:21.481
OF THEM. HOPEFULLY WE CAN
03:34:21.548 --> 03:34:24.151
REUNITE A LOT OF FAMILIES AND DO
03:34:24.218 --> 03:34:25.652
SOME JUSTICE IN THE MEANTIME AND
03:34:25.719 --> 03:34:26.753
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR I VOTE.
03:34:26.820 --> 03:34:27.654
ALRIGHTY, MADAM SECRETARY, IF
03:34:27.721 --> 03:34:29.489
YOU WOULD CALL THE ROLL THE
03:34:29.556 --> 03:34:30.624
MOTION IS DEEP PAST. BUT FIRST
03:34:30.691 --> 03:34:31.992
WE RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
03:34:32.059 --> 03:34:33.760
ON HUMAN SERVICES. HAMBURG
03:34:33.827 --> 03:34:35.963
CYBORG GIS, CABALLERO. WE'RE
03:34:36.029 --> 03:34:38.332
JUST NO CABALLERO. T<c.cyan>RASO.</c>
03:34:38.398 --> 03:34:43.804
KANSEN SO I GONZALEZ. HERTZBERG.
03:34:43.870 --> 03:34:50.010
JONES. CLEARED BY STERN STERN. I
03:34:50.077 --> 03:34:54.615
WIECKOWSKI WIENER. YOU HAVE FORD
03:34:54.681 --> 03:34:56.016
ONE WITH MEMBERS MISSING.
03:34:56.083 --> 03:34:57.951
ALRIGHT WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
03:34:58.018 --> 03:35:00.921
OKAY NEXT, UM, I SEE SOMEBODY
03:35:00.988 --> 03:35:03.557
MEMBER MAIENSCHEIN IS NOW AT THE
03:35:03.624 --> 03:35:04.725
PODIUM AND POSSESSION IS 9/10 OF
03:35:04.791 --> 03:35:07.127
THE LAW. SO LET'S SEE ITEM
03:35:07.194 --> 03:35:10.964
NUMBER 20 A B 27 66 THANK YOU SO
03:35:11.031 --> 03:35:12.399
MUCH MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
03:35:12.466 --> 03:35:13.467
CURRENT LAW ALLOWS THE ATTORNEY
03:35:13.533 --> 03:35:14.901
GENERAL DISTRICT ATTORNEYS AND
03:35:14.968 --> 03:35:16.336
SPECIFIED COUNTY COUNCILS AND
03:35:16.403 --> 03:35:18.405
CITY ATTORNEYS TO BRING ACTIONS
03:35:18.472 --> 03:35:20.207
UNDER THE UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW
03:35:20.274 --> 03:35:22.109
TO PROTECT CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS.
03:35:22.175 --> 03:35:23.477
CURRENT LAW ALSO ALLOWS THE
03:35:23.543 --> 03:35:24.578
ATTORNEY GENERAL AND DISTRICT
03:35:24.645 --> 03:35:26.613
ATTORNEYS TO ISSUE PRE
03:35:26.680 --> 03:35:27.114
LITIGATION SUBPOENAS FOR
03:35:27.180 --> 03:35:28.282
DOCUMENTS OR TESTIMONY TO
03:35:28.348 --> 03:35:29.783
CONFIDENTIALLY INVESTIGATE
03:35:29.850 --> 03:35:31.918
WHETHER A VIOLATION HAS OCCURRED
03:35:31.985 --> 03:35:33.954
DESPITE HAVING THE EXACT SAME
03:35:34.021 --> 03:35:36.023
AUTHORITY TO FILE UCL ACTION,
03:35:36.089 --> 03:35:37.024
CITY ATTORNEYS AND COUNTY
03:35:37.090 --> 03:35:38.925
COUNCILS. DO NOT HAVE THE SAME
03:35:38.992 --> 03:35:40.627
ABILITY TO FILE PRE LITIGATION
03:35:40.694 --> 03:35:44.064
SUBPOENAS. 27 66 WILL ADDRESS
03:35:44.131 --> 03:35:45.499
THIS ANOMALY BY PROVIDING THESE
03:35:45.565 --> 03:35:46.900
COUNTY COUNCILS AND CITY
03:35:46.967 --> 03:35:48.568
ATTORNEYS THE SAME INVESTIGATIVE
03:35:48.635 --> 03:35:50.337
TOOLS AS THEIR DISTRICT ATTORNEY
03:35:50.404 --> 03:35:52.572
COUNTERPARTS FOR UCL ACTIONS.
03:35:52.639 --> 03:35:54.141
THE BILL WILL BOLSTER COMMUNITY
03:35:54.207 --> 03:35:56.176
CONSUMER PROTECTION AND HELP TO
03:35:56.243 --> 03:35:58.578
EXPEDITE UCL INVESTIGATIONS. A B
03:35:58.645 --> 03:36:00.814
27 66 ALSO PROVIDES ADEQUATE
03:36:00.881 --> 03:36:01.782
PROTECTION TO SUBPOENAED
03:36:01.848 --> 03:36:02.883
ENTITIES, INCLUDING
03:36:02.949 --> 03:36:05.319
CONFIDENTIALITY PROTECTIONS. THE
03:36:05.385 --> 03:36:06.653
AMENDMENTS THAT I AM ACCEPTING
03:36:06.720 --> 03:36:08.455
TODAY AS DETAILED IN THE
03:36:08.522 --> 03:36:09.456
ANALYSIS AT INCREASED
03:36:09.523 --> 03:36:10.724
PROTECTIONS BY ALLOWING THE
03:36:10.791 --> 03:36:13.427
SUBPOENAED ENTITY TO FILE A
03:36:13.493 --> 03:36:14.394
MOTION TO QUASH THE SUBPOENA. I
03:36:14.461 --> 03:36:15.796
HAVE NO NEGOTIATED THIS
03:36:15.862 --> 03:36:17.331
AMENDMENT VERY CLOSELY WITH
03:36:17.397 --> 03:36:19.099
STAKEHOLDERS AND NEARLY ALL
03:36:19.166 --> 03:36:20.133
GROUPS HAVE REMOVED THEIR
03:36:20.200 --> 03:36:22.002
OPPOSITION. I WANT TO THANK
03:36:22.069 --> 03:36:23.403
MEMBERS OF THE OPPOSITION WHO
03:36:23.470 --> 03:36:25.238
ARE HERE TODAY WHO WE WORKED FOR
03:36:25.305 --> 03:36:27.507
A VERY LONG TIME WITH ON THIS
03:36:27.574 --> 03:36:29.543
AND WITH ME TO TESTIFY ON THE
03:36:29.609 --> 03:36:31.011
PHONE IS MARKING CORN THAT
03:36:31.078 --> 03:36:32.612
SENIOR CHIEF DEPUTY CITY
03:36:32.679 --> 03:36:33.847
ATTORNEY FOR THE CITY OF SAN
03:36:33.914 --> 03:36:36.383
DIEGO AND MICHAEL BOSTROM, THE
03:36:36.450 --> 03:36:37.451
ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY FOR THE
03:36:37.517 --> 03:36:39.252
CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ALRIGHT. MR
03:36:39.319 --> 03:36:42.889
AND CORN. YOU'RE AVAILABLE. YES
03:36:42.956 --> 03:36:44.424
MR CHAIRMAN. THANK YOU. GOOD
03:36:44.491 --> 03:36:46.193
AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS MARK AND
03:36:46.259 --> 03:36:47.728
CORNE AND I'M THE SENIOR CHIEF
03:36:47.794 --> 03:36:48.662
DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY FOR THE
03:36:48.729 --> 03:36:50.831
CITY OF SAN DIEGO. I'M THE HEAD
03:36:50.897 --> 03:36:52.032
OF OUR OFFICES. AFFIRMATIVE
03:36:52.099 --> 03:36:53.066
CIVIL ENFORCEMENT DIVISION. AND
03:36:53.133 --> 03:36:53.967
HAVE RESPONSIBILITY FOR
03:36:54.034 --> 03:36:54.968
PROSECUTING UNFAIR COMPETITION
03:36:55.035 --> 03:36:58.171
CASES. SANTIAGO CITY ATTORNEY
03:36:58.238 --> 03:37:00.140
MARA ELLIOT ASKED ME TO APPEAR
03:37:00.207 --> 03:37:01.675
ON HER BEHALF TODAY, AND SHE
03:37:01.742 --> 03:37:03.009
THINKS THIS COMMITTEE FOR ITS
03:37:03.076 --> 03:37:05.112
ENGAGEMENT ON THESE ISSUES. MY
03:37:05.178 --> 03:37:06.780
OFFICE IS THE PRINCIPAL CONSUMER
03:37:06.847 --> 03:37:07.881
PROTECTION AGENCY FOR THE EIGHTH
03:37:07.948 --> 03:37:10.617
LARGEST CITY IN AMERICA. THAT'S
03:37:10.684 --> 03:37:12.018
MAJORITY OF OUR CASES INVOLVE
03:37:12.085 --> 03:37:14.221
MATTERS OF LOCAL CONCERN CARS
03:37:14.287 --> 03:37:15.756
THAT ARE TOWED DESPITE BEING
03:37:15.822 --> 03:37:17.290
LEGALLY PARKED CONTRACTORS WHO
03:37:17.357 --> 03:37:18.892
DON'T FINISH THE JOB DESPITE
03:37:18.959 --> 03:37:20.160
BEING FULLY PAID AND LANDLORDS
03:37:20.227 --> 03:37:22.529
WHO ILLEGALLY EVICTED TENANTS.
03:37:22.596 --> 03:37:24.398
MOST OF THE TIME. THE FACTS ARE
03:37:24.464 --> 03:37:25.699
CLEAR, BUT SOMETIMES WE HIT A
03:37:25.766 --> 03:37:27.434
WALL WHEN WE NEED ADDITIONAL
03:37:27.501 --> 03:37:29.503
FACTS THAT CAN ONLY BE OBTAINED
03:37:29.569 --> 03:37:31.371
BY SUBPOENA. ONE MATTER THAT WE
03:37:31.438 --> 03:37:32.806
ARE CURRENTLY INVESTIGATING AS A
03:37:32.873 --> 03:37:34.808
PRIME EXAMPLE, CONTRACTOR IN OUR
03:37:34.875 --> 03:37:36.076
AREA, HAS BEEN EMPLOYING
03:37:36.143 --> 03:37:36.877
UNDOCUMENTED WORKERS BUT HASN'T
03:37:36.943 --> 03:37:39.946
PAID THEM THE WAGES THEY EARNED.
03:37:40.013 --> 03:37:41.081
THEY'VE GIVEN US SOME DETAILS,
03:37:41.148 --> 03:37:43.083
BUT ARE UNDERSTANDABLY RELUCTANT
03:37:43.150 --> 03:37:44.584
TO MAKE A SWORN STATEMENT OR TO
03:37:44.651 --> 03:37:46.787
AGREE TO TESTIFY IN COURT DUE TO
03:37:46.853 --> 03:37:47.888
THEIR PRECARIOUS IMMIGRATION
03:37:47.954 --> 03:37:50.190
STATUS. WE NEED THE BUSINESS
03:37:50.257 --> 03:37:51.491
RECORDS OF THE CONTRACTOR TO
03:37:51.558 --> 03:37:53.393
EVALUATE THE WORKERS CLAIMS, BUT
03:37:53.460 --> 03:37:54.795
WE CAN'T GET THE RECORDS THROUGH
03:37:54.861 --> 03:37:56.196
REGULAR DISCOVERY CHANNELS
03:37:56.263 --> 03:37:57.564
BECAUSE WE DON'T YET HAVE ENOUGH
03:37:57.631 --> 03:38:00.033
PROOF TO FILE A LAWSUIT. AND
03:38:00.100 --> 03:38:01.568
WITHOUT AN ACTIVE LAWSUIT. WE
03:38:01.635 --> 03:38:02.636
CAN'T MAKE A DEMAND FOR
03:38:02.702 --> 03:38:05.572
DOCUMENTS. A PRE FILING SUBPOENA
03:38:05.639 --> 03:38:06.807
WOULD ENABLE US TO SUPPORT OR
03:38:06.873 --> 03:38:07.908
CONTRADICT THE WORKERS
03:38:07.974 --> 03:38:10.043
ALLEGATIONS AND CARRY OUT THE
03:38:10.110 --> 03:38:11.445
RESPONSIBILITY TO ENFORCE THE
03:38:11.511 --> 03:38:13.146
UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW WITH
03:38:13.213 --> 03:38:14.314
WHICH THIS LEGISLATURE HAS
03:38:14.381 --> 03:38:17.717
CHARGED MY OFFICE. MAYBE 2766 IS
03:38:17.784 --> 03:38:19.719
AN IMPORTANT TOOL TO PROTECT
03:38:19.786 --> 03:38:22.055
CONSUMERS, THE ENVIRONMENT AND
03:38:22.122 --> 03:38:23.190
WORKERS IN CALIFORNIA WE URGE
03:38:23.256 --> 03:38:24.891
AND I VOTE. THANK YOU. THANK
03:38:24.958 --> 03:38:29.396
YOU, MR AND CORN, MR BOSTROM.
03:38:29.463 --> 03:38:30.230
GOOD AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND
03:38:30.297 --> 03:38:31.665
FELLOW MEMBERS. MY NAME IS MIKE
03:38:31.731 --> 03:38:33.934
BOSTROM, AND I'M, A SENIOR
03:38:34.000 --> 03:38:34.534
ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY UNDER
03:38:34.601 --> 03:38:35.368
LOS ANGELES CITY ATTORNEY MIKE
03:38:35.435 --> 03:38:38.605
FEAR. MR FEARS BEHALF. I'M HERE
03:38:38.672 --> 03:38:40.340
TODAY TO URGE YOUR I VOTE ON
03:38:40.407 --> 03:38:42.709
THIS BILL. OUR OFFICES USED THE
03:38:42.776 --> 03:38:44.044
UNFAIR COMPETITION LAWS TO
03:38:44.110 --> 03:38:45.712
PROTECT CONSUMERS AND REMEDY
03:38:45.779 --> 03:38:47.514
VIOLATIONS AND A BROAD RANGE OF
03:38:47.581 --> 03:38:49.950
AREAS. YOUR NAME? JUST A FEW.
03:38:50.016 --> 03:38:51.585
WE'VE BROUGHT AN ENFORCEMENT
03:38:51.651 --> 03:38:52.319
ACTION AGAINST THE LARGEST
03:38:52.385 --> 03:38:54.020
PURVEYOR OF GHOST GUN KITS AND
03:38:54.087 --> 03:38:55.956
COMPONENTS. WE HAVE PURSUED
03:38:56.022 --> 03:38:57.457
BUSINESSES MARKETING FRAUDULENT
03:38:57.524 --> 03:38:58.558
COVID TESTS, AND WE BROUGHT
03:38:58.625 --> 03:38:59.626
SEVERAL ACTIONS TO PROTECT
03:38:59.693 --> 03:39:03.296
WORKERS' RIGHTS. PRE LITIGATION
03:39:03.363 --> 03:39:05.065
SUBPOENA POWER ALREADY BROADLY
03:39:05.131 --> 03:39:06.566
GRANTED TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
03:39:06.633 --> 03:39:09.069
, AND EVERY DISTRICT ATTORNEY IN
03:39:09.135 --> 03:39:09.636
THE STATE WOULD ENHANCE OUR
03:39:09.703 --> 03:39:11.671
ABILITY TO PROTECT CONSUMERS AND
03:39:11.738 --> 03:39:14.207
ENSURE FAIR COMPETITION. WE
03:39:14.274 --> 03:39:15.642
WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE AUTHOR
03:39:15.709 --> 03:39:17.210
FOR INITIATING THIS BILL AND FOR
03:39:17.277 --> 03:39:19.246
BRINGING TOGETHER THE SPONSORS
03:39:19.312 --> 03:39:21.047
AND THE OPPOSITION TO ARRIVE AT
03:39:21.114 --> 03:39:22.415
A COMPROMISE THAT IS REFLECTED
03:39:22.482 --> 03:39:23.517
IN THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
03:39:23.583 --> 03:39:26.152
BEFORE YOU TODAY. WITH THESE
03:39:26.219 --> 03:39:27.821
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS, THIS BILL
03:39:27.888 --> 03:39:28.355
APPROPRIATELY BALANCES THE
03:39:28.421 --> 03:39:30.657
INTERESTS. OF CALIFORNIA
03:39:30.724 --> 03:39:33.693
CONSUMERS AND EMPLOYEES WITH THE
03:39:33.760 --> 03:39:34.561
INTERESTS OF CALIFORNIA
03:39:34.628 --> 03:39:35.729
BUSINESSES. WE URGE YOUR I VOTE.
03:39:35.795 --> 03:39:40.700
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR
03:39:40.767 --> 03:39:41.935
BACKSTROM. OTHERS AND SUPPORT
03:39:42.002 --> 03:39:44.137
THAT ARE HERE IN ROOM. 2100 IF
03:39:44.204 --> 03:39:45.071
YOU APPROACH THE MICROPHONE,
03:39:45.138 --> 03:39:46.106
PROVIDE YOUR NAME YOUR
03:39:46.172 --> 03:39:47.674
AFFILIATION YOUR POSITION. MR
03:39:47.741 --> 03:39:48.441
CHAIRMAN, REMEMBERS MICHAEL
03:39:48.508 --> 03:39:49.843
RIGHT AGAIN ON BEHALF OF THE
03:39:49.910 --> 03:39:51.077
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS, SANTA
03:39:51.144 --> 03:39:52.712
CLARA COUNTY CO SPONSORING
03:39:52.779 --> 03:39:54.681
SUPPORT, AND I'VE BEEN ASKED BY
03:39:54.748 --> 03:39:56.750
FAITH CONNOLLY TO INDICATE THE
03:39:56.816 --> 03:39:58.752
SUPPORT OF THE COUNTY OF LOS
03:39:58.818 --> 03:40:00.020
ANGELES WILL COSPONSOR. THANK
03:40:00.086 --> 03:40:04.658
YOU. THANK YOU. OTHERS MODERATED
03:40:04.724 --> 03:40:06.860
. A FEW WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN
03:40:06.927 --> 03:40:11.598
SUPPORT OF A B 27 66. DEFINITELY
03:40:11.665 --> 03:40:12.566
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, IF YOU ARE
03:40:12.632 --> 03:40:16.403
IN SUPPORT OF A B 27 66 IT IS
03:40:16.469 --> 03:40:19.172
ONE THEN ZERO ON YOUR PHONE. AND
03:40:19.239 --> 03:40:21.308
ONCE AGAIN THAT IS FOR SUPPORT
03:40:21.374 --> 03:40:25.045
BABIES. 27 6 MODERATE WHERE
03:40:25.111 --> 03:40:26.880
YOU'RE QUEUING UP, FOLKS BELIEVE
03:40:26.947 --> 03:40:28.415
SOME OF THE MANSION. YOU ACCEPT
03:40:28.481 --> 03:40:29.783
THE AMENDMENTS. CORRECT ALL
03:40:29.849 --> 03:40:30.884
RIGHT, GREAT. THANKS. ALRIGHT,
03:40:30.951 --> 03:40:33.420
MODERATOR, GO AHEAD. GET THE
03:40:33.486 --> 03:40:34.788
THERE, GIVING THEIR LINE NUMBERS
03:40:34.854 --> 03:40:41.328
TO BE JUST ONE SECOND. AND JUST
03:40:41.394 --> 03:40:42.495
REMINDERS FOR SUPPORT. ONE N
03:40:42.562 --> 03:40:46.132
ZERO OKAY, AND THEN WE WILL
03:40:46.199 --> 03:40:48.902
START WITH HERE. LINE NUMBER 66
03:40:48.969 --> 03:41:00.480
PEOPLE HAD. LINE NUMBER 2 66.
03:41:00.547 --> 03:41:01.715
YOU MIGHT HAVE A NUDE. I'M NOT
03:41:01.781 --> 03:41:07.520
SURE. ALL RIGHT. WE WILL GO TO
03:41:07.587 --> 03:41:11.524
THE NEXT IN LINE HERE. WE WILL
03:41:11.591 --> 03:41:16.529
GO TO LONG LINE NUMBER 2 64 64.
03:41:16.596 --> 03:41:17.931
HELLO. CAN YOU HEAR ME? YES, WE
03:41:17.998 --> 03:41:23.670
CAN. THANK YOU. THIS IS ANTHONY
03:41:23.737 --> 03:41:26.406
LIU WITH THE CALIFORNIA
03:41:26.473 --> 03:41:27.540
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE OFFICE OF
03:41:27.607 --> 03:41:31.144
LEGISLATIVE SPHERE. UM ON BEHALF
03:41:31.211 --> 03:41:33.013
OF A G ROB BONTA, WHO SUPPORTS
03:41:33.079 --> 03:41:39.052
THIS STILL A B 27 66. THANK YOU.
03:41:39.119 --> 03:41:40.420
HEY, WE DO NOT HAVE ANY MORE.
03:41:40.487 --> 03:41:43.356
YOU MR CARE? ALRIGHT, LET'S GO
03:41:43.423 --> 03:41:43.890
TO OPPOSITION. ANYONE IN
03:41:43.957 --> 03:41:45.592
OPPOSITION? I KNOW OF NOKNOWN
03:41:45.659 --> 03:41:48.028
WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION. UM I
03:41:48.094 --> 03:41:51.765
SEE. MISS HUFF SEEMS TO OWE TO
03:41:51.831 --> 03:41:54.034
TESTIFY. GO AHEAD NOT TO TESTIFY
03:41:54.100 --> 03:41:56.202
JUST TO SAY THANKS AS HE JOCK
03:41:56.269 --> 03:41:58.338
LED THE POSE UNLESS AMENDED
03:41:58.405 --> 03:42:00.173
COALITION AND THE AUTHOR WORKED
03:42:00.240 --> 03:42:04.577
WITH US. PAINSTAKINGLY SO DID
03:42:04.644 --> 03:42:06.680
DID A GREAT JOB WITH US AND
03:42:06.746 --> 03:42:07.747
APPRECIATE IT. SO THE MAJORITY
03:42:07.814 --> 03:42:09.849
OF OU A COALITION IS REMOVED
03:42:09.916 --> 03:42:11.317
OPPOSITION SO I JUST WANTED TO
03:42:11.384 --> 03:42:12.619
SAY THANK YOU. ALRIGHT ANYONE
03:42:12.686 --> 03:42:14.387
ELSE IN THE ROOM THAT WANTS TO
03:42:14.454 --> 03:42:15.388
SAY THANK YOU TO
03:42:15.455 --> 03:42:16.156
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MAIENSCHEIN? NO
03:42:16.222 --> 03:42:17.457
ONE ELSE WANTS TO SAY THANK YOU
03:42:17.524 --> 03:42:18.591
TO YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:42:18.658 --> 03:42:22.128
MAIENSCHEIN. AH ALL RIGHT ON ON
03:42:22.195 --> 03:42:24.464
ON THE PHONE WITH THOSE. THANK
03:42:24.531 --> 03:42:25.432
YOU. THANK YOU. ALRIGHT, THERE
03:42:25.498 --> 03:42:26.933
WE GO, SENATOR, SENATOR D ROSS.
03:42:27.000 --> 03:42:28.668
SO ANSWER VOICE NOTE THAT IN THE
03:42:28.735 --> 03:42:31.071
RECORD IN THE RECORD, ALL RIGHT?
03:42:31.137 --> 03:42:35.308
UM OKAY. SO UH, ANYONE ELSE WHO
03:42:35.375 --> 03:42:36.443
WISHES TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:42:36.509 --> 03:42:37.377
MAIENSCHEIN OR AN OPPOSITION
03:42:37.444 --> 03:42:40.613
EITHER, OR MATTER IF YOU WOULD
03:42:40.680 --> 03:42:44.217
QUEUE UP THOSE ON THE PHONE. IF
03:42:44.284 --> 03:42:45.418
YOU ARE AN OPPOSITION OF A B
03:42:45.485 --> 03:42:52.625
2766 IS 10 ON YOUR PHONE. AND
03:42:52.692 --> 03:42:53.793
ONCE AGAIN OPPOSITION ONE, THEN
03:42:53.860 --> 03:42:58.598
ZERO. AND WE HAVE THE LINE
03:42:58.665 --> 03:43:01.134
NUMBER 66 CUTE UP HERE. HOLD ON.
03:43:01.201 --> 03:43:06.606
YOU MAY GO AHEAD TO 66. HELLO,
03:43:06.673 --> 03:43:11.644
KING HUMAN WE CAN. OH THAT WAS
03:43:11.711 --> 03:43:13.113
ME. HI<c.cyan> READY WITH OAKLAND</c>
03:43:13.179 --> 03:43:15.014
PRIVACY AND SUPPORT OF 27 66.
03:43:15.081 --> 03:43:20.820
RIGHT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WE
03:43:20.887 --> 03:43:22.455
DO NOT HAVE ANY MAREQUE. YOU MR
03:43:22.522 --> 03:43:24.023
CARE? ALRIGHT LET'S BRING IT
03:43:24.090 --> 03:43:25.091
BACK COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY
03:43:25.158 --> 03:43:26.126
COMMITTEE MEMBERS SAYING NONE.
03:43:26.192 --> 03:43:28.061
SENATOR DURAZO MOVES THE BILL.
03:43:28.128 --> 03:43:30.296
ALRIGHT UH, SOME OF THEM WERE
03:43:30.363 --> 03:43:31.898
MENTIONED. YOU CARE TO CLOSE.
03:43:31.965 --> 03:43:32.665
WELL, THANK YOU SO MUCH, MR
03:43:32.732 --> 03:43:34.868
CHAIR. AND THANKS FOR THE KIND
03:43:34.934 --> 03:43:36.569
WORDS I THOUGHT I HEARD MR LAIRD
03:43:36.636 --> 03:43:37.737
AND MR STERN ALSO MUMBLING.
03:43:37.804 --> 03:43:39.539
THANK YOU, BUT I WANT TO KNOW I
03:43:39.606 --> 03:43:41.141
DON'T THINK THAT'S THE CASE. SO
03:43:41.207 --> 03:43:44.611
ALRIGHT. JUST HEARD IT. BUT OKAY
03:43:44.677 --> 03:43:45.445
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I VOTE.
03:43:45.512 --> 03:43:47.247
ALRIGHT, MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU
03:43:47.313 --> 03:43:52.152
WOULD CALL THE ROLL. I SEE
03:43:52.218 --> 03:43:53.253
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVIN STANDING
03:43:53.319 --> 03:43:59.559
READY TO GO. WE NEED. YEAH, HE'S
03:43:59.626 --> 03:44:01.261
SQUATTING, ACTUALLY. BUT MANY
03:44:01.327 --> 03:44:03.630
MEANT SO THE MOTION IS TO PASS
03:44:03.696 --> 03:44:05.965
AS AMENDED. HAMBURG I BORE GIS.
03:44:06.032 --> 03:44:10.370
CABALLERO. TO RUSTLE GONZALES.
03:44:10.436 --> 03:44:17.143
HERTZBERG. JONES WEIRD. I STERN
03:44:17.210 --> 03:44:21.314
STERN. I WIECKOWSKI WIENER. YOU
03:44:21.381 --> 03:44:23.249
HAVE 4 TO 0. ALRIGHT. WE'LL PUT
03:44:23.316 --> 03:44:24.417
THAT ON CALL. THANK YOU. THANK
03:44:24.484 --> 03:44:26.219
YOU, MR CHAIR MEMBERS. SOME OF
03:44:26.286 --> 03:44:33.827
THE MEMBER LEVINE. ITEM NUMBER
03:44:33.893 --> 03:44:36.963
18. MAYBE 1917 THANK YOU VERY
03:44:37.030 --> 03:44:38.264
MUCH. MR CHAIR AND SENATORS.
03:44:38.331 --> 03:44:40.300
MAYBE 1917 WANTED SURE THAT
03:44:40.366 --> 03:44:41.401
PERSONAL INFORMATION COLLECTED
03:44:41.467 --> 03:44:42.635
THROUGH CONTACT TRACING CANNOT
03:44:42.702 --> 03:44:43.837
BE USED FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT
03:44:43.903 --> 03:44:46.439
PURPOSES. SINCE THE BEGINNING OF
03:44:46.506 --> 03:44:48.474
THE COVID 19 PANDEMIC. THERE
03:44:48.541 --> 03:44:49.342
HAVE BEEN OVER NINE MILLION
03:44:49.409 --> 03:44:51.511
CASES OF COVID 19 IN CALIFORNIA
03:44:51.578 --> 03:44:53.313
AND OVER 88,000 PEOPLE HAVE DIED
03:44:53.379 --> 03:44:55.381
AS A RESULT OF THE VIRUS. ONE OF
03:44:55.448 --> 03:44:57.784
THE STRATEGIES USED TO LIMIT THE
03:44:57.851 --> 03:44:58.852
TRANSMISSION OF COVID 19 HAS
03:44:58.918 --> 03:45:00.119
BEEN THE USE OF CONTACT TRACING
03:45:00.186 --> 03:45:01.688
WHICH IDENTIFIES INDIVIDUALS WHO
03:45:01.754 --> 03:45:03.623
TEST POSITIVE FOR COVID AND THE
03:45:03.690 --> 03:45:05.758
INDIVIDUALS THEY MAY HAVE BEEN
03:45:05.825 --> 03:45:06.759
IN CLOSE CONTACT WITH MEASURES
03:45:06.826 --> 03:45:07.594
MUST BE TAKEN TO PROTECT
03:45:07.660 --> 03:45:08.728
CALIFORNIANS PERSONAL
03:45:08.795 --> 03:45:10.063
INFORMATION AND BUILD PUBLIC
03:45:10.129 --> 03:45:11.197
TRUST THAT CONTACT TRACING
03:45:11.264 --> 03:45:14.467
INFORMATION. WILL NOT BE USED
03:45:14.534 --> 03:45:15.935
INAPPROPRIATELY BY LAW
03:45:16.002 --> 03:45:18.204
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY. THIS IS
03:45:18.271 --> 03:45:20.340
ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT IN MINORITY
03:45:20.406 --> 03:45:21.407
AND IMMIGRANT COMMUNITIES WHO
03:45:21.474 --> 03:45:22.609
HAVE BEEN DISPROPORTIONATELY
03:45:22.675 --> 03:45:25.245
IMPACTED BY COVID. REPORTS OF
03:45:25.311 --> 03:45:26.846
LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS BEING
03:45:26.913 --> 03:45:28.214
USED TO CONDUCT CONTACT TRACING
03:45:28.281 --> 03:45:30.917
IS NOT ONLY A POOR USE OF PUBLIC
03:45:30.984 --> 03:45:31.885
RESOURCES, IT IS INAPPROPRIATE
03:45:31.951 --> 03:45:34.087
AND ERODES PUBLIC TRUST IN OUR
03:45:34.153 --> 03:45:35.188
EFFORTS TO CONTROL THIS AND
03:45:35.255 --> 03:45:36.322
FUTURE PANDEMICS. THROUGH THE
03:45:36.389 --> 03:45:39.025
USE OF CONTACT TRACING A B 1917
03:45:39.092 --> 03:45:40.260
WILL INCREASE PUBLIC CONFIDENCE
03:45:40.326 --> 03:45:42.028
IN FUTURE CONTACT, TRACING
03:45:42.095 --> 03:45:43.363
EFFORTS AND ENSURE THAT CONTACT
03:45:43.429 --> 03:45:44.597
TRACING DATA IS USED ONLY FOR
03:45:44.664 --> 03:45:45.732
PUBLIC HEALTH PURPOSES. I
03:45:45.798 --> 03:45:49.836
RESPECTFULLY ASK I VOTE AND WITH
03:45:49.903 --> 03:45:51.771
ME TODAY IS YADI JANTZ FROM
03:45:51.838 --> 03:45:55.174
OAKLAND. PRIVACY, OKAY? AH YEAH.
03:45:55.241 --> 03:45:55.775
THE ANSWER IF YOU'RE AVAILABLE
03:45:55.842 --> 03:45:57.310
ON THE PHONE IF YOU WOULD
03:45:57.377 --> 03:46:14.594
PRESENT YOURSELF.
03:46:14.661 --> 03:46:16.229
WELL, WHILE WE'RE WAITING, WHY
03:46:16.296 --> 03:46:17.363
DON'T WE GO AHEAD AND TAKE
03:46:17.430 --> 03:46:19.699
OTHERS IN SUPPORT? WHO MAY BE IN
03:46:19.766 --> 03:46:21.334
THE HEARING ROOM IF YOU'RE IN
03:46:21.401 --> 03:46:23.670
SUPPORT OF A B 1917 AND YOUR IN
03:46:23.736 --> 03:46:24.871
ROOM 2100, PLEASE APPROACH THE
03:46:24.938 --> 03:46:27.840
MICROPHONE. SEEING NO ONE.
03:46:27.907 --> 03:46:29.309
ALRIGHT LET'S GO TO THE PHONE
03:46:29.375 --> 03:46:30.576
AND THEN, UH, IF YOUR ACCOUNT'S
03:46:30.643 --> 03:46:32.612
PRESENTS THEN WE'LL GO AHEAD AND
03:46:32.679 --> 03:46:35.448
GO BACK. THAT SEPARATE YOU. ALL
03:46:35.515 --> 03:46:36.616
RIGHT. THANK YOU. SEVEN MEMBER
03:46:36.683 --> 03:46:39.352
LEVIN. ALRIGHT. MODERATOR IF YOU
03:46:39.419 --> 03:46:41.220
WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN SUPPORT
03:46:41.287 --> 03:46:45.058
OF A B 1917 LADIES AND GENTLEMEN
03:46:45.124 --> 03:46:46.559
, IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B
03:46:46.626 --> 03:46:49.162
1917 IT'S ONE AND ZERO ON YOUR
03:46:49.228 --> 03:46:53.199
PHONE. ONCE AGAIN THAT SUPPORT
03:46:53.266 --> 03:47:02.709
IS 10. OKAY WE HAVE SOMEBODY
03:47:02.775 --> 03:47:04.477
QUEUING UP HERE. THAT'LL BE JUST
03:47:04.544 --> 03:47:14.687
A MOMENT.
03:47:14.754 --> 03:47:15.722
THEY'RE GETTING THEIR LINE
03:47:15.788 --> 03:47:22.762
NUMBER. IN SUPPORT IS 10. NEXT
03:47:22.829 --> 03:47:24.297
WEEK. WE'LL GO TO LINE NUMBER
03:47:24.364 --> 03:47:28.868
71, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THIS IS
03:47:28.935 --> 03:47:30.470
GEORGE BROWN DO ON BEHALF OF
03:47:30.536 --> 03:47:31.838
ASIA, YOU CALIFORNIA ACTION IN
03:47:31.904 --> 03:47:36.075
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:47:36.142 --> 03:47:37.710
THANK YOU. WE DO NOT HAVE ANY
03:47:37.777 --> 03:47:39.278
MORE IN QUÊ. MR. CHAIR ALRIGHT,
03:47:39.345 --> 03:47:40.580
WELL TURNED OPPOSITION OF
03:47:40.646 --> 03:47:42.582
EUROPEANS PRESENTS, THEN WE'LL
03:47:42.648 --> 03:47:44.450
GO BACK. UH THOSE THOSE THAT I
03:47:44.517 --> 03:47:46.285
DON'T HEAR YOU ARE OKAY. GO
03:47:46.352 --> 03:47:51.157
AHEAD. HI MEMBERS OF THE SENATE
03:47:51.224 --> 03:47:53.259
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS
03:47:53.326 --> 03:47:55.395
JERRY YANG AND I AM THE PRIVACY
03:47:55.461 --> 03:47:56.896
RIGHTS FELLOW AT OAKLAND PRIVACY
03:47:56.963 --> 03:47:58.431
AS CITIZENS COALITION THAT WORKS
03:47:58.498 --> 03:47:59.732
REGIONALLY TO DEFEND THE RIGHTS
03:47:59.799 --> 03:48:01.634
TO PRIVACY AND BASED IN THE
03:48:01.701 --> 03:48:04.771
AREA. 18 19 SEVENTIES CENTERS.
03:48:04.837 --> 03:48:06.205
PUBLIC HOUSING CALIFORNIA'S
03:48:06.272 --> 03:48:07.473
RESPONSE TO COMMUNICABLE
03:48:07.540 --> 03:48:09.175
DISEASES, ENSURING THAT ALL
03:48:09.242 --> 03:48:10.443
CALIFORNIA'S C<c.cyan> PARTICIPATING</c>
03:48:10.510 --> 03:48:13.246
CRITICAL CONTACT MAKING EFFORTS.
03:48:13.312 --> 03:48:14.914
IT IS IN LINE WITH OTHER
03:48:14.981 --> 03:48:16.349
LEGISLATIVE INITIATIVES. PUBLIC
03:48:16.416 --> 03:48:18.317
HEALTH RESPONSES FROM THE POLICE
03:48:18.384 --> 03:48:20.486
TO NON LAW ENFORCEMENT ENTITY.
03:48:20.553 --> 03:48:22.288
CONTACT TRACING INFORMATION CAN
03:48:22.355 --> 03:48:23.923
INCLUDE WHO A PERSON WAS WITH
03:48:23.990 --> 03:48:25.725
WHEN AND WHERE. WHEN THAT
03:48:25.792 --> 03:48:26.559
INFORMATION IS COLLECTED BY
03:48:26.626 --> 03:48:28.895
POLICE CAN NEGATIVELY IMPACT
03:48:28.961 --> 03:48:30.363
URGENT PUBLIC HEALTH GOALS
03:48:30.430 --> 03:48:32.498
BECAUSE PEOPLE MAY SHARE LESS OF
03:48:32.565 --> 03:48:33.466
THEIR PERSONAL INFORMATION. IF,
03:48:33.533 --> 03:48:35.535
FOR EXAMPLE, IN THE IMPLICATE
03:48:35.601 --> 03:48:37.270
THEM IN THE CRIME OR RISK
03:48:37.336 --> 03:48:38.371
LABELING THEM AS AN ASSOCIATION
03:48:38.438 --> 03:48:40.573
OF THIS SUPPOSED GANG MEMBERS,
03:48:40.640 --> 03:48:42.041
DEGREE OF DISTRESS FOR LAW
03:48:42.108 --> 03:48:43.509
ENFORCEMENT AND MANY COMMUNITIES
03:48:43.576 --> 03:48:45.078
REMAIN, PARTICULARLY IMMIGRANTS
03:48:45.144 --> 03:48:46.813
AND THOSE WHO ARE MOST IMPACTED
03:48:46.879 --> 03:48:49.515
BY POLICE VIOLENCE. ENSURING
03:48:49.582 --> 03:48:51.084
CONTACT TRACING IS CONDUCTED BY
03:48:51.150 --> 03:48:51.918
PUBLIC HEALTH PROFESSIONAL IS
03:48:51.984 --> 03:48:53.386
IMPORTANT FOR ENSURING THAT
03:48:53.453 --> 03:48:54.320
COMMUNITIES FEEL COMFORTABLE
03:48:54.387 --> 03:48:55.455
TALKING HONESTLY, WITH CONTRACT
03:48:55.521 --> 03:48:59.725
PAPERS. I THINK A B 1970 STATES
03:48:59.792 --> 03:49:01.828
CARD. SOME PEOPLE ARE LIKELY TO
03:49:01.894 --> 03:49:03.096
WITHHOLD INFORMATION THAT IS
03:49:03.162 --> 03:49:04.163
NECESSARY TO CONTAIN THE
03:49:04.230 --> 03:49:05.698
COMMUNICABLE DISEASE OUTBREAK.
03:49:05.765 --> 03:49:06.666
CONTACT TEACHING IS AN
03:49:06.732 --> 03:49:07.200
INAPPROPRIATE FUNCTION FOR
03:49:07.266 --> 03:49:09.902
POLICE. ANY BAR ON THE
03:49:09.969 --> 03:49:11.804
ENTANGLEMENT OF THE POLICE AND
03:49:11.871 --> 03:49:13.272
PUBLIC HEALTH PRACTICE NECESSARY
03:49:13.339 --> 03:49:15.241
TO ENSURE THAT PEOPLE WILL FULLY
03:49:15.308 --> 03:49:15.875
COOPERATE WITH CRUCIAL CONTACT.
03:49:15.942 --> 03:49:20.146
TRACING EFFORTS. 18 1917 ENSURES
03:49:20.213 --> 03:49:21.814
THAT PUBLIC HEALTH RESPONSES TO
03:49:21.881 --> 03:49:23.282
COMMUNICABLE DISEASES ARE
03:49:23.349 --> 03:49:24.617
HANDLED BY THE PEOPLE THAT
03:49:24.684 --> 03:49:26.252
PREPARED TO DO SO. FOR THESE
03:49:26.319 --> 03:49:27.920
REASONS, WE ASK YOU FOR YOUR
03:49:27.987 --> 03:49:34.127
SUPPORT FOR A B 1917. THANK YOU.
03:49:34.193 --> 03:49:37.463
ALRIGHTY. THANK YOU. UM, ANYONE
03:49:37.530 --> 03:49:43.069
ELSE IN SUPPORT? OPPOSITION. I
03:49:43.136 --> 03:49:45.171
BELIEVE WE WENT TO OPPOSITION.
03:49:45.238 --> 03:49:46.639
UH ANYONE ON THE PHONE LINE IN
03:49:46.706 --> 03:49:52.044
OPPOSITION TO A B 1917? IF YOU
03:49:52.111 --> 03:49:53.446
WERE IN OPPOSITION OF BABY 1917
03:49:53.513 --> 03:49:55.381
. IT IS ONE THAN ZERO ON YOUR
03:49:55.448 --> 03:50:00.520
PHONE. ONCE AGAIN OPPOSITION ONE
03:50:00.586 --> 03:50:07.326
THAN ZERO. THEY WE DO NOT HAVE
03:50:07.393 --> 03:50:09.262
ANYBODY QUEUING UP AS HIS NOW MR
03:50:09.328 --> 03:50:12.198
CHAIR. ALREADY THANK YOU. ALL
03:50:12.265 --> 03:50:12.732
RIGHT, BRING IT BACK TO
03:50:12.798 --> 03:50:13.799
COMMITTEE QUESTIONS BY COMMITTEE
03:50:13.866 --> 03:50:15.635
MEMBERS. YES, SENATOR STERN.
03:50:15.701 --> 03:50:18.471
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. UM JUST ONE
03:50:18.538 --> 03:50:19.472
QUESTION. I APPRECIATE YOU
03:50:19.539 --> 03:50:22.508
BRINGING THE MEASURE BACK. I
03:50:22.575 --> 03:50:23.776
THINK SIMILAR MEASURE AT THE
03:50:23.843 --> 03:50:24.944
BEGINNING OF THE PENDANT THIRD
03:50:25.011 --> 03:50:30.216
TIME. SO THE ONE SCENARIO THE
03:50:30.283 --> 03:50:31.450
FIRST COUPLE OF TIMES THAT IT
03:50:31.517 --> 03:50:33.352
CAME THROUGH. I HAD A CONCERN
03:50:33.419 --> 03:50:35.421
ABOUT WAS IF THERE'S SORT OF A
03:50:35.488 --> 03:50:37.890
CRISIS OUTBREAK SITUATION. SE
03:50:37.957 --> 03:50:42.161
ANA <c.cyan>/C CAMPUS OR CSU CAMPUS. UM</c>
03:50:42.228 --> 03:50:44.430
WHERE YOU WOULD HAVE TO HAVE A
03:50:44.497 --> 03:50:46.165
RAPID NOTIFICATION PROCESS.
03:50:46.232 --> 03:50:47.400
RIGHT? YOU WANT TO VISIT EVERY
03:50:47.466 --> 03:50:49.735
ON CAMPUS DORM OR THIS
03:50:49.802 --> 03:50:51.737
PARTICULAR DORM HAD ITS OWN
03:50:51.804 --> 03:50:52.838
OUTBREAK AND AN ISSUE AND THEY
03:50:52.905 --> 03:50:54.740
NEED TO BE NOTIFIED. SO LONG AS
03:50:54.807 --> 03:50:58.544
THAT. IF THE IF THE CAMPUS
03:50:58.611 --> 03:51:00.680
PUBLIC HEALTH DEPARTMENT ENGAGED
03:51:00.746 --> 03:51:03.049
ALL HANDS ON DECK, INCLUDING S<c.cyan></c>
03:51:03.115 --> 03:51:03.816
CAMPUS POLICE IN THE
03:51:03.883 --> 03:51:07.153
NOTIFICATION PROCESS. THAT
03:51:07.220 --> 03:51:08.621
WOULDN'T NECESSARILY BE
03:51:08.688 --> 03:51:10.623
CONTACTED. BARRED I MEAN, THAT'S
03:51:10.690 --> 03:51:12.592
SORT OF HOW I READ THE LANGUAGE
03:51:12.658 --> 03:51:14.994
BECAUSE I APPRECIATE I LIKE THE
03:51:15.061 --> 03:51:16.162
BILL AND THE OVERALL INTENT TO
03:51:16.229 --> 03:51:17.964
SAY. LAW ENFORCEMENT SHOULDN'T
03:51:18.030 --> 03:51:19.932
BE INVOLVED WITH IDENTIFICATION
03:51:19.999 --> 03:51:21.934
WITH MONITORING WITH SORT OF THE
03:51:22.001 --> 03:51:23.936
DATA ACCESS, BUT I JUST WANT TO
03:51:24.003 --> 03:51:26.072
BE CLEAR THAT IN AN EMERGENCY
03:51:26.138 --> 03:51:27.206
SITUATION, ESPECIALLY
03:51:27.273 --> 03:51:32.278
NOTIFICATION OF PEOPLE. WOULD BE
03:51:32.345 --> 03:51:34.547
MAYBE A DIFFERENT FUNCTION. YEAH
03:51:34.614 --> 03:51:35.414
YOU KNOW, IT'S INTERESTING. I
03:51:35.481 --> 03:51:37.450
MEAN, THIS IS THE THIRD TIME
03:51:37.516 --> 03:51:38.618
THAT WE'VE DONE THIS BILL. UM
03:51:38.684 --> 03:51:40.920
THIS. THIS PANDEMIC FLOWN BY
03:51:40.987 --> 03:51:43.456
HASN'T YET BUT AND YOU SEE, HAD
03:51:43.522 --> 03:51:44.857
RAISED ISSUES WITH THE FIRST
03:51:44.924 --> 03:51:46.492
VERSION OF THIS BILL. THEY DON'T
03:51:46.559 --> 03:51:47.727
HAVE ANY ISSUES WITH THIS
03:51:47.793 --> 03:51:49.762
VERSION OF THE BILL. UM SO I
03:51:49.829 --> 03:51:50.796
HAVEN'T YOU KNOW, RUN THE TRAPS
03:51:50.863 --> 03:51:53.065
DOWN. THE MARTIAL LAW SCENARIO
03:51:53.132 --> 03:51:54.533
THAT I THINK YOU'RE KIND OF
03:51:54.600 --> 03:51:55.935
THINKING WHERE YOU KNOW THE SKY
03:51:56.002 --> 03:51:58.070
IS FALLING, AND WE JUST NEED TO
03:51:58.137 --> 03:51:59.138
HAVE EVERYONE ENGAGING IN THIS
03:51:59.205 --> 03:52:00.640
TYPE OF THING. BUT I DON'T THINK
03:52:00.706 --> 03:52:02.775
THAT THAT IS ACTUALLY PART OF
03:52:02.842 --> 03:52:03.409
THE CONTACT TRACING PROCESS. SO
03:52:03.476 --> 03:52:04.543
I APPRECIATE THAT CONCERN. THANK
03:52:04.610 --> 03:52:08.781
YOU. I'M HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL
03:52:08.848 --> 03:52:09.682
AT THE SENATOR STERN MOVES THE
03:52:09.749 --> 03:52:11.017
BUILT OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS
03:52:11.083 --> 03:52:13.452
SEEING NONE. ALL RIGHT, MADAM
03:52:13.519 --> 03:52:14.987
SECRETARY KERRY CLOSE THERE'S NO
03:52:15.054 --> 03:52:15.988
OPPOSITION OURSELVES FASTER AND
03:52:16.055 --> 03:52:17.857
I VOTE. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU.
03:52:17.923 --> 03:52:18.958
MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU WOULD
03:52:19.025 --> 03:52:22.295
CALL THE ROLL. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:52:22.361 --> 03:52:24.430
PAST BUT FIRST WE RE REFERRED TO
03:52:24.497 --> 03:52:25.665
THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
03:52:25.731 --> 03:52:30.069
UMBERG. HI, GORGEOUS. OR JUST
03:52:30.136 --> 03:52:32.538
KNOW CABALLERO. SO GONZALEZ
03:52:32.605 --> 03:52:36.876
HERTZBERG. JONES. LEERED, DICE
03:52:36.942 --> 03:52:40.279
TURN. STERN. I WIECKOWSKI
03:52:40.346 --> 03:52:44.250
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WIENER. YOU
03:52:44.317 --> 03:52:46.352
HAVE 5 TO 1 WITH MEMBERS
03:52:46.419 --> 03:52:47.453
MISSING. ALRIGHT. WE'LL PUT THAT
03:52:47.520 --> 03:52:49.288
ON CALL. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT.
03:52:49.355 --> 03:52:51.957
THANK YOU. WE'RE GONNA TAKE A
03:52:52.024 --> 03:53:09.075
BRIEF PAUSE HERE IN PLACE.
03:54:18.110 --> 03:54:20.045
ALRIGHT UM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
03:54:20.112 --> 03:54:21.414
WARD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. AND
03:54:21.480 --> 03:54:22.648
YOU'VE BEEN IN AND OUT TODAY SO
03:54:22.715 --> 03:54:26.218
I AM GRATEFUL FOR YOUR UM FOR
03:54:26.285 --> 03:54:28.220
YOUR PRESENCE AND YOUR PRESENCE
03:54:28.287 --> 03:54:30.222
ONCE MORE, UM, FOR THOSE OF YOU
03:54:30.289 --> 03:54:31.690
WHO MAY BE LISTENING ON THE
03:54:31.757 --> 03:54:33.726
PHONE, I REMEMBER 29 A B 25 59
03:54:33.793 --> 03:54:37.530
BY SOME MEMBER WARD. CONSIDERING
03:54:37.596 --> 03:54:38.931
REASONABLE TENANT SCREENING
03:54:38.998 --> 03:54:40.800
REPORTS. WE'RE GOING TO PUT THAT
03:54:40.866 --> 03:54:43.569
OVER FOR A WEEK. UM AND THEN,
03:54:43.636 --> 03:54:46.372
BUT BUT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD IS
03:54:46.439 --> 03:54:47.873
GOING TO PRESENT ITEM NUMBER 28
03:54:47.940 --> 03:54:51.243
A B 15 60. EXCUSE ME, 15 94. BY,
03:54:51.310 --> 03:54:54.280
UM SOME OF THE MEMBER TING. IS
03:54:54.346 --> 03:54:55.381
THAT CORRECT? THAT'S CORRECT.
03:54:55.448 --> 03:54:59.185
ALRIGHT. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
03:54:59.251 --> 03:55:00.453
SENATORS. I DO RISE TODAY TO
03:55:00.519 --> 03:55:02.788
PRESENT EVERY 15 1994 ON BEHALF
03:55:02.855 --> 03:55:03.689
OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S KING, OF
03:55:03.756 --> 03:55:05.925
WHICH I AM ALSO A JOINT AUTHOR.
03:55:05.991 --> 03:55:06.759
JUST THIS YEAR THE COUNTRY HAS
03:55:06.826 --> 03:55:08.561
FACED OVER 200 MASS SHOOTINGS,
03:55:08.627 --> 03:55:09.795
ONE OF WHICH WAS A BLOCK AWAY
03:55:09.862 --> 03:55:11.730
FROM THIS BUILDING. MILLIONS OF
03:55:11.797 --> 03:55:13.199
PEOPLE WERE IMPACTED BY THE
03:55:13.265 --> 03:55:13.833
UNSETTLING SHOOTING THAT TOOK
03:55:13.899 --> 03:55:14.900
THE LIVES OF 19 INNOCENT
03:55:14.967 --> 03:55:17.670
CHILDREN HOLIDAY. CALIFORNIA
03:55:17.736 --> 03:55:18.471
NEEDS TO LEAD THE WAY AND
03:55:18.537 --> 03:55:20.239
SENDING A MESSAGE TO THE GUN
03:55:20.306 --> 03:55:21.474
INDUSTRY THAT THEY ARE LIABLE
03:55:21.540 --> 03:55:23.976
FOR THE PRODUCTS THAT THEY SELL
03:55:24.043 --> 03:55:24.577
PRODUCTS THAT ARE CREATED TO
03:55:24.643 --> 03:55:25.911
CAUSE HARM. ALMOST EVERY
03:55:25.978 --> 03:55:27.480
INDUSTRY IN THE U. S. HAS HELD
03:55:27.546 --> 03:55:29.949
LIABLE FOR WHAT ITS PRODUCTS DO,
03:55:30.015 --> 03:55:31.150
BUT THE GUN INDUSTRY IS NOT HELD
03:55:31.217 --> 03:55:32.651
TO THE SAME STANDARD. WITH
03:55:32.718 --> 03:55:34.753
RIGHTS COME RESPONSIBILITIES. IT
03:55:34.820 --> 03:55:36.155
IS TIME TO HOLD THIS KIND OF
03:55:36.222 --> 03:55:37.289
INDUSTRY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE
03:55:37.356 --> 03:55:39.191
CARNAGE IN FEAR THAT OUR STREETS
03:55:39.258 --> 03:55:41.060
IN OUR COMMUNITIES FACE 15 94
03:55:41.126 --> 03:55:43.162
ESTABLISHES THE FIREARM INDUSTRY
03:55:43.229 --> 03:55:44.763
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT, ALLOWING THE
03:55:44.830 --> 03:55:46.265
CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY GENERAL,
03:55:46.332 --> 03:55:47.900
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND SURVIVORS
03:55:47.967 --> 03:55:50.236
OF GUN VIOLENCE TO PURSUE LEGAL
03:55:50.302 --> 03:55:51.270
ACTION IN CALIFORNIA COURTS
03:55:51.337 --> 03:55:53.272
AGAINST IRRESPONSIBLE RECKLESS
03:55:53.339 --> 03:55:54.440
AND NEGLIGENT GUN MANUFACTURERS
03:55:54.507 --> 03:55:56.675
, IMPORTERS AND DEALERS LAST
03:55:56.742 --> 03:55:58.444
MONTH, U. S DISTRICT JUDGE MADE
03:55:58.511 --> 03:56:00.446
D'AGOSTINO DISMISSED A LAWSUIT
03:56:00.513 --> 03:56:02.147
FROM GUN INDUSTRY GROUPS THAT
03:56:02.214 --> 03:56:03.616
CHALLENGE NEW YORK'S LAW FROM
03:56:03.682 --> 03:56:05.017
2021 PERMITTING CIVIL SUITS
03:56:05.084 --> 03:56:06.252
AGAINST GUN MANUFACTURERS AND
03:56:06.318 --> 03:56:09.255
SELLERS. FINANCIAL REPERCUSSIONS
03:56:09.321 --> 03:56:11.223
MAY FINALLY PUSHED THE FIREARMS
03:56:11.290 --> 03:56:13.192
INDUSTRY AND DEALERS TO BE MORE
03:56:13.259 --> 03:56:15.060
RESPONSIBLE BY IMPROVING THEIR
03:56:15.127 --> 03:56:16.829
PRACTICES AND OBEYING CALIFORNIA
03:56:16.896 --> 03:56:19.298
. STRICT GUN LAWS. WITH THAT WE
03:56:19.365 --> 03:56:20.599
HAVE WITNESSES THAT ARE CALLING
03:56:20.666 --> 03:56:22.401
IN, OR E FREILICH WITH GIFFORDS.
03:56:22.468 --> 03:56:24.003
LAUREN LEAVE WITH BRADY AND
03:56:24.069 --> 03:56:26.372
WOMEN AGAINST GUN VIOLENCE OR
03:56:26.438 --> 03:56:28.507
ALRIGHT. MARCUS MIGHT ALSO BE
03:56:28.574 --> 03:56:30.209
HERE IN THE ROOM. IF SHE WISHES
03:56:30.276 --> 03:56:31.477
TO SPEAK. ALL RIGHT, WELL, LET'S
03:56:31.544 --> 03:56:34.413
START WITH THE PHONE. UM LAUREN
03:56:34.480 --> 03:56:36.849
LIEBE OR ARI FREILICH. IF EITHER
03:56:36.916 --> 03:56:38.684
OF YOU ARE AVAILABLE, PLEASE
03:56:38.751 --> 03:56:42.321
IDENTIFY YOURSELVES. YES, I. MY
03:56:42.388 --> 03:56:44.056
NAME IS ARI FREILICH. I'M STEVE,
03:56:44.123 --> 03:56:45.624
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR GIFFORDS.
03:56:45.691 --> 03:56:47.026
THE GUN VIOLENCE PREVENTION
03:56:47.092 --> 03:56:47.860
ORGANIZATION LED BY FORMER
03:56:47.927 --> 03:56:49.228
CONGRESSWOMAN DONNA AND GUN
03:56:49.295 --> 03:56:51.196
VIOLENCE SURVIVOR GABBY GIFFORDS
03:56:51.263 --> 03:56:52.731
, VERY HAPPY AND PROUD TO SPEAK
03:56:52.798 --> 03:56:53.866
TODAY AND SUPPORT THE FARM
03:56:53.933 --> 03:56:56.035
INDUSTRY RESPONSIBILITY ACT. WE
03:56:56.101 --> 03:56:56.635
BELIEVE QUITE SIMPLY THAT THE
03:56:56.702 --> 03:56:57.836
FIRE MINISTRY HAS A
03:56:57.903 --> 03:57:00.372
RESPONSIBILITY LIKE ANY OTHER TO
03:57:00.439 --> 03:57:01.407
TAKE REASONABLE PRECAUTIONS TO
03:57:01.473 --> 03:57:03.008
PROTECT HUMAN LIFE, PREVENT
03:57:03.075 --> 03:57:05.010
UNNECESSARY HARM AND SUFFERING.
03:57:05.077 --> 03:57:06.645
WHEN INDUSTRY MEMBERS FAILED TO
03:57:06.712 --> 03:57:08.080
TAKE REASONABLE PRECAUTIONS.
03:57:08.147 --> 03:57:09.214
THEY SHOULD BE HELD FAIRLY AND
03:57:09.281 --> 03:57:10.382
JUSTLY ACCOUNTABLE IN COURT,
03:57:10.449 --> 03:57:11.684
JUST LIKE EVERY OTHER INDUSTRY,
03:57:11.750 --> 03:57:13.385
THE MORE NO LESS. TO THOSE THEY
03:57:13.452 --> 03:57:16.789
WRONGFULLY HARMED. UNFORTUNATELY
03:57:16.855 --> 03:57:17.690
GUN INDUSTRY TODAY HAS OFTEN
03:57:17.756 --> 03:57:19.158
BEEN EXEMPTED FROM ANY LEVELS OF
03:57:19.224 --> 03:57:19.858
REGULATION, OVERSIGHT AND
03:57:19.925 --> 03:57:20.459
ACCOUNTABILITY THAT OTHERWISE
03:57:20.526 --> 03:57:21.560
PROMOTE SAFER PRACTICES AND
03:57:21.627 --> 03:57:24.296
AVERT HARM. THESE COMMUNITIES
03:57:24.363 --> 03:57:25.531
HAVE SHIELDED THIS PROFITABLE
03:57:25.598 --> 03:57:26.599
INDUSTRY, PACING BASIC FINANCIAL
03:57:26.665 --> 03:57:28.767
INCENTIVES TO DO BETTER. THEY'VE
03:57:28.834 --> 03:57:30.669
OFTEN LEFT VICTIMS OF GUN
03:57:30.736 --> 03:57:31.737
VIOLENCE WITHOUT ANY MEASURE OF
03:57:31.804 --> 03:57:32.771
COMPENSATION OR JUSTICE. AND
03:57:32.838 --> 03:57:34.807
THEY PROVIDED AN UNFAIR BUSINESS
03:57:34.873 --> 03:57:35.274
ADVANTAGE TO THE MOST
03:57:35.341 --> 03:57:36.475
AGGRESSIVELY IRRESPONSIBLE
03:57:36.542 --> 03:57:38.043
FOREIGN MINISTRY MEMBERS OVER
03:57:38.110 --> 03:57:40.746
MORE RESPONSIBLE COMPETITORS.
03:57:40.813 --> 03:57:41.614
THE GOOD NEWS THAT STATES CAN
03:57:41.680 --> 03:57:43.616
ACT AS THIS BILL PROPOSES TO
03:57:43.682 --> 03:57:44.383
PROMOTE ACCOUNTABILITY AND LIMIT
03:57:44.450 --> 03:57:46.218
THE REACH OF THE FEDERAL GUN
03:57:46.285 --> 03:57:47.553
INDUSTRY COMMUNITY LAW. WHICH
03:57:47.620 --> 03:57:49.254
SPECIFICALLY PRESERVES A ROLE
03:57:49.321 --> 03:57:50.289
FOR STATES TO PRESCRIBE AND
03:57:50.356 --> 03:57:51.323
ENFORCE STANDARDS OF CONDUCT FOR
03:57:51.390 --> 03:57:53.559
THE GUN INDUSTRY, PARTICULARLY
03:57:53.626 --> 03:57:55.060
REGARDING CASES WERE PLAINTIFFS
03:57:55.127 --> 03:57:56.395
CAN PROVE THEY WERE HARMED BY A
03:57:56.462 --> 03:57:58.030
GUN INDUSTRY MEMBERS VIOLATION
03:57:58.097 --> 03:57:59.665
OF STATE LAW APPLICABLE TO THE
03:57:59.732 --> 03:58:00.833
SALES OR MARKETING. OF A FIREARM
03:58:00.899 --> 03:58:03.469
OR RELATED PRODUCTS. CONSISTENT
03:58:03.535 --> 03:58:04.637
WITH THE FEDERAL LAW THAT WOULD
03:58:04.703 --> 03:58:06.005
CODIFY A FARM INDUSTRY STANDARD
03:58:06.071 --> 03:58:08.073
OF CONDUCT AND CALIFORNIA CIVIL
03:58:08.140 --> 03:58:08.707
CODE REQUIRING FOREIGN MINISTRY
03:58:08.774 --> 03:58:09.642
MEMBERS TO TAKE REASONABLE
03:58:09.708 --> 03:58:10.643
PRECAUTIONS TO PREVENT SPECIFIED
03:58:10.709 --> 03:58:13.178
HARMS. I WOULD EXPRESSLY CLARIFY
03:58:13.245 --> 03:58:15.247
THAT THE STANDARD OF CONDUCT
03:58:15.314 --> 03:58:16.281
INCORPORATE SOME OTHER CONSUMER
03:58:16.348 --> 03:58:16.815
SAFETY AND FAIR BUSINESS
03:58:16.882 --> 03:58:17.416
PRACTICES LAWS. CALIFORNIA'S
03:58:17.483 --> 03:58:17.883
LAWS PROHIBITING FALSE
03:58:17.950 --> 03:58:21.286
ADVERTISING. PEREIRA PROACTIVELY
03:58:21.353 --> 03:58:22.721
PROHIBIT FAR MINISTRY DEFENDANTS
03:58:22.788 --> 03:58:23.355
FROM PRODUCING OR SELLING
03:58:23.422 --> 03:58:24.556
FIREARMS, LIKE THE NEXT BUMP
03:58:24.623 --> 03:58:26.158
STOCK DEVICES THAT ARE
03:58:26.225 --> 03:58:27.026
ABNORMALLY DANGEROUS AND LIKELY
03:58:27.092 --> 03:58:29.061
TO CAUSE AN UNREASONABLE RISK OF
03:58:29.128 --> 03:58:30.195
HARM TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND
03:58:30.262 --> 03:58:31.497
SAFETY. AND FINALLY WOULD
03:58:31.563 --> 03:58:33.298
AUTHORIZE PEOPLE HARMED BY FIRE
03:58:33.365 --> 03:58:34.500
MINISTRY MEMBERS VIOLATION OF
03:58:34.566 --> 03:58:35.968
THIS STANDARD OF CONDUCT AND
03:58:36.035 --> 03:58:37.503
DESIGNATED OFFICIALS ACTING ON
03:58:37.569 --> 03:58:39.304
BEHALF OF THE PEOPLE TO SEEK
03:58:39.371 --> 03:58:40.506
FAIR JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY
03:58:40.572 --> 03:58:42.007
FOR THAT HARM IN THE COURT. THIS
03:58:42.074 --> 03:58:44.043
BUILDING FROM A SAFER AND MORE
03:58:44.109 --> 03:58:44.677
RESPONSIBLE INDUSTRY PRACTICES
03:58:44.743 --> 03:58:46.445
AND ENSURE WE'RE DOING ALL WE
03:58:46.512 --> 03:58:47.713
CAN TO OPEN COURTROOM DOORS. THE
03:58:47.780 --> 03:58:49.581
VICTIMS ACCESS TO JUSTICE TOP
03:58:49.648 --> 03:58:50.649
EARLY FOR ORGANIZATION AND WE
03:58:50.716 --> 03:58:53.052
STRONGLY URGE YOUR SUPPORT.
03:58:53.118 --> 03:58:54.219
THANK YOU, MR FREILICH. ALRIGHT
03:58:54.286 --> 03:58:59.758
LAUREN LIEB. CHAIR AMBERG AND
03:58:59.825 --> 03:59:00.793
DISTINGUISHED MEMBERS OF THE
03:59:00.859 --> 03:59:01.493
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
03:59:01.560 --> 03:59:02.795
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
03:59:02.861 --> 03:59:04.897
SPEAK WITH YOU TODAY. MY NAME IS
03:59:04.963 --> 03:59:07.533
LAUREN LI. OH, WE LOST HIM
03:59:07.599 --> 03:59:12.171
ASLEEP. HELLO. CAN YOU? YOU
03:59:12.237 --> 03:59:14.106
CAN'T HEAR ME. YES, WE HEAR YOU
03:59:14.173 --> 03:59:18.377
NOW. OKAY MY NAME IS LAUREN LI
03:59:18.444 --> 03:59:19.678
AND GRASSROOTS GUN VIOLENCE
03:59:19.745 --> 03:59:20.679
PREVENTION ACTIVISTS FOR MORE
03:59:20.746 --> 03:59:23.882
THAN 20 YEARS. MY ACTIVISM BEGAN
03:59:23.949 --> 03:59:25.584
, AS IT DOES FOR SO MANY PEOPLE
03:59:25.651 --> 03:59:26.418
IN RESPONSE TO MY FAMILY'S
03:59:26.485 --> 03:59:27.519
PERSONAL EXPERIENCE WITH GUN
03:59:27.586 --> 03:59:31.790
VIOLENCE. IN THE SUMMER OF 1999
03:59:31.857 --> 03:59:33.559
, THE HEAVILY ARMED NEO ATTACK
03:59:33.625 --> 03:59:34.727
THE JEWISH COMMUNITY CENTER IN A
03:59:34.793 --> 03:59:36.795
SUBURB OF LOS ANGELES. HE
03:59:36.862 --> 03:59:38.063
ENTERED THE BUILDING WITH
03:59:38.130 --> 03:59:39.231
MULTIPLE FIREARMS AND HIGH
03:59:39.298 --> 03:59:40.265
CAPACITY MAGAZINES AND BEGIN
03:59:40.332 --> 03:59:43.402
SHOOTING. HIS BARRAGE OF BULLETS
03:59:43.469 --> 03:59:45.337
LASTED LESS THAN A MINUTE,
03:59:45.404 --> 03:59:46.705
DURING WHICH TIME HE FIRED ABOUT
03:59:46.772 --> 03:59:48.207
70 ROUNDS AND MULTIPLE PEOPLE
03:59:48.273 --> 03:59:50.542
WERE SHOT. HE WAS EXPECTING TO
03:59:50.609 --> 03:59:52.111
SEND A MESSAGE BY MASSACRING AN
03:59:52.177 --> 03:59:54.313
ASSEMBLY OF JEWISH ADULT.
03:59:54.379 --> 03:59:55.914
INSTEAD HE ENCOUNTERED SMALL
03:59:55.981 --> 03:59:57.282
CHILDREN WHO ARE ATTENDING
03:59:57.349 --> 03:59:59.418
SUMMER DAY CANCER. MY SIX YEAR
03:59:59.485 --> 04:00:01.520
OLD SON WAS ONE OF THE CHILDREN
04:00:01.587 --> 04:00:03.255
IN THE LINE OF FIRE. HE WAS HIT
04:00:03.322 --> 04:00:04.857
MULTIPLE TIMES, AND MY EIGHT
04:00:04.923 --> 04:00:06.692
YEAR OLD SON WAS ONE OF 200
04:00:06.759 --> 04:00:08.026
OTHER CHILDREN WHO WITNESSED THE
04:00:08.093 --> 04:00:10.262
CHAOS AND TERROR THAT DAY. AFTER
04:00:10.329 --> 04:00:12.164
LEAVING THE JCC, THE SHOOTER
04:00:12.231 --> 04:00:13.665
MURDERED JOSEPH A. LET Ó
04:00:13.732 --> 04:00:15.067
FILIPINO AMERICAN POSTER WORKER
04:00:15.134 --> 04:00:17.035
WHO WAS ON HIS ROUTE DELIVERING
04:00:17.102 --> 04:00:18.804
MAIL. MY SON SURVIVED HIS
04:00:18.871 --> 04:00:21.874
PHYSICAL WOUNDS. BUT FROM BOTH
04:00:21.940 --> 04:00:24.209
OF MY CHILDREN, MY FAMILY AND MY
04:00:24.276 --> 04:00:24.843
COMMUNITY, THE EMOTIONAL SCARS
04:00:24.910 --> 04:00:27.780
WILL LAST A LIFETIME. OUR
04:00:27.846 --> 04:00:29.481
EXPERIENCE. THIS EXPERIENCE IS
04:00:29.548 --> 04:00:33.485
UNIQUELY AMERICAN. AFTER THE
04:00:33.552 --> 04:00:35.053
SHOOTING, WE JOINED WITH OTHER
04:00:35.120 --> 04:00:36.822
FAMILIES TO SUE THE GUN
04:00:36.889 --> 04:00:38.157
MANUFACTURERS THAT ENGAGED IN
04:00:38.223 --> 04:00:39.458
DANGEROUS AND IRRESPONSIBLE
04:00:39.525 --> 04:00:41.193
BUSINESS PRACTICES RELATED TO
04:00:41.260 --> 04:00:41.827
THE MANUFACTURER, MARKETING AND
04:00:41.894 --> 04:00:42.828
DISTRIBUTION OF THE SHOOTERS,
04:00:42.895 --> 04:00:46.732
FIREARMS. WE FILED OUR SUIT IN
04:00:46.799 --> 04:00:48.500
2000, BUT THE GUN INDUSTRY
04:00:48.567 --> 04:00:50.969
FOUGHT US FOR FIVE YEARS AND ALL
04:00:51.036 --> 04:00:53.005
THE WAY UP TO THE SUPREME COURT
04:00:53.071 --> 04:00:54.807
TO STOP THE CASE FROM GOING TO
04:00:54.873 --> 04:00:56.041
TRIAL. THE SUPREME COURT RULED
04:00:56.108 --> 04:00:57.810
TO ALLOW THE CASE TO MOVE
04:00:57.876 --> 04:01:00.045
FORWARD. BUT LITTLE DID WE KNOW
04:01:00.112 --> 04:01:01.213
THAT CONGRESS HAD ALSO BEEN
04:01:01.280 --> 04:01:02.281
LOOKING AT FIREARM INDUSTRY
04:01:02.347 --> 04:01:04.149
LAWSUITS LIKE OURS. THAT SAME
04:01:04.216 --> 04:01:06.318
YEAR IN 2000 AND FIVE CONGRESS
04:01:06.385 --> 04:01:08.220
PASSED THE PROTECTION OF LAWFUL
04:01:08.287 --> 04:01:10.189
COMMERCE IN ARMS ACT, OR PLACA.
04:01:10.255 --> 04:01:12.024
NOT ONLY DID PLAKA PROTECT THE
04:01:12.090 --> 04:01:14.092
INDUSTRY FROM NEW LAWSUITS, BUT
04:01:14.159 --> 04:01:15.694
IT IMPACTED CASES LIKE OURS THAT
04:01:15.761 --> 04:01:16.862
HAD ALREADY AHEAD AND WRAP UP.
04:01:16.929 --> 04:01:23.068
OKAY? IT'S NOT EQUAL JUSTICE
04:01:23.135 --> 04:01:24.169
WHEN PEOPLE HARMED BY THE GUN
04:01:24.236 --> 04:01:26.672
INDUSTRY CAN'T DO IN COURT, AND
04:01:26.738 --> 04:01:28.707
WE APPRECIATE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
04:01:28.774 --> 04:01:29.541
KING FOR HIS DEDICATED WORK AND
04:01:29.608 --> 04:01:31.844
URGED SUPPORT OF ABBY 15 94.
04:01:31.910 --> 04:01:35.781
THANK YOU, MA'AM. OKAY. UM
04:01:35.848 --> 04:01:37.883
OTHERS IN SUPPORT HERE IN THE
04:01:37.950 --> 04:01:38.717
HEARING ROOM HAD APPROACHED THE
04:01:38.784 --> 04:01:39.818
MICROPHONE. PROVIDE YOUR NAME,
04:01:39.885 --> 04:01:40.853
YOUR AFFILIATION AND YOUR
04:01:40.919 --> 04:01:44.289
POSITION. GOOD AFTERNOON. SHE
04:01:44.356 --> 04:01:45.724
REMEMBERS REBECCA MARCUS ON
04:01:45.791 --> 04:01:47.826
BEHALF OF ONE OF THE BILL'S
04:01:47.893 --> 04:01:48.493
SPONSORS. BRADY, CALIFORNIA
04:01:48.560 --> 04:01:51.830
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. HELLO I'M
04:01:51.897 --> 04:01:53.832
EMILY ALL FROM DAVIS. AND I'M A
04:01:53.899 --> 04:01:55.133
MOMS DEMAND ACTION, VOLUNTEER
04:01:55.200 --> 04:01:56.802
AND I SUPPORT THIS, BILL. THANK
04:01:56.869 --> 04:01:59.538
YOU. HI CRYSTAL OPAL OTTO, MY
04:01:59.605 --> 04:02:00.672
MOM'S RAN ACTION VOLUNTEER FROM
04:02:00.739 --> 04:02:03.041
ALAMEDA AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
04:02:03.108 --> 04:02:04.743
CASSANDRA WEB STONE MOMS DEMAND
04:02:04.810 --> 04:02:05.878
ACTION VOLUNTEER FROM FOLSOM AND
04:02:05.944 --> 04:02:08.747
SUPPORT THANK YOU. ALRIGHT
04:02:08.814 --> 04:02:11.216
OTHERS IN SUPPORT, MODERATE IF
04:02:11.283 --> 04:02:13.318
YOU WOULD QUEUE THEM UP THOSE IN
04:02:13.385 --> 04:02:15.320
SUPPORT OF A B 15 94 ON THE
04:02:15.387 --> 04:02:17.256
PHONE. THANK YOU FOR THOSE IN
04:02:17.322 --> 04:02:20.592
SUPPORT. PRESS LONDON ZERO WE
04:02:20.659 --> 04:02:22.728
FIRST GO TO LINE 2 75 1 MOMENT,
04:02:22.794 --> 04:02:31.403
PLEASE. AND GO AHEAD TO 75.
04:02:31.470 --> 04:02:33.472
NIELSEN MARKS MORE ON BEHALF OF
04:02:33.538 --> 04:02:35.374
THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO IN
04:02:35.440 --> 04:02:37.075
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. NEXT IS 2
04:02:37.142 --> 04:02:43.181
37. GO AHEAD, PLEASE. HELLO
04:02:43.248 --> 04:02:48.320
REMEMBERS. NICOLE OPINION IS ON
04:02:48.387 --> 04:02:50.455
BEHALF OF EVERY TOWN FOR GUN
04:02:50.522 --> 04:02:52.824
SAFETY AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
04:02:52.891 --> 04:02:55.727
NEXT IS ONE. UH PARDON ME. NEXT
04:02:55.794 --> 04:02:57.696
IS TWO THIRDS TO 17. PLEASE GO
04:02:57.763 --> 04:03:00.966
AHEAD. AFTERNOON DYLAN FROM THE
04:03:01.033 --> 04:03:01.934
NATIONALIST ASSOCIATION OF
04:03:02.000 --> 04:03:03.201
SOCIAL WORKERS, CALIFORNIA
04:03:03.268 --> 04:03:04.503
CHAPTER. I AM IN SUPPORT OF 15
04:03:04.569 --> 04:03:08.907
94. THANK YOU. NEXT IS TO 76 GO
04:03:08.974 --> 04:03:13.378
AHEAD, PLEASE. HELLO MY NAME'S
04:03:13.445 --> 04:03:16.815
JULIETTE ML. OH, UH, APPALLING
04:03:16.882 --> 04:03:18.317
ON BEHALF OF WOMEN FOR AMERICAN
04:03:18.383 --> 04:03:20.919
VALUES AND ETHICS WAVE, AND WE
04:03:20.986 --> 04:03:21.920
STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS, BILL.
04:03:21.987 --> 04:03:24.189
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO
04:03:24.256 --> 04:03:28.961
TO 1 87. THIS IS CLAIRE SIMPSON
04:03:29.027 --> 04:03:31.797
FROM OPEN IN CALIFORNIA. I AM A
04:03:31.863 --> 04:03:33.098
GUN VIOLENCE SURVIVOR AND A
04:03:33.165 --> 04:03:34.967
VOLUNTEER WITH MOMS DEMAND
04:03:35.033 --> 04:03:36.702
ACTION, AND I'M CALLING TO
04:03:36.768 --> 04:03:37.869
STRONGLY SUPPORT MAYBE 15 94.
04:03:37.936 --> 04:03:42.274
THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO TO 1 70,
04:03:42.341 --> 04:03:49.715
PLEASE GO AHEAD. HEY! GOOD
04:03:49.781 --> 04:03:51.850
AFTERNOON, CARRYING MEMBERS NAME
04:03:51.917 --> 04:03:53.518
ALI, LEGISLATIVE DIRECTOR WITH
04:03:53.585 --> 04:03:54.519
THE OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY
04:03:54.586 --> 04:03:56.588
GENERAL ROB CONTEST WHO IS A
04:03:56.655 --> 04:03:58.390
PROUD POST SPONSORS. 15 94.
04:03:58.457 --> 04:04:02.260
THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND NO
04:04:02.327 --> 04:04:03.996
FURTHER LINES. YOU MAY PROCEED.
04:04:04.062 --> 04:04:05.197
ALRIGHT LET'S GO TO OPPOSITION.
04:04:05.263 --> 04:04:10.902
AH! OPPOSITION TO A B 15 94
04:04:10.969 --> 04:04:15.440
NOTE. NICK VIA. IF MR VISAS
04:04:15.507 --> 04:04:17.542
EITHER HERE OR ON THE PHONE, MR
04:04:17.609 --> 04:04:22.280
VIA YES. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR AND
04:04:22.347 --> 04:04:25.183
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE. AGAIN
04:04:25.250 --> 04:04:26.752
MY NAME IS PHILIP, REPRESENTING
04:04:26.818 --> 04:04:27.953
THE CALIFORNIA RIFLE AND PISTOL
04:04:28.020 --> 04:04:32.591
ASSOCIATION. UM. CRP S ALREADY
04:04:32.657 --> 04:04:33.525
SUBMITTED A VERY LENGTHY AND
04:04:33.592 --> 04:04:36.862
DETAILED AND VERY COMPELLING
04:04:36.928 --> 04:04:38.964
LETTER IN STRONG OPPOSITION TO
04:04:39.031 --> 04:04:41.600
ÁP 15 94, SO I DON'T WANT TO BE
04:04:41.666 --> 04:04:43.502
LABOR THAT I WOULD LIKE TO
04:04:43.568 --> 04:04:47.205
MENTION AH! THAT PUBLIC LAW THAT
04:04:47.272 --> 04:04:48.340
EARLIER WITNESS WASN'T ABLE TO
04:04:48.407 --> 04:04:51.276
FINISH AND THAT WAS THE FEDERAL
04:04:51.343 --> 04:04:52.411
LAW THAT PREVENTS FIREARM MEANT
04:04:52.477 --> 04:04:55.881
BEING SUED. PROTECTION OF LAWFUL
04:04:55.947 --> 04:04:58.917
COMMERCE. ACTEAL ONE O 9-90 TO
04:04:58.984 --> 04:05:00.452
PROTECT MANUFACTURERS AND
04:05:00.519 --> 04:05:02.387
DEALERS FROM BEING SUED WEN A
04:05:02.454 --> 04:05:05.424
FIREARM IS USED IN A CRIME. THE
04:05:05.490 --> 04:05:07.893
ACT WAS PASSED BY THE US SET
04:05:07.959 --> 04:05:09.227
2000 AND FIVE AND PROHIBITS
04:05:09.294 --> 04:05:12.064
VICTIMS OF A PERSON. MISUSING
04:05:12.130 --> 04:05:13.532
FIREARMS PRODUCTS FROM SEEKING
04:05:13.598 --> 04:05:14.499
DAMAGES OR INJUNCTIVE OR
04:05:14.566 --> 04:05:17.769
BELIEFS. RULING DETERMINED
04:05:17.836 --> 04:05:19.337
BUSINESSES IN THE UNITED STATES
04:05:19.404 --> 04:05:20.839
THAT ARE LEGALLY ENGAGING IN
04:05:20.906 --> 04:05:23.241
COMMERCE CANNOT AND SHOULD NOT
04:05:23.308 --> 04:05:24.743
BE LIABLE FOR THE CRIMINAL
04:05:24.810 --> 04:05:26.311
ACTIONS OF OTHERS DECIDE TO ACT
04:05:26.378 --> 04:05:28.447
OUTSIDE OF THE CONTROL OF A
04:05:28.513 --> 04:05:31.450
COMPANY OR MISUSE OF THEIR
04:05:31.516 --> 04:05:33.251
PRODUCT, SPECIFICALLY THE RULING
04:05:33.318 --> 04:05:34.953
STATE AND I QUOTE THE
04:05:35.020 --> 04:05:39.057
POSSIBILITY OF IMPOSING
04:05:39.124 --> 04:05:40.992
FOR HARM THAT IS SOLELY CAUSED
04:05:41.059 --> 04:05:43.028
BY OTHERS IS AN ABUSE OF THE
04:05:43.095 --> 04:05:44.629
LEGAL SYSTEM ERODES PUBLIC
04:05:44.696 --> 04:05:46.198
CONFIDENCE IN OUR NATION'S LAWS.
04:05:46.264 --> 04:05:49.901
THREATENS THE DOMINATION. OF A
04:05:49.968 --> 04:05:51.636
BASIC CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND
04:05:51.703 --> 04:05:53.872
CIVIL LIBERTY INVITES THE
04:05:53.939 --> 04:05:56.308
DISASSEMBLY AND DESTABILIZATION
04:05:56.374 --> 04:05:58.210
OF OTHER DISTRICT ECONOMIC
04:05:58.276 --> 04:06:00.145
SECTORS LAWFULLY COMPETING IN
04:06:00.212 --> 04:06:01.213
THE FREE ENTERPRISE OF THE
04:06:01.279 --> 04:06:03.982
UNITED STATES. CONSTITUTES AN
04:06:04.049 --> 04:06:05.383
UNREASONABLE BURDEN ON
04:06:05.450 --> 04:06:06.551
INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN COMMERCE
04:06:06.618 --> 04:06:11.790
OF THE UNITED STATES. UNQUOTE. P
04:06:11.857 --> 04:06:13.358
R PA. THE SAFETY OF CALIFORNIA'S
04:06:13.425 --> 04:06:14.826
IS REALLY AT THE VERY FOUNDATION
04:06:14.893 --> 04:06:17.496
OF ORGANIZATION. IT'S BEEN OUR
04:06:17.562 --> 04:06:19.598
CONSISTENT GOAL TO WORK TOWARDS
04:06:19.664 --> 04:06:20.799
COMMON SENSE SOLUTIONS REGARDING
04:06:20.866 --> 04:06:22.701
THOSE ISSUES OF CRIME. IN
04:06:22.767 --> 04:06:25.370
RESPONSIBLE FIREARM OWNERSHIP.
04:06:25.437 --> 04:06:26.771
THIS CAN BE DONE, HOWEVER,
04:06:26.838 --> 04:06:28.406
WITHOUT SACRIFICING OUR
04:06:28.473 --> 04:06:29.474
CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND THE
04:06:29.541 --> 04:06:33.211
ABILITY OF LAW ABIDING UM, LAW
04:06:33.278 --> 04:06:34.980
ABIDING PEOPLE TO PROTECT THEIR
04:06:35.046 --> 04:06:37.015
FAMILIES AND ENJOY COMPETITIVE
04:06:37.082 --> 04:06:39.551
SHOOTING THIS WE THANK YOU AGAIN
04:06:39.618 --> 04:06:41.887
, AND WE HEARD YOU, UH, NO. VOTE
04:06:41.953 --> 04:06:43.989
ON. MAYBE 15 94 ALREADY. THANK
04:06:44.055 --> 04:06:45.123
YOU. THANK YOU, MR PHILIP.
04:06:45.190 --> 04:06:48.460
ALRIGHT. UM OTHERS IN OPPOSITION
04:06:48.527 --> 04:06:50.662
HERE IN ROOM 2100, SAYING NO ONE
04:06:50.729 --> 04:06:51.863
APPROACHES THE MICROPHONE ON THE
04:06:51.930 --> 04:06:53.832
PHONE MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
04:06:53.899 --> 04:06:56.201
QUEUE UP THOSE IN OPPOSITION TO
04:06:56.268 --> 04:06:58.370
HB 15 94. THANK YOU, LADIES AND
04:06:58.436 --> 04:07:00.805
GENTLEMEN, ONCE AGAIN IF YOU ARE
04:07:00.872 --> 04:07:09.080
AN OPPOSITION PRESS 10. AND WE
04:07:09.147 --> 04:07:11.116
WILL FIRST GO TO LINE 2 38,
04:07:11.183 --> 04:07:14.252
PLEASE GO AHEAD. MR CHAIRMAN AND
04:07:14.319 --> 04:07:14.986
MEMBERS SAM PAREDES,
04:07:15.053 --> 04:07:16.421
REPRESENTING GUN OWNERS OF
04:07:16.488 --> 04:07:18.523
CALIFORNIA AND ON BEHALF OF THE
04:07:18.590 --> 04:07:20.125
NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION AND
04:07:20.192 --> 04:07:21.259
THE NATIONAL SHOOTING SPORTS
04:07:21.326 --> 04:07:22.327
FOUNDATION IN STRONG OPPOSITION
04:07:22.394 --> 04:07:27.766
TO THIS BILL. NEXT WE GO TO 78
04:07:27.832 --> 04:07:31.970
GO AHEAD, PLEASE. HI I MISSED
04:07:32.037 --> 04:07:33.572
WHEN I WHEN I WAS SUPPOSED TO
04:07:33.638 --> 04:07:35.106
CALL IN FOR SUPPORT. THIS IS
04:07:35.173 --> 04:07:36.341
PETER STEIN FROM WOMEN FOR
04:07:36.408 --> 04:07:37.642
AMERICAN VALUES AND ETHICS AND
04:07:37.709 --> 04:07:40.545
STRONG SUPPORT. NEXT WE GO TO
04:07:40.612 --> 04:07:44.983
68, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HEIGHT
04:07:45.050 --> 04:07:46.284
HEATHER COLA, MAC AND I OPPOSE
04:07:46.351 --> 04:07:50.789
15 94. AND NO FURTHER QUESTIONS
04:07:50.855 --> 04:07:52.490
. YOU MAY CONTINUE ALREADY BRING
04:07:52.557 --> 04:07:53.825
IT BACK TO COMMITTEE QUESTIONS
04:07:53.892 --> 04:07:56.127
BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS SEEING NO
04:07:56.194 --> 04:07:57.229
QUESTIONS. NO COMMENTS. IS THERE
04:07:57.295 --> 04:08:00.765
A MOTION SENATOR STERN MOVES THE
04:08:00.832 --> 04:08:03.235
BILL. ALL RIGHT, UM WOULD YOU
04:08:03.301 --> 04:08:05.503
CARE TO CLOSE ON BEHALF OF SOME
04:08:05.570 --> 04:08:07.472
OF THE MEMBER TING? THANK YOU,
04:08:07.539 --> 04:08:08.406
MR. UH MR CHAIR AND SENATORS.
04:08:08.473 --> 04:08:10.609
THIS IS ONE OF THE BILLS AMONG
04:08:10.675 --> 04:08:12.244
THE PACKAGE OF GUN VIOLENCE
04:08:12.310 --> 04:08:13.812
PREVENTION LEGISLATION, WHICH
04:08:13.878 --> 04:08:15.814
HOPED TO BE HEADING TO THE
04:08:15.880 --> 04:08:16.848
GOVERNOR'S DESK LATER THIS
04:08:16.915 --> 04:08:17.449
MONTH. I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
04:08:17.515 --> 04:08:19.084
FOR I VOTE. THANK YOU. ALL
04:08:19.150 --> 04:08:20.819
RIGHT, MADAM SECRETARY, IF YOU
04:08:20.885 --> 04:08:22.320
WOULD CALL THE ROLL THE MOTION
04:08:22.387 --> 04:08:23.688
IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST WE RE
04:08:23.755 --> 04:08:25.690
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:08:25.757 --> 04:08:26.324
APPROPRIATIONS UMBERG. HAMBURG.
04:08:26.391 --> 04:08:30.028
I BORE GIS. OR JUST KNOW OF A
04:08:30.095 --> 04:08:33.932
EURO HUESO. GRASSO. I GONZALES.
04:08:33.999 --> 04:08:37.302
HERTZBERG HERZBERG, I. JONES.
04:08:37.369 --> 04:08:41.306
CLEARED BY STERN STERN. I
04:08:41.373 --> 04:08:42.474
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE
04:08:42.540 --> 04:08:47.245
WIENER. WIENER? AYE. YOU HAVE 7
04:08:47.312 --> 04:08:50.115
TO 1 WITH MEMBERS MISSING.
04:08:50.181 --> 04:08:51.116
ALRIGHT. WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
04:08:51.182 --> 04:08:52.317
ALL RIGHT, UM NEXT. WE HAVE THE
04:08:52.384 --> 04:08:54.986
VERY LAST BILL FOR TODAY.
04:08:55.053 --> 04:08:56.121
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY YOU'VE
04:08:56.187 --> 04:08:58.123
BEEN IN AND OUT. THANK YOU VERY
04:08:58.189 --> 04:08:59.658
MUCH. SO I TOLD COMMITTEE
04:08:59.724 --> 04:09:00.725
MEMBERS. I THOUGHT WE WOULD BE
04:09:00.792 --> 04:09:02.527
HERE TILL SIX O'CLOCK TONIGHT.
04:09:02.594 --> 04:09:04.029
AND SINCE IT'S THE LAST BILL,
04:09:04.095 --> 04:09:06.765
YOU HAVE ONE HOUR AND 55 MINUTES
04:09:06.831 --> 04:09:07.632
. I WILL TALK VERY SLOWLY, ALL
04:09:07.699 --> 04:09:10.835
RIGHT. SEE, THERE'S BEEN A
04:09:10.902 --> 04:09:11.970
THERE'S BEEN A REVOLT HERE, SO
04:09:12.037 --> 04:09:14.039
MAYBE NOT. MAYBE NOT THAT LONG.
04:09:14.105 --> 04:09:15.840
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR MEMBERS
04:09:15.907 --> 04:09:18.009
TODAY. I'M I'M PRESENTING A B
04:09:18.076 --> 04:09:20.178
2031. I'LL BE ACCEPTING THE
04:09:20.245 --> 04:09:21.379
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS, AND I
04:09:21.446 --> 04:09:22.013
APPRECIATE THE COMMITTEE'S WORK
04:09:22.080 --> 04:09:23.114
ON THIS. THE AMENDMENTS
04:09:23.181 --> 04:09:24.749
CLARIFIED THAT A RESIDENT CAN
04:09:24.816 --> 04:09:25.550
BRING AN INTERPRETER AS WELL AS
04:09:25.617 --> 04:09:26.685
ANOTHER REPRESENTATIVE TO A
04:09:26.751 --> 04:09:27.986
MEETING WITH PARK MANAGEMENT.
04:09:28.053 --> 04:09:29.654
THIS BILL WILL ENSURE THAT
04:09:29.721 --> 04:09:30.755
RESIDENTS CAN BRING A
04:09:30.822 --> 04:09:31.856
REPRESENTATIVE TO MEETINGS WITH
04:09:31.923 --> 04:09:34.359
PARK MANAGEMENT. CURRENTLY PARK
04:09:34.426 --> 04:09:35.460
MANAGEMENT HAS BEEN INTERPRETING
04:09:35.527 --> 04:09:37.429
STATURE TO MEAN THAT THEY CAN
04:09:37.495 --> 04:09:39.197
ONLY ALLOW RESIDENTS OR THEIR
04:09:39.264 --> 04:09:40.098
REPRESENTATIVES TO MEET WITH
04:09:40.165 --> 04:09:40.665
PARK MANDARIN, BUT NOT BOTH.
04:09:40.732 --> 04:09:42.000
SIMULTANEOUSLY THIS RESULTS IN
04:09:42.067 --> 04:09:43.468
WASTED TIME AND INEFFECTIVE
04:09:43.535 --> 04:09:44.969
MEETINGS WHEN THE RESIDENT NEEDS
04:09:45.036 --> 04:09:46.004
THE HELP OF AN INTERPRETER OR
04:09:46.071 --> 04:09:48.039
THE SPECIALIZED KNOWLEDGE OF AN
04:09:48.106 --> 04:09:49.174
ADVOCATE OR ATTORNEY TO NAVIGATE
04:09:49.240 --> 04:09:50.442
COMPLEX ISSUES. THIS BILL WILL
04:09:50.508 --> 04:09:52.644
CLARIFY THAT BOTH RESIDENTS AND
04:09:52.711 --> 04:09:53.511
THEIR REPRESENTATIVES CAN MEET
04:09:53.578 --> 04:09:54.512
THE PARK MANAGEMENT ABOUT
04:09:54.579 --> 04:09:55.680
SPECIFIED ISSUES SUCH AS
04:09:55.747 --> 04:09:56.214
MAINTENANCE STANDARDS OR
04:09:56.281 --> 04:09:57.282
RESIDENT CONCERNS ABOUT MOBILE
04:09:57.349 --> 04:09:58.383
HOME PARK RULES. ESPECTFULLY
04:09:58.450 --> 04:10:01.119
ASK FOR I VOTE. AND WITH ME
04:10:01.186 --> 04:10:02.620
TESTIFYING, I BELIEVE ON THE
04:10:02.687 --> 04:10:04.356
PHONE WILL BE MARTHA O'CONNELL
04:10:04.422 --> 04:10:06.157
FROM DISMAL STANDING. WHO'S
04:10:06.224 --> 04:10:07.826
BRUCE STANTON IS THE LEGAL
04:10:07.892 --> 04:10:09.160
COUNSEL FOR DISMAL. BOTH ARE
04:10:09.227 --> 04:10:10.095
ALSO AVAILABLE FOR QUESTIONS.
04:10:10.161 --> 04:10:11.196
ALRIGHT, MISS O'CONNELL, YOU'RE
04:10:11.262 --> 04:10:17.902
AVAILABLE. OR MR STANTON,
04:10:17.969 --> 04:10:19.237
EITHER. IF EITHER OF YOU ARE
04:10:19.304 --> 04:10:21.039
AVAILABLE ON THE PHONE, PLEASE
04:10:21.106 --> 04:10:23.842
IDENTIFY YOURSELVES. CENTER
04:10:23.908 --> 04:10:28.747
LAYERED WISHES TO ADVISED THAT
04:10:28.813 --> 04:10:30.382
YOU MAY BE AS BRIEF AS THE
04:10:30.448 --> 04:10:37.455
AUTHOR. THIS IS BRUCE STANTON. I
04:10:37.522 --> 04:10:39.791
WAS ACTUALLY GONNA JUST LEND
04:10:39.858 --> 04:10:41.259
SUPPORT TO MS O'CONNELL'S
04:10:41.326 --> 04:10:43.895
HELPFUL FOR QUESTIONS, OKAY?
04:10:43.962 --> 04:10:44.896
MISS O'CONNELL, ARE YOU
04:10:44.963 --> 04:10:47.265
AVAILABLE? IF SHE'S NOT
04:10:47.332 --> 04:10:49.100
AVAILABLE, WE CAN COME BACK TO
04:10:49.167 --> 04:10:53.004
HER. LET'S DO THIS. LET'S TAKE
04:10:53.071 --> 04:10:54.606
OTHERS AND SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM
04:10:54.672 --> 04:10:56.007
2100 SEEING NO ONE APPROACHED
04:10:56.074 --> 04:10:57.709
THE MICROPHONE, LET'S GO TO THE
04:10:57.776 --> 04:10:59.043
PHONES AND MISS O'CONNELL
04:10:59.110 --> 04:11:00.645
PRESENTS HERSELF WILL COME BACK
04:11:00.712 --> 04:11:01.913
TO HER IF THAT'S ACCEPTABLE USE
04:11:01.980 --> 04:11:03.081
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY ALRIGHT.
04:11:03.148 --> 04:11:07.919
I SEE AHEAD. NOT OKAY. MODERATOR
04:11:07.986 --> 04:11:08.653
IF YOU WOULD QUEUE UP THOSE IN
04:11:08.720 --> 04:11:28.606
SUPPORT OF A B 2031.
04:11:30.241 --> 04:11:31.342
MATTER. IS THERE ANYONE IN
04:11:31.409 --> 04:11:33.278
SUPPORT ON THE PHONE LINE A. B
04:11:33.344 --> 04:11:35.547
2031. LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, ONCE
04:11:35.613 --> 04:11:42.520
AGAIN PRESS 10. NO ONE IS
04:11:42.587 --> 04:11:44.556
QUEUING UP, SIR. ALRIGHT UH,
04:11:44.622 --> 04:11:45.757
WELL NOW TURNED OPPOSITION ONCE
04:11:45.824 --> 04:11:47.025
AGAIN IF MISS O'CONNELL PRESENTS
04:11:47.091 --> 04:11:48.193
HERSELF WILL TAKE HER TESTIMONY.
04:11:48.259 --> 04:11:51.629
UM ANYONE. I SEE THERE'S NO
04:11:51.696 --> 04:11:54.032
PRIMARY WITNESSES AND OPPOSITION
04:11:54.098 --> 04:11:55.567
. UM AND I SEE NO ONE
04:11:55.633 --> 04:11:56.234
APPROACHING THE MICROPHONE HERE
04:11:56.301 --> 04:11:58.470
IN ROOM 2100 AND OPPOSITION TO A
04:11:58.536 --> 04:12:01.606
B 2031. MODERATOR IF YOU WOULD
04:12:01.673 --> 04:12:03.341
QUEUE UP THOSE ON THE PHONE LINE
04:12:03.408 --> 04:12:07.412
IN OPPOSITION TO A B 2031 THANK
04:12:07.479 --> 04:12:09.447
YOU. LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, ONCE
04:12:09.514 --> 04:12:10.648
AGAIN PRESS 10, IF YOU ARE AN
04:12:10.715 --> 04:12:20.091
OPPOSITION. AND NO ONE HAS
04:12:20.158 --> 04:12:21.192
QUEUED UP, SIR. ALRIGHT, IT'S
04:12:21.259 --> 04:12:29.667
MISS O'CONNELL AVAILABLE. I DO
04:12:29.734 --> 04:12:33.538
NOT SHOW HER LINE CONNECTED. I'M
04:12:33.605 --> 04:12:36.241
SORRY. I'VE BEEN WAITING TO THE
04:12:36.307 --> 04:12:37.842
LINE TO BE MUTED. YOU HEAR ME,
04:12:37.909 --> 04:12:39.777
PLEASE? YES, WE CAN GO AHEAD,
04:12:39.844 --> 04:12:42.247
MISS O'CONNELL. GOOD AFTERNOON
04:12:42.313 --> 04:12:43.781
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS,
04:12:43.848 --> 04:12:45.450
MARTHA O'CONNELL ON BEHALF OF
04:12:45.517 --> 04:12:46.918
THE GOLDEN STATE MANUFACTURED
04:12:46.985 --> 04:12:48.186
HOMEOWNERS LEAGUE IN SUPPORT OF
04:12:48.253 --> 04:12:51.990
THE BILL. I AM A SENIOR BEING IN
04:12:52.056 --> 04:12:54.025
A MOBILE HOME PARK AND SAN JOSE.
04:12:54.092 --> 04:12:55.326
AS A GSM. OH, WELL REGIONAL
04:12:55.393 --> 04:12:58.763
MANAGER. I AM CONSISTENTLY
04:12:58.830 --> 04:13:00.532
WORKING TO HELP SOLVE PROBLEMS
04:13:00.598 --> 04:13:01.499
IT MY PARKS AND SCROUNGING
04:13:01.566 --> 04:13:07.839
PARTS. MAYBE 2031. PROPOSES TO
04:13:07.906 --> 04:13:09.807
AMEND THE MOBILE HOME RESIDENCY
04:13:09.874 --> 04:13:11.409
LAW TO PROMOTE IMPROVED
04:13:11.476 --> 04:13:13.378
COMMUNICATION AND PROBLEM
04:13:13.444 --> 04:13:14.546
SOLVING BETWEEN MOBILE HOMES.
04:13:14.612 --> 04:13:15.813
HOMEOWNERS. MOBILE HOME PARK
04:13:15.880 --> 04:13:20.518
MANAGEMENT. MANY PARK OWNERS ARE
04:13:20.585 --> 04:13:22.153
INTERPRETING CIVIL CODES.
04:13:22.220 --> 04:13:25.890
798.532 LITERALLY. ALLOWING
04:13:25.957 --> 04:13:28.426
EITHER A MOBILE HOME RESIDENT OR
04:13:28.493 --> 04:13:29.694
THEIR REPRESENTATIVES TO MEET
04:13:29.761 --> 04:13:31.029
WITH PARK MANAGEMENT. BUT NOT
04:13:31.095 --> 04:13:34.332
BOTH. THIS LAW WAS MEANT TO
04:13:34.399 --> 04:13:35.433
BREAK A VEHICLE FOR RESOLVING
04:13:35.500 --> 04:13:38.603
GRIEVANCES. WHEN PEOPLE SEEK
04:13:38.670 --> 04:13:39.904
REDRESS, THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO
04:13:39.971 --> 04:13:41.940
DO SO ALONE. BUT SHOULD THEY
04:13:42.006 --> 04:13:45.143
NEED ASSISTANCE? STATE LAWS
04:13:45.209 --> 04:13:47.245
COMMONLY ALLOW THEM TO UTILIZE
04:13:47.312 --> 04:13:49.480
THE ASSISTANCE OF AND BE JOINED
04:13:49.547 --> 04:13:52.283
BY QUALIFIED ADVOCATES OR
04:13:52.350 --> 04:13:53.785
REPRESENTATIVES FOR THE SAKE OF
04:13:53.851 --> 04:13:56.621
RESOLVING PROBLEMS. THIS BILL
04:13:56.688 --> 04:13:59.157
PROPOSES TO ALIGN ITSELF WITH
04:13:59.223 --> 04:13:59.857
THOSE CURRENT CALIFORNIA
04:13:59.924 --> 04:14:01.926
GOVERNANCE VALUES. THANK YOU FOR
04:14:01.993 --> 04:14:06.197
YOUR CONSIDERATION. WARD.
04:14:06.264 --> 04:14:07.532
ALRIGHTY THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
04:14:07.599 --> 04:14:09.334
MISS O'CONNELL. ALRIGHT, LET'S
04:14:09.400 --> 04:14:11.135
TURN TO COMMITTEE. I BELIEVE
04:14:11.202 --> 04:14:12.437
WE'VE TAKEN ALL THE SUPPORTING
04:14:12.503 --> 04:14:13.338
OPPOSITION QUESTIONS BY
04:14:13.404 --> 04:14:14.372
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. SEEING NONE.
04:14:14.439 --> 04:14:17.508
IS THERE A MOTION SENATOR DURAZO
04:14:17.575 --> 04:14:19.744
MOVES THE BILL. ALL RIGHT? UM
04:14:19.811 --> 04:14:22.046
SOME OF THEM WERE LEADING CARE
04:14:22.113 --> 04:14:23.982
TO CLOSE ITS RIGHTFUL MASTER. I
04:14:24.048 --> 04:14:25.049
VOTE ALRIGHT, GREAT. THANK YOU
04:14:25.116 --> 04:14:26.851
VERY MUCH, ALRIGHT. MADAM
04:14:26.918 --> 04:14:28.486
SECRETARY, IF YOU WOULD CALL THE
04:14:28.553 --> 04:14:30.021
ROLE, AND I BELIEVE WE ARE
04:14:30.088 --> 04:14:31.589
COMPLETE, SO WE'RE GOING TO CALL
04:14:31.656 --> 04:14:32.590
THE ROLL ON THIS BILL, AND THEN
04:14:32.657 --> 04:14:33.858
WE'RE GONNA GO, SENATOR
04:14:33.925 --> 04:14:35.860
GONZALEZ, WE'RE WAITING FOR
04:14:35.927 --> 04:14:36.494
SENATOR GONZALEZ ALSO ALRIGHT,
04:14:36.561 --> 04:14:37.862
BUT WE'LL WE'LL GO THROUGH THE
04:14:37.929 --> 04:14:39.931
ROLL TWICE. SO GO AHEAD. MADAM
04:14:39.998 --> 04:14:41.199
SECRETARY, IF YOU WOULD CALL THE
04:14:41.265 --> 04:14:44.035
ROLL ON A B 2031 THE MOTION IS
04:14:44.102 --> 04:14:45.703
DUE PASS AS AMENDED. HAMBURG
04:14:45.770 --> 04:14:48.806
HAMBURG GORGEOUS GORGEOUS. I
04:14:48.873 --> 04:14:50.908
CABALLERO ZERO. I DURAZO. SO I
04:14:50.975 --> 04:14:54.545
GONZALEZ. HERTZBERG HERZBERG, I.
04:14:54.612 --> 04:14:59.984
JONES. JONES. I LAIRD GLARED. I
04:15:00.051 --> 04:15:02.453
STERN STERN. I WIECKOWSKI
04:15:02.520 --> 04:15:06.190
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WIENER. WIENER
04:15:06.257 --> 04:15:08.226
I YOU HAVE 10 TO 0 WITH ONE
04:15:08.292 --> 04:15:09.427
MEMBER. ALRIGHT LET'S PUT IT
04:15:09.494 --> 04:15:11.229
BACK ON CALL. LET'S START AT THE
04:15:11.295 --> 04:15:12.530
TOP AND GO THROUGH THE LIST. ONE
04:15:12.597 --> 04:15:15.299
TIME. UM, AND WHEN SENATOR
04:15:15.366 --> 04:15:16.067
GONZALEZ PRESENTS HERSELF WILL
04:15:16.134 --> 04:15:20.672
WILL GO AGAIN. ON THE CONSENT
04:15:20.738 --> 04:15:22.507
CALENDAR WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:15:22.573 --> 04:15:29.280
GORGEOUS. GORGEOUS. I HERTZBERG. PITTSBURGH I, JONES JONES. I
04:15:29.347 --> 04:15:31.049
LAYERED LAIRD. I WIECKOWSKI
04:15:31.115 --> 04:15:35.720
WIECKOWSKI. AYE. YOU HAVE 11 TO
04:15:35.787 --> 04:15:36.888
0 ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
04:15:36.954 --> 04:15:37.822
ALRIGHT, CONSENT COUNTER IS
04:15:37.889 --> 04:15:43.895
ADOPTED. FILE ITEM NUMBER 1 22
04:15:43.961 --> 04:15:46.264
23 NEEDS A MOTION. UM SENATOR
04:15:46.330 --> 04:15:49.567
WIENER MOOSE VILLE. BILLS HEARD
04:15:49.634 --> 04:15:54.105
BY SUBCOMMITTEE. THE MOTION IS
04:15:54.172 --> 04:15:55.073
DUE PAST BUT FIRST BE RE
04:15:55.139 --> 04:15:56.741
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:15:56.808 --> 04:15:57.842
HEALTH HAMBURG. HAMBURG. I BORE
04:15:57.909 --> 04:16:02.080
GIS. GORGEOUS. NO, CABALLERO.
04:16:02.146 --> 04:16:03.948
COUPLE OF YEAR OLD DURAZO
04:16:04.015 --> 04:16:08.186
GONZALEZ. HARTSBURG. HERTZBERG
04:16:08.252 --> 04:16:10.855
I, JONES JONES? NO, LAIRD LAIRD.
04:16:10.922 --> 04:16:14.992
I STERN STERN. I WIECKOWSKI.
04:16:15.059 --> 04:16:17.995
WIECKOWSKI AYE. WIENER WIENER I
04:16:18.062 --> 04:16:19.931
YOU HAVE 8 TO 2 WITH ONE MEMBER
04:16:19.997 --> 04:16:23.501
MISSING BACK ON CALL. FILE ITEM
04:16:23.568 --> 04:16:25.002
NUMBER TWO A B 2777 BY
04:16:25.069 --> 04:16:26.137
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS NEEDS
04:16:26.204 --> 04:16:28.973
EMOTION. M
04:16:29.040 --> 04:16:34.212
E BILL. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
04:16:34.278 --> 04:16:36.247
BUT FIRST AMEND AND BE REFERRED
04:16:36.314 --> 04:16:37.281
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:16:37.348 --> 04:16:38.583
APPROPRIATIONS UMBERG. HAMBURG.
04:16:38.649 --> 04:16:40.651
I BURGESS GORGEOUS. NO,
04:16:40.718 --> 04:16:42.887
CABALLERO. CABALLERO. I DO
04:16:42.954 --> 04:16:47.759
RUSSELL. SO I GONZALES.
04:16:47.825 --> 04:16:51.028
HERTZBERG HERZBERG, I, JONES
04:16:51.095 --> 04:16:55.900
JONES. NO, LAIRD, I STERN.
04:16:55.967 --> 04:16:56.901
STERN. I WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI.
04:16:56.968 --> 04:17:01.038
AYE, WIENER. WIENER? AYE. YOU
04:17:01.105 --> 04:17:03.441
HAVE 8 TO 2 WITH ONE MEMBER
04:17:03.508 --> 04:17:06.144
MISSING, ALL RIGHT BACK ON CALL.
04:17:06.210 --> 04:17:09.180
FILE ITEM NUMBER FOUR A B 16 66.
04:17:09.247 --> 04:17:10.515
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING, AYE.
04:17:10.581 --> 04:17:16.387
GORGEOUS. GORGEOUS. NO.
04:17:16.454 --> 04:17:19.490
HERTZBERG HERZBERG, I. JONES.
04:17:19.557 --> 04:17:21.626
JONES NO. LAIRD CLEARED. I
04:17:21.692 --> 04:17:24.695
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE. YOU
04:17:24.762 --> 04:17:29.066
HAVE. 922 WITH EVERYONE PRESENT
04:17:29.133 --> 04:17:36.107
IS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER FIVE A
04:17:36.174 --> 04:17:37.909
B 25 71. WITH THE CHAIR VOTING,
04:17:37.975 --> 04:17:45.249
AYE. PORCHES. TO RUSSELL. LARA.
04:17:45.316 --> 04:17:47.585
SO I GONZALEZ FIND THEM FIVE.
04:17:47.652 --> 04:17:53.558
HMM. GONZALES. I HERTZBERG
04:17:53.624 --> 04:17:55.393
HARTSBURG. AYE, WIECKOWSKI.
04:17:55.459 --> 04:17:57.528
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WIENER. WIENER?
04:17:57.595 --> 04:18:04.902
AYE. YOU HAVE 9 TO 1 WITH
04:18:04.969 --> 04:18:05.803
EVERYONE VOTED. ALRIGHT, BILLS
04:18:05.870 --> 04:18:12.844
OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER EIGHT A. B
04:18:12.910 --> 04:18:15.079
2091 WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I TO
04:18:15.146 --> 04:18:20.117
RUSSELL. SO I GONZALES. GONZALEZ
04:18:20.184 --> 04:18:23.421
I HERZBERG HERZBERG. I JONES
04:18:23.487 --> 04:18:26.424
JONES. NO WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI
04:18:26.490 --> 04:18:28.893
. AYE, WIENER WIENER, I YOU HAVE
04:18:28.960 --> 04:18:29.594
9 TO 2 WITH EVERYONE VOTING.
04:18:29.660 --> 04:18:36.300
BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 9 18
04:18:36.367 --> 04:18:38.402
21 59 WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:18:38.469 --> 04:18:40.504
CABALLERO. FILE ITEM NUMBER
04:18:40.571 --> 04:18:44.876
NINE. CABALLERO I, GONZALEZ
04:18:44.942 --> 04:18:46.978
GONZALEZ. I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG,
04:18:47.044 --> 04:18:52.583
I JONES. JONES. NO WIECKOWSKI.
04:18:52.650 --> 04:18:55.052
WIECKOWSKI AYE. WIENER WIENER, I
04:18:55.119 --> 04:18:55.920
YOU HAVE 92 WITH EVERYONE. VOTED
04:18:55.987 --> 04:19:02.393
OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 10 ABC, 7
04:19:02.460 --> 04:19:03.794
48 BY SIMILAR MEMBER CABALLERO
04:19:03.861 --> 04:19:06.697
NEEDS A MOTION. A REAL KOREA.
04:19:06.764 --> 04:19:08.799
I'M SORRY, SENATOR LAIRD MOVES
04:19:08.866 --> 04:19:11.969
THE BILL O SER, COVER YOUR OWN
04:19:12.036 --> 04:19:14.839
MOVES. THE BILL. IT'S CERTAINLY
04:19:14.906 --> 04:19:17.375
YEAH AS WELL AS SENATOR
04:19:17.441 --> 04:19:20.978
CABALLERO. BOTH OF THEM DID UM
04:19:21.045 --> 04:19:22.480
THE MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST
04:19:22.546 --> 04:19:24.315
AMEND AND RE REFERRED TO THE
04:19:24.382 --> 04:19:24.882
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
04:19:24.949 --> 04:19:28.185
HAMBURG. HAMBURG. I BORE GIS.
04:19:28.252 --> 04:19:30.621
GORGEOUS I CABALLERO COUPLE
04:19:30.688 --> 04:19:31.923
YEARS OLD. I DO NOT SO I
04:19:31.989 --> 04:19:35.726
GONZALES GONZALES. I HERTZBERG.
04:19:35.793 --> 04:19:38.663
HERTZBERG JONES JONES, I LAIRD
04:19:38.729 --> 04:19:42.934
EYES STERN. STERN. I WIECKOWSKI
04:19:43.000 --> 04:19:46.304
WIECKOWSKI. AYE, WIENER. WIENER
04:19:46.370 --> 04:19:51.208
I YOU HAVE 11 TO 0 BILLS OUT.
04:19:51.275 --> 04:19:54.345
FILE ITEM NUMBER 14 MAYBE 23 09
04:19:54.412 --> 04:19:54.946
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN
04:19:55.012 --> 04:19:57.181
NEEDS A MOTION. SENATOR ROSS
04:19:57.248 --> 04:20:02.820
RAMOS BILL. THE MOTION IS DUE
04:20:02.887 --> 04:20:03.955
PAST BUT FIRST AMEND AND
04:20:04.021 --> 04:20:04.555
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
04:20:04.622 --> 04:20:05.856
HUMAN SERVICES UMBERG. UM, I
04:20:05.923 --> 04:20:10.594
BURGESS. GORGEOUS I CABALLERO
04:20:10.661 --> 04:20:11.429
CABALLERO, I DURAZO Hí
04:20:11.495 --> 04:20:16.300
GONZALES. GONZALEZ I HERZBERG
04:20:16.367 --> 04:20:20.604
HERZBERG. I JONES JONES. I LAIRD
04:20:20.671 --> 04:20:23.174
LAYERED I STERN STERN. I
04:20:23.240 --> 04:20:23.741
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE,
04:20:23.808 --> 04:20:27.578
WIENER. WIENER. I HAVE 11 TO 0.
04:20:27.645 --> 04:20:34.485
BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 15,
04:20:34.552 --> 04:20:36.020
MAYBE 20 TO 96 BY
04:20:36.087 --> 04:20:39.523
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JOHN SWEAR WITH
04:20:39.590 --> 04:20:44.095
DORIS. OH, H
04:20:44.161 --> 04:20:46.330
NZALEZ. I HERTZBERG HERTZBERG,
04:20:46.397 --> 04:20:53.771
I JONES. WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI.
04:20:53.838 --> 04:20:57.241
AYE WIENER. WIENER I YOU HAVE 9
04:20:57.308 --> 04:20:59.010
TO 0 WITH ALL MEMBERS BEING
04:20:59.076 --> 04:21:04.081
PRESENT. FILE ITEM NUMBER 16 BY
04:21:04.148 --> 04:21:05.950
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S EARLY A B 2031
04:21:06.017 --> 04:21:08.019
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:21:08.085 --> 04:21:09.687
GONZALES. GONZALEZ I THAT'S 11
04:21:09.754 --> 04:21:14.792
TO 0 BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM NUMBER
04:21:14.859 --> 04:21:16.293
18, MAYBE 1917 BY
04:21:16.360 --> 04:21:18.229
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVINE. WITH
04:21:18.295 --> 04:21:20.498
THE CHAIR VOTING. I COPY EURO
04:21:20.564 --> 04:21:24.235
COMING YEAR OLD I GONZALES.
04:21:24.301 --> 04:21:25.503
GONZALEZ. I HERZBERG HERZBERG. I
04:21:25.569 --> 04:21:30.141
JONES JONES, NO WIENER. WIENER,
04:21:30.207 --> 04:21:36.380
I YOU HAVE 9 TO 2. GOES OUT.
04:21:36.447 --> 04:21:39.984
FILE ITEM NUMBER 28 27 66 BY
04:21:40.051 --> 04:21:40.551
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MAIENSCHEIN
04:21:40.618 --> 04:21:42.119
WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
04:21:42.186 --> 04:21:45.556
GORGEOUS. OR JUST KNOW CABALLERO
04:21:45.623 --> 04:21:49.160
CABALLERO? AYE. GONZALES.
04:21:49.226 --> 04:21:51.629
GONZALEZ. I HERTZBERG
04:21:51.695 --> 04:21:56.467
PITTSBURGH, I JONES. JONES NO
04:21:56.534 --> 04:21:57.735
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE,
04:21:57.802 --> 04:22:02.606
WIENER. WIENER? AYE. YOU HAVE 9
04:22:02.673 --> 04:22:03.841
TO 2, WITH ALL MEMBERS HAVING
04:22:03.908 --> 04:22:08.512
VOTED BILLS OUT. FILE ITEM
04:22:08.579 --> 04:22:11.682
NUMBER 27 A B 17 11 BY SOME
04:22:11.749 --> 04:22:13.617
REMEMBER SEYARTO THE MOTION. WE
04:22:13.684 --> 04:22:16.787
NEED A MOTION. SENATOR JONES.
04:22:16.854 --> 04:22:23.461
MOST BILL. THE MOTION IS TO PASS
04:22:23.527 --> 04:22:24.862
. BUT FIRST WE RE REFERRED TO
04:22:24.929 --> 04:22:26.397
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
04:22:26.464 --> 04:22:28.499
HAMBURG. HAMBURG. I BORE GIS.
04:22:28.566 --> 04:22:30.835
GORGEOUS. I CABALLERO TO
04:22:30.901 --> 04:22:37.308
RUSSELL. GONZALES. HERTZBERG.
04:22:37.374 --> 04:22:43.781
JONES. JONES. I LAIRD. STERN.
04:22:43.848 --> 04:22:47.685
WIECKOWSKI. AYE WIECKOWSKI I
04:22:47.751 --> 04:22:54.024
WINNER. WIENER I YOU HAVE 5 TO
04:22:54.091 --> 04:22:56.694
0. CALL THE ROLL. CLUB HERO.
04:22:56.760 --> 04:23:03.634
BROSSEAU. GONZALES. HERTZBERG.
04:23:03.701 --> 04:23:09.273
HERTZBERG? AYE, LAIRD. STERN.
04:23:09.340 --> 04:23:10.941
YOU HAVE 60 0. ALRIGHT, BILLS
04:23:11.008 --> 04:23:27.424
OUT. OKAY? YEAH. UH, OKAY. FILE
04:23:27.491 --> 04:23:30.461
ITEM NUMBER 28 MAYBE 15 94 BY
04:23:30.528 --> 04:23:31.462
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING WITH THE
04:23:31.529 --> 04:23:34.665
CHAIR VOTING, AYE. CABALLERO.
04:23:34.732 --> 04:23:39.170
GONZALEZ. GONZALES. I JONES.
04:23:39.236 --> 04:23:48.078
JONES. NO. YOU HAVE 8 TO 2.
04:23:48.145 --> 04:23:56.253
BUILT IS OUT. THAT'S IT. I
04:23:56.320 --> 04:24:01.125
THINK, MADAM SECRETARY. ALL
04:24:01.192 --> 04:24:09.400
FINAL ON 29 IF YOU DIDN'T.
04:24:09.466 --> 04:24:11.902
ALRIGHT ON FILM NUMBER 29 HAS
04:24:11.969 --> 04:24:14.672
BEEN PULLED THIS WEEK. FOUND
04:24:14.738 --> 04:24:16.140
29TH PULLED SO WE'LL GO AHEAD
04:24:16.207 --> 04:24:18.075
AND CALL THE ROLL ONE MORE TIME.
04:24:18.142 --> 04:24:20.578
UM ON THE BILLS THAT SENATOR
04:24:20.644 --> 04:24:22.413
GONZALEZ WAS NOT HERE TO VOTE
04:24:22.479 --> 04:24:32.957
UPON.
04:24:33.023 --> 04:24:34.391
FILE IN, UM, NUMBER ONE, MAYBE
04:24:34.458 --> 04:24:37.795
22 23 GONZALEZ. GONZALEZ, I YOU
04:24:37.861 --> 04:24:47.404
HAVE 92. SENATOR. FILE ITEM
04:24:47.471 --> 04:24:49.974
NUMBER TWO A B 27 77 BY ASSEMBLY
04:24:50.040 --> 04:24:51.108
. I'M ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS.
04:24:51.175 --> 04:24:55.980
GONZALEZ. GONZALES I YOU HAVE 9
04:24:56.046 --> 04:25:00.618
TO 2. I THINK THAT'S I THINK
04:25:00.684 --> 04:25:05.856
THAT'S IT. YEAH. ALRIGHT, WE'RE
04:25:05.923 --> 04:25:09.093
DONE. ALL RIGHT. WE'LL BE BACK
04:25:09.159 --> 04:25:10.261
NEXT TUESDY. OKAY. DRINK YOUR
04:25:10.327 --> 04:25:17.735
RED BULL. THANK YOU ALL. DHCS.
04:25:17.801 --> 04:25:19.169
YEAH. HOW ABOUT THAT, HUH? I
04:25:19.236 --> 04:25:35.319
KNOW.