WEBVTT
00:00:29.829 --> 00:00:32.198
THE SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE
00:00:32.265 --> 00:00:35.368
WILL COME TO ORDER GOOD
00:00:35.435 --> 00:00:36.870
AFTERNOON, EVERYBODY AS WE
00:00:36.936 --> 00:00:38.104
CONTINUE TO TAKE SOME
00:00:38.171 --> 00:00:39.506
PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE ONGOING
00:00:39.572 --> 00:00:41.374
COVID 19 RISK. THE SENATE
00:00:41.441 --> 00:00:43.376
CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE PUBLIC
00:00:43.443 --> 00:00:44.744
AND AS PROVIDED ACCESS TO BOTH
00:00:44.811 --> 00:00:46.079
IN PERSON AND TELECONFERENCE
00:00:46.146 --> 00:00:46.613
PARTICIPATION. FOR PUBLIC
00:00:46.679 --> 00:00:50.784
COMMENT. FOR INDIVIDUALS WISHING
00:00:50.850 --> 00:00:52.185
TO PROVIDE PUBLIC COMMENT VIA
00:00:52.252 --> 00:00:53.887
THE TELECONFERENCE SERVICE
00:00:53.953 --> 00:00:55.655
PARTICIPANT. TOLL FREE NUMBER
00:00:55.722 --> 00:00:57.891
AND ACCESS CODE IS POSTED ON OUR
00:00:57.957 --> 00:00:59.025
COMMITTEE WEBSITE. IT WILL BE
00:00:59.092 --> 00:01:01.161
DISPLAYED ON THE SCREEN. AND I
00:01:01.227 --> 00:01:03.029
WILL ANNOUNCE IT NOW. TODAY'S
00:01:03.096 --> 00:01:09.869
PARTICIPANT CODE IS 877. 22681.
00:01:09.936 --> 00:01:14.140
AND THE ACCESS CODE IS 64886. I
00:01:14.207 --> 00:01:15.575
WILL MAINTAIN DECORUM DURING THE
00:01:15.642 --> 00:01:17.944
HEARING, AS IS CUSTOMARY IN ANY
00:01:18.011 --> 00:01:19.913
INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE,
00:01:19.979 --> 00:01:21.481
MAYBE MAYBE REMOVED FROM THEIR
00:01:21.548 --> 00:01:23.416
REMOTE MEETING SERVICE OR HAVE
00:01:23.483 --> 00:01:24.851
THEIR CONNECTIONS MUTED. WE
00:01:24.918 --> 00:01:26.453
DON'T EXPECT THIS TO HAPPEN. WE
00:01:26.519 --> 00:01:28.455
HAVE NEVER HAD IT HAPPENED
00:01:28.521 --> 00:01:29.856
BEFORE. BUT JUST AS A WARNING.
00:01:29.923 --> 00:01:31.191
WE ARE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
00:01:31.257 --> 00:01:32.258
HEARINGS HERE IN THE OLD STREET
00:01:32.325 --> 00:01:34.194
BUILDING, AND I ASK ALL MEMBERS
00:01:34.260 --> 00:01:35.862
OF THE COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT
00:01:35.929 --> 00:01:37.330
IN ROOM 2100 SO WE CAN ESTABLISH
00:01:37.397 --> 00:01:39.199
OUR QUORUM AND BEGIN OUR
00:01:39.265 --> 00:01:43.603
HEARING. UM I AM SITTING IN FOR,
00:01:43.670 --> 00:01:45.939
UM, SHARE PERSON WIENER WHO
00:01:46.005 --> 00:01:48.308
SHOULD BE HERE MOMENTARILY.
00:01:48.374 --> 00:01:49.843
MEMBERS ARE PRESENTING BILLS AND
00:01:49.909 --> 00:01:51.010
OTHER COMMITTEES, SO I EXPECT IT
00:01:51.077 --> 00:01:53.012
WILL HAVE MEMBERS IN AND OUT OF
00:01:53.079 --> 00:01:54.981
THE HEARING ROOM. WE HAVE 17
00:01:55.048 --> 00:01:57.250
BILLS ON TODAY'S AGENDA. AND
00:01:57.317 --> 00:01:58.318
BEFORE WE HEAR PRESENTATION ON
00:01:58.384 --> 00:02:00.520
THE BILLS, WE'RE GOING TO TRY TO
00:02:00.587 --> 00:02:01.654
ESTABLISH A QUORUM CONSULTANT.
00:02:01.721 --> 00:02:05.024
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. WE DO NOT
00:02:05.091 --> 00:02:05.925
HAVE A QUORUM. THAT'S PRETTY
00:02:05.992 --> 00:02:08.561
OBVIOUS. SO I GUESS WE'LL JUST
00:02:08.628 --> 00:02:09.696
WAIT UNTIL WE GET SOME MORE
00:02:09.762 --> 00:02:17.570
MEMBERS HERE. SO, UM WE WANT TO
00:02:17.637 --> 00:02:22.742
ASK THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THAT
00:02:22.809 --> 00:02:25.879
HAVE BILLS TO PLEASE HUSTLE OVER
00:02:25.945 --> 00:02:28.214
THE HOUSING IF YOU CAN, AND WILL
00:02:28.281 --> 00:02:29.215
WAIT FOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM,
00:02:29.282 --> 00:02:49.202
WHO HAS THE FIRST BILL.
00:04:04.544 --> 00:04:05.411
GOOD AFTERNOON. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:04:05.478 --> 00:04:09.082
BLOOM YOU ARE UP I WAS GOING TO
00:04:09.148 --> 00:04:11.317
SIT HERE ON DECK, BUT THAT WOULD
00:04:11.384 --> 00:04:12.518
HAVE BEEN INCORRECT. YOU ARE UP
00:04:12.585 --> 00:04:17.590
TO BAT. WELCOME AH, YES. GOOD
00:04:17.657 --> 00:04:23.262
AFTERNOON, EVERYONE. ARE WE ON A
00:04:23.329 --> 00:04:28.735
B 6? 82? WE ARE ALL RIGHT. THIS
00:04:28.801 --> 00:04:30.770
IS A MEASURE TO INCENTIVIZE
00:04:30.837 --> 00:04:34.007
SHARED HOUSING. CURED HOUSING,
00:04:34.073 --> 00:04:36.175
ALSO KNOWN AS COMMUNAL LIVING,
00:04:36.242 --> 00:04:38.678
IS TYPICALLY MADE UP OF UNITS
00:04:38.745 --> 00:04:39.879
THAT ARE SMALLER THAN 400 SQUARE
00:04:39.946 --> 00:04:42.448
FEET. THEY OFFER SHARED KITCHEN
00:04:42.515 --> 00:04:43.983
AND DINING AREAS AND ARE MORE
00:04:44.050 --> 00:04:45.218
AFFORDABLE THAN THE AVERAGE
00:04:45.284 --> 00:04:48.354
STUDIO OR ONE BEDROOM APARTMENT.
00:04:48.421 --> 00:04:50.089
IN SAN FRANCISCO, WHERE THE
00:04:50.156 --> 00:04:52.659
AVERAGE RENT IS ALSO WELL OVER
00:04:52.725 --> 00:04:53.926
$3000, THE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY.
00:04:53.993 --> 00:04:55.895
STAR CITY BUILT SHARED HOUSING
00:04:55.962 --> 00:04:57.797
UNITS AVERAGING 200 SQUARE FEET
00:04:57.864 --> 00:04:58.965
AND RENTED THEM FOR $1400 A
00:04:59.032 --> 00:05:01.734
MONTH. LESS THAN HALF OF THE
00:05:01.801 --> 00:05:04.070
CITY'S AVERAGE RENT. THESE
00:05:04.137 --> 00:05:05.438
NATURALLY OCCURRING AFFORDABLE
00:05:05.505 --> 00:05:07.640
UNITS ARE IDEAL FOR THOSE WHO
00:05:07.707 --> 00:05:08.675
DON'T QUALIFY FOR SUBSIDIZED
00:05:08.741 --> 00:05:09.842
HOUSING, BUT CANNOT COMPETE FOR
00:05:09.909 --> 00:05:12.078
MARKET RATE APARTMENTS. THOSE
00:05:12.145 --> 00:05:13.279
WHO WE IDENTIFIED AS THE MISSING
00:05:13.346 --> 00:05:17.150
MIDDLE THE SHARED HOUSING MODEL
00:05:17.216 --> 00:05:18.184
CAN ALSO BE USED TO HOUSE
00:05:18.251 --> 00:05:19.719
SENIORS AND FORMERLY HOMELESS
00:05:19.786 --> 00:05:21.621
INDIVIDUALS, SINCE COMMUNAL
00:05:21.688 --> 00:05:24.223
LIVING PROVIDE A UNIQUE MIX OF
00:05:24.290 --> 00:05:26.359
PRIVACY AND COMMUNITY SUPPORT.
00:05:26.426 --> 00:05:28.761
UNFORTUNATELY LOCAL RESTRICTIONS
00:05:28.828 --> 00:05:30.897
THAT REQUIRE A MINIMUM UNIT SIZE
00:05:30.963 --> 00:05:32.799
OR A MAXIMUM DENSITY HAVE MADE
00:05:32.865 --> 00:05:34.767
IT DIFFICULT TO BUILD SHARED
00:05:34.834 --> 00:05:37.170
HOUSING AND A B 6 82 WILL ALLOW
00:05:37.236 --> 00:05:39.372
SHARED HOUSING PROJECTS TO
00:05:39.439 --> 00:05:41.407
QUALIFY FOR INCENTIVES UNDER THE
00:05:41.474 --> 00:05:42.508
DENSITY BONUS LAW AND HELP
00:05:42.575 --> 00:05:44.010
MAXIMIZE THE NUMBER OF UNITS
00:05:44.077 --> 00:05:45.244
WITHIN AN ALREADY COSTLY
00:05:45.311 --> 00:05:49.015
PERSONAL OF LAND. THE MEASURE
00:05:49.082 --> 00:05:49.916
WILL REQUIRE DEED RESTRICTED
00:05:49.982 --> 00:05:52.051
AFFORDABLE UNITS IN EXCHANGE FOR
00:05:52.118 --> 00:05:54.153
ANY CONCESSIONS OR INCENTIVES
00:05:54.220 --> 00:05:56.522
AND 86 82 WILL HELP DIVERSIFY
00:05:56.589 --> 00:05:58.491
HOUSING STOCK OFFERING BOTH
00:05:58.558 --> 00:05:59.559
NATURALLY OCCURRING OCCURRING
00:05:59.625 --> 00:06:02.061
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AND THE
00:06:02.128 --> 00:06:04.497
OPTION FOR COMMUNAL COMMUNAL
00:06:04.564 --> 00:06:06.766
LIVING. TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT OF
00:06:06.833 --> 00:06:09.168
THE BILL IS JANE BLUMENFELD.
00:06:09.235 --> 00:06:10.870
SENIOR FELLOW AT U. C. L. A S
00:06:10.937 --> 00:06:15.341
CITY LAB. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:06:15.408 --> 00:06:18.945
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE UM JANE
00:06:19.011 --> 00:06:27.620
BLUMENFELD. YEP. YOU ARE UP.
00:06:27.687 --> 00:06:29.288
OKAY THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:06:29.355 --> 00:06:31.157
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS JANE BLUMEN
00:06:31.224 --> 00:06:33.126
FILM. AND I'M A SENIOR FELLOW AT
00:06:33.192 --> 00:06:35.762
YOU FEEL LÀ CITY LAB. CITY LAB
00:06:35.828 --> 00:06:36.796
IS PROUD TO SPONSOR MAYBE
00:06:36.863 --> 00:06:38.931
SUCCEEDED, TOO. AND THANKS TO
00:06:38.998 --> 00:06:39.599
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM FIRST
00:06:39.665 --> 00:06:41.768
EFFORTS ON THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE
00:06:41.834 --> 00:06:43.269
, CALIFORNIA IS WELL DOCUMENTED
00:06:43.336 --> 00:06:44.270
. HOUSING CRISIS REQUIRES MANY
00:06:44.337 --> 00:06:46.072
SOLUTIONS. THERE IS NOT A SINGLE
00:06:46.139 --> 00:06:48.441
FIX. AND THE STATED SOLUTIONS
00:06:48.508 --> 00:06:49.575
THAT ARE EFFECTIVE WITHOUT THE
00:06:49.642 --> 00:06:51.577
NEED FOR PUBLIC DOLLARS. WE NEED
00:06:51.644 --> 00:06:53.513
A VARIETY OF HELPING TOPOLOGY IS
00:06:53.579 --> 00:06:55.014
THAT CAN SIMULTANEOUSLY HOUSE
00:06:55.081 --> 00:06:56.082
PEOPLE AFFORDABLY AND BE
00:06:56.149 --> 00:06:57.784
PROFITABLE ENOUGH SO THAT PEOPLE
00:06:57.850 --> 00:06:59.018
IN THE BUSINESS OF BUILDING
00:06:59.085 --> 00:07:00.520
HOUSING WILL ACTUALLY BUILD IT.
00:07:00.586 --> 00:07:02.522
86 82 CREATES A NEW HOUSING
00:07:02.588 --> 00:07:04.423
TYPOLOGY THAT HAS NOT BEEN LEGAL
00:07:04.490 --> 00:07:05.525
FOR MANY REASONS, ZONING AND
00:07:05.591 --> 00:07:08.327
OTHERWISE. 86 82 WILL ALLOW
00:07:08.394 --> 00:07:09.829
DEVELOPERS TO BUILD WHAT LOOKS
00:07:09.896 --> 00:07:11.130
LIKE ALL OTHER APARTMENT
00:07:11.197 --> 00:07:13.032
BUILDINGS AND WHICH MUST COMPLY
00:07:13.099 --> 00:07:15.001
WITH ALL LOCAL HEIGHT, GLORIES
00:07:15.067 --> 00:07:17.170
AND OTHER REQUIREMENTS. THE ONLY
00:07:17.236 --> 00:07:18.638
DIFFERENCE IS THAT KITCHENS AND
00:07:18.704 --> 00:07:19.739
DINING SPACES WILL BE SHARED
00:07:19.806 --> 00:07:21.874
AMONGST THE RESIDENCE. EACH UNIT
00:07:21.941 --> 00:07:23.376
IS REQUIRED TO HAVE A PRECINCT
00:07:23.442 --> 00:07:24.243
ELTON APARTMENT WOULD HAVE A
00:07:24.310 --> 00:07:26.445
BATHROOM SINK, REFRIGERATOR,
00:07:26.512 --> 00:07:28.581
MICROWAVE AND EACH UNIT AND
00:07:28.648 --> 00:07:30.917
HOUSE ONLY ONE OR TWO PEOPLE.
00:07:30.983 --> 00:07:33.019
MAYBE 6 82 WILL GIVE DEVELOPERS
00:07:33.085 --> 00:07:34.086
THE ABILITY TO BUILD SMALLER
00:07:34.153 --> 00:07:35.822
UNITS TO NOT BUILD MULTIPLE
00:07:35.888 --> 00:07:38.357
KITCHENS. SO THAT WE CAN CREATE
00:07:38.424 --> 00:07:40.760
MORE AND LESS EXPENSIVE HOUSING
00:07:40.827 --> 00:07:42.862
. FOR CALIFORNIA. THESE SHARED
00:07:42.929 --> 00:07:43.896
HOUSING BUILDINGS CAN BE LOW
00:07:43.963 --> 00:07:46.399
RISE OR HIGH RISE, WHICH SPEAKS
00:07:46.465 --> 00:07:47.500
TO THE FLEXIBILITY OF THIS
00:07:47.567 --> 00:07:49.602
TYPOLOGY. 86 82 ISN'T
00:07:49.669 --> 00:07:51.070
PARTICULARLY APPROPRIATE FOR
00:07:51.137 --> 00:07:52.138
SENIORS BECAUSE KITCHENS ARE A
00:07:52.205 --> 00:07:54.273
HAZARD FOR ELDERLY PEOPLE AND
00:07:54.340 --> 00:07:56.509
KEENAN. COMMUNAL DINING BUILT AN
00:07:56.576 --> 00:07:58.678
IMPORTANT SOCIAL NEED FOR THEM,
00:07:58.744 --> 00:08:00.680
AND THERE IS VERY LITTLE HOUSING
00:08:00.746 --> 00:08:01.981
THAT IS AFFORDABLE FOR SENIORS.
00:08:02.048 --> 00:08:03.749
THIS TYPE OF SHARED HELPING WILL
00:08:03.816 --> 00:08:05.184
ALSO BE ATTRACTIVE TO STUDENTS
00:08:05.251 --> 00:08:06.485
AND YOUNG PEOPLE NEWLY IN THE
00:08:06.552 --> 00:08:07.987
JOB MARKET WHO ARE WILLING TO
00:08:08.054 --> 00:08:09.021
SHARE A KITCHEN IN EXCHANGE FOR
00:08:09.088 --> 00:08:12.491
LESS TERRENCE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:08:12.558 --> 00:08:13.893
REFERRED TO THE SAN FRANCISCO'S
00:08:13.960 --> 00:08:16.696
OUR CITY PROJECT. THAT IS ALMOST
00:08:16.762 --> 00:08:18.264
EXACTLY LIKE THE SPECIFICATIONS
00:08:18.331 --> 00:08:20.132
THAT THEY BE 6 82. I'D LIKE TO
00:08:20.199 --> 00:08:21.567
ADD THAT WHEN IT FIRST OPENED
00:08:21.634 --> 00:08:22.668
THE BUILDING, LEASED UP
00:08:22.735 --> 00:08:24.070
IMMEDIATELY AND HAD A WEDDING
00:08:24.136 --> 00:08:26.639
LIST OF 8000 PEOPLE.
00:08:26.706 --> 00:08:28.140
CALIFORNIA'S DIVERSE POPULATION
00:08:28.207 --> 00:08:30.276
REQUIRES HOUSING THAT CAN MEET
00:08:30.343 --> 00:08:31.043
DIFFERENT NEEDS FOR SENIORS,
00:08:31.110 --> 00:08:32.712
YOUNG PEOPLE AND STUDENTS. THIS
00:08:32.778 --> 00:08:34.747
TYPE OF SHARED HOUSING SHARING
00:08:34.814 --> 00:08:36.549
KITCHENS OFFERS THE RIGHT
00:08:36.616 --> 00:08:37.583
BALANCE OF PRIVACY,
00:08:37.650 --> 00:08:39.185
AFFORDABILITY AND COMMUNITY. I
00:08:39.252 --> 00:08:42.121
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR IDOLS.
00:08:42.188 --> 00:08:45.758
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:08:45.825 --> 00:08:48.127
UM NOW I'M GOING TO CHECK AND
00:08:48.194 --> 00:08:49.629
SEE IF THERE IS ANYBODY IN ROOM
00:08:49.695 --> 00:08:52.365
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:08:52.431 --> 00:08:54.333
AND SUPPORT OF 86 26 82. IS
00:08:54.400 --> 00:08:58.738
THERE ANYONE IN THE ROOM? SAYING
00:08:58.804 --> 00:09:01.140
NONE MODERATOR. IF YOU COULD
00:09:01.207 --> 00:09:03.142
QUEUE UP THE LINE AND ASK IF
00:09:03.209 --> 00:09:05.077
THERE'S ANYBODY ON THE LINE THAT
00:09:05.144 --> 00:09:06.145
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:09:06.212 --> 00:09:10.249
SUPPORT. GIVE IT SUPPORT OF A B
00:09:10.316 --> 00:09:12.251
6 82 YOU MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN
00:09:12.318 --> 00:09:14.787
ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND THEN
00:09:14.854 --> 00:09:22.228
ZERO SUPPORT. WE WILL VOTE TO
00:09:22.295 --> 00:09:24.196
LINE TWO. OH, NINE. YOUR LINE IS
00:09:24.263 --> 00:09:28.501
OPEN, WHICH GO AHEAD. YES THIS
00:09:28.567 --> 00:09:30.469
HAS BEEN THE CECILIA CUNNINGHAM.
00:09:30.536 --> 00:09:35.308
I'M CALLING FROM RESIDENTS. AND
00:09:35.374 --> 00:09:37.977
UNITED NETWORK AND THE HOUSING
00:09:38.044 --> 00:09:40.446
ORGANIZATION. I'M CALLING STRONG
00:09:40.513 --> 00:09:44.250
SUPPORT OF A B 1816. THANK YOU.
00:09:44.317 --> 00:09:46.585
I'M SORRY, MA'AM. WE'RE ON A B 6
00:09:46.652 --> 00:09:50.990
82. IS THERE ANYBODY THAT WOULD
00:09:51.057 --> 00:09:53.459
LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT IN
00:09:53.526 --> 00:09:55.328
SUPPORT OF A B 6 82 ON THE
00:09:55.394 --> 00:09:59.465
TELECONFERENCE LINE? THAT DO WE
00:09:59.532 --> 00:10:01.534
WILL GO TO LINE 2 47. YOUR LINE
00:10:01.600 --> 00:10:05.504
IS OPEN. AFTERNOON CHAIR AND
00:10:05.571 --> 00:10:07.039
MEMBER SYLVIA KHALIF SHOW ON
00:10:07.106 --> 00:10:08.607
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA
00:10:08.674 --> 00:10:09.809
MONICA. AND STRONG SUPPORT.
00:10:09.875 --> 00:10:11.010
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:10:11.077 --> 00:10:15.147
NEXT, PLEASE. THANK YOU TO 40
00:10:15.214 --> 00:10:18.751
FOR YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
00:10:18.818 --> 00:10:20.152
AFTERNOON. THIS IS ZEKE SANDOVAL
00:10:20.219 --> 00:10:21.620
WAS PASSED PEOPLE ASSISTING THE
00:10:21.687 --> 00:10:23.189
HOMELESS IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
00:10:23.255 --> 00:10:24.890
MORE HOUSING LIKE THIS. THANK
00:10:24.957 --> 00:10:28.427
YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
00:10:28.494 --> 00:10:30.363
GOAL LINE TO 27. YOUR LINE IS
00:10:30.429 --> 00:10:33.466
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON LAUREN DAY
00:10:33.532 --> 00:10:34.400
VALENCIA, REPRESENTING THE
00:10:34.467 --> 00:10:35.401
AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION
00:10:35.468 --> 00:10:40.673
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK
00:10:40.740 --> 00:10:41.774
YOU. NEXT LINE TO 45. YOUR LINE
00:10:41.841 --> 00:10:45.311
IS OPEN. HI THIS IS ADAM
00:10:45.378 --> 00:10:47.013
BOOKBINDER, RESIDENT OF CAMPBELL
00:10:47.079 --> 00:10:47.513
AND SENATE-DISTRICT. 11
00:10:47.580 --> 00:10:48.981
SUPPORTING A B 6 82. THANK YOU.
00:10:49.048 --> 00:10:53.619
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT TO THE
00:10:53.686 --> 00:10:58.090
LINE UP TO 28 AIRLINE IS OPEN.
00:10:58.157 --> 00:10:59.558
THANK YOU. JOHN INSTITUTED ON
00:10:59.625 --> 00:11:00.626
BEHALF OF HOUSING, ASTON
00:11:00.693 --> 00:11:05.765
COALITION AND SUPPORT. THANK
00:11:05.831 --> 00:11:07.433
YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT TO THE LINE
00:11:07.500 --> 00:11:10.870
OF 2 49. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. THIS
00:11:10.936 --> 00:11:12.204
IS RECALL WITH LIVABLE
00:11:12.271 --> 00:11:13.205
CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT. THANK
00:11:13.272 --> 00:11:17.643
YOU. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. WE
00:11:17.710 --> 00:11:18.944
HAVE NO FURTHER SUPPORTING QUÊ
00:11:19.011 --> 00:11:20.112
AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU VERY
00:11:20.179 --> 00:11:22.181
MUCH. NOW WE'RE GOING TO MOVE ON
00:11:22.248 --> 00:11:23.182
TO OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO LEAD,
00:11:23.249 --> 00:11:25.284
OPPOSITION LISTED, SO WE'RE
00:11:25.351 --> 00:11:26.318
GONNA CHECK AND SEE IF THERE'S
00:11:26.385 --> 00:11:28.687
ANYBODY IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD
00:11:28.754 --> 00:11:30.122
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
00:11:30.189 --> 00:11:32.591
SAYING NO ONE WILL MOVE ON TO
00:11:32.658 --> 00:11:33.492
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE. MADAM
00:11:33.559 --> 00:11:35.227
CUT MODERATOR IF YOU COULD QUEUE
00:11:35.294 --> 00:11:37.129
UP THOSE IN OPPOSITION OF A B 6
00:11:37.196 --> 00:11:41.300
82. THANK YOU. IF YOU'RE NOT
00:11:41.367 --> 00:11:42.334
POSITION, YOU MAY PERHAPS ONE
00:11:42.401 --> 00:11:45.871
AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN IF YOU'RE
00:11:45.938 --> 00:11:48.541
IN OPPOSITION OF A B 6 82 YOU
00:11:48.607 --> 00:11:53.412
MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:11:53.479 --> 00:11:54.580
THE MINIATURE. WE HAVE TWO IN Q
00:11:54.647 --> 00:11:59.618
ONE MOMENT, PLEASE. AND WE WILL
00:11:59.685 --> 00:12:01.687
GO TO BLIND TO 50. YOUR LINE IS
00:12:01.754 --> 00:12:05.024
OPEN. CATCHING AND CHAIR MEMBERS
00:12:05.091 --> 00:12:06.092
. APOLOGIES FOR THE LATE
00:12:06.158 --> 00:12:08.627
OPPOSITION. BUT ON BEHALF OF THE
00:12:08.694 --> 00:12:09.995
CITY OF BEVERLY HILLS IN
00:12:10.062 --> 00:12:10.563
ESPECTFUL OPPOSITION, THANK
00:12:10.629 --> 00:12:14.333
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK
00:12:14.400 --> 00:12:16.302
YOU. NEXT IN LINE TO 29. YOUR
00:12:16.368 --> 00:12:19.705
LINE IS OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON AND
00:12:19.772 --> 00:12:21.774
SHARING MEMBERS WITH THE WESTERN
00:12:21.841 --> 00:12:23.309
CENTER ONLINE POVERTY. WE HAVE
00:12:23.375 --> 00:12:24.743
AN OPPOSING POSITION. THANK YOU.
00:12:24.810 --> 00:12:29.081
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU,
00:12:29.148 --> 00:12:30.416
MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
00:12:30.483 --> 00:12:33.352
OPPOSITION IN Q. VERY GOOD WILL
00:12:33.419 --> 00:12:34.787
BRING THE MATTER BACK TO THE
00:12:34.854 --> 00:12:38.157
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS? CHESKY
00:12:38.224 --> 00:12:39.258
REMEMBER BLOOM. OUR STAFF REPORT
00:12:39.325 --> 00:12:43.829
TALKS ABOUT THE. THE DEPARTMENT
00:12:43.896 --> 00:12:47.766
OF FINANCE AND, UM, THE REGIONAL
00:12:47.833 --> 00:12:50.803
HOUSING FOLKS USING THE CENSUS
00:12:50.870 --> 00:12:54.373
DEFINITION OF WHAT A UNIT IS AND
00:12:54.440 --> 00:12:55.875
IT SEEMS TO ME A LITTLE
00:12:55.941 --> 00:12:58.410
ANTIQUATED IN 2022, CAN YOU UH,
00:12:58.477 --> 00:13:00.379
GIVE US YOUR INPUT ON ON WHAT
00:13:00.446 --> 00:13:04.250
YOU THINK. WHAT DEFINITION
00:13:04.316 --> 00:13:05.351
SHOULD BE USED WHEN WE'RE
00:13:05.417 --> 00:13:07.319
CALCULATING THE HOUSING NEEDS OF
00:13:07.386 --> 00:13:08.821
OUR DIFFERENT IN DIVERSE
00:13:08.888 --> 00:13:10.523
COMMUNITIES. I'M NOT AN EXPERT
00:13:10.589 --> 00:13:13.692
ON THAT DEFINITIONAL ASPECT THAT
00:13:13.759 --> 00:13:17.496
UM, THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT USES
00:13:17.563 --> 00:13:21.033
AN H C D ADOPTS FOR PURPOSES OF
00:13:21.100 --> 00:13:25.237
ARENA CALCULATION. UM BUT I
00:13:25.304 --> 00:13:29.275
THINK A BROADER DEFINITION IS IN
00:13:29.341 --> 00:13:31.076
ORDER, ONE THAT IS INCLUSIVE OF
00:13:31.143 --> 00:13:33.145
MULTIPLE TYPES OF HOUSING. AND
00:13:33.212 --> 00:13:36.482
WHEN WE SHOULD LOOK AT, UM AH
00:13:36.549 --> 00:13:38.551
THE PERMANENCE OF THE OPERATING
00:13:38.617 --> 00:13:39.552
HOUSING OPPORTUNITY THAT'S BEING
00:13:39.618 --> 00:13:43.289
PRESENTED. I MEAN, THE EXAMPLES
00:13:43.355 --> 00:13:45.858
THAT USE OUR STUDENT HOUSING AND
00:13:45.925 --> 00:13:48.260
NURSING HOMES AND I THINK THIS
00:13:48.327 --> 00:13:51.630
IS A 300 SQUARE FOOT APARTMENT.
00:13:51.697 --> 00:13:54.800
IN THE IN CITY, NOT IN THE SAN
00:13:54.867 --> 00:13:57.136
FRANCISCO IS NOT REALLY LIKE A
00:13:57.203 --> 00:13:59.572
NURSING HOME TO PUT THAT, AT
00:13:59.638 --> 00:14:01.273
LEAST FOR THE CALCULATIONS OF
00:14:01.340 --> 00:14:03.809
HOW WE LOOK AT HOW WE DEFINE AND
00:14:03.876 --> 00:14:05.911
CALIFORNIA WHAT A UNIT IS VERSUS
00:14:05.978 --> 00:14:08.147
AN 80. YOU COULD BE 300 SQUARE
00:14:08.214 --> 00:14:10.115
FEET, AND IT WOULD IT WOULD MEET
00:14:10.182 --> 00:14:11.383
THE DEFINITION. SO IT SEEMS I
00:14:11.450 --> 00:14:14.853
DON'T KNOW. IT'S NOT THE BILL
00:14:14.920 --> 00:14:16.355
MOVES FORWARD. I JUST THOUGHT
00:14:16.422 --> 00:14:18.257
THAT THAT WAS ONE OF THE THINGS
00:14:18.324 --> 00:14:21.493
WE WANT TO GET A TRUE PICTURE OF
00:14:21.560 --> 00:14:23.495
THE HOUSING THAT WE'RE PROVIDING
00:14:23.562 --> 00:14:25.064
FOR THE POPULATION, AND THIS
00:14:25.130 --> 00:14:27.399
SEEMS TO BE FITS ALL THOSE NEEDS
00:14:27.466 --> 00:14:29.034
THAT WE HAVE, EXCEPT IT DOESN'T
00:14:29.101 --> 00:14:30.669
GET COUNTED IN FOR THE CITY'S
00:14:30.736 --> 00:14:33.872
FOR SOME ANTIQUATED CENSUS
00:14:33.939 --> 00:14:36.275
REASON, RIGHT? RIGHT AND OF
00:14:36.342 --> 00:14:37.009
COURSE, THIS IS NOT STUDENT
00:14:37.076 --> 00:14:38.644
HOUSING, ALTHOUGH IT CAN
00:14:38.711 --> 00:14:40.045
ACCOMMODATE STUDENTS AND MAY
00:14:40.112 --> 00:14:43.148
WELL, UH, BE A USEFUL HOUSING
00:14:43.215 --> 00:14:44.650
OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDENTS BECAUSE
00:14:44.717 --> 00:14:46.919
IT IS LOWER COST WHILE I KNOW
00:14:46.986 --> 00:14:49.655
THAT THIS GOES MOVES FORWARD, IF
00:14:49.722 --> 00:14:50.756
IT'S SUCCESSFUL, THEY WILL MOVE
00:14:50.823 --> 00:14:53.525
FORWARD TO THE UH, COMMITTEE AND
00:14:53.592 --> 00:14:54.760
GOVERNMENTS AND FINANCE. I HOPE
00:14:54.827 --> 00:14:56.161
THAT YOU WOULD WORK WITH THE
00:14:56.228 --> 00:14:58.564
CHAIR OF THAT COMMITTEE AND THAT
00:14:58.631 --> 00:14:59.632
COMMITTEE STAFF TO FLUSH OUT
00:14:59.698 --> 00:15:02.067
THESE ISSUES. AND AT THE
00:15:02.134 --> 00:15:04.803
APPROPRIATE TIME. I'LL MOVE TO
00:15:04.870 --> 00:15:05.704
BILL, BUT WE DON'T HAVE A
00:15:05.771 --> 00:15:07.873
QUORUM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:15:07.940 --> 00:15:10.276
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI THE ONLY SO
00:15:10.342 --> 00:15:12.244
LET ME JUST TELL YOU THAT, UM I
00:15:12.311 --> 00:15:13.512
JUST HAD SOME QUESTIONS IN
00:15:13.579 --> 00:15:16.615
REGARDS TO WHERE IT'S
00:15:16.682 --> 00:15:18.684
APPROPRIATELY PLACED, IN OTHER
00:15:18.751 --> 00:15:20.286
WORDS, IF IT IF IT'S IN THE
00:15:20.352 --> 00:15:22.187
DENSITY BONUS AREA OR IF IT'S IF
00:15:22.254 --> 00:15:24.790
IT'S I LIKE THE CONCEPT. I'M
00:15:24.857 --> 00:15:29.828
CONCERNED WITH. MAKING SURE THAT
00:15:29.895 --> 00:15:30.829
AS WE CONSTRUCT THESE KINDS OF
00:15:30.896 --> 00:15:35.267
PROJECTS THAT THEY FIT IN WITH
00:15:35.334 --> 00:15:38.270
WHAT GOES IN IN TERMS OF I HEARD
00:15:38.337 --> 00:15:39.204
YOUR LEAD WITNESS SAY, THIS
00:15:39.271 --> 00:15:41.040
LOOKS LIKE EVERY OTHER APARTMENT
00:15:41.106 --> 00:15:42.308
COMPLEX THAT WOULD BE BUILT AND
00:15:42.374 --> 00:15:44.243
I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
00:15:44.310 --> 00:15:45.511
NOT CREATING AN OPPORTUNITY TO
00:15:45.577 --> 00:15:51.116
BUILD UM. THE LIKE THE OLD
00:15:51.183 --> 00:15:52.651
PROJECTS THAT USED TO BE A
00:15:52.718 --> 00:15:55.621
CONCRETE BUILDING ON A PARCEL
00:15:55.688 --> 00:15:57.589
WITH NO AMENITIES. NO PLACE TO
00:15:57.656 --> 00:15:59.491
SIT OUTSIDE. NO TREES, NO GREEN
00:15:59.558 --> 00:16:02.394
SPACE. AND THAT BECAUSE I REALLY
00:16:02.461 --> 00:16:06.165
APPRECIATE THE ABILITY TO CREATE
00:16:06.231 --> 00:16:07.700
SMALL UNITS, BUT THEN YOU NEED
00:16:07.766 --> 00:16:09.868
TO BE ABLE TO GO OUTSIDE AND SIT
00:16:09.935 --> 00:16:12.004
ON A PARK BENCH OR BE ABLE TO
00:16:12.071 --> 00:16:13.806
ENJOY SOMETHING ELSE. THAT UM,
00:16:13.872 --> 00:16:15.908
THAT GETS YOU OUTSIDE. IF
00:16:15.974 --> 00:16:16.942
THERE'S ONE THING WE LEARNED
00:16:17.009 --> 00:16:18.344
DURING COVID IS THAT IT'S
00:16:18.410 --> 00:16:20.346
IMPORTANT TO BE ABLE TO SIT IN A
00:16:20.412 --> 00:16:22.014
PATIO OR SIT SOMEWHERE THAT NOT
00:16:22.081 --> 00:16:23.148
INSIDE THE BUILDING OR EVEN TO
00:16:23.215 --> 00:16:25.451
HAVE A UM, UH, PORCH OR
00:16:25.517 --> 00:16:29.788
SOMETHING THAT OUTSIDE SPACE
00:16:29.855 --> 00:16:31.623
THAT BRINGS THE OUTSIDE IN. SO
00:16:31.690 --> 00:16:35.194
THE QUESTION I HAD FOR YOU AND I
00:16:35.260 --> 00:16:37.296
AND WE WILL BE SEEING THIS IN
00:16:37.363 --> 00:16:38.364
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. SO, UM,
00:16:38.430 --> 00:16:41.133
I'M GONNA SUPPORTED TODAY, BUT I
00:16:41.200 --> 00:16:43.135
WANT TO DELVE INTO IT. A LITTLE
00:16:43.202 --> 00:16:45.237
BIT MORE IS DO YOU IN FACT MEET
00:16:45.304 --> 00:16:46.438
ALL THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS
00:16:46.505 --> 00:16:49.241
THAT A CITY WOULD WOULD REQUIRE
00:16:49.308 --> 00:16:52.611
. IF THIS WAS JUST A REGULAR
00:16:52.678 --> 00:16:55.414
APARTMENT BUILDING STANDARD OR
00:16:55.481 --> 00:16:57.082
TRADITIONAL APARTMENT BUILDINGS,
00:16:57.149 --> 00:16:59.084
SO THAT THERE'S THE SOME KIND OF
00:16:59.151 --> 00:17:01.053
AMENITY THAT GOES ALONG WITH.
00:17:01.120 --> 00:17:02.121
YOU COULDN'T DRIVE DOWN THE
00:17:02.187 --> 00:17:03.989
STREET. GO. YEAH, THAT'S THE
00:17:04.056 --> 00:17:05.724
THERE'S 1000 UNITS RIGHT THERE,
00:17:05.791 --> 00:17:09.261
AND THERE'S NOTHING THAT THAT IS
00:17:09.328 --> 00:17:10.596
ATTRACTIVE ABOUT THE BUILDING
00:17:10.662 --> 00:17:12.598
BECAUSE THERE'S NO DENT. THERE'S
00:17:12.664 --> 00:17:14.833
NO DENSITY. AS I UNDERSTAND IT,
00:17:14.900 --> 00:17:16.702
THERE'S NO DENSITY REQUIREMENTS
00:17:16.769 --> 00:17:17.736
. IN OTHER WORDS, YOU CAN'T SET
00:17:17.803 --> 00:17:21.240
THESE LIMITS. WHICH WOULD SEEM
00:17:21.306 --> 00:17:22.508
TO FLY IN THE FACE OF THE
00:17:22.574 --> 00:17:24.309
STATEMENT THAT YOU HAVE TO
00:17:24.376 --> 00:17:28.347
FOLLOW THE. THE BUILDING
00:17:28.414 --> 00:17:29.448
STANDARDS OF THE CITY THAT
00:17:29.515 --> 00:17:33.152
YOU'RE GOING TO BE LOCATED IN
00:17:33.218 --> 00:17:34.653
RIGHT. I COMPLETELY UNDERSTAND
00:17:34.720 --> 00:17:36.155
THAT CONCERN. I THINK THE
00:17:36.221 --> 00:17:38.257
QUESTION WOULD BEST BE ANSWERED
00:17:38.323 --> 00:17:39.491
BY MR BLUMENFELD. IF THAT'S ALL
00:17:39.558 --> 00:17:42.494
RIGHT. THAT'S TERRIFIC. CAN YOU
00:17:42.561 --> 00:17:48.901
HEAR ME? WE CAN OKAY, UM, BUT
00:17:48.967 --> 00:17:50.869
FEW THINGS THIS, UM, THIS THIS,
00:17:50.936 --> 00:17:52.438
THESE BUILDINGS MUST MEET ALL
00:17:52.504 --> 00:17:53.972
THE CITY REQUIREMENTS. THEY WILL
00:17:54.039 --> 00:17:55.641
LOOK JUST LIKE APARTMENTS, THE
00:17:55.707 --> 00:17:56.775
ONLY DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE
00:17:56.842 --> 00:17:57.943
BUILDINGS AND ALL OTHER
00:17:58.010 --> 00:17:59.111
BUILDINGS. ALL OTHER APARTMENTS
00:17:59.178 --> 00:18:03.148
ARE THE. IT'S LITERALLY THE ONLY
00:18:03.215 --> 00:18:05.284
DIFFERENCE AND WHEN YOU DON'T
00:18:05.350 --> 00:18:06.785
HAVE TO BUILD 11 OR 27, OR 50
00:18:06.852 --> 00:18:08.353
KITCHENS, IT WILL BE CHEAPER.
00:18:08.420 --> 00:18:10.255
BUILD IT. THEY DON'T HAVE TO BE
00:18:10.322 --> 00:18:12.925
SMALL. THEY CAN BE SMALL. THEY
00:18:12.991 --> 00:18:14.860
CAN HAVE ONE ROOM OR TWO ROOMS.
00:18:14.927 --> 00:18:17.262
THEY CAN HAVE ONE ROOM. THEY CAN
00:18:17.329 --> 00:18:18.464
BE 400 SQUARE FEET. THEY CAN BE
00:18:18.530 --> 00:18:21.333
800 SQUARE FEET. SO THEY STILL
00:18:21.400 --> 00:18:23.302
NEED TO GET BANK LOANS, AND THEY
00:18:23.368 --> 00:18:24.503
STILL NEED TO ATTRACT TENANTS.
00:18:24.570 --> 00:18:25.838
SO I UNDERSTAND THE CONSERVATIVE
00:18:25.904 --> 00:18:30.375
RAISING. BUT THERE'S VERY LITTLE
00:18:30.442 --> 00:18:32.544
TO DIFFERENTIATE THESE KINDS OF
00:18:32.611 --> 00:18:33.712
UNITS FROM APARTMENTS OTHER THAN
00:18:33.779 --> 00:18:36.982
THE KITCHEN. GOT IT. THAT'S
00:18:37.049 --> 00:18:38.417
THAT'S THAT'S REALLY HELPFUL.
00:18:38.484 --> 00:18:39.751
AND I DO APPRECIATE THAT. THANK
00:18:39.818 --> 00:18:43.155
YOU VERY MUCH. SO WE DO NOT HAVE
00:18:43.222 --> 00:18:45.691
A QUORUM SO WE CAN'T TAKE A
00:18:45.757 --> 00:18:47.326
MOTION. BUT I WILL ALLOW YOU TO
00:18:47.392 --> 00:18:48.260
CONCLUDE. THANK YOU. I'LL
00:18:48.327 --> 00:18:49.127
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
00:18:49.194 --> 00:18:51.864
WHEN THE TIME COMES VERY GOOD.
00:18:51.930 --> 00:18:54.266
YOU HAVE ITEM NUMBER TWO, WHICH
00:18:54.333 --> 00:18:56.235
IS A B 23 39. I HAVE IT AS ITEM
00:18:56.301 --> 00:19:00.339
13, BUT T<c.cyan>WORKS FOR ME ALSO. OH</c>
00:19:00.405 --> 00:19:05.978
BILL NUMBER IS IDENTICAL. OKAY?
00:19:06.044 --> 00:19:07.746
WELL I'VE GOT IT AS ITEM NUMBER
00:19:07.813 --> 00:19:09.915
TWO. SO IF YOU'D LIKE TO TAKE IT
00:19:09.982 --> 00:19:11.016
UP NOW GOING TO ARGUE WITH YOU,
00:19:11.083 --> 00:19:13.519
BECAUSE YOU'RE ACTING AS CHAIR
00:19:13.585 --> 00:19:17.489
OF, UM SO LET ME BEGIN BY
00:19:17.556 --> 00:19:18.023
ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE'S
00:19:18.090 --> 00:19:19.992
AMENDMENTS ON THIS BILL. UH
00:19:20.058 --> 00:19:20.993
CURRENT LAW REQUIRES
00:19:21.059 --> 00:19:23.495
JURISDICTIONS TO IDENTIFY AT
00:19:23.562 --> 00:19:25.130
LEAST ONE ZONE WITHIN THEIR
00:19:25.197 --> 00:19:26.064
HOUSING ELEMENT WHERE EMERGENCY
00:19:26.131 --> 00:19:29.134
SHELTERS ARE PERMITTED BY RIGHT
00:19:29.201 --> 00:19:30.702
BUT THE LAW DOES NOT REQUIRE THE
00:19:30.769 --> 00:19:32.504
JURISDICTION TO DEMONSTRATE THAT
00:19:32.571 --> 00:19:35.073
THE SITES THAT ARE IDENTIFIED OR
00:19:35.140 --> 00:19:36.108
SUITABLE AND AVAILABLE FOR
00:19:36.174 --> 00:19:38.977
SHELTER DEVELOPMENT. THE RESULT
00:19:39.044 --> 00:19:40.379
HAS BEEN THAT MANY JURISDICTIONS
00:19:40.445 --> 00:19:42.781
ARE NOT ADEQUATELY PLANNING FOR
00:19:42.848 --> 00:19:44.149
SHELTERS OR OTHER INTERIM
00:19:44.216 --> 00:19:46.518
HOUSING, AND IN FACT, WE'RE
00:19:46.585 --> 00:19:47.286
CREATING BARRIERS TO THE
00:19:47.352 --> 00:19:48.253
DEVELOPMENT OF EMERGENCY
00:19:48.320 --> 00:19:51.757
SHELTERS. IN ADDITION, CURRENT
00:19:51.823 --> 00:19:53.258
LAW REQUIRES THAT IF A
00:19:53.325 --> 00:19:54.760
JURISDICTION FAILED TO REZONE
00:19:54.826 --> 00:19:57.329
ENOUGH LAND TO MEET ITS ARENA AT
00:19:57.396 --> 00:19:58.797
ALL INCOME LEVELS DURING THE
00:19:58.864 --> 00:20:01.166
PRIOR HOUSING ELEMENT PERIOD. IT
00:20:01.233 --> 00:20:02.935
MUST MAKE UP THIS ZONING
00:20:03.001 --> 00:20:04.036
SHORTFALL IN ITS SUBSEQUENT
00:20:04.102 --> 00:20:07.739
HOUSING ELEMENT. BESIDES REZONED
00:20:07.806 --> 00:20:09.141
TO MAKE UP THE SHORTFALL FROM
00:20:09.207 --> 00:20:10.842
THE PRIOR HOUSING ELEMENT ARE
00:20:10.909 --> 00:20:12.911
KNOWN AS CARRYOVER SITES. THERE
00:20:12.978 --> 00:20:14.880
IS SOME AMBIGUITY IN THE LAW AS
00:20:14.947 --> 00:20:16.715
TO WHETHER THE STATES NO NET
00:20:16.782 --> 00:20:18.684
LOSS ZONING LAW APPLIES TO BOTH
00:20:18.750 --> 00:20:21.219
CARRY OVERSIGHTS. INSIGHTS TO
00:20:21.286 --> 00:20:23.522
MEET THE CURRENT RINA OBLIGATION
00:20:23.589 --> 00:20:25.991
. AS A RESULT, SOME LOCALITIES
00:20:26.058 --> 00:20:27.292
MAY NOT COMPLY WITH THE
00:20:27.359 --> 00:20:29.027
OBLIGATION TO REPLACE CARRYOVER
00:20:29.094 --> 00:20:31.163
SITES THAT ARE DEVELOPED WITHOUT
00:20:31.229 --> 00:20:32.164
HOUSING FOR LOWER INCOME
00:20:32.230 --> 00:20:34.733
HOUSEHOLDS. FURTHER CONSTRAINING
00:20:34.800 --> 00:20:35.968
THE SUPPLY OF BADLY NEEDED SITES
00:20:36.034 --> 00:20:39.738
FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 8 23 39
00:20:39.805 --> 00:20:41.974
WILL ENSURE LOCATIONS WHERE
00:20:42.040 --> 00:20:43.208
EMERGENCY SHELTERS AND OTHER
00:20:43.275 --> 00:20:45.978
INTERIM HOUSING CAN BE BUILT.
00:20:46.044 --> 00:20:49.047
ARE SUITABLE, AVAILABLE AND
00:20:49.114 --> 00:20:50.482
SUFFICIENT TO ADDRESS THE NEED
00:20:50.549 --> 00:20:51.984
FOR THOSE EXPERIENCING
00:20:52.050 --> 00:20:53.619
HOMELESSNESS. THE BILL WOULD
00:20:53.685 --> 00:20:55.253
ALSO CLARIFY THAT NO NET LOSS
00:20:55.320 --> 00:20:57.289
LAW APPLIES TO BOTH CARRY OVER
00:20:57.356 --> 00:20:58.590
SITES AND SITES IDENTIFIED TO
00:20:58.657 --> 00:21:00.726
MEET THE CURRENT ARENA. THIS
00:21:00.792 --> 00:21:03.195
BILL HAS NO OPPOSITION AND WITH
00:21:03.261 --> 00:21:04.997
ME TESTIFYING IN SUPPORT HIS
00:21:05.063 --> 00:21:06.865
ANNUAL LAW LAWLER, REPRESENTING
00:21:06.932 --> 00:21:08.300
THE CALIFORNIA RURAL LEGAL
00:21:08.367 --> 00:21:09.334
ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN THE
00:21:09.401 --> 00:21:12.971
PUBLIC INTEREST LAW PROJECT.
00:21:13.038 --> 00:21:14.439
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ASKED MS
00:21:14.506 --> 00:21:15.607
LAWLOR TO PLEASE COME FORWARD
00:21:15.674 --> 00:21:19.811
AND PRESENT YOUR TESTIMONY. GOOD
00:21:19.878 --> 00:21:21.279
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:21:21.346 --> 00:21:23.382
MEMBER, DANIEL LAWLER AGAIN ON
00:21:23.448 --> 00:21:24.883
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA RURAL
00:21:24.950 --> 00:21:25.550
LEGAL ASSISTANCE FOUNDATION IN
00:21:25.617 --> 00:21:27.285
THE PUBLIC INTEREST LAW PROJECT
00:21:27.352 --> 00:21:28.186
, MR WILLIAM COVERED THE BILL.
00:21:28.253 --> 00:21:30.455
WELL SO I'LL BE BRIEF. THE LAW
00:21:30.522 --> 00:21:31.156
HAS LONG REQUIRED EVERY
00:21:31.223 --> 00:21:33.258
JURISDICTION IN THE STATE TO
00:21:33.325 --> 00:21:34.393
HAVE SUFFICIENT SITES ZONED TO
00:21:34.459 --> 00:21:35.394
ALLOW THE DEVELOPMENT OF
00:21:35.460 --> 00:21:36.595
EMERGENCY SHELTERS BY RIGHT
00:21:36.662 --> 00:21:39.631
UNFORTUNATELY, THE LAW HAS SOME
00:21:39.698 --> 00:21:40.399
LOOPHOLES IN IT, AND SOME
00:21:40.465 --> 00:21:41.433
JURISDICTIONS, UNFORTUNATELY,
00:21:41.500 --> 00:21:42.768
CONTINUE TO EXPLOIT THOSE
00:21:42.834 --> 00:21:43.468
LOOPHOLES. THIS BILL SIMPLY
00:21:43.535 --> 00:21:45.103
TIGHTENS THOSE TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:21:45.170 --> 00:21:46.405
WE ACTUALLY HAVE PLACES WHERE
00:21:46.471 --> 00:21:47.506
SHELTERS CAN LOCATE EASILY IN
00:21:47.572 --> 00:21:49.374
EVERY SINGLE CITY THROUGHOUT THE
00:21:49.441 --> 00:21:50.609
STATE, AND WE WOULD RESPECTFULLY
00:21:50.676 --> 00:21:52.911
ASK YOUR VERY GOOD. IS THERE
00:21:52.978 --> 00:21:54.646
ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:21:54.713 --> 00:21:56.548
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
00:21:56.615 --> 00:21:58.483
HERE IN THE COMMITTEE ROOM?
00:21:58.550 --> 00:22:00.986
SEEING NONE MATTER MODERATOR
00:22:01.053 --> 00:22:02.554
WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:22:02.621 --> 00:22:03.355
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASK IF
00:22:03.422 --> 00:22:04.523
THERE'S ANYBODY THAT WOULD LIKE
00:22:04.589 --> 00:22:06.925
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A B 23
00:22:06.992 --> 00:22:11.096
39. THANK YOU IF YOU'RE IN
00:22:11.163 --> 00:22:13.432
SUPPORT OF A B 23 39 YOU MAY
00:22:13.498 --> 00:22:17.369
PRESS ONE, THEN ZERO. I GET THAT
00:22:17.436 --> 00:22:19.304
IT'S ONE AND THEN THREW UP HERE
00:22:19.371 --> 00:22:22.107
IN SUPPORT. WE WILL GO TO LINE
00:22:22.174 --> 00:22:28.013
29. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HAPPENING
00:22:28.080 --> 00:22:30.148
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS SALAS
00:22:30.215 --> 00:22:31.783
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY
00:22:31.850 --> 00:22:32.884
SPONSORS IN SUPPORT OF THIS
00:22:32.951 --> 00:22:34.419
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:22:34.486 --> 00:22:38.490
MUCH. THANK YOU. NEXT TO THE
00:22:38.557 --> 00:22:42.494
LINE UP TO 42 YEAR LINE IS OPEN.
00:22:42.561 --> 00:22:44.262
GOOD AFTERNOON SHARON REPORT
00:22:44.329 --> 00:22:45.230
WITH THE CORPORATION FOR
00:22:45.297 --> 00:22:51.269
SUPPORTIVE HOUSING AND SUPPORT.
00:22:51.336 --> 00:22:52.771
NEXT PLEASE. THANK YOU, MADAM
00:22:52.838 --> 00:22:54.506
CHAIR. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
00:22:54.573 --> 00:22:56.241
SUPPORTING QUÊ AT THIS TIME.
00:22:56.308 --> 00:22:59.377
VERY GOOD. WE'LL MOVE ON TO, UM
00:22:59.444 --> 00:23:01.179
OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO LEAD,
00:23:01.246 --> 00:23:04.049
OPPOSITION LISTED, SO WE'RE
00:23:04.116 --> 00:23:06.551
GOING TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE
00:23:06.618 --> 00:23:07.886
IN ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:23:07.953 --> 00:23:10.989
TESTIFY. AN OPPOSITION SAYING NO
00:23:11.056 --> 00:23:12.624
MOVEMENT WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:23:12.691 --> 00:23:14.092
TELECONFERENCE LINE AT A
00:23:14.159 --> 00:23:15.494
MODERATOR, COULD YOU PLEASE
00:23:15.560 --> 00:23:17.195
PROMPT THOSE INDIVIDUALS TO SEE
00:23:17.262 --> 00:23:18.396
IF THEY'D LIKE TO TESTIFY IN
00:23:18.463 --> 00:23:21.433
OPPOSITION? THANK YOU. IF YOU'RE
00:23:21.500 --> 00:23:22.601
IN OPPOSITION, YOU MIGHT PRESS
00:23:22.667 --> 00:23:25.837
ONE AND THEN ZERO. FORGETTING
00:23:25.904 --> 00:23:28.240
THAT IS ONE IN THE ZERO POSITION
00:23:28.306 --> 00:23:36.348
OF A B 23 39. AND BUT I'M SURE
00:23:36.414 --> 00:23:37.849
WE HAVE NO OPPOSITION IN Q AT
00:23:37.916 --> 00:23:40.418
THIS TIME, THANK YOU SO MUCH
00:23:40.485 --> 00:23:41.853
WILL BRING THE MATTER BACK TO
00:23:41.920 --> 00:23:43.989
THE COMMITTEE. THERE AREN'T THAT
00:23:44.055 --> 00:23:45.490
NO QUESTION FROM SENATOR
00:23:45.557 --> 00:23:46.992
WIECKOWSKI. SO I THINK YOU'RE
00:23:47.058 --> 00:23:49.427
YOU'RE IN THE CLEAR, HOWEVER,
00:23:49.494 --> 00:23:51.029
THE ONE THING THAT I DO WANT TO
00:23:51.096 --> 00:23:53.398
KNOW FAST, NOT SO FAST. AND THIS
00:23:53.465 --> 00:23:58.703
IS JUST MY. MY SENSITIVITY TO
00:23:58.770 --> 00:24:00.305
THE ISSUE IS THAT THE ONE OF THE
00:24:00.372 --> 00:24:01.840
AMENDMENTS WAS TO PROVIDE THAT,
00:24:01.907 --> 00:24:07.179
UM. AH VACANT NONRESIDENTIAL
00:24:07.245 --> 00:24:08.713
SITES MAY BE IDENTIFIED FOR
00:24:08.780 --> 00:24:10.115
SHELTERS PROVIDED THE SITES ARE
00:24:10.182 --> 00:24:11.082
LOCATED NEAR AMENITIES AND
00:24:11.149 --> 00:24:13.185
SERVICES THAT SERVE THE HOME
00:24:13.251 --> 00:24:14.052
PEOPLE EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
00:24:14.119 --> 00:24:18.056
. AND I WOULD. ASK YOU TO
00:24:18.123 --> 00:24:19.257
CONSIDER IT. IT'S NOT A
00:24:19.324 --> 00:24:21.359
REQUIREMENT THAT IT BE OR THAT
00:24:21.426 --> 00:24:21.927
TRANSPORTATION WE PROVIDED.
00:24:21.993 --> 00:24:24.296
BECAUSE MANY TIMES WE END UP UM
00:24:24.362 --> 00:24:28.033
PROVIDING THE SERVICES AT THE
00:24:28.099 --> 00:24:32.003
COUNTY SEAT. UM AND THEN EXPECT
00:24:32.070 --> 00:24:34.172
EVERYTHING TO BE AROUND THERE,
00:24:34.239 --> 00:24:36.775
WHICH, UM, EXPECT WHICH IMPACTS
00:24:36.842 --> 00:24:38.743
THE NEIGHBORHOODS. BUT I'M A BIG
00:24:38.810 --> 00:24:40.312
BELIEVER IN MAKING SURE THAT
00:24:40.378 --> 00:24:42.080
THERE'S A SHELTER IN EVERY
00:24:42.147 --> 00:24:43.915
SINGLE DISTRICT. OR IN EVERY
00:24:43.982 --> 00:24:45.750
SINGLE PART OF THE CITY OR THE
00:24:45.817 --> 00:24:49.821
COUNTY SO THAT NOT ONE UM, SO
00:24:49.888 --> 00:24:51.423
THAT PEOPLE DON'T FEEL LIKE
00:24:51.489 --> 00:24:52.224
YOU'RE PUTTING ALL THE HOMELESS
00:24:52.290 --> 00:24:53.692
SHELTERS IN ONE NEIGHBORHOOD,
00:24:53.758 --> 00:24:55.360
FOR EXAMPLE, SO IT'S THAT'S JUST
00:24:55.427 --> 00:24:59.531
MY, UM MY INTEREST IS MAKING
00:24:59.598 --> 00:25:01.333
SURE THAT WE'RE BEING FAIR ABOUT
00:25:01.399 --> 00:25:02.467
WHERE WE'RE CITING AND I KNOW
00:25:02.534 --> 00:25:04.302
THERE'S IT'S REALLY, REALLY HARD
00:25:04.369 --> 00:25:05.871
TO SITE SITE TO SITE HOMELESS
00:25:05.937 --> 00:25:08.573
SHELTER SITES BECAUSE EVERYBODY
00:25:08.640 --> 00:25:10.208
COMES WITH A BIAS THEY WANT IT
00:25:10.275 --> 00:25:12.644
SOLVED. THEY JUST DON'T WANT TO
00:25:12.711 --> 00:25:13.645
SOLVED IN THEIR NEIGHBORHOOD.
00:25:13.712 --> 00:25:14.246
IT'S LIKE AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
00:25:14.312 --> 00:25:16.147
BUT I THINK SOMETIMES IF WE HAVE
00:25:16.214 --> 00:25:17.015
SOME TRANSPORTATION SERVICES
00:25:17.082 --> 00:25:19.017
THAT MAKE IT EASIER FOR PEOPLE
00:25:19.084 --> 00:25:20.318
TO GET TO THE SERVICES THEY
00:25:20.385 --> 00:25:23.221
NEED, THAT'S AS SUFFICIENT AS UM
00:25:23.288 --> 00:25:24.055
, JUST HAVING IT BE NEXT DOOR,
00:25:24.122 --> 00:25:25.991
SO THAT'S JUST MY TWO CENTS
00:25:26.057 --> 00:25:27.592
WORTH. OTHERWISE I DON'T HAVE
00:25:27.659 --> 00:25:29.027
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS. WE'D ALLOW
00:25:29.094 --> 00:25:31.029
YOU TO CONCLUDE AND WILL TAKE UP
00:25:31.096 --> 00:25:32.230
THE BILL WHEN WE GET A QUORUM.
00:25:32.297 --> 00:25:35.000
THANK YOU. CITING ISSUES ARE
00:25:35.066 --> 00:25:37.202
UNIFORMLY AND UNIVERSALLY
00:25:37.269 --> 00:25:38.703
DIFFICULT, ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE
00:25:38.770 --> 00:25:40.705
OF US WHO HAVE BEEN AT LOCAL
00:25:40.772 --> 00:25:42.374
GOVERNMENT LEVEL. AND I
00:25:42.440 --> 00:25:43.675
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
00:25:43.742 --> 00:25:46.344
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
00:25:46.411 --> 00:25:47.512
PRESENTATION HERE TODAY. THANK
00:25:47.579 --> 00:25:52.984
YOU. WE SHALL MOVE ON TO
00:25:53.051 --> 00:25:55.320
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RIVAS. I DON'T
00:25:55.387 --> 00:25:56.354
SEE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS HERE.
00:25:56.421 --> 00:26:01.426
AM I CORRECT? OKAY, SO WELL. WE
00:26:01.493 --> 00:26:03.395
WILL JUMP OVER HIM FOR RIGHT NOW
00:26:03.461 --> 00:26:05.096
AND WELCOME. THANKS FOR HAVING
00:26:05.163 --> 00:26:06.932
ME IT'S GREAT TO SEE BOTH OF
00:26:06.998 --> 00:26:10.769
YOU. AND UM, THIS LEGISLATION IS
00:26:10.835 --> 00:26:13.338
ASSEMBLY BILL 1654, AND IT SEEKS
00:26:13.405 --> 00:26:15.273
TO HELP ELIMINATE OUR STATEWIDE
00:26:15.340 --> 00:26:17.142
SHORTAGE OF FARMWORKER HOUSING
00:26:17.208 --> 00:26:19.277
INDUSTRY IN TWO IMPORTANT WAYS,
00:26:19.344 --> 00:26:19.978
AND FIRST. THIS LEGISLATION
00:26:20.045 --> 00:26:21.012
REQUIRES THE DEPARTMENT OF
00:26:21.079 --> 00:26:22.881
HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
00:26:22.948 --> 00:26:25.317
DEVELOPMENT TO CONDUCT A FIRST
00:26:25.383 --> 00:26:26.084
OF ITS KIND STATEWIDE ASSESSMENT
00:26:26.151 --> 00:26:27.152
OF FARMWORKER, HOUSING NEEDS AND
00:26:27.218 --> 00:26:30.088
CONDITIONS. AND THEN DEVELOPING
00:26:30.155 --> 00:26:30.922
FARMWORKER HOUSING STRATEGY
00:26:30.989 --> 00:26:32.991
BASED ON THOSE FINDINGS,
00:26:33.058 --> 00:26:34.526
UNFORTUNATELY, WE CLEARLY LACK
00:26:34.592 --> 00:26:35.593
THE KIND OF STATEWIDE DATA THAT
00:26:35.660 --> 00:26:37.495
IS NEEDED TO DEVELOP A
00:26:37.562 --> 00:26:38.330
COMPREHENSIVE APPROACH. YOU KNOW
00:26:38.396 --> 00:26:41.166
, I SHOULD NOTE THAT A 2018
00:26:41.232 --> 00:26:42.667
FARMWORKER HOUSING STUDYING
00:26:42.734 --> 00:26:44.302
ACTION PLAN THAT WAS IT WAS
00:26:44.369 --> 00:26:47.539
CONDUCTED FOR THE CITY OF
00:26:47.605 --> 00:26:48.840
SELENA'S THE SLEEVES VALLEY AND
00:26:48.907 --> 00:26:50.608
THE POWER VALLEYS. UM, IT
00:26:50.675 --> 00:26:51.876
ILLUSTRATED A DIRE HOUSING
00:26:51.943 --> 00:26:54.713
SITUATION IN OUR REGION AND HIGH
00:26:54.779 --> 00:26:55.981
RATES OF OVERCROWDING AND
00:26:56.047 --> 00:26:57.082
HOMELESSNESS AMONG FARM WORKERS
00:26:57.148 --> 00:27:00.118
AND THEIR FAMILIES. HAVING
00:27:00.185 --> 00:27:01.119
TOURED OUR STATE'S AGRICULTURAL
00:27:01.186 --> 00:27:02.554
REGIONS SEVERAL TIMES SINCE
00:27:02.620 --> 00:27:04.122
BECOMING CHAIR OF THE ASSEMBLY
00:27:04.189 --> 00:27:05.590
AGRICULTURE COMMITTEE. IT'S
00:27:05.657 --> 00:27:07.258
ABSOLUTELY CLEAR THAT WE NEED
00:27:07.325 --> 00:27:09.160
STATEWIDE DATA IN THIS HOUSING
00:27:09.227 --> 00:27:11.596
AREA. AND SECOND. THIS
00:27:11.663 --> 00:27:13.631
LEGISLATION SEEKS TO PROVIDE A
00:27:13.698 --> 00:27:15.200
DEDICATED FUNDING SOURCE FOR
00:27:15.266 --> 00:27:16.835
FARMWORKER HOUSING BY SETTING
00:27:16.901 --> 00:27:19.671
ASIDE AT LEAST 5% OF ALL
00:27:19.738 --> 00:27:20.505
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TAX CREDITS
00:27:20.572 --> 00:27:21.639
FOR FARMWORKER HOUSING FOR 10
00:27:21.706 --> 00:27:24.342
YEARS. ALTOGETHER THESE
00:27:24.409 --> 00:27:26.277
IMPORTANT TO MEASURES WILL PUT
00:27:26.344 --> 00:27:27.912
CALIFORNIA ON A PATH TO DO MUCH
00:27:27.979 --> 00:27:30.315
MORE THAN WE HAVE AS A STATE TO
00:27:30.382 --> 00:27:31.316
ADDRESS OUR FARMWORKER HOUSING
00:27:31.383 --> 00:27:34.019
SHORTAGE IN ENSURING DECENT,
00:27:34.085 --> 00:27:35.453
DECENT LIVING CONDITIONS FOR THE
00:27:35.520 --> 00:27:37.989
ESSENTIAL WORKERS. WITH ME HERE
00:27:38.056 --> 00:27:39.024
THIS AFTERNOON TO TESTIFY IN
00:27:39.090 --> 00:27:40.859
SUPPORT OF THIS LEGISLATION ARE
00:27:40.925 --> 00:27:41.926
PARKER EVANS OF MUTUAL HOUSING,
00:27:41.993 --> 00:27:44.596
CALIFORNIA AND ROB WIENER WITH
00:27:44.662 --> 00:27:45.597
THE CALIFORNIA COALITION FOR
00:27:45.663 --> 00:27:50.101
RURAL HOUSING. THANK YOU. THANK
00:27:50.168 --> 00:27:51.736
YOU VERY MUCH WANT TO START WITH
00:27:51.803 --> 00:27:52.737
PARKER EVANS? WELCOME. THANK
00:27:52.804 --> 00:27:55.874
YOU. AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
00:27:55.940 --> 00:27:57.609
PARKER AND HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
00:27:57.675 --> 00:27:58.276
PROJECT MANAGER WITH MUTUAL
00:27:58.343 --> 00:27:59.277
HOUSE IN CALIFORNIA, WHERE
00:27:59.344 --> 00:28:00.412
NONPROFIT, AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:28:00.478 --> 00:28:01.946
DEVELOPER HERE IN TOWN. AND ONE
00:28:02.013 --> 00:28:03.815
OF THE REASONS I'M HERE IS
00:28:03.882 --> 00:28:04.983
BECAUSE MUTUAL IS ONE OF THE
00:28:05.050 --> 00:28:06.484
VERY FEW AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:28:06.551 --> 00:28:07.585
DEVELOPERS WHO CAN SAY THAT
00:28:07.652 --> 00:28:09.320
WE'VE ACTUALLY USED THE CURRENT
00:28:09.387 --> 00:28:10.455
VERSION OF THE STATE FARM MARKET
00:28:10.522 --> 00:28:11.056
TAX CREDIT. WE'RE APPROACHING
00:28:11.122 --> 00:28:13.358
THE SITE UP IN THE CITY OF
00:28:13.425 --> 00:28:13.925
WOODLAND, ABOUT 25 MINUTES
00:28:13.992 --> 00:28:14.993
NORTHWEST OF HERE, TALK TO THE
00:28:15.060 --> 00:28:17.862
LOCAL OFFICIALS AND COMMUNITY
00:28:17.929 --> 00:28:18.696
LEADERS. THEY SAID. WILL YOU
00:28:18.763 --> 00:28:19.297
BUILD SOME FARMWORKER HOUSING
00:28:19.364 --> 00:28:20.365
HERE? WE SAID, ABSOLUTELY. LET'S
00:28:20.432 --> 00:28:21.699
GET IT GOING. AND FOR THE
00:28:21.766 --> 00:28:23.334
FINANCING. WE STARTED WHERE WE
00:28:23.401 --> 00:28:24.302
ALWAYS START, WHICH IS THE LOCAL
00:28:24.369 --> 00:28:25.170
MONEY BECAUSE THAT'S ALWAYS THE
00:28:25.236 --> 00:28:27.238
MONEY THAT NEEDS TO COME IN
00:28:27.305 --> 00:28:28.073
FIRST, AND WE IMMEDIATELY RUN
00:28:28.139 --> 00:28:29.707
INTO THE PROBLEMS THAT ARE
00:28:29.774 --> 00:28:30.575
INHERENT TO FARMWORKER. HOUSING
00:28:30.642 --> 00:28:31.176
DEVELOPMENT IS YOU'RE DEALING
00:28:31.242 --> 00:28:32.744
WITH SMALL JURISDICTIONS THAT
00:28:32.811 --> 00:28:33.812
LACK THE RESOURCES NEEDED TO
00:28:33.878 --> 00:28:36.314
DEVELOP THE PROJECT. AND SO THE
00:28:36.381 --> 00:28:37.482
CITY WOODLAND, THEY DID HAVE AN
00:28:37.549 --> 00:28:38.516
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TRUST FUND.
00:28:38.583 --> 00:28:39.818
THEY DID HAVE A HOME ALLOCATION.
00:28:39.884 --> 00:28:41.152
THEY DID HAVE A CDBG ALLOCATION,
00:28:41.219 --> 00:28:42.153
BUT NOT NEARLY ENOUGH TO FILL
00:28:42.220 --> 00:28:44.456
THE GAP. SO WE TOOK ALL THAT
00:28:44.522 --> 00:28:46.291
MONEY. WE WENT TO THE USDA GOT
00:28:46.357 --> 00:28:47.358
SOME MONEY FROM THEM. STILL NOT
00:28:47.425 --> 00:28:48.893
ENOUGH TO FILL THE GAPS. WE
00:28:48.960 --> 00:28:50.428
LOOKED AT THE STATE OPTIONS, AND
00:28:50.495 --> 00:28:51.930
THAT'S WHAT WE BECAME ACQUAINTED
00:28:51.996 --> 00:28:53.231
WITH THE FARMWORKER HOUSING TAX
00:28:53.298 --> 00:28:54.099
CREDIT HERE GRAND TOTAL OF
00:28:54.165 --> 00:28:56.267
$500,000 A YEAR THAT IS NOT THE
00:28:56.334 --> 00:28:57.235
500 MILLION, THAT IS THE CURRENT
00:28:57.302 --> 00:28:58.136
HOUSING BROAD TAX CUT ABOUT
00:28:58.203 --> 00:29:00.371
500,000. IT'S SO SMALL, THAT TEA
00:29:00.438 --> 00:29:01.706
CAKE DOESN'T EVEN PUT IT OUT.
00:29:01.773 --> 00:29:03.208
EACH YEAR. THEY HAVE TO WAIT FOR
00:29:03.274 --> 00:29:04.976
IT TO ACCUMULATE FOR FIVE YEARS.
00:29:05.043 --> 00:29:06.077
AND THEN THEY PUT IT OUT THAT
00:29:06.144 --> 00:29:08.079
IT'S EVEN A USABLE AMOUNT. WE
00:29:08.146 --> 00:29:09.013
WERE FORTUNATE WITH OUR TIMING
00:29:09.080 --> 00:29:10.348
AND COMPETITIVE WITH OUR
00:29:10.415 --> 00:29:12.584
APPLICATION. WE GOT THAT 2.5
00:29:12.650 --> 00:29:13.084
MILLION THAT FIVE YEAR
00:29:13.151 --> 00:29:14.085
ALLOCATION TO HELP CLOSE OUR GAP
00:29:14.152 --> 00:29:16.187
AND BUILD THE PROJECT AND I'M SO
00:29:16.254 --> 00:29:17.922
GLAD WE DID. BECAUSE IN A LOT OF
00:29:17.989 --> 00:29:19.357
WAYS THIS PROJECT SPRING LAKE IS
00:29:19.424 --> 00:29:20.291
THE CROWN JEWEL IN OUR
00:29:20.358 --> 00:29:22.360
PORTFOLIO, AND I THINK IT'S A
00:29:22.427 --> 00:29:23.528
LARGE PART BECAUSE THE SHARED
00:29:23.595 --> 00:29:24.762
EXPERIENCES BY THE FARM WORKERS
00:29:24.829 --> 00:29:25.964
REALLY HELPS BUILD THIS THIS
00:29:26.030 --> 00:29:27.465
SUPPORT NETWORK AND STRONG SENSE
00:29:27.532 --> 00:29:29.000
OF COMMUNITY. SO I WANT TO BUILD
00:29:29.067 --> 00:29:29.934
MORE PROJECTS LIKE SPRING LAKE.
00:29:30.001 --> 00:29:32.036
I THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF
00:29:32.103 --> 00:29:33.471
JURISDICTIONS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:29:33.538 --> 00:29:34.973
SEE PROJECTS LIKE SPRING LAKE,
00:29:35.039 --> 00:29:35.974
AND I THINK OUR FARM WORKERS
00:29:36.040 --> 00:29:36.875
DESERVE MORE PROJECTS LIKE
00:29:36.941 --> 00:29:37.942
SPRING LAKE, BUT I'LL TELL YOU,
00:29:38.009 --> 00:29:39.878
IT'S REALLY HARD RIGHT NO TO
00:29:39.944 --> 00:29:40.912
BUILD MORE PROJECTS LIKE SPRING
00:29:40.979 --> 00:29:42.714
LAKE WITH THE RESOURCES THAT ARE
00:29:42.780 --> 00:29:44.082
AVAILABLE. AND SO I DON'T THINK
00:29:44.149 --> 00:29:46.217
5% OF FUTURE TAX CREDIT IS A
00:29:46.284 --> 00:29:47.418
HUGE ASK FOR FARM WORKERS AND
00:29:47.485 --> 00:29:49.220
JUMPING FROM 505,000 TO 2.5, OR
00:29:49.287 --> 00:29:50.355
2 25 MILLION OVERNIGHT WILL BE
00:29:50.421 --> 00:29:50.989
TRANSFORMATIONAL INTER INDUSTRY,
00:29:51.055 --> 00:29:52.157
SO THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:29:52.223 --> 00:29:54.392
MUCH. NEXT I'D LIKE TO ASK ROB
00:29:54.459 --> 00:29:56.161
WIENER. WELCOME WELCOME. THANK
00:29:56.227 --> 00:29:57.295
YOU. ROB WIENER, CALIFORNIA
00:29:57.362 --> 00:30:00.265
COALITION FOR RURAL HOUSING. I'M
00:30:00.331 --> 00:30:01.833
GOING TO COMMENT ON THE STUDY
00:30:01.900 --> 00:30:05.203
COMPONENT OF THE BILL. UH
00:30:05.270 --> 00:30:06.471
THERE'S A LOT WE DON'T KNOW
00:30:06.538 --> 00:30:08.673
ABOUT FARMWORKERS. WHAT WE DO
00:30:08.740 --> 00:30:10.408
KNOW IS THAT THEY TOIL IN THE
00:30:10.475 --> 00:30:13.011
FIELDS, UH, DOING BACKBREAKING
00:30:13.077 --> 00:30:14.846
WORK IN VERY HARSH CONDITIONS.
00:30:14.913 --> 00:30:18.249
HEAT COLD. AND THEY OFTEN LIVE
00:30:18.316 --> 00:30:20.285
IN SQUALID HOUSING CONDITIONS.
00:30:20.351 --> 00:30:24.789
CAVES FEELS TENTS, TRAILERS,
00:30:24.856 --> 00:30:26.457
COOL SHIRTS. WE ALSO KNOW THAT
00:30:26.524 --> 00:30:28.493
DURING THE PANDEMIC, THEY WERE
00:30:28.560 --> 00:30:31.496
HIGHLY EXPOSED TO COVID BECAUSE
00:30:31.563 --> 00:30:32.497
THEY TYPICALLY LIVE IN
00:30:32.564 --> 00:30:34.365
SUBSTANDARD, VERY POOR, CROWDED
00:30:34.432 --> 00:30:37.435
HOUSING CONDITIONS. SO THERE ARE
00:30:37.502 --> 00:30:40.605
A LOT OF THINGS WE DON'T KNOW.
00:30:40.672 --> 00:30:41.606
AND THOSE THINGS ARE WE DON'T
00:30:41.673 --> 00:30:42.740
KNOW THE CURRENT PERCENTAGE. UM
00:30:42.807 --> 00:30:43.875
OR DEMOGRAPHICS OF THE
00:30:43.942 --> 00:30:45.843
FARMWORKER POPULATION. WE DON'T
00:30:45.910 --> 00:30:47.345
KNOW THE CURRENT PERCENTAGE OF
00:30:47.412 --> 00:30:49.747
FARM WORKERS WHO ARE DOMESTIC
00:30:49.814 --> 00:30:51.649
FARM WORKERS WHO LIVE AND WORK
00:30:51.716 --> 00:30:54.185
PERMANENTLY. IN CALIFORNIA. WE
00:30:54.252 --> 00:30:55.820
DON'T KNOW WHICH WHAT PERCENTAGE
00:30:55.887 --> 00:30:59.090
OF THOSE WORKERS MIGRATE FROM
00:30:59.157 --> 00:31:00.458
CROP TO CROP IN CALIFORNIA OR
00:31:00.525 --> 00:31:02.594
OUTSIDE OF CALIFORNIA. WE DON'T
00:31:02.660 --> 00:31:03.995
KNOW THE PERCENTAGE OF THE FARM
00:31:04.062 --> 00:31:06.030
WORK LABOR FORCE THAT IS FOREIGN
00:31:06.097 --> 00:31:10.635
WORKERS. WHO ARE IMPORTED INTO
00:31:10.702 --> 00:31:12.937
CALIFORNIA. WE DON'T KNOW THE
00:31:13.004 --> 00:31:14.572
HOUSING CONDITIONS THAT THEY
00:31:14.639 --> 00:31:15.840
LIVE IN. WE DON'T KNOW HOW LONG
00:31:15.907 --> 00:31:17.976
IT TAKES THEM TO COMMUTE FROM
00:31:18.042 --> 00:31:21.713
HOME TO THE FIELDS. UH AND WE
00:31:21.779 --> 00:31:23.014
DON'T KNOW WHAT THEIR HOUSING
00:31:23.081 --> 00:31:25.416
NEEDS ARE WHAT KIND OF KINDS OF
00:31:25.483 --> 00:31:27.485
HOUSING PROTOTYPES WOULD BEST
00:31:27.552 --> 00:31:28.820
FIT THEIR CONDITIONS? WHAT ARE
00:31:28.886 --> 00:31:32.223
THEIR PREFERENCES? AND WHAT
00:31:32.290 --> 00:31:34.359
KINDS OF THINGS CAN THE LOCAL
00:31:34.425 --> 00:31:36.327
GOVERNMENTS DO TO REMOVE
00:31:36.394 --> 00:31:38.329
OBSTACLES TO DEVELOPMENT OF FARM
00:31:38.396 --> 00:31:41.199
LABOR? HOUSING AND FINALLY, UM,
00:31:41.266 --> 00:31:42.800
WHAT EFFECT HAVE THE STATE'S
00:31:42.867 --> 00:31:43.668
PHARMACARE HOUSING PROGRAMS
00:31:43.735 --> 00:31:47.438
WORKED? AND WHAT WILL IT COST TO
00:31:47.505 --> 00:31:48.473
REALLY TRULY ADDRESS THE
00:31:48.539 --> 00:31:51.342
FARMWORKER HOUSING? PROBLEM IN
00:31:51.409 --> 00:31:52.910
CALIFORNIA. SO THOSE ARE ALL
00:31:52.977 --> 00:31:55.013
THINGS THAT WE CAN LEARN FROM
00:31:55.079 --> 00:31:56.047
THE FIRST EVER STUDY LIKE THIS,
00:31:56.114 --> 00:31:57.215
AND I STRONGLY RECOMMEND THAT
00:31:57.282 --> 00:31:58.916
YOU'VE TAKEN MY VOTE ON THIS
00:31:58.983 --> 00:32:01.352
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:32:01.419 --> 00:32:02.787
MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE IN
00:32:02.854 --> 00:32:04.055
COMMITTEE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:32:04.122 --> 00:32:05.089
TESTIFY MARKS DIVERSE THE
00:32:05.156 --> 00:32:06.024
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP
00:32:06.090 --> 00:32:09.160
AND SUPPORT GOOD AFTERNOON,
00:32:09.227 --> 00:32:10.194
MARIE CASTALDI ON BEHALF OF
00:32:10.261 --> 00:32:12.797
HOUSING, CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT
00:32:12.864 --> 00:32:13.965
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
00:32:14.032 --> 00:32:18.369
ANYONE ELSE? SAYING THEN WE'LL
00:32:18.436 --> 00:32:19.737
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:32:19.804 --> 00:32:21.706
LINE OUT OF MODERATOR. IF YOU
00:32:21.773 --> 00:32:22.907
COULD PLEASE QUEUE UP MEMBERS
00:32:22.974 --> 00:32:26.878
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY. THANK YOU
00:32:26.944 --> 00:32:28.746
FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF 80 16 BEFORE
00:32:28.813 --> 00:32:33.251
YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:32:33.318 --> 00:32:34.452
AGAIN THAT IT'S ONE AND THEN
00:32:34.519 --> 00:32:41.359
ZERO FEAR AND SUPPORT. IN ONE
00:32:41.426 --> 00:32:43.594
MOMENT, WE DO HAVE CUTE TO
00:32:43.661 --> 00:32:44.796
QUEUING UP TO GET THEIR LINE
00:32:44.862 --> 00:32:47.131
NUMBER. JUST REMIND OVER HERE
00:32:47.198 --> 00:32:52.970
AND SUPPORT OF A B 16 54, TEXAS.
00:32:53.037 --> 00:32:55.073
AND WE WOULD GO TO LINE UP TO
00:32:55.139 --> 00:33:02.780
63. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. I'M SORRY
00:33:02.847 --> 00:33:04.649
. LYING TO 63. YOUR LINE IS
00:33:04.716 --> 00:33:08.086
OPEN. HI. I'M HURTING FOR THE
00:33:08.152 --> 00:33:13.658
COURT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:33:13.725 --> 00:33:15.626
THANK YOU NEXT TO THE LINE OF TO
00:33:15.693 --> 00:33:19.497
61. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HI MY
00:33:19.564 --> 00:33:20.998
NAME IS RACHEL SMITH AND
00:33:21.065 --> 00:33:22.500
REPRESENTING WORLD COMMUNITY
00:33:22.567 --> 00:33:24.736
ASSISTANCE CORPORATION IN FRONT
00:33:24.802 --> 00:33:26.003
SUPPORT OF 80. 16 54. THANK YOU
00:33:26.070 --> 00:33:30.641
SO MUCH. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
00:33:30.708 --> 00:33:33.010
MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
00:33:33.077 --> 00:33:34.746
SUPPORTING QUÊ IT THIS TIME
00:33:34.812 --> 00:33:36.047
GOING TO TRY THE ROOM AGAIN WHEN
00:33:36.114 --> 00:33:38.716
ONE FINAL TIME. IS THERE ANYBODY
00:33:38.783 --> 00:33:40.651
ELSE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:33:40.718 --> 00:33:49.494
AND SUPPORT OF A B 16 54. WE
00:33:49.560 --> 00:33:50.361
NEED TO GET YOU SOME
00:33:50.428 --> 00:33:51.729
ROLLERBLADES. THANK YOU. MADAM
00:33:51.796 --> 00:33:53.297
CHAIR, REMEMBERS BRIAN AUGUSTA
00:33:53.364 --> 00:33:54.565
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:33:54.632 --> 00:33:55.366
RURAL LEGAL ASSISTANCE
00:33:55.433 --> 00:33:56.100
FOUNDATION. PLEASED TO CO
00:33:56.167 --> 00:33:57.435
SPONSOR THIS MEASURE. THANK YOU.
00:33:57.502 --> 00:33:59.137
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH. IS
00:33:59.203 --> 00:34:03.007
THERE ANYONE ELSE? THING THEN
00:34:03.074 --> 00:34:04.475
WE'LL MOVE ON INTO ONTO
00:34:04.542 --> 00:34:06.344
OPPOSITION. IS THERE ANYBODY IN
00:34:06.411 --> 00:34:07.578
ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:34:07.645 --> 00:34:11.149
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION? SEEING THEN
00:34:11.215 --> 00:34:12.116
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
00:34:12.183 --> 00:34:14.552
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND SEE IF
00:34:14.619 --> 00:34:15.720
THERE'S ANYONE THAT WOULD LIKE
00:34:15.787 --> 00:34:17.121
TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. OF A B
00:34:17.188 --> 00:34:22.360
16 54. THANK YOU FOR NOT
00:34:22.427 --> 00:34:24.295
POSITION. YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
00:34:24.362 --> 00:34:28.032
THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT IT'S WHAT
00:34:28.099 --> 00:34:29.267
AND THEN THE EUROPEAN OPPOSITION
00:34:29.333 --> 00:34:38.009
OF A B 16 54. AND MADAM CHAIR.
00:34:38.075 --> 00:34:40.011
WE HAVE NO OPPOSITION IN CUBA AT
00:34:40.077 --> 00:34:41.078
THIS TIME. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU
00:34:41.145 --> 00:34:43.514
SO MUCH FOR BRINGING THE MATTER
00:34:43.581 --> 00:34:44.715
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE QUESTIONS.
00:34:44.782 --> 00:34:46.117
NO QUESTIONS FROM SENATOR
00:34:46.184 --> 00:34:48.653
WIECKOWSKI AND NO QUESTIONS FOR
00:34:48.719 --> 00:34:50.021
ME, EITHER OTHER THAN I'D LIKE
00:34:50.087 --> 00:34:51.889
TO BE ADDED AS A CO AUTHOR,
00:34:51.956 --> 00:34:53.758
WHEN, IF AND WHEN THE TIME IS
00:34:53.825 --> 00:34:54.325
APPROPRIATE? UM AND YOU MAY
00:34:54.392 --> 00:34:58.596
CONCLUDE. WELL I CERTAINLY WILL
00:34:58.663 --> 00:34:59.831
DO THAT AND APPRECIATE THE
00:34:59.897 --> 00:35:00.865
OPPORTUNITY HERE AND%
00:35:00.932 --> 00:35:03.067
DISRESPECTFUL ASPIRIN. I VOTE.
00:35:03.134 --> 00:35:04.135
THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:35:04.202 --> 00:35:06.103
WHEN WE GET A QUORUM WILL HAVE
00:35:06.170 --> 00:35:09.240
WILL TAKE A MOTION AND MOVE ON
00:35:09.307 --> 00:35:11.242
IT. SO THANK YOU SO MUCH, SO I
00:35:11.309 --> 00:35:14.245
UNDERSTAND, UM, ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:35:14.312 --> 00:35:16.280
Væ VALLAPUDUA IS HERE AND YOU
00:35:16.347 --> 00:35:19.350
WILL BE PRESENTING, UM ITEM
00:35:19.417 --> 00:35:20.284
NUMBER THREE FOR
00:35:20.351 --> 00:35:20.918
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALAS AS WELL.
00:35:20.985 --> 00:35:26.624
VERY GOOD. YOU ARE UP, WE'LL
00:35:26.691 --> 00:35:30.428
TAKE UP A B 9 16. THANK YOU,
00:35:30.495 --> 00:35:33.698
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. I AM
00:35:33.764 --> 00:35:36.567
PLEASED TO PRESENT A B 9 16 ON
00:35:36.634 --> 00:35:38.135
BEHALF OF SO MANY MEMBERS SALAS
00:35:38.202 --> 00:35:39.804
AND WOULD LIKE TO BEGIN BY
00:35:39.871 --> 00:35:41.038
STATING THAT THE
00:35:41.105 --> 00:35:42.039
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SELLERS ACCEPTS
00:35:42.106 --> 00:35:45.243
THE COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS. AND
00:35:45.309 --> 00:35:47.478
IS COMMITTED TO ALIGN ALIGN THIS
00:35:47.545 --> 00:35:51.015
BILL WITH SB 897 TO AVOID
00:35:51.082 --> 00:35:53.050
CHARTING OUT ISSUES. THIS BILL
00:35:53.117 --> 00:35:56.687
WILL REMOVE BARRIERS TO THE
00:35:56.754 --> 00:35:58.756
CREATION OF ACCESSORY DWELLING
00:35:58.823 --> 00:36:01.158
UNITS AND ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS
00:36:01.225 --> 00:36:03.394
WERE FACING THAT WE ARE FACING
00:36:03.461 --> 00:36:05.730
HERE IN CALIFORNIA, WITH BOTH A
00:36:05.796 --> 00:36:08.032
LACK OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AND
00:36:08.099 --> 00:36:11.769
THE PANDEMIC OF HOMELESSNESS.
00:36:11.836 --> 00:36:14.405
ENABLES THE CREATION TOO EASY,
00:36:14.472 --> 00:36:17.241
TOO EASY TO BUILD HOUSING ON
00:36:17.308 --> 00:36:18.442
LAND THAT IS ALREADY UTILIZING
00:36:18.509 --> 00:36:21.846
FOR HOUSING. THIS BRINGING DOWN
00:36:21.913 --> 00:36:23.214
THE COST OF CREATING NEW HOUSING
00:36:23.281 --> 00:36:28.853
THIS BILL WILL ALLEVIATE BURDENS
00:36:28.920 --> 00:36:31.989
TO 80 YOU CREATION IN THE STATE
00:36:32.056 --> 00:36:33.524
AND CREATE MORE HOUSING FOR LOW
00:36:33.591 --> 00:36:34.825
INCOME RESIDENTS TESTIFIED
00:36:34.892 --> 00:36:37.762
TESTIFYING REMOTELY TODAY IS
00:36:37.828 --> 00:36:40.898
CHARLES CAN WHO IS AN 80 YOU
00:36:40.965 --> 00:36:43.868
ARCHITECT IN THE STATE. VERY
00:36:43.935 --> 00:36:47.572
GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH. AND IF
00:36:47.638 --> 00:36:49.073
WE COULD GET MR CHARLES CAN ON
00:36:49.140 --> 00:36:51.976
THE LINE. I'M HERE. WELCOME.
00:36:52.043 --> 00:36:56.747
YOU'RE UP. THANK YOU, MADAM
00:36:56.814 --> 00:36:59.183
CHAIR. YES I'D LIKE TO SPEAK ON
00:36:59.250 --> 00:37:02.587
BEHALF OF EVERY 9 16. I THINK AN
00:37:02.653 --> 00:37:04.555
EARLIER SPEAKER THIS AFTERNOON
00:37:04.622 --> 00:37:06.557
MENTIONED THAT WE NEED TO ATTACK
00:37:06.624 --> 00:37:09.126
OUR HOUSING. CRISIS ON MANY
00:37:09.193 --> 00:37:10.795
FRONTS, AND THAT'S ADDRESSED
00:37:10.861 --> 00:37:14.131
THIS TWO OF THE MORE AFFORDABLE
00:37:14.198 --> 00:37:15.299
UH, EXTREMES OF HOW WE CAN
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:18.169
ATTACK THAT. CURRENTLY THE A D,
00:37:18.235 --> 00:37:23.374
U, UH I'M THE BOSS BILL AS AS
00:37:23.441 --> 00:37:25.509
PRACTICED IN THE STATE ONLY
00:37:25.576 --> 00:37:26.544
ALLOWS THE 16 FT, UH, MAXIMUM
00:37:26.611 --> 00:37:31.282
HEIGHT. THAT DOES ALLOW FOR TWO
00:37:31.349 --> 00:37:33.784
STORIES, BUT IT REQUIRES
00:37:33.851 --> 00:37:36.287
SIGNIFICANT EXCAVATION WITH THE
00:37:36.354 --> 00:37:37.355
COSTS AND ENVIRONMENTAL
00:37:37.421 --> 00:37:38.689
CHALLENGES OF OFF PULLING THIRD
00:37:38.756 --> 00:37:42.593
DOWNSIDE. AND ALSO REQUIRES YOU
00:37:42.660 --> 00:37:44.762
TO BURY THE GROUND FLOOR TWO FT
00:37:44.829 --> 00:37:46.297
BELOW GRADE, WHICH OBVIOUSLY
00:37:46.364 --> 00:37:48.566
MAKES THE SECOND CLASS UNITS,
00:37:48.633 --> 00:37:50.468
WHICH WE DON'T WANT, UH FOR MORE
00:37:50.534 --> 00:37:53.704
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SECTOR. AND
00:37:53.771 --> 00:37:56.340
IT MAKES THEM INACCESSIBLE TO
00:37:56.407 --> 00:37:57.775
PEOPLE WHO HAVE ACCESSIBILITY
00:37:57.842 --> 00:37:59.510
ISSUES WHEN THE GROUND FORCE
00:37:59.577 --> 00:38:01.712
BELOW GRADE AND UNAPPEALING AND
00:38:01.779 --> 00:38:02.780
OF COURSE, IT'S VERY EXPENSIVE,
00:38:02.847 --> 00:38:05.216
AND THAT'S A TREMENDOUS COST. TO
00:38:05.282 --> 00:38:07.985
WHAT IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE, AND
00:38:08.052 --> 00:38:09.387
SHOULD BE ONE OF THE MORE
00:38:09.453 --> 00:38:10.821
AFFORDABLE WAS PROVIDING HOUSING
00:38:10.888 --> 00:38:12.189
, WHICH IS SO DESPERATELY NEEDED
00:38:12.256 --> 00:38:13.958
IN THE STATE PARTY THAT GETS
00:38:14.025 --> 00:38:16.093
ADDED TO RUN OR SOMETIMES THE
00:38:16.160 --> 00:38:17.328
PROJECTS JUST DON'T GET BUILT.
00:38:17.395 --> 00:38:18.996
THE 18 FT HEIGHTS OF ALL OF
00:38:19.063 --> 00:38:21.232
THESE PROBLEMS IF THE POINT OF
00:38:21.298 --> 00:38:22.667
OUR LEGISLATION AT EU
00:38:22.733 --> 00:38:24.235
LEGISLATION TO ENCOURAGE THEIR
00:38:24.301 --> 00:38:25.970
CONSTRUCTION, THIS IS REALLY
00:38:26.037 --> 00:38:27.271
WHERE THE MUCH BETTER NUMBER FOR
00:38:27.338 --> 00:38:30.775
THE MAXIMUM HEIGHT UM IN TERMS
00:38:30.841 --> 00:38:32.343
OF THE ADDITIONAL BEDROOM, WHICH
00:38:32.410 --> 00:38:36.247
IS THE OTHER COMPONENT OF A B 9
00:38:36.313 --> 00:38:38.616
16. THANKFULLY IT'S A GREAT THIS
00:38:38.683 --> 00:38:40.518
IS A REALLY GREAT PART OF THE
00:38:40.584 --> 00:38:44.088
BILL. AS AN ARCHITECT. ONE OF MY
00:38:44.155 --> 00:38:46.390
FRUSTRATIONS IS THE COST OF
00:38:46.457 --> 00:38:47.825
CONSTRUCTION OF BUILDING NEW
00:38:47.892 --> 00:38:49.960
UNITS, EVEN A D S, WHICH ARE
00:38:50.027 --> 00:38:51.762
MORE FOR DOBLE TO BUILD, THEN
00:38:51.829 --> 00:38:52.997
MULTI LARGE MULTI FAMILY
00:38:53.064 --> 00:38:56.834
PROJECTS. UM. STILL COST A LOT
00:38:56.901 --> 00:38:59.770
OF MONEY TO BUILD, AND BY FAR BY
00:38:59.837 --> 00:39:02.006
FAR THE MOST ECONOMICAL SOLUTION
00:39:02.073 --> 00:39:02.940
TO THE HOUSING CRISIS, WHICH WE
00:39:03.007 --> 00:39:04.075
REALLY HAVEN'T ADDRESSED BEFORE
00:39:04.141 --> 00:39:06.343
THIS BILL, BUT FOR BAD EVEN
00:39:06.410 --> 00:39:08.879
BETTER THAN EIGHT YEARS. IS
00:39:08.946 --> 00:39:10.181
ALLOWING ADDITIONAL BEDROOMS TO
00:39:10.247 --> 00:39:13.417
BE BUILT AND CURRENTLY OVERSIZED
00:39:13.484 --> 00:39:15.086
UNITS THAT WE HAVE THROUGHOUT
00:39:15.152 --> 00:39:16.587
THE STATE. YOU'VE ALREADY GOT
00:39:16.654 --> 00:39:18.522
YOUR ROOF. YOUR FOUNDATION, YOUR
00:39:18.589 --> 00:39:19.523
UTILITIES, YOUR BATHROOM YOUR
00:39:19.590 --> 00:39:20.624
KITCHEN ALREADY THERE. YOU DON'T
00:39:20.691 --> 00:39:22.526
HAVE TO PAY FOR ALL THAT, AND
00:39:22.593 --> 00:39:25.262
IT'S CORRECT. OR IT SHOULD BE IN
00:39:25.329 --> 00:39:26.630
CITIES AND COUNTIES THAT REQUIRE
00:39:26.697 --> 00:39:27.932
PUBLIC HEARINGS, THOUGH
00:39:27.998 --> 00:39:28.933
APPLICANTS CAN EXPERIENCE A YEAR
00:39:28.999 --> 00:39:31.836
OR MORE DELAYS. IS FRANKLY
00:39:31.902 --> 00:39:33.137
DISCOURAGING OWNERS FROM
00:39:33.204 --> 00:39:34.405
CONVERTING EXTRA SPACE AND
00:39:34.472 --> 00:39:35.506
THEY'RE BUILDING MUCH NEEDED
00:39:35.573 --> 00:39:38.976
BEDROOMS. SO IF WE REALLY WANT
00:39:39.043 --> 00:39:39.944
TO SOLVE THE HOUSING CRISIS, WE
00:39:40.010 --> 00:39:41.879
HAVE TO ATTACK IT ON ALL FRONTS.
00:39:41.946 --> 00:39:44.615
LARGE PROJECTS, SMALL PROJECTS
00:39:44.682 --> 00:39:47.318
AND MAKING IT EASIER FOR
00:39:47.384 --> 00:39:48.619
INDIVIDUAL VETERANS TO BE
00:39:48.686 --> 00:39:50.321
PROVIDED AND EXISTING UNITS AND
00:39:50.387 --> 00:39:51.455
I'M AVAILABLE FOR ANY QUESTIONS
00:39:51.522 --> 00:39:53.124
THE COMMITTEE MAY HAVE THANK YOU
00:39:53.190 --> 00:39:56.560
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE IN IN
00:39:56.627 --> 00:39:57.795
THE COMMITTEE ROOM THAT WOULD
00:39:57.862 --> 00:40:01.499
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT?
00:40:01.565 --> 00:40:02.566
MICHAEL LINE WAS SPUR AND
00:40:02.633 --> 00:40:08.005
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:40:08.072 --> 00:40:09.840
HOLLY FOR MANY DAYS, USE OF
00:40:09.907 --> 00:40:10.808
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ON
00:40:10.875 --> 00:40:12.009
BEHALF OF CIVIC WELL AND ACTION
00:40:12.076 --> 00:40:15.646
AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU. JORDAN
00:40:15.713 --> 00:40:16.847
PLANET CARVER HARD ON BEHALF OF
00:40:16.914 --> 00:40:17.448
CALIFORNIA, MAYBE IN SUPPORT.
00:40:17.515 --> 00:40:19.784
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
00:40:19.850 --> 00:40:25.256
ANYONE ELSE? NOW WE'RE GOING TO
00:40:25.322 --> 00:40:26.323
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
00:40:26.390 --> 00:40:28.392
LINE. IS THERE ANYBODY ON THE
00:40:28.459 --> 00:40:28.993
TELE TELECONFERENCE LINE THAT
00:40:29.059 --> 00:40:30.561
WOULD LIKE TO SEE, UM TESTIFY IN
00:40:30.628 --> 00:40:35.833
SUPPORT OF A B 9 16? THANK YOU.
00:40:35.900 --> 00:40:38.202
IF YOU'RE IN SUPPORT OF A B 9 16
00:40:38.269 --> 00:40:42.139
YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:40:42.206 --> 00:40:43.340
AGAIN THAT IT'S ONE AND THEN
00:40:43.407 --> 00:40:47.344
ZERO FEAR AND SUPPORT. WE WILL
00:40:47.411 --> 00:40:49.480
GO TO THE LINE TO 65. YOUR LINE
00:40:49.547 --> 00:40:54.185
IS OPEN. AFTERNOON SO BE IT.
00:40:54.251 --> 00:40:55.219
POLICE SHOT ON BEHALF OF THE
00:40:55.286 --> 00:40:57.087
CITY OF SANTA MONICA AND SUPPORT
00:40:57.154 --> 00:41:01.258
THANK YOU. THANK YOU NEXT TO GO
00:41:01.325 --> 00:41:02.493
LINE UP TO 54. YOUR LINE IS
00:41:02.560 --> 00:41:06.030
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM
00:41:06.096 --> 00:41:07.631
CHAIR. REMEMBER KATE BELL ON
00:41:07.698 --> 00:41:09.333
BEHALF OF CALORIE DAY AND
00:41:09.400 --> 00:41:10.334
TAGLINE, STRONG SUPPORT. THANK
00:41:10.401 --> 00:41:15.372
YOU. THANK YOU NEXT TO THE LINE
00:41:15.439 --> 00:41:18.142
OF TO 62. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:41:18.209 --> 00:41:19.677
GOOD AFTERNOON. I'M TRYING
00:41:19.743 --> 00:41:21.712
MEMBERS. A LIST IS SO HIGH ON
00:41:21.779 --> 00:41:23.647
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA ROSA
00:41:23.714 --> 00:41:28.285
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT U
00:41:28.352 --> 00:41:30.254
THE LINE OF 2 52 YEAR LINE IS
00:41:30.321 --> 00:41:36.760
OPEN. LINE TO 50 TO YOUR LINE IS
00:41:36.827 --> 00:41:43.868
OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. AFTER
00:41:43.934 --> 00:41:52.276
THAT, YOU PLEASE GO AHEAD. OKAY
00:41:52.343 --> 00:41:53.844
MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE NO FOR THE
00:41:53.911 --> 00:41:56.180
SUPPORTING QUÊ AT THIS TIME.
00:41:56.247 --> 00:41:57.648
GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE
00:41:57.715 --> 00:41:59.483
GOING TO SEE IF THERE IS ANY
00:41:59.550 --> 00:42:00.651
TESTIMONY AND OPPOSITION. HERE
00:42:00.718 --> 00:42:06.523
IN ROOM 2100. SEEING NONE WILL
00:42:06.590 --> 00:42:06.991
WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:42:07.057 --> 00:42:08.392
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:42:08.459 --> 00:42:09.460
ANYBODY ON THE TELEPHONE
00:42:09.526 --> 00:42:13.230
CONFERENCE LINE IN OPPOSITION?
00:42:13.297 --> 00:42:14.598
THANK YOU FOR YOUR NOT POSITION
00:42:14.665 --> 00:42:18.469
OF A BABY. 9 16. YOU MAY PRESS
00:42:18.535 --> 00:42:22.072
THE ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
00:42:22.139 --> 00:42:24.074
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO IF
00:42:24.141 --> 00:42:27.311
YOU'RE IN OPPOSITION WE'VE GOT
00:42:27.378 --> 00:42:32.516
TO LINE UP TO 66 LINE IS OPEN.
00:42:32.583 --> 00:42:34.919
CHAIR MEMBERS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:42:34.985 --> 00:42:36.353
BEVERLY HILTON. RESPECTFUL
00:42:36.420 --> 00:42:37.388
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:42:37.454 --> 00:42:41.292
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. WE'LL GO
00:42:41.358 --> 00:42:44.628
TO LINE 2 43. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
00:42:44.695 --> 00:42:45.896
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM SHARON
00:42:45.963 --> 00:42:47.331
MEMBERS DURING THEM BOULDERS ON
00:42:47.398 --> 00:42:49.633
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF RANCHO
00:42:49.700 --> 00:42:50.567
PALOS VERDES RESPECTFULLY IN
00:42:50.634 --> 00:42:52.670
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:42:52.736 --> 00:42:56.040
THANK YOU. UM MADAM CHAIR. WE
00:42:56.106 --> 00:42:57.808
HAVE NO FURTHER POSITIONING QUÊ
00:42:57.875 --> 00:43:00.277
AT THIS TIME. VERY GOOD. THANK
00:43:00.344 --> 00:43:01.445
YOU SO MUCH. WE'LL BRING THIS
00:43:01.512 --> 00:43:03.380
BACK TO COMMITTEE. FOR COMMENTS
00:43:03.447 --> 00:43:08.552
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS. I SEE. I
00:43:08.619 --> 00:43:11.722
SEE NONE SO YOU MAY CONCLUDE.
00:43:11.789 --> 00:43:13.524
THANK YOU, MADAM. CHAIR MEMBERS.
00:43:13.590 --> 00:43:14.625
THIS BILL HAS RECEIVED NO NO
00:43:14.692 --> 00:43:16.293
VOTES. AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:43:16.360 --> 00:43:19.663
FOR MY VOTE. VERY GOOD WHEN WE
00:43:19.730 --> 00:43:23.000
GET A QUORUM WILL TAKE A MOTION
00:43:23.067 --> 00:43:26.036
UP AND WORK ON THAT. THANK YOU.
00:43:26.103 --> 00:43:28.305
YOUR ITEM NUMBER EIGHT IS UP. IF
00:43:28.372 --> 00:43:31.542
YOU'RE HERE, SO IT MIGHT AS WELL
00:43:31.608 --> 00:43:33.143
OKAY AHEAD AND DO IT. THANK YOU.
00:43:33.210 --> 00:43:35.179
THAT'S A GOOD WAY TO GET AT THE
00:43:35.245 --> 00:43:37.014
FRONT OF THE LINE. YOU
00:43:37.081 --> 00:43:38.148
VOLUNTEERED TO DO SOMEONE ELSE'S
00:43:38.215 --> 00:43:39.316
BILL, AND THERE YOU ARE. THANK
00:43:39.383 --> 00:43:44.021
YOU, MADAM. A B. UH 2002. THANK
00:43:44.088 --> 00:43:44.989
YOU. THANK YOU, MADAM. CHAIR
00:43:45.055 --> 00:43:47.057
MEMBERS. FIRST I WANT TO START
00:43:47.124 --> 00:43:48.759
BY THANKING YOU AND YOUR STAFF
00:43:48.826 --> 00:43:50.227
ARE WORKING WITH MY OFFICE ON
00:43:50.294 --> 00:43:52.296
THIS BILL AND ACCEPT ALL THE
00:43:52.363 --> 00:43:54.498
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. CALIFORNIA
00:43:54.565 --> 00:43:56.967
IS A IS IN A HOUSING CRISIS IN
00:43:57.034 --> 00:44:00.471
THE MOBILE HOMES ARE ON. UM
00:44:00.537 --> 00:44:02.339
OBTAINABLE FORM OF HOUSING FOR
00:44:02.406 --> 00:44:04.375
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE
00:44:04.441 --> 00:44:06.477
THERE ARE OVER 5200 PARKS WITH
00:44:06.543 --> 00:44:13.283
MORE THAN 3000. 7 378,000 SPACES
00:44:13.350 --> 00:44:14.518
THAT CURRENTLY HOUSED OVER 707
00:44:14.585 --> 00:44:18.355
100,000 PEOPLE. MAYBE 200 TO
00:44:18.422 --> 00:44:22.693
CREATE A FUN. IN THE DEPARTMENT
00:44:22.760 --> 00:44:24.228
OF HOUSING, COMMUNITY AND
00:44:24.294 --> 00:44:28.132
DEVELOPMENT TO HELP UH FIXED
00:44:28.198 --> 00:44:30.300
VIOLATIONS, LET THEM STAY IN
00:44:30.367 --> 00:44:32.136
THEIR HOMES AND AVOID EVICTIONS
00:44:32.202 --> 00:44:33.704
UNDER THIS BILL RESIDENTS AND
00:44:33.771 --> 00:44:37.608
PARK OWNERS CAN KEN MORE EASILY
00:44:37.674 --> 00:44:40.511
WORKED TOGETHER TO ACCESS FUNDS
00:44:40.577 --> 00:44:42.012
TO FIX ISSUES THAT WOULD
00:44:42.079 --> 00:44:43.847
POTENTIALLY RESULT IN THE
00:44:43.914 --> 00:44:44.648
RESIDENTS EVICTIONS OR
00:44:44.715 --> 00:44:45.849
JEOPARDIZE A PARK ABILITY TO
00:44:45.916 --> 00:44:49.186
OPERATE. WITH ME TODAY TO
00:44:49.253 --> 00:44:53.557
TESTIFY AT SP 202 IS CHRIS WAS
00:44:53.624 --> 00:44:55.526
SOCKS WAS SASKIA WITH WESTERN
00:44:55.592 --> 00:44:56.760
MANUFACTURED HOUSING COMMUNITIES
00:44:56.827 --> 00:44:59.663
ASSOCIATIONS? AND JASON OCCURRED
00:44:59.730 --> 00:45:00.798
REPRESENTING THE CALIFORNIA
00:45:00.864 --> 00:45:02.666
MOBILE PARK LINES. THANK YOU
00:45:02.733 --> 00:45:09.540
VERY MUCH WELCOME. THANK YOU,
00:45:09.606 --> 00:45:10.441
MADAM CHAIR AND THANK YOU.
00:45:10.507 --> 00:45:12.509
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MY NAME'S CHRIS
00:45:12.576 --> 00:45:14.745
WEITZ SAKE WITH W M A. WE WANT
00:45:14.812 --> 00:45:16.380
TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR HIS HARD
00:45:16.447 --> 00:45:18.282
WORK ON THIS BILL AND ALSO THE
00:45:18.348 --> 00:45:19.383
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR EVERYTHING
00:45:19.450 --> 00:45:21.885
THAT THEY'VE DONE. TO MOVE THIS
00:45:21.952 --> 00:45:24.988
BALL DOWN THE FIELD. THE NUMBER
00:45:25.055 --> 00:45:26.256
ONE GOAL OF MY MANUFACTURED
00:45:26.323 --> 00:45:28.892
HOUSING IS TO ACTUALLY ACHIEVE
00:45:28.959 --> 00:45:30.494
AFFORDABLE AND ATTAINABLE
00:45:30.561 --> 00:45:32.329
HOUSING, AND THAT'S WHAT A B
00:45:32.396 --> 00:45:35.632
2002 IS REALLY INTENDED TO DO.
00:45:35.699 --> 00:45:36.900
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT MOBILE
00:45:36.967 --> 00:45:38.669
HOME PARK OWNERS AND RESIDENTS
00:45:38.735 --> 00:45:40.337
HAVE THE ABILITY TO WORK
00:45:40.404 --> 00:45:42.372
TOGETHER TO CREATE SOLUTIONS TO
00:45:42.439 --> 00:45:43.740
PROBLEMS THAT MAY ULTIMATELY END
00:45:43.807 --> 00:45:47.211
AN EVICTION. IF THEY ARE CITED
00:45:47.277 --> 00:45:49.546
BY H CD OR THE LOCAL ENFORCEMENT
00:45:49.613 --> 00:45:52.683
AGENCY, MAYBE 20 OH, TO CREATE A
00:45:52.749 --> 00:45:54.685
MOBILE HAIR MOBILE HOME REPAIR
00:45:54.751 --> 00:45:58.122
GRANT FUNDS. WE HAVE A $98
00:45:58.188 --> 00:46:01.125
BILLION SURPLUS. WE THINK USING
00:46:01.191 --> 00:46:02.659
SOME OF THAT SURPLUS IS A GOOD
00:46:02.726 --> 00:46:05.262
IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO ALLOW SOME
00:46:05.329 --> 00:46:07.297
OF THAT MONEY TO BE USED TO KEEP
00:46:07.364 --> 00:46:08.899
ROOFS OVER HEADS, AND THAT'S
00:46:08.966 --> 00:46:11.335
WHAT A B 22 ATTEMPTS TO DO. IN
00:46:11.401 --> 00:46:12.503
THIS BUDGET. A, UH, VOTED FOR
00:46:12.569 --> 00:46:16.740
TODAY. $100 MILLION WAS
00:46:16.807 --> 00:46:18.775
ALLOCATED TO REPAIR MOBILE HOME
00:46:18.842 --> 00:46:21.545
PARKS. THE HOPE IS THAT SOME OF
00:46:21.612 --> 00:46:22.913
THAT MONEY CAN BE USED TO HELP
00:46:22.980 --> 00:46:25.716
FIND HCG AND THE ELIA'S TO
00:46:25.782 --> 00:46:27.651
ACTUALLY FUND THIS MOBILE HOME
00:46:27.718 --> 00:46:28.752
REPAIR GRANT FUND. FIRST.
00:46:28.819 --> 00:46:34.057
SECONDLY, UM, MOBILE HOME PARK
00:46:34.124 --> 00:46:35.192
OWNERS AND RESIDENTS OFTEN WORK
00:46:35.259 --> 00:46:39.096
TOGETHER. I STILL THINK THAT
00:46:39.163 --> 00:46:40.330
THERE IS A FALSE NARRATIVE OUT
00:46:40.397 --> 00:46:43.233
THERE THAT RESIDENTS AND PARK
00:46:43.300 --> 00:46:44.334
OWNERS HAVE THIS TREMENDOUS
00:46:44.401 --> 00:46:48.138
DISAGREEMENT. IF A PARK OWNER IS
00:46:48.205 --> 00:46:52.009
NOTIFIED PROPERLY. OF A RESIDENT
00:46:52.075 --> 00:46:54.745
VIOLATION. THEY HAVE THE ABILITY
00:46:54.811 --> 00:46:56.413
TO WORK TOGETHER TO FIX THE
00:46:56.480 --> 00:46:59.283
PROBLEM. RIGHT NOW WE'RE OFTEN
00:46:59.349 --> 00:47:01.084
AS MOBILE HOME PARK OWNERS. WE
00:47:01.151 --> 00:47:02.352
OFTEN DON'T EVEN KNOW THAT THERE
00:47:02.419 --> 00:47:04.021
IS A VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED.
00:47:04.087 --> 00:47:06.456
UNTIL 60 DAYS AFTER THE AFTER
00:47:06.523 --> 00:47:09.993
THE RESIDENT HAS BEEN NOTIFIED.
00:47:10.060 --> 00:47:11.528
THAT LEAVES US NO OPTION WITH
00:47:11.595 --> 00:47:13.630
OTHER THAN PROVIDING AN EVICTION
00:47:13.697 --> 00:47:15.632
NOTICE ON ON THE ON THE
00:47:15.699 --> 00:47:18.702
RESIDENTS. A B 20 OH, TO
00:47:18.769 --> 00:47:21.205
EXPEDITES THE PROCESS, AND IT'LL
00:47:21.271 --> 00:47:23.307
ACTUALLY MAKE IT EASIER FOR
00:47:23.373 --> 00:47:24.775
RESIDENTS AND MOBILE HOME PARK
00:47:24.841 --> 00:47:26.210
OWNERS TO WORK TOGETHER AND
00:47:26.276 --> 00:47:27.244
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FOR
00:47:27.311 --> 00:47:29.913
INTRODUCING THE BILL. AND WE
00:47:29.980 --> 00:47:32.149
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING TO KEEP
00:47:32.216 --> 00:47:33.183
THE BALL MOVING DOWN THE FIELD.
00:47:33.250 --> 00:47:36.954
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:47:37.020 --> 00:47:38.455
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:47:38.522 --> 00:47:40.090
MEMBERS JASON AKER ON BEHALF OF
00:47:40.157 --> 00:47:42.326
THE CALIFORNIA MOBILE HOME PARK
00:47:42.392 --> 00:47:43.193
OWNERS ALLIANCE JUST TO BE VERY
00:47:43.260 --> 00:47:45.062
BRIEF AGAIN WANT TO EXPRESS OUR
00:47:45.128 --> 00:47:46.063
APPRECIATION FOR THE
00:47:46.129 --> 00:47:46.663
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FOR AUTHORING
00:47:46.730 --> 00:47:49.099
THE BILL AS WELL? AS YOU JUST
00:47:49.166 --> 00:47:50.500
HEARD FROM MR Y SAKE, PARK
00:47:50.567 --> 00:47:52.703
OWNERS WHEN A RESIDENT HAS A
00:47:52.769 --> 00:47:55.005
VIOLATION, UNFORTUNATELY, THEIR
00:47:55.072 --> 00:47:56.807
ONLY REAL RECOURSES TO EVICT
00:47:56.873 --> 00:47:57.975
THAT RESIDENT IF IT'S NOT BEING
00:47:58.041 --> 00:48:00.143
ADDRESSED. NO ONE REALLY WANTS
00:48:00.210 --> 00:48:01.311
TO BE DOING THAT. I MEAN,
00:48:01.378 --> 00:48:02.980
BLUNTLY. IT'S BAD BUSINESS FOR
00:48:03.046 --> 00:48:04.248
THE PARK OWNER, BUT IT'S ALSO
00:48:04.314 --> 00:48:05.415
NOT A GREAT THING FOR THE
00:48:05.482 --> 00:48:07.184
RESIDENT OBVIOUSLY TO HAVE A
00:48:07.251 --> 00:48:08.685
MINOR VIOLATION AND A PROBLEM ON
00:48:08.752 --> 00:48:10.454
THEIR PROPERTY. KEEP THEM OUT OF
00:48:10.520 --> 00:48:12.189
THEIR HOME. AND SO WE THINK IT
00:48:12.256 --> 00:48:13.857
IS AN EXCELLENT IDEA IS, MR Y.
00:48:13.924 --> 00:48:15.325
SAKE SAID, TO PROVIDE SOME SORT
00:48:15.392 --> 00:48:17.694
OF RELIEF SO THAT RATHER THAN
00:48:17.761 --> 00:48:18.962
HAVING A SUSPENDED PTO PERMIT TO
00:48:19.029 --> 00:48:20.664
OPERATE OVER YOUR HEAD, YOU HAVE
00:48:20.731 --> 00:48:22.032
THE ABILITY TO HELP YOUR
00:48:22.099 --> 00:48:24.101
RESIDENT BIND RESOURCES FROM THE
00:48:24.167 --> 00:48:25.602
STATE AND FIXED THE ISSUE. FOR
00:48:25.669 --> 00:48:27.070
THAT REASON, WE'RE GLAD TO BE
00:48:27.137 --> 00:48:29.006
HERE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL, DR
00:48:29.072 --> 00:48:31.208
Ó. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
00:48:31.275 --> 00:48:32.509
THERE ANYONE ELSE IN ROOM 2100
00:48:32.576 --> 00:48:34.411
THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY AND
00:48:34.478 --> 00:48:38.015
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. SEEING THEN
00:48:38.081 --> 00:48:39.416
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
00:48:39.483 --> 00:48:40.183
TELECONFERENCE LINE. IS THERE
00:48:40.250 --> 00:48:41.218
ANYBODY ON THE TELECONFERENCE
00:48:41.285 --> 00:48:43.654
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO GIVE
00:48:43.720 --> 00:48:47.524
TESTIMONY ON A B 20 20,002?
00:48:47.591 --> 00:48:49.660
THANK YOU IF YOU'RE IN SUPPORT
00:48:49.726 --> 00:48:52.696
OF A B 20 OH, TWO. YOU MAY PRESS
00:48:52.763 --> 00:48:56.400
ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS
00:48:56.466 --> 00:48:58.235
ONE AND THEN ZERO HERE AND
00:48:58.302 --> 00:49:03.807
SUPPORT. AND MADAM CHAIR. WE
00:49:03.874 --> 00:49:05.175
HAVE NO SUPPORTING QUÊ AT THIS
00:49:05.242 --> 00:49:07.311
TIME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE
00:49:07.377 --> 00:49:08.478
GOING TO MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION.
00:49:08.545 --> 00:49:10.280
THERE IS NO LEAD OPPOSITION.
00:49:10.347 --> 00:49:13.150
NOTED. SO WE'LL SEE IF THERE'S
00:49:13.216 --> 00:49:15.552
ANYBODY IN ROOM. 2100 THAT WOULD
00:49:15.619 --> 00:49:19.656
LIKE TO SPEAK IN OPPOSITION.
00:49:19.723 --> 00:49:20.857
THAT'S A NEW CHAIR MEMBERS BRADY
00:49:20.924 --> 00:49:22.426
GOING ON BEHALF OF THE
00:49:22.492 --> 00:49:23.527
CALIFORNIA BUILDING OFFICIALS I
00:49:23.593 --> 00:49:25.295
WANTED TO SAY WE REMOVED OUR
00:49:25.362 --> 00:49:26.330
OPPOSITION WERE NEUTRAL ON IT.
00:49:26.396 --> 00:49:27.397
SO THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS WAS
00:49:27.464 --> 00:49:29.366
DIDN'T HAVE THAT UPDATED, BUT WE
00:49:29.433 --> 00:49:30.367
APPRECIATED THE UPDATE THE
00:49:30.434 --> 00:49:32.336
AMENDMENTS AND AS LONG AS
00:49:32.402 --> 00:49:33.270
THERE'S AN IMMINENT DANGER TO
00:49:33.337 --> 00:49:35.305
HEALTH AND SAFETY. WE'RE OKAY
00:49:35.372 --> 00:49:36.206
WITH IT. SO WANTED TO SAY WE'VE
00:49:36.273 --> 00:49:38.742
MOVED TO NEUTRAL ON THE BILL. SO
00:49:38.809 --> 00:49:40.043
THANK YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FOR
00:49:40.110 --> 00:49:40.644
TAKING THOSE AMENDMENTS. VERY
00:49:40.711 --> 00:49:42.145
GOOD. AND THANK YOU FOR BEING
00:49:42.212 --> 00:49:43.814
HERE TODAY. APPRECIATE IT VERY
00:49:43.880 --> 00:49:44.581
MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE ELSE THAT
00:49:44.648 --> 00:49:46.316
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
00:49:46.383 --> 00:49:47.317
OPPOSITION OR REMOVE THEIR
00:49:47.384 --> 00:49:49.753
OPPOSITION? HERE IN THE ROOM,
00:49:49.820 --> 00:49:51.455
SEEING NONE WILL MOVE ON TO THE
00:49:51.521 --> 00:49:52.322
TELECONFERENCE LINE. MADAM
00:49:52.389 --> 00:49:54.257
MODERATOR, IF YOU COULD PROMPT
00:49:54.324 --> 00:49:54.958
AND SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY ON
00:49:55.025 --> 00:49:56.993
THE LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:49:57.060 --> 00:49:58.061
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION. TO THIS
00:49:58.128 --> 00:50:02.165
BILL. THANK YOU IF YOU'RE NOT
00:50:02.232 --> 00:50:04.768
POSITION OF A B 20 OH, TWO. YOU
00:50:04.835 --> 00:50:08.939
MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:50:09.005 --> 00:50:10.207
AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
00:50:10.273 --> 00:50:16.546
IF YOU'RE NOT POSITION. AND
00:50:16.613 --> 00:50:18.548
MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
00:50:18.615 --> 00:50:19.516
POSITIONING QUÊ AT THIS TIME.
00:50:19.583 --> 00:50:21.685
VERY GOOD. WE'LL BRING THE ISSUE
00:50:21.752 --> 00:50:22.919
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE AND SEE IF
00:50:22.986 --> 00:50:23.553
THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS. SEEING
00:50:23.620 --> 00:50:30.660
NONE. UM ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
00:50:30.727 --> 00:50:32.562
VALLAPUDUA. YOU MAY CONCLUDE.
00:50:32.629 --> 00:50:33.697
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
00:50:33.764 --> 00:50:34.564
RESPECTIVELY ASKED FOR NAVAL.
00:50:34.631 --> 00:50:37.534
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
00:50:37.601 --> 00:50:39.169
AGAIN WE WILL TAKE THIS UP WHEN
00:50:39.236 --> 00:50:50.280
WE GET A QUORUM. AND WE'RE READY
00:50:50.347 --> 00:51:03.260
TO MOVE ON TO THE NEXT.
00:51:03.326 --> 00:51:05.729
VERY GOOD. WE WILL TAKE UP THE
00:51:05.796 --> 00:51:08.698
NEXT BILL, WHICH IS A B 17 19 BY
00:51:08.765 --> 00:51:17.974
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD. WELCOME.
00:51:18.041 --> 00:51:19.576
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:51:19.643 --> 00:51:22.612
MEMBERS UNDER FEDERAL LAW IF A
00:51:22.679 --> 00:51:23.647
RESIDENTIAL UNIT IS PROVIDED BY
00:51:23.713 --> 00:51:25.182
AN EMPLOYER FOR ITS EMPLOYEES,
00:51:25.248 --> 00:51:27.317
THE UNIT IS NOT FOR USE BY THE
00:51:27.384 --> 00:51:28.585
PUBLIC AND IS NOT ELIGIBLE FOR
00:51:28.652 --> 00:51:31.021
AFFORDABLE TAX CREDITS. IN 2019
00:51:31.087 --> 00:51:31.888
. THE LEGISLATURE IS YOU KNOW,
00:51:31.955 --> 00:51:33.523
PAST THE 33 O, EIGHT, WHICH
00:51:33.590 --> 00:51:35.525
CLARIFIED THAT A SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:51:35.592 --> 00:51:37.093
COULD LIMIT THE HOUSING TWO
00:51:37.160 --> 00:51:38.562
EMPLOYEES OF THE DISTRICT AND
00:51:38.628 --> 00:51:39.663
STILL BE ELIGIBLE FOR THE
00:51:39.729 --> 00:51:40.864
AFFORDABLE HOUSING TAX CREDIT.
00:51:40.931 --> 00:51:43.800
HOWEVER A B 33 33 OH, EIGHT DID
00:51:43.867 --> 00:51:45.302
NOT INCLUDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:51:45.368 --> 00:51:48.305
DISTRICT. SO THIS BILL, A B 17
00:51:48.371 --> 00:51:49.306
19 WOULD ALLOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:51:49.372 --> 00:51:51.308
DISTRICTS, THE ABILITY TO MANAGE
00:51:51.374 --> 00:51:52.142
AFFORDABLE HOUSING UNITS FOR
00:51:52.209 --> 00:51:53.210
STUDENTS AND STAFF AND THE
00:51:53.276 --> 00:51:54.311
OPPORTUNITY TO APPLY FOR
00:51:54.377 --> 00:51:56.980
NECESSARY TAX CREDITS. THE BILL
00:51:57.047 --> 00:51:57.881
WILL ALLOW COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:51:57.948 --> 00:51:59.149
DISTRICTS WITH THE APPROPRIATE
00:51:59.216 --> 00:52:00.951
EXISTING LAND AND RESOURCES TO
00:52:01.017 --> 00:52:02.552
BE ACTIVE MEMBERS AND ADDRESSING
00:52:02.619 --> 00:52:04.688
CALIFORNIA'S EXACERBATED HOUSING
00:52:04.754 --> 00:52:06.890
CRISIS. I WOULD LIKE TO THANK
00:52:06.957 --> 00:52:08.258
THE OPPOSITION FOR REACHING OUT
00:52:08.325 --> 00:52:09.259
AND CONTINUING TO WORK WITH MY
00:52:09.326 --> 00:52:11.428
STAFF TO ADDRESS THEIR CONCERNS,
00:52:11.495 --> 00:52:12.095
AND WE ARE DEDICATING TO
00:52:12.162 --> 00:52:13.563
CONTINUING THOSE CONVERSATIONS.
00:52:13.630 --> 00:52:15.065
I'D LIKE TO PRESENT MY WITNESSES
00:52:15.131 --> 00:52:16.066
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL MARK
00:52:16.132 --> 00:52:17.334
MCDONALD, REPRESENTING THE SAN
00:52:17.400 --> 00:52:18.335
DIEGO COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:52:18.401 --> 00:52:23.640
DISTRICT. VERY GOOD. WELCOME.
00:52:23.707 --> 00:52:25.709
THANK YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS AND
00:52:25.775 --> 00:52:26.977
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD FOR
00:52:27.043 --> 00:52:31.147
CARRYING THE BILL. THE BILL. UM
00:52:31.214 --> 00:52:32.883
THE ANALYSIS LAYS OUT PRETTY
00:52:32.949 --> 00:52:36.586
WELL WHAT THE BILL DOES IT
00:52:36.653 --> 00:52:38.889
SIMPLY EXPANDS A K 12 PROGRAM
00:52:38.955 --> 00:52:40.590
THROUGH COMMUNITY COLLEGES TO
00:52:40.657 --> 00:52:41.625
ENABLE COMMUNITY COLLEGES TO
00:52:41.691 --> 00:52:44.127
HELP THEIR EMPLOYEES. BETTER
00:52:44.194 --> 00:52:46.630
AFFORD HOUSING THAT IS NEAR THE
00:52:46.696 --> 00:52:49.533
CAMPUSES. IT WOULD PROVIDE A
00:52:49.599 --> 00:52:52.068
TOOL FOR COMMUNITY COLLEGES TO
00:52:52.135 --> 00:52:56.106
HELP. ALSO UM UM, GET.
00:52:56.172 --> 00:52:58.775
INCENTIVES TO EMPLOYEES TO COME
00:52:58.842 --> 00:53:00.710
TO THE COLLEGE AND WORK SO WE
00:53:00.777 --> 00:53:02.646
WOULD URGE YOUR SUPPORT OF THE
00:53:02.712 --> 00:53:03.280
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
00:53:03.346 --> 00:53:07.651
MUCH. THERE ANYONE ELSE IN
00:53:07.717 --> 00:53:09.452
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
00:53:09.519 --> 00:53:11.321
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL? IF SO,
00:53:11.388 --> 00:53:15.992
PLEASE COME FORWARD. GOOD
00:53:16.059 --> 00:53:17.527
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR JANICE,
00:53:17.594 --> 00:53:18.194
NORMALLY WITH THE AMERICAN
00:53:18.261 --> 00:53:19.729
FEDERATION OF STATE COUNTY
00:53:19.796 --> 00:53:20.597
MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES ASKED ME
00:53:20.664 --> 00:53:21.598
CALIFORNIA AND SUPPORT. THANK
00:53:21.665 --> 00:53:26.102
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GOOD
00:53:26.169 --> 00:53:28.004
AFTERNOON CÁC MANCINI ON BEHALF
00:53:28.071 --> 00:53:29.239
OF THE CALIFORNIA SCHOOL
00:53:29.306 --> 00:53:30.473
EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION AND
00:53:30.540 --> 00:53:34.077
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS
00:53:34.144 --> 00:53:38.515
THERE ANYONE ELSE? SEEING THEN
00:53:38.582 --> 00:53:39.349
WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE
00:53:39.416 --> 00:53:41.017
TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASKED
00:53:41.084 --> 00:53:43.086
THE MODERATOR TO QUEUE UP
00:53:43.153 --> 00:53:44.955
INDIVIDUALS THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:53:45.021 --> 00:53:48.658
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 19.
00:53:48.725 --> 00:53:50.193
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF A
00:53:50.260 --> 00:53:56.766
B 17 19 YEAR BY PRESS 10. AGAIN
00:53:56.833 --> 00:53:58.501
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO
00:53:58.568 --> 00:54:04.574
SUPPORT OF A B 17 19. AND ONE
00:54:04.641 --> 00:54:06.176
JUST QUEUED UP. ONE MOMENT WILL
00:54:06.242 --> 00:54:11.147
WHY WE GIVE THEIR LINE NUMBER.
00:54:11.214 --> 00:54:12.916
JUST A REMINDER. WE ARE ON
00:54:12.983 --> 00:54:18.021
SUPPORT OF A B 17 19. AND WE
00:54:18.088 --> 00:54:20.757
WILL GO TO A LINE OF 2 74. YOUR
00:54:20.824 --> 00:54:24.294
LINE IS OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON.
00:54:24.361 --> 00:54:25.829
THIS IS INTEGRATION, CALLING ON
00:54:25.895 --> 00:54:27.697
BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY COLLEGE
00:54:27.764 --> 00:54:28.598
LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA IN SUPPORT.
00:54:28.665 --> 00:54:30.033
THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:54:30.100 --> 00:54:32.936
THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR. WE HAVE
00:54:33.003 --> 00:54:35.271
NO FURTHER IMPORTANT QUÊ. THANK
00:54:35.338 --> 00:54:36.940
YOU VERY MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO
00:54:37.007 --> 00:54:38.208
MOVE ON TO OPPOSITION. THERE IS
00:54:38.274 --> 00:54:39.876
NO LEAD OPPOSITION LISTED, SO
00:54:39.943 --> 00:54:41.378
WE'LL SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN
00:54:41.444 --> 00:54:43.780
ROOM 2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO
00:54:43.847 --> 00:54:44.848
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION OF THIS
00:54:44.914 --> 00:54:47.584
BILL. SAYING NONE WILL MOVE TO
00:54:47.651 --> 00:54:49.686
THE TELECONFERENCE LINE AND ASK
00:54:49.753 --> 00:54:51.287
IF THERE'S ANYBODY THAT WOULD
00:54:51.354 --> 00:54:52.722
LIKE TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO
00:54:52.789 --> 00:54:57.260
A B 17 19. IF YOU'RE NOT
00:54:57.327 --> 00:54:59.529
POSITION OF A B 17 19 YOU MAY
00:54:59.596 --> 00:55:04.534
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. THAT IS
00:55:04.601 --> 00:55:06.670
ONE AND THEN ZERO FOR AN
00:55:06.736 --> 00:55:10.807
OPPOSITION OF A B 17 19. AND WE
00:55:10.874 --> 00:55:12.676
HAVE NO OPPOSITION IN CUBA AT
00:55:12.742 --> 00:55:14.911
THIS TIME, MADAM. THANK YOU VERY
00:55:14.978 --> 00:55:16.746
MUCH. WE'LL BRING THIS BACK TO
00:55:16.813 --> 00:55:18.615
THE COMMITTEE FOR QUESTIONS OR
00:55:18.682 --> 00:55:21.685
COMMENTS. UM, I JUST HAVE ONE
00:55:21.751 --> 00:55:24.554
QUESTION AND THAT IS, UM IT'S
00:55:24.621 --> 00:55:26.623
NOT CLEAR TO ME WHETHER THE BILL
00:55:26.690 --> 00:55:32.595
REQUIRES UM THAT THE. THE
00:55:32.662 --> 00:55:36.332
DEVELOPER. FOLLOW THE, UM THE
00:55:36.399 --> 00:55:37.934
RULES AND REGULATIONS OF THE
00:55:38.001 --> 00:55:40.403
LOCAL JURISDICTION BY THAT BY
00:55:40.470 --> 00:55:42.172
THAT, I MEAN LAND USE AND THE
00:55:42.238 --> 00:55:43.873
SETBACKS AND THE OPEN SPACE AND
00:55:43.940 --> 00:55:45.809
ALL THAT KIND OF GOOD STUFF. UM
00:55:45.875 --> 00:55:47.877
DO YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH THE
00:55:47.944 --> 00:55:48.945
REGULAR PLANNING PROCESS IN
00:55:49.012 --> 00:55:50.647
ORDER TO DO THAT? OR CAN YOU
00:55:50.714 --> 00:55:51.948
JUST SAY HEY, WE'RE A SCHOOL
00:55:52.015 --> 00:55:53.016
DISTRICT. WE GET TO DO WHATEVER
00:55:53.083 --> 00:55:58.188
WE WANT TO DO, AND SO THAT'S IT.
00:55:58.254 --> 00:55:59.422
THINK EMAIL CHAIR WOULD SAY OFF
00:55:59.489 --> 00:56:00.890
THE CUT. THAT IS A REALLY GOOD
00:56:00.957 --> 00:56:02.492
QUESTION. I BELIEVE THEY WOULD
00:56:02.559 --> 00:56:04.027
NEED TO FOLLOW AND BE CONFORMING
00:56:04.094 --> 00:56:05.428
WITH LOCAL REGULATIONS S WELL.
00:56:05.495 --> 00:56:06.830
THEY ARE NOT A STATE ENTITY SO
00:56:06.896 --> 00:56:08.498
THEY WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO
00:56:08.565 --> 00:56:09.499
SUPERSEDE LOCAL ORDINANCES. I'M
00:56:09.566 --> 00:56:11.468
HAPPY TO FURTHER RESEARCH THAT
00:56:11.534 --> 00:56:12.836
AND GET BACK TO YOUR OFFICE. I
00:56:12.902 --> 00:56:14.838
THINK THAT WOULD BE THAT WE CAN
00:56:14.904 --> 00:56:15.772
GET TO YOU WITH THAT
00:56:15.839 --> 00:56:18.208
INFORMATION, BUT, YOU KNOW
00:56:18.274 --> 00:56:20.176
GENERALLY SPEAKING, THE BILL
00:56:20.243 --> 00:56:21.678
WOULDN'T ALLOW YOU TO SUPERSEDE
00:56:21.745 --> 00:56:23.313
ANY ANY LOCAL ORDINANCES. IT'S
00:56:23.379 --> 00:56:25.582
NOT INCLUDED IN THAT AS A PART
00:56:25.648 --> 00:56:27.484
OF THAT BILL THAT I APPRECIATE
00:56:27.550 --> 00:56:29.619
THAT BECAUSE HAVING SERVED IN
00:56:29.686 --> 00:56:31.554
LOCAL GOVERNMENT. IT'S IMPORTANT
00:56:31.621 --> 00:56:33.923
THAT WHATEVER IT IS, IT'S BUILT
00:56:33.990 --> 00:56:36.159
SUPPORTS AND LOOKS LIKE THE REST
00:56:36.226 --> 00:56:37.160
OF THE COMMUNITY THAT THAT'S
00:56:37.227 --> 00:56:39.295
BEING BUILT IN. AND UM AND SO,
00:56:39.362 --> 00:56:44.300
TO THE EXTENT THAT, UM THAT.
00:56:44.367 --> 00:56:47.036
THAT IT'S BEING IT IS BEING
00:56:47.103 --> 00:56:48.538
BUILT IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
00:56:48.605 --> 00:56:51.341
HOUSING FOR THE LOCAL WORKFORCE
00:56:51.407 --> 00:56:52.108
THAT IT'S IMPORTANT TO ME THAT
00:56:52.175 --> 00:56:53.843
THAT IT REALLY FIT IN WITH THE
00:56:53.910 --> 00:56:56.713
COMMUNITY, SO I APPRECIATE THAT.
00:56:56.780 --> 00:56:58.948
SO I'LL SUPPORT IT TODAY WHEN WE
00:56:59.015 --> 00:57:01.217
FINALLY GET A MOTION AND IF YOU
00:57:01.284 --> 00:57:03.853
COULD JUST VERIFY THAT, UM IN
00:57:03.920 --> 00:57:06.189
THE YOU KNOW, JUST TO MAKE SURE
00:57:06.256 --> 00:57:07.190
THAT WOULD BE REALLY GREAT. I
00:57:07.257 --> 00:57:09.159
APPRECIATE IT, SO I WILL ALLOW
00:57:09.225 --> 00:57:10.693
YOU TO CONCLUDE. THANK YOU.
00:57:10.760 --> 00:57:11.628
SENATOR. APPRECIATE THE
00:57:11.694 --> 00:57:12.395
QUESTION. IT'S A VERY GOOD
00:57:12.462 --> 00:57:13.930
INSIGHT, AND I AGREE. WE
00:57:13.997 --> 00:57:15.298
DEFINITELY WANT TO CONFORM TO
00:57:15.365 --> 00:57:16.733
OUR SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES. AND
00:57:16.800 --> 00:57:19.102
YOU KNOW THIS IS A VALUE ADD FOR
00:57:19.169 --> 00:57:20.236
THE NEEDED HOUSING THAT WE HAVE,
00:57:20.303 --> 00:57:21.704
ESPECIALLY FOR COMMUNITY.
00:57:21.771 --> 00:57:22.172
COLLEGE STUDENTS THAT
00:57:22.238 --> 00:57:23.573
DISPROPORTIONATELY ARE AT RISK
00:57:23.640 --> 00:57:24.474
OF HOMELESSNESS, SO WE
00:57:24.541 --> 00:57:27.310
APPRECIATE ON THE SUPPORT OF ANY
00:57:27.377 --> 00:57:28.378
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. AND I WOULD
00:57:28.444 --> 00:57:29.312
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR I
00:57:29.379 --> 00:57:30.480
VOTED THAT TIME. VERY GOOD.
00:57:30.547 --> 00:57:32.482
THANK YOU SO MUCH. WE'RE GOING
00:57:32.549 --> 00:57:39.155
TO MOVE ON IN THE AGENDA. SO
00:57:39.222 --> 00:57:40.123
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S NEXT YEAR.
00:57:40.190 --> 00:57:42.292
YOU'RE NOT NEXT. BUT AS LONG AS
00:57:42.358 --> 00:57:43.827
YOU'VE CLEARED WITH THE REST OF
00:57:43.893 --> 00:57:45.328
THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THAT YOU'RE
00:57:45.395 --> 00:57:47.497
GOING TO JUMP IN FRONT OF THE
00:57:47.564 --> 00:57:49.532
MIC. GUESS I CAN TAKE IT OUT OF
00:57:49.599 --> 00:57:50.333
ORDER. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
00:57:50.400 --> 00:57:52.535
MADAM CHAIR AND, UH, OUR BUDGET
00:57:52.602 --> 00:57:54.137
CHAIR FOR ALLOWING ME TO GO
00:57:54.204 --> 00:57:55.805
AHEAD, HAVE SOME CHILDCARE
00:57:55.872 --> 00:57:56.406
ISSUES AND CONTENDING.
00:57:56.472 --> 00:57:58.541
UNDERSTAND COMPLETELY. THANK
00:57:58.608 --> 00:57:59.409
YOU. MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
00:57:59.475 --> 00:58:00.076
AND COMMITTEE STAFF. CALIFORNIA
00:58:00.143 --> 00:58:01.845
CURRENTLY HAS A GAP OF 1.2
00:58:01.911 --> 00:58:03.847
MILLION AFFORDABLE HOMES FOR
00:58:03.913 --> 00:58:05.515
STRUGGLING LOW INCOME HOUSEHOLDS
00:58:05.582 --> 00:58:06.316
AND ROUGHLY 160,000 HOMELESS
00:58:06.382 --> 00:58:07.417
FOLKS ON OUR STREETS AT ANY
00:58:07.483 --> 00:58:10.653
GIVEN NIGHT. WHILE MOST SIGNAL
00:58:10.720 --> 00:58:12.088
THE MOST SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS TO
00:58:12.155 --> 00:58:12.922
CONSTRUCTION OF AFFORDABLE
00:58:12.989 --> 00:58:14.190
HOUSING IS A LACK OF PUBLIC
00:58:14.257 --> 00:58:15.792
FUNDING, LAND USE POLICIES ALSO
00:58:15.859 --> 00:58:16.860
SIGNIFICANTLY LIMIT THE AMOUNT
00:58:16.926 --> 00:58:19.262
OF UNITS THAT CAN BE BUILT. IN
00:58:19.329 --> 00:58:22.665
2019 18 17 63 BY MR CHU AMENDED
00:58:22.732 --> 00:58:24.267
STATE DENSITY BONUS SLOT TO
00:58:24.334 --> 00:58:25.335
ALLOW 100% AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:58:25.401 --> 00:58:27.804
DEVELOPMENTS. UNLIMITED DENSITY
00:58:27.871 --> 00:58:29.272
FOR DEVELOPMENTS WITHIN ONE HALF
00:58:29.339 --> 00:58:31.241
MILE OF A MAJOR TRANSIT STOP OR
00:58:31.307 --> 00:58:32.775
HIGH QUALITY BUS CORRIDOR. MAYBE
00:58:32.842 --> 00:58:34.777
20 TO 34 BUILDS ON RECENT
00:58:34.844 --> 00:58:35.845
IMPROVEMENTS IMPROVEMENTS TO A B
00:58:35.912 --> 00:58:37.814
17 63 BY ALLOWING 100%
00:58:37.881 --> 00:58:39.415
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
00:58:39.482 --> 00:58:40.250
TO RECEIVE AN ADDITIONAL
00:58:40.316 --> 00:58:41.818
INCENTIVE FROM THE LOCAL AGENCY
00:58:41.885 --> 00:58:43.353
ADDED HEIGHT AND AN INCREASED
00:58:43.419 --> 00:58:45.054
DENSITY IF THE PROJECT IS
00:58:45.121 --> 00:58:46.222
LOCATED IN AN URBANIZED, VERY
00:58:46.289 --> 00:58:49.025
LOW VNT AREA. THIS BILL DEFINES
00:58:49.092 --> 00:58:50.627
A VERY LOW V INTERIOR AS AN
00:58:50.693 --> 00:58:51.661
URBANIZED AREA WHERE THE
00:58:51.728 --> 00:58:53.563
EXISTING RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
00:58:53.630 --> 00:58:55.131
GENERATES V PER CAPITA THAT IS
00:58:55.198 --> 00:58:57.300
BELOW 85% OF THE OF EITHER
00:58:57.367 --> 00:58:58.468
REGIONAL V. PER CAPITA, OR CITY
00:58:58.534 --> 00:59:01.337
V PER CAPITA. THE GOVERNOR'S
00:59:01.404 --> 00:59:02.138
OFFICE OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH
00:59:02.205 --> 00:59:03.539
WILL BE RELEASING MAPS WITH
00:59:03.606 --> 00:59:05.909
REGIONAL VIEW. CAP CALCULATIONS
00:59:05.975 --> 00:59:07.443
AT THE METROPOLITAN PLANNING
00:59:07.510 --> 00:59:08.011
ORGANIZATIONAL LEVEL IN THE
00:59:08.077 --> 00:59:09.579
COMING MONTHS. THESE MAPS ARE
00:59:09.646 --> 00:59:11.147
BASED ON LOCAL TRAVEL DEMAND
00:59:11.214 --> 00:59:12.415
MODELS DEVELOPED BY
00:59:12.482 --> 00:59:13.616
JURISDICTIONS THAT HAVE PRODUCED
00:59:13.683 --> 00:59:16.286
THEIR OWN MAPS OF THE. THIS BILL
00:59:16.352 --> 00:59:17.754
ADDRESSES THE HOUSING OF FOR
00:59:17.820 --> 00:59:18.755
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS AND
00:59:18.821 --> 00:59:20.189
FURTHERS ENVIRONMENTAL
00:59:20.256 --> 00:59:21.524
SUSTAINABILITY GOALS BY
00:59:21.591 --> 00:59:22.725
INCREASING THE UNIVERSE OF SITES
00:59:22.792 --> 00:59:24.427
AVAILABLE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
00:59:24.494 --> 00:59:25.461
DEVELOPMENTS THAT ARE SO
00:59:25.528 --> 00:59:26.796
DESPERATELY NEEDED IN THE STATE.
00:59:26.863 --> 00:59:29.165
WITH ME OR TO TESTIFY AND
00:59:29.232 --> 00:59:31.401
SUPPORT IS MARINA Y IN OF THE
00:59:31.467 --> 00:59:32.001
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM
00:59:32.068 --> 00:59:32.869
AND WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:59:32.936 --> 00:59:37.373
MY VOTE. VERY GOOD WELCOME. GOOD
00:59:37.440 --> 00:59:40.343
AFTERNOON, CHAIR AND MEMBER,
00:59:40.410 --> 00:59:41.811
MAYBE MARINA WHITE WITH THE
00:59:41.878 --> 00:59:43.079
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM,
00:59:43.146 --> 00:59:44.781
23 34 ADDRESSES THE HOUSING,
00:59:44.847 --> 00:59:46.249
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS AND FURTHER
00:59:46.316 --> 00:59:47.650
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABLE STATE
00:59:47.717 --> 00:59:49.118
SUSTAINABILITY GOALS BY
00:59:49.185 --> 00:59:50.420
INCENTIVIZING INFILL DEVELOPMENT
00:59:50.486 --> 00:59:51.421
AND DENSIFICATION OF URBANIZING
00:59:51.487 --> 00:59:54.223
COMMUNITIES. THEY MAY NOT YET
00:59:54.290 --> 00:59:55.725
HAVE HIGH QUALITY TRANSIT BUT
00:59:55.792 --> 00:59:57.360
OFFER CONVENIENT ACCESS TO JOBS,
00:59:57.427 --> 00:59:58.861
RETAIL AND SERVICES, ALLOWING
00:59:58.928 --> 01:00:00.563
RESIDENTS TO DRIVE LESS TO REACH
01:00:00.630 --> 01:00:02.532
THEIR DAILY DESTINATIONS. AS
01:00:02.598 --> 01:00:03.599
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WICKS NOTED 80
01:00:03.666 --> 01:00:05.601
23 34 MERELY BUILDS ON THE
01:00:05.668 --> 01:00:07.103
IMPROVEMENTS PROVIDED BY A B 17
01:00:07.170 --> 01:00:09.205
63 BY ALLOWING ALL LOCATION
01:00:09.272 --> 01:00:10.640
EFFICIENT 100% AFFORDABLE
01:00:10.707 --> 01:00:11.207
DEVELOPMENTS TO QUALIFY FOR
01:00:11.274 --> 01:00:14.177
THESE ENHANCED DENSITY RULES.
01:00:14.243 --> 01:00:15.478
THIS BILL IS CRITICAL TO HELPING
01:00:15.545 --> 01:00:16.446
HIS CLOTHES ARE TREMENDOUS
01:00:16.512 --> 01:00:17.680
AFFORDABILITY GAP AND ENSURE
01:00:17.747 --> 01:00:18.715
THAT LOW INCOME CALIFORNIANS
01:00:18.781 --> 01:00:20.316
HAVE ACCESS TO SAFE, STABLE,
01:00:20.383 --> 01:00:21.317
AFFORDABLE PLACES TO CALL HOME
01:00:21.384 --> 01:00:23.219
AND EVERY COMMUNITY ACROSS THE
01:00:23.286 --> 01:00:24.854
STREET AND TO HELP US ACHIEVE
01:00:24.921 --> 01:00:25.955
OUR CLIENT STATES CLIMATE GOALS
01:00:26.022 --> 01:00:27.190
AND FOR THESE REASONS. AH WHEN
01:00:27.256 --> 01:00:29.125
YOU HAVE QUORUM, I URGE YOUR
01:00:29.192 --> 01:00:31.361
SUPPORT TODAY. THANK YOU VERY
01:00:31.427 --> 01:00:32.929
MUCH. I UNDERSTAND THERE'S
01:00:32.996 --> 01:00:35.198
ANOTHER LEAD WITNESS IN SUPPORT
01:00:35.264 --> 01:00:36.232
IS NOT TESTIFYING. MERRIMAN.
01:00:36.299 --> 01:00:39.635
OKAY, VERY GOOD. IS THERE ANYONE
01:00:39.702 --> 01:00:41.337
ELSE WHO WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
01:00:41.404 --> 01:00:42.905
AND SUPPORT IN ROOM 2100 MARKS?
01:00:42.972 --> 01:00:44.307
DIVERS CALIFORNIA HOUSING
01:00:44.374 --> 01:00:45.308
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT? THANK
01:00:45.375 --> 01:00:48.544
YOU. THANK YOU. DANIEL ALLAH ON
01:00:48.611 --> 01:00:49.779
BEHALF OF THE WESTERN, CENTRAL
01:00:49.846 --> 01:00:50.913
AND POVERTY, THE CALIFORNIA
01:00:50.980 --> 01:00:51.714
WORLD LEGAL ASSISTANCE
01:00:51.781 --> 01:00:52.315
FOUNDATION IN THE PUBLIC
01:00:52.382 --> 01:00:53.049
INTEREST LAW, PROJECT AND
01:00:53.116 --> 01:00:56.052
SUPPORT THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:00:56.119 --> 01:00:57.720
MARIE CASTALDI ON BEHALF OF
01:00:57.787 --> 01:00:59.555
HOUSING, CALIFORNIA PROUD CO
01:00:59.622 --> 01:01:00.556
SPONSORS AND SUPPORT. THANKS.
01:01:00.623 --> 01:01:02.892
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. JORDAN
01:01:02.959 --> 01:01:03.893
CARVAJAL ON BEHALF OF
01:01:03.960 --> 01:01:06.029
CALIFORNIA. UM, BE IN SUPPORT.
01:01:06.095 --> 01:01:07.196
THANK YOU, MICHAEL AND WHISPER
01:01:07.263 --> 01:01:11.034
AND SUPPORT. LATE FOR MEETING ON
01:01:11.100 --> 01:01:12.835
BEHALF OF CIVIC WELL AND THE
01:01:12.902 --> 01:01:15.605
ACTION IN SPORTS. VERY GOOD. IS
01:01:15.671 --> 01:01:17.507
THERE ANYONE ELSE HERE IN ROOM
01:01:17.573 --> 01:01:21.844
2100? THING NONE. WE'RE GOING TO
01:01:21.911 --> 01:01:22.812
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
01:01:22.879 --> 01:01:25.348
LINE. IS THERE ANYBODY ON ON THE
01:01:25.415 --> 01:01:27.483
LINE THAT WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
01:01:27.550 --> 01:01:30.253
AND SUPPORT OF A B 23 34? THANK
01:01:30.319 --> 01:01:35.024
YOU. YOU MAY PRESS ONE. AND THEN
01:01:35.091 --> 01:01:37.560
ZERO IF YOU WERE IN SUPPORT OF A
01:01:37.627 --> 01:01:41.731
B 23 34. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND
01:01:41.798 --> 01:01:45.034
THEN ZERO, FEAR AND SUPPORT.
01:01:45.101 --> 01:01:46.302
MERKEL LINE UP TO 27. YOUR LINE
01:01:46.369 --> 01:01:50.440
IS OPEN. THANK YOU. LAWRENCE
01:01:50.506 --> 01:01:51.207
DAVID LANCIA, REPRESENTING THE
01:01:51.274 --> 01:01:52.141
AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION
01:01:52.208 --> 01:01:56.813
AND SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:01:56.879 --> 01:02:00.516
. I'M TOO 25. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:02:00.583 --> 01:02:02.685
CARLY SHELBY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:02:02.752 --> 01:02:03.352
NONPROFIT HOUSING ASSOCIATION OF
01:02:03.419 --> 01:02:04.120
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. STRONG
01:02:04.187 --> 01:02:05.788
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:02:05.855 --> 01:02:09.859
VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. LINE TO 71
01:02:09.926 --> 01:02:14.263
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. THIS IS 100.
01:02:14.330 --> 01:02:16.532
THEY CAN BE SUPPORTED A B 2334.
01:02:16.599 --> 01:02:20.002
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT,
01:02:20.069 --> 01:02:21.871
PLEASE. THANK YOU. I'M TOO 75.
01:02:21.938 --> 01:02:26.075
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. THIS IS RYAN
01:02:26.142 --> 01:02:28.311
O'CONNELL ON BEHALF OF NAPA.
01:02:28.377 --> 01:02:29.579
SOLANO, UM, BE IN IN SUPPORT.
01:02:29.645 --> 01:02:35.918
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:02:35.985 --> 01:02:41.824
. LINE TO 28. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:02:41.891 --> 01:02:45.161
LINE TWO YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:02:45.228 --> 01:02:53.169
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CRAZY 20? YES.
01:02:53.236 --> 01:02:54.937
I APOLOGIZE, DO YOU HONESTLY
01:02:55.004 --> 01:02:56.405
TODAY ON BEHALF OF THE HOUSING
01:02:56.472 --> 01:02:57.406
ACTION, COALITION AND SUPPORT
01:02:57.473 --> 01:03:00.676
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
01:03:00.743 --> 01:03:01.377
PLEASE THANK YOU. LINE TO 78
01:03:01.444 --> 01:03:06.282
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. HI GOOD
01:03:06.349 --> 01:03:07.683
AFTERNOON, CAITLIN JOHNSON WITH
01:03:07.750 --> 01:03:09.919
POLITICAL SOLUTIONS ON BEHALF OF
01:03:09.986 --> 01:03:10.453
THE CALIFORNIA COUNCIL FOR
01:03:10.520 --> 01:03:11.287
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND SUPPORT.
01:03:11.354 --> 01:03:16.392
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND WE DO
01:03:16.459 --> 01:03:17.660
HAVE TWO MORE ONE MOMENT WHERE
01:03:17.727 --> 01:03:21.597
THEY GET THEIR LINE NUMBER. AND
01:03:21.664 --> 01:03:23.366
AGAIN WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B
01:03:23.432 --> 01:03:33.476
23 34. AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 2
01:03:33.543 --> 01:03:36.179
81. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. CHIMNEY
01:03:36.245 --> 01:03:37.380
FAN ON BEHALF OF BRIDGE HOUSING
01:03:37.446 --> 01:03:39.849
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:03:39.916 --> 01:03:44.387
YOU. AND ONE MOMENT, MADAM CHAIR
01:03:44.453 --> 01:03:50.860
FOR ONE MORE IN QUÊ. AND WE WILL
01:03:50.927 --> 01:03:52.929
GO TO LINE 2 82 YEAR LINE IS
01:03:52.995 --> 01:03:57.533
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON SILVIO
01:03:57.600 --> 01:03:58.734
FERRARI ON BEHALF OF META AND
01:03:58.801 --> 01:04:03.339
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. AND WE HAVE
01:04:03.406 --> 01:04:04.407
NO FURTHER IMPORTANT QUÊ AT THIS
01:04:04.473 --> 01:04:06.175
TIME, MADAM CHAIR. THANK YOU
01:04:06.242 --> 01:04:07.310
VERY MUCH. WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
01:04:07.376 --> 01:04:09.212
ON TO OPPOSITION. THERE IS NO
01:04:09.278 --> 01:04:10.346
LEAD OPPOSITION LISTED, SO WE'LL
01:04:10.413 --> 01:04:12.148
SEE IF THERE'S ANYBODY IN ROOM
01:04:12.215 --> 01:04:13.316
2100 THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
01:04:13.382 --> 01:04:15.918
OPPOSITION. THING. THEN WE'LL
01:04:15.985 --> 01:04:17.620
MOVE ON TO THE TELECONFERENCE
01:04:17.687 --> 01:04:18.654
LINE. MADAM MODERATOR, IF YOU
01:04:18.721 --> 01:04:20.456
COULD CURE UP ANYONE WHO WAS
01:04:20.523 --> 01:04:22.692
WISHES TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:04:22.758 --> 01:04:27.797
OF A B 23 34. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:04:27.863 --> 01:04:28.864
OPPOSITION. YOU MAKE PRESS ONE
01:04:28.931 --> 01:04:32.134
AND THEN ZERO. I GET THAT IS ONE
01:04:32.201 --> 01:04:34.570
AND THEN ZERO FOR OPPOSITION OF
01:04:34.637 --> 01:04:40.776
A B 23 34. AND WE WILL GO TO
01:04:40.843 --> 01:04:42.778
LINE UP TO 49. YOUR LINE IS
01:04:42.845 --> 01:04:46.549
OPEN. RECALL ON BEHALF OF LITTLE
01:04:46.616 --> 01:04:47.483
LIVABLE CALIFORNIA IN
01:04:47.550 --> 01:04:54.223
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. NEXT GOAL
01:04:54.290 --> 01:04:57.793
LINE OF 2 80. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:04:57.860 --> 01:04:58.794
TERRY STARBASE SIDE IN
01:04:58.861 --> 01:05:04.133
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU, MADAM
01:05:04.200 --> 01:05:06.035
CHAIR. WE HAVE NO FURTHER
01:05:06.102 --> 01:05:07.236
OPPOSITION IN CUBA AT THIS TIME.
01:05:07.303 --> 01:05:09.038
VERY GOOD. WE'RE GOING TO BRING
01:05:09.105 --> 01:05:10.072
THE MATTER BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:05:10.139 --> 01:05:11.907
AND SEE IF THERE ARE ANY
01:05:11.974 --> 01:05:15.177
QUESTIONS. COMMENTS CONCERNS.
01:05:15.244 --> 01:05:18.848
YES, SENATOR, UM, HI. SO I WAS,
01:05:18.914 --> 01:05:26.055
UM. I WOULD LIKE TO ASK THE
01:05:26.122 --> 01:05:27.089
AUTHOR QUESTION THROUGH THE
01:05:27.156 --> 01:05:31.093
CHAIR. YES. UM HOW WOULD YOU
01:05:31.160 --> 01:05:33.929
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS? UM I'M
01:05:33.996 --> 01:05:35.831
SORRY. LOOKING FOR MY NOTES
01:05:35.898 --> 01:05:36.966
HERE. I HAVE BEEN RUSHING
01:05:37.033 --> 01:05:40.703
AROUND, UM THAT THIS WOULD COST
01:05:40.770 --> 01:05:43.406
SOME LOCAL CONTROL ISSUES AND
01:05:43.472 --> 01:05:44.674
THAT THIS DENSITY BONUS HAS
01:05:44.740 --> 01:05:46.208
UNLIMITED DENSITY AND ADDED
01:05:46.275 --> 01:05:50.179
HEIGHT. UM INTO THE BILL. SHIRT
01:05:50.246 --> 01:05:51.213
MARINA, DO YOU WANT TO TAKE A
01:05:51.280 --> 01:05:52.982
STEP AT THIS FIRST? HAPPY TO DO
01:05:53.049 --> 01:05:55.284
IT? I THINK THE BEAUTY OF
01:05:55.351 --> 01:05:56.252
DENSITY BONUS DENSITY BONUS LAW
01:05:56.319 --> 01:05:58.054
IS THAT IT'S A NEGOTIATION
01:05:58.120 --> 01:05:59.155
BETWEEN THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
01:05:59.221 --> 01:06:01.290
THE DEVELOPER. AND SO WHILE YES.
01:06:01.357 --> 01:06:03.693
THERE IS SORT OF THE UNLIMITED
01:06:03.759 --> 01:06:05.027
DENTYNE E AND NO MORE THAN THREE
01:06:05.094 --> 01:06:06.529
ADDITIONAL STORIES IS TYPICALLY
01:06:06.595 --> 01:06:07.363
NEGOTIATED BECAUSE THE PROJECT
01:06:07.430 --> 01:06:09.532
STILL NEEDS TO BE APPROVED BY
01:06:09.598 --> 01:06:10.399
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AT THE
01:06:10.466 --> 01:06:12.001
LOCAL LEVEL, AND SO IF THE
01:06:12.068 --> 01:06:14.303
DEVELOPER CHOSE TO SORT OF DO
01:06:14.370 --> 01:06:16.372
SOMETHING THAT WAS SO OBSCENE
01:06:16.439 --> 01:06:17.506
THAT THE COMMUNITY WOULD OPPOSE
01:06:17.573 --> 01:06:20.109
IT. THEY WOULD DENY THE PROJECT
01:06:20.176 --> 01:06:21.410
ONCE IT WAS GOING THROUGH A
01:06:21.477 --> 01:06:23.879
PROCESS. OH, SO HE'S STILL
01:06:23.946 --> 01:06:25.915
ALLOWS FOR LOCAL CONTROL SIDE,
01:06:25.981 --> 01:06:30.553
THE HEIGHT AND THE IN. THE
01:06:30.619 --> 01:06:32.722
PROJECT COULD STILL BE DENIED IF
01:06:32.788 --> 01:06:34.190
THE COMMUNITY FELT LIKE THE
01:06:34.256 --> 01:06:35.291
PROJECT BEING PROPOSED, THEY
01:06:35.358 --> 01:06:38.160
COULD NOT SUPPORT SO LIKE, WHILE
01:06:38.227 --> 01:06:40.563
THE DEVELOPER COULD GO TO THE
01:06:40.629 --> 01:06:41.664
VERY MAXIMUM OF WHAT IS
01:06:41.731 --> 01:06:43.432
ALLOWABLE IN DENSITY BONUS LAW,
01:06:43.499 --> 01:06:45.735
IF THAT WAS GOING TO LEAD TO
01:06:45.801 --> 01:06:47.737
OPPOSITION LOCALLY AND DENIAL BY
01:06:47.803 --> 01:06:49.004
THE LOCAL CITY COUNCIL AT THE
01:06:49.071 --> 01:06:52.141
PROJECT APPROVAL STAGE. UM THEY
01:06:52.208 --> 01:06:54.310
WOULD STILL HAVE THE DISCRETION
01:06:54.377 --> 01:06:55.611
TO BE ABLE TO DENY THE PROJECT
01:06:55.678 --> 01:06:58.214
AT THAT POINT. OKAY SO IT
01:06:58.280 --> 01:06:59.248
DOESN'T CIRCUMVENT ALL LOCAL
01:06:59.315 --> 01:07:03.886
CONTROL. OKAY I'M GRATEFUL TO
01:07:03.953 --> 01:07:05.621
HEAR THAT. I ACTUALLY APPRECIATE
01:07:05.688 --> 01:07:07.790
THAT THAT COMPONENT AND THEN THE
01:07:07.857 --> 01:07:09.191
OTHER CONCERN. I WOULD NOT
01:07:09.258 --> 01:07:11.227
CONCERNED ABOUT THE QUESTION I
01:07:11.293 --> 01:07:12.428
WOULD HAVE WOULD BE WITH REGARD
01:07:12.495 --> 01:07:13.629
TO THE PARKING STANDARDS. AND
01:07:13.696 --> 01:07:16.198
LOCAL AGENCIES AS WELL. YES SO,
01:07:16.265 --> 01:07:18.000
UM, CURRENT DENSITY BONUS LAW
01:07:18.067 --> 01:07:20.669
DOES PROVIDE PARKING REDUCTIONS
01:07:20.736 --> 01:07:22.204
OR PARKING, UM, NO LIMITS ON
01:07:22.271 --> 01:07:25.107
PARKING MINIMUMS. THIS BILL
01:07:25.174 --> 01:07:26.642
DOESN'T ACTUALLY CHANGE THOSE
01:07:26.709 --> 01:07:29.612
STANDARDS. IT JUST SORT OF IT
01:07:29.678 --> 01:07:31.247
TWEAKS A BIT OF THE DEFINITION
01:07:31.313 --> 01:07:33.182
WITHIN WHAT TYPES OF PROJECTS
01:07:33.249 --> 01:07:34.316
QUALIFY FOR THOSE PARKING
01:07:34.383 --> 01:07:35.651
REDUCTIONS WERE NOT EXPANDING
01:07:35.718 --> 01:07:39.255
SORT OF. ADDITIONAL PROJECTS TO
01:07:39.321 --> 01:07:40.689
FALL UNDER IT, BUT I UNDERSTAND
01:07:40.756 --> 01:07:41.824
THE CONCERN IF FOLKS HAVE
01:07:41.891 --> 01:07:43.025
CONCERNS WITH ELIMINATING
01:07:43.092 --> 01:07:45.494
PARKING MINIMUMS, UM THOSE ARE
01:07:45.561 --> 01:07:47.029
VALID CONCERNS. JUST THIS BILL
01:07:47.096 --> 01:07:48.864
DOESN'T DOESN'T CHANGE CREATING
01:07:48.931 --> 01:07:52.001
NEW PARKING MINIMUM CATEGORIES.
01:07:52.067 --> 01:07:54.503
OKAY PERFECT. THANK YOU. THAT'S
01:07:54.570 --> 01:07:56.071
ALL I HAVE. IS THERE ANYBODY
01:07:56.138 --> 01:07:57.773
ELSE THAT HAS ANY QUESTIONS
01:07:57.840 --> 01:08:00.776
CONCERNS? THING THEN YOU MAY
01:08:00.843 --> 01:08:02.812
CONCLUDE DISRESPECT FASTER AND I
01:08:02.878 --> 01:08:04.113
VOTE WHEN YOU ESTABLISH CORN.
01:08:04.180 --> 01:08:05.848
VERY GOOD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:08:05.915 --> 01:08:07.450
SO MUCH. LET'S SEE
01:08:07.516 --> 01:08:16.725
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. MOVING DOWN
01:08:16.792 --> 01:08:19.328
THE AGENDA. ITEM NUMBER SIX, UM
01:08:19.395 --> 01:08:22.932
BOERNER HORVATH HER VET. ALWAYS
01:08:22.998 --> 01:08:25.034
WANT TO GET THAT ONE RIGHT AND I
01:08:25.100 --> 01:08:26.068
NEED TO THINK ABOUT IT. IT'S
01:08:26.135 --> 01:08:28.437
LIKE A JOB, OKAY? I JUST NEED TO
01:08:28.504 --> 01:08:30.172
THINK ABOUT IT. YOU JUST CAN'T
01:08:30.239 --> 01:08:31.240
LOOK AT THIS FELLA. I KNOW
01:08:31.307 --> 01:08:33.175
THAT'S EXACTLY ABOUT BURNER LIKE
01:08:33.242 --> 01:08:34.743
A BURNER PHONE ONCE AND BURGER
01:08:34.810 --> 01:08:35.411
THIS BEFORE AND ARE HONEST STOVE
01:08:35.478 --> 01:08:39.648
BACKBURNER. I'VE HEARD THEM ALL.
01:08:39.715 --> 01:08:42.151
SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GOOD
01:08:42.218 --> 01:08:43.452
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS.
01:08:43.519 --> 01:08:45.754
A B 17 38 WOULD REQUIRE THE
01:08:45.821 --> 01:08:46.555
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
01:08:46.622 --> 01:08:47.656
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND THE
01:08:47.723 --> 01:08:48.657
CALIFORNIA BUILDING STANDARDS
01:08:48.724 --> 01:08:50.359
COMMISSION. TO CONSIDER THE
01:08:50.426 --> 01:08:52.561
ADOPTION OF MANDATORY BUILDING
01:08:52.628 --> 01:08:53.896
STANDARDS FOR THE INSTALLATION
01:08:53.963 --> 01:08:54.797
OF ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING
01:08:54.864 --> 01:08:56.332
STATION. IN EXISTING MULTI
01:08:56.398 --> 01:08:57.800
FAMILY DWELLINGS. SCHOOLS ARE
01:08:57.867 --> 01:08:59.702
NOT SCHOOLS, MULTI FAMILY
01:08:59.768 --> 01:09:00.769
DWELLINGS, HOTELS AND MOTELS AND
01:09:00.836 --> 01:09:02.037
NON RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTS.
01:09:02.104 --> 01:09:03.706
DURING RETROFITS ADDITIONS AND
01:09:03.772 --> 01:09:04.740
ALTERATIONS TO EXISTING PARKING
01:09:04.807 --> 01:09:06.876
FACILITIES. UPDATES TO THE
01:09:06.942 --> 01:09:08.477
CALGARY IN CODE ADOPTED IN
01:09:08.544 --> 01:09:10.579
DECEMBER. 2021 REQUIRE THAT WHEN
01:09:10.646 --> 01:09:11.814
ADDITIONS OR ALTERATIONS ARE
01:09:11.881 --> 01:09:13.482
MADE TO PARKING FACILITIES AND
01:09:13.549 --> 01:09:14.216
EXISTING MULTI FAMILY BUILDINGS
01:09:14.283 --> 01:09:16.018
, AT LEAST 10% OF THE PARKING
01:09:16.085 --> 01:09:17.253
SPACES MUST BE UPGRADED. TOO
01:09:17.319 --> 01:09:19.922
EASY CAPABLE. FURTHERMORE WHEN
01:09:19.989 --> 01:09:20.823
ADDITIONS OR ALTERATIONS ARE
01:09:20.890 --> 01:09:22.958
MADE TO EXISTING MULTI FAMILY
01:09:23.025 --> 01:09:24.126
DWELLINGS, HOTELS AND MOTELS, AT
01:09:24.193 --> 01:09:25.628
LEAST 25% OF THE PARKING SPACES
01:09:25.694 --> 01:09:27.563
MUST BE E V READY, MEANING THAT
01:09:27.630 --> 01:09:28.597
THE PARKING SPACES HAVE BOTH
01:09:28.664 --> 01:09:30.432
RACEWAY AND LOW POWER LEVEL TO
01:09:30.499 --> 01:09:32.001
ELECTRICAL OUTLETS. WHILE THE
01:09:32.067 --> 01:09:33.269
BUILDING STANDARD COMMISSION
01:09:33.335 --> 01:09:34.837
ADOPTED EDDIE CAPABLE AND EASY
01:09:34.904 --> 01:09:36.071
READY REQUIREMENTS FOR EXISTING
01:09:36.138 --> 01:09:37.740
PARKING FACILITIES, IT DID NOT
01:09:37.806 --> 01:09:39.241
INCLUDE EASY INSTALL
01:09:39.308 --> 01:09:40.676
REQUIREMENTS, WHICH REQUIRE ALL
01:09:40.743 --> 01:09:42.177
THE INFRASTRUCTURE PLUS THE
01:09:42.244 --> 01:09:43.479
ACTUAL CHARGING STATION. THERE
01:09:43.546 --> 01:09:44.680
IS THE EQUIVALENT OF SAYING
01:09:44.747 --> 01:09:46.282
WE'RE GONNA HAVE A PLUMBING FOR
01:09:46.348 --> 01:09:47.716
A TOILET. BUT NO ACTUAL TOILET
01:09:47.783 --> 01:09:49.652
AND WE ALL KNOW IF YOU NEED TO
01:09:49.718 --> 01:09:51.587
GO TO THE BATHROOM. IT DOESN'T
01:09:51.654 --> 01:09:52.421
HELP IF THERE'S NOT A TOILET
01:09:52.488 --> 01:09:54.023
THERE. SO A B 17 38 WOULD
01:09:54.089 --> 01:09:55.424
REQUIRE REGULATIONS TO BE
01:09:55.491 --> 01:09:56.025
CONSIDERED AND ADOPTED TO FILL
01:09:56.091 --> 01:09:58.327
THIS GAP. I THINK IT'S ALSO
01:09:58.394 --> 01:09:58.961
IMPORTANT TO MENTION THAT AS THE
01:09:59.028 --> 01:10:01.497
COST OF TVS HAS DECREASED IN
01:10:01.564 --> 01:10:02.665
RECENT YEARS, AND IT'S EXPECTED
01:10:02.731 --> 01:10:04.400
TO CONTINUE TO DECLINE IN THE
01:10:04.466 --> 01:10:05.301
FUTURE. E. V S ARE BECOMING MORE
01:10:05.367 --> 01:10:06.569
ACCESSIBLE TO LOW INCOME
01:10:06.635 --> 01:10:08.237
POPULATIONS OVER THE LACK OF
01:10:08.304 --> 01:10:10.005
ACCESS TO HOME CHARGING STATIONS
01:10:10.072 --> 01:10:12.775
REMAIN A MAJOR BARRIER TO THE
01:10:12.841 --> 01:10:13.876
ADOPTION ANALYSIS BY THE
01:10:13.943 --> 01:10:15.344
CALIFORNIA ENERGY COMMISSION
01:10:15.411 --> 01:10:16.211
FOUND THAT LOW INCOME
01:10:16.278 --> 01:10:17.713
COMMUNITIES HAVE FEWER CHARGING
01:10:17.780 --> 01:10:18.347
STATIONS PER CAPITAL, THE MIDDLE
01:10:18.414 --> 01:10:20.916
AND HIGH INCOME COMMUNITIES.
01:10:20.983 --> 01:10:22.484
RELIABLE ACCESS TO EVIE CHARGING
01:10:22.551 --> 01:10:24.620
STATIONS IN PARTICULAR, OR IS
01:10:24.687 --> 01:10:26.288
PARTICULARLY CHALLENGING FOR
01:10:26.355 --> 01:10:27.256
RENTERS AND THOSE LIVING IN
01:10:27.323 --> 01:10:29.391
MULTI UNIT DWELLINGS. STUDIES
01:10:29.458 --> 01:10:31.193
HAVE SHOWN THAT AS MUCH AS 85%
01:10:31.260 --> 01:10:32.461
OF CHARGING FOR PERSONAL
01:10:32.528 --> 01:10:34.196
ELECTRIC VEHICLES OCCURS AT HOME
01:10:34.263 --> 01:10:35.230
, BUT PEOPLE LIVING IN
01:10:35.297 --> 01:10:35.831
APARTMENTS AND CONDOMINIUMS,
01:10:35.898 --> 01:10:37.633
ALSO KNOWN AS MULTI FAMILY
01:10:37.700 --> 01:10:38.334
DWELLINGS ARE MULTI UNIT
01:10:38.400 --> 01:10:39.768
DWELLINGS DO NOT HAVE ACCESS TO
01:10:39.835 --> 01:10:41.737
THESE CHARGING IN THEIR UNITS. A
01:10:41.804 --> 01:10:43.806
B 17 38 WILL PROVIDE GREATER
01:10:43.872 --> 01:10:45.507
MORE RELIABLE ACCESS TO CHARGING
01:10:45.574 --> 01:10:46.141
INFRASTRUCTURE TO LOW AND
01:10:46.208 --> 01:10:47.509
MODERATE INCOME COMMUNITIES AND
01:10:47.576 --> 01:10:48.544
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR.
01:10:48.611 --> 01:10:49.244
SPECIFICALLY THOSE LIVING IN
01:10:49.311 --> 01:10:50.479
MULTI FAMILY BUILDINGS, WHICH
01:10:50.546 --> 01:10:52.448
WILL MAKE ELECTRIC AND ZERO
01:10:52.514 --> 01:10:53.415
EMISSION VEHICLE OWNERSHIP MORE
01:10:53.482 --> 01:10:54.717
FEASIBLE. I HAVE AUTHORS
01:10:54.783 --> 01:10:55.985
AMENDMENTS THAT WILL THAT SHOULD
01:10:56.051 --> 01:10:58.387
REMOVE MOST OF THE OPPOSITION.
01:10:58.454 --> 01:10:59.121
AT THE COMMITTEE'S REQUEST. THE
01:10:59.188 --> 01:11:00.322
BILL WILL BE AMENDED IN SENATE
01:11:00.389 --> 01:11:03.325
APPROPRIATIONS. I CAN GO THROUGH
01:11:03.392 --> 01:11:03.926
THOSE AMENDMENTS IF NECESSARY
01:11:03.993 --> 01:11:05.027
FOR THE COMMITTEE. I DO WANT TO
01:11:05.094 --> 01:11:07.062
SAY I TALKED TO SEVERAL OF YOU
01:11:07.129 --> 01:11:09.431
WANT TO GO THROUGH SOME OF THE
01:11:09.498 --> 01:11:10.165
CONCERNS THAT I'VE HEARD WHEN
01:11:10.232 --> 01:11:11.367
TAKING THIS THROUGH THE ASSEMBLY
01:11:11.433 --> 01:11:13.302
AND NOW IN THE SENATE, I WROTE
01:11:13.369 --> 01:11:15.137
THIS BILL MYSELF, AND MY GOAL IS
01:11:15.204 --> 01:11:17.206
YOU KNOW, IN 2030. WE HAVE AN
01:11:17.272 --> 01:11:18.807
EXECUTIVE ORDER THAT SAYS WE'RE
01:11:18.874 --> 01:11:19.842
NO LONGER GOING TO SELL
01:11:19.908 --> 01:11:20.809
COMBUSTION ENGINE CARS IN
01:11:20.876 --> 01:11:22.177
CALIFORNIA. AND SO WE KNOW AS
01:11:22.244 --> 01:11:23.946
MULTI FAMILY DWELLINGS, EXISTING
01:11:24.013 --> 01:11:26.081
MULTI FAMILY DWELLINGS REDEVELOP
01:11:26.148 --> 01:11:27.750
. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE THOSE
01:11:27.816 --> 01:11:28.784
CHARGING STATIONS ARE ACTUALLY
01:11:28.851 --> 01:11:30.552
INSTALLED OVER TIME. AND THERE'S
01:11:30.619 --> 01:11:32.087
300 MILLION IN THE BUDGET THIS
01:11:32.154 --> 01:11:35.224
YEAR FOR TVS FOR LOW INCOME
01:11:35.290 --> 01:11:37.459
SINGLE FAMILY AS WELL AS MULTI
01:11:37.526 --> 01:11:39.595
FAMILY AND MY BILL WOULD SAY
01:11:39.662 --> 01:11:40.663
THIS IS THE BUILDING STANDARDS
01:11:40.729 --> 01:11:41.230
COMMISSIONS UPDATE IN THREE
01:11:41.296 --> 01:11:42.631
YEARS, SO WE'LL BE FOLLOWING
01:11:42.698 --> 01:11:44.166
THAT IN THE BUDGET BECAUSE THE
01:11:44.233 --> 01:11:46.235
INTENTION IS NOT TO PUT THIS ON
01:11:46.301 --> 01:11:47.336
THE DEVELOPERS OR THE LANDLORDS
01:11:47.403 --> 01:11:49.271
TO DO THIS, BUT IT HELPED TO
01:11:49.338 --> 01:11:49.905
OFFSET THEIR COSTS BECAUSE THIS
01:11:49.972 --> 01:11:52.007
IS A BENEFIT FOR EQUITY IN ALL
01:11:52.074 --> 01:11:53.142
OF CALIFORNIA. WE DON'T WANT TO
01:11:53.208 --> 01:11:54.143
LEAVE. OUR LOW INCOME
01:11:54.209 --> 01:11:55.544
CALIFORNIANS AND NEIGHBORS
01:11:55.611 --> 01:11:57.346
BEHIND WHEN WE GO TO THE
01:11:57.413 --> 01:11:58.447
TRANSITION TO ELECTRIC VEHICLES
01:11:58.514 --> 01:11:59.915
, SO WE'LL BE FOLLOWING THAT
01:11:59.982 --> 01:12:02.351
CLOSELY AND LOOKING NEXT YEAR,
01:12:02.418 --> 01:12:03.619
INTRODUCING LEGISLATION AND
01:12:03.686 --> 01:12:04.753
WORKING WITH THE GOVERNOR'S
01:12:04.820 --> 01:12:05.387
OFFICE AND CONTINUING THAT WORK
01:12:05.454 --> 01:12:06.855
TO ENSURE THAT THIS COST IS
01:12:06.922 --> 01:12:09.191
HELPED THREE OFFSET BY THE
01:12:09.258 --> 01:12:11.593
STATE. AND SO WITH THAT, I
01:12:11.660 --> 01:12:12.327
RESPECTFULLY ASK HER. I VOTE
01:12:12.394 --> 01:12:13.996
BECAUSE THIS IS A TBH SPECIAL. I
01:12:14.063 --> 01:12:16.131
WROTE IT MYSELF. IF YOU HAVE ANY
01:12:16.198 --> 01:12:16.765
QUESTIONS OR CONCERNS, PLEASE
01:12:16.832 --> 01:12:17.966
LET ME KNOW I'M I'VE BEEN
01:12:18.033 --> 01:12:19.134
WORKING WITH THE OPPOSITION THE
01:12:19.201 --> 01:12:21.270
ENTIRE TIME. ON THIS BILL AND
01:12:21.336 --> 01:12:22.371
HAPPY TO CONSIDER ANY OF YOUR
01:12:22.438 --> 01:12:24.339
SUGGESTIONS AS WE MOVE THIS BILL
01:12:24.406 --> 01:12:27.276
FORWARD IN THE SENATE. VERY GOOD
01:12:27.342 --> 01:12:29.678
. I'M PASSING THE GAVEL, PASSING
01:12:29.745 --> 01:12:31.847
THE GAVELS THROUGH THE CHAIR.
01:12:31.914 --> 01:12:33.615
THANK YOU, SENATOR CAVIAR FOR
01:12:33.682 --> 01:12:34.249
BEING A TROOPER AND STEPPING IN
01:12:34.316 --> 01:12:39.088
UM OKAY. DO WE HAVE A MOTION?
01:12:39.154 --> 01:12:44.259
OH, WHAT DO YOU SAY? OKAY I'M
01:12:44.326 --> 01:12:45.060
SORRY. I THOUGHT THAT WAS HER
01:12:45.127 --> 01:12:47.196
CLOTHES. THAT WAS HER OPENING
01:12:47.262 --> 01:12:49.498
OPENING. MY APOLOGIES. OKAY WE
01:12:49.565 --> 01:12:50.399
DON'T HAVE ANY LEADS SUPPORT
01:12:50.466 --> 01:12:55.604
IDENTIFIED. WE HAVE A QUORUM.
01:12:55.671 --> 01:12:56.772
OKAY, CAN YOU PLEASE CALL THE
01:12:56.839 --> 01:12:57.973
ROLL OR ACTUALLY ESTABLISHED
01:12:58.040 --> 01:13:06.381
WARM? SENATOR WIENER PRESIDENT
01:13:06.448 --> 01:13:07.416
WIENER PRESENT BATES BATES
01:13:07.483 --> 01:13:11.153
PRESENT CORTEZ E. CABALLERO
01:13:11.220 --> 01:13:12.521
CABALLERO PRESIDENT MCGUIRE
01:13:12.588 --> 01:13:13.756
OCHOA BUG. HERE. LOOK HERE,
01:13:13.822 --> 01:13:17.159
SKINNER. HAMBURG. HAMBURG HERE,
01:13:17.226 --> 01:13:21.230
WIECKOWSKI WE HAVE A QUORUM.
01:13:21.296 --> 01:13:24.333
OKAY WE HAVE ESTABLISHED QUORUM
01:13:24.399 --> 01:13:28.036
AND WELL NOW AS FOR IS THERE ANY
01:13:28.103 --> 01:13:30.773
SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM 2100 FOR SP
01:13:30.839 --> 01:13:34.376
17 38. SEEING NONE WILL GO TO
01:13:34.443 --> 01:13:40.382
THE PHONE LINES. MR MODERATOR OR. OR THE MODERATOR. IS THERE
01:13:40.449 --> 01:13:41.383
ANY, UH, SUPPORTIVE PUBLIC
01:13:41.450 --> 01:13:45.387
COMMENT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR IN
01:13:45.454 --> 01:13:47.389
SUPPORT OF A B 17 38 YOU MAY
01:13:47.456 --> 01:13:51.760
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
01:13:51.827 --> 01:13:54.429
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO. FEAR
01:13:54.496 --> 01:14:00.369
AND SUPPORT OF A B 17 38. HAD
01:14:00.435 --> 01:14:01.570
ONE MOMENT WHILE WE GET THEIR
01:14:01.637 --> 01:14:06.341
LINE NUMBERS. AND AGAIN WE ARE
01:14:06.408 --> 01:14:12.648
IN SUPPORT OF A B 17 38. WE'VE
01:14:12.714 --> 01:14:14.416
GOT TO LINE UP TO 57. YOUR LINE
01:14:14.483 --> 01:14:19.655
IS OPEN. MRS SANTIAGO, ANGELINA,
01:14:19.721 --> 01:14:20.689
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL VOTERS
01:14:20.756 --> 01:14:26.528
AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU NEXT TO
01:14:26.595 --> 01:14:28.597
THE LINE OF 2 84. YOUR LINE IS
01:14:28.664 --> 01:14:31.767
OPEN. MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS ROGER
01:14:31.834 --> 01:14:33.535
DICKINSON ON BEHALF OF CIVIC
01:14:33.602 --> 01:14:35.304
WELL, FORMERLY THE LOCAL
01:14:35.370 --> 01:14:36.271
GOVERNMENT COMMISSIONS IN
01:14:36.338 --> 01:14:41.376
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:14:41.443 --> 01:14:43.679
NEXT TO GO ONLINE TO 76 LINE IS
01:14:43.745 --> 01:14:49.151
OPEN. HELLO THIS IS WILL BRING
01:14:49.218 --> 01:14:50.219
ER UNDER HALF OF 3 50,
01:14:50.285 --> 01:14:52.087
SACRAMENTO AND WE ARE IN
01:14:52.154 --> 01:14:55.457
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
01:14:55.524 --> 01:15:00.929
AND NEXT WEEK OR TWO. ONE MOMENT
01:15:00.996 --> 01:15:02.231
WHERE THEY GET THEIR LINE NUMBER
01:15:02.297 --> 01:15:04.166
ONE MOMENT LIKE TO 70. YOUR LINE
01:15:04.233 --> 01:15:09.705
IS OPEN. LINE 2 70. YOUR LINE IS
01:15:09.771 --> 01:15:17.079
OPEN. IS THERE ANYONE ON THE
01:15:17.145 --> 01:15:24.019
LINE? DO YOU HAVE A MUTE? ALL
01:15:24.086 --> 01:15:26.054
RIGHT. AND MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
01:15:26.121 --> 01:15:27.689
FOR THIS IMPORTANT TO YOU AT
01:15:27.756 --> 01:15:29.057
THIS TIME. GREAT. THANK YOU VERY
01:15:29.124 --> 01:15:29.892
MUCH. IS THERE ANYONE IN ROOM
01:15:29.958 --> 01:15:32.227
2100 AND OPPOSITION TO A B 17
01:15:32.294 --> 01:15:36.231
38? SEEING THAT WE'LL GO TO THE
01:15:36.298 --> 01:15:39.668
PHONE LINES, MADAM MODERATOR.
01:15:39.735 --> 01:15:41.270
THANK YOU IF YOU'RE AN
01:15:41.336 --> 01:15:44.239
OPPOSITION OF A B 17 38 YOU MAY
01:15:44.306 --> 01:15:48.911
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
01:15:48.977 --> 01:15:51.346
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO FOR AN
01:15:51.413 --> 01:15:54.850
OPPOSITION OF A B 17 38. AND WE
01:15:54.917 --> 01:15:55.984
WILL GO TO LINE 2 82. YOUR LINE
01:15:56.051 --> 01:16:00.889
IS OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON, MR
01:16:00.956 --> 01:16:03.191
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS SILVIO FERRARI
01:16:03.258 --> 01:16:04.927
, CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
01:16:04.993 --> 01:16:06.995
ASSOCIATION. WE HAD AN OPPOSING
01:16:07.062 --> 01:16:09.231
LESS AMENDED THE BILL TO THE
01:16:09.298 --> 01:16:11.166
GREAT WORK OF THE AUTHOR AND HER
01:16:11.233 --> 01:16:14.136
STAFF. WE ARE NOW. USUAL ON THE
01:16:14.202 --> 01:16:16.171
BILL FOR AGAIN. THANK YOU,
01:16:16.238 --> 01:16:18.307
AUTHOR FOR ALL THE WORK AND LOOK
01:16:18.373 --> 01:16:19.841
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH HER
01:16:19.908 --> 01:16:21.410
MOVING FORWARD ON EXPENSIVE
01:16:21.476 --> 01:16:22.644
ANOTHER WAY TO BRING THAT
01:16:22.711 --> 01:16:27.950
REALITY. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
01:16:28.016 --> 01:16:29.952
NEXT TO GO TO LINE UP TO 58
01:16:30.018 --> 01:16:33.655
AIRLINE IS OPEN. YES GOOD
01:16:33.722 --> 01:16:35.190
AFTERNOON, MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS
01:16:35.257 --> 01:16:37.059
KAREEM GREASY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:16:37.125 --> 01:16:38.260
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:16:38.327 --> 01:16:39.227
REALTORS AND OPPOSITION
01:16:39.294 --> 01:16:39.828
RESPECTFULLY REQUESTING OVER.
01:16:39.895 --> 01:16:44.433
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT,
01:16:44.499 --> 01:16:46.401
WE'LL GO TO THE LINE UP TO 51
01:16:46.468 --> 01:16:48.704
YEAR, LINUS OPEN THIS RUN
01:16:48.770 --> 01:16:50.639
KINGSTON. I REPRESENT SEVERAL
01:16:50.706 --> 01:16:54.409
ASSOCIATIONS, NOTABLY THE ENTIRE
01:16:54.476 --> 01:16:56.578
STATE FOR AFFORDABLE HAPPENING,
01:16:56.645 --> 01:17:00.682
UM AND SERVING ALL LOW INCOME.
01:17:00.749 --> 01:17:03.018
AS WELL AS THE APARTMENT
01:17:03.085 --> 01:17:13.428
ASSOCIATION. AH! RESOLVING THE
01:17:13.495 --> 01:17:15.130
MAJOR ISSUE FOR US, WHICH WAS A
01:17:15.197 --> 01:17:16.131
MANDATORY RETRO SHIFT
01:17:16.198 --> 01:17:19.534
REQUIREMENTS. ALL MULTIFAMILY
01:17:19.601 --> 01:17:22.704
PROBLEM PROPERTIES THAT IS AND
01:17:22.771 --> 01:17:24.373
WILL BE REMOVED. AS I UNDERSTAND
01:17:24.439 --> 01:17:26.408
IT AT THE APPROPRIATIONS
01:17:26.475 --> 01:17:27.142
COMMITTEE WE RESPECTFULLY HAPPY
01:17:27.209 --> 01:17:32.547
MOVED OUR OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
01:17:32.614 --> 01:17:34.249
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
01:17:34.316 --> 01:17:35.751
FURTHER OPPOSITION. THANK YOU.
01:17:35.817 --> 01:17:36.985
OKAY WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
01:17:37.052 --> 01:17:38.453
COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES IN COMMENTS
01:17:38.520 --> 01:17:40.255
OR QUESTIONS. YES, SENATOR
01:17:40.322 --> 01:17:42.924
COBURG. I'M JUST GRATEFUL FOR
01:17:42.991 --> 01:17:43.792
AND THE CONVERSATIONS ARE
01:17:43.859 --> 01:17:45.560
REACHING OUT AND TRYING TO
01:17:45.627 --> 01:17:47.462
EXPLAIN YOUR WILLINGNESS TO WORK
01:17:47.529 --> 01:17:49.064
WITH THE OPPOSITION AND I'M
01:17:49.131 --> 01:17:50.766
GRATEFUL. THIS IS HOW WE COME
01:17:50.832 --> 01:17:52.267
TOGETHER IN WORK ON GOOD,
01:17:52.334 --> 01:17:54.336
BALANCED POLICIES WHEN WE HAVE
01:17:54.403 --> 01:17:55.670
ALL STAKEHOLDERS AND WE TRY TO
01:17:55.737 --> 01:17:57.806
DELIBERATELY TRY TO WORK OUT THE
01:17:57.873 --> 01:17:59.508
ISSUES. SO I COMMEND YOU FOR THE
01:17:59.574 --> 01:18:02.310
WORK THAT YOU'RE DOING, AND I
01:18:02.377 --> 01:18:03.812
TRULY TRULY APPRECIATE ALL THE
01:18:03.879 --> 01:18:05.313
EFFORT AND YOUR CONTINUED
01:18:05.380 --> 01:18:06.448
WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH THE
01:18:06.515 --> 01:18:07.616
OPPOSITION AND I WILL GLADLY
01:18:07.682 --> 01:18:11.119
SUPPORT THE BILL. THANK YOU. ANY
01:18:11.186 --> 01:18:12.554
OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? YES
01:18:12.621 --> 01:18:14.489
SENATOR COMING TO COMMENT, AND I
01:18:14.556 --> 01:18:16.925
REALLY APPRECIATE THE THEIR
01:18:16.992 --> 01:18:20.729
RECOGNITION THAT, UM WE HAVE NOT
01:18:20.796 --> 01:18:22.531
DONE ENOUGH TO INCLUDE LOWERING
01:18:22.597 --> 01:18:23.865
THERE ARE LOW IN COMMUTE LOW
01:18:23.932 --> 01:18:27.569
INCOME COMMUNITY AS PART OF OUR
01:18:27.636 --> 01:18:30.305
THE RESOURCES THAT WE SPEND ON
01:18:30.372 --> 01:18:32.874
ELECTRIFICATION AND I WANT TO
01:18:32.941 --> 01:18:35.677
THANK YOU FOR PUTTING THIS
01:18:35.744 --> 01:18:36.745
TOGETHER AND WORKING SO HARD ON
01:18:36.812 --> 01:18:40.682
IT. APPRECIATE IT VERY MUCH.
01:18:40.749 --> 01:18:44.453
GREAT SEEING THE OTHER MIKES.
01:18:44.519 --> 01:18:46.321
OKAY MOTION BY SENATOR CABALLERO
01:18:46.388 --> 01:18:48.023
. UM YOU MAKE CLOTHES
01:18:48.090 --> 01:18:51.793
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN IVO. UM
01:18:51.860 --> 01:18:55.297
THE MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST
01:18:55.363 --> 01:18:57.032
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:18:57.099 --> 01:18:58.100
APPROPRIATIONS AND WILL CALL THE
01:18:58.166 --> 01:19:03.038
ROLL. WIENER WIENER. AYE, BATES
01:19:03.105 --> 01:19:05.173
, NOT VOTING CABALLERO. YOU'RE
01:19:05.240 --> 01:19:09.744
LIKE ORTEZ. MCGUIRE PHð BUG. PHð
01:19:09.811 --> 01:19:11.947
LIKE ORTEZ. MCGUIRE PHð BUG. PHð-BUG I. SKINNER. HAMBURG,
01:19:12.013 --> 01:19:17.385
WIECKOWSKI. 320 OKAY. WE'LL PUT
01:19:17.452 --> 01:19:19.254
THAT ON CALL. THANK YOU VERY
01:19:19.321 --> 01:19:22.324
MUCH, SO REMEMBER. OKAY I WILL
01:19:22.390 --> 01:19:25.327
NOT GO TO ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S TING
01:19:25.393 --> 01:19:28.430
A B 26 56 YOUR OTHER BILL. I
01:19:28.497 --> 01:19:30.532
BELIEVE HIS OWN CONSENT. THANK
01:19:30.599 --> 01:19:33.568
YOU, MR CHAIR. UM FIRST LET ME
01:19:33.635 --> 01:19:35.036
JUST THANK THE COMMITTEE STAFF
01:19:35.103 --> 01:19:36.905
FOR THEIR FOR THEIR ASSISTANCE
01:19:36.972 --> 01:19:37.572
ON THIS BILL AS A COMMITTEE
01:19:37.639 --> 01:19:39.574
KNOWS THE HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY
01:19:39.641 --> 01:19:41.176
ACT, ESTABLISHED IN 1982 WAS
01:19:41.243 --> 01:19:42.210
ESTABLISHED TO LIMIT LOCAL
01:19:42.277 --> 01:19:44.913
AGENCIES ABILITY. COULD DENY
01:19:44.980 --> 01:19:46.548
QUALIFYING HOUSING PROJECTS FROM
01:19:46.615 --> 01:19:48.316
BEING BUILT IN THE JURISDICTION
01:19:48.383 --> 01:19:50.085
OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS, THE
01:19:50.152 --> 01:19:51.786
LEGISLATURE HAS STRENGTHENED THE
01:19:51.853 --> 01:19:53.121
HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY ACT IN
01:19:53.188 --> 01:19:54.589
RESPONSE TO SOME CITIES
01:19:54.656 --> 01:19:56.091
RESORTING TO SOME FAR FETCHED
01:19:56.158 --> 01:19:57.859
ARGUMENTS TO DENY VALID SECRET
01:19:57.926 --> 01:20:00.328
CLEARANCES. FOR EXAMPLE, IN MY
01:20:00.395 --> 01:20:01.630
AND MY TOWN, AS WELL AS SENATORS
01:20:01.696 --> 01:20:02.898
TOWN WE'VE HAD TWO INSTANCES OF
01:20:02.964 --> 01:20:05.800
SAN FRANCISCO ALONE. WHERE HDD
01:20:05.867 --> 01:20:08.837
HAS HAD TO ADDRESS TO SPECIFIC
01:20:08.904 --> 01:20:11.006
EXAMPLES WHERE OUR LOCAL, UM
01:20:11.072 --> 01:20:13.575
LOCAL BOARD HAS GONE TO GREAT
01:20:13.642 --> 01:20:14.676
LENGTHS TO STOP TO HOUSING
01:20:14.743 --> 01:20:18.046
PROJECTS. THIS BILL CLARIFIES
01:20:18.113 --> 01:20:19.614
WHAT A WRONGFUL DENIAL IS, AS
01:20:19.681 --> 01:20:21.082
WELL AS THE WITHHOLDING OF A
01:20:21.149 --> 01:20:22.551
SECRET CLEARANCE. IT DOESN'T
01:20:22.617 --> 01:20:23.151
CHANGE SEQUEL. IT ALSO DOESN'T
01:20:23.218 --> 01:20:25.420
EXPAND DOESN'T EXPAND WHAT
01:20:25.487 --> 01:20:27.122
CONSTITUTES A DISAPPROVAL OF A
01:20:27.189 --> 01:20:29.191
PROJECT. OR DOES IT EXPAND? A
01:20:29.257 --> 01:20:31.126
SECRET EXEMPTIONS TO CHANGE IS
01:20:31.193 --> 01:20:34.095
TOTALLY CONSISTENT WITH H C. D S
01:20:34.162 --> 01:20:34.996
INTERPRETATION OF DISAPPROVAL OF
01:20:35.063 --> 01:20:36.631
THE PROJECT HAVE RECEIVED
01:20:36.698 --> 01:20:37.098
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT AND
01:20:37.165 --> 01:20:38.900
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE ON A
01:20:38.967 --> 01:20:42.804
B. 26 56. I HAVE TWO WITNESSES
01:20:42.871 --> 01:20:44.773
MICHAEL LANE FROM SPUR AND
01:20:44.839 --> 01:20:48.810
CORNELIUS BURKE FROM CBI. GREAT
01:20:48.877 --> 01:20:51.079
MR CHAIR AND MEMBERS. MY CLAIM
01:20:51.146 --> 01:20:52.314
WAS FOR A PUBLIC POLICY THINK
01:20:52.380 --> 01:20:53.982
TANK IN THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY
01:20:54.049 --> 01:20:56.318
AREA. EVERY 26 56 DOES NOT TOUCH
01:20:56.384 --> 01:20:57.018
SEQUENCE ANYWAY, NOR DOES IT
01:20:57.085 --> 01:20:58.086
ALTER ANY EXISTING RIGHTS OR
01:20:58.153 --> 01:20:59.321
RESPONSIBILITIES THAT EXIST IN
01:20:59.387 --> 01:21:01.022
CURRENT LAW WITH REGARD TO THAT
01:21:01.089 --> 01:21:03.792
STATUTE, THIS BILL IN NO WAY
01:21:03.858 --> 01:21:04.926
ELIMINATES OR LIMITS LAWFUL AND
01:21:04.993 --> 01:21:06.194
LEGITIMATE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW.
01:21:06.261 --> 01:21:07.395
NOR DOES IT CHANGE SECRET
01:21:07.462 --> 01:21:08.296
TIMELINES OR TRUNCATE THE
01:21:08.363 --> 01:21:10.398
PROCESS. THE FINANCE AND
01:21:10.465 --> 01:21:11.333
DECLARATIONS WERE AMENDED INTO
01:21:11.399 --> 01:21:12.734
THE BILL TO EXPLICITLY CONVEY
01:21:12.801 --> 01:21:14.236
ITS INTENT TO CLARIFY EXISTING
01:21:14.302 --> 01:21:16.371
LAW AND CODIFY HZDS
01:21:16.438 --> 01:21:17.105
INTERPRETATION OF THE HOUSING
01:21:17.172 --> 01:21:18.106
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT AND ITS
01:21:18.173 --> 01:21:20.642
INTERACTION WITH SEQUEL. THE
01:21:20.709 --> 01:21:21.776
BILL DOES NOT EXPAND THE
01:21:21.843 --> 01:21:23.311
DEFINITION OF DISAPPROVAL UNDER
01:21:23.378 --> 01:21:25.146
THE A, WHICH BOTH THE
01:21:25.213 --> 01:21:26.681
LEGISLATURE HAS FOUND IN COURTS
01:21:26.748 --> 01:21:28.717
HAVE RECOGNIZED ALREADY BROADLY
01:21:28.783 --> 01:21:29.784
INCLUDES ANY REQUIRED LAND USE
01:21:29.851 --> 01:21:30.318
APPROVALS OR ENTITLEMENTS
01:21:30.385 --> 01:21:32.254
NECESSARY. FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A
01:21:32.320 --> 01:21:35.323
BUILDING PERMIT. WHILE THE DOES
01:21:35.390 --> 01:21:37.359
NOT EXEMPT PROJECTS FROM SEQUEL
01:21:37.425 --> 01:21:38.526
THAT ALSO DOES NOT AUTHORIZE
01:21:38.593 --> 01:21:40.695
CITIES TO DENY A SECRET
01:21:40.762 --> 01:21:41.863
CLEARANCE TO WHICH A HOUSING
01:21:41.930 --> 01:21:42.864
DEVELOPMENT IS OTHERWISE LEGALLY
01:21:42.931 --> 01:21:45.467
ENTITLED. MAYBE 26 56 MERELY
01:21:45.533 --> 01:21:46.735
REQUIRES A SECRET EXEMPTION
01:21:46.801 --> 01:21:48.603
ALREADY ON THE BOOKS AND THEN A
01:21:48.670 --> 01:21:49.704
HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS LEGALLY
01:21:49.771 --> 01:21:51.673
ENTITLED TO BASED ON THE RECORD
01:21:51.740 --> 01:21:54.476
BEFORE THE AGENCY BE GRANTED, OR
01:21:54.542 --> 01:21:56.544
THAT AN IR OR NAG DECK WITH A
01:21:56.611 --> 01:21:57.579
LEGALLY SUFFICIENT BASIS IN THE
01:21:57.646 --> 01:21:59.681
RECORD. BE ADOPTED. THIS IN NO
01:21:59.748 --> 01:22:01.182
WAY PRECLUDES ADDITIONAL STUDY
01:22:01.249 --> 01:22:03.118
IF THE NEED IS IDENTIFIED. THE
01:22:03.184 --> 01:22:05.854
FACT IS A B 26 56 ONLY SEEKS TO
01:22:05.920 --> 01:22:07.422
ENFORCE THE LAWS AROUND
01:22:07.489 --> 01:22:08.523
ENVIRONMENT REVIEW THAT ARE
01:22:08.590 --> 01:22:09.658
ALREADY IN STATUTE AND WE
01:22:09.724 --> 01:22:11.926
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AND I VOTE.
01:22:11.993 --> 01:22:16.298
THANK YOU. GO AHEAD. GOOD
01:22:16.364 --> 01:22:17.899
AFTERNOON CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF
01:22:17.966 --> 01:22:19.200
THE COMMITTEE CORNELIUS BURKE
01:22:19.267 --> 01:22:20.468
WITH THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING
01:22:20.535 --> 01:22:22.170
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION. WE ARE THE
01:22:22.237 --> 01:22:23.905
HOMEBUILDERS. WE'RE PROUD TO
01:22:23.972 --> 01:22:26.641
SUPPORT A B 26 56. IN FACT, WE
01:22:26.708 --> 01:22:28.543
HAVE CALLED IT A HOUSING CREATOR
01:22:28.610 --> 01:22:30.345
FOR THIS YEAR. THIS IS IMPORTANT
01:22:30.412 --> 01:22:31.946
BILL TO SOLVE OUR STATES
01:22:32.013 --> 01:22:33.448
HOUSING CRISIS AS MICHAEL LANE
01:22:33.515 --> 01:22:35.550
FROM SPUR JUST MENTIONED. THIS
01:22:35.617 --> 01:22:37.285
BILL DOES NOT EXEMPT PRODUCTS IN
01:22:37.352 --> 01:22:38.820
SEQUENCE DOES NOT CHANGE SEQUEL
01:22:38.887 --> 01:22:40.055
. WHAT IT REALLY DOES. IS THAT A
01:22:40.121 --> 01:22:42.891
CLOSE A LOOPHOLE IN THE HOUSE OF
01:22:42.957 --> 01:22:44.326
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT RECENTLY
01:22:44.392 --> 01:22:45.327
CREATED BY SOME TO ADD
01:22:45.393 --> 01:22:46.928
ADDITIONAL STEPS IN CALIFORNIA'S
01:22:46.995 --> 01:22:48.930
LENGTHY AND COMPLICATED HOUSING
01:22:48.997 --> 01:22:50.899
APPROVAL PROCESS IN AN EFFORT TO
01:22:50.965 --> 01:22:52.434
SCUTTLE ADDITIONAL HOUSING, SOME
01:22:52.500 --> 01:22:53.535
JURISDICTIONS HAVE REQUIRED
01:22:53.601 --> 01:22:55.737
FURTHER ENVIRONMENT REVIEW. IN
01:22:55.804 --> 01:22:57.505
ADDITION TO COMPLY WITH SEEKER
01:22:57.572 --> 01:22:58.840
WHERE THERE WAS NOT ILLEGALLY
01:22:58.907 --> 01:23:00.542
SUFFICIENT BASIS FOR DOING SO.
01:23:00.608 --> 01:23:02.043
ALTERNATIVELY SOME JURISDICTIONS
01:23:02.110 --> 01:23:04.546
HAVE DENIED EXEMPTION FOR SICA
01:23:04.612 --> 01:23:05.947
WHEN A HOUSING PROJECT WAS
01:23:06.014 --> 01:23:07.882
ELIGIBLE FOR THE EXEMPTION. 80
01:23:07.949 --> 01:23:09.050
26 36 CLOSES ITS ABUSIVE
01:23:09.117 --> 01:23:12.220
LOOPHOLE. FOR THESE REASONS AND
01:23:12.287 --> 01:23:14.923
MORE A B 26 56 IS A HOUSING
01:23:14.989 --> 01:23:16.024
CREATOR. WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:23:16.091 --> 01:23:21.296
YOUR VOTE. I'VE BEEN STARTING
01:23:21.363 --> 01:23:22.664
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT OF PUBLIC
01:23:22.731 --> 01:23:24.065
COMMENT ON SOCIETY, CALIFORNIA
01:23:24.132 --> 01:23:29.371
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP AND SUPPORT. HOLLY FOR MANY INTO HIS DUES
01:23:29.437 --> 01:23:30.472
WITH LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS
01:23:30.538 --> 01:23:31.940
HERE TODAY AND SUPPORT ON BEHALF
01:23:32.006 --> 01:23:32.407
PACIFIC WELL, SANDHILL
01:23:32.474 --> 01:23:33.975
PROPERTIES IN B ACTION AND
01:23:34.042 --> 01:23:38.146
FIELDS DONE. JORDAN PLANET
01:23:38.213 --> 01:23:39.347
KANDAHAR ON BEHALF OF CONFERENCE
01:23:39.414 --> 01:23:42.717
ROOM B AND SUPPORT ANY
01:23:42.784 --> 01:23:44.819
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT HERE
01:23:44.886 --> 01:23:46.421
IN ROOM 2100 SAYING THAT WE'LL
01:23:46.488 --> 01:23:48.790
GO TO THE PHONE LINE PHONE LINE,
01:23:48.857 --> 01:23:49.758
MADAM MODERATOR, COULD YOU
01:23:49.824 --> 01:23:52.327
PLEASE QUEUE UP SUPPORT? THANK
01:23:52.394 --> 01:23:53.995
YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. YOU MAY
01:23:54.062 --> 01:23:58.700
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
01:23:58.767 --> 01:23:59.401
ONE AND THEN ZERO. FEAR IN
01:23:59.467 --> 01:24:04.606
SUPPORT OF A B 26 56. WE WOULD
01:24:04.672 --> 01:24:06.641
GO TO LINE 2 71. YOUR LINE IS
01:24:06.708 --> 01:24:10.678
OPEN. HI. THIS IS ADAM BOOK DNB
01:24:10.745 --> 01:24:12.781
SUPPORTER OF A B 26 56. THANK
01:24:12.847 --> 01:24:16.484
YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT. WE'RE
01:24:16.551 --> 01:24:18.486
GOING TO LINE 2 75. YOUR LINE IS
01:24:18.553 --> 01:24:22.190
OPEN. PRACTICES AROUND O'CONNELL
01:24:22.257 --> 01:24:23.324
CALLING FROM NAPA. SOLANO, UM,
01:24:23.391 --> 01:24:27.328
BE IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
01:24:27.395 --> 01:24:29.230
YOU NEXT TO THE LINE TO 28. YOUR
01:24:29.297 --> 01:24:33.935
LINE IS OPEN. PRIVATE CHILI ON
01:24:34.002 --> 01:24:35.069
BEHALF OF HOUSING ACTION
01:24:35.136 --> 01:24:38.973
COALITION AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU
01:24:39.040 --> 01:24:44.279
AND NEXT LINE TO 69. HI IT'S
01:24:44.345 --> 01:24:45.046
PHILIPPA CHECKER WITH THE LOS
01:24:45.113 --> 01:24:46.848
ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:24:46.915 --> 01:24:51.052
IN SUPPORT. THANK YOU, MR
01:24:51.119 --> 01:24:52.554
CHARIOT. NO FURTHER SUPPORTING
01:24:52.620 --> 01:24:54.155
QUÊ. THANK YOU VERY MUCH WILL
01:24:54.222 --> 01:24:56.558
NOW GO TO OPPOSITION. IS THERE
01:24:56.624 --> 01:24:57.725
ANY OPPOSITION HERE IN THE ROOM?
01:24:57.792 --> 01:25:04.799
PLEASE COME FORWARD. GOOD
01:25:04.866 --> 01:25:06.801
AFTERNOON, CHAIRMAN OR MEMBERS
01:25:06.868 --> 01:25:08.470
OF THE COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS
01:25:08.536 --> 01:25:09.471
CRISTINA KERO MAN ATTORNEY ON
01:25:09.537 --> 01:25:11.339
BEHALF OF THE STATE BUILDING
01:25:11.406 --> 01:25:12.140
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL HERE
01:25:12.207 --> 01:25:15.944
IN OPPOSITION TO 26 56. OUR
01:25:16.010 --> 01:25:17.412
OPPOSITION IS BASED ON FORMING
01:25:17.479 --> 01:25:19.814
REASONS. SO CONTRARY TO WHAT
01:25:19.881 --> 01:25:22.584
SOME OF THE SUPPORT HAS STATED,
01:25:22.650 --> 01:25:23.418
THIS BILL WOULD ACTUALLY
01:25:23.485 --> 01:25:25.920
REDEFINE BASIC LAND USE LAWS BY
01:25:25.987 --> 01:25:27.322
CREATING A NEW AND EXPANDED
01:25:27.388 --> 01:25:28.389
DEFINITION OF PROJECT
01:25:28.456 --> 01:25:30.992
DISAPPROVAL. WHICH WOULD OCCUR
01:25:31.059 --> 01:25:33.394
AT SOME AMBIGUOUS POINT DURING
01:25:33.461 --> 01:25:34.429
THE AGENCY'S DECISION MAKING
01:25:34.496 --> 01:25:37.232
PROCESS ON A PROJECT. THIS WOULD
01:25:37.298 --> 01:25:39.033
PROHIBIT AGENCIES FROM COMPLYING
01:25:39.100 --> 01:25:40.869
WITH THEIR LEGAL OBLIGATIONS TO
01:25:40.935 --> 01:25:42.704
REQUIRE ADDITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL
01:25:42.770 --> 01:25:45.106
AND PUBLIC HEALTH REVIEW AND
01:25:45.173 --> 01:25:46.341
MITIGATION WHEN THEY REASONABLY
01:25:46.407 --> 01:25:47.408
BELIEVE, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE
01:25:47.475 --> 01:25:50.044
IN THE RECORD. THAT A PROJECT
01:25:50.111 --> 01:25:51.646
DOES NOT MEET ITS ENVIRONMENTAL
01:25:51.713 --> 01:25:53.781
REQUIREMENTS IS NOT EXEMPT FROM
01:25:53.848 --> 01:25:55.383
SEQUA, OR THAT ADDITIONAL
01:25:55.450 --> 01:25:57.785
ANALYSIS IS REQUIRED IN ORDER TO
01:25:57.852 --> 01:25:58.419
DETERMINE HOW TO BEST MITIGATE
01:25:58.486 --> 01:25:59.787
THOSE IMPACTS AS REQUIRED BY
01:25:59.854 --> 01:26:02.857
LAW. SO, FOR EXAMPLE, WHETHER AN
01:26:02.924 --> 01:26:05.226
EXCEPTION TO A SECRET EXEMPTION
01:26:05.293 --> 01:26:07.729
APPLIES OR WHETHER FURTHER STUDY
01:26:07.795 --> 01:26:09.297
IS REQUIRED AFTER CONSIDERING
01:26:09.364 --> 01:26:10.365
PUBLIC COMMENT ON A NEGATIVE
01:26:10.431 --> 01:26:13.067
DECLARATION OR ANY IR THESE ARE
01:26:13.134 --> 01:26:14.536
FACT BASED QUESTIONS THEY'RE
01:26:14.602 --> 01:26:16.137
MADE ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS BY
01:26:16.204 --> 01:26:18.172
THE DECISION MAKER. THIS BILL
01:26:18.239 --> 01:26:19.941
WOULD SHIFT THAT DECISION MAKING
01:26:20.008 --> 01:26:21.576
PROCESS FROM THE AGENCY AS
01:26:21.643 --> 01:26:24.212
REQUIRED BY LAW TO THE COURTS.
01:26:24.279 --> 01:26:26.548
SECOND MAYBE 26 56 WOULD CREATE
01:26:26.614 --> 01:26:27.549
AN INTERNALLY INCONSISTENT
01:26:27.615 --> 01:26:31.185
STATUES. SO DENIAL OF A SECRET
01:26:31.252 --> 01:26:32.787
CLEARANCES PRECISELY NOT
01:26:32.854 --> 01:26:34.255
ENCOMPASSED IN THE HOUSING
01:26:34.322 --> 01:26:35.557
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT'S EXISTING
01:26:35.623 --> 01:26:37.559
DEFINITION OF PROJECT
01:26:37.625 --> 01:26:38.793
DISAPPROVAL, AND THAT IS BECAUSE
01:26:38.860 --> 01:26:40.795
THE HOUSING ACCOUNTABILITY ACT
01:26:40.862 --> 01:26:42.797
SAYS THE OPPOSITE. IT SAYS THAT
01:26:42.864 --> 01:26:43.965
NOTHING SHALL AFFECT COMPLIANCE
01:26:44.032 --> 01:26:46.768
WITH SEQUEL. THE AGENCY MUST
01:26:46.834 --> 01:26:48.202
MAKE FINDINGS UNDER SECRET IN
01:26:48.269 --> 01:26:50.238
ORDER TO APPROVE A PROJECT AND
01:26:50.305 --> 01:26:51.706
THE AGENCY MUST ALSO MAKE
01:26:51.773 --> 01:26:52.774
FINDINGS UNDER THE HOUSING
01:26:52.840 --> 01:26:54.142
ACCOUNTABILITY ACT, AND THOSE
01:26:54.208 --> 01:26:55.476
FINDINGS WOULD BE IRRECONCILABLY
01:26:55.543 --> 01:26:56.377
INCONSISTENT IF THIS BILL WERE
01:26:56.444 --> 01:27:02.183
PASSED. THIRD THE BILL VIOLATES
01:27:02.250 --> 01:27:04.185
BASIC ADMINISTRATIVE AND LOCAL
01:27:04.252 --> 01:27:05.019
ADMINISTRATIVE EXHAUSTION
01:27:05.086 --> 01:27:07.922
REQUIREMENTS. BY ALLOWING A
01:27:07.989 --> 01:27:09.657
DEVELOPER TO FILE A LAWSUIT IN
01:27:09.724 --> 01:27:10.925
THE MIDDLE OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE
01:27:10.992 --> 01:27:13.061
PROCESS BEFORE THE AGENCY HAS
01:27:13.127 --> 01:27:14.562
TAKEN FINAL ACTION AND WITHOUT
01:27:14.629 --> 01:27:16.064
COMPLYING WITH LOCAL AGENCY
01:27:16.130 --> 01:27:17.865
PROCEDURES, WHICH WOULD ENTITLE
01:27:17.932 --> 01:27:19.033
MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC TO FILE
01:27:19.100 --> 01:27:21.302
THAT LAWSUIT IN THE FIRST PLACE.
01:27:21.369 --> 01:27:23.838
FINALLY A B 26 56 IS
01:27:23.905 --> 01:27:25.907
INCONSISTENT WITH THE CODE OF
01:27:25.974 --> 01:27:27.408
CIVIL PROCEDURE, WHICH IS A
01:27:27.475 --> 01:27:29.110
STATUTE THAT GOVERNS THE ABILITY
01:27:29.177 --> 01:27:31.312
TO FILE A LAND USE LAWSUIT. SO
01:27:31.379 --> 01:27:32.714
THEY COULD HAVE CIVIL PROCEDURE
01:27:32.780 --> 01:27:34.916
HAS THE COURT LOOK AT WHETHER AN
01:27:34.983 --> 01:27:37.051
AGENCY HAS VIOLATED A MANDATORY
01:27:37.118 --> 01:27:38.720
DUTY OR WHETHER THEY'RE DECISION
01:27:38.786 --> 01:27:39.787
WAS SUPPORTED BY SUBSTANTIAL
01:27:39.854 --> 01:27:42.790
EVIDENCE. THIS BILL WOULD
01:27:42.857 --> 01:27:44.325
REQUIRE THE COURT TO WEIGH
01:27:44.392 --> 01:27:46.060
EVIDENCE BASED ON AN INCOMPLETE
01:27:46.127 --> 01:27:48.329
PARTIAL RECORD WITH NON EXISTENT
01:27:48.396 --> 01:27:49.597
FINDINGS, WHICH THE PETITIONER
01:27:49.664 --> 01:27:51.466
SAYS SHOULD HAVE BEEN MADE BUT
01:27:51.532 --> 01:27:54.235
WEREN'T AND IT WOULD ALLOW THE
01:27:54.302 --> 01:27:55.670
COURT TO DETERMINE WHETHER THAT
01:27:55.737 --> 01:27:57.538
PARTIAL RECORD SHOULD HAVE BEEN
01:27:57.605 --> 01:27:58.706
ENOUGH TO APPROVE A PROJECT THAT
01:27:58.773 --> 01:28:00.642
WOULD TURN THE LAW ON ITS HEAD,
01:28:00.708 --> 01:28:01.576
CALIFORNIA CODE OF CIVIL
01:28:01.643 --> 01:28:03.745
PROCEDURE AND SEQUA PUT THAT
01:28:03.811 --> 01:28:04.278
DECISION MAKING AUTHORITY
01:28:04.345 --> 01:28:05.913
SQUARELY ON THE AGENCY AND NOT
01:28:05.980 --> 01:28:08.049
ON THE COURSE. SO FOR THESE
01:28:08.116 --> 01:28:09.417
REASONS, WE URGED THE COMMITTEE
01:28:09.484 --> 01:28:11.953
TO VOTE NO ON THIS BILL, AND I'M
01:28:12.020 --> 01:28:13.154
HAPPY TO TAKE ANY QUESTIONS.
01:28:13.221 --> 01:28:15.423
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
01:28:15.490 --> 01:28:17.525
ANY ADDITONAL OPPOSITION PUBLIC
01:28:17.592 --> 01:28:20.795
COMMENT HERE IN ROOM 2100?
01:28:20.862 --> 01:28:22.063
SEEING NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE
01:28:22.130 --> 01:28:27.201
LINES. META MODERATOR. THANK YOU
01:28:27.268 --> 01:28:28.870
IF YOU'RE NOT POSITION OF A B 26
01:28:28.936 --> 01:28:30.838
56, YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
01:28:30.905 --> 01:28:34.876
ZERO. AGAIN THAT IT'S ONE IN THE
01:28:34.942 --> 01:28:41.215
ZERO FAIR IN OPPOSITION. AND WE
01:28:41.282 --> 01:28:44.752
HAVE NO OPPOSITION IN CUBA AT-THIS TIME, MR. CHAIR THANK YOU
01:28:44.819 --> 01:28:45.853
VERY MUCH FOR BRINGING BACK TO
01:28:45.920 --> 01:28:47.622
THE COMMITTEE. UM COLLEAGUES ANY
01:28:47.689 --> 01:28:48.690
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FOR THE
01:28:48.756 --> 01:28:52.226
AUTHOR. YES SENATOR JOBURG. I
01:28:52.293 --> 01:28:55.063
WOULD JUST LOVE AN OPPORTUNITY
01:28:55.129 --> 01:28:58.066
OR THROUGH THE CHAIR. IF HE, UM,
01:28:58.132 --> 01:28:59.100
OF THE OTHER WOULD WOULDN'T MIND
01:28:59.167 --> 01:29:00.134
ADDRESSING THE CONCERNS OF THE
01:29:00.201 --> 01:29:03.304
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU HAPPY TO
01:29:03.371 --> 01:29:04.105
THAT'S GOING TO HAVE MICHAEL
01:29:04.172 --> 01:29:06.340
LANE FROM SPURRED TO THAT THAT'S
01:29:06.407 --> 01:29:08.676
OKAY WITH YOU. GREAT THANK YOU.
01:29:08.743 --> 01:29:10.712
JUST A FEW POINTS TO REPEAT WHAT
01:29:10.778 --> 01:29:12.180
? YOU JUST HEARD THE DEFINITION
01:29:12.246 --> 01:29:13.848
OF DISAPPROVAL UNDER THE ALREADY
01:29:13.915 --> 01:29:15.750
EXTENDS TO A NEGATIVE VOTE ON
01:29:15.817 --> 01:29:17.285
ANY REQUIRED LAND USE APPROVALS
01:29:17.351 --> 01:29:18.219
OR ENTITLEMENTS NECESSARY FOR
01:29:18.286 --> 01:29:19.454
THE ISSUANCE OF A BUILDING
01:29:19.520 --> 01:29:21.422
PERMIT NOW, BUT ALSO IN INCLUDE
01:29:21.489 --> 01:29:22.457
THE ENVIRONMENTAL WORK THAT
01:29:22.523 --> 01:29:24.592
NEEDS TO BE DONE. SO THE ISSUE
01:29:24.659 --> 01:29:25.927
THERE IS IF A JURISDICTION
01:29:25.993 --> 01:29:27.528
DENIES A VALID EXEMPTION, FOR
01:29:27.595 --> 01:29:28.963
EXAMPLE, TYPICALLY, DEVELOPERS
01:29:29.030 --> 01:29:30.698
DID NOT BRING LITIGATION IF THEY
01:29:30.765 --> 01:29:31.999
DO PROVIDE THE EXEMPTION.
01:29:32.066 --> 01:29:33.267
OFTENTIMES NEIGHBORS WILL SUE
01:29:33.334 --> 01:29:35.203
FOR $900, WHICH IS TO FILE A
01:29:35.269 --> 01:29:38.239
LAWSUIT. AND SO THEY GO THROUGH
01:29:38.306 --> 01:29:39.407
AND DO THE ENTIRE ENVIRONMENTAL
01:29:39.474 --> 01:29:40.975
WORK. EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE
01:29:41.042 --> 01:29:42.276
ENTITLED TO THAT EXEMPTION. THEY
01:29:42.343 --> 01:29:43.244
DON'T CHALLENGE IT IN COURT
01:29:43.311 --> 01:29:45.179
BECAUSE THE JUDGE WOULD JUST
01:29:45.246 --> 01:29:46.781
REMANDED BACK TO THE LEAD
01:29:46.848 --> 01:29:48.015
AGENCY. THEY'D HAVE TO JUST TELL
01:29:48.082 --> 01:29:49.117
THEM TO DO MORE ENVIRONMENTAL
01:29:49.183 --> 01:29:50.284
WORK. SO WE'RE NOT. WE'RE SAYING
01:29:50.351 --> 01:29:51.886
GO THROUGH THE ENTIRE PROCESS IS
01:29:51.953 --> 01:29:53.121
JUST THAT ONE STAFF BRINGS THE
01:29:53.187 --> 01:29:55.456
DECISION MAKING BODY, A DOCUMENT
01:29:55.523 --> 01:29:57.058
THAT COULD BE CERTIFIED. THEY
01:29:57.125 --> 01:29:59.127
NEED TO GO AHEAD AND DO SO
01:29:59.193 --> 01:30:00.361
UNLESS THERE IS A RECORD IN
01:30:00.428 --> 01:30:01.329
ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD THAT
01:30:01.395 --> 01:30:02.396
IDENTIFIES ADDITIONAL NEED FOR
01:30:02.463 --> 01:30:03.498
STUDY, SO IT'S NOT JUST
01:30:03.564 --> 01:30:04.732
EFFICIENT EXPEDITION. TRYING TO
01:30:04.799 --> 01:30:06.567
FIND REASONS TO STALL OUT
01:30:06.634 --> 01:30:08.536
BECAUSE THE DEADLINES AND
01:30:08.603 --> 01:30:09.604
TIMELINES AND STATUTE FOR SECRET
01:30:09.670 --> 01:30:11.105
OR NOT ENFORCEABLE, THE COURTS
01:30:11.172 --> 01:30:13.007
HAVE ALREADY FOUND THAT WE DO
01:30:13.074 --> 01:30:14.242
HAVE AN HCG LETTER THAT SAYS,
01:30:14.308 --> 01:30:16.544
ACTUALLY, THE ACTIONS THAT MR
01:30:16.611 --> 01:30:17.345
TING HAD TALKED ABOUT IN SAN
01:30:17.411 --> 01:30:18.279
FRANCISCO MAY ACTUALLY
01:30:18.346 --> 01:30:19.647
CONSTITUTE EFFECTIVE DENIAL
01:30:19.714 --> 01:30:21.916
UNDER THE BECAUSE BECAUSE OF THE
01:30:21.983 --> 01:30:24.285
FACT PATTERN IN THAT CASE. WHAT
01:30:24.352 --> 01:30:26.888
OUR BILL SEEKS TO DO IS ACTUALLY
01:30:26.954 --> 01:30:27.822
RUN THROUGH THE ENTIRE DOESN'T
01:30:27.889 --> 01:30:29.524
CUT THE PROCESS SHORT AT ALL RUN
01:30:29.590 --> 01:30:30.191
THROUGH THE FOUR SECRET
01:30:30.258 --> 01:30:32.360
TIMELINES THAT'S 30 DAYS TO
01:30:32.426 --> 01:30:32.994
DETERMINE WHETHER AN EXEMPTION
01:30:33.060 --> 01:30:35.596
IS VALID SIX MONTHS FOR A
01:30:35.663 --> 01:30:36.831
NEGATIVE DECLARATION OR THE FULL
01:30:36.898 --> 01:30:39.433
YEAR FOR THE E I. R FOR THE
01:30:39.500 --> 01:30:41.202
UPPER COMPLETE FULL O'NEILL AREA
01:30:41.269 --> 01:30:42.870
AFTER THAT POINT IF THERE IS IN
01:30:42.937 --> 01:30:44.772
THE RECORD AND A NEED FOR
01:30:44.839 --> 01:30:46.040
ADDITIONAL STUDY THAT CAN BE
01:30:46.107 --> 01:30:48.075
DONE, CERTAINLY UNDER THIS BILL
01:30:48.142 --> 01:30:49.377
, AS I SAID THAT THE COURTS HAVE
01:30:49.443 --> 01:30:51.746
ALREADY RECOGNIZED THE DOES NOT
01:30:51.813 --> 01:30:52.914
ALLOW YOU TO INDEFINITELY. D<c.cyan></c>
01:30:52.980 --> 01:30:55.516
SEQUENCE STUDIES AS A WAY TO GET
01:30:55.583 --> 01:30:57.118
AROUND OUTRIGHT DENIAL OR MAKING
01:30:57.185 --> 01:30:58.252
A DECISION. YES OR NO ON A
01:30:58.319 --> 01:31:00.221
PROJECT. AND THAT'S WHAT WE'RE
01:31:00.288 --> 01:31:02.557
TRYING TO AVOIDERS. THE INFINITE
01:31:02.623 --> 01:31:04.559
STUDIES WITHOUT MERIT THAT EVEN
01:31:04.625 --> 01:31:06.060
WHEN STAFFS BROUGHT FORWARD
01:31:06.127 --> 01:31:06.661
ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS THAT
01:31:06.727 --> 01:31:08.329
COULD BE APPROVED BY THE
01:31:08.396 --> 01:31:11.766
LEGISLATIVE BODY. THANK YOU. ANY
01:31:11.833 --> 01:31:12.867
OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
01:31:12.934 --> 01:31:18.806
COLLEAGUES. OKAY? UM SO FIRST OF
01:31:18.873 --> 01:31:21.042
ALL, I WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
01:31:21.108 --> 01:31:22.443
FOR BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD.
01:31:22.510 --> 01:31:25.580
I STRONGLY SUPPORT IT, AND I
01:31:25.646 --> 01:31:26.681
KNOW THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE WAS
01:31:26.747 --> 01:31:29.584
FLAGGED IN A MAJOR WAY. UMAND
01:31:29.650 --> 01:31:31.118
THE STEVENSON STREET PROJECT IN
01:31:31.185 --> 01:31:33.321
SAN FRANCISCO, BUT I KNOW THAT'S
01:31:33.387 --> 01:31:35.556
CERTAINLY JUST AN EXAMPLE. UM
01:31:35.623 --> 01:31:38.059
AND THIS REALLY IS A FOCUSED
01:31:38.125 --> 01:31:39.560
BILL. I RESPECT THE OPPOSITION
01:31:39.627 --> 01:31:42.763
AND THEIR CONTENTIONS, BUT I IS
01:31:42.830 --> 01:31:45.366
A FOCUS BILL DESIGNED TO ADDRESS
01:31:45.433 --> 01:31:47.802
THE SITUATION WHERE GOVERNING
01:31:47.869 --> 01:31:50.204
BODY IS BASICALLY ABUSING SEQUA
01:31:50.271 --> 01:31:52.240
AS A WAY TO EFFECTIVELY DENY A
01:31:52.306 --> 01:31:55.776
PROJECT ON THE MERIT. AND WE SAW
01:31:55.843 --> 01:31:57.278
THAT IN STEVENSON STREET WITH
01:31:57.345 --> 01:31:58.813
FRANKLY, THE STATEMENTS THAT
01:31:58.880 --> 01:32:00.414
WERE MADE BY SOME OF MY FORMER
01:32:00.481 --> 01:32:02.583
COLLEAGUES ON THE BOARD OF
01:32:02.650 --> 01:32:03.451
SUPERVISORS THAT WERE, FRANKLY
01:32:03.517 --> 01:32:05.119
EITHER NOT SECRET ISSUES AT ALL,
01:32:05.186 --> 01:32:06.320
OR ISSUES WHERE THERE DID NOT
01:32:06.387 --> 01:32:08.289
APPEAR TO BE ANY REAL BASIS. IN
01:32:08.356 --> 01:32:09.857
THE RECORD AND AGAIN. THAT'S
01:32:09.924 --> 01:32:12.326
JUST ONE EXAMPLE. AND THAT WAS A
01:32:12.393 --> 01:32:14.295
VERY GLARING EXAMPLE. BUT WE
01:32:14.362 --> 01:32:15.930
KNOW THIS HAPPENS IN OTHER
01:32:15.997 --> 01:32:20.167
SITUATIONS AND SEQUA IS, UM NOT
01:32:20.234 --> 01:32:22.904
DOES NOT EXIST TO BE AWAY FOR A
01:32:22.970 --> 01:32:24.772
GOVERNING BODY TO EFFECTIVELY DO
01:32:24.839 --> 01:32:27.108
A MERIT REJECTION OF A PROJECT.
01:32:27.174 --> 01:32:29.243
IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE ABOUT SEQUA
01:32:29.310 --> 01:32:31.779
, AND THIS BILL PROVIDES THAT
01:32:31.846 --> 01:32:33.381
CLARITY AND MAKES IT CLEAR THAT
01:32:33.447 --> 01:32:35.116
YOU CAN'T GET AROUND THE H A
01:32:35.182 --> 01:32:40.087
WITH A BOGUS SEQUA. REJECTION SO
01:32:40.154 --> 01:32:43.591
WITH THAT, UM, YOU MAY CLOSE NO,
01:32:43.658 --> 01:32:45.393
NO, THANK YOU. THANK YOU. I
01:32:45.459 --> 01:32:47.228
THINK YOU SUMMED IT UP VERY WELL
01:32:47.295 --> 01:32:48.896
. AND I THINK THE ONLY THING I
01:32:48.963 --> 01:32:50.197
WOULD JUST ADD IS OFTENTIMES
01:32:50.264 --> 01:32:51.299
WHAT IS THE WORST SITUATION IS
01:32:51.365 --> 01:32:53.601
WHEN PROJECTS ARE JUST HELD IN
01:32:53.668 --> 01:32:54.702
LIMBO. THEY'RE NOT ASKED TO
01:32:54.769 --> 01:32:56.404
ADDRESS ANYTHING. THEY'RE TOLD
01:32:56.470 --> 01:32:59.440
THAT PERHAPS SOMEDAY THERE'LL BE
01:32:59.507 --> 01:33:00.942
TOLD WHAT THEY NEED TO ADDRESS
01:33:01.008 --> 01:33:02.443
AND THEY JUST SIT THERE. SO THIS
01:33:02.510 --> 01:33:04.312
IS A WAY TO GET SOME CERTAINTY
01:33:04.378 --> 01:33:05.146
FOR PROJECTS, WHETHER IT'S A
01:33:05.212 --> 01:33:07.848
REJECTION OR APPROVAL. AND AS AS
01:33:07.915 --> 01:33:09.216
YOU MENTIONED, WE THINK THIS IS
01:33:09.283 --> 01:33:10.685
A NARROWLY CRAFTED BILL TO
01:33:10.751 --> 01:33:12.586
TACKLE THIS VERY SPECIFIC ISSUE.
01:33:12.653 --> 01:33:13.721
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A VOTE ON
01:33:13.788 --> 01:33:15.423
MAYBE 26 56. GREAT. DO WE HAVE A
01:33:15.489 --> 01:33:19.026
MOTION? TO MOVE MOVE BY SENATOR
01:33:19.093 --> 01:33:20.895
WIECKOWSKI AND WE WILL CALL THE
01:33:20.962 --> 01:33:29.203
ROLL. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT
01:33:29.270 --> 01:33:30.338
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
01:33:30.404 --> 01:33:31.238
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
01:33:31.305 --> 01:33:33.140
FINANCE WIENER BATES. I
01:33:33.207 --> 01:33:38.279
CABALLERO. CORTESI. MCGUIRE. PHí
01:33:38.346 --> 01:33:42.183
BUG BUG. I SKINNER. BLOOMBERG
01:33:42.249 --> 01:33:45.419
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I 4 TO 0
01:33:45.486 --> 01:33:47.488
AND WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
01:33:47.555 --> 01:33:50.124
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY NEXT
01:33:50.191 --> 01:33:53.627
SUMMER MEMBER GRAYSON, UM HE WAS
01:33:53.694 --> 01:33:58.199
TWO BILLS. WELL MAYBE 21 86 26
01:33:58.265 --> 01:33:59.133
68. WHICH WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:33:59.200 --> 01:34:01.836
PRESENT 1ST 21 86 ITEM? MAYBE 21
01:34:01.902 --> 01:34:06.407
86 1. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
01:34:06.474 --> 01:34:08.709
CHAIR AND VERY MEMBERS. I AM
01:34:08.776 --> 01:34:10.878
PLEASED TO PRESENT A B 21 86,
01:34:10.945 --> 01:34:12.713
WHICH WILL ESTABLISH THE HOUSING
01:34:12.780 --> 01:34:14.048
COST REDUCTION THAT SENATE
01:34:14.115 --> 01:34:16.384
PROGRAM TO INCENTIVIZE LOCAL
01:34:16.450 --> 01:34:18.219
JURISDICTIONS TO REDUCE OR DEFER
01:34:18.285 --> 01:34:19.520
LOCAL IMPACT FEES FOR AFFORDABLE
01:34:19.587 --> 01:34:22.256
HOUSING PROJECTS. SO DESPITE THE
01:34:22.323 --> 01:34:24.291
MONUMENTAL EFFORTS FROM THE
01:34:24.358 --> 01:34:26.694
LEGISLATURE, IT CONTINUES TO BE
01:34:26.761 --> 01:34:28.262
TOO EXPENSIVE TO BUILD IN THE
01:34:28.329 --> 01:34:30.331
STATE OF CALIFORNIA IMPACT FEES
01:34:30.398 --> 01:34:32.199
CAN ACTUALLY REPRESENT UP TO 18%
01:34:32.266 --> 01:34:33.501
OF THE COST ASSOCIATED WITH
01:34:33.567 --> 01:34:35.903
BUILDING NEW HOUSING. THIS COST
01:34:35.970 --> 01:34:38.239
US ADDED DIRECTLY ONTO THE COST
01:34:38.305 --> 01:34:39.840
OF THE UNIT, OFTEN MAKING IT
01:34:39.907 --> 01:34:42.676
DIFFICULT OR EVEN IMPOSSIBLE TO
01:34:42.743 --> 01:34:45.012
BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 21 86
01:34:45.079 --> 01:34:46.514
PROVIDES TO INCENTIVES TO
01:34:46.580 --> 01:34:48.716
ADDRESS THE PROBLEM FIRST, MAYBE
01:34:48.783 --> 01:34:50.217
21 86 WILL PROVIDE LOCAL
01:34:50.284 --> 01:34:52.720
JURISDICTIONS WITH 50. OF THE
01:34:52.787 --> 01:34:54.422
VALUE OF THE FEE REDUCTION
01:34:54.488 --> 01:34:56.190
GRANTED FOR THE PROJECT, AND
01:34:56.257 --> 01:34:57.458
THEN SECONDLY, ALLOWING
01:34:57.525 --> 01:34:59.593
JURISDICTIONS TO DEFER FEES.
01:34:59.660 --> 01:35:01.128
ANGELA HOUSING PROJECT IS
01:35:01.195 --> 01:35:02.830
CONVERTED TO PERMANENT FINANCING
01:35:02.897 --> 01:35:05.032
WHILE CHARGING INTEREST. THE
01:35:05.099 --> 01:35:06.434
STATE WILL THEN BACKFILL THAT
01:35:06.500 --> 01:35:07.968
INTEREST, EFFECTIVELY PROVIDIN
01:35:08.035 --> 01:35:09.737
DEVELOPERS WITH A ZERO INTEREST
01:35:09.804 --> 01:35:10.237
LOAN AND ENSURING LOCAL
01:35:10.304 --> 01:35:13.307
JURISDICTIONS ARE MADE WHOLE.
01:35:13.374 --> 01:35:14.775
THIS INCENTIVE PROGRAM WILL
01:35:14.842 --> 01:35:17.111
SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE THE COST OF
01:35:17.178 --> 01:35:18.679
BUILDING HOUSING WHILE
01:35:18.746 --> 01:35:19.146
SUPPORTING BOTH LOCAL
01:35:19.213 --> 01:35:20.581
JURISDICTIONS AND AFFORDABLE
01:35:20.648 --> 01:35:23.084
HOUSING DEVELOPERS. I DO HAVE A
01:35:23.150 --> 01:35:24.285
WITNESS TO THE CHAIR, MR MR MARK
01:35:24.351 --> 01:35:25.453
STIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
01:35:25.519 --> 01:35:28.789
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP. RIGHT GOOD
01:35:28.856 --> 01:35:29.590
AFTERNOON MARKS. DIVERS WITH THE
01:35:29.657 --> 01:35:30.858
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP,
01:35:30.925 --> 01:35:32.493
PROUD TO SPONSOR THIS MEASURE,
01:35:32.560 --> 01:35:33.294
JUST LIKE TO HIGHLIGHT TWO
01:35:33.360 --> 01:35:35.329
THINGS BRIEFLY ONE. THIS IS A
01:35:35.396 --> 01:35:36.831
VOLUNTARY PROGRAM. LOCALS ARE
01:35:36.897 --> 01:35:38.532
NOT REQUIRED TO REDUCE FEES, BUT
01:35:38.599 --> 01:35:39.867
THEY ARE INCENTIVIZED TO DO SO.
01:35:39.934 --> 01:35:41.902
AND TO THIS PROGRAM, ACTUALLY,
01:35:41.969 --> 01:35:43.370
WHILE IT IS A REIMBURSEMENT
01:35:43.437 --> 01:35:44.305
PROGRAM REALLY SAVES THE STATE
01:35:44.371 --> 01:35:46.307
MONEY. THE STATE IS ULTIMATELY
01:35:46.373 --> 01:35:47.575
PAYING FOR MOST OF THESE
01:35:47.641 --> 01:35:48.275
DEVELOPMENT FEES NOW IN
01:35:48.342 --> 01:35:49.510
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, EITHER
01:35:49.577 --> 01:35:50.644
THROUGH THE STATE LOW INCOME
01:35:50.711 --> 01:35:52.346
HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM OR
01:35:52.413 --> 01:35:53.781
THROUGH THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF
01:35:53.848 --> 01:35:56.417
HOUSING PROGRAMS. AND IF WE CAN
01:35:56.484 --> 01:35:57.284
GET LOCALS TO REDUCE THE FEES,
01:35:57.351 --> 01:35:59.386
EVEN THOUGH WE'RE PAYING HALF OF
01:35:59.453 --> 01:36:01.522
THAT IT'S A NET WIND OF THE
01:36:01.589 --> 01:36:02.723
STATE. SO IT'S A WIN WIN ALL
01:36:02.790 --> 01:36:04.325
AROUND. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:36:04.391 --> 01:36:05.392
GREAT ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT OF
01:36:05.459 --> 01:36:07.661
PUBLIC COMMENT IN ROOM 2100.
01:36:07.728 --> 01:36:10.331
SEEING NONE. WE WILL GO TO THE
01:36:10.397 --> 01:36:13.934
PHONE LINES. META MODERATOR.
01:36:14.001 --> 01:36:15.302
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF A
01:36:15.369 --> 01:36:17.071
B 21 86. YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
01:36:17.138 --> 01:36:21.375
THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND
01:36:21.442 --> 01:36:25.846
THEN Ì0 SUPPORT. AND WE GO TO
01:36:25.913 --> 01:36:27.815
THE LINE TO 28. YOUR LINE IS
01:36:27.882 --> 01:36:31.318
OPEN. THANK YOU. JOHN INSTITUTE
01:36:31.385 --> 01:36:32.486
ON BEHALF OF HOUSING ACTION
01:36:32.553 --> 01:36:35.389
COALITION AND SUPPORT. THANK
01:36:35.456 --> 01:36:40.027
YOU. NEXT WE WILL GO TO LINE.
01:36:40.094 --> 01:36:46.133
ONE MOMENT. IT IS A REMINDER WE
01:36:46.200 --> 01:36:49.537
ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B 21 86.
01:36:49.603 --> 01:36:50.804
HUGO CHILLIN OF 2 91. YOUR LINE
01:36:50.871 --> 01:36:54.742
IS OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON. SYDNEY
01:36:54.808 --> 01:36:56.977
CAN ON BEHALF OF BRIDGE HOUSING
01:36:57.044 --> 01:36:58.913
IN SUPPORT OF A B T 186. THANK
01:36:58.979 --> 01:37:02.349
YOU. AGAIN WAIT FOR NO FURTHER,
01:37:02.416 --> 01:37:03.918
UH, IMPORTANT. QUÊ AT THIS TIME,
01:37:03.984 --> 01:37:05.920
MR CHAIR. THANK YOU WILL NOW GO
01:37:05.986 --> 01:37:07.021
TO OPPOSITION? IS THERE ANY
01:37:07.087 --> 01:37:09.757
OPPOSITION TO A B 21 86 HERE IN
01:37:09.823 --> 01:37:10.591
ROOM 2100. SITTING DOWN, WE'LL
01:37:10.658 --> 01:37:15.529
GO TO THE PHONE LINES. THANK YOU
01:37:15.596 --> 01:37:17.131
FOR YOUR OPPOSITION OF A B 21 86
01:37:17.198 --> 01:37:19.066
. YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND THEN
01:37:19.133 --> 01:37:22.436
ZERO. AGAIN OPPOSITION ONE AND
01:37:22.503 --> 01:37:28.042
THEN ZERO. AND WE HAVE NO
01:37:28.108 --> 01:37:29.677
OPPOSITE. NO OPPOSITION IN QUÊ,
01:37:29.743 --> 01:37:31.612
MR. CHAIR OKAY, WE'LL BRING IT
01:37:31.679 --> 01:37:32.713
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:37:32.780 --> 01:37:33.681
COLLEAGUES. ANY QUESTIONS,
01:37:33.747 --> 01:37:35.249
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. I WAS, I
01:37:35.316 --> 01:37:39.787
GUESS. YOU KNOW, IT'S. SHOCKED
01:37:39.853 --> 01:37:41.822
FRIGHTENED. WHAT WORD COULD I
01:37:41.889 --> 01:37:43.791
SAY ON PAGE FOUR OF THE
01:37:43.857 --> 01:37:45.226
COMMITTEE REPORT WHEN THEY TALK
01:37:45.292 --> 01:37:47.328
ABOUT LOS ANGELES, CHARGING
01:37:47.394 --> 01:37:51.198
$2700 FOR THEIR FEES. AND THE
01:37:51.265 --> 01:37:53.567
CITY OF FREMONT, WHICH I PROUDLY
01:37:53.634 --> 01:37:55.703
REPRESENT AND LIVE IN CHARGING
01:37:55.769 --> 01:38:00.674
$51,000 AND WHAT'S THE RIGHT FEE
01:38:00.741 --> 01:38:02.042
? I MEAN, IF YOU'RE PROCESSING A
01:38:02.109 --> 01:38:05.813
THREE STORY BUILDING A HOME THAT
01:38:05.879 --> 01:38:07.548
SOMEBODY'S GONNA BUILD CANDID
01:38:07.615 --> 01:38:11.352
KINDY ACTUAL COSTS BE THAT GREAT
01:38:11.418 --> 01:38:13.287
BETWEEN LOS ANGELES AND THE CITY
01:38:13.354 --> 01:38:16.423
OF FREMONT. IS THAT POSSIBLE OR
01:38:16.490 --> 01:38:19.193
OR THESE FEES BEING HOW THEY
01:38:19.260 --> 01:38:21.562
FUNCTIONING AS PROFIT CENTERS
01:38:21.629 --> 01:38:22.463
FOR LOCALITIES WHERE THEY'RE
01:38:22.529 --> 01:38:24.598
MAKING MONEY OFF OF THE
01:38:24.665 --> 01:38:25.633
DEVELOPER BY THE FEES THERE,
01:38:25.699 --> 01:38:27.534
ISN'T IT FEE FOR SERVICE, OR AM
01:38:27.601 --> 01:38:30.037
I WRONG? ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:38:30.104 --> 01:38:31.138
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI GREAT
01:38:31.205 --> 01:38:33.040
OBSERVATION AND THANK YOU FOR
01:38:33.107 --> 01:38:34.608
BRINGING THAT FORTH. I DO
01:38:34.675 --> 01:38:37.044
BELIEVE THIS THAT THAT FEES ARE
01:38:37.111 --> 01:38:39.113
VERY IMPORTANT, ESPECIALLY TO
01:38:39.179 --> 01:38:40.147
LOCAL MUNICIPALITIES. IT'S WHAT
01:38:40.214 --> 01:38:41.582
HELPS COVER THE COST OF
01:38:41.649 --> 01:38:42.650
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR DEVELOPMENT
01:38:42.716 --> 01:38:45.386
AND SERVICES THAT ARE THAT ARE
01:38:45.452 --> 01:38:46.320
INCURRED BECAUSE OF THAT
01:38:46.387 --> 01:38:49.423
DEVELOPMENT, AND WE MUST BE ON
01:38:49.490 --> 01:38:50.758
ON A STATE LEVEL, ESPECIALLY
01:38:50.824 --> 01:38:52.026
WITH THE LEGISLATURE. VERY
01:38:52.092 --> 01:38:54.461
CAREFUL TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
01:38:54.528 --> 01:38:56.864
DON'T TAKE ON A MINDSET THAT ONE
01:38:56.930 --> 01:38:57.798
SIZE FITS ALL HAVING GONE ON A
01:38:57.865 --> 01:39:00.668
STATEWIDE HOUSING TOUR. AND
01:39:00.734 --> 01:39:01.669
VISITING DIFFERENT REGIONS FROM
01:39:01.735 --> 01:39:03.704
CHICO ALL THE WAY TO SAN DIEGO.
01:39:03.771 --> 01:39:05.372
WE DID REALIZE THAT THERE ARE
01:39:05.439 --> 01:39:07.341
THINGS THAT ARE MUCH DIFFERENT
01:39:07.408 --> 01:39:08.342
FROM ONE JURISDICTION OR REGION
01:39:08.409 --> 01:39:10.311
TO ANOTHER. SO IT IS EXPECTED
01:39:10.377 --> 01:39:11.845
THAT THERE WOULD BE A DIFFERENCE
01:39:11.912 --> 01:39:13.547
IN IMPACT FEES, WHICH IS WHY IN
01:39:13.614 --> 01:39:15.115
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA WE HAVE
01:39:15.182 --> 01:39:17.251
A TOOL FOR LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
01:39:17.318 --> 01:39:18.786
CALLED THE NEXUS TOOL. AND SO
01:39:18.852 --> 01:39:21.855
IT'S A NEXUS STUDY. AND THEY CAN
01:39:21.922 --> 01:39:23.691
USE THAT NEXUS STUDY WITH THE
01:39:23.757 --> 01:39:27.695
RIGHT PARAMETERS RIGHT AS SET OF
01:39:27.761 --> 01:39:30.064
QUALIFICATIONS TO BE ABLE TO
01:39:30.130 --> 01:39:30.931
DEVELOP. WHAT IS THE APPROPRIATE
01:39:30.998 --> 01:39:31.932
FEE FOR THAT PARTICULAR
01:39:31.999 --> 01:39:35.402
JURISDICTION? SO IT CAN BE DONE.
01:39:35.469 --> 01:39:37.204
IT CAN BE DONE THE RIGHT WAY AND
01:39:37.271 --> 01:39:39.306
DONE IN A WAY THAT IS
01:39:39.373 --> 01:39:41.342
COMPLEMENTARY TO THE DEVELOPMENT
01:39:41.408 --> 01:39:43.310
AND ALSO MAKE SURE THAT THE
01:39:43.377 --> 01:39:45.145
LOCAL JURISDICTION HAS ITS NEEDS
01:39:45.212 --> 01:39:47.715
MET AS WELL. THIS BILL DOES
01:39:47.781 --> 01:39:49.216
EXACTLY WHAT YOU BROUGHT OUT AND
01:39:49.283 --> 01:39:51.552
THAT IS IT REALLY CALLS OUT
01:39:51.618 --> 01:39:55.055
THOSE THAT ARE, UM A BIT
01:39:55.122 --> 01:39:56.457
EXCESSIVE IN THEIR IMPACT FEES
01:39:56.523 --> 01:40:00.060
AND WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS
01:40:00.127 --> 01:40:01.795
MAKE IT BETTER FOR AFFORDABLE
01:40:01.862 --> 01:40:02.763
HOUSING DEVELOPERS TO GET THE
01:40:02.830 --> 01:40:04.398
JOB DONE. THANK YOU. I'LL MOVE
01:40:04.465 --> 01:40:08.268
THE BILL, MR CHAIR. OKAY SENATOR
01:40:08.335 --> 01:40:11.739
TO A BOOK. I JUST, UM ADDRESSING
01:40:11.805 --> 01:40:15.042
YOUR QUESTION. I THINK IT'S VERY
01:40:15.109 --> 01:40:17.211
TRY TO MAKE IT VERY SIMPLE
01:40:17.277 --> 01:40:18.746
BECAUSE I HAVE OFTEN WONDERED. I
01:40:18.812 --> 01:40:20.013
KNOW IN THE PAST, WE'VE HAD
01:40:20.080 --> 01:40:25.052
EFFORTS TO, UM. TO DISCLOSE THE
01:40:25.119 --> 01:40:27.755
COST OF BUILDING IN FOR
01:40:27.821 --> 01:40:28.555
DIFFERENT CITIES SO THAT
01:40:28.622 --> 01:40:30.090
DEVELOPERS CAN COME IN AND SAY,
01:40:30.157 --> 01:40:31.158
OKAY, HOW MUCH WOULD IT COST TO
01:40:31.225 --> 01:40:33.093
DEVELOP IN THIS CITY VERSUS THE
01:40:33.160 --> 01:40:35.896
CITY AND ABLE TO DECIDED WHERE
01:40:35.963 --> 01:40:37.765
TO DEVELOP, BUT I THINK PART OF
01:40:37.831 --> 01:40:40.401
THE COST DIFFERENCE. UM AND
01:40:40.467 --> 01:40:42.369
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG, BUT I
01:40:42.436 --> 01:40:43.470
THINK PART OF THE COST
01:40:43.537 --> 01:40:45.439
DIFFERENCE. RELATES TO HOW MUCH
01:40:45.506 --> 01:40:47.174
MORE DEVELOPMENT WITHIN THAT
01:40:47.241 --> 01:40:48.742
CITY OR THAT JURISDICTION IS
01:40:48.809 --> 01:40:50.577
LEFT TO DEVELOP AS FAR AS THE
01:40:50.644 --> 01:40:51.478
NFRASTRUCTURE OR THE SERVICES
01:40:51.545 --> 01:40:56.183
NEEDED. UM T MEET THE NEEDS OF
01:40:56.250 --> 01:40:58.185
NEW DEVELOPMENT. THAT MAKES ANY
01:40:58.252 --> 01:41:00.421
SENSE SO THERE'S COST
01:41:00.487 --> 01:41:02.756
DIFFERENCES, ONE BASED ON THE
01:41:02.823 --> 01:41:04.024
COST OF LAND, AND, UM WHAT IT
01:41:04.091 --> 01:41:07.161
COST TO DEVELOP THOSE PARTICULAR
01:41:07.227 --> 01:41:10.697
UM, EXTRA SCHOOLS, OR, UM, POST
01:41:10.764 --> 01:41:15.903
OFFICE OR SO FORTH OR UM. UM
01:41:15.969 --> 01:41:17.204
WHAT DO YOU CALL IT? UM, ANOTHER
01:41:17.271 --> 01:41:19.540
THING THAT WE DEVELOP, UM
01:41:19.606 --> 01:41:22.810
FIREHOUSES, BUT I THINK ALL OF
01:41:22.876 --> 01:41:24.278
THAT DEPENDS ON WHAT IS LEFT AND
01:41:24.344 --> 01:41:26.613
WHAT IT WILL BE NEEDED IN THOSE
01:41:26.680 --> 01:41:27.347
AREAS AND SO WHEN THEY'RE
01:41:27.414 --> 01:41:28.816
LOOKING AT THE DEVELOPMENT
01:41:28.882 --> 01:41:30.150
IMPACT FEES OF CREATING NEW
01:41:30.217 --> 01:41:31.118
DEVELOPMENTS THERE TAKING
01:41:31.185 --> 01:41:34.188
CONSIDERATION. WHAT WHAT IS
01:41:34.254 --> 01:41:36.190
GOING TO BE NEEDED AND HOW MUCH
01:41:36.256 --> 01:41:37.424
IT'S GOING TO COST IN THAT
01:41:37.491 --> 01:41:39.092
PARTICULAR REGION, SO I'M
01:41:39.159 --> 01:41:42.329
ASSUMING THAT IN YOU'RE IN AREAS
01:41:42.396 --> 01:41:44.665
WHERE REAL ESTATE IS A REALLY,
01:41:44.731 --> 01:41:45.699
REALLY EXPENSIVE AND IT'S MORE
01:41:45.766 --> 01:41:46.900
COSTLY TO DEVELOP. THAT YOUR
01:41:46.967 --> 01:41:48.936
FEES WOULD PROBABLY BE IMPACTED
01:41:49.002 --> 01:41:51.171
BY THAT VERSUS SOMEWHERE WHERE
01:41:51.238 --> 01:41:52.673
IT'S NOT AS EXPENSIVE. OUR LAND
01:41:52.739 --> 01:41:54.341
IS NOT AS EXPENSIVE TO DEVELOP,
01:41:54.408 --> 01:41:55.609
SO I'M ASSUMING THAT WOULD
01:41:55.676 --> 01:41:57.478
PROBABLY HAVE THE BIGGEST IMPACT
01:41:57.544 --> 01:42:00.280
ON THOSE FEES. IF IT DOES THAT
01:42:00.347 --> 01:42:03.283
HELP, MR. CHAIR IF I MEAN I KNOW
01:42:03.350 --> 01:42:06.386
IN 1977, IF WE SOME OF US WERE
01:42:06.453 --> 01:42:09.223
ALIVE, THERE ARE A LOT OF CITIES
01:42:09.289 --> 01:42:10.257
LIKE CITY OF FREMONT HAD VERY
01:42:10.324 --> 01:42:11.892
LOW PROPERTY TAXES BECAUSE THEY
01:42:11.959 --> 01:42:13.827
WANTED TO ATTRACT PEOPLEFROM
01:42:13.894 --> 01:42:15.362
THE SURROUNDING AREAS TO GO
01:42:15.429 --> 01:42:17.130
THERE, SO THEY SET THEIR BASE
01:42:17.197 --> 01:42:19.199
REALLY LOW BECAUSE THEY
01:42:19.266 --> 01:42:20.367
DEVELOPERS WILL COME IN. YOU CAN
01:42:20.434 --> 01:42:22.302
BUILD A SCHOOL. IT WAS NO BIG
01:42:22.369 --> 01:42:25.305
DEAL. AND THEN 13 CAME AND THEY
01:42:25.372 --> 01:42:27.541
CUT THEMSELVES. THEY GOT CAUGHT
01:42:27.608 --> 01:42:29.710
AT A VERY LOW LEVEL OF TEXAS
01:42:29.776 --> 01:42:31.578
WERE THE NEIGHBORING CITIES HAD
01:42:31.645 --> 01:42:33.780
WHEN I WOULD SAY MORE REASONABLE
01:42:33.847 --> 01:42:35.716
THEY WERE TRYING TO AGGRESSIVELY
01:42:35.782 --> 01:42:36.216
BUILD HOUSING AND BRING
01:42:36.283 --> 01:42:39.720
DEVELOPERS IN WITH THE LO FI
01:42:39.786 --> 01:42:42.723
MUCH TO THEIR CHAGRIN IN 1978,
01:42:42.789 --> 01:42:43.757
SO I AM FAMILIAR WITH THE
01:42:43.824 --> 01:42:47.461
PROBLEM IS JUST DISHES WHEN WE
01:42:47.528 --> 01:42:49.796
HAVE SO MUCH MONEY, $12 BILLION
01:42:49.863 --> 01:42:51.365
GOING INTO AFFORDABLE HOUSING,
01:42:51.431 --> 01:42:52.933
AND WE'RE PAYING THE FEES WERE
01:42:53.000 --> 01:42:55.369
PAYING ALL THOSE IMPACT FEES ALL
01:42:55.435 --> 01:42:56.837
OVER THE STATE. YOU LOOK AT IT
01:42:56.904 --> 01:42:58.238
AND YOU SAY WAIT A MINUTE. WE'RE
01:42:58.305 --> 01:43:00.240
THIS IS A SHARED RESPONSIBILITY
01:43:00.307 --> 01:43:01.408
. WE WANT EVERYBODY TO HELP OUT
01:43:01.475 --> 01:43:06.213
WITH THIS SO GOOD LUCK. OKAY ANY
01:43:06.280 --> 01:43:10.317
OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? UM
01:43:10.384 --> 01:43:14.021
I JUST WANT TO THANK THE AUTHOR
01:43:14.087 --> 01:43:16.290
FOR THIS BILL, BUT ALSO FOR
01:43:16.356 --> 01:43:17.324
SEVERAL YEARS OF WORK ON THE
01:43:17.391 --> 01:43:20.894
IMPACT ON THE ISSUE OF IMPACT IS
01:43:20.961 --> 01:43:22.129
IT'S REALLY TOUGH ISSUE BECAUSE
01:43:22.195 --> 01:43:26.333
AS WE'VE HEARD TODAY, IT IS NOT
01:43:26.400 --> 01:43:27.534
A LOT OF TRANSPARENCY THAT
01:43:27.601 --> 01:43:28.535
THERE'S PARITIES AMONG THE
01:43:28.602 --> 01:43:34.174
CITIES. IS JUST OR MASSIVE. AND
01:43:34.241 --> 01:43:35.042
I MEAN, COMPARING SAN FRANCISCO
01:43:35.108 --> 01:43:37.177
AND OAKLAND. THERE'S A HUGE
01:43:37.244 --> 01:43:39.046
DIFFERENCE, AND, YOU KNOW
01:43:39.112 --> 01:43:40.147
HONESTLY, BUT IT'S HARD TO
01:43:40.213 --> 01:43:43.050
CRITICIZE THE CITY'S BECAUSE YES
01:43:43.116 --> 01:43:44.785
, I THINK THERE ARE SOME CITIES
01:43:44.851 --> 01:43:46.119
THAT USE IMPACT VISAS AWAY TO
01:43:46.186 --> 01:43:47.588
UNDERMINE DEVELOPMENT.
01:43:47.654 --> 01:43:49.056
DEFINITELY, BUT THERE ARE OTHERS
01:43:49.122 --> 01:43:50.557
WHERE WE MADE IT SO HARD FOR
01:43:50.624 --> 01:43:53.527
CITIES TO RAISE REVENUE. BECAUSE
01:43:53.594 --> 01:43:54.761
OF A SERIES OF CONSTITUTIONAL
01:43:54.828 --> 01:43:57.531
AMENDMENTS THAT THIS IS LIKE ONE
01:43:57.598 --> 01:44:01.201
OF THE FEW, UM EASIER WAYS TO
01:44:01.268 --> 01:44:02.369
RAISE REVENUE. SO WE PUT CITIES
01:44:02.436 --> 01:44:04.771
IN A REALLY DIFFICULT SITUATION.
01:44:04.838 --> 01:44:08.775
I APPRECIATE YOU TRYING TO. TO
01:44:08.842 --> 01:44:10.344
GET AT THIS ISSUE FROM A NUMBER
01:44:10.410 --> 01:44:12.379
OF ANGLES AND HAVING A LOT OF
01:44:12.446 --> 01:44:14.214
DIALOGUE WITH THE STAKEHOLDERS
01:44:14.281 --> 01:44:16.350
OVER TWO OR THREE YEARS NOW, I
01:44:16.416 --> 01:44:18.385
THINK SO. THANK YOU FOR THAT,
01:44:18.452 --> 01:44:19.686
AND I'LL BE RECOMMENDING AN AYE
01:44:19.753 --> 01:44:21.321
VOTE ON THIS BILL. AH, AND YOU
01:44:21.388 --> 01:44:24.825
MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU, MR CHAIR
01:44:24.891 --> 01:44:26.526
AND THANK YOU FOR THE ROBUST
01:44:26.593 --> 01:44:27.561
DISCUSSION BECAUSE EACH OF YOU
01:44:27.628 --> 01:44:29.296
WERE BROUGHT BRINGING OUT SOME
01:44:29.363 --> 01:44:30.597
VERY GOOD POINTS AND ACTUALLY
01:44:30.664 --> 01:44:31.765
TAKING THE CONVERSATION FROM
01:44:31.832 --> 01:44:32.766
SCRATCHING THE SERVICE TO AT
01:44:32.833 --> 01:44:35.235
LEAST ETCHING. HEAD SO WITH
01:44:35.302 --> 01:44:36.703
THAT, I WOULD RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:44:36.770 --> 01:44:41.808
FOR. GREAT I'M SORRY. DO WE HAVE
01:44:41.875 --> 01:44:42.943
A MOTION? NO. SOME MOVED BY
01:44:43.010 --> 01:44:44.578
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. AND THE
01:44:44.645 --> 01:44:46.713
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST BE
01:44:46.780 --> 01:44:48.348
WE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:44:48.415 --> 01:44:49.816
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE, AND WE
01:44:49.883 --> 01:44:51.485
WILL CALL THE ROLL SENATOR
01:44:51.551 --> 01:44:57.157
WIENER BEDS, CABALLERO. CORTEZ E
01:44:57.224 --> 01:45:00.227
. MCGUIRE COBURG COBURG AYE
01:45:00.293 --> 01:45:03.196
SKINNER, HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI.
01:45:03.263 --> 01:45:06.299
WIECKOWSKI THAT'S 4 TO 0. OKAY
01:45:06.366 --> 01:45:07.601
WE WILL PUT THAT ON CALL, AND
01:45:07.668 --> 01:45:10.904
YOUR NEXT BILL IS A B 2668 ITEM
01:45:10.971 --> 01:45:14.975
NUMBER 12. MR CHAIR AND
01:45:15.042 --> 01:45:17.911
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. A B 26 68 IS
01:45:17.978 --> 01:45:18.979
A FIX UP BILL TO ENSURE
01:45:19.046 --> 01:45:20.947
QUALIFIED HOUSING PROJECTS ARE
01:45:21.014 --> 01:45:22.449
STREAMLINED AS INTENDED UNDER
01:45:22.516 --> 01:45:24.918
CURRENT LAW, SB 35. THANK YOU,
01:45:24.985 --> 01:45:27.587
MR CHAIR WAS A LANDMARK EFFORT
01:45:27.654 --> 01:45:29.089
TO INCREASE OUR HOUSING SUPPLY
01:45:29.156 --> 01:45:30.824
AND UNDER SP 35 LOCAL
01:45:30.891 --> 01:45:32.359
JURISDICTIONS MUST ESTABLISH
01:45:32.426 --> 01:45:34.227
OBJECTIVE STANDARDS AND
01:45:34.294 --> 01:45:35.328
STREAMLINE APPROVALS FOR
01:45:35.395 --> 01:45:36.329
DEVELOPMENTS THAT MEET THOSE
01:45:36.396 --> 01:45:40.500
STANDARDS. 26 60. WELL FIRST OF
01:45:40.567 --> 01:45:42.803
ALL, THE AMBIGUITIES IN THE LAW
01:45:42.869 --> 01:45:44.938
HAVE BEEN EXPLOITED TO DERAIL
01:45:45.005 --> 01:45:45.739
DESPERATELY DESPERATELY NEEDED
01:45:45.806 --> 01:45:46.740
HOUSING PROJECTS ACROSS THE
01:45:46.807 --> 01:45:50.343
STATE. SO THIS SIMPLY CLARIFIES
01:45:50.410 --> 01:45:52.746
THAT A PROJECT SHALL BE APPROVED
01:45:52.813 --> 01:45:54.081
IF IT MEETS OBJECTIVE STANDARDS
01:45:54.147 --> 01:45:56.083
, AND THAT TOTAL PROJECT UNITS
01:45:56.149 --> 01:45:57.584
ARE ACCOUNTED PRIOR TO DENSITY
01:45:57.651 --> 01:46:00.120
BONUS. THIS WILL ENSURE THAT LAW
01:46:00.187 --> 01:46:01.722
FUNCTION THAT THAT THE LAW
01:46:01.788 --> 01:46:03.790
FUNCTIONS AS INTENDED TO BUILD
01:46:03.857 --> 01:46:05.158
THE HOUSING THAT WE NEED SO
01:46:05.225 --> 01:46:06.893
DESPERATELY, AND WITH THAT I DO
01:46:06.960 --> 01:46:08.829
HAVE TO THE CHAIR WITNESS
01:46:08.895 --> 01:46:13.266
MICHAEL LANE FROM SPUR. MR
01:46:13.333 --> 01:46:14.801
CHAIRMAN MEMBERS. MY CLAIM IS
01:46:14.868 --> 01:46:15.969
FOR PUBLIC POLICY THINK TANK IN
01:46:16.036 --> 01:46:17.604
THE SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA.
01:46:17.671 --> 01:46:19.039
LET'S BE 35 HOUSING APPROVALS
01:46:19.106 --> 01:46:20.540
STREAMLINE HAS BEEN A TREMENDOUS
01:46:20.607 --> 01:46:21.575
BOON TO THE PRODUCTION OF
01:46:21.641 --> 01:46:22.342
AFFORDABLE HOUSING, AND IT'S
01:46:22.409 --> 01:46:23.744
HELPING TO BRING NEW HOMES
01:46:23.810 --> 01:46:25.278
ONLINE MORE QUICKLY AND
01:46:25.345 --> 01:46:25.879
EFFICIENTLY WHILE RESPECTING
01:46:25.946 --> 01:46:26.446
LOCAL ZONING AND OBJECTIVE
01:46:26.513 --> 01:46:27.047
DESIGN. AND DEVELOPMENT
01:46:27.114 --> 01:46:30.417
STANDARDS. AS DETAILED IN THE
01:46:30.484 --> 01:46:31.785
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS. A B 26 68
01:46:31.852 --> 01:46:33.053
PROVIDES ADDITIONAL TECHNICAL
01:46:33.120 --> 01:46:34.521
CLEANUP AND CLARIFYING LANGUAGE
01:46:34.588 --> 01:46:35.555
CONSISTENT WITH LEGISLATIVE
01:46:35.622 --> 01:46:38.759
INTENT CDS. SP 35 GUIDELINES.
01:46:38.825 --> 01:46:39.559
THESE CLARIFICATIONS WILL
01:46:39.626 --> 01:46:40.627
FURTHER PERFECT THE LAW AND
01:46:40.694 --> 01:46:41.661
ENSURED FUNCTIONS AS INTENDED.
01:46:41.728 --> 01:46:43.430
WE RESPECT THE REQUEST AND I
01:46:43.497 --> 01:46:47.434
VOTE. IS THERE ANY OTHER
01:46:47.501 --> 01:46:48.502
SUPPORTIVE PUBLIC COMMENT IN THE
01:46:48.568 --> 01:46:55.108
ROOM? PROBABLY FOR MANY DAYS USE
01:46:55.175 --> 01:46:56.076
WITH WHITE HOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS
01:46:56.143 --> 01:46:58.311
AND SUPPORT ON BEHALF OF THE
01:46:58.378 --> 01:46:59.546
UNTIL PROPERTIES. CIVIC. WELL,
01:46:59.613 --> 01:47:04.184
UM, BE ACTION AND FIELD STUDY.
01:47:04.251 --> 01:47:05.218
DURING PLANTING CARVAJAL ON
01:47:05.285 --> 01:47:06.319
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA AND BE IN
01:47:06.386 --> 01:47:14.194
SUPPORT. ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT
01:47:14.261 --> 01:47:16.163
HERE IN THE ROOM, AND THEN WE'LL
01:47:16.229 --> 01:47:17.397
GO TO THE PHONE LINE. MADAM
01:47:17.464 --> 01:47:18.498
MODERATOR, WILL YOU PLEASE QUEUE
01:47:18.565 --> 01:47:21.935
UP SUPPORT? THANK YOU FOR THE
01:47:22.002 --> 01:47:24.571
SUPPORT OF A B 26 68 YOU MAY
01:47:24.638 --> 01:47:27.941
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
01:47:28.008 --> 01:47:29.843
THAT IT'S ONE AND THEN ZERO FEAR
01:47:29.910 --> 01:47:33.046
AND SUPPORT. WE'VE GOT TO LINE
01:47:33.113 --> 01:47:36.116
UP TO 71. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HI.
01:47:36.183 --> 01:47:37.417
THIS IS ADAM BOOKBINDER,
01:47:37.484 --> 01:47:38.118
RESIDENT OF CAMPBELL AND
01:47:38.185 --> 01:47:39.786
SENATE-DISTRICT. 11 BOARDING A B
01:47:39.853 --> 01:47:46.193
2668. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
01:47:46.259 --> 01:47:48.328
WE WILL GO TO THE LINE OF 2 80
01:47:48.395 --> 01:47:53.200
OR 2 28. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:47:53.266 --> 01:47:54.534
THANK YOU. JOHNSON TODAY ON
01:47:54.601 --> 01:47:56.236
BEHALF OF THE HOUSING ACTION
01:47:56.303 --> 01:48:01.041
COALITION IS SUPPORT. THANK YOU
01:48:01.107 --> 01:48:02.475
. AND WE HAVE TWO MORE. ONE
01:48:02.542 --> 01:48:05.445
MOMENT, MR CHURCH, AND WE WILL
01:48:05.512 --> 01:48:08.215
GO TO LINE 2022. YOUR LINE IS
01:48:08.281 --> 01:48:15.422
OPEN. THIS IS JIM FINNEGAN FROM
01:48:15.488 --> 01:48:16.756
AARP. WE'RE TOTALLY SUPPORTIVE
01:48:16.823 --> 01:48:21.828
OF THE BILL. THANK YOU. NEXT
01:48:21.895 --> 01:48:26.933
CAROLINE OF 2 88 LINE IS OPEN.
01:48:27.000 --> 01:48:28.702
HI THIS IS ADAM BREE ANDERSON,
01:48:28.768 --> 01:48:29.636
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY BUILDERS
01:48:29.703 --> 01:48:30.637
CALLING AND SUPPORTED THE BILL.
01:48:30.704 --> 01:48:34.207
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT
01:48:34.274 --> 01:48:36.243
WE GO TO LIKE TO 75. THE AIRLINE
01:48:36.309 --> 01:48:38.778
IS OPEN. BRIAN O'CONNELL FROM
01:48:38.845 --> 01:48:39.846
NAPA, SOLANO. GAMBIAN SUPPORT
01:48:39.913 --> 01:48:43.383
THANK YOU. THANK YOU AND WE HAVE
01:48:43.450 --> 01:48:46.953
NO FURTHER SUPPORTING QUÊ. IT'S
01:48:47.020 --> 01:48:48.521
GREAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
01:48:48.588 --> 01:48:49.322
WE'RE NOT GOING TO OPPOSITION.
01:48:49.389 --> 01:48:51.558
IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION TO A B
01:48:51.625 --> 01:48:52.859
26 68 IN THE HEARING ROOM?
01:48:52.926 --> 01:48:54.027
SEEING NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE
01:48:54.094 --> 01:48:58.465
LINES. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:48:58.531 --> 01:49:01.534
POSITION OF A B 26 68 YOU MAY
01:49:01.601 --> 01:49:06.306
PRESS 10. AGAIN. THERE IS ONE
01:49:06.373 --> 01:49:10.777
AND THEN ZERO FOR AN OPPOSITION.
01:49:10.844 --> 01:49:12.078
AND MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
01:49:12.145 --> 01:49:15.215
OPPOSITION IN. Q OKAY, WE WILL
01:49:15.282 --> 01:49:17.417
BRING BACK TO THE COMMITTEE. ANY
01:49:17.484 --> 01:49:19.452
QUESTIONS? SENATOR BATES? UM
01:49:19.519 --> 01:49:21.054
QUESTION. I'M SUPPORTIVE OF THE
01:49:21.121 --> 01:49:24.024
BILL, BUT I'M CURIOUS. IF
01:49:24.090 --> 01:49:26.259
THERE'S AN EXAMPLE OR YOU HAVE
01:49:26.326 --> 01:49:28.228
NUMBERS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
01:49:28.295 --> 01:49:29.362
THAT MIGHT HAVE THROUGH A
01:49:29.429 --> 01:49:32.198
BUREAUCRATIC PROCESS, NOT
01:49:32.265 --> 01:49:33.800
APPROVED A PROJECT BECAUSE THEY
01:49:33.867 --> 01:49:35.435
FORGOT PAGE FIVE OF THE
01:49:35.502 --> 01:49:36.569
APPLICATION PROCESS, WHERE THERE
01:49:36.636 --> 01:49:38.905
THAT MANY SINCE THE SINCE SB 35
01:49:38.972 --> 01:49:42.976
BECAME LAW THAT'S SOMETHING THAT
01:49:43.043 --> 01:49:45.679
SEEMS TO BE, YOU KNOW, A PATTERN
01:49:45.745 --> 01:49:47.814
. SOMETIMES IT'S NOT THE NUMBER
01:49:47.881 --> 01:49:49.716
BUT IT'S THE BUT IT'S THE
01:49:49.783 --> 01:49:53.586
MAGNITUDE OF A PROJECT. AND SO,
01:49:53.653 --> 01:49:55.822
THOUGH WE MAY NOT HAVE NUMBERS
01:49:55.889 --> 01:49:58.024
AS FAR AS NUMEROUS ACROSS THE
01:49:58.091 --> 01:50:00.026
STATE, WE DO HAVE A SIGNIFICANT
01:50:00.093 --> 01:50:02.128
EXAMPLE WHERE A JURISDICTION WAS
01:50:02.195 --> 01:50:06.232
USING SOME LOOPHOLES. TO TRY TO
01:50:06.299 --> 01:50:08.368
STALL AND EVEN STOP A PROJECT.
01:50:08.435 --> 01:50:11.204
SO THROUGH THIS CLEANUP OF
01:50:11.271 --> 01:50:12.872
SOMETHING THAT WAS INTENDED IN
01:50:12.939 --> 01:50:14.007
THE ORIGINAL LANGUAGE, IT IS IT
01:50:14.074 --> 01:50:16.009
WILL HELP. THIS PROJECT BE ABLE
01:50:16.076 --> 01:50:19.012
TO MOVE FORWARD. I THINK I AM
01:50:19.079 --> 01:50:21.047
FEEL AT LEAST COMFORTABLE THAT
01:50:21.114 --> 01:50:22.282
IT MAY BE ONLY ONE OR TWO
01:50:22.349 --> 01:50:24.050
JURISDICTIONS AND NOT SOMETHING
01:50:24.117 --> 01:50:25.819
THAT THERE'S A BIG LOOPHOLE
01:50:25.885 --> 01:50:27.253
THERE THAT EVERYBODY IS TAKING A
01:50:27.320 --> 01:50:29.656
LOOK AT BECAUSE THAT I THINK THE
01:50:29.723 --> 01:50:31.624
BUREAUCRACY THAT DEVELOPERS HAVE
01:50:31.691 --> 01:50:32.759
TO FACE IT MANY LOCAL
01:50:32.826 --> 01:50:35.028
GOVERNMENTS AS A PROBLEM BECAUSE
01:50:35.095 --> 01:50:36.563
I'VE HAD MY OWN ISSUES WITH
01:50:36.629 --> 01:50:40.700
FINANCIAL EXAMPLE. BUT I I'M I
01:50:40.767 --> 01:50:41.701
WOULDN'T WANT TO SUPPORT
01:50:41.768 --> 01:50:43.069
SOMETHING WHERE ONLY ONE PERSON
01:50:43.136 --> 01:50:45.238
TRIED IT. AND THEN YOU GOT THIS
01:50:45.305 --> 01:50:47.140
LAW NOW EVERYBODY IS GOING TO,
01:50:47.207 --> 01:50:49.175
YOU KNOW, BE AFRAID TO SAY NO.
01:50:49.242 --> 01:50:51.244
BECAUSE YOU DIDN'T FILL OUT PAGE
01:50:51.311 --> 01:50:53.213
FIVE, WHICH IS ESSENTIAL TO US
01:50:53.279 --> 01:50:54.481
UNDERSTANDING THAT THIS IS
01:50:54.547 --> 01:50:55.482
SOMETHING THAT MEETS THE
01:50:55.548 --> 01:50:57.817
STANDARDS. THAT WE HAVE IN OUR
01:50:57.884 --> 01:50:59.552
IN OUR, YOU KNOW, YOU KNOW, IN
01:50:59.619 --> 01:51:01.855
OUR CITY, YES OR SOMETHING
01:51:01.921 --> 01:51:03.390
THAT'S REALLY IMPORTANT IN TERMS
01:51:03.456 --> 01:51:05.492
OF PUBLIC SAFETY IN TERMS OF THE
01:51:05.558 --> 01:51:06.893
BUILDING THAT'S GOING FORWARD.
01:51:06.960 --> 01:51:08.695
SO I THINK I'M HEARING FROM YOU
01:51:08.762 --> 01:51:11.698
THAT COMFORTABLE THAT IT'S KIND
01:51:11.765 --> 01:51:13.199
OF A LOOPHOLE THAT NEEDS TO BE
01:51:13.266 --> 01:51:14.367
CLOSED, BUT NOT OVERUSED. THAT'S
01:51:14.434 --> 01:51:15.835
WHAT I HOPE YOU'RE SAYING. THAT
01:51:15.902 --> 01:51:16.403
IS ABSOLUTELY CORRECT. VERY
01:51:16.469 --> 01:51:20.673
INTUITIVE. THANK YOU. YES. OKAY
01:51:20.740 --> 01:51:21.641
ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR
01:51:21.708 --> 01:51:24.377
QUESTIONS SEEING NONE SOME.
01:51:24.444 --> 01:51:25.812
REMEMBER YOU MAKE CLOTHES. I
01:51:25.879 --> 01:51:27.580
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN EVIDENCE
01:51:27.647 --> 01:51:28.948
AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
01:51:29.015 --> 01:51:30.016
BRINGING THIS FORWARD AND I'M
01:51:30.083 --> 01:51:33.319
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE. AH!
01:51:33.386 --> 01:51:34.754
MOTION BY SENATOR WIECKOWSKI.
01:51:34.821 --> 01:51:37.023
AND THAT MOTION IS TO DO PASS
01:51:37.090 --> 01:51:38.758
BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
01:51:38.825 --> 01:51:39.993
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
01:51:40.060 --> 01:51:42.095
FINANCE WILL CALL THE ROLL.
01:51:42.162 --> 01:51:43.730
SENATOR WIENER WIENER. AYE BATES
01:51:43.797 --> 01:51:48.568
ALRIGHT, CABALLERO. ORTEZ E.
01:51:48.635 --> 01:51:52.072
MCGUIRE ACTUAL BUG EYES SKINNER.
01:51:52.138 --> 01:51:54.941
HAMBURG WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I
01:51:55.008 --> 01:51:56.443
? THAT'S 4 TO 0. PUT THAT ON
01:51:56.509 --> 01:51:58.611
CALL. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
01:51:58.678 --> 01:51:59.479
REMEMBER, I SEE SOME REMEMBER
01:51:59.546 --> 01:52:04.451
REYES IS HERE. UM ITEM 13 22 17.
01:52:04.517 --> 01:52:09.422
BLOCK HIM. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S.
01:52:09.489 --> 01:52:15.361
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR MEMBERS. I'M
01:52:15.428 --> 01:52:18.865
PLEASED TO PRESENT 20 TO 17 THE
01:52:18.932 --> 01:52:20.300
AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP
01:52:20.366 --> 01:52:22.569
PRODUCTION ACT, WHICH WILL
01:52:22.635 --> 01:52:23.803
EMPOWER CALIFORNIA FAMILIES TO
01:52:23.870 --> 01:52:26.039
BECOME FIRST TIME HOMEOWNERS.
01:52:26.106 --> 01:52:27.307
AND THE BILL IS SPONSORED BY
01:52:27.373 --> 01:52:30.210
HABITAT FOR HUMANITY. THE BILL
01:52:30.276 --> 01:52:31.678
ALLOWS THE DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING
01:52:31.744 --> 01:52:33.179
AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
01:52:33.246 --> 01:52:35.315
INCREASE TO INCREASE THE PER
01:52:35.381 --> 01:52:37.817
UNIT AND TOTAL PROJECT CAPS
01:52:37.884 --> 01:52:39.352
WITHIN THE KILL HOME PROGRAM
01:52:39.419 --> 01:52:41.321
BASED ON LOCAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
01:52:41.387 --> 01:52:42.489
, AND WE EXPECT THAT THIS WOULD
01:52:42.555 --> 01:52:43.923
ENCOURAGE THE CONSTRUCTION OF
01:52:43.990 --> 01:52:47.293
AFFORDABLE HOMES. HOMEOWNERSHIP
01:52:47.360 --> 01:52:49.195
IN CALIFORNIA REMAINS GROSSLY
01:52:49.262 --> 01:52:52.465
INEQUITABLE ONLY 41% OF BLACKS
01:52:52.532 --> 01:52:55.034
AND 49% OF LATINO FAMILIES OWNED
01:52:55.101 --> 01:52:58.037
THEIR HOMES COMPARED TO 68% OF
01:52:58.104 --> 01:52:59.772
WHITE AND 60 66% OF ASIAN
01:52:59.839 --> 01:53:03.543
FAMILIES. CURRENTLY THE CALLA
01:53:03.610 --> 01:53:04.978
HOME PROGRAM FOR AFFORDABLE
01:53:05.044 --> 01:53:06.212
HOMEOWNERSHIP CONSTRUCTION IS
01:53:06.279 --> 01:53:09.549
OVERSUBSCRIBED AND UNDERFUNDED.
01:53:09.616 --> 01:53:11.117
THIS HAS SEVERELY LIMITED THE
01:53:11.184 --> 01:53:12.752
ABILITY OF NONPROFIT DEVELOPERS
01:53:12.819 --> 01:53:14.854
TO ACCESS THESE FUNDS, MEANING
01:53:14.921 --> 01:53:16.623
DESPERATELY NEEDED AFFORDABLE
01:53:16.689 --> 01:53:17.690
HOMES HAVE GONE UNBUILT YEAR
01:53:17.757 --> 01:53:22.428
AFTER YEAR. A B 22 17 WILL
01:53:22.495 --> 01:53:23.263
ADDRESS THESE ISSUES BY
01:53:23.329 --> 01:53:26.199
PERMITTING H C D TO INCREASE PER
01:53:26.266 --> 01:53:27.433
UNIT AND TOTAL PROJECT
01:53:27.500 --> 01:53:28.468
ALLOCATIONS WITHIN THE CAL HOME
01:53:28.535 --> 01:53:31.404
PROGRAM. BASED ON LOCAL
01:53:31.471 --> 01:53:33.640
DEVELOPMENT COSTS. THIS BILL
01:53:33.706 --> 01:53:34.974
WILL ENSURE THESE CAPS ARE
01:53:35.041 --> 01:53:37.343
UPDATED REGULARLY BY REQUIRING H
01:53:37.410 --> 01:53:40.313
C D TO CONSIDER INCREASING
01:53:40.380 --> 01:53:41.447
ALLOCATIONS FOR EACH NEW ROUND
01:53:41.514 --> 01:53:45.385
OF FUNDING. I AM PLEASED TO
01:53:45.451 --> 01:53:48.321
SHARE ALSO THAT FUNDING FOR 20
01:53:48.388 --> 01:53:50.790
TO 17 HAS BEEN INCLUDED IN THIS
01:53:50.857 --> 01:53:53.560
YEAR'S LEGISLATIVE BUDGET. ACT
01:53:53.626 --> 01:53:54.994
WHICH ALLOCATES 350 MILLION FOR
01:53:55.061 --> 01:53:59.265
THE QUEL HOMME PROGRAM. BY
01:53:59.332 --> 01:54:00.600
UPDATING THE FUNDING CAPS FOR
01:54:00.667 --> 01:54:03.336
QUEL HOMME. MAYBE 20 TO 17 WILL
01:54:03.403 --> 01:54:04.270
PROMOTE THE CONSTRUCTION OF
01:54:04.337 --> 01:54:05.772
AFFORDABLE HOMES AND GENERATE
01:54:05.838 --> 01:54:07.440
MORE OPPORTUNITY FOR CALIFORNIA
01:54:07.507 --> 01:54:08.508
FAMILIES TO BECOME FIRST TIME
01:54:08.575 --> 01:54:12.579
HOMEOWNERS. HERE TO TESTIFY AND
01:54:12.645 --> 01:54:15.481
SUPPORT IS DEBBIE ORACLE,
01:54:15.548 --> 01:54:16.449
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF HABITAT
01:54:16.516 --> 01:54:19.452
FOR HUMANITY, CALIFORNIA YOU MAY
01:54:19.519 --> 01:54:23.756
COME FORWARD. THANK YOU, MR
01:54:23.823 --> 01:54:25.291
CHAIR AND COMMITTEE MEMBERS. I'M
01:54:25.358 --> 01:54:26.726
DEBBIE ARTICLE EXECUTIVE
01:54:26.793 --> 01:54:27.527
DIRECTOR WITH HABITAT FOR
01:54:27.594 --> 01:54:29.796
HUMANITY CALIFORNIA AND I'M HERE
01:54:29.862 --> 01:54:30.430
TODAY REPRESENTING THE VIEWS OF
01:54:30.496 --> 01:54:33.533
OUR LOCAL HABITAT FOR HUMANITY'S
01:54:33.600 --> 01:54:35.835
IN URBAN AND RURAL COMMUNITIES
01:54:35.902 --> 01:54:38.238
STATEWIDE, AND I'VE PERSONALLY
01:54:38.304 --> 01:54:39.505
BEEN ABLE TO USE THE CAL HOME
01:54:39.572 --> 01:54:40.573
PROGRAM AS A NONPROFIT
01:54:40.640 --> 01:54:42.875
DEVELOPER. AND WE'RE PROUD TO
01:54:42.942 --> 01:54:46.312
SPONSOR A B 22 17 AND STAND
01:54:46.379 --> 01:54:46.879
ALONGSIDE ASSEMBLY MAJORITY
01:54:46.946 --> 01:54:50.550
LEADER ELOISE RACE. TO INCREASE
01:54:50.617 --> 01:54:52.685
THE SUPPLY OF AFFORDABLE
01:54:52.752 --> 01:54:54.554
HOMEOWNERSHIP OWNER OCCUPIED
01:54:54.621 --> 01:54:57.223
UNITS. THIS LEGISLATION UPDATES
01:54:57.290 --> 01:55:00.593
THE ANTIQUATED ONE SIZE FITS ALL
01:55:00.660 --> 01:55:01.861
PER UNIT AND PER PROJECT FUNDING
01:55:01.928 --> 01:55:04.464
CAPS. BY ALLOWING THE DEPARTMENT
01:55:04.530 --> 01:55:05.698
OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY
01:55:05.765 --> 01:55:07.267
DEVELOPMENT THE FLEXIBILITY TO
01:55:07.333 --> 01:55:10.203
MAKE APPROPRIATE INCREASES BASED
01:55:10.270 --> 01:55:12.138
ON THE ACTUAL COSTS. THE CURRENT
01:55:12.205 --> 01:55:13.773
CAPS ARE INHIBITING PRODUCTION.
01:55:13.840 --> 01:55:17.710
AND SCALE ABILITY. WITH THIS
01:55:17.777 --> 01:55:19.178
ALLOWANCE TO INCREASE THE CAPS
01:55:19.245 --> 01:55:21.347
NONPROFIT HOME DEVELOPERS,
01:55:21.414 --> 01:55:23.182
INCLUDING HABITAT FOR HUMANITY
01:55:23.249 --> 01:55:24.684
STATEWIDE, CAN ACCELERATE
01:55:24.751 --> 01:55:25.685
PRODUCTION AND INCREASE THE
01:55:25.752 --> 01:55:29.188
SUPPLY. OF AFFORDABLE HOMES IN
01:55:29.255 --> 01:55:32.158
URBAN AND RURAL COMMUNITIES HAVE
01:55:32.225 --> 01:55:33.559
A CHAT AND OTHER NON PROFIT
01:55:33.626 --> 01:55:35.928
DEVELOPERS HAVE A PIPELINE OF
01:55:35.995 --> 01:55:38.598
OWNER OCCUPIED PROJECTS AND WITH
01:55:38.665 --> 01:55:39.732
RELIABLE, APPROPRIATELY
01:55:39.799 --> 01:55:41.934
LEVERAGE. HERBAL FUNDING. BASED
01:55:42.001 --> 01:55:43.536
ON THE ACTUAL COSTS. THIS WILL
01:55:43.603 --> 01:55:46.205
HELP US INCREASE MUCH NEEDED
01:55:46.272 --> 01:55:47.907
PRODUCTION. THIS LEGISLATION IS
01:55:47.974 --> 01:55:50.176
PARTICULARLY CRITICAL BECAUSE
01:55:50.243 --> 01:55:51.511
THERE'S ONLY ONE SINGLE
01:55:51.577 --> 01:55:52.412
OWNERSHIP PRODUCTION STATE
01:55:52.478 --> 01:55:55.915
PROGRAM. AVAILABLE TO NONPROFIT
01:55:55.982 --> 01:55:57.550
DEVELOPERS AND LOCAL
01:55:57.617 --> 01:55:58.818
JURISDICTIONS. AND THIS IS CAL
01:55:58.885 --> 01:56:00.687
HOME AND, AS WAS MENTIONED THIS
01:56:00.753 --> 01:56:02.989
CAL HOME FUNDING IS ABOUT TO RUN
01:56:03.056 --> 01:56:04.924
OUT, BUT IT IS INCLUDED
01:56:04.991 --> 01:56:06.726
HOPEFULLY IN THE PROPOSED STATE
01:56:06.793 --> 01:56:09.362
BUDGET. AND WE'RE PROUD TO
01:56:09.429 --> 01:56:11.197
SUPPORT THAT PRIORITY AS WELL.
01:56:11.264 --> 01:56:13.232
JUST A COUPLE OF QUICK POINTS TO
01:56:13.299 --> 01:56:15.435
CLARIFY FOR CAL HOME. IT IS ONLY
01:56:15.501 --> 01:56:16.803
AVAILABLE TO NONPROFIT
01:56:16.869 --> 01:56:17.704
DEVELOPERS AND LOCAL
01:56:17.770 --> 01:56:20.039
JURISDICTIONS. IT'S 100%
01:56:20.106 --> 01:56:21.207
AFFORDABLE. IT'S ONLY UP TO 80%
01:56:21.274 --> 01:56:25.278
AM I AND IT INCLUDES MULTI
01:56:25.345 --> 01:56:27.180
FAMILY OWNERSHIP AND SINGLE
01:56:27.246 --> 01:56:29.315
FAMILY OWNERSHIP. IT FOLLOWS A
01:56:29.382 --> 01:56:31.250
REPAYMENT RE USE MODEL, SO AN
01:56:31.317 --> 01:56:33.219
INVESTMENT IN THIS PROGRAM HELPS
01:56:33.286 --> 01:56:36.222
PRODUCE MORE UNITS IN THE FUTURE
01:56:36.289 --> 01:56:38.491
. EXACTLY AND IT'S EFFECTIVE IN
01:56:38.558 --> 01:56:40.560
ALL DIFFERENT TYPES OF REGIONS
01:56:40.626 --> 01:56:42.028
IN THE STATE FROM LARGER METRO
01:56:42.095 --> 01:56:43.563
AREAS LIKE GREATER SAN FRANCISCO
01:56:43.629 --> 01:56:45.665
BAY AREA TO RURAL COMMUNITIES
01:56:45.732 --> 01:56:46.833
LIKE HILLARY KINGS COUNTY,
01:56:46.899 --> 01:56:49.669
NEVADA COUNTY. CALVARY'S AND
01:56:49.736 --> 01:56:51.337
THERE'S A MANDATED GEOGRAPHIC.
01:56:51.404 --> 01:56:52.271
JUST PURSE MINT REQUIREMENT
01:56:52.338 --> 01:56:55.775
BUILT INTO THE PROGRAM. OVER
01:56:55.842 --> 01:56:56.843
12,000 PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO
01:56:56.909 --> 01:56:58.177
AFFORDABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP JUST
01:56:58.244 --> 01:57:00.413
THROUGH HABITAT ALONE, AND
01:57:00.480 --> 01:57:01.814
THAT'S JUST IN THE LAST DECADE
01:57:01.881 --> 01:57:04.784
80% OF HABITAT HOMEOWNERS ARE
01:57:04.851 --> 01:57:06.419
HOUSEHOLDS OF COLOR WE SERVE
01:57:06.486 --> 01:57:08.187
VETERANS. WE SERVE OLDER ADULTS
01:57:08.254 --> 01:57:09.455
, AND WE SERVE FAMILIES WITH
01:57:09.522 --> 01:57:11.724
MEMBERS WITH A DISABILITY. SO
01:57:11.791 --> 01:57:13.860
THIS LEGISLATION IS KEY TO
01:57:13.926 --> 01:57:16.028
INCREASING ACCESS AFFORDABLE
01:57:16.095 --> 01:57:18.664
ACCESS TO HOMEOWNERSHIP FOR MORE
01:57:18.731 --> 01:57:19.866
CALIFORNIANS, SO WE'RE PROUD TO
01:57:19.932 --> 01:57:21.601
SPONSOR THIS LEGISLATION AND WE
01:57:21.667 --> 01:57:23.035
ENCOURAGE AND I VOTE. THANK YOU.
01:57:23.102 --> 01:57:33.179
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. GO AHEAD
01:57:33.246 --> 01:57:34.914
HOLLY FOR MANY DAYS, ISSUES FROM
01:57:34.981 --> 01:57:36.315
LIGHTHOUSE PUBLIC AFFAIRS ALSO
01:57:36.382 --> 01:57:38.084
IN SUPPORT TODAY ON BEHALF OF
01:57:38.151 --> 01:57:39.085
THE BLACK LEADERSHIP COUNCILS
01:57:39.152 --> 01:57:43.589
FOR AN NBA ACTION. MR CHAIRMAN,
01:57:43.656 --> 01:57:44.757
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:57:44.824 --> 01:57:45.491
CORNELIUS BURKE WITH THE
01:57:45.558 --> 01:57:46.592
CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
01:57:46.659 --> 01:57:48.461
ASSOCIATION, JUST WANT TO ALIGN
01:57:48.528 --> 01:57:49.395
OURSELVES WITH HABITAT FOR
01:57:49.462 --> 01:57:51.297
HUMANITY AND FULL SUPPORT OF
01:57:51.364 --> 01:57:52.165
THIS IMPORTANT, BILL. THANK YOU.
01:57:52.231 --> 01:57:54.033
THANK YOU VERY MUCH ANY FURTHER
01:57:54.100 --> 01:57:56.669
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENT HERE IN
01:57:56.736 --> 01:57:58.137
THE HEARING ROOM, SAYING NONE
01:57:58.204 --> 01:57:59.372
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES,
01:57:59.439 --> 01:58:03.342
MADAM MODERATOR. THANK YOU FOR
01:58:03.409 --> 01:58:05.812
YOUR SUPPORT OF A 22 17. YOU MAY
01:58:05.878 --> 01:58:08.748
PRESS ONE, AND THEN ZERO AGAIN
01:58:08.815 --> 01:58:10.683
THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO IF
01:58:10.750 --> 01:58:13.686
YOU'RE IN SUPPORT AND WE WILL GO
01:58:13.753 --> 01:58:16.823
TO LINE. 2 28. YOUR LINE IS
01:58:16.889 --> 01:58:21.527
OPEN. THINK YOU'VE DONE ON
01:58:21.594 --> 01:58:22.728
BEHALF OF HOUSING ACTION
01:58:22.795 --> 01:58:26.399
COALITION AND SUPPORT THANK YOU
01:58:26.466 --> 01:58:31.437
LYING TO 29. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
01:58:31.504 --> 01:58:32.405
AND MEMBERS OF THE WESTERN
01:58:32.472 --> 01:58:34.207
CENTER ON LAW AND POVERTY AND
01:58:34.273 --> 01:58:38.110
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. LYING TO 88
01:58:38.177 --> 01:58:45.284
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. LINE 2 88.
01:58:45.351 --> 01:58:47.186
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
01:58:47.253 --> 01:58:57.263
AHEAD. DO YOU HAVE A MUTE? AND
01:58:57.330 --> 01:58:58.564
WE HAVE NO FURTHER SUPPRTING
01:58:58.631 --> 01:59:00.433
QUÊ IT THIS TIME, MISS TEACHER
01:59:00.500 --> 01:59:03.202
GREAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH WILL
01:59:03.269 --> 01:59:04.370
NOW GO TO OPPOSITION. IS THERE
01:59:04.437 --> 01:59:06.038
ANY OPPOSITION IN ROOM 2100?
01:59:06.105 --> 01:59:07.273
SEEING THEM WILL GO TO THE PHONE
01:59:07.340 --> 01:59:12.044
LINES. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
01:59:12.111 --> 01:59:14.180
OPPOSITION OF A B 22 17 YOU MAKE
01:59:14.247 --> 01:59:19.218
PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO. AGAIN
01:59:19.285 --> 01:59:21.954
FOR OPPOSITION OF A B 22 17 YOU
01:59:22.021 --> 01:59:27.593
MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
01:59:27.660 --> 01:59:29.061
AND MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
01:59:29.128 --> 01:59:30.429
OPPOSITION IN. Q. GREAT. WE'LL
01:59:30.496 --> 01:59:31.764
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
01:59:31.831 --> 01:59:33.332
COLLEAGUES. ANY QUESTIONS OR
01:59:33.399 --> 01:59:33.900
COMMENTS, SENATOR WIECKOWSKI
01:59:33.966 --> 01:59:36.736
ALRIGHT? LOOKED LIKE HE WAS ON
01:59:36.802 --> 01:59:40.039
THE VERGE. OKAY SEEING NONE. YOU
01:59:40.106 --> 01:59:44.443
MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
01:59:44.510 --> 01:59:46.379
AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUILT BY
01:59:46.445 --> 01:59:48.214
NONPROFITS, I THINK IS ONE OF
01:59:48.281 --> 01:59:50.616
THE WAYS TO GO. UM WE'VE SEEN
01:59:50.683 --> 01:59:52.118
GREAT SUCCESS WITH HABITAT FOR
01:59:52.184 --> 01:59:54.086
HUMANITY IN ALL OF OUR
01:59:54.153 --> 01:59:55.154
COMMUNITIES, INCLUDING MINE AND
01:59:55.221 --> 01:59:56.255
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
01:59:56.322 --> 01:59:59.225
VOTE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MOTION
01:59:59.292 --> 02:00:00.793
BY CENTER WIECKOWSKI. I AM
02:00:00.860 --> 02:00:02.862
RECOMMENDING AN AYE VOTE AND THE
02:00:02.929 --> 02:00:05.665
MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
02:00:05.731 --> 02:00:06.832
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:00:06.899 --> 02:00:08.634
APPROPRIATIONS. PLEASE CALL THE
02:00:08.701 --> 02:00:10.836
ROLL, SENATOR WIENER, WIENER
02:00:10.903 --> 02:00:15.207
FATES CABALLERO CORTESI MCGUIRE
02:00:15.274 --> 02:00:18.210
BOOK YOUR BOOK I SKINNER HAMBURG
02:00:18.277 --> 02:00:21.347
. WIECKOWSKI I ZERO. THANK YOU
02:00:21.414 --> 02:00:23.683
PUT THAT ON CALL. OKAY I SEE.
02:00:23.749 --> 02:00:24.684
REMEMBER, QUIRK-SILVA IS HERE.
02:00:24.750 --> 02:00:26.686
WELCOME. HOPE YOU ENJOYED THE
02:00:26.752 --> 02:00:27.853
WEEKEND AND SAN FRANCISCO. I SAW
02:00:27.920 --> 02:00:31.857
IT ON SOCIAL MEDIA. UM ITEM 14
02:00:31.924 --> 02:00:38.631
82 2 TO 1. YES I DID ENJOY THAT
02:00:38.698 --> 02:00:42.034
SAN FRANCISCO DODGER GAME. AH
02:00:42.101 --> 02:00:45.571
GOOD JOB ON THOSE GIANTS. BUT MR
02:00:45.638 --> 02:00:46.839
CHAIR I'M HERE TO PRESENT A B
02:00:46.906 --> 02:00:50.242
2221, MY ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT
02:00:50.309 --> 02:00:55.047
BILL. A B 2 TO 1 WILL CLARIFY
02:00:55.114 --> 02:00:57.483
EXISTING LAW TO HELP EXPEDITE
02:00:57.550 --> 02:01:01.053
THE DEVELOPMENT OF A D US JUST
02:01:01.120 --> 02:01:02.722
TO REFRESH SOME PEOPLE CALL HIM
02:01:02.788 --> 02:01:06.058
A DUS. BUT SENATOR WIECKOWSKI
02:01:06.125 --> 02:01:07.293
WILL REMEMBER THAT WE USED TO
02:01:07.360 --> 02:01:09.161
CALL THEM MOTHER IN LAW OR
02:01:09.228 --> 02:01:11.597
GRANNY FLATS. LAST YEAR,
02:01:11.664 --> 02:01:13.099
CALIFORNIA BROKE THE $800,000
02:01:13.165 --> 02:01:16.435
MEDIAN HOME PRICE MARK. FOR THE
02:01:16.502 --> 02:01:19.338
FIRST TIME IN HISTORY IF WE WANT
02:01:19.405 --> 02:01:20.573
TO SUPPORT OUR WORKING
02:01:20.640 --> 02:01:22.842
CALIFORNIANS AND THEIR PURSUIT
02:01:22.908 --> 02:01:24.210
OF THE CALIFORNIA DREAM OF
02:01:24.276 --> 02:01:25.411
HOMEOWNERSHIP, THEN WE MUST MAKE
02:01:25.478 --> 02:01:28.447
HOMES MORE AFFORDABLE. ONE OF
02:01:28.514 --> 02:01:31.450
THE BRIGHT SMILE IN BUILDING IN
02:01:31.517 --> 02:01:34.754
CALIFORNIA HAS BEEN A D. U S.
02:01:34.820 --> 02:01:36.522
AND WE ARE SEEING MORE INTEREST
02:01:36.589 --> 02:01:37.657
IN PEOPLE USING THEIR OWN
02:01:37.723 --> 02:01:41.527
PROPERTY TO ADD ANOTHER UNIT.
02:01:41.594 --> 02:01:43.329
AWS ARE PART OF THE SOLUTION TO
02:01:43.396 --> 02:01:45.898
OUR STATE'S HOUSING CRISIS IN
02:01:45.965 --> 02:01:47.700
THIS MEASURE WILL HELP OWNERS
02:01:47.767 --> 02:01:49.935
HOMEOWNERS GET ACCESS TO A D U.
02:01:50.002 --> 02:01:52.004
S AND SPEED THE DEVELOPMENT OF
02:01:52.071 --> 02:01:55.041
HOUSING ACROSS CALIFORNIA. THIS
02:01:55.107 --> 02:01:58.678
BILL SIMPLY CLARIFIES EXISTING
02:01:58.744 --> 02:02:01.080
EU LAW THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
02:02:01.147 --> 02:02:03.282
READ MUST RETURN A FULL SET OF
02:02:03.349 --> 02:02:05.051
COMMENTS TO A PROJECT COMPONENT
02:02:05.117 --> 02:02:07.486
WITHIN 60 DAYS OF THE SUBMISSION
02:02:07.553 --> 02:02:10.589
OF THE RADIO APPLICATION. IN
02:02:10.656 --> 02:02:13.192
MANY CITIES. WE HAVE SEEN THAT
02:02:13.259 --> 02:02:16.562
60 DAYS MANY TIMES LOOK MORE
02:02:16.629 --> 02:02:18.130
LIKE SIX MONTHS TO A YEAR,
02:02:18.197 --> 02:02:20.132
SOMETIMES FOR APPLICATION AND
02:02:20.199 --> 02:02:22.201
ALSO SPECIFIES THAT LOCAL
02:02:22.268 --> 02:02:23.803
GOVERNMENTS CANNOT EXCEED THE
02:02:23.869 --> 02:02:25.638
LIMITS ON PLANNING STANDARDS FOR
02:02:25.705 --> 02:02:28.307
CERTAIN TYPES OF AID US THAT ARE
02:02:28.374 --> 02:02:28.874
ALREADY IN STATE LAWS AND
02:02:28.941 --> 02:02:32.044
FINALLY EXPENSIVE DEFINITION. OF
02:02:32.111 --> 02:02:35.548
THE PERMITTING AGENCY TO ANY
02:02:35.614 --> 02:02:37.316
AGENCY THAT MIGHT ISSUE A PERMIT
02:02:37.383 --> 02:02:39.318
TO A PROJECT APPLICANT, NOT JUST
02:02:39.385 --> 02:02:40.786
THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT AND
02:02:40.853 --> 02:02:42.588
AGAIN, THAT'S IMPORTANT AS WE
02:02:42.655 --> 02:02:45.191
KNOW THAT MANY CITIES DON'T HAVE
02:02:45.257 --> 02:02:48.227
A FULL PLANNER ON SITE AND THOSE
02:02:48.294 --> 02:02:49.528
PLANS THAT NEED TO GO OUT AND
02:02:49.595 --> 02:02:51.597
MANY TIMES THAT TURNAROUND CAN
02:02:51.664 --> 02:02:54.066
BE QUITE LENGTHY. SO WITH THAT
02:02:54.133 --> 02:02:56.569
TODAY WE HAVE IN SUPPORT OF THE
02:02:56.635 --> 02:02:57.603
BILL TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
02:02:57.670 --> 02:02:58.738
FROM THE COMMITTEE. WE HAVE
02:02:58.804 --> 02:03:01.540
JORDAN'S CARVAJAL WITH
02:03:01.607 --> 02:03:03.309
CALIFORNIA TMB. THANK YOU VERY
02:03:03.375 --> 02:03:05.244
MUCH. AND MR CARVAJAL, YOU MAY
02:03:05.311 --> 02:03:07.146
PROCEED. GOOD AFTERNOON CHAIR
02:03:07.213 --> 02:03:08.180
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
02:03:08.247 --> 02:03:10.049
NAME IS JORDAN. PARANA CARVAJAL
02:03:10.116 --> 02:03:11.684
ADVOCATE FOR CALIFORNIA AND BE
02:03:11.751 --> 02:03:13.519
WHERE THE PROUD SPONSOR AND HERE
02:03:13.586 --> 02:03:14.653
TO SUPPORT SPEAKING SUPPORT 22
02:03:14.720 --> 02:03:18.023
21. CALIFORNIA IS A STATEWIDE
02:03:18.090 --> 02:03:19.825
ORGANIZATION OF OVER 80,000
02:03:19.892 --> 02:03:22.161
NEIGHBORS GET TO MAKING OUR
02:03:22.228 --> 02:03:23.462
STATE AND FORMAL PLACE TO LIVE
02:03:23.529 --> 02:03:25.231
WORK AND RAISE A FAMILY FOR ALL
02:03:25.297 --> 02:03:26.365
RAISE THEIR FAMILY FOR ALL
02:03:26.432 --> 02:03:28.334
CALIFORNIANS. ONE OF THE WAYS WE
02:03:28.400 --> 02:03:30.402
CAN ACCOMPLISH THAT THAT GOAL IS
02:03:30.469 --> 02:03:31.971
BYPASSING REFORMS THAT WILL
02:03:32.037 --> 02:03:33.339
ACCELERATE ESPECIALLY ADRENALINE
02:03:33.405 --> 02:03:34.840
UNIONS ALSO KNOWN THAT ALSO
02:03:34.907 --> 02:03:36.242
KNOWN AT 80. U S PRODUCTION BY
02:03:36.308 --> 02:03:37.309
CLARIFYING BY CLARIFYING EIGHT
02:03:37.376 --> 02:03:39.812
EU RULES. WHERE LOCAL
02:03:39.879 --> 02:03:41.947
GOVERNMENTS AND HOMEOWNERS SINCE
02:03:42.014 --> 02:03:43.716
CALIFORNIA ENACTING LAWS TO
02:03:43.783 --> 02:03:45.117
ALLOW IT TO USE ON REGINALD
02:03:45.184 --> 02:03:46.719
RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES HAS
02:03:46.786 --> 02:03:48.053
FURTHER CREATIONS OF TENS OF
02:03:48.120 --> 02:03:49.755
THOUSANDS OF HOMES IN THE
02:03:49.822 --> 02:03:51.390
CREATION OF A MULTI BILLION
02:03:51.457 --> 02:03:52.324
DOLLAR INDUSTRY FOR EU
02:03:52.391 --> 02:03:55.294
SPECIALISTS. ACCORDING TO
02:03:55.361 --> 02:03:57.563
RESEARCH FROM THE UC BERKELEY
02:03:57.630 --> 02:03:58.798
TURNER CENTER, 80 USE PRODUCE
02:03:58.864 --> 02:04:00.699
MORE AFFORDABLE HOMES TYPICALLY
02:04:00.766 --> 02:04:01.901
OCCUPIED BY LOW INCOME FAMILIES
02:04:01.967 --> 02:04:05.204
AND INDIVIDUALS. MAYBE 20 TO 21
02:04:05.271 --> 02:04:07.072
, TEXAS, ONE STEP CLOSER TO
02:04:07.139 --> 02:04:08.207
ADDRESSING THE HOUSING SHORTAGE
02:04:08.274 --> 02:04:09.742
BUT EXPANDING AVENUES FOR
02:04:09.809 --> 02:04:10.976
HOMEOWNERS TO ACCELERATE THE
02:04:11.043 --> 02:04:13.813
PRODUCTIONS OF 80 US. CALIFORNIA
02:04:13.879 --> 02:04:15.414
HAS A SHORTAGE OF THREE POINT
02:04:15.481 --> 02:04:18.083
MITT 3.5 MILLION HOMES, AND WE
02:04:18.150 --> 02:04:19.118
BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL WOULD BE
02:04:19.185 --> 02:04:21.320
ONE OF THE SOLUTIONS TO GET US
02:04:21.387 --> 02:04:23.155
BACK ON TRACK. AND WITH THAT, I
02:04:23.222 --> 02:04:23.689
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR
02:04:23.756 --> 02:04:25.391
SUPPORT FOR A B 20 TO 21. THANK
02:04:25.457 --> 02:04:27.493
YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANY
02:04:27.560 --> 02:04:29.428
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT IN ROOM 2100?
02:04:29.495 --> 02:04:30.663
SEEING NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE
02:04:30.729 --> 02:04:35.434
LINES. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:04:35.501 --> 02:04:37.369
SUPPORT OF A B 20 TO 21. YOU
02:04:37.436 --> 02:04:40.806
MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN ZERO.
02:04:40.873 --> 02:04:42.074
AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND THEN ZERO,
02:04:42.141 --> 02:04:44.844
FEAR AND SUPPORT. OF A B 20 TO
02:04:44.910 --> 02:04:52.818
21. AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 2 71.
02:04:52.885 --> 02:04:54.720
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:04:54.787 --> 02:04:57.189
AHEAD. THAT BOOK EXCEPT THE NBA
02:04:57.256 --> 02:04:59.158
IN SUPPORT OF A B 2221. THANK
02:04:59.225 --> 02:05:03.562
YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT WILL LINE
02:05:03.629 --> 02:05:07.032
UP TO 75. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
02:05:07.099 --> 02:05:08.834
THIS IS RYAN O'CONNELL. FROM HOW
02:05:08.901 --> 02:05:10.970
TO A D U AND EYE CALLING IN
02:05:11.036 --> 02:05:16.775
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:05:16.842 --> 02:05:18.777
AND WE HAVE LINE TO 90. YOUR
02:05:18.844 --> 02:05:21.947
LINEIS OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:05:22.014 --> 02:05:23.515
MR CHAIRMAN MEMBERS, PAT MORAN,
02:05:23.582 --> 02:05:24.550
WITH AARON READING ASSOCIATES
02:05:24.617 --> 02:05:25.651
REPRESENTING THE SOUTHERN
02:05:25.718 --> 02:05:26.585
CALIFORNIA RENTAL HOUSING
02:05:26.652 --> 02:05:30.689
ASSOCIATION. SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:05:30.756 --> 02:05:33.025
THANK YOU, MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
02:05:33.092 --> 02:05:34.827
FURTHER SUPPORTING QUÊ AT THIS
02:05:34.894 --> 02:05:36.795
TIME. UM WELL, NO GOOD
02:05:36.862 --> 02:05:37.830
OPPOSITION. IS THERE ANY
02:05:37.897 --> 02:05:40.566
OPPOSITION IN ROOM 2100? SEEING
02:05:40.633 --> 02:05:42.468
NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES
02:05:42.534 --> 02:05:45.804
FOR OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. FOR
02:05:45.871 --> 02:05:47.640
NOW. THERE'S A BABY 20 TO 21.
02:05:47.706 --> 02:05:49.541
YOU MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN
02:05:49.608 --> 02:05:53.445
ZERO. AGAIN. THAT IS ONE AND
02:05:53.512 --> 02:05:57.783
THEN ZERO. YOU'RE NOT POSITION.
02:05:57.850 --> 02:05:59.485
AND WE HAVE NO OPPOSITION IN
02:05:59.551 --> 02:06:01.053
CUBA AT THIS TIME, MR CHIP.
02:06:01.120 --> 02:06:02.388
GREAT THANK YOU. WE'LL BRING IT
02:06:02.454 --> 02:06:03.255
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES
02:06:03.322 --> 02:06:07.026
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS THE
02:06:07.092 --> 02:06:09.161
STAFF REPORT AT PAGE FIVE,
02:06:09.228 --> 02:06:12.097
ROLLING INTO SIX ASKED THAT THE
02:06:12.164 --> 02:06:13.999
AUTHOR AND ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:06:14.066 --> 02:06:17.670
SALAS WORK WITH THE AUTHOR OF SB
02:06:17.736 --> 02:06:19.972
897 TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
02:06:20.039 --> 02:06:22.207
CHAPTER RING AND THE OBJECTIVE
02:06:22.274 --> 02:06:25.344
STANDARDS SO I'M REPRESENTING
02:06:25.411 --> 02:06:26.478
THAT. THE AUTHORS EAGER TO WORK
02:06:26.545 --> 02:06:30.516
WITH UH, THE OTHER TWO AUTHORS
02:06:30.582 --> 02:06:32.518
AND THE AUTHORS IN FRONT OF US
02:06:32.584 --> 02:06:33.786
TO HARMONIZE THOSE CHAPTERS, SO
02:06:33.852 --> 02:06:35.421
WE GET THEM IN THE RIGHT CODE
02:06:35.487 --> 02:06:38.424
SECTION. AND I'LL MOVE THE BILL.
02:06:38.490 --> 02:06:41.093
GREAT THANK YOU. UM CHAPTER IS
02:06:41.160 --> 02:06:44.530
ALMOST IT'S ALWAYS SO MUCH FUN.
02:06:44.596 --> 02:06:46.732
UM SO SOMETHING LIKE, THANK YOU
02:06:46.799 --> 02:06:48.133
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD AND
02:06:48.200 --> 02:06:48.968
FOR YOUR WORK IN GENERAL AND
02:06:49.034 --> 02:06:50.436
HOUSING, AND I'M HAPPY TO
02:06:50.502 --> 02:06:53.572
SUPPORT THIS LEGISLATION AND
02:06:53.639 --> 02:06:56.608
WITHOUT I THINK WE HAVE A MOTION
02:06:56.675 --> 02:06:57.242
BY SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. AND THAT
02:06:57.309 --> 02:06:59.244
MOTION ISD PASS, BUT FIRST BE
02:06:59.311 --> 02:07:00.546
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:07:00.612 --> 02:07:01.613
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE, AND WE
02:07:01.680 --> 02:07:03.415
WILL AND YOU MAY CLOSE.
02:07:03.482 --> 02:07:08.187
DISRESPECTFULLY AS FRAN. I VOTE.
02:07:08.253 --> 02:07:10.489
SENATOR WIENER? AYE BATES VOTING
02:07:10.556 --> 02:07:15.828
COPYRIGHT CORTESI ACQUIRE. A
02:07:15.894 --> 02:07:19.798
CHILD, BUG. I SKINNER. HAMBURG
02:07:19.865 --> 02:07:22.835
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I 3 TO 0.
02:07:22.901 --> 02:07:24.503
WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL FOR
02:07:24.570 --> 02:07:25.270
ABSENT MEMBERS. THANK YOU FAMILY
02:07:25.337 --> 02:07:28.507
MEMBER, AND NOW WE WILL GO TO
02:07:28.574 --> 02:07:29.608
ITEM 17 ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JOAN
02:07:29.675 --> 02:07:33.412
SAWYER. 80 28 73 WELCOME
02:07:33.479 --> 02:07:38.717
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. THANK YOU.
02:07:38.784 --> 02:07:41.120
CHAIR MEMBERS, UM, ARRIVED TO
02:07:41.186 --> 02:07:43.288
PRESENT A B 28 73, THE
02:07:43.355 --> 02:07:44.757
AFFORDABLE HOUSING SUPPLIER
02:07:44.823 --> 02:07:46.291
DIVERSITY ACT, WHICH WILL
02:07:46.358 --> 02:07:47.192
REQUIRE HOUSING SPONSORED THAT
02:07:47.259 --> 02:07:48.293
RECEIVED AN ALLOCATION OF LOW
02:07:48.360 --> 02:07:50.929
INCOME TAX CREDIT. THE REPORT TO
02:07:50.996 --> 02:07:52.564
THE REPORT. THE USE OF WOMEN,
02:07:52.631 --> 02:07:54.767
MINORITY DISABLED VETERANS AND
02:07:54.833 --> 02:07:57.803
LGBT Q BUSINESS ENTERPRISES
02:07:57.870 --> 02:07:59.438
MEMBERS, THOUGH CALIFORNIA HAS
02:07:59.505 --> 02:08:00.873
RECENTLY MAKES SIGNIFICANT
02:08:00.939 --> 02:08:02.274
INVESTMENTS INTO AFFORDABLE
02:08:02.341 --> 02:08:03.675
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT, THESE
02:08:03.742 --> 02:08:05.310
RESOURCES HAVE BEEN HISTORICALLY
02:08:05.377 --> 02:08:07.012
LIMITED TO DEVELOPERS THAT DO
02:08:07.079 --> 02:08:08.180
NOT ALWAYS REFLECT OUR STATE'S
02:08:08.247 --> 02:08:09.214
RICH RACIAL AND ETHNIC
02:08:09.281 --> 02:08:12.584
DIVERSITY. THE INDUSTRY BY AND
02:08:12.651 --> 02:08:14.686
LARGE HAS NOT MADE A CONSCIOUS
02:08:14.753 --> 02:08:15.921
EFFORT TO ENSURE THAT MORE
02:08:15.988 --> 02:08:18.090
DIVERSE AND WOMEN OWNED FIRMS
02:08:18.157 --> 02:08:19.558
HAVE ACCESS TO DEVELOPMENT
02:08:19.625 --> 02:08:21.660
RELATED CONTRACTS. THIS BILL IS
02:08:21.727 --> 02:08:22.895
AN OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE
02:08:22.961 --> 02:08:24.129
CALIFORNIA MORE EQUITABLE BY
02:08:24.196 --> 02:08:25.431
REQUIRING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:08:25.497 --> 02:08:26.532
DEVELOPERS SHOULD CREATE A
02:08:26.598 --> 02:08:28.600
REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE. A
02:08:28.667 --> 02:08:31.203
DETAILED AND VERIFIABLE PLAN WAS
02:08:31.270 --> 02:08:32.404
SHORT AND LONG TERM GOALS TO
02:08:32.471 --> 02:08:34.506
INCREASE DIVERSE PROCUREMENT. A
02:08:34.573 --> 02:08:36.708
B 28 73 IS ABOUT CREATING
02:08:36.775 --> 02:08:38.277
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR
02:08:38.343 --> 02:08:39.711
UNDERREPRESENTED COMMUNITIES WHO
02:08:39.778 --> 02:08:41.814
NEED IT MOST BIODIVERSE FIRMS
02:08:41.880 --> 02:08:43.449
THAT MORE LIKELY TO PUT THESE
02:08:43.515 --> 02:08:44.550
COMMUNITIES AND THE PEOPLE THAT
02:08:44.616 --> 02:08:46.952
LIVE IN THEM. FIRST THIS MEASURE
02:08:47.019 --> 02:08:49.288
WILL INCREASE TRANSPARENCY ON
02:08:49.354 --> 02:08:51.323
WHO BENEFITS FROM STATE DOLLARS
02:08:51.390 --> 02:08:53.459
AND PROVIDE CRUCIAL DATA TO THIS
02:08:53.525 --> 02:08:54.626
BODY THAT WILL ASSIST IN
02:08:54.693 --> 02:08:55.828
CRAFTING NEW HOUSING POLICIES.
02:08:55.894 --> 02:08:56.829
CENTERED ON DIVERSITY, EQUITY
02:08:56.895 --> 02:08:58.530
AND INCLUSION. JOINING ME TO
02:08:58.597 --> 02:09:03.202
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT. OUR
02:09:03.268 --> 02:09:05.204
CONSTANTINE CONSTANTINE HATCHER
02:09:05.270 --> 02:09:10.509
WITH CALIFORNIA BMB. AH GOOD
02:09:10.576 --> 02:09:12.044
AFTERNOON. THANK YOU. CHAIRS AND
02:09:12.111 --> 02:09:13.679
COMMITTEE MEMBERS FOR HAVING ME
02:09:13.745 --> 02:09:15.147
HERE TODAY AND THANK YOU STILL
02:09:15.214 --> 02:09:16.582
REMEMBER JOAN SAWYER FOR YOUR
02:09:16.648 --> 02:09:17.549
LEADERSHIP AND AUTHORING THIS
02:09:17.616 --> 02:09:18.784
IMPORTANT BILL. MY NAME IS
02:09:18.851 --> 02:09:20.452
CONSTANTINE HATCHER THEME
02:09:20.519 --> 02:09:22.254
DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY IMPACT FOR
02:09:22.321 --> 02:09:23.322
CALIFORNIA. UM, BEING PROUD CO
02:09:23.388 --> 02:09:28.060
SPONSOR. OF A B 28 73. I'M ALSO
02:09:28.127 --> 02:09:30.329
THREAT IN TOOK PRESIDENCY OF THE
02:09:30.395 --> 02:09:32.064
LINDA SH OF THE CENTER BY LINDE
02:09:32.131 --> 02:09:34.066
ASTRI TO ALLEVIATE AFFORDABLE
02:09:34.133 --> 02:09:35.567
HOUSING CRISIS AND UNPRECEDENTED
02:09:35.634 --> 02:09:37.069
INVESTMENT IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
02:09:37.136 --> 02:09:38.637
DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN DEPLOYED.
02:09:38.704 --> 02:09:40.939
IN FACT, 52 BILLION BETWEEN 2000
02:09:41.006 --> 02:09:43.809
AND 15 AND 2020. WE ALSO KNOW
02:09:43.876 --> 02:09:44.643
CALIFORNIA NEEDS ABOUT THREE
02:09:44.710 --> 02:09:46.512
TIMES THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE IN
02:09:46.578 --> 02:09:47.746
THE CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE. AND
02:09:47.813 --> 02:09:49.882
HAS NOW TO BUILD THE HOMES THAT
02:09:49.948 --> 02:09:51.517
WE NEED, HOWEVER, BUSINESSES
02:09:51.583 --> 02:09:52.851
OWNED BY PEOPLE OF COLOR AND
02:09:52.918 --> 02:09:54.887
OTHER MINORITIES HAVE NOT SHARED
02:09:54.953 --> 02:09:55.854
IN THESE DEVELOPMENT RESOURCES
02:09:55.921 --> 02:09:58.991
AT A RATE EQUIVALENT, UM TO OUR
02:09:59.057 --> 02:10:01.026
STATE'S RICH DIVERSITY. OVER THE
02:10:01.093 --> 02:10:02.461
YEARS, THIS HAS LED TO DIVERSE
02:10:02.528 --> 02:10:03.929
FIRMS LOSING BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
02:10:03.996 --> 02:10:05.464
IN POTENTIAL CONTRACTS, WHICH
02:10:05.531 --> 02:10:06.365
MEANS THE FIRST COMMUNITIES HAVE
02:10:06.431 --> 02:10:08.133
MISSED OUT ON THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:10:08.200 --> 02:10:09.101
EARN BILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN
02:10:09.168 --> 02:10:10.536
WEALTH. AND THOUSANDS OF LIFE
02:10:10.602 --> 02:10:12.104
CHANGING JOBS IF THE
02:10:12.171 --> 02:10:13.539
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY WAS AS
02:10:13.605 --> 02:10:14.673
DIVERSE AS CALIFORNIA'S
02:10:14.740 --> 02:10:15.807
POPULATION ARE DIVERSE
02:10:15.874 --> 02:10:16.808
COMMUNITIES COULD EXPECT
02:10:16.875 --> 02:10:19.645
APPROXIMATELY 32.4 BILLION IN
02:10:19.711 --> 02:10:21.113
PAYROLL INVESTMENTS ALONE.
02:10:21.180 --> 02:10:22.047
IMAGINE THE IMPACT THESE
02:10:22.114 --> 02:10:23.515
RESOURCES COULD HAVE ON SOME OF
02:10:23.582 --> 02:10:24.850
OUR MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES
02:10:24.917 --> 02:10:26.451
BY JUST INCENTIVIZING, OUR
02:10:26.518 --> 02:10:27.486
AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUILDERS TO
02:10:27.553 --> 02:10:28.587
BE MORE INTENTIONAL ABOUT WHO
02:10:28.654 --> 02:10:31.256
THEY ARE HIRING. EVERY 28 73 IS
02:10:31.323 --> 02:10:32.291
THE FIRST STEP IN ADDRESSING
02:10:32.357 --> 02:10:34.193
THIS TRAGIC INEQUITY AND GIVES
02:10:34.259 --> 02:10:35.294
THE OPPORTUNITY TO DRIVE FOR
02:10:35.360 --> 02:10:37.196
RACIAL AND ECONOMIC JUSTICE AND
02:10:37.262 --> 02:10:38.664
PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY AROUND
02:10:38.730 --> 02:10:39.798
RACIAL INEQUITIES WITHIN THE
02:10:39.865 --> 02:10:40.899
INDUSTRY BY TRACKING SUPPLIER
02:10:40.966 --> 02:10:43.502
DIVERSITY. BY DIVERSIFYING THE
02:10:43.569 --> 02:10:44.970
PIPELINE OF PEOPLE WHO SHARE IN
02:10:45.037 --> 02:10:46.438
THE REVENUE RESULTING FROM THESE
02:10:46.505 --> 02:10:47.439
VITAL PUBLIC INVESTMENTS. WE CAN
02:10:47.506 --> 02:10:48.240
INCREASE WEALTH AMONGST
02:10:48.307 --> 02:10:49.608
COMMUNITIES TYPICALLY EXCLUDED
02:10:49.675 --> 02:10:52.444
FROM SUCH VALUABLE OPPORTUNITIES
02:10:52.511 --> 02:10:54.012
SIMULTANEOUSLY NURTURING DIVERSE
02:10:54.079 --> 02:10:55.480
CONSTRUCTION AND DEVELOPMENT
02:10:55.547 --> 02:10:56.381
PLATFORMS WILL HELP INCREASE THE
02:10:56.448 --> 02:10:57.382
VOLUME OF DESPERATELY NEEDED
02:10:57.449 --> 02:10:58.584
CONSTRUCTION, DESIGN,
02:10:58.650 --> 02:11:01.453
ENGINEERING AND OTHER RELATED
02:11:01.520 --> 02:11:02.854
BERMS OPERATING SUCCESSFULLY
02:11:02.921 --> 02:11:04.590
ACROSS THE STATE. UPLIFTING
02:11:04.656 --> 02:11:05.857
DIVERSE FIRMS AND WORKERS WILL
02:11:05.924 --> 02:11:06.959
HELP INCREASE ANNUAL NUMBER OF
02:11:07.025 --> 02:11:09.027
HOMES BUILT IN CALIFORNIA AND
02:11:09.094 --> 02:11:10.028
HELP FINANCIALLY EMPOWERED
02:11:10.095 --> 02:11:11.129
COMMUNITIES OF COLOR THAT HAVE
02:11:11.196 --> 02:11:13.031
LONG BEEN SHUT OUT PAST THE
02:11:13.098 --> 02:11:14.433
UPWARD MOBILITY AND PROSPERITY.
02:11:14.499 --> 02:11:15.667
THIS HELPS GROW THE WORKPLACE
02:11:15.734 --> 02:11:17.436
FORCE IN A WAY THAT ENCOURAGES
02:11:17.502 --> 02:11:18.704
EQUITY, HELPING SOLVE OUR
02:11:18.770 --> 02:11:20.272
OVERALL SUPPLY SHORTAGE IN A WAY
02:11:20.339 --> 02:11:22.107
THAT ALSO ADVANCES GOOD JOBS
02:11:22.174 --> 02:11:24.276
WHERE PEOPLE OF COLOR WOMEN AND
02:11:24.343 --> 02:11:25.911
THOSE FROM DIVERSE BACKGROUNDS.
02:11:25.978 --> 02:11:26.912
THIS IS WHY ON BEHALF OF
02:11:26.979 --> 02:11:29.047
CALIFORNIA MB IN OUR 80,000
02:11:29.114 --> 02:11:30.816
MEMBERS AFFILIATED ORGANIZATIONS
02:11:30.882 --> 02:11:32.684
ACROSS THE STATE. I HUMBLY
02:11:32.751 --> 02:11:33.819
REQUEST YOUR VOTE IN SUPPORT OF
02:11:33.885 --> 02:11:37.422
A B 28 73. THANK YOU. AND I
02:11:37.489 --> 02:11:40.025
BELIEVE OUR SECOND WIN. THIS IS
02:11:40.092 --> 02:11:41.560
, UH, SHE COULDN'T MAKE IT WAS
02:11:41.627 --> 02:11:43.462
GOING TO MAKE IT. I'M SORRY.
02:11:43.528 --> 02:11:45.097
OKAY UM, IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL
02:11:45.163 --> 02:11:46.198
SUPPORT OF PUBLIC COMMENT HERE
02:11:46.265 --> 02:11:49.001
IN 2100? SEEING NONE WILL GO TO
02:11:49.067 --> 02:11:52.471
THE PHONE LINE. THANK YOU FOR
02:11:52.537 --> 02:11:54.906
YOUR SUPPORT OF A B 28 73 YOU
02:11:54.973 --> 02:11:58.644
MAKE ONE THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT
02:11:58.710 --> 02:12:00.445
IS ONE AND THEN ZERO APPEARANCE
02:12:00.512 --> 02:12:06.485
SUPPORT. AND WE CALL LINE 2 TO
02:12:06.551 --> 02:12:08.453
71. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:12:08.520 --> 02:12:11.890
AHEAD. HI THIS IS ADAM BOOK
02:12:11.957 --> 02:12:13.091
FIGHTER FOR THE NBA IN SUPPORT
02:12:13.158 --> 02:12:17.529
OF A B 2873. THANK YOU. THANK
02:12:17.596 --> 02:12:19.331
YOU AND NEXT, WE'LL GO TO LINE
02:12:19.398 --> 02:12:23.302
UP TO 75. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. IT
02:12:23.368 --> 02:12:25.037
IS RYAN O'CONNELL COLLEAGUE FROM
02:12:25.103 --> 02:12:26.305
NAPA. SOLANO, UM, B AND SUPPORT.
02:12:26.371 --> 02:12:32.544
THANK YOU. OKAY. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:12:32.611 --> 02:12:37.683
WE WILL GO TO LINE. USE ME TO 96
02:12:37.749 --> 02:12:39.618
. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:12:39.685 --> 02:12:43.288
AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON STRATA
02:12:43.355 --> 02:12:44.790
WITHDREW STRATEGIES CALLING ON
02:12:44.856 --> 02:12:46.758
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA FORWARD
02:12:46.825 --> 02:12:49.628
ACTION FUND AND SUPPORT THANK
02:12:49.695 --> 02:12:54.232
YOU. AND WE HAVE TWO MORE IN Q
02:12:54.299 --> 02:13:04.109
ONE MOMENT, PLEASE. WE'LL GO TO
02:13:04.176 --> 02:13:06.044
LINE TO 60 FOR YOUR LINE IS
02:13:06.111 --> 02:13:09.981
OPEN. I'M SORRY. EXCUSE ME, 2 46
02:13:10.048 --> 02:13:15.187
LINE IS OPEN. HI. GOOD
02:13:15.253 --> 02:13:16.154
AFTERNOON. THIS IS CARLA HAS
02:13:16.221 --> 02:13:17.522
HISTORY YOU GOT FROM THE LOCAL
02:13:17.589 --> 02:13:19.057
INITIATIVES CORPORATION OFFICE
02:13:19.124 --> 02:13:20.659
IN LOS ANGELES, CALLING TO
02:13:20.726 --> 02:13:25.297
STRONGLY SUPPORT MAYBE 28 73.
02:13:25.364 --> 02:13:27.499
THANK YOU. NEXT. QUOTE TILL 2 38
02:13:27.566 --> 02:13:32.204
YEAR LINE IS OPEN. RON CHÁVEZ
02:13:32.270 --> 02:13:32.738
WITH CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
02:13:32.804 --> 02:13:34.239
BUILDERS AND STRONG SUPPORT OF
02:13:34.306 --> 02:13:37.476
THE BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
02:13:37.542 --> 02:13:38.677
MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NOT FOR THE
02:13:38.744 --> 02:13:40.679
IMPORTANT QUÊ AT THIS TIME.
02:13:40.746 --> 02:13:42.447
THANK YOU. IS THERE ANY
02:13:42.514 --> 02:13:45.050
OPPOSITION IN ROOM 2100? SEEING
02:13:45.117 --> 02:13:49.321
NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
02:13:49.388 --> 02:13:50.856
THANK YOU FOR YOUR POSITION OF A
02:13:50.922 --> 02:13:53.191
B 28 73 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
02:13:53.258 --> 02:13:59.331
THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND
02:13:59.398 --> 02:14:01.066
THEN ZERO FOR AN OPPOSITION OF A
02:14:01.133 --> 02:14:06.538
B 28 73. AND MR CHAIR. WE HAVE
02:14:06.605 --> 02:14:09.040
NO LISTENING AT THE TIME. OKAY
02:14:09.107 --> 02:14:09.941
WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
02:14:10.008 --> 02:14:11.243
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS?
02:14:11.309 --> 02:14:13.578
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI, SO I THINK I
02:14:13.645 --> 02:14:14.713
UNDERSTAND THAT CURRENTLY RIGHT
02:14:14.780 --> 02:14:18.850
NOW, WHAT? ON THE CPUC PROGRAM.
02:14:18.917 --> 02:14:20.919
WE SET A THRESHOLD OF $15
02:14:20.986 --> 02:14:23.054
MILLION ON THE BOTTOM AND $25
02:14:23.121 --> 02:14:25.891
MILLION ON THE TOP, AND WE THINK
02:14:25.957 --> 02:14:27.125
THAT THIS WOULD ENCOURAGE WOMEN
02:14:27.192 --> 02:14:28.126
MINORITY DISABLED. PEOPLE SORT
02:14:28.193 --> 02:14:31.797
OF RIGHT SIZE. THIS BILL WOULD
02:14:31.863 --> 02:14:34.966
CHANGE THAT TO FIVE PROJECTS. SO
02:14:35.033 --> 02:14:37.602
I AM IN MY MIND. I'M THINKING,
02:14:37.669 --> 02:14:39.204
OKAY. IT SEEMS LIKE YOU WANT TO
02:14:39.271 --> 02:14:40.105
ENCOURAGE SMALLER PLAYERS, SO
02:14:40.172 --> 02:14:42.741
YOU DIDN'T HAVE TO MEET THE 15.
02:14:42.808 --> 02:14:47.846
MILLION DOLLAR. FLOOR RIGHT AND
02:14:47.913 --> 02:14:50.115
IT WOULD BE AND AS THE LOW UH
02:14:50.182 --> 02:14:55.220
WELL, THERE'S. AS THEY GO ABOUT
02:14:55.287 --> 02:14:56.288
REPORTING ON THIS, YOU'LL GET
02:14:56.354 --> 02:14:58.223
MORE PEOPLE INCLUDED. BUT I
02:14:58.290 --> 02:15:00.625
THOUGHT IT CAN ALSO BE THESE
02:15:00.692 --> 02:15:02.060
FIVE MEGA PROJECTS. YOU KNOW,
02:15:02.127 --> 02:15:03.829
SOMEBODY COMES IN WITH A BRAND
02:15:03.895 --> 02:15:04.930
NEW CORPORATION AND, YOU KNOW,
02:15:04.996 --> 02:15:07.132
THEY JUST SET UP AND THEY GOT
02:15:07.199 --> 02:15:08.533
ONE PROJECT. IT'S $100 MILLION.
02:15:08.600 --> 02:15:10.969
CAN YOU WALK ME THROUGH LIKE, I
02:15:11.036 --> 02:15:12.437
THINK I UNDERSTAND THE INTENT.
02:15:12.504 --> 02:15:15.707
I'M JUST THE MECHANICS AND MAYBE
02:15:15.774 --> 02:15:17.442
MY SPONSORS AND CLOSE TO TALK TO
02:15:17.509 --> 02:15:19.244
YOU, BUT PART OF PART OF THE
02:15:19.311 --> 02:15:20.479
BRINGING IT BACK TO THE
02:15:20.545 --> 02:15:22.247
LEGISLATURE IS TO ENSURE THAT
02:15:22.314 --> 02:15:23.415
WHAT YOU'RE JUST TALKING ABOUT
02:15:23.482 --> 02:15:26.017
DOESN'T HAPPEN THAT THIS BODY.
02:15:26.084 --> 02:15:28.353
MAKE ANY ADJUSTMENTS TO THE
02:15:28.420 --> 02:15:30.055
FORMULA BECAUSE IT REALLY IS
02:15:30.121 --> 02:15:31.823
ABOUT ACCESS TO CAPITAL,%
02:15:31.890 --> 02:15:32.757
ESPECIALLY WOMEN OWNED
02:15:32.824 --> 02:15:33.291
BUSINESSES AND BUSINESS OF
02:15:33.358 --> 02:15:36.795
COLOR, NOT BEING ABLE TO COMPETE
02:15:36.862 --> 02:15:39.931
ON THE LARGER SCALE. SO THIS IS
02:15:39.998 --> 02:15:41.600
FOCUSING LIKE A LASER ON THAT
02:15:41.666 --> 02:15:43.702
AND THEN TO GET THE DATA SO THAT
02:15:43.768 --> 02:15:45.237
WE CAN BE ABLE TO MAKE A MORE
02:15:45.303 --> 02:15:45.971
INFORMED DECISION BECAUSE
02:15:46.037 --> 02:15:47.506
PRESUMABLY IF THEY'VE GOT IF
02:15:47.572 --> 02:15:49.107
THEY'RE REPORTING ON IT, THEY'RE
02:15:49.174 --> 02:15:50.509
NOT GOING TO NOT INCLUDE
02:15:50.575 --> 02:15:52.577
MINORITY OWNED BUSINESSES AND
02:15:52.644 --> 02:15:53.478
LGBTQ BUSINESS IN PRICE
02:15:53.545 --> 02:15:55.514
SECURITY. TRY TO SIT THAT SO
02:15:55.580 --> 02:15:59.918
WE'RE NOT CONCERNED ABOUT. AN
02:15:59.985 --> 02:16:02.721
ADVERSE. WE ARE CONCERNED ABOUT
02:16:02.787 --> 02:16:03.955
THAT. THAT'S WHY WE WANT OPEN
02:16:04.022 --> 02:16:05.757
BOOKS AND BEING ABLE TO SEE
02:16:05.824 --> 02:16:07.459
WHAT'S GOING ON. T<c.cyan> EVERYTHING</c>
02:16:07.526 --> 02:16:12.030
ELSE. OKAY. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
02:16:12.097 --> 02:16:13.732
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
02:16:13.798 --> 02:16:20.872
WELCOME, SENATOR MCGARR. YEAH.
02:16:20.939 --> 02:16:25.210
YEAH UM OKAY MOTION BY SENATOR
02:16:25.277 --> 02:16:28.680
WIECKOWSKI, AND THAT IS EMOTION.
02:16:28.747 --> 02:16:30.815
D PASS, BOTH FIRST BE REFERRED
02:16:30.882 --> 02:16:32.317
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:16:32.384 --> 02:16:32.918
APPROPRIATIONS. SOME REMEMBER
02:16:32.984 --> 02:16:34.019
YOU MAY CLOSE RESPECT TO LAST
02:16:34.085 --> 02:16:36.121
THREE. I VOTE. I WILL CALL THE
02:16:36.187 --> 02:16:41.226
ROLL. WIENER BATES NÓI COPY YOUR
02:16:41.293 --> 02:16:44.863
OLD CORTESI. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE. I
02:16:44.930 --> 02:16:50.035
KNOW BUG. A SHOW BOOK? NO,
02:16:50.101 --> 02:16:55.273
SKINNER. HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI.
02:16:55.340 --> 02:16:56.708
WIECKOWSKI I? THAT'S THREE OR
02:16:56.775 --> 02:16:58.710
TWO. WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
02:16:58.777 --> 02:16:59.945
PERHAPS SOME MEMBERS. THANK YOU.
02:17:00.011 --> 02:17:02.013
THANK YOU. OKAY FINAL
02:17:02.080 --> 02:17:03.181
PRESENTATION. TODAY I'LL BE
02:17:03.248 --> 02:17:04.549
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY
02:17:04.616 --> 02:17:11.590
MEMBER BRIAN AND THAT IS. A B 18
02:17:11.656 --> 02:17:15.927
16 ITEM NUMBER SEVEN. SO I'M
02:17:15.994 --> 02:17:18.063
PRESENTING TODAY WOULD BE 6 18
02:17:18.129 --> 02:17:20.465
16 ON BEHALF OF SOME MEMBER
02:17:20.532 --> 02:17:21.299
BRIAN. THE BILL WILL FIND
02:17:21.366 --> 02:17:22.367
PRACTICAL AND EVIDENCE BASED
02:17:22.434 --> 02:17:26.037
SOLUTIONS. TO OUR HOMELESSNESS
02:17:26.104 --> 02:17:27.672
PROBLEM IN CALIFORNIA, ONE OF
02:17:27.739 --> 02:17:29.441
THE BIGGEST FEEDERS INTO
02:17:29.507 --> 02:17:31.610
HOMELESSNESS IS OUR SYSTEM OF
02:17:31.676 --> 02:17:33.945
MASS INCARCERATION. AH IN FACT,
02:17:34.012 --> 02:17:38.350
IT HAS BECOME SUCH A MAJOR
02:17:38.416 --> 02:17:39.918
FEEDER IN THE HOMELESSNESS THAT
02:17:39.985 --> 02:17:42.821
CDCR ESTIMATES ABOUT 20% OF ALL
02:17:42.887 --> 02:17:43.955
PEOPLE LEAVING PRISONS WILL
02:17:44.022 --> 02:17:46.424
LEAVE ONLY TO BECOME HOMELESS.
02:17:46.491 --> 02:17:49.060
IN ADDITION, THE CRS ESTIMATED
02:17:49.127 --> 02:17:51.529
THAT ABOUT A THIRD TO HALF OF
02:17:51.596 --> 02:17:53.465
THE PEOPLE ON PAROLE LIVING IN
02:17:53.531 --> 02:17:54.566
LA OR SAN FRANCISCO ARE
02:17:54.633 --> 02:17:56.835
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS. RIGHT
02:17:56.901 --> 02:17:59.170
NOW, 70% OF THE PEOPLE ON OUR
02:17:59.237 --> 02:18:00.705
STREETS HAVE AT ONE POINT BEEN
02:18:00.772 --> 02:18:02.807
INCARCERATED. AND THE REASON IS
02:18:02.874 --> 02:18:04.275
BECAUSE WHEN YOU CONTACT THE
02:18:04.342 --> 02:18:05.644
CRIMINALS, THE CRIMINAL LEGAL
02:18:05.710 --> 02:18:07.579
SYSTEM THE LIKELIHOOD OF
02:18:07.646 --> 02:18:08.546
EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
02:18:08.613 --> 02:18:11.282
INCREASES. AND WHEN YOU HAVE
02:18:11.349 --> 02:18:12.684
BECOME AN HOUSED THE LIKELIHOOD
02:18:12.751 --> 02:18:14.552
OF CONTACTING THE CRIMINAL LEGAL
02:18:14.619 --> 02:18:17.222
SYSTEM INCREASES AS WELL, IT'S A
02:18:17.288 --> 02:18:19.290
SYMBIOTIC RELATIONSHIP IN L, A
02:18:19.357 --> 02:18:21.726
OVER A FOUR YEAR PERIOD, ONE IN
02:18:21.793 --> 02:18:22.360
FIVE ARRESTS WITH SOMEBODY WHO
02:18:22.427 --> 02:18:25.830
WAS EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS.
02:18:25.897 --> 02:18:27.499
AND SO THE LINKAGE BETWEEN OUR
02:18:27.565 --> 02:18:28.833
SYSTEMS OF MASS INCARCERATION
02:18:28.900 --> 02:18:30.635
AND HOUSING AND EQUITY OR
02:18:30.702 --> 02:18:32.804
EXACERBATING EACH OTHER. FOR
02:18:32.871 --> 02:18:34.873
THAT REASON, WE SHOULD BE
02:18:34.939 --> 02:18:36.374
FOCUSED ON CREATING PERMANENT
02:18:36.441 --> 02:18:37.308
HOUSING AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR
02:18:37.375 --> 02:18:40.445
PEOPLE EXITING PRISON. CURRENTLY
02:18:40.512 --> 02:18:42.247
CDCR FUNDS PROGRAMS THAT PLACE
02:18:42.313 --> 02:18:44.149
PEOPLE IN TEMPORARY HOUSING FOR
02:18:44.215 --> 02:18:47.519
6 TO 12 MONTHS. WHAT A B 18 16
02:18:47.585 --> 02:18:53.425
WILL DO IS, UH, WILL CREATE. RE
02:18:53.491 --> 02:18:54.492
ENTRY, HOUSING AND WORKFORCE
02:18:54.559 --> 02:18:56.528
DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM TO DO FOUR
02:18:56.594 --> 02:18:58.163
MAIN THINGS NUMBER ONE FOR
02:18:58.229 --> 02:18:59.464
PEOPLE EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
02:18:59.531 --> 02:19:01.433
WITH RECENT PRISON STAYS. IT
02:19:01.499 --> 02:19:02.767
WILL PROVIDE AN AFFORDABLE PLACE
02:19:02.834 --> 02:19:05.036
TO LIVE AND SUPPORTIVE HOUSING.
02:19:05.103 --> 02:19:06.438
NUMBER TO PROVIDE TENANTS WITH
02:19:06.504 --> 02:19:08.206
SERVICES TO HELP THEM STABILIZE
02:19:08.273 --> 02:19:09.274
AND ACCESS TREATMENT THEY MAY
02:19:09.340 --> 02:19:12.210
NEED. NUMBER THREE PROVIDE
02:19:12.277 --> 02:19:14.546
TENANTS WITH LIVABLE WAGE JOBS
02:19:14.612 --> 02:19:16.047
THROUGH WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT
02:19:16.114 --> 02:19:18.216
COMPONENT, ALLOWING PARTICIPANTS
02:19:18.283 --> 02:19:19.184
TO EVENTUALLY TAKE OVER THEIR
02:19:19.250 --> 02:19:20.452
OWN RENT. NUMBER FOUR CREATE A
02:19:20.518 --> 02:19:21.553
REPORT TO EVALUATE PROGRAM
02:19:21.619 --> 02:19:25.023
OUTCOMES. THIS IS NOT A NEW
02:19:25.090 --> 02:19:27.726
MODEL. THIS HAS BEEN TRIED OUT
02:19:27.792 --> 02:19:29.594
IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE
02:19:29.661 --> 02:19:31.563
COUNTRY WITH POSITIVE RESULTS. I
02:19:31.629 --> 02:19:33.531
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I VOTE.
02:19:33.598 --> 02:19:36.935
UM AND, UM, WITH WITH US TODAY
02:19:37.001 --> 02:19:38.336
TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THE
02:19:38.403 --> 02:19:40.538
BILL IS NICK QUARREL RESIDENT OF
02:19:40.605 --> 02:19:41.706
UNITED NETWORK. PLEASE COME
02:19:41.773 --> 02:19:47.812
FORWARD. THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME
02:19:47.879 --> 02:19:50.448
TODAY. UM, I AM IN DON'T EVEN
02:19:50.515 --> 02:19:54.285
KNOW HOW TO PUT IT. I'VE GREATLY
02:19:54.352 --> 02:19:58.056
SUPPORT THIS BILL. UM I AM A
02:19:58.123 --> 02:20:00.458
FELON. I WAS RELEASED FROM
02:20:00.525 --> 02:20:02.560
PRISON FOUR YEARS AGO IN THE
02:20:02.627 --> 02:20:05.296
HOMELESSNESS AND HAD I HAD THE
02:20:05.363 --> 02:20:06.431
SUPPORT THAT THIS BILL WOULD
02:20:06.498 --> 02:20:09.000
GIVE US I WOULDN'T HAVE HAD TO
02:20:09.067 --> 02:20:11.436
LIVE THAT LIFE AND THEY HAVE TO
02:20:11.503 --> 02:20:14.572
TRY TO STRUGGLE. AND BEING WITH
02:20:14.639 --> 02:20:16.474
THIS BILL. IF IT WAS PASSED, IT
02:20:16.541 --> 02:20:19.744
WOULD GIVE PEOPLE THE SUPPORT
02:20:19.811 --> 02:20:22.614
AND STABILITY THAT THEY NEED TO
02:20:22.680 --> 02:20:25.350
STOP HAVING TO GO THROUGH THAT
02:20:25.416 --> 02:20:28.319
REVOLVING DOOR THAT PRISON IS IF
02:20:28.386 --> 02:20:31.055
THIS HAD ALREADY BEEN IN PLACE
02:20:31.122 --> 02:20:31.923
FOR YEARS AGO, I WOULDN'T HAVE
02:20:31.990 --> 02:20:33.158
HAD TO BEEN HOMELESS FOR FOUR
02:20:33.224 --> 02:20:35.560
YEARS, I WOULD HAVE WENT INTO A
02:20:35.627 --> 02:20:36.561
PROGRAM THAT LASTED MORE THAN
02:20:36.628 --> 02:20:37.962
SIX MONTHS. THAT ACTUALLY HELPS
02:20:38.029 --> 02:20:41.032
YOU GET INTO HOUSING. VERSUS
02:20:41.099 --> 02:20:42.634
TRIES TO GIVE YOU A DRUG
02:20:42.700 --> 02:20:43.735
REHABILITATION AND SAYS THAT'S
02:20:43.802 --> 02:20:45.603
ALL WE CAN DO. THEY DON'T HELP
02:20:45.670 --> 02:20:48.540
YOU FIND HOUSING. THEY DON'T DO.
02:20:48.606 --> 02:20:50.241
NONE OF THAT. ALL THEY DO IS PUT
02:20:50.308 --> 02:20:52.777
YOU IN A SIX MONTH PROGRAM AND
02:20:52.844 --> 02:20:53.845
BOUNCE YOU FROM PROGRAM TO
02:20:53.912 --> 02:20:54.879
PROGRAM UNTIL YOU GET OFF
02:20:54.946 --> 02:20:56.114
PAROLE. AND THROUGH THAT, AT
02:20:56.181 --> 02:20:57.816
LEAST THAT REVOLVING DOOR OPEN
02:20:57.882 --> 02:21:00.552
TO CONTINUE TO GO IN AND OUT OF
02:21:00.618 --> 02:21:01.619
PRISON JUST BECAUSE PRISON IS
02:21:01.686 --> 02:21:03.154
EASIER. HAVING SOMEBODY TAKE
02:21:03.221 --> 02:21:06.925
CARE OF YOU IS EASIER. AND IF
02:21:06.991 --> 02:21:08.026
YOU'RE ON THE STREET, AND YOU'RE
02:21:08.092 --> 02:21:10.328
HOMELESS, YOU HAVE TO TAKE CARE
02:21:10.395 --> 02:21:11.563
OF YOURSELF AND YOU RUN INTO
02:21:11.629 --> 02:21:14.432
MORE ISSUES AND PROBLEMS WITH
02:21:14.499 --> 02:21:15.867
THE LAW AND EVERYBODY ELSE
02:21:15.934 --> 02:21:17.001
LIVING ON THE STREET VERSUS
02:21:17.068 --> 02:21:20.438
HAVING THAT SUPPORT. SO WITH
02:21:20.505 --> 02:21:22.640
THIS, YOU WOULD HAVE HOUSING AND
02:21:22.707 --> 02:21:23.675
YOU WOULD HAVE THAT STABILITY
02:21:23.741 --> 02:21:25.710
AND YOU WOULD HAVE THAT SUPPORT
02:21:25.777 --> 02:21:29.848
TO HELP YOU. TO RISE UP. AND
02:21:29.914 --> 02:21:35.286
MOVE AWAY FROM THAT. PRISON LIFE
02:21:35.353 --> 02:21:38.089
AND MAYBE BECOME A CITIZEN AND
02:21:38.156 --> 02:21:40.525
BE ABLE TO BE A PART OF YOUR
02:21:40.592 --> 02:21:42.360
COMMUNITY VERSUS BEING LOOKED AT
02:21:42.427 --> 02:21:43.695
OR LOOKED DOWN AT BECAUSE YOU'RE
02:21:43.761 --> 02:21:49.234
A FELON. SO I SUPPORT THIS BILL,
02:21:49.300 --> 02:21:51.569
BECAUSE IF THIS BILL HAD BEEN IN
02:21:51.636 --> 02:21:52.904
PLACE ALREADY, I WOULD HAVE
02:21:52.971 --> 02:21:54.672
NEVER HAD TO HAVE SEEN THE
02:21:54.739 --> 02:21:56.808
STREETS AND LIVE FOR FOUR YEARS
02:21:56.875 --> 02:22:00.612
STRUGGLING AND I HATE TO SAY IT
02:22:00.678 --> 02:22:03.681
THINKING ABOUT SUICIDE. BECAUSE
02:22:03.748 --> 02:22:05.483
THAT IS NO WAY FOR ANYBODY
02:22:05.550 --> 02:22:07.619
COMING OUT OF PRISON TO HAVE TO
02:22:07.685 --> 02:22:08.953
LIVE OR TO THINK THAT NOBODY
02:22:09.020 --> 02:22:10.154
CARES ABOUT THEM ENOUGH TO GIVE
02:22:10.221 --> 02:22:13.124
THEM THE SUPPORT. AND THE HELP
02:22:13.191 --> 02:22:15.026
THAT THEY NEED TO GET THEIR
02:22:15.093 --> 02:22:17.595
HOUSING OR TO EVEN GET A JOB OR
02:22:17.662 --> 02:22:18.663
EVEN THAT MENTAL HEALTH HELP
02:22:18.730 --> 02:22:20.131
THAT THEY MAY NEED BECAUSE THOSE
02:22:20.198 --> 02:22:21.199
OTHER PROGRAMS DON'T WORK
02:22:21.266 --> 02:22:23.468
ANYMORE. THEY'RE NOT ENOUGH. AND
02:22:23.534 --> 02:22:25.136
THIS WOULD BE THE MORE THAT WE
02:22:25.203 --> 02:22:28.706
NEED. SO I FIRMLY I SUPPORT A B
02:22:28.773 --> 02:22:31.910
18 16. THANK YOU. THANK YOU VERY
02:22:31.976 --> 02:22:34.045
MUCH. IS THERE ADDITIONAL
02:22:34.112 --> 02:22:35.880
SUPPORT? PUBLIC COMMENT HERE IN
02:22:35.947 --> 02:22:38.616
21 2100. PLEASE COME FORWARD AND
02:22:38.683 --> 02:22:40.952
STATE YOUR NAME, AFFILIATION AND
02:22:41.019 --> 02:22:42.453
YOUR SUPPORT. HI. THANKS SO
02:22:42.520 --> 02:22:43.988
MUCH. I'M MARI CASTALDI ON
02:22:44.055 --> 02:22:45.056
BEHALF OF HOUSING, CALIFORNIA
02:22:45.123 --> 02:22:45.857
VERY PROUD SPONSORS OF THIS
02:22:45.924 --> 02:22:49.827
BILL. THANK YOU. I'M CHRISTINE
02:22:49.894 --> 02:22:52.630
MORALE AND, UH, FOR PRESIDENT,
02:22:52.697 --> 02:22:53.598
UNITED NETWORK AND I FIRMLY
02:22:53.665 --> 02:22:57.802
SUPPORT THIS BILL. MARK STEPHENS
02:22:57.869 --> 02:22:58.903
OF THE CALIFORNIA PILOTING
02:22:58.970 --> 02:23:02.173
PARTNERSHIP AND SUPPORT GREAT
02:23:02.240 --> 02:23:03.207
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORT PUBLIC
02:23:03.274 --> 02:23:05.209
COMMENT IN ROOM 2100? SEEING
02:23:05.276 --> 02:23:10.181
THEM WILL GO TO THE PHONE LINES.
02:23:10.248 --> 02:23:11.549
THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT OF A
02:23:11.616 --> 02:23:13.685
B 18 16 YOU MAY PRESS ONE AND
02:23:13.751 --> 02:23:17.455
THEN ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND
02:23:17.522 --> 02:23:20.625
THEN ZERO FEAR IN SUPPORT. WE'VE
02:23:20.692 --> 02:23:22.627
GOT TO ALIGN TO 97. YOUR LINE IS
02:23:22.694 --> 02:23:25.863
OPEN. BIT OF MEAN. THIS IS
02:23:25.930 --> 02:23:26.965
REBECCA GONZALEZ WITH THE
02:23:27.031 --> 02:23:28.666
NATIONALISTS ASSOCIATION OF
02:23:28.733 --> 02:23:29.600
SOCIAL WORKERS, CALIFORNIA
02:23:29.667 --> 02:23:32.770
CHAPTER AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU
02:23:32.837 --> 02:23:33.972
NEXT TO GUIDELINE TO 83. YOUR
02:23:34.038 --> 02:23:38.076
LINE IS OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON.
02:23:38.142 --> 02:23:39.744
SHARON REPORT WITH THE
02:23:39.811 --> 02:23:41.045
CORPORATION FOR SUPPORTIVE
02:23:41.112 --> 02:23:42.814
HOUSING, PROUD SPONSOR OF THIS
02:23:42.880 --> 02:23:47.185
IMPORTANT, BILL. THANK YOU.
02:23:47.251 --> 02:23:48.419
THANK YOU. LINE TO 94. YOUR LINE
02:23:48.486 --> 02:23:52.357
IS OPEN. GOOD EVENING. SHARON
02:23:52.423 --> 02:23:53.791
MEMBERS. MADELINE COOPER FROM
02:23:53.858 --> 02:23:55.259
NIELSEN MARKS MORE ON BEHALF OF
02:23:55.326 --> 02:23:57.161
THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO AND
02:23:57.228 --> 02:23:59.764
SUPPORT THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:23:59.831 --> 02:24:04.302
I'M 300. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
02:24:04.369 --> 02:24:05.870
EVENING. THIS IS THE EXTENT OF
02:24:05.937 --> 02:24:07.238
ALL THE PATH PEOPLE ASSISTING
02:24:07.305 --> 02:24:09.707
THE HOMELESS AS ONE OF THE
02:24:09.774 --> 02:24:10.308
LARGEST SORT OF SURVIVORS IN
02:24:10.375 --> 02:24:11.542
CALIFORNIA AND, UM, PROVIDERS OF
02:24:11.609 --> 02:24:13.544
A REENTRY PROGRAM IN SAN DIEGO.
02:24:13.611 --> 02:24:14.545
WE ARE A PROUD SPONSOR OF THE
02:24:14.612 --> 02:24:17.448
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. LINE
02:24:17.515 --> 02:24:22.720
304. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. GOOD
02:24:22.787 --> 02:24:24.722
EVENING, AND ALVARADO ON BEHALF
02:24:24.789 --> 02:24:26.190
OF THE CALIFORNIA EDGE COALITION
02:24:26.257 --> 02:24:29.527
AND STRONG SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:24:29.594 --> 02:24:30.795
THANK YOU TO 93. YOUR LINE IS
02:24:30.862 --> 02:24:34.932
OPEN. GOOD AFTERNOON. MR CARE
02:24:34.999 --> 02:24:36.234
MEMBERS, MARTHA GUERRERO,
02:24:36.300 --> 02:24:37.268
REPRESENTING THE LOS ANGELES
02:24:37.335 --> 02:24:42.540
COUNTY SUPERVISORS AND SUPPORT.
02:24:42.607 --> 02:24:43.808
THANK YOU LINED TO 29. YOUR LINE
02:24:43.875 --> 02:24:47.445
IS OPEN. GOOD EVENING CHAIR AND
02:24:47.512 --> 02:24:50.248
MEMBERS OF THE WESTERN CENTER ON
02:24:50.314 --> 02:24:51.582
LAW AND POVERTY, PODCAST,
02:24:51.649 --> 02:24:54.218
SPONSORS AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:24:54.285 --> 02:24:55.386
THANK YOU. LINE 301. YOUR LINE
02:24:55.453 --> 02:24:59.791
IS OPEN. TIME HAS BEEN PROCESSED
02:24:59.857 --> 02:25:00.825
WITH RESIDENTS. UNITED NETWORK
02:25:00.892 --> 02:25:05.663
SINCLAIR SUPPORT. THANK YOU
02:25:05.730 --> 02:25:11.135
LYING TO 24. YOUR LINE IS OPEN.
02:25:11.202 --> 02:25:13.638
THIS IS DAMIAN SCOTT WITH EAST
02:25:13.704 --> 02:25:14.505
BAY HOUSING ORGANIZATIONS AND
02:25:14.572 --> 02:25:15.940
THE RESIDENTS UNITED NETWORK
02:25:16.007 --> 02:25:18.543
CALLING AND STRONG SUPPORT OF 18
02:25:18.609 --> 02:25:21.779
16. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:25:21.846 --> 02:25:24.715
TO GO TO LINE 30 TO YOUR LINE IS
02:25:24.782 --> 02:25:28.152
OPEN. HI THERE. MONICA CALLING
02:25:28.219 --> 02:25:29.320
WITH UNITED WAY OF GREATER LOS
02:25:29.387 --> 02:25:33.257
ANGELES AND STRONG SUPPORT.
02:25:33.324 --> 02:25:36.594
THANK YOU LINE TO 48 YEAR LINE
02:25:36.661 --> 02:25:43.201
IS OPEN. PLEASE GO AHEAD. LIKE 2
02:25:43.267 --> 02:25:52.643
48 YEAR LINE IS OPEN. NEXT WE'LL
02:25:52.710 --> 02:25:53.911
GO TO THE LINE OF TWO. OH, NINE.
02:25:53.978 --> 02:25:55.947
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
02:25:56.013 --> 02:25:57.582
AHEAD AND AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS
02:25:57.648 --> 02:25:59.317
MRS CECILIA CUNNINGHAM. I'M
02:25:59.383 --> 02:26:02.620
CALLING BEHALF OF RESIDENCE.
02:26:02.687 --> 02:26:05.156
UNITED NETWORK AND THE HOUSING
02:26:05.223 --> 02:26:07.058
ORGANIZATION WILL CERTAINLY
02:26:07.125 --> 02:26:13.464
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. A B 1816.
02:26:13.531 --> 02:26:14.999
THANK YOU. THE NEXT WE GO TO
02:26:15.066 --> 02:26:19.804
LINE 2 70. YOUR LINE IS OPEN. HI
02:26:19.871 --> 02:26:21.939
MY NAME IS FRANCINE BLOODY FROM
02:26:22.006 --> 02:26:24.308
THE RESIDENTS AND THE NETWORK
02:26:24.375 --> 02:26:26.043
STRONGLY SUPPORT 80 18 CHICKEN.
02:26:26.110 --> 02:26:31.349
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. AND NEXT
02:26:31.415 --> 02:26:33.351
WE'LL GO TO LINE 2 99. YOUR LINE
02:26:33.417 --> 02:26:38.322
IS OPEN. HI ROBERT IS VIA GÓMEZ
02:26:38.389 --> 02:26:39.690
. PRESIDENTS UNITED NETWORK IN
02:26:39.757 --> 02:26:41.759
SUPPORT AND PLEASE FUND US SO
02:26:41.826 --> 02:26:45.696
OFTEN. THANK YOU. AND WE HAVE NO
02:26:45.763 --> 02:26:47.165
FURTHER SUPPORTING QUÊ AT THIS
02:26:47.231 --> 02:26:48.766
TIME, MR CHAIR. GREAT. THANK YOU
02:26:48.833 --> 02:26:50.635
WILL NOW GO TO OPPOSITION. IS
02:26:50.701 --> 02:26:51.769
THERE ANY OPPOSITION HERE IN THE
02:26:51.836 --> 02:26:53.137
ROOM? SEEING THAT WE'LL GO TO
02:26:53.204 --> 02:26:57.141
THE PHONE LINES. THANK YOU. IF
02:26:57.208 --> 02:26:59.644
YOU'RE NOT POSITION OF A B 18 16
02:26:59.710 --> 02:27:00.811
YOU MAKE PRESS ONE AND THEN
02:27:00.878 --> 02:27:04.382
ZERO. AGAIN THAT IS ONE AND THEN
02:27:04.448 --> 02:27:09.086
ZERO HERE IN OPPOSITION. AND WE
02:27:09.153 --> 02:27:11.722
HAVE NO OPPOSITION. QUÊ GREAT.
02:27:11.789 --> 02:27:13.157
WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO THE
02:27:13.224 --> 02:27:15.493
COMMITTEE. ANY QUESTIONS OR
02:27:15.560 --> 02:27:16.561
COMMENTS? SENATOR WIECKOWSKI HAD
02:27:16.627 --> 02:27:17.762
A QUESTION BECAUSE THE STAFF
02:27:17.828 --> 02:27:22.033
REPORT. POINTS OUT THAT PAGE
02:27:22.099 --> 02:27:24.068
FIVE THAT THIS THIS BILL CREATES
02:27:24.135 --> 02:27:25.236
A NEW PROGRAM, BUT IT DOESN'T
02:27:25.303 --> 02:27:27.471
SPECIFICALLY FUND THE PROGRAM.
02:27:27.538 --> 02:27:29.540
BUT IT SEEMS TO ME THAT SOME OF
02:27:29.607 --> 02:27:32.643
THE YOU KNOW WE'VE HAD TWO BILLS
02:27:32.710 --> 02:27:34.779
ON A D U. S. WE HAD A BILL ON
02:27:34.845 --> 02:27:37.114
FARM WORKERS. WE HAVE LOTS OF
02:27:37.181 --> 02:27:39.317
BILLS THAT ARE LOOKING TO BUY
02:27:39.383 --> 02:27:40.518
ADVOCATES THAT WANT TO BUILD
02:27:40.585 --> 02:27:43.221
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND IS IT?
02:27:43.287 --> 02:27:44.689
THERE'S NO, THEY'RE NOT
02:27:44.755 --> 02:27:46.824
PRECLUDED FROM USING SOME OF THE
02:27:46.891 --> 02:27:49.460
MONEY THAT WE SPECIFICALLY CALL
02:27:49.527 --> 02:27:51.696
OUT OR. LET'S SAY FARMWORKER
02:27:51.762 --> 02:27:54.031
HOUSING THAT WOULD THAT WOULD
02:27:54.098 --> 02:27:55.099
HOUSE FORMERLY INCARCERATED
02:27:55.166 --> 02:28:00.771
PEOPLE OR I GUESS. COOPERATE
02:28:00.838 --> 02:28:03.140
WITH WITH THEM IN THE C. D. C
02:28:03.207 --> 02:28:07.878
ARE SORT OF AS A BRIDGE UNTIL
02:28:07.945 --> 02:28:08.946
THERE'S ACTUAL SPECIFIC FUNDING.
02:28:09.013 --> 02:28:15.620
BÀN. MR ARTHUR IN CHIEF. AH I
02:28:15.686 --> 02:28:17.722
WOULD HAVE TO GET BACK TO YOU ON
02:28:17.788 --> 02:28:19.857
THAT SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. JUST
02:28:19.924 --> 02:28:24.428
SORT OF PLANTING STUFF HAS. JUST
02:28:24.495 --> 02:28:25.263
BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE FUNDING
02:28:25.329 --> 02:28:26.831
FOR THIS PROGRAM, BUT THERE'S I
02:28:26.897 --> 02:28:28.332
DON'T SEE ANYTHING THAT I READ
02:28:28.399 --> 02:28:29.834
THAT WOULD PRECLUDE SOME OF
02:28:29.900 --> 02:28:32.003
THESE OTHER FUNDING SOURCES TO
02:28:32.069 --> 02:28:33.771
USE THEM TO HOUSE FORMERLY
02:28:33.838 --> 02:28:36.807
INCARCERATED PEOPLE. YOU KNOW,
02:28:36.874 --> 02:28:38.109
THEY'RE THEY'RE DEVELOPING AN AD
02:28:38.175 --> 02:28:40.044
PROGRAM WITH 50 MILLION. THERE'S
02:28:40.111 --> 02:28:41.545
SOMEBODY COMES IN AND SAYS, I'M
02:28:41.612 --> 02:28:43.047
WILLING WITH SOME FINANCIAL
02:28:43.114 --> 02:28:45.816
ASSISTANCE TO USE SOME OF THESE
02:28:45.883 --> 02:28:46.350
FUNDS WITH THE WITH THE
02:28:46.417 --> 02:28:47.752
AGREEMENT TO DO THAT. I'VE GOT
02:28:47.818 --> 02:28:51.188
SOME FARM. WORKING OUR FARMER
02:28:51.255 --> 02:28:53.424
WORKER HOUSING AND WE HAVE
02:28:53.491 --> 02:28:55.059
SEASONAL SHIFTS, AND WE'LL PUT
02:28:55.126 --> 02:28:57.228
SOME PEOPLE IN THE HOUSE. THEM.
02:28:57.295 --> 02:28:59.163
UM, JUST JUST SAID I THOUGHT
02:28:59.230 --> 02:29:07.471
OKAY? OTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS. OKAY SEEING SEEING NONE, AND
02:29:07.538 --> 02:29:09.607
WE KNOW IF SENATOR COURTESY IS
02:29:09.674 --> 02:29:11.542
CLOSE. OKAY UM I RESPECTFULLY
02:29:11.609 --> 02:29:15.046
ASK FOR A VOTE. OKAY MOTION BY
02:29:15.112 --> 02:29:16.113
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI AND THAT
02:29:16.180 --> 02:29:22.787
MOTION. IS EXCUSE ME. YEAH,
02:29:22.853 --> 02:29:30.928
SEVEN. OKAY THAT MOTION IS DUE
02:29:30.995 --> 02:29:32.163
PAST BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
02:29:32.229 --> 02:29:34.198
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
02:29:34.265 --> 02:29:36.434
WE WILL CALL THE ROLL. BUT DO WE
02:29:36.500 --> 02:29:37.868
HAVE A MOTION SENATOR? YES BY
02:29:37.935 --> 02:29:39.437
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. THANK YOU.
02:29:39.503 --> 02:29:40.237
SARAH. WHAT? KELSEY YOU MOVED
02:29:40.304 --> 02:29:42.506
THE BILL. RIGHT OKAY. SENATOR.
02:29:42.573 --> 02:29:45.676
WIENER WINNER BEATS I COPY YOUR
02:29:45.743 --> 02:29:49.613
ORTEZ MCGUIRE. MAGUIRE SHOW BUG
02:29:49.680 --> 02:29:53.918
BUG. I SKINNER. SKINNER I
02:29:53.984 --> 02:29:57.355
HAMBURG, HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI
02:29:57.421 --> 02:30:02.693
WIECKOWSKI I CALL. SENATOR
02:30:02.760 --> 02:30:04.628
CORTESI THAT WAS ITEM NUMBER
02:30:04.695 --> 02:30:07.331
SEVEN BY SOME REMEMBER BRIAN. NO
02:30:07.398 --> 02:30:15.172
OPPOSITION. CORTESI. CORTEZ EI.
02:30:15.239 --> 02:30:17.408
90 0. OKAY THE VOTE IS 9 TO 0.
02:30:17.475 --> 02:30:22.446
THAT BILL IS OUT UNANIMOUSLY.
02:30:22.513 --> 02:30:23.547
OKAY COLLEAGUES, WE'RE ALL HERE.
02:30:23.614 --> 02:30:27.852
BEAUTIFUL THING. UM WE WILL
02:30:27.918 --> 02:30:30.254
START AT THE TOP FOR SOME OF
02:30:30.321 --> 02:30:31.422
THESE. THEY WERE PRESENTED
02:30:31.489 --> 02:30:32.790
BEFORE WE HAD A QUORUM. SO THERE
02:30:32.857 --> 02:30:34.658
IS NO MOTION, SO LET'S GO ONE BY
02:30:34.725 --> 02:30:36.060
ONE. WE'LL START WITH ITEM
02:30:36.127 --> 02:30:38.562
NUMBER ONE A B 6 82 BY
02:30:38.629 --> 02:30:40.364
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HOLD ON A
02:30:40.431 --> 02:30:44.668
SECOND. I JUST BY SELLING MEMBER
02:30:44.735 --> 02:30:46.470
BLOOM. UH AND THAT IS A MOTION
02:30:46.537 --> 02:30:50.141
BY SENATOR WHITE. WIECKOWSKI DO
02:30:50.207 --> 02:30:51.409
PASS BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
02:30:51.475 --> 02:30:53.844
THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE. AND
02:30:53.911 --> 02:30:55.813
FINANCE. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:30:55.880 --> 02:31:02.853
WIENER. RIGHT DEBATES. COPY URL
02:31:02.920 --> 02:31:04.755
. ORTEZ E CORTESI MCGUIRE.
02:31:04.822 --> 02:31:10.494
MCGUIRE BIOKO BUG. SKINNER. I AM
02:31:10.561 --> 02:31:14.064
BERG WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I
02:31:14.131 --> 02:31:17.067
THAT'S 7 TO 0. OKAY 7 TO 0. THAT
02:31:17.134 --> 02:31:20.304
BILL IS OUT. WELL NEXT GO TO
02:31:20.371 --> 02:31:23.974
ITEM NUMBER TWO A B SHOOTS 339
02:31:24.041 --> 02:31:27.178
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER. BLOOM MOVED
02:31:27.244 --> 02:31:33.551
THE BILL TO 39. 23392339 RIGHT.
02:31:33.617 --> 02:31:36.554
SORRY TO 33933 92 339
02:31:36.620 --> 02:31:39.757
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S BLOOM. SENATOR
02:31:39.824 --> 02:31:41.792
WIECKOWSKI MOVES AND THE MOTION
02:31:41.859 --> 02:31:44.061
IS PASSED AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST
02:31:44.128 --> 02:31:45.129
WE REFER THE COMMITTEE ON
02:31:45.196 --> 02:31:49.333
APPROPRIATIONS. UH CAN YOU
02:31:49.400 --> 02:31:52.336
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL WIENER?
02:31:52.403 --> 02:31:54.038
BATES BATES? NO CABALLERO
02:31:54.104 --> 02:31:57.675
CORTESI. ORTEZ E. MCGUIRE.
02:31:57.741 --> 02:32:03.814
MCGUIRE KOBACH. HI I SKINNER
02:32:03.881 --> 02:32:07.818
SKINNER. I HAMBURG WIECKOWSKI
02:32:07.885 --> 02:32:09.887
WIECKOWSKI I THAT'S 8 TO 1. THAT
02:32:09.954 --> 02:32:14.692
BILL IS OUT. WE WILL NEXT GO TO
02:32:14.758 --> 02:32:17.461
ITEM NUMBER 3 89 16 BY SOME
02:32:17.528 --> 02:32:19.597
MEMBER OF VEHICLE DUA OR IS THAT
02:32:19.663 --> 02:32:21.565
I'M SORRY. THAT'S BYE BYE. I'M
02:32:21.632 --> 02:32:24.201
SORRY BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SALIS.
02:32:24.268 --> 02:32:28.038
AS AMENDED. I MOVED THE BILL.
02:32:28.105 --> 02:32:31.175
OKAY SO THAT MOTION BY SENATOR
02:32:31.242 --> 02:32:33.444
WIECKOWSKI IS DO PASS AS AMENDED
02:32:33.511 --> 02:32:35.012
, BUT FIRST DEMAND AND WE REFER
02:32:35.079 --> 02:32:36.780
TO THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE
02:32:36.847 --> 02:32:37.781
AND FINANCE. PLEASE CALL THE
02:32:37.848 --> 02:32:44.021
ROLL. WIENER BATES BATES, NO
02:32:44.088 --> 02:32:45.890
COPYRIGHT YOUR EYE. CORTEZ
02:32:45.956 --> 02:32:52.663
CORTEZ E. MCGUIRE. A JOKE BOOK.
02:32:52.730 --> 02:32:56.867
SKINNER SKINNER I HAMBURG BY
02:32:56.934 --> 02:32:58.002
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I THAT'S 6
02:32:58.068 --> 02:33:02.907
pTO 1. OKAY 6 TO 1. THAT BILL IS
02:33:02.973 --> 02:33:07.811
OUT. WHEN IT'S GOOD ITEM NUMBER
02:33:07.878 --> 02:33:08.913
FIVE A B 7 19 BY
02:33:08.979 --> 02:33:11.815
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD. KIND OF
02:33:11.882 --> 02:33:14.818
EMOTION, PLEASE SO MOVED. MOTION
02:33:14.885 --> 02:33:16.420
BY SENATOR WIECKOWSKI DO PASS
02:33:16.487 --> 02:33:18.355
BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:33:18.422 --> 02:33:19.924
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
02:33:19.990 --> 02:33:23.327
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. WIENER
02:33:23.394 --> 02:33:25.262
BATES CABALLERO CABALLERO LIKE
02:33:25.329 --> 02:33:29.767
ORTEZ. ORTEZ MCGUIRE MCGUIRE, I
02:33:29.833 --> 02:33:37.007
COBURG. ITEM 55. NO. OH, KOBACH,
02:33:37.074 --> 02:33:44.748
NO SKINNER. SKINNER I HAMBURG. I
02:33:44.815 --> 02:33:46.317
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I THAT'S 8
02:33:46.383 --> 02:33:50.821
TO 1. WORRY ABOUT IS IT'S ONE
02:33:50.888 --> 02:33:53.657
THAT BILL IS OUT WILL NOW GO TO
02:33:53.724 --> 02:34:05.302
HERE. WITH. FOR ONCE AGAIN. WE.
02:34:05.369 --> 02:34:07.571
SO I SKIPPED IT. I SKIPPED THE
02:34:07.638 --> 02:34:10.207
BILL. MY APOLOGIES, OKAY. SHE
02:34:10.274 --> 02:34:15.813
WAS VERY DIFFERENT. OKAY LET'S
02:34:15.879 --> 02:34:17.548
LET'S RESET. LET'S RESCIND THE
02:34:17.615 --> 02:34:19.516
WILL RESEND IT WITHOUT OBJECT.
02:34:19.583 --> 02:34:20.918
IS THERE A MOTION TO RESEND
02:34:20.985 --> 02:34:22.786
SENTENCE? OKAY MOTION AND
02:34:22.853 --> 02:34:23.921
WITHOUT OBJECTION, RESCINDING
02:34:23.988 --> 02:34:25.956
THE VOTE AN ITEM. 5 87 19 MY
02:34:26.023 --> 02:34:27.091
APOLOGIES. I SKIPPED OVER A BILL
02:34:27.157 --> 02:34:30.127
AND CAUSE CONFUSION. SO WE'RE
02:34:30.194 --> 02:34:32.096
VOTING NOW ON ITEM NUMBER 5 87
02:34:32.162 --> 02:34:42.406
19 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD. THE. 17 1917 19 VOTING ON THE ITEM
02:34:42.473 --> 02:34:43.507
FIVE A. B 17 19 BY
02:34:43.574 --> 02:34:45.409
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WARD. WE HAVE A
02:34:45.476 --> 02:34:49.747
MOTION BY SEN. ME? NO, I'M HOLD
02:34:49.813 --> 02:34:53.150
ON A SECOND. IT WAS INTERESTING.
02:34:53.217 --> 02:34:59.790
NO. NOTHING TO CONCERN. I'LL
02:34:59.857 --> 02:35:01.692
TELL YOU AFTERWARDS. OKAY A
02:35:01.759 --> 02:35:05.262
LITTLE MISTAKE HERE. ITEM NUMBER
02:35:05.329 --> 02:35:06.864
FIVE A B 17 19 BY
02:35:06.930 --> 02:35:07.931
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S AWARD. WE HAVE
02:35:07.998 --> 02:35:09.099
A MOTION BY SENATOR WYCHE
02:35:09.166 --> 02:35:12.569
KOWSKI. AND THAT IS DO PASSPORT
02:35:12.636 --> 02:35:14.338
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:35:14.405 --> 02:35:15.673
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS.
02:35:15.739 --> 02:35:19.009
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. WIENER
02:35:19.076 --> 02:35:22.046
BATES BATES? NO CABALLERO
02:35:22.112 --> 02:35:24.248
CABALLERO I CORTEZ CORTEZ E
02:35:24.314 --> 02:35:26.216
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I KOBACH A
02:35:26.283 --> 02:35:30.721
CHILD, BUGNO SKINNER. SKINNER I
02:35:30.788 --> 02:35:33.691
HAMBURG, HAMBURG. I WIECKOWSKI
02:35:33.757 --> 02:35:35.793
WIECKOWSKI I THAT IS 7 TO 2.
02:35:35.859 --> 02:35:38.195
OKAY THAT BILL IS OUT WHEN I GO
02:35:38.262 --> 02:35:39.430
BACK TO AN M FOUR, AND I'M
02:35:39.496 --> 02:35:41.231
SORRY, SENATOR SKINNER. OKAY WE
02:35:41.298 --> 02:35:43.834
WERE CONFUSED ABOUT YES. OKAY
02:35:43.901 --> 02:35:45.035
HOPEFULLY WE'RE ALL I APOLOGIZE
02:35:45.102 --> 02:35:47.905
FOR THE CONFUSION. NEVER GOING
02:35:47.971 --> 02:35:50.441
BACK TO ITEM FOR A B 16 54 BY
02:35:50.507 --> 02:35:55.512
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RIVAS. UM. WELL
02:35:55.579 --> 02:36:00.050
WE HAVE A MOTION. YEAH. OKAY
02:36:00.117 --> 02:36:01.218
MOTION BY SENATOR CAVALLERO IS
02:36:01.285 --> 02:36:03.620
GIVING SENDER WIECKOWSKI BREAK.
02:36:03.687 --> 02:36:05.856
UM AND THAT IS DO PASS, BUT
02:36:05.923 --> 02:36:06.490
FIRST BE REFERRED THE COMMITTEE
02:36:06.557 --> 02:36:07.157
ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE.
02:36:07.224 --> 02:36:12.162
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. WIENER AYE
02:36:12.229 --> 02:36:14.131
. BATES BATES, CABALLERO
02:36:14.198 --> 02:36:20.337
CABALLERO CORTESI. ITEM FOUR.
02:36:20.404 --> 02:36:23.640
FARMWORKER HOUSING. CORTESI
02:36:23.707 --> 02:36:30.447
MCGUIRE. HI MCGUIRE. I OKO BUG I
02:36:30.514 --> 02:36:34.017
SKINNER, HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI
02:36:34.084 --> 02:36:38.555
WIECKOWSKI I THAT'S 9 TO 0. OKAY
02:36:38.622 --> 02:36:40.724
THAT BILL IS OUT THERE. NOW
02:36:40.791 --> 02:36:42.226
WE'RE GONNA GET BACK ON TRACK.
02:36:42.292 --> 02:36:45.195
UM I DON'T NUMBER SIX IS ON CALL
02:36:45.262 --> 02:36:46.196
, SO COULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE
02:36:46.263 --> 02:36:49.900
OPPOSITE MEMBERS THAT A B 17 38.
02:36:49.967 --> 02:36:56.206
YES. WE DID THAT I JUST WENT OUT
02:36:56.273 --> 02:36:59.576
OF ORDER WAS FORMED FIVE SORRY.
02:36:59.643 --> 02:37:00.744
THAT'S NOT YOUR FAULT, SENATOR.
02:37:00.811 --> 02:37:04.748
IT'S MY FAULT. WITH TOUCH. JUST
02:37:04.815 --> 02:37:10.387
TESTING YOU. YEAH. ALL RIGHT.
02:37:10.454 --> 02:37:12.890
THIS IS A B 17 38. THE MOTION IS
02:37:12.956 --> 02:37:14.124
DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE REFERRED
02:37:14.191 --> 02:37:15.125
TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:37:15.192 --> 02:37:16.093
APPROPRIATIONS WITH THE CHAIR
02:37:16.160 --> 02:37:18.629
VOTING, AYE. SPEEDS. CABALLERO
02:37:18.695 --> 02:37:23.700
CABALLERO CORTESI. MCGUIRE
02:37:23.767 --> 02:37:27.304
MCGUIRE I OH, KOBACH. I'M SORRY
02:37:27.371 --> 02:37:28.472
. YOU ALREADY VOTED. I'M SORRY,
02:37:28.539 --> 02:37:32.576
SKINNER. BY SKINNER I HAMBURG
02:37:32.643 --> 02:37:37.414
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. THAT'S 7
02:37:37.481 --> 02:37:39.683
TO 0. OKAY THAT BILL AND THAT
02:37:39.750 --> 02:37:41.451
WAS WIECKOWSKI I THAT'S CORRECT.
02:37:41.518 --> 02:37:46.123
OK SO THAT BILL IS OUT. UM FOR
02:37:46.190 --> 02:37:48.525
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN. WE ALREADY
02:37:48.592 --> 02:37:50.661
VOTED. THAT BILL HAS ALREADY OUT
02:37:50.727 --> 02:37:54.798
TO ITEM NUMBER. I ATE A B 2000
02:37:54.865 --> 02:37:56.900
AND TWO BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER VIA
02:37:56.967 --> 02:37:58.836
PADOA WILL NEED A MOTION MOVE AS
02:37:58.902 --> 02:38:01.338
AMENDED. OKAY, AND THAT'S
02:38:01.405 --> 02:38:02.873
EMOTION BY SENATOR WIECKOWSKI DO
02:38:02.940 --> 02:38:04.875
PASS AS AMENDED, BUT FIRST
02:38:04.942 --> 02:38:06.043
PEOPLE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
02:38:06.109 --> 02:38:08.145
ON APPROPRIATIONS CALLED THE
02:38:08.212 --> 02:38:09.813
ROLL, PLEASE. WIENER. AYE,
02:38:09.880 --> 02:38:14.451
BATES. BEING A HERO. I CORTESI
02:38:14.518 --> 02:38:18.789
CORTESI MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE BIOKO
02:38:18.856 --> 02:38:24.294
BUG I. SKINNER SKINNER, HAMBURG
02:38:24.361 --> 02:38:26.496
, WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I 8 TO 0
02:38:26.563 --> 02:38:30.434
ABOUT BILL IS OUT WILL NOW DO
02:38:30.500 --> 02:38:32.436
THE CONSENT CALENDAR. THERE ARE
02:38:32.502 --> 02:38:33.337
TWO ITEMS ON THE CONSENT
02:38:33.403 --> 02:38:37.908
CALENDAR ITEM NINE A B 2075 M 16
02:38:37.975 --> 02:38:42.179
80 24 83. I COULD HAVE EMOTION
02:38:42.246 --> 02:38:43.981
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR BY
02:38:44.047 --> 02:38:45.115
SENATOR SKINNER. PLEASE CALL THE
02:38:45.182 --> 02:38:51.021
ROLL. WIENER WIENER? AYE, BATES.
02:38:51.088 --> 02:38:52.689
BATES I CABALLERO, COVER YOUR
02:38:52.756 --> 02:38:56.360
EYE CORTESI. ORTEZ MCGUIRE.
02:38:56.426 --> 02:39:01.899
MCGUIRE I JOBURG I SKINNER
02:39:01.965 --> 02:39:04.101
HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI I
02:39:04.167 --> 02:39:07.671
THAT'S 9 TO 0. OKAY THAT BUILT
02:39:07.738 --> 02:39:09.773
THE CONSENT CALENDAR IS APPROVED
02:39:09.840 --> 02:39:11.775
, WILL NOW GO TO ITEM NUMBER 10
02:39:11.842 --> 02:39:14.177
, WHICH IS ON CALL. LET'S PLEASE
02:39:14.244 --> 02:39:18.849
CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS. THE
02:39:18.916 --> 02:39:20.450
MOTIONS DO PASS BUT FIRST BE
02:39:20.517 --> 02:39:22.085
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:39:22.152 --> 02:39:23.120
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WITH THE
02:39:23.186 --> 02:39:24.154
CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. BOTH
02:39:24.221 --> 02:39:26.156
VOTING I CABALLERO, HOW ARE YOUR
02:39:26.223 --> 02:39:27.758
ORTEZ? MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I.
02:39:27.824 --> 02:39:34.064
SKINNER. SKINNER HAMBURG I,
02:39:34.131 --> 02:39:37.935
THAT'S 8 TO 0. THAT BILL IS OUT
02:39:38.001 --> 02:39:39.770
. WE'LL GO TO ANIMAL 11, PLEASE
02:39:39.836 --> 02:39:40.938
CALL THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS IS A B
02:39:41.004 --> 02:39:44.775
21 86. THE MOTION IS PASSED, BUT
02:39:44.841 --> 02:39:46.376
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:39:46.443 --> 02:39:46.944
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
02:39:47.010 --> 02:39:48.145
FINANCE WITH THE CHAIR AND VICE
02:39:48.211 --> 02:39:49.179
CHAIR. VOTING. I CABALLERO. COPY
02:39:49.246 --> 02:39:52.316
YOUR EYE CORTESI. CORTESI
02:39:52.382 --> 02:39:56.053
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I. SKINNER
02:39:56.119 --> 02:39:59.089
SKINNER I HAMBURG I THAT'S 9 TO
02:39:59.156 --> 02:40:02.526
0. THAT BILL IS OUT WHEN MEXICO
02:40:02.592 --> 02:40:05.395
TO ITEM NUMBER 12 TO 668 BY
02:40:05.462 --> 02:40:06.330
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S GRAYSON, PLEASE
02:40:06.396 --> 02:40:08.665
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. THE
02:40:08.732 --> 02:40:10.267
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST BE
02:40:10.334 --> 02:40:11.835
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:40:11.902 --> 02:40:12.903
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WITH THE
02:40:12.970 --> 02:40:15.605
CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. VOTING. I
02:40:15.672 --> 02:40:16.606
COPY EURO. COVER YOUR EYE
02:40:16.673 --> 02:40:17.541
CORTESI. FOR TESSIE MCGUIRE.
02:40:17.607 --> 02:40:19.843
MCGUIRE I. SKINNER SKINNER I
02:40:19.910 --> 02:40:26.550
HAMBURG. I THAT'S 9 TO 0 BILL IS
02:40:26.616 --> 02:40:28.585
OUT WILL NOW GO TO ITEM NUMBER
02:40:28.652 --> 02:40:31.688
13 A B. 2217 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:40:31.755 --> 02:40:32.956
REYES. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
02:40:33.023 --> 02:40:36.293
MEMBERS. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS.
02:40:36.360 --> 02:40:37.794
BUT FIRST WE RE REFERRED TO THE
02:40:37.861 --> 02:40:39.463
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WITH
02:40:39.529 --> 02:40:40.931
THE CHAIR AND VICE CHAIR. VOTING
02:40:40.998 --> 02:40:41.732
I CABALLERO CABALLERO, I CORTEZ
02:40:41.798 --> 02:40:46.803
CORTEZ MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE SKINNER.
02:40:46.870 --> 02:40:49.473
SKINNER I HAMBURG, HAMBURG. I 9
02:40:49.539 --> 02:40:53.310
TO 0 BILL IS OUT. WELL NOW GOOD.
02:40:53.377 --> 02:40:55.379
ADAM 14 82 TO 21. BY
02:40:55.445 --> 02:40:56.313
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK. SILVA IS
02:40:56.380 --> 02:41:00.450
CALLED THE OPPOSITE MEMBERS.
02:41:00.517 --> 02:41:01.918
THIS IS THE MOTION IS DUE PAST
02:41:01.985 --> 02:41:03.086
BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:41:03.153 --> 02:41:04.187
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
02:41:04.254 --> 02:41:05.889
FINANCE WITH THE CHAIR VOTING I
02:41:05.956 --> 02:41:11.695
BATES 2221 QUIRK-SILVA. COPY
02:41:11.762 --> 02:41:16.166
YOUR OWN. AYE. CORTEZ, CORTEZ
02:41:16.233 --> 02:41:21.938
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE I. SKINNER.
02:41:22.005 --> 02:41:23.874
SKINNER I HAMBURG, I SO THAT'S 8
02:41:23.940 --> 02:41:29.546
TO 0. OKAY, THE BILL IS OUT. NO
02:41:29.613 --> 02:41:33.016
ITEM. 15 82334 BY SOME REMEMBER
02:41:33.083 --> 02:41:33.950
WICKS, I WILL NEED A MOTION ON
02:41:34.017 --> 02:41:37.354
THAT BILL. DOUBLE MOVED BY
02:41:37.421 --> 02:41:38.922
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI AND THE
02:41:38.989 --> 02:41:41.258
MOTION IS PASSED. BUT FIRST WE
02:41:41.324 --> 02:41:43.393
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:41:43.460 --> 02:41:45.829
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE. PLEASE
02:41:45.896 --> 02:41:49.699
CALL THE ROLL. WIENER BATES.
02:41:49.766 --> 02:41:50.267
BATES? NO CABALLERO, YOU'RE
02:41:50.333 --> 02:41:54.337
BUSY. CORTESI MCGUIRE MCGUIRE, I
02:41:54.404 --> 02:42:00.710
OH, KOBACH. SKINNER SKINNER I
02:42:00.777 --> 02:42:03.814
HAMBURG, HAMBURG, WIECKOWSKI.
02:42:03.880 --> 02:42:06.416
WIECKOWSKI THAT'S 7 TO 1. BILL
02:42:06.483 --> 02:42:14.691
IS OUT. UH, WELL, WHAT IS THAT?
02:42:14.758 --> 02:42:19.696
FOUR WEEKS. YEAH, YOU STAY. I
02:42:19.763 --> 02:42:21.264
THINK WE STAYED OFF IF YOU WANT
02:42:21.331 --> 02:42:24.167
TO RESEND AND REVOLT SHE CAN ADD
02:42:24.234 --> 02:42:26.536
ON. IF SHE HASN'T VOTED, SHE CAN
02:42:26.603 --> 02:42:28.672
ADD ON. OKAY. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
02:42:28.738 --> 02:42:33.043
THIS IS ITEM 15. OH, KOBACH.
02:42:33.110 --> 02:42:35.912
YEAH I HAD A NICE SORRY YOU MUST
02:42:35.979 --> 02:42:36.913
HAVE NOT REGISTERED. OKAY ON
02:42:36.980 --> 02:42:39.349
THAT BOOK. I SO YOU WANTED TO.
02:42:39.416 --> 02:42:41.718
YEAH WORKS. THAT'S AN EYE. OKAY
02:42:41.785 --> 02:42:43.820
ALRIGHT. SO 8 TO 1 TO ONE. OKAY?
02:42:43.887 --> 02:42:47.324
THAT BILL IS OUT. UM UM FINALLY
02:42:47.390 --> 02:42:49.726
, ITEM 17 18 28 73 BY
02:42:49.793 --> 02:42:52.963
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JOHN SAWYER WE
02:42:53.029 --> 02:42:54.598
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:42:54.664 --> 02:42:56.099
YES THE MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT
02:42:56.166 --> 02:42:57.434
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
02:42:57.501 --> 02:42:58.635
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WITH
02:42:58.702 --> 02:43:00.036
THE CHAIR VOTING I AND THE VICE
02:43:00.103 --> 02:43:01.304
CHAIR VOTING NO CABALLERO
02:43:01.371 --> 02:43:06.443
CORTESI. ORTEZ E I. SKINNER
02:43:06.510 --> 02:43:08.245
SKINNER I HAMBURG. THAT'S 7 TO
02:43:08.311 --> 02:43:13.316
2. OKAY THAT BILL IS OUT, RIGHT?
02:43:13.383 --> 02:43:15.418
CAN YOU JUST DOUBLE CHECK? HAVE
02:43:15.485 --> 02:43:16.419
WE GOTTEN EVERYTHING? EVERYTHING
02:43:16.486 --> 02:43:19.256
OKAY? WE'RE GOOD. OKAY I WANT TO
02:43:19.322 --> 02:43:21.124
THANK EVERYONE FOR PARTICIPATING
02:43:21.191 --> 02:43:22.225
TODAY AND THE COMMITTEE ON
02:43:22.292 --> 02:43:40.443
HOUSING. IS ADJOURNED. Ó.