WEBVTT
00:00:04.404 --> 00:00:05.839
THE SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE
00:00:05.905 --> 00:00:07.374
WILL COME TO ORDER. GOOD MORNING
00:00:07.440 --> 00:00:09.042
, EVERYONE AS WE CONTINUE TO
00:00:09.109 --> 00:00:10.677
TAKESOME PRECAUTIONSTO MANAGE
00:00:10.744 --> 00:00:13.346
THE ONGOING COVID 19 RISK. THE
00:00:13.413 --> 00:00:14.614
SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME THE
00:00:14.681 --> 00:00:16.416
PUBLIC AND HAS PROVIDED ACCESS
00:00:16.483 --> 00:00:18.017
TO BOTH IN PERSON. AND
00:00:18.084 --> 00:00:19.018
TELECONFERENCE PARTICIPATION FOR
00:00:19.085 --> 00:00:21.821
PUBLIC COMMENT. FOR INDIVIDUALS
00:00:21.888 --> 00:00:22.756
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
00:00:22.822 --> 00:00:25.125
COMMENT VIA THE TELECONFERENCE
00:00:25.191 --> 00:00:26.493
SERVICE, THE PARTICIPANT TOLL
00:00:26.559 --> 00:00:28.495
FREE NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS
00:00:28.561 --> 00:00:30.230
POSTED ON OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE
00:00:30.296 --> 00:00:32.265
AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT NOW.
00:00:32.332 --> 00:00:34.267
TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER IS
00:00:34.334 --> 00:00:39.939
8772. AND THE ACCESS CODE IS 736
00:00:40.006 --> 00:00:45.078
TO 8. 33. I WILL MAINTAIN
00:00:45.145 --> 00:00:46.579
DECORUM DURING THE HEARING, AS
00:00:46.646 --> 00:00:49.015
IS CUSTOMARY IN ANY INDIVIDUAL
00:00:49.082 --> 00:00:50.450
WHO IS DISRUPTIVE MAY BE REMOVED
00:00:50.517 --> 00:00:51.751
FROM THE REMOTE MEETING SERVICE
00:00:51.818 --> 00:00:53.620
OR HAVE THEIR CONNECTIONS MUTED.
00:00:53.686 --> 00:00:54.754
WE'RE HOLDING OUR COMMITTEE
00:00:54.821 --> 00:00:55.955
HEARINGS HERE IN THE OLD STREET
00:00:56.022 --> 00:00:58.458
BUILDING. MAY I ASK ALL MEMBERS
00:00:58.525 --> 00:00:59.893
OF THE COMMITTEE TO BE PRESENT
00:00:59.959 --> 00:01:01.361
NOW IN ROOM 2100 SO WE CAN
00:01:01.428 --> 00:01:03.263
ESTABLISH OUR QUORUM AND BEGIN
00:01:03.329 --> 00:01:05.999
OUR HEARING. WE HAVE 21 BILLS ON
00:01:06.065 --> 00:01:08.601
TODAY'S AGENDA. DON'T BE SCARED
00:01:08.668 --> 00:01:10.203
. NINE BILLS ARE ON CONSENT. THE
00:01:10.270 --> 00:01:12.472
BILLS ON CONSENT ARE ITEM ONE A
00:01:12.539 --> 00:01:14.374
B ONE. OH, TWO. ITEM FOUR. MAYBE
00:01:14.441 --> 00:01:19.612
3 21. ITEM 12 87 40. ITEM 13.
00:01:19.679 --> 00:01:24.884
MAYBE 12 32 ITEM 15 87 48. ITEM
00:01:24.951 --> 00:01:31.958
18 80 14 67 ITEM 19 A B 17 16 71
00:01:32.025 --> 00:01:36.229
ITEM 28 18 76 AND ITEM 21 A B 18
00:01:36.296 --> 00:01:38.998
93 BEFORE WE HEAR HEAR BILL
00:01:39.065 --> 00:01:41.634
PRESENTATION. WAS ESTABLISHED A
00:01:41.701 --> 00:01:42.802
QUORUM, MADAM ASSISTANT, PLEASE
00:01:42.869 --> 00:01:46.172
CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR LEVA HERE
00:01:46.239 --> 00:01:48.041
TO LEAVE IT HERE AT SHOWBOAT.
00:01:48.107 --> 00:01:52.111
ORTEZ E. SALLY. SALLY HERE,
00:01:52.178 --> 00:01:55.582
GLASER MCGUIRE, PAN PAN HERE,
00:01:55.648 --> 00:01:56.916
ALRIGHT, WE'RE GOING TO START AS
00:01:56.983 --> 00:01:59.519
A SUBCOMMITTEE AND I SEE SOME OF
00:01:59.586 --> 00:02:01.454
MEMBER FRIEDMAN.
00:02:01.521 --> 00:02:03.056
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FRIEDMAN COME
00:02:03.122 --> 00:02:04.858
FORWARD IF YOU WILL, AND THAT IS
00:02:04.924 --> 00:02:08.361
ITEM FIVE. A B 4 52. PLEASE
00:02:08.428 --> 00:02:12.131
BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE READY. OH, AT
00:02:12.198 --> 00:02:16.736
THE PODIUM. WELCOME IS THIS YOUR
00:02:16.803 --> 00:02:18.505
FIRST TIME IN THE BUILDING, AND
00:02:18.571 --> 00:02:19.806
THIS IS MY FIRST TIME IN THIS
00:02:19.873 --> 00:02:21.374
PARTICULAR ROOM. WELL WE'RE
00:02:21.441 --> 00:02:22.876
HAPPY TO HAVE YOU. THANK YOU SO
00:02:22.942 --> 00:02:24.377
MUCH FOR HAVING ME YOU'RE
00:02:24.444 --> 00:02:25.745
WELCOME. GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM
00:02:25.812 --> 00:02:27.347
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I WANT TO.
00:02:27.413 --> 00:02:28.681
FIRST OF ALL, THANK YOU AND YOUR
00:02:28.748 --> 00:02:30.550
COMMITTEE STAFF FOR ALL OF YOUR
00:02:30.617 --> 00:02:31.885
HARD WORK ON THIS IMPORTANT
00:02:31.951 --> 00:02:33.052
BILL. I DON'T THINK AND I
00:02:33.119 --> 00:02:35.321
CERTAINLY DON'T WANT TO GO INTO
00:02:35.388 --> 00:02:37.690
REMINDING ANYBODY. WHY IT IS
00:02:37.757 --> 00:02:38.992
IMPORTANT THAT WE KEEP GUNS OUT
00:02:39.058 --> 00:02:41.761
OF THE WRONG HANDS, AND I THINK
00:02:41.828 --> 00:02:43.730
WE CAN ALL AGREE. THAT CHILDREN
00:02:43.796 --> 00:02:45.131
ARE THE WRONG HANDS FOR GUNS,
00:02:45.198 --> 00:02:46.699
AND UNFORTUNATELY, A LOT OF
00:02:46.766 --> 00:02:49.002
PARENTS DON'T REALIZE HOW
00:02:49.068 --> 00:02:50.069
VULNERABLE THEIR CHILDREN AND
00:02:50.136 --> 00:02:50.737
OTHER PEOPLE'S FAMILIES ARE FROM
00:02:50.803 --> 00:02:52.672
THE GUNS THAT THEY KEEP IN THEIR
00:02:52.739 --> 00:02:54.741
HOME. THERE ARE FAR TOO MANY
00:02:54.807 --> 00:02:56.643
PARENTS WHO BELIEVE THAT PUTTING
00:02:56.709 --> 00:02:58.711
A GUN IN A SHOE BOX ON THE TOP
00:02:58.778 --> 00:03:00.013
OF THE CLOSET IS APPROPRIATE OR
00:03:00.079 --> 00:03:01.748
KEEPING A GUN SAFE, UNLOCKED OR
00:03:01.814 --> 00:03:03.149
GIVING THEIR OWN CHILDREN THE
00:03:03.216 --> 00:03:05.285
KEYS TO THEIR GUN SAFE IS
00:03:05.351 --> 00:03:06.085
APPROPRIATE BEHAVIOR.
00:03:06.152 --> 00:03:07.020
UNFORTUNATELY TIME AND TIME
00:03:07.086 --> 00:03:08.788
AGAIN WE'VE SEEN THAT'S NOT
00:03:08.855 --> 00:03:11.624
TRUE. AS GUN VIOLENCE IS NOW THE
00:03:11.691 --> 00:03:13.493
NUMBER ONE LEADING CAUSE OF
00:03:13.560 --> 00:03:14.761
DEATH FOR CHILDREN IN THIS
00:03:14.827 --> 00:03:16.062
NATION AND IS FAR TOO MANY F
00:03:16.129 --> 00:03:18.731
THOSE RESULTS FROM UNINTENTIONAL
00:03:18.798 --> 00:03:20.033
FIREARM USE FROM CHILDREN WHO
00:03:20.099 --> 00:03:21.801
LITERALLY FIND GUNS LYING AROUND
00:03:21.868 --> 00:03:25.171
THEIR HOME. AND WAY TOO MANY
00:03:25.238 --> 00:03:27.173
TEAMS, SUICIDES AND EVEN TEEN
00:03:27.240 --> 00:03:28.808
MASS SHOOTINGS HAVE OCCURRED
00:03:28.875 --> 00:03:30.076
FROM CHILDREN WHO ARE TOO YOUNG
00:03:30.143 --> 00:03:31.744
TO LEGALLY PURCHASE WEAPONS. GET
00:03:31.811 --> 00:03:33.112
THEM FROM A FAMILY'S HOME WHERE
00:03:33.179 --> 00:03:35.381
GUNS WERE INSECURITY. WITH THIS
00:03:35.448 --> 00:03:37.450
BILL DOES. IT'S A VERY COMMON
00:03:37.517 --> 00:03:38.084
SENSE MEASURE THAT'S HAD WIDE
00:03:38.151 --> 00:03:41.688
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. THAT EVERY
00:03:41.754 --> 00:03:42.689
YEAR HAS THE SCHOOL DISTRICTS
00:03:42.755 --> 00:03:44.791
INFORM PARENTS ABOUT THEIR LEGAL
00:03:44.857 --> 00:03:46.526
RESPONSIBILITIES TO SAFELY STORE
00:03:46.593 --> 00:03:48.428
FIREARMS AND HOPEFULLY ALSO
00:03:48.494 --> 00:03:50.129
REMIND THEM ABOUT THE MORAL
00:03:50.196 --> 00:03:51.798
IMPERATIVE AND THE REASONS WHY
00:03:51.864 --> 00:03:54.567
EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM TO KEEP
00:03:54.634 --> 00:03:56.336
FIREARMS LOCKED AND STORED
00:03:56.402 --> 00:03:58.538
SAFELY AWAY FROM ANYONE WHO IS
00:03:58.605 --> 00:04:00.006
TOO YOUNG TO LEGALLY USE THAT
00:04:00.073 --> 00:04:01.674
WEAPON WITH THAT I WOULD REQUEST
00:04:01.741 --> 00:04:02.709
AN AYE. VOTE. THANK YOU.
00:04:02.775 --> 00:04:05.712
ASSEMBLY. LET'S GO AHEAD AND
00:04:05.778 --> 00:04:06.746
ESTABLISH A QUORUM. MADAM
00:04:06.813 --> 00:04:11.317
ASSISTANT PHð BUG. ORTEZ E.
00:04:11.384 --> 00:04:18.057
GLASER. GLASER HERE. WE HAVE
00:04:18.124 --> 00:04:19.692
FOUR. GREAT WE HAVE A QUORUM HAS
00:04:19.759 --> 00:04:22.161
BEEN ESTABLISHED AND BEFORE WE
00:04:22.228 --> 00:04:23.830
GO TO SUPPORT THE OPPOSITE, NO,
00:04:23.896 --> 00:04:25.198
WE'RE GONNA DO THAT FIRST. ALL
00:04:25.264 --> 00:04:27.400
RIGHT, LET'S GO TO ANY SUPPORT
00:04:27.467 --> 00:04:31.170
HERE IN ROOM 2100. SEEING NONE.
00:04:31.237 --> 00:04:33.539
BUT WE DO HAVE OH, THERE WE GO.
00:04:33.606 --> 00:04:37.877
COME ON UP. YES PLEASE. THAT
00:04:37.944 --> 00:04:39.045
WOULD BE GREAT BECAUSE WE SHOULD
00:04:39.112 --> 00:04:40.847
GO TO OUR LEAD SUPPORT FIRST,
00:04:40.913 --> 00:04:41.848
WHICH IS DONNA FINKELSTEIN.
00:04:41.914 --> 00:04:44.150
SHE'S CALLING IN AND ROWAN BY
00:04:44.217 --> 00:04:46.085
BOLT, WHO'S ALSO CALLING IN
00:04:46.152 --> 00:04:48.087
MODERATOR IF YOU CAN PLEASE
00:04:48.154 --> 00:04:49.188
QUEUE UP OUR SUPPORT. SORRY
00:04:49.255 --> 00:04:50.957
ABOUT THAT. I JUMPED THE GUN. OH
00:04:51.024 --> 00:04:51.758
GOSH. NO, THANK YOU. LADIES AND
00:04:51.824 --> 00:04:52.692
GENTLEMEN, IF YOU ARE IN
00:04:52.759 --> 00:04:54.627
SUPPORT, AND WHAT WAS THE BILL,
00:04:54.694 --> 00:04:57.463
I'M SORRY, MADAM CHAIR. THE BILL
00:04:57.530 --> 00:05:02.068
IS A B 4 52. THANK YOU VERY
00:05:02.135 --> 00:05:03.736
MUCH. IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A
00:05:03.803 --> 00:05:05.772
B FOR 52, PLEASE PRESS ONE FALL
00:05:05.838 --> 00:05:06.939
BY ZERO AT THIS TIME ONE,
00:05:07.006 --> 00:05:08.808
FOLLOWED BY A ZERO IN ONE
00:05:08.875 --> 00:05:09.842
MOMENT, WE DO HAVE SOME
00:05:09.909 --> 00:05:10.943
PARTICIPANTS QUEUING OUT. ONE
00:05:11.010 --> 00:05:13.212
MOMENT, SIR, WE JUST WANT THE
00:05:13.279 --> 00:05:14.180
TWO WITNESSES THAT ARE CALLING
00:05:14.247 --> 00:05:16.416
IN AND SUPPORT. YOU SHOULD HAVE
00:05:16.482 --> 00:05:17.917
A DONALD DONNA FINKELSTEIN AND A
00:05:17.984 --> 00:05:21.454
ROWAN FIVE BOLT ON THE LINE.
00:05:21.521 --> 00:05:22.622
PLEASE GO AHEAD. YOUR LINES ARE
00:05:22.689 --> 00:05:27.694
OPEN. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:05:27.760 --> 00:05:28.961
DONNA FINKELSTEIN, AND I'M, A
00:05:29.028 --> 00:05:30.697
MEMBER OF BRADY UNITED AND A
00:05:30.763 --> 00:05:31.998
BOARD MEMBER OF WOMEN AGAINST
00:05:32.065 --> 00:05:33.599
VIOLENCE PROFESSIONALLY FOR THE
00:05:33.666 --> 00:05:34.767
PAST 38 YEARS, I WORKED AS A
00:05:34.834 --> 00:05:37.570
HIGH SCHOOL COUNSELOR. WITH LOS
00:05:37.637 --> 00:05:39.305
ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:05:39.372 --> 00:05:40.473
. IN ADDITION, MY YOUNGEST
00:05:40.540 --> 00:05:42.041
DAUGHTER, MINDY, AT AGE 16
00:05:42.108 --> 00:05:43.676
SURVIVED BEING SHOT IN THE
00:05:43.743 --> 00:05:45.978
SCHOOL SHOOTING BACK IN 2020. I
00:05:46.045 --> 00:05:48.414
TESTIFIED BEFORE THIS COMMITTEE.
00:05:48.481 --> 00:05:51.451
TO ASK YOU TO SUPPORT ABBY TO 76
00:05:51.517 --> 00:05:52.752
, WHICH WAS THE ORIGINAL BILL TO
00:05:52.819 --> 00:05:53.720
BOLSTER CALIFORNIA STATES
00:05:53.786 --> 00:05:56.456
STORAGE LOSS. CALIFORNIA HAS
00:05:56.522 --> 00:05:59.659
STRONG ACCESS PREVENTION LAWS.
00:05:59.726 --> 00:06:01.127
BUT MANY PARENTS DO NOT KNOW
00:06:01.194 --> 00:06:04.263
ABOUT THIS LOT. ELIHU SD TELLS
00:06:04.330 --> 00:06:06.999
THE RESOLUTION IN JUNE 2019 TO
00:06:07.066 --> 00:06:08.301
DO JUST THAT AND HAS DISTRIBUTED
00:06:08.367 --> 00:06:10.870
THIS INFORMATION. TO THEIR
00:06:10.937 --> 00:06:12.839
PARENTS. SCHOOL SAFETY IS OF
00:06:12.905 --> 00:06:14.240
CRITICAL IMPORTANCE TO ALL
00:06:14.307 --> 00:06:15.775
PARENTS, SCHOOL STAFF AND THE
00:06:15.842 --> 00:06:17.877
COMMUNITY THAT LARGE MOST SCHOOL
00:06:17.944 --> 00:06:18.878
SHOOTINGS WERE COMMITTED BY
00:06:18.945 --> 00:06:20.546
MINORS. WHERE THERE WAS
00:06:20.613 --> 00:06:22.749
KNOWLEDGE OF THE COUNTRY ORIGIN
00:06:22.815 --> 00:06:24.650
80% OF THE SHOOTERS USED TO GUN
00:06:24.717 --> 00:06:26.085
HE OR SHE OBTAINED FROM THEIR
00:06:26.152 --> 00:06:28.421
HOME OVER 81 MILLION ADULT
00:06:28.488 --> 00:06:31.424
AMERICANS OWNED FIREARMS ARMS.
00:06:31.491 --> 00:06:32.992
THESE NUMBERS ARE STAGGERING,
00:06:33.059 --> 00:06:34.560
SENDING HOME SAFE STORAGE
00:06:34.627 --> 00:06:36.062
INFORMATION TO PARENTS IS NOT A
00:06:36.129 --> 00:06:38.364
REACTIVE MEASURE AT SCHOOL. WE
00:06:38.431 --> 00:06:39.265
HOLD ACTIVE SHOOTER DRILLS,
00:06:39.332 --> 00:06:40.399
LOCKDOWNS AND CHRIST THIS
00:06:40.466 --> 00:06:42.635
TRAINING FOR FACULTY. WE HAD
00:06:42.702 --> 00:06:44.237
BRADY UNITED RECOMMEND THAT THE
00:06:44.303 --> 00:06:46.706
STATE'S GUN STORAGE INFORMATION
00:06:46.773 --> 00:06:49.075
ON CALIFORNIA'S CATALOG BE SENT
00:06:49.142 --> 00:06:50.643
HOME TO US STUDENTS WHO ATTEND
00:06:50.710 --> 00:06:52.678
PUBLIC AND CHARTER SCHOOLS.
00:06:52.745 --> 00:06:54.514
PREVENTING CHILD ACCESS TO
00:06:54.580 --> 00:06:55.748
FIREARMS NOT ONLY REDUCES THE
00:06:55.815 --> 00:06:57.683
RISK OF UNINTENTIONAL AND
00:06:57.750 --> 00:06:59.619
SUICIDAL SHOOTINGS IN THE HOME
00:06:59.685 --> 00:07:01.087
BUT ALSO REACHES THE RISK OF
00:07:01.154 --> 00:07:02.722
SHOOTING SCHOOL. DISTRIBUTING
00:07:02.789 --> 00:07:04.157
THIS INFORMATION WOULD BE A
00:07:04.223 --> 00:07:05.958
SMALL BUT ESSENTIAL STEP TOWARDS
00:07:06.025 --> 00:07:06.959
PREVENTING GUN VIOLENCE AND
00:07:07.026 --> 00:07:09.328
KEEPING OUR CHILDREN SAFE. THIS
00:07:09.395 --> 00:07:11.597
NOTIFICATION IS INEXPENSIVE,
00:07:11.664 --> 00:07:13.599
SIMPLE AND EDUCATE THE STAFF AND
00:07:13.666 --> 00:07:15.301
THE STUDENTS AS WELL. LET'S LET
00:07:15.368 --> 00:07:17.537
US MAKE IT A STATEWIDE LAW. I
00:07:17.603 --> 00:07:19.906
URGE YOU TO PASS A B 4 52 TO
00:07:19.972 --> 00:07:21.574
SAVE THE LIVES OF OUR CHILDREN.
00:07:21.641 --> 00:07:23.576
WE ARE COUNTING ON YOU. THANK
00:07:23.643 --> 00:07:25.611
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
00:07:25.678 --> 00:07:26.679
FINKELSTEIN. NOW WE HAVE ROWAN
00:07:26.746 --> 00:07:31.417
TYBALT. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:07:31.484 --> 00:07:33.052
ROHAN TURBO. I'M A HIGH SCHOOL
00:07:33.119 --> 00:07:34.754
SENIOR LIVING IN LOS ANGELES.
00:07:34.821 --> 00:07:36.088
AND I'M A VOLUNTEER LEADER WITH
00:07:36.155 --> 00:07:37.456
STUDENTS DEMAND ACTION AND EVERY
00:07:37.523 --> 00:07:39.058
TOWN FOR GUN SAFETY WHERE I'VE
00:07:39.125 --> 00:07:39.892
BEEN SO EXCITED TO SEE
00:07:39.959 --> 00:07:41.694
CALIFORNIA LEAD THE WAY ON GUN
00:07:41.761 --> 00:07:43.362
VIOLENCE PREVENTION. JUST A
00:07:43.429 --> 00:07:44.831
MONTH AFTER I STARTED STUDENTS
00:07:44.897 --> 00:07:46.399
DEMAND ACTION CHAPTER AT MY HIGH
00:07:46.465 --> 00:07:47.767
SCHOOL WE EXPERIENCED SHOOTING
00:07:47.834 --> 00:07:49.001
SCARE WHEN A LOOKALIKE SON WAS
00:07:49.068 --> 00:07:51.270
BROUGHT ON TO OUR CAMP. THE
00:07:51.337 --> 00:07:52.772
INCIDENT WAS JUST A PHRASE THE
00:07:52.839 --> 00:07:54.841
FEAR OF HAVING MY LIFE CUT SHORT
00:07:54.907 --> 00:07:56.843
BY GUN VIOLENCE WAS VERY REAL. I
00:07:56.909 --> 00:07:58.144
FEARED THAT I WOULD NOT BE ABLE
00:07:58.211 --> 00:07:59.879
TO WALK THE AYELECH GRADUATION
00:07:59.946 --> 00:08:01.747
AS I WILL IN JUST A FEW WEEKS
00:08:01.814 --> 00:08:03.049
AND THAT MY PARENTS WOULD BE
00:08:03.115 --> 00:08:04.817
DELIVERED THE HORRIBLE NEWS THAT
00:08:04.884 --> 00:08:05.885
THEIR SON WILL NEVER COME HOME.
00:08:05.952 --> 00:08:07.019
BUT TOO MANY CALIFORNIANS
00:08:07.086 --> 00:08:08.087
PARENTS NOT HERE EVERY DAY.
00:08:08.154 --> 00:08:09.689
THAT'S WHY SECURE STORAGE LAWS
00:08:09.755 --> 00:08:11.390
ARE SO IMPORTANT. THEY'RE ONE OF
00:08:11.457 --> 00:08:12.592
THE SIMPLEST WAYS TO PREVENT
00:08:12.658 --> 00:08:14.393
SCHOOL SHOOTINGS, AND THEY ALSO
00:08:14.460 --> 00:08:15.094
COMBAT ON SUICIDE AND
00:08:15.161 --> 00:08:16.529
UNINTENTIONAL SHOOTINGS BY
00:08:16.596 --> 00:08:18.598
CHILDREN. SECURE FIREARM STORAGE
00:08:18.664 --> 00:08:21.400
IN THE HOME IS ONE OF THE MOST
00:08:21.467 --> 00:08:22.468
EFFECTIVE TOOLS TO PREVENT GUN
00:08:22.535 --> 00:08:23.336
VIOLENCE IN SCHOOLS. ACCORDING
00:08:23.402 --> 00:08:24.837
TO RESEARCH FROM THE U. S SECRET
00:08:24.904 --> 00:08:27.039
SERVICE, IN FACT, UP TO 76% OF
00:08:27.106 --> 00:08:27.840
SCHOOL SHOOTERS OBTAINED THEIR
00:08:27.907 --> 00:08:29.742
GUNS FROM THE HOME OR THE HOME
00:08:29.809 --> 00:08:31.878
OF THE RELATIVE. IN ADDITION TO
00:08:31.944 --> 00:08:32.745
PREVENTING GUN VIOLENCE ON
00:08:32.812 --> 00:08:34.213
SCHOOL GROUNDS, RESEARCH SHOWS
00:08:34.280 --> 00:08:36.883
THAT SECURE FIREARM STORAGE ALSO
00:08:36.949 --> 00:08:38.251
PLAYS A VITAL ROLE IN REDUCING
00:08:38.317 --> 00:08:39.218
UNINTENTIONAL SHOOTING AND GUN
00:08:39.285 --> 00:08:42.221
SUICIDE. BY PREVENTING CHILDREN
00:08:42.288 --> 00:08:43.723
AND TEAMS FROM ACCESSING WEAPONS
00:08:43.789 --> 00:08:45.391
IN THE FIRST PLACE. SECURE
00:08:45.458 --> 00:08:46.058
FIREARM STORAGE CAN HELP REDUCE
00:08:46.125 --> 00:08:47.860
THE RISK OF GUN VIOLENCE IN AND
00:08:47.927 --> 00:08:50.062
OUT OF SCHOOL. CALIFORNIA
00:08:50.129 --> 00:08:50.796
ALREADY HAS A STRONG SECURE
00:08:50.863 --> 00:08:53.032
STORAGE LAW REQUIRING GUN OWNERS
00:08:53.099 --> 00:08:54.567
TO STORE THEIR GUNS SO THAT
00:08:54.634 --> 00:08:56.502
CHILDREN ARE NOT LIKELY TO
00:08:56.569 --> 00:08:58.437
ACCESS THEM. BUT THE LAW IS ONLY
00:08:58.504 --> 00:08:59.038
EFFECTIVE IF PEOPLE KNOW ABOUT
00:08:59.105 --> 00:09:00.139
IT. FOLLOWING YEARS OF
00:09:00.206 --> 00:09:01.140
GRASSROOTS ADVOCACY FOR MOMS,
00:09:01.207 --> 00:09:02.074
DEMAND ACTION AND STUDENTS,
00:09:02.141 --> 00:09:03.342
AMANDA ACTION VOLUNTEERS AS WELL
00:09:03.409 --> 00:09:05.478
AS OTHER COMMUNITY GROUPS, MORE
00:09:05.544 --> 00:09:06.379
THAN TWO DOZEN SCHOOL DISTRICT
00:09:06.445 --> 00:09:08.314
IN CALIFORNIA ALREADY SENT HOME
00:09:08.381 --> 00:09:10.449
INFORMATION ABOUT SCHOOL SHIRT.
00:09:10.516 --> 00:09:12.351
ABOUT SECURE STORAGE EVERY YEAR,
00:09:12.418 --> 00:09:13.352
INCLUDING MY OWN GLENDALE
00:09:13.419 --> 00:09:15.588
UNIFIED WITH THE SURGEON,
00:09:15.655 --> 00:09:17.189
FIREARMS SALES AND FIRST TIME
00:09:17.256 --> 00:09:18.324
GUN OWNERS OVER THE PAST FEW
00:09:18.391 --> 00:09:20.826
YEARS. STUDENTS LIKE ME CAN GO
00:09:20.893 --> 00:09:21.861
TO SCHOOL CONFIDENCE. LIKE
00:09:21.928 --> 00:09:23.296
GLENDALE PARENTS ARE EQUIPPED
00:09:23.362 --> 00:09:25.097
WITH THE RESOURCES THEY NEED TO
00:09:25.164 --> 00:09:26.332
STORE THEIR GUNS SAFELY. THIS
00:09:26.399 --> 00:09:28.401
PAST A BEFORE 52 WOULD ENSURE
00:09:28.467 --> 00:09:30.069
THAT ALL CALIFORNIA PARENTS
00:09:30.136 --> 00:09:31.671
WOULD RECEIVE NOTIFICATIONS. IN
00:09:31.737 --> 00:09:33.439
FACT, IT WOULD BE THE FIRST
00:09:33.506 --> 00:09:34.006
LEGISLATION IN THE COUNTRY
00:09:34.073 --> 00:09:35.508
REQUIRING SCHOOLS STATEWIDE
00:09:35.574 --> 00:09:36.342
ISSUES SECURE STORAGE
00:09:36.409 --> 00:09:38.144
NOTIFICATION. IT'S THE
00:09:38.210 --> 00:09:40.313
RESPONSIBILITY OF ADULTS TO KEEP
00:09:40.379 --> 00:09:41.814
FIREARMS AWAY FROM CHILDREN. AND
00:09:41.881 --> 00:09:43.716
I HOPE YOU TAKE ACTION AND VOTE
00:09:43.783 --> 00:09:45.718
YES, ON A B 45 TO ENSURE THAT
00:09:45.785 --> 00:09:46.886
PARENTS AND GUARDIANS HAD THE
00:09:46.953 --> 00:09:47.987
TOOLS, PARENTS, STATES AND KIDS
00:09:48.054 --> 00:09:50.222
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU,
00:09:50.289 --> 00:09:52.191
MR TEBOW. ALRIGHT NOW WE WILL GO
00:09:52.258 --> 00:09:54.427
TO SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM 2100
00:09:54.493 --> 00:09:55.861
ANYONE WISHING TO STATE THEIR
00:09:55.928 --> 00:09:58.197
NAME AND SUPPORT FOR THE BILL,
00:09:58.264 --> 00:09:59.932
PLEASE COME FORWARD. GO RIGHT
00:09:59.999 --> 00:10:01.200
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. SHARON
00:10:01.267 --> 00:10:02.601
MEMBERS. REBECCA MARCUS,
00:10:02.668 --> 00:10:03.669
REPRESENTING THE CHILDREN'S
00:10:03.736 --> 00:10:04.670
ADVOCACY INSTITUTE AT THE U. S
00:10:04.737 --> 00:10:06.605
D. SCHOOL OF LAW. THANK YOU.
00:10:06.672 --> 00:10:10.242
THANK YOU. SEEING NO ONE ELSE
00:10:10.309 --> 00:10:12.578
HERE IN ROOM 2100, MR MODERATOR
00:10:12.645 --> 00:10:14.780
, IF YOU WOULD OPEN THE LINES
00:10:14.847 --> 00:10:16.015
FOR ANYONE WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY
00:10:16.082 --> 00:10:19.452
AND SUPPORT OF A B 4 52, PLEASE.
00:10:19.518 --> 00:10:21.153
THANK YOU, MADAM. SURE. LADIES
00:10:21.220 --> 00:10:22.054
AND GENTLEMEN, THE PHONE LINES
00:10:22.121 --> 00:10:24.156
IF YOU DO WISH TO TESTIFY AND
00:10:24.223 --> 00:10:25.157
SUPPORT THE A B 452, PLEASE
00:10:25.224 --> 00:10:27.059
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO. AT
00:10:27.126 --> 00:10:29.395
THIS TIME, AN OPERATOR WILL
00:10:29.462 --> 00:10:30.029
QUICKLY GIVE YOUR LINE NUMBER
00:10:30.096 --> 00:10:31.397
OFFLINE. THE POLICE YOU RIGHT
00:10:31.464 --> 00:10:32.465
BACK INTO THE QUÊ. PLEASE PRESS
00:10:32.531 --> 00:10:34.333
10 FOR PUBLIC COMMENT AND WE
00:10:34.400 --> 00:10:35.768
WILL GO TO LINE 16 TO BEGIN. GO
00:10:35.835 --> 00:10:39.705
AHEAD, 16. GOOD MORNING. NICOLE
00:10:39.772 --> 00:10:41.507
KIDMAN IS ON BEHALF OF EVERY
00:10:41.574 --> 00:10:42.575
CANCER, GUN SAFETY AND SUPPORT.
00:10:42.641 --> 00:10:48.581
THANK YOU. 9 40, YOU ARE OPEN.
00:10:48.647 --> 00:10:50.349
GOOD MORNING, REBECCA GONZALEZ
00:10:50.416 --> 00:10:51.584
FOR THE NATIONALIST ASSOCIATION
00:10:51.650 --> 00:10:53.352
OF SOCIAL WORKERS. CALIFORNIA
00:10:53.419 --> 00:10:55.454
CHAPTER IN SUPPORT, ALSO
00:10:55.521 --> 00:10:56.689
EXPRESSING SUPPORT FOR THE
00:10:56.756 --> 00:10:57.156
FRIENDS COMMITTEE ON
00:10:57.223 --> 00:10:58.024
LEGISLATION. THANK YOU. THANK
00:10:58.090 --> 00:11:04.063
YOU. LINE. 24, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:11:04.130 --> 00:11:05.464
GOOD MORNING, KAREN ROSS ON
00:11:05.531 --> 00:11:07.099
BEHALF OF THE CITIES OF BURBANK
00:11:07.166 --> 00:11:10.403
AND SOLANA BEACH IN SUPPORT. 23
00:11:10.469 --> 00:11:16.876
YOU ARE OPEN. PLANE. 43, PLEASE
00:11:16.942 --> 00:11:23.582
GO AHEAD. MORNING CARE MEMBERS
00:11:23.649 --> 00:11:24.884
FOR SILICA DUST ON BEHALF OF THE
00:11:24.950 --> 00:11:26.719
CITY OF LOS ANGELES AND L. A
00:11:26.786 --> 00:11:27.953
CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE IN
00:11:28.020 --> 00:11:29.955
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
00:11:30.022 --> 00:11:34.193
NEXT. WE'VE GOT A LINE 35. HELLO
00:11:34.260 --> 00:11:35.761
THIS IS ROBIN BRANT. I'M AN
00:11:35.828 --> 00:11:37.329
ORANGE COUNTY PARENTS AND A
00:11:37.396 --> 00:11:39.398
MEMBER OF WOMEN FOR AMERICAN
00:11:39.465 --> 00:11:40.566
VALUES AND ETHICS. I'M SPEAKING
00:11:40.633 --> 00:11:47.573
IN SUPPORT. PLEASE GO AHEAD. 31.
00:11:47.640 --> 00:11:50.209
HI THIS IS JUSTICE SEMEN ON
00:11:50.276 --> 00:11:52.344
BEHALF OF THE 1900 MEMBERS AMONG
00:11:52.411 --> 00:11:54.914
TOURISTS AND THE 350 MEMBERS OF
00:11:54.980 --> 00:11:56.048
FEMINISTS AND ACTION. WE ARE IN
00:11:56.115 --> 00:11:58.717
PASSIONATE SUPPORT. 9 25, YOU
00:11:58.784 --> 00:12:04.190
ARE OPEN. GOOD MORNING. MY NAME
00:12:04.256 --> 00:12:05.958
IS JULIA DEMO, AND I'M A PARENT
00:12:06.025 --> 00:12:08.094
WITH STUDENTS IN NEWPORT MADE
00:12:08.160 --> 00:12:09.095
THE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND A MEMBER
00:12:09.161 --> 00:12:11.097
OF WOMEN FOR AMERICAN VALUES AND
00:12:11.163 --> 00:12:12.965
ETHICS AND I'M IN STRONG SUPPORT
00:12:13.032 --> 00:12:14.400
OF ABC. 4 50 TEACHERS. THANK
00:12:14.467 --> 00:12:17.136
YOU. THANK YOU. 9 46, YOU ARE
00:12:17.203 --> 00:12:21.941
UP. GOOD MORNING. LET'S JUST
00:12:22.007 --> 00:12:25.077
STUDENT LU FROM ORANGE COUNTY.
00:12:25.144 --> 00:12:26.345
AND I'M WITH WOMEN FOR AMERICAN
00:12:26.412 --> 00:12:28.714
VALUES AND ETHICS. AND I'M
00:12:28.781 --> 00:12:33.185
CALLING IN SUPPORT OF A B 4 52.
00:12:33.252 --> 00:12:34.987
AND AS A FINAL REMINDER IF YOU
00:12:35.054 --> 00:12:36.155
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY AND
00:12:36.222 --> 00:12:38.424
SUPPORT OF A B 452 PLEASE TAKE
00:12:38.491 --> 00:12:40.126
THIS OPPORTUNITY AND PRESS ONE
00:12:40.192 --> 00:12:42.128
FOLLOWED BY 0 45, PLEASE GO
00:12:42.194 --> 00:12:45.931
AHEAD. MORNING PETER STEIN. I'M
00:12:45.998 --> 00:12:47.733
IN ORANGE COUNTY PARENT AND A
00:12:47.800 --> 00:12:49.835
MEMBER OF WOMEN FOR AMERICAN
00:12:49.902 --> 00:12:51.470
VALUES AND ETHICS IN STRONG
00:12:51.537 --> 00:12:52.538
SUPPORT OF MAYBE 45. THANKS.
00:12:52.605 --> 00:12:55.841
THANK YOU. LINE. 52, PLEASE GO
00:12:55.908 --> 00:13:01.914
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. I'M DEARLY
00:13:01.981 --> 00:13:03.149
GAFFNEY AND I'M, A PARENT IN
00:13:03.215 --> 00:13:06.986
NEWPORT, MESA. AND I'M ONE OF
00:13:07.052 --> 00:13:09.355
THE THOUSANDS OF MEMBERS OF THE
00:13:09.421 --> 00:13:10.756
WOMEN FOR AMERICAN VALUES AND
00:13:10.823 --> 00:13:12.858
ETHICS THAT ARE CALLING IN
00:13:12.925 --> 00:13:15.194
SUPPORT OF A B 4 52 SO KISSING
00:13:15.261 --> 00:13:17.196
QUÊ. GET GUNS AND THANK YOU.
00:13:17.263 --> 00:13:20.266
NEXT CALLER, PLEASE. THANK YOU,
00:13:20.332 --> 00:13:26.805
LANE. 56, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:13:26.872 --> 00:13:27.973
PLAYING 56. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:13:28.040 --> 00:13:31.377
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT? HI MY NAME
00:13:31.443 --> 00:13:33.846
IS KEN GOURLAY WILL RESENTMENT
00:13:33.913 --> 00:13:36.682
OF JENNA, WHICH OF THE 4002
00:13:36.749 --> 00:13:38.017
STATE AND TO USE EDUCATIONAL,
00:13:38.083 --> 00:13:39.818
OBVIOUSLY ORGANIZATION AND WE
00:13:39.885 --> 00:13:41.921
ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF MAYBE 4
00:13:41.987 --> 00:13:45.558
52. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MADAM
00:13:45.624 --> 00:13:47.860
CHAIR. WE HAVE EXHAUSTED THE CUE
00:13:47.927 --> 00:13:48.627
. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
00:13:48.694 --> 00:13:49.795
ALRIGHT WE HAVE NO LEAD
00:13:49.862 --> 00:13:51.363
OPPOSITION LISTED. IS THERE
00:13:51.430 --> 00:13:53.599
ANYONE IN ROOM 2100, WHO WISHES
00:13:53.666 --> 00:13:57.303
TO TESTIFY AGAINST A B 4 52 SEEN
00:13:57.369 --> 00:13:58.437
NONE. MR MODERATOR ARE COMING
00:13:58.504 --> 00:13:59.838
BACK TO YOU. PLEASE QUEUE UP
00:13:59.905 --> 00:14:01.907
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO SPEAK IN
00:14:01.974 --> 00:14:05.177
OPPOSITION TO A B 4 52. IF YOU
00:14:05.244 --> 00:14:06.779
WOULD LIKE TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION
00:14:06.845 --> 00:14:08.781
TO A B 452 PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
00:14:08.847 --> 00:14:11.050
THIS TIME 10 FOR OPPOSITION TO A
00:14:11.116 --> 00:14:17.990
B 452. MADAM CHAIR. NOBODY IS
00:14:18.057 --> 00:14:19.458
QUEUING UP AT THIS TIME. THANK
00:14:19.525 --> 00:14:20.492
YOU, MR MODERATOR. WE'RE GOING
00:14:20.559 --> 00:14:22.294
TO BRING IT BACK HERE TO THE
00:14:22.361 --> 00:14:23.963
COMMITTEE. YES, SENATOR PAN.
00:14:24.029 --> 00:14:25.698
THANK YOU. AND FIRST OF ALL,
00:14:25.764 --> 00:14:27.866
IT'S AND WE'RE FRIEDMAN. THANK
00:14:27.933 --> 00:14:28.734
YOU SO MUCH FOR BRINGING THIS
00:14:28.801 --> 00:14:30.869
BILL FORWARD. I KNOW. YOU CITED
00:14:30.936 --> 00:14:32.471
THE STATISTIC THAT WHICH IS
00:14:32.538 --> 00:14:34.640
UNFORTUNATELY TRUE THAT THE
00:14:34.707 --> 00:14:35.708
LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH AND
00:14:35.774 --> 00:14:38.611
CHILDREN'S NOW FIREARMS, AND I
00:14:38.677 --> 00:14:42.181
THINK IT'S GOOD TO PUT THAT, UM
00:14:42.248 --> 00:14:43.882
STATISTIC ACTUALLY IN IN SOME
00:14:43.949 --> 00:14:46.118
CONTEXT, BECAUSE PREVIOUSLY WAS
00:14:46.185 --> 00:14:47.152
ACTUALLY MOTOR VEHICLE CLASS
00:14:47.219 --> 00:14:50.756
ACCIDENTS. AND I WOULD POINT OUT
00:14:50.823 --> 00:14:53.225
THAT BACK IN 2000 FACT MOTOR
00:14:53.292 --> 00:14:56.829
VEHICLE ACCIDENTS OR INJURIES
00:14:56.895 --> 00:14:57.896
SAY NOTHING'S REALLY AN ACCIDENT
00:14:57.963 --> 00:15:00.699
. IT'S PREVENTABLE, RIGHT? UM
00:15:00.766 --> 00:15:02.901
ACTUALLY IS TWOFOLD. AND WHAT WE
00:15:02.968 --> 00:15:04.903
DID IS WE PASSED THROUGH VARIOUS
00:15:04.970 --> 00:15:08.641
LAWS. REDUCE THE CHANCES THAT
00:15:08.707 --> 00:15:10.909
YOU DIE IN A MOTOR VEHICLE. UM,
00:15:10.976 --> 00:15:14.546
INCIDENT RIGHT? AND PEOPLE
00:15:14.613 --> 00:15:15.581
DIDN'T GO AROUND SAYING OH,
00:15:15.648 --> 00:15:17.483
WE'RE TRYING TO BE IN CARS.
00:15:17.549 --> 00:15:21.754
RIGHT, WE SAID OKAY. WORD YOU
00:15:21.820 --> 00:15:24.290
KNOW WE'RE GOING TO DO THINGS TO
00:15:24.356 --> 00:15:25.591
BE SURE CHILDREN ARE SAFER IN
00:15:25.658 --> 00:15:27.793
THESE VEHICLES NOW. I THINK
00:15:27.860 --> 00:15:29.762
THERE'S SOME DEBATE IN TERMS OF
00:15:29.828 --> 00:15:30.963
YOU KNOW WHAT THE PURPOSE OF
00:15:31.030 --> 00:15:32.064
FIREARMS ARE, BUT MORE
00:15:32.131 --> 00:15:34.199
FUNDAMENTALLY, THERE ARE THINGS
00:15:34.266 --> 00:15:37.136
WE CAN DO TO REDUCE DEATH AND
00:15:37.202 --> 00:15:38.704
INJURY FROM FIREARMS WITHOUT
00:15:38.771 --> 00:15:39.772
TAKING PEOPLE'S FIREARMS AWAY.
00:15:39.838 --> 00:15:40.806
WE CAN HAVE A WHOLE DIFFERENT
00:15:40.873 --> 00:15:43.175
DEBATE ABOUT YOU KNOW TOO MANY
00:15:43.242 --> 00:15:44.410
GUNS, ALL THAT OTHER STUFF. BUT
00:15:44.476 --> 00:15:47.513
EVEN THAT AND WE NEED TO TAKE
00:15:47.579 --> 00:15:49.682
ACTION TO KEEP PEOPLE SAFER. AND
00:15:49.748 --> 00:15:51.850
SO WE HAVE HERE IN THIS
00:15:51.917 --> 00:15:52.584
LEGISLATURE, BUT I THINK YOUR
00:15:52.651 --> 00:15:54.119
BILL TO REMIND PEOPLE PEOPLE
00:15:54.186 --> 00:15:55.754
DON'T ALWAYS KNOW WE PASS THINGS
00:15:55.821 --> 00:15:57.056
HERE. YOU KNOW THIS. WE PASS
00:15:57.122 --> 00:15:58.223
THINGS HERE, AND PEOPLE DON'T
00:15:58.290 --> 00:16:00.592
ALWAYS REALIZE THAT SO CERTAINLY
00:16:00.659 --> 00:16:02.761
I WANT TO THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
00:16:02.828 --> 00:16:03.729
BEING THIS BILL FORWARD. IT'S
00:16:03.796 --> 00:16:04.897
IMPORTANT PEOPLE KNOW WHAT THE
00:16:04.963 --> 00:16:07.466
SCIENCE IS. THEY KNOW WHAT THE
00:16:07.533 --> 00:16:08.634
POLICIES ARE. THE LAWS ARE THAT
00:16:08.701 --> 00:16:09.902
WE PUT IN PLACE BECAUSE OF THOSE
00:16:09.968 --> 00:16:12.137
THAT SCIENCE AND, UM AND IT IS.
00:16:12.204 --> 00:16:14.106
IT IS A VERY SAD STATISTIC THAT
00:16:14.173 --> 00:16:15.708
RIGHT NOW THAT FIREARMS IS THE
00:16:15.774 --> 00:16:17.276
LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH IN
00:16:17.343 --> 00:16:18.811
CHILDREN AND WE SHOULD BE DOING
00:16:18.877 --> 00:16:20.212
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO REDUCE
00:16:20.279 --> 00:16:21.814
CAUSES OF DEATH. WE WORKED ON
00:16:21.880 --> 00:16:24.483
THAT AND MOTOR VEHICLES. WE NEED
00:16:24.550 --> 00:16:26.852
TO DO THAT AROUND FIREARMS. SO
00:16:26.919 --> 00:16:27.653
WITH THAT I CERTAINLY WANT TO
00:16:27.720 --> 00:16:29.722
SUPPORT YOUR BILL AND WE'LL MOVE
00:16:29.788 --> 00:16:31.623
IT AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.
00:16:31.690 --> 00:16:32.224
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
00:16:32.291 --> 00:16:33.359
PAN ANY OTHER QUESTIONS?
00:16:33.425 --> 00:16:34.360
COMMENTS CONCERNS. THANK YOU.
00:16:34.426 --> 00:16:35.427
VERY. THE BILL'S ALREADY BEEN
00:16:35.494 --> 00:16:37.463
MOVED, BUT THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
00:16:37.529 --> 00:16:38.364
SENATOR. EXIT ASSEMBLYWOMAN,
00:16:38.430 --> 00:16:40.065
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? TO SAY
00:16:40.132 --> 00:16:41.767
I'VE BEEN VERY GRATIFIED TO SEE
00:16:41.834 --> 00:16:43.669
BY THE BIPARTISAN AND WIDE
00:16:43.736 --> 00:16:45.371
SUPPORT FOR THIS BILL, AND IT
00:16:45.437 --> 00:16:47.906
SEEMS VERY BASIC AND MINOR BUT
00:16:47.973 --> 00:16:49.475
THE FACT THAT THERE ARE PEOPLE
00:16:49.541 --> 00:16:51.043
WHO RIGHT NOW DON'T HAVE
00:16:51.110 --> 00:16:52.444
CHILDREN IN THEIR LIVES BECAUSE
00:16:52.511 --> 00:16:53.412
THEY EITHER DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT
00:16:53.479 --> 00:16:55.280
THEIR LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY OR NO
00:16:55.347 --> 00:16:57.816
ONE TOLD THEM. WHAT COULD
00:16:57.883 --> 00:16:59.284
HAPPEN? NO ONE REMINDED THEM SO
00:16:59.351 --> 00:17:01.186
I DO THINK THE SAME WAY THAT DR
00:17:01.253 --> 00:17:02.454
PAN WE SENT HOME INFORMATION
00:17:02.521 --> 00:17:03.689
ABOUT MEDICATION TO PEOPLE
00:17:03.756 --> 00:17:05.357
REMIND THEM TO KEEP IT AWAY FROM
00:17:05.424 --> 00:17:07.159
KIDS. HOW TO TAKE IT CORRECTLY.
00:17:07.226 --> 00:17:08.694
WE NEED TO DO THE SAME WITH
00:17:08.761 --> 00:17:09.828
FIREARMS. SO WITH THAT I WOULD
00:17:09.895 --> 00:17:10.796
APPRECIATE AND I BOTH. THANK
00:17:10.863 --> 00:17:11.930
YOU. THANK YOU, ASSEMBLYWOMAN.
00:17:11.997 --> 00:17:13.966
ALRIGHT WE THE BILL HAS BEEN
00:17:14.032 --> 00:17:15.067
MOVED BY SENATOR PAN. MADAM
00:17:15.134 --> 00:17:16.835
ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:17:16.902 --> 00:17:19.972
FILE ITEM FIVE. MAYBE 4 52. THE
00:17:20.038 --> 00:17:22.207
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST BE
00:17:22.274 --> 00:17:22.941
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:17:23.008 --> 00:17:25.444
JUDICIARY, LIVER. LEAVE IT. I
00:17:25.511 --> 00:17:26.779
SHOW BOOK BOOK I. CORTEZ E.
00:17:26.845 --> 00:17:33.452
SALLY. LASER. GLASER I MCGUIRE
00:17:33.519 --> 00:17:36.555
PAN AND I W HAS ENOUGH VOTES TO
00:17:36.622 --> 00:17:38.590
GET OUT. BUT WE'LL LEAVE IT ON
00:17:38.657 --> 00:17:40.259
CALL FOR ABSENT MEMBERS.
00:17:40.325 --> 00:17:40.893
ALRIGHT, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO
00:17:40.959 --> 00:17:41.860
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO
00:17:41.927 --> 00:17:44.296
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CALDERON. PLEASE
00:17:44.363 --> 00:17:45.464
COME FORWARD WHEN YOU'RE READY
00:17:45.531 --> 00:17:47.166
RIGHT OVER HERE TO YOUR RIGHT.
00:17:47.232 --> 00:17:54.573
YOU CAN GO EITHER WAY. MHM. YES.
00:17:54.640 --> 00:17:56.975
BEFORE WE START WITH A B 2 88.
00:17:57.042 --> 00:17:57.943
LET'S TAKE UP THE CONSENT
00:17:58.010 --> 00:18:00.112
CALENDAR. DO WE HAVE A MOTION
00:18:00.179 --> 00:18:01.213
FOR THE CONSENT CALENDAR? SO
00:18:01.280 --> 00:18:02.347
MOVED BY SENATOR PAN? MADAM
00:18:02.414 --> 00:18:05.117
ASSISTANT, PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:18:05.184 --> 00:18:07.786
CONSENT CALENDAR. LEYVA LEAVE
00:18:07.853 --> 00:18:10.389
IT. I WILL BOOK A BOOK BY CORTEZ
00:18:10.456 --> 00:18:15.060
E DELI. SALLY I GLASER. LASER
00:18:15.127 --> 00:18:18.797
EYE MCGUIRE PAN AND I THANK YOU
00:18:18.864 --> 00:18:20.199
SO MUCH. ALRIGHT WELCOME.
00:18:20.265 --> 00:18:22.134
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CALDERON, PLEASE
00:18:22.201 --> 00:18:23.702
PRESENT A B 288 WHEN YOU'RE
00:18:23.769 --> 00:18:25.904
READY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
00:18:25.971 --> 00:18:28.106
I'M HERE TO PRESENT A B 288,
00:18:28.173 --> 00:18:29.608
WHICH IS A CALIFORNIA BAN ON
00:18:29.675 --> 00:18:30.809
SCHOLARSHIP DISPLACEMENT ACT,
00:18:30.876 --> 00:18:32.044
WHICH THUS FAR HAS RECEIVED
00:18:32.110 --> 00:18:34.847
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT. I'M EARNING
00:18:34.913 --> 00:18:36.615
A COLLEGE DEGREE CAN BE VERY
00:18:36.682 --> 00:18:37.616
EXPENSIVE AND MANY STUDENTS
00:18:37.683 --> 00:18:39.818
STRUGGLE. EVERY DAY TO COVER THE
00:18:39.885 --> 00:18:41.520
ADDITIONAL COST OF COLLEGE EVEN
00:18:41.587 --> 00:18:43.856
WITH FINANCIAL AID AWARDS. MANY
00:18:43.922 --> 00:18:46.091
STUDENTS ARE UNABLE TO MAKE FULL
00:18:46.158 --> 00:18:47.593
USE OF AWARDS GIVEN BY PRIVATE
00:18:47.659 --> 00:18:49.495
SCHOLARSHIP PROVIDERS BECAUSE
00:18:49.561 --> 00:18:50.562
COLLEGES CAN REDUCE THEIR
00:18:50.629 --> 00:18:52.865
INSTITUTIONAL GIFT AID, WHICH
00:18:52.931 --> 00:18:53.966
THOSE STUDENTS WOULD OTHERWISE
00:18:54.032 --> 00:18:56.168
BE QUALIFIED TO RECEIVE. THIS
00:18:56.235 --> 00:18:57.336
PRACTICE IS KNOWN AS SCHOLARSHIP
00:18:57.402 --> 00:19:01.039
DISPLACEMENT. AND IT CREATES AN
00:19:01.106 --> 00:19:03.075
EVEN GREATER FINANCIAL BURDEN ON
00:19:03.141 --> 00:19:04.109
STUDENTS FROM LOWER INCOME
00:19:04.176 --> 00:19:06.078
COMMUNITIES WHO MAY HAVE NO
00:19:06.144 --> 00:19:07.679
OTHER MEANS TO PAY FOR THE NON
00:19:07.746 --> 00:19:09.882
TUITION COST OF COLLEGE, SUCH AS
00:19:09.948 --> 00:19:13.685
BOOKS, FOOD AND HOUSING. A B 288
00:19:13.752 --> 00:19:15.587
WOULD INCREASE ACCESS TO HIGHER
00:19:15.654 --> 00:19:17.489
EDUCATION BY PREVENTING COLLEGES
00:19:17.556 --> 00:19:18.056
FROM REDUCING INSTITUTIONAL
00:19:18.123 --> 00:19:22.427
GIFT. EIGHT AWARDS, AND IF A
00:19:22.494 --> 00:19:23.829
STUDENT WHO IS ELIGIBLE FOR THE
00:19:23.896 --> 00:19:25.097
FEDERAL PELL GRANT OR CALIFORNIA
00:19:25.163 --> 00:19:27.366
DREAM ACT IS ALSO AWARDED A
00:19:27.432 --> 00:19:30.035
PRIVATE SCHOLARSHIP. HERE WITH
00:19:30.102 --> 00:19:31.937
ME TODAY SPEAKING AND SUPPORTIVE
00:19:32.004 --> 00:19:34.139
. MAYBE 288 IS YVETTE HERNANDEZ
00:19:34.206 --> 00:19:35.607
, A COLLEGE STUDENT AT UC
00:19:35.674 --> 00:19:37.309
BERKELEY AND PART OF THE
00:19:37.376 --> 00:19:38.243
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COLLEGE
00:19:38.310 --> 00:19:40.212
ACCESS NETWORK. AND CALL WITH
00:19:40.279 --> 00:19:41.313
LOW DIRECTOR OF POLICY FOR
00:19:41.380 --> 00:19:44.116
SCHOLARSHIP AMERICA. THANK YOU
00:19:44.182 --> 00:19:46.351
VERY MUCH, ASSEMBLYWOMAN, AND IT
00:19:46.418 --> 00:19:47.986
LOOKS LIKE WE HAVE YVETTE
00:19:48.053 --> 00:19:49.187
HERNANDEZ IN PERSON. IF YOU'RE
00:19:49.254 --> 00:19:51.156
HERE, COME ON UP. AND GO RIGHT
00:19:51.223 --> 00:19:53.125
OVER HERE TO THE MICROPHONE. YOU
00:19:53.191 --> 00:19:58.463
HAVE TWO MINUTES. MORNING SENATE
00:19:58.530 --> 00:19:59.831
CHAIR LEAVING EDUCATION
00:19:59.898 --> 00:20:01.400
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
00:20:01.466 --> 00:20:02.968
YVETTE HERNANDEZ, AND I'M, A
00:20:03.035 --> 00:20:04.836
FIRST GENERATION 30 YEAR STUDENT
00:20:04.903 --> 00:20:05.971
AT UC BERKELEY, WHERE I'M
00:20:06.038 --> 00:20:06.972
STUDYING PUBLIC HEALTH AND
00:20:07.039 --> 00:20:09.841
PUBLIC POLICY. I'M HERE TO TALK
00:20:09.908 --> 00:20:10.776
ABOUT MY EXPERIENCE PAYING FOR
00:20:10.842 --> 00:20:12.311
HIGHER EDUCATION, ALTHOUGH THERE
00:20:12.377 --> 00:20:13.745
HAVE BEEN EXPANSIONS TO
00:20:13.812 --> 00:20:15.581
FINANCIAL AID COLLEGE IS STILL
00:20:15.647 --> 00:20:16.148
VERY EXPENSIVE FOR MANY LOW
00:20:16.214 --> 00:20:18.684
INCOME STUDENTS LIKE MYSELF. AS
00:20:18.750 --> 00:20:20.719
A RESULT, MANY OF US ALSO RELY
00:20:20.786 --> 00:20:21.720
ON THE SCHOLARSHIPS THAT WE
00:20:21.787 --> 00:20:24.256
EARNED TO AFFORD THE NON TUITION
00:20:24.323 --> 00:20:25.724
COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE HIGHER
00:20:25.791 --> 00:20:28.026
EDUCATION. BUT MORE THAN ONCE I
00:20:28.093 --> 00:20:28.994
HAVE EXPERIENCED SCHOLARSHIP
00:20:29.061 --> 00:20:31.563
DISPLACEMENT. AND HAVE EVEN HAD
00:20:31.630 --> 00:20:33.432
TO POSTPONE RECEIVING MY DELL
00:20:33.498 --> 00:20:34.433
SCHOLARSHIP BECAUSE IT WOULD
00:20:34.499 --> 00:20:36.568
ALSO BE DISPLACED. THIS IS SPICE
00:20:36.635 --> 00:20:38.170
MEANT MEANS THAT WHENEVER I EARN
00:20:38.236 --> 00:20:39.705
A SCHOLARSHIP, I RECEIVED LESS
00:20:39.771 --> 00:20:41.306
FINANCIAL AID BECAUSE THE
00:20:41.373 --> 00:20:42.608
UNIVERSITY FEELS I NO LONGER
00:20:42.674 --> 00:20:44.676
NEED THAT FULL AMOUNT. PROMISE.
00:20:44.743 --> 00:20:46.311
BUT I DO AND IT'S REALLY
00:20:46.378 --> 00:20:47.312
DISAPPOINTING BECAUSE IT CREATES
00:20:47.379 --> 00:20:49.815
MORE FINANCIAL STRESS ON ME.
00:20:49.881 --> 00:20:51.316
SCHOLARSHIPS THAT I'VE EARNED
00:20:51.383 --> 00:20:53.018
ARE CRUCIAL FOR ME BECAUSE THEY
00:20:53.085 --> 00:20:53.819
HELPED ME PAY FOR MY
00:20:53.885 --> 00:20:55.854
TRANSPORTATION COSTS TO TRAVEL
00:20:55.921 --> 00:20:56.989
FROM MY HOME IN EL MONTE,
00:20:57.055 --> 00:20:59.024
CALIFORNIA ALL THE WAY TO C
00:20:59.091 --> 00:21:01.426
BERKELEY. THEY HELPED ME PAY FOR
00:21:01.493 --> 00:21:02.427
MY EXPENSIVE TEXTBOOKS AND
00:21:02.494 --> 00:21:04.196
DIGITAL COURSE MATERIALS. USING
00:21:04.262 --> 00:21:06.632
TODAY'S CLASSES, MANY OF WHICH
00:21:06.698 --> 00:21:08.033
REQUIRE ACCESS CODES TO PROGRAMS
00:21:08.100 --> 00:21:10.202
THAT I NEED TO DO MY EXAMS AND
00:21:10.268 --> 00:21:13.538
pTHAT I CANNOT GET THESE ACCESS
00:21:13.605 --> 00:21:15.307
CODES FROM USE TEXTBOOKS. MOST
00:21:15.374 --> 00:21:16.708
IMPORTANTLY, THESE SCHOLARSHIPS
00:21:16.775 --> 00:21:18.043
HELPED ME PAY FOR NECESSITIES
00:21:18.110 --> 00:21:20.212
LIKE MY FOOD AND MY HOUSING AS
00:21:20.278 --> 00:21:21.713
THE FIRST OF MY FAMILY TO STUDY
00:21:21.780 --> 00:21:23.548
AT A UNIVERSITY. IT'S IMPORTANT
00:21:23.615 --> 00:21:25.150
THAT I CAN AFFORD THE COST OF
00:21:25.217 --> 00:21:27.119
GOING TO SCHOOL TO GRADUATE AND
00:21:27.185 --> 00:21:29.187
GIVE BACK TO MY COMMUNITY. AMONG
00:21:29.254 --> 00:21:30.589
MY PEERS. IT'S COMMON KNOWLEDGE
00:21:30.656 --> 00:21:32.257
THAT IF WE RECIPIENTS OF
00:21:32.324 --> 00:21:33.158
SCHOLARSHIPS AND THE REPORTED TO
00:21:33.225 --> 00:21:35.193
THE SCHOOL, WE WOULD NEVER SEE
00:21:35.260 --> 00:21:36.595
THAT MONEY AND CONTINUE HAVING
00:21:36.662 --> 00:21:38.764
FINANCIAL DIFFICULTIES. IT'S SO
00:21:38.830 --> 00:21:39.865
IMPORTANT THAT WE'RE ABLE TO
00:21:39.931 --> 00:21:41.767
KEEP OUR SCHOLARSHIPS TO PAY FOR
00:21:41.833 --> 00:21:43.001
THESE NON TUITION COSTS. THERE
00:21:43.068 --> 00:21:44.202
AREN'T BEING ACCURATELY
00:21:44.269 --> 00:21:46.138
CALCULATED BY UNIVERSITIES. I
00:21:46.204 --> 00:21:47.572
RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT YOU ALL
00:21:47.639 --> 00:21:49.941
PLEASE VOTE YES, ON 80 TO 88 FOR
00:21:50.008 --> 00:21:52.210
ME AND FOR THE THOUSANDS OF
00:21:52.277 --> 00:21:53.478
STUDENTS AFFECTED BY SCHOLARSHIP
00:21:53.545 --> 00:21:54.246
DISPLACEMENT, CALIFORNIA THANK
00:21:54.312 --> 00:21:57.582
YOU. THANK YOU, MS. HERNANDEZ
00:21:57.649 --> 00:21:58.817
MR. MODERATOR COULD YOU PLEASE
00:21:58.884 --> 00:22:02.554
QUEUE UP CALL WAS LOW. OH YOU'RE
00:22:02.621 --> 00:22:04.289
HERE IN PERSON WOULD BE GREAT IF
00:22:04.356 --> 00:22:05.757
I COULD READ MY NOTES. WELCOME
00:22:05.824 --> 00:22:07.359
MR LOWE. PLEASE PROCEED WHEN
00:22:07.426 --> 00:22:08.593
YOU'RE READY. THANK YOU SO MUCH
00:22:08.660 --> 00:22:10.162
GOOD MORNING CHAIR, LEVA AND
00:22:10.228 --> 00:22:11.063
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE. MY
00:22:11.129 --> 00:22:13.198
NAME IS CALVIN SLOW AND I SERVED
00:22:13.265 --> 00:22:15.067
AS A DIRECTOR OF POLICY. FOR
00:22:15.133 --> 00:22:15.600
SCHOLARSHIP AMERICA, THE
00:22:15.667 --> 00:22:17.102
NATION'S LARGEST PRIVATE
00:22:17.169 --> 00:22:18.770
SCHOLARSHIP PROVIDER, WE PARTNER
00:22:18.837 --> 00:22:20.872
WITH OVER 1400 CORPORATIONS,
00:22:20.939 --> 00:22:22.340
FOUNDATIONS AND PHILANTHROPIC
00:22:22.407 --> 00:22:24.142
INDIVIDUALS TO DELIVER NEARLY
00:22:24.209 --> 00:22:25.310
$300 MILLION IN SCHOLARSHIPS
00:22:25.377 --> 00:22:28.380
EVERY YEAR. OF WHICH $25 MILLION
00:22:28.447 --> 00:22:30.215
GOES TO RECORD STUDENTS HERE IN
00:22:30.282 --> 00:22:33.085
CALIFORNIA. I'M ALSO HERE TODAY,
00:22:33.151 --> 00:22:33.985
JOINED BY THE NORTHERN
00:22:34.052 --> 00:22:35.320
CALIFORNIA COLLEGE PROMISE
00:22:35.387 --> 00:22:36.855
COALITION AND THE SOUTHERN
00:22:36.922 --> 00:22:37.723
CALIFORNIA COLLEGE ACCESS
00:22:37.789 --> 00:22:39.858
NETWORK, AS CO SPONSORS OF A B 2
00:22:39.925 --> 00:22:42.027
88, AS WELL AS THE OVER 300
00:22:42.094 --> 00:22:43.061
ORGANIZATIONS AND INDIVIDUALS
00:22:43.128 --> 00:22:46.364
WHO ALSO SUPPORT THE BILL. A B 2
00:22:46.431 --> 00:22:48.467
88 PROTECTS STUDENTS WHO ARE
00:22:48.533 --> 00:22:49.935
ELIGIBLE, AND THERE WAS TO
00:22:50.001 --> 00:22:51.770
QUALIFY FOR ASSISTANCE UNDER THE
00:22:51.837 --> 00:22:53.171
CALIFORNIA DREAM BACK. IT WOULD
00:22:53.238 --> 00:22:55.207
GUARANTEE THAT CALIFORNIA'S MOST
00:22:55.273 --> 00:22:56.808
VULNERABLE STUDENTS WILL BENEFIT
00:22:56.875 --> 00:22:58.710
FROM GRANTS AND SCHOLARSHIPS THE
00:22:58.777 --> 00:22:59.911
WAY THEY ARE INTENDED TO SUPPORT
00:22:59.978 --> 00:23:01.780
STUDENTS WHEN SCHOLARSHIP
00:23:01.847 --> 00:23:03.348
DISPLACEMENT OCCURS IN THAT ONLY
00:23:03.415 --> 00:23:05.617
RESULT IN A ZERO NET GAIN FOR
00:23:05.684 --> 00:23:07.519
STUDENTS WHO PUT IN THE WORK TO
00:23:07.586 --> 00:23:08.320
EARN SCHOLARSHIPS. BUT IT ALSO
00:23:08.386 --> 00:23:09.187
DISCOURAGES STUDENTS FROM
00:23:09.254 --> 00:23:10.956
APPLYING FOR AID WHEN THE
00:23:11.022 --> 00:23:11.757
EXPERIENCE OR LEARN OF
00:23:11.823 --> 00:23:13.258
SCHOLARSHIP DISPLACEMENT FROM
00:23:13.325 --> 00:23:15.260
PEERS. ADDITIONALLY SCHOLARSHIP
00:23:15.327 --> 00:23:16.394
DISPLACEMENT DISRUPTS THE
00:23:16.461 --> 00:23:17.129
MISSION OF SCHOLARSHIP
00:23:17.195 --> 00:23:18.330
PROVIDERS, WHICH IS TO MAKE
00:23:18.396 --> 00:23:19.064
HIGHER EDUCATION MORE
00:23:19.131 --> 00:23:20.065
AFFORDABLE. AND REDUCE STUDENT
00:23:20.132 --> 00:23:23.668
DEBT. ESTATE IN THE BILL. FACT
00:23:23.735 --> 00:23:25.971
SHEET MORE THAN 95% OF STUDENTS
00:23:26.037 --> 00:23:27.672
PURSUING A BACHELOR'S DEGREE IN
00:23:27.739 --> 00:23:29.040
CALIFORNIA WHO COME FROM
00:23:29.107 --> 00:23:30.609
FAMILIES WITH INCOMES OF LESS
00:23:30.675 --> 00:23:32.577
THAN $50,000 HAVE UNMET
00:23:32.644 --> 00:23:34.246
FINANCIAL NEED ON AVERAGE OF
00:23:34.312 --> 00:23:37.048
$9000, ACCORDING TO THE NATIONAL
00:23:37.115 --> 00:23:38.150
POST SECONDARY STUDENT AID STUDY
00:23:38.216 --> 00:23:40.719
DATA. AS WE HAVE JUST LEARNED
00:23:40.786 --> 00:23:42.454
FROM THE VET JUST MOMENTS AGO,
00:23:42.521 --> 00:23:43.822
STUDENTS NEED ALL OF THE EIGHTH
00:23:43.889 --> 00:23:45.190
THEY'RE AWARDED. WE'RE SIMPLY
00:23:45.257 --> 00:23:46.858
ASKING FOR SCHOLARSHIPS FOR THE
00:23:46.925 --> 00:23:48.360
HIGHEST NEED STUDENTS TO BE
00:23:48.426 --> 00:23:49.795
TREATED SIMILAR TO THE PELL
00:23:49.861 --> 00:23:50.796
GRANT, WHERE FEDERAL REGULATIONS
00:23:50.862 --> 00:23:51.830
PROHIBIT PEOPLE FROM BEING
00:23:51.897 --> 00:23:54.833
DISPLACED. WE THINK
00:23:54.900 --> 00:23:56.401
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CALDERON AND
00:23:56.468 --> 00:23:57.602
BONTA AND SENATOR LIMÓN FOR
00:23:57.669 --> 00:23:59.371
SERVING AS CO AUTHORS OF THE
00:23:59.437 --> 00:24:01.373
BILL. WE URGE AND I VOTE FOR
00:24:01.439 --> 00:24:03.341
MEMBERS OF THIS COMMITTEE. THANK
00:24:03.408 --> 00:24:04.376
YOU, AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO ANY
00:24:04.442 --> 00:24:04.976
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. THANK
00:24:05.043 --> 00:24:06.578
YOU, MR LOW. ALRIGHT MR
00:24:06.645 --> 00:24:07.646
MODERATOR, COULD YOU PLEASE
00:24:07.712 --> 00:24:09.581
QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
00:24:09.648 --> 00:24:11.583
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 2 88?
00:24:11.650 --> 00:24:14.352
WITH THAT. IF YOU THINK YOU
00:24:14.419 --> 00:24:15.987
MADAM CHAIR IF YOU ARE, MR ROD
00:24:16.054 --> 00:24:17.622
AERATOR, I'M VERY SORRY. I'M
00:24:17.689 --> 00:24:20.325
CLEARLY NOT ON MY GAME TODAY. UH
00:24:20.392 --> 00:24:21.626
ANYONE IN SUPPORT IN ROOM 2100.
00:24:21.693 --> 00:24:26.364
PLEASE COME FORWARD. THANK YOU,
00:24:26.431 --> 00:24:27.833
CHAIR AND MEMBERS ON BEHALF OF
00:24:27.899 --> 00:24:29.401
MOUNT SAN ANTONIO COLLEGE AND
00:24:29.467 --> 00:24:30.168
NORTH ORANGE COUNTY COMMUNITY
00:24:30.235 --> 00:24:31.102
COLLEGE DISTRICT AND SUPPORT.
00:24:31.169 --> 00:24:35.240
THANK YOU. MADAM CHAIR SENATORS,
00:24:35.307 --> 00:24:36.208
MICHAEL YOUNG WITH THE
00:24:36.274 --> 00:24:37.209
CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF
00:24:37.275 --> 00:24:38.276
TEACHERS. ALSO HEARING SUPPORT.
00:24:38.343 --> 00:24:40.645
THANK YOU. FOR COMING.
00:24:40.712 --> 00:24:41.479
ALESSANDRA HALF OF THE EDUCATION
00:24:41.546 --> 00:24:45.150
TRUST WEST AND SUPPORT. JOSHUA
00:24:45.217 --> 00:24:46.318
HIGGINS ON BEHALF OF THE
00:24:46.384 --> 00:24:47.552
CAMPAIGN FOR COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY
00:24:47.619 --> 00:24:50.522
AND SUPPORT. MORNING JASON
00:24:50.589 --> 00:24:52.023
VASQUEZ ON BEHALF OF THE
00:24:52.090 --> 00:24:52.724
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COLLEGE
00:24:52.791 --> 00:24:55.126
ACCESS NETWORK HERE AS A AS A
00:24:55.193 --> 00:24:56.795
STRENGTH IN STRONG SUPPORT OF A
00:24:56.862 --> 00:24:58.797
B 28 ALSO CO SPONSOR OF 80 20.
00:24:58.864 --> 00:25:01.867
THANK HEY, THAT DOES WALTON,
00:25:01.933 --> 00:25:03.201
DIRECTOR OF HIGHER EDUCATION AND
00:25:03.268 --> 00:25:04.903
PUBLIC ADVOCATES IN SUPPORT OF
00:25:04.970 --> 00:25:06.805
82 88. THANK YOU. TERRIFIC THANK
00:25:06.872 --> 00:25:07.973
YOU ALL VERY MUCH. OKAY, MR
00:25:08.039 --> 00:25:09.741
MODERATOR. NOW WE'RE COMING TO
00:25:09.808 --> 00:25:12.077
YOU FOR ANYONE WHO YOU CAN QUEUE
00:25:12.143 --> 00:25:16.081
UP IN SUPPORT OF A B 2 88. THANK
00:25:16.147 --> 00:25:18.250
YOU VERY MUCH. IF YOU ARE IN
00:25:18.316 --> 00:25:20.318
SUPPORT OF A B 288 PLEASE PRESS
00:25:20.385 --> 00:25:21.319
10 AT THIS TIME ONE FOLLOWED BY
00:25:21.386 --> 00:25:23.154
ZERO. MATTER OF SHARE WILL BEGIN
00:25:23.221 --> 00:25:25.190
WITH BLIND 40 YOU ARE OPEN. GOOD
00:25:25.257 --> 00:25:26.758
MORNING, REBECCA GONZALEZ FOR
00:25:26.825 --> 00:25:27.926
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF
00:25:27.993 --> 00:25:28.860
SOCIAL WORKERS, CALIFORNIA
00:25:28.927 --> 00:25:33.431
CHAPTER IN SUPPORT. AND LINE 58.
00:25:33.498 --> 00:25:39.104
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
00:25:39.170 --> 00:25:40.772
AND ALVARADO ON BEHALF OF THE
00:25:40.839 --> 00:25:41.773
CALIFORNIA COALITION AND STRONG
00:25:41.840 --> 00:25:49.447
SUPPORT. 9 38, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:25:49.514 --> 00:25:50.949
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS CINDY
00:25:51.016 --> 00:25:53.285
LEE AND I'M CALLING ON BEHALF OF
00:25:53.351 --> 00:25:54.886
THE LOS ANGELES AREA CHAMBER OF
00:25:54.953 --> 00:25:56.855
COMMERCE IN SUPPORT OF A B 28.
00:25:56.922 --> 00:26:01.826
THANK YOU. AND NEXT WE HAVE
00:26:01.893 --> 00:26:05.497
WINE. 61, YOU ARE OPEN. GOOD
00:26:05.563 --> 00:26:06.698
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
00:26:06.765 --> 00:26:07.966
COMMITTEE MEMBERS, COLLIN HOLLY
00:26:08.033 --> 00:26:09.868
ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF WEST
00:26:09.935 --> 00:26:11.903
SACRAMENTO IN SUPPORT. 42,
00:26:11.970 --> 00:26:18.343
PLEASE GO AHEAD. 42. WOULD YOU
00:26:18.410 --> 00:26:24.215
LIKE TO. MY APOLOGIES, MADAM
00:26:24.282 --> 00:26:26.351
CHAIR, HENNEBERG SAID WITH THE
00:26:26.418 --> 00:26:27.485
CAL STATE ASSOCIATION AND STRONG
00:26:27.552 --> 00:26:34.025
SUPPORT 56, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 56
00:26:34.092 --> 00:26:39.597
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. ONE MORE SHOT
00:26:39.664 --> 00:26:42.701
LIKE 56, PLEASE. I'M YOU. HI
00:26:42.767 --> 00:26:44.769
SORRY I HEARD MY NUMBER WRONG.
00:26:44.836 --> 00:26:47.706
UM HI, KIMBERLY WILL INCOMING
00:26:47.772 --> 00:26:48.773
SENIOR EASY BERKELEY AND A
00:26:48.840 --> 00:26:50.108
REPRESENTATIVE OF JENNA
00:26:50.175 --> 00:26:51.943
REPRESENTS A 4000 ACROSS THE
00:26:52.010 --> 00:26:53.311
STATE AND WE ARE STRONG SPELL.
00:26:53.378 --> 00:27:01.319
THANK YOU. 52 YOU ARE OPEN. HI
00:27:01.386 --> 00:27:02.287
ALISA. GUEST ME. I'M AN
00:27:02.354 --> 00:27:04.322
INSTRUCTOR AT CERRITOS COLLEGE
00:27:04.389 --> 00:27:05.890
IN NORWALK. AND I'M CALLING IN
00:27:05.957 --> 00:27:07.058
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL FOR MY
00:27:07.125 --> 00:27:15.200
STUDENTS. 9 11, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
00:27:15.266 --> 00:27:16.334
GOOD MORNING. MY NAME IS
00:27:16.401 --> 00:27:17.936
MICHELLE WAXMAN JOHNSTON. I'M
00:27:18.003 --> 00:27:21.239
CEO OF ALL SORTS PARTNERS LLC,
00:27:21.306 --> 00:27:21.940
INTERNATIONAL CONSULTANT AND
00:27:22.007 --> 00:27:23.341
ADVOCATE IN THE SCHOLARSHIP
00:27:23.408 --> 00:27:24.743
INDUSTRY. I AM PLEASED TO
00:27:24.809 --> 00:27:26.911
SUPPORT A B 2 88. THANK YOU.
00:27:26.978 --> 00:27:32.951
THANK YOU. 62 YOU ARE UP. GOOD
00:27:33.018 --> 00:27:34.352
MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:27:34.419 --> 00:27:36.855
ME ANGELA REID ON BEHALF OF THE
00:27:36.921 --> 00:27:37.922
WESTERN ASSOCIATION FOR COLLEGE
00:27:37.989 --> 00:27:38.757
ADMISSION, COUNSELING AND STROKE
00:27:38.823 --> 00:27:39.824
SUPPORTIVELY BETWEEN 2 80. THANK
00:27:39.891 --> 00:27:46.331
YOU. 63, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
00:27:46.398 --> 00:27:49.067
MORNING, PETER STEIN FROM
00:27:49.134 --> 00:27:51.536
FULFILLMENT FUND AND WOMEN FOR
00:27:51.603 --> 00:27:52.470
AMERICAN VALUES AND ETHICS IN
00:27:52.537 --> 00:27:56.808
SUPPORT. THANKS. I'LL GIVE THE
00:27:56.875 --> 00:27:58.209
FINAL REMINDER, PLEASE PRESS
00:27:58.276 --> 00:28:00.245
ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO TO TESTIFY
00:28:00.311 --> 00:28:02.080
IN SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 2 88. 9 59,
00:28:02.147 --> 00:28:06.384
YOU ARE OPEN. GOOD MORNING,
00:28:06.451 --> 00:28:07.852
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS RON
00:28:07.919 --> 00:28:09.421
WRAPPED, SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF
00:28:09.487 --> 00:28:10.221
THE CALIFORNIA FACULTY
00:28:10.288 --> 00:28:12.390
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT OF A B 2
00:28:12.457 --> 00:28:15.560
88. THANK YOU. 9 60, PLEASE GO
00:28:15.627 --> 00:28:20.198
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MELISSA
00:28:20.265 --> 00:28:21.299
BARDO ON BEHALF OF THE
00:28:21.366 --> 00:28:23.268
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES,
00:28:23.334 --> 00:28:24.302
CHANCELLOR'S OFFICE AND SUPPORT
00:28:24.369 --> 00:28:28.606
OF A B 2 88. LINE 50. YOU ARE
00:28:28.673 --> 00:28:33.411
ALWAYS. MORNING SENATE EDUCATION
00:28:33.478 --> 00:28:34.779
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
00:28:34.846 --> 00:28:36.481
MEREDITH CURRY, NUNES AND I'M
00:28:36.548 --> 00:28:37.715
CALLING US THE EXECUTIVE
00:28:37.782 --> 00:28:38.583
DIRECTOR OF THE NORTHERN
00:28:38.650 --> 00:28:39.417
CALIFORNIA COLLEGE PROMISED
00:28:39.484 --> 00:28:41.186
COALITION TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR
00:28:41.252 --> 00:28:46.057
ABBY TO 88. AND WE DO HAVE ONE
00:28:46.124 --> 00:28:47.192
MORE QUEUING UP ONE MOMENT,
00:28:47.258 --> 00:28:55.333
PLEASE. AND WE WILL GO TO LINE.
00:28:55.400 --> 00:28:56.634
WELL THERE WITH AN OPERATOR 15
00:28:56.701 --> 00:29:00.672
65, YOUR LINE NUMBER SIX. 9 65,
00:29:00.738 --> 00:29:06.878
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING.
00:29:06.945 --> 00:29:08.780
MY NAME IS JONATHAN COLON WITH
00:29:08.847 --> 00:29:09.714
HAYWARD PROMISED NEIGHBORHOOD
00:29:09.781 --> 00:29:11.850
ACCOUNTS CITY STATE. I'M ALSO
00:29:11.916 --> 00:29:12.817
REPRESENTING THE CITY OF
00:29:12.884 --> 00:29:17.188
HAYWARD. AS WELL AS ON THE TRUST
00:29:17.255 --> 00:29:17.822
KEPER ALAMEDA COUNTY PEOPLE OR
00:29:17.889 --> 00:29:20.492
THE EDUCATION AND CALLING ASKING
00:29:20.558 --> 00:29:24.963
FOR THE SUPPORT OF 80 TO 88. AND
00:29:25.029 --> 00:29:26.698
SAY THAT WHEN OUR STUDENTS
00:29:26.764 --> 00:29:28.433
RECEIVE THANK YOU VERY MUCH NEXT
00:29:28.500 --> 00:29:32.203
NEXT CALLER, PLEASE FUNDING
00:29:32.270 --> 00:29:33.338
MADAM CHAIR THERE. NO OTHER
00:29:33.404 --> 00:29:34.839
PARTICIPANTS QUEUED UP. THANK
00:29:34.906 --> 00:29:36.741
YOU, MR MODERATOR. WE ME NO
00:29:36.808 --> 00:29:38.276
LEADS. OPPOSITION LISTED. IS
00:29:38.343 --> 00:29:40.378
THERE ANYONE HERE IN ROOM 2100
00:29:40.445 --> 00:29:41.913
WHO WISHES TO OPPOSE SEEING
00:29:41.980 --> 00:29:42.981
THAT, MR MODERATOR, WE'RE COMING
00:29:43.047 --> 00:29:45.717
BACK TO YOU. YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP
00:29:45.783 --> 00:29:48.453
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO SPEAK IN
00:29:48.520 --> 00:29:51.556
OPPOSITION OF A B 288. IF YOU
00:29:51.623 --> 00:29:53.558
ARE IN OPPOSITION TO A B 2 80,
00:29:53.625 --> 00:29:57.662
PLEASE PRESS 10. ONE TALL BY
00:29:57.729 --> 00:30:02.700
ZERO FOR OPPOSITION TO HB 2 88.
00:30:02.767 --> 00:30:04.102
BUDDY IS QUEUING UP, MADAM.
00:30:04.169 --> 00:30:05.203
SURE. TERRIFIC THANK YOU VERY
00:30:05.270 --> 00:30:06.971
MUCH. ALRIGHT, WE'RE GOING TO
00:30:07.038 --> 00:30:08.106
BRING IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE
00:30:08.173 --> 00:30:10.008
MOVED THE BILL. SENATOR PAN HAS
00:30:10.074 --> 00:30:11.609
MOVED THE BILL AND THE OTHER
00:30:11.676 --> 00:30:12.644
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS
00:30:12.710 --> 00:30:14.679
SEEING. YES, SENATOR GLASER.
00:30:14.746 --> 00:30:17.248
YEAH I CERTAINLY AM AN AGREEMENT
00:30:17.315 --> 00:30:18.783
WITH THE BROADER GOALS THAT YOUR
00:30:18.850 --> 00:30:20.451
BILL TRIES TO ACCOMPLISH. I
00:30:20.518 --> 00:30:21.619
DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S ANYBODY
00:30:21.686 --> 00:30:23.521
FROM THE CSU OR YOU SEE HERE IN
00:30:23.588 --> 00:30:24.689
THE IN THE HEARING ROOM THAT
00:30:24.756 --> 00:30:27.225
COULD SPEAK TO THE CHOICES THAT
00:30:27.292 --> 00:30:27.959
THEY MAKE IN THIS SPACE. IF
00:30:28.026 --> 00:30:29.727
THERE IS MAYBE THEY COULD
00:30:29.794 --> 00:30:31.162
INDICATE IF NOT TO THE AUTHOR.
00:30:31.229 --> 00:30:33.198
WHAT CONFUSES ME A LITTLE BIT.
00:30:33.264 --> 00:30:36.834
IS THAT, UM IS THIS A POTENTIAL
00:30:36.901 --> 00:30:38.102
WHERE A STUDENT WHO IS ELIGIBLE
00:30:38.169 --> 00:30:41.539
FOR AID? MIGHT NOT BE ABLE TO
00:30:41.606 --> 00:30:43.107
GET IT BECAUSE THE INSTITUTION
00:30:43.174 --> 00:30:45.510
THAT HAS RUN OUT OF MONEY FOR
00:30:45.577 --> 00:30:47.879
FINANCIAL AID. BECAUSE OF THE
00:30:47.946 --> 00:30:48.947
ENHANCEMENTS THAT YOUR BILL
00:30:49.013 --> 00:30:52.784
TRIES TO ALLOW CHURCH AND MR LOW
00:30:52.850 --> 00:30:59.857
ON THAT. SO IN WORKING ON THIS
00:30:59.924 --> 00:31:01.526
BILL, WE CONSULTED WITH THE
00:31:01.593 --> 00:31:03.595
AMERICAN INDEPENDENT CALIFORNIA
00:31:03.661 --> 00:31:05.230
COLLEGES, UNIVERSITIES, THE C S,
00:31:05.296 --> 00:31:08.099
U. S AND THE U. C S AND WE HAVE
00:31:08.166 --> 00:31:09.234
GOT ALL THE CONCERNS THAT
00:31:09.300 --> 00:31:10.001
THEY'VE RAISED. HAVE BEEN
00:31:10.068 --> 00:31:11.536
REFLECTED IN THE AMENDMENTS IN
00:31:11.603 --> 00:31:12.870
THE ASSEMBLY AND THE BILL BEFORE
00:31:12.937 --> 00:31:13.972
THIS COMMITTEE, AND THAT IS NOT
00:31:14.038 --> 00:31:15.873
A CONCERN OF THAT. THAT YOU SEE
00:31:15.940 --> 00:31:18.176
THE C. S U. S OR THE INDEPENDENT
00:31:18.243 --> 00:31:20.011
COLLEGES HAVE RAISED SO FAR SO
00:31:20.078 --> 00:31:21.212
CAN YOU SPEAK TO MY QUESTION
00:31:21.279 --> 00:31:24.082
DIRECTLY NOW, WHICH IS THAT? UH
00:31:24.148 --> 00:31:25.750
IS THE AMOUNTOF MONEY THAT'S
00:31:25.817 --> 00:31:27.785
PROVIDED IN THESE KINDS OF
00:31:27.852 --> 00:31:30.888
GRANTS. I FIXED AMOUNT IN OTHER
00:31:30.955 --> 00:31:33.791
WORDS, IF OR IS IT PREDICT FOR
00:31:33.858 --> 00:31:35.526
THOSE ELIGIBLE UNDER THIS BILL,
00:31:35.593 --> 00:31:36.961
IT SAID THAT THERE IS PLENTY OF
00:31:37.028 --> 00:31:38.896
MONEY TO GO FOR EVERYBODY THAT
00:31:38.963 --> 00:31:40.665
THAT MEETS THE ELIGIBILITY. BUT
00:31:40.732 --> 00:31:42.033
COULD THERE BE A SITUATION
00:31:42.100 --> 00:31:43.234
WHEREBY THE ENHANCED GRANTS THIS
00:31:43.301 --> 00:31:45.503
BILL WOULD PROVIDE THAT IT WOULD
00:31:45.570 --> 00:31:47.372
TAKE MONEY AWAY FROM ANOTHER
00:31:47.438 --> 00:31:49.674
NEEDY STUDENT FOR TUITION OR
00:31:49.741 --> 00:31:51.709
FEES OR SOMETHING TO THAT EFFECT
00:31:51.776 --> 00:31:52.844
. I CANNOT SPEAK FOR THE
00:31:52.910 --> 00:31:54.712
INSTITUTIONS, BUT THE GOAL OF
00:31:54.779 --> 00:31:56.514
THIS BILL IS TO PROTECT THE
00:31:56.581 --> 00:31:57.448
HIGHEST NEED. STUDENTS WERE
00:31:57.515 --> 00:31:58.750
TALKING ABOUT THE NEEDIEST OF
00:31:58.816 --> 00:32:00.752
THE NEEDY STUDENTS. I UNDERSTAND
00:32:00.818 --> 00:32:01.719
THAT, BUT I'M ASKING VERY
00:32:01.786 --> 00:32:02.620
SPECIFIC QUESTIONS. SO I GUESS
00:32:02.687 --> 00:32:05.156
I'D GO BACK TO THE AUTHOR AND
00:32:05.223 --> 00:32:06.391
ASK IS THERE ANYONE HERE THAT
00:32:06.457 --> 00:32:07.892
THANK YOU, MR LOWE? IN TERMS OF
00:32:07.959 --> 00:32:09.694
THE INSTITUTIONS AND THEIR POT
00:32:09.761 --> 00:32:10.995
OF MONEY AND HOW THIS WOULD
00:32:11.062 --> 00:32:12.530
AFFECT THAT PART OF MONEY FOR
00:32:12.597 --> 00:32:13.965
THE OTHER NEEDY STUDENTS. SO
00:32:14.032 --> 00:32:16.301
THERE'S NOBODY IN THE ROOM THAT
00:32:16.367 --> 00:32:17.669
CAN ANSWER THAT. BUT I WILL FIND
00:32:17.735 --> 00:32:19.070
OUT THE ANSWER. I DON'T KNOW. I
00:32:19.137 --> 00:32:19.837
APPRECIATE THAT VERY MUCH,
00:32:19.904 --> 00:32:22.073
BECAUSE I THINK THE GOALS OF
00:32:22.140 --> 00:32:22.640
YOUR BILL OR MERITORIOUS FOR
00:32:22.707 --> 00:32:24.442
SURE, BUT I'M JUST TRYING TO
00:32:24.509 --> 00:32:24.909
UNDERSTAND UNINTENDED
00:32:24.976 --> 00:32:26.611
CONSEQUENCES. RIGHT THERE'S A
00:32:26.678 --> 00:32:27.912
FIXED AMOUNT OF MONEY AND THIS
00:32:27.979 --> 00:32:28.980
MEANS ANOTHER NEEDY STUDENT
00:32:29.047 --> 00:32:30.948
DOESN'T GET IT. AND LOOK, LOOK
00:32:31.015 --> 00:32:32.550
AT YOU HAVE TO ACKNOWLEDGE AND
00:32:32.617 --> 00:32:34.218
RECOGNIZE THE EXCELLENCE THAT IS
00:32:34.285 --> 00:32:35.386
PROVIDED FOR THESE TYPES OF
00:32:35.453 --> 00:32:37.488
PRIVATE FINANCIAL AID.
00:32:37.555 --> 00:32:38.956
SCHOLARSHIPS GIFTS. HOWEVER, YOU
00:32:39.023 --> 00:32:41.092
WANT TO REFER TO THEM. THAT'S A
00:32:41.159 --> 00:32:41.993
STUDENT WORKING HARD AND
00:32:42.060 --> 00:32:43.761
DESERVING OF THAT KNOWLEDGE
00:32:43.828 --> 00:32:45.129
RECOGNITION, BUT THAT SUPPORT
00:32:45.196 --> 00:32:47.098
I'M JUST TRYING TO UNDERSTAND
00:32:47.165 --> 00:32:47.999
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES. TRUE
00:32:48.066 --> 00:32:50.168
AND I WILL JUST SAY THAT THE
00:32:50.234 --> 00:32:52.103
COLLEGE FINANCIAL AID IT'S SO
00:32:52.170 --> 00:32:53.971
COMPLEX SO I WOULD BE TO ASK
00:32:54.038 --> 00:32:57.709
BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW HOW. THAT
00:32:57.775 --> 00:32:59.210
THAT WORKS. THAT'S SO I WILL
00:32:59.277 --> 00:33:00.812
FIND OUT RIGHT? I'M GOING TO
00:33:00.878 --> 00:33:01.946
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY, BUT I
00:33:02.013 --> 00:33:03.815
WOULD ASK IF THERE COULD BE
00:33:03.881 --> 00:33:05.583
FOLLOW UP FROM THE INSTITUTIONS
00:33:05.650 --> 00:33:07.151
TO BE CLEAR ON THAT QUESTION.
00:33:07.218 --> 00:33:07.819
THANK YOU SO MUCH. YOU'RE
00:33:07.885 --> 00:33:08.986
WELCOME. $100 A MADAM CHAIR. SO
00:33:09.053 --> 00:33:12.056
ON PAGE FIVE SPECIFICALLY IF A
00:33:12.123 --> 00:33:13.291
STUDENT IS PROVIDED WITH $1000
00:33:13.358 --> 00:33:16.027
SCHOLARSHIP. THE COLLEGE MAY
00:33:16.094 --> 00:33:16.894
DETERMINE THAT THE STUDENTS
00:33:16.961 --> 00:33:19.597
FINANCIAL NEED HAS BEEN REDUCED
00:33:19.664 --> 00:33:21.933
BY 1000. THIS OFTEN OCCURS IF A
00:33:21.999 --> 00:33:23.634
STUDENT IS DEEMED OVER AWARDED,
00:33:23.701 --> 00:33:26.204
MEANING THAT ALL OF THE STUDENTS
00:33:26.270 --> 00:33:28.740
MEANING, MEANING THAT ALL OF THE
00:33:28.806 --> 00:33:29.240
STUDENTS SCHOLARSHIP AND
00:33:29.307 --> 00:33:30.908
FINANCIAL AIDS EXCEED THE TOTAL
00:33:30.975 --> 00:33:32.543
COST OF ATTENDANCE AT THE
00:33:32.610 --> 00:33:34.712
COLLEGE. WHEN THIS HAPPENS, THE
00:33:34.779 --> 00:33:36.214
COLLEGE MAY DECIDE TO REDUCE
00:33:36.280 --> 00:33:37.448
THEIR INSTITUTIONAL AID BY A
00:33:37.515 --> 00:33:39.951
SIMILAR AMOUNT AND PROVIDE THAT
00:33:40.017 --> 00:33:41.753
MONEY TO ANOTHER STUDENT WHO
00:33:41.819 --> 00:33:43.421
STILL HAS A NET MEETS. SO THAT'S
00:33:43.488 --> 00:33:49.026
I THINK. PART OF THE ANSWER TO
00:33:49.093 --> 00:33:50.128
THE QUESTION. I THINK THE
00:33:50.194 --> 00:33:52.397
SENATOR WAS ASKING I THINK SO,
00:33:52.463 --> 00:33:54.198
TOO LITTLE BIT CONFUSED, TOO,
00:33:54.265 --> 00:33:56.968
AND ACTUALLY SENATOR AND I WERE
00:33:57.034 --> 00:33:58.336
TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT THE SAME
00:33:58.403 --> 00:33:59.971
EXACT QUESTION THAT SENATOR
00:34:00.037 --> 00:34:01.639
GLASER WAS ASKING, SO I DON'T
00:34:01.706 --> 00:34:04.008
THINK WE HAVE THAT ANSWER TODAY
00:34:04.075 --> 00:34:06.043
, BUT I KNOW THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN
00:34:06.110 --> 00:34:07.545
WILL FIND OUT AND GET THAT TO
00:34:07.612 --> 00:34:09.046
US. UM DID YOU WANT TO SAY
00:34:09.113 --> 00:34:11.849
SOMETHING JUST SHARE THE SAME.
00:34:11.916 --> 00:34:13.985
CONCERNSWITH MY COLLEAGUES
00:34:14.051 --> 00:34:15.486
HERE, AND WE WERE I WAS TRYING
00:34:15.553 --> 00:34:18.055
TO RE TRY TO SEE IF I COULD FIND
00:34:18.122 --> 00:34:18.890
THE ANSWER MYSELF. BUT SINCE WE
00:34:18.956 --> 00:34:21.592
DON'T HAVE ANYONE WILL WAIT FOR
00:34:21.659 --> 00:34:23.428
THE ANSWER. WE JUST WANT TO MAKE
00:34:23.494 --> 00:34:24.028
SURE THAT EVERYONE THAT HAS A
00:34:24.095 --> 00:34:25.863
TRUE NEED GETS THE MONEY THAT
00:34:25.930 --> 00:34:28.065
THEY NEED. AND WE HAVE, IF THE
00:34:28.132 --> 00:34:29.700
LOGIC BEHIND DISPLACEMENT WOULD
00:34:29.767 --> 00:34:31.335
BE THAT IF THEY HAVE RECEIVED
00:34:31.402 --> 00:34:32.737
THE MONEY THAT THEY NEED, THEN
00:34:32.804 --> 00:34:34.305
IT COULD GO THAT MONEY COULD
00:34:34.372 --> 00:34:36.507
THEN GO TO ANOTHER CHILD OR
00:34:36.574 --> 00:34:37.875
ANOTHER STUDENT, RIGHT? THAT
00:34:37.942 --> 00:34:39.410
WOULD NEED IT. SO OKAY, THAT'S
00:34:39.477 --> 00:34:40.912
THE ONLY THING THAT WE WANTED TO
00:34:40.978 --> 00:34:42.880
MAKE SURE THAT IS CLEAR. OKAY, I
00:34:42.947 --> 00:34:44.248
WILL FIND OUT VERY GOOD. THANK
00:34:44.315 --> 00:34:46.050
YOU. ALRIGHT SEEING NO FURTHER
00:34:46.117 --> 00:34:47.251
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS,
00:34:47.318 --> 00:34:48.853
ASSEMBLYWOMAN, YOU MAY CLOSE
00:34:48.920 --> 00:34:50.688
YOUR THANK YOU AND I WILL GET
00:34:50.755 --> 00:34:52.523
BACK TO YOU WITH THE ANSWER TO
00:34:52.590 --> 00:34:53.524
YOUR QUESTIONS. I APPRECIATE
00:34:53.591 --> 00:34:54.659
THEM AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:34:54.725 --> 00:34:57.061
A NIGHT. WE KNOW YOU WILL. IT'S
00:34:57.128 --> 00:34:59.030
NOT A PROBLEM, AND THE BILL HAS
00:34:59.096 --> 00:35:00.898
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR PAN. MADAM
00:35:00.965 --> 00:35:02.834
ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:35:02.900 --> 00:35:05.603
FILE ITEM TO A B 2 88. THE
00:35:05.670 --> 00:35:07.872
MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
00:35:07.939 --> 00:35:08.940
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
00:35:09.006 --> 00:35:10.408
APPROPRIATIONS LEVER LEVER. I
00:35:10.475 --> 00:35:11.676
CHILL BOOK BOOK I. CORTEZ E.
00:35:11.742 --> 00:35:16.981
DOLLY! SALLY I GLASER. LASER EYE
00:35:17.048 --> 00:35:20.451
FROM MCGUIRE PAN, AND I THAT
00:35:20.518 --> 00:35:22.487
BILL HAS ENOUGH VOTES TO GET
00:35:22.553 --> 00:35:24.255
OUT, BUT WE'LL KEEP IT ON CALL
00:35:24.322 --> 00:35:26.357
FOR ABSENT MEMBERS. THANK YOU,
00:35:26.424 --> 00:35:27.692
ASSEMBLYWOMAN. ALRIGHT WE ARE
00:35:27.758 --> 00:35:28.759
NOW GOING TO GO TO
00:35:28.826 --> 00:35:32.263
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MEDINA. I THINK
00:35:32.330 --> 00:35:33.464
YOU HAVE THREE BILLS BEFORE US
00:35:33.531 --> 00:35:38.669
TODAY. AND WE ARE GOING TO START
00:35:38.736 --> 00:35:42.106
WITH A B 595. PROCEED WHEN
00:35:42.173 --> 00:35:42.940
YOU'RE READY. MR
00:35:43.007 --> 00:35:45.142
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THANK YOU,
00:35:45.209 --> 00:35:49.680
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I AM
00:35:49.747 --> 00:35:52.850
PLEASED TO PRESENT A B 5 95.
00:35:52.917 --> 00:35:54.619
WHICH WILL ENSURE THAT DECISIONS
00:35:54.685 --> 00:35:56.320
DECISIONS ABOUT NEW COLLEGE
00:35:56.387 --> 00:35:57.522
ADMISSIONS PROPOSALS ARE MORE
00:35:57.588 --> 00:36:00.458
TRANSPARENT. HAVE PROPER
00:36:00.525 --> 00:36:02.860
OVERSIGHT AND IMPACT ASSESSMENTS
00:36:02.927 --> 00:36:05.196
AND COORDINATE IMPLEMENTATION
00:36:05.263 --> 00:36:07.098
PLANS WITH PUBLIC ELEMENTARY AND
00:36:07.164 --> 00:36:10.568
SECONDARY EDUCATION SYSTEMS.
00:36:10.635 --> 00:36:11.903
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITIES,
00:36:11.969 --> 00:36:13.571
CURRENTLY CONSIDERING THE
00:36:13.638 --> 00:36:14.772
ADDITION OF A NEW ADMISSIONS
00:36:14.839 --> 00:36:18.409
POLICY. THE PROPOSAL WOULD ADD
00:36:18.476 --> 00:36:19.577
ONE YEAR OF QUANTITATIVE
00:36:19.644 --> 00:36:22.013
REASONING COURSEWORK TO THE A
00:36:22.079 --> 00:36:23.481
THROUGH G SUBJECT ADMISSIONS
00:36:23.548 --> 00:36:24.348
REQUIREMENT, RAISING THE
00:36:24.415 --> 00:36:27.919
REQUIREMENTS FROM 15 YEARS. OF
00:36:27.985 --> 00:36:28.753
COMPREHENSIVE COLLEGE
00:36:28.819 --> 00:36:31.689
PREPARATORY COURSE WORK TO 16
00:36:31.756 --> 00:36:34.091
YEARS FOR THE ENTERING FRESHMAN
00:36:34.158 --> 00:36:36.594
OF THE CLASS OF 2027. THE
00:36:36.661 --> 00:36:38.296
ADDITIONAL YEAR OF QUANTITATIVE
00:36:38.362 --> 00:36:40.331
REASONING AS AN ADMISSIONS
00:36:40.398 --> 00:36:42.433
REQUIREMENT BECAUSE EXACERBATE
00:36:42.500 --> 00:36:43.834
THE VARIOUS STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT
00:36:43.901 --> 00:36:45.102
GAPS THAT THE STATE IS WORKING
00:36:45.169 --> 00:36:48.406
HARD TO OVERCOME. STUDENTS AND
00:36:48.472 --> 00:36:50.341
LOW INCOME SCHOOL DISTRICTS
00:36:50.408 --> 00:36:52.710
ALREADY LACK ACCESS TO MANY
00:36:52.777 --> 00:36:53.878
COURSES THAT ARE OFFERED TO
00:36:53.945 --> 00:36:55.680
AFFLUENT SCHOOLS. ADDING THIS
00:36:55.746 --> 00:36:58.316
REQUIREMENT. WITHOUT PROPER
00:36:58.382 --> 00:37:00.551
IMPACT ASSESSMENTS OF PRE AND
00:37:00.618 --> 00:37:03.321
POST COVID GAPS OR THE TEACHER
00:37:03.387 --> 00:37:04.889
SHORTAGE WILL EXACERBATE
00:37:04.956 --> 00:37:05.723
EXISTING INEQUITIES ACROSS
00:37:05.790 --> 00:37:09.460
CALIFORNIA. SINCE THEN, THE CSU
00:37:09.527 --> 00:37:12.229
HAS CREATED A TASK FORCE BUT THE
00:37:12.296 --> 00:37:13.698
WORK OF THE TASK FORCE AND THE
00:37:13.764 --> 00:37:16.067
INDEPENDENT ANALYSIS IS NOT
00:37:16.133 --> 00:37:17.068
RELIEVED TRANSPARENCY OR EQUITY
00:37:17.134 --> 00:37:21.639
CONCERNS. EVEN AMONG MEMBERS OF
00:37:21.706 --> 00:37:23.407
THE OVERSIGT COMMITTEE AND
00:37:23.474 --> 00:37:25.710
INSTALLED SINCE THIS BILL WAS
00:37:25.776 --> 00:37:27.445
INTRODUCED LAST YEAR, WITH NO
00:37:27.511 --> 00:37:28.913
ENDPOINT IN SIGHT IN RESPONSE TO
00:37:28.980 --> 00:37:32.683
THIS A B 5 95. WILL ESTABLISH
00:37:32.750 --> 00:37:34.752
THE FOLLOWING GUIDELINES AS THE
00:37:34.819 --> 00:37:35.786
SEGMENTS REVISIT THE NEW
00:37:35.853 --> 00:37:38.322
ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS.
00:37:38.389 --> 00:37:40.424
COLLABORATION WITH EDUCATION
00:37:40.491 --> 00:37:42.693
ENTITIES THAT WOULD BE IMPACTED
00:37:42.760 --> 00:37:45.029
BY POLICIES, POLICY CHANGES, AN
00:37:45.096 --> 00:37:47.131
INDEPENDENT THIRD PARTY STUDY ON
00:37:47.198 --> 00:37:48.199
THE POTENTIAL IMPACT THE POLICY
00:37:48.265 --> 00:37:51.936
CHANGE WOULD HAVE ON STUDENTS.
00:37:52.003 --> 00:37:52.970
PRESENTATION OF POLICY CHANGES
00:37:53.037 --> 00:37:55.406
TO THE LEGISLATURE. AND THE
00:37:55.473 --> 00:37:56.974
DEVELOPMENT OF A COMMITTEE TO
00:37:57.041 --> 00:38:00.111
OVERSEE A MULTIYEAR PLAN. A B 5
00:38:00.177 --> 00:38:02.179
95, THEREFORE PROMOTE
00:38:02.246 --> 00:38:04.682
TRANSPARENCY AND FAIRNESS IN OUR
00:38:04.749 --> 00:38:06.717
UNIVERSITIES ADMISSIONS PROCESS
00:38:06.784 --> 00:38:08.285
AT A TIME WHEN THE PATH TO
00:38:08.352 --> 00:38:12.089
COLLEGE REMAINS UNEQUAL. I AM
00:38:12.156 --> 00:38:12.556
PLEASED TO ACCEPT THE
00:38:12.623 --> 00:38:13.958
COMMITTEE'S AMENDMENTS, WHICH
00:38:14.025 --> 00:38:15.593
ADDRESS THE CONCERNS AROUND
00:38:15.660 --> 00:38:16.627
WHICH REQUIREMENTS WOULD BE
00:38:16.694 --> 00:38:20.631
INCLUDED IN THE BILL. HERE TO
00:38:20.698 --> 00:38:22.166
TESTIFY AND SUPPORT IS BRIAN
00:38:22.233 --> 00:38:23.801
REVIS FROM THE EDUCATIONAL TRUST
00:38:23.868 --> 00:38:25.770
WEST AND SARAH RC FROM THE
00:38:25.836 --> 00:38:28.706
CAMPAIGN OF COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY.
00:38:28.773 --> 00:38:30.541
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT.
00:38:30.608 --> 00:38:31.976
WE'RE GONNA START WITH MR REVIS
00:38:32.043 --> 00:38:34.078
. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES MADAM
00:38:34.145 --> 00:38:35.680
CHAIR MEMBERS AND BRIAN RIVAS ON
00:38:35.746 --> 00:38:37.415
BEHALF OF THE EDUCATION TRUST
00:38:37.481 --> 00:38:39.684
WEST AND SUPPORT THE MEASURE.
00:38:39.750 --> 00:38:42.453
WHENEVER YOU SEE YOUR CSU AD AND
00:38:42.520 --> 00:38:43.921
ADMISSIONS REQUIREMENTS, SOME
00:38:43.988 --> 00:38:44.989
STUDENTS ARE GOING TO BE
00:38:45.056 --> 00:38:46.123
DISPLACED FROM THE ELIGIBLE
00:38:46.190 --> 00:38:48.693
POOL. WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT
00:38:48.759 --> 00:38:50.828
PUTS IN PLACE SOME MINIMUM
00:38:50.895 --> 00:38:52.430
STANDARDS OR SAFEGUARDS TO
00:38:52.496 --> 00:38:53.931
ENSURE THAT THE PROCESS IS
00:38:53.998 --> 00:38:55.700
PUBLIC, AND THAT MULTIPLE
00:38:55.766 --> 00:38:56.801
PARTIES HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO
00:38:56.867 --> 00:39:00.404
ASK QUESTIONS. LIKE WHAT'S THE
00:39:00.471 --> 00:39:02.006
RATIONALE FOR THE CHANGE WHO
00:39:02.073 --> 00:39:04.275
WILL BE IMPACTED AND WHAT'S
00:39:04.341 --> 00:39:05.643
BEING DONE TO MITIGATE ANY
00:39:05.710 --> 00:39:07.878
CONSEQUENCES? IT WAS A BUMPY
00:39:07.945 --> 00:39:10.214
RIDE OVER THE IN THE PAST, WHEN
00:39:10.281 --> 00:39:12.183
THE CSU INITIALLY CONSIDERED THE
00:39:12.249 --> 00:39:13.984
QUANTITATIVE REASONING PROPOSALS
00:39:14.051 --> 00:39:15.920
, SO WE THINK THIS MEASURE IS
00:39:15.986 --> 00:39:18.889
NEEDED AND URGE YOUR SUPPORT AND
00:39:18.956 --> 00:39:21.158
ALSO, UM, THE PART ABOUT
00:39:21.225 --> 00:39:22.226
ENSURING THAT THERE'S AN
00:39:22.293 --> 00:39:24.061
OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE TO MAKE SURE
00:39:24.128 --> 00:39:25.563
THAT MULTIPLE EDUCATIONAL
00:39:25.629 --> 00:39:27.498
PARTNERS ARE WORKING TOGETHER TO
00:39:27.565 --> 00:39:29.400
SMOOTHLY IMPLEMENT ANY CHANGES
00:39:29.467 --> 00:39:31.602
NEEDED. SO WE'RE URGING YOUR
00:39:31.669 --> 00:39:33.871
SUPPORT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
00:39:33.938 --> 00:39:36.107
RIVAS. ALRIGHT MISS RC, PLEASE
00:39:36.173 --> 00:39:36.941
PROCEED. YOU ALSO HAVE TWO
00:39:37.007 --> 00:39:39.110
MINUTES. THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING
00:39:39.176 --> 00:39:39.744
, CHARLIE. EVEN MEMBERS OF THE
00:39:39.810 --> 00:39:40.745
COMMITTEE SARAH ARSON WITH THE
00:39:40.811 --> 00:39:41.712
CAMPAIGN FOR COLLEGE
00:39:41.779 --> 00:39:44.181
OPPORTUNITY. UM WE ARE A
00:39:44.248 --> 00:39:45.683
STATEWIDE POLICY RESEARCH AND
00:39:45.750 --> 00:39:47.985
ADVOCACY ORGANIZATION DEDICATED
00:39:48.052 --> 00:39:48.652
TO ENSURING ALL CALIFORNIA
00:39:48.719 --> 00:39:50.087
STUDENTS HAVE AN EQUAL
00:39:50.154 --> 00:39:51.989
OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO COLLEGE AND
00:39:52.056 --> 00:39:54.625
SUCCEED THERE. COVID 19 IS VERY
00:39:54.692 --> 00:39:56.160
SERIOUS CHALLENGES ACROSS OUR
00:39:56.227 --> 00:39:58.796
NATION AND STAY, ESPECIALLY FOR
00:39:58.863 --> 00:40:00.231
OUR MOST VULNERABLE STUDENTS IN
00:40:00.297 --> 00:40:03.000
K 12 AND IN COLLEGE AS WE STRIVE
00:40:03.067 --> 00:40:04.502
TO ENSURE RECOVERY WITH EQUITY
00:40:04.568 --> 00:40:05.636
FROM THE LASTING IMPACTS OF THE
00:40:05.703 --> 00:40:07.972
PANDEMIC. COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY IS
00:40:08.038 --> 00:40:10.608
KEY NOT JUST TO THE STRENGTH OF
00:40:10.674 --> 00:40:12.209
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY, NOT JUST
00:40:12.276 --> 00:40:13.444
FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO EARN A
00:40:13.511 --> 00:40:14.779
DEGREE, BUT IT'S INOCULATION
00:40:14.845 --> 00:40:15.846
AGAINST THE UNEQUAL IMPACT OF
00:40:15.913 --> 00:40:19.583
JOB LOSS. THAT IS WHY CHANGES
00:40:19.650 --> 00:40:21.452
AND ADMISSION REQUIREMENTS TO
00:40:21.519 --> 00:40:22.787
OUR PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES STAND TO
00:40:22.853 --> 00:40:24.655
HAVE SIGNIFICANT IMPACT AND
00:40:24.722 --> 00:40:25.623
WARRANT THE LEGISLATURE'S
00:40:25.689 --> 00:40:29.326
ENGAGEMENT AND OVERSIGHT. 85 95
00:40:29.393 --> 00:40:30.694
RECOGNIZES THIS AND WOULD
00:40:30.761 --> 00:40:32.463
PROVIDE THE STATE AND STUDENTS
00:40:32.530 --> 00:40:33.130
WITH A MORE THOUGHTFUL, FAIR AND
00:40:33.197 --> 00:40:36.734
TRANSPARENT PROCESS. THE STATE
00:40:36.801 --> 00:40:37.868
HAS AN INTEREST IN ENSURING THAT
00:40:37.935 --> 00:40:39.136
IT'S SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT IN
00:40:39.203 --> 00:40:42.072
HIGHER EDUCATION RESULTS IN FAIR
00:40:42.139 --> 00:40:43.140
AND EQUITABLE ADMISSION PROCESS
00:40:43.207 --> 00:40:45.843
FOR THE STUDENTS OF CALIFORNIA.
00:40:45.910 --> 00:40:47.344
POLICIES THAT IMPACT THOUSANDS
00:40:47.411 --> 00:40:49.046
OF CALIFORNIA STUDENTS ABILITY
00:40:49.113 --> 00:40:50.347
TO PURSUE THEIR HIGHER EDUCATION
00:40:50.414 --> 00:40:52.349
DREAMS IN THE STATE SHOULD NOT
00:40:52.416 --> 00:40:53.517
BE MADE WITHIN THE CONFINES OF
00:40:53.584 --> 00:40:54.552
ONE INSTITUTION AND WITHOUT A
00:40:54.618 --> 00:40:56.520
FULL CONSIDERATION. OF HOW THE
00:40:56.587 --> 00:40:57.621
UNIVERSITY ARRIVED AT THAT
00:40:57.688 --> 00:41:01.192
DECISION. 85 95 ENSURES THAT
00:41:01.258 --> 00:41:02.493
CHANGES IN ADMISSION
00:41:02.560 --> 00:41:03.661
REQUIREMENTS WILL CAREFULLY
00:41:03.727 --> 00:41:05.596
CONSIDER THE IMPACT OF THOSE
00:41:05.663 --> 00:41:07.164
POTENTIAL CHANGES. AND, MORE
00:41:07.231 --> 00:41:08.732
IMPORTANTLY, IT CREATES A
00:41:08.799 --> 00:41:10.501
TRANSPARENT, DATA DRIVEN
00:41:10.568 --> 00:41:11.402
PROCESS. THE LAWS, THE
00:41:11.468 --> 00:41:13.204
LEGISLATURE TO ENSURE THAT
00:41:13.270 --> 00:41:14.839
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS DO NOT
00:41:14.905 --> 00:41:16.240
SYSTEMATICALLY LEAVE BEHIND
00:41:16.307 --> 00:41:18.008
BLACK, LATIN X NATIVE AMERICAN
00:41:18.075 --> 00:41:21.212
AND SOUTH EAST ASIAN STUDENTS.
00:41:21.278 --> 00:41:22.780
ESTABLISHING CLEAR CRITERIA FOR
00:41:22.847 --> 00:41:24.815
HOW THE CSU AND UC CONSIDER
00:41:24.882 --> 00:41:25.783
ADOPT AND IMPLEMENT NEW
00:41:25.850 --> 00:41:27.952
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS WILL
00:41:28.018 --> 00:41:30.120
MOVE US CLOSER TO ENSURING THAT
00:41:30.187 --> 00:41:31.722
DUE DILIGENCE IS DONE ON BEHALF
00:41:31.789 --> 00:41:32.723
OF CALIFORNIA STUDENTS AND
00:41:32.790 --> 00:41:34.692
FAMILIES. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
00:41:34.758 --> 00:41:36.360
VERY MUCH, MISS RC. ALL RIGHT.
00:41:36.427 --> 00:41:37.962
DO WE HAVE ANYONE HERE IN ROOM
00:41:38.028 --> 00:41:39.029
2100, WHO WISHES TO EXPRESS
00:41:39.096 --> 00:41:42.132
THEIR SUPPORT FOR A B 5 95?
00:41:42.199 --> 00:41:43.634
SEEING THAT, MR MODERATOR, WE'RE
00:41:43.701 --> 00:41:45.035
GOING TO YOU. IF YOU CAN PLEASE
00:41:45.102 --> 00:41:47.304
QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
00:41:47.371 --> 00:41:50.708
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A B 5 95.
00:41:50.774 --> 00:41:52.109
THANK YOU. IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT
00:41:52.176 --> 00:41:55.079
OF A B 5 95, PLEASE PRESS 10 AT
00:41:55.145 --> 00:41:56.280
THIS TIME, 10. IF YOU'RE IN
00:41:56.347 --> 00:41:58.716
SUPPORT FOR MAYBE 595 ONE
00:41:58.782 --> 00:42:12.830
MOMENT, PLEASE. MADAM CHAIR.
00:42:12.897 --> 00:42:14.064
DO THAT ONE WITH AN OPERATOR
00:42:14.131 --> 00:42:15.366
SHOULD BE WITH THIS MOMENTARILY.
00:42:15.432 --> 00:42:21.205
PROBLEM. ANYBODY ELSE? PLEASE
00:42:21.272 --> 00:42:22.206
TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY AND PRESS
00:42:22.273 --> 00:42:25.843
10 HERE IN SUPPORT OF A B 5 95
00:42:25.910 --> 00:42:30.314
AND LINE 48, YOU ARE MY NAME IS
00:42:30.381 --> 00:42:31.782
ADRIAN A CHAMPAGNE WITH THE
00:42:31.849 --> 00:42:32.917
LEGAL WOMEN VOTERS WITH
00:42:32.983 --> 00:42:33.984
CALIFORNIA AND WE STRONGLY
00:42:34.051 --> 00:42:37.721
SUPPORT THIS BILL. AND AS A
00:42:37.788 --> 00:42:40.357
FINAL REMINDER, 10 IF YOU ARE IN
00:42:40.424 --> 00:42:45.129
SUPPORT OF 85 95. NOBODY ELSE IS
00:42:45.195 --> 00:42:49.166
QUEUING UP. ALRIGHT VERY GOOD.
00:42:49.233 --> 00:42:50.768
THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
00:42:50.834 --> 00:42:52.503
ALRIGHT, WE HAVE NO LEAD
00:42:52.569 --> 00:42:54.104
OPPOSITION. IS THERE ANYONE HERE
00:42:54.171 --> 00:42:57.074
IN ROOM 2100, WHICH IS TO OPPOSE
00:42:57.141 --> 00:42:59.510
SEEING NO ONE. WE WILL NOW GO
00:42:59.576 --> 00:43:01.245
BACK TO YOU, MR MODERATOR, CAN
00:43:01.312 --> 00:43:02.846
YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
00:43:02.913 --> 00:43:18.862
WISHES TO OPPOSE A B 5 95.
00:43:18.929 --> 00:43:21.098
OH I'M SORRY. I WAS MUTED, MADAM
00:43:21.165 --> 00:43:23.367
CHAIR. MY FAULT IF YOU ARE
00:43:23.434 --> 00:43:25.636
TALKING TO MYSELF AGAIN, IF YOU
00:43:25.703 --> 00:43:28.072
ARE AN OPPOSITION TO A B 595
00:43:28.138 --> 00:43:29.206
PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY
00:43:29.273 --> 00:43:31.175
ZERO. EXPRESS OPPOSITION TO A B
00:43:31.241 --> 00:43:39.316
5 95. AND NOBODY IS QUEUING UP.
00:43:39.383 --> 00:43:40.818
TERRIFIC THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
00:43:40.884 --> 00:43:43.087
MODERATOR. ALRIGHT WE'LL BRING
00:43:43.153 --> 00:43:44.455
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY
00:43:44.521 --> 00:43:45.522
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS.
00:43:45.589 --> 00:43:48.859
SEEING IT? YES, SENATOR GLASER.
00:43:48.926 --> 00:43:49.960
THANK YOU. CHAIR LEVA WELL,
00:43:50.027 --> 00:43:53.430
FIRST ASSEMBLYMAN. LET ME JUST
00:43:53.497 --> 00:43:55.332
SAY WE'RE GONNA MISS YOU. YOU'VE
00:43:55.399 --> 00:43:57.301
BEEN A GREAT LEADER IN THIS
00:43:57.368 --> 00:43:58.669
HIGHER EDUCATION SPACE FOR A
00:43:58.736 --> 00:44:00.637
LONG, LONG TIME AND YOU BRING
00:44:00.704 --> 00:44:03.273
YOUR HEART AND SOUL. TO OUR FOR
00:44:03.340 --> 00:44:04.208
OUR STUDENTS, WELFARE AND
00:44:04.274 --> 00:44:05.943
EVERYTHING THAT YOU DO, AND I
00:44:06.010 --> 00:44:06.710
CONGRATULATE YOU ON A GREAT
00:44:06.777 --> 00:44:10.914
GREAT TENURE UP HERE, SO WHAT A
00:44:10.981 --> 00:44:12.916
WONDERFUL LEGACY THAT YOU HAVE
00:44:12.983 --> 00:44:14.818
LEFT BEHIND FOR ALL OF OUR
00:44:14.885 --> 00:44:17.054
STUDENTS, SO THANK YOU. THE
00:44:17.121 --> 00:44:17.988
CHALLENGE FOR ME IN THIS BILL,
00:44:18.055 --> 00:44:19.857
AND THIS MAY BE A PHILOSOPHICAL
00:44:19.923 --> 00:44:22.826
ISSUE. UM, IS THAT AT WHAT POINT
00:44:22.893 --> 00:44:24.294
DOES THE LEGISLATURE GET
00:44:24.361 --> 00:44:25.863
INVOLVED IN THE RUNNING OF THESE
00:44:25.929 --> 00:44:27.965
INSTITUTIONS? WE CREATED A BOARD
00:44:28.032 --> 00:44:29.800
OF REGIONS A BOARD OF TRUSTEES.
00:44:29.867 --> 00:44:31.802
WE ARE BLESSED IN THE SENATE TO
00:44:31.869 --> 00:44:32.970
BE ABLE TO CONFIRM THOSE
00:44:33.037 --> 00:44:34.204
NOMINEES THAT THEY'RE CAPABLE OF
00:44:34.271 --> 00:44:36.340
DOING THEIR BEST WORK. AND
00:44:36.407 --> 00:44:37.641
CERTAINLY THE LEADERSHIP OF
00:44:37.708 --> 00:44:39.243
THESE INSTITUTIONS ARE GREAT
00:44:39.309 --> 00:44:40.911
SCHOLARS AND ACCOMPLISH
00:44:40.978 --> 00:44:42.279
EDUCATION LEADERS AND THEY
00:44:42.346 --> 00:44:44.348
DESERVE OUR RESPECT. NOW IT
00:44:44.415 --> 00:44:45.416
DOESN'T MEAN WE ALWAYS AGREE
00:44:45.482 --> 00:44:46.850
WITH THEM BECAUSE THERE ARE
00:44:46.917 --> 00:44:48.052
TIMES WHEN WE MIGHT DIFFER, AND
00:44:48.118 --> 00:44:50.387
I KNOW AS A AS A TRUSTEE OF THE
00:44:50.454 --> 00:44:51.088
STATE UNIVERSITY. THERE WERE
00:44:51.155 --> 00:44:52.956
TIMES WHEN I HAD DIFFERENCES
00:44:53.023 --> 00:44:53.991
WITH OUR WONDERFUL PRESIDENTS
00:44:54.058 --> 00:44:57.094
AND CHANCELLOR AND OTHERS. BUT
00:44:57.161 --> 00:44:57.961
I'M WONDERING, YOU KNOW WHERE
00:44:58.028 --> 00:45:00.297
AND HOW WE CREATE THAT? THAT
00:45:00.364 --> 00:45:02.299
LINE THAT GETS CROSSED TO
00:45:02.366 --> 00:45:03.534
WHETHER WE'RE GOING TO BRING OUR
00:45:03.600 --> 00:45:06.603
IN SOME CASES, POLITICAL VIEWS.
00:45:06.670 --> 00:45:08.105
TO EDUCATION POLICY AT THE
00:45:08.172 --> 00:45:09.706
INSTITUTIONS AND WHETHER THAT
00:45:09.773 --> 00:45:11.141
LINE HAS BEEN CROSSED OR NOT
00:45:11.208 --> 00:45:12.643
CROSSED ON A BILL LIKE THIS AND
00:45:12.709 --> 00:45:14.478
OTHER THINGS THAT WE HAVE HAD
00:45:14.545 --> 00:45:17.214
CONVERSATIONS ABOUT UM, AND THAT
00:45:17.281 --> 00:45:18.749
THAT IS THE ELEMENT THAT GIVES
00:45:18.816 --> 00:45:21.718
ME SOME PAUSE AND THE UNIVERSITY
00:45:21.785 --> 00:45:23.087
OF CALIFORNIA AND THE CSU JUST
00:45:23.153 --> 00:45:24.955
MADE A CHANGE ON THE S A T
00:45:25.022 --> 00:45:26.723
REQUIREMENTS. TALK ABOUT
00:45:26.790 --> 00:45:28.859
IMPACTFUL TO STUDENTS, SOMETHING
00:45:28.926 --> 00:45:31.295
THAT I HAVE BEEN WORRIED ABOUT,
00:45:31.361 --> 00:45:32.329
AND EVEN WRITTEN ABOUT 40 YEARS
00:45:32.396 --> 00:45:33.730
AGO IN TERMS OF HOW THAT
00:45:33.797 --> 00:45:36.467
DISCRIMINATES, UM AND HURTS OUR
00:45:36.533 --> 00:45:38.168
DIVERSITY GOALS WITH YOUR YOUR
00:45:38.235 --> 00:45:39.369
BUILT ATTEMPTS TO TRY TO ADDRESS
00:45:39.436 --> 00:45:41.371
AS WELL. BUT I'M WONDERING IF
00:45:41.438 --> 00:45:44.208
YOU COULD SPEAK TO THAT BECAUSE
00:45:44.274 --> 00:45:45.742
THE S A T REQUIREMENT DIDN'T
00:45:45.809 --> 00:45:47.344
HAVE THAT SAME REVIEW THAT YOUR
00:45:47.411 --> 00:45:48.812
BILL WOULD REQUIRE. AND WOULD IT
00:45:48.879 --> 00:45:50.747
HAVE BEEN GOOD IF THAT HAD COME
00:45:50.814 --> 00:45:53.283
BACK TO US? FOR OUR DECISION TO
00:45:53.350 --> 00:45:55.652
SAY YES. WE LIKE AN S A T OR NO
00:45:55.719 --> 00:45:57.154
, WE DON'T. AND EVEN THOUGH
00:45:57.221 --> 00:45:57.855
WE'RE YOU KNOW, THE EDUCATION
00:45:57.921 --> 00:45:59.022
POLICY COMMITTEE IN THE SENATE,
00:45:59.089 --> 00:46:01.325
YOU KNOW WE AND WE HAVE
00:46:01.391 --> 00:46:02.459
WONDERFUL STAFF AND CONSULTANTS.
00:46:02.526 --> 00:46:03.727
WE ARE IN A DIFFERENT KIND OF
00:46:03.794 --> 00:46:05.996
ARENA TO KIND OF MAKE THOSE KIND
00:46:06.063 --> 00:46:06.864
OF CHOICES ABOUT EDUCATION
00:46:06.930 --> 00:46:08.132
POLICY. IT'S DIFFERENT THAN THE
00:46:08.198 --> 00:46:09.633
REGIONS OF THE TRUSTEES. SO
00:46:09.700 --> 00:46:12.169
MAYBE YOU COULD SPEAK TO THAT
00:46:12.236 --> 00:46:12.836
AND WE COULD HAVE A LITTLE
00:46:12.903 --> 00:46:13.737
EXCHANGE ABOUT IT, BECAUSE
00:46:13.804 --> 00:46:16.073
THAT'S THE TROUBLE I HAVE WITH
00:46:16.140 --> 00:46:17.274
THIS BILL, WHICH HAS WONDERFUL,
00:46:17.341 --> 00:46:18.108
WORTHY GOALS BEHIND IT. WELL
00:46:18.175 --> 00:46:20.310
REMEMBER, GO AHEAD. THANK YOU,
00:46:20.377 --> 00:46:22.146
SENATOR GLAZER AND THANK YOU
00:46:22.212 --> 00:46:22.746
VERY MUCH FOR YOUR VERY KIND
00:46:22.813 --> 00:46:25.682
WORDS OF MY TENURE HERE IN THE
00:46:25.749 --> 00:46:28.418
LEGISLATURE, AND IT'S BEEN A
00:46:28.485 --> 00:46:29.419
PLEASURE WORKING WITH YOU AND
00:46:29.486 --> 00:46:30.554
WITH THIS COMMITTEE ON HIGHER
00:46:30.621 --> 00:46:35.058
EDUCATION. AND, YOU KNOW, I. UM
00:46:35.125 --> 00:46:37.227
I THINK THAT THE QUESTION THAT
00:46:37.294 --> 00:46:39.196
YOU RAISE IS A VERY VALID
00:46:39.263 --> 00:46:40.364
QUESTION AND A QUESTION THAT
00:46:40.430 --> 00:46:42.466
SHOULD BE RAISED AND CERTAINLY
00:46:42.533 --> 00:46:44.735
THERE'S ALWAYS A BALANCE. I
00:46:44.801 --> 00:46:47.104
THINK RIGHT A BALANCE BETWEEN
00:46:47.171 --> 00:46:48.939
THE LEGISLATURE'S OVERSIGHT AND
00:46:49.006 --> 00:46:52.209
THE AUTONOMY OF BOTH THE U. C
00:46:52.276 --> 00:46:53.844
WHICH IS, UH, AUTONOMY GIVEN IN
00:46:53.911 --> 00:46:57.548
THE CONSTITUTION. AND CSU,WHICH
00:46:57.614 --> 00:46:59.049
WE ENJOY MORE OVERSIGHT. I
00:46:59.116 --> 00:47:03.854
BELIEVE CONSTITUTIONALLY. UM BUT
00:47:03.921 --> 00:47:05.122
THOSE ARE QUESTIONS THAT I'M
00:47:05.189 --> 00:47:06.990
SURE WE GRAPPLE WITH ALL THE
00:47:07.057 --> 00:47:10.727
TIME. UM AND WE DID THE SAME
00:47:10.794 --> 00:47:12.829
WHEN WE WERE TALKING ABOUT 12
00:47:12.896 --> 00:47:14.531
EDUCATION AND ANOTHER BILL THAT
00:47:14.598 --> 00:47:17.701
I HAD HERE TO CHANGE. ENTRANCE
00:47:17.768 --> 00:47:19.136
REQUIREMENTS OR THE GRADUATION
00:47:19.203 --> 00:47:23.307
REQUIREMENTS FOR K 12. AND WE
00:47:23.373 --> 00:47:24.374
HAD LIVELY DISCUSSION,
00:47:24.441 --> 00:47:25.008
PHILOSOPHICAL DISCUSSIONS, THEN.
00:47:25.075 --> 00:47:29.947
ON THAT BILL. UM. AND YOU BRING
00:47:30.013 --> 00:47:31.882
UP THE SUBJECT OF THE S, A. T
00:47:31.949 --> 00:47:34.418
AND THE AND THE DIFFERENCE THAT
00:47:34.484 --> 00:47:36.220
I WOULD POINT OUT, SENATOR IS
00:47:36.286 --> 00:47:39.489
THAT THE A. C T S A T DECISION
00:47:39.556 --> 00:47:43.594
DOESN'T HAVE THE IMPACT. ON HIGH
00:47:43.660 --> 00:47:47.097
SCHOOLS THAT, UH, THE
00:47:47.164 --> 00:47:48.932
REQUIREMENT CHANGING THE
00:47:48.999 --> 00:47:51.101
ENTRANCE REQUIREMENT TO CSU,
00:47:51.168 --> 00:47:54.671
ADDING HAS ON HIGH SCHOOL. IN
00:47:54.738 --> 00:47:56.807
OTHER WORDS, CHANGING THAT
00:47:56.873 --> 00:47:58.308
ENTRANCE REQUIREMENTS WOULD
00:47:58.375 --> 00:47:59.643
REQUIRE HIGH SCHOOLS TO OFFER
00:47:59.710 --> 00:48:03.413
ANOTHER CLASS. YET AGAIN ANOTHER
00:48:03.480 --> 00:48:07.150
CLASS TO THERE. WHAT THEY
00:48:07.217 --> 00:48:09.720
OFFERED HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS AND
00:48:09.786 --> 00:48:11.154
WOULD CHANGE THE TRAJECTORY OF
00:48:11.221 --> 00:48:14.725
HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS. WHERE THE
00:48:14.791 --> 00:48:16.793
S ÁP GETTING RID OF THE S, A T
00:48:16.860 --> 00:48:19.329
AND A C. ALTHOUGH IT CERTAINLY
00:48:19.396 --> 00:48:22.065
HAS A HUGE IMPACT ON STUDENTS
00:48:22.132 --> 00:48:23.267
DOESN'T HAVE THAT SAME IMPACT ON
00:48:23.333 --> 00:48:24.901
THE SCHEDULE. OF STUDENTS
00:48:24.968 --> 00:48:29.106
WHETHER ARE IN SCHOOLS. AND SO I
00:48:29.172 --> 00:48:31.174
WAS HERE. I THINK A YEAR OR TWO
00:48:31.241 --> 00:48:33.410
YEARS AGO. YOU KNOW, TALKING
00:48:33.477 --> 00:48:35.078
ABOUT THE SAME ENTRANCE
00:48:35.145 --> 00:48:38.081
REQUIREMENT AND THE ISSUE THAT
00:48:38.148 --> 00:48:39.916
WAS BEFORE US WAS THE LACK OF
00:48:39.983 --> 00:48:46.290
CONSULTATION. BY CSU. WITH. ANY
00:48:46.356 --> 00:48:47.858
ANY OF THE STAKEHOLDERS WHETHER
00:48:47.924 --> 00:48:50.360
THEY WERE K 12 SCHOOL DISTRICTS
00:48:50.427 --> 00:48:51.528
OR EVEN THE DEPARTMENT OF
00:48:51.595 --> 00:48:57.434
EDUCATION. UM, I HAD. IN THAT
00:48:57.501 --> 00:48:59.936
INTERIM O TIME, WE HAD A CHANGE
00:49:00.003 --> 00:49:03.473
IN THE LEADERSHIP OF CSU AND I
00:49:03.540 --> 00:49:05.409
HAD A COMMITMENT FROM THE
00:49:05.475 --> 00:49:09.913
INCOMING. PRESIDENT OF CSU THAT
00:49:09.980 --> 00:49:13.083
IT WAS GOING TO BE, UH, VERY
00:49:13.150 --> 00:49:14.918
MUCH REVIEWED. THE POLICY ON THE
00:49:14.985 --> 00:49:18.155
NEW ENTRANCE REQUIREMENT. SINCE
00:49:18.221 --> 00:49:20.524
THEN, I THINK YOU KNOW IT'S BEEN
00:49:20.590 --> 00:49:24.261
HELD BACK, BUT THERE IS NO UH, I
00:49:24.328 --> 00:49:25.495
THINK IT'S STILL COMING FORWARD
00:49:25.562 --> 00:49:26.763
, AND I THINK WITH THIS BILL OF
00:49:26.830 --> 00:49:29.132
PROPERLY DOES IS GIVE THE
00:49:29.199 --> 00:49:33.570
LEGISLATURE OVERSIGHT. AT LEAST
00:49:33.637 --> 00:49:35.939
LET US BE INFORMED BEFORE
00:49:36.006 --> 00:49:38.241
DECISIONS ARE MADE CHANGING THE
00:49:38.308 --> 00:49:41.878
ENTRANCE REQUIREMENT. TO CSU,
00:49:41.945 --> 00:49:43.747
SOMETHING THAT WOULD HAVE A HUGE
00:49:43.814 --> 00:49:46.316
IMPACT. AND THE SCHEDULES OF
00:49:46.383 --> 00:49:48.151
STUDENTS, AND I THINK THAT'S OUR
00:49:48.218 --> 00:49:50.187
PROPER ROLE, AND THAT IS TO HAVE
00:49:50.253 --> 00:49:52.956
OVERSIGHT OVER CSU. THANK YOU.
00:49:53.023 --> 00:49:54.491
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S CENTER GLASER.
00:49:54.558 --> 00:49:57.394
WELL, ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. I DID.
00:49:57.461 --> 00:50:00.230
YOU'VE ADDRESSED THIS ISSUE OF
00:50:00.297 --> 00:50:02.299
CONSULTATION AND NOTICED AND
00:50:02.366 --> 00:50:03.200
IT'S AGAIN AN EXAMPLE OF WHERE
00:50:03.266 --> 00:50:05.369
WE HAVE WE FIND COMMON GROUND
00:50:05.435 --> 00:50:06.136
IMMEDIATELY THAT THAT IS
00:50:06.203 --> 00:50:07.971
SOMETHING THAT IS, YOU KNOW,
00:50:08.038 --> 00:50:09.072
OBVIOUSLY REQUIRED AND NEEDED.
00:50:09.139 --> 00:50:12.109
I'M REMINDED THAT THE PROCESS OF
00:50:12.175 --> 00:50:14.177
DECISIONS FROM THE CSU IN THIS
00:50:14.244 --> 00:50:16.947
CASE IS NOT A FAST ONE. THEY PUT
00:50:17.013 --> 00:50:18.715
MATTERS ON THEIR AGENDA AS AN
00:50:18.782 --> 00:50:21.651
INFORMATION ITEM. UH AND THEN
00:50:21.718 --> 00:50:22.886
TWO MONTHS LATER, IF THEY JUST
00:50:22.953 --> 00:50:25.055
CHOOSE TO ADVANCE THAT THEY PUT
00:50:25.122 --> 00:50:26.723
IT ON THE AGENDA AS AN ACTION
00:50:26.790 --> 00:50:27.924
ITEM. THEY HAVE PUBLIC HEARINGS
00:50:27.991 --> 00:50:29.226
AND TESTIMONY FROM ALL
00:50:29.292 --> 00:50:30.861
STAKEHOLDERS. AND IF THEY WERE
00:50:30.927 --> 00:50:32.763
NOT CONSULTING AS YOU SUGGEST, I
00:50:32.829 --> 00:50:34.231
THINK THAT WAS A BAD MOVE ON
00:50:34.297 --> 00:50:36.233
THEIR PART. IF THAT'S THE CASE,
00:50:36.299 --> 00:50:37.701
I WOULD ASK KIRA AGAIN IF WE
00:50:37.768 --> 00:50:39.069
HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE
00:50:39.136 --> 00:50:40.504
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY HERE
00:50:40.570 --> 00:50:42.339
IN THE ROOM OR ON THE LINE THAT
00:50:42.406 --> 00:50:43.907
COULD SPEAK TO THEIR THEIR
00:50:43.974 --> 00:50:45.542
PROCESS INVOLVED IN AND THIS
00:50:45.609 --> 00:50:46.843
PARTICULAR CHANGE THAT HAS
00:50:46.910 --> 00:50:48.278
WORRIED THE AUTHOR BECAUSE I
00:50:48.345 --> 00:50:50.647
LIKE TO HEAR THEM EXPLAIN IF
00:50:50.714 --> 00:50:51.615
THEY'RE CONSULTATION HAS NOT
00:50:51.681 --> 00:50:53.116
BEEN THOROUGH. YOU KNOW WHY NOT
00:50:53.183 --> 00:50:55.218
AND WHAT THEY'RE DOING ABOUT IT.
00:50:55.285 --> 00:50:56.686
PLEASE INTRODUCE YOURSELF AND
00:50:56.753 --> 00:50:59.089
PROCEED. GOOD MORNING CHEN CHASE
00:50:59.156 --> 00:51:00.524
ON BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA STATE
00:51:00.590 --> 00:51:02.893
UNIVERSITY. SO SINCE THE WITH
00:51:02.959 --> 00:51:05.195
THE CSU QUANTITATIVE REASONING
00:51:05.262 --> 00:51:06.329
PROPOSAL, WE'VE HAD EIGHT
00:51:06.396 --> 00:51:07.330
PRESENTATIONS BEFORE THE BOARD
00:51:07.397 --> 00:51:09.766
OF TRUSTEES, INCLUDING ONE THAT
00:51:09.833 --> 00:51:12.602
WAS A PUBLIC FORUM THAT INCLUDED
00:51:12.669 --> 00:51:14.204
MULTIPLE PRESENTATIONS WE'VE
00:51:14.271 --> 00:51:15.839
USED WE'VE HAD A MULTITUDE OF
00:51:15.906 --> 00:51:16.473
STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT OVER THE
00:51:16.540 --> 00:51:19.342
COURSE OF SEVERAL YEARS. AND
00:51:19.409 --> 00:51:21.578
HAVE HAVE CREATED A CSU STEERING
00:51:21.645 --> 00:51:22.345
COMMITTEE ON ACADEMIC
00:51:22.412 --> 00:51:23.880
PREPARATION, QUANTITATIVE
00:51:23.947 --> 00:51:25.348
REASONING, AS WELL AS
00:51:25.415 --> 00:51:26.883
COMMISSIONED A STUDY TO EVALUATE
00:51:26.950 --> 00:51:29.052
IMPACTS. SO FOR THIS EXAMPLE,
00:51:29.119 --> 00:51:30.554
WE'RE ACTUALLY ABLE, YOU KNOW,
00:51:30.620 --> 00:51:32.456
WE HEARD THE PUBLIC INPUT IN IN
00:51:32.522 --> 00:51:35.358
THE LEGISLATURES IN SOME MEMBER
00:51:35.425 --> 00:51:36.993
OF MODENA'S, UM INTEREST IN THE
00:51:37.060 --> 00:51:38.595
SUBJECT AND HAVE EXTENDED AND
00:51:38.662 --> 00:51:41.097
CREATED A HAVE CREATED A LONGER
00:51:41.164 --> 00:51:41.731
PROCESS COMPARED TO THE WHICH
00:51:41.798 --> 00:51:45.202
WERE ABLE TO HAVE A MORE
00:51:45.268 --> 00:51:46.803
RELATIVELY FASTER PROCESSING
00:51:46.870 --> 00:51:48.805
ABOUT A YEAR BEFORE WE MADE THAT
00:51:48.872 --> 00:51:49.840
CHANGE, BUT FOR THIS, WE HAVE
00:51:49.906 --> 00:51:51.775
HAD THIS LONGER STUDY AND WE
00:51:51.842 --> 00:51:52.876
BELIEVED IN THE STUDY WILL BE
00:51:52.943 --> 00:51:54.711
THAT SHOULD BE COMPLETED IN THE
00:51:54.778 --> 00:51:57.147
FALL. AT THAT POINT, WE WOULD
00:51:57.214 --> 00:51:58.782
THE BOARD IT WOULD BE THE BOARD
00:51:58.849 --> 00:52:00.984
WOULD BE ABLE TO REVIEW THE
00:52:01.051 --> 00:52:01.952
STUDY AND THEN MAKE A DECISION
00:52:02.018 --> 00:52:03.820
WHETHER THERE SHOULD BE ANY ANY
00:52:03.887 --> 00:52:06.122
CHANGES OR NOT. THE IF THROUGH
00:52:06.189 --> 00:52:08.158
THE CHAIR, THE BILL'S AUTHOR HAS
00:52:08.225 --> 00:52:09.626
SUGGESTED THAT THERE WAS A LACK
00:52:09.693 --> 00:52:11.094
OF CONSULTATION WITH IMPORTANT
00:52:11.161 --> 00:52:12.796
STAKEHOLDERS. COULD YOU SPEAK TO
00:52:12.863 --> 00:52:14.030
THAT? ARE PEOPLE BEING LEFT OUT
00:52:14.097 --> 00:52:15.198
OF THIS DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
00:52:15.265 --> 00:52:17.067
THAT THE CONCERNS HAVE BEEN
00:52:17.133 --> 00:52:19.703
RAISED ABOUT UH, I COULD
00:52:19.769 --> 00:52:20.770
ACTUALLY DIRECT YOU TO OUR
00:52:20.837 --> 00:52:22.272
WEBSITE, WHICH HAS A LONG
00:52:22.339 --> 00:52:23.640
TIMELINE OF ALL THE CONSULTATION
00:52:23.707 --> 00:52:25.242
THAT WE'VE DONE, UM, ACROSS WITH
00:52:25.308 --> 00:52:25.909
MULTIPLE STAKEHOLDERS, K 12 I'VE
00:52:25.976 --> 00:52:30.213
ACTUALLY CONVENED ALSO. UM WITH
00:52:30.280 --> 00:52:31.348
WITHIN OUR LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS
00:52:31.414 --> 00:52:32.916
OFFICE, WE'VE CONVENED AT LEAST
00:52:32.983 --> 00:52:36.353
THREE OR FOUR, UM MEDIANS WITH
00:52:36.419 --> 00:52:38.355
OUR STAKEHOLDERS, AS WELL AS OUR
00:52:38.421 --> 00:52:39.322
CHANCELLOR'S OFFICE COLLEAGUES
00:52:39.389 --> 00:52:40.957
HAVE THROUGH THE THROUGH THE
00:52:41.024 --> 00:52:42.893
QUANTITATIVE REASONING STEERING
00:52:42.959 --> 00:52:44.261
COMMITTEE HAVE HAVE CONSULTED. I
00:52:44.327 --> 00:52:46.196
HAVE HAD HELD MULTIPLE HEARINGS
00:52:46.263 --> 00:52:49.432
AS WELL AS THE AS WE'VE DONE A
00:52:49.499 --> 00:52:50.767
LOT OF OUTREACH WITH COMMUNITY
00:52:50.834 --> 00:52:52.002
WITH, LIKE THE RIVERSIDE COUNTY
00:52:52.068 --> 00:52:54.437
OFFICE OF EDUCATION. L A. L E. U
00:52:54.504 --> 00:52:56.139
S D AS WELL AS IN DIEGO USD SO
00:52:56.206 --> 00:52:57.874
AND WE'VE WORKED. ALSO PARTNERED
00:52:57.941 --> 00:53:00.443
WITH K 12 TO TRY TO LOOK AT
00:53:00.510 --> 00:53:01.611
WHAT? WHAT QUANTITY OF RAISING
00:53:01.678 --> 00:53:03.280
CURRICULUM THEY HAVE. AND THEN
00:53:03.346 --> 00:53:04.714
TRYING TO KIND OF HELP WITH THE
00:53:04.781 --> 00:53:05.882
TEACHER PREP AS WELL. ONE FINAL
00:53:05.949 --> 00:53:11.988
QUESTION TO THE CHAIR. UM. I
00:53:12.055 --> 00:53:14.024
DON'T WANT TO DEBATE THE MERITS
00:53:14.090 --> 00:53:16.126
OF THE POTENTIAL PROPOSAL HERE.
00:53:16.192 --> 00:53:18.595
BUT THE BUT THE CONCERN HAS BEEN
00:53:18.662 --> 00:53:20.664
RAISED ABOUT EQUITY. AND UH,
00:53:20.730 --> 00:53:22.966
COULD YOU SPEAK TO THE ISSUE OF
00:53:23.033 --> 00:53:23.767
EQUITY IN REGARD TO THIS
00:53:23.833 --> 00:53:25.802
PROPOSAL AND WHETHER OR NOT
00:53:25.869 --> 00:53:26.870
THERE'S MERIT AND CONCERN TO
00:53:26.937 --> 00:53:30.140
THAT. WELL I THINK IT'S
00:53:30.206 --> 00:53:31.675
OBVIOUSLY WE'RE ALWAYS CONCERNED
00:53:31.741 --> 00:53:33.843
ABOUT EQUITY AT THE CSU IS A
00:53:33.910 --> 00:53:34.678
HIGH PRIORITY. AND SO THAT WAS
00:53:34.744 --> 00:53:37.514
WHEN WE CONVENE THE INITIAL, UM
00:53:37.581 --> 00:53:39.182
, WE HAVE THE INITIAL STEERING
00:53:39.249 --> 00:53:41.117
COMMITTEE. THERE WAS INDICATION
00:53:41.184 --> 00:53:42.652
THAT THAT MANY OF OUR OF OUR
00:53:42.719 --> 00:53:43.954
STUDENTS THAT WE'RE ENTERING THE
00:53:44.020 --> 00:53:45.622
CSU WERE ALREADY MEETING THIS
00:53:45.689 --> 00:53:46.690
THESE REQUIREMENT. AND THEN WE
00:53:46.756 --> 00:53:47.958
WENT BACK AND WE'RE WORKING WITH
00:53:48.024 --> 00:53:49.659
K 12 DIVERSITY EXTRA DISTRICTS
00:53:49.726 --> 00:53:50.894
TO TRY TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF
00:53:50.961 --> 00:53:51.995
QUANTITATIVE REASONING, BUT
00:53:52.062 --> 00:53:52.996
EQUITY IS ALWAYS THE HIGHEST
00:53:53.063 --> 00:53:54.764
PRIORITY AND AGAIN WITH THE
00:53:54.831 --> 00:53:56.266
CONCERNS WITHOUT CONCERNS THAT
00:53:56.333 --> 00:53:57.968
WERE RAISED. THAT WAS ONE OF THE
00:53:58.034 --> 00:53:59.302
REASONS THAT WE SLOWED DOWN THE
00:53:59.369 --> 00:54:01.071
PROCESS IN ORDER TO EVALUATE AND
00:54:01.137 --> 00:54:02.639
THAT'S REALLY A BIG PART OF THE
00:54:02.706 --> 00:54:04.207
STUDY IS THAT WE'LL BE ABLE TO
00:54:04.274 --> 00:54:05.742
LOOK AT EQUITY AND ONE OF THE
00:54:05.809 --> 00:54:08.011
STUDY ACTUALLY HAS BEEN EXPANDED
00:54:08.078 --> 00:54:08.612
OVER TIME AND COMPLICATION TO
00:54:08.678 --> 00:54:10.714
TRY TO LOOK AT WHAT HAS HAPPENED
00:54:10.780 --> 00:54:11.848
DURING THE PANDEMIC TO TRY TO
00:54:11.915 --> 00:54:14.250
UNDERSTAND. HOW THAT HAS IMPACT
00:54:14.317 --> 00:54:16.286
OUR INCOMING STUDENTS AS WELL.
00:54:16.353 --> 00:54:18.188
FINALLY, DO YOU HAVE A POSITION
00:54:18.254 --> 00:54:19.422
ON THIS BILL? WE DON'T HAVE A
00:54:19.489 --> 00:54:20.957
NORMAL POSITION. THANK YOU AND
00:54:21.024 --> 00:54:22.025
MISS RC. LOOK. THANK YOU VERY
00:54:22.092 --> 00:54:23.994
MUCH. LOOKS LIKE YOU HAVE
00:54:24.060 --> 00:54:24.995
SOMETHING TO SAY. GO AHEAD.
00:54:25.061 --> 00:54:27.530
THANK YOU. CHAIR I JUST WANTED
00:54:27.597 --> 00:54:29.366
TO RESPOND TO A COUPLE OF THE
00:54:29.432 --> 00:54:30.767
COMMENTS. I THINK UM THERE'S A
00:54:30.834 --> 00:54:32.035
DISTINCTION TO MAKE BETWEEN THE
00:54:32.102 --> 00:54:33.870
CURRENT PROCESS THAT'S UNDERWAY
00:54:33.937 --> 00:54:36.806
AND THE PROCESS THAT WAS TAKEN
00:54:36.873 --> 00:54:38.241
TO ADD THIS AS AN AGENDA ITEM
00:54:38.308 --> 00:54:41.578
INITIALLY A FEW YEARS BACK. AS A
00:54:41.645 --> 00:54:42.946
PROPOSAL FOR CONSIDERATION BY
00:54:43.013 --> 00:54:44.814
THE CSU TRUSTEES. AND IT WAS
00:54:44.881 --> 00:54:46.750
UNDER THAT FIRST PROCESS THAT
00:54:46.816 --> 00:54:47.751
REALLY HIGHLIGHTED TO US THE
00:54:47.817 --> 00:54:49.019
LACK OF CONVERSATIONS AND
00:54:49.085 --> 00:54:52.589
TRANSPARENCY. AND THAT HAD GONE
00:54:52.656 --> 00:54:54.591
ABOUT WHEN PUTTING TOGETHER THIS
00:54:54.658 --> 00:54:56.259
INITIAL PROPOSAL. IT WAS, IN
00:54:56.326 --> 00:54:58.361
FACT THE STAKEHOLDERS AND THE
00:54:58.428 --> 00:55:01.231
EDUCATIONAL EQUITY ADVOCATES WHO
00:55:01.297 --> 00:55:03.767
BROUGHT THIS PROPOSAL TO THE
00:55:03.833 --> 00:55:04.734
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND
00:55:04.801 --> 00:55:06.002
OTHER K THROUGH 12 STAKEHOLDERS
00:55:06.069 --> 00:55:08.571
TO LET THEM KNOW THIS WAS BEING
00:55:08.638 --> 00:55:12.108
CONSIDERED BY THE CSU. WE HAD
00:55:12.175 --> 00:55:13.476
MANY INDICATIONS THAT PEOPLE
00:55:13.543 --> 00:55:15.011
HAVE THAT DISTRICT HAD NOT BEEN
00:55:15.078 --> 00:55:16.846
PROPERLY NOTIFIED THAT THIS WAS
00:55:16.913 --> 00:55:20.650
, UM ON THE TABLE AND CONSULTED
00:55:20.717 --> 00:55:23.687
ABOUT THEIR CAPACITY TO ADD THIS
00:55:23.753 --> 00:55:25.255
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT AND WHAT
00:55:25.321 --> 00:55:26.823
THAT WOULD MEAN TO STUDENTS. AND
00:55:26.890 --> 00:55:30.260
IT WAS ALSO THE STAKEHOLDERS
00:55:30.326 --> 00:55:31.594
EDUCATIONAL EQUITY STAKE HOLDERS
00:55:31.661 --> 00:55:32.729
THAT CONVENED AN IMPACT
00:55:32.796 --> 00:55:36.232
ANALYSIS. TO SEE WHAT THE
00:55:36.299 --> 00:55:39.069
PROPOSAL WITH ME IN TERMS OF
00:55:39.135 --> 00:55:41.204
EDUCATIONAL EQUITY FOR OUR MOST
00:55:41.271 --> 00:55:42.839
VULNERABLE STUDENTS. AND SO THAT
00:55:42.906 --> 00:55:44.841
IS, I THINK THE PROCESS THAT WE
00:55:44.908 --> 00:55:46.710
WOULD LIKE TO SEE OUR
00:55:46.776 --> 00:55:48.344
INSTITUTIONS UNDERTAKE GOING
00:55:48.411 --> 00:55:49.813
FORWARD AS THEY'RE CONSIDERING
00:55:49.879 --> 00:55:51.881
PROPOSALS AS YOU, SAID SENATOR,
00:55:51.948 --> 00:55:53.750
IT'S NOT ABOUT THE MERITS OF THE
00:55:53.817 --> 00:55:54.884
CURRENT PROPOSAL ON THE TABLE.
00:55:54.951 --> 00:55:58.588
BUT WHAT COUNSEL CONSULTED. WHAT
00:55:58.655 --> 00:56:00.790
KIND OF PROCESS AH THE
00:56:00.857 --> 00:56:01.858
INSTITUTIONS SHOULD TAKE WHEN
00:56:01.925 --> 00:56:04.227
THEY ARE FIRST CONSIDERING THESE
00:56:04.294 --> 00:56:05.762
THESE PROPOSALS, AND THAT'S WHAT
00:56:05.829 --> 00:56:08.064
WE'RE TRYING TO HIGHLIGHT HERE.
00:56:08.131 --> 00:56:09.265
AND ADDITIONALLY I WANTED TO
00:56:09.332 --> 00:56:10.800
NOTE SENATOR. I'M GLAD THAT YOU
00:56:10.867 --> 00:56:13.103
BROUGHT UP THE EXAMPLE OF THE S
00:56:13.169 --> 00:56:14.771
A T DECISION THAT WAS MADE BY
00:56:14.838 --> 00:56:17.173
THE CSU BECAUSE I THINK THAT WAS
00:56:17.240 --> 00:56:21.144
CITED BY THE CSU. THAT IT WAS A
00:56:21.211 --> 00:56:24.581
DECISION MADE OVERWHELMINGLY ON
00:56:24.647 --> 00:56:26.983
DATA AND RESEARCH THAT HAD
00:56:27.050 --> 00:56:29.352
INDICATED THESE TESTS WERE NOT
00:56:29.419 --> 00:56:30.553
ACCURATE PREDICTOR OF STUDENTS
00:56:30.620 --> 00:56:34.224
CAPABILITIES. AND IT'S THAT DATA
00:56:34.290 --> 00:56:36.359
DRIVEN EQUITY FOCUS PROCESS THAT
00:56:36.426 --> 00:56:38.862
WE WANT TO AND INTEND TO
00:56:38.928 --> 00:56:41.598
CLARIFY. AND MAYBE 5 95. YOU
00:56:41.664 --> 00:56:43.266
KNOW, WE WILL NOT ALWAYS HAVE
00:56:43.333 --> 00:56:44.400
THE BENEFIT OF EXTENSIVE
00:56:44.467 --> 00:56:44.968
RESEARCH ON DISPARATE IMPACT
00:56:45.034 --> 00:56:45.902
WHEN PROPOSING STATE LEVEL
00:56:45.969 --> 00:56:49.339
CHANGES. SO MAYBE 595 REALLY
00:56:49.405 --> 00:56:51.508
ENSURES THAT FUTURE PROPOSALS
00:56:51.574 --> 00:56:53.576
CAN BE MET WITH THAT SAME LEVEL
00:56:53.643 --> 00:56:56.112
OF DATA TO INFORM THE DECISION.
00:56:56.179 --> 00:56:58.114
THANK YOU, MISS RC. GREAT GLASER
00:56:58.181 --> 00:56:59.916
INCLUDE CHAIR AND THANK YOU FOR
00:56:59.983 --> 00:57:00.817
THE CONVERSATION. BECAUSE THESE
00:57:00.884 --> 00:57:04.788
ARE CHALLENGING PLACES AND. TO
00:57:04.854 --> 00:57:07.791
LEGISLATE. UM YOU KNOW, I KNOW,
00:57:07.857 --> 00:57:08.792
AND THE CAMPAIGN FOR COLLEGE
00:57:08.858 --> 00:57:09.859
OPPORTUNITY SHOULD APPROPRIATELY
00:57:09.926 --> 00:57:13.596
STAND UP AND ACKNOWLEDGE THEIR
00:57:13.663 --> 00:57:14.597
GREAT LEADERSHIP THAT THE
00:57:14.664 --> 00:57:16.599
ASSOCIATE DEGREE FOR TRANSFER
00:57:16.666 --> 00:57:19.002
ISSUE WAS A LEGISLATIVE DRIVEN
00:57:19.068 --> 00:57:20.770
ONE. IT WAS BECAUSE OF CONCERN
00:57:20.837 --> 00:57:22.205
THAT THE INSTITUTIONS WEREN'T
00:57:22.272 --> 00:57:22.839
TALKING TO EACH OTHER AND THAT
00:57:22.906 --> 00:57:24.140
STUDENTS ARE BEING HURT. THAT'S
00:57:24.207 --> 00:57:25.742
ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF WHERE WE
00:57:25.809 --> 00:57:26.743
HAVEN'T SLECTED PLACES HAVE
00:57:26.810 --> 00:57:29.546
STEPPED IN. TO SAY, YOU KNOW
00:57:29.612 --> 00:57:30.713
WE'RE NOT HAPPY, AND WE GOT TO
00:57:30.780 --> 00:57:33.082
HAVE A CHANGE IN AND FORCE THAT
00:57:33.149 --> 00:57:34.117
THROUGH THROUGH A LEGISLATIVE
00:57:34.184 --> 00:57:36.953
INITIATIVE. I'M NOT CONVINCED
00:57:37.020 --> 00:57:38.655
THAT THAT WE HAVE THAT THAT SAME
00:57:38.721 --> 00:57:40.690
SERIOUS PROBLEM AT THIS MOMENT.
00:57:40.757 --> 00:57:42.525
ASSEMBLY MEMBER AND SO
00:57:42.592 --> 00:57:43.960
ACCORDINGLY I'M GOING TO STAY
00:57:44.027 --> 00:57:45.094
OFF THE BILL TODAY, BUT I
00:57:45.161 --> 00:57:47.730
CERTAINLY APPLAUD THAT THE
00:57:47.797 --> 00:57:49.232
THRUST OF WHAT YOU ARE TRYING TO
00:57:49.299 --> 00:57:51.901
ACCOMPLISH, AND IT AMPLIFIES
00:57:51.968 --> 00:57:52.969
AGAIN. YOU'RE GREAT LEADERSHIP
00:57:53.036 --> 00:57:54.037
IN THIS EQUITY SPACE, AND I
00:57:54.103 --> 00:57:56.239
THANK YOU FOR THAT. THANK YOU,
00:57:56.306 --> 00:57:57.740
SENATOR GLASER, CENTER PAN.
00:57:57.807 --> 00:57:59.843
THANK YOU. AND I TO, UH YOU
00:57:59.909 --> 00:58:03.780
KNOW, WANT TO JOIN, UM MY
00:58:03.847 --> 00:58:05.315
COLLEAGUE AND THANKING YOU,
00:58:05.381 --> 00:58:07.750
SENATOR MEDINA AND PROUD TO BE
00:58:07.817 --> 00:58:10.386
WITH TO SERVE WITH YOU IN THE
00:58:10.453 --> 00:58:11.588
ASSEMBLY AS WELL AND REALLY
00:58:11.654 --> 00:58:13.423
APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR LEADERSHIP.
00:58:13.489 --> 00:58:17.026
UM I GUESS YOU KNOW, I AS
00:58:17.093 --> 00:58:17.961
SOMEONE WHO'S YOU KNOW, FORMER
00:58:18.027 --> 00:58:20.129
FACULTY MEMBER I HAVE MET. I DO
00:58:20.196 --> 00:58:22.332
SHARE SOME OF THE SAME CONCERNS
00:58:22.398 --> 00:58:24.167
AS MY COLLEAGUE ABOUT. I THINK
00:58:24.234 --> 00:58:25.735
ACADEMIC FREEDOM AND EXACTLY
00:58:25.802 --> 00:58:30.740
WHERE. DOES THE LEGISLATURE
00:58:30.807 --> 00:58:31.841
INTERVENE? IN FACT, THAT'S WHY
00:58:31.908 --> 00:58:35.778
YOU KNOW THE AND BELIEVE ME,
00:58:35.845 --> 00:58:37.146
THERE ARE TIMES WHEN I'M NOT
00:58:37.213 --> 00:58:39.315
HAPPY ABOUT THAT. THE THAT THE
00:58:39.382 --> 00:58:40.717
FOUNDERS OF OUR STATE YOU KNOW,
00:58:40.783 --> 00:58:41.784
MADE YOU SEE IN THE
00:58:41.851 --> 00:58:44.587
CONSTITUTION. SOMEWHAT
00:58:44.654 --> 00:58:46.189
INDEPENDENT, AND THAT'S WHY I
00:58:46.256 --> 00:58:47.757
HEAR IT'S FOR CSU AND WE
00:58:47.824 --> 00:58:50.226
SUGGESTED FOR C. BUT WE CAN'T
00:58:50.293 --> 00:58:51.427
MANDATE IT RIGHT BECAUSE THEY
00:58:51.494 --> 00:58:53.196
DID WANT TO PROVIDE THAT BUFFER
00:58:53.263 --> 00:58:55.431
THAT OF TRYING TO DECREASE
00:58:55.498 --> 00:58:59.802
POLITICAL. UM INTERFERENCE IN
00:58:59.869 --> 00:59:03.106
ACADEMIC AFFAIRS. SO UM, I GUESS
00:59:03.172 --> 00:59:04.641
MY QUESTION HERE FOR THIS
00:59:04.707 --> 00:59:06.476
PARTICULAR BILL IS THAT, UM
00:59:06.542 --> 00:59:11.614
WOULD. BECAUSE YOU TALKED ABOUT
00:59:11.681 --> 00:59:13.516
AND WE TALKED A LITTLE ABOUT THE
00:59:13.583 --> 00:59:14.884
S A. T S. AND THEN WE TALKED
00:59:14.951 --> 00:59:17.253
ABOUT THE QUALITY OF REASONING.
00:59:17.320 --> 00:59:18.488
SO THIS IS THIS BILL IF IT
00:59:18.554 --> 00:59:20.723
PASSES AND GET SIGNED INTO LAW
00:59:20.790 --> 00:59:23.126
IT SAYS FROM THE ANALYSIS SAYS
00:59:23.192 --> 00:59:25.328
ANY CHANGE. SO DOES THAT MEAN
00:59:25.395 --> 00:59:26.996
EVERY SINGLE CHANGE HAS TO GO
00:59:27.063 --> 00:59:29.265
THROUGH THIS PROCESS SO I CAN
00:59:29.332 --> 00:59:30.667
IMAGINE THE FUTURE. SOMEONE MAY
00:59:30.733 --> 00:59:32.402
HAVE A CHANGE THAT'S SIMILAR TO
00:59:32.468 --> 00:59:33.670
THE S A T THING. SO WHILE I
00:59:33.736 --> 00:59:35.705
UNDERSTAND, I THINK THERE'S SOME
00:59:35.772 --> 00:59:38.041
TALK ABOUT MAKING IT NOT GO
00:59:38.107 --> 00:59:38.975
RETROACTIVE SO IT WOULD HAVE TO
00:59:39.042 --> 00:59:40.677
GO BACK AND, YOU KNOW, REVERSE
00:59:40.743 --> 00:59:42.912
THE S A T THING AND THEN GO BACK
00:59:42.979 --> 00:59:44.747
THROUGH THAT. THERE MAY BE A
00:59:44.814 --> 00:59:46.182
FUTURE THINGS LIKE THAT. THAT
00:59:46.249 --> 00:59:47.183
ACTUALLY PROMOTES EQUITY BUT
00:59:47.250 --> 00:59:48.384
WOULD HAVE TO GO THROUGH THIS
00:59:48.451 --> 00:59:50.620
ENTIRE PROCESS. WHICH YOU KNOW,
00:59:50.687 --> 00:59:51.988
FRANKLY, DOES SLOW THINGS DOWN A
00:59:52.055 --> 00:59:55.391
BIT. SO UH WHICH IS MY CLARIFY?
00:59:55.458 --> 00:59:56.993
IF THIS BILL YOU KNOW IT GETS
00:59:57.060 --> 00:59:58.861
SIGNED INTO LAW. THIS IS THE
00:59:58.928 --> 01:00:00.330
PROCESS THAT WOULD HAVE TO GO
01:00:00.396 --> 01:00:01.731
THROUGH FOR ANY CHANGE IN
01:00:01.798 --> 01:00:05.068
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS. WELL
01:00:05.134 --> 01:00:06.602
THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION,
01:00:06.669 --> 01:00:10.640
SENATOR PAN AND MY UNDERSTANDING
01:00:10.707 --> 01:00:12.842
IS THAT THE LEGISLATION AND THE
01:00:12.909 --> 01:00:16.679
BILL ADDRESSES. UH CHANGES IN
01:00:16.746 --> 01:00:18.881
ADMISSION POLICY THAT AFFECTS,
01:00:18.948 --> 01:00:20.883
UH STUDENTS ACROSS THE SEGMENTS
01:00:20.950 --> 01:00:25.054
AND AFFECTS AGAIN, I WOULD SAY,
01:00:25.121 --> 01:00:27.457
UH, HAVE THE IMPACT ON THEIR
01:00:27.523 --> 01:00:30.460
SCHEDULES AND THE WORDS CHANGE.
01:00:30.526 --> 01:00:33.229
UH THE REQUIREMENTS TO THE K 12.
01:00:33.296 --> 01:00:39.502
OKAY, SO. ALRIGHT SO I JUST WANT
01:00:39.569 --> 01:00:41.671
TO CLARIFY YOU. SO YOU'RE SAYING
01:00:41.738 --> 01:00:43.673
THIS DOESN'T APPLY TO ANY CHANGE
01:00:43.740 --> 01:00:45.174
THAT IS IT ONLY APPLIES TO
01:00:45.241 --> 01:00:46.876
CERTAIN CHANGES, AND I DON'T
01:00:46.943 --> 01:00:51.581
KNOW IF THOSE OKAY GOOD. I ASK
01:00:51.647 --> 01:00:53.683
MISS RC TO COME UP AGAIN, PLEASE
01:00:53.750 --> 01:00:54.650
RIGHT BECAUSE THE WAY THE
01:00:54.717 --> 01:00:55.718
ANALYSIS READS IT SAYS ANY
01:00:55.785 --> 01:00:57.687
CHANGE. I GUESS I CAN GO BACK TO
01:00:57.754 --> 01:00:59.922
THE BUILD LANGUAGE. UM ANY ANY
01:00:59.989 --> 01:01:01.190
CHANGE IN UNDERGRADUATE STUDENT
01:01:01.257 --> 01:01:02.458
ELIGIBILITY POLICY. THAT'S WHAT
01:01:02.525 --> 01:01:07.730
IT SAYS. AND 662 OH 5.4, A. IS
01:01:07.797 --> 01:01:09.766
OUR SECOND AHEAD. I JUST WANTED
01:01:09.832 --> 01:01:12.168
TO CONFIRM THAT ANY CHANGE TO
01:01:12.235 --> 01:01:14.370
STUDENT ELIGIBILITY POLICY. SO
01:01:14.437 --> 01:01:16.639
ANY POLICIES THAT CHANGE RELATED
01:01:16.706 --> 01:01:18.174
TO, UM WHAT MAKES A STUDENT
01:01:18.241 --> 01:01:20.476
ELIGIBLE FOR THE CSU AND I
01:01:20.543 --> 01:01:21.711
WANTED TO CONFIRM THAT I BELIEVE
01:01:21.778 --> 01:01:24.847
THIS. ALRIGHT COMMITTEE
01:01:24.914 --> 01:01:26.349
AMENDMENTS ADDRESSED THE
01:01:26.416 --> 01:01:28.084
RETROACTIVE ISSUES, SO IF NOT
01:01:28.151 --> 01:01:31.120
APPLY TO THE I UNDERSTAND THAT
01:01:31.187 --> 01:01:32.288
THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING. GOING
01:01:32.355 --> 01:01:33.289
FORWARD, THOUGH, SO THERE'S A
01:01:33.356 --> 01:01:35.458
FUTURE CHANGE. THEN THIS ALSO
01:01:35.525 --> 01:01:38.628
APPLIES. SO IN THE FUTURE S 80
01:01:38.694 --> 01:01:40.096
THING, RIGHT, ALTHOUGH I GUESS
01:01:40.163 --> 01:01:41.197
THAT'S A REMOVAL OF THE
01:01:41.264 --> 01:01:43.066
REQUIREMENT, BUT IF YOU HAVE ANY
01:01:43.132 --> 01:01:44.700
ANY AND ACTUALLY, I THINK YOU
01:01:44.767 --> 01:01:46.569
KNOW ONE OF THE CHALLENGES. IS
01:01:46.636 --> 01:01:48.638
THAT THIS THIS I GUESS IF YOU
01:01:48.704 --> 01:01:50.573
ADD REQUIREMENT, YOU HAVE TO GO
01:01:50.640 --> 01:01:51.741
THROUGH THIS. IF YOU TAKE AWAY
01:01:51.808 --> 01:01:52.708
REQUIREMENT, YOU DON'T IS THAT
01:01:52.775 --> 01:01:56.379
CORRECT? THAT'S THE ONLY
01:01:56.446 --> 01:01:58.114
DISTINGUISHING THING I SEE AND
01:01:58.181 --> 01:02:00.183
IN THE LANGUAGE, CORRECT ANY NEW
01:02:00.249 --> 01:02:01.884
REQUIREMENTS ANY NEW
01:02:01.951 --> 01:02:03.286
REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO
01:02:03.352 --> 01:02:06.956
ELIGIBILITY ELIGIBILITY, OKAY.
01:02:07.023 --> 01:02:08.091
ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. UM OKAY.
01:02:08.157 --> 01:02:10.126
NOW I APPRECIATE THAT, UM
01:02:10.193 --> 01:02:13.062
BECAUSE I MEAN, I THINK THAT AND
01:02:13.129 --> 01:02:14.263
THEN THE OTHER QUESTION I HAVE
01:02:14.330 --> 01:02:18.101
HERE IS THAT UM, IT REQUIRES
01:02:18.167 --> 01:02:19.635
THAT WE COMMISSIONED AN
01:02:19.702 --> 01:02:21.070
INDEPENDENT STUDY BY THIRD PARTY
01:02:21.137 --> 01:02:24.941
RESEARCH ORGANIZATION, SO UM SO
01:02:25.007 --> 01:02:30.246
THAT MEANS THAT. WE DON'T WE SAY
01:02:30.313 --> 01:02:32.381
SO. IT CAN'T BE ANY ENTITY
01:02:32.448 --> 01:02:33.983
WITHIN CSC, WHICH IS AN
01:02:34.050 --> 01:02:35.651
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION HAS
01:02:35.718 --> 01:02:36.953
RESEARCH CAPACITY, ETCETERA. IT
01:02:37.019 --> 01:02:38.788
WOULD HAVE TO, UH, IT'S SO THEY
01:02:38.855 --> 01:02:41.991
WOULD HAVE BUT THEY ASSUMED THEY
01:02:42.058 --> 01:02:43.092
WOULD THEY WOULD PICK THE
01:02:43.159 --> 01:02:44.160
ORGANIZATION. SO HOW? HOW DOES
01:02:44.227 --> 01:02:46.596
THAT WORK? WELL, I LOOKING AT
01:02:46.662 --> 01:02:53.603
THE LANGUAGE. UM. AND TO BACK TO
01:02:53.669 --> 01:02:54.704
SENATOR GLASER'S QUESTION AND
01:02:54.770 --> 01:02:58.074
OUR OVERSIGHT. IF I USED THE
01:02:58.141 --> 01:03:01.344
EXAMPLE OF WHAT HAS HAPPENED.
01:03:01.410 --> 01:03:05.615
SEXUAL HARASSMENT. CSU. YOU KNOW
01:03:05.681 --> 01:03:06.816
, I THINK THAT THAT THAT IT IS
01:03:06.883 --> 01:03:08.818
VERY WELL UNDERSTOOD. THAT THE
01:03:08.885 --> 01:03:10.820
LEGISLATURE HAS A ROLE ON THAT.
01:03:10.887 --> 01:03:17.026
WE HAVE, UM. YOU KNOW,
01:03:17.093 --> 01:03:18.127
COMMITTEES HERE ALREADY
01:03:18.194 --> 01:03:21.164
ESTABLISHED THAT WOULD WOULD
01:03:21.230 --> 01:03:26.869
OVERLOOK AND CONDUCT HEARINGS.
01:03:26.936 --> 01:03:29.205
AND THOSE HEARINGS WOULD COULD
01:03:29.272 --> 01:03:31.440
INVOLVED, UH, INDEPENDENT THIRD
01:03:31.507 --> 01:03:34.143
PARTIES AND IN THE SAME MANNER.
01:03:34.210 --> 01:03:35.711
I THINK THIS LEGISLATION
01:03:35.778 --> 01:03:40.082
PROPOSES TO ALLOW. A THIRD PARTY
01:03:40.149 --> 01:03:41.784
ENTITY TO LOOK AT THE
01:03:41.851 --> 01:03:43.486
CONCLUSIONS THAT HAVE BEEN
01:03:43.553 --> 01:03:49.792
DRYING BY CSU. OKAY, SO, UM. ALL
01:03:49.859 --> 01:03:51.194
RIGHT. SO IT SAYS, OKAY, WELL,
01:03:51.260 --> 01:03:53.329
FIRST OF ALL, I ACTUALLY I DO
01:03:53.396 --> 01:03:54.297
WANT TO MAKE A SLIGHT
01:03:54.363 --> 01:03:55.231
DISTINCTION BETWEEN LET'S SAY
01:03:55.298 --> 01:03:56.666
SEXUAL ARREST, MINT AND
01:03:56.732 --> 01:04:01.003
ELIGIBILITY, SO COURSE. CONTENT
01:04:01.070 --> 01:04:03.706
UM YOU KNOW WHICH CLASSES YOU
01:04:03.773 --> 01:04:05.875
HAVE TO TAKE WHAT YOU NEED TO,
01:04:05.942 --> 01:04:06.976
YOU KNOW TO GRADUATE WHO GETS
01:04:07.043 --> 01:04:08.711
ADMITTED SO FORTH. THOSE ARE
01:04:08.778 --> 01:04:09.812
PRETTY CORE ACADEMIC FUNCTIONS.
01:04:09.879 --> 01:04:15.618
RIGHT, UM AH! I THINK SO. SO
01:04:15.685 --> 01:04:17.820
THOSE ARE I MEAN, THOSE ARE
01:04:17.887 --> 01:04:19.255
QUITE FUNDAMENTAL TO THE
01:04:19.322 --> 01:04:21.390
EDUCATIONAL MISSION OF THE OF
01:04:21.457 --> 01:04:22.725
THE UNIVERSITY. OBVIOUSLY THINGS
01:04:22.792 --> 01:04:24.927
OTHER ISSUES. HAVE AN IMPACT ON
01:04:24.994 --> 01:04:29.165
THAT. BUT. I THINK SO AGAIN. I
01:04:29.232 --> 01:04:32.835
DO VIEW SOME OF THESE CORE
01:04:32.902 --> 01:04:34.704
ACADEMIC FUNCTIONS AS BEING YOU
01:04:34.770 --> 01:04:35.871
KNOW, IN TERMS OF ACADEMIC
01:04:35.938 --> 01:04:37.740
FREEDOM FROM WERE ESSENTIAL TO
01:04:37.807 --> 01:04:38.841
THE ISSUES AROUND ACADEMIC
01:04:38.908 --> 01:04:40.977
FREEDOM. UM IN TERMS OF THE
01:04:41.043 --> 01:04:45.448
COMMISSION IS, UH AND, ACTUALLY
01:04:45.514 --> 01:04:46.916
, UM, THIS THE REPRESENTATIVE
01:04:46.983 --> 01:04:48.818
CSU HERE BECAUSE I UNDERSTAND SO
01:04:48.884 --> 01:04:50.553
I KNOW YOU DON'T HAVE A
01:04:50.620 --> 01:04:51.587
PHYSICIAN ON THE BILL, BUT AT
01:04:51.654 --> 01:04:53.522
LEAST IN ANALYSIS INDICATE YOU
01:04:53.589 --> 01:04:54.490
HAD SOME CONCERNS ABOUT THAT.
01:04:54.557 --> 01:04:59.228
UM, CAN UM AND JUST SIMPLY. I
01:04:59.295 --> 01:05:00.763
MEAN, I GUESS CSU WOULD BE THE
01:05:00.830 --> 01:05:02.832
ONE WHO PICKS THE END AND I CAN
01:05:02.898 --> 01:05:04.700
YOU, CAN YOU MAYBE ELABORATE ON
01:05:04.767 --> 01:05:05.701
YOUR CONCERNS ABOUT THAT
01:05:05.768 --> 01:05:07.003
REQUIREMENT? PLEASE PROCEED.
01:05:07.069 --> 01:05:08.638
THANK THANK YOU, JOHN CHASE FROM
01:05:08.704 --> 01:05:09.839
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY. SO
01:05:09.905 --> 01:05:11.540
WE HAD TALKED WITH THE WITH THE
01:05:11.607 --> 01:05:13.142
AUTHOR'S OFFICE AND STAFF ABOUT
01:05:13.209 --> 01:05:14.410
THE DEFINITION OF NEW
01:05:14.477 --> 01:05:15.044
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENT, WHICH
01:05:15.111 --> 01:05:17.046
IS ON PAGE SIX OF THE STAFF
01:05:17.113 --> 01:05:19.448
ANALYSIS. TO EXCLUDE, OR
01:05:19.515 --> 01:05:21.250
REQUIREMENT MANDATED UNDER
01:05:21.317 --> 01:05:22.485
RESULTING FROM EXISTING LAWS SO
01:05:22.551 --> 01:05:24.320
THOSE WOULD BE BILLS PASSED BY
01:05:24.387 --> 01:05:24.854
THE LEGISLATURE. EXISTING
01:05:24.920 --> 01:05:25.755
UNIVERSITY ADMISSIONS
01:05:25.821 --> 01:05:27.056
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENT THAT HAS
01:05:27.123 --> 01:05:28.257
BEEN REMOVED REMOVED A REVISED
01:05:28.324 --> 01:05:31.894
THAT WOULD HELP WITH KIND OF ACT
01:05:31.961 --> 01:05:33.496
LIKE ISSUE IN THE FUTURE AND
01:05:33.562 --> 01:05:34.330
REQUIREMENTS APPLYING TO
01:05:34.397 --> 01:05:35.865
ENROLLMENT CATEGORIES DESIGNATED
01:05:35.931 --> 01:05:39.769
IN SUBDIVISIONS. A ONE A 12 AND
01:05:39.835 --> 01:05:42.271
THREE OF SECTION 66 2. OH, TWO.
01:05:42.338 --> 01:05:43.773
SO WE HAD WORKED WITH THE
01:05:43.839 --> 01:05:44.840
AUTHOR'S OFFICE TO HELP KIND OF
01:05:44.907 --> 01:05:46.108
NARROW THE BILL BECAUSE
01:05:46.175 --> 01:05:47.410
ORIGINALLY IT WAS VERY EXPENSIVE
01:05:47.476 --> 01:05:50.313
AND WOULD ANY ANY, FOR EXAMPLE,
01:05:50.379 --> 01:05:52.048
IT WOULD PERHAPS REQUIRE US
01:05:52.114 --> 01:05:53.616
UNDER THE LIKE THE LEGISLATURE
01:05:53.683 --> 01:05:54.850
HAS MANDATED E D T TRANSFERS
01:05:54.917 --> 01:05:58.821
UNDER 9 28, AND IT WOULD
01:05:58.888 --> 01:06:01.057
POTENTIALLY HAVE REQUIRED US TO
01:06:01.123 --> 01:06:01.891
DO A STUDY BEFORE WE'RE ABLE TO
01:06:01.957 --> 01:06:04.126
IMPLEMENT THAT. UM AND SO THOSE
01:06:04.193 --> 01:06:05.695
THOSE WERE SO WE HAD TALKED TO
01:06:05.761 --> 01:06:06.896
THE AUTHOR'S OFFICE ABOUT TRYING
01:06:06.962 --> 01:06:08.030
TO NARROW SO THAT WE'RE NOT
01:06:08.097 --> 01:06:09.732
REPEATING, BUT OVERALL, WE DO
01:06:09.799 --> 01:06:10.766
THINK THERE WILL BE AN
01:06:10.833 --> 01:06:11.901
ADDITIONAL LENGTHENING THE
01:06:11.967 --> 01:06:12.835
PROCESS BECAUSE OF THE
01:06:12.902 --> 01:06:14.503
REQUIREMENT FOR THE INDEPENDENT
01:06:14.570 --> 01:06:16.339
THIRD PARTY, AND I BELIEVE FROM
01:06:16.405 --> 01:06:17.773
FROM TALKS WITH THE AUTHOR'S
01:06:17.840 --> 01:06:19.275
OFFICE. THIS HAS TO BE KIND OF
01:06:19.342 --> 01:06:20.843
COULDN'T BE LIKE CONVERSE WITH
01:06:20.910 --> 01:06:22.845
THE UCR CSU BUT WOULD HAVE TO BE
01:06:22.912 --> 01:06:24.246
OUTSIDE AN INDEPENDENT THIRD
01:06:24.313 --> 01:06:24.814
PARTY. SO IN GENERAL, WE DO
01:06:24.880 --> 01:06:27.149
BELIEVE IT WOULD. IT WOULD SLOW
01:06:27.216 --> 01:06:28.484
DOWN ANY CHANGE PROCESS, BUT WE
01:06:28.551 --> 01:06:30.086
HAD WORKED WITH THE AUTHOR TO
01:06:30.152 --> 01:06:31.520
TRY TO NARROW THE SCOPE OF
01:06:31.587 --> 01:06:32.555
THINGS THAT WOULD BE REQUIRED
01:06:32.621 --> 01:06:34.757
UNDER THE BILL, OKAY? RIGHT
01:06:34.824 --> 01:06:37.860
WELL, YEAH, THANK YOU. SO FIRST
01:06:37.927 --> 01:06:41.130
OF ALL, I AGREE WITH THE GOLD
01:06:41.197 --> 01:06:43.232
THE BILL, RIGHT? AND THEN YOU
01:06:43.299 --> 01:06:45.234
THINK WHEN WE'RE DOING AS WE'RE
01:06:45.301 --> 01:06:46.802
LOOKING AT SOME OF THESE BASIC,
01:06:46.869 --> 01:06:47.937
YOU KNOW, PROCESSES. WE NEED TO
01:06:48.003 --> 01:06:49.772
HAVE AN EQUITY LENS ON THAT
01:06:49.839 --> 01:06:51.374
RIGHT? AND THERE NEEDS TO BE
01:06:51.440 --> 01:06:52.041
ACCOUNTABILITY. SO I APPRECIATE
01:06:52.108 --> 01:06:53.843
YOUR TRYING TO BRING IN SOME
01:06:53.909 --> 01:06:54.610
EXTERNAL ACCOUNTABILITY TO THIS.
01:06:54.677 --> 01:06:58.748
I DO HAVE SOME CONCERNS ABOUT.
01:06:58.814 --> 01:07:00.082
AND IN TWO LEVELS. ONE IS THAT,
01:07:00.149 --> 01:07:03.853
UM, YOU KNOW, I WENT WELL, THERE
01:07:03.919 --> 01:07:05.688
SHOULD BE OVERSIGHT. I THINK WE
01:07:05.755 --> 01:07:07.189
HAVE TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT YOU
01:07:07.256 --> 01:07:08.357
KNOW, OVER TO TOO MUCH
01:07:08.424 --> 01:07:12.361
INTERFERENCE FROM EXTERNAL, YOU
01:07:12.428 --> 01:07:14.130
KNOW, OUT FROM US OVER SORT OF
01:07:14.196 --> 01:07:16.365
ACADEMIC FUNCTIONS OF THE
01:07:16.432 --> 01:07:18.134
UNIVERSITY, BUT BUT, YOU KNOW, I
01:07:18.200 --> 01:07:19.869
SAID THAT THERE DOESN'T NEED TO
01:07:19.935 --> 01:07:21.103
BE OVERSIGHT AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
01:07:21.170 --> 01:07:23.072
AND THE SECOND THING IS THAT IN
01:07:23.139 --> 01:07:24.306
THE EFFORT TO TRY TO ADDRESS, I
01:07:24.373 --> 01:07:25.574
THINK PARTICULAR SITUATION THAT
01:07:25.641 --> 01:07:29.111
YOU'RE CONCERNED ABOUT. I'M
01:07:29.178 --> 01:07:30.479
CONCERNED THAT PERHAPS THE IN
01:07:30.546 --> 01:07:36.185
THIS BILL. THAT. WE MAY ACTUALLY
01:07:36.252 --> 01:07:37.186
BE CREATING MORE BARRIERS TO
01:07:37.253 --> 01:07:40.122
CHANGES THAT MAY ADDRESS EQUITY.
01:07:40.189 --> 01:07:43.092
BY CRUZ BY ESTABLISHING THE CODE
01:07:43.159 --> 01:07:45.394
OR PROCESS THAT IS THAT THAT'S
01:07:45.461 --> 01:07:50.166
THAT THAT ACTUALLY MAKES, UH,
01:07:50.232 --> 01:07:53.969
MAYBE OVERLY ONEROUS. SO UM, SO
01:07:54.036 --> 01:07:56.338
I GUESS MY QUESTION. I GUESS MY
01:07:56.405 --> 01:07:57.640
FINAL QUESTION TO YOU IS THAT
01:07:57.706 --> 01:07:59.375
ARE YOU LOOKING AT? YOU CONTINUE
01:07:59.442 --> 01:08:01.911
TO WORK WITH CSU AND I GUESS WE
01:08:01.977 --> 01:08:03.279
CAN'T REALLY MANDATE FOR C.
01:08:03.345 --> 01:08:04.113
BUT HOPEFULLY YOU'RE ALSO
01:08:04.180 --> 01:08:06.348
TALKING TO YOU SEE TO TRY TO
01:08:06.415 --> 01:08:06.982
MAYBE THINK ABOUT STREAMLINING
01:08:07.049 --> 01:08:09.852
SOME OF THESE ISSUES BY MAYBE
01:08:09.919 --> 01:08:11.253
MAYBE BEING LESS PRESCRIPTIVE,
01:08:11.320 --> 01:08:13.389
BUT SETTING ASIDE CLEAR GOALS AS
01:08:13.456 --> 01:08:15.458
TO WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE IN
01:08:15.524 --> 01:08:17.827
TERMS OF WHAT KIND OF ANALYSIS
01:08:17.893 --> 01:08:19.829
NEEDS TO BE DONE BEFORE ANY SORT
01:08:19.895 --> 01:08:20.796
OF DECISIONS MADE. AND, OF
01:08:20.863 --> 01:08:22.364
COURSE, AGREE WITH WHAT? YOU
01:08:22.431 --> 01:08:23.632
KNOW WHAT YOUR GOALS FOR
01:08:23.699 --> 01:08:24.500
TRANSPARENCY AND THOSE ANALYSES
01:08:24.567 --> 01:08:25.968
SHOULD BE MADE PUBLIC BEFORE ANY
01:08:26.035 --> 01:08:27.670
FINAL DECISIONS MADE SO THAT
01:08:27.736 --> 01:08:28.771
STAKEHOLDERS HAVE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:08:28.838 --> 01:08:30.439
WEIGH IN. WITH RESPECT OF
01:08:30.506 --> 01:08:31.407
SEGMENTS BEFORE ANY CHANGES
01:08:31.474 --> 01:08:35.845
ACTUALLY FINALLY ADOPTED. WELL
01:08:35.911 --> 01:08:39.215
THANK YOU, DR PAN, AND I DON'T
01:08:39.281 --> 01:08:41.650
DISAGREE BECAUSE YOU KNOW THAT I
01:08:41.717 --> 01:08:42.952
COME FROM EDUCATION, AND THERE
01:08:43.018 --> 01:08:44.220
WAS A COMMUNITY COLLEGE TRUSTEE
01:08:44.286 --> 01:08:46.722
RIGHT AND VERY MUCH. I AGREE
01:08:46.789 --> 01:08:50.226
WITH YOU THAT I'M MATTERS OF. OF
01:08:50.292 --> 01:08:53.229
WHAT IS THE CONTENT AND ACADEMIC
01:08:53.295 --> 01:08:55.965
THAT SHOULD BE IN THE PURVIEW OF
01:08:56.031 --> 01:08:57.533
THOSE WHO ARE INTERESTED TO DO
01:08:57.600 --> 01:09:00.503
THAT. THE FACULTY UM IN HIGHER
01:09:00.569 --> 01:09:04.773
EDUCATION. THOSE DECISIONS ARE
01:09:04.840 --> 01:09:06.842
IN THE FACULTIES HAT AND I DON'T
01:09:06.909 --> 01:09:10.079
GO AGAINST THAT. UM WE HAVE
01:09:10.145 --> 01:09:12.114
WORKED WITH CSU. WE'VE ACCEPTED
01:09:12.181 --> 01:09:13.749
THEIR AMENDMENTS AND I'D BE VERY
01:09:13.816 --> 01:09:15.351
WILLING TO CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:09:15.417 --> 01:09:18.487
CSU. I THINK OUR GOAL HERE IS
01:09:18.554 --> 01:09:22.024
THE TWO THINGS RIGHT, UH,
01:09:22.091 --> 01:09:24.460
ENSURING THAT EQUITY REMAINS
01:09:24.527 --> 01:09:28.230
HIGH GOAL IN ADMISSIONS AND ALSO
01:09:28.297 --> 01:09:30.032
TRANSPARENCY ACROSS THE BOARD
01:09:30.099 --> 01:09:30.966
TRANSPARENCY TO ALL THE
01:09:31.033 --> 01:09:32.234
STAKEHOLDERS. TRANSPARENCY TO
01:09:32.301 --> 01:09:37.106
THE LEGISLATURE. AND VERY
01:09:37.172 --> 01:09:38.240
WILLING TO CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
01:09:38.307 --> 01:09:40.676
CSU ON THE BILL. OKAY I
01:09:40.743 --> 01:09:43.646
APPRECIATE THAT. UM SO I DO HAVE
01:09:43.712 --> 01:09:45.848
SOME CONCERNS. I HOPE I KNOW
01:09:45.915 --> 01:09:47.650
THIS IS NOW IN THE SECOND HOUSE
01:09:47.716 --> 01:09:48.884
. I KNOW YOU'RE SOMEONE WHO'S
01:09:48.951 --> 01:09:50.753
WHO I'VE SEEN, YOU KNOW, WORKED
01:09:50.819 --> 01:09:52.054
CLOSELY WITH PEOPLE TO MAKE SURE
01:09:52.121 --> 01:09:53.756
YOUR POLICIES AND YOUR YOUR LAW.
01:09:53.822 --> 01:09:54.924
YOU KNOW YOUR BILLS. HOPEFULLY
01:09:54.990 --> 01:09:57.293
THAT BECOME LAWS. ARE EFFECTIVE.
01:09:57.359 --> 01:09:59.194
AND SO I WILL BE VOTING FOR THE
01:09:59.261 --> 01:10:01.630
BILL TODAY, BUT UM, BUT I WANT
01:10:01.697 --> 01:10:03.198
TO SEE WHAT THE EVOLUTION IS
01:10:03.265 --> 01:10:05.501
BEFORE DECIDING WHAT TO DO ON
01:10:05.568 --> 01:10:07.636
THE FLOOR. BUT I KNOW I ALSO
01:10:07.703 --> 01:10:08.771
HAVE CONFIDENCE IN IN YOUR YOUR
01:10:08.837 --> 01:10:10.239
LEADERSHIP AND COMMITMENT TO
01:10:10.306 --> 01:10:11.273
MAKING THINGS NOT ONLY, OF
01:10:11.340 --> 01:10:15.044
COURSE. ACHIEVE THE GOALS BUT
01:10:15.110 --> 01:10:16.745
ALSO, YOU KNOW, FUNCTIONAL IN
01:10:16.812 --> 01:10:18.080
THE WAY THAT ISN'T GOING TO
01:10:18.147 --> 01:10:19.415
CREATE A DISH YOU KNOW
01:10:19.481 --> 01:10:21.116
UNNECESSARY ARE I SAY ADDITIONAL
01:10:21.183 --> 01:10:22.818
BARRIERS TO ACTUALLY TRYING TO
01:10:22.885 --> 01:10:23.619
ACHIEVE THE VERY GOLDIE
01:10:23.686 --> 01:10:24.687
HOPEFULLY THAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
01:10:24.753 --> 01:10:25.854
ACHIEVE AND I SUPPORT RIGHT
01:10:25.921 --> 01:10:28.490
TRYING TO GET MORE EQUITY. INTO
01:10:28.557 --> 01:10:29.391
OUR HIGHER EDUCATION EDUCATION
01:10:29.458 --> 01:10:30.392
SYSTEM. THANK YOU. THANK YOU,
01:10:30.459 --> 01:10:35.898
SENATOR PAN COBO CENTER KOBO. UM. SOMEONE AROUND MEDINA, COULD
01:10:35.965 --> 01:10:40.636
YOU EXPLAIN? THAT THAT THE NEED
01:10:40.703 --> 01:10:42.204
THAT YOU SAW TO BRING THIS
01:10:42.271 --> 01:10:43.772
FOURTH BECAUSE THE
01:10:43.839 --> 01:10:45.808
REPRESENTATIVE FROM CAL STATE,
01:10:45.874 --> 01:10:48.177
UM, MENTIONED THE FACT THAT SHE
01:10:48.243 --> 01:10:49.411
WAS GOING THROUGH THE PROCESS OF
01:10:49.478 --> 01:10:51.347
HOW THEY ANALYZE IN THE SYSTEM
01:10:51.413 --> 01:10:54.750
THEY HAVE IN PLACE TO T
01:10:54.817 --> 01:10:57.753
CONSIDER ANY MUTE IMPLEMENTATION
01:10:57.820 --> 01:10:59.388
, SO I'M JUST KIND OF CURIOUS AS
01:10:59.455 --> 01:11:00.889
TO WHERE YOU'RE COMING FROM THAT
01:11:00.956 --> 01:11:02.925
YOU DID NOT SEE THAT IN PLACE
01:11:02.992 --> 01:11:04.660
THAT THEY WAS IT JUST A MISHAP
01:11:04.727 --> 01:11:05.995
THAT HAPPENED ONCE OR IS THE
01:11:06.061 --> 01:11:07.129
PROCESS THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE
01:11:07.196 --> 01:11:08.964
IN PLACE? NOT SUFFICIENT IN YOUR
01:11:09.031 --> 01:11:10.799
EYES. THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR
01:11:10.866 --> 01:11:13.602
THE QUESTION. AND I WOULD SAY TO
01:11:13.669 --> 01:11:17.339
ANSWER CANDIDLY. AND HONESTLY.
01:11:17.406 --> 01:11:19.975
AS I LEAVE HERE AND MY TIME HERE
01:11:20.042 --> 01:11:21.276
IN THE IN THE LEGISLATURE. YOU
01:11:21.343 --> 01:11:22.511
KNOW THAT? THE LEGISLATURE'S
01:11:22.578 --> 01:11:26.849
RELATION. WITH BOTH UC AND CSU.
01:11:26.915 --> 01:11:30.986
IS DYNAMIC. AND THAT IS THAT
01:11:31.053 --> 01:11:34.189
IT'S NOT THE SAME ALWAYS AND I
01:11:34.256 --> 01:11:36.025
WOULD VERY MUCH, UH, HERE THIS
01:11:36.091 --> 01:11:37.760
MORNING. SAY THAT I AM GRATEFUL
01:11:37.826 --> 01:11:39.795
TO CSU AND THE WORK THAT THEY'VE
01:11:39.862 --> 01:11:41.797
DONE. FROM THE PREVIOUS TIME
01:11:41.864 --> 01:11:42.898
THAT I BROUGHT THIS BILL
01:11:42.965 --> 01:11:46.235
FORWARD. AND I DON'T BELIEVE
01:11:46.301 --> 01:11:47.436
SENATOR THAT YOU WERE HERE WHEN
01:11:47.503 --> 01:11:48.604
I BROUGHT THE FIRST BILL
01:11:48.671 --> 01:11:51.674
FORWARD. BUT I WOULD GO TO
01:11:51.740 --> 01:11:53.042
SENATOR PAN AND I REMEMBER THAT
01:11:53.108 --> 01:11:55.244
HEARING AND HOW CONTENTIOUS IT
01:11:55.310 --> 01:11:58.414
WAS AND HOW SENATOR PEN STOOD UP
01:11:58.480 --> 01:12:03.018
FOR THE LEGISLATURE TO CSU. AND
01:12:03.085 --> 01:12:05.454
TALKED ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP.
01:12:05.521 --> 01:12:08.023
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN YOU SEE
01:12:08.090 --> 01:12:10.025
THAT THIS IS A CSU BILL. FOCUS.
01:12:10.092 --> 01:12:14.263
UM BUT IT'S NOT ALWAYS THE SAME
01:12:14.329 --> 01:12:15.764
. AND SO WHAT I'M POINTING OUT
01:12:15.831 --> 01:12:18.333
TO IS THAT A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO
01:12:18.400 --> 01:12:19.501
MAYBE 23 YEARS AGO. UH WE
01:12:19.568 --> 01:12:20.869
WEREN'T GETTING THE SAME. I
01:12:20.936 --> 01:12:23.238
WOULD EVEN SAY RESPECT. IN THE
01:12:23.305 --> 01:12:27.910
PROCESS. AND I THINK THAT'S
01:12:27.976 --> 01:12:29.511
WHERE I THINKING SENATOR PAN FOR
01:12:29.578 --> 01:12:31.146
STANDING UP THAT DAY IN THAT
01:12:31.213 --> 01:12:33.348
HEARING. IN OTHER WORDS, YOU
01:12:33.415 --> 01:12:35.117
KNOW IT. IT IS. THESE ARE
01:12:35.184 --> 01:12:37.386
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA.
01:12:37.453 --> 01:12:39.621
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
01:12:39.688 --> 01:12:41.356
FUNDED BY THE STATE OF
01:12:41.423 --> 01:12:43.158
CALIFORNIA, SO I THINK THAT
01:12:43.225 --> 01:12:44.660
THERE IS A RECIPROCAL
01:12:44.727 --> 01:12:47.062
RESPONSIBILITY ONE TO THE OTHER
01:12:47.129 --> 01:12:49.998
AND I WILL VERY MUCH ACKNOWLEDGE
01:12:50.065 --> 01:12:52.167
THAT HERE THIS MORNING SEE AS
01:12:52.234 --> 01:12:53.836
YOU HAS DONE A GOOD JOB MOVING
01:12:53.902 --> 01:12:55.137
FORWARD AND BEING MORE
01:12:55.204 --> 01:12:57.306
TRANSPARENT, MORE ACCESSIBLE,
01:12:57.372 --> 01:12:58.373
MORE COMMUNICATIVE, BUT IT WAS
01:12:58.440 --> 01:13:00.776
THAT LACK OF THAT FIRST LED ME
01:13:00.843 --> 01:13:03.979
TO INTRODUCE THIS. VERY GOOD. SO
01:13:04.046 --> 01:13:06.882
YOU KNOW MUCH OTHER QUESTIONS.
01:13:06.949 --> 01:13:08.684
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S WOULD YOU LIKE
01:13:08.751 --> 01:13:10.185
THAT TO BE YOUR CLOTHES? OR DO
01:13:10.252 --> 01:13:11.754
YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WOULD
01:13:11.820 --> 01:13:13.789
LIKE TO ADD? THAT WILL BE MY
01:13:13.856 --> 01:13:14.757
CLOTHES. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:13:14.823 --> 01:13:16.358
YOUR I VOTE. EXCELLENT THANK
01:13:16.425 --> 01:13:18.127
YOU, BILL. THANK YOU. BILL HAS
01:13:18.193 --> 01:13:19.328
BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR PAM. MADAM
01:13:19.394 --> 01:13:21.130
ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:13:21.196 --> 01:13:24.133
FILE ITEM 9 85 95. THE MOTION IS
01:13:24.199 --> 01:13:25.801
DUE PASS AS AMENDED BUT FIRST
01:13:25.868 --> 01:13:27.803
AMEND AND RE REFERRED TO THE
01:13:27.870 --> 01:13:28.370
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:13:28.437 --> 01:13:30.572
LEVER LEVER JOB, OKAY? JOBURG
01:13:30.639 --> 01:13:35.644
CORTEZ E. SALLY. GLASER. MCGUIRE
01:13:35.711 --> 01:13:39.982
PAN. WE'LL LEAVE THAT BILL ON
01:13:40.048 --> 01:13:41.984
CALL ASSEMBLY MEMBER. YOU ALSO
01:13:42.050 --> 01:13:44.953
HAVE FILE ITEM 10 A B 16 50 TO
01:13:45.020 --> 01:13:46.255
BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE READY. THANK
01:13:46.321 --> 01:13:47.589
YOU AGAIN. THANK YOU, MADAM
01:13:47.656 --> 01:13:50.425
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. I PRESENT A B
01:13:50.492 --> 01:13:55.764
16 52 A B 16 52 CODIFIES THE
01:13:55.831 --> 01:13:57.533
RECENT ATTORNEY GENERAL'S LEGAL
01:13:57.599 --> 01:13:59.601
OPINION THAT AN EXECUTIVE
01:13:59.668 --> 01:14:01.370
DIRECTOR AND EMPLOYEE OF THE
01:14:01.436 --> 01:14:03.806
CHARTER SCHOOL MAY NOT SERVE AS
01:14:03.872 --> 01:14:06.175
A MEMBER OF THE COUNTY BOARD OF
01:14:06.241 --> 01:14:07.943
EDUCATION IN THE COUNTY, WHERE
01:14:08.010 --> 01:14:08.944
THEY'RE EMPLOYING SCHOOL IS
01:14:09.011 --> 01:14:11.814
LOCATED. EXISTING LAW PROHIBITS
01:14:11.880 --> 01:14:13.649
AN EMPLOYEE OF THE SCHOOL
01:14:13.715 --> 01:14:15.884
DISTRICT FROM BEING AN ELECTED
01:14:15.951 --> 01:14:17.119
OR APPOINTED MEMBER OF THAT
01:14:17.186 --> 01:14:18.720
SCHOOL DISTRICTS GOVERNING BOARD
01:14:18.787 --> 01:14:20.122
UNLESS AND UNTIL THEY RESIGN AS
01:14:20.189 --> 01:14:27.129
AN EMPLOYEE. A B 16 52 WILL
01:14:27.196 --> 01:14:29.398
APPLY THE SAME LIMITATION TO ANY
01:14:29.464 --> 01:14:31.066
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OR CHARTER
01:14:31.133 --> 01:14:32.568
SCHOOL EMPLOYEE FROM SERVING ON
01:14:32.634 --> 01:14:34.803
THE CHARTER SCHOOLS. AUTHORIZING
01:14:34.870 --> 01:14:35.637
SCHOOL DISTRICTS GOVERNING
01:14:35.704 --> 01:14:39.408
BOARD. WHILE PROVIDING A PROCESS
01:14:39.474 --> 01:14:41.510
FOR THE IMPACTED SITTING BOARD
01:14:41.577 --> 01:14:42.644
MEMBER TO FINISH THEIR
01:14:42.711 --> 01:14:44.513
RESPECTIVE TERM OF OFFICE. THIS
01:14:44.580 --> 01:14:48.483
BILL IS SIMPLE. IS A SIMPLE
01:14:48.550 --> 01:14:50.819
SOLUTION TO ENSURE FAIR AND
01:14:50.886 --> 01:14:52.487
DIVERSE REPRESENTATION FOR
01:14:52.554 --> 01:14:53.789
PARENTS, TEACHERS AND STUDENTS
01:14:53.856 --> 01:14:56.859
ON LOCAL SCHOOL BOARDS. COUNTY
01:14:56.925 --> 01:14:58.227
BOARDS OF EDUCATIONS HAVE
01:14:58.293 --> 01:14:59.661
VARIOUS OVERSIGHT
01:14:59.728 --> 01:15:01.997
RESPONSIBILITIES OVER SCHOOLS
01:15:02.064 --> 01:15:04.299
WITHIN THEIR JURISDICTION,
01:15:04.366 --> 01:15:05.901
INCLUDING DECISION MAKING
01:15:05.968 --> 01:15:06.869
REGARDING PUPILS, SUSPENSIONS
01:15:06.935 --> 01:15:09.738
AND EXPULSIONS. REVIEWING SCHOOL
01:15:09.805 --> 01:15:11.840
DISTRICT BUDGETS MONITORING
01:15:11.907 --> 01:15:13.575
EQUAL ACCESS TO INSTRUCTIONAL
01:15:13.642 --> 01:15:15.744
MATERIALS SAFE AND DECENT SCHOOL
01:15:15.811 --> 01:15:16.612
FACILITIES AND QUALIFIED
01:15:16.678 --> 01:15:21.083
TEACHERS. AUTHORIZING AND ALSO
01:15:21.149 --> 01:15:23.051
AUTHORIZING COUNTYWIDE CHARTER
01:15:23.118 --> 01:15:25.087
SCHOOLS, HELPING DISTRICTS AND
01:15:25.153 --> 01:15:27.456
CHARTER SCHOOLS USE THEIR LOCAL
01:15:27.522 --> 01:15:30.058
CONTROL AND ACCOUNTABILITY PLAN.
01:15:30.125 --> 01:15:31.727
CHARTER SCHOOLS, EXECUTIVES OR
01:15:31.793 --> 01:15:34.162
EMPLOYEES SERVING ON EDUCATIONAL
01:15:34.229 --> 01:15:35.664
BOARDS AND THEIR SCHOOLS.
01:15:35.731 --> 01:15:36.732
JURISDICTIONS IS A CONFLICT OF
01:15:36.798 --> 01:15:39.468
INTEREST. WHICH THE ATTORNEY
01:15:39.534 --> 01:15:43.672
GENERAL'S OPINION POINTED OUT A
01:15:43.739 --> 01:15:46.675
B 16 52 WILL PREVENT ANY
01:15:46.742 --> 01:15:48.210
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AND
01:15:48.277 --> 01:15:49.912
ESTABLISH EQUALITY BETWEEN
01:15:49.978 --> 01:15:50.879
CHARTER SCHOOL EMPLOYEES AND
01:15:50.946 --> 01:15:51.813
TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOL
01:15:51.880 --> 01:15:54.583
EMPLOYEES. THANK YOU.
01:15:54.650 --> 01:15:59.922
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. YES YOU'RE
01:15:59.988 --> 01:16:00.989
GOOD. YOU'RE DONE. OKAY. THANK
01:16:01.056 --> 01:16:02.891
YOU, SIR. ALRIGHT I SEE NO LEAD
01:16:02.958 --> 01:16:05.294
SUPPORT, SO WE'LL COME HERE TO
01:16:05.360 --> 01:16:06.628
ROOM 2100 ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
01:16:06.695 --> 01:16:08.797
EXPRESS THEIR SUPPORT SEEING NO
01:16:08.864 --> 01:16:10.732
ONE, MR MODERATOR, WE WILL GO TO
01:16:10.799 --> 01:16:11.900
YOU. PLEASE CURE ANYONE WHO
01:16:11.967 --> 01:16:14.169
WISHES TO EXPRESS THEIR SUPPORT.
01:16:14.236 --> 01:16:19.241
FOR FINAL ITEM 10 A B 16 52. I
01:16:19.308 --> 01:16:20.609
WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY AND
01:16:20.676 --> 01:16:23.111
SUPPORT FOR A B 16 52 PLEASE
01:16:23.178 --> 01:16:25.180
PRESS ONE, POWERED BY 01
01:16:25.247 --> 01:16:34.656
FOLLOWED BY THE RIGHT THIS TIME.
01:16:34.723 --> 01:16:37.059
AND NOBODY IS QUEUING UP.
01:16:37.125 --> 01:16:37.926
ALRIGHT VERY GOOD. THANK YOU, MR
01:16:37.993 --> 01:16:40.128
MODERATOR. WE ALSO HAVE NO LEAD
01:16:40.195 --> 01:16:42.264
OPPOSITION, SO WE'LL GO TO ROOM
01:16:42.331 --> 01:16:44.199
2100. ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
01:16:44.266 --> 01:16:45.200
TESTIFY AND OPPOSITION SEEING
01:16:45.267 --> 01:16:47.235
NO. ONE. MR MODERATOR, WE'RE
01:16:47.302 --> 01:16:48.637
GOING BACK TO YOU. CAN YOU
01:16:48.704 --> 01:16:50.238
PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
01:16:50.305 --> 01:16:51.974
WISHES TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION
01:16:52.040 --> 01:16:56.578
OF A B 16 52? IF YOU ARE IN
01:16:56.645 --> 01:16:58.547
OPPOSITION TO A B 16 52 PLEASE
01:16:58.613 --> 01:17:01.016
PRESS 1081, FOLLOWED BY ZERO FOR
01:17:01.083 --> 01:17:07.823
OPPOSITION TO A B 16 52. AND
01:17:07.889 --> 01:17:10.025
NOBODY IS KILLING UP. THANK YOU,
01:17:10.092 --> 01:17:10.993
MR MODERATOR. WE'LL COME BACK
01:17:11.059 --> 01:17:13.895
HERE TO THE MOVED THE BILL. THE
01:17:13.962 --> 01:17:14.930
BILL HAS BEEN MOVED ANY
01:17:14.997 --> 01:17:16.031
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS?
01:17:16.098 --> 01:17:19.534
SENATOR GLASER. YEAH THANK YOU.
01:17:19.601 --> 01:17:20.902
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S FOR BRINGING
01:17:20.969 --> 01:17:22.471
THIS BILL FORWARD. CONFLICT OF
01:17:22.537 --> 01:17:24.573
INTEREST IS A SERIOUS ISSUE AT
01:17:24.639 --> 01:17:26.274
ALL LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT IN
01:17:26.341 --> 01:17:27.542
TERMS OF BUILDING THE CONFIDENCE
01:17:27.609 --> 01:17:29.344
THAT WE WANT PEOPLE TO HAVE IN
01:17:29.411 --> 01:17:30.879
THE WORK THAT WE DO. AT EVERY
01:17:30.946 --> 01:17:31.780
LEVEL, AND I APPLAUD YOUR
01:17:31.847 --> 01:17:32.814
LEADERSHIP IN THAT SPACE. I HAVE
01:17:32.881 --> 01:17:35.350
A BILL ALSO DEALING WITH IT FOR
01:17:35.417 --> 01:17:36.184
LOCAL OFFICIALS THAT YOU MIGHT
01:17:36.251 --> 01:17:38.220
SEE ON THE OTHER SIDE. HOPEFULLY
01:17:38.286 --> 01:17:39.721
SOMETIME IN THE FUTURE, I NOTE
01:17:39.788 --> 01:17:41.223
THAT THIS BILL IS DOUBLE
01:17:41.289 --> 01:17:41.823
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
01:17:41.890 --> 01:17:42.791
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL
01:17:42.858 --> 01:17:44.993
AMENDMENTS OF WHICH I CHAIR. WE
01:17:45.060 --> 01:17:47.029
LOOK AT THESE ISSUES FROM
01:17:47.095 --> 01:17:47.963
DIFFERENT ANGLES, BUT CERTAINLY
01:17:48.030 --> 01:17:49.297
FROM AN EDUCATION COMMITTEE
01:17:49.364 --> 01:17:50.699
POINT OF VIEW. I THINK IT'S A
01:17:50.766 --> 01:17:51.733
WORTHY BILL, AND I'M HAPPY TO
01:17:51.800 --> 01:17:53.535
SUPPORT IT TODAY. THANK YOU,
01:17:53.602 --> 01:17:54.536
SENATOR GLASER SEEING NO FURTHER
01:17:54.603 --> 01:17:55.237
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
01:17:55.303 --> 01:17:55.771
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S YOU MAKE
01:17:55.837 --> 01:17:57.072
CLOTHES. I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:17:57.139 --> 01:17:59.808
YOUR VOTE. THE BILL'S BEEN MOVED
01:17:59.875 --> 01:18:01.543
BY SENATOR PAN MADAM ASSISTANT.
01:18:01.610 --> 01:18:04.012
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FILE ITEM
01:18:04.079 --> 01:18:06.915
10 A B 16 52. THE MOTION IS DUE
01:18:06.982 --> 01:18:08.383
PAST BUT FIRST WE RE REFERRED TO
01:18:08.450 --> 01:18:10.118
THE COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND
01:18:10.185 --> 01:18:10.786
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS LEAVE.
01:18:10.852 --> 01:18:12.988
LEAVE IT. I CHOSE BOOK. JOBURG
01:18:13.055 --> 01:18:17.759
CORTESI DOLLY! GLASER. GLASER I
01:18:17.826 --> 01:18:20.996
MCGUIRE PAN I THAT BILL HAS
01:18:21.063 --> 01:18:22.931
ENOUGH VOTES TO GET OUT, BUT WE
01:18:22.998 --> 01:18:24.699
WILL LEAVE IT OPEN FOR OUR
01:18:24.766 --> 01:18:25.801
MEMBERS WHO ARE ABSENT. ALRIGHT
01:18:25.867 --> 01:18:29.304
ONE MORE, UH, FILE ITEM 11.
01:18:29.371 --> 01:18:31.139
ASSEMBLY JOINT RESOLUTION. 26
01:18:31.206 --> 01:18:32.641
PLEASE PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE READY
01:18:32.707 --> 01:18:33.842
. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
01:18:33.909 --> 01:18:37.579
MEMBERS PRESENT A JR 26 GR 26
01:18:37.646 --> 01:18:38.814
URGES THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO
01:18:38.880 --> 01:18:41.650
RECONSIDER. THE STUDENT LOAN
01:18:41.716 --> 01:18:43.752
REPAYMENT PLAN FOR ALL STUDENT
01:18:43.819 --> 01:18:44.886
LOANS DETERMINED BY THE PERSONAL
01:18:44.953 --> 01:18:48.023
SAVINGS RATE. PERSONAL SAVINGS
01:18:48.090 --> 01:18:49.391
RATE IS THEPERCENTAGE OF
01:18:49.458 --> 01:18:51.793
DISPOSABLE INCOME THAT PEOPLE
01:18:51.860 --> 01:18:53.662
HAVE AFTER PAYING TAXES, BILLS
01:18:53.728 --> 01:18:55.897
AND GROCERIES. THE STUDENT LOAN
01:18:55.964 --> 01:18:57.365
DEBT IN THE UNITED STATES HAS
01:18:57.432 --> 01:18:59.067
INCREASED BY MORE THAN 100% OVER
01:18:59.134 --> 01:19:02.137
THE LAST 10 YEARS. CURRENTLY
01:19:02.204 --> 01:19:03.672
MORE THAN 3.5. MILLION
01:19:03.738 --> 01:19:06.007
CALIFORNIA BAUER BORROWERS OR
01:19:06.074 --> 01:19:08.443
140 BILLION IN FEDERAL STUDENT
01:19:08.510 --> 01:19:11.980
LOANS. THE INCREASING COST OF
01:19:12.047 --> 01:19:13.982
HIGHER EDUCATION HAS BEEN EVEN
01:19:14.049 --> 01:19:15.250
MORE BURDENSOME FOR COMMUNITIES
01:19:15.317 --> 01:19:20.455
OF COLOR. 37% OF HISPANIC POWERS
01:19:20.522 --> 01:19:21.256
DELAYED GETTING MARRIED OR
01:19:21.323 --> 01:19:23.291
HAVING CHILDREN DUE TO STUDENT
01:19:23.358 --> 01:19:26.294
DEBT AND ABOUT 46% OF BLACK
01:19:26.361 --> 01:19:27.429
STUDENT BORROWERS HAVE PUT OFF
01:19:27.496 --> 01:19:28.663
BUYING A HOUSE DUE TO THEIR
01:19:28.730 --> 01:19:30.365
STUDENT DEBT. AMONG BLACK
01:19:30.432 --> 01:19:34.269
STUDENT BORROWERS OR ON INCOME
01:19:34.336 --> 01:19:36.404
DRIVEN REPAYMENT PLAN 71% HAVE
01:19:36.471 --> 01:19:39.141
DO NOT HAVE A SAVINGS ACCOUNT.
01:19:39.207 --> 01:19:40.142
THEREFORE, THE PERSONAL SAVINGS
01:19:40.208 --> 01:19:43.778
RATE SHOULD BE THE DETERMINING
01:19:43.845 --> 01:19:45.313
FACTOR OF THE STUDENT LOAN
01:19:45.380 --> 01:19:47.082
REPAYMENT RATE BASED ON INCOME
01:19:47.149 --> 01:19:50.418
LEFT OVER AFTER MONTHLY BUILDS.
01:19:50.485 --> 01:19:52.120
THIS NEW RATE OF STUDENT LOAN
01:19:52.187 --> 01:19:53.688
REPAYMENT PLAN WOULD GIVE
01:19:53.755 --> 01:19:55.757
BORROWERS PEACE OF MIND ON
01:19:55.824 --> 01:19:57.459
REPAYMENTS WHILE HELPING THEM
01:19:57.526 --> 01:19:59.361
SAVE FOR TRADITIONAL LIFE
01:19:59.427 --> 01:20:00.562
MILESTONES. THIS WOULD ALSO URGE
01:20:00.629 --> 01:20:02.797
MORE STUDENTS OF COLOR. TO
01:20:02.864 --> 01:20:04.766
ENROLL IN HIGHER EDUCATION
01:20:04.833 --> 01:20:06.935
INSTITUTIONS WITHOUT FEAR OF
01:20:07.002 --> 01:20:08.403
BEING BURDENED BY STUDENT LOAN
01:20:08.470 --> 01:20:11.206
REPAYMENTS. AGUILAR 26 URGES THE
01:20:11.273 --> 01:20:12.407
SECRETARY OF EDUCATION TO
01:20:12.474 --> 01:20:15.310
ESTABLISH AND SUBMIT CONGRESS
01:20:15.377 --> 01:20:17.479
FOR APPROVAL A MONTHLY STUDENT
01:20:17.546 --> 01:20:19.748
LOAN PAYMENT PLAN FOR ALL
01:20:19.814 --> 01:20:21.416
STUDENTS LOAN CENTERED ON THE
01:20:21.483 --> 01:20:23.552
MONTHLY PERSONAL SAVINGS RATE. I
01:20:23.618 --> 01:20:25.820
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I VOTE.
01:20:25.887 --> 01:20:27.222
THANK YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S I
01:20:27.289 --> 01:20:28.356
HAVE NO ONE LISTED AS LEAD
01:20:28.423 --> 01:20:30.792
SUPPORT. THAT CORRECT? CORRECT
01:20:30.859 --> 01:20:32.360
OKAY. VERY GOOD. ANYONE HERE
01:20:32.427 --> 01:20:34.462
ROOM 2100 WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY
01:20:34.529 --> 01:20:37.165
AND SUPPORT. PLEASE PROCEED.
01:20:37.232 --> 01:20:39.467
JUST TO MEET YOU. GOLDMAN ON
01:20:39.534 --> 01:20:40.035
BEHALF OF THE FACULTY
01:20:40.101 --> 01:20:41.269
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
01:20:41.336 --> 01:20:42.437
COMMUNITY COLLEGES AND SUPPORT
01:20:42.504 --> 01:20:46.141
pMR. MODERATOR CAN YOU PLEASE
01:20:46.208 --> 01:20:47.676
QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
01:20:47.742 --> 01:20:50.679
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A J. R. 26?
01:20:50.745 --> 01:20:53.281
IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A JR
01:20:53.348 --> 01:20:54.749
26, PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED
01:20:54.816 --> 01:20:56.785
BY ZERO, PLEASE PRESS 10 FOR A
01:20:56.851 --> 01:21:05.126
JR. 26 ONE MOMENT, PLEASE. AND
01:21:05.193 --> 01:21:06.261
NO PARTICIPANTS ARE QUEUING UP
01:21:06.328 --> 01:21:08.930
AT THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
01:21:08.997 --> 01:21:11.366
MODERATOR. WE ALSO HAVE NO LEAD
01:21:11.433 --> 01:21:13.168
OPPOSITION, SO WE WILL COME TO
01:21:13.235 --> 01:21:15.136
2100 ANYONE WHO WISHES TO OPPOSE
01:21:15.203 --> 01:21:17.038
SEEING NO ONE. MR MODERATOR,
01:21:17.105 --> 01:21:18.573
WE'RE GOING BACK TO YOU. PLEASE
01:21:18.640 --> 01:21:20.408
QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
01:21:20.475 --> 01:21:22.277
SPEAK IN OPPOSITION TO A J. R.
01:21:22.344 --> 01:21:25.647
26. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO TESTIFY
01:21:25.714 --> 01:21:27.349
IN OPPOSITIONTO A J. R 26.
01:21:27.415 --> 01:21:34.155
PLEASE PRESS 1010 AT THIS TIME.
01:21:34.222 --> 01:21:35.290
MADAM CHAIR. NOBODY IS QUEUING
01:21:35.357 --> 01:21:39.261
OUT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, AND,
01:21:39.327 --> 01:21:40.395
UM BEFORE, LET'S BRING IT BACK
01:21:40.462 --> 01:21:45.767
TO THE COMMITTEE. OKAY THE BILL
01:21:45.834 --> 01:21:47.168
, ALL RIGHT? THE BILL HAS BEEN
01:21:47.235 --> 01:21:48.903
MOVED AND I DO BELIEVE THERE
01:21:48.970 --> 01:21:50.505
WERE AMENDMENTS. AND ARE YOU
01:21:50.572 --> 01:21:51.806
ACCEPTING THE COMMUNITY
01:21:51.873 --> 01:21:53.441
AMENDMENTS? YES EXCELLENT. THANK
01:21:53.508 --> 01:21:54.843
YOU VERY MUCH. ALRIGHT THE BILL
01:21:54.909 --> 01:21:57.245
HAS BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR PAN.
01:21:57.312 --> 01:21:58.346
MADAM ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE
01:21:58.413 --> 01:22:06.121
ROLL. FILE ITEM 11 A JR 26. THE
01:22:06.187 --> 01:22:07.989
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED.
01:22:08.056 --> 01:22:10.659
LABOR LEVI SHOWBOAT JOBURG LIKE
01:22:10.725 --> 01:22:15.263
ORTEZ E DELI. SALLY I. GLASER
01:22:15.330 --> 01:22:20.268
GLASER. I MCGUIRE PAN. THAT BILL
01:22:20.335 --> 01:22:22.637
HAS ENOUGH VOTES TO GET OUT, BUT
01:22:22.704 --> 01:22:24.439
WE'LL LEAVE IT OPEN FOR ABSENT
01:22:24.506 --> 01:22:26.141
MEMBERS. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MEDINA
01:22:26.207 --> 01:22:27.642
. IT'S BEEN A PLEASURE WORKING
01:22:27.709 --> 01:22:29.277
WITH YOU AND THANK YOU FOR
01:22:29.344 --> 01:22:30.111
EVERYTHING YOU'VE DONE FOR
01:22:30.178 --> 01:22:31.880
HIGHER EDUCATION, EDUCATION IN
01:22:31.946 --> 01:22:33.114
GENERAL. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR.
01:22:33.181 --> 01:22:34.115
YOU'RE WELCOME. HAVE A GREAT
01:22:34.182 --> 01:22:35.817
REST OF THE DAY. ALL RIGHT. WE
01:22:35.884 --> 01:22:38.586
ARE LOOKING FOR AUTHORS. IF YOU
01:22:38.653 --> 01:22:40.488
HAVE A BILL TO PRESENT AND
01:22:40.555 --> 01:22:57.539
SENATE EDUCATION COME ON DOWN.
01:26:31.486 --> 01:26:36.190
WELCOME ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. KANSEN
01:26:36.257 --> 01:26:41.296
NO, I'M GOOD RIGHT NOW. ARE YOU
01:26:41.362 --> 01:26:43.798
OKAY? GOOD DID YOU RUN OVER HERE
01:26:43.865 --> 01:26:45.333
? KIND OF GOOD. THANK YOU. WE
01:26:45.400 --> 01:26:48.202
LIKE THAT YOU GO. ALRIGHT
01:26:48.269 --> 01:26:49.671
WELCOME. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
01:26:49.737 --> 01:26:50.705
RODRIGUEZ. YOU'RE HERE TO
01:26:50.772 --> 01:26:53.408
PRESENT FILE ITEM SIX A. B 5 24.
01:26:53.474 --> 01:26:55.043
PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE READY. THANK
01:26:55.109 --> 01:26:57.545
YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. THANK
01:26:57.612 --> 01:26:59.581
YOU ONCE AGAIN FOR ALLOWING ME
01:26:59.647 --> 01:27:01.583
TO PRESENT A B 5 24, WHICH WOULD
01:27:01.649 --> 01:27:02.417
REQUIRE SORORITIES AND
01:27:02.483 --> 01:27:03.551
FRATERNITIES TO SUBMIT TO
01:27:03.618 --> 01:27:05.787
INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER LEARNING
01:27:05.853 --> 01:27:08.022
SPECIFIC INFORMATION, INCLUDING
01:27:08.089 --> 01:27:09.657
GRADE POINT AVERAGES, COMMUNITY
01:27:09.724 --> 01:27:11.693
SERVICE HOURS AND MONEY RATES
01:27:11.759 --> 01:27:12.860
WITHIN THEIR MEMBERSHIP, AS WELL
01:27:12.927 --> 01:27:16.030
AS OTHER INFORMATION. THIS BILL
01:27:16.097 --> 01:27:17.899
ALSO REQUIRES INSTITUTIONS ARE
01:27:17.966 --> 01:27:19.434
COMPILED AND MAINTAIN, COLLECT
01:27:19.500 --> 01:27:20.535
THE INFORMATION INTO PUBLICLY
01:27:20.602 --> 01:27:23.905
ACCESSIBLE REPORT. AND THESE
01:27:23.972 --> 01:27:25.006
REPORTS, INSTITUTIONS WILL
01:27:25.073 --> 01:27:26.708
REQUIRED TO REPORT THE NUMBER OF
01:27:26.774 --> 01:27:27.809
CITATIONS OR DISCIPLINARY
01:27:27.875 --> 01:27:31.245
ACTIONS TAKEN. T<c.cyan> MISCONDUCT AT</c>
01:27:31.312 --> 01:27:33.414
A CHAPTER HOUSE OR SANCTIONED
01:27:33.481 --> 01:27:34.482
EVENT FOR EACH SORORITY AND
01:27:34.549 --> 01:27:37.285
FRATERNITY. THIS REPORT WOULD BE
01:27:37.352 --> 01:27:38.686
PUBLISHED ON THE CAMPUS, GREEK
01:27:38.753 --> 01:27:39.754
LIFE INTERNET HOMEPAGE AND SENT
01:27:39.821 --> 01:27:42.156
TO ALL STUDENTS ANNUALLY. ALL
01:27:42.223 --> 01:27:43.591
THE INFORMATION REPORTED WOULD
01:27:43.658 --> 01:27:46.461
ADHERE TO FEDERAL AND STATE
01:27:46.527 --> 01:27:48.129
PRIVACY LAWS, INCLUDING FERPA.
01:27:48.196 --> 01:27:49.497
BECAUSE THESE INCIDENTS IN GREEK
01:27:49.564 --> 01:27:51.132
LIFE ORGANIZATIONS CAN HAVE
01:27:51.199 --> 01:27:52.634
SEVERE IMPACTS ON STUDENTS AND
01:27:52.700 --> 01:27:54.802
THEIR FAMILIES. STUDENTS SHOULD
01:27:54.869 --> 01:27:56.304
HAVE MORE INFORMATION ABOUT
01:27:56.371 --> 01:27:56.938
ORGANIZATION ORGANIZATION. THEY
01:27:57.005 --> 01:27:59.407
PLAN TO JOIN. THIS BILL WOULD
01:27:59.474 --> 01:28:00.575
INCREASE TRANSPARENCY, WHICH IS
01:28:00.642 --> 01:28:02.310
A KEY PIECE TO KEEPING OUR
01:28:02.377 --> 01:28:05.213
STUDENTS SAFE. WITH ME TODAY TO
01:28:05.279 --> 01:28:07.415
PROVIDE TESTIMONY IS ALIAS SKY
01:28:07.482 --> 01:28:08.983
AND ELENA BARCELONA WAS STUDENTS
01:28:09.050 --> 01:28:12.053
AGAINST SEXUAL ASSAULT. VERY
01:28:12.120 --> 01:28:12.854
GOOD. THANK YOU.
01:28:12.920 --> 01:28:14.822
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ALRIGHT. LOOKS
01:28:14.889 --> 01:28:15.890
LIKE BOTH OF YOUR WITNESSES ARE
01:28:15.957 --> 01:28:17.892
CALLING IN MR MODERATOR. IF YOU
01:28:17.959 --> 01:28:19.260
CAN PLEASE QUEUE UP ALANA
01:28:19.327 --> 01:28:22.263
BARTOLINI AND AALIYAH SKY.
01:28:22.330 --> 01:28:24.098
PLEASE GO AHEAD. WE HAVE TWO
01:28:24.165 --> 01:28:31.105
MINUTES. ALANA WOULD YOU LIKE TO
01:28:31.172 --> 01:28:32.907
START MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE?
01:28:32.974 --> 01:28:34.542
OH, HELLO? YES RESPECTED MEMBERS
01:28:34.609 --> 01:28:35.943
OF THE COMMITTEE. GOOD MORNING.
01:28:36.010 --> 01:28:37.045
MY NAME IS ELENA BAR CELLINI,
01:28:37.111 --> 01:28:40.214
AND I AM THE POLICY DIRECTOR OF
01:28:40.281 --> 01:28:40.815
THE NONPROFIT STUDENTS AGAINST
01:28:40.882 --> 01:28:41.582
SEXUAL ASSAULT. OUR ORGANIZATION
01:28:41.649 --> 01:28:45.687
IS CO SPONSORING 85 24. SO I'M A
01:28:45.753 --> 01:28:48.156
PHD CANDIDATE AT UCSD, AND I'VE
01:28:48.222 --> 01:28:49.357
BEEN TEACHING AT THE UNIVERSITY
01:28:49.424 --> 01:28:51.292
FOR SEVEN YEARS, MOSTLY AS A T A
01:28:51.359 --> 01:28:53.027
GOOD TWO YEARS AS A TEACHER, BUT
01:28:53.094 --> 01:28:54.929
ALSO A BIT OF A BIG SISTER
01:28:54.996 --> 01:28:56.064
FRIEND THAT THERAPIST SHOULDER
01:28:56.130 --> 01:28:58.032
TO CRY ON. WE KNOW THAT LEARNING
01:28:58.099 --> 01:28:59.867
IS SOCIAL, AND WHEN WE INVEST IN
01:28:59.934 --> 01:29:00.802
THEM, THEY INVEST MORE IN THE
01:29:00.868 --> 01:29:02.970
WORK AND IN THEMSELVES. THIS IS
01:29:03.037 --> 01:29:04.906
THE DUTY OF A TEACHER, BUT WHEN
01:29:04.972 --> 01:29:06.574
IT COMES TWO UCSB. THERE'S A BIT
01:29:06.641 --> 01:29:07.909
OF A DARKER SIDE THAT I'VE
01:29:07.975 --> 01:29:09.811
EXPERIENCED. I HAVE ABOUT ONE
01:29:09.877 --> 01:29:10.945
STUDENT A QUARTER COME FORWARD
01:29:11.012 --> 01:29:12.046
AND DISCLOSED THAT THEY'VE BEEN
01:29:12.113 --> 01:29:12.647
SEXUALLY ASSAULTED. WHERE WEEK
01:29:12.714 --> 01:29:14.515
10 OF THE SPRING QUARTER I'VE
01:29:14.582 --> 01:29:15.750
HAD TWO GIRLS COME FORWARD BY
01:29:15.817 --> 01:29:19.420
WEEK SIX. THE STATISTICS SIGNAL
01:29:19.487 --> 01:29:21.022
A CRISIS BETWEEN ONE AND FOUR
01:29:21.089 --> 01:29:22.390
AND ONE AND FIVE STUDENTS WILL
01:29:22.457 --> 01:29:23.357
EXPERIENCE SEXUAL ASSAULT IN
01:29:23.424 --> 01:29:25.426
THEIR TIME AT THE UNIVERSITY AND
01:29:25.493 --> 01:29:26.060
THE ALLEGED PERPETRATORS, YOU'RE
01:29:26.127 --> 01:29:27.261
THREE TIMES AS LIKELY TO BE
01:29:27.328 --> 01:29:29.297
ASSOCIATED WITH GREEK LIFE. MY
01:29:29.363 --> 01:29:31.332
EXPERIENCE. THERE'S THIS HOUSE.
01:29:31.399 --> 01:29:32.533
I JUST THOUGHT 1000 STUDENTS IN
01:29:32.600 --> 01:29:36.471
MY TIME AT UCSB. 20 TO 25% OF
01:29:36.537 --> 01:29:39.674
pSO LADIES AND GENTLEMEN OF THE
01:29:39.741 --> 01:29:41.042
COMMITTEE I'M HERE TO IMPLORE
01:29:41.109 --> 01:29:42.710
YOU TO VOTE ON THIS BILL. WE
01:29:42.777 --> 01:29:44.178
WILL NOT END RAPE CULTURE IN ONE
01:29:44.245 --> 01:29:46.080
FILM BLUE AND THE PROBLEM IS
01:29:46.147 --> 01:29:47.315
BIGGER THAN ONE BILL CAN MANAGE.
01:29:47.381 --> 01:29:49.150
CULTURAL CHANGE IS LIKE STEERING
01:29:49.217 --> 01:29:51.285
A BIG SHIP. IT WILL TAKE TIME TO
01:29:51.352 --> 01:29:53.054
CHANGE THE COURSE. BUT WHAT THIS
01:29:53.121 --> 01:29:54.122
BILL DOES. THAT IS SO VITALLY
01:29:54.188 --> 01:29:55.823
IMPORTANT IS IT ALLOWS FOR
01:29:55.890 --> 01:29:56.858
UNIVERSITIES TOGETHER AND
01:29:56.924 --> 01:29:57.792
EXAMINE INFORMATION IN A NEW
01:29:57.859 --> 01:30:00.228
WAY. IT WILL EMPOWER THEM TO
01:30:00.294 --> 01:30:01.529
COLLECT AND INTERPRET DATA
01:30:01.596 --> 01:30:02.663
SURROUNDING ISSUES OF SEXUAL
01:30:02.730 --> 01:30:04.031
MISCONDUCT IN MORE NUANCED WAYS,
01:30:04.098 --> 01:30:05.800
AND THEY ARE ABLE TO DO NOW AND
01:30:05.867 --> 01:30:07.835
TO DO IT IN A UNIFORM WAY ACROSS
01:30:07.902 --> 01:30:09.036
CAMPUSES. DATA IS USEFUL BECAUSE
01:30:09.103 --> 01:30:11.939
IT REVEALS PATTERNS. AND THOSE
01:30:12.006 --> 01:30:13.241
PATTERNS TELL A STORY AND THE
01:30:13.307 --> 01:30:15.176
TIME TO TELL THIS STORY IS NOW
01:30:15.243 --> 01:30:17.645
THE AWFUL TRUTH IS WE ARE IN AN
01:30:17.712 --> 01:30:18.780
EPIDEMIC OF IMPUNITY AND SCHOOLS
01:30:18.846 --> 01:30:19.981
SHOULD BE SAFE PLACE. THE POLICE
01:30:20.047 --> 01:30:23.017
ARE ON 85 24. THANK YOU. THANK
01:30:23.084 --> 01:30:25.319
YOU VERY MUCH. ALRIGHT WE'RE NOW
01:30:25.386 --> 01:30:26.521
GOING TO GO TO AALIYAH SKY YOU
01:30:26.587 --> 01:30:31.626
HAVE TWO MINUTES ALSO. THANK YOU
01:30:31.692 --> 01:30:33.060
RESPECT THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
01:30:33.127 --> 01:30:34.762
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
01:30:34.829 --> 01:30:36.631
TESTIFY TODAY. MY NAME IS JULIA
01:30:36.697 --> 01:30:39.000
SKY AND I SERVE AS THE HISTORY,
01:30:39.066 --> 01:30:40.501
EDUCATION AND RESEARCH DIRECTOR
01:30:40.568 --> 01:30:41.736
FOR STUDENTS AGAINST SEXUAL
01:30:41.803 --> 01:30:42.870
ASSAULT, THE CO SPONSOR OF HB 5
01:30:42.937 --> 01:30:46.541
24. THIS BILL IS MEANT TO BRING
01:30:46.607 --> 01:30:48.543
MORE TRANSPARENCY TO THE
01:30:48.609 --> 01:30:49.977
PERVASIVE CULTURE OF SEXUAL
01:30:50.044 --> 01:30:51.512
VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT THAT
01:30:51.579 --> 01:30:52.880
OCCURS WITHIN FRATERNITIES AND
01:30:52.947 --> 01:30:55.349
SORORITIES THAT COLLEGES IT IS
01:30:55.416 --> 01:30:56.818
NECESSARY BECAUSE IT ALLOWS
01:30:56.884 --> 01:30:58.920
STUDENTS TO HAVE MORE CONTROL
01:30:58.986 --> 01:31:00.655
OVER CHOICES THAT IMPACT THEIR
01:31:00.721 --> 01:31:01.622
SAFETY AND PRESENT THEM WITH
01:31:01.689 --> 01:31:02.723
MORE INFORMATION TO MAKE THESE
01:31:02.790 --> 01:31:06.160
CHOICES. FIVE UNDERGRADUATE AT
01:31:06.227 --> 01:31:08.429
UCSB STUDENTS CAN SEXUAL ASSAULT
01:31:08.496 --> 01:31:10.064
CONDUCTED A SURVEY OF THE CSP
01:31:10.131 --> 01:31:12.200
STUDENTS, WHICH INDICATED THAT
01:31:12.266 --> 01:31:14.502
LIST INTO RESPONDED, 28%
01:31:14.569 --> 01:31:15.636
REPORTED THEY WERE HARASSED AT A
01:31:15.703 --> 01:31:16.804
FRATERNITY HOUSE OR ANNEX
01:31:16.871 --> 01:31:20.908
LOCATION. OPPORTUNITIES ARE ALSO
01:31:20.975 --> 01:31:21.976
THE MOST REPORTED SINGLE
01:31:22.043 --> 01:31:23.511
LOCATION OF SEXUAL MISCONDUCT
01:31:23.578 --> 01:31:26.581
FOUND ON THIS SURVEY. DURING MY
01:31:26.647 --> 01:31:28.716
FOUR YEARS AT U. C S C AND THREE
01:31:28.783 --> 01:31:29.951
YEARS AS A STUDENT WORKING ON
01:31:30.017 --> 01:31:30.985
ADVOCACY AROUND ENDING SEXUAL
01:31:31.052 --> 01:31:33.287
VIOLENCE. I FOUND THAT AND IT'S
01:31:33.354 --> 01:31:35.556
TOTALLY THE MAJORITY OF THOSE
01:31:35.623 --> 01:31:37.058
WHO RECOUNTED THEIR EXPERIENCES
01:31:37.124 --> 01:31:37.925
OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE AND
01:31:37.992 --> 01:31:40.361
HARASSMENT. TO ME WERE STUDENTS
01:31:40.428 --> 01:31:41.362
PARTICIPATING IN GREEK LIFE
01:31:41.429 --> 01:31:43.998
ORGANIZATIONS. THIS WOULD BE
01:31:44.065 --> 01:31:45.366
ESPECIALLY IMPASSABLE FOR
01:31:45.433 --> 01:31:46.567
PROVIDING FIRST YEAR AND
01:31:46.634 --> 01:31:47.602
TRANSFER STUDENTS WITH THE
01:31:47.668 --> 01:31:49.804
INFORMATION NECESSARY TO MAKE
01:31:49.871 --> 01:31:51.339
EDUCATED CHOICES ABOUT WHERE
01:31:51.405 --> 01:31:53.207
THEY GO TO SOCIALIZE. WHAT WE'RE
01:31:53.274 --> 01:31:54.475
GOING TO IZATION TO JOIN AS THEY
01:31:54.542 --> 01:31:56.544
INTERACT WITH OBOE, ENABLING
01:31:56.611 --> 01:31:59.180
MORE EDUCATED, EDUCATED CHOICES
01:31:59.247 --> 01:32:00.281
CANNOT END ALL INCIDENTS OF
01:32:00.348 --> 01:32:02.550
SEXUAL VIOLENCE AND HARASSMENT.
01:32:02.617 --> 01:32:03.818
IT CAN BRING MORE TRANSPARENCY
01:32:03.885 --> 01:32:04.752
TO WHERE THESE ASSAULTS
01:32:04.819 --> 01:32:06.554
OCCURRED. AND PROVIDES STUDENTS
01:32:06.621 --> 01:32:07.588
AND INSTITUTIONS WITH MORE
01:32:07.655 --> 01:32:10.458
INFORMATION. HOPEFULLY THIS WILL
01:32:10.524 --> 01:32:12.026
LAST COLLEGES TO MAKE NECESSARY
01:32:12.093 --> 01:32:13.160
CHANGES IN THEIR METHOD OF
01:32:13.227 --> 01:32:14.962
COMBATING THIS EPIDEMIC. I
01:32:15.029 --> 01:32:18.299
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOU TO VOTE. I
01:32:18.366 --> 01:32:20.001
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT.
01:32:20.067 --> 01:32:21.903
WE WILL NOW COME TO ROOM 2100
01:32:21.969 --> 01:32:23.104
FOR ANYONE WHO WISHES TO EXPRESS
01:32:23.170 --> 01:32:26.407
SUPPORT. SEEING NO ONE. MR
01:32:26.474 --> 01:32:28.209
MODERATOR, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO
01:32:28.276 --> 01:32:29.510
YOU. PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
01:32:29.577 --> 01:32:31.345
WISHES TO EXPRESS THEIR SUPPORT
01:32:31.412 --> 01:32:35.883
FOR A B 5 24. THANK YOU IF YOU
01:32:35.950 --> 01:32:37.852
ARE IN SUPPLY AND SUPPORT OF A B
01:32:37.919 --> 01:32:40.254
5 24 TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY AND
01:32:40.321 --> 01:32:42.657
PRESS £1.00 AT THIS TIME. ONE
01:32:42.723 --> 01:32:45.459
FALL BY ZERO. SUPPORT FOR A B 5
01:32:45.526 --> 01:32:51.966
24. 9 67, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI MY
01:32:52.033 --> 01:32:53.768
NAME IS ALEX NILES AND I SERVED
01:32:53.834 --> 01:32:55.269
AS CHAIR OF GOVERNMENT RELATIONS
01:32:55.336 --> 01:32:57.905
FOR THE UC STUDENTS ASSOCIATION
01:32:57.972 --> 01:32:59.573
ASSOCIATION REPRESENTS ALL OF
01:32:59.640 --> 01:33:01.008
225,000 YOU SEE UNDERGRADUATE
01:33:01.075 --> 01:33:03.144
STUDENTS, FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. UM
01:33:03.210 --> 01:33:05.947
U. C S A JOINTS ASTON CO
01:33:06.013 --> 01:33:09.617
SPONSORING THIS BILL. AND OUR
01:33:09.684 --> 01:33:11.152
CONSTITUENTS FEEL THAT THIS
01:33:11.218 --> 01:33:11.786
ISN'T PROVIDES ESSENTIAL
01:33:11.852 --> 01:33:13.354
TRANSPARENCY, SAFETY INFORMATION
01:33:13.421 --> 01:33:15.923
FOR COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND DATA
01:33:15.990 --> 01:33:17.091
FOR THE UNIVERSITY TO ACT ON
01:33:17.158 --> 01:33:18.993
THIS PROBLEM. THANK YOU. THANK
01:33:19.060 --> 01:33:23.564
YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU. AND
01:33:23.631 --> 01:33:25.433
NEXT WEEK, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO
01:33:25.499 --> 01:33:29.904
THE LINE 61. HOW DO YOU MY NAME
01:33:29.971 --> 01:33:33.174
IS CAROLINA PHOBIA. HIâU FAVOR
01:33:33.240 --> 01:33:34.308
PRONOUNCED ON THE FIFTH YEAR
01:33:34.375 --> 01:33:36.210
STUDENT AT UC SANTA BARBARA AND
01:33:36.277 --> 01:33:38.245
I SERVED AS THE VICE PRESIDENT
01:33:38.312 --> 01:33:40.247
FOR STATE. WHAT IF THERE'S AND I
01:33:40.314 --> 01:33:41.248
CONCURRENTLY SERVE AS <c.cyan>/C</c>
01:33:41.315 --> 01:33:42.450
STUDENT ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT?
01:33:42.516 --> 01:33:44.885
I'M HERE TO VOICE MY SUPPORT IN
01:33:44.952 --> 01:33:47.822
FAVOR OF 85 24 SURVIVOR MYSELF
01:33:47.888 --> 01:33:49.056
WHEN HE WAS DEALT WITH SEXUAL
01:33:49.123 --> 01:33:51.392
VIOLENCE FROM A SIMPLE THANK YOU
01:33:51.459 --> 01:33:52.460
COMMITTEES TO CONSIDER PASSING
01:33:52.526 --> 01:33:53.027
THIS LEGISLATION. THANK YOU.
01:33:53.094 --> 01:33:59.800
THANK YOU. AND NEXT IS MINE 66
01:33:59.867 --> 01:34:00.735
FOR ANYBODY ELSE. I'LL GIVE A
01:34:00.801 --> 01:34:02.803
FINAL REMINDER, PLEASE PRESS 10
01:34:02.870 --> 01:34:04.805
TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR A B 5 24
01:34:04.872 --> 01:34:09.310
WINE. 66, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:34:09.377 --> 01:34:10.911
EVERYONE. MY NAME IS BECKY
01:34:10.978 --> 01:34:13.447
PAASKE WORDS. I AM A MEMBER OF
01:34:13.514 --> 01:34:14.448
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
01:34:14.515 --> 01:34:16.484
STUDENT ASSOCIATION, SPONSOR OF
01:34:16.550 --> 01:34:19.520
THE STOVE ON A FORMER MEMBER AND
01:34:19.587 --> 01:34:20.421
LEADER OF SORORITY AND
01:34:20.488 --> 01:34:23.290
FRATERNITY LIFE AT UC SAN DIEGO.
01:34:23.357 --> 01:34:25.359
AS A MEMBER OF GREAT LIFE. I'VE
01:34:25.426 --> 01:34:29.330
SEEN IT. COUNTLESS CASES OF
01:34:29.397 --> 01:34:30.598
SEXUAL ASSAULT AND SEXUAL
01:34:30.664 --> 01:34:33.801
HARASSMENT IN GROUP FIVE. IT IS
01:34:33.868 --> 01:34:35.336
, UM, TO BE QUITE HONEST,
01:34:35.403 --> 01:34:37.405
PERVASIVE THROUGHOUT THE
01:34:37.471 --> 01:34:40.674
INSTITUTION, AND I WOULD REALLY
01:34:40.741 --> 01:34:42.810
TO SEE GREATER TRANSPARENCY
01:34:42.877 --> 01:34:44.412
AFFORDED. THANK YOU. WE'RE GOING
01:34:44.478 --> 01:34:46.180
TO GO TO OUR NEXT CALLER. THANK
01:34:46.247 --> 01:34:48.949
YOU. THANK YOU. MIXED IS LYING.
01:34:49.016 --> 01:34:55.256
82 YOU'RE UP. HELLO MY NAME IS
01:34:55.322 --> 01:34:58.192
MARVIN TO I AM A C SP STUDENT
01:34:58.259 --> 01:35:00.661
. I'M THE INCOMING EXTERNAL VICE
01:35:00.728 --> 01:35:02.229
PRESIDENT FOR STATEWIDE AFFAIRS
01:35:02.296 --> 01:35:04.265
AND I ALSO SERVE ON THE BOARD OF
01:35:04.331 --> 01:35:05.766
THE USE USE EATING THE
01:35:05.833 --> 01:35:06.834
ASSOCIATION AND I'M HERE TO
01:35:06.901 --> 01:35:10.304
VOICE UM STRONG SUPPORT FOR 85
01:35:10.371 --> 01:35:12.706
24 URGED THE COMMITTEE TO VOTE
01:35:12.773 --> 01:35:15.443
BY ON THE BILL BECAUSE YOU NEXT
01:35:15.509 --> 01:35:17.211
CALLER, PLEASE MAKE INFORMED
01:35:17.278 --> 01:35:20.047
DECISIONS ABOUT, UM, THE ORDER
01:35:20.114 --> 01:35:21.816
MODERATOR. NEXT CALLER, PLEASE
01:35:21.882 --> 01:35:22.950
ORGANIZATIONS THAT THERE WILL BE
01:35:23.017 --> 01:35:26.420
MADAM SHERIFF. YES WE HAVE
01:35:26.487 --> 01:35:27.955
EXHAUSTED THE QUÊ. OKAY, GREAT.
01:35:28.022 --> 01:35:28.989
I'LL JUST REMIND FOLKS THAT WHEN
01:35:29.056 --> 01:35:30.524
WE GET TO THE COLLARS, YOU'RE
01:35:30.591 --> 01:35:31.992
JUST TO STATE YOUR NAME AND
01:35:32.059 --> 01:35:33.427
SUPPORT HER OPPOSITION TO THE
01:35:33.494 --> 01:35:35.529
BILL. WE HAVE NO LEAD OPPOSITION
01:35:35.596 --> 01:35:36.797
ON THIS BILL. IS THERE ANYONE
01:35:36.864 --> 01:35:38.032
HERE IN 2100, WHO WISHES TO
01:35:38.099 --> 01:35:40.935
TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION? SEEING NO
01:35:41.001 --> 01:35:41.836
ONE. MR MODERATOR, WE'RE GOING
01:35:41.902 --> 01:35:44.038
TO GO BACK TO YOU. PLEASE QUEUE
01:35:44.105 --> 01:35:45.473
UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO EXPRESS
01:35:45.539 --> 01:35:49.910
OPPOSITION TO A B 5 24. MADAM
01:35:49.977 --> 01:35:51.512
CHAIR SAID. IF YOU'RE IN
01:35:51.579 --> 01:35:53.147
OPPOSITION TO A B 5 24 PLEASE
01:35:53.214 --> 01:35:59.186
PRESS 101, FOLLOWED BY ZERO.
01:35:59.253 --> 01:36:00.754
NOBODY IS QUEUING UP AT THIS
01:36:00.821 --> 01:36:03.657
TIME. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU, MR
01:36:03.724 --> 01:36:04.725
MODERATOR. I'LL BRING IT BACK TO
01:36:04.792 --> 01:36:05.693
THE COMMITTEE. QUESTIONS,
01:36:05.759 --> 01:36:08.596
COMMENTS CONCERNS SENATOR PAN.
01:36:08.662 --> 01:36:10.831
THANK YOU. SUMMER RODRIGUEZ FOR
01:36:10.898 --> 01:36:11.932
BRINGING THIS BILL FORWARD
01:36:11.999 --> 01:36:14.969
APPRECIATE. WHAT YOU AND YOUR
01:36:15.035 --> 01:36:16.804
SPONSOR TRYING TO DO BECAUSE MY
01:36:16.871 --> 01:36:17.905
QUESTION IS BECAUSE WHEN THE
01:36:17.972 --> 01:36:19.039
ISSUES IS PRIVACY, RIGHT, AND,
01:36:19.106 --> 01:36:21.876
UM WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF
01:36:21.942 --> 01:36:23.377
ACTUALLY HAVING TO REPORT THE
01:36:23.444 --> 01:36:24.845
GRADE POINT AVERAGE OF THE
01:36:24.912 --> 01:36:26.614
MEMBERSHIP AND THE NEW MEMBERS?
01:36:26.680 --> 01:36:28.716
IN OTHER WORDS, I HEAR A LOT OF
01:36:28.782 --> 01:36:29.650
STUFF ABOUT SEXUAL ASSAULT AND
01:36:29.717 --> 01:36:31.352
SO FORTH. I DON'T THINK WE'VE
01:36:31.418 --> 01:36:32.153
SEEN STUDIES CORRELATING SEXUAL
01:36:32.219 --> 01:36:33.120
ASSAULT WITH SOMEONE'S GRADE
01:36:33.187 --> 01:36:35.789
POINT AVERAGE. AND I HAVE
01:36:35.856 --> 01:36:36.824
CONSUMED CONCERNS. WELL
01:36:36.891 --> 01:36:38.492
CERTAINLY THERE'S A PROVISION
01:36:38.559 --> 01:36:39.493
BILL SAYS THAT YOU KNOW YOU
01:36:39.560 --> 01:36:42.062
DON'T BECAUSE OF FOR PA BUT I'M
01:36:42.129 --> 01:36:43.964
NOT SURE WHY THE GRADE POINT
01:36:44.031 --> 01:36:48.903
AVERAGE AT ALL THERE OR ARE, YOU
01:36:48.969 --> 01:36:50.304
KNOW, MAYBE FIVE YEAR RUNNING
01:36:50.371 --> 01:36:51.972
AVERAGE FOR PEOPLE WHO DIDN'T
01:36:52.039 --> 01:36:53.040
GRADUATE? MAYBE IF PEOPLE ARE
01:36:53.107 --> 01:36:54.909
CONCERNED THAT PEOPLE JOINING A
01:36:54.975 --> 01:36:56.710
FRATERNITY AREN'T GRADUATING OR
01:36:56.777 --> 01:36:57.978
HURTING THEM ACADEMICALLY OR
01:36:58.045 --> 01:37:00.414
SOMETHING BUT ACTUALLY PUBLISHED
01:37:00.481 --> 01:37:02.049
THE GRADE POINT AVERAGE. I
01:37:02.116 --> 01:37:03.184
UNDERSTAND THAT THE CHAPTERS MAY
01:37:03.250 --> 01:37:05.553
IN ORDER TO KEEP THEIR YOU KNOW
01:37:05.619 --> 01:37:06.353
, THROUGH PARTIES. WHATEVER
01:37:06.420 --> 01:37:07.755
NATIONAL NETWORK THEY'RE PART OF
01:37:07.821 --> 01:37:09.256
MAY REPORT GREAT, BUT THAT'S IN
01:37:09.323 --> 01:37:10.824
A PRIVATE SETTING. WE'RE GOING
01:37:10.891 --> 01:37:12.193
TO BE POSTING THIS, AND
01:37:12.259 --> 01:37:13.127
DEPENDING ON HOW BIG THE
01:37:13.194 --> 01:37:14.361
FURNITURE ATTORNEYS SORORITY IS,
01:37:14.428 --> 01:37:16.163
YOU COULD START FIGURING OUT
01:37:16.230 --> 01:37:17.831
INDIVIDUALS OR YOU CAN MAKE
01:37:17.898 --> 01:37:19.600
CONJECTURES ABOUT INDIVIDUALS.
01:37:19.667 --> 01:37:20.634
GRADE POINT AVERAGES, WHICH I
01:37:20.701 --> 01:37:23.804
THINK IS SOMETHING THAT HIS
01:37:23.871 --> 01:37:24.905
PERSONAL PRIVATE. I'M NOT SURE
01:37:24.972 --> 01:37:26.040
HOW IT CONTRIBUTES TO THE GOALS
01:37:26.106 --> 01:37:28.175
OF YOUR BILL. SO MAYBE YOU CAN
01:37:28.242 --> 01:37:30.511
ADDRESS THAT. JUST ONE THING WE
01:37:30.578 --> 01:37:31.745
WANTED TO LOOK AT AS WELL ON TOP
01:37:31.812 --> 01:37:35.549
OF THE REPORTED. ISSUES THEY
01:37:35.616 --> 01:37:37.985
HAVE THEIR, UM, JUST MORE GIVE
01:37:38.052 --> 01:37:39.286
INFORMATION TO STUDENTS WHILE
01:37:39.353 --> 01:37:40.654
THEY'RE LOOKING AT JOINING FOR
01:37:40.721 --> 01:37:41.789
FRATERNITY TO SHORTY, IF THIS IS
01:37:41.855 --> 01:37:44.024
THE RIGHT DIRECTION. I'M JUST
01:37:44.091 --> 01:37:45.693
LOOKING AT THE WHOLE PAGE, RIGHT
01:37:45.759 --> 01:37:47.561
AND ON THE TYPE OF STUDENTS THAT
01:37:47.628 --> 01:37:48.762
ARE THERE, BUT THAT'S SOMETHING
01:37:48.829 --> 01:37:49.863
DEFINITELY COULD WORK WITH
01:37:49.930 --> 01:37:51.765
FOLKS, IF THAT IS AN ISSUE WITH
01:37:51.832 --> 01:37:54.401
OTHERS, TOO. GET SUPPORT OR WORK
01:37:54.468 --> 01:37:56.403
ON IT, RIGHT? I APPRECIATE THAT.
01:37:56.470 --> 01:37:58.639
I MEAN, I THINK THAT, UM I'M
01:37:58.706 --> 01:37:59.707
JUST CONCERNED FROM PRIVACY
01:37:59.773 --> 01:38:01.041
POINT BECAUSE ALL THE OTHER
01:38:01.108 --> 01:38:02.710
ITEMS ARE YOU KNOW ABOUT THE
01:38:02.776 --> 01:38:03.644
INSTITUTION RIGHT? FRATERNITY
01:38:03.711 --> 01:38:04.979
SORORITY. THE CHAPTER. THIS ONE
01:38:05.045 --> 01:38:07.114
GETS A LITTLE MORE SPECIFIC.
01:38:07.181 --> 01:38:07.881
WELL, IT DOESN'T SAY INDIVIDUALS
01:38:07.948 --> 01:38:10.451
GPS, DEPENDING IF THERE IS A
01:38:10.517 --> 01:38:11.118
SMALL NUMBER. YOU CAN CONJECTURE
01:38:11.185 --> 01:38:13.187
THAT AND IT DIDN'T SEEM TO BE AS
01:38:13.254 --> 01:38:15.155
CLOSELY TIED TO SOME OF THE
01:38:15.222 --> 01:38:16.257
ISSUES THAT WERE RAISED BY BY
01:38:16.323 --> 01:38:17.458
THE PEOPLE WHO TESTIFIED IN
01:38:17.524 --> 01:38:18.959
FAVOR OF THE BILL. SO I THINK.
01:38:19.026 --> 01:38:20.561
WELL, YOU DO HAVE THAT LINE
01:38:20.628 --> 01:38:22.029
ABOUT FERPA. I WOULD PERSONALLY
01:38:22.096 --> 01:38:23.297
FEEL A LITTLE MORE COMFORTABLE
01:38:23.364 --> 01:38:24.865
THAT WASN'T THERE OR USE THE
01:38:24.932 --> 01:38:26.166
PRODUCT. ANOTHER PROXY FOR
01:38:26.233 --> 01:38:29.470
ACADEMIC SUCCESS THAT PERHAPS IS
01:38:29.536 --> 01:38:31.405
LESS IDENTIFIABLE TO PARTICULAR
01:38:31.472 --> 01:38:34.408
INDIVIDUALS, UH AND THE FEROCITY
01:38:34.475 --> 01:38:36.043
OF SORORITY. SO IF IT'S LIKE A,
01:38:36.110 --> 01:38:37.411
YOU KNOW, FOUR YEAR GRADUATION
01:38:37.478 --> 01:38:38.646
RATE FOR HER, YOU KNOW, OVER THE
01:38:38.712 --> 01:38:40.614
LAST FIVE YEARS OR XR THREE
01:38:40.681 --> 01:38:42.416
YEARS, WHATEVER FOR THE SORT OF
01:38:42.483 --> 01:38:44.818
TO GIVE PEOPLE SOME IDEA ABOUT
01:38:44.885 --> 01:38:46.186
IS THIS A FRATERNITY OF SONORITY
01:38:46.253 --> 01:38:48.122
WHERE PEOPLE DON'T JOIN AND THEY
01:38:48.188 --> 01:38:49.323
HAVE PROBLEMS? YOU KNOW YOU'RE
01:38:49.390 --> 01:38:50.257
GETTING THROUGH SCHOOL OR
01:38:50.324 --> 01:38:50.958
WHATEVER. SO, UM, MAYBE
01:38:51.025 --> 01:38:54.028
SOMETHING THAT MAYBE MORE
01:38:54.094 --> 01:38:55.629
REFLECTIVE AND CERTAINLY OF
01:38:55.696 --> 01:38:57.031
FRATERNITIES ALREADY. WHO'S
01:38:57.097 --> 01:38:58.198
RECRUITING WANTS TO, YOU KNOW,
01:38:58.265 --> 01:39:00.067
TALK FIRST TO THE ACADEMIC
01:39:00.134 --> 01:39:01.068
PROWESS AND THEY WANT TO TALK
01:39:01.135 --> 01:39:03.203
ABOUT IT. THAT'S FINE, BUT WE'RE
01:39:03.270 --> 01:39:04.271
ACTUALLY GONNA REQUIRE THEM AND
01:39:04.338 --> 01:39:05.673
THEN POSTED PUBLICLY ONTO A
01:39:05.739 --> 01:39:07.174
WEBSITE OR SOMETHING FOR OTHER
01:39:07.241 --> 01:39:08.742
STUDENTS IN THE SAME CAMPUS TO
01:39:08.809 --> 01:39:10.311
LOOK AT, SO I'M JUST CONCERNED,
01:39:10.377 --> 01:39:12.313
ESPECIALLY THE SMALL NUMBER OF
01:39:12.379 --> 01:39:13.981
PEOPLE SO ANYWAY, I SO I WILL BE
01:39:14.048 --> 01:39:15.949
SUPPORTING YOUR BILL, BUT I'M
01:39:16.016 --> 01:39:17.418
HOPING YOU COULD ADDRESS THAT
01:39:17.484 --> 01:39:18.452
GOING FORWARD. OKAY? I WILL
01:39:18.519 --> 01:39:20.654
OBVIOUSLY. LOT OF THE LANGUAGE
01:39:20.721 --> 01:39:21.722
CAME FROM WORKING WITH HER
01:39:21.789 --> 01:39:23.390
ATTORNEYS OUT THERE AS WELL AND
01:39:23.457 --> 01:39:24.958
OTHER INSTITUTIONS BUT TO LOOK
01:39:25.025 --> 01:39:26.727
AT THAT AS WELL, BUT THAT'S
01:39:26.794 --> 01:39:27.761
SOMETHING THAT COULD BE AN ISSUE
01:39:27.828 --> 01:39:30.364
WITH FOCUS ON MORE THAN OPEN TO
01:39:30.431 --> 01:39:31.632
SEE WHAT I CAN DO THAT AS WELL.
01:39:31.699 --> 01:39:33.600
I APPRECIATE THAT. THANK YOU.
01:39:33.667 --> 01:39:34.601
SPEAKING SENATOR PAN. OTHER
01:39:34.668 --> 01:39:35.803
FURTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS,
01:39:35.869 --> 01:39:37.438
SENATOR GLASER YEAH, I'M HAPPY
01:39:37.504 --> 01:39:38.305
TO MOVE THE ABILITY APPROPRIATE
01:39:38.372 --> 01:39:39.440
TIME I SUPPORT THE DIRECTION
01:39:39.506 --> 01:39:41.108
THAT YOU'RE GOING. I THINK IT'S
01:39:41.175 --> 01:39:43.510
FAIR TO SAY THAT THERE'S BEEN
01:39:43.577 --> 01:39:44.478
SOME EXTRAORDINARY EXAMPLES OF
01:39:44.545 --> 01:39:47.414
ABUSE. ON CAMPUSES WITH HAZING
01:39:47.481 --> 01:39:49.750
AND OTHER SEXUAL ASSAULT
01:39:49.817 --> 01:39:51.251
ACTIVITIES THAT ARE
01:39:51.318 --> 01:39:53.153
REPREHENSIBLE, BUT IT'S ALSO
01:39:53.220 --> 01:39:54.054
IMPORTANT TO SAY THAT I THINK
01:39:54.121 --> 01:39:55.889
THE VAST MAJORITY OF ATTORNEYS
01:39:55.956 --> 01:39:58.625
AND STORIES BASED BEHAVE IN AN
01:39:58.692 --> 01:40:01.061
APPROPRIATE WAY, AND THAT THAT
01:40:01.128 --> 01:40:04.398
THE EXCEPTIONS THAT WE THAT YOURBILL TRIES TO ADDRESS AND
01:40:04.465 --> 01:40:06.667
IDENTIFYING UM, SHOULDN'T TAKE
01:40:06.734 --> 01:40:07.835
AWAY FROM THE GREAT EXPERIENCES
01:40:07.901 --> 01:40:09.737
THAT PEOPLE DO HAVE. IN
01:40:09.803 --> 01:40:10.971
FRATERNITIES AND SORORITIES. I
01:40:11.038 --> 01:40:12.806
WAS IN A FRATERNITY IN MY
01:40:12.873 --> 01:40:15.776
COLLEGE, I'LL ADMIT TO THAT. UH
01:40:15.843 --> 01:40:17.811
BUT, UH AND, UH BUT I ALSO WOULD
01:40:17.878 --> 01:40:20.414
NOTE THAT WHEN I WAS A STUDENT
01:40:20.481 --> 01:40:21.815
LEADER, AND THERE'S A 19
01:40:21.882 --> 01:40:22.750
SEVENTIES, WE CARRIED THE BILL
01:40:22.816 --> 01:40:24.818
ON HAZING BECAUSE OF THE ABUSES
01:40:24.885 --> 01:40:25.953
WE WERE SEEING AT THAT TIME THAT
01:40:26.019 --> 01:40:27.921
YOU CONTINUE TO TRY TO ADVANCE
01:40:27.988 --> 01:40:29.790
IN A GOOD WAY WITH THAT. I'M
01:40:29.857 --> 01:40:30.758
HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL. THANK
01:40:30.824 --> 01:40:32.793
YOU, SENATOR GLASER RIGHT BEFORE
01:40:32.860 --> 01:40:33.827
I ASK YOU TO CLOSE
01:40:33.894 --> 01:40:35.062
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S I WOULD JUST
01:40:35.129 --> 01:40:36.730
LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR BRINGING
01:40:36.797 --> 01:40:38.966
THE BILL FORWARD. I DO PROBABLY
01:40:39.032 --> 01:40:39.900
SHARE A LITTLE BIT OF THE
01:40:39.967 --> 01:40:41.935
CONCERNS ABOUT THE G P A. BUT I
01:40:42.002 --> 01:40:43.103
LOVE THE DIRECTION YOUR BILL IS
01:40:43.170 --> 01:40:44.838
GOING THIS IS AN AREA. I'VE DONE
01:40:44.905 --> 01:40:47.007
A LOT OF WORK IN MY EIGHT YEARS
01:40:47.074 --> 01:40:49.009
HERE, AND IF WE CAN KEEP ONE
01:40:49.076 --> 01:40:50.110
STUDENT FROM BEING RAPED ON ANY
01:40:50.177 --> 01:40:52.079
CAMPUS, WE HAVE DONE OUR JOB, SO
01:40:52.146 --> 01:40:54.014
THANK YOU FOR BEING BRINGING IT
01:40:54.081 --> 01:40:55.048
FORWARD AND YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:40:55.115 --> 01:40:57.484
RESPECT TO ASK FOR A VOTE. THANK
01:40:57.551 --> 01:40:58.519
YOU. THANK YOU, SIR. ALRIGHT.
01:40:58.585 --> 01:41:00.287
THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED BY
01:41:00.354 --> 01:41:01.422
SENATOR GLASER, MADAM ASSISTANT.
01:41:01.488 --> 01:41:02.523
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. FILE ITEM
01:41:02.589 --> 01:41:05.392
6 85 24. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
01:41:05.459 --> 01:41:06.960
BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
01:41:07.027 --> 01:41:08.061
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
01:41:08.128 --> 01:41:10.531
LEVER LEVER. I JOB, OKAY? JOBURG
01:41:10.597 --> 01:41:15.169
CÁC ORTEZ. PRETTY EASY. I DOLLY.
01:41:15.235 --> 01:41:19.206
SALLY. I LASER GLASER. I MCGUIRE
01:41:19.273 --> 01:41:25.179
PAN. CAN I. THANK YOU SO MUCH
01:41:25.245 --> 01:41:26.046
MEMBER. THAT BILL HAS ENOUGH
01:41:26.113 --> 01:41:27.548
VOTES TO GET OUT. BUT WE WILL
01:41:27.614 --> 01:41:29.249
KEEP IT OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBER.
01:41:29.316 --> 01:41:30.551
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU
01:41:30.617 --> 01:41:31.652
FOR RUNNING RIGHT OVER. ALL
01:41:31.718 --> 01:41:33.921
RIGHT. WE HAVE OUR NEXT AUTHOR.
01:41:33.987 --> 01:41:36.390
YOU HAVE ONE MORE. YOU KNOW
01:41:36.457 --> 01:41:37.558
WHAT? HOLD ON. LET ME JUST TURN
01:41:37.624 --> 01:41:39.927
MY PAGE HERE AND SEE THAT IF YOU
01:41:39.993 --> 01:41:41.462
WOULD PLEASE PRESENT FILE ITEM
01:41:41.528 --> 01:41:44.198
SEVEN A B 15. OH, FIVE. THANK
01:41:44.264 --> 01:41:45.566
YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS. THANK
01:41:45.632 --> 01:41:47.401
YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT
01:41:47.468 --> 01:41:48.802
MAYBE 15 OR FIVE, WHICH WAS RE
01:41:48.869 --> 01:41:50.103
BENCH. THE FAN IN CALIFORNIA
01:41:50.170 --> 01:41:51.505
COMMUNITY COLLEGES, THE FUND
01:41:51.572 --> 01:41:53.474
ESTABLISHED A FLOOR FOR THE
01:41:53.540 --> 01:41:54.608
MINIMUM NUMBER OF FULL TIME
01:41:54.675 --> 01:41:55.742
FACULTY. EACH COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:41:55.809 --> 01:41:57.845
MUST HAVE THE FUND WAS DEVELOPED
01:41:57.911 --> 01:41:59.546
INSURED ECOLOGISTS AT A MINIMUM
01:41:59.613 --> 01:42:01.281
INCREASED THEIR NUMBER OF FULL
01:42:01.348 --> 01:42:03.116
TIME FACULTY WORKERS IN
01:42:03.183 --> 01:42:04.918
PROPORTION TO THE GROWTH IN FULL
01:42:04.985 --> 01:42:05.953
TIME EQUIVALENT STUDENTS
01:42:06.019 --> 01:42:07.187
CURRENTLY ALL BUT TWO OF THE 72
01:42:07.254 --> 01:42:09.656
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICTS. OR
01:42:09.723 --> 01:42:10.891
OVER THEIR FRONT IN SOME CASES
01:42:10.958 --> 01:42:12.993
BY HUNDREDS OF FACULTY. BY RE
01:42:13.060 --> 01:42:15.562
BENCHING THE FUND. WE CAN ASSURE
01:42:15.629 --> 01:42:16.230
FUTURE INVESTMENTS IN FULL TIME
01:42:16.296 --> 01:42:17.631
FACULTY RESULT IN ACTUALLY
01:42:17.698 --> 01:42:20.200
HIRING NEW FOUR TIME FACULTY
01:42:20.267 --> 01:42:20.868
WITH ME TODAY TO PROVIDE
01:42:20.934 --> 01:42:21.869
TESTIMONY TO HELP ANSWER
01:42:21.935 --> 01:42:25.539
QUESTIONS. IS WENDY BROUGH
01:42:25.606 --> 01:42:26.974
LINKUP PRESIDENT WITH THE
01:42:27.040 --> 01:42:27.875
FACULTY ASSOCIATION OF
01:42:27.941 --> 01:42:30.077
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES
01:42:30.143 --> 01:42:31.545
AND MICHAEL YOUNG, LEGISLATIVE
01:42:31.612 --> 01:42:32.846
ADVOCATE FOR THE CALIFORNIA,
01:42:32.913 --> 01:42:34.381
CALIFORNIA FEDERATION OF
01:42:34.448 --> 01:42:35.415
TEACHERS. THANK YOU
01:42:35.482 --> 01:42:36.683
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ALRIGHT, WE'RE
01:42:36.750 --> 01:42:38.485
GOING TO START WITH OUR IN
01:42:38.552 --> 01:42:39.419
PERSON. UH, PEOPLE TESTIFYING MR
01:42:39.486 --> 01:42:42.923
YOUNG, PLEASE PROCEED. MADAM
01:42:42.990 --> 01:42:43.991
CHAIR SENATORS, MICHAEL YOUNG
01:42:44.057 --> 01:42:45.459
WITH THE CALIFORNIA FEDERATION
01:42:45.526 --> 01:42:46.560
OF TEACHERS, ONE OF THE COAST
01:42:46.627 --> 01:42:48.195
MANAGER OF THE BILL, AS THE
01:42:48.262 --> 01:42:49.563
MEMBER STATED, THE GOAL OF THE
01:42:49.630 --> 01:42:51.632
BILL REALLY IS TO INCENTIVIZE
01:42:51.698 --> 01:42:52.933
ACCOUNTABILITY AND TO CREATE
01:42:53.000 --> 01:42:54.935
PROGRESS RIGHT. THE FILE WAS
01:42:55.002 --> 01:42:56.737
CREATED 30 YEARS AGO OR OVER 30
01:42:56.803 --> 01:42:58.372
YEARS AGO, AND WE HAVEN'T SEEN
01:42:58.438 --> 01:42:59.039
SIGNIFICANT PROGRESS IN TERMS OF
01:42:59.106 --> 01:43:00.240
REACHING THAT STATUTORY GOAL OF
01:43:00.307 --> 01:43:02.910
70 75% OF INSTRUCTIONAL HOURS
01:43:02.976 --> 01:43:03.911
BEING TAUGHT BY FULL TIME
01:43:03.977 --> 01:43:05.812
FACULTY. I SAID AN ANALYSIS. I
01:43:05.879 --> 01:43:07.314
THINK THE NUMBERS WILL UNDER 60%
01:43:07.381 --> 01:43:09.182
NOW, UM AND ALSO THE
01:43:09.249 --> 01:43:10.417
ACCOUNTABILITY PIECES THAT
01:43:10.484 --> 01:43:12.219
OFTENTIMES WHEN, OVER THE LAST
01:43:12.286 --> 01:43:13.587
FEW YEARS, THE LEGISLATURE HAS
01:43:13.654 --> 01:43:14.821
GIVEN COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:43:14.888 --> 01:43:16.023
DISTRICTS MONEY FOR THE EXPRESS
01:43:16.089 --> 01:43:17.057
PURPOSE OF HIRING FULL TIME
01:43:17.124 --> 01:43:18.859
FACULTY. AND WITH DISTRICTS USE
01:43:18.926 --> 01:43:21.528
IS THE FACT THAT THERE ARE ABOVE
01:43:21.595 --> 01:43:22.829
THE FAWN AS JUSTIFICATION FOR
01:43:22.896 --> 01:43:24.164
TAKING THAT MONEY AND USING IT
01:43:24.231 --> 01:43:25.532
FOR OTHER PURPOSES. SO
01:43:25.599 --> 01:43:26.967
HYPOTHETICALLY, IF YOU HAVE A
01:43:27.034 --> 01:43:27.801
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT THAT
01:43:27.868 --> 01:43:28.936
HAS 200 FACULTY AND THEY'RE
01:43:29.002 --> 01:43:31.405
FALLING IS 100. WE GIVE THEM
01:43:31.471 --> 01:43:33.340
MONEY TO HIRE 20 MORE PEOPLE.
01:43:33.407 --> 01:43:34.408
WHAT'S HAPPENING IS THAT BOND
01:43:34.474 --> 01:43:35.976
JUMPS TO 1 20. THEY TAKE THE
01:43:36.043 --> 01:43:38.045
MONEY AND SAY THANK YOU VERY
01:43:38.111 --> 01:43:39.112
MUCH SINCE WE'RE OVER OUR
01:43:39.179 --> 01:43:39.746
MINIMUM OBLIGATIONS SINCE WE'RE
01:43:39.813 --> 01:43:42.115
AT 200. WE DON'T NEED TO HIRE 20
01:43:42.182 --> 01:43:42.883
NEW PEOPLE. THANKS FOR THOSE
01:43:42.950 --> 01:43:45.319
FUNDS. WE CAN USE IT FOR
01:43:45.385 --> 01:43:46.420
SOMETHING ELSE. SO OUR GOAL
01:43:46.486 --> 01:43:47.654
ABOUT RE BENCHING THE FALL IN
01:43:47.721 --> 01:43:49.122
THE STATING THAT NOW, IF YOU GET
01:43:49.189 --> 01:43:50.757
NEW MONEY, YOUR NEW FLOOR IS
01:43:50.824 --> 01:43:51.792
GOING TO BE WHERE YOU'RE AT
01:43:51.858 --> 01:43:53.594
TODAY. WE'RE NOT REQUIRING ANY
01:43:53.660 --> 01:43:55.295
DISTRICT TO GO OUT AND HIRE NEW
01:43:55.362 --> 01:43:57.197
PEOPLE WERE GOING TO SET THE
01:43:57.264 --> 01:43:58.265
PHONE THAT WE'RE DISTRICTS ARE
01:43:58.332 --> 01:43:59.232
AT PRESENTLY TODAY AND AGAIN,
01:43:59.299 --> 01:44:01.234
THE FUND CAN ADJUST UP OR DOWN.
01:44:01.301 --> 01:44:02.569
BASED OFF OF ENROLLMENT OR
01:44:02.636 --> 01:44:03.537
FUNDING, SO WE'RE NOT FREEZING
01:44:03.604 --> 01:44:05.072
YOU INTO PRISON FIGURES WERE
01:44:05.138 --> 01:44:05.772
SAYING THAT NUMBER THAT YOU'RE
01:44:05.839 --> 01:44:08.108
USING TODAY WAS BASED OFF ABOUT
01:44:08.175 --> 01:44:09.309
30 YEARS AGO NUMBER. WE WANT TO
01:44:09.376 --> 01:44:10.944
BASE IT OFF A MORE REALISTIC
01:44:11.011 --> 01:44:12.479
FIGURE THIS TODAY. ALLOW THE
01:44:12.546 --> 01:44:13.447
FOREIGN TO CONTINUE TO ADJUST
01:44:13.513 --> 01:44:15.015
BASED ON CURRENT METHODOLOGY AND
01:44:15.082 --> 01:44:17.317
ENSURE THAT IN THE FUTURE IF YOU
01:44:17.384 --> 01:44:17.951
GET ADDITIONAL FUNDS THAT WILL
01:44:18.018 --> 01:44:19.052
TRANSLATE TO HIRING FULL TIME
01:44:19.119 --> 01:44:20.220
FACULTY, AS WAS THE EXPRESS
01:44:20.287 --> 01:44:21.355
PURPOSE, UH, STATED IN THE
01:44:21.421 --> 01:44:23.056
BUDGET BOTH LAST YEAR AND IN THE
01:44:23.123 --> 01:44:24.925
YEARS PRIOR SO WITH THAT, WE
01:44:24.992 --> 01:44:26.159
RESPECTFULLY ASK TRIBAL. THANK
01:44:26.226 --> 01:44:26.760
YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR
01:44:26.827 --> 01:44:28.929
YOUNG. ALRIGHT, WE'RE NOW GOING
01:44:28.996 --> 01:44:30.397
TO GO TO OUR CALL IN LINE. MR
01:44:30.464 --> 01:44:31.865
MODERATOR, IF YOU CAN PLEASE
01:44:31.932 --> 01:44:33.000
QUEUE UP MISS BRILL WIND CUP. GO
01:44:33.066 --> 01:44:38.138
AHEAD. GOOD MORNING. I'M WENDY
01:44:38.205 --> 01:44:39.573
BROUGH WINE COOP. I'M THE
01:44:39.640 --> 01:44:40.307
PRESIDENT OF THE FACULTY
01:44:40.374 --> 01:44:41.408
ASSOCIATION OF THE CALIFORNIA
01:44:41.475 --> 01:44:44.578
COMMUNITY COLLEGES OR FACT AND
01:44:44.645 --> 01:44:46.146
IN FACULTY MEMBER AT COLLEGE OF
01:44:46.213 --> 01:44:48.181
THE CANYONS. WE ARE PROUD
01:44:48.248 --> 01:44:50.584
SPONSOR OF HB 15 OH, FIVE, WHICH
01:44:50.651 --> 01:44:51.785
WOULD REQUIRE THE COMMUNITY
01:44:51.852 --> 01:44:53.487
COLLEGE BOARD OF GOVERNORS TO
01:44:53.553 --> 01:44:55.789
ADOPT REGULATIONS REQUIRING THE
01:44:55.856 --> 01:44:58.425
2023 FAULT, FULL TIME FACULTY
01:44:58.492 --> 01:45:00.360
OBLIGATION FROM EACH DISTRICT TO
01:45:00.427 --> 01:45:02.963
BE RE BENCHED AT THE 2022 FALL
01:45:03.030 --> 01:45:06.333
FULL TIME FACULTY NUMBERS FOR 35
01:45:06.400 --> 01:45:07.801
YEARS, THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
01:45:07.868 --> 01:45:09.536
COLLEGES HAVE RELIED ON PART
01:45:09.603 --> 01:45:10.504
TIME FACULTY TO TEACH THE
01:45:10.570 --> 01:45:12.973
MAJORITY OF COURSES. AND THE
01:45:13.040 --> 01:45:15.175
OPPORTUNITY FOR CRITICAL ONE ON
01:45:15.242 --> 01:45:16.610
ONE MENTORSHIP THE KEY TO
01:45:16.677 --> 01:45:18.478
STUDENT SUCCESS BETWEEN FACULTY
01:45:18.545 --> 01:45:19.446
AND STUDENTS HAS BEEN
01:45:19.513 --> 01:45:21.415
DIMINISHED. TO ADDRESS STUDENT
01:45:21.481 --> 01:45:22.849
EQUITY LIKE RETENTION,
01:45:22.916 --> 01:45:24.718
COMPLETION AND TRANSFER. WE MUST
01:45:24.785 --> 01:45:25.852
ALSO ADDRESS ACCESS TO FULL
01:45:25.919 --> 01:45:29.322
TIME. PROGRESS ON THE PH<c.cyan></c>
01:45:29.389 --> 01:45:31.058
SHOULD BE CONSIDERED A FUNCTION
01:45:31.124 --> 01:45:33.527
OF STUDENT SUCCESS. STUDENTS AT
01:45:33.593 --> 01:45:34.628
ALL COLLEGES SHOULD EXPECT TO
01:45:34.695 --> 01:45:37.164
INTERACT WITH FULL TIME FACULTY.
01:45:37.230 --> 01:45:38.598
IN RESPONSE TO THE OPPOSITION.
01:45:38.665 --> 01:45:41.001
IT'S IMPERATIVE NOTES THAT THE
01:45:41.068 --> 01:45:42.169
BILL DOES NOT REQUIRE DISTRICTS
01:45:42.235 --> 01:45:44.571
TO DO OR CHANGE ANYTHING IN THE
01:45:44.638 --> 01:45:45.405
CURRENT MODEL. THE FOND
01:45:45.472 --> 01:45:46.640
REQUIREMENT INCREASES AND
01:45:46.707 --> 01:45:48.375
DECREASES WITH AN ENROLLMENT.
01:45:48.442 --> 01:45:49.643
AND MAYBE 15. OH, FIVE WILL NOT
01:45:49.710 --> 01:45:52.479
CHANGE THIS. DISTRICTS WILL NOT
01:45:52.546 --> 01:45:54.014
NEED TO HIRE ANY ADDITIONAL
01:45:54.081 --> 01:45:55.849
FACULTY AND THE BENCHMARK CAN
01:45:55.916 --> 01:45:57.017
INCREASE FUNDING OR ENROLLMENT
01:45:57.084 --> 01:46:00.454
DROPS. HASSAN WILL CONTINUE TO
01:46:00.520 --> 01:46:02.155
ADJUST BASED ON THE CURRENT
01:46:02.222 --> 01:46:04.758
METHODOLOGY. WE HOPE IT IS WE
01:46:04.825 --> 01:46:07.060
HAVE OUR HOPE IS THAT WE WILL
01:46:07.127 --> 01:46:07.928
SEE THE STATE'S INVESTMENT IN
01:46:07.994 --> 01:46:09.329
FULL TIME FACULTY HIRING
01:46:09.396 --> 01:46:11.665
ACTUALLY TRANSLATE INTO HIRING
01:46:11.732 --> 01:46:13.333
COMMUNITY COLLEGES THAT ARE
01:46:13.400 --> 01:46:15.235
ALREADY OVER THE FAWN. THANK YOU
01:46:15.302 --> 01:46:16.536
VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME. THANK
01:46:16.603 --> 01:46:18.739
YOU. I WILL GO HERE TO ROOM 2100
01:46:18.805 --> 01:46:20.540
FOR ANYONE WHO WISHES TO SPEAK
01:46:20.607 --> 01:46:23.243
IN SUPPORT. SEEING NO ONE. MR.
01:46:23.310 --> 01:46:24.811
MODERATOR WE ARE GOING TO YOU.
01:46:24.878 --> 01:46:26.847
CAN YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE
01:46:26.913 --> 01:46:28.849
WHO WISHES TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
01:46:28.915 --> 01:46:31.084
OF A B? 15? OH, FIVE. THANK YOU
01:46:31.151 --> 01:46:33.120
TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF A B 15
01:46:33.186 --> 01:46:35.322
05, PLEASE. PRESS 10 AT THIS
01:46:35.388 --> 01:46:38.125
TIME ONE FOLLOWED BY ZERO AND
01:46:38.191 --> 01:46:42.028
FIRST IS LINE 23, YOU ARE OPEN.
01:46:42.095 --> 01:46:43.597
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS,
01:46:43.663 --> 01:46:45.065
MITCH STEIGER, WITH CALIFORNIA
01:46:45.132 --> 01:46:45.899
LABOR FEDERATION ALSO EXPORT.
01:46:45.966 --> 01:46:50.637
THANK YOU. CAN FOR ANYBODY ELSE.
01:46:50.704 --> 01:46:52.906
10 AT THIS TIME ONE FOLLOWED BY
01:46:52.973 --> 01:47:00.180
ZERO. WE DO HAVE ONE QUEUING UP.
01:47:00.247 --> 01:47:03.550
IN LINE 85, PLEASE GO AHEAD.
01:47:03.617 --> 01:47:13.927
BELIEVE THE MEMBER IS. WE CANNOT
01:47:13.994 --> 01:47:15.028
HEAR YOU, SIR, BUT WE WILL
01:47:15.095 --> 01:47:19.533
ASSUME THAT YOU ARE IN SUPPORT.
01:47:19.599 --> 01:47:21.168
MADAM SHARON. NOBODY ELSE QUEUED
01:47:21.234 --> 01:47:23.203
UP. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
01:47:23.270 --> 01:47:25.005
WE'RE GOING TO MOVE TO OUR LEAD
01:47:25.071 --> 01:47:27.941
OPPOSITION. WE HAVE TWO FOLKS,
01:47:28.008 --> 01:47:30.177
RYAN, AND BOTH ARE HERE IN THIS
01:47:30.243 --> 01:47:31.678
ROOM. RYAN MICKEY NICOLINI. I'M
01:47:31.745 --> 01:47:33.213
GOING TO START WITH YOU.
01:47:33.280 --> 01:47:34.347
APPARENTLY YOU'RE SPEAKING FOR
01:47:34.414 --> 01:47:35.448
30 SECONDS AND THEN DEFERRING
01:47:35.515 --> 01:47:37.050
THE REST OF YOUR TIME. TO MR
01:47:37.117 --> 01:47:39.085
WILLY DUNCAN. SO PLEASE PROCEED
01:47:39.152 --> 01:47:39.920
. GOOD MORNING, RYAN MCELHANEY
01:47:39.986 --> 01:47:40.987
WITH COMMUNITY COLLEGE LEAGUE OF
01:47:41.054 --> 01:47:42.289
CALIFORNIA. WE REPRESENT
01:47:42.355 --> 01:47:43.156
CALIFORNIA 73 COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:47:43.223 --> 01:47:44.825
DISTRICTS AND ARE IN OPPOSITION
01:47:44.891 --> 01:47:46.726
TO THIS BILL. YOU KNOW FIRST, DO
01:47:46.793 --> 01:47:48.028
YOU WANT TO SAY THAT OUR
01:47:48.094 --> 01:47:49.196
DISTRICTS ABSOLUTELY UNDERSTAND
01:47:49.262 --> 01:47:50.297
THE IMPORTANCE OF FULL TIME
01:47:50.363 --> 01:47:51.932
FACULTY. HOWEVER WE ARE THE
01:47:51.998 --> 01:47:53.567
LOWEST YOUR PUPIL FUNDED SYSTEM
01:47:53.633 --> 01:47:55.302
IN THE STATE REGARDING THE
01:47:55.368 --> 01:47:56.803
BUDGET, AND THEREFORE WE MUST
01:47:56.870 --> 01:47:58.038
MAKE HARD CHOICES WERE CONCERNED
01:47:58.104 --> 01:47:59.072
THAT THIS BILL IS GOING TO
01:47:59.139 --> 01:48:01.408
ARTIFICIALLY MOVE THE GOALPOSTS
01:48:01.474 --> 01:48:03.043
ON THE MINIMUM AMOUNT OF FACULTY
01:48:03.109 --> 01:48:05.011
THAT HAVE COLLEGE MUST HIRE AND
01:48:05.078 --> 01:48:06.179
MAKE THOSE CHOICES HARDER. IT
01:48:06.246 --> 01:48:07.214
COULD IMPACT PROGRAMS THAT
01:48:07.280 --> 01:48:10.183
BENEFIT CURRENT FACULTY, STUDENT
01:48:10.250 --> 01:48:11.484
SUCCESS AND BASIC NEEDS. AND
01:48:11.551 --> 01:48:12.986
WITH THAT, I'D LIKE TO SEE THE
01:48:13.053 --> 01:48:15.488
REST OF MY TIME. THANK YOU VERY
01:48:15.555 --> 01:48:16.122
MUCH. RIGHT. MR. DUNCAN PLEASE
01:48:16.189 --> 01:48:17.057
PROCEED. YOU HAVE THREE MINUTES
01:48:17.123 --> 01:48:18.925
AND 30 SECONDS. THANK YOU VERY
01:48:18.992 --> 01:48:20.260
MUCH. MADAM CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
01:48:20.327 --> 01:48:21.161
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS WILLY
01:48:21.228 --> 01:48:22.329
DUNCAN. I'M THE SUPERINTENDENT
01:48:22.395 --> 01:48:23.263
PRESIDENT AT SIERRA COLLEGE.
01:48:23.330 --> 01:48:24.664
WHICH IS IN SENATOR DOLLIES
01:48:24.731 --> 01:48:26.333
DISTRICT AND SEE SENATOR I'D
01:48:26.399 --> 01:48:27.801
LIKE TO BEGIN BY SAYING AN
01:48:27.868 --> 01:48:29.302
ECHOING MR MCENEANEY COMMENTS
01:48:29.369 --> 01:48:30.770
THAT I HIGHLY VALUE THE UNIQUE
01:48:30.837 --> 01:48:32.939
AND CRITICAL ROLE THAT FULL TIME
01:48:33.006 --> 01:48:34.941
FACULTY PLAY ON A COLLEGE CAMPUS
01:48:35.008 --> 01:48:36.576
IN THE SUCCESS OF OUR STUDENTS,
01:48:36.643 --> 01:48:38.111
AND THIS IS EVIDENCED BY THE
01:48:38.178 --> 01:48:39.779
FACT THAT WE ARE ONE OF THE
01:48:39.846 --> 01:48:40.914
DISTRICTS SIERRA COLLEGE THAT IS
01:48:40.981 --> 01:48:42.649
SIGNIFICANTLY OVER OUR OUR FUND.
01:48:42.716 --> 01:48:45.685
AND IN FACT WILL BE PROJECTED TO
01:48:45.752 --> 01:48:47.187
BE AT 42 FULL TIME FACULTY OVER
01:48:47.254 --> 01:48:50.257
OUR FUND IN THE FALL OF 2022. WE
01:48:50.323 --> 01:48:51.691
COULD HAVE HIRED LESS FACULTY
01:48:51.758 --> 01:48:53.260
AND COMPLIED WITH THE LAW. SO IN
01:48:53.326 --> 01:48:54.694
THAT OBVIOUSLY WOULD HAVE BEEN
01:48:54.761 --> 01:48:55.795
EASIER ON OUR BUDGET. BUT WE'RE
01:48:55.862 --> 01:48:57.364
FOCUSED ON WHAT OUR STUDENTS
01:48:57.430 --> 01:49:00.267
NEED. AND AT THAT POINT IN TIME,
01:49:00.333 --> 01:49:01.167
OUR STUDENTS NEED MORE FULL TIME
01:49:01.234 --> 01:49:02.736
FACULTY. UM BUT WE'RE NOW AT THE
01:49:02.802 --> 01:49:04.237
HIGHEST NUMBER THAT WE'VE EVER
01:49:04.304 --> 01:49:05.872
BEEN IN OUR FULL TIME FACULTY IN
01:49:05.939 --> 01:49:08.208
OUR COLLEGES, HISTORY, UM AND,
01:49:08.275 --> 01:49:11.311
UH, THERE ARE MANY FACTORS THAT
01:49:11.378 --> 01:49:11.945
WENT INTO THAT DECISION AS TO
01:49:12.012 --> 01:49:14.314
WHY WE INCREASE SO HIGH A FEW
01:49:14.381 --> 01:49:15.015
YEARS AGO IN THE CALIFORNIA
01:49:15.081 --> 01:49:17.250
COMMUNITY COLLEGES PUT IN THE
01:49:17.317 --> 01:49:17.984
VISION FOR SUCCESS ARE COLLEGE
01:49:18.051 --> 01:49:19.719
GOT TOGETHER, LOOKED AT THOSE
01:49:19.786 --> 01:49:20.921
GOALS AND DEVELOPED A PLAN AS TO
01:49:20.987 --> 01:49:23.223
HOW WE WOULD REACH THOSE GOALS.
01:49:23.290 --> 01:49:24.691
AS PART OF THAT PLAN. WE LOOKED
01:49:24.758 --> 01:49:26.192
AT OUR WORKFORCE AND RECOGNIZE
01:49:26.259 --> 01:49:27.928
THAT WE HAVE AN AGING FACULTY
01:49:27.994 --> 01:49:28.795
WORKFORCE AND WE'D SOON BE
01:49:28.862 --> 01:49:30.563
EXPERIENCING A LARGE NUMBER OF
01:49:30.630 --> 01:49:32.198
RETIREMENTS. WE ALSO IDENTIFIED
01:49:32.265 --> 01:49:33.300
THE NEED TO CREATE MORE
01:49:33.366 --> 01:49:36.069
DIVERSITY IN OUR IN OUR FACULTY
01:49:36.136 --> 01:49:37.604
WORKFORCE AND INFUSED NEW TALENT
01:49:37.671 --> 01:49:39.105
TO WORK ON CURRICULUM PROGRAM
01:49:39.172 --> 01:49:40.307
DEVELOPMENT. UM, STUDENT SUCCESS
01:49:40.373 --> 01:49:42.909
AND EQUITY INITIATIVES. OUR PLAN
01:49:42.976 --> 01:49:43.777
HAS BEEN TO SIGNIFICANTLY
01:49:43.843 --> 01:49:45.145
INCREASE THE NUMBER OF FULL TIME
01:49:45.211 --> 01:49:47.514
FACULTY THAT WE HAVE ON STAFF
01:49:47.580 --> 01:49:48.081
QUICKER THAN WE WOULD HAVE
01:49:48.148 --> 01:49:50.450
NEEDED TO, RATHER THAN WAITING
01:49:50.517 --> 01:49:51.184
FOR RETIREMENTS. SO THIS BRINGS
01:49:51.251 --> 01:49:53.520
US TO A B 15 05 AND THE
01:49:53.586 --> 01:49:54.821
POTENTIAL RE BENCHING THE FUN
01:49:54.888 --> 01:49:56.156
AND THE FALL OF 2022. WHEN OUR
01:49:56.222 --> 01:49:58.024
FULL TIME FACULTY WILL LITERALLY
01:49:58.091 --> 01:49:59.125
BE AT THEIR HIGHEST AS I
01:49:59.192 --> 01:50:00.427
MENTIONED EVER IN OUR HISTORY.
01:50:00.493 --> 01:50:01.995
AND THIS GIVES US NO TIME TO
01:50:02.062 --> 01:50:04.130
PLAN OR BE PREPARED FOR SUCH A
01:50:04.197 --> 01:50:05.565
SIGNIFICANT CHANGE, AND IT WILL
01:50:05.632 --> 01:50:07.634
HAVE A LONG TERM IMPACT ON MY
01:50:07.701 --> 01:50:09.069
COLLEGE THE PRIMARY. MY PRIMARY
01:50:09.135 --> 01:50:10.637
OBJECTION OF THE BILL IS THAT IT
01:50:10.704 --> 01:50:11.738
REMOVES ALL FLEXIBILITY THAT WE
01:50:11.805 --> 01:50:14.441
HAVE GOING FORWARD. EVERY TIME I
01:50:14.507 --> 01:50:15.308
RESTRICTIONS PLACED ON OUR
01:50:15.375 --> 01:50:18.144
FUNDING THAT MAKES A CHOICE THAT
01:50:18.211 --> 01:50:19.779
WE HAVE TO MAKE AS OTHER THINGS,
01:50:19.846 --> 01:50:21.181
AND HERE'S THE AREASTHAT I'M
01:50:21.247 --> 01:50:22.215
WORRIED ABOUT WHERE WE WOULD
01:50:22.282 --> 01:50:24.084
HAVE PROBLEMS. FIRST THE ABILITY
01:50:24.150 --> 01:50:25.585
TO SUPPORT CURRENT FACULTY WE
01:50:25.652 --> 01:50:27.220
MEET REGULARLY WITH OUR FACULTY
01:50:27.287 --> 01:50:28.788
TO PROVIDEHIGH WAGES, HIGH
01:50:28.855 --> 01:50:31.057
BENEFITS, AND THIS COULD
01:50:31.124 --> 01:50:32.592
POSSIBLY HAVE A DOWNWARD PUSH ON
01:50:32.659 --> 01:50:34.427
THAT, NOT JUST OUR FACULTY. BUT
01:50:34.494 --> 01:50:35.795
ALL OF OUR STAFF ON OUR ON OUR
01:50:35.862 --> 01:50:38.198
CAMPUS SECOND, THE ABILITY TO
01:50:38.264 --> 01:50:38.832
EXPAND AND MEET THE BASIC NEEDS
01:50:38.898 --> 01:50:41.201
OF OUR STUDENTS. OUR COLLEGE HAS
01:50:41.267 --> 01:50:42.635
MADE A SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT IN
01:50:42.702 --> 01:50:44.771
TRYING TO ADDRESS BASIC NEEDS BY
01:50:44.838 --> 01:50:46.206
CREATING STUDENT ENGAGEMENT
01:50:46.272 --> 01:50:47.107
CENTERS REPRESENTING
01:50:47.173 --> 01:50:51.044
UNDOCUMENTED VETERANS CENTER. UM
01:50:51.111 --> 01:50:52.712
CROSS CULTURAL CENTER, PRIDE
01:50:52.779 --> 01:50:53.680
CENTER, WOMEN AND GENDER
01:50:53.747 --> 01:50:54.848
RESOURCE CENTER, ALL OF WHICH
01:50:54.914 --> 01:50:56.182
SUPPORT OUR MOST VULNERABLE
01:50:56.249 --> 01:50:57.784
STUDENTS. ADDITIONALLY WE'VE
01:50:57.851 --> 01:50:59.185
ADDED THINGS LIKE A FOOD PANTRY
01:50:59.252 --> 01:51:00.687
. WE'RE WORKING ON A CLOTHING
01:51:00.754 --> 01:51:01.621
CLOSET RIGHT NOW FOR OUR
01:51:01.688 --> 01:51:03.256
STUDENTS, AND AS YOU MIGHT
01:51:03.323 --> 01:51:03.990
IMAGINE THAT THE DEMAND FOR
01:51:04.057 --> 01:51:05.191
THESE SERVICES HAVE SKYROCKETED
01:51:05.258 --> 01:51:07.394
THREE PANDEMIC AND I WORRY THAT
01:51:07.460 --> 01:51:08.361
THESE SERVICES WOULD BE AT RISK.
01:51:08.428 --> 01:51:09.763
AND THEN THIRD THE ABILITY TO
01:51:09.829 --> 01:51:10.797
SUPPORT OUR STUDENT SUCCESS IN
01:51:10.864 --> 01:51:12.699
EQUITY INITIATIVES AND FULLY
01:51:12.766 --> 01:51:14.234
IMPLEMENT GUIDED PATHWAYS.
01:51:14.300 --> 01:51:15.402
SIERRA COLLEGE HAS BEEN AN EARLY
01:51:15.468 --> 01:51:17.404
ADOPTER AND A LEADER IN THE
01:51:17.470 --> 01:51:18.338
STUDENT SUCCESS INITIATIVES
01:51:18.405 --> 01:51:21.174
ACROSS THE STATE. AND WE'VE AND
01:51:21.241 --> 01:51:23.276
WE HAVE AN EXTREMELY HIGH LEVEL
01:51:23.343 --> 01:51:24.844
OF RESOURCES ALLOCATED TO THESE
01:51:24.911 --> 01:51:27.213
EFFORTS, AND I FEAR THAT WITH
01:51:27.280 --> 01:51:27.847
LESS FLEXIBILITY IN OUR BUDGET,
01:51:27.914 --> 01:51:29.582
THESE EFFORTS WOULD DERAIL THAT
01:51:29.649 --> 01:51:31.317
WE WILL NOT HAVE THE RESOURCES
01:51:31.384 --> 01:51:31.951
TO CONTINUE TO FUND THEM. THANK
01:51:32.018 --> 01:51:33.853
YOU VERY MUCH FOR THE TIME. I
01:51:33.920 --> 01:51:36.289
URGE YOU TO VOTE NO ON A B 15
01:51:36.356 --> 01:51:37.424
OH, FIVE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH,
01:51:37.490 --> 01:51:38.792
MR DUNCAN. ALRIGHT ANYONE ELSE
01:51:38.858 --> 01:51:41.327
HERE IN ROOM 2100, WHO WISHES TO
01:51:41.394 --> 01:51:42.328
EXPRESS THEIR OPPOSITION. PLEASE
01:51:42.395 --> 01:51:44.097
PROCEED. THANK YOU. CHAIR AND
01:51:44.164 --> 01:51:45.832
MEMBERS ASHLEY WALKER WITH NO
01:51:45.899 --> 01:51:47.700
HOSEMANN ON BEHALF OF NORTH
01:51:47.767 --> 01:51:48.902
ORANGE COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:51:48.968 --> 01:51:50.670
DISTRICT, MOUNT SAN ANTONIO
01:51:50.737 --> 01:51:53.006
COLLEGE AND THE ASSOCIATION OF
01:51:53.073 --> 01:51:53.873
COMMUNITY AND CONTINUING
01:51:53.940 --> 01:51:54.874
EDUCATION AND OPPOSITION. THANK
01:51:54.941 --> 01:52:01.281
YOU. GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR
01:52:01.347 --> 01:52:02.615
AND MEMBERS DAVID NEVIN ON
01:52:02.682 --> 01:52:04.451
BEHALF OF THE PASADENA CITY
01:52:04.517 --> 01:52:05.952
COLLEGE, SANTA MONICA COLLEGE
01:52:06.019 --> 01:52:07.053
AND THE SOUTH ORANGE COUNTY
01:52:07.120 --> 01:52:08.021
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT IN
01:52:08.088 --> 01:52:10.290
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. GREAT
01:52:10.356 --> 01:52:11.658
SEEING NO ONE ELSE. MR.
01:52:11.724 --> 01:52:13.226
MODERATOR WE'RE GOING TO GO TO
01:52:13.293 --> 01:52:15.061
YOU TO PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE
01:52:15.128 --> 01:52:16.162
WHO WISHES TO SPEAK IN
01:52:16.229 --> 01:52:18.898
OPPOSITION OF A B 15. OH, FIVE.
01:52:18.965 --> 01:52:19.999
PRESS OPPOSITION TO AB 15 OH
01:52:20.066 --> 01:52:23.103
FIVE. PLEASE PRESS 10. 9 87, YOU
01:52:23.169 --> 01:52:28.408
ARE OPEN. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
01:52:28.475 --> 01:52:29.809
CHAIR AND MEMBERS CARLY SHELBY
01:52:29.876 --> 01:52:31.277
CALLING ON BEHALF OF COAST
01:52:31.344 --> 01:52:32.779
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT AND
01:52:32.846 --> 01:52:34.414
RAN CHESTER THIAGO COMMUNITY
01:52:34.481 --> 01:52:35.648
COLLEGE DISTRICT AND OPPOSITION.
01:52:35.715 --> 01:52:38.651
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. 9 88,
01:52:38.718 --> 01:52:43.356
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING,
01:52:43.423 --> 01:52:44.524
MICHELLE UNDERWOOD ON BEHALF OF
01:52:44.591 --> 01:52:46.392
THE ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
01:52:46.459 --> 01:52:47.193
COMMUNITY, COLLEGE
01:52:47.260 --> 01:52:52.398
ADMINISTRATORS AND OPPOSITION.
01:52:52.465 --> 01:52:53.566
AND FOR ANYBODY ELSE, PLEASE
01:52:53.633 --> 01:52:55.935
PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME. AND NEXT
01:52:56.002 --> 01:52:59.572
IS LINE 71. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI
01:52:59.639 --> 01:53:00.840
THIS IS SONNY COOK,
01:53:00.907 --> 01:53:02.308
SUPERINTENDENT PRESIDENT AT MIRA
01:53:02.375 --> 01:53:03.009
COSTA COLLEGE. AND I'M AN
01:53:03.076 --> 01:53:06.646
OPPOSITION TO HB 15. OH, FIVE.
01:53:06.713 --> 01:53:11.584
AND ONE MOMENT, MADAM CHAIR. 9
01:53:11.651 --> 01:53:15.922
41, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU,
01:53:15.989 --> 01:53:17.590
MADAM CHAIR MARK MCDONALD ON
01:53:17.657 --> 01:53:19.459
BEHALF OF THE ANTELOPE VALLEY,
01:53:19.526 --> 01:53:21.027
MOUNT SENATE-TV YOU ABOUT
01:53:21.094 --> 01:53:21.928
COMMUNITY, COLLEGE DISTRICTS AND
01:53:21.995 --> 01:53:22.896
OPPOSITION. THANK YOU. THANK
01:53:22.962 --> 01:53:28.434
YOU. ONE MORE WAS AN OPERATOR.
01:53:28.501 --> 01:53:29.702
AND THAT WILL BE LYING. 21, YOU
01:53:29.769 --> 01:53:33.907
ARE OPEN. YES THIS IS NICOLE
01:53:33.973 --> 01:53:36.042
KRUSE CALLING ON THE HALF OF
01:53:36.109 --> 01:53:36.543
MARINE COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:53:36.609 --> 01:53:47.587
DISTRICT IN OPPOSITION. ALL
01:53:47.654 --> 01:53:49.022
RIGHT. WAS THAT THE LAST PERSON?
01:53:49.088 --> 01:53:50.557
MR MODERATOR? THAT IS THE LAST
01:53:50.623 --> 01:53:51.925
PERSON AT THIS TIME. GREAT.
01:53:51.991 --> 01:53:53.293
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. LET'S BRING
01:53:53.359 --> 01:53:54.694
IT BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY
01:53:54.761 --> 01:53:55.828
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS.
01:53:55.895 --> 01:53:56.829
WE'RE GOING TO START WITH
01:53:56.896 --> 01:54:00.934
SENATOR PAN. YES ACTUALLY, UM,
01:54:01.000 --> 01:54:02.268
CAN HAVE THE LEAD OPPOSITION
01:54:02.335 --> 01:54:05.471
WITNESS WHICH MR DUNCAN THE
01:54:05.538 --> 01:54:07.273
FIRST OR SECOND PERSON IS THE
01:54:07.340 --> 01:54:08.441
FIRST STEP EITHER ONE. BUT
01:54:08.508 --> 01:54:13.780
EVERYONE WANTS TO TAKE THE LEAD.
01:54:13.846 --> 01:54:15.315
OKAY DEPENDS ON THE QUESTION.
01:54:15.381 --> 01:54:16.916
ALRIGHT WELL, NO. I MEAN, I
01:54:16.983 --> 01:54:19.819
THINK SO. SO SO FIRST OF ALL, UM
01:54:19.886 --> 01:54:20.853
, I THINK YOU KNOW, COMMUNITY
01:54:20.920 --> 01:54:22.288
COLLEGES HAVE DONE VERY
01:54:22.355 --> 01:54:23.523
IMPORTANT WORK AND SO FORTH,
01:54:23.590 --> 01:54:26.593
RIGHT AND CERTAINLY DON'T DENY
01:54:26.659 --> 01:54:28.194
EVERYTHING THAT YOU TALKED
01:54:28.261 --> 01:54:30.230
ABOUT. YOUR TESTIMONY IS THE
01:54:30.296 --> 01:54:33.233
QUESTION TO ME, IS THAT, UM, WE
01:54:33.299 --> 01:54:34.667
HAVE, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE A GOAL
01:54:34.734 --> 01:54:36.369
AND I ACTUALLY AUTHORED
01:54:36.436 --> 01:54:37.403
LEGISLATION BEFORE TO INCREASE
01:54:37.470 --> 01:54:39.472
THE NUMBER OF FULL TIME FACULTY.
01:54:39.539 --> 01:54:40.773
WE HAVE THIS NUMBER THIS FUN.
01:54:40.840 --> 01:54:43.676
WHICH DATES BACK TO 1988, WHICH
01:54:43.743 --> 01:54:44.711
CLEARLY DOESN'T REFLECT WHAT'S
01:54:44.777 --> 01:54:48.481
GOING ON RIGHT NOW. AND SO I GET
01:54:48.548 --> 01:54:51.551
YOUR SO. SO WHEN I HEAR YOUR
01:54:51.618 --> 01:54:52.685
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL, I GUESS
01:54:52.752 --> 01:54:54.621
MY QUESTION IS, IS THAT DO YOU
01:54:54.687 --> 01:54:57.357
HAVE AN ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION TO
01:54:57.423 --> 01:54:59.125
THIS PROBLEM, TOO, BECAUSE WHAT
01:54:59.192 --> 01:55:01.327
WE'RE USING WAS USING A NUMBER
01:55:01.394 --> 01:55:04.464
BACK FROM 1988. WHICH YOU KNOW,
01:55:04.530 --> 01:55:06.132
POPULATIONS GROWN. CALIFORNIA'S
01:55:06.199 --> 01:55:07.467
CHANGED, ETCETERA. A LOT OF
01:55:07.533 --> 01:55:08.801
THINGS HAVE HAPPENED SINCE THEN
01:55:08.868 --> 01:55:10.403
, INCLUDING, AS YOU POINTED OUT,
01:55:10.470 --> 01:55:11.170
YOU KNOW YOU'RE YOU'RE ABOVE
01:55:11.237 --> 01:55:12.171
BECAUSE ACTUALLY, YOU KNOW,
01:55:12.238 --> 01:55:13.873
YOU'RE YOU'RE MEETING THE NEEDS
01:55:13.940 --> 01:55:15.208
OF STUDENTS AND SO FORTH. SO I
01:55:15.275 --> 01:55:17.310
UNDERSTAND. YOU DON'T LIKE THIS
01:55:17.377 --> 01:55:17.977
SOLUTION. DO YOU HAVE AN
01:55:18.044 --> 01:55:20.713
ALTERNATIVE TO SO THAT WE HAVE A
01:55:20.780 --> 01:55:21.314
MORE ACCURATE NUMBER TO PUSH
01:55:21.381 --> 01:55:22.715
TOWARDS GETTING THAT TO ACHIEVE
01:55:22.782 --> 01:55:24.484
THE GOALS THEY HAVE BEEN LONG
01:55:24.550 --> 01:55:25.785
ESTABLISHED IN TERMS OF TRYING
01:55:25.852 --> 01:55:27.720
TO GET IT TO A HIGHER PERCENTAGE
01:55:27.787 --> 01:55:30.123
OF FULL TIME FACULTY. SO UM, SO
01:55:30.189 --> 01:55:33.059
I GUESS THAT BECAUSE I'M SO I
01:55:33.126 --> 01:55:34.894
LITTLE PUZZLED ABOUT NOT
01:55:34.961 --> 01:55:36.195
NECESSARILY OPPOSITION. BUT
01:55:36.262 --> 01:55:37.730
WHAT'S THE ALTERNATIVE? AT LEAST
01:55:37.797 --> 01:55:39.966
THIS SEEMS TO BE AT LEAST A
01:55:40.033 --> 01:55:42.402
SOLUTION TO THE TO THE VERY LONG
01:55:42.468 --> 01:55:43.536
ONGOING PROBLEMS THAT I OFFERED
01:55:43.603 --> 01:55:44.671
TO BUILD, YOU KNOW, WAY BACK.
01:55:44.737 --> 01:55:47.407
NGUYEN YOU KNOW ON ON THIS
01:55:47.473 --> 01:55:48.007
ISSUE, 2015. SO THAT'S SEVEN
01:55:48.074 --> 01:55:50.443
YEARS AGO AND WE STARTED WE HAD
01:55:50.510 --> 01:55:51.044
DON'T SEEM TO HAVE MADE MUCH
01:55:51.110 --> 01:55:53.012
PROGRESS ON THIS. SO CAN YOU
01:55:53.079 --> 01:55:54.614
SPEAK TO THAT? YEAH SO IT'S
01:55:54.681 --> 01:55:56.015
IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT THE
01:55:56.082 --> 01:55:57.917
DISTRICT'S CURRENT FUND IS BASED
01:55:57.984 --> 01:55:58.918
OFF OF WHERE THEY WERE IN 1988,
01:55:58.985 --> 01:56:00.920
BUT THAT NUMBER HAS CONTINUOUSLY
01:56:00.987 --> 01:56:01.554
BEEN ADJUSTED FOR INCREASES IN
01:56:01.621 --> 01:56:02.789
ENROLLMENT. UM AND BUDGET, SO
01:56:02.855 --> 01:56:05.858
IT'S NOT NOT THE NUMBER THAT WAS
01:56:05.925 --> 01:56:08.428
IN 1988. IT'S BASED OFF OF THAT
01:56:08.494 --> 01:56:10.563
NUMBER SO THAT NUMBER HAS UM THE
01:56:10.630 --> 01:56:13.032
SECOND THING IS OUR OUR REAL
01:56:13.099 --> 01:56:15.835
SOLUTION, AND THIS IS ACTUALLY I
01:56:15.902 --> 01:56:17.303
FRIENDS IS THAT THE REALLY TRULY
01:56:17.370 --> 01:56:18.404
FIXED FACULTY WORKING DISHES IN
01:56:18.471 --> 01:56:20.340
THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES IS TO
01:56:20.406 --> 01:56:21.474
INCREASE OUR FUNDING SO THAT WE
01:56:21.541 --> 01:56:22.675
COULD HIRE AND BETTER SUPPORT.
01:56:22.742 --> 01:56:24.177
THAT THAT WOULD BE OUR SOLUTION
01:56:24.243 --> 01:56:26.112
WOULD BE, TOO IF WE DO NEED TO
01:56:26.179 --> 01:56:28.314
HAVE MORE FACULTY PROVIDE THE
01:56:28.381 --> 01:56:29.482
FUNDING IN WHICH ARE COLLEGES
01:56:29.549 --> 01:56:30.950
CAN RESPONSIBLY. OKAY WELL,
01:56:31.017 --> 01:56:32.852
THAT'S THE BUDGETARY PROCESS. UM
01:56:32.919 --> 01:56:34.754
AND WILL BE WE'RE ENGAGING IN
01:56:34.821 --> 01:56:37.924
THAT. SO UM, I DO YOU KNOW, AND
01:56:37.990 --> 01:56:39.559
I KNOW THAT'S USUALLY THE ANSWER
01:56:39.625 --> 01:56:40.593
RIGHT HERE FROM LATVIA. JUST
01:56:40.660 --> 01:56:42.428
GIVE US MORE MONEY, AND IT WILL
01:56:42.495 --> 01:56:45.231
BE OKAY. UM SO AND I'M NOT
01:56:45.298 --> 01:56:45.798
SAYING THERE'S NOT TRUTH TO
01:56:45.865 --> 01:56:47.734
THAT. ALL RIGHT? I MEAN, IT'S A,
01:56:47.800 --> 01:56:52.205
UH, THAT BUT I GUESS I GUESS THE
01:56:52.271 --> 01:56:54.907
ULTIMATE I'M FRUSTRATED. I AND
01:56:54.974 --> 01:56:57.310
MY AND MY GUESS IS, UM YOU DON'T
01:56:57.377 --> 01:56:58.177
REALLY HAVE TO ANSWER THIS
01:56:58.244 --> 01:57:00.446
SENATOR. OBVIOUS I ASSUME YOU'RE
01:57:00.513 --> 01:57:01.781
FRUSTRATED, TOO. AND TO ME. I
01:57:01.848 --> 01:57:02.915
WOULD REALIZE THERE'S AN
01:57:02.982 --> 01:57:04.016
ADJUSTMENT FROM MY UNDERSTANDING
01:57:04.083 --> 01:57:06.018
OF THIS BILL IS JUST THAT THIS
01:57:06.085 --> 01:57:07.887
BILL ALSO GIVES US NOT ONLY YOU
01:57:07.954 --> 01:57:09.188
KNOW, DOES THE RESET BUT ALSO
01:57:09.255 --> 01:57:10.556
GIVES US A PATH FORWARD TO
01:57:10.623 --> 01:57:11.691
CONTINUALLY ADJUST SO THAT WE'RE
01:57:11.758 --> 01:57:14.093
NOT GUINEA STUCK IN THE PAST.
01:57:14.160 --> 01:57:17.163
CORRECT OKAY. ALRIGHT WITH THAT,
01:57:17.230 --> 01:57:19.031
UM, YOU KNOW, I JUST, YOU KNOW,
01:57:19.098 --> 01:57:20.600
I KNOW YOU WILL CONTINUE TO WORK
01:57:20.666 --> 01:57:21.868
WITH THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES. I
01:57:21.934 --> 01:57:23.503
KNOW THAT MY COMMUNITY COLLEGE
01:57:23.569 --> 01:57:25.505
HAD SOME CONCERNS. BUT I'M BUT
01:57:25.571 --> 01:57:28.541
THIS ISN'T AN ISSUE. THAT'S JUST
01:57:28.608 --> 01:57:29.876
, YOU KNOW, A LONG STANDING
01:57:29.942 --> 01:57:32.845
ISSUE AND TO ME USING NUMBERS
01:57:32.912 --> 01:57:34.947
THAT GO BACK AND GET IT. MAYBE
01:57:35.014 --> 01:57:36.149
YOU KNOW, THEY'RE JUST ETCETERA.
01:57:36.215 --> 01:57:38.684
WE NEED TO LOOK AT THIS SO I'M
01:57:38.751 --> 01:57:39.752
CERTAINLY GOING TO SUPPORT THE
01:57:39.819 --> 01:57:40.820
BILL, AND THEY'LL MOVE THE BILL
01:57:40.887 --> 01:57:43.055
AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. THANK
01:57:43.122 --> 01:57:44.190
YOU. THANK YOU, SENATOR PAN.
01:57:44.257 --> 01:57:45.158
FURTHER QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR
01:57:45.224 --> 01:57:46.926
CONCERNS, SENATOR GLASER. THANK
01:57:46.993 --> 01:57:49.128
YOU THROUGH THE CHAIR. I'D LIKE
01:57:49.195 --> 01:57:50.430
TO ASK THE PRESIDENT'S YEAR OF
01:57:50.496 --> 01:57:52.999
COLLEGE QUESTION. UM UH, WHEN
01:57:53.065 --> 01:57:54.200
YOU MAKE THESE DECISIONS ABOUT
01:57:54.267 --> 01:57:57.603
THESE, THESE CHOICES. DO YOU
01:57:57.670 --> 01:57:59.272
HAVE A GOVERNING BOARD THAT
01:57:59.338 --> 01:58:00.706
OVERSEES YOUR COLLEGE? WE DO
01:58:00.773 --> 01:58:03.009
ABSOLUTELY ELECTED BOARD THAT IS
01:58:03.075 --> 01:58:03.910
AN ELECTED BOARD OF TRUSTEES.
01:58:03.976 --> 01:58:06.045
AND ARE THESE MATTERS IN WHICH
01:58:06.112 --> 01:58:06.946
THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES WOULD
01:58:07.013 --> 01:58:09.048
WOULD CONSIDER IN TERMS OF THE
01:58:09.115 --> 01:58:10.216
GOVERNANCE OF YOUR COLLEGE AND
01:58:10.283 --> 01:58:11.851
OTHERS? YES, ABSOLUTELY. AND
01:58:11.918 --> 01:58:13.820
THEN CAN YOU SPEAK TO THE ISSUE
01:58:13.886 --> 01:58:15.555
OF THE HOW THE LACK OF
01:58:15.621 --> 01:58:18.524
FLEXIBILITY MIGHT AFFECT AH, THE
01:58:18.591 --> 01:58:20.059
DELIVERY OF EDUCATION OF THE
01:58:20.126 --> 01:58:21.828
STUDENTS. IF THERE WAS A
01:58:21.894 --> 01:58:22.862
LIMITATION AS DISCUSSED IN A
01:58:22.929 --> 01:58:25.064
BILL LIKE THIS AND AS STUDENT
01:58:25.131 --> 01:58:26.799
INTERESTS CHANGE AS DEMAND
01:58:26.866 --> 01:58:28.301
CHANGES. HOW IS THAT GOING TO
01:58:28.367 --> 01:58:29.936
AFFECT THE ABILITY OF YOUR
01:58:30.002 --> 01:58:31.404
COLLEGE TO PROVIDE THE STUDENTS
01:58:31.471 --> 01:58:32.505
WITH THE CLASSES THAT THEY WANT
01:58:32.572 --> 01:58:35.174
TO TAKE? YES CERTAINLY. UM WELL
01:58:35.241 --> 01:58:36.576
, OBVIOUSLY, YOU KNOW, WE BUILD
01:58:36.642 --> 01:58:37.977
A SCHEDULE EVERY YEAR. WE DO AN
01:58:38.044 --> 01:58:39.645
ANALYSIS EVERY YEAR OF WHAT OUR
01:58:39.712 --> 01:58:41.180
STUDENTS ARE LOOKING FOR. AND
01:58:41.247 --> 01:58:43.349
YOU KNOW, THE MORE WE LOCK IN ON
01:58:43.416 --> 01:58:45.885
A PARTICULAR SET OF STAFF. SO
01:58:45.952 --> 01:58:47.053
FOR HIRING MORE FULL TIME
01:58:47.119 --> 01:58:48.020
FACULTY MEMBERS, AND WE'VE
01:58:48.087 --> 01:58:50.389
ELEVATED THAT THAT AMOUNT IT'S
01:58:50.456 --> 01:58:51.824
HARDER TO CHANGE DIRECTION.
01:58:51.891 --> 01:58:53.493
DEFINITELY OFTENTIMES IF WE
01:58:53.559 --> 01:58:54.894
CREATE A NEW PROGRAM THAT FIRST
01:58:54.961 --> 01:58:57.263
STARTS WITH PART TIME FACULTY TO
01:58:57.330 --> 01:58:58.097
GET IT STARTED OFF THE GROUND,
01:58:58.164 --> 01:59:00.366
AND THEN WE HIRE FULL TIME
01:59:00.433 --> 01:59:01.501
FACULTY INTO THE ROLE TO BUILD
01:59:01.567 --> 01:59:03.603
THAT PROGRAM. I'M SURE IT
01:59:03.669 --> 01:59:04.871
DOESN'T SURPRISE YOU TO HEAR ME
01:59:04.937 --> 01:59:06.772
AND OTHERS IN THE LEGISLATURE
01:59:06.839 --> 01:59:08.307
RAISED CONCERNS AND EVEN
01:59:08.374 --> 01:59:11.344
CRITICISMS ABOUT THE ABILITY OF
01:59:11.410 --> 01:59:12.578
STUDENTS TO GET THE CLASSES THEY
01:59:12.645 --> 01:59:14.480
NEED TO. UM, PLAYED A TWO YEAR
01:59:14.547 --> 01:59:16.449
DEGREE OR CERTIFICATION.
01:59:16.516 --> 01:59:17.884
CERTAINLY THEY'VE HEARD FROM ME
01:59:17.950 --> 01:59:19.118
IN REGARD TO THE FOUR YEAR
01:59:19.185 --> 01:59:20.152
GRADUATION RATES AT THE STATE
01:59:20.219 --> 01:59:22.788
UNIVERSITY. UM BUT SO THIS IS
01:59:22.855 --> 01:59:24.123
KIND OF THERE'S SOME FLEX ITTY
01:59:24.190 --> 01:59:25.858
IN THIS SPACE, BUT THERE'S A
01:59:25.925 --> 01:59:27.293
TRADE OFF ISN'T THERE ABOUT WE
01:59:27.360 --> 01:59:28.794
WANT STUDENT COMPLETION? WE WANT
01:59:28.861 --> 01:59:30.096
TO LOWER DEBT AND OBLIGATIONS.
01:59:30.162 --> 01:59:31.864
WE WANT THEM TO GET AND MEET
01:59:31.931 --> 01:59:35.801
THEIR GOALS. AND YET, A PART OF
01:59:35.868 --> 01:59:38.638
WRESTLE WITH EVERY YEAR. IS THIS
01:59:38.704 --> 01:59:40.673
ISSUE OF PART TIME FACULTY
01:59:40.740 --> 01:59:42.174
VERSUS FULL TIME FACULTY. ISN'T
01:59:42.241 --> 01:59:43.809
THAT RIGHT? ABSOLUTELY AND IT'S
01:59:43.876 --> 01:59:45.411
SOMETHING WE CLOSELY MONITOR. IT
01:59:45.478 --> 01:59:48.447
ALSO GIVES STUDENTS CHOICE IN
01:59:48.514 --> 01:59:49.849
FACULTY MEMBERS, AS WE KNOW
01:59:49.916 --> 01:59:51.484
STUDENTS OFTENTIMES NEED A
01:59:51.551 --> 01:59:53.619
DIFFERENT TYPE OF INSTRUCTOR,
01:59:53.686 --> 01:59:54.620
SOMEBODY THAT PROVIDES A
01:59:54.687 --> 01:59:55.821
DIFFERENT WAY OF TEACHING TO
01:59:55.888 --> 01:59:57.890
HELP THEM BE SUCCESSFUL. AND
01:59:57.957 --> 02:00:00.159
THEN I DON'T THINK YOU CAN
02:00:00.226 --> 02:00:00.726
OVERLOOK ALL OF THE STUDENT
02:00:00.793 --> 02:00:02.194
SUCCESS INITIATIVES THAT WE'VE
02:00:02.261 --> 02:00:03.663
GOT IN PLACE, AND I TRIED TO
02:00:03.729 --> 02:00:05.197
ADDRESS THAT IN MY COMMENTS, BUT
02:00:05.264 --> 02:00:06.499
, UM, WE'VE GOT MILLIONS
02:00:06.566 --> 02:00:09.936
INVESTED IN STAFF AND, UM AND IN
02:00:10.002 --> 02:00:12.138
SYSTEMS THAT DON'T INVOLVE A
02:00:12.204 --> 02:00:13.673
FULL TIME FACULTY MEMBER OR
02:00:13.739 --> 02:00:15.408
INVOLVE A FULL TIME FACULTY
02:00:15.474 --> 02:00:16.876
MEMBER FROM THE STANDPOINT OF
02:00:16.943 --> 02:00:18.511
RAISING A FLAG THAT I HAVE A
02:00:18.578 --> 02:00:19.111
STUDENT THAT'S STRUGGLING. BUT
02:00:19.178 --> 02:00:20.880
THEN WE HAVE A WHOLE TEAM THAT
02:00:20.947 --> 02:00:22.882
TRIES TO STEP IN AND SUPPORT AND
02:00:22.949 --> 02:00:24.250
THAT'S BEEN PART OF SOME OF THE
02:00:24.317 --> 02:00:25.685
CHANGES IN THE REENGINEERING
02:00:25.751 --> 02:00:26.886
THAT WE'VE GONE THROUGH IN THE
02:00:26.953 --> 02:00:27.820
LAST FEW YEARS. THANK YOU AND
02:00:27.887 --> 02:00:30.056
THEN TO THE AUTHOR, UM AND THIS
02:00:30.122 --> 02:00:31.958
IS THE DILEMMA THAT I HAVE ON
02:00:32.024 --> 02:00:33.125
YOUR BILL AGAIN. I SHARE THE
02:00:33.192 --> 02:00:34.727
GOALS IN WHICH YOU HAVE ADVANCED
02:00:34.794 --> 02:00:36.796
IN THIS BILL, BUT I WORRY ABOUT
02:00:36.862 --> 02:00:37.563
THE COMPLEXITY OF THESE
02:00:37.630 --> 02:00:38.965
INDIVIDUAL CHOICES AT EACH
02:00:39.031 --> 02:00:39.966
COLLEGE, AND I WORRY THAT THE
02:00:40.032 --> 02:00:42.568
GOALS THAT WE HAVE ABOUT STUDENT
02:00:42.635 --> 02:00:43.169
COMPLETION CAN CONFLICT WITH
02:00:43.235 --> 02:00:45.204
THESE REQUIREMENTS THAT MIGHT BE
02:00:45.271 --> 02:00:46.405
PUT FORWARD IN YOUR BILL. AND
02:00:46.472 --> 02:00:50.810
FINALLY WE MAY NEVER BE AT A
02:00:50.876 --> 02:00:52.778
SITUATION A YEAR, A BUDGET YEAR.
02:00:52.845 --> 02:00:56.616
AS AS AS RICH AND SUPPORTIVE OF
02:00:56.682 --> 02:00:58.684
OUR COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES.
02:00:58.751 --> 02:00:59.819
AS WE ARE GOING TO EXPERIENCE
02:00:59.885 --> 02:01:02.788
THIS YEAR. AS WE FINALIZE OUR
02:01:02.855 --> 02:01:05.424
BUDGET FOR THE COMING YEAR. AND
02:01:05.491 --> 02:01:07.426
BY BENCHMARKING IT IN THIS IN
02:01:07.493 --> 02:01:09.462
THIS MOMENT, IT REALLY IS
02:01:09.528 --> 02:01:10.997
CREATING. WHAT POTENTIALLY IS AN
02:01:11.063 --> 02:01:12.698
ARTIFICIAL NUMBER THAT IS GOING
02:01:12.765 --> 02:01:14.867
TO CREATE A LOT OF DIFFICULTY.
02:01:14.934 --> 02:01:17.103
IT SEEMS TO ME AND I WANT TO
02:01:17.169 --> 02:01:18.304
GIVE YOU THE CHANCE TO ADDRESS
02:01:18.371 --> 02:01:19.572
THAT. AND FINALLY ARE THERE.
02:01:19.639 --> 02:01:20.606
PENALTIES IN YOUR BILL? IF A
02:01:20.673 --> 02:01:22.341
COLLEGE IT DOESN'T COMPLY? WHAT
02:01:22.408 --> 02:01:23.943
HAPPENS TO A COLLEGE IF THEY'RE
02:01:24.010 --> 02:01:25.911
NOT ABLE TO YOU TWO YEARS OUT
02:01:25.978 --> 02:01:27.780
FIVE YEARS OUT, THE BUDGET DROPS
02:01:27.847 --> 02:01:30.850
20, AND IT HAS AND THEY HAVE TO
02:01:30.916 --> 02:01:32.652
MAKE TOUGH CALLS. WHAT ARE THE
02:01:32.718 --> 02:01:33.786
CONSEQUENCES THAT MIGHT BE
02:01:33.853 --> 02:01:35.788
REQUIRED AS A PART OF YOUR BILL?
02:01:35.855 --> 02:01:37.556
GOING BACK TO THE FIRST QUESTION
02:01:37.623 --> 02:01:39.091
? I MEAN, THEY'RE STILL GOING TO
02:01:39.158 --> 02:01:41.127
BE SOME FLEXIBILITY, RIGHT? AND,
02:01:41.193 --> 02:01:42.028
YEAH, YOU'RE RIGHT. THIS IS A
02:01:42.094 --> 02:01:42.695
VERY IMPRESSIVE PRENTICE IN THE
02:01:42.762 --> 02:01:44.563
YEAR, RIGHT? THERE ARE OTHER THE
02:01:44.630 --> 02:01:45.931
FUNDING THAT WE HAVE, BUT WE
02:01:45.998 --> 02:01:47.933
ALSO GOT TO MAKE SURE THAT THESE
02:01:48.000 --> 02:01:49.035
INSTITUTIONS REALLY GET THE
02:01:49.101 --> 02:01:50.302
FUNNY. THEY NEED TO HIRE THOSE
02:01:50.369 --> 02:01:52.004
FULL TIME STUDENTS AND MAKE SURE
02:01:52.071 --> 02:01:53.572
OUR FACULTY I SHOULD SAY TO MAKE
02:01:53.639 --> 02:01:54.907
SURE THAT THEIR SERVICES BEING
02:01:54.974 --> 02:01:55.941
PROVIDED AND ONCE AGAIN,
02:01:56.008 --> 02:01:57.076
DEPENDING ON ENROLLMENT, RIGHT
02:01:57.143 --> 02:01:58.544
AS FAR AS THE SECOND QUESTION
02:01:58.611 --> 02:02:00.212
REGARDING THE PENALTY, I DON'T
02:02:00.279 --> 02:02:00.780
THINK THERE IS BUT MAYBE OUR
02:02:00.846 --> 02:02:01.914
SPONSOR HERE CAN MAYBE ELABORATE
02:02:01.981 --> 02:02:05.384
MORE ON THAT. RIGHT? CAN'T
02:02:05.451 --> 02:02:07.086
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S. THERE ARE
02:02:07.153 --> 02:02:08.821
EXISTING PENALTIES THAT EXIST
02:02:08.888 --> 02:02:09.922
FOR DISTRICTS THAT DON'T COMPLY
02:02:09.989 --> 02:02:11.157
WITH THE FOLLOWING THEIR
02:02:11.223 --> 02:02:12.091
DISCRETIONARY IMPOSED BY THE
02:02:12.158 --> 02:02:13.125
COMMUNITY COLLEGE BY THE
02:02:13.192 --> 02:02:16.195
CHANCELLOR'S OFFICE. UM AGAIN.
02:02:16.262 --> 02:02:18.264
WE WANT TO POINT OUT THAT JUST
02:02:18.330 --> 02:02:20.433
ON THE FUNDING ISSUE THAT WE'RE
02:02:20.499 --> 02:02:21.467
TALKING MOSTLY ABOUT IN YEARS
02:02:21.534 --> 02:02:23.436
PAST IN BUDGET YEARS WHERE THIS
02:02:23.502 --> 02:02:24.470
LEGISLATURE, THIS BODY HAS
02:02:24.537 --> 02:02:25.971
ALLOCATED SPECIFIC FUNDS FOR THE
02:02:26.038 --> 02:02:27.139
SOLE PURPOSE OF HIRING FULL TIME
02:02:27.206 --> 02:02:28.974
FACULTY. SO I UNDERSTAND THE
02:02:29.041 --> 02:02:31.343
NECESSITY OF, UH OF HAVING TO
02:02:31.410 --> 02:02:32.978
DEAL WITH SORT OF THE BUDGETARY
02:02:33.045 --> 02:02:34.313
INTEREST OF THE DISTRICT AND
02:02:34.380 --> 02:02:35.815
DEALING WITH OTHER STUDENT NEEDS
02:02:35.881 --> 02:02:37.016
AND PROGRAM NEEDS, BUT WE'RE
02:02:37.083 --> 02:02:38.117
TALKING ABOUT WHEN THIS BODY
02:02:38.184 --> 02:02:40.086
SAYS HERE'S $100 MILLION TO GO
02:02:40.152 --> 02:02:42.254
OUT FOR THE EXPRESS PURPOSE OF
02:02:42.321 --> 02:02:43.355
HIRING FULL TIME FACULTY. WE'RE
02:02:43.422 --> 02:02:44.523
GOING TO GIVE YOU THIS MONEY
02:02:44.590 --> 02:02:45.825
ONGOING. AND IN THE DISTRICT.
02:02:45.891 --> 02:02:46.926
THEY THANK YOU FOR THAT MONEY.
02:02:46.992 --> 02:02:48.828
WE'RE NOT GOING TO HIRE FULL
02:02:48.894 --> 02:02:49.695
TIME FACULTY. WELL, THAT'S
02:02:49.762 --> 02:02:51.931
REALLY ONE OF THE PROBLEMS THAT
02:02:51.997 --> 02:02:52.832
WE'RE TRYING TO SOLVE. HERE AND
02:02:52.898 --> 02:02:54.200
AGAIN, AS THE ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:02:54.266 --> 02:02:54.834
SAID IN THOSE BUDGETARY YEARS,
02:02:54.900 --> 02:02:56.102
AS YOU EXPRESSED WHEN THE BUDGET
02:02:56.168 --> 02:02:57.803
DROPS OR ENROLLMENT DROPS, THE
02:02:57.870 --> 02:02:58.904
PHONE GOES DOWN. SO EVEN THOUGH
02:02:58.971 --> 02:02:59.739
WE'RE BENCHMARKING THE FONT
02:02:59.805 --> 02:03:01.140
TODAY AT PRESENT VALUES NOT
02:03:01.207 --> 02:03:02.775
SAYING DISTRICTS GO OUT AND HIRE
02:03:02.842 --> 02:03:04.143
A BUNCH OF PEOPLE WERE SAYING
02:03:04.210 --> 02:03:05.711
HOWEVER MANY FULL TIME FACULTY
02:03:05.778 --> 02:03:06.979
YOU HAVE TODAY THAT'S GOING TO
02:03:07.046 --> 02:03:08.647
BE THAT BENCHMARK AND THEN IN
02:03:08.714 --> 02:03:10.116
THE FUTURE IF ENROLLMENT DROPS
02:03:10.182 --> 02:03:11.283
IF FUNDING DROPS, THEN THE PHONE
02:03:11.350 --> 02:03:12.985
DROPS. IN THE RESPONSIBILITY AND
02:03:13.052 --> 02:03:14.487
OBLIGATION FOR THOSE DISTRICTS
02:03:14.553 --> 02:03:16.021
TO PROVIDE. THAT NUMBER WILL
02:03:16.088 --> 02:03:18.224
DROP AS WELL. SO AM I VIEW. I
02:03:18.290 --> 02:03:19.825
DON'T THINK WE'RE LIMITING
02:03:19.892 --> 02:03:21.327
FLEXIBILITY HERE. I THINK WE'RE
02:03:21.393 --> 02:03:22.628
ENSURING THAT THOSE FUNDS ARE
02:03:22.695 --> 02:03:23.796
ALLOCATED FOR THE EXPRESS
02:03:23.863 --> 02:03:25.598
PURPOSE OF HIRING FULL TIME
02:03:25.664 --> 02:03:26.766
FACULTY OR USED FOR THAT PURPOSE
02:03:26.832 --> 02:03:28.601
AND AGAIN BECAUSE THE PHONE
02:03:28.667 --> 02:03:29.668
DROPS, THEY HAVE THE ABILITY TO
02:03:29.735 --> 02:03:31.003
ADJUST. AND I APPRECIATE THE
02:03:31.070 --> 02:03:31.971
INSIGHT THAT YOU BRING ONE
02:03:32.037 --> 02:03:33.706
FOLLOW UP QUESTION. SO IF YOU'RE
02:03:33.773 --> 02:03:35.775
A COLLEGE PROFESSOR PRESIDENT
02:03:35.841 --> 02:03:38.410
AND YOU SEE THE BENCHMARKS GOING
02:03:38.477 --> 02:03:40.546
TO BE ON THE BUDGET? 22 23.
02:03:40.613 --> 02:03:42.047
ISN'T THERE SOME UNINTENDED
02:03:42.114 --> 02:03:43.549
CONSEQUENCES THAT WILL GO INTO
02:03:43.616 --> 02:03:45.284
THE DECISIONS THAT YOU'RE GOING
02:03:45.351 --> 02:03:46.218
TO BE MAKING NEXT YEAR ABOUT
02:03:46.285 --> 02:03:48.020
FULL TIME FACULTY BECAUSE YOU
02:03:48.087 --> 02:03:49.255
KNOW THAT YOU'RE GOING TO SET A
02:03:49.321 --> 02:03:50.389
BENCHMARK DOESN'T CREATE A
02:03:50.456 --> 02:03:51.924
PRESSURE TO CREATE A LOWER
02:03:51.991 --> 02:03:52.658
BENCHMARK. AND ACTUALLY DO THE
02:03:52.725 --> 02:03:54.059
OPPOSITE OF WHAT YOU'D LIKE TO
02:03:54.126 --> 02:03:55.961
DO, BECAUSE NOW YOU'RE GOING TO
02:03:56.028 --> 02:03:56.695
BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE ABOUT A
02:03:56.762 --> 02:03:58.197
BENCHMARK THAT YOU HAVE SOME
02:03:58.264 --> 02:03:59.632
CONTROL OF FOR THE MOMENT ISN'T
02:03:59.698 --> 02:04:00.800
GOING TO AFFECT YOUR DECISIONS
02:04:00.866 --> 02:04:01.767
GOING FORWARD AND HAVE THE
02:04:01.834 --> 02:04:04.637
ACTUAL OPPOSITE EFFECT. I DON'T
02:04:04.703 --> 02:04:06.405
THINK SO. I THINK WE'RE MAKING
02:04:06.472 --> 02:04:08.207
THE ASSUMPTION NOW THAT THAT
02:04:08.274 --> 02:04:10.910
NUMBER THAT'S BASED OFF 30
02:04:10.976 --> 02:04:12.378
SOMETHING YEARS AGO. IT'S PRETTY
02:04:12.444 --> 02:04:13.479
OUTDATED, AND I THINK THAT'S
02:04:13.546 --> 02:04:15.915
THAT'S UH, IDENTIFIABLE BY THE
02:04:15.981 --> 02:04:18.184
BY THE FACT THAT 70 OUT OF 72
02:04:18.250 --> 02:04:20.052
DISTRICTS ARE WELL ABOVE THE
02:04:20.119 --> 02:04:20.853
FAWN, SO I THINK THE BENCHING
02:04:20.920 --> 02:04:23.355
AND SAYING LET'S SET IT LET'S
02:04:23.422 --> 02:04:24.523
RESET THE FLOOR AT PRESIDENT
02:04:24.590 --> 02:04:25.457
VALUES. I'M ASSUMING THESE
02:04:25.524 --> 02:04:26.559
DISTRICTS HAVE DONE THEIR
02:04:26.625 --> 02:04:28.060
ASSESSMENT TO SAY THIS IS HOW
02:04:28.127 --> 02:04:29.829
MANY FULL TIME FACULTY WE NEED
02:04:29.895 --> 02:04:31.130
FOR THE MOMENT AND THAT'S THE
02:04:31.197 --> 02:04:32.965
NUMBER OF WHERE THEY'RE AT NOW.
02:04:33.032 --> 02:04:35.201
AND I WANT TO ALSO PREDICATE THE
02:04:35.267 --> 02:04:36.135
FACT THAT NONE OF THESE
02:04:36.202 --> 02:04:36.936
DISTRICTS HAVE MET THEIR GOAL OF
02:04:37.002 --> 02:04:38.904
75. SO AGAIN, THEORY COLLEGE. I
02:04:38.971 --> 02:04:40.506
THINK THEY'RE AT 55% SO WE'RE
02:04:40.573 --> 02:04:42.908
NOT SAYING, UH, SAID IT FOR A
02:04:42.975 --> 02:04:44.143
HIGHER BENCHMARK. IT'S AT A
02:04:44.210 --> 02:04:45.811
HIGHER GOAL. WE'RE SAYING THIS
02:04:45.878 --> 02:04:47.947
BODY HAS ESTABLISHED A GOAL AND
02:04:48.013 --> 02:04:48.948
SAID THAT WE WANT TO ACHIEVE 75%
02:04:49.014 --> 02:04:50.816
AND NOBODY IS THERE. SO WE
02:04:50.883 --> 02:04:51.717
DECIDED TO PRESENT VALUES AND
02:04:51.784 --> 02:04:53.152
PRESUMABLY, THESE DISTRICTS HAVE
02:04:53.219 --> 02:04:54.653
GONE OUT AND DONE THE WORK AND
02:04:54.720 --> 02:04:56.355
SAYING THIS IS THE NUMBER THAT
02:04:56.422 --> 02:04:57.823
WE NEED. SO THAT'S WHERE WE'RE
02:04:57.890 --> 02:04:59.725
GOING TO RESET THE FLOOR AND IT
02:04:59.792 --> 02:05:00.993
WILL ONLY ADJUST IF THEY GET
02:05:01.060 --> 02:05:03.028
MORE MONEY. SO THERE'S NOT A
02:05:03.095 --> 02:05:03.996
LIKEIHOOD OF THE FUN, YOU KNOW,
02:05:04.063 --> 02:05:05.064
JUMPING UP AND THEY'RE NOT
02:05:05.130 --> 02:05:06.966
GETTING MONEY FOR IT SO AND IF
02:05:07.032 --> 02:05:08.968
THERE'S A DROP IN ENROLLMENT IN
02:05:09.034 --> 02:05:10.202
THE PHONE CAN GO DOWN, SO THAT
02:05:10.269 --> 02:05:11.103
FLEXIBILITY IS THERE. WE'RE
02:05:11.170 --> 02:05:12.905
ASSUMING THAT THE DISTRICTS HAVE
02:05:12.972 --> 02:05:13.472
DONE THEIR DUE DILIGENCE TO
02:05:13.539 --> 02:05:15.107
ASSUME THAT THEY'VE HAD THE
02:05:15.174 --> 02:05:16.876
RIGHT AMOUNT OF FACULTY FOR THE
02:05:16.942 --> 02:05:18.110
MOMENT AND HOPEFULLY BARRY BENCH
02:05:18.177 --> 02:05:20.479
IN IT TODAY WE CAN SEE PROGRESS
02:05:20.546 --> 02:05:21.580
TOWARDS GETTING SOURCE AT 75% I
02:05:21.647 --> 02:05:22.848
GET IT. I'M ONLY POINTING OUT
02:05:22.915 --> 02:05:24.049
THAT WE'RE GOING TO GIVE THEM
02:05:24.116 --> 02:05:25.084
MILLIONS AND MILLIONS OF MORE
02:05:25.150 --> 02:05:26.619
DOLLARS IN THE COMING YEAR. AND
02:05:26.685 --> 02:05:27.820
THEY'RE GOING TO MAKE DECISIONS
02:05:27.887 --> 02:05:30.189
ABOUT HOW TO SPEND ALL THAT
02:05:30.256 --> 02:05:31.357
MONEY. AND IT DOES SEEM LIKE
02:05:31.423 --> 02:05:32.524
THERE'S ANY CRAZY DISINCENTIVE
02:05:32.591 --> 02:05:34.026
AND I DON'T DISAGREE WITH YOUR
02:05:34.093 --> 02:05:35.227
ANALYSIS OF THE 75% BUT IT JUST
02:05:35.294 --> 02:05:36.462
SEEMED STRANGE DISINCENTIVE THAT
02:05:36.528 --> 02:05:37.963
WOULD COME FROM THE SPILL AND
02:05:38.030 --> 02:05:39.098
FINALLY TO THE AUTHOR. YOU KNOW,
02:05:39.164 --> 02:05:40.799
ONE OF THE CHALLENGES AND POLICY
02:05:40.866 --> 02:05:42.101
MAKING IN THE EDUCATION SPACE,
02:05:42.167 --> 02:05:43.836
AND THIS IS A PHILOSOPHICAL
02:05:43.903 --> 02:05:44.970
CHALLENGE FOR ALL OF US IS THAT
02:05:45.037 --> 02:05:46.772
WE HAVE ELECTED TRUSTEES. EACH
02:05:46.839 --> 02:05:47.673
OF THESE DISTRICTS THAT DO WHAT
02:05:47.740 --> 02:05:49.775
WE TRY TO DO HERE, WHICH IS TO
02:05:49.842 --> 02:05:52.311
OVERSEE THE GREAT PROFESSIONAL
02:05:52.378 --> 02:05:52.912
STAFF AND THE CHOICES THEY'RE
02:05:52.978 --> 02:05:53.712
THAT THEY'RE MAKING. AND THIS
02:05:53.779 --> 02:05:55.981
BILL DOES CREATE A ONE SIZE FITS
02:05:56.048 --> 02:05:57.983
ALL AND A VERY COMPLEX. IN YOU
02:05:58.050 --> 02:05:59.184
KNOW, BUDGETARYENVIRONMENT,
02:05:59.251 --> 02:06:00.185
STUDENTS SERVICES ENVIRONMENT,
02:06:00.252 --> 02:06:01.353
AND MAYBE YOU COULD SPEAK TO
02:06:01.420 --> 02:06:03.789
THAT. YEAH WELL, YOU KNOW, UM,
02:06:03.856 --> 02:06:05.724
WE COME FROM DIFFERENT PARTS
02:06:05.791 --> 02:06:07.793
WHERE WE LOOK AT WHAT'S BEST AND
02:06:07.860 --> 02:06:09.561
REALLY LOOKING AT THIS BILL IS
02:06:09.628 --> 02:06:11.697
JUST TO MAKE SURE THAT THESE, UH
02:06:11.764 --> 02:06:13.465
, COMMUNITY COLLEGES REALLY USE
02:06:13.532 --> 02:06:14.700
THAT MONEY FOR WHAT IT'S FOR, IN
02:06:14.767 --> 02:06:16.435
THIS CASE TO HIRE THE FULL TIME
02:06:16.502 --> 02:06:17.703
FACULTY AND THERE IS A
02:06:17.770 --> 02:06:19.038
FLEXIBILITY, RIGHT? AND IT MAY
02:06:19.104 --> 02:06:20.906
NOT BE THE BEST FOR EVERYBODY,
02:06:20.973 --> 02:06:22.107
BUT THIS IS A START, RIGHT? AND
02:06:22.174 --> 02:06:23.842
LIKE WE SAID, IF THIS ISN'T THE
02:06:23.909 --> 02:06:25.811
RIGHT, BILL, THEN TELL ME WHICH
02:06:25.878 --> 02:06:27.813
HOW DO WE GET THERE? HOW DO WE
02:06:27.880 --> 02:06:29.048
ACHIEVE THE GOALS THAT WE ALL
02:06:29.114 --> 02:06:30.950
WANT? AND MAYBE IT'S NOT GOING
02:06:31.016 --> 02:06:32.284
TO BE UNDER SENT FOR EVERYBODY.
02:06:32.351 --> 02:06:34.019
BUT IT WILL BE MOVING FORWARD.
02:06:34.086 --> 02:06:35.321
HOW DO WE ADDRESS IT? AND REALLY
02:06:35.387 --> 02:06:35.754
MAKE SURE THAT THESE
02:06:35.821 --> 02:06:36.889
INSTITUTIONS HAVE THE RESOURCES
02:06:36.956 --> 02:06:38.791
NECESSARY TO CONTINUE PROVIDING
02:06:38.857 --> 02:06:39.792
THE EDUCATION FOR THE STUDENTS,
02:06:39.858 --> 02:06:41.560
NOT ONLY FOR TODAY BUT FOR THE
02:06:41.627 --> 02:06:42.861
FUTURE AND ADJUST AS ACCORDINGLY
02:06:42.928 --> 02:06:44.296
AS AS THE YEARS AGO. THANK YOU,
02:06:44.363 --> 02:06:45.931
SENATOR GLASER ANY FURTHER
02:06:45.998 --> 02:06:46.999
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS?
02:06:47.066 --> 02:06:50.769
SENATOR KOBO. HELLO AND THANK
02:06:50.836 --> 02:06:51.804
YOU ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RODRIGUEZ
02:06:51.870 --> 02:06:52.838
FOR BEING BRINGING THIS BILL
02:06:52.905 --> 02:06:56.408
FORWARD. I DO HAVE SEVERAL
02:06:56.475 --> 02:06:59.979
CONCERNS WITH THE BILL AND I
02:07:00.045 --> 02:07:02.214
THAT ASIDE, I WOULD BE HAPPY TO
02:07:02.281 --> 02:07:03.716
WORK WITH YOU IN THE FUTURE AND
02:07:03.782 --> 02:07:06.185
TRYING TO SEE HOW WE CAN MAKE
02:07:06.251 --> 02:07:08.787
THIS FIX THE ISSUE. ONE OF THE
02:07:08.854 --> 02:07:11.357
CONCERNS THAT I SEE RIGHT NOW IS
02:07:11.423 --> 02:07:12.391
THE COMMENTS THAT YOU MADE THAT
02:07:12.458 --> 02:07:13.392
YEARLY WITNESSES MADE WITH
02:07:13.459 --> 02:07:15.194
REGARD TO THE FACT THAT PEOPLE
02:07:15.260 --> 02:07:17.129
ARE OR THE SCHOOL DISTRICT ARE
02:07:17.196 --> 02:07:18.664
NOT MEETING THAT ON ALREADY, AND
02:07:18.731 --> 02:07:19.832
I THINK THAT THE PROBLEM THERE
02:07:19.898 --> 02:07:22.301
LIES MORE IN ACCOUNTABILITY AND
02:07:22.368 --> 02:07:23.736
HOLDING, YOU KNOW, THE UNIVERSE
02:07:23.802 --> 02:07:24.770
, THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES
02:07:24.837 --> 02:07:26.705
ACCOUNTABLE TO THOSE NUMBERS. SO
02:07:26.772 --> 02:07:28.507
ONE OF THE PROBLEMS THAT I'VE
02:07:28.574 --> 02:07:30.442
SEEN IN JUST MY YEAR AND A HALF
02:07:30.509 --> 02:07:32.211
HERE IN THE LEGISLATURE IS THAT
02:07:32.277 --> 02:07:32.811
WE CONTINUALLY PASS BILLS OR
02:07:32.878 --> 02:07:35.080
LAWS WITH THE INTENT TO FIX
02:07:35.147 --> 02:07:37.816
PROBLEMS THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE
02:07:37.883 --> 02:07:38.650
, BECAUSE WE'RE NOT ENFORCING
02:07:38.717 --> 02:07:40.486
CURRENT LAW, SO WE JUST TRY TO
02:07:40.552 --> 02:07:42.354
PUT ANOTHER BAND AID OVER AND
02:07:42.421 --> 02:07:43.288
OVER AGAIN. THE PROBLEM THAT I
02:07:43.355 --> 02:07:44.556
HAVE WITH THIS PARTICULAR BILL
02:07:44.623 --> 02:07:46.792
IS THAT IT DOESN'T ACTUALLY FIX
02:07:46.859 --> 02:07:48.127
THE ISSUE AT THE ROOT OF THE
02:07:48.193 --> 02:07:49.795
PROBLEM BECAUSE IT DOESN'T DEAL
02:07:49.862 --> 02:07:50.596
WITH THE ACCOUNTABILITY PORTION
02:07:50.662 --> 02:07:52.831
OF IT, UM, ON THAT END AND
02:07:52.898 --> 02:07:54.266
TRYING TO ENFORCE WHAT'S ALREADY
02:07:54.333 --> 02:07:56.402
CURRENTLY IN PLACE AND STATUES.
02:07:56.468 --> 02:07:58.037
THE OTHER CONCERN THAT I HAVE
02:07:58.103 --> 02:08:01.273
WITH IT IS THE FACT THAT IT SAYS
02:08:01.340 --> 02:08:03.175
HERE THE BILL ARTIFICIALLY SETS
02:08:03.242 --> 02:08:05.544
THE 2023 FACULTY OBLIGATION
02:08:05.611 --> 02:08:07.679
NUMBER OF THE NUMBER OF FULL
02:08:07.746 --> 02:08:09.681
TIME FACULTY FOR 2022, BUT DOES
02:08:09.748 --> 02:08:11.917
NOT LOOK AT HOW THE ENROLLMENT
02:08:11.984 --> 02:08:14.486
CRATERED GOING INTO COVID AND
02:08:14.553 --> 02:08:15.988
POST COVID 92. SO ONE OF THE
02:08:16.055 --> 02:08:18.791
ISSUES THAT WE SAW IN BUDGETS OF
02:08:18.857 --> 02:08:20.926
ONE WAS THE COMMENT THAT WE'VE
02:08:20.993 --> 02:08:22.327
HAD A DECREASE ENROLLMENT,
02:08:22.394 --> 02:08:24.296
SEVERE DECREASE ENROLLMENT.
02:08:24.363 --> 02:08:27.232
PRIOR TO AND EVEN NOW IN
02:08:27.299 --> 02:08:28.267
COMMUNITY COLLEGES, SO BY
02:08:28.333 --> 02:08:32.938
SETTING THIS AT. REQUIREMENT
02:08:33.005 --> 02:08:33.772
YOU'RE NOT REALLY TAKING INTO
02:08:33.839 --> 02:08:35.274
ACCOUNT WHAT HAS HAPPENED WHAT
02:08:35.340 --> 02:08:37.376
IS CURRENTLY HAPPENING AND
02:08:37.443 --> 02:08:38.777
MOVING FORWARD HOW WE CAN
02:08:38.844 --> 02:08:41.180
ADDRESS THE VERY END NUMBERS. SO
02:08:41.246 --> 02:08:43.449
UM, JUST ON THAT PRINCIPLE
02:08:43.515 --> 02:08:44.616
ITSELF AND HOW IT'S SET UP. I
02:08:44.683 --> 02:08:47.786
FEEL THAT THERE IS A FRAMEWORK
02:08:47.853 --> 02:08:49.555
CONCERN OR ISSUE THAT NEEDS TO
02:08:49.621 --> 02:08:51.256
BE ADDRESSED. SO I'M NOT SURE
02:08:51.323 --> 02:08:53.058
THAT THIS WOULD PARTICULARLY FIX
02:08:53.125 --> 02:08:56.028
THAT. UM UM, AND THEN WE KNOW WE
02:08:56.095 --> 02:08:57.796
HAVE FACTS HERE THAT COULD BE
02:08:57.863 --> 02:09:01.667
PLACED ON THEIR, UM SO THE OTHER
02:09:01.733 --> 02:09:03.235
POINT THAT WAS MADE HERE IS THAT
02:09:03.302 --> 02:09:05.137
IT MAY BE MORE APPROPRIATE TO
02:09:05.204 --> 02:09:06.105
LOOK AT THE FACULTY NUMBERS IN
02:09:06.171 --> 02:09:07.739
STUDENT GROWTH OVER A NUMBER OF
02:09:07.806 --> 02:09:09.942
YEARS TO ENSURE THAT WE HAVE THE
02:09:10.008 --> 02:09:11.143
RIGHT NUMBER FULL TIME FACULTY.
02:09:11.210 --> 02:09:12.911
SO MY QUESTION TO YOU IS THAT
02:09:12.978 --> 02:09:14.146
WITH THE FUN AND LOOKING AND
02:09:14.213 --> 02:09:16.048
MOVING FORWARD. YOU THINK THAT
02:09:16.115 --> 02:09:19.151
AS YOU ASSESS THE PROGRAMS THAT
02:09:19.218 --> 02:09:20.886
ARE BEING PROVIDED THE COMMUNITY
02:09:20.953 --> 02:09:21.720
COLLEGES THE NUMBER OF STUDENTS
02:09:21.787 --> 02:09:23.188
BEING ENROLLED, MOVING FORWARD
02:09:23.255 --> 02:09:26.692
THAT, UM THAT THE PERCENTAGES
02:09:26.758 --> 02:09:29.695
pCURRENT FORMULA IS FOR THE FUN,
02:09:29.761 --> 02:09:30.662
BUT THAT THERE WOULD BE A
02:09:30.729 --> 02:09:32.231
PERCENTAGE OF INCREASE
02:09:32.297 --> 02:09:33.966
ENROLLMENT THAT WOULD MATCH THE
02:09:34.032 --> 02:09:36.802
INCREASE STAFF NUMBERS. BUT
02:09:36.869 --> 02:09:38.237
FIRST, STARTING OFF WITH THE
02:09:38.303 --> 02:09:40.172
FACT THAT YOU NEED TO ENFORCE
02:09:40.239 --> 02:09:41.874
WHAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE IN PLACE
02:09:41.940 --> 02:09:43.408
THAT WE'RE NOT BEING ACCOUNTABLE
02:09:43.475 --> 02:09:44.810
TO THAT END, AND THIS IS WHERE
02:09:44.877 --> 02:09:46.378
CITIZENS AND BOARD MEMBERS
02:09:46.445 --> 02:09:47.446
SHOULD BE INCREDIBLY INFORMED IN
02:09:47.513 --> 02:09:48.914
ORDER TO HOLD YOU KNOW
02:09:48.981 --> 02:09:50.782
ACCOUNTABLE WHAT WE ALREADY HAVE
02:09:50.849 --> 02:09:52.651
IN PLACE IF PEOPLE ARE NOT AWARE
02:09:52.718 --> 02:09:55.921
OF WHAT WE HAVE IN STATUTE, THEN
02:09:55.988 --> 02:09:57.356
HOW DO WE HOLD ANYONE
02:09:57.422 --> 02:09:59.191
ACCOUNTABLE ON THAT END, SO
02:09:59.258 --> 02:10:00.826
INFORMATION FIRST EDUCATION
02:10:00.893 --> 02:10:01.793
THAT'S NOT ADVOCATE FOR
02:10:01.860 --> 02:10:02.761
INFORMATION AND DISCLOSURE
02:10:02.828 --> 02:10:05.197
TRANSPARENCY SO THAT WE CAN HOLD
02:10:05.264 --> 02:10:06.798
THIS EASE INDIVIDUAL OR THESE
02:10:06.865 --> 02:10:10.669
BOARDS AND THE SCHOOLS
02:10:10.736 --> 02:10:12.571
ARE SOME OF THE CONCERNS THAT I
02:10:12.638 --> 02:10:13.772
HAVE WITH THE FRAMEWORK AND THE
02:10:13.839 --> 02:10:15.574
INTENT AND NOT REALLY FIXING THE
02:10:15.641 --> 02:10:17.976
ISSUE AT THE ROOT, BUT I WILL BE
02:10:18.043 --> 02:10:18.977
HAPPY TO WORK WITH THE
02:10:19.044 --> 02:10:20.612
COLLABORATIVELY ON A BILL THAT
02:10:20.679 --> 02:10:24.416
WILL ADDRESS ACCOUNTABILITY. IN
02:10:24.483 --> 02:10:25.417
ADDRESSING WHAT WE CURRENTLY
02:10:25.484 --> 02:10:27.419
HAVE IN STATUTE BECAUSE I THINK
02:10:27.486 --> 02:10:29.121
AND I AND I'M NOT THE EXPERT
02:10:29.188 --> 02:10:31.356
HERE, BUT, UM, I WOULD BE HAPPY
02:10:31.423 --> 02:10:32.057
TO HEAR. CURRENTLY THE FUND
02:10:32.124 --> 02:10:33.859
NUMBERS ARE THEY BASED ON A
02:10:33.926 --> 02:10:36.995
PERCENTAGE OF AH!NUMBER OF FULL
02:10:37.062 --> 02:10:38.630
TIME FACULTY IS BASED ON
02:10:38.697 --> 02:10:40.432
ENROLLMENT NUMBERS, BECAUSE THAT
02:10:40.499 --> 02:10:42.334
WOULD MAKE SENSE THAT YOU WOULD
02:10:42.401 --> 02:10:44.436
BASE THAT WHAT'S REQUIRED WITH
02:10:44.503 --> 02:10:45.971
THE MINIMUM BASED BASED ON
02:10:46.038 --> 02:10:46.972
ENROLLMENT, SO AS YOUR
02:10:47.039 --> 02:10:50.209
ENROLLMENT INCREASES THEN FIRST
02:10:50.275 --> 02:10:52.010
MAKING SURE THAT YOU MEET WHAT
02:10:52.077 --> 02:10:53.579
IS CURRENTLY IN STATUTE AND THEN
02:10:53.645 --> 02:10:55.847
IF THERE'S NECESSARY, DEPENDING
02:10:55.914 --> 02:10:57.282
ON THE CONTENT, BECAUSE THAT'S
02:10:57.349 --> 02:10:59.151
THE OTHER THING THAT YOU NEED TO
02:10:59.218 --> 02:11:00.886
HAVE. DO YOU HAVE A FULL TIME?
02:11:00.953 --> 02:11:03.922
NUMBER OF STUDENTS WHO T<c.cyan> MEET</c>
02:11:03.989 --> 02:11:06.158
THE NEEDS OF A FULL TIME STAFF
02:11:06.225 --> 02:11:07.626
MEMBER FOR THAT PARTICULAR
02:11:07.693 --> 02:11:09.194
SUBJECT MATTER, SO THERE'S A LOT
02:11:09.261 --> 02:11:11.563
OF COMPONENTS ON THERE THAT ARE
02:11:11.630 --> 02:11:12.564
COMPONENTS THAT NEED TO BE
02:11:12.631 --> 02:11:14.566
ADDRESSED AND ONE OF THOSE RIGHT
02:11:14.633 --> 02:11:15.801
WON'T BE ABLE TO SUPPORT YOUR
02:11:15.867 --> 02:11:17.636
BILL ON THIS ISSUE, BUT WOULD BE
02:11:17.703 --> 02:11:19.905
HAPPY. HAPPY TO WORK WITH YOU ON
02:11:19.972 --> 02:11:20.472
ACCOUNTABILITY AND ACTUALLY
02:11:20.539 --> 02:11:23.675
FIXING THE ISSUE. YEAH AND
02:11:23.742 --> 02:11:26.511
DEFINITELY I'M OPEN TO DO IT
02:11:26.578 --> 02:11:27.145
WITH THE WITH THE SPONGES. WHAT
02:11:27.212 --> 02:11:29.314
TO SEE HOW WE CAN GET A BETTER
02:11:29.381 --> 02:11:30.716
PLACE FOR THE FOLKS. OBVIOUSLY
02:11:30.782 --> 02:11:31.683
THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE TO TALK
02:11:31.750 --> 02:11:33.719
ABOUT IT AND SEE HOW WE CAN GET
02:11:33.785 --> 02:11:35.654
A BETTER AND GET EVERYBODY ON
02:11:35.721 --> 02:11:36.788
BOARD. BUT DEFINITELY AT THE END
02:11:36.855 --> 02:11:39.057
OF THE WOULD EITHER. MAKE SURE
02:11:39.124 --> 02:11:40.025
THAT ALL THESE ALL THESE
02:11:40.092 --> 02:11:40.826
INSTITUTIONS HAVE WHAT'S NEEDED
02:11:40.892 --> 02:11:42.561
TO MOVE FORWARD FOR NOT JUST
02:11:42.628 --> 02:11:43.762
TODAY. THE FUTURE. AS I SAID,
02:11:43.829 --> 02:11:45.130
SO, DEFINITELY KEEP THOSE IN
02:11:45.197 --> 02:11:46.698
MIND MOVING FORWARD. THANK YOU.
02:11:46.765 --> 02:11:48.300
THANK YOU. FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
02:11:48.367 --> 02:11:48.867
DEBATE? YES. SENATOR CORTEZ.
02:11:48.934 --> 02:11:50.068
THANK THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR. I
02:11:50.135 --> 02:11:51.803
JUST WANT TO MAKE A SUPPORTIVE
02:11:51.870 --> 02:11:53.171
COMMENT IN FROM THE PERSPECTIVE
02:11:53.238 --> 02:11:55.173
OF HAVING SERVED MANY YEARS AGO.
02:11:55.240 --> 02:11:57.643
UM AS A SCHOOL BOARD MEMBER FOR
02:11:57.709 --> 02:11:58.777
EIGHT YEARS WITHOUT STAFF, PART
02:11:58.844 --> 02:12:00.979
TIME. YOU KNOW, PLOWING THROUGH
02:12:01.046 --> 02:12:02.981
BUDGET DOCUMENTS, SERVING ON
02:12:03.048 --> 02:12:04.049
BUDGET COMMITTEES AND REALLY
02:12:04.116 --> 02:12:05.017
HAVING TO RELY ON
02:12:05.083 --> 02:12:07.019
ADMINISTRATION. FOR BASIC
02:12:07.085 --> 02:12:09.488
FUNDAMENTAL INFORMATION LIKE IS
02:12:09.554 --> 02:12:10.689
THIS ARE THESE DOLLARS DOLLARS
02:12:10.756 --> 02:12:12.424
THAT WE RECEIVE? IN A VERY
02:12:12.491 --> 02:12:15.127
SIMPLE PREMISE THAT I ALWAYS GOT
02:12:15.193 --> 02:12:18.263
BY WITH WAS DOLLARS RECEIVED.
02:12:18.330 --> 02:12:19.498
DOLLARS PAID AND TO ME, THAT'S
02:12:19.564 --> 02:12:21.533
WHAT THIS BILL STANDS FOR. HE
02:12:21.600 --> 02:12:23.068
RECEIVED THE DOLLARS PAY THE
02:12:23.135 --> 02:12:25.437
DOLLARS OUT ON THAT BASIS. UM,
02:12:25.504 --> 02:12:27.406
I'LL BE IN A VOTE ON THE BILL.
02:12:27.472 --> 02:12:28.340
THANK YOU. THANK YOU, SENATOR.
02:12:28.407 --> 02:12:30.175
CORTESI ALRIGHT BEFORE I LOOK
02:12:30.242 --> 02:12:31.677
FOR A MOTION OKAY. IT'S BEEN
02:12:31.743 --> 02:12:36.281
MOVED BY. SENATOR MCGUIRE. I
02:12:36.348 --> 02:12:37.916
JUST WANTED TO SAY TO YOUR POINT
02:12:37.983 --> 02:12:39.918
, SENATOR GLASER. IT'S ALREADY
02:12:39.985 --> 02:12:41.653
IN LAW AND IN STATUTE. IF THE
02:12:41.720 --> 02:12:43.555
MONEY ISN'T THERE, THEN THERE
02:12:43.622 --> 02:12:45.324
ARE NO INCREASES. SO I THINK
02:12:45.390 --> 02:12:47.159
YOUR CONCERN WAS OUR GOOD YEARS
02:12:47.225 --> 02:12:48.360
AND OUR BAD YEARS. SO THAT IS
02:12:48.427 --> 02:12:51.196
ALREADY IN STATUTE. ALL RIGHT.
02:12:51.263 --> 02:12:52.698
WE HAVE A MOTION BY SENATOR
02:12:52.764 --> 02:12:54.800
MCGUIRE. WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
02:12:54.866 --> 02:12:56.435
MY VOTE? VERY GOOD. ALRIGHT
02:12:56.501 --> 02:12:57.569
MADAM ASSISTANT, PLEASE CALL THE
02:12:57.636 --> 02:13:01.907
ROLL. FILE ITEM SEVEN. A. B 15
02:13:01.973 --> 02:13:04.109
OH, FIVE. THE MOTION IS DUE
02:13:04.176 --> 02:13:05.177
PASS. BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO
02:13:05.243 --> 02:13:06.378
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
02:13:06.445 --> 02:13:09.614
LEVER LEVER I SHOW BOOK. KOBACH
02:13:09.681 --> 02:13:12.250
NO CORTEZ E CI DELI. SALLY NO,
02:13:12.317 --> 02:13:19.791
GLASER. MCGUIRE MCGUIRE I PAN.
02:13:19.858 --> 02:13:21.593
AND I ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU.
02:13:21.660 --> 02:13:22.928
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THAT BILL IS
02:13:22.994 --> 02:13:24.129
OUT. THANK YOU. APPRECIATE IT.
02:13:24.196 --> 02:13:25.897
HAVE A GOOD DAY. YOU TOO.
02:13:25.964 --> 02:13:27.032
ALRIGHT WE'RE GONNA GO TO
02:13:27.099 --> 02:13:28.133
ASSEMBLYWOMAN QUIRK. SILVA COME
02:13:28.200 --> 02:13:31.436
ON UP TO PRESENT. FALLOUT OF
02:13:31.503 --> 02:13:33.605
EIGHT A B 5 50 TO BEGIN WHEN
02:13:33.672 --> 02:13:46.284
YOU'RE READY.
02:13:46.351 --> 02:13:48.053
GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND
02:13:48.120 --> 02:13:51.123
MEMBERS ASSEMBLY BILL 5 50 TO
02:13:51.189 --> 02:13:53.859
ALLOW NOT REQUIRE SCHOOLS AND
02:13:53.925 --> 02:13:56.261
COUNTIES TO ENTER INTO THE
02:13:56.328 --> 02:13:57.162
INTEGRATED SCHOOL BASED
02:13:57.229 --> 02:14:00.165
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PARTNERSHIP.
02:14:00.232 --> 02:14:01.900
PROGRAM TO PROVIDE EARLY
02:14:01.967 --> 02:14:03.568
INTERVENTION AND ACCESS TO
02:14:03.635 --> 02:14:05.537
BEHAVIORAL AND MENTAL HEALTH
02:14:05.604 --> 02:14:09.274
SERVICES FOR ALL STUDENTS. PRIOR
02:14:09.341 --> 02:14:11.276
TO THE PANDEMIC REPORTS HAVE
02:14:11.343 --> 02:14:12.911
PROVIDED STARTLING INFORMATION
02:14:12.978 --> 02:14:15.914
ONTO THE AUNT REGARDING MENTAL
02:14:15.981 --> 02:14:16.915
AND BEHAVIORAL LANDSCAPE OF
02:14:16.982 --> 02:14:19.785
SCHOOL AGE CHILDREN AND YOUTH.
02:14:19.851 --> 02:14:22.287
SCHOOLS AND HOSPITALS HAVE SEEN
02:14:22.354 --> 02:14:23.822
A STEADY RISE IN STUDENT
02:14:23.889 --> 02:14:25.824
SUFFERING FROM TRAUMA, ANXIETY,
02:14:25.891 --> 02:14:27.692
DEPRESSION AND SUICIDAL THOUGHTS
02:14:27.759 --> 02:14:31.129
OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS.
02:14:31.196 --> 02:14:33.198
SOCIAL MEDIA BULLYING SCHOOL
02:14:33.265 --> 02:14:36.501
SHOOTINGS. AND I'LL JUST
02:14:36.568 --> 02:14:39.538
UNDERLINE THAT SCHOOL SHOOTINGS.
02:14:39.604 --> 02:14:41.273
FAMILY SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND
02:14:41.339 --> 02:14:43.175
POVERTY OR SOME OF THE
02:14:43.241 --> 02:14:45.811
UNDERLYING UNDERLINING CAUSES.
02:14:45.877 --> 02:14:47.145
AS WE ALL KNOW TOO WELL. THE
02:14:47.212 --> 02:14:49.481
COVID 19 PANDEMIC HAS ALSO
02:14:49.548 --> 02:14:51.783
INTENSIFIED THIS HEALTH CRISIS
02:14:51.850 --> 02:14:54.419
ISOLATION ANXIETY OVER THE
02:14:54.486 --> 02:14:55.787
UNCERTAINTY OF THE IMMEDIATE AND
02:14:55.854 --> 02:14:58.390
LONG TERM FUTURE. LACK OF PEER
02:14:58.457 --> 02:15:00.792
SUPPORT AND CONCERNS WITH FAMILY
02:15:00.859 --> 02:15:02.828
HAVE AND CONTINUES TO TAKE A
02:15:02.894 --> 02:15:04.963
TOLL WITH OUR STUDENTS,
02:15:05.030 --> 02:15:06.431
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH, MENTAL
02:15:06.498 --> 02:15:07.165
ILLNESS AND SUPPORT HAVE BEEN
02:15:07.232 --> 02:15:08.433
CRUCIAL SINCE STUDENTS RETURNED
02:15:08.500 --> 02:15:12.204
TO SCHOOL AS AS A STATE. WE MUST
02:15:12.270 --> 02:15:13.905
DO WHAT WE CAN TO ADDRESS THE
02:15:13.972 --> 02:15:16.775
NEEDS FOR OUR STUDENTS. WE ALSO
02:15:16.842 --> 02:15:18.310
NEED TO RELIEVE SOE OF THE
02:15:18.376 --> 02:15:20.278
PRESSURE AT SCHOOLS BY ALLOWING
02:15:20.345 --> 02:15:23.949
pORGANIZATIONS SUCH AS A COUNTY
02:15:24.015 --> 02:15:24.950
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AGENCIES TO
02:15:25.016 --> 02:15:28.353
PROVIDE BETTER. BEHAVIORAL AND
02:15:28.420 --> 02:15:30.088
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES ON SCHOOL
02:15:30.155 --> 02:15:34.092
SITE. UM, I'LL JUST, UH GO PUT
02:15:34.159 --> 02:15:36.695
ON MY EDUCATION HAT AS A TEACHER
02:15:36.761 --> 02:15:41.433
FOR 30 YEARS, UM YOU KNOW, I SAW
02:15:41.500 --> 02:15:43.301
THIS MANY YEARS AGO. NOT JUST
02:15:43.368 --> 02:15:47.806
NOW, UH AND MANY TIMES FAMILIES
02:15:47.873 --> 02:15:49.574
REALLY DON'T KNOW WHO TO LOOK
02:15:49.641 --> 02:15:51.243
FOR SUPPORT IN ORANGE COUNTY. WE
02:15:51.309 --> 02:15:52.611
HAVE THE CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL OF
02:15:52.677 --> 02:15:56.147
ORANGE COUNTY. AND THEY RECENTLY
02:15:56.214 --> 02:15:58.817
OPENED UP AN ADOLESCENT WING,
02:15:58.884 --> 02:16:00.252
WHICH SOUNDS LIKE A GOOD
02:16:00.318 --> 02:16:01.853
ADDITION. RIGHT BUT I ASKED HIM
02:16:01.920 --> 02:16:03.722
WHY, AND THEY SAID THEY'VE SEEN
02:16:03.788 --> 02:16:08.560
CASES OF YOUNG GIRLS AS YOUNG AS
02:16:08.627 --> 02:16:10.962
EIGHT. HAVING EATING DISORDERS,
02:16:11.029 --> 02:16:13.031
OF COURSE, SUICIDE ATTEMPT
02:16:13.098 --> 02:16:15.200
ATTEMPTS, BUT SADLY, THEIR BEDS
02:16:15.267 --> 02:16:19.037
HAVE BEEN FILLED. AND EVEN MORE
02:16:19.104 --> 02:16:21.640
SINCE THE PANDEMIC AND SOMETIMES
02:16:21.706 --> 02:16:22.841
TOO LATE, WHERE THE SUICIDE
02:16:22.908 --> 02:16:24.910
SUICIDE ATTEMPTS ACTUALLY ARE
02:16:24.976 --> 02:16:27.913
SUICIDES SO WE CAN DO MORE. THIS
02:16:27.979 --> 02:16:30.248
IS NOT A MANDATE. IT'S SIMPLY TO
02:16:30.315 --> 02:16:31.616
DO MORE AND TO ADDRESS OUR
02:16:31.683 --> 02:16:33.785
MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS TODAY WITH
02:16:33.852 --> 02:16:36.221
ME VIA PHONE TO PROVIDE
02:16:36.288 --> 02:16:36.755
TESTIMONY AND ANSWER ANY
02:16:36.821 --> 02:16:38.256
QUESTIONS THAT COMMUNITY MAY
02:16:38.323 --> 02:16:40.692
HAVE WE HAVE IS MRS MARNIE
02:16:40.759 --> 02:16:41.693
SANDOVAL, DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF
02:16:41.760 --> 02:16:44.462
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH. WITH THE
02:16:44.529 --> 02:16:45.597
MONTEREY COUNTY BEHAVIORAL,
02:16:45.664 --> 02:16:48.900
HEALTH AND CHILD. IN ADOLESCENTS
02:16:48.967 --> 02:16:50.802
AND MRS WENDY WING CHIEF OF
02:16:50.869 --> 02:16:52.304
PUBLIC POLICY ADVOCACY WITH
02:16:52.370 --> 02:16:55.140
HATHAWAY, SYCAMORES. THANK YOU,
02:16:55.206 --> 02:16:57.242
ASSEMBLYWOMAN. MR MODERATOR. IF
02:16:57.309 --> 02:16:59.277
YOU CAN PLEASE QUEUE UP, MARNIE
02:16:59.344 --> 02:17:00.779
SANDOVAL. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES
02:17:00.845 --> 02:17:02.581
AND THEN WE WILL GO TO MS WENDY
02:17:02.647 --> 02:17:06.551
WANG WENDY WANG. SORRY. PLEASE
02:17:06.618 --> 02:17:11.389
GO AHEAD. YES HELLO. THANK YOU,
02:17:11.456 --> 02:17:12.891
SHARON SENATORS FOR YOUR TIME
02:17:12.958 --> 02:17:15.293
TODAY. MY NAME IS DR MARNIE
02:17:15.360 --> 02:17:16.795
SANDOVAL. I'M THE DEPUTY
02:17:16.861 --> 02:17:18.196
DIRECTOR OF BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:17:18.263 --> 02:17:19.564
OVER OUR CHILD AND ADOLESCENT
02:17:19.631 --> 02:17:21.466
SERVICES FOR THE MONTEREY COUNTY
02:17:21.533 --> 02:17:22.500
HEALTH DEPARTMENT. AND I'M ALSO
02:17:22.567 --> 02:17:23.702
REPRESENTING THE COUNTY
02:17:23.768 --> 02:17:25.236
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH DIRECTORS
02:17:25.303 --> 02:17:26.438
ASSOCIATION, THE PROUD CO
02:17:26.504 --> 02:17:30.175
SPONSORS OF A B 552. THIS STILL
02:17:30.241 --> 02:17:31.543
ROUTE WILL CREATE THE INTEGRATED
02:17:31.610 --> 02:17:33.178
SCHOOL BASED BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:17:33.244 --> 02:17:34.846
SERVICES PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM,
02:17:34.913 --> 02:17:36.181
ENCOURAGING LOCAL EDUCATION
02:17:36.247 --> 02:17:38.316
AGENCIES OR LIAISE AND COUNTY
02:17:38.383 --> 02:17:39.784
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AGENCIES TO
02:17:39.851 --> 02:17:41.119
COLLABORATE ON PROVIDING SCHOOL
02:17:41.186 --> 02:17:43.154
BASED SERVICES FOR ANY STUDENT.
02:17:43.221 --> 02:17:45.190
APPROPRIATELY REFERRED BY SCHOOL
02:17:45.256 --> 02:17:46.224
PERSONNEL, REGARDLESS OF
02:17:46.291 --> 02:17:48.126
INSURANCE, STATUS, OR TYPE AND
02:17:48.193 --> 02:17:49.427
PROVIDE BRIEF INITIAL
02:17:49.494 --> 02:17:50.996
INTERVENTION SERVICES INTENDED
02:17:51.062 --> 02:17:52.163
TO PREVENT A BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:17:52.230 --> 02:17:54.532
CONDITION FROM WORSENING. WITHIN
02:17:54.599 --> 02:17:56.301
MONTEREY COUNTY. OUR COUNTY
02:17:56.368 --> 02:17:56.801
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH HAS A
02:17:56.868 --> 02:17:59.204
RELATIONSHIP WITH THE OFFICE OF
02:17:59.270 --> 02:18:01.172
EDUCATION AND SELF THAT STANDS
02:18:01.239 --> 02:18:03.174
OVER 30 YEARS AND OVER THE PAST
02:18:03.241 --> 02:18:04.643
10 YEARS WE HAVE DEVELOPED
02:18:04.709 --> 02:18:06.444
RELATIONSHIPS WITH OUR L E. A S
02:18:06.511 --> 02:18:08.680
THROUGH MOU. PROVIDE SCHOOL
02:18:08.747 --> 02:18:09.814
BASEMENT OR HEALTH SERVICES AND
02:18:09.881 --> 02:18:12.050
SUPPORT FOR ALL OF OUR STUDENT.
02:18:12.117 --> 02:18:13.184
THIS PLACE IS THE BEHAVIORAL
02:18:13.251 --> 02:18:15.153
HEALTH STAFF ON SCHOOL CAMPUSES
02:18:15.220 --> 02:18:16.187
, AND THEY BECOME INTEGRATED
02:18:16.254 --> 02:18:18.523
INTO THE SCHOOL COMMUNITY. OUR
02:18:18.590 --> 02:18:20.158
CHILDREN HAVE BEEN STRUGGLING
02:18:20.225 --> 02:18:21.793
WITH MENTAL HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE
02:18:21.860 --> 02:18:22.894
USE ISSUES INCREASINGLY OVER THE
02:18:22.961 --> 02:18:25.764
LAST FIVE YEARS. AND SINCE THE
02:18:25.830 --> 02:18:27.799
COVID 19 PANDEMIC IN PARTICULAR
02:18:27.866 --> 02:18:29.300
, OUR CHILDREN'S BEHAVIORAL
02:18:29.367 --> 02:18:30.969
HEALTH NEEDS ARE GREATER THAN
02:18:31.036 --> 02:18:32.804
EVER. OUR CHILDREN AND YOUTH ARE
02:18:32.871 --> 02:18:34.572
IN CRISIS. IN MONTEREY COUNTY IN
02:18:34.639 --> 02:18:36.841
THE PAST THREE MONTHS. OUR
02:18:36.908 --> 02:18:38.576
CAMPUS COMMUNITIES HAVE SUFFERED
02:18:38.643 --> 02:18:41.880
FOR YOUTH LOST TO OVERDOSE. ONE
02:18:41.946 --> 02:18:44.416
STUDENT SUICIDE TO TEACHERS
02:18:44.482 --> 02:18:46.151
SUICIDE AND CONFIRMED THREATS OF
02:18:46.217 --> 02:18:46.651
VIOLENCE TOWARDS SEVERAL
02:18:46.718 --> 02:18:49.788
STUDENTS. AND IN THE EARLY
02:18:49.854 --> 02:18:51.790
MOMENTS OF EACH OF THESE CRISES
02:18:51.856 --> 02:18:53.892
BECAUSE OUR INTEGRATION IN THE
02:18:53.958 --> 02:18:55.193
SCHOOLS IS THERE ARE BEHAVIORAL
02:18:55.260 --> 02:18:57.395
HEALTH STAFF WERE ONE OF THE
02:18:57.462 --> 02:18:58.463
FIRST CALLED THAT SCHOOL
02:18:58.530 --> 02:19:00.432
ADMINISTRATORS MADE REACH OUT
02:19:00.498 --> 02:19:02.133
FOR HELP AND SUPPORT AND WE
02:19:02.200 --> 02:19:04.469
MOBILIZED OUR FULL ARRAY OF
02:19:04.536 --> 02:19:05.470
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND CHILDREN'S
02:19:05.537 --> 02:19:06.871
SYSTEM OF CARE SUPPORT. TO
02:19:06.938 --> 02:19:08.406
ADDRESS THE NEEDS OF EACH CAMPUS
02:19:08.473 --> 02:19:10.408
COMMUNITY, PROVIDING CRISIS
02:19:10.475 --> 02:19:12.544
STABILIZATION. CRITICAL INCIDENT
02:19:12.610 --> 02:19:14.245
, STRESS MANAGEMENT, DEBRIEFING
02:19:14.312 --> 02:19:15.747
AND SUPPORT FOR THE STUDENTS AND
02:19:15.814 --> 02:19:17.082
EDUCATORS AND MENTAL HEALTH
02:19:17.148 --> 02:19:19.417
TREATMENT FOR THE STUDENT. AND
02:19:19.484 --> 02:19:20.852
TRULY, IT'S OUR BEHAVIORAL
02:19:20.919 --> 02:19:22.353
HEALTH PARTNERSHIP WITH THE
02:19:22.420 --> 02:19:23.955
ELIA'S THAT HAS ENABLED THE
02:19:24.022 --> 02:19:26.024
COORDINATION DIRECTLY WITH THE
02:19:26.091 --> 02:19:27.759
SCHOOL AND L E. EIGHT IN
02:19:27.826 --> 02:19:29.728
ENSURING STUDENTS, FAMILIES,
02:19:29.794 --> 02:19:31.463
TEACHERS AND STAFF ARE RECEIVING
02:19:31.529 --> 02:19:32.664
THE NECESSARY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
02:19:32.731 --> 02:19:35.667
SUPPORT AND SERVICES. THERE ARE
02:19:35.734 --> 02:19:37.268
CHALLENGES TO MAKING THESE
02:19:37.335 --> 02:19:38.670
SERVICES AVAILABLE WHEN THERE
02:19:38.737 --> 02:19:40.205
ARE NOT PARTNERSHIPS BETWEEN
02:19:40.271 --> 02:19:42.307
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH AND THE L E
02:19:42.373 --> 02:19:44.075
EIGHT MAYBE 55 TO PROVIDE THE
02:19:44.142 --> 02:19:45.143
OPPORTUNITY TO ENSURE THAT
02:19:45.210 --> 02:19:48.179
STUDENTS, FAMILIES AND EDUCATORS
02:19:48.246 --> 02:19:49.714
HAVE THE TIMELY ACCESS TO
02:19:49.781 --> 02:19:50.915
CRITICALLY NEEDED BEHAVIORAL
02:19:50.982 --> 02:19:51.783
HEALTH SUPPORTS AND SERVICES
02:19:51.850 --> 02:19:54.686
RIGHT ON THEIR SCHOOL CAMPUSES.
02:19:54.753 --> 02:19:56.721
WE HAVE BEEN PROUD TO BE ABLE TO
02:19:56.788 --> 02:19:58.156
DO THIS IN MONTEREY COUNTY. I
02:19:58.223 --> 02:19:59.758
THINK YOU SHARON SENATORS FOR
02:19:59.824 --> 02:20:01.559
YOUR TIME, AND I RESPECTFULLY
02:20:01.626 --> 02:20:03.394
URGE YOUR VOTES IN FAVOR OF A B
02:20:03.461 --> 02:20:06.264
552. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT, MISS
02:20:06.331 --> 02:20:07.799
WANG, YOU HAVE A MINUTE AND 10
02:20:07.866 --> 02:20:10.168
SECONDS. MOST OF YOUR SOME OF
02:20:10.235 --> 02:20:11.369
YOUR TIME WAS EATEN UP BY THE
02:20:11.436 --> 02:20:12.470
PREVIOUS SPEAKER. PLEASE
02:20:12.537 --> 02:20:17.308
PROCEED. CHAIRPERSON. THERE ARE
02:20:17.375 --> 02:20:19.611
NO BOWEN MEMBER COMMITTEE. MY
02:20:19.677 --> 02:20:21.312
NAME IS WENDY WANG, PUBLIC
02:20:21.379 --> 02:20:22.447
POLICY AND ADVOCACY OFFICER AT
02:20:22.514 --> 02:20:25.884
SYCAMORE. WE ARE A MEMBER OF THE
02:20:25.950 --> 02:20:26.885
CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE HAS TOLD
02:20:26.951 --> 02:20:28.019
THEM FAMILY SERVICES, A PROUD CO
02:20:28.086 --> 02:20:31.122
SPONSOR OF THE BILL. HURT ME OUR
02:20:31.189 --> 02:20:32.056
SCHOOL DAYS PROGRAMS THROUGH
02:20:32.123 --> 02:20:35.026
REFUNDING BY ELLIS COUNTY. DMH
02:20:35.093 --> 02:20:36.294
ENABLES US TO SERVE STUDENTS AND
02:20:36.361 --> 02:20:38.029
OVER 30 SCHOOL CAMPUSES AS A
02:20:38.096 --> 02:20:40.298
RESULT OF MOU, SIX LOCAL SCHOOL
02:20:40.365 --> 02:20:41.299
DISTRICTS AND FIVE CHARTER
02:20:41.366 --> 02:20:43.802
SCHOOL GROUP. AS A SPECIALTY
02:20:43.868 --> 02:20:45.170
MENTAL HEALTH PROVIDERS SERVING
02:20:45.236 --> 02:20:47.071
STUDENTS AND TOUCH TO MEDICAL
02:20:47.138 --> 02:20:49.407
SERVICES. SYCAMORE FIRMLY
02:20:49.474 --> 02:20:50.375
BELIEVE ALL STUDENTS AND THEIR
02:20:50.441 --> 02:20:52.076
FAMILIES AND TIMELY ACCESS TO
02:20:52.143 --> 02:20:53.044
MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES. THROUGH
02:20:53.111 --> 02:20:53.912
MORE ROBUST PROSPECTOR
02:20:53.978 --> 02:20:56.781
PARTNERSHIP. CURRENTLY A
02:20:56.848 --> 02:20:58.016
STUDENTS ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
02:20:58.082 --> 02:21:00.018
MEDICAL UPS TO T THEY RECEIVE A
02:21:00.084 --> 02:21:01.786
COMPREHENSIVE SET OF BENEFITS.
02:21:01.853 --> 02:21:03.421
IN CONTRAST, THE STUDENTS ARE
02:21:03.488 --> 02:21:04.389
UNDER THEIR PARENTS' PRIVATE
02:21:04.455 --> 02:21:05.690
HEALTH PLANS RECEIVED LIMITED
02:21:05.757 --> 02:21:08.793
SERVICES. COVID HAS LEFT AN
02:21:08.860 --> 02:21:10.495
INDELIBLE MARK OVER LIVES,
02:21:10.562 --> 02:21:12.397
ESPECIALLY CHILDREN AND YOUTH.
02:21:12.463 --> 02:21:14.966
MAGICALLY AS OF JUNE 2021 MORE
02:21:15.033 --> 02:21:17.635
THAN 140,000 US CHILDREN HAD
02:21:17.702 --> 02:21:18.770
LOST THE PRIMARY SECONDARY
02:21:18.837 --> 02:21:21.172
CAREGIVER DUE TO COVID. IN
02:21:21.239 --> 02:21:23.274
ADDITION TO DEFINITELY, STUDENTS
02:21:23.341 --> 02:21:24.175
HAVE EXPERIENCED INCREASED
02:21:24.242 --> 02:21:25.743
ANXIETY, REDUCED INTERACTION
02:21:25.810 --> 02:21:27.278
WITH PEERS STRUGGLED WITH
02:21:27.345 --> 02:21:28.479
DISTANCE, LEARNING ANYTHING
02:21:28.546 --> 02:21:29.514
THEIR FAMILY'S FINANCIAL
02:21:29.581 --> 02:21:33.651
SITUATION WORSENED. DECEMBER
02:21:33.718 --> 02:21:34.953
2021, U. S. SURGEON GENERAL
02:21:35.019 --> 02:21:37.822
ADVISOR AT EMPHASIZE THAT YOU
02:21:37.889 --> 02:21:40.058
FROM COMMUNITIES COLOR LGBTQ,
02:21:40.124 --> 02:21:41.693
PLUS THESE AND OTHER SPECIALIZED
02:21:41.759 --> 02:21:43.061
USE POPULATION RIGHT GREATER
02:21:43.127 --> 02:21:44.362
RISK OF MENTAL HEALTH CHALLENGES
02:21:44.429 --> 02:21:45.663
DURING THE COVID. DURING THE
02:21:45.730 --> 02:21:49.167
CURRENT PANDEMIC. THIS DATA,
02:21:49.234 --> 02:21:51.002
ADDITIONAL POLICE QUÊ EXPERIENCE
02:21:51.069 --> 02:21:53.404
ON THE GROUND. THANK YOU. THANK
02:21:53.471 --> 02:21:55.206
YOU. ALL RIGHT, WE'RE GONNA GO
02:21:55.273 --> 02:21:56.975
TO ANYONE IN SUPPORT HERE IN
02:21:57.041 --> 02:21:58.109
ROOM. 2100 PLEASE COME FORWARD
02:21:58.176 --> 02:21:59.143
STATE YOUR NAME AND YOUR
02:21:59.210 --> 02:22:03.514
SUPPORT. HI THERESA COMES STOCK
02:22:03.581 --> 02:22:05.550
WITH CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
02:22:05.617 --> 02:22:06.684
LOCAL BEHAVIORAL HEALTH BOARDS
02:22:06.751 --> 02:22:07.719
AND COMMISSIONS IN SUPPORT.
02:22:07.785 --> 02:22:12.690
THANK YOU. ADRIAN HOW DID THE
02:22:12.757 --> 02:22:14.325
WITH THE STEINBERG INSTITUTE AND
02:22:14.392 --> 02:22:16.194
SUPPORT? THANK YOU. NO FURTHER
02:22:16.261 --> 02:22:17.695
WITNESSES. MR MODERATOR, WE'RE
02:22:17.762 --> 02:22:19.998
GOING TO GO TO YOU TO QUEUE UP.
02:22:20.064 --> 02:22:21.199
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO SPEAK IN
02:22:21.266 --> 02:22:24.836
SUPPORT OF A B 552. IF YOU ARE
02:22:24.903 --> 02:22:26.971
IN SUPPORT OF A B 552, PLEASE
02:22:27.038 --> 02:22:29.374
PRESS ONE FALL BY 01 FOLLOWED BY
02:22:29.440 --> 02:22:33.077
ZERO FOR A B 552. AND WE'LL
02:22:33.144 --> 02:22:34.245
BEGIN WITH FLYING 80. YOU'RE
02:22:34.312 --> 02:22:39.250
OPEN. THE MORNING SIMON VIEW ON
02:22:39.317 --> 02:22:41.486
BEHALF OF THE TALIBAN COUNCIL OF
02:22:41.552 --> 02:22:42.420
COMMUNITY PAPER, HEALTHY
02:22:42.487 --> 02:22:45.356
AGENCIES AND SUPPORT AND NEXT
02:22:45.423 --> 02:22:49.060
WEEK WE'LL GO TO LINE 26. YOUR
02:22:49.127 --> 02:22:51.162
MICROPHONE'S ON JUST SO YOU
02:22:51.229 --> 02:22:51.963
KNOW, ADRIAN, SHELTERED WITH THE
02:22:52.030 --> 02:22:53.932
CALIFORNIA ALLIANCE OF CHILD AND
02:22:53.998 --> 02:22:54.966
FAMILY SERVICES, PROUD CO
02:22:55.033 --> 02:22:57.535
SPONSOR AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
02:22:57.602 --> 02:23:01.806
THANK YOU. 30. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:23:01.873 --> 02:23:03.007
GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND
02:23:03.074 --> 02:23:04.809
MEMBERS MEDDLING SUPER FROM
02:23:04.876 --> 02:23:05.877
NIELSEN MARKS MORE ON BEHALF OF
02:23:05.944 --> 02:23:08.446
THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO AND
02:23:08.513 --> 02:23:09.514
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:23:09.580 --> 02:23:14.552
BY 91. YOU ARE OPEN. GOOD
02:23:14.619 --> 02:23:16.187
MORNING CAROL MEMBERS CRYSTAL
02:23:16.254 --> 02:23:18.222
IQUITOS ON BEHALF OF THE
02:23:18.289 --> 02:23:18.856
CALIFORNIA ACADEMY OF CHILD AND
02:23:18.923 --> 02:23:20.358
ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY AND
02:23:20.425 --> 02:23:21.859
CALIFORNIA, THE ASSOCIATION OF
02:23:21.926 --> 02:23:22.827
PSYCHIATRISTS AND STRONG
02:23:22.894 --> 02:23:26.297
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
02:23:26.364 --> 02:23:27.432
MOVING ALONG LINES. 69, PLEASE
02:23:27.498 --> 02:23:31.536
GO AHEAD. GOOD MORNING, MADAM
02:23:31.602 --> 02:23:33.604
CHAIR AND MEMBERS NICOLE WARD
02:23:33.671 --> 02:23:34.672
ULLMAN ON BEHALF OF THE
02:23:34.739 --> 02:23:35.640
CHILDREN'S PARTNERSHIP IN
02:23:35.707 --> 02:23:42.547
SUPPORT. MY 94. YOU ARE OPEN.
02:23:42.613 --> 02:23:44.315
GOOD MORNING LEE ANGELA REID ON
02:23:44.382 --> 02:23:45.550
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:23:45.616 --> 02:23:46.551
ASSOCIATION OF PRIVATE SPECIAL
02:23:46.617 --> 02:23:51.889
EDUCATION SCHOOL. IN SUPPORT.
02:23:51.956 --> 02:23:53.625
FINAL REMINDER, PLEASE PRESS 10
02:23:53.691 --> 02:23:56.661
TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR A B 552.
02:23:56.728 --> 02:23:59.030
AND WE'LL GO TO LINE 77 YOU ARE
02:23:59.097 --> 02:24:10.908
OPEN. WE CANNOT HEAR YOU, BUT WE
02:24:10.975 --> 02:24:13.678
ASSUME THAT YOU ARE TERRIBLE.
02:24:13.745 --> 02:24:15.079
YES. THANK YOU, MR MODERATE.
02:24:15.146 --> 02:24:16.581
MOVE ALONG TO 93. THANK YOU.
02:24:16.647 --> 02:24:18.750
SORRY, MADAM CHAIR. 93, PLEASE
02:24:18.816 --> 02:24:24.122
GO AHEAD. HI THIS IS DR VAN
02:24:24.188 --> 02:24:25.556
BRANNIGAN AND CALLING FROM THE
02:24:25.623 --> 02:24:27.058
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS
02:24:27.125 --> 02:24:28.760
CALIFORNIA CHAPTER TWO, WHICH
02:24:28.826 --> 02:24:30.161
REPRESENTS OVER 1000
02:24:30.228 --> 02:24:31.529
PEDIATRICIANS IN THE LOS ANGELES
02:24:31.596 --> 02:24:33.464
COUNTY AND SURROUNDING AREAS.
02:24:33.531 --> 02:24:35.466
AND WE ARE IN FULL SUPPORT OF 85
02:24:35.533 --> 02:24:39.303
52. AND THERE ARE NO OTHER
02:24:39.370 --> 02:24:40.571
PARTICIPANTS QUEUED UP AT THIS
02:24:40.638 --> 02:24:42.240
TIME. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
02:24:42.306 --> 02:24:44.375
WE HAVE NO LEAD OPPOSITION. WE
02:24:44.442 --> 02:24:45.643
WILL GO HERE TO ROOM 2100 FOR
02:24:45.710 --> 02:24:47.578
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY. AN
02:24:47.645 --> 02:24:49.747
OPPOSITION SEEING NO ONE. MR.
02:24:49.814 --> 02:24:50.815
MODERATOR, WE'RE COMING BACK TO
02:24:50.882 --> 02:24:53.618
YOU. TO QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
02:24:53.684 --> 02:24:54.852
WISHES TO TESTIFY AND OPPOSITION
02:24:54.919 --> 02:24:58.689
TO A B 552. THANK YOU IF YOU ARE
02:24:58.756 --> 02:25:00.858
IN OPPOSITION TO A B 552 PLEASE
02:25:00.925 --> 02:25:03.327
PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME 10 PER
02:25:03.394 --> 02:25:07.331
OPPOSITION TO A B 552. WE HAVE
02:25:07.398 --> 02:25:08.566
ONE WITH AN OPERATOR. ANYBODY
02:25:08.633 --> 02:25:12.403
ELSE GOING AT 10 GETTING QUÊ?
02:25:12.470 --> 02:25:14.405
AND WE WILL GO TO LINE 99 YOU
02:25:14.472 --> 02:25:18.910
ARE OPEN. HELLO MEMBERS AND
02:25:18.976 --> 02:25:19.911
CHAIR. MY ALWAYS SAYS I WAS
02:25:19.977 --> 02:25:21.045
CALLING ON BEHALF OF THE
02:25:21.112 --> 02:25:22.346
CALIFORNIA CHARTER SCHOOLS
02:25:22.413 --> 02:25:24.549
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT AND
02:25:24.615 --> 02:25:25.783
MISSED THE EARLIER TO APOLOGIES.
02:25:25.850 --> 02:25:30.221
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. WE'LL GIVE
02:25:30.288 --> 02:25:30.855
ONE MORE FINAL REMINDER IF YOU
02:25:30.922 --> 02:25:32.890
ARE IN OPPOSITION TO A B 552
02:25:32.957 --> 02:25:40.465
PLEASE PRESS 10. AND NOBODY HAS
02:25:40.531 --> 02:25:42.033
QUEUED UP AT THIS TIME. THANK
02:25:42.100 --> 02:25:43.701
YOU. MR MODERATOR WILL COME BACK
02:25:43.768 --> 02:25:45.470
TO THE COMMITTEE FOR ANY
02:25:45.536 --> 02:25:46.604
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS.
02:25:46.671 --> 02:25:49.740
I HAVE DR PANT. OKAY. THANK YOU
02:25:49.807 --> 02:25:51.476
. IT WE WILL MOVE IT AT THE
02:25:51.542 --> 02:25:52.577
APPROPRIATE TIME. SENATOR DOLLY!
02:25:52.643 --> 02:25:54.946
DOCTOR PAN. YES UM, SO AGAIN
02:25:55.012 --> 02:25:56.414
APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING THIS
02:25:56.481 --> 02:25:57.582
BILL FORWARD. SO REMEMBER
02:25:57.648 --> 02:25:59.417
QUIRK-SILVA AND CERTAINLY BE
02:25:59.484 --> 02:26:00.985
SUPPORTING THE BILL. MAYBE YOU
02:26:01.052 --> 02:26:02.153
CAN JUST BRIEFLY TOUCH ON THERE
02:26:02.220 --> 02:26:04.922
SO THERE'S ACTUALLY SEVERAL
02:26:04.989 --> 02:26:06.390
YOUTH MENTAL HEALTH INITIATIVES
02:26:06.457 --> 02:26:08.793
AFFECTING THE GOVERNOR'S BUDGET
02:26:08.860 --> 02:26:09.927
COUPLE YEARS AGO, YOU KNOW, WEEK
02:26:09.994 --> 02:26:12.263
ACTUALLY LAST YEAR WE COMMITTED
02:26:12.330 --> 02:26:13.331
TO SEVERAL BILLION DOLLARS AND
02:26:13.397 --> 02:26:15.533
YOUTH MENTAL HEALTH INITIATIVE.
02:26:15.600 --> 02:26:18.002
UM SO CAN YOU, MAYBE JUST
02:26:18.069 --> 02:26:20.905
BRIEFLY TOUCH ON HOW YOUR BILL
02:26:20.972 --> 02:26:23.040
IS COORDINATING WITH THESE OTHER
02:26:23.107 --> 02:26:25.910
EFFORTS AS WELL. SO THAT WE'RE
02:26:25.977 --> 02:26:29.881
WORKING TOGETHER AND THAT IT
02:26:29.947 --> 02:26:30.982
WOULD MAKE NOTE THAT THE
02:26:31.048 --> 02:26:32.283
APPRECIATE THE ANALYSIS FROM THE
02:26:32.350 --> 02:26:33.518
EDUCATION EDUCATION COMMITTEE
02:26:33.584 --> 02:26:35.820
STAF THAT ALSO SPEAKS TO OTHER
02:26:35.887 --> 02:26:38.322
OTHER PROGRAMS AS WELL THROUGH
02:26:38.389 --> 02:26:40.958
SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND R L E A S
02:26:41.025 --> 02:26:42.426
TO DO THIS AND I'M ALSO SPEAKING
02:26:42.493 --> 02:26:44.395
AS A FORMER MEDICAL CONSULTANT
02:26:44.462 --> 02:26:45.530
FOR SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT WORKED
02:26:45.596 --> 02:26:46.898
ON MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES. YEAH
02:26:46.964 --> 02:26:49.767
FIRST THIS, UH THIS BILL IS NOT
02:26:49.834 --> 02:26:51.235
A NEW PROGRAM. IT'S SIMPLY THE
02:26:51.302 --> 02:26:53.638
OPPORTUNITY FOR A SCHOOL
02:26:53.704 --> 02:26:55.673
DISTRICT OR LOCAL EDUCATION
02:26:55.740 --> 02:26:58.242
AUTHORITY TO PARTNER WITH THE
02:26:58.309 --> 02:27:00.545
COUNTY WENT THROUGH AN MOU. AND
02:27:00.611 --> 02:27:01.779
THAT'S ACTUALLY BEEN ABLE TO BE
02:27:01.846 --> 02:27:04.282
DONE FOR QUITE A LONG TIME. BUT
02:27:04.348 --> 02:27:06.417
THERE HASN'T BEEN A REAL CONCISE
02:27:06.484 --> 02:27:08.319
MEASURE TO GET THIS INFORMATION
02:27:08.386 --> 02:27:09.654
OUT THROUGH LEGISLATION AND TO
02:27:09.720 --> 02:27:12.890
PUSH IT FORWARD. THE OTHER THING
02:27:12.957 --> 02:27:15.293
IS THAT MANY TIMES THERE IS A
02:27:15.359 --> 02:27:17.562
QUESTION IS, UH, DON'T SCHOOLS
02:27:17.628 --> 02:27:20.231
ALREADY HAVE A SCHOOL COUNSELOR
02:27:20.298 --> 02:27:23.167
OR THIS TYPE OF STAFF ON BOARD?
02:27:23.234 --> 02:27:24.669
AND MANY TIMES THE SCHOOL'S
02:27:24.735 --> 02:27:26.237
COUNSELORS ARE, IN FACT,
02:27:26.304 --> 02:27:28.739
ACADEMIC COUNSELORS SO A SCHOOL
02:27:28.806 --> 02:27:30.675
CAN CHOOSE TO USE ADDITIONAL
02:27:30.741 --> 02:27:32.543
FUNDS OUT OF THEIR GENERAL FUND
02:27:32.610 --> 02:27:35.580
OR THEIR SCHOOL BUDGETS. TO HIRE
02:27:35.646 --> 02:27:36.881
AN ADDITIONAL COUNSEL, BUT THIS
02:27:36.948 --> 02:27:37.882
WOULD BE WORKING DIRECTLY WITH
02:27:37.949 --> 02:27:39.817
THE COUNTY. NOT SURE IF THAT
02:27:39.884 --> 02:27:41.385
ANSWERED YOUR QUESTION. WELL THE
02:27:41.452 --> 02:27:42.920
BUDGET PART WHERE WE'RE MOVING
02:27:42.987 --> 02:27:44.555
THE LEGISLATION. I'M NOT REALLY
02:27:44.622 --> 02:27:45.823
WORKING OUT THROUGH THE BUDGET
02:27:45.890 --> 02:27:47.391
SIDE OF IT. ALL RIGHT NOW, I
02:27:47.458 --> 02:27:49.360
APPRECIATE THAT. AND I THINK I
02:27:49.427 --> 02:27:50.828
UNDERSTAND THIS IS GOING TO
02:27:50.895 --> 02:27:51.896
HEALTH COMMITTEE, SO WE'LL BE
02:27:51.963 --> 02:27:53.030
LOOKING AT THAT IN MORE DETAIL,
02:27:53.097 --> 02:27:54.232
BUT AGAIN APPRECIATE YOU
02:27:54.298 --> 02:27:55.733
BRINGING THIS FORWARD. I THINK
02:27:55.800 --> 02:27:57.568
IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE HAVE A
02:27:57.635 --> 02:27:58.436
COLLABORATION BETWEEN
02:27:58.502 --> 02:27:59.437
BEHAVIORAL, HEALTH AND SCHOOL
02:27:59.503 --> 02:28:02.807
DISTRICTS. UM BECAUSE, AFTER
02:28:02.873 --> 02:28:04.575
ALL, UM SCHOOL DISTRICTS WHILE
02:28:04.642 --> 02:28:06.677
THEY CERTAINLY DEAL WITH A LOT
02:28:06.744 --> 02:28:07.278
OF DIFFERENT ISSUES, TEACHERS,
02:28:07.345 --> 02:28:08.579
ETCETERA, AS YOU KNOW, IS THAT
02:28:08.646 --> 02:28:10.648
AS A 30 YEAR TEACHER THAT, UM
02:28:10.715 --> 02:28:13.184
THAT YOU KNOW, WE CAN'T JUST
02:28:13.251 --> 02:28:14.585
CAN'T DEPEND ON EDUCATION
02:28:14.652 --> 02:28:16.354
DOLLARS TO ALSO DO ALL THIS. WE
02:28:16.420 --> 02:28:18.189
NEED TO BRING SYSTEMS TOGETHER
02:28:18.256 --> 02:28:19.757
SO THAT LIKE BEHAVIOR HEALTH
02:28:19.824 --> 02:28:20.858
SYSTEM, WHICH IS GEARED TOWARD
02:28:20.925 --> 02:28:22.693
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH. CAN HELP
02:28:22.760 --> 02:28:23.928
SUPPORT EDUCATION. RIGHT? SO WE
02:28:23.995 --> 02:28:25.763
NEED TO BRING THESE SYSTEMS
02:28:25.830 --> 02:28:26.864
TOGETHER. I KNOW THAT'S WHAT
02:28:26.931 --> 02:28:28.532
YOUR BILL DOES. SO THANK YOU.
02:28:28.599 --> 02:28:29.567
THANK YOU, SENATOR PAN, FURTHER
02:28:29.634 --> 02:28:31.302
DISCUSSION SEEING AND HEARING
02:28:31.369 --> 02:28:32.637
NONE. THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED BY
02:28:32.703 --> 02:28:34.639
SENATOR DOLLY. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
02:28:34.705 --> 02:28:36.440
CLOSE? I WOULD JUST CLOSE WITH
02:28:36.507 --> 02:28:38.776
SAYING THAT YOU KNOW ONE OF THE
02:28:38.843 --> 02:28:40.878
PIECES AND THIS IS TO ALSO BRING
02:28:40.945 --> 02:28:42.847
THE PARENTS AND SO IF THERE IS A
02:28:42.913 --> 02:28:45.182
CRISIS THAT THE PARENTS CAN
02:28:45.249 --> 02:28:48.185
UNDERSTAND HOW TO ALSO NAVIGATE
02:28:48.252 --> 02:28:50.054
THE COUNTY SYSTEMS, WHICH IS ALL
02:28:50.121 --> 02:28:52.323
VERY, VERY DIFFICULT AS WE ALL
02:28:52.390 --> 02:28:55.059
KNOW, AND WHEN YOU'RE IN CRISIS
02:28:55.126 --> 02:28:55.860
, IT'S EVEN HARDER. SO OUR HOPE
02:28:55.926 --> 02:28:58.062
IS THAT THERE WILL BE THAT
02:28:58.129 --> 02:28:58.663
SEAMLESS CONNECTION AND
02:28:58.729 --> 02:28:59.730
RESPECTFULLY ASKED FOR AN I
02:28:59.797 --> 02:29:02.333
VOTE. THANK YOU, ASSEMBLYWOMAN.
02:29:02.400 --> 02:29:03.601
THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED BY
02:29:03.668 --> 02:29:04.702
SENATOR DOLLY MADAM ASSISTANT.
02:29:04.769 --> 02:29:06.570
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. VIOLATING
02:29:06.637 --> 02:29:09.840
8 85 5 TO THE MOTION IS DUE
02:29:09.907 --> 02:29:11.509
PASS, BUT FIRST THEY RE REFERRED
02:29:11.575 --> 02:29:12.910
TO THE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH LEVER
02:29:12.977 --> 02:29:14.011
LEVER. I, JOE BUCK. JOE BORG
02:29:14.078 --> 02:29:19.383
COURTESY. ORTEZ EI DOLLY! SALLY
02:29:19.450 --> 02:29:23.287
I. GLASER GLASER. I MCGUIRE PAN
02:29:23.354 --> 02:29:25.189
PAN I THAT BILL HAS ENOUGH VOTES
02:29:25.256 --> 02:29:26.724
TO GET OUT AND WE WILL LEAVE IT
02:29:26.791 --> 02:29:28.192
OPEN FOR ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:29:28.259 --> 02:29:28.926
MEMBERS. THANK YOU,
02:29:28.993 --> 02:29:30.194
ASSEMBLYWOMAN. ALL RIGHT. NEXT
02:29:30.261 --> 02:29:32.296
UP IS ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MCCARTY.
02:29:32.363 --> 02:29:35.599
WITH FINALLY HAD HIM 14 A B 14
02:29:35.666 --> 02:29:36.834
91 PLEASE PRESENT WHEN YOU ARE
02:29:36.901 --> 02:29:46.544
READY. YOUR FIRST TIME OVER
02:29:46.610 --> 02:29:51.248
HERE. THANK YOU, SENATOR FOR
02:29:51.315 --> 02:29:53.184
ALLOWING ME TO PRESENT THIS BILL
02:29:53.250 --> 02:29:54.685
AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR TEAM FOR
02:29:54.752 --> 02:29:56.821
WORKING WITH US TO CLARIFY AND
02:29:56.887 --> 02:29:58.389
WE THINK REMOVE SOME CONCERNS
02:29:58.456 --> 02:30:00.758
FROM OPPOSITION. SO YES. I WILL
02:30:00.825 --> 02:30:02.626
BE ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE
02:30:02.693 --> 02:30:03.728
AMENDMENTS THIS BILLS RELATED TO
02:30:03.794 --> 02:30:06.297
ADULT EDUCATION. WHICH WE ALL
02:30:06.364 --> 02:30:07.698
HAVE IN OUR COMMUNITIES AND OUR
02:30:07.765 --> 02:30:09.600
DISTRICTS. WE KNOW IT MAKES A
02:30:09.667 --> 02:30:10.601
BIG DIFFERENCE. PEOPLE LOOKING
02:30:10.668 --> 02:30:12.269
TO GET THEIR CITIZENSHIP COULD
02:30:12.336 --> 02:30:15.172
BASIC SKILLS ABOUT ENGLISH AND
02:30:15.239 --> 02:30:17.575
CAREER SKILLS ALSO HELP STUDENTS
02:30:17.641 --> 02:30:18.642
, HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS GO AND
02:30:18.709 --> 02:30:19.844
FOCUS ON CREDIT RECOVERY, AND
02:30:19.910 --> 02:30:22.346
I'LL SAY THIS THAT TEST BEFORE
02:30:22.413 --> 02:30:24.915
SOME OF YOU MAY KNOW THAT I DID
02:30:24.982 --> 02:30:26.684
NOT GRADUATE FROM HIGH SCHOOL. I
02:30:26.751 --> 02:30:27.651
WENT TO A LOCAL ADULT SCHOOL
02:30:27.718 --> 02:30:29.553
ABOUT FIVE MILES FROM HERE WAS
02:30:29.620 --> 02:30:30.621
ABLE TO TURN MY LIFE AROUND
02:30:30.688 --> 02:30:32.156
THROUGH AN ADULT SCHOOL, SO I
02:30:32.223 --> 02:30:33.090
KNOW FIRSTHAND THAT ADULT
02:30:33.157 --> 02:30:34.024
SCHOOLS MATTER DURING THE
02:30:34.091 --> 02:30:37.528
RECESSION. WE TOOK A LOT OUT OF
02:30:37.595 --> 02:30:39.363
THE LAST RECESSION. WE TOOK A
02:30:39.430 --> 02:30:40.531
LOT OUT OF ADULT EDUCATION
02:30:40.598 --> 02:30:42.066
FUNDING THROUGH OUR COMMUNITIES
02:30:42.133 --> 02:30:43.334
. WE BUILT IT BACK UP,
02:30:43.401 --> 02:30:44.869
UNFORTUNATELY, DOESN'T ALWAYS GO
02:30:44.935 --> 02:30:46.404
TO THE ADULT DEAD PROGRAMS. TOO
02:30:46.470 --> 02:30:47.605
OFTEN IT STAYS OVER IN THE
02:30:47.671 --> 02:30:48.606
DISTRICT HEADQUARTERS, SO THIS
02:30:48.672 --> 02:30:50.841
WOULD MAKE SURE THEY HAVE AN
02:30:50.908 --> 02:30:53.110
ADEQUATE RESERVE, BUT NOT TOO
02:30:53.177 --> 02:30:55.312
MUCH OF A RESERVE THAT DOESN'T
02:30:55.379 --> 02:30:57.848
GO TO DIRECT PROGRAMS LAST YEAR
02:30:57.915 --> 02:31:00.618
ABOUT 100 AND $30 MILLION IN
02:31:00.684 --> 02:31:01.685
ADULT ADD RESOURCES WENT
02:31:01.752 --> 02:31:04.722
UNSPENT. THAT WOULD BE ENOUGH
02:31:04.789 --> 02:31:06.791
MONEY TO SERVE SL FOR ROUGHLY
02:31:06.857 --> 02:31:08.292
260,000 CALIFORNIANS AND OUR
02:31:08.359 --> 02:31:11.996
GREAT STATE. SO THIS BILL REALLY
02:31:12.062 --> 02:31:14.365
DOES TWO THINGS. IT GIVES
02:31:14.432 --> 02:31:15.132
REGIONAL CONSORTIA THE TOOLS
02:31:15.199 --> 02:31:16.901
THEY NEED TO SELF GOVERNMENT
02:31:16.967 --> 02:31:18.803
REALLOCATE FUNDING WHEN
02:31:18.869 --> 02:31:20.171
NECESSARY TO ENSURE THAT LIMITED
02:31:20.237 --> 02:31:21.572
ADULT EDUCATION DOLLARS ARE USED
02:31:21.639 --> 02:31:24.175
IN THE MOST EFFECTIVE WAY. BUT
02:31:24.241 --> 02:31:25.609
ALSO SURE THAT REGIONAL
02:31:25.676 --> 02:31:29.447
CONSORTIUM HAVE A TOOL. UM TO
02:31:29.513 --> 02:31:30.781
PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
02:31:30.848 --> 02:31:32.583
DISTRICTS TO HELP IMPROVE THEIR
02:31:32.650 --> 02:31:33.851
EFFECTIVENESS AND REDUCE
02:31:33.918 --> 02:31:35.953
CARRYOVER. WE THINK THIS IS A
02:31:36.020 --> 02:31:37.955
WIN WIN, AND I THINK WE HAVE TWO
02:31:38.022 --> 02:31:39.857
WITNESSES ON THE PHONE, NOT IN
02:31:39.924 --> 02:31:40.858
PERSON TODAY AND RESPECTFULLY
02:31:40.925 --> 02:31:42.893
ASK THANK YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:31:42.960 --> 02:31:44.562
ALRIGHT, WE HAVE TO LEAD
02:31:44.628 --> 02:31:46.797
WITNESSES SONIA RAMIREZ AND TONY
02:31:46.864 --> 02:31:50.634
. TRUE TRIGGER CEO. SORRY IF I
02:31:50.701 --> 02:31:51.669
PRONOUNCE THAT WRONG, MR
02:31:51.735 --> 02:31:52.870
MODERATOR, IF YOU CAN QUEUE UP
02:31:52.937 --> 02:31:56.273
OUR WITNESSES PLEASE GO AHEAD.
02:31:56.340 --> 02:32:00.277
GOOD MORNING. I'M TONY RAMIREZ
02:32:00.344 --> 02:32:01.879
AND I SERVICE THE PRINCIPAL AT
02:32:01.946 --> 02:32:03.280
POSSIBLE SOUTHEAST OCCUPATIONAL
02:32:03.347 --> 02:32:04.181
CENTER WITH THE DIVISION OF
02:32:04.248 --> 02:32:05.850
ADULT CAREER EDUCATION IN THE
02:32:05.916 --> 02:32:06.851
LOS ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL
02:32:06.917 --> 02:32:08.953
DISTRICT. IN ADDITION TO THE
02:32:09.019 --> 02:32:10.921
THROAT, I HAVE THE PRIVILEGE TO
02:32:10.988 --> 02:32:12.156
SERVE AS A STATE PRESIDENT OF
02:32:12.223 --> 02:32:13.457
THE CALIFORNIA COUNCIL FOR ADULT
02:32:13.524 --> 02:32:14.024
EDUCATION. I APPRECIATE THE
02:32:14.091 --> 02:32:15.092
OPPORTUNITY TO PRIVATE TESTIMONY
02:32:15.159 --> 02:32:18.429
TODAY. IN SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY
02:32:18.496 --> 02:32:19.864
BILL 14 91 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:32:19.930 --> 02:32:22.566
KEVIN MCCARTY. IT IS CRUCIAL
02:32:22.633 --> 02:32:23.968
THAT THE STATE INVESTMENTS IN
02:32:24.034 --> 02:32:24.802
ADULT EDUCATION ARE USED
02:32:24.869 --> 02:32:27.238
EFFECTIVELY TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
02:32:27.304 --> 02:32:28.372
OUR UNDERSERVED ADULT STUDENTS
02:32:28.439 --> 02:32:30.741
WITHIN EACH REGIONAL CONSORTIUM.
02:32:30.808 --> 02:32:32.843
HOWEVER A SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF
02:32:32.910 --> 02:32:34.278
THE LIMITED EDUCATION PROGRAM
02:32:34.345 --> 02:32:36.013
DOLLARS ARE CARRIED OVER BY
02:32:36.080 --> 02:32:37.314
INDIVIDUAL CONSORTIUM MEMBERS
02:32:37.381 --> 02:32:38.082
AND CONSORTIUM ANNUALLY RATHER
02:32:38.148 --> 02:32:39.049
THAN BEING USED TO SERVE
02:32:39.116 --> 02:32:42.520
STUDENT. LEAVING SCARCE
02:32:42.586 --> 02:32:44.088
RESOURCES AND SPENT WHILE THE
02:32:44.154 --> 02:32:46.390
MEMBERS OF THE SAME CONSORTIUM
02:32:46.457 --> 02:32:47.491
HAVE INSUFFICIENT FUNDS TO
02:32:47.558 --> 02:32:48.859
OPERATE THE PROGRAMS AND MEET
02:32:48.926 --> 02:32:49.493
THE NEEDS OF THEIR COMMUNITIES.
02:32:49.560 --> 02:32:50.427
UNDERMINES THE PURPOSE OF THE
02:32:50.494 --> 02:32:54.298
REGIONAL CONSORTIUM. IN 2020 21
02:32:54.365 --> 02:32:55.799
. THE TOTAL ESTIMATED CARRYOVER
02:32:55.866 --> 02:32:58.469
WAS MORE THAN $130 MILLION. IN
02:32:58.536 --> 02:33:00.571
SOME CASES, THERE MAY BE A VALID
02:33:00.638 --> 02:33:01.605
REASON FOR LARGE ANNUAL
02:33:01.672 --> 02:33:03.908
CARRYOVER. SUCH AS NEW FACILITY
02:33:03.974 --> 02:33:05.943
CONSTRUCTION, HOWEVER,
02:33:06.010 --> 02:33:07.044
CONSORTIUM THROUGHOUT THE STATE
02:33:07.111 --> 02:33:08.412
THERE ARE LARGE AND GROWING THEM
02:33:08.479 --> 02:33:10.247
MOUNTS OF CARE OVER WITHOUT A
02:33:10.314 --> 02:33:12.983
PLAN FOR FUTURE EXPENDITURE. A B
02:33:13.050 --> 02:33:15.085
14 91 WOULD EMPOWER REGIONAL
02:33:15.152 --> 02:33:17.121
CONSORTIUM BY GIVING THEM THE
02:33:17.187 --> 02:33:18.556
AUTHORITY TO REALLOCATE FUNDING
02:33:18.622 --> 02:33:19.823
WITH THE MAJORITY VOTE WHEN IT
02:33:19.890 --> 02:33:21.559
CONSORTIUM MEMBERS PERSISTENTLY
02:33:21.625 --> 02:33:23.027
INEFFECTIVE SERVING THE NEEDS OF
02:33:23.093 --> 02:33:24.828
ADULT EDUCATION STUDENTS DUE TO
02:33:24.895 --> 02:33:26.931
EXCESS CARRYOVER. IT ALSO
02:33:26.997 --> 02:33:29.266
ENSURES THAT REGION PORSCHE WITH
02:33:29.333 --> 02:33:31.569
THE NECK TERRIER ABOUT 20% WILL
02:33:31.635 --> 02:33:33.571
RECEIVE TECHNICAL SYSTEMS FROM
02:33:33.637 --> 02:33:35.372
THE CAPE OFFICE TO HELP THEM
02:33:35.439 --> 02:33:36.373
REDUCE CARRYOVER AND SPEND
02:33:36.440 --> 02:33:39.410
FUNDING MORE EFFECTIVELY. A B 14
02:33:39.476 --> 02:33:41.545
91 HONORS AND STRENGTHENS THE
02:33:41.612 --> 02:33:43.213
LOCAL DECISION MAKING AUTHORITY
02:33:43.280 --> 02:33:44.615
WHILE PROVIDING SUPPORT TO
02:33:44.682 --> 02:33:46.917
ENSURE THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF
02:33:46.984 --> 02:33:48.052
ADULT EDUCATION PROGRAM FUNDING
02:33:48.118 --> 02:33:49.987
IS USED TO SUPPORT THE GROWING
02:33:50.054 --> 02:33:51.155
AND IMMEDIATE NEED. OF ADULT
02:33:51.221 --> 02:33:54.224
EDUCATION STUDENT ON BEHALF OF
02:33:54.291 --> 02:33:56.293
CALIFORNIA DO EDUCATION PROGRAMS
02:33:56.360 --> 02:33:57.962
AND THE STUDENTS THAT WE SERVE.
02:33:58.028 --> 02:34:00.598
I URGE YOU TO SUPPORT A B 14 91
02:34:00.664 --> 02:34:01.699
. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. NEXT
02:34:01.765 --> 02:34:05.269
WITNESS. MADAM CHAIR TONY
02:34:05.336 --> 02:34:07.371
TRUMPCARE O ON BEHALF OF THE
02:34:07.438 --> 02:34:09.773
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
02:34:09.840 --> 02:34:11.342
. WE WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE
02:34:11.408 --> 02:34:12.943
WORK DONE BY THE AUTHOR AND THE
02:34:13.010 --> 02:34:14.678
COMMITTEE. WE APPRECIATE THE
02:34:14.745 --> 02:34:17.781
WORK. THE AUTHOR IS DONE. SITA
02:34:17.848 --> 02:34:18.816
BELIEVES ALL ADULT STUDENTS
02:34:18.882 --> 02:34:21.151
SHOULD HAVE ACCESS TO FULLY
02:34:21.218 --> 02:34:23.287
FUNDED ADULT EDUCATION PROGRAMS
02:34:23.354 --> 02:34:25.689
AND CURRENTLY TOO MUCH ADULT
02:34:25.756 --> 02:34:27.191
EDUCATION FUNDING IS GOING
02:34:27.257 --> 02:34:29.360
UNSPENT BY SOME CONSORTIA OR
02:34:29.426 --> 02:34:33.230
CONSORTIA MEMBERS. AGREES MORE
02:34:33.297 --> 02:34:35.666
ACCOUNTABILITY AND SUPPORT IS
02:34:35.733 --> 02:34:37.701
NEEDED TO ENSURE ADULT EDUCATION
02:34:37.768 --> 02:34:39.470
PROGRAM PROGRAMS ARE MAXIMIZING
02:34:39.536 --> 02:34:42.172
FUNDING TO BETTER SERVE STUDENT
02:34:42.239 --> 02:34:44.208
AND FOR THESE REASONS WE SUPPORT
02:34:44.274 --> 02:34:46.477
A B 14 91 AND ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
02:34:46.543 --> 02:34:52.916
THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. DO WE HAVE
02:34:52.983 --> 02:34:55.919
ANYONE HERE IN ROOM? 2100 PLEASE
02:34:55.986 --> 02:34:57.855
LET US KNOW THAT YOU ARE IN
02:34:57.921 --> 02:34:59.556
SUPPORT OF THE BILL. TIFFANY
02:34:59.623 --> 02:35:02.459
MARK WITH CFT AND, UH, UNION OF
02:35:02.526 --> 02:35:04.028
EDUCATORS AND CLASSIFIED
02:35:04.094 --> 02:35:05.062
PROFESSIONALS SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:35:05.129 --> 02:35:08.899
NEXT WITNESS. SASHA HORWITZ, LOS
02:35:08.966 --> 02:35:10.434
ANGELES UNIFIED IN SUPPORT.
02:35:10.501 --> 02:35:12.903
THANK YOU SEEING NO ONE ELSE. MR
02:35:12.970 --> 02:35:13.971
MODERATOR, WE'RE GOING TO GO TO
02:35:14.038 --> 02:35:16.306
YOU TO QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
02:35:16.373 --> 02:35:17.541
WISHES TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF A
02:35:17.608 --> 02:35:20.911
B 14 91. MUCH FOR ANYBODY
02:35:20.978 --> 02:35:23.414
WISHING TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT
02:35:23.480 --> 02:35:26.183
TO A B 14 91 GO AHEAD AND HIT 10
02:35:26.250 --> 02:35:28.318
AT THIS TIME WHEN FOLLOWED BY
02:35:28.385 --> 02:35:31.989
ZERO AND LINE 49. YOU ARE UP.
02:35:32.056 --> 02:35:33.457
GOOD MORNING, MADAM CHAIR AND
02:35:33.524 --> 02:35:35.292
COMMITTEE MEMBERS CORRECT MUSKY
02:35:35.359 --> 02:35:36.860
ON BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATION OF
02:35:36.927 --> 02:35:38.796
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS
02:35:38.862 --> 02:35:40.964
CALLING IN SUPPORT OF A B 14 1
02:35:41.031 --> 02:35:42.099
AND SUPPORTIVE OF THE COMMITTEE
02:35:42.166 --> 02:35:43.133
AMENDMENTS TODAY. THANK YOU.
02:35:43.200 --> 02:35:45.936
THANK YOU. GVE ONE OUT ONE
02:35:46.003 --> 02:35:51.675
MORE. UM. OPPORTUNITY HERE BY
02:35:51.742 --> 02:35:53.444
HITTING ONE, PLEASE PRESS 10 FOR
02:35:53.510 --> 02:35:58.148
A B 14 91 1, PROBABLY ZERO. AND
02:35:58.215 --> 02:35:59.249
NOBODY ELSE QUEUED UP, MADAM
02:35:59.316 --> 02:36:02.686
CHAIR. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
02:36:02.753 --> 02:36:04.188
WE WILL NOW GO TO LEAD
02:36:04.254 --> 02:36:06.256
OPPOSITION, BOTH OF WHOM ARE ON
02:36:06.323 --> 02:36:08.492
THE, UM, ARE CALLING IN BALL,
02:36:08.559 --> 02:36:09.293
TINA PATEL AND MADELEINE
02:36:09.359 --> 02:36:12.730
ALBRIGHT BELOW. WHICHEVER ONE OF
02:36:12.796 --> 02:36:14.565
YOU WISHES TO SPEAK FIRST, AND
02:36:14.631 --> 02:36:18.569
YOU EACH HAVE TWO MINUTES. GOOD
02:36:18.635 --> 02:36:19.870
MORNING, SENATOR LEAVE AND
02:36:19.937 --> 02:36:21.805
COMMITTEE MEMBERS. MY NAME IS
02:36:21.872 --> 02:36:22.639
MADELINE. OUR BIO AND I AM THE
02:36:22.706 --> 02:36:23.974
PROVOST FOR THE SCHOOLS,
02:36:24.041 --> 02:36:25.275
CONTINUING EDUCATION AT MOUNT
02:36:25.342 --> 02:36:26.810
SAN ANTONIO COLLEGE AND HERE
02:36:26.877 --> 02:36:27.344
REPRESENTING THE COLLEGES
02:36:27.411 --> 02:36:30.180
POSITION TODAY AND MAYBE 14 91.
02:36:30.247 --> 02:36:31.815
WE'VE WORKED CLOSELY WITH
02:36:31.882 --> 02:36:32.349
ARCHITECTURAL PARTNERS. HE
02:36:32.416 --> 02:36:33.817
SPONSORED THIS BILL AND THE
02:36:33.884 --> 02:36:35.786
AUTHORS OFFICE. AND ARE NON
02:36:35.853 --> 02:36:37.454
CREDIT COLLEAGUES ON THIS
02:36:37.521 --> 02:36:38.856
PROPOSED SHAPE CARRYOVER POLICY
02:36:38.922 --> 02:36:40.324
FOR A FEW YEARS. WITH DIFFERENT
02:36:40.390 --> 02:36:41.558
VIEWS ON HOW STATEWIDE POLICY
02:36:41.625 --> 02:36:43.527
SHOULD ADDRESS THIS ISSUE. WE'RE
02:36:43.594 --> 02:36:44.962
STRONG BELIEVERS IN FISCAL
02:36:45.028 --> 02:36:47.197
RESPONSIBILITY AND HAVE BEEN IN
02:36:47.264 --> 02:36:48.098
FAVOR OF ADDRESSING CARRYOVER,
02:36:48.165 --> 02:36:50.134
WHICH WE BELIEVE IS IN LINE WITH
02:36:50.200 --> 02:36:51.168
THEIR HIGHLY VALUED KATO
02:36:51.235 --> 02:36:53.370
PARTNERS. AS YOU KNOW, WE'VE HAD
02:36:53.437 --> 02:36:55.205
SOME SERIOUS CONCERNS ABOUT THE
02:36:55.272 --> 02:36:55.773
BILL AND MAINTAINING A POST
02:36:55.839 --> 02:36:59.176
POSITION. WAS INTRODUCED. WE
02:36:59.243 --> 02:37:01.411
BELIEVE THAT ITS CURRENT AS
02:37:01.478 --> 02:37:02.546
CURRENTLY WRITTEN PRIOR TO THE
02:37:02.613 --> 02:37:04.915
AMENDMENTS, MAYBE 14 91. COULD
02:37:04.982 --> 02:37:06.583
LEAD TO UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES
02:37:06.650 --> 02:37:07.184
AND POTENTIALLY IRRESPONSIBLE
02:37:07.251 --> 02:37:09.219
SPENDING HABITS. AT THE EXPENSE
02:37:09.286 --> 02:37:12.389
OF THE STUDENTS. WE SERVE. THE
02:37:12.456 --> 02:37:13.724
COMMITTEE'S PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
02:37:13.791 --> 02:37:14.691
DO ADDRESS SEVERAL OF OUR
02:37:14.758 --> 02:37:17.728
CONCERNS. AND ALTHOUGH WE DON'T
02:37:17.795 --> 02:37:18.929
THINK THE BILL IS ENTIRELY
02:37:18.996 --> 02:37:21.498
NECESSARY STAFF IS AGREEABLE TO
02:37:21.565 --> 02:37:26.069
REMOVING OUR OPPOSITION WITH THE-COMMITTEE AMENDMENT. IMPORTANTLY
02:37:26.136 --> 02:37:27.671
THE NEW LANGUAGE RESPECTS EACH
02:37:27.738 --> 02:37:30.107
CONSORTIUMS LOCAL OVERSIGHT ON
02:37:30.174 --> 02:37:31.809
MATTERS AFFECTING THEIR REGION,
02:37:31.875 --> 02:37:32.643
INCLUDING CARRYOVER AND
02:37:32.709 --> 02:37:35.179
EXPANDING OF RESOURCES. WE WOULD
02:37:35.245 --> 02:37:36.446
LIKE TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:37:36.513 --> 02:37:39.016
MCCARTY STAFF. AND OUR T TOLD
02:37:39.082 --> 02:37:41.084
PARTNERS FOR INVESTING THE TIME
02:37:41.151 --> 02:37:42.286
TO ENGAGE IN DISCUSSIONS OVER
02:37:42.352 --> 02:37:44.788
THE PAST TWO YEARS. WE'RE ALSO
02:37:44.855 --> 02:37:46.256
GRATEFUL FOR THIS COMMITTEE
02:37:46.323 --> 02:37:48.325
STAFF FOR THEIR HOURS OF
02:37:48.392 --> 02:37:49.426
ATTENTION WITH THIS LEGISLATION.
02:37:49.493 --> 02:37:51.128
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUE
02:37:51.195 --> 02:37:52.896
TO SERVE OUR ADULT STUDENTS IN
02:37:52.963 --> 02:37:53.664
SHORT TERM CAREER AND COLLEGE
02:37:53.730 --> 02:37:55.032
TRANSITION PROGRAMS AT SUCH A
02:37:55.098 --> 02:37:56.567
CRITICAL TIME FOR OUR STATE.
02:37:56.633 --> 02:37:58.135
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. MISS
02:37:58.202 --> 02:38:02.906
PATEL. THANK YOU. HELLO
02:38:02.973 --> 02:38:04.408
HONORABLE CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
02:38:04.474 --> 02:38:06.410
MEMBERS. MY NAME IS VALENTINA
02:38:06.476 --> 02:38:08.278
CARTEL, AND I'M THE PRESIDENT OF
02:38:08.345 --> 02:38:09.780
NORTH ORANGE. CONTINUING
02:38:09.847 --> 02:38:11.915
EDUCATION REPRESENTING NORTH
02:38:11.982 --> 02:38:13.417
ORANGE COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE
02:38:13.483 --> 02:38:15.252
DISTRICT POSITION TODAY ON A B
02:38:15.319 --> 02:38:19.022
14 91. I WOULD DISTRICT HAS BEEN
02:38:19.089 --> 02:38:21.024
A CLOSE PARTNER WORKING WITH
02:38:21.091 --> 02:38:22.226
OTHER NON CREDIT PROVIDERS
02:38:22.292 --> 02:38:24.928
ACROSS THE STATE IN DISCUSSION
02:38:24.995 --> 02:38:25.963
ABOUT POTENTIAL IMPLICATIONS OF
02:38:26.029 --> 02:38:30.667
A B 14 91. AS CURRENTLY WRITTEN.
02:38:30.734 --> 02:38:32.236
IN ADDITION TO THE REASONS
02:38:32.302 --> 02:38:35.172
STATED BY PROVOST ARE BIO NORTH
02:38:35.239 --> 02:38:36.940
ORANGE HAS SERIOUS CONCERNS
02:38:37.007 --> 02:38:39.176
ABOUT THE TIMING OF THIS BILL
02:38:39.243 --> 02:38:40.611
DURING THE RECOVERY FROM THE
02:38:40.677 --> 02:38:43.914
IMPACT OF THE COVID 19. PANDEMIC
02:38:43.981 --> 02:38:45.015
ON COMMUNITY COLLEGE AND ADULT
02:38:45.082 --> 02:38:48.318
COURT ENROLLMENT. WE FEARED THAT
02:38:48.385 --> 02:38:51.188
WHEN WE NEED RESOURCES, THE MOST
02:38:51.255 --> 02:38:52.556
, THE BILL, AS CURRENTLY WRITTEN
02:38:52.623 --> 02:38:54.791
COULD HAVE RESULTED IN MILLIONS
02:38:54.858 --> 02:38:56.260
OF DOLLARS LIVING A REGION TO
02:38:56.326 --> 02:38:59.162
SERVE IT OUT LEARNERS. AND GOING
02:38:59.229 --> 02:39:01.331
BACK TO THE STATE GENERAL FUND,
02:39:01.398 --> 02:39:03.667
LEAVING THE MOST RISK AND UNDER
02:39:03.734 --> 02:39:05.102
REPRESENTED STUDENTS WAS OUT
02:39:05.168 --> 02:39:08.171
ACCESS TO ADULT EDUCATION. WAS
02:39:08.238 --> 02:39:09.406
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
02:39:09.473 --> 02:39:11.775
ACCEPTED BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:39:11.842 --> 02:39:13.911
MCCARTHY NORTH ORANGE COUNTY
02:39:13.977 --> 02:39:15.545
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT IS
02:39:15.612 --> 02:39:17.180
PLEASED TO REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION
02:39:17.247 --> 02:39:21.652
TO A B 14 91. WE WOULD ALSO LIKE
02:39:21.718 --> 02:39:22.786
TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
02:39:22.853 --> 02:39:26.490
MCCARTHY, HIS STAFF SPONSORS AND
02:39:26.556 --> 02:39:27.658
THE COMMUNITIES FOR THEIR HARD
02:39:27.724 --> 02:39:29.393
WORK AND ATTENTION TO THE BILL
02:39:29.459 --> 02:39:30.727
THAT WILL IMPACT THE MOST
02:39:30.794 --> 02:39:31.728
VULNERABLE POPULATIONS IN OUR
02:39:31.795 --> 02:39:34.298
STATE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME
02:39:34.364 --> 02:39:37.167
AND CONSIDERATION. THANK YOU
02:39:37.234 --> 02:39:39.136
VERY MUCH. ALRIGHT WE'RE GOING
02:39:39.202 --> 02:39:40.837
TO GO TO ANY OPPOSITION HERE IN
02:39:40.904 --> 02:39:44.308
ROOM 2100. PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
02:39:44.374 --> 02:39:45.676
YOU. CHAIR AND MEMBERS ASHLEY
02:39:45.742 --> 02:39:47.444
WALKER YOU ALREADY HEARD FROM
02:39:47.511 --> 02:39:48.712
NORTH ORANGE COUNTY AND MOUNT
02:39:48.779 --> 02:39:50.914
SAN ANTONIO COLLEGE. SO I AM
02:39:50.981 --> 02:39:51.782
REPRESENTING THE ASSOCIATION OF
02:39:51.848 --> 02:39:52.916
COMMUNITY AND CONTINUING
02:39:52.983 --> 02:39:54.751
EDUCATION. WE WERE A PARTNER
02:39:54.818 --> 02:39:56.520
WORKING ON AMENDMENTS WITH
02:39:56.586 --> 02:39:57.220
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MCCARTHY'S
02:39:57.287 --> 02:39:58.555
OFFICE AND THE SPONSORS. AND
02:39:58.622 --> 02:39:59.856
WE'RE HAPPY TO REMOVE OUR
02:39:59.923 --> 02:40:01.458
OPPOSITION TODAY. WITH THE
02:40:01.525 --> 02:40:03.226
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS ACCEPTED.
02:40:03.293 --> 02:40:04.728
WE'D LIKE TO THANK THE COMMITTEE
02:40:04.795 --> 02:40:06.396
AND COMMITTEE STAFF FOR THEIR
02:40:06.463 --> 02:40:08.231
HARD WORK ON THIS BILL. THANK
02:40:08.298 --> 02:40:10.701
YOU. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. DAVID
02:40:10.767 --> 02:40:11.768
O'BRIEN WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:40:11.835 --> 02:40:12.669
COMMUNITY COLLEGES CHANCELLOR'S
02:40:12.736 --> 02:40:14.171
OFFICE. JUST ONE ALIGN OURSELVES
02:40:14.237 --> 02:40:15.672
WITH OUR COLLEAGUES THAT WE
02:40:15.739 --> 02:40:16.974
INTEND TO REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION
02:40:17.040 --> 02:40:18.375
WITH THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS IN
02:40:18.442 --> 02:40:19.376
PRINT. THANKS. TERRIFIC. THANK
02:40:19.443 --> 02:40:21.545
YOU. ALL RIGHT. WE WILL NOW GO
02:40:21.611 --> 02:40:23.180
TO OUR PHONE LINES, MR MODERATOR
02:40:23.246 --> 02:40:24.648
AND SEE IF THERE IS ANYONE WHO
02:40:24.715 --> 02:40:26.616
WISHES TO EXPRESS OPPOSITION FOR
02:40:26.683 --> 02:40:31.188
ABBY 14 91. THANK YOU TO EXPRESS
02:40:31.254 --> 02:40:32.956
OPPOSITION TO A B 14 91 GO AHEAD
02:40:33.023 --> 02:40:34.958
AND HIT 10 AT THIS TIME, ONCE
02:40:35.025 --> 02:40:40.497
ALL BY ZERO. AND NOBODY IS
02:40:40.564 --> 02:40:42.799
QUEUING UP, MADAM CHAIR. VERY
02:40:42.866 --> 02:40:43.667
GOOD. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR.
02:40:43.734 --> 02:40:45.635
WE'RE GOING TO COME BACK HERE TO
02:40:45.702 --> 02:40:47.237
COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS?
02:40:47.304 --> 02:40:48.905
COMMENTS OVER THE BILL EARNS THE
02:40:48.972 --> 02:40:50.040
BILL HAS BEEN MOVED. PARACHA
02:40:50.107 --> 02:40:51.008
VOGUE. SO JUST FOR
02:40:51.074 --> 02:40:55.045
CLARIFICATION. PURPOSES. I'LL BE
02:40:55.112 --> 02:40:59.149
SUPPORTING THE BILL. JUST BUT I
02:40:59.216 --> 02:41:00.951
DO HAVE TO HAVE A QUESTION OR
02:41:01.018 --> 02:41:09.159
WITH REGARDS TO SORRY. SO RIGHT
02:41:09.226 --> 02:41:11.895
NOW, UH, THESE DISTRICTS ARE
02:41:11.962 --> 02:41:14.398
REQUIRED TO HAVE A THREE YEAR
02:41:14.464 --> 02:41:15.665
PLANNING CYCLE. IN THE CONCERN
02:41:15.732 --> 02:41:18.402
THAT THEY WERE HAVING THAT THIS
02:41:18.468 --> 02:41:19.569
WOULD CREATE A TWO YEAR CARRY
02:41:19.636 --> 02:41:23.707
OVER. UM IS THAT STILL IN PLACE
02:41:23.774 --> 02:41:25.575
OR DO THE AMENDMENTS TAKE CARE
02:41:25.642 --> 02:41:34.284
OF THAT ISSUE? AYE. ME PULL UP
02:41:34.351 --> 02:41:36.253
THE I KNOW HE'S STRUCK THE WHOLE
02:41:36.319 --> 02:41:38.221
OF THE CONTENTS OF THE BILL AND
02:41:38.288 --> 02:41:39.389
HAD THIS NEW LANGUAGE IN THERE
02:41:39.456 --> 02:41:42.192
SO I JUST WANT TO BECAUSE IT TO
02:41:42.259 --> 02:41:44.094
ME. IT MAKES SENSE THAT IF YOU
02:41:44.161 --> 02:41:45.896
HAVE A THREE YEAR PLANNING CYCLE
02:41:45.962 --> 02:41:51.435
THAT YOU WOULD HAVE A HAVE. THAT
02:41:51.501 --> 02:41:52.702
YOUR EDUCATION PLAN FOR THREE
02:41:52.769 --> 02:41:55.305
YEARS SHOULD BE TIED TO YOUR
02:41:55.372 --> 02:41:55.939
THREE YEAR FISCAL PLANNING. I
02:41:56.006 --> 02:41:57.741
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT THAT'S
02:41:57.808 --> 02:41:58.575
NOT COMPROMISED. I THINK THE
02:41:58.642 --> 02:42:00.310
FOCUS HERE IS ON THE TWO YEARS
02:42:00.377 --> 02:42:02.712
AND IF WE HAVE AN ISSUE, I CAN
02:42:02.779 --> 02:42:04.681
WORK WITH YOU ON IT STILL, BUT I
02:42:04.748 --> 02:42:06.283
DON'T HAVE THAT. 100% CONCRETE
02:42:06.349 --> 02:42:08.085
ANSWER, BUT I KNOW WE TALKED
02:42:08.151 --> 02:42:09.219
ABOUT FOR TWO CONSECUTIVE FISCAL
02:42:09.286 --> 02:42:11.855
YEARS AS FAR AS THE AMOUNT OF
02:42:11.922 --> 02:42:14.391
MONEY IN, UM IN RESERVE. UM I
02:42:14.458 --> 02:42:16.226
THINK THE BIG PICTURE HERE,
02:42:16.293 --> 02:42:18.862
THOUGH, IS WE HAVE A RESERVE
02:42:18.929 --> 02:42:20.564
POLICY FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS? YES
02:42:20.630 --> 02:42:22.632
WE HAVE AN AMAZING STATE RESERVE
02:42:22.699 --> 02:42:24.768
NOW. $30 BILLION. WE HAVE A
02:42:24.835 --> 02:42:26.903
PRODUCT TO PROBLEM 98 RESERVE.
02:42:26.970 --> 02:42:29.372
AND SO FOR THESE ADULT DEAD
02:42:29.439 --> 02:42:30.774
PROGRAMS, THEY HAD WAY MORE
02:42:30.841 --> 02:42:32.409
MONEY THAN THEIR REPORTING. THEN
02:42:32.476 --> 02:42:33.844
ARE OPEN OUR SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
02:42:33.910 --> 02:42:35.445
THIS PUTS SOME SOMEWHAT MORE IN
02:42:35.512 --> 02:42:36.580
LINE AND IT'S STILL THEY COULD
02:42:36.646 --> 02:42:37.647
HAVE HIGHER RESERVES. IN A
02:42:37.714 --> 02:42:43.186
TYPICAL. SO UM, BUT ON THAT
02:42:43.253 --> 02:42:45.088
TECHNICAL ISSUE WILL HAVE TO
02:42:45.155 --> 02:42:49.559
CONTINUE. CONCRETE. YOU DO
02:42:49.626 --> 02:42:51.094
UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN THAT I
02:42:51.161 --> 02:42:51.928
WOULD HAVE. IF THEY'RE REQUIRED
02:42:51.995 --> 02:42:53.597
TO HAVE A THREE YEAR PLANNING.
02:42:53.663 --> 02:42:54.831
WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY
02:42:54.898 --> 02:42:57.067
ARE ABLE TO PLAN FISCALLY FOR
02:42:57.134 --> 02:42:58.101
THREE YEARS AS WELL AND NOT
02:42:58.168 --> 02:42:59.803
COMPROMISE THERE. BILITY TO DO
02:42:59.870 --> 02:43:01.638
THAT. SO THAT'S THE ONLY CONCERN
02:43:01.705 --> 02:43:03.707
I HAVE, BUT I WOULD BE HAPPY TO
02:43:03.773 --> 02:43:04.875
HEAR YOUR THOUGHTS AND MOVE
02:43:04.941 --> 02:43:06.776
FORWARD. AND I THINK I MIGHT BE
02:43:06.843 --> 02:43:08.945
ABLE TO HAVE HELP. IT'S A THREE
02:43:09.012 --> 02:43:10.480
YEAR PLAN THAT GETS UPDATED
02:43:10.547 --> 02:43:11.515
ANNUALLY. SO BASICALLY, IT'S AN
02:43:11.581 --> 02:43:12.449
ANNUAL PLAN. OKAY, HOPEFULLY,
02:43:12.516 --> 02:43:15.952
THAT'S HELPFUL. AND I ALWAYS
02:43:16.019 --> 02:43:17.020
UNDERSTAND LITTLE CHALLENGING
02:43:17.087 --> 02:43:17.988
WHEN COMMITTEE MAKES A LOT OF
02:43:18.054 --> 02:43:20.357
AMENDMENT. UM YOUR BILLS A
02:43:20.423 --> 02:43:21.925
LITTLE DIFFERENT, BUT I'D LIKE
02:43:21.992 --> 02:43:23.693
TO THINK A LOT BETTER GO.
02:43:23.760 --> 02:43:24.694
ALRIGHT ANY OTHER QUESTIONS,
02:43:24.761 --> 02:43:27.731
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS? SEEING AND
02:43:27.797 --> 02:43:29.166
HEARING MEN REMEMBER, YOU MAY
02:43:29.232 --> 02:43:30.600
CLOSE. WELL THANK YOU. THANKS TO
02:43:30.667 --> 02:43:32.202
YOUR COMMITTEE STAFF ARE ALWAYS
02:43:32.269 --> 02:43:34.204
WORKING WITH US TO IMPROVE OUR
02:43:34.271 --> 02:43:36.039
PRODUCTS, AND IT'S ALL ABOUT THE
02:43:36.106 --> 02:43:37.274
KIDS AND THIS ISSUE IT'S ABOUT
02:43:37.340 --> 02:43:38.942
ARE ADULTS. CALIFORNIA AND SO
02:43:39.009 --> 02:43:42.412
WITH THAT, UM, ASK FOR YOUR
02:43:42.479 --> 02:43:43.680
THANK YOU DO HAVE EMOTION ON THE
02:43:43.747 --> 02:43:47.284
BILL. IT'S BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR
02:43:47.350 --> 02:43:48.351
CORTEZ. MADAM ASSISTANT. PLEASE
02:43:48.418 --> 02:43:52.155
CALL THE ROLL. HIGHLIGHT IN 14
02:43:52.222 --> 02:43:55.158
80 14 91. THE MOTION IS DUE PASS
02:43:55.225 --> 02:43:56.893
AS AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND
02:43:56.960 --> 02:43:58.094
RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
02:43:58.161 --> 02:44:00.564
APPROPRIATIONS. LEAVE US. I
02:44:00.630 --> 02:44:02.332
LEAVE A CHILL BOOK. I CORTESI.
02:44:02.399 --> 02:44:08.838
ORTEZ EI DELI. DELI. I GLASER.
02:44:08.905 --> 02:44:12.242
MCGUIRE PAN AND I CALL CAN YOU
02:44:12.309 --> 02:44:13.443
CALL THE ROLL ONE MORE TIME,
02:44:13.510 --> 02:44:15.645
PLEASE. OR THE ABSENT MEMBERS
02:44:15.712 --> 02:44:16.846
ABSENT MEMBERS GLASER GLASER, I
02:44:16.913 --> 02:44:20.183
VERY GOOD, MCGUIRE PERFECT.
02:44:20.250 --> 02:44:21.651
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. BILL HAS
02:44:21.718 --> 02:44:23.019
ENOUGH VOTES TO GET OUT, BUT
02:44:23.086 --> 02:44:24.955
WE'LL KEEP IT ON CALL. ALRIGHT
02:44:25.021 --> 02:44:26.790
REMEMBERS AT THIS TIME WE ARE
02:44:26.856 --> 02:44:28.458
GOING TO RECESS UNTIL ONE
02:44:28.525 --> 02:44:31.394
O'CLOCK FOR A CAUCUS MEETING.
02:44:31.461 --> 02:44:33.797
AND WE WILL BE BACK AT ONE AND I
02:44:33.863 --> 02:44:35.498
WOULD ENCOURAGE. WE HAVE THREE
02:44:35.565 --> 02:44:36.800
AUTHORS LEFT. I WOULD ENCOURAGE
02:44:36.866 --> 02:44:38.935
ALL OF THEM TO BE HERE RIGHT AT
02:44:39.002 --> 02:44:39.970
ONE O'CLOCK BECAUSE WE ARE GOING
02:44:40.036 --> 02:44:41.771
TO START RIGHT AT ONE AND
02:44:41.838 --> 02:44:42.906
TECHNICALLY HAVE TO BE ABLE TO
02:44:42.973 --> 02:44:45.041
ROOM AT 1 30. SO IF YOU'RE ONE
02:44:45.108 --> 02:44:47.110
OF THE THREE AUTHORS PLEASE BE
02:44:47.177 --> 02:44:48.211
HERE, RIGHT AT ONE O'CLOCK. WE
02:44:48.278 --> 02:45:05.095
STAND IN RECESS.
02:45:32.055 --> 02:45:34.624
UM ALL RIGHT. RECESS IS OVER.
02:45:34.691 --> 02:45:35.091
WELCOME MR O'DONNELL,
02:45:35.158 --> 02:45:38.628
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S MEMBERS. WE ARE
02:45:38.695 --> 02:45:40.664
NOW GOING TO BE LIVE STREAMING.
02:45:40.730 --> 02:45:41.698
SO FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE
02:45:41.765 --> 02:45:43.667
WATCHING ON TV, THE PARTICIPANT
02:45:43.733 --> 02:45:45.602
NUMBER IS NOT AT THE BOTTOM OF
02:45:45.669 --> 02:45:47.504
THE SCREEN, SO I'M GOING TO
02:45:47.570 --> 02:45:49.205
ANNOUNCE IT FOR YOU NOW. IT IS
02:45:49.272 --> 02:45:54.978
8772 TO 6. 8163. AND THE ACCESS
02:45:55.045 --> 02:45:59.949
CODE IS 736. 87 LET ME START
02:46:00.016 --> 02:46:04.888
AGAIN. 736 TO 833. ALRIGHT
02:46:04.954 --> 02:46:06.323
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S O DONNELL, YOU
02:46:06.389 --> 02:46:09.259
ARE HERE TO PRESENT FILE ITEM 16
02:46:09.326 --> 02:46:11.394
89 02. PLEASE BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE
02:46:11.461 --> 02:46:12.762
READY. THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR
02:46:12.829 --> 02:46:14.731
AND MEMBERS. A B 902 ESTABLISHES
02:46:14.798 --> 02:46:15.632
AN ALTERNATIVE DESIGN BUILD
02:46:15.699 --> 02:46:18.735
PROJECT. FOR THE PROCUREMENT OF
02:46:18.802 --> 02:46:21.237
SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS.
02:46:21.304 --> 02:46:22.639
THE TRADITIONAL METHOD FOR
02:46:22.706 --> 02:46:23.973
AWARDING CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS
02:46:24.040 --> 02:46:25.208
IS DESIGN BID BUILD THREE STEP
02:46:25.275 --> 02:46:28.378
PROCESS. WHERE A SCHOOL DISTRICT
02:46:28.445 --> 02:46:29.479
FIRST HIRES AN ARCHITECT
02:46:29.546 --> 02:46:31.514
DESIGNER SCHOOL. STEP ONE, THEN
02:46:31.581 --> 02:46:33.416
GOES OUT TO BID FOR THE
02:46:33.483 --> 02:46:34.718
CONSTRUCTION FOR THE CONTRACT.
02:46:34.784 --> 02:46:36.886
OTHER DESIGN BUILD A SCHOOL
02:46:36.953 --> 02:46:38.121
DISTRICT SEEKS BIDS FOR BOTH THE
02:46:38.188 --> 02:46:40.623
DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION. HAVING
02:46:40.690 --> 02:46:42.058
AN ARCHITECT AND CONTRACTOR
02:46:42.125 --> 02:46:43.460
WORKED TOGETHER FROM THE
02:46:43.526 --> 02:46:44.694
BEGINNING OF THE PROJECT. THE
02:46:44.761 --> 02:46:46.996
BEGINNING OF THE PROJECT IS MORE
02:46:47.063 --> 02:46:47.864
EFFICIENT AND HELPS PREVENT
02:46:47.931 --> 02:46:49.032
PROBLEMS LATER ON IN THE
02:46:49.099 --> 02:46:49.933
PROJECT, CHANGE ORDERS,
02:46:49.999 --> 02:46:51.101
ETCETERA. WITH THE PRIVATE
02:46:51.167 --> 02:46:54.637
SECTOR. SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND
02:46:54.704 --> 02:46:55.939
OTHER AGENCIES HAVE FOUND IS
02:46:56.005 --> 02:46:58.007
THAT BY SETTING A PRICE FOR THE
02:46:58.074 --> 02:46:59.442
CONTRACT BEFORE A DESIGN TO
02:46:59.509 --> 02:47:01.211
STARTED OR HAS BEEN COMPLETED,
02:47:01.277 --> 02:47:03.747
CAUSES ONE OF TWO PROBLEMS. I
02:47:03.813 --> 02:47:05.515
DID THE SCHOOL DISTRICT OVERPAYS
02:47:05.582 --> 02:47:06.583
BECAUSE CONSTRUCTION COSTS
02:47:06.649 --> 02:47:08.251
PROJECTED BY THE BIDDER IS MUCH
02:47:08.318 --> 02:47:09.886
HIGHER THAN THE ACTUAL COSTS,
02:47:09.953 --> 02:47:11.421
WHICH MAY NOT BE REALIZED UNTIL
02:47:11.488 --> 02:47:12.522
YEARS AFTER THE CONTRACT IS
02:47:12.589 --> 02:47:15.558
AWARDED, OR THE SCHOOL DISTRICT
02:47:15.625 --> 02:47:16.926
ENDS UP WITH THE FACILITY OF
02:47:16.993 --> 02:47:18.528
LOWER QUALITY OR DOES NOT MEET
02:47:18.595 --> 02:47:20.063
THE NEEDS OF THE SCHOOL BECAUSE
02:47:20.130 --> 02:47:21.798
THE CONTRACT AMOUNT CANNOT BE
02:47:21.865 --> 02:47:25.101
CHANGED. A B 902 CREATES A PILOT
02:47:25.168 --> 02:47:27.203
PILOT THAT ALLOWS A SCHOOL
02:47:27.270 --> 02:47:28.238
DISTRICT TO AWARD AN INITIAL BID
02:47:28.304 --> 02:47:29.873
THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE
02:47:29.939 --> 02:47:31.241
CONSTRUCTION COSTS AND INSTEAD
02:47:31.307 --> 02:47:32.976
ALLOWS THE SCHOOL DISTRICT TO
02:47:33.042 --> 02:47:34.043
RENEGOTIATE WITH THE DESIGN BID.
02:47:34.110 --> 02:47:37.414
BUILD HIM. BUILD TEAM ONCE THERE
02:47:37.480 --> 02:47:39.215
IS DESIGN SO NOW THAT THE DESIGN
02:47:39.282 --> 02:47:40.750
GETS COMPLETED, THEN THEY CAN
02:47:40.817 --> 02:47:42.152
NEGOTIATE COSTS DOWN TO MAKE
02:47:42.218 --> 02:47:44.087
SURE THE PROCESS PROJECT IS COST
02:47:44.154 --> 02:47:46.122
EFFICIENT. WE HAVE TAKEN
02:47:46.189 --> 02:47:46.956
AMENDMENTS TO REMOVE ANY
02:47:47.023 --> 02:47:49.159
OPPOSITION FROM THE BILL AND I
02:47:49.225 --> 02:47:50.693
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE TODAY. HERE
02:47:50.760 --> 02:47:52.662
TODAY IS I BELIEVE SASHA HORWITZ
02:47:52.729 --> 02:47:54.631
AND I BELIEVE IN THE LOS ANGELES
02:47:54.697 --> 02:47:56.566
UNIFIED SCHOOL DIST. VERY GOOD.
02:47:56.633 --> 02:47:58.001
THANK YOU. ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S YOUR
02:47:58.067 --> 02:48:00.103
LEAD WITNESS IS SASHA, PLEASE
02:48:00.170 --> 02:48:01.671
PROCEED. YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES.
02:48:01.738 --> 02:48:03.339
GOOD AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
02:48:03.406 --> 02:48:05.308
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE SANDRA
02:48:05.375 --> 02:48:06.476
HORWITZ WITH THE LOS ANGELES
02:48:06.543 --> 02:48:07.110
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT. WE ARE
02:48:07.177 --> 02:48:09.245
PLEASED TO SPONSOR ASSEMBLY BILL
02:48:09.312 --> 02:48:11.114
902 TO ESTABLISH A PILOT PROGRAM
02:48:11.181 --> 02:48:12.182
AUTHORIZING A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO
02:48:12.248 --> 02:48:14.017
USE AN ALTERNATIVE DESIGN BUILD
02:48:14.083 --> 02:48:14.751
CONTRACTING PROCESS FOR ANY
02:48:14.818 --> 02:48:15.752
CONSTRUCTION PROJECT OVER $5
02:48:15.819 --> 02:48:19.456
MILLION. THE DESIGN BUILD
02:48:19.522 --> 02:48:20.356
PROCUREMENT METHOD PROVIDES
02:48:20.423 --> 02:48:21.991
SCHOOL DISTRICTS WITH THE USEFUL
02:48:22.058 --> 02:48:23.860
TOOL THAT RESULTS IN EFFICIENCY
02:48:23.927 --> 02:48:25.395
AND COST SAVINGS BY ALLOWING
02:48:25.462 --> 02:48:26.396
SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO ENTER INTO
02:48:26.463 --> 02:48:27.230
PARTNERSHIPS WITH ENTITIES THAT
02:48:27.297 --> 02:48:29.065
CAN BOTH DESIGN AND BUILD SCHOOL
02:48:29.132 --> 02:48:31.034
FACILITIES. THE PARTIES CAN WORK
02:48:31.100 --> 02:48:32.035
COOPERATIVELY THROUGH THE DESIGN
02:48:32.101 --> 02:48:33.736
AND CONSTRUCTION PHASES OF A
02:48:33.803 --> 02:48:36.473
PROJECT. HOWEVER BOTH PARTIES
02:48:36.539 --> 02:48:37.740
FACE UNCERTAINTY AT THE
02:48:37.807 --> 02:48:38.908
INCEPTION OF THE DESIGN BUILDING
02:48:38.975 --> 02:48:41.077
PROJECT. UNDER CURRENT LAW,
02:48:41.144 --> 02:48:42.779
SINCE NO FINAL DESIGN EXISTS AT
02:48:42.846 --> 02:48:44.347
THE TIME, A SCHOOL DISTRICT
02:48:44.414 --> 02:48:45.882
ENTERS INTO A DESIGN BUILD
02:48:45.949 --> 02:48:46.816
CONTRACT. IT IS DIFFICULT FOR
02:48:46.883 --> 02:48:48.017
EITHER PARTY TO PREDICT THE
02:48:48.084 --> 02:48:49.118
ULTIMATE COST TO CONSTRUCT THE
02:48:49.185 --> 02:48:51.087
PROJECT. FURTHER THE EXISTING
02:48:51.154 --> 02:48:52.856
DESIGN BUILD PROCUREMENT METHOD
02:48:52.922 --> 02:48:54.023
DOES NOT ALLOW FOR UPWARD
02:48:54.090 --> 02:48:55.024
ADJUSTMENT IN THE INITIAL
02:48:55.091 --> 02:48:57.026
CONTRACT PRICE. AS A RESULT,
02:48:57.093 --> 02:48:58.194
DESIGN BUILDERS MUST ADD
02:48:58.261 --> 02:48:59.329
CONTINGENCIES TO THE PROPOSALS
02:48:59.395 --> 02:49:02.031
TO COVER FUTURE UNCERTAINTIES.
02:49:02.098 --> 02:49:03.099
UNCERTAINTIES INCLUDE THE
02:49:03.166 --> 02:49:04.400
UNPREDICTABLE COST TO CONSTRUCT
02:49:04.467 --> 02:49:05.168
THE FINAL DESIGN INFLATION
02:49:05.235 --> 02:49:07.937
DURING THE DESIGN OF THAT THAT
02:49:08.004 --> 02:49:09.038
DURING THE DURATION OF THE
02:49:09.105 --> 02:49:11.908
DESIGN PHASE ONCE THE DESIGN IS
02:49:11.975 --> 02:49:12.809
COMPLETE, BOTH PARTIES HAVE
02:49:12.876 --> 02:49:13.810
GREATER CERTAINTY ABOUT
02:49:13.877 --> 02:49:16.779
CONSTRUCTION COSTS. NO. TWO
02:49:16.846 --> 02:49:17.847
WOULD ALLOW SCHOOL DISTRICTS AND
02:49:17.914 --> 02:49:19.215
DESIGN BUILDERS TO NEGOTIATE
02:49:19.282 --> 02:49:20.250
ACTUAL CONSTRUCTION COSTS ONCE
02:49:20.316 --> 02:49:22.318
THE DESIGN IS COMPLETE. THE
02:49:22.385 --> 02:49:23.987
DESIGN BUILDER WOULD OBTAIN
02:49:24.053 --> 02:49:25.522
SUBCONTRACTOR COSTS BASED ON
02:49:25.588 --> 02:49:27.323
DESIGN APPROVED BY THE DIVISION
02:49:27.390 --> 02:49:28.291
OF STATE ARCHITECTS. SCHOOL
02:49:28.358 --> 02:49:29.259
DISTRICTS WOULD EXAMINE THESE
02:49:29.325 --> 02:49:32.729
SOME CONTRACT. SOME CONTRACTOR
02:49:32.795 --> 02:49:34.364
COST THROUGH AN OPEN BOOK
02:49:34.430 --> 02:49:35.498
EVALUATION OF THE BIDS RECEIVED
02:49:35.565 --> 02:49:37.100
BY THE DESIGN BUILDER. SINCE
02:49:37.166 --> 02:49:38.468
DESIGN BUILDERS AND THEIR
02:49:38.535 --> 02:49:39.869
SUBCONTRACTORS WOULD NO LONGER
02:49:39.936 --> 02:49:41.437
NEED TO ADD CONSTITUENCIES TO
02:49:41.504 --> 02:49:43.006
THE PROPOSALS TO COVER FUTURE
02:49:43.072 --> 02:49:43.940
UNCERTAINTIES. THE FINAL
02:49:44.007 --> 02:49:45.341
CONSTRUCTION COSTS ARE
02:49:45.408 --> 02:49:46.109
ANTICIPATED TO BE LOWER,
02:49:46.175 --> 02:49:47.911
RESULTING IN SAVINGS FOR SCHOOL
02:49:47.977 --> 02:49:50.713
DISTRICTS. IN ADDITION, SINCE
02:49:50.780 --> 02:49:52.315
EXISTING LAW DOES NOT ALLOW FOR
02:49:52.382 --> 02:49:53.283
UPWARD ADJUSTMENTS IN THE
02:49:53.349 --> 02:49:54.684
INITIAL CONTRACT PRICE, 89 02
02:49:54.751 --> 02:49:57.053
WOULD ALLOW SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO
02:49:57.120 --> 02:49:57.687
ISSUE CHANGE ORDERS AUTHORIZED
02:49:57.754 --> 02:50:02.859
UNDER OTHER PROCUREMENT METHOD.
02:50:02.926 --> 02:50:04.060
RECENT AMENDMENTS REMOVE THE
02:50:04.127 --> 02:50:05.228
CONCERNS OF SOME DISTRICTS BY
02:50:05.295 --> 02:50:06.729
MAKING CLEAR THE PROJECTS
02:50:06.796 --> 02:50:07.830
ALREADY UNDERWAY WILL NOT BE
02:50:07.897 --> 02:50:08.998
AFFECTED BY THE PROVISIONS OF
02:50:09.065 --> 02:50:11.301
THIS BILL. FOR THESE REASONS TO
02:50:11.367 --> 02:50:12.335
INCREASE EFFICIENCY AND RESULT
02:50:12.402 --> 02:50:15.004
IN COST SAVINGS. LOS ANGELES
02:50:15.071 --> 02:50:16.539
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT IS
02:50:16.606 --> 02:50:18.007
PRACTICE EITHER SPONSOR OF HB
02:50:18.074 --> 02:50:20.510
902 IN URGES YOUR I VOTE ON THE
02:50:20.577 --> 02:50:21.911
BILL. THANK YOU. THANK YOU, MR
02:50:21.978 --> 02:50:23.413
HORWITZ. ALRIGHT WE'RE GOING TO
02:50:23.479 --> 02:50:25.014
ANYONE IN SUPPORT HERE IN ROOM
02:50:25.081 --> 02:50:27.317
2100 SEEING NO. ONE. MR
02:50:27.383 --> 02:50:28.751
MODERATOR, WOULD YOU PLEASE OPEN
02:50:28.818 --> 02:50:30.587
THE LINES FOR ANYONE WHO WISHES
02:50:30.653 --> 02:50:33.256
TO EXPRESS SUPPORT FOR A B 902?
02:50:33.323 --> 02:50:34.857
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. MADAM CHAIR
02:50:34.924 --> 02:50:36.859
IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B 902
02:50:36.926 --> 02:50:38.795
PLEASE PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY A
02:50:38.861 --> 02:50:42.265
ZERO FOLLOWED BY THIS TIME. AND
02:50:42.332 --> 02:50:43.866
OUR FIRST ONE WILL BE LINE ONE.
02:50:43.933 --> 02:50:45.969
OH, THREE. ANYBODY ELSE GO AHEAD
02:50:46.035 --> 02:50:48.171
AND HIT 10 TO TESTIFY IN SUPPORT
02:50:48.237 --> 02:50:49.305
FOR MAYBE NINE. OH, 21. OH,
02:50:49.372 --> 02:50:51.708
THREE. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
02:50:51.774 --> 02:50:53.042
AFTERNOON, MADAM CHAIR AND
02:50:53.109 --> 02:50:54.477
MEMBERS. MADELINE COOPER FROM
02:50:54.544 --> 02:50:55.979
NIELSEN WORKS MURDER ON BEHALF
02:50:56.045 --> 02:50:57.113
OF THE PRECEDED BUILDERS AND
02:50:57.180 --> 02:50:58.247
CONTRACTORS OF CALIFORNIA AND
02:50:58.314 --> 02:51:00.049
CROWD SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK
02:51:00.116 --> 02:51:03.620
YOU. MADAM CHAIR. NOBODY ELSE
02:51:03.686 --> 02:51:05.288
DID CURE. EXCLLENT THANK YOU
02:51:05.355 --> 02:51:06.789
VERY MUCH. ALL RIGHT. WE WILL
02:51:06.856 --> 02:51:08.858
BRING IT BACK OR EXCUSE ME. WE
02:51:08.925 --> 02:51:10.093
NEED TO GO TO OPPOSITION. WE
02:51:10.159 --> 02:51:11.728
HAVE NO LEAD OPPOSITION. ANYONE
02:51:11.794 --> 02:51:13.496
HERE IN ROOM 2100, WHICH IS TO
02:51:13.563 --> 02:51:15.531
OPPOSE SEEING NO ONE. MR
02:51:15.598 --> 02:51:16.899
MODERATOR, WOULD YOU PLEASE
02:51:16.966 --> 02:51:18.101
QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO WISHES TO
02:51:18.167 --> 02:51:22.372
OPPOSE A B 902? IF YOU ARE IN
02:51:22.438 --> 02:51:24.240
OPPOSITION TO A B 902 PLEASE
02:51:24.307 --> 02:51:25.642
PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME ONE
02:51:25.708 --> 02:51:32.048
FOLLOWED BY ZERO. NOBODY IS
02:51:32.115 --> 02:51:34.384
KILLING UP THIS TIME. THANK YOU
02:51:34.450 --> 02:51:36.219
VERY MUCH. WE'LL BRING IT BACK
02:51:36.285 --> 02:51:37.420
TO THE COMMITTEE. FOR QUESTIONS,
02:51:37.487 --> 02:51:40.456
SENATOR PAN. THANK YOU AND THANK
02:51:40.523 --> 02:51:43.326
YOU, SENATOR MACDONALD FOR
02:51:43.393 --> 02:51:44.427
BRINGING THIS FORWARD DON'T JUST
02:51:44.494 --> 02:51:48.865
WANT TO CLARIFY SO AH! SO RIGHT
02:51:48.931 --> 02:51:50.867
NOW, IF YOU WANT TO DO DESIGN
02:51:50.933 --> 02:51:52.735
BUILD YOU IS IT THAT THE SCHOOL
02:51:52.802 --> 02:51:54.170
DISTRICT HAS TO BECAUSE YOU
02:51:54.237 --> 02:51:56.139
SAID, TALK ABOUT NEGOTIATING THE
02:51:56.205 --> 02:51:57.206
PRICE AFTER DESIGN WHERE YOU
02:51:57.273 --> 02:51:58.307
HAVE MORE CERTAINTY THAT MAKES
02:51:58.374 --> 02:51:59.809
LESS SENSE. IS WHAT YOUR BILLS
02:51:59.876 --> 02:52:01.177
ADDRESSING IS THAT WHEN THE
02:52:01.244 --> 02:52:03.513
SCHOOL BOARD OR ARE MAKES A
02:52:03.579 --> 02:52:05.181
DECISION TO DO CONSTRUCTION THAT
02:52:05.248 --> 02:52:07.250
THEY ACTUALLY HAVE TO BID OUT
02:52:07.316 --> 02:52:09.619
WITH WITH THE PRICE INITIALLY IS
02:52:09.686 --> 02:52:10.253
THAT THAT'S I'M I'M JUST TRYING
02:52:10.319 --> 02:52:13.022
TO UNDERSTAND WHAT'S CHANGING.
02:52:13.089 --> 02:52:13.890
SO I SUPPORT WHAT YOU'RE TRYING
02:52:13.956 --> 02:52:16.059
TO DO. I JUST TRY TO UNDERSTAND.
02:52:16.125 --> 02:52:18.094
LIKE WHAT? WHY CAN'T YOU DO IT
02:52:18.161 --> 02:52:18.795
NOW? WHAT IS IT THAT WE'RE
02:52:18.861 --> 02:52:21.531
CHANGING THAT THE IN THIS
02:52:21.597 --> 02:52:23.066
PARTICULAR BILL, RIGHT, SO THE
02:52:23.132 --> 02:52:25.334
EFFORT HERE IS TO TRY AND NOT
02:52:25.401 --> 02:52:27.236
GET AH! THOSE INDIVIDUALS
02:52:27.303 --> 02:52:28.204
INVOLVED IN SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
02:52:28.271 --> 02:52:30.973
TO BE THE DESIGNER, THE
02:52:31.040 --> 02:52:34.744
ARCHITECT BUILDER. AH TO NOT
02:52:34.811 --> 02:52:36.746
OPERATE IN SILOS, RIGHT
02:52:36.813 --> 02:52:38.214
ARCHITECT MIGHT NOT BE CONCERNED
02:52:38.281 --> 02:52:39.749
WITH ULTIMATELY WHAT THE PROJECT
02:52:39.816 --> 02:52:42.652
COST YET IF WE WERE TO GET THE
02:52:42.719 --> 02:52:43.986
ARCHITECT IN THE ROOM WITH THE
02:52:44.053 --> 02:52:45.021
BUILDER, SOMETIMES MAYBE THE
02:52:45.088 --> 02:52:47.223
SAME FIRM UM WE CAN ULTIMATELY
02:52:47.290 --> 02:52:49.025
IMPACT WE GET THEM TO THINK
02:52:49.092 --> 02:52:51.661
TOGETHER. OKAY OKAY. THANK HOW
02:52:51.728 --> 02:52:54.063
HOW? HOW THE IMPLICATIONS OF A
02:52:54.130 --> 02:52:56.299
CHANGE TO THE DESIGN. HOW THOSE
02:52:56.365 --> 02:52:58.568
ARE GONNA ULTIMATELY IMPACT THE
02:52:58.634 --> 02:53:00.470
COST OF A PROJECT PREVENTS THAT
02:53:00.536 --> 02:53:02.138
FROM HAPPENING RIGHT NOW BEFORE
02:53:02.205 --> 02:53:03.806
. YEAH THEY'RE PRECLUDED BY
02:53:03.873 --> 02:53:05.174
CURRENT LAW AND CURRENT PRACTICE
02:53:05.241 --> 02:53:06.743
FROM DOING THAT, OKAY, ALRIGHT.
02:53:06.809 --> 02:53:09.312
OKAY NOW I APPRECIATE THAT. JUST
02:53:09.378 --> 02:53:10.613
ONE. GET THAT UNDERSTANDING. SO
02:53:10.680 --> 02:53:12.749
BE HAPPY TO MOVE THE BILL AT THE
02:53:12.815 --> 02:53:13.616
APPROPRIATE TIME. THANK YOU.
02:53:13.683 --> 02:53:14.717
THANK YOU. OTHER QUESTIONS,
02:53:14.784 --> 02:53:16.085
COMMENTS OR CONCERNS, SEEING AND
02:53:16.152 --> 02:53:19.122
HEARING THEM. SORRY, PHð BOGUE.
02:53:19.188 --> 02:53:20.857
THANK YOU VERY MUCH A SIMILAR
02:53:20.923 --> 02:53:22.358
MURDER O'DONNELL FOR BRINGING
02:53:22.425 --> 02:53:24.494
THIS PROCESS HERE AS WELL. AND
02:53:24.560 --> 02:53:26.562
I'M GONNA POSE THE FOLLOWING
02:53:26.629 --> 02:53:27.764
QUESTIONS WITH CONCERNS, AND I
02:53:27.830 --> 02:53:29.632
KNOW THIS IS AN EDUCATION
02:53:29.699 --> 02:53:31.134
COMMITTEE AND OUR FOCUS IS THERE
02:53:31.200 --> 02:53:32.902
BUT THE BILL DOES HAVE THIS
02:53:32.969 --> 02:53:34.470
QUESTION. OR THE STATEMENTS THAT
02:53:34.537 --> 02:53:35.905
REQUIRES WORKERS AND THE PROJECT
02:53:35.972 --> 02:53:37.807
TO BE SKILLED AND TRAINED. AND,
02:53:37.874 --> 02:53:40.743
UM THE CONCERNS THAT I HAVE WITH
02:53:40.810 --> 02:53:42.445
THAT IS THAT THERE ARE MANY,
02:53:42.512 --> 02:53:43.513
MANY CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES THAT
02:53:43.579 --> 02:53:46.482
ARE NOT NECESSARILY WHAT YOU
02:53:46.549 --> 02:53:47.183
WOULD TRADITIONALLY CALLED
02:53:47.250 --> 02:53:48.651
SKILLED AND TRAINED BUT BY THE
02:53:48.718 --> 02:53:50.453
STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAVE MET THE
02:53:50.520 --> 02:53:53.723
REQUIREMENTS AND, UM OUR LICENSE
02:53:53.790 --> 02:53:58.227
TO BUILD AND CONSTRUCT. SCHOOLS
02:53:58.294 --> 02:54:00.596
IN THE STATE AND THE CONCERNS
02:54:00.663 --> 02:54:01.731
THAT I HAVE, AND I'M GOING TO
02:54:01.798 --> 02:54:04.300
POST THEM TO YOU IS THAT WHEN WE
02:54:04.367 --> 02:54:05.802
AND I'M NOT TALKING ABOUT
02:54:05.868 --> 02:54:06.469
PREVAILING WAGE BECAUSE ANYTHING
02:54:06.536 --> 02:54:08.337
THAT'S PUBLICLY FUNDED IS
02:54:08.404 --> 02:54:09.338
ALREADY AUTOMATICALLY IN STATUTE
02:54:09.405 --> 02:54:12.742
TO BE UM, PREPAID PREVAILING
02:54:12.809 --> 02:54:14.343
WAGE SO THEY DON'T HAVE TO
02:54:14.410 --> 02:54:16.112
TECHNICALLY BE A SKILLED AND
02:54:16.179 --> 02:54:17.280
TRAINED OR UNION FORCE IN ORDER
02:54:17.346 --> 02:54:18.281
TO RECEIVE PREVAILING WAGE
02:54:18.347 --> 02:54:19.715
ANYONE THAT CONTRACTS AND BIDS
02:54:19.782 --> 02:54:24.020
THESE JOBS. ARE REQUIRED TO BE
02:54:24.086 --> 02:54:25.621
PAID PREVAILING WAGE. BUT THE
02:54:25.688 --> 02:54:27.523
CONCERNS THAT I HAVE IS THAT
02:54:27.590 --> 02:54:31.360
WHEN YOU HAVE THIS OUT SPECIFIC
02:54:31.427 --> 02:54:34.463
BURBAGE. UM, YOU ARE LIMITING
02:54:34.530 --> 02:54:38.100
THE CONSTRUCTION. COMPANIES FROM
02:54:38.167 --> 02:54:41.971
THE ABILITY TO WORK BID. AND
02:54:42.038 --> 02:54:44.373
WORK ON THESE PROJECTS. AND THE
02:54:44.440 --> 02:54:46.008
PROBLEM THAT I HAVE IS THAT HERE
02:54:46.075 --> 02:54:48.010
IN CALIFORNIA WE TALKED ABOUT
02:54:48.077 --> 02:54:48.778
THE IMPORTANCE OF HAVING
02:54:48.845 --> 02:54:49.378
ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY, ALLOWING
02:54:49.445 --> 02:54:52.615
EVERYONE TO HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY.
02:54:52.682 --> 02:54:55.585
AND YET, EVEN THOUGH AS A STATE
02:54:55.651 --> 02:54:57.320
WE HAVE THESE REQUIREMENTS FOR
02:54:57.386 --> 02:55:00.289
PEOPLE TO MEET AND BE LICENSED
02:55:00.356 --> 02:55:01.958
TO WORK AND PROVIDED LIVING FOR
02:55:02.024 --> 02:55:04.260
THEMSELVES, THEIR FAMILIES. AN
02:55:04.327 --> 02:55:06.696
EMPLOYEES WERE SAYING SORRY
02:55:06.762 --> 02:55:10.499
pFROM THIS SPECIFIC, UM,
02:55:10.566 --> 02:55:11.701
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM OR THIS
02:55:11.767 --> 02:55:14.704
SPECIFIC, UM. CERTIFICATION
02:55:14.770 --> 02:55:20.243
CERTIFICATION. OUR UNION OR
02:55:20.309 --> 02:55:21.410
WHATEVER IT MAY BE. HE GOES,
02:55:21.477 --> 02:55:24.447
YOU'RE NOT QUALIFIED TO WORK AND
02:55:24.513 --> 02:55:25.948
BID ON THESE PROJECTS. EVEN
02:55:26.015 --> 02:55:27.583
THOUGH AS A STATE WE HAVE GIVEN
02:55:27.650 --> 02:55:29.252
THEM THAT OPPORTUNITY AND
02:55:29.318 --> 02:55:30.553
LICENSE THEM AND SAID YES, YOU
02:55:30.620 --> 02:55:33.322
CAN WORK IN CALIFORNIA. SO WHEN
02:55:33.389 --> 02:55:34.924
I THINK ABOUT, IT'S FUNNY
02:55:34.991 --> 02:55:36.492
BECAUSE WE'RE JUST TALKING ABOUT
02:55:36.559 --> 02:55:37.526
CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES THAT ARE
02:55:37.593 --> 02:55:38.828
PRIMARILY OWNED BY UM BLACK
02:55:38.895 --> 02:55:42.465
AMERICANS. THAT ARE
02:55:42.531 --> 02:55:44.066
DISPROPORTIONATELY AFFECTED BY
02:55:44.133 --> 02:55:46.402
THESE TYPE OF LANGUAGES IN HERE
02:55:46.469 --> 02:55:47.403
, AND I'M SURPRISED THAT THEY'RE
02:55:47.470 --> 02:55:48.604
NOT SPEAKING A LITTLE BIT MORE,
02:55:48.671 --> 02:55:51.073
BUT I THINK WE'RE GOING TO SEE A
02:55:51.140 --> 02:55:53.075
LITTLE BIT MORE OF THEM HERE IN
02:55:53.142 --> 02:55:53.976
CALIFORNIA, SPEAKING ABOUT TO
02:55:54.043 --> 02:55:54.543
THIS TO THIS FACT. BUT
02:55:54.610 --> 02:55:55.645
CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES THAT YOU
02:55:55.711 --> 02:55:57.647
KNOW THAT ARE FAMILY OWNED.
02:55:57.713 --> 02:56:00.016
SMALL BUSINESSES, LITERALLY,
02:56:00.082 --> 02:56:00.950
EXCLUDING THEM FROM AN
02:56:01.017 --> 02:56:02.385
OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE FOR
02:56:02.451 --> 02:56:03.319
THEMSELVES AND THEIR FAMILIES
02:56:03.386 --> 02:56:04.820
AND THEIR EMPLOYEES, AND I HAVE
02:56:04.887 --> 02:56:10.159
JUST. PHILOSOPHICALLY AS WELL AS
02:56:10.226 --> 02:56:12.328
AN ETHICAL AND, UM AND IDEALISM
02:56:12.395 --> 02:56:14.130
. AMERICAN. UM, I HAVE A
02:56:14.196 --> 02:56:17.099
PROBLEM. BECAUSE I TRULY TRULY
02:56:17.166 --> 02:56:18.901
BELIEVE IN ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
02:56:18.968 --> 02:56:20.369
FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS AND
02:56:20.436 --> 02:56:23.472
ANYTHING THAT DISPARAGES THAT OR
02:56:23.539 --> 02:56:24.507
EXCLUDES PEOPLE FROM THAT
02:56:24.573 --> 02:56:27.276
OPPORTUNITY. I JUST CAN'T CAN'T
02:56:27.343 --> 02:56:30.880
SUPPORT SO WE JUST WANTED TO
02:56:30.947 --> 02:56:32.048
GIVE YOU AN OPPORTUNITY TO
02:56:32.114 --> 02:56:33.549
EXPRESS YOUR THOUGHTS. AND IF
02:56:33.616 --> 02:56:35.151
YOU HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:56:35.217 --> 02:56:36.919
SPEAK TO THESE TO THESE
02:56:36.986 --> 02:56:39.021
COMPANIES, AND THESE OWNERS AND
02:56:39.088 --> 02:56:39.555
THESE EMPLOYEES OF THESE
02:56:39.622 --> 02:56:42.024
COMPANIES, WHAT WOULD YOU SAY TO
02:56:42.091 --> 02:56:44.060
THEM? AND IF I MAY? I THINK THE
02:56:44.126 --> 02:56:45.227
BILL IS ABOUT DESIGN BUILD. I
02:56:45.294 --> 02:56:46.362
THINK THE ISSUE YOU'RE SPEAKING
02:56:46.429 --> 02:56:48.364
OF THIS BILL DOESN'T DOESN'T
02:56:48.431 --> 02:56:50.499
HELP OR HURT WHAT YOU'RE TALKING
02:56:50.566 --> 02:56:52.168
ABOUT, BUT IT'S SPECIFICALLY HAS
02:56:52.234 --> 02:56:53.569
THAT LANGUAGE IN THERE. SO
02:56:53.636 --> 02:56:55.304
THAT'S WHY I'M TRYING TO ADDRESS
02:56:55.371 --> 02:56:57.440
AS WHERE IF YOU SUPPORT THIS,
02:56:57.506 --> 02:56:59.208
BILL, YOU'RE SUPPORTING THAT. SO
02:56:59.275 --> 02:57:00.443
I'M JUST KIND OF CURIOUS. WHAT
02:57:00.509 --> 02:57:01.444
WOULD YOU SAY TO THESE
02:57:01.510 --> 02:57:03.045
COMPANIES? AND THESE PEOPLE IN
02:57:03.112 --> 02:57:04.380
THE PROCESS THAT YOU'RE TRYING
02:57:04.447 --> 02:57:06.749
TO PROVE HERE BECAUSE I WOULD BE
02:57:06.816 --> 02:57:07.750
OKAY WITH THE WHOLE PROCESS,
02:57:07.817 --> 02:57:08.951
EXCEPT FOR THAT PARTICULAR
02:57:09.018 --> 02:57:11.921
COMPONENT, UNDERSTOOD. AND UM I
02:57:11.988 --> 02:57:12.955
WHOLEHEARTEDLY DEFEND THE
02:57:13.022 --> 02:57:13.956
SKILLED AND TRAINED WORKFORCE
02:57:14.023 --> 02:57:15.858
COMPONENT IN THIS BILL. IT IS A
02:57:15.925 --> 02:57:19.228
CONTINUOUS, IT IS A CONTINUUM OF
02:57:19.295 --> 02:57:20.563
PAST PRACTICE OF THE STATE
02:57:20.629 --> 02:57:21.731
LEGISLATURE TO PUT LANGUAGE LIKE
02:57:21.797 --> 02:57:25.101
THAT. IN SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
02:57:25.167 --> 02:57:26.602
POLICY. WE'VE DONE IT IN MANY
02:57:26.669 --> 02:57:27.837
PLACES. THIS IS JUST CONTINUING
02:57:27.903 --> 02:57:29.672
THAT PRACTICE. BUT THE QUESTION
02:57:29.739 --> 02:57:33.175
IS WHY, UM, I THINK IF YOU WOULD
02:57:33.242 --> 02:57:34.310
ASK ANYONE IN THE COUNTRY
02:57:34.377 --> 02:57:35.011
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY THOSE
02:57:35.077 --> 02:57:36.078
PROJECTS THAT ARE DONE BY
02:57:36.145 --> 02:57:37.146
INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE GONE
02:57:37.213 --> 02:57:38.414
THROUGH APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM.
02:57:38.481 --> 02:57:40.950
TEND TO TURN OUT TO BE A BETTER
02:57:41.017 --> 02:57:42.118
PRODUCT AND OFTENTIMES UNDER
02:57:42.184 --> 02:57:44.220
BUDGET. OKAY THEY'RE JUST
02:57:44.286 --> 02:57:44.854
THEY'RE JUST THEY'RE JUST
02:57:44.920 --> 02:57:47.623
TYPICALLY STRONGER, MORE SOLID
02:57:47.690 --> 02:57:49.025
COMPANIES WITH A LONGER HISTORY
02:57:49.091 --> 02:57:49.959
IN SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION, JUST A
02:57:50.026 --> 02:57:51.394
LONGER HISTORY IN THE
02:57:51.460 --> 02:57:52.695
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY. BUT WHY,
02:57:52.762 --> 02:57:53.729
SPECIFICALLY, THAT SKILLED AND
02:57:53.796 --> 02:57:56.565
TRAINED WORKFORCE? LANGUAGE IN
02:57:56.632 --> 02:57:58.934
THERE. IT'S THE POLICY THAT
02:57:59.001 --> 02:57:59.502
KEEPS GIVING BECAUSE WHAT IT
02:57:59.568 --> 02:58:01.003
SAYS IS, WE WANT INDIVIDUALS
02:58:01.070 --> 02:58:02.238
THAT WORK ON THIS BUILDING TO
02:58:02.304 --> 02:58:03.172
HAVE BEEN THROUGH AN
02:58:03.239 --> 02:58:04.640
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS STATE
02:58:04.707 --> 02:58:06.142
CERTIFIED APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM
02:58:06.208 --> 02:58:07.476
, NOT A PRIVATE ONE THAT SOMEONE
02:58:07.543 --> 02:58:08.644
JUST STARTED UP ON A CORNER.
02:58:08.711 --> 02:58:09.578
THAT'S REALLY NOT AN
02:58:09.645 --> 02:58:10.780
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAM. BUT ONE
02:58:10.846 --> 02:58:12.214
THAT STATE CERTIFIED THAT THEY
02:58:12.281 --> 02:58:14.583
CAN SPEND THEIR TIME. UH AND
02:58:14.650 --> 02:58:15.851
STARTED AN APPRENTICE WORK UP TO
02:58:15.918 --> 02:58:17.987
A JOURNEYMAN AND BEYOND. SO THIS
02:58:18.054 --> 02:58:19.388
POLICY IS REALLY THE POLICY
02:58:19.455 --> 02:58:20.656
AGAIN. AS I STATED THAT KEEPS
02:58:20.723 --> 02:58:21.791
GIVING BECAUSE IT BUILDS A PATH
02:58:21.857 --> 02:58:23.626
TO MIDDLE CLASS. WORD IS A
02:58:23.692 --> 02:58:25.094
KEEPER OF THE MIDDLE CLASS. IT
02:58:25.161 --> 02:58:26.796
ALSO BUILDS A SKILLED AND
02:58:26.862 --> 02:58:27.730
TRAINED WORKFORCE. THAT'S WHAT
02:58:27.797 --> 02:58:29.031
IT DOES PEOPLE THAT ARE REALLY
02:58:29.098 --> 02:58:31.333
SKILLED IN THEIR CRAFT, AND I
02:58:31.400 --> 02:58:33.502
CAN TELL YOU CAN GO AROUND
02:58:33.569 --> 02:58:34.336
CONSTRUCTION SITES AROUND TOWN.
02:58:34.403 --> 02:58:35.171
I CAN OFTEN TELL YOU WHAT SITES
02:58:35.237 --> 02:58:36.872
CONSTRUCTION. WHAT SITES? WHAT
02:58:36.939 --> 02:58:39.008
SIDES UNION? WHAT SIDE IS NOT
02:58:39.075 --> 02:58:39.542
WHAT SIDE SKILLED, TRAINED
02:58:39.608 --> 02:58:41.510
WORKFORCE. WHAT SIDES? NOT WHICH
02:58:41.577 --> 02:58:43.412
ONE IS NOT BECAUSE YOU CAN SEE
02:58:43.479 --> 02:58:44.046
THE HOURS THEY'RE WORKING. OKAY
02:58:44.113 --> 02:58:49.318
IT'S JUST IT'S JUST NOT UM THIS
02:58:49.385 --> 02:58:51.087
POLICY IS AND IS PUT IN THIS
02:58:51.153 --> 02:58:54.757
LEGISLATION TO AGAIN BE A KEEPER
02:58:54.824 --> 02:58:56.892
AND A PATH TO MIDDLE CLASS AND
02:58:56.959 --> 02:58:58.260
AGAIN HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE
02:58:58.327 --> 02:58:59.295
TRAINED TO DO THE WORK THEY'RE
02:58:59.361 --> 02:59:00.563
DOING. NOT JUST HIRED OFF THE
02:59:00.629 --> 02:59:01.897
STREET. NOT THAT I'VE JUST GONE
02:59:01.964 --> 02:59:03.899
THROUGH SOME PROGRAM. THERE'S NO
02:59:03.966 --> 02:59:04.700
ONE HAD ANY OVERSIGHT OF THAT'S
02:59:04.767 --> 02:59:07.036
WHAT REALLY THE EFFORT IS. SO
02:59:07.103 --> 02:59:07.770
THIS IS GOOD FOR WORKERS. THIS
02:59:07.837 --> 02:59:09.538
IS ALSO GOOD FOR CONSTRUCTION
02:59:09.605 --> 02:59:11.173
COMPANY OWNERS SO I WOULD
02:59:11.240 --> 02:59:11.774
COUNTER TO ANYONE. THEY WOULD
02:59:11.841 --> 02:59:14.009
ARGUE THAT THIS IS POOR POLICY.
02:59:14.076 --> 02:59:16.178
THIS IS ABOUT, UM, AGAIN MAKING
02:59:16.245 --> 02:59:17.947
CALIFORNIA A BETTER PLACE AND
02:59:18.013 --> 02:59:19.115
GETTING PEOPLE INTO JOBS WITH
02:59:19.181 --> 02:59:23.252
GOOD BENEFITS. GOOD PAY. UM
02:59:23.319 --> 02:59:25.287
THERE HAVE BEEN STUDIES THAT
02:59:25.354 --> 02:59:26.288
HAVE DONE THAT HAVE BEEN DONE BY
02:59:26.355 --> 02:59:27.756
INDIVIDUALS THAT DON'T GO INTO
02:59:27.823 --> 02:59:28.757
COMPANIES THAT HAVE THAT SKILLED
02:59:28.824 --> 02:59:30.059
AND TRAINED WORKFORCE COMPONENT
02:59:30.126 --> 02:59:31.127
REQUIREMENT AND OFTEN TIMES IT
02:59:31.193 --> 02:59:33.362
ENDS UP BEING THE TAXPAYER.
02:59:33.429 --> 02:59:34.330
THAT'S SUPPORTING THESE
02:59:34.396 --> 02:59:35.865
INDIVIDUALS. THE COMPANY HAS IT
02:59:35.931 --> 02:59:37.867
FALL ON THEM BECAUSE THEY DON'T
02:59:37.933 --> 02:59:38.901
PROVIDE HEALTH CARE. THEY DON'T
02:59:38.968 --> 02:59:40.436
PROVIDE PENSIONS. THEY DON'T
02:59:40.503 --> 02:59:41.737
PROVIDE A DECENT PAY. SO AGAIN,
02:59:41.804 --> 02:59:45.474
I STRONGLY SUPPORT THE SKILLED
02:59:45.541 --> 02:59:47.209
AND TRAINED WORKFORCE LANGUAGE
02:59:47.276 --> 02:59:47.977
BECAUSE I THINK IT'S STRONGLY
02:59:48.043 --> 02:59:50.212
SUPPORTS A BETTER PRODUCT, AND
02:59:50.279 --> 02:59:51.213
IT'S STRONGLY SUPPORTS THE
02:59:51.280 --> 02:59:54.350
MIDDLE CLASS IN CALIFORNIA. SO
02:59:54.416 --> 02:59:56.018
UM, SO LET ME ADDRESS SOME OF
02:59:56.085 --> 02:59:58.320
THE COMMENTS THAT YOU MADE ON
02:59:58.387 --> 02:59:59.488
HERE. SO MOST OF THE COMPANIES
02:59:59.555 --> 03:00:02.558
THAT I HAVE SPOKEN TO ACTUALLY,
03:00:02.625 --> 03:00:04.460
I WOULD SAY PROBABLY ALL OF THEM
03:00:04.527 --> 03:00:05.494
PROVIDE BENEFITS TO THEIR TO
03:00:05.561 --> 03:00:08.097
THEIR EMPLOYEES. AND SO I DON'T
03:00:08.164 --> 03:00:09.765
THINK THAT IS A FACTOR AND
03:00:09.832 --> 03:00:11.433
WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE, I WOULD
03:00:11.500 --> 03:00:13.869
DISPUTE THAT. BUT OKAY? THE
03:00:13.936 --> 03:00:15.371
MAJOR ONES THAT BUILDING SCHOOLS
03:00:15.437 --> 03:00:16.872
. I'M PRETTY SURE THEY'RE ALL
03:00:16.939 --> 03:00:19.909
PROVIDING BENEFITS ON THAT, UM,
03:00:19.975 --> 03:00:22.244
NUMBER TWO, UM, AS FAR AS THE
03:00:22.311 --> 03:00:24.180
MIDDLE CLASS WHEN IT COMES TO
03:00:24.246 --> 03:00:25.781
ONCE AGAIN THE WAGES IT'S IN
03:00:25.848 --> 03:00:27.917
STATUE WHAT THEY MADE THE UNION
03:00:27.983 --> 03:00:29.919
OR NONUNION, SKILLED OR NOT.
03:00:29.985 --> 03:00:32.655
QUOTE UNQUOTE NON SKILLED. UM
03:00:32.721 --> 03:00:33.956
THEY COULD MAKE ABOVE THAT SCALE
03:00:34.023 --> 03:00:35.291
TO YES, YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT
03:00:35.357 --> 03:00:37.393
. THEY COULD, BUT THE PREVAILING
03:00:37.459 --> 03:00:38.961
WAGE IS PRETTY MUCH SET IN
03:00:39.028 --> 03:00:40.629
STATUTE, SO I DON'T THINK THAT
03:00:40.696 --> 03:00:43.566
IS A FACTOR IN THAT. UM THE
03:00:43.632 --> 03:00:46.135
OTHER PART IS THE SO THE COST
03:00:46.202 --> 03:00:48.037
BENEFITS THE MIDDLE CLASS.
03:00:48.103 --> 03:00:50.406
THEY'RE ALL THE SAME. THE OTHER
03:00:50.472 --> 03:00:51.540
CONCERN THAT YOU HAVE IS THAT
03:00:51.607 --> 03:00:53.442
WHEN YOU HAVE YOU LIMIT THE POOL
03:00:53.509 --> 03:00:56.378
OF WHO CAN BID ON THESE PROJECTS
03:00:56.445 --> 03:00:58.881
. YOU'RE ALSO LIMITING THE COST
03:00:58.948 --> 03:01:00.649
EFFECTIVENESS ON THAT ON THOSE
03:01:00.716 --> 03:01:01.550
PROJECTS BECAUSE IT'S MY
03:01:01.617 --> 03:01:02.551
UNDERSTANDING THAT THERE AREN'T
03:01:02.618 --> 03:01:07.623
ENOUGH. ACROSS THE STATE, UM OF
03:01:07.690 --> 03:01:09.858
WORKFORCE TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE
03:01:09.925 --> 03:01:12.928
THE NECESSARY LABOR WORKFORCE ON
03:01:12.995 --> 03:01:16.031
MANY OF THESE PROJECTS, SO YOU
03:01:16.098 --> 03:01:18.801
PUT A LIMIT AS TO, UM THE
03:01:18.867 --> 03:01:20.236
EXPERIENCE IN WHICH THESE
03:01:20.302 --> 03:01:22.404
PARTIES CAN BE COMPLETED AND
03:01:22.471 --> 03:01:25.341
NUMBER TWO. THE UM, THE
03:01:25.407 --> 03:01:26.742
EXPEDIENCY AND THEN THE COST
03:01:26.809 --> 03:01:29.011
FACTOR. SO THE MORE COMPETITION
03:01:29.078 --> 03:01:32.248
THAT WE HAVE IN IN IN COMPANIES
03:01:32.314 --> 03:01:34.250
BIDDING FOR THESE PROJECTS
03:01:34.316 --> 03:01:35.718
ALLOWED TO BE MORE COMPETITIVE
03:01:35.784 --> 03:01:36.986
AS THE COST THE COST OF THE
03:01:37.052 --> 03:01:40.356
PROJECT AS A WHOLE. SO THAT'S
03:01:40.422 --> 03:01:41.890
ANOTHER FACTOR THAT WHEN WE
03:01:41.957 --> 03:01:43.659
DON'T HAVE MANY PLAYERS IN PLACE
03:01:43.726 --> 03:01:44.860
THE COSTS BECAUSE THEY'RE SO
03:01:44.927 --> 03:01:48.998
LIMITED. THE IT AFFECTS THE COST
03:01:49.064 --> 03:01:49.732
OF THE PRODUCT OR THE COST OF
03:01:49.798 --> 03:01:51.634
THE PROJECT TO GO EVEN FURTHER
03:01:51.700 --> 03:01:54.003
HIGH, WHICH IS TAXPAYERS, SO, UM
03:01:54.069 --> 03:01:56.505
, IT DOES POTENTIALLY HAS THE
03:01:56.572 --> 03:01:57.773
ABILITY TO COST THE TAXPAYERS
03:01:57.840 --> 03:02:00.576
MUCH, MUCH MORE MONEY. ON ON
03:02:00.643 --> 03:02:02.978
THAT END, SO, UM, THERE'S COST
03:02:03.045 --> 03:02:05.614
IN IN IN IN BENEFITS TO BOTH
03:02:05.681 --> 03:02:06.749
ANGLES IN WHICH THEY COULD
03:02:06.815 --> 03:02:10.519
POTENTIALLY COULD COULD BE, UM,
03:02:10.586 --> 03:02:12.054
IS THERE A QUESTION THERE OR
03:02:12.121 --> 03:02:13.422
IT'S A STATEMENT THAT COMMENT.
03:02:13.489 --> 03:02:15.357
IT'S A COMMENT ON THAT END. AND
03:02:15.424 --> 03:02:18.093
THEN LASTLY, UM, LET'S SEE. I
03:02:18.160 --> 03:02:19.561
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE MY TRAIN OF
03:02:19.628 --> 03:02:21.030
THOUGHT PROCESSES THAT I CAN'T
03:02:21.096 --> 03:02:22.998
COMMENT ON THAT MANAGER. SURE
03:02:23.065 --> 03:02:24.133
LISTEN, I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT
03:02:24.199 --> 03:02:25.267
TO WORRY ABOUT THE CONSTRUCTION
03:02:25.334 --> 03:02:26.635
COMPANY OWNER. AND I'M WORRIED
03:02:26.702 --> 03:02:27.469
ABOUT THE CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
03:02:27.536 --> 03:02:29.405
OWNER FOR SURE, BUT I'M ALSO
03:02:29.471 --> 03:02:31.006
WORRIED ABOUT THE EMPLOYEES, AND
03:02:31.073 --> 03:02:32.508
IT'S BEEN A LONG STANDING
03:02:32.574 --> 03:02:33.575
POLICY. THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
03:02:33.642 --> 03:02:34.643
IN ANY PUBLIC CONSTRUCTION
03:02:34.710 --> 03:02:39.081
ARENA. TO APPLY A SKILLED AND
03:02:39.148 --> 03:02:40.182
TRAINED WORKFORCE COMPONENT
03:02:40.249 --> 03:02:42.017
BECAUSE IN MY BELIEF, AND I
03:02:42.084 --> 03:02:43.986
THINK STUDIES BEAR THIS OUT, IT
03:02:44.053 --> 03:02:45.154
PRODUCES ULTIMATELY A BETTER
03:02:45.220 --> 03:02:46.522
PROJECT THAT IS ON TIME AND
03:02:46.588 --> 03:02:49.892
OFTEN UNDER BUDGET. SO I'M WE
03:02:49.958 --> 03:02:51.060
CAN HAVE A DIFFERENCE OF OPINION
03:02:51.126 --> 03:02:51.593
THERE BECAUSE MOST OF THE
03:02:51.660 --> 03:02:53.228
CONSTRUCTION COMPANIES THAT I
03:02:53.295 --> 03:02:54.496
KNOW IN THE SCHOOLS THAT ARE
03:02:54.563 --> 03:02:56.065
BUILT. OUR FAMILY IS PART OF
03:02:56.131 --> 03:02:58.033
THAT PART OF IT, SO I KNOW
03:02:58.100 --> 03:03:00.602
FIRSTHAND. DON'T NECESSARILY IS
03:03:00.669 --> 03:03:02.237
NOT NECESSARILY A SKILL, THE
03:03:02.304 --> 03:03:03.706
WORKFORCE IT'S BEEN OPEN TO
03:03:03.772 --> 03:03:06.041
EVERY FAMILY OWNED SMALL
03:03:06.108 --> 03:03:08.043
CONSTRUCTION COMPANY TO BE ABLE
03:03:08.110 --> 03:03:09.278
TO BEAR ON THESE PROJECTS, AND
03:03:09.345 --> 03:03:11.246
ONLY RECENTLY, PROBABLY UM, I
03:03:11.313 --> 03:03:12.815
WOULD SAY IN THE LAST TIME JUST
03:03:12.881 --> 03:03:13.949
GONNA THROW A FIGURE THEY'RE
03:03:14.016 --> 03:03:15.651
ACTUALLY I'M NOT EVEN GONNA
03:03:15.718 --> 03:03:17.319
THROW A FIGURE. THERE YOU FOLKS
03:03:17.386 --> 03:03:20.255
AREN'T LITERALLY EXCLUDING SMALL
03:03:20.322 --> 03:03:21.123
OWNED FAMILY OWNED COMPANIES
03:03:21.190 --> 03:03:22.858
FROM BE ABLE TO DO THESE
03:03:22.925 --> 03:03:25.361
PROJECTS. I TAKE THAT PERSONALLY
03:03:25.427 --> 03:03:26.528
, I UNDERSTAND. AND I WOULD
03:03:26.595 --> 03:03:28.464
ACTUALLY MY COMMENT TO THAT. WE
03:03:28.530 --> 03:03:30.532
I THINK WE'RE INCLUDING UH,
03:03:30.599 --> 03:03:31.100
WE'RE INCLUDING MORE
03:03:31.166 --> 03:03:32.668
CALIFORNIANS WERE GIVING THEM
03:03:32.735 --> 03:03:33.502
OPPORTUNITY TO CLIMB INTO THE
03:03:33.569 --> 03:03:35.170
MIDDLE CLASS TO TRAIN THEM IN
03:03:35.237 --> 03:03:35.938
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS, AND I
03:03:36.004 --> 03:03:38.173
THINK THAT'S A GOOD THING. AND
03:03:38.240 --> 03:03:38.774
ULTIMATELY THAT'S THE POLICY
03:03:38.841 --> 03:03:40.309
THAT KEEPS GIVING A STRONGER
03:03:40.376 --> 03:03:41.410
MIDDLE CLASS MEANS A STRONGER
03:03:41.477 --> 03:03:43.245
CALIFORNIA. AND THAT'S WHAT THE
03:03:43.312 --> 03:03:44.179
STILLMAN SKILLED AND TRAINED
03:03:44.246 --> 03:03:45.914
WORKFORCE COMPONENT IN THIS BILL
03:03:45.981 --> 03:03:48.183
SPEAKS TO IN MY AND THANK YOU
03:03:48.250 --> 03:03:49.518
FOR SHARING THAT AND I'M JUST
03:03:49.585 --> 03:03:51.120
GONNA SHARE THROUGH THE CHAIR.
03:03:51.186 --> 03:03:52.554
ALL OF THIS HAS BEEN THROUGH THE
03:03:52.621 --> 03:03:54.156
CHAIR, AND I'LL JUST REMIND
03:03:54.223 --> 03:03:55.791
FOLKS THAT WERE KICKED OUT AT 1
03:03:55.858 --> 03:03:57.059
40. IF WE DON'T FINISH, WE HAVE
03:03:57.126 --> 03:03:59.228
TO COME BACK AFTER THEY FINISHED
03:03:59.294 --> 03:04:00.929
IN LABOR. OKAY, UM SO I JUST I
03:04:00.996 --> 03:04:03.732
JUST WANNA I JUST WANT EVERYONE
03:04:03.799 --> 03:04:05.234
DO REALLY CONSIDER THE POLICIES
03:04:05.300 --> 03:04:06.902
THAT WERE MAKING AND WHAT IS
03:04:06.969 --> 03:04:08.003
DOING THAT WHAT IT'S AND HOW
03:04:08.070 --> 03:04:09.271
IT'S AFFECTING AND IMPACTING
03:04:09.338 --> 03:04:12.474
MANY. NOT JUST THE OWNERS, BUT
03:04:12.541 --> 03:04:15.110
THE EMPLOYEE IS A BIG THAT THEY
03:04:15.177 --> 03:04:17.246
UNDERSTOOD. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
03:04:17.312 --> 03:04:18.747
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
03:04:18.814 --> 03:04:19.782
SEEING NONE. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
03:04:19.848 --> 03:04:21.817
CLOSE? I JUST ASKED FOR AN I
03:04:21.884 --> 03:04:23.051
VOTE, MADAM CHAIR AND THANK YOU
03:04:23.118 --> 03:04:24.820
FOR THE CONVERSATION. THANK YOU
03:04:24.887 --> 03:04:25.754
VERY MUCH IS THE BILL MOVED THE
03:04:25.821 --> 03:04:27.623
BILL HAS BEEN MOVED BY SENATOR
03:04:27.689 --> 03:04:28.690
PAN MADAM ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL
03:04:28.757 --> 03:04:31.794
THE ROLL. FILE ITEM 16 89 02.
03:04:31.860 --> 03:04:33.495
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS, BUT
03:04:33.562 --> 03:04:34.897
FIRST THEY RE REFERRED TO THE
03:04:34.963 --> 03:04:36.565
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:04:36.632 --> 03:04:37.266
LIVER EVER. I KNOW BUG JOE
03:04:37.332 --> 03:04:40.002
BUGNER, CORTEZ. ORTEZ EI DOLLY!
03:04:40.068 --> 03:04:47.276
GLASER. MAGUIRE CAN CAN I THANK
03:04:47.342 --> 03:04:48.143
YOU. SIMON MEMBER O'DONNELL WILL
03:04:48.210 --> 03:04:50.245
EAT THAT ON CALL FOR ABSENT
03:04:50.312 --> 03:04:51.046
MEMBERS. THANK YOU FOR KEEPING
03:04:51.113 --> 03:04:53.348
ME ON MY TOES. MADAM I'M HERE TO
03:04:53.415 --> 03:04:54.750
HELP YOU HAVE A GOOD REST TODAY
03:04:54.817 --> 03:04:56.118
. ALRIGHT ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S IRWIN
03:04:56.185 --> 03:04:57.352
. THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE.
03:04:57.419 --> 03:05:00.122
I'M SORRY WE HAD TO ASK YOU TO
03:05:00.189 --> 03:05:01.957
COME BACK. YOU ARE HERE TO
03:05:02.024 --> 03:05:03.992
PRESENT A B 11 87 BEGIN WHEN
03:05:04.059 --> 03:05:06.028
YOU'RE READY. ALL RIGHT. THANK
03:05:06.094 --> 03:05:07.129
YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND COMMITTEE
03:05:07.196 --> 03:05:10.365
MEMBERS. A B 11 87 WILL INCREASE
03:05:10.432 --> 03:05:13.001
ACCESS TO SUPERVISE TUTORING AT
03:05:13.068 --> 03:05:14.203
THE CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
03:05:14.269 --> 03:05:15.237
COLLEGES BY AUTHORIZING COLLEGES
03:05:15.304 --> 03:05:18.307
TO CLAIM APPORTIONMENT. FOR
03:05:18.373 --> 03:05:19.808
STUDENTS RECEIVING ASSISTANCE IN
03:05:19.875 --> 03:05:21.410
CREDENTIAL OR DEGREE APPLICABLE
03:05:21.477 --> 03:05:24.379
AND TRANSFER LEVEL COURSES.
03:05:24.446 --> 03:05:26.782
CURRENT LAW ALLOWS COLLEGES TO
03:05:26.849 --> 03:05:28.350
CLAIM APPORTIONMENT FUNDING FOR
03:05:28.417 --> 03:05:30.452
SUPERVISED TUTORING AND NON
03:05:30.519 --> 03:05:33.388
CREDIT BASIC SKILLS COURSES, BUT
03:05:33.455 --> 03:05:34.923
NOT FOR CREDIT BEARING TRANSFER
03:05:34.990 --> 03:05:36.291
LEVEL COURSES AS COLLEGES
03:05:36.358 --> 03:05:37.459
CONTINUE TO PLACE MORE STUDENTS
03:05:37.526 --> 03:05:39.328
DIRECTLY. INTO TRANSFER LEVEL
03:05:39.394 --> 03:05:41.363
COURSES TO COMPLY WITH A B 705
03:05:41.430 --> 03:05:43.732
SUPERVISED TUTORING REPRESENTS
03:05:43.799 --> 03:05:45.400
ONE IMPORTANT TOOL TO ENSURE
03:05:45.467 --> 03:05:46.835
THAT STUDENTS ARE SUCCESSFUL BUT
03:05:46.902 --> 03:05:49.838
DOES NOT REPLACE OTHER FORMS OF
03:05:49.905 --> 03:05:51.273
CO REQUISITE OR CONCURRENT
03:05:51.340 --> 03:05:52.841
SUPPORTS BY ALLOWING COLLEGES TO
03:05:52.908 --> 03:05:54.409
CLAIM CLAIM APPORTIONMENT FOR
03:05:54.476 --> 03:05:55.544
STUDENTS ENROLLED IN SUPERVISED
03:05:55.611 --> 03:05:57.813
TUTORING. A B 11 87 WILL
03:05:57.880 --> 03:06:00.315
INCREASE LONG TERM STABILITY AND
03:06:00.382 --> 03:06:01.817
INVESTMENT IN TUTORING CENTERS
03:06:01.884 --> 03:06:03.118
WITH ME TODAY IS DR LEBARON
03:06:03.185 --> 03:06:07.789
WOODYARD. WOODYARD DEAN OF
03:06:07.856 --> 03:06:09.224
ACADEMIC AFFAIRS AT THE
03:06:09.291 --> 03:06:10.759
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES,
03:06:10.826 --> 03:06:13.128
UH, CHANCELLOR'S OFFICE, AND
03:06:13.195 --> 03:06:14.696
CASEY GARDNER, VICE PRESIDENT OF
03:06:14.763 --> 03:06:15.631
INSTRUCTION AT WOODLAND
03:06:15.697 --> 03:06:16.598
COMMUNITY COLLEGE. THANK YOU,
03:06:16.665 --> 03:06:19.434
ASSEMBLYWOMAN. ARE YOU AS ONE OF
03:06:19.501 --> 03:06:23.539
THEM IN PERSON? OKAY VERY GOOD.
03:06:23.605 --> 03:06:25.107
WELL, PLEASE COME FORWARD. YOU
03:06:25.173 --> 03:06:27.142
WILL GO TO YOU FIRST. AND THEN
03:06:27.209 --> 03:06:28.443
WE'LL GO TO OUR PHONE LINES. YOU
03:06:28.510 --> 03:06:29.478
HAVE TWO MINUTES. PLEASE
03:06:29.545 --> 03:06:30.712
PROCEED. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:06:30.779 --> 03:06:31.513
COMMITTEE CHAIR, SENATOR LEYVA
03:06:31.580 --> 03:06:33.015
AND HONORABLE COMMITTEE MEMBERS
03:06:33.081 --> 03:06:34.082
. MY NAME IS CASEY GARDENER. I
03:06:34.149 --> 03:06:36.051
SERVED AS THE VICE PRESIDENT
03:06:36.118 --> 03:06:36.552
INSTRUCTION AT WOODLAND
03:06:36.618 --> 03:06:37.119
COMMUNITY COLLEGE, AND I'M
03:06:37.185 --> 03:06:39.054
GRATEFUL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
03:06:39.121 --> 03:06:41.623
TALK ABOUT A B 11 87. SO WAS WE
03:06:41.690 --> 03:06:43.158
ALREADY HEARD ABOUT THE
03:06:43.225 --> 03:06:44.526
DEFINITION OF SUPERVISED
03:06:44.593 --> 03:06:45.994
TUTORING, INCLUDING THE PEER
03:06:46.061 --> 03:06:47.195
TUTORING, EMBEDDED TUTORS? I
03:06:47.262 --> 03:06:49.031
WANTED TO REPORT TO YOU THAT
03:06:49.097 --> 03:06:49.765
WOODLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE WHERE
03:06:49.831 --> 03:06:51.033
I WORK, STUDENTS WHO USE
03:06:51.099 --> 03:06:52.367
TUTORING, AVERAGE AND ENTIRE
03:06:52.434 --> 03:06:53.569
LETTER GRADE HIGHER AND ARE MORE
03:06:53.635 --> 03:06:55.470
LIKELY TO PASS THEIR COURSES.
03:06:55.537 --> 03:06:57.105
TUTORING IS ALSO AN EQUITY
03:06:57.172 --> 03:06:59.508
FRIENDLY PRACTICE OF 77% OF OUR
03:06:59.575 --> 03:07:00.709
TUTORING STUDENTS. THESE ARE
03:07:00.776 --> 03:07:01.743
STUDENTS RECEIVING TUTORING,
03:07:01.810 --> 03:07:04.379
ALTHOUGH MANY WORK AS TUTORS UM
03:07:04.446 --> 03:07:05.881
, IDENTIFY AS FIRST GENERATION
03:07:05.948 --> 03:07:09.017
81% AS LOW INCOME AND 83% FROM
03:07:09.084 --> 03:07:09.985
DISPROPORTIONATELY IMPACTED
03:07:10.052 --> 03:07:12.054
RACIAL ETHNIC GROUPS. SO IT IS A
03:07:12.120 --> 03:07:13.255
TOOL FOR EQUITY IN OUR SYSTEM.
03:07:13.322 --> 03:07:15.724
THE BILL WOULD INCLUDE DEGREE
03:07:15.791 --> 03:07:16.491
APPLICABLE AND TRANSFER COURSES
03:07:16.558 --> 03:07:18.126
AS YOU KNOW, AND REALLY
03:07:18.193 --> 03:07:19.261
ACCOMPLISHED THREE GOALS. FIRST
03:07:19.328 --> 03:07:20.429
COLLEGES WILL BE PROVIDED WITH A
03:07:20.495 --> 03:07:21.830
RELIABLE FINANCIAL INCENTIVE TO
03:07:21.897 --> 03:07:23.765
PROVIDE THE SERVICE. SECOND
03:07:23.832 --> 03:07:24.933
COLLEGES BE ABLE TO BETTER
03:07:25.000 --> 03:07:26.335
SUPPORT STUDENT SUCCESS IN ALL
03:07:26.401 --> 03:07:28.070
COURSES, SO NOT JUST BASIC
03:07:28.136 --> 03:07:29.237
SKILLS OR NON CREDIT COURSES.
03:07:29.304 --> 03:07:31.540
BUT PARTICULARLY MATH AND
03:07:31.607 --> 03:07:32.608
ENGLISH, WHERE WE'RE ALWAYS
03:07:32.674 --> 03:07:33.642
LOOKING FOR NEW STRATEGIES
03:07:33.709 --> 03:07:35.377
SUPPORT STUDENTS. AND FINALLY
03:07:35.444 --> 03:07:36.945
BETTER COURSE SUCCESS RATES DUE
03:07:37.012 --> 03:07:39.014
TO THE TUTORING COULD LEAD TO
03:07:39.081 --> 03:07:40.048
SHORTER COMPLETION TIME FOR
03:07:40.115 --> 03:07:41.116
STUDENTS AND ULTIMATELY SAVE
03:07:41.183 --> 03:07:42.150
TAXPAYERS MONEY ON COURSE,
03:07:42.217 --> 03:07:44.486
REPETITION. SO ULTIMATELY THIS
03:07:44.553 --> 03:07:46.154
PORTION IT WOULD ALLOW COLLEGES
03:07:46.221 --> 03:07:47.589
TO BE IN THE POSITION OF MAKING
03:07:47.656 --> 03:07:49.024
MORE SECURE FUNDING DECISIONS
03:07:49.091 --> 03:07:50.058
AROUND HOW WE SUPPORT TUTORING
03:07:50.125 --> 03:07:52.027
CENTERS AND HOPEFULLY MOVE OUR
03:07:52.094 --> 03:07:53.095
STAFF FROM BEING THOSE OF A
03:07:53.161 --> 03:07:54.396
SHORT TERM OR TEMPORARY NATURE
03:07:54.463 --> 03:07:56.398
INTO PERMANENT FULL TIME STATUS.
03:07:56.465 --> 03:07:57.566
THANK YOU. VERY GOOD. THANK YOU
03:07:57.633 --> 03:07:59.368
VERY MUCH. ALRIGHT MR MODERATOR
03:07:59.434 --> 03:08:00.602
, PLEASE QUEUE UP. CASEY,
03:08:00.669 --> 03:08:01.670
GARDENER, MR. GARDNER, YOU HAVE
03:08:01.737 --> 03:08:05.874
TWO MINUTES. TALK TO GO AHEAD,
03:08:05.941 --> 03:08:07.976
DOCTOR, YOU WERE CASEY. I AM SO
03:08:08.043 --> 03:08:09.211
SORRY. DOCTOR. WOODYARD, PLEASE.
03:08:09.277 --> 03:08:13.081
YOU HAVE TWO MINUTES. YES. GOOD
03:08:13.148 --> 03:08:14.049
AFTERNOON, CHAIRWOMAN. LABOR AND
03:08:14.116 --> 03:08:16.918
MEMBERS OF THE SENATE EDUCATION
03:08:16.985 --> 03:08:18.987
COMMITTEE. MY NAME IS DR LEBARON
03:08:19.054 --> 03:08:21.156
WOULD YOU'RE NOT ONLY BEING A
03:08:21.223 --> 03:08:22.357
REGULAR FARES FOR THE CALIFORNIA
03:08:22.424 --> 03:08:24.292
COMMUNITY COLLEGES. I'M PLEASED
03:08:24.359 --> 03:08:25.627
TO BE HERE TODAY TO TESTIFY,
03:08:25.694 --> 03:08:28.397
SUPPORTIVE BABY 11 87. IN 2017,
03:08:28.463 --> 03:08:29.931
CALIFORNIA LAWMAKERS TOOK
03:08:29.998 --> 03:08:31.900
HISTORIC ACTION TO ELIMINATE
03:08:31.967 --> 03:08:33.468
LONGSTANDING INEQUITIES AND
03:08:33.535 --> 03:08:34.836
STUDENT ACCESS TO TRANSFER LEVEL
03:08:34.903 --> 03:08:36.004
ENGLISH AND MATH COURSES BY
03:08:36.071 --> 03:08:39.541
ADOPTING SOME OF THE BILLS. 705
03:08:39.608 --> 03:08:40.809
UNFORTUNATELY, CURRENT LAW
03:08:40.876 --> 03:08:41.810
RESTRICTS APPORTIONMENT CONICAL,
03:08:41.877 --> 03:08:44.946
SUPERVISED ONLY TO DISSOLVE. TO
03:08:45.013 --> 03:08:45.914
SUPPORT STUDENTS ENROLLED WITHIN
03:08:45.981 --> 03:08:48.984
BASIC SKILLS OF REMEDIAL COURSE.
03:08:49.051 --> 03:08:49.985
LIMITATION MEANS THAT COLLEGES
03:08:50.052 --> 03:08:53.388
DO NOT HAVE SUNDAY. C<c.cyan> ABOUT</c>
03:08:53.455 --> 03:08:54.389
SUPERVISED STUDENTS FOR CREDIT
03:08:54.456 --> 03:08:58.360
BEARING COURSES. UNDER 87. OH,
03:08:58.427 --> 03:08:59.361
FIVE MINUTES TUESDAY, NINE
03:08:59.428 --> 03:09:00.362
ROLLING AND TRANSFER LEVEL
03:09:00.429 --> 03:09:03.231
COURSES. IN THE SPIRIT OF MAYBE
03:09:03.298 --> 03:09:04.366
705. WE MUST ENSURE THESE THINGS
03:09:04.433 --> 03:09:05.400
RECEIVED APPROPRIATE ACADEMIC
03:09:05.467 --> 03:09:08.737
SUPPORT. SUPERVISED TUNAS AND
03:09:08.804 --> 03:09:10.472
METHOD OF INSTRUCTION THAT
03:09:10.539 --> 03:09:11.640
INVOLVES STUDENT TUTORS WHO WAS
03:09:11.707 --> 03:09:13.742
SUCCESSFUL IN A PARTICULAR SET.
03:09:13.809 --> 03:09:14.743
I RECEIVED AN ADDITIONAL
03:09:14.810 --> 03:09:15.744
ACADEMIC SUPPORT FROM THEIR
03:09:15.811 --> 03:09:17.813
PEERS. TO THE STUDENTS ARE MORE
03:09:17.879 --> 03:09:20.115
LIKELY TO OUR PARTICULAR AND
03:09:20.182 --> 03:09:22.250
REACH THEIR EDUCATIONAL GOALS.
03:09:22.317 --> 03:09:24.152
IT'S STILL AESTHETIC CONDUCTED
03:09:24.219 --> 03:09:25.520
BY THE CHANCES OF THIS TOWN THAT
03:09:25.587 --> 03:09:27.522
THE COURT SUCCESSFULLY BECAUSE
03:09:27.589 --> 03:09:28.623
TUNES WHO RECEIVED CHILDREN IN
03:09:28.690 --> 03:09:30.726
BASIC SKILLS, ENGLISH AND MATH
03:09:30.792 --> 03:09:32.127
WAS ON AVERAGE 8% HIGHER
03:09:32.194 --> 03:09:34.029
COMPARED TO STUDENTS WHO DID NOT
03:09:34.096 --> 03:09:36.865
RECEIVE T. ANOTHER LONGITUDINAL
03:09:36.932 --> 03:09:38.734
STUDY BODY COLLEGE TO THE CANYON
03:09:38.800 --> 03:09:41.670
FOUND THAT BETWEEN 2014 AND 2018
03:09:41.737 --> 03:09:43.004
STUDENTS WHO PARTICIPATED IN TWO
03:09:43.071 --> 03:09:44.906
AND HAD HIGHER COURT SUCCESS AND
03:09:44.973 --> 03:09:47.075
RETENTION RATE. COMPARED TO
03:09:47.142 --> 03:09:48.043
STUDENTS WHO DID NOT REGARDLESS
03:09:48.110 --> 03:09:49.911
OF THE AMOUNT OF TUTORING THAT
03:09:49.978 --> 03:09:52.614
THEY RECEIVE. MAYBE 11 87 WOULD
03:09:52.681 --> 03:09:54.483
REMOVE THIS RESTRICTION AND LOCK
03:09:54.549 --> 03:09:55.484
COLLEGES CLAIMED SUPERVISE
03:09:55.550 --> 03:09:57.552
STORY. APPORTIONMENT FUNDING FOR
03:09:57.619 --> 03:09:58.653
ALL QUESTIONS, ENABLING MORE
03:09:58.720 --> 03:10:00.856
STUDENTS TO BE SUCCESSFUL. THIS
03:10:00.922 --> 03:10:02.958
WILL RESULT IN HIGH STUDENT
03:10:03.024 --> 03:10:03.892
COURSE COMPLETION AND SUCCESS
03:10:03.959 --> 03:10:05.627
RATE. LAUREN TIME 2 DEGREES
03:10:05.694 --> 03:10:07.629
CERTIFICATE IN TRANSFER. MAYBE
03:10:07.696 --> 03:10:10.132
11 7 80 11 87 IS CONSISTENT WITH
03:10:10.198 --> 03:10:13.368
THE PARADIGM. ESTABLISH AN ABC
03:10:13.435 --> 03:10:15.871
705 JUST FEEL WILL PROVIDE
03:10:15.937 --> 03:10:17.272
COLLEGES FLEXIBILITY TO ADOPT
03:10:17.339 --> 03:10:18.340
INNOVATIVE BLENDED STRATEGY
03:10:18.406 --> 03:10:20.742
ENSURE T<c.cyan> GATEWAY COURSES ON THE</c>
03:10:20.809 --> 03:10:23.645
FIRST TRY. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
03:10:23.712 --> 03:10:25.881
TIME WITH ANSWER ANY QUESTION.
03:10:25.947 --> 03:10:27.616
THANK YOU, DOCTOR. WOODYARD WE
03:10:27.682 --> 03:10:28.984
WILL NOW GO TO ANYONE HERE IN
03:10:29.050 --> 03:10:30.819
2100, WHO WISHES TO TESTIFY AND
03:10:30.886 --> 03:10:34.689
SUPPORT. STEPHANIE GOLDMAN ON
03:10:34.756 --> 03:10:35.791
BEHALF OF THE FACULTY
03:10:35.857 --> 03:10:36.792
ASSOCIATION OF CALIFORNIA
03:10:36.858 --> 03:10:37.759
COMMUNITY COLLEGES AND SUPPORT
03:10:37.826 --> 03:10:41.496
THANK YOU. SPACE BATTLES WALTON
03:10:41.563 --> 03:10:43.131
, DIRECTOR OF PIRATE OF HIGHER
03:10:43.198 --> 03:10:44.166
EDUCATION AND PUBLIC ADVOCATES,
03:10:44.232 --> 03:10:46.268
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF A B 11 87.
03:10:46.334 --> 03:10:49.004
THANK YOU. WE'LL NOW GO TO OUR
03:10:49.070 --> 03:10:49.971
PHONE LINES. MR MODERATOR, CAN
03:10:50.038 --> 03:10:52.007
YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP ANYONE WHO
03:10:52.073 --> 03:10:53.275
WISHES TO TESTIFY AND SUPPORT OF
03:10:53.341 --> 03:10:57.279
A B 11 87? THANK YOU VERY MUCH
03:10:57.345 --> 03:11:00.248
IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT OF A B 11
03:11:00.315 --> 03:11:01.416
87 PLEASE PRESS 101 FOULED BY
03:11:01.483 --> 03:11:06.254
0109. PLEASE GO AHEAD. HI GOOD
03:11:06.321 --> 03:11:07.189
AFTERNOON, CAROL GONZALEZ ON
03:11:07.255 --> 03:11:08.690
BEHALF OF LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY
03:11:08.757 --> 03:11:10.892
COLLEGE DISTRICT AND PASADENA
03:11:10.959 --> 03:11:12.227
CITY COLLEGE IN SUPPORT OF BABY
03:11:12.294 --> 03:11:17.232
11 87 QUÊ. THANK YOU. NEXT WE'LL
03:11:17.299 --> 03:11:21.503
GO TO LINE 1 12, YOU ARE OPEN.
03:11:21.570 --> 03:11:23.738
GOOD AFTERNOON, AND ALBARADO AND
03:11:23.805 --> 03:11:24.906
HE HAS TO CALIFORNIA EDGE
03:11:24.973 --> 03:11:28.844
COALITION AND STRONG SUPPORT.
03:11:28.910 --> 03:11:33.748
102, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:11:33.815 --> 03:11:35.183
AFTERNOON. THIS IS SAVANNAH
03:11:35.250 --> 03:11:35.984
MENDOZA ON BEHALF OF THE
03:11:36.051 --> 03:11:37.152
CAMPAIGN FOR COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY
03:11:37.219 --> 03:11:38.854
AND STRONG SUPPORT OF 11 87.
03:11:38.920 --> 03:11:42.557
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. GET ONE
03:11:42.624 --> 03:11:43.758
FINAL REMINDER FOR SUPPORT ON A
03:11:43.825 --> 03:11:46.995
B 11 87. PLEASE. PRESS 101 13,
03:11:47.062 --> 03:11:50.999
PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:11:51.066 --> 03:11:51.967
, RYAN MCELHENNEY WITH THE
03:11:52.033 --> 03:11:53.902
COMMUNITY HEALTHY CALIFORNIA IN
03:11:53.969 --> 03:11:57.873
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:11:57.939 --> 03:11:59.407
ADAM SHARE THEIR NO OTHER
03:11:59.474 --> 03:12:01.042
PARTICIPANTS QUEUED UP. THANK
03:12:01.109 --> 03:12:02.811
YOU VERY MUCH. JUST WHAT I SAID
03:12:02.878 --> 03:12:05.013
THAT WE DO HAVE ONE QUEUING UP
03:12:05.080 --> 03:12:05.914
ONE MOMENT, PLEASE PROBLEM. JUST
03:12:05.981 --> 03:12:07.148
CUTE UP THERE WITH THE OPERATING
03:12:07.215 --> 03:12:16.858
ONE MOMENT. AND WE'LL GO TO LINE
03:12:16.925 --> 03:12:19.227
ONE. OH, FOUR. YOU ARE OPEN.
03:12:19.294 --> 03:12:21.696
THANK YOU, MADAM CHAIR AND
03:12:21.763 --> 03:12:23.732
MEMBERS MARK MCDONALD ON BEHALF
03:12:23.798 --> 03:12:25.500
OF THE CONTRA COSTA THAT TURN
03:12:25.567 --> 03:12:27.736
FOR ALL THE SAN BERNARDINO, SAN
03:12:27.802 --> 03:12:28.937
DIEGO, AND YOU BOUGHT COMMUNITY
03:12:29.004 --> 03:12:29.838
COLLEGE DISTRICTS ALL IN
03:12:29.905 --> 03:12:35.277
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
03:12:35.343 --> 03:12:36.711
AND THERE ARE NO OTHER
03:12:36.778 --> 03:12:38.246
PARTICIPANTS QUEUED UP THIS TIME
03:12:38.313 --> 03:12:39.748
. THANK YOU, MR MODERATOR. WE
03:12:39.814 --> 03:12:41.483
HAVE NO LEAD OPPOSITION. IS
03:12:41.549 --> 03:12:43.118
THERE ANYONE HERE IN 2100? WHO
03:12:43.184 --> 03:12:45.287
WISHES TO OPPOSE SEEING NO ONE.
03:12:45.353 --> 03:12:46.588
MR. MODERATOR, PLEASE KEEP
03:12:46.655 --> 03:12:47.989
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO OPPOSE
03:12:48.056 --> 03:12:51.860
MAYBE 11 87. IF YOU'RE NOT
03:12:51.927 --> 03:12:53.895
POSITION TO A B 11 87, PLEASE
03:12:53.962 --> 03:12:55.030
TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY AND PRESS
03:12:55.096 --> 03:13:01.803
ONE, FOLLOWED BY ZERO. NOBODY IS
03:13:01.870 --> 03:13:03.571
QUEUING UP AT THIS TIME. THANK
03:13:03.638 --> 03:13:04.773
YOU. MR MODERATOR WILL BRING IT
03:13:04.839 --> 03:13:05.974
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE FOR
03:13:06.041 --> 03:13:07.309
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS OR CONCERNS.
03:13:07.375 --> 03:13:09.277
SEEING NONE. DO WE HAVE A
03:13:09.344 --> 03:13:12.414
MOTION? SO MOVE. THANK YOU.
03:13:12.480 --> 03:13:13.982
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE? I JUST
03:13:14.049 --> 03:13:16.384
WANT TO SAY THAT 87 05 HAS BEEN
03:13:16.451 --> 03:13:17.886
TRANSFORMATIONAL FOR OUR
03:13:17.953 --> 03:13:20.121
COMMUNITY COLLEGE STUDENTS AND
03:13:20.188 --> 03:13:20.956
THIS ADDITIONAL TUTORING FOR
03:13:21.022 --> 03:13:23.491
THOSE STUDENTS THAT GO DIRECTLY
03:13:23.558 --> 03:13:26.861
INTO TRANSFER LEVEL WILL HELP US
03:13:26.928 --> 03:13:30.532
, UH GAIN EVEN MORE SUCCESS FOR
03:13:30.598 --> 03:13:32.267
THE STUDENTS THAT NEED A LITTLE
03:13:32.334 --> 03:13:33.635
EXTRA PUSH, SO I WOULD
03:13:33.702 --> 03:13:34.869
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT. THANK
03:13:34.936 --> 03:13:36.905
YOU VERY MUCH, ASSEMBLYWOMAN.
03:13:36.972 --> 03:13:38.540
THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED BY
03:13:38.606 --> 03:13:39.007
SENATOR CORTEZ MINIMUM
03:13:39.074 --> 03:13:41.710
ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
03:13:41.776 --> 03:13:44.980
VIOLET AND 17 A B 11 87. THE
03:13:45.046 --> 03:13:47.182
MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
03:13:47.248 --> 03:13:48.650
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:13:48.717 --> 03:13:49.751
APPROPRIATIONS LIVER, BUT I KNOW
03:13:49.818 --> 03:13:52.620
BUG JOBURG COURTESY. TESSIE I
03:13:52.687 --> 03:13:58.727
DELI. GLASER MCGUIRE PAN. THANK
03:13:58.793 --> 03:14:00.362
YOU. WE'LL LEAVE THAT ON CALL
03:14:00.428 --> 03:14:01.563
FOR OTHER MEMBERS. THANK YOU,
03:14:01.629 --> 03:14:04.499
ASSEMBLYWOMAN. ALRIGHT WE JUST
03:14:04.566 --> 03:14:07.769
WE HAVE ABOUT EIGHT MINUTES.
03:14:07.836 --> 03:14:08.937
REALLY MR JONES. SAWYER MAKES IT
03:14:09.004 --> 03:14:14.909
IN TIME. YES LET'S DO THAT.
03:14:14.976 --> 03:14:15.944
LET'S LIFT THE CLOUD THINGS. I
03:14:16.011 --> 03:14:16.945
DON'T THINK YOU'VE MISSED ANY
03:14:17.012 --> 03:14:19.114
VOTES. SARAH 12. OH IS THAT
03:14:19.180 --> 03:14:20.315
RIGHT? OKAY, SO LET'S LIFT THE
03:14:20.382 --> 03:14:22.350
CALL FOR SENATOR CORTEZ. CONSENT
03:14:22.417 --> 03:14:25.086
CALENDAR. CORTEZ E. PRETTY AS
03:14:25.153 --> 03:14:35.463
THE AYE. MCGUIRE. THANK YOU.
03:14:35.530 --> 03:14:37.032
SIX. SO IT'S OUT BECAUSE, OKAY,
03:14:37.098 --> 03:14:38.099
VERY GOOD CALENDAR HAS BEEN
03:14:38.166 --> 03:14:42.937
ADOPTED. YEAH LET'S GO AHEAD AND
03:14:43.004 --> 03:14:47.208
LIFT THE CALLS. YEAH. LET'S JUST
03:14:47.275 --> 03:14:50.045
RUN THROUGH UP, OKAY? FILE ITEM
03:14:50.111 --> 03:14:54.382
TO A B 2 88. THE CHAIR IS VOTING
03:14:54.449 --> 03:14:56.317
. I BUY SHARE VOTING I. THE
03:14:56.384 --> 03:14:58.153
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST BE
03:14:58.219 --> 03:14:59.320
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:14:59.387 --> 03:15:00.355
APPROPRIATIONS. CORTEZ E.
03:15:00.422 --> 03:15:03.358
CRITICALLY. I MCGUIRE GOT 60.
03:15:03.425 --> 03:15:13.101
BILLS OUT 60. MOVING ON A FILE
03:15:13.168 --> 03:15:16.771
ITEM. 5 84 52. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:15:16.838 --> 03:15:17.872
PAST BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
03:15:17.939 --> 03:15:19.074
THE COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY CHAIR
03:15:19.140 --> 03:15:20.608
VOTING. I'VE BEISTER VOTING I.
03:15:20.675 --> 03:15:25.380
CORTEZ E. TO THE EYE. MCGUIRE.
03:15:25.447 --> 03:15:32.287
THANK YOU. MCGUIRE SAYS HE'S
03:15:32.353 --> 03:15:46.234
COMING BACK.
03:15:46.301 --> 03:15:51.005
ITEM 9 85 95. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:15:51.072 --> 03:15:52.874
PASSES AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND
03:15:52.941 --> 03:15:54.242
AND RE REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE
03:15:54.309 --> 03:15:55.810
ON APPROPRIATIONS THE CHAIR
03:15:55.877 --> 03:15:57.479
VOTING I'VE VICE CHAIR VOTING I.
03:15:57.545 --> 03:15:59.981
CORTEZ E. TO THE EYE, DOLLY!
03:16:00.048 --> 03:16:11.826
GLASER MCGUIRE THINK. FILE ITEM
03:16:11.893 --> 03:16:14.863
10 A B 16 52. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:16:14.929 --> 03:16:17.031
PASS BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO
03:16:17.098 --> 03:16:18.099
THE COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND
03:16:18.166 --> 03:16:19.467
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS. CHAIR
03:16:19.534 --> 03:16:20.602
VOTING. I ADVISED HER VOTING I
03:16:20.668 --> 03:16:22.403
CORTEZ E. TO THE EYE DELI.
03:16:22.470 --> 03:16:33.882
CHOIR. THAT'S. FILE ITEM 11 A JR
03:16:33.948 --> 03:16:36.117
26. THE MOTION IS DUE PASSES
03:16:36.184 --> 03:16:37.685
AMENDED CHAIR, PUTTING I VICE
03:16:37.752 --> 03:16:39.420
CHAIR VOTING I. CORTEZ E. TO THE
03:16:39.487 --> 03:16:52.534
EYE. MM. THANK YOU. I WOULD TELL
03:16:52.600 --> 03:16:53.535
YOU THAT TAKE OFF FOR YOUR
03:16:53.601 --> 03:16:55.236
COMMITTEE, BUT I'M IN YOUR
03:16:55.303 --> 03:17:11.486
CHAIR. YEAH.
03:20:04.025 --> 03:20:05.093
PLEASE EXCUSE ME, MADAM CHAIR
03:20:05.159 --> 03:20:06.227
DOES THAT WRAP UP THE FIRST
03:20:06.294 --> 03:20:08.663
SESSION? NOT QUITE YET, MR ROD
03:20:08.730 --> 03:20:10.098
AERATOR. THANK YOU FOR YOUR
03:20:10.164 --> 03:20:12.500
PATIENCE. WE'RE KIND OF JUST
03:20:12.567 --> 03:20:14.168
OKAY. THANK YOU. AND YOU'VE BEEN
03:20:14.235 --> 03:20:15.036
A GREAT MODERATOR TODAY. THANK
03:20:15.103 --> 03:20:17.171
YOU. I APPRECIATE IT, AND I WAS
03:20:17.238 --> 03:20:18.573
JUST MAKING SURE THAT WE YOU
03:20:18.639 --> 03:20:19.774
KNOW I'M IN THERE WITH YOU.
03:20:19.841 --> 03:20:22.243
WHILE TO MAKE SURE THANKS A LOT.
03:20:22.310 --> 03:20:27.982
THANK YOU. OKAY LET'S LIFT THE
03:20:28.049 --> 03:20:31.953
CALL. AH MADAME ASSISTANT SO WE
03:20:32.019 --> 03:20:33.988
CAN TAKE MR MR MOORE. MAGUIRE
03:20:34.055 --> 03:20:35.723
CAN VOTE. OKAY, WE'RE GONNA
03:20:35.790 --> 03:20:39.227
START WITH FILE ITEM FIVE. 84 52
03:20:39.293 --> 03:20:41.362
. THE MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT
03:20:41.429 --> 03:20:42.430
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
03:20:42.497 --> 03:20:43.965
COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY. CHAIR.
03:20:44.031 --> 03:20:45.733
VOTING I VICE CHAIR VOTING. I
03:20:45.800 --> 03:20:49.937
MCGUIRE WHERE I 600 THAT BILL IS
03:20:50.004 --> 03:20:56.744
OUT. OKAY? FILE ITEM 6 85 24.
03:20:56.811 --> 03:20:58.946
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS, BUT
03:20:59.013 --> 03:21:00.481
FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
03:21:00.548 --> 03:21:01.449
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:21:01.516 --> 03:21:03.084
CHAIR. VOTING I VICE CHAIR
03:21:03.151 --> 03:21:04.452
VOTING I MCGUIRE REQUIRE. AYE.
03:21:04.519 --> 03:21:11.659
70 THEY HAVE. HOW MANY DID WE
03:21:11.726 --> 03:21:14.962
HAVE? THAT BILL IS OUT, OKAY?
03:21:15.029 --> 03:21:18.833
FILE ITEM 8 85 5 TO THE MOTION
03:21:18.900 --> 03:21:20.334
IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
03:21:20.401 --> 03:21:21.602
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:21:21.669 --> 03:21:22.904
HEALTH CARE. VOTING I VICE CHAIR
03:21:22.970 --> 03:21:25.072
VOTING I MCGUIRE REQUIRE I THAT
03:21:25.139 --> 03:21:32.146
BILL IS OUT. FILE ITEM 9 85 95.
03:21:32.213 --> 03:21:33.614
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
03:21:33.681 --> 03:21:34.882
AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND RE
03:21:34.949 --> 03:21:37.185
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:21:37.251 --> 03:21:37.752
APPROPRIATIONS CHAIR VOTING.
03:21:37.819 --> 03:21:39.320
I'VE I STIR VOTING, AYE. DOLLY
03:21:39.387 --> 03:21:43.858
MCGUIRE. AFTER I CHANGED. THAT
03:21:43.925 --> 03:21:49.263
BILL IS OUT, OKAY? HIGHLIGHT AND
03:21:49.330 --> 03:21:52.967
10 A B 16 52. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:21:53.034 --> 03:21:55.136
PAST BUT FIRST WE RE REFERRED TO
03:21:55.203 --> 03:21:56.304
THE COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND
03:21:56.370 --> 03:21:56.938
CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS. DELI.
03:21:57.004 --> 03:21:59.707
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE. YOU HEAR
03:21:59.774 --> 03:22:03.978
THAT FILLS OUT. FILE ITEM 11
03:22:04.045 --> 03:22:05.746
AGUILAR 26. THE MOTION IS DUE
03:22:05.813 --> 03:22:07.882
PASS AS AMENDED CHAIR VOIGTS
03:22:07.949 --> 03:22:09.150
VOTING I VICE CHAIR VOTING I
03:22:09.217 --> 03:22:14.222
MCGUIRE WHERE I 70 BILLS OUT 70.
03:22:14.288 --> 03:22:17.625
FILE ITEM 14 14 91. THE MOTION
03:22:17.692 --> 03:22:19.126
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED BUT FIRST
03:22:19.193 --> 03:22:20.628
AMEND AND REFERRED TO THE
03:22:20.695 --> 03:22:21.429
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:22:21.496 --> 03:22:22.597
CHAIR VOTING I VICE CHAIR VOTING
03:22:22.663 --> 03:22:25.433
I MCGUIRE WHERE I 70 PULLS OUT
03:22:25.500 --> 03:22:31.606
70. HIGHLIGHT HIM 16 89 02
03:22:31.672 --> 03:22:33.641
MOTIONS DO PASS BUT FIRST BE
03:22:33.708 --> 03:22:35.443
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:22:35.510 --> 03:22:36.377
APPROPRIATIONS CHAIR, VOTING
03:22:36.444 --> 03:22:37.411
VICE, HER VOTING NO. DOLLY
03:22:37.478 --> 03:22:39.714
GLASER MCGUIRE. GLASER. AYE.
03:22:39.780 --> 03:22:45.152
MCGUIRE WHERE I. THAT PULLS OUT
03:22:45.219 --> 03:22:48.189
60550. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:22:48.256 --> 03:22:52.760
5151. THANK YOU. FILE ITEMS 17 A
03:22:52.827 --> 03:22:55.830
B 11 87. THE MOTION IS DUE PAST
03:22:55.897 --> 03:22:57.798
BUT FIRST BE REFERRED TO THE
03:22:57.865 --> 03:22:58.366
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
03:22:58.432 --> 03:22:59.967
CHAIR VOTING. I'VE ICED HER
03:23:00.034 --> 03:23:01.102
VOTING I DAILY GLASER. GLASER. I
03:23:01.168 --> 03:23:06.941
MCGUIRE CHOIR. I PAN PAN. AYE.
03:23:07.008 --> 03:23:10.011
AT 60 THAT BUILDS OUT 6 TO 0.
03:23:10.077 --> 03:23:11.512
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
03:23:11.579 --> 03:23:12.947
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S JOAN SAWYER. I
03:23:13.014 --> 03:23:14.649
THANK YOU. WE ARE ON BORROWED
03:23:14.715 --> 03:23:17.652
TIME, SIR. GRACIOUS GRACIOUS
03:23:17.718 --> 03:23:19.053
CHAIR OF SENATE. LABOR IS
03:23:19.120 --> 03:23:20.922
LETTING US POWER THROUGH. IF YOU
03:23:20.988 --> 03:23:23.090
WOULD PLEASE PRESENT A B 2 95.
03:23:23.157 --> 03:23:27.528
THANK YOU, OKAY. YEAH YOU AND
03:23:27.595 --> 03:23:28.963
YOU HAVE NO WITNESSES ON EITHER
03:23:29.030 --> 03:23:30.565
SIDE. SO IF YOU'RE OKAY WITH
03:23:30.631 --> 03:23:32.667
THAT, OKAY, VERY GOOD. WE
03:23:32.733 --> 03:23:34.969
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN I VOTE.
03:23:35.036 --> 03:23:36.103
I BELIEVE THE BILL HAS BEEN
03:23:36.170 --> 03:23:38.239
MOVED BY SENATOR MCGUIRE. MADAM
03:23:38.306 --> 03:23:39.206
CONSULTANT. PLEASE CALL THE
03:23:39.273 --> 03:23:43.010
ROLL. HAVE A QUESTION SIGN OF
03:23:43.077 --> 03:23:48.783
NEVER TALKED PAST THE YES, I.
03:23:48.849 --> 03:23:51.719
OKAY YES, YOU'RE RIGHT. OKAY
03:23:51.786 --> 03:23:53.688
SORRY. THIS IS WHY WE HAVE GOOD
03:23:53.754 --> 03:23:55.723
PEOPLE IN OUR LIVES. WE HAVE TO
03:23:55.790 --> 03:23:57.525
MAKE SURE THAT WE ASK EVERYONE
03:23:57.592 --> 03:23:58.559
IS THERE ANYONE IN THE ROOM WHO
03:23:58.626 --> 03:23:59.760
WOULD LIKE TO SUPPORT OR OPPOSE
03:23:59.827 --> 03:24:04.131
A B 2 95. SEEING NO ONE. MR
03:24:04.198 --> 03:24:05.733
MODERATOR, CAN YOU CUE UP ANYONE
03:24:05.800 --> 03:24:07.702
ON THE LINES WHO WOULD LIKE TO
03:24:07.768 --> 03:24:10.438
SUPPORT OR OPPOSE A B 2 95?
03:24:10.504 --> 03:24:13.074
ABSOLUTELY IF YOU ARE IN SUPPORT
03:24:13.140 --> 03:24:14.508
OR OPPOSITION TO A B 2 95,
03:24:14.575 --> 03:24:16.277
PLEASE TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO
03:24:16.344 --> 03:24:17.979
PRESS ONE, FOLLOWED BY 01 FALL
03:24:18.045 --> 03:24:20.648
BY ZERO AND WE WILL GO TO LINE
03:24:20.715 --> 03:24:23.718
106, PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
03:24:23.784 --> 03:24:25.820
AFTERNOON CHAIR MEMBERS PERSONAL
03:24:25.886 --> 03:24:26.787
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA FACULTY
03:24:26.854 --> 03:24:27.722
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT. THANK
03:24:27.788 --> 03:24:32.927
YOU. THANK YOU. I'LL GIVE ONE
03:24:32.994 --> 03:24:34.395
MORE REMINDER, MADAM CHAIR TO
03:24:34.462 --> 03:24:36.931
HIT 10 THAT YOU ARE IN SUPPORT
03:24:36.998 --> 03:24:41.936
OR OPPOSITION TO A B 2 95.
03:24:42.003 --> 03:24:43.537
NOBODY ELSE IS QUEUING UP AT
03:24:43.604 --> 03:24:45.239
THIS TIME. THANK YOU, MR
03:24:45.306 --> 03:24:47.141
MODERATOR. WE DO HAVE A MOTION
03:24:47.208 --> 03:24:48.009
BY SENATOR MCGUIRE. MADAM
03:24:48.075 --> 03:24:52.613
ASSISTANT. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
03:24:52.680 --> 03:24:55.616
YES I KEPT AMENDMENTS YOU WANT
03:24:55.683 --> 03:24:57.118
20 READ? THE WHOLE THING YOU
03:24:57.184 --> 03:24:59.086
HAVE TO SAY IS I ACCEPT THE
03:24:59.153 --> 03:25:02.223
AMENDMENTS. YOU'RE GOOD TO GO.
03:25:02.289 --> 03:25:05.259
OKAY HIGHLIGHT. UM 3 80 TO 95.
03:25:05.326 --> 03:25:06.227
THE MOTION IS DUE PASS AS
03:25:06.293 --> 03:25:07.762
AMENDED BUT FIRST AMEND AND
03:25:07.828 --> 03:25:09.263
REFER TO THE COMMITTEE ON
03:25:09.330 --> 03:25:10.297
APPROPRIATIONS. LEYVA LEAVE IT I
03:25:10.364 --> 03:25:16.971
BOOK CORTEZ. PRETTY EASY I DALI
03:25:17.038 --> 03:25:21.208
BLAZER. LASER EYE. MCGUIRE.
03:25:21.275 --> 03:25:23.978
WHERE I PAN PAN THAT BUILDS OUT
03:25:24.045 --> 03:25:25.646
5 TO 1 COMMITTEE.
03:25:25.713 --> 03:25:27.181
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S THANK YOU FOR
03:25:27.248 --> 03:25:28.182
YOUR GRACIOUSNESS. ALRIGHT
03:25:28.249 --> 03:25:31.786
MEMBERS. THANK YOU. UH WE'RE ARE
03:25:31.852 --> 03:25:33.587
GOING TO CLOSE IT DOWN. THANK
03:25:33.654 --> 03:25:34.989
YOU TO ALL INDIVIDUALS WHO
03:25:35.056 --> 03:25:36.223
PARTICIPATED IN PUBLIC TESTIMONY
03:25:36.290 --> 03:25:37.992
TODAY. THANK YOU. IF YOU'RE NOT
03:25:38.059 --> 03:25:39.827
ABLE TO TESTIFY TODAY, PLEASE
03:25:39.894 --> 03:25:40.828
SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS OR
03:25:40.895 --> 03:25:42.163
SUGGESTIONS IN WRITING. TO THE
03:25:42.229 --> 03:25:43.698
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE OR
03:25:43.764 --> 03:25:45.866
VISIT OUR WEBSITE. YOUR COMMENTS
03:25:45.933 --> 03:25:47.301
AND SUGGESTIONS ARE IMPORTANT TO
03:25:47.368 --> 03:25:48.836
US, AND WE WANT TO INCLUDE YOUR
03:25:48.903 --> 03:25:49.570
TESTIMONY IN THE OFFICIAL
03:25:49.637 --> 03:25:50.604
HEARING RECORDS. THANK YOU. WE
03:25:50.671 --> 03:25:53.574
APPRECIATE YOUR PARTICIPATION.
03:25:53.641 --> 03:25:55.276
THANK YOU, EVERYONE FOR YOUR
03:25:55.342 --> 03:25:56.811
PATIENCE AND COOPERATION. WE
03:25:56.877 --> 03:25:58.245
HAVE CONCLUDED THE AGENDA AND
03:25:58.312 --> 03:25:59.480
THE SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE
03:25:59.547 --> 03:26:16.130
IS ADJOURNED.