SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING WILL
COME TO ORDER GOOD AFTERNOON. SO
THIS AFTERNOON AS WE CONTINUE TO
TAKE SOME PRECAUTIONS TO MANAGE
THE ONGOING COVID 19 PANDEMIC.
THE SENATE CONTINUES TO WELCOME
THE PUBLIC AND HAS PROVIDED
ACCESS TO BOTH IN PERSON UNTIL A
CONFERENCE DISSIPATION. FOR
PUBLIC COMMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS
WISHING TO PROVIDE PUBLIC
COMMENT VIA THE TELECONFERENCE
SERVICE PARTICIPANT TOLL FREE
NUMBER AND ACCESS CODE IS POSTED
ON OUR COMMITTEE WEBSITE. YOU
WILL ALSO BE DISPLAYED ON THE
SCREEN AND I WILL ANNOUNCE IT
NOW. TODAY'S PARTICIPANT NUMBER
IS 877. 2268163. AND THE ACCESS
CODE IS 864. 6445. I WILL
MAINTAIN THE QUORUM DURING THE
HEARING, AS IS CUSTOMARY IN ANY
INDIVIDUAL WHO IS DISRUPTIVE MAY
BE REMOVED FROM THE REMOTE
MEETING SERVICE. OR HAVE THEIR
CONNECTION MUTED. WE'RE HOLDING
OUR COMMITTEE HEARING. IN OUR
BOTH STRAIGHT OH STREET BUILDING
THE SWING SPACE. UM, I ASKED ALL
MEMBERS OTHER THAN SENATOR
CORTEZ E. THANK YOU FOR BEING
HERE, SENATOR TO PLEASE COME TO
ROOM 2200 SO WE CAN ESTABLISH A
QUARANTINE AND BEGIN OUR
HEARING. WE HAVE SIX BILLS ON
TODAY'S AGENDA. UM AND AH. ITEM
NUMBER OR 89 16. HAS BEEN PULLED
THAT WILL BE HEARD AT A LATER
DATE. UM I WANT TO ALSO NOTE
THAT, UM NO, THAT'S IT. AND SO
WE DO NOT HAVE A QUORUM YET. WE
WILL PROCEED AS A SUBCOMMITTEE
AND WILL ESTABLISH A QUORUM AS
SOON AS WE HAVE THREE MORE
MEMBERS HERE. UM I WILL BE
PRESENTING, UH, FOR OUR FIRST
AUTHOR, ASSEMBLY MEMBER, IRWIN
A. B FOR 11 ITEM NUMBER ONE. ONE
MOMENT. OKAY? 84 11 AGAIN ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR
WHEN ENACTS THE VETERANS HOUSING
AND HOMELESS PREVENTION BOND
ACT, AUTHORIZED THE ISSUANCE.
BONDS TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
FUNDING FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF
AFFORDABLE MULTI FAMILY HOUSING
WITH SUPPORTIVE SERVICES FOR
VETERANS. IN 2014, CALIFORNIA
VOTERS APPROVED PROPOSITION 41.
TO FIND MULTIFAMILY, AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FOR VETERANS, CREATING
THE VHP. THE PROPOSITION ALLOWED
FOR $600 MILLION IN BONDS TO BE
ISSUED. OVER SIX ROUNDS OF
FUNDING. THE PROGRAM HAS
RESULTED IN NEARLY 6000 UNITS
PRODUCED NOW ABOUT 100 MILLION
REMAINING FOR THIS SUCCESSFUL
PROGRAMS, SO THE PROGRAM WILL BE
EXHAUSTED. A BEFORE 11 PROPOSES
ASKED VOTERS IN 2024 TO CONTINUE
FUNDING THE PROGRAM WITH ANOTHER
$600 MILLION. THERE ARE AN
ESTIMATED 11,000 HOMELESS
VETERANS IN CALIFORNIA AND EVEN
MORE EXPERIENCING HOUSING AND
SECURITY OR STRUGGLING TO MAKE
ENDS MEET IN TRANSITION. A
BEFORE 11 WILL ASSIST VETERANS
WHO ARE HOMELESS OR WHO NEED
AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING TO
SECURE HOUSING AND SERVICES. FOR
THEMSELVES AND THEIR FAMILIES.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S ASKS FOR AN I
VOTE. MOMENT. OKAY. WE HAVE NO
LEAD. WE DO OKAY. PLEASE COME
FORWARD AND SUPPORT OF A BEFORE,
11. THANKS A LOT. THANK YOU, MR
CHAIR AND MEMBERS. GOOD TO SEE
YOU. ALEX TORRES HERE WITH THE
STRETCH WITH THE STRATEGIES. 3
60 ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF VETERANS SERVICE
AGENCIES. IN STRONG SUPPORT OF
THIS MEASURE, AND LIKE TO LIKE
TO THANK ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S OR WIN
FOR CHAMPION, THIS SITE WOULD BE
REMISS TO NOT OBSERVE. WE'RE
HAVING THIS IMPORTANT DISCUSSION
AFTER MEMORIAL DAY WHERE WE
HONOR OUR FALLEN MEN AND WOMEN
OF THE ARMED FORCES, BUT HERE IN
OUR STATE VETERANS HAVE TROUBLE
FINDING HOUSING AND ACCESS TO
SERVICES. AND THIS MEASURE WORKS
TO ADDRESS THESE DISPARITIES AND
SERVE OUR CALIFORNIA VETERANS.
WE TALK A LOT ABOUT CULTURAL,
CULTURALLY COMPETENT CARE IN OUR
POLICY DISCUSSIONS. PRIMARY
FEATURE OF THIS PROGRAM IS THAT
AT LEAST 50% OF THE HOUSING
FUNDED SERVES EXTREMELY LOW
INCOME VETERAN HOUSEHOLDS, THOSE
EARNING 30% OF THE AREA MEDIAN
INCOME 60% OF THOSE UNITS MUST
BE COUPLED WITH SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES PROJECT TEAMS THAT
INCLUDE SERVICE PROVIDERS WITH
EXPERIENCE, HOUSING OR HOUSING
OR SERVICES TO VETERANS ARE
PRIORITIZED, EMPHASIZING THAT
CULTURAL COMPETENCY WHEN
ADDRESSING THE NEEDS OF
CALIFORNIA'S VETERANS.
DIFFERENCES IN CIVILIAN AND
VETERAN EXPERIENCES MAKE
TRANSITION FROM MILITARY LIFE
INTO SOCIAL PROFESSIONAL AND
THERAPEUTIC, CITING IT'S
DIFFICULT, CULTURALLY COMPETENT
SERVICES FOR VETERANS INTEGRATE
MILITARY CULTURE KNOWLEDGE AND
TO PATIENT ASSESSMENT AND
TREATMENT. AND THAT'S WHY THIS
MEASURE IS SO IMPORTANT,
IMPORTANT NOT ONLY BRINGS ABOUT
THE CULTURALLY COMPETENT VETERAN
SERVICES THAT WE'VE SEEN BRING
ABOUT BETTER OUTCOMES. IT ALSO
BRINGS ABOUT HOUSING, WHICH WE
BADLY NEED IS THIS COMMITTEE IS
WELL AWARE. 88 PROJECTS HAVE
BEEN FUNDED, CREATING ALMOST
6000 UNITS OF SENATOR WEINER
SAID. THIS MONEY HAS ALSO BEEN
GEOGRAPHICALLY TARGETED TO
ENCOURAGE DEVELOPMENT OF VETERAN
HOUSING AND REGIONS WITH HIGH
CONCENTRATIONS OF CALIFORNIA'S
MOST VULNERABLE VETERANS. SINCE
WE'RE HERE IN THE SENATE. I ALSO
WANT TO STATE CABINET SUPPORT
FOR ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RAMOS IS
REQUEST FOR $250 MILLION TO FUND
THE PROGRAM IN THE INTERIM. WELL
THIS BILL GOES THROUGH THE
PROCESS AND WE GET IT ON THE
MARCH 2024 BALLOT. WITH THIS
FUNDING RUNNING OUT THIS YEAR,
IT IS VITAL THAT CALIFORNIA
VOTERS BE ASKED IN EARLY 2024 TO
VOTE YES FOR VETERAN HOUSING,
BUT ALSO THAT THE PROGRAM BE
FUNDED IN THE INTERIM. THANK YOU
AGAIN STRONGLY AT YOUR SPORT.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH, AND HE
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC COMMENT HERE
IN ROOM 2200 MARKS DIVERS WITH
THE CALIFORNIA HOUSING
PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT OF MORE
RESOURCES FOR VETERAN HOUSING
JUST FROM A STATEWIDE PROGRAM
EFFICIENCY PERSPECTIVE, WE JUST
ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONSIDER
RUNNING THIS MONEY THROUGH THE
MULTI FAMILY HOUSING PROGRAM. AS
A SET ASIDE FOR VETERANS, YOU
CAN HAVE ALL THE SAME THRESHOLD
CRITERIA THAT EXISTS IN THE HP.
BUT IT'S A YOU HAVE WE HAVE ONE
PROGRAM TO ADMINISTER INSTEAD OF
MULTIPLE PROGRAMS THAT HD, BUT
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT
OF THE BILL. THANK YOU VERY
MUCH. IS THERE ANY ADDITIONAL
SUPPORT PUBLIC COMMENT HERE IN
ROOM 2200? SEEING NONE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINE OR THE
MODERATOR, PLEASE QUEUE UP ANY
SUPPORT FOR A B 4 11. DO IT.
COMMUNIST SUPPORT PRESS ONE AND
ZERO AT THIS TIME. PLEASE GO TO
LINE 12. PLEASE GO AHEAD. GOOD
AFTERNOON MEMBERS. MADELINE
COOPER FROM THE OCEAN MARKS WERE
ON BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATED
BUILDERS AND CONTRACTORS OF
CALIFORNIA AND PROUD SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. NEXT WE GO TO LINE
19, PLEASE GO AHEAD. THANK YOU
AGAIN ON BEHALF OF HOUSING
ACTION COALITION AND SUPPORT.
THIS TIME, THERE'S NO ONE ELSE
IN QUÊ. GREAT WELL, NOW GO TO
ANY OPPOSITION. WE HAVE NO LEAD
OPPOSITION IDENTIFIED. IS THERE
ANY OPPOSITION TO A BEFORE 11
HERE IN ROOM 2200. SEEING THEM.
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINE WITH
THE OPERATOR. PLEASE QUEUE UP
ANY OPPOSITION TO A BEFORE 11.
YOU'D LIKE TO COMMENT.
OPPOSITION MAYBE 4, 11 1 AND
ZERO AT THIS TIME. RIGAS ASKED
ME TO PRISON. OH, I THOUGHT THIS
TIME THERE'S NO ONE IN QUÊ.
THANK YOU AND I'LL BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE. WE DO NOT YET
HAVE A QUORUM OR ONE MEMBER
SHORT, WE WILL ENTERTAIN A
MOTION ONCE WE HAVE 1/5 MEMBER
HERE. THANK YOU.
OKAY WE WILL NOW MOVE TO ITEM
NUMBER THREE A. B 12 88 BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S QUIRK SILVA.
AND SENATOR CABALLERO WILL BE
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF THE
AUTHOR. SENATOR YOU MAY PROCEED
. THANK YOU, MR PRESIDENT, MR
CHAIR AND COLLEAGUES. I'M
PRESENTING A B BOB 88 ON BEHALF
OF ASSEMBLYWOMAN QUIRK-SILVA.
FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS, THE
STATE BUDGET HAS INCREASED ITS
INVESTMENT IN THE LOW INCOME
HOUSING TAX CREDIT PROGRAM BY
$500 MILLION EACH YEAR. A B 12
88 GIVES US A BIGGER BANG FOR
THE BUCK AND MAXIMIZES OUR
PRODUCTION OF AFFORDABLE HOMES
BY ALLOWING THE TAX CREDIT
ALLOCATION COMMITTEE. TWO PAIR
THESE STATE TAX CREDITS WITH
EITHER 4% OR 9% FEDERAL CREDITS
AS CONDITIONS BEST DICTATE. IN
2019, CALIFORNIA PAIRED THE
STATE CREDITS WITH 4% FEDERAL
CREDITS BECAUSE THE 4% FEDERAL
CREDITS WERE UNDERSUBSCRIBED AT
THE TIME. SINCE THEN, CONDITIONS
HAVE CHANGED DRAMATICALLY. 4%
FEDERAL CREDIT ARE NOW
OVERSUBSCRIBED. 321 AND FEDERAL
RULES DO NOT ALLOW US TO EXPAND
THE PROGRAM. HOWEVER THERE IS NO
FEDERAL BARRIER TO EXPANDING THE
9% FEDERAL CREDIT PROGRAM.
THEREFORE IF UNDER THESE
CONDITIONS WE PAIR THE STATES,
THE STATE CREDITS WITH 9%
FEDERAL CREDITS WE CAN FUND
ADDITIONAL HOMES. A B 12 88 DOES
NOT INCREASE TAXES IN ANY WAY.
BECAUSE THE AMOUNT OF CREDIT IS
FIXED IN THE BUDGET EACH YEAR
THIS, BUT BILL SIMPLY IS A MORE
EFFECTIVE AND IMPACTFUL WAY FOR
CALIFORNIA TO DEPLOY ITS SCARCE,
AFFORDABLE HOUSING RESOURCES.
WITH ME TODAY TO SPEAK IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IS MARK
STIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP CORPORATION.
MR SIEVERS. THANK YOU. SENATOR
MARKS. DIVERS WITH THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING PARTNERSHIP,
AND THIS BILL WILL IS AN
EFFICIENCY MEASURE. IT WILL
ALLOW US TO PRODUCE MORE HOMES
WITH THE SAME AMOUNT OF STATE
RESOURCES HERE TO ANSWER. ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS AND ASK FOR YOUR
SUPPORT. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. UM AND I BELIEVE THAT
WAS THE ONLY WITNESS. THAT'S
CORRECT. CORRECT IS THERE ANYONE
ELSE HERE IN ROOM 2200 AND
SUPPORT OF A B 12 88? SAYING NOW
WE'LL GO TO THE PHONE LINES, MR
MODERATOR. FAMILY'S DOING IF YOU
WISH TO COMMENT ON THE DECISION
THIS TIME. AND WE DO HAVE TO.
FREE CHEWING UP. WE'LL START
WITH LINE 19 AHEAD. BY 19 YEAR
LINE IS OPEN. FRIENDS AT ME.
HE WILL GO TO LINE 11, PLEASE GO
AHEAD. GREEN AND WHITE WITH THE
CALIFORNIA HOUSING CONSORTIUM
AND SUPPORT. AND WE GOT A LINE.
15, PLEASE GO AHEAD. HELLO MY
NAME'S CONNIE CHAN AND THE
LEGISLATIVE ANALYST FOR STATE
TREASURER. FIONA MA. I'M CALLING
IN SUPPORT OF A B 12 88 ON
BEHALF OF THE TREASURER. THE
TREASURER THINKS THE AUTHOR FOR
THEIR LEADERSHIP. THANK YOU. AND
WE'LL GO BACK TO LINE 19. 19,
PLEASE GO AHEAD. COMMERCENTRE.
YOUR LINE IS OPEN. PLEASE GO
AHEAD. I CAN HEAR ME. YES.
APOLOGIES I DIDN'T GET A NUMBER
JOHN INSTITUTING ON BEHALF OF
HOUSING ACTION COALITION. THANK
YOU. IN THIS CHAIR. WE HAVE NO
ONE ELSE IN CUBA AT THIS TIME.
OKAY THANK YOU. WE HAVE NO
REGISTERED OPPOSITION, BUT I
WILL ASK OF THIS. ANY OPPOSITION
TESTIMONY TO A B 12 88 HERE IN
ROOM 2200. SEEING NONE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINES, MR
MODERATOR. IF YOU WISH TO SPEAK
ON THIS, PLEASE PRESS ONE THIS
TIME. MRS. HERE. NO ONE HAS
QUEUED UP AT THIS TIME. OKAY,
GREAT. WE'LL BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES ANY. UH
UM, DISCUSSION AROUND? MAYBE 12
88. QUESTIONS, COMMENTS. 18 9,
AND I SHOULD HAVE ASKED THAT
BEFORE. WAS THERE ANY QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS AROUND 84 11? OKAY,
GREAT. UM OKAY, SO WE ARE NOW
JUST THANK YOU VERY MUCH SENATOR
COVERED. UM AND IF YOU WANT TO
CLOSE YOUR WELCOME TO HMM. UM WE
WILL WAIT FOR OUR NEXT
PRESENTERS CENTER WIECKOWSKI.
YEAH. ONE MOMENT, PLEASE.
PERCENT. THIS IS ON THE. JESTED.
HOW WAS THAT? ADJUST?
OKAY SENATOR WIECKOWSKI IS GOING
TO PRESENT A B 14 10 ON BEHALF
OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RODRIGUEZ.
SENATOR, PLEASE PROCEED. THANK
YOU, MR CHAIR, AND, UM. A. WE
ACCEPTING THE AMENDMENTS. YES,
WE ARE ACCEPTING THE COMMITTEE'S
AMENDMENTS, AND THIS MAKES
SEVERAL CHANGES. I DON'T THINK
THERE ARE AMENDMENTS. I THINK
THERE WERE SOME SUGGESTIONS.
MOVING FORWARD, BUT WE DON'T
HAVE ANY COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS
THAT CORRECT, MADAM CONSULTANT.
HOLD ON ONE SEC. YEAH. UH HUH.
OKAY BUT NO NO AMENDMENTS OF
THIS TIME, IT MAKES YOUR WELCOME
TO ACCEPT ON THE FLY. WELL OKAY.
WE'RE GOING TO AMEND. NO, WE'RE
NOT GOING TO AMEND IT. DISALLOWS
MEMBERS AND RESIDENTS OF H O A
SOCIETY TO USE SOCIAL MEDIA AND
OTHER ONLINE RESOURCES TO
DISCUSS DEVELOPMENT LIVING
ASSOCIATION ELECTIONS
LEGISLATION ELECTION TO PUBLIC
OFFICE OR AN INITIATIVE,
REFERENDUM AND RECALL PROCESS
EVEN IF DISCUSSIONS ARE CRITICAL
OF THE A, UM AND ITS GOVERNANCE
, UH, SIMILARLY PROHIBITS AN H
AWAY FROM PURSUING ENFORCEMENT
ACTIONS. AGAIN DURING DECLARED
EMERGENCIES IF THE NATURE OF THE
EMERGENCY MAKES IT UNSAFE FOR
IMPOSSIBLE FOR HOMEOWNERS, UH TO
EITHER PREVENT OR FIX THE
VIOLATION, AND IT REQUIRES
HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION TO SEEK TO
IMPOSE MONETARY PENALTIES
AGAINST THE MEMBER SHALL MAKE
ANY SHALL MAKE ANY PHYSICAL
EVIDENCE USED TO DETERMINE A
VIOLATION AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS,
SO IT'S ONCE AGAIN ON THIS LINE
OF MORE TRANSPARENCY IN THE
OPERATION OF HOMEOWNERS
ASSOCIATION AND UM WITH THAT WE
HAVE WITNESSES HERE IN SUPPORT.
ACTUALLY I DON'T BELIEVE WE
DON'T HAVE ANY LEAD WITNESSES
IDENTIFIED BUT AS SOMEONE IS
THERE ANY SUPPORT TESTIMONY HERE
IN ROOM 2200, PLEASE COME
FORWARD. THANK YOU. MARGARET.
SENATOR WEINER AND MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE. I'M MARJORIE
MURRAY FROM THE CENTER FOR
CALIFORNIA HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION
LAW, AND WE WORKED WITH SENATOR
WIECKOWSKI TO CREATE THE
ORIGINAL CIVIL CODE 45. 15
AFFIRMING THOSE RIGHTS, WHICH
THE SENATOR HAS JUST LAID OUT.
WE ARE IN STRONG SUPPORT OF, UM
A B 14 10 BECAUSE OF THE
COMPLAINTS THAT ARE BEING
REPORTED TO OUR CENTER BY
HOMEOWNERS, NAMELY THAT THEY ARE
BEING BARRED FROM POSTING
COMMENTS ON MATTERS OF COMMON
CONCERN. ONLINE ON SOCIAL MEDIA
ON TWITTER ON NEXT DOOR AND
FACEBOOK. UM, PLATFORMS. FOR
EXAMPLE, ONE MARIN COUNTY
HOMEOWNER, A LAWYER AND FORMER
BOARD MEMBER, CREATED A WEBSITE
THAT DISCUSSED ASSOCIATION
ELECTIONS AND THE RULES THAT THE
BOARD ADOPTED TO EXECUTE THEM.
HER WEBSITE ASSERTED THAT THE
RULES WERE INVALID. SHE HAS NOW
GOTTEN A LETTER FROM THE
ASSOCIATIONS LAW FIRM DEMANDING
THAT SHE TAKE DOWN THE WEBSITE.
SHE HAS REFUSED, AND THE CASE IS
NOW IN LITIGATION. ANOTHER
HOMEOWNER, THIS ONE IN SANTA
CLARA COUNTY HAS BEEN LEVIED AT
$12,500 SPECIAL ASSESSMENT FOR
THE PLATFORM, WHICH IS MODERATED
BY THE BOARD PRESIDENT. HE HAS
BEEN SUMMONED. TO A SPECIAL
DISCIPLINARY SESSION DAY AFTER
TOMORROW. AND AGAIN, THE LAW
FIRM IS DEMANDING THAT HE PAID
$12,500 TO REIMBURSE THE LAW
FIRM FOR SERVICES THAT IT HAS
PROVIDED TO THE ASSOCIATION. ONE
OF THE AMENDMENTS THAT HAS BEEN
DISCUSSED IN THE ANALYSIS IS
THAT A POSSIBLE SOLUTION IS TO
INSERT INTO LAW SOME KIND OF
CODE OF CONDUCT. BUT WE HAVE
SAMPLES OF THOSE CODES OF
CONDUCT AND THEY THEY STATE
EXACTLY WHAT HOMEOWNERS HAVE
BEEN SUFFERING, WHICH IS THEY
ARE BEING PROHIBITED FROM
POSTING ONLINE ON THE SOCIAL
PLATFORMS WITH THREATS OF
ADDITIONAL FINES AND POSSIBLE
FORECLOSURE. SO WE SUPPORT THE
BILL AND URGED THE COMMITTEE TO
VOTE. YES, ON IT. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. IS THERE
ANY ADDITIONAL SUPPORTIVE PUBLIC
COMMENT HERE IN ROOM 2200? THIS
IS, UM AGAIN ON A B 14 10,
SAYING NONE WILL GO TO THE PHONE
LINES, MR MODERATOR. AND IF YOU
WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
THIS, PLEASE PRESS ONE AND ZERO
AT THIS TIME. MR CHAIR. WE HAVE
NO ONE QUEUING UP AT THIS TIME.
OKAY WELL, NOW GO TO OPPOSITION
. UM, IS THERE ANY OPPOSITION
PRESENT IN ROOM? 2200, PLEASE
COME FORWARD. MR CHAIRMAN,
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE LOUIS
BROWN TODAY ON THE COMMUNITY ON
BEHALF OF THE COMMUNITY
ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE,
CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE ACTION
COMMITTEE FIRST LET ME EXPRESS
OUR APPRECIATION TO THE
COMMITTEE STAFF AS WELL AS THE
AUTHOR STAFF. HALF FOR TALKING
WITH US ON THIS BILL. I THINK
WE'VE NARROWED IT DOWN TO TWO
ISSUES THAT WE HAVE, AND IT
LOOKS LIKE WE MAY BE MOVING
FORWARD TO SOME RESOLUTION FIRST
AS IT RELATES TO SOCIAL MEDIA.
AN INTERNET WEBSITES. WE HAVE NO
ISSUE WITH THE IDEA OF PUBLICLY
ACCESSIBLE WEBSITES OR SOCIAL
MEDIA. TWITTER FACEBOOK,
ETCETERA. WE HAVE A CONCERN WITH
THE BREATH OF THE LANGUAGE AND
THE BILL, AND THAT WE BELIEVE IT
WOULD ACTUALLY INCLUDE THE
WEBSITE OF THE ASSOCIATION
THAT'S CONTROLLED OR MANAGED BY
THE ASSOCIATION. SO WE LIKE TO
WORK WITH THE AUTHOR'S OFFICE ON
SOME LANGUAGE TO SPECIFICALLY
EXEMPT THOSE WEBSITES OR SOCIAL
MEDIA SITES THAT ARE CONTROLLED
OR MANAGED BY THE ASSOCIATION. I
BELIEVE THAT SINCE THEY DO OWN
OR CONTROL THEM THAT THEY SHOULD
BE ABLE TO MITIGATE WHAT TYPE OF
INFORMATION IS SHARED ON THOSE
WEBSITES. THE SECOND PIECE OF
CONCERN THAT WE HAVE AGAIN THAT
WE THINK IS AN AVENUE FORWARD
WAS PUT IN. THE ANALYSIS WAS ON
THE BILL NOW CONTAINS MANDATORY
EDUCATION. THE ANALYSIS SAYS,
WELL, MAYBE INSTEAD OF MANDATORY
EDUCATION FOR BOARD MEMBERS, WE
MOVE DOWN THE PATH OF A CODE OF
CONDUCT THAT IDENTIFIES THAT THE
BOARD MEMBERS HAVE BEEN MADE
AWARE OF THEIR FIDUCIARY ETHICS.
AS WELL AS, UH, ISSUES DEALING
WITH HARASSMENT AND UNLAWFUL
HARASSMENT. IN PARTICULAR, WE
THINK THAT'S PROBABLY MORE
REASONABLE WAY TO GO TO AVOID
THE COST PRESSURES, IT'LL AVOID
ENFORCEMENT ISSUES THAT
MANDATORY EDUCATION OF
VOLUNTEERS WOULD BRING FORWARD.
AGAIN WE'RE WORKING WITH THE
AUTHOR'S OFFICE ON THAT. I THINK
WE HAVE A PATHWAY FORWARD,
HOPEFULLY, BEFORE THE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE HERE ON THE SENATE
SIDE WILL BE ABLE TO HAVE THOSE
ISSUES ADDRESSED. I APPRECIATE
YOUR TIME. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANY
ADDITIONAL OPPOSITION COMMENT
HERE IN ROOM 2200 ON A B 14 10
SAYING THEN WE'LL GO TO THE
PHONE LINES, MR MODERATOR. IF
YOU WERE SPEAKING OPPOSITION OF
THIS, PLEASE PRESS 10 AT THIS
TIME. JUST A MOMENT WE HAVE
SOMEBODY COMING UP. YEAH.
OKAY, WE'LL GO WITH LINE. 20,
PLEASE GO AHEAD. CENTER FOR WADA
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF COMMUNITY
MANAGERS. UM WE CURRENTLY HAVE
AN OPPOSED UNLESS AMENDED
POSITION ON THE BILL. WE REMAIN
CONCERNED ABOUT SPORTS
REQUIREMENT FOR DIRECTORS AND
EMPLOYEES. WE CERTAINLY
UNDERSTAND THE OBJECTIVE BUT
BELIEVE THAT THE REQUIREMENT
WOULD EXACERBATE THE DIFFICULTY
THAT HAVE BEEN GETTING VOLUNTEER
HOMEOWNERS TO RUN FOR THE BOARD
. WE DO SUPPORT THE SUGGESTION
IN THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS THAT
IN LIEU OF THE TRAINING
REQUIREMENT OCCURRED OF CONDUCT
MUST BE SIGNED BY DIRECTORS THAT
INCLUDES LANGUAGE ON ETHICS AND
HARASSMENT PREVENTION. WE ALSO
SHARE THE VIEWPOINT EXPRESSED BY
THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS
INSTITUTE WITH REGARDS TO
ASSOCIATIONS BEING ABLE TO
CONTROL WHAT IS POSTED ON THEIR
OWN WEBSITE. WE DO APPRECIATE
THE WORK THAT THE AUTHOR AND THE
COMMITTEE HAVE DONE AND WE LOOK
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH THEM.
THIS BILL MOVES FORWARD. THANK
YOU. IS THERE ADDITIONAL. OKAY
THANK YOU. WE'LL BRING IT BACK
TO THE COMMITTEE ANY QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS AND RECOVER HERO? UM
ASK HIM A HARD ONE. WELL I'M
JUST IT'S JUST UNFORTUNATE THAT
THAT, UM THE AUTHOR ISN'T HERE.
I APPRECIATE THE TESTIMONY
BECAUSE THE QUESTION I HAD. THE
BIGGEST QUESTION I HAVE IS, WHAT
IS THE PROBLEM WE'RE TRYING TO
SOLVE FOR AND DOES THIS REALLY
DOES THIS REALLY DO IT? IT SEEMS
TO ME LIKE IT'S A MORE ABOUT UM. IT'S A SHOT AT A BUNCH OF A
BUNCH OF DIFFERENT ACTIVITIES
THAT ALL ARE A LITTLE BIT
DIFFERENT. FOR EXAMPLE, UM, THE. YOU KNOW, WE PASSED
LEGISLATION THAT FORCES COA'S.
TO ALLOW UP TO 20, OR 25% OF THE
UNITS TO BE RENTED IN THE IN THE
IN THE. AND MY CONCERN ABOUT
THAT WAS THAT, UM THAT IS REALLY
ARE SET UP TO MAKE SURE THAT
PEOPLE WORK TOGETHER TO MAKE
SURE THAT THINGS HAPPEN. AND THE
MINUTE YOU START RENTING THINGS
OUT, THEN YOU LOSE CONTROL OVER
PEOPLE'S ACTIONS AND I DIDN'T
SUPPORT IT. IT PASSED. IT GOT
SIGNED, AND NOW THIS BILL WOULD
ALLOW INDIVIDUALS TO RENT OUT
PART OF THEIR OAS ARE PART OF
THAT. UM I GUESS YOU CAN HAVE AN
A D A BIâU WITHIN AN H O A UM,
AND THE CONCERN I HAVE IS IF
THAT INDIVIDUAL THAT'S RENTING
IS A NUISANCE TO THE H O A. WHAT
IS THE WHAT IS THE MECHANISM FOR
ASKING THE OWNER TO GET RID OF
SOMEONE WHO HAS TURNED INTO A
NUISANCE, BUT THAT YOU DON'T
WANT TO EITHER, BECAUSE YOU
CAN'T AFFORD IT OR BECAUSE YOU
DON'T WANT TO GO THROUGH THE, UM
THE LEGAL PROCESS OR YOU JUST
DON'T CARE. SO I JUST GET
CONCERNED ABOUT US TAKING THE
RIGHTS OF H O S A WAY TO BE ABLE
TO MANAGE THINGS IN THEIR SOCIAL
MEDIA DISCUSSION. I DO
APPRECIATE THAT. UM THAT THE
TESTIMONY, UM AND, UM, I THOUGHT
THE CODE OF CONDUCT WAS A WAY OF
DEALING WITH IT WITH THE ISSUE
ABOUT ABOUT TAKING CLASSES THAT
DON'T EXIST FOR RIGHT NOW, BUT
THEN THE OTHER PART OF IT. WHAT?
I'M NOT SURE IS THIS REALLY A
PROBLEM, WHICH IT WOULD PROHIBIT
HIBBITTS, THE ASSOCIATION FROM
ENFORCING PROVISIONS. THAT ARE
IMPOSSIBLE TO MEET. TO PREVENT
HER TO FIX DURING AN EMERGENCY.
IS THAT BEEN SOMETHING THAT
THAT'S BEEN A PROBLEM BECAUSE IT
JUST SEEMS TO ME THAT AGAIN.
WE'RE TELLING US WHAT THEY
SHOULD BE DOING AND I THINK
THERE SHOULD BE MECHANISMS
INTERNALLY TO DEAL WITH THIS. SO
SENATOR, YOU CAN ANSWER THAT, OR
WE COULD HAVE OUR LEAD WITNESS
IN SUPPORT OF BOND. WHICHEVER
YOU PREFER, SENATOR WHAT?
KELSEY? MARCHER YOU ARE PART OF
IT WAS IN RESPONSE TO COVID THAT
PEOPLE WEREN'T WE'RE WE'RE
SUPPOSED TO HAVE THINGS FIXED,
AND THEY JUST FELT UNSAFE ABOUT
DOING THE ACTION. SO THAT'S A
SORT OF AN APPARATUS TO.
CORRECTED I MEAN, WE KNOW THAT H
O S HAVE COVENANTS AND
CONDITIONS THAT THEY'RE SUPPOSED
TO ABIDE BY. SO WHETHER THE
TENANTS IN THERE OR IT'S THE
HOMEOWNER, AND THEY'RE SUPPOSED
TO FULFILL THOSE. THEY'RE
DIFFERENT FROM REGULAR SOCIETY.
THAT DOESN'T HAVE THOSE
CONDITIONS. SO, UM, I THINK
THERE WAS JUST SOME AH,
CONCERNED THAT THAT THE PERSON
WAS UNABLE TO DO IT AND THEY
WERE OUT OF COMPLIANCE BECAUSE
THEY WERE IN A GENERAL
EMERGENCY. SENATOR KOLBER, WOULD
YOU? WOULD YOU LIKE ADDITIONAL?
IF THERE'S EXAMPLES, I THINK IT
WAS REALLY HELPFUL IF YOU WOULD
LIKE TO. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
COME UP. UM, WOULD WELCOME THAT.
AND AGAIN NORMAL SINCE WE DON'T
HAVE OUR AUTHOR HERE, UM WE HAVE
ANY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S HERE. NOT
TO DON'T WANT TO INSULT CENTER.
WIECKOWSKI IS AN EXPERT IN THIS
AREA. NO, NO, IT'S TRULY AN
EXPERT. BUT, SENATOR, WOULD YOU
PLEASE REPEAT YOUR QUESTION?
YES. UM, THE. IF I WERE THERE,
EXAMPLES, OR WAS IT A PROBLEM
DURING THE COVID CRISIS? UM.
WITH HORUS ENFORCING PROVISIONS
OF THE H O A. THAT REQUIRED
PEOPLE TO PREVENT OR FIX
SOMETHING. AND THEY JUST DIDN'T
DO IT. AND SO THAT'S WHY WE NEED
THIS. THIS ADDITIONAL CHANGE TO
THE RULES. THAT IS NOT AN ISSUE
THAT WE ADDRESSED IN OUR LETTER
TO THE COMMITTEE. AND MY. SORRY.
I'M SORRY. SENATOR THAT WAS NOT
AN ISSUE WE ADDRESSED IN OUR
LETTER OR IN OUR TESTIMONY. I
KNOW THAT FROM THE LAW REVISION
COMMISSION, THERE HAVE BEEN
OTHER EMERGENCY PROVISIONS.
APPLIED TO HOMEOWNER
ASSOCIATIONS WITH REGARD TO
MEETINGS, EMERGENCY MEETINGS AND
SPECIAL PROVISIONS. I'M NOT
PREPARED TO ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF
REPAIRS AND, UM. THOSE KINDS OF
THINGS. I APPRECIATE IT. THANK
YOU. I THOUGHT YOUR TESTIMONY
ABOUT THE, UM THE FINES AND THEN
AND THEN THE AH! ALL AROUND THE
SOCIAL MEDIA AND THE YOU KNOW,
DISAGREEMENT WITH THE OAS WAS
REALLY IMPORTANT. AND SO THAT I
FOUND THAT COMPELLING, BUT I'M
JUST TRYING TO UNDERSTAND WHY
WE'RE WHY WE'RE DOING SOME OF
THESE CHANGES, AND IT SEEMED
MORE LIKE A SHOTGUN APPROACH.
THAT'S KIND OF LIKE, THROW
EVERYTHING ELSE IN THAT ANYBODY
SAYS IS A COMPLAINT. BUT I JUST
WONDERED. I HAVE NOT HEARD ANY
OF THIS. THE AUTHORS OFFICES
INDICATED THAT THERE WERE PEOPLE
WHO WERE GIVEN DEMANDS BY THE
WAY TO FIX SOMETHING, AND THEN
WE WENT INTO A DECLARED
EMERGENCY, AND THEY JUST
COULDN'T GET THE PERSON THAT
COME IN. AND THEN THEY WERE
BECAUSE YOU GET DINGED YOU YOU
GET YOU GET FINED FOR NOT BEING
IT, SO I THINK THIS WAS A
PROPHYLACTIC MEASURE THE SAY
OKAY, WHEN YOU'RE IN A DECLARED
EMERGENCY, THESE THINGS ARE
STAYED, WHICH, NORMALLY, THE
CITY'S WOULD DO THAT. BUT
HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION IS NOT
NECESSARILY BEYOND I WILL
EXPRESS THAT TO THE AUTHOR'S
OFFICE. TWO STUDIES GO TO
JUDICIARY NEXT. YES. TALENTED
GROUP OF PEOPLE ON THAT
COMMITTEE TO LOOK AT THESE EVERY
ASPECT OF GOING TO BE SITTING ON
THAT COMMITTEE. SO I'M THINKING
OF ABSTAINING TODAY AND THEN
LOOKING AT IT WHEN IT COMES TO
JUDICIARY. I DON'T WANT TO STOP
THE BILL. I JUST WANT TO BE ABLE
TO ASK THOSE QUESTIONS. SO
APPRECIATE IT. THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TESTIMONY APPRECIATE. THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. BUT THE CHAIR
HAD TO LEAD TO PRESENT A BILL
AND HERE THE GAVEL OVER TO ME.
UM SENATOR CORTEZ E. SO IF
THERE'S NOTHING ELSE THANK YOU,
SENATOR. COUPLE EURO SEEDS, THE
FOUR AND BY UNDERSTANDING AS WE
STILL ARE SHORT OF A QUORUM. AND
SO WE WILL. WE'LL JUST MOVE ON
TO THE NEXT BILL AND COME BACK
TO THE ROYAL CALL LATER
APPROPRIATE TIME ON BEHALF OF
SOME MEMBER DR FRIEDEN SAID.
URGENT. I BOTH THANK YOU,
SENATOR. CENTER. IF YOU LIKE TO
KEEP PRESENTING, WE HAVE ANOTHER
PILL. WE'LL SEE WHAT HAPPENS
NEXT WEEK BILLS TOO, SO. WAS
JUST SYNDICATE. WE'RE GOING TO
WE'RE GOING TO RECESS, BUT WE'RE
GOING TO PAUSE FOR A COUPLE OF
MINUTES. IF IT'S MORE THAN A
COUPLE OF MINUTES, ALL ANNOUNCED
A RECESS BUT OTHERWISE FOR THOSE
LISTENING OR VIEWING, WE'RE JUST
WE'RE WAITING FOR PRESENTED TO
COME INTO THE COMMITTEE ROOM.
THE NEXT BILL IN ORDER WOULD BE
A B 15 51, AUTHOR OF SANTIAGO.
THANK YOU.
YOU CAN HAVE YOUR ATTENTION. UM. WE ARE GOING TO CALL A RECESS
FOR APPROXIMATELY FIVE MINUTES.
ESPECIALLY WOULD BE A LOT LESS
THAN FIVE MINUTES. SENATOR
MCGUIRE. UM IF YOU'D LIKE. SO
THERE'S NO RECESS FOR MEMBERS OF
THE PUBLIC THAT ARE LISTENING.
IF YOU STARTED TO WALK AWAY,
PLEASE SIT BACK DOWN AND PLEASE
PAY ATTENTION. UM SENATOR
MAGUIRE IS HERE TO PRESENT A B
15 51, AUTHOR OF THAT BILL IS
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO
TURNOVER. SENATOR MCGUIRE. IF
YOU'RE READY, YOU MAY PROCEED.
THANK YOU SO MUCH, MR CHAIR AND
I APOLOGIZE. I WAS AN ENERGY
COMMITTEE VOTING AND THEN ALMOST
COLLAPSED WITH A HEART ATTACK
RUNNING UP THE STAIRS SO
GRATEFUL TO BE WITH YOU, SO I AM
PRESENTING ON BEHALF OF THE
BUDDHIST IN THE MEMBER, MR
SANTIAGO. SIMPLE BILL. IT'S A
SUNSET EXTENSION, MAYBE 15 51
WOULD ENCOURAGE MORE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT BY GIVING
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPER DEVELOPMENT
BONUSES INCENTIVES AS LONG AS
THEY PARTNER WITH AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPERS TO CONSTRUCT
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. AS WE ALL
KNOW, THANKS TO THE HARD WORK
AND MR SANTIAGO, THIS
LEGISLATURE AND THE GOVERNOR
ENACTED A B 1934 AND AFFORDABLE
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT BONUS SLOT
ENCOURAGES COMMERCIAL DEVELOPERS
TO BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING. FOR
LOW AND MODERATE INCOME
HOUSEHOLDS. THIS BILL WILL
MERELY REESTABLISHED THE
PROVISIONS ALREADY IN LAW THAT
EXPIRED IN JANUARY. 2022 ON
BEHALF OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
SANTIAGO I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AN I VOTE. WE DO HAVE
ONE WITNESS ON THE LINE. AND
THAT'S UM ALFRED FOR HELL AND
LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING HIS
TESTIMONY HERE TODAY, MR CHAIR.
ALRIGHT THANKS, SENATOR, AND WE
WILL GO TO THE LEAD SUPPORT
WITNESS AT THIS TIME, MR FRAIL.
HE'S NOT AVAILABLE YET. OKAY, UM. LET ME DO THIS. WE'LL COME
BACK TO THE LEAD SUPPORT
WITNESS, BUT WE'RE FIRST GOING
TO TAKE THINGS A LITTLE BIT OUT
OF ORDER HERE AND ASK, THERE'S
ANYONE IN THE ROOM WHO WOULD
LIKE TO EXPRESS THE SUPPORT
POSITION ON THE BILL. MARCUS
DIVERS WITH THE CALIFORNIA
HOUSING PARTNERSHIP IN SUPPORT.
THANK YOU. ANYONE ELSE IN THE
COMMITTEE ROOM? PLEASE COME
FORWARD. CORNELIUS BURKE WITH
THE CALIFORNIA BUILDING INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL. ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU. ANY
OTHERS IN THE ROOM WHO WISH TO
SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL AT
THIS TIME? SEE NO ONE ELSE IN
THE COMMITTEE ROOM. MODERATOR
COULD YOU PLEASE QUEUE UP ANY
SUPPORT WITNESSES? ON THE
TELECONFERENCE LINE AT THIS
TIME. THIS IS A B 15 51. AND IF
YOU WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF
A B 15 51 PLUS ONE THAN ZERO AT
THIS TIME. WE DO HAVE TO QUEUE
ALREADY. GREAT 17. GO AHEAD. MR
CHAIR AND MEMBERS SYLVIA SALAS
SHOT ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
SANTA MONICA. AND SUPPORT THANK
YOU. THANK YOU. AND WE'LL GO TO
LINE 13. PLEASE GO AHEAD.
ISABELLA OR GUERRA ON BEHALF OF
SPUR AND SUPPORT. THANK YOU.
THANK YOU ANY OTHERS MODERATOR?
MR CHAIRMAN NELSON THIS TIME ALL
RIGHT. THANK YOU FOR CHECKING.
WE'RE GOING TO COME BACK AND ASK
IF THE LEAD SUPPORT WITNESSES IS
YET AVAILABLE. I UNDERSTAND THE
ANSWER IS NO. SO WE'RE GOING TO
CONTINUE A LITTLE OUT OF
SEQUENCE. UM WE DO NOT HAVE ANY
LISTED OPPOSITION. SO NO
OPPOSITION LEAD WITNESS WILL
COME BACK TO THE ROOM AND ASK IF
THERE'S ANYONE HERE PRESENT WHO
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION TO THIS BILL. SEE NO
ONE. STAND UP OR COME FORWARD.
MODERATOR WOULD YOU PLEASE
INQUIRE AS TO THE TOLL
CONFERENCE LINE IF AS S TO
ANYONE WHO WISHES TO EXPRESS AND
OPPOSED POSITION TO ABBY 15 51
IN A FEW WISH TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION OF A B 15 51 PLEASE
PRESS ONE THAN ZERO AT THIS
TIME. MR CHAIR. WE HAVE NO ONE
QUEUING UP AT THIS TIME.
ALRIGHT, MODERATOR. THANK YOU
FOR CHECKING. WE THEN IF THE
LEAD SUPPORT WITNESSES STILL
UNAVAILABLE, I'M GOING TO TURN
THE GAVEL BACK TO THE CHAIR OF
THIS COMMITTEE SENATOR WINNER
AND WE HAVE JUST COMPLETED
OPPOSITION TESTIMONY ON A B 15
51. THE COMPLETE SUPPORT WITNESS
WAS UNAVAILABLE. I'M SO I WAS
JUST ABOUT TO BRING IT BACK TO
THE COMMITTEE. WHICH IS US.
THANK YOU, SENATOR COURTESY AND
WE WILL HAVE A QUORUM
MOMENTARILY. UM, SENATOR
MCGUIRE. WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSE? WE RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
AN I VOTE AT THE APPROPRIATE
TIME. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK
YOU, UM. SORRY. THAT WAS 15 51.
THANK YOU. THANK. UM SO I WILL
PRESENT ITEM 5 80 14 45. BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S LEVINE. SO THIS
BILL WILL REQUIRE, UM COUNCILS
OF GOVERNMENT TO CONSIDER
CLIMATE CHANGE IMPACTS AS A
FACTOR IN DEVELOPING METHODOLOGY
FOR HOUSING NEEDS. PREACH CITY
AND COUNTY WITHIN A REGION. IT
WILL REQUIRE BEGINNING IN 2025
THE METHODOLOGY USED BY THE CARD
OR EACH CD. UM FOR ALLOCATING.
UM ARENA MUST FACTOR THE IMPACTS
CAUSED BY CLIMATE CHANGE,
INCLUDING EMERGENCY EVACUATION
ROUTE CAPACITY, WILDFIRE RISK
AND SEA LEVEL RISE. UM WE AH,
THE AUTHOR IS ACCEPTING
AMENDMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE AS
OUTLINED IN COMMENT, COMMENT.
FIVE OF THE ANALYSIS SO THOSE
ARE BEING ACCEPTED AND ON BEHALF
OF THE AUTHOR RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR AN I VOTE. WE HAVE NO
IDENTIFIED SUPPORTER OPPOSITION.
RELIEVED SUPPORTER OPPOSITION.
SO IS THERE ANYONE IN THE ROOM
IN ROOM 2200? AH WHO WANTS TO
PROVIDE SUPPORT? PUBLIC COMMENT
FOR A B 14 45? SEEING THEN WE'LL
GO TO THE PHONE LINES MODERATOR.
FEEL LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT. YOU
MAY PRESS 10 AT THIS TIME. WE'LL
GO TO LINE 21 IS GO AHEAD.
SANTIAGO YES. CALIFORNIA
ENVIRONMENTAL LIVERS AND
SUPPORT. JUST A MOMENT.
NEXT WE'LL GO TO LINE 16, PLEASE
GO AHEAD. PILLOWS GOOD AFTERNOON
, MR CHAIR. MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE SHARING GONZALVES ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF SANTA ROSA
IN SUPPORT OF A B 14 45. THANK
YOU. JUST STAND. THERE ARE NO
OTHERS IN QUÊ. OKAY IS THERE ANY
OPPOSITION HERE IN ROOM 2200? TO
A B 14 45. SEEING NONE WILL GO
TO THE PHONE LINES, MR
MODERATOR. IF YOU'D LIKE TO
COMMENT OPPOSITION, YOU MAY
PRESS ONE AND ZERO AT THIS TIME.
IT WAS JUST A MOMENT.
WE'RE GOING TO LINE 22, PLEASE
GO AHEAD. GOOD AFTERNOON TO
REMEMBERS PRISCILLA KIDDOS ON
BEHALF OF THE CITY OF LOS
ANGELES, START CITY OF BEVERLY
HILLS AND RESPECTFUL OPPOSITION.
THANK YOU. AT THE TIME. THERE
WAS NO OTHERS IN Q WILL BRING IT
BACK TO THE COMMITTEE COLLEAGUES
ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS OKAY,
SAYING NONE ON BEHALF OF SOME OF
THEM ARE LEVINE. I RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR MY VOTE. OKAY, WE ARE, I
THINK MOMENTARILY WILL HAVE A
QUORUM. AND.
TEST. WE'LL JUST KEEP THE ROLE
OF OKAY, WE. HAVE A QUORUM AFTER
THE PRESENTATION OF ALL OUR
BILLS AWESOME. YES, WE WILL
ESTABLISH FORM, THOUGH. SENATOR
WIENER PRESIDENT PRESENT FATES,
ORTEZ. DIZZY PRESENT, CABALLERO.
TOMORROW. PRESIDENT MCGUIRE THE
WIRE PRISON, WHICH NOBODY
SKINNER. HAMBURG. HAMBURG
PRESENT WIECKOWSKI. WIECKOWSKI
PRESIDENT. WE HAVE A QUORUM.
OKAY LET'S START WITH OUR
CONSENT ITEM. UM ITEM SEVEN. A B
2094 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S RIVAS,
ROBERT RIVAS. DO WE HAVE A
MOTION? MOVED BY SENATOR COME ON
HERO. UM IS THERE. I DON'T DO. I
NEED TO DO THIS QUESTION AGAIN.
WE DID IT ALREADY. OKAY? UM
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ON THE
CONSENT CALENDAR, WHICH CONSISTS
OF FILE ITEM SEVEN. SENATOR
WIENER? AYE BATES BURROW BURROW
. CORTESI AYE, MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE,
I PHG. SKINNER. HAMBURG
HAMBURG. I WIECKOWSKI CASSIE.
AYE. ABOUT 60 0 WILL PUT THAT
ITEM ON CALL. GOING BACK TO THE
TOP OF THE AGENDA. ITEM ONE A
BEFORE 11 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
IRWIN DO HAVE EMOTION. BY
SENATOR CAVALLERO. AND WE
ALREADY I AGAIN. I DON'T NEED TO
DO DISCUSSION BECAUSE WE DID. WE
DID IT ALREADY. OKAY GREAT.
WE'LL CALL THE ROLL AND ITEM
NUMBER 1 84 11. THIS IS FOLLOWED
HIM ONE THAT'S ONLY BUILT 4 11
BY SOME MEMBER IRWIN. THE MOTION
IS DUE PASS BEFORE THE REFERRED
TO THE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE
AND FINANCE. SENATOR WIENER. AYE
BATES, CAMEROON. CAMERA I CORTEZ
E EASY, I MCGUIRE MCGUIRE. I
KNOW BUG. SKINNER NUMBERED. AYE,
WIECKOWSKI. CASKEY AYE. OKAY 6
TO 0 WILL PUT THAT ON CALL. NEXT
WE'LL GO TO ITEM NUMBER THREE A.
B 12 88 BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S
QUIRK-SILVA. KIND OF. PLEASE
HAVE EMOTION. BY SENATOR
CABALLERO MOVED. AND WILL CALL
THE ROLL. THIS IS FOLLOWED IN
THREE IS SOMETHING BUILT 12 88
BY SOME MEMBER QUIRK-SILVA. THE
MOTION IS DUE PASS BUT FIRST BE
REFERRED TO COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE SENATOR
WIENER. AYE. FATES GIRL CAMARO.
I COURTESY I MCGUIRE MCGUIRE. I
KNOW BOB SKINNER, HAMBURG.
HAMBURG I WIECKOWSKI MCCASKEY.
AYE. SIX TO NOTHING WILL PUT
THAT ON CALL WILL NOW GO TO ITEM
NUMBER. FOR A B 14 10 BY SOME
MEMBER RODRIGUEZ. CAN I PLEASE
HAVE EMOTION? OKAY EMOTION BY
SENATOR MCGUIRE AND I THINK THEY
WANT. I THINK I'LL STAY AT THE
MOTION NOW. YEAH THE MOTION IS
DUE PAST BUT FIRST PEOPLE
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
JUDICIARY. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR WIENER I STATES,
CAMEROON. ORTEZ AYE, MCGUIRE.
ACQUIRE MACHO BUG SKINNER.
HAMBURG. BY HAMBURG. I
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE. 5 TO
0. UM THE MOST HAS ENOUGH
NOTABLE. PUT HER ON CALL WHEN I
GO TO ITEM NUMBER 5 80 14 45 BY
SOMEBODY MEMBER LEVIN, CAN I
PLEASE HAVE EMOTION? MOVED BY
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI AND THE
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED,
BUT FIRST DEMAND AND WE REFER
THE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. SENATOR
WIENER, I BATES. CALDERON.
CABALLERO NÓ ORTEZ, E I. MCGUIRE
ACQUIRE. AYE, KOBO. SKINNER,
HAMBURG. HAMBURG I WIECKOWSKI
WIECKOWSKI. AYE. HEY THE VOTERS
5 TO 1. WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL.
NEGATIVE ITEM NUMBER 6 80 15 51
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER'S SANTIAGO CAN
I PLEASE HAVE A MOTION? SO MOVED
BY SENATOR CORTESI AND THE
MOTION IS DUE PAST BUT FIRST
BEEF WE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND
FINANCE. PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
SENATOR WIENER. AYE, BATES
CABALLERO. ORTEZ ORTEZ? AYE
MCGUIRE. MCGUIRE, I TROW BUG.
SKINNER. SKINNER I HAMBURG. I
WIECKOWSKI WIECKOWSKI. AYE.
OKAY. WE'LL PUT THAT ON CALL. UM
OKAY. WE'RE NOW GONNA I THINK WE
HAVE ALL THE MEMBERS WERE GOING
TO HAVE SO WE'LL OPEN THE ROLE.
OKAY WE WILL START. UM WITH THE
ITEMS. SEVEN THAT CONSENT
CALENDAR. UH PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS. AND THE CONSENT
CALENDAR, WHICH CONSISTS OF FILE
ITEM SEVEN. SENATOR BATES PATROL
BUG. I'M SORRY. CAN YOU SUFFER?
MISTER CAN WE PLEASE DISCONNECT
THE PHONE LINES? THANK YOU. MR
MODERATOR, CAN YOU PLEASE MUTE
EVERYONE? WE'RE HEARING PEOPLE
ON THE PHONE LINE. OKAY. THANK
YOU. THAT LINE. THANK YOU. OKAY
I'M SORRY. UM, WHY DON'T WE
START AGAIN? LET'S OPEN THE ROLL
ON THE CONSENT CALENDAR. ON THE
CONCERN CALENDAR, WHICH CONSISTS
OF FILE ADAM SEVEN, SENATOR
BATES. PHð BUG BUG. I SKINNER.
SKINNER. AYE. K 7 TO 0. UH I'M
SORRY. EIGHT THIS YEAR. YES 8 TO
0 THAT CONSENT CALENDAR PASSES.
WE'LL GO BACK TO ITEM NUMBER
ONE. 84 11, PLEASE OPEN. PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. THIS IS
FILE ADAM ONE ASSEMBLY BILL 4 11
BY SOME MEMBER IRWIN. THE MOTION
IS DUE PASS. BUT FIRST WE
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNMENT AND FINANCE. WITH A
TEAR VOTING. AYE. SENATOR BATES
SO BUG. PHð BUG I. SKINNER.
SKINNER. AYE. OKAY IT TO ZERO.
THAT BILL IS OUT. UM ITEM TWO
HAS BEEN PULLED. IT'S GOING TO
BE SCHEDULED FOR LATER HEARING.
UM ITEM NUMBER THREE. PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. A B 12
88. THIS IS 53 SONNY BILL 12 88
BY SOME REMEMBER QUIRK-SILVA.
THE MOTION IS DO PASS THE FIRST
BE REFERRED TO COMMITTING
GOVERNMENTS FINANCE WITH THE
CHAIR. VOTING I, SENATOR BATES,
A CHILL BUG. SKINNER. HI. I.
OKAY, THAT BILL IS OUT. WELL,
NEXT GO TO ITEM NUMBER 4 14 10.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
THIS IS FINE AND FOUR. IT'S ONLY
ABOUT 14 10 BY SOME MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ. THE MOTION IS DUE
PASS. BUT FIRST WE REFERRED TO
COMMITTEE JUDICIARY WITH THE
CHAIR. VOTING I, SENATOR BATES.
CALDERON. PHùBUG. YEAH.
RODRIGUEZ. PHð BUGNO SKINNER.
SKINNER. AYE. THAT BILL IS OUT.
WELL NEXT GOOD ITEM NUMBER FIVE
B 14 45. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. THIS IS FIVE AND FIVE.
IT'S SOMETHING BILL 14 45 BISON
, THE MEMBER LEVIN. THE MOTION
IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED BUT FIRST
AMEND AND BE REFERRED TO THE
COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS WITH
A CHAIR VOTING AYE. SENATOR
BATES. PHð BUG. PHð BUGNO.
SKINNER SKINNER. AYE. THAT BILL
IS OUT. AND THEN FINALLY, UM 6
18 15 51. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS. THIS IS FOLLOWED, UM
SIX. SOMETHING BILL 15 51 BY
SOME MEMBER SANTIAGO. THE
MOTIONS DO PASS, BUT FIRST, HE
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCESENATOR
BATES CABALLERO. PHùBUG ROBO?
AYE. CLEAR THAT BILL IS OUT, SO
I BELIEVE WE'RE WE HAVE
COMPLETED OUR AGENDA. THANK YOU
. EVERYONE AND THE COMMITTEE ON
HOUSING IS ADJOURNED.