WEBVTT
00:00:28.561 --> 00:00:30.663
MENACE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:00:30.730 --> 00:00:33.933
ALLEN ARCHULETA ATKINS BATES
00:00:34.000 --> 00:00:38.905
BAKER FORTUS BRADFORD CABALLERO
00:00:38.972 --> 00:00:43.209
QUARTET THE VALLEY DODD TORONTO
00:00:43.276 --> 00:00:48.014
EGGMAN GLAZER GONZALEZ GROVE
00:00:48.081 --> 00:00:52.452
HERTZBERG WESO HER TADO JONES
00:00:52.519 --> 00:00:56.523
KAMLAGER LAYERED LEYVA LIMÓN
00:00:56.589 --> 00:01:01.661
MCGUIRE MELENDEZ BEEN NEWMAN
00:01:01.728 --> 00:01:05.098
NIELSEN A SHOW OF HANDS
00:01:05.165 --> 00:01:09.002
PORTANTINO ROTH RUBIO SKINNER
00:01:09.068 --> 00:01:14.674
STERN NUMBER WHY CASTING WIENER
00:01:14.741 --> 00:01:17.744
WILK. THANK YOU MADAM SECRETARY
00:01:17.811 --> 00:01:20.480
A QUORUM IS PRESENT MEMBERS
00:01:20.547 --> 00:01:21.581
WOULD YOU PLEASE RISE IN OUR
00:01:21.648 --> 00:01:22.949
GUESTS BEYOND THE REAL IN THE
00:01:23.016 --> 00:01:24.884
GALLERY PLEASE RISE AS WELL WILL
00:01:24.951 --> 00:01:26.653
BE LED IN PRAYER THIS MORNING BY
00:01:26.719 --> 00:01:28.555
SENATOR PAN AND AFTER WHICH
00:01:28.621 --> 00:01:30.690
PLEASE REMAIN STANDING AND WILL
00:01:30.757 --> 00:01:32.759
BE LED IN THE PLEDGE OF
00:01:32.826 --> 00:01:33.326
ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG BY
00:01:33.393 --> 00:01:35.462
SENATOR NEWMAN SENATOR PAM.
00:01:35.528 --> 00:01:38.264
THANK YOU LET US PRAY. COMMA A
00:01:38.331 --> 00:01:41.434
LIFE GIVING SPIRIT TRANSFORMERS
00:01:41.501 --> 00:01:43.470
STIR UP IN US THE FLAME OF LOVE
00:01:43.536 --> 00:01:45.705
WHICH IS YOUR GIFT. GIVE US
00:01:45.772 --> 00:01:48.808
WISDOM TO SEE IS YOU SEE. GIVE
00:01:48.875 --> 00:01:51.044
US UNDERSTANDING TO HEAR AS YOU
00:01:51.110 --> 00:01:53.346
HERE. GIVE US COURAGE AND
00:01:53.413 --> 00:01:56.082
STRENGTH THE WALK THE WAY OF
00:01:56.149 --> 00:01:57.450
JUSTICE AND INTEGRITY. CANDLE IN
00:01:57.517 --> 00:02:00.687
US THE WONDER AND WONDER AND AWE
00:02:00.753 --> 00:02:01.855
THAT WE MAY HAVE GRATEFUL
00:02:01.921 --> 00:02:05.058
SPIRITS. YOU WHO DWELL WITHIN US
00:02:05.124 --> 00:02:07.527
FILL US WITH LOVE AND DEVOTION
00:02:07.594 --> 00:02:09.562
GUIDE US IN OUR DAILY DECISIONS.
00:02:09.629 --> 00:02:11.965
HOLY WISDOM GIVE US DISCERNING
00:02:12.031 --> 00:02:14.033
HEARTS THAT WE MAKE CHOOSE WHAT
00:02:14.100 --> 00:02:15.902
IS NECESSARY TO THE COMMON GOOD
00:02:15.969 --> 00:02:17.370
AND FOR THE BENEFIT OF FUTURE
00:02:17.437 --> 00:02:21.941
GENERATIONS. A MAN. COLLARS
00:02:22.008 --> 00:02:23.209
PLEASE JOIN ME IN THE PLEDGE OF
00:02:23.276 --> 00:02:25.144
ALLEGIANCE I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE
00:02:25.211 --> 00:02:26.446
TO THE FLAG. OF THE UNITED
00:02:26.513 --> 00:02:34.521
STATES. BECAUSE. ONE INDIVIDUAL
00:02:34.587 --> 00:02:39.225
. S. MEMBERS CAN I PLEASE ASK
00:02:39.292 --> 00:02:40.159
YOU TO REMAIN STANDING AND
00:02:40.226 --> 00:02:43.129
VOEPEL YOUR HEADS WE ARE IN THE
00:02:43.196 --> 00:02:45.064
UNFORTUNATE SITUATION OF ASKING
00:02:45.131 --> 00:02:46.432
FOR A MOMENT OF SILENCE YET
00:02:46.499 --> 00:02:48.768
AGAIN FOR THE HORRIFIC MASS
00:02:48.835 --> 00:02:52.372
SHOOTING IN TEXAS. NINETEEN
00:02:52.438 --> 00:02:53.473
ELEMENTARY STUDENTS INTO
00:02:53.540 --> 00:02:55.742
EDUCATORS WERE MURDERED BY ALONE
00:02:55.808 --> 00:02:58.111
THAT MEANT. TODAY WE REMOTE WE
00:02:58.177 --> 00:02:59.946
REMEMBER AND REMINDED OF THE
00:03:00.013 --> 00:03:02.949
TRAGIC DEATH OF MR GEORGE FLOYD
00:03:03.016 --> 00:03:04.117
WHO WAS ALSO KILLED TWO YEARS
00:03:04.183 --> 00:03:19.666
AGO.
00:03:19.732 --> 00:03:26.072
THANK YOU MEMBERS. ALL RIGHT
00:03:26.139 --> 00:03:27.273
MESSAGES FROM THE GOVERNOR WILL
00:03:27.340 --> 00:03:29.576
BE DEEMED READ MESSAGES FROM THE
00:03:29.642 --> 00:03:31.544
ASSEMBLY WILL BE DEEMED READ
00:03:31.611 --> 00:03:33.546
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES WILL BE
00:03:33.613 --> 00:03:34.480
DEEMED READ AND AMENDMENTS
00:03:34.547 --> 00:03:36.382
ADOPTED MOTION MOTIONS
00:03:36.449 --> 00:03:37.951
RESOLUTIONS AND NOTICES THIS
00:03:38.017 --> 00:03:39.686
WOULD BE THE APPROPRIATE TIME TO
00:03:39.752 --> 00:03:41.487
PULL ANYTHING FROM THE FILE
00:03:41.554 --> 00:03:43.656
SEEING AND HEARING NOTHING WE
00:03:43.723 --> 00:03:45.858
WILL GO TO CONSIDERATION OF THE
00:03:45.925 --> 00:03:47.594
DAILY FILE WE'RE GOING TO START
00:03:47.660 --> 00:03:49.462
WITH SENATE THIRD READING AND
00:03:49.529 --> 00:03:50.597
WE'RE GOING TO START WITH FILE
00:03:50.663 --> 00:03:54.834
ITEM FIFTEEN. SENATOR BACKER.
00:03:54.901 --> 00:03:56.736
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
00:03:56.803 --> 00:03:58.805
SENATE BILL TWELVE TWENTY THREE
00:03:58.871 --> 00:04:00.039
BY SENATOR BACKER AND AFTER
00:04:00.106 --> 00:04:01.774
RELATING TO CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
00:04:01.841 --> 00:04:07.513
CENTER BECKER. A GOOD MORNING
00:04:07.580 --> 00:04:11.017
MEMBERS. SB TWELVE TWENTY THREE
00:04:11.084 --> 00:04:11.484
WILL ENSURE THAT MORE
00:04:11.551 --> 00:04:12.952
CALIFORNIANS RECEIVE MENTAL
00:04:13.019 --> 00:04:14.053
HEALTH SUPPORT AND RESOURCES
00:04:14.120 --> 00:04:15.855
THEY NEED BY SIMPLY INCREASING
00:04:15.922 --> 00:04:17.023
THE USE OF MENTAL HEALTH
00:04:17.090 --> 00:04:19.826
DIVERSION IN APPROPRIATE CASES
00:04:19.892 --> 00:04:21.728
IT'S RESEARCH AND RECOMMENDED BY
00:04:21.794 --> 00:04:22.428
THE COMMITTEE ON THE REVISION OF
00:04:22.495 --> 00:04:24.731
THE PENAL CODE AFTER FINDING THE
00:04:24.797 --> 00:04:25.565
MENTAL HEALTH VERSION HAS BEEN
00:04:25.632 --> 00:04:28.901
SUBSTANTIALLY UNDER UTILIZED. IT
00:04:28.968 --> 00:04:30.737
PRESERVES JUDICIAL X. DISCRETION
00:04:30.803 --> 00:04:32.572
AND IT'S CONSISTENT WITH WHAT
00:04:32.639 --> 00:04:34.507
OTHER STATES HAVE DONE ANY WORK
00:04:34.574 --> 00:04:36.643
WITH JUDICIAL COUNCIL C. P. D.
00:04:36.709 --> 00:04:39.045
A. THE ACLU AND OUR COUNTY
00:04:39.112 --> 00:04:41.814
BEHAVIOR HEALTH DEPARTMENTS ARE
00:04:41.881 --> 00:04:44.183
SPECIALLY ASK DR VOTE. THANK YOU
00:04:44.250 --> 00:04:45.852
CENTER BAKER MEMBERS ANY
00:04:45.918 --> 00:04:48.421
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
00:04:48.488 --> 00:04:50.156
HEARING NONE BETTER SECRETARY
00:04:50.223 --> 00:04:54.761
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN
00:04:54.827 --> 00:04:59.899
ARCHULETA I ATKINS AYE BATES.
00:04:59.966 --> 00:05:05.872
BAKER HI FOR JUST NO BRADFORD I
00:05:05.938 --> 00:05:10.309
CABALLERO OR TESTING I DALY. NO
00:05:10.376 --> 00:05:18.484
DODD. I TORONTO. EGGMAN I GLAZER
00:05:18.551 --> 00:05:26.793
I GONZALEZ I GROW. NO HERTZBERG
00:05:26.859 --> 00:05:31.864
WESO I FURTADO AYE JONES NO
00:05:31.931 --> 00:05:36.335
KAMLAGER I LAYERED I LEYVA I
00:05:36.402 --> 00:05:42.809
LIMON. I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ.
00:05:42.875 --> 00:05:47.013
MAN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. A CHOI
00:05:47.080 --> 00:05:54.721
BOGUE. PAN I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
00:05:54.787 --> 00:05:59.325
. I RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
00:05:59.392 --> 00:06:04.430
AYE NUMBER I Y. CASKEY I WIENER
00:06:04.497 --> 00:06:07.300
AYE WILK. NO SENATOR MOVES THE
00:06:07.366 --> 00:06:09.235
CALL MEMBERS JUST AS A HEADS UP
00:06:09.302 --> 00:06:11.170
WE WILL BE PUTTING ALL BILLS ON
00:06:11.237 --> 00:06:13.806
CALL FOR- FOR THE TEMPORARY TIME
00:06:13.873 --> 00:06:16.142
BEING WE'RE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
00:06:16.209 --> 00:06:18.177
SIXTEEN SENATOR ARCH ALETTA. AND
00:06:18.244 --> 00:06:20.279
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
00:06:20.346 --> 00:06:21.981
BILL ELEVEN THIRTY THREE BY
00:06:22.048 --> 00:06:23.416
SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
00:06:23.483 --> 00:06:25.585
RELATING TO PRICE GOUGING CENTER
00:06:25.651 --> 00:06:28.955
CHILLA. THANK YOU MANAGE YOUR- I
00:06:29.021 --> 00:06:30.490
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
00:06:30.556 --> 00:06:32.391
MEMBERS I RISE TODAY 2% SENATE
00:06:32.458 --> 00:06:35.161
BILL ELEVEN THIRTY THREE WHICH
00:06:35.228 --> 00:06:37.396
CLARIFIES EXISTING LAW OR WHEN
00:06:37.463 --> 00:06:39.732
A STATE OF EMERGENCY DECLARED.
00:06:39.799 --> 00:06:41.434
TO ENSURE BETTER COMPLIANCE AND
00:06:41.501 --> 00:06:43.336
PROTECTION FOR CONSUMERS IN THE
00:06:43.402 --> 00:06:44.771
MARKETPLACE THE ANTI PRICE
00:06:44.837 --> 00:06:46.639
GOUGING LAW THAT IS TRIGGERED
00:06:46.706 --> 00:06:49.308
AFTER A- AS STATE OF EMERGENCY
00:06:49.375 --> 00:06:51.110
DECLARED PROHIBITS MANY
00:06:51.177 --> 00:06:52.779
INDUSTRIES FROM INCREASING
00:06:52.845 --> 00:06:55.214
PRICES. BY MORE THAN 10% THE
00:06:55.281 --> 00:06:57.583
PENALTY FOR VIOLATING THIS LAW
00:06:57.650 --> 00:06:59.252
INCLUDE FINES AND JAIL TIME.
00:06:59.318 --> 00:07:00.520
ALTHOUGH THE PRICE GOUGING
00:07:00.586 --> 00:07:02.688
LIMITATION WAS ONLY INTENDED TO
00:07:02.755 --> 00:07:05.057
APPLY FOR THIRTY DAYS STATE AND
00:07:05.124 --> 00:07:06.192
LOCAL OFFICIALS HAVE EXTENDED
00:07:06.259 --> 00:07:08.127
NUMEROUS STATE OF EMERGENCY FOR
00:07:08.194 --> 00:07:10.429
MONTHS EVEN YEARS THEREBY MAKING
00:07:10.496 --> 00:07:12.131
THE CORRECT THIRTY DAY PERIOD
00:07:12.198 --> 00:07:14.934
UNAVAILABLE. OVER THE LAST TWO
00:07:15.001 --> 00:07:16.736
YEARS SOME EMERGENCIES DUE TO
00:07:16.803 --> 00:07:18.404
COVERT NINETEEN WILDFIRES AND
00:07:18.471 --> 00:07:20.339
DROUGHTS HAVE YET TO END
00:07:20.406 --> 00:07:22.408
UNFORTUNATELY THESE EXTENSIONS
00:07:22.475 --> 00:07:24.644
ARE NOT MADE PUBLIC BY STATE AND
00:07:24.710 --> 00:07:26.045
LOCAL OFFICIALS LEAVING
00:07:26.112 --> 00:07:28.314
BUSINESSES CONFUSED ON HOW TO
00:07:28.381 --> 00:07:29.849
PROPERLY COMPLY WITH EXISTING
00:07:29.916 --> 00:07:32.185
LAW. SENATE BILL ELEVEN THIRTY
00:07:32.251 --> 00:07:34.387
THREE FIXES THIS PROBLEM BY
00:07:34.453 --> 00:07:36.155
REQUIRING THE CALIFORNIA OFFICE
00:07:36.222 --> 00:07:37.857
OF EMERGENCY SERVICES TO UPDATE
00:07:37.924 --> 00:07:40.860
WEBSITE REGARDING ALL DECLARED
00:07:40.927 --> 00:07:42.228
EMERGENCIES PROCLAMATIONS
00:07:42.295 --> 00:07:44.397
ADDITIONALLY THE BILL REQUIRES
00:07:44.463 --> 00:07:46.566
SPECIFIC FINDINGS RELATED TO
00:07:46.632 --> 00:07:48.434
HOUSING IN ORDER TO CONTINUE TO
00:07:48.501 --> 00:07:49.902
THE STATE OF EMERGENCY THAT
00:07:49.969 --> 00:07:52.038
EXTENDS BEYOND ONE YEAR. THIS
00:07:52.104 --> 00:07:53.439
BILL PASSED WITH UNANIMOUS
00:07:53.506 --> 00:07:55.541
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT OUT OF THE
00:07:55.608 --> 00:07:59.011
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY FOR THESE
00:07:59.078 --> 00:08:00.112
REGIONS I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
00:08:00.179 --> 00:08:03.216
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
00:08:03.282 --> 00:08:05.451
ARCHULETA MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
00:08:05.518 --> 00:08:07.119
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING
00:08:07.186 --> 00:08:10.356
NONE MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
00:08:10.423 --> 00:08:16.762
THE ROLL. ALLEN I ARCHULETA HI
00:08:16.829 --> 00:08:22.635
ATKINS AYE BATES I BAKER.
00:08:22.702 --> 00:08:25.905
GORGEOUS AYE BRADFORD AYE
00:08:25.972 --> 00:08:30.409
CABALLERO CORTESE I DALY AYE
00:08:30.476 --> 00:08:34.847
DODD. I TORONTO. EGGMAN AYE
00:08:34.914 --> 00:08:40.453
GLAZER I GONZALEZ I GROWTH AYE
00:08:40.519 --> 00:08:45.191
HERTZBERG WESTERN. HER TADO.
00:08:45.258 --> 00:08:50.529
JONES I KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
00:08:50.596 --> 00:08:56.302
LEYVA AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE. I
00:08:56.369 --> 00:09:01.207
MELENDEZ MAN I NEWMAN AYE
00:09:01.274 --> 00:09:06.612
NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE. PAN I
00:09:06.679 --> 00:09:12.251
PORTANTINO I OTH AYE RUBIO.
00:09:12.318 --> 00:09:18.557
SKINNER HI STERN I AMBERG I
00:09:18.624 --> 00:09:22.061
WHITE HOUSE KING AYE WIENER AYE
00:09:22.128 --> 00:09:26.132
WILK I. CENTER MOVES A CALL
00:09:26.198 --> 00:09:27.967
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
00:09:28.034 --> 00:09:30.369
ITEM NINETEEN ALSO SENATOR ARCH
00:09:30.436 --> 00:09:32.438
ALETTA MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
00:09:32.505 --> 00:09:34.807
READ SENATE BILL ELEVEN ELEVEN
00:09:34.874 --> 00:09:36.509
BY SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
00:09:36.575 --> 00:09:39.211
RELATING TO PUBLIC SAFETY CENTER
00:09:39.278 --> 00:09:40.313
CHULA. THANK YOU BETTER
00:09:40.379 --> 00:09:42.081
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT
00:09:42.148 --> 00:09:43.916
SENATE BILL ELEVEN ELEVEN THE
00:09:43.983 --> 00:09:46.218
REQUEST SAFETY ACT NAMED AFTER
00:09:46.285 --> 00:09:48.254
LONG TIME LEGISLATIVE STAFF AND
00:09:48.321 --> 00:09:50.790
LOBBYISTS. RICK BEST TO SADLY
00:09:50.856 --> 00:09:52.591
PASSED AWAY AFTER TRAFFIC
00:09:52.658 --> 00:09:54.260
ACCIDENT WITH AN UNMARKED
00:09:54.327 --> 00:09:56.862
DUMPSTER THIS IS A COMMON SENSE
00:09:56.929 --> 00:09:58.998
MEASURE WILL REQUIRE LARGE TRASH
00:09:59.065 --> 00:10:00.599
RECEPTACLES PLACED ON ROZIER
00:10:00.666 --> 00:10:02.668
CURBSIDE. TO HAVE REFLECTIVE
00:10:02.735 --> 00:10:04.603
MARKETING ON EACH SIDE TO
00:10:04.670 --> 00:10:06.906
PREVENT DEATHS ACCIDENTS AND
00:10:06.973 --> 00:10:09.809
INJURY. SENATE BILL ELEVEN
00:10:09.875 --> 00:10:11.344
ELEVEN IS AN IMPORTANT STEP.
00:10:11.410 --> 00:10:13.212
HERE IN CALIFORNIA AND IT COULD
00:10:13.279 --> 00:10:15.948
REALLY IMPROVE OUR ROADWAY FOR
00:10:16.015 --> 00:10:18.217
MOTORISTS AND BIKEL'S BY TILLIS
00:10:18.284 --> 00:10:20.353
ALIGHT. WITHOUT REFLECTIVE
00:10:20.419 --> 00:10:22.021
MARKETING LARGE DRESSES UP GIRLS
00:10:22.088 --> 00:10:23.990
PLACED ON ROADS OR CURBS ARE
00:10:24.056 --> 00:10:25.658
VIRTUALLY INVISIBLE ON A DARK
00:10:25.725 --> 00:10:27.693
STREET AND PRESENT HAS RISK TO
00:10:27.760 --> 00:10:29.829
THE GENERAL PUBLIC. HEAVY LOADED
00:10:29.895 --> 00:10:31.797
YARD WASTE CANS ARE ESSENTIALLY
00:10:31.864 --> 00:10:33.833
IMMOVABLE OBJECTS AND ARE AT
00:10:33.899 --> 00:10:36.502
RISK WE'RE NOT COLORED PROPERLY
00:10:36.569 --> 00:10:39.171
OR MARK. TO OFTEN YOU SEE THE
00:10:39.238 --> 00:10:40.906
DRAFT RECEPTACLE BLOCK IN A
00:10:40.973 --> 00:10:43.476
BICYCLE LANE CAUSING BICYCLISTS
00:10:43.542 --> 00:10:45.378
TO VEER OUT OF THE BIKE LANES IT
00:10:45.444 --> 00:10:47.413
INTO THE TRAFFIC LANE. AS YOU
00:10:47.480 --> 00:10:50.149
KNOW IN RICK'S SCENARIO A DRIVER
00:10:50.216 --> 00:10:52.385
BICYCLIST RIDING ALONG AT NIGHT
00:10:52.451 --> 00:10:54.553
CAN POTENTIALLY RUN INTO ONE OF
00:10:54.620 --> 00:10:57.089
THESE FULL LOADED RECEPTACLES
00:10:57.156 --> 00:10:58.858
AND BECOME SERIOUSLY INJURED
00:10:58.924 --> 00:11:00.126
STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT THE
00:11:00.192 --> 00:11:01.961
EFFECTIVENESS OF RETRO
00:11:02.028 --> 00:11:04.163
REFLECTIVE MARKETING TO ENHANCE
00:11:04.230 --> 00:11:05.698
VISIBILITY. FURTHERMORE
00:11:05.765 --> 00:11:07.466
CALIFORNIA ALREADY UTILIZE OF
00:11:07.533 --> 00:11:09.101
REFLECTIVE MARKED IN ON OUR
00:11:09.168 --> 00:11:10.836
ROADS TRAFFIC SIGNS AND LICENSE
00:11:10.903 --> 00:11:13.406
PLATES JUST TO NAME A FEW SB
00:11:13.472 --> 00:11:14.340
ELEVEN ELEVEN SEEKS TO IMPROVE
00:11:14.407 --> 00:11:16.642
NIGHTTIME VISIBILITY AND ENHANCE
00:11:16.709 --> 00:11:19.612
SAFETY AND THEY BLAME MORE TIME.
00:11:19.678 --> 00:11:22.081
FOR THE BIKES LIST. TO SEE THE
00:11:22.148 --> 00:11:27.753
OBSTACLE THERE AND- SAVE. JURY I
00:11:27.820 --> 00:11:28.387
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
00:11:28.454 --> 00:11:29.889
THANK YOU CENTER ARE MEMBERS
00:11:29.955 --> 00:11:31.490
DISCUSS OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
00:11:31.557 --> 00:11:33.459
HEARING NONE. MADAM SECRETARY
00:11:33.526 --> 00:11:38.731
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
00:11:38.798 --> 00:11:43.736
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
00:11:43.803 --> 00:11:48.674
BAKER I PORCHES AYE BRADFORD I
00:11:48.741 --> 00:11:52.645
HAVE ITEM OR TESTING I DALY AYE
00:11:52.711 --> 00:11:57.917
DODD. I TORONTO EGGMAN AYE
00:11:57.983 --> 00:12:03.222
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I WROTE.
00:12:03.289 --> 00:12:08.527
HERTZBERG WESO. I HER DAUGHTER.
00:12:08.594 --> 00:12:15.501
JONES KAMLAGER I FLARED I LEYVA
00:12:15.568 --> 00:12:22.007
AYE MON I MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ.
00:12:22.074 --> 00:12:27.980
MAN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN.
00:12:28.047 --> 00:12:35.454
CONTROL OF BOTH. PAN. PORTANTINO
00:12:35.521 --> 00:12:39.125
PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
00:12:39.191 --> 00:12:45.698
RUBIO. SKINNER I STERN HI I'M
00:12:45.764 --> 00:12:49.502
BURKE I WHITE HOUSE E. I WIENER
00:12:49.568 --> 00:12:52.771
I WILK I DIDN'T REMOVE THE CALL
00:12:52.838 --> 00:12:55.007
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
00:12:55.074 --> 00:12:56.008
TWENTY THREE SENATOR OCHO OF
00:12:56.075 --> 00:12:59.145
BOTH MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
00:12:59.211 --> 00:13:00.846
. SENATE BILL TWELVE SEVENTY
00:13:00.913 --> 00:13:02.214
NINE BY SENATOR CHOI BOGUE AN
00:13:02.281 --> 00:13:04.450
ACT RELATING TO GUARDIANS AD
00:13:04.517 --> 00:13:06.752
LITEM CENTER SHOWBOAT. THANK YOU
00:13:06.819 --> 00:13:09.255
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SB
00:13:09.321 --> 00:13:10.089
TWELVE SEVENTY NINE WILL
00:13:10.156 --> 00:13:10.789
STRENGTHENING CODIFY SEVERAL
00:13:10.856 --> 00:13:12.458
ASPECTS OF GUARDIAN ADLAI ITEM
00:13:12.525 --> 00:13:14.960
ALSO CALL GAO APPOINTMENTS THAT
00:13:15.027 --> 00:13:16.262
OFTEN OCCUR INFORMALLY OR
00:13:16.328 --> 00:13:17.596
WITHOUT CLEAR GUIDANCE FOR
00:13:17.663 --> 00:13:19.231
LITIGANTS AND THEIR LAWYERS THIS
00:13:19.298 --> 00:13:20.699
BILL WILL RESOLVE AMBIGUITIES
00:13:20.766 --> 00:13:23.235
ENDS IN THE STATUTE AS TO WHO IS
00:13:23.302 --> 00:13:25.004
CONSIDERED. AN INCAPACITATED
00:13:25.070 --> 00:13:26.238
PERSON FOR WHOM A GUARDIAN AD
00:13:26.305 --> 00:13:27.973
LIGHT ON MAY BE APPOINTED
00:13:28.040 --> 00:13:28.841
ALTHOUGH THE PURPOSE OF A
00:13:28.908 --> 00:13:30.776
GEOLOGIST TO ENSURE THE
00:13:30.843 --> 00:13:32.344
INDIVIDUALS RIGHTS ARE PROTECTED
00:13:32.411 --> 00:13:34.280
IN LITIGATION. OFTEN THEY'RE
00:13:34.346 --> 00:13:35.748
APPOINTED BY THE COURT WITHOUT
00:13:35.814 --> 00:13:37.383
CLEAR PARAMETERS AROUND THEIR
00:13:37.449 --> 00:13:39.485
POWERS OR WHAT THE REPORTING
00:13:39.552 --> 00:13:41.487
RESPONSIBILITIES ARE IN ADDITION
00:13:41.554 --> 00:13:42.821
ALTHOUGH THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL
00:13:42.888 --> 00:13:43.956
FORM REQUIRES DISCLOSURE OF
00:13:44.023 --> 00:13:45.357
CONFLICT OF INTEREST ON BEHALF
00:13:45.424 --> 00:13:47.259
OF THE PROPOSED OUT HE DOES NOT
00:13:47.326 --> 00:13:48.694
CURRENTLY REQUIRED BY STATUTE.
00:13:48.761 --> 00:13:50.162
THESE AMBIGUITIES HAVE LED TO
00:13:50.229 --> 00:13:51.730
UNEVEN PRACTICE ACROSS THE STATE
00:13:51.797 --> 00:13:53.299
CONFUSION AMONG LITIGANTS AND AS
00:13:53.365 --> 00:13:55.501
WELL AS ABUSES EXISTING PROBATE
00:13:55.568 --> 00:13:58.170
CODE SECTION ONE ZERO ZERO THREE
00:13:58.237 --> 00:13:59.071
SUBDIVISION EIGHT AND THE CODE
00:13:59.138 --> 00:14:01.173
OF CIVIL PROCEDURE SECTION THREE
00:14:01.240 --> 00:14:02.107
SEVENTY TWO DO NOT SET FORTH
00:14:02.174 --> 00:14:04.376
CLEAR REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR
00:14:04.443 --> 00:14:06.579
THE JAILS. GALS OR AND ALSO
00:14:06.645 --> 00:14:07.546
COMPLETE WITH THEIR DECISION OF
00:14:07.613 --> 00:14:09.882
WHO REGARD GUARDIAN ADLAI ITEM
00:14:09.949 --> 00:14:11.584
MAY BE APPOINTED FOR. THROUGH
00:14:11.650 --> 00:14:13.018
CLARIFYING AND MAKING HIS SYSTEM
00:14:13.085 --> 00:14:15.287
THE POWERS OF JAILS ARE GALS
00:14:15.354 --> 00:14:15.854
INDIVIDUALS WILL BE FURTHER
00:14:15.921 --> 00:14:17.523
PROTECTED FROM ABUSE I'M
00:14:17.590 --> 00:14:19.024
COMMITTED TO WORKING WITH THE
00:14:19.091 --> 00:14:20.259
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA TO
00:14:20.326 --> 00:14:21.227
ADDRESS THEIR CONCERNS AND LOOK
00:14:21.293 --> 00:14:22.494
FORWARD TO CONTINUING THE
00:14:22.561 --> 00:14:24.663
CONVERSATION I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:14:24.730 --> 00:14:26.265
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
00:14:26.332 --> 00:14:27.132
CENTER- CHAU BOGUT MEMBERS JUST
00:14:27.199 --> 00:14:33.372
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING.
00:14:33.439 --> 00:14:34.106
NONE M. SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
00:14:34.173 --> 00:14:37.209
THE ROLL. ALLEN I TO LET. AYE AT
00:14:37.276 --> 00:14:42.181
. AYE BATES. I BAKER I PORCHES
00:14:42.248 --> 00:14:45.451
HI BRADFORD I HAVE MY OTHER
00:14:45.517 --> 00:14:49.888
CORTESE I DALY AYE DODD. I
00:14:49.955 --> 00:14:55.794
TORONTO. EGGMAN AYE GLAZER I
00:14:55.861 --> 00:15:00.666
GONZALEZ I GROWTH. I HERTZBERG
00:15:00.733 --> 00:15:07.439
WESSEL I FURTADO. JONES. HI
00:15:07.506 --> 00:15:13.479
KAMLAGER. I LAYERED I LEYVA AYE
00:15:13.545 --> 00:15:19.118
THE MON. I MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ
00:15:19.184 --> 00:15:24.423
AYE MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
00:15:24.490 --> 00:15:28.560
AYE A CHOI BOGUE. I PAN. I
00:15:28.627 --> 00:15:32.731
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
00:15:32.798 --> 00:15:40.139
AYE SKINNER. I STERN. I'M BURKE
00:15:40.205 --> 00:15:46.912
I BY CASKEY. I WIENER I WILK HI
00:15:46.979 --> 00:15:48.580
. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
00:15:48.647 --> 00:15:57.456
CABALLERO. TORONTO. HERTZBERG
00:15:57.523 --> 00:16:10.402
HER TADO I. STERN I. TORONTO I'D
00:16:10.469 --> 00:16:21.747
- YEAH. SENATOR MOVES THE CALL
00:16:21.814 --> 00:16:23.215
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
00:16:23.282 --> 00:16:25.117
ITEM TWENTY FIVE SENATOR ARCH
00:16:25.184 --> 00:16:27.019
ALETTA MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
00:16:27.086 --> 00:16:30.155
READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE NINETY
00:16:30.222 --> 00:16:31.924
ONE BY SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
00:16:31.990 --> 00:16:33.492
RELATING TO ENERGY CENTER
00:16:33.559 --> 00:16:36.528
ARCHULETA. THANK YOU BETTER
00:16:36.595 --> 00:16:38.197
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT
00:16:38.263 --> 00:16:40.132
SENATE BILL TWELVE NINETY ONE
00:16:40.199 --> 00:16:41.266
WHICH DIRECTION LOCAL
00:16:41.333 --> 00:16:42.601
GOVERNMENTS TO EXPAND THEIR
00:16:42.668 --> 00:16:44.536
EXISTING ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVAL
00:16:44.603 --> 00:16:46.071
PROCESS FOR THE PERMITTING OF
00:16:46.138 --> 00:16:46.772
ZERO EMISSION VEHICLE
00:16:46.839 --> 00:16:48.374
INFRASTRUCTURE TO INCLUDE
00:16:48.440 --> 00:16:50.409
HYDROGEN FUELING INFRASTRUCTURE
00:16:50.476 --> 00:16:52.678
AND ALLOW FOR DENIAL. OF THOSE
00:16:52.745 --> 00:16:55.614
PERMITS BASED ON HEALTH AND
00:16:55.681 --> 00:16:57.850
SAFETY ONLY UNDER THE EMERGENCY-
00:16:57.916 --> 00:16:59.518
THAT THIS WOULD CAUSE A TO I'M
00:16:59.585 --> 00:17:01.687
SORRY IT MAY GO BACK SB TWELVE
00:17:01.754 --> 00:17:03.288
NODE ONE WILL EASE PERMITTING
00:17:03.355 --> 00:17:04.623
REQUIREMENTS WITHOUT SACRIFICING
00:17:04.690 --> 00:17:06.625
LOCAL CONTROL ENSURING THAT
00:17:06.692 --> 00:17:08.293
ELECTRIC CHARGING STATIONS AND
00:17:08.360 --> 00:17:10.429
HYDROGEN FUELING STATIONS ARE
00:17:10.496 --> 00:17:12.097
BEING INSTALLED IN ORDER TO KEEP
00:17:12.164 --> 00:17:13.899
PACE WITH THE STATE'S GOAL OF
00:17:13.966 --> 00:17:14.800
INCREASING TECHNICAL BILL
00:17:14.867 --> 00:17:16.568
BECAUSE- A USAGE AND HYDROGEN
00:17:16.635 --> 00:17:19.438
FUELING STATION FOR THESE
00:17:19.505 --> 00:17:20.639
REGIONS I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
00:17:20.706 --> 00:17:22.474
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
00:17:22.541 --> 00:17:23.142
ARCHULETA MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
00:17:23.208 --> 00:17:25.244
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING
00:17:25.310 --> 00:17:27.546
NONE M. SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
00:17:27.613 --> 00:17:33.218
THE ROLL. ALLEN I ARCHULETA I
00:17:33.285 --> 00:17:37.790
ATKINS AYE BATES AYE BACKER AYE
00:17:37.856 --> 00:17:41.093
FORTUS AYE BRADFORD AYE
00:17:41.160 --> 00:17:45.931
CABALLERO. PORTENDING I DOLLY.
00:17:45.998 --> 00:17:51.270
DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
00:17:51.336 --> 00:17:56.842
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROWTH I
00:17:56.909 --> 00:18:00.979
HERTZBERG WESSEL I HER DAUGHTER
00:18:01.046 --> 00:18:06.251
I JONES I KAMLAGER. I LAYERED
00:18:06.318 --> 00:18:12.658
AYE LEYVA AYE THE MON. MCGUIRE I
00:18:12.724 --> 00:18:17.930
MELENDEZ AYE MIN I NEWMAN AYE
00:18:17.996 --> 00:18:23.569
NIELSEN AYE TELEVOTE AYE PAN. I
00:18:23.635 --> 00:18:27.840
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
00:18:27.906 --> 00:18:35.214
AYE SKINNER. I STERN. AMBERG WHY
00:18:35.280 --> 00:18:41.620
CASTING. HI I WIENER AYE WILK HI
00:18:41.687 --> 00:18:44.623
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
00:18:44.690 --> 00:18:51.597
CABALLERO I DALLY I. GLAZER
00:18:51.663 --> 00:18:58.437
HERTZBERG LIMON I STERN. AMBERG
00:18:58.504 --> 00:19:02.074
HI IS THIRTY SEVEN NO ZERO THE
00:19:02.140 --> 00:19:03.876
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
00:19:03.942 --> 00:19:06.011
MOVING TO FILE ITEM TWENTY SEVEN
00:19:06.078 --> 00:19:08.647
SENATOR SKINNER. BEN SECRETARY
00:19:08.714 --> 00:19:11.216
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE
00:19:11.283 --> 00:19:12.718
HUNDRED BY SENATOR SKINNER AN
00:19:12.784 --> 00:19:14.286
ACT RELATING TO CIVIL PROCEDURE
00:19:14.353 --> 00:19:17.322
CENTERS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH-
00:19:17.389 --> 00:19:21.493
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS- WE ARE
00:19:21.560 --> 00:19:23.362
AND THEN FORTUNATE SITUATION OF
00:19:23.428 --> 00:19:26.064
. HAVING THE ECONOMY'S REBOUND
00:19:26.131 --> 00:19:28.600
FROM THE PANDEMIC BUT STILL HIGH
00:19:28.667 --> 00:19:31.537
INFLATION AND MANY PEOPLE
00:19:31.603 --> 00:19:35.541
STRUGGLING WE'VE GOT 61% OF THE
00:19:35.607 --> 00:19:37.676
POPULATION ACROSS THE US ARE
00:19:37.743 --> 00:19:39.578
ESTIMATED TO BE LIVING PAYCHECK
00:19:39.645 --> 00:19:42.514
TO PAYCHECK AND PERSONAL DEBT.
00:19:42.581 --> 00:19:45.751
INCREASED BY 6% LAST YEAR AN
00:19:45.817 --> 00:19:47.586
UNEXPECTED MEDICAL BILL CAR
00:19:47.653 --> 00:19:51.390
REPAIR. VARIOUS THINGS LIKE THAT
00:19:51.456 --> 00:19:54.826
CAN LEAD TO A SPIRAL OF PEOPLE
00:19:54.893 --> 00:19:56.662
FALLING INTO DEBT AND THEN
00:19:56.728 --> 00:19:59.698
SUFFERING THE SITUATION WHERE
00:19:59.765 --> 00:20:02.334
THEY GET A COURT ORDER JUDGMENT
00:20:02.401 --> 00:20:05.203
FROM A DEBT COLLECTOR NOW. THE
00:20:05.270 --> 00:20:06.672
DEBT COLLECTOR WHEN THEY RECEIVE
00:20:06.738 --> 00:20:08.373
A COURT ORDER JUDGMENT HAS THE
00:20:08.440 --> 00:20:11.677
ABILITY TO THEN GARNISH WAGES-
00:20:11.743 --> 00:20:13.412
CAP INTO A BANK ACCOUNT PUT A
00:20:13.478 --> 00:20:14.980
LIEN ON PROPERTY VARIOUS OTHER
00:20:15.047 --> 00:20:17.182
THINGS BUT THE OTHER THING THAT
00:20:17.249 --> 00:20:19.651
ARE CALIFORNIA LAW DOES
00:20:19.718 --> 00:20:21.987
ADDITIONALLY IS REQUIRES THE
00:20:22.054 --> 00:20:24.823
COURT TO PUT A 10% INTEREST RATE
00:20:24.890 --> 00:20:26.792
ON THAT COURT ORDERED JUDGMENT.
00:20:26.858 --> 00:20:29.027
NOW MANY OTHER STATES HAVE BEEN
00:20:29.094 --> 00:20:30.562
REDUCING THEIR INTEREST RATES
00:20:30.629 --> 00:20:32.464
ARE ALREADY HAD LOWER INTEREST
00:20:32.531 --> 00:20:33.799
RATES NEW YORK FOR EXAMPLE LAST
00:20:33.865 --> 00:20:36.201
YEAR PASSED A LAW TO REQUIRE
00:20:36.268 --> 00:20:38.437
ONLY A 2% INTEREST RATE THE
00:20:38.503 --> 00:20:40.372
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ONLY REQUIRES
00:20:40.439 --> 00:20:42.674
PRIME FOR SUCH DEBT JUDGMENTS
00:20:42.741 --> 00:20:45.911
WHAT THIS BILL DOES. IS LOWERS
00:20:45.978 --> 00:20:48.914
THE INTEREST RATES SOLELY IN
00:20:48.981 --> 00:20:51.416
ONLY ON. COURT ORDERED JUDGMENTS
00:20:51.483 --> 00:20:54.286
ON PERSONAL DEBT WITH A CAP OF
00:20:54.353 --> 00:20:56.788
THEIR PERSONAL DEBT AT FIFTY
00:20:56.855 --> 00:20:57.856
THOUSAND SO IF YOU HAVE MUCH
00:20:57.923 --> 00:20:59.591
HIGHER PERSONAL DEBT YOU WOULD
00:20:59.658 --> 00:21:01.493
NOT BENEFIT FROM THIS BILL.
00:21:01.560 --> 00:21:03.128
UNLESS IT IS MEDICAL DEBT THE
00:21:03.195 --> 00:21:05.030
CAP FOR MEDICAL DEBT IS TWO
00:21:05.097 --> 00:21:07.566
HUNDRED THOUSAND. SO THIS BILL
00:21:07.633 --> 00:21:09.768
BASICALLY MAKES IT A LITTLE
00:21:09.835 --> 00:21:11.169
EASIER FOR FAMILIES TO GET
00:21:11.236 --> 00:21:13.605
BEHIND TO PAY THAT DEBT IN GET
00:21:13.672 --> 00:21:15.841
OUT OF A CYCLE OF DEBT. AND
00:21:15.907 --> 00:21:16.942
THAT'S REALLY THE PURPOSE OF THE
00:21:17.009 --> 00:21:18.710
BILL AND I APPRECIATE THE
00:21:18.777 --> 00:21:21.713
JUDICIAL COMMITTEES. HELP IN
00:21:21.780 --> 00:21:23.548
MAKING VARIOUS AMENDMENTS THAT
00:21:23.615 --> 00:21:26.985
SET THE INTEREST RATE FOR THE
00:21:27.052 --> 00:21:29.755
BILL AT CRIME. AND WITH THAT I
00:21:29.821 --> 00:21:31.623
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
00:21:31.690 --> 00:21:34.126
CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS
00:21:34.192 --> 00:21:36.461
DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE. SEEING
00:21:36.528 --> 00:21:38.163
AND HEARING NONE BOOKS WHO MY
00:21:38.230 --> 00:21:40.499
MISSING CENTER BROCK I AM SORRY
00:21:40.565 --> 00:21:41.133
THE PRESIDING OFFICER PLENTY OF
00:21:41.199 --> 00:21:42.768
CLASSES. PLEASE PROCEED WHEN
00:21:42.834 --> 00:21:45.704
YOU'RE READY. THANK MATTER
00:21:45.771 --> 00:21:46.838
PRESENT JUST A QUICK QUESTION OF
00:21:46.905 --> 00:21:49.274
THE AUTHOR WE TAKE A QUESTION
00:21:49.341 --> 00:21:50.275
CENTER SKINNER YES PLEASE
00:21:50.342 --> 00:21:52.944
PROCEED. I THINK I'VE GOT THE
00:21:53.011 --> 00:21:55.047
RIGHT BILL WHEN I LOOKED AT THIS
00:21:55.113 --> 00:21:56.348
BILL AND I COMPARED IT TO THE
00:21:56.415 --> 00:21:58.116
CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE IT
00:21:58.183 --> 00:21:59.117
APPEARED THAT THE INITIAL
00:21:59.184 --> 00:21:59.951
VERSION OF THE BILL. HAVE A
00:22:00.018 --> 00:22:01.653
BROAD IMPACT ON COLLECTION
00:22:01.720 --> 00:22:03.722
ACTIVITIES WITH RESPECT TO- THE
00:22:03.789 --> 00:22:04.990
JUDGMENTS AND RENEWAL OF
00:22:05.057 --> 00:22:06.925
JUDGMENTS AND THE LIKE. AND I
00:22:06.992 --> 00:22:10.362
DIDN'T HEAR YOU ADDRESS. THAT IN
00:22:10.429 --> 00:22:11.363
YOUR PRESENTATION AND I'M
00:22:11.430 --> 00:22:13.365
WONDERING. IF YOUR INTENT IS TO
00:22:13.432 --> 00:22:15.267
REDUCE THE IMPACT OF THAT TO THE
00:22:15.333 --> 00:22:16.735
CONSUMER DEBT THAT YOU'RE
00:22:16.802 --> 00:22:18.837
ATTEMPTING TO ADDRESS. IN THE
00:22:18.904 --> 00:22:20.672
BILL IF I HAVE THE RIGHT BILL
00:22:20.739 --> 00:22:22.874
YES YOU HAVE THE RIGHT BILL AND
00:22:22.941 --> 00:22:25.177
IT IS THE INTENT OF THE BILL TO
00:22:25.243 --> 00:22:27.846
ALSO. BUY LIMIT THESE RENEWALS
00:22:27.913 --> 00:22:30.816
OF THE JUDGMENT NOT TO LIMIT THE
00:22:30.882 --> 00:22:33.085
ABILITY FOR THE COLLECTOR TO.
00:22:33.151 --> 00:22:35.721
COLLECT BUT RATHER FOR RENEWALS
00:22:35.787 --> 00:22:38.190
ON THOSE- JUDGMENTS THAT HAVE
00:22:38.256 --> 00:22:40.392
NOT HAD COLLECTION INITIATED AND
00:22:40.459 --> 00:22:42.828
I THINK- WHAT YOU HAVE POINTED
00:22:42.894 --> 00:22:46.565
OUT. IS THAT THE DRAFTING MAY
00:22:46.631 --> 00:22:48.033
HAVE AN ERROR AND WE'RE STILL
00:22:48.100 --> 00:22:49.701
WORKING ON THAT THAT WOULD HAVE
00:22:49.768 --> 00:22:51.269
COVERED A BROADER SET OF
00:22:51.336 --> 00:22:53.338
JUDGMENTS BUT OUR INTENTION IS
00:22:53.405 --> 00:22:58.043
pJUDGMENTS IN THE SAME WAY THAT
00:22:58.110 --> 00:23:00.112
THIS BILL IS COVERING AND SO WE
00:23:00.178 --> 00:23:01.246
ARE WORKING NOW WITH PLEDGE
00:23:01.313 --> 00:23:03.849
COUNCIL TO DETERMINE- WHETHER
00:23:03.915 --> 00:23:05.450
THERE IS THAT DRAFTING AARON IF
00:23:05.517 --> 00:23:08.120
THERE IS AS YOU HAVE AS YOU IN-
00:23:08.186 --> 00:23:10.856
HAVE. YOUR READING OF THE BILL
00:23:10.922 --> 00:23:12.991
THEN WE WILL CORRECT THAT IN THE
00:23:13.058 --> 00:23:14.626
NEXT HOUSE. FRIEDMAN PRESIDENT
00:23:14.693 --> 00:23:16.495
OF MY OWN TIME FOR JUST A SECOND
00:23:16.561 --> 00:23:17.996
THANK YOU- THANK ME THANKS TO
00:23:18.063 --> 00:23:19.064
THE AUTHOR FOR DRESSING THIS
00:23:19.131 --> 00:23:20.699
BECAUSE AS YOU WELL KNOW.
00:23:20.766 --> 00:23:22.100
JUDGMENTS UTILIZED IN A WIDE
00:23:22.167 --> 00:23:24.202
VARIETY OF AREAS FROM MEDICAL
00:23:24.269 --> 00:23:26.004
MALPRACTICE CASES TO REAL ESTATE
00:23:26.071 --> 00:23:28.273
DISPUTES TO CIVIL ACTIONS. AND
00:23:28.340 --> 00:23:30.041
BECAUSE OF THE SIZE OF THE
00:23:30.108 --> 00:23:31.810
JUDGMENTS WHETHER IT'S- FORTY
00:23:31.877 --> 00:23:33.545
SEVEN MILLION DOLLARS LIKE ONE
00:23:33.612 --> 00:23:35.714
OF MY FRIENDS OF. SECURE NOT TOO
00:23:35.781 --> 00:23:37.783
LONG AGO OR FIVE MILLION DOLLARS
00:23:37.849 --> 00:23:39.885
OR FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND OR
00:23:39.951 --> 00:23:40.952
FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLARS IN THE
00:23:41.019 --> 00:23:42.287
CIVIL CONTEXT SOMETIMES IT'S
00:23:42.354 --> 00:23:45.090
IMPORTANT TO. NOT ONLY- OBTAINED
00:23:45.157 --> 00:23:47.325
A JUDGMENT DO WHAT'S NECESSARY
00:23:47.392 --> 00:23:49.494
TO FILE THE LIENS BUT TO RENEW
00:23:49.561 --> 00:23:50.629
THAT JUDGMENT BEYOND THE TEN
00:23:50.695 --> 00:23:53.064
YEARS IN A ROW FACT COLLECTION
00:23:53.131 --> 00:23:54.499
PARTICULARLY. OF LARGE JUDGMENTS
00:23:54.566 --> 00:23:56.201
WHICH HAVE. THIS IS NOTHING TO
00:23:56.268 --> 00:23:58.103
DO WITH CONSUMER DEBT SO RIGHT
00:23:58.170 --> 00:23:59.571
AS LONG AS IT'S RESTRICTED TO
00:23:59.638 --> 00:24:00.305
CONSUMER DEBT I'M FINE WITH
00:24:00.372 --> 00:24:02.174
THAT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
00:24:02.240 --> 00:24:04.009
TAKING MY QUESTION THANK YOU THE
00:24:04.075 --> 00:24:06.011
CENTER ROTH MEMBERS FURTHER
00:24:06.077 --> 00:24:08.580
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
00:24:08.647 --> 00:24:10.215
HEARING NINE CENTER SKINNER WAS
00:24:10.282 --> 00:24:12.050
LIKE TO CLOSE BY US FOR A VOTE
00:24:12.117 --> 00:24:16.488
THANK YOU MADAM. SECRETARY
00:24:16.555 --> 00:24:17.656
PLEASE READ OUR CULTURAL. ALLEN
00:24:17.722 --> 00:24:20.792
I ARCHULETA I ATKINS AYE BATES.
00:24:20.859 --> 00:24:27.899
BAKER I PORCHES. NO BRADFORD AYE
00:24:27.966 --> 00:24:31.503
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
00:24:31.570 --> 00:24:35.407
DALY NO DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
00:24:35.473 --> 00:24:41.079
EGGMAN. I GLAZER. GONZALEZ I
00:24:41.146 --> 00:24:48.854
GROWTH. HERTZBERG WELCOME. HER
00:24:48.920 --> 00:24:55.493
TADO. I JONES NO KAMLAGER I
00:24:55.560 --> 00:24:59.764
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE
00:24:59.831 --> 00:25:05.537
MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ. NO MAN.
00:25:05.604 --> 00:25:11.676
NEWMAN I NIELSEN. NIELSEN NO A
00:25:11.743 --> 00:25:15.413
CHOI BOGUE. NO PAN AYE
00:25:15.480 --> 00:25:19.484
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO. I
00:25:19.551 --> 00:25:25.390
SKINNER. I STERN AYE I'M BURKE I
00:25:25.457 --> 00:25:32.230
WHITE HOUSE SKI. WIENER AYE WILK
00:25:32.297 --> 00:25:34.399
. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
00:25:34.466 --> 00:25:43.842
WITH. FAITH NO. GLAZER I GROVE.
00:25:43.909 --> 00:25:51.049
HERTZBERG WESO I MAN. WHITE
00:25:51.116 --> 00:25:57.222
HOUSE KING I. WILK NO. I TWENTY
00:25:57.289 --> 00:25:58.356
NINE KNOWS EIGHT THE MEASURE
00:25:58.423 --> 00:25:59.958
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO
00:26:00.025 --> 00:26:01.393
FILE ITEM TWENTY EIGHT SENATOR
00:26:01.459 --> 00:26:03.028
ARCHULETA MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE
00:26:03.094 --> 00:26:06.064
READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE FORTY
00:26:06.131 --> 00:26:08.767
NINE BY SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
00:26:08.833 --> 00:26:09.334
RELATING TO VEHICLES CENTER
00:26:09.401 --> 00:26:12.137
ARCHULETA. THANK YOU MADAM
00:26:12.203 --> 00:26:13.371
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT
00:26:13.438 --> 00:26:15.540
SENATE BILL TWELVE FORTY NINE
00:26:15.607 --> 00:26:17.475
WHICH SEEKS TO MODERNIZE THE NON
00:26:17.542 --> 00:26:18.677
GOVERNMENTAL CHARGE KNOWN AS THE
00:26:18.743 --> 00:26:21.413
DOCUMENT PROCESSING CHARGE THAT
00:26:21.479 --> 00:26:22.347
AUTO DEALERSHIP MAY COLLECT IN
00:26:22.414 --> 00:26:25.317
ORDER TO. RECOVER THEIR COSTS
00:26:25.383 --> 00:26:27.319
FOR THE WORK THEY PERFORMED TO
00:26:27.385 --> 00:26:29.220
COMPLETE VEHICLE SALES AND LEASE
00:26:29.287 --> 00:26:31.323
TRANSACTIONS WITHOUT DEALER
00:26:31.389 --> 00:26:32.924
BASED DOCUMENT PROCESSING
00:26:32.991 --> 00:26:34.993
SERVICES CUSTOMERS WOULD HAVE TO
00:26:35.060 --> 00:26:36.494
GO THROUGH SEVERAL SIGNIFICANT
00:26:36.561 --> 00:26:38.997
STEPS ON THEIR OWN YOUR PROCESS
00:26:39.064 --> 00:26:40.165
TO COMPLETE VEHICLE PURCHASE OR
00:26:40.231 --> 00:26:42.667
LEASE TRANSACTION INCLUDING MANY
00:26:42.734 --> 00:26:44.469
MANY TRIPS TO DMV TO COMPLETE
00:26:44.536 --> 00:26:47.339
MULTIPLE STEPS. OUT TO COVER THE
00:26:47.405 --> 00:26:49.174
SUBSTANTIAL STAFF TIME AND COST
00:26:49.240 --> 00:26:51.109
OF TECHNOLOGY AND EQUIPMENT
00:26:51.176 --> 00:26:52.544
ASSOCIATED WITH OBLIGATIONS
00:26:52.610 --> 00:26:54.512
CALIFORNIA CURRENTLY ALLOWS OUR
00:26:54.579 --> 00:26:55.647
DEALERSHIP TO COLLECT THE
00:26:55.714 --> 00:26:57.315
STATUTORY MAXIMUM DOCUMENT
00:26:57.382 --> 00:26:59.384
PROCESSING FEE OF EIGHTY FIVE
00:26:59.451 --> 00:27:01.553
DOLLARS PER TRANSACTION. SENATE
00:27:01.619 --> 00:27:04.222
BILL TWELVE FORTY NINE WOULD
00:27:04.289 --> 00:27:05.824
RAISE THE KAPPA DOCUMENT
00:27:05.890 --> 00:27:07.759
PROCESSING- CHARGER ONE SEVENTY
00:27:07.826 --> 00:27:09.728
FIVE WHICH IS DIRECTLY IN LINE
00:27:09.794 --> 00:27:11.296
WITH A DOCUMENT PROCESSING
00:27:11.363 --> 00:27:13.231
CHARGE INCREASE IN NEW YORK
00:27:13.298 --> 00:27:15.500
STATE THAT WAS ENACTED JUST LAST
00:27:15.567 --> 00:27:17.669
YEAR EVEN WITH THIS INCREASE
00:27:17.736 --> 00:27:19.304
CALIFORNIA DOCUMENT PROCESSING
00:27:19.371 --> 00:27:21.106
CHARGE WOULD REMAIN ONE OF THE
00:27:21.172 --> 00:27:24.876
LOWEST IN THE COUNTRY AND FOR
00:27:24.943 --> 00:27:25.977
THESE REASONS I ASK FOR YOUR-
00:27:26.044 --> 00:27:27.312
AYE VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
00:27:27.379 --> 00:27:28.913
ARCHULETA DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
00:27:28.980 --> 00:27:32.117
CENTER GLAZER. Q. THANK YOU
00:27:32.183 --> 00:27:33.518
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS- I'M
00:27:33.585 --> 00:27:35.353
GONNA SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY BUT
00:27:35.420 --> 00:27:37.155
I WANTED TO KNOW TO THE AUTHOR
00:27:37.222 --> 00:27:39.057
AND THOSE WHO ARE. BEHIND THIS
00:27:39.124 --> 00:27:40.291
BILL THAT I THINK A GREAT POINT
00:27:40.358 --> 00:27:42.193
OF FRUSTRATION BY AUTO
00:27:42.260 --> 00:27:44.396
PURCHASERS IS TO MAKE THAT
00:27:44.462 --> 00:27:45.797
AGREEMENT WHATEVER GOES INTO
00:27:45.864 --> 00:27:46.965
MAKING THAT AGREEMENT AND THEN
00:27:47.032 --> 00:27:48.967
YOU GET INTO THE BACK ROOM TO
00:27:49.034 --> 00:27:50.668
KIND OF DO THE PAPERWORK AND
00:27:50.735 --> 00:27:53.538
THEN OUT OF THE BLUE COMES THESE
00:27:53.605 --> 00:27:54.873
FEES AS JUSTIFIED AS THEY MAY
00:27:54.939 --> 00:27:57.242
BE. I DO THINK YOUR BILL WOULD
00:27:57.308 --> 00:27:58.977
BE BETTER IF IT PROVIDED SOME
00:27:59.044 --> 00:28:01.546
LEVEL OF DISCLOSURE TO POTENTIAL
00:28:01.613 --> 00:28:03.415
BUYERS ABOUT THESE FEES I THINK
00:28:03.481 --> 00:28:04.949
THAT THERE IS SOME JUSTIFICATION
00:28:05.016 --> 00:28:07.118
FOR THIS CASE I THINK THAT THE
00:28:07.185 --> 00:28:09.054
BILL COULD BE BETTER IF WE COULD
00:28:09.120 --> 00:28:10.321
DEAL WITH THAT CONSUMER ANGST
00:28:10.388 --> 00:28:11.856
THAT COMES WHEN YOU THINK YOU'VE
00:28:11.923 --> 00:28:14.626
MADE THAT DEAL. BUT THEN THERE'S
00:28:14.692 --> 00:28:15.927
A LOT MORE TO IT THAN YOU
00:28:15.994 --> 00:28:19.164
REALIZED WITH THAT I WOULD ASK
00:28:19.230 --> 00:28:20.932
FOR AN AYE VOTE TODAY. THANK YOU
00:28:20.999 --> 00:28:22.167
SENATOR GLAZERS CINDER. JONES
00:28:22.233 --> 00:28:23.401
DID YOU PUT YOUR OKAY SENATOR
00:28:23.468 --> 00:28:26.938
DORADO. YES I AM THANK YOU MADAM
00:28:27.005 --> 00:28:29.808
PRESIDENT OF JUST FOR THE AUTHOR
00:28:29.874 --> 00:28:32.644
IF I COULD ASK. CENTER TO LET WE
00:28:32.710 --> 00:28:34.345
TAKE A QUESTION YES MA'AM PLEASE
00:28:34.412 --> 00:28:36.848
PROCEED THANK YOU- I'M CONCERNED
00:28:36.915 --> 00:28:38.583
AND WITH FEW WOULD ADDRESS THE
00:28:38.650 --> 00:28:41.953
ISSUE OF. HOW THIS IS GOING TO
00:28:42.020 --> 00:28:46.291
DOUBLE THE AMOUNT OF THAT OF A
00:28:46.357 --> 00:28:56.067
WE CHARGE- YOU KNOW NEW AND USED. AS WE KNOW WHERE EVERYBODY'S
00:28:56.134 --> 00:28:57.469
GOING THROUGH A TOUGH TIME AND
00:28:57.535 --> 00:28:59.237
WE'RE ALL TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
00:28:59.304 --> 00:29:03.041
HOW TO CONTROL THE INCREASE IN
00:29:03.108 --> 00:29:06.244
PRICES AND COST- AND THIS ONE
00:29:06.311 --> 00:29:08.313
CERTAINLY IS GOING IN THE
00:29:08.379 --> 00:29:10.982
DIRECTION OF INCREASING THE
00:29:11.049 --> 00:29:13.451
COSTS SO- AND THERE'S NO
00:29:13.518 --> 00:29:15.453
OPPORTUNITY SOLITAIRE
00:29:15.520 --> 00:29:17.222
NEGOTIATING OVER THE PRICE OF
00:29:17.288 --> 00:29:20.291
THE CAR. THIS IS A- UNMOUNT THAT
00:29:20.358 --> 00:29:23.161
HIS IN BEING PUT ON THEM- SO HOW
00:29:23.228 --> 00:29:24.929
DO YOU RESPOND TO THAT THIS IS
00:29:24.996 --> 00:29:26.464
OF GRAVE CONCERN TO
00:29:26.531 --> 00:29:28.867
ORGANIZATIONS THAT REPRESENT
00:29:28.933 --> 00:29:30.902
WORKING PEOPLE WHO REALLY WANT
00:29:30.969 --> 00:29:34.005
TO BUY THE CAR AND THEN THEY GET
00:29:34.072 --> 00:29:36.374
ADDED ADDITIONAL FEES. THANK YOU
00:29:36.441 --> 00:29:38.209
AND TO ANSWER SOME OF THE
00:29:38.276 --> 00:29:39.277
QUESTIONS FROM MY COLLEAGUE FROM
00:29:39.344 --> 00:29:41.412
LOS ANGELES THE FEE HAS NOT BEEN
00:29:41.479 --> 00:29:43.481
RAISED SINCE SINCE THE NINETIES
00:29:43.548 --> 00:29:46.551
AND AGAIN. WE ARE IN PART NOW
00:29:46.618 --> 00:29:48.219
WITH NEW YORK WHICH IS THE VERY
00:29:48.286 --> 00:29:49.821
LOWEST IN THE TIME AND EFFORT
00:29:49.888 --> 00:29:52.690
THAT GOES INTO THE PROCESSING OF
00:29:52.757 --> 00:29:55.226
THIS DOCUMENTATION AND AGAIN THE
00:29:55.293 --> 00:29:57.095
LABOR THAT'S PUT INTO IT. AND
00:29:57.162 --> 00:29:59.330
OBVIOUSLY THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
00:29:59.397 --> 00:30:01.332
WORKING WILL BENEFIT FROM THAT
00:30:01.399 --> 00:30:03.568
THE PRICE OF THE CAR AS IT IS A
00:30:03.635 --> 00:30:05.069
WHOLE DIFFERENT THING- THE
00:30:05.136 --> 00:30:06.504
DISCLOSURES WILL BE MADE UP
00:30:06.571 --> 00:30:11.042
FRONT SO THE CAR BUYER KNOWS-THAT IN THE PROCESSING FEE- WILL
00:30:11.109 --> 00:30:13.211
BE THE AMOUNT. SO EVERYTHING IS
00:30:13.278 --> 00:30:15.880
BEEN THERE IN PLACE. TO PROTECT
00:30:15.947 --> 00:30:17.649
CONSUMER AND ANY ADJUSTMENTS
00:30:17.715 --> 00:30:18.917
WE'RE GOING TO GO HEAD CONTINUE
00:30:18.983 --> 00:30:22.420
OVER INTO THE ASSEMBLY AND WILL
00:30:22.487 --> 00:30:23.588
CONTINUE WITH ANY ADJUSTMENTS WE
00:30:23.655 --> 00:30:25.190
CAN'T. IF I CAN OF ALL EQUITIES
00:30:25.256 --> 00:30:28.393
PROCEED YEAH I GUESS. I GUESS AT
00:30:28.459 --> 00:30:30.728
A TIME WHEN. PEOPLE ARE REALLY
00:30:30.795 --> 00:30:32.997
STRUGGLING AT A TIME WHEN THE
00:30:33.064 --> 00:30:36.067
CAR DEALERS HAVE PROFITED IT'S
00:30:36.134 --> 00:30:38.136
NOT LIKE THEY ARE YOU KNOW
00:30:38.203 --> 00:30:40.271
HAVING A REALLY ROUGH TIME IT'S
00:30:40.338 --> 00:30:42.507
NOT LIKE NOBODY'S BUYING CARS IN
00:30:42.574 --> 00:30:45.476
FACT THERE'S A SHORTAGE. OF
00:30:45.543 --> 00:30:49.047
AVAILABLE CARS- IT AND THESE CAR
00:30:49.113 --> 00:30:52.750
DEALERS UP BENEFITTED A LOT FROM
00:30:52.817 --> 00:30:54.552
OF OUR PAYCHECK PROTECTION
00:30:54.619 --> 00:30:57.288
PROGRAM LOANS- JUST TO HELP THEM
00:30:57.355 --> 00:30:59.591
KEEP IN AND PASTE IT JUST SEEMS
00:30:59.657 --> 00:31:01.759
IF YOU COULD JUST RESPOND TO
00:31:01.826 --> 00:31:04.596
THIS. HOW DO WE JUSTIFY TO THE
00:31:04.662 --> 00:31:07.498
DEGREE THAT. WE SHOULD AND-
00:31:07.565 --> 00:31:09.534
CALIFORNIANS ARE ASKING US TO
00:31:09.601 --> 00:31:11.502
WATCH OUT FOR THEM AS CONSUMERS
00:31:11.569 --> 00:31:14.339
AND I JUST AND WE'RE ALSO HAVING
00:31:14.405 --> 00:31:15.573
TO BALANCE THAT WITH WATCHING
00:31:15.640 --> 00:31:17.942
OUT FOR BUSINESSES BUT WATCHING
00:31:18.009 --> 00:31:19.477
OUT FOR BUSINESSES THAT NEED IT
00:31:19.544 --> 00:31:22.113
SO. AGAIN IF YOU COULD IF
00:31:22.180 --> 00:31:23.348
THERE'S ANOTHER WAY OF
00:31:23.414 --> 00:31:24.849
RESPONDING TO THAT. WELL ONE OF
00:31:24.916 --> 00:31:26.651
THE ISSUES WE SHOULD NOT ASK HIM
00:31:26.718 --> 00:31:28.286
TO INCREASE IT OR PUT IT ON THE
00:31:28.353 --> 00:31:30.221
PRICE OF THE CAR BECAUSE OF THE
00:31:30.288 --> 00:31:31.789
FACT THAT EVERY DEALER WITHIN
00:31:31.856 --> 00:31:33.258
THE FLUCTUATING FROM ONE THE
00:31:33.324 --> 00:31:35.293
OTHER THIS IS STATUTORY APPROACH
00:31:35.360 --> 00:31:37.128
ACROSS THE STATE SO DOESN'T
00:31:37.195 --> 00:31:39.197
GALGIANI WANT. AND THAT'S WHY
00:31:39.264 --> 00:31:41.199
IT'S SO IMPORTANT TO KEEP A CAP
00:31:41.266 --> 00:31:43.034
ON IT. THANK YOU THANK CENTER
00:31:43.101 --> 00:31:45.036
DRAWS OUT CENTER JONES. THANK
00:31:45.103 --> 00:31:46.771
YOU MA'AM PRESIDENT I ALSO- WILL
00:31:46.838 --> 00:31:48.906
BE SUPPORTING SB TWELVE FORTY
00:31:48.973 --> 00:31:51.876
NINE TODAY AND I UNDERSTAND THE
00:31:51.943 --> 00:31:53.411
CONCERNS FROM THE TWO PREVIOUS
00:31:53.478 --> 00:31:55.213
SPEAKERS ON THE DISCLOSURE-
00:31:55.280 --> 00:31:57.382
THAT'S PRETTY SIMPLE THE
00:31:57.448 --> 00:31:59.183
CUSTOMER JUST NEED TO ASK THE
00:31:59.250 --> 00:32:02.153
DEALER YOU KNOW WHAT. WHAT THESE
00:32:02.220 --> 00:32:04.489
CHARGES COVER AND IT'S AS THE
00:32:04.555 --> 00:32:06.291
AUTHOR SPOKE TO AND THEN AS AS
00:32:06.357 --> 00:32:09.127
FAR AS- THE BUSINESS PRACTICES
00:32:09.193 --> 00:32:10.261
OF THE DEALERSHIPS YOU KNOW
00:32:10.328 --> 00:32:12.530
RIGHT NOW. I NOT JUST IN
00:32:12.597 --> 00:32:13.865
CALIFORNIA ACROSS THE COUNTRY
00:32:13.931 --> 00:32:15.566
DEALERS ARE STRUGGLING WITH
00:32:15.633 --> 00:32:18.102
ACTUALLY GETTING SUPPLY. FROM
00:32:18.169 --> 00:32:19.937
THE MANUFACTURERS AND THAT'S
00:32:20.004 --> 00:32:21.539
WHAT WE'RE SEEING IS DRIVING UP
00:32:21.606 --> 00:32:23.875
THE COSTS OF USED CARS AND THE
00:32:23.941 --> 00:32:25.777
AVAILABILITY OF NEW CARS SO THE
00:32:25.843 --> 00:32:27.879
DEALERSHIPS- THAT I KNOW ARE
00:32:27.945 --> 00:32:29.947
WORKING VERY HARD EVERY DAY TO
00:32:30.014 --> 00:32:31.349
INCREASE THEIR SUPPLIES SO THAT
00:32:31.416 --> 00:32:34.285
THEY CAN- YOU KNOW BEGIN TO. I
00:32:34.352 --> 00:32:35.553
HAVE A POSITIVE IMPACT ON THE
00:32:35.620 --> 00:32:37.155
MARKET DRIVING DOWN TE PRICES
00:32:37.221 --> 00:32:39.390
PARTICULAR TO SB TWELVE FORTY
00:32:39.457 --> 00:32:41.225
NINE THIS IS AN ISSUE- THAT I
00:32:41.292 --> 00:32:42.393
KNOW HAS BEEN IN CALIFORNIA
00:32:42.460 --> 00:32:44.996
STATE LAW FOR A LONG PERIOD OF
00:32:45.063 --> 00:32:47.632
TIME. BUT I REMAIN UNCONVINCED
00:32:47.699 --> 00:32:48.599
THAT THE STATE SHOULD EVEN BE
00:32:48.666 --> 00:32:50.635
REGULATING THIS PART OF THE
00:32:50.702 --> 00:32:52.670
TRANSACTION AND SO I WILL BE
00:32:52.737 --> 00:32:54.372
VOTING IN FAVOR OF BEST FULL
00:32:54.439 --> 00:32:55.206
FORTY NINE THANK YOU THANK YOU
00:32:55.273 --> 00:32:59.344
CENTER JONES MEMBERS FURTHER
00:32:59.410 --> 00:33:00.144
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. C. AND
00:33:00.211 --> 00:33:01.679
HEARING NONE ARCHER WHICH I
00:33:01.746 --> 00:33:03.147
CLOSE I RESPECT ASK YOUR AYE
00:33:03.214 --> 00:33:04.982
VOTE. THANK YOU SIR MADAM
00:33:05.049 --> 00:33:06.117
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:33:06.184 --> 00:33:11.289
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
00:33:11.356 --> 00:33:21.799
BATES. BAKER I PORCHES. BRADFORDAYE CABALLERO AYE FOR TESTING I
00:33:21.866 --> 00:33:29.507
DALY. DODD FIVE TORONTO. EGGMAN
00:33:29.574 --> 00:33:34.011
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW AYE
00:33:34.078 --> 00:33:38.416
HERTZBERG WESSEL. I HER TADO
00:33:38.483 --> 00:33:44.288
JONES I KAMLAGER. LAYERED I
00:33:44.355 --> 00:33:51.162
LEYVA. LIMON I MCGUIRE I
00:33:51.229 --> 00:33:56.501
MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN AYE
00:33:56.567 --> 00:34:02.840
NIELSEN. I A TROUBLED AYE PAN. I
00:34:02.907 --> 00:34:08.746
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE
00:34:08.813 --> 00:34:15.586
SKINNER I STERN. AMBERG I WAS
00:34:15.653 --> 00:34:20.491
ASKING AYE WIENER AYE WILK I.
00:34:20.558 --> 00:34:22.894
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
00:34:22.960 --> 00:34:30.368
ATKINS I BATES. FOR JUST. VALLEY
00:34:30.435 --> 00:34:35.440
THEY'RE ALSO EGGMAN. HERTZBERG
00:34:35.506 --> 00:34:40.611
HER TADO KAMLAGER. LEYVA
00:34:40.678 --> 00:34:46.784
MELENDEZ STERN. I TWENTY NINE NO
00:34:46.851 --> 00:34:48.286
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
00:34:48.352 --> 00:34:50.855
WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
00:34:50.922 --> 00:34:52.256
THIRTY THREE SENATOR HER TADO
00:34:52.323 --> 00:34:53.925
THEM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
00:34:53.991 --> 00:34:56.027
SENATE BILL EIGHT FORTY SEVEN BY
00:34:56.093 --> 00:34:57.762
SENATOR HER TADO AN ACT RELATING
00:34:57.829 --> 00:35:00.064
TO TENANCY CENTER HER TADO THANK
00:35:00.131 --> 00:35:01.299
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT TODAY I RISE
00:35:01.365 --> 00:35:03.134
TO PRESENT SB EIGHT FOUR SEVEN
00:35:03.201 --> 00:35:04.068
WHICH ESTABLISHES A GRANT
00:35:04.135 --> 00:35:05.336
PROGRAM ADMINISTERED BY THE
00:35:05.403 --> 00:35:06.671
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND
00:35:06.737 --> 00:35:08.539
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT THE LAWS
00:35:08.606 --> 00:35:09.640
FOR DISTRIBUTION OF FUNDS TO
00:35:09.707 --> 00:35:11.642
HOMEOWNERS APPLICANTS UPON
00:35:11.709 --> 00:35:14.078
APPROPRIATION BY THE LEGISLATURE
00:35:14.145 --> 00:35:15.446
. WHEN THE FOR ALL WHEN THE
00:35:15.513 --> 00:35:16.347
FEDERAL MORTGAGE FORBEARANCE
00:35:16.414 --> 00:35:18.182
ENDS. THEY MAY BE FORCED TO
00:35:18.249 --> 00:35:19.417
REMOVE THE RENTAL UNITS FROM THE
00:35:19.484 --> 00:35:21.819
MARKET SELL THEM IN ORDER TO
00:35:21.886 --> 00:35:22.487
AVOID FORECLOSURE THE CALIFORNIA
00:35:22.553 --> 00:35:23.454
MORTGAGE RELIEF PROGRAM USES
00:35:23.521 --> 00:35:25.556
FEDERAL HOME OWNER. ASSISTANCE
00:35:25.623 --> 00:35:26.858
FUNDS TO HELP HOMEOWNERS GET
00:35:26.924 --> 00:35:28.059
CAUGHT UP ON THEIR HOUSING
00:35:28.125 --> 00:35:29.293
PAYMENTS BUT IT DOESN'T INCLUDE
00:35:29.360 --> 00:35:30.962
HOMEOWNERS WHO DON'T. WHO HAVE
00:35:31.028 --> 00:35:32.930
RENTAL PROPERTIES SB EIGHT FOUR
00:35:32.997 --> 00:35:33.431
SEVEN CLOSES THE GAP FOR
00:35:33.498 --> 00:35:35.800
TENANTS. AND HOMEOWNERS WHO HAVE
00:35:35.867 --> 00:35:37.368
APPLIED AND BEEN REJECTED FROM.
00:35:37.435 --> 00:35:38.736
THE STATE RENTAL ASSISTANCE
00:35:38.803 --> 00:35:41.572
PROGRAMS FOR NEEDED RENTAL UNITS
00:35:41.639 --> 00:35:42.807
STAY IN THE MARKET AND PEOPLE DO
00:35:42.874 --> 00:35:43.975
NOT LOSE. THE ROOF OVER THEIR
00:35:44.041 --> 00:35:45.443
SHOCK OVER OVER THEIR HEADS I
00:35:45.510 --> 00:35:47.078
RESPECT LAST NIGHT. THANK YOU
00:35:47.144 --> 00:35:49.213
CENTER HER TADO MEMBERS
00:35:49.280 --> 00:35:51.482
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
00:35:51.549 --> 00:35:52.750
HEARING NONE MADAM SECRETARY
00:35:52.817 --> 00:35:58.389
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
00:35:58.456 --> 00:36:02.493
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
00:36:02.560 --> 00:36:08.099
AYE BAKER. I PORCHES I BRADFORD
00:36:08.165 --> 00:36:12.803
AYE CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
00:36:12.870 --> 00:36:17.375
DOLLY AYE DODD. I TORONTO.
00:36:17.441 --> 00:36:23.281
EGGMAN I GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ.
00:36:23.347 --> 00:36:30.788
GROVE I HERTZBERG WESSEL. I HER
00:36:30.855 --> 00:36:36.394
TADO I JONES. I KAMLAGER.
00:36:36.460 --> 00:36:41.499
LAYERED I LEYVA AYE THE MOUNT. I
00:36:41.566 --> 00:36:46.771
MCGUIRE AYE MELINDA'S AYE MIN. I
00:36:46.837 --> 00:36:50.575
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN I A CHOI
00:36:50.641 --> 00:36:55.880
BOGUE I PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
00:36:55.947 --> 00:37:01.719
ROTH AYE RUBIO. I SKINNER. STERN
00:37:01.786 --> 00:37:07.625
HI I'M BURKE. HI MY CASTING.
00:37:07.692 --> 00:37:11.696
WIENER AYE WILK. HI PLEASE CALL
00:37:11.762 --> 00:37:15.299
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. TORONTO
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:20.404
GONZALEZ HERTZBERG KAMLAGER.
00:37:20.471 --> 00:37:27.478
SKINNER I WHITE HOUSE SKI. I
00:37:27.545 --> 00:37:28.679
THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
00:37:28.746 --> 00:37:36.320
PASSES. MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO
00:37:36.387 --> 00:37:37.888
FILE ITEM THIRTY FOUR CENTER
00:37:37.955 --> 00:37:40.291
PORTANTINO WILL BE PRESENTING
00:37:40.358 --> 00:37:42.693
SENATE BILL NINE THIRTY TWO
00:37:42.760 --> 00:37:44.428
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
00:37:44.495 --> 00:37:45.896
BILL NINE THIRTY TWO BY SENATOR
00:37:45.963 --> 00:37:47.932
PORTANTINO AN ACT RELATING TO
00:37:47.999 --> 00:37:49.667
LAND USE CENTER PORTANTINO YOU
00:37:49.734 --> 00:37:51.402
ARE RECOGNIZED THANK YOU MR
00:37:51.469 --> 00:37:53.537
PRESIDENT MEMBERS TODAY I RISE
00:37:53.604 --> 00:37:55.506
TO PRESENT SB NINE THIRTY TWO
00:37:55.573 --> 00:37:56.974
THE BILL WHICH SEEKS FRANKLY TO
00:37:57.041 --> 00:37:58.743
MAKE OUR STREETS SAFER- AND OUR
00:37:58.809 --> 00:38:00.411
ROADS SAFER AND WILL LEAD TO
00:38:00.478 --> 00:38:02.847
SAVING LIVES. DESPITE DECADES OF
00:38:02.913 --> 00:38:04.148
RHETORIC ON THE NEED FOR SAFER
00:38:04.215 --> 00:38:05.583
STREETS MOST CALIFORNIANS
00:38:05.650 --> 00:38:07.251
STREETS HAVE GROWN MORE
00:38:07.318 --> 00:38:09.086
DANGEROUS IN RECENT YEARS
00:38:09.153 --> 00:38:09.920
ACCORDING TO THE NATIONAL
00:38:09.987 --> 00:38:10.755
HIGHWAY TRAFFIC SAFETY
00:38:10.821 --> 00:38:12.890
ADMINISTRATION TWENTY TWENTY ONE
00:38:12.957 --> 00:38:15.393
SAW NEARLY 20% INCREASE IN
00:38:15.459 --> 00:38:17.561
TRAFFIC FATALITIES IN THE FIRST
00:38:17.628 --> 00:38:19.563
SIX MONTHS COMPARED TO BOTH
00:38:19.630 --> 00:38:21.198
TWENTY TWENTY AND TWENTY
00:38:21.265 --> 00:38:22.366
NINETEEN SB NINE THIRTY TWO
00:38:22.433 --> 00:38:24.001
REQUIRES A COUNTY OR CITY TO
00:38:24.068 --> 00:38:25.803
INCLUDE IN A CHANNEL PLANTS A
00:38:25.870 --> 00:38:27.171
MAP OF THE HIGH INJURY NETWORK
00:38:27.238 --> 00:38:28.305
WITHIN ITS BOUNDARIES AND
00:38:28.372 --> 00:38:30.708
FURTHER REQUIRE A COUNTY OR CITY
00:38:30.775 --> 00:38:32.510
TO IDENTIFYING. PRIORITIZE AND
00:38:32.576 --> 00:38:34.912
IMPLEMENT SAFETY MEASURES WE CAN
00:38:34.979 --> 00:38:36.981
HELP REDUCE TRAFFIC VIOLENCE AND
00:38:37.048 --> 00:38:39.050
WE HAVE TO BE BOLD ENOUGH TO ACT
00:38:39.116 --> 00:38:40.885
AS YOU ALL KNOW IN THE PAST YEAR
00:38:40.951 --> 00:38:42.987
AND A HALF I BECOME AN ACTIVE
00:38:43.054 --> 00:38:44.388
BIKER AND FRANKLY JUST LAST WEEK
00:38:44.455 --> 00:38:47.625
ALMOST GOT TO CLICK OFF THE
00:38:47.692 --> 00:38:49.393
ROAD. BY A TRUCK AND THAT HAVE
00:38:49.460 --> 00:38:52.930
HAD SEVERAL NEAR NEAR MISSES. ON
00:38:52.997 --> 00:38:54.432
OWN STREETS IN MY OWN
00:38:54.498 --> 00:38:55.199
NEIGHBORHOOD AND UP HERE IN
00:38:55.266 --> 00:38:56.400
SACRAMENTO AS WELL AND
00:38:56.467 --> 00:38:58.202
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
00:38:58.269 --> 00:38:58.836
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
00:38:58.903 --> 00:38:59.937
PORTANTINO MEMBERS ANY
00:39:00.004 --> 00:39:01.405
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON SENATE
00:39:01.472 --> 00:39:04.642
BILL NINE THIRTY TWO DISCUSSION
00:39:04.709 --> 00:39:05.342
OR DEBATE. THERE'S LOTS OF
00:39:05.409 --> 00:39:07.244
DISCUSSION GOING ON NOT
00:39:07.311 --> 00:39:10.347
REGARDING NINE THIRTY TWO.
00:39:10.414 --> 00:39:12.817
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
00:39:12.883 --> 00:39:23.127
NINE THIRTY TWO. CENTERS THANK
00:39:23.194 --> 00:39:24.361
YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION SECRETARY
00:39:24.428 --> 00:39:28.999
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
00:39:29.066 --> 00:39:33.637
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
00:39:33.704 --> 00:39:45.716
NO BACKER. I PORCHES NO BRADFORD. BY ADAM I CORTES HE AYE DALY
00:39:45.783 --> 00:39:51.288
NO DODD. NO TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
00:39:51.355 --> 00:39:58.863
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO
00:39:58.929 --> 00:40:03.501
HERTZBERG PUESTO I FURTADO. I
00:40:03.567 --> 00:40:07.338
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
00:40:07.404 --> 00:40:13.711
LEYVA I LIMON AYE MCGUIRE AYE
00:40:13.778 --> 00:40:17.548
MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE
00:40:17.615 --> 00:40:20.985
NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF VOGUE NO
00:40:21.051 --> 00:40:26.190
PAN. I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH. I
00:40:26.257 --> 00:40:32.963
RUBIO. SKINNER I STERN AYE
00:40:33.030 --> 00:40:39.970
AMBERG AYE I LIKE ASKING. WIENER
00:40:40.037 --> 00:40:42.573
I WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE
00:40:42.640 --> 00:40:53.851
ABSENT MEMBERS. BRADFORD GLAZER. HERTZBERG RUBIO. WHITE HOUSE
00:40:53.918 --> 00:40:58.823
SKI. IS TWENTY FIVE KNOWS TEN
00:40:58.889 --> 00:41:01.358
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE HAVE-
00:41:01.425 --> 00:41:02.459
TO BILLS BY THE PRESIDING
00:41:02.526 --> 00:41:04.195
OFFICER THIS MORNING WE ARE
00:41:04.261 --> 00:41:07.064
GOING TO BE- HEARING SENATE BILL
00:41:07.131 --> 00:41:09.767
SEVENTY ARE I'M SORRY FILE ITEM
00:41:09.834 --> 00:41:12.269
SEVENTY FOUR FIRST AND A WILL BE
00:41:12.336 --> 00:41:14.238
FILED- FOLLOWED BY FILE ITEM
00:41:14.305 --> 00:41:17.074
SEVENTY SEVEN. FILE ITEM SEVENTY
00:41:17.141 --> 00:41:18.876
FOUR IS SENATE BILL EIGHT SIXTY
00:41:18.943 --> 00:41:20.578
NINE MY CENTER LABOR SECRETARY
00:41:20.644 --> 00:41:23.080
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL EIGHT
00:41:23.147 --> 00:41:24.248
SIXTY NINE BY SENATOR LEYVA AN
00:41:24.315 --> 00:41:26.250
ACT RELATING TO HOUSING CENTER
00:41:26.317 --> 00:41:27.785
LEYVA THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
00:41:27.852 --> 00:41:29.253
GOOD MORNING MEMBERS AS MANY OF
00:41:29.320 --> 00:41:31.021
YOU ARE AWARE I SERVE AS THE
00:41:31.088 --> 00:41:33.424
CHAIROF THE SELECT COMMITTEE ON
00:41:33.490 --> 00:41:34.658
MANUFACTURED HOME COMMUNITIES
00:41:34.725 --> 00:41:35.993
THROUGH THAT POSITION I HAVE
00:41:36.060 --> 00:41:37.995
BEEN ABLE TO SEE FIRSTHAND SOME
00:41:38.062 --> 00:41:39.530
OF THE ISSUES THAT IMPACT THESE
00:41:39.597 --> 00:41:40.898
COMMUNITIES THERE ARE
00:41:40.965 --> 00:41:43.701
APPROXIMATELY FIVE HUNDRED AND
00:41:43.767 --> 00:41:44.301
NINETEEN THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED
00:41:44.368 --> 00:41:45.703
AND SEVENTY TWO. MOBILE HOMES
00:41:45.769 --> 00:41:46.837
AND MANUFACTURED HOMES IN
00:41:46.904 --> 00:41:49.106
CALIFORNIA WHICH ACCOUNTS FOR
00:41:49.173 --> 00:41:50.941
THREE POINT 8% OF THE TOTAL
00:41:51.008 --> 00:41:52.943
HOUSING STOCK AND EQUALING
00:41:53.010 --> 00:41:54.478
ROUGHLY ONE POINT FIVE MILLION
00:41:54.545 --> 00:41:56.547
RESIDENTS IN THE STATE NEARLY
00:41:56.614 --> 00:41:58.549
HALF OF THESE HOMES ARE
00:41:58.616 --> 00:41:59.550
AFFORDABLE TO VERY LOW INCOME
00:41:59.617 --> 00:42:00.951
HOUSEHOLDS AND SERVICE A
00:42:01.018 --> 00:42:02.486
SIGNIFICANT SOURCE OF AFFORDABLE
00:42:02.553 --> 00:42:04.989
HOUSING IN OUR STATE THAT WE
00:42:05.055 --> 00:42:07.191
KNOW HAS A DESPERATE NEED FOR
00:42:07.258 --> 00:42:08.225
HOUSING THAT IS AFFORDABLE
00:42:08.292 --> 00:42:09.660
MOBILE HOME RESIDENTS MANY OF
00:42:09.727 --> 00:42:11.795
WHOM ARE SENIORS RELY ON
00:42:11.862 --> 00:42:13.030
EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF THEIR
00:42:13.097 --> 00:42:14.899
MOBILE HOME PARK. TO ENSURE THAT
00:42:14.965 --> 00:42:16.901
THEIR HOUSING IS SAFE AND MEETS
00:42:16.967 --> 00:42:18.602
THE APPROPRIATE QUALITY
00:42:18.669 --> 00:42:19.970
STANDARDS CURRENTLY CALIFORNIA
00:42:20.037 --> 00:42:21.572
HAS NO REQUIREMENTS FOR THE
00:42:21.639 --> 00:42:23.741
TRAINING OR EDUCATION A MOBILE
00:42:23.807 --> 00:42:25.743
HOME PARK MANAGERS IN MANY
00:42:25.809 --> 00:42:27.678
INSTANCES THE PARK MANAGER MAY
00:42:27.745 --> 00:42:29.580
BE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAFETY OF
00:42:29.647 --> 00:42:31.582
OVER TWO HUNDRED RESIDENTS AND
00:42:31.649 --> 00:42:33.817
SOMETIMES IN REMOTE LOCATIONS OF
00:42:33.884 --> 00:42:36.353
OUR STATE ONGOING VIOLATIONS OF
00:42:36.420 --> 00:42:37.521
THE LAW GENERALLY STEM FROM THE
00:42:37.588 --> 00:42:39.256
LACK OF SUFFICIENT UNDERSTANDING
00:42:39.323 --> 00:42:41.191
BY PARK MANAGERS OF THE MOBILE
00:42:41.258 --> 00:42:44.628
HOME RESIDENCY LAW WHICH WE-
00:42:44.695 --> 00:42:46.530
LOVINGLY CALL THE BIBLE. THIS
00:42:46.597 --> 00:42:48.098
LACK OF TRAINING HAS LED TO
00:42:48.165 --> 00:42:50.100
SITUATIONS OF UNLAWFUL EVICTIONS
00:42:50.167 --> 00:42:52.169
IMPROPER FEES AND INVOICES
00:42:52.236 --> 00:42:53.637
DISCRIMINATION AND POOR
00:42:53.704 --> 00:42:56.307
MAINTENANCE WHICH GRADUALLY IF
00:42:56.373 --> 00:42:58.575
GREATLY AFFECT THE OF LIFE IN
00:42:58.642 --> 00:42:59.610
MOBILE HOME PARKS. AS WITH SIXTY
00:42:59.677 --> 00:43:00.244
NINE WOULD REQUIRE MOBILE HOME
00:43:00.311 --> 00:43:02.146
PARK MANAGERS TO BE TRAINED AND
00:43:02.212 --> 00:43:04.348
CERTIFIED ON THE MOBILE HOME
00:43:04.415 --> 00:43:06.317
RULES AND REGULATIONS THE
00:43:06.383 --> 00:43:07.151
AMENDMENTS IN SENATE
00:43:07.217 --> 00:43:09.119
APPROPRIATIONS REDUCE THE NUMBER
00:43:09.186 --> 00:43:11.155
OF TRAINING HOURS. TO ADDRESS
00:43:11.221 --> 00:43:12.823
THE CONCERNS EXPRESSED BY THE
00:43:12.890 --> 00:43:15.426
MOBILE HOME PARK OWNERS. AND SO
00:43:15.492 --> 00:43:17.494
THIS IS CERTAINLY THE TIME THAT
00:43:17.561 --> 00:43:18.429
WE FOLLOW SUIT HERE IN
00:43:18.495 --> 00:43:20.631
CALIFORNIA AS ORGAN AND ABOUT I
00:43:20.698 --> 00:43:23.267
HAVE ALREADY DONE SIMILAR
00:43:23.334 --> 00:43:24.335
MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:43:24.401 --> 00:43:25.469
AN AYE VOTE. MEMBERS ANY
00:43:25.536 --> 00:43:27.004
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON SENATE
00:43:27.071 --> 00:43:28.973
BILL EIGHT SIXTY NINE ANY
00:43:29.039 --> 00:43:30.774
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE THING NINE
00:43:30.841 --> 00:43:33.377
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:43:33.444 --> 00:43:37.081
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
00:43:37.147 --> 00:43:42.353
AYE BATES. NO BAKER I PORCHES NO
00:43:42.419 --> 00:43:47.992
BRADFORD HI CABALLERO CORTESE I
00:43:48.058 --> 00:43:53.964
DALY NO DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
00:43:54.031 --> 00:43:57.668
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER. GONZALEZ I
00:43:57.735 --> 00:44:03.741
GROWTH. NO HERTZBERG WESSEL. I
00:44:03.807 --> 00:44:09.813
FURTADO I JONES NO KAMLAGER I
00:44:09.880 --> 00:44:14.084
LAYERED AYE LEYVA I LIMON. I
00:44:14.151 --> 00:44:18.222
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN I
00:44:18.288 --> 00:44:23.660
NEWMAN. I NIELSEN NO A TROUBLE
00:44:23.727 --> 00:44:28.632
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO. I ROTH
00:44:28.699 --> 00:44:33.404
AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I STERN
00:44:33.470 --> 00:44:36.507
AYE I'M BURKE I THANK HOUSEKI
00:44:36.573 --> 00:44:41.078
AYE WIENER AYE WILK. NOW THIS
00:44:41.145 --> 00:44:42.880
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
00:44:42.946 --> 00:44:50.154
CABALLERO. GLAZER I HERTZBERG.
00:44:50.220 --> 00:44:52.156
HIS TWENTY NINE IT KNOWS NINE
00:44:52.222 --> 00:44:54.091
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
00:44:54.158 --> 00:44:56.460
MOVING THE FILE ITEM SEVENTY
00:44:56.527 --> 00:44:58.429
SEVEN WHICH IS SENATE BILL NINE
00:44:58.495 --> 00:44:59.596
SEVENTY SIX BY CENTER LEYVA
00:44:59.663 --> 00:45:01.532
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
00:45:01.598 --> 00:45:03.967
BILL NINE SEVENTY SIX BY SENATOR
00:45:04.034 --> 00:45:05.069
LEYVA AN ACT RELATING TO
00:45:05.135 --> 00:45:07.071
PRESCHOOL CENTER LEYVA THANK YOU
00:45:07.137 --> 00:45:08.472
MR PRESIDENT GOOD MORNING AGAIN
00:45:08.539 --> 00:45:10.674
MEMBERS SB NINE SEVENTY SIX
00:45:10.741 --> 00:45:12.443
PROVIDES UNIVERSAL PRESCHOOL BY
00:45:12.509 --> 00:45:13.944
ENSURING THAT PARENTS ACROSS
00:45:14.011 --> 00:45:15.846
CALIFORNIA HAVE INCREASED
00:45:15.913 --> 00:45:17.147
OPTIONS WHEN IT COMES TO CHILD
00:45:17.214 --> 00:45:19.283
CARE CLEARLY ACCESS TO CHILD
00:45:19.349 --> 00:45:21.385
CARE IS CRITICALLY IMPORTANT SO
00:45:21.452 --> 00:45:22.886
THAT PARENTS CAN WORK AND
00:45:22.953 --> 00:45:25.422
PROVIDE FOR THEIR FAMILIES SB
00:45:25.489 --> 00:45:25.956
NINE SEVENTY SIX CREATES A
00:45:26.023 --> 00:45:27.891
UNIVERSAL PRESCHOOL SYSTEM BY
00:45:27.958 --> 00:45:30.260
EXTENDING THE EXPANDING ACROSS
00:45:30.327 --> 00:45:32.029
THE STATE. PRESCHOOL PROGRAM TO
00:45:32.096 --> 00:45:33.730
ALL THREE AND WORLD REGARDLESS
00:45:33.797 --> 00:45:35.566
OF FAMILY INCOME THE BILL
00:45:35.632 --> 00:45:37.101
SUPPLEMENTS THE STATE CAN
00:45:37.167 --> 00:45:38.168
STATE'S COMMITMENT TO
00:45:38.235 --> 00:45:39.803
TRANSITIONAL KINDERGARTEN BY
00:45:39.870 --> 00:45:41.305
STRENGTHENING OUR CHILD CARE
00:45:41.371 --> 00:45:42.940
INFRASTRUCTURE MEMBERS THE
00:45:43.006 --> 00:45:44.541
COVERED NINETEEN PANDEMIC PUSHED
00:45:44.608 --> 00:45:46.477
OUR CHILD CARE SYSTEM TO THE
00:45:46.543 --> 00:45:48.479
BRINK OF COLLAPSE MANY PROVIDERS
00:45:48.545 --> 00:45:49.880
WERE FORCED TO CLOSE OR
00:45:49.947 --> 00:45:51.482
SIGNIFICANTLY LIMIT THEIR
00:45:51.548 --> 00:45:53.083
ENROLLMENT DURING THE PANDEMIC
00:45:53.150 --> 00:45:54.151
CHILD CARE PROGRAMS IN
00:45:54.218 --> 00:45:56.520
CALIFORNIA RELY ON SERVING A
00:45:56.587 --> 00:45:58.088
RANGE OF AGE GROUPS GIVEN THE
00:45:58.155 --> 00:46:00.457
HIGH COST OF INFANT AND TODDLER
00:46:00.524 --> 00:46:02.392
CARE AS YOU MAY KNOW THIS
00:46:02.459 --> 00:46:04.061
INDUSTRY EMPLOYS PRIMARILY WOMEN
00:46:04.128 --> 00:46:06.497
AS THE VAGUELY WOMEN OF COLOR WE
00:46:06.563 --> 00:46:07.998
MUST CREATE A SYSTEM THAT NOT
00:46:08.065 --> 00:46:09.500
ONLY WORKS FOR FAMILIES BUT ALSO
00:46:09.566 --> 00:46:11.201
UP LIVES ARE PROVIDERS. BY
00:46:11.268 --> 00:46:12.469
ENSURING THAT THEY HAVE THE
00:46:12.536 --> 00:46:13.937
ABILITY TO OPEN THE DOORS TO
00:46:14.004 --> 00:46:15.506
MORE CHILDREN AND PAY THEIR PUT
00:46:15.572 --> 00:46:18.675
EMPLOYEES A LIVING WAGE SB NINE
00:46:18.742 --> 00:46:19.276
SEVENTY SIX STRENGTHENS CHILD
00:46:19.343 --> 00:46:21.278
CARE IN CALIFORNIA AND PROVIDES
00:46:21.345 --> 00:46:22.446
FAMILIES WITH MUCH NEEDED
00:46:22.513 --> 00:46:24.348
FLEXIBILITY AS WELL AS OFFER
00:46:24.414 --> 00:46:25.749
STABILITY TO THE CHILD CARE
00:46:25.816 --> 00:46:28.752
COMMUNITY THIS BILL HAS NO
00:46:28.819 --> 00:46:29.653
OPPOSITION AND IS A LEGISLATIVE
00:46:29.720 --> 00:46:31.455
LEGISLATIVE WOMEN'S CAUCUS PARTY
00:46:31.522 --> 00:46:33.257
MEMBERS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
00:46:33.323 --> 00:46:34.992
YOUR VOTE. THANK YOU SIR AND I
00:46:35.058 --> 00:46:40.998
REMEMBER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON. THIS ITEM ANY DISCUSSION OR
00:46:41.064 --> 00:46:44.401
DEBATE. SEEING NONE SECRETARY
00:46:44.468 --> 00:46:49.573
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN I
00:46:49.640 --> 00:46:54.011
ARCHULETA I ATKINS AYE BATES.
00:46:54.077 --> 00:46:59.917
BAKER I PORCHES. BRADFORD AYE
00:46:59.983 --> 00:47:02.719
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
00:47:02.786 --> 00:47:10.794
DALY. DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN
00:47:10.861 --> 00:47:17.267
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
00:47:17.334 --> 00:47:22.806
HERTZBERG WESTERN. I FURTADO I
00:47:22.873 --> 00:47:27.778
JONES NO KAMLAGER. HI LARRY I
00:47:27.844 --> 00:47:34.051
LEYVA. I LIMÓN. I REQUIRE I
00:47:34.117 --> 00:47:39.623
MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN AYE
00:47:39.690 --> 00:47:45.162
NIELSEN. BUT CHAU OF BOTH I PAN
00:47:45.229 --> 00:47:48.599
. I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
00:47:48.665 --> 00:47:53.637
RUBIO RUBIO. I SKINNER I STERN
00:47:53.704 --> 00:47:57.007
AYE NUMBER I WHITE HOUSE E. AYE
00:47:57.074 --> 00:48:01.979
WIENER. I WELL HI PLEASE CALL
00:48:02.045 --> 00:48:05.949
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. BATES FOR
00:48:06.016 --> 00:48:14.291
JUST. DALLY GROVE. HERTZBERG
00:48:14.358 --> 00:48:21.064
MELENDEZ. NIELSEN. HIGHS THIRTY
00:48:21.131 --> 00:48:35.279
TWO KNOWS ONE MEASURE PASSES.
00:48:35.345 --> 00:48:36.346
MEMBERS ARE MOVING BACK TO FILE
00:48:36.413 --> 00:48:38.515
ORDER WILL BE TAKING UP FILE
00:48:38.582 --> 00:48:41.018
ITEM THIRTY SIX WHICH IS SENATE
00:48:41.084 --> 00:48:43.153
BILL NINE FIFTY FOUR BY SENATE
00:48:43.220 --> 00:48:46.089
ARCHULETA. SECRETARY PLEASE READ
00:48:46.156 --> 00:48:47.958
SENATE BILL NINE FIFTY FOUR BY
00:48:48.025 --> 00:48:49.192
SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
00:48:49.259 --> 00:48:50.727
RELATING TO EMPLOYMENT CENTER
00:48:50.794 --> 00:48:52.663
ARCHULETA. THANK YOU MR
00:48:52.729 --> 00:48:54.798
PRESIDENT TODAY I RISE TO
00:48:54.865 --> 00:48:56.633
PRESENT SENATE BILL NINE FIFTY
00:48:56.700 --> 00:48:58.068
FOUR. TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT
00:48:58.135 --> 00:48:59.236
OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS TO
00:48:59.303 --> 00:49:01.238
ESTABLISH A DATABASE OF
00:49:01.305 --> 00:49:02.339
ELECTRONIC CERTIFIED PAPER
00:49:02.406 --> 00:49:04.675
RECORDS THAT IS ESSENTIAL TO
00:49:04.741 --> 00:49:06.710
BOTH MULTI EMPLOYER TAFT HARTLEY
00:49:06.777 --> 00:49:09.579
TRUST FUNDS AND OR JOINT LABOR
00:49:09.646 --> 00:49:11.114
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEES
00:49:11.181 --> 00:49:13.016
ESTABLISHED PURSUANT TO THE
00:49:13.083 --> 00:49:13.817
FEDERAL LABOR MANAGEMENT
00:49:13.884 --> 00:49:16.586
CORPORATION ACT OF NINETEEN
00:49:16.653 --> 00:49:18.388
SEVENTY EIGHT. BY ESTABLISHING
00:49:18.455 --> 00:49:20.791
THE STANDALONE DATABASE TO BE
00:49:20.857 --> 00:49:23.427
ACCESS ONLY BY TAP PARTY TRUST
00:49:23.493 --> 00:49:25.062
FUND AND OR JOINT LABOR
00:49:25.128 --> 00:49:26.997
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEES WE WILL B
00:49:27.064 --> 00:49:29.266
ENABLING A MORE EFFICIENT FORM
00:49:29.333 --> 00:49:31.668
OF RECORD ACCESS THAT WILL LEAD
00:49:31.735 --> 00:49:33.603
TO INCREASED LABOR COMPLIANCE
00:49:33.670 --> 00:49:35.439
STREAMLINED THE PROCESS TO
00:49:35.505 --> 00:49:36.340
CALCULATE EMPLOYER
00:49:36.406 --> 00:49:38.842
CONTRIBUTIONS. AND SAVE TAX
00:49:38.909 --> 00:49:41.778
DOLLARS BY DECREASING WORKLOADS
00:49:41.845 --> 00:49:44.481
OF A WAR AGENCIES AND DIVISION
00:49:44.548 --> 00:49:48.452
OF LABOR STANDARDS ENFORCEMENT.
00:49:48.518 --> 00:49:49.653
FOR THESE REASONS I RESPECTFULLY
00:49:49.720 --> 00:49:51.221
ASK YOUR AYE BOOK. THANK YOU
00:49:51.288 --> 00:49:52.289
CENTER ARCHULETA- ANY MEMBERS
00:49:52.356 --> 00:49:54.124
WITHOUT DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
00:49:54.191 --> 00:49:57.127
THIS ITEM ANY DISCUSSION OR
00:49:57.194 --> 00:49:59.796
DEBATE ON SB NINE FIFTY FOUR.
00:49:59.863 --> 00:50:00.764
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
00:50:00.831 --> 00:50:05.435
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
00:50:05.502 --> 00:50:09.773
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
00:50:09.840 --> 00:50:16.046
NO BAKER. FORGES BRADFORD I HAVE
00:50:16.113 --> 00:50:22.953
ITEM. PORTENDING I DALY NO DODD
00:50:23.019 --> 00:50:33.663
HI HI TORONTO I EGGMAN I GLAZER. I GONZALEZ I GROWTH NO
00:50:33.730 --> 00:50:37.701
HERTZBERG WESSEL I FURTADO. I
00:50:37.768 --> 00:50:44.508
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
00:50:44.574 --> 00:50:48.278
LEYVA AYE THE MON. I MCGUIRE AYE
00:50:48.345 --> 00:50:53.984
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN I
00:50:54.050 --> 00:50:58.889
NIELSEN NO TROUBLE NO PAN AYE
00:50:58.955 --> 00:51:03.360
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
00:51:03.427 --> 00:51:08.732
AYE SKINNER. I STERN I NUMBER I
00:51:08.799 --> 00:51:12.169
Y. CASTING AYE WIENER AYE WILK
00:51:12.235 --> 00:51:15.939
NOW. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
00:51:16.006 --> 00:51:21.011
MEMBERS BAKER I. PORCHES NO
00:51:21.077 --> 00:51:27.717
CABALLERO I HERTZBERG. I IS
00:51:27.784 --> 00:51:29.052
THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS NINE MEASURE
00:51:29.119 --> 00:51:30.387
PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO
00:51:30.454 --> 00:51:32.055
MOVE AHEAD IN THE FILE AND WE'RE
00:51:32.122 --> 00:51:35.125
GOING TO TAKE UP FILE ITEM FIFTY
00:51:35.192 --> 00:51:36.993
SIX WHICH IS SENATE BILL
00:51:37.060 --> 00:51:38.128
THIRTEEN FORTY THREE BY CENTER
00:51:38.195 --> 00:51:40.831
LEYVA. SECOND CENTER LEYVA
00:51:40.897 --> 00:51:43.200
YOU'RE READY- SURGERY PLEASE
00:51:43.266 --> 00:51:45.836
READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN FORTY
00:51:45.902 --> 00:51:47.137
THREE BY SENATOR LEYVA AN ACT
00:51:47.204 --> 00:51:48.505
RELATING TO RETIREMENT AND
00:51:48.572 --> 00:51:49.573
MAKING AN APPROPRIATION
00:51:49.639 --> 00:51:51.041
THEREFORE CENTER LEYVA THANK YOU
00:51:51.107 --> 00:51:52.242
MR PRESIDENT GOOD MORNING
00:51:52.309 --> 00:51:53.577
MEMBERS YOU MAY REMEMBER THIS
00:51:53.643 --> 00:51:55.512
BILL FROM YESTERDAY THIS WILL
00:51:55.579 --> 00:51:57.013
ENSURE THAT EVERY TEACHER IN
00:51:57.080 --> 00:51:59.182
CALIFORNIA HAS THE RETIREMENT
00:51:59.249 --> 00:52:00.951
SECURITY OFFERED BY OUR STATE
00:52:01.017 --> 00:52:03.320
PENSION SYSTEM SPECIFICALLY THIS
00:52:03.386 --> 00:52:05.589
BILL REQUIRE NEWLY CREATED NEWLY
00:52:05.655 --> 00:52:07.157
CREATED CHARTER SCHOOLS. TO
00:52:07.224 --> 00:52:08.825
PARTICIPATE IN THE CALIFORNIA
00:52:08.892 --> 00:52:10.827
STATE TEACHERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM
00:52:10.894 --> 00:52:12.229
CALPERS AND THE CALIFORNIA
00:52:12.295 --> 00:52:13.497
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT
00:52:13.563 --> 00:52:15.632
SYSTEM CALPERS MEMBERS I
00:52:15.699 --> 00:52:16.933
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:52:17.000 --> 00:52:19.035
VOTE THANK YOU SIR DAVID MEMBERS
00:52:19.102 --> 00:52:20.537
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
00:52:20.604 --> 00:52:23.807
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN FORTY THREE
00:52:23.874 --> 00:52:25.742
CENTER GLAZER YOU ARE RECOGNIZED
00:52:25.809 --> 00:52:27.110
. THANK YOU OF THIS PRESENT
00:52:27.177 --> 00:52:29.546
NUMBERS I DIDN'T SPEAK ON THIS
00:52:29.613 --> 00:52:30.881
BILL YESTERDAY- YOU KNOW WE
00:52:30.947 --> 00:52:34.951
HAVE- IN THE PAST SESSION WE
00:52:35.018 --> 00:52:36.152
HAVE HAD BIG FIGHTS ON THIS
00:52:36.219 --> 00:52:39.022
FLOOR- IN THIS AREA FOR A PUBLIC
00:52:39.089 --> 00:52:40.957
CHARTER SCHOOLS. AND WE ADDED
00:52:41.024 --> 00:52:45.395
STANDARDS. TO THEM ON CONFLICT.
00:52:45.462 --> 00:52:47.464
AND WE ADDED STANDARDS THEM ON
00:52:47.531 --> 00:52:50.166
REPORTING AND IT WAS A BIG FIGHT
00:52:50.233 --> 00:52:52.702
AND IN THAT DISCUSSION. IT WAS
00:52:52.769 --> 00:52:53.904
CLEAR THAT THIS IS LIKE THE LAST
00:52:53.970 --> 00:52:56.706
FIGHT WE ESTABLISH THESE PUBLIC
00:52:56.773 --> 00:52:58.742
CHARTERS- WITH THE ABILITY TO
00:52:58.808 --> 00:53:01.111
INNOVATE. AND THE ABILITY TO-
00:53:01.177 --> 00:53:04.581
PERCENTILE. IT VANCE EXCELLENCE
00:53:04.648 --> 00:53:07.450
IN THEIR OWN UNIQUE WAY AND IT'S
00:53:07.517 --> 00:53:08.118
BEEN WORKING THERE ARE MORE THAN
00:53:08.184 --> 00:53:10.520
A THOUSAND PUBLIC CHARTER
00:53:10.587 --> 00:53:12.923
SCHOOLS IN CALIFORNIA TODAY AND
00:53:12.989 --> 00:53:14.457
MANY OF THEM ARE THRIVING
00:53:14.524 --> 00:53:16.560
DESPITE THE MANY CHALLENGES THAT
00:53:16.626 --> 00:53:20.430
OUR EDUCATION SYSTEM. IS FACING
00:53:20.497 --> 00:53:23.767
. AND SO THIS BILL IS AN ATTEMPT
00:53:23.833 --> 00:53:25.902
TO TAKE AWAY THAT INDEPENDENT
00:53:25.969 --> 00:53:28.638
SORTIE YEAH IT'S NOT TO SAY THAT
00:53:28.705 --> 00:53:30.106
CHARTERS PUBLIC CHARTERS DON'T
00:53:30.173 --> 00:53:31.174
HAVE RETIREMENT SYSTEMS THEY ALL
00:53:31.241 --> 00:53:34.477
DO. AND MANY OF THEM I'M TOLD
00:53:34.544 --> 00:53:38.014
90% OF THEM ARE IN CANCERS. SO
00:53:38.081 --> 00:53:40.317
WHAT PROBLEM ARE WE TRYING TO
00:53:40.383 --> 00:53:43.954
FIX HERE. WAS ABOUT A MONTH AGO
00:53:44.020 --> 00:53:46.256
THAT ON THIS FLOOR WE-
00:53:46.323 --> 00:53:47.958
RECOGNIZED OUR FORMER SENATOR
00:53:48.024 --> 00:53:51.061
GARY HART. ON HIS PASSING HE WAS
00:53:51.127 --> 00:53:53.563
THE ONE WHO AUTHORED THE CHARTER
00:53:53.630 --> 00:53:55.498
SCHOOL LEGISLATION AND HE WAS.
00:53:55.565 --> 00:53:58.268
RECOGNIZED FOR THE COURAGE AND
00:53:58.335 --> 00:54:00.804
IN ADVANCING THIS INNOVATIVE.
00:54:00.870 --> 00:54:03.173
PROGRAM TO HELP OUR KIDS.
00:54:03.239 --> 00:54:04.240
AHRENDTS WANTED TO MAKE THAT
00:54:04.307 --> 00:54:06.610
CHOICE. AND SO WE HAVE SEEN OVER
00:54:06.676 --> 00:54:09.713
THE YEARS AND TEMPS TO TRY TO A
00:54:09.779 --> 00:54:11.247
ROAD THAT INDEPENDENCE. AND I
00:54:11.314 --> 00:54:13.583
DON'T THINK IT'S BEEN A HEALTHY
00:54:13.650 --> 00:54:14.584
ACTIVITY. I THINK IT'S
00:54:14.651 --> 00:54:17.320
REVERSING. A WONDERFUL TRADITION
00:54:17.387 --> 00:54:18.154
THAT THE SENATE HAD ESTABLISHED
00:54:18.221 --> 00:54:20.957
IN THAT. IN THAT LEGISLATION BY
00:54:21.024 --> 00:54:23.526
SENATOR HART. SO THIS BILL IS
00:54:23.593 --> 00:54:25.662
NOT ABOUT FIXING A PROBLEM WHEN
00:54:25.729 --> 00:54:27.564
I ASKED THE SPONSORS OF THE BILL
00:54:27.631 --> 00:54:29.232
TO KEEP EXAMPLES OF WHERE
00:54:29.299 --> 00:54:30.500
RETIREMENT FUNDS OF PUBLIC
00:54:30.567 --> 00:54:31.835
CHARTERS HAVE GONE UPSIDE DOWN
00:54:31.901 --> 00:54:34.471
AND CREATED SOME CRISIS AT THIS
00:54:34.537 --> 00:54:36.706
BILL WOULD SOMEHOW FIX. AND THE
00:54:36.773 --> 00:54:39.376
ANSWER WAS NOTHING. THIS ISN'T
00:54:39.442 --> 00:54:41.444
TRYING TO FIX SOME BIG PROBLEM
00:54:41.511 --> 00:54:43.546
OUT THERE SO WHY ARE WE PASSING
00:54:43.613 --> 00:54:46.316
A BILL LIKE THIS. AND SO I DON'T
00:54:46.383 --> 00:54:48.418
THINK THERE IS JUSTIFICATION FOR
00:54:48.485 --> 00:54:51.354
FORCING NEW CHARTERS TO FIT INTO
00:54:51.421 --> 00:54:53.390
A CONSTRUCT THAT WE ACKNOWLEDGE.
00:54:53.456 --> 00:54:54.457
IS A SPACE THAT WE WANT
00:54:54.524 --> 00:54:55.859
INNOVATION AND I'LL
00:54:55.925 --> 00:54:59.095
OPPORTUNITIES AND OPTIONS SO WHY
00:54:59.162 --> 00:55:02.799
DO IT HERE- WITH THOSE REASONS I
00:55:02.866 --> 00:55:04.234
WOULD ASK THAT WE- VOTE NO ON
00:55:04.300 --> 00:55:06.436
THIS LEGISLATION. THANK YOU
00:55:06.503 --> 00:55:12.108
CENTER GLAZIER. CENTER BORDERS.
00:55:12.175 --> 00:55:14.144
I'D HAVE TO AGREE WITH MY
00:55:14.210 --> 00:55:15.712
COLLEAGUES COMMENTS WHAT IS THE
00:55:15.779 --> 00:55:18.214
MOTIVATION BEHIND THIS. I'VE
00:55:18.281 --> 00:55:20.083
KNOWN FOR LAST THREE YEARS THAT
00:55:20.150 --> 00:55:21.484
I'VE BEEN A MEMBER FOR YEARS
00:55:21.551 --> 00:55:23.553
I'VE BEEN A MEMBER OF THIS BOARD
00:55:23.620 --> 00:55:25.588
THIS AND THIS BODY THAT WE'VE
00:55:25.655 --> 00:55:28.525
HAD- DRAG OUT FIGHTS ON CHARTER
00:55:28.591 --> 00:55:31.194
SCHOOLS. AND I THINK IT REALLY
00:55:31.261 --> 00:55:33.697
COMES DOWN TO THOSE THAT WISH
00:55:33.763 --> 00:55:35.265
FOR THE NEW EXIST TO SERVICE
00:55:35.331 --> 00:55:40.336
PETRI DISHES OF EVOLUTION AND- A
00:55:40.403 --> 00:55:41.871
TRANSFORMATION EDUCATIONAL
00:55:41.938 --> 00:55:44.174
PROCESS. AND THOSE THAT
00:55:44.240 --> 00:55:46.943
VEHEMENTLY. WANT TO DENY THEIR
00:55:47.010 --> 00:55:48.912
EXISTENCE. AND SO THIS IS
00:55:48.978 --> 00:55:50.914
ANOTHER STRATEGIC MOVE FORWARD
00:55:50.980 --> 00:55:53.416
BY DEPRIVING THESE SCHOOLS OF
00:55:53.483 --> 00:55:55.051
THE FLEXIBILITY TO CREATE NEW
00:55:55.118 --> 00:55:57.153
MODELS TO CREATE NEW WAYS OF
00:55:57.220 --> 00:55:58.855
OFFERING COMPENSATION IN
00:55:58.922 --> 00:56:01.091
ATTRACTIVENESS THAT OTHER
00:56:01.157 --> 00:56:02.659
SCHOOLS ON THE TRADITIONAL
00:56:02.726 --> 00:56:06.296
MODEL- FINE TO THREATENING.
00:56:06.362 --> 00:56:07.564
LET'S NOT KID OURSELVES THIS
00:56:07.630 --> 00:56:09.833
ISN'T ABOUT MAKING ART TEACHERS
00:56:09.899 --> 00:56:11.801
ELIGIBLE FOR RETIREMENT IN AN
00:56:11.868 --> 00:56:13.903
EQUITABLE KIND OF WAY THIS IS
00:56:13.970 --> 00:56:15.171
DESIGNED TO TAKE AWAY THE
00:56:15.238 --> 00:56:17.407
ENTICEMENT AND ATTRACTIVENESS OF
00:56:17.474 --> 00:56:19.242
AN ALTERNATIVE MODEL. COLLEAGUES
00:56:19.309 --> 00:56:23.713
I'M- I'M HOPEFUL THAT. THIS IS A
00:56:23.780 --> 00:56:26.116
BILL THAT WILL RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:56:26.182 --> 00:56:27.117
THE AUTHOR TO GO BACK TO THE
00:56:27.183 --> 00:56:29.686
DRAWING BOARD AND COME PERHAPS
00:56:29.753 --> 00:56:31.221
COME BACK AT SOME OTHER POINT IN
00:56:31.287 --> 00:56:33.123
TIME WITH MORE REASONABLE-
00:56:33.189 --> 00:56:40.864
PROPOSAL. CENTER OCTOBER. HELLO
00:56:40.930 --> 00:56:43.366
COLLEAGUES AT MISTER CHAIR THANK
00:56:43.433 --> 00:56:47.103
YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK
00:56:47.170 --> 00:56:48.404
. WE HAD A VERY LIVELY
00:56:48.471 --> 00:56:50.740
DISCUSSION ON THIS BILL- WHEN
00:56:50.807 --> 00:56:52.275
CAME THROUGH EDUCATION BY ONE OF
00:56:52.342 --> 00:56:54.010
THE THINGS I JUST WANTED TO
00:56:54.077 --> 00:56:55.378
HIGHLIGHT. IS THE FACT THAT.
00:56:55.445 --> 00:56:58.715
THIS BILL. SORT OF CONVEYS THE
00:56:58.782 --> 00:57:01.251
NOTION THAT PERHAPS. AT CHARTER
00:57:01.317 --> 00:57:03.920
SCHOOLS DO NOT HAVE ACCESS. TO
00:57:03.987 --> 00:57:05.655
THESE RETIREMENT PROGRAMS
00:57:05.722 --> 00:57:06.856
ALREADY. IN WHICH QUITE FRANKLY
00:57:06.923 --> 00:57:09.793
THEY DO. AND AS MENTIONED BY MY
00:57:09.859 --> 00:57:13.229
COLLEAGUE- ALSO ON THE EDUCATION
00:57:13.296 --> 00:57:16.499
COMMITTEE CAN'T THINK OF YOUR
00:57:16.566 --> 00:57:20.003
CITY ANTHOLOGIZED BUT- BUT AS
00:57:20.069 --> 00:57:21.337
MENTIONED MANY OF THE CHARTER
00:57:21.404 --> 00:57:23.306
SCHOOLS ALREADY PARTICIPATE IN
00:57:23.373 --> 00:57:25.708
THIS PROGRAM. THE ONLY THING
00:57:25.775 --> 00:57:27.343
THAT THIS WOULD DO IS REMOVE THE
00:57:27.410 --> 00:57:30.880
OPTION FOR THE SCHOOLS TO CREATE
00:57:30.947 --> 00:57:33.683
OR THINK OR OR DEVICES NEW
00:57:33.750 --> 00:57:35.351
MODELS AS MENTIONED BY MY OTHER
00:57:35.418 --> 00:57:38.588
COLLEAGUE- WITH REGARDS TO WHAT
00:57:38.655 --> 00:57:42.759
SORT OF RETIREMENT AB. OPTIONS
00:57:42.826 --> 00:57:46.095
TEACHERS MAY HAVE BUT ONCE AGAIN
00:57:46.162 --> 00:57:47.564
CHARTER SCHOOLS ALREADY HAVE
00:57:47.630 --> 00:57:49.732
THIS OPTION IN MANY HAVE OPTED
00:57:49.799 --> 00:57:52.168
FOR IT ALL OF THIS BILL WILL BE
00:57:52.235 --> 00:57:54.404
DOING TO THEM IS REMOVING THE
00:57:54.470 --> 00:57:57.340
ABILITY TO CREATE AND INNOVATE
00:57:57.407 --> 00:57:59.209
THE VERY ESSENCE OF WHAT CHARTER
00:57:59.275 --> 00:58:02.212
SCHOOLS ARE SUPPOSED TO BE.
00:58:02.278 --> 00:58:06.316
DOING SO I RESPECTFULLY WILL ASK
00:58:06.382 --> 00:58:08.051
FOR A NO VOTE ON THIS BILL
00:58:08.117 --> 00:58:09.519
BECAUSE I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT
00:58:09.586 --> 00:58:11.588
TO HAVE INNOVATION NEW MODELS SO
00:58:11.654 --> 00:58:14.023
WE CAN THINK OF AND ALLOW THEM
00:58:14.090 --> 00:58:16.326
TO DO WHAT THEY DO BEST. THAT'S
00:58:16.392 --> 00:58:18.027
THE ESSENCE OF CHARTER SCHOOLS
00:58:18.094 --> 00:58:20.697
ONCE AGAIN THEY ALREADY HAVE THE
00:58:20.763 --> 00:58:22.932
OPTION TO PARTICIPATE. ALL THIS
00:58:22.999 --> 00:58:24.701
BILL WILL BE DOING IS REMOVING
00:58:24.767 --> 00:58:28.037
THOSE OPTIONS AND MANDATING A
00:58:28.104 --> 00:58:32.809
ONE SIZE FITS ALL. THANK YOU.
00:58:32.876 --> 00:58:34.310
THANK YOU CENTER TROUBLED
00:58:34.377 --> 00:58:36.546
SENATOR GROVE THANK YOU MR
00:58:36.613 --> 00:58:38.314
PRESIDENT I TO JOIN MY
00:58:38.381 --> 00:58:39.816
COLLEAGUES IN RISE IN OPPOSITION
00:58:39.883 --> 00:58:41.918
TO THIS BILL THESE TEACHERS HAVE
00:58:41.985 --> 00:58:43.887
A CHOICE TO WORK FOR A PUBLIC
00:58:43.953 --> 00:58:45.221
SCHOOL TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOL
00:58:45.288 --> 00:58:47.023
OR A PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOL IN
00:58:47.090 --> 00:58:49.058
THE QUEUES TO WORK FOR A CHARTER
00:58:49.125 --> 00:58:50.393
SCHOOL BECAUSE OF THE
00:58:50.460 --> 00:58:51.327
FLEXIBILITY THAT THEY HAVE NOT
00:58:51.394 --> 00:58:53.062
ONLY IN THE EDUCATION PROCESS
00:58:53.129 --> 00:58:54.097
BUT JUST ON THE WAY THEY
00:58:54.163 --> 00:58:56.132
OPERATE. IT'S NOT A ONE SIZE
00:58:56.199 --> 00:58:58.067
FITS ALL I CAN TELL YOU THAT
00:58:58.134 --> 00:58:59.502
CHARTER SCHOOLS HAVE HIGHER
00:58:59.569 --> 00:59:00.436
ATTENDANCE NUMBERS HIGHER
00:59:00.503 --> 00:59:02.672
GRADUATION RATES IN THEIR
00:59:02.739 --> 00:59:03.306
STUDENTS ARE SHOWN TO DO BETTER
00:59:03.373 --> 00:59:06.709
IN COLLEGE AND THEY ALSO HAVE
00:59:06.776 --> 00:59:08.778
HIGHER PARENT PARTICIPATION. WE
00:59:08.845 --> 00:59:09.979
HAD A CHARTER SCHOOL A
00:59:10.046 --> 00:59:11.281
FOUNDATION THAT STARTED A
00:59:11.347 --> 00:59:12.382
CHARTER SCHOOL THE FIRST WHEN
00:59:12.448 --> 00:59:14.417
THEY STARTED WAS IN A SMALL AND
00:59:14.484 --> 00:59:15.718
MINORITY COMMUNITY JUST SOUTH OF
00:59:15.785 --> 00:59:18.588
BAKERSFIELD IN ARVIN CALIFORNIA
00:59:18.655 --> 00:59:20.590
WHERE I GREW UP. AND IT WAS
00:59:20.657 --> 00:59:22.058
SUPPOSED TO BY CTA WAS OPPOSED
00:59:22.125 --> 00:59:23.426
BY THE TEACHERS T WAS OPPOSED
00:59:23.493 --> 00:59:25.328
BY PARENTS. BUT THEY WENT
00:59:25.395 --> 00:59:27.096
FORWARD AND THEY MOVED- BECAUSE
00:59:27.163 --> 00:59:28.698
OF ALL THE MISINFORMATION THAT
00:59:28.765 --> 00:59:30.233
WAS SENT OUT TO THE COMMUNITY.
00:59:30.300 --> 00:59:31.534
PARENTS WERE VERY VERY UPSET
00:59:31.601 --> 00:59:33.169
ABOUT IT. BUT WHEN THEY WENT
00:59:33.236 --> 00:59:35.238
FORWARD IT WAS FINALLY APPROVED-
00:59:35.305 --> 00:59:37.006
THROUGH THE PROCESS. THERE IS A
00:59:37.073 --> 00:59:39.509
WAITING LIST NOW IT'S BEEN IN
00:59:39.575 --> 00:59:40.576
EXISTENCE FOR A THINK THIRTEEN
00:59:40.643 --> 00:59:42.612
YEARS. AND THERE S A WAITING
00:59:42.679 --> 00:59:44.614
LIST NOW- AND THEY BUILT TWO
00:59:44.681 --> 00:59:45.782
ADDITIONAL SCHOOLS IN THESE
00:59:45.848 --> 00:59:47.250
FARMING COMMUNITIES WHERE. HE'S
00:59:47.317 --> 00:59:50.586
LIKE TINO KIDS PREDOMINATELY 99%
00:59:50.653 --> 00:59:52.021
LATINO CHILDREN THAT ATTEND
00:59:52.088 --> 00:59:53.189
THESE SCHOOLS AND THESE FARMING
00:59:53.256 --> 00:59:55.758
COMMUNITIES IN ARVIN SHAFTER.
00:59:55.825 --> 00:59:58.661
DELANO WASCO WHERE THIS
00:59:58.728 --> 00:59:59.996
FOUNDATION IS BUILT THESE
01:00:00.063 --> 01:00:02.198
CHARTER SCHOOLS. PARENTS ARE SO
01:00:02.265 --> 01:00:04.167
EXCITED TO HAVE THEIR KIDS GO TO
01:00:04.233 --> 01:00:05.101
SCHOOL THEY HAVE A HIGHER
01:00:05.168 --> 01:00:07.003
GRADUATION RATE OF HIGHER
01:00:07.070 --> 01:00:10.073
COLLEGE RATES. THEY HAVE- PARENT
01:00:10.139 --> 01:00:11.607
PARTICIPATION MAY HAVE AN EDIBLE
01:00:11.674 --> 01:00:14.110
GARDEN THAT'S BEEN ADOPTED BY A
01:00:14.177 --> 01:00:15.578
LOT OF SCHOOLS. AND IT'S CREATED
01:00:15.645 --> 01:00:18.815
A COMPETITION SORT OF IN THE-TRADITIONAL PUBLIC SCHOOLS
01:00:18.881 --> 01:00:20.350
BECAUSE THE KIDS WANTTO ATTEND
01:00:20.416 --> 01:00:21.451
THIS CHARTER SCHOOL IN THIS
01:00:21.517 --> 01:00:25.855
AREA. AND IT'S ACTUALLY- THE
01:00:25.922 --> 01:00:26.856
PUBLIC SCHOOLS HAVE MODEL.
01:00:26.923 --> 01:00:27.991
ASTRUM TRAINING INSTEAD AROUND
01:00:28.057 --> 01:00:30.026
THESE CHARTER SCHOOLS YOU KNOW
01:00:30.093 --> 01:00:31.294
TWENTY MINUTES A CLASS VERSUS AN
01:00:31.361 --> 01:00:33.396
HOUR FOR THE LOWER GRADE
01:00:33.463 --> 01:00:34.230
STUDENTS SO THAT THEY CAN. HAVE
01:00:34.297 --> 01:00:35.898
AN ATTENTION SPAN WHERE THEY
01:00:35.965 --> 01:00:38.001
GARNER MORE INFORMATION. SOME OF
01:00:38.067 --> 01:00:40.003
THESE KIDS. COMING AND WORKING
01:00:40.069 --> 01:00:41.637
IN THE FIELDS FOURTH AND FIFTH
01:00:41.704 --> 01:00:43.473
GENERATION FARMWORKERS. THEY
01:00:43.539 --> 01:00:44.474
NEVER THOUGHT THEY'D HAVE THE
01:00:44.540 --> 01:00:47.410
OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO COLLEGE AND
01:00:47.477 --> 01:00:49.979
BE SOMETHING OTHER THAN. WHAT
01:00:50.046 --> 01:00:51.848
WAS AROUND THEM IN THEIR
01:00:51.914 --> 01:00:52.815
COMMUNITY AND THESE KIDS ARE
01:00:52.882 --> 01:00:54.784
VERY VERY SUCCESSFUL AND HAVING
01:00:54.851 --> 01:00:56.853
TEACHERS THAT WANT TO ENGAGE IN
01:00:56.919 --> 01:00:59.956
THIS PROCESS. AND HAVE AN OPTION
01:01:00.023 --> 01:01:01.958
TO BE ABLE TO HAVE A FOUR OH ONE
01:01:02.025 --> 01:01:04.193
K. OR TO HAVE THE AGREEMENTS
01:01:04.260 --> 01:01:05.428
THAT THEY HAVE IN PLACE VERSUS
01:01:05.495 --> 01:01:07.730
HAVING TO PARTICIPATING CASTERS.
01:01:07.797 --> 01:01:09.799
THIS IS JUST AN OPTION AND IF
01:01:09.866 --> 01:01:11.267
YOU WANT TO PARTICIPATE AS A
01:01:11.334 --> 01:01:13.036
CHARTER SCHOOL TEACHER IN CAL
01:01:13.102 --> 01:01:15.138
STIRS YOU CAN. AND IF YOU DON'T
01:01:15.204 --> 01:01:16.706
WANT TO UNDER EXISTING LAW YOU
01:01:16.773 --> 01:01:18.741
DON'T HAVE TO AND YOU CAN
01:01:18.808 --> 01:01:19.842
PARTICIPATE IN THE PROGRAM AT
01:01:19.909 --> 01:01:21.277
THE CHARTER SCHOOL OFFERS. JUST
01:01:21.344 --> 01:01:23.146
LIKE MY COLLEAGUE SAID. AND THIS
01:01:23.212 --> 01:01:25.381
BILL JUST ELIMINATES THAT OPTION
01:01:25.448 --> 01:01:26.315
AND IT'S REALLY SAD THAT WE
01:01:26.382 --> 01:01:27.950
WOULD DO THAT AN ATTACK THE
01:01:28.017 --> 01:01:29.152
SCHOOLS EVEN FURTHER THAN WE
01:01:29.218 --> 01:01:30.620
HAVE IN THIS LEGISLATIVE BODY IN
01:01:30.686 --> 01:01:32.922
THE PAST AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:01:32.989 --> 01:01:34.057
FOR A NO VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
01:01:34.123 --> 01:01:37.393
GROVE SENATOR BECKER. I THANK
01:01:37.460 --> 01:01:39.362
YOU I JUST WANNA MAKE A COMMENT
01:01:39.429 --> 01:01:40.396
UNLIKE PRICE IN THIS PREVIOUS
01:01:40.463 --> 01:01:41.964
SPEAKERS I DO SUPPORT THIS ONE
01:01:42.031 --> 01:01:44.801
NEW SCHOOLS RIGHT TO HAVE A LOT
01:01:44.867 --> 01:01:45.935
OF EXISTING NETWORKS TO HAVE A
01:01:46.002 --> 01:01:48.471
BUILT UP ONE SYSTEM AND THIS
01:01:48.538 --> 01:01:50.339
BILL RIGHT NOW WOULD FORCE THEM
01:01:50.406 --> 01:01:51.174
TO THAT MAINTAIN TWO SYSTEMS
01:01:51.240 --> 01:01:52.341
WITHIN THE SAME CHARTER
01:01:52.408 --> 01:01:54.177
MANAGEMENT ORGANIZATION SO
01:01:54.243 --> 01:01:56.112
THAT'S ISSUE THAT I HAVE. WITH
01:01:56.179 --> 01:01:59.515
IT BUT WOULD SUPPORT IT- IN THE
01:01:59.582 --> 01:02:00.850
FUTURE WITH FOR NEW CHARTERS.
01:02:00.917 --> 01:02:03.119
THANK YOU SIR BAKER ANY OTHER
01:02:03.186 --> 01:02:05.254
MEMBERS WISHING TO BE RECOGNIZED
01:02:05.321 --> 01:02:07.123
. CENTER LEYVA YOU MAY CLOSE
01:02:07.190 --> 01:02:08.291
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT MEMBERS
01:02:08.357 --> 01:02:09.826
THANK YOU FOR THE ROBUST
01:02:09.892 --> 01:02:11.861
DISCUSSION I JUST WANT TO SAY
01:02:11.928 --> 01:02:13.529
THAT I THINK- SOME FOLKS ARE
01:02:13.596 --> 01:02:15.331
OVER THINKING THIS BILL AND THAT
01:02:15.398 --> 01:02:17.300
THEY'RE CONFLATING SOME ISSUES I
01:02:17.366 --> 01:02:19.068
WOULD DISAGREE WITH MY COLLEAGUE
01:02:19.135 --> 01:02:20.603
THIS IS NOT A BIG FIGHT. AND
01:02:20.670 --> 01:02:22.572
IT'S NOT AN ATTACK ON CHARTER
01:02:22.638 --> 01:02:24.407
SCHOOLS CHARTER SCHOOLS WILL
01:02:24.474 --> 01:02:26.409
STILL HAVE THEIR INDEPENDENCE
01:02:26.476 --> 01:02:27.810
THEY WILL STILL BE ABLE TO TEACH
01:02:27.877 --> 01:02:29.679
WHAT THEY CHOOSE TO TEACH IT
01:02:29.745 --> 01:02:32.115
ISN'T A BIG STRATEGIC MOVE TO DO
01:02:32.181 --> 01:02:34.917
SOMETHING DIFFERENT. ALL THIS IS
01:02:34.984 --> 01:02:37.653
MAKING SURE THE TEACHERS WHO ARE
01:02:37.720 --> 01:02:39.622
TEACHING OUR FUTURE OR TEACHING
01:02:39.689 --> 01:02:42.992
OUR FUTURE LEADERS HAVE ACCESS
01:02:43.059 --> 01:02:45.094
TO A DEFINED BENEFIT PENSION.
01:02:45.161 --> 01:02:46.429
MANY YOUNG TEACHERS START
01:02:46.496 --> 01:02:48.331
TEACHING AT THE AGE OF TWENTY
01:02:48.397 --> 01:02:50.133
THREE AGE TWENTY FOUR THEY DON'T
01:02:50.199 --> 01:02:51.467
KNOW THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A
01:02:51.534 --> 01:02:52.635
FOUR ONE K. AND A DEFINED
01:02:52.702 --> 01:02:54.537
BENEFIT PENSION THEY DON'T KNOW
01:02:54.604 --> 01:02:56.772
THAT A FOUR OH ONE K. HAVE EBBS
01:02:56.839 --> 01:02:59.108
AND FLOWS WITH THE STOCK MARKET
01:02:59.175 --> 01:03:00.376
FOR ONE CASE ARE GREAT FOR
01:03:00.443 --> 01:03:02.478
WEALTHY PEOPLE THEY'RE NOT GREAT
01:03:02.545 --> 01:03:03.446
FOR PEOPLE WHO ARE WORKING
01:03:03.513 --> 01:03:05.615
CLASS. A DEFINED BENEFIT PENSION
01:03:05.681 --> 01:03:07.483
MEANS THAT YOU KNOW EVERY SINGLE
01:03:07.550 --> 01:03:09.152
MONTH WHEN YOU RETIRE WHAT
01:03:09.218 --> 01:03:10.987
YOU'LL RECEIVE AND FOR ALL OF US
01:03:11.053 --> 01:03:12.555
ON THIS FLOOR EVERY SINGLE ONE
01:03:12.622 --> 01:03:14.891
OF OUR STAFFERS HAVE A DEFINED
01:03:14.957 --> 01:03:17.426
BENEFIT PENSION THROUGH CALPERS.
01:03:17.493 --> 01:03:19.462
THIS BILL JUST MAKE SURE THAT
01:03:19.529 --> 01:03:22.498
TEACHERS IN CHARTER SCHOOLS MORE
01:03:22.565 --> 01:03:24.467
FEB ARE FUNDED WITH PUBLIC MONEY
01:03:24.534 --> 01:03:26.435
ALSO HAVE THAT OPTION MEMBERS I
01:03:26.502 --> 01:03:28.538
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
01:03:28.604 --> 01:03:32.475
VOTE THANK YOU SIR LEYVA
01:03:32.542 --> 01:03:33.776
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:03:33.843 --> 01:03:37.547
ALLEN CHULA FIVE ATKINS AYE
01:03:37.613 --> 01:03:42.485
BATES NO BAKER. PORGES NO
01:03:42.552 --> 01:03:47.790
BRADFORD. CABALLERO AYE CORTESE
01:03:47.857 --> 01:03:53.729
AYE DALY NO DODD. TORONTO I
01:03:53.796 --> 01:03:59.001
EGGMAN I GLAZER NO GONZALEZ I
01:03:59.068 --> 01:04:04.674
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESSEL. HER
01:04:04.740 --> 01:04:12.448
TADO. JONES NO KAMLAGER. LAYERED
01:04:12.515 --> 01:04:22.825
I LEYVA. LEYVA AYE LIMÓN. I
01:04:22.892 --> 01:04:30.566
MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ. NO MAN AYE
01:04:30.633 --> 01:04:34.704
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A CHOI
01:04:34.770 --> 01:04:39.041
BOGUE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO.
01:04:39.108 --> 01:04:47.516
ROTH RUBIO. SKINNER AYE STERN
01:04:47.583 --> 01:04:50.553
AYE AMBERG AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE
01:04:50.620 --> 01:04:56.325
WIENER. WILK NOW. PLEASE CALL
01:04:56.392 --> 01:05:01.564
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN BAKER
01:05:01.631 --> 01:05:08.237
. BRADFORD DODD. HERTZBERG WESO
01:05:08.304 --> 01:05:16.445
I HER TADO. KAMLAGER PORTANTINO
01:05:16.512 --> 01:05:25.855
. ROTH RUBIO. WIENER. PLEASE
01:05:25.921 --> 01:05:29.659
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN
01:05:29.725 --> 01:05:38.134
BACKER. BRADFORD DODD. HERTZBERG
01:05:38.200 --> 01:05:44.440
HER TADO. KAMLAGER PORTANTINO.
01:05:44.507 --> 01:05:51.447
ROTH RUBIO WIENER. ALL CENTER
01:05:51.514 --> 01:06:00.356
LABOR MOVES A CALL. MEMBERS ARE
01:06:00.423 --> 01:06:01.924
GOING TO GO BACK INTO THE FILE
01:06:01.991 --> 01:06:04.093
IN FILE ORDER FILE ITEM THIRTY
01:06:04.160 --> 01:06:07.196
SEVEN. FILE ITEM THIRTY SEVEN
01:06:07.263 --> 01:06:09.031
SENATE BILL NINE FIFTY EIGHT
01:06:09.098 --> 01:06:16.272
CENTER LA MON. SECRETARY PLEASE
01:06:16.339 --> 01:06:18.974
READ. SENATE BILL NINE FIFTY
01:06:19.041 --> 01:06:20.743
EIGHT BY SENATOR LIMÓN AN ACT
01:06:20.810 --> 01:06:22.978
RELATING TO HEALTH CARE COVERAGE
01:06:23.045 --> 01:06:24.914
. CEREMONY THANK YOU MR
01:06:24.980 --> 01:06:26.515
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES S. B. THE
01:06:26.582 --> 01:06:29.251
GOAL OF SB NINE FIVE EIGHT IS TO
01:06:29.318 --> 01:06:30.453
ENSURE THAT PATIENTS WITH
01:06:30.519 --> 01:06:31.320
COMPLEX AND LIFE THREATENING
01:06:31.387 --> 01:06:33.789
ILLNESSES WHO NEED SPECIALTY
01:06:33.856 --> 01:06:36.125
INFUSED OR INJECTED MEDICATIONS
01:06:36.192 --> 01:06:37.426
ADMINISTERED BY A DOCTOR OR
01:06:37.493 --> 01:06:39.662
NURSE SUCH AS CHEMOTHERAPY. CAN
01:06:39.729 --> 01:06:42.031
RECEIVE THE NECESSARY MEDICATION
01:06:42.098 --> 01:06:43.866
IN A SAFE AND TIMELY MANNER.
01:06:43.933 --> 01:06:45.701
UNFORTUNATELY HEALTH PLANS HAVE
01:06:45.768 --> 01:06:47.002
STARTED TO IMPLEMENT POLICIES
01:06:47.069 --> 01:06:48.404
THAT RESTRICT PATIENT ACCESS TO
01:06:48.471 --> 01:06:50.306
THESE IMPORTANT MEDICATIONS
01:06:50.373 --> 01:06:51.607
INSTEAD OF ALLOWING THE HEALTH
01:06:51.674 --> 01:06:53.309
CARE PROVIDER TO USE THE
01:06:53.376 --> 01:06:54.710
MEDICATION ON HAND THE PLAN
01:06:54.777 --> 01:06:57.446
REQUIRES THE DOCTOR TO CALL THE
01:06:57.513 --> 01:06:59.081
HEALTH PLAN'S PREFERRED VENDOR.
01:06:59.148 --> 01:07:00.683
THE VENDOR THEN SHIPS THE
01:07:00.750 --> 01:07:01.984
MEDICATION TO THE HEALTH CARE
01:07:02.051 --> 01:07:03.919
PROVIDER LABELED SPECIFICALLY
01:07:03.986 --> 01:07:06.355
FOR THAT PATIENT THIS PROCESS IS
01:07:06.422 --> 01:07:08.224
KNOWN AS WHITE BANKING. WHITE
01:07:08.290 --> 01:07:09.492
BACKING CAN RESULT IN
01:07:09.558 --> 01:07:11.260
SIGNIFICANT DELAYED TREATMENT
01:07:11.327 --> 01:07:12.528
WHICH MAY PUT THE PATIENT'S
01:07:12.595 --> 01:07:15.398
HEALTH AT RISK FOR EXAMPLE IN
01:07:15.464 --> 01:07:17.767
THE SAME DAY TEST RIG IF THE
01:07:17.833 --> 01:07:20.336
SAME DAY TEST REQUIRES A
01:07:20.403 --> 01:07:22.505
DIFFERENT MEDICATION. THEN THE
01:07:22.571 --> 01:07:24.573
MEDICAL PROVIDER MUST RE ORDER
01:07:24.640 --> 01:07:25.941
THE MEDICATION AND RESCHEDULE
01:07:26.008 --> 01:07:27.877
THE APPOINTMENT AS A RESULT THIS
01:07:27.943 --> 01:07:29.745
CAN SIGNIFICANTLY DEBT DELAYED
01:07:29.812 --> 01:07:31.080
TREATMENT AND IMPACTS THE HEALTH
01:07:31.147 --> 01:07:33.549
OF THE PATIENT. WELL SOME ALLEGE
01:07:33.616 --> 01:07:34.984
COST SAVINGS ASSOCIATED WITH
01:07:35.050 --> 01:07:37.186
WHITE BAGGING IT SHOULD ALSO BE
01:07:37.253 --> 01:07:38.788
NOTED THAT THERE ARE NO TANGIBLE
01:07:38.854 --> 01:07:41.490
SAVINGS BUT RATHER A COST SHIFT
01:07:41.557 --> 01:07:43.426
IN RECENT STUDY FOUND THAT WHITE
01:07:43.492 --> 01:07:46.529
BAGGING COST HOSPITAL'S OVER
01:07:46.595 --> 01:07:47.563
THREE HUNDRED AND TEN MILLION
01:07:47.630 --> 01:07:50.132
ANNUALLY. ADDITIONALLY HOSPITALS
01:07:50.199 --> 01:07:51.534
AND PROVIDERS ARE REIMBURSED
01:07:51.600 --> 01:07:55.738
BASED ON AGO SHEETED CONTRACT
01:07:55.805 --> 01:07:57.339
RATES WITH HEALTH PLANS. THE
01:07:57.406 --> 01:07:58.240
RATES ARE MUCH. THAN THE THAN
01:07:58.307 --> 01:08:00.976
THE MARKUPS THE EVIDENCE BY THE
01:08:01.043 --> 01:08:03.179
ADMIN. AS EVIDENCED BY THE
01:08:03.245 --> 01:08:04.680
AMENDMENTS IN THE SENATE HEALTH
01:08:04.747 --> 01:08:06.615
ANALYSIS THE GOAL OF THIS BILL
01:08:06.682 --> 01:08:08.350
IS NOT TO PROHIBIT WHITE BAGGING
01:08:08.417 --> 01:08:09.752
COMPLETELY BUT TO PUT
01:08:09.819 --> 01:08:11.220
APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS AROUND
01:08:11.287 --> 01:08:13.422
THE PRACTICE TO PREVENT DELAYED
01:08:13.489 --> 01:08:15.324
CARE. THE OPTIMAL CARE PATIENT
01:08:15.391 --> 01:08:17.293
DISTRESS AND UNNECESSARY
01:08:17.359 --> 01:08:19.195
HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS THIS BILL
01:08:19.261 --> 01:08:21.330
HAS ALWAYS BEEN ABOUT PROTECTING
01:08:21.397 --> 01:08:23.566
PATIENTS. THIS BILL SUPPORTED BY
01:08:23.632 --> 01:08:26.268
OVER THIRTY FIVE ORGANIZATIONS
01:08:26.335 --> 01:08:28.637
INCLUDING MANY CHILDREN'S
01:08:28.704 --> 01:08:30.639
HOSPITALS ACROSS THE STATE I
01:08:30.706 --> 01:08:32.241
HAVE WITNESSED FIRST HAND HOW
01:08:32.308 --> 01:08:33.843
WHITE BAG IN IMPACTS PATIENT
01:08:33.909 --> 01:08:35.678
CARE. I CONTINUE TO BE IN
01:08:35.744 --> 01:08:36.579
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE
01:08:36.645 --> 01:08:38.848
OPPOSITION ABOUT STRIKING THE
01:08:38.914 --> 01:08:39.715
APPROPRIATE BALANCE THAT
01:08:39.782 --> 01:08:41.484
PROTECTS PATIENTS AND ALSO
01:08:41.550 --> 01:08:43.786
CONTROLS COST WE JUST RECEIVED
01:08:43.853 --> 01:08:45.054
AN AMENDMENTS THIS WEEKEND FROM
01:08:45.120 --> 01:08:46.522
THE OPPOSITION AND WE ARE
01:08:46.589 --> 01:08:47.690
REVIEWING THOSE AND HAVING
01:08:47.756 --> 01:08:49.792
ADDITIONAL MEETINGS. WITH THAT I
01:08:49.859 --> 01:08:51.560
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
01:08:51.627 --> 01:08:53.362
THANK YOU CENTER ALONE AT THE
01:08:53.429 --> 01:08:55.965
MOMENT THANK YOU. SENATOR DODD
01:08:56.031 --> 01:08:57.900
YOU WILL BE FOLLOWED BY SENATOR
01:08:57.967 --> 01:09:00.369
GLAZERS. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
01:09:00.436 --> 01:09:02.304
QUESTION THE AUTHOR. THERE LIMON
01:09:02.371 --> 01:09:03.973
WE TAKE ACTION. CENTERED ON. IT
01:09:04.039 --> 01:09:07.176
KAY- ON THIS BILL I'VE BEEN A I
01:09:07.243 --> 01:09:08.911
THINK I'VE BEEN A STRONG
01:09:08.978 --> 01:09:10.546
ADVOCATE FOR MY LOCAL HOSPITALS
01:09:10.613 --> 01:09:11.881
THROUGHOUT THE SIX COUNTIES THAT
01:09:11.947 --> 01:09:14.817
I REPRESENT. IT'S I WAS A- HERO
01:09:14.884 --> 01:09:17.319
I WAS LIKELY- YOUR TO SUPPORT
01:09:17.386 --> 01:09:19.421
THIS BILL BUT I HAD YEAH THIS IS
01:09:19.488 --> 01:09:21.190
A BIT YET ANOTHER THING THE
01:09:21.257 --> 01:09:22.858
WORK. WERE ASKED TO CHOOSE
01:09:22.925 --> 01:09:25.828
BETWEEN. PATIENT CARE AND COST
01:09:25.895 --> 01:09:28.330
IT I IN I GUESS AT THE END OF
01:09:28.397 --> 01:09:30.432
THE DAY- BIKE MY CONCERN ON THIS
01:09:30.499 --> 01:09:34.370
IS- I DON'T KNOW WHAT. WHAT
01:09:34.436 --> 01:09:36.539
AMENDMENTS WRE GIVEN TO YOU BUT
01:09:36.605 --> 01:09:37.573
I WOULD HOPE WORKING THIS BILL
01:09:37.640 --> 01:09:40.242
IN THE FUTURE- DO YOU LOOK AT
01:09:40.309 --> 01:09:42.945
MA'AM IT'S THAT KIND OF PUTS THE
01:09:43.012 --> 01:09:45.147
CORRALS SOME OF THESE COSTS- YOU
01:09:45.214 --> 01:09:49.184
ON. NOT ON THE PLANS PER SE BUT
01:09:49.251 --> 01:09:51.487
ON. YOU KNOW IT IS JUST ANOTHER
01:09:51.554 --> 01:09:53.188
CONCERN THAT WE ALL HAVE IN
01:09:53.255 --> 01:09:55.157
TERMS OF THE COST OF DRUGS ED.
01:09:55.224 --> 01:09:56.592
I'VE SEEN IT EVEN WITH MY OWN
01:09:56.659 --> 01:09:58.494
HOSPITALS SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE
01:09:58.561 --> 01:10:00.496
DONE WITH THAT AS WELL- I WILL
01:10:00.563 --> 01:10:02.264
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY BUT- BE
01:10:02.331 --> 01:10:03.866
LOOKING FORWARD TO. YOU TAKING
01:10:03.933 --> 01:10:05.701
SOME AMENDMENTS THANK YOU. THANK
01:10:05.768 --> 01:10:07.036
YOU AND I WILL COMMENTED THAT I
01:10:07.102 --> 01:10:09.238
THINK WE ALL CARE ABOUT COST AND
01:10:09.305 --> 01:10:10.339
CERTAINLY THAT IS SOMETHING
01:10:10.406 --> 01:10:12.675
WE'RE LOOKING- ATTY WHAT ARE THE
01:10:12.741 --> 01:10:14.944
APPROPRIATE GUARDRAILS- AROUND
01:10:15.010 --> 01:10:17.413
COSTA OF MEDICATIONS SO- WE WILL
01:10:17.479 --> 01:10:18.781
BE LOOKING AT AMENDMENTS IN
01:10:18.847 --> 01:10:19.548
CONTINUING TALKS WITH THE
01:10:19.615 --> 01:10:22.451
OPPOSITION. THE USER LEMOND
01:10:22.518 --> 01:10:24.720
CENTER GLAZER. THANK YOU THANK
01:10:24.787 --> 01:10:25.955
YOU MR PRESIDENT NUMBERS THE
01:10:26.021 --> 01:10:27.089
SENATOR FROM NAPA CERTAINLY
01:10:27.156 --> 01:10:29.058
IDENTIFIED A CONCERN OF MINE AS
01:10:29.124 --> 01:10:30.859
WELL- WEEK WE COMPLAIN A LOT
01:10:30.926 --> 01:10:32.394
ABOUT THESE HEALTHCARE COSTS
01:10:32.461 --> 01:10:33.629
AND- AND WHAT THAT MEANS THE TO
01:10:33.696 --> 01:10:35.798
OUR CONSUMERS OUT THERE WHO. ARE
01:10:35.864 --> 01:10:37.633
DESPERATELY NEED THAT TYPE OF
01:10:37.700 --> 01:10:39.702
COVERAGE. I THINK THAT- YOU KNOW
01:10:39.768 --> 01:10:41.503
WHAT HAS BEEN COMPELLING TO ME
01:10:41.570 --> 01:10:42.838
IN THIS PARTICULAR CASE IS THE%
01:10:42.905 --> 01:10:44.940
FACT THAT IT'S- IT'S NARROW TO-
01:10:45.007 --> 01:10:46.942
INFUSED OR INJECTED MEDICATIONS
01:10:47.009 --> 01:10:49.244
AND THE- AND TALKING TO EXPERTS
01:10:49.311 --> 01:10:50.879
INCLUDING OUR WONDERFUL. DOCTOR
01:10:50.946 --> 01:10:52.181
PAN WHO SERVES AS CHAIR OF THE
01:10:52.247 --> 01:10:53.716
HEALTH COMMITTEE- HE'S MADE
01:10:53.782 --> 01:10:55.117
CLEAR AND OTHERS HAVE MADE CLEAR
01:10:55.184 --> 01:10:56.619
THE DELICATE NATURE OF THESE
01:10:56.685 --> 01:10:58.320
PARTICULAR TYPES. OF DRUGS AND
01:10:58.387 --> 01:10:59.622
THE CARE THAT THESE PARTICULAR
01:10:59.688 --> 01:11:02.157
TYPES OF DRUGS. I NEED TO HAVE
01:11:02.224 --> 01:11:04.493
TO BE PROPERLY ADMINISTERED. AND
01:11:04.560 --> 01:11:06.462
SO BECAUSE IT'S NEARLY CRAFTED
01:11:06.528 --> 01:11:09.031
FOR ME IT'S SOMETHING THAT- I
01:11:09.098 --> 01:11:11.700
CAN I CAN ACCEPT AS A AS MAY BE
01:11:11.767 --> 01:11:14.770
A PRUDENT- REQUIREMENT NOW. OR
01:11:14.837 --> 01:11:16.805
ELIMINATION OF THE EVER. OF A
01:11:16.872 --> 01:11:18.874
MANDATE. OR AN OPTION THAT- THAT
01:11:18.941 --> 01:11:21.043
EXISTS TODAY BUT I WOULD JOIN
01:11:21.110 --> 01:11:22.077
WITH MINE THE SENATOR FROM
01:11:22.144 --> 01:11:23.979
HAPPEN SAYING THAT- I UNDERSTAND
01:11:24.046 --> 01:11:24.980
THERE HAVE BEEN SOME MEMBERS
01:11:25.047 --> 01:11:26.482
FORWARDED I HAVEN'T SEEN EITHER
01:11:26.548 --> 01:11:28.317
AND I'M HOPING THAT. WHEN THIS
01:11:28.384 --> 01:11:29.218
BILL COMES BACK FROM THE
01:11:29.284 --> 01:11:30.319
ASSEMBLY THAT. THAT DUE
01:11:30.386 --> 01:11:32.254
CONSIDERATION WILL BE GIVEN BY A
01:11:32.321 --> 01:11:34.056
WONDERFUL AUTHOR- TO THOSE AND
01:11:34.123 --> 01:11:36.392
WITH THAT I WOULD SUPPORT THE
01:11:36.458 --> 01:11:36.992
BILL TODAY. THANK YOU SENATOR
01:11:37.059 --> 01:11:38.560
GLAZERS SENATOR NEWMAN YOU ARE
01:11:38.627 --> 01:11:40.696
RECOGNIZED AS THEY MATURE YET I
01:11:40.763 --> 01:11:41.397
JUST WANTED NOW ASSOCIATE
01:11:41.463 --> 01:11:43.699
MYSELF. WITH THE CENTER FOR NOW
01:11:43.766 --> 01:11:46.335
BUT AS WELL AS THE FORMER MAYOR
01:11:46.402 --> 01:11:48.837
OF ORINDA. AND ALSO SECOND IS
01:11:48.904 --> 01:11:51.607
COMING ON THE WONDERFUL MISS OF
01:11:51.674 --> 01:11:53.842
THE AUTHOR. RIGHT I GLAD TO HEAR
01:11:53.909 --> 01:11:55.277
. THAT YOU ARE WORKING WITH UP
01:11:55.344 --> 01:11:57.079
AS- TO YOUR- THIS MEMBERS TO
01:11:57.146 --> 01:11:58.147
NARROW THE BILL RENDER. RENDERED
01:11:58.213 --> 01:11:59.248
UNAMBIGUOUS AS WE FORTUNE THANK
01:11:59.314 --> 01:12:01.317
YOU I WILL ALSO BE. SUPPORTING
01:12:01.383 --> 01:12:02.484
THE BILL TO. THANK YOU CENTER
01:12:02.551 --> 01:12:05.387
NEWMAN CENTER PORTANTINO YES- MR
01:12:05.454 --> 01:12:06.722
PRESIDENT I RISE IS A JOINT
01:12:06.789 --> 01:12:08.657
AUTHORS AND SB NINE FIVE EIGHT
01:12:08.724 --> 01:12:09.925
AND AGAIN WANT TO JOIN THE
01:12:09.992 --> 01:12:13.629
CHORUS OF- SUPPORT OF FOR- THE
01:12:13.696 --> 01:12:15.464
AUTHOR OF THE BILL. I KNOW SHE'S
01:12:15.531 --> 01:12:16.865
WORKING DILIGENTLY THIS IS AN
01:12:16.932 --> 01:12:18.133
IMPORTANT SUBJECT WE WANT TO
01:12:18.200 --> 01:12:20.736
MAKE SURE. THAT THE COSTS ARE
01:12:20.803 --> 01:12:22.171
FAIR AND EQUITABLE AND WE ALSO
01:12:22.237 --> 01:12:24.773
WANT TO MAKESURE THAT THOSE WHO
01:12:24.840 --> 01:12:26.442
ADMINISTER THESE PROGRAMS- OUR
01:12:26.508 --> 01:12:27.876
SUCCESSFUL IN THEIR EFFORTS TO
01:12:27.943 --> 01:12:29.545
HELP MAKE PATIENTS. BETTER AND
01:12:29.611 --> 01:12:32.481
SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
01:12:32.548 --> 01:12:33.716
VOTE ON SB NINE FIVE EIGHT.
01:12:33.782 --> 01:12:35.050
THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO ANY
01:12:35.117 --> 01:12:36.251
OTHER MEMBERS WISHING TO BE
01:12:36.318 --> 01:12:38.287
RECOGNIZED SEEING NONE SENATOR
01:12:38.353 --> 01:12:39.521
LIMÓN YOU MAY CLOSE I
01:12:39.588 --> 01:12:40.889
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
01:12:40.956 --> 01:12:42.891
THANK YOU CENTER LA MON.
01:12:42.958 --> 01:12:44.793
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
01:12:44.860 --> 01:12:50.733
ALLEN I ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
01:12:50.799 --> 01:12:55.337
BATES NO BACKER I FOR JUST NO
01:12:55.404 --> 01:13:00.142
BRADFORD. I CABALLERO I
01:13:00.209 --> 01:13:04.980
PROTECTING AYE DALY NO DODD AYE
01:13:05.047 --> 01:13:09.451
TORONTO AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
01:13:09.518 --> 01:13:13.021
AYE GONZALEZ I GROW. NO
01:13:13.088 --> 01:13:19.528
HERTZBERG WESSEL. I FURTADO. I
01:13:19.595 --> 01:13:24.032
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
01:13:24.099 --> 01:13:29.471
LEYVA I LIMON AYE MCGUIRE AYE
01:13:29.538 --> 01:13:33.876
MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE
01:13:33.942 --> 01:13:39.348
NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE NO PAN AYE
01:13:39.414 --> 01:13:43.752
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO
01:13:43.819 --> 01:13:47.856
AYE SKINNER. I STERN HI I'M
01:13:47.923 --> 01:13:52.561
BURKE I BY CASKEY. I WIENER I
01:13:52.628 --> 01:13:56.298
WILK. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
01:13:56.365 --> 01:14:04.173
MEMBERS. HERTZBERG NIELSEN NO.
01:14:04.239 --> 01:14:06.241
IS THIRTY KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE
01:14:06.308 --> 01:14:08.310
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO
01:14:08.377 --> 01:14:10.045
FILE ITEM THIRTY EIGHT CENTER
01:14:10.112 --> 01:14:12.714
CONTAINS THE WILL OF THESE-
01:14:12.781 --> 01:14:13.882
PRESENTING SENATE BILL NINE NINE
01:14:13.949 --> 01:14:17.286
NINE. SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
01:14:17.352 --> 01:14:18.987
SENATE BILL NINE NINETY NINE BY
01:14:19.054 --> 01:14:20.689
SENATOR CORTEZ HE AN ACT
01:14:20.756 --> 01:14:21.390
RELATING TO HEALTH CARE
01:14:21.456 --> 01:14:24.159
COVERAGE. CERTEZA THANK YOU MR
01:14:24.226 --> 01:14:26.628
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES BUT TODAY I
01:14:26.695 --> 01:14:28.397
RISE TO PRESENT SENATE BILL NINE
01:14:28.463 --> 01:14:30.132
NINETY NINE. IT WILL ENSURE THAT
01:14:30.199 --> 01:14:31.500
CALIFORNIANS SUFFERING FROM
01:14:31.567 --> 01:14:33.001
MENTAL HEALTH CONDITIONS AND
01:14:33.068 --> 01:14:34.903
SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS ARE ABLE
01:14:34.970 --> 01:14:36.171
TO RECEIVE THE TREATMENT THEY
01:14:36.238 --> 01:14:38.106
NEED TO RECOVER SAFELY. TO
01:14:38.173 --> 01:14:39.374
ACHIEVE THIS BILL REQUIRES THAT
01:14:39.441 --> 01:14:41.844
MENTAL HEALTH AND SUBSTANCE USE
01:14:41.910 --> 01:14:44.446
UTILIZATION REVIEWS BE CONDUCTED
01:14:44.513 --> 01:14:46.114
BY HEALTH CARE PROVIDER WITH THE
01:14:46.181 --> 01:14:48.050
APPROPRIATE EDUCATION TRAINING
01:14:48.116 --> 01:14:49.985
AND EXPERIENCE. THANK YOU AND I
01:14:50.052 --> 01:14:51.987
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL MEMBERS
01:14:52.054 --> 01:14:54.623
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON
01:14:54.690 --> 01:14:57.292
SENATE BILL NINE NINETY NINE.
01:14:57.359 --> 01:14:58.260
SEEING NONE SECRETARY PLEASE
01:14:58.327 --> 01:15:02.731
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
01:15:02.798 --> 01:15:06.635
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
01:15:06.702 --> 01:15:12.674
NO BAKER. I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
01:15:12.741 --> 01:15:15.844
. I HAVE ITEM I FOR TESTING I
01:15:15.911 --> 01:15:22.751
DALY NO DODD. I TORONTO I EGGMAN
01:15:22.818 --> 01:15:28.624
I GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW. NO
01:15:28.690 --> 01:15:33.161
HERTZBERG WESSEL I HER DAUGHTER
01:15:33.228 --> 01:15:38.800
I JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
01:15:38.867 --> 01:15:43.705
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN. I MCGUIRE I
01:15:43.772 --> 01:15:48.010
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
01:15:48.076 --> 01:15:54.216
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED. NO PAN
01:15:54.283 --> 01:16:00.789
AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH I RUBIO. I
01:16:00.856 --> 01:16:04.893
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE I'M BURKE
01:16:04.960 --> 01:16:08.997
AYE WHY CASTING. I WIENER AYE
01:16:09.064 --> 01:16:13.869
WILK NO. IS THIRTY KNOWS NINE
01:16:13.936 --> 01:16:23.879
MAJOR PASSES. THANK YOU SENATOR
01:16:23.946 --> 01:16:26.581
JONES MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING TO
01:16:26.648 --> 01:16:27.749
FILE ITEM THIRTY NINE SENATOR
01:16:27.816 --> 01:16:29.718
UMBERG AND SECRETARY PLEASE READ
01:16:29.785 --> 01:16:32.521
SENATE BILL TEN FIFTY SIX BY
01:16:32.587 --> 01:16:34.323
SENATOR UMBERG AN ACT RELATING
01:16:34.389 --> 01:16:36.124
TO SOCIAL MEDIA. CENTER NUMBER.
01:16:36.191 --> 01:16:37.192
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
01:16:37.259 --> 01:16:38.493
COLLEAGUES I'M PROUD TO PRESENT
01:16:38.560 --> 01:16:40.929
S. B. TEN FIFTY SIX THE ONLINE
01:16:40.996 --> 01:16:43.231
VIOLENCE PREVENTION ACT. THIS IS
01:16:43.298 --> 01:16:44.633
A BILL THAT IS PRECISELY
01:16:44.700 --> 01:16:46.301
TAILORED TO DEAL WITH THE ISSUE
01:16:46.368 --> 01:16:48.937
WHEN INDIVIDUALS ARE TARGETED ON
01:16:49.004 --> 01:16:50.839
SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS WITH
01:16:50.906 --> 01:16:52.674
THREATS OR INCITEMENT TO
01:16:52.741 --> 01:16:54.710
IMMINENT VIOLENCE. IT DOESN'T
01:16:54.776 --> 01:16:56.311
REQUIRES SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS
01:16:56.378 --> 01:16:59.281
WITH USERS IN CALIFORNIA- OVER
01:16:59.348 --> 01:17:01.483
ONE MILLION TO HAVE A PORTAL
01:17:01.550 --> 01:17:03.852
WHERE YOU CAN REPORT- SUCH
01:17:03.919 --> 01:17:07.122
INCIDENTS SUCH THREATS FOR SUCH
01:17:07.189 --> 01:17:09.024
INCITEMENT TO IMMINENT VIOLENCE.
01:17:09.091 --> 01:17:12.260
AND IF THEY DON'T TAKE THAT DOWN
01:17:12.327 --> 01:17:14.963
THEN IT GIVES YOU- THE ABILITY
01:17:15.030 --> 01:17:18.233
TO SEEK AN INJUNCTION- AFTER
01:17:18.300 --> 01:17:20.502
FORTY EIGHT HOURS. IF THE SOCIAL
01:17:20.569 --> 01:17:23.238
MEDIA PLATFORM- IS ENJOINED AND
01:17:23.305 --> 01:17:26.708
FAILS TO TAKE DOWN THAT THREAT-
01:17:26.775 --> 01:17:28.543
THEN THEY CAN BE HELD IN
01:17:28.610 --> 01:17:31.079
CONTEMPT OF COURT WITH ALL THE-
01:17:31.146 --> 01:17:32.714
WITH THE ARRAY OF PENALTIES THAT
01:17:32.781 --> 01:17:34.583
ARE ACCESSIBLE TO COURT. IF ONE
01:17:34.649 --> 01:17:36.952
IS HELD IN CONTEMPT WE'VE
01:17:37.019 --> 01:17:39.621
DRAFTED THIS IN A WAY TO BE-
01:17:39.688 --> 01:17:42.457
COGNISANT OF SECTION- TO THIRTY
01:17:42.524 --> 01:17:45.627
OF THE- OF FEDERAL LAW- AND I
01:17:45.694 --> 01:17:47.362
BELIEVE IT IS CONSTITUTIONAL I
01:17:47.429 --> 01:17:49.898
BELIEVE THAT THIS IS THE RIGHT
01:17:49.965 --> 01:17:51.299
THING TO DO AND AYE URGENT AYE
01:17:51.366 --> 01:17:52.367
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER AMBERG
01:17:52.434 --> 01:17:54.302
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
01:17:54.369 --> 01:17:57.539
CENTER PAN. THE THANK YOU MADAM
01:17:57.606 --> 01:17:59.241
PRESIDENT CENTERS I TO RISE IN
01:17:59.307 --> 01:18:01.109
SUPPORT OF SB TEN FIFTY SIX NOT
01:18:01.176 --> 01:18:02.411
THANK MY GOOD FRIEND FROM SANTA
01:18:02.477 --> 01:18:04.046
ANA FOR BRING THIS FORWARD AND
01:18:04.112 --> 01:18:05.580
APPRECIATE HIS LEADERSHIP AS
01:18:05.647 --> 01:18:06.815
CHAIR OF OUR JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
01:18:06.882 --> 01:18:08.383
IN WHICH THEY HELD A HEARING
01:18:08.450 --> 01:18:10.152
VERY IMPORTANT HEARING ON.
01:18:10.218 --> 01:18:12.654
SOCIAL MEDIA AND AMPLIFICATION
01:18:12.721 --> 01:18:15.957
OF HATE AND EXTREMISM- THIS I
01:18:16.024 --> 01:18:18.760
MEAN WE CAN SEE CAN WE JUST LOOK
01:18:18.827 --> 01:18:19.428
AT RECENT EVENTS- WE THINK ABOUT
01:18:19.494 --> 01:18:22.464
WHAT HAPPENED AND- THE SHOOTING
01:18:22.531 --> 01:18:25.600
BUFFALO OF- TEN- THEN AFTER
01:18:25.667 --> 01:18:27.869
AMERICANS- WE THINK ABOUT OTHER
01:18:27.936 --> 01:18:30.472
INCIDENTS EL PASO- EVEN HERE IN
01:18:30.539 --> 01:18:32.107
THIS VERY CHAMBER I SHOULD
01:18:32.174 --> 01:18:34.576
MENTION THAT- BACK IN TWENTY
01:18:34.643 --> 01:18:35.744
NINETEEN AFTER I WAS ASSAULTED
01:18:35.811 --> 01:18:40.015
ON THE STREET- THAT. WAS LIVE
01:18:40.082 --> 01:18:42.417
STREAMED ON SOCIAL MEDIA AND THE
01:18:42.484 --> 01:18:44.386
SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY WHEN WE
01:18:44.453 --> 01:18:46.588
NOTIFIED THEM OF THAT SAID THAT
01:18:46.655 --> 01:18:47.355
. IT WOULD TAKE IT DOWN HIS
01:18:47.422 --> 01:18:49.357
WASN'T VIOLENT ENOUGH EVEN THOSE
01:18:49.424 --> 01:18:50.926
ACTUALLY PHYSICALLY ASSAULTED.
01:18:50.992 --> 01:18:52.928
IN HE ENTERED WITH AND I THINK
01:18:52.994 --> 01:18:55.097
WE'VE ALL SEEN WITH CERTAIN
01:18:55.163 --> 01:18:57.265
ISSUES- SOME OF THE HEAT THAT'S
01:18:57.332 --> 01:18:59.768
BEEN DIRECTED- AT OUR STAFF
01:18:59.835 --> 01:19:04.739
OURSELVES- IS AS WELL NOW. IT'S
01:19:04.806 --> 01:19:06.708
IMPORTANT THAT PEOPLE BE ABLE TO
01:19:06.775 --> 01:19:09.644
EXPRESS THEIR VIEWS. THAT'S FINE
01:19:09.711 --> 01:19:11.880
BUT WHEN PEOPLE ARE THREATENING
01:19:11.947 --> 01:19:16.651
VIOLENCE- THAT IS NO LONGER IN
01:19:16.718 --> 01:19:20.322
EXPRESSION OF USE THAT IS NOW
01:19:20.388 --> 01:19:21.990
INTIMIDATION AND THREATS AND
01:19:22.057 --> 01:19:24.092
UNFORTUNATELY WHILE SOCIAL MEDIA
01:19:24.159 --> 01:19:25.427
THE SOCIAL SOCIAL MEDIA
01:19:25.494 --> 01:19:27.162
COMPANIES ESSENTIALLY GIVE
01:19:27.229 --> 01:19:28.430
PEOPLE WHO HAVE THOSE THOUGHTS
01:19:28.497 --> 01:19:31.566
THE VOICE BEEN THERE BUT GIVE
01:19:31.633 --> 01:19:34.202
THEM A AND- A MEGAPHONE. AND A
01:19:34.269 --> 01:19:37.072
FORTUNE HAS UNDERMINED I THINK
01:19:37.139 --> 01:19:39.441
OUR OUR DISCOURSE BECAUSE AS WE
01:19:39.508 --> 01:19:41.176
TALK ABOUT THE FREE MARKET OF
01:19:41.243 --> 01:19:42.611
IDEAS IT'S HARD TO EXPRESS IDEAS
01:19:42.677 --> 01:19:44.379
WHEN YOUR LIFE'S UNDER THREAT
01:19:44.446 --> 01:19:45.981
BUT SOMEONE ISN'T GOING TO GET
01:19:46.047 --> 01:19:47.983
YOU ON YOUR IDEA INSTEAD THEY
01:19:48.049 --> 01:19:49.050
TRY TO THREATEN YOUR LIFE FOR
01:19:49.117 --> 01:19:51.219
THAT YOUR FAMILY OR OTHER PEOPLE
01:19:51.286 --> 01:19:52.921
ARE CLOSE TO YOU. SO I THINK
01:19:52.988 --> 01:19:55.123
THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT STEP I
01:19:55.190 --> 01:19:56.591
THINK THE PRIME MORE STEPS NEED
01:19:56.658 --> 01:19:58.527
TO BE TAKEN BY DO APPRECIATE THE
01:19:58.593 --> 01:20:01.129
LEADERSHIP OF MCCARTY FROM SANTA
01:20:01.196 --> 01:20:03.632
ANA AND SAYING LOOK WE NEED TO
01:20:03.698 --> 01:20:05.500
TAKE THAT FIRST STEP- WE NEED
01:20:05.567 --> 01:20:08.103
TO. BE SURE PEOPLE FEEL
01:20:08.170 --> 01:20:09.404
COMFORTABLE AND SAFE IN FACT HOW
01:20:09.471 --> 01:20:11.206
CAN YOU EXPRESS YOUR FIRST
01:20:11.273 --> 01:20:13.375
AMENDMENT USE IF YOU HAVE TO
01:20:13.441 --> 01:20:14.409
WORRY ABOUT. THREATS TO YOUR
01:20:14.476 --> 01:20:16.378
LFE. AND SO IT'S IMPORTANT
01:20:16.444 --> 01:20:19.447
SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANIES- TO
01:20:19.514 --> 01:20:21.883
PREVENT SUPPRESSION OF USE. ACT
01:20:21.950 --> 01:20:24.586
ON THREATS IMMINENT THREATS OF
01:20:24.653 --> 01:20:27.189
VIOLENCE AND HATE AND SO I
01:20:27.255 --> 01:20:30.525
APPRECIATE THIS- BILL- TO TAKE
01:20:30.592 --> 01:20:32.460
SOME OF THESE FIRST STEPS-
01:20:32.527 --> 01:20:34.262
CERTAINLY- WE NEED CONGRESS TO
01:20:34.329 --> 01:20:35.363
ACT AS WELL BUT CERTAINLY
01:20:35.430 --> 01:20:36.831
CALIFORNIA SHOULD CONTINUE LEAD
01:20:36.898 --> 01:20:39.201
AND DOES A HOME OF MANY OF OUR
01:20:39.267 --> 01:20:40.869
TECHNOLOGY COMPANIES- HOPEFULLY
01:20:40.936 --> 01:20:43.205
THEY CAN HELP STEP UP AND- LET'S
01:20:43.271 --> 01:20:45.240
ESTABLISH A STANDARD WHERE.
01:20:45.307 --> 01:20:47.709
EVERYONE CAN ENGAGED ONLINE WITH
01:20:47.776 --> 01:20:49.044
AND EXPRESS THEIR VIEWS WITHOUT
01:20:49.110 --> 01:20:52.847
FEAR OF PERSONAL ATTACK AND-
01:20:52.914 --> 01:20:55.217
INTERESTS THEIR LIVES I THANK
01:20:55.283 --> 01:20:56.952
YOU AS QUICKLY AS WHEN I WROTE.
01:20:57.018 --> 01:21:00.288
THANK YOU CENTER PANTS UNDER
01:21:00.355 --> 01:21:01.056
NEWMAN. YEAH I'D WAS NOT
01:21:01.122 --> 01:21:02.657
PLANNING ON SPEAKING ABOUT MY
01:21:02.724 --> 01:21:04.626
COLLEAGUES SEGMENT A MOVIE SO I
01:21:04.693 --> 01:21:06.361
TO HAVE BEEN THE SUBJECT OF
01:21:06.428 --> 01:21:07.762
VIOLENT THREATS AND I'LL TELL
01:21:07.829 --> 01:21:10.599
YOU. ONE WHICH WAS TO TAKE THE
01:21:10.665 --> 01:21:11.099
DISTURBING WHICH I THINK
01:21:11.166 --> 01:21:13.001
TESTIFIES TO THE VALUE THIS
01:21:13.068 --> 01:21:14.603
BILL. IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN. TO
01:21:14.669 --> 01:21:16.037
SOMEBODY ON SOCIAL MEDIA POSTED
01:21:16.104 --> 01:21:18.673
A PICTURE OF MY DAUGHTER- AND
01:21:18.740 --> 01:21:19.374
NOTED HOW MUCH FUN THEY WERE
01:21:19.441 --> 01:21:21.810
GOING TO HAVE. WITH HER A DAY
01:21:21.876 --> 01:21:23.912
AFTER AND I WAS NOT THE ONE WHO
01:21:23.979 --> 01:21:25.614
SOUGHT IT ESPECIALLY MY WIFE- SO
01:21:25.680 --> 01:21:29.551
I CALLED- WE LOOKED ON THE
01:21:29.618 --> 01:21:31.353
SOCIAL MEDIA SITE. THERE WAS NO
01:21:31.419 --> 01:21:33.822
OBVIOUS WAY TO PROPERLY APPRISED
01:21:33.888 --> 01:21:36.324
AMBER BORN MAKE A COMPLAINT- SO
01:21:36.391 --> 01:21:37.759
I CALLED THE LOBBYIST FOR THE
01:21:37.826 --> 01:21:40.262
SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY. WHO SAID
01:21:40.328 --> 01:21:41.696
OH THAT'S DISTURBING- IN THE
01:21:41.763 --> 01:21:43.365
COLUMBIA IT SAID LOOK WE'LL LOOK
01:21:43.431 --> 01:21:43.932
INTO IT BECAUSE WE HAVE AN
01:21:43.999 --> 01:21:46.468
EXCHANGE HAD GOOD NEWS. CENTER
01:21:46.534 --> 01:21:47.068
NEWMAN- THE NEXT TIME THIS
01:21:47.135 --> 01:21:49.804
GENTLEMAN SIGNS ON HE'LL GET A
01:21:49.871 --> 01:21:52.440
MESSAGE. URGING HIM TO BE MORE
01:21:52.507 --> 01:21:54.643
CIVIL- AND CLEARLY THAT'S NOT
01:21:54.709 --> 01:21:56.945
ENOUGH. AND IN ANYBODY WHO'S
01:21:57.012 --> 01:21:59.714
BEEN. IN THIS SITUATION SADLY
01:21:59.781 --> 01:22:01.583
IT'S MORE MORE COMMON. THERE
01:22:01.650 --> 01:22:04.052
SHOULD BE AN EASY WAY THERE
01:22:04.119 --> 01:22:05.820
SHOULD BE A RESPONSIBILITY.
01:22:05.887 --> 01:22:07.789
AMONG THESE COMPANIES TO TAKE
01:22:07.856 --> 01:22:10.158
IMMEDIATE AND EFFECTIVE ACTION.
01:22:10.225 --> 01:22:11.693
IN THESE CASES RIGHT I URGE
01:22:11.760 --> 01:22:13.728
SUPPORT THIS BILL THANK YOU
01:22:13.795 --> 01:22:14.663
THANK YOU CENTER NEWMAN CENTER
01:22:14.729 --> 01:22:17.599
GROVE. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
01:22:17.666 --> 01:22:20.101
A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR.
01:22:20.168 --> 01:22:22.103
SENATOR NUMBER WOULD YOU TAKE A
01:22:22.170 --> 01:22:23.104
QUESTION I WOULD LOVE TO TAKE A
01:22:23.171 --> 01:22:25.273
QUESTION PLEASE THE HAULING FROM
01:22:25.340 --> 01:22:27.642
BAKERSFIELD THANK YOU SIR AND
01:22:27.709 --> 01:22:30.011
WHO DETERMINES ARM WHAT DOES THE
01:22:30.078 --> 01:22:31.446
BILL SAY ABOUT REPEATING EITHER
01:22:31.513 --> 01:22:33.181
COMMITTEE OR IS THERE GOING TO
01:22:33.248 --> 01:22:36.584
BE WHO DETERMINES. BECAUSE I TO
01:22:36.651 --> 01:22:37.786
LIKE MY COLLEAGUE WHO JUST SPOKE
01:22:37.852 --> 01:22:39.721
HAVE A- HE'S JUST CRAZY I HAVE A
01:22:39.788 --> 01:22:42.223
CRAZY SO- THAT FOLLOWS ME AND
01:22:42.290 --> 01:22:44.292
THAT YOU KNOW THE POLICE HAVE TO
01:22:44.359 --> 01:22:46.094
BE ENGAGED IT'S LIKE. SO I TO
01:22:46.161 --> 01:22:48.496
GET THAT AND I THINK WE ALL DO
01:22:48.563 --> 01:22:50.098
SENATOR PAN- SKEWS ME I CALLING
01:22:50.165 --> 01:22:51.433
FROM TAMPA SACRAMENTO WAS
01:22:51.499 --> 01:22:53.401
OBVIOUSLY HIT WAS WALKING ON THE
01:22:53.468 --> 01:22:55.337
STREET- IN THE POST ON SOCIAL
01:22:55.403 --> 01:22:57.038
MEDIA SO I TOOK AND I'M TRYING
01:22:57.105 --> 01:22:59.507
TO FIND A WAY. TO SUPPORT EVEN
01:22:59.574 --> 01:23:01.376
THOSE IN OPPOSITION EVERY YOU
01:23:01.443 --> 01:23:03.044
KNOW REQUEST ON THE BILL BUT I
01:23:03.111 --> 01:23:04.379
WANT TO KNOW WHO MAKES THE
01:23:04.446 --> 01:23:05.914
DETERMINATION. OF WHAT IS
01:23:05.980 --> 01:23:09.284
CONSIDERED A VIOLENT OR A THREAT
01:23:09.351 --> 01:23:11.353
VERSUS NOT. SO THE FIRST TIME
01:23:11.419 --> 01:23:13.355
I'M SORRY FOR YOUR CRAZY THAT
01:23:13.421 --> 01:23:15.757
SOMEONE. A NUMBER TWO IS THAT.
01:23:15.824 --> 01:23:17.792
UP IS A TWO STEP PROCESS SO FOR
01:23:17.859 --> 01:23:20.261
EXAMPLE- GIVEN THE EXAMPLE THAT
01:23:20.328 --> 01:23:22.731
YOU JUST RAISED IS THAT. YOU
01:23:22.797 --> 01:23:24.299
TELL THE SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY
01:23:24.366 --> 01:23:26.468
HEY. HERE'S WHAT'S BEEN POSTED I
01:23:26.534 --> 01:23:28.770
VIEW THIS AS A THREAT. OF
01:23:28.837 --> 01:23:34.609
VIOLENCE. CAN EITHER LEAVE IT UP
01:23:34.676 --> 01:23:36.211
OR THEY CAN TAKE IT DOWN IF THEY
01:23:36.277 --> 01:23:38.179
LEAVE IT UP. YOU CAN GO TO COURT
01:23:38.246 --> 01:23:40.014
AND THEN THE COURT MAKES A
01:23:40.081 --> 01:23:41.282
DECISION AS TO WHETHER OR NOT.
01:23:41.349 --> 01:23:45.053
THIS IS OUTSIDE OF THE- AMBIT OF
01:23:45.120 --> 01:23:46.454
THE FIRST AMENDMENT IF IT IS
01:23:46.521 --> 01:23:48.390
OUTSIDE THE AMBIT OF THE FIRST
01:23:48.456 --> 01:23:49.157
AMENDMENT IN OTHER WORDS
01:23:49.224 --> 01:23:51.159
THEY'RE-ALL SPEECH IT IS NOT
01:23:51.226 --> 01:23:52.961
WITHIN THE FIRST AMENDMENT. SO
01:23:53.027 --> 01:23:54.462
FOR EXAMPLE SOMEONE IS
01:23:54.529 --> 01:23:55.797
ADVOCATING THAT A VIOLENT ACT
01:23:55.864 --> 01:23:57.065
PERPETRATED UPON YOU OR YOUR
01:23:57.132 --> 01:23:58.867
FAMILY. THE COURT CAN THEN IN
01:23:58.933 --> 01:24:01.069
JOINED. THE SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANY
01:24:01.136 --> 01:24:03.671
SAYING TAKE IT DOWN IF THEY SAY
01:24:03.738 --> 01:24:05.540
NO WE'RE NOT TAKING IT DOWN.
01:24:05.607 --> 01:24:07.075
THEN THERE IN CONTEMPT OF COURT
01:24:07.142 --> 01:24:08.943
CAN YOU GO BACK AND YOU ASK THE
01:24:09.010 --> 01:24:10.578
COURT TO FIND HIM IN CONTEMPT.
01:24:10.645 --> 01:24:12.113
IN ORDER THEM TO YOU KNOW
01:24:12.180 --> 01:24:14.916
THERE'S AN ARRAY OF SANCTIONS UP
01:24:14.983 --> 01:24:16.151
TO AND INCLUDING JAIL. OKAY
01:24:16.217 --> 01:24:17.752
THANK YOU FOR THAT SO BASICALLY
01:24:17.819 --> 01:24:19.287
IT'S NOT A GROUP IT'S- YOU CAN
01:24:19.354 --> 01:24:20.955
ACT JUST TO CONFIRM YOU CAN
01:24:21.022 --> 01:24:22.090
APPLY TO THE SOCIAL MEDIA
01:24:22.157 --> 01:24:23.591
COMPANY THERE'S BEEN A THREAT
01:24:23.658 --> 01:24:24.192
AGAINST MY FAMILY MY
01:24:24.259 --> 01:24:25.126
GRANDCHILDREN. IS A CREDIBLE
01:24:25.193 --> 01:24:26.861
THREAT HE SHOWS UP EVERY DAY THE
01:24:26.928 --> 01:24:28.363
POLICE HAVE BEEN INFORMED
01:24:28.430 --> 01:24:29.764
WHATEVER THE CASE MAY BE. AND
01:24:29.831 --> 01:24:31.232
THEN IF THEY REFUSED TO TAKE IT
01:24:31.299 --> 01:24:33.067
DOWN REGARDLESS OF WHAT SOCIAL
01:24:33.134 --> 01:24:35.470
MEDIA WE CAN GO TO COURT. AND
01:24:35.537 --> 01:24:36.004
THE JUDGE WILL MAKE THAT
01:24:36.070 --> 01:24:36.604
DECISION THAT'S CORRECT OKAY
01:24:36.671 --> 01:24:38.540
THANK YOU SIR FOR ANSWERING
01:24:38.606 --> 01:24:42.210
SERVICE. CENTER EGGMAN. LET ME
01:24:42.277 --> 01:24:44.078
HAS ALSO ASK A QUESTION THE
01:24:44.145 --> 01:24:47.248
NUMBER WE TO QUESTION- OKAY
01:24:47.315 --> 01:24:49.651
PLEASE PROCEED BUT THANK YOU- I
01:24:49.717 --> 01:24:50.952
DOES THE JUDICIARY JST IN
01:24:51.019 --> 01:24:52.854
READING OVER THIS EVERYONE GIVEN
01:24:52.921 --> 01:24:57.392
EXAMPLES OF BEING ATTACKED AND
01:24:57.459 --> 01:24:58.526
PEOPLE SUFFERING FROM MENTAL
01:24:58.593 --> 01:25:00.728
HEALTH ISSUES WOULD BE A NICE
01:25:00.795 --> 01:25:02.997
WAY TO SAY THAT- AND OTHERS AND
01:25:03.064 --> 01:25:04.499
JUST OUT OF MEANNESS BUT DOES
01:25:04.566 --> 01:25:06.501
THIS JUST APPLY TO ELECTED.
01:25:06.568 --> 01:25:07.535
OFFICIALS OR RESIST APPLY FOR
01:25:07.602 --> 01:25:09.070
EVERYBODY IT WOULD PLAY TO
01:25:09.137 --> 01:25:11.139
ANYONE OKAY THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:25:11.206 --> 01:25:13.007
BECAUSE THEN I GUESS MY POINT MY
01:25:13.074 --> 01:25:14.042
THE QUESTION I WANT THE POINT I
01:25:14.108 --> 01:25:16.711
WANT TO MAKE IT IS NOT JUST
01:25:16.778 --> 01:25:17.946
ABOUT US. RIGHT ONE OF THE
01:25:18.012 --> 01:25:19.347
EPIDEMICS WE HAVE RIGHT NOW IS
01:25:19.414 --> 01:25:20.882
SUICIDE AMONGST KIDS. I ONE OF
01:25:20.949 --> 01:25:22.016
THE REASONS KIDS ARE COMMITTING
01:25:22.083 --> 01:25:23.618
SUICIDE IS BECAUSE THE ONLINE
01:25:23.685 --> 01:25:25.186
HARASSMENT AND BULLYING AND
01:25:25.253 --> 01:25:27.021
THREATS AND SWARMING THAT
01:25:27.088 --> 01:25:29.257
HAPPENS- AND THINK ABOUT AS HARD
01:25:29.324 --> 01:25:31.059
AS US FOR US TO SUSTAIN THESE
01:25:31.125 --> 01:25:33.394
THINGS AND I DON'T I HAVE BEEN
01:25:33.461 --> 01:25:35.196
TO AND I DON'T THINK WE SHOULD
01:25:35.263 --> 01:25:36.631
HAVE TO. PUT UP WITH IT I
01:25:36.698 --> 01:25:38.266
CERTAINLY BELIEVE IN FREE SPEECH
01:25:38.333 --> 01:25:39.100
SPEECH AND I. YOU KNOW I HAVE
01:25:39.167 --> 01:25:40.235
CERTAIN UNITED STATES MILITARY
01:25:40.301 --> 01:25:42.237
AND TAKE AN OATH TO DEFEND THE
01:25:42.303 --> 01:25:44.038
CONSTITUTION BUT THERE IS A LINE
01:25:44.105 --> 01:25:45.306
THAT IS HIS CROSSING WE HAVE
01:25:45.373 --> 01:25:47.041
CROSSED THAT LINE WE HAVE BECOME
01:25:47.108 --> 01:25:50.311
UNMOORED WHERE. UNACCEPTABLE
01:25:50.378 --> 01:25:52.647
VIOLENCE- BE. IS TAUGHT. IT IS
01:25:52.714 --> 01:25:54.249
UNACCEPTABLE. AND I ENCOURAGE IN
01:25:54.315 --> 01:25:56.584
THE IN FOR THE FOR OUR CHILDREN
01:25:56.651 --> 01:25:58.720
AND FOR NOBODY ELSE. A CHRISTIAN
01:25:58.786 --> 01:26:00.688
AYE VOTE ON THIS BILL. THANK YOU
01:26:00.755 --> 01:26:03.224
CENTER EGGMAN CENTER MELINDA'S.
01:26:03.291 --> 01:26:04.893
I THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT- I
01:26:04.959 --> 01:26:07.161
HAVE A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR IF
01:26:07.228 --> 01:26:08.329
I MAY TURN OVER WE TAKE A
01:26:08.396 --> 01:26:09.797
QUESTION- YES PLEASE PROCEED
01:26:09.864 --> 01:26:11.966
THANK YOU- I FIRST OF ALL LET ME
01:26:12.033 --> 01:26:13.167
SAY THAT I COMPLETELY
01:26:13.234 --> 01:26:14.869
WHOLEHEARTEDLY AGREE WITH THE
01:26:14.936 --> 01:26:16.404
MEMBER FROM STOCKTON IN HER
01:26:16.471 --> 01:26:19.240
COMMENTS- MY QUESTION- COMES
01:26:19.307 --> 01:26:21.943
INTO. A YOU KNOW CALIFORNIA
01:26:22.010 --> 01:26:24.746
CAN'T REGULATE WHAT SOCIAL MEDIA
01:26:24.812 --> 01:26:26.848
COMPANIES DO NECESSARY THEY THEY
01:26:26.915 --> 01:26:28.149
ARE REGULATED UNDER FEDERAL
01:26:28.216 --> 01:26:30.385
AUTHORITY SO HOW IS THIS GOING
01:26:30.451 --> 01:26:33.488
TO WORK SHOULD IT GO TO COURT I
01:26:33.555 --> 01:26:35.523
MEAN CAN YOU SPEAK TO THAT
01:26:35.590 --> 01:26:37.759
PLEASE BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE THE
01:26:37.825 --> 01:26:39.360
AUTHORITY OVER THESE. PLATFORMS
01:26:39.427 --> 01:26:42.664
RIGHT NOW. SO FOR EXAMPLE- IF
01:26:42.730 --> 01:26:46.334
SOMEONE. POST A THREAT ON SOCIAL
01:26:46.401 --> 01:26:48.069
MEDIA YOU SAY THE SOCIAL MEDIA
01:26:48.136 --> 01:26:50.371
COMPANY YOU MUST TAKE IT DOWN-
01:26:50.438 --> 01:26:52.240
THAT YOU'RE RIGHT WE ONLY HAVE
01:26:52.307 --> 01:26:53.107
JURISDICTION CALIFORNIA COURTS
01:26:53.174 --> 01:26:54.309
ONLY A JURISDICTION OVER
01:26:54.375 --> 01:26:56.177
CALIFORNIA SO I SUPPOSE IF THEY
01:26:56.244 --> 01:26:56.978
CAN TAKE IT DOWN JUST IN
01:26:57.045 --> 01:26:58.313
CALIFORNIA THEY MAY BE IN
01:26:58.379 --> 01:26:59.847
COMPLIANCE WITH ASSUMING THAT
01:26:59.914 --> 01:27:02.150
THEY CAN'T. AND THEY REFUSE TO
01:27:02.216 --> 01:27:04.152
TAKE IT DOWN THEN THE COURT CAN
01:27:04.218 --> 01:27:05.119
HOLD THEM IN CONTEMPT OF THE
01:27:05.186 --> 01:27:06.921
DOING BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA
01:27:06.988 --> 01:27:08.556
THEN AT THAT POINT IN TIME IN
01:27:08.623 --> 01:27:09.657
THEIR SUFFICIENT MINIMUM
01:27:09.724 --> 01:27:11.292
CONTACTS TO BE ABLE TO EXERCISE
01:27:11.359 --> 01:27:12.894
PERSONAL JURISDICTION AS FOR ALL
01:27:12.961 --> 01:27:15.897
YOU LAWYERS HERE- THEN THEN THEY
01:27:15.964 --> 01:27:17.332
WOULD BE SUBJECT TO A CONTEMPT
01:27:17.398 --> 01:27:20.068
ORDER NOW UP IS SOMEONE WHO
01:27:20.134 --> 01:27:22.170
REFUSES TO TAKE IT DOWN GOING TO
01:27:22.236 --> 01:27:23.972
POSE THE- DEFENSE OF FEDERAL
01:27:24.038 --> 01:27:26.007
PREEMPTION. I'M GUESSING THAT
01:27:26.074 --> 01:27:27.875
THEY WOULD- IS IT OUR
01:27:27.942 --> 01:27:29.510
RESPONSIBILITY TO DO WHAT WE CAN
01:27:29.577 --> 01:27:31.579
TO PROTECT CALIFORNIANS YES I
01:27:31.646 --> 01:27:33.781
THINK IT IS AND SO THEREFORE I
01:27:33.848 --> 01:27:35.049
WOULD URGE THAT WE VOTE THIS
01:27:35.116 --> 01:27:38.386
BILL- I THINK IT IT WOULD PASS
01:27:38.453 --> 01:27:39.253
CONSTITUTIONAL MUSTER BUT I
01:27:39.320 --> 01:27:40.588
UNDERSTAND THAT SOME MAY
01:27:40.655 --> 01:27:42.256
DISAGREE WITH THAT BUT I THINK
01:27:42.323 --> 01:27:44.959
THAT IT'S TIME FOR US TO. AT A
01:27:45.026 --> 01:27:47.762
MINIMUM TEST THAT. OKAY THANK
01:27:47.829 --> 01:27:48.796
YOU SO MUCH FOR THE
01:27:48.863 --> 01:27:50.698
CLARIFICATION I'M ON MY OWN TIME
01:27:50.765 --> 01:27:53.434
I WILL JUST SAY THAT- RIGHT. I'M
01:27:53.501 --> 01:27:55.870
NOT COMPLETELY CONVINCED THAT
01:27:55.937 --> 01:27:57.538
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE COULD
01:27:57.605 --> 01:27:59.641
ENFORCE AND PULL OFF THOUGH I
01:27:59.707 --> 01:28:00.908
DON'T DISAGREE WITH THE FACT
01:28:00.975 --> 01:28:02.243
THAT. SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE DONE
01:28:02.310 --> 01:28:03.978
MEAN PEOPLE ARE NOT OUT THERE
01:28:04.045 --> 01:28:08.016
THE THINGS THAT THEY SAY. IT'S A
01:28:08.082 --> 01:28:09.517
- THE THINGS THAT THEY WOULD NOT
01:28:09.584 --> 01:28:11.819
SAY TO SOMEONE'S FACE. IN ANY
01:28:11.886 --> 01:28:13.087
CIRCUMSTANCE HE WOULDN'T HAVE
01:28:13.154 --> 01:28:14.455
THE COURAGE TO SAY IT TO THEIR
01:28:14.522 --> 01:28:16.090
FACE BUT THEY WILL CERTAINLY BE
01:28:16.157 --> 01:28:18.292
THE KEYBOARD WARRIOR AND SAY
01:28:18.359 --> 01:28:19.961
ANYTHING THEY CHOOSE IN ANY
01:28:20.028 --> 01:28:20.928
MANNER WHICH THEY CHOOSE NO
01:28:20.995 --> 01:28:22.764
MATTER WHO IT HURTS. AND THAT
01:28:22.830 --> 01:28:26.034
INCLUDES CHILDREN SPECIFICALLY-
01:28:26.100 --> 01:28:28.670
I REALLY WANT TO BELIEVE THAT
01:28:28.736 --> 01:28:30.772
THIS COULD WORK I AM JUST NOT.
01:28:30.838 --> 01:28:32.807
I'M NOT CONVINCED THAT THE
01:28:32.874 --> 01:28:34.008
COURTS WOULDN'T SAY YOU
01:28:34.075 --> 01:28:35.777
CALIFORNIA- OVERSTEPPING YOUR
01:28:35.843 --> 01:28:37.478
BOUNDS THOUGH I COMMEND YOUR
01:28:37.545 --> 01:28:38.646
EFFORTS CERTAINLY IN THE
01:28:38.713 --> 01:28:41.082
MOTIVATION BEHIND IT- THANK YOU
01:28:41.149 --> 01:28:42.517
MADAM PRESIDENT. THANK YOU
01:28:42.583 --> 01:28:44.852
CENTER MELINDA'S MEMBERS FURTHER
01:28:44.919 --> 01:28:47.021
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
01:28:47.088 --> 01:28:48.389
HEARING NONE SIR I'M BURKE YOU
01:28:48.456 --> 01:28:50.925
MAY CLOSE I I'VE LITTLE THAT THE
01:28:50.992 --> 01:28:53.094
ELOQUENT DOT COM COMMENTS BY MY
01:28:53.161 --> 01:28:54.996
COLLEAGUES BUT JUST TO REFER TO
01:28:55.063 --> 01:28:56.664
RESPOND TO LAST COMMENT. IS
01:28:56.731 --> 01:28:59.267
THAT- WITH A CHOICE HERE WE CAN
01:28:59.333 --> 01:29:01.369
DO NOTHING. AND WE CAN SAY YOU
01:29:01.436 --> 01:29:03.438
KNOW WHAT I'M SORRY FEDERAL LAW
01:29:03.504 --> 01:29:06.574
MAY MAY PREEMPT STATE LAW A
01:29:06.641 --> 01:29:09.777
COURT MAY DECIDE THAT WE HAVE
01:29:09.844 --> 01:29:11.045
EXCEEDED OUR CONSTITUTIONAL
01:29:11.112 --> 01:29:13.281
AUTHORITY. I DON'T THINK SO AND
01:29:13.347 --> 01:29:16.284
I THINK AT A MINIMUM WE SHOULD
01:29:16.350 --> 01:29:17.585
TEST THAT ORIGINAL VOTE. THANK
01:29:17.652 --> 01:29:19.187
YOU CENTER MA'AM SECRETARY
01:29:19.253 --> 01:29:22.657
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
01:29:22.724 --> 01:29:27.462
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
01:29:27.528 --> 01:29:32.900
BAKER I FOR JUST AYE BRADFORD. I
01:29:32.967 --> 01:29:36.270
CABALLERO I FOR THIRTY FIVE
01:29:36.337 --> 01:29:43.878
DOLLARS. DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN
01:29:43.945 --> 01:29:50.318
. I GLAZER. I GONZALEZ I GROW.
01:29:50.384 --> 01:29:55.289
HERTZBERG HUESO AYE HURTADO AYE
01:29:55.356 --> 01:30:01.462
JONES. KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
01:30:01.529 --> 01:30:05.900
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE I
01:30:05.967 --> 01:30:11.706
MELENDEZ. MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE
01:30:11.773 --> 01:30:18.279
NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE. PAN AYE
01:30:18.346 --> 01:30:22.416
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO I
01:30:22.483 --> 01:30:28.623
SKINNER. I STERN HI I'M BURKE I
01:30:28.689 --> 01:30:33.828
LIKE AYE WIENER. I WILK HI
01:30:33.895 --> 01:30:36.030
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
01:30:36.097 --> 01:30:44.272
BATES I. DALLY. GROVE I
01:30:44.338 --> 01:30:48.609
HERTZBERG JONES. MELENDEZ
01:30:48.676 --> 01:30:53.748
NIELSEN A CHOI BOGUE. I THIRTY
01:30:53.815 --> 01:30:54.782
FOUR NEWS ZERO THE MEASURE
01:30:54.849 --> 01:30:56.350
PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA MOVE
01:30:56.417 --> 01:30:58.986
TO FILE ITEM ONE ZERO THREE
01:30:59.053 --> 01:31:01.389
SENATOR LA MON. MADAM SECRETARY
01:31:01.455 --> 01:31:04.859
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE
01:31:04.926 --> 01:31:06.060
NINETY FIVE BY SENATOR LIMÓN AN
01:31:06.127 --> 01:31:08.563
ACT RELATING TO OIL AND GAS SAN
01:31:08.629 --> 01:31:14.969
RAMON. THANK YOU MEMBERS. ONE I
01:31:15.036 --> 01:31:18.372
COULD. THANK YOU I PRESIDENT
01:31:18.439 --> 01:31:20.842
COLLEAGUES SB TWELVE NINETY FIVE
01:31:20.908 --> 01:31:22.076
ADDRESSESTHE SERIOUS PROBLEM OF
01:31:22.143 --> 01:31:23.911
DESERTED WELLS IN CALIFORNIA
01:31:23.978 --> 01:31:25.146
DESERTED WELLS- FINANCIAL
01:31:25.213 --> 01:31:27.582
LIABILITY TO THE STATE AND
01:31:27.648 --> 01:31:28.583
DANGEROUS TO THE SURROUNDING
01:31:28.649 --> 01:31:30.818
ENVIRONMENT AND RESIDENTS. THE
01:31:30.885 --> 01:31:32.420
WELLS CAN LEAD TO GRADING AIR
01:31:32.486 --> 01:31:35.089
QUALITY IN CONTAMINATED AQUIFERS
01:31:35.156 --> 01:31:35.590
HARMING THE SURROUNDING
01:31:35.656 --> 01:31:38.426
COMMUNITY. JUST LAST WEEK THERE
01:31:38.492 --> 01:31:41.929
WAS NEWS OF TWO OF CALIFORNIA'S
01:31:41.996 --> 01:31:43.030
THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND IDLE WELLS
01:31:43.097 --> 01:31:44.899
LEAKING LARGE AMOUNTS OF METHANE
01:31:44.966 --> 01:31:46.934
INTO A COMMUNITY IN BAKERSFIELD
01:31:47.001 --> 01:31:48.035
ONE WELL WAS LEAKING AT A
01:31:48.102 --> 01:31:50.304
MINIMUM OF FIFTY THOUSAND PARTS
01:31:50.371 --> 01:31:52.640
PER MILLION. THE MAXIMUM LEVEL
01:31:52.707 --> 01:31:55.276
THE DEVICE COULD RECORD. THIS
01:31:55.343 --> 01:31:57.044
BILL ADDRESSES THE MASSIVE NEED
01:31:57.111 --> 01:31:58.212
FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDING FOR
01:31:58.279 --> 01:31:59.547
PLUGGING AND ABANDONING THESE
01:31:59.614 --> 01:32:01.415
ORPHAN WELLS AND ENSURING
01:32:01.482 --> 01:32:04.018
INDUSTRY ALSO HAS A PART TO PLAY
01:32:04.085 --> 01:32:05.987
IN FUNDING FOR THE PLUGIN PLUGIN
01:32:06.053 --> 01:32:09.023
OF ABANDONING THESE WELLS. SB
01:32:09.090 --> 01:32:10.057
TWELVE NINETY FIVE WOULD REQUIRE
01:32:10.124 --> 01:32:11.525
THAT THE MONEY THAT WHEN MONEY
01:32:11.592 --> 01:32:13.761
IS ALLOCATED THROUGH THE GENERAL
01:32:13.828 --> 01:32:15.763
FUND AND ONLY THROUGH THE
01:32:15.830 --> 01:32:16.564
GENERAL FUND. TO PAY FOR
01:32:16.631 --> 01:32:18.299
PLUGGING AND ABANDONING CAL JAM
01:32:18.366 --> 01:32:20.401
CAN COLLECT AND SPEND AN
01:32:20.468 --> 01:32:21.702
ADDITIONAL AMOUNT FROM INDUSTRY
01:32:21.769 --> 01:32:23.371
. IN THE LAST TWO YEARS THE OIL
01:32:23.437 --> 01:32:25.439
INDUSTRY HAS SET RECORD BREAKING
01:32:25.506 --> 01:32:27.808
PROFITS IN THE FIRST QUARTER OF
01:32:27.875 --> 01:32:29.410
TWENTY TWENTY TWO. THE LARGEST
01:32:29.477 --> 01:32:31.712
PRODUCERS MADE CLOSE TO A
01:32:31.779 --> 01:32:33.481
HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS. AS
01:32:33.547 --> 01:32:35.149
PRESIDENT BIDEN HAS SAID THE OIL
01:32:35.216 --> 01:32:36.517
COMPANIES COULD EASILY GIVE THE
01:32:36.584 --> 01:32:38.019
AMERICAN PEOPLE A BREAK BY
01:32:38.085 --> 01:32:40.154
PASSING SOME OF THE SAVINGS. ON
01:32:40.221 --> 01:32:41.923
TO THEIR CUSTOMERS I LOOK
01:32:41.989 --> 01:32:43.591
FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO WORK
01:32:43.658 --> 01:32:45.726
WITH THE OPPOSITION. I WANT TO
01:32:45.793 --> 01:32:47.695
FIND A SOLUTION TO ADDRESS SOME
01:32:47.762 --> 01:32:49.397
OF THEIR CONCERNS WHILE ALSO
01:32:49.463 --> 01:32:51.065
ENSURING THAT IF CALIFORNIA
01:32:51.132 --> 01:32:53.434
TAXPAYERS. TAXPAYER DOLLARS ARE
01:32:53.501 --> 01:32:55.002
USED IN PLUGGING AND ABANDONING
01:32:55.069 --> 01:32:56.971
WELLS WE ALSO FIND A WAY TO
01:32:57.038 --> 01:32:59.040
ENSURE THAT INDUSTRY INDUSTRY
01:32:59.106 --> 01:33:00.875
HAS PARTICIPATION IN BY. I
01:33:00.942 --> 01:33:02.643
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
01:33:02.710 --> 01:33:03.778
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER LOAN
01:33:03.844 --> 01:33:06.847
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
01:33:06.914 --> 01:33:10.985
SEEING AND HEARING. CENTER GROVE
01:33:11.052 --> 01:33:12.353
. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I
01:33:12.420 --> 01:33:14.655
RESPECTFULLY I REQUEST A NO VOTE
01:33:14.722 --> 01:33:16.657
ON THIS PARTICULAR PIECE OF
01:33:16.724 --> 01:33:17.992
LEGISLATION D. AT CAL JIM
01:33:18.059 --> 01:33:20.261
CONTACTED ME DIRECTLY AND THAT
01:33:20.328 --> 01:33:22.063
THE CLAIMS THAT THIS YEAR CLUB
01:33:22.129 --> 01:33:24.165
MADE ABOUT THOSE PARTICULAR-
01:33:24.231 --> 01:33:25.733
ABANDONED WELLS OR FROM WELLS IN
01:33:25.800 --> 01:33:28.869
ARVIN IN MY COLLEAGUES- DISTRICT
01:33:28.936 --> 01:33:30.771
AT WAS NOT TRUE THEY WENT OUT
01:33:30.838 --> 01:33:32.873
THERE THE TICKET TEAM OUT THERE
01:33:32.940 --> 01:33:34.308
THE DETERMINE THAT WHAT THEY
01:33:34.375 --> 01:33:37.211
CLAIMED- IN THE COMPLAINT- IN
01:33:37.278 --> 01:33:39.947
THE PUBLIC ARENA WAS NOT TRUE.
01:33:40.014 --> 01:33:41.515
AND THAT THEY DID ADDRESS IT AND
01:33:41.582 --> 01:33:43.117
THAT THEY HAVE COME TO AN
01:33:43.184 --> 01:33:44.352
AGREEMENT TO ABANDON THOSE WELLS
01:33:44.418 --> 01:33:47.088
PROPERLY AND SO THAT'S THE FIRST
01:33:47.154 --> 01:33:48.656
TIME THE OTHER THING IS THAT WE
01:33:48.723 --> 01:33:50.358
HAVE HAD EXTENUATING CONVERSE
01:33:50.424 --> 01:33:52.526
ALONG LENGTHLY CONVERSATIONS I
01:33:52.593 --> 01:33:54.195
THINK ON THE REAL PROBLEM THAT
01:33:54.261 --> 01:33:55.629
WE HAVE WITH ORPHANED AND
01:33:55.696 --> 01:33:56.864
ABANDONED WELLS- A LOT OF THEM
01:33:56.931 --> 01:33:59.433
ARE SMALL INDEPENDENT PRODUCERS
01:33:59.500 --> 01:34:01.802
THAT AND- I THINK THEIR
01:34:01.869 --> 01:34:03.871
GENERATIONAL HIS THE BEST WAY TO
01:34:03.938 --> 01:34:05.806
EXPLAIN IT SO THE GRANDFATHER
01:34:05.873 --> 01:34:08.376
HAS AND PASS AND TO THE YOU KNOW
01:34:08.442 --> 01:34:09.076
THAT THE DAD THE DAD TO THE
01:34:09.143 --> 01:34:11.078
SENATE NOW THIS. TWO CENT OR
01:34:11.145 --> 01:34:13.180
THREE CENTS AND THE SISTER IS A
01:34:13.247 --> 01:34:14.048
NEW YORK ATTORNEY OR SOMETHING
01:34:14.115 --> 01:34:15.783
DR IN SAN FRANCISCO OR WHATEVER
01:34:15.850 --> 01:34:17.151
THEY HAVE NO DESIRE TO EVEN DEAL
01:34:17.218 --> 01:34:19.220
WITH THESE ISSUES THAT ARE GOING
01:34:19.286 --> 01:34:22.189
ON SO WE DO NEED CALCIUM TO BE
01:34:22.256 --> 01:34:25.092
ABLE TO AN ISSUE CONTRACTS TO BE
01:34:25.159 --> 01:34:28.095
ABLE TO- AT ADDRESS THESE
01:34:28.162 --> 01:34:30.031
ORPHANED AND ABANDONED WELLS THE
01:34:30.097 --> 01:34:30.998
WAY THAT THEY SHOULD BE
01:34:31.065 --> 01:34:33.300
ABANDONED- CORRECTLY IN THE
01:34:33.367 --> 01:34:35.102
STATE OF CALIFORNIA I HAVE NO
01:34:35.169 --> 01:34:36.003
DISAGREEMENT WITH THAT
01:34:36.070 --> 01:34:38.706
WHATSOEVER. BUT I DO HAVE AN A
01:34:38.773 --> 01:34:40.041
DISAGREEMENT ON IS THAT THE
01:34:40.107 --> 01:34:42.309
BILLS THAT ARE PASSED IN THIS
01:34:42.376 --> 01:34:44.211
ACT IN THIS BODY
01:34:44.278 --> 01:34:46.947
DISPROPORTIONATELY AFFECT THE
01:34:47.014 --> 01:34:51.819
SMALL PRODUCER. NOW LIKE MY CAR
01:34:51.886 --> 01:34:54.088
SAID THERE ERROR KNOW LAW PROF.
01:34:54.155 --> 01:34:55.923
AS YOU KNOW THEY WANT SOME KIND
01:34:55.990 --> 01:34:57.391
IN ALICE'S GIVE PEOPLE MONEY
01:34:57.458 --> 01:34:59.293
BACK AT THE PUMP AND THE WHOLE
01:34:59.360 --> 01:35:01.829
BIT. WE SOME RANDOM OIL COMPANY
01:35:01.896 --> 01:35:04.231
IN KERN COUNTY DOES NOT SET. THE
01:35:04.298 --> 01:35:06.600
FUEL PRICE IT SET BY SUPPLY AND
01:35:06.667 --> 01:35:08.769
DEMAND IT'S SET GLOBALLY MOSTLY
01:35:08.836 --> 01:35:10.805
BY OPEC AND THEN THEY DETERMINE
01:35:10.871 --> 01:35:13.541
THE COST PER BARREL. SOME RANDOM
01:35:13.607 --> 01:35:15.176
OIL COMPANY IN KERN COUNTY DOES
01:35:15.242 --> 01:35:18.079
NOT SET A PRICE PER BARREL.
01:35:18.145 --> 01:35:19.146
THERE'S NOTHING THEY CAN DO
01:35:19.213 --> 01:35:21.415
ABOUT IT AND THEN WHEN THAT
01:35:21.482 --> 01:35:23.217
SUPPLIER THAT PRODUCER SELLS
01:35:23.284 --> 01:35:24.819
THREE FINERAN THEY REFINE THE
01:35:24.885 --> 01:35:27.488
GASOLINE. AND THEN THAT GOES TO
01:35:27.555 --> 01:35:28.689
IT I DOES SEVEN ELEVEN FASTER
01:35:28.756 --> 01:35:30.624
FOREVER WHERE YOU PURCHASE YOUR
01:35:30.691 --> 01:35:33.994
FUEL. AND THEY HAVE NO CONTROL
01:35:34.061 --> 01:35:37.364
OVER THAT PRICE WHETHER IT'S SET
01:35:37.431 --> 01:35:39.133
ON A GLOBAL SCALE AT FORTY
01:35:39.200 --> 01:35:41.235
DOLLARS A BARREL- HUNDRED FIFTY
01:35:41.302 --> 01:35:43.471
DOLLARS A BARREL. AND THEY HAVE
01:35:43.537 --> 01:35:45.506
NO CONTROL OVER THAT PRICE.
01:35:45.573 --> 01:35:47.274
AGAIN THE ARTICLE THAT CAME OUT
01:35:47.341 --> 01:35:49.143
FROM THE SIERRA CLUB WAS
01:35:49.210 --> 01:35:50.678
INCORRECT AND IT WAS AND CAL JIM
01:35:50.744 --> 01:35:51.979
BITTERMANN IT WAS NOT CORRECT
01:35:52.046 --> 01:35:52.980
BUT THEY HAVE ADDRESSED THE
01:35:53.047 --> 01:35:54.849
ISSUE. AND THEY ARE MOVING
01:35:54.915 --> 01:35:59.053
FORWARD TO DO THAT. AND THE
01:35:59.120 --> 01:36:01.188
BIGGEST ISSUE WE HAVE. AN WITH
01:36:01.255 --> 01:36:02.189
THESE ORPHANED AND ABANDONED
01:36:02.256 --> 01:36:03.357
WELLS IF THERE ARE MAJOR
01:36:03.424 --> 01:36:05.159
COMPANIES IN THIS STATE THE
01:36:05.226 --> 01:36:07.595
KERRY THE- THE BURDEN I GUESS
01:36:07.661 --> 01:36:09.363
YOU WOULD SAY. OF HAVING THE
01:36:09.430 --> 01:36:12.233
MOST WELLS. BUT WE DON'T MAKE
01:36:12.299 --> 01:36:14.568
THEM PARTICIPATE IN THIS PROGRAM
01:36:14.635 --> 01:36:16.604
THEY'RE EXCLUDED OBVIOUSLY
01:36:16.670 --> 01:36:18.706
BECAUSE THERE ARE THE THREE
01:36:18.772 --> 01:36:20.374
LARGEST COMPANIES IN THE STATE.
01:36:20.441 --> 01:36:22.643
AND A LOT OF THESE COMPANIES
01:36:22.710 --> 01:36:24.645
THESE THREE LARGE COMPANIES THEY
01:36:24.712 --> 01:36:27.715
COULD A POST A BOND FOR THIRTY
01:36:27.781 --> 01:36:29.116
MILLION LIKE A BILL THAT THAT MY
01:36:29.183 --> 01:36:30.351
COLLEAGUE THE AUTHOR OF THIS
01:36:30.417 --> 01:36:32.119
BILL HAD. THIRTY MILLION THEY
01:36:32.186 --> 01:36:33.888
CAN GET A LETTER OF CREDIT FOR
01:36:33.954 --> 01:36:35.189
THE BANK THEY COULD DO SOMETHING
01:36:35.256 --> 01:36:36.390
IN THE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
01:36:36.457 --> 01:36:38.192
BILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND IT WOULD
01:36:38.259 --> 01:36:41.629
NOT EVEN BE A BLIMP. ON THEIR
01:36:41.695 --> 01:36:42.563
FINANCIAL RADAR SCREEN. THE
01:36:42.630 --> 01:36:44.765
SMALL COMPANIES THAT THIS BILL
01:36:44.832 --> 01:36:47.234
ADVERSELY AFFECTS. JUST CREATE
01:36:47.301 --> 01:36:49.303
ANOTHER REASON WHY PEOPLE WOULD
01:36:49.370 --> 01:36:51.405
JUST WALK AWAY FROM THEIR SMALL
01:36:51.472 --> 01:36:53.874
PRODUCERS. YOU HAVE A COMPANY-
01:36:53.941 --> 01:36:55.743
IN TAFT FOR EXAMPLE FIFTY
01:36:55.809 --> 01:36:59.380
GENERATION I THINK THEY HAVE
01:36:59.446 --> 01:37:00.481
FOURTEEN WELLS. AND IT'S LIKE A
01:37:00.548 --> 01:37:02.516
JOB TO YOU IN ME LIKE WE GET
01:37:02.583 --> 01:37:04.585
PAID A CERTAIN SALARY EVERY
01:37:04.652 --> 01:37:05.953
YEAR. THIS FAMILY FOR THE LAST
01:37:06.020 --> 01:37:07.655
SEVERAL GENERATIONS HAS RAISED
01:37:07.721 --> 01:37:09.957
THEIR KIDS AND GRANDKIDS ON
01:37:10.024 --> 01:37:12.359
THESE WELLS. AND THEY PROBABLY
01:37:12.426 --> 01:37:14.728
MAKE TWO OR THREE OR FOUR
01:37:14.795 --> 01:37:16.030
THOUSAND DOLLARS A YEAR IT'S YOU
01:37:16.096 --> 01:37:17.698
KNOW A FAIRLY DECENT GOOD INCOME
01:37:17.765 --> 01:37:19.400
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA THERE
01:37:19.466 --> 01:37:21.569
NO BY NO MEANS BILLIONAIRES OR
01:37:21.635 --> 01:37:23.737
MILLIONAIRES. THERE NO MEANS
01:37:23.804 --> 01:37:25.906
EIGHT BY NO MEANS A LARGE
01:37:25.973 --> 01:37:28.108
CORPORATION. BUT TO COME UP WITH
01:37:28.175 --> 01:37:30.177
THE BOND FOR EACH WELL FOR
01:37:30.244 --> 01:37:31.445
PROBABLY THIRTY MILLION DOLLARS
01:37:31.512 --> 01:37:32.947
WHICH AGAIN IS JUST ANOTHER
01:37:33.013 --> 01:37:33.948
PIECE OF LEGISLATION THAT PASSED
01:37:34.014 --> 01:37:35.849
NOT THIS ONE. YOU HAVE TALK
01:37:35.916 --> 01:37:37.318
EVERYTHING THEN YOU CAN'T EVEN
01:37:37.384 --> 01:37:38.953
GET A BANKER SOMEONE TO PROVIDE
01:37:39.019 --> 01:37:41.388
THAT BOND TO THEM SO WHAT DO
01:37:41.455 --> 01:37:43.123
THEY DO IF NO THEY CAN'T EVEN
01:37:43.190 --> 01:37:44.058
OPERATE THEIR OWN FACILITY THAT
01:37:44.124 --> 01:37:45.426
HAS PRAYED FOR THEIR- FAMILY IS
01:37:45.492 --> 01:37:47.394
A REGULAR INCOME IN A JOB TO
01:37:47.461 --> 01:37:49.430
THEM FOR SEVERAL GENERATIONS.
01:37:49.496 --> 01:37:50.731
THIS PARTICULAR PIECE OF
01:37:50.798 --> 01:37:52.533
LEGISLATION I'M THAT WE'RE
01:37:52.600 --> 01:37:54.668
DEALING WITH HERE JUST A DAY
01:37:54.735 --> 01:37:57.071
INCREASES THE COST FOR THE SMALL
01:37:57.137 --> 01:37:59.139
INDEPENDENT PRODUCERS. I HAVE
01:37:59.206 --> 01:38:00.841
SAID OVER AND OVER AND OVER
01:38:00.908 --> 01:38:02.376
AGAIN WITH MY COLLEAGUES FROM
01:38:02.443 --> 01:38:03.978
MALIBU AND MY COLLEAGUE THAT HAS
01:38:04.044 --> 01:38:05.846
PRESENTED THIS BILL. I WILL WORK
01:38:05.913 --> 01:38:07.748
WITH YOU AS REPRESENTATIVE OF
01:38:07.815 --> 01:38:10.351
THE 70% OF THE OIL AND FOSSIL
01:38:10.417 --> 01:38:11.285
FUELS IT IS COMPLETED IN THE
01:38:11.352 --> 01:38:13.053
STATE TO DO SOMETHING FAIR AND
01:38:13.120 --> 01:38:14.922
EQUITABLE. TO ADDRESS THESE
01:38:14.989 --> 01:38:16.890
ORPHANED AND ABANDONED WELLS
01:38:16.957 --> 01:38:18.225
BECAUSE WE DO NEED TO ADDRESS
01:38:18.292 --> 01:38:19.960
THEM BUT WE HAVE TO STOP
01:38:20.027 --> 01:38:21.395
ATTACKING THE SMALL AND MID
01:38:21.462 --> 01:38:23.397
LEVEL PRODUCERS. THERE ARE MORE
01:38:23.464 --> 01:38:25.032
PEOPLE THAT OPERATE AND PROVIDE
01:38:25.099 --> 01:38:26.300
JOBS IN THIS STATE WITH
01:38:26.367 --> 01:38:28.002
CONTRACTORS AND EVERYTHING THAT
01:38:28.068 --> 01:38:30.771
DO NOT HAVE. THE RESOURCES THAT
01:38:30.838 --> 01:38:32.239
THESE THREE MAJOR COMPANIES DO
01:38:32.306 --> 01:38:34.141
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA SO I
01:38:34.208 --> 01:38:36.910
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A NO VOTE
01:38:36.977 --> 01:38:39.280
AND I WILL COMMIT TO WORK WITH
01:38:39.346 --> 01:38:43.617
ANYBODY. ON THIS FLOOR. TO
01:38:43.684 --> 01:38:44.385
ADDRESS THE ISSUE THAT WE HAVE
01:38:44.451 --> 01:38:46.854
WITH ORPHAN IN A WELLS WE NEED
01:38:46.920 --> 01:38:48.222
TO DO IT IN A WAY THAT DOES NOT
01:38:48.289 --> 01:38:50.157
HURT. THE MIDDLE LEVEL OR SMALL
01:38:50.224 --> 01:38:52.026
PRODUCER I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
01:38:52.092 --> 01:38:52.960
ANTHER. BIG CENTER GROVE CENTER
01:38:53.027 --> 01:38:55.462
BECKER. THANK YOU YOUR AGE WHEN
01:38:55.529 --> 01:38:57.097
I. REFER TO THAT ARE GONNA
01:38:57.164 --> 01:38:59.133
SUPPORT IN OUR- STATEMENT HERE
01:38:59.199 --> 01:39:00.000
SAYS THE CALIFORNIA COUNCIL
01:39:00.067 --> 01:39:02.036
SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY ESTIMATED.
01:39:02.102 --> 01:39:04.438
CALIFORNIA HAS FIVE THOUSAND
01:39:04.505 --> 01:39:05.539
FIVE HUNDRED FORTY WELLS WITHOUT
01:39:05.606 --> 01:39:08.175
A VIABLE OPERATOR. AN ESTIMATED
01:39:08.242 --> 01:39:09.977
MAYBE AN ADDITIONAL SIXTY NINE
01:39:10.044 --> 01:39:11.111
THOUSAND FORTUNE TWENTY FIVE
01:39:11.178 --> 01:39:12.813
WELLS. ECONOMICALLY MARGINAL
01:39:12.880 --> 01:39:14.281
THAT COULD BECOME DESERTED IN
01:39:14.348 --> 01:39:16.550
THE NEAR FUTURE. HIS ALLOWING
01:39:16.617 --> 01:39:18.752
CALCIUM TO COLLECT THESE FUNDS
01:39:18.819 --> 01:39:19.353
FOR THE OIL INDUSTRY. GLASSES
01:39:19.420 --> 01:39:20.254
STATE TO LEVERAGE THE PUBLIC
01:39:20.321 --> 01:39:21.588
FUNDS WITH PRIVATE INVESTMENTS
01:39:21.655 --> 01:39:22.923
BUT IT'S WE'RE TALK ABOUT.
01:39:22.990 --> 01:39:24.425
LEVERAGING THE POP THE PUBLIC
01:39:24.491 --> 01:39:26.026
FUNDS WITH PRIVATE INVESTMENT.
01:39:26.093 --> 01:39:29.029
TO ENSURE. THAT THE COSTS ARE
01:39:29.096 --> 01:39:29.930
NOT ALL PASSED ON TO THE
01:39:29.997 --> 01:39:31.932
TAXPAYER SO. I DO TRUST YOU
01:39:31.999 --> 01:39:34.034
AUTHOR GIVEN THE BENEFIT OUT TO
01:39:34.101 --> 01:39:35.836
CONTINUE TO WORK MAKE SURE
01:39:35.903 --> 01:39:37.705
SENSITIVE TO THE CONCERNS ON
01:39:37.771 --> 01:39:41.008
SMALL. SMALL PRODUCERS. IN THIS
01:39:41.075 --> 01:39:42.376
NOT ABOUT CUTTING WILL
01:39:42.443 --> 01:39:43.277
PRODUCTION THE STATE THIS IS
01:39:43.344 --> 01:39:44.411
REALLY ABOUT CAP IN THESE WELLS
01:39:44.478 --> 01:39:46.013
THAT MANY INTERNAL VIBE OPERATOR
01:39:46.080 --> 01:39:47.881
WILL NOT HAVE A VIABLE OPERATOR.
01:39:47.948 --> 01:39:49.049
IN THE NEAR FUTURE WE NEED A
01:39:49.116 --> 01:39:50.284
SOLUTION AND JUST ABOUT
01:39:50.351 --> 01:39:52.019
LEVERAGING PUBLIC MONEY WITH
01:39:52.086 --> 01:39:53.620
PRIVATE MONEY. THANK YOU CENTER
01:39:53.687 --> 01:40:00.094
BECKER CENTER DOLLY. THANK YOU
01:40:00.160 --> 01:40:02.796
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I RISE
01:40:02.863 --> 01:40:05.132
IN OPPOSITION I SET ON SIDE TO
01:40:05.199 --> 01:40:07.000
WITH A COUPLE OF MY COLLEAGUES
01:40:07.067 --> 01:40:08.936
AND WE GET TO ACTUALLY ASK CAL
01:40:09.002 --> 01:40:11.271
JIM ABOUT WHAT IS HAPPENING WITH
01:40:11.338 --> 01:40:13.073
ORPHAN WELLS THERE HAS BEEN A
01:40:13.140 --> 01:40:15.342
PART OF MONEY THAT HAS BEEN SET
01:40:15.409 --> 01:40:16.710
ASIDE TO DEAL WITH ORPHANED
01:40:16.777 --> 01:40:20.748
WELLS IN CALIFORNIA. BY LARGE
01:40:20.814 --> 01:40:22.916
PRODUCERS AND SMALL PRODUCERS.
01:40:22.983 --> 01:40:25.986
THE PROBLEM IS THAT EVERY YEAR
01:40:26.053 --> 01:40:27.187
SINCE I'VE BEEN HERE ON THE SITE
01:40:27.254 --> 01:40:28.622
TO COMMITTEE. CALLAGY INCOMES
01:40:28.689 --> 01:40:30.591
AND ASKED FOR MORE POSITIONS
01:40:30.657 --> 01:40:31.191
ACTUALLY IMPLEMENT THE WORKING
01:40:31.258 --> 01:40:33.193
CAN'T GET THE WORK DONE. THAT'S
01:40:33.260 --> 01:40:34.595
FOR SIXTY POSITIONS THIS YEAR
01:40:34.661 --> 01:40:36.797
SIXTY POSITION LAST YEAR AND THE
01:40:36.864 --> 01:40:38.499
ONLY HARD LIKE TEN POSITIONS.
01:40:38.565 --> 01:40:40.667
COLLAGEN IS A FAILURE WHEN IT
01:40:40.734 --> 01:40:43.137
COMES TO DOING ORPHAN WELLS AND
01:40:43.203 --> 01:40:45.139
ENFORCEMENT THERE IS PLENTY OF
01:40:45.205 --> 01:40:46.573
MONEY IN THE SYSTEM ALREADY TO
01:40:46.640 --> 01:40:48.709
GO OUT AND CAP THESE WELLS AND I
01:40:48.776 --> 01:40:50.544
PASSED EVERY YEAR FOR THEM TO
01:40:50.611 --> 01:40:52.579
GIVE US A REPORT AND NOT THE-
01:40:52.646 --> 01:40:55.215
CRICKETS. BUT THERE CONTINUE TO
01:40:55.282 --> 01:40:57.484
HIRE MORE AND MORE PEOPLE AT THE
01:40:57.551 --> 01:41:00.053
EXPENSE OF THE- OIL PRODUCERS
01:41:00.120 --> 01:41:03.690
WHO PAY INTO THAT PROGRAM. AT
01:41:03.757 --> 01:41:05.526
THE SAME TIME WE HAVE A THOUSAND
01:41:05.592 --> 01:41:07.494
WELLS WAITING TO BE PERMITTED AT
01:41:07.561 --> 01:41:10.130
CAL JIM AT THE SAME TIME. SO
01:41:10.197 --> 01:41:11.331
THIS BILL WILL DO NOTHING
01:41:11.398 --> 01:41:12.966
WHETHER IT PASSES OR FAILS WHICH
01:41:13.033 --> 01:41:15.469
I BELIEVE IT WILL PASS WILL DO
01:41:15.536 --> 01:41:17.137
NOTHING TO CAP ORPHAN WELLS
01:41:17.204 --> 01:41:19.940
UNTIL WE FIX. CAL JIM. IT IS THE
01:41:20.007 --> 01:41:22.109
PROBLEM. AND EVERY YEAR WE KEEP
01:41:22.176 --> 01:41:23.577
THROWING MORE MONEY AT AND KEEP
01:41:23.644 --> 01:41:25.512
PASSING MORE LAWS AND NOTHING
01:41:25.579 --> 01:41:27.648
HAPPENS IT'S LIKE THE E. D. D.
01:41:27.714 --> 01:41:29.817
THAT THE STATE OPERATES. IT'S
01:41:29.883 --> 01:41:33.954
LIKE THE DMV. ALL THESE THINGS I
01:41:34.021 --> 01:41:36.290
WANT TO COST RIGHT NOW DON'T
01:41:36.356 --> 01:41:38.292
WORK AND WE DEAL WITH IT IN OUR
01:41:38.358 --> 01:41:39.159
OFFICES. THE MEMBERS THAT SAID
01:41:39.226 --> 01:41:40.928
ON SAID TO HAVE ASKED THESE
01:41:40.994 --> 01:41:42.896
QUESTIONS EVERY YEAR WE GET THE
01:41:42.963 --> 01:41:45.599
SAME. THANK BACK NOTHING THIS
01:41:45.666 --> 01:41:47.134
BILL WILL DO NOTHING UNTIL WE
01:41:47.201 --> 01:41:49.102
FIXED CAL JIM THAT IS BROKEN.
01:41:49.169 --> 01:41:50.471
ADMINISTRATION NEED TO PUT
01:41:50.537 --> 01:41:52.573
PRESSURE ON THEIR RUNNING THIS
01:41:52.639 --> 01:41:53.273
AND THEY'RE NOT DOING IT THE
01:41:53.340 --> 01:41:54.908
FACT. FOR THOSE REASONS I WILL
01:41:54.975 --> 01:41:56.944
OPPOSE THIS BILL BECAUSE IT WILL
01:41:57.010 --> 01:41:58.212
DO NOTHING TO HELP FIX THE
01:41:58.278 --> 01:42:00.514
ORPHAN WELLS THAT WE NEED TO FIX
01:42:00.581 --> 01:42:01.248
IN CALIFORNIA THAT HAVE BEEN
01:42:01.315 --> 01:42:03.217
ABANDONED. FOR GENERATIONS.
01:42:03.283 --> 01:42:04.418
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THANK
01:42:04.485 --> 01:42:06.220
YOU CENTER DOLLING CENTER HER
01:42:06.286 --> 01:42:09.990
TADO. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
01:42:10.057 --> 01:42:12.359
I HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE AUTHOR
01:42:12.426 --> 01:42:15.128
CEREMONY TO GO QUESTION SURE
01:42:15.195 --> 01:42:17.798
PLEASE PROCEED. WHAT DO WE HAVE
01:42:17.865 --> 01:42:21.568
AN UPDATE IN TERMS OF IT.
01:42:21.635 --> 01:42:23.537
REPORTING THAT THAT IS IT IN
01:42:23.604 --> 01:42:25.239
TERMS OF FIND THE LOCATION OF
01:42:25.305 --> 01:42:27.207
ORPHAN WELLS I KNOW IN A
01:42:27.274 --> 01:42:28.976
CRESCENTA SUPPORT FROM EVERYBODY
01:42:29.042 --> 01:42:31.111
ON THIS FLOOR LAST YEAR FOR SB
01:42:31.178 --> 01:42:33.013
EIGHTY FOUR. ARE BOTH PART OF
01:42:33.080 --> 01:42:35.782
THE REPORT PART OF TAT BILL
01:42:35.849 --> 01:42:37.451
INCLUDED GETTING AN UPDATED
01:42:37.518 --> 01:42:38.919
REPORT OF WHERE. YOU KNOW ALL
01:42:38.986 --> 01:42:41.021
THESE ORPHANED WELLS ARE LOCATED
01:42:41.088 --> 01:42:42.923
THROUGHOUT THE STATE AND HAVING
01:42:42.990 --> 01:42:44.358
AN ASSESSMENT I JUST. PERSONALLY
01:42:44.424 --> 01:42:49.429
I DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE. WITH
01:42:49.496 --> 01:42:51.098
WHAT. YOU KNOW I DID I DO
01:42:51.164 --> 01:42:52.933
BELIEVE THAT WE SIT ON THE ON
01:42:53.000 --> 01:42:55.269
THE ON THE SAME PAGE LIKE FOR ON
01:42:55.335 --> 01:42:57.137
THE SAME PAGE IN TERMS OF THE
01:42:57.204 --> 01:42:59.072
COMPANY'S ORPHANED WELLS BUT THE
01:42:59.139 --> 01:43:01.441
PART OF THE CHALLENGE OF PROBLEM
01:43:01.508 --> 01:43:04.478
IS ACCOUNTABILITY. GOING TO WHAT
01:43:04.545 --> 01:43:06.079
ARE CALLING JUST SAID THAT WE
01:43:06.146 --> 01:43:07.347
NEED A WHOLE. CAL JIM
01:43:07.414 --> 01:43:10.317
ACCOUNTABLE I MEAN. SB EIGHTY
01:43:10.384 --> 01:43:13.487
FOUR I HOPING WOULD HELP WITH
01:43:13.554 --> 01:43:15.088
THAT BUT I THINK IT ALSO TAKES
01:43:15.155 --> 01:43:16.990
OUR EFFORTS TO. GO BACK TO MY
01:43:17.057 --> 01:43:19.893
QUESTION IS DO WE HAVE ANY KIND
01:43:19.960 --> 01:43:20.727
OF UPDATE ARE THEY WERE EXPECTED
01:43:20.794 --> 01:43:22.796
TO PROVIDE A REPAIR AN UPDATE IN
01:43:22.863 --> 01:43:25.966
APRIL AND SO I WAS JUST
01:43:26.033 --> 01:43:27.834
WONDERING IF YOU KNEW. ANYTHING
01:43:27.901 --> 01:43:29.603
IN REGARDS TO THAT. SO CAL JAM A
01:43:29.670 --> 01:43:32.806
DOES A REPORT PUBLISHED. AN IDOL
01:43:32.873 --> 01:43:35.208
WELL REPORT PUBLISHED ANNUALLY
01:43:35.275 --> 01:43:36.810
AND SO THERE IS AN APPENDIX-
01:43:36.877 --> 01:43:38.745
THAT HAS ALL THE COUNTIES IN ALL
01:43:38.812 --> 01:43:40.414
THE IDLE AND DESERTED WELLS. SO
01:43:40.480 --> 01:43:41.815
THAT IS AN ANNUAL REPORT AND
01:43:41.882 --> 01:43:44.952
THAT WE HAVE AVAILABLE TO US AND
01:43:45.018 --> 01:43:48.255
THAT IS WHAT WE'RE WORKING ON.
01:43:48.322 --> 01:43:51.124
SIT AT THE PROVIDER REPORT TO
01:43:51.191 --> 01:43:53.860
YOU. THIS IS A THIS IS THIS IS
01:43:53.927 --> 01:43:55.062
NOT A REPORT PROVIDED TO ME THIS
01:43:55.128 --> 01:43:56.997
IS A REPORT THAT THEY DO
01:43:57.064 --> 01:43:59.466
ANNUALLY THAT ANYONE OF US CAN
01:43:59.533 --> 01:44:01.068
ACCESS. THROUGH CAL JIM. OKAY
01:44:01.134 --> 01:44:05.872
THANK YOU. IT'S A PUBLIC REPORT
01:44:05.939 --> 01:44:11.111
JUST TO BE CLEAR. OVER HERE.
01:44:11.178 --> 01:44:13.580
THANK YOU CENTER LAYERED I DID
01:44:13.647 --> 01:44:15.983
SEE YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
01:44:16.049 --> 01:44:19.086
MADAM PRESIDENT. I WANTED TO
01:44:19.152 --> 01:44:22.356
OFFER SOME FACTS ABOUT THIS THE
01:44:22.422 --> 01:44:24.391
GLOBAL SITUATION THAT SURROUNDS
01:44:24.458 --> 01:44:27.861
THIS BILL R. ONE IS THAT IT ONE
01:44:27.928 --> 01:44:29.796
OF THE KEY THINGS AND CLIMATE
01:44:29.863 --> 01:44:31.932
EFFORTS IS TO DEAL WITH SHORT
01:44:31.999 --> 01:44:34.134
TERM CLIMATE POLLUTANTS IT'S
01:44:34.201 --> 01:44:38.405
ESTIMATED THAT 9213% ALL OF THEM
01:44:38.472 --> 01:44:40.607
IN CALIFORNIA COM FROM WELLS IN
01:44:40.674 --> 01:44:43.043
THIS CATEGORY SO FOR GOING TO
01:44:43.110 --> 01:44:44.978
HAVE CLIMATE EFFORTS WE HAVE TO
01:44:45.045 --> 01:44:48.215
DEAL WITH THIS SECOND. ARE THERE
01:44:48.281 --> 01:44:50.617
IS A CAP THERE'S ONLY A CERTAIN
01:44:50.684 --> 01:44:52.285
AMOUNT I THINK IT'S THREE
01:44:52.352 --> 01:44:53.120
BILLION DOLLARS A YEAR THAT CAN
01:44:53.186 --> 01:44:56.323
BE SPENT ON THIS PURPOSE AND NOW
01:44:56.390 --> 01:44:57.491
WE HAVE THE AVAILABILITY OF
01:44:57.557 --> 01:44:58.992
FEDERAL FUNDS. THAT MIGHT TAKE
01:44:59.059 --> 01:45:00.961
IT UP TO AS HIGH AS A HUNDRED
01:45:01.028 --> 01:45:03.030
AND EIGHTY MILLION BUT UNLESS WE
01:45:03.096 --> 01:45:04.898
PASS THIS BILL OR ANOTHER BILL.
01:45:04.965 --> 01:45:07.267
THAT BLOWS OFF THE CAP WE CAN'T
01:45:07.334 --> 01:45:09.202
DO WITH THE MONEY THAT COMES IN
01:45:09.269 --> 01:45:11.538
TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEM FOR WHICH
01:45:11.605 --> 01:45:14.141
IT WAS INTENDED. ADDITIONALLY A
01:45:14.207 --> 01:45:16.143
LOT OF US HAVE BEEN HAVING TALKS
01:45:16.209 --> 01:45:17.911
ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT THEIR
01:45:17.978 --> 01:45:21.548
LABOR PROTECTIONS. IN ALL THE
01:45:21.615 --> 01:45:24.217
PIECES OF CLIMATE WORK. AND THE
01:45:24.284 --> 01:45:26.019
LABOR PROTECTIONS IN THIS
01:45:26.086 --> 01:45:28.522
CATEGORY ARE SO UNIQUE BECAUSE
01:45:28.588 --> 01:45:30.424
AS WAS POINTED OUT BY. BY ONE
01:45:30.490 --> 01:45:32.826
SPEAKER SOME OF THESE PROJECTS
01:45:32.893 --> 01:45:35.696
ARE REALLY SMALL. SO HAVING
01:45:35.762 --> 01:45:38.498
REQUIREMENTS ON. INDIVIDUAL
01:45:38.565 --> 01:45:40.133
PROJECTS IS NOT NECESSARILY
01:45:40.200 --> 01:45:42.135
VIABLE AND SO THERE'S REALLY
01:45:42.202 --> 01:45:44.938
BEEN. A FRAMEWORK SET OUT TO
01:45:45.005 --> 01:45:47.708
CLUMP THEM TOGETHER TO DO IT IN
01:45:47.774 --> 01:45:48.709
A WAY THAT ADDRESSES THE LABOR
01:45:48.775 --> 01:45:51.678
ISSUES. BUT RESPECTS THE FACT
01:45:51.745 --> 01:45:52.546
THAT SOME OF THESE PROJECTS ARE
01:45:52.612 --> 01:45:56.049
SMALL. AND LASTLY BECAUSE OF
01:45:56.116 --> 01:45:58.251
THESE LEVELS OF COMPLEXITY. THE
01:45:58.318 --> 01:46:01.021
AUTHOR HAS BEEN. WORKING WITH
01:46:01.088 --> 01:46:03.090
MANY STAKEHOLDERS AND IT'S CLEAR
01:46:03.156 --> 01:46:05.125
WILL CONTINUE TO WORK. POSSESS
01:46:05.192 --> 01:46:08.395
SOME OF THESE ISSUES ARE RAISED
01:46:08.462 --> 01:46:09.296
IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TO MAKE SURE
01:46:09.362 --> 01:46:11.064
THEIR CORPORATION. SO I THINK
01:46:11.131 --> 01:46:14.267
THIS IS AN IMPORTANT BILL. TO
01:46:14.334 --> 01:46:16.536
MOVE THIS ISSUE WHERE IT IS
01:46:16.603 --> 01:46:18.839
WORTH THE MONEY MOVE IT IS WHERE
01:46:18.905 --> 01:46:20.774
THE LEGALITY OF ALLOWING THE
01:46:20.841 --> 01:46:23.110
AGENCY. TO BE ABLE TO ADDRESS
01:46:23.176 --> 01:46:24.678
IT. AND ADDRESS LABOR
01:46:24.745 --> 01:46:26.613
PROTECTIONS THAT HAVE BEEN
01:46:26.680 --> 01:46:29.249
AMENDED DIRECTLY INTO THIS BILL.
01:46:29.316 --> 01:46:31.651
M. THE AUTHOR IS STILL WILLING
01:46:31.718 --> 01:46:34.121
TO WORK. ON ISSUES THAT. PEOPLE
01:46:34.187 --> 01:46:35.756
MIGHT HAVE BECAUSE IT'S SO
01:46:35.822 --> 01:46:37.057
IMPORTANT TO GET SOME OF THIS
01:46:37.124 --> 01:46:39.092
DONE. THAT IT'S VERY IMPORTANT
01:46:39.159 --> 01:46:40.460
THAT THERE BE A VEHICLE AND A
01:46:40.527 --> 01:46:42.062
CONVERSATION THIS BILL IS THE
01:46:42.129 --> 01:46:44.231
VEHICLE TO GET THESE THINGS DONE
01:46:44.297 --> 01:46:45.165
TO MOVE WITH THE ADDITIONAL
01:46:45.232 --> 01:46:47.067
MONEY AND LABOR PROTECTIONS. IT
01:46:47.134 --> 01:46:48.468
IS THE VEHICLE TO CONTINUE THE
01:46:48.535 --> 01:46:50.904
CONVERSATION I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:46:50.971 --> 01:46:55.475
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK. YOU
01:46:55.542 --> 01:46:56.109
CENTER LAYERED THUNDERSTORMS. AT
01:46:56.176 --> 01:46:59.646
THE YOU MADAM. I RISE IN SUPPORT
01:46:59.713 --> 01:47:00.247
OF THIS MEASURE- AND I THOUGHT
01:47:00.313 --> 01:47:02.415
IT MIGHT HELP TO GIVE A LITTLE
01:47:02.482 --> 01:47:03.617
BIT OF HISTORY WE'RE WE'RE
01:47:03.683 --> 01:47:06.052
TALKING ABOUT. THIS MOVIE- THE
01:47:06.119 --> 01:47:07.587
FAILINGS PERHAPS OF A STATE
01:47:07.654 --> 01:47:11.224
AGENCY. WE REFORMED IN FACT IF
01:47:11.291 --> 01:47:12.392
THE FORMER STATE AGENCY DOG OR
01:47:12.459 --> 01:47:16.062
TO. TO BECOME THIS NEW- JIM FOR
01:47:16.129 --> 01:47:19.166
THE STATE CAL JIM- SO WE SPENT A
01:47:19.232 --> 01:47:21.401
LOT OF TIME TALKING ABOUT HOW TO
01:47:21.468 --> 01:47:22.435
HOLD THE AGENCY ACCOUNTABLE OR
01:47:22.502 --> 01:47:24.004
OR BLAMING GOVERNMENT BUT TO
01:47:24.070 --> 01:47:25.872
GIVE YOU ALL A LITTLE CONTEXT
01:47:25.939 --> 01:47:26.907
ESPECIALLY MY FRIENDS IN THE
01:47:26.973 --> 01:47:28.809
CENTRAL VALLEY WHO WERE
01:47:28.875 --> 01:47:31.144
CONCERNED ABOUT SMALL OPERATORS.
01:47:31.211 --> 01:47:34.281
UNDER CALIFORNIA LAW. ANY WELL
01:47:34.347 --> 01:47:37.651
OWN PRIOR TO NINETEEN NINETY SIX
01:47:37.717 --> 01:47:38.952
THAT OWNER. THAT PREVIOUS OWNERS
01:47:39.019 --> 01:47:42.155
NOT LIABLE. THE FUNDAMENTAL
01:47:42.222 --> 01:47:44.157
PROBLEM IN CALIFORNIA LAW IS
01:47:44.224 --> 01:47:47.160
THAT BIG OIL PASSED THE BUCK TO
01:47:47.227 --> 01:47:49.196
THE SMALL GUYS INSULATED
01:47:49.262 --> 01:47:52.866
THEMSELVES FROM LIABILITY IN
01:47:52.933 --> 01:47:54.501
NINETEEN NINETY SIX THANKS TO
01:47:54.568 --> 01:47:55.302
LEGISLATION PASSED BY NOW
01:47:55.368 --> 01:47:57.237
CONGRESSMAN JIM COSTA. THAT
01:47:57.304 --> 01:47:59.439
EXEMPTS THE OIL INDUSTRY FROM
01:47:59.506 --> 01:48:05.178
ANY LIABILITY FOR WELLS ON PRIOR
01:48:05.245 --> 01:48:06.613
SITTING HERE TRYING TO PLUG A
01:48:06.680 --> 01:48:09.516
HOLE IN A SYSTEM THAT WE CREATED
01:48:09.583 --> 01:48:11.718
A HOLE IN IN THE FIRST PLACE. SO
01:48:11.785 --> 01:48:13.453
I WOULD SUBMIT TO MEMBERS I
01:48:13.520 --> 01:48:15.789
APPRECIATE ALL THE FRUSTRATION
01:48:15.856 --> 01:48:17.490
WITH THE LACK IN THE PACE OF
01:48:17.557 --> 01:48:18.859
WORK. AND I MET MY COLLEAGUE
01:48:18.925 --> 01:48:21.695
FROM FROM THE NORTH. WHO WHO I
01:48:21.761 --> 01:48:24.130
SAT ON BUDGET SUB WITH. AND BEEN
01:48:24.197 --> 01:48:26.766
FRUSTRATED WITH- THE PACE OF
01:48:26.833 --> 01:48:28.501
WORK THAT'S GOING ON BECAUSE
01:48:28.568 --> 01:48:30.937
TRUST ME WE HAVE THESE ABANDONED
01:48:31.004 --> 01:48:32.806
WELLS ALL OVER LOS ANGELES TWO.
01:48:32.873 --> 01:48:34.774
AND WE HAVE VITAL WELLS. IT JUST
01:48:34.841 --> 01:48:36.409
SPRUNG A LEAK IN OUR BACKYARD
01:48:36.476 --> 01:48:38.178
AND SPILLED OIL ALL OUT ON THE
01:48:38.245 --> 01:48:41.648
STREETS PICO AND DOHENY ABOUT A
01:48:41.715 --> 01:48:42.782
MONTH AND A HALF AGO. SO
01:48:42.849 --> 01:48:44.784
BAKERSFIELD ARVIN AREN'T ALONE.
01:48:44.851 --> 01:48:50.290
BUT UNTIL WE COLLECTIVELY LOOK
01:48:50.357 --> 01:48:52.359
TO THE BIG PLAYERS WHO HAVE
01:48:52.425 --> 01:48:55.161
PROFITED FOR MANY MANY DECADES
01:48:55.228 --> 01:48:57.998
OFF OF THESE FIELDS AND THEN
01:48:58.064 --> 01:48:59.766
CONVENIENTLY EXEMPTED THEMSELVES
01:48:59.833 --> 01:49:02.168
FROM LIABILITY AND NOW HAVE ALL
01:49:02.235 --> 01:49:03.837
THE SMALL OPERATORS SAYING IT'S
01:49:03.904 --> 01:49:05.906
NOT OURS LET THEM SORT IT OUT OR
01:49:05.972 --> 01:49:08.508
LET THE TAXPAYERS PAY FOR IT
01:49:08.575 --> 01:49:09.109
THAT'S WHERE I THINK THE WORK
01:49:09.175 --> 01:49:11.011
NEEDS TO BE DONE NOW. I
01:49:11.077 --> 01:49:13.413
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S EFFORTS
01:49:13.480 --> 01:49:16.416
HERE AND I OFFERED TO HER EARLY
01:49:16.483 --> 01:49:18.018
ON N THIS SESSION THAT
01:49:18.084 --> 01:49:20.186
AMENDMENT TO SAY WE COULD STRIKE
01:49:20.253 --> 01:49:22.022
ACOSTA AMENDMENT IN CALIFORNIA
01:49:22.088 --> 01:49:24.624
LAW. AND THEN THAT. BUT TO HER
01:49:24.691 --> 01:49:26.493
CREDIT I THINK SHE'S BEEN TRYING
01:49:26.559 --> 01:49:27.961
TO FIND SOME KIND OF COMPROMISE
01:49:28.028 --> 01:49:30.297
TO GET OFF THIS FLOOR TO BRING
01:49:30.363 --> 01:49:32.632
FOLKS ON BOARD WHO MIGHT BE
01:49:32.699 --> 01:49:35.302
WORRIED ABOUT. WHAT WHISPER HAS
01:49:35.368 --> 01:49:37.070
TO SAY ABOUT A BILL. I DON'T
01:49:37.137 --> 01:49:39.472
WORRY ABOUT BUT I APPRECIATE
01:49:39.539 --> 01:49:41.074
THAT WE'VE HAD TO STRIKE SOME
01:49:41.141 --> 01:49:43.410
KIND OF COMPROMISE HERE- BUT I
01:49:43.476 --> 01:49:46.613
WILL I WILL ADMIT THAT THIS BILL
01:49:46.680 --> 01:49:48.214
WILL NOT SOLVE THE WHOLE ISSUE
01:49:48.281 --> 01:49:50.517
IT WILL CHIP AWAY AT THE PROBLEM
01:49:50.583 --> 01:49:51.618
IT WILL PUT IMPORTANT GUARDRAILS
01:49:51.685 --> 01:49:53.219
IN PLACE AND ENSURE THAT
01:49:53.286 --> 01:49:55.322
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES ARE
01:49:55.388 --> 01:49:58.591
PRIORITIZED. IN THIS PROCESS
01:49:58.658 --> 01:50:00.860
THAT THOSE WHO HAVE THE OLDEST
01:50:00.927 --> 01:50:02.762
WELLS CLOSEST TO PEOPLE ARE
01:50:02.829 --> 01:50:04.597
GOING TO BE HELPED OUT SO
01:50:04.664 --> 01:50:06.366
WHETHER YOU'RE IN SOUTH LA OR
01:50:06.433 --> 01:50:08.201
URINE ARVIN ARE YOU UP IN
01:50:08.268 --> 01:50:10.303
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA YOUR PEOPLE
01:50:10.370 --> 01:50:12.272
ARE MOST IN HARM'S WAY ARGAN BE
01:50:12.339 --> 01:50:13.673
PRIORITIZED BY THIS LEGISLATION
01:50:13.740 --> 01:50:15.041
I THINK THE CAP IN THE LABOR
01:50:15.108 --> 01:50:16.176
PROTECTIONS MAKES SENSE FOR THE
01:50:16.242 --> 01:50:20.180
TIME BEING BUT IF WE REALLY WANT
01:50:20.246 --> 01:50:21.915
TO TACKLE THIS ISSUE MEMBERS.
01:50:21.982 --> 01:50:22.849
WE'VE GOT A LOOK BACK TO
01:50:22.916 --> 01:50:24.050
NINETEEN NINETY SIX AND SAY WHY
01:50:24.117 --> 01:50:25.652
SUDDENLY. IS EVERYONE MAGICALLY
01:50:25.719 --> 01:50:29.889
EXEMPT FROM LIABILITY. WHO'S
01:50:29.956 --> 01:50:30.991
PROFITED BILLIONS UP TO THAT
01:50:31.057 --> 01:50:34.294
POINT. SO I WOULD ENCOURAGE US
01:50:34.361 --> 01:50:37.097
AS WE MOVE THIS MEASURE TODAY TO
01:50:37.163 --> 01:50:39.032
TAKE ON THE BIG WORK THAT NEEDS
01:50:39.099 --> 01:50:40.367
TO BE DONE. THANK YOU CENTER
01:50:40.433 --> 01:50:43.670
STERN CENTER DOLLY. THANK YOU
01:50:43.737 --> 01:50:45.138
MADAM PRESIDENT FOR INDULGING ME
01:50:45.205 --> 01:50:47.440
I JUST WANT TO GO ON RECORD
01:50:47.507 --> 01:50:48.375
BECAUSE THERE'S BEEN SOME NEW
01:50:48.441 --> 01:50:50.543
INFORMATION PUT OUT THAT. PRE
01:50:50.610 --> 01:50:51.144
NINETEEN NINETY SIX THERE'S A
01:50:51.211 --> 01:50:53.213
PER OIL FEE. THAT HAS BEEN PUT
01:50:53.279 --> 01:50:54.214
ON TO TAKE CARE OF THE
01:50:54.280 --> 01:50:58.018
REMEDIATION OF THOSE WELLS PRIOR
01:50:58.084 --> 01:50:59.219
TO NINETY NINE NINETEEN NINETY
01:50:59.285 --> 01:51:01.221
SIX THAT'S THE POINT. THERE'S
01:51:01.287 --> 01:51:02.489
MONEY IN THE BUDGET TO DO IT AND
01:51:02.555 --> 01:51:04.090
IT'S NOT BEING DONE LAST YEAR.
01:51:04.157 --> 01:51:05.158
THEY TOOK I THINK WAS LAST YEAR
01:51:05.225 --> 01:51:08.061
TEN MILLION DOLLARS DEPARTMENT
01:51:08.128 --> 01:51:09.129
OF FINANCE FINANCE TOOK OUT OF
01:51:09.195 --> 01:51:12.298
THE FUND. WHILE WELLS INSTANCE
01:51:12.365 --> 01:51:13.400
SOMEWHERE ELSE THOSE ARE THE
01:51:13.466 --> 01:51:15.969
PROBLEMS WE HAVE WITH. WITH THIS
01:51:16.036 --> 01:51:18.204
THIS LEGISLATION IS THAT THERE'S
01:51:18.271 --> 01:51:20.407
MONEY THERE TO DO IT. IT'S JUST
01:51:20.473 --> 01:51:23.410
NOT GETTING DONE. THANK YOU
01:51:23.476 --> 01:51:24.444
CENTER DOLLY MEMBERS FURTHER
01:51:24.511 --> 01:51:26.246
RESEARCH CENTER GROVE THANK YOU
01:51:26.312 --> 01:51:28.081
IN JUST TO CORRECT THE RECORD-
01:51:28.148 --> 01:51:29.849
JUST TO CORRECT THE RECORD THERE
01:51:29.916 --> 01:51:31.117
WAS TEN MILLION DOLLARS IT WAS
01:51:31.184 --> 01:51:32.752
TAKEN OUT OF THE IDYLLWILD
01:51:32.819 --> 01:51:34.087
SIGNED TO BE ABLE TO FIND OTHER
01:51:34.154 --> 01:51:35.855
OTHER THINGS OTHER THAN I TO
01:51:35.922 --> 01:51:37.257
WILSON THAT WE'RE ALL VERY
01:51:37.323 --> 01:51:39.459
CONCERNED ABOUT. AND JUST TO BE
01:51:39.526 --> 01:51:40.827
CLEAR NOT ONE NOT ONE IF
01:51:40.894 --> 01:51:42.395
SOMEBODY CAN PROVE ME WRONG I
01:51:42.462 --> 01:51:44.431
WOULD LOVE IT BUT NOT ONE
01:51:44.497 --> 01:51:48.168
TAXPAYER PINI. HAS GONE TO
01:51:48.234 --> 01:51:50.003
SIXTIES OR FIND A BUYER I DO
01:51:50.070 --> 01:51:52.305
WELL SO THAT NEEDS TO BE
01:51:52.372 --> 01:51:52.872
CORRECTED. BECAUSE BUSINESS
01:51:52.939 --> 01:51:55.375
OWNERS INDUSTRY ARE TAXPAYERS.
01:51:55.442 --> 01:51:57.210
SO THEY PAY FOR THIS INDUSTRY
01:51:57.277 --> 01:52:02.482
FUNDS THIS ONE HUNDRED PERCENT.
01:52:02.549 --> 01:52:04.451
101% INDUSTRY FINDS CAL JIM. AND
01:52:04.517 --> 01:52:06.753
IF YOU GUYS WOULD JUST. WE CAN
01:52:06.820 --> 01:52:09.289
AGAIN I'VE OFFERED I KNOW
01:52:09.355 --> 01:52:11.524
SENATOR DOLLY WOULD JOIN S. THAT
01:52:11.591 --> 01:52:13.526
WE COULD COME UP WITH A SOLUTION
01:52:13.593 --> 01:52:14.761
THAT DOES NOT DISPROPORTIONATELY
01:52:14.828 --> 01:52:16.129
AFFECT THE SMALL AND MID SIZE
01:52:16.196 --> 01:52:18.098
PRODUCERS. AND WE COULD MOVE
01:52:18.164 --> 01:52:20.467
FORWARD AND FIX THE PROBLEM ALL
01:52:20.533 --> 01:52:21.901
THE PROBLEMS IN MALIBU IN THE
01:52:21.968 --> 01:52:23.970
BEACH AREA. THE ONES THAT WE
01:52:24.037 --> 01:52:26.206
HAVE IN KERN. AND BUT YOU CAN'T
01:52:26.272 --> 01:52:29.008
SHUT DOWN THE MID SIZE AND MID
01:52:29.075 --> 01:52:30.110
LEVEL PRODUCERS AND SMALL
01:52:30.176 --> 01:52:31.644
PRODUCERS. AND HAVE THE
01:52:31.711 --> 01:52:33.079
CONVERSATION TO MOVE FORWARD IT
01:52:33.146 --> 01:52:35.215
JUST DOESN'T WORK YOU'RE GOING
01:52:35.281 --> 01:52:36.416
TO DOUBLE THE AMOUNT OF ORPHANED
01:52:36.483 --> 01:52:37.951
AND ABANDONED IDLE WELLS THAT
01:52:38.017 --> 01:52:40.053
YOU HAVE IN THIS STATE. AND WHAT
01:52:40.120 --> 01:52:41.521
ARE YOU GONNA DO YOU THINK THE
01:52:41.588 --> 01:52:45.158
MAJORS ARE GOING TO PAY FOR IT
01:52:45.225 --> 01:52:46.893
THEY'RE NOT. HIS THEY KEPT THOSE
01:52:46.960 --> 01:52:48.228
DEALS IN THEY HAVE THEIR OWN.
01:52:48.294 --> 01:52:50.196
WHERE THEY MOVE FORWARD AND THEY
01:52:50.263 --> 01:52:52.232
SET UP THEIR OWN ABANDONED OR
01:52:52.298 --> 01:52:52.999
FROM OFTEN THEY DON'T EVEN
01:52:53.066 --> 01:52:54.968
PARTICIPATE IN THE STATE PROJECT
01:52:55.034 --> 01:52:57.170
. SO I JUST ASK YOU GUYS TO JUST
01:52:57.237 --> 01:52:59.005
SIT ON THIS BILL. LET'S WORK ON
01:52:59.072 --> 01:53:01.207
A PROJECT THAT WORKS I PROMISE
01:53:01.274 --> 01:53:02.775
TO COMMITTEE LET'S FIX IT SO
01:53:02.842 --> 01:53:03.977
THAT WE CAN ADDRESS THIS ISSUE
01:53:04.043 --> 01:53:06.045
ONCE AND FOR ALL. AND THEN LET'S
01:53:06.112 --> 01:53:07.313
LOOK AT CARBON EMISSIONS AND
01:53:07.380 --> 01:53:09.215
CARBON CAPTURE AND LET'S LOOK AT
01:53:09.282 --> 01:53:10.483
CARBON EMISSIONS AND CO TWO
01:53:10.550 --> 01:53:12.085
THAT'S GOING INTO THE ATMOSPHERE
01:53:12.152 --> 01:53:14.220
BY IMPORTING OIL. YOU SEE YOU
01:53:14.287 --> 01:53:15.221
CARE ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT AND
01:53:15.288 --> 01:53:17.056
THERE ARE MILLIONS OF METRIC
01:53:17.123 --> 01:53:19.392
TONS FOR ONE SHIP COMING FROM
01:53:19.459 --> 01:53:21.394
SAUDI ARABIA. AND WE COULD
01:53:21.461 --> 01:53:23.530
PRODUCE IT HERE THE WE CONTROL
01:53:23.596 --> 01:53:25.632
THE ENVIRONMENT WE CONTROL THAT
01:53:25.698 --> 01:53:27.634
THE WAY THEY DID THE REGULATORY
01:53:27.700 --> 01:53:29.435
PROCESSES. IT'S THE BEST
01:53:29.502 --> 01:53:31.104
SOLUTION AND I JUST CHALLENGE
01:53:31.171 --> 01:53:33.373
ALL OF YOU GUYS TO JUST. OPPOSE
01:53:33.439 --> 01:53:34.674
THIS BILL AGAIN RESPECTFULLY
01:53:34.741 --> 01:53:36.442
ASKING FOR A NO VOTE. THE CENTER
01:53:36.509 --> 01:53:38.811
GROVE MEMBERS FURTHER TO SENATOR
01:53:38.878 --> 01:53:41.047
WHITE HOUSE SKI. THANK YOU MADAM
01:53:41.114 --> 01:53:44.450
PRESIDENT. I WANT TO REITERATE.
01:53:44.517 --> 01:53:45.451
THE POINT THAT WAS MADE BY THE
01:53:45.518 --> 01:53:47.820
FORMER US SECRETARY OF NATURAL
01:53:47.887 --> 01:53:50.023
RESOURCES. NOW I KNOW MOST
01:53:50.089 --> 01:53:51.791
PEOPLE DON'T KNOW THAT WE HAVE
01:53:51.858 --> 01:53:53.826
THIS OIL GAS AND GEOTHERMAL
01:53:53.893 --> 01:53:57.297
ADMINISTRATIVE FINES WHICH- THE-
01:53:57.363 --> 01:54:00.867
OIL COMMUNITY PAYS INTO. BUT
01:54:00.934 --> 01:54:02.702
WHAT PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE IS
01:54:02.769 --> 01:54:05.104
THAT THEY HAVE A CAP OF FIVE
01:54:05.171 --> 01:54:06.806
MILLION DOLLARS A YEAR WHICH-
01:54:06.873 --> 01:54:08.274
ONCE UPON A TIME WAS PROBABLY
01:54:08.341 --> 01:54:10.677
SOME MONEY TO DO SOME. CAPPING
01:54:10.743 --> 01:54:12.512
OF THESE ABANDONED WELLS BUT
01:54:12.579 --> 01:54:14.380
IT'S ENOUGH AND BURGER RIGHT NOW
01:54:14.447 --> 01:54:17.250
IT'S A FEW IT'S A HANDFUL WELLS
01:54:17.317 --> 01:54:20.787
THE KIDS CAPT. IN THIS UNIVERSE.
01:54:20.853 --> 01:54:22.822
THERE ARE THE ABANDONED WELLS
01:54:22.889 --> 01:54:24.757
WERE WE DON'T HAVE RESPONSIBLE
01:54:24.824 --> 01:54:26.359
PERSON WE'RE WE KNOW THAT THEIR
01:54:26.426 --> 01:54:27.794
LEAKING THERE MAY BE FACILITIES
01:54:27.860 --> 01:54:29.462
THAT ARE LEAKING. THAT'S ONE
01:54:29.529 --> 01:54:31.331
WORLD THAT WE HAVE THIS IDLE
01:54:31.397 --> 01:54:33.533
WELLS WITH PEOPLE HAVING USED
01:54:33.600 --> 01:54:35.134
THE IDLE WELLS. ARE YOU HAVING
01:54:35.201 --> 01:54:37.337
USED TO WELLS IN TWO YEARS AND
01:54:37.403 --> 01:54:39.239
THEY'RE TECHNICALLY. I'LL I GET
01:54:39.305 --> 01:54:41.040
THAT THAT MAKES PEOPLE NERVOUS
01:54:41.107 --> 01:54:45.011
BUT WE GOT PLENTY OF WORK TO DO.
01:54:45.078 --> 01:54:49.849
ON THE FIVE. FIVE THOUSAND. WE
01:54:49.916 --> 01:54:51.884
ARE. WELL TO WE THE STATE
01:54:51.951 --> 01:54:53.019
ACCOUNT. HAS AND IF THIS BILL
01:54:53.086 --> 01:54:55.188
DOES NOT ELSE IS IT MOVE
01:54:55.255 --> 01:54:56.522
FORWARD. IT LIVE STEP THOUSAND
01:54:56.589 --> 01:54:58.558
DOLLAR CEILING SO THAT WE DON'T
01:54:58.625 --> 01:55:00.059
HAVE TO DIVERT MONEY FROM THIS
01:55:00.126 --> 01:55:02.128
FUND BECAUSE WE'VE MAXED OUT OF
01:55:02.195 --> 01:55:03.329
FIVE MILLION DOLLARS THAT WE
01:55:03.396 --> 01:55:06.099
CAN. WE CAN WORK WITH OUR
01:55:06.165 --> 01:55:08.601
COLLEAGUES ON BUGS SAID TO AND
01:55:08.668 --> 01:55:10.069
WITH THE BUDGET NEGOTIATION TO
01:55:10.136 --> 01:55:12.639
MAKE SURE THAT THE STATE OF
01:55:12.705 --> 01:55:13.573
CALIFORNIA HAS ENOUGH MONEY IN
01:55:13.640 --> 01:55:15.275
THERE WITH THE MONEY THAT THE
01:55:15.341 --> 01:55:19.445
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS. SO THAT
01:55:19.512 --> 01:55:21.080
BE DONE THERE'S A WHOLE LOT OF
01:55:21.147 --> 01:55:22.982
WORK THAT NEEDS TO BE DONE IN
01:55:23.049 --> 01:55:25.251
THIS FIELD. AND I WOULD URGE AN
01:55:25.318 --> 01:55:26.719
AYE VOTE TO MOVE THE BILL ALONG
01:55:26.786 --> 01:55:28.288
SO WE CAN CONTINUE TO ADDRESS
01:55:28.354 --> 01:55:30.290
SOME OF THESE AND FIRE. CLEARLY
01:55:30.356 --> 01:55:32.725
ENVIRONMENTAL. HAZARDS THE
01:55:32.792 --> 01:55:36.729
PEOPLE EVERYBODY AGREES. WITH
01:55:36.796 --> 01:55:37.964
THAT NEEDS TO BE REMEDIATED.
01:55:38.031 --> 01:55:38.965
THANK YOU CENTER RIGHT SCHEME
01:55:39.032 --> 01:55:41.801
FURTHER. OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
01:55:41.868 --> 01:55:43.503
HEARING THEN SETTLE AMONG YOU
01:55:43.569 --> 01:55:45.705
MAY CLOSE THANK YOU MEMBERS FOR
01:55:45.772 --> 01:55:49.008
THAT VERY ROBUST DISCUSSION- I
01:55:49.075 --> 01:55:50.109
WANT TO FOCUS ON THIS BILL
01:55:50.176 --> 01:55:51.978
BECAUSE A LOT OF THINGS CAME UP
01:55:52.045 --> 01:55:53.880
IN THIS DISCUSSION THAT ARE NOT
01:55:53.946 --> 01:55:56.716
PART OF THIS BILL- LED TO IT YOU
01:55:56.783 --> 01:55:58.217
KNOW THE DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
01:55:58.284 --> 01:56:00.053
DID WHEN I WAS NOT ELECTED IS
01:56:00.119 --> 01:56:01.287
SOMETHING THAT IS NOT ADDRESS IN
01:56:01.354 --> 01:56:03.589
THIS BILL- YOU KNOW IT IT
01:56:03.656 --> 01:56:05.625
DEFINITELY- THAT YOU KNOW
01:56:05.692 --> 01:56:08.728
NEGOTIATED FORMULAS IN TERMS OF
01:56:08.795 --> 01:56:10.463
THE OIL WELL COST. I MEAN THIS
01:56:10.530 --> 01:56:14.000
WAS ON THIS BILL IS ABOUT TRYING
01:56:14.067 --> 01:56:15.802
TO FIND A WAY TO LEVERAGE
01:56:15.868 --> 01:56:18.404
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYER DOLLARS WITH
01:56:18.471 --> 01:56:20.707
SOME PRIVATE DOLLARS. TO ADDRESS
01:56:20.773 --> 01:56:23.609
A PROBLEM OF THIRTY FIVE
01:56:23.676 --> 01:56:24.477
THOUSAND WELLS THAT ARE NOT
01:56:24.544 --> 01:56:27.013
BEING USED. TO EXTRACT OIL THAT
01:56:27.080 --> 01:56:28.581
ARE SITTING THERE THIS IS WHAT
01:56:28.648 --> 01:56:30.283
THIS BILL IS ABOUT ADDITIONALLY
01:56:30.350 --> 01:56:32.585
THIS BILL ALSO ADDRESSES THE
01:56:32.652 --> 01:56:34.887
FACT THAT WE DON'T HAVE. A
01:56:34.954 --> 01:56:37.890
LEVER. YOU KNOW ENTITY TO
01:56:37.957 --> 01:56:40.393
ADDRESS THIS IT FOR THE NEXT
01:56:40.460 --> 01:56:41.160
TWENTY TO FIFTY YEARS. THE
01:56:41.227 --> 01:56:42.762
REASON THAT THIS CONVERSATION
01:56:42.829 --> 01:56:45.031
HAS COME UP ANNUALLY IN THE LAST
01:56:45.098 --> 01:56:47.233
COUPLE OF YEARS IS BECAUSE-
01:56:47.300 --> 01:56:48.868
THESE WELLS ARE CLOSE TO PEOPLE
01:56:48.935 --> 01:56:50.670
AND WHEN THEY'RE CLOSE TO PEOPLE
01:56:50.737 --> 01:56:52.205
THEY POSE A GREATER DANGER. BUT
01:56:52.271 --> 01:56:54.173
WE ALSO NEED TO CREATE A LABOR
01:56:54.240 --> 01:56:56.676
FORCE TO ADDRESS THIS MANY WELLS
01:56:56.743 --> 01:56:59.145
IF WE ARE ONLY CLOSING AND
01:56:59.212 --> 01:57:02.415
PROPERLY ABANDONING. FIVE TO
01:57:02.482 --> 01:57:04.016
ELEVEN WELLS A YEAR RUN AND WHAT
01:57:04.083 --> 01:57:05.785
CALIFORNIANS IN A ONE THOUSAND
01:57:05.852 --> 01:57:07.620
YEAR PLAN TO FINISH. AND WHAT
01:57:07.687 --> 01:57:09.722
WE'RE TRYING TO DO IS EXPEDITE
01:57:09.789 --> 01:57:12.425
THIS WE WANT THIS TO BE OVER THE
01:57:12.492 --> 01:57:13.593
NEXT TWENTY TO FIFTY YEARS AND
01:57:13.659 --> 01:57:15.294
IT IS BEEN SAID THAT IT'S BEEN
01:57:15.361 --> 01:57:15.995
PIECED TOGETHER AND YOU'RE
01:57:16.062 --> 01:57:18.998
RIGHT. EVEN THE SMALL PIECES
01:57:19.065 --> 01:57:20.466
HAVE BEEN FIGHTS TO BE ABLE TO
01:57:20.533 --> 01:57:22.769
GET. ON IT AND THAT THAT IS WHAT
01:57:22.835 --> 01:57:25.438
WE'RE TRYING TO DO WE'RE TRYING
01:57:25.505 --> 01:57:27.206
TO ADD. TO THE POOL OF TOOLS
01:57:27.273 --> 01:57:29.809
THAT CALIFORNIA HAS TO BE ABLE
01:57:29.876 --> 01:57:32.311
TO ADDRESS THIS- SO I RESPECT
01:57:32.378 --> 01:57:34.213
AND UNDERSTAND EVERYONE'S
01:57:34.280 --> 01:57:38.618
DIFFERENT POSITIONS I WILL.
01:57:38.684 --> 01:57:39.419
CONTINUE AS I HAVE WITH EVERY
01:57:39.485 --> 01:57:40.887
OTHER THE BILL TO WORK WITH THE
01:57:40.953 --> 01:57:42.255
OPPOSITE TO FEED OUT WHAT THAT
01:57:42.321 --> 01:57:44.457
BALLOT IS I CAN TELL YOU THAT
01:57:44.524 --> 01:57:46.259
THIS HOUSE IS NOT THE ONLY HOUSE
01:57:46.325 --> 01:57:47.393
TALKING ABOUT THIS ISSUE- THIS
01:57:47.460 --> 01:57:49.128
IS A BROADER CONVERSATION. AND I
01:57:49.195 --> 01:57:51.631
DEFINITELY AM HOPEFUL. THAT WE
01:57:51.697 --> 01:57:53.933
CAN FIGURE OUT A WAY TO DO MORE
01:57:54.000 --> 01:57:55.334
THAN WHAT WE'RE DOING NOW
01:57:55.401 --> 01:57:57.203
BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT WE NEED TO
01:57:57.270 --> 01:57:58.838
DO TO KEEP CALIFORNIANS SAFE.
01:57:58.905 --> 01:58:00.740
AND ALSO TO ENSURE WERE MAXINE
01:58:00.807 --> 01:58:02.575
MAXIMIZING. THE CALIFORNIA
01:58:02.642 --> 01:58:04.477
TAXPAYER DOLLARS I WHICH IS
01:58:04.544 --> 01:58:06.345
GOING TO BE PUT INTO THIS EFFORT
01:58:06.412 --> 01:58:08.014
SO WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
01:58:08.080 --> 01:58:09.482
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
01:58:09.549 --> 01:58:11.884
CENTER LIMÓN MADAM SECRETARY
01:58:11.951 --> 01:58:15.054
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN I
01:58:15.121 --> 01:58:19.725
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
01:58:19.792 --> 01:58:26.232
NOW FACTOR I FORTUS NO BRADFORD
01:58:26.299 --> 01:58:30.770
. CABALLERO HI CORTESE I DALY NO
01:58:30.837 --> 01:58:35.808
DODD. TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
01:58:35.875 --> 01:58:41.614
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROW NO
01:58:41.681 --> 01:58:46.452
HERTZBERG WESSEL. HI HER TADO.
01:58:46.519 --> 01:58:52.225
JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED
01:58:52.291 --> 01:58:56.762
AYE LEYVA AYE THE- AYE MCGUIRE
01:58:56.829 --> 01:59:02.401
AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN.
01:59:02.468 --> 01:59:07.406
NIELSEN NO A CHOI BOGUE NO PAN.
01:59:07.473 --> 01:59:13.813
PORTANTINO I ROTH. I RUBIO.
01:59:13.880 --> 01:59:20.920
SKINNER I STERN. AMBERG HI MY
01:59:20.987 --> 01:59:27.460
CASTING. HI WIENER AYE WILK NO
01:59:27.527 --> 01:59:28.895
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
01:59:28.961 --> 01:59:36.602
BRADFORD I. DODD GLAZER.
01:59:36.669 --> 01:59:42.875
HERTZBERG FURTADO. NEWMAN PAN.
01:59:42.942 --> 01:59:49.015
RUBIO. STERN HI I TWENTY FOUR
01:59:49.081 --> 01:59:51.083
NEWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
01:59:51.150 --> 01:59:52.318
MEMBERS WE ARE NOT GOING TO FILE
01:59:52.385 --> 01:59:54.754
ITEM FORTY ONE SENATOR ARCH
01:59:54.820 --> 01:59:55.888
ALETTA. MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
01:59:55.955 --> 02:00:00.426
READ ANNABEL TEN SEVENTY SIX BY
02:00:00.493 --> 02:00:00.960
SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
02:00:01.027 --> 02:00:03.229
RELATING TO LEAD BASED PAINT
02:00:03.296 --> 02:00:06.032
CENTER ARCHULETA. THANK YOU
02:00:06.098 --> 02:00:07.667
MADAM PRESIDENT I RISE TO
02:00:07.733 --> 02:00:10.870
PRESENT SENATE BILL TEN SEVENTY
02:00:10.937 --> 02:00:11.537
SIX THIS BILL REQUIRES THE
02:00:11.604 --> 02:00:13.539
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH TO
02:00:13.606 --> 02:00:15.541
REVIEW AND AMEND ITS REGULATIONS
02:00:15.608 --> 02:00:17.043
GOVERNING LEAD RELATED
02:00:17.109 --> 02:00:19.111
CONSTRUCTION WORK INCLUDING
02:00:19.178 --> 02:00:20.913
TRAINING AND CERTIFICATION FOR
02:00:20.980 --> 02:00:23.149
WORKERS AND ACCREDITATION FOR
02:00:23.215 --> 02:00:26.152
TRAINERS. IN LEAD SAFE WORK
02:00:26.218 --> 02:00:27.520
PRACTICES TO COMPLY WITH
02:00:27.587 --> 02:00:30.022
EXISTING STATE REGULATIONS AND
02:00:30.089 --> 02:00:32.825
WITH UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
02:00:32.892 --> 02:00:35.795
PROTECTION AGENCY. REPAIRS
02:00:35.861 --> 02:00:37.763
PAINTING AND REMOVAL STANDARDS
02:00:37.830 --> 02:00:39.999
SB TEN SEVENTY SIX REQUIRES TO
02:00:40.066 --> 02:00:41.567
REGULATION TO INCLUDE BUT NOT
02:00:41.634 --> 02:00:44.403
LIMITED TO REQUIRING A COPY OF
02:00:44.470 --> 02:00:46.172
THE WORKERS AND FIRMS
02:00:46.238 --> 02:00:48.207
CERTIFICATION TO PROVIDE BEFORE
02:00:48.274 --> 02:00:50.509
THE START OF THE JOB TO THE
02:00:50.576 --> 02:00:52.578
PRIMARY CONTRACTOR OTHER
02:00:52.645 --> 02:00:54.947
EMPLOYERS ON THE SITE TO BE
02:00:55.014 --> 02:00:57.650
POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BESIDES
02:00:57.717 --> 02:00:59.385
THE DIVISION- BESIDES A DIVISION
02:00:59.452 --> 02:01:01.153
OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND
02:01:01.220 --> 02:01:03.522
HEALTH HELLO CHAU LED WORK PRE
02:01:03.589 --> 02:01:05.024
JOB NOTIFICATION IT IS A
02:01:05.091 --> 02:01:07.326
PROTECTION FOR THE CONSUMER I
02:01:07.393 --> 02:01:08.861
URGE YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
02:01:08.928 --> 02:01:10.529
CENTER ARCHULETA MEMBERS
02:01:10.596 --> 02:01:13.866
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
02:01:13.933 --> 02:01:14.967
HEARING THEN MADAM SECRETARY
02:01:15.034 --> 02:01:18.070
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
02:01:18.137 --> 02:01:22.441
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
02:01:22.508 --> 02:01:29.482
BACKER I PORCHES NO BRADFORD AYE
02:01:29.548 --> 02:01:32.184
CABALLERO HIGH COURT HAS HE I
02:01:32.251 --> 02:01:36.689
DALY. I DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
02:01:36.756 --> 02:01:42.862
EGGMAN. EGGMAN FIVE GLAZER AYE
02:01:42.928 --> 02:01:46.832
GONZALEZ I GROW NO HERTZBERG
02:01:46.899 --> 02:01:52.872
WESSEL. I HER DAUGHTER I JONES
02:01:52.938 --> 02:01:59.011
NO KAMLAGER. I FLARED I LEYVA
02:01:59.078 --> 02:02:03.816
AYE LIMÓN I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
02:02:03.883 --> 02:02:09.622
NO MAN I NEWMAN I NIELSEN NO A
02:02:09.689 --> 02:02:12.458
SHOW OF BOTH I PAN AYE
02:02:12.525 --> 02:02:17.163
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE
02:02:17.229 --> 02:02:22.802
SKINNER HI STERN I AM BURKE AYE
02:02:22.868 --> 02:02:26.405
AYE CASTING AYE WIENER AYE WILK
02:02:26.472 --> 02:02:29.075
HI. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
02:02:29.141 --> 02:02:34.880
MEMBERS BATES. HERTZBERG DALLY I
02:02:34.947 --> 02:02:40.186
DON'T KNOW. IS THIRTY TWO NO SIX
02:02:40.252 --> 02:02:42.021
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
02:02:42.088 --> 02:02:43.956
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY
02:02:44.023 --> 02:02:45.658
THREE SENATOR NEWMAN MADAM
02:02:45.725 --> 02:02:48.260
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
02:02:48.327 --> 02:02:50.096
BILL ELEVEN THIRTY ONE BY
02:02:50.162 --> 02:02:52.331
SENATOR NEWMAN AN ACT RELATING
02:02:52.398 --> 02:02:53.866
TO ADDRESS CONFIDENTIALITY AND
02:02:53.933 --> 02:02:54.867
DECLARING THEIR AGENCY THEY'RE
02:02:54.934 --> 02:02:56.836
OUT SICK FOR TWO MEDIALLY CENTER
02:02:56.902 --> 02:02:58.738
NEWMAN THANK YOU- MADAM
02:02:58.804 --> 02:03:01.073
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT S.
02:03:01.140 --> 02:03:03.843
B. ELEVEN THIRTY ONE IN RECENT
02:03:03.909 --> 02:03:04.677
YEARS. AN INCREASING NUMBER OF
02:03:04.744 --> 02:03:05.911
THE CIVIL SERVANTS IN PART TIME
02:03:05.978 --> 02:03:07.179
WORKERS CHARGED WITH
02:03:07.246 --> 02:03:07.713
ADMINISTERING CALIFORNIA
02:03:07.780 --> 02:03:09.749
ELECTIONS HAVE BEEN SUBJECTED TO
02:03:09.815 --> 02:03:11.751
THREATS INTIMIDATION AND
02:03:11.817 --> 02:03:12.852
SOMETIMES VIOLENCE AT POLLING
02:03:12.918 --> 02:03:15.287
PLACES IN THEIR OFFICES AND EVEN
02:03:15.354 --> 02:03:17.823
AT THEIR HOMES. IN A TWENTY
02:03:17.890 --> 02:03:18.991
TWENTY ONE NATIONWIDE SURVEY AS
02:03:19.058 --> 02:03:20.459
MANY AS ONE IN THREE ELECTION
02:03:20.526 --> 02:03:22.094
WORKERS INDICATED THEY FELT
02:03:22.161 --> 02:03:23.996
UNSAFE IN THE CONDUCT OF THEIR
02:03:24.063 --> 02:03:26.265
JOBS WITH THE STUDY WANTED SIX
02:03:26.332 --> 02:03:27.733
LISTING THREATS TO THEIR LIVES
02:03:27.800 --> 02:03:29.969
AS A JOB RELATED CONCERNS. SADLY
02:03:30.035 --> 02:03:31.237
THE STRESSES OF BEGUN TO AFFECT
02:03:31.303 --> 02:03:33.072
OUR ABILITY DUE TO OFFICIALLY
02:03:33.139 --> 02:03:35.107
MISTER ELECTIONS IN CALIFORNIA
02:03:35.174 --> 02:03:36.675
SINCE NOVEMBER OF TWENTY TWENTY
02:03:36.742 --> 02:03:38.377
MORE THAN 15% OF CALIFORNIA'S
02:03:38.444 --> 02:03:39.545
ELECTION OFFICIALS HAVE LEFT
02:03:39.612 --> 02:03:42.348
THEIR JOBS DUE IN NO SMALL PART
02:03:42.414 --> 02:03:43.449
TO THE MARKED INCREASE IN
02:03:43.516 --> 02:03:44.216
AGGRESSIVE AND ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR
02:03:44.283 --> 02:03:47.453
DIRECTED TOWARDS THEM. SB ELEVEN
02:03:47.520 --> 02:03:48.554
THIRTY ONE WILL PROVIDE
02:03:48.621 --> 02:03:49.488
PROTECTION AND PEACE OF MIND TO
02:03:49.555 --> 02:03:50.156
ELECTION WORKERS THROUGHOUT
02:03:50.222 --> 02:03:51.490
CALIFORNIA BY EXTENDING THE
02:03:51.557 --> 02:03:53.125
OPTION OF THEIR ENROLLMENT IN
02:03:53.192 --> 02:03:54.894
EITHER OF THE STATE'S TO ADDRESS
02:03:54.960 --> 02:03:57.163
PROTECTION PROGRAMS CALIFORNIA
02:03:57.229 --> 02:03:58.397
HAS A PROGRAM CALLED SAFE AT
02:03:58.464 --> 02:04:00.332
HOME ADMINISTERED BY THE OFFICE
02:04:00.399 --> 02:04:02.134
OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE. WHICH
02:04:02.201 --> 02:04:03.302
PROVIDES PROTECTIONS TO
02:04:03.369 --> 02:04:05.137
SURVIVORS OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
02:04:05.204 --> 02:04:06.438
AND THE PEOPLE WHO WORK IN
02:04:06.505 --> 02:04:08.941
REPRODUCTIVE CARE FACILITIES SB
02:04:09.008 --> 02:04:10.109
ELEVEN THIRTY ONE WILL EXTEND
02:04:10.176 --> 02:04:11.477
THOSE PROTECTIONS TO INDIVIDUALS
02:04:11.544 --> 02:04:12.444
TO INDIVIDUALS WHO PERFORM
02:04:12.511 --> 02:04:14.480
ELECTION RELATED WORK. UNDER THE
02:04:14.547 --> 02:04:15.514
PROVISIONS OF THE BILL ELECTION
02:04:15.581 --> 02:04:16.482
WORKERS WHO FEEL THAT THE
02:04:16.549 --> 02:04:18.350
PROVISIONS OF SAFE AT HOME MAYBE
02:04:18.417 --> 02:04:19.885
TOO CUMBERSOME MAY ALSO CHOOSE
02:04:19.952 --> 02:04:21.320
TO BE ENROLLED IN THE SAME
02:04:21.387 --> 02:04:22.788
ADDRESS CONFIDENTIALITY PROGRAM
02:04:22.855 --> 02:04:24.490
THAT IS AVAILABLE TO PEACE
02:04:24.557 --> 02:04:26.091
OFFICERS AT THE COUNTY LEVEL.
02:04:26.158 --> 02:04:27.092
THE INCLUSION OF ELECTION
02:04:27.159 --> 02:04:28.427
WORKERS IN THIS PROGRAM WILL
02:04:28.494 --> 02:04:30.262
ALLOW ALLOW THEM TO ATTAIN A
02:04:30.329 --> 02:04:31.463
SIMILAR LEVEL OF PRIVACY
02:04:31.530 --> 02:04:32.498
ENABLING STATE AND LOCAL
02:04:32.565 --> 02:04:37.002
AGENCIES TO RESPOND TO REQUESTS.
02:04:37.069 --> 02:04:38.470
FOR PUBLIC RECORDS. WITHOUT HAVE
02:04:38.537 --> 02:04:39.371
TWO DISCLOSE THE ADDRESSES OF
02:04:39.438 --> 02:04:40.139
ELECTION WORKERS AND THEIR
02:04:40.206 --> 02:04:42.174
FAMILY MEMBERS SB ELEVEN THIRTY
02:04:42.241 --> 02:04:43.309
ONE WILL ALSO ELIMINATE THE
02:04:43.375 --> 02:04:45.177
CURRENT STATUTORY REQUIREMENT TO
02:04:45.244 --> 02:04:46.111
PROMINENTLY POST THE NAMES. OF
02:04:46.178 --> 02:04:48.047
POLL WORKERS AT POLLING PLACES
02:04:48.113 --> 02:04:49.114
THOUGH POSTING THE POLITICAL
02:04:49.181 --> 02:04:50.516
PARTY AFFILIATIONS OF POLL
02:04:50.583 --> 02:04:51.684
WORKERS ARE POLLING LOCATIONS
02:04:51.750 --> 02:04:53.686
WILL CONTINUE TO BE REQUIRED.
02:04:53.752 --> 02:04:54.954
THE BILL SPONSORS AND I HAVE
02:04:55.020 --> 02:04:55.988
WORKED CLOSELY WITH ELECTION
02:04:56.055 --> 02:04:58.324
OFFICIALS TO ENSURE THAT SB
02:04:58.390 --> 02:04:58.924
ELEVEN THIRTY ONE FULFILLS THE
02:04:58.991 --> 02:05:00.793
NEEDS ELECTION WORKERS. WHO FACE
02:05:00.860 --> 02:05:02.695
THREATS ON A REGULAR BASIS THIS
02:05:02.761 --> 02:05:05.531
LEGISLATION IS. SADLY VERY MUCH
02:05:05.598 --> 02:05:07.633
NEEDED IN ORDER TO PROTECT THE
02:05:07.700 --> 02:05:08.267
CALIFORNIANS WHO DO THE LARGELY
02:05:08.334 --> 02:05:10.035
THANKLESS. BUT VERY ESSENTIAL
02:05:10.102 --> 02:05:11.203
WORK OF ENSURING THAT OUR
02:05:11.270 --> 02:05:12.771
ELECTIONS ARE FREE FAIR AND
02:05:12.838 --> 02:05:14.240
EFFECTIVELY ADMINISTERED THIS IS
02:05:14.306 --> 02:05:16.175
AN EMERGENCY MEASURE. AND I
02:05:16.242 --> 02:05:18.878
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
02:05:18.944 --> 02:05:20.446
VOTE TODAY. THANK YOU CENTER
02:05:20.512 --> 02:05:21.447
NEWMAN MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR
02:05:21.513 --> 02:05:24.049
DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING THEN
02:05:24.116 --> 02:05:25.751
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
02:05:25.818 --> 02:05:29.388
ROLL. ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
02:05:29.455 --> 02:05:34.493
ATKINS. AYE BATES NO BAKER. I
02:05:34.560 --> 02:05:39.098
PORCHES NO BRADFORD HI CABALLERO
02:05:39.164 --> 02:05:44.870
HI CORTESE I DALY NO DODD AYE
02:05:44.937 --> 02:05:48.674
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
02:05:48.741 --> 02:05:54.546
GONZALEZ. I GROWTH NO HERTZBERG
02:05:54.613 --> 02:06:01.987
WESSEL I HER TADO I JONES. NO
02:06:02.054 --> 02:06:07.960
KAMLAGER. I LAYERED I LEYVA AYE
02:06:08.027 --> 02:06:13.332
THE MON. I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
02:06:13.399 --> 02:06:18.470
NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A
02:06:18.537 --> 02:06:24.076
CHOI BOGUE. PAN I PORTANTINO AYE
02:06:24.143 --> 02:06:27.813
ROTH AYE RUBIO I SKINNER. I
02:06:27.880 --> 02:06:32.384
STERN HI I'M BURKE I WAKE
02:06:32.451 --> 02:06:36.956
HOUSEKI AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO
02:06:37.022 --> 02:06:38.924
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:06:38.991 --> 02:06:42.895
HERTZBERG A CHOI BOGUE. IS
02:06:42.962 --> 02:06:45.597
THIRTY NEWS EIGHT ON THE URGENCY
02:06:45.664 --> 02:06:46.432
HIGHS THIRTY KNOWS EIGHT THE
02:06:46.498 --> 02:06:48.033
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
02:06:48.100 --> 02:06:50.169
MOVING TO FILE ITEM FORTY FOUR
02:06:50.235 --> 02:06:52.471
SENATOR PAN AM SECRETARY PLEASE
02:06:52.538 --> 02:06:56.342
READ. SENATE BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY
02:06:56.408 --> 02:06:58.377
TWO BY SENATOR PAN AN ACT
02:06:58.444 --> 02:07:00.012
RELATING TO PRIVACY CENTER PANTS
02:07:00.079 --> 02:07:01.280
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
02:07:01.347 --> 02:07:04.750
SENATORS I'M PROUD TO PRESENT SB
02:07:04.817 --> 02:07:05.250
ELEVEN SEVENTY TWO WHICH
02:07:05.317 --> 02:07:06.585
PROTECTS THE PRIVACY OF OUR
02:07:06.652 --> 02:07:07.353
STUDENTS. BY LIMITING THE
02:07:07.419 --> 02:07:09.188
PERSONAL BIOMETRIC INFORMATION
02:07:09.254 --> 02:07:11.290
THAT REMOTE TRACKING COMPANIES
02:07:11.357 --> 02:07:13.092
CAN COLLECT TO ONLY INFORMATION
02:07:13.158 --> 02:07:15.928
IT'S ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY TO
02:07:15.995 --> 02:07:17.696
OFFER THE TEST TAKING SERVICES.
02:07:17.763 --> 02:07:19.331
SB ELEVEN SEVENTY TWO EMPOWERS
02:07:19.398 --> 02:07:20.833
STUDENTS TO TAKE ACTION OF THEIR
02:07:20.899 --> 02:07:22.368
PRIVACY IS BEING VIOLATED BY
02:07:22.434 --> 02:07:24.603
REQUIRING DATA MINIMIZATION
02:07:24.670 --> 02:07:26.905
ALLOWING HARM USERS. LONG HARM
02:07:26.972 --> 02:07:28.540
USES A REMOTE PROPERTY SAW
02:07:28.607 --> 02:07:32.244
SOFTWARE TO BE ABLE TO TAKE
02:07:32.311 --> 02:07:34.613
ACTION ON THEIR OWN. NOW WITH CO
02:07:34.680 --> 02:07:35.848
WE KNOW THAT AS WE'VE- MORE MORE
02:07:35.914 --> 02:07:36.849
PEOPLE BEEN REQUIRED TO STUDENTS
02:07:36.915 --> 02:07:38.250
AND OTHERS HAVE BEEN REQUIRED TO
02:07:38.317 --> 02:07:40.419
TAKE TEST REMOTELY. AND MANY
02:07:40.486 --> 02:07:43.422
TIMES. SCHOOLS OR UNIVERSITIES
02:07:43.489 --> 02:07:46.258
SUPPORT. USE REMOTE PROMPTING
02:07:46.325 --> 02:07:50.562
SERVICES. TO VERIFY AND FOR IT'S
02:07:50.629 --> 02:07:52.564
- THE PERSON TAKING THE TEST AND
02:07:52.631 --> 02:07:54.266
IN FACT WE KNOW THAT REMOTE
02:07:54.333 --> 02:07:56.402
PROXY IN SCHOOL FOR A SCHOOL FOR
02:07:56.468 --> 02:07:58.170
PROFESSIONAL LICENSING STATE
02:07:58.237 --> 02:07:58.904
FARM INCREASED ALMOST FIVE
02:07:58.971 --> 02:08:02.274
HUNDRED PERCENT. NOW- IF YOU'RE
02:08:02.341 --> 02:08:04.109
THE PERSON TAKING THE TEST YOU
02:08:04.176 --> 02:08:05.978
DON'T EXACTLY HAVE A CHOICE.
02:08:06.045 --> 02:08:07.479
WHEN THE PRACTICE COMEY SAYS I
02:08:07.546 --> 02:08:09.281
WANT ALL THE STATE ON YOU. IT'S
02:08:09.348 --> 02:08:12.451
NOT L. YOU CAN EITHER TAKE THE
02:08:12.518 --> 02:08:13.952
BAR EXAM. OR NOT TAKE THE BAR
02:08:14.019 --> 02:08:15.587
EXAM IF YOU DON'T TAKE IT THEN
02:08:15.654 --> 02:08:17.990
YOU'RE NOT HARD RIGHT- YOU CAN
02:08:18.057 --> 02:08:19.591
THAT YOU DON'T TAKE THE FINAL
02:08:19.658 --> 02:08:21.660
THEN YOU FAIL THE CLASS SO IT'S-
02:08:21.727 --> 02:08:23.295
SO YOU'RE COMPELLED TO PROVIDE
02:08:23.362 --> 02:08:24.329
WHATEVER INFORMATION TO
02:08:24.396 --> 02:08:27.800
FRACKING. COMPANY ASKS FROM YOU
02:08:27.866 --> 02:08:28.901
. HOWEVER FORTUNATELY TO ME
02:08:28.967 --> 02:08:30.235
REMOTE TRACKING COMPANIES THAT
02:08:30.302 --> 02:08:33.338
COLLECT. NONESSENTIAL BIOMETRIC
02:08:33.405 --> 02:08:34.940
INFORMATION INCLUDING FACIAL
02:08:35.007 --> 02:08:36.308
RECOGNITION TEMPLATES
02:08:36.375 --> 02:08:38.410
FINGERPRINTS THIS IS YOUR DATA
02:08:38.477 --> 02:08:39.378
MEDICAL INFORMATION BROWSING
02:08:39.445 --> 02:08:42.381
HISTORY VIDEO AND AUDIO OF THE
02:08:42.448 --> 02:08:44.183
USER AND THE SURROUNDINGS. AND
02:08:44.249 --> 02:08:46.652
THE CHALLENGES THAT WE HAVE A
02:08:46.718 --> 02:08:49.955
CALIFORNIA CONSUMER PRIVACY ACT-
02:08:50.022 --> 02:08:51.323
AND DEAD THEY'LL SAY WELL IT
02:08:51.390 --> 02:08:52.825
COVERS FRACKING COMPANIES BUT
02:08:52.891 --> 02:08:54.460
UNFORTUNATELY THE LAW DOES NOT
02:08:54.526 --> 02:08:56.028
ACTUALLY GIVE ME TO TOOLS TO
02:08:56.095 --> 02:08:57.763
STUDENTS BECAUSE THE PROPERTY
02:08:57.830 --> 02:08:59.498
COMPANIES EXPLOIT LOOPHOLES SAID
02:08:59.565 --> 02:09:00.766
WELL OUR CONTRACTS WITH THE
02:09:00.833 --> 02:09:03.268
SCHOOL OR THE YOU KNOW THE BAR
02:09:03.335 --> 02:09:05.104
WHERE IT IS WRITTEN IN THIS EXAM
02:09:05.170 --> 02:09:08.373
THAT THE STUDENT SO WE HAVE. TO
02:09:08.440 --> 02:09:09.241
A STUDENT COMPLAINTS THEY'RE
02:09:09.308 --> 02:09:10.476
LIKE WELL IT'S NOT OUR PROBLEM-
02:09:10.542 --> 02:09:12.044
YOU BECAUSE LARGE CONTRACTS WITH
02:09:12.111 --> 02:09:13.846
THE SCHOOL SO THEREFORE THAT
02:09:13.912 --> 02:09:16.081
LOOPHOLE PREVENTS A STUDENT FROM
02:09:16.148 --> 02:09:17.850
BEING ABLE TO PROTECT OUR OWN
02:09:17.916 --> 02:09:18.951
PRIVACY. AND AS RESULT HE'S
02:09:19.017 --> 02:09:19.952
TRACKING COMPANIES COLLECT
02:09:20.018 --> 02:09:21.720
STUDENTS PRIVATE INFORMATION AND
02:09:21.787 --> 02:09:23.222
HOLD THE DATA FOR FAR LONGER
02:09:23.288 --> 02:09:24.923
THAN IS NECESSARY TO ADMINISTER
02:09:24.990 --> 02:09:27.292
THE EXAM OR FOR OTHER PURPOSES
02:09:27.359 --> 02:09:28.527
AND THAT PUTS THE STUDENTS
02:09:28.594 --> 02:09:30.362
PRIVACY AT RISK UNFORTUNATELY
02:09:30.429 --> 02:09:32.464
PROVIDE BIOMETRIC DATA. YOU
02:09:32.531 --> 02:09:33.999
CANNOT CHANGE YOUR EYEBALL OR
02:09:34.066 --> 02:09:35.467
FINGERPRINT OR SOMETHING IF
02:09:35.534 --> 02:09:37.469
SOMEONE STEALS- THAT THAT DATE
02:09:37.536 --> 02:09:41.874
IS SOLD. TO SOMEONE ELSE THE
02:09:41.940 --> 02:09:43.442
DATABROKER. SO THIS BILLS GIVING
02:09:43.509 --> 02:09:45.010
ARE STILL TO PROTECT OWN PERSON
02:09:45.077 --> 02:09:45.544
FROM. TO REQUIRE PRACTICE
02:09:45.611 --> 02:09:47.246
COMPANIES TO BE TRANSPARENT
02:09:47.312 --> 02:09:49.948
ABOUT THE DATA COLLECTION. AND
02:09:50.015 --> 02:09:52.217
LIMITED TO WHATEVER'S NECESSARY
02:09:52.284 --> 02:09:53.785
TO ACTUALLY CONDUCT THE EXAM SO
02:09:53.852 --> 02:09:55.254
THEY DO NOT TO THE LIKING EXCESS
02:09:55.320 --> 02:09:57.156
DATA. AND THEN RESELLING THAT
02:09:57.222 --> 02:09:59.024
DATA TO OTHERS. AND SO IT THAT
02:09:59.091 --> 02:10:01.260
THIS IS THE ESSENTIAL TOOL FOR
02:10:01.326 --> 02:10:03.262
PROTECTING OUR STUDENTS PRIVACY.
02:10:03.328 --> 02:10:04.897
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
02:10:04.963 --> 02:10:06.365
VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR PAN
02:10:06.431 --> 02:10:08.200
MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
02:10:08.267 --> 02:10:10.836
SEEN HEARING THEN MADAM
02:10:10.903 --> 02:10:11.703
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:10:11.770 --> 02:10:17.142
ALLEN I ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
02:10:17.209 --> 02:10:22.414
BATES NO BAKER. I PORCHES NO
02:10:22.481 --> 02:10:25.450
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
02:10:25.517 --> 02:10:30.556
CORTESE AYE DALY NO DODD.
02:10:30.622 --> 02:10:35.561
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER.
02:10:35.627 --> 02:10:40.165
GONZALEZ I GROW NO HERTZBERG
02:10:40.232 --> 02:10:45.204
WESTERN I FURTADO AYE JONES NO
02:10:45.270 --> 02:10:49.975
KAMLAGER I LAYERED I LEYVA AYE
02:10:50.042 --> 02:10:54.446
THE MON I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
02:10:54.513 --> 02:11:00.953
NO MAN. NEWMAN I NIELSEN NO A
02:11:01.019 --> 02:11:03.722
SHOW OF BOTH NO PAN AYE
02:11:03.789 --> 02:11:09.328
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH. I RUBIO I
02:11:09.394 --> 02:11:13.699
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE NUMBER I
02:11:13.765 --> 02:11:16.969
LIKE HOUSE SPEAKER I WIENER AYE
02:11:17.035 --> 02:11:20.038
WILK NO THIS CALL THE ABSENT
02:11:20.105 --> 02:11:24.209
MEMBERS DODD. GLAZER HERTZBERG
02:11:24.276 --> 02:11:29.248
MEN. I TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS NINE
02:11:29.314 --> 02:11:30.315
THE MEASURE PASSES WE WERE
02:11:30.382 --> 02:11:32.651
REMOVING TO OF- ITEM FORTY SEVEN
02:11:32.718 --> 02:11:34.052
SENATOR UMBERG MA'AM SECRETARY
02:11:34.119 --> 02:11:36.989
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL ELEVEN
02:11:37.055 --> 02:11:39.591
NINETY SIX BY SENATOR UMBERG AN
02:11:39.658 --> 02:11:40.492
ACT RELATING TO TRANSPORTATION
02:11:40.559 --> 02:11:42.761
CINEMARK- THANK YOU BETTER
02:11:42.828 --> 02:11:45.864
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES- SPL LEVIN
02:11:45.931 --> 02:11:47.099
NINETY SIX THE DISTRICT BILL
02:11:47.165 --> 02:11:49.034
THAT SO FAR AS I KNOW HIS NO
02:11:49.101 --> 02:11:50.435
OPPOSITION IN SUPPORT FROM LOS
02:11:50.502 --> 02:11:52.137
ANGELES. ORANGE COUNTY'S
02:11:52.204 --> 02:11:53.538
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES
02:11:53.605 --> 02:11:55.073
COUNCIL TEAMSTERS AND OTHER
02:11:55.140 --> 02:11:56.808
LOCAL ENTITIES IT INCREASES
02:11:56.875 --> 02:11:58.610
TRANSPORTATION FUNDING FOR THE
02:11:58.677 --> 02:12:00.379
ANAHEIM TRANSPORTATION NETWORK.
02:12:00.445 --> 02:12:02.481
WHICH IS EIGHT RECOGNIZE PUBLIC
02:12:02.547 --> 02:12:04.416
TRANSPORTATION PROVIDER BY. BOTH
02:12:04.483 --> 02:12:05.884
US DEPARTMENT TRANSPORTATION
02:12:05.951 --> 02:12:07.319
CITY OF ANAHEIM IS A CRITICAL
02:12:07.386 --> 02:12:08.320
PART OF THE REGIONAL
02:12:08.387 --> 02:12:10.155
TRANSPORTATION SYSTEM. IT
02:12:10.222 --> 02:12:11.957
OPERATES THE LARGEST FLEET OF
02:12:12.024 --> 02:12:13.191
ZERO EMISSION BUSES IN SOUTHERN
02:12:13.258 --> 02:12:15.560
CALIFORNIA PLANS TO HAVE A 100%
02:12:15.627 --> 02:12:17.129
ELECTRIC FLEET BY TWENTY TWENTY
02:12:17.195 --> 02:12:20.198
FIVE- THE ATS EXISTS RIGHT NOW
02:12:20.265 --> 02:12:23.101
HAS HAS A GOVERNANCE BODY. THAT
02:12:23.168 --> 02:12:25.704
IS OT OVERSEEN BY GOVERNMENTAL
02:12:25.771 --> 02:12:27.572
ELECTED OFFICIALS THIS BILL
02:12:27.639 --> 02:12:29.808
CHANGES THAT SO THAT THE-
02:12:29.875 --> 02:12:31.943
GOVERNMENT STRUCTURE DOES. HAVE
02:12:32.010 --> 02:12:33.912
A- ELECTED OFFICIAL
02:12:33.979 --> 02:12:37.582
RESPONSIBILITY ACCOUNTABILITY
02:12:37.649 --> 02:12:39.051
COMPONENT TO AN ORIGINAL VOTE.
02:12:39.117 --> 02:12:39.818
THANK YOU CENTER AMBERG
02:12:39.885 --> 02:12:41.453
DISCUSSION OR TO. SEEING AND
02:12:41.520 --> 02:12:42.554
HEARING THEN MA'AM SECRETARY
02:12:42.621 --> 02:12:46.692
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
02:12:46.758 --> 02:12:50.796
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
02:12:50.862 --> 02:12:57.069
BACKER I PORCHES. BRADFORD AYE
02:12:57.135 --> 02:13:00.305
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
02:13:00.372 --> 02:13:07.779
DALLY. DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN
02:13:07.846 --> 02:13:12.818
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
02:13:12.884 --> 02:13:17.222
HERTZBERG WESSEL I FURTADO I
02:13:17.289 --> 02:13:22.094
JONES I KAMLAGER. AYE LAYERED
02:13:22.160 --> 02:13:28.066
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN. MCGUIRE AYE
02:13:28.133 --> 02:13:33.438
MELENDEZ. MANY AYE NEWMAN AYE
02:13:33.505 --> 02:13:40.078
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED. PAN I
02:13:40.145 --> 02:13:45.951
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO. I
02:13:46.017 --> 02:13:51.556
SKINNER I STERN I AM BURKE I
02:13:51.623 --> 02:13:55.627
FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE WILK
02:13:55.694 --> 02:13:58.430
I. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
02:13:58.497 --> 02:14:06.438
MEMBERS. BATES FORTUS. DALLY
02:14:06.505 --> 02:14:35.534
GROVE. HERTZBERG LIMÓN. MELENDEZ. A TOTAL OF A.
02:14:40.439 --> 02:14:41.640
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
02:14:41.706 --> 02:14:47.679
BATES FORTUS VALLEY GROVE
02:14:47.746 --> 02:14:52.117
HERTZBERG LIMÓN HI MELENDEZ A
02:14:52.184 --> 02:14:55.454
CHOI BOGUE. IS THIRTY TWO KNOWS
02:14:55.520 --> 02:14:57.122
ONE THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
02:14:57.189 --> 02:14:59.591
REMOVING THE FILE ITEM FORTY
02:14:59.658 --> 02:15:01.193
EIGHT SENATOR HER TADO THEM
02:15:01.259 --> 02:15:02.894
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
02:15:02.961 --> 02:15:04.830
BILL TWELVE NINETEEN BY SENATOR
02:15:04.896 --> 02:15:06.765
HER TADO AN ACT RELATING TO
02:15:06.832 --> 02:15:09.100
WATER CENTER TACO THANK YOU
02:15:09.167 --> 02:15:11.203
MATTER PRESENT TODAY I RISE TO
02:15:11.269 --> 02:15:12.904
PRESENT SB TWELVE NINETEEN ALSO
02:15:12.971 --> 02:15:14.372
KNOWN AS THE STATE WATER
02:15:14.439 --> 02:15:15.173
RESILIENCY AND MODERNIZATION
02:15:15.240 --> 02:15:18.276
ACT. SB TWELVE NINETEEN
02:15:18.343 --> 02:15:19.978
PRIORITIZES THE PRESERVATION AND
02:15:20.045 --> 02:15:21.980
SUSTAINABILITY OF WATER USAGE
02:15:22.047 --> 02:15:23.215
AND ENSURES THAT WATER IS
02:15:23.281 --> 02:15:26.518
PROTECTED FOR FUTURE FOR FUTURE
02:15:26.585 --> 02:15:29.421
GENERATIONS OF USE. THE CENTRAL
02:15:29.488 --> 02:15:30.489
VALLEY IS REALLY FROM WATER
02:15:30.555 --> 02:15:32.190
DELIVERY SHORTEST ROUTE AND
02:15:32.257 --> 02:15:34.092
DAMAGE WATER INFRASTRUCTURE
02:15:34.159 --> 02:15:36.127
ALONG WITH MANY OTHER PARTS OF
02:15:36.194 --> 02:15:38.396
THE STATE AND WESTERN STATE WITH
02:15:38.463 --> 02:15:39.397
LITTLE TO NO RAIN A BELOW
02:15:39.464 --> 02:15:41.466
AVERAGE SNOWPACK IT IS CLEAR WE
02:15:41.533 --> 02:15:43.134
ARE HEADED TO ANOTHER YEAR. OF A
02:15:43.201 --> 02:15:44.736
DROUGHT A DROP THE WILL FURTHER
02:15:44.803 --> 02:15:47.138
DISRUPT THE SUPPLY CHAIN. AND
02:15:47.205 --> 02:15:49.241
LEAD TO INCREASES IN THE COST OF
02:15:49.307 --> 02:15:50.842
FOOD ONE THAT WILL AFFECT OUR
02:15:50.909 --> 02:15:52.477
FAMILIES FARMS AND WALLETS.
02:15:52.544 --> 02:15:54.012
THERE IS NO QUICK FIX TO THIS
02:15:54.079 --> 02:15:56.147
PROBLEM PROBLEM OUR CLIMATE IS
02:15:56.214 --> 02:15:57.916
CONTINUING TO CHANGE. AND THE
02:15:57.983 --> 02:15:59.518
RAMIFICATIONS OF THAT CHANGE ARE
02:15:59.584 --> 02:16:01.553
BEING FELT ACROSS CALIFORNIA NOW
02:16:01.620 --> 02:16:03.622
WITH WATER RESTRICTIONS AS WELL
02:16:03.688 --> 02:16:05.457
. IN MY HUMBLE OPINION A LARGE
02:16:05.524 --> 02:16:07.192
PART OF THE IMPACTS OF DRUG IS
02:16:07.259 --> 02:16:09.194
DUE TO AN ANTIQUATED WATER
02:16:09.261 --> 02:16:11.463
SYSTEM THAT HAS LED TO. A THE
02:16:11.530 --> 02:16:12.664
MISMANAGEMENT OF OUR MOST
02:16:12.731 --> 02:16:14.099
PRECIOUS PRECIOUS NATURAL
02:16:14.165 --> 02:16:16.935
RESOURCE WHICH IS WATER. I WANT
02:16:17.002 --> 02:16:18.303
TO MAKE A POINT OF NOTING THAT
02:16:18.370 --> 02:16:20.038
THIS IS A- THE FIRST TIME I
02:16:20.105 --> 02:16:22.107
PARTNERED UP IN VERY PROMPTLY.
02:16:22.173 --> 02:16:24.109
TO DO SO WITH A MEMBER OF THE
02:16:24.175 --> 02:16:25.243
LEGISLATION WATER DOES NOT FROM
02:16:25.310 --> 02:16:28.680
THE CENTRAL VALLEY- AND- AND
02:16:28.747 --> 02:16:30.181
THAT IS BECAUSE WATER SECURITY
02:16:30.248 --> 02:16:32.117
IS NOT JUST A CENTRAL VALLEY
02:16:32.183 --> 02:16:33.985
ISSUE ALTHOUGH I HAVE. BEEN VERY
02:16:34.052 --> 02:16:36.054
OUTSPOKEN ABOUT THAT FOR THE
02:16:36.121 --> 02:16:38.557
LAST THREE YEARS. AND IT'S NOT
02:16:38.623 --> 02:16:40.025
JUST A CALIFORNIA ISSUE IT'S A
02:16:40.091 --> 02:16:42.961
GLOBAL ISSUE. REPORT AFTER
02:16:43.028 --> 02:16:45.030
REPORT ALSO THAT WATER SCARCITY
02:16:45.096 --> 02:16:46.364
NEEDS TO BE EXAMINED IN THE
02:16:46.431 --> 02:16:48.333
NEXUS FRAMEWORK ALONG WITH FOOD
02:16:48.400 --> 02:16:52.671
HEALTH ENERGY AND SECURITY. A
02:16:52.737 --> 02:16:53.171
TWENTY TWELVE COMMUNITY
02:16:53.238 --> 02:16:54.372
INTELLIGENCE ASSESSMENT REPORT
02:16:54.439 --> 02:16:56.007
ON THE STATE OF GLOBAL WATER
02:16:56.074 --> 02:16:57.709
SECURITY INDICATED. THAT IN THE
02:16:57.776 --> 02:16:59.544
NEXT TEN YEARS MANY COUNTRIES
02:16:59.611 --> 02:17:01.780
IMPORTANT TO THE UNITED STATES
02:17:01.846 --> 02:17:02.280
WE'RE EXPERIENCING WATER
02:17:02.347 --> 02:17:06.017
PROBLEMS SHORTAGE SHORTAGES POOR
02:17:06.084 --> 02:17:07.986
WATER QUALITY OR FLOODS THAT
02:17:08.053 --> 02:17:09.754
WILL RISKY INSTABILITY AND
02:17:09.821 --> 02:17:11.790
CRITICALLY TO STATE FAILURE AND
02:17:11.856 --> 02:17:14.326
SOME NATIONS. INCREASED REGIONAL
02:17:14.392 --> 02:17:16.161
TENSIONS AND DISTRACT THEM FROM
02:17:16.227 --> 02:17:18.229
WORKING WITH THE UNITED STATES
02:17:18.296 --> 02:17:20.832
OR WITH EACH OTHER IMPORTANT US
02:17:20.899 --> 02:17:23.401
POLICY OBJECTIVES. THE REPORT
02:17:23.468 --> 02:17:25.003
ALSO STATED THAT THE DEPLETION
02:17:25.070 --> 02:17:26.338
OF GROUNDWATER SUPPLIES AND SOME
02:17:26.404 --> 02:17:29.074
AGRICULTURAL AREAS OWING TO POOR
02:17:29.140 --> 02:17:30.609
WATER MANAGEMENT WILL POSE A
02:17:30.675 --> 02:17:33.111
RISK TO BOTH NATIONAL AND GLOBAL
02:17:33.178 --> 02:17:36.481
FOOD MARKETS. LAST YEAR THE
02:17:36.548 --> 02:17:38.717
SENATE MADE. AN UNPRECEDENTED
02:17:38.783 --> 02:17:39.951
INVESTMENTS IN OUR WATER
02:17:40.018 --> 02:17:41.786
INFRASTRUCTURE AND CONSTRUCTION
02:17:41.853 --> 02:17:43.688
HAS ALREADY BEGUN TO REPAIR THE
02:17:43.755 --> 02:17:45.457
STATE'S WATER CONVEYANCE SYSTEMS
02:17:45.523 --> 02:17:46.725
ONE OF THE BEST INVESTMENTS WE
02:17:46.791 --> 02:17:48.360
CAN MAKE TO CONSERVE THE LIMITED
02:17:48.426 --> 02:17:49.628
WATER WE HAVE BEEN DELIVERED TO
02:17:49.694 --> 02:17:51.663
COMMUNITIES ACROSS THE STATE NOT
02:17:51.730 --> 02:17:54.733
JUST THE VALLEY. TO COMBAT THIS
02:17:54.799 --> 02:17:56.835
UNCERTAINTY CENTER OR TO THE AND
02:17:56.901 --> 02:17:58.069
I HARD WORKING TO PROVE THE
02:17:58.136 --> 02:17:59.671
TRANSPARENCY THOUGHTFULNESS AND
02:17:59.738 --> 02:18:01.306
EFFICIENCY OF HOW DECISIONS
02:18:01.373 --> 02:18:03.274
SURROUNDING WATER MADE. TODAY
02:18:03.341 --> 02:18:04.309
THERE TOO MANY GOVERNMENT
02:18:04.376 --> 02:18:06.244
ENTITIES THAT EACH DEAL WITH THE
02:18:06.311 --> 02:18:07.112
PEACE OF WATER MANAGEMENT WITH
02:18:07.178 --> 02:18:08.213
SIMILAR BUT SOMETIMES
02:18:08.279 --> 02:18:15.754
CONFLICTING GOALS. AND THOSE. AS
02:18:15.820 --> 02:18:17.555
AS WELL AS AGRICULTURE ARE TOO
02:18:17.622 --> 02:18:18.923
OFTEN NOT PART OF THE DECISION
02:18:18.990 --> 02:18:20.792
MAKING PROCESS AS IT STANDS
02:18:20.859 --> 02:18:21.559
TODAY. MANY PEOPLE WHOSE
02:18:21.626 --> 02:18:22.794
LIVELIHOOD AND THE HEALTH
02:18:22.861 --> 02:18:24.329
DEPENDS ON THIS WATER ARE NOT
02:18:24.396 --> 02:18:26.698
INVITED OR WALKING AT THE TABLE
02:18:26.765 --> 02:18:28.333
THIS IS SOMETHING WE MUST FIX.
02:18:28.400 --> 02:18:30.368
AND MODERNIZE PEOPLE WHO ARE
02:18:30.435 --> 02:18:32.504
IMPACTED BY THESE DECISIONS HAVE
02:18:32.570 --> 02:18:33.138
A RIGHT TO BE INVOLVED IN THE
02:18:33.204 --> 02:18:36.207
PROCESS. MODERNIZING IN TWENTY
02:18:36.274 --> 02:18:37.108
TWENTY TWO MEANS INCREASING
02:18:37.175 --> 02:18:39.377
TRANSPARENCY AND EXTENDING WAYS
02:18:39.444 --> 02:18:40.879
FOR PEOPLE TO NAVIGATE PROCESSES
02:18:40.945 --> 02:18:43.014
AND PROCEDURES. ESPECIALLY WHEN
02:18:43.081 --> 02:18:44.449
IT COMES TO YOUR WATER
02:18:44.516 --> 02:18:46.951
CURTAILMENTS. MODERNIZING MEANS
02:18:47.018 --> 02:18:48.720
THAT WE HAVE BETTER CONTROL OF
02:18:48.787 --> 02:18:50.889
WATER FEE INCREASES. MODERNIZE
02:18:50.955 --> 02:18:52.657
THE MEANS THAT WE DO BETTER
02:18:52.724 --> 02:18:53.892
PROVIDING CLEAN DRINKING WATER
02:18:53.958 --> 02:18:55.293
FOR ALL AND THAT WE DON'T TO
02:18:55.360 --> 02:18:57.562
LADIES PROJECTS OUR MOST
02:18:57.629 --> 02:18:58.530
VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES.
02:18:58.596 --> 02:19:00.231
MODERNIZING MEANS THAT WE HAVE
02:19:00.298 --> 02:19:02.400
CYBER SECURITY ACROSS OUR WATER
02:19:02.467 --> 02:19:04.035
SYSTEM THAT ACKNOWLEDGES THE NEW
02:19:04.102 --> 02:19:06.571
ERA OF CYBER WARFARE WHERE WE
02:19:06.638 --> 02:19:07.839
ARE IN TODAY AND HEALTH THIS
02:19:07.906 --> 02:19:09.407
COULD BE USED AS A WEAPON
02:19:09.474 --> 02:19:11.976
AGAINST US. MODERNIZING IN
02:19:12.043 --> 02:19:13.144
TWENTY TWENTY TWO MEANS
02:19:13.211 --> 02:19:14.713
INCREASING TRANSPARENCY AND
02:19:14.779 --> 02:19:15.847
EXTENDING WAYS FOR PEOPLE TO.
02:19:15.914 --> 02:19:17.415
NAVIGATE THIS COMPLICATED
02:19:17.482 --> 02:19:19.617
PROCESS. ESPECIALLY WHEN IT
02:19:19.684 --> 02:19:22.721
COMES ONCE AGAIN TO OUR WATER TO
02:19:22.787 --> 02:19:24.322
CURTAILMENTS SB TWELVE NINETY
02:19:24.389 --> 02:19:25.356
ONE PROVE OUR WATER MANAGEMENT
02:19:25.423 --> 02:19:27.158
BY CREATING A COMMITTEE THAT
02:19:27.225 --> 02:19:28.727
WILL PROVIDE GUIDANCE. FOR A
02:19:28.793 --> 02:19:30.729
MORE INTEGRATED WATER MANAGEMENT
02:19:30.795 --> 02:19:33.298
FRAMEWORK. COLLEAGUES FOR WATER
02:19:33.364 --> 02:19:35.400
MANAGEMENT MAKES US ALL
02:19:35.467 --> 02:19:36.868
VULNERABLE AND THREATENS. OUR
02:19:36.935 --> 02:19:38.403
DEMOCRACY AND OUR VERY OWN
02:19:38.470 --> 02:19:41.573
EXISTENCE WE MUST MATER NICE
02:19:41.639 --> 02:19:43.141
WATER NOW BEING CAN I RESPECT
02:19:43.208 --> 02:19:45.076
LAST FOR MY BOAT THANK YOU
02:19:45.143 --> 02:19:46.177
CENTER HER TADO MEMBERS
02:19:46.244 --> 02:19:48.847
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE SENATOR
02:19:48.913 --> 02:19:50.682
NIELSEN. MADAM PRESIDENT AND
02:19:50.749 --> 02:19:52.951
LADIES AND OF THE SENATE. I
02:19:53.017 --> 02:19:55.787
CERTAINLY DO AND DOURSON WILL
02:19:55.854 --> 02:19:58.056
SUPPORT THIS BILL BY MY
02:19:58.123 --> 02:19:59.924
COLLEAGUE FROM SHANKER. BY THE
02:19:59.991 --> 02:20:03.194
WAY MY COLLEAGUES THANK GOD I
02:20:03.261 --> 02:20:06.164
HAIL FROM THE SAME HOMETOWN.
02:20:06.231 --> 02:20:08.066
THERE ARE SOME CONCERNS I HAVE
02:20:08.133 --> 02:20:12.303
YET WITH THE BILL. FIRST OF ALL
02:20:12.370 --> 02:20:14.506
WE'RE OF POINTING AND EMPOWERING
02:20:14.572 --> 02:20:16.508
AGENCIES OF STATE GOVERNMENT AND
02:20:16.574 --> 02:20:19.611
THEY MORE OFTEN THAN NOT ARE THE
02:20:19.677 --> 02:20:20.578
BIGGEST PROBLEM. AND HAVE BEEN
02:20:20.645 --> 02:20:23.782
RELATED TO WATER SPECIFICALLY.
02:20:23.848 --> 02:20:26.084
TO WHAT ONE. THE OROVILLE DAM
02:20:26.151 --> 02:20:28.486
SPILLWAY FAILURE WAS THE FAILURE
02:20:28.553 --> 02:20:31.956
OF STATE GOVERNMENT FOR DECADES
02:20:32.023 --> 02:20:33.892
NOT ATTENDING TO. THE
02:20:33.958 --> 02:20:36.895
MAINTENANCE AND INSPECTION OF
02:20:36.961 --> 02:20:41.232
THAT VERY CRITICAL RESOURCE. NOW
02:20:41.299 --> 02:20:43.501
THIS ADVISED AND THEN APPOINT
02:20:43.568 --> 02:20:45.670
THE AGENCIES OF GOVERNMENT CAN
02:20:45.737 --> 02:20:48.173
APPOINT. KIND OF A CITIZENS
02:20:48.239 --> 02:20:51.342
ADVISORY. I'VE BEEN DOWN THIS
02:20:51.409 --> 02:20:54.245
TRAIL. I WANTED TO MAJOR BILLS
02:20:54.312 --> 02:20:55.680
ONE TO MANAGE THE SACRAMENTO
02:20:55.747 --> 02:21:00.485
RIVER. AND ONE TO OVERSEE THE
02:21:00.552 --> 02:21:03.688
SALARIES AND CONVEYANCE OF THE
02:21:03.755 --> 02:21:06.825
OROVILLE DAM. WHAT'S DIFFERENT
02:21:06.891 --> 02:21:09.928
ABOUT THAT PRIOR LEGISLATION.
02:21:09.994 --> 02:21:13.832
THE COMMUNITY. THE CITIZENS
02:21:13.898 --> 02:21:16.100
DIRECTLY AREN'T APPOINTED PART
02:21:16.167 --> 02:21:20.171
OF. THESE ENTITIES WORKING WITH
02:21:20.238 --> 02:21:22.941
THE ENTITIES OF STATE GOVERNMENT
02:21:23.007 --> 02:21:24.843
. HEREWE ARE GIVING THOSE
02:21:24.909 --> 02:21:26.978
AGENCIES FAR TOO MUCH POWER
02:21:27.045 --> 02:21:30.248
ALMOST DANGEROUS POWER BECAUSE
02:21:30.315 --> 02:21:31.950
OF HOW THEIR FAILURES. IN THE
02:21:32.016 --> 02:21:36.654
PAST. I WOULD ALSO REMIND THE
02:21:36.721 --> 02:21:40.124
BODY I BELIEVE WAS TWO THOUSAND
02:21:40.191 --> 02:21:42.794
AND TEN. A NEW WATER PLAN FOR
02:21:42.861 --> 02:21:47.665
CALIFORNIA. WAS PUT INTO STATUTE
02:21:47.732 --> 02:21:50.001
. IT CHANGE LONG HELD DYNAMICS
02:21:50.068 --> 02:21:51.970
THAT EVERYTHING ABOUT WATER WAS
02:21:52.036 --> 02:21:54.806
ABOUT THE DELTA. NOW FOR NUMBER
02:21:54.873 --> 02:21:56.808
OF YEARS I WAS A DELTA CENTER I
02:21:56.875 --> 02:21:59.043
KNOW THE DELTA I LOVE THE DELTA.
02:21:59.110 --> 02:22:00.712
BUT EVERYTHING ABOUT WATER IS
02:22:00.778 --> 02:22:03.448
NOT RELATED TO THE DAY AFTER.
02:22:03.514 --> 02:22:05.717
THERE'S A NORTH. OR SOUTH
02:22:05.783 --> 02:22:07.385
THERE'S A CENTRAL AS MY
02:22:07.452 --> 02:22:08.887
COLLEAGUE FROM SANDERS
02:22:08.953 --> 02:22:12.957
ARTICULATED. EAST AND WEST THE
02:22:13.024 --> 02:22:16.995
WATER. IN CALIFORNIA FOR DECADES
02:22:17.061 --> 02:22:18.329
IN WATER POLICY HAS NOT
02:22:18.396 --> 02:22:19.330
RECOGNIZED THAT CRITICAL
02:22:19.397 --> 02:22:22.100
DIFFERENT. THE AGENCIES ARE
02:22:22.166 --> 02:22:23.735
STATE GOVERNMENT I WILL ARGUE
02:22:23.801 --> 02:22:27.305
HAVE NOT EITHER. BEING
02:22:27.372 --> 02:22:30.475
PREOCCUPIED OR OVERLY FOCUSED ON
02:22:30.541 --> 02:22:33.778
THE DAY OF. THIS IS IMPORTANT
02:22:33.845 --> 02:22:36.981
LEGISLATION. IT IS WORTHY OF
02:22:37.048 --> 02:22:40.151
SUPPORT. BUT AS IT MOVES ALONG I
02:22:40.218 --> 02:22:44.355
WOULD SUGGEST MY COLLEAGUE. PUT
02:22:44.422 --> 02:22:48.259
THE CITIZENS THE PRIVATE SECTOR
02:22:48.326 --> 02:22:50.395
. I REQUEST TO. WITH THE
02:22:50.461 --> 02:22:51.496
AGENCIES OF GOVERNMENT NOT
02:22:51.562 --> 02:22:56.501
SUPPOSE TO. OR AT THE MERCY OF
02:22:56.567 --> 02:23:01.739
THOSE A- THAT SAID I I'VE- THANK
02:23:01.806 --> 02:23:02.974
YOU CENTER NEAR SENATOR TO
02:23:03.041 --> 02:23:08.079
RUSSELL. THANK YOU- MADAM I JUST
02:23:08.146 --> 02:23:09.380
IF I HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE
02:23:09.447 --> 02:23:11.349
AUTHOR. CENTER TOTALLY TAKE A
02:23:11.416 --> 02:23:15.887
QUESTION. YES PLEASE PROCEED
02:23:15.954 --> 02:23:19.223
THANK YOU I KNOW THE AUTHOR HAS
02:23:19.290 --> 02:23:21.159
. EIGHT PASSION FOR THE ISSUE OF
02:23:21.225 --> 02:23:22.694
WATER PARTICULARLY IN THE
02:23:22.760 --> 02:23:25.330
CENTRAL VALLEY- THOSE OF US IN
02:23:25.396 --> 02:23:27.332
METROPOLITAN AREAS ALSO HAVE A
02:23:27.398 --> 02:23:31.102
BIG PASSION FOR. CLEAN AND SAFE
02:23:31.169 --> 02:23:32.770
WATER AND AS I'VE BEEN TOLD
02:23:32.837 --> 02:23:34.272
THERE ARE MILLION PEOPLE MILLION
02:23:34.339 --> 02:23:36.307
CALIFORNIANS WHO DON'T HAVE
02:23:36.374 --> 02:23:39.010
ACCESS TO CLEAN AND SAFE WATER
02:23:39.077 --> 02:23:41.012
I'D LIKE TO IF THE AUTHOR COULD
02:23:41.079 --> 02:23:42.347
JUST EXPLAIN A LITTLE BIT ABOUT.
02:23:42.413 --> 02:23:46.784
HOW THIS NEW. GOVERNANCE SORT
02:23:46.851 --> 02:23:49.020
SYSTEM OR STRUCTURE WOULD REALLY
02:23:49.087 --> 02:23:53.658
ADDRESS THE INEQUALITIES- THAT
02:23:53.725 --> 02:23:55.093
MILLIONS OF CALIFORNIANS ARE
02:23:55.159 --> 02:23:57.495
FACING WHETHER IT BE IN
02:23:57.562 --> 02:23:59.897
METROPOLITAN AREA LIKE SOUTHERN
02:23:59.964 --> 02:24:01.833
CALIFORNIA AND CENTRAL VALLEY
02:24:01.899 --> 02:24:04.068
BUT IT NOT JUST WHAT WE DO WITH
02:24:04.135 --> 02:24:06.270
WATER. THERE IS ENORMOUS
02:24:06.337 --> 02:24:10.541
INEQUITIES- AND HOW WILL THIS
02:24:10.608 --> 02:24:13.678
ADDRESS THE INEQUITIES THANK YOU
02:24:13.745 --> 02:24:14.846
. SENATOR HER TADO PLEASE
02:24:14.912 --> 02:24:16.681
PROCEED WHEN YOU'RE READY THANK
02:24:16.748 --> 02:24:18.349
YOU FOR THE QUESTION I BROKE MY
02:24:18.416 --> 02:24:19.550
MICROPHONE- SO NERVOUS ABOUT
02:24:19.617 --> 02:24:22.487
LIKE YOUR QUESTION BUT- NO I
02:24:22.553 --> 02:24:24.122
THINK THIS IS A THIS IS A GREAT
02:24:24.188 --> 02:24:26.657
QUESTION THAT YOU ANSWER AND-
02:24:26.724 --> 02:24:29.494
AND I'LL SAY THAT THIS BILL- IT
02:24:29.560 --> 02:24:32.063
REALLY LOOKS TO MODERNIZE WATER.
02:24:32.130 --> 02:24:33.064
AND NOT JUST FOR THE CENTRAL
02:24:33.131 --> 02:24:35.199
VALLEY. I DON'T WANT THE WATER
02:24:35.266 --> 02:24:36.934
JUST TO WORK FOR THE CENTRAL
02:24:37.001 --> 02:24:39.003
VALLEY I WANTED TO WORK FOR ALL
02:24:39.070 --> 02:24:42.507
CALIFORNIA. AND WE GOTTA HAVE A
02:24:42.573 --> 02:24:45.209
BETTER SYSTEM IN PLACE SO THAT.
02:24:45.276 --> 02:24:46.944
WERE ALL ABLE TO HAVE ACCESS TO
02:24:47.011 --> 02:24:48.713
THAT WATER SO THAT COMMUNITIES
02:24:48.780 --> 02:24:51.015
IN. YOUR COMMUNITIES IN YOUR-
02:24:51.082 --> 02:24:53.918
DISK. AB SENATE DISTRICT DON'T
02:24:53.985 --> 02:24:55.019
GO WITHOUT WATER IN THAT COULD
02:24:55.086 --> 02:24:57.789
BE A REAL POSSIBILITY THIS YEAR
02:24:57.855 --> 02:24:59.624
. AND IT END ALTHOUGH I DON'T
02:24:59.690 --> 02:25:01.292
REPRESENT YOUR REGION IT
02:25:01.359 --> 02:25:02.860
FRIGHTENS ME TO DEATH THAT
02:25:02.927 --> 02:25:06.064
ANYONE IN THIS STATE WOULD GO
02:25:06.130 --> 02:25:07.198
WITHOUT WATER WHEN WE KNOW WE
02:25:07.265 --> 02:25:09.600
CAN. YOU KNOW REALLY MAXIMIZE
02:25:09.667 --> 02:25:11.569
THE LIMIT YOU THE INCREASINGLY
02:25:11.636 --> 02:25:13.738
LIMITED WATER THAT WE HAVE SO
02:25:13.805 --> 02:25:15.306
THAT WE ALL HAVE ACCESS TO IT
02:25:15.373 --> 02:25:18.309
BUT- BECAUSE IT THERE'S THE-
02:25:18.376 --> 02:25:19.977
THERE'S I THINK ABOUT A LITTLE
02:25:20.044 --> 02:25:21.846
OVER TWENTY DIFFERENT ENTITIES
02:25:21.913 --> 02:25:24.382
THAT. THAT GOVERNOR AND TOUCH
02:25:24.449 --> 02:25:26.951
WATER US SOMEHOW IT COMPLICATES
02:25:27.018 --> 02:25:28.686
IT IT MAKES IT MORE DIFFICULT
02:25:28.753 --> 02:25:30.555
FOR YOUR COMMUNITIES AND MY AND
02:25:30.621 --> 02:25:32.723
MY COMMUNITIES TO. TO HAVE
02:25:32.790 --> 02:25:35.526
ACCESS TO THE- THE FUNDS IN THE
02:25:35.593 --> 02:25:37.128
TOOLS AND THE RESOURCES THAT
02:25:37.195 --> 02:25:40.598
THEY NEED TO BE ABLE TO HAVE
02:25:40.665 --> 02:25:41.766
ACCESS TO CLEAN WATER. AND SO
02:25:41.833 --> 02:25:43.334
YOU'RE TO THE POINT THAT I MADE
02:25:43.401 --> 02:25:45.303
EARLIER. THIS IS THE FIRST TIME
02:25:45.369 --> 02:25:46.504
THAT I ACTUALLY PARTNERED ON ON
02:25:46.571 --> 02:25:47.939
A BILL THAT WITH WITH A
02:25:48.005 --> 02:25:49.907
COLLEAGUE THAT HAS COMPLETELY
02:25:49.974 --> 02:25:50.808
DIFFERENT VIEWS IT WOULD
02:25:50.875 --> 02:25:52.343
PROBABLY WHEN IT COMES ALL
02:25:52.410 --> 02:25:54.178
THINGS OF WATER. A DAY AND THEN-
02:25:54.245 --> 02:25:56.514
THAN THOSE THAT I YOUR THAN THE
02:25:56.581 --> 02:25:57.381
PEOPLE THAT I REPRESENT AND MY
02:25:57.448 --> 02:25:59.250
SENATE DISTRICT IN THE CENTRAL
02:25:59.317 --> 02:26:00.084
VALLEY THAT'S BECAUSE WATER IS
02:26:00.151 --> 02:26:01.752
NOT JUST ABOUT THE CENTRAL
02:26:01.819 --> 02:26:03.955
VALLEY. IT'S ABOUT PEOPLE AND
02:26:04.021 --> 02:26:06.157
IT'S ABOUT MAKING SURE THAT WE
02:26:06.224 --> 02:26:07.558
HAVE ENOUGH WATER FOR THE
02:26:07.625 --> 02:26:11.395
ENTIRE- AT FOR THE ENTIRE STATE
02:26:11.462 --> 02:26:12.363
I MEAN WHO WOULD EVER THOUGHT
02:26:12.430 --> 02:26:14.866
THAT. WE WOULD NEED TO UP CYBER
02:26:14.932 --> 02:26:18.970
SECURITY TO PROTECT OUR DAMS AND
02:26:19.036 --> 02:26:21.572
TO PROTECT- IT WATER TREATMENT
02:26:21.639 --> 02:26:23.708
PLANT. I DON'T THINK THAT WHEN
02:26:23.774 --> 02:26:25.977
ALL THESE DIFFERENT LAWS THAT
02:26:26.043 --> 02:26:27.745
WERE BEING ESTABLISHED THAT WE
02:26:27.812 --> 02:26:28.813
WOULD EVEN THINK THAT INTERNET
02:26:28.880 --> 02:26:29.914
WOULD PLAY A ROLE IN THAT
02:26:29.981 --> 02:26:31.682
HACKERS WOULD. POTENTIALLY BE
02:26:31.749 --> 02:26:33.684
WILL PLAY A ROLE IN IN IN WATER
02:26:33.751 --> 02:26:35.920
SECURITY AND THIS IS WHAT THIS
02:26:35.987 --> 02:26:37.155
BILL IS REALLY LOOKING AT YOU
02:26:37.221 --> 02:26:40.124
MEAN. TO DO- AND MODERNIZING
02:26:40.191 --> 02:26:44.529
WATER- AND- AND YOU KNOW. I'LL
02:26:44.595 --> 02:26:46.631
JUST KIND OF ALSO ADDRESSED WHAT
02:26:46.697 --> 02:26:49.267
A- MIKE MY COLLEAGUE FROM
02:26:49.333 --> 02:26:51.135
FORMALLY FINGER- MENTIONED
02:26:51.202 --> 02:26:53.971
EARLIER THAT YEAR IS A LITTLE
02:26:54.038 --> 02:26:55.606
BIT CONCERNED ABOUT. YOUR THAT
02:26:55.673 --> 02:26:58.609
THE AGENCY'S PLANE HADN'T HAVING
02:26:58.676 --> 02:27:02.013
CONTROL AND SAY OVER- THE
02:27:02.079 --> 02:27:03.915
DECISION ABOUT WHAT THE- YOU
02:27:03.981 --> 02:27:06.751
KNOW THE WATER OR THE FUTURE
02:27:06.817 --> 02:27:08.119
WATER LOOKS LIKE AND HOW TO.
02:27:08.186 --> 02:27:10.054
LOOK AT IT IN IN CALIFORNIA AND
02:27:10.121 --> 02:27:12.256
IN THAT I HAVE THOSE CONCERNS TO
02:27:12.323 --> 02:27:14.759
BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT THERE'S AN
02:27:14.825 --> 02:27:17.495
APP A PROCESS IN THIS BILL THAT
02:27:17.562 --> 02:27:19.096
WOULD ALLOW. YES STAKEHOLDERS
02:27:19.163 --> 02:27:21.832
OUTSIDE OF THE AGENCIES TO BE
02:27:21.899 --> 02:27:25.236
ABLE TO PLAY AN IMPORTANT ROLE
02:27:25.303 --> 02:27:26.571
AND WE ALL. THE GOAL IS
02:27:26.637 --> 02:27:27.471
EVERYBODY TO COME TOGETHER TO
02:27:27.538 --> 02:27:29.574
MAKE IT AT TO PROVIDE EIGHTY
02:27:29.640 --> 02:27:33.211
FUTURE THAT WE CAN ALL BENEFIT
02:27:33.277 --> 02:27:35.379
FROM. THANK YOU SIR HER TADO.
02:27:35.446 --> 02:27:40.518
DRAW SO. JUST SET A FINAL
02:27:40.585 --> 02:27:41.352
COMMENT I SEE THE- MANY IN THE
02:27:41.419 --> 02:27:43.788
OP. OR THAT WEWITH THAT ARE.
02:27:43.854 --> 02:27:49.093
YOU KNOW OUR LA. THAT WE COUNT
02:27:49.160 --> 02:27:51.395
ON AND DEPEND. FOR THE OF THE-
02:27:51.462 --> 02:27:53.097
THAT WE IN OUR- SO I WOULD. URGE
02:27:53.164 --> 02:27:55.266
THE AUTHOR CONTINUE TO WORK WITH
02:27:55.333 --> 02:27:56.267
THEM ON THEIR PARTICULAR-
02:27:56.334 --> 02:27:57.101
CONCERNS THAT THEY HAVE RAISED
02:27:57.168 --> 02:27:58.736
ON EVERYONE'S BEHALF THANK YOU.
02:27:58.803 --> 02:28:00.171
THANK YOU CENTER DORADO SENATOR
02:28:00.238 --> 02:28:02.707
STERN. THANK YOU REPRESENT I WAS
02:28:02.773 --> 02:28:11.449
NOT TO SPEAK BUT THEY- I WANTED. THE HARD WORK OF MY COLLEAGUES
02:28:11.515 --> 02:28:13.217
HERE AND IT'S TRUE AT AS CHAIR
02:28:13.284 --> 02:28:15.786
THE WATER COMMITTEE WE DID- TRY
02:28:15.853 --> 02:28:18.456
TO HELP HER GET TO SOMEPLACE OF
02:28:18.522 --> 02:28:20.324
A OF A CONSTRUCTIVE PIECE OF
02:28:20.391 --> 02:28:21.926
LEGISLATION WHAT I WILL SAY IS.
02:28:21.993 --> 02:28:27.398
AT THE PREMISE OF THE BILL- IN A
02:28:27.465 --> 02:28:29.166
PART OF THE REASON IT A LOT OF
02:28:29.233 --> 02:28:30.201
PEOPLE STILL HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT
02:28:30.268 --> 02:28:33.638
IS. STARS A BILL. NOT UNLIKE A
02:28:33.704 --> 02:28:34.705
DEBATE HAD EARLIER WHERE IT'S
02:28:34.772 --> 02:28:36.374
VERY EASY TO BLAME THE AGENCY.
02:28:36.440 --> 02:28:38.209
WHEN YOU'RE BLAMING CAL JAM FOR
02:28:38.276 --> 02:28:40.778
THE- THE PROBLEM IS A BIG OIL OR
02:28:40.845 --> 02:28:42.680
YOU'RE BLAMING THE WATER BOARD
02:28:42.747 --> 02:28:45.249
FOR AN UNSUSTAINABLE APPROACH.
02:28:45.316 --> 02:28:47.285
TO CORPORATIONS TAKING UP.
02:28:47.351 --> 02:28:51.055
BLOWING PEOPLES WATER- THERE IS
02:28:51.122 --> 02:28:53.291
A FUNDAMENTALLY. AND I THINK
02:28:53.357 --> 02:28:55.159
THAT. YOU KNOW WE TRIED TO PUT
02:28:55.226 --> 02:28:58.329
FORWARD- WORKING WITH THE
02:28:58.396 --> 02:29:00.431
AUTHOR. THE COMMISSION PROCESS
02:29:00.498 --> 02:29:02.066
THAT HOPEFULLY STARTS TO.
02:29:02.133 --> 02:29:03.701
RESTORE SOME AT BALANCER
02:29:03.768 --> 02:29:05.303
INITIATE THAT CONVERSATION BUT I
02:29:05.369 --> 02:29:09.206
WILL SAY- YOU KNOW I FEEL LIKE
02:29:09.273 --> 02:29:12.243
AS A COMMITTEE WE DID OUR PART-
02:29:12.310 --> 02:29:15.146
ENDS. I WOULD I WOULD NOT- BE
02:29:15.212 --> 02:29:16.681
URGING MEMBERS ONE WAY OR
02:29:16.747 --> 02:29:18.849
ANOTHER ON THIS VOTE. BUT AS FAR
02:29:18.916 --> 02:29:21.485
AS I'M MY OWN PERSONAL VIEWS ON
02:29:21.552 --> 02:29:24.755
THIS I DO THINK THE GOVERNOR IS
02:29:24.822 --> 02:29:26.657
LEGISLATURE WE HAVE EXISTING
02:29:26.724 --> 02:29:28.826
TOOLS TO LOOK AT A LOT OF THIS
02:29:28.893 --> 02:29:32.096
VISION RIGHT NOW- SO I WON'T BE
02:29:32.163 --> 02:29:35.166
SUPPORTING THE MEASURE TODAY-
02:29:35.232 --> 02:29:37.835
BUT I DO APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S
02:29:37.902 --> 02:29:39.203
WILLINGNESS TO WORK ON BEHALF OF
02:29:39.270 --> 02:29:42.173
OUR COMMUNITY- BUT- WITHOUT SOME
02:29:42.239 --> 02:29:47.278
FURTHER. THAT EQUITY. I'M
02:29:47.345 --> 02:29:48.346
ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE WITH YOU
02:29:48.412 --> 02:29:51.549
ANY SUPPORTER VILLE OR LA. BUT
02:29:51.615 --> 02:29:53.217
THOSE ARE GOING TO BE AT THE OF
02:29:53.284 --> 02:29:54.652
THIS- I'M CONCERNED THAT YOU
02:29:54.719 --> 02:29:56.153
KNOW WE'RE JUST GONNA STUDY
02:29:56.220 --> 02:29:57.121
FURTHER AND FURTHER AND NOT
02:29:57.188 --> 02:29:59.490
REALLY MAKE PROGRESS BUT- I KNOW
02:29:59.557 --> 02:30:00.991
THE AUTHOR GOING TO DIG IN HERE
02:30:01.058 --> 02:30:02.727
AND DO THAT WORK SO- JUST TO
02:30:02.793 --> 02:30:06.897
GIVE SOME KIND. IN Y. I'LL BE A
02:30:06.964 --> 02:30:08.866
TO. THANK YOU CENTER STERN
02:30:08.933 --> 02:30:11.669
SENATOR CORTESE. THANK YOU MR
02:30:11.736 --> 02:30:16.073
PRESIDENT TO. ARISE IN OF THE
02:30:16.140 --> 02:30:20.344
PRO CO AUTHOR OF THIS BILL- IN
02:30:20.411 --> 02:30:22.680
IOWA JUST SIX THINGS THAT IT CAN
02:30:22.747 --> 02:30:25.249
. OF ONE OF THEM- AS TO ONE OF
02:30:25.316 --> 02:30:27.818
OUR CALL FROM LOS ANGELES- THE
02:30:27.885 --> 02:30:29.954
BILL SETS UP ACTUALLY NOT ONLY
02:30:30.020 --> 02:30:33.791
ONE COMMITTEE BUT- A BLUE RIBBON
02:30:33.858 --> 02:30:36.694
COMMISSION OF CITIZENS-
02:30:36.761 --> 02:30:38.462
RESIDENTS OF THE CITY CALIFORNIA
02:30:38.529 --> 02:30:41.365
TO HELP DIRECT INPUT- IN
02:30:41.432 --> 02:30:43.367
ADDITION TO A MORE FORMAL GROUP
02:30:43.434 --> 02:30:44.735
COMPOSED OF AGENCIES AND
02:30:44.802 --> 02:30:47.138
COMPOSED OF MEMBERS OF THIS
02:30:47.204 --> 02:30:48.172
LEGISLATURE THAT WILL BE
02:30:48.239 --> 02:30:50.174
APPOINTED BY THE GOVERNOR. IT'S
02:30:50.241 --> 02:30:50.941
NOT OF THAT CHANGES THE
02:30:51.008 --> 02:30:52.710
GOVERNANCE THAT EXIST IN THE
02:30:52.777 --> 02:30:55.246
STATE OF CALIFORNIA ROLL TO
02:30:55.312 --> 02:30:56.714
WATER ANYTHING ELSE. ALBEIT
02:30:56.781 --> 02:30:58.849
UNDER THE ORIGINAL VERSION OF
02:30:58.916 --> 02:31:01.485
THE BILL DID ATTEMPT TO DO THAT
02:31:01.552 --> 02:31:02.787
THAT WAS AMENDED OUT. IN THE
02:31:02.853 --> 02:31:04.422
OPPOSITION WAS LISTEN TO NOT
02:31:04.488 --> 02:31:06.023
ONLY VERY CAREFULLY BUT- ALL BE
02:31:06.090 --> 02:31:08.092
CANDID IN OUR OWN CONVERSATIONS
02:31:08.159 --> 02:31:09.994
AS CO AUTHORS I INDICATED THAT
02:31:10.060 --> 02:31:11.896
IF- IF THE CONCERNS OF
02:31:11.962 --> 02:31:13.330
ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS WERE NOT
02:31:13.397 --> 02:31:15.132
ADDRESS. A PERSON PARTICULARLY
02:31:15.199 --> 02:31:17.535
THOSE THAT I WORK WITH FOR OVER
02:31:17.601 --> 02:31:19.203
TWENTY YEARS- AROUND THE BAY
02:31:19.270 --> 02:31:21.972
DELTA ESTUARY- THAT I'D BE OFF
02:31:22.039 --> 02:31:23.974
THE BILL MYSELF- BUT EVERY
02:31:24.041 --> 02:31:25.676
SINGLE ONE OF THOSE CONCERNS WAS
02:31:25.743 --> 02:31:27.611
A DRESS WITH A GOOD HELP. OF THE
02:31:27.678 --> 02:31:29.947
WATER COMMITTEE AND- OUR OTHER
02:31:30.014 --> 02:31:31.482
COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES AND
02:31:31.549 --> 02:31:33.484
IT'S VERY MUCH APPRECIATED. OF
02:31:33.551 --> 02:31:36.120
THE BILL WAS REWORKED TOP TO
02:31:36.187 --> 02:31:38.889
BOTTOM IN A WAY- THAT- I THINK
02:31:38.956 --> 02:31:41.592
DIRECT STAKEHOLDERS AND DIRECTS
02:31:41.659 --> 02:31:44.862
THE MULTIPLICITY. OF CONCERNS
02:31:44.929 --> 02:31:47.431
AROUND WATER IN THE STATE- TO A
02:31:47.498 --> 02:31:49.066
PLACE WHERE THEY CAN BE RESOLVED
02:31:49.133 --> 02:31:52.236
WEEK TAKE ON A THAT INPUT WE
02:31:52.303 --> 02:31:54.572
KNOW THAT WHO HAS A HISTORY OF
02:31:54.638 --> 02:31:56.474
THAT. NOT ONLY IN THE STATE OF
02:31:56.540 --> 02:31:58.709
CALIFORNIA BUT- THE- WEEK TAKE
02:31:58.776 --> 02:32:01.045
IT ON DIRECTLY AS A LEGISLATURE
02:32:01.111 --> 02:32:02.713
NO BILL IN THIS LEGISLATURE WILL
02:32:02.780 --> 02:32:06.217
EVER CAPTURE. IN RE. EVERY
02:32:06.283 --> 02:32:09.386
CONCERN SOUTH IS. NOW A WERE MY
02:32:09.453 --> 02:32:11.989
OWN CAL. BUT NOW IS DOWN TO
02:32:12.056 --> 02:32:14.391
DESPITE DESPITE THE FACT IT HAS
02:32:14.458 --> 02:32:16.794
ONE OF THE MOST SIGNIFICANT-
02:32:16.861 --> 02:32:20.064
LOCAL. OWNED RESERVOIR SYSTEMS
02:32:20.130 --> 02:32:22.266
BUT WITH NEARLY A HALF DOZEN
02:32:22.333 --> 02:32:24.435
STORES THIS GROUND HETCH HETCHY
02:32:24.502 --> 02:32:28.806
WATER- IN AND- UNTIL WATER IS
02:32:28.873 --> 02:32:31.509
WELL- THAT WE'RE DOWN TO TWENTY
02:32:31.575 --> 02:32:33.577
THREE PERCENT. OF WHAT WE NEED
02:32:33.644 --> 02:32:35.713
TO SURVIVE IN TERMS OF WATER-
02:32:35.779 --> 02:32:37.615
BUT I WANT TO BE SURE THAT IF
02:32:37.681 --> 02:32:39.049
YOU LOOK AT THE REQUIREMENTS
02:32:39.116 --> 02:32:40.851
THAT THE STRATEGIC VISION AND
02:32:40.918 --> 02:32:43.487
ONLY DROP STATUTES- BY THESE TWO
02:32:43.554 --> 02:32:46.891
GROUPS. WOULD WOULD INCLUDE- IT
02:32:46.957 --> 02:32:48.893
IT INCLUDES- WATER SUPPLY
02:32:48.959 --> 02:32:50.461
RELIABILITY IS NUMBER ONE AND
02:32:50.528 --> 02:32:52.496
WATER QUALITY IS NUMBER TWO.
02:32:52.563 --> 02:32:54.832
WATER DEPENDENT ECOSYSTEMS IS
02:32:54.899 --> 02:32:59.470
NUMBER THREE IN A. OF THE ISSUES
02:32:59.537 --> 02:33:00.838
OF A WILL BE ADDRESSED UNDER
02:33:00.905 --> 02:33:02.606
THAT SECTION THREE OF- OF THE
02:33:02.673 --> 02:33:06.644
BILL SO. I DO THINK THE CONCERNS
02:33:06.710 --> 02:33:08.279
OF EMBRACE HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED-
02:33:08.345 --> 02:33:09.914
I WAS ACTUALLY SURPRISED THE
02:33:09.980 --> 02:33:12.316
LAST POLICY COMMITTEE TO SEE.
02:33:12.383 --> 02:33:15.019
OPPOSITION NOT FORMALLY. IN ON
02:33:15.085 --> 02:33:17.555
THE BILL BUT I UNDERSTAND THIS
02:33:17.621 --> 02:33:18.622
SUBJECT MATTER IS ALWAYS GOING
02:33:18.689 --> 02:33:20.291
TO MAKE FOLKS. NERVOUS AND
02:33:20.357 --> 02:33:22.192
THAT'S WHY. AND THAT'S WHY IT
02:33:22.259 --> 02:33:25.529
WAS REQUIRED ON THIS BILL-
02:33:25.596 --> 02:33:28.032
REQUIRED OF THIS BILL IS NOT NEW
02:33:28.098 --> 02:33:31.201
GOVERNANCE- OR A KIND OF FINAL
02:33:31.268 --> 02:33:33.604
CODIFICATION OR STATUTORY. BUT
02:33:33.671 --> 02:33:38.242
SO RE. THAT ANY DRAFTS. SUGGEST
02:33:38.309 --> 02:33:40.778
COME BACK ONTO THE BODY- INTO
02:33:40.844 --> 02:33:44.248
THE OTHER HOUSE FOR-CONSIDERATION IN IF IT ISN'T
02:33:44.315 --> 02:33:46.183
TIME TO DO THAT I DON'T KNOW. A
02:33:46.250 --> 02:33:47.952
WIN IT EVER WILL BE I
02:33:48.018 --> 02:33:49.753
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
02:33:49.820 --> 02:33:51.555
YOU THANK CENTER. MEMBERS
02:33:51.622 --> 02:33:54.058
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR TO. C. IN
02:33:54.124 --> 02:33:55.159
HEARING THEM SENATOR HER TADO
02:33:55.225 --> 02:33:56.860
YOU MAY CLOSE RESPECT
02:33:56.927 --> 02:33:58.896
ASTRONOMICAL. BEEN SECRETARY
02:33:58.963 --> 02:34:03.434
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN
02:34:03.500 --> 02:34:09.406
ARCHULETA I AT AYE BATES AYE
02:34:09.473 --> 02:34:13.877
BAKER. GORGEOUS I BRADFORD
02:34:13.944 --> 02:34:17.915
MICROBIOTA AYE PROTESTING AYE
02:34:17.982 --> 02:34:23.554
DALY. GOD I THEY'RE AWESOME.
02:34:23.621 --> 02:34:28.292
EGGMAN NO GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ.
02:34:28.359 --> 02:34:32.963
GROVE I HERTZBERG WHAT. I FOR
02:34:33.030 --> 02:34:40.337
TODD HI JOHN. KAMLAGER LAYERED
02:34:40.404 --> 02:34:48.846
LEYVA NO LIMÓN. MCGUIRE. I
02:34:48.912 --> 02:34:56.353
MELENDEZ. MAN NO NEWMAN. NIELSEN
02:34:56.420 --> 02:34:59.757
HI A SHOW OF BOTH I PAN AYE
02:34:59.823 --> 02:35:05.195
PORTANTINO. I ROTH. I RUBIO AYE
02:35:05.262 --> 02:35:11.902
SKINNER. I STERN. I'M BURKE I BY
02:35:11.969 --> 02:35:17.875
CASTING. WIENER NO WILK. PLEASE
02:35:17.941 --> 02:35:22.312
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN
02:35:22.379 --> 02:35:29.053
BACKER. DALLY DURACELL GONZALEZ
02:35:29.119 --> 02:35:35.359
HERTZBERG JONES KAMLAGER NO
02:35:35.426 --> 02:35:42.132
LAYERED. LIMÓN MELENDEZ. NEWMAN
02:35:42.199 --> 02:35:48.839
NO. STERN WHITE HOUSE SKI WELL
02:35:48.906 --> 02:35:51.575
IS TWENTY ONE NO SIX THE MEASURE
02:35:51.642 --> 02:35:53.277
PASSES MEMBERS WERE ABOUT TO
02:35:53.343 --> 02:35:55.646
BREAK FOR LUNCH BUT PART OF
02:35:55.713 --> 02:35:56.613
BREAKING FOR LUNCH WE'RE GOING
02:35:56.680 --> 02:35:57.381
TO MOTIONS AND RESIDENT
02:35:57.448 --> 02:35:59.450
RESOLUTION SENATOR CROWE THANK
02:35:59.516 --> 02:36:00.884
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT RESPECTFULLY
02:36:00.951 --> 02:36:03.587
I ASKED REQUEST SB NINE EIGHTY
02:36:03.654 --> 02:36:04.488
SIX FILE NUMBER TWO THIRTY
02:36:04.555 --> 02:36:06.056
THREE- BE REMOVED FROM THE
02:36:06.123 --> 02:36:08.492
CONSENT CALENDAR THE DESK WILL
02:36:08.559 --> 02:36:10.227
NOTE THANK YOU MA'AM. CENTER
02:36:10.294 --> 02:36:13.430
DRAWS A SORRY PRESS I WOULD TO
02:36:13.497 --> 02:36:15.232
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST TO PULL.
02:36:15.299 --> 02:36:18.736
ITEM NUMBER ONE SIX THREE SB
02:36:18.802 --> 02:36:20.370
NINE TWO FOUR AND- FILE NUMBER
02:36:20.437 --> 02:36:22.372
TWO TWO THREE SB FOUR EIGHT FOUR
02:36:22.439 --> 02:36:24.608
SIX FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR.
02:36:24.675 --> 02:36:27.010
THANK YOU SENATOR DRAWS OF
02:36:27.077 --> 02:36:29.446
SENATOR MCGUIRE. PLEASE FOR THE
02:36:29.513 --> 02:36:31.048
PRESIDENT TO ATTACK TO
02:36:31.115 --> 02:36:32.750
RESPECTFULLY REQUESTED TO REMOVE
02:36:32.816 --> 02:36:35.486
FILE ITEM FORTY S. C. TEN
02:36:35.552 --> 02:36:37.054
SEVENTY FIVE I LIKE TO MOVE FILE
02:36:37.121 --> 02:36:38.889
ITEM FORTY SB TEN SEVENTY FOUR
02:36:38.956 --> 02:36:40.224
TO THE INACTIVE FILE. THANK YOU
02:36:40.290 --> 02:36:43.160
SENATOR- ACQUIRE SENATOR NEWMAN-
02:36:43.227 --> 02:36:44.762
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I'D
02:36:44.828 --> 02:36:48.532
LIKE TO REQUEST TO MOVE AB TEN
02:36:48.599 --> 02:36:50.300
THIRTY SEVEN FIVE ITEM A TO- ON
02:36:50.367 --> 02:36:52.569
BEHALF OF ITS MEANT GRAYSON FOR
02:36:52.636 --> 02:36:56.073
THE PURPOSE OF AMENDMENT. THANK
02:36:56.140 --> 02:36:57.574
YOU SENATE-ROOM ANY ELSE. ALL
02:36:57.641 --> 02:36:59.042
RIGHT SEEN HERE NO ONE MEMBERS
02:36:59.109 --> 02:37:01.044
WE ARE GOING TO BREAK. CENTER
02:37:01.111 --> 02:37:07.251
PAN. WHAT WAS ON- I WANT FULL.
02:37:07.317 --> 02:37:11.088
AND WHICH MICHAEL. YES YES THANK
02:37:11.155 --> 02:37:13.524
YOU I WISH TO MOVE MOVE I THINK
02:37:13.590 --> 02:37:15.025
IS ITEM TWO FORTY FIVE FROM THE
02:37:15.092 --> 02:37:17.094
CONSENT CALENDAR THANK YOU THANK
02:37:17.161 --> 02:37:18.295
YOU THE DESK WILL NOTE ART
02:37:18.362 --> 02:37:20.631
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A
02:37:20.697 --> 02:37:21.965
BREAK FOR LUNCH WE WILL BE BACK
02:37:22.032 --> 02:37:24.368
HERE IN CHAMBERS AT ONE FORTY
02:37:24.434 --> 02:37:26.603
FIVE AND WE WILL START VOTING AT
02:37:26.670 --> 02:37:28.038
ONE FORTY FIVE SO PLEASE BE ON
02:37:28.105 --> 02:37:46.924
TIME.
02:38:17.454 --> 02:38:19.456
SENATOR NEWMAN I KNOW THAT YOU
02:38:19.523 --> 02:38:21.525
WERE HERE CENTER BRADFORD IS
02:38:21.592 --> 02:38:22.793
HERE THOUGH CENTER BRADFORD
02:38:22.860 --> 02:38:25.128
WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE UP. HOLD
02:38:25.195 --> 02:38:28.732
ON LET ME GET BACK TO YOUR BILL
02:38:28.799 --> 02:38:30.400
. ALL RIGHT FILE ITEM SIXTY FOUR
02:38:30.467 --> 02:38:32.102
SENATOR GLAZERS WHAT WE'RE GOING
02:38:32.169 --> 02:38:33.036
TO START WITH MADAM SECRETARY
02:38:33.103 --> 02:38:35.505
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL
02:38:35.572 --> 02:38:36.306
FOURTEEN THIRTY NINE BY SENATOR
02:38:36.373 --> 02:38:38.008
GLAZER AN ACT RELATING TO THE
02:38:38.075 --> 02:38:40.244
POLITICAL REFORM ACT OF NINETEEN
02:38:40.310 --> 02:38:41.578
SEVENTY FOUR SENATOR GLAZERS
02:38:41.645 --> 02:38:42.546
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
02:38:42.613 --> 02:38:44.581
MEMBERS- SB FOURTEEN THIRTY
02:38:44.648 --> 02:38:46.950
NINE. WOULD ENSURE THE PAY TO
02:38:47.017 --> 02:38:48.952
PLAY PROHIBITIONS THAT APPLY TO
02:38:49.019 --> 02:38:50.454
STATE AGENCY APPOINTEES ARE
02:38:50.520 --> 02:38:52.756
APPOINTED LOCAL OFFICIALS. WHEN
02:38:52.823 --> 02:38:54.291
APPROVING A LICENSE PERMIT OR
02:38:54.358 --> 02:38:56.493
ENTITLEMENT FOR USE ALSO APPLY
02:38:56.560 --> 02:38:58.495
TO LOCAL ELECTED OFFICIALS WHEN
02:38:58.562 --> 02:39:01.265
ACTING IN IDENTICAL CAPACITY.
02:39:01.331 --> 02:39:02.866
THE LEVINE ACT PROHIBITS AN
02:39:02.933 --> 02:39:04.768
OFFICER OF AN AGENCY FROM
02:39:04.835 --> 02:39:06.103
ACCEPTING SOLICITING OR
02:39:06.169 --> 02:39:07.337
DIRECTING A CONTRIBUTION MORE
02:39:07.404 --> 02:39:09.072
THAN TWO HUNDRED FIFTY DOLLARS
02:39:09.139 --> 02:39:10.908
FROM ANY PARTY. PARTICIPANT OR
02:39:10.974 --> 02:39:11.875
THEIR AGENTS IN CERTAIN
02:39:11.942 --> 02:39:13.877
INSTANCES. WHEN THE OFFICER
02:39:13.944 --> 02:39:18.115
KNOWS OR HAS REASON TO KNOW THAT
02:39:18.181 --> 02:39:18.849
THE PARTICIPANT HAS FINANCIAL
02:39:18.916 --> 02:39:19.783
INTERESTS. THIS PROHIBITION IS
02:39:19.850 --> 02:39:21.084
IN EFFECT WHILE I PROCEEDING
02:39:21.151 --> 02:39:22.719
INVOLVING A LICENSE OR PERMIT.
02:39:22.786 --> 02:39:24.388
OR OTHER ENTITLEMENT FOR USE IS
02:39:24.454 --> 02:39:27.057
PENDING. AND FOR THREE MONTHS
02:39:27.124 --> 02:39:27.991
FOLLOWING THE DATE OF FINAL
02:39:28.058 --> 02:39:29.226
DECISION IS RENDERED. THIS
02:39:29.293 --> 02:39:31.094
PROHIBITION APPLIES TO STATE AND
02:39:31.161 --> 02:39:32.162
LOCAL AGENCIES COMPRISED OF
02:39:32.229 --> 02:39:33.931
APPOINTED OFFICIALS WHO MIGHT.
02:39:33.997 --> 02:39:35.832
BE RUNNING FOR OFFICE. HOWEVER
02:39:35.899 --> 02:39:37.901
UNDER CURRENT LAW LOCAL AGENCIES
02:39:37.968 --> 02:39:39.236
WHOSE MEMBERS ARE DIRECTLY
02:39:39.303 --> 02:39:40.704
ELECTED BY VOTERS. AND WHO MAY
02:39:40.771 --> 02:39:43.240
BE RUNNING FOR RE ELECTION ARE
02:39:43.307 --> 02:39:45.175
NOT INCLUDED IN THIS PROHIBITION
02:39:45.242 --> 02:39:46.443
. CURRENT STATE LAW COUNTER
02:39:46.510 --> 02:39:48.378
INTUITIVELY PERMITS LOCAL
02:39:48.445 --> 02:39:49.179
ELECTED OFFICIALS RUNNING FOR
02:39:49.246 --> 02:39:51.148
REELECTION. TO SOLICIT AND
02:39:51.214 --> 02:39:52.649
ACCEPT SIZEABLE CONTRIBUTIONS
02:39:52.716 --> 02:39:53.984
FROM THOSE WHO ARE SEEKING
02:39:54.051 --> 02:39:56.353
PERMITS OR LICENSES. BUT THEN
02:39:56.420 --> 02:39:57.254
PROHIBITS IDENTICAL
02:39:57.321 --> 02:39:58.722
CONTRIBUTIONS TO AN APPOINTED
02:39:58.789 --> 02:40:00.590
OFFICIAL RUNNING FOR OFFICE WHO
02:40:00.657 --> 02:40:02.125
IS ACTING EXACTLY THE SAME
02:40:02.192 --> 02:40:04.895
CAPACITY. SO WE'RE TRYING TO
02:40:04.962 --> 02:40:06.830
CLEAR UP THIS CONFUSION IN THE
02:40:06.897 --> 02:40:08.432
LAW- AND MAYBE MY STATEMENTS ARE
02:40:08.498 --> 02:40:09.499
CONFUSING USE THAT YOU JUST
02:40:09.566 --> 02:40:13.003
HEARD BUT- THE PROBLEM AS ITS
02:40:13.070 --> 02:40:14.304
ESSENCE IS THAT. ACTUAL INTEREST
02:40:14.371 --> 02:40:15.939
SEEKING INFLUENCE LOCAL DECISION
02:40:16.006 --> 02:40:18.375
MAKING- AS WE KNOW IS A LONG
02:40:18.442 --> 02:40:20.777
STANDING WELL DOCUMENTED IN REAL
02:40:20.844 --> 02:40:23.347
PROBLEM. LET ME GIVE YOU AN
02:40:23.413 --> 02:40:25.415
EXAMPLE- IN TWO THOUSAND
02:40:25.482 --> 02:40:26.850
EIGHTEEN AND TWO THOUSAND TWENTY
02:40:26.917 --> 02:40:29.386
MORE THAN 30% OF THE ROUGHLY
02:40:29.453 --> 02:40:30.320
HUNDRED TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND
02:40:30.387 --> 02:40:30.754
DOLLARS IN CAMPAIGN
02:40:30.821 --> 02:40:31.922
CONTRIBUTIONS TO CURRENT
02:40:31.989 --> 02:40:33.590
HUNTINGTON PARK CITY COUNCIL
02:40:33.657 --> 02:40:34.825
MEMBERS CAME FROM EIGHT
02:40:34.891 --> 02:40:36.426
COMPANIES AND THEIR EXECUTIVES.
02:40:36.493 --> 02:40:38.061
WITH PENDING REQUESTS FOR
02:40:38.128 --> 02:40:39.863
CONTRACTS WITH THE CITY. AND OF
02:40:39.930 --> 02:40:41.331
COURSE THAT'S THE PURPOSE OF
02:40:41.398 --> 02:40:43.033
THIS BILL TO PROHIBIT THAT
02:40:43.100 --> 02:40:44.334
CIRCUMSTANCE FROM HAPPENING TO
02:40:44.401 --> 02:40:47.037
LOCAL OFFICIALS. NOW IN ADDITION
02:40:47.104 --> 02:40:48.739
TO THE PROHIBITION ON
02:40:48.805 --> 02:40:49.673
CONTRIBUTIONS. THIS FOR BILL
02:40:49.740 --> 02:40:51.208
REQUIRES AN ADDITIONAL
02:40:51.274 --> 02:40:53.210
DISCLOSURE PRIOR TO PROCEEDING
02:40:53.276 --> 02:40:55.679
BY THE PARTIES- IT ALSO EXPANDS
02:40:55.746 --> 02:40:57.114
THE CONTRIBUTION PROHIBITION TO
02:40:57.180 --> 02:40:59.616
INCLUDE SPOUSES- AND IT INCLUDES
02:40:59.683 --> 02:41:01.585
A TIME FRAME EXPANDED TIME FRAME
02:41:01.651 --> 02:41:02.619
FOR WHEN A- SPECIFIC
02:41:02.686 --> 02:41:03.653
CONTRIBUTION WOULD NOT BE
02:41:03.720 --> 02:41:06.656
ALLOWED. WE WANT OUR- LOCAL
02:41:06.723 --> 02:41:08.025
OFFICIALS TO HAVE CONFIDENCE IN
02:41:08.091 --> 02:41:08.925
THEIR COMMUNITY AND THE
02:41:08.992 --> 02:41:10.761
DECISIONS THAT THEY MAKE CLOSING
02:41:10.827 --> 02:41:12.362
THIS PAY TO PLAY LOOPHOLE WOULD
02:41:12.429 --> 02:41:13.063
PROVIDE THAT APPROPRIATE
02:41:13.130 --> 02:41:14.898
ACCOUNTABILITY. WITH THAT
02:41:14.965 --> 02:41:16.500
RESPECTFULLY ASTRONAUT VOTE.
02:41:16.566 --> 02:41:17.901
THANK YOU CENTER GLAZER MEMBERS
02:41:17.968 --> 02:41:20.937
DISCUSSION AND DEBATE SENATOR
02:41:21.004 --> 02:41:25.776
STERN. THANK YOU MEMBERS I RISE
02:41:25.842 --> 02:41:26.410
IN SUPPORT OF THIS MEASURE. AND
02:41:26.476 --> 02:41:28.345
IF I PROVIDE JUST A BRIEF MOMENT
02:41:28.412 --> 02:41:30.080
OF SOME PERSONAL TESTIMONY ON
02:41:30.147 --> 02:41:32.215
THIS IS SOMEBODY WHO'S- HOLDING
02:41:32.282 --> 02:41:34.184
THIS OFFICE WHILE TRYING TO LOOK
02:41:34.251 --> 02:41:37.187
AT A LOCAL OFFICE IN- IN THE
02:41:37.254 --> 02:41:39.556
TRANSACTIONAL NATURE OF WHAT'S
02:41:39.623 --> 02:41:41.058
HAPPENING IN OUR CITIES AND
02:41:41.124 --> 02:41:42.959
COUNTIES RIGHT NOW WHERE PEOPLE
02:41:43.026 --> 02:41:45.762
HAVE PROJECTS. BEFORE BOARD OF
02:41:45.829 --> 02:41:48.065
SUPERVISORS ARE BEFORE CITY
02:41:48.131 --> 02:41:50.967
COUNCILS- THE PAY TO PLAY A GAME
02:41:51.034 --> 02:41:53.804
IS VERY REAL AND ANYONE WHO
02:41:53.870 --> 02:41:55.939
DECIDES NOT TO BE A PART OF THAT
02:41:56.006 --> 02:41:58.108
GAME. OR SAYS THEY WON'T CLOSE
02:41:58.175 --> 02:41:58.809
KINDS OF CONTRIBUTIONS IS PUT IS
02:41:58.875 --> 02:42:03.380
AT A SIGNIFICANT DISADVANTAGE-
02:42:03.447 --> 02:42:03.847
THE RIGHT THING TO DO
02:42:03.914 --> 02:42:06.817
NONETHELESS BUT THE LAW TO
02:42:06.883 --> 02:42:08.852
RECOGNIZE THAT RIGHT. AND FOR
02:42:08.919 --> 02:42:11.588
THAT REASON I RISE IN SUPPORT.
02:42:11.655 --> 02:42:12.355
THANK YOU CENTER STERN SENATOR
02:42:12.422 --> 02:42:14.324
GONZALEZ. THANK YOU MADAM
02:42:14.391 --> 02:42:16.626
PRESIDENT I TO RISE AND- STRONG
02:42:16.693 --> 02:42:18.962
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL- I THINK
02:42:19.029 --> 02:42:21.698
THE GOOD SENATOR FROM. A CONTRA
02:42:21.765 --> 02:42:23.967
COSTA FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD.
02:42:24.034 --> 02:42:26.837
AND I BELIEVE IN THIS- TIME OF-
02:42:26.903 --> 02:42:28.071
NEEDING EVEN MORE PUBLIC
02:42:28.138 --> 02:42:29.573
TRANSPARENCY AND TRUST AND
02:42:29.639 --> 02:42:31.141
ENSURING THAT OUR ELECTED
02:42:31.208 --> 02:42:33.143
OFFICIALS ARE WORKING WITH-
02:42:33.210 --> 02:42:35.245
WITHIN THAT INTEGRITY AND TRUST
02:42:35.312 --> 02:42:36.246
THAT WE CONTINUE TO PUSH THESE
02:42:36.313 --> 02:42:38.115
TYPES OF. OF BILLS FOR IT SO
02:42:38.181 --> 02:42:40.183
WITH THAT I URGE MY VOTE AS
02:42:40.250 --> 02:42:41.451
WELL. THANK YOU CENTER GONZALEZ
02:42:41.518 --> 02:42:42.919
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
02:42:42.986 --> 02:42:45.155
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING ANSWER
02:42:45.222 --> 02:42:46.590
BECAUSE I WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE
02:42:46.656 --> 02:42:47.991
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THANK
02:42:48.058 --> 02:42:49.526
THE SENATOR. FROM LONG BEACH AND
02:42:49.593 --> 02:42:51.695
LOS ANGELES FOR THEIR KIND
02:42:51.761 --> 02:42:52.462
WORDS. YOU KNOW THAT THE HEART
02:42:52.529 --> 02:42:54.464
OF WHAT WE DO IS GETS TRUST AND
02:42:54.531 --> 02:42:56.066
CONFIDENCE THAT THE WORK THAT WE
02:42:56.133 --> 02:42:57.033
DO IS. BEING DONE FOR ALL THE
02:42:57.100 --> 02:43:00.170
RIGHT REASONS. AND UNFORTUNATELY
02:43:00.237 --> 02:43:02.005
WE HAVE A PRACTICE PATTERN OF
02:43:02.072 --> 02:43:03.240
WHERE THAT HASN'T BEEN DONE
02:43:03.306 --> 02:43:04.975
RIGHT. THIS BILL IS GOING TO
02:43:05.041 --> 02:43:06.676
PROVIDE CLARITY ON EXACTLY WHAT
02:43:06.743 --> 02:43:08.345
THOSE RULES ARE SO THAT OUR
02:43:08.411 --> 02:43:10.313
LOCAL OFFICIALS CAN DO THE RIGHT
02:43:10.380 --> 02:43:13.350
THING. I THINK MANY EMAIL ME ON
02:43:13.416 --> 02:43:15.452
THE FLOOR. HAS BEEN. TO ME AS
02:43:15.519 --> 02:43:17.654
BEING A VERY STRONG OF LOCAL
02:43:17.721 --> 02:43:19.222
CONTROL AND THIS IS A SPACE- IN
02:43:19.289 --> 02:43:20.790
THOSE RARE INSTANCES WHERE THE
02:43:20.857 --> 02:43:22.959
STATE SHOULD STEP IN WITH CLEAR
02:43:23.026 --> 02:43:23.727
STANDARDS WITHOUT RESPECTFULLY
02:43:23.793 --> 02:43:26.463
ASK FOR NIGHT OF. THANK CENTER
02:43:26.530 --> 02:43:27.864
GLAZER MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE
02:43:27.931 --> 02:43:31.535
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
02:43:31.601 --> 02:43:36.907
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS. EIGHT
02:43:36.973 --> 02:43:41.311
BAKER I FOR JUST. BRADFORD HI
02:43:41.378 --> 02:43:44.881
CABALLERO PROTECTING AYE TALLY.
02:43:44.948 --> 02:43:50.620
DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
02:43:50.687 --> 02:43:55.825
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
02:43:55.892 --> 02:44:00.297
HERTZBERG WESTERN HI FURTADO.
02:44:00.363 --> 02:44:06.736
JONES KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED AYE
02:44:06.803 --> 02:44:10.173
LEYVA AYE THE MOMENT I MCGUIRE
02:44:10.240 --> 02:44:15.278
AYE MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN I
02:44:15.345 --> 02:44:20.784
NIELSEN A CHOI BOGUE. PAN AYE
02:44:20.850 --> 02:44:26.856
PORTANTINO. RALPH HI RUBIO AYE
02:44:26.923 --> 02:44:32.429
SKINNER I STERN AYE NUMBER HI MY
02:44:32.495 --> 02:44:38.034
COUNTY I WIENER AYE WILK HI.
02:44:38.101 --> 02:44:39.703
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
02:44:39.769 --> 02:44:45.242
ATKINS FAITH. FOR JUST.
02:44:45.308 --> 02:44:55.518
CABALLERO. HI I DALY I. GROVE
02:44:55.585 --> 02:45:00.790
HERTZBERG FURTADO JONES.
02:45:00.857 --> 02:45:05.328
MELENDEZ I NIELSEN OSHO A VOGUE
02:45:05.395 --> 02:45:11.568
I. PORTANTINO. SENATORS I AM
02:45:11.635 --> 02:45:13.670
DISHEARTENED TO TELL YOU WE'RE
02:45:13.737 --> 02:45:15.772
GOING TO MOVE A CALL. NOT MY
02:45:15.839 --> 02:45:17.574
PLAN BUT YOU KNOW WE DON'T ALL
02:45:17.641 --> 02:45:19.109
GET TO MAKE THE RULES WE'RE
02:45:19.175 --> 02:45:21.111
GOING BACK TO FILE ITEM FORTY
02:45:21.177 --> 02:45:23.280
NINE SENATOR CABALLERO. MEN
02:45:23.346 --> 02:45:25.649
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
02:45:25.715 --> 02:45:27.117
BILL TWELVE THIRTY ONE BY
02:45:27.183 --> 02:45:28.652
SENATOR CABALLERO AN ACT
02:45:28.718 --> 02:45:30.520
RELATING TO PUBLIC HEALTH CENTER
02:45:30.587 --> 02:45:33.556
CABALLERO. THANK YOU MADAM
02:45:33.623 --> 02:45:36.393
PRESIDENT THANK YOU FOR THE
02:45:36.459 --> 02:45:39.296
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT S. B.
02:45:39.362 --> 02:45:39.896
TWELVE THIRTY ONE WHICH WILL
02:45:39.963 --> 02:45:41.831
EDUCATE AND PROTECT CALIFORNIANS
02:45:41.898 --> 02:45:43.967
AGAINST VALLEY FEVER AN
02:45:44.034 --> 02:45:46.202
INCURABLE DISEASE THAT IS
02:45:46.269 --> 02:45:48.038
PREVALENT IN MANY AREAS OF OUR
02:45:48.104 --> 02:45:50.006
COUNTRY. VALLEY FEVER IS A
02:45:50.073 --> 02:45:52.309
RESPIRATORY DISEASE CAUSED BY A
02:45:52.375 --> 02:45:54.577
SOIL DWELLING FUNGUS COMMONLY
02:45:54.644 --> 02:45:56.279
FOUND IN CALIFORNIA'S CENTRAL
02:45:56.346 --> 02:45:57.480
VALLEY AND THE AMERICAN
02:45:57.547 --> 02:46:00.216
SOUTHWEST IT APPEARS AS IF THIS
02:46:00.283 --> 02:46:02.352
FUNGUS HAS SPREAD DUE TO CLIMATE
02:46:02.419 --> 02:46:06.890
CHANGE. SB TWENTY ONE THIRTY
02:46:06.956 --> 02:46:08.258
TWELVE THIRTY ONE WILL ADDRESS
02:46:08.325 --> 02:46:09.693
AN INFORMATION RESOURCE GAP BY
02:46:09.759 --> 02:46:11.594
PROVIDING A DIAGNOSTIC GUIDE FOR
02:46:11.661 --> 02:46:14.064
VALLEY FEVER FOR PHYSICIANS AND
02:46:14.130 --> 02:46:15.598
HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS IN
02:46:15.665 --> 02:46:17.100
CALIFORNIA. SPECIFICALLY
02:46:17.167 --> 02:46:19.936
SPECIFICALLY THE BILL WILL AID
02:46:20.003 --> 02:46:21.304
PHYSICIANS AND HEALTH CARE
02:46:21.371 --> 02:46:23.173
WORKERS IN IDENTIFYING VALLEY
02:46:23.239 --> 02:46:24.908
FEVER EARLY BY COMPILING THE
02:46:24.974 --> 02:46:27.210
LATEST PUBLIC HEALTH IMMUNITY
02:46:27.277 --> 02:46:30.246
IMMUNOLOGY AND CLINICAL RESEARCH
02:46:30.313 --> 02:46:32.349
WITH BEST PRACTICES INTO A GUIDE
02:46:32.415 --> 02:46:34.417
THAT IS DIGESTIBLE TO THE PUBLIC
02:46:34.484 --> 02:46:36.453
AND USEFUL WITHIN THE MEDICAL
02:46:36.519 --> 02:46:37.954
FIELD. ADDITIONALLY THE
02:46:38.021 --> 02:46:39.756
DIAGNOSTIC GUIDE WILL BE MULTI
02:46:39.823 --> 02:46:41.758
LINGUAL TERRIFIC REFLECT
02:46:41.825 --> 02:46:43.493
CALIFORNIA'S DIVERSE COMMUNITIES
02:46:43.560 --> 02:46:44.594
WE MUST FARM HEALTH CARE
02:46:44.661 --> 02:46:45.962
PRACTITIONERS WITH CULTURALLY
02:46:46.029 --> 02:46:48.998
RELEVANT RESOURCES TO DISRUPT IN
02:46:49.065 --> 02:46:50.800
IN IN EQUITIES WITHIN THE
02:46:50.867 --> 02:46:52.769
MEDICAL CARE SYSTEM. THE VALLEY
02:46:52.836 --> 02:46:56.106
FEVER IS HAS A LOW MORTALITY IT
02:46:56.172 --> 02:46:58.475
HAS A HIGH PROBABILITY RATE IT'S
02:46:58.541 --> 02:47:00.043
EARLY SYMPTOMS ARE SIMILAR TO
02:47:00.110 --> 02:47:01.878
THE FLU FURTHER COMPLICATING
02:47:01.945 --> 02:47:03.947
DIAGNOSIS HOWEVER THE CONDITION
02:47:04.013 --> 02:47:05.749
MUST BE CAUGHT AT ITS EARLIEST
02:47:05.815 --> 02:47:07.484
STAGES BECAUSE VALLEY FEVER CAN
02:47:07.550 --> 02:47:09.586
PROGRESS INTO A CHRONIC ILLNESS
02:47:09.652 --> 02:47:11.354
THAT SEVERELY LIMITS THE
02:47:11.421 --> 02:47:13.623
PATIENT'S QUALITY OF LIFE AND
02:47:13.690 --> 02:47:14.858
FOR UNFORTUNATELY THERE'S NO
02:47:14.924 --> 02:47:17.394
CURE. FOR CHRONIC VALLEY FEVER
02:47:17.460 --> 02:47:18.795
AND THERE IS LITTLE INFORMATION
02:47:18.862 --> 02:47:20.897
AS TO WHY A PERSON DEVELOPS THE
02:47:20.964 --> 02:47:22.365
SEVERE DISEASE THEREFORE THE
02:47:22.432 --> 02:47:23.833
BEST TREATMENT IS PREVENTION
02:47:23.900 --> 02:47:25.335
WHICH REQUIRES A SWIFT AND
02:47:25.402 --> 02:47:27.537
ACCURATE DIAGNOSIS THANK YOU FOR
02:47:27.604 --> 02:47:29.105
YOUR CONSIDERATION AND I
02:47:29.172 --> 02:47:30.039
RESPECTFULLY REQUEST YOUR AYE
02:47:30.106 --> 02:47:33.443
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER CABALLERO
02:47:33.510 --> 02:47:36.079
MEMBERS IN. DEBATE OR DISCUSSION
02:47:36.146 --> 02:47:37.747
SEEING AND HEARING NO MA'AM
02:47:37.814 --> 02:47:39.382
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:47:39.449 --> 02:47:44.788
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
02:47:44.854 --> 02:47:49.692
BATES AYE BAKER. I PORCHES I
02:47:49.759 --> 02:47:53.129
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
02:47:53.196 --> 02:47:58.001
PROTESTING AYE VALLEY AYE DODD.
02:47:58.067 --> 02:48:02.572
I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
02:48:02.639 --> 02:48:07.811
AYE GONZALEZ I GROW. HERTZBERG
02:48:07.877 --> 02:48:13.283
WESSEL HI FURTADO. JONES I
02:48:13.349 --> 02:48:17.520
KAMLAGER I LAYERED I LEYVA AYE
02:48:17.587 --> 02:48:24.794
LIMÓN I MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ AYE
02:48:24.861 --> 02:48:31.100
MIN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. I
02:48:31.167 --> 02:48:37.740
OTOBO I CAN I PORTANTINO. ROTH I
02:48:37.807 --> 02:48:42.412
RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I STERN HI
02:48:42.479 --> 02:48:47.183
I'M BURKE. I FORECASTING AYE
02:48:47.250 --> 02:48:51.254
WIENER AYE WILK. HI PLEASE CALL
02:48:51.321 --> 02:48:52.722
THE ABSENT MEMBERS I'M SORRY
02:48:52.789 --> 02:48:54.290
CENTER MUSICAL MEMBERS ARE
02:48:54.357 --> 02:48:56.359
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM FIFTY
02:48:56.426 --> 02:48:58.828
SENATOR BRADFORD MEN SECRETARY
02:48:58.895 --> 02:49:02.398
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE
02:49:02.465 --> 02:49:03.666
EIGHTY ONE BY SENATOR BRADFORD
02:49:03.733 --> 02:49:05.001
AN ACT RELATING TO CANNABIS AND
02:49:05.068 --> 02:49:07.303
TAKING IT TO TAKE EFFECT
02:49:07.370 --> 02:49:08.271
IMMEDIATELY TAX LEVY. CENTER
02:49:08.338 --> 02:49:10.807
BRADFORD. THANK YOU MADAM
02:49:10.874 --> 02:49:13.109
PRESIDENT TWELVE EIGHTY ONE
02:49:13.176 --> 02:49:14.244
WOULD ELIMINATE THE CANNABIS
02:49:14.310 --> 02:49:16.246
CULTIVATION TAX AND REDUCED
02:49:16.312 --> 02:49:18.848
EXCISE TAX FROM 15% TO FIVE
02:49:18.915 --> 02:49:20.583
PERCENT. WOULD LSO MOVE THE
02:49:20.650 --> 02:49:22.185
POINT OF COLLECTION OF THE
02:49:22.252 --> 02:49:24.320
EXCISE TAX FROM THE DISTRIBUTOR
02:49:24.387 --> 02:49:25.588
TO THE RETAILER OR POINT OF
02:49:25.655 --> 02:49:27.690
SALE. THE INDUSTRY IS STRUGGLING
02:49:27.757 --> 02:49:29.559
TO CREATE A ROBUST LEGAL
02:49:29.626 --> 02:49:30.660
CANNABIS MARKET BECAUSE OF
02:49:30.727 --> 02:49:32.795
EXCESSIVE TAXATION AND
02:49:32.862 --> 02:49:35.698
OVERREGULATION. THIS IS NOT JUST
02:49:35.765 --> 02:49:36.299
A CALIFORNIA ISSUES TO NATION
02:49:36.366 --> 02:49:38.201
WIDE CONCERN. LEGAL CANNABIS
02:49:38.268 --> 02:49:41.638
PRODUCTS OR AT LEAST 50% MORE
02:49:41.704 --> 02:49:44.040
EXPENSIVE AT A RETAIL LOCATION
02:49:44.107 --> 02:49:47.777
THEN THE LICIT MARKET- AFFORDS
02:49:47.844 --> 02:49:49.746
WITHOUT MEANINGFUL CHANGES TO
02:49:49.812 --> 02:49:51.781
CALIFORNIA'S TAX POLICY INDUSTRY
02:49:51.848 --> 02:49:53.283
IS DESTINED FOR FAILURE.
02:49:53.349 --> 02:49:55.184
ESPECIALLY FOR EQUITY CANNABIS
02:49:55.251 --> 02:49:56.853
OPERATORS ARE OPERATING ON A
02:49:56.920 --> 02:49:59.389
VERY THIN MARGIN STUDIES SHOW
02:49:59.455 --> 02:50:00.356
THAT THE REDUCTION OF THIS TAX
02:50:00.423 --> 02:50:02.258
BURDEN WILL RESULT IN GREATER
02:50:02.325 --> 02:50:05.995
DEMAND AND INCREASED SALES AND
02:50:06.062 --> 02:50:08.031
OUR LEGAL. OPERATORS IN MORK AND
02:50:08.097 --> 02:50:10.433
CREATE A MORE COMPETITIVE MARKET
02:50:10.500 --> 02:50:11.034
AND PRODUCT I RESPECTFULLY ASK
02:50:11.100 --> 02:50:12.802
FOR YOUR VOTE. THINKCENTRE
02:50:12.869 --> 02:50:14.837
BRADFORD MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
02:50:14.904 --> 02:50:18.274
DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING NONE
02:50:18.341 --> 02:50:19.342
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
02:50:19.409 --> 02:50:26.716
ROLL. ALLEN. ARCHULETA I ATKINS
02:50:26.783 --> 02:50:33.456
AYE BATES. BAKER I PORCHES.
02:50:33.523 --> 02:50:36.292
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
02:50:36.359 --> 02:50:43.132
CORTESE AYE DALY. DODD I TORONTO
02:50:43.199 --> 02:50:47.837
I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER. GONZALEZ I
02:50:47.904 --> 02:50:52.976
GROW. HERTZBERG WESSEL I HER
02:50:53.042 --> 02:51:00.516
TADO. JONES KAMLAGER I LAYERED
02:51:00.583 --> 02:51:07.523
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN. MCGUIRE. I
02:51:07.590 --> 02:51:12.395
MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN AYE
02:51:12.462 --> 02:51:17.467
NIELSEN. BUT CHOI BOGUE. PAN
02:51:17.533 --> 02:51:23.773
PORTANTINO. ROCK I RUBIO FIVE
02:51:23.840 --> 02:51:29.612
SKINNER. I STERN. AMBERG I BY
02:51:29.679 --> 02:51:36.719
CASTING. WIENER AYE WILK. HI
02:51:36.786 --> 02:51:39.055
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:51:39.122 --> 02:51:48.564
ALLEN BATES. BORCHERS DALLY. ONE
02:51:48.631 --> 02:51:54.337
SEVEN YEARS LATER. GROVE.
02:51:54.404 --> 02:51:59.676
HERTZBERG FURTADO NO. JONES
02:51:59.742 --> 02:52:07.150
LIMÓN. MELENDEZ NIELSEN. BUT
02:52:07.216 --> 02:52:14.323
CHOI BOGUE. I PAN. PORTANTINO
02:52:14.390 --> 02:52:18.795
STERN WHITE HOUSE GATE SENATOR
02:52:18.861 --> 02:52:20.396
MOVES THE CALL MEMBERS WE ARE
02:52:20.463 --> 02:52:23.866
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM FIFTY TWO
02:52:23.933 --> 02:52:27.170
ALSO SENATOR BRADFORD. MADAM
02:52:27.236 --> 02:52:29.238
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
02:52:29.305 --> 02:52:31.574
BILL TWELVE NINETY THREE BY
02:52:31.641 --> 02:52:33.142
SENATOR BRADFORD AN ACT RELATING
02:52:33.209 --> 02:52:34.110
TO TAXATION SHOULD TAKE
02:52:34.177 --> 02:52:35.411
APPROXIMATELY TAX LEVY. CENTER
02:52:35.478 --> 02:52:37.980
BRADFORD THANK YOU TO ALL NINETY
02:52:38.047 --> 02:52:39.248
THREE WOULD PROVIDE LICENSE
02:52:39.315 --> 02:52:40.717
CANNABIS EQUITY OPERATORS WOULD
02:52:40.783 --> 02:52:42.418
TAX CREDIT THAT WOULD APPLY TO
02:52:42.485 --> 02:52:44.420
THEIR PERSONAL AND CORPORATE
02:52:44.487 --> 02:52:45.588
INCOME TAX WHAT CALIFORNIA LAW
02:52:45.655 --> 02:52:47.156
HAS CLEARED THE PATH FOR
02:52:47.223 --> 02:52:48.357
CANNABIS INDUSTRY TO OPERATE
02:52:48.424 --> 02:52:50.226
LEGALLY ME TOO CANNABIS
02:52:50.293 --> 02:52:51.194
BUSINESSES ARE STRUGGLING TO
02:52:51.260 --> 02:52:52.962
SURVIVE ESPECIALLY THOSE OWNED.
02:52:53.029 --> 02:52:55.198
BY A OPERATORS WE OPERATE REPORT
02:52:55.264 --> 02:52:56.833
THAT THEY ARE IN CRISIS AND ON
02:52:56.899 --> 02:52:59.335
THE VERGE OF COLLAPSE IN PART TO
02:52:59.402 --> 02:53:00.737
THE OVER TAXATION OF THIS
02:53:00.803 --> 02:53:03.873
INDUSTRY THE REPORT RELEASED IN
02:53:03.940 --> 02:53:05.108
TWENTY TWENTY ONE BY THE
02:53:05.174 --> 02:53:06.008
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
02:53:06.075 --> 02:53:07.443
ASSOCIATION NOTES THAT WHILE THE
02:53:07.510 --> 02:53:09.078
BARRIERS TO MARKET ENTRY ARE
02:53:09.145 --> 02:53:11.214
HARD FOR ANY CANNABIS OPERATOR
02:53:11.280 --> 02:53:13.149
THE ODDS ARE. AGAINST AVERAGE
02:53:13.216 --> 02:53:15.084
EQUITY OPERATOR WHO MIGHT NOT
02:53:15.151 --> 02:53:16.652
HAVE THE SAME RESOURCES
02:53:16.719 --> 02:53:18.321
ADVANTAGES OF OTHER OPERATORS IN
02:53:18.387 --> 02:53:20.156
THE MARKET PLACE THE REPORT
02:53:20.223 --> 02:53:22.358
RECOMMENDS PROVIDING TAX RELIEF
02:53:22.425 --> 02:53:23.693
AND ADDITIONAL FUNDING TO
02:53:23.760 --> 02:53:25.695
SUPPORT CANNABIS SOCIAL EQUITY
02:53:25.762 --> 02:53:28.664
OPERATORS TWELVE NINETY EIGHTY
02:53:28.731 --> 02:53:30.233
THREE WITHOUT A TAX CREDIT OR
02:53:30.299 --> 02:53:32.635
ALLOW. LICENSE EQUITY OPERATORS
02:53:32.702 --> 02:53:34.837
CANNABIS INDUSTRY TO ACCOUNT FOR
02:53:34.904 --> 02:53:36.572
THE FACT THAT THEY CANNOT WRITE
02:53:36.639 --> 02:53:39.942
OFF BUSINESS RELATED EXPENSES
02:53:40.009 --> 02:53:42.311
AFTER FEDERAL LEVEL. THE CREDIT
02:53:42.378 --> 02:53:46.916
WILL HELP. WITH THEIR- PORTION
02:53:46.983 --> 02:53:48.851
THE HOT HARM WHO HAVE BEEN TO
02:53:48.918 --> 02:53:50.753
PROPORTION HARM THE WARRANTY AND
02:53:50.820 --> 02:53:52.088
I. AT AND YOU CAN TO JUST IN OR
02:53:52.155 --> 02:53:54.791
GROW ACCOUNT BUSINESS. TWELVE
02:53:54.857 --> 02:53:55.391
NINETY THREE TAKES EFFECT IN
02:53:55.458 --> 02:53:58.261
JANUARY ONE TWENTY TWENTY THREE
02:53:58.327 --> 02:54:00.663
AND APPLIES. TO THE TAX YEAR
02:54:00.730 --> 02:54:02.799
TWENTY TWENTY TWO INCLUSIVE AND-
02:54:02.865 --> 02:54:04.433
TWELVE NINETY THREE INCLUDES A
02:54:04.500 --> 02:54:05.835
SUNSET DATE. OF DECEMBER THIRTY
02:54:05.902 --> 02:54:08.271
FIRST TWENTY TWENTY SEVEN I
02:54:08.337 --> 02:54:08.905
RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL. SENATOR
02:54:08.971 --> 02:54:10.740
BRADFORD MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
02:54:10.807 --> 02:54:14.010
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING
02:54:14.076 --> 02:54:15.111
THEM M. SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
02:54:15.178 --> 02:54:19.949
THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
02:54:20.016 --> 02:54:25.988
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES. BAKER I
02:54:26.055 --> 02:54:30.493
PORCHES NO BRADFORD. I HAVE I
02:54:30.560 --> 02:54:34.297
GOTTA AYE CORTESE AYE DALY NO
02:54:34.363 --> 02:54:40.736
DODD. THE RAZA. I EGGMAN AYE
02:54:40.803 --> 02:54:47.176
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROW. NO
02:54:47.243 --> 02:54:52.415
HERTZBERG WESSEL. HI HER TADO
02:54:52.481 --> 02:54:58.554
NOPE JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED
02:54:58.621 --> 02:55:04.260
I LEYVA HI LIMÓN. MCGUIRE HI
02:55:04.327 --> 02:55:08.931
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN I
02:55:08.998 --> 02:55:14.837
NIELSEN NO A SHOW ABOUT. PAN AYE
02:55:14.904 --> 02:55:21.043
PORTANTINO. ROTH I RUBIO I
02:55:21.110 --> 02:55:26.449
SKINNER. I STERN AYE AMBERG I
02:55:26.515 --> 02:55:32.188
CASTING I WIENER AYE WILK HI
02:55:32.255 --> 02:55:34.257
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
02:55:34.323 --> 02:55:42.465
BATES DODD I. GLAZER. HERTZBERG
02:55:42.531 --> 02:55:49.538
LIMÓN. A CHOI BOGUE. PORTANTINO
02:55:49.605 --> 02:55:51.307
I TWENTY SEVEN NO SEVEN THE
02:55:51.374 --> 02:55:52.909
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
02:55:52.975 --> 02:55:54.810
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM FIFTY
02:55:54.877 --> 02:55:56.279
THREE CENTER CABALLERO AND
02:55:56.345 --> 02:55:58.414
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
02:55:58.481 --> 02:56:01.083
BILL THIRTEEN TWENTY SIX BY
02:56:01.150 --> 02:56:02.184
SENATOR CABALLERO AN ACT
02:56:02.251 --> 02:56:03.386
RELATING TO CANNABIS CENTER
02:56:03.452 --> 02:56:04.320
CABALLERO THANK YOU MADAM
02:56:04.387 --> 02:56:05.988
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I AM PLEASED
02:56:06.055 --> 02:56:08.858
TO PRESENT SB THIRTEEN TWENTY
02:56:08.925 --> 02:56:09.825
SIX WHICH WOULD ALLOW THE CROSS
02:56:09.892 --> 02:56:12.228
JURISDICTIONAL IMPORT AND EXPORT
02:56:12.295 --> 02:56:14.263
TO OTHER STATES OF CANNABIS AND
02:56:14.330 --> 02:56:15.898
CANNABIS PRODUCTS BY AUTHORIZING
02:56:15.965 --> 02:56:17.833
THE GOVERNOR TO ENTER INTO AN
02:56:17.900 --> 02:56:19.268
AGREEMENT TO PROVIDE LAWFUL
02:56:19.335 --> 02:56:22.405
INTERSTATE COMMERCE SB THIRTEEN
02:56:22.471 --> 02:56:23.873
TWENTY SIX ALLOWS THE STATE TO
02:56:23.940 --> 02:56:24.407
ENTER INTO AN INTERSTATE
02:56:24.473 --> 02:56:26.342
CANNABIS AGREEMENT. TO ALLOW
02:56:26.409 --> 02:56:28.678
CANNABIS OR CANNABIS PRODUCTS TO
02:56:28.744 --> 02:56:30.012
BE TRANSPORTED ACROSS STATE
02:56:30.079 --> 02:56:31.847
LINES REQUIRES THE AGREEMENT TO
02:56:31.914 --> 02:56:33.916
MEET SPECIFIED REQUIREMENTS
02:56:33.983 --> 02:56:34.850
INCLUDING THAT PARTICIPATING
02:56:34.917 --> 02:56:37.353
STATES MUST MEET OR EXCEED
02:56:37.420 --> 02:56:38.988
HEALTH AND SAFETY REQUIREMENTS
02:56:39.055 --> 02:56:40.690
THAT WE HAVE ESTABLISHED AND
02:56:40.756 --> 02:56:42.525
ALLOW THE STATE TO ENGAGE IN
02:56:42.591 --> 02:56:44.260
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES WITH OUT
02:56:44.327 --> 02:56:45.928
OF STATE LICENSES WITHOUT
02:56:45.995 --> 02:56:47.830
CONSIDERABLE MARKET EXPANSION AS
02:56:47.897 --> 02:56:49.298
PART OF THE SOLUTION TO
02:56:49.365 --> 02:56:51.334
STABILIZE THE LEGAL INDUSTRY AND
02:56:51.400 --> 02:56:53.436
INCENTIVIZE PARTICIPATION IN THE
02:56:53.502 --> 02:56:55.571
REGULATED MARKET CALIFORNIA
02:56:55.638 --> 02:56:57.606
RISKS THE COLLAPSE OF PORTIONS
02:56:57.673 --> 02:56:59.375
OF THE LEGAL INDUSTRY RESULTING
02:56:59.442 --> 02:57:01.610
IN CONSIDERABLE EXPANSION OF THE
02:57:01.677 --> 02:57:02.912
ILLICIT MARKET IN CALIFORNIA
02:57:02.979 --> 02:57:05.648
WHICH IS WHAT WE'VE SEEN IT'S A
02:57:05.715 --> 02:57:07.316
LOT CHEAPER A LOT EASIER TO GET
02:57:07.383 --> 02:57:09.185
SOMETIMES. SB THIRTEEN TWENTY
02:57:09.251 --> 02:57:10.853
SIX IS IN THIS ESSENTIAL STEP TO
02:57:10.920 --> 02:57:13.589
ENSURE THE CALIFORNIA CAN FULLY
02:57:13.656 --> 02:57:15.624
CAPITALIZE ON AND REMAIN A
02:57:15.691 --> 02:57:16.993
LEADER IN THE FORTHCOMING
02:57:17.059 --> 02:57:18.794
NATIONAL CANNABIS MARKET
02:57:18.861 --> 02:57:20.830
CALIFORNIA SHOULD LAY THE
02:57:20.896 --> 02:57:22.465
GROUNDWORK FOR A MULTI STATE
02:57:22.531 --> 02:57:25.901
LEGAL CANNABIS MARKET NOT ONLY
02:57:25.968 --> 02:57:27.069
CAN THE STRATEGY BE REPLICATED.
02:57:27.136 --> 02:57:28.938
THANK YOU CAN BE CAN IT BE
02:57:29.005 --> 02:57:30.239
REPLICATED ON A NATIONAL SCALE
02:57:30.306 --> 02:57:31.941
IT CAN GIVE CALIFORNIA A
02:57:32.008 --> 02:57:34.243
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE. IN THE
02:57:34.310 --> 02:57:35.811
SENATE BMP COMMITTEE I COMMITTED
02:57:35.878 --> 02:57:37.580
TO WORK WITH THE CHAIR TO
02:57:37.646 --> 02:57:39.315
DEVELOP AN APPROPRIATE MECHANISM
02:57:39.382 --> 02:57:40.883
FOR LEGISLATIVE INVOLVEMENT AND
02:57:40.950 --> 02:57:42.718
OVERSIGHT FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
02:57:42.785 --> 02:57:44.920
INTERSTATE AGREEMENTS UNDER THIS
02:57:44.987 --> 02:57:47.156
BILL. DUE TO TIME CONSTRAINTS WE
02:57:47.223 --> 02:57:48.824
WERE NOT ABLE TO AMEND THE BILL
02:57:48.891 --> 02:57:50.793
IN THE SENATE BUT I WILL BE
02:57:50.860 --> 02:57:51.293
TAKING AMENDMENTS IN THE
02:57:51.360 --> 02:57:52.962
ASSEMBLY WHICH WILL INCLUDE A
02:57:53.029 --> 02:57:54.263
REQUIREMENT FOR PROPOSED
02:57:54.330 --> 02:57:55.598
AGREEMENTS OR AGREEMENT
02:57:55.664 --> 02:57:56.866
AMENDMENTS TO BE SUBMITTED TO
02:57:56.932 --> 02:57:58.167
THE JOINT BUDGET COMMITTEE FOR
02:57:58.234 --> 02:57:59.635
REVIEW AND COMMENT. THE
02:57:59.702 --> 02:58:00.903
COMMITTEE WOULD HAVE SIXTY DAYS
02:58:00.970 --> 02:58:02.538
TO REVIEW AND SUBMIT WRITTEN
02:58:02.605 --> 02:58:05.107
RECOMMENDATIONS AND THE GOVERNOR
02:58:05.174 --> 02:58:06.809
MUST PROVIDE IN WRITING REASONS
02:58:06.876 --> 02:58:07.243
FOR ANY LEGISLATIVE
02:58:07.309 --> 02:58:08.677
RECOMMENDATION BUT INCORPORATED
02:58:08.744 --> 02:58:10.679
INTO THE AGREEMENT SECOND WOULD
02:58:10.746 --> 02:58:12.348
REQUIRE PROPOSED AGREEMENTS OR
02:58:12.415 --> 02:58:14.650
AMENDMENTS TO BE POSTED ON THE
02:58:14.717 --> 02:58:16.185
DEPARTMENT'S INTERNET WEBSITE
02:58:16.252 --> 02:58:17.386
FOR THIRTY DAYS FOR PUBLIC
02:58:17.453 --> 02:58:18.054
COMMENT. AND THIRD REQUIRE
02:58:18.120 --> 02:58:20.189
ACTIVITIES UNDERTAKEN PURSUANT
02:58:20.256 --> 02:58:21.690
TO THIS LEGISLATION BE INCLUDED
02:58:21.757 --> 02:58:22.525
IN THE DEPARTMENT'S ANNUAL
02:58:22.591 --> 02:58:24.660
REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE THIS
02:58:24.727 --> 02:58:25.294
WILL ENSURE THAT WE'RE GETTING
02:58:25.361 --> 02:58:27.229
INFORMATION WERE PARTICIPATING
02:58:27.296 --> 02:58:29.832
IN THE PROCESS AS WELL. SB
02:58:29.899 --> 02:58:31.333
THIRTEEN TWENTY SIX HAS NO
02:58:31.400 --> 02:58:32.168
OPPOSITION AND I RESPECTFULLY
02:58:32.234 --> 02:58:33.502
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
02:58:33.569 --> 02:58:34.503
CENTER CABALLERO MEMBERS
02:58:34.570 --> 02:58:36.906
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
02:58:36.972 --> 02:58:39.575
PAN. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
02:58:39.642 --> 02:58:42.945
SENATORS- I APPRECIATE. THE
02:58:43.012 --> 02:58:44.380
AUTHOR ACTUALLY- I'M TALKING
02:58:44.447 --> 02:58:45.815
ABOUT THE ROLE OF THE
02:58:45.881 --> 02:58:48.184
LEGISLATURE IN THESE CONTACTS- I
02:58:48.250 --> 02:58:50.219
KNOW WE HAD THAT DISCUSSION AND-
02:58:50.286 --> 02:58:51.821
AND BMP COMMITTEE AND-
02:58:51.887 --> 02:58:53.355
APPRECIATE HER EXPLANATION ABOUT
02:58:53.422 --> 02:58:54.457
WHY THEY'RE NOT IN THE CURRENT
02:58:54.523 --> 02:58:55.958
VERSION OF THE BILL BUT THEY'LL
02:58:56.025 --> 02:58:57.726
BE TAKEN OUT. AFTER MIDNIGHT
02:58:57.793 --> 02:58:59.161
WILL TO SERVE SAY THAT MY
02:58:59.228 --> 02:59:00.629
PREFERENCE WOULD BE IS THAT
02:59:00.696 --> 02:59:01.664
ACTUALLY. IN THE END THAT ANY
02:59:01.730 --> 02:59:02.898
INTERSTATE COMPACTS THE FULL
02:59:02.965 --> 02:59:04.266
CONTACT SHOULD BE I THINK
02:59:04.333 --> 02:59:05.634
RATIFIED BY THE LEGISLATURE I
02:59:05.701 --> 02:59:07.136
THINK PERHAPS A STEP FURTHER
02:59:07.203 --> 02:59:08.737
THAN YOU YOU MENTIONED MAYBE
02:59:08.804 --> 02:59:11.340
THAT CAN BE FURTHER- POINT OF.
02:59:11.407 --> 02:59:13.175
DISCUSSION AS IT GOES THROUGH
02:59:13.242 --> 02:59:14.643
THE ASSEMBLY BUT CERTAINLY-
02:59:14.710 --> 02:59:16.645
APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO
02:59:16.712 --> 02:59:19.348
DO AND- CERTAINLY. WE DO NEED TO
02:59:19.415 --> 02:59:21.150
SEE WHETHER WE CAN WORK WITH
02:59:21.217 --> 02:59:23.052
OTHER STATES- TOGETHER AS WELL-
02:59:23.119 --> 02:59:24.920
IN THE IN THE SERENUS OF THE
02:59:24.987 --> 02:59:26.021
SUPPORTING THE BILL BUT- YEAH
02:59:26.088 --> 02:59:28.357
AND VERY MUCH LOOKING FORWARD TO
02:59:28.424 --> 02:59:30.459
BEFORE THE BILL COMES BACK AND
02:59:30.526 --> 02:59:32.528
CURTAINS- BETTER DEFINING AND
02:59:32.595 --> 02:59:34.163
BEING SURE THAT THE LEGISLATURE.
02:59:34.230 --> 02:59:36.398
HAS A ERY IMPORTANT SAY IN ANY
02:59:36.465 --> 02:59:38.067
FINAL COMPACT THAT'S AGREED TO
02:59:38.134 --> 02:59:39.668
WITH OTHER STATES IN REGARDS
02:59:39.735 --> 02:59:41.670
CAMPUS THANK YOU. THINK YOUR
02:59:41.737 --> 02:59:43.439
BENCH THANK YOU CENTER DOWN
02:59:43.506 --> 02:59:44.840
MEMBERS FOR THE DISCUSSION BASED
02:59:44.907 --> 02:59:47.209
SENATOR MELINDA'S. THANK YOU
02:59:47.276 --> 02:59:50.746
MADAM PRESIDENT. I HAVE A
02:59:50.813 --> 02:59:52.615
QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR. THE
02:59:52.681 --> 02:59:53.883
QUOTE AND YES THEY WILL PLEASE.
02:59:53.949 --> 02:59:54.817
THANK YOU- SENATOR REID. HAVE A
02:59:54.884 --> 02:59:56.652
QUESTION RESPECT TO PROP SIXTY
02:59:56.719 --> 02:59:58.287
FOUR. BECAUSE PROP SIXTY FOUR
02:59:58.354 --> 03:00:01.457
STATED- THAT IT SHALL NOT BE
03:00:01.524 --> 03:00:02.992
CONSTRUED TO AUTHORIZE OR PERMIT
03:00:03.058 --> 03:00:04.627
A LICENSEE TRANSPORTER
03:00:04.693 --> 03:00:05.895
DISTRIBUTE OR CAUSE TO BE
03:00:05.961 --> 03:00:07.730
TRANSPORTED OR DISTRIBUTED.
03:00:07.796 --> 03:00:09.098
MARIJUANA OR MARIJUANA PRODUCTS
03:00:09.165 --> 03:00:11.033
OUTSIDE THE STATE UNLESS
03:00:11.100 --> 03:00:14.537
AUTHORIZED BY FEDERAL LAW. SO
03:00:14.603 --> 03:00:15.804
HOW DO YOU SQUARE THIS BILL WITH
03:00:15.871 --> 03:00:17.006
THE FACT THAT. WHAT SIXTY FOUR
03:00:17.072 --> 03:00:18.874
SAID ONE THING IN YOUR BILL IS
03:00:18.941 --> 03:00:20.709
ASKING TO DO SOMETHING ENTIRELY
03:00:20.776 --> 03:00:21.343
DIFFERENT. THANK YOU VERY THANK
03:00:21.410 --> 03:00:22.945
YOU FOR THAT QUESTION- THIS IS
03:00:23.012 --> 03:00:26.982
ANTICIPATION OF. OF BASICALLY
03:00:27.049 --> 03:00:29.251
FEDERAL ELECTION AGING OR
03:00:29.318 --> 03:00:30.686
PERMITTING THE TRACK
03:00:30.753 --> 03:00:33.556
TRANSPORTATION- OF- DRUGS ACROSS
03:00:33.622 --> 03:00:35.991
STATE LINES IT OBVIOUSLY WE NEED
03:00:36.058 --> 03:00:38.093
TO BE VERY CAREFUL. NOT TO BE
03:00:38.160 --> 03:00:39.962
VIOLATING FEDERAL LAW IN THE IN
03:00:40.029 --> 03:00:44.166
THE- IN THE CONSTRUCT OF- OF
03:00:44.233 --> 03:00:45.701
INTERSTATE COMMERCE BUT I THINK
03:00:45.768 --> 03:00:47.169
IT'S PRETTY WELL RECOGNISED AT
03:00:47.236 --> 03:00:50.773
THE STATE'S- IT SHOULD. NOT DO
03:00:50.839 --> 03:00:54.376
ANYTHING THAT THAT- CONSTRAINTS
03:00:54.443 --> 03:00:56.445
BETTER- CONSTRAINTS COMMERCE-
03:00:56.512 --> 03:00:59.448
AND SO WE ARE CAREFUL WHEN WE
03:00:59.515 --> 03:01:01.450
LOOK AT OUR BILLS HERE IN THE
03:01:01.517 --> 03:01:02.218
LEGISLATURE TO MAKE SURE THAT
03:01:02.284 --> 03:01:04.186
THAT OUR- ACTIONS ARE NOT
03:01:04.253 --> 03:01:06.055
CONSTRAINING COMMERCE THIS IS
03:01:06.121 --> 03:01:08.157
ONE WAY FOR US TO BE ABLE TO
03:01:08.224 --> 03:01:09.391
PUSH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. TO
03:01:09.458 --> 03:01:11.293
ALLOW US TO DO INTERSTATE
03:01:11.360 --> 03:01:14.530
TRANSPORTATION AND SO THAT THAT
03:01:14.597 --> 03:01:15.164
ACTUALLY THE PROPOSITION DOESN'T
03:01:15.231 --> 03:01:17.333
SAY CAN'T DO IT WHAT IS IT YOU
03:01:17.399 --> 03:01:21.537
NEED- YOU NEED A FEDERAL. NOT
03:01:21.604 --> 03:01:23.606
LEGISLATION IN ORDER TO BE ABLE
03:01:23.672 --> 03:01:25.641
TO ALLOW IT TO HAPPEN AND THAT'S
03:01:25.708 --> 03:01:27.443
THAT'S THE DIRECTION WE BE GOING
03:01:27.509 --> 03:01:29.445
IN. OKAY THURMOND US YES THANK
03:01:29.511 --> 03:01:32.248
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT- SO AGAIN
03:01:32.314 --> 03:01:34.049
PROP SIXTY FOUR VERY CLEARLY
03:01:34.116 --> 03:01:35.251
STATE TO HAVE THE WORDING RIGHT
03:01:35.317 --> 03:01:37.186
IN FRONT OF ME THERE SHALL NOT
03:01:37.253 --> 03:01:38.120
BE CONSTRUED TO AUTHORIZE OR
03:01:38.187 --> 03:01:42.224
PERMIT. THIS- DISTRIBUTION OF
03:01:42.291 --> 03:01:43.626
MARIJUANA MARIE MARIJUANA
03:01:43.692 --> 03:01:46.428
PRODUCTS OUTSIDE THE STATE SO
03:01:46.495 --> 03:01:48.897
WHAT YOU'RE SAYING IS. THIS IS
03:01:48.964 --> 03:01:51.400
IN ANTICIPATION OF CONGRESS
03:01:51.467 --> 03:01:52.835
PASSING A LAW THAT LEGALIZES
03:01:52.901 --> 03:01:55.571
MARIJUANA I'VE YET TO SEE A BILL
03:01:55.638 --> 03:01:58.140
LIKE THAT BE INTRODUCED IF IT
03:01:58.207 --> 03:01:58.941
HASN'T BEEN INTRODUCED IT
03:01:59.008 --> 03:02:02.378
CERTAINLY HASN'T BEEN PASSED. SO
03:02:02.444 --> 03:02:04.113
IF THIS BILL PASSES IT MAKES IT
03:02:04.179 --> 03:02:06.482
. LEGAL IF YOU WELL AS FAR AS
03:02:06.548 --> 03:02:07.283
CALIFORNIA STATE LAW AND THAT IS
03:02:07.349 --> 03:02:09.618
IN DIRECT OPPOSITION TO FEDERAL
03:02:09.685 --> 03:02:11.787
LAWSUIT THAT PUTS US OUT OF STEP
03:02:11.854 --> 03:02:13.989
WITH FEDERAL LAW SO ARE YOU
03:02:14.056 --> 03:02:16.792
SUGGESTING THAT. CALIFORNIA IS
03:02:16.859 --> 03:02:18.494
NOT GOING TO ENGAGE IN THIS KIND
03:02:18.560 --> 03:02:20.696
OF COMMERCE. EVEN THOUGH THIS
03:02:20.763 --> 03:02:22.598
BILL MAY PASS MAY BE SIGNED BY
03:02:22.665 --> 03:02:25.034
THE GOVERNOR UNLESS. CONGRESS
03:02:25.100 --> 03:02:27.136
LEGALIZES MARIJUANA BECAUSE
03:02:27.202 --> 03:02:28.570
THAT'S NOT IN THE BILL IT
03:02:28.637 --> 03:02:30.572
DOESN'T SAY YOU KNOW DEPENDED
03:02:30.639 --> 03:02:33.042
UPON CONGRESS LEGALIZING THIS
03:02:33.108 --> 03:02:35.744
PRODUCT. CENTER CABALLERO YES IT
03:02:35.811 --> 03:02:39.148
IS THAT IS MY EXPECTATION. AND
03:02:39.214 --> 03:02:40.883
IN THE IT'S CERTAINLY SOMETHING
03:02:40.949 --> 03:02:43.619
WE CAN WE CAN ADD TO THE BILL OF
03:02:43.686 --> 03:02:44.320
THE AT THE ANTICIPATION IS THAT
03:02:44.386 --> 03:02:45.854
THIS WILL GIVE THE GOVERNOR THE
03:02:45.921 --> 03:02:47.156
AUTHORITY IN OTHER WORDS A
03:02:47.222 --> 03:02:49.458
GOVERNOR CAN DECLINE THAT A
03:02:49.525 --> 03:02:51.360
THIRTY YOU CAN EITHER NOT HE CAN
03:02:51.427 --> 03:02:53.095
EITHER BE TO THE BILL OR HE CAN
03:02:53.162 --> 03:02:54.296
SIGN IT AND THEN NEVER. NEVER
03:02:54.363 --> 03:02:56.198
COME UP WITH A COMPACT WITH
03:02:56.265 --> 03:02:57.499
OTHER STATES BUT TO THE EXTENT
03:02:57.566 --> 03:02:59.968
THAT- THE LEGISLATURE IS IN
03:03:00.035 --> 03:03:02.137
SUPPORT OF THAT IT GIVES THE
03:03:02.204 --> 03:03:03.706
GOVERNOR THE ABILITY TO. START
03:03:03.772 --> 03:03:05.974
DISCUSSING. INTERSTATE COMPACTS
03:03:06.041 --> 03:03:07.710
WITH THOSE STATES THAT HAVE
03:03:07.776 --> 03:03:11.347
LEGALIZED MARIJUANA. AND AND USE
03:03:11.413 --> 03:03:13.115
THAT IS AT THE READY TO GO TO
03:03:13.182 --> 03:03:14.850
THIS TO THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
03:03:14.917 --> 03:03:16.485
AND ASK CONGRESS TO CHANGE THE
03:03:16.552 --> 03:03:18.687
LAW SO THAT IT AT THAT CONTACT
03:03:18.754 --> 03:03:19.922
WOULD BE AFFECTED. OKAY
03:03:19.988 --> 03:03:21.390
MILLENDER. THANK YOU MATTER
03:03:21.457 --> 03:03:26.095
PRESENT ON MY OWN TIME I WOULD
03:03:26.161 --> 03:03:26.962
JUST BRIEFLY- BRING THIS TO A
03:03:27.029 --> 03:03:28.931
CLOSE AND JUST SAY THAT THIS.
03:03:28.997 --> 03:03:30.432
THIS BILL THAT'S BEING PROPOSED
03:03:30.499 --> 03:03:31.667
IF PASSED AND SIGNED BY THE
03:03:31.734 --> 03:03:33.302
GOVERNOR IS. REN'S COMPLETELY
03:03:33.369 --> 03:03:35.037
AFOUL OF FEDERAL LAW WHETHER OR
03:03:35.104 --> 03:03:38.540
NOT WE ANTICIPATE THAT CONGRESS.
03:03:38.607 --> 03:03:39.942
MAY LEGALIZE MARIJUANA THEY HAVE
03:03:40.008 --> 03:03:42.778
NOT YET AND SO THIS PUTS US ON
03:03:42.845 --> 03:03:44.146
THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE TABLE
03:03:44.213 --> 03:03:45.180
AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND I
03:03:45.247 --> 03:03:46.815
WILL REMIND EVERYONE THAT WE
03:03:46.882 --> 03:03:48.016
HAVE BEEN DOWN THIS ROAD BEFORE
03:03:48.083 --> 03:03:49.785
AND OF COURSE YOU KNOW. THAT IF
03:03:49.852 --> 03:03:51.387
YOU RUN AFOUL OF FEDERAL LAW YOU
03:03:51.453 --> 03:03:53.188
RUN THE RISK OF HAVING FEDERAL
03:03:53.255 --> 03:03:55.591
FUNDING WITHHELD FROM THE STATES
03:03:55.657 --> 03:03:56.892
THAT ARE NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH
03:03:56.959 --> 03:03:59.161
FEDERAL LAW SO WITH THAT I WOULD
03:03:59.228 --> 03:04:02.231
ASK FOR NO BETTER. THANK YOU
03:04:02.297 --> 03:04:03.565
CENTER WINDOWS MEMBERS FURTHER
03:04:03.632 --> 03:04:04.199
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE THING IN
03:04:04.266 --> 03:04:05.667
HEARING CENTER CABALLERO YOU
03:04:05.734 --> 03:04:07.102
MAKE. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
03:04:07.169 --> 03:04:09.204
NAY A- SHEET THAT. HOWEVER THE
03:04:09.271 --> 03:04:10.906
REAL THE REAL ISSUE HERE HAS TO
03:04:10.973 --> 03:04:13.776
DO WITH- SETTING UP A FRAMEWORK
03:04:13.842 --> 03:04:15.911
TO BE ABLE TO TALK TO OUR-
03:04:15.978 --> 03:04:17.913
STATE. PARTNERS WHO HAVE
03:04:17.980 --> 03:04:19.715
LEGALIZED MARIJUANA. IN
03:04:19.782 --> 03:04:21.150
VIOLATION OF FEDERAL LAW AND
03:04:21.216 --> 03:04:24.453
MIGHT I MIGHT ADD. AND AND PUSH
03:04:24.520 --> 03:04:25.621
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO DO THE
03:04:25.687 --> 03:04:28.323
RIGHT THING. I WANNA IS NOT ONLY
03:04:28.390 --> 03:04:29.925
A RECREATIONAL DRUG BUT IT ALSO
03:04:29.992 --> 03:04:32.060
IS A DRUG THAT PROVIDES GREAT
03:04:32.127 --> 03:04:33.729
RELIEF FOR PEOPLE THAT ARE
03:04:33.796 --> 03:04:35.931
SUFFERING A WHOLE SERIES. OF
03:04:35.998 --> 03:04:38.467
ILLNESSES AND- THE FACT THAT
03:04:38.534 --> 03:04:40.803
CALIFORNIA RECOGNIZES VERY EARLY
03:04:40.869 --> 03:04:43.739
ON AND HAS PROVIDED A FORUM TO
03:04:43.806 --> 03:04:45.340
BE ABLE TO HELP IS REALLY
03:04:45.407 --> 03:04:47.910
IMPORTANT AND SO I WOULD I THINK
03:04:47.976 --> 03:04:49.044
THIS IS JUST PART OF THAT
03:04:49.111 --> 03:04:51.413
TRAJECTORY OF TRYING TO GET THE
03:04:51.480 --> 03:04:52.281
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT. BOARD AND
03:04:52.347 --> 03:04:53.449
THEN STAND THAT LEGALIZING
03:04:53.515 --> 03:04:55.818
MARIJUANA IS A RIGHT THING TO DO
03:04:55.884 --> 03:04:56.852
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
03:04:56.919 --> 03:04:58.954
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER CABALLERO
03:04:59.021 --> 03:05:00.389
I'M SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
03:05:00.456 --> 03:05:03.192
ROLL. ALLEN I ARCHULETA AYE
03:05:03.258 --> 03:05:07.329
ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER I
03:05:07.396 --> 03:05:11.667
PORCHES NOPE BRADFORD I
03:05:11.733 --> 03:05:15.604
CABALLERO I FOR TESTING I DOLLY
03:05:15.671 --> 03:05:21.109
NO DODD. I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
03:05:21.176 --> 03:05:26.315
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH. NO
03:05:26.381 --> 03:05:32.254
HERTZBERG WESSEL I HER TADO.
03:05:32.321 --> 03:05:36.959
NOPE JONES NOPE KAMLAGER I
03:05:37.025 --> 03:05:41.330
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE
03:05:41.396 --> 03:05:47.169
MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE
03:05:47.236 --> 03:05:51.440
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF
03:05:51.507 --> 03:05:56.612
THE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO.
03:05:56.678 --> 03:06:04.953
PORTANTINO ROTH I RUBIO. SKINNER
03:06:05.020 --> 03:06:09.658
I STERN AYE NUMBER HI MY COUNTY
03:06:09.725 --> 03:06:13.996
AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE
03:06:14.062 --> 03:06:15.464
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
03:06:15.531 --> 03:06:21.169
HERTZBERG PORTANTINO RUBIO I
03:06:21.236 --> 03:06:22.104
TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS TEN THE
03:06:22.170 --> 03:06:24.106
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
03:06:24.172 --> 03:06:26.808
MOVING TO FILE ITEM FIFTY SEVEN
03:06:26.875 --> 03:06:29.044
SENATOR ALAN ARE YOU NEARBY
03:06:29.111 --> 03:06:31.246
SENATOR ALAN HERE HE COMES
03:06:31.313 --> 03:06:32.347
EXCELLENT MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
03:06:32.414 --> 03:06:35.450
READ. SENATE BILL THIRTEEN FIFTY
03:06:35.517 --> 03:06:36.885
TWO BY SENATOR ALAN AN ACT
03:06:36.952 --> 03:06:38.320
RELATING TO THE POLITICAL REFORM
03:06:38.387 --> 03:06:39.922
ACT OF NINETEEN SEVENTY FOUR
03:06:39.988 --> 03:06:41.390
SENATOR ALAN THANKS SO MUCH NOT
03:06:41.456 --> 03:06:42.858
A PRESIDENT- CAMPAIGN
03:06:42.925 --> 03:06:44.359
CONTRIBUTION DISCLOSURES ARE AN
03:06:44.426 --> 03:06:46.161
IMPORTANT TRANSPARENCY TOOL USED
03:06:46.228 --> 03:06:47.396
TO SHED LIGHT ON INDIVIDUALS AND
03:06:47.462 --> 03:06:49.197
ENTITIES THAT PROVIDE SUPPORT.
03:06:49.264 --> 03:06:50.399
TO CANDIDATES FROM LOOK OFFICE
03:06:50.465 --> 03:06:52.301
THIS BILL SEEKS TO STRENGTHEN
03:06:52.367 --> 03:06:53.035
PUBLIC ACCESS TO CAMPAIGN
03:06:53.101 --> 03:06:54.102
CONTRIBUTION INFORMATION BY
03:06:54.169 --> 03:06:55.137
SPINNING YOU AROUND
03:06:55.203 --> 03:06:55.938
CONTRIBUTIONS CLOSURES LORING
03:06:56.004 --> 03:06:58.006
THE NON ELECTION PEWTER PORTING
03:06:58.073 --> 03:06:59.207
THRESHOLD TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED
03:06:59.274 --> 03:07:01.410
DOLLARS. IN THE REPORTING TIME
03:07:01.476 --> 03:07:03.645
ONE TO FIVE BUSINESS DAYS. HI I
03:07:03.712 --> 03:07:05.614
RESPECTFULLY ASK FROM ABOUT
03:07:05.681 --> 03:07:07.082
THANK YOU SENATOR ALAN MEMBERS
03:07:07.149 --> 03:07:09.618
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
03:07:09.685 --> 03:07:14.456
NIELSEN. THEY DOWN THE SENATE.
03:07:14.523 --> 03:07:17.092
THE LITTLE HOOVER COMMISSION.
03:07:17.159 --> 03:07:19.928
AND CAL ACCESS TO BOTH ACCESS TO
03:07:19.995 --> 03:07:22.731
BOTH. FIND THAT WE ARE A
03:07:22.798 --> 03:07:27.336
SLOWDOWN. THESE BILLS. THAT IT'S
03:07:27.402 --> 03:07:30.872
TIME TO. TAKE A PAUSE AND I
03:07:30.939 --> 03:07:35.177
SHOULD OBSERVE I THINK THAT
03:07:35.243 --> 03:07:36.912
WOULD BE HELPFUL AT THIS POINT
03:07:36.979 --> 03:07:38.246
WITH THIS PARTICULAR BILL. WE
03:07:38.313 --> 03:07:41.717
DON'T NEED IT AND TWO VERY
03:07:41.783 --> 03:07:45.654
LEARNED BODIES HAVE SO APPOINT.
03:07:45.721 --> 03:07:47.756
I WOULD HEED THEIR WISDOM AND
03:07:47.823 --> 03:07:50.492
ASKED THAT WE NOT MOVE AHEAD
03:07:50.559 --> 03:07:52.027
WITH THIS BILL. THANK YOU SIR
03:07:52.094 --> 03:07:54.096
NIELSEN MEMBERS FURTHER
03:07:54.162 --> 03:07:55.964
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. THOROUGH
03:07:56.031 --> 03:08:02.104
CHAU BOOK. THANK YOU MADAM
03:08:02.170 --> 03:08:04.539
PRESIDENT I HAD A QUESTION TO
03:08:04.606 --> 03:08:06.475
THE OTHER FOR THE OTHER ALAMEDA
03:08:06.541 --> 03:08:11.380
QUESTION YES PLEASE PROCEED. MS
03:08:11.446 --> 03:08:13.548
THE FIRST A STATEMENT I AM IN
03:08:13.615 --> 03:08:15.684
FULL SUPPORT OF DISCLOSURE AND
03:08:15.751 --> 03:08:18.286
TRANSPARENCY I THINK THAT IS-
03:08:18.353 --> 03:08:19.421
SOMETHING THAT WE SHOULD ALL
03:08:19.488 --> 03:08:21.056
STRIVE FOR BUT I'M KIND OF
03:08:21.123 --> 03:08:23.058
CURIOUS AS TO THE NEED FOR THE
03:08:23.125 --> 03:08:25.227
SHORTEN PURITY DISCLOSURE.
03:08:25.293 --> 03:08:26.695
REDUCING THE DAYS BECAUSE IT
03:08:26.762 --> 03:08:29.498
SEEMS VERY CUMBERSOME IN A WAY
03:08:29.564 --> 03:08:31.500
SO THE DISCLOSURE IS FINE DURING
03:08:31.566 --> 03:08:34.503
THE AMOUNT IS FINE BUT WHY THE
03:08:34.569 --> 03:08:36.471
NEED TO LOWER THE NUMBER OF
03:08:36.538 --> 03:08:38.874
DAYS. FOR THE REQUIREMENT TO
03:08:38.940 --> 03:08:41.176
DISCLOSURE PURPOSES THE REASON
03:08:41.243 --> 03:08:43.278
CENTER APPRECIATE THE QUESTION A
03:08:43.345 --> 03:08:44.646
GREAT DEAL WE KNOW WE HAVE ALL
03:08:44.713 --> 03:08:45.881
OF THAT VERY TIMELY DISCLOSURE
03:08:45.947 --> 03:08:50.118
AT THE END OF AUCTION CAMPAIGNS.
03:08:50.185 --> 03:08:53.355
BUT TOWARD THE BEGINNING. I THE
03:08:53.422 --> 03:08:55.624
SO SLOW RIGHT WE CAN FINE OUT
03:08:55.691 --> 03:08:57.926
ABOUT OTHER FOLKS REPORTS YOU
03:08:57.993 --> 03:08:59.961
SIX MONTHS AT A TIME AND WE ALL
03:09:00.028 --> 03:09:02.097
KNOW HOW IMPORTANT THE EARLY
03:09:02.164 --> 03:09:02.931
STAGE OF CAMPAIGNS CAN BE
03:09:02.998 --> 03:09:05.867
DETERMINED YET INDETERMINATE-
03:09:05.934 --> 03:09:07.502
YOU KNOW WHAT WHETHER CANDIDATES
03:09:07.569 --> 03:09:08.937
CAN BE VIABLE OR NOT AND TO HAVE
03:09:09.004 --> 03:09:10.505
TO BE THE JUXTAPOSITION BETWEEN
03:09:10.572 --> 03:09:11.940
THE TWENTY FOUR HOUR DISCLOSURE
03:09:12.007 --> 03:09:13.442
OF THE LATE DAYS OF THE CAMPAIGN
03:09:13.508 --> 03:09:17.546
AND EVERY SIX MONTHS DISCLOSURE
03:09:17.612 --> 03:09:21.516
AT EARLY STAGE SEEMS I REALLY.
03:09:21.583 --> 03:09:24.252
HE SAID. HELLO TROUBLED JUST ONE
03:09:24.319 --> 03:09:25.787
OF ALL UP QUESTION PRESIDENT OF
03:09:25.854 --> 03:09:28.523
ALL THE QUESTION SURROUND WE TO
03:09:28.590 --> 03:09:30.459
GO OVERSEAS OF COURSE RECEIVED
03:09:30.525 --> 03:09:31.493
SO WITH REGARDS TO THE TIME
03:09:31.560 --> 03:09:32.894
FRAMES HOW DID YOU COME UP WITH
03:09:32.961 --> 03:09:37.299
THE- THE NUMBER OF DAYS FOR
03:09:37.365 --> 03:09:38.800
DISCLOSURE. YOU HAVE GOT
03:09:38.867 --> 03:09:40.135
TOGETHER VARIOUS GROUPS THAT
03:09:40.202 --> 03:09:42.037
WORK IN IN THE IN THE GOOD
03:09:42.104 --> 03:09:43.805
GOVERNMENT SPACE AND THEN OF
03:09:43.872 --> 03:09:44.973
COURSE WORK OF THE COMMITTEE BUT
03:09:45.040 --> 03:09:47.075
YOU KNOW I DON'T THINK THERE'S
03:09:47.142 --> 03:09:48.176
NO THERE'S NO MAGIC. MEDICAL
03:09:48.243 --> 03:09:49.945
SCIENCE TO THESE. THESE DAYS
03:09:50.011 --> 03:09:51.213
IT'S JUST A MATTER OF TRYING TO
03:09:51.279 --> 03:09:53.048
PROVIDE MORE DISCLOSURE THAT
03:09:53.115 --> 03:09:54.316
CURRENTLY EXISTS IN A MEANINGFUL
03:09:54.382 --> 03:09:55.784
WAY WITHOUT BEING OVERLY ONEROUS
03:09:55.851 --> 03:09:57.152
I WAS YOU KNOW SPOKE TO SOME
03:09:57.219 --> 03:09:58.453
COLLEAGUES. I TALKED SOME
03:09:58.520 --> 03:10:00.055
PREPARE POLITICAL PROFESSIONALS
03:10:00.122 --> 03:10:01.256
WHO WORK ON ON A COMPLIANCE AND
03:10:01.323 --> 03:10:03.625
REPORTING. AND THIS WAS WHERE WE
03:10:03.692 --> 03:10:06.561
LANDED. AB CAN BE INCREASED OR
03:10:06.628 --> 03:10:08.230
DECREASED BY FIVE TEN DAYS YOU
03:10:08.296 --> 03:10:09.531
KNOW MY YEAH OF COURSE WE COULD
03:10:09.598 --> 03:10:11.133
AND I. ABSOLUTE HAPPY TO TAKE-
03:10:11.199 --> 03:10:12.868
MORE FOLKS INPUT AS WE TRY TO
03:10:12.934 --> 03:10:14.836
HONE. I GET TO A PLACE WHERE
03:10:14.903 --> 03:10:17.105
IT'S GOING TO BE- YOU KNOW GOOD.
03:10:17.172 --> 03:10:19.040
BUT THIS IS JUST ABOUT TRYING TO
03:10:19.107 --> 03:10:20.876
TRYING TO GET US DOWN. THAT THAT
03:10:20.942 --> 03:10:22.644
FOR FROM THE ABSOLUTE AT THE
03:10:22.711 --> 03:10:23.445
ABSOLUTE LACK OF INFORMATION
03:10:23.512 --> 03:10:26.581
THAT CURRENTLY EXISTS- YEAH TELL
03:10:26.648 --> 03:10:27.749
THAT. EVERY SIX MONTH REPORTING
03:10:27.816 --> 03:10:29.818
PERIOD. THANK YOU SENATOR ALAN
03:10:29.885 --> 03:10:31.486
MEMBERS ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION
03:10:31.553 --> 03:10:33.855
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING
03:10:33.922 --> 03:10:35.957
ANSWER ELEMENTS LIKE CLOSE. TO
03:10:36.024 --> 03:10:39.027
THIS QUESTION RESEARCHERS THANK
03:10:39.094 --> 03:10:40.162
YOU SIR MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE
03:10:40.228 --> 03:10:42.230
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
03:10:42.297 --> 03:10:46.401
ARCHULETA. AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
03:10:46.468 --> 03:10:52.374
. BAKER I PORCHES. BRADFORD AYE
03:10:52.440 --> 03:10:57.612
CABALLERO. I FOR TESTING I DALY
03:10:57.679 --> 03:11:04.119
. DODD. HI TORONTO HI EGGMAN AYE
03:11:04.186 --> 03:11:10.625
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROW.
03:11:10.692 --> 03:11:15.463
HERTZBERG WESTERN HI FURTADO. I
03:11:15.530 --> 03:11:20.936
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
03:11:21.002 --> 03:11:26.975
LEYVA. I LIMÓN. I MCGUIRE I
03:11:27.042 --> 03:11:32.013
MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN AYE
03:11:32.080 --> 03:11:37.385
NIELSEN NO A CHOI BOGUE I PAN
03:11:37.452 --> 03:11:41.122
AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
03:11:41.189 --> 03:11:45.727
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN AYE
03:11:45.794 --> 03:11:49.397
I'M BURKE. I BY CASTING AYE
03:11:49.464 --> 03:11:52.834
WIENER AYE WILK HI PLEASE CALL
03:11:52.901 --> 03:11:58.039
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. BATES PORGES
03:11:58.106 --> 03:12:05.080
. DALLYING GLAZER I GROVE.
03:12:05.146 --> 03:12:09.684
HERTZBERG MELENDEZ. FIVE THIRTY
03:12:09.751 --> 03:12:11.386
TWO NOSE TO THE MEASURE PASSES
03:12:11.453 --> 03:12:13.889
MEMBERS ARE GOING TO MOVE TO
03:12:13.955 --> 03:12:15.924
FILE ITEM ONE SIXTEEN. METAM PRO
03:12:15.991 --> 03:12:19.394
TEM AND SECRETARY PLEASE READ
03:12:19.461 --> 03:12:21.463
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN SEVENTY
03:12:21.529 --> 03:12:22.898
FIVE BY SENATOR ATKINS AN ACT
03:12:22.964 --> 03:12:25.300
RELATING TO HEALING ARTS CENTER
03:12:25.367 --> 03:12:28.236
ATKINS. THANK YOU VERY MUCH FIVE
03:12:28.303 --> 03:12:29.671
MEN AND PRESENT CALYX I RISE
03:12:29.738 --> 03:12:32.240
TODAY TO PRESENT MY BILL SB
03:12:32.307 --> 03:12:33.808
THIRTEEN SEVENTY FIVE. IN STATE
03:12:33.875 --> 03:12:35.443
HOUSES IN COURTHOUSES ACROSS OUR
03:12:35.510 --> 03:12:37.212
COUNTRY ALL THE WAY UP TO THE
03:12:37.279 --> 03:12:38.780
SUPREME COURT OUR REPRODUCTIVE
03:12:38.847 --> 03:12:39.981
RIGHTS ARE NOT ONLY BEING
03:12:40.048 --> 03:12:41.449
THREATENED BUT FOR SO MANY
03:12:41.516 --> 03:12:43.151
THEY'VE ALREADY BEEN STOLEN.
03:12:43.218 --> 03:12:44.452
ONCE AGAIN WOMEN ARE BEING
03:12:44.519 --> 03:12:46.087
PUSHED TO EXTREME MEASURES TO
03:12:46.154 --> 03:12:48.123
ACCESS ABORTION CARE AND OTHER
03:12:48.189 --> 03:12:51.192
STATES. ONCE AGAIN THEY FACE
03:12:51.259 --> 03:12:52.928
HAVING TO PUT THEIR BODIES IN
03:12:52.994 --> 03:12:53.628
DANGER. THE SUPREME COURT'S
03:12:53.695 --> 03:12:55.530
IMPENDING DECISION ON A CASE
03:12:55.597 --> 03:12:56.898
THAT WILL DESTROY ROE VERSUS
03:12:56.965 --> 03:12:58.667
WADE AND THE RAIL REPRODUCTIVE
03:12:58.733 --> 03:13:00.435
FREEDOM IN AMERICA IS BIGGER
03:13:00.502 --> 03:13:02.971
THAN THIS ONE BILL AND IT STANDS
03:13:03.038 --> 03:13:04.472
TO HAVE A VERY REAL IMPACT ON
03:13:04.539 --> 03:13:06.408
THE LIVES OF MANY OF MOST
03:13:06.474 --> 03:13:06.942
VULNERABLE INDIVIDUALS AND
03:13:07.008 --> 03:13:09.144
COMMUNITIES. THAT DECISION WILL
03:13:09.210 --> 03:13:10.545
CARRY THE WEIGHT OF MILLIONS OF
03:13:10.612 --> 03:13:12.247
WOMEN WHO WILL NOT HAVE A TANAMI
03:13:12.314 --> 03:13:14.282
OVER THEIR OWN BODIES. IT'S A
03:13:14.349 --> 03:13:16.551
DECISION THAT WILL IMPACT WOMEN
03:13:16.618 --> 03:13:17.819
FAMILIES AND OUR COUNTRY FOR
03:13:17.886 --> 03:13:20.088
DECADES TO COME. AND ONCE AGAIN
03:13:20.155 --> 03:13:21.489
WE IN CALIFORNIA FIND OURSELVES
03:13:21.556 --> 03:13:24.592
SAYING NOT ON OUR WATCH THIS IS
03:13:24.659 --> 03:13:26.161
A DECISION WE NEED TO PREPARE
03:13:26.227 --> 03:13:29.831
FOR IN EVERY WAY THAT WE CAN. SB
03:13:29.898 --> 03:13:31.166
THIRTEEN SEVENTY FIVE AS PART OF
03:13:31.232 --> 03:13:32.434
THAT PREPARATION. BY GIVING MORE
03:13:32.500 --> 03:13:34.536
TRAINED AND QUALIFIED NURSE
03:13:34.602 --> 03:13:35.637
PRACTITIONERS THE ABILITY TO
03:13:35.704 --> 03:13:39.007
PROVIDE A PERSON'S THIS. DOCTOR
03:13:39.074 --> 03:13:42.577
SB THIRTEEN SEVENTY FIVE IS
03:13:42.644 --> 03:13:44.045
PROACTIVE. FURTHER IN ACCESS TO.
03:13:44.112 --> 03:13:44.946
QUALITY REPRODUCTIVE CARE IN
03:13:45.013 --> 03:13:47.749
CALIFORNIA. CALIFORNIA HAS LONG
03:13:47.816 --> 03:13:49.084
BEEN A LEADER IN REPRODUCTIVE
03:13:49.150 --> 03:13:51.152
RIGHTS BUT THE PRACTICAL NEED TO
03:13:51.219 --> 03:13:53.455
ENSURE REAL ACCESS IS FAR FROM
03:13:53.521 --> 03:13:55.824
COMPLETE. ONE EARLY STEP THAT I
03:13:55.890 --> 03:13:58.860
TOOK WAS OFFERING AB ONE FIFTY
03:13:58.927 --> 03:14:00.695
FOUR IN TWENTY THIRTEEN TO
03:14:00.762 --> 03:14:02.664
EXPAND THE TYPES OF HEALTH CARE
03:14:02.731 --> 03:14:03.298
PROVIDERS WHO CAN PERFORM FIRST
03:14:03.365 --> 03:14:04.599
TERM ABORTIONS WITH THE
03:14:04.666 --> 03:14:06.301
SUPERVISION OF A DOCTOR TO
03:14:06.368 --> 03:14:08.436
INCLUDE NURSE PRACTITIONERS.
03:14:08.503 --> 03:14:10.338
THEN SEVEN YEARS LATER THE
03:14:10.405 --> 03:14:11.539
LEGISLATURE PASSED AB EIGHT
03:14:11.606 --> 03:14:13.641
NINETY. AUTHORED BY ASSEMBLY
03:14:13.708 --> 03:14:15.377
MEMBER WOULD AND CREATED
03:14:15.443 --> 03:14:17.112
OPPORTUNITIES FOR QUALIFYING
03:14:17.178 --> 03:14:18.513
NURSE PRACTITIONERS TO CARE FOR
03:14:18.580 --> 03:14:20.482
PATIENTS WITHOUT THE SUPERVISION
03:14:20.548 --> 03:14:22.817
OF A DOCTOR. NOW WE NEED TO MAKE
03:14:22.884 --> 03:14:24.052
SURE THOSE LAWS CAN WORK
03:14:24.119 --> 03:14:27.288
TOGETHER IN UNISON. SB THIRTEEN
03:14:27.355 --> 03:14:28.390
SEVENTY FIVE WOULD MAKE IT CLEAR
03:14:28.456 --> 03:14:30.158
THAT NURSE PRACTITIONERS TO
03:14:30.225 --> 03:14:31.559
PRACTICE INDEPENDENTLY CAN ALSO
03:14:31.626 --> 03:14:33.561
PROVIDE FIRST TERM ABORTIONS
03:14:33.628 --> 03:14:34.029
WITHOUT A PHYSICIAN'S
03:14:34.095 --> 03:14:36.031
SUPERVISION. THE BILL ALSO
03:14:36.097 --> 03:14:37.332
CLARIFIES THAT AMONG OTHER
03:14:37.399 --> 03:14:39.034
CRITERIA NURSE PRACTITIONERS
03:14:39.100 --> 03:14:40.835
NEED THREE YEARS OF EXPERIENCE
03:14:40.902 --> 03:14:43.004
UNDER A PHYSICIAN IN ORDER TO BE
03:14:43.071 --> 03:14:45.540
ABLE TO PRACTICE INDEPENDENTLY.
03:14:45.607 --> 03:14:46.207
ADDITIONALLY AMENDMENTS MADE TO
03:14:46.274 --> 03:14:49.611
THE BILL AS IT CAME OUT OF THE
03:14:49.677 --> 03:14:50.645
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
03:14:50.712 --> 03:14:51.846
WOULD REMOVE BARRIERS AND
03:14:51.913 --> 03:14:53.848
CURRENT LAW THAT MAKE IT. FOR A
03:14:53.915 --> 03:14:55.550
PRACTICE CLINIC. TRAINING FOR
03:14:55.617 --> 03:14:57.786
ABORTION CARE. ADVANCED PRACTICE
03:14:57.852 --> 03:14:59.254
CLINICIANS PLAY A CRITICAL ROLE
03:14:59.320 --> 03:15:01.289
IN PROVIDING REPRODUCTIVE CARE.
03:15:01.356 --> 03:15:03.058
BY REMOVING BARRIERS TO ABORTION
03:15:03.124 --> 03:15:04.759
TRAINING ALLOWING EXPERIENCED
03:15:04.826 --> 03:15:06.561
NURSE PRACTITIONERS TO UTILIZE
03:15:06.628 --> 03:15:07.762
THEIR FULL TRAINING AND
03:15:07.829 --> 03:15:10.732
EDUCATION. SB THIRTEEN SEVENTY
03:15:10.799 --> 03:15:12.167
FIVE LOOKS BEYOND THE NUMBER OF
03:15:12.233 --> 03:15:13.268
QUALIFIED REPRODUCTIVE CARE
03:15:13.334 --> 03:15:18.006
PRACTITIONER. CHECK IS ASKING AT
03:15:18.073 --> 03:15:21.342
THE K. SB SEVENTY FIVE BILLS
03:15:21.409 --> 03:15:23.411
OFFER THIS OF EIGHT ONE FIFTY
03:15:23.478 --> 03:15:24.913
FOUR END AB EIGHT NINETY TO
03:15:24.979 --> 03:15:25.680
FURTHER STRENGTHEN. AND EXPAND
03:15:25.747 --> 03:15:27.082
ACCESS TO REPRODUCTIVE CARE
03:15:27.148 --> 03:15:28.616
WHILE ALSO LIFTING UP A
03:15:28.683 --> 03:15:30.652
WORKFORCE OF SKILLED NURSE
03:15:30.718 --> 03:15:32.020
PRACTITIONERS AND GIVING THEM
03:15:32.087 --> 03:15:33.555
MORE OPPORTUNITIES TO CARE FOR
03:15:33.621 --> 03:15:35.557
THEIR OWN PATIENTS. WHAT TIME
03:15:35.623 --> 03:15:37.258
SEEMS TO BE MOVING BACKWARD IN
03:15:37.325 --> 03:15:38.526
MANY PLACES ACROSS OUR NATION
03:15:38.593 --> 03:15:40.195
THIS BILL WOULDHELP CALIFORNIA
03:15:40.261 --> 03:15:42.597
CONTINUE MOVING FORWARD. I
03:15:42.664 --> 03:15:43.765
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
03:15:43.832 --> 03:15:45.266
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER TKINS
03:15:45.333 --> 03:15:47.135
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
03:15:47.202 --> 03:15:49.337
SENATOR MEN. THANK YOU MADAM
03:15:49.404 --> 03:15:51.339
PRESIDENT I WANT TO THANK MY
03:15:51.406 --> 03:15:52.173
COLLEAGUE FROM SAN DIEGO FOR
03:15:52.240 --> 03:15:54.275
INTRODUCING THIS BILL AND I'M
03:15:54.342 --> 03:15:56.311
PROUD TO BE A CO AUTHOR OF IT-
03:15:56.377 --> 03:15:58.746
ONE FORTUNE WE LIVE IN A TIME
03:15:58.813 --> 03:16:01.282
WHEN WE HAVE A VERY RADICAL-
03:16:01.349 --> 03:16:03.785
BENCH INCLUDING FIVE MEMBERS OF
03:16:03.852 --> 03:16:05.787
THE SUPREME COURT HOOST TALK
03:16:05.854 --> 03:16:07.522
ABOUT CALLING BALLS AND STRIKES.
03:16:07.589 --> 03:16:08.289
ARE THEY TALK ABOUT BEING
03:16:08.356 --> 03:16:10.658
NEUTRAL ARBITERS OF JUSTICE ALL
03:16:10.725 --> 03:16:11.793
THREE OF THEM STOOD BEFORE THE
03:16:11.860 --> 03:16:12.894
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND
03:16:12.961 --> 03:16:14.529
SAID UNDER OATH THAT THEY
03:16:14.596 --> 03:16:16.097
RESPECTED ROE V. WADE IS A
03:16:16.164 --> 03:16:18.032
PRECEDENT AS WELL AS A NUMBER OF
03:16:18.099 --> 03:16:20.068
OTHER KEY DECISIONS THAT
03:16:20.135 --> 03:16:22.637
ESTABLISHED A RIGHT TO PRIVACY.
03:16:22.704 --> 03:16:25.106
AS PART SUCH. S. THESE. HAVE
03:16:25.173 --> 03:16:26.841
PROVEN THEMSELVES TO BE LIARS TO
03:16:26.908 --> 03:16:28.910
BE RADICAL EXTREMISTS. ARE AN
03:16:28.977 --> 03:16:30.712
UNFORTUNATE TODAY WE ARE DEALING
03:16:30.778 --> 03:16:31.813
WITH AN ENVIRONMENT WHERE THEY
03:16:31.880 --> 03:16:34.315
HAVE TAKEN AWAY. ARE EXPECTED TO
03:16:34.382 --> 03:16:35.550
TAKE AWAY A WOMAN'S RIGHT TO
03:16:35.617 --> 03:16:37.652
ACCESS ABORTIONS. I THEY WILL
03:16:37.719 --> 03:16:39.454
PROBABLY GO AFTER OTHER RIGHTS
03:16:39.521 --> 03:16:40.021
NEXT. AND SO I THINK IT'S
03:16:40.088 --> 03:16:41.789
CRITICAL THAT WE IN THIS STATE
03:16:41.856 --> 03:16:42.957
STAND UP FOR JUSTICE FOR LONG
03:16:43.024 --> 03:16:44.492
ESTABLISHED PRINCIPLES OF
03:16:44.559 --> 03:16:47.529
PRIVACY. ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE-
03:16:47.595 --> 03:16:49.364
OTHER FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS THAT WE
03:16:49.430 --> 03:16:51.366
HAVE TAKEN FOR GRANTED FOR FAR
03:16:51.432 --> 03:16:52.634
TOO LONG. AND CALIFORNIA IS
03:16:52.700 --> 03:16:54.736
GONNA HAVE TO LEAD FOR I DO
03:16:54.802 --> 03:16:56.337
THAT. WE WILL HAVE TO BE A
03:16:56.404 --> 03:16:57.438
SANCTUARY STATE FOR ABORTION
03:16:57.505 --> 03:17:00.575
ACCESS HI THIS BILL IS HELPING
03:17:00.642 --> 03:17:01.776
TO PREPARE FOR THE DEMAND THAT
03:17:01.843 --> 03:17:02.844
WE'VE ALREADY SEEN INCREASE
03:17:02.911 --> 03:17:04.112
WE'VE SEEN A NUMBER OF WOMEN
03:17:04.179 --> 03:17:05.713
ALREADY TRAVEL TO CALIFORNIA. IN
03:17:05.780 --> 03:17:06.915
THE WAKE OF DRACONIAN LAWS
03:17:06.981 --> 03:17:09.117
PASSED IN THEIR HOME STATES- AND
03:17:09.184 --> 03:17:10.185
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO CONTINUE
03:17:10.251 --> 03:17:12.687
TO FACE THIS SURGING DEMAND. WE
03:17:12.754 --> 03:17:14.956
HAVE TO LEAD SO I AM PROUD TO BE
03:17:15.023 --> 03:17:16.991
A CO AUTHOR THIS BILL AGAIN WANT
03:17:17.058 --> 03:17:18.393
TO THANK MY COLLEAGUE FROM SAN
03:17:18.459 --> 03:17:19.227
DIEGO FOR BRINGING THIS. OP
03:17:19.294 --> 03:17:21.796
UNFORTUNATE THINK THIS IS THE
03:17:21.863 --> 03:17:22.430
BEGINNING A LONG FIGHT THEY WILL
03:17:22.497 --> 03:17:23.898
BE FACING. THANK YOU SENATOR
03:17:23.965 --> 03:17:27.001
MEANT SENATOR WIENER. I THANK
03:17:27.068 --> 03:17:29.270
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT I ALSO RISE
03:17:29.337 --> 03:17:31.372
IN SUPPORT OF SB THIRTEEN
03:17:31.439 --> 03:17:32.807
SEVENTY FIVE WANT TO THANK THE
03:17:32.874 --> 03:17:34.275
PROTON I WOULD LOVE TO BE ADDED
03:17:34.342 --> 03:17:35.977
AS A CO AUTHOR- IN THE ASSEMBLY
03:17:36.044 --> 03:17:38.346
ON YOU KNOW I WAS LISTENING TO A
03:17:38.413 --> 03:17:39.480
pPODCAST THE OTHER DAY ABOUT THE
03:17:39.547 --> 03:17:41.749
SITUATION IN TEXAS THE HEALTH
03:17:41.816 --> 03:17:43.551
CARE DISASTER WHAT'S HAPPENING
03:17:43.618 --> 03:17:45.253
IN TEXAS AS A- MOVE TOWARDS
03:17:45.320 --> 03:17:48.189
EFFECTIVELY ARE BANNING-
03:17:48.256 --> 03:17:50.024
ABORTION. AND WHAT I HEARD
03:17:50.091 --> 03:17:53.661
LISTEN TO A PHYSICIAN- AND-
03:17:53.728 --> 03:17:57.565
OBSTETRICIAN WHO- WHO- PERFORMS
03:17:57.632 --> 03:17:59.000
ABORTIONS AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE
03:17:59.067 --> 03:18:00.935
HEALTH SERVICES BOB TALKING
03:18:01.002 --> 03:18:02.170
ABOUT HOW THEY'VE BEEN
03:18:02.237 --> 03:18:05.006
REFERRING- PEOPLE SEEKING
03:18:05.073 --> 03:18:07.342
ABORTION SERVICES TO THE GO TO
03:18:07.408 --> 03:18:08.843
NEW MEXICO BECAUSE ON LIGHT
03:18:08.910 --> 03:18:10.478
TEXAS NEW MEXICO HAS NOT
03:18:10.545 --> 03:18:13.448
CRIMINALIZED ON ABORTION-
03:18:13.514 --> 03:18:14.882
HOWEVER THE CLINICS IN NEW
03:18:14.949 --> 03:18:17.018
MEXICO ARE INTENSELY BACKLOG
03:18:17.085 --> 03:18:18.586
BECAUSE THERE ARE NOT ENOUGH.
03:18:18.653 --> 03:18:20.355
HEALTH PROVIDERS THERE TO TAKE
03:18:20.421 --> 03:18:22.156
TO CARE FOR NACHOS PEOPLE IN
03:18:22.223 --> 03:18:23.758
MEXICO BUT ALSO TEXANS WERE
03:18:23.825 --> 03:18:25.360
COMING ACROSS THE BORDER BECAUSE
03:18:25.426 --> 03:18:27.195
OF THE DESPICABLE ACTION OF
03:18:27.262 --> 03:18:28.696
THEIR STATE GOVERNMENT- HAS
03:18:28.763 --> 03:18:30.932
TAKEN- AND SO THIS DOCTOR WAS
03:18:30.999 --> 03:18:32.800
QUESTIONING SHOULD I MOVED TO
03:18:32.867 --> 03:18:35.637
NEW MEXICO. TO HELP- AND ITS
03:18:35.703 --> 03:18:36.938
RECENT BECAUSE NO ONE SHOULD BE
03:18:37.005 --> 03:18:39.774
IN A POSITION TO WONDER DO I
03:18:39.841 --> 03:18:41.542
SAID I APPROVED AT OUT OF A
03:18:41.609 --> 03:18:42.844
SENSE OF OBLIGATION TO MY
03:18:42.910 --> 03:18:44.412
PATIENTS. TO ANOTHER STATE SO
03:18:44.479 --> 03:18:46.948
MAKE SURE WE- STRENGTHENING
03:18:47.015 --> 03:18:49.550
EXPANDS I'M REPRODUCTVE HEALTH
03:18:49.617 --> 03:18:51.753
RIGHTS IN CALIFORNIA THAT'S NOT
03:18:51.819 --> 03:18:54.022
JUST ON PAPER THAT WE ACTUALLY
03:18:54.088 --> 03:18:55.890
HAVE THE CAPACITY TO PROVIDE
03:18:55.957 --> 03:18:58.359
THOSE SERVICES WE HAVE WE KNOW
03:18:58.426 --> 03:19:00.728
WE HAVE- A PHYSICIAN SHORTAGE IN
03:19:00.795 --> 03:19:02.864
CALIFORNIA AND- THE NECESSARY
03:19:02.930 --> 03:19:05.300
BUT MANY AREAS- I'M WE HAVE
03:19:05.366 --> 03:19:06.801
NURSE PRACTITIONERS. ARE
03:19:06.868 --> 03:19:09.437
COMPLETELY QUALIFIED TO PERFORM
03:19:09.504 --> 03:19:11.072
THIS REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH SERVICE
03:19:11.139 --> 03:19:13.107
IT SHOULD BE ABOUT TO DO SO AND-
03:19:13.174 --> 03:19:14.309
IS AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
03:19:14.375 --> 03:19:20.682
SENATOR. WIENER CENTER SKINNER.
03:19:20.748 --> 03:19:22.383
I ALSO WANT TO THANK THE ARE TEM
03:19:22.450 --> 03:19:25.320
FOR US THIS BILL- THE POINTS
03:19:25.386 --> 03:19:26.554
THAT MY COLLEAGUE FROM SAN
03:19:26.621 --> 03:19:28.222
FRANCISCO MADE WERE SIMILAR TO
03:19:28.289 --> 03:19:30.591
THE ONES I WAS GOING TO MAKE AND
03:19:30.658 --> 03:19:31.893
ALSO MY COLLEAGUE FROM IRVINE.
03:19:31.959 --> 03:19:34.195
THAT WE ALREADY HAVE A SHORTAGE
03:19:34.262 --> 03:19:36.297
OF DOCTORS IN OUR STATE IN
03:19:36.364 --> 03:19:39.133
CALIFORNIA. AND WE ARE GOING TO
03:19:39.200 --> 03:19:41.703
SEE AN INCREASING. NEED TO HAVE
03:19:41.769 --> 03:19:44.305
PRACTITIONERS. BECAUSE OTHER
03:19:44.372 --> 03:19:46.841
STATES ARE GOING TO PREVENT
03:19:46.908 --> 03:19:49.577
PEOPLE IN THOSE STATES FROM
03:19:49.644 --> 03:19:53.748
ACCESSING A- SAFE. WHAT IS IN
03:19:53.815 --> 03:19:55.350
OUR STATE LEGAL MEDICAL
03:19:55.416 --> 03:19:57.719
PROCEDURE THAT EVERY PERSON HAS
03:19:57.785 --> 03:20:01.522
THE RIGHT TO HAVE AND WITH A
03:20:01.589 --> 03:20:02.690
INDEPENDENT OF THE SUPREME
03:20:02.757 --> 03:20:04.325
COURT'S DECISION WE ALREADY HAVE
03:20:04.392 --> 03:20:06.394
STATES DOING THAT AND WE ALREADY
03:20:06.461 --> 03:20:08.196
KNOW THAT WE HAVE AN INCREASE OF
03:20:08.262 --> 03:20:10.431
PEOPLE COMING FROM ELSEWHERE TO
03:20:10.498 --> 03:20:13.868
CALIFORNIA SO NOT ONLY IS THIS
03:20:13.935 --> 03:20:16.804
JUST SMART TO DO BECAUSE THE
03:20:16.871 --> 03:20:19.173
NURSE PRACTITIONERS HAVE THE
03:20:19.240 --> 03:20:21.609
FULL QUALIFICATIONS TO DO THIS
03:20:21.676 --> 03:20:25.380
VERY SAFE. MEDICAL PROCEDURE IT
03:20:25.446 --> 03:20:27.048
WILL ALSO REDUCE THE STAIN ON
03:20:27.115 --> 03:20:28.816
OUR DOCTORS FOR WHICH WE ALREADY
03:20:28.883 --> 03:20:31.419
HAVE A DOCTOR SHORTAGE AND THIS
03:20:31.486 --> 03:20:34.188
JUST CONTINUES- LEADERSHIP THAT
03:20:34.255 --> 03:20:37.992
THE PRO TEMAS CARRIED ON THIS-
03:20:38.059 --> 03:20:40.395
VIEW ALLOWING FOR THIS CHANGE OF
03:20:40.461 --> 03:20:42.897
A SCOPE FOR YEARS NOW BUT IT
03:20:42.964 --> 03:20:44.799
HELPS ENSURE THAT WE ACTUALLY
03:20:44.866 --> 03:20:46.434
ACCOMPLISH IT WHEN WE ARE GOING
03:20:46.501 --> 03:20:48.269
TO NEED IT THE MOST IN
03:20:48.336 --> 03:20:49.036
CALIFORNIA AND WITH THAT I ASK
03:20:49.103 --> 03:20:51.305
FOR YOUR I. BOATS THANK YOU
03:20:51.372 --> 03:20:52.306
CENTER SKINNER MEMBERS FURTHER
03:20:52.373 --> 03:20:54.008
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING
03:20:54.075 --> 03:20:56.177
HEARING NONE BETTER PROTECT ME
03:20:56.244 --> 03:20:58.413
MY CLOTHES THANK YOU- AND TO MY
03:20:58.479 --> 03:20:59.580
COLLEAGUES YOUR COMMENTS ARE
03:20:59.647 --> 03:21:01.149
ONLY TWO OTHER POINTS I WANT TO
03:21:01.215 --> 03:21:03.317
MAKE BECAUSE THIS BILL- SHOULD
03:21:03.384 --> 03:21:05.186
IT WITH YOUR SUPPORT GET OFF
03:21:05.253 --> 03:21:06.087
THIS FLOOR TODAY MOVES TO THE
03:21:06.154 --> 03:21:08.589
ASSEMBLY I WANT TO SAY I'VE I'VE
03:21:08.656 --> 03:21:11.325
WORKED DILIGENTLY- WITH A
03:21:11.392 --> 03:21:13.628
STAKEHOLDERS TO TRY TO SURE THAT
03:21:13.694 --> 03:21:14.896
WE ARE ENHANCING IN EVERY WAY
03:21:14.962 --> 03:21:18.232
POSSIBLE ADEQUATE TRAINING AND
03:21:18.299 --> 03:21:20.034
TRAINING. FOR TWO ALREADY HAVE A
03:21:20.101 --> 03:21:21.536
LOT OF THIS TRAINING WHICH IS
03:21:21.602 --> 03:21:23.504
WHY WE'RE LOOKING AT THIS PIECE
03:21:23.571 --> 03:21:24.639
OF LEGISLATION BUT I JUST WANT
03:21:24.705 --> 03:21:26.441
TO SAY WALL CORNY LEADS THE WAY
03:21:26.507 --> 03:21:29.177
IN TERMS OF THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY
03:21:29.243 --> 03:21:31.045
WHICH IN THIS STATE AND ACROSS
03:21:31.112 --> 03:21:33.147
THIS COUNTRY UNTIL RECENT HAS
03:21:33.214 --> 03:21:37.351
INCLUDED THE PORTION. RIGHT NOT
03:21:37.418 --> 03:21:39.253
LEADING WAY. TO THOSE WHO CAN
03:21:39.320 --> 03:21:40.388
PROVIDE THE SERVICE. NINE OTHERS
03:21:40.455 --> 03:21:41.656
. ALLOW FOR AND TRAINERS
03:21:41.722 --> 03:21:43.724
PRACTITIONERS ALREADY TO PROVIDE
03:21:43.791 --> 03:21:45.993
FIRST TRIMESTER ABORTION WITHOUT
03:21:46.060 --> 03:21:47.562
SUPERVISION OF A DOCTOR.
03:21:47.628 --> 03:21:49.964
CALIFORNIA ALREADY ALSO REQUIRES
03:21:50.031 --> 03:21:52.133
MORE HOURS OF TRAINING AND YEARS
03:21:52.200 --> 03:21:54.135
OF EXPERIENCE THAN ANY OTHER
03:21:54.202 --> 03:21:56.404
STATE THAT HAS A TRANSITION TO
03:21:56.471 --> 03:21:57.805
PRACTICE FOR NURSE PRACTITIONERS
03:21:57.872 --> 03:22:00.041
AND I JUST WANT TO PUT THAT OUT
03:22:00.107 --> 03:22:02.076
THERE BECAUSE I THINK THE ISSUE.
03:22:02.143 --> 03:22:04.612
IS QUALITY HEALTHCARE AND ACCESS
03:22:04.679 --> 03:22:06.314
THESE PRACTITIONERS ARE TRAINED
03:22:06.380 --> 03:22:08.483
THEY ARE READY THEY WANT TO
03:22:08.549 --> 03:22:09.183
SERVE THEIR PATIENTS WE ARE
03:22:09.250 --> 03:22:10.918
MAKING SURE. THAT THE
03:22:10.985 --> 03:22:12.887
PROTECTIONS ARE IN PLACE AND
03:22:12.954 --> 03:22:14.589
WE'RE FOLLOWING THE LEAD ON THIS
03:22:14.655 --> 03:22:15.990
OF NINE OTHER STATES WHO HAVE
03:22:16.057 --> 03:22:17.658
PROVEN THAT THIS CAN BE DONE
03:22:17.725 --> 03:22:20.361
SAFELY AND EFFECTIVELY SO WITH
03:22:20.428 --> 03:22:22.396
THAT I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
03:22:22.463 --> 03:22:24.432
AYE VOTE THANK. MENEM'S VERY
03:22:24.499 --> 03:22:29.103
PLEASE CALL. ALLEN I ARCHULETA
03:22:29.170 --> 03:22:34.542
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER. I
03:22:34.609 --> 03:22:38.846
FOR JUST NO BRADFORD I COME BY
03:22:38.913 --> 03:22:42.884
OTHER I PROTECTING AYE DALY NO
03:22:42.950 --> 03:22:48.489
DODD. I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
03:22:48.556 --> 03:22:52.760
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW NO
03:22:52.827 --> 03:22:58.799
HERTZBERG WESSEL II FURTADO. I
03:22:58.866 --> 03:23:04.505
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
03:23:04.572 --> 03:23:09.010
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE. I
03:23:09.076 --> 03:23:13.681
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
03:23:13.748 --> 03:23:19.320
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLE NO PAN. I
03:23:19.387 --> 03:23:24.926
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO
03:23:24.992 --> 03:23:29.230
FIVE SKINNER I STERN HI I'M
03:23:29.297 --> 03:23:32.633
BURKE I WHITE HOUSE BEING AYE
03:23:32.700 --> 03:23:36.871
WIENER AYE WILK NO. HIGHS THIRTY
03:23:36.938 --> 03:23:38.639
KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
03:23:38.706 --> 03:23:41.676
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
03:23:41.742 --> 03:23:43.878
EIGHTY ONE SENATOR ATKINS MADAM
03:23:43.945 --> 03:23:46.147
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
03:23:46.213 --> 03:23:48.282
BILL TEN THIRTEEN BY SENATOR
03:23:48.349 --> 03:23:49.517
ATKINS AN ACT RELATING TO
03:23:49.584 --> 03:23:50.284
RECYCLING AND MAKING AN
03:23:50.351 --> 03:23:51.652
APPROPRIATION THEREFORE CENTER
03:23:51.719 --> 03:23:54.455
ATKINS THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
03:23:54.522 --> 03:23:56.591
COLLEAGUES SB TEN THIRTEEN ADDS
03:23:56.657 --> 03:23:58.626
WINE AND DISTILLED SPIRITS TO
03:23:58.693 --> 03:24:00.661
CALIFORNIA'S BOTTLE BILL PROGRAM
03:24:00.728 --> 03:24:02.229
TO INCREASE RECYCLING RATES AND
03:24:02.296 --> 03:24:03.497
TO PROVIDE MORE CONVENIENT
03:24:03.564 --> 03:24:04.665
RECYCLING OPPORTUNITIES FOR
03:24:04.732 --> 03:24:07.168
CONSUMERS. FIRST I REALLY WANT
03:24:07.234 --> 03:24:09.203
TO THANK THE SENATOR FROM NAPA
03:24:09.270 --> 03:24:10.104
FOR COLLABORATING WITH ME ON
03:24:10.171 --> 03:24:12.139
THIS ISSUE AND THIS MEASURE HIS
03:24:12.206 --> 03:24:13.608
POLICY KNOWLEDGE AND THE
03:24:13.674 --> 03:24:15.209
ESTABLISHED RELATIONSHIPS HE HAS
03:24:15.276 --> 03:24:17.511
IN THIS INDUSTRY HAVE BEEN OF
03:24:17.578 --> 03:24:19.513
INCREDIBLE VALUE AS THE
03:24:19.580 --> 03:24:21.549
LEGISLATION WAS CRAFTED. I ALSO
03:24:21.616 --> 03:24:23.451
WANT TO COMMEND SENATOR FROM
03:24:23.517 --> 03:24:25.419
FREMONT FOR HIS YEARS OF
03:24:25.486 --> 03:24:27.755
ADVOCACY AND IMPROVING THE
03:24:27.822 --> 03:24:28.623
BOTTLE BILL PROGRAM.
03:24:28.689 --> 03:24:29.790
CALIFORNIA'S BEVERAGE CONTAINER
03:24:29.857 --> 03:24:31.759
RECYCLING AND LITTER REDUCTION
03:24:31.826 --> 03:24:34.595
ACT TOOK EFFECT IN NINETEEN
03:24:34.662 --> 03:24:35.329
EIGHTY SIX SINCE THIS TIME THE
03:24:35.396 --> 03:24:36.764
PROGRAM HAS SUCCESSFULLY
03:24:36.831 --> 03:24:37.999
RESULTED IN DRAMATICALLY
03:24:38.065 --> 03:24:39.467
INCREASING RECYCLING FOR
03:24:39.533 --> 03:24:41.969
ALUMINUM GLASS. AND PT BECAUSE
03:24:42.036 --> 03:24:44.005
I'M NOT EVEN GOING TO TRY TO SAY
03:24:44.071 --> 03:24:45.473
WHAT THAT STANDS FOR. OUR
03:24:45.539 --> 03:24:47.341
PLASTIC BEVERAGE CONTAINERS
03:24:47.408 --> 03:24:49.443
HOWEVER THE CURRENT PROGRAM DOES
03:24:49.510 --> 03:24:51.445
HAVE A GAP IN THE TYPES OF
03:24:51.512 --> 03:24:52.947
RECYCLABLES IT ACCEPTS.
03:24:53.014 --> 03:24:54.849
SPECIFICALLY WINE AND DISTILLED
03:24:54.915 --> 03:24:58.352
SPIRITS- CONTAINERS THAT MAKE UP
03:24:58.419 --> 03:24:59.754
A SIGNIFICANT FRACTION OF THE
03:24:59.820 --> 03:25:01.288
BEVERAGE CONTAINER THREE HAVE
03:25:01.355 --> 03:25:03.157
NOT BEEN RECYCLABLE UNDER THE
03:25:03.224 --> 03:25:05.726
EXISTING BOTTLE BILL. PROGRAM
03:25:05.793 --> 03:25:07.595
THIS CREATES CONFUSION AND IN
03:25:07.662 --> 03:25:09.163
EQUITIES IN THE PROGRAM AND A
03:25:09.230 --> 03:25:10.865
FINANCIAL BURDEN FOR CONSUMERS
03:25:10.931 --> 03:25:12.033
WHO HAVE TO PAY THE COST OF
03:25:12.099 --> 03:25:13.701
RECYCLING WINE AND DISTILLED
03:25:13.768 --> 03:25:15.770
SPIRITS CONTAINERS. AS PART OF
03:25:15.836 --> 03:25:16.637
THEIR MONTHLY GARBAGE OR
03:25:16.704 --> 03:25:19.507
RECYCLING BILLS. SB TEN THIRTEEN
03:25:19.573 --> 03:25:20.808
REMEDIES THIS PROBLEM BY
03:25:20.875 --> 03:25:22.076
ENSURING WINE AND SPIRITS
03:25:22.143 --> 03:25:23.244
BEVERAGE CONTAINERS ARE TREATED
03:25:23.310 --> 03:25:25.680
THE SAME AS OTHER BEVERAGE
03:25:25.746 --> 03:25:26.347
CONTAINERS UNDER THE BOTTLE BILL
03:25:26.414 --> 03:25:28.516
PROGRAM. THE SIMPLE ADDITION OF
03:25:28.582 --> 03:25:30.217
ADDING WINE AND SPIRITS
03:25:30.284 --> 03:25:32.286
BEVERAGES TO THIS PROGRAM IS
03:25:32.353 --> 03:25:34.021
HISTORIC CHANGE IN THE LAW THAT
03:25:34.088 --> 03:25:36.123
IS FORTY YEARS IN THE MAKING. I
03:25:36.190 --> 03:25:38.059
WANT TO COMMEND THE WINE
03:25:38.125 --> 03:25:38.592
INDUSTRY DISTILLED SPIRITS
03:25:38.659 --> 03:25:40.928
INDUSTRY ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES
03:25:40.995 --> 03:25:42.163
AND OTHERS WHO COME TOGETHER TO
03:25:42.229 --> 03:25:44.398
SUPPORT THIS LANDMARK PROPOSAL.
03:25:44.465 --> 03:25:45.833
I'LL CONTINUE TO WORK WITH ALL
03:25:45.900 --> 03:25:46.834
THE PARTIES TO ENSURE THESE
03:25:46.901 --> 03:25:50.471
ISSUES ARE. THAT HAVE BEEN HEARD
03:25:50.538 --> 03:25:51.105
WILL BE ADDRESSED AS THE BILL
03:25:51.172 --> 03:25:53.541
PROGRESSES- S. B. TEN THIRTEEN
03:25:53.607 --> 03:25:56.477
ALONG WITH- SENATOR ALLEN'S
03:25:56.544 --> 03:25:57.712
EFFORTS TO ADDRESS PLASTIC
03:25:57.778 --> 03:25:59.280
POLLUTION. AND THE GOVERNOR SIR
03:25:59.346 --> 03:26:03.584
KANEMI BUT- BUT RESULT. IN THE
03:26:03.651 --> 03:26:05.119
TWO TWENTY TO BRING MOST IN YEAR
03:26:05.186 --> 03:26:06.120
IN RECYCLING AND REDUCING SOLID
03:26:06.187 --> 03:26:08.656
WASTE IN DECADES. I RESPECTFULLY
03:26:08.723 --> 03:26:10.758
ASK FOR AN IPHONE. THANK YOU
03:26:10.825 --> 03:26:13.394
CENTER ATKINS MEMBERS DISCUSSION
03:26:13.461 --> 03:26:16.063
AND DEBATE CENTER DOT. IT'S BEEN
03:26:16.130 --> 03:26:18.132
A PRESIDENT MEMBERS I REALLY
03:26:18.199 --> 03:26:20.034
WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE PRO TEM
03:26:20.101 --> 03:26:21.969
FOR HER LEADERSHIP IN THIS ISSUE
03:26:22.036 --> 03:26:24.271
OBVIOUSLY- SHE'S ABSOLUTELY
03:26:24.338 --> 03:26:26.507
RIGHT THIS IS A LONG TIME IN
03:26:26.574 --> 03:26:29.143
COMING. IT TO BE ABLE TO GET THE
03:26:29.210 --> 03:26:30.878
WINE INDUSTRY IN THE SPIRITS
03:26:30.945 --> 03:26:33.347
INDUSTRY YOU KNOW IN THE ROOM-
03:26:33.414 --> 03:26:35.850
WITH THE ADVOCATES- TO COME TO
03:26:35.916 --> 03:26:37.952
SUCH A SOLUTION AS WE HAVE TODAY
03:26:38.018 --> 03:26:39.120
IS NOT ONLY BETTER FOR
03:26:39.186 --> 03:26:41.822
CONSUMERS. IT'S BETTER FOR- THE
03:26:41.889 --> 03:26:44.558
RECYCLING AGENCIES IT JUST FROM
03:26:44.625 --> 03:26:46.727
A CONSISTENCY STANDPOINT IN
03:26:46.794 --> 03:26:48.763
POLICY THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
03:26:48.829 --> 03:26:49.864
CALIFORNIA SO I RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:26:49.930 --> 03:26:52.133
YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
03:26:52.199 --> 03:26:55.002
DODD SENATOR MURKOWSKI.
03:26:55.069 --> 03:26:55.903
RESIDENTS TO RICIN SUPPORT OF
03:26:55.970 --> 03:26:57.338
THE MEASURE AND THANK TO PRO
03:26:57.404 --> 03:27:01.742
TEMP FOR THE WORK- NO MARC IS A
03:27:01.809 --> 03:27:04.211
INDEPENDENT THING TAKE THAT DID
03:27:04.278 --> 03:27:06.580
A REPORT IN TWENTY NINETEEN AND
03:27:06.647 --> 03:27:08.616
THEY SUGGEST THAT WE HAVE. OVER
03:27:08.682 --> 03:27:11.218
A BILLION BOTTLES OF WINE AND
03:27:11.285 --> 03:27:13.287
SPIRITS THAT DID NOT GET
03:27:13.354 --> 03:27:15.389
RECYCLED AND NOT GET REVIEWS MY
03:27:15.456 --> 03:27:17.224
COLLEAGUE FROM LOS ANGELES LAST
03:27:17.291 --> 03:27:19.627
YEAR HAD A FANTASTIC BILL THAT
03:27:19.693 --> 03:27:21.362
WOULD ALLOW FOR THE REUSABLE
03:27:21.428 --> 03:27:23.464
BOTTLES AND MANY OF US ARE OLD
03:27:23.531 --> 03:27:24.598
ENOUGH TO REMEMBER WE ACTUALLY
03:27:24.665 --> 03:27:26.734
WOULD RE USE BOTTLES. AND WINE
03:27:26.801 --> 03:27:28.869
NOT SO MUCH SPEAKERS BUT WINE IS
03:27:28.936 --> 03:27:31.305
A BRILLIANT ADDITION TO OUR
03:27:31.372 --> 03:27:34.708
OPPORTUNITY FOR THAT TECHNOLOGY
03:27:34.775 --> 03:27:36.811
WHICH NOW USES A MINIMUM AMOUNT
03:27:36.877 --> 03:27:38.813
OF WATER TO BE ADDED TO THAT BUT
03:27:38.879 --> 03:27:40.047
WHAT IT REALLY DOES AND WHAT I
03:27:40.114 --> 03:27:42.616
APPLAUD. THE PRO TEMP FOR
03:27:42.683 --> 03:27:44.251
GETTING THIS ACROSS THE LINE AT
03:27:44.318 --> 03:27:46.086
LEAST AT THIS STAGE IN IN THE
03:27:46.153 --> 03:27:48.756
LEGISLATIVE UP DANCE IS THAT IT
03:27:48.823 --> 03:27:50.157
REALLY IS GOING TO REDUCE OUR
03:27:50.224 --> 03:27:52.459
CARBON FOOTPRINT IN IN
03:27:52.526 --> 03:27:54.495
CALIFORNIA AND IS GOING TO. JOIN
03:27:54.562 --> 03:27:56.330
WITH OTHER NATIONS AND OTHER
03:27:56.397 --> 03:27:57.331
JURISDICTIONS AROUND THE WORLD
03:27:57.398 --> 03:27:59.567
THAT DOES THAT SO I WOULD URGE
03:27:59.633 --> 03:28:01.335
AND I THOUGHT. THANK YOU CENTER
03:28:01.402 --> 03:28:04.038
WHITE HOUSE THE MEMBERS FURTHER
03:28:04.104 --> 03:28:05.206
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
03:28:05.272 --> 03:28:07.575
HEARING THEM BUT HER TENURE MAY
03:28:07.641 --> 03:28:08.943
CLOSE. I WOULD JUST RESPECTFULLY
03:28:09.009 --> 03:28:11.812
ASK FOR YOUR I. BOATS. MADAM
03:28:11.879 --> 03:28:13.480
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
03:28:13.547 --> 03:28:19.787
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA I ATKINS AYE
03:28:19.854 --> 03:28:24.692
BATES AYE BAKER I PORCHES FIVE
03:28:24.758 --> 03:28:28.395
BRADFORD. HI CABALLERO HI
03:28:28.462 --> 03:28:33.267
CORTESE AYE DOLLY AYE DODD AYE
03:28:33.334 --> 03:28:38.873
DURAZO AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER. I
03:28:38.939 --> 03:28:42.943
GONZALEZ I GROW HI HERTZBERG
03:28:43.010 --> 03:28:50.117
WESSEL. I FURTADO AYE JONES. I
03:28:50.184 --> 03:28:55.623
KAMLAGER I LAYERED I LEYVA AYE
03:28:55.689 --> 03:29:01.161
THE MON. I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
03:29:01.228 --> 03:29:06.400
AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN.
03:29:06.467 --> 03:29:09.870
I A SHOW ALTHOUGH I PAN. I
03:29:09.937 --> 03:29:15.175
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
03:29:15.242 --> 03:29:21.715
SKINNER. I STERN AYE I'M BURKE
03:29:21.782 --> 03:29:27.354
HI MY COUNTY. I WIENER I WILK HI
03:29:27.421 --> 03:29:29.523
IS THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
03:29:29.590 --> 03:29:32.359
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS IT IS TWO
03:29:32.426 --> 03:29:33.694
THIRTY EIGHT AND WE HAVE
03:29:33.761 --> 03:29:34.528
ESTABLISHED OUR UNANIMOUS ROLL
03:29:34.595 --> 03:29:36.997
CALL ALL RIGHT WE ARE MOVING ON
03:29:37.064 --> 03:29:38.899
TO FILE ITEM TWENTY SIX SENATOR
03:29:38.966 --> 03:29:40.768
LEE MON MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
03:29:40.834 --> 03:29:43.470
READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
03:29:43.537 --> 03:29:45.072
FOURTEEN BY SENATOR LIMÓN AN ACT
03:29:45.139 --> 03:29:46.674
RELATING TO OIL AND GAS
03:29:46.740 --> 03:29:49.376
SIMILARLY MON THANK YOU MADAM
03:29:49.443 --> 03:29:50.778
PRESIDENT AND COLLEAGUES I WANT
03:29:50.844 --> 03:29:52.813
TO START OFF BY THINKING SENATE
03:29:52.880 --> 03:29:54.548
CLIMATE WORKING GROUP FOR
03:29:54.615 --> 03:29:56.216
STARTING A VERY IMPORTANT
03:29:56.283 --> 03:29:58.285
CONVERSATION. AROUND INCREASE IN
03:29:58.352 --> 03:30:00.187
RENEWABLE ENERGY PRODUCTION AND
03:30:00.254 --> 03:30:02.890
EXPLORING THE POTENTIAL OF
03:30:02.957 --> 03:30:05.392
CARBON CAPTURE IN THE STATE. THE
03:30:05.459 --> 03:30:06.026
SENATOR FOR MERCED I HAVE BEEN
03:30:06.093 --> 03:30:08.862
WORKING FOR MONTHS ON TRYING TO
03:30:08.929 --> 03:30:11.332
ADDRESS HOW WE BRING A COMPLETE
03:30:11.398 --> 03:30:13.500
PACKAGE. OF RELATED TO CARBON
03:30:13.567 --> 03:30:16.370
CAPTURE UP FOR DIALOGUE FOR
03:30:16.437 --> 03:30:18.105
INPUT FOR REVIEW THROUGH THE
03:30:18.172 --> 03:30:20.441
LEGISLATIVE PROCESS. I WANT TO
03:30:20.507 --> 03:30:21.809
THANK HER IN PARTICULAR BECAUSE
03:30:21.875 --> 03:30:24.511
WE HAVE HELD DOZENS OF MEETINGS
03:30:24.578 --> 03:30:26.914
OF MANY HOURS IN THE LAST MONTHS
03:30:26.981 --> 03:30:29.550
TRYING TO COME FORWARD. WITH A
03:30:29.616 --> 03:30:31.051
PERSPECTIVE IN PACKAGE THAT
03:30:31.118 --> 03:30:34.788
KEEPS STAKEHOLDERS ARE ENGAGED
03:30:34.855 --> 03:30:37.291
IN THIS CONVERSATION. THIS BILL
03:30:37.358 --> 03:30:39.760
SB THIRTEEN FOR FOURTEEN
03:30:39.827 --> 03:30:40.995
INSURERS THAT CARBON CAPTURE IS
03:30:41.061 --> 03:30:42.596
NOT USED TO INCREASE OIL
03:30:42.663 --> 03:30:44.965
PRODUCTION ANY MISSIONS THROUGH
03:30:45.032 --> 03:30:47.001
A PROCESS KNOWN AS ENHANCED OIL
03:30:47.067 --> 03:30:50.237
RECOVERY ALSO KNOWN AS E. O. R.
03:30:50.304 --> 03:30:51.905
YOU ARE IS A PROCESS THAT USES
03:30:51.972 --> 03:30:53.307
PRESSURE FROM PUMPING CARBON
03:30:53.374 --> 03:30:54.575
UNDERGROUND TO PRODUCE
03:30:54.641 --> 03:30:56.276
ADDITIONAL OIL THAT WOULD NOT.
03:30:56.343 --> 03:30:58.445
BE RECOVERABLE OTHERWISE THIS
03:30:58.512 --> 03:31:01.448
PROCESS IS CURRENTLY NOT USED AS
03:31:01.515 --> 03:31:03.851
IT RELATES TO CARBON CAPTURE IN
03:31:03.917 --> 03:31:06.253
THE STATE AND THIS BILL DOES NOT
03:31:06.320 --> 03:31:09.323
PROHIBIT OTHER FORM. YOUR THAT
03:31:09.390 --> 03:31:11.692
ARE CURRENTLY USED IN THE SIX
03:31:11.759 --> 03:31:14.028
STATES SUCH AS STEAM. A STUDY
03:31:14.094 --> 03:31:15.863
REPORTED IN THE ANALYSIS FOR
03:31:15.929 --> 03:31:17.364
THIS BILL FOUND THAT CARBON
03:31:17.431 --> 03:31:21.235
DIOXIDE YOUR USE USE RESULTED IN
03:31:21.301 --> 03:31:23.070
AN INCREASE IN CARBON EMISSIONS
03:31:23.137 --> 03:31:26.106
OVERALL. ANOTHER RECENT ANALYSIS
03:31:26.173 --> 03:31:27.875
FOUND THAT EXPANDING YOUR WOULD
03:31:27.941 --> 03:31:29.343
LEAD DIRECTLY TO OVER FIFTEEN
03:31:29.410 --> 03:31:32.813
MILLION METRIC TONS METRIC TONS
03:31:32.880 --> 03:31:34.648
OF NET CO TWO EMISSIONS ANNUALLY
03:31:34.715 --> 03:31:36.450
. YOU ARE PRESENT SERIOUS HEALTH
03:31:36.517 --> 03:31:37.885
AND SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENTAL
03:31:37.951 --> 03:31:39.253
RISKS PARTICULARLY FOR
03:31:39.319 --> 03:31:40.054
MARGINALIZED FRONTLINE
03:31:40.120 --> 03:31:42.489
COMMUNITIES FOR EXAMPLE AN E. O.
03:31:42.556 --> 03:31:44.124
R. FIELD IN WYOMING LEAKED AND
03:31:44.191 --> 03:31:45.392
SPEWED CARBON INTO THE
03:31:45.459 --> 03:31:46.927
ATMOSPHERE NEXT TO A PUBLIC
03:31:46.994 --> 03:31:49.730
SCHOOL. WITH AIR POLLUTION SO
03:31:49.797 --> 03:31:52.966
SEVERE. BUT IT TOOK ALMOST THE
03:31:53.033 --> 03:31:55.469
ENTIRE SCHOOL YEAR TO RETURN.
03:31:55.536 --> 03:31:58.238
THE PROMISES TO SAFETY. THE
03:31:58.305 --> 03:31:59.606
INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON
03:31:59.673 --> 03:32:02.276
CLIMATE CHANGE IPCC HAS RAISED
03:32:02.342 --> 03:32:04.111
SIGNIFICANT CONCERNS ABOUT THE
03:32:04.178 --> 03:32:06.113
RISK OF CO TWO LEAKAGE FROM E.
03:32:06.180 --> 03:32:08.282
O. R. AND THE U. S. EPA
03:32:08.348 --> 03:32:10.384
RECOGNIZES THAT EXISTING OIL
03:32:10.451 --> 03:32:12.953
WELLS MAY NOT BE SUITABLE FOR
03:32:13.020 --> 03:32:15.122
PERMANENT SEQUESTRATION. IF
03:32:15.189 --> 03:32:17.558
CARBON CAPTURE IS REALLY A TOOL
03:32:17.624 --> 03:32:19.359
TO HELP MITIGATE THE IMPACT OF
03:32:19.426 --> 03:32:21.395
THE CLIMATE CRISIS THEN WHY
03:32:21.462 --> 03:32:22.996
WOULD THE STATE PERMITTED TO BE
03:32:23.063 --> 03:32:25.532
USED TO INCREASE EMISSIONS
03:32:25.599 --> 03:32:27.734
THROUGH INCREASED OIL PRODUCTION
03:32:27.801 --> 03:32:35.109
. TO BE. IN THE STATE. IT SETS
03:32:35.175 --> 03:32:36.777
AN APPROPRIATE GUARD RAIL TO
03:32:36.844 --> 03:32:37.945
ENSURE THAT WE TRULY ARE
03:32:38.011 --> 03:32:40.814
PRIORITIZING OUR CLIMATE GOALS.
03:32:40.881 --> 03:32:43.484
THIS BILL DOES NOT IMPACT ANY
03:32:43.550 --> 03:32:45.252
CURRENT OIL PRODUCTION IN THE
03:32:45.319 --> 03:32:46.787
FORM OF ENHANCED OIL RECOVERY
03:32:46.854 --> 03:32:50.090
DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE USED IN
03:32:50.157 --> 03:32:52.626
CALIFORNIA FOR CCS. AS THE
03:32:52.693 --> 03:32:54.128
CONVERSATION CONTINUED AROUND
03:32:54.194 --> 03:32:55.996
THE FUTURE OF CARBON CAPTURE IN
03:32:56.063 --> 03:32:57.898
THE STATE WE MUST MAKE IT CLEAR
03:32:57.965 --> 03:32:59.967
pTHAT INCREASING OIL PRODUCTION
03:33:00.033 --> 03:33:02.569
AND EMISSIONS WILL NOT BE PART
03:33:02.636 --> 03:33:05.272
OF THE STATE'S. GOALS TO ACHIEVE
03:33:05.339 --> 03:33:07.541
OUR CLIMATE TO ACHIEVE OUR
03:33:07.608 --> 03:33:10.611
CLIMATE GOALS I REMAIN COMMITTED
03:33:10.677 --> 03:33:12.346
TO WORK TOGETHER AND ALIGNED
03:33:12.412 --> 03:33:14.348
WITH THE CENTER FOR MERCED TO
03:33:14.414 --> 03:33:16.383
MOVE THESE BILLS FORWARD WE ARE
03:33:16.450 --> 03:33:18.051
BOTH WORKING TOGETHER AND ASKING
03:33:18.118 --> 03:33:22.422
THAT THESE BILLS. A BUT THESE
03:33:22.489 --> 03:33:25.526
BILLS THAT THESE BILLS AT MOVE
03:33:25.592 --> 03:33:27.060
MOVE FORWARD- IN A MANNER SO WE
03:33:27.127 --> 03:33:28.462
CAN CONTINUE TO HAVE THE
03:33:28.529 --> 03:33:29.630
INCREASED DIALOGUE AND
03:33:29.696 --> 03:33:32.099
CONVERSATION AND ANALYSIS AND
03:33:32.166 --> 03:33:34.401
REVIEW AND LEGISLATIVE IMPASSE
03:33:34.468 --> 03:33:36.103
AND I DO WANT TO NOTE THAT I
03:33:36.170 --> 03:33:37.304
HAVE- MEMBERS AT FROM DIFFERENT
03:33:37.371 --> 03:33:38.906
PARTS OF THE STATE FLAG IN THAT
03:33:38.972 --> 03:33:41.241
THE TWO WOULD LIKE TO BE PART OF
03:33:41.308 --> 03:33:42.910
THIS CONVERSATION AND THAT IS
03:33:42.976 --> 03:33:44.111
CERTAINLY A IT IS NOT LIMITED TO
03:33:44.178 --> 03:33:46.780
JUST MYSELF AND THE SENATOR FROM
03:33:46.847 --> 03:33:48.749
MERCED SO WITH THAT I
03:33:48.815 --> 03:33:51.118
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
03:33:51.185 --> 03:33:53.086
THANK YOU SENATOR LIMÓN SENATOR
03:33:53.153 --> 03:33:55.355
MEN. MADAM PRESIDENT- I WENT IN
03:33:55.422 --> 03:33:57.391
MY COLLEAGUES FROM SANTA BARBARA
03:33:57.457 --> 03:33:59.326
FOR BRINGING THIS FORWARD. IS
03:33:59.393 --> 03:34:01.128
THE SECOND OF I BELIEVE FOR
03:34:01.195 --> 03:34:02.596
BILLS THAT WE'RE GOING TO BE
03:34:02.663 --> 03:34:04.231
CONSIDERING RELATED TO CARBON
03:34:04.298 --> 03:34:06.466
CAPTURE AND SEQUESTRATION I AND
03:34:06.533 --> 03:34:08.268
I AM HOPEFUL AFTER CONVERSATIONS
03:34:08.335 --> 03:34:09.403
WITH SOME OF THE AUTHORS THAT
03:34:09.469 --> 03:34:11.171
THEY WORK TOGETHER TO HASH OUT
03:34:11.238 --> 03:34:12.272
SOME OF THE DIFFERENCES IN THEIR
03:34:12.339 --> 03:34:14.041
BILLS. I VOTED FOR THE ONE
03:34:14.107 --> 03:34:15.509
YESTERDAY I WILL VOTE FOR THIS
03:34:15.576 --> 03:34:17.177
ONE I URGE YOUR AYE VOTE ON THIS
03:34:17.244 --> 03:34:19.313
I WILL FOR ALL FOUR BECAUSE I
03:34:19.379 --> 03:34:20.581
THINK IT'S CRITICAL THAT WE
03:34:20.647 --> 03:34:22.216
EXPLORE ALL OPTIONS AS WE
03:34:22.282 --> 03:34:24.351
CONFRONT THE ONE OF OUR TIMES
03:34:24.418 --> 03:34:26.220
CLIMATE CHANGE- WE ARE IN THIS
03:34:26.286 --> 03:34:26.987
KIND OF CRISIS WERE SEEN
03:34:27.054 --> 03:34:29.022
IMPACTS. IN THE WORLD WERE
03:34:29.089 --> 03:34:29.957
LEAVING BEHIND FOR OUR CHILDREN
03:34:30.023 --> 03:34:31.225
AND GRANDCHILDREN IS ONE THAT IS
03:34:31.291 --> 03:34:33.827
A BUSINESS- WE HAVE TO REVERSE
03:34:33.894 --> 03:34:36.296
THINGS THAT WE CANNOT FORECLOSE
03:34:36.363 --> 03:34:37.097
OPTIONS- WE REALLY HAVE TO
03:34:37.164 --> 03:34:38.165
EXPLORE EVERYTHING I'M NOT A
03:34:38.232 --> 03:34:40.033
SCIENTIST AND ENGINEER. NOR CAN
03:34:40.100 --> 03:34:41.835
I PREDICT THE FUTURE AND I THINK
03:34:41.902 --> 03:34:43.770
THAT'S WHY IT'S IMPORTANT THAT
03:34:43.837 --> 03:34:44.538
WE INVEST AND EMPOWER ALL
03:34:44.605 --> 03:34:46.039
DIFFERENT TYPES OF TECHNOLOGY IS
03:34:46.106 --> 03:34:47.140
THE ONLY WAY WE'RE GOING TO
03:34:47.207 --> 03:34:48.175
REVERSE THIS IS THROUGH
03:34:48.242 --> 03:34:50.244
TECHNOLOGY NONE OF US CAN GO
03:34:50.310 --> 03:34:51.144
BACK THEIR HOME DISTRICTS. AND
03:34:51.211 --> 03:34:52.813
STATE YOU YOU WILL USE
03:34:52.879 --> 03:34:54.281
ELECTRICITY YOU CAN'T USE ENERGY
03:34:54.348 --> 03:34:56.416
THAT IS NOT A VIABLE OPTION FOR
03:34:56.483 --> 03:34:57.351
OUR SOCIETY FOR COMPANY. THAT
03:34:57.417 --> 03:35:00.087
MEET THE INNOVATION TECH. IN
03:35:00.153 --> 03:35:01.455
THIS GREEN SPACE IS GOING TO
03:35:01.521 --> 03:35:02.956
CRITICAL AND I THINK WE HAVE TO
03:35:03.023 --> 03:35:04.958
OUR OPTIONS SO I WOULD URGE YOU
03:35:05.025 --> 03:35:06.827
TO CONSIDER ALL THESE CARBON
03:35:06.893 --> 03:35:09.263
CAPTURE OPTIONS ALL OF OUR
03:35:09.329 --> 03:35:16.903
AVAILABLE OPTIONS AS WE TRY THIS. ANAMENSIS THANK YOU MADAM
03:35:16.970 --> 03:35:18.939
MEMBERS. ASSEMBLY WHO IS VERY
03:35:19.006 --> 03:35:22.643
CONCERNED ABOUT. THE CLIMATE AND
03:35:22.709 --> 03:35:25.712
NOT ONLY JUST THE CLIMATE IN
03:35:25.779 --> 03:35:26.246
CALIFORNIA BUT THE CLIMATE
03:35:26.313 --> 03:35:30.651
AROUND THE WORLD. WE DO A LOT OF
03:35:30.717 --> 03:35:34.054
LEGISLATION IN THIS BODY TO. SET
03:35:34.121 --> 03:35:36.256
GOALS OF A 100% RENEWABLE BY A
03:35:36.323 --> 03:35:40.193
CERTAIN DATE OR WE'RE GONNA DO.
03:35:40.260 --> 03:35:41.762
THIRTY MILLION ELECTRIC VEHICLES
03:35:41.828 --> 03:35:43.930
BY TWENTY THIRTY FIVE AND THOSE
03:35:43.997 --> 03:35:45.465
GOALS ARE ARE VERY AGGRESSIVE
03:35:45.532 --> 03:35:48.435
GOALS. WE HAVE TECHNOLOGY
03:35:48.502 --> 03:35:51.004
AVAILABLE TO US TODAY THE ALLOWS
03:35:51.071 --> 03:35:54.341
TO CAPTURE CARBON IN STORE IT.
03:35:54.408 --> 03:35:59.413
AS WERE PRODUCING. ENERGY FUEL
03:35:59.479 --> 03:36:01.815
THINGS THAT EVERY CALIFORNIA
03:36:01.882 --> 03:36:02.916
NEEDS NOW YESTERDAY WE SAW A
03:36:02.983 --> 03:36:05.819
BILL THAT IS GOING TO BE A PILOT
03:36:05.886 --> 03:36:08.455
PROJECT ON. THE MANUFACTURING OF
03:36:08.522 --> 03:36:12.926
SEAMEN. THIS BILL IS TALKING
03:36:12.993 --> 03:36:15.696
ABOUT NOT ALLOWING US TO USE THE
03:36:15.762 --> 03:36:17.631
SAME TECHNOLOGY IN THE
03:36:17.698 --> 03:36:25.872
PRODUCTION OF OIL. AT THIS POINT. CALIFORNIANS USE ONE POINT
03:36:25.939 --> 03:36:27.274
EIGHT MILLION BARRELS OF OIL
03:36:27.341 --> 03:36:30.344
EVERY DAY AND IN NO TIME SOON
03:36:30.410 --> 03:36:31.578
ARE WE GOING TO BE AWAY FROM
03:36:31.645 --> 03:36:34.181
USING OIL. AT THIS TIME YOU CAN
03:36:34.247 --> 03:36:36.817
AFFORD TO LIVE IN CALIFORNIA. WE
03:36:36.883 --> 03:36:39.653
HAVE THE HIGHEST ENERGY RATES.
03:36:39.720 --> 03:36:44.391
76% HIGHER THAN NEVADA. ARIZONA
03:36:44.458 --> 03:36:50.263
OREGON. WHY IS THAT WHY DO WE
03:36:50.330 --> 03:36:53.367
HAVE TO PAY MORE. AS WE EXPORT
03:36:53.433 --> 03:36:56.970
OUR JOBS AND OUR EMISSIONS TO
03:36:57.037 --> 03:36:59.039
OTHER COUNTRIES OR OTHER STATES
03:36:59.106 --> 03:37:00.874
AN IMPORT THE GOODS THAT EVERY
03:37:00.941 --> 03:37:03.343
CALIFORNIANS NEED IN CASE POINT
03:37:03.410 --> 03:37:05.979
IT'S BECAUSE POLICIES. LIKE THIS
03:37:06.046 --> 03:37:07.414
THAT DON'T ALOW US TO USE GOOD
03:37:07.481 --> 03:37:10.317
TECHNOLOGY ACROSS THE BOARD FOR
03:37:10.384 --> 03:37:13.653
ALL. PRODUCTS FOR SOME REASON
03:37:13.720 --> 03:37:17.124
THE LEGISLATURE SEEMS TO HAVE.
03:37:17.190 --> 03:37:19.893
AN ALL OUT WAR AGAINST OIL IN
03:37:19.960 --> 03:37:21.428
CALIFORNIA WILL REPRODUCE IT
03:37:21.495 --> 03:37:25.899
MORE EFFICIENT. MORE ENVIRONMENT
03:37:25.966 --> 03:37:26.900
FRIENDLY AND WITH CALIFORNIA
03:37:26.967 --> 03:37:30.270
WORKERS. IT'S APPALLING. THAT WE
03:37:30.337 --> 03:37:34.975
DON'T DO MORE TO MAKE CALIFORNIA
03:37:35.041 --> 03:37:36.209
A PLACE WHERE WE CAN ACTUALLY
03:37:36.276 --> 03:37:38.211
LEAD THE WORLD. BY NOT IMPORTING
03:37:38.278 --> 03:37:40.046
OIL FROM PLACES WHERE THEY'RE
03:37:40.113 --> 03:37:43.483
DESTROYING A RAIN FORCE. THE
03:37:43.550 --> 03:37:45.552
TECHNOLOGY WE HAVE AVAILABLE WE
03:37:45.619 --> 03:37:47.287
SHOULD BE USING ACROSS THE BOARD
03:37:47.354 --> 03:37:49.289
IT'S KIND OF LIKE REGULATING
03:37:49.356 --> 03:37:51.057
YOUR LAWN MOWER HERE WE NEED
03:37:51.124 --> 03:37:53.360
YOUR AND YOUR GENERATOR AS THE
03:37:53.427 --> 03:37:55.896
FORSBERG'S DOWN. YOU MIGHT FEEL
03:37:55.962 --> 03:37:58.965
GOOD ABOUT IT BUT IT'S NOT DOING
03:37:59.032 --> 03:38:01.268
WHAT WE WANTED TO DO. WE NEED TO
03:38:01.334 --> 03:38:03.136
DO THIS TECHNOLOGY ACROSS ALL
03:38:03.203 --> 03:38:04.938
SECTORS SO WE CAN ACTUALLY LEAD
03:38:05.005 --> 03:38:07.307
THE WORLD IN SEQUESTERING CARBON
03:38:07.374 --> 03:38:11.211
PUTTING IT BACK IN THE GROUND.
03:38:11.278 --> 03:38:13.180
IN MAKING CALIFORNIA SAFER PLACE
03:38:13.246 --> 03:38:14.581
A MORE PRODUCTIVE PLACE AND
03:38:14.648 --> 03:38:16.683
ACTUALLY LEADING THE WORLD FOR
03:38:16.750 --> 03:38:17.918
THOSE REASONS I WILL BE OPPOSING
03:38:17.984 --> 03:38:19.352
THIS BILL. THANK YOU SAID
03:38:19.419 --> 03:38:21.521
DYRDAHL SENDER GONZALEZ AND
03:38:21.588 --> 03:38:24.157
MADAM PRESIDENT IF I MAY JUST
03:38:24.224 --> 03:38:27.060
RESPOND. TO SEVERAL MOUNTED DID
03:38:27.127 --> 03:38:28.862
YOU HAVE POSED A QUESTION. CAN
03:38:28.929 --> 03:38:30.230
YOU DO IN YOUR CLOTHES PLEASE
03:38:30.297 --> 03:38:31.498
CEREMONY THANK YOU CENTER
03:38:31.565 --> 03:38:33.400
GONZALEZ THANK YOU MADAM
03:38:33.467 --> 03:38:34.901
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS I TOO
03:38:34.968 --> 03:38:36.903
WOULD LIKE TO THANK MY COLLEAGUE
03:38:36.970 --> 03:38:38.672
FROM SANTA BARBARA FOR BRINGING
03:38:38.738 --> 03:38:40.106
THIS FORWARD AND- REALLY ALL OF
03:38:40.173 --> 03:38:40.707
MY COLLEAGUES- IN THE CLIMATE
03:38:40.774 --> 03:38:43.343
WORKING GROUP- AND PARTICULARLY
03:38:43.410 --> 03:38:47.013
OUR- PRESIDENT PRO TEM. UM FOR
03:38:47.080 --> 03:38:49.115
ALLOWING US TO HAVE A DIALOGUE A
03:38:49.182 --> 03:38:50.884
REALLY IN DEPTH DIALOGUE ABOUT
03:38:50.951 --> 03:38:52.419
THIS TYPES OF THESE TYPES OF
03:38:52.486 --> 03:38:56.523
VARIOUS TECHNOLOGIES AND I WILL
03:38:56.590 --> 03:38:57.624
SAY SPEAKING FROM AN AREA SOME
03:38:57.691 --> 03:39:02.963
THE LESS. FONG BEACH. IN DATA
03:39:03.029 --> 03:39:04.431
WITH POLLUTION AND- WITH YOU
03:39:04.498 --> 03:39:06.433
KNOW- ISSUE UPON IT. WITH EMPIRE
03:39:06.500 --> 03:39:09.469
AND SHE- I BELIEVE THAT- THE CO
03:39:09.536 --> 03:39:10.804
TWO LEAKAGE ISSUES THAT HAVE
03:39:10.871 --> 03:39:11.938
BEEN BROUGHT UP BY THE E. J.
03:39:12.005 --> 03:39:13.874
COMMUNITIES ARE. A REASONABLE
03:39:13.940 --> 03:39:15.909
THEY ARE- THEY HAVE HAPPENED AND
03:39:15.976 --> 03:39:17.777
SO I THINK WE HAVE TO BE
03:39:17.844 --> 03:39:19.846
CAUTIOUS OF THAT AND I DO- AT
03:39:19.913 --> 03:39:21.448
HERE WITH MY COLLEAGUES ARE
03:39:21.515 --> 03:39:22.148
SAYING BUT WE ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO
03:39:22.215 --> 03:39:24.184
BE CAUTIOUS OF THAT I THOUGHT IT
03:39:24.251 --> 03:39:25.785
URGENT. BOATS AND I THINK MY
03:39:25.852 --> 03:39:27.087
COLLEAGUES FROM THE WORKING
03:39:27.153 --> 03:39:28.421
GROUP FOR COMING TOGETHER WITH
03:39:28.488 --> 03:39:31.491
VARIOUS- UNDERSTANDINGS WITH THE
03:39:31.558 --> 03:39:33.493
VARIOUS FROM VARIOUS REGIONS OF
03:39:33.560 --> 03:39:34.561
THE STATE WITH VARIOUS
03:39:34.628 --> 03:39:36.029
PERSPECTIVES TO BE ABLE TO
03:39:36.096 --> 03:39:37.497
REALLY COME TOGETHER TO. TO
03:39:37.564 --> 03:39:39.132
BUILD A PLAN THAT WORKS FOR ALL
03:39:39.199 --> 03:39:41.468
OF US OF THANK YOU VERY MUCH I
03:39:41.535 --> 03:39:44.137
URGE I PUT. THE USER GONZALEZ
03:39:44.204 --> 03:39:45.939
CENTER LAYERED. THANK YOU VERY
03:39:46.006 --> 03:39:47.173
MUCH MADAM PRESIDENT BECAUSE
03:39:47.240 --> 03:39:51.611
SOME OF US ARE WENT ON A TRIP.
03:39:51.678 --> 03:39:53.980
TO ICELAND DURING THE BREAK AND
03:39:54.047 --> 03:39:56.716
ACTUALLY SAW. A CARBON AIR
03:39:56.783 --> 03:40:00.287
CAPTURE WHERE IT WAS FUNDED I
03:40:00.353 --> 03:40:03.990
MEAN IT WAS POWERED RENEWABLY-
03:40:04.057 --> 03:40:07.093
IT TOOK CARBON FROM THE AIR. IT
03:40:07.160 --> 03:40:09.763
WAS CLEARLY A PRODUCTIVE THING
03:40:09.829 --> 03:40:13.400
AND WHAT IT WHAT WE ARE SEEING
03:40:13.466 --> 03:40:15.001
AND IT WAS MENTIONED THERE FOR
03:40:15.068 --> 03:40:17.904
BILLS THERE ARE TWO I THINK IN
03:40:17.971 --> 03:40:20.941
CHIEF AND THE EACH COMMENTED
03:40:21.007 --> 03:40:22.742
FROM A LITTLE BIT OF A DIFFERENT
03:40:22.809 --> 03:40:24.444
WAY WAS JUST REFERENCED THAT
03:40:24.511 --> 03:40:26.212
THERE SOME GEOGRAPHICAL.
03:40:26.279 --> 03:40:31.284
DIFFERENCES AND N. ONE BILL- HAS
03:40:31.351 --> 03:40:33.153
REAL CONCERNS EXPRESSED ON
03:40:33.219 --> 03:40:34.454
ENVIRONMENTAL OUR ENVIRONMENTAL
03:40:34.521 --> 03:40:36.456
JUSTICE COMMUNITY THE OTHER BILL
03:40:36.523 --> 03:40:38.558
HAS REAL CONCERNS EXPRESSED FROM
03:40:38.625 --> 03:40:41.728
CERTAIN LABOR ORGANIZATIONS BUT
03:40:41.795 --> 03:40:42.729
BASICALLY IT'S OUR JOB TO
03:40:42.796 --> 03:40:47.100
GOVERN. AND IT WOULD BE EASY TO
03:40:47.167 --> 03:40:48.835
RELAPSE. EACH BILL GO ON ITS OWN
03:40:48.902 --> 03:40:51.471
AND SEE IF ONE MAKES IT BUT THE
03:40:51.538 --> 03:40:52.339
ODDS ARE THAT THEY WOULD BOTH
03:40:52.405 --> 03:40:53.573
CRASH SHOULD WE WOULD GET
03:40:53.640 --> 03:40:55.375
THROUGH THE SESSION WITHOUT ANY
03:40:55.442 --> 03:40:57.444
MEANINGFUL MOVEMENT ON THIS
03:40:57.510 --> 03:41:01.114
POLICY. AND SO WHAT HAS HAPPENED
03:41:01.181 --> 03:41:03.650
IS AN IMPORTANT ENGAGEMENT
03:41:03.717 --> 03:41:05.852
DISCUSSIONS BETWEEN THE TWO
03:41:05.919 --> 03:41:08.288
LEGISLATORS AND QUESTION TO TRY
03:41:08.355 --> 03:41:10.523
TO BRIDGE THE GAPS AND THEY HAVE
03:41:10.590 --> 03:41:13.660
MADE PROGRESS IN AND I THINK
03:41:13.727 --> 03:41:15.629
THAT THE REAL THING OF GOVERNING
03:41:15.695 --> 03:41:17.497
IS TO GIVE THEM A CHANCE TO WORK
03:41:17.564 --> 03:41:20.233
IT OUT GIVE THEM A CHANCE TO SEE
03:41:20.300 --> 03:41:21.234
IF THEY CAN FIND A COMMON
03:41:21.301 --> 03:41:23.937
GROUND. IN SOME WAY AND ADDRESS
03:41:24.004 --> 03:41:25.839
THIS ISSUE SO THAT WE DON'T MOVE
03:41:25.905 --> 03:41:28.041
OUT OF SESSION AND HAVE
03:41:28.108 --> 03:41:29.409
EVERYBODY IN THEIR RESPECTIVE
03:41:29.476 --> 03:41:31.778
CORNERS WITHOUT THERE BEING
03:41:31.845 --> 03:41:33.446
SOMETHING THAT MOVES AHEAD SO I
03:41:33.513 --> 03:41:35.515
THINK IT'S VERY IMPORTANT TO
03:41:35.582 --> 03:41:37.651
MOVE BOTH THESE BILLS AHEAD. AND
03:41:37.717 --> 03:41:39.586
I AM SURE EACH OF US HAS AN
03:41:39.653 --> 03:41:41.354
ISSUE WITH ONE PART IN ONE OR
03:41:41.421 --> 03:41:43.923
ANOTHER BUT TO GIVE THEM THE
03:41:43.990 --> 03:41:45.158
CHANCE TO WORK IT OUT AND THEY
03:41:45.225 --> 03:41:47.060
HAVE MADE PROGRESS AND SO I
03:41:47.127 --> 03:41:50.764
REALLY URGE MEMBERS. TO MOVE
03:41:50.830 --> 03:41:52.465
THIS BILL FORWARD AND WHEN THE
03:41:52.532 --> 03:41:54.901
BILL. FROM HER FORMER SAID
03:41:54.968 --> 03:41:56.770
REALLY URGE EVERYONE REGARDLESS
03:41:56.836 --> 03:41:58.638
OF YOUR VIEWS TO MOVE THAT POINT
03:41:58.705 --> 03:42:01.408
FORWARD AND HAVE IT BE A
03:42:01.474 --> 03:42:02.809
STATEMENT THAT WE WANT SOMETHING
03:42:02.876 --> 03:42:04.878
TO HAPPEN ON THIS ISSUE SO I
03:42:04.944 --> 03:42:07.213
RECKON RESPECTFULLY REQUEST AN
03:42:07.280 --> 03:42:11.284
AYE VOTE ON THIS BILL. THANK-
03:42:11.351 --> 03:42:12.352
LAYERED CENTER PAM. THANK YOU
03:42:12.419 --> 03:42:14.788
MADAM PRESIDENT SENATORS- FIRST
03:42:14.854 --> 03:42:17.424
OF ALL I WANT TO THANK MY GOOD
03:42:17.490 --> 03:42:19.659
FRIEND FROM SANTA BARBARA AND-
03:42:19.726 --> 03:42:20.960
MERCED FOR WORKING TOGETHER ON
03:42:21.027 --> 03:42:23.630
CLIMATE DONE- CARBON CAPTURE. ME
03:42:23.697 --> 03:42:26.032
ULTIMATELY MY NO CLIMATE CRISIS
03:42:26.099 --> 03:42:28.168
IS REAL HOPE HOPEFULLY NO ONE
03:42:28.234 --> 03:42:30.070
DISAGREES WITH THAT. AND WE NEED
03:42:30.136 --> 03:42:32.372
TO FIGURE OUT HOW WE GET.
03:42:32.439 --> 03:42:33.873
BASICALLY WELL FIRST OF ALL
03:42:33.940 --> 03:42:35.408
REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF CARBON AND
03:42:35.475 --> 03:42:38.578
IDEALLY DRIVE IT DOWN RIGHT- NO
03:42:38.645 --> 03:42:41.181
NO I WILL SAY I AM I'M A LITTLE
03:42:41.247 --> 03:42:42.949
SKEPTICAL ABOUT THIS BILL-
03:42:43.016 --> 03:42:46.786
BECAUSE IS THE AUTHOR SAID.
03:42:46.853 --> 03:42:49.055
ACTUALLY WE CAN USE OUR THINK
03:42:49.122 --> 03:42:49.989
ABOUT OTHER THINGS INTO THE
03:42:50.056 --> 03:42:52.092
GROUND TO GET MORE OIL OUT
03:42:52.158 --> 03:42:54.828
RIGHT- SO IF WE PUT CARBON DOWN
03:42:54.894 --> 03:42:57.030
THERE AT LEAST A AND IT'S TO ME
03:42:57.097 --> 03:42:58.598
DOESN'T LEAK SO THERE'S OTHER
03:42:58.665 --> 03:43:00.266
ROLLS RIGHT AWAY THE PLAN PLACE
03:43:00.333 --> 03:43:02.235
THEN AT LEAST THE NET CARBON IS
03:43:02.302 --> 03:43:03.970
LESS THAN IF WE JUST USE THEME
03:43:04.037 --> 03:43:05.672
OR SOMETHING ELSE SO I'M LOOKING
03:43:05.739 --> 03:43:07.173
ABOUT REMOVING THAT OFF THE
03:43:07.240 --> 03:43:08.475
TABLE BUT I ALSO GET PEOPLE'S
03:43:08.541 --> 03:43:10.510
CONCERNS THAT WELL ACTUALLY YES
03:43:10.577 --> 03:43:12.045
WE PUT MORE COMMON GROUND AND
03:43:12.112 --> 03:43:13.847
WE'RE PULLING UP EVEN PERHAPS
03:43:13.913 --> 03:43:15.949
CARBON WITHIN THE GROUND SO
03:43:16.015 --> 03:43:17.083
WE'RE STILL NET POSITIVE RIGHT.
03:43:17.150 --> 03:43:19.953
BUT BUT YOU SMALL POSITIVE THAT
03:43:20.019 --> 03:43:20.954
TWENTY SOMETHING ELSE IN THE
03:43:21.020 --> 03:43:22.288
GROUND IT'S NOT BANNING THOSE
03:43:22.355 --> 03:43:23.957
THOSE EFFORTS AND I KNOW WE'VE
03:43:24.023 --> 03:43:25.158
HAD DISCUSSIONS HERE ON THE
03:43:25.225 --> 03:43:26.593
FLOOR AS WELL BUT I THINK
03:43:26.659 --> 03:43:30.330
THERE'S BY THE END- IT'S ABOUT
03:43:30.396 --> 03:43:33.266
NOT ONLY OF COURSE REDUCING THE-
03:43:33.333 --> 03:43:34.901
THE USAGE AND BY THE WAY SOME OF
03:43:34.968 --> 03:43:36.536
THE DEMAND DRIVEN AND I DO
03:43:36.603 --> 03:43:39.773
APPRECIATE WHAT DOES MY FRIENDS
03:43:39.839 --> 03:43:42.008
ACROSS THE AISLE ARE SAYING IS
03:43:42.075 --> 03:43:43.777
THAT. IF YOU KNOW FALSE. IN THE
03:43:43.843 --> 03:43:44.978
STATE AND DON'T FIGURE OUT OF
03:43:45.044 --> 03:43:47.247
THE TREES THAT MAN. AND WE DON'T
03:43:47.313 --> 03:43:48.648
PRODUCE IT HERE IT COMES SOME
03:43:48.715 --> 03:43:50.183
OTHER PLACES AND PERHAPS USING
03:43:50.250 --> 03:43:50.950
EVEN MORE CARBON TO BRING IT
03:43:51.017 --> 03:43:53.052
<c.red>NTO OUR STATE. SO QUESTIONS</c>
03:43:53.119 --> 03:43:54.854
LIKE WHERE DO YOU LAND TO TRY TO
03:43:54.921 --> 03:43:56.089
MINIMIZE THE AMOUNT OF CARBON WE
03:43:56.156 --> 03:43:58.158
SE. HERE NOW IN CALIFORNIA
03:43:58.224 --> 03:44:00.693
AROUND THE WORLD. AND WE NEED
03:44:00.760 --> 03:44:02.829
TO. AND CARBON CAPTURE IS PART
03:44:02.896 --> 03:44:04.531
OF THAT SOLUTION IS NOT THE
03:44:04.597 --> 03:44:06.299
ENTIRE SOLUTION THERE'S NO WAY
03:44:06.366 --> 03:44:07.901
WE CAPTURE ALL THE CARBON HE
03:44:07.967 --> 03:44:08.968
NEEDS TO MAKE UP FOR ALL THE
03:44:09.035 --> 03:44:11.104
CARBON WE'RE DIGGING OUT. BUT IT
03:44:11.171 --> 03:44:12.472
IS SOMETHING THAT WE NEED TO DO
03:44:12.539 --> 03:44:14.741
AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT THAT.
03:44:14.808 --> 03:44:16.576
WE ALLOW THE BILL TO GO FORWARD
03:44:16.643 --> 03:44:17.744
TO HAVE THAT CONVERSATION AND I
03:44:17.811 --> 03:44:19.179
THINK IT. WAS MENTIONEDBEFORE
03:44:19.245 --> 03:44:21.414
THAT HOPEFULLY IDEALLY WE COME
03:44:21.481 --> 03:44:22.849
UP WITH SOME KIND OF SOLUTION.
03:44:22.916 --> 03:44:25.185
LEGISLATIVELY POLICY WISE THAT
03:44:25.251 --> 03:44:26.085
WILL ALLOW US TO DO CARBON
03:44:26.152 --> 03:44:27.854
CAPTURE. IN ADDITION TO THE
03:44:27.921 --> 03:44:29.122
CONSUMING WORK WE'RE DOING. TO
03:44:29.189 --> 03:44:31.257
TRY TO REDUCE THE DEMAND THAT WE
03:44:31.324 --> 03:44:33.059
HAVE FOR CARBON. AND OTHER TYPES
03:44:33.126 --> 03:44:34.794
OF GREENHOUSE GASES IN OUR
03:44:34.861 --> 03:44:37.230
COMMUNITY. SO AFTER THAT IS A
03:44:37.297 --> 03:44:39.132
SKEPTIC. ABOUT THIS PARTICULAR
03:44:39.199 --> 03:44:41.301
BILL- I'M SUPPORTING THIS BILL
03:44:41.367 --> 03:44:43.670
BECAUSE I THINK THIS IS A VERY
03:44:43.736 --> 03:44:44.938
IMPORTANT CONVERSATION TO MOVE
03:44:45.004 --> 03:44:46.272
FORWARD. AND I DO THINK THAT
03:44:46.339 --> 03:44:48.141
ANSWERED THE AUTHOR IS GOING TO
03:44:48.208 --> 03:44:49.409
WORK OUT SOME OF THE NUANCES
03:44:49.475 --> 03:44:51.811
THAT I SEE ABOUT WHAT CAN WE DO
03:44:51.878 --> 03:44:53.980
IN THE- END THAT WILL HELP US
03:44:54.047 --> 03:44:54.914
GET THE NEXT LEAST AMOUNT OF
03:44:54.981 --> 03:44:56.182
CARBON WE'RE PUMPING INTO THE
03:44:56.249 --> 03:44:58.818
AIR AND IDEALLY EVEN. YOU MIGHT
03:44:58.885 --> 03:45:00.286
THINK. THE REDUCING THE ACTUAL
03:45:00.353 --> 03:45:02.422
AMOUNT CARBON AND AIR. SO THAT
03:45:02.488 --> 03:45:02.956
WE CAN ADDRESS THE CLIMATE
03:45:03.022 --> 03:45:05.024
CRISIS WITH THAT ASPECT YES WHEN
03:45:05.091 --> 03:45:06.125
I DON'T. THANK YOU SENATOR PAN
03:45:06.192 --> 03:45:09.896
CENTER GROVE BILL. THANK YOU
03:45:09.963 --> 03:45:11.698
MADAM PRESIDENT I RESPECTFULLY
03:45:11.764 --> 03:45:13.199
RISE IN OPPOSITION AGAIN THIS
03:45:13.266 --> 03:45:16.402
BILL. I DO QUESTION THE AUTHOR
03:45:16.469 --> 03:45:19.505
THOUGH. SIMILARLY MOM WE TAKE A
03:45:19.572 --> 03:45:21.574
QUESTION YES PLEASE PROCEED
03:45:21.641 --> 03:45:23.676
THANK YOU MY GOOD COLLEAGUE- HOW
03:45:23.743 --> 03:45:26.379
MANY METRIC TONS OF CARBON WILL
03:45:26.446 --> 03:45:29.382
THESE FIELDS CAPTURE. SO I WANT
03:45:29.449 --> 03:45:32.752
TO BE CLEAR THAT THIS BILL
03:45:32.819 --> 03:45:34.554
THERE'S BEEN SOME CONFUSION THIS
03:45:34.621 --> 03:45:38.291
BILL DOES NOT BAN OR STOP CARBON
03:45:38.358 --> 03:45:41.361
CAPTURE THIS IS ABOUT ENHANCED
03:45:41.427 --> 03:45:43.863
OIL RECOVERY SO. THERE IS ONE
03:45:43.930 --> 03:45:45.932
BILL THAT THE AT MEMBERS WILL
03:45:45.999 --> 03:45:48.735
HAVE THE CHANCE TO VOTE FOR THAT
03:45:48.801 --> 03:45:50.336
ESTABLISHES THE BEGINNING OF A
03:45:50.403 --> 03:45:52.472
FRAMEWORK THIS IS ONE COMPONENT
03:45:52.538 --> 03:45:53.907
OF THE MANY THINGS THAT CAN
03:45:53.973 --> 03:45:55.875
HAPPEN WHEN YOU CAPTURE THAT
03:45:55.942 --> 03:45:59.012
CARBON STILL EVERY PROJECT WILL
03:45:59.078 --> 03:46:00.947
CAPTURE A DIFFERENT AMOUNT.
03:46:01.014 --> 03:46:02.815
RIGHT SO THIS DOESN'T SPEAK TO
03:46:02.882 --> 03:46:04.617
WHETHER IT'S A CEMENT PROJECT OR
03:46:04.684 --> 03:46:06.552
WHETHER IT'S A REFINERY PROJECT
03:46:06.619 --> 03:46:08.388
OR ANY OTHER KIND OF PROJECTS SO
03:46:08.454 --> 03:46:10.156
I CAN'T ANSWER THAT QUESTION
03:46:10.223 --> 03:46:12.358
BECAUSE IT IS BASED ON THE
03:46:12.425 --> 03:46:13.927
PRODUCT ITSELF SO I THINK IT'S-
03:46:13.993 --> 03:46:15.528
IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND THAT
03:46:15.595 --> 03:46:17.297
THIS BILL DOESN'T STOP CARBON
03:46:17.363 --> 03:46:19.299
CAPTURE PROGRAMS THIS IS ABOUT A
03:46:19.365 --> 03:46:24.270
METHOD. THAT CAN BE IN THAT SOME
03:46:24.337 --> 03:46:25.538
MAY OR MAY NOT USE. WITH THE
03:46:25.605 --> 03:46:27.407
CARBON THAT THEY CAPTURE THIS IS
03:46:27.473 --> 03:46:30.009
NOT ABOUT THIS DOESN'T IMPACT
03:46:30.076 --> 03:46:32.211
CARBON CAPTURE PROGRAMS.
03:46:32.278 --> 03:46:33.613
ESTABLISHING CARBON CAPTURE
03:46:33.680 --> 03:46:35.148
PROGRAMS I UNDERSTAND THAT I WAS
03:46:35.214 --> 03:46:37.150
IN THE GROWTH THANK YOU MADAM
03:46:37.216 --> 03:46:38.918
PRESIDENT. I UNDERSTAND THAT I
03:46:38.985 --> 03:46:42.488
WAS- TRYING TO GET. A RESPONSE
03:46:42.555 --> 03:46:44.958
BECAUSE- I FEEL LIKE WE ARE
03:46:45.024 --> 03:46:46.926
REALLY REALLY REALLY MISSING THE
03:46:46.993 --> 03:46:48.861
BOAT AND I THINK MY GOOD
03:46:48.928 --> 03:46:50.129
COLLEAGUE FROM SACRAMENTO FOR AT
03:46:50.196 --> 03:46:52.932
LEAST ADMITTING THAT THERE IS AT
03:46:52.999 --> 03:46:54.901
LEAST A CONVERSATION THAT CAN BE
03:46:54.968 --> 03:46:58.638
HAD. AN ONE GALLON JUST ONE
03:46:58.705 --> 03:47:00.940
GALLON LIKE A GALLON OF MILK.
03:47:01.007 --> 03:47:03.910
ONE GALLON OF DIESEL FUEL. THAT
03:47:03.977 --> 03:47:06.079
COMES- FROM THE SHIPS THAT BRING
03:47:06.145 --> 03:47:07.847
US WELL FROM SAUDI ARABIA IRAQ
03:47:07.914 --> 03:47:11.651
AND ECUADOR. BURNS TWENTY EIGHT.
03:47:11.718 --> 03:47:14.654
AN EXCUSE ME TWENTY TWO POINT
03:47:14.721 --> 03:47:17.457
EIGHT POUNDS OF CO TWO TWENTY
03:47:17.523 --> 03:47:20.727
TWO POINT EIGHT POUNDS. ONE TRIP
03:47:20.793 --> 03:47:23.496
ONE WAY. FROM SAUDI ARABIA TO
03:47:23.563 --> 03:47:30.169
HEAR. BURNS TWENTY SEVEN POINT.
03:47:30.236 --> 03:47:31.504
SIX SEVEN TWENTY SEVEN POINT SIX
03:47:31.571 --> 03:47:35.875
SEVEN METRIC TONS. OF CARBON CO
03:47:35.942 --> 03:47:38.544
TWO. KERN COUNTY THE EPICENTER
03:47:38.611 --> 03:47:41.781
THE OIL THE OIL AT THE CENTER OF
03:47:41.848 --> 03:47:43.182
THE ENERGY EPICENTER ACTUALLY
03:47:43.249 --> 03:47:44.851
FOR THIS STATE 70% OF THE
03:47:44.917 --> 03:47:47.420
STATE'S OIL AND GAS FOSSIL FUELS
03:47:47.487 --> 03:47:49.088
53% OF THE STATE'S RENEWABLE
03:47:49.155 --> 03:47:52.058
GAS- WINDMILL IN WIND TURBINES
03:47:52.125 --> 03:47:54.994
WE IN THE COUNTY UNDERSTANDING
03:47:55.061 --> 03:47:57.597
WOULD LIKE TO HOPEFULLY. IMPART
03:47:57.663 --> 03:47:59.832
THAT KNOWLEDGE TO YOU GUYS THAT
03:47:59.899 --> 03:48:03.069
YOU HAVE TO HAVE OIL TO PRODUCE
03:48:03.136 --> 03:48:06.472
WIND TURBINES. AND YOU HAVE TO
03:48:06.539 --> 03:48:08.808
HAVE OIL TO PRODUCE SOLAR. IT
03:48:08.875 --> 03:48:10.710
TAKES ABOUT TWELVE THOUSAND
03:48:10.777 --> 03:48:13.780
GALLONS OF OIL TO MAKE AWIND
03:48:13.846 --> 03:48:16.282
TURBINE WORK IN A YEAR. SO WE
03:48:16.349 --> 03:48:18.084
CAN'T HAVE ONE WITHOUT THE
03:48:18.151 --> 03:48:20.520
OTHER. AND AS MUCH AS YOU GUYS
03:48:20.586 --> 03:48:23.423
CONTINUALLY ATTACK MY DISTRICT.
03:48:23.489 --> 03:48:25.491
AND THE PEOPLE THAT WORK THERE
03:48:25.558 --> 03:48:27.693
IN THE JOBS AND I REALIZE THIS
03:48:27.760 --> 03:48:29.662
THIS NOT MAYBE PARTICULAR FOR
03:48:29.729 --> 03:48:31.230
THIS BILL EXCEPT FOR THE CARBON
03:48:31.297 --> 03:48:32.965
CAPTURE ME SON OIL AND NATURAL
03:48:33.032 --> 03:48:35.535
GAS SUPPLY. AND IS MEANT TO YOU
03:48:35.601 --> 03:48:37.737
GUYS CONTINUE TO ATTACK IT WE DO
03:48:37.804 --> 03:48:40.807
IT RIGHT. WE PRODUCE THERE'S
03:48:40.873 --> 03:48:42.742
FIFTY EIGHT COUNTIES IN THIS
03:48:42.809 --> 03:48:45.378
STATE AND WE- 3% OF THIS THREE
03:48:45.445 --> 03:48:48.081
NOBLE ENERGY. WE KNOW ENERGY
03:48:48.147 --> 03:48:51.084
COME VISIT US LET US SHOW YOU WE
03:48:51.150 --> 03:48:53.252
HAVE A E. I. R. KERN COUNTY I
03:48:53.319 --> 03:48:55.822
ARE AND MAKES S. NEXT TO CARBON
03:48:55.888 --> 03:48:58.124
NEUTRAL ON EVERY BARREL OF OIL
03:48:58.191 --> 03:49:00.026
THAT COMES OUT OF THE GROUND
03:49:00.093 --> 03:49:01.627
EVERY BARREL OF OIL. WE HAVE
03:49:01.694 --> 03:49:03.963
APPROVAL FOR CARBON CAPTURE
03:49:04.030 --> 03:49:06.132
FIELD TO USE SO THAT WE CAN
03:49:06.199 --> 03:49:07.700
CAPTURE THE REST OF THE CARBON
03:49:07.767 --> 03:49:09.602
IS PRODUCED BY THE OIL INDUSTRY
03:49:09.669 --> 03:49:11.037
AND NOW THIS BILL IS SAYING WE
03:49:11.104 --> 03:49:14.273
CAN'T DO IT FOR ENHANCED OIL
03:49:14.340 --> 03:49:16.442
RECOVERY. IF YOU DON'T GET OIL
03:49:16.509 --> 03:49:17.510
FROM FOREIGN COUNTRIES THAT ARE
03:49:17.577 --> 03:49:20.146
HOSTILE TO US THE BILL LET WOMEN
03:49:20.213 --> 03:49:22.882
VOTE. THAT AND YOU KNOW. MAKE
03:49:22.949 --> 03:49:25.184
WOMEN SUBSERVIENT TO MEN ON A
03:49:25.251 --> 03:49:28.855
CONTINUOUS BASIS. THAT DESTROY
03:49:28.921 --> 03:49:29.856
AND BULLDOZED DOWN THE
03:49:29.922 --> 03:49:31.057
RAINFOREST AND DON'T HAVE THE
03:49:31.124 --> 03:49:32.058
SAME ENVIRONMENTAL AND
03:49:32.125 --> 03:49:33.192
REGULATORY PROCESSES THAT WE
03:49:33.259 --> 03:49:34.994
HAVE HERE IN CALIFORNIA. YOU
03:49:35.061 --> 03:49:37.930
HAVE TO GET IT FROM CALIFORNIA.
03:49:37.997 --> 03:49:39.765
AND WE'RE THE EPICENTER IN BILLS
03:49:39.832 --> 03:49:42.468
LIKE THIS JUST ATTACK MY
03:49:42.535 --> 03:49:44.103
DISTRICT AND WITH ALL DUE
03:49:44.170 --> 03:49:45.304
RESPECT I DON'T RUN A TON OF.
03:49:45.371 --> 03:49:47.073
THAT ATTACK YOUR DISTRICT. YOU
03:49:47.140 --> 03:49:50.443
HAVE ONE ALMOST ON A DAILY BASIS
03:49:50.510 --> 03:49:52.411
. IN THIS CHAMBER TO ATTACK MY
03:49:52.478 --> 03:49:54.113
DISTRICT WHO DOES NOTHING BUT
03:49:54.180 --> 03:49:55.248
HELP ALL OF YOUR DISTRICTS
03:49:55.314 --> 03:49:56.782
PROVIDE ENERGY FOR YOUR
03:49:56.849 --> 03:49:58.518
CONSTITUENTS AND GROW THE FOOD
03:49:58.584 --> 03:50:01.120
YOU EAT. I JUST DON'T GET IT
03:50:01.187 --> 03:50:03.689
THIS IS A UNDER. WITH HER AND
03:50:03.756 --> 03:50:05.358
OTHER QUESTION THERE NO I'M ON
03:50:05.424 --> 03:50:07.660
MY OWN TIME MA'AM. IS A SENATE
03:50:07.727 --> 03:50:09.262
THING OR AN ASSEMBLY THING I YOU
03:50:09.328 --> 03:50:12.565
KNOW IT'S A SENATE THING- I
03:50:12.632 --> 03:50:13.499
DIDN'T KNOW THAT. ALL RIGHT ON
03:50:13.566 --> 03:50:15.968
MY OWN TIME ON YOUR OWN TIME AND
03:50:16.035 --> 03:50:17.370
TO MATCH THE BILL PLEASE YEAH
03:50:17.436 --> 03:50:17.970
ABSOLUTELY WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
03:50:18.037 --> 03:50:19.472
CARBON CAPTURE AND THAT'S WHAT
03:50:19.539 --> 03:50:20.406
I'M ADDRESSING YOUR LITTLE CARD
03:50:20.473 --> 03:50:23.042
CAN'T. YEAH CARBON CAPTURE IN MY
03:50:23.109 --> 03:50:24.710
DISTRICT MA'AM. SO CARBON
03:50:24.777 --> 03:50:31.617
CAPTURE BORDER IN MY DISHONORING. THIS PERCENT RETURN WHAT IS
03:50:31.684 --> 03:50:33.352
YOUR POINT OF ORDER I UNDERSTAND
03:50:33.419 --> 03:50:34.787
HE'S IN THE RULES YOU'RE NOT
03:50:34.854 --> 03:50:36.422
SUPPOSED TO REGARD A MEMBER
03:50:36.489 --> 03:50:37.823
PERSONALLY AND INDIVIDUALLY CALL
03:50:37.890 --> 03:50:39.759
THEM OUT I HEARD IN THE REMARKS
03:50:39.825 --> 03:50:41.127
SAYING THAT A MEMBER IS
03:50:41.194 --> 03:50:42.595
ATTACKING ANOTHER MEMBER INNER
03:50:42.662 --> 03:50:44.864
DISTRICTS I'D LIKE THEM TO SPEAK
03:50:44.931 --> 03:50:46.299
TO THE MERITS OF THE BILL AND
03:50:46.365 --> 03:50:50.603
NOT. ADDRESS INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS-
03:50:50.670 --> 03:50:51.704
AND BREAK SENATE PROTOCOL.
03:50:51.771 --> 03:50:53.406
INCORRECT THE POINT OF ORDER IS
03:50:53.472 --> 03:50:55.241
WELL TAKEN YOU'RE NOT SUPPOSED
03:50:55.308 --> 03:50:57.109
TO CALL OUT OTHER MEMBERS WHO
03:50:57.176 --> 03:51:00.112
DID NOT USERNAME BUT YES. ONE OF
03:51:00.179 --> 03:51:01.280
ORDER IS WELL TAKEN PLEASE
03:51:01.347 --> 03:51:03.382
PROCEED. I DID A CALL OUT OF
03:51:03.449 --> 03:51:05.585
PARTICULAR MEMBER I TALKED ABOUT
03:51:05.651 --> 03:51:08.354
THE BODY AS A WHOLE. IT WASN'T A
03:51:08.421 --> 03:51:09.622
PARTICULAR MEMBER IT WAS THESE
03:51:09.689 --> 03:51:12.658
BODIED ON THE BILL. SO THE BILL
03:51:12.725 --> 03:51:13.826
THE BILL IS JUST ANOTHER
03:51:13.893 --> 03:51:15.761
MECHANISM THAT ATTACKS MY
03:51:15.828 --> 03:51:18.664
DISTRICT. WE USE WE HAVE AN
03:51:18.731 --> 03:51:21.100
APPROVAL FOR ONE OF THE MOST
03:51:21.167 --> 03:51:22.401
GREATEST CARBON CAPTURE WE WERE
03:51:22.468 --> 03:51:24.170
THE FIRST ONES HOW MANY GUYS IN
03:51:24.237 --> 03:51:25.171
YOUR DISTRICT HAVE A CARBON
03:51:25.238 --> 03:51:26.239
CAPTURE FIELDING YOUR DISTRICTS
03:51:26.305 --> 03:51:29.342
RIGHT NOW WE HAVE ONE BECAUSE
03:51:29.408 --> 03:51:31.244
WE'RE TRYING TO PIECE ALL OF YOU
03:51:31.310 --> 03:51:32.345
TO SHOW YOU THAT WE CAN.
03:51:32.411 --> 03:51:34.614
RECOVERY IN A VERY SAFE AND
03:51:34.680 --> 03:51:36.015
EFFECTIVE WAY INSTEAD OF
03:51:36.082 --> 03:51:38.551
POLLUTING THE WORLD WITH BUNKER
03:51:38.618 --> 03:51:40.219
FUEL TANKER SHIPS THAT BRING IT
03:51:40.286 --> 03:51:42.154
TO OUR STATE OR BULLDOZED DOWN
03:51:42.221 --> 03:51:44.890
THE RAINFOREST SO WE'RE SHOWING
03:51:44.957 --> 03:51:46.926
YOU THAT WE CAN DO THIS WE HAVE
03:51:46.993 --> 03:51:49.095
A WE HAVE BEEN DOING IT FOR THE
03:51:49.161 --> 03:51:50.162
LAST I DON'T KNOW A HUNDRED
03:51:50.229 --> 03:51:52.331
YEARS AND WE GOT INTO TECHNOLOGY
03:51:52.398 --> 03:51:54.367
AS FAR AS GREEN ENERGY. PRODUCED
03:51:54.433 --> 03:51:57.103
53% OF THE STATE'S GREEN
03:51:57.169 --> 03:51:58.604
TECHNOLOGY IN GREEN ENERGY.
03:51:58.671 --> 03:52:01.307
EXPENDING TRANSMISSION LINES AND
03:52:01.374 --> 03:52:04.110
ALL THOSE THINGS WE'RE THE ONLY
03:52:04.176 --> 03:52:05.411
COUNTY IT HAS MAJOR TRANSIT
03:52:05.478 --> 03:52:08.047
GOING. GOOD SO WE CAN SHOW YOU.
03:52:08.114 --> 03:52:09.649
I DO IT RIGHT IN THIS CERTAIN
03:52:09.715 --> 03:52:11.450
THIS BILL SIR CONDEMNS THAT
03:52:11.517 --> 03:52:14.787
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NO VOTE
03:52:14.854 --> 03:52:17.823
BECAUSE CENTER GROVE CENTER DODD
03:52:17.890 --> 03:52:20.426
. YEAH PRESIDENT MEMBERS. I MAY
03:52:20.493 --> 03:52:22.528
BE BRIEF YOU KNOW WE'VE HEARD IN
03:52:22.595 --> 03:52:24.597
THIS IN THIS ROOM HERE A NUMBER
03:52:24.664 --> 03:52:27.733
OF TIMES WITH BILLS AND MAYBE
03:52:27.800 --> 03:52:29.835
EVEN BACK TO THE ASSEMBLY ABOUT
03:52:29.902 --> 03:52:32.672
- CLIMATE CHANGE BEING A CLEAR
03:52:32.738 --> 03:52:33.406
AND EXISTENTIAL THREAT TO
03:52:33.472 --> 03:52:34.607
MANKIND AS WE KNOW IT. BUT THEN
03:52:34.674 --> 03:52:37.343
WE HEAR POSITS FROM TIME TO TIME
03:52:37.410 --> 03:52:40.346
EXCEPT. IF THERE'S NOT TESLA OR
03:52:40.413 --> 03:52:43.015
LABOR PEACE OF TESLA EXCEPT IF
03:52:43.082 --> 03:52:45.518
THERE'S NOT- AUTOMATION AT THE
03:52:45.584 --> 03:52:48.020
PORTS. AND NOW WE'RE HEARING
03:52:48.087 --> 03:52:51.991
EXCEPT- IF THERE'S- ENHANCED OIL
03:52:52.058 --> 03:52:55.795
RECOVERY. I DO AGREE WITH THAT
03:52:55.861 --> 03:52:57.163
BY COLLEAGUES FROM FROM THE
03:52:57.229 --> 03:52:59.732
OTHER SIDE OF THE ISLAND SOME OF
03:52:59.799 --> 03:53:02.501
THEIR POINTS THAT THEY MAKE I'VE
03:53:02.568 --> 03:53:06.038
TALKED. TO WITH A I CARE MIKE
03:53:06.105 --> 03:53:08.274
I'VE TALKED TO MY COLLEAGUE WITH
03:53:08.341 --> 03:53:10.109
WITH THE OTHER BILL AND IN THE
03:53:10.176 --> 03:53:12.044
IN THE CENTER FROM YOUR SANTA
03:53:12.111 --> 03:53:14.613
CRUZ I THINK THEY DO MAKE SENSE
03:53:14.680 --> 03:53:15.181
IT'S NOT AN EITHER OR THING
03:53:15.247 --> 03:53:17.583
RIGHT NOW THEY TOLD ME WHAT WE
03:53:17.650 --> 03:53:20.019
HAVE TO DO IS WE HAVE TO GET TO
03:53:20.086 --> 03:53:22.755
A PLACE WHERE WE'RE GONNA
03:53:22.822 --> 03:53:23.956
HOPEFULLY MERE A FEDERAL POLICY
03:53:24.023 --> 03:53:26.625
OR- SPON OFTEN THAT. YOU'LL BE A
03:53:26.692 --> 03:53:29.261
BETTER LEADER- YOUR FOR THE
03:53:29.328 --> 03:53:31.731
CALIFORNIA STATE SENATE ON THIS
03:53:31.797 --> 03:53:32.932
SPECIFIC ISSUE. SO I WILL BE
03:53:32.998 --> 03:53:35.968
TRUST TRUSTING- THE LEADERSHIP.
03:53:36.035 --> 03:53:38.104
WHO HAS- MOVED BOTH OF THESE
03:53:38.170 --> 03:53:40.940
BILLS FOR. AND WITH THAT IN
03:53:41.006 --> 03:53:43.209
MIND- I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE ON
03:53:43.275 --> 03:53:45.177
THIS BILL. THANK CENTER DOT
03:53:45.244 --> 03:53:46.746
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
03:53:46.812 --> 03:53:49.248
DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING THEM
03:53:49.315 --> 03:53:50.850
SENATE LET ALONE YOU MAY CLOSE
03:53:50.916 --> 03:53:52.718
THANK YOU MEMBERS AND I
03:53:52.785 --> 03:53:54.353
APPRECIATE THE DISCUSSION AND
03:53:54.420 --> 03:53:55.121
THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU
03:53:55.187 --> 03:53:57.156
HAVE A BILL- AND IT GOES THROUGH
03:53:57.223 --> 03:53:58.324
THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS YOU'RE
03:53:58.391 --> 03:53:59.392
ABLE TO HAVE A PUBLIC
03:53:59.458 --> 03:54:00.826
CONVERSATION. RECEIVE
03:54:00.893 --> 03:54:03.629
LEGISLATIVE INPUT REVIEW AND
03:54:03.696 --> 03:54:05.931
ANALYSIS- AND I RESPECT ALL THE
03:54:05.998 --> 03:54:07.833
DIFFERENT POINTS OF. WANT TO GO
03:54:07.900 --> 03:54:09.034
ON RECORD FIRST. IN THE ATTIC
03:54:09.101 --> 03:54:11.070
KERN COUNTY AND I HAVE VISITED-
03:54:11.137 --> 03:54:12.872
THE COMMUNITIES THERE WE DO HAVE
03:54:12.938 --> 03:54:14.240
SUPPORT FROM THIS BILL FROM KERN
03:54:14.306 --> 03:54:17.476
COUNTY- CONSTITUENTS- IN SO I
03:54:17.543 --> 03:54:18.377
THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT TO KNOW
03:54:18.444 --> 03:54:21.947
BECAUSE- THIS IS ONE TOOL THERE
03:54:22.014 --> 03:54:23.816
IS NO ONE IN THIS STATE RIGHT
03:54:23.883 --> 03:54:25.684
NOW THAT IS USING ENHANCED OIL
03:54:25.751 --> 03:54:27.686
RECOVERY RELATED TO CARBON
03:54:27.753 --> 03:54:30.289
CAPTURE. I REPEAT THAT THERE IS
03:54:30.356 --> 03:54:32.091
NO ONE IN THIS STATE THAT IS
03:54:32.158 --> 03:54:34.994
USING ENHANCED OIL RECOVERY
03:54:35.060 --> 03:54:36.996
RELATED TO CARBON CAPTURE AND
03:54:37.062 --> 03:54:39.165
THIS IS ABOUT ENSURING THAT A
03:54:39.231 --> 03:54:41.534
TOOL- THAT HAVE POTENTIAL TO
03:54:41.600 --> 03:54:46.405
IMPACT FRONTLINE COMMUNITIES IS
03:54:46.472 --> 03:54:48.741
NOT A TOOL THAT WILL BE USED TO
03:54:48.808 --> 03:54:51.544
EVEN. THE PROJECT. IN OUR STATE
03:54:51.610 --> 03:54:53.279
THIS IS NOT A TOOL THAT'S BEING
03:54:53.345 --> 03:54:55.247
USED AND WE WANT TO MAKE SURE IT
03:54:55.314 --> 03:54:57.116
MOVES FORWARD THIS BILL DOES NOT
03:54:57.183 --> 03:54:59.018
STOP ANY CARBON CAPTURING
03:54:59.084 --> 03:55:02.688
PROGRAM IN ANY OF THE SPECIFIC
03:55:02.755 --> 03:55:03.923
INDUSTRIES AS A MATTER OF FACT
03:55:03.989 --> 03:55:07.560
YESTERDAY A LOT OF VOTED AT FOR
03:55:07.626 --> 03:55:08.727
ONE OF THE CARBON CAPTURE BILLS
03:55:08.794 --> 03:55:12.131
THAT INCLUDED THIS LANGUAGE IN
03:55:12.198 --> 03:55:12.965
THE BATTLE FOR THE PILOT
03:55:13.032 --> 03:55:15.034
PROJECT- THAT WAS EXIST THAT
03:55:15.100 --> 03:55:18.070
EXISTS FOR CEMENT SO WE HAVE A
03:55:18.137 --> 03:55:20.639
RECORD. OF THIS AND I'LL PASS A
03:55:20.706 --> 03:55:22.775
FOR PURPOSES OF CONTINUING THE
03:55:22.842 --> 03:55:27.246
CONVERSATION- THAT WE MOVE THIS
03:55:27.313 --> 03:55:28.714
BILL FORWARD AND WE VúI. THE
03:55:28.781 --> 03:55:30.416
ENTER LIMÓN MADAM SECRETARY
03:55:30.483 --> 03:55:33.519
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN I
03:55:33.586 --> 03:55:38.424
ARCHULETA ATKINS AYE BATES NO
03:55:38.491 --> 03:55:44.463
BAKER I PORTIONS NO BRADFORD.
03:55:44.530 --> 03:55:49.502
CABALLERO I CORTES HE DALLY NO
03:55:49.568 --> 03:55:54.507
DODD AYE TORONTO AYE EGGMAN.
03:55:54.573 --> 03:55:59.245
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER. GONZALEZ I
03:55:59.311 --> 03:56:04.783
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESTERN HI
03:56:04.850 --> 03:56:11.790
FURTADO. JONES NO KAMLAGER. I
03:56:11.857 --> 03:56:17.229
LAYERED I LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE
03:56:17.296 --> 03:56:22.101
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ. NO MAN I
03:56:22.167 --> 03:56:27.940
NEWMAN. NIELSEN NO A CHOI BOGUE
03:56:28.007 --> 03:56:33.646
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO. ROTH AYE
03:56:33.712 --> 03:56:41.253
RUBIO. SKINNER I STERN. HI I'M
03:56:41.320 --> 03:56:45.391
BURKE I WAKE HAUSPIE I WIENER
03:56:45.457 --> 03:56:48.761
AYE WILK. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
03:56:48.827 --> 03:56:55.534
MEMBERS. ARCHULETA BRADFORD I.
03:56:55.601 --> 03:57:00.673
CORTELLI GLAZER. HERTZBERG
03:57:00.739 --> 03:57:07.279
FURTADO. NEWMAN PORTANTINO I
03:57:07.346 --> 03:57:12.785
RUBIO. WILK I TWENTY FOUR NEWS
03:57:12.851 --> 03:57:19.224
EIGHT. WELCOME NO. IS TWENTY
03:57:19.291 --> 03:57:20.392
FOUR KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE
03:57:20.459 --> 03:57:21.961
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON THE
03:57:22.027 --> 03:57:23.996
FILE ITEM NUMBER FORTY TWO
03:57:24.063 --> 03:57:25.631
SENATOR CABALLERO MADAM
03:57:25.698 --> 03:57:28.434
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
03:57:28.500 --> 03:57:30.235
BILL ELEVEN OH ONE BY SENATOR
03:57:30.302 --> 03:57:34.239
CABALLERO AN ACT RELATING TO
03:57:34.306 --> 03:57:34.840
CARBON SEQUESTRATION. CENTER
03:57:34.907 --> 03:57:36.375
CABALLERO. VERY MUCH MADAM
03:57:36.442 --> 03:57:38.577
PRESIDENT SENATORS I'M PLEASED
03:57:38.644 --> 03:57:41.780
TO PRESENT S. B. ELEVEN OH ONE
03:57:41.847 --> 03:57:42.681
WHICH WILL ENABLE THE
03:57:42.748 --> 03:57:44.516
DEVELOPMENT AND THE USE OF
03:57:44.583 --> 03:57:46.652
CARBON CAPTURE UTILIZATION AND
03:57:46.719 --> 03:57:50.289
SEQUESTRATION OR C. C. U. S. AS
03:57:50.356 --> 03:57:51.724
PART OF THE STATE'S CLIMATE
03:57:51.790 --> 03:57:53.058
STRATEGY BY CREATING AN
03:57:53.125 --> 03:57:55.094
ADMINISTRATIVE FRAMEWORK THAT
03:57:55.160 --> 03:57:58.063
ENSURES. X. EXPEDIENCY SAFETY
03:57:58.130 --> 03:58:00.366
AND ACCOUNTABILITY FOR CARBON
03:58:00.432 --> 03:58:01.233
CAPTURE PROJECTS ACROSS THE
03:58:01.300 --> 03:58:03.602
STATE. I'D LIKE TO THANK THE PRO
03:58:03.669 --> 03:58:05.404
TEM FOR HER LEADERSHIP IN
03:58:05.471 --> 03:58:07.172
CONVENING A SENATE CLIMATE
03:58:07.239 --> 03:58:10.609
WORKING AT THE SENATE. CLIMATE
03:58:10.676 --> 03:58:12.845
CHANGE WORKING GROUP AND MEMBERS
03:58:12.911 --> 03:58:14.613
OF THE GROUP THAT WORKS HARD TO
03:58:14.680 --> 03:58:16.382
CRAFT PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS TO
03:58:16.448 --> 03:58:19.051
MEET OUR GHG GOALS I ESPECIALLY
03:58:19.118 --> 03:58:20.452
WOULD LIKE TO RECOGNIZE THE
03:58:20.519 --> 03:58:22.588
SENATOR FROM SANTA BARBARA FOR
03:58:22.655 --> 03:58:25.357
WORKING WITH. WITH ME TO MEET
03:58:25.424 --> 03:58:26.792
WITH THE STAKEHOLDERS AS WE
03:58:26.859 --> 03:58:29.094
DISCUSSED CARBON CAPTURE AND
03:58:29.161 --> 03:58:31.030
ALSO RECOGNIZE THE CHAIR THE
03:58:31.096 --> 03:58:32.264
SENATOR FROM SANTA CRUZ FOR
03:58:32.331 --> 03:58:33.532
SHEPHERDING US THROUGH THIS
03:58:33.599 --> 03:58:34.967
PROCESS I'S NOT EASY TO GET A
03:58:35.034 --> 03:58:36.602
GROUP OF SENATORS TOGETHER. TO
03:58:36.669 --> 03:58:38.804
DISCUSS POLICY THAT IS VERY
03:58:38.871 --> 03:58:40.973
DIFFICULT AND COMPLICATED AND SO
03:58:41.040 --> 03:58:42.675
I REALLY WANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT
03:58:42.741 --> 03:58:44.209
THE HARD WORK THAT WENT INTO IT.
03:58:44.276 --> 03:58:46.045
AND I ALSO WANT TO THANK
03:58:46.111 --> 03:58:47.646
EVERYONE WHO MET WITH US TO
03:58:47.713 --> 03:58:49.248
DISCUSS THE C. C. U. S. POLICY-
03:58:49.314 --> 03:58:51.550
DESPITE THEIR DISAGREEMENTS ON
03:58:51.617 --> 03:58:53.052
HOW TO DO IT AND WHEN TO DO IT
03:58:53.118 --> 03:58:55.120
AND WHETHER IT SHOULD IT SHOULD
03:58:55.187 --> 03:58:57.122
HAPPEN AT ALL I THINK WE HAD
03:58:57.189 --> 03:58:58.691
SOME REALLY ROBUST CONVERSATIONS
03:58:58.757 --> 03:59:01.560
SO. ON I WANT TO THANK EVERYONE
03:59:01.627 --> 03:59:03.262
FOR MEETING WITH US. NUMEROUS
03:59:03.328 --> 03:59:05.998
EXPERTS. INCLUDING THE
03:59:06.065 --> 03:59:07.032
INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON
03:59:07.099 --> 03:59:09.068
CLIMATE CHANGE THE INTERNATIONAL
03:59:09.134 --> 03:59:11.070
ENERGY AGENCY STANFORD
03:59:11.136 --> 03:59:13.939
UNIVERSITY LAWRENCE. LIVERMORE
03:59:14.006 --> 03:59:15.774
NATIONAL LABORATORY THE
03:59:15.841 --> 03:59:17.242
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA AT
03:59:17.309 --> 03:59:19.478
BERKELEY AND THE UNIVERSITY OF
03:59:19.545 --> 03:59:21.213
CALIFORNIA AT LAST AT AT LOS
03:59:21.280 --> 03:59:23.782
ANGELES ALL. INCREDIBLY
03:59:23.849 --> 03:59:25.884
DEDICATED RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS
03:59:25.951 --> 03:59:27.319
INCLUDING THE CALIFORNIA AIR
03:59:27.386 --> 03:59:29.455
RESOURCES BOARD HAVE IDENTIFIED
03:59:29.521 --> 03:59:32.324
C. C. U. S. AS A CRITICAL AND
03:59:32.391 --> 03:59:33.759
NECESSARY COMPONENT OF
03:59:33.826 --> 03:59:35.794
SUCCESSFUL CLIMATE ACTION WE
03:59:35.861 --> 03:59:38.497
NASH. THE CALIFORNIA CARBON
03:59:38.564 --> 03:59:40.899
NEUTRALITY BY TWENTY FORTY FIVE
03:59:40.966 --> 03:59:42.000
AND NET NEGATIVE EMISSIONS
03:59:42.067 --> 03:59:43.635
THEREAFTER WILL REQUIRE A
03:59:43.702 --> 03:59:45.871
MULTITUDE OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN
03:59:45.938 --> 03:59:48.307
ITS INITIATIVES ONE THAT IS
03:59:48.373 --> 03:59:50.142
VITAL TO OUR STATE SUCCESS IS
03:59:50.209 --> 03:59:51.877
CARBON CAPTURE UTILIZATION IS
03:59:51.944 --> 03:59:54.413
SEQUESTRATION. AS THE TECHNOLOGY
03:59:54.480 --> 03:59:57.082
ADVANCES WE NEED TO LOOK AT ALL
03:59:57.149 --> 03:59:59.485
OUR TECHNOLOGIES TO BE ABLE TO
03:59:59.551 --> 04:00:01.420
ANALYZE AND TO DETERMINE WHETHER
04:00:01.487 --> 04:00:03.155
THEY HELP US TO MEET OUR GOALS.
04:00:03.222 --> 04:00:04.890
SO THIS SENTIMENT IS SHARED WITH
04:00:04.957 --> 04:00:07.092
OUR EX WITH ARE NOT ONLY OUR
04:00:07.159 --> 04:00:07.993
EXPERT SCIENTIST BUT OUR FEDERAL
04:00:08.060 --> 04:00:10.162
PARTNERS. AS WELL IN ORDER TO
04:00:10.229 --> 04:00:11.563
ACHIEVE PRESIDENT BIDEN'S
04:00:11.630 --> 04:00:13.298
AMBITIOUS DOMESTIC CLIMATE GOAL
04:00:13.365 --> 04:00:15.100
OF NET ZERO EMISSIONS ECONOMY
04:00:15.167 --> 04:00:17.136
WIDE BY TWENTY FIFTY THE BIDEN
04:00:17.202 --> 04:00:18.937
ADMINISTRATION PROJECTS THE NEED
04:00:19.004 --> 04:00:20.272
TO CAPTURE TRANSPORT AND
04:00:20.339 --> 04:00:21.473
PERMANENTLY SEQUESTER
04:00:21.540 --> 04:00:23.742
SIGNIFICANT QUANTITIES OF CARBON
04:00:23.809 --> 04:00:26.111
DIOXIDE DIOXIDE. C. C. U. S.
04:00:26.178 --> 04:00:28.213
PROVIDES ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS
04:00:28.280 --> 04:00:29.915
THE PRODUCT THE PROCESS CAPTURE
04:00:29.982 --> 04:00:32.084
CARBON THIS IS A REAL
04:00:32.151 --> 04:00:34.486
SIMPLIFICATION BUT IT CAPTURES
04:00:34.553 --> 04:00:36.121
CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS
04:00:36.188 --> 04:00:37.790
STRAIGHT FROM THE SOURCE TO
04:00:37.856 --> 04:00:39.258
AVOID RELEASED INTO THE
04:00:39.324 --> 04:00:41.059
ATMOSPHERE AND ESTIMATE
04:00:41.126 --> 04:00:43.629
ESTIMATES INDICATE ABOUT 50% OF
04:00:43.695 --> 04:00:45.597
THE STATE'S TOTAL. CO TWO
04:00:45.664 --> 04:00:46.932
EMISSIONS CAN BE CAPTURED AND
04:00:46.999 --> 04:00:50.903
STORED WITH C. C. U. S. IT HAS
04:00:50.969 --> 04:00:51.904
BENEFITS FOR OUR WORKFORCE AND
04:00:51.970 --> 04:00:54.339
OVERALL IT. IS WELL THE USE OF
04:00:54.406 --> 04:00:56.308
C. C. U. S. COULD ENABLE
04:00:56.375 --> 04:00:57.109
DIFFICULT TO DECARBONISE
04:00:57.176 --> 04:00:59.945
INDUSTRY TO STAY IN BUSINESS AND
04:01:00.012 --> 04:01:01.079
CONTINUE TO MAKE LARGE
04:01:01.146 --> 04:01:02.981
CONTRIBUTIONS TO CALIFORNIA'S
04:01:03.048 --> 04:01:04.550
ECONOMY WHILE DRAMATICALLY
04:01:04.616 --> 04:01:08.654
REDUCING THEIR GHG. EMISSIONS
04:01:08.720 --> 04:01:10.189
JUST REASONABLE THE STATE COULD
04:01:10.255 --> 04:01:11.990
ACTUALLY COME BACK AND PROVIDE
04:01:12.057 --> 04:01:14.226
GOOD JOBS IN THE OPPORTUNITY BE
04:01:14.293 --> 04:01:16.328
FOR US TO BE ABLE TO. MAKE OUR
04:01:16.395 --> 04:01:18.630
OWN STEEL CONTINUE TO DO CEMENT
04:01:18.697 --> 04:01:19.498
PRODUCTION AND DO THE
04:01:19.565 --> 04:01:22.301
INDUSTRIAL- WORK THAT WE'VE DONE
04:01:22.367 --> 04:01:24.770
IN IMPACT IN PAST YEARS SB
04:01:24.837 --> 04:01:26.505
ELEVEN A ONE SEEKS TO ESTABLISH
04:01:26.572 --> 04:01:27.706
A CARBON CAPTURE UTILIZATION
04:01:27.773 --> 04:01:29.842
SEQUESTRATION PROGRAM UNDER THE
04:01:29.908 --> 04:01:31.510
CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES BOARD
04:01:31.577 --> 04:01:34.112
BOARD. THE PRIMARY OBJECTIVE OF
04:01:34.179 --> 04:01:35.247
WHICH IS TO ASSIST IN THE
04:01:35.314 --> 04:01:37.349
DEPLOYMENT OF PROJECTS THAT WILL
04:01:37.416 --> 04:01:38.884
ACCELERATE THE DEVELOPMENT AND
04:01:38.951 --> 04:01:40.619
COMMERCIALIZATION OF ADVANCED
04:01:40.686 --> 04:01:43.822
NEW TECHNOLOGIES THE CAPTURE AND
04:01:43.889 --> 04:01:46.258
SEQUESTER CARBON DIOXIDE.
04:01:46.325 --> 04:01:48.927
INDUSTRIAL THE BILL WILL ADDRESS
04:01:48.994 --> 04:01:50.295
THE ISSUE OF UNDERGROUND FOR
04:01:50.362 --> 04:01:52.331
SPACE AND CREATE A CLEAR AND
04:01:52.397 --> 04:01:53.899
DEFINED LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR POOR
04:01:53.966 --> 04:01:55.601
SPACE OWNERSHIP FOR THE
04:01:55.667 --> 04:01:57.436
SEQUESTRATION ALIGNING OUR
04:01:57.502 --> 04:01:58.904
STANDARDS WITH FEDERAL CSU
04:01:58.971 --> 04:02:01.740
REGULAR REGULATIONS WILL ENSURE
04:02:01.807 --> 04:02:04.042
ONE THE CALIFORNIA CAN BENEFIT
04:02:04.109 --> 04:02:08.280
FROM FEDERAL DOLLARS THAT HAVE
04:02:08.347 --> 04:02:12.451
BEEN- EDS ARE TAX- CREDITS. AND
04:02:12.517 --> 04:02:13.652
THAT CALIFORNIA'S WORKING WITH
04:02:13.719 --> 04:02:15.020
OUR FEDERAL PARTNERS TO MEET OUR
04:02:15.087 --> 04:02:16.688
CLIMATE GOALS IN AN EFFICIENT
04:02:16.755 --> 04:02:18.457
AND LOGICAL FASHION WE COULD
04:02:18.523 --> 04:02:20.259
EASILY BECOME A GLOBAL THE
04:02:20.325 --> 04:02:22.160
GLOBAL LEADER IN C. C. U. S. THE
04:02:22.227 --> 04:02:24.396
DEVELOPMENT AND DEPLOYMENT AS WE
04:02:24.463 --> 04:02:26.331
HAVE WITH OTHER CLEAN ENERGY'S
04:02:26.398 --> 04:02:27.666
BY SUPPORTING MEASURES THAT
04:02:27.733 --> 04:02:29.167
ENDEAVOR TO UTILIZE C. C. U. S.
04:02:29.234 --> 04:02:30.802
TO THE STATE'S BENEFIT WE CAN
04:02:30.869 --> 04:02:32.738
CREATE ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY FOR
04:02:32.804 --> 04:02:35.173
ALL CALIFORNIANS ON. THERE THE
04:02:35.240 --> 04:02:37.643
DRESSED INDUSTRIAL TRANSITION TO
04:02:37.709 --> 04:02:39.011
GOOD PAYING INDUSTRIAL JOBS YOU
04:02:39.077 --> 04:02:42.514
KNOW WE THAT WE KEEP TALKING
04:02:42.581 --> 04:02:44.149
ABOUT IT JUST TRANSITION THIS IS
04:02:44.216 --> 04:02:46.151
A PIECE THAT. FOR GOOD
04:02:46.218 --> 04:02:48.587
INDUSTRIAL JOBS. WHILE WE WORK
04:02:48.654 --> 04:02:49.922
TO ATTAIN OUR STATES CLIMATE
04:02:49.988 --> 04:02:50.889
CHANGE BECAUSE THAT'S HOW I
04:02:50.956 --> 04:02:53.191
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
04:02:53.258 --> 04:02:55.494
TODAY. THE USER CABALLERO
04:02:55.560 --> 04:03:00.999
SENATOR ALAN. OUR MEMBERS I JUST
04:03:01.066 --> 04:03:02.968
WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO
04:03:03.035 --> 04:03:05.203
PUBLICLY THANK AND APPLAUD THE
04:03:05.270 --> 04:03:07.172
HARD WORK OF OUR COLLEAGUES FROM
04:03:07.239 --> 04:03:08.907
MERCED AND FROM SANTA BARBARA
04:03:08.974 --> 04:03:10.342
THE WORKING SO HARD IN THIS VERY
04:03:10.409 --> 04:03:11.276
DIFFICULT VERY PUBLIC POLICY
04:03:11.343 --> 04:03:13.111
MAKING I WITH THE SENATE HAVING
04:03:13.178 --> 04:03:15.213
JUST PASSED SB THIRTEEN FOURTEEN
04:03:15.280 --> 04:03:17.049
I CERTAINLY FEEL COMFORTABLE
04:03:17.115 --> 04:03:19.084
SUPPORTING. SB ELEVEN A ONE AND-
04:03:19.151 --> 04:03:20.452
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
04:03:20.519 --> 04:03:22.554
VOTE FOR THESE TWO BILLS TO MOVE
04:03:22.621 --> 04:03:25.357
FORWARD. ON THIS IMPORTANT ISSUE
04:03:25.424 --> 04:03:26.858
OF PUBLIC POLICY MAKING. THANK
04:03:26.925 --> 04:03:30.896
YOU SENATOR ALAN CENTER GROVE.
04:03:30.963 --> 04:03:34.166
THANK YOU- MADAM PRESIDENT I
04:03:34.232 --> 04:03:37.169
RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL. MY
04:03:37.235 --> 04:03:38.837
COLLEAGUE FROM STOCKTON IS
04:03:38.904 --> 04:03:41.173
GRABBING HER CHEST I DO I RISE
04:03:41.239 --> 04:03:43.241
IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL IT DOES
04:03:43.308 --> 04:03:44.609
IT DOES INCLUDE ENHANCED OIL
04:03:44.676 --> 04:03:47.346
RECOVERY WHICH IS HUGE. AND-
04:03:47.412 --> 04:03:48.914
JUST TO MAKE A CLARIFICATION THE
04:03:48.981 --> 04:03:50.682
CARBON CAPTURE FIELD THAT WE
04:03:50.749 --> 04:03:52.117
HAVE IS AN ESTIMATED SEVENTY
04:03:52.184 --> 04:03:54.353
EIGHT MILLION TONS OF CARBON
04:03:54.419 --> 04:03:56.021
THAT WILL BE CAPTURED WHICH WE
04:03:56.088 --> 04:03:59.324
DON'T EVEN HAVE A- IN THE CARBON
04:03:59.391 --> 04:04:01.093
ARENA IN KERN COUNTY BECAUSE WE
04:04:01.159 --> 04:04:03.128
HAVE THE E. I. R. THAT OFFSETS
04:04:03.195 --> 04:04:05.297
ALL OF THAT WERE WE BUY. AND
04:04:05.364 --> 04:04:07.165
SELL THEIR VEHICLES FOR CHURCHES
04:04:07.232 --> 04:04:08.600
FOR SCHOOLS WE SOLAR PANELS FOR
04:04:08.667 --> 04:04:09.935
ALL OF OUR SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
04:04:10.002 --> 04:04:12.304
AND SO ON AND SO FORTH AND THAT
04:04:12.371 --> 04:04:14.139
OFFSETS AND MITIGATES THE CARBON
04:04:14.206 --> 04:04:16.308
THAT THE OIL INDUSTRY PRODUCES.
04:04:16.375 --> 04:04:18.377
SO I APPRECIATE AND APPLAUD THE
04:04:18.443 --> 04:04:19.878
GOOD SENATOR FROM MERCED FOR
04:04:19.945 --> 04:04:21.246
BRINGING A COMMONSENSE CARBON
04:04:21.313 --> 04:04:23.215
CAPTURE BILL TO THE FLOOR TODAY
04:04:23.281 --> 04:04:25.717
THANK YOU THANK YOU CENTER GROVE
04:04:25.784 --> 04:04:28.987
SENATOR LAYERED. ANOTHER
04:04:29.054 --> 04:04:30.355
SOMETHING TO SAY IF I'M
04:04:30.422 --> 04:04:31.757
FOLLOWING THE SENATOR FROM
04:04:31.823 --> 04:04:33.625
BAKERSFIELD AND ASKING PEOPLE TO
04:04:33.692 --> 04:04:36.194
VOTE THE SAME WAY. THAT THERE'S
04:04:36.261 --> 04:04:37.396
SOMETHING I SHOULD BE SAYING
04:04:37.462 --> 04:04:38.997
ABOUT THAT. BUT I THOUGHT IT WAS
04:04:39.064 --> 04:04:43.702
IMPORTANT TO- NOT TO JUST STAND
04:04:43.769 --> 04:04:46.071
UP ON ONE OF THESE BILLS. BUT TO
04:04:46.138 --> 04:04:49.107
STAND UP ON BOTH A AND ONCE
04:04:49.174 --> 04:04:51.877
AGAIN. RATE AT THE ENTRANCE THAT
04:04:51.943 --> 04:04:53.912
HAVE ISSUES WITH THEM BOTH BUT
04:04:53.979 --> 04:04:55.480
THE CONVERSATION IS WHAT'S
04:04:55.547 --> 04:04:57.382
IMPORTANT HERE AND SO I JUST
04:04:57.449 --> 04:05:00.452
WANT TO RENEW MY COMMENTS AND
04:05:00.519 --> 04:05:02.054
ASK FOR NIGHT VOTE THANK YOU.
04:05:02.120 --> 04:05:03.488
BECAUSE THEY'RE LAYERED MEMBERS
04:05:03.555 --> 04:05:05.457
FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
04:05:05.524 --> 04:05:07.292
THING IN HER NONE SENATE CAREER
04:05:07.359 --> 04:05:09.795
YOU MAY CLOSE I THINK THANK YOU
04:05:09.861 --> 04:05:12.464
FOR ALL YOUR COMMENTS AND I
04:05:12.531 --> 04:05:13.498
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
04:05:13.565 --> 04:05:15.567
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER CABALLERO
04:05:15.634 --> 04:05:17.669
MADAM SECRETARY. ALLEN I
04:05:17.736 --> 04:05:23.108
ARCHULETA. AYE ATKINS. AYE BATES
04:05:23.175 --> 04:05:27.879
. I BAKER I FORTUS AYE BRADFORD
04:05:27.946 --> 04:05:32.517
I HAVE ITEM I FOR TESTING I DALY
04:05:32.584 --> 04:05:37.722
I DODD. I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
04:05:37.789 --> 04:05:43.361
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
04:05:43.428 --> 04:05:51.203
MARLBORO GROVE. HI HERTZBERG
04:05:51.269 --> 04:05:55.640
WESO HI FURTADO I JONES I
04:05:55.707 --> 04:06:00.579
KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA.
04:06:00.645 --> 04:06:06.151
I LIMON AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
04:06:06.218 --> 04:06:14.159
. MAN. NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. I A
04:06:14.226 --> 04:06:21.199
CHOI BOGUE I PAN. I PORTANTINO.
04:06:21.266 --> 04:06:26.438
I ROTH AYE RUBIO I SKINNER AYE
04:06:26.505 --> 04:06:30.308
STERN AYE NUMBER HI MY KELSEY
04:06:30.375 --> 04:06:36.047
AYE WIENER. WILK HI PLEASE CALL
04:06:36.114 --> 04:06:38.817
THE ABSENT MEMBERS HERTZBERG
04:06:38.884 --> 04:06:47.893
MELENDEZ I MAN I WIENER. NO I
04:06:47.959 --> 04:06:49.060
THIRTY EIGHT KNOWS ONE THE
04:06:49.127 --> 04:06:50.629
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE ARE
04:06:50.695 --> 04:06:52.764
MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM ONE
04:06:52.831 --> 04:06:55.133
TWENTY SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI
04:06:55.200 --> 04:06:57.502
MEN SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
04:06:57.569 --> 04:06:59.171
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN NINETY NINE
04:06:59.237 --> 04:07:01.306
BY SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI AN
04:07:01.373 --> 04:07:02.440
ACT RELATING TO GREENHOUSE
04:07:02.507 --> 04:07:04.576
GASES. CENTER BY CAL SKI SIMILAR
04:07:04.643 --> 04:07:06.444
PRESENT THIS IS A SIMPLE BILL ON
04:07:06.511 --> 04:07:10.382
CARBON CAPTURE- IT IS ENTITLED.
04:07:10.448 --> 04:07:12.551
THE CARBON CAPTURE TECHNOLOGY
04:07:12.617 --> 04:07:14.486
DEMONSTRATION PROJECT GRANT
04:07:14.553 --> 04:07:20.592
PROGRAM OF TWENTY TWENTY TWO AND
04:07:20.659 --> 04:07:21.126
WHAT WOULD DO IS IT WOULD
04:07:21.193 --> 04:07:21.893
CHARGE. CALIFORNIA THE
04:07:21.960 --> 04:07:22.961
COMMISSION. IN CARBON CAPTURE
04:07:23.028 --> 04:07:24.529
GRANT PROGRAMS THAT WOULD
04:07:24.596 --> 04:07:26.097
PARTIALLY FUND THE UP FRONT
04:07:26.164 --> 04:07:28.033
COSTS OF RETROFITTING PLANTS
04:07:28.099 --> 04:07:30.835
WITH CARBON CAPTURE SYSTEMS AND
04:07:30.902 --> 04:07:32.837
TO CREATE A TASK FORCE TO
04:07:32.904 --> 04:07:34.773
PROVIDE TECHNICAL AND POLICY.
04:07:34.839 --> 04:07:36.308
ASSISTANCE FACILITIES
04:07:36.374 --> 04:07:38.777
MANEUVERING THROUGH THE CARBON
04:07:38.843 --> 04:07:41.546
CAPTURE PERMITTING PROCESS WE'VE
04:07:41.613 --> 04:07:42.347
HEARD OF SOME OTHER. THAT WOULD
04:07:42.414 --> 04:07:44.849
PUT A FORTY IN THE AIR RESOURCES
04:07:44.916 --> 04:07:47.619
BOARD PART OF THE CITING UP
04:07:47.686 --> 04:07:49.487
NATURAL GAS FACILITIES BIOMASS
04:07:49.554 --> 04:07:51.990
FACILITIES IS WITH THE ENERGY
04:07:52.057 --> 04:07:53.959
COMMISSION SO THIS BILL AND
04:07:54.025 --> 04:07:56.695
DEBATE THOSE TWO. AGENCIES AS
04:07:56.761 --> 04:07:58.863
WELL AS CALCIUM AS WELL AS THE
04:07:58.930 --> 04:08:00.665
WATER BOARD WILL BE WORKING
04:08:00.732 --> 04:08:02.567
TOGETHER IT SEEKS TO COMBAT
04:08:02.634 --> 04:08:05.303
CLIMATE. CHANGE IN A JUST AND
04:08:05.370 --> 04:08:07.072
EQUITABLE MANNER- THAT ENSURES
04:08:07.138 --> 04:08:12.110
THE STATE INTO CONTINUE SERVICE
04:08:12.177 --> 04:08:15.180
TRANSITION TO GREEN ENERGY. BUT
04:08:15.247 --> 04:08:22.787
RICK.
04:08:22.854 --> 04:08:25.323
INTO HIGH QUALITY HERE GEOLOGIC
04:08:25.390 --> 04:08:26.625
RESERVOIRS WHICH MEANS THAT
04:08:26.691 --> 04:08:29.427
THERE IS NO. OIL IN HASSLE
04:08:29.494 --> 04:08:31.496
RECOVERY WITH THESE THREE
04:08:31.563 --> 04:08:33.732
PROJECTS THEY ONLY USE THE
04:08:33.798 --> 04:08:35.033
CARBON CAPPERS CAPTURE FOR
04:08:35.100 --> 04:08:37.502
PURPOSES THAT RESULT IN A NET
04:08:37.569 --> 04:08:39.170
REDUCTION OF GREENHOUSE GAS
04:08:39.237 --> 04:08:42.807
EMISSIONS AS OTHER MEMBERS HAVE
04:08:42.874 --> 04:08:45.243
SAID WE'VE GOT THE IPCC REPORT.
04:08:45.310 --> 04:08:47.746
BERKELEY CALIF UCLA LIVERMORE
04:08:47.812 --> 04:08:50.749
LABS THEY'VE ALL INDICATED IS.
04:08:50.815 --> 04:08:51.983
MANY OF MY COLLEAGUES HAVE
04:08:52.050 --> 04:08:54.286
STATED WE NEED TO GET IN THE
04:08:54.352 --> 04:08:56.354
HUNDRED AND TWENTY FIVE MILLION
04:08:56.421 --> 04:08:59.291
METRIC TON RANGE HERE RIGHT NOW
04:08:59.357 --> 04:09:01.893
I THINK WE'VE INDICATED THAT WE
04:09:01.960 --> 04:09:04.095
HAVE ABOUT SEVENTY EIGHT MILLION
04:09:04.162 --> 04:09:06.164
METRIC TONS OF WHEAT JENNIFER I
04:09:06.231 --> 04:09:09.501
DO. SO THE- PORTS GATHER SAY
04:09:09.567 --> 04:09:11.369
THAT WE HAVE MANY WAYS WE CAN
04:09:11.436 --> 04:09:16.141
CAPTURE CARBON THIS BILL HOPES
04:09:16.207 --> 04:09:18.310
TO GET THE BALL ROLLING INTO A
04:09:18.376 --> 04:09:20.211
THREE AND OUT DOUBLE TO ANSWER
04:09:20.278 --> 04:09:22.647
BUT BY REGION I'VE- THANK YOU
04:09:22.714 --> 04:09:24.149
CENTER WHITE SKI. MEMBERS ANY
04:09:24.215 --> 04:09:26.351
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
04:09:26.418 --> 04:09:28.119
HEARING THEM BETTER SECRETARY
04:09:28.186 --> 04:09:31.790
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
04:09:31.856 --> 04:09:36.194
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
04:09:36.261 --> 04:09:42.267
NO BACKER. I PORTIONS. BRADFORD
04:09:42.334 --> 04:09:45.136
AYE CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
04:09:45.203 --> 04:09:53.244
DALY. DODD I TORONTO. EGGMAN AYE
04:09:53.311 --> 04:09:59.284
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROW.
04:09:59.351 --> 04:10:07.225
HERTZBERG SO. HI FURTADO. JONES
04:10:07.292 --> 04:10:12.664
KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE
04:10:12.731 --> 04:10:18.870
THE MON. I MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ
04:10:18.937 --> 04:10:25.210
NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. A
04:10:25.276 --> 04:10:32.484
CHOI BOGUE NO PAN. PORTANTINO I
04:10:32.550 --> 04:10:36.388
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I
04:10:36.454 --> 04:10:42.494
STERN. AMBERG HI MY COUNTY AYE
04:10:42.560 --> 04:10:46.398
WIENER AYE WILK NOW. PLEASE CALL
04:10:46.464 --> 04:10:50.435
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. FOR JUST.
04:10:50.502 --> 04:10:57.776
DALLY I. YOU'RE AWESOME I GLAZER
04:10:57.842 --> 04:11:03.748
. GROVE I HERTZBERG FURTADO.
04:11:03.815 --> 04:11:13.491
JONES NO. NIELSEN PAN. PAN I
04:11:13.558 --> 04:11:18.696
STERN. FIVE TWENTY NINE WINDOWS
04:11:18.763 --> 04:11:24.769
FIVE BUT. PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
04:11:24.836 --> 04:11:26.738
MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME. FORTUS
04:11:26.805 --> 04:11:32.043
GLAZER HERTZBERG FURTADO NIELSEN
04:11:32.110 --> 04:11:38.349
I STERN. HIGHS THIRTY KNOWS FIVE
04:11:38.416 --> 04:11:40.485
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
04:11:40.552 --> 04:11:43.488
ARE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM FORTY
04:11:43.555 --> 04:11:45.290
FIVE SENATOR GONZALO'S MADAM
04:11:45.356 --> 04:11:47.459
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
04:11:47.525 --> 04:11:48.960
BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY THREE BY
04:11:49.027 --> 04:11:51.596
SENATOR GONZALEZ AN ACT RELATING
04:11:51.663 --> 04:11:52.163
TO PUBLIC RETIREMENT SYSTEMS
04:11:52.230 --> 04:11:54.999
SYSTEMS CENTER GONZALEZ THANK
04:11:55.066 --> 04:11:56.334
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS
04:11:56.401 --> 04:11:58.069
I RISE TODAY TO PRESENT SENATE
04:11:58.136 --> 04:11:59.838
BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY THREE WHICH
04:11:59.904 --> 04:12:01.539
WILL PROHIBIT THE CALIFORNIA
04:12:01.606 --> 04:12:02.106
PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT
04:12:02.173 --> 04:12:03.641
SYSTEM AND THE CALIFORNIA STATE
04:12:03.708 --> 04:12:05.710
TEACHERS RETIREMENT SYSTEM FROM
04:12:05.777 --> 04:12:07.612
CONTINUING TO INVEST IN THE TWO
04:12:07.679 --> 04:12:08.546
HUNDRED LARGEST FOSSIL FUEL
04:12:08.613 --> 04:12:09.881
COMPANIES NAMED THE CARBON
04:12:09.948 --> 04:12:12.750
UNDERGROUND TWO HUNDRED. SB
04:12:12.817 --> 04:12:13.418
ELEVEN SEVENTY THREE BUILDS UPON
04:12:13.485 --> 04:12:14.719
A GLOBAL DIVESTMENT MOVEMENT
04:12:14.786 --> 04:12:16.721
THAT INCLUDES THE UC SYSTEM
04:12:16.788 --> 04:12:17.956
WHICH I VESTED OVER A BILLION
04:12:18.022 --> 04:12:19.357
DOLLARS OF INVESTMENT IN FOSSIL
04:12:19.424 --> 04:12:21.559
FUELS AS WELL AS OUR CSU'S WHICH
04:12:21.626 --> 04:12:24.162
DIVESTED THEIR PORTFOLIO LEADER
04:12:24.229 --> 04:12:25.897
LAST YEAR AS YOU ALL MAY
04:12:25.964 --> 04:12:27.198
REMEMBER THE LEGISLATURE. FOR
04:12:27.265 --> 04:12:29.434
WITH DIRECTED. ENGINE SYSTEMS TO
04:12:29.501 --> 04:12:31.135
DIVEST FROM COAL COMPANIES AND
04:12:31.202 --> 04:12:33.238
THE COUNTRIES OF SUDAN AND IRAN
04:12:33.304 --> 04:12:34.272
AND THE PENSION BOARDS
04:12:34.339 --> 04:12:36.140
THEMSELVES HAVE INDEPENDENTLY
04:12:36.207 --> 04:12:37.976
CHOSEN TO DIVEST FROM TOBACCO.
04:12:38.042 --> 04:12:39.611
GUN MANUFACTURERS PRIVATE
04:12:39.677 --> 04:12:41.846
PRISONS AND SOUTH AFRICA THESE
04:12:41.913 --> 04:12:43.448
DIVESTMENTS HAVE RESULTED IN A
04:12:43.515 --> 04:12:46.117
POSITIVE FINANCIAL RETURN EXCEPT
04:12:46.184 --> 04:12:47.752
FOR THE TYPE TOBACCO PORTFOLIO
04:12:47.819 --> 04:12:49.654
AGAIN WHICH IS BOARD LEAD.
04:12:49.721 --> 04:12:50.755
ARTICLE SIXTEEN OF THE
04:12:50.822 --> 04:12:52.524
CALIFORNIA CONSTITUTION ****
04:12:52.590 --> 04:12:53.525
EXPLICITLY ALLOWS THE
04:12:53.591 --> 04:12:55.193
LEGISLATURE TO PROHIBIT
04:12:55.260 --> 04:12:56.327
INVESTMENTS BY CALPERS AND CAL
04:12:56.394 --> 04:12:57.962
STIRS. WHERE THERE IS PUBLIC
04:12:58.029 --> 04:12:59.964
INTEREST TO DO SO DESPITE THE
04:13:00.031 --> 04:13:01.599
CONSTITUTIONAL AUTHORITY I HAVE
04:13:01.666 --> 04:13:03.134
INCLUDED LANGUAGE IN THIS BILL
04:13:03.201 --> 04:13:04.435
THAT EMPOWERS BOTH PENSION
04:13:04.502 --> 04:13:05.970
BOARDS TO REFRAIN FROM
04:13:06.037 --> 04:13:07.205
IMPLEMENTING THIS BILL SHOULD
04:13:07.272 --> 04:13:09.040
THEY DETERMINE. IN GOOD FAITH
04:13:09.107 --> 04:13:10.174
THAT T WOULD IMPACT THEIR
04:13:10.241 --> 04:13:11.643
FIDUCIARY DUTIES UNDER THE
04:13:11.709 --> 04:13:14.012
CONSTITUTION. THIS IS ALSO AS
04:13:14.078 --> 04:13:15.046
SOMETHING THAT WAS ADDED AND
04:13:15.113 --> 04:13:17.248
SENATE LABOR AS WELL AS IN THE
04:13:17.315 --> 04:13:19.751
IS IN OUR CONSTITUTION AS WELL
04:13:19.817 --> 04:13:21.986
SO THIS IS ALL EXPLICIT AND
04:13:22.053 --> 04:13:23.454
VERY. IN VERY. FINALLY WE HAVE
04:13:23.521 --> 04:13:24.556
ALSO. AMENDMENTS AND SENATE
04:13:24.622 --> 04:13:26.157
LABOR AND JUDICIARY AND I WANT
04:13:26.224 --> 04:13:27.792
TO THANK MY COLLEAGUES FOR THEIR
04:13:27.859 --> 04:13:30.361
SUPPORT IN THAT. A TO PROVIDE A
04:13:30.428 --> 04:13:31.930
TO GO TO GIVE THE FUNDS EIGHT
04:13:31.996 --> 04:13:33.865
YEARS TO SCALE DOWN THAT
04:13:33.932 --> 04:13:35.366
INVESTMENTS AND ALLOW THEM TO
04:13:35.433 --> 04:13:36.968
POSSIBLE FOR AN ADDITIONAL FIVE
04:13:37.035 --> 04:13:39.103
YEARS. BEYOND THAT SHOULD AN
04:13:39.170 --> 04:13:40.371
UNFORESEEABLE EVENT CREATE
04:13:40.438 --> 04:13:42.240
CONDITIONS THAT IMPACT NORMAL
04:13:42.307 --> 04:13:44.375
MARKET NECK AND MECHANISMS I
04:13:44.442 --> 04:13:45.977
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
04:13:46.044 --> 04:13:48.880
ON SB ELEVEN SEVENTY THREE THANK
04:13:48.947 --> 04:13:50.181
YOU THANK YOU CENTER GONZALEZ
04:13:50.248 --> 04:13:52.250
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
04:13:52.317 --> 04:13:55.520
SENATOR NIELSEN. BETTER
04:13:55.587 --> 04:13:58.289
PRESIDENT LADIES ON THE SENATE.
04:13:58.356 --> 04:13:59.991
OVER THE MANY YEARS I'VE BEEN
04:14:00.058 --> 04:14:01.693
HERE THEY'VE BEEN COUNTLESS
04:14:01.759 --> 04:14:04.429
DIVESTITURE BILLS. THE VESTMENT
04:14:04.495 --> 04:14:06.097
BILLS IF YOU WILL. I VOTED FOR
04:14:06.164 --> 04:14:09.801
SOME MOST OF MY VOTED AGAINST
04:14:09.867 --> 04:14:11.970
BECAUSE I DON'T THINK IT'S GOOD
04:14:12.036 --> 04:14:15.173
POLICY. IT'S A STATEMENT MAYBE
04:14:15.239 --> 04:14:17.342
TO THESE MASSIVE GIGANTIC
04:14:17.408 --> 04:14:20.178
PENSION FUNDS. BUT IS IT ALWAYS
04:14:20.244 --> 04:14:21.512
TO THE ADVANTAGE OF THE
04:14:21.579 --> 04:14:26.484
PENSIONERS. NOT IT IS SOMETIMES
04:14:26.551 --> 04:14:28.319
IT'S COST THEM DEARLY AND GOT
04:14:28.386 --> 04:14:31.889
THEM IN TROUBLE. THIS PARTICULAR
04:14:31.956 --> 04:14:36.194
ONE. I GUESS I'M WORRYING A BIT
04:14:36.260 --> 04:14:40.164
. ABOUT THE- BARELA CONDEMNATION
04:14:40.231 --> 04:14:44.102
OF THE FOSSIL FUELS IN THE WORLD
04:14:44.168 --> 04:14:47.205
IN AMERICA IN CALIFORNIA. WE
04:14:47.271 --> 04:14:49.307
NEED TO LOOK BEYOND OUR NOSES TO
04:14:49.374 --> 04:14:51.943
THE FUTURE NOW MAYBE SOME THINK
04:14:52.010 --> 04:14:54.078
THAT THEY ARE LET'S GET RID OF
04:14:54.145 --> 04:14:56.881
FOSSIL FUELS FEMEN DC THINK
04:14:56.948 --> 04:14:58.516
THAT'S BEEN A GOOD IDEA. I DON'T
04:14:58.583 --> 04:15:02.754
THINK SO. IF WE DEPEND ON A ONLY
04:15:02.820 --> 04:15:04.455
IN WHICH IS A WORD FOR WIND OR
04:15:04.522 --> 04:15:07.325
SOLAR ENERGY. THE TAKE CARE OF
04:15:07.392 --> 04:15:10.461
OUR GRANDCHILDREN'S ENERGY NEEDS
04:15:10.528 --> 04:15:13.665
IN THE FUTURE. WE'RE CONDEMNING
04:15:13.731 --> 04:15:16.801
THEM TO A COMPROMISED FUTURE I
04:15:16.868 --> 04:15:19.804
TRULY BELIEVE THAT. FOSSIL FUELS
04:15:19.871 --> 04:15:22.040
HAVE HAD AND WILL HAVE AND
04:15:22.106 --> 04:15:23.908
CONTINUE AND SHOULD AVE THEIR
04:15:23.975 --> 04:15:27.045
PLACE IN OUR FUTURE. SO NOW THIS
04:15:27.111 --> 04:15:29.247
ATTACK. ON THE FOSSIL FUEL
04:15:29.313 --> 04:15:33.618
INDUSTRY DAY AFTER DAY. AND NOW
04:15:33.685 --> 04:15:35.920
WITH THE PENSIONS AS WELL. I DO
04:15:35.987 --> 04:15:38.723
NOT THINK IT'S IN THE DEFENSE
04:15:38.790 --> 04:15:39.791
LETTERS TO THE STATE OF
04:15:39.857 --> 04:15:42.527
CALIFORNIA. NOR THE PENSIONERS
04:15:42.593 --> 04:15:45.163
AND MORE PARTICULARLY OUR
04:15:45.229 --> 04:15:47.532
GRANDCHILDREN ORIGINAL THANK YOU
04:15:47.598 --> 04:15:50.468
SENATOR NELSON CENTER GLAZER.
04:15:50.535 --> 04:15:56.040
AREA. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT-
04:15:56.107 --> 04:15:59.043
AND MEMBERS- I'M TRYING TO
04:15:59.110 --> 04:16:01.312
SEPARATE THE ISSUE OF- THE A
04:16:01.379 --> 04:16:04.115
POLITICAL STATEMENT. VERSUS THE
04:16:04.182 --> 04:16:05.717
FIDUCIARY RESPONSIBILITIES OF
04:16:05.783 --> 04:16:08.086
PENSION SYSTEM AND THAT YOU KNOW
04:16:08.152 --> 04:16:09.921
WE TAKE POSITIONS ON THIS FLOOR
04:16:09.987 --> 04:16:11.723
WHERE WE HAVE A PHILOSOPHICAL
04:16:11.789 --> 04:16:14.125
VIEW ONE THING OR ANOTHER- BUT
04:16:14.192 --> 04:16:15.626
IT'S QUITE DIFFERENT IF YOU HAVE
04:16:15.693 --> 04:16:17.695
THAT THAT RESPONSIBILITY- AS
04:16:17.762 --> 04:16:19.497
MENTIONED BY THE AUTHOR. YOU
04:16:19.564 --> 04:16:22.600
KNOW WE TOOK ACTION THE BILL- IF
04:16:22.667 --> 04:16:23.167
YOU WEEKS AGO ABOUT RUSSIAN
04:16:23.234 --> 04:16:25.837
ASSETS- BUT INCLUDED IN THAT
04:16:25.903 --> 04:16:27.705
BILL. WAS OF A SIMILAR PROVISION
04:16:27.772 --> 04:16:29.774
IS INCLUDED IN THIS BILL. THAT
04:16:29.841 --> 04:16:30.875
SAYS THAT YOU STILL HAVE A
04:16:30.942 --> 04:16:32.643
RESPONSIBILITY AS A FIDUCIARY IF
04:16:32.710 --> 04:16:33.711
YOU'RE ON THESE PENSION BOARDS
04:16:33.778 --> 04:16:35.513
TO MAKE THE BEST JUDGMENT THAT
04:16:35.580 --> 04:16:39.083
YOU CAN MAKE IN THE INTEREST OF.
04:16:39.150 --> 04:16:40.084
THE PENSIONERS THAT YOU'RE
04:16:40.151 --> 04:16:42.186
RESPONSIBLE FOR. AND SO MY
04:16:42.253 --> 04:16:43.020
QUESTION TO THE AUTHOR WOULD BE
04:16:43.087 --> 04:16:44.956
THAT. RIGHT NOW SHE'S NOT A
04:16:45.022 --> 04:16:46.724
SENATOR ANYMORE A DISTINGUISHED
04:16:46.791 --> 04:16:48.526
SENATOR COURSE CERTAINLY ONE-
04:16:48.593 --> 04:16:49.827
BUT NOW YOU'RE ON THIS PENSION
04:16:49.894 --> 04:16:51.729
BOARD AND YOUR BILL HAS PASSED
04:16:51.796 --> 04:16:54.031
WE PASS THIS BILL IT'S BEEN
04:16:54.098 --> 04:16:55.466
SIGNED INTO LAW. WHAT'S THE
04:16:55.533 --> 04:16:56.300
PROCESS THAT YOU WOULD GO
04:16:56.367 --> 04:16:58.503
THROUGH- AS A MEMBER OF THE
04:16:58.569 --> 04:16:59.370
PENSION BOARD TO DETERMINE
04:16:59.437 --> 04:17:01.005
WHETHER OR NOT. ACTING AS A
04:17:01.072 --> 04:17:03.074
FIDUCIARY YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO
04:17:03.141 --> 04:17:04.408
THE BILL THAT. YOU'RE CURRENTLY
04:17:04.475 --> 04:17:06.978
AUTHORIZED. CENTER GLAZER THAT A
04:17:07.044 --> 04:17:08.746
QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR IT WAS.
04:17:08.813 --> 04:17:10.381
WE TAKE A QUESTION SENATOR
04:17:10.448 --> 04:17:11.649
GONZALEZ ABSOLUTELY PLEASE
04:17:11.716 --> 04:17:13.017
PROCEED THANK YOU MADAM
04:17:13.084 --> 04:17:14.085
PRESIDENT I WANT TO THANK MY
04:17:14.152 --> 04:17:16.187
COLLEAGUE- FROM CONTRA COSTA
04:17:16.254 --> 04:17:18.089
ORINDA. FOR BRINGING THAT
04:17:18.156 --> 04:17:19.590
FORWARD AND YES AS MENTIONED IN
04:17:19.657 --> 04:17:21.793
MY OPENING STATEMENT IT IS
04:17:21.859 --> 04:17:23.561
INCLUDED IN THE BILL SECTION F.
04:17:23.628 --> 04:17:25.096
NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL
04:17:25.163 --> 04:17:26.931
REQUIRE A BOARD TO TAKE ACTION
04:17:26.998 --> 04:17:28.366
AS DESCRIBED IN THE SECTION
04:17:28.432 --> 04:17:30.001
UNLESS THE BOARD DETERMINES IN
04:17:30.067 --> 04:17:32.637
GOOD FAITH. THAT THE ACTION
04:17:32.703 --> 04:17:33.237
DESCRIBED IN THIS SECTION IS
04:17:33.304 --> 04:17:35.373
CONSISTENT WITH. JERRY RESPONSE.
04:17:35.439 --> 04:17:37.475
THE BOARD AS DESCRIBED IN THE
04:17:37.542 --> 04:17:40.511
CONSTITUTION SO- AND ON TOP OF
04:17:40.578 --> 04:17:42.046
THAT AS MENTIONED AS WELL IF
04:17:42.113 --> 04:17:42.914
THERE ARE UNFORESEEABLE
04:17:42.980 --> 04:17:44.482
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT SHOULD SAY
04:17:44.549 --> 04:17:46.851
THAT AFTER THE EIGHT YEARS. OR
04:17:46.918 --> 04:17:49.387
AT A POINTS NEXT YEAR WORDS JUST
04:17:49.453 --> 04:17:51.022
AN ANOMALY AND WE HAVE YOU KNOW
04:17:51.088 --> 04:17:52.590
SOME ISSUES THEN THERE'S AN
04:17:52.657 --> 04:17:53.991
EXTENSION OF FIVE YEARS THE ON
04:17:54.058 --> 04:17:55.026
THE EIGHT YEARS THAT WOULD BE
04:17:55.092 --> 04:17:56.527
GIVEN FOR UNFORESEEABLE
04:17:56.594 --> 04:17:57.795
CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH WAS TAKEN
04:17:57.862 --> 04:18:00.131
AND- SENATE LABOR- SENATOR
04:18:00.198 --> 04:18:02.266
GLAZERS. WELL I THINK THE AUTHOR
04:18:02.333 --> 04:18:02.934
FROM LONG BEACH FOR HER
04:18:03.000 --> 04:18:05.703
THOUGHTFULNESS AND HER RESPONSE.
04:18:05.770 --> 04:18:07.104
BECAUSE I GUESS WHAT IT LEAVES
04:18:07.171 --> 04:18:09.173
ME WITH THIS IS THIS IS A- IS A
04:18:09.240 --> 04:18:10.374
POLITICAL STATEMENT THE
04:18:10.441 --> 04:18:12.577
STATEMENT OF. IS WHAT I LIKE TO
04:18:12.643 --> 04:18:14.579
SEE US REDUCE OUR RELIANCE UPON.
04:18:14.645 --> 04:18:17.915
FOSSIL FUELS YES. WHAT I LIKE TO
04:18:17.982 --> 04:18:20.251
AS WE HAVE IS THE SENATE AND AS
04:18:20.318 --> 04:18:21.385
A LEGISLATURE PROMOTED
04:18:21.452 --> 04:18:23.321
ALTERNATIVE ENERGIES OF COURSE.
04:18:23.387 --> 04:18:25.623
BECAUSE THE FUELS THAT WE'RE
04:18:25.690 --> 04:18:26.357
CONCERNED ABOUT ARE GOING TO GO
04:18:26.424 --> 04:18:28.192
AWAY TOMORROW. AND HEART OUR
04:18:28.259 --> 04:18:30.528
SYSTEM RELIES UPON THEM. ON A
04:18:30.595 --> 04:18:32.496
GIVEN THE CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WE
04:18:32.563 --> 04:18:37.668
FIND OURSELVES IN. SO I A- I
04:18:37.735 --> 04:18:38.803
SAID IN MY- IT'S A GOAL IN THIS
04:18:38.870 --> 04:18:41.839
BILL IS THAT- A VALUE IN A GOAL
04:18:41.906 --> 04:18:43.908
OKAY. BUT I DO KNOW THAT IF I
04:18:43.975 --> 04:18:45.409
WAS A TO DO SHERRY. THAT IT
04:18:45.476 --> 04:18:47.678
WOULDN'T BE A REQUIREMENT THAT
04:18:47.745 --> 04:18:50.982
WOULD- OBSCURE MY DECISION ABOUT
04:18:51.048 --> 04:18:52.783
ADVANCING THE THAT THE PURPOSES
04:18:52.850 --> 04:18:54.952
OF OUR RETIREMENT SYSTEMS. AND
04:18:55.019 --> 04:18:57.121
SO WITH THAT I'M GOING TO
04:18:57.188 --> 04:18:59.056
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY. THANK
04:18:59.123 --> 04:19:00.491
YOU SENATOR GLAZERS US SENATOR
04:19:00.558 --> 04:19:08.099
WIENER. I THANK YOU MADAM
04:19:08.165 --> 04:19:10.001
PRESIDENT ARISES- PROUD I JOIN
04:19:10.067 --> 04:19:12.637
AUTHOR OF ESTIMATES AMID THREE
04:19:12.703 --> 04:19:14.038
ON ONE OF THANKED THE CENTRE
04:19:14.105 --> 04:19:15.539
FROM LONG BEACH FOR LEADING ON
04:19:15.606 --> 04:19:18.109
THIS ISSUE IT'S NOT BEEN AN EASY
04:19:18.175 --> 04:19:21.479
RIDE- I THIS THIS BILL MAKES ALL
04:19:21.545 --> 04:19:22.980
THE SENSE IN THE WORLD RIGHT IN
04:19:23.047 --> 04:19:25.182
THE CENTER FROM AROUND- THIS IS
04:19:25.249 --> 04:19:26.250
REALLY SUMMED UP AS IT THE
04:19:26.317 --> 04:19:28.853
AUTHOR- BUT THIS IS NOT ANYWHERE
04:19:28.920 --> 04:19:30.888
WILL NINE ANYWAY BECAUSE-
04:19:30.955 --> 04:19:32.556
CALPERS OR TELL STORIES TO
04:19:32.623 --> 04:19:34.859
VIOLATE THEIR FIDUCIARY. DUTIES
04:19:34.926 --> 04:19:36.494
THEY HAVE FLEXIBILITY IN
04:19:36.560 --> 04:19:38.596
ADDITION THE FACT THIS IS A
04:19:38.663 --> 04:19:41.732
PRETTY SMALL- PORTION OF THE
04:19:41.799 --> 04:19:44.669
INVESTMENT OF FUNDS ARE BY DO
04:19:44.735 --> 04:19:46.637
YOU JUST WANT TO SAY IN TERMS
04:19:46.704 --> 04:19:49.206
OF- OUR COLLEAGUE FROM- TO HIM-
04:19:49.273 --> 04:19:53.544
TALKED ABOUT- OUR FUTURE. THE
04:19:53.611 --> 04:19:55.246
PROGRAMME CARE. I THINK THAT IT
04:19:55.313 --> 04:19:58.182
. IS A LOT REALLY THIS IS ABOUT-
04:19:58.249 --> 04:20:00.818
AND IN TERMS OF THEIR FUTURE.
04:20:00.885 --> 04:20:02.486
WHEN WE LOOK AT WHAT'S HAPPENING
04:20:02.553 --> 04:20:04.855
ON THE PLANET NOW. AND HOW IT'S
04:20:04.922 --> 04:20:07.525
GETTING WORSE IT'S NOT NORMAL OR
04:20:07.591 --> 04:20:09.827
JUST RANDOM. THE CALIFORNIA HAS
04:20:09.894 --> 04:20:11.395
BEEN EXPERIENCING LITERALLY THE
04:20:11.462 --> 04:20:14.231
WORST WILDFIRES AND IN OUR
04:20:14.298 --> 04:20:16.500
HISTORY. IT SAYS THE LAST FEW
04:20:16.567 --> 04:20:17.802
YEARS AND THAT THE WILDFIRE
04:20:17.868 --> 04:20:19.337
SEASON BECAUSE I ALMOST YEAR
04:20:19.403 --> 04:20:21.472
ROUND NOW THAT WE ACTUALLY HAVE
04:20:21.539 --> 04:20:24.041
CONCERNED ABOUT WILDFIRES. IN
04:20:24.108 --> 04:20:26.077
THE MIDDLE OF THE WINTER. THAT'S
04:20:26.143 --> 04:20:29.313
NOT NORMAL. MY LOOK AT THE SEA
04:20:29.380 --> 04:20:30.514
LEVEL RISE I THE FACT AND SAN
04:20:30.581 --> 04:20:33.351
FRANCISCO MUNY BART TUNNELS. ARE
04:20:33.417 --> 04:20:35.286
GONNA GET FLOODED I'M GONNA
04:20:35.353 --> 04:20:37.121
SPEND BILLIONS OF DOLLARS TO
04:20:37.188 --> 04:20:39.256
SHORE UP THE SEA WALL. SO THAT
04:20:39.323 --> 04:20:40.257
OUR PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
04:20:40.324 --> 04:20:42.693
SYSTEMS ARE FLOODED OR HIGHWAY
04:20:42.760 --> 04:20:44.028
THIRTY SEVEN WE GO ON AND ON
04:20:44.095 --> 04:20:45.262
AROUND THE WORLD THE LEVEL OF
04:20:45.329 --> 04:20:47.131
FOOD INSECURITY THE DROUGHT THE
04:20:47.198 --> 04:20:49.433
FIRES THE FLOODING THAT'S NOT
04:20:49.500 --> 04:20:51.502
NORMAL. IT'S BECAUSE WE ARE
04:20:51.569 --> 04:20:53.771
ADDICTED TO FOSSIL FUEL AND IT'S
04:20:53.838 --> 04:20:56.007
DESTROYING THE PLANET. BUT IT'S
04:20:56.073 --> 04:20:57.908
NOT TOO LATE FOR US TO TURN
04:20:57.975 --> 04:20:59.710
AROUND AND IF WE ONE OF. IF WE
04:20:59.777 --> 04:21:01.178
WANT TO BE A FUTURE FOR OUR KIDS
04:21:01.245 --> 04:21:02.947
AND GRANDKIDS WITH OKAY I
04:21:03.014 --> 04:21:04.148
BELIEVE THAT EVERY SINGLE ONE OF
04:21:04.215 --> 04:21:06.350
US DIES. DOWN POSSIBLY WAS
04:21:06.417 --> 04:21:08.486
CANNOT BE PART OF OUR FUTURE WE
04:21:08.552 --> 04:21:10.054
HAVE TO MOVE AGGRESSIVELY AWAY
04:21:10.121 --> 04:21:12.223
FROM THEM THIS BILL IS NOT YOU
04:21:12.289 --> 04:21:13.124
KNOW IT'S GONNA BE A SILVER
04:21:13.190 --> 04:21:14.992
BULLET. BUT IT IS A STRONG
04:21:15.059 --> 04:21:17.795
STATEMENT BY CALIFORNIA THAT WE
04:21:17.862 --> 04:21:21.766
ARE NOT GOING TO BE A PARTY TO
04:21:21.832 --> 04:21:22.767
THIS CONTINUED DESTRUCTION OF
04:21:22.833 --> 04:21:23.434
THE PLANET. THANK YOU CENTER
04:21:23.501 --> 04:21:25.202
WIENER MEMBERS FURTHER
04:21:25.269 --> 04:21:27.838
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
04:21:27.905 --> 04:21:29.306
HEARING MANSON- GONZALEZ YOU MAY
04:21:29.373 --> 04:21:31.142
CLOSE THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
04:21:31.208 --> 04:21:32.777
WHEN I THINK MY COLLEAGUES FOR
04:21:32.843 --> 04:21:34.512
THEIR WORDS- I ALSO WOULD LIKE
04:21:34.578 --> 04:21:36.714
TO THANK THE MANY OVER TWO
04:21:36.781 --> 04:21:37.515
HUNDRED THOUSAND BENEFICIARIES
04:21:37.581 --> 04:21:38.649
MANY OF WHICH ARE FACULTY
04:21:38.716 --> 04:21:41.085
MEMBERS TEACHERS AND MANY OF THE
04:21:41.152 --> 04:21:43.120
YOUTH THAT CAME FOR TO BRING
04:21:43.187 --> 04:21:44.789
THIS THIS- PIECE OF LEGISLATION
04:21:44.855 --> 04:21:46.290
FORWARD AND PUT. PLACE WHERE WE
04:21:46.357 --> 04:21:48.259
ARE MAKE STATEMENT WITH OUR
04:21:48.325 --> 04:21:49.360
DOLLARS MORE IMPORTANTLY WE'RE
04:21:49.427 --> 04:21:51.762
DOING SO IN A WAY I BELIEVE THAT
04:21:51.829 --> 04:21:53.664
IS- CLIMATE SAFE AND RESPONSIBLE
04:21:53.731 --> 04:21:54.398
SO WITHOUT AYE AYE URGENT AYE
04:21:54.465 --> 04:21:57.601
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER GONZALEZ
04:21:57.668 --> 04:21:58.669
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
04:21:58.736 --> 04:22:03.240
ROLL. ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA. AYE
04:22:03.307 --> 04:22:07.545
ATKINS. AYE BATES NO BAKER I
04:22:07.611 --> 04:22:13.918
PORCHES. BRADFORD. CABALLERO AYE
04:22:13.984 --> 04:22:19.123
CORTESE AYE DALY NO DODD.
04:22:19.190 --> 04:22:24.061
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
04:22:24.128 --> 04:22:28.699
GONZALEZ FIVE GROVE. NO
04:22:28.766 --> 04:22:35.139
HERTZBERG WEST SO. HI FURTADO.
04:22:35.206 --> 04:22:39.376
HUESO I DON'T KNOW. HER TADO.
04:22:39.443 --> 04:22:43.681
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
04:22:43.747 --> 04:22:49.854
LEYVA. LIMON AYE MCGUIRE AYE
04:22:49.920 --> 04:22:53.390
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN.
04:22:53.457 --> 04:22:59.163
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED NO HAN.
04:22:59.230 --> 04:23:06.370
PORTANTINO I ROTH. RUBIO.
04:23:06.437 --> 04:23:09.907
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG AYE
04:23:09.974 --> 04:23:15.913
WHITE HOUSE E. WIENER AYE WILK
04:23:15.980 --> 04:23:17.047
NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
04:23:17.114 --> 04:23:31.228
MEMBERS. GORGEOUS BRADFORD. DODD. HERTZBERG FURTADO NO. LEYVA
04:23:31.295 --> 04:23:38.402
NEWMAN. PAM ROTH RUBIO WHITE
04:23:38.469 --> 04:23:43.407
HOUSE SKI. SEN REMOVES THE CALL
04:23:43.474 --> 04:23:45.709
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
04:23:45.776 --> 04:23:48.779
ITEM EIGHTY THREE SENATOR DORADO
04:23:48.846 --> 04:23:50.948
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
04:23:51.015 --> 04:23:52.950
SENATE BILL TEN FORTY FOUR BY
04:23:53.017 --> 04:23:54.718
SENATOR ALSO AN ACT RELATING TO
04:23:54.785 --> 04:23:56.854
EMPLOYMENT CENTER DORADO THANK
04:23:56.921 --> 04:23:59.523
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SB TEN FORTY
04:23:59.590 --> 04:24:01.625
FOUR IS A BILL THAT WILL ALLOW
04:24:01.692 --> 04:24:02.993
WORKERS TO HAVE ACCESS TO THE
04:24:03.060 --> 04:24:04.261
MOBILE PHONES OR OTHER
04:24:04.328 --> 04:24:06.397
COMMUNICATION DEVICES AND BE
04:24:06.463 --> 04:24:08.032
ALLOWED TO LEAVE THE WORKPLACE
04:24:08.098 --> 04:24:09.967
FOR THEIR SAFETY. IN THE STATE
04:24:10.034 --> 04:24:11.468
OF EMERGENCY OR EMERGENCY
04:24:11.535 --> 04:24:13.571
CONDITION WITH CERTAIN
04:24:13.637 --> 04:24:16.006
EXEMPTIONS WORKER SAFETY IS A
04:24:16.073 --> 04:24:18.309
BASIC PROTECTION AFFORDED TO ALL
04:24:18.375 --> 04:24:20.211
CALIFORNIANS UNFORTUNATELY THERE
04:24:20.277 --> 04:24:22.246
BEEN CASES OF WORKERS REQUIRED
04:24:22.313 --> 04:24:24.448
TO CONTINUE TO WORK DESPITE THE
04:24:24.515 --> 04:24:26.584
IMMINENT THREAT OF A SEVERE
04:24:26.650 --> 04:24:29.053
EMERGENCY THAT HAS INCLUDED
04:24:29.119 --> 04:24:31.155
WORKERS EXPECTED TO WORK IN THE
04:24:31.222 --> 04:24:32.756
FACE OF NATURAL DESIRES
04:24:32.823 --> 04:24:35.726
DISASTERS. SUCH AS WILDFIRES AND
04:24:35.793 --> 04:24:38.362
MUDSLIDES ALSO MAN MADE
04:24:38.429 --> 04:24:41.632
EMERGENCY SITUATIONS INCLUDING
04:24:41.699 --> 04:24:43.634
MASS SHOOTINGS AND TERROR EVENTS
04:24:43.701 --> 04:24:45.169
THE CALIFORNIA NEW NORMAL
04:24:45.236 --> 04:24:46.937
WILDFIRE SEASON HAS BECOME A
04:24:47.004 --> 04:24:49.106
YEARLONG THREAT WITH NINE OF
04:24:49.173 --> 04:24:51.108
THE LARGEST AND SEVEN OF THE
04:24:51.175 --> 04:24:54.411
MOST DESTRUCTIVE FIRES IN STATE
04:24:54.478 --> 04:24:56.747
HISTORY. I CONTINUE TO PICK
04:24:56.814 --> 04:24:58.949
PRODUCE FIRES JUST A FEW MILES
04:24:59.016 --> 04:25:00.784
FROM THE FIRE LINES INTO OUR
04:25:00.851 --> 04:25:03.587
COMMUNITIES IN THE REGION. IN
04:25:03.654 --> 04:25:05.923
THE REGION WERE IN DANGER.
04:25:05.990 --> 04:25:07.858
DOMESTIC WORKERS LANDSCAPERS
04:25:07.925 --> 04:25:09.560
WERE REQUIRED TO REPORT TO WORK
04:25:09.627 --> 04:25:11.729
IN THE BACK YOU WAITED HILL
04:25:11.795 --> 04:25:13.597
PROPERTIES AS THE THREAT OF THE
04:25:13.664 --> 04:25:15.199
FIRE LOOMED AROUND THEM. TELLING
04:25:15.266 --> 04:25:16.700
EMERGENCY PERSONNEL THAT THEY
04:25:16.767 --> 04:25:18.435
COULD NOT LEAVE THE WORKPLACE
04:25:18.502 --> 04:25:20.304
UNTIL THEIR JOB WAS FINISHED.
04:25:20.371 --> 04:25:22.139
SIMILAR INCIDENTS HAVE OCCURRED
04:25:22.206 --> 04:25:24.275
IN AMAZON WAREHOUSES WITH THEIR
04:25:24.341 --> 04:25:26.610
FORCED TO WORK DESPITE THREATS A
04:25:26.677 --> 04:25:30.447
BUILDING FIRES. ONE EXAMPLE
04:25:30.514 --> 04:25:32.116
ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS THE PUSH FOR
04:25:32.182 --> 04:25:34.251
WORKERS TO CONTINUE IN THE MIDST
04:25:34.318 --> 04:25:36.420
OF AN ACTIVE SHOOTING. THESE
04:25:36.487 --> 04:25:38.589
INCIDENTS MAKE IT CLEAR THAT WE
04:25:38.656 --> 04:25:41.659
NEED A NEW SET A NEW CLEAR
04:25:41.725 --> 04:25:44.361
STANDARDS TO KEEP WORKERS SAFE
04:25:44.428 --> 04:25:47.865
IN REAL TIME IN REAL TIME DURING
04:25:47.931 --> 04:25:50.034
THESE EVENTS TEN FORTY FOUR
04:25:50.100 --> 04:25:51.902
PROVIDES CLEAR REQUIREMENTS FOR
04:25:51.969 --> 04:25:53.671
EMPLOYERS TO ALLOW WORKERS TO
04:25:53.737 --> 04:25:55.739
ACCESS TO PHONES. AND OTHER
04:25:55.806 --> 04:25:57.941
METHODS OF COMMUNICATIONS AS
04:25:58.008 --> 04:25:59.910
WELL AS WORKERS BEING PERMITTED
04:25:59.977 --> 04:26:01.979
TO LEAVE IF THEY MUST DO SO FOR
04:26:02.046 --> 04:26:04.348
THEIR SAFETY OR THAT OF THEIR
04:26:04.415 --> 04:26:06.517
CHILDREN. COMMITTED TO MAKING
04:26:06.583 --> 04:26:08.052
THIS AN EFFECTIVE AND JUST
04:26:08.118 --> 04:26:09.920
POLICY I HAVE BEEN ENGAGED
04:26:09.987 --> 04:26:12.489
EXTENSIVELY WITH SPONSORS AND
04:26:12.556 --> 04:26:14.591
OPPOSITION AND THEY'VE TAKEN
04:26:14.658 --> 04:26:17.127
SEVERAL AMENDMENTS TO ACCOUNT
04:26:17.194 --> 04:26:19.330
FOR LEGITIMATE CONCERNS.
04:26:19.396 --> 04:26:21.231
EXEMPTIONS FROM THE RIGHT TO
04:26:21.298 --> 04:26:23.067
LEAVE THE WORKPLACE INCLUDE
04:26:23.133 --> 04:26:25.269
FIRST RESPONDERS PUBLIC SECTOR
04:26:25.336 --> 04:26:27.338
WORKERS DEEMED DISASTER SERVICES
04:26:27.404 --> 04:26:29.206
WORKERS HEALTHCARE WORKERS
04:26:29.273 --> 04:26:31.241
EXPECTED TO ASSIST IN
04:26:31.308 --> 04:26:33.377
EMERGENCIES AND ALL WORKERS
04:26:33.444 --> 04:26:35.612
REQUIRED BY LAW TO REMAIN ON THE
04:26:35.679 --> 04:26:37.881
PREMISES OR RENDER AID. WE'VE
04:26:37.948 --> 04:26:39.883
NARROWED THE SCOPE OF THE BILL
04:26:39.950 --> 04:26:42.052
AS ONE OF THE MANY REQUESTS MADE
04:26:42.119 --> 04:26:43.587
BY THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
04:26:43.654 --> 04:26:45.089
SPECIFYING THAT THIS BILL DOES
04:26:45.155 --> 04:26:47.091
NOT APPLY TO HEALTH CARE
04:26:47.157 --> 04:26:50.260
EMERGENCIES. INCORPORATING A
04:26:50.327 --> 04:26:52.996
REASONABLE PERSON STANDARD AND
04:26:53.063 --> 04:26:54.531
REQUIRING THE NOTICE TO
04:26:54.598 --> 04:26:57.668
EMPLOYERS AS IS POSSIBLE. AND
04:26:57.735 --> 04:26:59.436
FINALLY PROVIDE EMPLOYERS ARE
04:26:59.503 --> 04:27:02.439
RIGHT TO CURE THE VIOLATION. AS
04:27:02.506 --> 04:27:03.974
A RESULT OF ADOPTING THESE
04:27:04.041 --> 04:27:04.908
AMENDMENTS SEVERAL OF
04:27:04.975 --> 04:27:06.643
ORGANIZATIONS HAVE GONE NEUTRAL
04:27:06.710 --> 04:27:08.712
ON THE LEGISLATION THE
04:27:08.779 --> 04:27:10.681
CALIFORNIA HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION
04:27:10.748 --> 04:27:12.950
CALIFORNIA FIRE CHIEFS AND THE
04:27:13.016 --> 04:27:14.785
FIRE DISTRICTS ASSOCIATION.
04:27:14.852 --> 04:27:15.986
ALTHOUGH THERE WAS NOT AN
04:27:16.053 --> 04:27:18.155
OFFICIAL POSITION AMENDMENTS
04:27:18.222 --> 04:27:20.391
ALSO ADDRESSED CONCERNS RAISED
04:27:20.457 --> 04:27:23.527
FROM SCHOOL EMPLOYERS. I ALSO
04:27:23.594 --> 04:27:27.131
WANT TO RAISE OTHER ISSUES-
04:27:27.197 --> 04:27:29.600
WE'VE INCLUDED A BROAD EXEMPTION
04:27:29.666 --> 04:27:31.602
COVERING PUBLIC SECTOR AND
04:27:31.668 --> 04:27:33.937
WORKERS REQUIRED BY LAW TO
04:27:34.004 --> 04:27:39.309
ASSIST IN EMERGENCIES- THE ALL-
04:27:39.376 --> 04:27:41.478
THERE ARE SOME CLAIMS THAT ALL
04:27:41.545 --> 04:27:43.113
LAWS RELATING TO HEALTH AND
04:27:43.180 --> 04:27:45.015
SAFETY OR IN THE CARILLO CHAU
04:27:45.082 --> 04:27:46.683
SECTION OF THE LABOR CODE NOT
04:27:46.750 --> 04:27:49.086
SUBJECT TO PAPA WELL WE'RE NOT
04:27:49.153 --> 04:27:50.521
WILLING TO MAKE THIS BILL
04:27:50.587 --> 04:27:53.390
UNENFORCEABLE THERE IS A RIGHT
04:27:53.457 --> 04:27:55.225
AND AN OPPORTUNITY TO CURE THE
04:27:55.292 --> 04:27:58.095
VIOLATION. SB TEN FORTY FOUR
04:27:58.162 --> 04:28:00.130
DOES NOT REQUIRE EMPLOYERS TO
04:28:00.197 --> 04:28:02.266
SEND WORKERS HOME OR HALT THEIR
04:28:02.332 --> 04:28:04.701
BUSINESS OPERATIONS IT DOES NOT
04:28:04.768 --> 04:28:06.603
CONFLICT WITH DUPLICATE OR
04:28:06.670 --> 04:28:08.572
OVERRIDE IN THE XISTING
04:28:08.639 --> 04:28:11.008
REGULATIONS THIS SIMPLY IS A
04:28:11.074 --> 04:28:13.777
BILL THAT SAYS PEOPLE WORKER
04:28:13.844 --> 04:28:16.413
LEAVES THEIR JOB DURING ON THE
04:28:16.480 --> 04:28:18.215
MERGING SEA OR A NATURAL
04:28:18.282 --> 04:28:20.517
DISASTER BASED ON A REASONABLE
04:28:20.584 --> 04:28:22.953
BELIEF OF DANGER OF DEATH OR
04:28:23.020 --> 04:28:25.422
SERIOUS INJURY IF THEY REMAIN ON
04:28:25.489 --> 04:28:29.326
THE PREMISES THE WORKER SHOULD
04:28:29.393 --> 04:28:30.594
NOT BE FIRED OR DISCIPLINED. WE
04:28:30.661 --> 04:28:32.329
ALSO REQUIRE THAT WORKERS HAVE
04:28:32.396 --> 04:28:33.897
ACCESS TO PHONES DURING
04:28:33.964 --> 04:28:36.667
EMERGENCIES. COLLEAGUES WE HAVE
04:28:36.733 --> 04:28:38.635
CONTINUED TO WITNESS DEVASTATING
04:28:38.702 --> 04:28:40.838
IMPACTS THAT EMERGENCIES AND
04:28:40.904 --> 04:28:43.073
NATURAL DISASTERS CONTINUE TO
04:28:43.140 --> 04:28:44.942
HAVE ON OUR COMMUNITIES
04:28:45.008 --> 04:28:47.344
ESPECIALLY OUR MOST VULNERABLE
04:28:47.411 --> 04:28:50.347
WORKERS. WE HAVE TO PROVIDE A
04:28:50.414 --> 04:28:55.152
WAY TO. RESPOND IN A MINIMAL AN
04:28:55.219 --> 04:28:57.488
ESSENTIAL REAL TIME. CLEAR
04:28:57.554 --> 04:29:00.190
PROTECTIONS CLEAR RULES FOR BOTH
04:29:00.257 --> 04:29:02.326
WORKERS AND EMPLOYERS BUT THE
04:29:02.392 --> 04:29:04.127
OPPORTUNITY KEEP THEIR
04:29:04.194 --> 04:29:04.962
THEMSELVES AND THEIR FAMILY
04:29:05.028 --> 04:29:08.665
SAFE. AND FINALLY WE HAVE AGREED
04:29:08.732 --> 04:29:11.068
TO INCLUDE UNMANNED MEANT THAT
04:29:11.134 --> 04:29:13.136
WOULD COVER AN EXAM TO EMPLOYEES
04:29:13.203 --> 04:29:15.906
OF NURSING HOMES AND CERTAIN
04:29:15.973 --> 04:29:17.975
PRIVATE FIREFIGHTERS. COLLEAGUES
04:29:18.041 --> 04:29:20.777
ASK FOR YOUR I. BOATS. THANK YOU
04:29:20.844 --> 04:29:22.613
CENTER DRAWS A SENATOR MEN.
04:29:22.679 --> 04:29:24.414
THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT I WANT TO
04:29:24.481 --> 04:29:25.682
APPLAUD MY COLLEAGUES FROM LOS
04:29:25.749 --> 04:29:27.451
ANGELES ARE PROPOSING THIS BILL
04:29:27.518 --> 04:29:28.519
EIGHT I THINK IT'S AN IMPORTANT
04:29:28.585 --> 04:29:30.053
GOAL HERE TO MAKE SURE THAT
04:29:30.120 --> 04:29:32.055
WORKERS ARE SAFE. I DID HAVE
04:29:32.122 --> 04:29:33.657
SOME CONCERNS ON THIS BILL CAME
04:29:33.724 --> 04:29:35.092
UP AND UNITE TALK ABOUT THEM BUT
04:29:35.158 --> 04:29:37.794
I WAS VERY PLEASED TO SEE THAT
04:29:37.861 --> 04:29:38.896
YOU WORK WITH ALL STAKEHOLDERS
04:29:38.962 --> 04:29:40.998
INCLUDING OPPOSITION ON'T AND
04:29:41.064 --> 04:29:42.165
SOME BUSINESS GROUPS TO TRY TO
04:29:42.232 --> 04:29:43.934
MAKE SURE THAT YOUR ADDRESS SOME
04:29:44.001 --> 04:29:45.168
OF THE REGIONAL CONCERNS- WE
04:29:45.235 --> 04:29:46.837
DON'T WANNA MAKE A LOOPHOLE HERE
04:29:46.904 --> 04:29:49.540
THAT JUST ALLOWS- YOU KNOW- IT
04:29:49.606 --> 04:29:51.141
WORKERS TO BE USES SYSTEM WE
04:29:51.208 --> 04:29:52.543
WANT TO MAKE SURE WORKERS ARE
04:29:52.609 --> 04:29:53.911
SAFE SUCH. AS REALLY
04:29:53.977 --> 04:29:55.045
APPRECIATIVE
04:29:55.112 --> 04:29:55.913
YOU TOOK MANAGEMENT AT MACY'S
04:29:55.979 --> 04:29:57.214
THE REASONABLE PERSON STANDARD
04:29:57.281 --> 04:29:59.149
BY RATHER THAN A SUBJECT IF YOU
04:29:59.216 --> 04:30:01.118
WHICH I THINK COULD BE FRAUGHT
04:30:01.184 --> 04:30:02.352
WITH ABUSE I DON'T ENCOURAGE YOU
04:30:02.419 --> 04:30:03.253
TO KEEP WORKING WITH
04:30:03.320 --> 04:30:04.521
STAKEHOLDERS AS THIS BILL GOES
04:30:04.588 --> 04:30:06.123
THROUGH THE ASSEMBLY TO TRY TO
04:30:06.189 --> 04:30:07.057
MAKE SURE THAT IT'S A TIGHT
04:30:07.124 --> 04:30:09.126
NARROWLY DRAFTED BILL- I DO.
04:30:09.192 --> 04:30:10.928
APPRECIATE THE GOALS OF THIS BUT
04:30:10.994 --> 04:30:12.796
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
04:30:12.863 --> 04:30:13.864
WE'RE NOT MAKING IT HARDER FOR
04:30:13.931 --> 04:30:15.265
BUSINESSES TO SUCCEED IN THE
04:30:15.332 --> 04:30:16.967
STATE I WITH THAT I WOULD
04:30:17.034 --> 04:30:17.901
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY
04:30:17.968 --> 04:30:19.570
COLLEAGUES TO SUPPORT THIS BILL
04:30:19.636 --> 04:30:22.706
THANK YOU SIR MEN SENATOR LEYVA
04:30:22.773 --> 04:30:23.807
. YOU MISTER PRESS. MEMBERS IRA
04:30:23.874 --> 04:30:25.609
. IN STRONG SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
04:30:25.676 --> 04:30:27.177
IN THE MIDDLE OF AN EMERGENCY IT
04:30:27.244 --> 04:30:28.512
IS CRITICAL THAT WORKERS ARE
04:30:28.579 --> 04:30:30.981
ABLE TO USE A CELL PHONE OR EVEN
04:30:31.048 --> 04:30:33.183
LEAVE WORK. TO HELP THEMSELVES.
04:30:33.250 --> 04:30:34.484
IS UNCONSCIONABLE THAT IN THE
04:30:34.551 --> 04:30:36.653
MIDDLE OF A WILDFIRE A FLOOD OR
04:30:36.720 --> 04:30:38.522
EVEN A SHOOTING. WORKERS WOULD
04:30:38.589 --> 04:30:39.523
BE PREVENTED FROM DOING
04:30:39.590 --> 04:30:41.491
SOMETHING. AS COMMON SENSE AS
04:30:41.558 --> 04:30:43.660
USING A COMMUNICATION DEVICE. OR
04:30:43.727 --> 04:30:45.929
EVEN LEAVE IF NEEDED. BUT THIS
04:30:45.996 --> 04:30:47.598
BILL ISN'T JUST ABOUT
04:30:47.664 --> 04:30:49.132
COMMONSENSE. IT ALSO SPEAKS TO
04:30:49.199 --> 04:30:50.567
THE HEART OF BASIC HUMAN
04:30:50.634 --> 04:30:52.102
DECENCY. WHICH I'M VERY PROUD TO
04:30:52.169 --> 04:30:54.771
SUPPORT. IN SB TEN FORTY FOUR.
04:30:54.838 --> 04:30:56.139
AS A PROUD CO AUTHOR I
04:30:56.206 --> 04:30:57.975
APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR'S WORK. ON
04:30:58.041 --> 04:30:59.576
THIS IMPORTANT BILL. THAT WILL
04:30:59.643 --> 04:31:01.044
HELP KEEP CALIFORNIA WORKERS AND
04:31:01.111 --> 04:31:02.479
THEIR FAMILIES SAFE. AND
04:31:02.546 --> 04:31:04.648
ADVANCES POLICY THAT PRIORITIZES
04:31:04.715 --> 04:31:06.717
THE HEALTH AND SAFETY. OF OUR
04:31:06.783 --> 04:31:08.885
RESIDENTS ACROSS OUR STATE. I
04:31:08.952 --> 04:31:10.120
LOOK FORWARD TO SUPPORTING THE
04:31:10.187 --> 04:31:11.188
BILL TODAY AND I'M HOPEFUL THAT
04:31:11.254 --> 04:31:14.157
MY COLLEAGUES. ON THE RED CARPET
04:31:14.224 --> 04:31:15.692
WILL ALSO JOIN ME IN SUPPORTING
04:31:15.759 --> 04:31:26.436
SB TEN. Q. SENATOR MELENDEZ YEAH. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT- I HAVE
04:31:26.503 --> 04:31:28.005
A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR IF I
04:31:28.071 --> 04:31:30.207
MAY CENTER DRAWS A WOULD YOU
04:31:30.273 --> 04:31:32.142
LIKE TO TAKE A QUESTION YES
04:31:32.209 --> 04:31:34.277
CENTER MELINDA'S THANK YOU
04:31:34.344 --> 04:31:36.980
THROUGH THE CHAIR- THE BILL
04:31:37.047 --> 04:31:39.349
SPECIFIES. THAT EMPLOYER CAN'T
04:31:39.416 --> 04:31:42.252
TAKE AN ADVERSE REACTION. I'M
04:31:42.319 --> 04:31:44.421
AGAINST PLEASE REFUSE TO COME TO
04:31:44.488 --> 04:31:45.922
OR REMAIN AT WORK BECAUSE THEY
04:31:45.989 --> 04:31:47.691
FEEL UNSAFE DURING A STATE OR
04:31:47.758 --> 04:31:51.395
CONDITION OF EMERGENCY. SO THAT
04:31:51.461 --> 04:31:53.196
COULD INCLUDE WILDFIRES ARE
04:31:53.263 --> 04:31:54.865
RIGHT ABOUT THE THINGS THAT CAN
04:31:54.931 --> 04:31:56.600
ALSO I'M ASSUMING INCLUDE THE
04:31:56.667 --> 04:31:58.035
CURRENT STATE OF EMERGENCY THAT
04:31:58.101 --> 04:32:01.271
WE WERE IN. SO I'M WONDERING HOW
04:32:01.338 --> 04:32:03.306
THIS WOULD APPLY TO. THE DAY TO
04:32:03.373 --> 04:32:04.941
DAY RIGHT NOW SINCE WE ARE STILL
04:32:05.008 --> 04:32:06.877
IN A STATE OF EMERGENCY CNTER
04:32:06.943 --> 04:32:08.945
DRAWS A WOULD YOU LIKE TO
04:32:09.012 --> 04:32:10.747
CLARIFY. YES THANK- AND THANK
04:32:10.814 --> 04:32:12.582
YOU FOR THE FOR THE QUESTION
04:32:12.649 --> 04:32:15.218
THIS IS- THE WAY WE'VE ADDRESS
04:32:15.285 --> 04:32:17.220
THIS IS TO SHOW THAT THERE HAS
04:32:17.287 --> 04:32:19.222
TO BE AN EMERGENCY IN REAL TIME.
04:32:19.289 --> 04:32:22.092
AND EMERGENCY FACING THAT WORKER
04:32:22.159 --> 04:32:24.828
AT THE TIME NOT SOMETHING THAT
04:32:24.895 --> 04:32:26.229
PASSED NOT SOMETHING THAT COULD
04:32:26.296 --> 04:32:29.733
BE IN THE FUTURE WHAT ARE THEY
04:32:29.800 --> 04:32:31.568
THEY FACED WITH IMMINENT DANGER
04:32:31.635 --> 04:32:33.503
OF A FACE WITH LIFE AND DEATH
04:32:33.570 --> 04:32:35.739
THEY OR A FAMILY MEMBER AND
04:32:35.806 --> 04:32:36.206
THAT'S WHAT MAKES THE
04:32:36.273 --> 04:32:38.041
DISTINCTION IT IS NOT JUST A
04:32:38.108 --> 04:32:41.678
GENERAL- ON EMERGENCY. IT'S VERY
04:32:41.745 --> 04:32:44.147
SPECIFIC TO THEM AND THEIR WELL
04:32:44.214 --> 04:32:46.049
BEING AND THEIR SAFETY. CENTER
04:32:46.116 --> 04:32:51.455
MELENDEZ AM THANK YOU WELL- I
04:32:51.521 --> 04:32:53.390
GUESS ONE ADDITIONAL QUESTION IF
04:32:53.457 --> 04:32:55.792
I MAY WOULD BE IF SHE WOULD
04:32:55.859 --> 04:32:57.728
ACCEPT THE QUESTION A- TENER
04:32:57.794 --> 04:33:00.030
DRAWS A WOULD YOU ACCEPT ONE
04:33:00.097 --> 04:33:01.865
MORE CLARIFYING QUESTIONS. YES
04:33:01.932 --> 04:33:04.668
THANK YOU I'M- IS THERE A
04:33:04.735 --> 04:33:07.370
DEFINITION WITHIN THE BILL THAT
04:33:07.437 --> 04:33:10.774
YOU KNOW EXPLAINS WHAT- IN A
04:33:10.841 --> 04:33:14.044
REASONABLE FIERER REASONABLE
04:33:14.111 --> 04:33:23.019
HARM MIGHT BE. SENATE RAZA YES.
04:33:23.086 --> 04:33:24.688
YES IT IS THE A REASONABLE
04:33:24.755 --> 04:33:26.389
PERSON STANDARD THIS IS ALSO
04:33:26.456 --> 04:33:29.059
SOMETHING THAT WE TOOK OFF FROM
04:33:29.126 --> 04:33:31.128
THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE THE
04:33:31.194 --> 04:33:33.497
REASONABLE PERSON STANDARD WHAT
04:33:33.563 --> 04:33:34.831
WOULD A REASONABLE PERSON DO IN
04:33:34.898 --> 04:33:36.600
THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES BECAUSE IN
04:33:36.666 --> 04:33:39.636
FACT IF A WORKER WALKS OUT
04:33:39.703 --> 04:33:43.140
SAYING I'M AN M. L. I'M UNDER.
04:33:43.206 --> 04:33:45.709
IMMINENT HARM I AM IN THE DANGER
04:33:45.776 --> 04:33:47.944
OF SERIOUS BODILY HARM THEY HAVE
04:33:48.011 --> 04:33:50.881
TO BE ABLE TO PROVE THAT BECAUSE
04:33:50.947 --> 04:33:52.816
IF THE EMPLOYER DECIDES TO FIRE
04:33:52.883 --> 04:33:54.518
THEM FOR WALKING OFF THEY HAVE
04:33:54.584 --> 04:33:56.620
TO BE ABLE TO SAY LOOK YOU ARE
04:33:56.686 --> 04:33:58.655
YOU ARE YOU ANYBODY A REASONABLE
04:33:58.722 --> 04:34:00.690
PERSON WOULD HAVE DONE THE SAME
04:34:00.757 --> 04:34:04.261
THING THIS IS NOT- THIS IS NOT
04:34:04.327 --> 04:34:05.762
SOMETHING THAT YOU SHOULD TAKE
04:34:05.829 --> 04:34:07.164
LIGHTLY THIS IS SOMETHING THAT'S
04:34:07.230 --> 04:34:08.732
VERY SERIOUS YOU'RE GOING TO
04:34:08.799 --> 04:34:10.901
HAVE TO PROVE. THAT YOU WERE
04:34:10.967 --> 04:34:12.135
UNDER THOSE CONDITIONS UNDER
04:34:12.202 --> 04:34:14.271
THOSE CIRCUMSTANCES OR ELSE THE
04:34:14.337 --> 04:34:16.873
EMPLOYER WILL. NOT HAVE A REASON
04:34:16.940 --> 04:34:19.943
TO TAKE THEM BACK. OKAY THANK
04:34:20.010 --> 04:34:21.545
YOU THEN- I DON'T HAVE ANY
04:34:21.611 --> 04:34:22.879
FURTHER QUESTIONS JUST SOME
04:34:22.946 --> 04:34:25.615
COMMENTS- I STILL HAVE SOME
04:34:25.682 --> 04:34:26.817
CONCERNS ABOUT HOW THIS WOULD
04:34:26.883 --> 04:34:29.920
PLAY OUT- YOU KNOW IT'S A RATHER
04:34:29.986 --> 04:34:31.521
LITIGIOUS SOCIETY THAT WE DO
04:34:31.588 --> 04:34:33.156
LIVE IN HERE AND I DO HAVE GREAT
04:34:33.223 --> 04:34:35.258
CONCERN THAT THERE WILL BE SOME
04:34:35.325 --> 04:34:38.028
FOLKS WHO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS
04:34:38.094 --> 04:34:39.830
AM I RECOGNIZE THAT'S NOT YOUR
04:34:39.896 --> 04:34:41.998
INTENT- BUT I THINK IT WOULD BE
04:34:42.065 --> 04:34:43.967
NAIVE OF US TO ASSUME THAT NO
04:34:44.034 --> 04:34:45.302
ONE WOULD TRY TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
04:34:45.368 --> 04:34:47.137
OF THIS. GIVEN THE FACT THAT WE
04:34:47.204 --> 04:34:49.873
ARE IS STILL IN A DECLARED STATE
04:34:49.940 --> 04:34:50.907
OF EMERGENCY ONE CAN IMAGINE A
04:34:50.974 --> 04:34:52.976
SITUATION WHERE AN EMPLOYEE
04:34:53.043 --> 04:34:57.414
PERHAPS- HE WORKS AT A BUSY MALL
04:34:57.480 --> 04:34:59.416
OR SOME SORT OF TRANSPORTATION
04:34:59.482 --> 04:35:01.251
HOWEVER THERE ARE MANY MANY
04:35:01.318 --> 04:35:02.686
PEOPLE WHO ARE COMING AND GOING
04:35:02.752 --> 04:35:05.422
COULD SAY- YOU KNOW I. I HEARD
04:35:05.488 --> 04:35:07.757
THAT THERE WAS HAVE. YOU KNOW A
04:35:07.824 --> 04:35:10.360
COPAY THE OUTBREAK IN THIS
04:35:10.427 --> 04:35:11.995
GENERAL NEIGHBORHOOD AREA AND I
04:35:12.062 --> 04:35:14.831
DON'T FEEL SAFE SO I'M NOT GOING
04:35:14.898 --> 04:35:16.900
TO COME TO WORK FOR THE NEXT.
04:35:16.967 --> 04:35:19.169
TWO DAYS OR THREE DAYS OR
04:35:19.236 --> 04:35:21.204
WHATEVER- I THINK THAT'S-
04:35:21.271 --> 04:35:22.973
REASONABLE TO ASSUME THAT THAT
04:35:23.039 --> 04:35:24.007
COULD HAPPEN WHICH PUTS
04:35:24.074 --> 04:35:25.842
EMPLOYERS IN A VERY PRECARIOUS
04:35:25.909 --> 04:35:28.345
POSITION BECAUSE THE BURDEN IS
04:35:28.411 --> 04:35:30.280
NOW ON THE EMPLOYER TO PROVE.
04:35:30.347 --> 04:35:32.616
THAT THAT THEY WEREN'T IN DANGER
04:35:32.682 --> 04:35:34.117
I'M NOT SURE HOW THEY COULD
04:35:34.184 --> 04:35:37.754
POSSIBLY- PROVED THAT SO- THANK
04:35:37.821 --> 04:35:38.421
YOU THOUGH FOR THE
04:35:38.488 --> 04:35:41.825
CLARIFICATION- AND I.
04:35:41.892 --> 04:35:43.260
RESPECTFULLY I'M GOING TO HAVE
04:35:43.326 --> 04:35:44.995
TO OPPOSE THIS BILL THANK YOU
04:35:45.061 --> 04:35:45.962
THANK YOU CENTER MELENDEZ
04:35:46.029 --> 04:35:48.465
SENATOR ROBERT. I THANK YOU MR
04:35:48.531 --> 04:35:50.433
PRESIDENT AND JUST FOLLOWING ON-
04:35:50.500 --> 04:35:52.335
WITH THE QUESTION TO THE AUTHOR
04:35:52.402 --> 04:35:54.638
FOLLOWING ON FROM MY COLLEAGUE
04:35:54.704 --> 04:35:58.842
FROM LAKE ELSINORE- CENTER DRAWS
04:35:58.909 --> 04:35:59.976
A WOULD YOU ACCEPT THE QUESTION.
04:36:00.043 --> 04:36:02.112
YES THANK YOU SO RUMORED- IF I
04:36:02.178 --> 04:36:04.147
UNDERSTAND CORRECTLY THERE ARE
04:36:04.214 --> 04:36:05.415
TWO DIFFERENT STANDARDS IN THE
04:36:05.482 --> 04:36:07.384
LAW ONE IS A SUBJECTIVE STANDARD
04:36:07.450 --> 04:36:08.652
SUBJECT TO STANDARD BEING
04:36:08.718 --> 04:36:09.853
WHETHER SOMEONE FOR EXAMPLE
04:36:09.920 --> 04:36:12.289
FEARS THAT COVE IT. MAY IMPACT
04:36:12.355 --> 04:36:15.191
THEM- SORT OF IN A GENERAL WAY
04:36:15.258 --> 04:36:16.927
BECAUSE COVERT MAY EXIST IN
04:36:16.993 --> 04:36:18.929
GENERAL SOCIETY. AND SO THUS
04:36:18.995 --> 04:36:20.931
THEY DECIDE NOT TO COME TO WORK
04:36:20.997 --> 04:36:21.932
BECAUSE THEY HAVE THIS
04:36:21.998 --> 04:36:23.266
GENERALIZED FEAR THAT SOME
04:36:23.333 --> 04:36:25.869
ALCOVE IT MAY. IMPACT THEM. THEY
04:36:25.936 --> 04:36:27.070
MAY TRULY BELIEVE IT BUT
04:36:27.137 --> 04:36:28.438
SUBJECTIVELY AND THEN THERE'S
04:36:28.505 --> 04:36:30.106
THE OBJECT OF STANDARD OBJECT OF
04:36:30.173 --> 04:36:31.608
STANDARDS WHETHER RESULT PERSON
04:36:31.675 --> 04:36:33.109
NOT NOT THE INDIVIDUAL BUT A
04:36:33.176 --> 04:36:34.878
REASONABLE PERSON. USING THAT
04:36:34.945 --> 04:36:36.479
STANDARD IN LAW THE OBJECTIVE
04:36:36.546 --> 04:36:38.081
STANDARD IN LAW WITH A
04:36:38.148 --> 04:36:40.583
REASONABLE PERSON. IS DETERMINED
04:36:40.650 --> 04:36:41.952
BY THE FINDER OF FACT FOR
04:36:42.018 --> 04:36:44.054
EXAMPLE JURY OR A JUDGE. WOULD
04:36:44.120 --> 04:36:45.055
BELIEVE THAT THERE WAS A
04:36:45.121 --> 04:36:47.524
OBJECTIVELY A REAL FEAR THAT
04:36:47.590 --> 04:36:50.527
THAT THEY WOULD BE IN- IN IN
04:36:50.593 --> 04:36:52.262
FEAR OF THEIR PERSONAL SAFETY.
04:36:52.329 --> 04:36:53.730
OF IN WHICH STANDARD IS USED IN
04:36:53.797 --> 04:36:56.967
THIS BILL THIS BILL UP WE ARE
04:36:57.033 --> 04:36:58.868
ADOPTING THE REASONABLE PERSON
04:36:58.935 --> 04:37:01.371
STANDARD THE- AS TO WHAT WOULD
04:37:01.438 --> 04:37:02.772
THE REASONABLE OBJECTIVELY
04:37:02.839 --> 04:37:05.308
SPEAKING PERSON DO. IN THAT
04:37:05.375 --> 04:37:08.912
SITUATION RT. OBJECTIVES THE
04:37:08.979 --> 04:37:10.347
UNIT IS DETERMINED BY THE FINDER
04:37:10.413 --> 04:37:11.881
OF FACT NOT SUBJECTIVE IS
04:37:11.948 --> 04:37:13.316
DETERMINED BY THE INDIVIDUAL
04:37:13.383 --> 04:37:14.951
RIGHTS RIGHT ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
04:37:15.018 --> 04:37:17.287
FOR THE QUESTION THANK YOU SERRA
04:37:17.354 --> 04:37:20.056
BURKE CENTER GLAZER. HELLO MR
04:37:20.123 --> 04:37:21.458
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I WAS HOPING
04:37:21.524 --> 04:37:23.626
THAT THE- THE AUTHOR WOULD SPEAK
04:37:23.693 --> 04:37:25.395
TO THE PRIVATE ATTORNEY GENERAL
04:37:25.462 --> 04:37:26.429
ACT THAT SEEMS TO BE A PROVISION
04:37:26.496 --> 04:37:28.198
OF THE BILL. AND WHY THAT'S
04:37:28.264 --> 04:37:30.500
NECESSARY- GIVEN THE VARIOUS
04:37:30.567 --> 04:37:33.136
STATE. ANOTHER A HEALTH AND
04:37:33.203 --> 04:37:34.504
SAFETY AGENCIES THAT CAN
04:37:34.571 --> 04:37:37.874
PROPERLY ENFORCE. CENTER GLAZER
04:37:37.941 --> 04:37:39.209
ARE YOU ASKING A QUESTION OR
04:37:39.275 --> 04:37:40.910
ANSWER IN THE AUTHOR TO RESPOND
04:37:40.977 --> 04:37:42.078
IN HER COTHES I'M ASKING THE
04:37:42.145 --> 04:37:43.813
AUTHOR QUESTION CENTER DRAWS A
04:37:43.880 --> 04:37:45.582
WOULD YOU ACCEPT THAT AS A
04:37:45.648 --> 04:37:48.184
QUESTION. YES THANK YOU. THE
04:37:48.251 --> 04:37:49.786
RIGHT TO CURE IS SOMETHING
04:37:49.853 --> 04:37:51.788
THAT'S IN THE LABOR CODE AND
04:37:51.855 --> 04:37:54.724
WERE ADOPTING THE SAME. THE SAME
04:37:54.791 --> 04:37:57.160
PROVISION. OF AND THERE'S A
04:37:57.227 --> 04:37:58.728
WHOLE PROCESS THAT THE EMPLOYEE
04:37:58.795 --> 04:38:00.230
MUST FILE THE NOTICE OF THE
04:38:00.296 --> 04:38:01.998
VIOLATION IN OTHER WORDS IF
04:38:02.065 --> 04:38:04.034
SOMEBODY GETS FIRED. AND WE
04:38:04.100 --> 04:38:05.535
CONSIDER THAT A VIOLATION OF
04:38:05.602 --> 04:38:07.904
THIS OF THIS LAW IF IT WERE TO
04:38:07.971 --> 04:38:10.306
BECOME LAW- A NOTICE OF
04:38:10.373 --> 04:38:12.442
VIOLATION TO THE LABOR AGENCY.
04:38:12.509 --> 04:38:14.077
NOTICE TO THE EMPLOYER THE
04:38:14.144 --> 04:38:17.514
EMPLOYER RESPONDS- THAT HAS A AN
04:38:17.580 --> 04:38:18.181
OPPORTUNITY TO CURE THE
04:38:18.248 --> 04:38:20.116
VIOLATION I MEAN THERE'S A WHOLE
04:38:20.183 --> 04:38:23.620
VERY SPECIFIC STEP BY STEP. OF
04:38:23.686 --> 04:38:29.592
PROCESS THAT IS DONE- THROUGH
04:38:29.659 --> 04:38:31.227
THE LABOR CODE RIGHT NOW. OKAY
04:38:31.294 --> 04:38:33.430
THE ON MY OWN TIME THEN I. I
04:38:33.496 --> 04:38:35.265
DON'T THINK THAT THE YOU KNOW.
04:38:35.331 --> 04:38:36.900
THE PRIVATE ATTORNEY GENERAL ACT
04:38:36.966 --> 04:38:38.168
AND WHEN THOSE THOSE COME
04:38:38.234 --> 04:38:40.103
THROUGH VARIOUS BILS THAT THAT
04:38:40.170 --> 04:38:41.271
THAT WE HAVE HEARD I'VE I'VE
04:38:41.337 --> 04:38:42.972
BEEN OPPOSED TO THOSE BECAUSE
04:38:43.039 --> 04:38:44.474
THEY SEEM TO BE LITIGATION
04:38:44.541 --> 04:38:46.009
TRAPS- FOR EMPLOYERS AND FOR
04:38:46.076 --> 04:38:47.110
OTHERS WHERE. WE HAVE
04:38:47.177 --> 04:38:48.978
PUBLICATIONS USED IF SOMEONE IS
04:38:49.045 --> 04:38:50.947
INVOLVED THE LAW CORRECTLY TO
04:38:51.014 --> 04:38:55.351
ENFORCE BUT WHEN YOU PUT THESE
04:38:55.418 --> 04:38:56.052
WHAT ARE FOR TO HIS PAGO.
04:38:56.119 --> 04:38:57.854
OPTIONS IN LEGISLATION LIKE HIS
04:38:57.921 --> 04:39:01.057
YOU CREATE A WHOLE- CAN OF
04:39:01.124 --> 04:39:02.392
POTENTIAL LITIGATION THAT I
04:39:02.459 --> 04:39:05.695
THINK. CREATES A LOT OF OUR
04:39:05.762 --> 04:39:06.362
ABILITY- FOR EMPLOYERS AND
04:39:06.429 --> 04:39:08.565
OTHERS. I CERTAINLY SUPPORT THE
04:39:08.631 --> 04:39:10.533
GOALS THAT THE- THE AUTHOR HAS
04:39:10.600 --> 04:39:12.702
PUT FORWARD IN THIS BILL. BUT I
04:39:12.769 --> 04:39:15.038
FEEL IT THAT THAT'S A- A POISON
04:39:15.105 --> 04:39:17.006
PILL FOR SO MANY INCLUDING THIS
04:39:17.073 --> 04:39:19.042
ONE AND SO THAT'S WHY. I'M FORTY
04:39:19.109 --> 04:39:20.910
NOT GONNA BE ABLE TO SUPPORT IT
04:39:20.977 --> 04:39:22.912
TODAY. THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZERS
04:39:22.979 --> 04:39:25.014
SENATOR GROW. THANK YOU MR
04:39:25.081 --> 04:39:26.616
PRESIDENT- I APPRECIATE MY
04:39:26.683 --> 04:39:28.184
COLLEAGUES FROM ORINDA- BRINGING
04:39:28.251 --> 04:39:29.552
UP THE SITUATION WE HAVE WITH
04:39:29.619 --> 04:39:31.988
POCKETS. AND AM I GOING TO
04:39:32.055 --> 04:39:33.156
CORRECT THE RECORD THAT. THAT
04:39:33.223 --> 04:39:34.290
WAS JUST RESPONDED TO IN THE
04:39:34.357 --> 04:39:36.693
QUESTION SO PARTISAN LABOR CODE
04:39:36.759 --> 04:39:37.994
IT IS AND PRIVATE ATTORNEY
04:39:38.061 --> 04:39:39.629
GENERAL ACT SIGNED UNDER DAVIS
04:39:39.696 --> 04:39:42.398
ADMINISTRATION. BUT AND THERE IS
04:39:42.465 --> 04:39:44.968
NO CURE. BECAUSE THERE IS A
04:39:45.034 --> 04:39:47.137
PENALTY PHASE AND THE LIABILITY
04:39:47.203 --> 04:39:49.772
PHASE. SO BASICALLY THE JUDGE
04:39:49.839 --> 04:39:52.275
SAYS YOU HAVE NO LIABILITY THE
04:39:52.342 --> 04:39:53.910
BUILDING WAS ON FIRE HE TOLD THE
04:39:53.977 --> 04:39:56.179
EMPLOYEES TO GO HOME. YOU PAID
04:39:56.246 --> 04:39:58.314
THEM FOR THE DAY THEY CAME BACK.
04:39:58.381 --> 04:39:59.215
THERE IS NO ISSUE BUT SOMEBODY
04:39:59.282 --> 04:40:01.551
GOES OH MY GOD I DIDN'T GET THE
04:40:01.618 --> 04:40:03.019
MESSAGE AND- I DIDN'T KNOW I
04:40:03.086 --> 04:40:05.788
COULD COME BACK IN SO THEY FILE
04:40:05.855 --> 04:40:06.422
A LAWSUIT THERE'S NO LIABILITY
04:40:06.489 --> 04:40:08.324
BECAUSE THERE WAS NO HARM. KIND
04:40:08.391 --> 04:40:09.025
LIKE THE PAYCHECK ISSUE THEY
04:40:09.092 --> 04:40:10.426
WERE PROTECTION TO DO SIX HAS
04:40:10.493 --> 04:40:12.028
NINE VIOLATIONS ON A PAYCHECK
04:40:12.095 --> 04:40:14.330
STUB IN A PRODUCT. THAT YOU HAVE
04:40:14.397 --> 04:40:16.166
TO ADHERE TO IT HAS TO BE
04:40:16.232 --> 04:40:18.535
SPECIFIC. SO IF YOU HAVE. LIKE
04:40:18.601 --> 04:40:20.103
TO SEE THE LAST FOUR DIGITS OF A
04:40:20.170 --> 04:40:21.905
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER IN YOUR
04:40:21.971 --> 04:40:22.572
PLACE FOR IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
04:40:22.639 --> 04:40:24.908
YOU PUT THAT ON THERE. THAT
04:40:24.974 --> 04:40:26.676
DOESN'T HURT THE EMPLOYEE. AND
04:40:26.743 --> 04:40:28.678
THERE'S NO PENALTY UNDER THE
04:40:28.745 --> 04:40:30.647
LIABILITY FIFTIES OF THE
04:40:30.713 --> 04:40:32.315
LITIGATION BUT UNDER THE PENALTY
04:40:32.382 --> 04:40:34.184
PHASE IS TWO HUNDRED DOLLARS A
04:40:34.250 --> 04:40:36.419
PAY PERIOD PER EMPLOYEE PER
04:40:36.486 --> 04:40:37.654
PERSON. PER PAYCHECK ISSUE GOING
04:40:37.720 --> 04:40:39.155
BACK FOUR YEARS FOR A OF A
04:40:39.222 --> 04:40:41.257
VIOLATION OF IT IS AND ONE YEAR
04:40:41.324 --> 04:40:42.825
FOR VIOLATIONS. OF WAGE
04:40:42.892 --> 04:40:44.861
STATEMENT ERRORS OR FOUR
04:40:44.928 --> 04:40:45.595
THOUSAND DOLLARS WHICHEVER IS
04:40:45.662 --> 04:40:48.064
GREATER. SO THAT STILL STANDS
04:40:48.131 --> 04:40:50.200
AND IS NOT MITIGATED BY A JUDGE.
04:40:50.266 --> 04:40:52.135
SO IF THERE IS A PAGA CLAIM
04:40:52.202 --> 04:40:53.937
BROUGHT UNDER THIS PARTICULAR
04:40:54.003 --> 04:40:55.872
PIECE OF LEGISLATION. THERE WILL
04:40:55.939 --> 04:40:57.674
BE LIGHT BILITY AND THE
04:40:57.740 --> 04:41:00.410
LIABILITY COULD BE ZERO. BUT
04:41:00.476 --> 04:41:02.212
UNDER THE LIABILITY PHASE BUT
04:41:02.278 --> 04:41:04.013
UNDER THE PENALTY PHASE THAT HAS
04:41:04.080 --> 04:41:05.281
NOT BEN ADDRESSED BY THIS
04:41:05.348 --> 04:41:06.716
LEGISLATOR THERE'S LEGISLATURE
04:41:06.783 --> 04:41:08.284
THEY'RE STILL LIKE IN OF THE
04:41:08.351 --> 04:41:09.986
PHASE. THE SECOND PHASE OF THE
04:41:10.053 --> 04:41:11.454
LITIGATION THAT REQUIRES A
04:41:11.521 --> 04:41:14.190
PENALTY TO BE PAID. TO THE TRIAL
04:41:14.257 --> 04:41:17.327
ATTORNEYS. AND FOR THAT TWO
04:41:17.393 --> 04:41:18.761
HUNDRED DOLLARS PER PAY PERIOD
04:41:18.828 --> 04:41:19.495
PER PAYCHECK GOING BACK FOR
04:41:19.562 --> 04:41:24.734
YEARS. OR IN THIS CASE IT WOULD
04:41:24.801 --> 04:41:27.070
BE FOUR YEARS BECAUSE IT WOULD
04:41:27.136 --> 04:41:28.371
BE AWAITING OUR- FOR. SILICEOUS
04:41:28.438 --> 04:41:29.973
AN EARLY MISTER REST PERIOD OR
04:41:30.039 --> 04:41:32.609
THEN THEY DIDN'T GET PAID FOR AN
04:41:32.675 --> 04:41:33.276
EIGHT HOUR PERIOD EVEN IF THEY
04:41:33.343 --> 04:41:34.944
CURED IT AND PAID THEM AND
04:41:35.011 --> 04:41:36.913
GIVING THEM AN ADDITIONAL WAGES
04:41:36.980 --> 04:41:38.214
A DAY'S WAGES BECAUSE THAT'S
04:41:38.281 --> 04:41:40.183
WHAT REQUIRED BY THE LABOR CODE
04:41:40.250 --> 04:41:42.285
TO CORRECT EIGHT MISSED PAY OF
04:41:42.352 --> 04:41:44.020
AN EMPLOYEE'S PAYCHECK YOU WOULD
04:41:44.087 --> 04:41:46.122
STILL FACE THE PENALTIES BY THE
04:41:46.189 --> 04:41:47.323
MULTIPLE NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES
04:41:47.390 --> 04:41:50.326
THAT YOU HAVE SO- THE PAGO
04:41:50.393 --> 04:41:53.162
POISON PILL IN THIS BILL IS HUGE
04:41:53.229 --> 04:41:55.965
AND- WE CUT- EMPLOYERS ARE JUST
04:41:56.032 --> 04:41:57.300
STARTING TO COME OUT OF RECOVERY
04:41:57.367 --> 04:41:59.168
BECAUSE OF CODED. THEY WERE SHUT
04:41:59.235 --> 04:42:01.504
DOWN THE IDA AND BY BY SO MANY
04:42:01.571 --> 04:42:03.640
DIFFERENT ROLES AT SO MANY
04:42:03.706 --> 04:42:04.274
DIFFERENT TIMES AND I THINK WE
04:42:04.340 --> 04:42:06.242
SHOULD JUST GIVE HIM SOME SPACE
04:42:06.309 --> 04:42:09.145
TO TRY TO RECOVER FROM COBURN
04:42:09.212 --> 04:42:11.848
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR NOVA
04:42:11.914 --> 04:42:13.783
. THANK YOU SIR GROVE CENTER
04:42:13.850 --> 04:42:18.288
CORTESE. THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT-
04:42:18.354 --> 04:42:20.490
I DO RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
04:42:20.556 --> 04:42:22.725
BILL BUT I WANTED TO ASK
04:42:22.792 --> 04:42:23.459
CLARIFYING QUESTION BECAUSE I'VE
04:42:23.526 --> 04:42:26.729
BEEN- KIND OF QATAR CONFUSED BY
04:42:26.796 --> 04:42:29.532
SOME OF THE QUESTIONS. ASKED
04:42:29.599 --> 04:42:31.501
ACCORDING TO THE BILL IN OUR
04:42:31.567 --> 04:42:32.869
ZERO ZERO WOULD YOU TAKE ANOTHER
04:42:32.935 --> 04:42:34.037
QUESTION THE CANCER THANK YOU
04:42:34.103 --> 04:42:35.571
SENATOR CORTESE ARE RECOGNIZED
04:42:35.638 --> 04:42:37.006
FOR QUESTION TO THE AUTHOR.
04:42:37.073 --> 04:42:38.741
ACCORDING TO THE BILL ENOSIS
04:42:38.808 --> 04:42:41.511
BEFORE US TODAY- IT SAYS THAT
04:42:41.577 --> 04:42:43.379
THIS BILL DEFINES FOR PURPOSES
04:42:43.446 --> 04:42:45.148
OF THE BILL A STATE OF EMERGENCY
04:42:45.214 --> 04:42:47.483
TO ME IN THE EXISTENCE OF ANY OF
04:42:47.550 --> 04:42:48.985
THE FOLLOWING. THAT IS DECLARED
04:42:49.052 --> 04:42:51.988
AFTER ENACTMENT OF THIS BILL- IS
04:42:52.055 --> 04:42:53.923
IN THE COUNTY WERE WORKER LIVES
04:42:53.990 --> 04:42:56.559
OR WORKS. IS NOT A HEALTH
04:42:56.626 --> 04:42:59.062
PANDEMIC. IMPOSES AN IMMINENT
04:42:59.128 --> 04:43:00.663
AND ONGOING RISK OF HARM TO THE
04:43:00.730 --> 04:43:03.132
WORKER. SO TO ME THAT YOU
04:43:03.199 --> 04:43:04.634
AMENDED OUT COALBED FOR WHOLE
04:43:04.701 --> 04:43:06.602
CONDEMNING FROM THE BILL. SO
04:43:06.669 --> 04:43:08.137
THAT THESE ISSUES ABOUT WHETHER
04:43:08.204 --> 04:43:12.442
OR NOT A PERSON COULD. TODAY
04:43:12.508 --> 04:43:13.876
TOMORROW AFTERNOON ACTON OF THIS
04:43:13.943 --> 04:43:14.944
BILL. CLAIM CODE ED- AS AN
04:43:15.011 --> 04:43:17.046
EMERGENCY WOULD BE MOVED IS THAT
04:43:17.113 --> 04:43:18.481
CORRECT YES THAT'S CORRECT OKAY
04:43:18.548 --> 04:43:20.216
THANK YOU AND THEN. LATER IN THE
04:43:20.283 --> 04:43:22.251
IN THE BILL ANALYSIS SPEAKS TO
04:43:22.318 --> 04:43:24.520
PAGA. AND IT DOESN'T-
04:43:24.587 --> 04:43:26.189
DISCRIMINATE BETWEEN THE
04:43:26.255 --> 04:43:28.124
LIABILITY PHASE OR PENALTY PHASE
04:43:28.191 --> 04:43:30.493
IT SIMPLY SAYS. THAT UNDER THE
04:43:30.560 --> 04:43:34.564
PAGA. ACT BUT THERE IS A RIGHT
04:43:34.630 --> 04:43:37.367
TO CURE. READ FULL STOP IS IT IS
04:43:37.433 --> 04:43:39.235
THAT. YOU'RE REALLY LAZY ARE YOU
04:43:39.302 --> 04:43:40.970
ASKING ADDITIONAL QUESTION I AM
04:43:41.037 --> 04:43:42.839
I AM MISTER PRESIDENT THANK YOU
04:43:42.905 --> 04:43:44.640
CENTER CORTESE THROUGH THE CHAIR
04:43:44.707 --> 04:43:47.810
CENTER DRAWS- WOULD YOU ACCEPT
04:43:47.877 --> 04:43:49.011
THAT AS A QUESTION. YES MISSING
04:43:49.078 --> 04:43:51.514
ISN'T. YES YES THAT IS CORRECT
04:43:51.581 --> 04:43:53.082
THANK YOU THANK YOU MR PRESIDENT
04:43:53.149 --> 04:43:54.884
I WOULD SUPPORT HIGH VOTE. THANK
04:43:54.951 --> 04:43:56.386
YOU CENTER CORTESE. SENATOR
04:43:56.452 --> 04:44:00.990
CABALLERO. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
04:44:01.057 --> 04:44:05.061
MR- PRESIDENT- SO THIS THIS- I
04:44:05.128 --> 04:44:06.362
REALLY APPRECIATE WHAT YOU'RE
04:44:06.429 --> 04:44:07.930
YOU'RE YOU'RE TRYING TO DO IN
04:44:07.997 --> 04:44:09.999
THIS BILL AND I GUESS PART OF
04:44:10.066 --> 04:44:11.000
THAT I'M I'M A LITTLE BIT
04:44:11.067 --> 04:44:13.202
BOTHERED BY POCKET JUST BECAUSE-
04:44:13.269 --> 04:44:14.470
I JUST THINK IT IT STARTS
04:44:14.537 --> 04:44:17.373
SETTING UP A SYSTEM APART FROM.
04:44:17.440 --> 04:44:20.143
OUR OWN REGULATORY FRAMEWORK-
04:44:20.209 --> 04:44:21.778
BUT I BET THAT A SECOND ISSUE
04:44:21.844 --> 04:44:24.280
CAME UP AS I WAS THINKING
04:44:24.347 --> 04:44:25.615
THROUGH THIS IS THAT MANY TIMES
04:44:25.681 --> 04:44:28.751
THAT WE DO IS WE TELL EMPLOYERS-
04:44:28.818 --> 04:44:32.021
HERE THE RULES. AND THEN THE
04:44:32.088 --> 04:44:34.857
STATE AGENCIES RIGHT UP- A ONE
04:44:34.924 --> 04:44:36.392
SHEET PAPER SAYING THIS IS HOW
04:44:36.459 --> 04:44:39.262
YOU FOLLOW THE ROLE. AND AND
04:44:39.328 --> 04:44:42.432
EMPLOYERS RELY ON THAT ADVICE
04:44:42.498 --> 04:44:45.201
WHEN THEY'RE- MAKING DECISIONS
04:44:45.268 --> 04:44:46.235
IN ABOUT THEIR EMPLOYMENT
04:44:46.302 --> 04:44:49.972
SITUATION. AND IN THE PAST. IF
04:44:50.039 --> 04:44:51.541
YOU WERE AN EMPLOYER THAT
04:44:51.607 --> 04:44:55.645
FOLLOWED STATE. ADVISEMENT IF IT
04:44:55.711 --> 04:44:57.447
WAS FOUND OR IF THE COURT
04:44:57.513 --> 04:44:59.515
DETERMINED THAT THAT ADVISEMENT
04:44:59.582 --> 04:45:01.918
WAS IT IN ERROR AND YOU FOLLOWED
04:45:01.984 --> 04:45:03.853
AS AN EMPLOYER YOU CAN STILL PAY
04:45:03.920 --> 04:45:05.721
HAVE TO PAY PENALTIES AND
04:45:05.788 --> 04:45:09.192
SIGNIFICANT- FIND OUT FOR THAT
04:45:09.258 --> 04:45:11.494
AND FUNDAMENTALLY TO ME THAT
04:45:11.561 --> 04:45:13.863
JUST SEEMS NOT VERY FAIR- IF
04:45:13.930 --> 04:45:15.364
WE'RE GOING TO TELL PEOPLE HOW
04:45:15.431 --> 04:45:18.568
THEY CAN AVOID VIOLATING THE LAW
04:45:18.634 --> 04:45:21.604
THEN THEN TO ME WE OUGHT TO HAVE
04:45:21.671 --> 04:45:23.239
A RULE THAT SAYS IF YOU FOLLOW
04:45:23.306 --> 04:45:25.575
WHAT THE STATE SAID TO DO. IT
04:45:25.641 --> 04:45:27.543
WAS FOUND TO BE WRONG THEN YOU
04:45:27.610 --> 04:45:28.377
SHOULDN'T BE PENALTIES YOU KNOW
04:45:28.444 --> 04:45:30.179
SLAP UPSIDE THE FACE TO THE
04:45:30.246 --> 04:45:31.247
STATE'S LAB INSIDE THE FACE TO
04:45:31.314 --> 04:45:33.149
THE EMPLOYER- LET'S GET IT RIGHT
04:45:33.216 --> 04:45:35.384
HERE'S THE RIGHT ADVICE I'M SO
04:45:35.451 --> 04:45:37.520
I'M WONDERING IF AN EMPLOYER IS
04:45:37.587 --> 04:45:40.089
FILE FOLLOWING CAL OSHA
04:45:40.156 --> 04:45:44.660
ADVISEMENT- IT IS THAT A- IS
04:45:44.727 --> 04:45:46.128
THAT A- IS THAT A PART. OF
04:45:46.195 --> 04:45:48.164
PROTECTION. FROM FOR THE
04:45:48.231 --> 04:45:51.267
EMPLOYER- IN THIS KIND OF A
04:45:51.334 --> 04:45:53.836
SITUATION. IN OTHER WORDS CAN
04:45:53.903 --> 04:45:55.705
THE EMPLOYER RELY ON CAL OR
04:45:55.771 --> 04:45:58.541
OSHA. REGULATIONS AND IT BUYS
04:45:58.608 --> 04:46:01.711
MEANT INFORMATION- IN IN
04:46:01.777 --> 04:46:03.613
DETERMINING WHETHER THAT WHAT
04:46:03.679 --> 04:46:05.281
THE EMPLOYER DID WAS REASONABLE
04:46:05.348 --> 04:46:06.516
IN THIS SITUATION BECAUSE YOU
04:46:06.582 --> 04:46:07.984
YOU WANT TO DO IT RIGHT TO CARE
04:46:08.050 --> 04:46:11.320
AND THAT'S GREAT SO WE TELL THE
04:46:11.387 --> 04:46:11.954
EMPLOYER. YEAH YOU FOLLOW THE
04:46:12.021 --> 04:46:13.856
ADVISEMENT AND YOU YOU WERE YOU
04:46:13.923 --> 04:46:15.224
WERE WRONG- WE WERE WRONG TO.
04:46:15.291 --> 04:46:17.493
BUT IT DOES DOES THAT SHE'LL BE
04:46:17.560 --> 04:46:19.161
EMPLOYER IT IS MIGHT MY QUESTION
04:46:19.228 --> 04:46:20.563
CENTER CARRIER ARE YOU ASKING A
04:46:20.630 --> 04:46:22.298
QUESTION YES IT IS A QUESTION OR
04:46:22.365 --> 04:46:24.534
OR WOULD YOU PREFER FOR TO
04:46:24.600 --> 04:46:25.868
RESPOND TO THAT AND HER CLOTHES.
04:46:25.935 --> 04:46:26.903
HOWEVER SHE'D LIKE TO DO IT I'M
04:46:26.969 --> 04:46:30.473
I'M I'M OKAY I JUST THAT FOR MY
04:46:30.540 --> 04:46:32.174
OWN SAKE IN TERMS OF TRYING TO
04:46:32.241 --> 04:46:35.144
FIGURE OUT. THANK YOU WHAT I
04:46:35.211 --> 04:46:36.379
THINK YOU HAVE A DID CENTERS ARE
04:46:36.445 --> 04:46:38.347
COVERED- DO YOU HAVE ADDITIONAL
04:46:38.414 --> 04:46:39.515
COMMENTS TO MAKE. NO THAT'S MY
04:46:39.582 --> 04:46:40.550
QUESTION THANK YOU CENTER
04:46:40.616 --> 04:46:42.885
COLORADO'S. SENATE RAZA SINGH NO
04:46:42.952 --> 04:46:44.253
OTHER MICROPHONES- YOU MAY
04:46:44.320 --> 04:46:46.122
CLOSE. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MR
04:46:46.188 --> 04:46:48.791
PRESIDENT- AND PARTIALLY IN IN
04:46:48.858 --> 04:46:51.027
RESPONSE TO THE CENTER OF THIS
04:46:51.093 --> 04:46:53.563
QUESTION. THIS BILL IS NOT ABOUT
04:46:53.629 --> 04:46:56.799
ROUTINE SAFETY VIOLATIONS. THIS
04:46:56.866 --> 04:46:59.268
IS CAL. AS ITS REGULATIONS ON
04:46:59.335 --> 04:47:01.137
NUMEROUS AS YOU MENTIONED AS THE
04:47:01.203 --> 04:47:02.872
SENATOR MENTIONED OF WORKSITE
04:47:02.939 --> 04:47:04.874
ISSUES. THERE'S A PROCESS WHERE
04:47:04.941 --> 04:47:06.776
WORKERS CAN REPORT VIOLATIONS TO
04:47:06.842 --> 04:47:09.178
CAL OSHA. CAL OSHA HAS MONTHS TO
04:47:09.245 --> 04:47:11.080
INVESTIGATE AND DETERMINE IF
04:47:11.147 --> 04:47:12.815
THERE WAS A VIOLATION. THIS BILL
04:47:12.882 --> 04:47:14.784
IS NOT ABOUT ROUTINE SAFETY
04:47:14.850 --> 04:47:17.253
VIOLATIONS. IT IS ABOUT HOW WE
04:47:17.320 --> 04:47:20.222
PROTECT WORKERS. AS EXTREME
04:47:20.289 --> 04:47:22.725
WEATHER EVENTS HAPPEN AND OTHER
04:47:22.792 --> 04:47:25.027
ISSUES OTHER- CONDITIONS
04:47:25.094 --> 04:47:27.096
THREATEN THE WORKSITE. IT'S NOT
04:47:27.163 --> 04:47:28.531
ABOUT OVERRIDING CALLOW SURE
04:47:28.598 --> 04:47:31.100
DUPLICATING A REGULATIONS IT
04:47:31.167 --> 04:47:33.469
SIMPLY SAYS THAT IF THERE IS AN
04:47:33.536 --> 04:47:35.371
EMERGENCY. AND THE WORKER
04:47:35.438 --> 04:47:37.607
REASONABLY BELIEVES THEIR LIFE
04:47:37.673 --> 04:47:39.909
IS IN DANGER IN JEOPARDY. THEY
04:47:39.976 --> 04:47:42.311
CAN LEAVE WITHOUT THE FEAR OF
04:47:42.378 --> 04:47:44.113
RETALIATION AND LOSING THEIR
04:47:44.180 --> 04:47:48.150
JOBS. THAT IS THE FUNDAMENTAL
04:47:48.217 --> 04:47:51.020
GOAL OF THIS. LEGISLATION AND I
04:47:51.087 --> 04:47:52.922
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE.
04:47:52.989 --> 04:47:56.759
THANK YOU SIR DRAWS- SECRETARY
04:47:56.826 --> 04:48:00.529
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN ARCHULETA I
04:48:00.596 --> 04:48:05.201
ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER I
04:48:05.268 --> 04:48:12.475
PORCHES. BRADFORD CABALLERO. OR
04:48:12.541 --> 04:48:18.381
TESTING I DALY NO DODD NOTARIZED
04:48:18.447 --> 04:48:24.754
SO I EGGMAN. LATER NO GONZALEZ I
04:48:24.820 --> 04:48:29.158
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESSEL.
04:48:29.225 --> 04:48:34.997
HURTADO JONES NO KAMLAGER.
04:48:35.064 --> 04:48:39.935
LAYARD I LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE
04:48:40.002 --> 04:48:45.675
MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ NO MAN I
04:48:45.741 --> 04:48:50.379
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF
04:48:50.446 --> 04:48:55.685
BOTH. NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
04:48:55.751 --> 04:49:04.060
ROTH. RUBIO I SKINNER. I STERN
04:49:04.126 --> 04:49:13.769
AYE AMBERG AYE BY CASKEY. WIENER
04:49:13.836 --> 04:49:20.743
MEMBERS. ALLEN FOR JUST BRADFORD
04:49:20.810 --> 04:49:26.582
. CABALLERO EGGMAN I. HERTZBERG
04:49:26.649 --> 04:49:34.657
WESTERN I HER TADO. KAMLAGER.
04:49:34.724 --> 04:49:41.430
ROTH I WHY CASTING WILK. ONE
04:49:41.497 --> 04:49:43.199
LAST TIME PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
04:49:43.265 --> 04:49:48.304
MEMBERS ALLEN I. FOR JUST
04:49:48.370 --> 04:49:53.309
BRADFORD I CABALLERO. HERTZBERG
04:49:53.375 --> 04:49:58.614
FURTADO KAMLAGER AIKAU SKIING
04:49:58.681 --> 04:50:04.920
WILK NO. IS TWENTY FOUR KNOWS
04:50:04.987 --> 04:50:18.667
TEN THE MEASURE PASSES.
04:50:18.734 --> 04:50:19.568
FIFTY ALL RIGHT MEMBERS WE'RE
04:50:19.635 --> 04:50:20.970
GOING TO LIFT THE CALL ON A
04:50:21.036 --> 04:50:22.972
COUPLE BILLS WE'RE GOING TO
04:50:23.038 --> 04:50:31.313
START WITH FILE ITEM FIFTY.
04:50:31.380 --> 04:50:43.025
ALLEN BASED I. FOR JUST. DALLY
04:50:43.092 --> 04:50:50.466
GLAZER. GROVE I HERTZBERG JONES
04:50:50.533 --> 04:51:00.609
I. LIMÓN MELENDEZ NIELSEN. PAN
04:51:00.676 --> 04:51:05.848
PORTANTINO. STERN WHITE HOUSE
04:51:05.915 --> 04:51:08.083
SKI HI PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
04:51:08.150 --> 04:51:10.452
MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME ALLEN.
04:51:10.519 --> 04:51:16.792
GORGEOUS DALLY GLAZER HERTZBERG
04:51:16.859 --> 04:51:24.900
RAMON I MELENDEZ NIELSEN. PAN
04:51:24.967 --> 04:51:29.805
PORTANTINO STERN I TWENTY NINE
04:51:29.872 --> 04:51:31.607
KNOWS ONE THE MEASURE PASSES
04:51:31.674 --> 04:51:34.076
MEMBERS MOVED TO FILE ITEM FORTY
04:51:34.143 --> 04:51:35.678
FIVE MA'AM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
04:51:35.744 --> 04:51:44.086
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. FORTUS
04:51:44.153 --> 04:51:51.126
BRADFORD. DODD HERTZBERG LEYVA.
04:51:51.193 --> 04:51:57.800
NEWMAN PAM ROTH RUBIO WHITE
04:51:57.867 --> 04:52:01.904
HOUSE SKI. PLEASE CALL THE
04:52:01.971 --> 04:52:03.739
ABSENT MEMBERS ARE MORE TIME. OR
04:52:03.806 --> 04:52:09.144
JUST BRADFORD DODD. HERTZBERG
04:52:09.211 --> 04:52:17.453
LEYVA NEWMAN PAN ROTH. RUBIO
04:52:17.519 --> 04:52:22.892
WHITE HOUSE SKI BRADFORD I AS
04:52:22.958 --> 04:52:24.093
TWENTY ONE KNOWS TEN THE MEASURE
04:52:24.159 --> 04:52:26.962
PASSES. MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON
04:52:27.029 --> 04:52:32.534
TO FILE ITEM. FIFTY EIGHT.
04:52:32.601 --> 04:52:34.737
CENTER NUMBER MADAM SECRETARY
04:52:34.803 --> 04:52:37.406
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
04:52:37.473 --> 04:52:39.241
SIXTY BY SENATOR UMBERG AN ACT
04:52:39.308 --> 04:52:40.843
RELATING TO ELECTIONS CENTER
04:52:40.910 --> 04:52:43.245
AMBERG BUT THANK YOU MAN
04:52:43.312 --> 04:52:44.513
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES OF THIS
04:52:44.580 --> 04:52:46.715
BILL SIMPLY PROVIDES FOR
04:52:46.782 --> 04:52:48.417
ADDITIONAL TRANSPARENCY IN
04:52:48.484 --> 04:52:50.819
POLITICAL ADVERTISING- WHAT IT
04:52:50.886 --> 04:52:54.423
DOES IS IT REQUIRES THAT ONLINE
04:52:54.490 --> 04:52:55.925
IMAGE ADVERTISEMENTS PLAYED
04:52:55.991 --> 04:52:58.560
SCHOOL. OF THE BACKGROUND. THE
04:52:58.627 --> 04:53:00.996
WHITE ON PAGE REQUIRE ONLINE
04:53:01.063 --> 04:53:02.564
IMAGE JETS THAT ARE LARGE ENOUGH
04:53:02.631 --> 04:53:04.300
THAT THEY BE LARGE UP TO NAME
04:53:04.366 --> 04:53:06.168
THE COMMITTEE PAYING FOR THE AT
04:53:06.235 --> 04:53:08.704
THIS TOP FUNDER OF FIFTY
04:53:08.771 --> 04:53:12.041
THOUSAND DOLLARS- OR MORE AND IT
04:53:12.107 --> 04:53:13.609
WOULD REQUIRE TELEVISION VIDEO
04:53:13.676 --> 04:53:17.046
ADVERTISERS DISPLAY THE TOP
04:53:17.112 --> 04:53:18.013
THREE FUNDERS OF THE COMMITTEE
04:53:18.080 --> 04:53:21.450
DO. ROUTE BLANK RESULT
04:53:21.517 --> 04:53:23.352
DISTINGUISH THEM THE SAME OF THE
04:53:23.419 --> 04:53:26.255
COMMITTEE. I WILL ALSO- WHEN OF
04:53:26.322 --> 04:53:28.991
PETITIONS BEING CIRCULATED- THAT
04:53:29.058 --> 04:53:31.226
DOESN'T LIST THE TOP FUNDERS ON
04:53:31.293 --> 04:53:34.096
THE PETITION- THAT THE-
04:53:34.163 --> 04:53:36.565
SIGNATURE BOX SAY DON'T SIGN
04:53:36.632 --> 04:53:38.167
UNLESS YOU'VE BEEN SHOWN THIS
04:53:38.233 --> 04:53:40.235
SHEET THAT SHOWS THE TOP
04:53:40.302 --> 04:53:43.038
FUNDRAISER TONIGHT. THE CENTER
04:53:43.105 --> 04:53:45.274
AMBERG DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
04:53:45.341 --> 04:53:49.011
SENATOR WILK. RESIDENTS LAST
04:53:49.078 --> 04:53:51.780
YEAR I SUPPORTED SB SEVEN FIFTY
04:53:51.847 --> 04:53:53.115
TWO FROM THE FIND SENATOR FROM
04:53:53.182 --> 04:53:55.284
SANTA MONICA AND AFTER
04:53:55.351 --> 04:53:57.786
DISCUSSIONS ON THE SENATE FLOOR
04:53:57.853 --> 04:54:01.123
LAST YEAR AND WITH HIS AGREEMENT
04:54:01.190 --> 04:54:02.958
SET TO WORK WITH ME ON JUST A
04:54:03.025 --> 04:54:05.494
MINUTE BY I SUPPORTED BILL. WE
04:54:05.561 --> 04:54:08.464
MAY ASSEMBLY ACTUALLY IS THESE
04:54:08.530 --> 04:54:10.499
APPROPRIATE COMMITTEE. EWING
04:54:10.566 --> 04:54:13.202
THIS VERSION NUMBER DEPARTMENTS
04:54:13.268 --> 04:54:14.636
FROM LAST YEAR ALREADY INCLUDED
04:54:14.703 --> 04:54:16.505
IN THE BILL WHICH I'M VERY
04:54:16.572 --> 04:54:18.440
PLEASED WITH. THROUGH THE
04:54:18.507 --> 04:54:20.843
CHAIRED LIKE TO ASK A QUESTION
04:54:20.909 --> 04:54:23.045
OF THE AUTHOR. THE NUMBER WE TO
04:54:23.112 --> 04:54:25.681
QUESTION. YES I WILL PLEASE
04:54:25.748 --> 04:54:27.349
PROCEED OKAY SO WITH THE OTHER
04:54:27.416 --> 04:54:29.385
BE OPEN TO WORKING WITH MY
04:54:29.451 --> 04:54:30.319
OFFICE ON ADDITIONAL MINUTES
04:54:30.386 --> 04:54:32.287
THAT WITH EIGHT IN COMPLIANCE
04:54:32.354 --> 04:54:34.123
SUCH AS THOSE ON CLARIFICATION
04:54:34.189 --> 04:54:38.260
OF CULT USED IT CODE SECTIONS- I
04:54:38.327 --> 04:54:40.562
AM ALWAYS HAPPY WORK IN THE
04:54:40.629 --> 04:54:42.331
CENTER FROM SANTA CLARITA. WAY
04:54:42.398 --> 04:54:44.266
BACK FOR THAT ANSWER IN WITH
04:54:44.333 --> 04:54:46.668
THAT I WILL BE SUPPORTING- THE
04:54:46.735 --> 04:54:49.338
BILL ON THE FLOOR TODAY THANK
04:54:49.405 --> 04:54:50.272
YOU SIR YEAH. THANK YOU CENTER
04:54:50.339 --> 04:54:51.774
WORK MEMBERS FIRST QUESTION
04:54:51.840 --> 04:54:54.009
ORDER EIGHT SEEING AND HEARING
04:54:54.076 --> 04:54:56.345
MANSER AMBER CHECK TO CLOSE I
04:54:56.412 --> 04:54:57.279
WOULD URGE AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU
04:54:57.346 --> 04:54:59.848
SIR MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
04:54:59.915 --> 04:55:04.787
THE ROLL. ALLEN I ATKINS AYE
04:55:04.853 --> 04:55:09.658
BATES NO BAKER I FORTUS AYE
04:55:09.725 --> 04:55:13.162
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
04:55:13.228 --> 04:55:17.866
PROTESTING AYE DOLLY. DODD I
04:55:17.933 --> 04:55:23.238
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
04:55:23.305 --> 04:55:28.544
GONZALEZ I GROWTH. I BURKE
04:55:28.610 --> 04:55:34.183
WESTERN I HER TADO. I JONES NO
04:55:34.249 --> 04:55:38.520
KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE
04:55:38.587 --> 04:55:43.759
THE MON. I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ
04:55:43.826 --> 04:55:50.332
. MAN I NEWMAN. I NIELSEN NO A
04:55:50.399 --> 04:55:56.638
SHOW OF BOTH. PAN I PORTANTINO I
04:55:56.705 --> 04:56:02.010
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I
04:56:02.077 --> 04:56:05.013
STERN AYE AMBERG I LIKE ASKING
04:56:05.080 --> 04:56:09.151
AYE WIENER AYE WILK. HI PLEASE
04:56:09.218 --> 04:56:12.955
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS. DALLY
04:56:13.021 --> 04:56:18.193
HERTZBERG MELENDEZ. A CHOI BOGUE
04:56:18.260 --> 04:56:22.264
I. THIRTY FOUR KNOWS THREE THE
04:56:22.331 --> 04:56:23.832
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
04:56:23.899 --> 04:56:26.068
MOVING TO A FILE ITEM FIFTY NINE
04:56:26.135 --> 04:56:28.337
SENATOR TO RAZA. M. SECRETARY
04:56:28.403 --> 04:56:31.473
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
04:56:31.540 --> 04:56:32.941
SIXTY FOUR BY SENATOR DORADO AN
04:56:33.008 --> 04:56:34.543
ACT RELATING TO EMPLOYMENT
04:56:34.610 --> 04:56:37.112
CENTER DORADO. THANK YOU MADAM
04:56:37.179 --> 04:56:42.217
PRESIDENT. SB THIRTEEN SIXTY
04:56:42.284 --> 04:56:43.385
FOUR A CREATES A FAIR
04:56:43.452 --> 04:56:45.587
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM FOR THE
04:56:45.654 --> 04:56:48.090
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA'S OWN
04:56:48.157 --> 04:56:51.193
EQUAL PAY FOR EQUAL WORK POLICY
04:56:51.260 --> 04:56:52.594
THE BILL REQUIRES VENDOR
04:56:52.661 --> 04:56:55.931
COMPANIES THAT HAVE ONE OF AN
04:56:55.998 --> 04:56:57.466
ESTIMATED FOUR HUNDRED SIR
04:56:57.533 --> 04:57:00.035
CONTRACT YOU SEE TO PAY THEIR
04:57:00.102 --> 04:57:02.137
COMPANY'S EMPLOYEES WAGES AND
04:57:02.204 --> 04:57:04.873
BENEFITS EQUAL TO WHAT YOU SEE
04:57:04.940 --> 04:57:07.042
PAYS OWN SERVICE WORKERS WHO
04:57:07.109 --> 04:57:09.645
WORK ACTUALLY YOU SEE. THE UC
04:57:09.711 --> 04:57:11.580
CONTRACTUALLY OBLIGATES THESE
04:57:11.647 --> 04:57:13.081
VENDORS TO COMPLY WITH THIS
04:57:13.148 --> 04:57:15.817
POLICY FOR THE MOST PART THEIR
04:57:15.884 --> 04:57:17.452
EFFORTS DO NOT INSURE
04:57:17.519 --> 04:57:19.821
COMPLIANCE. TO ADDRESS THIS
04:57:19.888 --> 04:57:22.024
PROBLEM THIS BILL REQUIRES
04:57:22.090 --> 04:57:24.760
VENDORS TO SUPPLY THE UC AND THE
04:57:24.826 --> 04:57:26.228
APPROPRIATE JOINT LABOR
04:57:26.295 --> 04:57:28.597
MANAGEMENT COMPANY THE BASIC
04:57:28.664 --> 04:57:31.533
PAYROLL INFORMATION NECESSARY TO
04:57:31.600 --> 04:57:34.069
KNOW IF A VENDOR IS A EIGHTEEN
04:57:34.136 --> 04:57:37.439
BY. SEE BILL ALSO THE CARD UNDER
04:57:37.506 --> 04:57:39.908
TO SUPPLY A WRITTEN NOTICE TO
04:57:39.975 --> 04:57:42.211
THEIR EMPLOYEES ABOUT THE
04:57:42.277 --> 04:57:44.379
RELEVANT COMPENSATION EIGHT. AND
04:57:44.446 --> 04:57:47.149
IT WOULD ALLOW CONTACT INFO
04:57:47.216 --> 04:57:50.118
TWENTY ONE UP. TO CURE ANY
04:57:50.185 --> 04:57:53.755
DISCREPANCY BE AFRAID. BECAUSE
04:57:53.822 --> 04:57:55.958
REFUSAL TO COMPLY WITH THIS
04:57:56.024 --> 04:57:58.126
REQUIREMENT WOULD RESULT IN THE
04:57:58.193 --> 04:57:59.995
EMPLOYEES HAVE THE RIGHT TO
04:58:00.062 --> 04:58:02.431
PURSUE RECOVERY OF LOST WAGES
04:58:02.497 --> 04:58:04.900
FROM THE CONTRACTING VENDOR IN
04:58:04.967 --> 04:58:08.337
COURT. AND THE DISQUALIFICATION
04:58:08.403 --> 04:58:10.005
OF A VIOLATING COMPANY FROM
04:58:10.072 --> 04:58:12.307
DOING BUSINESS WITH YOU SEE FOR
04:58:12.374 --> 04:58:14.409
A FIVE YEAR PERIOD THIS BILL
04:58:14.476 --> 04:58:17.079
DOES NOT PROVIDE A RIGHT DO YOU
04:58:17.145 --> 04:58:20.082
SEE. AND VENDORS CAN ONLY BE
04:58:20.148 --> 04:58:22.651
TAKEN TO COURT AFTER FAILING TO
04:58:22.718 --> 04:58:27.155
CURE THE VIOLATIONS RESPECTFULLY
04:58:27.222 --> 04:58:27.923
ASK FOR YOUR- THANK YOU FOR
04:58:27.990 --> 04:58:29.658
DRAWS- MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND
04:58:29.725 --> 04:58:32.928
DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING NONE
04:58:32.995 --> 04:58:33.996
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
04:58:34.062 --> 04:58:40.168
ROLL. ALLEN. ARCHULETA AYE
04:58:40.235 --> 04:58:45.741
ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER. I
04:58:45.807 --> 04:58:50.379
PORCHES NO BRADFORD I HAVE ITEM
04:58:50.445 --> 04:58:55.217
I CORTES E. I. DALY NO DODD NO
04:58:55.284 --> 04:59:00.656
TORONTO I EGGMAN. I GLAZER NOPE
04:59:00.722 --> 04:59:04.926
GONZALEZ I GROW NO HERTZBERG
04:59:04.993 --> 04:59:09.298
WESSEL AYE FURTADO AYE JONES NO
04:59:09.364 --> 04:59:13.869
KAMLAGER I FLARED AYE LEYVA AYE
04:59:13.935 --> 04:59:18.974
THE MON. I MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ NO
04:59:19.041 --> 04:59:24.279
MAN. NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO WHAT
04:59:24.346 --> 04:59:28.517
SHOW OF BOTH. PAN AYE PORTANTINO
04:59:28.583 --> 04:59:36.325
AYE ROTH. I RUBIO. I SKINNER I
04:59:36.391 --> 04:59:40.195
STERN AYE AMBERG AYE ACOSTA AYE
04:59:40.262 --> 04:59:43.632
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL
04:59:43.699 --> 04:59:47.602
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN.
04:59:47.669 --> 04:59:54.076
HERTZBERG MEN I A CHOI BOGUE NO
04:59:54.142 --> 04:59:56.144
. IS TWENTY SEVEN KNOWS ELEVEN
04:59:56.211 --> 04:59:57.779
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS FROM
04:59:57.846 --> 04:59:59.748
GOING O FILE ITEM SIXTY SENATOR
04:59:59.815 --> 05:00:02.517
NEWMAN M. SECRETARY PLEASE READ
05:00:02.584 --> 05:00:04.519
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN SEVENTY
05:00:04.586 --> 05:00:06.221
SEVEN BY SENATOR NEWMAN AN ACT
05:00:06.288 --> 05:00:07.289
RELATING TO TAXATION TO TAKE
05:00:07.356 --> 05:00:08.623
EFFECT IMMEDIATELY TAX LEVY
05:00:08.690 --> 05:00:10.826
CENTER NEWMAN THANK YOU MADAM
05:00:10.892 --> 05:00:14.663
PRESIDENT I RISE TO PRESENT SB
05:00:14.730 --> 05:00:15.530
THIRTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN WHICH
05:00:15.597 --> 05:00:16.131
WILL EXEMPTED TOURNEY'S FEES
05:00:16.198 --> 05:00:17.666
ASSOCIATED WITH THE CONSUMER
05:00:17.733 --> 05:00:19.901
PROTECT EAGLE SETTLE. IN COUNTED
05:00:19.968 --> 05:00:21.703
AGAINST SIX POINT TAXPAYERS
05:00:21.770 --> 05:00:24.373
ADJUSTED GROSS INCOME AS SOME OF
05:00:24.439 --> 05:00:26.241
YOU MAY BE AWARE THROUGH A
05:00:26.308 --> 05:00:27.142
PROCESS CALLED FEE SHIFTING
05:00:27.209 --> 05:00:29.044
CALIFORNIA ALLOWS LAWYERS TO
05:00:29.111 --> 05:00:31.813
REPRESENT CLIENTS IN CONSUMER
05:00:31.880 --> 05:00:34.616
PROTECTION CASES WITHOUT
05:00:34.683 --> 05:00:37.252
CHARGING DIRECTLY FOR THEIR
05:00:37.319 --> 05:00:38.587
LIVES. EIGHT PEOPLE YOU CAN SEE
05:00:38.653 --> 05:00:40.055
PROTECTION SUITS BY REMOVING
05:00:40.122 --> 05:00:41.556
BARRIERS ASSOCIATED WITH HAVING
05:00:41.623 --> 05:00:43.225
A QUALIFIED ATTORNEY REPRESENT
05:00:43.291 --> 05:00:44.993
THEM IN SEEKING REDRESS FOR
05:00:45.060 --> 05:00:46.695
HARMED. IN RECENT YEARS
05:00:46.762 --> 05:00:48.330
COMPANIES ON THE LOSING SIDE OF
05:00:48.397 --> 05:00:49.598
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWSUITS YOU
05:00:49.664 --> 05:00:52.701
MAY PRACTICE OF ISSUING IRIS TEN
05:00:52.768 --> 05:00:53.468
NINETY NINE FORMS TO INDIVIDUALS
05:00:53.535 --> 05:00:55.003
PARTICIPATING. IN CONSUMER
05:00:55.070 --> 05:00:56.738
PROTECT LAWSUIT AND ATTRIBUTING
05:00:56.805 --> 05:00:58.940
ALL OR SOME OF THE ATTORNEYS
05:00:59.007 --> 05:01:00.842
FEES ASSOCIATED WITH THE CASE AS
05:01:00.909 --> 05:01:01.743
PERSONAL INCOME. RECEIVED BY AN
05:01:01.810 --> 05:01:03.512
INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFF. OUT OF
05:01:03.578 --> 05:01:05.213
THESE LEGAL FEES A TRIBUTE TO A
05:01:05.280 --> 05:01:06.148
PLAINTIFF MAY BE LARGE EVEN
05:01:06.214 --> 05:01:08.183
THOUGH THEY THEY THEMSELVES MAY
05:01:08.250 --> 05:01:09.151
NOT HAVE RECEIVED ANY CASH%
05:01:09.217 --> 05:01:11.153
BENEFIT FROM THEM SUCH INFERRED
05:01:11.219 --> 05:01:15.090
FEES CAN ULTIMATELY REPRESENT A
05:01:15.157 --> 05:01:18.326
SUBSTANTIAL TAX LIABILITY TO AN
05:01:18.393 --> 05:01:19.060
- CASES EXCEEDING THE ACTUAL
05:01:19.127 --> 05:01:21.062
VALUE. ANY WAR THAT ARE
05:01:21.129 --> 05:01:22.030
PLAINTIFF MAY HAVE EVENTUALLY
05:01:22.097 --> 05:01:23.498
RECEIVE. ATTORNEY'S FEES
05:01:23.565 --> 05:01:25.367
ATTRIBUTED IS INCOME MAY ALSO
05:01:25.434 --> 05:01:27.102
IMPACTED PLAINTIFFS ELIGIBILITY
05:01:27.169 --> 05:01:28.503
FOR IMPORTANT PROGRAMS LIKE THE
05:01:28.570 --> 05:01:29.738
CALIFORNIA EARNED INCOME TAX
05:01:29.805 --> 05:01:31.673
CREDIT. HOUSING BENEFITS FOR
05:01:31.740 --> 05:01:33.542
EDUCATIONAL BENEFITS IT'S
05:01:33.608 --> 05:01:34.643
IMPORTANT NOTE THAT ATTORNEYS
05:01:34.709 --> 05:01:36.111
WHO OF LITIGATING THESE CASES
05:01:36.178 --> 05:01:37.879
ARE ALSO ISSUED A FORM TEN
05:01:37.946 --> 05:01:39.281
NINETY NINE. FOR THE PAYMENT OF
05:01:39.347 --> 05:01:41.383
THEIR FEES THEREBY RESULTING IN
05:01:41.450 --> 05:01:42.484
THE SAME SETTLEMENT FUNDS BEING
05:01:42.551 --> 05:01:45.053
TAXED NOT ONCE BUT TWICE.
05:01:45.120 --> 05:01:46.388
TREATING ATTORNEYS FEES AS A TAX
05:01:46.455 --> 05:01:47.823
LIABILITY ASSIGNABLE TO A
05:01:47.889 --> 05:01:49.991
PLAINTIFF IN A FEW SHIFTED CASE
05:01:50.058 --> 05:01:51.626
RUNS DIRECTLY COUNTER TO THE
05:01:51.693 --> 05:01:53.094
INTENT OF CALIFORNIA'S EXISTING
05:01:53.161 --> 05:01:54.696
CONSUMER PROTECTION LAWS.
05:01:54.763 --> 05:01:56.932
MOREOVER THE PROSPECT OF SUCH AS
05:01:56.998 --> 05:01:59.568
IN SUCH A SCENARIO IS OFTEN
05:01:59.634 --> 05:02:00.068
LEVERAGED BY CORPORATE
05:02:00.135 --> 05:02:01.703
DEFENDANTS TO DISSUADE CONSUMERS
05:02:01.770 --> 05:02:03.171
FROM MOVING FOR WITH LEGITIMATE
05:02:03.238 --> 05:02:04.773
AND CREDIBLE COMPLAINTS. IF
05:02:04.840 --> 05:02:06.608
YOU'VE RECEIVED A FULL REPORT-
05:02:06.675 --> 05:02:08.176
FROM THE OPPOSITION IT IS
05:02:08.243 --> 05:02:09.945
ACTUALLY THIS STRATEGY IN THAT
05:02:10.011 --> 05:02:13.415
THEY ARE SEEKING TO PRESERVE. SB
05:02:13.482 --> 05:02:14.516
THIRTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN WILL
05:02:14.583 --> 05:02:15.116
EXTEND THE TWO THOUSAND FOUR
05:02:15.183 --> 05:02:16.685
FEDERAL TAX AMENDMENT TO PROVIDE
05:02:16.751 --> 05:02:18.119
AN ABOVE THE LINE DEDUCTION FOR
05:02:18.186 --> 05:02:20.355
FEE AWARDS WERE. IN CONSUMER
05:02:20.422 --> 05:02:21.056
PROTECTION CASES SO THAT
05:02:21.122 --> 05:02:23.258
ATTORNEYS FEES WILL NOT. AGAINST
05:02:23.325 --> 05:02:24.526
AN INDIVIDUAL'S ADJUSTED GROSS
05:02:24.593 --> 05:02:26.428
INCOME ON THEIR STATE TAXES HERE
05:02:26.495 --> 05:02:28.597
IN CALIFORNIA THIS COMMONSENSE
05:02:28.663 --> 05:02:30.732
EXEMPTION WILL RELIEVE CONSUMERS
05:02:30.799 --> 05:02:32.567
TO UNDUE UNREASONABLE AS A
05:02:32.634 --> 05:02:33.635
BURDENS WEBER. ENFORCING
05:02:33.702 --> 05:02:35.604
PROTECTIONS FOR THOSE WHO MAY
05:02:35.670 --> 05:02:37.472
HAVE BEEN INJURED AS A RESULT OF
05:02:37.539 --> 05:02:38.707
A PRODUCT DEFECT OR ILLEGAL
05:02:38.773 --> 05:02:40.675
BUSINESS PRACTICES. I WOULD LIKE
05:02:40.742 --> 05:02:42.010
TO NOTE THAT THE CALIBER.
05:02:42.077 --> 05:02:44.079
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION
05:02:44.145 --> 05:02:45.380
WHICH HAD BEEN LISTED AS OPPOSED
05:02:45.447 --> 05:02:48.350
IS NO LONGER LISTED. I KNOW LONG
05:02:48.416 --> 05:02:50.585
TERM POSITION SB SEVENTY TWO THE
05:02:50.652 --> 05:02:52.220
BILL INTO A PORT CONSUMER
05:02:52.287 --> 05:02:54.122
FEDERATION CAL. AND MANY OTHER
05:02:54.189 --> 05:02:55.657
CONCERT ADVOCATE ORGANIZATIONS I
05:02:55.724 --> 05:02:57.259
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR PRIVATE
05:02:57.325 --> 05:03:03.899
TODAY. THANK YOU SENATOR NEWMAN. ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE.
05:03:03.965 --> 05:03:05.200
SEEING AND HEARING. MA'AM
05:03:05.267 --> 05:03:11.273
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
05:03:11.339 --> 05:03:17.546
NO BACKER I FORTUS. NO BRADFORD
05:03:17.612 --> 05:03:20.882
AYE CABALLERO AYE CORTESE AYE
05:03:20.949 --> 05:03:25.587
DOLLY NO DODD. HI TORONTO I
05:03:25.654 --> 05:03:30.592
EGGMAN I GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
05:03:30.659 --> 05:03:36.932
GROW. NO HERTZBERG WESSEL I
05:03:36.998 --> 05:03:41.570
FURTADO I JONES NO KAMLAGER I
05:03:41.636 --> 05:03:47.042
LAYERED I LEYVA AYE THE MON. I
05:03:47.108 --> 05:03:53.081
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ. NO MAN.
05:03:53.148 --> 05:03:57.819
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
05:03:57.886 --> 05:04:02.791
NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO. I ROTH
05:04:02.857 --> 05:04:10.298
AYE RUBIO. SKINNER I STERN HI
05:04:10.365 --> 05:04:13.702
I'M BURKE I LIKE HOW SPEAK. I
05:04:13.768 --> 05:04:16.838
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL
05:04:16.905 --> 05:04:19.774
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. HERTZBERG
05:04:19.841 --> 05:04:26.781
MEN. RUBIO. TWENTY EIGHT KNOWS
05:04:26.848 --> 05:04:28.450
NINE THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
05:04:28.516 --> 05:04:30.452
FOR ME TO FOLLOW HIM SIXTY THREE
05:04:30.518 --> 05:04:32.721
SENATOR CABALLERO AND SECRETARY
05:04:32.787 --> 05:04:35.290
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL FOURTEEN
05:04:35.357 --> 05:04:37.225
TEN BY SENATOR CABALLERO AN ACT
05:04:37.292 --> 05:04:38.493
RELATING TO ENVIRONMENTAL
05:04:38.560 --> 05:04:41.630
QUALITY CENTER CABALLERO THANK
05:04:41.696 --> 05:04:42.230
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I
05:04:42.297 --> 05:04:46.468
RISE TO PRESENT S. B. TEN. IN
05:04:46.534 --> 05:04:47.402
TWENTY THIRTEEN THE LEGISLATURE
05:04:47.469 --> 05:04:50.805
PASSED IN THE GOVERNOR SIGNED SB
05:04:50.872 --> 05:04:52.574
SEVEN FORTY THREE BY SENATOR
05:04:52.641 --> 05:04:53.508
STEINBERG THAT BILL ESTABLISHED
05:04:53.575 --> 05:04:55.343
THE SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE AND
05:04:55.410 --> 05:04:57.512
JUDICIAL REVIEW PROCESS UNDER
05:04:57.579 --> 05:04:59.314
SYKORA FOR THE CITY OF
05:04:59.381 --> 05:05:01.216
SACRAMENTO TO STREAMLINE THE
05:05:01.282 --> 05:05:03.051
DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTRUCTION. OF
05:05:03.118 --> 05:05:04.419
THE GOLDEN ONE CENTER IN
05:05:04.486 --> 05:05:06.021
DOWNTOWN NOW EVERYBODY'S BEEN TO
05:05:06.087 --> 05:05:07.455
THE GOLDEN ONE CENTER IN
05:05:07.522 --> 05:05:09.891
DOWNTOWN AND YOU KNOW. THAT IF
05:05:09.958 --> 05:05:12.293
THAT CENTER HAD BEEN BUILT UNDER
05:05:12.360 --> 05:05:14.529
THE SEQUEL GUIDELINES IN EFFECT
05:05:14.596 --> 05:05:16.798
AT THAT TIME THAT IT COULD NEVER
05:05:16.865 --> 05:05:18.833
HAVE BEEN BUILT WHY BECAUSE
05:05:18.900 --> 05:05:20.135
THERE'S NO WAY THAT YOU COULD
05:05:20.201 --> 05:05:22.971
HAVE MITIGATED THE TRAFFIC
05:05:23.038 --> 05:05:25.540
IMPACTS. PUTTING A BIG CENTER
05:05:25.607 --> 05:05:29.044
LIKE THAT. YEAH B. TO WHICH
05:05:29.110 --> 05:05:30.345
IMPROVE EVERY SINGLE
05:05:30.412 --> 05:05:31.980
INTERSECTION THE PEOPLE WOULD
05:05:32.047 --> 05:05:34.015
DRIVE INTO TOWN ON AND THAT
05:05:34.082 --> 05:05:36.017
WOULD HAVE MEANT CREATING NEW
05:05:36.084 --> 05:05:38.253
LANES AND NEW TURN LANES AND
05:05:38.319 --> 05:05:41.489
NEWS STOPLIGHTS SO IS IMPERATIVE
05:05:41.556 --> 05:05:42.691
IF YOU WERE GONNA DO INFILL
05:05:42.757 --> 05:05:45.593
CONSTRUCTION THIS MAGNITUDE THAT
05:05:45.660 --> 05:05:47.429
YOU CHANGE THE MEASUREMENT TOOL
05:05:47.495 --> 05:05:50.532
THAT YOU CHANGE HOW YOU EVALUATE
05:05:50.598 --> 05:05:53.334
AND COMPLY WITH SEEK WHAT. SO IT
05:05:53.401 --> 05:05:55.503
WOULD BECAUSE OF SB SEVEN FORTY
05:05:55.570 --> 05:05:58.039
THREE- THAT THE GOVERNOR'S
05:05:58.106 --> 05:06:01.776
OFFICE OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH
05:06:01.843 --> 05:06:04.412
OPR WITH CAST TO DEVELOP. GUIDE
05:06:04.479 --> 05:06:07.148
IS TO REPLACE. YEAH POST TO
05:06:07.215 --> 05:06:08.083
MEASURE THE TRANSPORTATION
05:06:08.149 --> 05:06:11.319
IMPACT AND- WHAT THEY DID IS
05:06:11.386 --> 05:06:13.388
THEY CAME UP WITH A NEW STANDARD
05:06:13.455 --> 05:06:16.391
AND THAT STANDARD BASICALLY IT
05:06:16.458 --> 05:06:17.625
WAS CALLED VEHICLE MILES
05:06:17.692 --> 05:06:20.195
TRAVELED- OPR DEVISED THE
05:06:20.261 --> 05:06:22.330
METHODOLOGY TO SATISFY SEEK
05:06:22.397 --> 05:06:24.899
WEBER INFILL PROJECTS IN TRANSIT
05:06:24.966 --> 05:06:27.168
PRIORITY AREAS I MEAN TO SAY
05:06:27.235 --> 05:06:29.771
THAT AGAIN BECAUSE THIS IS
05:06:29.838 --> 05:06:31.005
IMPORTANT. OPR DEVELOPED AT
05:06:31.072 --> 05:06:33.174
ANOTHER METHODOLOGY TO SATISFY
05:06:33.241 --> 05:06:36.010
SYKORA FOR INFILL PROJECTS IN
05:06:36.077 --> 05:06:38.313
TRANSIT PRIORITY AREAS AND THAT
05:06:38.379 --> 05:06:39.647
WAS CALLED VEHICLE MILES
05:06:39.714 --> 05:06:41.116
TRAVELED NOW I DON'T KNOW ABOUT
05:06:41.182 --> 05:06:43.184
YOU BUT I DON'T HAVE IN MY
05:06:43.251 --> 05:06:46.721
DISTRICT I DO NOT HAVE TRANSIT
05:06:46.788 --> 05:06:49.224
PRIORITY AREAS TRANSIT PRIORITY
05:06:49.290 --> 05:06:52.660
AREAS ARE DOING FINE WITH A-
05:06:52.727 --> 05:06:55.230
INSPUR. SYSTEM THAT STOPS WITHIN
05:06:55.296 --> 05:06:57.932
A HALF MILE EVERY FIFTEEN
05:06:57.999 --> 05:07:01.102
MINUTES SO IN RURAL CALIFORNIA
05:07:01.169 --> 05:07:03.705
YOU DON'T HAVE THESE. TRANSIT
05:07:03.772 --> 05:07:06.107
PRIORITY AREAS AND IN MANY OF
05:07:06.174 --> 05:07:09.911
OUR NON URBANIZED COMMUNITIES IN
05:07:09.978 --> 05:07:12.080
OTHER WORDS THE SUBURBS YOU
05:07:12.147 --> 05:07:15.550
KNOW. PLEASE THESE XIN STOPS-
05:07:15.617 --> 05:07:17.352
I'VE BEEN ADVOCATING IN ARGUING
05:07:17.418 --> 05:07:19.187
FOR YEARS THAT WE OUGHT TO
05:07:19.254 --> 05:07:22.157
IMPROVE OUR OUR TRANSIT OPTIONS
05:07:22.223 --> 05:07:24.092
AND PROVIDE AN ALTERNATIVE. SO
05:07:24.159 --> 05:07:26.661
THAT THE RURAL COMMUNITIES AND
05:07:26.728 --> 05:07:28.730
THE SUBURBS ARE CONNECTED BUT WE
05:07:28.797 --> 05:07:32.000
HAVEN'T GOTTEN THERE WE JUST
05:07:32.066 --> 05:07:33.768
DON'T HAVE THE INFRASTRUCTURE.
05:07:33.835 --> 05:07:35.503
VMT IS A MEASURE HOW MANY
05:07:35.570 --> 05:07:36.805
VEHICLE TRIPS ARE JUST THEIR
05:07:36.871 --> 05:07:39.407
PROSPECT. AND WHAT HAPPENED IS
05:07:39.474 --> 05:07:44.212
THAT- THAT IN TWENTY TWENTY.
05:07:44.279 --> 05:07:46.381
TWENTY TWENTY OPR DECIDED THAT
05:07:46.447 --> 05:07:47.882
WORK WE WERE GOING TO SCRAP THE
05:07:47.949 --> 05:07:50.351
OLD METHOD OF ANALYZING
05:07:50.418 --> 05:07:52.187
TRANSPORTATION AND WE WOULD USE
05:07:52.253 --> 05:07:55.890
VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED INSTEAD
05:07:55.957 --> 05:08:00.528
FOR ALL. SO WHERE DID TWENTY
05:08:00.595 --> 05:08:03.832
TWENTY TWO VMT NOW HAS TO BE
05:08:03.898 --> 05:08:06.334
UTILIZED AS PART OF A SECRET
05:08:06.401 --> 05:08:08.603
ANALYSIS TO ACCOUNT FOR THE
05:08:08.670 --> 05:08:09.804
CONSTRUCTION OF ANY NEW
05:08:09.871 --> 05:08:11.806
DEVELOPMENT REGARDLESS OF WHERE
05:08:11.873 --> 05:08:16.144
IT IS LOCATED AND SO AS WE DEAL
05:08:16.211 --> 05:08:20.048
WITH OUR HOUSING CRISIS. CITIES
05:08:20.114 --> 05:08:22.083
AND COUNTIES ARE NOW HAVING TO
05:08:22.150 --> 05:08:23.985
USE V. M. T. TO DETERMINE HOW
05:08:24.052 --> 05:08:24.853
THEY'RE GOING TO MITIGATE THE
05:08:24.919 --> 05:08:26.988
IMPACTS OF THOSE RESIDENTS THAT
05:08:27.055 --> 05:08:29.123
ARE. THAT ARE LIVING IN THEIR
05:08:29.190 --> 05:08:31.226
COMMUNITIES SO FOR PROJECTS WITH
05:08:31.292 --> 05:08:33.127
IBM TO THE DEVELOPMENT DEVELOPED
05:08:33.194 --> 05:08:35.663
DEVELOPER MAY BE ASSISTED VMT
05:08:35.730 --> 05:08:37.732
MITIGATION FEE ARE BE REQUIRED
05:08:37.799 --> 05:08:40.401
TO BUILD IN. TO BUILD AN
05:08:40.468 --> 05:08:41.603
AMENITIES OR DESIGN FEATURES
05:08:41.669 --> 05:08:44.339
THAT REDUCE THE ANTI BMT SUCH AS
05:08:44.405 --> 05:08:46.274
IMPROVING OR INCREASING ACCESS
05:08:46.341 --> 05:08:48.643
TO TRANSIT THE GREAT GOAL ADDING
05:08:48.710 --> 05:08:50.778
BICYCLE PARKING PROVIDING RIDE
05:08:50.845 --> 05:08:52.780
SHARING OP OPTIONS ARE PROVIDING
05:08:52.847 --> 05:08:55.049
TRANSIT PASSES SO MUCH YOU TO
05:08:55.116 --> 05:08:56.050
THINK ABOUT IT IN RURAL
05:08:56.117 --> 05:08:58.186
COMMUNITIES TO PROVIDE TRANSIT
05:08:58.253 --> 05:09:02.790
PASSES WHEN THERE'S A TRANSIT
05:09:02.857 --> 05:09:06.494
DOESN'T EXIST OR TWO PER. TIONS
05:09:06.561 --> 05:09:08.396
BIGELOW OR HOW TO TAKE THEIR
05:09:08.463 --> 05:09:10.131
KIDS TO SCHOOL IT'S JUST NOT
05:09:10.198 --> 05:09:12.533
IT'S NOT PRACTICAL IT'S NOT
05:09:12.600 --> 05:09:14.802
ACTUALLY EASY TO DO OR TO
05:09:14.869 --> 05:09:17.372
INCREASE ACCESS TO TRANSIT- OR
05:09:17.438 --> 05:09:18.306
TO MAKE IMPROVEMENTS LIKE
05:09:18.373 --> 05:09:20.742
BICYCLE LANES SO MY POINT ABOUT
05:09:20.808 --> 05:09:23.811
ALL OF THIS MEMBERS IS THAT- VMT
05:09:23.878 --> 05:09:26.881
BECOMES A BARRIER TO THE
05:09:26.948 --> 05:09:28.850
DEVELOPMENT THE BUILDING AND
05:09:28.917 --> 05:09:30.251
DEVELOPMENT OF AFFORDABLE
05:09:30.318 --> 05:09:34.188
HOUSING AND IT IT IT IT IT AND
05:09:34.255 --> 05:09:35.757
MANY OF OUR COMMUNITIES IN THE
05:09:35.823 --> 05:09:37.225
CITY OF FRESNO THEY'RE LOOKING
05:09:37.292 --> 05:09:38.459
AT THE EMPTY AND THEIR BATTLE
05:09:38.526 --> 05:09:41.229
ICED THE SITUATION AND IT'S
05:09:41.296 --> 05:09:42.297
GOING TO COST THOUSANDS OF
05:09:42.363 --> 05:09:44.499
DOLLARS. SOME OF. THEM TO COMPLY
05:09:44.565 --> 05:09:45.633
WITH THIS NEW SEQUEL
05:09:45.700 --> 05:09:47.468
REQUIREMENT. AND TO HIGHLIGHT
05:09:47.535 --> 05:09:49.437
HOW EXTREME IMPLEMENTING VMT CAN
05:09:49.504 --> 05:09:51.906
BE. A PROPOSED BMT MITIGATION
05:09:51.973 --> 05:09:53.875
FEE RANGE FROM FIFTY THOUSAND
05:09:53.942 --> 05:09:56.711
DOLLARS PER UNIT TO TWO MILLION
05:09:56.778 --> 05:09:58.446
DOLLARS. IN A RECENT HOUSING
05:09:58.513 --> 05:10:00.515
FOR. SAN DIEGO COUNTY AND SO
05:10:00.581 --> 05:10:02.884
THIS PARTICULAR PROJECT FACE
05:10:02.951 --> 05:10:04.252
CONSIDERABLE UPPER OPPOSITION
05:10:04.319 --> 05:10:06.187
HASN'T BEEN IMPROVED BUT IT'S A
05:10:06.254 --> 05:10:07.322
CLEAR EXAMPLE. OF THE
05:10:07.388 --> 05:10:09.190
CONSEQUENCES OF WHAT WE MAY SEE
05:10:09.257 --> 05:10:11.125
INTO THE FUTURE CALIFORNIA'S
05:10:11.192 --> 05:10:12.794
HOUSING CRISIS IS NOT ONLY A
05:10:12.860 --> 05:10:14.062
SUPPLY ISSUE BUT IT'S AN
05:10:14.128 --> 05:10:15.964
AFFORDABILITY ISSUE. AS THE
05:10:16.030 --> 05:10:19.467
MEDIAN HOME PRICE IN THE STATE
05:10:19.534 --> 05:10:21.069
CONTINUES TO SOAR MANY FAMILIES
05:10:21.135 --> 05:10:23.638
ARE FORCED TO BUY. BURBS RURAL.
05:10:23.705 --> 05:10:24.939
STATE DEFINED HOUSING THAT FITS
05:10:25.006 --> 05:10:26.174
THEIR BUDGET WE'RE SEEING THIS
05:10:26.240 --> 05:10:28.242
IN IN MY DISTRICT WHERE PEOPLE
05:10:28.309 --> 05:10:31.579
ARE COMING FROM- BAY AREA CITIES
05:10:31.646 --> 05:10:33.081
THAT HAVE BECOME BECOME VERY
05:10:33.147 --> 05:10:34.349
UNAFFORDABLE AND NOW ARE MOVING
05:10:34.415 --> 05:10:36.150
INTO THE- CENTRAL VALLEY AND
05:10:36.217 --> 05:10:38.419
INTO THE CENTRAL COAST AREA. AND
05:10:38.486 --> 05:10:41.522
THE ABILITY FOR THEM TO AFFORD A
05:10:41.589 --> 05:10:42.790
HOUSE BECOMES EVEN MORE
05:10:42.857 --> 05:10:46.661
DIFFICULT WITH BMT- SO WE'RE
05:10:46.728 --> 05:10:48.997
LAYING THIS V. M. T. ON TOP OF
05:10:49.063 --> 05:10:52.300
AN INEQUALITY SYSTEM OF HOUSING-
05:10:52.367 --> 05:10:55.937
IN OUR COMMUNITIES. VMT WILL
05:10:56.004 --> 05:10:57.538
DISCOURAGE THE MUCH NEEDED
05:10:57.605 --> 05:10:59.507
HOUSING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
05:10:59.574 --> 05:11:02.543
. AND CITY. WHY FIVE THIS BILL
05:11:02.610 --> 05:11:03.845
AMENDMENTS TAKEN COMMITTEE
05:11:03.911 --> 05:11:05.580
SIGNIFICANTLY CHANGE THE BILL
05:11:05.646 --> 05:11:07.148
AND INSTEAD OF LIMITING THE
05:11:07.215 --> 05:11:09.417
EMPTIES APPLICATION WHICH IS WAS
05:11:09.484 --> 05:11:11.252
THE ORIGINAL INTENT OF THE BILL
05:11:11.319 --> 05:11:12.954
TO TRANSIT PRIORITY AREAS THE
05:11:13.021 --> 05:11:14.122
BILL PASSED THE GOVERNOR'S
05:11:14.188 --> 05:11:15.656
OFFICE OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH
05:11:15.723 --> 05:11:17.025
WITH CONDUCTING A STUDY OF THE
05:11:17.091 --> 05:11:18.426
IMPLEMENTATION AND IMPACT TO BE
05:11:18.493 --> 05:11:20.328
A VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED. IN
05:11:20.395 --> 05:11:22.230
ADDITION IT CREATES A GRANT
05:11:22.296 --> 05:11:23.498
PROGRAM TO FACILITATE THE
05:11:23.564 --> 05:11:25.800
IMPLEMENTATION THE BNT BY LOCAL
05:11:25.867 --> 05:11:27.201
JURISDICTIONS TO CONDUCT THEIR
05:11:27.268 --> 05:11:29.037
OWN REGIONAL ANALYSIS AND
05:11:29.103 --> 05:11:30.338
DETERMINE IF THERE'S OTHER
05:11:30.405 --> 05:11:34.008
MEASURES THAT THEY CAN USE- TWO
05:11:34.075 --> 05:11:36.144
METERS SEQUEL OBLIGATION DESPITE
05:11:36.210 --> 05:11:37.512
THE FACT THAT THEY'RE UNDER
05:11:37.578 --> 05:11:39.614
RESOURCE SO- I WANTED TO MAKE
05:11:39.680 --> 05:11:41.315
SURE TO THE SENATORS FROM
05:11:41.382 --> 05:11:42.650
RIVERSIDE IN SANTA MONICA
05:11:42.717 --> 05:11:45.353
FURTHER COLLABORATE ON THIS
05:11:45.420 --> 05:11:46.954
ISSUE. TO CONTINUING THE DISK.
05:11:47.021 --> 05:11:49.424
AND I WANT TO WORK TO CONTINUE
05:11:49.490 --> 05:11:50.224
TO DISCUSS THIS WITH THE
05:11:50.291 --> 05:11:51.392
STAKEHOLDERS BECAUSE THE BOTTOM
05:11:51.459 --> 05:11:56.931
LINE IS THAT- THAT. DMT IS- IS
05:11:56.998 --> 05:11:58.066
REALLY KILLING THE HOUSING
05:11:58.132 --> 05:12:00.168
DEVELOPMENT IN MY COMMUNITY AND
05:12:00.234 --> 05:12:01.335
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
05:12:01.402 --> 05:12:02.603
VOTE. THANK YOU SENATOR
05:12:02.670 --> 05:12:04.739
CABALLERO DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
05:12:04.806 --> 05:12:08.042
SENATOR ROTH. THANK YOU MADAM
05:12:08.109 --> 05:12:09.544
PRESIDENT I APOLOGIZE I REALIZE
05:12:09.610 --> 05:12:11.879
THIS IS A SUPPORT SUPPORT BILL
05:12:11.946 --> 05:12:13.114
AND I'M USUALLY THE ONE SIT
05:12:13.181 --> 05:12:14.315
AROUND QUESTIONS FOR THE SIZING
05:12:14.382 --> 05:12:16.417
FOLKS FOR TALKING TOO MUCH BUT
05:12:16.484 --> 05:12:17.518
THE- THIS IS A PARTICULARLY
05:12:17.585 --> 05:12:19.087
IMPORTANT ISSUE TO THOSE OF US
05:12:19.153 --> 05:12:21.389
IN INLAND CALIFORNIA I WANT TO
05:12:21.456 --> 05:12:23.458
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR PURSUING.
05:12:23.524 --> 05:12:24.859
THIS BILL I LOOK FORWARD TO THE
05:12:24.926 --> 05:12:27.428
STUDY AND I LOOK FORWARD TO WHAT
05:12:27.495 --> 05:12:29.664
I HOPE COMES OUT OF THIS STUDY.
05:12:29.730 --> 05:12:31.866
YOU KNOW WE HAVE ARENA
05:12:31.933 --> 05:12:34.068
ALLOCATION SYSTEM IN THE STATE.
05:12:34.135 --> 05:12:35.203
AND THOSE OF US IN INLAND
05:12:35.269 --> 05:12:36.637
CALIFORNIA NO THIS WELL BECAUSE
05:12:36.704 --> 05:12:38.973
THE REALLOCATION AT LEAST IN THE
05:12:39.040 --> 05:12:40.675
PAST AND CONTINUING SEEMS TO
05:12:40.741 --> 05:12:42.977
PUSH HOUSING ALLOCATIONS TO THE
05:12:43.044 --> 05:12:45.113
INLAND AREAS OF THE STATE ONE
05:12:45.179 --> 05:12:46.080
BECAUSE WE HAVE A LAND INTO
05:12:46.147 --> 05:12:47.982
BECAUSE HOUSING AT LEAST IN THE
05:12:48.049 --> 05:12:51.853
PAST HAS BEEN. LESS EXPENSIVE.
05:12:51.919 --> 05:12:55.056
WE HAVE OF A GOVERNMENT PROGRAM
05:12:55.123 --> 05:12:57.158
SEVERAL OF THEM IN THE STATE OF
05:12:57.225 --> 05:12:58.025
CALIFORNIA TO INCENTIVIZE JOB
05:12:58.092 --> 05:13:00.661
CREATION. BOTH RECRUITING
05:13:00.728 --> 05:13:02.363
INDUSTRY AND JOBS INTO
05:13:02.430 --> 05:13:04.332
CALIFORNIA FROM OTHER STATES AND
05:13:04.398 --> 05:13:06.000
TO INCENTIVIZE EMPLOYERS IN THE
05:13:06.067 --> 05:13:08.035
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. TO EXPAND
05:13:08.102 --> 05:13:10.571
THEIR OPERATIONS HERE ADDING
05:13:10.638 --> 05:13:13.374
ADDITIONAL WORKERS. WHEN WE DO
05:13:13.441 --> 05:13:15.843
THAT HOWEVER WE DO NOT REQUIRE
05:13:15.910 --> 05:13:17.845
THAT THOSE JURISDICTIONS IT GAIN
05:13:17.912 --> 05:13:19.247
THE ADDITIONAL COMPANIES WITH A
05:13:19.313 --> 05:13:21.349
NEW JOB THROUGH EXPANSION TO
05:13:21.415 --> 05:13:23.017
CERTIFY THAT THEY EITHER HAVE OR
05:13:23.084 --> 05:13:25.153
WILL BUILD. AFFORDABLE WORKING
05:13:25.219 --> 05:13:26.921
HOUSING IN THEIR COMMUNITIES
05:13:26.988 --> 05:13:29.857
THUS THE REALLOCATION AND THOSE
05:13:29.924 --> 05:13:31.659
THOSE OF US IN INLAND CALIFORNIA
05:13:31.726 --> 05:13:33.027
. BUILDING HOUSING FOR THE
05:13:33.094 --> 05:13:35.062
WORKERS IN OTHER PARTS OF THE
05:13:35.129 --> 05:13:36.664
STATE WE HAVE A SUSTAINABLE
05:13:36.731 --> 05:13:38.399
COMMUNITY SERIES OF STATUES
05:13:38.466 --> 05:13:40.968
STATUTES IN THE STATE. FULLY
05:13:41.035 --> 05:13:43.738
SUPPORT BUT THOSE SUSTAINABLE
05:13:43.804 --> 05:13:45.706
COMMUNITY EFFORTS RESTRICT OR IN
05:13:45.773 --> 05:13:47.675
SOME CASES PROHIBIT
05:13:47.742 --> 05:13:49.610
TRANSPORTATION PROJECTS
05:13:49.677 --> 05:13:51.112
CERTAINLY CAPACITY BUILDING
05:13:51.179 --> 05:13:53.981
PROJECTS BECAUSE WHY THOSE
05:13:54.048 --> 05:13:56.951
PROJECTS INCREASE IN MANY CASES
05:13:57.018 --> 05:13:59.320
VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED. SO THINK
05:13:59.387 --> 05:14:01.322
ABOUT IT FOR THOSE IN OF THE US
05:14:01.389 --> 05:14:03.724
IN THE INLAND PARTS THOSE OF US
05:14:03.791 --> 05:14:04.992
IN THE IN IN PARTS OF THE STATE
05:14:05.059 --> 05:14:07.028
NORTH CENTRAL AND CERTAINLY
05:14:07.094 --> 05:14:07.762
SOUTH WE BUILD HOUSING FOR
05:14:07.828 --> 05:14:09.397
WORKERS WHO WORK IN OTHER PARTS
05:14:09.463 --> 05:14:11.332
OF THE STATE AND OUR STATE
05:14:11.399 --> 05:14:13.067
POLICIES RESTRICT TRANSPORTATION
05:14:13.134 --> 05:14:15.503
PROJECTS THE DEBT CAPACITY TO
05:14:15.570 --> 05:14:18.739
ALLOW US TO GET THE WORKERS FROM
05:14:18.806 --> 05:14:20.274
THOSE HOUSES TO THE JOBS THAT WE
05:14:20.341 --> 05:14:22.210
PAY TO LOCATE IN THE STATE. THIS
05:14:22.276 --> 05:14:24.412
HAS TO BE CHANGED. AGAIN THE
05:14:24.478 --> 05:14:27.381
AUTHOR. AND MY COLLEAGUE FROM
05:14:27.448 --> 05:14:28.783
SANTA MONICA FOR PUSHING THIS
05:14:28.849 --> 05:14:30.051
BILL FOR THAT LOOK FORWARD TO
05:14:30.117 --> 05:14:32.653
THE RESULTS OF THE STUDY AND I
05:14:32.720 --> 05:14:33.287
CERTAINLY LOOK FORWARD. TO WHAT
05:14:33.354 --> 05:14:34.488
FOLLOWS FROM THIS STUDY THANK
05:14:34.555 --> 05:14:36.524
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT. THANK YOU
05:14:36.591 --> 05:14:38.359
SAID A ROTH MEMBERS FURTHER
05:14:38.426 --> 05:14:40.094
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
05:14:40.161 --> 05:14:41.429
HEARING TO ANSWER RECOVERY-
05:14:41.495 --> 05:14:44.432
PLEASE CLOSE. RESPECTFULLY ASK
05:14:44.498 --> 05:14:45.633
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
05:14:45.700 --> 05:14:48.636
MA'AM. MEMBERS THIS BILL.
05:14:48.703 --> 05:14:51.639
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS CONSENT
05:14:51.706 --> 05:14:54.041
OUR FIRST ONE OF THE DAY IS
05:14:54.108 --> 05:14:56.177
THERE ANY OBJECTION. SEEING AND
05:14:56.244 --> 05:14:58.879
HEARING NONE FIVE THIRTY NINE NO
05:14:58.946 --> 05:15:00.514
ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
05:15:00.581 --> 05:15:02.016
WE ARE NOW MOVING ON TO FILE
05:15:02.083 --> 05:15:03.618
ITEM SIXTY FIVE SENATOR
05:15:03.684 --> 05:15:05.886
CABALLERO MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
05:15:05.953 --> 05:15:08.522
READ. SENATE BILL FOURTEEN FORTY
05:15:08.589 --> 05:15:10.224
NINE BY SENATOR CABALLERO AN ACT
05:15:10.291 --> 05:15:11.726
RELATING TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT
05:15:11.792 --> 05:15:13.728
CENTER CABALLERO THANK YOU MADAM
05:15:13.794 --> 05:15:15.463
PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS I RISE
05:15:15.529 --> 05:15:18.666
TODAY TO PRESENT SB FOURTEEN
05:15:18.733 --> 05:15:19.900
FORTY NINE. WHICH IS THE AN
05:15:19.967 --> 05:15:21.902
INCORPORATED AREA ANNEXATION
05:15:21.969 --> 05:15:25.206
INCENTIVE PROGRAM SO IN A IN A
05:15:25.273 --> 05:15:28.809
NUTSHELL. PRIOR TO LASKO BEING
05:15:28.876 --> 05:15:32.380
ORGANIZED IN AND SET UP. MANY OF
05:15:32.446 --> 05:15:35.583
THE CITY'S WOULD GROW AND GROW
05:15:35.650 --> 05:15:36.717
IN THE DIRECTION OF UNKNOWN
05:15:36.784 --> 05:15:38.853
UNINCORPORATED AREA AND INSTEAD
05:15:38.919 --> 05:15:41.856
OF ANNEXING IT THEY JUMP OVER IT
05:15:41.922 --> 05:15:43.991
. AND BUILD A CITY AND
05:15:44.058 --> 05:15:45.559
SURROUNDING THE INCORPORATED
05:15:45.626 --> 05:15:47.695
AREA THE AN INCORPORATED AREA IT
05:15:47.762 --> 05:15:49.764
WAS BUILT WITHOUT CURBS GUTTERS
05:15:49.830 --> 05:15:53.000
SIDEWALKS SEWERS AND- MANY MANY
05:15:53.067 --> 05:15:55.469
CASES WATER SYSTEMS THEY WERE ON
05:15:55.536 --> 05:16:00.374
WELLS. MANY OF THOSE. OKAY ARE.
05:16:00.441 --> 05:16:04.312
DISADVANTAGE BECAUSE WITHOUT
05:16:04.378 --> 05:16:06.580
THAT INFRASTRUCTURE THEY FLOOD
05:16:06.647 --> 05:16:10.184
WHEN IT RAINS AND THEY HAVE FROM
05:16:10.251 --> 05:16:12.353
THEIR THEY'RE NOT HOOKED UP TO A
05:16:12.420 --> 05:16:14.288
SEWER AND EITHER ON WELLS WHICH
05:16:14.355 --> 05:16:17.091
ARE GOING DRY. WITH THIS BILL
05:16:17.158 --> 05:16:18.292
WOULD DO IS SET UP AN INCENTIVE
05:16:18.359 --> 05:16:20.294
PROGRAMS THAT WOULD ENCOURAGE
05:16:20.361 --> 05:16:22.463
THE CITIES AND THE OUNTIES TO
05:16:22.530 --> 05:16:25.066
ALLOW ANNEXATION OF THESE AREAS.
05:16:25.132 --> 05:16:26.934
AND INSTALL THE CURBS GUTTERS
05:16:27.001 --> 05:16:29.704
SIDEWALKS SEWER. AND WATER
05:16:29.770 --> 05:16:32.406
SERVICE TO THE RESIDENTS IT
05:16:32.473 --> 05:16:34.709
WOULD FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE THE
05:16:34.775 --> 05:16:37.845
LIGHTS PEOPLE THAT ARE LIVING IN
05:16:37.912 --> 05:16:39.413
VERY VERY UNDER SERVED
05:16:39.480 --> 05:16:41.215
COMMUNITIES AND I RESPECT. YOUR
05:16:41.282 --> 05:16:43.317
AYE BUT THANK YOU CENTER WHERE
05:16:43.384 --> 05:16:45.453
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
05:16:45.519 --> 05:16:46.821
SEEING AND HEARING THEM MEMBERS
05:16:46.887 --> 05:16:48.522
HAS ALSO CALLED FOR A UNANIMOUS
05:16:48.589 --> 05:16:51.425
ROLL CALL IS THERE ANY
05:16:51.492 --> 05:16:52.460
OBJECTION. SEEING AND HEARING
05:16:52.526 --> 05:16:55.062
NONE IS THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
05:16:55.129 --> 05:16:58.532
MEASURE PASSED THIS IS A BY THE
05:16:58.599 --> 05:17:02.336
LAST. TIME FILE ITEM SIX SENATOR
05:17:02.403 --> 05:17:05.072
PER MAN SIX. PLEASE READ SENATE
05:17:05.139 --> 05:17:06.974
BILL FOURTEEN FIFTY SEVEN BY
05:17:07.041 --> 05:17:08.242
SENATOR HERTZBERG AN ACT
05:17:08.309 --> 05:17:09.810
RELATING TO HOUSING BY PROVIDING
05:17:09.877 --> 05:17:11.178
THE FUNDS NECESSARY THEREFORE
05:17:11.245 --> 05:17:12.380
THROUGH AN ELECTION FOR THE
05:17:12.446 --> 05:17:14.148
ISSUANCE. AND SALE OF BONDS OF
05:17:14.215 --> 05:17:15.416
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND FOR
05:17:15.483 --> 05:17:16.917
THE HANDLING AND DISPOSITIONS OF
05:17:16.984 --> 05:17:19.353
THOSE FUNDS THAT ACCORDING THE
05:17:19.420 --> 05:17:20.521
URGENCY THERE OF SIGNIFICANTLY.
05:17:20.588 --> 05:17:22.790
SENATOR PORTANTINO THANK YOU HI
05:17:22.857 --> 05:17:24.925
SEAN THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
05:17:24.992 --> 05:17:27.995
MEMBERS I RISE ON BEHALF OF. MY
05:17:28.062 --> 05:17:30.097
COLLEAGUE SENATOR HERTZBERG TO
05:17:30.164 --> 05:17:32.166
PRESENT THE BILL JOINTLY THAT WE
05:17:32.233 --> 05:17:34.702
ARE JOINTLY AUTHORED SB FOURTEEN
05:17:34.769 --> 05:17:36.270
FIFTY SEVEN. WE KNOW THAT
05:17:36.337 --> 05:17:37.838
HOMEOWNERSHIP BENEFITS ARE
05:17:37.905 --> 05:17:39.774
INDISPUTABLE. AND LEAD TO
05:17:39.840 --> 05:17:41.208
MEASURABLE IMPROVEMENTS IN
05:17:41.275 --> 05:17:43.244
HEALTH EDUCATION AND SECURITY.
05:17:43.310 --> 05:17:44.845
THAT OLD SAYING HOME IS WHERE
05:17:44.912 --> 05:17:48.582
THE HEART IS ALSO HOME WHERE THE
05:17:48.649 --> 05:17:50.251
WEALTH IS. BUILDING EQUITY
05:17:50.317 --> 05:17:52.086
ABSENT WITH UPWARD MOBILITY IT'S
05:17:52.153 --> 05:17:54.655
CLEAR GENERATION- AFTER
05:17:54.722 --> 05:17:56.724
GENERATION HAS EXPERIENCED THAT.
05:17:56.791 --> 05:17:58.259
BUT TODAY IT'S MORE CHALLENGING
05:17:58.325 --> 05:18:00.494
ESCALATING HOME PRICES SEVERE
05:18:00.561 --> 05:18:01.796
PRODUCTION SHORTAGES AND
05:18:01.862 --> 05:18:03.831
GENERATIONAL BARRIERS CAUSED BY
05:18:03.898 --> 05:18:05.800
SYSTEM SYSTEMATIC ECONOMIC
05:18:05.866 --> 05:18:08.636
INEQUITY ARE SQUEEZING MANY
05:18:08.702 --> 05:18:09.637
ASPIRING HOMEOWNERS OUT OF THE
05:18:09.703 --> 05:18:11.439
MARKET. ADDING FUEL TO THIS
05:18:11.505 --> 05:18:13.407
RAGING FIRE THE WORST INFLATION
05:18:13.474 --> 05:18:14.542
RATES OF THE TWENTY FIRST
05:18:14.608 --> 05:18:16.544
CENTURY MAKING IT EVEN MORE
05:18:16.610 --> 05:18:17.912
DIFFICULT FOR THOSE GRAPPLING
05:18:17.978 --> 05:18:19.547
WITH RISING GAS COSTS AND
05:18:19.613 --> 05:18:21.248
BALLOONING GROCERY BILLS TO
05:18:21.315 --> 05:18:23.117
BECOME HOMEOWNERS. THE DATA
05:18:23.184 --> 05:18:25.820
SPEAKS FOR ITSELF ONE IN FIVE
05:18:25.886 --> 05:18:27.221
CALIFORNIA HOUSEHOLDS SPENDS
05:18:27.288 --> 05:18:30.491
HALF OR MORE OF THEIR INCOME ON
05:18:30.558 --> 05:18:33.060
HOUSING. THE MEDIAN COST OF HOME
05:18:33.127 --> 05:18:35.362
IS NOW IN EXCESS OF SEVEN
05:18:35.429 --> 05:18:36.764
HUNDRED AND FIFTY THOUSAND
05:18:36.831 --> 05:18:38.699
DOLLARS MORE THAN TWO TIMES THE
05:18:38.766 --> 05:18:42.837
NATIONAL AVERAGE AND THE STATE
05:18:42.903 --> 05:18:44.972
RANKS FORTY NINTH IN THE NATION
05:18:45.039 --> 05:18:47.842
FOR HOME OWNERSHIP. FIFTY AS A
05:18:47.908 --> 05:18:49.677
RESULT ANY RENTERS OF ALL
05:18:49.743 --> 05:18:51.312
INCOME LEVELS BUT ESPECIALLY
05:18:51.378 --> 05:18:53.314
THOSE OF LOW AND MODERATE INCOME
05:18:53.380 --> 05:18:54.982
VIEW HOMEOWNERSHIP AS AN
05:18:55.049 --> 05:18:57.852
UNATTAINABLE GOAL THIS ONE'S
05:18:57.918 --> 05:18:59.386
STANDARD BUILD UP OF A
05:18:59.453 --> 05:19:01.322
CONVENTIONAL DOWN PAYMENT OF 20%
05:19:01.388 --> 05:19:03.724
OF A HOME PRICE IS NOW PLAINLY
05:19:03.791 --> 05:19:05.292
UNREALISTIC FOR MANY
05:19:05.359 --> 05:19:07.161
CALIFORNIANS WE HAVE A
05:19:07.228 --> 05:19:09.230
RESPONSIBILITY TO CREATE MORE
05:19:09.296 --> 05:19:10.731
OPPORTUNITIES FOR FIRST TIME AND
05:19:10.798 --> 05:19:13.033
OFTEN LEFT BEHIND HOMEOWNERS WHO
05:19:13.100 --> 05:19:14.802
PURCHASED A HOME THRIVE IN THE
05:19:14.869 --> 05:19:16.337
MIDDLE CLASS AND BUILD
05:19:16.403 --> 05:19:20.441
GENERATIONAL WEALTH THIS CANNOT
05:19:20.508 --> 05:19:22.142
BE ACCOMPLISHED WITHOUT
05:19:22.209 --> 05:19:24.545
ADDRESSING THE SEVERE LACK OF.
05:19:24.612 --> 05:19:26.747
IN ITS FUEL THIS CALIFORNIA
05:19:26.814 --> 05:19:28.582
PRODUCES FEWER HOUSING UNITS PER
05:19:28.649 --> 05:19:31.285
CAPITA THAN ANY OTHER STATE
05:19:31.352 --> 05:19:34.889
OTHER THAN UTAH THAT IS WHERE SB
05:19:34.955 --> 05:19:36.891
FOURTEEN FIFTY SEVEN COMES IN
05:19:36.957 --> 05:19:38.893
THE MEASURE BEFORE YOU TODAY IS
05:19:38.959 --> 05:19:40.461
A HOMEOWNERSHIP PRODUK RESULTS
05:19:40.528 --> 05:19:43.097
SB FOURTEEN SEVEN PROPOSES TO
05:19:43.163 --> 05:19:44.899
PLACE A TWENTY FIVE BILLION
05:19:44.965 --> 05:19:47.535
DOLLAR VOTER APPROVED GENERAL
05:19:47.601 --> 05:19:51.038
OBLIGATION BOND ON THE NOVEMBER
05:19:51.105 --> 05:19:52.206
TWENTY TWO TWENTY THREE TO ABOUT
05:19:52.273 --> 05:19:53.674
TO FINANCE HOMEOWNERSHIP
05:19:53.741 --> 05:19:58.212
OPPORTUNITIES AND PROMOTE NEW
05:19:58.279 --> 05:19:59.747
HOMEOWNERSHIP CONSTRUCTION SB
05:19:59.813 --> 05:20:02.550
FOUR. THE SEVEN. CREATE
05:20:02.616 --> 05:20:05.352
FINANCING PROGRAMS ONE TO
05:20:05.419 --> 05:20:06.987
PROVIDE DOWN PAYMENT ASSISTANCE
05:20:07.054 --> 05:20:08.489
TO WOULD BE HOMEOWNERS SQUEEZED
05:20:08.556 --> 05:20:11.091
OUT BY THE INSANE MARKET AND TO
05:20:11.158 --> 05:20:13.360
ANOTHER TO PROVIDE
05:20:13.427 --> 05:20:15.062
INFRASTRUCTURE LOANS FOR UP
05:20:15.129 --> 05:20:18.933
FRONT. COST IMPORTANTLY SB
05:20:18.999 --> 05:20:20.034
FOURTEEN FIFTY SEVEN PROPOSES TO
05:20:20.100 --> 05:20:22.136
USE INVESTOR MONEY TO BUILD NEW
05:20:22.202 --> 05:20:25.706
HOUSING NOT TAXPAYER FUNDS THE
05:20:25.773 --> 05:20:28.309
USE OF BOND FUNDS INCH. RIM IS
05:20:28.375 --> 05:20:29.977
BACKED BY THE FULL FAITH AND
05:20:30.044 --> 05:20:32.646
CREDIT OF THE STATE AND WILL BE
05:20:32.713 --> 05:20:34.615
SELF LIQUIDATING THIS MEANS THAT
05:20:34.682 --> 05:20:36.917
THE PROCEEDS SERVICE FROM THE
05:20:36.984 --> 05:20:38.152
LOAN REPAYMENTS WILL BE
05:20:38.218 --> 05:20:40.254
SUFFICIENT IN OVERTIME TO RETIRE
05:20:40.321 --> 05:20:42.423
THE DEBT IN FULL AND WITH NO
05:20:42.489 --> 05:20:48.929
MEANINGFUL RISK LOSS TO THE
05:20:48.996 --> 05:20:57.571
STATE'S GENERAL FUND FOR OUR.
05:20:57.638 --> 05:20:58.839
INTEREST RATE ON A FIRST
05:20:58.906 --> 05:21:00.541
MORTGAGE THIS IS USUALLY
05:21:00.608 --> 05:21:02.743
IMPORTANT FOR HOME BUYERS THE
05:21:02.810 --> 05:21:04.545
BILL ALSO INCLUDES MODERN ZONING
05:21:04.612 --> 05:21:06.180
IN STREAMLINING PROVISIONS AS
05:21:06.246 --> 05:21:07.448
WELL AS IMPORTANT LABOR
05:21:07.514 --> 05:21:09.550
STANDARDS TO ENABLE HOMEBUILDERS
05:21:09.617 --> 05:21:11.352
TO SELL MORE NEW ENTRY LEVEL
05:21:11.418 --> 05:21:13.120
HOMES AT PRICES THAT ARE
05:21:13.187 --> 05:21:15.322
ATTAINABLE PERSPIRING HOMEOWNERS
05:21:15.389 --> 05:21:16.924
SQUEEZED OUT OF THE CURRENT
05:21:16.991 --> 05:21:19.159
MARKET. ITS CAREFULLY BALANCED
05:21:19.226 --> 05:21:21.929
AGAIN I COMMEND. OUR COLLEAGUE
05:21:21.996 --> 05:21:24.098
WHO'S NOT HERE SENATOR HERTZBERG
05:21:24.164 --> 05:21:25.399
FOR BRINGING THIS IDEA TO MY
05:21:25.466 --> 05:21:27.434
ATTENTION AND WE JOINTLY
05:21:27.501 --> 05:21:29.503
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE
05:21:29.570 --> 05:21:30.638
. THANK YOU CENTER PORTANTINO
05:21:30.704 --> 05:21:33.674
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND OR DEBATE
05:21:33.741 --> 05:21:37.745
. CENTER MELINDA'S. THANK YOU
05:21:37.811 --> 05:21:40.714
MADAM PRESIDENT- YOU KNOW I
05:21:40.781 --> 05:21:43.784
APPRECIATE THAT THE SENATORS
05:21:43.851 --> 05:21:46.353
RECOGNIZE THAT WE HAVE A HOUSING
05:21:46.420 --> 05:21:48.922
CRISIS IN CALIFORNIA I THINK WE
05:21:48.989 --> 05:21:50.891
ALL UNDERSTAND THAT BUT I'M
05:21:50.958 --> 05:21:53.394
HAVING DIFFICULTY UNDERSTANDING
05:21:53.460 --> 05:21:56.530
HELLO PROVIDING SOMEONE WITH A
05:21:56.597 --> 05:21:58.399
DOWN PAYMENT IS GOING TO HELP
05:21:58.465 --> 05:22:02.169
THEM. PURCHASE IN STAY IN A HOME
05:22:02.236 --> 05:22:03.337
WHERE THE HOME PRICES IN
05:22:03.404 --> 05:22:05.039
CALIFORNIA THE MEDIAN HOME PRICE
05:22:05.105 --> 05:22:07.207
IN CALIFORNIA IS EIGHT HUNDRED
05:22:07.274 --> 05:22:10.010
THOUSAND DOLLARS. I DON'T KNOW I
05:22:10.077 --> 05:22:11.078
MEAN THAT'S GONNA HAVE TO BE A
05:22:11.145 --> 05:22:13.147
PRETTY BIG DOWN PAYMENT I WOULD
05:22:13.213 --> 05:22:14.915
SAY IN ORDER FOR SOMEONE IF WE
05:22:14.982 --> 05:22:16.950
ARE TALKING ABOUT LOW INCOME
05:22:17.017 --> 05:22:18.318
FOLKS. BE ABLE TO MAINTAIN
05:22:18.385 --> 05:22:20.521
MORTGAGE EVERY MONTH I MEAN I
05:22:20.587 --> 05:22:24.858
SEE THAT. SEVEN BILLION- TO
05:22:24.925 --> 05:22:26.894
PROVIDE LOANS TO DEVELOPERS SO I
05:22:26.960 --> 05:22:28.328
GUESS THEY'RE PRETTY BIG WINNERS
05:22:28.395 --> 05:22:30.297
IN THIS DEAL BUT I DON'T SEE HOW
05:22:30.364 --> 05:22:31.832
THE PERSON TRYING TO GET INTO A
05:22:31.899 --> 05:22:33.400
HOME. AND OF BEING A WINNER LIKE
05:22:33.467 --> 05:22:35.169
THE DEVELOPERS THERE IS NO
05:22:35.235 --> 05:22:36.804
POSSIBLE WAY. UNLESS YOU'RE
05:22:36.870 --> 05:22:40.074
GIVING A 50% DOWN PAYMENT. THAT
05:22:40.140 --> 05:22:43.877
ANYONE. IS GOING TO BE ABLE TO
05:22:43.944 --> 05:22:46.480
GET INTO. A HOME AND BE ABLE TO
05:22:46.547 --> 05:22:48.549
STAY IN IT GIVEN THE COST OF
05:22:48.615 --> 05:22:50.884
HOUSING IN CALIFORNIA NOT TO
05:22:50.951 --> 05:22:52.086
MENTION ALL THE OTHER THINGS
05:22:52.152 --> 05:22:54.521
THAT THE- GOOD SENATOR POINTED
05:22:54.588 --> 05:22:56.857
OUT WHICH IS THE INCREASED COST
05:22:56.924 --> 05:22:59.727
OF. GASOLINE WHICH IS DUE TO
05:22:59.793 --> 05:23:01.495
POLICIES ENACTED BY THE STATE
05:23:01.562 --> 05:23:03.931
THE INCREASED COST IN UTILITIES
05:23:03.997 --> 05:23:05.899
WHICH IS DUE TO POLICIES ENACTED
05:23:05.966 --> 05:23:07.634
BY THE LEGISLATURE IN THE STATE
05:23:07.701 --> 05:23:09.903
THE INCREASED COST IN GOODS AND
05:23:09.970 --> 05:23:12.339
SERVICES AGAIN. DONE SO BY THE
05:23:12.406 --> 05:23:13.574
POLICIES ENACTED BY THE
05:23:13.640 --> 05:23:17.377
LEGISLATURE IN THE STATE SO- I'M
05:23:17.444 --> 05:23:20.013
SORRY BUT THOUGH I YOU CERTAINLY
05:23:20.080 --> 05:23:22.983
AGREE THAT WE WOULD LIKE TO GET
05:23:23.050 --> 05:23:24.218
MORE PEOPLE IN THE HOME- I'M
05:23:24.284 --> 05:23:25.853
GOING TO HAVE TO RESPECTFULLY
05:23:25.919 --> 05:23:28.589
OPPOSE THIS BILL. THANK YOU
05:23:28.655 --> 05:23:32.226
CENTER MELINDA'S SENATOR STERN-
05:23:32.292 --> 05:23:34.528
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT. I
05:23:34.595 --> 05:23:36.330
APPRECIATE THE INTENT OF THE
05:23:36.396 --> 05:23:37.998
LEGISLATION AND I'VE I'M I'M
05:23:38.065 --> 05:23:41.068
TRYING TO A TO GET TO PLACES
05:23:41.135 --> 05:23:42.236
SUPPORT BUT MY OUTSTANDING
05:23:42.302 --> 05:23:45.606
CONCERNS- ARE THOSE RAISED BY
05:23:45.672 --> 05:23:48.842
SOME OF THE OPPOSITION- NAMELY
05:23:48.909 --> 05:23:52.880
THE PROVISION THAT ALLOWS THE
05:23:52.946 --> 05:23:55.716
PROJECTS TO OVERRIDE A LOCAL
05:23:55.783 --> 05:23:58.418
ORDINANCE ESPECIALLY ON.
05:23:58.485 --> 05:24:00.387
COLLUSION NERI ZONING FOR
05:24:00.454 --> 05:24:03.423
AFFORDABILITY- AS WELL AS THE
05:24:03.490 --> 05:24:05.192
ONGOING ISSUE THAT I'VE I'VE
05:24:05.259 --> 05:24:07.561
PROBABLY RAISED ODD NAUSEUM ON
05:24:07.628 --> 05:24:10.764
THIS FLOOR IN THIS HOUSE. THE
05:24:10.831 --> 05:24:12.065
THE NOT PRESSURE PERMITTING
05:24:12.132 --> 05:24:14.368
OTHER WORDS THE STREAMLINING OF
05:24:14.434 --> 05:24:17.204
HOUSING BILLS DEEPER INTO OUR
05:24:17.271 --> 05:24:19.573
HIGH FIRE SEVERITY ZONES WHERE I
05:24:19.640 --> 05:24:22.342
THINK THAT. WE SOLD NEW
05:24:22.409 --> 05:24:24.578
HOMEOWNERS AND RENTERS ON A RAW
05:24:24.645 --> 05:24:27.047
DEAL THAT LOCKS THEM INTO SUPER
05:24:27.114 --> 05:24:30.551
COMMUTES- AND OFTEN
05:24:30.617 --> 05:24:32.286
UNSUSTAINABLE INSURANCE. THAT
05:24:32.352 --> 05:24:34.555
MAKES WHERE THEY BUY A HOME BUT
05:24:34.621 --> 05:24:36.356
CAN NO LONGER AFFORD IT
05:24:36.423 --> 05:24:37.591
AFTERWARDS BECAUSE THEIR
05:24:37.658 --> 05:24:39.393
INSURANCE RATES SKYROCKET- I
05:24:39.459 --> 05:24:41.562
THINK THERE IS THERE A WORKABLE
05:24:41.628 --> 05:24:42.996
PROVISIONS IN HERE AND I DO LOOK
05:24:43.063 --> 05:24:45.799
FOR DISSING OF THE BILL OF ALL.
05:24:45.866 --> 05:24:46.900
BUT IN LIGHT OF THESE
05:24:46.967 --> 05:24:48.902
AFFORDABILITY AND FIRES ON
05:24:48.969 --> 05:24:51.271
ISSUES OF ALL THE SPORTS THANK.
05:24:51.338 --> 05:24:53.373
THANK YOU CENTER STERN MEMBERS
05:24:53.440 --> 05:24:56.944
CENTER CHULA. THANK YOU MADAM
05:24:57.010 --> 05:24:59.213
PRESIDENT I APPLAUD THIS BILL I
05:24:59.279 --> 05:25:01.081
THINK ALL OF US HAVE HEARD FROM
05:25:01.148 --> 05:25:02.883
OUR CONSTITUENTS WHAT ARE WE
05:25:02.950 --> 05:25:05.853
DOING FOR THE FIRST TIME HOME
05:25:05.919 --> 05:25:07.321
BUYER ENTRY LEVEL BUYERS
05:25:07.387 --> 05:25:09.923
COMMUNITIES THAT ARE DYING TO
05:25:09.990 --> 05:25:12.226
HAVE PEOPLE JOIN THEIR COMMUNITY
05:25:12.292 --> 05:25:13.927
TO BE PART OF THE COMMUNITY YEAH
05:25:13.994 --> 05:25:17.097
OF COURSE. AS OF. DIFFICULT BUT
05:25:17.164 --> 05:25:18.899
THIS PROGRAM HERE OVER THE LONG
05:25:18.966 --> 05:25:21.001
HAUL WILLESTABLISH A ENTRY
05:25:21.068 --> 05:25:24.504
LEVEL- SILENT- LUPONE OF SOME
05:25:24.571 --> 05:25:26.273
SORT I GUESS WE CALL IT THE SIDE
05:25:26.340 --> 05:25:28.242
OF THE SECOND TO HELP BRING
05:25:28.308 --> 05:25:29.776
COSTS IN A PORTION DOWN PAYMENT
05:25:29.843 --> 05:25:31.511
BUT REMEMBER THEY STILLHAVE TO
05:25:31.578 --> 05:25:34.448
FIGHT THIS WILL HAVE TO MEET THE
05:25:34.514 --> 05:25:36.416
STANDARD SET. UNDER SO THE WAY
05:25:36.483 --> 05:25:40.988
IT IS IN THE DISTANCE THAT IS-
05:25:41.054 --> 05:25:41.989
PAYABLE. IT BE GIVEN TO THE
05:25:42.055 --> 05:25:44.324
NEXT- HOMEOWNER IN THE FUTURE SO
05:25:44.391 --> 05:25:46.293
I THINK THIS IS A GREAT START.
05:25:46.360 --> 05:25:48.462
TO HELP THAT ENTRY LEVEL BUYER
05:25:48.528 --> 05:25:50.297
BECAUSE WE'VE HEARD IN THE PAST
05:25:50.364 --> 05:25:51.465
FIREFIGHTERS POLICE OFFICERS
05:25:51.531 --> 05:25:53.634
NURSES WHO WORK IN A COMMUNITY
05:25:53.700 --> 05:25:55.168
CAN'T LIVE IN THAT COMMUNITY
05:25:55.235 --> 05:25:56.837
THIS WILL OPEN THAT BURKE. FOR
05:25:56.904 --> 05:25:59.339
CONSTRUCTION AND HOMEOWNERSHIP I
05:25:59.406 --> 05:26:01.341
APPLAUD THE BILL AND AYE URGENT
05:26:01.408 --> 05:26:05.145
AYE VOTE ON SB FOURTEEN FIFTY
05:26:05.212 --> 05:26:07.681
SEVEN. THANK YOU ARE CLOSER
05:26:07.748 --> 05:26:11.251
DOLLY. MEMBERS I AM. MUST STAND
05:26:11.318 --> 05:26:13.587
IN OPPOSITION- I MODE MANY
05:26:13.654 --> 05:26:15.389
PROBABLY DON'T KNOW BUT I WAS
05:26:15.455 --> 05:26:17.557
THE CHAIR OF THE LARGEST HOUSING
05:26:17.624 --> 05:26:20.093
AUTHORITY IN THE NATION. WE DID
05:26:20.160 --> 05:26:21.428
TAX EXEMPT BONDS THROUGH THE
05:26:21.495 --> 05:26:24.531
REGIONAL RULE RULE COUNTIES AND-
05:26:24.598 --> 05:26:25.599
THERE ARE MANY PROGRAMS
05:26:25.666 --> 05:26:27.834
AVAILABLE- FOR FIRST TIME HOME
05:26:27.901 --> 05:26:29.436
BUYERS OF PROGRAMS CARRY THIS
05:26:29.503 --> 05:26:31.939
BILL. THIS IS GOING TO PUT. OUR
05:26:32.005 --> 05:26:34.274
TAXPAYERS ARE OUR MONEY ON THE
05:26:34.341 --> 05:26:36.209
LINE TWENTY TWENTY FIVE BILLION
05:26:36.276 --> 05:26:37.911
DOLLARS OF BONDING. THERE'S NO
05:26:37.978 --> 05:26:39.479
NEED FR THERE'S ALREADY HOUSING
05:26:39.546 --> 05:26:41.515
AUTHORITIES IN CALIFORNIA- THAT
05:26:41.581 --> 05:26:42.950
DO FIRST TIME HOME BUYERS HOME
05:26:43.016 --> 05:26:45.152
BUYERS ASSISTANCE. ALL THE
05:26:45.218 --> 05:26:46.286
THINGS THAT THIS BILL IS GOING
05:26:46.353 --> 05:26:48.221
TO DO AND THERE'S REALLY NO NEED
05:26:48.288 --> 05:26:50.157
FOR THIS BILL THERE'S PLENTY OF
05:26:50.223 --> 05:26:51.758
PROGRAMS OUT THERE THAT ALLOW
05:26:51.825 --> 05:26:53.293
QUALIFIED. A CALIFORNIANS TO BE
05:26:53.360 --> 05:26:55.696
ABLE TO APPLY FOR THOSE A TAX
05:26:55.762 --> 05:26:56.797
EXEMPT BONDS THAT ARE ALREADY
05:26:56.863 --> 05:26:58.598
AVAILABLE SO FOR THOSE REASONS
05:26:58.665 --> 05:27:00.334
ALL BE OPPOSING THIS BILL. THANK
05:27:00.400 --> 05:27:02.436
YOU CENTER DOLLY CENTER BECKER.
05:27:02.502 --> 05:27:04.604
YOUR RISE IN STRONG SUPPORT BILL
05:27:04.671 --> 05:27:08.408
I THINK TOO MUCH ABOUT. THE ARE
05:27:08.475 --> 05:27:11.211
SPENT STATE. THING WE BEEN MORE
05:27:11.278 --> 05:27:12.646
FOCUSED ON THE OWNERSHIP HOUSING
05:27:12.713 --> 05:27:15.349
AND TO MY COLLEAGUE FROM LAKE
05:27:15.415 --> 05:27:17.617
ELSINORE I'LL JUST SAY THAT THE
05:27:17.684 --> 05:27:20.821
DOCUMENT IS THE ISSUE IN
05:27:20.887 --> 05:27:22.322
MEDICAID. THIS IS YOUR HI IN THE
05:27:22.389 --> 05:27:24.157
STATE SO IF YOU LOOK AT. VERSYS
05:27:24.224 --> 05:27:26.159
DO I KNOW STANFORD DOES THE HELP
05:27:26.226 --> 05:27:27.394
MATCH THE DOWN PAYMENT TO HELP
05:27:27.461 --> 05:27:28.829
PEOPLE WITH A DOWN PAYMENT.
05:27:28.895 --> 05:27:30.297
BECAUSE THEY KNOW THEY CAN
05:27:30.364 --> 05:27:31.865
AFFORD- THE ON GOING AT PAYMENTS
05:27:31.932 --> 05:27:33.500
BUT JUST THE DOWN PAYMENT IS THE
05:27:33.567 --> 05:27:36.103
ISSUE SO. I THINK THERE'S A LOT
05:27:36.169 --> 05:27:38.038
OF GOOD APART IS BILL AND I- WAS
05:27:38.105 --> 05:27:39.740
STRONGLY SUPPORTED. CENTER BAKER
05:27:39.806 --> 05:27:42.009
SENATOR WHITEHOUSE DEVELOPERS IN
05:27:42.075 --> 05:27:43.777
THE I RISE IN SUPPORT OF THIS
05:27:43.844 --> 05:27:45.579
BILL AND LET'S BE CLEAR WHAT
05:27:45.645 --> 05:27:47.047
THE- BILL DOES AND DOESN'T DO
05:27:47.114 --> 05:27:48.115
PEOPLE TALK ABOUT THE MISSING
05:27:48.181 --> 05:27:50.951
MIDDLE. TALK BILL IS TO CREATE A
05:27:51.018 --> 05:27:53.587
NEW MONEY. THAT IS GOING TO.
05:27:53.653 --> 05:27:55.422
HAVE A BASICALLY A SILENCE
05:27:55.489 --> 05:27:57.724
SECOND ON PEOPLE'S HOUSES SO
05:27:57.791 --> 05:28:00.260
THAT THEY CAN HAVE A HUNDRED AND
05:28:00.327 --> 05:28:01.962
FIFTY THOUSAND DOLLAR DOWN
05:28:02.029 --> 05:28:05.032
PAYMENT. ASSEMBLY PULLED A GOOD
05:28:05.098 --> 05:28:07.901
WORK. PEOPLE WORK COULD BE
05:28:07.968 --> 05:28:12.439
CALLED. THE YOUNG. PEEP THAT
05:28:12.506 --> 05:28:14.041
WANT TO HAVE HOME. WITH THIS NEW
05:28:14.107 --> 05:28:15.075
MONEY THE- BACK IS GETTING VAN.
05:28:15.142 --> 05:28:18.245
OF THE- AT THE TAX CODE SO THAT
05:28:18.311 --> 05:28:19.946
WE CAN CREATE THIS LITTLE POOL
05:28:20.013 --> 05:28:22.182
OF MONEY SEVERAL BILLION DOLLARS
05:28:22.249 --> 05:28:24.317
SO THAT PEOPLE CAN BUY HOMES IT
05:28:24.384 --> 05:28:26.286
IS I UNDERSTAND SOME PEOPLE IT'S
05:28:26.353 --> 05:28:27.888
NOT IF IT'S NOT NECESSARILY
05:28:27.954 --> 05:28:29.356
AFFORDABLE THAT'S IT'S SOMETHING
05:28:29.423 --> 05:28:31.191
THAT WE HAVE TO WORK ON THIS NOT
05:28:31.258 --> 05:28:33.293
THIS BILL IF WE CAN LOWER THE
05:28:33.360 --> 05:28:33.894
PRICE OF HOUSING THEY'LL BE
05:28:33.960 --> 05:28:36.129
GREAT I WANT TO WORK ON THAT
05:28:36.196 --> 05:28:37.697
BILL WITH SOMEBODY. BUT THIS IS
05:28:37.764 --> 05:28:38.899
JUST THE PEOPLE HOPE THEY'RE IN
05:28:38.965 --> 05:28:40.233
THE MIDDLE THERE TINK FEELING
05:28:40.300 --> 05:28:41.935
THAT WE'RE NOT DOING ANYTHING
05:28:42.002 --> 05:28:43.970
THAT THERE'S A HUNDRED FIFTY
05:28:44.037 --> 05:28:44.538
THOUSAND BUCKS THAT THEY'RE
05:28:44.604 --> 05:28:46.006
GONNA BE ABLE HAVE AS A DOWN
05:28:46.073 --> 05:28:48.442
PAYMENT AND AFTER FIFTEEN YEARS
05:28:48.508 --> 05:28:49.609
THEY GOT A REFINANCE TO DO
05:28:49.676 --> 05:28:51.745
WHATEVER THEY HAVE AYE- AYE
05:28:51.812 --> 05:28:53.113
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER RIGHT
05:28:53.180 --> 05:28:55.382
KELSEY CENTER WIENER. THANK YOU
05:28:55.449 --> 05:28:56.616
VERY MUCH RUNNING PRESIDENT AYE
05:28:56.683 --> 05:28:58.118
WE SAW BILL IN THE HOUSING
05:28:58.185 --> 05:29:00.120
COMMITTEE AND WE WORK WITH THE
05:29:00.187 --> 05:29:01.455
AUTHOR AND PUT SOME OF THE
05:29:01.521 --> 05:29:02.923
STRONG AMENDMENTS AND TO MAKE
05:29:02.989 --> 05:29:04.558
SURE THAT IT WAS NOT-
05:29:04.624 --> 05:29:07.260
ENCOURAGING SPRAWL- BECAUSE WE
05:29:07.327 --> 05:29:08.695
DO NEED A HOUSING WITH ONE
05:29:08.762 --> 05:29:12.966
SPRAWL. AND I THINK IT'S A IT IS
05:29:13.033 --> 05:29:15.302
A BILL I DO JUST WANT TO SAY-
05:29:15.368 --> 05:29:16.570
THAT FUNDAMENTALLY TO SOLVE OUR
05:29:16.636 --> 05:29:19.172
HOUSING CRISIS WE NEED TO DO IS
05:29:19.239 --> 05:29:23.477
BUILD A LOT MORE AS- EVERY. IT
05:29:23.543 --> 05:29:29.850
AND WHICH THE MONEY. I SUPPORT
05:29:29.916 --> 05:29:31.017
DOWN PAYMENTS TENS OF SPORTS
05:29:31.084 --> 05:29:33.553
BILL- E NEED TO BE A LOT MORE.
05:29:33.620 --> 05:29:34.321
I AM. VERY HAPPY THAT THIS.
05:29:34.387 --> 05:29:36.957
CONTAINS ROBOTS. REQUIREMENTS
05:29:37.023 --> 05:29:39.493
BECAUSE WE DO WANT TO MAKE SURE.
05:29:39.559 --> 05:29:41.228
THAT ONCE WE ZONED FOR HOUSING
05:29:41.294 --> 05:29:44.064
ONCE WE'VE- BEEN ABLE THAT- THAT
05:29:44.131 --> 05:29:45.699
PEOPLE CAN GET THEIR PERMITS IN
05:29:45.765 --> 05:29:47.000
A TIMELY MANNER AND DON'T GET
05:29:47.067 --> 05:29:49.603
STUCK. IN A FIVE TO TEN YEAR
05:29:49.669 --> 05:29:52.205
PROCESS- SO- THIS BILL IS NOT A
05:29:52.272 --> 05:29:55.008
SILVER BULLET BUT I THINK IT'S A
05:29:55.075 --> 05:29:56.109
GOOD STEP FORWARD I'M HAPPY TO
05:29:56.176 --> 05:29:57.410
SUPPORT IT. THE CENTER WIENER
05:29:57.477 --> 05:29:58.812
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION AND
05:29:58.879 --> 05:30:00.313
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
05:30:00.380 --> 05:30:01.448
CENTER PORTANTINO YOU MAY CLOSE
05:30:01.515 --> 05:30:02.716
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THANK
05:30:02.782 --> 05:30:05.852
YOU FOR THE ROBUST DEBATE TO- I
05:30:05.919 --> 05:30:07.454
KNOW MY COLLEAGUE- CENTER
05:30:07.521 --> 05:30:09.356
HERTZBERG APPRECIATED AND THE
05:30:09.422 --> 05:30:11.491
WORK THAT'S BEEN DONE TO GET
05:30:11.558 --> 05:30:12.192
THIS BILL TO THIS POINT. HAS
05:30:12.259 --> 05:30:13.093
BEEN SIGNIFICANT THROUGH THE
05:30:13.160 --> 05:30:16.830
POLICY COMMITTEE. GONE THROUGH-
05:30:16.897 --> 05:30:19.633
WE'RE AT WE ARE COGNISANT OF THE
05:30:19.699 --> 05:30:21.301
POTENTIAL. CALIFORNIA OUT. THERE
05:30:21.368 --> 05:30:23.303
ARE SAFEGUARDS BEING DISCUSSED
05:30:23.370 --> 05:30:25.338
IN BEING BUILT INTO THE BILL AS
05:30:25.405 --> 05:30:26.606
MY COLLEAGUES HAVE MENTIONED WE
05:30:26.673 --> 05:30:28.542
HAVE TO PRODUCE MORE WE HAVE TO
05:30:28.608 --> 05:30:30.110
MAKE SURE IT'S AFFORDABLE. AND
05:30:30.177 --> 05:30:31.778
WE HAVE TO LOOK AT THE SOCIOLOGY
05:30:31.845 --> 05:30:34.147
OF HOUSING. YOU KNOW SO MUCH OF
05:30:34.214 --> 05:30:36.249
WHAT WE DO ISTO CREATE MORE
05:30:36.316 --> 05:30:37.884
RENTAL HOUSING AND TO SAY TO
05:30:37.951 --> 05:30:39.319
CALIFORNIANS. THAT
05:30:39.386 --> 05:30:41.521
HOMEOWNERSHIP. WILL NOT BE IN
05:30:41.588 --> 05:30:43.623
THEIR FUTURE IS REALLY A CYNICAL
05:30:43.690 --> 05:30:46.960
VIEW. WE HAVE TO SAY WE'RE GONNA
05:30:47.027 --> 05:30:48.261
DO WHAT WE CAN TO PROVIDE
05:30:48.328 --> 05:30:50.197
OPPORTUNITIES FOR THOSE FIRST
05:30:50.263 --> 05:30:51.598
TIME HOMEBUYERS. YOU SEE THE
05:30:51.665 --> 05:30:53.366
MODELS POST WORLD WAR TWO WE
05:30:53.433 --> 05:30:55.669
SEEN HOW UPWARD MOBILITY HAS
05:30:55.735 --> 05:30:57.204
BEEN TIED TO THAT FIRST HOME
05:30:57.270 --> 05:31:00.574
OWNERSHIP IN EQUITY BUILDING
05:31:00.640 --> 05:31:02.342
WE'VE SEEN THE SUCCESS OF THIS
05:31:02.409 --> 05:31:05.145
IN. DO PER. YOU TO GO SOMEBODY
05:31:05.212 --> 05:31:07.214
OUT AT AN INNOVATION STRATEGY IS
05:31:07.280 --> 05:31:08.315
FIND OUT WHAT WORKS AND THEN
05:31:08.381 --> 05:31:10.617
REPEAT IT- SO BY DOING THEM
05:31:10.684 --> 05:31:12.786
ECONOMIC MODEL THAT WORKS AND
05:31:12.852 --> 05:31:14.554
FUNDING IT AND CREATING MORE
05:31:14.621 --> 05:31:16.890
SUPPLY AND MAKING SURE THAT THAT
05:31:16.957 --> 05:31:19.759
WAS FORGOTTEN MIDDLE IS ONE OF
05:31:19.826 --> 05:31:22.262
MY COLLEAGUES MENTIONED HAS THE
05:31:22.329 --> 05:31:23.997
OPPORTUNITY TO GET THOSE. THAT
05:31:24.064 --> 05:31:26.099
ACOSTA CALIFORNIA WILL BE
05:31:26.166 --> 05:31:28.301
SIGNIFICANT AND THE GENERATIONS
05:31:28.368 --> 05:31:29.603
THAT WILL BENEFIT FROM HAVING
05:31:29.669 --> 05:31:30.904
THAT PIECE OF THE AMERICAN DREAM
05:31:30.971 --> 05:31:33.340
AND THEIR FIRST TIME HOME ON. A
05:31:33.406 --> 05:31:34.507
HOMEOWNERSHIP OPPORTUNITIES IS
05:31:34.574 --> 05:31:36.543
SIGNIFICANCE I RESPECTFULLY ASK
05:31:36.610 --> 05:31:38.578
FOR AN AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
05:31:38.645 --> 05:31:40.380
SENATE PORTANTINO MADAM
05:31:40.447 --> 05:31:42.782
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
05:31:42.849 --> 05:31:46.920
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
05:31:46.987 --> 05:31:52.325
AYE BATES NO BAKER I FORTUS. NO
05:31:52.392 --> 05:31:55.495
BRADFORD. AYE CABALLERO AYE
05:31:55.562 --> 05:31:59.966
PORTENDING AYE DALY NO DODD. AYE
05:32:00.033 --> 05:32:04.271
TORONTO. AYE EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
05:32:04.337 --> 05:32:08.174
AYE GONZALEZ. I GROWTH NO
05:32:08.241 --> 05:32:12.445
HERTZBERG WESSEL. I HER DAUGHTER
05:32:12.512 --> 05:32:19.352
I JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
05:32:19.419 --> 05:32:23.823
LEYVA AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE. I
05:32:23.890 --> 05:32:29.663
MELENDEZ NO MAN. NEWMAN I
05:32:29.729 --> 05:32:35.468
NIELSEN. A SHOW OF BOTH NO HAN.
05:32:35.535 --> 05:32:41.141
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO. I
05:32:41.207 --> 05:32:45.779
SKINNER AYE STERN. AMBERG I BY
05:32:45.845 --> 05:32:51.951
CASTING I WIENER. I WILL. PLEASE
05:32:52.018 --> 05:32:53.520
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
05:32:53.586 --> 05:33:01.594
HERTZBERG MAN. NIELSEN PAM STERN
05:33:01.661 --> 05:33:07.100
WILK HI. I TWENTY EIGHT NO SEVEN
05:33:07.167 --> 05:33:09.202
ON THE URGENCY IS TWENTY EIGHT
05:33:09.269 --> 05:33:10.870
NO SEVEN THE MEASURE PASSES
05:33:10.937 --> 05:33:12.305
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO MOVE
05:33:12.372 --> 05:33:14.341
FORWARD TO FILE ITEM ONE TEN
05:33:14.407 --> 05:33:16.776
SENATOR UMBERG MADAM SECRETARY
05:33:16.843 --> 05:33:19.679
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL THIRTEEN
05:33:19.746 --> 05:33:20.613
THIRTY EIGHT BY SENATOR UMBERG
05:33:20.680 --> 05:33:22.582
AN ACT RELATING TO MENTAL HEALTH
05:33:22.649 --> 05:33:24.617
CENTER NUMBER THANK YOU MADAM
05:33:24.684 --> 05:33:25.919
PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES I'M PLEASE
05:33:25.985 --> 05:33:28.722
PRESENT SB THIRTEEN THIRTY EIGHT
05:33:28.788 --> 05:33:31.257
ALONG WITH MY JOIN AUTHOR MY
05:33:31.324 --> 05:33:32.359
COLLEAGUES ARE COLLEAGUES I'M
05:33:32.425 --> 05:33:35.328
STOCKS UP COLLEAGUES THERE ARE
05:33:35.395 --> 05:33:36.329
SEVEN TO TWELVE THOUSAND
05:33:36.396 --> 05:33:37.797
CALIFORNIANS WHO ARE AFFLICTED
05:33:37.864 --> 05:33:39.766
WITH SCHIZOPHRENIA SCHIZOPHRENIA
05:33:39.833 --> 05:33:43.303
LIKE. ILLNESSES THE FAMILIES OF
05:33:43.370 --> 05:33:45.171
THOSE WHO ARE FLECKED DID THEY
05:33:45.238 --> 05:33:47.307
KNOW THE PAIN AND SUFFERING OF
05:33:47.374 --> 05:33:48.942
SCHIZOPHRENIA AND SCHIZOPHRENIA
05:33:49.008 --> 05:33:50.877
LIKE ILLNESSES THEY KNOW THE
05:33:50.944 --> 05:33:52.979
TURMOIL OF GETTING PHONE CALLS
05:33:53.046 --> 05:33:55.749
IN THE MORNING- NOTIFYING THEM
05:33:55.815 --> 05:33:57.350
THAT THEIR LOVED ONE IS
05:33:57.417 --> 05:33:59.185
INCARCERATED AND ACTUALLY
05:33:59.252 --> 05:34:00.320
FEELING A SENSE OF RELIEF
05:34:00.387 --> 05:34:01.654
BECAUSE THEY KNOW THEIR LOVED
05:34:01.721 --> 05:34:03.757
ONE AT LEAST IS SOMEPLACE WHERE
05:34:03.823 --> 05:34:05.992
THEY CAN BE FOUND IT IS
05:34:06.059 --> 05:34:09.329
PRESUMABLY TO BE WELL AS OPPOSED
05:34:09.396 --> 05:34:10.764
TO. CALLS THEY MAY GET. THE
05:34:10.830 --> 05:34:13.600
GOVERNOR HAS PROPOSED A BOLD NEW
05:34:13.666 --> 05:34:16.336
PARADIGM SHIFTS- WHICH IS THE
05:34:16.403 --> 05:34:17.737
COMMUNITY ASSISTANCE RECOVERY
05:34:17.804 --> 05:34:21.641
EMPOWERMENT. CARE COURT PROGRAM
05:34:21.708 --> 05:34:22.876
. THIS IS A PROPOSED FRAMEWORK
05:34:22.942 --> 05:34:27.614
THAT IS INTENDED TO ADDRESS THE
05:34:27.680 --> 05:34:31.251
NEEDS TO STABILIZE THOSE SEVEN
05:34:31.317 --> 05:34:32.385
TO TWELVE THOUSAND CALIFORNIANS
05:34:32.452 --> 05:34:33.820
IN ADDRESS THE NEEDS OF THEIR
05:34:33.887 --> 05:34:35.688
FAMILIES AS WELL THIS
05:34:35.755 --> 05:34:39.159
COMPREHENSIVE PROGRAM PROVIDES
05:34:39.225 --> 05:34:43.430
FOR A- STRUCTURE WHERE THERE IS
05:34:43.496 --> 05:34:45.832
A COURT WHO HAS ACCOUNTABILITY
05:34:45.899 --> 05:34:47.534
WHERE THERE'S A SUPPORTER WHO
05:34:47.600 --> 05:34:49.602
PROVIDES ASSISTANCE TO THOSE WHO
05:34:49.669 --> 05:34:51.805
ARE ILL. A PUBLIC DEFENDER IF
05:34:51.871 --> 05:34:54.007
NECESSARY BUT IT IS NOT A
05:34:54.073 --> 05:34:56.876
COLLABORATIVE COURT IS CAN TWO
05:34:56.943 --> 05:34:58.511
ONE IT DOESN'T PROVIDE FOR
05:34:58.578 --> 05:35:00.947
INCARCERATION IT DOESN'T PROVIDE
05:35:01.014 --> 05:35:04.083
AN ALTERNATIVE FOR EXAMPLE TO
05:35:04.150 --> 05:35:05.785
CONSERVANCY. IT PROVIDES
05:35:05.852 --> 05:35:07.287
INDIVIDUALS WITH CLINICALLY
05:35:07.353 --> 05:35:08.488
APPROPRIATE COMMUNITY BASED
05:35:08.555 --> 05:35:10.690
SERVICES AND SUPPORTS THAT ARE
05:35:10.757 --> 05:35:13.560
CLINICALLY AND LOGISTICALLY AND
05:35:13.626 --> 05:35:16.095
CULTURALLY COMPETENT- OUR
05:35:16.162 --> 05:35:17.430
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE-
05:35:17.497 --> 05:35:18.698
PROVIDED TWO IMPORTANT
05:35:18.765 --> 05:35:20.567
AMENDMENTS TO STRENGTHENING THE
05:35:20.633 --> 05:35:22.202
HOUSING COMPONENT OF THE CARE
05:35:22.268 --> 05:35:23.636
COURTS BECAUSE YOU CAN'T GET
05:35:23.703 --> 05:35:25.572
WELL UNLESS YOU HAVE A STABLE.
05:35:25.638 --> 05:35:28.875
LOCATION FROM WHICH YOU CAN.
05:35:28.942 --> 05:35:33.379
THRIVE AND SURVIVE- ARE A DISH
05:35:33.446 --> 05:35:35.215
ARE GOING TO BE ADDITIONAL MATHS
05:35:35.281 --> 05:35:38.618
. THE CARE COURT PROGRAM IS ONE
05:35:38.685 --> 05:35:41.020
THAT IS INNOVATIVE AND AS I
05:35:41.087 --> 05:35:42.222
MENTIONED AT THE OUTSET IS A
05:35:42.288 --> 05:35:44.457
PARADIGM SHIFT BUT ONE THAT'S
05:35:44.524 --> 05:35:47.393
NECESSARY TO ADDRESS THOSE THAT-
05:35:47.460 --> 05:35:49.762
WE'VE HAD A VERY DIFFICULT TIME
05:35:49.829 --> 05:35:52.131
REACHING WHO HAVE SO IF ACTED
05:35:52.198 --> 05:35:54.000
COURSE THEMSELVES THEIR FAMILIES
05:35:54.067 --> 05:35:55.935
AND COMMUNITIES AND- THEY WHERE
05:35:56.002 --> 05:36:00.039
THEY RESULT. RESIDE THANK YOU.
05:36:00.106 --> 05:36:01.207
THANK YOU SERRA BURKE CENTER
05:36:01.274 --> 05:36:04.344
EGGMAN. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
05:36:04.410 --> 05:36:06.212
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS I AM A
05:36:06.279 --> 05:36:08.114
PROUD TO RISE AS A CO AUTHOR IN
05:36:08.181 --> 05:36:11.618
SUPPORT OF MY COLLEAGUE YOU HAVE
05:36:11.684 --> 05:36:13.887
THE CARE YOU HAVE THE COURT- SO
05:36:13.953 --> 05:36:15.088
WE FEEL LIKE WE ARE. WE'RE
05:36:15.154 --> 05:36:16.589
EXCITED TO BE WORKING TOGETHER
05:36:16.656 --> 05:36:17.790
ON THIS AND REALLY BRINGING
05:36:17.857 --> 05:36:19.292
BRINGING TOGETHER WE THINK A
05:36:19.359 --> 05:36:20.293
COMPREHENSIVE TEAM WE'RE VERY
05:36:20.360 --> 05:36:21.761
GRATEFUL TO THE GOVERNOR'S
05:36:21.828 --> 05:36:23.596
OFFICE FOR COMING UP WITH THIS.
05:36:23.663 --> 05:36:25.965
NEW CONCEPT YOU'VE ALL HEARD ME
05:36:26.032 --> 05:36:28.468
TALK A LOT ABOUT OUR BROKEN
05:36:28.535 --> 05:36:29.435
MENTAL HEALTH SYSTEM. NO I HAVE
05:36:29.502 --> 05:36:31.471
BEEN SITTING ON THIS A PRETTY
05:36:31.538 --> 05:36:33.473
INTENTLY THIS YEAR. NEITHER BY A
05:36:33.540 --> 05:36:36.376
BILL PACKAGE THAT. WE'RE TO. OR
05:36:36.442 --> 05:36:38.444
THIS BILL WILL WILL SOLVE ALL OF
05:36:38.511 --> 05:36:40.313
OUR ISSUES BUT IT WILL GO A LONG
05:36:40.380 --> 05:36:41.548
WAY TOWARDS DOING THAT
05:36:41.614 --> 05:36:43.383
ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE. WHO HAVE
05:36:43.449 --> 05:36:46.352
BEEN THE HARDEST TO TREAT- AND
05:36:46.419 --> 05:36:47.186
SOME PEOPLE SAY YOU'RE PUTTING
05:36:47.253 --> 05:36:49.155
IN AT THE FRONT OF THE LINE YES
05:36:49.222 --> 05:36:51.190
KIND OF BECAUSE RIGHT NOW
05:36:51.257 --> 05:36:53.459
THEY'RE NOT EVEN IN LINE THERE
05:36:53.526 --> 05:36:55.061
TOO HARD TO TREAT. AS WE SAID
05:36:55.128 --> 05:36:55.995
BEFORE. ONLY A PACK IMPACT
05:36:56.062 --> 05:36:57.697
BETWEEN SEVEN AND TWELVE
05:36:57.764 --> 05:36:59.365
THOUSAND PEOPLE- WILL IT SOLVE.
05:36:59.432 --> 05:37:01.334
HOMELESSNESS NO IT WILL NOT BUT
05:37:01.401 --> 05:37:03.069
ARE THE MAJORITY OF THESE PEOPLE
05:37:03.136 --> 05:37:04.671
THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
05:37:04.737 --> 05:37:05.872
SUFFERING FROM HOMELESSNESS. YES
05:37:05.939 --> 05:37:08.808
THEY ARE- THIS AGAIN COMES WITH
05:37:08.875 --> 05:37:10.410
THREE CORE COMPONENTS THAT ONE
05:37:10.476 --> 05:37:13.780
BEING THE CARE BEING PROVIDED. A
05:37:13.846 --> 05:37:15.548
TREATMENT PLAN. HAVING A
05:37:15.615 --> 05:37:18.818
SUPPORTER. MY MEDICATION PLAN AS
05:37:18.885 --> 05:37:21.387
WELL AS A HOUSING PLAN- AS I
05:37:21.454 --> 05:37:23.189
THINK ABOUT. WHAT WE ALL
05:37:23.256 --> 05:37:24.290
EXPERIENCE YESTERDAY IN THE
05:37:24.357 --> 05:37:25.725
HELPLESSNESS AND HOPELESSNESS
05:37:25.792 --> 05:37:28.194
THAT MAYBE YOU ALL FELT AS I DID
05:37:28.261 --> 05:37:29.495
IN THINKING ABOUT THOSE CHILDREN
05:37:29.562 --> 05:37:30.930
GUNNED DOWN. AND WE THINK WE
05:37:30.997 --> 05:37:32.966
NEED TO DO MORE. AND YOU FEEL
05:37:33.032 --> 05:37:35.301
FRUSTRATING CALIFORNIA BECAUSE
05:37:35.368 --> 05:37:36.369
WE'VE PASSED SOME OF THE MOST
05:37:36.436 --> 05:37:37.904
STRINGENT. WE CAN'T FIX OUR
05:37:37.971 --> 05:37:40.440
COUNTRY'S GUN LAWS TODAY BUT WE
05:37:40.506 --> 05:37:42.609
CAN. STOP PEOPLE DYING ON OUR
05:37:42.675 --> 05:37:45.478
STREETS. AND LANGUISHING IN OUR
05:37:45.545 --> 05:37:47.113
JAILS AND LANGUISHING IN OUR
05:37:47.180 --> 05:37:49.449
EMERGENCY. AND FAMILIES ARE
05:37:49.515 --> 05:37:50.850
LIVING HERE EVERY SINGLE DAY OF
05:37:50.917 --> 05:37:52.251
THAT PHONE CALL THEY'RE GOING TO
05:37:52.318 --> 05:37:54.153
GET A AND PRAYING THAT IT'S
05:37:54.220 --> 05:37:54.787
THEIR PERSON'S BEEN TAKEN
05:37:54.854 --> 05:37:56.823
SOMEWHERE SAFELY- SO THIS IS A
05:37:56.889 --> 05:37:58.658
NEW AND INNOVATIVE NEW ON RAMP
05:37:58.725 --> 05:38:01.127
INTO OUR MENTAL HEALTH SYSTEM-
05:38:01.194 --> 05:38:02.962
IT IS INNOVATIVE AS WE ALL KNOW
05:38:03.029 --> 05:38:04.998
OUR LPS LAWS WERE PASSED IN THE
05:38:05.064 --> 05:38:06.199
SIXTIES WE'VE WAITED VENTURE
05:38:06.265 --> 05:38:07.533
THERE. AND WHAT WE NEED TO
05:38:07.600 --> 05:38:08.868
CONTINUE TO STRENGTHEN AND FIX
05:38:08.935 --> 05:38:11.938
THOSE THIS IS A NEW ON RAMP FOR
05:38:12.005 --> 05:38:13.506
THOSE VERY CHRONIC FOLKS WHOSE
05:38:13.573 --> 05:38:16.175
DESPERATE CARE AND I WOULD
05:38:16.242 --> 05:38:18.811
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
05:38:18.878 --> 05:38:20.847
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER CENTER
05:38:20.913 --> 05:38:23.116
BORJA. BEN PRESENT I WANT TO
05:38:23.182 --> 05:38:26.019
COMMEND- BOTH SENATORS BOTH
05:38:26.085 --> 05:38:28.354
AUTHORS FOR THIS BILL. AND I
05:38:28.421 --> 05:38:30.156
CERTAINLY WOULD HAVE SUPPORTED
05:38:30.223 --> 05:38:32.692
IT INTO DISH IF THE CHAIR HAD
05:38:32.759 --> 05:38:35.161
CLOSED THE ROLE- I THINK THIS IS
05:38:35.228 --> 05:38:37.363
A- IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT AND I
05:38:37.430 --> 05:38:40.867
WANT TO CONGRATULATE YOU FOR THE
05:38:40.933 --> 05:38:42.135
BOTH OF YOU FOR THE HARD WORK
05:38:42.201 --> 05:38:44.737
THAT YOU'VE DONE. THANK YOU SEE
05:38:44.804 --> 05:38:46.139
. I THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
05:38:46.205 --> 05:38:48.307
CENTERS ACTUALLY- THE QUESTION
05:38:48.374 --> 05:38:50.643
FOR THE AUTHOR. THE NUMBER WE
05:38:50.710 --> 05:38:52.311
TAKE YOUR QUESTION WELL IT IF
05:38:52.378 --> 05:38:53.746
IT'S A HARD QUESTION MY
05:38:53.813 --> 05:38:55.014
COLLEAGUE FROM STOCKTON SAID
05:38:55.081 --> 05:38:56.849
SHE'D LIKE TO TAKE. YOU TO FOR
05:38:56.916 --> 05:38:59.318
EITHER HANDED OUT OF TAKE A SHOT
05:38:59.385 --> 05:39:01.487
FIRST YES- SO APPRECIATE THAT
05:39:01.554 --> 05:39:04.557
AND FIRST OF ALL I WANNA THANK
05:39:04.624 --> 05:39:05.892
YOU FOR. BOTH BOTH YOU AND
05:39:05.958 --> 05:39:07.627
SENATOR I CAN FOR BRING THIS
05:39:07.694 --> 05:39:08.961
FORWARD YOU KNOW WE HAD IT.
05:39:09.028 --> 05:39:12.832
THINK OF VERY THOROUGH HEARING
05:39:12.899 --> 05:39:16.703
AND HEALTH COMMITTEE AND- WHAT.
05:39:16.769 --> 05:39:18.604
COUPLE CAME OUT DOING IT BUT ONE
05:39:18.671 --> 05:39:20.740
OF THESE MEGA TO TAKEN APPROACH
05:39:20.807 --> 05:39:22.008
- SO I THINK BOTH THE
05:39:22.075 --> 05:39:23.609
ADMINISTRATION AND KNOWLEDGE.
05:39:23.676 --> 05:39:26.946
AND AND I THINK YOU UNDERSTAND
05:39:27.013 --> 05:39:30.383
THAT. HOUSING IS GOING TO BE
05:39:30.450 --> 05:39:31.784
VERY IMPORTANT AND- THE BILL
05:39:31.851 --> 05:39:33.519
THIS IS A CAME THROUGH HEALTH
05:39:33.586 --> 05:39:35.388
COMMITTEE WE DID NOT HAVE A
05:39:35.455 --> 05:39:37.890
REQUIREMENT FOR HOUSING. I THINK
05:39:37.957 --> 05:39:39.158
I RAISE THE ISSUE ABOUT PRIORITY
05:39:39.225 --> 05:39:43.262
FOR HOUSING LEAST. AND OF USE TO
05:39:43.329 --> 05:39:45.364
AT THIS POINT TIME DOUBTS ON THE
05:39:45.431 --> 05:39:48.267
FLOOR- WHAT THE- I ALSO
05:39:48.334 --> 05:39:50.236
REQUIREMENTS FULL- BUT WHAT'S
05:39:50.303 --> 05:39:52.004
BEING DONE TO ENSURE THAT PEOPLE
05:39:52.071 --> 05:39:53.272
GOING THROUGH KERR CORE WILL
05:39:53.339 --> 05:39:54.307
HAVE HOUSING BECAUSE WITHOUT
05:39:54.373 --> 05:39:56.743
HOUSING TO BE VERY DIFFICULT TO
05:39:56.809 --> 05:39:57.376
OBSERVE THESE SERVICES. AND IF
05:39:57.443 --> 05:39:59.345
IT'S NOT ON THE IN THE FORM
05:39:59.412 --> 05:40:01.881
THAT'S ON THE FLOOR- WHAT DO YOU
05:40:01.948 --> 05:40:04.717
DISSIPATE ARE YOU COMMITTING TO-
05:40:04.784 --> 05:40:06.819
IN THE ASSEMBLY TO TRY TO.
05:40:06.886 --> 05:40:08.554
HOUSING HE SAID HE DID SAY YOU
05:40:08.621 --> 05:40:13.192
OF THE- IN THE. AB CAN OPERATE
05:40:13.259 --> 05:40:16.329
ON THAT. THIRD THANK YOU. THANK
05:40:16.395 --> 05:40:18.898
YOU. SO PENCIL ARE CURRENTLY
05:40:18.965 --> 05:40:20.600
THERE'S A TWELVE BILLION DOLLAR
05:40:20.666 --> 05:40:23.603
INVESTMENT IN IN HOUSING ISSUES
05:40:23.669 --> 05:40:25.505
BUT THERE'S ALSO A ONE POINT
05:40:25.571 --> 05:40:27.373
FIVE BILLION DOLLAR INVEST IN
05:40:27.440 --> 05:40:29.242
HOUSING SUPPORT BEHAVIORAL
05:40:29.308 --> 05:40:32.612
HEALTH CHALLENGES- IN ONE OF THE
05:40:32.678 --> 05:40:34.413
ATTRIBUTES OF THE OF THE CARE
05:40:34.480 --> 05:40:35.982
COURTS IS THAT YOU HAVE A JUDGE
05:40:36.048 --> 05:40:37.917
AND TO THE EXTENT THAT THE
05:40:37.984 --> 05:40:40.253
COUNTY HAS THE CAPACITY BUT
05:40:40.319 --> 05:40:42.221
HOUSING THE COURT CAN ACTUALLY
05:40:42.288 --> 05:40:43.556
ORDER THE LEAST THAT'S MY
05:40:43.623 --> 05:40:46.192
VISION- THE CAN ORDER THE COUNTY
05:40:46.259 --> 05:40:49.262
TO PROVIDE THAT HOUSING- THERE
05:40:49.328 --> 05:40:50.396
ARE STILL SOME CHALLENGES WE
05:40:50.463 --> 05:40:52.498
RECOGNIZE THAT THERE ARE STILL
05:40:52.565 --> 05:40:54.066
SOME CHANNELS THAT NEED TO BE
05:40:54.133 --> 05:40:56.202
ADDRESSED AS THIS BILL MOVES
05:40:56.269 --> 05:41:00.473
FORWARD. BUT I NOTICE WHEN
05:41:00.540 --> 05:41:06.579
THERE'S INTENT AND IS CERTAINLY
05:41:06.646 --> 05:41:06.712
.
05:41:06.779 --> 05:41:10.216
AIRPORT AND I THINK I'LL TAKE
05:41:10.283 --> 05:41:11.217
YOU THERE- BURKE I THINK CENTER
05:41:11.284 --> 05:41:13.419
EGGMAN WOULD ALSO LIKE TO ANSWER
05:41:13.486 --> 05:41:15.721
PARTY QUESTION CENTER PAM YES IF
05:41:15.788 --> 05:41:18.891
IT'S ALRIGHT WITH THE NUMBER BUT
05:41:18.958 --> 05:41:21.093
JUST. TO FURTHER ADD TO THE- AS
05:41:21.160 --> 05:41:23.296
AS A STELLAR NUMBER SAID. OVER
05:41:23.362 --> 05:41:24.664
TWELVE BILLION DOLLARS WE HAVE
05:41:24.730 --> 05:41:26.165
PROVIDED FOR HOUSING IN AND
05:41:26.232 --> 05:41:28.000
ENDED WITH LAST YEAR'S BUDGET
05:41:28.067 --> 05:41:29.235
MORE WILL BE PROVIDED THIS
05:41:29.302 --> 05:41:30.803
YEAR'S BUDGET. AND AS YOU KNOW
05:41:30.870 --> 05:41:33.339
DR PAN. ONE SIZE DOES NOT FIT
05:41:33.406 --> 05:41:35.374
ALL WITH. WITH THE POPULATION
05:41:35.441 --> 05:41:37.944
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT- IT SO IT IS
05:41:38.010 --> 05:41:39.145
VERY DIFFICULT TO TRY TO SEE
05:41:39.212 --> 05:41:41.414
WHAT IT WILL BE. BECAUSE AS WE
05:41:41.480 --> 05:41:43.015
SAID AN INDIVIDUAL WILL HAVE A
05:41:43.082 --> 05:41:45.017
DEVELOP PLAN AND THEN THE JUDGE
05:41:45.084 --> 05:41:47.153
WILL BE ABLE TO SAY IS THAT
05:41:47.220 --> 05:41:48.087
ADEQUATE WHAT YOU'RE- PLANNING
05:41:48.154 --> 05:41:49.522
FOR THEIR HOUSING OR IS IT NOT.
05:41:49.589 --> 05:41:51.023
AND FOR THE COURT TO BE ABLE TO
05:41:51.090 --> 05:41:53.192
ORDER THAT. BUT AS YOU KNOW SOME
05:41:53.259 --> 05:41:55.228
PEOPLE MIGHT GO TO A SOBER
05:41:55.294 --> 05:41:56.562
LIVING SOME PEOPLE MIGHT GO. BE
05:41:56.629 --> 05:41:58.264
ABLE TO LIVE WITH THEIR FAMILY
05:41:58.331 --> 05:41:59.131
WHO NOW BE WILLING TO HAVE THEM
05:41:59.198 --> 05:42:01.200
BACK AT THE HOUSE IF THEY'RE
05:42:01.267 --> 05:42:02.101
UNDER MEDICATION AND UNDER CARE.
05:42:02.168 --> 05:42:04.103
SO WE REALIZE MORE NEEDS TO BE
05:42:04.170 --> 05:42:05.404
DONE BUT WITH THE OVER TWELVE
05:42:05.471 --> 05:42:06.606
BILLION DOLLARS INVESTMENTS THAT
05:42:06.672 --> 05:42:08.107
WE HAVE SENT DOWN AND MORE
05:42:08.174 --> 05:42:09.442
COMING THIS YEAR. WE KNOW THAT
05:42:09.508 --> 05:42:10.977
THERE'S OUT THERE A LOT THE
05:42:11.043 --> 05:42:13.746
FUNDING EXIST CURRENTLY. AND
05:42:13.813 --> 05:42:14.447
BECAUSE WE'RE ONLY TALKING
05:42:14.513 --> 05:42:17.550
BETWEEN SEVEN AND TWELVE
05:42:17.617 --> 05:42:19.385
THOUSAND PEOPLE THAT WILL EACH
05:42:19.452 --> 05:42:23.956
BE HAVE AN INDIVIDUALIZED PLAN.
05:42:24.023 --> 05:42:28.761
THAT. IT WILL BE ORDER WHAT IS A
05:42:28.828 --> 05:42:30.162
PRO FOR EACH INDIVIDUAL ALL
05:42:30.229 --> 05:42:33.332
RIGHT I APPRECIATE IN THE ARE.
05:42:33.399 --> 05:42:34.767
RIGHT IN A TO OF- COURSE ALSO
05:42:34.834 --> 05:42:36.903
THE INVEST ARE BEING MADE IN THE
05:42:36.969 --> 05:42:38.471
BUDGET- SO I I'M HERE I WANT
05:42:38.537 --> 05:42:40.306
SEND THE SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY
05:42:40.373 --> 05:42:41.474
TEAM BEFORE TO THINK I'VE BAY
05:42:41.540 --> 05:42:42.775
SERVE INDICATE THIS AND
05:42:42.842 --> 05:42:43.976
COMMITTEE BUT I'M GOING TO
05:42:44.043 --> 05:42:45.978
REITERATE THIS IS THAT AND I
05:42:46.045 --> 05:42:47.046
REALLY APPRECIATE MY GOOD FOR
05:42:47.113 --> 05:42:49.282
STOCKTON SAYING THAT. THE ISSUE
05:42:49.348 --> 05:42:50.983
IS THAT OFTENTIMES THE EVEN ON
05:42:51.050 --> 05:42:52.952
THE LINE AND I THINK THAT'S ALSO
05:42:53.019 --> 05:42:54.287
WHAT THE SECRETARY OF HEALTH AND
05:42:54.353 --> 05:42:55.721
HUMAN SERVICES SAID AS WELL AND
05:42:55.788 --> 05:42:57.657
THAT'S MY CONCERN IS THAT ALL
05:42:57.723 --> 05:42:58.591
VESTING ALL THIS MONEY IN
05:42:58.658 --> 05:43:00.259
HOUSING. I ALSO WANT TO BE SURE
05:43:00.326 --> 05:43:03.629
THAT BY THE TIME SOMEONE ENDS UP
05:43:03.696 --> 05:43:04.997
IN. COURT TEN THE INJURY CARE
05:43:05.064 --> 05:43:06.966
COURT DAY SHOULD BE AT THE FRONT
05:43:07.033 --> 05:43:08.434
OF THE LINE FOR WHATEVER HOUSING
05:43:08.501 --> 05:43:09.135
CONSISTENT WITH THE HOUSING
05:43:09.201 --> 05:43:10.937
PLAN. NOW MAYBE WE DON'T HAVE IT
05:43:11.003 --> 05:43:12.204
READY YET AND WE'RE STILL STREET
05:43:12.271 --> 05:43:14.240
BUT IF IT'S THERE. THEY SHOULD
05:43:14.307 --> 05:43:15.174
BE WAITING WAITING WAITING THEY
05:43:15.241 --> 05:43:16.943
SHOULD BE AT THE FRONT OF THE
05:43:17.009 --> 05:43:18.177
LINE. OKAY SO I'M GONNA MAKE
05:43:18.244 --> 05:43:20.279
THAT PITCH SO WHEN HIS OF
05:43:20.346 --> 05:43:21.847
ASSEMBLY TO BE A LITTLE MORE
05:43:21.914 --> 05:43:23.049
EXPLICIT ABOUT THAT. THAT IS.
05:43:23.115 --> 05:43:26.385
OUR SO FAR THAT YOU'RE IN THE UP
05:43:26.452 --> 05:43:28.387
IN THE KARAKUL. AND JUDGE OF THE
05:43:28.454 --> 05:43:30.656
CARE IF IT HAS A HOUSING PLAN
05:43:30.723 --> 05:43:31.257
WHICH IS REQUIRED UNDER YOUR
05:43:31.324 --> 05:43:36.562
BELT. AT THE- THAT. THAT HOUSING
05:43:36.629 --> 05:43:38.097
PLAN THERE A FRONTLINE TO GET
05:43:38.164 --> 05:43:38.998
THAT THAT THEY DON'T HAVE TO
05:43:39.065 --> 05:43:41.067
KEEP WEIGHT IN AN I REALIZE
05:43:41.133 --> 05:43:42.335
MAYBE OTHER PEOPLE ONLINE IT'S
05:43:42.401 --> 05:43:43.803
BETTER BUT IF YOU'RE AT THE
05:43:43.869 --> 05:43:45.338
POINT WHERE YOU HAVE TO REQUIRE
05:43:45.404 --> 05:43:46.772
CARE TOWARDS GETS CUT IN FRONT A
05:43:46.839 --> 05:43:48.274
LINE BECAUSE EACH YEAR IN
05:43:48.341 --> 05:43:48.908
CONSIDERABLE STRAITS AS LONG AS
05:43:48.975 --> 05:43:50.977
YOU'RE UNDER THE CARE COURT IT
05:43:51.043 --> 05:43:52.945
SO I DO WANT TO SAY THAT THE
05:43:53.012 --> 05:43:54.814
OTHER THING I'M JUST GONNA SAY
05:43:54.880 --> 05:43:55.614
BRIEFLY WHICH I KNOWS LITTLE
05:43:55.681 --> 05:43:56.849
BEYOND THE PURVIEW BUT KNOWS
05:43:56.916 --> 05:43:58.484
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THE BUDGET I
05:43:58.551 --> 05:44:00.186
THINK IT'S GOING TO PORT THAT
05:44:00.252 --> 05:44:01.487
OUR COUNTY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
05:44:01.554 --> 05:44:02.121
SYSTEM WHICH WERE ALSO COUNTING
05:44:02.188 --> 05:44:04.090
ON. TO BE ABLE TO DO A LOT OF
05:44:04.156 --> 05:44:05.257
DIFFERENT THINGS TO MAKE THE
05:44:05.324 --> 05:44:07.059
CARE COURT WORK NEEDS TO GET
05:44:07.126 --> 05:44:08.995
FUNDING AS WELL TO BE ABLE TO DO
05:44:09.061 --> 05:44:10.663
THOSE FUNCTIONS AND THAT'S
05:44:10.730 --> 05:44:11.297
SOMETHING THAT YOU KNOW WE CAN
05:44:11.364 --> 05:44:13.799
BE SURE THAT IT AGAIN TO MAKE A
05:44:13.866 --> 05:44:15.001
SUCCESSFUL SO I KNOW IT'S A
05:44:15.067 --> 05:44:16.836
LITTLE PERHAPS BEYOND YOUR BILL
05:44:16.902 --> 05:44:20.940
ABOUT BUDGET. FOR THAT THEY HAVE
05:44:21.007 --> 05:44:23.175
. PARTS OF THE IF YOU EVER HELP
05:44:23.242 --> 05:44:24.777
. SYSTEM CAN ALSO DO THEIR RAW.
05:44:24.844 --> 05:44:26.245
THAT YOU'RE- IN THAT THE BILL'S
05:44:26.312 --> 05:44:27.413
GONE REQUIRED ON. SO I PREACH.
05:44:27.480 --> 05:44:29.382
THE WORK. I KNOW THIS IS A- THE
05:44:29.448 --> 05:44:31.050
L. TEN. DAYS THE ON THE WHOLE
05:44:31.117 --> 05:44:32.952
LIST PEOPLE IN. YOU KNOW HAVE-
05:44:33.019 --> 05:44:34.787
IT'S GONNA BE IS A VERY. TIME
05:44:34.854 --> 05:44:35.521
DICK. KEEPING FORWARD I
05:44:35.588 --> 05:44:36.589
APPRECIATE YOUR LEADERSHIP AND-
05:44:36.655 --> 05:44:37.790
I'M CERTAINLY GOING TO SUPPORT
05:44:37.857 --> 05:44:39.025
THE BILL I URGE OTHER PEOPLE
05:44:39.091 --> 05:44:41.293
SUPPORT THE BILL BUT I ALSO
05:44:41.360 --> 05:44:42.161
THINK THERE'S CONTINUE WORK TO
05:44:42.228 --> 05:44:44.630
DO. AND I KNOW THAT YOU'RE GOING
05:44:44.697 --> 05:44:45.498
TO CREATE A FOLDER THANK YOU.
05:44:45.564 --> 05:44:50.269
THANK SENATE PANEL. THANK THAT A
05:44:50.336 --> 05:44:52.271
PRESIDENTIAL POLL FOLKS DOWN
05:44:52.338 --> 05:44:54.306
WHERE I COME FROM- WHEN THEY SEE
05:44:54.373 --> 05:44:56.175
ME ON THE STREET SAY IN THE OF
05:44:56.242 --> 05:44:58.411
THINKING ABOUT THIS CARE COURT
05:44:58.477 --> 05:44:59.545
PROPOSAL THEY SAY IT'S ABOUT
05:44:59.612 --> 05:45:01.547
TIME. SO I ONE OF CERTAINLY
05:45:01.614 --> 05:45:02.948
THANK THE GOVERNOR I WANT TO
05:45:03.015 --> 05:45:05.051
THANK THE PRO TEM I WANT TO
05:45:05.117 --> 05:45:06.152
THANK THE BILL AUTHORS AND
05:45:06.218 --> 05:45:07.553
OTHERS INVOLVED IN THIS EFFORT.
05:45:07.620 --> 05:45:09.321
COMMENDED THE EFFORT BECAUSE I
05:45:09.388 --> 05:45:11.357
THINK. EVERYONE IT'S A CRITICAL
05:45:11.424 --> 05:45:12.892
COMPONENT OF OUR ATTEMPT TO DEAL
05:45:12.958 --> 05:45:14.927
WITH. MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS
05:45:14.994 --> 05:45:17.630
THAT'S A LONG STANDING CRISIS-
05:45:17.696 --> 05:45:20.633
IN THE STATE I WILL NOTE THAT-
05:45:20.699 --> 05:45:23.402
DO AS YOU ALL KNOW DUE TO THE
05:45:23.469 --> 05:45:25.371
NINETEEN NINETY ONE- MENTAL
05:45:25.438 --> 05:45:26.939
HEALTH AND HEALTH REALIGNMENT OF
05:45:27.006 --> 05:45:29.275
FUNDING IN THE STATE. THERE ARE
05:45:29.341 --> 05:45:31.210
SIGNIFICANT FUNDING INEQUITIES
05:45:31.277 --> 05:45:34.280
COUNTY TO COUNTY NORTH TO SOUTH.
05:45:34.346 --> 05:45:36.882
EAST TO WEST IN THE STATE THOSE
05:45:36.949 --> 05:45:38.651
INEQUITIES REMAIN AND SO I'VE
05:45:38.717 --> 05:45:40.152
SAID THIS BEFORE I'LL SAY IT
05:45:40.219 --> 05:45:41.787
AGAIN IN ORDER FOR THIS PROGRAM
05:45:41.854 --> 05:45:44.056
TO BE EFFICIENT EFFECTIVE. AND
05:45:44.123 --> 05:45:45.825
ROBUST WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO
05:45:45.891 --> 05:45:47.860
FIGURE OUT A WAY TO DEAL WITH
05:45:47.927 --> 05:45:49.595
THOSE FUNDING INEQUITIES PERHAPS
05:45:49.662 --> 05:45:53.299
NOT. THROUGH RESTRUCTURING THE
05:45:53.365 --> 05:45:53.933
NINETEEN NINETY ONE REALIGNMENT
05:45:53.999 --> 05:45:56.202
BUT RATHER THROUGH AUG TATIAN
05:45:56.268 --> 05:45:58.504
FROM THE GENERAL FUND BUDGET.
05:45:58.571 --> 05:45:59.839
AND IT'S ESSENTIAL THAT WE DO
05:45:59.905 --> 05:46:02.174
THAT BECAUSE IT'S WELL WE HAVE
05:46:02.241 --> 05:46:04.410
APPROPRIATED. BILLIONS OF
05:46:04.477 --> 05:46:06.145
DOLLARS FOR HOUSING THIS PROGRAM
05:46:06.212 --> 05:46:08.481
IS MORE THAN JUST HOUSING IT'S
05:46:08.547 --> 05:46:10.749
ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT.
05:46:10.816 --> 05:46:13.018
IT'S ABOUT PERSONNEL AT THE
05:46:13.085 --> 05:46:14.653
COUNTY LEVEL TO PROVIDE THAT
05:46:14.720 --> 05:46:16.789
SORT OF TREATMENT. IT'S ABOUT
05:46:16.856 --> 05:46:21.861
ACUTE CARE SUB ACUTE CARE AND
05:46:21.927 --> 05:46:25.030
SUB SUB ACUTE CARE MATT. TO HAVE
05:46:25.097 --> 05:46:26.532
OF THE FUNDING DO THAT I'M
05:46:26.599 --> 05:46:29.902
CONFIDENT THAT LEADERSHIP MY
05:46:29.969 --> 05:46:31.604
BUDGET LEADERSHIP WILL PURSUE
05:46:31.670 --> 05:46:32.204
THAT DURING THE BUDGET
05:46:32.271 --> 05:46:34.206
NEGOTIATIONS. I LOOK FORWARD TO
05:46:34.273 --> 05:46:35.674
SEEING FAULTS AND I CERTAINLY
05:46:35.741 --> 05:46:38.611
URGE AN AYE VOTE ON THIS MEASURE
05:46:38.677 --> 05:46:39.745
THANK YOU CENTER ROTH SENATOR
05:46:39.812 --> 05:46:45.885
BATES. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT
05:46:45.951 --> 05:46:49.221
AND- LET ME OUT OF MY ARM. OF A
05:46:49.288 --> 05:46:50.656
GREAT APPRECIATION TO THE
05:46:50.723 --> 05:46:52.258
AUTHORS OF THIS MEASURE IT IS SO
05:46:52.324 --> 05:46:54.360
VERY IMPORTANT IN IS CLEAR TO
05:46:54.426 --> 05:46:56.462
ALL OF US AND ALL OF OUR
05:46:56.529 --> 05:46:57.096
CONSTITUENTS THAT WHAT WE ARE
05:46:57.163 --> 05:46:58.731
DOING ON HOMELESSNESS NEEDS NEW
05:46:58.797 --> 05:47:00.199
APPROACHES. WE DO NEED
05:47:00.266 --> 05:47:01.767
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THE RESOURCES
05:47:01.834 --> 05:47:03.335
WE'VE EXPANDED AND WE NEED
05:47:03.402 --> 05:47:05.337
ACCOUNTABILITY FOR THE PROGRAMS
05:47:05.404 --> 05:47:06.438
THE GOVERNORS CARE COURT
05:47:06.505 --> 05:47:09.074
PROPOSAL IS. ABSOLUTELY A STEP
05:47:09.141 --> 05:47:11.243
IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION. IT IS A
05:47:11.310 --> 05:47:13.812
NEW APPROACH AND WHILE I
05:47:13.879 --> 05:47:14.747
HEARTILY SUPPORT THIS BILL
05:47:14.813 --> 05:47:17.683
MOVING. WE DO NEED TO BE. NOT TO
05:47:17.750 --> 05:47:19.318
SET COUNTIES ON COURTS UP FOR
05:47:19.385 --> 05:47:21.020
THE FAILURE. THE CHARACTER
05:47:21.086 --> 05:47:22.021
PROGRAM INCLUDES NEW
05:47:22.087 --> 05:47:23.789
RESPONSIBILITIES AND OBLIGATIONS
05:47:23.856 --> 05:47:25.791
IMPOSED ON COUNTIES AND COURTS
05:47:25.858 --> 05:47:27.126
THAT REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
05:47:27.193 --> 05:47:28.928
RESOURCES AND ONGOING FOR
05:47:28.994 --> 05:47:30.763
FUNDING. IN ORDER FOR THE
05:47:30.829 --> 05:47:32.765
PROPOSAL TO WORK AND BE
05:47:32.831 --> 05:47:33.799
IMPLEMENTED AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
05:47:33.866 --> 05:47:35.134
THE GOVERNOR AND THE LEGISLATURE
05:47:35.201 --> 05:47:36.869
NEED TO COMMIT TO ADEQUATE AND
05:47:36.936 --> 05:47:39.138
SUSTAINABLE SUSTAINABLE FUNDING
05:47:39.205 --> 05:47:40.673
FOR COUNTIES. GIVEN THE
05:47:40.739 --> 05:47:43.209
MAGNITUDE OF CARE COURT PROPOSAL
05:47:43.275 --> 05:47:44.977
AND CAPACITY ISSUES THROUGHOUT
05:47:45.044 --> 05:47:46.712
THE STATE AROUND BEHAVIORAL
05:47:46.779 --> 05:47:48.747
HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE WORKFORCE
05:47:48.814 --> 05:47:51.083
AND HOUSING THE BEST PATH TO
05:47:51.150 --> 05:47:52.851
SUCCESS FOR IMPLEMENTERS SHOULD
05:47:52.918 --> 05:47:54.553
BE GROUNDED IN A THOUGHTFUL.
05:47:54.620 --> 05:47:58.490
TRANSPARENT IN INCREMENTAL FEES
05:47:58.557 --> 05:48:01.727
AND MODEL AND EIGHTEEN. YES
05:48:01.794 --> 05:48:03.362
HOWEVER WE DO NEED TO GET ON TO
05:48:03.429 --> 05:48:05.431
IT WE CAN'T HAVE YEARS OF DELAY
05:48:05.497 --> 05:48:06.899
THIS APPROACH WILL AFFORD
05:48:06.966 --> 05:48:08.367
STAKEHOLDERS AT ALL LEVELS OF
05:48:08.434 --> 05:48:10.302
GOVERNMENT THE OPPORTUNITY TO
05:48:10.369 --> 05:48:12.271
EXAMINE THE OUTCOMES CARE COURT
05:48:12.338 --> 05:48:14.540
PARTICIPANTS FOR CARE COURT
05:48:14.607 --> 05:48:15.774
PARTICIPANTS WORK THROUGH
05:48:15.841 --> 05:48:17.309
IMPLEMENTATION HURDLES AND
05:48:17.376 --> 05:48:18.911
DEVELOP A ROBUST AND SUCCESSFUL
05:48:18.978 --> 05:48:20.980
STATE WIDE ROLLOUT THE CARE
05:48:21.046 --> 05:48:22.848
COURT EFFORT MUST BE PAIRED WITH
05:48:22.915 --> 05:48:24.016
TREATMENT THERE'S NO REAL PATH
05:48:24.083 --> 05:48:26.352
TO SOLVING ARE HOMELESS YES
05:48:26.418 --> 05:48:28.520
CRISIS THAT DOES NOT INVOLVE
05:48:28.587 --> 05:48:32.491
EXPANDING TREATMENT CAPACITY TO
05:48:32.558 --> 05:48:34.960
THAT END WE NEED TO CONSIDER IT.
05:48:35.027 --> 05:48:36.128
INTEREST THAT WOULD PROVIDE
05:48:36.195 --> 05:48:38.330
ACCESS TO INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
05:48:38.397 --> 05:48:40.399
UNABLE TO CARE FOR THEMSELVES
05:48:40.466 --> 05:48:42.434
DUE TO UNTREATED ILLNESS OR
05:48:42.501 --> 05:48:43.936
ADDICTION IN WILL PROVIDE MOST
05:48:44.003 --> 05:48:45.037
IMPORTANTLY WILL PROVIDE THE
05:48:45.104 --> 05:48:46.572
RESOURCES ARE LOCAL COUNTY
05:48:46.639 --> 05:48:48.407
GOVERNMENTS ARE LOCAL
05:48:48.474 --> 05:48:49.208
GOVERNMENTS AND COUNTY
05:48:49.275 --> 05:48:50.576
GOVERNMENTS WILL NEED TO MEET
05:48:50.643 --> 05:48:53.412
THE EXPECTATIONS THAT ARE PLACED
05:48:53.479 --> 05:48:55.681
ON CALIFORNIA CARE COURT. NEED
05:48:55.748 --> 05:48:57.850
TO RESET REPORT. THE RAND
05:48:57.916 --> 05:48:59.351
CORPORATION AND FINANCED BY THE
05:48:59.418 --> 05:49:00.386
CALIFORNIA MENTAL HEALTH
05:49:00.452 --> 05:49:02.488
SERVICES AUTHORITY CALIFORNIA
05:49:02.554 --> 05:49:04.757
HAS A DEFICIT OF FORTY SEVEN
05:49:04.823 --> 05:49:06.191
HUNDRED SUB ACUTE AND ACUTE
05:49:06.258 --> 05:49:08.327
PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT BEDS. AND
05:49:08.394 --> 05:49:10.095
IF WE HAVE THE LOWER ACUITY
05:49:10.162 --> 05:49:11.997
ACUITY TREATMENT BEDS IN
05:49:12.064 --> 05:49:14.066
COMMUNITY RESIDENTIAL FACILITIES
05:49:14.133 --> 05:49:17.336
THAT DEFICIT INCREASES TO
05:49:17.403 --> 05:49:17.870
SEVENTY SEVEN HUNDRED THE
05:49:17.936 --> 05:49:19.171
REPORTS FIRST RECOMMENDATION IS
05:49:19.238 --> 05:49:20.939
THAT A SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT IS
05:49:21.006 --> 05:49:23.809
NEEDED INSIDE. PSYCHIATRIC BEEN
05:49:23.876 --> 05:49:25.844
INFRASTRUCTURE AND WE NEED TO
05:49:25.911 --> 05:49:27.046
CREATE A NEWS NEW CENTERS THAT
05:49:27.112 --> 05:49:28.781
ARE STATE UNIVERSITIES FOR
05:49:28.847 --> 05:49:30.215
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH FOCUS
05:49:30.282 --> 05:49:32.985
ADDITIONAL. EDUCATION AND
05:49:33.052 --> 05:49:34.720
DEGREES IN ORDER TO EXPAND THE
05:49:34.787 --> 05:49:37.189
TREATMENT. IN MY OWN DISTRICT.
05:49:37.256 --> 05:49:39.925
OF ABOUT TWO YEARS AGO- WE COULD
05:49:39.992 --> 05:49:41.994
NOT GET PSYCHIATRISTS AVAILABLE
05:49:42.061 --> 05:49:45.197
ARE IN OUR EMERGENCY ROOMS FOR
05:49:45.264 --> 05:49:46.265
FIFTY ONE FIFTY FOLKS BROUGHT
05:49:46.332 --> 05:49:48.400
THEIR IT WAS REALLY REALLY A
05:49:48.467 --> 05:49:49.401
CRISIS IF WE DO NOT BUILD THE
05:49:49.468 --> 05:49:51.003
TREATMENT CAPACITY NOW IT WILL
05:49:51.070 --> 05:49:52.171
NEVER DO IT IN TOO MANY
05:49:52.237 --> 05:49:54.306
CALIFORNIANS WILL CONTINUE. TO
05:49:54.373 --> 05:49:56.375
NEEDLESSLY SUFFER AGAIN I
05:49:56.442 --> 05:49:58.911
SUPPORT MOVING S. B. THIRTEEN
05:49:58.977 --> 05:49:59.812
THIRTY EIGHT FORWARD BUT IT MUST
05:49:59.878 --> 05:50:01.413
BE WORKED ON IN THE ASSEMBLY TO
05:50:01.480 --> 05:50:03.048
MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE NOT
05:50:03.115 --> 05:50:04.616
SETTING OUR COUNTIES AND COURTS
05:50:04.683 --> 05:50:07.252
UP FOR FAILURE HE MUST ALSO BE
05:50:07.319 --> 05:50:08.821
PAIRED WITH EXPANDED TREATMENT
05:50:08.887 --> 05:50:10.923
CAPACITY. AND THAT CAN BE FUNDED
05:50:10.989 --> 05:50:12.391
BY THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE
05:50:12.458 --> 05:50:13.692
MENTAL HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE
05:50:13.759 --> 05:50:15.694
FUND AND I WOULD LIKE TO SEE
05:50:15.761 --> 05:50:17.463
HERE THAT THE BUDGET PROPOSAL
05:50:17.529 --> 05:50:19.198
REAP RECENTLY SUBMITTED AND
05:50:19.264 --> 05:50:20.699
DISCUSSED BY THE REPUBLICAN
05:50:20.766 --> 05:50:22.434
CAUCUS TO THAT END. AND I
05:50:22.501 --> 05:50:26.405
STRONGLY SUPPORT OSWIN AN AYE
05:50:26.472 --> 05:50:28.073
VOTE ON THIS MEASURE. THANK YOU
05:50:28.140 --> 05:50:30.542
CENTER BATES CENTER ALSO. THANK
05:50:30.609 --> 05:50:33.779
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT- I TO RISE
05:50:33.846 --> 05:50:36.515
IN SUPPORT WITH CONCERNS AND I'M
05:50:36.582 --> 05:50:38.417
SURE I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO
05:50:38.484 --> 05:50:42.654
HAS- CONCERNS- SPEAKING OF WHICH
05:50:42.721 --> 05:50:47.159
WITH IT. AND I'M NOT OPPOSED TO
05:50:47.226 --> 05:50:49.261
THE QUICKNESS OF PUTTING FORWARD
05:50:49.328 --> 05:50:51.697
OF THIS FRAMEWORK UP. THERE ARE
05:50:51.764 --> 05:50:53.632
CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED
05:50:53.699 --> 05:50:55.734
BY A NUMBER OF ORGANIZATIONS WHO
05:50:55.801 --> 05:50:58.604
I BELIEVE ARE GOOD ALLIES OF
05:50:58.670 --> 05:51:01.840
OURS ON ALL OF THE ISSUES- SO
05:51:01.907 --> 05:51:03.876
ONE QUESTION I HAVE IF I MAY AND
05:51:03.942 --> 05:51:06.178
PRESIDENT WE TAKE A QUESTION
05:51:06.245 --> 05:51:11.016
CENTER NUMBER. YEAH IS- TO
05:51:11.083 --> 05:51:13.652
ADDRESS THE REMAINING CONCERNS
05:51:13.719 --> 05:51:15.788
WHAT DO YOU SEE WHERE IS THE
05:51:15.854 --> 05:51:18.190
ENGAGEMENT PROCESS THAT WE CAN
05:51:18.257 --> 05:51:20.125
CREATE OR THAT YOU'VE ALREADY
05:51:20.192 --> 05:51:22.261
THOUGHT OF CREATING- SECOND
05:51:22.327 --> 05:51:24.763
BECAUSE WE ALL WE BOTH WORK ON
05:51:24.830 --> 05:51:28.033
OF THE JUDICIAL ISSUES IN THE
05:51:28.100 --> 05:51:30.169
STATE IS- WHAT DO YOU SEE AS-
05:51:30.235 --> 05:51:33.405
THE OF THE JUDICIAL SYSTEM IN
05:51:33.472 --> 05:51:35.274
LIGHT OF SO MANY OTHER GREAT
05:51:35.340 --> 05:51:37.209
NEEDS THAT WE HAVE LIKE-
05:51:37.276 --> 05:51:39.311
EVICTIONS OR- CRIMINAL THERE'S
05:51:39.378 --> 05:51:40.946
SO MANY THINGS THAT HAPPENED
05:51:41.013 --> 05:51:44.516
THAT THE BACKLOG. AND THEN-
05:51:44.583 --> 05:51:47.753
THREE IS BECAUSE OF THE- BLACK
05:51:47.820 --> 05:51:49.521
AND BROWN BEING MORE
05:51:49.588 --> 05:51:51.657
MISDIAGNOSED OR OVER DIAGNOSED
05:51:51.723 --> 05:51:53.959
WITH THE SAME MENTAL ILLNESSES
05:51:54.026 --> 05:51:55.394
HOW DO WE MAKE SURE THAT THIS
05:51:55.461 --> 05:51:58.197
DOESN'T SPILL OVER INTO A NEW
05:51:58.263 --> 05:52:02.134
SYSTEM- THAT ALSO BECOME SORT OF
05:52:02.201 --> 05:52:07.172
A NEW- WAY OF. OF A
05:52:07.239 --> 05:52:09.007
INCARCERATING OF THOSE
05:52:09.074 --> 05:52:11.076
INDIVIDUALS SO IF YOU COULD
05:52:11.143 --> 05:52:13.412
RESPOND- ROBERT SURE THANK YOU
05:52:13.479 --> 05:52:14.947
LET ME LET ME ADDRESS THOSE IN
05:52:15.013 --> 05:52:16.915
REVERSE ORDER IF I CAN ROOM
05:52:16.982 --> 05:52:18.684
REMEMBER THAT PERSONAL IN TERMS
05:52:18.750 --> 05:52:21.186
OF PRESERVATION- THIS IS A COURT
05:52:21.253 --> 05:52:22.821
THAT IS IN THE CIVIL
05:52:22.888 --> 05:52:24.456
JURISDICTION IS NOT A CRIMINAL
05:52:24.523 --> 05:52:25.958
COURT AND I MENTION
05:52:26.024 --> 05:52:27.459
COLLABORATIVE COURTS IT IS NOT A
05:52:27.526 --> 05:52:28.260
CULT IS A COUSIN OF
05:52:28.327 --> 05:52:29.962
COLLABORATIVE COURTS ITS PURPOSE
05:52:30.028 --> 05:52:32.164
IS TO MAKE SURE THAT WE GET
05:52:32.231 --> 05:52:33.932
PEOPLE BACK UP ON THEIR FEET BUT
05:52:33.999 --> 05:52:36.969
BUT THERE IS NO- COMPONENT THIS
05:52:37.035 --> 05:52:39.238
PROVIDES FOR. INCARCERATION
05:52:39.304 --> 05:52:41.406
NUMBER ONE TERMS OF OTHER ISSUES
05:52:41.473 --> 05:52:42.908
THAT BEEN RAISED- ARE A
05:52:42.975 --> 05:52:43.809
COLLEAGUE AND FRIEND FROM
05:52:43.876 --> 05:52:45.944
SACRAMENTO RAISED ISSUES
05:52:46.011 --> 05:52:46.979
CONCERNING PRIVATIZATION OF
05:52:47.045 --> 05:52:48.480
HOUSING THAT IS IN THE BILL
05:52:48.547 --> 05:52:51.016
PRIORITIZING HOUSING IN FACT IT
05:52:51.083 --> 05:52:52.150
IF THE COUNTY IS THE CAPACITY
05:52:52.217 --> 05:52:54.052
THE COURT CAN ORDER THE MONEY TO
05:52:54.119 --> 05:52:55.354
PROVIDE THAT HOUSING AND I
05:52:55.420 --> 05:52:57.289
BELIEVE THAT- HAS BEEN ADDRESSED
05:52:57.356 --> 05:52:59.458
AND WILL CONTINUE TO ADDRESS
05:52:59.525 --> 05:53:00.926
THAT IN TERMS OF MY CALLING FROM
05:53:00.993 --> 05:53:03.228
RIVERSIDE- IN FUNDING FUNDING IS
05:53:03.295 --> 05:53:04.596
OBVIOUSLY THE UNDERPINNING OF
05:53:04.663 --> 05:53:06.965
ANY POLICY AND THERE IS
05:53:07.032 --> 05:53:08.534
SIGNIFICANT FUNDING. THE
05:53:08.600 --> 05:53:12.170
GOVERNOR'S I THINK THAT WE ARE-
05:53:12.237 --> 05:53:14.373
IN AGREE WITH INTER OF A PRO-
05:53:14.439 --> 05:53:16.642
HOUSING TERMS OF THE- ISSUE
05:53:16.708 --> 05:53:18.210
CONCERNING POTENTIAL RACIAL
05:53:18.277 --> 05:53:21.046
DISPARITY THAT IS CLEARLY. NOT
05:53:21.113 --> 05:53:23.081
THE INTENT- THE INTENT IS TO
05:53:23.148 --> 05:53:26.184
HELP ALL THOSE OF THOSE SEVEN TO
05:53:26.251 --> 05:53:28.320
TWELVE THOUSAND FOLKS WHO ARE-
05:53:28.387 --> 05:53:30.255
SERIOUSLY AFFLICTED WITH MENTAL
05:53:30.322 --> 05:53:30.989
ILLNESS IN PARTICULAR
05:53:31.056 --> 05:53:33.292
SCHIZOPHRENIA. THAT THAT THAT'S
05:53:33.358 --> 05:53:35.160
THE PURPOSE IS TO ADDRESS THAT
05:53:35.227 --> 05:53:38.230
UNIVERSE IRRESPECTIVE OF YOU
05:53:38.297 --> 05:53:42.301
KNOW REYES- THE- OTHER ISSUES
05:53:42.367 --> 05:53:44.102
RAISED IN TERMS OF THE COURT
05:53:44.169 --> 05:53:46.638
JUDICIAL. SIX ANOTHER QUESTION
05:53:46.705 --> 05:53:49.141
ANOTHER IMPORTANT ISSUE- YES
05:53:49.207 --> 05:53:50.008
THERE'S ADDITIONAL FUNDING THAT
05:53:50.075 --> 05:53:52.578
PROVIDED TO THE COURTS TO ALSO.
05:53:52.644 --> 05:53:54.246
MAKE SURE THAT WE DO THINGS LIKE
05:53:54.313 --> 05:53:56.648
WE PROVIDE THAT ADDITIONAL
05:53:56.715 --> 05:53:57.616
CAPACITY IN THE COURTS.
05:53:57.683 --> 05:53:59.384
ADDITIONALLY TRAINING FOR JUDGES
05:53:59.451 --> 05:54:00.919
THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THAT MIGHT
05:54:00.986 --> 05:54:04.222
NATURALLY COME- TO- SOMEONE WHO
05:54:04.289 --> 05:54:05.857
EITHER IS OR SPIRES TO BE A
05:54:05.924 --> 05:54:07.726
JUDGE AND SO- WE DO RECOGNIZE
05:54:07.793 --> 05:54:08.961
THAT ADDITIONAL TRAINING IS
05:54:09.027 --> 05:54:11.163
GOING TO HAVE TO BE PROVIDED. TO
05:54:11.229 --> 05:54:12.164
THE JUDGES THIS IS THIS IS A
05:54:12.230 --> 05:54:14.600
DIFFERENT SORT OF ANIMAL FOR THE
05:54:14.666 --> 05:54:16.168
COURTS BUT ONE I'M CONFIDENT
05:54:16.234 --> 05:54:18.036
THEY'LL HANDLE AND HAVING A
05:54:18.103 --> 05:54:19.938
JUDGE WHO HAS RESPONSIBILITY
05:54:20.005 --> 05:54:22.240
ACCOUNTABILITY IS A CRITICAL
05:54:22.307 --> 05:54:24.309
COMPONENT I HOPE THAT'S-
05:54:24.376 --> 05:54:25.844
ADDRESSED AT LEAST SOME OF YOUR
05:54:25.911 --> 05:54:27.813
ISSUES. THANK YOU IT CENTER
05:54:27.879 --> 05:54:29.982
RECOMMENDED. CENTER EGGMAN YEAH
05:54:30.048 --> 05:54:31.249
AND I WANTED TO RESPOND
05:54:31.316 --> 05:54:33.518
SPECIFICALLY TO THE ISSUE OF
05:54:33.585 --> 05:54:36.588
BLACK AND BROWN- HISTORICALLY
05:54:36.655 --> 05:54:37.923
PEOPLE OF COLOR HAVE SOUGHT OUT
05:54:37.990 --> 05:54:39.524
MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT LESS AND
05:54:39.591 --> 05:54:41.793
HAVE HAD LESS ACCESS TO IT. AND
05:54:41.860 --> 05:54:43.962
WE KNOW THAT THE BEST WAY TO BE
05:54:44.029 --> 05:54:45.530
ABLE TO TREAT THEM EFFECTIVELY
05:54:45.597 --> 05:54:46.565
IS EARLIER INTERVENTION AND SO
05:54:46.632 --> 05:54:47.499
OFTEN TIMES PEOPLE DON'T GET
05:54:47.566 --> 05:54:49.034
CARE AND THEN END UP MUCH MORE
05:54:49.101 --> 05:54:50.902
INTENSIVE YEARS. CIRCUMSTANCES
05:54:50.969 --> 05:54:53.639
THAN OTHERS AND SO THE ISSUES
05:54:53.705 --> 05:54:56.942
AROUND ACCESS. IT EXIST
05:54:57.009 --> 05:54:59.244
HISTORICALLY. WITH THIS BILL
05:54:59.311 --> 05:55:01.146
DOES NOT AFFECT IT AT ALL BUT IT
05:55:01.213 --> 05:55:03.048
DOES MOVE ANYBODY WHO WHO I
05:55:03.115 --> 05:55:05.050
FITS THIS CRITERIA TO THE VERY
05:55:05.117 --> 05:55:07.786
FOR THE LINE TO MAKE SURE THEY
05:55:07.853 --> 05:55:09.821
GET THE HELP THEY NEED AND
05:55:09.888 --> 05:55:10.455
AGAIN. IT'S SIMPLE IT IS.
05:55:10.522 --> 05:55:11.857
PENALIZING THESE FOLKS AT ALL IS
05:55:11.923 --> 05:55:14.359
ABOUT GETTING ON THE CARE THE
05:55:14.426 --> 05:55:15.460
HOUSING AND THE TREATMENT THAT
05:55:15.527 --> 05:55:18.463
THEY NEED. THANK YOU ALL SENATOR
05:55:18.530 --> 05:55:22.567
COM LONGER. THANK YOU AT MADAM
05:55:22.634 --> 05:55:26.805
PRESIDENT I TO RISE IN- CAUTIOUS
05:55:26.872 --> 05:55:29.141
SUPPORT OF THIS BILL I THINK
05:55:29.207 --> 05:55:31.276
IT'S INCREDIBLY AUDACIOUS I MEAN
05:55:31.343 --> 05:55:33.679
THIS IS NOT A BITE AT THE APPLE
05:55:33.745 --> 05:55:35.881
THIS IS THE ENTIRE ORCHARD- AND
05:55:35.947 --> 05:55:38.283
I'M ALSO HOPING THAT THE AUTHORS
05:55:38.350 --> 05:55:39.451
OF THIS BILL WILL TAKE INTO
05:55:39.518 --> 05:55:41.787
CONSIDERATION SOME OF THE- VERY
05:55:41.853 --> 05:55:44.690
VOCAL AND LEGITIMATE OPPOSITION
05:55:44.756 --> 05:55:46.091
THAT HAS BEEN RAISED I WANT TO
05:55:46.158 --> 05:55:48.260
ECHO SOME OF THE CONCERNS BY THE
05:55:48.326 --> 05:55:50.328
GOOD SENATOR FROM LOS ANGELES-
05:55:50.395 --> 05:55:52.164
WHO ALSO RAISE SOME OF THEM. YOU
05:55:52.230 --> 05:55:54.066
KNOW THIS BILL AS I READ IT
05:55:54.132 --> 05:55:55.600
IMPACTS FOUR DIFFERENT CODES THE
05:55:55.667 --> 05:55:57.402
PENAL CODE THE INSURANCE CODE
05:55:57.469 --> 05:55:58.837
THE WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS
05:55:58.904 --> 05:56:01.206
CODE AND HEALTH AND SAFETY AND
05:56:01.273 --> 05:56:02.607
SOMETIMES THOSE CODES DON'T WORK
05:56:02.674 --> 05:56:06.011
TOGETHER AND NOW WE HAVE CREATED
05:56:06.078 --> 05:56:09.281
THIS VERY. ASPIRATIONAL AND
05:56:09.347 --> 05:56:11.983
DYNAMIC OVERHAUL OF THE SYSTEM
05:56:12.050 --> 05:56:13.919
AND SO I THINK WE SHOULD BE VERY
05:56:13.985 --> 05:56:15.854
ROOTED IN REALITY THAT THIS IS
05:56:15.921 --> 05:56:18.790
NOT GOING TO- SEE SUCCESS
05:56:18.857 --> 05:56:20.826
OVERNIGHT BECAUSE THESE ARE
05:56:20.892 --> 05:56:23.195
SYSTEMS THAT HAVE BEEN IN PLACE
05:56:23.261 --> 05:56:25.263
FOR QUITE SOME TIME IN TERMS OF
05:56:25.330 --> 05:56:26.398
THEIR DEVELOPMENT HOW THEY'VE
05:56:26.465 --> 05:56:28.166
BEEN OPERATIONALIZED IMPLEMENTED
05:56:28.233 --> 05:56:30.569
WHERE THEY FAIL AND WHERE THEY
05:56:30.635 --> 05:56:34.039
LEAVE PEOPLE OUT. I YOU KNOW THE
05:56:34.106 --> 05:56:36.508
REALITY IS THAT YOU CANNOT
05:56:36.575 --> 05:56:39.077
LEGISLATE BY IN. IN THIS
05:56:39.144 --> 05:56:41.213
PROPOSAL IS GOING TO REQUIRE BUY
05:56:41.279 --> 05:56:42.781
IN FROM BOTH IMPACTED.
05:56:42.848 --> 05:56:48.086
COMMUNITIES FROM THE COURT. FROM
05:56:48.153 --> 05:56:52.424
COUNTIES AND FROM SYSTEMS AND
05:56:52.491 --> 05:56:54.059
MOST IMPORTANTLY IT'S GOING TO
05:56:54.126 --> 05:56:58.130
REQUIRE. AND INFUSION OF HUMAN
05:56:58.196 --> 05:57:00.632
CONTACT OF PEOPLE WORKING WITH
05:57:00.699 --> 05:57:02.801
PEOPLE AND WHAT YOU DON'T WANT
05:57:02.868 --> 05:57:04.469
IS TO CREATE A NEW SYSTEM OF
05:57:04.536 --> 05:57:05.871
CHUTES AND LADDERS WHERE PEOPLE
05:57:05.937 --> 05:57:09.674
ARE FUNNELED THROUGH NEW CHAOS.
05:57:09.741 --> 05:57:10.942
THAT'S BEEN DESIGNED TO HELP
05:57:11.009 --> 05:57:12.377
THEM GET TREATMENT OR FORCE THEM
05:57:12.444 --> 05:57:14.112
INTO TREATMENT AND IT DOESN'T
05:57:14.179 --> 05:57:15.947
WORK BECAUSE THERE IS NOT A
05:57:16.014 --> 05:57:18.483
HUMAN CONNECTION OF LIKE THE
05:57:18.550 --> 05:57:21.319
CHECK INS AND THE UNDERSTANDINGS
05:57:21.386 --> 05:57:24.856
AND THE NON JUDGMENTAL SUPPORT.
05:57:24.923 --> 05:57:27.292
I CAUTION THAT THERE ARE FAMILY
05:57:27.359 --> 05:57:29.761
MEMBERS AND FRIENDS OF PEOPLE
05:57:29.828 --> 05:57:30.595
WHO ARE IMPACTED. WHO ARE NOT
05:57:30.662 --> 05:57:33.932
INTERESTED IN THEIR PEOPLE'S
05:57:33.999 --> 05:57:36.067
WELL BEING AND SUCCESS. THERE
05:57:36.134 --> 05:57:38.136
ARE NOT VARIOUS FOLKS OUT THERE
05:57:38.203 --> 05:57:40.038
INTERESTED IN A GAMING SYSTEMS
05:57:40.105 --> 05:57:41.406
AND BE TAKING ADVANTAGE OF
05:57:41.473 --> 05:57:43.241
PEOPLE WHO NEED HELP AND HOW DO
05:57:43.308 --> 05:57:45.143
WE MAKE SURE WHEN WE'RE CREATING
05:57:45.210 --> 05:57:45.977
A SYSTEM THAT WE ARE NOT
05:57:46.044 --> 05:57:48.013
LEANING. YOU KNOW BECAUSE YOU
05:57:48.079 --> 05:57:49.214
HAVE TO HAVE THE SUPPORT FROM
05:57:49.281 --> 05:57:51.049
THE FAMILY MEMBER OR THIS PERSON
05:57:51.116 --> 05:57:52.984
IS GOING TO YOU KNOW WRITE IN A
05:57:53.051 --> 05:57:54.219
LETTER AND IS THERE INVOLVED IN
05:57:54.286 --> 05:57:56.788
THE DECISION MAKING OF THIS
05:57:56.855 --> 05:57:58.523
PERSON'S HEALTH AND WELL BEING
05:57:58.590 --> 05:57:59.891
WHAT IT THE CHECKS AND BALANCES
05:57:59.958 --> 05:58:01.059
TO MAKE SURE THAT. THE
05:58:01.126 --> 05:58:02.127
INTERESTED IN THAT. AND SUCCESS.
05:58:02.194 --> 05:58:03.829
ARE AT THE TABLE. AND I ALSO
05:58:03.895 --> 05:58:05.330
HOPE THAT THIS DOESN'T CREATE A
05:58:05.397 --> 05:58:06.698
COTTAGE INDUSTRY FOR LAWYERS WHO
05:58:06.765 --> 05:58:07.866
ARE HELPING FAMILIES AND FRIENDS
05:58:07.933 --> 05:58:10.001
LIKE NAVIGATE THIS NEW THING.
05:58:10.068 --> 05:58:11.169
BECAUSE WE KNOW WHERE THAT CAN
05:58:11.236 --> 05:58:13.505
END UP. YOU KNOW LASTLY I JUST
05:58:13.572 --> 05:58:15.707
WANT TO SAY THAT- SELF
05:58:15.774 --> 05:58:18.877
DETERMINATION. IS INCREDIBLY.
05:58:18.944 --> 05:58:21.880
IMPORTANT IT IS PRIMARY FOR ME.
05:58:21.947 --> 05:58:23.782
AND IT'S PRIMARY FOR FOLKS FROM
05:58:23.849 --> 05:58:25.684
THE DISABILITY COMMUNITY. IT'S
05:58:25.750 --> 05:58:27.285
ALSO REALLY PRIMARY FOR FOLKS
05:58:27.352 --> 05:58:29.087
WHO ARE MENTALLY ON WELL IN FOR
05:58:29.154 --> 05:58:30.055
HOMELESS FOLKS AND FOR BLACK AND
05:58:30.121 --> 05:58:32.090
BROWN COMMUNITIES THAT FIND
05:58:32.157 --> 05:58:32.791
THEMSELVES IN THE SYSTEMS.
05:58:32.858 --> 05:58:34.526
DISPROPORTIONATELY AND I JUST
05:58:34.593 --> 05:58:36.661
WANT TO SHARE TWO STORIES THAT I
05:58:36.728 --> 05:58:37.896
THINK HELP RESONATE BOTH MY
05:58:37.963 --> 05:58:40.432
CONCERN. AND MY SUPPORT FOR THIS
05:58:40.498 --> 05:58:43.668
BILL. THE FIRST ONE IS. FATIMA
05:58:43.735 --> 05:58:47.639
FATIMA IS HOMELESS SHE HAS. HE'S
05:58:47.706 --> 05:58:49.541
HAVE AIDS HE'S BLIND HE'S
05:58:49.608 --> 05:58:55.080
HOMELESS. SHE THE WAS MOVED IN
05:58:55.146 --> 05:58:56.481
THE PROJECT ROOM KEY AFTER
05:58:56.548 --> 05:58:58.116
LIVING ON THE STREETS FOR A
05:58:58.183 --> 05:59:00.185
REALLY LONG TIME SHE HAS A CARE
05:59:00.252 --> 05:59:00.919
GIVER HER BOYFRIEND WHO'S ALSO
05:59:00.986 --> 05:59:03.088
HER DEALER AND HER PART TIME
05:59:03.154 --> 05:59:06.858
USER FRIEND. AND HER PAM. AND
05:59:06.925 --> 05:59:07.993
THEY BOTH ENDED UP IN PROJECT
05:59:08.059 --> 05:59:12.864
ROOM KEY. AND SHE- ENSURING THE
05:59:12.931 --> 05:59:15.133
STORY I WAS LIKE WELL YOU NEED
05:59:15.200 --> 05:59:17.435
TO GET AWAY FROM THIS MAN. AND
05:59:17.502 --> 05:59:19.170
THE FOLKS THE HEALTH CARE
05:59:19.237 --> 05:59:20.372
PROVIDERS SAID YEAH WE'VE BEEN
05:59:20.438 --> 05:59:22.007
TRYING TO DO THAT BUT SHE WON'T
05:59:22.073 --> 05:59:23.808
GO AND I SAID THIS DOESN'T MAKE
05:59:23.875 --> 05:59:25.076
ANY SENSE THEY BOTH ENDED UP IN
05:59:25.143 --> 05:59:27.579
PROJECT ROOM KEY THEN THERE WAS
05:59:27.646 --> 05:59:29.514
A SERIES OF EVENTS AND SHE GOT
05:59:29.581 --> 05:59:30.949
KICKED OUT- AND SHE ENDED UP
05:59:31.016 --> 05:59:33.485
PITCHING A TENT RIGHT NEXT DOOR.
05:59:33.551 --> 05:59:35.086
TO THE FACILITY SO SHE COULD BE
05:59:35.153 --> 05:59:38.189
CLOSE. TO HER FRIEND WHO WAS HER
05:59:38.256 --> 05:59:42.928
CARE GIVER HER PAMPER HER DEALER
05:59:42.994 --> 05:59:46.097
. ME AND PROVIDERS LIKE WHAT NOW
05:59:46.164 --> 05:59:48.233
SHE'S OUT GET HER NOW THAT SHE'S
05:59:48.300 --> 05:59:51.202
OUT HOW DO WE HELP HER GET AWAY
05:59:51.269 --> 05:59:53.004
FROM THIS PERSON. AND THEY SAID
05:59:53.071 --> 05:59:55.106
WELL YOU KNOW SHE HER BELIEF IS
05:59:55.173 --> 05:59:56.875
THAT SHE WOULD RATHER BE ABUSED
05:59:56.942 --> 05:59:58.843
BY THE PERSON THAT SHE KNOWS.
05:59:58.910 --> 06:00:00.745
WHO IS GETTING MONEY EVERY MONTH
06:00:00.812 --> 06:00:02.547
BECAUSE HE IS HER CARE GIVER SO
06:00:02.614 --> 06:00:04.716
HE'S GIVING HER MEDICATION HE'S
06:00:04.783 --> 06:00:06.584
GETTING HER AROUND BECAUSE SHE-
06:00:06.651 --> 06:00:08.920
IS BLIND- AND HE'S ALSO ABUSING
06:00:08.987 --> 06:00:10.989
HER. AND SHE SAID SHE WOULD
06:00:11.056 --> 06:00:12.223
RATHER BE WITH THAT PERSON THEN
06:00:12.290 --> 06:00:14.025
OUT ON THE STREET ALONE BEING
06:00:14.092 --> 06:00:15.226
ABUSED AND SEXUALIZED BY SO
06:00:15.293 --> 06:00:18.029
MANY. PEOPLE NOW IS SHE DEFIANT
06:00:18.096 --> 06:00:21.032
OR ISSUE SELF DETERMINANT. IT IS
06:00:21.099 --> 06:00:23.568
AT MY RIGHT TO DETERMINE THAT. I
06:00:23.635 --> 06:00:24.936
STILL HAVE CONFLICT ABOUT THE
06:00:25.003 --> 06:00:27.839
STORY ABOUT THE TEAM BUT FATIMA
06:00:27.906 --> 06:00:29.574
IS NOT ONE PERSON THERE ARE
06:00:29.641 --> 06:00:31.609
THOUSANDS OF THE TEAM IS OUT
06:00:31.676 --> 06:00:35.146
THERE. AND SHE PITCHED HER TENT
06:00:35.213 --> 06:00:37.949
NEXT TO WHERE HE WAS TO BE CLOSE
06:00:38.016 --> 06:00:41.152
TO A MAN WHO WAS ABUSING HER.
06:00:41.219 --> 06:00:44.189
THE SECOND STORY IS DAVID. DAVID
06:00:44.255 --> 06:00:47.492
SISTER- BABYSAT ME WHEN I WAS
06:00:47.559 --> 06:00:51.229
LITTLE. CLOSE FAMILY FRIEND. I
06:00:51.296 --> 06:00:54.566
HAD A DAVID WAS SMART AND
06:00:54.632 --> 06:00:58.203
ATTRACTIVE AND GOING PLACES
06:00:58.269 --> 06:01:03.174
DAVID. I TOOK A TRIP AND BECAME
06:01:03.241 --> 06:01:10.849
SCHIZOPHRENIC. AND DAVID. HIS HE
06:01:10.915 --> 06:01:13.018
WOULD EIGHT HE GOT HELP WHEN HE
06:01:13.084 --> 06:01:14.152
WANTED TO AND HE DIDN'T WHEN HE
06:01:14.219 --> 06:01:16.254
DIDN'T WANT TO DAVID WAS OVER
06:01:16.321 --> 06:01:18.156
EIGHTEEN AND SO THE DOCTOR SAID
06:01:18.223 --> 06:01:21.426
TO HIS MOTHER MY GOOD FRIEND WE
06:01:21.493 --> 06:01:23.395
CANNOT MANDATE DAVID TO GET HELP
06:01:23.461 --> 06:01:24.896
. SO THERE WERE DAYS WHEN DAVID
06:01:24.963 --> 06:01:26.998
WOULD WALK BY HIS MOTHER. AND
06:01:27.065 --> 06:01:29.634
DID NOT NOTICE HER AT ALL DID
06:01:29.701 --> 06:01:32.103
NOT RECOGNIZE HER. I WENT TO
06:01:32.170 --> 06:01:34.305
VISIT THEM DAVID WENT TO THE
06:01:34.372 --> 06:01:38.143
ROOM. HE WASTALKING TO HIMSELF
06:01:38.209 --> 06:01:40.578
IN A VOICE THAT WAS SO DEMONIC.
06:01:40.645 --> 06:01:42.480
THAT IT MADE ME DEEPLY AFRAID.
06:01:42.547 --> 06:01:44.649
DAVID TRIED TO SET THEIR CONDO
06:01:44.716 --> 06:01:48.019
ON FIRE. AND HE WAS THEY HAD TO
06:01:48.086 --> 06:01:51.823
GO. DAVID WALKED INTO LAKE
06:01:51.890 --> 06:01:58.630
MICHIGAN. AND HIS MOTHER. I HEAD
06:01:58.696 --> 06:02:00.365
TO IDENTIFY HIM AS A JOHN DOE
06:02:00.432 --> 06:02:03.068
WITH ATTACK ON HIS SPORT AT THE
06:02:03.134 --> 06:02:10.208
CORNERS. I GREW UP WITH DAVID.
06:02:10.275 --> 06:02:12.811
THEY DESERVE TO GET HELP. MAYBE
06:02:12.877 --> 06:02:17.982
THAT HELP. WOULD HAVE SAVED. BUT
06:02:18.049 --> 06:02:22.587
I DON'T KNOW. WHICH VOICE OR
06:02:22.654 --> 06:02:27.459
VOICE IS. FRANCINE OR THE
06:02:27.525 --> 06:02:30.929
DOCTORS OR DAVID. SHOULD HAVE
06:02:30.995 --> 06:02:35.333
LISTENED TO. DAVID IS WHY WE
06:02:35.400 --> 06:02:37.902
NEED SOMETHING LIKE THIS. FATIMA
06:02:37.969 --> 06:02:39.671
IS WHY WE NEED TO BE INCREDIBLY
06:02:39.737 --> 06:02:42.006
CAUTIOUS AND THOUGHTFUL ABOUT
06:02:42.073 --> 06:02:45.376
THE OPPOSITION. I DON'T TALK
06:02:45.443 --> 06:02:50.348
MUCH ABOUT DAVID. BUT IT IS VERY
06:02:50.415 --> 06:02:52.117
HARD IN OFTENTIMES FOLKS WHO ARE
06:02:52.183 --> 06:02:53.184
MENTALLY UNWELL AND HAVE
06:02:53.251 --> 06:02:56.387
SCHIZOPHRENIC ARE LEFT INTO THE
06:02:56.454 --> 06:02:59.657
MARGINS OF OUR SOCIETY. AND THEY
06:02:59.724 --> 06:03:02.627
DO HAVE A RIGHT. THEY HAVE A
06:03:02.694 --> 06:03:07.932
RIGHT. TO BE LISTENED TO. AND
06:03:07.999 --> 06:03:14.539
ONCE AGAIN. DAVID ABDICATE. OR
06:03:14.606 --> 06:03:17.308
WAS IT SELF DETERMINATION. THESE
06:03:17.375 --> 06:03:21.045
ARE SO IMPORTANT QUESTIONS THAT
06:03:21.112 --> 06:03:23.982
WE NEED TO REALLY MAKE SURE. WE
06:03:24.048 --> 06:03:27.852
GET RIGHT. SO I WILL BE
06:03:27.919 --> 06:03:29.320
SUPPORTING THIS BILL. BUT I WILL
06:03:29.387 --> 06:03:31.089
BE THINKING ABOUT THE- BOTH OF
06:03:31.156 --> 06:03:32.590
THOSE PEOPLE WHILE THIS MAKES
06:03:32.657 --> 06:03:37.495
ITS WAY. TO THE OTHER SIDE.
06:03:37.562 --> 06:03:39.164
BECAUSE BOTH OF THEIR STORIES
06:03:39.230 --> 06:03:42.834
ARE IMPORTANT. THANK YOU SIR
06:03:42.901 --> 06:03:49.107
WATER CERRO CHOKE. THANK YOU
06:03:49.174 --> 06:03:51.676
MADAM PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS. AS
06:03:51.743 --> 06:03:53.511
A PLANNING ON FILING SENATOR.
06:03:53.578 --> 06:03:57.782
FROM LA BUT I WANT TO THANK HER
06:03:57.849 --> 06:03:58.783
THOUGHTS FISHING HER THOUGHTS
06:03:58.850 --> 06:04:00.952
BECAUSE I ABSOLUTELY AGREE WITH
06:04:01.019 --> 06:04:03.288
THEM AND I ALSO AGREE WITH MANY
06:04:03.354 --> 06:04:06.191
OF THE COMMENTS I HAVE MADE ON
06:04:06.257 --> 06:04:07.525
THIS FLOOR TODAY. I LIKE TO
06:04:07.592 --> 06:04:11.162
THINK THE AUTHORS FOR THIS BILL
06:04:11.229 --> 06:04:12.697
. BECAUSE AS OUR SENATOR FROM
06:04:12.764 --> 06:04:15.400
RIVERSIDE MANSION MANY HAVE
06:04:15.466 --> 06:04:19.571
STATED IT'S ABOUT TIME. AND
06:04:19.637 --> 06:04:21.239
WE'RE LUCKY SUPPORTING THIS BILL
06:04:21.306 --> 06:04:23.174
TODAY DO RISE WITH CONCERNS THAT
06:04:23.241 --> 06:04:24.075
HAVE BEEN SHARED IN SOME THAT
06:04:24.142 --> 06:04:25.877
HAVEN'T YET I HAVE HEARD FROM
06:04:25.944 --> 06:04:27.879
MANY STAKEHOLDERS THAT THEY NEED
06:04:27.946 --> 06:04:30.682
MORE TIME TO IMPLEMENT THE NEW
06:04:30.748 --> 06:04:32.584
PROCESSES IN THIS BILL.
06:04:32.650 --> 06:04:34.485
ADDITIONALLY AS MENTIONED
06:04:34.552 --> 06:04:35.687
THEY'RE NOT ENOUGH RESOURCES
06:04:35.753 --> 06:04:38.423
CURRENTLY COMMITTED IN ORDER TO
06:04:38.489 --> 06:04:41.092
ENSURE THE SUCCESS OF THE SYSTEM
06:04:41.159 --> 06:04:42.360
. I DO HAVE A QUESTION TO THE
06:04:42.427 --> 06:04:44.963
AUTHOR. CENTER I'M BURKE WE TAKE
06:04:45.029 --> 06:04:47.665
A QUESTION- YES CENTER TROUBLE
06:04:47.732 --> 06:04:49.867
PLEASE PROCEED. WOULD YOU BE
06:04:49.934 --> 06:04:52.237
WILLING TO AMEND THE BILL IN THE
06:04:52.303 --> 06:04:54.372
ASSEMBLY TO PUSH THE TIMELINE
06:04:54.439 --> 06:04:56.774
BECAUSE THAT IS ONE OF THE-
06:04:56.841 --> 06:04:58.910
CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED.
06:04:58.977 --> 06:05:02.180
CENTER NUMBER OF THE- THE
06:05:02.247 --> 06:05:04.382
PROPOSAL HAS A VERY AGGRESSIVE
06:05:04.449 --> 06:05:06.918
TIMELINE AS IS APPROPRIATE FOR
06:05:06.985 --> 06:05:09.554
AN ISSUE THAT IS SIGNIFICANT AND
06:05:09.621 --> 06:05:11.623
IS A CUTE AS IT EXISTS TODAY
06:05:11.689 --> 06:05:15.326
CALIFORNIA BUT- WE ARE MINDFUL I
06:05:15.393 --> 06:05:17.195
SUPPOSE OF ALL SPEAK FOR MIKE
06:05:17.262 --> 06:05:18.696
JOIN AUTHOR WE ARE MINDFUL OF
06:05:18.763 --> 06:05:20.231
THE FACT THAT THAT THIS
06:05:20.298 --> 06:05:21.766
AGGRESSIVE TIMELINE- IS
06:05:21.833 --> 06:05:24.135
IMPORTANT THAT WE STAY ON TRACK
06:05:24.202 --> 06:05:26.037
BUT WE DO THIS RIGHT. AND SO YES
06:05:26.104 --> 06:05:29.107
WE ARE GOING TO BE FLEXIBLE AS
06:05:29.173 --> 06:05:31.042
TO THE TIMELINE WE DON'T WANT TO
06:05:31.109 --> 06:05:32.310
DELAY THIS TOO LONG WE WANT TO
06:05:32.377 --> 06:05:34.212
MAKE SURE WE GET IT RIGHT SO THE
06:05:34.279 --> 06:05:36.581
SHORT ANSWER IS YES. THANK YOU
06:05:36.648 --> 06:05:40.485
VERY MUCH- SENATORS AND THAT
06:05:40.551 --> 06:05:43.454
THANK YOU VERY MUCH CENTERED
06:05:43.521 --> 06:05:45.823
SHOWBOAT CENTER NIELSEN. MADAM
06:05:45.890 --> 06:05:49.827
LADIES GEM OF THE SENATE I WANT
06:05:49.894 --> 06:05:51.929
. RECORD A LITTLE BIT OF HISTORY
06:05:51.996 --> 06:05:54.332
HERE JUST TO. INSURE THE
06:05:54.399 --> 06:05:56.100
CONFERENCE AND WHERE THIS IS
06:05:56.167 --> 06:05:58.670
HEADED. LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT
06:05:58.736 --> 06:06:02.974
PROGRAM MAYBE. BUT THE PATTERN.
06:06:03.041 --> 06:06:08.012
IS THE ONE FIX THAT. MY STAFF
06:06:08.079 --> 06:06:10.815
WERE ABLE TO DIG UP A- ARTICLE
06:06:10.882 --> 06:06:13.117
IN THE PICTURE ABOUT THE SIGNING
06:06:13.184 --> 06:06:15.486
OF THE GAIN PROGRAM. IN THE
06:06:15.553 --> 06:06:17.355
PICTURE I AM ANISE WOULD CENTER
06:06:17.422 --> 06:06:20.692
GARAMENDI. THE SETTLEMENT KHAN
06:06:20.758 --> 06:06:22.160
YOUNIS SEVEN MINS AGNES. IN THE
06:06:22.226 --> 06:06:25.963
MID EIGHTIES. GAINED
06:06:26.030 --> 06:06:28.733
DRAMATICALLY CHANGED WELFARE IN
06:06:28.800 --> 06:06:32.603
CALIFORNIA. WHICH WAS NOT ABOUT
06:06:32.670 --> 06:06:34.138
DEPENDENCE BUT ABOUT EMPOWERMENT
06:06:34.205 --> 06:06:37.175
ABOUT HELP. LIKE WE DO AND
06:06:37.241 --> 06:06:39.043
SPECIAL ED IN OUR SCHOOLS I II
06:06:39.110 --> 06:06:41.079
PEACE WELL THIS IS KIND OF LIKE
06:06:41.145 --> 06:06:43.748
AN IEP INDIVIDUAL TREATMENT
06:06:43.815 --> 06:06:46.451
PROGRAM IF YOU WILL. TO ASSIST
06:06:46.517 --> 06:06:51.322
AN INDIVIDUAL. TO REDRESS THE
06:06:51.389 --> 06:06:53.424
ISSUE SUPPORT ADDRESS THE ISSUES
06:06:53.491 --> 06:06:57.628
THAT WERE PLAGUING HIM. AND THAT
06:06:57.695 --> 06:07:01.099
THEN LATER. BAGANDA THE DRUG
06:07:01.165 --> 06:07:05.470
COURT AND CALIFORNIA. AND I
06:07:05.536 --> 06:07:07.638
HELPED JUDGE DARRELL STEPHENS IN
06:07:07.705 --> 06:07:09.507
BUTTE COUNTY START ONE OF THE
06:07:09.574 --> 06:07:11.509
FIRST IF NOT THE FIRST. IN
06:07:11.576 --> 06:07:15.413
CALIFORNIA. THE DRUG COURT COURT
06:07:15.480 --> 06:07:17.615
WAS NOT JUST ABOUT DEPENDENCE.
06:07:17.682 --> 06:07:21.018
IS ABOUT ACCOUNTABILITY AND HELP
06:07:21.085 --> 06:07:25.323
AND EMPOWERMENT IT WORKED. IT
06:07:25.390 --> 06:07:27.325
TOOK PROP FORTY SEVEN DESTROYED
06:07:27.392 --> 06:07:30.328
THE DRUG COURT. I WON'T GET INTO
06:07:30.395 --> 06:07:32.296
THE WHOLE EYES IT DID BUT IT DID
06:07:32.363 --> 06:07:34.098
. NOW DRUG COURTS WHICH WAS
06:07:34.165 --> 06:07:36.834
IMMENSELY SUCCESSFUL. HAS BEEN
06:07:36.901 --> 06:07:39.404
REPLACED BY INDIVIDUALS NOT
06:07:39.470 --> 06:07:41.939
HAVING THEIR NEEDS MET. BUT THEY
06:07:42.006 --> 06:07:43.908
GET SLICE INCARCERATIONS WHICH
06:07:43.975 --> 06:07:46.077
IS NONSENSE NOW WHAT'S THE KEY
06:07:46.144 --> 06:07:49.914
HERE. WITH THIS PARTICULAR PLAN
06:07:49.981 --> 06:07:54.585
THAT IS BEING PROPOSED. IT TALKS
06:07:54.652 --> 06:07:58.055
ABOUT RECOVERY. ASSISTANCE
06:07:58.122 --> 06:08:02.593
EMPOWER. THAT IS A PATHWAY TO
06:08:02.660 --> 06:08:05.730
SUCCESS. NOT THE PATHWAY THE
06:08:05.797 --> 06:08:09.500
DEPENDENCE. AND YOU PROBABLY
06:08:09.567 --> 06:08:11.569
HEARD ME AT LEAST SOME OF YOU IN
06:08:11.636 --> 06:08:13.037
COMMITTEE AND ON THE FLOOR TALK
06:08:13.104 --> 06:08:16.340
ABOUT. A KIND OF AN
06:08:16.407 --> 06:08:18.543
INDIVIDUALIZED TREATMENT PLAN.
06:08:18.609 --> 06:08:20.945
FOR THE HOMELESS POPULATION.
06:08:21.012 --> 06:08:23.214
BECAUSE I SAY HISTORICALLY ALL
06:08:23.281 --> 06:08:24.182
WE'VE DONE ABOUT HOMELESSNESS
06:08:24.248 --> 06:08:25.349
THROW MONEY AT. NOT
06:08:25.416 --> 06:08:28.820
ACCOUNTABILITY. NOT TREATMENT
06:08:28.886 --> 06:08:30.988
NOT ASSESSMENT OF NEEDS AND
06:08:31.055 --> 06:08:33.291
HELPING THOSE INDIVIDUALS
06:08:33.357 --> 06:08:34.091
ADDRESS THEIR NEEDS SO THEY ARE
06:08:34.158 --> 06:08:37.495
NOT DEPEND ON BEING HOMELESS.
06:08:37.562 --> 06:08:40.031
WELL THIS IS SUCH A PATHWAY FOR
06:08:40.097 --> 06:08:41.532
PARTICULARLY CHALLENGED
06:08:41.599 --> 06:08:45.536
INDIVIDUALS. AND I BELIEVE IT'S
06:08:45.603 --> 06:08:48.406
HELPFUL. THAT HAS INCORPORATED
06:08:48.473 --> 06:08:52.109
INTO IT ASSESSMENT. TRAITEMENT
06:08:52.176 --> 06:08:55.112
THE ACCOUNTABILITY. AND I WILL
06:08:55.179 --> 06:08:58.583
ARGUE RESULTS IF WE REALLY WANT
06:08:58.649 --> 06:08:59.584
TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT
06:08:59.650 --> 06:09:01.886
HOMELESSNESS. SHELTER IS A PART
06:09:01.953 --> 06:09:03.955
OF THE DEAL BUT UNFORTUNATELY
06:09:04.021 --> 06:09:04.989
THAT'S ALL WE'VE REALLY FOCUSED
06:09:05.056 --> 06:09:10.094
ON. THIS CAN BE A PATHWAY. BUT
06:09:10.161 --> 06:09:12.530
THAT SUCCESS OF INDIVIDUALS WHO
06:09:12.597 --> 06:09:17.068
HAVE CHALLENGES. IN THEIR LIVES
06:09:17.134 --> 06:09:19.303
. NOW ONE OF THE ASPECTS OF THIS
06:09:19.370 --> 06:09:21.472
THAT MUST BE ADDRESSED AND I
06:09:21.539 --> 06:09:23.941
SUGGEST WE CAN TAKE STEPS IN
06:09:24.008 --> 06:09:26.677
THIS PARTICULAR BUDGET. AND
06:09:26.744 --> 06:09:28.112
REPUBLICANS HAVE ADVOCATED FOR
06:09:28.179 --> 06:09:31.048
THIS. AND THEN THERE ARE THE
06:09:31.115 --> 06:09:32.416
DIFFERENT WAYS MAYBE THE
06:09:32.483 --> 06:09:34.452
DEMOCRATS HAVE TO. SO THERE'S
06:09:34.519 --> 06:09:38.122
ROOM HERE FOR COMPROMISED AND
06:09:38.189 --> 06:09:41.592
SUCCESS. AND AS WE FINISH UP
06:09:41.659 --> 06:09:44.495
THIS YEAR WITH OUR BUDGET THIS
06:09:44.562 --> 06:09:46.297
IS ONE AREA WE MOST ASSUREDLY
06:09:46.364 --> 06:09:49.867
SHOULD FOCUS ON AND ADDRESS.
06:09:49.934 --> 06:09:51.469
HELP THOSE INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE
06:09:51.536 --> 06:09:55.473
HOMELESS. I THINK WE ALL GET
06:09:55.540 --> 06:09:57.642
TIRED OF SEEING THE TENTS ALL
06:09:57.708 --> 06:09:59.710
OVER THE PLACE I DRIVE IN FOUR
06:09:59.777 --> 06:10:02.713
DAYS A WEEK IN HERE. THIS CAP
06:10:02.780 --> 06:10:07.051
AND SEE NOTHING BUT- DIFFICULTY
06:10:07.118 --> 06:10:09.420
. AND THAT'S POLITELY PUT. WE
06:10:09.487 --> 06:10:11.188
ARE HELPING THOSE INDIVIDUALS BY
06:10:11.255 --> 06:10:12.623
JUST THROWING DOLLARS AT THE
06:10:12.690 --> 06:10:16.494
WALL AND- NOT REALLY HELPING
06:10:16.561 --> 06:10:17.595
THEIR INDIVIDUAL NEEDS AND THEY
06:10:17.662 --> 06:10:20.331
HAVE MANY. ALL OF THEM ARE NOT
06:10:20.398 --> 06:10:23.467
MENTAL AND ALL OF NOT PHYSICAL.
06:10:23.534 --> 06:10:25.770
BUT A HECK OF A LOT OF THE MARK
06:10:25.836 --> 06:10:27.538
. AS I SAID OFTEN HERE TO THE
06:10:27.605 --> 06:10:29.707
CONSTANT IN THE LIVES OF MOST
06:10:29.774 --> 06:10:31.576
CRIMINALS IN CALIFORNIA. IS A
06:10:31.642 --> 06:10:34.145
BROKEN HEART. WHICH IS WHERE
06:10:34.211 --> 06:10:36.781
THIS ALL STARTS SOMETIMES IN THE
06:10:36.847 --> 06:10:39.784
WOMB. AND THE NEGATIVE BEHAVIOR
06:10:39.850 --> 06:10:41.586
THAT THEY RESORT TO. THE COUPLE
06:10:41.652 --> 06:10:46.390
THEMSELVES AND TO SURVIVE. THAT
06:10:46.457 --> 06:10:50.127
IS A PATHWAY TO SUCCESS. AND
06:10:50.194 --> 06:10:53.664
INDEED A PROVEN ONE. AS WE
06:10:53.731 --> 06:10:55.900
PROCEED IN THE STILL. WE CANNOT
06:10:55.967 --> 06:11:00.638
IGNORE WE MUST FOCUS ON A
06:11:00.705 --> 06:11:03.174
COUNTIES OF CALIFORNIA. WHO ARE
06:11:03.240 --> 06:11:05.710
AT THE VANGUARD TO THEIR
06:11:05.776 --> 06:11:08.212
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PROGRAMS. FOR
06:11:08.279 --> 06:11:11.015
THE TREATMENT NECESSITY AND THE
06:11:11.082 --> 06:11:13.117
SUCCESS OF INDIVIDUALS. COULD
06:11:13.184 --> 06:11:16.821
NOT BE CONSTRAINED AND DESTROYED
06:11:16.887 --> 06:11:20.391
. BY THE CHALLENGES THIS IS A
06:11:20.458 --> 06:11:24.362
POSITIVE PATHWAY. I ENCOURAGE IT
06:11:24.428 --> 06:11:28.265
ARJUN I VOTE AND I URGE A
06:11:28.332 --> 06:11:31.002
SUSTAINED ATTEMPT NOT AN ATTEMPT
06:11:31.068 --> 06:11:33.838
RATHER BUT ITS SUCCESS OF ALL OF
06:11:33.904 --> 06:11:36.874
US. TO ADDRESS THESE NEEDS OF
06:11:36.941 --> 06:11:39.276
INDIVIDUALS IN SOME CASES BEFORE
06:11:39.343 --> 06:11:41.512
THEY END OUT ON THE STREETS. OR
06:11:41.579 --> 06:11:46.117
DECEASED. OR OTHER SITUATIONS I
06:11:46.183 --> 06:11:49.587
DO WORDS AND I VOTE THANK YOU
06:11:49.654 --> 06:11:50.554
SENATOR NELSON SENATOR
06:11:50.621 --> 06:11:54.125
PORTANTINO. THANK YOU MADAM
06:11:54.191 --> 06:11:55.626
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I RISE TO
06:11:55.693 --> 06:11:58.162
SUPPORT S. B. THIRTEEN THIRTY
06:11:58.229 --> 06:11:59.463
EIGHT AND- CERTAINLY APPRECIATE
06:11:59.530 --> 06:12:03.668
THE CONVERSATION THAT HAS
06:12:03.734 --> 06:12:04.969
SEVEN YOU KNOW THIS IS A
06:12:05.036 --> 06:12:07.872
SENSITIVE IMPORTANT. PROBLEM TO
06:12:07.938 --> 06:12:10.441
HAVE. ACROSS CALIFORNIA AND IT
06:12:10.508 --> 06:12:12.209
NEEDS. A SENSITIVE
06:12:12.276 --> 06:12:14.378
IMPLEMENTATION AND FRANKLY NEW
06:12:14.445 --> 06:12:17.948
IDEAS- WE'VE TRIED FOR DECADES
06:12:18.015 --> 06:12:19.650
TO ADDRESS MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES
06:12:19.717 --> 06:12:22.053
HOMELESS ISSUES AND FRANKLY I'VE
06:12:22.119 --> 06:12:25.222
NOT HAD TREMENDOUS SUCCESS- AND
06:12:25.289 --> 06:12:27.391
WE DO NEED TO TRY A NEW
06:12:27.458 --> 06:12:30.127
APPROACH- WHENEVER YOU TRY TO
06:12:30.194 --> 06:12:31.429
BRING SOMETHING NEW TO THE TABLE
06:12:31.495 --> 06:12:33.631
THERE'S A NATURAL. HESITANCY AND
06:12:33.698 --> 06:12:34.999
RESISTANCE AND I THINK IT'S
06:12:35.066 --> 06:12:37.268
IMPORTANT THE CON THAT CERTAINLY
06:12:37.334 --> 06:12:39.336
THE CONCERNS HAVE BEEN RAISED
06:12:39.403 --> 06:12:40.971
ARE ARE THE RIGHT QUESTIONS TO
06:12:41.038 --> 06:12:43.974
ASK AND I HAVE FAITH IN IN THE
06:12:44.041 --> 06:12:48.479
AUTHORS- BOTH OF THEM- AND- THE
06:12:48.546 --> 06:12:50.781
FOR THE FOLKS SHEPHERDING THIS.
06:12:50.848 --> 06:12:53.818
TO ADDRESS THEM- SHARING MEMORY
06:12:53.884 --> 06:12:55.853
FAMILIES BEEN TOUCHED BY A
06:12:55.920 --> 06:12:57.254
MENTAL HEALTH ISSUE BY A
06:12:57.321 --> 06:13:00.825
HOMELESS PERSON- NO THIS IS NOT.
06:13:00.891 --> 06:13:02.927
WE'RE NOT IMMUNE TO THIS- JUST
06:13:02.993 --> 06:13:06.363
IN MY OWN FAMILY SITUATION I-
06:13:06.430 --> 06:13:09.300
HAD A SIBLING. WHO WENT THROUGH
06:13:09.366 --> 06:13:11.502
THREE DIFFERENT COUNTY HOSPITALS
06:13:11.569 --> 06:13:14.004
. IN CALIFORNIA THREE DIFFERENT
06:13:14.071 --> 06:13:15.005
COUNTY HOSPITALS THREE DIFFERENT
06:13:15.072 --> 06:13:18.275
COUNTIES. AND LO AND BEHOLD ON
06:13:18.342 --> 06:13:21.045
DAY FOURTEEN. WAS DECLARED NOT A
06:13:21.112 --> 06:13:23.814
THREAT TO HIMSELF. AND I DON'T
06:13:23.881 --> 06:13:25.382
WANT TO BELIEVE THAT BECAUSE YOU
06:13:25.449 --> 06:13:27.351
DIDN'T HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE THE
06:13:27.418 --> 06:13:30.654
DECISION NOT TO KEEP HIM WAS
06:13:30.721 --> 06:13:32.189
PREDICATED ON THAT- SITUATION
06:13:32.256 --> 06:13:35.392
BUT LO AND BEHOLD ON DAY
06:13:35.459 --> 06:13:36.393
FOURTEEN IN THREE DIFFERENT
06:13:36.460 --> 06:13:39.964
COUNTIES. HE WAS SENT HOME. AND
06:13:40.030 --> 06:13:42.666
AFTER THE THIRD TIME HE TOOK HIS
06:13:42.733 --> 06:13:45.503
OWN LIFE. AND I JUST IN A WISH
06:13:45.569 --> 06:13:46.637
WE HAD AN OPPORTUNITY AT THAT
06:13:46.704 --> 06:13:49.073
POINT. TO SEE HIM GET EXTENDED
06:13:49.140 --> 06:13:52.576
CARE- AND THE LOVE AN-
06:13:52.643 --> 06:13:54.411
OPPORTUNITY TO BE WITH US TODAY
06:13:54.478 --> 06:13:57.715
AND SELF I STRONGLY SUPPORT SB
06:13:57.782 --> 06:13:58.382
THIRTEEN THIRTY EIGHT AND REALLY
06:13:58.449 --> 06:14:00.251
APPRECIATE. THE CONVERSATION ON
06:14:00.317 --> 06:14:02.086
THE CONCERNS AND DEFINITELY KNOW
06:14:02.153 --> 06:14:04.088
THE AUTHORS ARE GOING TO BE
06:14:04.155 --> 06:14:05.022
ADDRESSING THEM AS WE MOVE
06:14:05.089 --> 06:14:06.290
FORWARD. THANK YOU CENTER
06:14:06.357 --> 06:14:08.859
PORTANTINO CENTER BAKER. THANKS
06:14:08.926 --> 06:14:10.227
MEMBERS AYE I KNOW THERE'S BEEN
06:14:10.294 --> 06:14:11.996
A LONG DEBATE AND WE CAN'T SAY
06:14:12.062 --> 06:14:14.165
BETTER THAN MY COLLEAGUE I JUST
06:14:14.231 --> 06:14:16.934
WANNA SAY THAT'S A REALLY RISING
06:14:17.001 --> 06:14:18.002
GRATITUDE. BECAUSE I KNOW THESE
06:14:18.068 --> 06:14:20.504
ISSUES ARE DIFFICULT. I KNOW
06:14:20.571 --> 06:14:22.673
THESE ISSUES ARE COMPLEX. AND I
06:14:22.740 --> 06:14:24.108
ALSO BELIEVE THEY ARE PROBABLY
06:14:24.175 --> 06:14:25.976
THE MOST IMPORTANT THAT WE WILL
06:14:26.043 --> 06:14:28.312
TRUST THIS YEAR. AND SO TO HAVE
06:14:28.379 --> 06:14:29.747
FOLKS X. CENTER FROM STOCKTON
06:14:29.814 --> 06:14:32.616
AND SENT FROM SANTANA. WHO ARE
06:14:32.683 --> 06:14:35.152
KNOWLEDGEABLE ARE COMPASSIONATE.
06:14:35.219 --> 06:14:36.854
I JUST KNOW THEY'RE GONNA GIVE
06:14:36.921 --> 06:14:38.055
US THE RIGHT PLACE AND I AM ALL
06:14:38.122 --> 06:14:40.858
IN. WHATEVER I CAN DO IN THIS
06:14:40.925 --> 06:14:42.226
LESSON GEN I DO THINK IT'S THAT
06:14:42.293 --> 06:14:43.394
IMPORTANT SO THANK YOU. THANK
06:14:43.460 --> 06:14:44.895
YOU SENATOR BAKER CENTER ALAN.
06:14:44.962 --> 06:14:46.197
MEMBERS I'M SO STRUCK BY HOW
06:14:46.263 --> 06:14:48.833
MANY OF US OF. PEOPLE WE LOVE
06:14:48.899 --> 06:14:51.902
AND NO. OUR COLLEAGUE FROM LOS
06:14:51.969 --> 06:14:53.737
ANGELES SPOKE SO ELOQUENTLY
06:14:53.804 --> 06:14:56.907
ABOUT DAVID- THERE'S SOMEONE IN
06:14:56.974 --> 06:14:58.142
MY LIFE FOR THE SIMILAR STORY
06:14:58.209 --> 06:15:00.077
DANNY WHO. PARENTS WERE SO
06:15:00.144 --> 06:15:01.779
DESPERATE TO HELP HIM WEREN'T
06:15:01.846 --> 06:15:04.381
ABLE TO FIND A WAY. AND HE
06:15:04.448 --> 06:15:05.616
ULTIMATELY TOOK HIS LIFE
06:15:05.683 --> 06:15:08.285
STEPPING INTO TRAFFIC. ANOTHER
06:15:08.352 --> 06:15:09.920
FRIEND I GREW UP WITH WENT TO
06:15:09.987 --> 06:15:11.255
HIGH SCHOOL WITH SIGNS ON THE
06:15:11.322 --> 06:15:12.890
STREETS I BELIEVE BUT I'M NOT
06:15:12.957 --> 06:15:14.058
QUITE SURE THAT IT'S AND VERY
06:15:14.124 --> 06:15:16.160
TOUGH SITUATIONS THAT I. THAT I
06:15:16.227 --> 06:15:17.928
KNOW WOULD HAVE BEEN HE WOULD
06:15:17.995 --> 06:15:19.129
BENEFIT FROM SOMETHING LIKE THIS
06:15:19.196 --> 06:15:21.365
SO I WANT TO VOTE. FOR THIS BILL
06:15:21.432 --> 06:15:23.601
TODAY IN IN THEIR HONOR. THANK
06:15:23.667 --> 06:15:27.805
YOU CENTER ALLEN CENTER STERN.
06:15:27.872 --> 06:15:31.075
THANK YOU VERY PRESIDENT. I RISE
06:15:31.141 --> 06:15:34.144
A CO AUTHOR OF THIS MEASURE. AND
06:15:34.211 --> 06:15:37.381
IN LIGHT OF THE- PERSONAL
06:15:37.448 --> 06:15:41.285
TESTIMONY. DELIVERED ON THE
06:15:41.352 --> 06:15:42.486
FLOOR HERE TODAY I'LL I'LL TAKE
06:15:42.553 --> 06:15:47.224
A SLIGHTLY. LESS PERSONAL ATTACK
06:15:47.291 --> 06:15:49.426
IN AND TALK ABOUT MECHANICS FOR
06:15:49.493 --> 06:15:53.330
SECOND- THE WELFARE AND
06:15:53.397 --> 06:15:55.900
INSTITUTIONS CODE. THAT THIS
06:15:55.966 --> 06:15:57.902
BILL AMENDS SAYS THAT MENTAL
06:15:57.968 --> 06:16:00.271
HEALTH CARE IS A BASIC HUMAN
06:16:00.337 --> 06:16:03.774
SERVICE. I BELIEVE IT OUGHT TO
06:16:03.841 --> 06:16:06.744
BE A BASIC HUMAN RIGHT. WE
06:16:06.810 --> 06:16:10.447
CURRENTLY TREAT. HOUSING THAT
06:16:10.514 --> 06:16:13.050
HEALS AS SOMETHING IT'S SUBJECT
06:16:13.117 --> 06:16:16.020
TO APPROPRIATION SOMETHING IS
06:16:16.086 --> 06:16:18.422
SUBJECT TO THE BUDGET CYCLES.
06:16:18.489 --> 06:16:23.661
AND IF WE'RE ACTUALLY GOING TO
06:16:23.727 --> 06:16:24.728
BILL THIS NEW INFRASTRUCTURE OF
06:16:24.795 --> 06:16:29.533
CARE. THE REQUIREMENT AND I
06:16:29.600 --> 06:16:31.936
BELIEVE THE MANDATE ON US IS TO
06:16:32.002 --> 06:16:35.039
SAY. THESE RESOURCES WILL BE
06:16:35.105 --> 06:16:36.740
THERE FOR YOU. IF YOU'RE GOING
06:16:36.807 --> 06:16:39.043
TO TRUST US ENOUGH TO COME INTO
06:16:39.109 --> 06:16:41.412
THIS CARE. WE'RE NOT GOING TO
06:16:41.478 --> 06:16:43.280
RECYCLE YOU THROUGH THE SYSTEM
06:16:43.347 --> 06:16:45.449
LIKE WE DO WITH SO MANY PEOPLE
06:16:45.516 --> 06:16:48.419
ON THE STREETS. OUR AUDIT OF L.
06:16:48.485 --> 06:16:50.821
A. COUNTY AND SAN FRANCISCO.
06:16:50.888 --> 06:16:52.523
FOUND THAT THE AVERAGE PERSON
06:16:52.589 --> 06:16:54.591
LIVING ON THE STREET RIGHT NOW
06:16:54.658 --> 06:16:57.094
IS CYCLED TEN TIMES THROUGH THE
06:16:57.161 --> 06:16:59.229
SYSTEM THROUGH FIFTY ONE FIFTY
06:16:59.296 --> 06:17:01.432
HOLDS FORCED HOSPITALIZATIONS
06:17:01.498 --> 06:17:03.467
EXPENSIVE STINTS IN JAIL
06:17:03.534 --> 06:17:06.770
SYSTEMS. OVER AND OVER AND OVER
06:17:06.837 --> 06:17:10.074
AGAIN CUMULATIVELY AN INCREDIBLY
06:17:10.140 --> 06:17:13.077
EXPENSIVE. SYSTEM THAT
06:17:13.143 --> 06:17:15.212
TRAUMATIZE IS IN BREACH IS OUR
06:17:15.279 --> 06:17:17.114
TRUST WITH PEOPLE SO THEY DON'T
06:17:17.181 --> 06:17:19.216
WANT TO COME INTO CARE ANYMORE
06:17:19.283 --> 06:17:21.051
THEY DON'T WANT TO GO TO A CARE
06:17:21.118 --> 06:17:22.753
COURT. AND THAT SOME OF THE
06:17:22.820 --> 06:17:24.121
SENSITIVITY YOU'RE HEARING FROM
06:17:24.188 --> 06:17:24.621
THE OPPOSITION TO THIS
06:17:24.688 --> 06:17:25.956
LEGISLATION. THAT THEY JUST
06:17:26.023 --> 06:17:29.293
DON'T TRUST. THAT IT'S GOING TO
06:17:29.360 --> 06:17:32.329
BE THERE FOR THEM. THE NEW
06:17:32.396 --> 06:17:33.964
PROVISIONS ADDED EVEN IN
06:17:34.031 --> 06:17:37.034
APPROPRIATIONS SAY. AT THE CARE
06:17:37.101 --> 06:17:40.838
PLAN MAY. MAY INCLUDE THE
06:17:40.904 --> 06:17:42.106
FOLLOWING HOUSING SUPPORT
06:17:42.172 --> 06:17:43.340
SYSTEMS AND THE FOLLOWING
06:17:43.407 --> 06:17:45.542
BEHAVIOR HEALTH SYSTEMS. NOW I
06:17:45.609 --> 06:17:48.746
RECOGNIZE IF THAT MAYBE CAME
06:17:48.812 --> 06:17:51.515
MICHELLE. THAT COULD BE A VERY
06:17:51.582 --> 06:17:53.884
EXPENSIVE PROPOSITION. AND WE
06:17:53.951 --> 06:17:56.120
DEBATED SOME OF THIS IN THE
06:17:56.186 --> 06:18:00.324
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE. AND I
06:18:00.391 --> 06:18:01.625
KNOW THAT THERE HAVE BEEN
06:18:01.692 --> 06:18:05.262
DOLLARS NOT PROPERLY TRACKED
06:18:05.329 --> 06:18:09.366
WASTED ON SPENT. BUT IF WE LOOK
06:18:09.433 --> 06:18:12.036
AT SOME ANALOG OUT THERE SO YOU
06:18:12.102 --> 06:18:13.537
HAVE A DISABILITY OF A DIFFERENT
06:18:13.604 --> 06:18:15.539
SORT NOT FROM A SEVERE MENTAL
06:18:15.606 --> 06:18:17.341
ILLNESS SAY AN INTELLECTUAL OR
06:18:17.408 --> 06:18:19.076
DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITY HERE IN
06:18:19.143 --> 06:18:20.878
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA. THE
06:18:20.944 --> 06:18:22.112
STATE OF CALIFORNIA GUARANTEES
06:18:22.179 --> 06:18:23.714
THAT YOU WILL HAVE CARE NOW IT'S
06:18:23.781 --> 06:18:25.783
UP NOT ALWAYS THE BEST CARE AND
06:18:25.849 --> 06:18:26.417
WE KNOW THERE CHALLENGES WITH
06:18:26.483 --> 06:18:28.519
OUR REGIONAL CENTERS. BUT THE
06:18:28.585 --> 06:18:30.687
STATE OF CALIFORNIA. WILL
06:18:30.754 --> 06:18:34.458
GUARANTEE YOU. UNDER THE LPS ACT
06:18:34.525 --> 06:18:35.392
. BUT IF YOU HAVE AN
06:18:35.459 --> 06:18:36.460
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENTAL
06:18:36.527 --> 06:18:38.562
DISABILITY THAT WAS DIAGNOSED AT
06:18:38.629 --> 06:18:40.130
THAT AGE YOU WILL HAVE ACCESS TO
06:18:40.197 --> 06:18:41.832
THAT CARE. BUT IF IN YOUR
06:18:41.899 --> 06:18:46.870
TWENTIES. YOU HAVE. MENTAL
06:18:46.937 --> 06:18:49.540
ILLNESS THAT IS SPARKED
06:18:49.606 --> 06:18:51.708
SOMETIMES BY SUBSTANCE USE
06:18:51.775 --> 06:18:55.179
DISORDERS SOMETIMES BY LATENT.
06:18:55.245 --> 06:18:56.947
PARANOID SCHIZOPHRENIA WE KNOW
06:18:57.014 --> 06:18:58.415
THAT THESE COME THESE THESE
06:18:58.482 --> 06:19:01.418
ILLNESSES COME ON LATER IN LIFE
06:19:01.485 --> 06:19:02.619
AND IT EVADES THE SYSTEM AS A
06:19:02.686 --> 06:19:06.190
RESULT. AND SO FULLER LEFT
06:19:06.256 --> 06:19:08.459
WITHOUT ANY ANYONE TO BACK THEM
06:19:08.525 --> 06:19:10.494
UP. WITHOUT THE GOVERNMENT
06:19:10.561 --> 06:19:12.830
BEHIND THEM AND SO YOU KNOW I'M
06:19:12.896 --> 06:19:15.065
A I'M A PROUD CO AUTHOR THIS
06:19:15.132 --> 06:19:18.435
MEASURE BECAUSE THIS IS AN
06:19:18.502 --> 06:19:19.436
INDISPENSABLE PIECE OF THE
06:19:19.503 --> 06:19:22.406
PUZZLE. BUT I HOPE THAT. AS WE
06:19:22.473 --> 06:19:24.575
GO THROUGH OUR LEGISLATING THIS
06:19:24.641 --> 06:19:25.909
YEAR AND I'M I'M WORKING WITH
06:19:25.976 --> 06:19:28.679
THE SENATOR. FROM STOCKTON ON
06:19:28.745 --> 06:19:30.180
WHAT I BELIEVE IS A CRITICAL
06:19:30.247 --> 06:19:32.916
COROLLARY TO THIS. WHICH IS TO
06:19:32.983 --> 06:19:34.885
ACTUALLY PROVIDE A RIGHT TO
06:19:34.952 --> 06:19:36.920
TREATMENT IN THIS PROCESS TO
06:19:36.987 --> 06:19:39.256
GUARANTEE THAT RIGHT. TO THE
06:19:39.323 --> 06:19:41.458
HOUSING THAT GOES ALONG WITH IT
06:19:41.525 --> 06:19:43.360
INTO THE TREATMENT. SO THAT WHEN
06:19:43.427 --> 06:19:45.496
THE BUDGET CYCLE IS NOT GOOD.
06:19:45.562 --> 06:19:47.631
AND WE DON'T HAVE A SURPLUS. AND
06:19:47.698 --> 06:19:49.133
WE DON'T HAVE ONE TIME FUNDING
06:19:49.199 --> 06:19:50.300
TO THROW BEHAVIORAL HEALTH
06:19:50.367 --> 06:19:52.669
INFRASTRUCTURE EVEN THEN WE WILL
06:19:52.736 --> 06:19:55.873
BE THERE FOR YOU. AND MAYBE IF
06:19:55.939 --> 06:19:57.040
WE CAN START TO BRIDGE THAT
06:19:57.107 --> 06:20:00.043
DIVIDE. THOSE WHO HAVE CONCERNS
06:20:00.110 --> 06:20:01.478
THOSE WHO WORRY ABOUT RIGHTS
06:20:01.545 --> 06:20:02.646
BEING COMPROMISE WILL START TO
06:20:02.713 --> 06:20:05.482
TRUST US. AND MORE IMPORTANTLY
06:20:05.549 --> 06:20:07.618
PEOPLE ON THE STREETS. WHO ARE
06:20:07.684 --> 06:20:09.753
LITERALLY DYING. FIVE PEOPLE A
06:20:09.820 --> 06:20:11.588
DAY LAST YEAR AND L. A. COUNTY
06:20:11.655 --> 06:20:14.258
LOW LITERALLY DYING ON OUR
06:20:14.324 --> 06:20:17.227
DOORSTEPS. THE MORAL DEBT WE OWE
06:20:17.294 --> 06:20:18.896
THOSE PEOPLE WILL SOON BE
06:20:18.962 --> 06:20:20.464
REPAIRED SO I THINK WE CAN'T
06:20:20.531 --> 06:20:23.066
AFFORD NOT TO MAKE MENTAL HEALTH
06:20:23.133 --> 06:20:26.303
CARE A BASIC HUMAN RIGHT. AND
06:20:26.370 --> 06:20:29.173
WITH THAT HOPEFUL. HOPEFUL
06:20:29.239 --> 06:20:31.475
VISION THAT WE CAN ET THERE AS
06:20:31.542 --> 06:20:34.244
FOR RIVAL THANK YOU CENTER CERN
06:20:34.311 --> 06:20:36.113
CENTER DOLLY. THANK YOU MADAM
06:20:36.180 --> 06:20:38.248
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I RISE- I'M
06:20:38.315 --> 06:20:39.516
GONNA SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY.
06:20:39.583 --> 06:20:44.354
AND- BUT SIR SIXTEEN YEARS ON
06:20:44.421 --> 06:20:46.323
THE COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
06:20:46.390 --> 06:20:47.991
AND ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS I
06:20:48.058 --> 06:20:49.359
RAN FOR THE LEGISLATURE IS
06:20:49.426 --> 06:20:52.095
BECAUSE OF UNFUNDED MANDATES
06:20:52.162 --> 06:20:56.233
THAT COME DOWN. TO THE CAMP. AB
06:20:56.300 --> 06:20:59.336
ONE OH NINE. THOSE TYPES OF
06:20:59.403 --> 06:21:01.171
PROGRAMS I KNOW THERE'S MONEY IN
06:21:01.238 --> 06:21:04.141
THE BUDGET I HAVE GREAT RESPECT
06:21:04.208 --> 06:21:05.342
FOR BOTH SENATORS THAT ARE
06:21:05.409 --> 06:21:08.412
WORKING ON THIS BILL- AND I JUST
06:21:08.478 --> 06:21:11.081
WANT TO. JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE
06:21:11.148 --> 06:21:13.050
THAT TOM THAT WE COMMUNICATE
06:21:13.116 --> 06:21:14.151
WITH THE COUNTY THEY'RE THE ONES
06:21:14.218 --> 06:21:16.553
THAT ARE REALLY GOING TO BE IN
06:21:16.620 --> 06:21:18.488
THE SERVICES AT THE END OF THE
06:21:18.555 --> 06:21:20.023
DAY. AND THEY THE ONE SIZE FITS
06:21:20.090 --> 06:21:21.858
ALL DOESN'T MATTER IF YOU'RE IN
06:21:21.925 --> 06:21:23.460
WHY RICA CALIFORNIA THE MOST
06:21:23.527 --> 06:21:28.365
SOUTHERN. COUN NORTHERN TOWN OR
06:21:28.432 --> 06:21:30.300
SAN DIEGO THERE ARE HOMELESS
06:21:30.367 --> 06:21:32.703
PEOPLE AND SCHIZOPHRENIA AND
06:21:32.769 --> 06:21:34.771
THESE ISSUES ACROSS OUR STATE.
06:21:34.838 --> 06:21:36.173
BUT WHAT WORKS IN SISKIYOU
06:21:36.240 --> 06:21:38.675
COUNTY OR MODOC COUNTY MAYBE
06:21:38.742 --> 06:21:40.077
LOOK A LOT DIFFERENT THAN IT
06:21:40.143 --> 06:21:43.146
DOES IN SAN DIEGO COUNTY OR SAN
06:21:43.213 --> 06:21:45.682
FRANCISCO COUNTY. SO I JUST WANT
06:21:45.749 --> 06:21:47.184
TO. WANT TO REACH OUT AND SAY.
06:21:47.251 --> 06:21:50.954
YOU KNOW. WE NEED TO COMMUNICATE
06:21:51.021 --> 06:21:51.989
WITH THOSE FOLKS BECAUSE AT THE
06:21:52.055 --> 06:21:54.124
END OF DAY THEY'RE THE ONES THAT
06:21:54.191 --> 06:21:55.125
ARE REALLY GOING TO BE
06:21:55.192 --> 06:21:57.227
DELIVERING THE SERVICES AND
06:21:57.294 --> 06:21:58.295
THERE ARE A LOT OF. ONE SIZE
06:21:58.362 --> 06:21:59.563
DOESN'T FIT ALL IN CALIFORNIA SO
06:21:59.630 --> 06:22:00.964
I WILL BE SUPPORTING THE BILL
06:22:01.031 --> 06:22:02.299
THIS IS NOT EASY. AS YOU'VE
06:22:02.366 --> 06:22:03.967
HEARD MANY MEMBERS ARE. ARE
06:22:04.034 --> 06:22:05.535
TALKING ON THIS BILL TODAY. THIS
06:22:05.602 --> 06:22:07.037
IS NOT GONNA BE EASY AND IT AND
06:22:07.104 --> 06:22:09.306
WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO.
06:22:09.373 --> 06:22:09.973
ACKNOWLEDGE THE FACT THAT WHEN
06:22:10.040 --> 06:22:12.042
WE DO IT WRONG WE NEED TO GO
06:22:12.109 --> 06:22:15.579
BACK AND REVISIT IT. AND MAKE IT
06:22:15.646 --> 06:22:16.446
RIGHT BECAUSE- WE'RE GONNA LEARN
06:22:16.513 --> 06:22:18.315
ALONG THEWAY THIS IS NOT
06:22:18.382 --> 06:22:19.182
SOMETHING WE GOT INTO A- FIGHT.
06:22:19.249 --> 06:22:21.418
IT'S NOT SOMETHING WE'RE GOING
06:22:21.485 --> 06:22:22.853
TO GET OUT OF. ANY TIME SOON.
06:22:22.919 --> 06:22:24.388
AND THERE ARE MANY ISSUES. I
06:22:24.454 --> 06:22:26.123
PRAY TO GOD THAT THE- BIG THAT
06:22:26.189 --> 06:22:28.458
HE INTERVENES BECAUSE A LOT OF
06:22:28.525 --> 06:22:31.628
THIS IS JUST- EVIL. AND DRUG
06:22:31.695 --> 06:22:34.765
ADDITION DICTION- HAS TO BE
06:22:34.831 --> 06:22:36.099
ADDRESSED THEY KEPT THEY HAVE TO
06:22:36.166 --> 06:22:37.834
BE CLEAN AND SOBER BEFORE WE CAN
06:22:37.901 --> 06:22:39.336
ACTUALLY START. A TRADITION
06:22:39.403 --> 06:22:40.404
THOSE IF YOU VISITED ANY OF
06:22:40.470 --> 06:22:43.373
YOUR- OF YOUR COUNTY FACILITIES.
06:22:43.440 --> 06:22:46.443
I'M SURE YOU'RE AWARE THAT- A
06:22:46.510 --> 06:22:47.611
LOT OF TIMES THE REASON THEY
06:22:47.678 --> 06:22:49.012
DON'T GOING TO SHELTERS BECAUSE
06:22:49.079 --> 06:22:50.047
THERE ARE PEOPLE IN THE SHELTERS
06:22:50.113 --> 06:22:52.582
THAT ARE. THAT ARE ABUSING THEM
06:22:52.649 --> 06:22:54.384
WORSE THAN BEING OUT UNDER THE
06:22:54.451 --> 06:22:55.419
BRIDGE WHERE THEY FEEL SAFE.
06:22:55.485 --> 06:22:56.987
THAT'S A FACT. AND WE'RE GONNA
06:22:57.054 --> 06:22:59.056
HAVE TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO.
06:22:59.122 --> 06:23:00.757
NAVIGATE THAT SO I WOULD LOOK
06:23:00.824 --> 06:23:02.793
FORWARD TO WORKING WITH. A BOTH
06:23:02.859 --> 06:23:04.995
THE COLLEAGUES- THAT I KNOW THAT
06:23:05.062 --> 06:23:06.630
TO. THIS THE SENATOR FROM
06:23:06.697 --> 06:23:09.266
STOCKTON WE CAME IN TOGETHER
06:23:09.333 --> 06:23:10.367
WE'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THESE
06:23:10.434 --> 06:23:11.968
ISSUES. FOR TOO LONG. THAT BUT I
06:23:12.035 --> 06:23:13.503
LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING HOW THIS
06:23:13.570 --> 06:23:14.604
LEGISLATION WORKSHOP AND I WILL
06:23:14.671 --> 06:23:17.207
BE SUPPORTING. SB THIRTEEN
06:23:17.274 --> 06:23:18.241
THIRTY EIGHT TODAY. THANK YOU
06:23:18.308 --> 06:23:20.410
CENTER DOLLY SEEING NO FURTHER
06:23:20.477 --> 06:23:22.412
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE CENTER I'M
06:23:22.479 --> 06:23:25.048
BURKE YOU MAY CLOSE. THANK YOU
06:23:25.115 --> 06:23:25.615
MADAM PRESIDENT COLLEAGUES-
06:23:25.682 --> 06:23:27.784
THANK YOU FOR SHARING THE PAIN
06:23:27.851 --> 06:23:28.618
OF YOUR OWN PERSONAL LIVED
06:23:28.685 --> 06:23:32.322
EXPERIENCE I BEGIN THIS BY-
06:23:32.389 --> 06:23:34.124
TALKING ABOUT ANECDOTE. THAT IS
06:23:34.191 --> 06:23:36.827
OF MY OWN LIVED EXPERIENCE-
06:23:36.893 --> 06:23:39.129
CONCERNING A FAMILY MEMBER THERE
06:23:39.196 --> 06:23:42.766
ARE CALIFORNIANS RIGHT NOW AT
06:23:42.833 --> 06:23:43.533
FIVE THIRTY TWO. ON WEDNESDAY
06:23:43.600 --> 06:23:45.035
THEY'RE LOOKING FOR LOVED ONES
06:23:45.102 --> 06:23:47.003
THEY CAN'T FIND THEM. AND
06:23:47.070 --> 06:23:49.106
THEY'RE LOOKING BECAUSE THEY
06:23:49.172 --> 06:23:51.007
DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO. BECAUSE
06:23:51.074 --> 06:23:53.310
THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO THEY
06:23:53.377 --> 06:23:54.444
DON'T KNOW HOW TO FIND THEM
06:23:54.511 --> 06:23:56.546
HELP- WE DON'T LOOK FOR OUR
06:23:56.613 --> 06:23:57.748
LOVED ONE ANYMORE BECAUSE
06:23:57.814 --> 06:23:59.649
THERE'S ACTUALLY NO NEED TO- BUT
06:23:59.716 --> 06:24:02.152
I'M I'M HOPEFUL IN WHAT GIVES ME
06:24:02.219 --> 06:24:04.121
INCREDIBLE HOPE. IS THE BREADTH
06:24:04.187 --> 06:24:08.358
AND SCOPE. OF THE SUPPORT FROM
06:24:08.425 --> 06:24:10.127
OUR COLLEAGUES MENLO PARK LOS
06:24:10.193 --> 06:24:12.996
ANGELES TO TAKE HEMA TO LAGUNA
06:24:13.063 --> 06:24:15.232
MIGUEL THE FRESNO. THAT
06:24:15.298 --> 06:24:17.167
THREATENS SUPPORT THAT DEPTH OF
06:24:17.234 --> 06:24:19.302
SUPPORT GIVES ME HOPE DO WE HAVE
06:24:19.369 --> 06:24:21.238
WORK TO DO WE OBVIOUSLY HAVE
06:24:21.304 --> 06:24:23.006
WORK TO DO DO WE HAVE CONCERNS
06:24:23.073 --> 06:24:24.841
ABOUT FOR EXAMPLE HOUSING
06:24:24.908 --> 06:24:26.343
OBVIOUSLY WE DO ABOUT MAKING
06:24:26.410 --> 06:24:28.378
SURE THE COUNTIES CAN SUPPLY THE
06:24:28.445 --> 06:24:30.480
SUPPORT THAT THIS BILL REQUIRES
06:24:30.547 --> 06:24:32.916
THIS BILL CALLS FOR OF COURSE WE
06:24:32.983 --> 06:24:35.018
HAVE THOSE CONCERNS. BUT I DO
06:24:35.085 --> 06:24:37.220
THINK THAT WE HAVE THIS UNIQUE
06:24:37.287 --> 06:24:40.223
OPPORTUNITY THIS UNIQUE. TIME WE
06:24:40.290 --> 06:24:41.992
HAVE THE RESOURCES IN THE
06:24:42.058 --> 06:24:44.895
COLLECTIVE. POLITICAL WILL TO
06:24:44.961 --> 06:24:46.963
MAKE A HUGE DIFFERENCE NOT JUST
06:24:47.030 --> 06:24:48.799
BY PARTISAN BUT ACROSS THE
06:24:48.865 --> 06:24:53.003
SPECTRUM AND SO- I AM INCREDIBLY
06:24:53.069 --> 06:24:55.138
HOPEFUL AND INCREDIBLY GRATEFUL
06:24:55.205 --> 06:24:57.374
TO ALL OF YOU IN THE GOVERNOR.
06:24:57.441 --> 06:24:58.842
FOR PUTTING THIS BOLD IS WE'VE
06:24:58.909 --> 06:25:00.844
SAID PARADIGM SHIFT BEFORE ALL
06:25:00.911 --> 06:25:03.280
OF US- SO THANK YOU AND I'LL
06:25:03.346 --> 06:25:05.882
ALSO DIFFER. ALL RIGHT THANK YOU
06:25:05.949 --> 06:25:07.451
VERY MUCH ASIAN AYE VOTE. THANK
06:25:07.517 --> 06:25:08.985
YOU CENTER OF BERGMAN'S
06:25:09.052 --> 06:25:10.821
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
06:25:10.887 --> 06:25:15.091
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA. AYE ATKINS
06:25:15.158 --> 06:25:18.662
AYE BATES. AYE BECKER. AYE
06:25:18.728 --> 06:25:21.798
FORTUNES. AYE BRADFORD I
06:25:21.865 --> 06:25:26.603
CABALLERO HI CORTESE AYE DALLY
06:25:26.670 --> 06:25:31.274
AYE DODD AYE DURAZO AYE EGGMAN
06:25:31.341 --> 06:25:36.446
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROWTH
06:25:36.513 --> 06:25:41.218
. I HERTZBERG WESSEL. HI HER
06:25:41.284 --> 06:25:46.690
TADO I JONES I KAMLAGER AYE
06:25:46.756 --> 06:25:50.360
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE THE MON.
06:25:50.427 --> 06:25:55.131
AYE MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ AYE MIN
06:25:55.198 --> 06:25:59.336
AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN I PATROL
06:25:59.402 --> 06:26:04.207
BOAT I PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
06:26:04.274 --> 06:26:11.781
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I
06:26:11.848 --> 06:26:16.319
STERN AYE AMBERG HIFI CASTING
06:26:16.386 --> 06:26:24.060
AYE WIENER AYE WILK. PLEASE CALL
06:26:24.127 --> 06:26:26.763
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
06:26:26.830 --> 06:26:40.210
. HERTZBERG WILK. OKAY FIVE
06:26:40.277 --> 06:26:41.678
THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE MEASURE
06:26:41.745 --> 06:26:44.214
PASSES MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO
06:26:44.281 --> 06:26:46.349
BREAK FOR A THIRTY MINUTE DINNER
06:26:46.416 --> 06:26:51.021
BREAK SO PLEASE BE BACK HERE AT
06:26:51.087 --> 06:26:53.189
SIX OH FIVE DO NOT LEAVE THE
06:26:53.256 --> 06:26:54.157
BUILDING WE ONLY HAVE A THIRTY
06:26:54.224 --> 06:26:55.825
MINUTE BREAK AT SIX OH FIVE WE
06:26:55.892 --> 06:26:57.160
WILL START TAKING UP BILLS.
06:26:57.227 --> 06:27:16.846
THANK YOU.
06:27:40.503 --> 06:27:42.172
EXCELLENT SENATOR ALAN WE'RE
06:27:42.238 --> 06:27:44.874
GOING TO YOU IT IS SIX OH FIVE.
06:27:44.941 --> 06:27:46.476
MEMBERS WE'RE GOING TO START
06:27:46.543 --> 06:27:48.745
WITH FILE ITEM FIFTY ONE SENATOR
06:27:48.812 --> 06:27:51.715
ALAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
06:27:51.781 --> 06:27:53.116
SENATE BILL TWELVE NINETY BY
06:27:53.183 --> 06:27:55.385
SENATOR ALLEN AN ACT RELATING TO
06:27:55.452 --> 06:28:08.064
SIDEWALK VENDORS. SENATOR ALAN.
06:28:08.131 --> 06:28:11.001
HI MEMBERS- ONE OF THE ONE OF
06:28:11.067 --> 06:28:14.871
THE- CHALLENGES ASSOCIATED WITH-
06:28:14.938 --> 06:28:16.773
BEING HERE FOR A LITTLE LONGER
06:28:16.840 --> 06:28:18.742
IS THAT YOU VOTE ON BILLS AND
06:28:18.808 --> 06:28:20.744
THEN- FEL THE NEED TO ADDRESS
06:28:20.810 --> 06:28:21.911
SOME OF THE CHALLENGES
06:28:21.978 --> 06:28:23.813
ASSOCIATED WITH THOSE POLICIES.
06:28:23.880 --> 06:28:26.316
I ACCUSE YESTERDAY SUPPORTED SB
06:28:26.383 --> 06:28:27.917
NINE FORTY SIX WHICH IS OUR
06:28:27.984 --> 06:28:29.219
COLLEAGUE COMMISSIONER LARA'S
06:28:29.285 --> 06:28:30.654
BILL TO LEGALIZE SIDEWALK
06:28:30.720 --> 06:28:32.055
VENDING I THINK IT'S BROUGHT A
06:28:32.122 --> 06:28:35.325
LOT OF WONDERFUL THINGS TO OUR
06:28:35.392 --> 06:28:37.227
STATE GREAT FOOD ON THE STREETS.
06:28:37.293 --> 06:28:40.030
ARE I. AND A COURSE. AN
06:28:40.096 --> 06:28:43.633
IMPORTANT PATH IMPORTANT PATH
06:28:43.700 --> 06:28:45.802
FOR THE ENTREPRENEURS MOST OF
06:28:45.869 --> 06:28:48.071
THEM FROM IMMIGRANT FAMILIES WHO
06:28:48.138 --> 06:28:50.073
HAVE FOUND A WAY TO MAKE SOME
06:28:50.140 --> 06:28:51.708
MONEY AND BUILD A LIFE FOR
06:28:51.775 --> 06:28:54.310
THEMSELVES BY SELLING FOOD ON
06:28:54.377 --> 06:28:56.379
THE STREETS. HI THERE THERE
06:28:56.446 --> 06:28:59.582
THERE HAVE BEEN TWO. MAJOR
06:28:59.649 --> 06:29:00.583
ISSUES ASSOCIATED WITH THIS
06:29:00.650 --> 06:29:04.521
PROGRAM ONE IS THAT IT'S TOO
06:29:04.587 --> 06:29:07.624
HARD TO GET A PERMIT. I THE
06:29:07.691 --> 06:29:09.826
RULES THAT WERE NEGOTIATED IN
06:29:09.893 --> 06:29:12.195
THE FIRST BILL SB NINE FORTY
06:29:12.262 --> 06:29:17.000
SIX. I ULTIMATELY LEFT THE FOOD
06:29:17.067 --> 06:29:19.469
SAFETY STANDARDS UP TO BASICALLY
06:29:19.536 --> 06:29:21.805
FOOD TRUCK STANDARDS. WHICH IS
06:29:21.871 --> 06:29:23.873
SOMETHING THAT THE AVERAGE FOOD
06:29:23.940 --> 06:29:25.775
CART SIMPLY CAN'T MEET. LOTS OF
06:29:25.842 --> 06:29:27.310
COUNTIES HAD MADE IT TOO
06:29:27.377 --> 06:29:29.212
DIFFICULT TO GET PERMITS. AND
06:29:29.279 --> 06:29:31.114
YOU HAVE A LOT OF FOLKS WHO ARE
06:29:31.181 --> 06:29:32.882
KIND OF OPERATING IN THE
06:29:32.949 --> 06:29:35.118
TWILIGHT ZONE. ARE IN TERMS OF
06:29:35.185 --> 06:29:37.754
PERMITS. THIS IS AN ISSUE THAT
06:29:37.821 --> 06:29:40.657
OUR COLLEAGUE FROM LONG BEACH IS
06:29:40.724 --> 06:29:41.758
ADDRESSING WITH HER SB NINE
06:29:41.825 --> 06:29:44.761
SEVENTY TWO. IT'S A BILL THAT I
06:29:44.828 --> 06:29:46.429
SUPPORT WE'LL BE TALKING ABOUT
06:29:46.496 --> 06:29:48.465
IT I BELIEVE TOMORROW. I'M THE
06:29:48.531 --> 06:29:50.233
OTHER PROBLEM WITH THIS I
06:29:50.300 --> 06:29:52.135
WATCHED ANY PROGRAM HAS BEEN. A
06:29:52.202 --> 06:29:54.104
RELATIVELY LIMITED. A
06:29:54.170 --> 06:29:56.940
PROBLEMATIC IN A FEW KEY CITIES
06:29:57.006 --> 06:29:59.542
IN OUR STATE. THESE ARE CITIES
06:29:59.609 --> 06:30:01.311
THAT HAVE TYPICALLY VERY HIGH
06:30:01.377 --> 06:30:04.214
TOURISM. FULLER SITES BALBOA
06:30:04.280 --> 06:30:06.449
PARK IN SAN DIEGO EMBARCADERO
06:30:06.516 --> 06:30:08.818
PIER THIRTY NINE AREA IN SAN
06:30:08.885 --> 06:30:10.787
FRANCISCO THE SANTA MONICA PIER.
06:30:10.854 --> 06:30:12.789
WHERE YOU'VE GOT A LOT OF
06:30:12.856 --> 06:30:15.525
VENDORS WHO COME TOGETHER. AND
06:30:15.592 --> 06:30:17.560
THEY'VE BEEN CHALLENGES IN
06:30:17.627 --> 06:30:20.497
TRYING TO MANAGE AND MAINTAIN.
06:30:20.563 --> 06:30:23.233
AND IN THE CASE OF THE PIER.
06:30:23.299 --> 06:30:25.335
WE'VE GOT FOLKS WITH OPEN FLAMES
06:30:25.401 --> 06:30:26.236
PEOPLE POURING GREASE INTO THE
06:30:26.302 --> 06:30:29.139
WATER THIS IS A RELATIVELY SMALL
06:30:29.205 --> 06:30:30.940
PORTION OF THE VENDOR COMMUNITY-
06:30:31.007 --> 06:30:34.010
BUT- NUMBER CITIES A SAID HEY
06:30:34.077 --> 06:30:36.579
WE'VE GOT A WE'VE GOT TO HAVE
06:30:36.646 --> 06:30:37.881
SOME MORE TOOLS. TO HOLD. THOSE
06:30:37.947 --> 06:30:39.716
FOLKS WHO ARE REALLY UNWILLING
06:30:39.783 --> 06:30:40.884
TO COMPLY WITH THE RULES
06:30:40.950 --> 06:30:42.418
ACCOUNTABLE. SO THAT'S WHERE
06:30:42.485 --> 06:30:44.854
THIS BILL COMES FROM. I'M NOT
06:30:44.921 --> 06:30:46.022
WEDDED TO THE MECHANISMS N THIS
06:30:46.089 --> 06:30:49.092
BILL I IF I WOULD HAVE PREDICTED
06:30:49.159 --> 06:30:50.293
WOULD BE IT'LL PROBABLY CHANGE
06:30:50.360 --> 06:30:52.862
QUITE A BIT. I'M I'M VERY
06:30:52.929 --> 06:30:54.297
COMMITTED TO WORKING WITH THE
06:30:54.364 --> 06:30:56.900
ADVOCATES ARE WHO ARE I THINK
06:30:56.966 --> 06:30:59.435
VERY RIGHTEOUSLY TRYING TO HELP
06:30:59.502 --> 06:31:01.538
PROVIDE MORE AVENUES FOR PEOPLE
06:31:01.604 --> 06:31:03.540
TO BUILD UP A LIFE FOR
06:31:03.606 --> 06:31:04.107
THEMSELVES THROUGH SIDEWALK
06:31:04.174 --> 06:31:05.241
VENDING. I'M ALSO TRYING TO
06:31:05.308 --> 06:31:06.075
FIGURE OUT A WAY TO HELP
06:31:06.142 --> 06:31:08.211
COMMUNITIES LIKE MINE THE CITY
06:31:08.278 --> 06:31:10.713
SANTA MONICA. HANDLE THIS
06:31:10.780 --> 06:31:12.248
DIFFICULT SITUATION THAT THEY
06:31:12.315 --> 06:31:15.051
FIND THEMSELVES IN AT THE PIER.
06:31:15.118 --> 06:31:17.854
SO THIS IS THE CHALLENGE. ARE
06:31:17.921 --> 06:31:18.488
THAT I'M TRYING TO ADDRESS FOR
06:31:18.555 --> 06:31:20.356
THIS BILL. IT'S BEEN VERY
06:31:20.423 --> 06:31:22.725
LIMITED IN COMMITTEE. AND IN THE
06:31:22.792 --> 06:31:24.828
GOVERNOR FIVE COMMITTEE- THERE
06:31:24.894 --> 06:31:26.963
ARE A SET OF RULES THAT HAVE TO
06:31:27.030 --> 06:31:29.399
BE PUT INTO A SET OF
06:31:29.465 --> 06:31:30.567
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WE PUT IN
06:31:30.633 --> 06:31:31.901
PLACE FOR TWO EVEN KICK IN. I
06:31:31.968 --> 06:31:34.270
ALSO CALLS FOR A STUDY. TO LOOK
06:31:34.337 --> 06:31:36.706
AT THE ISSUES AND CHALLENGES OF
06:31:36.773 --> 06:31:37.674
NONCOMPLIANCE SOCI LOCAL
06:31:37.740 --> 06:31:40.510
SIDEWALK VENDING. I'M HOPEFUL
06:31:40.577 --> 06:31:42.779
THAT. THROUGH THE COURSE OF THIS
06:31:42.846 --> 06:31:45.148
LEGISLATIVE. SESSION WILL BE
06:31:45.215 --> 06:31:47.450
ABLE TO COME TO A SERIES OF
06:31:47.517 --> 06:31:49.052
SOLUTIONS WHERE WE EXPAND ACCESS
06:31:49.118 --> 06:31:51.354
TO PERMITS. THAT'S AT THE HEART
06:31:51.421 --> 06:31:53.890
OF. SENATORS OFFICES BILL- AT
06:31:53.957 --> 06:31:56.626
BUT WE DO AND WE DO SO IN A WAY
06:31:56.693 --> 06:31:57.527
THAT WILL WORK. FOR COMMUNITIES
06:31:57.594 --> 06:31:59.295
AND ALSO WORK FOR CONSUMERS AND
06:31:59.362 --> 06:32:01.030
WORK FOR IMMIGRANT FAMILIES WHO
06:32:01.097 --> 06:32:02.866
ARE TRYING TO BUILD. LIVES FOR
06:32:02.932 --> 06:32:04.934
THEMSELVES. THROUGH THIS AT THE
06:32:05.001 --> 06:32:06.269
SIDEWALK VENDING. AND SO I ASK
06:32:06.336 --> 06:32:08.238
YOU TO GIVE ME THE OPPORTUNITY
06:32:08.304 --> 06:32:10.206
WORKING ON THIS IS NOT AN EASY.
06:32:10.273 --> 06:32:15.111
ISSUE HI AND- ASPIRIN ABOUT.
06:32:15.178 --> 06:32:16.179
THANK YOU CENTER ALAN SENATOR
06:32:16.246 --> 06:32:17.647
GONZALEZ. THANK YOU MADAM
06:32:17.714 --> 06:32:21.918
PRESIDENT AND- MEMBERS I WANT TO
06:32:21.985 --> 06:32:23.653
THANK MY COLLEAGUE FROM SANTA
06:32:23.720 --> 06:32:26.122
MONICA I RESPECT HIM DEARLY BUT
06:32:26.189 --> 06:32:27.790
I REALLY DISAGREE WITH HIS
06:32:27.857 --> 06:32:30.293
APPROACH INNISFAIL- WE WILL TALK
06:32:30.360 --> 06:32:32.362
ABOUT A SEPARATE BILL TOMORROW
06:32:32.428 --> 06:32:33.463
OF COURSE THAT IS NOT THE BILL
06:32:33.529 --> 06:32:35.131
THAT IS ON THE FLOOR CURRENTLY
06:32:35.198 --> 06:32:36.199
BUT WITH THIS BILL I AM
06:32:36.266 --> 06:32:38.234
COMMITTED TO COMMIT CONTINUING
06:32:38.301 --> 06:32:40.270
TO WORK WITH HIM. BUT ALTHOUGH A
06:32:40.336 --> 06:32:42.572
LOT OF- WHAT WE'VE SEEN SO FAR
06:32:42.639 --> 06:32:43.606
WE DON'T EVEN KNOW I MEAN
06:32:43.673 --> 06:32:45.074
THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF BLAME PUT
06:32:45.141 --> 06:32:48.011
ON WHAT WE THINK IS ON PERMITTED
06:32:48.077 --> 06:32:51.781
VENDORS WERE NOT SURE THAT THAT
06:32:51.848 --> 06:32:53.216
DATA IS NOT AVAILABLE NO IDEA
06:32:53.283 --> 06:32:56.853
THAT. A LOT. BUT LOCALS CAN DO
06:32:56.920 --> 06:32:59.155
TO CURB A LOT OF THE ISSUES THAT
06:32:59.222 --> 06:33:00.857
MAY BE HAPPENING IN CERTAIN
06:33:00.924 --> 06:33:02.492
CITIES- AND THEY'RE NOT DOING
06:33:02.558 --> 06:33:06.129
IT. AND SO I TAKE SORT OF- HEART
06:33:06.195 --> 06:33:07.397
TO THE FACT THAT THESE ISSUES
06:33:07.463 --> 06:33:09.265
ARE HAPPENING BUT I ALSO WANT TO
06:33:09.332 --> 06:33:10.500
ENCOURAGE THE LOCALS AND DO
06:33:10.566 --> 06:33:11.901
EVERYTHING THAT I CAN'T TO
06:33:11.968 --> 06:33:13.236
ENCOURAGE LOCALS TO SEPARATE THE
06:33:13.303 --> 06:33:14.871
ISSUE THAT. AT THE END OF THE
06:33:14.938 --> 06:33:17.640
DAY WE WANT MICRO BUSINESSES TO
06:33:17.707 --> 06:33:18.308
BE ABLE TO SUCCEED WE WANT TO
06:33:18.374 --> 06:33:20.109
ENSURE THAT WE INCLUDE WE HAVE A
06:33:20.176 --> 06:33:21.377
VERY INCLUSIVE ECONOMY THAT
06:33:21.444 --> 06:33:22.845
INCLUDES EVERYBODY. WHETHER
06:33:22.912 --> 06:33:25.481
THEY'RE- UNDOCUMENTED OR NOT
06:33:25.548 --> 06:33:26.816
WHETHER THEY YOU KNOW WHEREVER
06:33:26.883 --> 06:33:28.384
THEY COME FROM IF THEY'RE
06:33:28.451 --> 06:33:30.420
SELLING THESE STREET FOOD- ITEMS
06:33:30.486 --> 06:33:32.021
THAT ARE DELICIOUS AND EVERYONE
06:33:32.088 --> 06:33:33.356
WANTS TO ENJOY. THIS THIS
06:33:33.423 --> 06:33:35.258
ECONOMY HAS TO BE AS INCLUSIVE
06:33:35.325 --> 06:33:36.960
AS POSSIBLE WE HAVE TO TREAT
06:33:37.026 --> 06:33:37.961
MICRO BUSINESSES SIMILAR TO WHAT
06:33:38.027 --> 06:33:40.263
WE TREAT HOW WE TREAT OUR SMALL
06:33:40.330 --> 06:33:41.164
BUSINESSES ARE BRICK AND MORTAR
06:33:41.230 --> 06:33:43.032
BUSINESSES THAT ARE ALSO. DOING
06:33:43.099 --> 06:33:44.000
EVERYTHING THAT THEY CAN TO
06:33:44.067 --> 06:33:45.802
SURVIVE SO. I RESPECT MY
06:33:45.868 --> 06:33:47.937
COLLEAGUE I RESPECT WERE- HE'S
06:33:48.004 --> 06:33:49.973
GOING WITH- YOU KNOW WORKING
06:33:50.039 --> 06:33:53.076
WITH ME I JUST VEHEMENTLY IN OUR
06:33:53.142 --> 06:33:54.277
DISAGREE WITH WITH THIS APPROACH
06:33:54.344 --> 06:33:57.080
AND I. BE VOTING NO ON THIS BUT
06:33:57.146 --> 06:33:58.247
I AM COMMITTED TO CONTINUE
06:33:58.314 --> 06:34:00.216
WORKING ON IN A DIFFERENT MANNER
06:34:00.283 --> 06:34:01.351
TO ENSURE THAT WE GET THIS RIGHT
06:34:01.417 --> 06:34:03.152
SO I WANT TO. THANK YOU FOR
06:34:03.219 --> 06:34:05.588
THAT. THANK YOU CENTER GONZALEZ
06:34:05.655 --> 06:34:08.057
CENTER WIENER. THANK YOU VERY
06:34:08.124 --> 06:34:10.760
MUCH- MADAM PRESIDENT I WANT TO
06:34:10.827 --> 06:34:14.630
THANK- THE AUTHOR FOR TAKING ON-
06:34:14.697 --> 06:34:17.633
AND INCREDIBLY. DIFFICULT MMHM
06:34:17.700 --> 06:34:22.305
AT ISSUE WHERE- THERE IS IT'S
06:34:22.372 --> 06:34:24.907
HARD TO SURVIVE. THE TACKLE THIS
06:34:24.974 --> 06:34:26.809
PROBLEM AND TO FIND AN EFFECTIVE
06:34:26.876 --> 06:34:29.345
AND EQUITABLE WAY- TO ADDRESS IT
06:34:29.412 --> 06:34:31.547
AND THE AUTHOR AS WELL CENTER
06:34:31.614 --> 06:34:32.448
FROM LONG BEACH AND I HAVE BEEN
06:34:32.515 --> 06:34:35.118
HAVING. CONVERSATIONS AND WE'VE
06:34:35.184 --> 06:34:37.854
BEEN TALKING TO THE VARIOUS
06:34:37.920 --> 06:34:38.788
CITIES THAT ARE SORT OF
06:34:38.855 --> 06:34:41.057
STRUGGLING WITH THE ISSUE THAT A
06:34:41.124 --> 06:34:43.092
BIG ZOOM I KNOW WE'RE GONNA HAVE
06:34:43.159 --> 06:34:45.194
SOME ADDITIONAL MEETINGS- AND I
06:34:45.261 --> 06:34:46.262
AM SOMEONE RIGHT VERY VERY
06:34:46.329 --> 06:34:48.464
STRONGLY SUPPORTED SB NINE FORTY
06:34:48.531 --> 06:34:50.099
SIX. ON A IF THAT WAS THE
06:34:50.166 --> 06:34:52.068
CORRECT NUMBER- AND I THINK IT'S
06:34:52.135 --> 06:34:55.171
SO IMPORTANT THAT WE SUPPORT-
06:34:55.238 --> 06:34:56.906
THESE- THESE MICRO BUSINESSES
06:34:56.973 --> 06:34:59.642
AND- SUPPORTING CENTER FROM LONG
06:34:59.709 --> 06:35:01.878
BEACH IS A BILL TO REALLY TRY TO
06:35:01.944 --> 06:35:03.980
IMPROVE THE PERMITTING PROCESS
06:35:04.047 --> 06:35:05.048
AND SOME OF THE CODES THAT
06:35:05.114 --> 06:35:06.816
THESE. BUSINESSES HAVE AN EASIER
06:35:06.883 --> 06:35:09.585
PATH- TO GET A PERMIT AND BECOME
06:35:09.652 --> 06:35:11.788
LEGAL BECAUSE YOU CAN SAY HELLO
06:35:11.854 --> 06:35:14.023
WE DEMAND YOU BE LEGAL ROOMMATE
06:35:14.090 --> 06:35:15.591
REALLY HARD FOR YOU TO GET THE
06:35:15.658 --> 06:35:18.828
PERMIT- AND- AND THIS BILL AS I
06:35:18.895 --> 06:35:22.732
SETTING COMMITTEE. AND I THINK
06:35:22.799 --> 06:35:23.800
IT'S THE AUTHORIZING KNOWLEDGE.
06:35:23.866 --> 06:35:25.101
IT'S GOING TO NEED. SOME MORE
06:35:25.168 --> 06:35:27.203
WORK AND I THINK THE TERM YOU
06:35:27.270 --> 06:35:28.337
KNOW THERE MAY BE A DIFFERENT OR
06:35:28.404 --> 06:35:30.273
BETTER. PATH FOR BUT I THINK
06:35:30.339 --> 06:35:31.107
IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT FOR THIS.
06:35:31.174 --> 06:35:32.909
CONVERSATION TO CONTINUE OVER
06:35:32.975 --> 06:35:35.511
THE SUMMER SO WE CAN TRY TO COME
06:35:35.578 --> 06:35:37.313
TO A RESOLUTION THIS BILL MAY OR
06:35:37.380 --> 06:35:39.749
MAY NOT BE ENACTED. IN THE- BUT
06:35:39.816 --> 06:35:40.917
I DO THINK THE CONVERSATION IS A
06:35:40.983 --> 06:35:42.852
CONTINUE. AND WHAT I KNOW IS IN
06:35:42.919 --> 06:35:46.122
SAN FRANCISCO. ON WHICH IS A-
06:35:46.189 --> 06:35:48.124
TEMAS WHO HAS ALWAYS BEEN A TEAM
06:35:48.191 --> 06:35:50.126
MORE OPEN TO THESE MICRO
06:35:50.193 --> 06:35:52.195
BUSINESSES AND STREET VENDORS
06:35:52.261 --> 06:35:53.863
AND OTHER CITIES HAVE BEEN. SAN
06:35:53.930 --> 06:35:55.765
FRANCISCO HAS IMPLEMENTED- A
06:35:55.832 --> 06:35:57.467
PERMANENT PROGRAM SERVICES WAS
06:35:57.533 --> 06:35:59.702
NOT IN ANY WAY A CITY THAT'S
06:35:59.769 --> 06:36:01.938
HOSTILE- TO STREET VENDING- BUT
06:36:02.004 --> 06:36:04.373
THERE HAVE BEEN SOME REAL
06:36:04.440 --> 06:36:05.641
CHALLENGES- DIVE THE CITY. ARE
06:36:05.708 --> 06:36:07.743
SMALL BUSINESSES AND A PERMANENT
06:36:07.810 --> 06:36:09.712
VENDORS HAVE BEEN EXPERIENCING-
06:36:09.779 --> 06:36:11.114
AND SO I WANTED TO CONVERSATION
06:36:11.180 --> 06:36:12.849
CONTINUE AND I'LL BE SUPPORTING
06:36:12.915 --> 06:36:14.951
THE LEGISLATION TODAY. THANK YOU
06:36:15.017 --> 06:36:18.754
CENTER WIENER CENTER NIELSEN.
06:36:18.821 --> 06:36:21.124
SORRY. BUT YOUR MIKE DOWN THANK
06:36:21.190 --> 06:36:22.158
YOU CENTER DRAWS SO. YES ARE.
06:36:22.225 --> 06:36:24.060
YOU NON IN ADDITION TO
06:36:24.127 --> 06:36:25.661
EVERYTHING THAT'S THAT'S BEEN
06:36:25.728 --> 06:36:26.996
SET HERE- THESE ARE VERY
06:36:27.063 --> 06:36:29.232
ECONOMICALLY VULNERABLE STREET
06:36:29.298 --> 06:36:32.435
VENDORS. AND I KNOW THE AUTHOR
06:36:32.502 --> 06:36:34.537
ACKNOWLEDGES THAT BUT- WE NEED
06:36:34.604 --> 06:36:37.240
TO SHOW THAT. WE'RE GOING TO DO
06:36:37.306 --> 06:36:38.875
SOMETHING DIFFERENT TO
06:36:38.941 --> 06:36:41.410
ECONOMICALLY VULNERABLE VENDORS
06:36:41.477 --> 06:36:43.112
OTHER THAN WHAT SORT OF
06:36:43.179 --> 06:36:48.384
TRADITIONALLY- WE GET- WE GET
06:36:48.451 --> 06:36:50.052
HIT HIT WITH OR WE WANNA GET
06:36:50.119 --> 06:36:52.488
WITH WHICH IS MAKING IT HARDER
06:36:52.555 --> 06:36:54.724
FOR THEM- WE JUST DID A WHOLE
06:36:54.790 --> 06:36:56.192
SLEW AND I THINK THERE'S MORE TO
06:36:56.259 --> 06:36:59.495
COME ON CANNABIS BUSINESSES.
06:36:59.562 --> 06:37:01.964
WE'VE DONE WE ARE INVESTING A
06:37:02.031 --> 06:37:03.633
TON OF MONEY WERE LOWERING THEIR
06:37:03.699 --> 06:37:05.868
TAXES WE'RE GIVING THEM WE'RE
06:37:05.935 --> 06:37:08.471
INVESTING IN THEM TO BE ABLE TO
06:37:08.538 --> 06:37:10.106
PICK UP THEIR BUSINESSES WHETHER
06:37:10.173 --> 06:37:12.508
IT'S FROM CULTIVATION ALL THE
06:37:12.575 --> 06:37:14.744
WAY TO THE RETAIL IN. AND THAT'S
06:37:14.810 --> 06:37:17.613
A GOOD THING NGUYEN SAY PILE.
06:37:17.680 --> 06:37:21.284
THE PUNISHMENT WOULDN'T SAY THAT
06:37:21.350 --> 06:37:24.220
WE SAID LET'S DO THIS DIFFERENT
06:37:24.287 --> 06:37:26.789
APPROACH TO BUSINESSES THEY ARE
06:37:26.856 --> 06:37:28.991
BUSINESSES THEY'RE JUST REALLY
06:37:29.058 --> 06:37:32.361
POOR TRYING TO MAKE ENOUGH. FOR
06:37:32.428 --> 06:37:33.396
THEM AND THEIR FAMILIES TO GET
06:37:33.462 --> 06:37:36.566
BY SO AN ADDITIONAL LAYER OF
06:37:36.632 --> 06:37:38.935
FINES. MAY MAKE YOU KNOW SOME
06:37:39.001 --> 06:37:42.705
FOLKS- YOU KNOW FIELD OKAY WE'RE
06:37:42.772 --> 06:37:43.940
TAKING THE RIGHT APPROACH BUT
06:37:44.006 --> 06:37:45.741
YOU'RE NOT. AND I REALLY FEEL
06:37:45.808 --> 06:37:48.177
STRONGLY ABOUT THIS I THINK THAT
06:37:48.244 --> 06:37:50.046
THE APPROACH BY- THE AUTHOR OF
06:37:50.112 --> 06:37:53.516
SB NINE SEVENTY TWO IS- THE
06:37:53.583 --> 06:37:55.418
BETTER MORE POSITIVE APPROACH.
06:37:55.484 --> 06:37:57.453
IS BEING NINE SEVENTY TWO IS A
06:37:57.520 --> 06:38:00.723
LATINO **** AS A PRIORITY- WE
06:38:00.790 --> 06:38:01.958
THINK THAT IT'S MAKING THE KINDS
06:38:02.024 --> 06:38:04.427
OF CHANGES. TO THE REGULATIONS
06:38:04.493 --> 06:38:06.963
THAT COULD BE AND SHOULD BE.
06:38:07.029 --> 06:38:10.466
MADE AND WE NEED TO LOOK AT
06:38:10.533 --> 06:38:14.570
THESE VENDORS AS A RECOGNIZED
06:38:14.637 --> 06:38:17.974
ECONOMIC PART SECTOR. THEY ARE
06:38:18.040 --> 06:38:20.276
NOT THESE CRIMINALS THAT WE HAD
06:38:20.343 --> 06:38:22.078
TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO HOW TO
06:38:22.144 --> 06:38:24.513
BRUSH ASIDE AND I DO THINK THAT.
06:38:24.580 --> 06:38:26.182
THAT HAPPENS IN REAL IN SOME OF
06:38:26.249 --> 06:38:30.686
THE LOCAL AREAS SO- I REALLY.
06:38:30.753 --> 06:38:34.924
URGE THE- THE AUTHOR TWO. YOU
06:38:34.991 --> 06:38:39.161
KNOW LET'S BOMB WE DO THIS LET'S
06:38:39.228 --> 06:38:41.030
RESET THIS BECAUSE THIS IS NOT
06:38:41.097 --> 06:38:42.932
THE RIGHT APPROACH THIS IS NOT
06:38:42.999 --> 06:38:45.334
BEEN IS NOT GIVING THE APPROACH
06:38:45.401 --> 06:38:46.869
THAT THIS LEGISLATURE PASSED
06:38:46.936 --> 06:38:48.871
JUST A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO NOT
06:38:48.938 --> 06:38:51.607
GIVEN THE TIME NEEDED FOR THAT
06:38:51.674 --> 06:38:54.176
APPROACH TO WORK- AND I WOULD
06:38:54.243 --> 06:38:56.412
JUST SAY FINALLY YOU KNOW THOSE
06:38:56.479 --> 06:38:59.181
STREET VENDORS THEY KNOW WHAT'S
06:38:59.248 --> 06:39:02.718
FAIR. THEY KNOW WHAT TO DO LET'S
06:39:02.785 --> 06:39:06.289
INCLUDE THEM NOT AS ADVERSARIES
06:39:06.355 --> 06:39:07.823
THAT ARE DOING SOMETHING WRONG
06:39:07.890 --> 06:39:10.893
BUT LET'S INCLUDE THEM TO FIND
06:39:10.960 --> 06:39:14.697
THE RIGHT SOLUTIONS. THANK YOU
06:39:14.764 --> 06:39:16.932
CENTER DRAWS- CENTER GLAZER.
06:39:16.999 --> 06:39:18.134
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND
06:39:18.200 --> 06:39:19.969
MEMBERS AND IN THAT GREAT
06:39:20.036 --> 06:39:21.304
TRADITION OF THE SENATE- THAT
06:39:21.370 --> 06:39:23.172
LOVES TO BAIT AND DIFFERENT
06:39:23.239 --> 06:39:24.273
VIEWS- AND I SHARE A DIFFERENT
06:39:24.340 --> 06:39:26.275
VIEW A DIFFERENT VOICE THAT HAS
06:39:26.342 --> 06:39:27.109
BEEN SHARED SO FAR IN THIS
06:39:27.176 --> 06:39:28.811
CONVERSATION I OPPOSE THE
06:39:28.878 --> 06:39:30.546
ORIGINAL UNDERLINE BILL THAT
06:39:30.613 --> 06:39:33.349
THIS BILL SEEKS TO CORRECT WHY
06:39:33.416 --> 06:39:34.517
WAS THAT WAS IT ANTI STREET
06:39:34.583 --> 06:39:36.252
VENDOR OF COURSE NOT. BOB WAS
06:39:36.319 --> 06:39:38.921
ABOUT. JUSTLY TOOK AWAY LOCAL
06:39:38.988 --> 06:39:41.023
CONTROL FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
06:39:41.090 --> 06:39:42.591
TO BE ABLE TO REGULATE. THE
06:39:42.658 --> 06:39:44.527
HEALTH AND SAFETY OF THEIR
06:39:44.593 --> 06:39:47.463
COMMUNITY. AND SO NOW WE HAVE A
06:39:47.530 --> 06:39:48.564
PROBLEM THAT CENTER ALLEN IS
06:39:48.631 --> 06:39:51.434
TRYING TO CONSTRUCTIVELY ADDRESS
06:39:51.500 --> 06:39:54.170
BUT KEEP THIS IN MIND. YEAH WE
06:39:54.236 --> 06:39:55.237
HAVE SMALL BUSINESSES IN OUR
06:39:55.304 --> 06:39:56.972
COMMUNITY THAT THAT SERVE FOOD
06:39:57.039 --> 06:39:58.841
AND HAD PRODUCT THEY GO THROUGH
06:39:58.908 --> 06:40:00.209
ALL THE LICENSING THEY HAVE ALL
06:40:00.276 --> 06:40:03.813
THE OVERHEAD OBLIGATIONS. AND
06:40:03.879 --> 06:40:04.880
WALL STREET VENDING IS A
06:40:04.947 --> 06:40:06.148
WONDERFUL ADDITION TO OUR
06:40:06.215 --> 06:40:08.084
COMMUNITY THAT'S UNREGULATED
06:40:08.150 --> 06:40:10.052
THEY CAN STEP IN AND TAKE THE-
06:40:10.119 --> 06:40:13.255
THE- THE- KANEMI AWAY FROM THOSE
06:40:13.322 --> 06:40:15.091
BRICK AND MORTARS THAT WE HAVE
06:40:15.157 --> 06:40:16.959
FOLLOWED ALL THE RULES SO THAT'S
06:40:17.026 --> 06:40:18.994
THE DILEMMA. AND WHEN YOU TAKE
06:40:19.061 --> 06:40:20.329
AWAY LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ABILITY
06:40:20.396 --> 06:40:21.130
TO MAKE THESE THOUGHTFUL
06:40:21.197 --> 06:40:23.466
CHOICES. IN A COMMUNITY SETTING
06:40:23.532 --> 06:40:24.834
WITH PUBLIC HEARINGS AND PUBLIC
06:40:24.900 --> 06:40:26.635
INPUT IN THE REST THEN WE'RE
06:40:26.702 --> 06:40:28.037
LEFT WITH THE STATE NOW BECAUSE
06:40:28.104 --> 06:40:29.705
WE CREATED THIS ONE SIZE FITS
06:40:29.772 --> 06:40:31.874
ALL. TRYING TO FIND A CORRECTIVE
06:40:31.941 --> 06:40:34.009
ACTION WHICH IS LEGISLATION
06:40:34.076 --> 06:40:35.845
ATTEMPTS TO ADVANCE AND WALL
06:40:35.911 --> 06:40:37.380
THERE THE DEBATE IS GOING TO BE
06:40:37.446 --> 06:40:40.082
IN THE SPACE THAT WE CREATED.
06:40:40.149 --> 06:40:41.317
AND I WISH WE COULD GO BACKWARDS
06:40:41.384 --> 06:40:43.319
A LITTLE BIT ON IT WHICH I KNOW
06:40:43.386 --> 06:40:45.821
IS A DIFFERENT VIEW I THINK THIS
06:40:45.888 --> 06:40:47.356
BILL IS A CONSTRUCTIVE STEP
06:40:47.423 --> 06:40:48.290
FORWARD AND ALL SUPPORT IT
06:40:48.357 --> 06:40:49.291
TODAY. THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZERS
06:40:49.358 --> 06:40:51.594
CENTER CABALLERO. THANK YOU
06:40:51.660 --> 06:40:53.396
MADAM PRESIDENT WELL YOU KNOW
06:40:53.462 --> 06:40:55.898
WHAT- THIS IS A REALLY GOOD
06:40:55.965 --> 06:40:59.969
EXAMPLE OF HOW- ONE. SIZE
06:41:00.035 --> 06:41:03.272
DOESN'T FIT ALL- I AM VERY LUCKY
06:41:03.339 --> 06:41:05.508
I GUESS BECAUSE I DON'T HAVE BIG
06:41:05.574 --> 06:41:06.776
ENTERTAINMENT VENUES I DON'T
06:41:06.842 --> 06:41:08.177
HAVE PLACES THAT TOURISTS WANT
06:41:08.244 --> 06:41:10.045
TO GO I DON'T I DON'T HAVE BEEN
06:41:10.112 --> 06:41:12.114
USE WHERE THERE'S LOTS OF PEOPLE
06:41:12.181 --> 06:41:15.451
THAT SHOW UP. AND AND EXPECT TO
06:41:15.518 --> 06:41:18.154
GET IN AND OUT AND HAVE A GOOD
06:41:18.220 --> 06:41:21.590
TIME- CHAU ICING I. SAT ON THE
06:41:21.657 --> 06:41:23.392
CITY COUNCIL WHEN WE ADOPTED A
06:41:23.459 --> 06:41:25.961
BENDER ORDINANCE AND- I'M I'M
06:41:26.028 --> 06:41:27.563
REALLY PROUD TO SAY THAT IN OUR
06:41:27.630 --> 06:41:29.598
COMMUNITY- WE WELCOME THEM WITH
06:41:29.665 --> 06:41:31.434
OPEN ARMS AND MADE IT MADE IT
06:41:31.500 --> 06:41:33.502
POSSIBLE FOR THEM TO SET UP. A
06:41:33.569 --> 06:41:36.539
LEGAL SHOP AND NOT TO IMPACT THE
06:41:36.605 --> 06:41:38.174
BUSINESSES THAT WERE THE BRICK
06:41:38.240 --> 06:41:40.943
AND MORTAR BUSINESSES- AND WE
06:41:41.010 --> 06:41:43.145
FIGURED OUT A WAY TO BE ABLE TO
06:41:43.212 --> 06:41:44.947
DO IT. ONE SIZE DOESN'T FIT ALL
06:41:45.014 --> 06:41:46.882
SO I SAT IS THE CHAIR OF
06:41:46.949 --> 06:41:48.083
GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE WE HEARD
06:41:48.150 --> 06:41:49.585
THIS BILL. AND THE CHALLENGES IS
06:41:49.652 --> 06:41:51.454
THERE ARE SOME PARTS OF THE
06:41:51.520 --> 06:41:53.322
COMMUNITY- AND SOME PARTS OF
06:41:53.389 --> 06:41:56.358
CALIFORNIA. BAD THAT HOST HUGE
06:41:56.425 --> 06:41:58.594
CROWDS WHERE LOTS OF PEOPLE AND
06:41:58.661 --> 06:42:01.197
I'M TALKING TEN THOUSAND PEOPLE
06:42:01.263 --> 06:42:03.199
SHOW UP AND THEY WANT TO BE ABLE
06:42:03.265 --> 06:42:05.634
TO. ACCESS GET IN GET OUT AND
06:42:05.701 --> 06:42:07.336
SOME OF THOSE PEOPLE ARE
06:42:07.403 --> 06:42:08.938
DISABLED. SOME OF THEM- HAVE
06:42:09.004 --> 06:42:11.474
NEEDS TO BE ABLE TO USE THE
06:42:11.540 --> 06:42:13.409
SIDEWALKS AND- AND FOR THERE NOT
06:42:13.476 --> 06:42:16.111
TO BE. FOOD THROWN OUT ON THE ON
06:42:16.178 --> 06:42:20.149
THE GROUND OR OIL IT'S DUMPED-
06:42:20.216 --> 06:42:23.385
OR- KING. THAT THE ACCESS
06:42:23.452 --> 06:42:25.454
BECAUSE THEY JUST WANTED TO TAKE
06:42:25.521 --> 06:42:27.256
UP AS MUCH SPACE AS POSSIBLE.
06:42:27.323 --> 06:42:30.593
AND I'M SENSITIVE TO THAT ISSUE-
06:42:30.659 --> 06:42:32.294
BECAUSE WE ALL GO TO THOSE
06:42:32.361 --> 06:42:34.730
VENUES AS WELL WE WANT TO ENJOY
06:42:34.797 --> 06:42:35.998
A FISHERMAN'S WHARF WE WANT TO
06:42:36.065 --> 06:42:38.133
ENJOY GOING TO A RAMS GAME. WE
06:42:38.200 --> 06:42:40.202
WANT TO BE ABLE TO GO TO A
06:42:40.269 --> 06:42:42.137
GIANTS GAME AND ALL OF THOSE
06:42:42.204 --> 06:42:43.272
VENUES REQUIRES SOME ORDER
06:42:43.339 --> 06:42:45.407
AROUND THE VENUE. AND THAT'S
06:42:45.474 --> 06:42:47.376
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND SO I WENT
06:42:47.443 --> 06:42:49.078
I REALLY WANT TO RECOGNIZE THE
06:42:49.144 --> 06:42:51.514
HARD WORK- THAT THE GOOD SENATOR
06:42:51.580 --> 06:42:53.249
FROM SANTA MONICA IS DOING IS
06:42:53.315 --> 06:42:55.584
TRYING TO DO WHICH IS TO LISTEN
06:42:55.651 --> 06:42:57.486
TO ALL VOICES TO FIGURE OUT. HOW
06:42:57.553 --> 06:42:59.088
CAN WE BE SUPPORTIVE OF LOCAL
06:42:59.154 --> 06:43:01.290
GOVERNMENT IS TRYING TO MAINTAIN
06:43:01.357 --> 06:43:04.660
THE SECURITY AND THE SAFETY. AND
06:43:04.727 --> 06:43:06.929
SOME INDIVIDUALS AND IT'S NOT
06:43:06.996 --> 06:43:08.831
ALL OF THEM BUT SOME INDIVIDUALS
06:43:08.898 --> 06:43:10.032
BELIEVE THEY DON'T HAVE TO
06:43:10.099 --> 06:43:11.000
FOLLOW THE RULES. BECAUSE
06:43:11.066 --> 06:43:13.402
THEY'RE THEY THEY WILL DUMP COST
06:43:13.469 --> 06:43:15.337
CHEMICALS IN THE OCEAN OR DUBBED
06:43:15.404 --> 06:43:17.273
CAUSTIC CHEMICALS ON THE STREET.
06:43:17.339 --> 06:43:19.241
OR THEY HAVE OPEN FLAMES ARE
06:43:19.308 --> 06:43:21.243
REALLY DANGEROUS. JUST A NUMBER
06:43:21.310 --> 06:43:25.381
OF THINGS SO I IT'S NOT EASY TO
06:43:25.447 --> 06:43:26.615
SOLVE. IT I SUPPORTED THE BILL
06:43:26.682 --> 06:43:27.917
IN COMMITTEE IN A SUPPORT IT
06:43:27.983 --> 06:43:29.885
MOVING FORWARD BECAUSE WE NEED
06:43:29.952 --> 06:43:30.986
TO COME UP WITH THAT. A LOGICAL
06:43:31.053 --> 06:43:32.721
FRAMEWORK THAT ALLOWS LOCAL
06:43:32.788 --> 06:43:33.822
GOVERNMENT TO BE ABLE TO DO WHAT
06:43:33.889 --> 06:43:35.991
THEY DO BEST WHICH IS TO KEEP
06:43:36.058 --> 06:43:36.559
THEIR CITIZENS AND PEOPLE
06:43:36.625 --> 06:43:38.193
VISITING THE COMMUNITY SAFE. BUT
06:43:38.260 --> 06:43:39.929
ALSO ALLOW THE VENDORS TO BE
06:43:39.995 --> 06:43:41.597
ABLE TO MAKE A LIVING. IF THEY
06:43:41.664 --> 06:43:44.433
COMPLY WITH THE RULES. AND SO I
06:43:44.500 --> 06:43:46.235
THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO
06:43:46.302 --> 06:43:47.436
WE'RE GOING TO BE CONSIDERING
06:43:47.503 --> 06:43:49.204
ANOTHER BILL. WHICH DID NOT GO
06:43:49.271 --> 06:43:51.173
THROUGH MY COMMITTEE- AS WELL
06:43:51.240 --> 06:43:52.975
THAT WOULD PROVIDE A FRAMEWORK
06:43:53.042 --> 06:43:55.010
FOR THEM TO BE ABLE TO GET
06:43:55.077 --> 06:43:57.513
PERMITS. THAT MAY BE- THEY
06:43:57.580 --> 06:43:58.147
HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO GET FROM
06:43:58.213 --> 06:44:00.449
SOME OF THE COUNTIES BUT ON THIS
06:44:00.516 --> 06:44:02.084
THIS IS NOT EASY THIS IS NOT
06:44:02.151 --> 06:44:04.053
EASY TO DO BECAUSE YOU'RE TRYING
06:44:04.119 --> 06:44:06.188
TO THREAD THE NEEDLE AND TO BE
06:44:06.255 --> 06:44:06.956
RESPECTFUL OF EVERYBODY. SO I
06:44:07.022 --> 06:44:09.024
URGE A NO VOTE ON THIS BILL
06:44:09.091 --> 06:44:09.925
TODAY. THINKCENTRE CABALLERO
06:44:09.992 --> 06:44:11.660
CENTERING CAL SKI. A MADAM
06:44:11.727 --> 06:44:15.598
PRESIDENT I. SUPPORTED S. B.
06:44:15.664 --> 06:44:17.266
NINE FOUR SIX AND- I THINK I
06:44:17.333 --> 06:44:21.604
UNDERSTAND. THE GOAL OF S. B.
06:44:21.670 --> 06:44:22.171
NINE SEVEN TWO WHICH IS NOT
06:44:22.237 --> 06:44:24.707
BEFORE US WHICH IS. THIS WITH
06:44:24.773 --> 06:44:25.841
THE PERMITTING THAT THAT THE
06:44:25.908 --> 06:44:27.943
HEALTH SIDE. IS THE
06:44:28.010 --> 06:44:30.746
ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES OF THE
06:44:30.813 --> 06:44:34.149
STREET VENDORS. WIDESPREAD OR IS
06:44:34.216 --> 06:44:37.653
IT ISOLATED IS IT DEPENDING ON
06:44:37.720 --> 06:44:40.289
THE HISTORIC NATURE OF THE AREA
06:44:40.356 --> 06:44:41.390
WHERE THE FUNDING IS GOING ON
06:44:41.457 --> 06:44:43.759
CAN YOU GIVE ME SOME IDEA OF
06:44:43.826 --> 06:44:46.095
THE- THE SIZE OF THIS THE
06:44:46.161 --> 06:44:47.963
PROBLEM THAT. THE BILL ATTEMPTS
06:44:48.030 --> 06:44:51.166
TO A- FIX THEIR ACCOUNTS IS AT A
06:44:51.233 --> 06:44:53.268
QUESTION YES IT WAS CENTER AL WE
06:44:53.335 --> 06:44:55.037
TAKE A QUESTION YEAH THESE ARE
06:44:55.104 --> 06:44:59.408
SEAT- SO. AS SEATED THIS IS A
06:44:59.475 --> 06:45:01.477
PROBLEM THAT IT THAT IS VERY
06:45:01.543 --> 06:45:03.178
SERIOUS BUT IN A FEW PLACES IN
06:45:03.245 --> 06:45:05.180
THE STATE IT'S NOT A PART OF THE
06:45:05.247 --> 06:45:06.949
CHALLENGE HERE IS THAT MANY OF
06:45:07.016 --> 06:45:08.384
YOU. DON'T SEE IT DON'T DON'T
06:45:08.450 --> 06:45:09.284
HAVE THIS PROBLEM IN YOUR
06:45:09.351 --> 06:45:11.453
DISTRICTS ARE BUT THERE THERE'S
06:45:11.520 --> 06:45:13.255
SOMETHING ABOUT THE UNIQUE
06:45:13.322 --> 06:45:14.990
CIRCUMSTANCES OF A PLACE LIKE
06:45:15.057 --> 06:45:16.025
THE SANTA MONICA PIER FOR
06:45:16.091 --> 06:45:17.893
EXAMPLE THAT BRINGS IN A LOT OF
06:45:17.960 --> 06:45:19.828
TERRORISTS WHERE PEOPLE CAN MAKE
06:45:19.895 --> 06:45:21.030
A LOT OF MONEY OFF OF SELLING.
06:45:21.096 --> 06:45:22.665
IT'S IN A CONFINED SPACE WE'VE
06:45:22.731 --> 06:45:23.632
GOT HISTORIC STRUCTURE. THAT'S
06:45:23.699 --> 06:45:25.501
RIGHT BY THE OCEAN THERE ARE A
06:45:25.567 --> 06:45:27.136
FEW OTHER PLACES AROUND THE
06:45:27.202 --> 06:45:28.103
STATE THAT HAVE A SIMILAR
06:45:28.170 --> 06:45:29.371
SITUATION BALBOA PARK AND WE
06:45:29.438 --> 06:45:31.407
TALKED ABOUT- EMBARCADERO PIER
06:45:31.473 --> 06:45:32.808
THIRTY NINE IN SAN FRANCISCO A
06:45:32.875 --> 06:45:34.143
COUPLE OTHER PLACES AROUND THE
06:45:34.209 --> 06:45:36.145
STATE- BUT IT IS A LIMIT IT'S
06:45:36.211 --> 06:45:38.547
GEOGRAPHICALLY LIMITED- I DO
06:45:38.614 --> 06:45:40.215
KNOW- AND WE WILL BE DISCUSS
06:45:40.282 --> 06:45:41.650
THIS TOMORROW THE ENVIRONMENTAL
06:45:41.717 --> 06:45:44.019
HEALTH OFFICERS- DO YOU HAVE.
06:45:44.086 --> 06:45:47.056
REAL PROBLEMS WITH. THE BOTH OF
06:45:47.122 --> 06:45:49.158
THE CURRENT LAW AND ALSO THE
06:45:49.224 --> 06:45:51.160
TRAJECTORY OF SOME OF WHAT. IS
06:45:51.226 --> 06:45:53.062
BEING WORKED ON- IN IN SB NINE
06:45:53.128 --> 06:45:54.530
SEP SURE WE'LL DISCUSS THAT
06:45:54.596 --> 06:45:56.231
TOMORROW AND I WAS JUST AS THIS
06:45:56.298 --> 06:45:57.232
GOES FORWARD. ADEN BECAUSE OF
06:45:57.299 --> 06:45:58.767
THE ISSUES THAT WE'VE BEEN
06:45:58.834 --> 06:46:02.337
TALKING ABOUT GREECE- OPEN
06:46:02.404 --> 06:46:04.740
FLAMES- SACHA. SOUP MADAM
06:46:04.807 --> 06:46:06.308
PRESIDENT YES I'M AWAKE I'LL SKI
06:46:06.375 --> 06:46:08.544
WITHOUT QUESTION SO- THE
06:46:08.610 --> 06:46:10.145
ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERN THAT
06:46:10.212 --> 06:46:12.514
YOU'RE HOPING TO ADDRESS HERE IS
06:46:12.581 --> 06:46:15.484
NOT. HEALTH FOOD FOOD HEALTH
06:46:15.551 --> 06:46:17.386
RELATED THAT THE ENDING AND
06:46:17.453 --> 06:46:18.687
WHAT'S BEING SERVED AND ALL
06:46:18.754 --> 06:46:22.624
THAT. IT'S THE WASTE OR THE- ARM
06:46:22.691 --> 06:46:25.461
THE DANGER. VERSUS DANGER THE
06:46:25.527 --> 06:46:27.129
RIGHT WORDS THAT THEY MAY POSE
06:46:27.196 --> 06:46:29.031
TO SOME OF THESE WOODEN PIERS.
06:46:29.098 --> 06:46:32.201
OR THE AFTERMATH OF AFTER THE
06:46:32.267 --> 06:46:33.435
FOOD'S BEEN CONSUMING THE
06:46:33.502 --> 06:46:35.204
VENDORS HAVE GONE AWAY. I MEAN
06:46:35.270 --> 06:46:36.972
BASICALLY JUST HAVE TO GET UP ON
06:46:37.039 --> 06:46:39.208
WHO WE'RE TALKING TO BILLS OF.
06:46:39.274 --> 06:46:41.176
SB NICE TO MEET YOU WENT TO THE
06:46:41.243 --> 06:46:42.377
HEALTH COMMITTEE. AND THE CHAIR
06:46:42.444 --> 06:46:43.645
I WORKED VERY CLOSELY WITH THE
06:46:43.712 --> 06:46:46.115
AUTHOR TO ADDRESS. THE
06:46:46.181 --> 06:46:47.516
OUTSTANDING FOOD SAFETY
06:46:47.583 --> 06:46:50.152
CONCERNS. I BELIEVE THAT AT
06:46:50.219 --> 06:46:51.453
LEAST WITH REGARDS TO THAT
06:46:51.520 --> 06:46:52.721
ISSUE. PEOPLE ARE FEELING
06:46:52.788 --> 06:46:57.059
COMFORTABLE. WITH WITH OUR
06:46:57.126 --> 06:46:58.961
FRIENDS BILL. CENTER BY CAL SKI
06:46:59.027 --> 06:47:00.262
GOOD OKAY MOVING ON TO CENTER
06:47:00.329 --> 06:47:05.534
RUBIO. NOPE YOU'RE GOOD FIVE
06:47:05.601 --> 06:47:08.470
MEMBERS CENTER NIELSEN. NOT A
06:47:08.537 --> 06:47:10.806
PRIVILEGE ON THE SENATE THE
06:47:10.873 --> 06:47:13.776
RECENT. QUESTION OF WHERE THIS
06:47:13.842 --> 06:47:16.211
PROBLEM THEY PROVOKE ME TO
06:47:16.278 --> 06:47:19.715
DECIDE TO PUT MY CUP. IT'S KIND
06:47:19.782 --> 06:47:21.450
OF INTERESTING SAY WHAT PEOPLE
06:47:21.517 --> 06:47:23.585
WILL ABOUT RURAL COUNTIES IN
06:47:23.652 --> 06:47:27.523
RURAL AREAS. THEY ARE FAR MORE
06:47:27.589 --> 06:47:28.657
TOLERANT. OF THESE TYPE OF
06:47:28.724 --> 06:47:30.893
BUSINESSES THAN OTHER LARGER
06:47:30.959 --> 06:47:34.329
URBAN AREAS. WHY THEY'RE CLOSER
06:47:34.396 --> 06:47:37.466
TO THE INDIVIDUAL. THE KIDS GO
06:47:37.533 --> 06:47:39.468
TO SCHOOL WITH THEM THEY'VE BEEN
06:47:39.535 --> 06:47:41.670
RAISED WITHIN THEIR GENERATIONS
06:47:41.737 --> 06:47:43.672
. AND THESE ARE ENTERPRISING
06:47:43.739 --> 06:47:47.442
INDIVIDUALS. THE AMERICAN DREAM
06:47:47.509 --> 06:47:52.014
THERE LIVE IN IT. AND THOSE
06:47:52.080 --> 06:47:53.749
VEHICLES A DAY USE THEY'RE NOT
06:47:53.816 --> 06:47:58.353
CHEAP. YOU MAYBE GET A JOKER FOR
06:47:58.420 --> 06:47:59.421
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND. BUT
06:47:59.488 --> 06:48:01.957
EQUIPPING IT TO BE ABLE TO
06:48:02.024 --> 06:48:04.560
PREPARE FOODS YOU'RE TALKING A
06:48:04.626 --> 06:48:07.196
1-001-000-2200 THOUSAND OR MORE
06:48:07.262 --> 06:48:09.464
. I DON'T EVEN KNOW HOW THEY
06:48:09.531 --> 06:48:12.768
COME UP WITH. WE FREQUENT IN
06:48:12.835 --> 06:48:15.103
BECAUSE IT'S DARN GOOD FOOD.
06:48:15.170 --> 06:48:17.606
BETTER THAN UPSCALE RESTAURANTS
06:48:17.673 --> 06:48:21.910
IN BIG CITIES. MUCH BETTER. SO
06:48:21.977 --> 06:48:23.712
WE CANNOT DEMEAN THEY ARE
06:48:23.779 --> 06:48:26.715
EVERYWHERE. NOW I APPRECIATE THE
06:48:26.782 --> 06:48:28.517
AUTHOR HE HAS TRIED TO BE
06:48:28.584 --> 06:48:31.019
HELPFUL AND WORKING WITH THANKS
06:48:31.086 --> 06:48:32.287
I'M SURE HE WILL CONTINUE TO DO
06:48:32.354 --> 06:48:34.823
SO. BUT TO THE POINT OF WHERE
06:48:34.890 --> 06:48:37.459
THEY ARE. THEY'RE ALL OVER.
06:48:37.526 --> 06:48:39.428
THERE IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD. AND
06:48:39.494 --> 06:48:42.164
THE GOOD PEOPLE. SOME OF THE
06:48:42.231 --> 06:48:44.900
PRETTY LOUSY. WE WANT TO CLEAN
06:48:44.967 --> 06:48:47.336
UP THE MESSES MUCH CLEAN UP SOME
06:48:47.402 --> 06:48:48.704
OF THE HOMELESS. BUT THAT'S NOT
06:48:48.770 --> 06:48:51.673
MY POINT. THANK YOU SENATOR
06:48:51.740 --> 06:48:53.876
NIELSEN MEMBERS FURTHER
06:48:53.942 --> 06:48:56.645
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
06:48:56.712 --> 06:48:58.580
HEARING THEM SENATE ALLEN YOU
06:48:58.647 --> 06:49:01.116
MAY CLOSE MEMBERS I WANT I THINK
06:49:01.183 --> 06:49:02.150
I DO WANT TO SINCERELY THANK
06:49:02.217 --> 06:49:04.152
EVERYONE FOR THE FOR THE ROBUST
06:49:04.219 --> 06:49:05.520
DEBATE AND FOR THE PRAISE OF
06:49:05.587 --> 06:49:06.822
THESE OF THIS DELICIOUS FOOD
06:49:06.889 --> 06:49:08.323
THAT'S ON THE STREETS- THAT WE
06:49:08.390 --> 06:49:10.893
ALL ENJOY- HI THIS IS SOMETHING
06:49:10.959 --> 06:49:12.094
YOU DON'T HEAR A LOT WHEN PEOPLE
06:49:12.160 --> 06:49:14.129
MAKE BILL PRESENTATIONS AYE AYE
06:49:14.196 --> 06:49:15.964
AYE. AYE I DID NOT LOOK FOR TO
06:49:16.031 --> 06:49:18.000
BRING IN THIS BILL UP I KNOW MY
06:49:18.066 --> 06:49:19.868
FRIEND FROM LONG BEACH KNOWS
06:49:19.935 --> 06:49:21.336
THAT- I ACTUALLY HOPE THAT THIS
06:49:21.403 --> 06:49:23.605
BILL. DOES NOT GET SIGNED INTO
06:49:23.672 --> 06:49:28.610
LAW AND WHY DO I SAY THAT
06:49:28.677 --> 06:49:32.381
BECAUSE I HOPE THAT WE'RE GONNA
06:49:32.447 --> 06:49:35.484
BE ABLE TO STRIKE IT. WHERE
06:49:35.550 --> 06:49:37.286
THANK YOU FOR YOUR- LIVES FOR
06:49:37.352 --> 06:49:40.255
THEMSELVES ARE AND DO SO IN A
06:49:40.322 --> 06:49:41.890
WAY THAT SAY FOR OUR COMMUNITIES
06:49:41.957 --> 06:49:44.393
THAT'S MY PROFOUND HOPE WITH
06:49:44.459 --> 06:49:47.129
THIS BILL AND WITH THAT WITH SB
06:49:47.195 --> 06:49:49.564
NINE SEVENTY TWO TOMORROW- BUT I
06:49:49.631 --> 06:49:50.866
ASK YOU TO GIVE ME THE
06:49:50.933 --> 06:49:52.100
OPPORTUNITY TO YOU WORKING ON
06:49:52.167 --> 06:49:53.669
THIS AND I CERTAINLY TOMORROW
06:49:53.735 --> 06:49:55.737
WILL BE ASKING YOU TO GIVE ARE
06:49:55.804 --> 06:49:56.238
CALLING FROM LONG BEACH
06:49:56.305 --> 06:49:58.206
OPPORTUNITIES WELL. I DON'T WANT
06:49:58.273 --> 06:49:59.274
TO SISTER MYSELF ALL THE
06:49:59.341 --> 06:50:01.310
COMMENTED TO ME SO FAR INCLUDING
06:50:01.376 --> 06:50:02.878
THOSE FROM MY FRIENDS ARE FROM
06:50:02.945 --> 06:50:04.646
LOS ANGELES ARE. YOU KNOW WHO
06:50:04.713 --> 06:50:07.149
I'VE JUST HAD A LONG DISCUSSION-
06:50:07.215 --> 06:50:08.951
IT YOU KNOW EVEN TODAY WITH MY
06:50:09.017 --> 06:50:10.152
FRIEND FROM SANTA BARBARA. I
06:50:10.218 --> 06:50:11.153
VARIOUS POSSIBILITIES THAT WE
06:50:11.219 --> 06:50:12.387
COULD USE INSTEAD OF THE
06:50:12.454 --> 06:50:13.956
MECHANISM IT'S IN THIS BILL-
06:50:14.022 --> 06:50:15.791
THAT IS THAT ARE LESS PUNITIVE
06:50:15.857 --> 06:50:17.826
RIGHT PROMOTE ASK FOR IT FOR
06:50:17.893 --> 06:50:19.561
EXAMPLE. SOME SORT OF MECHANISM
06:50:19.628 --> 06:50:21.430
THAT WOULD THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR
06:50:21.496 --> 06:50:24.833
A ROBUST EDUCATION SYSTEM. I YOU
06:50:24.900 --> 06:50:26.768
KNOW THE CHALLENGE YOUR
06:50:26.835 --> 06:50:28.003
CONTINUES TO BE WHAT DO YOU DO
06:50:28.070 --> 06:50:30.572
WITH A VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE OF
06:50:30.639 --> 06:50:31.573
THE POPULATION. THAT THAT THAT
06:50:31.640 --> 06:50:32.874
THAT JUST DOESN'T WANNA COMPLY
06:50:32.941 --> 06:50:34.309
THAT'S THE CHALLENGE THAT WE
06:50:34.376 --> 06:50:35.310
CONTINUE TO GRAPPLE WITH. I'M
06:50:35.377 --> 06:50:37.312
HOPEFUL WE'LL BE ABLE TO. TO GET
06:50:37.379 --> 06:50:38.847
IT ADDRESS THIS YEAR. AND I
06:50:38.914 --> 06:50:42.317
JUST- IN THAT SPIRIT I ASK FOR
06:50:42.384 --> 06:50:43.952
YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
06:50:44.019 --> 06:50:44.953
ALLEN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
06:50:45.020 --> 06:50:48.757
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN I ARCHULETA
06:50:48.824 --> 06:50:53.996
ATKINS. BATES AYE BECKER AYE
06:50:54.062 --> 06:50:59.201
FORTRESS. BRADFORD BRADFORD FOR
06:50:59.267 --> 06:51:02.537
JUST AYE BRADFORD. CABALLERO I
06:51:02.604 --> 06:51:07.743
PROTECTING. DALY AYE DODD. HI
06:51:07.809 --> 06:51:13.482
TORONTO. EGGMAN GLAZER AYE
06:51:13.548 --> 06:51:18.854
GONZALEZ NO GROW I HERTZBERG
06:51:18.920 --> 06:51:26.528
WESSEL. HER TO HER TADO I JONES
06:51:26.595 --> 06:51:32.801
NO KAMLAGER. LAYERED LEYVA NO
06:51:32.868 --> 06:51:42.878
THE MON. MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ. MAN
06:51:42.944 --> 06:51:47.616
I NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO- CHOI
06:51:47.682 --> 06:51:51.887
BOGUE I PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE
06:51:51.953 --> 06:51:57.259
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER.
06:51:57.325 --> 06:52:00.629
STERN HI I'M BURKE I WAKE
06:52:00.695 --> 06:52:07.903
HOUSEKI. WIENER AYE WILK HI
06:52:07.969 --> 06:52:09.071
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
06:52:09.137 --> 06:52:15.243
ARCHULETA. ARGILLITE PLEASE LET
06:52:15.310 --> 06:52:16.878
MADAM SECRETARY GO THROUGH THE
06:52:16.945 --> 06:52:18.447
ROLE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
06:52:18.513 --> 06:52:22.851
MEMBERS ARCHULETA. I ATKINS
06:52:22.918 --> 06:52:29.257
BRADFORD. CORTESE TORONTO.
06:52:29.324 --> 06:52:34.830
EGGMAN HERTZBERG WESSEL.
06:52:34.896 --> 06:52:41.536
KAMLAGER LAYERED LIMÓN MELENDEZ
06:52:41.603 --> 06:52:47.576
SKINNER. WHITE HOUSE SKI. I
06:52:47.642 --> 06:52:48.310
TWENTY THREE KNOWS FOR THE
06:52:48.376 --> 06:52:50.545
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS REMOVING
06:52:50.612 --> 06:52:52.747
THE FILE ITEM SIXTY SEVEN CENTER
06:52:52.814 --> 06:52:54.816
ARCH ALETTA MADAM SECRETARY
06:52:54.883 --> 06:52:58.086
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL FOURTEEN
06:52:58.153 --> 06:52:59.387
SEVENTY EIGHT BY SENATOR
06:52:59.454 --> 06:53:00.222
ARCHULETA AN ACT RELATING TO
06:53:00.288 --> 06:53:01.356
DISABLED VETERAN BUSINESS
06:53:01.423 --> 06:53:12.400
ENTERPRISES. CENTER ARCHULETA.
06:53:12.467 --> 06:53:15.103
SELECT AGAIN ONE. THANK YOU
06:53:15.170 --> 06:53:18.540
MADAM PRESIDENT. I RISE TO
06:53:18.607 --> 06:53:21.109
PRESENT SENATE BILL FOURTEEN
06:53:21.176 --> 06:53:22.978
SEVENTY EIGHT TO SIX TO INCREASE
06:53:23.044 --> 06:53:24.112
THE MAXIMUM CONTRACT AMOUNT FOR
06:53:24.179 --> 06:53:26.114
SERVICES AND INFORMATION
06:53:26.181 --> 06:53:28.316
TECHNOLOGY CONTRACT AWARDED TO
06:53:28.383 --> 06:53:29.684
THROUGH THE SMALL BUSINESS AND
06:53:29.751 --> 06:53:31.353
DISABLED VETERANS ENTERPRISE
06:53:31.419 --> 06:53:35.390
OPTION FROM 200-500-0025 HUNDRED
06:53:35.457 --> 06:53:38.627
THOUSAND. S. B. FORTY SEVEN
06:53:38.693 --> 06:53:39.628
EIGHT AS STATED INCREASES THE
06:53:39.694 --> 06:53:43.265
MAXIMUM CONTRACT AWARD FROM
06:53:43.331 --> 06:53:44.266
255-001-0002 ALLOW SMALL IN
06:53:44.332 --> 06:53:46.568
VETERAN OWNED BUSINESSES. TO BE
06:53:46.635 --> 06:53:48.503
COMPETITIVE WITH BIDDING FOR
06:53:48.570 --> 06:53:50.539
STATE CONTRACTS WHILE ALSO
06:53:50.605 --> 06:53:52.073
INCREASING THE AMOUNT THEY CAN
06:53:52.140 --> 06:53:53.708
BENEFIT FINANCIALLY FOR DOING
06:53:53.775 --> 06:53:55.510
BUSINESS WITH THE STATE OF
06:53:55.577 --> 06:53:56.912
CALIFORNIA WITH THAT I ASK FOR
06:53:56.978 --> 06:53:58.213
YOUR I. BOATS. THANK YOU CENTER
06:53:58.280 --> 06:54:00.215
ARCHULETA MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
06:54:00.282 --> 06:54:03.285
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
06:54:03.351 --> 06:54:04.252
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
06:54:04.319 --> 06:54:08.924
ROLL. ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
06:54:08.990 --> 06:54:14.129
ATKINS BATES AYE BAKER. I FOR
06:54:14.196 --> 06:54:17.566
JUST AYE BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO
06:54:17.632 --> 06:54:22.837
AYE PROTESTING AYE DALY. DODD
06:54:22.904 --> 06:54:25.774
AYE TORONTO AYE EGGMAN AYE
06:54:25.840 --> 06:54:32.581
GLAZER HI GONZALEZ I GROW. I
06:54:32.647 --> 06:54:38.553
HERTZBERG WESSEL. I FURTADO. I
06:54:38.620 --> 06:54:44.726
JONES KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED AYE
06:54:44.793 --> 06:54:48.697
LEYVA AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE AYE
06:54:48.763 --> 06:54:52.767
MELENDEZ AYE MIN. I NEWMAN AYE
06:54:52.834 --> 06:54:56.638
NIELSEN I HAVE A SHOW OF BOTH.
06:54:56.705 --> 06:55:01.676
HI PAM. I PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE
06:55:01.743 --> 06:55:08.950
RUBIO I SKINNER. I STERN AYE I'M
06:55:09.017 --> 06:55:13.588
BURKE HI CASKEY. I WIENER AYE
06:55:13.655 --> 06:55:16.358
WILK HI PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
06:55:16.424 --> 06:55:21.763
MEMBERS. ATKINS VALLEY I
06:55:21.830 --> 06:55:25.767
HERTZBERG JONES. FIVE THIRTY
06:55:25.834 --> 06:55:27.335
SEVEN NO ZERO THE MEASURE PASSES
06:55:27.402 --> 06:55:29.304
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
06:55:29.371 --> 06:55:30.538
SIXTY EIGHT SENATOR GLAZERS
06:55:30.605 --> 06:55:32.374
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
06:55:32.440 --> 06:55:33.875
SENATE BILL FOURTEEN EIGHTY BY
06:55:33.942 --> 06:55:35.944
SENATOR GLAZER AN ACT RELATING
06:55:36.011 --> 06:55:38.079
TO VOTING CENTER GLAZER THANK
06:55:38.146 --> 06:55:39.214
YOU MADAM PRESIDENT LET ME SAY
06:55:39.281 --> 06:55:41.049
THAT PRESIDING OFFICER IN THE
06:55:41.116 --> 06:55:42.584
DEATH STAFF THANKS SO MUCH FOR
06:55:42.651 --> 06:55:45.353
WORKING SO HARD FOR US TODAY WE
06:55:45.420 --> 06:55:48.189
SO APPRECIATED. MEMBERS SB
06:55:48.256 --> 06:55:49.257
FOURTEEN EIGHTY WOULD PERMIT THE
06:55:49.324 --> 06:55:50.859
SECRETARY OF STATE. PERMIT THE
06:55:50.925 --> 06:55:52.627
SECRETARY OF STATE TO CERTIFY
06:55:52.694 --> 06:55:54.229
REMOTE ACCESSIBLE VOTE BY MAIL
06:55:54.296 --> 06:55:56.431
SYSTEM THAT PROVIDES AN OPTION
06:55:56.498 --> 06:55:57.732
FOR VOTERS WITH A QUALIFYING
06:55:57.799 --> 06:56:00.335
DISABILITY. ELECTRONICALLY
06:56:00.402 --> 06:56:02.470
RETURN THEIR BALLOTS UNDER
06:56:02.537 --> 06:56:04.973
CURRENT LAW VOTERS ABLE TO USE
06:56:05.040 --> 06:56:06.374
THIS REMOTE ACCESSIBLE VOTE BY
06:56:06.441 --> 06:56:10.845
MAIL SYSTEM- HOWEVER THEY HAVE
06:56:10.912 --> 06:56:13.048
TO RETURN A PRINTED BALLOT A
06:56:13.114 --> 06:56:15.183
PRINTED COPY OF THEIR BALLOTS.
06:56:15.250 --> 06:56:16.484
NOW WHILE REMOTE ACCESSIBLE
06:56:16.551 --> 06:56:18.253
VOTING HAS IMPROVED- TO GET HOME
06:56:18.320 --> 06:56:19.054
FOR MANY VOTERS WITH
06:56:19.120 --> 06:56:21.022
DISABILITIES IT IS STILL
06:56:21.089 --> 06:56:22.090
DIFFICULT FOR SOME VOTERS WITH
06:56:22.157 --> 06:56:25.060
VISUAL OR EXTERITY AND PALANCE.
06:56:25.126 --> 06:56:27.329
THE PUBLIC PRIVATELY AND
06:56:27.395 --> 06:56:28.330
INDEPENDENTLY USING THE CURRENT
06:56:28.396 --> 06:56:30.265
SYSTEM. FOR EXAMPLE A PERSON WHO
06:56:30.332 --> 06:56:32.534
IS BLIND WE NEED HELP COMPLETING
06:56:32.600 --> 06:56:34.669
THEIR BALLOT WHICH VIOLATES THE
06:56:34.736 --> 06:56:37.305
RIGHT. TO A SECRET BALLOT. ALL
06:56:37.372 --> 06:56:38.373
THIS BILL IS TO SPUR THE
06:56:38.440 --> 06:56:40.041
DEVELOPMENT OF TECHNOLOGY THAT
06:56:40.108 --> 06:56:42.010
WOULD ALLOW EVERYONE TO CAST A
06:56:42.077 --> 06:56:44.145
SECRET BALLOT. NOT JUST THOSE
06:56:44.212 --> 06:56:46.147
WHO ARE WHO DO SO USING CURRENT
06:56:46.214 --> 06:56:48.917
TECHNOLOGY. THIS BILL DOES NOT
06:56:48.983 --> 06:56:50.985
MANDATE A NEW SYSTEM DOES NOT
06:56:51.052 --> 06:56:52.520
MANDATE A NEW SYSTEM IS SIMPLY
06:56:52.587 --> 06:56:55.623
PERMITS. THE SECRETARY OF STATE
06:56:55.690 --> 06:56:57.359
TO CERTIFY A SYSTEM FOR LIMITED
06:56:57.425 --> 06:56:59.561
USE IF THE SECRETARY DETERMINES
06:56:59.627 --> 06:57:01.563
THAT CAN BE DONE SAFELY. AND
06:57:01.629 --> 06:57:04.399
SECURELY. FOR YEARS THE SENATE
06:57:04.466 --> 06:57:06.334
THIS LEGISLATURE HAS EXPANDED
06:57:06.401 --> 06:57:08.069
ACCESS TO VOTING TO ENSURE THAT
06:57:08.136 --> 06:57:09.437
ALL ELIGIBLE VOTERS HAVE THE
06:57:09.504 --> 06:57:11.373
ABILITY TO CAST A BALLOT. THIS
06:57:11.439 --> 06:57:12.907
BILL WILL HELP THOSE WHO ARE
06:57:12.974 --> 06:57:15.110
CURRENTLY UNABLE TO CAST A VOTE
06:57:15.176 --> 06:57:17.579
AND INDEPENDENT AND PRIVATE WAY.
06:57:17.645 --> 06:57:18.480
THIS BILL SUPPORTED BY THE
06:57:18.546 --> 06:57:20.749
DISABILITY RIGHTS CALIFORNIA THE
06:57:20.815 --> 06:57:22.217
CALIFORNIA COUNCIL FOR THE
06:57:22.283 --> 06:57:23.952
BLIND. AND THE CALIFORNIA
06:57:24.018 --> 06:57:25.754
CHAPTER OF THE NATIONAL
06:57:25.820 --> 06:57:27.555
ASSOCIATION OF SOCIAL WORKERS.
06:57:27.622 --> 06:57:29.190
THIS BILL IS ABOUT IMPROVING
06:57:29.257 --> 06:57:30.425
ACCESS FOR VOTERS WHO FACED A
06:57:30.492 --> 06:57:32.927
BARRIER WHEN SEEKING TO VOTE.
06:57:32.994 --> 06:57:36.564
WITHOUT A RESPECTFULLY ASK RIVAL
06:57:36.631 --> 06:57:37.899
. THANK YOU SENATOR GLAZER
06:57:37.966 --> 06:57:39.701
MEMBERS FURTHER DELAY ANY
06:57:39.768 --> 06:57:42.170
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
06:57:42.237 --> 06:57:43.738
HEARING THEN MADAM SECRETARY
06:57:43.805 --> 06:57:48.376
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN HI
06:57:48.443 --> 06:57:52.614
ARCHULETA I ATKINS BATES NO
06:57:52.680 --> 06:57:58.386
BAKER. I PORCHES NO BRADFORD HI
06:57:58.453 --> 06:58:02.524
CABALLERO I CORTES HE AYE DALY
06:58:02.590 --> 06:58:07.662
NO DODD. FIVE TORONTO I EGGMAN
06:58:07.729 --> 06:58:13.401
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
06:58:13.468 --> 06:58:18.239
NO HERTZBERG WESTERN I HER TADO
06:58:18.306 --> 06:58:23.111
. I JONES NO KAMLAGER. LAYARD I
06:58:23.178 --> 06:58:29.350
LABOR I LIMON I MCGUIRE. I
06:58:29.417 --> 06:58:36.224
MELENDEZ. NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
06:58:36.291 --> 06:58:41.329
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED. PAN AYE
06:58:41.396 --> 06:58:46.301
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
06:58:46.367 --> 06:58:52.507
SKINNER I STERN. NUMBER I BY
06:58:52.574 --> 06:58:57.712
CASTING AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO
06:58:57.779 --> 06:58:59.547
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
06:58:59.614 --> 06:59:05.119
ATKINS HERTZBERG KAMLAGER. A
06:59:05.186 --> 06:59:09.524
CHOI BOGUE I. STERN PLEASE CALL
06:59:09.591 --> 06:59:10.792
THE ABSENT MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME
06:59:10.859 --> 06:59:13.428
OR SENATE- TURBO DID YOU WANT
06:59:13.495 --> 06:59:16.965
CHANGE OR VOTE. I TRY BURKE I TO
06:59:17.031 --> 06:59:20.735
KNOW. VERY GOOD IS TWENTY SEVEN
06:59:20.802 --> 06:59:22.570
KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
06:59:22.637 --> 06:59:24.239
MEMBERS WE ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
06:59:24.305 --> 06:59:26.174
ITEM SIXTY NINE SENATOR MCGUIRE
06:59:26.241 --> 06:59:28.076
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ.
06:59:28.142 --> 06:59:29.777
SENATE BILL NINE SEVENTY EIGHT
06:59:29.844 --> 06:59:32.747
BY SENATOR MCGUIRE AN ACT-RELATING TO DISASTER CLEANUP
06:59:32.814 --> 06:59:34.516
SENATE MCGUIRE GOOD EVENING
06:59:34.582 --> 06:59:36.017
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS SB NINE
06:59:36.084 --> 06:59:37.352
SYDNEY'S RECEIVED BIPARTISAN
06:59:37.418 --> 06:59:39.254
SUPPORT IT REQUIRES GUY AT CAL
06:59:39.320 --> 06:59:40.922
RECYCLE TO ESTABLISH A PRE
06:59:40.989 --> 06:59:42.390
QUALIFIED LIST OF CONTRACTORS
06:59:42.457 --> 06:59:44.125
WHO CAN BE DEPLOYED ANYTIME WITH
06:59:44.192 --> 06:59:45.527
OUR STAFF TEAM TO BEGIN
06:59:45.593 --> 06:59:46.628
COMMUNITY CLEAN UPS AFTER
06:59:46.694 --> 06:59:49.130
WILDFIRES EARTHQUAKES TSUNAMIS.
06:59:49.197 --> 06:59:50.965
THIS IS NEARLY IDENTICAL TO THE
06:59:51.032 --> 06:59:52.734
FEDERAL FEMA PROCESS WHICH ALSO
06:59:52.800 --> 06:59:54.302
HAS PRE QUALIFIED CONTRACT LIST
06:59:54.369 --> 06:59:55.970
A WILDFIRE DEBRIS CLEAN IS THE
06:59:56.037 --> 06:59:57.171
MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THE
06:59:57.238 --> 06:59:58.139
RECOVERY PROCESS AND I
06:59:58.206 --> 06:59:59.874
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN IPHONE
06:59:59.941 --> 07:00:01.175
THANK YOU SENATE MCGUIRE MEMBERS
07:00:01.242 --> 07:00:03.611
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
07:00:03.678 --> 07:00:04.779
HEARING NONE MEMBERS IS
07:00:04.846 --> 07:00:08.383
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
07:00:08.449 --> 07:00:09.217
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION.
07:00:09.284 --> 07:00:10.585
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS
07:00:10.652 --> 07:00:12.887
THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE MEASURE
07:00:12.954 --> 07:00:15.590
PASSES. MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM
07:00:15.657 --> 07:00:18.526
SEVENTY SENATOR ALAN. MADAM
07:00:18.593 --> 07:00:20.495
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
07:00:20.562 --> 07:00:22.297
BILL TWELVE OH FIVE BY SENATOR
07:00:22.363 --> 07:00:24.165
ALAN AN ACT RELATING TO WATER
07:00:24.232 --> 07:00:31.739
CENTER ALAN. MEMBERS THIS A
07:00:31.806 --> 07:00:34.442
REQUIRES OUR WATER BOARD TO
07:00:34.509 --> 07:00:36.611
PROMULGATE REGULATIONS THAT-
07:00:36.678 --> 07:00:38.613
PROVIDE SOME GREATER SPECIFICITY
07:00:38.680 --> 07:00:40.615
AS TO THE METHODS FOR
07:00:40.682 --> 07:00:43.117
DETERMINING WATER AVAILABILITY.
07:00:43.184 --> 07:00:45.687
AND- IT'S ENJOYED STRONG SUPPORT
07:00:45.753 --> 07:00:47.288
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN COMMITTEE
07:00:47.355 --> 07:00:48.890
AND I RESPECT RESTAURANT ABOUT
07:00:48.957 --> 07:00:50.124
THANK YOU CENTER ALLEN MEMBERS
07:00:50.191 --> 07:00:51.659
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR
07:00:51.726 --> 07:00:55.730
NIELSEN. BETTER PRESENT LAYS
07:00:55.797 --> 07:00:56.998
DOWN THE SENATE THIS IS
07:00:57.065 --> 07:00:58.900
SOMETHING I MIGHT BE ASSUMED TO
07:00:58.967 --> 07:01:02.136
BE A SYMPATHETIC WITH BUT- BIG
07:01:02.203 --> 07:01:08.409
BUT- THIS MIGHT. OPERATIVE WORD
07:01:08.476 --> 07:01:11.212
IS MIGHT. AND DETERMINE THE
07:01:11.279 --> 07:01:13.548
AVAILABILITY OF WATER I AM
07:01:13.615 --> 07:01:16.718
RELUCTANT TO CEDE TO THE WATER
07:01:16.784 --> 07:01:19.420
BOARDS OF CALIFORNIA. VERY MUCH
07:01:19.487 --> 07:01:21.456
ABOUT THAT OR THE D. W. R. FOR
07:01:21.522 --> 07:01:24.392
THE GZIP WHEN SOMETIMES- WELL
07:01:24.459 --> 07:01:26.761
THE RESOURCES AGENCY AS WELL.
07:01:26.828 --> 07:01:28.763
BECAUSE THERE DETERMINATION MAY
07:01:28.830 --> 07:01:31.366
NOT TAKE COGNISANCE AT ALL OF
07:01:31.432 --> 07:01:33.201
WHAT THE STATUE TO WATER POLICY
07:01:33.267 --> 07:01:35.336
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA HAVE
07:01:35.403 --> 07:01:39.974
SENT. WHAT POLICY HAS BEEN. OR
07:01:40.041 --> 07:01:41.776
HOW THIS STATE HAS PROSPERED
07:01:41.843 --> 07:01:44.345
OVER ITS HISTORY. WITH THE
07:01:44.412 --> 07:01:45.380
DEVELOPMENT THE PRUDENT
07:01:45.446 --> 07:01:47.915
DEVELOPMENT OF OUR WATER
07:01:47.982 --> 07:01:50.752
RESOURCES AND THE INFRASTRUCTURE
07:01:50.818 --> 07:01:56.057
INVESTMENTS THAT WE HAVE MADE.
07:01:56.124 --> 07:01:58.493
RESECTED TWISTED AROUND GIVE ME
07:01:58.559 --> 07:02:02.196
TOO MUCH CONCERN TO BE SUPPORTED
07:02:02.263 --> 07:02:03.031
. THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN
07:02:03.097 --> 07:02:04.666
MEMBERS FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
07:02:04.732 --> 07:02:07.368
DEBATE SEEING HEARING NONE
07:02:07.435 --> 07:02:09.837
SENATE ALLEN YOU MAY CLOSE.
07:02:09.904 --> 07:02:11.172
APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS I MADE
07:02:11.239 --> 07:02:13.041
MY FRIEND FROM TO HIM- YOU KNOW
07:02:13.107 --> 07:02:15.743
WE HAVE AN ENORMOUS PROBLEM ON
07:02:15.810 --> 07:02:16.344
OUR HANDS OF THE GUARDS TO
07:02:16.411 --> 07:02:18.379
WATER. HI THERE ARE YOU KNOW
07:02:18.446 --> 07:02:19.981
WHAT ONE OF THE IF YOU TAKE A
07:02:20.048 --> 07:02:21.983
LOOK AT THE ANALYSIS TO TALK
07:02:22.050 --> 07:02:23.184
ABOUT HOW PASS IS NOT A RELIABLE
07:02:23.251 --> 07:02:24.152
INDICATOR THE FUTURE. WITH
07:02:24.218 --> 07:02:26.654
REGARDS TO WATER AVAILABILITY-
07:02:26.721 --> 07:02:27.522
ADVOCATE BECAUSE OF CLIMATE
07:02:27.588 --> 07:02:30.892
CHANGE. I AND YET A LOT OF ARE A
07:02:30.958 --> 07:02:32.060
CONTINUAL PREDICTIONS THAT ARE
07:02:32.126 --> 07:02:35.396
USED BY THE WATER BORDER BASED
07:02:35.463 --> 07:02:35.963
ON ON ON HISTORY. THINGS ARE
07:02:36.030 --> 07:02:37.465
CHANGING SO RAPIDLY WITH REGARDS
07:02:37.532 --> 07:02:39.200
TO HYDROLOGY BECAUSE OF CLIMATE
07:02:39.267 --> 07:02:40.468
CHANGE. THAT WE NEED A BILL LIKE
07:02:40.535 --> 07:02:42.570
THIS. AND SO I RESPECT FAST FROM
07:02:42.637 --> 07:02:45.139
ABOVE. THANK YOU CENTER ELEMENT
07:02:45.206 --> 07:02:47.742
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
07:02:47.809 --> 07:02:50.478
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA. AYE ATKINS.
07:02:50.545 --> 07:02:57.452
BATES I BAKER. I FOR JUST.
07:02:57.518 --> 07:03:01.923
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO I FOR
07:03:01.989 --> 07:03:10.298
TESTING I DALY. DODD I TORONTO.
07:03:10.364 --> 07:03:14.869
THANK TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
07:03:14.936 --> 07:03:19.640
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
07:03:19.707 --> 07:03:25.079
HERTZBERG WESSEL. HI FURTADO.
07:03:25.146 --> 07:03:30.952
JONES I KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
07:03:31.018 --> 07:03:35.123
LEYVA I LIMON I MCGUIRE. I
07:03:35.189 --> 07:03:43.064
MELENDEZ. MAN I NEWMAN I NIELSEN
07:03:43.131 --> 07:03:46.934
. A SHOW OF BOTH. I PAN I
07:03:47.001 --> 07:03:52.073
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
07:03:52.140 --> 07:03:57.912
SKINNER. I STERN AYE NUMBER I
07:03:57.979 --> 07:04:00.748
WHITE HOUSE SKI AYE WIENER AYE
07:04:00.815 --> 07:04:03.785
WILK AYE PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
07:04:03.851 --> 07:04:08.689
MEMBERS ATKINS. FOR JUST. DALLY
07:04:08.756 --> 07:04:14.862
GROVE I HERTZBERG FURTADO.
07:04:14.929 --> 07:04:20.067
MELENDEZ NIELSEN WHEN I WAS
07:04:20.134 --> 07:04:21.202
THIRTY THREE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
07:04:21.269 --> 07:04:23.004
PASSES MEMBERS REMAINING ON THE
07:04:23.070 --> 07:04:25.006
FILE ITEM SEVENTY ONE SENATOR
07:04:25.072 --> 07:04:26.340
EGGMAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
07:04:26.407 --> 07:04:28.643
READ SENATE BILL TWELVE TWENTY
07:04:28.709 --> 07:04:30.011
SEVEN BY SENATOR EGGMAN AN ACT
07:04:30.077 --> 07:04:32.380
RELATING TO TELL HEALTH. CENTER
07:04:32.446 --> 07:04:34.882
EGGMAN. TWELVE TWENTY SEVEN HAS
07:04:34.949 --> 07:04:36.284
TO DO WITH THE CLARIFICATION ON
07:04:36.350 --> 07:04:38.085
INTENSIVE TREATMENT IT RECEIVES
07:04:38.152 --> 07:04:40.454
REPORT US EVER SUPPORT ON BOTH
07:04:40.521 --> 07:04:42.356
SIDES I ASK FOR YOUR VOTE. WELL
07:04:42.423 --> 07:04:43.891
THEN SENATOR EGGMAN WELL DONE
07:04:43.958 --> 07:04:46.594
YOU SHOULD SERVE AS AN EXAMPLE
07:04:46.661 --> 07:04:48.863
TO ALL- MEMBERS THEN SEEING NO
07:04:48.930 --> 07:04:50.531
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE THIS ALSO
07:04:50.598 --> 07:04:52.934
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
07:04:53.000 --> 07:04:57.104
pSEEING AND HEARING NONE I WAS
07:04:57.171 --> 07:04:58.639
THIRTY EIGHT ZERO THE MEASURE
07:04:58.706 --> 07:05:00.675
PASSES FILE ITEM SEVENTY THREE
07:05:00.741 --> 07:05:02.510
SENATOR ARCH ALETTA MADAM
07:05:02.577 --> 07:05:05.379
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
07:05:05.446 --> 07:05:07.782
BILL THIRTEEN TWENTY THREE BY
07:05:07.849 --> 07:05:08.416
SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
07:05:08.482 --> 07:05:10.218
RELATING TO MORTGAGES SENATOR
07:05:10.284 --> 07:05:11.886
ARCHULETA THANK YOU MADAM
07:05:11.953 --> 07:05:13.187
PRESIDENT TODAY AND PRESENTED
07:05:13.254 --> 07:05:15.256
SENATE BILL THIRTEEN TWENTY
07:05:15.323 --> 07:05:16.891
THREE TO REQUIRED LENDERS IN A
07:05:16.958 --> 07:05:18.426
FORECLOSURE PROCEEDING TO HIRE A
07:05:18.492 --> 07:05:20.194
REALTOR. AND SELL THE SECURE
07:05:20.261 --> 07:05:22.730
PROPERTY OR ITS APPRAISED VALUE
07:05:22.797 --> 07:05:24.465
ON A MULTIPLE LISTING SERVICE
07:05:24.532 --> 07:05:27.068
THIS IN TURN WOULD PROTECT THAT
07:05:27.134 --> 07:05:28.302
HOMEOWNER WHO LOST THEIR
07:05:28.369 --> 07:05:30.271
PROPERTY THIS WOULD ALLOW
07:05:30.338 --> 07:05:32.039
DEFAULTED HOMEOWNERS TO BE PAID
07:05:32.106 --> 07:05:33.507
OUT THEIR FULL SAVINGS IN THEIR
07:05:33.574 --> 07:05:35.543
EQUITY CAN YOU IMAGINE. THE
07:05:35.610 --> 07:05:37.645
OTHER DAY WE HAD A WITNESS HERE
07:05:37.712 --> 07:05:39.847
WHO HAD A SEVEN HUNDRED THOUSAND
07:05:39.914 --> 07:05:42.083
DOLLAR HOUSE THE BANK GOT THEIR
07:05:42.149 --> 07:05:43.451
TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS
07:05:43.517 --> 07:05:44.352
APPROXIMATELY AND SOMEBODY ELSE
07:05:44.418 --> 07:05:45.853
WALKED AWAY WITH THAT EQUITY
07:05:45.920 --> 07:05:48.155
LOSS TIME AND TIME AGAIN- AND
07:05:48.222 --> 07:05:50.258
AGAIN SO THESE FORECLOSURES. IT
07:05:50.324 --> 07:05:52.426
GOT TO BE RE LOOKED AT
07:05:52.493 --> 07:05:54.028
FORECLOSURE HOMEOWNERS ARE
07:05:54.095 --> 07:05:55.730
NORMALLY DID LOW INCOME AND
07:05:55.796 --> 07:05:57.832
OFTEN ELDERLY IMMIGRANT OR
07:05:57.899 --> 07:05:59.333
DISABLED MEMBERS OF CALIFORNIA
07:05:59.400 --> 07:06:01.369
MOST VULNERABLE COMMUNITIES. FOR
07:06:01.435 --> 07:06:03.004
MEMBERS OF THESE COMMUNITIES
07:06:03.070 --> 07:06:05.473
THEIR HOME IS OUR ONLY ASSET AND
07:06:05.539 --> 07:06:07.341
THE HOME EQUITY IT ONLY LIFETIME
07:06:07.408 --> 07:06:09.610
SAVING THE LOSS OF EVEN A SINGLE
07:06:09.677 --> 07:06:11.178
DOLLAR OF THIS EQUITY IS
07:06:11.245 --> 07:06:12.747
IRREPLACEABLE PUTTING THE FOR
07:06:12.813 --> 07:06:15.349
CLOSE HOMER. IN INCREASED RISK
07:06:15.416 --> 07:06:17.351
OF POVERTY AND HOMELESSNESS-
07:06:17.418 --> 07:06:19.754
SPECIFIC THIS BILL WOULD RECAST
07:06:19.820 --> 07:06:21.122
FOR CLOSURE PROVISIONS TO
07:06:21.188 --> 07:06:22.757
REQUIRE THAT AN EQUITY SALE OF
07:06:22.823 --> 07:06:24.926
PROPERTY UNDER THE POWER OF SALE
07:06:24.992 --> 07:06:26.894
BUT MORTGAGE OR DEED OF TRUST.
07:06:26.961 --> 07:06:29.196
AND BE OBTAINED BY A LICENSED
07:06:29.263 --> 07:06:31.666
REALTOR TO PUBLICLY PROMOTE THE
07:06:31.732 --> 07:06:33.467
PROPERTY TO GET THE LARGEST
07:06:33.534 --> 07:06:35.836
AMOUNT TO BE GIVEN TO THAT OF
07:06:35.903 --> 07:06:38.172
FORECLOSED HOMEOWNER THIS BILL
07:06:38.239 --> 07:06:39.473
WOULD AUTHORIZE A TRUSTEE TO
07:06:39.540 --> 07:06:41.842
SELL IT WORKING TOGETHER AND I
07:06:41.909 --> 07:06:43.577
HAVE MET WITH SEVERAL OF MY
07:06:43.644 --> 07:06:45.780
COLLEAGUES. AND WE'VE COME UP
07:06:45.846 --> 07:06:46.914
WITH SOME OF THE AMENDMENTS THAT
07:06:46.981 --> 07:06:48.316
HAVE BEEN BROUGHT FORWARD I WILL
07:06:48.382 --> 07:06:51.285
TAKE THEM TO THE NEXT LEVEL. ONE
07:06:51.352 --> 07:06:52.486
OBVIOUSLY IS TO HAVE A THIRD
07:06:52.553 --> 07:06:54.689
PARTY LOOK AT THIS AND TO MAKE
07:06:54.755 --> 07:06:56.791
SURE THAT THE HOMEOWNER HAS
07:06:56.857 --> 07:06:59.093
RECEIVED AMPLIFIED NUMBER OF
07:06:59.160 --> 07:07:05.333
DISCLOSURES- NOTICES AND SO AND
07:07:05.399 --> 07:07:06.067
EVEN TO THE ABILITY TO POSTPONE
07:07:06.133 --> 07:07:07.535
THE PER UPDATE THE- FORECLOSURE.
07:07:07.601 --> 07:07:09.203
AND MAYBE UP TO BETWEEN TWENTY
07:07:09.270 --> 07:07:11.505
TO UP TO NINETY DAYS TO SAVE
07:07:11.572 --> 07:07:13.240
THAT HOMEOWNER. THE
07:07:13.307 --> 07:07:15.209
EMBARRASSMENT AND OBVIOUSLY MORE
07:07:15.276 --> 07:07:17.511
THAN THAT THE LOSS OF ALL THEIR
07:07:17.578 --> 07:07:19.580
EQUITY SO WITH THESE REASONS I
07:07:19.647 --> 07:07:21.582
ASK FOR YOUR I. BOATS. THANK YOU
07:07:21.649 --> 07:07:24.118
CENTER ARCHULETA OUR DISCUSSION
07:07:24.185 --> 07:07:25.019
AND DEBATE WE WILL START WITH
07:07:25.086 --> 07:07:27.121
CENTER AMBERG- THANK YOU MADAM
07:07:27.188 --> 07:07:28.889
PRESIDENT. OF THE JUST A
07:07:28.956 --> 07:07:31.993
QUESTION FOR THE AUTHOR- SO ONE
07:07:32.059 --> 07:07:33.361
MOMENT WE TAKE A QUESTION CENTER
07:07:33.427 --> 07:07:35.229
CHIRLA YES MA'AM PLEASE PROCEED
07:07:35.296 --> 07:07:37.431
SERRA BURKE. IS AS I UNDERSTAND
07:07:37.498 --> 07:07:39.066
THE INTENT OF THE BILL THE
07:07:39.133 --> 07:07:40.267
INTENT OF THE BILL IS FOR
07:07:40.334 --> 07:07:42.103
EXAMPLE LET ME GIVE YOU AN
07:07:42.169 --> 07:07:43.270
EXAMPLE WHEN IT WHEN A SENIOR
07:07:43.337 --> 07:07:46.407
HAS- SAY- FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND
07:07:46.474 --> 07:07:48.075
DOLLARS OF EQUITY IN THE HOME IN
07:07:48.142 --> 07:07:49.543
THE MORTGAGE IS TWO HUNDRED
07:07:49.610 --> 07:07:51.145
THOUSAND DOLLARS AND THEY ARE.
07:07:51.212 --> 07:07:52.613
LAID ON THE MORTGAGE THEN THE
07:07:52.680 --> 07:07:54.849
BANK WHICH IS TO FOR CLOSE THE
07:07:54.915 --> 07:07:56.017
BANK ONLY IS INTEREST IN GETTING
07:07:56.083 --> 07:07:57.918
THEIR TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND
07:07:57.985 --> 07:07:59.453
DOLLARS AND DOES THE FIVE
07:07:59.520 --> 07:08:00.254
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS. IS
07:08:00.321 --> 07:08:01.722
LOST IT'S NOT RETAINED BY THE
07:08:01.789 --> 07:08:03.190
BANK RIGHT IT IS NOT RETAINED BY
07:08:03.257 --> 07:08:05.159
THE BANK THIS WILL ENSURE THAT
07:08:05.226 --> 07:08:07.161
IT GOES TO THAT HOMEOWNER. AND
07:08:07.228 --> 07:08:08.629
THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO SAVE
07:08:08.696 --> 07:08:10.598
THE EQUITY THE BANK WILL ALWAYS
07:08:10.664 --> 07:08:12.333
RECEIVE THE MONEY THAT'S DUE BUT
07:08:12.400 --> 07:08:14.135
THE HOMEOWNER AND PAST HISTORY
07:08:14.201 --> 07:08:18.906
IS LOST. ALL OF THEIR EQUITY
07:08:18.973 --> 07:08:20.107
THIS WILL PREVENT THAT. ALL
07:08:20.174 --> 07:08:21.642
RIGHT WELL THE QUESTION SECOND
07:08:21.709 --> 07:08:23.344
QUESTION THEN TO YOU- IS THAT-
07:08:23.411 --> 07:08:24.812
THE BILL CAME THROUGH JUDICIARY
07:08:24.879 --> 07:08:26.213
COMMITTEE THERE ARE A NUMBER
07:08:26.280 --> 07:08:27.448
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS- I
07:08:27.515 --> 07:08:28.616
UNDERSTAND YOU'RE CONTINUE TO
07:08:28.682 --> 07:08:30.217
WORK ON THE BLL ONCE SUGGESTED
07:08:30.284 --> 07:08:31.852
AMENDMENT IS FOR EXAMPLE TO HAVE
07:08:31.919 --> 07:08:36.424
THE- THE HOMEOWNER. FOR EXAMPLE.
07:08:36.490 --> 07:08:38.192
ADVICE THAT THEY'RE GOING TO
07:08:38.259 --> 07:08:39.627
LISTED ON MULTIPLE LISTINGS THUS
07:08:39.693 --> 07:08:41.195
PROVIDING AN ADDITIONAL THIRTY
07:08:41.262 --> 07:08:42.963
DAYS. TO SELL IT BEFORE IT
07:08:43.030 --> 07:08:44.498
ACTUALLY GOES TO FORECLOSURE.
07:08:44.565 --> 07:08:46.934
AND IF YOU CONSIDER THAT A MA'AM
07:08:47.001 --> 07:08:48.302
AND I WILL CONSIDER THAT I'D
07:08:48.369 --> 07:08:50.871
LIKE TO SEE THAT. ANYWHERE UP TO
07:08:50.938 --> 07:08:52.339
SIXTY TO NINETY DAYS BUT WHAT
07:08:52.406 --> 07:08:53.974
WORK ON THAT I'LL CHECK RIGHT.
07:08:54.041 --> 07:08:55.242
THAT INCAN INTO CONSIDERATION IT
07:08:55.309 --> 07:08:57.044
WILL CENTER I LOOK FORWARD TO
07:08:57.111 --> 07:08:58.446
WORKING WITH YOU TO- IT IN THIS
07:08:58.512 --> 07:08:59.380
CIRCUMSTANCE THERE'S NOT
07:08:59.447 --> 07:09:02.149
NECESSARILY A- BAD ACTOR. BUT
07:09:02.216 --> 07:09:04.952
THERE IS A- BIG FOR WHATEVER
07:09:05.019 --> 07:09:06.720
REASON THERE IS A POTENTIAL LOSS
07:09:06.787 --> 07:09:07.955
OF EQUITY THAT IS A GREAT
07:09:08.022 --> 07:09:09.423
CONCERN BUT NOT SOLELY A BAD
07:09:09.490 --> 07:09:10.858
ACTORS SO LOOK FORWARD TO
07:09:10.925 --> 07:09:11.992
WORKING WITH YOU ON THIS BILL.
07:09:12.059 --> 07:09:14.095
IN AND I MIGHT POINT OUT THE
07:09:14.161 --> 07:09:16.530
BANKS ARE BACK BAD ACTORS IT'S A
07:09:16.597 --> 07:09:17.264
PROCESS AND PROCEDURE THAT IS
07:09:17.331 --> 07:09:19.100
THE BAD ACTOR AND WE NEED TO
07:09:19.166 --> 07:09:20.000
CLARIFY. CLEAN THIS UP AND I
07:09:20.067 --> 07:09:22.002
THINK THIS BILL WILL DO IT. AND
07:09:22.069 --> 07:09:23.170
I THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION.
07:09:23.237 --> 07:09:25.673
THANK YOU SENATOR UMBERG AND
07:09:25.739 --> 07:09:27.374
SENATOR ARCHULETA SENATOR WHITE
07:09:27.441 --> 07:09:29.577
HOUSE SKI. MAN PRESIDENT I
07:09:29.643 --> 07:09:31.345
STAYED OFF THIS BILL AND
07:09:31.412 --> 07:09:33.681
JUDICIARY BECAUSE RUNNING NO. I
07:09:33.747 --> 07:09:35.316
WAS A BANKRUPTCY ATTORNEY SO
07:09:35.382 --> 07:09:37.985
THESE ARE MY PEOPLE- THAT HAVE
07:09:38.052 --> 07:09:39.987
DEFAULTED ON THEIR LOAN. THE
07:09:40.054 --> 07:09:42.289
SALE IS TOMORROW AND THEY KNOCK
07:09:42.356 --> 07:09:44.592
ON MY DOOR AND SAY. HIT THE
07:09:44.658 --> 07:09:49.296
BRAKES SO. THE GOAL. THE AUTHOR
07:09:49.363 --> 07:09:52.666
HAS IS. IS ADMIRABLE AND I THINK
07:09:52.733 --> 07:09:55.202
THIS MAY BE A GOOD TIME. TO
07:09:55.269 --> 07:09:57.071
RETHINK OUR NON JUDICIAL
07:09:57.138 --> 07:09:59.406
FORECLOSURE PROCESS. THE NINETY
07:09:59.473 --> 07:10:00.808
DAY DEFAULT PERIOD I THINK
07:10:00.875 --> 07:10:02.409
EVERYBODY AGREES WITH THAT. BUT
07:10:02.476 --> 07:10:04.378
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THIS DEFAULT
07:10:04.445 --> 07:10:07.314
OCCURS. AND BOOK. I HAVE SOME
07:10:07.381 --> 07:10:08.716
CHALLENGES WITH THE MECHANICS
07:10:08.782 --> 07:10:11.185
HAVE AB AB. I'M GOING TO SUPPORT
07:10:11.252 --> 07:10:14.188
YOUR BILL TODAY. GIVEN THE- THE
07:10:14.255 --> 07:10:15.756
ACTIONS THAT YOU'VE TAKEN YOU'VE
07:10:15.823 --> 07:10:17.525
TAKEN BUT I HAVE PROBLEMS WITH
07:10:17.591 --> 07:10:19.160
THE MECHANICS. BECAUSE
07:10:19.226 --> 07:10:22.263
FUNDAMENTALLY. THE TRUSTEE THIS
07:10:22.329 --> 07:10:24.498
TRUSTEE THAT IS DOING THE SALE
07:10:24.565 --> 07:10:26.967
HAS ONE JOB AND THAT'S TO SELL.
07:10:27.034 --> 07:10:29.336
THE HOUSE THEY'RE NOT EMPLOYEE
07:10:29.403 --> 07:10:31.272
TO BE HIGHER REAL ESTATE FOLKS
07:10:31.338 --> 07:10:33.908
OR- OR- BE FAIR THEY'RE JUST
07:10:33.974 --> 07:10:35.142
HIRED BY THE BANK SO THEIR
07:10:35.209 --> 07:10:38.846
LOYALTY IS TO THE BANK SO. I
07:10:38.913 --> 07:10:41.715
YOUR INTENT IS GOOD YOU NEED A
07:10:41.782 --> 07:10:43.851
SEPARATE PARTY THAT WOULD STEP
07:10:43.918 --> 07:10:46.387
IN IN MY MIND THAT WOULD HAVE
07:10:46.453 --> 07:10:47.988
ACTED SUPPLY DO SHERRY TO
07:10:48.055 --> 07:10:49.690
ASSISTANCE PERSON SOMETIMES WE
07:10:49.757 --> 07:10:51.492
CALL THE BANKRUPTCY ATTORNEY BUT
07:10:51.559 --> 07:10:52.960
SOMETIMES IT MAY BE SOMEBODY
07:10:53.027 --> 07:10:55.663
ELSE. TO DO A SALE BECAUSE I
07:10:55.729 --> 07:10:57.398
THINK WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO GET
07:10:57.464 --> 07:11:00.334
AT IS THAT. THE LAW A POOR TO
07:11:00.401 --> 07:11:02.603
WASTE WE DON'T WANT TO SEE THESE
07:11:02.670 --> 07:11:04.205
HOMEOWNERS LOSE THREE HUNDRED
07:11:04.271 --> 07:11:05.206
THOUSAND DOLLARS WITH A VICTORY
07:11:05.272 --> 07:11:07.208
IN THEIR HOME I DON'T WANT TO
07:11:07.274 --> 07:11:08.876
SEE THE HOMEOWNERS LOSE THE
07:11:08.943 --> 07:11:10.778
HOME. RIGHT SO I'M GOING TO WHAT
07:11:10.844 --> 07:11:12.379
RELUCTANCE I'M GOING TO GO UP TO
07:11:12.446 --> 07:11:13.647
DATE ON THE BILL AFTER MY
07:11:13.714 --> 07:11:15.849
DISCUSSIONS WITH YOU AND WITH
07:11:15.916 --> 07:11:17.952
THE GENERAL INTENT THAT WE'VE
07:11:18.018 --> 07:11:19.987
GOTTA FIX THE MECHANICAL SIDE.
07:11:20.054 --> 07:11:22.990
ON THIS NON JUDICIAL PROCESS AND
07:11:23.057 --> 07:11:25.092
I AM THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENT
07:11:25.159 --> 07:11:26.060
IT IS SENATOR CENTER CHILL IS
07:11:26.126 --> 07:11:27.261
JUST KEEPING PEOPLE TALK OKAY
07:11:27.328 --> 07:11:28.896
YOU CAN RESPOND HE DID HAVE A
07:11:28.963 --> 07:11:30.564
QUESTION YOU RESPOND YOUR
07:11:30.631 --> 07:11:31.332
CLOTHES. SENATOR ALLEN EUROPE
07:11:31.398 --> 07:11:34.668
NEXT YEAH I JUST WANTED- THE- I
07:11:34.735 --> 07:11:36.637
WAN TO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR. A
07:11:36.704 --> 07:11:38.239
ROBUST DISCUSSION WE HAD ON THIS
07:11:38.305 --> 07:11:40.474
BILL AND- AND ALL THE WORK THAT
07:11:40.541 --> 07:11:41.942
I KNOW YOU'RE GONNA PUT INTO
07:11:42.009 --> 07:11:43.244
GETTING SOME OF THE MECHANISMS
07:11:43.310 --> 07:11:45.145
FIXED. SOME OF THE CONCERNS ARE
07:11:45.212 --> 07:11:46.413
OBSOLETE CORRECT- BUT- BUT I
07:11:46.480 --> 07:11:47.848
KNOW WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO DO
07:11:47.915 --> 07:11:49.250
HERE IT'S A RIGHTEOUS CAUSE. AND
07:11:49.316 --> 07:11:51.151
I'M GONNA SUPPORT YOUR EFFORTS
07:11:51.218 --> 07:11:52.453
TO MOVE FOR WITH THIS BILL AND
07:11:52.519 --> 07:11:54.588
GET THESE MECHANISMS FIX SO WE
07:11:54.655 --> 07:11:55.256
CAN. PROTECT PEOPLE OR JUST TRY
07:11:55.322 --> 07:11:57.091
TO PROTECT THEIR EQUITY IN THEIR
07:11:57.157 --> 07:11:58.959
HOMES. THANK YOU CENTER ALLEN
07:11:59.026 --> 07:12:01.195
SENATOR BORJAS. I THINK THE
07:12:01.262 --> 07:12:03.564
SECOND TO LAST SPEAKER- BROUGHT
07:12:03.631 --> 07:12:05.132
UP SO I GOT. SOME IMPORTANT
07:12:05.199 --> 07:12:06.567
POINTS WHEN THIS MATTER WAS
07:12:06.634 --> 07:12:09.303
BROUGHT TO JUDICIARY- I'D HEARD
07:12:09.370 --> 07:12:10.504
THAT THERE WERE SOME AMENDMENTS
07:12:10.571 --> 07:12:13.107
THAT HAVE BEEN PROPOSED- AND I
07:12:13.173 --> 07:12:15.175
JUST WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU- IF
07:12:15.242 --> 07:12:16.677
YOU COULD JUST QUICKLY DESCRIBE
07:12:16.744 --> 07:12:17.978
WHAT THOSE MINUTES MIGHT BE AND-
07:12:18.045 --> 07:12:20.147
IF YOU. IF YOU'VE TAKEN THEM. OR
07:12:20.214 --> 07:12:21.849
YOU ANTICIPATE TAKING THEM. AT
07:12:21.915 --> 07:12:23.817
THE NEXT HOUSE. SENATE ARCHULETA
07:12:23.884 --> 07:12:26.253
WE TAKE A QUESTION- YES MA'AM.
07:12:26.320 --> 07:12:29.356
PLEASE PROCEED. I AM GOING TO-
07:12:29.423 --> 07:12:31.225
TAKE ON ALL THE AMENDMENTS THAT
07:12:31.292 --> 07:12:33.494
WE POSSIBLY CAN. TO ENSURE THAT
07:12:33.560 --> 07:12:35.162
THIS BILL GOES FORWARD. AND IT'S
07:12:35.229 --> 07:12:37.197
SUCCESSFUL. WETHERBY THAT TIME
07:12:37.264 --> 07:12:40.267
FRAME. WHETHER IT BE AS- MY
07:12:40.334 --> 07:12:42.102
COLLEAGUE MENTIONED. ABOUT THE
07:12:42.169 --> 07:12:44.571
TIME FRAME. BUT ALSO A THIRD
07:12:44.638 --> 07:12:47.007
PARTY STEPPING IN. TO ENSURE
07:12:47.074 --> 07:12:50.511
PROTECT THAT HOMEOWNER. THAT'S
07:12:50.577 --> 07:12:52.513
ISSUES HERE. BUT THE GIST OF IT
07:12:52.579 --> 07:12:54.648
ALL. IS TO PROTECT THAT EQUITY.
07:12:54.715 --> 07:12:56.016
AND WE'RE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND
07:12:56.083 --> 07:12:57.818
MAKE SURE. THAT EVERY AMENDMENT
07:12:57.885 --> 07:13:00.387
POSSIBLE WILL BE CREATED. TO
07:13:00.454 --> 07:13:01.555
ENSURE THAT AND THE BANKS AGREE
07:13:01.622 --> 07:13:03.357
WITH ME. THEY AGREE THEY DON'T
07:13:03.424 --> 07:13:05.326
WANT TO BE THE BAD GUY. BUT WHAT
07:13:05.392 --> 07:13:07.094
IS THE TECHNICAL WAY TO GET
07:13:07.161 --> 07:13:08.128
THERE. AND WE WILL FIND IT. IN
07:13:08.195 --> 07:13:10.197
THE END OF THE YEAR. THE PATH.
07:13:10.264 --> 07:13:11.899
TO SUCCESS AND THE NEXT HOUSE AS
07:13:11.965 --> 07:13:13.167
WELL. THANK YOU CENTER ARCH LET
07:13:13.233 --> 07:13:15.169
US SING NO FURTHER DISCUSSION OR
07:13:15.235 --> 07:13:18.505
DEBATE MAY WE TAKE THAT AS YOUR
07:13:18.572 --> 07:13:22.710
CALL HOPE SORRY SENATOR ROTH.
07:13:22.776 --> 07:13:24.845
FRIEDMAN PRESIDENT YOU KNOW- I
07:13:24.912 --> 07:13:26.847
WAS JUST TRYING TO IT'S BEEN A
07:13:26.914 --> 07:13:28.716
LONG TIME SINCE I'VE DONE THIS
07:13:28.782 --> 07:13:30.117
SORT OF WORK AND I WASN'T
07:13:30.184 --> 07:13:31.151
PROBABLY VERY GOOD AT IT WHEN I
07:13:31.218 --> 07:13:33.721
DID IT. BUT- IN LOOKING AT THE
07:13:33.787 --> 07:13:35.589
TIMELINE. FOR A NON JUDICIAL
07:13:35.656 --> 07:13:36.990
FORECLOSURE AND I STAND TO BE
07:13:37.057 --> 07:13:39.093
CORRECTED BY MY MORE TALENTED
07:13:39.159 --> 07:13:43.430
COLLEAGUES. BUT THE. BLENDER
07:13:43.497 --> 07:13:47.634
CAN'T. BACK FOR THIRTY DAYS YOU
07:13:47.701 --> 07:13:49.370
HAVE TO CONTACT THE- PERSON
07:13:49.436 --> 07:13:52.172
DEFAULT GIVEN THIRTY DAYS THEN
07:13:52.239 --> 07:13:54.742
YOU DO A NOTICE OF DEFAULT. THEN
07:13:54.808 --> 07:13:57.911
THE DEBTOR HAS NINETY DAYS TO
07:13:57.978 --> 07:14:00.781
CURE. AND THEN AS A NOTICE OF
07:14:00.848 --> 07:14:02.916
SALE. I NEED TO CANCEL FOR
07:14:02.983 --> 07:14:04.885
ANOTHER TWENTY ONE DAYS OF
07:14:04.952 --> 07:14:06.720
SOMETIME AFTER THE TWENTY ONE
07:14:06.787 --> 07:14:09.390
NEWS. SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT. A
07:14:09.456 --> 07:14:11.725
HUNDRED AND FORTY ONE DAYS OVER
07:14:11.792 --> 07:14:14.027
. FOUR MONTHS FROM INITIAL
07:14:14.094 --> 07:14:17.798
CONTACT. THE KIND OF CONTACT
07:14:17.865 --> 07:14:19.032
WHEN YOU SAY IS ANOTHER ANOTHER
07:14:19.099 --> 07:14:21.769
PERSON OFTEN HERE'S A NOTICE OF
07:14:21.835 --> 07:14:24.805
DEFAULT. DOES YOUR BILL TAKE
07:14:24.872 --> 07:14:27.141
INTO ACCOUNT. THE INACTION BY
07:14:27.207 --> 07:14:29.143
THE DEBTOR DURING THAT WHOLE
07:14:29.209 --> 07:14:30.811
FOUR MONTH PERIOD WHERE THE
07:14:30.878 --> 07:14:32.846
DEBTOR DOES NOTHING TO LIST THE
07:14:32.913 --> 07:14:34.348
PROPERTY WITH A REALTOR OR TRY
07:14:34.415 --> 07:14:36.316
TO GET IT SOLD TO RECOVER OF THE
07:14:36.383 --> 07:14:37.217
EQUITY THAT WE'VE BEEN TALKING
07:14:37.284 --> 07:14:40.521
ABOUT. CENTER ARCHULETA WE TAKE
07:14:40.587 --> 07:14:41.655
A QUESTION YES MA'AM PLEASE
07:14:41.722 --> 07:14:44.024
PROCEED. IT IS PRETTY OBVIOUS
07:14:44.091 --> 07:14:46.193
THAT THE TYPE OF INDIVIDUAL THAT
07:14:46.260 --> 07:14:48.662
THIS BILL ADDRESSES IS ONE THAT
07:14:48.729 --> 07:14:50.063
EITHER PUT THEIR EAD IN THE
07:14:50.130 --> 07:14:52.900
SAND- HAS TROUBLE READING
07:14:52.966 --> 07:14:55.035
WRITING. PERHAPS IS ALONE
07:14:55.102 --> 07:14:57.404
DISABLED MENTALLY HAS A PROBLEM
07:14:57.471 --> 07:15:00.474
WHATEVER IT IS THEY HAVE CHOSEN
07:15:00.541 --> 07:15:01.809
TO HIDE FROM THE FACT THAT
07:15:01.875 --> 07:15:03.177
THEY'RE ABOUT TO LOSE THEIR
07:15:03.243 --> 07:15:06.547
HOMES THE EQUITY. AND SO IT IT'S
07:15:06.613 --> 07:15:08.315
IMPORTANT WE UNDERSTAND THAT
07:15:08.382 --> 07:15:09.583
WHAT THEY WERE TALKING FOR
07:15:09.650 --> 07:15:10.851
MONTHS TWENTY ONE DAYS WHATEVER
07:15:10.918 --> 07:15:13.420
THE THING IS AND COMPARED TO A
07:15:13.487 --> 07:15:15.522
LIFETIME. OF SAVINGS AND WORKING
07:15:15.589 --> 07:15:17.090
ON THAT PROPERTY TO HAVE THAT
07:15:17.157 --> 07:15:19.393
EQUITY FOR US TO HAVE A LITTLE
07:15:19.460 --> 07:15:20.994
BIT MORE TIME TO GIVE THEM THAT
07:15:21.061 --> 07:15:23.497
OPPORTUNITY. TO MAYBE GET IN
07:15:23.564 --> 07:15:25.065
TOUCH WITH SOMEONE AS WE HAD
07:15:25.132 --> 07:15:26.834
MENTIONED HAVING A THIRD PARTY I
07:15:26.900 --> 07:15:28.168
THINK THAT'S A GREAT IDEA AND
07:15:28.235 --> 07:15:30.003
I'M GOING TO PRESENT THAT AS AN
07:15:30.070 --> 07:15:31.371
AMENDMENT. IN MAY BE HAVING
07:15:31.438 --> 07:15:32.806
SOMEONE WITHIN THE COUNTY. COME
07:15:32.873 --> 07:15:35.075
IN AND JUMP IN BUT THERE IS A
07:15:35.142 --> 07:15:37.010
DEFINITELY A TIME WELL ENOUGH IS
07:15:37.077 --> 07:15:39.012
ENOUGH AND IT'LL GO ON. BUT AT
07:15:39.079 --> 07:15:40.781
THE SAME TIME WE SHOULD DO
07:15:40.848 --> 07:15:42.483
EVERYTHING WE POSSIBLY CAN TO
07:15:42.549 --> 07:15:44.518
PROTECT THAT HOMEOWNER. SENATE
07:15:44.585 --> 07:15:46.954
ROTH THANK YOU BERMAN PRESIDENT
07:15:47.020 --> 07:15:48.789
JUST ON MY OWN TIME. AND THEN
07:15:48.856 --> 07:15:50.090
THANK YOU FOR TAKING THAT INTO
07:15:50.157 --> 07:15:51.992
CONSIDERATION IN TRYING TO WORK
07:15:52.059 --> 07:15:54.228
WITH THAT. PERIOD OF AN ACTIVITY
07:15:54.294 --> 07:15:55.729
WHICH IS NOT INSUBSTANTIAL I
07:15:55.796 --> 07:15:57.531
THINK YOU'LL AGREE WHEN SOMEONE.
07:15:57.598 --> 07:16:00.267
OWES MONEY AND THERE'S AN ASSET
07:16:00.334 --> 07:16:01.468
JUST SITTING THERE. AND THEN I
07:16:01.535 --> 07:16:02.836
MAYBE YOU'VE AREADY ANSWERED
07:16:02.903 --> 07:16:05.038
THIS IN RESPONSE TO ONE OF THE
07:16:05.105 --> 07:16:07.007
EARLIER QUESTIONS BUT- I ASSUME
07:16:07.074 --> 07:16:08.642
THAT YOU WILL CONSIDER PUTTING A
07:16:08.709 --> 07:16:10.978
LIMIT ON THE LISTING. IF WE'VE
07:16:11.044 --> 07:16:13.347
BEEN FOUR AND A HALF MONTHS
07:16:13.413 --> 07:16:16.083
SINCE THE ORIGINAL CONTACT.
07:16:16.149 --> 07:16:18.118
FORMAL CONTACT WITH THE DEBTOR.
07:16:18.185 --> 07:16:20.153
THE ISTING WHICH AS YOU KNOW IF
07:16:20.220 --> 07:16:21.622
YOU KNOW WHEN YOUR BUSINESS CAN
07:16:21.688 --> 07:16:24.157
TAKE. STAND FOR SOME PERIOD OF
07:16:24.224 --> 07:16:26.894
TIME TO GET A PROPERTY SOLD IN
07:16:26.960 --> 07:16:29.096
THE AND THE ACTUAL SALE CLOSED.
07:16:29.162 --> 07:16:30.831
THAT YOU PUT A LIMIT ON THAT.
07:16:30.898 --> 07:16:33.033
LISTINGS SO AND THEN PROVIDE FOR
07:16:33.100 --> 07:16:35.235
HOW THE CREDITOR GETS BACK IN
07:16:35.302 --> 07:16:37.170
THE GAME. AT THAT POINT. DO YOU
07:16:37.237 --> 07:16:40.574
PAUSE THE- THE NOTICE OF DEFAULT
07:16:40.641 --> 07:16:42.276
THE FORECLOSURE PROCEEDING AND
07:16:42.342 --> 07:16:43.877
PICK IT UP WHERE YOU LEFT OFF
07:16:43.944 --> 07:16:46.113
FOR IS DOES THE CREDITOR OF TO
07:16:46.179 --> 07:16:47.414
GO BACK AND START THE FOUR AND A
07:16:47.481 --> 07:16:49.316
HALF MONTH PERIOD. YET AGAIN. IF
07:16:49.383 --> 07:16:51.785
THE SALE FALLS OUT. IN THE THREE
07:16:51.852 --> 07:16:53.353
MONTHS THAT WE ALLOW FOR A
07:16:53.420 --> 07:16:55.222
LISTING OF THE SIXTY DAYS. DOES
07:16:55.289 --> 07:16:59.359
NOT PRODUCE. A FINAL RESULT. IT
07:16:59.426 --> 07:17:00.627
WASN'T A QUESTION THAT'S ON MY
07:17:00.694 --> 07:17:02.296
OWN TIME THANK YOU FOR
07:17:02.362 --> 07:17:04.665
CONSIDERING THAT SIR AND YES ONE
07:17:04.731 --> 07:17:06.767
SENATE ROTH SEEING NO FURTHER
07:17:06.833 --> 07:17:08.802
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SURCHARGE
07:17:08.869 --> 07:17:10.304
LET YOU MAY CLOSE THANK YOU
07:17:10.370 --> 07:17:11.972
MADAM PRESIDENT OF ALL THE
07:17:12.039 --> 07:17:13.840
ISSUES THAT ARE BROUGHT UP BY MY
07:17:13.907 --> 07:17:15.008
COLLEAGUES ARE BEING LOOKED AT
07:17:15.075 --> 07:17:17.177
AND WE WILL BE WORKING ON THEM
07:17:17.244 --> 07:17:19.079
AND AGAIN I THINK ALL OF US CAN
07:17:19.146 --> 07:17:20.981
AGREE TO SAVE THAT HOMEOWNER-
07:17:21.048 --> 07:17:23.250
THEIR EQUITY IS MUCH AS WE CAN
07:17:23.317 --> 07:17:24.251
AND THAT'S WHAT THE BANK IS
07:17:24.318 --> 07:17:26.019
WORKING WITH ME. TO DO EXACTLY
07:17:26.086 --> 07:17:28.188
THAT THEY DON'T WANT TO BE THE
07:17:28.255 --> 07:17:29.022
BAD GUYS AND WE DON'T WANT
07:17:29.089 --> 07:17:31.291
ANYONE TO BE HURT AND SUFFER SO
07:17:31.358 --> 07:17:32.559
ALONG THE WAY THEY'LL BE AN
07:17:32.626 --> 07:17:34.328
OPPORTUNITY WHERE THEY HOMEOWNER
07:17:34.394 --> 07:17:36.630
ALWAYS HAS A CHANCE TO STEP UP
07:17:36.697 --> 07:17:37.898
AND GET THE PROPERTY SOLD
07:17:37.965 --> 07:17:40.167
THEMSELVES AND IF IT HAS TO BE
07:17:40.233 --> 07:17:41.501
LISTED A REASONABLE TIME A SIXTY
07:17:41.568 --> 07:17:43.270
DAY LISTING IS REASONABLE IN
07:17:43.337 --> 07:17:44.972
TODAY'S MARKET A THIRTY DAY
07:17:45.038 --> 07:17:46.640
ESCROW IS REASONABLE IN TODAY'S
07:17:46.707 --> 07:17:48.075
MARKET THE BANK WILL RECEIVE
07:17:48.141 --> 07:17:49.610
THEIR MONEY AT THE END AND WITH
07:17:49.676 --> 07:17:51.144
THESE REASONS I ASK FOR YOUR I.
07:17:51.211 --> 07:17:54.748
BOATS. THANK YOU CENTER
07:17:54.815 --> 07:17:55.482
ARCHULETA. MADAM SECRETARY
07:17:55.549 --> 07:17:57.417
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN HI
07:17:57.484 --> 07:18:03.156
ARCHULETA. I ATKINS AYE BATES NO
07:18:03.223 --> 07:18:10.564
BACKER. I FOR JUST. BRADFORD I
07:18:10.631 --> 07:18:12.866
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
07:18:12.933 --> 07:18:19.039
DALY NO DODD. I TORONTO I EGGMAN
07:18:19.106 --> 07:18:24.878
AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ. I GROW
07:18:24.945 --> 07:18:31.451
. HERTZBERG WESTERN. HI FURTADO
07:18:31.518 --> 07:18:37.791
I JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED I
07:18:37.858 --> 07:18:41.028
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE AYE
07:18:41.094 --> 07:18:46.800
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN. I
07:18:46.867 --> 07:18:52.005
NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED NO HAN. I
07:18:52.072 --> 07:18:58.011
PORTANTINO. I ROTH. HI RUBIO I
07:18:58.078 --> 07:19:03.483
SKINNER. I STERN HI I'M BURKE
07:19:03.550 --> 07:19:06.787
AYE AYE CASKEY AYE WIENER AYE
07:19:06.853 --> 07:19:10.323
WILK. NO PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
07:19:10.390 --> 07:19:18.098
MEMBERS. FORGES NO. GROW NO
07:19:18.165 --> 07:19:24.104
HERTZBERG. HIGHS THIRTY NO ZERO
07:19:24.171 --> 07:19:25.272
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS JUST
07:19:25.338 --> 07:19:28.508
SORT. KNOWS NINE I'M SORRY EYES
07:19:28.575 --> 07:19:30.243
THIRTY KNOWS NINE A MAJOR STILL
07:19:30.310 --> 07:19:32.079
PASSES AND MEMBERS JUST SO YOU
07:19:32.145 --> 07:19:33.780
KNOW WE HAVE A LOT MORE BILLS
07:19:33.847 --> 07:19:35.015
THAT WE HAVE TO GET THROUGH
07:19:35.082 --> 07:19:36.917
TONIGHT SO THE MORE WE CAN FOCUS
07:19:36.983 --> 07:19:38.118
AND PAY ATTENTION THE SOONER WE
07:19:38.185 --> 07:19:40.220
WILL BE DONE FOR THE EVENING AND
07:19:40.287 --> 07:19:42.122
TAKE A BACK UP TOMORROW WE'RE
07:19:42.189 --> 07:19:43.790
NOT GOING TO FILE ITEM SEVENTY
07:19:43.857 --> 07:19:45.492
FIVE WHICH IS THERE TO WRITE
07:19:45.559 --> 07:19:46.426
HOUSEKI. BEN SECRETARY PLEASE
07:19:46.493 --> 07:19:48.829
READ SENATE BILL EIGHT NINETY
07:19:48.895 --> 07:19:49.830
SEVEN BY SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI
07:19:49.896 --> 07:19:51.498
AN ACT RELATING TO LAND USE
07:19:51.565 --> 07:19:53.467
CENTER KELSEY MEN PRESENT
07:19:53.533 --> 07:19:55.035
MARKETS TELL EVERYONE HOW
07:19:55.102 --> 07:19:56.837
WONDERFUL EIGHTY USE ARE AND HOW
07:19:56.903 --> 07:19:59.606
PEOPLE CAN CAN. MAKE MONEY OFF
07:19:59.673 --> 07:20:00.941
OF- HELP OUT THEIR FAMILIES AND
07:20:01.007 --> 07:20:02.909
THEIR FRIENDS AND ALL THAT THIS
07:20:02.976 --> 07:20:05.479
BILL IN FRONT OF US ADDRESSES
07:20:05.545 --> 07:20:06.980
MANY OF THE PROBLEMS HAVE BEEN
07:20:07.047 --> 07:20:08.215
RAISED BY HOMEOWNERS ARE
07:20:08.281 --> 07:20:09.750
CONSTITUENTS AND HOUSING
07:20:09.816 --> 07:20:11.284
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT IT
07:20:11.351 --> 07:20:12.519
ADDRESSES THE ISSUE OF
07:20:12.586 --> 07:20:14.588
UNPERMITTED EIGHTY USE THE BILL
07:20:14.654 --> 07:20:17.224
WOULD. PROHIBIT A LOCAL AGENCY
07:20:17.290 --> 07:20:19.192
FROM DENYING A PERMIT UNLESS THE
07:20:19.259 --> 07:20:20.494
M. PERMITTED EIGHTY YOU WAS
07:20:20.560 --> 07:20:23.163
BUILT BEFORE TWO THOUSAND
07:20:23.230 --> 07:20:25.165
EIGHTEEN AND THERE IS A HEALTH
07:20:25.232 --> 07:20:26.733
AND SAFETY VIOLATION I TOOK
07:20:26.800 --> 07:20:28.468
AMENDMENTS IN THE GOVERNANCE AND
07:20:28.535 --> 07:20:32.506
FINANCE WHICH LIMITS THE HIVE OF
07:20:32.572 --> 07:20:33.807
. WHICH LIMITS THE TWENTY FIVE
07:20:33.874 --> 07:20:36.076
FOOT HEIGHT LIMIT TWENTY FIVE
07:20:36.143 --> 07:20:39.146
FEET IS ALLOWED IF YOU WERE IN A
07:20:39.212 --> 07:20:42.382
TRANSIT RICH. NEIGHBORHOOD THAT
07:20:42.449 --> 07:20:45.018
MEANS USUALLY FIXED RAIL OR FOR
07:20:45.085 --> 07:20:48.855
BUSES RUNNING PER HOUR PER HOUR.
07:20:48.922 --> 07:20:50.891
FOR THE EIGHTY YOU IS ATTACHED
07:20:50.957 --> 07:20:53.460
TO YOUR HOUSE YOU PUT IT ON. THE
07:20:53.527 --> 07:20:55.228
TOP OF THE GARAGE IN YOUR HOUSE
07:20:55.295 --> 07:20:57.964
EVERYWHERE ELSE THE SIXTEEN FOOT
07:20:58.031 --> 07:20:59.699
HEIGHT LIMIT EXISTS SO WHAT'S
07:20:59.766 --> 07:21:02.502
HIS IT'S A NARROWER FOR THE NON
07:21:02.569 --> 07:21:04.271
TENSE AREAS I THINK YOU COULD.
07:21:04.337 --> 07:21:06.973
TALK ABOUT WE'VE STREAMLINED THE
07:21:07.040 --> 07:21:08.008
PERMITTING AND CONSTRUCTION OF A
07:21:08.074 --> 07:21:11.244
TO USE- WE'RE ALLOWING MORE YOU
07:21:11.311 --> 07:21:13.380
WE'RE ALLOWING THESE UNITS AND
07:21:13.446 --> 07:21:14.714
HOMEOWNERS PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
07:21:14.781 --> 07:21:15.682
HOUSING OPTIONS TO THE
07:21:15.749 --> 07:21:17.484
COMMUNITIES IN ADDRESSING THESE
07:21:17.551 --> 07:21:19.953
BARRIERS WE HOPE WE ENCOURAGE
07:21:20.020 --> 07:21:20.921
MORE HOMEOWNERS TO TAKE
07:21:20.987 --> 07:21:22.656
ADVANTAGE OF IT. I WOULD URGE
07:21:22.722 --> 07:21:24.391
AND I VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
07:21:24.457 --> 07:21:27.861
RIGHT CASKEY. DISCUSSION AND
07:21:27.928 --> 07:21:29.429
DEBATE SENATOR BATES. THANK YOU
07:21:29.496 --> 07:21:32.399
ARE MADAM PRESIDENT ON THE
07:21:32.465 --> 07:21:34.234
QUESTION FOR THE AUTHORS TO THE
07:21:34.301 --> 07:21:35.101
CHAIR. SENATE WAT KELSEY WE
07:21:35.168 --> 07:21:37.103
TAKE A CLIP THE QUESTION I WILL
07:21:37.170 --> 07:21:39.072
THANK YOU CENTER BATES THANK YOU
07:21:39.139 --> 07:21:41.141
SENATOR ARM I BELIEVE IN THE
07:21:41.208 --> 07:21:42.843
HOUSING COMMITTEE YOU DID ANSWER
07:21:42.909 --> 07:21:44.311
THE QUESTION AS TO WHETHER THIS
07:21:44.377 --> 07:21:46.346
AFFECTED THOSE DEVELOPMENTS
07:21:46.413 --> 07:21:50.450
PROTECTED BY A- A COVENANT ARE A
07:21:50.517 --> 07:21:53.320
HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATIONS. AND I'VE
07:21:53.386 --> 07:21:55.121
FOUND IN THE CIVIL CODE AND I
07:21:55.188 --> 07:21:57.757
JUST LIKE YOU TO CLARIFY THIS IS
07:21:57.824 --> 07:21:59.426
A CHAPTER FIVE ARTICLE ONE
07:21:59.492 --> 07:22:01.027
PROTECTED USES THAT SAYS ON
07:22:01.094 --> 07:22:02.929
SECTION EIGHTY ANY COVENANT
07:22:02.996 --> 07:22:04.497
RESTRICTION OR CONDITION
07:22:04.564 --> 07:22:06.600
CONTAINED IN ANY DEED CONTRACT.
07:22:06.666 --> 07:22:08.268
SECURITY AN INSTRUMENT OR OTHER
07:22:08.335 --> 07:22:09.269
INSTRUMENT EFFECTING THE
07:22:09.336 --> 07:22:11.304
TRANSFER OR SALE OF ANY INTEREST
07:22:11.371 --> 07:22:12.405
IN A PLANNED DEVELOPMENT AND
07:22:12.472 --> 07:22:15.175
HERE'S THE CRUX OF THIS ANY
07:22:15.242 --> 07:22:16.509
PROVISION OF A GOVERNING
07:22:16.576 --> 07:22:18.979
DOCUMENT THAT EITHER EFFECTIVELY
07:22:19.045 --> 07:22:20.780
PROHIBITS OR UNREASONABLY
07:22:20.847 --> 07:22:22.415
RESTRICTS THE CONSTRUCTION OR
07:22:22.482 --> 07:22:24.451
USE OF AN ASSET. ACCESSORY
07:22:24.517 --> 07:22:25.518
DWELLING UNIT OR JUNIOR
07:22:25.585 --> 07:22:27.721
ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS ON A
07:22:27.787 --> 07:22:29.155
LOT ZONED FOR SINGLE FAMILY
07:22:29.222 --> 07:22:31.258
RESIDENTIAL USE THAT MEETS THE
07:22:31.324 --> 07:22:32.626
REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION IS
07:22:32.692 --> 07:22:34.594
VOID AND UNENFORCEABLE AND THAT
07:22:34.661 --> 07:22:36.796
WOULD SUGGEST TO ME MAN L.
07:22:36.863 --> 07:22:38.999
ANNOUNCER ARE YOU MAY DO THAT IN
07:22:39.065 --> 07:22:41.301
YOUR CLOTHES- DOES THAT ACTUALLY
07:22:41.368 --> 07:22:43.103
REMOVE THE COVENANTS AND
07:22:43.169 --> 07:22:47.774
PROTECTIONS. OF H. AWAY-
07:22:47.841 --> 07:22:49.442
GOVERNANCE. THERE WERE SCAMMELL
07:22:49.509 --> 07:22:50.076
IT'LL YOU INCLUDE HAT YOUR CALL
07:22:50.143 --> 07:22:52.512
BECAUSE WE HAVE NO FURTHER
07:22:52.579 --> 07:22:53.413
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE OKAY.
07:22:53.480 --> 07:22:55.448
ASSEMBLY MEMBER- FRIEDMAN HAD A
07:22:55.515 --> 07:22:57.417
BILL TWO YEARS AGO THAT HAD THE
07:22:57.484 --> 07:22:59.653
LANGUAGE IN THAT SAID THAT YOU
07:22:59.719 --> 07:23:02.055
COULDN'T I'VE H. AWAY COULDN'T.
07:23:02.122 --> 07:23:03.690
TOTALLY PROHIBIT THE
07:23:03.757 --> 07:23:06.326
CONSTRUCTION OF OUR EIGHTIES
07:23:06.393 --> 07:23:08.161
THIS BILL DOESN'T TOUCH IT AT
07:23:08.228 --> 07:23:10.096
ALL IN FACT NONE OF THE BILLS
07:23:10.163 --> 07:23:11.464
I'VE EVER DONE EVER AFFECTED
07:23:11.531 --> 07:23:14.567
DOES PRIVATE. AGREEMENTS THAT
07:23:14.634 --> 07:23:16.002
PEOPLE TAKE WOULD MAKE WHEN
07:23:16.069 --> 07:23:21.107
THEY- JORDAN- HLA SO. WITH THAT
07:23:21.174 --> 07:23:22.676
IT'S A GOOD BILL AYE RECURSION
07:23:22.742 --> 07:23:23.810
AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER AYE
07:23:23.877 --> 07:23:26.179
CASKEY MEN SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
07:23:26.246 --> 07:23:31.885
THE ROLL. ALLEN ARCHULETA I
07:23:31.952 --> 07:23:38.758
ATKINS I FACE NO BAKER. FOR JUST
07:23:38.825 --> 07:23:42.796
. BRADFORD I CABALLERO AYE
07:23:42.862 --> 07:23:50.003
CORTESE AYE DALY. DODD I TORONTO
07:23:50.070 --> 07:23:53.640
I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER NOPE
07:23:53.707 --> 07:23:58.078
GONZALEZ I GROW. NO HERTZBERG
07:23:58.144 --> 07:24:04.617
WESSEL. HI FURTADO. I JONES NO
07:24:04.684 --> 07:24:09.089
KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED AYE LEYVA
07:24:09.155 --> 07:24:14.627
AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE. MELENDEZ
07:24:14.694 --> 07:24:20.433
MAN. NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A
07:24:20.500 --> 07:24:25.672
TROUBLED. PAN AYE PORTANTINO.
07:24:25.739 --> 07:24:33.680
ROTH I RUBIO. SKINNER I STERN HI
07:24:33.747 --> 07:24:38.685
I'M BURKE. I BY CASTING AYE
07:24:38.752 --> 07:24:41.621
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL
07:24:41.688 --> 07:24:45.058
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. ALLEN I
07:24:45.125 --> 07:24:54.100
BAKER NO FOR JUST. DALLY NO.
07:24:54.167 --> 07:24:59.839
HERTZBERG MCGUIRE. MELENDEZ MAN
07:24:59.906 --> 07:25:05.412
NO A CHOI BOGUE. PORTANTINO
07:25:05.478 --> 07:25:10.050
RUBIO. BY TWENTY FOUR KNOWS NINE
07:25:10.116 --> 07:25:11.684
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS WE
07:25:11.751 --> 07:25:14.287
ARE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
07:25:14.354 --> 07:25:15.755
SEVENTY EIGHT SENATOR SKINNER
07:25:15.822 --> 07:25:18.058
MAN SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
07:25:18.124 --> 07:25:19.893
BILL NINE NINETY THREE BY
07:25:19.959 --> 07:25:21.127
SENATOR SKINNER AN ACT RELATING
07:25:21.194 --> 07:25:22.762
TO CRIMES AND MAKING AN
07:25:22.829 --> 07:25:25.098
APPROPRIATION THEREFORE CENTER.
07:25:25.165 --> 07:25:26.699
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND
07:25:26.766 --> 07:25:28.101
MEMBERS ACTUALLY IT'S AN ACT
07:25:28.168 --> 07:25:29.669
RELATED TO SUPPORT FOR CRIME
07:25:29.736 --> 07:25:31.971
VICTIMS CALIFORNIA WAS ONE OF
07:25:32.038 --> 07:25:33.873
THE FIRST STATES TO ESTABLISH A
07:25:33.940 --> 07:25:35.775
PROGRAM TO PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR
07:25:35.842 --> 07:25:38.178
VICTIMS OF CRIME. AND THAT'S THE
07:25:38.244 --> 07:25:40.580
PURPOSE OF SB NINE NINE THREE
07:25:40.647 --> 07:25:42.582
IT'S TO EXPAND AND IMPROVE THAT
07:25:42.649 --> 07:25:45.385
PROGRAM SO THAT WE PROVIDE
07:25:45.452 --> 07:25:48.555
SUPPORT TO MORE VICTIMS BECAUSE
07:25:48.621 --> 07:25:49.322
UNFORTUNATELY WE'RE IN A
07:25:49.389 --> 07:25:51.691
SITUATION NOW THAT ONLY LESS
07:25:51.758 --> 07:25:53.393
THAN ONE IN FIVE. OF
07:25:53.460 --> 07:25:55.462
CALIFORNIA'S CRIME SURVIVORS
07:25:55.528 --> 07:25:58.998
RECEIVED HELP FROM OUR PROGRAM-
07:25:59.065 --> 07:26:01.768
AND IT TAKES AN AVERAGE OF TEN
07:26:01.835 --> 07:26:03.803
MONTHS TO RECEIVE BENEFITS AND
07:26:03.870 --> 07:26:05.205
WHEN YOU CONSIDER THAT SOME OF
07:26:05.271 --> 07:26:07.107
THE BENEFITS THAT WE PROVIDE OUR
07:26:07.173 --> 07:26:09.342
FOR EXAMPLE TO COVER FUNERAL
07:26:09.409 --> 07:26:11.945
COSTS IF THERE WAS A DEATH- A
07:26:12.011 --> 07:26:15.782
MURDER. HI IT'S TEN MONTHS IS AN
07:26:15.849 --> 07:26:18.718
UNREASONABLE TIME TO WAIT FOR
07:26:18.785 --> 07:26:22.422
SUCH A- COMPENSATION. SO SB NINE
07:26:22.489 --> 07:26:23.923
NINE THREE IMPROVES ACCESS TO
07:26:23.990 --> 07:26:25.792
SUPPORT AND SERVICES FOR
07:26:25.859 --> 07:26:27.827
SURVIVORS AND EXONERATIONS IT
07:26:27.894 --> 07:26:30.230
INCREASES THE FINANCIAL SUPPORT
07:26:30.296 --> 07:26:33.099
A CRIME SURVIVOR CAN RECEIVE
07:26:33.166 --> 07:26:34.234
WHICH IS NOT BEEN ADJUSTED FOR
07:26:34.300 --> 07:26:36.970
YEARS. THAT IT STREAMLINES THE
07:26:37.036 --> 07:26:40.507
CLAIMS PROCESS SO THAT VICTIMS
07:26:40.573 --> 07:26:42.308
OF CRIME CAN RECEIVE SUPPORT
07:26:42.375 --> 07:26:45.612
SOONER- IN IT ALSO REMOVES SOME
07:26:45.678 --> 07:26:46.913
OF THE BARRIERS THAT HAVE
07:26:46.980 --> 07:26:48.548
PREVENTED SOME OF OUR CRIME
07:26:48.615 --> 07:26:50.250
VICTIMS FROM RECEIVING THAT
07:26:50.316 --> 07:26:53.653
SUPPORT. LASTLY IT PROVIDES
07:26:53.720 --> 07:26:56.990
IMPROVED ASSISTANCE TO EXONERATE
07:26:57.056 --> 07:26:58.324
THOSE ARE PEOPLE WHO ARE
07:26:58.391 --> 07:26:59.626
WRONGFULLY CONVICTED OR
07:26:59.692 --> 07:27:02.095
INCARCERATED FOR A CRIME. AND
07:27:02.162 --> 07:27:03.596
WITH THAT I ASK FOR YOUR AYE
07:27:03.663 --> 07:27:05.064
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER
07:27:05.131 --> 07:27:06.866
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
07:27:06.933 --> 07:27:09.502
SENATOR GROVE. THANK YOU MADAM
07:27:09.569 --> 07:27:11.237
PRESIDENT QUESTION EITHER.
07:27:11.304 --> 07:27:13.273
SANDERS CAN WE TAKE A QUESTION
07:27:13.339 --> 07:27:14.908
YES PLEASE PROCEED THERE'S A
07:27:14.974 --> 07:27:16.276
LANGUAGE IN THIS BILL ALLOW
07:27:16.342 --> 07:27:17.977
THOSE THAT COMMITTED OR
07:27:18.044 --> 07:27:20.413
PERPETRATED THE CRIME AND TO
07:27:20.480 --> 07:27:22.382
APPLY FOR THESE BENEFITS AS
07:27:22.448 --> 07:27:26.286
WELL. CENTER SKINNER.IF THE
07:27:26.352 --> 07:27:30.323
PERSON WHO COMMITTED THE CRIME
07:27:30.390 --> 07:27:33.393
IN QUESTION. IT ABSOLUTELY
07:27:33.459 --> 07:27:35.195
PROHIBITS THEM FROM RECEIVING
07:27:35.261 --> 07:27:37.430
ANY COMPENSATION OR SUBMITTING
07:27:37.497 --> 07:27:41.000
ANY FORM TO THE CRIME VICTIMS
07:27:41.067 --> 07:27:43.369
PROGRAM UNDER THIS BILL SO. THE
07:27:43.436 --> 07:27:46.539
IT DOES NOT DO THAT CENTER GROVE
07:27:46.606 --> 07:27:48.675
THANK YOU THINKING THEM CENTER
07:27:48.741 --> 07:27:52.845
NIELSEN. MADAM PRESIDENT LADIES
07:27:52.912 --> 07:27:54.881
GENTLEMAN OF THE SENATE. I
07:27:54.948 --> 07:27:59.485
DISAGREE I THINK JUST ABSOLUTELY
07:27:59.552 --> 07:28:01.287
. LET ALLOWS CRIMINALS TO
07:28:01.354 --> 07:28:05.225
QUALIFY THE BENEFITS CONTINUING
07:28:05.291 --> 07:28:07.293
THE TREND OF TURNING THE VICTIM
07:28:07.360 --> 07:28:09.295
SYSTEM THE JUSTICE SYSTEM INSIDE
07:28:09.362 --> 07:28:12.065
OUT MAKING CRIMINALS AND THEIR
07:28:12.131 --> 07:28:16.369
KIN OR FRIENDS THE VICTIMS.
07:28:16.436 --> 07:28:19.005
THAT'S JUST NOT RIGHT. THIS IS
07:28:19.072 --> 07:28:21.774
NOT ABSOLUTE AND IT ALSO AS I
07:28:21.841 --> 07:28:25.778
UNDERSTAND IT FROM OUR ANALYSIS
07:28:25.845 --> 07:28:27.280
. ELIMINATING THE REQUIREMENT
07:28:27.347 --> 07:28:31.017
THAT A POLICE REPORT BE MADE.
07:28:31.084 --> 07:28:33.620
THAT MIGHT LIMIT THE ABILITY TO
07:28:33.686 --> 07:28:35.488
VERIFY CLAIMS OR BALLOTS.
07:28:35.555 --> 07:28:37.423
ELIMINATING THE POLICE REPORT
07:28:37.490 --> 07:28:38.958
NOW THIS IS A FUNDAMENTAL
07:28:39.025 --> 07:28:41.594
DOCUMENT IN THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE
07:28:41.661 --> 07:28:43.596
SYSTEM WE'RE GONNA GET RID OF.
07:28:43.663 --> 07:28:46.466
SO YOU CANNOT VERIFY. WHETHER
07:28:46.532 --> 07:28:50.436
THAT CRIMINAL OR THEIR WHATEVER
07:28:50.503 --> 07:28:54.340
. ACTUALLY SHOULD QUALIFY. WRONG
07:28:54.407 --> 07:28:56.409
DIRECTION LADIES AND GENTLEMAN.
07:28:56.476 --> 07:28:59.145
GOSH SAKES IN TERMS OF THE
07:28:59.212 --> 07:29:00.980
RIGHTS OF THE VICTIMS. WHO LOST
07:29:01.047 --> 07:29:02.448
LOVED ONES WHO HAVE SUFFERED
07:29:02.515 --> 07:29:04.951
THEMSELVES. NOW WE'RE GONNA
07:29:05.018 --> 07:29:07.920
RECOMPENSE THOSE WHO HURT THEM I
07:29:07.987 --> 07:29:09.989
URGE AND NOBLE THANK YOU CENTER
07:29:10.056 --> 07:29:11.057
NIELSEN MEMBERS FURTHER
07:29:11.124 --> 07:29:14.427
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
07:29:14.494 --> 07:29:15.561
HEARING THEN CENTERS CAN REMAIN
07:29:15.628 --> 07:29:17.563
CLOSE. FIVE THANK YOU THIS BILL
07:29:17.630 --> 07:29:19.132
HAS NO OPPOSITION AND WITH THAT
07:29:19.198 --> 07:29:21.401
I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
07:29:21.467 --> 07:29:22.568
YOU CENTER SKINNER OF SECRETARY
07:29:22.635 --> 07:29:26.472
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
07:29:26.539 --> 07:29:30.677
ARCHULETA. AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
07:29:30.743 --> 07:29:37.016
. BACKER I PORCHES. BRADFORD AYE
07:29:37.083 --> 07:29:40.853
CABALLERO AYE CORTESE AYE DALY.
07:29:40.920 --> 07:29:47.260
DODD HI TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
07:29:47.327 --> 07:29:50.997
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW.
07:29:51.064 --> 07:29:57.503
HERTZBERG HUESO I HER TADO.
07:29:57.570 --> 07:30:03.142
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
07:30:03.209 --> 07:30:07.046
LEYVA AYE LIMON AYE MCGUIRE AYE
07:30:07.113 --> 07:30:11.284
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
07:30:11.351 --> 07:30:14.887
NIELSEN. NO CONTROL OF BOTH AYE
07:30:14.954 --> 07:30:19.759
PAN I PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE
07:30:19.826 --> 07:30:24.030
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN AYE
07:30:24.097 --> 07:30:28.868
AMBERG. I BY CASTING AYE WIENER
07:30:28.935 --> 07:30:32.505
AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL THE
07:30:32.572 --> 07:30:36.209
ABSENT MEMBERS FACE. PORGES
07:30:36.275 --> 07:30:42.548
VALLEY. GROVE NO HERTZBERG
07:30:42.615 --> 07:30:47.086
FURTADO. HIGHS THIRTY KNOWS FIVE
07:30:47.153 --> 07:30:48.621
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
07:30:48.688 --> 07:30:51.057
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM ID TWO
07:30:51.124 --> 07:30:52.959
EIGHTY TWO SENATOR PAN MADAM
07:30:53.025 --> 07:30:55.828
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
07:30:55.895 --> 07:30:57.864
BILL TEN EIGHTEEN BY SENATOR PAN
07:30:57.930 --> 07:30:59.599
AND AFTER RELATING TO BUSINESS
07:30:59.665 --> 07:31:00.900
CENTER PAN THANK YOU MADAM
07:31:00.967 --> 07:31:02.535
PRESIDENT CENTERS ON PLEASE
07:31:02.602 --> 07:31:04.070
PRESENT SB TEN EIGHTEEN THE
07:31:04.137 --> 07:31:05.671
PLATFORM ACCOUNTABILITY AND
07:31:05.738 --> 07:31:07.807
TRANSPARENCY ACT. AS WE
07:31:07.874 --> 07:31:09.041
DISCUSSED EARLIER TODAY SOCIAL
07:31:09.108 --> 07:31:10.843
MEDIA HAS DRAMATICALLY CHANGED
07:31:10.910 --> 07:31:13.012
THE WAY WE SHARE AND CONSUME
07:31:13.079 --> 07:31:14.280
INFORMATION YET WE KNOW NEXT TO
07:31:14.347 --> 07:31:15.615
NOTHING ABOUT HOW THIS
07:31:15.681 --> 07:31:17.450
INFORMATION WHAT INFORMATION.
07:31:17.517 --> 07:31:18.851
AND SOME OFTENTIMES
07:31:18.918 --> 07:31:20.353
MISINFORMATION IS PRESENTED TO
07:31:20.420 --> 07:31:21.721
US IN HER CONGRESSIONAL
07:31:21.788 --> 07:31:23.689
TESTIMONY FOR THIS SO FACEBOOK
07:31:23.756 --> 07:31:25.124
WHISTLEBLOWER FRANCIS HOW CAN
07:31:25.191 --> 07:31:26.692
EXPLAIN HOW FACEBOOK KNOWINGLY
07:31:26.759 --> 07:31:28.561
LEVERAGE THEIR PLATFORM TO
07:31:28.628 --> 07:31:29.996
PRIORITIES PROFITS ENGAGEMENT
07:31:30.062 --> 07:31:32.198
OVER CIVIC RESPONSIBILITY. THE
07:31:32.265 --> 07:31:33.833
FALLOUT OF JANUARY SIX ATTACK ON
07:31:33.900 --> 07:31:35.635
THE NATION'S CAPITAL THOUSANDS
07:31:35.701 --> 07:31:36.669
OF LEAKED INTERNAL DOCUMENTS
07:31:36.736 --> 07:31:37.970
PROVE THAT FACEBOOK PLAYED A
07:31:38.037 --> 07:31:39.205
LARGE PART IN SPREADING
07:31:39.272 --> 07:31:40.807
INFLAMMATORY MISINFORMATION
07:31:40.873 --> 07:31:42.375
ABOUT ELECTION FRAUD AND AIDED
07:31:42.442 --> 07:31:44.510
COMMUNICATION EFFORTS OF THE
07:31:44.577 --> 07:31:45.378
EXTREMIST MILITIA HEAD OF THE
07:31:45.445 --> 07:31:47.313
RIOTS. SOCIAL MEDIA IS ALSO A
07:31:47.380 --> 07:31:49.382
KEY DISTRIBUTOR PUBLIC HEALTH
07:31:49.449 --> 07:31:51.017
INFORMATION ACT ONE STUDY SHOWED
07:31:51.083 --> 07:31:52.552
THAT A MERE TWELVE PEOPLE UNDER
07:31:52.618 --> 07:31:53.886
SECEDED ORGANIZATIONS
07:31:53.953 --> 07:31:56.622
RESPONSIBLE 465% OF VACCINE
07:31:56.689 --> 07:31:57.790
MISINFORMATION ON TWITTER
07:31:57.857 --> 07:31:59.792
FACEBOOK AND INSTAGRAM POSING AN
07:31:59.859 --> 07:32:01.227
ENORMOUS DANGER TO PUBLIC
07:32:01.294 --> 07:32:02.895
HEALTH. IN FACT THE STUDY
07:32:02.962 --> 07:32:04.130
RECENTLY PUBLISHED IN THE
07:32:04.197 --> 07:32:05.264
SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL NATURE FOUND
07:32:05.331 --> 07:32:06.833
THAT ONLINE MISINFORMATION IS
07:32:06.899 --> 07:32:09.135
DIRECTLY LINKED TO COVER
07:32:09.202 --> 07:32:10.503
NINETEEN JACKSON HASN'T SEEN
07:32:10.570 --> 07:32:11.704
REFUSAL. MOST RECENTLY THIS
07:32:11.771 --> 07:32:12.705
COUNTRY HAS WITNESSED THE
07:32:12.772 --> 07:32:13.673
DESTRUCTIVE POWER OF
07:32:13.739 --> 07:32:14.874
MISINFORMATION AND RACIST
07:32:14.941 --> 07:32:16.709
CONTENT ON SOCIAL MEDIA AS
07:32:16.776 --> 07:32:18.211
EXEMPLIFIED BY THE BUFFALO
07:32:18.277 --> 07:32:19.879
GROCERY STORE SHOOTING. AND THE
07:32:19.946 --> 07:32:21.380
QUOTE NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL
07:32:21.447 --> 07:32:23.082
THE TISSUE JAMES THE TERROR
07:32:23.149 --> 07:32:25.418
ATTACK IN BUFFALO HAS ONCE AGAIN
07:32:25.485 --> 07:32:26.919
REVEALED THE DEPTHS AD DANGERS
07:32:26.986 --> 07:32:31.224
OF THE ONLINE. FORMS THAT SPREAD
07:32:31.290 --> 07:32:33.226
AND PROMOTE EIGHT. THIS CLEAR
07:32:33.292 --> 07:32:33.860
THAT THESE. HAVE SEPARATE. TO
07:32:33.926 --> 07:32:35.261
REINFORCE BIAS HATE AND
07:32:35.328 --> 07:32:35.661
MISINFORMATION AND
07:32:35.728 --> 07:32:37.563
PREFERENTIALLY AMPLIFY THAT. SO
07:32:37.630 --> 07:32:39.365
TRANSPARENCY IS ESSENTIAL IN
07:32:39.432 --> 07:32:41.300
UNDERSTANDING THE SOCIAL IMPACT
07:32:41.367 --> 07:32:43.669
OF THESE PLATFORMS THIS BILL
07:32:43.736 --> 07:32:45.071
WILL GIVE THE PUBLIC THE TOOLS
07:32:45.137 --> 07:32:47.840
WE NEED TO UNDERSTAND HOW SOCIAL
07:32:47.907 --> 07:32:48.875
MEDIA COMPANIES ARE IMPACTING
07:32:48.941 --> 07:32:51.244
OUR LIVES. SB TEN EIGHTEEN
07:32:51.310 --> 07:32:52.311
REQUIRES ONLINE SOCIAL MEDIA
07:32:52.378 --> 07:32:54.614
PLATFORMS TO MAKE ANY PUBLIC
07:32:54.680 --> 07:32:55.214
DISCLOSURES ABOUT THE CONTENT
07:32:55.281 --> 07:32:57.183
MODERATION EFFORTS THESE REPORTS
07:32:57.250 --> 07:32:58.784
INCLUDE STATISTICS ON THE ITEMS
07:32:58.851 --> 07:33:00.319
OF CONTENT THAT TH PLATFORM
07:33:00.386 --> 07:33:02.021
DETERMINE VIOLATED ITS POLICIES
07:33:02.088 --> 07:33:03.422
OFTEN THIS CONTENT WAS VIEWED
07:33:03.489 --> 07:33:05.424
AND TO THE EXTENT BY WHICH THE
07:33:05.491 --> 07:33:06.092
VIOLATING CONTENT WAS
07:33:06.158 --> 07:33:07.994
RECOMMENDED. AMPLIFIER IN
07:33:08.060 --> 07:33:10.129
IMPROVISED BY THE PLATFORM
07:33:10.196 --> 07:33:12.131
ALGORITHMS. SOCIAL MEDIA
07:33:12.198 --> 07:33:13.633
PLATFORMS HAVE TREMENDOUS POWER
07:33:13.699 --> 07:33:15.735
AFFECT WHAT WE SEE HOW WE FEEL
07:33:15.801 --> 07:33:18.437
WHAT WE BELIEVE. AND YET HOW THE
07:33:18.504 --> 07:33:20.439
OPERATE REMAINS EXTREMELY OKAY.
07:33:20.506 --> 07:33:22.074
I'LL MAKE NOTE THAT OF THE
07:33:22.141 --> 07:33:23.376
LEADING SOCIAL MEDIA COMPANIES
07:33:23.442 --> 07:33:25.011
ONE OF THEM A FACEBOOK
07:33:25.077 --> 07:33:26.045
ESSENTIALLY CONTROLLED BY ONE
07:33:26.112 --> 07:33:29.348
MAN. AND ANOTHER IS ABOUT TO BE
07:33:29.415 --> 07:33:30.182
TAKEN PRIVATE BY ANOTHER
07:33:30.249 --> 07:33:32.385
BILLIONAIRE. THESE COMPANIES ARE
07:33:32.451 --> 07:33:33.920
NOT ACCOUNTABLE TO THE PUBLIC IN
07:33:33.986 --> 07:33:35.454
FACT I'M NOT EVEN REALLY
07:33:35.521 --> 07:33:36.556
ACCOUNTABLE TO SHAREHOLDERS
07:33:36.622 --> 07:33:38.758
THEY'RE BEING SOLELY OUT OF
07:33:38.824 --> 07:33:40.893
CONTROL BY SINGLE PEOPLE. NOW I
07:33:40.960 --> 07:33:42.762
WANT TO THANK THE OPPOSITION FOR
07:33:42.828 --> 07:33:44.564
WORKING DILIGENTLY OFFICE I KNOW
07:33:44.630 --> 07:33:45.398
THAT THEY'RE STILL REVIEWING THE
07:33:45.464 --> 07:33:46.832
MOST RECENT AMENDMENTS. SHOULD
07:33:46.899 --> 07:33:48.200
THIS BILL MOVED TO THE ASSEMBLY
07:33:48.267 --> 07:33:49.101
OUTLOOK FOR THE CONTINUING
07:33:49.168 --> 07:33:50.703
PRODUCTIVE CONVERSATIONS SO THAT
07:33:50.770 --> 07:33:52.605
WE CAN HAVE MORE. AGAIN GREATER
07:33:52.672 --> 07:33:53.806
TRANSPARENCY GREATER
07:33:53.873 --> 07:33:54.407
UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT'S GOING
07:33:54.473 --> 07:33:57.343
ON. ULTIMATELY SB TEN EIGHTEEN
07:33:57.410 --> 07:33:59.312
THIS IS A NECESSARY STEP TO
07:33:59.378 --> 07:34:00.146
ENSURE TRANSPARENCY AND
07:34:00.212 --> 07:34:00.980
ACCOUNTABILITY IN THIS VERY
07:34:01.047 --> 07:34:02.148
POWERFUL AND BURGEONING
07:34:02.214 --> 07:34:05.651
INDUSTRY. AND ALSO IN TERMS OF
07:34:05.718 --> 07:34:06.652
US HAVING A BETTER UNDERSTANDING
07:34:06.719 --> 07:34:09.655
OF WHAT. IS PUT IN FRONT OF US.
07:34:09.722 --> 07:34:11.624
AND THE PUBLIC ART BY SOCIAL
07:34:11.691 --> 07:34:12.959
MEDIA COMPANIES WITH THAT I
07:34:13.025 --> 07:34:14.126
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
07:34:14.193 --> 07:34:15.528
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER PAN
07:34:15.595 --> 07:34:18.297
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
07:34:18.364 --> 07:34:20.232
SENATOR NIELSEN. MADAM PRESIDENT
07:34:20.299 --> 07:34:22.034
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN THE SENATE.
07:34:22.101 --> 07:34:23.970
THE GROUP GOT THIS A LITTLE
07:34:24.036 --> 07:34:26.539
BACKWARDS THE PROBLEM HERE. IS
07:34:26.606 --> 07:34:29.175
NOT AS MUCH I WOULD ARGUE OF
07:34:29.241 --> 07:34:31.043
WHOEVER'S READING THIS
07:34:31.110 --> 07:34:34.313
INFORMATION. AS A LARGE
07:34:34.380 --> 07:34:36.482
BILLIONAIRE COMPANIES. THE
07:34:36.549 --> 07:34:40.453
PROVIDERS THEY ARE THE ONES WHO
07:34:40.519 --> 07:34:41.854
DETERMINE CONTENT THEY'RE THE
07:34:41.921 --> 07:34:44.490
ONES WHO CLEARLY NOW ARE CENTURY
07:34:44.557 --> 07:34:47.960
. BLACKLISTING REMOVING FROM
07:34:48.027 --> 07:34:49.929
THEIR PLATFORMS THAT WILL IN
07:34:49.996 --> 07:34:51.931
DESIGNING THEIR OWN A LOGARITHMS
07:34:51.998 --> 07:34:54.934
ALGORITHMS. I THINK THAT'S A
07:34:55.001 --> 07:34:56.969
PART OF THE PROBLEM IF WE WANT
07:34:57.036 --> 07:34:58.204
TO ADDRESS THAT SIDE OF THE
07:34:58.270 --> 07:35:00.172
EQUATION THEN WE CAN AT LEAST
07:35:00.239 --> 07:35:02.141
I'LL HAVE A CONVERSATION. BUT
07:35:02.208 --> 07:35:05.444
SHORT OF THAT I LOOK AT THIS AS
07:35:05.511 --> 07:35:06.846
SOMETHING THAT IS NOT HELPFUL.
07:35:06.912 --> 07:35:10.082
TO THE PUBLIC TO THE PUBLIC
07:35:10.149 --> 07:35:12.852
THEY'RE GETTING FROZEN OUT. BY
07:35:12.918 --> 07:35:15.388
THESE QUOTES BILLIONAIRES WHO
07:35:15.454 --> 07:35:17.857
THINK THEY RULE THE WORLD NOW
07:35:17.923 --> 07:35:19.925
THE HIGH TECH COMPANIES SOME ARE
07:35:19.992 --> 07:35:23.963
GOOD. BUT THINK INCREASINGLY
07:35:24.030 --> 07:35:26.265
THEY'RE BECOMING PROBLEMATIC IN
07:35:26.332 --> 07:35:27.900
THE UNITED STATES AND
07:35:27.967 --> 07:35:30.936
PROBLEMATIC THE CITIZENS OF THIS
07:35:31.003 --> 07:35:33.673
COUNTRY I ORIGINAL THANK YOU
07:35:33.739 --> 07:35:37.309
SENATOR NELSON SENATOR MELINDA'S
07:35:37.376 --> 07:35:39.211
. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT- I
07:35:39.278 --> 07:35:41.147
HAVE A QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR
07:35:41.213 --> 07:35:42.548
CENTER PAN WE TAKE A QUESTION
07:35:42.615 --> 07:35:44.216
COURSE YES PLEASE PROCEED THANK
07:35:44.283 --> 07:35:46.919
YOU SO MUCH- I WILL POSE THE
07:35:46.986 --> 07:35:48.988
SAME QUESTION I POSED TO AN
07:35:49.055 --> 07:35:51.123
EARLIER AUTHOR WHICH IS FITTED
07:35:51.190 --> 07:35:52.525
CALIFORNIA DOESN'T REGULATE
07:35:52.591 --> 07:35:54.894
SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS SO HOW IS
07:35:54.960 --> 07:35:56.796
THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA GOING TO
07:35:56.862 --> 07:35:58.698
MAKE ANY SORT OF REQUIREMENT. ON
07:35:58.764 --> 07:36:00.232
THESE PLATFORMS WHEN THEY DON'T
07:36:00.299 --> 07:36:02.468
HAVE TO FOLLOW ANY RULES THAT WE
07:36:02.535 --> 07:36:04.804
SET WELL HARRIS COUNTY BUT THAT
07:36:04.870 --> 07:36:07.239
THANK YOU- WELL ACTUALLY- HERE
07:36:07.306 --> 07:36:08.741
TO STAY CALIFORNIA THINGS TO THE
07:36:08.808 --> 07:36:11.610
TENTH AMENDMENT- WE ACTUALLY ARE
07:36:11.677 --> 07:36:14.780
ABLE TO POLICE OF THINGS WITHIN
07:36:14.847 --> 07:36:16.582
OUR OWN TATE RIGHT THAT SAID IF
07:36:16.649 --> 07:36:18.117
YOU LOOK AT THE TENTH AMENDMENT
07:36:18.184 --> 07:36:20.486
OF THE CONSTITUTION. AND YEAH WE
07:36:20.553 --> 07:36:22.288
CAN SET THE RULES AND
07:36:22.354 --> 07:36:24.090
REGULATIONS AND LAWS TO PROTECT
07:36:24.156 --> 07:36:27.293
THE SAFETY OF THE PUBLIC AND- SO
07:36:27.359 --> 07:36:29.161
NOW THIS BILL IS MAINLY ABOUT
07:36:29.228 --> 07:36:31.130
TRANSPARENCY SO I AGAIN
07:36:31.197 --> 07:36:34.834
APPRECIATE- SOMETHING THAT IF WE
07:36:34.900 --> 07:36:36.535
WANT TO TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT'S
07:36:36.602 --> 07:36:38.804
GOING ON. BUT THIS BILL BECAUSE
07:36:38.871 --> 07:36:39.972
ON IS FOR THERE TO BE
07:36:40.039 --> 07:36:41.807
TRANSPARENCY CERTAINLY SOMEONE
07:36:41.874 --> 07:36:44.343
CAN IS I THINK THAT THE FROM A
07:36:44.410 --> 07:36:46.746
PRIOR SPEAKER ON THE PRIOR BILL
07:36:46.812 --> 07:36:47.913
SAID CERTAINLY AND WE CAN ALWAYS
07:36:47.980 --> 07:36:49.415
TAKE IT TO COURT AND SAY THAT
07:36:49.482 --> 07:36:51.150
THEY HAVE IT THEY THEY HAVE A
07:36:51.217 --> 07:36:52.485
DIFFERENT POINT OF VIEW- BUT
07:36:52.551 --> 07:36:54.487
AGAIN THIS BILL'S BEEN VETTED
07:36:54.553 --> 07:36:56.789
THROUGH OUR JUDICIARY COMMITTEE-
07:36:56.856 --> 07:36:58.324
THEY DID OUT AND OF A
07:36:58.390 --> 07:37:00.593
CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES. AND SO I
07:37:00.659 --> 07:37:02.795
BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL IS GOING
07:37:02.862 --> 07:37:05.131
TO MEET- THAT MUSTER CENTER
07:37:05.197 --> 07:37:07.733
BELINDA'S OKAY THANK YOU SO MUCH
07:37:07.800 --> 07:37:09.902
ONE OTHER QUESTION IF I MAY THE
07:37:09.969 --> 07:37:13.372
MOTION SIR PAN. YES THANK YOU-
07:37:13.439 --> 07:37:20.446
SO ONCE THE INFORMATION IS. IS
07:37:20.513 --> 07:37:21.280
POSTED IN PROVIDED. THE WHAT.
07:37:21.347 --> 07:37:23.115
WHAT SENATOR WHAT IS TO BE DONE
07:37:23.182 --> 07:37:24.583
WITH THAT SO ACTUALLY WHAT
07:37:24.650 --> 07:37:26.185
WHAT'S THE GOAL RIGHT WELL THE
07:37:26.252 --> 07:37:28.454
GOAL IS FOR US TO HAVE A BETTER
07:37:28.521 --> 07:37:29.655
UNDERSTANDING WHAT'S GOING ON IN
07:37:29.722 --> 07:37:32.124
SOCIAL MEDIA SO FOR EXAMPLE- MY
07:37:32.191 --> 07:37:33.592
GOOD FRIEND FROM TEN AM- BROUGHT
07:37:33.659 --> 07:37:35.060
UP THE ISSUE OF LIKE WELL WHAT A
07:37:35.127 --> 07:37:36.996
BILLION YEARS UP TO WHAT ONE
07:37:37.062 --> 07:37:38.764
THIRTY ALBUMS PUTTING IN FRONT
07:37:38.831 --> 07:37:40.733
OF US WHAT ARE THE THINGS THAT
07:37:40.800 --> 07:37:42.434
THEY ARE PUTTING FROM A SOMEWHAT
07:37:42.501 --> 07:37:43.068
DAY NOT PUTTING IN FRONT OF US
07:37:43.135 --> 07:37:45.070
RIGHT. SO WE WANT TO KNOW RIGHT
07:37:45.137 --> 07:37:47.072
NOW WHAT WE ARE DEPENDING ON AS
07:37:47.139 --> 07:37:47.506
WE'RE DEPENDING ON
07:37:47.573 --> 07:37:48.174
WHISTLEBLOWERS ATTALUS SO
07:37:48.240 --> 07:37:49.308
FACEBOOK ITSELF KNEW WHAT WAS
07:37:49.375 --> 07:37:51.110
DOING THEY WERE STUDYING IT BUT
07:37:51.177 --> 07:37:53.646
THE ONLY WAY WE THE PUBLIC CAN
07:37:53.712 --> 07:37:54.246
YOU WAS BECAUSE OF WHAT THE
07:37:54.313 --> 07:37:56.949
FIFTH WHISTLE BLOWER VANCE TOLD
07:37:57.016 --> 07:37:58.751
US WHAT THEY HAD AN INTERNAL
07:37:58.818 --> 07:38:01.587
FILES. SO BY CREATING THIS
07:38:01.654 --> 07:38:05.324
INCREASE TRANSPARENCY. THAT
07:38:05.391 --> 07:38:06.458
ALLOWS US THE PUBLIC. THE PUBLIC
07:38:06.525 --> 07:38:07.827
MAY COMMUNICATE WITH US AS
07:38:07.893 --> 07:38:09.328
LEGISLATORS AND SAY YOU KNOW
07:38:09.395 --> 07:38:11.096
WHAT. MAYBE THINGS ARE NOT RIGHT
07:38:11.163 --> 07:38:13.899
AND WE SHOULD. ACT AND ON THIS
07:38:13.966 --> 07:38:15.501
INFORMATION RIGHT. NOW THAT WE
07:38:15.568 --> 07:38:16.836
HAVE ACCURATE INFORMATION WHAT'S
07:38:16.902 --> 07:38:18.604
GOING ON THESE PLATFORMS. FOR
07:38:18.671 --> 07:38:20.005
EXAMPLE I KNOW WHERE THE
07:38:20.072 --> 07:38:22.208
CONCERNS IS THAT IS THERE. IS
07:38:22.274 --> 07:38:24.543
THERE BIAS IN IN IN WHAT IN HOW
07:38:24.610 --> 07:38:26.745
THE ISLAND'S WORK RIGHT. SO LET
07:38:26.812 --> 07:38:28.280
NOW WE'D BE ABLE TO IDENTIFY IS
07:38:28.347 --> 07:38:30.683
OUR BIAS OR NOT RIGHT NOW WE- SO
07:38:30.749 --> 07:38:31.884
FOR EXAMPLE WITHOUT TRANSPARENCY
07:38:31.951 --> 07:38:33.385
WE CAN ONLY SPECULATE. WE COULD
07:38:33.452 --> 07:38:34.820
SAY WELL BASED ON WHAT I'M
07:38:34.887 --> 07:38:36.222
SEEING MY FEET I THINK THAT THIS
07:38:36.288 --> 07:38:38.123
COMPANY IS BIASED. YOU KNOW
07:38:38.190 --> 07:38:41.360
AGAINST THE- CONSERVATIVES ORDER
07:38:41.427 --> 07:38:42.361
BIAS AGAINST WHATEVER IT ALSO.
07:38:42.428 --> 07:38:44.263
WITHOUT WITH TRANSPARENCY WE CAN
07:38:44.330 --> 07:38:46.565
SAY OKAY LET'S MAKE GOOD POLICY
07:38:46.632 --> 07:38:49.101
BASED ON FACTS. LET'S BASE IT ON
07:38:49.168 --> 07:38:51.337
INFORMATION ACCURATE INFORMATION
07:38:51.403 --> 07:38:52.805
THAT WE HAVE. AND THAT'S WHY
07:38:52.872 --> 07:38:54.306
THIS BILL SO IMPORTANT SO WE CAN
07:38:54.373 --> 07:38:55.241
ACTUALLY HAVE AN UNDERSTANDING
07:38:55.307 --> 07:38:57.042
AND THEN WE CAN HAVE THAT DEBATE
07:38:57.109 --> 07:38:58.844
OF IDEAS BECAUSE THIS IS NOT
07:38:58.911 --> 07:39:00.746
ABOUT CONTENT MODERATION IS
07:39:00.813 --> 07:39:01.513
ABOUT UNDERSTANDING. THE
07:39:01.580 --> 07:39:04.483
AMPLIFICATION AND REACH. THANK
07:39:04.550 --> 07:39:05.818
YOU CENTER PANTS AND OLYMPUS
07:39:05.885 --> 07:39:08.320
THANK YOU SO MUCH- OKAY SO NOW
07:39:08.387 --> 07:39:11.457
I'M EVEN MORE CONFUSED- THOUGH I
07:39:11.523 --> 07:39:13.792
APPRECIATE YOUR YOUR-
07:39:13.859 --> 07:39:14.627
THOUGHTFULNESS IN TRYING TO
07:39:14.693 --> 07:39:17.029
CLARIFY BUT THE BILL TALKS
07:39:17.096 --> 07:39:20.866
ABOUT- MAKING SURE THE PUBLIC
07:39:20.933 --> 07:39:23.202
KNOWS ABOUT. PEOPLE CALL THE
07:39:23.269 --> 07:39:25.170
CONTENT VIOLATING THE PLATFORM'S
07:39:25.237 --> 07:39:27.072
POLICY IT DOESN'T SAY ANYTHING
07:39:27.139 --> 07:39:29.141
ABOUT ALGORITHMS OR
07:39:29.208 --> 07:39:30.643
MISINFORMATION OR ANYTHING LIKE
07:39:30.709 --> 07:39:32.244
THAT IT'S TALKING ABOUT
07:39:32.311 --> 07:39:34.246
VIOLATING THE PLATFORM'S
07:39:34.313 --> 07:39:37.549
POLICIES SO I'M STILL LEFT TO
07:39:37.616 --> 07:39:40.619
WONDER IF YOU. TRY IN OUR
07:39:40.686 --> 07:39:42.154
SUCCESSFUL TO FORCE THE TECH
07:39:42.221 --> 07:39:44.323
COMPANY A SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORM
07:39:44.390 --> 07:39:46.525
TO POST EVER YOU KNOW THE
07:39:46.592 --> 07:39:49.228
PERCENTAGES OF WHEN. THEIR THEIR
07:39:49.295 --> 07:39:51.363
PLATFORM POLICIES WERE VIOLATED
07:39:51.430 --> 07:39:55.567
OKAY SO 12% OF THE TIME SO AND
07:39:55.634 --> 07:39:58.570
I'M- 12% OF THE TIME FOR THE
07:39:58.637 --> 07:40:02.441
YEAR TWENTY TWENTY TWO- NEAR THE
07:40:02.508 --> 07:40:03.676
PLATFORM'S POLICIES WERE
07:40:03.742 --> 07:40:07.046
VIOLATED OKAY. AND THEN WHAT
07:40:07.112 --> 07:40:09.481
SENATE AGAIN WHAT. THE ARGUMENT
07:40:09.548 --> 07:40:11.884
AT ALL SO NO. NO NOT A QUESTION
07:40:11.951 --> 07:40:12.985
I'M SORRY IT'S KIND OF
07:40:13.052 --> 07:40:14.253
RHETORICAL I MEAN I THINK HE
07:40:14.320 --> 07:40:16.055
TRIED TO ANSWER THAT ALREADY
07:40:16.121 --> 07:40:17.256
EARLIER BUT I'M JUST MAKING THE
07:40:17.323 --> 07:40:19.158
POINT THAT I JUST DON'T KNOW.
07:40:19.224 --> 07:40:21.327
WHAT EXACTLY IS THE STATE OF
07:40:21.393 --> 07:40:23.862
CALIFORNIA GOING TO DO THAT I
07:40:23.929 --> 07:40:25.898
MEAN IF THE BILL IS ABOUT. AGAIN
07:40:25.965 --> 07:40:28.267
WHICH IS WHAT I'M READING ABOUT.
07:40:28.334 --> 07:40:29.635
THE PLATFORM ALLOWING ITS OWN
07:40:29.702 --> 07:40:31.370
POLICIES TO BE VIOLATED AND THEN
07:40:31.437 --> 07:40:33.339
NOTIFYING THE PUBLIC OF WHEN
07:40:33.405 --> 07:40:35.674
THAT HAPPENS. I JUST DON'T
07:40:35.741 --> 07:40:37.576
UNDERSTAND THE POINT AND IN I
07:40:37.643 --> 07:40:39.378
WILL ADD TO THAT BUT I STILL
07:40:39.445 --> 07:40:40.479
DON'T THINK THAT WE HAVE
07:40:40.546 --> 07:40:42.114
JURISDICTION ON THE TENTH
07:40:42.181 --> 07:40:43.983
AMENDMENT OR NINE DAYS THESE
07:40:44.049 --> 07:40:45.751
THESE COMPANIES YOUR MANY
07:40:45.818 --> 07:40:47.386
THEY'RE NOT CALIFORNIA BASED
07:40:47.453 --> 07:40:48.954
COMPANIES WE HAVE NO AUTHORITY
07:40:49.021 --> 07:40:50.789
OVER THEM SOME OF THEM MAYBE.
07:40:50.856 --> 07:40:52.157
THESE CERTAINLY AREN'T ALL AND I
07:40:52.224 --> 07:40:54.093
JUST DON'T SEE HOW A COURT IS
07:40:54.159 --> 07:40:55.861
GOING TO RULE IN OUR FAVOR IN
07:40:55.928 --> 07:40:57.596
SAY YES CALIFORNIA YOU CAN
07:40:57.663 --> 07:41:00.065
REGULATE IN YOU CAN DEMAND THAT
07:41:00.132 --> 07:41:01.667
THESE PLATFORMS PROVIDE YOU WITH
07:41:01.734 --> 07:41:03.369
THE INFORMATION THAT YOU ARE
07:41:03.435 --> 07:41:04.903
SEEKING SO WITH THAT I WOULD
07:41:04.970 --> 07:41:05.971
ENCOURAGE YOU KNOW THAT THANK
07:41:06.038 --> 07:41:07.706
YOU. THANK YOU SEEN NO FURTHER
07:41:07.773 --> 07:41:09.641
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SENATOR PAM
07:41:09.708 --> 07:41:12.011
WHICH LIKE TO CLOSE YES- FIRST
07:41:12.077 --> 07:41:13.712
OF ALL I POINT OUT THAT- WE
07:41:13.779 --> 07:41:15.614
REGULATE MANY THINGS HERE TO
07:41:15.681 --> 07:41:17.282
PROTECT THE HEALTH AND SAFETY OF
07:41:17.349 --> 07:41:18.884
CALIFORNIANS- INCLUDING FROM
07:41:18.951 --> 07:41:20.386
COMPANIES THAT NOT AREN'T IN OUR
07:41:20.452 --> 07:41:23.655
STATE- WE ARE WE UNDER TENSE
07:41:23.722 --> 07:41:25.024
MOMENT WE DO ALL WE CAN
07:41:25.090 --> 07:41:27.659
ESTABLISH STANDARDS- I WOULD
07:41:27.726 --> 07:41:31.430
ALSO POINT OUT THAT. WHEN MY-
07:41:31.497 --> 07:41:33.065
GOOD FRIEND THE- THAT WELL WHAT
07:41:33.132 --> 07:41:34.900
WE DO ABOUT WE JUST GIVE YOU AN
07:41:34.967 --> 07:41:36.769
EXAMPLE ACTUALLY- CNN REPORT ON
07:41:36.835 --> 07:41:39.204
THIS- ACTUALLY INDEMNIFIED
07:41:39.271 --> 07:41:41.740
SEVERAL POSTS. ON FACEBOOK IN
07:41:41.807 --> 07:41:45.310
WHICH- AHRENDTS. PARENTS OF
07:41:45.377 --> 07:41:47.112
CHILDREN WHO IN FOURTEEN HAVE
07:41:47.179 --> 07:41:48.447
DIED OF A PREVENTABLE DISEASE
07:41:48.514 --> 07:41:51.183
WERE HARASSED AND WENT TO
07:41:51.250 --> 07:41:53.685
FACEBOOK AND SAID VIOLATED THESE
07:41:53.752 --> 07:41:54.653
VALLEY COMMUNITY STANDARDS OF
07:41:54.720 --> 07:41:57.089
FACEBOOK SAID YES. AND THEN
07:41:57.156 --> 07:41:58.357
CHECK NINE MONTHS LATER WHAT
07:41:58.424 --> 07:41:59.892
HAPPENED AND FOUND OUT THE
07:41:59.958 --> 07:42:01.727
COMPANY DID NOTHING ABOUT IT AND
07:42:01.794 --> 07:42:04.663
THEN THAT THEN LEADS TO- PUSH
07:42:04.730 --> 07:42:06.298
BACK ON FACEBOOK ABOUT WHY ARE
07:42:06.365 --> 07:42:09.468
YOU NOT BY YOU KNOW AND- IT.
07:42:09.535 --> 07:42:10.903
BASICALLY FORCING THE COULD
07:42:10.969 --> 07:42:12.538
STANDARD BY WAY THAT YOU
07:42:12.604 --> 07:42:13.505
YOURSELF ESTABLISHED I WOULD
07:42:13.572 --> 07:42:16.008
ALSO POINT OUT THAT SO I THINK
07:42:16.075 --> 07:42:18.010
THAT KIND OF TRANSPARENCY IS
07:42:18.077 --> 07:42:18.977
IMPORTANT- THAT'S HOLDING THE
07:42:19.044 --> 07:42:20.512
COMPANIES ACCOUNTABLE INTEREST
07:42:20.579 --> 07:42:22.614
ENOUGH EVEN FOR THEIR OWN
07:42:22.681 --> 07:42:23.148
STANDARDS- THIS IS ENOUGH
07:42:23.215 --> 07:42:25.117
FACEBOOK ITSELF ESTABLISHED.
07:42:25.184 --> 07:42:26.485
OVERSIGHT BOARD WHICH OF COURSE
07:42:26.552 --> 07:42:28.053
IT TURNS OUT THE OVERSIGHT BOARD
07:42:28.120 --> 07:42:29.421
IS NOW COMPLAINING THAT FACEBOOK
07:42:29.488 --> 07:42:30.789
IS ENSURING THAT DATA WITH THEM
07:42:30.856 --> 07:42:32.291
FOR THEM TO BE AUDITED JOBS OR
07:42:32.357 --> 07:42:33.492
EVEN FACEBOOK ITSELF ADMITTED
07:42:33.559 --> 07:42:35.828
THAT NEED TO HAVE AN OVERSIGHT
07:42:35.894 --> 07:42:37.029
BOARD- THEMSELVES- THE
07:42:37.096 --> 07:42:39.431
ESTABLISHED ONE- AND ALSO THIS
07:42:39.498 --> 07:42:41.266
BILL DOES ADDRESS IMPLICATION AS
07:42:41.333 --> 07:42:42.835
WELL AND I THINK AMPLIFICATIONS
07:42:42.901 --> 07:42:43.569
OF PARTICULAR IMPORTANT PART
07:42:43.635 --> 07:42:44.436
BECAUSE AFTER ALL WE'RE NOT
07:42:44.503 --> 07:42:46.972
ABOUT TRYING TO. REGULATE SPEECH
07:42:47.039 --> 07:42:49.908
IT'S ABOUT REACH AND- AND TRYING
07:42:49.975 --> 07:42:51.376
TO PREVENT THE SPREAD OF
07:42:51.443 --> 07:42:52.611
MISINFORMATION AND HATE BUT
07:42:52.678 --> 07:42:54.046
WITHOUT TRANSPARENCY WE DON'T
07:42:54.113 --> 07:42:56.048
KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON. AND THAT'S
07:42:56.115 --> 07:42:57.950
IMPORTANT FOR US TO BE ABLE TO
07:42:58.016 --> 07:42:59.151
UNDERSTAND THIS POLICYMAKERS WE
07:42:59.218 --> 07:43:00.886
CAN MAKE SOUND POLICIES AND WITH
07:43:00.953 --> 07:43:01.987
THAT RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
07:43:02.054 --> 07:43:04.656
VOTE TOO AGAIN PROTECT OUR
07:43:04.723 --> 07:43:05.491
DEMOCRACY AND PROTECT THE PEOPLE
07:43:05.557 --> 07:43:11.063
OF CALIFORNIA. THANK YOU CENTER. PAN MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
07:43:11.130 --> 07:43:12.965
CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
07:43:13.031 --> 07:43:17.169
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
07:43:17.236 --> 07:43:23.008
NO BAKER. I FOR JUST NO BRADFORD
07:43:23.075 --> 07:43:29.114
ICON BY OTHER. CORTESE I DALY NO
07:43:29.181 --> 07:43:34.153
DODD AYE TORONTO AYE EGGMAN. I
07:43:34.219 --> 07:43:42.628
GLAZER. GONZALEZ I GROVE NO
07:43:42.694 --> 07:43:46.465
HERTZBERG HUESO AYE FURTADO AYE
07:43:46.532 --> 07:43:51.937
JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
07:43:52.004 --> 07:43:56.575
LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE MCGUIRE. I
07:43:56.642 --> 07:43:59.945
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
07:44:00.012 --> 07:44:05.117
NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF BOTH NO PAN
07:44:05.184 --> 07:44:16.094
AYE PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO. SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
07:44:16.161 --> 07:44:19.865
AYE FORECASTING I WIENER AYE
07:44:19.932 --> 07:44:22.768
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
07:44:22.834 --> 07:44:29.007
MEMBERS CABALLERO I. GLAZER I
07:44:29.074 --> 07:44:33.779
HERTZBERG RUBIO HI IS THIRTY
07:44:33.845 --> 07:44:35.414
NEWS NINE THE MEASURE PASSES
07:44:35.480 --> 07:44:37.549
MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM
07:44:37.616 --> 07:44:39.151
EIGHTY FOUR SENATOR PAN MADAM
07:44:39.218 --> 07:44:41.119
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
07:44:41.186 --> 07:44:43.255
BILL TEN NINETY SEVEN BY SENATOR
07:44:43.322 --> 07:44:45.090
PAN AN ACT RELATING TO CANNABIS
07:44:45.157 --> 07:44:46.425
CENTER PAM THANK YOU MADAM
07:44:46.491 --> 07:44:48.427
PRESIDENT SENATORS SAY ALSO
07:44:48.493 --> 07:44:50.429
PLEASED TO PRESENT SB TEN NINETY
07:44:50.495 --> 07:44:52.064
SEVEN THE CANNABIS RIGHT TO KNOW
07:44:52.130 --> 07:44:53.432
ACT SB TO NINETY CENTS ABOUT
07:44:53.498 --> 07:44:55.000
CONSUMER SAFETY IN PARTICULAR
07:44:55.067 --> 07:44:56.802
SAFETY FOR TEENS AND ADULTS AND
07:44:56.868 --> 07:44:58.437
INFANTS DURING PREGNANCY. THE
07:44:58.503 --> 07:44:59.738
BRAINS ARE STILL DEVELOPING THIS
07:44:59.805 --> 07:45:01.006
CLEAR SIGNS THAT CANNABIS CAN
07:45:01.073 --> 07:45:02.975
HAVE LONG TERM DAMAGING EFFECTS
07:45:03.041 --> 07:45:04.276
THE MEASURES BASED ON THE MOST
07:45:04.343 --> 07:45:05.877
RECENT SCIENCE ABOUT THE HEALTH
07:45:05.944 --> 07:45:06.912
RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH CANNABIS
07:45:06.979 --> 07:45:08.480
USE IN THREE DIFFERENT WAYS
07:45:08.547 --> 07:45:09.815
FIRST A REQUIRES RETAILERS
07:45:09.881 --> 07:45:11.683
PROVIDE FIRST TIME CONSUMERS
07:45:11.750 --> 07:45:12.985
WITH A SCIENCE BASED. SINGLE
07:45:13.051 --> 07:45:14.620
PAGE BROCHURE WITH SIMPLE STEPS
07:45:14.686 --> 07:45:16.688
FOR SAFER USE SECOND REQUIRES A
07:45:16.755 --> 07:45:18.056
ROTATING HEALTH WARNING LABEL
07:45:18.123 --> 07:45:19.424
INTERCHANGE CONSUMERS TO BUY
07:45:19.491 --> 07:45:21.326
LEGAL PRODUCTS EXPLAINING THE
07:45:21.393 --> 07:45:23.495
HAZARDS OF ILLICIT CANNABIS AND
07:45:23.562 --> 07:45:24.730
THIRD IT REQUIRES A ROTATING
07:45:24.796 --> 07:45:26.665
PICTORIAL HEALTH WARNING LABEL
07:45:26.732 --> 07:45:27.799
AND A MORE PROMINENT POSITION
07:45:27.866 --> 07:45:29.268
THIS BILL ALSO SPECIFIES THAT
07:45:29.334 --> 07:45:31.203
THAT THERE ARE ROTATING MESSAGES
07:45:31.270 --> 07:45:32.638
DESIGNED FOR CERTAIN PRODUCT
07:45:32.704 --> 07:45:33.772
CATEGORIES. RESEARCHERS SHOW
07:45:33.839 --> 07:45:35.140
THAT SMOKERS WHO NOTICED
07:45:35.207 --> 07:45:36.208
WARNINGS HAVE AN INCREASE
07:45:36.275 --> 07:45:38.210
KNOWLEDGE OF HEALTH RISKS FIFTY
07:45:38.277 --> 07:45:39.811
FOUR STUDIES ON THE BACK OF THE
07:45:39.878 --> 07:45:41.213
VAN THAT STRENGTHENED WARNINGS
07:45:41.280 --> 07:45:41.847
WITH ENHANCED TEXTURE PICTURES
07:45:41.913 --> 07:45:42.981
ASSOCIATE WITH INCREASED
07:45:43.048 --> 07:45:44.716
KNOWLEDGE MORE CALLS TO QUIT
07:45:44.783 --> 07:45:46.451
LINE REDUCTION SMOKING BEHAVIOR.
07:45:46.518 --> 07:45:48.520
THE LABELING STANDARDS IN SB TEN
07:45:48.587 --> 07:45:49.354
NINETY SEVEN ALREADY IN USE IN
07:45:49.421 --> 07:45:51.290
CANADA AND THE LINE WAS SIMILAR
07:45:51.356 --> 07:45:52.491
INCOMING FDA APPROVED AND
07:45:52.557 --> 07:45:53.558
COMMERCIALLY MANDATED TOBACCO
07:45:53.625 --> 07:45:55.494
LABELLING STANDARDS THE LABELING
07:45:55.560 --> 07:45:59.798
REQUIREMENTS ARE BASED. ON WHAT
07:45:59.865 --> 07:46:00.399
SCIENCE SHOWS TO BE AFFECTED.
07:46:00.465 --> 07:46:01.833
SCIENTIFIC UNDER CAN'T HAS GROWN
07:46:01.900 --> 07:46:03.468
SIGNIFICANTLY SINCE THE PASSAGE
07:46:03.535 --> 07:46:04.336
OF PROP SIXTY FOUR IN THE NEED
07:46:04.403 --> 07:46:05.971
FOR SUPPLEMENTAL ABLE TO
07:46:06.038 --> 07:46:07.606
ACCOMPANY THE EXISTING ONE HAS
07:46:07.673 --> 07:46:08.240
BECOME APPARENT. WE ARE IN THE
07:46:08.307 --> 07:46:10.275
MIDST OF A MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS
07:46:10.342 --> 07:46:10.876
AND UNFORTUNATELY MANY PEOPLE
07:46:10.942 --> 07:46:12.477
ARE UNDER THE FALSE IMPRESSION
07:46:12.544 --> 07:46:13.712
THAT CANNABIS IS AN EFFECTIVE
07:46:13.779 --> 07:46:14.613
TREATMENT FOR THAT. CURRENT
07:46:14.680 --> 07:46:15.914
SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE SHOWS THAT
07:46:15.981 --> 07:46:18.016
CANNABIS CONSUMPTION. MAY HAVE
07:46:18.083 --> 07:46:19.151
THE PARTICULAR FOR USE A
07:46:19.217 --> 07:46:20.285
NEGATIVE IMPACT ON MENTAL
07:46:20.352 --> 07:46:22.621
HEALTH. AND THEREFORE THE
07:46:22.688 --> 07:46:24.423
IMPORTANCE OF THE WARNINGS. SOME
07:46:24.489 --> 07:46:25.791
PEOPLE IN THE INDUSTRY MAY TELL
07:46:25.857 --> 07:46:27.426
YOU THAT IT'S TOO EXPENSIVE OR
07:46:27.492 --> 07:46:28.860
PLAY IN THE HANDS OF THE
07:46:28.927 --> 07:46:30.262
LITTLEST AT MARKET HAVE LABELS
07:46:30.329 --> 07:46:31.630
BEEN EITHER THESE ARE ACCURATE.
07:46:31.697 --> 07:46:33.165
MANUFACTURES REGULARLY REPRINTED
07:46:33.231 --> 07:46:35.100
UPDATER PACKAGING. THE PROPOSAL
07:46:35.167 --> 07:46:36.568
IS ALSO BEEN AMENDED TO ENSURE
07:46:36.635 --> 07:46:38.203
THAT THERE'S NO NEED TO USE
07:46:38.270 --> 07:46:38.937
LARGER PACKAGING SO THERE'S NO
07:46:39.004 --> 07:46:40.906
ADDITIONAL COST. WE ALSO
07:46:40.972 --> 07:46:41.873
SUBSTANTIALLY REDUCE THE AMOUNT
07:46:41.940 --> 07:46:43.175
OF PAPER BEING HANDED OUT BY
07:46:43.241 --> 07:46:46.378
REDUCING THE FOCUS ON THE C. FOR
07:46:46.445 --> 07:46:48.080
YOU SHE TO NEW CUSTOMERS. SB TEN
07:46:48.146 --> 07:46:49.114
NINETY SEVEN HELPS BETTER
07:46:49.181 --> 07:46:50.749
INFORMED CONSUMERS OF SAFE AND
07:46:50.816 --> 07:46:52.317
LEGAL CANNABIS PRODUCTS AND
07:46:52.384 --> 07:46:54.419
THAT'S WHY I'M JOINED BY MY
07:46:54.486 --> 07:46:55.287
FELLOW PEDIATRICIANS IN AMERICAN
07:46:55.354 --> 07:46:56.822
COUNTY ADVERTS. AMERICAN COLLEGE
07:46:56.888 --> 07:46:58.390
OF EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS THE
07:46:58.457 --> 07:46:59.791
CALIFORNIA SOCIETY OF ADDICTION
07:46:59.858 --> 07:47:01.426
MEDICINE AND THE COUNTY
07:47:01.493 --> 07:47:03.128
BEHAVIORAL HEALTH DIRECTORS. AND
07:47:03.195 --> 07:47:04.229
A HOST OF OTHER ORGANIZATIONS
07:47:04.296 --> 07:47:05.664
AROUND THE STATE THE PROPOSAL
07:47:05.731 --> 07:47:06.932
THE SIMPLE INEXPENSIVE
07:47:06.998 --> 07:47:08.166
INFORMATION THAT SHOULD BE PART
07:47:08.233 --> 07:47:11.903
OF THE CITY FOR LEGAL CANNABIS
07:47:11.970 --> 07:47:12.504
MARKET EXPECT THE OSCAR NIGHT
07:47:12.571 --> 07:47:13.872
OF. THANK YOU CENTER PAN MEMBERS
07:47:13.939 --> 07:47:16.108
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
07:47:16.174 --> 07:47:17.109
HEARING NONE MADAM SECRETARY
07:47:17.175 --> 07:47:20.579
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
07:47:20.645 --> 07:47:24.182
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES.
07:47:24.249 --> 07:47:29.888
BAKER I FORTUS BRADFORD.
07:47:29.955 --> 07:47:37.028
CABALLERO CORTESE I DALY. DODD
07:47:37.095 --> 07:47:42.768
DORADO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
07:47:42.834 --> 07:47:46.104
GONZALEZ I GROW. HERTZBERG YES
07:47:46.171 --> 07:47:52.277
SIR. HI HURTADO I JONES.
07:47:52.344 --> 07:47:57.582
KAMLAGER LAYERED I LEYVA AYE THE
07:47:57.649 --> 07:48:05.457
MON. MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ MAN I
07:48:05.524 --> 07:48:10.996
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE
07:48:11.062 --> 07:48:15.667
. PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH.
07:48:15.734 --> 07:48:22.140
RUBIO FIVE SKINNER. I'VE STERN
07:48:22.207 --> 07:48:25.043
HI I'M BURKE HI MY COUNTY. I
07:48:25.110 --> 07:48:30.382
WIENER NO WILK. NO PLEASE CALL
07:48:30.449 --> 07:48:35.086
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. FAITH FOR
07:48:35.153 --> 07:48:41.993
JUST. BRADFORD. CABALLERO I
07:48:42.060 --> 07:48:49.234
DALLY. DODD GROWTH HERTZBERG
07:48:49.301 --> 07:48:56.741
JONES. KAMLAGER LIMÓN MELENDEZ
07:48:56.808 --> 07:49:04.349
NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE I. ROTH
07:49:04.416 --> 07:49:05.617
DID SOMEONE WANT TO CHANGE THEIR
07:49:05.684 --> 07:49:10.956
VOTE. NEWMAN ALL RIGHT TO KNOW.
07:49:11.022 --> 07:49:32.377
THE MON I. LIMÓN HI.
07:49:32.444 --> 07:49:34.379
CAN YOU PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
07:49:34.446 --> 07:49:37.048
MEMBERS ONE MORE TIME. FAITH FOR
07:49:37.115 --> 07:49:44.723
JUST. BRADFORD DALLY. DODD
07:49:44.789 --> 07:49:51.930
GROWTH. HERTZBERG JONES KAMLAGER
07:49:51.997 --> 07:50:14.920
. MELENDEZ NIELSEN. ROTH.
07:50:29.467 --> 07:50:31.336
THANK YOU VERY MUCH IS TWENTY
07:50:31.403 --> 07:50:32.170
FIVE KNOWS THREE THE MEASURE
07:50:32.237 --> 07:50:34.005
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING TO
07:50:34.072 --> 07:50:36.641
FILE ITEM EIGHTY FIVE CENTER
07:50:36.708 --> 07:50:38.877
DODD MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
07:50:38.944 --> 07:50:41.112
. SENATE BILL ELEVEN OH SEVEN BY
07:50:41.179 --> 07:50:42.414
SENATOR DODD AN ACT RELATING TO
07:50:42.480 --> 07:50:44.082
VEHICLES SENATE DODD BETTER
07:50:44.149 --> 07:50:47.686
PRESENT MEMBERS- S. B. ELEVEN OH
07:50:47.752 --> 07:50:48.320
SEVEN WILL HELP PROTECT
07:50:48.386 --> 07:50:50.188
CALIFORNIA DRIVERS AND ANYONE
07:50:50.255 --> 07:50:52.090
WHO WAS INJURED IN A CAR CRASH.
07:50:52.157 --> 07:50:53.525
BY MODERNIZING CALIFORNIA'S
07:50:53.592 --> 07:50:56.061
OUTDATED MINIMUM AUTO LIABILITY
07:50:56.127 --> 07:50:58.296
COVERAGE LIMITS WHAT EVERY STATE
07:50:58.363 --> 07:51:00.031
IN THE COUNTRYREQUIRES DRIVERS
07:51:00.098 --> 07:51:02.067
TO PURCHASE AUTO INSURANCE IN
07:51:02.133 --> 07:51:03.602
ORDER TO PROVIDE PROTECTION.
07:51:03.668 --> 07:51:05.670
CALIFORNIA HAS FALLEN
07:51:05.737 --> 07:51:07.238
DANGEROUSLY BEHIND IN PROTECTING
07:51:07.305 --> 07:51:09.975
OUR CITIZENS FIFTY FIVE YEARS
07:51:10.041 --> 07:51:11.776
AGO IN NINETEEN SIXTY SEVEN
07:51:11.843 --> 07:51:13.378
CALIFORNIA CENTER MANDATORY AUTO
07:51:13.445 --> 07:51:16.781
INSURANCE LIABILITY MINIMUMS AT
07:51:16.848 --> 07:51:17.349
FIFTEEN THOUSAND FOUR SINGLE
07:51:17.415 --> 07:51:20.251
INJURY OR DEATH. THIRTY THOUSAND
07:51:20.318 --> 07:51:22.954
FOR IT FOR INJURY TO OR DEATH OF
07:51:23.021 --> 07:51:26.424
MORE THAN ONE PERSON AND FIVE
07:51:26.491 --> 07:51:27.125
THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR PROPERTY
07:51:27.192 --> 07:51:29.394
DAMAGE. THE LIABILITY LIMITS
07:51:29.461 --> 07:51:31.429
ABOUT DIGESTED SINCE LEAVING
07:51:31.496 --> 07:51:33.264
CALIFORNIA THE BOTTOM OF THREE
07:51:33.331 --> 07:51:34.766
STATES WITH THE LOWEST LEVELS OF
07:51:34.833 --> 07:51:37.502
PROTECTION IN THE NATION. IN
07:51:37.569 --> 07:51:38.203
NINETEEN SIXTY SEVEN THE COST
07:51:38.269 --> 07:51:40.572
FOR A NEW FORD MUSTANG WAS
07:51:40.639 --> 07:51:41.539
TWENTY TWO HUNDRED DOLLARS TODAY
07:51:41.606 --> 07:51:43.808
NEW MUSTANG WOULD COST IN EXCESS
07:51:43.875 --> 07:51:46.544
OF THIRTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
07:51:46.611 --> 07:51:47.212
IN NINETEEN SIXTY SEVEN A DAY IN
07:51:47.278 --> 07:51:49.214
THE HOSPITAL. WOULD BE NINETY
07:51:49.280 --> 07:51:52.150
TWO DOLLARS IN TODAY IT'S OVER
07:51:52.217 --> 07:51:54.185
THIRTY SEVEN HUNDRED DOLLARS PER
07:51:54.252 --> 07:51:55.520
SE. A DRIVER MUST BE CAPABLE OF
07:51:55.587 --> 07:51:57.322
PROVIDING THE COMPENSATION
07:51:57.389 --> 07:51:58.590
NECESSARY TO MAKE AN INTRAPARTY
07:51:58.657 --> 07:52:01.426
WHOLE AGAIN IT IS CLEAR THAT THE
07:52:01.493 --> 07:52:02.260
CURRENT MINIMUM MODEL LIMITS
07:52:02.327 --> 07:52:04.863
CALIFORNIA ARE FAR TOO LOW TO
07:52:04.929 --> 07:52:07.132
ACCOMPLISH THAT. AND WE ARE WELL
07:52:07.198 --> 07:52:09.834
OVERDUE FOR AN INCREASE S. B.
07:52:09.901 --> 07:52:11.169
ELEVEN OH SEVEN WOULD MODERNIZE
07:52:11.236 --> 07:52:12.303
THE NATURE RESPONSIBILITY
07:52:12.370 --> 07:52:14.406
LIMITS. TO THIRTY THOUSAND
07:52:14.472 --> 07:52:16.141
DOLLARS FOR SINGLE INJURY OR
07:52:16.207 --> 07:52:17.308
DEATH SIXTY THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR
07:52:17.375 --> 07:52:20.311
INJURY OR DEATH OF MORE THAN ONE
07:52:20.378 --> 07:52:23.181
PERSON. AND IT HAS TO BE AMENDED
07:52:23.248 --> 07:52:23.982
FIFTEEN THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR
07:52:24.049 --> 07:52:28.053
PROPERTY DAMAGE. A SIGNIFICANT
07:52:28.119 --> 07:52:28.520
CONCESSION. CALIFORNIA
07:52:28.586 --> 07:52:29.621
DEPARTMENT INSURANCE ESTIMATES
07:52:29.688 --> 07:52:31.156
THE COST OF THE AMENDED BILL
07:52:31.222 --> 07:52:32.257
WOULD LIKELY INCREASE THE
07:52:32.323 --> 07:52:35.293
AVERAGE INSURANCE POLICY ABOUT
07:52:35.360 --> 07:52:36.695
FORTY FIVE DOLLARS A YEAR THE
07:52:36.761 --> 07:52:37.662
EQUIVALENT OF FOUR DOLLARS PER
07:52:37.729 --> 07:52:39.831
MONTH. NO ONE LIKES TO INCREASE
07:52:39.898 --> 07:52:41.266
COST TO CONSUMERS BUT WHEN
07:52:41.332 --> 07:52:43.334
CONSIDERING A BILL LIKE ELEVEN
07:52:43.401 --> 07:52:44.969
OH SEVEN WE MUST WEIGH THE COSTS
07:52:45.036 --> 07:52:46.705
AGAINST BENEFITS AND WHEN YOU
07:52:46.771 --> 07:52:47.839
CONSIDER THE HIGH COSTS OF
07:52:47.906 --> 07:52:49.708
VEHICLE REPAIR. MEDICAL EXPENSES
07:52:49.774 --> 07:52:51.409
LOST WAGES AND OTHER FALLOUT
07:52:51.476 --> 07:52:53.411
FROM VEHICLE COLLISION THE SMALL
07:52:53.478 --> 07:52:55.680
ADDITIONAL COSTS FROM ELEVEN OH
07:52:55.747 --> 07:52:57.582
SEVEN ARE WORTH. THE EXTRA
07:52:57.649 --> 07:52:59.918
PROTECTION. THE BILL HAS WIDE
07:52:59.984 --> 07:53:00.885
RANGING SUPPORT INCLUDING THE
07:53:00.952 --> 07:53:02.754
COMMISSIONER OF INSURANCE THE
07:53:02.821 --> 07:53:04.322
CONSUMER FEDERATIONS MOTHERS
07:53:04.389 --> 07:53:06.157
AGAINST DRUNK DRIVING UNITED
07:53:06.224 --> 07:53:08.093
POLICY HOLDERS. THE TEAMSTERS
07:53:08.159 --> 07:53:10.061
PUBLIC AFFAIRS COUNCIL IN MANY
07:53:10.128 --> 07:53:12.497
MORE AND MOST RECENTLY WE HAD AN
07:53:12.564 --> 07:53:13.932
AGREEMENT BETWEEN PATH AND THE
07:53:13.998 --> 07:53:15.467
CONSUMER ATTORNEYS WHICH TOOK
07:53:15.533 --> 07:53:17.936
AWAY MOST IF NOT ALL THE
07:53:18.002 --> 07:53:20.438
OPPOSITION RESPECTFULLY ASK DR.
07:53:20.505 --> 07:53:21.506
THANK YOU CENTER DOT MEMBERS
07:53:21.573 --> 07:53:24.008
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
07:53:24.075 --> 07:53:25.677
HEARING NONE MADAM SECRETARY
07:53:25.744 --> 07:53:29.247
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN I
07:53:29.314 --> 07:53:34.352
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS HI FAITH.
07:53:34.419 --> 07:53:39.491
NO BAKER I FOR JUST. BRADFORD
07:53:39.557 --> 07:53:42.961
AYE CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
07:53:43.027 --> 07:53:47.699
DALY NO DODD HI I TORONTO AYE
07:53:47.766 --> 07:53:52.337
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
07:53:52.403 --> 07:54:00.311
GROW. HERTZBERG HUESO. I FURTADO
07:54:00.378 --> 07:54:05.383
I JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED
07:54:05.450 --> 07:54:11.956
AYE LEYVA AYE THE MON. MCGUIRE I
07:54:12.023 --> 07:54:15.994
MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE NEWMAN AYE
07:54:16.060 --> 07:54:24.035
NIELSEN. A CHOI BOGUE. NO PAN I
07:54:24.102 --> 07:54:28.373
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO. I
07:54:28.439 --> 07:54:33.845
SKINNER I STERN AYE I'M BURKE HI
07:54:33.912 --> 07:54:39.217
MY COUNTY AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO
07:54:39.284 --> 07:54:40.451
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
07:54:40.518 --> 07:54:45.390
FORTUS. GROVE WE GOT A BINGO ON
07:54:45.456 --> 07:54:49.828
THE BOTTOM. NO HURTS HER TADO I
07:54:49.894 --> 07:55:04.042
TO KNOW. LIMÓN I NIELSEN. FOR A
07:55:04.108 --> 07:55:10.448
TAX INCREASE WILL. ENSURE. LESS
07:55:10.515 --> 07:55:31.069
AND LESS THAN ONE LATTE FIVE PM.
07:55:58.196 --> 07:56:00.231
I TWENTY NINE KNOWS EIGHT THE
07:56:00.298 --> 07:56:01.766
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
07:56:01.833 --> 07:56:03.568
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM EIGHTY
07:56:03.635 --> 07:56:05.103
SEVEN SENATOR CABALLERO MADAM
07:56:05.169 --> 07:56:07.272
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
07:56:07.338 --> 07:56:09.140
BILL ELEVEN TWENTY THREE BY
07:56:09.207 --> 07:56:10.341
SENATOR CABALLERO AN ACT
07:56:10.408 --> 07:56:12.043
RELATING TO CLIMATE CHANGE
07:56:12.110 --> 07:56:13.578
SENATE CARILLO THANK YOU MR
07:56:13.645 --> 07:56:15.280
PRESIDENT SENATORS AND PLEASED
07:56:15.346 --> 07:56:18.383
TO PRESENT SB ELEVEN TWENTY
07:56:18.449 --> 07:56:19.651
THREE WHICH WOULD REQUIRE INTER
07:56:19.717 --> 07:56:21.452
AGENCY COLLABORATION TO IMPROVE
07:56:21.519 --> 07:56:23.388
ACCESS TO GRANT AND LOAN
07:56:23.454 --> 07:56:25.890
PROGRAMS AND ESTABLISH REPORTING
07:56:25.957 --> 07:56:27.392
AND EVALUATION REQUIREMENTS OF
07:56:27.458 --> 07:56:28.726
STATE ENTITIES THAT OFFER
07:56:28.793 --> 07:56:31.129
CLIMATE RELATED GRANT PROGRAMS
07:56:31.195 --> 07:56:38.136
AS. WHO IDENTIFY AND FIND
07:56:38.202 --> 07:56:41.105
CLIMATE CHANGE GOALS SB ELEVEN
07:56:41.172 --> 07:56:42.040
TWENTY THREE DIRECTS THE OFFICE
07:56:42.106 --> 07:56:43.408
OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH TO
07:56:43.474 --> 07:56:45.176
DEVELOP A WEB BASED RESOURCE TO
07:56:45.243 --> 07:56:46.811
IDENTIFY ALL STATE FUNDED
07:56:46.878 --> 07:56:49.047
RESILIENCE FUNDING PROGRAMS AND
07:56:49.113 --> 07:56:50.648
TO PROVIDE HELPFUL INFORMATION
07:56:50.715 --> 07:56:52.383
AND ASSISTANCE TO COMMUNITIES
07:56:52.450 --> 07:56:54.252
AND OTHER ENTITIES SEEKING STATE
07:56:54.319 --> 07:56:55.920
FUNDING WHICH WILL INCLUDE
07:56:55.987 --> 07:56:57.255
TARGETED OUTREACH TO UNDER
07:56:57.322 --> 07:56:58.823
RESOURCE COMMUNITIES AS WE KNOW
07:56:58.890 --> 07:57:01.492
WE PUT A LOT OF MONEY IN THE
07:57:01.559 --> 07:57:02.560
BUDGET FOR DIFFERENT ENTITIES
07:57:02.627 --> 07:57:03.928
DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE STATE TO
07:57:03.995 --> 07:57:05.830
DO THIS KIND OF GRANT FUNDING.
07:57:05.897 --> 07:57:07.131
BUT WE HAVE COMMUNITIES THAT
07:57:07.198 --> 07:57:09.400
HAVE A HARD TIME ACCESSING THAT
07:57:09.467 --> 07:57:10.635
INFORMATION AND HAVING THE
07:57:10.702 --> 07:57:12.637
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE NECESSARY
07:57:12.704 --> 07:57:13.938
THE BILL ALSO REQUIRES THE
07:57:14.005 --> 07:57:15.707
IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES TO DEVELOP
07:57:15.773 --> 07:57:17.375
A COORDINATED APPROACH TO
07:57:17.442 --> 07:57:19.510
COMMUNICATE WHERE AND HOW THESE
07:57:19.577 --> 07:57:20.979
FUNDS ARE BEING SPENT AND A
07:57:21.045 --> 07:57:22.780
FRAMEWORK TO MEASURE SUCCESS AND
07:57:22.847 --> 07:57:24.649
CLIMATE RESILIENCE AGAINST
07:57:24.716 --> 07:57:25.783
MEASURES ADOPTED FROM EXISTING
07:57:25.850 --> 07:57:28.386
STATE STRATEGIES AS CLIMATE
07:57:28.453 --> 07:57:30.989
RESILIENCE RESILIENCY RELATED
07:57:31.055 --> 07:57:32.757
PROGRAMS DEVELOP ACROSS STATE
07:57:32.824 --> 07:57:34.592
AGENCIES IT'S CRITICAL THAT THE
07:57:34.659 --> 07:57:36.561
PUBLIC THE LEGISLATURE AND THE
07:57:36.627 --> 07:57:38.563
IMPLEMENTING AGENCIES KNOW WHERE
07:57:38.629 --> 07:57:40.298
AND HOW THESE FUNDS ARE BEING
07:57:40.365 --> 07:57:41.199
SPENT THANKFULLY AN IRISH THANK
07:57:41.265 --> 07:57:42.367
YOU AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
07:57:42.433 --> 07:57:44.135
YOUR I. BOATS THANK YOU CENTER
07:57:44.202 --> 07:57:45.603
CABALLERO MEMBERS ANY DISCUSSION
07:57:45.670 --> 07:57:47.472
OR DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING
07:57:47.538 --> 07:57:49.540
THEM MEMBERS OF QUALIFIED FOR
07:57:49.607 --> 07:57:51.075
UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL IS THERE ANY
07:57:51.142 --> 07:57:53.411
OBJECTION SEEING AND HEARING
07:57:53.478 --> 07:57:57.081
NONE IS THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
07:57:57.148 --> 07:57:58.016
MEASURE PASSES. LIVING ON A FILE
07:57:58.082 --> 07:57:59.417
ITEM EIGHTY EIGHT SENATOR
07:57:59.484 --> 07:58:01.319
ARCHULETA MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
07:58:01.386 --> 07:58:03.721
READ SENATE BILL ELEVEN TWENTY
07:58:03.788 --> 07:58:05.623
FOUR BY SENATOR ARCHULETA AN ACT
07:58:05.690 --> 07:58:07.458
RELATING TO DRINKING WATER.
07:58:07.525 --> 07:58:09.327
CENTER CHIRLA THANK YOU MADAM
07:58:09.394 --> 07:58:11.162
PRESIDENT TODAY AND- PRESENTING
07:58:11.229 --> 07:58:13.464
SENATE BILL ELEVEN TWENTY FOUR
07:58:13.531 --> 07:58:15.166
TO ADDRESS THE PROBLEM OF MAGNUM
07:58:15.233 --> 07:58:17.201
THESE IN CALIFORNIA'S WATER
07:58:17.268 --> 07:58:18.503
SYSTEMS THE CENTRAL BASIN
07:58:18.569 --> 07:58:20.772
REGION. IN MY OWN DISTRICT HAS
07:58:20.838 --> 07:58:22.073
HAD CHRONIC ISSUES WITH OUR
07:58:22.140 --> 07:58:25.043
WATER IN SPECIFICALLY MAGNETS
07:58:25.109 --> 07:58:27.211
70% OF CONSUMERS AND CUSTOMERS
07:58:27.278 --> 07:58:28.846
IN OUR DISTRICT COME FROM
07:58:28.913 --> 07:58:30.548
DISADVANTAGED COMMUNITIES AND IS
07:58:30.615 --> 07:58:33.017
INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT. THAT I
07:58:33.084 --> 07:58:35.153
WORK TO ENSURE THAT THEIR WATER
07:58:35.219 --> 07:58:38.156
IS NOT CONTAMINATED WITH
07:58:38.222 --> 07:58:40.291
DANGEROUS LEVELS OF MACINNES.
07:58:40.358 --> 07:58:40.825
PREVENTED THE ACCUMULATED
07:58:40.892 --> 07:58:44.729
POLLUTION'S- FOR MOVING FROM-
07:58:44.796 --> 07:58:46.097
ONE DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM TO
07:58:46.164 --> 07:58:49.033
ANOTHER CUSTER'S TAPS TAKES-
07:58:49.100 --> 07:58:50.601
TAKES ON TERRIBLE TERRIBLE
07:58:50.668 --> 07:58:53.237
SITUATIONS WHEN WATER IN SOME
07:58:53.304 --> 07:58:55.406
CASES BROWN PIPES NEED TO BE
07:58:55.473 --> 07:58:57.875
FLUSHED OUT WITH THE SYSTEMS AND
07:58:57.942 --> 07:59:00.178
NEED TO BE UPDATED THE POOREST
07:59:00.244 --> 07:59:02.146
SYSTEMS HAVE DIFFICULTY IN THE
07:59:02.213 --> 07:59:03.481
POOREST CONSUMERS HAVE
07:59:03.548 --> 07:59:04.882
DIFFICULTY PAYING THE WATER
07:59:04.949 --> 07:59:07.752
SYSTEMS AND OPERATORS- AND THAT
07:59:07.819 --> 07:59:09.420
WE NEED THE EXPERTISE IN AN
07:59:09.487 --> 07:59:11.989
ATTENTION IN THIS BILL FOR THESE
07:59:12.056 --> 07:59:14.425
REASONS I ASK FOR AN AYE VOTE.
07:59:14.492 --> 07:59:15.093
THANK YOU CENTER ARCHULETA
07:59:15.159 --> 07:59:16.861
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
07:59:16.928 --> 07:59:18.996
SEEING AND HEARING NONE BEN
07:59:19.063 --> 07:59:20.131
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
07:59:20.198 --> 07:59:25.470
ALLEN HI ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
07:59:25.536 --> 07:59:30.108
AYE BATES AYE BAKER I FOR JUST
07:59:30.174 --> 07:59:34.545
AYE BRADFORD AYE BY OTHER.
07:59:34.612 --> 07:59:40.852
CORTESE I DALY. DODD TORONTO I
07:59:40.918 --> 07:59:48.259
EGGMAN I GLAZER. I GONZALEZ I
07:59:48.326 --> 07:59:53.131
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESSEL. I
07:59:53.197 --> 08:00:00.138
FURTADO. JONES NO KAMLAGER I
08:00:00.204 --> 08:00:05.143
FLARED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN. AYE
08:00:05.209 --> 08:00:12.216
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ. MAN. I
08:00:12.283 --> 08:00:18.222
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN. NO CHOI
08:00:18.289 --> 08:00:22.293
BOGUE AYE PAN AYE PORTANTINO.
08:00:22.360 --> 08:00:36.207
ROTH I RUBIO I SKINNER. I STERN. I AM BURKE AYE AYE CASKEY AYE
08:00:36.274 --> 08:00:39.677
WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE CALL
08:00:39.744 --> 08:00:43.414
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. CABALLERO
08:00:43.481 --> 08:00:48.886
SALLY NO. DODD. HERTZBERG
08:00:48.953 --> 08:00:55.259
FURTADO. MELENDEZ I. PORTANTINO
08:00:55.326 --> 08:01:00.064
HI. FIVE THIRTY ONE KNOWS FIVE
08:01:00.131 --> 08:01:01.399
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:01:01.465 --> 08:01:03.201
MOVING TO FILE ITEM EIGHTY NINE
08:01:03.267 --> 08:01:04.802
SENATOR CABALLERO MADAM
08:01:04.869 --> 08:01:06.871
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
08:01:06.938 --> 08:01:09.640
BILL ELEVEN FORTY TWO BY SENATOR
08:01:09.707 --> 08:01:11.242
CABALLERO AN ACT RELATING TO
08:01:11.309 --> 08:01:12.977
MATERNAL HEALTH CENTER CABALLERO
08:01:13.044 --> 08:01:14.478
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT AND
08:01:14.545 --> 08:01:17.815
MEMBERS I RISE TO PRESENT SB
08:01:17.882 --> 08:01:19.016
ELEVEN FORTY TWO WHICH WILL
08:01:19.083 --> 08:01:20.151
IMPROVE ACCESS TO PRACTICAL
08:01:20.218 --> 08:01:21.219
SUPPORT SERVICES FOR PEOPLE
08:01:21.285 --> 08:01:22.620
SEEKING AN ABORTION AND
08:01:22.687 --> 08:01:24.488
REPRODUCTIVE REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
08:01:24.555 --> 08:01:26.691
SERVICES IN CALIFORNIA. THIS
08:01:26.757 --> 08:01:28.492
YEAR THE US SUPREME COURT WILL
08:01:28.559 --> 08:01:29.961
REVIEW A DIRECT CHALLENGE TO THE
08:01:30.027 --> 08:01:32.063
LANDMARK CASE ROE V. WADE SHOULD
08:01:32.129 --> 08:01:32.997
THE COURT OVERTURNED A
08:01:33.064 --> 08:01:34.498
LONGSTANDING LEGAL PROTECTIONS
08:01:34.565 --> 08:01:36.801
OF ABORTION SERVICES UNDER THIS
08:01:36.867 --> 08:01:39.103
MONUMENTAL DECISION TWENTY SIX
08:01:39.170 --> 08:01:41.372
STATES ARE CERTAIN OR LIKELY TO
08:01:41.439 --> 08:01:42.406
BAN ABORTIONS IMPACTING AS MANY
08:01:42.473 --> 08:01:44.842
AS THIRTY SIX MEN MILLION
08:01:44.909 --> 08:01:46.043
INDIVIDUALS WHO MAY BECOME
08:01:46.110 --> 08:01:48.346
PREGNANT ACCORDING TO A RECENT
08:01:48.412 --> 08:01:50.381
GOOD MARKER INSTITUTE REPORT
08:01:50.448 --> 08:01:53.718
CALIFORNIA MAY SEE A NEAR 3000%
08:01:53.784 --> 08:01:56.053
INCREASE IN PEOPLE TRAVELING TO
08:01:56.120 --> 08:01:57.922
CALIFORNIA FOR ABORTION CARE IF
08:01:57.989 --> 08:01:59.957
A TOTAL BAN WERE TO TAKE PLACE
08:02:00.024 --> 08:02:01.292
IN THE UNITED STATES. IF THIS
08:02:01.359 --> 08:02:02.760
HAPPENS PATIENTS WILL NEED
08:02:02.827 --> 08:02:04.962
SUPPORT AS THEY TRAVEL AND MAY
08:02:05.029 --> 08:02:06.897
NEED ACCESS TO TRANSPORTATION
08:02:06.964 --> 08:02:09.000
LODGING CHILDCARE AND MEDICAL
08:02:09.066 --> 08:02:10.735
CARE IN A BOOK AND ABORTION
08:02:10.801 --> 08:02:12.803
PROVIDERS CAN EXPECT TO SEE A
08:02:12.870 --> 08:02:14.639
RISE IN DEMAND AND IN THE
08:02:14.705 --> 08:02:17.375
WORKLOAD SB ELEVEN FORTY TWO.
08:02:17.441 --> 08:02:18.843
WILL PROVIDE GRANTS TO
08:02:18.909 --> 08:02:20.778
CALIFORNIA BASED ORGANIZATIONS
08:02:20.845 --> 08:02:22.947
WHO PROVIDE SERVICES TO PATIENTS
08:02:23.014 --> 08:02:25.082
. AND WHOSE DIRECT SUPPORT SUCH
08:02:25.149 --> 08:02:26.250
AS A RIGHT TO THE HEALTH CARE
08:02:26.317 --> 08:02:27.785
FACILITY IS SOMETIMES THE
08:02:27.852 --> 08:02:29.587
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SEEKING CARE
08:02:29.654 --> 08:02:31.522
AND NOT THE BILL WILL ALSO
08:02:31.589 --> 08:02:32.623
CREATE A WEBSITE WITH
08:02:32.690 --> 08:02:34.292
CENTRALIZED INFORMATION FOR
08:02:34.358 --> 08:02:35.126
PEOPLE SEEKING CARE IN
08:02:35.192 --> 08:02:37.295
CALIFORNIA. THIS WILL PERK THIS
08:02:37.361 --> 08:02:39.463
WILL COMBAT MISINFORMATION AND
08:02:39.530 --> 08:02:41.399
PROVIDE PATIENTS ACCESS TO THE
08:02:41.465 --> 08:02:43.501
RESOURCES THEY NEED TO ACCESS
08:02:43.567 --> 08:02:45.603
CARE AS A REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM
08:02:45.670 --> 08:02:47.405
STATE CALIFORNIA MUST BE
08:02:47.471 --> 08:02:49.173
PREPARED TO TREAT ALL OF ITS
08:02:49.240 --> 08:02:50.941
PATIENTS WHO ARE SEEKING CARE IN
08:02:51.008 --> 08:02:52.643
THE STATE AND NAVIGATE THEM TO
08:02:52.710 --> 08:02:55.346
THE BEST CARE POSSIBLE. SB
08:02:55.413 --> 08:02:56.013
ELEVEN FORTY TWO IS JUST ONE OF
08:02:56.080 --> 08:02:58.182
MANY STEPS THE STATE CAN TAKE
08:02:58.249 --> 08:03:00.051
THE KIDS TO ACHIEVE THIS GOAL
08:03:00.117 --> 08:03:01.552
THANK YOU AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK
08:03:01.619 --> 08:03:03.254
FOR YOUR I. BOATS THANK YOU
08:03:03.321 --> 08:03:05.022
CENTER CABALLERO DISCUSSION AND
08:03:05.089 --> 08:03:09.226
DEBATE CENTER SKINNER. THANK YOU
08:03:09.293 --> 08:03:10.561
MADAM PRESIDENT AND MEMBERS ARE
08:03:10.628 --> 08:03:13.931
RISES JOINT AUTHOR OF SB ELEVEN
08:03:13.998 --> 08:03:15.933
FORTY TWO AND REALLY THANK MY
08:03:16.000 --> 08:03:18.903
COLLEAGUES. FOR JOINING US IN
08:03:18.969 --> 08:03:22.206
THIS. IN PUTTING FOR DESPAIR
08:03:22.273 --> 08:03:24.275
VERY IMPORTANT MISSION HISTORY
08:03:24.342 --> 08:03:26.277
DEMONSTRATES THAT ABORTION
08:03:26.344 --> 08:03:27.812
RESTRICTIONS DO NOT STOP
08:03:27.878 --> 08:03:30.781
ABORTIONS PRIOR TO THE DECISION
08:03:30.848 --> 08:03:32.416
OF THE SUPREME COURT IN THE
08:03:32.483 --> 08:03:34.452
ROVER YOU WEIGHED IN THE U. S.
08:03:34.518 --> 08:03:37.254
AND THIS IS WHEN WE WERE QUITE A
08:03:37.321 --> 08:03:38.422
SMALLER POPULATION ACROSS THE
08:03:38.489 --> 08:03:40.825
COUNTRY THERE WERE OVER FIVE
08:03:40.891 --> 08:03:43.427
THOUSAND DEATHS PER YEAR. FIVE
08:03:43.494 --> 08:03:46.097
THOUSAND WOMEN DIED SEEKING THAT
08:03:46.163 --> 08:03:48.799
ABORTION THEY FELT THEY NEEDED.
08:03:48.866 --> 08:03:51.469
AND YET COULD NOT GET MEDICALLY
08:03:51.535 --> 08:03:55.239
SAFE OR LEGAL. AND WE KNOW THAT
08:03:55.306 --> 08:03:57.341
LOWER INCOME WOMEN AND WOMEN OF
08:03:57.408 --> 08:03:59.210
COLOR ARE DISPROPORTIONATELY AT
08:03:59.276 --> 08:04:05.483
RISK. SO THE SAD REALITY IS THAT
08:04:05.549 --> 08:04:11.222
ELIMINATING. R. RIGHT. WEALTHY
08:04:11.288 --> 08:04:12.356
WOMEN WILL ALWAYS HAVE THE
08:04:12.423 --> 08:04:14.058
CHOICEWEALTHY WOMEN WILL BE
08:04:14.125 --> 08:04:17.094
ABLE TO FIND AN ABORTION LOW
08:04:17.161 --> 08:04:19.029
INCOME WOMEN WILL HAVE A MUCH
08:04:19.096 --> 08:04:21.999
MORE DIFFICULT TIME AND SUFFER
08:04:22.066 --> 08:04:25.569
GREATER CONSEQUENCES AND WHAT SB
08:04:25.636 --> 08:04:27.037
ELEVEN FORTY TWO DOES IS
08:04:27.104 --> 08:04:29.473
COMMUNICATES TO EVERYONE IN OUR
08:04:29.540 --> 08:04:31.208
STATE AND WE'RE VERY LARGE STATE
08:04:31.275 --> 08:04:33.644
SO YOU YOU YOU DON'T NECESSARILY
08:04:33.711 --> 08:04:35.880
HAVE A CLINIC NEARBY EVEN THOUGH
08:04:35.946 --> 08:04:37.882
WE HAVE NO RESTRICTIONS. IT
08:04:37.948 --> 08:04:40.551
ALLOWS ANYONE WHO NEEDS THE
08:04:40.618 --> 08:04:43.387
SERVICES TO BE ABLE TO ACCESS A
08:04:43.454 --> 08:04:44.989
WEBSITE WHERE THEY CAN GET THIS
08:04:45.055 --> 08:04:48.058
INFORMATION AND THEN IN THE CASE
08:04:48.125 --> 08:04:50.194
THAT THEY FACE SOME PRACTICAL
08:04:50.261 --> 08:04:53.531
MEET THE PRACTICAL NEEDS STATE
08:04:53.597 --> 08:04:54.632
TO COVER CHILD CARE FOR THEIR
08:04:54.698 --> 08:04:57.768
CHILDREN OR PERHAPS YOU HAVE TO
08:04:57.835 --> 08:04:59.670
GET AN OVERNIGHT STAY BECAUSE OF
08:04:59.737 --> 08:05:01.305
THE DISTANCE WERE FROM WHERE
08:05:01.372 --> 08:05:03.174
THEY LIVE. THAT THERE WOULD BE A
08:05:03.240 --> 08:05:06.143
FUND ESTABLISHED THAT WE WOULD
08:05:06.210 --> 08:05:08.512
SEEK. BUSINESS SUPPORT FOR
08:05:08.579 --> 08:05:10.614
INDIVIDUAL DONATIONS YOU NAME IT
08:05:10.681 --> 08:05:12.450
. SO THAT PERHAPS THOSE PEOPLE
08:05:12.516 --> 08:05:14.118
COULD GET SOME PRACTICAL SUPPORT
08:05:14.185 --> 08:05:18.522
IF NEEDED. AND IT REALLY WILL
08:05:18.589 --> 08:05:21.559
ALLOW CALIFORNIA TO MAKE REAL
08:05:21.625 --> 08:05:24.695
OUR COMMITMENT TO BE THE BEACON
08:05:24.762 --> 08:05:26.430
FOR REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM AND
08:05:26.497 --> 08:05:31.168
ABORTION ACCESS IN THIS COUNTRY-AND WITH THAT I ASK FOR YOUR I.
08:05:31.235 --> 08:05:32.803
PHONE. THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER
08:05:32.870 --> 08:05:35.639
CENTER GROVE. THANK YOU MADAM
08:05:35.706 --> 08:05:37.308
PRESIDENT QUESTION OF THE AUTHOR
08:05:37.374 --> 08:05:38.676
CYNICAL WHERE WE TAKE THE
08:05:38.742 --> 08:05:40.544
QUESTION WELL PLEASE PROCEED
08:05:40.611 --> 08:05:42.046
THANK YOU MA'AM I WAS TRYING TO
08:05:42.112 --> 08:05:43.914
READ THROUGH THE BILL AS FAST AS
08:05:43.981 --> 08:05:45.583
I COULD BUT IN YOUR COMMENTS AND
08:05:45.649 --> 08:05:46.484
MY COLLEAGUE FROM BERKLEY'S
08:05:46.550 --> 08:05:47.718
COMMENTS- AS WELL. YOU TALKED
08:05:47.785 --> 08:05:50.554
ABOUT GRANT FUNDING THAT WOULD
08:05:50.621 --> 08:05:52.089
BE AVAILABLE. I'M ASSUMING.
08:05:52.156 --> 08:05:53.958
PLEASE CORRECT ME IF IM WRONG.
08:05:54.024 --> 08:05:56.160
IT'S OUT OF STATE INDIVIDUALS
08:05:56.227 --> 08:05:57.761
THAT WOULD. THAT WOULD BE
08:05:57.828 --> 08:05:58.996
RECEIVING THOSE THAT GRANT
08:05:59.063 --> 08:06:00.931
FUNDING FROM THE NONPROFITS THAT
08:06:00.998 --> 08:06:01.866
APPLY FOR THE GRANTS ELLER
08:06:01.932 --> 08:06:03.567
CABALLERO. SO THE GRANTS WOULD
08:06:03.634 --> 08:06:06.470
BE- APPLIED FOR BY ORGANIZATIONS
08:06:06.537 --> 08:06:08.272
THAT PURPORT PROVIDE HEALTH
08:06:08.339 --> 08:06:10.908
SERVICES. AND THE GRANTS COULD
08:06:10.975 --> 08:06:12.443
GO TO ANY INDIVIDUALS THAT ARE
08:06:12.510 --> 08:06:14.512
IN CALIFORNIA IN ORDER TO HELP
08:06:14.578 --> 08:06:16.280
THEM ACCESS THE SERVICES IN
08:06:16.347 --> 08:06:17.915
CALIFORNIA. CENTER GROVE.
08:06:17.982 --> 08:06:20.217
QUESTION OTHER AGAIN PLEASE WE
08:06:20.284 --> 08:06:21.051
TAKE ANOTHER QUESTION YES I WILL
08:06:21.118 --> 08:06:23.420
PLEASE PROCEED SO THE GRANT
08:06:23.487 --> 08:06:24.822
FUNDING THAT'S AVAILABLE BY THE
08:06:24.889 --> 08:06:26.457
STATE TAXPAYERS OF CALIFORNIA
08:06:26.524 --> 08:06:28.592
THROUGH THIS BILL IF THIS BILL
08:06:28.659 --> 08:06:31.362
PASSES WOULD ONLY GO TO. ADD
08:06:31.428 --> 08:06:33.964
ORGANIZATIONS IN CALIFORNIA TO
08:06:34.031 --> 08:06:36.433
HELP CALIFORNIA WOMEN OBTAIN
08:06:36.500 --> 08:06:39.236
ABORTIONS CENTER CABALLERO YES
08:06:39.303 --> 08:06:40.804
NOW IF YOU'RE IN CALIFORNIA
08:06:40.871 --> 08:06:42.706
SEEKING AN ABORTION- IN A
08:06:42.773 --> 08:06:45.175
CALIFORNIA FACILITY THEN YOU GET
08:06:45.242 --> 08:06:48.012
YOUR- YOU CAN ASK FOR RESOURCES
08:06:48.078 --> 08:06:49.914
AND IT WOULD BE UP TO THE
08:06:49.980 --> 08:06:50.481
ORGANIZATION TO GRANT THOSE
08:06:50.548 --> 08:06:52.816
RESOURCES. ASSEMBLY VISITING
08:06:52.883 --> 08:06:54.285
FROM CAL FROM ANOTHER STATE TO
08:06:54.351 --> 08:06:55.653
CALIFORNIA- IT THEORETICALLY I
08:06:55.719 --> 08:06:58.856
THINK THAT'S TRUE. OKAY THANK
08:06:58.923 --> 08:07:01.959
YOU. THANK YOU CENTER MELINDA'S
08:07:02.026 --> 08:07:04.128
. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT- WE
08:07:04.194 --> 08:07:06.196
HAD THIS BILL WE HAD THIS VERY
08:07:06.263 --> 08:07:07.631
CONVERSATION THAT MY COLLEAGUE
08:07:07.698 --> 08:07:09.199
FROM BAKERSFIELD JUST BROUGHT UP
08:07:09.266 --> 08:07:11.969
ABOUT THE FUNDING ISSUE- AND I
08:07:12.036 --> 08:07:14.238
ASK THE QUESTION. WILL THIS
08:07:14.305 --> 08:07:16.006
FUNDING BE AVAILABLE TO WOMEN
08:07:16.073 --> 08:07:18.309
WHO DO NOT LIVE IN CALIFORNIA
08:07:18.375 --> 08:07:20.678
AND THE ANSWER WAS YES. IT'S
08:07:20.744 --> 08:07:22.446
AVAILABLE TO WOMEN IN CALIFORNIA
08:07:22.513 --> 08:07:24.348
IT'S ALSO AVAILABLE TO WOMEN
08:07:24.415 --> 08:07:27.017
FROM THE EAST COAST FROM THE
08:07:27.084 --> 08:07:29.320
SOUTH YOU NAME IT IT WOULD BE
08:07:29.386 --> 08:07:30.821
AVAILABLE TO THEM IT WOULD PAY
08:07:30.888 --> 08:07:32.356
FOR. CHILDCARE SERVICES IF THEY
08:07:32.423 --> 08:07:33.958
HAPPEN TO BE BRINGING OTHER
08:07:34.024 --> 08:07:35.025
CHILDREN ALONG WITH THEM IT
08:07:35.092 --> 08:07:36.293
WOULD PAY FOR TRANSPORTATION
08:07:36.360 --> 08:07:39.196
PLANE FARE HOTELS MEALS YOU KNOW
08:07:39.263 --> 08:07:41.365
YOU NAME IT THAT'S WHAT THIS
08:07:41.432 --> 08:07:45.135
FUNDING WOULD GO TOWARDS IN MY-
08:07:45.202 --> 08:07:47.304
FEELING ON THIS IN. THIS IS
08:07:47.371 --> 08:07:49.540
IRRESPECTIVE OF YOUR POSITION ON
08:07:49.607 --> 08:07:52.209
ABORTION BUT WE'RE TALKING
08:07:52.276 --> 08:07:55.579
ABOUT. CREATING A FUND TO PAY
08:07:55.646 --> 08:07:57.615
FOR ABORTIONS WHEN WE HAVE
08:07:57.681 --> 08:08:00.017
PEOPLE LIVING ON THE STREETS IN
08:08:00.084 --> 08:08:02.019
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE PEOPLE WHO
08:08:02.086 --> 08:08:04.355
CANNOT AFFORD A HOME WHO CANNOT
08:08:04.421 --> 08:08:07.257
AFFORD RENT WE HAVE VETERANS WHO
08:08:07.324 --> 08:08:09.226
ARE LANGUISHING ON THE STREETS.
08:08:09.293 --> 08:08:12.696
AND THIS BILL IS DUE THIS IS THE
08:08:12.763 --> 08:08:14.898
GROUP THAT WE HAVE CHOSEN. TO
08:08:14.965 --> 08:08:16.600
GIVE OUR ATTENTION TO AND HELP
08:08:16.667 --> 08:08:21.372
THAT IS SHAMEFUL. YOUR POSITION
08:08:21.438 --> 08:08:22.906
ON ABORTION IS OF LITTLE
08:08:22.973 --> 08:08:24.742
CONSEQUENCE TO ME AT THIS POINT
08:08:24.808 --> 08:08:26.644
WHAT IS A CONSEQUENCE IS A FACT
08:08:26.710 --> 08:08:28.345
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT PUTTING
08:08:28.412 --> 08:08:31.015
TOGETHER A FIND OF MILLIONS AND
08:08:31.081 --> 08:08:33.884
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS. THERE'S SO
08:08:33.951 --> 08:08:36.053
MANY OTHER THINGS IN THE STATE
08:08:36.120 --> 08:08:37.821
WE CAN BE SPENDING THAT MONEY ON
08:08:37.888 --> 08:08:40.024
AND- BY THE WAY MAYBE WE SHOULD
08:08:40.090 --> 08:08:41.892
BE SPENDING THAT MONEY BUT
08:08:41.959 --> 08:08:42.893
PEOPLE WHO ARE ACTUALLY FROM
08:08:42.960 --> 08:08:44.962
CALIFORNIA. NOT SOMEBODY FROM
08:08:45.029 --> 08:08:47.531
UTAH OR NEW MEXICO OR LET THEIR
08:08:47.598 --> 08:08:50.534
STATES TAKE CARE OF THEM BUT WHY
08:08:50.601 --> 08:08:52.403
IN THE WORLD. WOULD WE SET UP A
08:08:52.469 --> 08:08:53.337
FUND TO HELP PEOPLE FROM OTHER
08:08:53.404 --> 08:08:55.039
STATES UNLESS OF COURSE IT'S
08:08:55.105 --> 08:08:57.274
BECAUSE WE'RE FALLING IN LINE
08:08:57.341 --> 08:09:01.178
WITH THE GOVERNOR'S. SPEECH THAT
08:09:01.245 --> 08:09:02.446
HE GAVE ABOUT HOW HE WANTS
08:09:02.513 --> 08:09:04.748
CALIFORNIA TO BECOME THE
08:09:04.815 --> 08:09:07.651
ABORTION SANCTUARY. THAT'S I
08:09:07.718 --> 08:09:09.286
GUESS WHAT WE WILL BE KNOWN FOR
08:09:09.353 --> 08:09:11.422
NOW THAT IN FREE SENTINEL
08:09:11.488 --> 08:09:13.724
WHEREVER YOU CAN FIND IT. I MEAN
08:09:13.791 --> 08:09:19.596
COME ON THIS IS. UP I RECOMMEND
08:09:19.663 --> 08:09:21.131
A NO VOTE ON THIS BILL THANK YOU
08:09:21.198 --> 08:09:24.501
pNO FURTHER DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
08:09:24.568 --> 08:09:26.236
CENTER CABALLERO YOU MAY CLOSE
08:09:26.303 --> 08:09:27.604
THANK YOU VERY MUCH- MADAM
08:09:27.671 --> 08:09:29.373
PRESIDENT AND I'M GOING TO THANK
08:09:29.440 --> 08:09:32.109
EVERYBODY FOR THE COMMENTS LOOK
08:09:32.176 --> 08:09:34.978
I THINK THE- WE CAN DEBATE.
08:09:35.045 --> 08:09:38.849
APPEAR KIND OF AD INFINITUM
08:09:38.916 --> 08:09:41.418
ABOUT ALL THE ISSUES THAT ARE-
08:09:41.485 --> 08:09:43.787
TROUBLES IN THE WORLD WE CAN
08:09:43.854 --> 08:09:47.157
TALK ABOUT- YOU KNOW HOW TO HOW
08:09:47.224 --> 08:09:49.593
THE CHILDREN ARE GETTING SHOT
08:09:49.660 --> 08:09:51.061
WHEN THEY GO TO SCHOOL WE CAN
08:09:51.128 --> 08:09:53.130
TALK ABOUT THE FACT THAT WE HAVE
08:09:53.197 --> 08:09:55.365
HOMELESS ON THE STREETS. WE CAN
08:09:55.432 --> 08:09:56.633
TALK ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES
08:09:56.700 --> 08:09:58.202
AND WE HAVE TALKED ABOUT A LOT
08:09:58.268 --> 08:10:00.738
OF THESE ISSUES HERE TODAY- BUT
08:10:00.804 --> 08:10:05.576
THE FACT THAT. WE ARE IN. THE
08:10:05.642 --> 08:10:08.479
MIX OF A CRISIS. AROUND
08:10:08.545 --> 08:10:10.114
HEALTHCARE AND REPRODUCTIVE
08:10:10.180 --> 08:10:12.583
RIGHTS- DOESN'T GET DIMINISHED
08:10:12.649 --> 08:10:14.318
BY THE FACT THAT THERE ARE OTHER
08:10:14.384 --> 08:10:15.586
CRISIS IS OUT OUT OUT IN THE
08:10:15.652 --> 08:10:20.657
WORLD- WHAT WE KNOW IS THAT WHEN
08:10:20.724 --> 08:10:24.595
WOMEN ARE DESPERATE. AND THEIR
08:10:24.661 --> 08:10:28.966
RIGHTS. ARE TAKEN AWAY. THAT
08:10:29.032 --> 08:10:30.167
THEY GET DESPERATE AND THEY DO
08:10:30.234 --> 08:10:32.302
DESPERATE THINGS AND WOMEN DIE
08:10:32.369 --> 08:10:34.538
AND SO DO THEIR CHILDREN AND SO
08:10:34.605 --> 08:10:38.275
ON THIS FUND. IS ONLY ONE OF THE
08:10:38.342 --> 08:10:40.844
SOLUTIONS THAT WE THINK IS
08:10:40.911 --> 08:10:43.947
CRITICALLY IMPORTANT TO BE ABLE
08:10:44.014 --> 08:10:45.816
TO FUNDED THE SERVICE THAT
08:10:45.883 --> 08:10:48.352
INDIVIDUALS DESPERATELY NEED WHO
08:10:48.418 --> 08:10:51.255
BECOME PREGNANT. AND ALLOW THEM
08:10:51.321 --> 08:10:53.190
TO MAKE PERSONAL CHOICES IN
08:10:53.257 --> 08:10:54.758
THEIR LIVES BECAUSE WE LOVE THEM
08:10:54.825 --> 08:10:56.794
AND WE THINK IT'S IMPORTANT FOR
08:10:56.860 --> 08:10:58.128
THEM TO LOVE THEMSELVES AND BE
08:10:58.195 --> 08:10:59.396
ABLE TO MAKE CHOICES ABOUT WHEN
08:10:59.463 --> 08:11:01.498
THEY START A FAMILY. THIS SIMPLE
08:11:01.565 --> 08:11:04.401
AS THAT- IN SO. THE BILL WOULD
08:11:04.468 --> 08:11:06.436
SET UP A FUND IT WOULD INVITE
08:11:06.503 --> 08:11:08.338
PRIVATE FUNDS AS WELL WE WOULD
08:11:08.405 --> 08:11:09.907
NOT BE FUNDING IT TOTALLY FROM
08:11:09.973 --> 08:11:11.508
THE STATE WE GET WE HAVE BOB
08:11:11.575 --> 08:11:13.110
OFFERS PHILANTHROPIC OFFERS AS
08:11:13.177 --> 08:11:16.647
WELL. AND WE EXPECT THIS TO BE A
08:11:16.713 --> 08:11:18.415
FINE THAT'LL PROVIDE SOME REALLY
08:11:18.482 --> 08:11:19.616
CRITICALLY HEALTH CRITICAL
08:11:19.683 --> 08:11:22.619
HEALTH. CARE INFORMATION AND
08:11:22.686 --> 08:11:24.588
SUPPORT SERVICES OUT TO PEOPLE
08:11:24.655 --> 08:11:26.323
IN DESPERATE NEED AND SO I
08:11:26.390 --> 08:11:26.924
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
08:11:26.990 --> 08:11:30.194
VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER CABALLERO
08:11:30.260 --> 08:11:31.628
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
08:11:31.695 --> 08:11:34.932
ROLL. ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
08:11:34.998 --> 08:11:40.070
ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER I
08:11:40.137 --> 08:11:43.340
PORCHES NO BRADFORD AYE
08:11:43.407 --> 08:11:46.944
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
08:11:47.010 --> 08:11:51.582
DALY NO DODD I TORONTO AYE
08:11:51.648 --> 08:11:55.519
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
08:11:55.586 --> 08:11:59.990
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESSEL. HER
08:12:00.057 --> 08:12:06.630
TADO. JONES NO KAMLAGER I
08:12:06.697 --> 08:12:10.200
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN AYE
08:12:10.267 --> 08:12:15.472
MCGUIRE. I MELENDEZ NO MAN I
08:12:15.539 --> 08:12:19.476
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A CHOI
08:12:19.543 --> 08:12:24.248
BOGUE NO PAN AYE PORTANTINO. I
08:12:24.314 --> 08:12:28.318
ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER I
08:12:28.385 --> 08:12:32.422
STERN I AM BURKE AYE FORECASTING
08:12:32.489 --> 08:12:36.493
AYE WIENER AYE WILK NO PLEASE
08:12:36.560 --> 08:12:38.061
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
08:12:38.128 --> 08:12:45.168
HERTZBERG WESSEL HI HER TADO. IS
08:12:45.235 --> 08:12:46.570
TWENTY NINE KNOWS NINE THE
08:12:46.637 --> 08:12:48.105
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
08:12:48.171 --> 08:12:50.040
MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM NUMBER
08:12:50.107 --> 08:12:51.408
NINETY SENATOR BAKER AND I'M
08:12:51.475 --> 08:12:53.310
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
08:12:53.377 --> 08:12:55.112
BILL ELEVEN FIFTY EIGHT BY
08:12:55.178 --> 08:12:57.581
SENATOR BACKER AN ACT RELATING
08:12:57.648 --> 08:12:59.616
TO ELECTRICITY. CENTER BAKER.
08:12:59.683 --> 08:13:01.919
HELLO SENATORS THAT MY FOR
08:13:01.985 --> 08:13:03.954
STATEMENT SAYS THIS IS A VERY
08:13:04.021 --> 08:13:05.522
SIMPLE BILL- BUT ACTUALLY REALLY
08:13:05.589 --> 08:13:07.591
NOT I'M IT'S ACTUALLY FAIRLY.
08:13:07.658 --> 08:13:09.326
IT'S ACTUALLY PRETTY WONKY BILL
08:13:09.393 --> 08:13:11.395
BUT LET ME SEE IF I CAN COVER IT
08:13:11.461 --> 08:13:12.829
QUICKLY FIRST THE GOOD NEWS.
08:13:12.896 --> 08:13:14.197
GOOD NEWS IS WE SET GREENHOUSE
08:13:14.264 --> 08:13:16.700
GAS TARGETS FOR ALL OF OUR
08:13:16.767 --> 08:13:17.634
ELECTRICITY SUPPLIERS THAT MEANS
08:13:17.701 --> 08:13:20.871
OUR USE OUR MUTINIES ARE CCA'S.
08:13:20.938 --> 08:13:22.439
THE BAD NEWS IS WE HAVE NOTHING
08:13:22.506 --> 08:13:24.041
IN PLACE TO MEASURE HOW WELL
08:13:24.107 --> 08:13:25.876
THEY'RE DOING AGAINST THOSE
08:13:25.943 --> 08:13:28.512
TARGETS. AND HOW QUESTIONS HOW
08:13:28.578 --> 08:13:30.714
CAN WE POSSIBLY EXPECT THAT TO
08:13:30.781 --> 08:13:31.748
WORK SO THIS BILL FIXES THAT
08:13:31.815 --> 08:13:34.117
GAP. AND IN DOING SO GET THIS ON
08:13:34.184 --> 08:13:36.219
THE WAY TO NOT HAVING CLEAN
08:13:36.286 --> 08:13:38.088
ENERGY JUST DURING THE DAY. BUT
08:13:38.155 --> 08:13:40.490
CLEAN ENERGY. OUR TWENTY FOUR
08:13:40.557 --> 08:13:42.559
SEVEN. SO MORE GOOD NEWS AND
08:13:42.626 --> 08:13:44.394
THIS IMPORTANT RESULT UNDERSTAND
08:13:44.461 --> 08:13:46.697
THE P. YOU SEE HAS IT INTEGRATED
08:13:46.763 --> 08:13:48.999
RESOURCE PLANNING PROCESS. THAT
08:13:49.066 --> 08:13:50.867
SETS GIGI TARGETS FOR EACH OF
08:13:50.934 --> 08:13:52.736
THESE ENTITIES. EACH LOAD
08:13:52.803 --> 08:13:54.304
SERVING ENTITIES USING AN HOUR
08:13:54.371 --> 08:13:56.606
BY HOUR ANALYSIS. OF EACH
08:13:56.673 --> 08:13:58.608
ELECTRICITY SUPPLIERS SOURCES OF
08:13:58.675 --> 08:14:01.545
ELECTRICITY. AND THE ASSOCIATED
08:14:01.611 --> 08:14:03.146
GHG EMISSIONS. SO WHAT THIS BILL
08:14:03.213 --> 08:14:05.449
DOES IS IT REQUIRES AND AT
08:14:05.515 --> 08:14:07.117
ANALYSIS APPROACH OF WHAT
08:14:07.184 --> 08:14:09.386
ACTUALLY HAPPENS TO BE
08:14:09.453 --> 08:14:11.421
CONSISTENT WITH THAT PROCESS. SO
08:14:11.488 --> 08:14:12.756
AGAIN WHY IS IT IMPORTANT TO
08:14:12.823 --> 08:14:14.958
HAVE THIS HOURLY ANALYSIS.
08:14:15.025 --> 08:14:16.293
BECAUSE FOR EXAMPLE ONE
08:14:16.360 --> 08:14:18.095
ELECTRICITY SUPPLIER FOUND THAT
08:14:18.161 --> 08:14:19.963
THE REPORTED EMISSIONS WERE
08:14:20.030 --> 08:14:21.798
ACTUALLY FIFTEEN TIMES HIGHER
08:14:21.865 --> 08:14:23.800
THAN FIFTEEN TIMES HIGHER WHEN
08:14:23.867 --> 08:14:25.435
ANALYZED MORE ACCURATELY ON AN
08:14:25.502 --> 08:14:27.337
HOUR BY HOUR BASIS RATHER THAN
08:14:27.404 --> 08:14:28.638
ON TRADITIONAL REPORTING WHICH
08:14:28.705 --> 08:14:30.774
IS DONE ON AN ANNUAL BASIS NOT
08:14:30.841 --> 08:14:33.276
OUR BY HARRISON ON ANNUAL BASIS.
08:14:33.343 --> 08:14:35.912
SUCH A SHOWS HOW INACCURATE OR
08:14:35.979 --> 08:14:37.347
OLD APPROACHES HAVE BEEN. SO
08:14:37.414 --> 08:14:38.582
THIS BILL DOESNOT REQUIRE
08:14:38.648 --> 08:14:40.717
CHANGES TO ANY PROCUREMENT PLANS
08:14:40.784 --> 08:14:42.185
IT JUST ESTABLISHES A FAIR AND
08:14:42.252 --> 08:14:44.221
pACCURATE WAY TO MEASURE HELLO
08:14:44.287 --> 08:14:45.789
EVERYONE EACH OF THESE LOAD
08:14:45.856 --> 08:14:47.958
SERVING ENTITIES ARE DOING. SO
08:14:48.025 --> 08:14:49.593
THAT WILL HAVE A TRANSPARENCY
08:14:49.659 --> 08:14:50.794
AND ACCOUNTABILITY TOWARDS OUR
08:14:50.861 --> 08:14:53.663
GOAL ARE SPECIALLY ASK DR VOTE.
08:14:53.730 --> 08:14:55.565
THANK YOU CENTER BAKER MEMBERS
08:14:55.632 --> 08:14:57.834
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
08:14:57.901 --> 08:14:59.436
HEARING THEN MA'AM SECRETARY
08:14:59.503 --> 08:15:03.774
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
08:15:03.840 --> 08:15:07.911
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
08:15:07.978 --> 08:15:14.051
NO BAKER. I FOR JUST NO BRADFORD
08:15:14.117 --> 08:15:17.454
. I CAMBIADO I PRETENDING FIVE
08:15:17.521 --> 08:15:23.126
DALLY NO DODD. I TORONTO I
08:15:23.193 --> 08:15:27.798
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
08:15:27.864 --> 08:15:33.003
GROW NO HERTZBERG WESSEL AYE.
08:15:33.070 --> 08:15:38.375
AYE JONES. KAMLAGER AYE LAYERED
08:15:38.442 --> 08:15:44.014
AYE LEYVA AYE LIMÓN I MCGUIRE I
08:15:44.081 --> 08:15:48.085
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
08:15:48.151 --> 08:15:54.391
NIELSEN NO- CHAU BOTH. PAN I
08:15:54.458 --> 08:16:00.764
PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
08:16:00.831 --> 08:16:04.868
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE ON BURKE
08:16:04.935 --> 08:16:08.438
HI FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE
08:16:08.505 --> 08:16:11.675
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
08:16:11.741 --> 08:16:16.546
MEMBERS. HERTZBERG JONES NO A
08:16:16.613 --> 08:16:20.417
CHOI BOGUE NO. FIVE THIRTY THOSE
08:16:20.484 --> 08:16:21.852
NINE THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:16:21.918 --> 08:16:23.386
WE ARE MOVING ON THE FILE ITEM
08:16:23.453 --> 08:16:26.056
NUMBER NINETY ONE SENATOR BAKER
08:16:26.123 --> 08:16:27.190
FOR SENATOR HERTZBERG MADAM
08:16:27.257 --> 08:16:29.126
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
08:16:29.192 --> 08:16:31.027
BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY FOUR BY
08:16:31.094 --> 08:16:32.129
SENATOR HERTZBERG AN ACT
08:16:32.195 --> 08:16:34.030
RELATING TO ELECTRICITY. CENTER
08:16:34.097 --> 08:16:37.734
BAKER. I THANK YOU IN THIS BILL
08:16:37.801 --> 08:16:39.002
IS ALSO PART OF I WOULD HAVE
08:16:39.069 --> 08:16:41.872
CALLED BUILD CLEAN FASTER YET BY
08:16:41.938 --> 08:16:44.107
CENTER HERTZBERG IT'S BASICALLY
08:16:44.174 --> 08:16:45.408
SAYING WE MUST ESTABLISH A
08:16:45.475 --> 08:16:47.144
ROBUST PROCESS FOR LONGER LEAD
08:16:47.210 --> 08:16:50.080
TIME RESOURCES. NINE AM AND AT
08:16:50.147 --> 08:16:52.349
WHICH TAKE MANY YEARS AS WE KNOW
08:16:52.415 --> 08:16:53.283
EIGHT TO TEN YEARS TO COME
08:16:53.350 --> 08:16:55.185
COMPLETES THIS WILL CONNECT THE
08:16:55.252 --> 08:16:56.953
STATE'S BULL PLANS FOR LEX INER
08:16:57.020 --> 08:16:59.089
KANEMI WITH COMMONSENSE POLICY
08:16:59.156 --> 08:17:00.657
FOR RAMPING UP. OUR CLEAN ENERGY
08:17:00.724 --> 08:17:02.259
MODERN INFRASTRUCTURE IT'S
08:17:02.325 --> 08:17:03.627
ANOTHER STEP IN THAT DIRECTION
08:17:03.693 --> 08:17:06.129
IT'S SUPPORT SUPPORT ESPECIALLY
08:17:06.196 --> 08:17:06.997
ASPIRIN I VOTE. THANK YOU
08:17:07.063 --> 08:17:08.498
SENATOR BAKER DISCUSSION AND
08:17:08.565 --> 08:17:10.300
DEBATE CENTER LAYERED. THANK YOU
08:17:10.367 --> 08:17:12.002
MADAM PRESIDENT I WAS JUST GONNA
08:17:12.068 --> 08:17:14.070
SAY BRIEFLY. SINCE IT DIDN'T GET
08:17:14.137 --> 08:17:16.139
SENT ON THIS BILL OR SAID ON THE
08:17:16.206 --> 08:17:18.275
PREVIOUS BILL THEY'RE BOTH PART
08:17:18.341 --> 08:17:20.477
OF THE CLIMATE GROUP PACKAGE
08:17:20.544 --> 08:17:22.112
THAT IS BEING BROUGHT IN FRONT
08:17:22.179 --> 08:17:26.216
OF THE- THE- OVERALL BY THE TIME
08:17:26.283 --> 08:17:28.985
WE GET DONE. WE WILL CONSIDER
08:17:29.052 --> 08:17:30.187
TWELVE BILLS AND WHAT WE HAVE
08:17:30.253 --> 08:17:32.789
HEARD. A TWO ALREADY TODAY SO I
08:17:32.856 --> 08:17:34.824
STRONGLY ASTRONOMICAL. THANK YOU
08:17:34.891 --> 08:17:36.393
CENTER LAYERED MEMBERS FURTHER
08:17:36.459 --> 08:17:38.762
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
08:17:38.828 --> 08:17:40.931
HEARING NONE. MEMBERS THIS
08:17:40.997 --> 08:17:42.599
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
08:17:42.666 --> 08:17:45.035
CALL UNLESS DID YOU WANNA CLOSE
08:17:45.101 --> 08:17:47.537
SENATOR BAKER. VERY GOOD ANY
08:17:47.604 --> 08:17:48.538
OBJECTION TO UNANIMOUS ROLL
08:17:48.605 --> 08:17:51.875
CALL. HEARING AND SEEING NONE I
08:17:51.942 --> 08:17:53.777
THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
08:17:53.843 --> 08:17:55.478
PASSES. MOVING TO FILE ITEM
08:17:55.545 --> 08:17:57.013
NINETY TWO SENATOR LIMÓN MADAM
08:17:57.080 --> 08:17:58.682
SECRETARY PLEASE READ. SENATE
08:17:58.748 --> 08:18:01.451
BILL ELEVEN SEVENTY SIX BY
08:18:01.518 --> 08:18:02.586
SENATOR LIMÓN AN ACT RELATING TO
08:18:02.652 --> 08:18:05.255
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS SIMILARLY
08:18:05.322 --> 08:18:07.057
MON. THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT.
08:18:07.123 --> 08:18:09.025
SB ELEVEN SEVENTY SIX REPRESENT
08:18:09.092 --> 08:18:10.493
THE CAN THE CONTINUATION OF AN
08:18:10.560 --> 08:18:11.695
IMPORTANT CONVERSATION ABOUT HOW
08:18:11.761 --> 08:18:13.063
WELL OUR FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
08:18:13.129 --> 08:18:14.231
ARE SERVING COMMUNITIES IN
08:18:14.297 --> 08:18:16.800
CALIFORNIA. IN NINETEEN SEVENTY
08:18:16.866 --> 08:18:17.467
SEVEN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TRY
08:18:17.534 --> 08:18:18.969
TO ADDRESS THESE DISPARITIES BY
08:18:19.035 --> 08:18:19.569
PASSING THE COMMUNITY
08:18:19.636 --> 08:18:21.304
REINVESTMENT ACT ALSO KNOWN AS
08:18:21.371 --> 08:18:23.406
THE CRP. WHICH ESTABLISHES A
08:18:23.473 --> 08:18:26.409
FRAMEWORK TO EVALUATE HOW WELL-BANKS ARE MEETING THE FINANCIAL
08:18:26.476 --> 08:18:27.811
SERVICES NEEDS OF THE
08:18:27.877 --> 08:18:28.878
COMMUNITIES IN WHICH THEY DO
08:18:28.945 --> 08:18:30.480
BUSINESS. THIS BILL WILL BEGIN
08:18:30.547 --> 08:18:32.349
THE PROCESS OF EXAMINING WHETHER
08:18:32.415 --> 08:18:33.683
IT'S C. R. A. LAW OR OTHER
08:18:33.750 --> 08:18:35.385
POLICIES TO ADDRESS EQUITY IN
08:18:35.452 --> 08:18:37.153
FINANCIAL SERVICES WOULD BE
08:18:37.220 --> 08:18:38.321
BENEFICIAL TO CALIFORNIA
08:18:38.388 --> 08:18:39.923
COMMUNITIES. WELL THIS BILL DOES
08:18:39.990 --> 08:18:41.291
NOT ESTABLISH ANY NEW
08:18:41.358 --> 08:18:42.559
REGULATIONS IN CALIFORNIA I SEE
08:18:42.626 --> 08:18:44.327
THIS IS THE FIRST STEP TOWARDS
08:18:44.394 --> 08:18:46.329
THE EVENTUAL GOAL I RESPECTFULLY
08:18:46.396 --> 08:18:48.298
ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE. THANK YOU
08:18:48.365 --> 08:18:51.134
SANDEL AMONG MEMBERS ANY
08:18:51.201 --> 08:18:52.569
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
08:18:52.636 --> 08:18:53.937
HEARING NONE MADAM SECRETARY
08:18:54.004 --> 08:18:58.108
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
08:18:58.174 --> 08:19:02.212
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
08:19:02.279 --> 08:19:07.284
NO BAKER I FOR JUST NO BRADFORD
08:19:07.350 --> 08:19:10.420
AYE CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
08:19:10.487 --> 08:19:15.492
DALY. NO DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
08:19:15.558 --> 08:19:19.863
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
08:19:19.929 --> 08:19:25.201
GROWTH. NO HERTZBERG WESSEL I
08:19:25.268 --> 08:19:29.606
FURTADO I JONES NO KAMLAGER.
08:19:29.673 --> 08:19:36.179
LAYARD. KAMLAGER I LAYERED AYE
08:19:36.246 --> 08:19:40.150
LEYVA AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE. I
08:19:40.216 --> 08:19:44.754
MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN AYE
08:19:44.821 --> 08:19:50.160
NIELSEN NO A CHOI BOGUE AYE PAN
08:19:50.226 --> 08:19:54.964
AYE PORTANTINO. I ROTH AYE RUBIO
08:19:55.031 --> 08:20:00.070
I SKINNER I STERN AYE I'M BURKE
08:20:00.136 --> 08:20:04.708
HI FORECASTING AYE WIENER I WILK
08:20:04.774 --> 08:20:07.510
NO I THIRTY ONE KNOWS EIGHT THE
08:20:07.577 --> 08:20:09.045
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
08:20:09.112 --> 08:20:11.748
MOVING TO FILE ITEM NINETY THREE
08:20:11.815 --> 08:20:12.315
SENATOR ROTHMAN'S SECRETARY
08:20:12.382 --> 08:20:15.485
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL ELEVEN
08:20:15.552 --> 08:20:16.553
NINETY NINE BY SENATOR ROTH AN
08:20:16.619 --> 08:20:18.088
ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC POST
08:20:18.154 --> 08:20:20.223
SECONDARY EDUCATION CENTER ROTH
08:20:20.290 --> 08:20:21.291
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT THIS
08:20:21.358 --> 08:20:22.992
BILL AUTHORIZES THE REGENTS OF
08:20:23.059 --> 08:20:24.694
THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA.
08:20:24.761 --> 08:20:26.162
SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATIONS IS
08:20:26.229 --> 08:20:27.731
SECURED ACUTE CARE TEACHING
08:20:27.797 --> 08:20:29.999
HOSPITAL IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY FOR
08:20:30.066 --> 08:20:31.167
THE PURPOSE OF TRAINING YOU SEE
08:20:31.234 --> 08:20:32.769
OUR SCHOOL OF MEDICINE MEDICAL
08:20:32.836 --> 08:20:34.337
STUDENTS MEDICAL RESIDENTS AND
08:20:34.404 --> 08:20:37.006
MEDICAL FELLOWS. AS SOME OF YOU
08:20:37.073 --> 08:20:38.108
MAY RECALL THE SCHOOL OF
08:20:38.174 --> 08:20:39.209
MEDICINE WAS DESIGNED IN
08:20:39.275 --> 08:20:39.943
ESTABLISHED FOR BUDGETARY
08:20:40.009 --> 08:20:42.379
REASONS IN TWO THOUSAND THIRTEEN
08:20:42.445 --> 08:20:43.847
AS A COMMUNITY BASED MEDICAL
08:20:43.913 --> 08:20:45.115
SCHOOL WITHOUT THE BENEFIT OF A
08:20:45.181 --> 08:20:47.117
DEDICATED UC HOSPITAL OR MEDICAL
08:20:47.183 --> 08:20:48.852
CENTRE FOR CLINICAL TRAINING AND
08:20:48.918 --> 08:20:49.953
EDUCATION OF ITS MEDICAL
08:20:50.019 --> 08:20:51.955
STUDENTS AND RESIDENTS. TO DATE
08:20:52.021 --> 08:20:54.624
IT IS THE ONLY UC MEDICAL SCHOOL
08:20:54.691 --> 08:20:56.559
TO OPERATE WITHOUT A DEDICATED
08:20:56.626 --> 08:21:00.330
UC ACADEMIC MEDICAL CENTER.
08:21:00.397 --> 08:21:01.264
COLLEAGUES OBVIOUSLY THIS IS
08:21:01.331 --> 08:21:02.665
SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATION BUT
08:21:02.732 --> 08:21:04.367
THIS IS THE FINAL MILE OF OUR
08:21:04.434 --> 08:21:06.035
VERY VERY LONG JOURNEY TO
08:21:06.102 --> 08:21:07.637
PROVIDE CRITICAL ACADEMIC
08:21:07.704 --> 08:21:09.839
MEDICAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING.
08:21:09.906 --> 08:21:11.841
IN THIS MEDICALLY UNDER SERVED
08:21:11.908 --> 08:21:14.344
REGION OF THE STATE. FOR THOSE
08:21:14.411 --> 08:21:15.879
OF YOU WHO'VE BEEN HERE AND YOU
08:21:15.945 --> 08:21:17.213
SAID YOU'VE SUPPORTED THIS
08:21:17.280 --> 08:21:19.182
EFFORT OVER THE YEARS I WANT TO
08:21:19.249 --> 08:21:20.150
SAY THANK YOU I WANT TO SAY
08:21:20.216 --> 08:21:22.485
SPECIFICALLY THANK YOU TO. MY CO
08:21:22.552 --> 08:21:24.087
AUTHOR THE SENATOR FROM YOU
08:21:24.154 --> 08:21:25.321
COOPER AND THOSE OF YOU WHO HAVE
08:21:25.388 --> 08:21:27.357
ALSO INDICATED YOU WISH TO COST
08:21:27.424 --> 08:21:29.259
OF THIS MEASURE. I RESPECTFULLY
08:21:29.325 --> 08:21:31.227
AS FOR A VOTE. THANK YOU CENTER
08:21:31.294 --> 08:21:32.862
ROTH MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
08:21:32.929 --> 08:21:35.632
DEBATE. SEEING AND HEARING NONE-
08:21:35.698 --> 08:21:37.300
SENATOR HUESO AND THEN SENATOR
08:21:37.367 --> 08:21:39.002
CHAU BOOK I'D LIKE TO BE HONEST
08:21:39.068 --> 08:21:41.604
CO AUTHORS WELL. YOU GOT IT.
08:21:41.671 --> 08:21:44.107
CENTER CHOKE. SENATE PRESIDENT
08:21:44.174 --> 08:21:46.276
AND MEMBERS. I RISE AS A PROUD
08:21:46.342 --> 08:21:48.178
JOIN AUTHOR OF THIS MEASURE. I
08:21:48.244 --> 08:21:50.880
WANTED TO START BY THANKING THE
08:21:50.947 --> 08:21:51.881
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING THIS
08:21:51.948 --> 08:21:52.449
IMPORTANT MEASURE FORWARD.
08:21:52.515 --> 08:21:53.950
HISTORICALLY THE INLAND EMPIRE
08:21:54.017 --> 08:21:55.185
HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MOST
08:21:55.251 --> 08:21:56.352
MEDICALLY UNDERSERVED
08:21:56.419 --> 08:21:57.987
COMMUNITIES IN THE COUNTRY.
08:21:58.054 --> 08:21:59.022
ACCORDING TO THE CALIFORNIA
08:21:59.088 --> 08:22:00.323
HEALTH CARE FOUNDATION THE
08:22:00.390 --> 08:22:01.891
REGION HAS ONLY THIRTY FIVE
08:22:01.958 --> 08:22:05.395
PRIMARY GIPSON POSITIONS PER ONE
08:22:05.462 --> 08:22:06.763
HUNDRED THOUSAND PEOPLE COMPARED
08:22:06.830 --> 08:22:07.664
TO SEVENTY OR MORE IN OTHER
08:22:07.730 --> 08:22:09.065
PARTS OF THE STATE. THE ROLE
08:22:09.132 --> 08:22:10.500
NATURE OF OUR AREA BRINGS ABOUT
08:22:10.567 --> 08:22:11.835
VERY UNIQUE CHALLENGES THAT
08:22:11.901 --> 08:22:13.169
REQUIRE EQUALLY UNIQUE AND
08:22:13.236 --> 08:22:15.138
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS. THE
08:22:15.205 --> 08:22:16.439
RESEARCH SHOWS THAT THE DOCTORS
08:22:16.506 --> 08:22:18.141
ARE MUCH MORE LIKELY TO STAY IN
08:22:18.208 --> 08:22:19.809
PRACTICE WHERE WHEREVER THEY DO
08:22:19.876 --> 08:22:21.744
THEIR RESIDENCY. THAT IS WHY
08:22:21.811 --> 08:22:23.446
THIS BILL IS SO ESSENTIAL IN WAS
08:22:23.513 --> 08:22:24.981
THE INLAND EMPIRE IN THE RIGHT
08:22:25.048 --> 08:22:26.583
DIRECTION BY CREATING THE CUTE
08:22:26.649 --> 08:22:27.650
CARE TEACHING HOSPITAL IN
08:22:27.717 --> 08:22:29.819
RIVERSIDE COUNTY WE MUST DO ALL
08:22:29.886 --> 08:22:31.654
THAT WE CAN TO INCREASE ACCESS
08:22:31.721 --> 08:22:33.356
TO EQUITABLE QUALITY AND TIMELY
08:22:33.423 --> 08:22:35.425
CARE FOR THOSE LIVING IN THE
08:22:35.492 --> 08:22:36.960
INLAND EMPIRE. THANK YOU. THANK
08:22:37.026 --> 08:22:38.361
YOU SENATOR CHOI BOGUE CENTER
08:22:38.428 --> 08:22:41.397
DORADO. YES I WANT TO THANK THE-
08:22:41.464 --> 08:22:44.534
AUTHOR OF THE BILL- THE FIRST
08:22:44.601 --> 08:22:47.003
YEAR I WAS HERE OF THIS TERM- I
08:22:47.070 --> 08:22:48.805
WILL NEVER FORGET. HEARING THE
08:22:48.872 --> 08:22:52.308
TESTIMONY. OF A YOUNG LATINO
08:22:52.375 --> 08:22:54.310
AHMED STUDENTS WHO WERE TALKING
08:22:54.377 --> 08:22:56.579
ABOUT. NOT ONLY GOING TO SCHOOL
08:22:56.646 --> 08:22:58.581
BUT THEIR FULL INTENTION AND
08:22:58.648 --> 08:23:00.750
THEY KNEW THAT BY HAVING THIS
08:23:00.817 --> 08:23:03.019
SCHOOL. IN AN AREA LIKE THE
08:23:03.086 --> 08:23:04.020
INLAND EMPIRE AND RIVERSIDE
08:23:04.087 --> 08:23:06.923
THAT. HE WAS THEY WERE GOING TO
08:23:06.990 --> 08:23:08.191
COME BACK. THE YOU KNOW MIGHT
08:23:08.258 --> 08:23:09.259
HAVE TO LEAVE FOR A WHILE BUT
08:23:09.325 --> 08:23:11.194
THEY WERE DEFINITELY COMING BACK
08:23:11.261 --> 08:23:12.996
AND SO. I WAS SO PROUD OF TO
08:23:13.062 --> 08:23:14.697
SUPPORT IT THEN AND I'M REALLY
08:23:14.764 --> 08:23:16.232
GRATEFUL THAT YOU HAVE DRIVEN
08:23:16.299 --> 08:23:18.134
AND DRIVEN AND DRIVEN IT SO.
08:23:18.201 --> 08:23:20.003
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANK YOU
08:23:20.069 --> 08:23:23.306
SENATOR DORADO CENTER ROTH WOULD
08:23:23.373 --> 08:23:24.908
YOU LIKE TO CLOSE. THANK YOU
08:23:24.974 --> 08:23:26.242
EVERYONE WHO'S SPOKEN IN JUST
08:23:26.309 --> 08:23:27.544
RESPECTFULLY HAS FROM THE VOTE
08:23:27.610 --> 08:23:28.912
THANK YOU SENATE ROTH THIS
08:23:28.978 --> 08:23:31.047
QUALIFIES FOR UNANIMOUS ROLL
08:23:31.114 --> 08:23:32.982
CALL IS THERE ANY OBJECTION.
08:23:33.049 --> 08:23:35.051
SEEING AND HEARING NONE IS
08:23:35.118 --> 08:23:36.185
THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE MEASURE
08:23:36.252 --> 08:23:38.021
PASSES MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON THE
08:23:38.087 --> 08:23:39.355
FILE ITEM NUMBER NINETY FOUR
08:23:39.422 --> 08:23:40.790
SENATOR BAKER MADAM SECRETARY
08:23:40.857 --> 08:23:43.293
PLEASE READ. SENATE BILL TWELVE
08:23:43.359 --> 08:23:44.794
OH THREE BY SENATOR BACK FOR AN
08:23:44.861 --> 08:23:46.429
ACT RELATING TO GREENHOUSE GASES
08:23:46.496 --> 08:23:49.832
CENTER BAKER. THANK YOU. BUT AS
08:23:49.899 --> 08:23:51.267
YOU KNOW A CALIFORNIA WE SET A
08:23:51.334 --> 08:23:53.836
TARGET TO BE NET ZERO BY TWENTY
08:23:53.903 --> 08:23:55.004
FORTY FIVE SO WE'RE ASKING OUR-
08:23:55.071 --> 08:23:56.406
COMPANIES AND OUR CITIZENS TO
08:23:56.472 --> 08:23:57.740
FIGURE OUT HOW TO. A
08:23:57.807 --> 08:23:59.108
DRAMATICALLY REDUCE OUR
08:23:59.175 --> 08:24:00.944
EMISSIONS IN ORDER TO HIT THAT
08:24:01.010 --> 08:24:02.812
TARGET. AND I BELIEVE IT'S
08:24:02.879 --> 08:24:04.714
IMPORTANT THAT OUR GOVERNMENT.
08:24:04.781 --> 08:24:06.616
LEAD BY EXAMPLE THAT'S WHAT THIS
08:24:06.683 --> 08:24:08.918
BILL IS ABOUT IT'S A IT'S A
08:24:08.985 --> 08:24:10.653
PLANNING GOAL FOR ALL OF OUR
08:24:10.720 --> 08:24:11.854
STATE AGENCIES. TO AIM TO BE NET
08:24:11.921 --> 08:24:14.090
ZERO FOR THEIR OWN OPERATIONS BY
08:24:14.157 --> 08:24:14.958
TWENTY THIRTY FIVE SO IT'S
08:24:15.024 --> 08:24:17.260
REALLY IT'S A LINE WITH A NUMBER
08:24:17.327 --> 08:24:18.628
OF THE BILLS WE'VE HAD IT'S-
08:24:18.695 --> 08:24:19.596
IT'S- MORE EXPENSIVE IT'S REALLY
08:24:19.662 --> 08:24:21.030
ABOUT. THE TRANSPORTATION FLEET
08:24:21.097 --> 08:24:22.799
IS ABOUT BUILDINGS AND ABOUT
08:24:22.865 --> 08:24:25.001
ELECTRICITY. THIS IS PART OF THE
08:24:25.068 --> 08:24:26.669
CLIMATE WORKING GROUP PACKAGE
08:24:26.736 --> 08:24:28.972
AND I WHEN I THINK OF THE CENTER
08:24:29.038 --> 08:24:30.640
FOR MERCED AND- THE CENTER FOR
08:24:30.707 --> 08:24:32.008
THE EAST BAY FOR WORKING VERY
08:24:32.075 --> 08:24:33.476
CLOSELY WITH ME. ON THIS BILL
08:24:33.543 --> 08:24:35.111
AND EXPECT FASTER AYE VOTE.
08:24:35.178 --> 08:24:37.213
THANK YOU SENATOR BAKER MEMBERS
08:24:37.280 --> 08:24:40.550
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE. SEEING AND
08:24:40.617 --> 08:24:41.551
HEARING NONE AND SECRETARY
08:24:41.618 --> 08:24:44.554
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL. ALLEN AYE
08:24:44.621 --> 08:24:48.691
ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
08:24:48.758 --> 08:24:55.164
NO BAKER. I FORTUS. BRADFORD AYE
08:24:55.231 --> 08:24:58.234
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
08:24:58.301 --> 08:25:03.373
DALY NO DODD AYE TORONTO AYE
08:25:03.439 --> 08:25:07.176
EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I
08:25:07.243 --> 08:25:11.547
GROW. NO HERTZBERG WEST SO I
08:25:11.614 --> 08:25:16.185
FURTADO I JONES NO KAMLAGER I
08:25:16.252 --> 08:25:20.957
LAYERED. I LEYVA AYE LIMÓN I
08:25:21.024 --> 08:25:27.830
MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ NO MAN. I
08:25:27.897 --> 08:25:33.569
NEWMAN I NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF
08:25:33.636 --> 08:25:39.075
BOTH NO PAN. I PORTANTINO I ROTH
08:25:39.142 --> 08:25:43.746
AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER. I STERN
08:25:43.813 --> 08:25:46.883
AYE I'M BURKE HI MY COUNTY I
08:25:46.949 --> 08:25:51.220
WIENER. I WILK NO PLEASE CALL
08:25:51.287 --> 08:25:55.558
THE ABSENT MEMBERS. FORTUS NO.
08:25:55.625 --> 08:25:57.960
HERTZBERG I THIRTY KNOWS NINE
08:25:58.027 --> 08:25:59.696
THE MASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
08:25:59.762 --> 08:26:01.564
MOVING TO FILE ITEM NINETY FIVE
08:26:01.631 --> 08:26:03.099
SENATORS SKINNER MADAM SECRETARY
08:26:03.166 --> 08:26:05.068
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TWELVE
08:26:05.134 --> 08:26:06.836
THOSE SIX BY SENATOR SKINNER AN
08:26:06.903 --> 08:26:08.738
ACT RELATING TO GREENHOUSE GASES
08:26:08.805 --> 08:26:11.074
CENTER SKINNER THANK YOU ARE
08:26:11.140 --> 08:26:12.809
MADAM PRESIDENT MEMBERS THE
08:26:12.875 --> 08:26:14.110
CHEMICALS THAT MAKE OUR
08:26:14.177 --> 08:26:16.379
REFRIGERATORS COLD ARE HYDRO
08:26:16.446 --> 08:26:19.649
FLUOROCARBONS HSCS AND THEY ARE
08:26:19.716 --> 08:26:21.284
A GROUP OF CHEMICALS ALONG WITH
08:26:21.350 --> 08:26:22.885
SOME OTHER THINGS THAT ARE
08:26:22.952 --> 08:26:24.454
CONSIDERED NOT CONSIDERED THEY
08:26:24.520 --> 08:26:27.123
ACTUALLY ARE CHEMICALS WITH WHAT
08:26:27.190 --> 08:26:29.525
THEY CALL HIGH GLOBAL WARMING
08:26:29.592 --> 08:26:31.761
POTENTIAL WHICH MEANS WELL THEY
08:26:31.828 --> 08:26:34.697
SHORT LIFE IN THE ATMOSPHERE IF
08:26:34.764 --> 08:26:36.833
THEY'RE RELEASED MAYBE TWENTY
08:26:36.899 --> 08:26:38.735
YEARS FOR THAT TWENTY YEARS
08:26:38.801 --> 08:26:40.503
THAT THEY'RE IN THE ATMOSPHERE
08:26:40.570 --> 08:26:42.605
THEY ARE THOUSANDS OF TIMES
08:26:42.672 --> 08:26:45.108
MORE POWERFUL IN TERMS OF
08:26:45.174 --> 08:26:48.177
TRAPPING HEAT GASES THEN CO TWO
08:26:48.978 --> 08:26:52.315
SO THE BENEFIT OF TRYING TO GET
08:26:52.381 --> 08:26:54.050
REDUCE OUR USE OF THESE AND GET
08:26:54.117 --> 08:26:55.918
THESE OUT OF THE ATMOSPHERE OR
08:26:55.985 --> 08:26:57.386
PREVENT THEM FROM GOING THERE
08:26:57.453 --> 08:27:00.923
NOW IS A CRISIS TIME SO THAT
08:27:00.990 --> 08:27:02.024
WE CAN TAKE A LITTLE LONGER
08:27:02.091 --> 08:27:03.259
FOR THE HARDER TRANSITION
08:27:03.326 --> 08:27:05.261
THAT'S MORE ECONOMY WIDE SO
08:27:05.328 --> 08:27:08.231
WHAT THIS BILL DOES IS TO HELP
08:27:08.297 --> 08:27:10.867
US ACHIEVE THAT BY REQUIRING
08:27:10.933 --> 08:27:12.635
WHAT'S CALLED NON RECLAIMED
08:27:12.702 --> 08:27:15.471
OR NEW HFC SOLD IN CALIFORNIA
08:27:15.538 --> 08:27:17.540
TO MEET A LOWER GLOBAL
08:27:17.607 --> 08:27:21.110
WARMING POTENTIAL AND TO ALSO
08:27:21.177 --> 08:27:24.046
INCENTIVIZE THE RECLAIMING OF
08:27:24.113 --> 08:27:25.615
IT IN OTHER WORDS THE CAPTURING
08:27:25.681 --> 08:27:27.350
OF THAT GAS OUT OF POLITICAL
08:27:27.416 --> 08:27:28.918
EXISTING RECRUITMENT AND THEN
08:27:28.985 --> 08:27:30.887
RE USING IT RATHER THAN HAVING
08:27:30.953 --> 08:27:33.022
TO KEEP BUYING NEW I WORKED
08:27:33.089 --> 08:27:34.123
WITH THE OPPOSITION WITH OUR
08:27:34.190 --> 08:27:35.358
GROCERS WITH THE HEATING AND
08:27:35.424 --> 08:27:36.692
AIR CONDITIONING MANUFACTURERS
08:27:36.759 --> 08:27:38.561
AND MADE AMENDMENTS THAT PUSHED
08:27:38.628 --> 08:27:40.396
BACK THE IMPLEMENTATION DATE
08:27:40.463 --> 08:27:41.998
SO IT BETTER ALIGNS WITH SOME
08:27:42.064 --> 08:27:44.167
EXISTING REQUIREMENTS WE HAVE
08:27:44.233 --> 08:27:45.902
THERE'S ALSO MONEY IN THE
08:27:45.968 --> 08:27:47.904
PROPOSED BUDGET THAT WOULD HELP
08:27:47.970 --> 08:27:50.540
SUPPORT OUR GROCERY STORES TO
08:27:50.606 --> 08:27:52.708
DO RETROFITS FOR THE S.
08:27:52.775 --> 08:27:53.976
AND WITHOUT AYE ELSEVIER AYE
08:27:54.043 --> 08:27:56.112
VOTE THANK YOU CENTER SKINNER
08:27:56.179 --> 08:27:58.281
MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR DEBATE
08:27:59.115 --> 08:28:00.249
SEEING AND HEARING NONE MADAM
08:28:00.316 --> 08:28:02.819
SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
08:28:03.719 --> 08:28:07.056
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
08:28:07.123 --> 08:28:10.860
ATKINS AYE BATES NO BAKER
08:28:12.094 --> 08:28:15.064
I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
08:28:17.133 --> 08:28:20.703
CABALLERO AYE CORTESE AYE DALY
08:28:21.237 --> 08:28:26.609
NO DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
08:28:26.676 --> 08:28:31.147
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW NO
08:28:31.214 --> 08:28:34.584
HERTZBERG WESSEL AYE HURTADO
08:28:34.984 --> 08:28:39.155
AYE JONES NOPE KAMLAGER AYE
08:28:39.222 --> 08:28:42.825
LAYERED AYE LEYVA AYE THE MOANS
08:28:43.359 --> 08:28:46.629
I MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ NOPE
08:28:46.696 --> 08:28:50.366
MEN AYE NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN
08:28:50.967 --> 08:28:54.937
NO A SHOW OF THE OAK NO PAN I
08:28:55.004 --> 08:29:00.076
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO I
08:29:00.142 --> 08:29:03.646
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE AMBERG
08:29:04.347 --> 08:29:07.550
AYE AYE CASKEY AYE WIENER AYE
08:29:07.617 --> 08:29:10.253
WILK NOW PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
08:29:10.319 --> 08:29:14.924
MEMBERS BRADFORD I HERTZBERG
08:29:15.524 --> 08:29:16.826
ICE THIRTY KNOWS NINE THE
08:29:16.893 --> 08:29:18.394
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS ARE
08:29:18.461 --> 08:29:20.062
MOVING THE FILE ITEM NINETY SIX
08:29:20.129 --> 08:29:21.664
SENATOR EGGMAN MADAM SECRETARY
08:29:21.731 --> 08:29:23.566
PLEASE READ SENATE BILL TWELVE
08:29:23.633 --> 08:29:25.268
OH NINE BY SENATOR EGGMAN AN
08:29:25.334 --> 08:29:26.903
ACT RELATING TO SENTENCING
08:29:26.969 --> 08:29:28.971
CENTER EGGMAN THANK YOU VERY
08:29:29.038 --> 08:29:30.640
MUCH OF MADAM PRESIDENT SB
08:29:30.706 --> 08:29:32.041
TWELVE OH NINE HAS TO DO
08:29:32.108 --> 08:29:34.477
WITH THE APPLICATION OF THE
08:29:34.543 --> 08:29:36.379
OF THE MITIGATION OF TRAUMA
08:29:36.445 --> 08:29:37.947
FOR VETERANS WHEN THEY'RE
08:29:38.014 --> 08:29:39.448
FACED WITH RESENTENCING I ASK
08:29:39.515 --> 08:29:40.416
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THIS BILL
08:29:40.483 --> 08:29:41.884
HAS NO OPPOSITION THANK YOU
08:29:41.951 --> 08:29:43.185
SENATOR EGGMAN DISCUSSION
08:29:43.252 --> 08:29:45.254
AND DEBATE SENATOR NIELSEN
08:29:46.956 --> 08:29:49.091
WELL I MAY BE INSIGNIFICANT
08:29:49.158 --> 08:29:51.160
BUT I DO ABOUT
08:29:53.396 --> 08:29:53.963
AND
08:29:56.766 --> 08:29:58.200
WE ALL HAVE SYMPATHY FOR THE
08:29:58.267 --> 08:30:00.569
MILITARY AND THE STRESSES UNDER
08:30:00.636 --> 08:30:02.905
WHICH THEY HAVE TO SUFFER AND
08:30:02.972 --> 08:30:05.541
INDOOR THE NIGHTMARES THEY HAVE
08:30:05.608 --> 08:30:07.843
FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES
08:30:07.910 --> 08:30:11.013
I UNDERSTAND THAT BUT THIS
08:30:11.080 --> 08:30:15.351
SEPSIS CLASS APART THERE WAS
08:30:15.418 --> 08:30:17.053
AN OLD DEFENSE STILL AROUND
08:30:17.119 --> 08:30:19.021
CALL DIMINISH CAPACITY SO YOU
08:30:19.088 --> 08:30:20.389
KILL SOMEBODY BUT YOU HAD A
08:30:20.456 --> 08:30:21.924
DIMINISHED CAPACITY HERE FOR
08:30:21.991 --> 08:30:24.093
YOU CANNOT BE AS GUILTY WE'RE
08:30:24.160 --> 08:30:26.929
DOING THAT OR IN SOME CASES GO
08:30:26.996 --> 08:30:28.798
FREE FOR WHATEVER YOU'RE CRIME
08:30:28.864 --> 08:30:30.433
WAS BECAUSE OF YOUR DIMINISH
08:30:30.499 --> 08:30:33.669
CAPACITY THOSE WHO SERVE IN
08:30:33.736 --> 08:30:34.937
THE MILITARY I THINK THAT ALL
08:30:35.004 --> 08:30:35.838
COME HOME WITH A LITTLE BIT
08:30:35.905 --> 08:30:37.273
OF DIMINISHED CAPACITY FOR THE
08:30:37.340 --> 08:30:39.976
RIGORS OF THEIR TASKS AND THEIR
08:30:40.042 --> 08:30:43.512
SACRIFICES BUT CRIMINALS I
08:30:43.579 --> 08:30:45.715
DON'T THINK NECESSARILY DESERVE
08:30:45.781 --> 08:30:48.217
THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PETTY
08:30:48.284 --> 08:30:51.921
THIEVES HERE AND THIS CREATES
08:30:53.189 --> 08:30:55.825
ALMOST AN EXEMPTION IT'S NOT AN
08:30:55.891 --> 08:30:59.195
ABSOLUTE DEFENSE FIRM SO VERY
08:30:59.428 --> 08:31:03.699
SEVERE BEHAVIOR DOES THAT IN
08:31:04.633 --> 08:31:06.969
AND THEN CLOSE IT THINK ABOUT
08:31:07.036 --> 08:31:10.506
THE VICTIMS GRIEVING THE LOSS
08:31:10.573 --> 08:31:13.075
OF THEIR LOVED ONES DECEASED
08:31:13.142 --> 08:31:15.578
AND BURIED FOREVER -- BUT
08:31:15.644 --> 08:31:20.816
THE KILLER HAD POSTTRAUMATIC
08:31:20.883 --> 08:31:23.519
STRESS DISORDER OR SOMETHING
08:31:23.586 --> 08:31:26.088
EVEN LESSER I REGION OVER
08:31:27.256 --> 08:31:29.258
THANK YOU CENTER NIELSEN
08:31:30.860 --> 08:31:33.362
CENTER GROVE THE AIR NAY
08:31:34.230 --> 08:31:35.498
MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND
08:31:35.564 --> 08:31:36.766
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NO
08:31:36.832 --> 08:31:37.833
MORE CENTER EGGMAN YOU MAY
08:31:37.900 --> 08:31:39.435
CLOSE THANK YOU VERY MUCH WE
08:31:39.502 --> 08:31:40.870
HAVE ALREADY PASSED WE HAVE
08:31:40.936 --> 08:31:42.204
ALREADY ACKNOWLEDGED IT BETTER
08:31:42.271 --> 08:31:43.806
SOMETIMES COME HOME TRAUMA
08:31:43.873 --> 08:31:45.007
SOMETIMES THEIR REACTION TO
08:31:45.074 --> 08:31:47.343
A SITUATION MIGHT NEED SOME
08:31:47.410 --> 08:31:49.011
MEDICATION WE HAVE PASSED THAT
08:31:49.078 --> 08:31:51.080
LAW THIS THEN APPLIES THAT
08:31:51.147 --> 08:31:52.782
TO FOR RESENTENCING IT'S BEEN
08:31:52.848 --> 08:31:53.883
POINTED OUT THAT THE SUCH A
08:31:53.949 --> 08:31:55.718
TRAVESTY THAT DOES NOT APPLY
08:31:55.785 --> 08:31:57.853
EVENLY TO ALL VETERANS THIS
08:31:57.920 --> 08:32:00.089
APPLIES EVENLY TO ALL VETERANS
08:32:00.156 --> 08:32:01.290
THE MOST HEINOUS CRIMES HAVE
08:32:01.357 --> 08:32:03.092
BEEN REMOVED FROM THIS BILL
08:32:03.159 --> 08:32:04.560
I ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE THANK
08:32:04.627 --> 08:32:06.629
SAN EGGMAN MA'AM SECRETARY
08:32:06.829 --> 08:32:09.331
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
08:32:09.632 --> 08:32:13.169
AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
08:32:13.235 --> 08:32:17.540
BATES AYE BAKER I PORCHES
08:32:19.708 --> 08:32:22.244
BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO
08:32:22.711 --> 08:32:26.749
AYE CORTESE AYE DALY DODD
08:32:27.550 --> 08:32:31.053
AYE TORONTO AYE EGGMAN AYE
08:32:31.120 --> 08:32:36.058
GLAZER GONZALEZ AYE GROVE AYE
08:32:36.125 --> 08:32:39.695
HERTZBERG WEST SO I HER TADO
08:32:40.362 --> 08:32:45.801
I JONES I KAMLAGER HI THERE I
08:32:45.868 --> 08:32:49.605
LEYVA AYE THE MOON I MCGUIRE
08:32:50.106 --> 08:32:54.276
AYE MELENDEZ MANY AYE NEWMAN
08:32:54.844 --> 08:32:59.148
AYE NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED I
08:32:59.215 --> 08:33:03.886
PAN AYE PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE
08:33:03.953 --> 08:33:07.790
RUBIO AYE SKINNER AYE STERN
08:33:08.224 --> 08:33:11.560
AYE AMBERG AYE FORECASTING AYE
08:33:11.627 --> 08:33:15.297
WIENER AYE WILK I PLEASE CALL
08:33:15.364 --> 08:33:17.633
THE ABSENT MEMBERS PURCHASE
08:33:18.667 --> 08:33:24.940
DALLY I GLAZER I HERTZBERG
08:33:25.307 --> 08:33:28.777
MELENDEZ I WAS THIRTY SIX NEWS
08:33:28.844 --> 08:33:30.880
WANT THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:33:30.946 --> 08:33:32.181
ARE MOVING TO FILE ITEM NINETY
08:33:32.248 --> 08:33:34.416
SEVEN SENATOR LEE MON M.
08:33:34.483 --> 08:33:36.218
SECRETARY PLEASE READ SENATE
08:33:36.285 --> 08:33:37.586
BILL TWELVE THIRTY BY SENATOR
08:33:37.653 --> 08:33:39.722
A REHMAN AN ACT RELATING TO OUR
08:33:39.788 --> 08:33:41.790
AIR POLLUTION CENTER THE MONTH
08:33:41.857 --> 08:33:43.092
THANK YOU MADAM PRESIDENT SB
08:33:43.159 --> 08:33:44.226
TWELVE THIRTY WILL STREAMLINE
08:33:44.293 --> 08:33:45.728
THE VARIOUS PROGRAMS CALIFORNIA
08:33:45.794 --> 08:33:47.730
HAS TO INCENTIVIZE CONSUMERS
08:33:47.796 --> 08:33:48.998
TO SWITCH TO LOWER EMISSION
08:33:49.064 --> 08:33:51.100
VEHICLES THIS BILL REQUIRE CARD
08:33:51.167 --> 08:33:52.568
TO CREATE ONE SINGLE PORTER
08:33:52.635 --> 08:33:54.537
WERE A PERSON CAN APPLY FOR
08:33:54.603 --> 08:33:56.005
ALL PROGRAMS ONLINE MAKING
08:33:56.071 --> 08:33:57.840
THE NETWORK OF PROGRAMS EASIER
08:33:57.907 --> 08:33:59.642
TO UNDERSTAND AND ACCESS
08:33:59.708 --> 08:34:01.177
ADDITIONALLY SB TWELVE THIRTY
08:34:01.243 --> 08:34:02.745
EXPAND THE CLEAR CREEK CLEAN
08:34:02.811 --> 08:34:04.280
CARS FOR ALL PROGRAM TO MORE
08:34:04.346 --> 08:34:05.648
AREAS OF THE STATE AND ASK
08:34:05.714 --> 08:34:07.082
HER TO EXPEDITE THAT APPROVAL
08:34:07.149 --> 08:34:09.051
PROCESS I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
08:34:09.118 --> 08:34:10.519
AN AYE VOTE THANK YOU CENTER
08:34:10.586 --> 08:34:12.154
LIMóN MEMBERS DISCUSSION OR
08:34:12.221 --> 08:34:14.990
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
08:34:15.057 --> 08:34:16.292
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL
08:34:16.358 --> 08:34:20.029
THE ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
08:34:20.429 --> 08:34:25.601
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES BAKER I
08:34:25.668 --> 08:34:29.972
PORCHES BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO
08:34:32.841 --> 08:34:37.713
CORTESE AYE DADDY AYE DODD I
08:34:37.780 --> 08:34:42.851
TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER AYE
08:34:42.918 --> 08:34:47.323
GONZALEZ I GROWTH I HERTZBERG
08:34:49.625 --> 08:34:52.161
GROVE I DON'T KNOW HERTZBERG
08:34:52.661 --> 08:34:56.265
HUESO AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
08:34:57.066 --> 08:35:00.869
NO KAMLAGER AYE FLARED AYE
08:35:00.936 --> 08:35:04.673
LEYVA AYE LIMóN AYE MCGUIRE
08:35:05.908 --> 08:35:12.047
I MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN I
08:35:12.114 --> 08:35:16.118
NIELSEN NO A SHOW OF BOTH I CAN
08:35:18.721 --> 08:35:19.221
PAN
08:35:21.357 --> 08:35:26.262
YEAH PAN I PORTANTINO I ROTH
08:35:26.862 --> 08:35:31.100
AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER I STERN
08:35:31.433 --> 08:35:34.370
AYE I'M BURKE AYE AYE CASKEY
08:35:34.436 --> 08:35:37.940
AYE WIENER AYE WILK HI PLEASE
08:35:38.007 --> 08:35:40.643
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS BATES
08:35:41.210 --> 08:35:46.882
NO PORGES NO CABALLERO I
08:35:47.783 --> 08:35:50.686
HERTZBERG I THIRTY THREE NO
08:35:50.753 --> 08:35:52.755
SIX THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:35:52.821 --> 08:35:53.789
ARE MOVING THE FILE ITEM
08:35:53.856 --> 08:35:55.758
NINETY NINE SENATOR COM LONGER
08:35:55.824 --> 08:35:57.926
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE READ
08:35:57.993 --> 08:35:59.495
SENATE BILL TWELVE FORTY FIVE
08:35:59.561 --> 08:36:01.363
BY SENATOR KAMLAGER AN ACT
08:36:01.430 --> 08:36:03.098
RELATING TO ABORTION CENTER
08:36:03.165 --> 08:36:04.900
COME LONGER THANK YOU AND
08:36:04.967 --> 08:36:06.068
GOOD EVENING MADAM PRESIDENT
08:36:06.135 --> 08:36:07.569
AND MEMBERS I AM HERE TODAY
08:36:07.636 --> 08:36:09.104
TO PRESENT SENATE BILL TWELVE
08:36:09.171 --> 08:36:10.572
FORTY FIVE THE L.
08:36:10.639 --> 08:36:11.173
A.
08:36:11.240 --> 08:36:12.308
COUNTY ABORTION ACCESS SAFE
08:36:12.374 --> 08:36:14.843
HAVEN PILOT PROGRAM SENATE
08:36:14.910 --> 08:36:16.345
BILL TWELVE FORTY FIVE WOULD
08:36:16.412 --> 08:36:18.380
SUPPORT A FUNDED PILOT PROGRAM
08:36:18.447 --> 08:36:20.182
FOR LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUBJECT
08:36:20.249 --> 08:36:21.317
TO APPROPRIATION BY THE
08:36:21.383 --> 08:36:23.052
LEGISLATURE TO BUILD ON THE
08:36:23.118 --> 08:36:24.520
STATEWIDE EFFORTS TO ADVANCE
08:36:24.586 --> 08:36:26.221
CALIFORNIA AS A REPRODUCTIVE
08:36:26.288 --> 08:36:28.490
FREEDOM STATE THIS PROGRAM WILL
08:36:28.557 --> 08:36:30.159
HOUSE INNOVATIVE APPROACHES AND
08:36:30.225 --> 08:36:32.027
PATIENT CENTERED COLLABORATIONS
08:36:32.094 --> 08:36:34.296
TO SAFEGUARD ACCESS TO ABORTION
08:36:34.363 --> 08:36:35.597
FOR PATIENTS COMING TO LOS
08:36:35.664 --> 08:36:37.333
ANGELES REGARDLESS OF WHERE A
08:36:37.399 --> 08:36:40.169
PATIENT RESIDES IN THE UNITED
08:36:40.235 --> 08:36:41.337
STATES SUPREME COURT DRAFT
08:36:41.403 --> 08:36:42.438
OPINION ON THE MISSISSIPPI
08:36:42.504 --> 08:36:43.739
ABORTION BAN THE COURT HAS
08:36:43.806 --> 08:36:44.807
SIGNALED THAT THEY WILL
08:36:44.873 --> 08:36:46.909
OVERTURN ROE AT THAT POINT
08:36:46.975 --> 08:36:48.510
PEOPLE IN OVER HALF THE STATES
08:36:48.577 --> 08:36:49.912
IN THIS COUNTRY OVER THIRTY
08:36:49.978 --> 08:36:51.880
SIX MILLION WOMEN AND OTHER
08:36:51.947 --> 08:36:53.615
PEOPLE WHO MAY BECOME PREGNANT
08:36:53.682 --> 08:36:55.417
WILL LOSE ACCESS TO ABORTION
08:36:55.484 --> 08:36:57.152
CARE AND THAT IS ALREADY
08:36:57.219 --> 08:36:58.654
HAPPENING PEOPLE IN TEXAS HAVE
08:36:58.721 --> 08:37:00.022
BEEN DENIED PROTECTIONS UNDER
08:37:00.089 --> 08:37:01.790
ROW SINCE THE STATE'S EXTREME
08:37:01.857 --> 08:37:03.425
ABORTION BAN WENT INTO EFFECT
08:37:03.492 --> 08:37:05.794
LAST YEAR ACCORDING TO A REPORT
08:37:05.861 --> 08:37:06.929
RELEASED BY THE GUTMACHER
08:37:06.995 --> 08:37:08.197
INSTITUTE THE NUMBER OF OUT
08:37:08.263 --> 08:37:09.398
OF STATE PATIENTS WHO WOULD
08:37:09.465 --> 08:37:10.733
FIND THEIR NEAREST ABORTION
08:37:10.799 --> 08:37:12.968
PROVIDER IN CALIFORNIA WILL
08:37:13.035 --> 08:37:14.370
GO FROM FORTY SIX THOUSAND TO
08:37:14.436 --> 08:37:16.605
ONE POINT FOUR MILLION PEOPLE
08:37:16.672 --> 08:37:18.006
AN INCREASE OF NEARLY THREE
08:37:18.073 --> 08:37:20.576
THOUSAND PERCENT L.
08:37:20.642 --> 08:37:21.143
A.
08:37:21.210 --> 08:37:21.877
COUNTY ACCOUNTS FOR OVER A
08:37:21.944 --> 08:37:23.479
THIRD OF ALL ABORTIONS THAT
08:37:23.545 --> 08:37:25.581
TAKE PLACE IN CALIFORNIA THE
08:37:25.647 --> 08:37:27.049
PREVALENCE OF ABORTION IN LOS
08:37:27.116 --> 08:37:28.784
ANGELES COUNTY IN PARTICULAR
08:37:28.851 --> 08:37:30.552
LIKELY REFLECTS BETTER ACCESS
08:37:30.619 --> 08:37:31.820
IN THE CITY THAN OTHER PARTS
08:37:31.887 --> 08:37:33.622
OF CALIFORNIA AND EVEN OTHER
08:37:33.689 --> 08:37:35.924
STATES IN THE NATION THIS
08:37:35.991 --> 08:37:37.159
PREVALENCE COUPLED WITH THE
08:37:37.226 --> 08:37:38.527
COUNTY IS ROLE AS A MAJOR
08:37:38.594 --> 08:37:40.162
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION
08:37:40.229 --> 08:37:41.930
HUB WITH MULTIPLE AIRPORTS
08:37:41.997 --> 08:37:43.499
MAKES IT HIGHLY LIKELY THAT
08:37:43.565 --> 08:37:44.833
NON RESIDENTS WILL COME TO
08:37:44.900 --> 08:37:46.468
LOS ANGELES COUNTY FOR THE
08:37:46.535 --> 08:37:48.237
ABORTION CARE THEY WILL NOT
08:37:48.303 --> 08:37:49.538
BE ABLE TO ACCESS IN THEIR
08:37:49.605 --> 08:37:51.974
HOME STATE OR COUNTY BUILDING
08:37:52.040 --> 08:37:53.609
UPON THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY'S
08:37:53.675 --> 08:37:55.444
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS RESOLUTION
08:37:55.511 --> 08:37:56.845
OF BUILDING A COUNTY WIDE
08:37:56.912 --> 08:37:58.147
RESPONSE TO THE POTENTIAL
08:37:58.213 --> 08:37:59.381
OVERTURN OF ROE V.
08:37:59.448 --> 08:38:01.683
WADE SB TWELVE FORTY FIVE
08:38:01.750 --> 08:38:03.452
WOULD FIND IN SUPPORT APART
08:38:03.519 --> 08:38:05.020
PILOT PROGRAM APPROACH TO
08:38:05.087 --> 08:38:07.022
CARE THAT IS RESPONSIVE TO
08:38:07.089 --> 08:38:09.892
THE IMPENDING NEEDS HI FOLKS
08:38:09.958 --> 08:38:12.094
SEEKING ABORTION CARE THIS BILL
08:38:12.161 --> 08:38:13.395
IS SUPPORTED BY THE CALIFORNIA
08:38:13.462 --> 08:38:14.963
ACADEMY OF FAMILY PHYSICIANS
08:38:15.030 --> 08:38:16.098
THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATIVE
08:38:16.165 --> 08:38:18.066
WOMEN'S CAUCUS A LOS ANGELES
08:38:18.133 --> 08:38:19.201
COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S
08:38:19.268 --> 08:38:20.569
OFFICE THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR
08:38:20.636 --> 08:38:21.837
YOUTH LAW PLANNED PARENTHOOD
08:38:21.904 --> 08:38:23.071
AND THE WOMEN'S FOUNDATION I
08:38:23.138 --> 08:38:24.173
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
08:38:24.239 --> 08:38:26.074
VOTE THANK YOU SENATOR COM
08:38:26.141 --> 08:38:28.143
LONGER MEMBERS DISCUSSION AND
08:38:28.210 --> 08:38:30.779
DEBATE SEEING AND HEARING NONE
08:38:30.846 --> 08:38:32.147
MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE CALL THE
08:38:32.214 --> 08:38:37.586
ROLL ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE
08:38:37.653 --> 08:38:41.323
ATKINS AYE BATES NOPE BACKER
08:38:42.291 --> 08:38:46.462
I PORCHES NO BRADFORD I HAVE
08:38:46.528 --> 08:38:50.766
ITEM AYE CORTESE AYE DALY NO
08:38:50.833 --> 08:38:56.972
DODD I TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE
08:38:57.039 --> 08:39:02.311
GLAZER AYE GONZALEZ I GROW NO
08:39:02.377 --> 08:39:05.647
HERTZBERG WESSEL AYE FURTADO
08:39:06.181 --> 08:39:09.818
AYE JONES NO KAMLAGER AYE
08:39:09.885 --> 08:39:14.723
FLARED AYE LEYVA AYE LIMóN I
08:39:15.123 --> 08:39:20.829
MCGUIRE I MELENDEZ NO MAN AYE
08:39:20.896 --> 08:39:24.466
NEWMAN AYE NIELSEN NO A SHOW
08:39:24.533 --> 08:39:28.871
OF BOTH NO HAN I PORTANTINO
08:39:29.605 --> 08:39:33.342
AYE ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE SKINNER
08:39:33.942 --> 08:39:38.447
AYE STERN HI I'M BURKE I LIKE
08:39:38.514 --> 08:39:44.286
HOW SKI I WIENER AYE WILK NO IS
08:39:44.353 --> 08:39:45.921
THIRTY KNOWS NINE THE MEASURE
08:39:45.988 --> 08:39:47.322
PASSES MEMBERS FROM MOVING ON
08:39:47.389 --> 08:39:49.424
A FILE ITEM ONE HUNDRED SENATOR
08:39:49.491 --> 08:39:51.126
GONZALEZ MADAM SECRETARY PLEASE
08:39:51.193 --> 08:39:52.995
READ SENATE BILL TWELVE FIFTY
08:39:53.061 --> 08:39:54.830
ONE BY SENATOR GONZALEZ AN
08:39:54.897 --> 08:39:57.165
ACT RELATING TO AIR POLLUTION
08:39:57.232 --> 08:39:58.600
CENTER GONZALEZ THANK YOU MADAM
08:39:58.667 --> 08:39:59.968
PRESIDENT MEMBERS I RISE TODAY
08:40:00.035 --> 08:40:01.136
TO PRESENT SENATE BILL TWELVE
08:40:01.203 --> 08:40:02.471
FIFTY ONE WHICH WILL CREATE A
08:40:02.538 --> 08:40:04.506
ZERO EMISSION EQUITY ADVOCATE
08:40:04.573 --> 08:40:06.174
IN THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE
08:40:06.241 --> 08:40:07.476
AND CALIFORNIA HIGHER INCOME
08:40:07.543 --> 08:40:08.877
HOUSEHOLDS ARE FAR MORE LIKELY
08:40:08.944 --> 08:40:10.412
TO PHONES THAT ZERO EMISSION
08:40:10.479 --> 08:40:12.014
VEHICLES THEN LOWER INCOME
08:40:12.080 --> 08:40:13.215
HOUSEHOLDS OF COLOR THIS IS
08:40:13.282 --> 08:40:14.483
ESPECIALLY TRUE IN IMMERSION
08:40:14.550 --> 08:40:15.784
EMISSIONS BURKE OVERBURDENED
08:40:15.851 --> 08:40:17.686
COMMUNITIES SB TWELVE FIFTY
08:40:17.753 --> 08:40:18.887
ONE WILL CREATED ZERO EMISSION
08:40:18.954 --> 08:40:20.289
EQUITY ADVOCATE THAT WILL SERVE
08:40:20.355 --> 08:40:22.357
AS A CENTRALIZED ENTITY TO PUT
08:40:22.424 --> 08:40:23.559
EQUITY FRONT AND CENTER AND
08:40:23.625 --> 08:40:24.927
THE STATE'S THAT DEPLOYMENT
08:40:24.993 --> 08:40:26.562
PLAN THAT WE ADVOCATE WILL
08:40:26.628 --> 08:40:28.630
ALSO WORK TO ALIGN DEFINITIONS
08:40:28.697 --> 08:40:30.032
GOALS AND INVESTMENTS ACROSS
08:40:30.098 --> 08:40:31.466
STATE AGENCIES THANK AND I
08:40:31.533 --> 08:40:32.701
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AN AYE
08:40:32.768 --> 08:40:35.203
VOTE SB TWELVE FIFTY ONE THANK
08:40:35.270 --> 08:40:36.805
YOU CENTER GONZALEZ MEMBERS
08:40:36.872 --> 08:40:39.608
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE SEEING AND
08:40:39.675 --> 08:40:41.109
HEARING NONE MA'AM SECRETARY
08:40:41.176 --> 08:40:43.679
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ALLEN
08:40:44.513 --> 08:40:47.916
AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS AYE
08:40:47.983 --> 08:40:51.920
BATES NO BACKER I FOR JUST
08:40:52.921 --> 08:40:55.691
NOPE BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO
08:40:56.158 --> 08:41:00.062
AYE CORTESE AYE DALY NOPE DODD
08:41:00.862 --> 08:41:05.133
HI TORONTO I EGGMAN AYE GLAZER
08:41:05.767 --> 08:41:09.037
AYE GONZALEZ HI I GROW NO
08:41:09.104 --> 08:41:13.308
HERTZBERG PUESTO AYE FURTADO
08:41:13.875 --> 08:41:18.013
AYE JONES NO KAMLAGER I LAYERED
08:41:18.847 --> 08:41:23.051
I LEYVA AYE THE MON I MCGUIRE
08:41:23.619 --> 08:41:28.457
AYE MELENDEZ NO MAN I NEWMAN I
08:41:28.523 --> 08:41:34.997
NIELSEN NO -- TROUBLE NO PAN I
08:41:35.063 --> 08:41:39.935
PORTANTINO I ROTH AYE RUBIO AYE
08:41:40.002 --> 08:41:44.106
SKINNER I STERN AYE I'M BURKE
08:41:44.740 --> 08:41:47.943
AYE FORECASTING AYE WIENER AYE
08:41:48.010 --> 08:41:51.813
WILK NO HIGHS THIRTY NEWS NINE
08:41:51.880 --> 08:41:53.582
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS THAT
08:41:53.649 --> 08:41:55.217
WAS OUR LAST BILL OF THE NIGHT
08:41:55.283 --> 08:41:57.986
WE ARE NOW GOING TO CUMULATE
08:41:58.053 --> 08:42:01.556
THE ON CALL BILLS SO HANG TIGHT
08:42:03.358 --> 08:42:03.859
SIX
08:42:17.039 --> 08:42:18.040
THANK YOU
08:42:20.342 --> 08:42:22.344
TO SEE IF YOU
08:42:31.453 --> 08:42:31.953
OKAY
08:42:37.993 --> 08:42:39.494
BUT IT IS
08:42:43.999 --> 08:42:47.202
ONE OF ALL RIGHT MEMBERS WE
08:42:47.269 --> 08:42:48.704
ARE GOING TO LIVE CALLS WE'RE
08:42:48.770 --> 08:42:50.238
GOING TO START WITH FILE
08:42:50.305 --> 08:42:53.008
ITEM FIFTEEN MEN SECRETARY
08:42:53.075 --> 08:42:55.577
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:43:02.517 --> 08:43:05.353
ALLEN YEAH FIVE
08:43:06.154 --> 08:43:09.758
BATES NO CABALLERO
08:43:12.527 --> 08:43:19.034
I TORONTO I HERTZBERG MELENDEZ
08:43:19.367 --> 08:43:23.872
NO NIELSEN NO A TROUBLED
08:43:29.611 --> 08:43:30.979
I THIRTY KNOWS EIGHT THE
08:43:31.046 --> 08:43:32.681
MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS REMOVING
08:43:32.748 --> 08:43:34.683
THE FILE ITEM SIXTEEN PLEASE
08:43:34.750 --> 08:43:36.752
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:43:41.890 --> 08:43:46.094
BAKER FIVE FIVE HAVE I EVER
08:43:46.528 --> 08:43:53.602
I TORONTO HERTZBERG HUESO I
08:43:54.803 --> 08:44:01.009
HURTADO I MELENDEZ I NIELSEN
08:44:01.543 --> 08:44:05.914
I A CHOI BOGUE I RUBIO
08:44:08.049 --> 08:44:08.550
HI
08:44:10.485 --> 08:44:12.988
MY CASKET I TO KNOW
08:44:14.322 --> 08:44:16.258
KING SIZE THIRTY SEVEN KNOWS
08:44:16.324 --> 08:44:18.460
WANT THE MEASURE PASSES MOVING
08:44:18.527 --> 08:44:20.228
ON TO FILE ITEM NINETEEN S.
08:44:20.295 --> 08:44:20.695
B.
08:44:20.762 --> 08:44:21.730
ELEVEN ELEVEN PLEASE
08:44:21.797 --> 08:44:23.799
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:44:27.903 --> 08:44:34.176
BATES I CABALLERO I YOUR
08:44:34.242 --> 08:44:40.715
BROWSER I GROWTH HERTZBERG
08:44:41.149 --> 08:44:46.755
HER TADO I JONES MELENDEZ I
08:44:47.556 --> 08:44:52.494
NIELSEN A CHOI BOGUE RUBIO
08:44:53.295 --> 08:44:55.564
FIVE THIRTY FIVE NO ZERO
08:44:55.630 --> 08:44:57.499
THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:44:57.566 --> 08:44:58.733
MOVING ON A FILE ITEM TWENTY
08:44:58.800 --> 08:45:00.569
THREE SB TWELVE SEVENTY NINE
08:45:00.635 --> 08:45:03.138
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:45:04.105 --> 08:45:07.676
CABALLERO AYE HERTZBERG AYE
08:45:07.742 --> 08:45:09.110
THIRTY NINE OH ZERO THE MEASURE
08:45:09.177 --> 08:45:12.480
PASSES FILE ITEM FIFTY SIX SB
08:45:12.547 --> 08:45:13.682
THIRTEEN FORTY THREE PLEASE
08:45:13.748 --> 08:45:17.185
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS ALLEN
08:45:19.621 --> 08:45:20.288
BACKER
08:45:22.958 --> 08:45:29.030
BRADFORD DODD HERTZBERG HER
08:45:29.097 --> 08:45:35.604
TADO I KAMLAGER I PORTANTINO
08:45:37.005 --> 08:45:41.977
ROTH RUBIO WIENER I TWENTY
08:45:42.043 --> 08:45:43.612
ONE KNOWS TEN THE MEASURE
08:45:43.678 --> 08:45:46.915
PASSES FILE ITEM SIXTY FOUR
08:45:46.982 --> 08:45:48.650
SB FOURTEEN THIRTY NINE
08:45:48.717 --> 08:45:51.219
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:45:52.988 --> 08:45:56.191
ATKINS I BATES
08:45:58.727 --> 08:46:04.466
FORTUS GROVE HERTZBERG COULD
08:46:04.532 --> 08:46:11.039
CALL HER TADO I JONES NIELSEN
08:46:12.774 --> 08:46:15.110
FIVE THIRTY THREE NO SIR
08:46:15.176 --> 08:46:16.244
CALL THE ROLL ONE MORE TIME
08:46:16.311 --> 08:46:19.681
PORTANTINO I FIVE THIRTY
08:46:19.748 --> 08:46:21.616
FOUR NO ZERO THE MEASURE
08:46:21.683 --> 08:46:24.452
PASSES FILE ITEM FORTY NINE
08:46:24.519 --> 08:46:26.421
SB TWELVE THIRTY ONE PLEASE
08:46:26.488 --> 08:46:28.490
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:46:31.192 --> 08:46:36.665
ATKINS I GROVE HERTZBERG
08:46:37.666 --> 08:46:42.737
HER TADO I PORTANTINO FIVE
08:46:43.905 --> 08:46:45.941
I THIRTY EIGHT NO ZERO THE
08:46:46.007 --> 08:46:50.178
MEASURE PASSES CENTER PAN A
08:46:50.245 --> 08:46:52.981
SEVEN PRESIDENT CENTERS -- I
08:46:53.048 --> 08:46:54.683
THINK -- MEMBER WANT THERE'S
08:46:54.749 --> 08:46:56.318
A FRACTION OF IT SO I'M GONNA
08:46:56.384 --> 08:46:57.585
ASK FOR RECONSIDERATION OF
08:46:57.652 --> 08:46:59.321
FILE NUMBER NUMBER EIGHTY FOUR
08:46:59.387 --> 08:47:01.489
SB TEN NINETY SEVEN MEMBERS
08:47:01.556 --> 08:47:03.391
IS THERE ANY OBJECTION TO
08:47:03.458 --> 08:47:05.226
RECONSIDERATION FOR FILE ITEM
08:47:05.293 --> 08:47:07.462
EIGHTY FOUR SB TEN NINETY
08:47:07.529 --> 08:47:10.665
SEVEN SENIOR OBJECTION IS
08:47:10.732 --> 08:47:12.567
THIRTY SEVEN KNOWS ZERO
08:47:12.634 --> 08:47:14.469
RECONSIDERATION IS GRANTED
08:47:15.870 --> 08:47:17.038
THIRTY NINE I'M SORRY THE
08:47:17.105 --> 08:47:18.006
PRESIDING OFFICERS GETTING
08:47:18.073 --> 08:47:20.175
TIRED I THIRTY NINE NO ZERO THE
08:47:20.241 --> 08:47:22.978
MEASURE PASSES MADAM SECRETARY
08:47:23.178 --> 08:47:24.479
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON
08:47:24.546 --> 08:47:26.047
ITEM EIGHTY FOUR S.
08:47:26.114 --> 08:47:26.448
B.
08:47:26.514 --> 08:47:27.782
TEN NINETY SEVEN
08:47:31.987 --> 08:47:35.490
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA
08:47:36.124 --> 08:47:38.793
AYE ATKINS AYE BATES
08:47:40.895 --> 08:47:41.529
BAKER
08:47:46.201 --> 08:47:49.637
I PORCHES NO BRADFORD
08:47:51.906 --> 08:47:55.143
CABALLERO AYE PROTESTING AYE
08:47:55.210 --> 08:48:01.983
DALY DODD DURACELL I EGGMAN
08:48:09.290 --> 08:48:12.627
GLAZER HE'S ONE OF THE
08:48:14.429 --> 08:48:17.532
HI GONZALEZ I DROVE
08:48:19.901 --> 08:48:22.303
HERTZBERG HUESO AYE
08:48:22.370 --> 08:48:27.442
FURTADO I JONES KAMLAGER
08:48:29.711 --> 08:48:35.050
LAYARD I LEYVA LIMóN AYE
08:48:35.116 --> 08:48:39.921
MCGUIRE AYE MELENDEZ MAN I
08:48:39.988 --> 08:48:44.793
NEWMAN NIELSEN BUT CHAU BOTH
08:48:45.727 --> 08:48:49.664
I PAN AYE PORTANTINO AYE ROTH
08:48:51.699 --> 08:48:53.802
RUBIO AYE SKINNER
08:48:55.837 --> 08:48:59.174
STERN AYE I'M BURKE I WHITE
08:48:59.240 --> 08:49:04.212
HOUSE SKI I WIENER NO WILK
08:49:05.980 --> 08:49:08.483
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
08:49:08.850 --> 08:49:15.623
BATES BRADFORD DALLY DODD
08:49:16.458 --> 08:49:21.963
EGGMAN GROVE HERTZBERG JONES
08:49:23.098 --> 08:49:27.902
KAMLAGER LEYVA I MELENDEZ
08:49:28.937 --> 08:49:34.742
NEWMAN NIELSEN RALPH SKINNER
08:49:35.910 --> 08:49:39.347
WILK HIS TWENTY THREE KNOWS
08:49:39.414 --> 08:49:41.983
TO THE MEASURE PASSES MEMBERS
08:49:42.050 --> 08:49:44.018
WE ARE MOVING TO THE CONSENT
08:49:44.085 --> 08:49:46.754
CALENDAR DOES ANYONE HAVE
08:49:46.821 --> 08:49:48.123
ANYTHING THEY WISH TO REMOVED
08:49:48.189 --> 08:49:50.191
FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR
08:49:50.692 --> 08:49:52.861
VERY GOOD JUST TO WARN YOU
08:49:52.927 --> 08:49:54.262
WHEN I ASKED MADAM SECRETARY
08:49:54.329 --> 08:49:55.597
TO PLEASE READ THERE ARE
08:49:55.663 --> 08:49:57.198
EIGHTY ITEMS ON THE CONSENT
08:49:57.265 --> 08:49:58.867
CALENDAR SO BEAR WITH US
08:49:58.933 --> 08:50:00.935
AND SECRETARY PLEASE READ
08:50:02.737 --> 08:50:04.072
SENATE BILLS EIGHT THIRTY THREE
08:50:04.139 --> 08:50:05.173
EIGHT THIRTY SEVEN EIGHT FORTY
08:50:05.240 --> 08:50:06.341
TWO EIGHT FIFTY EIGHT FIFTY
08:50:06.407 --> 08:50:07.408
THREE EIGHT FIFTY FIVE EIGHT
08:50:07.475 --> 08:50:08.610
SIXTY THREE EIGHT SIXTY FIVE
08:50:08.676 --> 08:50:09.511
EIGHT SEVENTY EIGHT SEVENTY
08:50:09.577 --> 08:50:10.645
TWO EIGHT SEVENTY SEVEN EIGHT
08:50:10.712 --> 08:50:11.779
EIGHTY EIGHT EIGHTY FIVE EIGHT
08:50:11.846 --> 08:50:13.381
NINETY FOUR EIGHT NINETY FIVE
08:50:13.448 --> 08:50:14.816
NINE OH ONE NINE OH THREE NINE
08:50:14.883 --> 08:50:16.284
OH SEVEN NINE TWELVE NINE SIXTY
08:50:16.351 --> 08:50:18.086
NINE THIRTY SIX NINE FORTY FIVE
08:50:18.153 --> 08:50:19.554
NINE FORTY SIX NINE FIFTY NINE
08:50:19.621 --> 08:50:21.990
SIXTY THREE NINE SIXTY SIX NINE
08:50:22.056 --> 08:50:23.358
SIXTY SEVEN NINE SEVENTY NINE
08:50:23.424 --> 08:50:24.592
SEVENTY THREE NINE SEVENTY FOUR
08:50:24.659 --> 08:50:25.727
NINE SEVENTY SEVEN NINE EIGHTY
08:50:25.793 --> 08:50:27.662
FOUR TEN OH ONE TEN TWELVE
08:50:27.729 --> 08:50:29.130
TEN SIXTEEN TEN TWENTY THREE
08:50:29.197 --> 08:50:30.798
TEN TWENTY EIGHT TEN TWENTY
08:50:30.865 --> 08:50:32.267
NINE TEN SIXTY TWO TEN SIXTY
08:50:32.333 --> 08:50:33.735
FIVE TEN SIXTY NINE TEN EIGHTY
08:50:33.801 --> 08:50:35.537
THREE TEN NINETY TEN NINETY
08:50:35.603 --> 08:50:37.138
ONE TEN NINETY TWO TO ELEVEN
08:50:37.205 --> 08:50:39.073
FORTY ELEVEN FORTY THREE ELEVEN
08:50:39.140 --> 08:50:40.508
SIXTY ONE ELEVEN SEVENTY FIVE
08:50:40.575 --> 08:50:41.576
ELEVEN EIGHTY ELEVEN EIGHTY
08:50:41.643 --> 08:50:43.578
EIGHT ELEVEN NINETY ONE TWELVE
08:50:43.645 --> 08:50:45.813
SIXTEEN TWELVE TWENTY NINE
08:50:45.880 --> 08:50:46.915
TWELVE THIRTY EIGHT TWELVE
08:50:46.981 --> 08:50:48.116
FORTY SIX TWELVE FIFTY THREE
08:50:48.183 --> 08:50:49.117
TWELVE FIFTY FIVE TWELVE
08:50:49.184 --> 08:50:50.418
SIXTY SEVEN THIRTEEN HUNDRED
08:50:50.485 --> 08:50:51.519
THIRTEEN FIFTEEN THIRTEEN
08:50:51.586 --> 08:50:53.021
TWENTY ONE THIRTEEN TWENTY
08:50:53.087 --> 08:50:55.089
NINE THIRTEEN FORTY TO THIRTEEN
08:50:55.156 --> 08:50:56.291
FORTY SEVEN THIRTEEN FIFTY
08:50:56.357 --> 08:50:57.759
SEVEN THIRTEEN EIGHTY THREE
08:50:57.825 --> 08:50:59.027
THIRTEEN NINETY SIX FOURTEEN
08:50:59.093 --> 08:51:00.528
OH SIX FORTINO SEVEN FOURTEEN
08:51:00.595 --> 08:51:02.597
THIRTEEN FOURTEEN TWENTY SEVEN
08:51:02.664 --> 08:51:03.831
FOURTEEN THIRTY FOUR FOURTEEN
08:51:03.898 --> 08:51:05.166
THIRTY EIGHT FOURTEEN FIFTY SIX
08:51:05.233 --> 08:51:06.601
FOURTEEN EIGHTY FOUR FOURTEEN
08:51:06.668 --> 08:51:07.936
EIGHTY SEVEN FOURTEEN NINETY
08:51:08.002 --> 08:51:10.038
FIVE AND FIFTEEN HUNDRED
08:51:10.104 --> 08:51:12.707
WELL DONE MADAM SECRETARY
08:51:16.377 --> 08:51:17.378
MADAM SECRETARY
08:51:17.445 --> 08:51:19.447
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
08:51:21.649 --> 08:51:25.553
ALLEN AYE ARCHULETA AYE ATKINS
08:51:26.054 --> 08:51:30.592
AYE BATES AYE BAKER I PORCHES
08:51:31.492 --> 08:51:34.762
I BRADFORD AYE CABALLERO AYE
08:51:34.829 --> 08:51:39.601
CORTESE AYE DALLY AYE DODD I
08:51:39.667 --> 08:51:44.872
TORONTO I EGGMAN I GLAZER AYE
08:51:44.939 --> 08:51:48.443
GONZALEZ I WROTE I HERTZBERG
08:51:49.010 --> 08:51:52.747
HUESO AYE HURTADO AYE JONES
08:51:54.515 --> 08:51:59.020
I KAMLAGER I LAYERED I LEYVA
08:51:59.721 --> 08:52:02.890
AYE LIMóN AYE MCGUIRE AYE
08:52:02.957 --> 08:52:06.828
MELINDA'S AYE MIN AYE NEWMAN
08:52:07.395 --> 08:52:10.198
AYE NIELSEN AYE A TROUBLED
08:52:10.732 --> 08:52:15.503
AYE PAN AYE PORTANTINO I
08:52:15.570 --> 08:52:19.307
ROTH AYE RUBIO I SKINNER
08:52:20.108 --> 08:52:23.211
I STERN AYE I'M BURKE AYE
08:52:23.278 --> 08:52:27.282
FORECASTING AYE WIENER I WILK
08:52:30.251 --> 08:52:31.019
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
08:52:31.085 --> 08:52:34.255
MEMBERS HERTZBERG WELL
08:52:36.924 --> 08:52:38.760
OKAY VERY GOOD IS THIRTY EIGHT
08:52:38.826 --> 08:52:41.095
KNOWS ZERO THE CONSENT CALENDAR
08:52:41.162 --> 08:52:43.631
HAS BEEN ADOPTED MEMBERS IF
08:52:43.698 --> 08:52:45.266
THERE IS NO FURTHER BUSINESS
08:52:45.333 --> 08:52:47.835
SENATOR ACHEN SUGGEST IS CLEAR
08:52:48.202 --> 08:52:49.437
MADAM PRESIDENT THANK YOU SO
08:52:49.504 --> 08:52:52.573
MUCH TO ALL OF THE STAFF TODAY
08:52:52.640 --> 08:52:55.076
-- I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU FOR
08:52:55.143 --> 08:52:57.211
THIS LONG AND PRODUCTIVE DAY
08:52:57.278 --> 08:52:58.746
WE MANAGED TO GET SIXTY SEVEN
08:52:58.813 --> 08:53:00.248
BILLS COMPLETED ON THE FLOOR
08:53:00.315 --> 08:53:02.317
TODAY AND ANOTHER EIGHTY ON THE
08:53:02.383 --> 08:53:04.452
CONSENT CALENDAR SO THAT'S A
08:53:04.519 --> 08:53:06.721
HUNDRED FORTY SEVEN BILLS AND
08:53:06.788 --> 08:53:08.756
YET WE HAVE SOME BILLS TO GO
08:53:08.823 --> 08:53:10.591
TOMORROW SHOULD BE A LONG DAY
08:53:10.658 --> 08:53:13.828
AS WELL -- BUT YOU WILL BE FED
08:53:13.895 --> 08:53:16.130
I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE YOU KNOW
08:53:16.197 --> 08:53:17.699
HI THANKS TO OUR INCREDIBLE
08:53:17.765 --> 08:53:19.901
STAFF -- SO THEREFORE OUR
08:53:19.967 --> 08:53:21.703
NEXT FLOOR SESSION WILL BE
08:53:21.769 --> 08:53:23.404
TOMORROW THURSDAY MAY TWENTY
08:53:23.471 --> 08:53:25.406
SIX TWENTY TWENTY TWO AT TEN
08:53:25.473 --> 08:53:27.842
AM THANK YOU THANK YOU MAYOR
08:53:27.909 --> 08:53:29.177
PRO TEM OF THE SENATE IS
08:53:29.243 --> 08:53:30.678
ADJOURNED WE WILL RECONVENE
08:53:30.745 --> 08:53:33.047
TOMORROW THURSDAY AT TEN AM
08:53:33.114 --> 08:53:35.616
HAVE A GREAT EVENING MEMBERS