WEBVTT
00:00:12.712 --> 00:00:14.981
PLEASE FOR GOING TO GET STARTED
00:00:15.048 --> 00:00:15.548
WITH OUR WITH OUR COMMITTEE
00:00:15.615 --> 00:00:31.831
HEARING TODAY
00:00:42.242 --> 00:00:42.409
. THANK YOU
00:00:42.475 --> 00:00:44.010
EVERYBODY- WELCOME GOOD
00:00:44.077 --> 00:00:47.313
MORNING- THIS IS- THE STATE
00:00:47.380 --> 00:00:50.550
SENATE. ENERGY UTILITIES AND
00:00:50.617 --> 00:00:51.584
COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE
00:00:51.651 --> 00:00:54.053
WELCOME EVERYBODY- THIS IS A
00:00:54.120 --> 00:00:55.889
CONTINUATION OF A HEARING THAT
00:00:55.955 --> 00:00:59.292
WE HAD IN NOVEMBER IT IN
00:00:59.359 --> 00:01:02.095
RESPONSE TO INCIDENTS- IN
00:01:02.162 --> 00:01:07.267
OCTOBER OF LAST YEAR- IN WHICH-
00:01:07.333 --> 00:01:09.702
THREE OF THE LARGEST- STATE.
00:01:09.769 --> 00:01:11.738
OWNED ELECTRIC UTILITIES A SHUT
00:01:11.805 --> 00:01:15.708
OFF ELECTRICITY- AND POWER TO
00:01:15.775 --> 00:01:17.143
MILLIONS OF CUSTOMERS IN
00:01:17.210 --> 00:01:19.312
CALIFORNIA. THE MAJORITY OF
00:01:19.379 --> 00:01:21.848
WHICH WERE IN THE ERA SERVICE
00:01:21.915 --> 00:01:24.784
AREA OF PGA ANY. IN ADDITION TO
00:01:24.851 --> 00:01:26.085
LOSING ELECTRICITY MANY
00:01:26.152 --> 00:01:28.054
CALIFORNIANS ALSO LOST
00:01:28.121 --> 00:01:28.721
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES
00:01:28.788 --> 00:01:30.423
DURING THE POWERSHOT OFFICE FOR
00:01:30.490 --> 00:01:34.494
CALIFORNIANS. IN THE EVACUATION
00:01:34.561 --> 00:01:36.029
ZONE OF THE- CAM K<c.cyan> FIRES</c>
00:01:36.095 --> 00:01:38.298
SPECIFICALLY THE LOSS OF THESE
00:01:38.364 --> 00:01:40.166
SERVICES MAY HAVE LIMITED THEIR
00:01:40.233 --> 00:01:41.968
ABILITY TO RECEIVE EMERGENCY
00:01:42.035 --> 00:01:44.704
WARNINGS ABOUT THE FIRE AND
00:01:44.771 --> 00:01:47.307
EVACUATION ROUTES PHONE AND
00:01:47.373 --> 00:01:48.842
INTERNET OUTAGES WERE NOT
00:01:48.908 --> 00:01:51.678
CONFIRMED WERE NOT CONFINED TO
00:01:51.744 --> 00:01:53.680
AREAS WHERE POWER WAS SHUT OFF.
00:01:53.746 --> 00:01:55.014
EVEN IN SITUATIONS WHERE
00:01:55.081 --> 00:01:57.183
CALIFORNIA'S CALIFORNIANS WERE
00:01:57.250 --> 00:01:59.085
PREPARED TO LOSE POWER MANY
00:01:59.152 --> 00:02:01.020
CONSUMERS WERE UNPREPARED TO
00:02:01.087 --> 00:02:02.689
LOSE PHONE AND INTERNET
00:02:02.755 --> 00:02:06.025
SERVICES. POWER SHOPS ARE NOT
00:02:06.092 --> 00:02:06.559
THE ONLY CAUSE OF
00:02:06.626 --> 00:02:08.962
TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGES A
00:02:09.028 --> 00:02:10.497
NUMBER OF FACTORS INCLUDING
00:02:10.563 --> 00:02:12.799
ACCIDENTS COMPUTER FAILURES AND
00:02:12.866 --> 00:02:14.000
POORLY MAINTAINED
00:02:14.067 --> 00:02:15.869
INFRASTRUCTURE ALSO CAUSED
00:02:15.935 --> 00:02:19.172
OUTAGES. TELECOMMUNICATIONS
00:02:19.239 --> 00:02:22.642
OUTAGES ARE NOT NEW BUT RECENT
00:02:22.709 --> 00:02:25.044
PHONE AND INTERNET OUTAGES HAVE
00:02:25.111 --> 00:02:26.045
HIGHLIGHTED THE RISKS
00:02:26.112 --> 00:02:28.648
ASSOCIATED WITH LOSING THESE
00:02:28.715 --> 00:02:31.885
ESSENTIAL SERVICES ESPECIALLY
00:02:31.951 --> 00:02:34.554
DURING TIMES OF URGENT NEED
00:02:34.621 --> 00:02:36.789
THIS HEARING IS INTENDED TO
00:02:36.856 --> 00:02:38.391
CONTINUE TO EXPLORE THE CAUSES
00:02:38.458 --> 00:02:41.261
OF TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGES.
00:02:41.327 --> 00:02:42.395
THE LESSONS THAT WERE LEARNED
00:02:42.462 --> 00:02:44.464
FROM THE RECENT OUTRAGEOUS AND
00:02:44.531 --> 00:02:46.165
WHAT WE CAN DO TO ENSURE THE
00:02:46.232 --> 00:02:46.733
CALIFORNIANS HAVE A RELIABLE
00:02:46.799 --> 00:02:49.302
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AT WORK.
00:02:49.369 --> 00:02:51.204
TODAY'S HEARING IS AGAIN A
00:02:51.271 --> 00:02:53.973
CONTINUATION OF WHAT WE STARTED
00:02:54.040 --> 00:02:55.475
IN NOVEMBER BUT SPECIFICALLY
00:02:55.542 --> 00:02:58.144
WILL BE LOOKING MORE. INTO THE
00:02:58.211 --> 00:02:59.712
TELECOMMUNICATION ASPECT OF
00:02:59.779 --> 00:03:02.081
THIS INCIDENT. THIS HEARING IS
00:03:02.148 --> 00:03:04.183
AS SCHEDULED- TO LAST
00:03:04.250 --> 00:03:06.553
APPROXIMATELY THREE HOURS WITH
00:03:06.619 --> 00:03:08.488
PUBLIC COMMENT AND WE HAVE A
00:03:08.555 --> 00:03:10.623
PRETTY PACKED AGENDA. SO WHERE
00:03:10.690 --> 00:03:13.126
WE'RE GONNA ASK- MEMBERS TO
00:03:13.192 --> 00:03:16.162
REALLY FOCUS ON ON WHAT. AREAS
00:03:16.229 --> 00:03:17.997
THEY WOULD LIKE TO- DEALT AND
00:03:18.064 --> 00:03:21.601
FURTHER IN THE IN THE. WITH
00:03:21.668 --> 00:03:23.202
WITH WITH HOPE THAT WE CAN
00:03:23.269 --> 00:03:26.005
REALLY AT A HIGHLIGHT THE MOST
00:03:26.072 --> 00:03:28.575
IMPORTANT AREAS THAT ARE OF
00:03:28.641 --> 00:03:29.175
CONCERN TO NOT ONLY US BUT OF
00:03:29.242 --> 00:03:32.512
THE PUBLIC. WE HAVE TRIED TO DO
00:03:32.579 --> 00:03:34.547
OUR BEST OF COURSE YOU KNOW THE
00:03:34.614 --> 00:03:36.416
THREE HOUR HEARING INCLUDES
00:03:36.482 --> 00:03:37.984
QUITE A BIT OF TESTIMONY AND WE
00:03:38.051 --> 00:03:39.786
TRY TO DO OUR BEST TO INCLUDE.
00:03:39.852 --> 00:03:41.754
A VERY DIVERSE GROUP OF VOICES
00:03:41.821 --> 00:03:43.356
AND REPRESENTATION FOR THOSE
00:03:43.423 --> 00:03:45.792
AFFECTED. AND IN MANY CASES
00:03:45.858 --> 00:03:47.427
WILL- THIS WILL BE THE VERY
00:03:47.493 --> 00:03:53.166
FIRST TIME THIS COMMITTEE. HAS
00:03:53.232 --> 00:03:53.967
BE HEARING FROM THE TECH
00:03:54.033 --> 00:03:55.868
TELECOMMUNICATIONS PROVIDERS
00:03:55.935 --> 00:03:56.436
DIRECTLY FOR THE VERY FIRST
00:03:56.502 --> 00:04:00.473
TIME. WE KNOW. THAT THIS-
00:04:00.540 --> 00:04:02.642
HEARING WILL NOT COVER. EVERY
00:04:02.709 --> 00:04:05.311
SINGLE ISSUE OF COURSE- THERE
00:04:05.378 --> 00:04:06.879
THERE'S QUITE A BIT THE PEOPLE
00:04:06.946 --> 00:04:10.016
LIKE TO HEAR FROM BUT- WE WILL
00:04:10.083 --> 00:04:12.752
BE- TAKE TAKING A LOT OF THOSE
00:04:12.819 --> 00:04:15.188
ISSUES THAT ARE NOT ONLY NOT
00:04:15.254 --> 00:04:18.124
HER TUTOR BUT REYES TODAY ES.
00:04:18.191 --> 00:04:20.493
INTO CONSIDERATION IN IN FUTURE
00:04:20.560 --> 00:04:22.395
HEARINGS AND FUTURE OF MATTERS
00:04:22.462 --> 00:04:26.499
THAT WE MAY HAVE. WHAT THE SAID
00:04:26.566 --> 00:04:27.967
I WANT TO WELCOME OUR FIRST
00:04:28.034 --> 00:04:29.836
PANELIST FROM THE CALIFORNIA
00:04:29.902 --> 00:04:31.771
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION. WE
00:04:31.838 --> 00:04:39.846
HAVE. HELEN WE HAVE. SORRY
00:04:39.912 --> 00:04:45.151
ABOUT THAT. WE HAVE HELL IN MY
00:04:45.218 --> 00:04:47.120
COULD MAKE WHICH IS- ASSISTANT
00:04:47.186 --> 00:04:49.756
GENERAL COUNSEL WE HAVE CLICK
00:04:49.822 --> 00:04:52.291
CLIFF. WRECK WRECKED CHAFFIN IT
00:04:52.358 --> 00:04:53.826
LOSES THE COMMISSIONER AND WE
00:04:53.893 --> 00:04:56.763
HAVE MARIBEL BADGER THE
00:04:56.829 --> 00:04:57.330
PRESIDENT FOR THE PC WELCOME
00:04:57.397 --> 00:05:07.840
THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE. SO
00:05:07.907 --> 00:05:08.374
SORRY ABOUT THAT AFTER MY
00:05:08.441 --> 00:05:13.846
CONFERENCE. I'M FIRST CELL I
00:05:13.913 --> 00:05:15.314
WILL START MORNING KEREN WEST
00:05:15.381 --> 00:05:19.452
SO. AND SENATORS AND THANK YOU
00:05:19.519 --> 00:05:20.086
FOR INVITING ME HERE TO SPEAK
00:05:20.153 --> 00:05:21.320
TODAY MY NAME IS HELEN
00:05:21.387 --> 00:05:22.889
MISCARRIAGE I'M AN ASSISTANT
00:05:22.955 --> 00:05:23.890
GENERAL COUNSEL OF THE
00:05:23.956 --> 00:05:25.558
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES
00:05:25.625 --> 00:05:27.260
COMMISSION WHERE I HAVE WORKED
00:05:27.326 --> 00:05:28.628
FOR THIRTY THREE YEARS. MOSTLY
00:05:28.695 --> 00:05:29.796
IN THE AREA OF COMMUNICATIONS
00:05:29.862 --> 00:05:31.898
I'VE BEEN ASKED TO SET THE
00:05:31.964 --> 00:05:32.465
COMMUNICATION STAGE FOR YOU
00:05:32.532 --> 00:05:35.334
TODAY. NOT THAT LONG AGO
00:05:35.401 --> 00:05:36.869
CONSUMERS HAD TRADITIONAL VOICE
00:05:36.936 --> 00:05:39.105
SERVICE PROVIDED OVER LAND
00:05:39.172 --> 00:05:39.639
LINES MY EIGHTEEN T. WHICH
00:05:39.706 --> 00:05:42.208
LATER BECAME. RATHER PACIFIC
00:05:42.275 --> 00:05:43.609
BELL OFFICIALLY BECAME EIGHTEEN
00:05:43.676 --> 00:05:45.144
T. AND GT CALIFORNIA WHICH
00:05:45.211 --> 00:05:48.081
LATER BECAME VERIZON AND A HOST
00:05:48.147 --> 00:05:48.681
OF SMALLER TELEPHONE COMPANIES
00:05:48.748 --> 00:05:50.383
ALSO PROVIDED THE SERVICE.
00:05:50.450 --> 00:05:51.984
MOBILE SERVICE WAS THE NEW
00:05:52.051 --> 00:05:53.286
TECHNOLOGY AND VOICE OVER
00:05:53.352 --> 00:05:55.455
INTERNET PROTOCOL WHICH ALLOWS
00:05:55.521 --> 00:05:57.323
A USER TO MAKE VOICE CALLS
00:05:57.390 --> 00:05:57.990
USING A BROADBAND INTERNET
00:05:58.057 --> 00:06:00.026
CONNECTION DID NOT EVEN EXIST.
00:06:00.093 --> 00:06:00.493
THE LANDSCAPE TODAY IS
00:06:00.560 --> 00:06:02.729
DRAMATICALLY DIFFERENT. WHILE
00:06:02.795 --> 00:06:04.230
MANY CUSTOMERS STILL HAVE
00:06:04.297 --> 00:06:05.064
TRADITIONAL PHONE SERVICE IN
00:06:05.131 --> 00:06:07.033
CALIFORNIA V. O. I. P. HAS
00:06:07.100 --> 00:06:09.235
BECOME THE DOMINANT WIRELINE
00:06:09.302 --> 00:06:09.702
SERVICE IN MILLIONS OF
00:06:09.769 --> 00:06:10.203
CUSTOMERS HAD OPTED FOR
00:06:10.269 --> 00:06:13.639
WIRELESS. TEN YEARS AGO THE FCC
00:06:13.706 --> 00:06:14.907
ADOPTED A NATIONAL BROADBAND
00:06:14.974 --> 00:06:16.776
PLAN. WHICH ENVISIONED
00:06:16.843 --> 00:06:17.977
TRANSITIONING THE NATION'S
00:06:18.044 --> 00:06:20.179
ENTIRE COMMUNICATIONS NETWORK
00:06:20.246 --> 00:06:21.414
TWO ONE IT IS INTERNET BASED.
00:06:21.481 --> 00:06:23.950
THAT TRANSITION DRIVEN BY
00:06:24.016 --> 00:06:24.917
CHANGES IN TECHNOLOGY WHICH
00:06:24.984 --> 00:06:26.886
WERE ALREADY UNDER WAY. HAS
00:06:26.953 --> 00:06:29.622
CREATED ARTIFICIAL DISTINCTIONS
00:06:29.689 --> 00:06:30.223
AND HOW WE REGULATE DIFFERENT
00:06:30.289 --> 00:06:33.493
SERVICES AND TECHNOLOGIES. TO
00:06:33.559 --> 00:06:34.460
GIVE YOU SOME BASICS
00:06:34.527 --> 00:06:36.829
TELECOMMUNICATIONS MEANS SIMPLY
00:06:36.896 --> 00:06:37.663
THE TRANSMISSION OF INFORMATION
00:06:37.730 --> 00:06:39.532
FROM ONE POINT TO ANOTHER.
00:06:39.599 --> 00:06:41.067
HISTORICALLY THE CPUC HAS
00:06:41.134 --> 00:06:42.468
REGULATED VOICE AND DATA
00:06:42.535 --> 00:06:44.504
SERVICES BECAUSE BOTH INVOLVED
00:06:44.570 --> 00:06:45.605
TRANSMITTING INFORMATION FROM
00:06:45.671 --> 00:06:47.440
ONE CUSTOMER TO ANOTHER. THE
00:06:47.507 --> 00:06:48.741
NETWORK USED TO TRANSMIT THIS
00:06:48.808 --> 00:06:50.843
INFORMATION IS MADE UP OF FIBER
00:06:50.910 --> 00:06:52.645
OPTIC LINES COPPER WIRE REMOTE
00:06:52.712 --> 00:06:54.814
TERMINALS BACK CALL TRUNKS
00:06:54.881 --> 00:06:56.916
GENERATORS AND OTHER EQUIPMENT
00:06:56.983 --> 00:06:59.852
THAT WE REFER TO AS FACILITIES.
00:06:59.919 --> 00:07:01.521
OVER TIME YOU SERVICES WERE
00:07:01.587 --> 00:07:03.256
DEVELOPED IN THOSE TO USE THE
00:07:03.322 --> 00:07:04.524
SAME FACILITIES FOR EXAMPLE
00:07:04.590 --> 00:07:06.826
VOIP SERVICE AND BROADBAND
00:07:06.893 --> 00:07:08.661
SERVICE CAN BE PROVIDED OVER
00:07:08.728 --> 00:07:09.262
THE COPPER WIRES THAT MADE UP
00:07:09.328 --> 00:07:10.830
THE ORIGINAL VOICE TELEPHONE
00:07:10.897 --> 00:07:14.233
NETWORK. CONVERSELY TRADITIONAL
00:07:14.300 --> 00:07:14.767
TELEPHONE SERVICE CAN BE
00:07:14.834 --> 00:07:16.402
PROVIDED OVER FIBER OPTIC
00:07:16.469 --> 00:07:18.137
LINES. FURTHER EXCEPT FOR THE
00:07:18.204 --> 00:07:20.406
PORTION TRANSMISSION FROM A
00:07:20.473 --> 00:07:23.042
CELL TOWER TO YOUR MOBILE PHONE
00:07:23.109 --> 00:07:26.279
WIRELESS SERVICE ALSO IS
00:07:26.345 --> 00:07:26.913
PROVIDED ON THE SAME FACILITIES
00:07:26.979 --> 00:07:29.382
JUST WIRELESS NETWORK. WHEN WE
00:07:29.448 --> 00:07:30.483
REFER TO A SERVICE AS A SUIT
00:07:30.550 --> 00:07:31.517
FUTURE SERVICE FOR- ESSENTIALLY
00:07:31.584 --> 00:07:33.152
SPACE WE SIMPLY MEAN THAT THE
00:07:33.219 --> 00:07:35.154
PROVIDER CONTROLS ARE OPERATE
00:07:35.221 --> 00:07:36.189
YOU QUIT MEN OVER WHICH THE
00:07:36.255 --> 00:07:38.257
TRANSMISSION TRAVELS. TO
00:07:38.324 --> 00:07:39.158
PROVIDE TO ME ONLY FACILITIES
00:07:39.225 --> 00:07:42.295
OR LEASE THEM ARE THE WAY TO
00:07:42.361 --> 00:07:42.929
PROVIDERS RESPONSIBLE FOR THOSE
00:07:42.995 --> 00:07:46.098
FACILITIES. THE CBC'S ABILITY
00:07:46.165 --> 00:07:47.900
TO REGULATE SPECIFIC SERVICES
00:07:47.967 --> 00:07:49.101
IS DICTATED BY STATE AND
00:07:49.168 --> 00:07:50.870
FEDERAL LAW AND CALIFORNIA'S
00:07:50.937 --> 00:07:52.038
SHARES WITH THE FEDERAL
00:07:52.104 --> 00:07:53.506
GOVERNMENT AUTHORITY TO
00:07:53.573 --> 00:07:54.841
REGULATE COMMUNICATION SERVICES
00:07:54.907 --> 00:07:57.043
AND PROVIDERS. CALIFORNIA LAW
00:07:57.109 --> 00:07:58.211
HISTORICALLY WAS TECHNOLOGY
00:07:58.277 --> 00:08:00.379
NEUTRAL. MEANING STATE LAWS
00:08:00.446 --> 00:08:01.914
APPLY TO ALL SERVICES
00:08:01.981 --> 00:08:03.049
TRANSMITTING INFORMATION OVER
00:08:03.115 --> 00:08:05.885
COMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES
00:08:05.952 --> 00:08:06.452
WHETHER THOSE SERVICES WERE
00:08:06.519 --> 00:08:08.354
USING WIRES OR WIRELESS.
00:08:08.421 --> 00:08:09.989
SECTION TWO THIRTY THREE OF THE
00:08:10.056 --> 00:08:11.390
PUBLIC UTILITIES CODE
00:08:11.457 --> 00:08:13.092
SPECIFICALLY STATES THAT A
00:08:13.159 --> 00:08:14.927
TELEPHONE LINE DEFINED IT
00:08:14.994 --> 00:08:16.662
STATUTE INCLUDES ALL FACILITIES
00:08:16.729 --> 00:08:18.297
AND EQUIPMENT. USED TO PROVIDE
00:08:18.364 --> 00:08:20.399
TELEPHONE SERVICE QUOTE WITH OR
00:08:20.466 --> 00:08:21.634
WITHOUT THE USE OF TRANSMISSION
00:08:21.701 --> 00:08:26.072
WIRES. UNDER STATE LAW THE PC
00:08:26.138 --> 00:08:26.572
REGULATED ALL ASPECTS OF
00:08:26.639 --> 00:08:27.173
TRADITIONAL TELEPHONE SERVICE
00:08:27.240 --> 00:08:30.509
AND- WIRELESS SERVICES WELL. AS
00:08:30.576 --> 00:08:31.711
COMPETITION BEGAN ON FULL
00:08:31.777 --> 00:08:32.712
BEGINNING IN THE NINETEEN
00:08:32.778 --> 00:08:34.680
NINETIES THE CPC RESPONDED BY
00:08:34.747 --> 00:08:35.615
CHANGING THE WAY IT REGULATED
00:08:35.681 --> 00:08:37.350
TRADITIONAL PHONE SERVICE
00:08:37.416 --> 00:08:38.718
ELIMINATING PRICE REGULATIONS
00:08:38.784 --> 00:08:40.686
AND ALLOWING PROVIDERS REPLACE
00:08:40.753 --> 00:08:41.287
TERRACE WITH CUSTOMER SERVICE
00:08:41.354 --> 00:08:44.457
AGREEMENTS. IN NINETEEN NINETY
00:08:44.524 --> 00:08:45.091
THREE A SIGNIFICANT CHANGE IN
00:08:45.157 --> 00:08:47.159
FEDERAL LAW LIMITED HOW STATE'S
00:08:47.226 --> 00:08:48.694
CAN REGULATE WIRELESS SERVICE
00:08:48.761 --> 00:08:50.396
EVEN THOUGH CALIFORNIA LAW PUTS
00:08:50.463 --> 00:08:52.098
WIRELESS SERVICE UNDER PC
00:08:52.164 --> 00:08:53.532
JURISDICTION. THE LEGISLATION
00:08:53.599 --> 00:08:55.668
CONGRESS ENACTED CONSTRAINED
00:08:55.735 --> 00:08:56.969
STATE AUTHORITY BY PROHIBITING
00:08:57.036 --> 00:08:58.704
STATES FROM REGULATING WIRELESS
00:08:58.771 --> 00:09:00.373
RATES AND ENTRY INTO THE
00:09:00.439 --> 00:09:02.742
MARKET. THAT SAME STATUE
00:09:02.808 --> 00:09:04.410
HOWEVER RESERVE TO THE STATE TO
00:09:04.477 --> 00:09:06.479
THIRTY TO REGULATE QUOTE OTHER
00:09:06.545 --> 00:09:07.713
TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF
00:09:07.780 --> 00:09:09.882
WIRELESS SERVICE. WIRELESS
00:09:09.949 --> 00:09:11.450
SERVICE FIRST CAME ALONG IN
00:09:11.517 --> 00:09:12.718
CALIFORNIA THE PC DEEMED
00:09:12.785 --> 00:09:14.287
WIRELESS PROVIDERS TO BE
00:09:14.353 --> 00:09:15.488
TELEPHONE CORPORATIONS UNDER
00:09:15.554 --> 00:09:17.823
FEDERAL LAW JUST AS TRADITIONAL
00:09:17.890 --> 00:09:19.992
WIRELINE COMPANIES WERE. THAT'S
00:09:20.059 --> 00:09:21.193
UNDER SECTION TWO THIRTY FOUR
00:09:21.260 --> 00:09:22.461
THE PUBLIC UTILITIES CODE IN
00:09:22.528 --> 00:09:23.963
THE PC IMPOSE ON THEM ALL THE
00:09:24.030 --> 00:09:26.198
RIGHTS DUTIES AND OBLIGATIONS
00:09:26.265 --> 00:09:29.502
OF OTHER CPUC LICENSEES. IN A
00:09:29.568 --> 00:09:30.970
DECISION THE UC ISSUED
00:09:31.037 --> 00:09:32.405
IMPLEMENTING THAT CHANGE IN
00:09:32.471 --> 00:09:34.740
FEDERAL LAW IN NINETEEN NINETY
00:09:34.807 --> 00:09:35.341
THREE THE COMMISSION REQUIRED
00:09:35.408 --> 00:09:36.742
WIRELESS PROVIDERS TO PAINT A
00:09:36.809 --> 00:09:38.911
WIRELESS REGISTRATION OR WHAT
00:09:38.978 --> 00:09:40.579
WE CALL W. LINE OUR NUMBER. IN
00:09:40.646 --> 00:09:42.949
TWO THOUSAND SIX WATCH TO
00:09:43.015 --> 00:09:44.550
EXPANDING COMPETITION IN THE
00:09:44.617 --> 00:09:46.252
VIDEO MARKET THE LEGISLATURE
00:09:46.319 --> 00:09:47.586
ENACTED THE DIGITAL
00:09:47.653 --> 00:09:48.354
INFRASTRUCTURE AND VIDEO
00:09:48.421 --> 00:09:50.256
COMPETITION ACT OR GIVE CA.
00:09:50.323 --> 00:09:52.758
WHICH GAVE LICENSING AUTHORITY.
00:09:52.825 --> 00:09:55.394
OVER VIDEO COMPANIES TO THE CPC
00:09:55.461 --> 00:09:56.562
BUT AFFORDED THE COMMISSION
00:09:56.629 --> 00:09:58.531
LITTLE OVERSIGHT OF THE SERVICE
00:09:58.597 --> 00:09:59.899
OTHER THAN A SIMPLIFIED LICENSE
00:09:59.966 --> 00:10:02.668
REVIEW PROCESS EACH FRANCHISE
00:10:02.735 --> 00:10:03.803
THE COMPS CPC ISSUES UNDER
00:10:03.869 --> 00:10:05.571
DIFFICULT FOR TEN YEARS. AND
00:10:05.638 --> 00:10:06.806
THE RENEWAL PROCESS DOES NOT
00:10:06.872 --> 00:10:08.541
ALLOW THE COMMISSION TO REVIEW
00:10:08.607 --> 00:10:09.175
THE FRANCHISE SHE'S PERFORMANCE
00:10:09.241 --> 00:10:12.945
AT ANY POINT. IN TWO THOUSAND
00:10:13.012 --> 00:10:13.612
ELEVEN LEGISLATURE ENACTED
00:10:13.679 --> 00:10:17.216
SECTION. EXCUSE ME AND ACTED SB
00:10:17.283 --> 00:10:18.284
ELEVEN SIXTY ONE WHICH PUT INTO
00:10:18.351 --> 00:10:19.318
THE PUBLIC UTILITIES CODE
00:10:19.385 --> 00:10:21.120
SECTION SEVEN TEN. THAT
00:10:21.187 --> 00:10:23.089
SECTIONS SEVERELY RESTRICTED
00:10:23.155 --> 00:10:24.290
THE COMMISSION'S ABILITY TO
00:10:24.357 --> 00:10:25.825
REGULATE VOICE OVER INTERNET
00:10:25.891 --> 00:10:27.026
PROTOCOL SERVICE AS WELL AS IP
00:10:27.093 --> 00:10:29.562
ENABLE SERVICES. THE STATUE DID
00:10:29.628 --> 00:10:31.364
CONTAIN AN EXCEPTION FOR BACKUP
00:10:31.430 --> 00:10:34.000
POWER. BUT THAT. EXCEPTION
00:10:34.066 --> 00:10:36.669
LIMITED THE P. UC'S AUTHORITY
00:10:36.736 --> 00:10:37.837
TO WHAT HE DID ADOPTED IN A
00:10:37.903 --> 00:10:41.807
DECISION ISSUED IN TWO TOP TWO
00:10:41.874 --> 00:10:42.408
THOUSAND TEN AND THAT DECISION
00:10:42.475 --> 00:10:43.042
JUST CONCERNED PROVIDING NOTICE
00:10:43.109 --> 00:10:45.244
TO CUSTOMERS. FINALLY A
00:10:45.311 --> 00:10:46.746
PROTRACTED BATTLE OF TEN YEARS
00:10:46.812 --> 00:10:48.814
THE FCC DETERMINED IN TWO
00:10:48.881 --> 00:10:49.281
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN THAT
00:10:49.348 --> 00:10:50.116
BROADBAND SERVICE SHOULD BE
00:10:50.182 --> 00:10:51.517
EXEMPT FROM ALL STATE
00:10:51.584 --> 00:10:52.585
REGULATION EVEN THOUGH
00:10:52.651 --> 00:10:54.120
BROADBAND SERVICE ALSO TRAVELS
00:10:54.186 --> 00:10:55.454
OVER THE SAME FACILITIES AS
00:10:55.521 --> 00:10:56.789
TRADITIONAL PHONE SERVICE. AND
00:10:56.856 --> 00:10:58.891
WIRELESS SERVICE AND PROVIDES
00:10:58.958 --> 00:11:00.493
ESSENTIAL ACCESS TO NECESSARY
00:11:00.559 --> 00:11:03.095
SERVICES SUCH AS NINE ONE ONE.
00:11:03.162 --> 00:11:03.796
THE ENERGY IS ATION MAPS AND
00:11:03.863 --> 00:11:06.232
EVACUATION INFORMATION. SEVERAL
00:11:06.298 --> 00:11:08.100
PARTIES INCLUDING THE CPUC
00:11:08.167 --> 00:11:09.502
CHALLENGE THE FCC'S DECISION TO
00:11:09.568 --> 00:11:10.603
PREEMPT STATES FROM REGULATING
00:11:10.669 --> 00:11:12.204
BROADBAND SERVICE IN FACT THE
00:11:12.271 --> 00:11:14.840
CPC WAS THE ONLY SATE
00:11:14.907 --> 00:11:15.441
COMMISSION. THE UNITED STATES
00:11:15.508 --> 00:11:17.209
THAT CHALLENGE THAT DECISION.
00:11:17.276 --> 00:11:18.044
IN A DECISION ISSUED OCTOBER
00:11:18.110 --> 00:11:20.046
FIRST OF LAST YEAR THE DC
00:11:20.112 --> 00:11:21.514
CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS
00:11:21.580 --> 00:11:23.315
REVERSED THAT PART OF THE FCC'S
00:11:23.382 --> 00:11:24.417
ORDER WHICH PREEMPTED THE
00:11:24.483 --> 00:11:26.252
STATE'S. NONE OF THE INTERNET
00:11:26.318 --> 00:11:28.320
SERVICE PROVIDERS HAVE FILED
00:11:28.387 --> 00:11:28.821
FOR THE REPEAL OF THE DC
00:11:28.888 --> 00:11:31.057
CIRCUIT'S DECISION. IT IS STILL
00:11:31.123 --> 00:11:33.659
UNCLEAR THAT MEANS. SECTION
00:11:33.726 --> 00:11:35.361
SEVEN TEN HAS SUNSET AS OF
00:11:35.428 --> 00:11:36.896
EIGHT DAYS AGO LEAVING OPEN THE
00:11:36.962 --> 00:11:38.230
OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PC TO
00:11:38.297 --> 00:11:40.032
EXERCISE ITS AUTHORITY TO
00:11:40.099 --> 00:11:41.033
ENSURE THE NINE ONE ONE
00:11:41.100 --> 00:11:41.901
SERVICES AVAILABLE THROUGHOUT
00:11:41.967 --> 00:11:43.169
THE STATE. AND ACTUALLY
00:11:43.235 --> 00:11:44.537
DELIVERED EVEN IN TIMES OF
00:11:44.603 --> 00:11:46.005
DISASTERS ALTHOUGH THE
00:11:46.072 --> 00:11:47.339
GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
00:11:47.406 --> 00:11:49.408
SERVICES HAS RESPONSIBILITY TO
00:11:49.475 --> 00:11:50.943
IMPLEMENT THE NINE ONE ONE
00:11:51.010 --> 00:11:52.611
SYSTEM- YES DOES NOT HAVE
00:11:52.678 --> 00:11:54.113
JURISDICTION OVER THE ENTITIES
00:11:54.180 --> 00:11:55.448
TO CARRY THE NINE ONE ONE
00:11:55.514 --> 00:11:56.415
TRAFFIC TRANSMITTING THE
00:11:56.482 --> 00:11:57.883
EMERGENCY CALL FROM A
00:11:57.950 --> 00:11:58.951
DISTRAUGHT CONSUMER TO THE
00:11:59.018 --> 00:12:00.820
DISPATCH CENTER. AND BURKE FROM
00:12:00.886 --> 00:12:01.921
THERE TO THE RELEVANT FIRST
00:12:01.987 --> 00:12:04.056
RESPONDER. THAT AUTHORITY FALL
00:12:04.123 --> 00:12:06.225
SQUARELY UNDER THE CPC. AS
00:12:06.292 --> 00:12:07.026
YOU'LL HEAR FROM PRESIDENT
00:12:07.093 --> 00:12:08.594
BASHER AND COMMISSION RUPTURE
00:12:08.661 --> 00:12:10.129
OFTEN MANY SYSTEM FAILURES
00:12:10.196 --> 00:12:11.664
REQUIRE THE ABILITIES OF BOTH
00:12:11.730 --> 00:12:14.266
THE OP THE C. P. U. C. M. O.
00:12:14.333 --> 00:12:17.336
YES TO REMEDY. SO THAT'S THAT'S
00:12:17.403 --> 00:12:18.404
MY SETTING OF THE STAGE. THAT
00:12:18.471 --> 00:12:19.472
DONE I WILL. COMMISSION RUSSIA
00:12:19.538 --> 00:12:20.806
FROM WILL GO ON TO DISCUSS THE
00:12:20.873 --> 00:12:22.074
COMMISSION EXISTING SERVICE
00:12:22.141 --> 00:12:24.610
QUALITY RULES FOR THE PC AS
00:12:24.677 --> 00:12:25.144
WELL AS THE RECENT NETWORK
00:12:25.211 --> 00:12:28.747
STUDY. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:12:28.814 --> 00:12:30.516
THANK YOU CENTER HUESO CENTERS
00:12:30.583 --> 00:12:33.452
A PLEASURE TO BE HERE. AS HELEN
00:12:33.519 --> 00:12:34.854
MENTIONED I WILL TALK ABOUT OUR
00:12:34.920 --> 00:12:37.423
EXISTING SERVICE QUALITY RULES
00:12:37.490 --> 00:12:40.826
AND OUR NETWORK EXAMINATION. OR
00:12:40.893 --> 00:12:43.062
EXISTING SERVICE QUALITY RULES
00:12:43.129 --> 00:12:45.664
REQUIRE TELEPHONE COMPANIES. TO
00:12:45.731 --> 00:12:47.500
REPORT ON THREE MAIN SERVICE
00:12:47.566 --> 00:12:50.302
QUALITY METRICS CUSTOMER
00:12:50.369 --> 00:12:52.071
TROUBLE REPORTS CUSTOMER
00:12:52.138 --> 00:12:54.707
SERVICE ANSWER TIME. IN THE
00:12:54.773 --> 00:12:56.775
AMOUNT OF TIME THAT CUSTOMERS
00:12:56.842 --> 00:12:59.512
ARE OUT OF SERVICE BUT- THESE
00:12:59.578 --> 00:13:02.081
RULES APPLY TO THE TRADITIONAL
00:13:02.148 --> 00:13:03.816
VOICE TELEPHONE SERVICE
00:13:03.883 --> 00:13:05.184
PROVIDED BY COMPANIES LIKE
00:13:05.251 --> 00:13:08.654
EIGHTEEN T. TEN FRONTIER. THEY
00:13:08.721 --> 00:13:09.855
DO NOT HOWEVER APPLY TO
00:13:09.922 --> 00:13:13.225
WIRELESS VOICE CABLE VIDEO OR
00:13:13.292 --> 00:13:16.762
INTERNET OUTAGES. THE OUT OF
00:13:16.829 --> 00:13:19.565
SERVICE MEASURES VERY IMPORTANT
00:13:19.632 --> 00:13:20.766
IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT INDICATOR
00:13:20.833 --> 00:13:22.868
FOR PUBLIC SAFETY IT MEASURES
00:13:22.935 --> 00:13:25.471
THE ABILITY OF THE PUBLIC TO
00:13:25.538 --> 00:13:27.673
CONTACT NINE ONE ONE. AND
00:13:27.740 --> 00:13:30.776
EMERGENCY SERVICE SERVICES IT
00:13:30.843 --> 00:13:32.878
REQUIRES CARRIERS TO RESTORE
00:13:32.945 --> 00:13:35.548
90% OF SERVICE OUTAGES FOR
00:13:35.614 --> 00:13:36.949
REGULAR THE REGULAR TELEPHONE
00:13:37.016 --> 00:13:39.218
SERVICE WITHIN TWENTY FOUR
00:13:39.285 --> 00:13:41.387
HOURS OR LESS ON STATEWIDE
00:13:41.453 --> 00:13:44.690
AVERAGE THIS IS BY NO MEANS AN
00:13:44.757 --> 00:13:47.193
IMPOSSIBLE STANDARD TO MEET.
00:13:47.259 --> 00:13:48.260
YET THE LARGEST SERVICE
00:13:48.327 --> 00:13:50.029
PROVIDERS ROUTINELY FAIL TO
00:13:50.095 --> 00:13:51.897
MEET THESE REQUIREMENTS WE
00:13:51.964 --> 00:13:54.433
DON'T HAVE DATA YET COMPLETELY
00:13:54.500 --> 00:13:58.504
FOR TWENTY NINETEEN BUT. FOR
00:13:58.571 --> 00:13:59.071
TWENTY SEVENTEEN EIGHTEEN T.
00:13:59.138 --> 00:14:00.306
STATEWIDE AVERAGE FOR SERVICE
00:14:00.372 --> 00:14:02.107
RESTORE ILL. WITH FORTY EIGHT
00:14:02.174 --> 00:14:04.910
PERCENT. FRONTIERS WITH SIXTY
00:14:04.977 --> 00:14:07.713
THREE PERCENT. IN TWENTY
00:14:07.780 --> 00:14:10.249
EIGHTEEN EIGHTEEN TEASE WAS 56%
00:14:10.316 --> 00:14:13.485
AND FRONTIERS WAS 78% OF COURSE
00:14:13.552 --> 00:14:16.155
POURS SERVICE QUALITY LIMITS
00:14:16.222 --> 00:14:17.957
THE PUBLIC'S ABILITY TO
00:14:18.023 --> 00:14:20.092
COMMUNICATE TO PARTICIPATE IN
00:14:20.159 --> 00:14:21.260
THE ECONOMY. CONTACT NINE ONE
00:14:21.327 --> 00:14:24.163
ONE. ORDER RECEIVE
00:14:24.230 --> 00:14:24.663
COMMUNICATIONS DURING AN
00:14:24.730 --> 00:14:28.467
EMERGENCY. PURSUANT TO A
00:14:28.534 --> 00:14:30.536
PENALTY PROGRAM THAT WE
00:14:30.603 --> 00:14:33.772
ESTABLISHED IN TWENTY SEVENTEEN
00:14:33.839 --> 00:14:34.506
THE P. YOU SEE FIND THESE
00:14:34.573 --> 00:14:36.041
COMPANIES FOR FAILURE TO MEET
00:14:36.108 --> 00:14:38.744
THE SERVICE REQUIREMENTS. AS
00:14:38.811 --> 00:14:40.479
PERMITTED BY THE PROGRAM IN
00:14:40.546 --> 00:14:42.781
LIEU OF PAYING FINES INTO THE
00:14:42.848 --> 00:14:45.017
GENERAL FUND. THE COMPANY'S
00:14:45.084 --> 00:14:48.621
OPTED INSTEAD TO PAY TWICE THE
00:14:48.687 --> 00:14:50.956
AMOUNT OF THE FINES INTO
00:14:51.023 --> 00:14:52.324
PROJECTS THAT THE COMMISSION
00:14:52.391 --> 00:14:54.693
MONITORS. TO IMPROVE PARTS OF
00:14:54.760 --> 00:14:55.995
THE NETWORK THAT POOR SERVICE
00:14:56.061 --> 00:14:58.430
QUALITY OVER THE LAST TWO YEARS
00:14:58.497 --> 00:15:00.733
THE COMPANIES HAVE INVESTED
00:15:00.799 --> 00:15:02.868
SIXTEEN MILLION DOLLARS. IN
00:15:02.935 --> 00:15:05.170
SPECIFIC PARTS OF THE NETWORKS
00:15:05.237 --> 00:15:05.771
WHICH WERE FAILING IN LIEU OF
00:15:05.838 --> 00:15:09.842
PENALTIES. THERE ARE SEVERAL
00:15:09.908 --> 00:15:10.643
DIFFERENT TYPES OF OUTAGES
00:15:10.709 --> 00:15:13.012
REPORTS THAT THE SPEED YOU SEE
00:15:13.078 --> 00:15:15.814
FCC AND CARILLO YES REQUIRE WE
00:15:15.881 --> 00:15:18.150
DON'T HAVE TIME TO GO INTO.
00:15:18.217 --> 00:15:20.786
DETAIL ABOUT THOSE BUT AT A
00:15:20.853 --> 00:15:22.655
HIGH LEVEL AS I MENTIONED WE
00:15:22.721 --> 00:15:25.291
REQUIRE REPORTING ON THESE
00:15:25.357 --> 00:15:26.725
THREE SERVICE QUALITY REPORTS
00:15:26.792 --> 00:15:30.496
THESE METRICS. PROVIDERS ALSO
00:15:30.562 --> 00:15:32.865
MUST SUBMIT REPORTS TO US OF
00:15:32.931 --> 00:15:35.100
MAJOR SERVICE OUTAGES WHEN THEY
00:15:35.167 --> 00:15:37.469
OCCUR AND THESE REPORTING
00:15:37.536 --> 00:15:38.570
REQUIREMENTS TO EXTEND TO
00:15:38.637 --> 00:15:42.141
WIRELESS INVOICE PROVIDERS OUR
00:15:42.207 --> 00:15:43.509
SERVERS OUT IS REPORTING
00:15:43.575 --> 00:15:45.844
REQUIREMENT IS BASED ON THE
00:15:45.911 --> 00:15:47.913
FEDERAL COMMUNICATION STANDARDS
00:15:47.980 --> 00:15:50.916
NETWORK OUTAGE. REPORTING
00:15:50.983 --> 00:15:54.086
SYSTEM KNOWN AS NO WARS AND
00:15:54.153 --> 00:15:56.288
THESE REQUIRE ALL CARRIERS TO
00:15:56.355 --> 00:16:00.092
REPORT ON MARCH SERVICE OUTAGES
00:16:00.159 --> 00:16:03.329
THE SPECIFIC CRITERIA VARY
00:16:03.395 --> 00:16:03.929
DEPENDING ON THE LENGTH OF THE
00:16:03.996 --> 00:16:04.496
OUT ITS NUMBER OF CUSTOMERS
00:16:04.563 --> 00:16:07.232
AFFECTED. TYPE OF BUT IS IT
00:16:07.299 --> 00:16:09.768
ACTED SO THE- STATE THE FCC
00:16:09.835 --> 00:16:10.703
MAJOR OUTAGE REPORTING THERE'S
00:16:10.769 --> 00:16:12.805
A THIRD REPORTING REQUIREMENT
00:16:12.871 --> 00:16:15.207
WHICH IS VOLUNTARY IT'S KNOWN
00:16:15.274 --> 00:16:16.942
AS THE DISASTER INFORMATION
00:16:17.009 --> 00:16:19.611
REPORTING SYSTEM ORDERS. OF
00:16:19.678 --> 00:16:23.982
NOTE LARA THE OCTOBER POWER PS
00:16:24.049 --> 00:16:25.951
PS TWO ROOMS WITH THE FIRST
00:16:26.018 --> 00:16:29.688
TIME THAT THE FCC HAD ACTIVATED
00:16:29.755 --> 00:16:32.524
DOORS FOR CALIFORNIA. THE FCC
00:16:32.591 --> 00:16:33.926
ACTIVATES THAT IN CONSULTATION
00:16:33.992 --> 00:16:35.260
WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND
00:16:35.327 --> 00:16:37.262
SECURITY AND PREVIOUSLY HAD
00:16:37.329 --> 00:16:38.764
ONLY ACTIVATED THIS FOR
00:16:38.831 --> 00:16:41.700
HURRICANES OR LARGE STORMS. AND
00:16:41.767 --> 00:16:43.435
THEN FINALLY CARILLO YES IS IN
00:16:43.502 --> 00:16:46.038
THE PROCESS OF IMPLEMENTING SB
00:16:46.105 --> 00:16:46.705
SEVEN SIX SEVENTY FROM LAST
00:16:46.772 --> 00:16:48.607
YEAR WHICH AS YOU KNOW IS
00:16:48.674 --> 00:16:49.575
INTENDED TO PROVIDE EVEN MORE
00:16:49.641 --> 00:16:51.877
TIMELY INFORMATION TO EMERGENCY
00:16:51.944 --> 00:16:53.946
RESPONDERS STATED PROPOSED
00:16:54.012 --> 00:16:55.447
RULES THAT ARE OUT FOR COMMENT
00:16:55.514 --> 00:16:57.750
DIRECTOR GIL TUCCI WILL SPEAK
00:16:57.816 --> 00:16:59.051
TO MORE TO THIS REQUIREMENT IN
00:16:59.118 --> 00:17:00.953
HIS TESTIMONY. SO THAT'S AN
00:17:01.019 --> 00:17:02.921
OVERVIEW OF THE OUR EXISTING
00:17:02.988 --> 00:17:05.290
SERVICE QUALITY RULES I WANT TO
00:17:05.357 --> 00:17:08.327
NOW TURN TO DISCUSS OUR NETWORK
00:17:08.394 --> 00:17:11.230
EXAM. THIS IS AN INVESTIGATION
00:17:11.296 --> 00:17:13.565
THE P. YOU SEE ORDERED. OF THE
00:17:13.632 --> 00:17:16.301
INFRASTRUCTURE NETWORKS OF
00:17:16.368 --> 00:17:17.603
EIGHTEEN T. CALIFORNIA AND
00:17:17.669 --> 00:17:20.105
FRONTIER THOSE ARE THE STATE'S
00:17:20.172 --> 00:17:22.508
TWO MAJOR LAND LINE PROVIDERS
00:17:22.574 --> 00:17:23.976
WE ORDERED AS A RESULT OF THEIR
00:17:24.042 --> 00:17:26.745
CONSISTENT FAILURE. TO MEET
00:17:26.812 --> 00:17:27.546
EXISTING SERVICE QUALITY
00:17:27.613 --> 00:17:29.982
METRICS THE REPORT COVERS THE
00:17:30.048 --> 00:17:34.787
PERIOD. TWENTY TEN TO TWENTY
00:17:34.853 --> 00:17:35.387
SEVENTEEN. KEY FINDINGS OF THE
00:17:35.454 --> 00:17:37.356
NETWORK EXAMPLE. WIRELINE
00:17:37.423 --> 00:17:39.324
SERVICE QUALITY HAS STEADILY
00:17:39.391 --> 00:17:41.527
DETERIORATED THEY'RE MORE
00:17:41.593 --> 00:17:43.662
OUTAGES SERVICE RESTORATION
00:17:43.729 --> 00:17:46.665
TIMES ARE GETTING LONGER. THE
00:17:46.732 --> 00:17:48.167
NETWORKS ARE NOT ROBUST AND
00:17:48.233 --> 00:17:51.003
RESILIENCE ARE RESILIENT. BOTH
00:17:51.069 --> 00:17:53.038
COMPANIES HAVE CUT BACK ON
00:17:53.105 --> 00:17:55.541
PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE THEY'RE
00:17:55.607 --> 00:17:56.708
NOT MAINTAINING THEIR NETWORKS
00:17:56.775 --> 00:17:59.011
TO WITHSTAND ENVIRONMENTAL AND
00:17:59.077 --> 00:18:01.847
WEATHER RELATED CONDITIONS. THE
00:18:01.914 --> 00:18:04.016
RESULT IS A STRONG RELATIONSHIP
00:18:04.082 --> 00:18:06.718
BETWEEN BAD WEATHER AND SERVICE
00:18:06.785 --> 00:18:09.254
OUTAGES AND WE SAW THIS THIS
00:18:09.321 --> 00:18:11.323
FALL WITH THE WILD FIRES AND
00:18:11.390 --> 00:18:14.760
THE PSP EVENTS. BOTH COMPANIES
00:18:14.827 --> 00:18:16.862
HAVE BEEN DIS INVESTING IN
00:18:16.929 --> 00:18:18.697
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE
00:18:18.764 --> 00:18:21.500
TRADITIONAL LANDLINE OPERATIONS
00:18:21.567 --> 00:18:22.067
AND MOVING MONEY INTO OTHER
00:18:22.134 --> 00:18:23.769
BUSINESS AREAS. SUCH AS
00:18:23.836 --> 00:18:27.439
BROADBAND. EIGHTEEN T. IN
00:18:27.506 --> 00:18:29.575
PARTICULAR HAS FOCUSED ITS
00:18:29.641 --> 00:18:31.977
INVESTMENT ON PROVIDING SERVICE
00:18:32.044 --> 00:18:34.847
AND HIGHER INCOME COMMUNITIES.
00:18:34.913 --> 00:18:36.582
AS A RESULT THEIR CUSTOMERS IN
00:18:36.648 --> 00:18:39.952
LOWER INCOME AREAS EXPERIENCE
00:18:40.018 --> 00:18:43.288
MORE OUTAGES AND WERE SERVICE.
00:18:43.355 --> 00:18:46.024
AND THEN FINALLY THE EXAM FOUND
00:18:46.091 --> 00:18:47.125
THAT THERE IS A DIRECT
00:18:47.192 --> 00:18:48.760
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE AMOUNT
00:18:48.827 --> 00:18:50.863
OF COMPETITION IN THE AREA. AND
00:18:50.929 --> 00:18:53.799
SERVICE QUALITY RESULTS. IS
00:18:53.866 --> 00:18:55.234
WITH LOW COME LIMITED OR NO
00:18:55.300 --> 00:18:57.503
COMPETITION HAVE LOWER SERVICE
00:18:57.569 --> 00:18:59.738
QUALITY RESULTS. MEAN THAT
00:18:59.805 --> 00:19:01.273
CUSTOMERS WHO LIKELY HAVE NO
00:19:01.340 --> 00:19:03.809
ALTERNATIVE MEANS OF SERVICE
00:19:03.876 --> 00:19:07.079
TYPICALLY LESS POPULATED ROTORS
00:19:07.145 --> 00:19:07.546
AND THEREFORE RELY ON
00:19:07.613 --> 00:19:08.146
TRADITIONAL PHONE SERVICE THE
00:19:08.213 --> 00:19:10.415
MOST. EXPERIENCE THE WORST
00:19:10.482 --> 00:19:15.420
SERVICE QUALITY. WE RELEASED
00:19:15.487 --> 00:19:17.322
THE SUMMARY AND REDACTED
00:19:17.389 --> 00:19:20.092
PORTIONS OF THE REPORT THOSE
00:19:20.158 --> 00:19:22.895
ARE AVAILABLE ON OUR WEBSITE.
00:19:22.961 --> 00:19:24.930
WE'RE COMMITTED TO RELEASING ON
00:19:24.997 --> 00:19:25.531
REDACTED VERSIONS OF THE FULL
00:19:25.597 --> 00:19:28.800
REPORT. HOWEVER BOTH EIGHTEEN
00:19:28.867 --> 00:19:31.203
T. IN FRONT HERE HAVE FILED
00:19:31.270 --> 00:19:33.472
VERY SWEEPING CONFIDENTIALLY
00:19:33.539 --> 00:19:35.207
CONFIDENTIALITY CLAIMS ABOUT
00:19:35.274 --> 00:19:37.843
THE REPORT AS WE ARE REQUIRED
00:19:37.910 --> 00:19:38.877
BY LAW WE ARE GOING THROUGH
00:19:38.944 --> 00:19:40.112
EACH AND EVERYONE OF THEM
00:19:40.178 --> 00:19:42.014
CLAIMED BY CLAIMS. WITH AND
00:19:42.080 --> 00:19:43.148
WE'VE BEEN DOING THAT OVER THE
00:19:43.215 --> 00:19:45.717
PAST FEW MONTHS AND WE HOPE TO
00:19:45.784 --> 00:19:48.186
RELEASE A LESS REDACTED VERSION.
00:19:48.253 --> 00:19:50.822
SOON SO NEXT STEPS. GOING
00:19:50.889 --> 00:19:52.391
FORWARD WE'RE GONNA BE LOOKING
00:19:52.457 --> 00:19:53.659
CLOSELY AT THE ISSUES
00:19:53.725 --> 00:19:56.295
HIGHLIGHTED. BY THE EXAM
00:19:56.361 --> 00:19:58.030
INCLUDING THE ADEQUACY OF OUR
00:19:58.096 --> 00:19:59.498
CURRENT SERVICE QUALITY
00:19:59.565 --> 00:20:02.467
METRICS. AND EFFECTIVENESS OF
00:20:02.534 --> 00:20:04.970
THE CURRENT PENALTY MECHANISMS.
00:20:05.037 --> 00:20:07.072
WILL ALSO CONSIDER WHAT SERVICE
00:20:07.139 --> 00:20:09.708
QUALITY ISSUES EXIST FOR OTHER
00:20:09.775 --> 00:20:12.911
TYPES OF COMMUNICATION SERVICES.
00:20:12.978 --> 00:20:14.413
I'D LIKE TO NOTE FINALLY THAT
00:20:14.479 --> 00:20:16.048
SOME OF THE IN THE IT IT IN
00:20:16.114 --> 00:20:18.383
EQUITIES IDENTIFIED IN THE
00:20:18.450 --> 00:20:18.951
NETWORK EXAM FOR TRADITIONAL
00:20:19.017 --> 00:20:21.253
PHONE SERVICE. ARE BEING FOUND
00:20:21.320 --> 00:20:25.223
IN OTHER. TYPES OF SERVICE
00:20:25.290 --> 00:20:25.857
BROADBAND AND OTHER SERVICES AS
00:20:25.924 --> 00:20:28.260
WELL. MANY OF YOU MAY BE
00:20:28.327 --> 00:20:30.596
FAMILIAR WITH A RECENT STUDY BY
00:20:30.662 --> 00:20:31.530
THE U. S. C. INDICATING THAT IN
00:20:31.597 --> 00:20:34.032
LOS ANGELES COUNTY. COMPETITION
00:20:34.099 --> 00:20:35.601
AND THE FASTEST BROADBAND
00:20:35.667 --> 00:20:38.837
SERVICES ARE LESS LIKELY TO
00:20:38.904 --> 00:20:39.471
OCCUR IN LOW INCOME COMMUNITIES
00:20:39.538 --> 00:20:40.939
AND COMMUNITIES OF COLOR. THESE
00:20:41.006 --> 00:20:43.909
FINDINGS ARE TROUBLING.
00:20:43.976 --> 00:20:45.477
CONSISTENT WITH OUR STATUTORY
00:20:45.544 --> 00:20:47.879
MANDATES WE WILL CONTINUE WITH
00:20:47.946 --> 00:20:50.082
OUR INVESTIGATIONS ON OUR WORK
00:20:50.148 --> 00:20:52.184
TO ENSURE THAT ALL CALIFORNIANS
00:20:52.250 --> 00:20:52.784
HAVE FAIR ACCESS TO ESSENTIAL
00:20:52.851 --> 00:20:55.921
SERVICES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:20:55.988 --> 00:20:56.455
AND I'LL TURN TO PRESIDENT
00:20:56.521 --> 00:21:01.994
PATCHER. THANK YOU CLOSE. I AM
00:21:02.060 --> 00:21:04.896
FIGHTING OFF THAT COLD THAT HAS
00:21:04.963 --> 00:21:06.298
MADE THE ROUNDS PLEASE FORGIVE
00:21:06.365 --> 00:21:08.433
ME FOR MY VOICE THANK YOU A
00:21:08.500 --> 00:21:11.136
TEAR HUESO AND SENATORS- FOR
00:21:11.203 --> 00:21:14.373
INVITING ME HERE TODAY- MY NAME
00:21:14.439 --> 00:21:16.541
IS MERRY BILL BADGERING I'M
00:21:16.608 --> 00:21:17.109
PRESIDENT OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:21:17.175 --> 00:21:18.744
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION.
00:21:18.810 --> 00:21:21.213
THIS PAST OCTOBER CALIFORNIA
00:21:21.279 --> 00:21:23.949
SUFFERED THROUGH MULTIPLE WILD
00:21:24.016 --> 00:21:24.516
FIRES AND THE PUBLIC SAFETY
00:21:24.583 --> 00:21:28.987
POWER SHUT OFF. IN IN SKEWS ME
00:21:29.054 --> 00:21:30.722
THE PS PS THE PUBLIC SAFETY
00:21:30.789 --> 00:21:32.224
POWER SHUT UP EVENTS THAT
00:21:32.290 --> 00:21:33.825
IMPACTED COMMUNICATIONS
00:21:33.892 --> 00:21:37.162
NETWORKS THESE PS PST VANS IN
00:21:37.229 --> 00:21:39.264
PARTICULAR RESULTED IN MAJOR
00:21:39.331 --> 00:21:39.865
IMPACTS TO THE COMMUNICATIONS
00:21:39.931 --> 00:21:43.235
GRID. CUSTOMERS OF ALL SERVICES
00:21:43.301 --> 00:21:44.970
WERE IMPACTED WITH THEIR LAN
00:21:45.037 --> 00:21:47.406
LINE CABLE THE- I. P. OR
00:21:47.472 --> 00:21:49.975
WIRELESS CARRIERS REPORTED
00:21:50.042 --> 00:21:53.412
OUTAGES FOR NEAR HALF A MILLION
00:21:53.478 --> 00:21:55.781
WIRELINE CUSTOMERS AND ALMOST A
00:21:55.847 --> 00:21:58.250
MILLION WIRELESS CUSTOMERS.
00:21:58.316 --> 00:22:00.819
HUNDREDS OF CELL SITES WERE OUT
00:22:00.886 --> 00:22:02.254
OF SERVICE FOR VARIOUS LENGTHS
00:22:02.320 --> 00:22:04.890
OF TIME AND WHY WIRELINE
00:22:04.956 --> 00:22:08.060
FACILITIES ALSO SUFFERED IN.
00:22:08.126 --> 00:22:09.695
PARTICULARLY THE CABLE
00:22:09.761 --> 00:22:11.430
PROVIDERS FOR EXAMPLE MARIN
00:22:11.496 --> 00:22:13.265
COUNTY AND I THINK THIS IS
00:22:13.331 --> 00:22:16.001
NOTED IN YOUR- STAFF ANALYSIS
00:22:16.068 --> 00:22:19.037
AS WELL MARIN COUNTY HAD 57% OF
00:22:19.104 --> 00:22:21.239
ITS TWO HUNDRED AND EIGHTY
00:22:21.306 --> 00:22:23.241
CELLULAR TOWERS OUT OF SERVICE
00:22:23.308 --> 00:22:25.977
AT ONE TIME DURING THE PSP YES.
00:22:26.044 --> 00:22:27.846
ON OCTOBER TWENTY EIGHTH I JUST
00:22:27.913 --> 00:22:28.814
WANT TO UNDERSCORE THAT THE
00:22:28.880 --> 00:22:30.649
PERCENTAGES DON'T WELL
00:22:30.716 --> 00:22:34.386
REPRESENT MANY THOUSANDS AND IN
00:22:34.453 --> 00:22:34.986
SOME CASES MILLIONS OF PEOPLE
00:22:35.053 --> 00:22:38.190
IMPACTED. IN THE BAY AREA
00:22:38.256 --> 00:22:39.191
SENATE DOWNEY AND CONTRA COSTA
00:22:39.257 --> 00:22:41.793
COUNTY THERE WERE 11% OF CELL
00:22:41.860 --> 00:22:43.929
TOWERS FAILED TO WORK ACCORDING
00:22:43.995 --> 00:22:46.531
TO THE REPORTS FROM THE FCC.
00:22:46.598 --> 00:22:49.534
CINEMA LAKE HUMBOLDT SANTA CRUZ
00:22:49.601 --> 00:22:52.437
AND CALAVERAS COUNTIES HAD DAYS
00:22:52.504 --> 00:22:54.139
WHERE OVER 20% OF THE CELL
00:22:54.206 --> 00:22:57.209
TOWERS WERE OUT. LACK OF
00:22:57.275 --> 00:23:00.445
COMMUNICATION SERVICE IS NOT A
00:23:00.512 --> 00:23:01.079
MERE INCONVENIENCE IT ENDANGERS
00:23:01.146 --> 00:23:04.883
LIVES. CALIFORNIANS RELY ON
00:23:04.950 --> 00:23:06.918
THEIR PHONES AND THE INTERNET
00:23:06.985 --> 00:23:09.454
WHETHER WIRED OR WIRELESS TO
00:23:09.521 --> 00:23:11.523
RECEIVE EMERGENCY NOTIFICATIONS
00:23:11.590 --> 00:23:14.760
TO CONTACT FAMILY AND FRIENDS.
00:23:14.826 --> 00:23:16.394
AND TO REACH FIRST RESPONDERS
00:23:16.461 --> 00:23:19.131
SKEWS ME. THESE OUTAGES WERE
00:23:19.197 --> 00:23:21.733
UNEXPECTED GIVEN THE PREVIOUS
00:23:21.800 --> 00:23:22.868
ASSURANCES THAT THE
00:23:22.934 --> 00:23:25.370
COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY PROVIDED
00:23:25.437 --> 00:23:27.806
TO THE FCC TO YOU THE LATE
00:23:27.873 --> 00:23:31.243
LEGISLATURE AND TO WE THE CPUC
00:23:31.309 --> 00:23:32.944
THESE COMPANIES HAVE THE
00:23:33.011 --> 00:23:34.746
OBLIGATION AS WELL AS THE
00:23:34.813 --> 00:23:37.115
PRIVILEGE AND RESPONSIBILITY TO
00:23:37.182 --> 00:23:38.316
PROVIDE SERVICE TO THEIR
00:23:38.383 --> 00:23:40.752
CUSTOMERS THESE OUTAGES WERE
00:23:40.819 --> 00:23:43.655
UNACCEPTABLE. THE CPUC IS
00:23:43.722 --> 00:23:45.891
CLOSELY WORKING CLOSELY WITH
00:23:45.957 --> 00:23:48.160
CAL YES AND CAL FIRE TO ENSURE
00:23:48.226 --> 00:23:49.227
THAT THE COMMUNICATIONS
00:23:49.294 --> 00:23:52.330
CUSTOMERS ARE ABLE TO ACCESS
00:23:52.397 --> 00:23:54.432
THESE SERVICES AT ALL TIMES
00:23:54.499 --> 00:23:56.568
DURING AN EMERGENCY. OUR
00:23:56.635 --> 00:23:58.537
AGENCIES HAVE DIFFERENT ROLES
00:23:58.603 --> 00:24:00.772
BUT COLLECTIVELY WE SERVE TO
00:24:00.839 --> 00:24:03.675
ENSURE THE PUBLIC SAFETY. CAL
00:24:03.742 --> 00:24:05.343
YES AND CAL FIRE ARE
00:24:05.410 --> 00:24:06.845
RESPONSIBLE FOR SITUATION
00:24:06.912 --> 00:24:09.848
MANAGEMENT AND NEEDS SPECIFIC
00:24:09.915 --> 00:24:11.616
AND ACTIONABLE INFORMATION
00:24:11.683 --> 00:24:14.452
IMMEDIATELY. THE CPUC HAS A
00:24:14.519 --> 00:24:16.721
RESPONSIBILITY TO DEVELOP RULES
00:24:16.788 --> 00:24:18.089
TO ENSURE SAFE AND RELIABLE
00:24:18.156 --> 00:24:21.226
SERVICE. THE CPUC IS WORKING TO
00:24:21.293 --> 00:24:23.361
ENSURE EMERGENCY RESPONDERS
00:24:23.428 --> 00:24:27.299
HAVE THE INFORMATION NECESSARY
00:24:27.365 --> 00:24:28.266
TO DO THEIR JOB AND THAT WE
00:24:28.333 --> 00:24:30.702
HAVE THE RULES IN PLACE TO HOLD
00:24:30.769 --> 00:24:33.071
SERVIE PROVIDERS ACCOUNTABLE.
00:24:33.138 --> 00:24:35.473
DURING THE PS PS EVENTS I WAS
00:24:35.540 --> 00:24:37.175
AT THE STATE OPERATIONS CENTER
00:24:37.242 --> 00:24:40.111
AND I SAW FIRST HAND HOW MUCH
00:24:40.178 --> 00:24:42.781
IMPROVEMENT IS INDEED NEEDED.
00:24:42.848 --> 00:24:44.850
PRIOR TO THE INTERVENTION FROM
00:24:44.916 --> 00:24:47.319
CAL O. E. S. DIRECTOR MARK
00:24:47.385 --> 00:24:49.287
KILLER DUTY THE ROOM FOR THE
00:24:49.354 --> 00:24:51.323
COMMUNICATIONS PROVIDER WAS
00:24:51.389 --> 00:24:53.859
PROVIDERS WAS NEARLY EMPTY. THE
00:24:53.925 --> 00:24:55.627
ENGAGEMENT AND THE DELIVERY OF
00:24:55.694 --> 00:24:56.828
REAL TIME INFORMATION DURING
00:24:56.895 --> 00:24:58.964
THIS CRITICAL PERIOD WAS SIMPLY
00:24:59.030 --> 00:25:00.966
NON EXISTENT CLEARLY THE
00:25:01.032 --> 00:25:02.934
EXISTING VOLUNTARY SYSTEM WHICH
00:25:03.001 --> 00:25:05.837
WAS MENTIONED BY HELEN. AND S.
00:25:05.904 --> 00:25:08.039
EARLIER IS NOT WORKING WE HAVE
00:25:08.106 --> 00:25:09.407
SEEN THAT COMMUNICATION
00:25:09.474 --> 00:25:12.510
CARRIERS REPORTING MUST BE
00:25:12.577 --> 00:25:15.113
IMPROVED MUST BE MORE RELIABLE.
00:25:15.180 --> 00:25:16.648
AND READILY AVAILABLE AND
00:25:16.715 --> 00:25:18.416
ACCESSIBLE TO THE PUBLIC AND
00:25:18.483 --> 00:25:21.086
THE COMPANIES THEMSELVES MUST
00:25:21.152 --> 00:25:21.519
IMPROVE SITUATIONAL
00:25:21.586 --> 00:25:24.823
COMMUNICATIONS. I AM THE
00:25:24.890 --> 00:25:26.324
ASSIGNED COMMISSIONER ON THE
00:25:26.391 --> 00:25:27.692
EMERGENCY DISASTER RELIEF
00:25:27.759 --> 00:25:30.362
MEASURES AB PROCEEDING THIS
00:25:30.428 --> 00:25:31.630
PROCEEDING SEEKS TO IMPROVE
00:25:31.696 --> 00:25:35.100
DISASTER RESPONSE AND CREATE A
00:25:35.166 --> 00:25:36.768
UNIFORM FRAMEWORK FOR ALL THE
00:25:36.835 --> 00:25:37.202
UTILITIES UNDER THE
00:25:37.269 --> 00:25:38.904
COMMISSION'S JURISDICTION. AS
00:25:38.970 --> 00:25:40.872
PART OF THIS PROCEEDING I SENT
00:25:40.939 --> 00:25:43.208
A LETTER ON NOVEMBER THIRTEENTH
00:25:43.275 --> 00:25:43.975
TO THE LARGEST COMMUNICATION
00:25:44.042 --> 00:25:45.777
PROVIDERS IN CALIFORNIA
00:25:45.844 --> 00:25:48.413
REGARDING THEIR PERFORMANCE
00:25:48.480 --> 00:25:51.016
DURING THE OCTOBER PS PS EVENTS.
00:25:51.082 --> 00:25:52.851
I YES THE COMMUNICATION SERVICE
00:25:52.918 --> 00:25:54.219
PROVIDERS TO REPORT THE AMOUNT
00:25:54.286 --> 00:25:56.121
OF BACKUP POWER CURRENTLY
00:25:56.187 --> 00:25:58.590
AVAILABLE AVAILABLE TO PINPOINT
00:25:58.657 --> 00:26:00.825
LOCATIONS IN THEIR NETWORKS
00:26:00.892 --> 00:26:02.294
THAT REQUIRE HARDENING FOR
00:26:02.360 --> 00:26:05.463
WILDFIRE AND PS PSP EVENTS. AND
00:26:05.530 --> 00:26:08.033
I CALLED A PUBLIC MEETING TO
00:26:08.099 --> 00:26:08.667
HEAR RESPONSES FROM THE COMPANY
00:26:08.733 --> 00:26:11.403
EXECUTIVES. ON NOVEMBER
00:26:11.469 --> 00:26:13.638
EIGHTEENTH MAJOR WIRELESS
00:26:13.705 --> 00:26:16.374
WIRELINE AND CABLE PROVIDERS OF
00:26:16.441 --> 00:26:19.010
VOICE SERVICES RESPONDED WITH
00:26:19.077 --> 00:26:20.612
THE AMOUNT OF BACKUP POWER
00:26:20.679 --> 00:26:22.113
THEIR FACILITIES HAVE AND THE
00:26:22.180 --> 00:26:24.783
PLANS IN WHICH FOR REFUELING IT
00:26:24.849 --> 00:26:26.484
PLANS IN PLACE FOR RE FUELING
00:26:26.551 --> 00:26:29.321
THE GENERATORS. IN ADDITION WE
00:26:29.387 --> 00:26:29.888
OBTAIN DATA ON THE NUMBER OF
00:26:29.955 --> 00:26:33.224
CELL SITES. LOCATED IN TIER TWO
00:26:33.291 --> 00:26:34.826
AND TIER THREE FIRE THREAT
00:26:34.893 --> 00:26:37.729
AREAS AS WELL AS THE AMOUNT AND
00:26:37.796 --> 00:26:40.365
TYPE OF BACKUP POWER AT THESE
00:26:40.432 --> 00:26:42.734
LOCATIONS. COLLECTIVELY THE
00:26:42.801 --> 00:26:44.636
DATA ILLUSTRATES THE CURRENT
00:26:44.703 --> 00:26:46.371
CONDITION OF RESILIENCY OF OUR
00:26:46.438 --> 00:26:49.174
COMMUNICATIONS GRET. THIS
00:26:49.240 --> 00:26:51.076
INFORMATION WILL BE USED TO
00:26:51.142 --> 00:26:53.211
INFORM AND GUIDE THE POLICY
00:26:53.278 --> 00:26:55.180
THAT STRENGTHENS OUR
00:26:55.246 --> 00:26:57.349
COMMUNICATIONS GRID PREPARES IT
00:26:57.415 --> 00:26:59.384
TO WITHSTAND DISASTERS AND
00:26:59.451 --> 00:27:00.585
INSURERS IT WILL REMAIN
00:27:00.652 --> 00:27:02.620
OPERATIONAL DURING PS PS EVENTS
00:27:02.687 --> 00:27:05.890
AND DISASTERS. THE HEARING ON
00:27:05.957 --> 00:27:06.758
NOVEMBER TWENTIETH WAS
00:27:06.825 --> 00:27:09.294
SPECIFICALLY HELD TO ADDRESS
00:27:09.361 --> 00:27:11.062
FAILURES IN THE COMMUNICATION
00:27:11.129 --> 00:27:12.897
NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURE DURING
00:27:12.964 --> 00:27:15.333
THE FIRES AND THE PS PS EVENTS
00:27:15.400 --> 00:27:17.435
I MADE IT VERY CLEAR. THAT
00:27:17.502 --> 00:27:18.570
THEIR FAILURES WERE NOT
00:27:18.636 --> 00:27:20.739
ACCEPTABLE I HIGHLIGHTED THE
00:27:20.805 --> 00:27:22.474
COMMUNICATION ISSUES WIH THE
00:27:22.540 --> 00:27:23.842
OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES
00:27:23.908 --> 00:27:25.076
THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF
00:27:25.143 --> 00:27:27.645
EMERGENCY SERVICES AND THE NEED
00:27:27.712 --> 00:27:30.115
FOR STANDARDS FOR BACKUP POWER
00:27:30.181 --> 00:27:33.018
AND PUBLIC OUTAGE. REPORTING AT
00:27:33.084 --> 00:27:34.719
THE HEARING CARRIERS INFORMED
00:27:34.786 --> 00:27:38.523
ME THAT THEY HAD ADVANCED A-
00:27:38.590 --> 00:27:41.259
ALL POWER ON AMENDED AUTOMATED
00:27:41.326 --> 00:27:43.328
SKEWS ME NETWORK COMP OPERATION
00:27:43.395 --> 00:27:45.930
SYSTEMS AND YET. AND YET WE
00:27:45.997 --> 00:27:47.999
HAVE CARRIERS WHO HAVE NOT
00:27:48.066 --> 00:27:48.566
PROVIDED INFORMATION TO OUR
00:27:48.633 --> 00:27:50.535
STATE WARNING CENTER. AT THAT
00:27:50.602 --> 00:27:52.937
TIME IF CARE IS HAVE THESE
00:27:53.004 --> 00:27:54.472
ADVANCED SYSTEMS WHY ARE THEY
00:27:54.539 --> 00:27:57.308
NOT BEING SHARED WITH CAL O. E.
00:27:57.375 --> 00:27:59.444
S. OR THE PUBLIC TO ENHANCE
00:27:59.511 --> 00:28:02.781
PUBLIC SAFETY. GOING FORWARD
00:28:02.847 --> 00:28:05.283
THIS PROCEEDING WILL FOCUS ON
00:28:05.350 --> 00:28:07.419
THE ADOPTION OF FURTHER RULES
00:28:07.485 --> 00:28:08.353
TO ADDRESS COMMUNICATION
00:28:08.420 --> 00:28:10.388
NETWORK OUTAGES DURING
00:28:10.455 --> 00:28:12.057
EMERGENCY EVENTS TO KEEP THE
00:28:12.123 --> 00:28:14.993
COMMUNICATION NETWORKS FUNCTION.
00:28:15.060 --> 00:28:18.229
ON DECEMBER EIGHTEENTH THE CPUC
00:28:18.296 --> 00:28:19.964
ISSUED AS MENTIONED EARLIER A
00:28:20.031 --> 00:28:22.901
RULING THAT INCLUDES ENABLING
00:28:22.967 --> 00:28:24.369
TRANSPARENT COMMUNICATIONS
00:28:24.436 --> 00:28:26.571
BETWEEN INDUSTRY FIRST
00:28:26.638 --> 00:28:27.539
RESPONDERS ACROSS THE
00:28:27.605 --> 00:28:29.507
GOVERNMENT AND THE PUBLIC IN A
00:28:29.574 --> 00:28:31.876
TIMELY MANNER DURING DISASTROUS
00:28:31.943 --> 00:28:34.479
EVENTS AND DEVELOPING.
00:28:34.546 --> 00:28:36.281
REQUIREMENTS FOR RESILIENT AND
00:28:36.347 --> 00:28:38.383
DEPENDABLE COMMUNICATIONS GRID
00:28:38.450 --> 00:28:38.983
TO FURTHER ADDRESS
00:28:39.050 --> 00:28:41.553
COMMUNICATIONS OUTAGES DURING
00:28:41.619 --> 00:28:44.489
EMERGENCY EVENTS. ADDITIONALLY
00:28:44.556 --> 00:28:45.590
LAST SPRING THE CALIFORNIA
00:28:45.657 --> 00:28:48.359
PUBLIC ADVOCATE'S OFFICE MODE
00:28:48.426 --> 00:28:50.562
AS IT ENTERED A MOTION IN THE
00:28:50.628 --> 00:28:52.697
EMERGENCY MEASURES PROCEEDING
00:28:52.764 --> 00:28:54.833
WHICH RAISED IMPORTANT ISSUES
00:28:54.899 --> 00:28:55.800
REGARDING RESILIENCY AND YOU
00:28:55.867 --> 00:28:57.735
WILL HEAR FROM THEM LATER TODAY
00:28:57.802 --> 00:28:59.637
THEY ADVOCATED FOR SPECIFIC
00:28:59.704 --> 00:29:01.639
DUTIES FOR CARRIERS FOR THE
00:29:01.706 --> 00:29:04.109
DELIVERY. OF NINE ONE ONE.
00:29:04.175 --> 00:29:05.877
CALLS AND ROBUST BATTERY BACKUP
00:29:05.944 --> 00:29:09.080
REQUIREMENTS WROTE DIVERSITY
00:29:09.147 --> 00:29:10.682
AND ASKED US TO IMPROVE THE
00:29:10.748 --> 00:29:13.485
RELIABILITY OF ALERT WARNINGS
00:29:13.551 --> 00:29:15.253
WE WANT TO BRING THESE
00:29:15.320 --> 00:29:15.787
PROPOSALS INTO OUR PUBLIC
00:29:15.854 --> 00:29:18.857
PROCESS. IN A IN A SECOND C. U.
00:29:18.923 --> 00:29:22.393
P. C. IN A SECOND HEARING PC
00:29:22.460 --> 00:29:24.829
UCC PROCEEDING TO WHICH I AM
00:29:24.896 --> 00:29:26.231
ALSO A SIGNED THE D. ENERGY IS
00:29:26.297 --> 00:29:28.433
ATION PROCEEDING WE WILL REFINE
00:29:28.500 --> 00:29:29.667
THE P. S. P. S. PLANNING AND
00:29:29.734 --> 00:29:31.669
NOTIFICATION GUIDELINES SO
00:29:31.736 --> 00:29:32.770
COMMUNICATIONS SERVICE
00:29:32.837 --> 00:29:34.939
PROVIDERS RECEIVED THE
00:29:35.006 --> 00:29:36.608
INFORMATION THEY NEED TO
00:29:36.674 --> 00:29:38.676
MINIMIZE THE IMPACT OF PSP A-
00:29:38.743 --> 00:29:40.879
P. S. P. S. OF DENSE. ON THEIR
00:29:40.945 --> 00:29:42.380
NETWORKS AND PURCHASE PLANNING
00:29:42.447 --> 00:29:44.749
EXERCISE WITH THE ELECTRIC I
00:29:44.816 --> 00:29:46.618
USE IN ADVANCE OF THE WILDFIRE
00:29:46.684 --> 00:29:49.187
SEASON. ON JOHN JANUARY FIRST
00:29:49.254 --> 00:29:50.922
AS HELEN MENTIONED THE P. YOU
00:29:50.989 --> 00:29:53.158
SEE CODE SECTION SEVEN TEN
00:29:53.224 --> 00:29:54.459
WHICH DE REGULATED INTERNET
00:29:54.526 --> 00:29:56.828
BASED SERVICES SUNSET IT. THE
00:29:56.895 --> 00:29:57.762
COMMISSION TAKES THIS
00:29:57.829 --> 00:30:00.365
RESTORATION OF OUR FORTY AND
00:30:00.431 --> 00:30:03.067
NEW RESPONSIBILITY SERIOUSLY.
00:30:03.134 --> 00:30:06.004
AS I AS HAS BEEN CONVEYED BY MY
00:30:06.070 --> 00:30:08.072
COLLEAGUES TODAY AND BY RECENT
00:30:08.139 --> 00:30:10.175
EVENTS THERE'S CONSIDERABLE
00:30:10.241 --> 00:30:11.843
ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT WITHIN THE
00:30:11.910 --> 00:30:13.878
INDUSTRY. GOING FOR THE
00:30:13.945 --> 00:30:15.346
COMMISSION WILL SEEK TO PROTECT
00:30:15.413 --> 00:30:16.848
PUBLIC SAFETY AND TO INSURE
00:30:16.915 --> 00:30:19.083
QUALITY OF SERVICE INCLUDING
00:30:19.150 --> 00:30:21.719
CONTINUE PROVISIONS OF NINE ONE
00:30:21.786 --> 00:30:22.720
ONE AND OTHER EMERGENCY
00:30:22.787 --> 00:30:25.456
SERVICES VITAL TO PUBLIC SAFETY
00:30:25.523 --> 00:30:27.258
AS PROTECTING THE PUBLIC HEALTH
00:30:27.325 --> 00:30:29.928
SAFETY AND THE GENERAL WELFARE.
00:30:29.994 --> 00:30:31.229
WE ARE ALREADY WORKING TO
00:30:31.296 --> 00:30:32.630
EXTEND THE PROTECTIONS
00:30:32.697 --> 00:30:34.699
PROVIDED. TO THE REST OF THE
00:30:34.766 --> 00:30:37.135
TELEPHONE CUSTOMERS TO
00:30:37.202 --> 00:30:38.269
CONSUMERS WITH COMPLAINTS ABOUT
00:30:38.336 --> 00:30:40.505
THE ALLIED PEACE SERVICE. AND
00:30:40.572 --> 00:30:43.174
ANY MORE SUBSTANTIVE CHANGES TO
00:30:43.241 --> 00:30:45.610
PROTECTIONS WILL FOR THE
00:30:45.677 --> 00:30:48.479
CONSUMERS WILL GO THROUGH THE
00:30:48.546 --> 00:30:51.049
COMMISSIONER'S FORMAL PROCESS.
00:30:51.115 --> 00:30:52.817
THE COMMISSION'S FORMAL PROCESS
00:30:52.884 --> 00:30:54.886
WHICH WILL GIVE THE PUBLIC AN
00:30:54.953 --> 00:30:57.088
INDUSTRY AMPLE NOTICE AN
00:30:57.155 --> 00:30:59.724
OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN
00:30:59.791 --> 00:31:01.426
THE DEVELOPMENT OF ANY
00:31:01.492 --> 00:31:03.861
REGULATORY CHANGES. WELL BEFORE
00:31:03.928 --> 00:31:06.130
THE NEXT WILDFIRE SEASON STARTS
00:31:06.197 --> 00:31:08.499
WE MUST TOGETHER DETERMINE HOW
00:31:08.566 --> 00:31:11.135
WE VIEW NINE ONE ONE EMERGENCY
00:31:11.202 --> 00:31:13.004
ALERTS AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE
00:31:13.071 --> 00:31:14.606
COMMUNICATIONS ARE THESE
00:31:14.672 --> 00:31:16.874
NECESSITIES THAT SHOULD BE
00:31:16.941 --> 00:31:19.477
ACCESSED UNFAILINGLY. EVEN WHEN
00:31:19.544 --> 00:31:22.313
THE POWER IS OUT SHOULD IT
00:31:22.380 --> 00:31:23.815
MATTER IF THE SERVICE IS A LAND
00:31:23.881 --> 00:31:26.784
LINE SERVICE OR WIRELESS OR
00:31:26.851 --> 00:31:30.121
INTERNET BASED SERVICE ALL OF
00:31:30.188 --> 00:31:30.588
THESE INITIATIVES ARE
00:31:30.655 --> 00:31:33.825
RESPONSIBLE. AND WITH IN OUR
00:31:33.891 --> 00:31:35.760
STATUTORY MANDATE THERE ARE
00:31:35.827 --> 00:31:37.695
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS AND THE
00:31:37.762 --> 00:31:39.931
ESSENTIAL COMPONENTS OF PUBLIC
00:31:39.998 --> 00:31:41.199
SAFETY WHICH SHOULD BE
00:31:41.266 --> 00:31:43.835
AVAILABLE FOR ALL CALIFORNIANS.
00:31:43.901 --> 00:31:45.103
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
00:31:45.169 --> 00:31:46.170
TIME I APPRECIATE THE
00:31:46.237 --> 00:31:48.139
INVITATION FOR BEING HERE WITH
00:31:48.206 --> 00:31:49.974
MY COLLEAGUES THANK YOU FOR.
00:31:50.041 --> 00:31:55.146
ONE OF THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
00:31:55.213 --> 00:31:57.749
DISPATCHER I KNOW YOU'RE NEW TO
00:31:57.815 --> 00:32:00.418
THE POSITION BUT WE'VE- WE'VE
00:32:00.485 --> 00:32:03.021
BECOME A STATE THAT SO DEPEND
00:32:03.087 --> 00:32:04.589
ON ELECTRICITY AND YOU OVERSEE
00:32:04.656 --> 00:32:05.223
ELECTRICITY AND
00:32:05.290 --> 00:32:07.158
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND YOU
00:32:07.225 --> 00:32:08.293
OVERSEE TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND
00:32:08.359 --> 00:32:10.995
WE'VE BEEN SEEING TRENDS. FOR
00:32:11.062 --> 00:32:14.799
DECADES NOW PEOPLE LEAVING HARD-LINE TO CELL PHONES IN THIS
00:32:14.866 --> 00:32:17.368
BEEN GOING ON FOR SOME TIME AND
00:32:17.435 --> 00:32:19.570
YES IF I WERE JUST DID USE AN
00:32:19.637 --> 00:32:22.106
EXAMPLE YOU KNOW TRYING TO. RE
00:32:22.173 --> 00:32:23.675
IMPLEMENT A NEW TAX YOU KNOW
00:32:23.741 --> 00:32:24.309
THEY THEY WERE THEY FELL BEHIND
00:32:24.375 --> 00:32:27.879
THE TREND. YOU KNOW ALMOST A
00:32:27.945 --> 00:32:30.214
DECADE OR SO ON ON WATCHING HOW
00:32:30.281 --> 00:32:32.050
THINGS WERE CHANGING AND HOW
00:32:32.116 --> 00:32:34.052
THEY HAD TO CHARGE. TAXPAYERS
00:32:34.118 --> 00:32:37.488
FOR THE- CHARGE TO HAVE A NINE
00:32:37.555 --> 00:32:38.589
ONE ONE SERVICE SIDE I'M JUST
00:32:38.656 --> 00:32:42.260
CURIOUS IF YOU COULD TELL ME
00:32:42.327 --> 00:32:44.362
ONE OR TWO OR THREE INITIATIVES
00:32:44.429 --> 00:32:48.299
THAT THE CPUC. PURSUED. FIFTEEN
00:32:48.366 --> 00:32:49.834
TEN FIVE YEARS AGO TO. TO TELL
00:32:49.901 --> 00:32:51.536
THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY
00:32:51.602 --> 00:32:53.438
AND THE ELECTRIC INDUSTRY HEY
00:32:53.504 --> 00:32:55.606
YOU IF THIS HAPPENS YOU SHOULD
00:32:55.673 --> 00:32:57.208
BE PREPARED LIKE- HAVE A BACK
00:32:57.275 --> 00:32:59.077
UP GENERATOR. OR SOMETHING LIKE
00:32:59.143 --> 00:33:02.347
THAT WHAT WHAT WHAT IS THE CPUC
00:33:02.413 --> 00:33:02.947
DONE TO BE PROACTIVE OVER THE
00:33:03.014 --> 00:33:05.483
LAST DECADE OR TWO. AND THANK
00:33:05.550 --> 00:33:07.985
YOU CENTER MORE LOCK ON AS YOU
00:33:08.052 --> 00:33:09.287
RIGHTLY STATED I'M NEW TO THE
00:33:09.354 --> 00:33:14.092
CITY. AS OF. AUGUST SIXTEENTH-
00:33:14.158 --> 00:33:15.760
AND I THINK SOME OF THOSE
00:33:15.827 --> 00:33:18.529
ACTIONS WERE OUTLINED IN-
00:33:18.596 --> 00:33:20.465
HELEN'S TESTIMONY AND EVEN SOME
00:33:20.531 --> 00:33:22.900
WERE. IN COMMISSIONER WRECK
00:33:22.967 --> 00:33:24.635
SHAMANS TESTIMONY BUT I'M GONNA
00:33:24.702 --> 00:33:28.406
TURN TO- HELEN TO FURTHER AND
00:33:28.473 --> 00:33:29.540
NANCY EIGHT SOME OF THOSE ITEMS
00:33:29.607 --> 00:33:32.009
THAT WE HAVE UNDERTAKEN. INDEED
00:33:32.076 --> 00:33:33.544
SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE
00:33:33.611 --> 00:33:35.279
NOT BEEN I'M GONNA USE THE WORD
00:33:35.346 --> 00:33:40.551
ALLOWED. TO IMPLEMENT. HELLO.
00:33:40.618 --> 00:33:41.386
SENATOR OUT AND PRESIDENT
00:33:41.452 --> 00:33:47.658
MATCHER THE COMMISSION. HAS.
00:33:47.725 --> 00:33:51.863
NOT BEEN AS. HAS NOT REGULARLY
00:33:51.929 --> 00:33:54.065
NEW SERVICES TO THE EXTENT
00:33:54.132 --> 00:33:54.665
REGULATED OLDER SERVICES THAT
00:33:54.732 --> 00:33:57.635
WAS THE. JUST OF MY TESTIMONY
00:33:57.702 --> 00:34:01.406
AND SO WE HAVE THE COMMISSION
00:34:01.472 --> 00:34:04.642
HAS ALLOWED NASCENT INDUSTRIES
00:34:04.709 --> 00:34:07.011
LIKE WIRELESS AND BEFORE
00:34:07.078 --> 00:34:08.579
SECTION SEVEN TEN WAS PASSED V.
00:34:08.646 --> 00:34:09.981
O. I. P. TO JUST DEVELOP
00:34:10.047 --> 00:34:12.917
WITHOUT MUCH REGULATION WE WERE
00:34:12.984 --> 00:34:14.252
CONSTRAINED BY FEDERAL LAW FROM
00:34:14.318 --> 00:34:17.321
REGULATING WIRELESS RATES TREE-
00:34:17.388 --> 00:34:19.190
AND WE DID ATTEMPT TO ADOPT
00:34:19.257 --> 00:34:20.958
BACKUP POWER RULES AND ACTUALLY
00:34:21.025 --> 00:34:22.994
THE FCC DID THAT AS WELL THEN
00:34:23.060 --> 00:34:25.329
THE FCC'S EFFORT FAILED. IN THE
00:34:25.396 --> 00:34:27.732
COMMISSION ADOPTED RULES FOR
00:34:27.799 --> 00:34:28.299
THE RULES REALLY JUST ABOUT
00:34:28.366 --> 00:34:29.901
NOTICE TO CUSTOMERS. AND WE
00:34:29.967 --> 00:34:34.272
HAVE. TAKING A CLOSER LOOK AT
00:34:34.338 --> 00:34:37.008
THIS MORE RECENTLY BUT IN PAST
00:34:37.074 --> 00:34:38.142
YEARS IT WAS REALLY MORE OF AN
00:34:38.209 --> 00:34:40.411
EMPHASIS ON. ALLOWING THESE
00:34:40.478 --> 00:34:42.747
INDUSTRIES TO DEVELOP AND THAT
00:34:42.814 --> 00:34:44.582
WAS CONSISTENT WITH LEGISLATIVE
00:34:44.649 --> 00:34:48.019
DIRECTION AS WELL. THANK YOU
00:34:48.085 --> 00:34:48.619
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR SENATE
00:34:48.686 --> 00:34:52.523
JACKSON. I'D LIKE TO TAKES LIKE
00:34:52.590 --> 00:34:55.059
A DIFFERENT APPROACH TO THIS. I
00:34:55.126 --> 00:34:56.527
UNDERSTAND THAT THERE HAS BEEN
00:34:56.594 --> 00:34:58.329
A BATTLE BETWEEN THE FCC AND
00:34:58.396 --> 00:35:01.299
WHAT THE STATE'S CAN DO- YOU'VE
00:35:01.365 --> 00:35:02.967
BEEN LIMITED BY CERTAIN FEDERAL
00:35:03.034 --> 00:35:04.836
LAWS LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT TODAY
00:35:04.902 --> 00:35:06.904
MY UNDERSTANDING FROM YOUR
00:35:06.971 --> 00:35:10.208
TESTIMONY IS THAT THE FCC TRIED
00:35:10.274 --> 00:35:12.510
TO REASSERT SOME OF THOR EDDIE
00:35:12.577 --> 00:35:13.744
THAT YOU BELIEVE THE STATE HAS.
00:35:13.811 --> 00:35:17.648
STATE HAS PREVAILED. SENATOR
00:35:17.715 --> 00:35:18.282
YOU REFERRING TO THE BROADBAND
00:35:18.349 --> 00:35:22.019
ISSUE. OKAY SO MY QUESTION IS
00:35:22.086 --> 00:35:24.255
WEIRD DO YOU BELIEVE THE STATE
00:35:24.322 --> 00:35:26.224
HAS THE AUTHORITY THAT WE HAVE
00:35:26.290 --> 00:35:28.759
NOT EXERCISED THAT WE NEED TO
00:35:28.826 --> 00:35:30.628
EXERCISE OVER THE
00:35:30.695 --> 00:35:31.996
COMMUNICATIONS NETWORK
00:35:32.063 --> 00:35:33.598
SPECIFICALLY THE WIRELESS
00:35:33.664 --> 00:35:35.032
NETWORKS WE KNOW DURING THE PS
00:35:35.099 --> 00:35:38.469
PS. A THE BARK COALS THAT AS
00:35:38.536 --> 00:35:39.003
YOU MENTIONED SO MANY THE
00:35:39.070 --> 00:35:42.473
SYSTEMS WERE DOWN. WE HAD IF
00:35:42.540 --> 00:35:44.575
I'M NOT MISTAKEN NO ABILITY TO
00:35:44.642 --> 00:35:46.878
ASCERTAIN WHY THEY WERE DOWN
00:35:46.944 --> 00:35:48.045
BECAUSE THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS
00:35:48.112 --> 00:35:49.413
COMPANIES DIDN'T FEEL THEY HAD
00:35:49.480 --> 00:35:50.414
THAT THEY OWED US ANY
00:35:50.481 --> 00:35:52.149
OBLIGATION TO THAT THAT THEY
00:35:52.216 --> 00:35:55.086
WERE UNDER NO REQUIREMENTS. TO
00:35:55.152 --> 00:36:01.526
COMPLY TO BE PART OF THE.
00:36:01.592 --> 00:36:03.694
DURING OUR- FORTY DAYS OF
00:36:03.761 --> 00:36:05.496
THOMAS FIRE IN THE SUBSEQUENT
00:36:05.563 --> 00:36:07.198
DEBRIS FLOW THAT COMMUNICATIONS
00:36:07.265 --> 00:36:09.367
NETWORKS WHENEVER HE A MERCHANT
00:36:09.433 --> 00:36:11.469
SEE OFFICES WERE NOT ENGAGED TO
00:36:11.536 --> 00:36:13.037
TOLD US BASICALLY TO GO POUND
00:36:13.104 --> 00:36:16.541
SAND- AND SO TO THE EXTENT THAT
00:36:16.607 --> 00:36:19.210
WE DO HAVE. THE AUTHORITY OR
00:36:19.277 --> 00:36:20.578
THAT WE SHOULD HAVE THE
00:36:20.645 --> 00:36:21.612
AUTHORITY WHAT IS SEEK YOU
00:36:21.679 --> 00:36:24.015
WOULD LIKE TO SEE. IN ORDER
00:36:24.081 --> 00:36:27.552
FOR- WIRELESS COMPANIES TO NOT
00:36:27.618 --> 00:36:29.086
ONLY BE RESPONSIVE BUT
00:36:29.153 --> 00:36:32.423
RESPONSIBLE. AND TAKE A STRONG
00:36:32.490 --> 00:36:34.825
ROLE IN TRYING TO SURE THAT
00:36:34.892 --> 00:36:36.494
WHEN WE HAVE THESE ADVANCE WE
00:36:36.561 --> 00:36:39.330
DON'T LOSE OUR COMMUNICATIONS
00:36:39.397 --> 00:36:40.765
NETWORKS FOR THE BASIS OF NOT
00:36:40.831 --> 00:36:43.134
ONLY FOR OUR ECONOMY. BUT ALSO
00:36:43.200 --> 00:36:47.071
THE SECURITY IN THE SAFETY OF
00:36:47.138 --> 00:36:50.541
OUR ABILITY AS FAMILIES TO
00:36:50.608 --> 00:36:51.108
COMMUNICATE WITH EACH OTHER
00:36:51.175 --> 00:36:52.843
WHEN THE SYSTEM'S GOING. DID IT
00:36:52.910 --> 00:36:53.611
LITERALLY IN EVERY WAY SHAPE
00:36:53.678 --> 00:36:55.680
AND FORM THAT'S NOT ACCEPTABLE
00:36:55.746 --> 00:36:57.848
WHAT CAN WE APPEAR ON THIS DIET
00:36:57.915 --> 00:37:01.652
IS DUE TO HELP YOU MAKE THESE
00:37:01.719 --> 00:37:03.321
COMPANIES MORE ACCOUNTABLE AND
00:37:03.387 --> 00:37:05.590
RESPONSIBLE. I'LL TAKE A FIRST
00:37:05.656 --> 00:37:07.592
SWING AND THAT SENATOR AND THEN
00:37:07.658 --> 00:37:09.994
TURNED TO MY COLLEAGUES- WE
00:37:10.061 --> 00:37:11.195
HAVE PROCEEDINGS THAT I
00:37:11.262 --> 00:37:13.297
MENTIONED IN MY TESTIMONY THAT
00:37:13.364 --> 00:37:15.299
ARE UNDER WAY WERE WE WILL BE
00:37:15.366 --> 00:37:16.634
FLUSHING OUT SOME OF THE
00:37:16.701 --> 00:37:19.437
AUTHORITY. THAT WE DO HAVE AND
00:37:19.503 --> 00:37:21.505
SOME OF THE RESTORED AUTHORITY
00:37:21.572 --> 00:37:22.907
S. SINCE THE SUN SETTING OF
00:37:22.974 --> 00:37:27.044
SEVEN TEN- BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY
00:37:27.111 --> 00:37:29.580
WE NEED TO HAVE A LIABILITY AND
00:37:29.647 --> 00:37:31.616
AS HAS BEEN WELL STATED TODAY.
00:37:31.682 --> 00:37:34.251
AND RELIABILITY WILL COME IN
00:37:34.318 --> 00:37:37.688
THE MOST. YEAH IT IN THE MOST
00:37:37.755 --> 00:37:40.524
CURRENT TIME AND IN THE NEAR
00:37:40.591 --> 00:37:41.826
FUTURE WITH BATTERY BACKUP AND
00:37:41.892 --> 00:37:45.496
GENERATION. AND THAT TAKES
00:37:45.563 --> 00:37:47.598
DIFFERENT FORMS ON DIFFERENT
00:37:47.665 --> 00:37:51.469
SYSTEMS BUT- AND I CERTAINLY
00:37:51.535 --> 00:37:55.806
RESPECT THAT HOWEVER- THEY THE
00:37:55.873 --> 00:37:57.508
THAT IS WHAT WE NEED WE HAVE TO
00:37:57.575 --> 00:37:58.809
HAVE A LIABILITY ISSUE SO WELL
00:37:58.876 --> 00:38:01.145
MENTION SENATOR. YOU HAVE DEAD
00:38:01.212 --> 00:38:04.081
AIR. NO COMMUNICATIONS THAT
00:38:04.148 --> 00:38:06.550
IMPACTS WAS WAS WELL STATED IN
00:38:06.617 --> 00:38:07.818
THE STAFF AND NOW IS THAT
00:38:07.885 --> 00:38:09.320
IMPACTS HOSPITALS IT IN PACKS-
00:38:09.387 --> 00:38:11.455
THE COMMERCE OF OUR STATE TAX
00:38:11.522 --> 00:38:13.691
EVERYTHING AND THEN THEN WE
00:38:13.758 --> 00:38:16.260
HAVE POWER SURGES WHEN THEY
00:38:16.327 --> 00:38:20.364
COME BACK ON AS WELL. ACT SO WE
00:38:20.431 --> 00:38:21.098
THE RELIABILITY AND WE HAVE TO
00:38:21.165 --> 00:38:22.400
GET THEIR LIFE AND THEY NEED TO
00:38:22.466 --> 00:38:24.268
ALSO IT HERE TO THE- GUIDELINES
00:38:24.335 --> 00:38:26.570
THAT WE HAVE ALREADY INSTITUTED
00:38:26.637 --> 00:38:29.206
IN TERMS OF WHEN THAT HOW LONG
00:38:29.273 --> 00:38:32.343
THEY HAVE TO. HAVE THAT BACK UP
00:38:32.410 --> 00:38:33.978
AND THAT RELIABILITY AND HOW
00:38:34.045 --> 00:38:36.347
SOON THEY HAVE TO HAVE IT. SO
00:38:36.414 --> 00:38:38.416
HELEN ARE THERE SOME COUPLE
00:38:38.482 --> 00:38:40.051
THINGS I PROBABLY MISSED IT
00:38:40.117 --> 00:38:41.285
WOULD LIKE TO ENUNCIATE THANK
00:38:41.352 --> 00:38:42.953
YOU PRESIDENT BASHER CENERS AT
00:38:43.020 --> 00:38:45.356
THE WHAT I WOULD SAY IS. WE
00:38:45.423 --> 00:38:46.190
ALSO NEED TO MOVE OFF OF
00:38:46.257 --> 00:38:48.225
VOLUNTARY DISCLOSURE I KNOW
00:38:48.292 --> 00:38:50.061
THAT A BILL PASSED THIS YEAR-
00:38:50.127 --> 00:38:51.762
OR RATHER IN TWO THOUSAND
00:38:51.829 --> 00:38:52.697
NINETEEN AND IT DIDN'T IS A
00:38:52.763 --> 00:38:53.597
MOVE IN THAT DIRECTION WE HAVE
00:38:53.664 --> 00:38:55.099
TO SEE HOW THAT. UNFOLDS BUT
00:38:55.166 --> 00:38:56.400
THE FIRST RESPONDERS HAVE
00:38:56.467 --> 00:38:58.135
PULLED THE COMMISSION. IN
00:38:58.202 --> 00:38:59.503
PUBLIC TWICE WHEN I'VE BEEN
00:38:59.570 --> 00:39:01.405
PRESENT THAT VOLUNTARY JUST
00:39:01.472 --> 00:39:04.075
REPORTING OF OUTAGE INFORMATION
00:39:04.141 --> 00:39:06.677
IS SIMPLY NOT GOOD ENOUGH
00:39:06.744 --> 00:39:08.212
THEY'RE GETTING INFORMATION IN
00:39:08.279 --> 00:39:10.548
CASE IN IN CONSISTENT FORMATS.
00:39:10.614 --> 00:39:13.851
SPENT JUST THE REPORTING IS
00:39:13.918 --> 00:39:17.521
THREE AND DOESN'T WORK SO WE
00:39:17.588 --> 00:39:22.526
HAVE TO LOOK AT THAT AND TO. WE
00:39:22.593 --> 00:39:23.160
NEED HELP PLEDGES I THINK A LOT
00:39:23.227 --> 00:39:28.432
OF. WITH MY LIFE HEARING HAD IN
00:39:28.499 --> 00:39:29.567
NOVEMBER WHERE WE GOD FEARING
00:39:29.633 --> 00:39:30.401
COMMITMENTS FROM THE CARRIER
00:39:30.468 --> 00:39:31.268
THE DEGREE TO WHICH THEY WERE
00:39:31.335 --> 00:39:31.969
WILLING TO PUBLICLY DISCLOSE
00:39:32.036 --> 00:39:33.237
THEIR OUTAGE INFORMATION IN MY
00:39:33.304 --> 00:39:34.271
LAST QUESTION IS DO YOU BELIEVE
00:39:34.338 --> 00:39:35.039
WE HAVE THE AUTHORITY IS A
00:39:35.106 --> 00:39:35.973
STATE TO IMPOSE THAT
00:39:36.040 --> 00:39:38.075
REQUIREMENT OR IS THAT
00:39:38.142 --> 00:39:38.609
SOMETHING THAT THE FCC HAS
00:39:38.676 --> 00:39:41.746
PREEMPTED. I'M THE STATE OF
00:39:41.812 --> 00:39:43.414
CALIFORNIA HAS THE AUTHORITY TO
00:39:43.481 --> 00:39:45.449
IMPOSE REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.
00:39:45.516 --> 00:39:47.017
AND ALSO TO IT WOULD REQUIRE
00:39:47.084 --> 00:39:52.923
BACKUP POWER. I THINK YOU'LL
00:39:52.990 --> 00:39:53.557
GET A DIFFERENT ANSWER FROM THE
00:39:53.624 --> 00:40:00.397
INDUSTRY. THE OWNER OF. THE
00:40:00.464 --> 00:40:02.600
MEASURE CHAIRED AND CHAIRMAN OF
00:40:02.666 --> 00:40:03.434
THE THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE
00:40:03.501 --> 00:40:08.272
TODAY- SO I HAPPEN TO REPRESENT
00:40:08.339 --> 00:40:10.441
TO SOME OF THOSE RULE AREAS
00:40:10.508 --> 00:40:11.075
SINCE THE FIRST OF FIRST I JUST
00:40:11.142 --> 00:40:12.910
WANT TO MAKE A STATEMENT. THE
00:40:12.977 --> 00:40:17.782
P. YOU SEE. SAYS THAT THE
00:40:17.848 --> 00:40:20.684
PROVIDERS DON'T DISCLOSE IN THE
00:40:20.751 --> 00:40:22.319
PROVIDER SAY THE P. YOU SEE
00:40:22.386 --> 00:40:23.554
DOZEN NEWS TO WORK SO I'M IN
00:40:23.621 --> 00:40:25.222
THE MIDDLE OF THIS AND I'M
00:40:25.289 --> 00:40:26.123
GONNA BE ASKING THEM THE SAME
00:40:26.190 --> 00:40:28.025
QUESTIONS WE'RE IN A DIFFERENT
00:40:28.092 --> 00:40:30.194
TIME NOW WHERE WE HAVE. WE HAVE
00:40:30.261 --> 00:40:32.930
POWER OUTAGES IT WASN'T COMMON
00:40:32.997 --> 00:40:35.533
FIVE YEARS AGO WE'VE HAD
00:40:35.599 --> 00:40:37.501
CATASTROPHIC WILD FIRE THAT WAS
00:40:37.568 --> 00:40:39.670
A- COMMON FIVE YEARS AGO. BUT
00:40:39.737 --> 00:40:45.209
THE LEGISLATURE IN THE AND THE.
00:40:45.276 --> 00:40:47.278
TAXPAYERS OR RATE PAYERS I
00:40:47.344 --> 00:40:47.878
SHOULD SAY HAVE STEPPED UP TO
00:40:47.945 --> 00:40:51.182
THE PLATE. WE DID A BILL LAST
00:40:51.248 --> 00:40:54.418
YEAR THAT INCREASE THE FEE FOR
00:40:54.485 --> 00:40:55.820
NINE ONE ONE SERVICES I KNOW
00:40:55.886 --> 00:40:56.320
THAT THAT MONIES IN THE
00:40:56.387 --> 00:40:58.656
PIPELINE AND ISN'T. ON THE
00:40:58.722 --> 00:41:01.492
GROUND YET. SO WE STEPPED UP
00:41:01.559 --> 00:41:02.493
THERE WE ALSO PASSED A BILL.
00:41:02.560 --> 00:41:05.663
COUPLE YEARS BACK YES SIXTEEN
00:41:05.729 --> 00:41:10.668
SIXTY TWO WHICH. DR MONEY TO
00:41:10.734 --> 00:41:11.535
LOW INCOME NEIGHBORHOODS.
00:41:11.602 --> 00:41:14.605
KAMALA YOUR SOME OF YOUR
00:41:14.672 --> 00:41:17.274
COSTITUENTS DO AND ALSO FOR
00:41:17.341 --> 00:41:19.944
RULE AREAS WHERE WE PROVIDED
00:41:20.010 --> 00:41:23.447
ASSISTANCE FOR- NON PROFITS A
00:41:23.514 --> 00:41:25.115
IN THE UTILITIES TO BE ABLE TO
00:41:25.182 --> 00:41:27.451
GO OUT AND PROVIDE INTERNET
00:41:27.518 --> 00:41:30.221
SERVICES TO LIBRARIES HOSPITALS
00:41:30.287 --> 00:41:32.990
AND UNDERSERVED AREAS. FIRST SO
00:41:33.057 --> 00:41:36.193
WE'VE STEPPED UP SO MY QUESTION
00:41:36.260 --> 00:41:37.862
TO YOU IS WITH ALL THOSE THINGS
00:41:37.928 --> 00:41:39.864
PUT INTO PLACE WHAT WOULD YOU
00:41:39.930 --> 00:41:41.565
WHAT WOULD YOU RECOMMEND TO THE
00:41:41.632 --> 00:41:45.769
LEGISLATURE. TO HELP. BRING
00:41:45.836 --> 00:41:47.705
POWER BACK ON IN A MORE MAN OR
00:41:47.771 --> 00:41:49.039
NOT I DON'T WANT TO HEAR THAT
00:41:49.106 --> 00:41:50.341
THE I MEAN ASKED HIM THE SAME
00:41:50.407 --> 00:41:51.141
QUESTIONS AGAIN ON THE
00:41:51.208 --> 00:41:52.409
OPPORTUNITY TO I'M TRYING TO
00:41:52.476 --> 00:41:53.777
FIND OUT THE FACTS SO I KNOW
00:41:53.844 --> 00:41:55.079
WERE TO MOVE WE'VE DONE A LOT
00:41:55.145 --> 00:41:56.547
AT THE ON OUR SIDE I BELIEVE ON
00:41:56.614 --> 00:41:58.015
OUR SIDE OF IT. BUT WE NEED THE
00:41:58.082 --> 00:41:59.350
FACTS THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY GET
00:41:59.416 --> 00:42:00.818
DOWN TO WHERE WE GET THE
00:42:00.885 --> 00:42:01.852
SERVICES OUT TO OUR
00:42:01.919 --> 00:42:03.153
CONSTITUENTS WHEN WE HAVE THESE
00:42:03.220 --> 00:42:05.556
CATASTROPHIC EVENTS NOW I
00:42:05.623 --> 00:42:08.592
HAPPEN TO REPRESENT- PARADISE-
00:42:08.659 --> 00:42:10.327
WHEN I WAS IN THE ASSEMBLY. AND
00:42:10.394 --> 00:42:12.563
I WILL TELL YOU. THE WELL IT'S
00:42:12.630 --> 00:42:15.399
OTHER PROVIDERS WHERE THERE.
00:42:15.466 --> 00:42:16.634
WHEN THE WHEN THE LINES WERE
00:42:16.700 --> 00:42:18.269
DOWN AND THEY SET UP TOWERS AND
00:42:18.335 --> 00:42:20.170
WE WERE ABLE TO COMMUNICATE
00:42:20.237 --> 00:42:23.073
SOMEWHAT AFTER THE FIRE
00:42:23.140 --> 00:42:23.707
IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE FIRE WHEN
00:42:23.774 --> 00:42:24.241
THE SMOKE WAS STILL IT WAS
00:42:24.308 --> 00:42:26.277
STILL SMOKING. BUT WHEN YOU'RE
00:42:26.343 --> 00:42:29.647
IN. SISKIYOU OR YOUR IN ALPINE
00:42:29.713 --> 00:42:31.882
OR YOUR IN NEVADA COUNTY AND
00:42:31.949 --> 00:42:34.151
YOU HAVE A FIRE A TEENS FIRE
00:42:34.218 --> 00:42:35.853
THERE'S NO POSSIBLE WAY YOU CAN
00:42:35.920 --> 00:42:37.554
GET THE POWER UP IN FORTY EIGHT
00:42:37.621 --> 00:42:38.355
HOURS WHEN YOU'RE- WORKING IN
00:42:38.422 --> 00:42:40.257
MOUNTAINS LIKE THIS. AND THE
00:42:40.324 --> 00:42:41.458
MOST OF THOSE CONSTITUENTS ARE
00:42:41.525 --> 00:42:43.193
ON LAND LINES OUT THERE BECAUSE
00:42:43.260 --> 00:42:46.063
WE DON'T HAVE CELL SERVICES. SO
00:42:46.130 --> 00:42:47.398
YOU HAVE TO COMPARE APPLES TO
00:42:47.464 --> 00:42:50.301
APPLES. AND SO THAT'S WHAT I'M
00:42:50.367 --> 00:42:52.002
ASKING YOU WHAT WHAT WHAT WOULD
00:42:52.069 --> 00:42:52.469
YOU RECOMMEND TO THIS
00:42:52.536 --> 00:42:55.673
LEGISLATURE DO. WITH THESE NEW.
00:42:55.739 --> 00:42:56.941
POWER OUTAGES THAT WE'RE GONNA
00:42:57.007 --> 00:42:58.409
SEE FOR THE FUTURE THAT'S
00:42:58.475 --> 00:42:59.376
THAT'S WHAT I WANT TO KNOW AND
00:42:59.443 --> 00:43:00.678
I DON'T WANT TO HEAR BLAME I
00:43:00.744 --> 00:43:01.912
WOULD SAY IF IT'S ON THERE AND
00:43:01.979 --> 00:43:02.780
I WANT THEM THEY'RE GONNA HAVE
00:43:02.846 --> 00:43:04.081
TO. SAY I WANT TO ME TELL ME
00:43:04.148 --> 00:43:05.749
WHO'S AT FAULT. BECAUSE WE'VE I
00:43:05.816 --> 00:43:07.251
THINK STEPPED UP IN THE
00:43:07.318 --> 00:43:08.752
TAXPAYERS AND RATEPAYERS OF
00:43:08.819 --> 00:43:10.154
STEPPED UP NOW IT'S TIME TO
00:43:10.220 --> 00:43:13.023
FIGURE OUT HOW WE- COORDINATE
00:43:13.090 --> 00:43:13.657
BETWEEN YOU. AND THEM TO GET IT
00:43:13.724 --> 00:43:16.794
DONE. SENATOR IS THANK YOU AND
00:43:16.860 --> 00:43:18.329
YOU HAVE STEPPED UP. AND WE
00:43:18.395 --> 00:43:21.198
GREATLY APPRECIATE IT AND- SOME
00:43:21.265 --> 00:43:22.900
OF THE- THE STEPS THAT YOU HAVE
00:43:22.967 --> 00:43:24.368
DONE WITH TO ARTICULATED TODAY
00:43:24.435 --> 00:43:26.470
AND WE- WILL BE IN THEM.
00:43:26.537 --> 00:43:27.871
PROCEEDINGS THAT I MENTIONED
00:43:27.938 --> 00:43:30.374
FURTHER EXAMINING AND- A
00:43:30.441 --> 00:43:32.643
UTILIZING AND IMPLEMENTING SOME
00:43:32.710 --> 00:43:33.811
OF THE THINGS THAT WE NOW HAVE
00:43:33.877 --> 00:43:35.746
THE- AUTHORITY AN OPPORTUNITY
00:43:35.813 --> 00:43:37.881
TO DO. I AGREE WITH YOU THE
00:43:37.948 --> 00:43:39.583
BLAME GAME DOESN'T WORK WE
00:43:39.650 --> 00:43:40.651
POINTING THE FINGER TO THE
00:43:40.718 --> 00:43:42.386
INDUSTRY. AND ANDERSON PUTTING
00:43:42.453 --> 00:43:43.554
THE FINGER BACK AT US IT
00:43:43.620 --> 00:43:45.089
DOESN'T WORK I WILL ADMIT. IN
00:43:45.155 --> 00:43:48.092
MY- HEARING IN NOVEMBER I DID
00:43:48.158 --> 00:43:51.662
GET A LITTLE EMOTIONAL ABOUT
00:43:51.729 --> 00:43:53.397
THE FACT THAT I DIDN'T THINK
00:43:53.464 --> 00:43:54.198
THEY SHOWED UP THE WAY THEY
00:43:54.264 --> 00:43:56.467
NEEDED TO AND IN THE OCTOBER
00:43:56.533 --> 00:43:59.503
NOVEMBER EVENTS. BUT THE TOOLS
00:43:59.570 --> 00:44:01.305
WE NEED ARE THE TOOLS WE
00:44:01.372 --> 00:44:04.408
DISCUSSED AND- WE NEED
00:44:04.475 --> 00:44:05.776
INFORMATION WE NEED DATA WE
00:44:05.843 --> 00:44:07.111
NEED TO KNOW WHERE PEOPLE ARE
00:44:07.177 --> 00:44:08.612
AWARE WHERE THE OUTAGES ARE WE
00:44:08.679 --> 00:44:10.247
NEED TO KNOW. WHY THEY ARE WE
00:44:10.314 --> 00:44:14.251
NEED TO KNOW. WHAT'S ON CERTAIN
00:44:14.318 --> 00:44:16.253
POLLS I KNOW THAT'S NOT
00:44:16.320 --> 00:44:17.554
SPECIFIC TO TODAY BUT WE DON'T
00:44:17.621 --> 00:44:20.657
HAVE THAT INFORMATION- AND SO
00:44:20.724 --> 00:44:22.526
IF THINGS IF POLLS GO DOWN FOR
00:44:22.593 --> 00:44:24.028
EXAMPLE HAVE NO CLUE WHAT.
00:44:24.094 --> 00:44:26.697
WHO'S WHO'S ON THAT POLE. BUT
00:44:26.764 --> 00:44:27.965
THERE UTILIZING HOW THE
00:44:28.032 --> 00:44:30.434
UTILIZING THAT. AT FOR WHAT.
00:44:30.501 --> 00:44:32.936
AND I THINK A COMBINATION OF
00:44:33.003 --> 00:44:35.339
THE INFORMATION THAT- YES-
00:44:35.406 --> 00:44:37.174
CALLOW YES NEEDS AS WELL AS CAL
00:44:37.241 --> 00:44:38.876
FIRE IN THE ON AND- SEE BE UC'S
00:44:38.942 --> 00:44:40.444
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT IN TERMS OF
00:44:40.511 --> 00:44:42.279
DATA. AND AS I MENTIONED BEFORE
00:44:42.346 --> 00:44:44.348
THE RELIABILITY IS EXTREMELY
00:44:44.415 --> 00:44:45.516
IMPORTANT AND THOSE ARE THINGS
00:44:45.582 --> 00:44:48.018
ARE WORKING ON AND WE WILL
00:44:48.085 --> 00:44:48.552
CONTINUE TO WORK WITH THE
00:44:48.619 --> 00:44:51.588
INDUSTRY ON DOING. IT WE HAVE
00:44:51.655 --> 00:44:52.956
TO. DO MY COLLEAGUES TO DO
00:44:53.023 --> 00:44:54.925
ANYTHING ELSE. NO I DON'T HAVE
00:44:54.992 --> 00:44:55.726
ANYTHING TO ADD I THINK
00:44:55.793 --> 00:44:56.894
PRESIDENT VENTURE HAS COVERED
00:44:56.960 --> 00:44:58.695
THAT THANK YOU SENATOR
00:44:58.762 --> 00:45:01.231
BRADFORD. THANK YOU AM I THINK.
00:45:01.298 --> 00:45:03.667
THANK CHAIRMAN FOR. CLEANING
00:45:03.734 --> 00:45:04.234
THIS HEARING TODAY AND WHAT
00:45:04.301 --> 00:45:07.404
BRINGS YOUR IS. PS PS BUT
00:45:07.471 --> 00:45:08.405
REALLY WHAT BRINGS HERE'S
00:45:08.472 --> 00:45:09.473
WHAT'S SOMETHING ON A
00:45:09.540 --> 00:45:11.608
COMMISSIONER. RUSSIA IVAN-
00:45:11.675 --> 00:45:13.377
TOUCHED UPON AND WHAT WE
00:45:13.444 --> 00:45:15.612
LEARNED IN 200-010-2000 ELEVEN.
00:45:15.679 --> 00:45:18.215
THE WALL FULL MAINTENANCE OF
00:45:18.282 --> 00:45:19.149
INFRASTRUCTURE BUYER
00:45:19.216 --> 00:45:21.952
TELECOMMUNICATIONS. COMPANIES
00:45:22.019 --> 00:45:24.521
AND WE SAW IT WITH THE RAIN AND
00:45:24.588 --> 00:45:26.723
THE END OF 200-010-2000 LEVEL
00:45:26.790 --> 00:45:29.059
ONE OUT. THOUSANDS OF CUSTOMERS
00:45:29.126 --> 00:45:31.829
WERE OUT OF PHONE SERVICE FOR.
00:45:31.895 --> 00:45:33.397
MANY MANY DAYS AND WE HAD
00:45:33.464 --> 00:45:36.166
HEARINGS. HERE AND DOWN IN LOS
00:45:36.233 --> 00:45:37.801
ANGELES AND WE GET THEIR OWN
00:45:37.868 --> 00:45:39.403
EMPLOYEES THE COMMUNICATION
00:45:39.470 --> 00:45:41.505
WORKERS OF AMERICA COME BEFORE
00:45:41.572 --> 00:45:42.639
US AND TESTIFIED. THAT THE A
00:45:42.706 --> 00:45:44.641
WORK ORDERS THIS HIGH. THAT
00:45:44.708 --> 00:45:46.743
WEREN'T BEING WORKED. AND IT'S
00:45:46.810 --> 00:45:48.145
CRITICAL TO CONTINUE TO MAKE
00:45:48.212 --> 00:45:49.713
THE ARGUMENT THAT. WHILE THE
00:45:49.780 --> 00:45:51.381
CUSTOMERS ARE MIGRATING AWAY
00:45:51.448 --> 00:45:52.816
FROM THE LAND LINE BUT THAT
00:45:52.883 --> 00:45:55.085
LAND LINE IS STILL CRITICAL TO
00:45:55.152 --> 00:45:56.787
EVERYTHING THAT WE DO WHETHER
00:45:56.854 --> 00:45:58.055
IT'S WIRELESS SERVICE WHETHER
00:45:58.122 --> 00:45:59.690
IT'S FOR YOU. AND THAT LAST
00:45:59.756 --> 00:46:01.425
MILE THAT COPPER IS NOT BEING
00:46:01.492 --> 00:46:02.893
MAINTAINED SO I NEED TO
00:46:02.960 --> 00:46:04.495
UNDERSTAND. WHERE ARE WE
00:46:04.561 --> 00:46:06.563
HOLDING YOUR FEET TO THE FIRE
00:46:06.630 --> 00:46:08.866
IT WAS THE IN VERIZON. AND
00:46:08.932 --> 00:46:10.701
EIGHTEEN T. NOW IT'S FRONTIER
00:46:10.767 --> 00:46:11.602
EIGHTEEN TO WHAT ARE WE DOING
00:46:11.668 --> 00:46:14.905
TO MAKE SURE THAT CAUGHT HIS
00:46:14.972 --> 00:46:16.807
MAINTAIN THIS CRITICAL NOT ONLY
00:46:16.874 --> 00:46:17.975
THE LAND LINE CUSTOMER BUT-
00:46:18.041 --> 00:46:19.810
WIRELESS. THE WHITE. HOUSE
00:46:19.877 --> 00:46:22.446
BURKE AND ROOM SHE HAD MORE
00:46:22.513 --> 00:46:28.152
WORN. OUT SENATOR THE STATE.
00:46:28.218 --> 00:46:28.719
ALLOCATED OUT BEST FOR THOSE
00:46:28.785 --> 00:46:32.389
RURAL AREAS. THAT
00:46:32.456 --> 00:46:33.257
INFRASTRUCTURE SHE CRITICAL
00:46:33.323 --> 00:46:36.093
IT'S NOT BEING MET THANK.
00:46:36.160 --> 00:46:37.261
SENATOR BRADFORD WE I THINK YOU
00:46:37.327 --> 00:46:38.195
DID IT QUITE WELL WE NOW HAVE
00:46:38.262 --> 00:46:39.396
THE FINDINGS OF THIS NETWORK
00:46:39.463 --> 00:46:40.297
EXAMINATION THAT PLAINLY LAY
00:46:40.364 --> 00:46:40.898
OUT WHAT THE CARRIERS ARE NOT
00:46:40.964 --> 00:46:42.299
DOING. WE HAVE A SYSTEM IN
00:46:42.366 --> 00:46:43.934
PLACE FOR FINING THEM BUT WE
00:46:44.001 --> 00:46:45.235
DON'T KNOW IF IT'S WORKING IF
00:46:45.302 --> 00:46:46.637
IT'S SUFFICIENT WE DON'T KNOW
00:46:46.703 --> 00:46:47.971
IF THE EXISTING METRICS ARE
00:46:48.038 --> 00:46:49.706
ENOUGH IF WE NEED TO EXPAND
00:46:49.773 --> 00:46:51.742
THEM. AND WE'RE GONNA BE
00:46:51.808 --> 00:46:52.342
LOOKING AT THAT RIGHT AWAY IN
00:46:52.409 --> 00:46:56.180
THIS NEXT YEAR. BUT AGAIN WE
00:46:56.246 --> 00:46:57.881
KNEW THAT IN TWO THOUSAND TEN
00:46:57.948 --> 00:46:58.916
WE KNEW IN TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN.
00:46:58.982 --> 00:47:02.052
AND ARE WE- AGAIN HAVING
00:47:02.119 --> 00:47:02.653
ONGOING DIALOGUE TO MAKE SURE
00:47:02.719 --> 00:47:05.289
LIKE TO SAY THIS. COPPER IS
00:47:05.355 --> 00:47:07.291
MAINTAINED THAT LAOS LAST FALL
00:47:07.357 --> 00:47:07.925
SERVICES CRITICAL TO EVERYTHING
00:47:07.991 --> 00:47:11.361
THAT WE DO HERE. GOING. FOR IT
00:47:11.428 --> 00:47:12.896
TO END THE SOMETHING TO ASK THE
00:47:12.963 --> 00:47:14.431
CARRIERS ABOUT IT'S A VERY BIG
00:47:14.498 --> 00:47:16.200
CHALLENGE BECAUSE THEY ARE
00:47:16.266 --> 00:47:17.935
DISINVEST TING IN THOSE
00:47:18.001 --> 00:47:21.505
TRADITIONAL SERVICES THEY- SEE.
00:47:21.572 --> 00:47:24.374
MORE OPPORTUNITIES IN BROADBAND
00:47:24.441 --> 00:47:25.542
ANOTHER SERVICES WIRELESS
00:47:25.609 --> 00:47:27.911
SERVICES. AS YOU KNOW THERE'S
00:47:27.978 --> 00:47:29.780
STILL MILLIONS OF CUSTOMERS IN
00:47:29.846 --> 00:47:30.881
CALIFORNIA DEPEND ON
00:47:30.948 --> 00:47:32.349
TRADITIONAL LAND LINES WE SEE
00:47:32.416 --> 00:47:34.885
WHAT A VITAL ROLE THEY PLAY IN
00:47:34.952 --> 00:47:36.887
EMERGENCIES IN NINE ONE ONE ONE
00:47:36.954 --> 00:47:39.656
OTHER. POWERS OFF. IN THOSE
00:47:39.723 --> 00:47:42.025
NETWORKS NEED TO BE MAINTAINED.
00:47:42.092 --> 00:47:44.061
I THINK WE'RE HOPEFUL THAT
00:47:44.127 --> 00:47:46.496
TAKING A CLOSER LOOK IN COMING
00:47:46.563 --> 00:47:48.665
UP WITH NEW RULES WILL ENSURE
00:47:48.732 --> 00:47:50.500
CONTINUED INVESTMENT I THINK
00:47:50.567 --> 00:47:53.837
STRONG LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT
00:47:53.904 --> 00:47:54.438
AND HOLDING THE CARRIER'S FEET
00:47:54.504 --> 00:47:55.606
TO THE FIRE WILL HELP AS WELL.
00:47:55.672 --> 00:48:02.312
CENTER GLAZER. AT THANK YOU
00:48:02.379 --> 00:48:03.814
MISTER CHAIRMAN LET ME OF
00:48:03.880 --> 00:48:05.549
PERCENT SAY I APPRECIATE THE
00:48:05.616 --> 00:48:07.451
SPECIAL INVITATION TO BE A PART
00:48:07.517 --> 00:48:10.954
OF THE DAY THE IMPACT OF THE PS
00:48:11.021 --> 00:48:12.723
PS Và ACROSS THE STATE OF THE
00:48:12.789 --> 00:48:13.757
BEEN PROFOUND AND IT'S
00:48:13.824 --> 00:48:14.758
CERTAINLY IN MY AREA AS WELL
00:48:14.825 --> 00:48:16.560
AND I THINK THAT THE TO THE
00:48:16.627 --> 00:48:18.095
CHAIRS LEADERSHIP ON THIS SAY
00:48:18.161 --> 00:48:20.464
IT TO HEARINGS WITHIN A MATTER
00:48:20.530 --> 00:48:22.099
OF US SIXTY DAYS IS AN
00:48:22.165 --> 00:48:23.533
INDICATION I THINK OF WHAT YOU
00:48:23.600 --> 00:48:25.469
FEEL IS. HOW THE URGENCY THAT
00:48:25.535 --> 00:48:26.837
YOU BRING TO THIS ISSUE WITH
00:48:26.903 --> 00:48:28.138
THE YOU KNOW IT IS SO CRITICAL
00:48:28.205 --> 00:48:30.240
THAT- AS A LOT OF QUESTIONS I
00:48:30.307 --> 00:48:34.177
HAVE BEEN ASKED ONE I'D ASK YOU
00:48:34.244 --> 00:48:34.678
TO THE PRESIDENT. OF THE
00:48:34.745 --> 00:48:38.015
COMMISSION. AS WE- YOU KNOW THE
00:48:38.081 --> 00:48:38.949
THAT. WE'VE WE'VE HEARD ABOUT
00:48:39.016 --> 00:48:39.549
THE LANDSCAPE YOU'VE LAID IT
00:48:39.616 --> 00:48:41.518
OUT. BUT THE THING THAT MY-
00:48:41.585 --> 00:48:45.355
RESIDENTS ASK ME. IS IT STEVE.
00:48:45.422 --> 00:48:46.923
NINE MONTHS FROM NOW WE'RE
00:48:46.990 --> 00:48:48.525
GONNA BE IN THE EXACT SAME HIGH
00:48:48.592 --> 00:48:52.663
RISK MOMENT. AGAIN AND HAVE YOU
00:48:52.729 --> 00:48:53.930
DONE EVERYTHING THAT YOU CAN
00:48:53.997 --> 00:48:55.399
DO. TO ENSURE THAT WHAT WE
00:48:55.465 --> 00:49:00.504
EXPERIENCE. BEFORE WILL NOT
00:49:00.570 --> 00:49:02.339
HAPPEN AGAIN AND SO MATTER
00:49:02.406 --> 00:49:03.206
PRESIDENT THAT'S REALLY MY
00:49:03.273 --> 00:49:05.776
SIMPLE QUESTION TO YOU. THAT
00:49:05.842 --> 00:49:07.978
YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH THAT.
00:49:08.045 --> 00:49:10.047
WHAT THE CARRIERS OF SAID
00:49:10.113 --> 00:49:10.547
YOU'RE FAMILIAR WITH THE
00:49:10.614 --> 00:49:13.083
INFASTRUCTURE CIRCUMSTANCES.
00:49:13.150 --> 00:49:14.584
WHAT INSURANCE IS CAN OU GIVE
00:49:14.651 --> 00:49:16.153
US AND WE ARE PARTNERS IN THIS
00:49:16.219 --> 00:49:17.654
AND I RESPECT AND RECOGNIZE
00:49:17.721 --> 00:49:19.723
THAT BUT THAT WE WILL NOT BE IN
00:49:19.790 --> 00:49:22.459
THE SAME SITUATION NINE MONTHS
00:49:22.526 --> 00:49:23.060
FROM NOW WHAT. WHAT ASSURANCE
00:49:23.126 --> 00:49:26.930
CAN YOU GIVE US. WELL I THINK.
00:49:26.997 --> 00:49:29.399
ARM EQ WELL STATED IT WE'RE ALL
00:49:29.466 --> 00:49:30.133
PARTNERS IN THIS AND THAT
00:49:30.200 --> 00:49:31.702
INCLUDES THE INDUSTRY AS WELL.
00:49:31.768 --> 00:49:35.105
SO ON IT'S THE LEGISLATIVE
00:49:35.172 --> 00:49:36.573
OVERSIGHT THAT SO VERY
00:49:36.640 --> 00:49:37.874
IMPORTANT. IT'S THE DIFFERENT
00:49:37.941 --> 00:49:39.009
ENTITIES WITHIN THE STATE
00:49:39.076 --> 00:49:41.111
GOVERNMENT. A CAT THE
00:49:41.178 --> 00:49:42.145
GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
00:49:42.212 --> 00:49:44.581
SERVICES CAL FIRES AND THE P.
00:49:44.648 --> 00:49:46.450
UC WE HAVE PROCEEDINGS THAT ARE
00:49:46.516 --> 00:49:49.152
UNDER WAY. THAT WILL ESTABLISH
00:49:49.219 --> 00:49:50.087
ADDITIONAL RULES AND
00:49:50.153 --> 00:49:52.222
AUTHORITIES IN OVERSIGHT. I
00:49:52.289 --> 00:49:54.791
CAN'T PREJUDGE THAT HOWEVER-
00:49:54.858 --> 00:49:55.859
THOSE OF SOME OF THE THINGS ARE
00:49:55.926 --> 00:49:58.095
LOOKING AT THESE PROCEEDINGS
00:49:58.161 --> 00:49:59.196
WILL NOT GO ON FOR YEARS. I
00:49:59.262 --> 00:50:03.633
WILL MAKE SURE OF THAT- WE ARE-
00:50:03.700 --> 00:50:05.669
WE ARE AS AS MY COLLEAGUES HAVE
00:50:05.736 --> 00:50:07.604
SAID WERE ALSO REVIEWING THINGS
00:50:07.671 --> 00:50:11.408
IN A POST. SUNSET OF SEVEN TEN
00:50:11.475 --> 00:50:14.177
DODD ERA OF LOOKING INTO OTHER
00:50:14.244 --> 00:50:16.546
THINGS THAT WE CAN HOLD THE
00:50:16.613 --> 00:50:18.849
INDUSTRY RESPONSIBLE FOR I
00:50:18.915 --> 00:50:19.449
THINK THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE
00:50:19.516 --> 00:50:22.519
ALREADY. DONE TALKED ABOUT
00:50:22.586 --> 00:50:23.587
THOSE THINGS THAT WE HAVE HAD
00:50:23.653 --> 00:50:26.423
THEM TESTIFY TO. NEED TO BE
00:50:26.490 --> 00:50:29.326
FULLY IMPLEMENTED. AND AGAIN I
00:50:29.393 --> 00:50:30.627
DON'T MEAN TO POINT THE FINGER
00:50:30.694 --> 00:50:32.562
BUT WE ARE ALL IN A PARTNERSHIP
00:50:32.629 --> 00:50:35.265
HERE. THE PC HAS TO BE THE
00:50:35.332 --> 00:50:38.869
REGULATOR AND WE HAVE TO CARRY
00:50:38.935 --> 00:50:39.269
OUT OUR REGULATORY
00:50:39.336 --> 00:50:40.737
RESPONSIBILITIES WHETHER THAT
00:50:40.804 --> 00:50:43.874
MEANS- NEW AUTHORITY. OR WHAT
00:50:43.940 --> 00:50:46.877
THAT MEANS ADDITIONAL OVERSIGHT
00:50:46.943 --> 00:50:47.477
OR FRANKLY WHETHER THAT MEANS
00:50:47.544 --> 00:50:50.414
PENALTIES. BUT NONE OF US NONE
00:50:50.480 --> 00:50:55.218
OF US. WANTS TO EVER SEE A FIRE
00:50:55.285 --> 00:50:56.987
SEASON LIKE WHAT WE EXPERIENCED
00:50:57.053 --> 00:51:00.090
THIS PAST FALL AND I'D THAT
00:51:00.157 --> 00:51:01.425
GOES FOR ALL OF MY COLLEAGUES
00:51:01.491 --> 00:51:03.627
IN STATE GOVERNMENT FROM THE
00:51:03.693 --> 00:51:05.395
GOVERNOR ON DOWN THEN IN PLEASE
00:51:05.462 --> 00:51:05.896
IN MY COLLEAGUES CAN ADD
00:51:05.962 --> 00:51:10.200
ANYTHING TO THAT. GUY WHICH IS
00:51:10.267 --> 00:51:10.734
STANDARD PRESIDENT VETERAN
00:51:10.801 --> 00:51:11.768
MENTIONED EARLIER THE-
00:51:11.835 --> 00:51:13.370
EMERGENCY MEASURES PROCEEDING
00:51:13.437 --> 00:51:14.504
THAT THAT IS UNDER HER
00:51:14.571 --> 00:51:17.607
OVERSIGHT AND THAT HAS AS- AN
00:51:17.674 --> 00:51:18.675
ELEMENT IN THE NEXT PHASE WHICH
00:51:18.742 --> 00:51:21.445
IS LAUNCHING NOW- THE ISSUE OF
00:51:21.511 --> 00:51:22.112
BACKUP POWER AND WHAT WE DO
00:51:22.179 --> 00:51:24.014
ABOUT THAT. SO WE ARE MOVING ON
00:51:24.080 --> 00:51:25.715
THAT CAN YOU JUST EXPAND ON THE
00:51:25.782 --> 00:51:27.984
TIMING OF IT. OKAY I CAN'T
00:51:28.051 --> 00:51:29.419
BECAUSE I'M NOT SURE WHEN THE
00:51:29.486 --> 00:51:31.988
SCOPING MAMMAL HAS GONE OUT OR
00:51:32.055 --> 00:51:33.723
IS GOING OUT BUT ONCE IT'S
00:51:33.790 --> 00:51:34.591
GIVING THEM A CLOSE OUT THEN WE
00:51:34.658 --> 00:51:35.792
SET TO SCHEDULE FOR THE
00:51:35.859 --> 00:51:37.427
PRECEDING. COMMENTS I DON'T
00:51:37.494 --> 00:51:38.895
THINK HEARINGS ARE GONNA BE
00:51:38.962 --> 00:51:39.496
REQUIRED BUT I DON'T KNOW THAT
00:51:39.563 --> 00:51:40.430
FOR SURE I DON'T WANT TO PRE
00:51:40.497 --> 00:51:43.433
JUDGE- BUT DO YOU HAVE GOALS IN
00:51:43.500 --> 00:51:44.167
TERMS OF ONE YOU WANT YOU WANT
00:51:44.234 --> 00:51:45.602
TO FINALIZE A PROCESS. HI I
00:51:45.669 --> 00:51:46.803
DON'T DO IT AS QUICKLY AS
00:51:46.870 --> 00:51:49.072
POSSIBLE AND IT AND WE DON'T
00:51:49.139 --> 00:51:50.340
WANT TO BE BUREAUCRATIC AND
00:51:50.407 --> 00:51:52.843
EXPLAINING RIGHT. OUR PROCESS
00:51:52.909 --> 00:51:53.944
BECAUSE MY GOD I'M TRYING TO
00:51:54.010 --> 00:51:56.213
UNDERSTAND IT MYSELF AFTER
00:51:56.279 --> 00:51:57.581
BEING THERE FOR JUST. THREE
00:51:57.647 --> 00:52:00.383
FOUR MONTHS- SO WON'T DO THAT
00:52:00.450 --> 00:52:02.752
TO YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN BUT- THE
00:52:02.819 --> 00:52:05.822
SCOPING MEMO WE CAN- IN THAT
00:52:05.889 --> 00:52:06.756
IT'S MY PRECEDING I CAN HAVE
00:52:06.823 --> 00:52:08.592
SOME OVERSIGHT OVER THE-
00:52:08.658 --> 00:52:10.527
TIMELINESS OF THAT. THANK YOU
00:52:10.594 --> 00:52:11.695
AND I THINK THAT'LL BE
00:52:11.761 --> 00:52:15.432
IMPORTANT GIVEN. THE CONCERNS
00:52:15.499 --> 00:52:17.868
RAISED OVER TIME IN AND I'M NOT
00:52:17.934 --> 00:52:21.137
APPROACHING FIRE SEASON. WE'RE
00:52:21.204 --> 00:52:27.577
GONNA MOVE ONTO CENTER MCGUIRE.
00:52:27.644 --> 00:52:29.312
THANK YOU SO MUCH MISTER CHAIR-
00:52:29.379 --> 00:52:30.280
AYE AYE TWO ONE ECHO THE THANKS
00:52:30.347 --> 00:52:31.214
TO THE CHAIR THE THAT. THE
00:52:31.281 --> 00:52:32.115
TEARS BEEN ON THIS ISSUE POWER
00:52:32.182 --> 00:52:33.083
SHUT OFFS- SINCE BEFORE THE
00:52:33.149 --> 00:52:34.384
HOLIDAYS MAKING SURE WE DON'T
00:52:34.451 --> 00:52:35.218
REPEAT. THE HOT MESS THAT WE
00:52:35.285 --> 00:52:37.087
HAD- OVER THE SUMMER AND INTO
00:52:37.153 --> 00:52:38.355
THE FALL. THANK CALIFORNIANS
00:52:38.421 --> 00:52:39.856
ARE BETTER AND VERY GRATEFUL
00:52:39.923 --> 00:52:40.724
FOR YOUR WORK ALONG WITH
00:52:40.790 --> 00:52:43.960
PROTEINS WORK IS WELL- JUST
00:52:44.027 --> 00:52:46.463
WANT TO CLARIFY ONE ISSUE-
00:52:46.530 --> 00:52:49.199
MISTER CHAIR THERE IS A- A
00:52:49.266 --> 00:52:52.869
COMMENT MADE EARLIER- YES HAS
00:52:52.936 --> 00:52:54.871
BEEN MOVING FAST ENOUGH FIND
00:52:54.938 --> 00:52:56.039
NINE ONE ONE UPGRADE. THE MOVE
00:52:56.106 --> 00:52:59.376
IN TEL. THANK YOU FOR. THEY'RE
00:52:59.442 --> 00:53:00.110
ABOUT TO TAKE IN AND IT WAS
00:53:00.176 --> 00:53:00.744
DEFEATED BY THIS LEGISLATURE SO
00:53:00.810 --> 00:53:01.378
I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE. THAT
00:53:01.444 --> 00:53:02.445
WE MAKE IT VERY CLEAR WE HAD TO
00:53:02.512 --> 00:53:03.780
WAIT TO THE LEGISLATOR PROVE
00:53:03.847 --> 00:53:06.216
THE FUNDING. SO THAT- WE ASK AN
00:53:06.283 --> 00:53:07.250
IMPLEMENT A NINE ONE ONE
00:53:07.317 --> 00:53:08.585
UPGRADE TO NEXT AND NUMBER ONE.
00:53:08.652 --> 00:53:09.953
AND THEN PRESIDENT IN IT ECHO
00:53:10.020 --> 00:53:12.289
WHERE CENTER GLAZER WAS AND I
00:53:12.355 --> 00:53:12.889
JUST TWO QUICK QUESTIONS RIGHT
00:53:12.956 --> 00:53:15.892
AFTER THAT. I KNOW YOU'RE THE
00:53:15.959 --> 00:53:17.193
SCOPING MEMO BUT I THINK THAT.
00:53:17.260 --> 00:53:18.528
MEMBERS AND I DON'T SPEAK FOR
00:53:18.595 --> 00:53:19.829
FOLKS BUT I THINK ALL THIS ONE
00:53:19.896 --> 00:53:21.565
HERE HOW YOU'RE GOING TO
00:53:21.631 --> 00:53:22.666
EXPEDITE PROCEEDINGS. PRIOR TO
00:53:22.732 --> 00:53:25.468
FIRE SEASON- AND THAT'S REALLY
00:53:25.535 --> 00:53:26.503
THE HEALTH IN THE ROOM ON THE
00:53:26.570 --> 00:53:28.238
PUBLIC UTILITY SIDE. I KNOW
00:53:28.305 --> 00:53:30.206
THIS IS A FRUSTRATION FOR YOU
00:53:30.273 --> 00:53:32.676
BUT- YOU TALK ABOUT RULES AND
00:53:32.742 --> 00:53:36.846
OVERSIGHT. WHAT DOES THAT MEAN
00:53:36.913 --> 00:53:38.381
AND THEN WHAT CALVET WHAT IN
00:53:38.448 --> 00:53:40.550
YOUR MIND WHAT CAN CALIFORNIANS
00:53:40.617 --> 00:53:41.885
EXPECTING PUBLIC UTILITIES
00:53:41.952 --> 00:53:44.487
COMMISSION PRIOR TO FIRE SEASON
00:53:44.554 --> 00:53:47.424
AT ALL TO SAY. LATE SUMMER
00:53:47.490 --> 00:53:50.193
EARLY FALL WHAT CAN EXPECT WHAT
00:53:50.260 --> 00:53:51.828
TYPE OF ACTION WILL THE PUBLIC
00:53:51.895 --> 00:53:52.429
UTILITIES COMMISSION BE ACTING
00:53:52.495 --> 00:53:59.269
ON. SPECIFICALLY AND TO ANSWER
00:53:59.336 --> 00:54:03.039
YOUR QUESTION- AND IN TERMS OF
00:54:03.106 --> 00:54:05.609
THE PROCEEDINGS I WOMAN I WILL
00:54:05.675 --> 00:54:08.511
AS THE PERSON A PERSON THAT HAS
00:54:08.578 --> 00:54:09.846
THE PROCEEDINGS- ASSIGNED TO
00:54:09.913 --> 00:54:12.115
ME- I'LL MAKE SURE THAT IT
00:54:12.182 --> 00:54:14.951
SAYS- EXPEDITED AS POSSIBLE THE
00:54:15.018 --> 00:54:16.886
ONE THING THAT IS DIFFICULT IS
00:54:16.953 --> 00:54:19.255
ARE NOT DIFFICULT THE ONE THING
00:54:19.322 --> 00:54:21.057
THAT IS CHALLENGING IN TERMS OF
00:54:21.124 --> 00:54:24.427
X. EXPEDITING- ACTIVITIES IS
00:54:24.494 --> 00:54:25.895
MAKING SURE THAT THERE'S PROPER
00:54:25.962 --> 00:54:29.165
DUE PROCESS AND THAT INCLUDES-
00:54:29.232 --> 00:54:30.834
THE DUE PROCESS FOR THOSE WE
00:54:30.900 --> 00:54:32.168
REGULATE AS WELL AS THE RATE
00:54:32.235 --> 00:54:34.704
PAYERS AND OF THE PEOPLE OF
00:54:34.771 --> 00:54:36.172
CALIFORNIA SO WE WILL WE WILL
00:54:36.239 --> 00:54:38.908
EXPEDITE. OUR PROCEEDINGS AS
00:54:38.975 --> 00:54:41.678
QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE AND IN
00:54:41.745 --> 00:54:44.347
TERMS OF IMPLEMENTING WE'VE
00:54:44.414 --> 00:54:47.183
TALKED ABOUT THE THINGS THAT WE
00:54:47.250 --> 00:54:47.784
NEED AND THOSE ARE THE THINGS
00:54:47.851 --> 00:54:50.353
THAT WILL HELP US. REGULATE THE
00:54:50.420 --> 00:54:52.455
INDUSTRY AND HAVE- PROPER
00:54:52.522 --> 00:54:54.124
OVERSIGHT OF THE INDUSTRY SO
00:54:54.190 --> 00:54:55.759
THAT THE THINGS THAT WE SAW THE
00:54:55.825 --> 00:54:57.494
HOT MESSAGE YOU WELL STATED
00:54:57.560 --> 00:54:59.896
DOESN'T OCCUR AGAIN A HOT MESS
00:54:59.963 --> 00:55:02.766
WILL MEAN THAT PEOPLE DO HAVE.
00:55:02.832 --> 00:55:05.335
THE ABILITY TO CALL NINE ONE
00:55:05.402 --> 00:55:08.605
ONE WHETHER THEIR WIRELESS OR.
00:55:08.672 --> 00:55:11.207
OUR LANDLINE YEAH IN IN I KNOW
00:55:11.274 --> 00:55:12.709
SO YOU WANT TO JUMP IN I THINK
00:55:12.776 --> 00:55:16.379
JUST BEING CANDID ABOUT IT. I
00:55:16.446 --> 00:55:19.115
HAVE SOME GREAT CONCERN. ABOUT
00:55:19.182 --> 00:55:21.785
BACKUP POWER UHHUH AND WHEN WE
00:55:21.851 --> 00:55:23.019
HAD FOREIGN FIFTY FOUR FOLK
00:55:23.086 --> 00:55:24.587
FOREIGN FIFTY FOUR THOUSAND
00:55:24.654 --> 00:55:27.557
FOLKS WHO RELIED ON CABLE PHONE
00:55:27.624 --> 00:55:28.158
SERVICE OR LAND LINE OUT THIS
00:55:28.224 --> 00:55:31.194
YEAR. GETTING TO WHERE CENTER
00:55:31.261 --> 00:55:33.363
DOLLY WAS MENTIONING MENDOCINO
00:55:33.430 --> 00:55:35.198
COAST THEY CAN CALL IN AND ONE
00:55:35.265 --> 00:55:36.700
ONE. NOW AND I HAVE GREAT
00:55:36.766 --> 00:55:39.936
CONCERN- BOTH ON HOW FAST IS
00:55:40.003 --> 00:55:41.671
TAKEN ACT IN HOW FAST
00:55:41.738 --> 00:55:43.006
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND CABLE
00:55:43.073 --> 00:55:44.841
CAN ACT THAT WE MAY BE IN STORE
00:55:44.908 --> 00:55:47.544
FOR THE SAME THING THIS YEAR. I
00:55:47.610 --> 00:55:48.111
THINK WE NEED TO GET OUR ACT
00:55:48.178 --> 00:55:48.712
TOGETHER TO BE ON THE MOVE ON
00:55:48.778 --> 00:55:51.715
THAT. AND IT'S GOING TO TAKE
00:55:51.781 --> 00:55:52.916
TIME TO BE ABLE TO DO THE
00:55:52.982 --> 00:55:55.952
BACKUP POWER- WHEN IT COMES TO
00:55:56.019 --> 00:55:59.556
CELL TOWERS. AND I DON'T HAVE A
00:55:59.622 --> 00:56:00.123
CONFIDENCE INDUSTRIES GONNA
00:56:00.190 --> 00:56:03.059
MOVE WITHOUT A MANDATE. BECAUSE
00:56:03.126 --> 00:56:04.494
WHAT WE SAW IN AND THIS IS A
00:56:04.561 --> 00:56:06.663
QUESTION OF SAVE FOR THEIR
00:56:06.730 --> 00:56:09.766
DIRECTOR MUNCIE SERVICES. EVEN
00:56:09.833 --> 00:56:11.768
SURE INCE'S THIS SUMMER. AS IN
00:56:11.835 --> 00:56:13.203
YOU KNOW THIS THAT THE WORST
00:56:13.269 --> 00:56:15.105
CASE SCENARIO WOULDN'T HAPPEN
00:56:15.171 --> 00:56:17.040
WE WERE AND THE HIGHER TO MY
00:56:17.107 --> 00:56:19.042
BEING PRESIDENT RIGHT YES THEY
00:56:19.109 --> 00:56:20.210
WERE TELECOMMUNICATION
00:56:20.276 --> 00:56:21.945
COMPANIES LITERALLY HAD TO
00:56:22.011 --> 00:56:24.948
DRIVE HUNDREDS OF GENERATORS IN
00:56:25.014 --> 00:56:28.985
FROM TEXAS. TRY TO KEEP
00:56:29.052 --> 00:56:30.553
CALIFORNIA UP AND RUNNING AND
00:56:30.620 --> 00:56:34.023
IT DIDN'T WORK BUT SO I BRING
00:56:34.090 --> 00:56:35.558
ALL THIS UP THESE. I'M TRYING
00:56:35.625 --> 00:56:37.527
TO FIGURE OUT. HOW THE PUBLIC
00:56:37.594 --> 00:56:38.595
UTILITIES COMMISSION IS GOING
00:56:38.661 --> 00:56:40.663
TO BE ABLE TO MOVE ON WHAT.
00:56:40.730 --> 00:56:41.965
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT PRIOR TO
00:56:42.031 --> 00:56:43.533
THE SEASON AND I THINK WHO IS
00:56:43.600 --> 00:56:44.167
BEING HONEST ABOUT IT NOT AT
00:56:44.234 --> 00:56:46.903
ALL I TRY TO BE DIFFICULT BUT I
00:56:46.970 --> 00:56:47.504
THINK IT'S CAN BE CHALLENGING
00:56:47.570 --> 00:56:49.906
FOR YOU TO DO SO. AND THAT
00:56:49.973 --> 00:56:52.108
MEANS. WE GOT TO MOVE. WE HAVE
00:56:52.175 --> 00:56:53.109
TO BE HONEST WITH. CALIFORNIA
00:56:53.176 --> 00:56:55.445
RESIDENTS ABOUT. WHAT CHANGE
00:56:55.512 --> 00:56:57.647
THEY'RE GONNA SEE THIS YEAR AND
00:56:57.714 --> 00:56:58.281
I THINK WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO.
00:56:58.348 --> 00:57:00.950
COME UP WITH THAT- HARD. LINE
00:57:01.017 --> 00:57:02.819
MESSAGE ABOUT WHAT CHANGES ARE
00:57:02.886 --> 00:57:04.254
GOING TO SEE. I UNDERSTAND YOU
00:57:04.320 --> 00:57:05.688
MAY NOT BE ABLE TO DO THAT NOW.
00:57:05.755 --> 00:57:07.390
BUT I KNOW MISTER CHAIR THAT'S
00:57:07.457 --> 00:57:07.991
WHAT I'M INTERESTED FROM THE
00:57:08.057 --> 00:57:09.893
PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION. I
00:57:09.959 --> 00:57:11.094
AND I KNOW YOU MAY HAVE FUTURE
00:57:11.161 --> 00:57:11.761
HEARING ANNUAL HEARING
00:57:11.828 --> 00:57:12.862
OVERSIGHT HEARING. AND
00:57:12.929 --> 00:57:13.596
HOPEFULLY YOU'RE GONNA BE OUR
00:57:13.663 --> 00:57:15.064
ADDRESS THAT WHEN YOU COME
00:57:15.131 --> 00:57:16.933
BACK. ON WHAT CALIFORNIA'S CAN
00:57:17.000 --> 00:57:19.936
SEE PRIOR TO THIS. FIRE SEASON
00:57:20.003 --> 00:57:21.471
FROM PC. SWISHER OF YET TO THE-
00:57:21.538 --> 00:57:22.906
CENTER OF OUR JUST WANNA
00:57:22.972 --> 00:57:24.274
COMMENT ABOUT THE EXPEDITING OF
00:57:24.340 --> 00:57:25.942
PROCEEDINGS IT'S- I THANK YOU
00:57:26.009 --> 00:57:26.843
FOR PRESIDENT PATCHER THAT
00:57:26.910 --> 00:57:30.313
THAT'S A CENTRAL. FOCUS OF HERS
00:57:30.380 --> 00:57:32.715
TO GET THINGS DONE MORE QUICKLY.
00:57:32.782 --> 00:57:33.516
I UNDERSTAND IT'S A CENTRAL
00:57:33.583 --> 00:57:34.083
CONCERN OF THIRD LEGISLATURE
00:57:34.150 --> 00:57:35.218
HAS BEEN FOR SOME TIME. I WILL
00:57:35.285 --> 00:57:37.153
SAY WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO
00:57:37.220 --> 00:57:39.289
QUICKLY RESOLVE. MANY
00:57:39.355 --> 00:57:41.524
PROCEEDINGS RELATED TO WHILE
00:57:41.591 --> 00:57:43.493
FOR MATTERS AS MANDATED BY SB
00:57:43.560 --> 00:57:44.861
NINE A ONE AND A. B. TEN FIFTY
00:57:44.928 --> 00:57:46.863
FOUR. INCLUDING PER APPROVING
00:57:46.930 --> 00:57:47.997
THE WHILE FOR MITIGATION PLANS
00:57:48.064 --> 00:57:50.633
WITHIN A SIX MONTH PERIOD. THE
00:57:50.700 --> 00:57:52.202
PRECEDING THAT PRESIDENT
00:57:52.268 --> 00:57:53.803
PATCHES TALKING ABOUT THE- P.
00:57:53.870 --> 00:57:54.737
S. P. S. PROCEEDING WE HAD AN
00:57:54.804 --> 00:57:56.172
EARLIER PHASE THAT WAS RESOLVED
00:57:56.239 --> 00:57:57.473
WITHIN SIX MONTHS. WE ARE
00:57:57.540 --> 00:57:59.142
PROCEEDING PROVIDING EMERGENCY
00:57:59.209 --> 00:58:00.810
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS THAT WAS
00:58:00.877 --> 00:58:02.645
RESOLVED QUICKLY. WE'VE
00:58:02.712 --> 00:58:04.547
IMPLEMENTED SEVERAL. VERSIONS
00:58:04.614 --> 00:58:06.115
OF OUR COUPLE PROVISIONS OF TEN
00:58:06.182 --> 00:58:07.050
FIFTY FOUR ALREADY SO THERE. IS
00:58:07.116 --> 00:58:09.385
A SENSE OF URGENCY ABOUT THESE
00:58:09.452 --> 00:58:10.587
PARTICULAR PROCEEDINGS AND
00:58:10.653 --> 00:58:12.455
THESE PROCESSES. AND THE NEED
00:58:12.522 --> 00:58:15.658
TO RESOLVE THEM QUICKLY WE CAN
00:58:15.725 --> 00:58:16.192
WE HAVE STATUTORY LIMITS.
00:58:16.259 --> 00:58:20.430
LIMITS. TO ENSURE THAT WE
00:58:20.496 --> 00:58:21.097
COMPORT TO COMPORT WITH DUE
00:58:21.164 --> 00:58:21.764
PROCESS BUT WE ARE TRUE. WITHIN
00:58:21.831 --> 00:58:22.599
THOSE CONSTRAINTS WE'RE DOING
00:58:22.665 --> 00:58:23.700
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO RESOLVE
00:58:23.766 --> 00:58:25.134
THESE PROCEEDINGS VERY QUICKLY
00:58:25.201 --> 00:58:26.669
MR MY LAST QUESTION IS A SIMPLE
00:58:26.736 --> 00:58:28.404
ONE- THANK YOU SO MUCH
00:58:28.471 --> 00:58:30.006
SCRIPTURE AND MANY PRESENT WHEN
00:58:30.073 --> 00:58:30.807
DO YOU THINK THAT YOU CAN BE
00:58:30.874 --> 00:58:33.142
MORE SPECIFIC. ON WHAT
00:58:33.209 --> 00:58:35.078
CALIFORNIANS CAN EXPECT PRIOR
00:58:35.144 --> 00:58:37.080
TO A CALL POWER SHUT OFF SEASON
00:58:37.146 --> 00:58:41.084
IF YOU WILL- WAS AT SIXTY DAYS.
00:58:41.150 --> 00:58:41.684
NINETY DAYS WHAT'S YOUR GOTTEN
00:58:41.751 --> 00:58:46.522
ALL. BACK TO THIS YEAR. I WILL
00:58:46.589 --> 00:58:54.964
BE AS SPECIFIC AS I CAN. THAT
00:58:55.031 --> 00:58:57.267
IT NOT TO BE BUREAUCRATIC BUT
00:58:57.333 --> 00:58:58.368
SOME OF THE THINGS THAT WERE
00:58:58.434 --> 00:59:01.070
LIMITED TO IS IN A PROCEEDING I
00:59:01.137 --> 00:59:04.474
CAN'T PREJUDGE IT ON I WOULD BE
00:59:04.540 --> 00:59:06.142
IN TROUBLE WITH ALL OF YOU IF I
00:59:06.209 --> 00:59:09.345
DID THAT SO- I WILL BE AS OPEN
00:59:09.412 --> 00:59:12.115
AND FORTHCOMING- UNDER THE
00:59:12.181 --> 00:59:15.318
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE UC IF I
00:59:15.385 --> 00:59:17.654
COULD TAKE THE WIND AND WAVE IT
00:59:17.720 --> 00:59:19.222
THERE'S A LOT OF THINGS WE
00:59:19.289 --> 00:59:20.757
WOULD DO DIFFERENTLY NOT ONLY
00:59:20.823 --> 00:59:23.092
IN THE TELE IT
00:59:23.159 --> 00:59:23.660
TELECOMMUNICATIONS WORLD BUT
00:59:23.726 --> 00:59:25.561
CERTAINLY IN ELECTRICITY WORLD.
00:59:25.628 --> 00:59:28.398
WE DON'T HAVE. WE ARE THE
00:59:28.464 --> 00:59:29.766
REGULATORS WERE NOT THE
00:59:29.832 --> 00:59:32.669
IMPLEMENTOR- AS I HAVESAID TO
00:59:32.735 --> 00:59:35.438
THEM THERE AS I'VE SAID TO THE
00:59:35.505 --> 00:59:37.273
IOP IS IT'S NOT ABOUT THEIR
00:59:37.340 --> 00:59:39.075
PLANS IT'S ABOUT THEIR OUTCOMES
00:59:39.142 --> 00:59:40.877
WE CAN'T DRIVE THEIR OUTCOMES
00:59:40.944 --> 00:59:42.512
BUT WE CAN CERTAINLY REGULATE
00:59:42.578 --> 00:59:45.014
THAT TO BETTER OUTCOMES. AND I
00:59:45.081 --> 00:59:45.648
WOULD SAY THE SAME IN THE TELCO
00:59:45.715 --> 00:59:48.484
WORLD. THANK YOU SENATOR A
00:59:48.551 --> 00:59:53.790
STERN. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR
00:59:53.856 --> 00:59:55.758
LIKE A MY COLLEAGUES REMARKS
00:59:55.825 --> 00:59:57.527
CREDITING YOUR LEADERSHIP HERE
00:59:57.593 --> 00:59:59.529
STAYING VIGILANT EVEN THOUGH
00:59:59.595 --> 01:00:01.030
WE'RE THROUGH HOPEFULLY THE
01:00:01.097 --> 01:00:03.032
WORST OF IT. THANK YOU ALSO
01:00:03.099 --> 01:00:05.501
PRESENT BADGER- GETTING
01:00:05.568 --> 01:00:08.805
BURNISHED THROUGH FIRE HERE- IN
01:00:08.871 --> 01:00:09.405
A VERY REAL WAY IN YOUR FIRST
01:00:09.472 --> 01:00:13.476
FEW MONTHS. TWO TWO QUESTIONS
01:00:13.543 --> 01:00:14.043
ONE IS POINT A CLARIFICATION
01:00:14.110 --> 01:00:17.347
CORRECTION OFTEN. IT YOU TALKED
01:00:17.413 --> 01:00:20.950
ABOUT THE ANALYSIS OF THE DATA
01:00:21.017 --> 01:00:22.885
YOU'VE COLLECTED GOING THROUGH
01:00:22.952 --> 01:00:23.820
THE VARIOUS TELECOMMUNICATIONS
01:00:23.886 --> 01:00:25.588
PROVIDERS AND THERE WOULD YOU
01:00:25.655 --> 01:00:27.724
CALM THEIR RESTORATION RATES
01:00:27.790 --> 01:00:30.193
THE PERCENTAGES THAT YOU TICKED
01:00:30.259 --> 01:00:32.362
OFF FIRST CAN YOU GO BACK
01:00:32.428 --> 01:00:32.929
THROUGH WOMEN AND JUST. WHAT
01:00:32.996 --> 01:00:34.697
WHAT DO THEY MEAN IS THAT. HOW
01:00:34.764 --> 01:00:36.299
HOW QUICKLY THEY'RE ABLE TO
01:00:36.366 --> 01:00:38.434
RESTORE SERVICE WITHIN A GIVEN
01:00:38.501 --> 01:00:41.070
PERIOD OF TIME OR OR IS IT.
01:00:41.137 --> 01:00:43.306
ABOUT THE SORT OF I KNOW
01:00:43.373 --> 01:00:44.374
THERE'S THE WE'RE GONNA HEAR
01:00:44.440 --> 01:00:45.408
DATA ALSO FROM THE
01:00:45.475 --> 01:00:46.843
TELECOMMUNICATIONS FOLKS BUT WE
01:00:46.909 --> 01:00:48.244
WHERE THEY'VE GOT BACK UP
01:00:48.311 --> 01:00:49.979
GENERATION ON WHICH SITES AT
01:00:50.046 --> 01:00:54.217
CETERA BUT JUST. RUN THAT BACK
01:00:54.283 --> 01:00:57.387
THROUGH S THE CENTER STERN.
01:00:57.453 --> 01:00:58.388
ONE OF THE METRICS IS THE
01:00:58.454 --> 01:01:01.257
AMOUNT OF TIME. THAT CERTAIN
01:01:01.324 --> 01:01:03.826
THAT SERVICES OUT AND HOW LONG
01:01:03.893 --> 01:01:05.595
IT TAKES TO RESTORE THE
01:01:05.661 --> 01:01:07.463
SERVICE. AND WE HAVE A
01:01:07.530 --> 01:01:08.831
REQUIREMENT THAT CARRIERS
01:01:08.898 --> 01:01:11.934
RESTORE 90% OF SERVICE OUTAGES
01:01:12.001 --> 01:01:14.871
FOR REGULAR TELEPHONE SERVICE.
01:01:14.937 --> 01:01:15.838
WITHIN TWENTY FOUR HOURS OR
01:01:15.905 --> 01:01:17.607
LESS ON THE STATEWIDE AVERAGE.
01:01:17.673 --> 01:01:19.208
IT'S A WIN USE I FORGET EXACTLY
01:01:19.275 --> 01:01:23.279
THE PERCENTAGES WERE 56% FOR AT
01:01:23.346 --> 01:01:26.182
AND T. OR 48% FOR THE WHAT IS
01:01:26.249 --> 01:01:27.617
THAT THAT PERTAINS TO THAT
01:01:27.683 --> 01:01:29.719
PERTAINS TO THEIR ABILITY TO.
01:01:29.786 --> 01:01:31.954
RESTORE SERVICE WITHIN TWENTY
01:01:32.021 --> 01:01:33.256
FOUR HOURS ON THE STATEWIDE
01:01:33.322 --> 01:01:36.125
AVERAGE SHOT IT SO ROUGHLY HALF
01:01:36.192 --> 01:01:38.928
FOR SO OR SOME A LITTLE MORE
01:01:38.995 --> 01:01:39.629
THAN HAVE SOME LESS THAN HALF
01:01:39.695 --> 01:01:41.364
FOR EIGHT ARE ABLE TO. MEET
01:01:41.431 --> 01:01:42.231
THAT REQUIREMENT ACROSS THEIR
01:01:42.298 --> 01:01:44.333
NETWORK. THAT'S CORRECT THEY
01:01:44.400 --> 01:01:46.302
WERE ABLE THEY WERE UNABLE TO
01:01:46.369 --> 01:01:47.503
RESTORE SERVICE WITHIN TWENTY
01:01:47.570 --> 01:01:52.708
FOUR HOURS IN. IN IN FOR A 52%
01:01:52.775 --> 01:01:55.645
OF THE CASES IN EIGHTEEN T. IN
01:01:55.711 --> 01:01:56.846
TWENTY SEVENTEEN FOR EXAMPLE.
01:01:56.913 --> 01:01:59.148
THERE'S AT THE WEB VERGE FOR
01:01:59.215 --> 01:02:01.150
SERVICE WAS SORREL. IN WHICH
01:02:01.217 --> 01:02:03.786
THEY WERE ABLE TO DO WAS 48% SO
01:02:03.853 --> 01:02:06.622
52% THEY WERE NOT ABLE TO AND
01:02:06.689 --> 01:02:11.461
IS THAT LIMITED JUST TO ACQUIRE
01:02:11.527 --> 01:02:15.431
LISTS OR- IS THAT ALSO INCLUDE.
01:02:15.498 --> 01:02:16.732
VOICE OVER IP THIS IS DOES THE
01:02:16.799 --> 01:02:17.733
TRICK IN ALL THE LAND MINES
01:02:17.800 --> 01:02:18.935
JUST FOR LAND I GOT IT SO I'M
01:02:19.001 --> 01:02:19.569
ONE OF THOSE CUSTOMERS THAT. IS
01:02:19.635 --> 01:02:21.270
NOW MAYBE IN THE PURVIEW OF
01:02:21.337 --> 01:02:23.272
PC'S- WORK GOING FORWARD
01:02:23.339 --> 01:02:24.207
ALTHOUGH I KNOW I WOULD NOTE
01:02:24.273 --> 01:02:26.109
THAT ELEVEN THINGS ELEVEN SIXTY
01:02:26.175 --> 01:02:27.210
ONE A LOT FOR THE MONITORING
01:02:27.276 --> 01:02:30.746
OF. VOICE SERVICES SO I STILL.
01:02:30.813 --> 01:02:33.015
EVEN UNDER PRESSURE PRIOR LIFE
01:02:33.082 --> 01:02:34.984
IT SEEMS LIKE THERE WAS A
01:02:35.051 --> 01:02:36.452
ABILITY COLLECT SOME DATA BUT
01:02:36.519 --> 01:02:37.920
DO YOU ANTICIPATE AND I'M ON
01:02:37.987 --> 01:02:39.722
THE FOLKS WHO WOKE UP TO A FIRE
01:02:39.789 --> 01:02:43.092
IN THEIR BACKYARD- HAVE A WEEK
01:02:43.159 --> 01:02:44.861
FOR MY WEAPON. WHATEVER YOU
01:02:44.927 --> 01:02:45.728
KNOW YOU PLAN AROUND THOSE
01:02:45.795 --> 01:02:47.530
THINGS YOU WAKE UP TO SMOKE I
01:02:47.597 --> 01:02:48.831
HAVE NO CELL PHONE RECEPTION ON
01:02:48.898 --> 01:02:51.100
THE MOUNTAIN ROAD I'M ON. BUT
01:02:51.167 --> 01:02:52.802
THE LOOK THEY GET MY CAR AND
01:02:52.869 --> 01:02:54.937
GET OUT OF THERE- NOT EVERYONE
01:02:55.004 --> 01:02:56.973
IS AS LUCKY. AND HAS THOSE
01:02:57.039 --> 01:03:02.011
FACULTIES OUR ABILITIES- AND MY
01:03:02.078 --> 01:03:02.645
VOICE OVER IP SERVICE WAS DOWN.
01:03:02.712 --> 01:03:05.114
SO DO YOU NEED MORE THORNY FROM
01:03:05.181 --> 01:03:07.016
US TO COLLECT THE DATA REQUIRED
01:03:07.083 --> 01:03:08.484
IS SORT OF IDENTIFY THE
01:03:08.551 --> 01:03:10.653
VULNERABLE. SPOTS WITHIN THE
01:03:10.720 --> 01:03:12.555
NETWORKS BOTH ON I. P. LANDLINE
01:03:12.622 --> 01:03:15.057
AND WIRELESS OR DO YOU NEED
01:03:15.124 --> 01:03:15.958
EXIT. ADDITIONAL STATUTORY
01:03:16.025 --> 01:03:18.227
AUTHORITY THING TO GO. AT LEAST
01:03:18.294 --> 01:03:20.296
AT LEAST ASSESS THE RISK AS
01:03:20.363 --> 01:03:22.131
ACCURATELY AS POSSIBLE AND IS
01:03:22.198 --> 01:03:25.501
GRANULAR LEE AS WE NEED TO.
01:03:25.568 --> 01:03:26.035
MEET ALL THESE CONCERNS AS
01:03:26.102 --> 01:03:29.238
SENATOR STERN. ONE OF THE MAJOR
01:03:29.305 --> 01:03:31.574
IMPEDIMENTS TO OUR ABILITY TO
01:03:31.641 --> 01:03:32.475
COLLECT DATA WAS SECTION SEVEN
01:03:32.542 --> 01:03:35.244
TEN. BECAUSE THE INDUSTRY
01:03:35.311 --> 01:03:36.913
ARGUED REPEATEDLY AND
01:03:36.979 --> 01:03:38.781
FREQUENTLY THAT WE HAD NO
01:03:38.848 --> 01:03:40.750
AUTHORITY OVER VOIP OR I. P.
01:03:40.816 --> 01:03:42.318
SERVICES AND SO THEREFORE WE
01:03:42.385 --> 01:03:43.219
HAVE NO RIGHT TO COLLECT THE
01:03:43.286 --> 01:03:44.887
DATA WE DISAGREED WITH THAT
01:03:44.954 --> 01:03:46.956
ASSESSMENT NONE THE LESS IT WAS
01:03:47.023 --> 01:03:49.392
A ROAD BLOCK FREQUENTLY NOW
01:03:49.458 --> 01:03:53.062
THAT SEVEN TEN IS. A SUNSET IT
01:03:53.129 --> 01:03:54.297
OPENS THE OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO
01:03:54.363 --> 01:03:57.266
BE MORE. AGGRESSIVE IN SEEKING
01:03:57.333 --> 01:04:01.037
DATA AND HOPEFULLY GETTING IT.
01:04:01.103 --> 01:04:03.339
AT LAST QUESTION IS. WERE
01:04:03.406 --> 01:04:04.507
FOCUSED IN TELECOMMUNICATIONS
01:04:04.574 --> 01:04:07.376
OUTAGES. BACKUP POWER ISSUES
01:04:07.443 --> 01:04:09.111
BUT GOOD TAKING US BACK TO THE
01:04:09.178 --> 01:04:10.446
FALL AND OUR LAST OVERSIGHT
01:04:10.513 --> 01:04:12.048
HEARING YOU A BETTER SENSE NOW
01:04:12.114 --> 01:04:14.884
ON TIMING FOR THE ROOT CAUSE
01:04:14.951 --> 01:04:16.652
BUT WHAT I WOULD. ABOUT HIS
01:04:16.719 --> 01:04:18.287
ROUTE BECAUSE THE ROOT CAUSE
01:04:18.354 --> 01:04:19.388
WHICH CLIMATE CHANGE THEN WE
01:04:19.455 --> 01:04:22.058
GET TO PS PS HOW CAN WE
01:04:22.124 --> 01:04:23.693
MEDICAID AT LEAST THAT RISK THE
01:04:23.759 --> 01:04:26.128
P. S. P. S. RISK WHERE. FRANKLY
01:04:26.195 --> 01:04:27.863
BLIGHTED TELCO FOLKS EVEN GOT
01:04:27.930 --> 01:04:29.565
HAD FAKED- ABOUT WHERE WAS
01:04:29.632 --> 01:04:31.367
GOING TO BE AND THEY THEY PUT
01:04:31.434 --> 01:04:33.536
ASSETS TO THE WRONG PLACES-
01:04:33.603 --> 01:04:35.504
SOME IT WAS OUT OF THEIR HANDS.
01:04:35.571 --> 01:04:38.040
HOW FAR ALONG ARE YOU IN-
01:04:38.107 --> 01:04:39.375
LAYING OUT THOSE NEW YOU
01:04:39.442 --> 01:04:40.843
MENTION YOUR NEW PROTOCOLS ARE
01:04:40.910 --> 01:04:43.679
YOUR NEW REQUIREMENTS WHAT WERE
01:04:43.746 --> 01:04:44.513
WE IN THAT PROCESS AND IN AND
01:04:44.580 --> 01:04:46.882
OUT. THANK YOU MISTER THANK YOU
01:04:46.949 --> 01:04:48.317
SENATOR WERE IN THE MIDDLE OF
01:04:48.384 --> 01:04:50.953
THAT PROCEEDING BUT ON I HAVE.
01:04:51.020 --> 01:04:53.990
IN BOTH IT IS IT TOO HEARINGS
01:04:54.056 --> 01:04:57.126
IN NOVEMBER AND DECEMBER
01:04:57.193 --> 01:04:58.527
MENTION THAT ONE OF THE THINGS
01:04:58.594 --> 01:05:00.529
THAT WE HAVE TO DO. IS THE I'LL
01:05:00.596 --> 01:05:03.599
HAVE TO BETTER COMMUNICATE WITH
01:05:03.666 --> 01:05:04.166
THE TELCOS. A TWO YEAR VERY
01:05:04.233 --> 01:05:06.702
POINT. TELL BECAUSE DIDN'T
01:05:06.769 --> 01:05:07.703
INFORMATION IN SOME CASES IT'S
01:05:07.770 --> 01:05:09.205
COMES VERY LATE. ANY NINE ON
01:05:09.272 --> 01:05:10.906
HOW THE PS PS IS ADMINISTERED.
01:05:10.973 --> 01:05:12.675
AND ADMINISTER THEM DIFFERENTLY
01:05:12.742 --> 01:05:15.544
ASIAN NOW- IT. ONE OF THE I USE
01:05:15.611 --> 01:05:18.114
FOR EXAMPLE DOESN'T REALLY-
01:05:18.180 --> 01:05:19.949
DECIDE WHEN THE PSP IS GONNA
01:05:20.016 --> 01:05:22.218
CURRENT TELL- LESSON IN SOME
01:05:22.285 --> 01:05:24.253
CASES COUPLE HOURS BEFORE. SO
01:05:24.320 --> 01:05:28.524
THAT DOES PUT. DIFFICULTIES ON-
01:05:28.591 --> 01:05:30.626
THE TELCOS FOR EXAMPLE AND
01:05:30.693 --> 01:05:32.862
WHERE THEY NEED TO DEPLOY
01:05:32.928 --> 01:05:34.196
GENERATORS FOR EXAMPLE THAT WAS
01:05:34.263 --> 01:05:36.565
TALKED ABOUT EARLIER BY SENATOR
01:05:36.632 --> 01:05:40.569
MCGUIRE. BUT. SO ONE OF THE
01:05:40.636 --> 01:05:41.871
THINGS I DID WANT TO MENTION IN
01:05:41.937 --> 01:05:45.274
TERMS OF TIMING- WE'D JUST
01:05:45.341 --> 01:05:47.143
YESTERDAY STARTED GETTING BACK-
01:05:47.209 --> 01:05:49.779
THE- PARTIES TO THE
01:05:49.845 --> 01:05:51.580
PROCEEDINGS- THAT I MENTIONED
01:05:51.647 --> 01:05:53.182
IN MY TESTIMONY THE DEVELOPING
01:05:53.249 --> 01:05:54.283
OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR
01:05:54.350 --> 01:05:56.218
RESILIENCY INDEPENDENT. A
01:05:56.285 --> 01:05:58.521
DEPENDABLE COMMUNICATIONS GRID
01:05:58.587 --> 01:06:00.222
OF FOR FURTHER SO WE CAN
01:06:00.289 --> 01:06:01.590
FURTHER ADDRESS A COMMUNICATION
01:06:01.657 --> 01:06:03.326
OUT JUST DURING A MARCH THE WE
01:06:03.392 --> 01:06:04.760
JUST. THE DEADLINE FOR THOSE
01:06:04.827 --> 01:06:06.862
COMMENTS WAS YESTERDAY SO STAFF
01:06:06.929 --> 01:06:08.564
IS JUST NOW GOING THROUGH THOSE
01:06:08.631 --> 01:06:10.866
COMMENTS WHICH WILL HELP. FOR
01:06:10.933 --> 01:06:13.869
ME AND THE A. L. J. INFORM THE
01:06:13.936 --> 01:06:16.205
SCOPE IN MEMEL WHICH WILL
01:06:16.272 --> 01:06:16.739
INDEED COM MISTER CHAIRMAN
01:06:16.806 --> 01:06:21.077
IMMEDIATELY. AND SENATOR I
01:06:21.143 --> 01:06:22.511
THINK BLANK MY COLLEAGUE
01:06:22.578 --> 01:06:24.213
COMMISSIONER REX OFTEN DID YOU
01:06:24.280 --> 01:06:24.814
WANT TO KNOW OKAY SORRY CENTER
01:06:24.880 --> 01:06:27.750
DOT. YEAH NUMBER MY QUESTIONS
01:06:27.817 --> 01:06:28.417
OF ALREADY BEEN ASKED- ANSWERED
01:06:28.484 --> 01:06:29.852
SO I APPRECIATE- MY COLLEAGUES
01:06:29.919 --> 01:06:30.853
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN FOR
01:06:30.920 --> 01:06:32.888
HOLDING THIS HEARING FIRST I DO
01:06:32.955 --> 01:06:34.190
I DO WANT TO MAKE CLEAR BECAUSE
01:06:34.256 --> 01:06:37.226
I THINK IT'S FAIR. THAT THE-
01:06:37.293 --> 01:06:40.062
THE TELECOMS AT LEAST IN THE
01:06:40.129 --> 01:06:41.197
TWO THOUSAND SEVENTEEN FIRES-
01:06:41.263 --> 01:06:43.232
IN THE NORTH BAY WERE EMBEDDED
01:06:43.299 --> 01:06:46.268
IN EVERY EMERGENCY- MEETING NOT
01:06:46.335 --> 01:06:48.070
THAT I WAS PLEASED WITH THE
01:06:48.137 --> 01:06:50.539
RESULTS. BUT THEY WERE THERE
01:06:50.606 --> 01:06:52.641
THEY WERE THERE ON THE GROUND
01:06:52.708 --> 01:06:53.275
THEY WERE DOING EVERYTHING THEY
01:06:53.342 --> 01:06:55.144
CAN. AND I THINK THAT WE-
01:06:55.211 --> 01:06:56.912
HELLO. IT'S BEEN MET. WHO'S AT
01:06:56.979 --> 01:06:59.315
FAULT HERE AND THE OF THIS OLD.
01:06:59.382 --> 01:07:01.150
HILL WE'VE ALL TALKED ABOUT TE
01:07:01.217 --> 01:07:03.586
NEW NORMAL A NEW PARADIGM. I
01:07:03.652 --> 01:07:05.321
DON'T KNOW FOR EXAMPLE IN LOCAL
01:07:05.388 --> 01:07:07.390
COMMUNITIES WE BLAME FIRST
01:07:07.456 --> 01:07:09.825
RESPONSE AND WHAT'S HAPPENED. I
01:07:09.892 --> 01:07:10.626
DON'T KNOW WHO COULD FOR
01:07:10.693 --> 01:07:14.163
SEEING. ALL THESE CATACLYSMIC
01:07:14.230 --> 01:07:17.133
EVENTS THAT THE STATE IS- FACED
01:07:17.199 --> 01:07:18.768
OVER THE LAST THREE TO THE
01:07:18.834 --> 01:07:22.004
THREE TO FOUR YEARS. YES
01:07:22.071 --> 01:07:22.471
SERIOUSLY IT'S IT IT'S
01:07:22.538 --> 01:07:26.041
SOMETHING THAT. SO I DON'T KNOW
01:07:26.108 --> 01:07:27.476
EVEN THE TELECOMS EVER THOUGHT
01:07:27.543 --> 01:07:29.145
ABOUT SEVENTY TWO HOURS OF
01:07:29.211 --> 01:07:31.447
BACKUP POWER FOR EXAMPLE- TO
01:07:31.514 --> 01:07:34.550
HELP COMMUNITIES WHAT ONE THING
01:07:34.617 --> 01:07:36.452
FOR SURE I REALLY DO BELIEVE
01:07:36.519 --> 01:07:38.421
THAT- WHEN THIRTY THREE
01:07:38.487 --> 01:07:40.189
COUNTIES ARE ALL SUDDEN CUT
01:07:40.256 --> 01:07:42.091
OFF- I DON'T THINK THE
01:07:42.158 --> 01:07:43.759
TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANY
01:07:43.826 --> 01:07:46.929
COULD EVER UNDERSTOOD. YOU KNOW
01:07:46.996 --> 01:07:50.232
WHAT WAS GOING ON WITH P.
01:07:50.299 --> 01:07:51.500
DECISIONS THE POWER OFF SO MANY
01:07:51.567 --> 01:07:54.170
COUNTIES ALL ONCE I THINK
01:07:54.236 --> 01:07:54.870
THOUGH THAT THAT GET OUT OF
01:07:54.937 --> 01:07:58.641
JAIL FREE CARD- IS IT IS MAY BE
01:07:58.707 --> 01:08:00.843
NECESSARY IN SOME RESPECTS WITH
01:08:00.910 --> 01:08:04.013
THE TELECOMS- I THINK THEY NEED
01:08:04.079 --> 01:08:06.282
TO BE PUT ON NOTICE THAT. THIS
01:08:06.348 --> 01:08:07.216
IS A PARTNERSHIP FOR THE STATE
01:08:07.283 --> 01:08:09.251
OF CALIFORNIA FOR ALL OUR
01:08:09.318 --> 01:08:11.187
RESPECTIVE TAXPAYERS AND
01:08:11.253 --> 01:08:12.655
THEY'VE GOT TO STEP UP TO THE
01:08:12.721 --> 01:08:14.356
TAPE PLATE THEY'VE GOT TO START
01:08:14.423 --> 01:08:16.358
IVING US THE INFORMATION
01:08:16.425 --> 01:08:17.193
THEY'VE GOT A QUICK PLAY
01:08:17.259 --> 01:08:19.762
DEFENSE AUDIO ON THE ACT IT
01:08:19.829 --> 01:08:27.470
LEAST ON THAT- THE ASPECT. I
01:08:27.536 --> 01:08:29.405
GUESS ON THE ENERGY THEY WHAT
01:08:29.472 --> 01:08:30.306
WHAT ONE OF THE THINGS I KNOW
01:08:30.372 --> 01:08:31.941
THAT WE GOT COMPETING GOALS WE
01:08:32.007 --> 01:08:34.009
TALK ALL THE TIME ABOUT WE NEED
01:08:34.076 --> 01:08:37.079
MORE OF RURAL. INTERNET SERVICE
01:08:37.146 --> 01:08:39.215
IN THEM. BUT WHEN WE'RE TALKING
01:08:39.281 --> 01:08:43.252
ABOUT ALSO. YOU'RE KEEPING THIS
01:08:43.319 --> 01:08:45.354
LAND LINE FOREVER LET ME TELL
01:08:45.421 --> 01:08:47.556
YOU MY WIFE IS A PROPONENT OF
01:08:47.623 --> 01:08:49.525
KEEPING THE LAND LINE FOR EVER.
01:08:49.592 --> 01:08:51.627
DID YOU KNOW I JUST THINK IT'S
01:08:51.694 --> 01:08:54.096
FRANKLY RIDICULOUS BUT THAT'S-
01:08:54.163 --> 01:08:56.499
THAT THAT'S SOMETHING. HAPPY
01:08:56.565 --> 01:08:59.668
WIFE HAPPY LIFE SHOULD HAVE IT.
01:08:59.735 --> 01:09:00.269
THE CALLER RIGHT NOW WITH THE
01:09:00.336 --> 01:09:02.972
LISTENING TO THE HEARING. BUT
01:09:03.038 --> 01:09:06.842
THAT SAID. WE REALLY DO HAVE TO
01:09:06.909 --> 01:09:09.378
DISCUSS THESE OR INVESTMENT
01:09:09.445 --> 01:09:11.180
GOING TO BE IN THE LAND
01:09:11.247 --> 01:09:12.681
LIGHTING KEEPING THE LAN LINE
01:09:12.748 --> 01:09:15.417
FOR EVER OR ARE WE GOING TO
01:09:15.484 --> 01:09:17.152
DEMAND THE INVESTMENTS IN RURAL
01:09:17.219 --> 01:09:19.255
AREAS FOR THE INTERNET AND
01:09:19.321 --> 01:09:21.257
COMMUNICATIONS SERVICE AND I
01:09:21.323 --> 01:09:22.992
THINK THAT THESE THESE ISSUES
01:09:23.058 --> 01:09:24.927
GET CONFLATED ALL THE TIME AND
01:09:24.994 --> 01:09:26.662
WE'RE ASKING FOR INVESTMENTS IN
01:09:26.729 --> 01:09:29.098
BOTH YEAH THERE WAS SUCH A
01:09:29.164 --> 01:09:32.334
THING AS A TRACK- TAPE CASSETTE
01:09:32.401 --> 01:09:34.436
TAPES YOU KNOW THEY WERE VIDEO
01:09:34.503 --> 01:09:36.405
STORES AT ONE POINT IN TIME YOU
01:09:36.472 --> 01:09:38.807
KNOW TECHNOLOGY CHANGES. PEOPLE
01:09:38.874 --> 01:09:40.943
NEED TO CHANGE- I DON'T HAVE
01:09:41.010 --> 01:09:42.344
ALL THE ANSWERS HERE BUT THE I
01:09:42.411 --> 01:09:43.979
THINK THAT'S UP WE NEED TO
01:09:44.046 --> 01:09:46.315
CONSIDER AS POLICY MAKERS AND I
01:09:46.382 --> 01:09:47.550
WILL BE ASKING YOU KNOW WHAT
01:09:47.616 --> 01:09:49.084
YOUR THOUGHTS ARE ON THAT BUT
01:09:49.151 --> 01:09:52.688
MORE TARGETED YOU DID MENTION-
01:09:52.755 --> 01:09:54.056
THE- THE COMMUNICATION SERVICE
01:09:54.123 --> 01:09:55.624
PROVIDERS ARE TREATED SHOULD BE
01:09:55.691 --> 01:09:57.593
TREATED AS PUBLIC SAFETY
01:09:57.660 --> 01:09:59.528
PARTNERS DURING PS PSP EVENTS
01:09:59.595 --> 01:10:02.231
SB NINE OH ONE REQUIRED THAT.
01:10:02.298 --> 01:10:06.669
IT ALSO- CODE SECTION EIGHTY
01:10:06.735 --> 01:10:07.236
EIGHTY THREE EIGHTY SIX YEAH
01:10:07.303 --> 01:10:08.003
SAID CONSIDER PUBLIC SAFETY
01:10:08.070 --> 01:10:09.271
IMPACTS ON COMMUNICATION
01:10:09.338 --> 01:10:11.273
INFRASTRUCTURE IT ALSO SAID
01:10:11.340 --> 01:10:12.875
INCLUDE PROCEDURES FOR DIRECT
01:10:12.942 --> 01:10:14.977
NOTIFICATION OF OPERATORS OF
01:10:15.044 --> 01:10:15.811
TELECOMMUNICATIONS
01:10:15.878 --> 01:10:18.514
INFRASTRUCTURE IT'S SO I GUESS
01:10:18.581 --> 01:10:21.483
MY QUESTION IS ALSO WHAT IS THE
01:10:21.550 --> 01:10:24.153
C. P. SEAT- GONNA DO IN THAT
01:10:24.219 --> 01:10:28.557
REGARD TO MAKE SURE THAT THE I.
01:10:28.624 --> 01:10:31.327
O. U.'S. IS SPECIFICALLY. FOR
01:10:31.393 --> 01:10:32.761
ME P. JEANNIE OR TREATING
01:10:32.828 --> 01:10:33.228
COMMUNICATIONS SERVICE
01:10:33.295 --> 01:10:34.697
PROVIDERS AS PUBLIC SAFETY
01:10:34.763 --> 01:10:36.899
PARTNERS IN PROVIDING PRIORITY
01:10:36.966 --> 01:10:42.972
NOTICE A PS BSE DEBTS. WE
01:10:43.038 --> 01:10:44.406
CERTAINLY RAISED THAT DIRECTLY
01:10:44.473 --> 01:10:47.643
WITH THE I. O. U.'S- I HAVE IN
01:10:47.710 --> 01:10:48.777
IN THE HEARINGS THAT I HELD
01:10:48.844 --> 01:10:51.947
AFTER- THE OCTOBER NOVEMBER
01:10:52.014 --> 01:10:55.217
EVENT DIRECTLY WITH P. JEANNIE
01:10:55.284 --> 01:10:56.118
THAT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WAS
01:10:56.185 --> 01:10:58.821
MISSING WAS THE COMMUNITY. THE
01:10:58.887 --> 01:11:00.189
PROPER COMMUNICATION WITH THE
01:11:00.255 --> 01:11:03.692
TELCO COMPANIES- AND WE WILL
01:11:03.759 --> 01:11:06.662
CONTINUE TO- AS WE GO THROUGH
01:11:06.729 --> 01:11:09.832
OUR PS PS- PROCEEDING WE WILL
01:11:09.898 --> 01:11:12.501
CONTINUE TO HIGHLIGHT AND HOLD
01:11:12.568 --> 01:11:15.137
ACCOUNTABLE. AS THE REGULATOR
01:11:15.204 --> 01:11:18.874
THE I. O. U.'S. I THINK THE
01:11:18.941 --> 01:11:20.576
ALLEN WANTED TO ANNOUNCE AN AS
01:11:20.643 --> 01:11:21.744
YET SOMETHING ON THE ON YOUR
01:11:21.810 --> 01:11:24.113
FIRST POINT YEAH CENTER I'M ONE
01:11:24.179 --> 01:11:26.181
OF THOSE DIE HARD LAND LINE.
01:11:26.248 --> 01:11:27.383
PHONE SERVICE PEOPLE AS WELL AS
01:11:27.449 --> 01:11:29.518
I SAY THEY'LL HAVE TO PRY IT
01:11:29.585 --> 01:11:32.321
OUT OF MY COLD DEAD FINGERS-
01:11:32.388 --> 01:11:34.890
BUT- I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO
01:11:34.957 --> 01:11:37.559
UNDERSTAND THAT THE- ROBO
01:11:37.626 --> 01:11:38.827
CALLS. WELL THAT'S TRUE THERE
01:11:38.894 --> 01:11:40.629
IS AFTER YOU USE THE OLD
01:11:40.696 --> 01:11:41.230
FASHIONED ANSWERING MACHINE TO
01:11:41.296 --> 01:11:46.669
SCREEN THEM OUT. BY. I WANT TO
01:11:46.735 --> 01:11:49.738
EMPHASIZE THAT THE TRADITIONAL
01:11:49.805 --> 01:11:52.074
WIRELINE TECHNOLOGY THAT THAT
01:11:52.141 --> 01:11:55.344
THAT IS THE UNDERLYING
01:11:55.411 --> 01:11:56.779
TECHNOLOGY PROVIDING THAT PHONE
01:11:56.845 --> 01:11:58.480
SERVICE TO YOUR HOUSE AND TO
01:11:58.547 --> 01:12:01.784
MINE IS ALSO RELYING ON FIND
01:12:01.850 --> 01:12:05.621
MANY- SERVICES. FOR THAT HAVE
01:12:05.688 --> 01:12:06.689
NOTHING TO DO WITH THE LAND
01:12:06.755 --> 01:12:07.523
LINE PHONE SERVICE GOING YOUR
01:12:07.589 --> 01:12:11.093
HOUSE THERE ARE IT'S ESSENTIAL
01:12:11.160 --> 01:12:14.296
TO MANY SERVICES THAT ARE START
01:12:14.363 --> 01:12:15.664
ARE PROVIDED THROUGHOUT THE
01:12:15.731 --> 01:12:19.168
STATE AND- SO DO WE NEED TO
01:12:19.234 --> 01:12:21.970
CONTINUE TO PROVIDE. THAT PHONE
01:12:22.037 --> 01:12:22.838
SERVICE TO EVERYBODY IN EVERY
01:12:22.905 --> 01:12:25.140
REMOTE AREA THAT IS A POLICY
01:12:25.207 --> 01:12:26.275
QUESTION THE COMMISSION WILL
01:12:26.341 --> 01:12:27.810
HAVE TO LOOK AT ME WITH THE
01:12:27.876 --> 01:12:29.778
LEGISLATURE AS WELL DO WE NEED
01:12:29.845 --> 01:12:32.915
TO MAINTAIN THAT TECHNOLOGY FOR
01:12:32.981 --> 01:12:34.249
SOME INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME
01:12:34.316 --> 01:12:36.552
IN ORDER TO PROVIDE THAT FOR
01:12:36.618 --> 01:12:38.320
SERVICES THAT DEPEND ON IT
01:12:38.387 --> 01:12:40.589
THAT- SOMETHING OTHER THAN YOUR
01:12:40.656 --> 01:12:41.423
PHONE IN MIND. YES THAT IS
01:12:41.490 --> 01:12:42.758
GOING TO HAVE TO CONTINUE
01:12:42.825 --> 01:12:45.060
BECAUSE SO MUCH DEPENDS ON IT
01:12:45.127 --> 01:12:46.729
AND THE NETWORK IS ALL INTER
01:12:46.795 --> 01:12:48.964
WOVEN SO NOT EITHER OR NO IT'S
01:12:49.031 --> 01:12:51.500
NOT EITHER OR- THANK YOU. THANK
01:12:51.567 --> 01:12:53.702
YOU FOR MUCH SOONER HERTZBERG.
01:12:53.769 --> 01:12:56.839
THANK YOU. MY IS REALLY MORE OF
01:12:56.905 --> 01:12:58.173
A COMMENT IN TERMS OF THE
01:12:58.240 --> 01:12:59.675
LARGER PICTURE I TAKE MY
01:12:59.742 --> 01:13:01.744
GUIDANCE FROM MY RECENT RE
01:13:01.810 --> 01:13:04.780
READING OF CITIZENS AT ALL AND-
01:13:04.847 --> 01:13:05.347
THE BIG PICTURE THINK IF YOU
01:13:05.414 --> 01:13:08.083
WILL AYE AYE HE- THERE ARE
01:13:08.150 --> 01:13:10.152
GOVERNMENT A LONG TIME. AND
01:13:10.219 --> 01:13:12.354
MARBLE BOETTCHER IS PROBABLY
01:13:12.421 --> 01:13:13.489
THE BEST PUBLIC SERVANT I'VE
01:13:13.555 --> 01:13:14.556
EVER MET WHETHER IT'S IN THE
01:13:14.623 --> 01:13:16.558
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT OTHER STATES
01:13:16.625 --> 01:13:18.494
THIS STATE PRIVATE SECTOR.
01:13:18.560 --> 01:13:20.028
EXTRAORDINARY AND I WAS STROKES
01:13:20.095 --> 01:13:21.730
ECSTATIC WHEN YOU BECAME THE
01:13:21.797 --> 01:13:23.232
PRESIDENT OF THIS ORGANIZATION
01:13:23.298 --> 01:13:25.768
BUT I. DIGITAL WORRIED THAT-
01:13:25.834 --> 01:13:26.802
YOU'RE THE PRESIDENT OF
01:13:26.869 --> 01:13:28.637
CALIFORNIA PHOTO MATCH. IN THE
01:13:28.704 --> 01:13:30.038
SENSE THAT AND YOU KIND OF
01:13:30.105 --> 01:13:31.573
TALKED ABOUT IT IN THE SENSE
01:13:31.640 --> 01:13:34.376
THAT. EVERYBODY HERE IS TRYING
01:13:34.443 --> 01:13:36.145
TO SOLVE A PROBLEM. THE
01:13:36.211 --> 01:13:38.147
ANALYSIS TALKS ABOUT
01:13:38.213 --> 01:13:40.215
OPPORTUNITIES TO RENT AND LIMIT
01:13:40.282 --> 01:13:40.849
THE CURRENTS AND IMPACT FUTURE
01:13:40.916 --> 01:13:42.484
OUTAGES WHICH IS WHAT WE'RE
01:13:42.551 --> 01:13:43.952
ABOUT. YOUR TESTIMONY YOU
01:13:44.019 --> 01:13:45.687
TALKED ABOUT. WE HAVE
01:13:45.754 --> 01:13:47.523
PROCEEDINGS I CAN'T TALK ABOUT
01:13:47.589 --> 01:13:48.690
IT BECAUSE IT'S PREJUDICE
01:13:48.757 --> 01:13:49.525
BECAUSE MIGHT BE PREJUDICED THE
01:13:49.591 --> 01:13:52.127
PROCEEDING. IN OTHER WORDS. THE
01:13:52.194 --> 01:13:53.829
RAILROAD COMMISSION WHICH IS
01:13:53.896 --> 01:13:56.398
WHAT YOU RUN BASICALLY. AND
01:13:56.465 --> 01:13:58.167
I'VE BEEN TALKING ABOUT THIS IN
01:13:58.233 --> 01:14:01.303
HEARINGS FOR MANY YEARS. IT'S
01:14:01.370 --> 01:14:01.937
JUST YESTERDAY'S NEWS AND
01:14:02.004 --> 01:14:03.772
PROCTER OF IT IN TERMS OF
01:14:03.839 --> 01:14:05.541
YOU'VE GOT THIS NEW DYNAMIC OF
01:14:05.607 --> 01:14:06.608
A NEW WORLD ORDER THINGS THAT
01:14:06.675 --> 01:14:07.676
WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT CENTER
01:14:07.743 --> 01:14:09.444
BRADFORD TALKING ABOUT TWO
01:14:09.511 --> 01:14:10.112
THOUSAND TEN WE CAN USE SO MANY
01:14:10.179 --> 01:14:12.014
EXAMPLES THROUGHOUT HISTORY. OF
01:14:12.080 --> 01:14:13.415
WHAT WE SOUGHT TO DO THE ENERGY
01:14:13.482 --> 01:14:15.784
CRISIS EXAMPLE AFTER EXAMPLE.
01:14:15.851 --> 01:14:18.086
I'M JUST FEARFUL THAT WE HAVE
01:14:18.153 --> 01:14:20.289
GOOD PEOPLE OF GOOD WILL AROUND
01:14:20.355 --> 01:14:22.191
THIS DíAS PEOPLE OF GOOD WILL
01:14:22.257 --> 01:14:23.992
IN THE MINISTRATION TRYING TO
01:14:24.059 --> 01:14:25.360
SOLVE THIS PROBLEM BUT WE ARE
01:14:25.427 --> 01:14:27.596
TRYING TO. SOLVE THE PROBLEM
01:14:27.663 --> 01:14:29.498
WITH PHOTO MATT BLOCKBUSTER AND
01:14:29.565 --> 01:14:31.800
A DIAL NOTARY PHONE. AND THE
01:14:31.867 --> 01:14:34.636
REALITY IS THAT IF AT THE END
01:14:34.703 --> 01:14:35.704
OF THE DAY THE QUESTION SHOULD
01:14:35.771 --> 01:14:37.272
BE NOT WHETHER WE'RE GOING TO
01:14:37.339 --> 01:14:39.775
PENALIZE PEOPLE MORE OR WILL WE
01:14:39.842 --> 01:14:41.944
COLLECT DATA I HEAR THE STORIES
01:14:42.010 --> 01:14:43.478
ABOUT DATA. AND SAYING OKAY
01:14:43.545 --> 01:14:44.413
WE'RE GONNA PASS A BILL THAT WE
01:14:44.479 --> 01:14:46.748
CAN COLLECT DATA TWENTY TWENTY
01:14:46.815 --> 01:14:47.482
ONE AND BY THE TIME WE GET TO
01:14:47.549 --> 01:14:50.652
THE THAT'S TWENTY TWENTY TWO.
01:14:50.719 --> 01:14:51.220
AND THEN WE'RE GONNA DO THIS
01:14:51.286 --> 01:14:51.753
AND THEN WE'RE GONNA START
01:14:51.820 --> 01:14:54.089
PROCEEDING. THE REALITY IS WE
01:14:54.156 --> 01:14:55.457
HAVE TO AS IN OUR SYSTEM AS-
01:14:55.524 --> 01:14:56.425
PROVIDE OPPORTUNITIES TO BE
01:14:56.491 --> 01:14:58.060
PAPA PAGE TO PREVENT AND LIMIT
01:14:58.126 --> 01:14:59.328
OCCURRENCES IMPACT FUTURE AT
01:14:59.394 --> 01:15:01.997
FUTURE OUTAGES. THE QUESTION IS
01:15:02.064 --> 01:15:04.099
CAN WE STEP BACK FOR A MOMENT.
01:15:04.166 --> 01:15:05.701
AND LOOK AT THE NEW WORLD ORDER
01:15:05.767 --> 01:15:07.469
THAT WE LIVE IN THE NEW DYNAMIC
01:15:07.536 --> 01:15:08.637
WE HAD ALWAYS PRIVACY
01:15:08.704 --> 01:15:09.938
DISCUSSIONS WITH SENATOR.
01:15:10.005 --> 01:15:11.340
JACKSON ABOUT ALL THE CREEPY
01:15:11.406 --> 01:15:12.908
STUFF THAT GOES ON. IN THE
01:15:12.975 --> 01:15:14.443
PRIVACY WORLD THERE'S SO MANY
01:15:14.509 --> 01:15:16.245
FUNDAMENTAL CHANGES I MEAN THIS
01:15:16.311 --> 01:15:18.046
WHOLE TELEPHONE BUSINESS. YOU
01:15:18.113 --> 01:15:19.181
KNOW I STILL HAVE A ROTARY
01:15:19.248 --> 01:15:21.550
PHONE. IT'S IN MY MUSEUM BUT I
01:15:21.617 --> 01:15:23.252
DON'T USE IT BUT THE POINT IS
01:15:23.318 --> 01:15:24.052
THAT I MEAN MEMBERS THE KIDS
01:15:24.119 --> 01:15:25.387
SO. THE QUESTION IS WHAT DOES
01:15:25.454 --> 01:15:26.955
THAT LOOK LIKE AND I'M JUST A
01:15:27.022 --> 01:15:28.323
LITTLE AFRAID THAT THIS
01:15:28.390 --> 01:15:30.325
CONVERSATION IS INFORMED BY THE
01:15:30.392 --> 01:15:31.960
ECONOMY. ON THE ONE HAND THE
01:15:32.027 --> 01:15:34.596
SURPLUS OF URGENCY. THAT ALL OF
01:15:34.663 --> 01:15:37.766
US ARE HONORABLY INFORMED BY
01:15:37.833 --> 01:15:38.500
EVERYONE OF US EVERY ONE OF THE
01:15:38.567 --> 01:15:40.535
PEOPLE THAT WORK FOR YOU. ON
01:15:40.602 --> 01:15:41.603
THE ONE HAND AND ON THE OTHER
01:15:41.670 --> 01:15:45.040
HAND ALL AND EVEN THOUGH THIS
01:15:45.107 --> 01:15:47.476
OLD CRUSTY MODEL THAT WE HAVE
01:15:47.542 --> 01:15:48.877
TO HAVE THE PROCEEDINGS. AND
01:15:48.944 --> 01:15:52.014
HEARINGS AND A. L. JAY'S. ALL
01:15:52.080 --> 01:15:54.416
THIS GARBAGE THAT WORK WHEN WE
01:15:54.483 --> 01:15:55.817
HAD A RAILROAD AND A DIFFERENT
01:15:55.884 --> 01:15:58.620
WORLD. BUT I'M NOT SO SURE THAT
01:15:58.687 --> 01:15:59.721
IF THE CHIEFS THE DELIVERABLES
01:15:59.788 --> 01:16:01.256
SO I'M JUST WORRIED THAT WE'RE
01:16:01.323 --> 01:16:02.524
BUILDING ON QUICKSAND. AND THAT
01:16:02.591 --> 01:16:03.292
WE'RE BUILDING ON IT YOU KNOW
01:16:03.358 --> 01:16:04.092
WE'RE WE'RE ALL CRAMMING.
01:16:04.159 --> 01:16:06.828
FORMAT SHOPS AND TRYING TO FIX
01:16:06.895 --> 01:16:08.630
THAT PROBLEM RATHER THAN
01:16:08.697 --> 01:16:10.198
STEPPING BACK FOR A MOMENT BE
01:16:10.265 --> 01:16:11.767
INFORMED BY THE CHALLENGE
01:16:11.833 --> 01:16:12.901
WHAT'S THE PROBLEM WE'RE TRYING
01:16:12.968 --> 01:16:15.237
TO SOLVE. AND THEN THINKING
01:16:15.304 --> 01:16:17.539
THROUGH NOT BEING LIMITED BY
01:16:17.606 --> 01:16:18.440
THE STRUCTURE. BECAUSE I THINK
01:16:18.507 --> 01:16:19.041
WHAT'S HAPPENING IS THIS
01:16:19.107 --> 01:16:20.375
DESTRUCTIVE DISCUSSION I LOVE
01:16:20.442 --> 01:16:21.510
WHEN USED TO IT I CAN'T TALK
01:16:21.576 --> 01:16:23.211
ABOUT THE PROCEEDINGS BECAUSE I
01:16:23.278 --> 01:16:25.080
GET PRE JUDGE. WE TALKS ABOUT
01:16:25.147 --> 01:16:27.416
YOU KNOW I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE A
01:16:27.482 --> 01:16:32.020
MAGIC WAND. MY QUESTION IS I
01:16:32.087 --> 01:16:32.587
WROTE DOWN GIVE YOU A MAGIC
01:16:32.654 --> 01:16:37.359
WAND. I TRUST YOU EXCELLENT
01:16:37.426 --> 01:16:38.627
WHAT'S THE MAGIC WAND BUT THE
01:16:38.694 --> 01:16:39.995
MAGIC ON TO ME IS NOT INFORMED
01:16:40.062 --> 01:16:41.096
BY THE D. THOUGH GIVING MORE
01:16:41.163 --> 01:16:41.997
AUTHORITY THE IDEAS THE TALKED
01:16:42.064 --> 01:16:43.098
ABOUT NEW AUTHORITY OVERSIGHT
01:16:43.165 --> 01:16:45.000
AND PENALTIES THAT YESTERDAY'S
01:16:45.067 --> 01:16:47.536
NEWS THIS IS THE NEW TECHNOLOGY
01:16:47.602 --> 01:16:48.937
IS GOING TO BE GONE AND OUT THE
01:16:49.004 --> 01:16:50.439
DOOR BEFORE WE IN IMPLEMENT A
01:16:50.505 --> 01:16:52.507
REGULATIONS LET'S FIGURE OUT
01:16:52.574 --> 01:16:54.609
WHAT THAT NEW WORLD ORDER LOOKS
01:16:54.676 --> 01:16:56.144
LIKE THAT WE CAN GIVE YOU THAT
01:16:56.211 --> 01:16:57.679
MAGIC WAND SO THAT WE PROMOTE
01:16:57.746 --> 01:16:59.881
INNOVATION PROMOTE EQUITY AND
01:16:59.948 --> 01:17:01.883
FAIRNESS AND TAKE CARE OF THE
01:17:01.950 --> 01:17:03.418
RULE PEOPLE IN ALL THE OTHER
01:17:03.485 --> 01:17:04.186
CHALLENGE THAT WE'RE DEALING
01:17:04.252 --> 01:17:05.821
WITH. AND THAT'S WHAT I DO SO
01:17:05.887 --> 01:17:07.189
BUT I WANT TO SUGGEST TONIGHT
01:17:07.255 --> 01:17:08.724
OBVIOUSLY HAVE NO ANSWER I JUST
01:17:08.790 --> 01:17:10.993
WANTED TO POSE IT TO TRY TO
01:17:11.059 --> 01:17:13.261
INFORM CALIFORNIA THIS GREAT
01:17:13.328 --> 01:17:15.630
PLACE OF CALIFORNIA THIS PLACE
01:17:15.697 --> 01:17:17.666
IF YOU READ CITIZENS BILL IS
01:17:17.733 --> 01:17:19.601
ALL ABOUT THE FUTURE I GOT UP
01:17:19.668 --> 01:17:21.503
TO CUBA ON MY WALL AND I WAS
01:17:21.570 --> 01:17:22.671
JUST CALL THE NEW SOME TEQUILA
01:17:22.738 --> 01:17:26.375
HE WAS CALLED THE OLD ONE SAID
01:17:26.441 --> 01:17:27.009
WHEN HE WAS LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR
01:17:27.075 --> 01:17:28.210
IT'S AT THE NEW ONE SAYS FUTURE
01:17:28.276 --> 01:17:30.245
MAN THE FUTURE ME. THANKS TO
01:17:30.312 --> 01:17:33.582
TALKING ABOUT THE FUTURE COSTS
01:17:33.648 --> 01:17:36.618
NOW I WANT TO TRY TO ENGAGE
01:17:36.685 --> 01:17:41.323
THAT OUR DISCUSSION AS WE THINK
01:17:41.390 --> 01:17:41.923
THROUGH GOING SPORT THANK YOU.
01:17:41.990 --> 01:17:48.597
IN A ROOM. THROW SOME. ALSO YOU
01:17:48.663 --> 01:17:49.197
MAKE REFERENCE TO SOME OF THE
01:17:49.264 --> 01:17:50.065
COMMENTS MADE HERE SO I'M SORRY
01:17:50.132 --> 01:17:50.932
BECAUSE I THINK YOU'VE TALKED
01:17:50.999 --> 01:17:51.533
ABOUT IT BUT I JUST KIND OF
01:17:51.600 --> 01:17:52.534
WANT TO BRING IT BACK TO US AT
01:17:52.601 --> 01:17:53.168
THE MENTION THE REPORT THAT I
01:17:53.235 --> 01:17:54.302
HAVE YOU BEEN BREAKING DOWN A
01:17:54.369 --> 01:17:55.404
LITTLE BIT THROUGHOUT IT YOU
01:17:55.470 --> 01:17:55.937
CALLED AT THE NET NETWORK
01:17:56.004 --> 01:17:57.606
EXAMINATION REPORT I WANT TO
01:17:57.672 --> 01:17:59.875
JUST FOCUS A LITTLE BIT MORE ON
01:17:59.941 --> 01:18:01.676
THAT IF YOU CAN AND OPERATE.
01:18:01.743 --> 01:18:02.277
FIRST OF ALL WANT TO KNOW IT'S
01:18:02.344 --> 01:18:02.911
A PUBLIC DOCUMENT THAT WE CAN
01:18:02.978 --> 01:18:04.813
REVIEW SECONDLY ARE YOU
01:18:04.880 --> 01:18:07.416
CREATING A STRATEGIC PLAN TO
01:18:07.482 --> 01:18:09.051
TACKLE ALL THE FINDINGS IN THAT
01:18:09.117 --> 01:18:11.586
REPORT I WANT TO KNOW LONG TERM
01:18:11.653 --> 01:18:14.089
SHORT TERM GOALS ON AND IT GOES
01:18:14.156 --> 01:18:15.357
BACK TO- WHAT SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:18:15.424 --> 01:18:16.992
WAS TALKING ABOUT I WANT TO
01:18:17.059 --> 01:18:18.193
KNOW THAT THERE'S IMMEDIATE
01:18:18.260 --> 01:18:19.327
ACTION TO ADDRESS SOME OF THOSE
01:18:19.394 --> 01:18:22.464
ISSUES BECAUSE HE'S RIGHT IN
01:18:22.531 --> 01:18:23.465
THAT WE HAVE INFORMATION AND
01:18:23.532 --> 01:18:25.300
THEN IT KIND OF GOES. IT TAKES
01:18:25.367 --> 01:18:25.901
A LONG TIME TO ADDRESS THOSE
01:18:25.967 --> 01:18:27.069
ISSUES IN MY TIME WE GET TO
01:18:27.135 --> 01:18:28.904
THEM IT'S ALREADY A NEW ISSUE
01:18:28.970 --> 01:18:30.572
VERSUS THE OLD ISSUE SO CAME TO
01:18:30.639 --> 01:18:31.573
SHARE A LITTLE BIT OF HARD
01:18:31.640 --> 01:18:33.742
GONNA TACKLES FINDINGS AND NOW
01:18:33.809 --> 01:18:35.610
REPORTED IT CAN WE HAVE ACCESS
01:18:35.677 --> 01:18:38.513
TO IT THANK YOU SENATOR THE WE
01:18:38.580 --> 01:18:41.850
RELEASED A SUMMARY AND REDACTED
01:18:41.917 --> 01:18:42.751
PORTIONS OF THE REPORT THOSE OR
01:18:42.818 --> 01:18:44.986
A WEBSITE OF COURSE WILL WILL.
01:18:45.053 --> 01:18:46.388
BE HAPPY SHERRY SHARE THEM WITH
01:18:46.455 --> 01:18:48.990
YOU WE'VE BEEN IN A FIGHT OVER
01:18:49.057 --> 01:18:50.926
THE PAST SEVERAL MONTHS WITH
01:18:50.992 --> 01:18:52.928
EIGHTEEN T. IN FRONT HERE OVER
01:18:52.994 --> 01:18:53.929
MAKING THE REQUEST OF THE
01:18:53.995 --> 01:18:58.133
PUBLIC THEY BOTH FIRED OF
01:18:58.200 --> 01:19:01.470
CONFIDENTIALITY CLEAN WHICH WE
01:19:01.536 --> 01:19:06.675
WERE QUITE BEING BUT WE WERE
01:19:06.741 --> 01:19:12.280
REQUIRED BY STATUTE I WHO
01:19:12.347 --> 01:19:15.217
DETERMINE WHAT THE TO
01:19:15.283 --> 01:19:17.819
CONFIDENTIAL FOR YOU. WITH
01:19:17.886 --> 01:19:24.626
THAT. CLAIM IS DOING. PORT
01:19:24.693 --> 01:19:26.261
SHOULD BE MADE PUBLIC. THE
01:19:26.328 --> 01:19:28.497
FINDINGS IN SUMMARY OUR ON OUR
01:19:28.563 --> 01:19:30.866
WEBSITE SO WITH STRIVING TO
01:19:30.932 --> 01:19:32.400
MAKE IT PUBLIC AS QUICKLY AS WE
01:19:32.467 --> 01:19:35.403
CAN. IN OUR INTENT IS TO DO
01:19:35.470 --> 01:19:37.272
JUST WHAT YOU SAID TO FOLLOW
01:19:37.339 --> 01:19:40.509
UP. ON THE- FIND OUT OF
01:19:40.575 --> 01:19:42.210
RECOMMENDATIONS AND TO GO
01:19:42.277 --> 01:19:47.349
THROUGH OUR PROCESS. AND FOR
01:19:47.415 --> 01:19:49.117
DETERMINE WHAT SPORT WHAT STEPS
01:19:49.184 --> 01:19:50.318
DO WE NEED TO TAKE TO WE NEED
01:19:50.385 --> 01:19:51.887
TO CHANGE THE EXISTING SERVICE
01:19:51.953 --> 01:19:53.455
QUALITY RULES WE HAVE THREE
01:19:53.522 --> 01:19:55.590
MAJOR RULES THAT I MENTIONED
01:19:55.657 --> 01:19:56.992
ARE THEY ENOUGH TO THEY NEED TO
01:19:57.058 --> 01:19:58.593
BE STRENGTHENED DO THEY NEED TO
01:19:58.660 --> 01:19:59.628
BE EXTENDED TO DIFFERENT
01:19:59.694 --> 01:20:02.130
SERVICE PROVIDERS WE HAVE A
01:20:02.197 --> 01:20:05.066
SCHEME. IN PLACE FOR PENALIZING.
01:20:05.133 --> 01:20:06.568
VIOLATIONS IS THAT THE RIGHT
01:20:06.635 --> 01:20:09.871
SCHEMES IS THE- MORE PENALTIES
01:20:09.938 --> 01:20:11.273
APPROPRIATE OR ARE. THE OTHERS
01:20:11.339 --> 01:20:13.642
ARE THIS THE OF A FOCUSED ON
01:20:13.708 --> 01:20:15.277
THE RIGHT AREAS AND SO FORTH
01:20:15.343 --> 01:20:18.280
AND SO ON. AND WE WILL. WE WILL
01:20:18.346 --> 01:20:20.382
MOVE EXPEDITIOUSLY IN THAT AREA.
01:20:20.448 --> 01:20:22.851
THE WE ARE STILL TAKING ACTION
01:20:22.918 --> 01:20:23.785
TO TRY TO BRING THE CARRIERS
01:20:23.852 --> 01:20:25.887
INTO COMPLIANCE. AND NOT
01:20:25.954 --> 01:20:28.089
WITHSTANDING THE FACT THAT THIS
01:20:28.156 --> 01:20:29.357
NETWORK EXAMINATION HAS NOT
01:20:29.424 --> 01:20:31.326
BEEN PUBLICIZED. THE TWO FILE
01:20:31.393 --> 01:20:32.961
QUARTERLY REPORTS AS I
01:20:33.028 --> 01:20:34.196
MENTIONED AND IF THEY'RE OUT OF
01:20:34.262 --> 01:20:36.264
COMPLIANCE THE TO EITHER PAY OF
01:20:36.331 --> 01:20:38.500
A PENALTY OR MAKE A AND
01:20:38.567 --> 01:20:41.102
INVESTMENT TWICE THE AMOUNT OF
01:20:41.169 --> 01:20:41.703
PENALTY IN LIEU OF THAT. THAT
01:20:41.770 --> 01:20:44.539
FIGHT. THANK YOU AND THE REASON
01:20:44.606 --> 01:20:45.907
I'M A LITTLE FRUSTRATED BECAUSE
01:20:45.974 --> 01:20:47.709
AS YOU CAN HEAR EVERYONE UP
01:20:47.776 --> 01:20:49.578
HERE IS REALLY WANTS TO BE
01:20:49.644 --> 01:20:50.812
HELPFUL AND FIND SOLUTIONS
01:20:50.879 --> 01:20:52.214
ALONG WITH YOU ON THE CARRIERS
01:20:52.280 --> 01:20:53.782
BUT- ALMOST FEELS LIKE WE HAVE
01:20:53.848 --> 01:20:55.584
PIECES OF INFORMATION RACES
01:20:55.650 --> 01:20:57.419
THAT. THE WHOLE PIECE AND WE
01:20:57.485 --> 01:20:58.587
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
01:20:58.653 --> 01:21:00.689
SOMEHOW FIND THAT FULL PICTURE
01:21:00.755 --> 01:21:01.790
SO THAT WE CAN MOVE FORWARD
01:21:01.856 --> 01:21:02.991
SOME POLICY WHERE WE CAN BE
01:21:03.058 --> 01:21:05.360
HELPFUL TO YOU BUT- THANK YOU
01:21:05.427 --> 01:21:06.328
FOR SHARING THAT I JUST WANTED
01:21:06.394 --> 01:21:08.230
OF. CLARITY ON THAT IT WILL
01:21:08.296 --> 01:21:09.397
TAKE THEM HAVE THE MIKE THE
01:21:09.464 --> 01:21:12.133
CENTER HERTZBERG WE I- WE
01:21:12.200 --> 01:21:14.336
UNDERSTAND YOUR CONCERNS AND
01:21:14.402 --> 01:21:15.737
FRUSTRATIONS AND I KNOW YOU'VE
01:21:15.804 --> 01:21:17.539
HAD DIALOGUES WITH. OTHER
01:21:17.606 --> 01:21:18.473
COMMISSIONERS PRESIDENT PICKER
01:21:18.540 --> 01:21:20.575
ABOUT THIS ISSUE. WE HAVE BEEN
01:21:20.642 --> 01:21:21.977
ENGAGED IN AN EFFORT
01:21:22.043 --> 01:21:23.278
ADMINISTRATIVELY OVER THE PAST
01:21:23.345 --> 01:21:24.579
COUPLE OF YEARS THAT WE'RE
01:21:24.646 --> 01:21:26.081
CONTINUING TO TRY TO MAKE OUR
01:21:26.147 --> 01:21:27.816
PROCEEDINGS. QUICKER MORE
01:21:27.882 --> 01:21:30.352
EFFECTIVE MORE TRANSPARENT.
01:21:30.418 --> 01:21:32.254
WE'RE WE'RE PROPOSING A SET OF
01:21:32.320 --> 01:21:35.290
RULES CHANGES WE'VE HAD SOME
01:21:35.357 --> 01:21:36.925
WORKSHOPS ABOUT THAT RIGHT NOW.
01:21:36.992 --> 01:21:38.393
MUCH OF WHAT YOU TALK ABOUT THE
01:21:38.460 --> 01:21:40.262
MORE FUNDAMENTAL REFORMS NEED
01:21:40.328 --> 01:21:42.731
STATUTORY CHANGE. WITH THE KIDS
01:21:42.797 --> 01:21:44.532
TO BUT BY STATURE WE HAVE TO
01:21:44.599 --> 01:21:46.768
PROCEED IN THE WAY WE DO. SO WE
01:21:46.835 --> 01:21:48.603
WOULD WELCOME YOUR ENGAGEMENT
01:21:48.670 --> 01:21:50.405
AND HELP IN THAT AREA THANK YOU
01:21:50.472 --> 01:21:53.008
VERY MUCH SENATOR HILL THANK
01:21:53.074 --> 01:21:54.743
YOU MISTER CHAIR AND LIKE THANK
01:21:54.809 --> 01:21:55.343
YOU TO MY COLLEAGUES FOR THE
01:21:55.410 --> 01:21:56.878
GREAT QUESTIONS TODAY HAD USE
01:21:56.945 --> 01:21:58.413
JUST. PHENOMENAL DISCUSSION AND
01:21:58.480 --> 01:22:00.081
THANK YOU PRESIDENT IN. AND
01:22:00.148 --> 01:22:01.483
COMMISSIONER FOR YOUR
01:22:01.549 --> 01:22:03.685
INVOLVEMENT ONE HERE LEADERSHIP
01:22:03.752 --> 01:22:04.886
BECAUSE I THINK THAT'S BEEN THE
01:22:04.953 --> 01:22:07.789
KEY. SINCE YOUR APPOINTMENTS-
01:22:07.856 --> 01:22:09.124
TO THE COMMISSION AND I THINK
01:22:09.190 --> 01:22:10.759
WE'VE ALL IS SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:22:10.825 --> 01:22:13.495
INDICATED. FEEL A SENSE OF
01:22:13.561 --> 01:22:14.963
RELIEF THAT THERE IS STRONG
01:22:15.030 --> 01:22:15.730
LEADERSHIP THERE THAT'S GOING
01:22:15.797 --> 01:22:17.299
TO TAKE US TO THE TWENTY FIRST
01:22:17.365 --> 01:22:18.767
CENTURY AND BRING IT INTO THE
01:22:18.833 --> 01:22:20.468
TWENTY FIRST CENTURY MADE. THE
01:22:20.535 --> 01:22:21.636
COMMENT AND SENATOR HERTZBERG
01:22:21.703 --> 01:22:23.772
AND- BECAUSE YOU JUST MADE THE
01:22:23.838 --> 01:22:26.374
ISSUE RAISED THE ISSUE OF. DUE
01:22:26.441 --> 01:22:28.810
PROCESS THE TIMELINESS OF
01:22:28.877 --> 01:22:30.512
PROCEEDINGS TO CHALLENGES AND I
01:22:30.578 --> 01:22:31.413
KNOW A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO I
01:22:31.479 --> 01:22:33.415
HAD. LEGISLATION DEALING WITH
01:22:33.481 --> 01:22:34.683
THE CONFIDENTIALITY OF SOME OF
01:22:34.749 --> 01:22:36.985
THE- REPORTS IN THE COMMISSION
01:22:37.052 --> 01:22:38.820
OF THE UTILITIES AND- THE
01:22:38.887 --> 01:22:40.055
TELECOMS AND HOW CHALLENGING
01:22:40.121 --> 01:22:41.623
THAT HAS BEEN. BECAUSE THEY
01:22:41.690 --> 01:22:42.524
CLAIM EVERYTHING IS
01:22:42.590 --> 01:22:44.592
CONFIDENTIAL AND THEN IT'S UP
01:22:44.659 --> 01:22:46.728
TO US TO FIGHT IN THE- THE
01:22:46.795 --> 01:22:48.897
CRIMINAL ASPECTS OF RELEASING
01:22:48.963 --> 01:22:50.298
THAT INFORMATION IS SOMETHING
01:22:50.365 --> 01:22:51.266
THAT WE TRIED TO CHANGE AS
01:22:51.333 --> 01:22:53.735
WELL. SO IDEA WHAT MY
01:22:53.802 --> 01:22:55.837
SUGGESTION IS AS YOU GO THROUGH
01:22:55.904 --> 01:23:01.009
THIS PROCESS WITH THE- THE
01:23:01.076 --> 01:23:04.279
LANDS OF EXPEDITING. AS BEST AS
01:23:04.346 --> 01:23:05.347
POSSIBLE BASED THE CONSTRAINT.
01:23:05.413 --> 01:23:06.348
IN THIS BUDGET TO. CONSTRUCT
01:23:06.414 --> 01:23:08.249
YOU HAVE. PLEASE CONFIRM. MAKE
01:23:08.316 --> 01:23:10.518
THOSE NOTES OF WHERE THOSE
01:23:10.585 --> 01:23:13.355
CHANGES WOULD BE MOST
01:23:13.421 --> 01:23:17.158
EFFECTIVE. TO BRING THE
01:23:17.225 --> 01:23:18.626
COMMISSION TO THE TWENTY FIRST
01:23:18.693 --> 01:23:19.461
CENTURY TO THAT WE CAN DEAL
01:23:19.527 --> 01:23:20.795
ISSUES THAT WE HAVE. AND THEN
01:23:20.862 --> 01:23:22.130
COME TO THE BUDGET. AND WE'RE
01:23:22.197 --> 01:23:24.466
HAPPY TO SUPPORT. THOSE THOSE
01:23:24.532 --> 01:23:25.834
CHANGES MAKE THIS A MORE NIMBLE
01:23:25.900 --> 01:23:27.969
AND- FUNCTIONAL AGENCY THAT YOU
01:23:28.036 --> 01:23:29.971
HAVEN'T COMMISSION SO PLEASE.
01:23:30.038 --> 01:23:35.877
LET US KNOW. IF YOU NEED HELP
01:23:35.944 --> 01:23:39.114
WITH THAT WE WILL INDEED I. AM.
01:23:39.180 --> 01:23:40.949
AT AS I THINK OF THE SENATOR
01:23:41.015 --> 01:23:42.550
CENTER HERTZBERG- SORT OF
01:23:42.617 --> 01:23:43.785
ALLUDED TO I WILL NOT TAKE.
01:23:43.852 --> 01:23:44.853
THAT PHRASE I'M LESS
01:23:44.919 --> 01:23:47.188
OVERWHELMING TO ME THANK YOU
01:23:47.255 --> 01:23:47.789
AND I HOPE YOU CAN SAY IT SIX
01:23:47.856 --> 01:23:51.092
MONTHS FROM NOW TO. BUT IT IS A
01:23:51.159 --> 01:23:51.760
I WILL TELL YOU PERSONALLY IT'S
01:23:51.826 --> 01:23:53.728
BEEN AB AND I HAVEN'T. I
01:23:53.795 --> 01:23:55.730
HAVEN'T BEEN THROUGH A LOT OF
01:23:55.797 --> 01:23:59.033
THE AND PROCESSES YET. BUT IT
01:23:59.100 --> 01:24:00.602
WE DO OPERATE A PRETTY ARCHAIC
01:24:00.668 --> 01:24:03.905
SYSTEM AND- THANK GOODNESS TO
01:24:03.972 --> 01:24:05.206
COMMISSION WRECK SHAMAN AND
01:24:05.273 --> 01:24:06.708
COMMISSIONER RANDALL FOR DOING
01:24:06.775 --> 01:24:08.276
TACKLING SOME OF THE REFORMS
01:24:08.343 --> 01:24:10.345
THAT THEY'VE TACKLED. AND WE'RE
01:24:10.412 --> 01:24:12.914
STILL WORKING THROUGH THOSE AND
01:24:12.981 --> 01:24:15.150
I COMING OUT OF GOV OP
01:24:15.216 --> 01:24:17.318
SECRETARY GOV UPSETS ONE OF THE
01:24:17.385 --> 01:24:18.853
THINGS THAT GOVERNOR BROWN IT.
01:24:18.920 --> 01:24:21.256
AND ALSO- NEWSHAM A CHARGE ME
01:24:21.322 --> 01:24:21.923
WITH AMOUNTS REFORMING
01:24:21.990 --> 01:24:23.758
GOVERNMENT AND REALLY REFORM IN
01:24:23.825 --> 01:24:25.860
PROCESS THIS IS WHAT I ALWAYS
01:24:25.927 --> 01:24:27.195
USED TO SAY NOT MAKING THINGS
01:24:27.262 --> 01:24:30.131
MORE EFFICIENT BUT ACTUALLY
01:24:30.198 --> 01:24:30.698
REFORM IN THE PROCESS. IT'S
01:24:30.765 --> 01:24:33.134
WHAT I'VE- IT'S WHAT I'VE-
01:24:33.201 --> 01:24:33.668
REALLY DEVOTED A LOT OF MY
01:24:33.735 --> 01:24:36.938
PUBLIC SERVICE TO. SO I REALLY
01:24:37.005 --> 01:24:40.875
AGREE WITH- CENTER HERTZBERG-
01:24:40.942 --> 01:24:42.477
OBSERVATION THAT WE ARE
01:24:42.544 --> 01:24:45.613
REGULATOR REGULATING. FOR THE
01:24:45.680 --> 01:24:46.181
LAST CENTURY NOT THE CURRENT
01:24:46.247 --> 01:24:49.484
CENTURY. TO CHANGE THIS S.
01:24:49.551 --> 01:24:51.352
SPEAKING ABOUT PARTNERSHIPS TO
01:24:51.419 --> 01:24:54.055
CHECK MAKE THE CHANGES- TO THE
01:24:54.122 --> 01:24:55.490
PROCESS CITIES OF THE
01:24:55.557 --> 01:24:57.325
COMMISSION WILL TAKE ALL WILL
01:24:57.392 --> 01:24:58.726
TAKE A PARTNERSHIP THE P. C.
01:24:58.793 --> 01:25:01.796
THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE THE
01:25:01.863 --> 01:25:03.765
LEGISLATURE AND I AM LOOKING AT
01:25:03.832 --> 01:25:05.967
OUR OWN PROCESSES WHICH WE ARE
01:25:06.034 --> 01:25:07.268
DOING AND WE'VE ALREADY MADE
01:25:07.335 --> 01:25:10.472
SOME CHANGES- I THINK THAT
01:25:10.538 --> 01:25:10.939
CENTER RICKSHAW OF IT
01:25:11.005 --> 01:25:13.975
COMMISSION WRECK SHOT AND-
01:25:14.042 --> 01:25:15.844
MENTIONED EARLIER. THAT WE-
01:25:15.910 --> 01:25:17.378
THROUGH A VERY EXPEDITED
01:25:17.445 --> 01:25:19.614
PROCESS TO IMPLEMENT THE LAW A
01:25:19.681 --> 01:25:22.984
WILDFIRE AND PROTOCOLS FROM
01:25:23.051 --> 01:25:25.119
AND- TEN FIFTY FOUR AND NINE A
01:25:25.186 --> 01:25:26.855
ONE. AND WORK WERE GOING WHERE
01:25:26.921 --> 01:25:28.690
YOU IT AS OUT ROCK GOING WHERE
01:25:28.756 --> 01:25:30.492
WILL THEY WERE BROWN TYLER SO
01:25:30.558 --> 01:25:32.026
IF WE CAN TAKE GENERAC
01:25:32.093 --> 01:25:33.962
PORTABLES STOPPED HIM SORRY BUT
01:25:34.028 --> 01:25:35.964
NOW WE DO HAVE STILL MORE
01:25:36.030 --> 01:25:39.467
MEMBERS ON THE- KIßM SORRY IN
01:25:39.534 --> 01:25:40.101
A WORLD WILL. TAKE YOUR ANSWERS
01:25:40.168 --> 01:25:41.703
CENTER MONEY. THANK YOU MISTER
01:25:41.769 --> 01:25:44.172
CHAIRMAN NO. WE'VE GOT MANY
01:25:44.239 --> 01:25:46.241
WAITING ON IMPORTANT PANEL IT
01:25:46.307 --> 01:25:48.576
WE HAVE A LONG AGENDA SO AND WE
01:25:48.643 --> 01:25:51.246
WILL HAVE THE PRAISES OF YOUR
01:25:51.312 --> 01:25:53.147
LEADERSHIP ON THIS AND DIRECT
01:25:53.214 --> 01:25:55.984
MY QUESTION. I THINK THE
01:25:56.050 --> 01:25:57.418
COMMISSIONERS COMMISSION
01:25:57.485 --> 01:25:59.120
MEMBERS FOR BEING HERE I THINK
01:25:59.187 --> 01:26:00.488
MY QUESTIONS PRIDE BEST
01:26:00.555 --> 01:26:02.790
DIRECTED- TO COMMISSIONER.
01:26:02.857 --> 01:26:06.961
WRECK SCHAFFEN- IT RELATES TO
01:26:07.028 --> 01:26:07.529
LAND LINES AND WHILE MANY I
01:26:07.595 --> 01:26:09.864
THINK FEEL. WE NEED TO MOVE
01:26:09.931 --> 01:26:11.232
FORWARD WITH NEW TECHNOLOGIES
01:26:11.299 --> 01:26:12.367
AND INVEST IN THE NEW
01:26:12.433 --> 01:26:14.402
TECHNOLOGIES I REPRESENT
01:26:14.469 --> 01:26:16.471
CONSTITUENTS WHO ARE DEPENDENT
01:26:16.538 --> 01:26:18.873
ON THEIR LAND LINE IT'S THEIR
01:26:18.940 --> 01:26:22.277
ONLY CONNECTION- IN TIMES OF
01:26:22.343 --> 01:26:26.114
EMERGENCY. AND OUR LAND LINE
01:26:26.180 --> 01:26:27.815
ACTUALLY WORKS WHEN WE LOSE OUR
01:26:27.882 --> 01:26:30.985
POWER SO WE CAN STILL MAKE A
01:26:31.052 --> 01:26:32.220
NINE ONE ONE CALL USING FIELD
01:26:32.287 --> 01:26:34.222
LAND LINE SO THERE'S A
01:26:34.289 --> 01:26:36.224
REDUNDANCY BENEFIT THEIR TO
01:26:36.291 --> 01:26:39.627
SOME CONSUMERS- DURING TIMES OF
01:26:39.694 --> 01:26:41.796
CRISIS MY QUESTION. YOU TALKED
01:26:41.863 --> 01:26:43.364
TO THERE'S A PATCHWORK
01:26:43.431 --> 01:26:45.533
AUTHORITY IN JURISDICTIONS AND
01:26:45.600 --> 01:26:46.601
PEOPLE ARE FIGHTING OVER THIS
01:26:46.668 --> 01:26:48.469
AUTHORITIES IN JURISDICTIONS IT
01:26:48.536 --> 01:26:50.038
SEEMS CLEAR THAT THE P. YOU SEE
01:26:50.104 --> 01:26:51.973
DOES HAVE AUTHORITY OVER LAND
01:26:52.040 --> 01:26:55.209
LINE REPORTING WHEN THERE IS A
01:26:55.276 --> 01:26:57.211
LOSS OF SERVICE THAT'S PART OF
01:26:57.278 --> 01:27:00.014
THE REPORTING OBLIGATION. AND
01:27:00.081 --> 01:27:02.884
TIME FOR RESTORATION. THIS P.
01:27:02.951 --> 01:27:05.720
UC'S AUTHORITY ALSO ALLOW WHEN
01:27:05.787 --> 01:27:08.423
THERE'S A SERIES OF SLOW
01:27:08.489 --> 01:27:11.392
RESPONSES TO REPLACING SERVICE.
01:27:11.459 --> 01:27:12.627
TO REQUIRE THE INVESTMENT
01:27:12.694 --> 01:27:17.765
INFRASTRUCTURE.
01:27:17.832 --> 01:27:18.666
TO SPEED CITY DON'T HAVE
01:27:18.733 --> 01:27:20.435
REPEATED LOSSES OF SERVICE
01:27:20.501 --> 01:27:24.639
EVERY TIME. THERE'S AN OUTAGE I
01:27:24.706 --> 01:27:26.908
WOULD SAY YES AND HELEN CAN
01:27:26.975 --> 01:27:28.142
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG I WE
01:27:28.209 --> 01:27:29.677
HAVE THE MOST PLENARY THE
01:27:29.744 --> 01:27:31.412
CLEAREST AND MOST PLENARY
01:27:31.479 --> 01:27:32.347
THIRTY OVER THE TRADITIONAL
01:27:32.413 --> 01:27:36.250
LAND LINES SO IN OUR I WANT TO
01:27:36.317 --> 01:27:36.784
HEAR YOUR ANSWER TO. SO MY
01:27:36.851 --> 01:27:39.287
QUESTION GOES. IF A CERTAIN
01:27:39.354 --> 01:27:41.789
PROVIDE. TELECOM PROVIDER ON
01:27:41.856 --> 01:27:43.758
LAND IT'S LAND LINE SERVICE
01:27:43.825 --> 01:27:45.793
CONTINUES TO SHOW AN INABILITY
01:27:45.860 --> 01:27:48.963
TO RESTORE SERVICE. DOES THAT
01:27:49.030 --> 01:27:50.498
OF THE WORDING INCLUDE
01:27:50.565 --> 01:27:51.933
REQUIRING THAT THIS THERE'S
01:27:52.000 --> 01:27:53.935
INVESTMENT IN IN THE ACTUAL
01:27:54.002 --> 01:27:56.170
INFRASTRUCTURE- IF THEY'RE
01:27:56.237 --> 01:27:58.606
GIVING THAT IS THE REASON THAT
01:27:58.673 --> 01:28:00.375
THEY'RE LOSING THE SERVICE YES
01:28:00.441 --> 01:28:01.542
SENATOR ARE STARTING DOES
01:28:01.609 --> 01:28:04.278
INCLUDE THE ABILITY TO DO THAT
01:28:04.345 --> 01:28:05.747
TO REQUIRE THE CARE TO MAKE
01:28:05.813 --> 01:28:08.750
FURTHER INVESTMENT WE HAVE NOT
01:28:08.816 --> 01:28:09.250
DONE THAT FOR SOME YEARS
01:28:09.317 --> 01:28:10.518
BECAUSE OF THE WAY THEN.
01:28:10.585 --> 01:28:13.221
NETWORK HAS IF. IN BUT WE HAVE
01:28:13.287 --> 01:28:17.492
THAT AUTHORITY. BECAUSE I THINK
01:28:17.558 --> 01:28:18.092
ONE OF OUR DILEMMAS THANK YOU
01:28:18.159 --> 01:28:21.262
FOR THE ANSWER IS. THE TELECOM
01:28:21.329 --> 01:28:23.264
COMPANIES WANT TO INVEST IN THE
01:28:23.331 --> 01:28:28.169
FUTURE IN MORE. RADIO ERVICES-
01:28:28.236 --> 01:28:30.805
CELL TOWERS THAT CENTRO BIT THE
01:28:30.872 --> 01:28:33.307
PUBLIC SAFETY REQUIRES
01:28:33.374 --> 01:28:34.542
MAINTAINING THAT LAND LINE
01:28:34.609 --> 01:28:37.445
SERVICE. TO PEOPLE THAT ARE
01:28:37.512 --> 01:28:38.946
DEPENDENT PARTICULARLY FOR
01:28:39.013 --> 01:28:41.082
EMERGENCY RESPONSE SO I THINK
01:28:41.149 --> 01:28:42.950
THAT'S ONE OF OUR CHALLENGES AS
01:28:43.017 --> 01:28:44.018
PURCHASING THAT THANK YOU
01:28:44.085 --> 01:28:45.620
MISTER CHAIR I CAN CENTER MONEY
01:28:45.687 --> 01:28:47.021
NO THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR
01:28:47.088 --> 01:28:47.655
BEING HERE AND THEIR TESTIMONY
01:28:47.722 --> 01:28:49.991
AND YOUR YOUR LAN ANSWERS THANK
01:28:50.058 --> 01:28:50.858
YOU VERY MUCH WE'RE GONNA MOVE
01:28:50.925 --> 01:28:52.927
ON TO THE NEXT PANEL. WHICH
01:28:52.994 --> 01:28:54.062
LOOKS AT THE IMPACTS TO PUBLIC
01:28:54.128 --> 01:28:57.298
SAFETY AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE
01:28:57.365 --> 01:29:00.968
WE HAVE. MARK YOU ARE DO CHI
01:29:01.035 --> 01:29:02.937
HIS THE FROM THE OFFICE OF
01:29:03.004 --> 01:29:04.972
EMERGENCY SERVICES WITH STATE
01:29:05.039 --> 01:29:05.940
CALIFORNIA. WE ALSO HAVE CHRIS
01:29:06.007 --> 01:29:10.445
RILEY. HE IS- THE EMERGENCY
01:29:10.511 --> 01:29:11.012
SERVICES MANAGER WITH MARIN
01:29:11.079 --> 01:29:17.452
COUNTY. RIGHT AND IF THEY'RE
01:29:17.518 --> 01:29:18.052
BOTH PRESENT IF YOU COULD COME
01:29:18.119 --> 01:29:24.025
FORWARD. THANK YOU AND WELCOME
01:29:24.092 --> 01:29:38.506
BACK. PLEASE SIR PROCEED WHEN
01:29:38.573 --> 01:29:40.374
YOU'RE WHEN YOU'RE READY ALL
01:29:40.441 --> 01:29:41.676
RIGHT FULL GOOD MORNING
01:29:41.743 --> 01:29:43.611
EVERYONE- MISS CHAIR MEMBERS OF
01:29:43.678 --> 01:29:45.646
THE COMMITTEE THANKS FOR HAVING
01:29:45.713 --> 01:29:46.914
ME HERE TO TALK ABOUT THE
01:29:46.981 --> 01:29:47.982
RESILIENCY OF OUR
01:29:48.049 --> 01:29:49.383
TELECOMMUNICATION SYSTEMS MARK
01:29:49.450 --> 01:29:52.253
RDG DIRECTOR OF THE GOVERNOR'S
01:29:52.320 --> 01:29:54.555
OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES.
01:29:54.622 --> 01:29:55.423
LET ME START OFF BY SAYING
01:29:55.490 --> 01:29:57.258
THAT- THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS
01:29:57.325 --> 01:29:58.760
PATHWAYS OF TODAY THAT THOSE
01:29:58.826 --> 01:30:00.762
PATHWAYS WE'VE BEEN TALKING
01:30:00.828 --> 01:30:01.295
ABOUT FOR THE WIRELESS AND
01:30:01.362 --> 01:30:03.564
INTERNET OF THINGS. HAVE
01:30:03.631 --> 01:30:05.566
EVOLVED TO BECOME VITAL
01:30:05.633 --> 01:30:06.100
COMPONENTS TO OUR STATE'S
01:30:06.167 --> 01:30:08.870
PUBLIC SAFETY SYSTEM. SO MANY
01:30:08.936 --> 01:30:10.037
OF THE COMPONENTS OF
01:30:10.104 --> 01:30:11.405
CALIFORNIA'S EMERGENCY RESPONSE
01:30:11.472 --> 01:30:13.674
OPERATIONS ARE BECOMING HEAVILY
01:30:13.741 --> 01:30:14.108
DEPENDENT UPON THESE
01:30:14.175 --> 01:30:16.644
CAPABILITIES AS SUCH ALERT
01:30:16.711 --> 01:30:18.279
MORNINGS SYSTEMS THAT ARE
01:30:18.346 --> 01:30:19.080
PROVIDING LIFESAVING
01:30:19.147 --> 01:30:21.082
NOTIFICATIONS TO THE PUBLIC AND
01:30:21.149 --> 01:30:22.784
INFORMATION SHARING AND
01:30:22.850 --> 01:30:23.818
DISSEMINATION CAPABILITIES THAT
01:30:23.885 --> 01:30:25.787
ALLOW FOR REAL TIME FLOW. OF
01:30:25.853 --> 01:30:27.588
DATA FROM THE FRONT LINES OF A
01:30:27.655 --> 01:30:29.924
DISASTER TO DECISION MAKERS.
01:30:29.991 --> 01:30:31.492
THE REALITY IS THE
01:30:31.559 --> 01:30:32.994
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES
01:30:33.060 --> 01:30:34.562
THAT WE ARE DEPENDING ON
01:30:34.629 --> 01:30:37.265
WHETHER THROUGH VOICE OVER IP
01:30:37.331 --> 01:30:38.966
LAND LINE CELLPHONE TV OR
01:30:39.033 --> 01:30:41.869
COMPUTER ARE NOW REALLY
01:30:41.936 --> 01:30:44.539
ESSENTIAL AND CRITICAL LIFELINE
01:30:44.605 --> 01:30:46.808
SERVICES. YET AS A AND C. AND
01:30:46.874 --> 01:30:48.676
THE RELIABILITY OF THE SYSTEMS
01:30:48.743 --> 01:30:51.179
ARE INCONSISTENT OR SIMPLY
01:30:51.245 --> 01:30:52.980
ABSENT WITH WHAT IS NECESSARY
01:30:53.047 --> 01:30:55.650
TO ENSURE. THE DELIVERY OF THE
01:30:55.716 --> 01:30:58.519
ESSENTIAL LIFELINE CAPABILITIES.
01:30:58.586 --> 01:30:59.921
OVER THE LAST SIX YEARS WE KNOW
01:30:59.987 --> 01:31:01.823
WE'VE HAD NUMEROUS OCCASIONS
01:31:01.889 --> 01:31:03.891
WHERE NATURAL AND HUMAN CAUSED
01:31:03.958 --> 01:31:04.425
DISASTERS HAVE RESULTED IN
01:31:04.492 --> 01:31:07.829
FAIRS WE'VE TALKED ABOUT THESE.
01:31:07.895 --> 01:31:09.897
AND I'VE TESTIFIED ON THE OF
01:31:09.964 --> 01:31:11.332
THE OF THE FINDINGS IN THE
01:31:11.399 --> 01:31:13.701
FACTUAL DATA THAT WE HAVE SEEN
01:31:13.768 --> 01:31:15.570
BUT I WANT TO LOOK FORWARD I
01:31:15.636 --> 01:31:16.304
WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT TODAY
01:31:16.370 --> 01:31:18.206
I'LL SEND SOME CONTEXT. OF
01:31:18.272 --> 01:31:21.042
WHERE WE'RE TRYING TO GET TO-
01:31:21.108 --> 01:31:22.743
TO BE ABLE TO FRAME. FOR IN THE
01:31:22.810 --> 01:31:26.113
EFFORT. DURING THE TWO THOUSAND
01:31:26.180 --> 01:31:27.081
ON THE OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND
01:31:27.148 --> 01:31:29.050
NINETEEN PS PS ADVANCE. REALLY
01:31:29.116 --> 01:31:31.352
A WORST CASE SCENARIO EMERGED
01:31:31.419 --> 01:31:32.587
AS THE AS LARGE REGIONS OF THE
01:31:32.653 --> 01:31:34.655
STATE'S WERE DEALING. WITH THE
01:31:34.722 --> 01:31:36.591
MULTI DAY PUBLIC SAFETY POWER
01:31:36.657 --> 01:31:38.860
SHUT OFFS COMBINED WITH A RED
01:31:38.926 --> 01:31:40.561
FLAG WHETHER. AND SEVERAL FIRES
01:31:40.628 --> 01:31:42.964
BROKE OUT. AS A ESULT OF THE
01:31:43.030 --> 01:31:45.600
OUTAGES HUNDREDS OF CELL SITES
01:31:45.666 --> 01:31:47.535
AND DATA LINES HAD LOST POWER.
01:31:47.602 --> 01:31:49.003
MOST WITH INSUFFICIENT BACKUP
01:31:49.070 --> 01:31:50.438
POWER OR NO BACKUP POWER AT
01:31:50.504 --> 01:31:52.240
ALL. MANY CALIFORNIANS WERE
01:31:52.306 --> 01:31:54.075
UNABLE TO COMMUNICATE GET
01:31:54.141 --> 01:31:55.743
INFORMATION ABOUT EVCUATION
01:31:55.810 --> 01:31:57.712
ROUTES OR OTHER LARGE OR
01:31:57.778 --> 01:32:00.114
RECEIVE UPDATES ON PS PS OR
01:32:00.181 --> 01:32:02.016
FIRE CONDITIONS. AND I WILL ONE
01:32:02.083 --> 01:32:03.117
CENTERS AND HOSPITALS WERE
01:32:03.184 --> 01:32:04.752
UNABLE TO PROCESS CRITICAL
01:32:04.819 --> 01:32:05.319
DATER OR LEVERAGE IMPORTANT
01:32:05.386 --> 01:32:07.955
RECORDS. TO AVOID REPEATING THE
01:32:08.022 --> 01:32:09.557
SCENARIO. OUR
01:32:09.624 --> 01:32:11.659
TELECOMMUNICATIONS PARTNERS
01:32:11.726 --> 01:32:13.694
BOTH WIRELESS AND CABLE NEED TO
01:32:13.761 --> 01:32:15.963
PERFORM WHAT I BELIEVE. AND I
01:32:16.030 --> 01:32:17.331
BELIEVE THERE ARE DOING THIS
01:32:17.398 --> 01:32:18.966
NOW A COMPREHENSIVE GAP
01:32:19.033 --> 01:32:21.402
ANALYSIS TO DEVELOP A STRATEGIC
01:32:21.469 --> 01:32:23.371
PLAN TO RAPIDLY BUILD IN BOTH
01:32:23.437 --> 01:32:25.306
RESILIENCY AND REDUNDANCY
01:32:25.373 --> 01:32:27.074
THROUGHOUT THEIR SYSTEM. WE
01:32:27.141 --> 01:32:28.276
BELIEVE THAT THE PROCESS OF
01:32:28.342 --> 01:32:30.378
UPGRADING THE SYSTEM TO WHAT I
01:32:30.444 --> 01:32:32.013
CALL PUBLIC SAFETY GRADE IS
01:32:32.079 --> 01:32:35.683
PRIMARILY TO FULL INCREASING
01:32:35.750 --> 01:32:36.317
DATA SHARING. AN INFRASTRUCTURE
01:32:36.384 --> 01:32:39.353
HARDENING. IN THE AREA OF DATA
01:32:39.420 --> 01:32:41.455
SHARING DURING DISASTERS LIKE
01:32:41.522 --> 01:32:42.924
TELECOMMUTE Là DURING
01:32:42.990 --> 01:32:44.992
DISASTERS THE- SERVICE
01:32:45.059 --> 01:32:47.295
PROVIDERS HOLD KEY INFORMATION
01:32:47.361 --> 01:32:49.063
CALAVERAS NEEDS IN ORDER TO
01:32:49.130 --> 01:32:50.097
EFFECTIVELY RESPOND TO
01:32:50.164 --> 01:32:52.099
EMERGENCIES. NO WE WENT AN
01:32:52.166 --> 01:32:53.734
OUTAGE OCCURS ENABLES- WE ASKED
01:32:53.801 --> 01:32:55.269
TO SHARE SUCH VALUABLE
01:32:55.336 --> 01:32:56.404
INFORMATION WITH RESPONSE
01:32:56.470 --> 01:32:58.606
AGENCIES IMPROVING THE ABILITY
01:32:58.673 --> 01:33:00.474
TO MAKE DECISIONS. WHICH ARE
01:33:00.541 --> 01:33:02.310
OFTEN LIFESAVING DECISIONS
01:33:02.376 --> 01:33:05.346
BASED ON THAT ACTIONABLE DATA
01:33:05.413 --> 01:33:07.448
THAT IS AVAILABLE. AT THE STATE
01:33:07.515 --> 01:33:09.250
LOCAL LEVEL RAPIDLY KNOWING
01:33:09.317 --> 01:33:10.818
WHEN AN OUTAGE HAS OCCURRED
01:33:10.885 --> 01:33:13.020
INCREASES SITUATIONAL AWARENESS
01:33:13.087 --> 01:33:14.555
AND FURTHER INFORMS AS WHEN
01:33:14.622 --> 01:33:15.923
ALTERNATE FORMS OF
01:33:15.990 --> 01:33:17.058
COMMUNICATION AND OR
01:33:17.124 --> 01:33:18.426
NOTIFICATIONS ARE NEEDED.
01:33:18.492 --> 01:33:20.695
ADDITIONALLY STATE AND LOCAL
01:33:20.761 --> 01:33:22.229
AGENCIES CAN ASSESS WHETHER
01:33:22.296 --> 01:33:24.565
COMMUNITIES ARE AT RISK OF
01:33:24.632 --> 01:33:27.335
BEING UNABLE TO ACCESS NINE ONE
01:33:27.401 --> 01:33:29.937
ONE SERVICE AND THEN WE CAN
01:33:30.004 --> 01:33:31.172
IMPLEMENT APPROPRIATE
01:33:31.238 --> 01:33:32.940
COUNTERMEASURES OR TAKE YOU SEE
01:33:33.007 --> 01:33:35.409
BEING MANY. ACTIONS IN THE
01:33:35.476 --> 01:33:37.945
PAST. THE INFORMATION WE NEED
01:33:38.012 --> 01:33:39.880
HAS NOT BEEN EASILY OBTAINED
01:33:39.947 --> 01:33:41.849
FROM THE SERVICE PROVIDERS
01:33:41.916 --> 01:33:43.484
DURING THE RECENT. VAN WHAT ARE
01:33:43.551 --> 01:33:44.852
WHAT OVER THIRTY COUNTIES LOST
01:33:44.919 --> 01:33:47.722
POWER WE HAVE HAD DIFFICULTY
01:33:47.788 --> 01:33:49.357
GETTING REQUIRED INFORMATION
01:33:49.423 --> 01:33:50.624
FROM SEVERAL WIRELESS AND
01:33:50.691 --> 01:33:51.826
WIRELINE PROVIDERS. NOT
01:33:51.892 --> 01:33:53.694
LAUGHTER I PERSONALLY REACHED
01:33:53.761 --> 01:33:56.263
OUT TO THEIR RESPECTIVE CEOS WE
01:33:56.330 --> 01:33:57.832
ABLE TO GET THE DETAILS OUTAGE
01:33:57.898 --> 01:34:00.434
INFORMATION NEEDED THAT WAS
01:34:00.501 --> 01:34:04.338
ACTIONABLE AND RELEVANT. DURING
01:34:04.405 --> 01:34:04.972
THE OCTOBER TWENTY EIGHT PS PS
01:34:05.039 --> 01:34:05.873
A BAD FOR INSTANCE IT WAS
01:34:05.940 --> 01:34:06.874
REPORTED THAT THREE POINT 3% OF
01:34:06.941 --> 01:34:08.376
THE CELL TOWERS IN THE PS PS
01:34:08.442 --> 01:34:11.145
AREAS WENT DOWN. WHILE THE
01:34:11.212 --> 01:34:11.612
NUMBER DOES NOT SEEM
01:34:11.679 --> 01:34:13.781
SIGNIFICANT AT FIRST CONSIDER.
01:34:13.848 --> 01:34:16.283
THE LOCAL AREA SPECIFIC IMPACT
01:34:16.350 --> 01:34:19.086
ABOUT THREE POINT 3% RESIDENTS
01:34:19.153 --> 01:34:20.654
OF MARIN COUNTY AS YOU'VE HEARD
01:34:20.721 --> 01:34:22.823
LOS CELLULAR SERVICE AND WE'RE
01:34:22.890 --> 01:34:26.627
ABLE TO GET INFORMATION AS 57%
01:34:26.694 --> 01:34:27.228
OF THE COUNTY CELL TOWERS WENT
01:34:27.294 --> 01:34:30.398
OFFLINE. THIS WAS CHALLENGING.
01:34:30.464 --> 01:34:31.632
THE ENDING THE P. S. P. S.
01:34:31.699 --> 01:34:33.467
EVENT HOW DID THE INABILITY TO
01:34:33.534 --> 01:34:34.535
GET INFORMATION ESSENTIAL
01:34:34.602 --> 01:34:36.303
INFORMATION OUT BUT MARIN
01:34:36.370 --> 01:34:38.072
COUNTY WAS A RECEIVING AND
01:34:38.139 --> 01:34:39.573
SHELTERING COUNTY FOR CAN QUE
01:34:39.640 --> 01:34:41.942
FIRED BACK YOU WE SEE. THE LACK
01:34:42.009 --> 01:34:43.177
OF CELLULAR AND INTERNET
01:34:43.244 --> 01:34:44.578
SERVICES CRIPPLED ESSENTIAL
01:34:44.645 --> 01:34:46.647
COMMUNICATIONS EXPONENTIALLY
01:34:46.714 --> 01:34:48.783
COMPLICATING THE SITUATION. AT
01:34:48.849 --> 01:34:50.785
PUT RIGHT LIVES AT RISK.
01:34:50.851 --> 01:34:52.219
WITHOUT RAPIDLY RECEIVING
01:34:52.286 --> 01:34:54.655
DETAIL AREA SPECIFIC OUTAGE
01:34:54.722 --> 01:34:57.024
DATA CALLOW YES AND LOCAL
01:34:57.091 --> 01:34:57.758
AGENCIES CANNOT TAKE THE
01:34:57.825 --> 01:35:00.795
REQUIRED STEPS TO PUT ALTERNATE
01:35:00.861 --> 01:35:01.362
COMMUNICATIONS IN PLACE. TO
01:35:01.429 --> 01:35:03.097
ENSURE FOR PUBLIC SAFETY. THERE
01:35:03.164 --> 01:35:04.565
ARE OPPORTUNITIES HOWEVER FOR
01:35:04.632 --> 01:35:07.268
IMPROVEMENT ALL AROUND. I'M
01:35:07.334 --> 01:35:08.702
HAPPY TO SAY THAT SERVICE
01:35:08.769 --> 01:35:10.471
PROVIDERS AND CAL WE **** HAVE
01:35:10.538 --> 01:35:12.206
BEEN MEETING OVER THE LAST FEW
01:35:12.273 --> 01:35:14.241
MONTHS TO ASSESS GAPS AND
01:35:14.308 --> 01:35:16.277
DISCUSS IMPROVEMENTS THESE
01:35:16.343 --> 01:35:18.312
MEETINGS HAVE BEEN BENEFICIAL
01:35:18.379 --> 01:35:19.947
AND CONSTRUCTIVE AND WILL BE ON
01:35:20.014 --> 01:35:22.783
GOING. AS WELL SB SIX SEVENTY
01:35:22.850 --> 01:35:24.952
BY SENATOR MCGUIRE PASSED LAST
01:35:25.019 --> 01:35:27.154
YEAR INSIDE BY THE GOVERNOR
01:35:27.221 --> 01:35:28.355
SAYS FOR THE STARTING POINT FOR
01:35:28.422 --> 01:35:29.824
OUTAGE INFORMATION SHARING
01:35:29.890 --> 01:35:32.226
HELLO YES HAS RELEASED PROPOSED
01:35:32.293 --> 01:35:34.395
REGULATIONS FOR PUBLIC COMMENT
01:35:34.462 --> 01:35:35.896
THAT ESTABLISHES A REPORTING
01:35:35.963 --> 01:35:38.132
THRESHOLD AND THE PROCESS BY
01:35:38.199 --> 01:35:39.533
WHICH SERVICE PROVIDERS SHALL
01:35:39.600 --> 01:35:41.602
REPORT. HE DRAFT REGULATIONS
01:35:41.669 --> 01:35:42.703
WERE RELEASED FOR PUBLIC
01:35:42.770 --> 01:35:44.572
COMMENT ON DECEMBER TWENTIETH
01:35:44.638 --> 01:35:45.906
AND WILL BE OPEN UNTIL FEBRUARY
01:35:45.973 --> 01:35:48.476
FOURTH ANOTHER SOLUTION THAT
01:35:48.542 --> 01:35:50.211
CALLOW YES PLEASE WOULD GREATLY
01:35:50.277 --> 01:35:52.379
BENEFIT SHARING DURING
01:35:52.446 --> 01:35:53.280
EMERGENCY OPERATIONS IS ANY
01:35:53.347 --> 01:35:54.248
THING SIR PROVIDER
01:35:54.315 --> 01:35:56.717
PARTICIPATION IN THE STATE
01:35:56.784 --> 01:35:58.018
OPERATIONS CENTER DURING
01:35:58.085 --> 01:35:59.487
EMERGENCY. WHEN THE STUDENTS
01:35:59.553 --> 01:36:00.654
OPERATE CENTER ACTIVATION
01:36:00.721 --> 01:36:01.489
SUPPORT UPPER TO SEE INCLUDING
01:36:01.555 --> 01:36:03.991
PS PS HELLO YES NEEDS TO HAVE
01:36:04.058 --> 01:36:04.525
SERVICE PROVIDER
01:36:04.592 --> 01:36:06.327
REPRESENTATIVES IN THE SOCK
01:36:06.393 --> 01:36:08.095
THAT CAN UNDERSTAND THE
01:36:08.162 --> 01:36:10.464
SITUATION AND DIRECTLY AND
01:36:10.531 --> 01:36:12.133
IMMEDIATELY PROVIDE THE
01:36:12.199 --> 01:36:13.968
INFORMATION THE CAL WE **** ASK
01:36:14.034 --> 01:36:17.571
FOR PROVIDER SHOULD ALSO
01:36:17.638 --> 01:36:18.172
ESTABLISH A POINT OF CONTACT.
01:36:18.239 --> 01:36:20.574
EITHER REGIONAL. AT THE
01:36:20.641 --> 01:36:22.543
OPERATIONAL AREA LEVEL THAT CAN
01:36:22.610 --> 01:36:23.177
BE USED BY EITHER HE'S HE'S OUR
01:36:23.244 --> 01:36:23.911
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WHEN THEY
01:36:23.978 --> 01:36:24.945
HAVE QUESTIONS CONCERNING
01:36:25.012 --> 01:36:26.614
SERVICE OUTAGES. THESE LAYERS
01:36:26.680 --> 01:36:28.516
ONS WILL BE IN A AN IMPROVEMENT
01:36:28.582 --> 01:36:29.717
AND ALLOW FOR REAL TIME DATA
01:36:29.783 --> 01:36:33.120
SHARING CRITICAL TO SUPPORTING
01:36:33.187 --> 01:36:33.721
EMERGENCIES ACROSS THE STATE.
01:36:33.787 --> 01:36:36.157
RESPONSE EFFORTS. THE OTHER
01:36:36.223 --> 01:36:38.392
AREA INFRASTRUCTURE HARDENING.
01:36:38.459 --> 01:36:39.660
EVERYTHING WE HAVE JUST BEEN
01:36:39.727 --> 01:36:41.595
DISCUSSING IS REALLY AN OFF
01:36:41.662 --> 01:36:43.531
SHOOT OF THE REAL PROBLEM DOWN
01:36:43.597 --> 01:36:45.232
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES IN
01:36:45.299 --> 01:36:48.736
A PERFECT WORLD. HE CAN WE CAN
01:36:48.802 --> 01:36:50.437
IF WE CAN MITIGATE OUTAGES
01:36:50.504 --> 01:36:52.339
THEMSELVES THE OUTAGE REPORTING
01:36:52.406 --> 01:36:53.974
ISSUES BECOME LESS SIGNIFICANT
01:36:54.041 --> 01:36:56.710
HOWEVER NOW CALIFORNIA HAS AN
01:36:56.777 --> 01:36:58.879
URGENT NEED TO ENSURE THAT THE
01:36:58.946 --> 01:37:00.548
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS WE
01:37:00.614 --> 01:37:02.917
DEPEND ON OUR BILL TO A
01:37:02.983 --> 01:37:04.285
RESILIENT RELIABLE EVERY DONE
01:37:04.351 --> 01:37:07.121
IN STANDARD. TIME IS OF THE
01:37:07.188 --> 01:37:10.024
ESSENCE SERVICE PROVIDERS CAN
01:37:10.090 --> 01:37:11.692
DO THIS BY DEVELOPING AND
01:37:11.759 --> 01:37:14.628
IMPLEMENTING A STRATEGIC PLAN
01:37:14.695 --> 01:37:16.497
WORKING. IN CONJUNCTION WITH
01:37:16.564 --> 01:37:18.666
THE STATE THAT EXECUTES A
01:37:18.732 --> 01:37:21.468
ROBUST INITIATIVE TO IDENTIFY
01:37:21.535 --> 01:37:22.903
VULNERABILITIES HARDEN
01:37:22.970 --> 01:37:25.172
INFRASTRUCTURE AND BUILD MORE
01:37:25.239 --> 01:37:26.574
RESILIENT AND WE'VE DONE IT
01:37:26.640 --> 01:37:28.442
SYSTEM. AS WELL SERVICE
01:37:28.509 --> 01:37:30.711
PROVIDERS SHOULD NOT RELY ON A
01:37:30.778 --> 01:37:32.947
PLAN THAT SIMPLY OUTLINES
01:37:33.013 --> 01:37:33.948
PROCURING OUT OF STATE
01:37:34.014 --> 01:37:36.083
GENERATORS ON THE FLY TO BE
01:37:36.150 --> 01:37:38.519
BROUGHT IN DURING AN EMERGENCY.
01:37:38.586 --> 01:37:42.089
BUT RATHER BY BUILDING IT BACK
01:37:42.156 --> 01:37:43.224
UP POWER AT THAT IS CAPABLE OF
01:37:43.290 --> 01:37:45.759
SUSTAINING THEIR SYSTEMS FOR
01:37:45.826 --> 01:37:47.928
THREE TO SEVEN DAYS ENSURING
01:37:47.995 --> 01:37:49.463
FOR ATTIC DEFENSIBLE SPACE
01:37:49.530 --> 01:37:51.198
HARDEN BACKHAUL INFRASTRUCTURE.
01:37:51.265 --> 01:37:53.167
SUCH AS FIBER BROADCAST
01:37:53.234 --> 01:37:55.636
BROADBAND AND MICROWAVE AND
01:37:55.703 --> 01:37:56.704
TAKING OTHER STEPS TO PROTECT
01:37:56.770 --> 01:37:59.740
CELL SITES. IN HINDSIGHT I
01:37:59.807 --> 01:38:00.608
BELIEVE THAT THESE COMPANIES
01:38:00.674 --> 01:38:02.843
NOW UNDERSTAND THE REALITY OF
01:38:02.910 --> 01:38:05.813
THE CASCADING CONSEQUENCES OF
01:38:05.879 --> 01:38:08.115
MULTIPLE LARGE SCALE PS PS
01:38:08.182 --> 01:38:11.652
ADVANCE AND THAT AN EFFORT TO
01:38:11.719 --> 01:38:12.620
PROVIDE FOR TEMPORARY MOBILE
01:38:12.686 --> 01:38:14.922
RESOURCES IS NOT ONLY CHALLENGE
01:38:14.989 --> 01:38:17.591
IS SIMPLY INADEQUATE.
01:38:17.658 --> 01:38:18.993
COMMUNICATIONS SITES MUST HAVE
01:38:19.059 --> 01:38:20.227
PROPERLY SIZED PLACE GENERATORS
01:38:20.294 --> 01:38:21.495
AND A REFUELING PLAN OR AN
01:38:21.562 --> 01:38:22.997
ALTERNATE POWER SOURCE SUCH AS
01:38:23.063 --> 01:38:23.530
SOLAR POWER WITH ADEQUATE
01:38:23.597 --> 01:38:29.536
BATTERY BACKUP. DURING THE TWO
01:38:29.603 --> 01:38:30.137
THOUSAND TEN NINETEEN P. S. P.
01:38:30.204 --> 01:38:32.006
S. EVENTS IN OCTOBER OUTAGES
01:38:32.072 --> 01:38:34.341
OUTLASTED MANY OF THE CELL
01:38:34.408 --> 01:38:37.278
TOWERS EXISTING BACKUP CAPACITY.
01:38:37.344 --> 01:38:39.980
AS WELL A LACK OF SUSTAINABLE
01:38:40.047 --> 01:38:40.514
BACK CALL CONNECTIVITY IS
01:38:40.581 --> 01:38:43.851
ANOTHER GAP. BACK CALL IS THE
01:38:43.917 --> 01:38:45.252
CONNECTION FROM THE CELL SITE
01:38:45.319 --> 01:38:47.054
TO THE CELLULAR NETWORK AND IS
01:38:47.121 --> 01:38:48.422
REQUIRED FOR CELL SITES TO
01:38:48.489 --> 01:38:50.424
FUNCTION MOST CELL SITES RELY
01:38:50.491 --> 01:38:52.726
ON FIBER CONNECTIONS WHICH HAVE
01:38:52.793 --> 01:38:54.728
SWITCHED WE HAVE SEEN DAMAGED
01:38:54.795 --> 01:38:56.597
OR DESTROYED DURING A FIRE OR
01:38:56.664 --> 01:38:57.898
AN EARTHQUAKE. BACKUP
01:38:57.965 --> 01:39:00.200
CONDUCTIVITY WOULD TYPICALLY BE
01:39:00.267 --> 01:39:01.435
PROVIDED VIA MICROWAVE
01:39:01.502 --> 01:39:02.936
CONNECTIONS BUT MOST CELL SITES
01:39:03.003 --> 01:39:05.606
DO NOT HAVE BACKUP MICROWAVE
01:39:05.673 --> 01:39:07.207
FOR BACK CALL IN A RECENT
01:39:07.274 --> 01:39:10.344
INCIDENT. A LACK OF REDUNDANCY
01:39:10.411 --> 01:39:12.880
IN BACK CALL CREATED SEVERE
01:39:12.946 --> 01:39:13.681
PROBLEM FOR THE SACRAMENTO
01:39:13.747 --> 01:39:15.883
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT. ON THE
01:39:15.949 --> 01:39:16.717
EVENING OF DECEMBER TWENTY
01:39:16.784 --> 01:39:18.952
FIRST A DRIVER STRUCK A
01:39:19.019 --> 01:39:22.256
TELEPHONE POLE THE SEVERED OF
01:39:22.323 --> 01:39:22.790
FIBER CABLE MILES FROM THE
01:39:22.856 --> 01:39:26.694
AIRPORT. OUTAGE HOWEVER LASTED
01:39:26.760 --> 01:39:28.028
FOR TWENTY THREE HOURS BECAUSE
01:39:28.095 --> 01:39:30.464
MANY FLIGHTS DELAYS AND LEAD TO
01:39:30.531 --> 01:39:31.332
TWENTY CANCEL CANCELLATION
01:39:31.398 --> 01:39:33.233
CANCELLED FLIGHTS. ON ONE OF
01:39:33.300 --> 01:39:35.736
THE BUSIEST TRAVEL DAYS OF THE
01:39:35.803 --> 01:39:36.337
YEAR MAYBE ONE OF YOU MAY HAVE
01:39:36.403 --> 01:39:39.807
GOTTEN CAUGHT UP IN THAT. OKAY
01:39:39.873 --> 01:39:41.141
HAVE THE AIRPORT MANAGEMENT
01:39:41.208 --> 01:39:42.543
UNDERSTOOD THE LACK OF BOTH
01:39:42.609 --> 01:39:44.578
RESILIENCY AND REDUNDANCY THEY
01:39:44.645 --> 01:39:46.914
MAY HAVE UTILIZE MULTIPLE OTHER
01:39:46.980 --> 01:39:48.582
SERVICE PROVIDERS TO AVOID SUCH
01:39:48.649 --> 01:39:50.117
AN OUTAGE AS WELL. AND
01:39:50.184 --> 01:39:50.751
UNDERSTANDING BY THE
01:39:50.818 --> 01:39:52.252
TELECOMMUNICATION PROVIDERS
01:39:52.319 --> 01:39:53.854
THAT AN UNPROTECTED SINGLE
01:39:53.921 --> 01:39:55.089
FIBER LINE TO CRITICAL
01:39:55.155 --> 01:39:56.657
INFRASTRUCTURE HAS EXTREME
01:39:56.724 --> 01:39:59.026
VULNERABILITY IS UNACCEPTABLE
01:39:59.093 --> 01:40:01.628
AND SPEAK TO MY FINAL POINT AND
01:40:01.695 --> 01:40:02.096
THAT IS A LACK OF SITE
01:40:02.162 --> 01:40:05.232
PROTECTION. LIKE THE EXAMPLES I
01:40:05.299 --> 01:40:06.300
JUST PROVIDED SEVERAL
01:40:06.367 --> 01:40:08.168
COMMERCIAL SITES SEVERAL
01:40:08.235 --> 01:40:09.636
COMMERCIAL CELL SITES AND
01:40:09.703 --> 01:40:11.238
CRITICAL FIBER LINES THAT
01:40:11.305 --> 01:40:13.741
BURNED IN THE TWO THOUSAND
01:40:13.807 --> 01:40:14.341
SEVENTEEN EIGHTEEN FIRES WERE
01:40:14.408 --> 01:40:17.678
LOCATED. ON THE SAME MOUNTAIN
01:40:17.745 --> 01:40:18.212
TOP AS THE STATE'S PUBLIC
01:40:18.278 --> 01:40:20.681
SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS SITES.
01:40:20.748 --> 01:40:22.149
INTERESTINGLY NONE OF THE
01:40:22.216 --> 01:40:22.816
STATE'S PUBLIC SAFETY
01:40:22.883 --> 01:40:25.152
COMMUNICATIONS SITES BURN BUT
01:40:25.219 --> 01:40:26.353
MANY AS MANY AS SIX OF THE
01:40:26.420 --> 01:40:27.521
COMMERCIAL CELL SITES WERE TO
01:40:27.588 --> 01:40:29.690
STORY. WE SUSPECT THAT THE GAPS
01:40:29.757 --> 01:40:31.458
AND DEFENSIBLE SPACE AND OTHER
01:40:31.525 --> 01:40:33.394
PREVENTABLE FACTORS CONTRIBUTED
01:40:33.460 --> 01:40:34.261
TO THE VULNERABILITIES OF THESE
01:40:34.328 --> 01:40:36.563
COMMERCIAL SITES LEADING TO THE
01:40:36.630 --> 01:40:37.064
DESTRUCTION OF CRITICAL
01:40:37.131 --> 01:40:40.033
COMMUNICATION SERVICES. AGAIN
01:40:40.100 --> 01:40:42.703
TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE
01:40:42.770 --> 01:40:45.038
COOPERATIVELY WE CAN WORK TO
01:40:45.105 --> 01:40:48.375
ACHIEVE WHAT IS NECESSARY. A
01:40:48.442 --> 01:40:49.109
PUBLIC SAFETY GRAY COMMITTEE
01:40:49.176 --> 01:40:51.078
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS
01:40:51.145 --> 01:40:53.280
SYSTEM THAT WILL ENSURE FOR
01:40:53.347 --> 01:40:54.681
REDUNDANT AD RESILIENT AND
01:40:54.748 --> 01:40:56.850
MOST IMPORTANTLY A RELIABLE
01:40:56.917 --> 01:40:57.551
WIRELESS AND DATA
01:40:57.618 --> 01:40:59.820
COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM THAT WE
01:40:59.887 --> 01:41:00.754
CAN THAT CAN WITHSTAND THE
01:41:00.821 --> 01:41:04.558
RISKS WE FACE IN CALIFORNIA I
01:41:04.625 --> 01:41:05.159
LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH
01:41:05.225 --> 01:41:05.559
OUR PARTNERS THE
01:41:05.626 --> 01:41:07.394
TELECOMMUNICATION INDUSTRY. MY
01:41:07.461 --> 01:41:09.530
WHOLE AGENCIES BEEN DIRECTED TO
01:41:09.596 --> 01:41:11.698
WRAP AROUND AND FIND THE
01:41:11.765 --> 01:41:13.000
SOLUTIONS THAT ARE NECESSARY TO
01:41:13.066 --> 01:41:15.302
GET THIS DONE- AND THROUGH A
01:41:15.369 --> 01:41:17.237
SERIES OF METRICS AND TIME
01:41:17.304 --> 01:41:19.273
FRAMES AND DELIVERABLES I
01:41:19.339 --> 01:41:20.908
BELIEVE THAT WE CAN GET THERE
01:41:20.974 --> 01:41:22.743
WITH NOT ONLY OUR PARTNERSHIP
01:41:22.810 --> 01:41:25.479
WITH YOUR HELP AS WELL I THANK
01:41:25.546 --> 01:41:28.215
YOU AGAIN FOR THE OP TO SPEAK
01:41:28.282 --> 01:41:28.782
ON THESE EVENTS BE HAPPY TO
01:41:28.849 --> 01:41:33.120
ANSWER ANY OF YOUR QUESTIONS.
01:41:33.187 --> 01:41:33.687
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN
01:41:33.754 --> 01:41:34.588
AND SENATORS THANK YOU VERY
01:41:34.655 --> 01:41:35.456
MUCH FOR INVITING ME TO SPEAK
01:41:35.522 --> 01:41:36.123
TODAY ABOUT TOLD
01:41:36.190 --> 01:41:38.659
TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGES I AM
01:41:38.725 --> 01:41:39.726
CHRIS RILEY ON THE EMERGENCY
01:41:39.793 --> 01:41:41.728
SERVICES MANAGER. WITH THE
01:41:41.795 --> 01:41:43.697
MARIN COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE-
01:41:43.764 --> 01:41:44.932
FIRST I JUST WANT TO COVER SOME
01:41:44.998 --> 01:41:47.201
BACKGROUND OF OUR EXPERIENCES
01:41:47.267 --> 01:41:47.801
AND I APOLOGIZE SO THIS IS
01:41:47.868 --> 01:41:49.069
BEING COVERED BY THE DIRECTOR
01:41:49.136 --> 01:41:51.038
AND OTHERS. BUT I JUST WANT TO
01:41:51.104 --> 01:41:52.573
GIVE YOU A FLAVOR OF WHAT OUR
01:41:52.639 --> 01:41:53.140
EXPERIENCES WERE IN IN MARIN
01:41:53.207 --> 01:41:55.576
COUNTY AS YOU'RE LIKELY AWARE-
01:41:55.642 --> 01:41:57.945
LATE LAST YEAR MARIN COUNTY
01:41:58.011 --> 01:41:59.146
EXPERIENCE TO PUBLIC SAFETY
01:41:59.213 --> 01:42:00.614
POWER SHUTDOWNS. THOSE
01:42:00.681 --> 01:42:01.448
SHUTDOWNS CAUSE
01:42:01.515 --> 01:42:03.383
TELECOMMUNICATION OUTAGES IN A
01:42:03.450 --> 01:42:05.552
SERIES OF CASCADING EVENTS. THE
01:42:05.619 --> 01:42:08.255
FIRST P. AS PS WAS FROM OCTOBER
01:42:08.322 --> 01:42:10.257
EIGHT TO TWELVE. AND THE SECOND
01:42:10.324 --> 01:42:13.126
MORE SERIOUS EVENT FOR US- WAS
01:42:13.193 --> 01:42:13.994
FROM OCTOBER TWENTY SIXTH TO
01:42:14.061 --> 01:42:16.029
NOVEMBER FIRST. WHEN KENNEDY
01:42:16.096 --> 01:42:18.098
WAS A LIKELY THE MOST
01:42:18.165 --> 01:42:19.733
NEGATIVELY IMPACTED COUNTY IN
01:42:19.800 --> 01:42:21.034
THE SECOND ADVENT. VIRTUALLY A
01:42:21.101 --> 01:42:22.703
100% OF OUR COUNTY WAS WAS
01:42:22.769 --> 01:42:25.606
WITHOUT POWER- THE PS PS TURNED
01:42:25.672 --> 01:42:26.473
OFF POWER TO VIRTUALLY THE
01:42:26.540 --> 01:42:28.408
ENTIRE COUNTY AS I STATED-
01:42:28.475 --> 01:42:30.110
INITIALLY WE WERE NOTIFIED BY
01:42:30.177 --> 01:42:30.844
P. JEANNIE THAT SOMEWHERE
01:42:30.911 --> 01:42:35.249
BETWEEN. ONE HUNDRED AND
01:42:35.315 --> 01:42:36.850
1-300-020-0200 TWENTY THREE
01:42:36.917 --> 01:42:38.652
THOUSAND CUSTOMERS. IT WOULD
01:42:38.719 --> 01:42:39.953
HAVE THEIR POWER SHUT DOWN FOR
01:42:40.020 --> 01:42:42.422
ALMOST ONE WEEK- THAT NUMBERS
01:42:42.489 --> 01:42:44.291
KIND OF MISLEADING BECAUSE IF-YOU THINK ABOUT IT THAT'S
01:42:44.358 --> 01:42:46.360
REALLY TIMES THREE. WHICH IF
01:42:46.426 --> 01:42:47.828
YOU DO THE MATH IS REALLY MORE
01:42:47.895 --> 01:42:52.966
THAN OUR POPULATION SO. IT HAD
01:42:53.033 --> 01:42:53.534
QUITE AN EFFECT ON US. QUITE
01:42:53.600 --> 01:42:58.171
SEVERE. PRIOR TO THE SECOND
01:42:58.238 --> 01:42:59.606
TIAS PAY US IS THE DIRECTOR'S
01:42:59.673 --> 01:43:00.407
STATED AND OTHERS HAVE STATED.
01:43:00.474 --> 01:43:02.409
KINCAID FIRE STARTED IN CINEMA
01:43:02.476 --> 01:43:03.043
COUNTY DIRECTLY TO THE NORTH OF
01:43:03.110 --> 01:43:04.711
MARIN. THE FIRE BURNED FROM
01:43:04.778 --> 01:43:05.212
OCTOBER TWENTY THIRD TO
01:43:05.279 --> 01:43:08.081
NOVEMBER SIXTH. IN A FIRE IN
01:43:08.148 --> 01:43:09.283
THE P. S. P. S. MARIN COUNTY
01:43:09.349 --> 01:43:11.718
PROVIDED MUTUALLY TO CINEMA IN
01:43:11.785 --> 01:43:12.352
VARIOUS FORMS INCLUDING
01:43:12.419 --> 01:43:15.789
PROVIDING MASCARA SHELTER- TO
01:43:15.856 --> 01:43:17.558
ALMOST FIVE HUNDRED PEOPLE IN
01:43:17.624 --> 01:43:18.825
OUR MARIN CENTER AT THE
01:43:18.892 --> 01:43:21.228
FAIRGROUNDS. THOSE PEOPLE AND
01:43:21.295 --> 01:43:23.463
PETS QUITE OPERATION OUR COUNTY
01:43:23.530 --> 01:43:25.265
EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER WAS
01:43:25.332 --> 01:43:26.800
ACTIVATED DURING THE DURATION
01:43:26.867 --> 01:43:29.036
OF THE FIRE AND THE P. S. P. S.
01:43:29.102 --> 01:43:31.505
AND IN OUR FUNCTION IS TO
01:43:31.572 --> 01:43:32.906
SUPPORT FIELD OPERATIONS AND
01:43:32.973 --> 01:43:36.543
COORDINATE RESOURCES WHICH WE
01:43:36.610 --> 01:43:37.110
WERE DOING FOR VIRTUALLY TO
01:43:37.177 --> 01:43:38.979
DISASTERS. AND I WILL TELL YOU
01:43:39.046 --> 01:43:40.380
THAT THE LACK OF POWER IN THE
01:43:40.447 --> 01:43:42.282
LACK OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS MADE
01:43:42.349 --> 01:43:43.283
IT MORE DIFFICULT TO MANAGE THE
01:43:43.350 --> 01:43:44.952
SHELTER OPERATION THAN THAN
01:43:45.018 --> 01:43:47.020
WE'VE EVER SEEN EVEN MORE SO
01:43:47.087 --> 01:43:48.956
THAN. TWENTY SEVENTEEN WHEN WE
01:43:49.022 --> 01:43:51.925
DID THAT. THE SAME THING.
01:43:51.992 --> 01:43:53.727
WITHIN A DAY OF THE PSP AS WE
01:43:53.794 --> 01:43:54.094
STARTED LOSING
01:43:54.161 --> 01:43:55.362
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICE
01:43:55.429 --> 01:43:57.097
THROUGHOUT MARIN. THIS SERVICE
01:43:57.164 --> 01:43:58.198
DISRUPTION WAS ACROSS THE
01:43:58.265 --> 01:44:00.100
SPECTRUM. AS WE TALKED ABOUT
01:44:00.167 --> 01:44:02.135
ALREADY TODAY WIRELESS VOICE
01:44:02.202 --> 01:44:03.570
AND DATA WAS EITHER SLOW OR
01:44:03.637 --> 01:44:06.340
NONEXISTENT. CABLE TV VOICE
01:44:06.406 --> 01:44:07.774
OVER INTERNET PROTOCOL IN
01:44:07.841 --> 01:44:09.509
INTERNET WAS OUT. WIRED AND
01:44:09.576 --> 01:44:11.144
FIRED FIBER LINE PHONES AND
01:44:11.211 --> 01:44:13.213
DATA WAS ALSO OUT OF VERY SLOW.
01:44:13.280 --> 01:44:14.681
WE'VE ALWAYS BEEN TOLD THE
01:44:14.748 --> 01:44:15.949
TRADITIONAL COPPER LINE
01:44:16.016 --> 01:44:17.317
TELEPHONE WOULD NEVER GO DOWN
01:44:17.384 --> 01:44:19.019
AND MERGING SEE YET THAT WAS
01:44:19.086 --> 01:44:20.053
NOT OUR EXPERIENCE AND I WAS
01:44:20.120 --> 01:44:21.622
NOT THE EXPERIENCE OF OUR
01:44:21.688 --> 01:44:23.056
RESIDENTS. MY OWN HOME WAS IT
01:44:23.123 --> 01:44:26.727
HAS A- COPPER LINE. PHONE AND
01:44:26.793 --> 01:44:27.995
IT WAS OUT FOR A WEEK SO THAT
01:44:28.061 --> 01:44:29.863
WAS NOT GOOD- THE EDGES
01:44:29.930 --> 01:44:32.466
CONTINUED FOR SEVERAL DAYS
01:44:32.532 --> 01:44:32.966
UNTIL THE PSP HAS POWER
01:44:33.033 --> 01:44:35.035
RESTORATION BEGAN. WE DID HAVE
01:44:35.102 --> 01:44:37.237
SOME CONTACTS WITH THE INDUSTRY
01:44:37.304 --> 01:44:39.673
SERVICE PROVIDERS- WE MADE
01:44:39.740 --> 01:44:41.274
CONTACT WITH SOME OF THEM BUT
01:44:41.341 --> 01:44:42.542
BASIC OF IT THE RESPONSE THAT
01:44:42.609 --> 01:44:44.645
WE GOT WAS- YOU'RE GONNA GET
01:44:44.711 --> 01:44:47.147
YOUR SERVICE BACK ON WHEN THE
01:44:47.214 --> 01:44:47.714
POWER COMES BACK ON BECAUSE
01:44:47.781 --> 01:44:50.217
WE'RE POWER DEPENDENT TO. SO
01:44:50.283 --> 01:44:51.885
WHAT WERE THE IMPACTS TO PUBLIC
01:44:51.952 --> 01:44:53.854
pSAFETY AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE
01:44:53.920 --> 01:44:55.722
I'D LIKE TO SHARE SOME OF OUR
01:44:55.789 --> 01:44:56.256
DIRECT EXPERIENCES IN THE
01:44:56.323 --> 01:44:59.226
COUNTY. AS I SAID OUR ROLE THAT
01:44:59.292 --> 01:45:00.927
COUNTY OFFICE OF EMERGENCY
01:45:00.994 --> 01:45:01.795
SERVICES DURING THE RESPONSE
01:45:01.862 --> 01:45:03.830
PHASE OF ANY DISASTER IS TO
01:45:03.897 --> 01:45:05.232
SUPPORT FIELD OPERATIONS
01:45:05.298 --> 01:45:07.434
COORDINATOR RESOURCES FROM OUR-
01:45:07.501 --> 01:45:09.670
EOC AND ELSEWHERE CAN SHARE
01:45:09.736 --> 01:45:12.539
INFORMATION. TWO OF OUR KEY
01:45:12.606 --> 01:45:13.940
FUNCTIONS ARE ALERT AND
01:45:14.007 --> 01:45:16.143
WARNING. AND PUBLIC INFORMATION
01:45:16.209 --> 01:45:19.079
DISSEMINATION. WE USE MANY
01:45:19.146 --> 01:45:21.348
DIFFERENT SYSTEMS AND PASSED TO
01:45:21.415 --> 01:45:21.982
WARN AND SHARE INFORMATION WITH
01:45:22.049 --> 01:45:24.418
THE PUBLIC. NOW IT IS A
01:45:24.484 --> 01:45:26.053
MAJORITY OF THESE SYSTEMS RELY
01:45:26.119 --> 01:45:29.022
ON TELECOMMUNICATIONS. WHEN
01:45:29.089 --> 01:45:30.791
THEY'RE NOT WORKING WE CANNOT
01:45:30.857 --> 01:45:31.358
WARN THE PUBLIC OF IMPENDING
01:45:31.425 --> 01:45:34.795
DANGER. LIKEWISE THE PUBLIC MAY
01:45:34.861 --> 01:45:35.429
NOT BE ABLE TO CALL OR TEXT FOR
01:45:35.495 --> 01:45:38.565
HELP. WHEN TELECOMMUNICATIONS
01:45:38.632 --> 01:45:40.600
SYSTEMS ARE DOWN WE ALSO CANNOT
01:45:40.667 --> 01:45:42.836
COMMUNICATE EFFECTIVELY WITH
01:45:42.903 --> 01:45:43.637
ALL THE PUBLIC SET TO RESPOND
01:45:43.704 --> 01:45:45.539
HERS SO THAT'S WITHIN OUR
01:45:45.605 --> 01:45:47.974
INDUSTRY SO TO SPEAK. AND THOSE
01:45:48.041 --> 01:45:50.644
ASSISTING RESPOND HERS. WE ALSO
01:45:50.711 --> 01:45:52.412
RELIANT TELECOMMUNICATIONS FOR
01:45:52.479 --> 01:45:55.749
SITUATIONAL AWARENESS RESOURCE
01:45:55.816 --> 01:45:56.783
MANAGEMENT. AND A COMMON
01:45:56.850 --> 01:45:58.719
OPERATING PICTURE. BY THE
01:45:58.785 --> 01:46:00.220
SYSTEM THAT WE USE IN
01:46:00.287 --> 01:46:03.056
CONJUNCTION WITH CALLAWAY US-
01:46:03.123 --> 01:46:04.424
AND EVEN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
01:46:04.491 --> 01:46:05.992
IS A SYSTEM CALLED LIBYA SEE
01:46:06.059 --> 01:46:08.628
KALLIO SEE FOR THE STATE- YOU
01:46:08.695 --> 01:46:10.263
KNOW THAT SYSTEM. IS
01:46:10.330 --> 01:46:11.031
INTERCONNECTED WITH THE STATE
01:46:11.098 --> 01:46:13.366
AND THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT- AND
01:46:13.433 --> 01:46:13.900
FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGERS
01:46:13.967 --> 01:46:16.136
THROUGH THE INTERNET. SO THESE
01:46:16.203 --> 01:46:18.138
SERVICES ARE PROVIDED BY TELL
01:46:18.205 --> 01:46:19.372
COMMUNITY TELECOMMUNICATION
01:46:19.439 --> 01:46:22.476
COMPANIES. I AND WE NEED THIS
01:46:22.542 --> 01:46:23.043
IS SERVICE TO BE RELIANT AND
01:46:23.110 --> 01:46:27.180
REDUNDANT. YOU KNOW I REALLY
01:46:27.247 --> 01:46:29.015
HAVE KIND OF A TOP THREE-
01:46:29.082 --> 01:46:31.418
IMPACTS MAJOR IMPACTS OF THESE
01:46:31.485 --> 01:46:33.587
OF THESE OUTAGES AND I MAY HAVE
01:46:33.653 --> 01:46:35.155
MENTIONED SOME OF THEM A NUMBER
01:46:35.222 --> 01:46:35.756
ONE REALLY IS PUBLIC SAFETY
01:46:35.822 --> 01:46:37.924
COMMUNICATIONS. YOU KNOW WE
01:46:37.991 --> 01:46:39.726
HAVE RADIOS IN THOSE ARE
01:46:39.793 --> 01:46:41.862
pALL THE OTHER
01:46:41.928 --> 01:46:43.497
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES FOR
01:46:43.563 --> 01:46:45.098
COMMUNICATING WITH PUBLIC
01:46:45.165 --> 01:46:46.600
SAFETY AND THROUGHOUT FROM EOC
01:46:46.666 --> 01:46:48.635
AND IN THE FIELD. THE LACK OF
01:46:48.702 --> 01:46:50.270
WIRED AND CELLULAR BASE VOICE
01:46:50.337 --> 01:46:52.873
SMS AND DATA COMMUNICATIONS AND
01:46:52.939 --> 01:46:54.441
SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTED PUBLIC
01:46:54.508 --> 01:46:56.810
SAFETY IS ABILITY TO
01:46:56.877 --> 01:46:57.310
COMMUNICATE. AND PROVIDE
01:46:57.377 --> 01:47:00.113
CRITICAL SERVICES. NOWADAYS
01:47:00.180 --> 01:47:03.183
MANY IMPOSED A MANY POLICE AND
01:47:03.250 --> 01:47:04.751
FIRE AGENCIES USE MOBILE DATA
01:47:04.818 --> 01:47:07.020
TERMINALS. THERE OFTEN THEY'RE
01:47:07.087 --> 01:47:08.555
ALSO KNOWN AS ENTITIES. AND
01:47:08.622 --> 01:47:10.824
THESE RUN ON CELLULAR DATA-
01:47:10.891 --> 01:47:12.425
ALSO MORE AND MORE AGENCIES ARE
01:47:12.492 --> 01:47:15.128
USING SMART PHONE BASED APPS
01:47:15.195 --> 01:47:16.329
FOR THINGS LIKE DATABASE CHECKS
01:47:16.396 --> 01:47:18.865
FOR. CRIMINALS ARE SUSPECTS LOS
01:47:18.932 --> 01:47:21.201
PERSONS AND MEDICAL REPORTING
01:47:21.268 --> 01:47:23.937
TO RECEIVING HOSPITALS. THE
01:47:24.004 --> 01:47:24.971
SECOND AND PROBABLY THE MORE
01:47:25.038 --> 01:47:26.706
IMPORTANT- OF FACTS NEGATIVE
01:47:26.773 --> 01:47:27.974
EFFECT OF THE LACK OF
01:47:28.041 --> 01:47:29.576
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES IS
01:47:29.643 --> 01:47:33.180
THE LACK OF OUR ABILITY TO WARN
01:47:33.246 --> 01:47:33.713
IN INFORM THOSE WITHIN OUR
01:47:33.780 --> 01:47:37.617
COUNTY. WITH NO OR DEGRADED
01:47:37.684 --> 01:47:38.752
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES
01:47:38.819 --> 01:47:40.587
WERE NOT ABLE TO WARN OR INFORM
01:47:40.654 --> 01:47:42.823
THE PUBLIC VIA PHONE CALL TEXT
01:47:42.889 --> 01:47:46.092
EMAIL OR WEBSITE. MANY OF OUR
01:47:46.159 --> 01:47:48.094
SYSTEM SUCH AS WHAT WE CALL
01:47:48.161 --> 01:47:50.330
MORAN WHICH IS A REVERSE NINE
01:47:50.397 --> 01:47:52.332
ONE ONE SYSTEM- OR IN ANOTHER
01:47:52.399 --> 01:47:53.066
SYSTEM THAT WE USE WHICH IS AN
01:47:53.133 --> 01:47:55.535
EXCELLENT SURE MOST OF YOU ARE
01:47:55.602 --> 01:47:58.605
AWARE THAT THEY RELY ON VOICE
01:47:58.672 --> 01:48:01.141
SMS EMAIL. APPLE OR OR A LINK
01:48:01.208 --> 01:48:01.775
TO A WEBSITE TO PROVIDE FURTHER
01:48:01.842 --> 01:48:05.378
INFORMATION. DURING THE RECENT
01:48:05.445 --> 01:48:06.313
PS PS IS THAT OF AND
01:48:06.379 --> 01:48:07.881
TELECOMMUNICATION FAILURES IT
01:48:07.948 --> 01:48:10.317
AT THE END OF LAST YEAR. THE
01:48:10.383 --> 01:48:12.419
MOST COMMON CONCERN AND
01:48:12.485 --> 01:48:12.953
FEEDBACK THAT WE GOT FROM
01:48:13.019 --> 01:48:15.055
PEOPLE IN MARIN COUNTY WAS. AND
01:48:15.121 --> 01:48:16.957
THEY WERE PUBLIC YEAH CONSUMERS
01:48:17.023 --> 01:48:18.291
OF OUR NEXT TO MESSAGES ON OUR
01:48:18.358 --> 01:48:20.694
OTHER FRIEND MESSAGES WAS.
01:48:20.760 --> 01:48:21.962
YOU'RE SENDING US INFORMATION
01:48:22.028 --> 01:48:23.530
SOMETIMES THE TEXAS GETTING
01:48:23.597 --> 01:48:24.698
THROUGH BUT WE OFTEN INCLUDE A
01:48:24.764 --> 01:48:27.267
LINK TO A WEBSITE AND OF COURSE
01:48:27.334 --> 01:48:27.868
WITH THE INTERNET DOWN THEY
01:48:27.934 --> 01:48:29.436
WERE UNABLE TO GET THAT FOR
01:48:29.502 --> 01:48:30.804
THEIR INFORMATION. THAT WAS THE
01:48:30.871 --> 01:48:32.472
NUMBER ONE. FEEDBACK THAT WE
01:48:32.539 --> 01:48:34.241
GOT- SO WE MADE SOME CHANGES
01:48:34.307 --> 01:48:35.642
BASED ON THAT BUT BUT THEN
01:48:35.709 --> 01:48:37.811
AGAIN WE NEED THAT TOOL TO BE
01:48:37.878 --> 01:48:38.245
ABLE TO PROVIDE FULL
01:48:38.311 --> 01:48:41.481
INFORMATION BASICALLY THEY WERE
01:48:41.548 --> 01:48:43.216
UNABLE TO OPEN THOSE LINKS ON
01:48:43.283 --> 01:48:45.085
THERE. THERE'S SOLD THEIR
01:48:45.151 --> 01:48:45.719
MOBILE DEVICES BECAUSE THE CELL
01:48:45.785 --> 01:48:48.555
TOWERS ARE DOWN. AND THEN THE
01:48:48.622 --> 01:48:52.359
THIRD. MOST IMPORTANT- FACTS-
01:48:52.425 --> 01:48:53.760
AND IT'S RELATED TO YOU KNOW
01:48:53.827 --> 01:48:55.395
MESSAGING THE PUBLIC OF COURSE
01:48:55.462 --> 01:48:58.565
IS THE INABILITY TO SEND- WE AS
01:48:58.632 --> 01:49:00.066
A WIRELESS EMERGENCY ALERTS AND
01:49:00.133 --> 01:49:01.568
I'M HIGHLIGHTING NOW WHEN
01:49:01.635 --> 01:49:02.502
BECAUSE THAT'S ONE OF OUR
01:49:02.569 --> 01:49:04.905
GREATEST TOOLS- THERE'S A REAL
01:49:04.971 --> 01:49:06.640
DIFFERENCE IN THE TOOLS THAT WE
01:49:06.706 --> 01:49:09.242
USE FOR ALERTING THE PUBLIC-
01:49:09.309 --> 01:49:10.844
THERE'S THE OLD. DIFFERENCE
01:49:10.911 --> 01:49:13.647
BETWEEN OPT IN OPT OUT SO WE IT
01:49:13.713 --> 01:49:16.449
IS NOT AN OPT IN SYSTEM SO WE
01:49:16.516 --> 01:49:18.518
CAN REACH THE MOST PEOPLE YOU
01:49:18.585 --> 01:49:19.252
KNOW AS LONG AS THEY COME INTO
01:49:19.319 --> 01:49:20.687
THAT GEOGRAPHIC AREA THAT WE
01:49:20.754 --> 01:49:22.455
TARGETED AND THEY HAVE THEIR
01:49:22.522 --> 01:49:23.957
MOBILE DEVICE ON. WE'RE GOING
01:49:24.024 --> 01:49:26.626
TO GET A MESSAGE TO THEM. AS
01:49:26.693 --> 01:49:27.260
LONG AS THOSE CELL PHONE TOWERS
01:49:27.327 --> 01:49:30.297
A RAP THIS SYSTEM REQUIRES THE
01:49:30.363 --> 01:49:30.931
MOBILE WIRELESS TOWERS ARE UP
01:49:30.997 --> 01:49:32.933
AND RUNNING. THIS IS IMPORTANT
01:49:32.999 --> 01:49:34.634
NOW MORE THAN EVER GIVEN THE
01:49:34.701 --> 01:49:35.835
FACT THAT MOST MEMBERS OF THE
01:49:35.902 --> 01:49:36.870
PUBLIC HAVE GIVEN UP THEIR WIRE
01:49:36.937 --> 01:49:39.072
LINE PHONES. IN FAVOR OF
01:49:39.139 --> 01:49:41.641
WIRELESS. AS I SAID BEFORE THIS
01:49:41.708 --> 01:49:44.411
IS REALLY ONE OF OUR BEST A
01:49:44.477 --> 01:49:45.011
WARNING OPTIONS GIVEN ITS NON
01:49:45.078 --> 01:49:48.415
OPT IN NATURE. SO IF YOU WELL
01:49:48.481 --> 01:49:49.349
I'D LIKE TO MENTION A FEW
01:49:49.416 --> 01:49:50.817
THINGS WHEN SOMETHING'S A WE'D
01:49:50.884 --> 01:49:52.886
LIKE TO SEE GOING FORWARD SOME
01:49:52.953 --> 01:49:54.254
SOME TOOLS SOME CHANGES SOME
01:49:54.321 --> 01:49:55.588
MAY BE IN A BETTER
01:49:55.655 --> 01:49:57.857
RELATIONSHIP. WHATEVER THAT WE
01:49:57.924 --> 01:50:00.260
NEED TO DO- TO DO A BETTER JOB.
01:50:00.327 --> 01:50:02.829
HELLO YES CAN DO A BETTER JOB
01:50:02.896 --> 01:50:04.130
IT'S BEEN STATED BEFORE
01:50:04.197 --> 01:50:05.699
EMERGENCY MANAGERS NEED TO
01:50:05.765 --> 01:50:07.600
CONSISTENT. AVAILABLE
01:50:07.667 --> 01:50:10.170
KNOWLEDGEABLE CONTACT TO G.
01:50:10.236 --> 01:50:10.570
WITH EACH OF THE
01:50:10.637 --> 01:50:13.506
TELECOMMUNICATION PROVIDERS.
01:50:13.573 --> 01:50:14.107
THAT WAY WE GET THE UP TO DATE
01:50:14.174 --> 01:50:16.276
AND ACCURATE INFORMATION.
01:50:16.343 --> 01:50:17.944
NUMBER TWO EMERGENCY MANAGERS
01:50:18.011 --> 01:50:18.545
NEED TO KNOW WHERE CELL PHONE
01:50:18.611 --> 01:50:21.548
TOWERS ARE LOCATED. I KNOW
01:50:21.614 --> 01:50:22.349
THAT'S A STRUGGLE I KNOW IT'S
01:50:22.415 --> 01:50:24.651
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION WHAT WE
01:50:24.718 --> 01:50:26.219
WANT TO DO IS TO BE ABLE TO
01:50:26.286 --> 01:50:28.088
ENSURE THAT OUR MESSAGES THAT
01:50:28.154 --> 01:50:28.755
WERE SENDING OUT ARE
01:50:28.822 --> 01:50:31.624
DISTRIBUTED. TO AN AREA THAT
01:50:31.691 --> 01:50:32.892
NEEDS POTENTIALLY LIFESAVING
01:50:32.959 --> 01:50:36.463
NOTIFICATIONS WE SEND OUT
01:50:36.529 --> 01:50:37.097
NOTIFICATIONS ABOUT EVACUATIONS
01:50:37.163 --> 01:50:39.933
IN SHELTERS IN PLACE. IN THE
01:50:40.000 --> 01:50:40.734
TWENTY SEVENTEEN FAR AS WE WERE
01:50:40.800 --> 01:50:42.035
ONE OF THE FEW COUNTIES IS SEND
01:50:42.102 --> 01:50:43.837
OUT A WE- TO THE PEOPLE THAT
01:50:43.903 --> 01:50:45.138
WERE SCAPIN CINNAMON COMING
01:50:45.205 --> 01:50:45.672
DOWN INTO MARIN. FOR KAREN
01:50:45.739 --> 01:50:49.576
SHELTER. WELL WE KNOW FROM
01:50:49.642 --> 01:50:52.178
EXPERIENCE AND STORIES- THAT IS
01:50:52.245 --> 01:50:54.147
CURRENTLY POSSIBLE TO SEND A WE
01:50:54.214 --> 01:50:55.582
ARE WITHOUT ACTUALLY GOING TO
01:50:55.648 --> 01:50:58.284
THE PUBLIC. BY INADVERTENTLY
01:50:58.351 --> 01:50:59.452
GEO LOCATING A TARGET AREA FOR
01:50:59.519 --> 01:51:01.788
A MESSAGE. THAT DOES NOT
01:51:01.855 --> 01:51:03.023
CONTAIN ANY TOWERS WITHIN THAT
01:51:03.089 --> 01:51:04.824
GEO LOCATED AREA. IT'S ACTUALLY
01:51:04.891 --> 01:51:07.527
OCCURRED IN THE STATE. SO IF WE
01:51:07.594 --> 01:51:08.928
HAVE THAT INFORMATION WE COULD
01:51:08.995 --> 01:51:11.464
ACT ACCORDINGLY. IN TERMS OF
01:51:11.531 --> 01:51:13.199
KNOWING WHICH TOOL TO USE TO
01:51:13.266 --> 01:51:15.368
THE WAR TO WARN THE PUBLIC.
01:51:15.435 --> 01:51:17.170
THIRDLY EMERGENCY MANAGERS NEED
01:51:17.237 --> 01:51:19.072
TO KNOW THE STATUS OF STE
01:51:19.139 --> 01:51:21.541
CELLULAR SMS- WIRELESS
01:51:21.608 --> 01:51:23.209
EMERGENCY ALERTS AND DATA
01:51:23.276 --> 01:51:23.843
FUNCTIONALITY OF EACH PROVIDER
01:51:23.910 --> 01:51:26.312
SYSTEM BY TARYN AREA. IN ORDER
01:51:26.379 --> 01:51:27.781
TO UNDERSTAND WHAT PUBLIC
01:51:27.847 --> 01:51:29.115
ALERTING OPTIONS ARE AVAILABLE
01:51:29.182 --> 01:51:32.218
DURING EMERGENCY WE WILL SHIFT
01:51:32.285 --> 01:51:33.253
OUR ACTIONS BASED ON WHAT WE
01:51:33.319 --> 01:51:35.422
KNOW. IS CAPABLE OF GETTING THE
01:51:35.488 --> 01:51:38.291
MESSAGE OUT. I NUMBER FOR
01:51:38.358 --> 01:51:40.160
EMERGENCY MANAGERS NEED BILL AN
01:51:40.226 --> 01:51:41.661
ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER OF
01:51:41.728 --> 01:51:43.029
CELLULAR CUSTOMERS FOR
01:51:43.096 --> 01:51:44.731
INCLUSION IN REVERSE NINE ONE
01:51:44.798 --> 01:51:46.299
ONE SYSTEMS. CURRENTLY WE CAN
01:51:46.366 --> 01:51:47.567
GET THAT DATA FOR PLAIN OLD
01:51:47.634 --> 01:51:49.702
TELEPHONE LINES WHICH WE GET
01:51:49.769 --> 01:51:51.571
FROM COMPANIES LIKE COMCAST-
01:51:51.638 --> 01:51:53.440
FRONTIER- FOR YOU KNOW THOSE
01:51:53.506 --> 01:51:55.408
THOSE WIRED PHONES WE POPULATE
01:51:55.475 --> 01:51:57.610
THAT IN OUR SYSTEM- AND THAT
01:51:57.677 --> 01:51:59.345
WAY WE CAN CALL THOSE NUMBERS
01:51:59.412 --> 01:52:00.647
IN EVENT OF EMERGENCY WE
01:52:00.713 --> 01:52:02.482
CURRENTLY CAN I GET THAT FOR.
01:52:02.549 --> 01:52:03.616
FOR CELL PHONE SO THEY HAVE TO
01:52:03.683 --> 01:52:05.618
OPT INTO OUR SYSTEM AND QUITE
01:52:05.685 --> 01:52:07.854
HONESTLY THAT'S THE STRUGGLE OF
01:52:07.921 --> 01:52:08.655
MOST OF THE COUNTIES IN THE
01:52:08.721 --> 01:52:11.124
STATE VERY AVERAGE SOMEWHERE
01:52:11.191 --> 01:52:14.694
AROUND TEN TO TWENTY PERCENT-
01:52:14.761 --> 01:52:15.428
YOU KNOW OPT IN WHICH IS PRETTY
01:52:15.495 --> 01:52:19.265
LOW- WE CAN DO WE CONSTANTLY
01:52:19.332 --> 01:52:19.833
MARKET OUR SYSTEM BUT WE'RE
01:52:19.899 --> 01:52:20.467
RELYING ON PEOPLE DOING THAT ON
01:52:20.533 --> 01:52:23.503
AROUND. FIFTH WE WOULD LIKE TO
01:52:23.570 --> 01:52:24.104
KNOW THE EXPECTED UP TIME AND
01:52:24.170 --> 01:52:24.771
FUNCTIONALITY OF CELLULAR SITES
01:52:24.838 --> 01:52:26.906
FOR PLANNING PURPOSES. AND THEN
01:52:26.973 --> 01:52:28.274
NEED AS CLOSE TO REAL TIME AS
01:52:28.341 --> 01:52:29.909
POSSIBLE INFORMATION AN ACTUAL
01:52:29.976 --> 01:52:32.245
UPTIME AND FUNCTIONALITY DURING
01:52:32.312 --> 01:52:32.812
EMERGENCY. I BELIEVE THAT'S
01:52:32.879 --> 01:52:35.448
BEEN STATED BEFORE. IN ADDITION
01:52:35.515 --> 01:52:36.783
TO WIRELESS AND CELLULAR WE'D
01:52:36.850 --> 01:52:38.051
LIKE TO KNOW THE EXPECTED UP
01:52:38.118 --> 01:52:39.319
TIME OF WIRELINE PHONE
01:52:39.385 --> 01:52:40.820
INFRASTRUCTURE AN ACTUAL UP
01:52:40.887 --> 01:52:41.921
TIME AND FUNCTIONALITY DURING
01:52:41.988 --> 01:52:43.957
EMERGENCY. AS WE DISCOVERED IN
01:52:44.023 --> 01:52:45.859
OCTOBER TWENTY NINETEEN MUCH OF
01:52:45.925 --> 01:52:48.361
THE WIRELESS SYSTEM NOW DEPENDS
01:52:48.428 --> 01:52:48.962
ON CONTINUOUS POWER OUTSIDE OF
01:52:49.028 --> 01:52:51.397
THE RESIDENCE. DURING THE
01:52:51.464 --> 01:52:52.332
OCTOBER TWENTY NINETEEN NOW
01:52:52.398 --> 01:52:54.167
JUST OUTAGES IT BECAME CLEAR
01:52:54.234 --> 01:52:56.169
THAT DATA COMMUNICATION TO SELL
01:52:56.236 --> 01:52:57.370
SITES IS ALSO A WEAK LINK THIS
01:52:57.437 --> 01:52:59.005
IS ALREADY BEEN DISCUSSED. WE
01:52:59.072 --> 01:53:01.141
NEED TO KNOW THE EXACT EXPECTED
01:53:01.207 --> 01:53:03.076
IMPACT OF POWER FAILURES AND
01:53:03.143 --> 01:53:04.611
ALSO NON POWER RELATED
01:53:04.677 --> 01:53:06.579
COMMUNICATION FAILURES ON THE
01:53:06.646 --> 01:53:07.046
WIRELESS AND CELLULAR
01:53:07.113 --> 01:53:11.951
INFRASTRUCTURE. FINALLY SO
01:53:12.018 --> 01:53:13.620
YOU'RE SITES NEED TO HAVE MUCH
01:53:13.686 --> 01:53:15.088
MUCH BETTER RESILIENCE TO POWER
01:53:15.155 --> 01:53:16.122
FAILURES THIS IS ALREADY BEEN
01:53:16.189 --> 01:53:18.591
DISCUSSED- THIS IS THE
01:53:18.658 --> 01:53:19.859
INFRASTRUCTURE THAT THE PUBLIC
01:53:19.926 --> 01:53:21.461
DEPENDS ON FOR POTENTIALLY LIFE
01:53:21.528 --> 01:53:22.962
SAVING. NINE ONE ONE
01:53:23.029 --> 01:53:24.030
COMMUNICATIONS WITH PUBLIC
01:53:24.097 --> 01:53:26.299
SAFETY FOR MEDICAL FIRE AND LAW
01:53:26.366 --> 01:53:35.041
ENFORCEMENT NEEDS. THANK YOU
01:53:35.108 --> 01:53:35.608
NOW WE'RE GONNA GO TO CENTER
01:53:35.675 --> 01:53:42.649
MORE LET. THANK YOU MEDICARE.
01:53:42.715 --> 01:53:43.683
MR KILLER DUDE SHE HAVE THE
01:53:43.750 --> 01:53:44.284
CHAIR OF THE COMMITTEE WOULD
01:53:44.350 --> 01:53:46.619
LIKE TO GIVE YOU A PROCLAMATION
01:53:46.686 --> 01:53:48.188
FOR HAVING PRESENTED AT THE
01:53:48.254 --> 01:53:49.989
MOST HEARINGS IN THE LAST THREE
01:53:50.056 --> 01:53:53.660
YEARS YOU. IT'S A DIRECT
01:53:53.726 --> 01:53:54.227
CORRELATION TO THE NUMBER OF
01:53:54.294 --> 01:53:59.599
DISASTERS WE. BUT I THINK MISS
01:53:59.666 --> 01:54:01.935
BADGERS A CATCHING UP TO YEAH
01:54:02.001 --> 01:54:03.002
SO SHOULD BE AN INTERESTING
01:54:03.069 --> 01:54:05.605
RACE- I WANT TO GET BACK TO A
01:54:05.672 --> 01:54:07.240
MISTRIAL YOU IF YOU HAD A- USE
01:54:07.307 --> 01:54:09.075
THE TERM EMERGENCY MANAGERS.
01:54:09.142 --> 01:54:11.110
AND I'M CONCERNED ABOUT PUBLIC
01:54:11.177 --> 01:54:13.646
SAFETY COMMUNICATION AS WELL
01:54:13.713 --> 01:54:16.482
PEOPLE AREN'T. ABLE TO CONTACT.
01:54:16.549 --> 01:54:17.383
HE'S DEPARTMENTS AND FIRE
01:54:17.450 --> 01:54:18.551
DEPARTMENTS FIRE DEPARTMENTS
01:54:18.618 --> 01:54:19.719
AND POLICE DEPARTMENTS AB
01:54:19.786 --> 01:54:21.621
HAVING TROUBLE AS WELL JUST
01:54:21.688 --> 01:54:23.456
COMMUNICATINGOF THEMSELVES
01:54:23.523 --> 01:54:26.593
WITH EACH OTHER IN ORANGE
01:54:26.659 --> 01:54:27.227
COUNTY WE HAVE AN EIGHT HUNDRED
01:54:27.293 --> 01:54:28.761
MEGAHERTZ SYSTEM. BUT A BIG
01:54:28.828 --> 01:54:29.996
TOWER ON CATALINA ISLAND SO
01:54:30.063 --> 01:54:31.264
THAT WE COULD TRY AND MAKE SURE
01:54:31.331 --> 01:54:32.966
WE COULD COMMUNICATE I'M JUST
01:54:33.032 --> 01:54:34.634
CURIOUS. HOW HOW WAS THE
01:54:34.701 --> 01:54:36.803
COMMUNICATION BETWEEN YOUR
01:54:36.869 --> 01:54:38.805
PUBLIC SAFETY OFFICIALS DURING
01:54:38.871 --> 01:54:42.175
THESE- DISASTERS. IT WAS GOOD I
01:54:42.242 --> 01:54:44.110
MEAN WEEK WE CAN RELY ON OUR-
01:54:44.177 --> 01:54:45.778
MORE IN EMERGENCY RADIO AS A
01:54:45.845 --> 01:54:47.413
SYSTEM AND WE'RE ACTUALLY IN
01:54:47.480 --> 01:54:48.982
THE MIDDLE OF A- NEXT
01:54:49.048 --> 01:54:50.516
GENERATION BUILD OUT OF THAT
01:54:50.583 --> 01:54:52.518
SYSTEM SO IN TERMS OF. THE
01:54:52.585 --> 01:54:53.820
ABILITY TO COMMUNICATE OVER
01:54:53.886 --> 01:54:56.322
RADIOS IT WAS FINE I MEAN
01:54:56.389 --> 01:54:57.390
THAT'S A REALLY GOOD SYSTEM AND
01:54:57.457 --> 01:54:59.826
WORKED WELL- I WAS IN THE A. C.
01:54:59.892 --> 01:55:03.229
FOR. ALMOST A WEEK DURING THE
01:55:03.296 --> 01:55:06.165
POWER SHUTDOWNS AND YOU KNOW WE
01:55:06.232 --> 01:55:06.699
IT WAS A LOT OF DISCUSSION
01:55:06.766 --> 01:55:07.233
ABOUT THE LHASA
01:55:07.300 --> 01:55:10.036
TELECOMMUNICATIONS. BECAUSE
01:55:10.103 --> 01:55:11.804
QUITE HONESTLY A LOT OF THE-
01:55:11.871 --> 01:55:13.072
MANNER IN LAW AND FIRE THEY USE
01:55:13.139 --> 01:55:13.806
THEIR CELL PHONE TWO TO
01:55:13.873 --> 01:55:15.141
COMMUNICATE A LOT TO TAX TO
01:55:15.208 --> 01:55:17.343
TALK TO EACH OTHER. AND THEY
01:55:17.410 --> 01:55:20.813
WERE VERY FRUSTRATED BY THOSE
01:55:20.880 --> 01:55:21.414
OUTAGES SO THERE IS THAT THAT
01:55:21.481 --> 01:55:25.585
WAS IN EFFECT. MR KILLER DO G.
01:55:25.652 --> 01:55:28.554
STAY CALM IS THAT YOUR-
01:55:28.621 --> 01:55:29.155
COMMUNICATION SYSTEM FOR THAT
01:55:29.222 --> 01:55:32.091
FOR YES. STATE CONDE COM S.
01:55:32.158 --> 01:55:35.795
TACOM. I HAVE A NO I DON'T
01:55:35.862 --> 01:55:37.263
EITHER THAT BACK OFFICE OF
01:55:37.330 --> 01:55:38.498
EMERGENCY SERVICES STATE ME
01:55:38.564 --> 01:55:41.067
MUNICH CATIONS SYSTEM WELL WE
01:55:41.134 --> 01:55:42.468
HAVE THE STATE PUBLIC SAFETY
01:55:42.535 --> 01:55:43.436
COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM WHICH IS
01:55:43.503 --> 01:55:47.440
THE ENTIRE A BACKBONE OF ALL OF
01:55:47.507 --> 01:55:48.408
THE PUBLIC SAFETY
01:55:48.474 --> 01:55:49.742
COMMUNICATIONS IN THE STATE
01:55:49.809 --> 01:55:51.644
THAT THE NOT ONLY HANDLES ALL
01:55:51.711 --> 01:55:53.346
STATE AGENCIES BUT IS THE
01:55:53.413 --> 01:55:55.882
BACKBONE FOR SUPPORTING LOCAL
01:55:55.948 --> 01:55:57.417
GOVERNMENT ARE NINE ONE ONE
01:55:57.483 --> 01:55:59.819
CENTERS- EXCEPT YOURSELF IF
01:55:59.886 --> 01:56:00.386
THAT IS WHAT YOU'RE TALKING
01:56:00.453 --> 01:56:02.388
ABOUT THAT IS OUR- PROGRAM.
01:56:02.455 --> 01:56:04.057
IT'S NOT IT'S A HIGH FREQUENCY
01:56:04.123 --> 01:56:05.224
RADIO I'VE HIGH FREQUENCY WAY
01:56:05.291 --> 01:56:09.696
IT'S BOTH MICROWAVE AND- AND IT
01:56:09.762 --> 01:56:10.530
IS A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT
01:56:10.596 --> 01:56:12.365
CAPABILITIES ASSOCIATED WITH
01:56:12.432 --> 01:56:15.368
THAT THAT THAT THAT WORK. IN
01:56:15.435 --> 01:56:15.935
OUR I'M UNDER THE IMPRESSION
01:56:16.002 --> 01:56:18.571
THAT. OTHER LAW ENFORCEMENT
01:56:18.638 --> 01:56:19.739
AGENCIES ARE TRYING TO UPGRADE
01:56:19.806 --> 01:56:21.307
AND WORK ON THEIR HIGH
01:56:21.374 --> 01:56:23.376
FREQUENCY IN AND I HAVE A
01:56:23.443 --> 01:56:24.177
LETTER FROM THE SHERIFF OF LOS
01:56:24.243 --> 01:56:27.313
ANGELES COUNTY- CONCERNED
01:56:27.380 --> 01:56:30.616
ABOUT. SAY SHIP COM. OR URGENT
01:56:30.683 --> 01:56:33.519
LINK. I'M JUST WONDERING. HOW
01:56:33.586 --> 01:56:36.122
HOW ARE THAT THE PROCESS SEES
01:56:36.189 --> 01:56:36.789
FOR MAYBE IMPLEMENTING THIS
01:56:36.856 --> 01:56:38.424
TECHNOLOGY HOW'S IT COMING
01:56:38.491 --> 01:56:40.626
ALONG. SO WE GET A LOT OF
01:56:40.693 --> 01:56:43.529
DIFFERENT. UNDER STATE COME
01:56:43.596 --> 01:56:45.998
DOES WITH NEW AND INNOVATIVE
01:56:46.065 --> 01:56:48.101
CAPABILITIES WE DO PUT THEM
01:56:48.167 --> 01:56:49.168
THROUGH A PROCESS OF
01:56:49.235 --> 01:56:52.138
EVALUATION- VIRGIN LIKE IS ONE
01:56:52.205 --> 01:56:55.007
OF SEVERAL- THAT- BILLS IN A
01:56:55.074 --> 01:56:56.943
REDUNDANCY LAYS OVER THE TOP
01:56:57.009 --> 01:56:59.846
OF. THE SYSTEMS THAT WE HAVE BY
01:56:59.912 --> 01:57:00.847
THE WAY WE HAVE I SOMETHING
01:57:00.913 --> 01:57:03.850
LIKE SIX DIFFERENT REDUNDANT
01:57:03.916 --> 01:57:05.251
COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS TO ENSURE
01:57:05.318 --> 01:57:07.320
THAT WE CAN HAVE. PUBLIC SAFETY
01:57:07.387 --> 01:57:09.422
COMMUNICATIONS POINT THE POINT
01:57:09.489 --> 01:57:11.057
TO OUR LOCAL JURISDICTIONS TO
01:57:11.124 --> 01:57:12.558
OUR STATE AGENCIES THAT'S
01:57:12.625 --> 01:57:14.327
DIFFERENT BY THE WAY THEN
01:57:14.394 --> 01:57:16.696
PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS THAT IS
01:57:16.763 --> 01:57:18.531
PROVIDED BY THE PRIVATE SECTOR
01:57:18.598 --> 01:57:20.833
CELLULAR PROVIDERS. BUT FROM
01:57:20.900 --> 01:57:22.635
THE STANDPOINT OF STATE
01:57:22.702 --> 01:57:23.569
COMMUNICATIONS AND PUBLIC
01:57:23.636 --> 01:57:26.072
SAFETY WE DO LOOK AT ALL THOSE-
01:57:26.139 --> 01:57:27.440
URGENT LIKE A TO MY KNOWLEDGE
01:57:27.507 --> 01:57:28.908
IS ONE THAT WE HAVE ARE IN THE
01:57:28.975 --> 01:57:32.011
PROCESS OF EVALUATING- BUT IT
01:57:32.078 --> 01:57:34.514
IS AGAIN A SYSTEM THAT WILL BE
01:57:34.580 --> 01:57:36.716
IS OVER. AND IS THEREFORE A
01:57:36.783 --> 01:57:37.283
REDUNDANCY THANK YOU CENTER
01:57:37.350 --> 01:57:43.189
JACKSON. YES THANK YOU ALWAYS A
01:57:43.256 --> 01:57:44.490
PLEASURE TO SEE YOU DIRECTOR
01:57:44.557 --> 01:57:45.491
GIL INTO CHIU SPECIALLY WHEN
01:57:45.558 --> 01:57:46.259
THERE'S NOT A FIRE. GOING ON
01:57:46.325 --> 01:57:49.128
BUT IT IS ALWAYS A GOOD FEELING
01:57:49.195 --> 01:57:50.163
TO HAVE YOU THERE WHEN WE HAVE
01:57:50.229 --> 01:57:52.632
FIRES BECAUSE I. I THINK WE ALL
01:57:52.698 --> 01:57:53.633
I'M LOOKING AROUND THE ROOM
01:57:53.699 --> 01:57:55.735
MANY OF US HAVE HAD THAT
01:57:55.802 --> 01:57:56.936
EXPERIENCE AND WHEN YOU'RE IN
01:57:57.003 --> 01:57:58.905
THE ROOM- THIS IS IT ELEVATES
01:57:58.971 --> 01:58:00.673
SENT SENSE OF CONFIDENCE AND SO
01:58:00.740 --> 01:58:02.742
I APPRECIATE VERY MUCH THE- THE
01:58:02.809 --> 01:58:04.777
WORK YOU'VE DONE. AND THE FACT
01:58:04.844 --> 01:58:07.146
THAT YOU'VE CONTINUED TO DO IT-
01:58:07.213 --> 01:58:07.647
EVEN THOUGH YOU'VE BEEN
01:58:07.713 --> 01:58:10.383
THREATENING TO- TO START TAKING
01:58:10.450 --> 01:58:11.517
SOME NICE LONG WALKS ON THE
01:58:11.584 --> 01:58:13.619
BEACH FOR QUITE SOME TIME
01:58:13.686 --> 01:58:14.854
REALLY DO APPRECIATE YOUR
01:58:14.921 --> 01:58:16.689
CONTINUED. EFFORTS ON BEHALF OF
01:58:16.756 --> 01:58:19.926
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA- I
01:58:19.992 --> 01:58:22.895
WANT TO ASK YOU THE- QUESTION
01:58:22.962 --> 01:58:25.131
TO WHAT I ASKED THE CPUC- YOU
01:58:25.198 --> 01:58:27.099
AND I'VE TALKED FOR QUITE SOME
01:58:27.166 --> 01:58:29.335
TIME MY PARTICULAR INTEREST IS
01:58:29.402 --> 01:58:31.404
A CENTER. ARE DONE ON OUR
01:58:31.471 --> 01:58:34.707
MERCHANT SEALER TO STORMS- THE
01:58:34.774 --> 01:58:36.342
FACT THAT WE ARE IS THERE ARE
01:58:36.409 --> 01:58:39.679
THOSE. THOSE ARE LOOKS AT
01:58:39.745 --> 01:58:41.981
PHONES THAT ARE WITHIN THE-
01:58:42.048 --> 01:58:43.950
AWARE THERE IS THAT NEED TO BE
01:58:44.016 --> 01:58:44.450
WARNED ABOUT POTENTIAL.
01:58:44.517 --> 01:58:45.418
DISASTER AND THE FACT THAT IT
01:58:45.485 --> 01:58:46.719
IS BEEN VERY DIFFICULT TO GET
01:58:46.786 --> 01:58:50.089
OUR WIRELESS COMPANIES TO- TAKE
01:58:50.156 --> 01:58:51.190
SOME LEVEL OF RESPONSIBILITY OR
01:58:51.257 --> 01:58:52.692
OWNERSHIP OF THEIR-
01:58:52.758 --> 01:58:55.127
REQUIREMENTS AS AS PARTNERS IN
01:58:55.194 --> 01:58:57.263
THIS EFFORT. I AM PLEASED TO
01:58:57.330 --> 01:58:59.565
HEAR THAT THAT SEEMS TO BE
01:58:59.632 --> 01:59:01.901
INVOLVING- AYE AYE IT GIVES ME
01:59:01.968 --> 01:59:03.603
SOME CONFIDENCE IN SOME OF THE
01:59:03.669 --> 01:59:05.338
LEGISLATION THAT I AM DOING TO
01:59:05.404 --> 01:59:06.472
TRY TO ENSURE THAT THAT
01:59:06.539 --> 01:59:09.075
HAPPENS. BUT I WOULD LIKE TO
01:59:09.141 --> 01:59:12.612
HEAR FROM YOU- WHAT AUTHORITY
01:59:12.678 --> 01:59:14.947
YOU BELIEVE YOU NEED. TO
01:59:15.014 --> 01:59:17.116
CONTINUE A BOWL TO COLLECT THE
01:59:17.183 --> 01:59:18.751
INFORMATION FROM THE
01:59:18.818 --> 01:59:21.454
TELECOMMUNICATION COMPANIES. I
01:59:21.521 --> 01:59:23.689
AND- THIS REQUIRE THEIR
01:59:23.756 --> 01:59:25.157
PARTICIPATION IN SOME OF THESE
01:59:25.224 --> 01:59:27.593
COLLECTED SOLUTIONS. AS WELL AS
01:59:27.660 --> 01:59:28.594
IN THESE EMERGENCY ALERT
01:59:28.661 --> 01:59:33.966
SITUATIONS- WHAT. WHAT WE IS A
01:59:34.033 --> 01:59:36.903
LEGISLATURE CAN DO TO ASSIST
01:59:36.969 --> 01:59:39.472
YOU. AND NOT JUST. ASKING THE
01:59:39.539 --> 01:59:40.940
COMPANIES TO PARTICIPATE BUT TO
01:59:41.007 --> 01:59:42.008
FOR THEM TO REALIZE THAT THEY
01:59:42.074 --> 01:59:45.244
HAVE AN OBLIGATION. UNDER LAW
01:59:45.311 --> 01:59:46.846
TO PARTICIPATE AND TO HELP
01:59:46.913 --> 01:59:49.282
PROTECT PUBLIC SAFETY- AND ALSO
01:59:49.348 --> 01:59:51.784
TO KEEP OUR STATE GOING. DURING
01:59:51.851 --> 01:59:55.688
THESE PSP SNC ENTERING OUR-
01:59:55.755 --> 01:59:59.425
FIRES WHEN THE SYSTEMS ARE DOWN
01:59:59.492 --> 02:00:04.397
WHAT DO YOU NEED. THANK YOU FOR
02:00:04.463 --> 02:00:05.231
THE QUESTION AND COURSE THE
02:00:05.298 --> 02:00:07.333
SUPPORT BASE- IS PHENOMENAL
02:00:07.400 --> 02:00:09.368
FROM THE LEGISLATURE- I THINK
02:00:09.435 --> 02:00:10.069
YOU KNOW THERE'S A LOT THERE'S
02:00:10.136 --> 02:00:11.037
A LOT PROBABLY THE ANSWER THAT
02:00:11.103 --> 02:00:11.871
QUESTION SENATOR- YOU KNOW
02:00:11.938 --> 02:00:13.005
CERTAINLY THE WORK THAT HAS
02:00:13.072 --> 02:00:14.440
BEEN IMPLEMENTED. WITH WITH FOR
02:00:14.507 --> 02:00:16.943
EXAMPLE ON ALERT AND WARNING
02:00:17.009 --> 02:00:19.178
YOU KNOW YOUR BILL ABOUT DOING-
02:00:19.245 --> 02:00:22.715
BE ABLE TO JUST- BOB DAN VERSUS
02:00:22.782 --> 02:00:24.383
YOU KNOW OPTING OUT THAT THAT
02:00:24.450 --> 02:00:25.351
THAT WHOLE PIECE. ACTUALLY
02:00:25.418 --> 02:00:26.586
TAKING THAT AND MOVING THAT BOW
02:00:26.652 --> 02:00:28.988
DOWN TO THE- CITY LEVEL WILL BE
02:00:29.055 --> 02:00:32.692
A HUGE- ASSISTANCE SO THAT WE
02:00:32.758 --> 02:00:35.394
HAVE ALL LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT-
02:00:35.461 --> 02:00:35.928
THAT HAVE THE ABILITY TO
02:00:35.995 --> 02:00:37.463
PARTICIPATE IN THAT PROGRAM.
02:00:37.530 --> 02:00:39.298
THAT WILL ALSO ENHANCE THEM THE
02:00:39.365 --> 02:00:40.633
COMMUNICATIONS WITH WITH OUR
02:00:40.700 --> 02:00:43.603
CITIZENS- THE- WORK THAT HAS
02:00:43.669 --> 02:00:45.204
BEEN DONE THE SENATE REQUIRES
02:00:45.271 --> 02:00:46.772
BILLION IN BEGINNING THAT
02:00:46.839 --> 02:00:51.177
PROCESS OF GETTING AYE DATA
02:00:51.243 --> 02:00:53.946
REPORTING GET OUT OF REPORTED.
02:00:54.013 --> 02:00:54.981
THAT'S GOOD THE REPORT I THINK
02:00:55.047 --> 02:00:56.115
IT'S EVOLVING- AND- I'M I'M
02:00:56.182 --> 02:00:57.083
HOPING THAT THAT MUCH OF THE
02:00:57.149 --> 02:00:59.785
WORK THAT WE'RE DOING- WITH OUR
02:00:59.852 --> 02:01:01.420
TELECOMMUNICATION PARTNERS NOW
02:01:01.487 --> 02:01:07.059
IS TRULY. GOING TO BE
02:01:07.126 --> 02:01:07.860
MAINTAINED A COLLABORATIVE
02:01:07.927 --> 02:01:10.763
EFFORT- WE ALL HAVE TO BE
02:01:10.830 --> 02:01:11.998
ROWING IN THE SAME DIRECTION
02:01:12.064 --> 02:01:14.467
AND THROUGH THAT- INITIATIVE-
02:01:14.533 --> 02:01:16.802
THERE THERE MAY BE THINGS FOR
02:01:16.869 --> 02:01:18.904
EXAMPLE IF WE'RE REALLY GOING
02:01:18.971 --> 02:01:22.108
TO PUT THE- THAT THE EFFORT
02:01:22.174 --> 02:01:24.777
FORWARD TO RAPIDLY ASSASSIN AND
02:01:24.844 --> 02:01:27.279
BUILD OUT THE NEEDS OF
02:01:27.346 --> 02:01:28.614
UPGRADING OUR SYSTEM TO MAKE IT
02:01:28.681 --> 02:01:31.117
RESILIENT. THERE MAY BE SOME
02:01:31.183 --> 02:01:33.252
LEGISLATIVE ACTIONS THAT NEED
02:01:33.319 --> 02:01:35.087
TO TAKE PLACE THAT STREAMLINED
02:01:35.154 --> 02:01:36.322
THAT EFFORT THAT CAN HELP THE
02:01:36.389 --> 02:01:40.326
TELCOS BE ABLE TO- AFFECTIVELY
02:01:40.393 --> 02:01:42.328
PUT THEIR CAPABILITIES IN PLACE
02:01:42.395 --> 02:01:44.363
AND- MUCH LIKE WE'VE DONE IN
02:01:44.430 --> 02:01:46.465
OTHER CRISIS SITUATIONS THERE
02:01:46.532 --> 02:01:48.300
THERE'S OPPORTUNITIES THERE TO
02:01:48.367 --> 02:01:49.101
BE ABLE TO STREAMLINE THAT
02:01:49.168 --> 02:01:50.369
PROCESS AND I THINK THAT WOULD
02:01:50.436 --> 02:01:52.838
BE A GREAT PLACE WHERE WE COULD
02:01:52.905 --> 02:01:54.540
WORK WITH YOU AND BASED UPON
02:01:54.607 --> 02:01:55.875
THE MEETINGS WERE HAVING WITH
02:01:55.941 --> 02:01:59.111
THE TELCOS FIND A WAY TO DO
02:01:59.178 --> 02:02:03.082
THAT. IT IT IT SHOULD I THINK.
02:02:03.149 --> 02:02:04.550
L. T. TO I MEAN WE ARE PRETTY
02:02:04.617 --> 02:02:06.318
GOOD AT FORTY IS NOW BUT- I
02:02:06.385 --> 02:02:07.486
THINK BUILDING ON THE EGGS ON
02:02:07.553 --> 02:02:12.224
THE INITIAL UP. THE BILL THAT
02:02:12.291 --> 02:02:14.627
THAT SET FORTH REPORTING I
02:02:14.694 --> 02:02:15.594
THINK WE PROBABLY NEED TO
02:02:15.661 --> 02:02:17.463
CONTINUE TO SEE HOW THAT GOES
02:02:17.530 --> 02:02:19.865
AND PROBABLY MAYBE STEPPED THAT
02:02:19.932 --> 02:02:21.000
UP A LITTLE BIT AS TIME GOES ON
02:02:21.067 --> 02:02:23.436
BECAUSE- YOU KNOW THERE THE
02:02:23.502 --> 02:02:24.670
REPORTING OF THAT IS THE
02:02:24.737 --> 02:02:26.539
REPORTING OF THOSE OUTAGES. ARE
02:02:26.605 --> 02:02:28.374
EXTREMELY CRITICAL AND UP IT
02:02:28.441 --> 02:02:30.776
WAS A SOURCE OF FRUSTRATION. I
02:02:30.843 --> 02:02:32.778
DO BELIEVE AT THIS POINT AFTER
02:02:32.845 --> 02:02:35.214
THIS LAST PS PS A BAD- THAT WE
02:02:35.281 --> 02:02:36.982
ARE ON MORE OF THE SAME PACE
02:02:37.049 --> 02:02:38.117
THAN WE'VE EVER BEEN BEFORE.
02:02:38.184 --> 02:02:40.219
BUT AS WE SAY THE PROOF'S IN
02:02:40.286 --> 02:02:41.821
THE PUDDING AND WE'RE GONNA
02:02:41.887 --> 02:02:43.422
HAVE TO SEE HOW THINGS PROGRESS
02:02:43.489 --> 02:02:44.023
THANK YOU SENATOR WILL MOVE ON
02:02:44.090 --> 02:02:47.927
TO CENTER MCGUIRE. THANK YOU SO
02:02:47.993 --> 02:02:51.764
MUCH AS CHAIR. THE VERY QUICK-
02:02:51.831 --> 02:02:52.364
MISTER DIRECTOR THANK YOU FOR
02:02:52.431 --> 02:02:53.799
YOUR WORK SIR- IN ECHO THE
02:02:53.866 --> 02:02:55.167
SENTIMENTS OF A CENTER JACKSON
02:02:55.234 --> 02:02:57.203
THAT THIS IS A LIFETIME JOB UP
02:02:57.269 --> 02:03:00.840
INTO YOUR NINETIES SO WE LOOK
02:03:00.906 --> 02:03:06.512
FOR TO ANSWER. I'M NOT A REPEAT
02:03:06.579 --> 02:03:11.150
WITH MISTER HILL DESCENT SO.
02:03:11.217 --> 02:03:11.951
LOOK I DON'T WANT TO JUST-
02:03:12.017 --> 02:03:13.152
THROW STONES TODAY BECAUSE I
02:03:13.219 --> 02:03:13.786
THINK THAT WE'RE ALL INTERESTED
02:03:13.853 --> 02:03:15.221
IN IN LOOKING FOR SOLUTIONS AND
02:03:15.287 --> 02:03:17.156
WILL SAY- OVER THE LAST SEVERAL
02:03:17.223 --> 02:03:18.424
MONTHS TELECOMMUNICATION
02:03:18.491 --> 02:03:19.625
COMPANIES IN ME WITH OUR OFFICE
02:03:19.692 --> 02:03:20.659
I KNOW THAT THE MEETING WITH
02:03:20.726 --> 02:03:22.294
YOU AND MEAN WITH MANY OF US
02:03:22.361 --> 02:03:23.996
ABOUT SOLUTIONS ESPECIALLY ON
02:03:24.063 --> 02:03:25.498
BACKUP POWER BUT I WANT TO
02:03:25.564 --> 02:03:27.266
ADDRESS SIX I THINK IT'S ONE OF
02:03:27.333 --> 02:03:29.401
OUR BIGGEST ONE ABILITIES WHEN
02:03:29.468 --> 02:03:29.935
IT COMES TO. OUR STATE WHY
02:03:30.002 --> 02:03:32.805
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM. MY
02:03:32.872 --> 02:03:34.406
UNDERSTANDING IS- EARLIER THIS
02:03:34.473 --> 02:03:37.476
PAST SUMMER OUR UNDERSTANDING
02:03:37.543 --> 02:03:39.111
WAS THAT TELECOMMUNICATION
02:03:39.178 --> 02:03:39.645
COMPANIES PREPARED FOR THE
02:03:39.712 --> 02:03:43.382
WORST. AND THEN WE GET THROUGH
02:03:43.449 --> 02:03:45.151
THIS SIGNIFICANT POWER OUTAGE
02:03:45.217 --> 02:03:47.386
OF IN A SERIES OF EVENTS THAT
02:03:47.453 --> 02:03:48.120
WE SAW THROUGHOUT- THE
02:03:48.187 --> 02:03:49.555
CALIFORNIA AND IN SOUTHERN
02:03:49.622 --> 02:03:50.122
CALIFORNIA. IT'S CLEAR THEY
02:03:50.189 --> 02:03:53.492
WERE NOT. IN IN FACT MY
02:03:53.559 --> 02:03:56.128
UNDERSTANDING IS. SCRAMBLING TO
02:03:56.195 --> 02:03:57.496
BRING IN RESOURCES FROM OUT OF
02:03:57.563 --> 02:03:58.697
STATE TO TRY TO KEEP THEIR
02:03:58.764 --> 02:04:01.233
GRADE. IN THEIR
02:04:01.300 --> 02:04:01.901
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM UP
02:04:01.967 --> 02:04:04.103
AND RUNNING. I'D LIKE TO GET A
02:04:04.170 --> 02:04:05.037
BETTER UNDERSTANDING WHAT YOU
02:04:05.104 --> 02:04:07.373
KNOW ABOUT THIS- AND THEN I'D
02:04:07.439 --> 02:04:08.374
LIKE TO BE ABLE TO HEAR YOUR
02:04:08.440 --> 02:04:10.376
SUGGESTIONS- IN REGARD TO
02:04:10.442 --> 02:04:14.914
REDUNDANT BACKUP POWER. SO
02:04:14.980 --> 02:04:19.518
THANK YOU. THE FACTS ARE THAT I
02:04:19.585 --> 02:04:21.754
THINK THAT THE THAT THE EVENTS
02:04:21.821 --> 02:04:25.391
OF THE P. S. P. WHERE. YOU KNOW
02:04:25.457 --> 02:04:28.093
UNDER UNDER THOUGHT AND- YOU
02:04:28.160 --> 02:04:30.796
KNOW THE EVENT GOT OUT IN FRONT
02:04:30.863 --> 02:04:34.500
OF THE TELECOMS- PROVIDERS- AND
02:04:34.567 --> 02:04:36.869
THEY REALIZE THAT- YOU KNOW
02:04:36.936 --> 02:04:38.838
THEIR EXISTING CAPABILITY TO
02:04:38.904 --> 02:04:40.773
KEEP THEIR TOWERS UP AND WHAT
02:04:40.840 --> 02:04:43.275
POWERS THEY HAD OR WHAT BACK
02:04:43.342 --> 02:04:44.076
CALL THEY HAVE BEEN THEY HAD
02:04:44.143 --> 02:04:45.377
SOME REGENCY POWER WAS IN THERE
02:04:45.444 --> 02:04:47.413
IN SUFFICIENT. SO THE BASE
02:04:47.479 --> 02:04:49.515
SCRAMBLED AROUND IT WAS THE
02:04:49.582 --> 02:04:50.816
RELATING NEED QUITE FRANKLY
02:04:50.883 --> 02:04:54.420
AND- AND SO- BACK THAT RESULT
02:04:54.486 --> 02:04:56.355
IN THEM HAVING TO GO. IN STATE
02:04:56.422 --> 02:04:58.724
BUT ALSO OUT OF STATE TO GET-
02:04:58.791 --> 02:05:00.593
EMERGENCY POWER BE HONEST IT
02:05:00.659 --> 02:05:01.794
WAS A LITTLE COMPLICATED
02:05:01.861 --> 02:05:03.863
BECAUSE AS THEY CAME TO THE
02:05:03.929 --> 02:05:04.830
BORDERS OF CALIFORNIA IF THEY
02:05:04.897 --> 02:05:06.899
COMING FROM TEXAS- THEY DID
02:05:06.966 --> 02:05:07.933
MEET OUR AIR QUALITY STANDARDS
02:05:08.000 --> 02:05:09.835
AND SO THEN- YES HAD TO
02:05:09.902 --> 02:05:11.971
SCRAMBLE TO GET WAIVERS- TO BE
02:05:12.037 --> 02:05:13.105
ABLE TO LET THAT MAN UNDER
02:05:13.172 --> 02:05:15.441
EMERGENCY ORDER- BECAUSE WE
02:05:15.507 --> 02:05:16.976
NEEDED HEM AT THE TIME. IT'S
02:05:17.042 --> 02:05:18.344
REALLY NOT THE WAY WE LIKE TO
02:05:18.410 --> 02:05:20.145
DO BUSINESS I THINK
02:05:20.212 --> 02:05:21.013
COLLECTIVELY IN AGAIN ALL BEING
02:05:21.080 --> 02:05:24.016
ON THE SAME PAGE. WE HAVE. WE
02:05:24.083 --> 02:05:26.652
HAVE FOUGHT THROUGH. WHAT
02:05:26.719 --> 02:05:27.386
CATASTROPHIC DISASTERS LOOK
02:05:27.453 --> 02:05:28.721
LIKE IN THE STATE WE HAVE BUILT
02:05:28.787 --> 02:05:30.856
CATASTROPHIC RESPONSE PLANS.
02:05:30.923 --> 02:05:33.626
THAT HAVE VERY DETAILED- DATA
02:05:33.692 --> 02:05:36.428
OUTLINED IN THOSE- TO TALK
02:05:36.495 --> 02:05:38.697
ABOUT LOSS OF POWER IT BACK TO
02:05:38.764 --> 02:05:41.367
COMMUNITIES EXCEPT TRUCK. THAT
02:05:41.433 --> 02:05:43.769
THAT DATA IS AVAILABLE AND WHEN
02:05:43.836 --> 02:05:45.604
CAN WE HAVE TALKED TO THE
02:05:45.671 --> 02:05:48.474
TELECOMS IN THE PAST ABOUT. THE
02:05:48.540 --> 02:05:49.742
FACT THAT GOING OUT OF STATE OR
02:05:49.808 --> 02:05:52.912
SIX. A PORTABLE CELL ON WHEELS-
02:05:52.978 --> 02:05:54.747
IS NOT A SUFFICIENT FOR THE
02:05:54.813 --> 02:05:56.248
KIND OF DISASTERS WE HAVE IN
02:05:56.315 --> 02:05:57.950
CALIFORNIA. I WOULD JUST SAY
02:05:58.017 --> 02:05:59.351
THAT THIS POINT. GOING THROUGH
02:05:59.418 --> 02:06:00.653
WHAT WE'VE ALL BEEN THROUGH. I
02:06:00.719 --> 02:06:01.820
THINK EVERYBODY UNDERSTANDS
02:06:01.887 --> 02:06:03.923
REALLY WHAT THE CASCADING
02:06:03.989 --> 02:06:05.591
IMPACTS AND THE DIRECT IMPACTS
02:06:05.658 --> 02:06:07.559
OF THOSE LIFE LINES ARE. SO WE
02:06:07.626 --> 02:06:09.328
NOW HAVE A NEW STANDARD TO
02:06:09.395 --> 02:06:11.230
OPERATE FROM. EVERYBODY'S BEEN
02:06:11.297 --> 02:06:12.965
THROUGH IT AND I'M HOPING THAT
02:06:13.032 --> 02:06:14.233
THROUGH THIS COLLABORATIVE.
02:06:14.300 --> 02:06:16.001
EFFORT WHAT WILL CONTINUE TO
02:06:16.068 --> 02:06:18.704
MOVE FORWARD. AND TO GET WHERE
02:06:18.771 --> 02:06:20.806
WE NEED TO GET TO YES I MENTION
02:06:20.873 --> 02:06:23.676
MY- MY STATEMENT IS THAT DUMB.
02:06:23.742 --> 02:06:24.743
THEY REALLY NEED TO BUILD AND
02:06:24.810 --> 02:06:26.779
BAKE IN- AS WE DO THIS
02:06:26.845 --> 02:06:28.380
INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS-
02:06:28.447 --> 02:06:31.450
AYE AYE DRAFTING- CAPABILITY
02:06:31.517 --> 02:06:32.718
WITH HIS EMERGENCY POWER THAT
02:06:32.785 --> 02:06:36.088
IS. BEYOND FOUR HOURS AND THAT
02:06:36.155 --> 02:06:38.190
IS REALLY PART OF HARDENING
02:06:38.257 --> 02:06:40.326
THAT. CAPABILITY WRAPPING FIBER
02:06:40.392 --> 02:06:42.394
LINES SO THAT THEY DON'T CRACK
02:06:42.461 --> 02:06:45.497
BREAK BURN OR MELT- BEING ABLE
02:06:45.564 --> 02:06:47.032
TO DO DEFENSIBLE SPACE AROUND
02:06:47.099 --> 02:06:47.900
CELL SIZE HARDENING THOSE
02:06:47.967 --> 02:06:50.836
SITES- AND IF THERE'S SOME.
02:06:50.903 --> 02:06:53.772
REGULATORY OR OTHER KINDS OF
02:06:53.839 --> 02:06:55.708
ADMINISTRATIVE ISSUES WHERE THE
02:06:55.774 --> 02:06:57.042
STATE CAN HELP STREAMLINE THOSE
02:06:57.109 --> 02:06:59.044
EFFORTS. I THINK WE'D SIT DOWN
02:06:59.111 --> 02:07:00.312
AND HELP TO DO THAT AND THAT
02:07:00.379 --> 02:07:01.246
YOU KNOW ARE THIS IS RELEASED
02:07:01.313 --> 02:07:04.950
ABOUT CRISIS SITUATION BECAUSE
02:07:05.017 --> 02:07:08.721
THERE IS NO WAY. NO WAY. THAT
02:07:08.787 --> 02:07:10.222
WE SHOULD HAVE ANOTHER YEAR
02:07:10.289 --> 02:07:11.357
LIKE WE DID IN TWO THOUSAND
02:07:11.423 --> 02:07:12.925
NINETEEN WE- AS A SOCIETY
02:07:12.992 --> 02:07:14.360
SHOULD NOT EXPECT. THAT WE NOT
02:07:14.426 --> 02:07:16.996
ONLY LOSE. POWER TO MILLIONS
02:07:17.062 --> 02:07:17.629
BUT ARE ALL OF OUR
02:07:17.696 --> 02:07:20.265
COMMUNICATIONS ALL OF OUR DATA.
02:07:20.332 --> 02:07:21.667
WE CAN'T BE DRIVEN INTO ONE
02:07:21.734 --> 02:07:24.370
SYSTEM. AND THEN THAT SYSTEM
02:07:24.436 --> 02:07:26.138
THEN BECOME SO VULNERABLE THAT
02:07:26.205 --> 02:07:28.307
WE LOSE IT ALL BECAUSE LEISER
02:07:28.374 --> 02:07:30.576
RISK IT'S UNACCEPTABLE. SO WE
02:07:30.642 --> 02:07:31.777
CAN'T LET THAT HAPPEN SO TIME
02:07:31.844 --> 02:07:33.712
IS OF THE ESSENCE AND WE NEED
02:07:33.779 --> 02:07:35.047
TO MOVE FOR WITH A DEFINITIVE
02:07:35.114 --> 02:07:38.650
PLAN WORKING TOGETHER TO GET
02:07:38.717 --> 02:07:39.218
WHAT WE NEED TO GET TO THANK
02:07:39.284 --> 02:07:39.818
YOU WE'RE GONNA GO. TO CENTER
02:07:39.885 --> 02:07:43.122
MONEY. THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
02:07:43.188 --> 02:07:44.656
I ALSO WANT TO THINK MISTER
02:07:44.723 --> 02:07:46.058
KILLER DUE TO YOU AND ALL OF
02:07:46.125 --> 02:07:49.361
YOUR TEAM- ALSO WELCOME TO
02:07:49.428 --> 02:07:52.564
MISTER RILEY- SO MISTER RILEY
02:07:52.631 --> 02:07:54.466
TOUCHED ON FIRST RESPONDER
02:07:54.533 --> 02:07:55.934
ABILITY TO COMMUNICATE WITH
02:07:56.001 --> 02:07:58.871
EACH OTHER- USING IMPROVED
02:07:58.937 --> 02:08:00.906
RADIO SYSTEMS AND I I'VE SEEN
02:08:00.973 --> 02:08:03.142
WITH CAL FIRE AND STATE PARKS
02:08:03.208 --> 02:08:05.544
THESE NEW SYSTEMS ALLOW INTER
02:08:05.611 --> 02:08:08.180
AGENCY COMMUNICATION ETCETERA.
02:08:08.247 --> 02:08:09.882
I GUESS FOR MISTER GULAR DUE TO
02:08:09.948 --> 02:08:12.251
FIRST WAS THERE ANY EVIDENCE OF
02:08:12.317 --> 02:08:14.720
OUTAGES IMPEDING FIRST
02:08:14.787 --> 02:08:16.989
RESPONDER ABILITY TO
02:08:17.056 --> 02:08:21.160
COMMUNICATE WITH EACH OTHER.
02:08:21.226 --> 02:08:22.227
LET ME JUST CAST MEASURES ARE
02:08:22.294 --> 02:08:22.761
DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR PUBLIC
02:08:22.828 --> 02:08:25.831
SAFETY COMMUNICATIONS SO.
02:08:25.898 --> 02:08:27.232
BETTER AND GOOD MORNING- MITCH
02:08:27.299 --> 02:08:28.634
MEDIC OF A CHAIR. I WAS JUST
02:08:28.700 --> 02:08:29.668
LIKE SAY IF WE DID NOT HAVE ANY
02:08:29.735 --> 02:08:31.136
EXPERIENCE OF ANY- MAJOR
02:08:31.203 --> 02:08:32.871
OUTAGES OR OUR ISSUES WITH OUR
02:08:32.938 --> 02:08:35.040
NETWORK SO THAT SUPPORTS ALL
02:08:35.107 --> 02:08:36.041
THE STATE AGENCIES THAT- RIGHT
02:08:36.108 --> 02:08:37.976
OVER THE RADIO SYSTEM. AND IT'S
02:08:38.043 --> 02:08:39.845
OUR NETWORK IS BUILT WITH ALL
02:08:39.912 --> 02:08:43.215
OF THE PUBLIC SAFETY GRADE
02:08:43.282 --> 02:08:43.782
UPGRADES THAT THE DIRECTORS
02:08:43.849 --> 02:08:46.518
TALKING ABOUT SO. THAT'S THAT'S
02:08:46.585 --> 02:08:48.821
REASSURING ACTUALLY IN THAT
02:08:48.887 --> 02:08:51.056
WOULD SUGGEST. INDEPENDENT
02:08:51.123 --> 02:08:54.660
POWER SOURCES FROM. CLEARLY
02:08:54.726 --> 02:08:55.260
RADIOS ARE BATTERY DRIVEN BUT
02:08:55.327 --> 02:08:57.563
THE- RELAY CENTERS AT CENTER
02:08:57.629 --> 02:09:01.333
HAVE THEIR OWN. POWER
02:09:01.400 --> 02:09:03.502
REDUNDANCY DURING A POWER
02:09:03.569 --> 02:09:05.504
OUTAGE THAT'S CORRECT IN COURSE
02:09:05.571 --> 02:09:06.305
WE HAD TO DO REFUELING
02:09:06.371 --> 02:09:08.207
OPERATIONS TO THOSE GENERATORS%
02:09:08.273 --> 02:09:09.875
AND THAT IS A CHALLENGE DURING
02:09:09.942 --> 02:09:10.509
THE MIDDLE THE EVENT PARTICULAR
02:09:10.576 --> 02:09:12.478
IN FIRE AREAS THERE MIGHT HAVE
02:09:12.544 --> 02:09:13.979
BEEN MOMENTARY LAPSES BECAUSE
02:09:14.046 --> 02:09:15.380
OF A FIRE THAT'S EXISTING
02:09:15.447 --> 02:09:16.515
BECAUSE YOU COULDN'T GET IN BUT
02:09:16.582 --> 02:09:17.716
AS SOON AS IT WAS REFILL.
02:09:17.783 --> 02:09:19.918
RESTORE LET ME SAY THOUGH THAT
02:09:19.985 --> 02:09:21.787
THE PUBLIC REACHED FIFTY
02:09:21.854 --> 02:09:23.455
RESPOND HERS WHEN WE TALK ABOUT
02:09:23.522 --> 02:09:25.424
MOVING DATA YOU KNOW THEY'RE
02:09:25.491 --> 02:09:27.993
USING CELLS CELLS SERVICES WELL
02:09:28.060 --> 02:09:30.295
THE USE OF THE SYSTEMS. TO
02:09:30.362 --> 02:09:33.065
COMMUNICATE WAS IMPEDED RIGHT
02:09:33.132 --> 02:09:34.833
THE LAND MOBILE RADIO SYSTEMS
02:09:34.900 --> 02:09:36.101
ARE MICROWAVE NETWORK OUR
02:09:36.168 --> 02:09:37.503
PUBLIC SAID COMMUNICATIONS THEM
02:09:37.569 --> 02:09:39.705
WAS OPERATIONAL FOR WHAT- FOR
02:09:39.771 --> 02:09:41.673
BUT THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR JUST
02:09:41.740 --> 02:09:43.542
MENTIONED- BUT THE IN THE USE
02:09:43.609 --> 02:09:45.277
OF THESE WERE IN IMPACTED JUST
02:09:45.344 --> 02:09:47.846
LIKE- JUST LIKE- THE PUBLIC
02:09:47.913 --> 02:09:49.781
THANK YOU IN IN THAT CAN IMPEDE
02:09:49.848 --> 02:09:51.283
THE ABILITY TO RELATE OTHER
02:09:51.350 --> 02:09:55.654
DATA OR- GROUPS DATA MAPPING
02:09:55.721 --> 02:09:57.723
YEAH. TO THE OTHER SIDE OF THAT
02:09:57.789 --> 02:10:00.225
MISTER RILEY LOU THIS IS WELL
02:10:00.292 --> 02:10:03.996
LAND MINES WE HAVE THE ABILITY
02:10:04.062 --> 02:10:06.398
FOR REVERSE NINE ONE ONE
02:10:06.465 --> 02:10:10.469
NOTIFICATION IN IN THE EXTREME
02:10:10.536 --> 02:10:13.338
OF ACTIVATION THIS IS. THE
02:10:13.405 --> 02:10:19.978
CONCERN Là. BUT ONLY OFTEN FOR
02:10:20.045 --> 02:10:21.180
SELF SERVICE TODAY I UNDERSTAND
02:10:21.246 --> 02:10:22.314
THAT CORRECTLY WITH A VERY LOW
02:10:22.381 --> 02:10:23.382
UPTAKE TOM WAS IN MARIN COUNTY
02:10:23.448 --> 02:10:24.416
OF PEOPLE OPTING IN FOR THAT
02:10:24.483 --> 02:10:27.653
RIVERS. NINE ONE ONE- WHY IS
02:10:27.719 --> 02:10:29.021
THERE THAT DISTINCTION AND
02:10:29.087 --> 02:10:31.723
WHAT'S THE REMEDY TO GET WITH
02:10:31.790 --> 02:10:33.492
MORE AND MORE PEOPLE MOVING TO
02:10:33.559 --> 02:10:36.061
ONLY WIRELESS AT THEIR HOMES
02:10:36.128 --> 02:10:38.597
HAD WE BUILD THAT INTO THAN
02:10:38.664 --> 02:10:40.232
NINE WERE VERSE NINE ONE ONE
02:10:40.299 --> 02:10:42.534
WITHOUT REQUIRING AN OPT IN
02:10:42.601 --> 02:10:46.238
THAT PEOPLE AREN'T USING. SO
02:10:46.305 --> 02:10:46.805
ANY OF YOU THAT WANT TO TAKE
02:10:46.872 --> 02:10:50.576
THEM. START AND I'LL TURN OVER%
02:10:50.642 --> 02:10:51.910
TO CHRIS BECAUSE HE CAN TELL
02:10:51.977 --> 02:10:52.678
YOU OPERATIONS THERE'S A LOT OF
02:10:52.744 --> 02:10:55.214
SHARED INFRASTRUCTURE. SO WHEN
02:10:55.280 --> 02:10:57.049
WE TALK ABOUT WIRELINE WIRELESS
02:10:57.115 --> 02:10:57.482
AND ALL THESE OTHER
02:10:57.549 --> 02:10:58.784
COMMUNICATIONS A LOT OF TIMES
02:10:58.850 --> 02:11:00.886
IF YOU FALL THAT SPIDER WEB FOR
02:11:00.953 --> 02:11:02.754
THAT INFRASTRUCTURE THE
02:11:02.821 --> 02:11:04.156
BACKBONE OF HOW COMMUNICATIONS
02:11:04.223 --> 02:11:06.491
MOVE. THERE'S A VULNERABILITY
02:11:06.558 --> 02:11:07.926
POINTS THAT EXIST WITHIN THAT
02:11:07.993 --> 02:11:10.629
SHORT TERM STRUCTURE SO- TO
02:11:10.696 --> 02:11:13.131
ANSWER YOUR QUESTION YOU HAVE-
02:11:13.198 --> 02:11:14.633
LAND LINES ARE WERE SIGNIFICANT
02:11:14.700 --> 02:11:16.568
PROBLEM AND ANSWER THE DIRECTOR
02:11:16.635 --> 02:11:17.169
HAD MENTIONED HERE I MEAN THAT
02:11:17.236 --> 02:11:19.171
ARE HIGH POINT WE HAD FOR OVER.
02:11:19.238 --> 02:11:21.907
CLOSE TO HALF A MILLION BEFORE
02:11:21.974 --> 02:11:23.041
FIFTY FOUR THOUSAND LANDLINES
02:11:23.108 --> 02:11:25.110
CUSTOMERS THAT'S NOT I AM NOT
02:11:25.177 --> 02:11:26.945
CORRECTION THERE'S STILL SITES
02:11:27.012 --> 02:11:28.547
NOT INDIVIDUAL SEEK MULTIPLIED
02:11:28.614 --> 02:11:30.015
BY THREE LIKE A CHRIS TALKED
02:11:30.082 --> 02:11:31.416
ABOUT THIS IS A SIGNIFICANT
02:11:31.483 --> 02:11:33.986
IMPACT IN NOT HAVING THE
02:11:34.052 --> 02:11:35.387
SERVICE PROVIDERS FOR THAT THAT
02:11:35.454 --> 02:11:39.424
PORTION OF IT. AND SO WHEN THE
02:11:39.491 --> 02:11:42.294
SHARED INFRASTRUCTURES DOWN. AS
02:11:42.361 --> 02:11:42.894
CHRIS POINTED OUT HE'S HE WAS
02:11:42.961 --> 02:11:44.563
NOT ABLE TO COMMUNICATE NOT
02:11:44.630 --> 02:11:46.565
ONLY BY WIRE LESS TO SEND OUT
02:11:46.632 --> 02:11:47.966
MEMBERS MESSAGE TO EVERY PHONE
02:11:48.033 --> 02:11:49.368
OUT THERE IN HIS AREA YOU CAN
02:11:49.434 --> 02:11:51.536
DO THAT. IF THE WIRE LINE WAS
02:11:51.603 --> 02:11:53.038
DOWN HE COULDN'T REACH HIM IF
02:11:53.105 --> 02:11:54.306
THERE OF A CUSTOMER THAT
02:11:54.373 --> 02:11:56.174
BUNDLES THEIR INTERNET IN YOUR
02:11:56.241 --> 02:11:57.843
TELEVISION AND ALL THE THINGS
02:11:57.909 --> 02:11:58.877
THAT YOU HAVE. YOU'RE NOT GONNA
02:11:58.944 --> 02:12:00.212
GET BROADCAST TELEVISION SIGNAL
02:12:00.279 --> 02:12:01.246
YOU'RE NOT GOING TO GET AVOID
02:12:01.313 --> 02:12:03.582
PHONE INTO YOUR HOUSE AND
02:12:03.649 --> 02:12:05.050
YOU'RE NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO
02:12:05.117 --> 02:12:05.651
USE YOUR INTERNET TO VALIDATE
02:12:05.717 --> 02:12:08.020
MEANING IT'S GOING ON THERE SO.
02:12:08.086 --> 02:12:09.121
YOU KNOW THE CHALLENGES HE
02:12:09.187 --> 02:12:11.056
FACED AT THE COUNTY LEVEL IN
02:12:11.123 --> 02:12:12.491
AND ALL OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS
02:12:12.557 --> 02:12:14.393
ARE IMPACTED BY IT WE'RE FACING
02:12:14.459 --> 02:12:16.194
THE SAME ISSUE IS THE ABILITY
02:12:16.261 --> 02:12:18.497
TO COMMUNICATE WAS. DIRECTLY
02:12:18.563 --> 02:12:21.967
IMPACTED BY ALL AREAS. YEAH YOU
02:12:22.034 --> 02:12:23.535
PEOPLE DON'T OPT INTO OUR
02:12:23.602 --> 02:12:24.136
SYSTEM FOR A LOT OF DIFFERENT
02:12:24.202 --> 02:12:26.004
REASONS YOU KNOW- VERY
02:12:26.071 --> 02:12:27.839
INDIVIDUAL REASONS BUT YOU KNOW
02:12:27.906 --> 02:12:28.573
IT MIGHT THEIR WITH MAY BE
02:12:28.640 --> 02:12:30.142
SUSPICIOUS OF GOVERNMENT OR
02:12:30.208 --> 02:12:31.076
THEY'RE AFRAID THAT THEY'RE
02:12:31.143 --> 02:12:32.177
GONNA GET SPAMMER. BUT THEY
02:12:32.244 --> 02:12:33.245
WERE GONNA SHARE THEIR
02:12:33.312 --> 02:12:35.314
INFORMATION WITH- YOU KNOW SOME
02:12:35.380 --> 02:12:37.316
OF THE SOME MAKETERS SOMETHING
02:12:37.382 --> 02:12:38.150
LIKE THAT YOU KNOW EVERYBODY
02:12:38.216 --> 02:12:39.351
HAS A LOT OF. DIFFERENT
02:12:39.418 --> 02:12:42.454
REASONS- WE CAN GET THE DATA AS
02:12:42.521 --> 02:12:44.356
I SAID FOR A REGULAR LINE
02:12:44.423 --> 02:12:46.325
PHONES WE GET FOR CALM FROM
02:12:46.391 --> 02:12:47.793
COMCAST NOW WE PUT THAT IN
02:12:47.859 --> 02:12:49.628
THERE. SO VERIZON EIGHTEEN T.
02:12:49.695 --> 02:12:50.862
THEY SHARE THAT INFORMATION
02:12:50.929 --> 02:12:53.031
WITH US BUT- WIRELESS COMPANIES
02:12:53.098 --> 02:12:55.400
ARE NOT REQUIRED TO DO THAT. I
02:12:55.467 --> 02:12:56.668
KNOW THAT THERE WAS A BILL
02:12:56.735 --> 02:12:58.870
RECENTLY. I THAT WAS GOING TO
02:12:58.937 --> 02:12:59.938
EXPAND THE DEFINITION I
02:13:00.005 --> 02:13:01.673
UNDERSTAND AND OF YOU KNOW TO
02:13:01.740 --> 02:13:03.608
INCLUDE WIRELESS COMPANIES IN
02:13:03.675 --> 02:13:05.310
AND REQUIRING TO SHARE THAT.
02:13:05.377 --> 02:13:06.511
WITH US. BUT I UNDERSTAND IT
02:13:06.578 --> 02:13:08.447
THAT FAILED- WE WOULD LOVE TO
02:13:08.513 --> 02:13:10.515
HAVE THAT ABILITY- WE WANT TO
02:13:10.582 --> 02:13:11.983
BE ABLE TO NOTIFY AS MANY
02:13:12.050 --> 02:13:14.419
PEOPLE AS POSSIBLE- YEAH THAT
02:13:14.486 --> 02:13:17.155
NUMBERS YOU KNOW 15220% HOW
02:13:17.222 --> 02:13:19.391
OFTEN IS. NOT UNUSUAL YOU KNOW
02:13:19.458 --> 02:13:21.626
IT TOO WE- WE TALKED OR OTHER
02:13:21.693 --> 02:13:22.861
COUNTIES AROUND THE STATE THAT
02:13:22.928 --> 02:13:24.229
EXPERIENCED THE SAME KIND OF
02:13:24.296 --> 02:13:26.198
LOW LEVEL ABOUT THAT YASSER IS
02:13:26.264 --> 02:13:28.500
THIS. THE VULNERABILITY OF LAND
02:13:28.567 --> 02:13:31.770
LINES- YEAH. THE RIVERS AND
02:13:31.837 --> 02:13:32.571
NINE ONE ONE. SO I THINK WILL
02:13:32.637 --> 02:13:35.674
BE HELPFUL FOR US AND- NOT AT
02:13:35.741 --> 02:13:38.677
THIS MOMENT. IS FOLLOW UP. IF
02:13:38.744 --> 02:13:39.311
YOU HAD A MAGIC WAND WHAT WOULD
02:13:39.378 --> 02:13:42.047
BE. SOME WHAT WOULD BE THE
02:13:42.114 --> 02:13:50.589
IDEAL COMMUNICATION. ACCESS FOR.
02:13:50.655 --> 02:13:51.990
FULLER HUH. RESIDENTS RATE
02:13:52.057 --> 02:13:54.326
PAYERS- OF IMPENDING DANGER
02:13:54.393 --> 02:13:55.527
WHAT WHAT HOW DO WE CREATE THAT
02:13:55.594 --> 02:13:57.295
REDUNDANCY IDEALLY FORGETTING.
02:13:57.362 --> 02:13:59.898
ABOUT CARSON. WELL HONESTLY
02:13:59.965 --> 02:14:01.533
THEY ALL NEED TO BE ROBUST AND
02:14:01.600 --> 02:14:08.240
WE'VE DONE THAT ALL OF THE.
02:14:08.306 --> 02:14:09.408
INTERNET NEEDS TO BE UP SO WE
02:14:09.474 --> 02:14:10.275
CAN PROVIDE ADDITIONAL
02:14:10.342 --> 02:14:11.243
INFORMATION THERE ACTUALLY IS
02:14:11.309 --> 02:14:13.712
NOT ONE PREFERRED. SOURCE OF
02:14:13.779 --> 02:14:15.046
NOTIFYING THE PROPER PUBLIC
02:14:15.113 --> 02:14:16.515
BECAUSE IT'S VERY. INCIDENT
02:14:16.581 --> 02:14:18.016
DRIVEN YEAH BUT ONE OF THE
02:14:18.083 --> 02:14:19.718
LESSONS I GUESS IS THE NEED FOR
02:14:19.785 --> 02:14:21.620
REDUNDANCY THE SACRAMENTO
02:14:21.686 --> 02:14:24.923
AIRPORT- AND- I WON'T GET INTO
02:14:24.990 --> 02:14:26.258
THIS NOW BUT WE- WERE TRYING
02:14:26.324 --> 02:14:27.459
OUT RESPONSES TO NATURAL
02:14:27.526 --> 02:14:30.228
DISASTERS. AND PLAN TO POWER
02:14:30.295 --> 02:14:33.265
OUTAGES. THIS HEARINGS NOT
02:14:33.331 --> 02:14:35.534
ABOUT POTENTIAL SUSCEPTIBILITY
02:14:35.600 --> 02:14:37.402
TO TERRORIST EFFORTS TO KNOCK
02:14:37.469 --> 02:14:40.338
OUT THE GRID TO KNOCK OUT
02:14:40.405 --> 02:14:43.041
INFORMATION SYSTEMS. IN BED BUT
02:14:43.108 --> 02:14:45.477
OUR ABILITY TO PREPARE IN THIS
02:14:45.544 --> 02:14:47.946
INSTANCE I WOULD THINK ALSO
02:14:48.013 --> 02:14:50.015
BENEFIT SERVICE IN TERMS OF OUR
02:14:50.081 --> 02:14:52.384
BROADER- SECURITY CONCERNS BUT
02:14:52.451 --> 02:14:54.286
I KEEP THINKING CENTER. AND
02:14:54.352 --> 02:14:55.020
WE'RE GONNA MOVE TO OUR NEXT
02:14:55.086 --> 02:14:57.022
PANEL THANK YOU VERY MUCH. FOR
02:14:57.088 --> 02:15:01.126
BEING HERE TODAY. HELLO PHONE
02:15:01.193 --> 02:15:02.828
TURN A CLEARLY OKAY CENTER
02:15:02.894 --> 02:15:05.063
SKINNER DID MASS TO. KNOW WHAT
02:15:05.130 --> 02:15:05.864
HAPPENED HERE THANK YOU DEAR
02:15:05.931 --> 02:15:07.666
THANK YOU FOR THIS HEARING ARE
02:15:07.732 --> 02:15:10.068
ALSO ON A GIVE MY APPRECIATION
02:15:10.135 --> 02:15:11.536
TO THE REPRESENTS THE P. YOU
02:15:11.603 --> 02:15:13.405
SEE WHO SPOKE WELL I WASN'T
02:15:13.472 --> 02:15:15.040
SITTING ON THE DíAS I WAS
02:15:15.106 --> 02:15:17.943
LISTENING- MISTER DRILLER DO G.
02:15:18.009 --> 02:15:20.345
YOU WERE SAYING AND SPECIFIC
02:15:20.412 --> 02:15:22.681
AND I APPRECIATE IT. AND MISTER
02:15:22.747 --> 02:15:25.417
RILEY A SIMILARLY- MY DISTRICT
02:15:25.484 --> 02:15:27.819
WAS ALSO AFFECTED BY THE POWER
02:15:27.886 --> 02:15:29.154
OUTAGES AND I BRING IT UP NOT
02:15:29.221 --> 02:15:31.056
BECAUSE LIKE YOU KNOW WE'RE
02:15:31.122 --> 02:15:32.657
UNIQUE OR SOMETHING BUT AS MOST
02:15:32.724 --> 02:15:34.793
PEOPLE KNOW BE OPEN BERKELEY
02:15:34.860 --> 02:15:36.595
HILLS FIRE WAS THE MOST
02:15:36.661 --> 02:15:39.030
DAMAGING DEVASTATING AND LIKE
02:15:39.097 --> 02:15:41.566
LOS BUYER PRIOR TO. EITHER THE
02:15:41.633 --> 02:15:45.070
COFFEE OR THE PARADISE AND MUCH
02:15:45.136 --> 02:15:47.038
OF OUR SELL EQUIPMENT IS IN THE
02:15:47.105 --> 02:15:48.807
BERKELEY AND OAKLAND HILLS
02:15:48.874 --> 02:15:51.309
EXACTLY WHERE THE FIRE OCCURRED
02:15:51.376 --> 02:15:53.144
SO OF COURSE THAT IS WHERE THE
02:15:53.211 --> 02:15:55.046
POWER WAS TURNED OFF AND WHEN
02:15:55.113 --> 02:15:56.047
THEIR POWER WAS TURNED OFF
02:15:56.114 --> 02:15:58.083
THOSE VERY RESIDENTS WHO ARE
02:15:58.149 --> 02:16:00.285
MOST SUSCEPTIBLE TO A FIRE.
02:16:00.352 --> 02:16:02.354
DâN DID NOT HAVE FOR MANY OF
02:16:02.420 --> 02:16:03.855
THEM EITHER INTERNET OR SELL
02:16:03.922 --> 02:16:05.957
ACCESS TO THE VERY WAY AND
02:16:06.024 --> 02:16:07.225
WE'VE DISCUSSED THIS THAT
02:16:07.292 --> 02:16:09.094
SOMEONE IS NOTIFIED THEY NO
02:16:09.160 --> 02:16:14.165
LONGER HAD AND WE THEN WE WERE
02:16:14.232 --> 02:16:17.769
FORTUNATE WE DID NOT HAVE A
02:16:17.836 --> 02:16:20.338
SERIOUS INCIDENT BUT THERE IS
02:16:20.405 --> 02:16:23.742
A- IN LAFAYETTE WHICH IS BASED.
02:16:23.808 --> 02:16:26.144
ON THE OF THE BILLS AND IN
02:16:26.211 --> 02:16:28.780
CERTAIN EIGHT THERE WOULD FIRE.
02:16:28.847 --> 02:16:31.816
BERKELEY KENSINGTON AREA.
02:16:31.883 --> 02:16:32.851
CONTACT THE COUNTY WAS ALSO
02:16:32.918 --> 02:16:33.451
ACTED AND THEN OF COURSE THRE
02:16:33.518 --> 02:16:34.586
WAS THE FIRE IN VALLEJO THAT
02:16:34.653 --> 02:16:35.820
JUMPED THE CARQUINEZ STRAITS.
02:16:35.887 --> 02:16:38.056
IN HIT BY THE NORTHERN PART OF
02:16:38.123 --> 02:16:38.623
NORTHWESTERN PART OF CONTRA
02:16:38.690 --> 02:16:39.391
COSTA COUNTY AGAIN WITH THE
02:16:39.457 --> 02:16:42.661
POWER OUTAGES. THE PEOPLE WHO
02:16:42.727 --> 02:16:43.895
LIVE THERE DID NOT HAVE THIS
02:16:43.962 --> 02:16:47.732
ACCESS SO- SO WE KNOW THAT
02:16:47.799 --> 02:16:49.534
PLACES THAT NEED THIS CRITICAL
02:16:49.601 --> 02:16:53.271
INFRASTRUCTURE. WERE WITHOUT IT
02:16:53.338 --> 02:16:54.806
AND- THE MAIN BESIDES JUST
02:16:54.873 --> 02:16:59.511
BRINGING IT UP. WHEN AS WE LOOK
02:16:59.578 --> 02:17:03.715
AT REQUIRING BACK TO POWER.
02:17:03.782 --> 02:17:05.684
GIVEN WHERE MUCH OF THIS
02:17:05.750 --> 02:17:07.953
EQUIPMENT IS LOCATED TO RELY ON
02:17:08.019 --> 02:17:10.855
DIESEL GENERATORS IN THE MID IN
02:17:10.922 --> 02:17:12.757
THE PLACE WHERE WE ARE MOST
02:17:12.824 --> 02:17:14.025
SUSCEPTIBLE TO FIRE DOES NOT
02:17:14.092 --> 02:17:15.627
MAKE A LOT OF SENSE. NOW I KNOW
02:17:15.694 --> 02:17:20.465
THERE'S- DIFFICULTIES WITH- YOU
02:17:20.532 --> 02:17:23.468
KNOW A STORAGE- BATTERY STORAGE
02:17:23.535 --> 02:17:26.237
IN SUCH AS A LIMITED HOURS BUT-
02:17:26.304 --> 02:17:27.205
THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF
02:17:27.272 --> 02:17:29.140
TECHNOLOGICAL BREAKTHROUGHS AND
02:17:29.207 --> 02:17:30.275
I THINK IT'S VERY VERY
02:17:30.342 --> 02:17:34.045
IMPORTANT THAT WE REALLY LOOK
02:17:34.112 --> 02:17:36.615
AT. WHAT WHAT TECHNOLOGICAL
02:17:36.681 --> 02:17:39.117
WHAT TECHNOLOGIES ARE AVAILABLE
02:17:39.184 --> 02:17:41.086
AND WHAT BREAKTHROUGHS TO BE
02:17:41.152 --> 02:17:42.787
ABLE TO NOT BE IN A
02:17:42.854 --> 02:17:44.089
CIRCUMSTANCE WHERE WE'RE
02:17:44.155 --> 02:17:46.291
RELIANT PRIMARILY ON DIESEL
02:17:46.358 --> 02:17:49.995
GENERATION AT ESPECIALLY IN
02:17:50.061 --> 02:17:50.962
THOSE LOCATIONS THAT ARE MOST
02:17:51.029 --> 02:17:53.598
FIRE SUSCEPTIBLE. SO I WANTED
02:17:53.665 --> 02:17:57.369
TO JUST LEAVE YOU KNOW IF WE.
02:17:57.435 --> 02:17:59.304
IN THINKING ABOUT HOW WE MOVE
02:17:59.371 --> 02:18:01.473
FORWARD WHETHER THERE HAS BEEN
02:18:01.539 --> 02:18:03.775
THOUGHT TO THESE OTHER
02:18:03.842 --> 02:18:05.744
TECHNOLOGIES WHETHER IT'S
02:18:05.810 --> 02:18:07.479
WHETHER IT'S OTHER TECHNOLOGIES
02:18:07.545 --> 02:18:10.081
FOR BACKUP POWER OR WHETHER
02:18:10.148 --> 02:18:10.515
IT'S A WHOLE NOTHER
02:18:10.582 --> 02:18:13.918
COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY. WELL
02:18:13.985 --> 02:18:17.589
YOUR YOUR- IS IT YOUR POINT IS
02:18:17.656 --> 02:18:18.189
SO IMPORTANT IT'S ONE OF THOSE
02:18:18.256 --> 02:18:20.025
TOPICS TO WE HAVE BEEN.
02:18:20.091 --> 02:18:22.160
DISCUSSING COLOURED THREE- ON
02:18:22.227 --> 02:18:24.295
THE STATE SYSTEM WE USE A
02:18:24.362 --> 02:18:27.165
COMBINATION OF SOLAR PROPANE
02:18:27.232 --> 02:18:30.635
DIESEL- CURRENTLY AND I WOULD
02:18:30.702 --> 02:18:33.405
JUST SAY DURING THE PS PS
02:18:33.471 --> 02:18:33.972
ADVANCE AND THEN IMMEDIATELY
02:18:34.039 --> 02:18:35.940
AFTER THE NUMBER OF. DIESEL
02:18:36.007 --> 02:18:37.475
GENERATORS THEIR PROCURED AND
02:18:37.542 --> 02:18:40.178
NOW ARE LAID OUT THROUGHOUT THE
02:18:40.245 --> 02:18:40.679
STATE IS INCREASED
02:18:40.745 --> 02:18:43.715
TREMENDOUSLY- IT IS WHAT WE
02:18:43.782 --> 02:18:45.850
HAVE TO WORK WITH NOW BUT BUT
02:18:45.917 --> 02:18:47.318
THERE THERE CAN BE NEW
02:18:47.385 --> 02:18:49.154
TECHNOLOGY AND WE KNOW WE'VE
02:18:49.220 --> 02:18:51.389
BEEN TALKING WITH- FOLKS FROM-
02:18:51.456 --> 02:18:53.091
UNIVERSITY SYSTEMS ABOUT MAYBE
02:18:53.158 --> 02:18:55.293
DOING SOME DESIGN- AND IN THE
02:18:55.360 --> 02:18:56.695
DISCUSSIONS WERE HAVING WITH
02:18:56.761 --> 02:18:58.563
OUR TELCO PARTNERS. IS WHAT ARE
02:18:58.630 --> 02:18:59.597
SOME OF THE DIFFERENT WAYS THAT
02:18:59.664 --> 02:19:01.833
WE CAN LOOK TO ADDRESS THIS NOT
02:19:01.900 --> 02:19:03.368
AN EASY SOLUTION YET OR
02:19:03.435 --> 02:19:04.736
SOMETHING THAT COULD BE HAPPEN
02:19:04.803 --> 02:19:06.938
REALLY FAST BUT IT IS SOMETHING
02:19:07.005 --> 02:19:08.273
THAT WE ARE DISCUSSING AND
02:19:08.339 --> 02:19:10.075
WE'RE TRYING TO FIND AND WHERE
02:19:10.141 --> 02:19:12.410
WE CAN PARTICULARLY SOLAR. AND
02:19:12.477 --> 02:19:14.212
RENEWABLE- IS AREA WERE FOLK
02:19:14.279 --> 02:19:15.814
ON. THANK YOU KNOW WHAT'S IT
02:19:15.880 --> 02:19:17.348
WILL LAST LONG TIME THAT MEAN
02:19:17.415 --> 02:19:18.249
YOUR BATTERIES NOW THAT WITH
02:19:18.316 --> 02:19:20.618
ENOUGH SOLAR CAM CAN YOU KNOW
02:19:20.685 --> 02:19:22.087
KEEP KEEP I THINK POWER FOR
02:19:22.153 --> 02:19:23.088
QUITE A LONG TIME DEL. OKAY
02:19:23.154 --> 02:19:25.323
THANK YOU. WE'RE GONNA- NOW
02:19:25.390 --> 02:19:27.292
HEAR FROM THE TELEPHONE
02:19:27.358 --> 02:19:28.626
TELECOMMUNICATIONS PROVIDERS
02:19:28.693 --> 02:19:32.363
AND THEIR- RESPONSES TO THE
02:19:32.430 --> 02:19:34.199
OUTAGES AND THE LESSONS LEARNED
02:19:34.265 --> 02:19:39.104
AND- HOPEFULLY WHAT THEY- PLAN
02:19:39.170 --> 02:19:42.273
TO IMPROVE. THE DELIVERY OF
02:19:42.340 --> 02:19:48.279
SERVICE EACH JOB. IF WE CAN
02:19:48.346 --> 02:19:49.914
HAVE- EVERYONE JUST COME
02:19:49.981 --> 02:19:51.583
FORWARD WE CAN HAVE A STEVE
02:19:51.649 --> 02:19:53.418
CARLSON WITH THE WIRELESS
02:19:53.485 --> 02:19:56.287
ASSOCIATION JEFF LONG. WITH.
02:19:56.354 --> 02:19:58.957
THE WITH A. T. AND T. CONSIDER
02:19:59.023 --> 02:20:02.794
MINUS WITH VERIZON. AND I'M AN
02:20:02.861 --> 02:20:04.395
S. CAROLINE MCINTYRE IF YOU CAN
02:20:04.462 --> 02:20:06.064
ALSO COME UP AND BE PART OF
02:20:06.131 --> 02:20:07.832
THIS PANEL WITH THE
02:20:07.899 --> 02:20:09.501
TELECOMMUNICATIONS ASSOCIATION
02:20:09.567 --> 02:20:13.204
AND JOHN LUNDGREN WITH THE
02:20:13.271 --> 02:20:13.772
VOLCANO TELEPHONE IF YOU CAN
02:20:13.838 --> 02:20:30.155
ALSO JOIN THIS PANEL
02:20:30.922 --> 02:20:31.022
. IS THE
02:20:31.089 --> 02:20:32.891
CHAIR MEMBERS- ON BEHALF OF C.
02:20:32.957 --> 02:20:33.958
T. I A AND CALIFORNIA'S
02:20:34.025 --> 02:20:36.561
WIRELESS INDUSTRY WE ARE
02:20:36.628 --> 02:20:37.195
GRATEFUL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:20:37.262 --> 02:20:39.998
APPEAR BEFORE YOU TODAY. OUR
02:20:40.064 --> 02:20:40.832
COMPANIES ARE AN INTEGRAL PART
02:20:40.899 --> 02:20:42.834
OF CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMIC ENGINE
02:20:42.901 --> 02:20:44.836
SUPPORTING SIX HUNDRED THOUSAND
02:20:44.903 --> 02:20:46.871
WIRELESS RELATED JOBS AND
02:20:46.938 --> 02:20:47.472
SEVENTY THREE BILLION DOLLARS
02:20:47.539 --> 02:20:48.273
IN ANNUAL ECONOMIC
02:20:48.339 --> 02:20:50.175
PRODUCTIVITY. BUT MORE THAN
02:20:50.241 --> 02:20:52.076
THAT WE ARE ALSO PROUD TO BE
02:20:52.143 --> 02:20:54.245
CALIFORNIA'S CONNECTIVE TISSUE.
02:20:54.312 --> 02:20:55.413
CONNECTING AN EMPOWERING MORE
02:20:55.480 --> 02:20:57.916
THAN FORTY MILLION PEOPLE IN
02:20:57.982 --> 02:20:58.516
EVERY DIVERSE COMMUNITY ACROSS
02:20:58.583 --> 02:21:01.553
THE NATION'S LARGEST STATE. OUR
02:21:01.619 --> 02:21:02.821
BUSINESS IS CONNECTING
02:21:02.887 --> 02:21:03.955
CALIFORNIA AND LIKE EVERY
02:21:04.022 --> 02:21:05.990
INDUSTRY IN THE STATE OURS WAS
02:21:06.057 --> 02:21:07.458
IMPACTED BY A HISTORICALLY
02:21:07.525 --> 02:21:10.795
UNPRECEDENTED SERVICE OF POWER
02:21:10.862 --> 02:21:11.362
OUTAGES IN UNIQUE AND OFTEN
02:21:11.429 --> 02:21:13.665
UNPREDICTABLE WAYS. AND YET IN
02:21:13.731 --> 02:21:15.099
THE FACE OF THE MENTAL POWER
02:21:15.166 --> 02:21:16.234
CHALLENGES ARE CALIFORNIA
02:21:16.301 --> 02:21:17.535
COMPANIES WORKED AROUND THE
02:21:17.602 --> 02:21:19.237
CLOCK TO DO EVERYTHING IN THEIR
02:21:19.304 --> 02:21:20.205
POWER TO KEEP OUR CALIFORNIA
02:21:20.271 --> 02:21:22.173
ASSETS OPERATIONAL. INCLUDING
02:21:22.240 --> 02:21:23.508
ALL HANDS DEPLOYMENT OF
02:21:23.575 --> 02:21:24.642
TECHNICAL PERSONNEL AND
02:21:24.709 --> 02:21:26.477
EMERGENCY ASSETS DRAW NOT JUST
02:21:26.544 --> 02:21:29.013
FROM EVERY CORNER OF CALIFORNIA
02:21:29.080 --> 02:21:29.614
BUT AS YOU HEARD IN SOME CASES
02:21:29.681 --> 02:21:31.850
FROM ACROSS THE COUNTRY. AS
02:21:31.916 --> 02:21:33.551
MIGHT BE EXPECTED THE MAGNITUDE
02:21:33.618 --> 02:21:34.285
AND THE UNIQUENESS OF THE
02:21:34.352 --> 02:21:36.254
EVENTS PRESENTED CHALLENGES.
02:21:36.321 --> 02:21:38.523
BUT I CAN ASSURE ALL OF YOU.
02:21:38.590 --> 02:21:39.624
FOR THE SAKE OF THE MILLIONS OF
02:21:39.691 --> 02:21:41.059
CALIFORNIA HOUSEHOLDS AND
02:21:41.125 --> 02:21:42.527
BUSINESSES WHO RELY ON US EVERY
02:21:42.594 --> 02:21:44.762
DAY. TO REACH ONE ANOTHER. THIS
02:21:44.829 --> 02:21:46.631
INDUSTRY STANDS READY TO SHARE
02:21:46.698 --> 02:21:48.099
LESSONS LEARNED AND TO WORK
02:21:48.166 --> 02:21:49.734
WITH THIS LEGISLATURE BUT WE
02:21:49.801 --> 02:21:50.201
ASK YOU SEE AND OTHER
02:21:50.268 --> 02:21:53.638
STAKEHOLDERS. AS CONSTRUCTIVE
02:21:53.705 --> 02:21:54.906
WORKING PARTNERS TO BETTER
02:21:54.973 --> 02:21:55.974
PREPARE OUR STATE ON OUR
02:21:56.040 --> 02:21:58.710
NETWORKS FOR FUTURE EVENTS AND
02:21:58.776 --> 02:21:59.344
THE UNPRECEDENTED NEW NORMAL OF
02:21:59.410 --> 02:22:02.814
P. S. P. S. WE ARE PLEASED TO
02:22:02.881 --> 02:22:04.482
BE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE. TO HEAR
02:22:04.549 --> 02:22:06.017
FROM STATE AND LOCAL PARTIES AS
02:22:06.084 --> 02:22:07.919
WELL AS TO PROVIDE INFORMATION
02:22:07.986 --> 02:22:08.519
THAT MAY BE NEW. TO MEMBERS OF
02:22:08.586 --> 02:22:11.956
THE COMMITTEE. AS I INDICATED
02:22:12.023 --> 02:22:14.459
AS YOU HEARD. PS PS ADVANCE FOR
02:22:14.525 --> 02:22:15.627
UNPRECEDENTED IN THE MOST
02:22:15.693 --> 02:22:16.160
EXTENSIVE IN CALIFORNIA'S
02:22:16.227 --> 02:22:19.530
HISTORY. RESPONDING TO THESE ON
02:22:19.597 --> 02:22:20.798
PRESIDENT OUTAGES WAS A
02:22:20.865 --> 02:22:22.333
COLOSSAL TASK IT WIRELESS
02:22:22.400 --> 02:22:24.068
CARRIERS WERE ABLE TO LARGELY
02:22:24.135 --> 02:22:25.536
MAINTAIN SERVICES WITH
02:22:25.603 --> 02:22:26.504
THOUSANDS OF TECHNICIANS
02:22:26.571 --> 02:22:28.573
WORKING AROUND THE CLOCK. TO
02:22:28.640 --> 02:22:29.173
DEPLOY EMERGENCY ASSETS ACROSS
02:22:29.240 --> 02:22:32.110
THE STATE. THE WIRELESS
02:22:32.176 --> 02:22:33.311
INDUSTRY SUPPORTS THE
02:22:33.378 --> 02:22:34.846
COMMITTEE'S INTEREST IN GOAL IN
02:22:34.913 --> 02:22:35.980
BETTER UNDERSTANDING THE
02:22:36.047 --> 02:22:36.915
CHALLENGES THAT AROSE FROM THE
02:22:36.981 --> 02:22:39.183
P. S. P. S. EVENTS. AND AS WE
02:22:39.250 --> 02:22:40.218
LOOK TOGETHER FOR HOW TO
02:22:40.285 --> 02:22:41.653
ADDRESS THEM IN THE FUTURE
02:22:41.719 --> 02:22:43.688
THERE ARE SOME BASELINE FACTS
02:22:43.755 --> 02:22:44.322
REGARDING THESE EVENTS. THAT WE
02:22:44.389 --> 02:22:46.424
WOULD LIKE TO SHARE. FOR
02:22:46.491 --> 02:22:48.059
EXAMPLE THE FCC'S COMMUNICATION
02:22:48.126 --> 02:22:50.361
STATUS REPORTS SHOW THAT 96% OF
02:22:50.428 --> 02:22:51.729
CELL SITES THROUGHOUT THE
02:22:51.796 --> 02:22:53.131
AFFECTED AREAS. REMAINED
02:22:53.197 --> 02:22:55.099
OPERATIONAL. DESPITE THE FACT
02:22:55.166 --> 02:22:56.935
THAT OVER TWO POINT SEVEN
02:22:57.001 --> 02:22:57.468
MILLION CALIFORNIANS WERE
02:22:57.535 --> 02:23:00.638
WITHOUT POWER. SIMULTANEOUSLY
02:23:00.705 --> 02:23:02.006
SHUTTING OFF POWER TO A LARGE
02:23:02.073 --> 02:23:03.341
PORTION OF THE STATE AT TIMES
02:23:03.408 --> 02:23:04.375
REACHING MORE THAN HALF OF
02:23:04.442 --> 02:23:05.810
CALIFORNIA'S FIFTY EIGHT
02:23:05.877 --> 02:23:07.478
COUNTIES PLACED ON HEARD OF
02:23:07.545 --> 02:23:08.012
CONSTRAINTS AND TELECOM AN
02:23:08.079 --> 02:23:10.515
EXISTING RESOURCES. MAINTAIN
02:23:10.581 --> 02:23:12.450
POWER BARS FACILITIES WITH A
02:23:12.517 --> 02:23:14.152
MOVING TARGET AS THE NATURE AND
02:23:14.218 --> 02:23:16.554
MAGNITUDE OF THE PS PS EVENTS
02:23:16.621 --> 02:23:17.188
MADE IT EXTREMELY DIFFICULT FOR
02:23:17.255 --> 02:23:20.258
ALL INVOLVED. PUBLIC SAFETY
02:23:20.325 --> 02:23:22.126
GOVERNMENT BUSINESS TO KNOW
02:23:22.193 --> 02:23:24.495
EXACTLY WHEN AND WHERE THE SHUT
02:23:24.562 --> 02:23:25.063
OUTS WOULD OCCUR AND FOR HOW
02:23:25.129 --> 02:23:27.732
LONG THEY WOULD CONTINUE. AS
02:23:27.799 --> 02:23:29.033
NOTED WIRELESS NETWORKS ARE
02:23:29.100 --> 02:23:29.901
DESIGNED WITH NUMEROUS
02:23:29.968 --> 02:23:31.602
OVERLAPPING CELL SITES THAT MAY
02:23:31.669 --> 02:23:33.037
PROVIDE MAXIMUM CAPACITY AND
02:23:33.104 --> 02:23:35.106
CONTINUITY OF SERVICE EVEN WHEN
02:23:35.173 --> 02:23:35.606
AN INDIVIDUAL SITE AS AN
02:23:35.673 --> 02:23:38.409
OPERABLE. COMMERCIAL POWER IS
02:23:38.476 --> 02:23:40.078
CRITICAL TO PROVIDING TELECOM
02:23:40.144 --> 02:23:41.746
SERVICES AND COMPREHENSIVE BACK
02:23:41.813 --> 02:23:43.982
POWERS BACKUP POWER SYSTEMS ARE
02:23:44.048 --> 02:23:45.850
REQUIRED TO MEET A VARIETY OF
02:23:45.917 --> 02:23:46.317
NEEDS AND A VARIETY OF
02:23:46.384 --> 02:23:48.953
CIRCUMSTANCES. EVERY NETWORK IS
02:23:49.020 --> 02:23:50.455
UNIQUELY DESIGNED AND POWER
02:23:50.521 --> 02:23:52.123
FAILURES ESPECIALLY THOSE OF
02:23:52.190 --> 02:23:53.725
THE MAGNITUDE OF P. S. P. S.
02:23:53.791 --> 02:23:55.360
CANNOT BE SOLVED BY A ONE SIZE
02:23:55.426 --> 02:23:58.563
FITS ALL APPROACH. MOST
02:23:58.629 --> 02:24:00.164
FACILITIES HAVE BATTERY BACKUP
02:24:00.231 --> 02:24:01.666
SOLUTIONS WHILE FIX GENERATORS
02:24:01.733 --> 02:24:03.134
ARE OFTEN PERMANENTLY INSTALLED
02:24:03.201 --> 02:24:04.402
AT SITES WERE STRICTLY
02:24:04.469 --> 02:24:06.971
FEASIBLE. PERMITTED BY STATE
02:24:07.038 --> 02:24:07.572
AND LOCAL LAWS IN STATE TO DO
02:24:07.638 --> 02:24:10.208
SO. IN ADDITION PORTABLE
02:24:10.274 --> 02:24:12.010
GENERATORS ALLOW LONG TERM AND
02:24:12.076 --> 02:24:14.045
FLEXIBLE POWER TO BE RAPIDLY
02:24:14.112 --> 02:24:15.113
DEPLOYED TO STRATEGIC HIGH
02:24:15.179 --> 02:24:17.382
PRIORITY SITES. INCLUDING THOSE
02:24:17.448 --> 02:24:17.982
SERVING THE GREATEST NUMBER OF
02:24:18.049 --> 02:24:20.852
CUSTOMERS. THROUGHOUT THE PS PS
02:24:20.918 --> 02:24:22.453
PROCESS CARRIERS FOLLOWED
02:24:22.520 --> 02:24:24.055
ESTABLISHED PROTOCOLS AND
02:24:24.122 --> 02:24:24.922
PROVIDED DETAILED STATUS OF
02:24:24.989 --> 02:24:27.225
PLATES THREE TIMES A DAY. TO
02:24:27.291 --> 02:24:28.259
THE CALIFORNIA UTILITIES
02:24:28.326 --> 02:24:31.062
EMERGENCY ASSOCIATION EMBEDDED
02:24:31.129 --> 02:24:31.696
WITHIN THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF
02:24:31.763 --> 02:24:34.732
EMERGENCY SERVICES. PROVIDE
02:24:34.799 --> 02:24:35.967
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT TO VICTIMS
02:24:36.034 --> 02:24:37.101
OF WILDFIRES CARE IS ALSO
02:24:37.168 --> 02:24:38.503
ESTABLISHED RESOURCES AT
02:24:38.569 --> 02:24:40.304
EVACUATION CENTERS ACROSS THE
02:24:40.371 --> 02:24:41.606
STATE WITH ON SITE CHARGING
02:24:41.672 --> 02:24:43.841
STATIONS ACCESS TO VOICE IN MY
02:24:43.908 --> 02:24:44.842
FIVE SERVICES AND OTHER
02:24:44.909 --> 02:24:46.978
CUSTOMER SUPPORT AS WELL AS
02:24:47.045 --> 02:24:47.578
PROVIDING ADDITIONAL SUPPORT.
02:24:47.645 --> 02:24:49.847
TO PUBLIC SAFETY ENTITIES. CARE
02:24:49.914 --> 02:24:51.649
IS ALSO A OFFERED UNLIMITED
02:24:51.716 --> 02:24:53.451
VOICE TEXT AND DATA SERVICES TO
02:24:53.518 --> 02:24:55.386
AFFECTED CUSTOMERS BY OFFERING
02:24:55.453 --> 02:24:55.987
CREDITS AND OR WAVING OVERAGE
02:24:56.054 --> 02:24:59.090
CHARGES. AS MOST OF THE STATE
02:24:59.157 --> 02:25:01.426
LEARNS HOW TO BETTER COPE WITH
02:25:01.492 --> 02:25:01.959
THE SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS OF
02:25:02.026 --> 02:25:04.228
SIGNIFICANT POWER SHUTDOWNS.
02:25:04.295 --> 02:25:05.596
CARRIERS TO OUR LEARNING HOW TO
02:25:05.663 --> 02:25:06.631
ADAPT TO REGULAR ON
02:25:06.697 --> 02:25:08.366
AVAILABILITY OF COMMERCIAL
02:25:08.433 --> 02:25:09.700
POWER AND HOW BEST TO MAINTAIN
02:25:09.767 --> 02:25:12.136
NETWORK OPERATIONS UNDER SUCH
02:25:12.203 --> 02:25:12.637
PREVIOUSLY EXTRAORDINARY
02:25:12.703 --> 02:25:15.306
CIRCUMSTANCES. AS ONE
02:25:15.373 --> 02:25:16.541
RECOMMENDATION TO BUILD ON
02:25:16.607 --> 02:25:18.876
GOING FORWARD WE WOULD SUGGEST
02:25:18.943 --> 02:25:19.777
AND AS WE'VE HEARD AND ACTUALLY
02:25:19.844 --> 02:25:22.447
WAS VERY PLEASED TO HEAR FROM-
02:25:22.513 --> 02:25:24.482
FROM FROM BUT- DIRECTOR GUARD
02:25:24.549 --> 02:25:25.583
TO CHEAP. OUT FROM PRESIDENT
02:25:25.650 --> 02:25:27.852
BACHELOR. THAT PUBLIC SAFETY
02:25:27.919 --> 02:25:29.921
AGENCIES REGULATORS OTHER
02:25:29.987 --> 02:25:31.522
STAKEHOLDERS SIT DOWN TOGETHER
02:25:31.589 --> 02:25:34.759
AND IDENTIFY HOW WE CAN MOST
02:25:34.826 --> 02:25:35.193
SUCCESSFULLY WORK IN
02:25:35.259 --> 02:25:35.793
PARTNERSHIP DURING FUTURE SET
02:25:35.860 --> 02:25:38.162
UP. NOT NECESSARILY IN
02:25:38.229 --> 02:25:40.298
SITUATIONS LIKE THIS WHICH IS
02:25:40.364 --> 02:25:43.434
REQUIRED- OVERSIGHT. BUT
02:25:43.501 --> 02:25:44.869
INFORMALLY AROUND THE TABLE
02:25:44.936 --> 02:25:46.537
OKAY WHAT DID YOU SEE HOW TO
02:25:46.604 --> 02:25:48.639
JUST SEE WHAT WORKED WHAT
02:25:48.706 --> 02:25:50.141
DIDN'T. BECAUSE WHEN WE GET IT
02:25:50.208 --> 02:25:52.110
IN THE PROCEEDINGS CIRCUMSTANCE
02:25:52.176 --> 02:25:54.378
WERE IN FRONT OF A COMMITTEE-
02:25:54.445 --> 02:25:56.914
THE ABILITY TO KIND OF- TO
02:25:56.981 --> 02:25:58.683
ENGAGE IN IN THAT THE KIND OF
02:25:58.750 --> 02:25:59.984
DIALOGUE THAT WE THINK IS
02:26:00.051 --> 02:26:02.620
REALLY THE WAY TO DO THIS
02:26:02.687 --> 02:26:04.722
SOMETIMES. SOMETIMES IS LACKING.
02:26:04.789 --> 02:26:06.224
SO WITH THAT WE ARE COMMITTED
02:26:06.290 --> 02:26:07.358
TO CONTINUE OUR WORK TOGETHER
02:26:07.425 --> 02:26:08.759
WITH THE STATE TO REPLACE
02:26:08.826 --> 02:26:11.162
IDENTIFIED OBSTACLES AND I DID.
02:26:11.229 --> 02:26:12.263
ALSO WANTED TO POINT OUT THAT
02:26:12.330 --> 02:26:13.998
THE SUGGESTION OF STREAMLINING
02:26:14.065 --> 02:26:15.833
WAS VERY IMPORTANT WE THINK AS
02:26:15.900 --> 02:26:17.335
WE TRY TO ADDRESS SOME OF THE
02:26:17.401 --> 02:26:18.636
CONCERNS WE HAD AND THE AND THE
02:26:18.703 --> 02:26:21.005
OBSTACLES WE HAD STREAMLINING.
02:26:21.072 --> 02:26:22.907
THE APPROACH TO BE ABLE TO DO
02:26:22.974 --> 02:26:24.175
WITH THAT I THINK IT'S Vç IS
02:26:24.242 --> 02:26:27.979
VERY IMPORTANT. AND THE OTHER
02:26:28.045 --> 02:26:29.647
ISSUE I DIDN'T WANT A PLAYOFF
02:26:29.714 --> 02:26:32.150
AND A AND THE- CHAIR WEST SO
02:26:32.216 --> 02:26:33.417
WAS VERY MUCH INVOLVED WITH
02:26:33.484 --> 02:26:35.987
THIS IS THE ABILITY TO BRING ON
02:26:36.053 --> 02:26:37.255
NEW INFRASTRUCTURE NOT JUST
02:26:37.321 --> 02:26:38.389
UPGRADE THE EXISTING
02:26:38.456 --> 02:26:40.124
INFRASTRUCTURE BUT- AS YOU
02:26:40.191 --> 02:26:42.727
BRING A NEW INFRASTRUCTURE YOU
02:26:42.793 --> 02:26:44.896
CREATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO- TO
02:26:44.962 --> 02:26:46.831
PUT. SERVICE IN AREAS WHERE
02:26:46.898 --> 02:26:49.834
OTHERS MAY BE MAY GO DOWN- THAT
02:26:49.901 --> 02:26:51.502
STILL A REAL CHALLENGE AND IT'S
02:26:51.569 --> 02:26:53.137
A BIG CHALLENGE AND SOME OF THE
02:26:53.204 --> 02:26:54.505
AREAS THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
02:26:54.572 --> 02:26:56.841
THE WANTED T. THAT UP- FOR THE
02:26:56.908 --> 02:26:59.610
GROUP ANYWAY- WANTED TO. THIS
02:26:59.677 --> 02:27:01.512
OVER TO OUR OUR WITNESSES
02:27:01.579 --> 02:27:04.882
PEOPLE WHO HAVE DEALT WITH THIS
02:27:04.949 --> 02:27:05.516
ON THE GROUND LET ME START WITH
02:27:05.583 --> 02:27:08.085
JEFF LEON OF EIGHTEEN T. GOOD
02:27:08.152 --> 02:27:09.153
MORNING CHAIR AT. MY NAME IS
02:27:09.220 --> 02:27:10.021
JEFF LONG I'M THE VICE
02:27:10.087 --> 02:27:11.389
PRESIDENT OF ACCESS
02:27:11.455 --> 02:27:12.924
CONSTRUCTION AND ENGINEERING
02:27:12.990 --> 02:27:14.725
FOR EIGHTEEN ANTI. MY TEAM IS
02:27:14.792 --> 02:27:16.561
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PLANNING
02:27:16.627 --> 02:27:17.828
ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION
02:27:17.895 --> 02:27:19.697
MAINTENANCE AND OPERATION OF
02:27:19.764 --> 02:27:20.798
WIRELESS AND WIRELINE
02:27:20.865 --> 02:27:24.068
FACILITIES. ACROSS THE WESTERN
02:27:24.135 --> 02:27:24.569
UNITED STATES INCLUDING
02:27:24.635 --> 02:27:27.705
CALIFORNIA. I PREVIOUSLY HAD
02:27:27.772 --> 02:27:29.740
NATION WIDE RESPONSIBILITY FOR
02:27:29.807 --> 02:27:31.542
WIRELESS BUILD AN OPERATIONS
02:27:31.609 --> 02:27:32.877
WHICH INCLUDES DISASTER
02:27:32.944 --> 02:27:35.112
RECOVERY. IN THE AFTERMATH OF
02:27:35.179 --> 02:27:37.949
MANY NATURAL DISASTERS
02:27:38.015 --> 02:27:38.983
INCLUDING HURRICANE MARIA
02:27:39.050 --> 02:27:41.285
SANDY. AND THE CALIFORNIA
02:27:41.352 --> 02:27:43.955
WILDFIRES OVER THE PAST FEW
02:27:44.021 --> 02:27:44.522
YEARS AND EVERYTHING ELSE IN
02:27:44.589 --> 02:27:47.191
BETWEEN. THANK YOU FOR
02:27:47.258 --> 02:27:48.826
CONVENING THIS HEARING I
02:27:48.893 --> 02:27:49.427
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
02:27:49.493 --> 02:27:51.929
BE HERE BEFORE YOU TODAY. AT
02:27:51.996 --> 02:27:53.631
THE OUTSET I WANT TO SAY THAT
02:27:53.698 --> 02:27:55.499
WE ARE COMMITTED TO PROVIDING
02:27:55.566 --> 02:27:57.702
COMMUNICATION SERVICES THAT THE
02:27:57.768 --> 02:27:58.803
PUBLIC. AND PUBLIC SAFETY
02:27:58.869 --> 02:28:01.272
AGENCY CAN RELY ON. EIGHTEEN T.
02:28:01.339 --> 02:28:03.274
HAS OPERATED IN CALIFORNIA FOR
02:28:03.341 --> 02:28:05.476
OVER ON YOU FORTY YEARS. WE
02:28:05.543 --> 02:28:06.577
HAVE WORKED THROUGH MANY
02:28:06.644 --> 02:28:08.446
EMERGENCIES. AND ENGAGE WITH
02:28:08.512 --> 02:28:11.582
THE PUBLIC ON EVERY LEVEL. I'LL
02:28:11.649 --> 02:28:13.284
TELL YOU THAT FROM MY TEAMS
02:28:13.351 --> 02:28:15.620
PERSPECTIVE WE HAVE THAT
02:28:15.686 --> 02:28:16.153
HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE WORKING
02:28:16.220 --> 02:28:20.825
TIRELESSLY. BEFORE DURING AND
02:28:20.891 --> 02:28:23.227
AFTER EACH OF THESE EVENTS TO
02:28:23.294 --> 02:28:25.963
DEPLOY HUNDREDS OF ASSETS
02:28:26.030 --> 02:28:27.898
ENSURING THAT WE HAVE GREATER
02:28:27.965 --> 02:28:31.369
RELIABILITY LEVENTIS THAT. I
02:28:31.435 --> 02:28:31.936
AGREE WITH EVERYTHING STEVE
02:28:32.003 --> 02:28:35.673
SAID I WANT TO PROVIDE SOME
02:28:35.740 --> 02:28:37.441
INSIGHT ON WHAT EIGHTEEN T.
02:28:37.508 --> 02:28:39.243
DOING TO DEAL WITH THE NEW
02:28:39.310 --> 02:28:41.345
NORMAL FOR THE FUTURE OF P. S.
02:28:41.412 --> 02:28:43.347
P. S. EVENTS. AT SOME OF THE
02:28:43.414 --> 02:28:45.516
CHALLENGES THAT WE FACE. LET ME
02:28:45.583 --> 02:28:47.184
BE BRIEF TOP BUT THREE ACTIONS
02:28:47.251 --> 02:28:51.055
THAT WE'RE TAKING. FIRST. WE
02:28:51.122 --> 02:28:52.790
HAVE IMPLEMENTED REPORTING
02:28:52.857 --> 02:28:55.726
PROTOCOLS IN ACCORDANCE WITH SB
02:28:55.793 --> 02:28:56.794
FIVE SIXTY AND WILL CONTINUE TO
02:28:56.861 --> 02:28:58.329
WORK OF OUR PUBLIC SAFETY
02:28:58.396 --> 02:28:59.597
PARTNERS ON ENGAGEMENT DURING
02:28:59.664 --> 02:29:01.732
DISASTERS THIS WILL INCLUDE
02:29:01.799 --> 02:29:03.034
DISCUSSIONS WITH ELECTED
02:29:03.100 --> 02:29:05.970
OFFICIALS STATE COUNTY TRIBAL
02:29:06.037 --> 02:29:08.572
EMERGENCY RESPONSE PERSONNEL.
02:29:08.639 --> 02:29:10.308
WORKING WITH THE CALIFORNIA
02:29:10.374 --> 02:29:13.277
UTILITY EMERGENCY ASSOCIATION.
02:29:13.344 --> 02:29:14.945
ON COMMUNICATIONS STATE AND THE
02:29:15.012 --> 02:29:17.682
HEARING WILL ALSO WORK WITH THE
02:29:17.748 --> 02:29:18.816
POWER COMPANIES TO ENSURE THAT
02:29:18.883 --> 02:29:21.852
TIMELY ACCURATE CRITICAL
02:29:21.919 --> 02:29:24.288
INFORMATION IS RECEIVED TO
02:29:24.355 --> 02:29:24.822
IMPROVE OUR RESPONSE GOING
02:29:24.889 --> 02:29:29.026
FORWARD. SECOND. WE HAVE
02:29:29.093 --> 02:29:30.328
CONVENE AN EXECUTIVE LEVEL
02:29:30.394 --> 02:29:32.530
STRIKE FORCE TO ENHANCE NETWORK
02:29:32.596 --> 02:29:34.031
RELIABILITY FOR THE NEXT FAR
02:29:34.098 --> 02:29:37.234
SEASON ACTIONS TRIGGERED
02:29:37.301 --> 02:29:39.537
INCLUDE INCREASED DEPLOYMENT OF
02:29:39.603 --> 02:29:42.139
FIX GENERATORS AUGMENTING
02:29:42.206 --> 02:29:44.075
HUNDREDS OF EXISTING CRITICAL
02:29:44.141 --> 02:29:47.011
SITES AND AT STEVE MENTION ALSO
02:29:47.078 --> 02:29:50.848
BUILDING HUNDREDS OF NEW CELL
02:29:50.915 --> 02:29:51.982
SITES WOULD FIX GENERATORS.
02:29:52.049 --> 02:29:57.021
ORDERS WERE ALREADY PLACE FOR
02:29:57.088 --> 02:29:58.289
HUNDREDS OF ADDITIONAL PORTABLE
02:29:58.356 --> 02:30:00.991
GENERATORS WE MANUFACTURE
02:30:01.058 --> 02:30:02.259
COMMITMENT TO START DELIVERY.
02:30:02.326 --> 02:30:05.529
IN THE COMING MONTHS. BATTERY
02:30:05.596 --> 02:30:09.734
ENHANCEMENTS. AUTOMATION
02:30:09.800 --> 02:30:10.568
INCLUDING ARTIFICIAL
02:30:10.634 --> 02:30:13.437
INTELLIGENCE FOR POWER
02:30:13.504 --> 02:30:14.071
MANAGEMENT CAPABILITIES ALSO ON
02:30:14.138 --> 02:30:17.942
THE WAY. IN THE RECENT PS PS
02:30:18.008 --> 02:30:20.845
THE VENTS MY TEAM WORKS HARD TO
02:30:20.911 --> 02:30:22.113
MAINTAIN COMMUNICATIONS
02:30:22.179 --> 02:30:24.915
ULTIMATELY ACHIEVING WIRELESS
02:30:24.982 --> 02:30:27.084
COVERAGE AT 97% OF NORMAL
02:30:27.151 --> 02:30:30.388
WITHIN THAT THIRTY FOUR AFFECT
02:30:30.454 --> 02:30:30.955
THE COUNTIES DURING THE PEAK
02:30:31.021 --> 02:30:33.958
HOLIDAY IN OCTOBER. HOWEVER OUR
02:30:34.024 --> 02:30:38.195
GOAL IS ALWAYS A 100% SO WE
02:30:38.262 --> 02:30:38.763
NEED TO BE THE- BEST A MORE
02:30:38.829 --> 02:30:41.265
NEEDS TO BE DONE. GIVEN THE
02:30:41.332 --> 02:30:43.401
ACTIONS THAT WE HAVE TAKEN. IF
02:30:43.467 --> 02:30:46.303
THE SAME INCIDENT WERE TO OCCUR
02:30:46.370 --> 02:30:49.039
IN TWENTY TWENTY WE WILL BE
02:30:49.106 --> 02:30:50.641
EVEN BETTER PREPARED TO RESPOND.
02:30:50.708 --> 02:30:55.846
FINALLY. WE ARE PREPARED TO
02:30:55.913 --> 02:30:57.348
DRAMATICALLY IN WE INCREASE
02:30:57.415 --> 02:30:59.250
CAPITAL INVESTMENT TO TRANSFORM
02:30:59.316 --> 02:31:02.153
OUR NETWORK IN RESPONSE TO THIS
02:31:02.219 --> 02:31:03.687
NEW NORMAL OF MASSIVE POWER
02:31:03.754 --> 02:31:07.625
SHUT OFFS. OUR GOAL WE HOPE OUR
02:31:07.691 --> 02:31:09.160
COMMERCIAL POWER COMPANIES WILL
02:31:09.226 --> 02:31:12.663
BE MORE LIMITED. AND PRECISE IN
02:31:12.730 --> 02:31:13.564
HOW THE IMPLEMENT P. S. P. S.
02:31:13.631 --> 02:31:16.033
EVENTS GOING FORWARD WE STRIVE
02:31:16.100 --> 02:31:18.436
TO HAVE A ROBUST NETWORK THAT
02:31:18.502 --> 02:31:20.404
WILL WITHSTAND THE SCALE OF
02:31:20.471 --> 02:31:22.473
OUTAGES THAT WE EXPERIENCE IN
02:31:22.540 --> 02:31:25.810
NORTHERN CALIFORNIA. OUR PLAN
02:31:25.876 --> 02:31:28.345
IS TO BUILD OVER EIGHT THOUSAND
02:31:28.412 --> 02:31:31.449
ADDITIONAL FIX GENERATORS. AT
02:31:31.515 --> 02:31:32.583
OTHER ALTERNATIVE POWER
02:31:32.650 --> 02:31:33.884
RESOURCES AT NEW YOU AN
02:31:33.951 --> 02:31:37.121
EXISTING CELL SITES. THE
02:31:37.188 --> 02:31:38.322
CHALLENGES THAT WE FACE IN
02:31:38.389 --> 02:31:41.625
OBTAINING PERMITS FOR OVER A
02:31:41.692 --> 02:31:42.760
THOUSAND NEW GENERATORS IS A
02:31:42.827 --> 02:31:46.263
MONUMENTAL UNDERTAKING. DUE TO
02:31:46.330 --> 02:31:47.865
INCONSISTENT REQUIREMENTS
02:31:47.932 --> 02:31:50.134
ACROSS JURISDICTIONS LINK THE
02:31:50.201 --> 02:31:52.536
REVIEW TIMES OWNERS AND WE DONE
02:31:52.603 --> 02:31:54.472
THEM PERMITTING CONDITIONS WE
02:31:54.538 --> 02:31:57.374
EXPECT IT COULD TAKE THREE TO
02:31:57.441 --> 02:31:59.810
FIVE YEARS TO GET ALL THOSE
02:31:59.877 --> 02:32:00.344
GENERATORS PERMIT BUILT AN
02:32:00.411 --> 02:32:04.281
OPERATIONAL. WE WOULD LIKE TO
02:32:04.348 --> 02:32:05.716
GO FASTER. AND WE WANT TO GO
02:32:05.783 --> 02:32:08.519
FASTER BUT THAT WOULD TAKE SOME
02:32:08.586 --> 02:32:08.986
CHANGES IN THE CURRENT
02:32:09.053 --> 02:32:12.122
PERMITTING STRUCTURE. THE CIVIC
02:32:12.189 --> 02:32:12.623
LEE WE BELIEVE THAT SOME
02:32:12.690 --> 02:32:15.926
TARGETED PERMITTING. TARGETED
02:32:15.993 --> 02:32:18.596
PERMITTING STREAMLINING EFFORTS
02:32:18.662 --> 02:32:22.066
FOR STANDARDIZED FIX GENERATORS.
02:32:22.132 --> 02:32:23.801
COULD ALLOW US TO COMPLETE THE
02:32:23.868 --> 02:32:25.703
BILL OF ALL FIX GENERATOR SITES
02:32:25.769 --> 02:32:28.772
WITHIN ONE TO THREE YEARS.
02:32:28.839 --> 02:32:30.941
EIGHTEEN ANTI IS ALSO EXPLORING
02:32:31.008 --> 02:32:32.810
INNOVATIVE ALTERNATIVE ENERGY
02:32:32.877 --> 02:32:35.346
TECHNOLOGIES INCLUDING HOW YOU
02:32:35.412 --> 02:32:35.880
DOING FUEL CELLS AND SOLAR
02:32:35.946 --> 02:32:39.950
POWER. LET ME CONCLUDE BY
02:32:40.017 --> 02:32:41.385
SAYING AGAIN THANK YOU FOR
02:32:41.452 --> 02:32:42.820
CONVENING THE DISCUSSION TODAY
02:32:42.887 --> 02:32:44.688
WE APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY
02:32:44.755 --> 02:32:45.222
TO BE HERE TO ANSWER YOUR
02:32:45.289 --> 02:32:48.058
QUESTIONS. AT AND T. IS
02:32:48.125 --> 02:32:49.527
PREPARED TO HELP MEET THE
02:32:49.593 --> 02:32:52.897
EXTRAORDINARY CHALLENGES.
02:32:52.963 --> 02:32:54.265
CALIFORNIA FACES WE HAVE
02:32:54.331 --> 02:32:57.334
INVESTED AND ARE PREPARED TO
02:32:57.401 --> 02:32:59.203
IMPROVE OUR NETWORK RELIABILITY
02:32:59.270 --> 02:33:01.805
FOR THE NEXT FAR SEASON FURTHER
02:33:01.872 --> 02:33:03.674
WE ARE READY TO INCREASE
02:33:03.741 --> 02:33:05.476
INVESTMENT TO TRANSFORM OUR
02:33:05.543 --> 02:33:07.678
NETWORK TO ADDRESS WIDESPREAD
02:33:07.745 --> 02:33:10.180
PS PS EVENTS. EIGHTEEN ANTI
02:33:10.247 --> 02:33:11.515
WILL CONTINUE TO ACHIEVE
02:33:11.582 --> 02:33:12.850
IMPROVE RESULTS FOR OUR
02:33:12.917 --> 02:33:15.619
CUSTOMERS AND YOUR CONSTITUENTS
02:33:15.686 --> 02:33:18.188
IT IS ESSENTIAL THAT WE IMPROVE
02:33:18.255 --> 02:33:19.924
COLLABORATION AND CLOUT AND
02:33:19.990 --> 02:33:21.759
COOPERATION AMONGST THE
02:33:21.825 --> 02:33:23.961
AGENCIES ELECTED OFFICIALS OUR
02:33:24.028 --> 02:33:25.963
CUSTOMERS AND TELECOMMUNICATION
02:33:26.030 --> 02:33:30.167
INDUSTRIES THANK YOU. THE
02:33:30.234 --> 02:33:32.536
MORNING- MISTER CHAIR GOOD
02:33:32.603 --> 02:33:33.437
MORNING SENATORS- MY NAME'S HAS
02:33:33.504 --> 02:33:35.072
HIS FROM MINE I'M THE CHIEF
02:33:35.139 --> 02:33:37.341
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL FOR VERIZON
02:33:37.408 --> 02:33:39.443
I HAVE NEXT TO ME AT MY RIGHT
02:33:39.510 --> 02:33:41.312
TO IT IS SAW SCOTT STEWART HE'S
02:33:41.378 --> 02:33:42.880
OUR NETWORK ENGINEER HE BUILT
02:33:42.947 --> 02:33:44.381
OUR SYSTEM WILL BE AVAILABLE
02:33:44.448 --> 02:33:46.617
FOR. A MORE TECHNICAL QUESTIONS
02:33:46.684 --> 02:33:48.852
I ALSO WANT TO THANK OUR
02:33:48.919 --> 02:33:51.121
PARTNERS IN GOVERNMENT-
02:33:51.188 --> 02:33:53.057
DIRECTOR GERD DO SHE FOR HIS
02:33:53.123 --> 02:33:55.326
COMMENTS AND PRESIDENT BACHELOR
02:33:55.392 --> 02:33:56.660
FOR HER COMMENTS ALONG WITH THE
02:33:56.727 --> 02:34:00.097
REST OF THE PANELISTS- WE ARE
02:34:00.164 --> 02:34:02.066
IN A SITUATION OF ON PRESIDENTE
02:34:02.132 --> 02:34:04.168
AT- POWER SHUT OFF THIS IS
02:34:04.234 --> 02:34:05.803
SOMETHING NEW WE DID NOT
02:34:05.869 --> 02:34:09.106
EXPERIENCED US IN THE PAST TO
02:34:09.173 --> 02:34:09.907
THE EXTENT THAT WE HAD THIS
02:34:09.974 --> 02:34:14.411
PAST YEAR. BOB ARISES IT WAS A
02:34:14.478 --> 02:34:16.547
VERY PROUD YES THE DAY. ABOUT
02:34:16.614 --> 02:34:18.682
HOW OUR NETWORK CONTINUE TO
02:34:18.749 --> 02:34:23.087
SERVE OUR CUSTOMERS DURING-
02:34:23.153 --> 02:34:23.687
THESE PROACTIVE SHOT OFFICE IN
02:34:23.754 --> 02:34:27.024
OCTOBER. I WANT TO NOW
02:34:27.091 --> 02:34:29.326
VERIZON'S STEPPED UP. NUMBER
02:34:29.393 --> 02:34:30.260
ONE IS WE'VE ALWAYS BEEN
02:34:30.327 --> 02:34:31.228
PROACTIVE BUT EVEN MORE
02:34:31.295 --> 02:34:31.795
PROACTIVE IN PREPARING OUR
02:34:31.862 --> 02:34:32.763
NETWORK WITH BACKUP POWER
02:34:32.830 --> 02:34:35.599
SOURCES ALL OF OUR MACROS WHICH
02:34:35.666 --> 02:34:37.267
PROVIDE THE COVERAGE FOR
02:34:37.334 --> 02:34:38.669
CONNECTIVITY HAVE BACKUP POWER
02:34:38.736 --> 02:34:41.472
SOURCES AND MOST OF THEM HAVE
02:34:41.538 --> 02:34:45.376
GENERATORS THAT PROVIDE BOB
02:34:45.442 --> 02:34:46.010
BACKUP POWER FOR TWENTY FOUR TO
02:34:46.076 --> 02:34:48.846
SEVENTY TWO HOURS. WE WERE ALSO
02:34:48.912 --> 02:34:51.281
VERY PROACTIVE IN COMMUNICATING
02:34:51.348 --> 02:34:53.017
WITH STAKEHOLDERS ABOUT THE
02:34:53.083 --> 02:34:54.818
POTENTIAL IMPACTS OF THE
02:34:54.885 --> 02:34:59.023
NETWORK SO WHILE OUR NETWORK IS.
02:34:59.089 --> 02:35:00.424
VERY RESILIENT WITH BACKUP
02:35:00.491 --> 02:35:02.426
POWER SOURCES WE KNOW THAT
02:35:02.493 --> 02:35:02.960
THERE ARE CERTAIN CERTAIN
02:35:03.027 --> 02:35:05.763
DISCRETE AREAS THAT- WILL
02:35:05.829 --> 02:35:07.831
SUFFER DEGRADATION OR LOSS OF
02:35:07.898 --> 02:35:11.468
POWER DURING A POWER OUTAGE I'M
02:35:11.535 --> 02:35:12.002
ONE OF THOSE PLACES ARE A
02:35:12.069 --> 02:35:12.970
CENTER SKINNER IN THE BERKELEY
02:35:13.037 --> 02:35:15.039
HILLS- OAKLAND HILLS- WE
02:35:15.105 --> 02:35:16.173
ACTUALLY HAVE BEEN THINKING
02:35:16.240 --> 02:35:17.641
ABOUT THAT QUITE A BIT AND COME
02:35:17.708 --> 02:35:20.210
UP WITH A SOLUTION FOR THAT.
02:35:20.277 --> 02:35:21.245
I'M AFRAID YOU MIGHT OF
02:35:21.311 --> 02:35:22.713
THROWING A LITTLE BIT OF COLD
02:35:22.780 --> 02:35:25.182
WATER ON OUR SOLUTION BOB IT'S
02:35:25.249 --> 02:35:25.749
COUPLE TO SPEAK TO WITHOUT A
02:35:25.816 --> 02:35:30.154
LITTLE LATER. WE AT OURSELVES
02:35:30.220 --> 02:35:32.589
WITH- SO IN TERMS OF THE
02:35:32.656 --> 02:35:35.893
PROACTIVE COMMUNICATING- WE
02:35:35.959 --> 02:35:38.495
ARE. SPOKE WITH CALLOW YES
02:35:38.562 --> 02:35:40.564
PRIOR TO THE POWER SHUT OFF WE
02:35:40.631 --> 02:35:42.399
SPOKE WITH- DIFFERENT
02:35:42.466 --> 02:35:44.201
LEGISLATORS. WITH CITY COUNCIL
02:35:44.268 --> 02:35:46.370
MEMBERS WITH LOCAL YOU'LL SEIZE
02:35:46.437 --> 02:35:48.872
ABOUT WHERE WE WOULD EXPECT TO
02:35:48.939 --> 02:35:51.508
HAVE SOME POTENTIAL. IMPACTS ON
02:35:51.575 --> 02:35:53.444
OUR NETWORK. THIS WAS SOMETHING
02:35:53.510 --> 02:35:55.646
NEW FOR US OUR- UNDERSTANDING
02:35:55.713 --> 02:35:58.615
HOW WIDESPREAD. THIS POWER
02:35:58.682 --> 02:36:00.417
OUTAGE WAS GOING TO BE WE SAID
02:36:00.484 --> 02:36:03.020
THIS IS NOT A TIME FOR US TO.
02:36:03.087 --> 02:36:04.922
TO WAIT AND REACT WE HAVE TO BE
02:36:04.988 --> 02:36:07.357
PROACTIVE SO WE ACTUALLY WENT
02:36:07.424 --> 02:36:11.695
OUT AND SPOKE WITH- A LOT OF
02:36:11.762 --> 02:36:14.031
FOLKS AND LET THEM KNOW. EXIT
02:36:14.098 --> 02:36:14.631
THE FOLS ABOUT WHAT'S GOING TO
02:36:14.698 --> 02:36:18.035
HAPPEN ON OUR NETWORK. IN THAT
02:36:18.102 --> 02:36:19.703
IT OURSELVES A CALLOW YES STATE
02:36:19.770 --> 02:36:20.437
OPERATIONS CENTER AND OPENLY
02:36:20.504 --> 02:36:22.306
AND CONSISTENTLY COMMUNICATE
02:36:22.372 --> 02:36:23.340
WITH CARILLO YES TO PROVIDE
02:36:23.407 --> 02:36:25.375
THEM REAL TIME- MISSION
02:36:25.442 --> 02:36:27.644
CRITICAL INFORMATION. IN FACT
02:36:27.711 --> 02:36:31.315
ON DAY ONE- WE HAD A FELLOW
02:36:31.381 --> 02:36:34.084
NAMED JOHN LAWLER AT FOUR PM
02:36:34.151 --> 02:36:35.853
AVAILABLE FOR THE BRIEFING THAT
02:36:35.919 --> 02:36:37.287
CALLOW YES HAD ONE DAY
02:36:37.354 --> 02:36:39.490
TRIGGERED. THEIR LEVEL ONE OUR
02:36:39.556 --> 02:36:41.759
STATE OPERATIONS CENTER SO AND
02:36:41.825 --> 02:36:43.327
I KNOW PRESIDENT BACHELOR-
02:36:43.393 --> 02:36:44.261
MENTIONED THAT THERE WERE VERY
02:36:44.328 --> 02:36:48.565
FEW PEOPLE THERE- THAT VERY
02:36:48.632 --> 02:36:49.166
FIRST DAY WELL WE WERE ONE OF
02:36:49.233 --> 02:36:52.236
THE FEW THAT WERE THERE. WEEK
02:36:52.302 --> 02:36:54.037
HELLO YES INFORMED THE
02:36:54.104 --> 02:36:55.672
GOVERNOR'S OFFICE TO INFORM THE
02:36:55.739 --> 02:36:59.009
CPUC INFORMED- ALONG WITH OTHER
02:36:59.076 --> 02:37:01.378
STRAIGHT STAKEHOLDERS ON A
02:37:01.445 --> 02:37:02.179
DAILY BASIS AS TO THE
02:37:02.246 --> 02:37:04.081
PERFORMANCE OF OUR NETWORK I
02:37:04.148 --> 02:37:05.115
WAS ONE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT
02:37:05.182 --> 02:37:07.484
WE WERE TOLD THAT THIS PANEL
02:37:07.551 --> 02:37:09.186
TODAY WAS GOING TO ASK AS WE
02:37:09.253 --> 02:37:10.921
KNOW HOW WELL WERE YOU
02:37:10.988 --> 02:37:11.755
COMMUNICATING WITH THE
02:37:11.822 --> 02:37:13.357
DIFFERENT STAKEHOLDERS VERIZON
02:37:13.423 --> 02:37:14.992
PRIDES ITSELF IN THE FACT THAT
02:37:15.058 --> 02:37:16.960
NOT ONLY DID IT PROACTIVELY
02:37:17.027 --> 02:37:18.028
COMMUNICATE BUT IT
02:37:18.095 --> 02:37:21.665
COMMUNICATED- DURING THE DAY ON
02:37:21.732 --> 02:37:23.734
REQUEST TWO OR THREE TIMES A
02:37:23.801 --> 02:37:25.536
DAY WE WILL PROVIDE CALLOW
02:37:25.602 --> 02:37:27.604
BUSES ARE UP. ON A REAL TIME
02:37:27.671 --> 02:37:29.439
BASIS AT THE TOP ACT WE PROVIDE
02:37:29.506 --> 02:37:32.309
AID END OF DAY COMMUNICATIONS
02:37:32.376 --> 02:37:36.547
TO ALL THE CYCLE. WE ALSO RAISE
02:37:36.613 --> 02:37:37.414
THE BAR ON TRANSPARENCY BY
02:37:37.481 --> 02:37:38.515
PROVIDING PUBLICLY THE
02:37:38.582 --> 02:37:40.384
PERCENTAGE OF CELL SITES IN
02:37:40.450 --> 02:37:42.419
OPERATIONS IN THE IMPACTED. OUR
02:37:42.486 --> 02:37:44.454
POWER SHUT OFF AREAS IT'S NOT
02:37:44.521 --> 02:37:46.456
SOMETHING THAT WE DID BEFORE-
02:37:46.523 --> 02:37:48.225
WE MADE A CORPORATE DECISION
02:37:48.292 --> 02:37:49.459
THAT WE WERE GOING TO BE MORE
02:37:49.526 --> 02:37:52.329
TRANSPARENT. ABOUT THIS AND BY
02:37:52.396 --> 02:37:54.398
ON A GOING FORWARD BASIS WE
02:37:54.464 --> 02:37:57.734
INTEND TO BE TRANSPARENT. THE
02:37:57.801 --> 02:37:58.702
RESULTS OF ALL OF OUR WORK WAS
02:37:58.769 --> 02:38:01.471
THAT OUR NETWORK. SHOWED GREAT
02:38:01.538 --> 02:38:03.140
RESILIENCY DUE TO OUR BACK UP
02:38:03.207 --> 02:38:05.242
POWER RESOURCES ARE OVERLAPPING
02:38:05.309 --> 02:38:07.778
CELL SITE DESIGN. AND ARE
02:38:07.845 --> 02:38:10.347
RUNNING TO THE CRISIS WITH THE
02:38:10.414 --> 02:38:12.349
DEPLOYMENT OF TEMPORARY ASSETS
02:38:12.416 --> 02:38:15.519
SUCH AS CAL'S COLD SPOTS IN
02:38:15.586 --> 02:38:18.388
PORTABLE GENERATORS WERE NEEDED.
02:38:18.455 --> 02:38:21.191
AND SO PART OF THE RESULTS WAS
02:38:21.258 --> 02:38:21.792
FOR EXAMPLE AT THE HEIGHT OF
02:38:21.859 --> 02:38:23.193
THE VENTS ON OCTOBER TWENTY
02:38:23.260 --> 02:38:25.596
EIGHTH. THE FCC REPORTED ON
02:38:25.662 --> 02:38:29.099
AGGREGATE 27% OF WIRELESS
02:38:29.166 --> 02:38:29.700
SERVICE CELL SITES WERE OUT OF
02:38:29.766 --> 02:38:31.902
SERVICE AND SOMEONE COUNTY. THE
02:38:31.969 --> 02:38:32.836
TO THE POWERSHOT AWESOME WELL
02:38:32.903 --> 02:38:35.973
VERIZON ONLY EXPERIENCE 7% OF
02:38:36.039 --> 02:38:37.507
SITES OUT OF SERVICE AT THE
02:38:37.574 --> 02:38:39.943
TIME. NOW THAT 7% IS NOT
02:38:40.010 --> 02:38:41.912
SOMETHING TO CROW ABOUT-
02:38:41.979 --> 02:38:43.680
BECAUSE WE HAVE TO DO BETTER
02:38:43.747 --> 02:38:45.515
AND WE OF KNOWLEDGE THAT. BUT
02:38:45.582 --> 02:38:47.885
WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO SAY IS OUR
02:38:47.951 --> 02:38:49.019
RESILIENCY ACTUALLY SHOWED UP%
02:38:49.086 --> 02:38:51.321
IN THE NUMBERS. THE SAME IS FOR
02:38:51.388 --> 02:38:52.856
MARIN COUNTY MARIN COUNTY THERE
02:38:52.923 --> 02:38:55.692
WAS A 57% CELL SITES OUT OF
02:38:55.759 --> 02:38:58.829
SERVICE ACCORDING TO THE- DERS
02:38:58.896 --> 02:39:01.398
REPORTS. ARISES OUT OF SERVICE
02:39:01.465 --> 02:39:04.067
WAS 8% OF ITS CELL SITES BUT
02:39:04.134 --> 02:39:05.335
THAT DOESN'T MEAN THAT COVERAGE
02:39:05.402 --> 02:39:07.070
WAS AL. BECAUSE WE HAVE THIS
02:39:07.137 --> 02:39:09.239
OVERLAP IN THE SIGN AND WE HAVE
02:39:09.306 --> 02:39:10.540
THE TEMPORARY ASSETS THAT WE
02:39:10.607 --> 02:39:12.542
DEPLOY. AND THAT'S AN IMPORTANT
02:39:12.609 --> 02:39:15.345
METRIC THAT WE NEED TO DISCUSS
02:39:15.412 --> 02:39:18.849
IN THIS COLLABORATIVE. AS WE GO
02:39:18.916 --> 02:39:19.583
FORWARD IN A COLLABORATIVE
02:39:19.650 --> 02:39:20.684
MANNER IS WHAT DOES IT REALLY
02:39:20.751 --> 02:39:22.386
MEAN FOR CELL SITE TO BE OUT
02:39:22.452 --> 02:39:23.820
DOES THAT MEAN THAT COVERAGES
02:39:23.887 --> 02:39:25.455
OUT. NOT NECESSARILY AND
02:39:25.522 --> 02:39:26.823
SOMETHING THAT WE NEED TO
02:39:26.890 --> 02:39:28.325
REALLY BE CAREFUL ABOUT
02:39:28.392 --> 02:39:30.227
EQUATING CELL SITES OUT WITH
02:39:30.294 --> 02:39:39.269
COVERAGE OUT. WE THINK THAT
02:39:39.336 --> 02:39:40.137
THERE IS A REAL NEED FOR
02:39:40.203 --> 02:39:42.039
PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN INDUSTRY
02:39:42.105 --> 02:39:43.774
THE ELECTRIC UTILITIES AND
02:39:43.840 --> 02:39:44.808
GOVERNMENT AND OTHER
02:39:44.875 --> 02:39:46.276
STAKEHOLDERS TO COME UP WITH
02:39:46.343 --> 02:39:49.446
SOLUTIONS TO THE- PRESIDENTE
02:39:49.513 --> 02:39:50.514
CHALLENGES CLIMATE CHANGE HAS
02:39:50.580 --> 02:39:52.549
IMPOSED ON CALIFORNIA WE ARE
02:39:52.616 --> 02:39:54.151
PREPARED TO PARTNER WITH
02:39:54.217 --> 02:39:56.687
CALIFORNIA TO DEVELOP THE
02:39:56.753 --> 02:39:57.154
SENSIBLE AND FEASIBLE
02:39:57.220 --> 02:40:01.358
SOLUTIONS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU
02:40:01.425 --> 02:40:03.226
AND I FORGOT TO CLARIFY THAT
02:40:03.293 --> 02:40:04.528
MISTER CARLSON MISTER LONG AND
02:40:04.594 --> 02:40:07.297
MR AMMAN. ARE REPRESENTING THE
02:40:07.364 --> 02:40:09.933
WIRELESS INDUSTRY WE HAVE
02:40:10.000 --> 02:40:11.635
CAROLINE MACINTYRE REPRESENTING
02:40:11.702 --> 02:40:13.971
THE CABLE INDUSTRY AND- JOHN
02:40:14.037 --> 02:40:16.740
LUNDGREN. IS REPRESENTING
02:40:16.807 --> 02:40:19.609
WIRELESS LINE SO NOW WE'LL HEAR
02:40:19.676 --> 02:40:20.210
FROM CARE A MISS MCINTYRE AND
02:40:20.277 --> 02:40:25.048
THEN MISTER. LONGER. ABSOLUTELY
02:40:25.115 --> 02:40:26.116
AS THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
02:40:26.183 --> 02:40:27.417
AND MEMBERS CAROLINE MCINTYRE
02:40:27.484 --> 02:40:28.986
IN BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
02:40:29.052 --> 02:40:30.420
CABLE AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS
02:40:30.487 --> 02:40:32.122
INDUSTRY THANK YOU FOR THE
02:40:32.189 --> 02:40:33.724
OPPORTUNITY TO ADDRESS THE
02:40:33.790 --> 02:40:36.493
COMMITTEE TODAY ON BEHALF OF
02:40:36.560 --> 02:40:38.962
THE ASSOCIATION'S MEMBERS WE
02:40:39.196 --> 02:40:41.631
GREATLY APPRECIATE THE
02:40:41.698 --> 02:40:44.668
DIALOGUE WE UNDERSTAND HOW. WE
02:40:44.735 --> 02:40:47.270
CAN PROVIDE TECHNICAL EXPERTISE
02:40:47.337 --> 02:40:48.105
AND WORK TOGETHER ON THE
02:40:48.171 --> 02:40:50.741
PRACTICAL REALISTIC AND
02:40:50.807 --> 02:40:51.341
WORKABLE SOLUTIONS FOR KEEPING
02:40:51.408 --> 02:40:53.844
CALIFORNIA'S SAFE. AT THE CABLE
02:40:53.910 --> 02:40:55.712
INDUSTRY HAS INVESTED BILLIONS
02:40:55.779 --> 02:40:57.314
OF DOLLARS TO BUILD AND
02:40:57.381 --> 02:40:58.148
MAINTAIN STATE OF THE ART
02:40:58.215 --> 02:41:00.417
COMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS CAPABLE
02:41:00.484 --> 02:41:01.551
OF DELIVERING SUPERIOR
02:41:01.618 --> 02:41:05.055
BROADBAND VIDEO INVOICE SERVICE
02:41:05.122 --> 02:41:06.523
FOR CALIFORNIANS. WHETHER
02:41:06.590 --> 02:41:07.924
EXPANDING NETWORKS TO PROVIDE
02:41:07.991 --> 02:41:10.093
FASTER BROADBAND OFFERING HIGH
02:41:10.160 --> 02:41:12.062
SPEED VALUE WIRELINE VOICE
02:41:12.129 --> 02:41:14.965
SERVICE AND MOBILE SERVICES OR
02:41:15.032 --> 02:41:16.433
DELIVERING VIDEO PROGRAMMING
02:41:16.500 --> 02:41:18.902
THE MEMBERS THE CC TA CONTINUE
02:41:18.969 --> 02:41:20.070
TO INNOVATE AND INVEST IN THE
02:41:20.137 --> 02:41:21.338
NETWORK INFRASTRUCTURE
02:41:21.405 --> 02:41:24.408
BENEFITING CALIFORNIANS. ALL OF
02:41:24.474 --> 02:41:26.443
THE CTA'S MEMBERS TAKE NETWORK
02:41:26.510 --> 02:41:29.513
RELIABILITY VERY SERIOUSLY AND
02:41:29.579 --> 02:41:31.782
WORK HARD TO ENSURE OUR BACK UP
02:41:31.848 --> 02:41:32.482
SERVICE IN THE EVENT OF
02:41:32.549 --> 02:41:34.618
COMMERCIAL POWER OUTAGE IS. THE
02:41:34.684 --> 02:41:36.119
ELECTRIC UTILITY P. S. P. S. C.
02:41:36.186 --> 02:41:37.387
VETS LAST YEAR WERE
02:41:37.454 --> 02:41:40.223
UNPRECEDENTED IN SCOPE SCALE
02:41:40.290 --> 02:41:42.325
AND HAVE SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON
02:41:42.392 --> 02:41:43.894
THE STATE'S COMMUNICATIONS
02:41:43.960 --> 02:41:45.962
NETWORKS THAT RELY ON
02:41:46.029 --> 02:41:49.599
COMMERCIAL POWER. WE AGREE WITH
02:41:49.666 --> 02:41:50.534
THE GOVERNOR THE OFFICE OF
02:41:50.600 --> 02:41:51.868
EMERGENCY SERVICES THE CPUC THE
02:41:51.935 --> 02:41:54.371
MEMBERS OF THE LEGISLATURE THAT
02:41:54.438 --> 02:41:55.472
WHAT HAPPENED LAST YEAR CANNOT
02:41:55.539 --> 02:41:58.175
HAPPEN AGAIN. THE CABLE
02:41:58.241 --> 02:41:59.309
INDUSTRY IS COMMITTED TO
02:41:59.376 --> 02:42:01.711
FINDING SOLUTIONS THERE ARE
02:42:01.778 --> 02:42:03.413
SEVERAL KEY PRINCIPLES THAT WE
02:42:03.480 --> 02:42:05.048
VIEW WAS FUNDAMENTAL TO
02:42:05.115 --> 02:42:07.184
UNDERSTANDING THE CHALLENGES
02:42:07.250 --> 02:42:09.252
AND FINDING EFFECTIVE SOLUTIONS
02:42:09.319 --> 02:42:12.422
TO SUPPORT PUBLIC SAFETY. IN A
02:42:12.489 --> 02:42:14.858
P. S. P. S. OR OTHER EMERGENCY.
02:42:14.925 --> 02:42:16.259
LET ME JUST START BY SAYING
02:42:16.326 --> 02:42:18.862
THAT IT IS UNFAIR AND
02:42:18.929 --> 02:42:21.064
UNREASONABLE FOR THE
02:42:21.131 --> 02:42:24.034
LEGISLATURE AND THE CPC TO
02:42:24.101 --> 02:42:26.703
ALLOW THE ELECTRIC UTILITIES TO
02:42:26.770 --> 02:42:29.739
DE ENERGIZED THEIR NETWORKS AND
02:42:29.806 --> 02:42:31.775
EXPECT THAT THE COMMUNICATIONS
02:42:31.842 --> 02:42:34.044
NETWORK IS GOING TO BECOME A
02:42:34.111 --> 02:42:35.579
WHOLESALE REPLACEMENT. FOR
02:42:35.645 --> 02:42:39.683
POWER 21100% OUR THE
02:42:39.749 --> 02:42:43.520
COMMUNICATIONS NETWORK. THE
02:42:43.587 --> 02:42:44.888
COMMUNICATIONS NETWORK IS IN
02:42:44.955 --> 02:42:46.123
FACT DEPENDENT UPON COMMERCIAL
02:42:46.189 --> 02:42:49.659
POWER AND WHILE WE DO HAVE
02:42:49.726 --> 02:42:52.662
BACKUP POWER IN PLACE TO
02:42:52.729 --> 02:42:54.931
SUPPORT MOST OF OUR FACILITIES
02:42:54.998 --> 02:42:57.501
BATTERIES AND THEN GENERATORS
02:42:57.567 --> 02:43:00.637
WE CANNOT BE EXPECTED TO KEEP
02:43:00.704 --> 02:43:03.974
UP 1100% OF THE NETWORK UNLESS
02:43:04.040 --> 02:43:05.809
YOU ARE WILLING TO ACKNOWLEDGE
02:43:05.876 --> 02:43:08.311
AND MAKE CERTAIN CONCESSIONS
02:43:08.378 --> 02:43:09.779
FOR CHALLENGES THAT WE BUT HAVE
02:43:09.846 --> 02:43:12.716
DOING CELL WE ARE COMMITTED TO
02:43:12.782 --> 02:43:14.684
KEEPING POWER AND CAPABLE OF
02:43:14.751 --> 02:43:16.820
KEEPING POWER UP TO OUR MAIN
02:43:16.887 --> 02:43:19.689
FACILITIES ARE HEAD ENDS. KEEP
02:43:19.756 --> 02:43:21.558
BEING AT THE BACK HOME POWER
02:43:21.625 --> 02:43:24.227
FOR- WIRELESS SERVICES TO
02:43:24.294 --> 02:43:26.730
SUPPORT CELL TOWERS I'VE BEEN
02:43:26.796 --> 02:43:28.365
READING TO SUPPORT FIRST
02:43:28.431 --> 02:43:31.034
RESPONDERS TO SUPPORT CRITICAL
02:43:31.101 --> 02:43:33.403
FACILITIES ALL THROUGH AN
02:43:33.470 --> 02:43:34.971
IDENTIFICATION PROCESS IN
02:43:35.038 --> 02:43:36.206
COORDINATION WITH LOCAL
02:43:36.273 --> 02:43:39.509
GOVERNMENT BUT TO THE EXTENT
02:43:39.576 --> 02:43:41.878
THAT YOU ARE EXPECTING THAT WE
02:43:41.945 --> 02:43:46.449
WILL BE ABLE TO KEEP 1100% OF
02:43:46.516 --> 02:43:49.486
RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMERS. CAN DID
02:43:49.553 --> 02:43:50.754
AND HAVING THE ABILITY TO HAVE
02:43:50.820 --> 02:43:53.423
CONTENT AS MEDICATION YOU HAVE
02:43:53.490 --> 02:43:54.758
TO RECOGNIZE THAT ARE
02:43:54.824 --> 02:43:59.729
CHALLENGES WITH. THE I AS I
02:43:59.796 --> 02:44:01.097
INDICATED THE K. YLIDES DO IN
02:44:01.164 --> 02:44:01.865
FACT HAVE BACKUP BATTERIES THE
02:44:01.932 --> 02:44:02.566
FACILITIES THAT ACTUALLY
02:44:02.632 --> 02:44:04.568
PROVIDE THAT LAST MILE
02:44:04.634 --> 02:44:05.635
CONNECTIVE ITTY TO THE
02:44:05.702 --> 02:44:07.771
RESIDENTIAL CONSUMER WILL IN
02:44:07.837 --> 02:44:10.040
FACT LAST ON BACK UP BATTERY
02:44:10.106 --> 02:44:11.975
POWER FOR A SHORT PERIOD OF
02:44:12.042 --> 02:44:14.311
TIME. THERE AFTER YOU WERE
02:44:14.377 --> 02:44:16.213
GOING TO HAVE TO BRING IN
02:44:16.279 --> 02:44:18.448
PORTABLE GENERATORS OR OTHER
02:44:18.515 --> 02:44:20.917
SOURCES OF POWER IN ORDER TO
02:44:20.984 --> 02:44:23.253
POWER THAT NETWORK WE CALL
02:44:23.320 --> 02:44:25.055
THOSE FACILITIES THAT ARE
02:44:25.121 --> 02:44:26.790
PROVIDING THAT LAST MILE
02:44:26.856 --> 02:44:29.226
CONNECTIVE ITTY. AND UPLOAD. WE
02:44:29.292 --> 02:44:31.895
HAVE. IN EXCESS OF FIFTY
02:44:31.962 --> 02:44:34.664
THOUSAND NOTES THAT ARE PART OF
02:44:34.731 --> 02:44:35.131
THE CABLE NETWORKS IN
02:44:35.198 --> 02:44:38.268
CALIFORNIA. ONE NOTE SERVES
02:44:38.335 --> 02:44:40.003
APPROXIMATELY THREE HUNDRED
02:44:40.070 --> 02:44:44.741
HOUSEHOLDS THAT IS TWO HUNDRED
02:44:44.808 --> 02:44:46.943
PORTABLE GENERATORS THAT WE
02:44:47.010 --> 02:44:48.311
WOULD HAVE TO BRING INTO A
02:44:48.378 --> 02:44:51.481
COMMUNITY TO ENSURE THAT POWER
02:44:51.548 --> 02:44:54.317
CONTINUES TO BE AVAILABLE TO
02:44:54.384 --> 02:44:56.119
THAT NETWORK INTO THAT
02:44:56.186 --> 02:44:59.856
RESIDENTIAL CUSTOMERS HOW. EVEN
02:44:59.923 --> 02:45:02.659
IF WE ARE CAPABLE OF DOING THAT.
02:45:02.726 --> 02:45:04.361
THERE ARE STILL CHALLENGES WITH
02:45:04.427 --> 02:45:06.663
WHETHER OR NOT THE CONSUMER
02:45:06.730 --> 02:45:07.597
WOULD BE ABLE TO ACTUALLY
02:45:07.664 --> 02:45:10.767
UTILIZE THE SERVICE ONE THEY
02:45:10.834 --> 02:45:12.035
MUST HAVE A BACK UP BATTERY FOR
02:45:12.102 --> 02:45:13.670
THE VEAL PIE V. O. I. P. SYSTEM
02:45:13.737 --> 02:45:16.840
SECONDLY MOST CONSUMERS ARE
02:45:16.906 --> 02:45:19.142
ALSO GOING TO BE DEPENDED UPON
02:45:19.209 --> 02:45:21.645
SOME SORT OF ENERGY SOURCE IN
02:45:21.711 --> 02:45:24.681
THEIR HOME TO POWER. THEIR
02:45:24.748 --> 02:45:27.484
COMMUNICATION DEVICE. I'M NOT
02:45:27.550 --> 02:45:28.852
TALKING ABOUT THE GHETTO POT
02:45:28.918 --> 02:45:31.554
SYSTEM I AM TALKING ABOUT THAT
02:45:31.621 --> 02:45:34.424
TELEPHONE SYSTEM THAT MANY VOID
02:45:34.491 --> 02:45:36.426
CUSTOMERS COMMUNICATE OVER THAT
02:45:36.493 --> 02:45:39.095
MAY BE A CORDLESS PHONE OR SOME
02:45:39.162 --> 02:45:41.898
OTHER TYPE OF INSTRUMENT THAT
02:45:41.965 --> 02:45:44.701
DEPENDS ON ELECTRICITY. IN
02:45:44.768 --> 02:45:46.503
ADDITION JUST TO GET THOSE
02:45:46.569 --> 02:45:49.306
PORTABLE GENERATORS OUT TO
02:45:49.372 --> 02:45:50.573
THOSE COMMUNITIES WE'VE GOT
02:45:50.640 --> 02:45:52.409
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES WE'VE GOT
02:45:52.475 --> 02:45:54.711
NAME BE ISSUES WE'VE GOT
02:45:54.778 --> 02:45:56.980
INCONSISTENCIES WITH THE STATE
02:45:57.047 --> 02:45:57.914
OF CALIFORNIA IS VERY MISSION
02:45:57.981 --> 02:46:00.150
GOALS. THERE ARE MANY MANY
02:46:00.216 --> 02:46:04.054
CHALLENGES SO WE ASK THAT AS WE
02:46:04.120 --> 02:46:06.923
COLLECTIVELY LOOK TO FIND
02:46:06.990 --> 02:46:09.326
SOLUTIONS IN A SPACE THAT WE
02:46:09.392 --> 02:46:10.927
TAKE ALL OF THOSE FACTORS INTO
02:46:10.994 --> 02:46:13.596
CONSIDERATION. OUR PRIORITY
02:46:13.663 --> 02:46:15.832
RECOGNIZING THAT 80% OF THE
02:46:15.899 --> 02:46:18.868
CALLS THAT GO INTO NINE ONE ONE
02:46:18.935 --> 02:46:19.936
ARE COMING FROM WIRELESS
02:46:20.003 --> 02:46:23.106
NETWORKS WE HAVE MADE PROVIDING
02:46:23.173 --> 02:46:25.675
BACKUP POWER TO THE BACK HOME
02:46:25.742 --> 02:46:28.078
NETWORK THAT SUPPORTS THE CELL
02:46:28.144 --> 02:46:32.282
SYSTEM OUR PRIORITY. TO PROVIDE
02:46:32.349 --> 02:46:33.750
AS MUCH CERTAINTY ON OUR END
02:46:33.817 --> 02:46:34.951
IT'S POSSIBLE THAT THE
02:46:35.018 --> 02:46:36.953
CONNECTIVE ITTY IS ULTIMATELY
02:46:37.020 --> 02:46:38.888
THERE THAT WOULD BE NEEDED BY
02:46:38.955 --> 02:46:40.857
THE WIRELESS COMPANIES TO
02:46:40.924 --> 02:46:41.391
CONTINUE TO PROVIDE THEIR
02:46:41.458 --> 02:46:48.898
SERVICE. THERE IS NO ONE SIZE
02:46:48.965 --> 02:46:51.368
FITS ALL SOLUTION HERE- AS
02:46:51.434 --> 02:46:53.103
COMMISSIONER I'M SORRY DIRECTOR
02:46:53.169 --> 02:46:54.137
GIRLY DID YOU MENTIONED
02:46:54.204 --> 02:46:57.574
EARLIER- OUR INDUSTRY HAS BEEN
02:46:57.640 --> 02:46:59.943
IN COMMUNICATIONS WITH THE
02:47:00.009 --> 02:47:02.779
OFFICE OF EMERGENCY SERVICES-
02:47:02.846 --> 02:47:04.447
OUR COMPANIES ALSO HAVE LOCAL
02:47:04.514 --> 02:47:06.216
PUBLIC AFFAIRS FOLKS THAT ARE.
02:47:06.282 --> 02:47:07.684
ALWAYS IN CONTACT WITH LOCAL
02:47:07.751 --> 02:47:10.487
GOVERNMENTS AND WE ARE LOOKING
02:47:10.553 --> 02:47:11.554
FORWARD TO CONTINUING OUR
02:47:11.621 --> 02:47:14.624
COLLABORATION TO WORK WITH- WE
02:47:14.691 --> 02:47:16.926
ASKED TO FIGURE OUT THE BEST-
02:47:16.993 --> 02:47:18.495
REPORTING PROTOCOLS AND
02:47:18.561 --> 02:47:21.531
PARTNERSHIPS WITH- WITH- YES
02:47:21.598 --> 02:47:23.333
AND OTHER LOCAL GOVERNMENT
02:47:23.400 --> 02:47:25.668
PARTNERS. AND MANY OF THE
02:47:25.735 --> 02:47:27.604
CURRENT LAWS THAT ARE ON THE
02:47:27.670 --> 02:47:29.172
BOOKS ALREADY PROVIDE AN
02:47:29.239 --> 02:47:31.608
ADEQUATE FRAMEWORK FOR US TO
02:47:31.674 --> 02:47:32.675
MAKE SOME IMPROVEMENTS IN THIS
02:47:32.742 --> 02:47:34.144
SPACE INCLUDING CENTER
02:47:34.210 --> 02:47:37.814
MAGUIRE'S SB SIX SEVENTY WHICH
02:47:37.881 --> 02:47:41.418
I WE **** IN THE PROCESS OF. AS
02:47:41.484 --> 02:47:43.286
DEVELOPING REGULATIONS THE
02:47:43.353 --> 02:47:44.454
LEADERSHIP OF LOCAL EMERGENCY
02:47:44.521 --> 02:47:45.955
MANAGEMENT OFFICIALS IS ALSO
02:47:46.022 --> 02:47:47.223
GOING TO BE VERY IMPORTANT IN
02:47:47.290 --> 02:47:49.058
THIS SPACE IN THAT WE NEED TO
02:47:49.125 --> 02:47:50.593
WORK WITH PHÃN COLLABORATIVE
02:47:50.660 --> 02:47:52.629
LEAD TO IDENTIFY THOSE CRITICAL
02:47:52.695 --> 02:47:55.331
FACILITIES AND OTHER LOCAL
02:47:55.398 --> 02:47:56.466
PUBLIC SAFETY PRIORITIES THAT
02:47:56.533 --> 02:47:58.535
WE MESSED IT MIGHT MUST FOCUS
02:47:58.601 --> 02:48:00.937
ON DURING A P. S. P. S. OR
02:48:01.004 --> 02:48:02.872
OTHER EMERGENCY. CABLE
02:48:02.939 --> 02:48:04.774
OPERATORS CAN HELP PROVIDE
02:48:04.841 --> 02:48:05.942
SOLUTIONS TO MEET THE
02:48:06.009 --> 02:48:08.011
INDIVIDUAL COUNTY NEEDS AND
02:48:08.077 --> 02:48:10.313
THEIR COMMUNITIES PRIORITIES
02:48:10.380 --> 02:48:12.115
BASED ON THE MOST RELIABLE AND
02:48:12.182 --> 02:48:14.384
ASSESSABLE TECHNOLOGIES WE LOOK
02:48:14.451 --> 02:48:16.085
FORWARD TO COLLABORATING- WITH
02:48:16.152 --> 02:48:18.188
THOSE AGENCIES AS I INDICATED
02:48:18.254 --> 02:48:20.990
AND I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
02:48:21.057 --> 02:48:21.591
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE. THANK
02:48:21.658 --> 02:48:26.863
YOU MISTER ALONG WITH. HELLO
02:48:26.930 --> 02:48:29.065
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
02:48:29.132 --> 02:48:30.066
SPEAK SENATORS- MY NAME IS JOHN
02:48:30.133 --> 02:48:32.268
LUNDGREN HIRING DIRECTOR
02:48:32.335 --> 02:48:33.303
NETWORK SERVICES VICE PRESIDENT
02:48:33.369 --> 02:48:35.738
WALKING A TELEPHONE COMPANY-
02:48:35.805 --> 02:48:37.106
I'VE BEEN ASKED TO SPEAK FROM A
02:48:37.173 --> 02:48:39.542
SMALL LOCAL STRANGER
02:48:39.609 --> 02:48:40.109
PERSPECTIVE TODAY AND HOW IT
02:48:40.176 --> 02:48:44.547
AFFECTS US IN THESE SITUATIONS.
02:48:44.614 --> 02:48:45.081
GIVE A LITTLE BACKGROUND
02:48:45.148 --> 02:48:47.350
VOLCANO- IS FIFTY FIVE MILES
02:48:47.417 --> 02:48:48.885
SOUTHEAST OF SACRAMENTO NOT
02:48:48.952 --> 02:48:51.087
VERY FAR FROM HERE ANSWERS FOUR
02:48:51.154 --> 02:48:52.956
HUNDRED SIXTEEN SQUARE MILES
02:48:53.022 --> 02:48:53.957
MUCH OF WHICH IS HIGHER FOOT
02:48:54.023 --> 02:48:55.492
HILL AREAS TO VERY MOUNTAINOUS
02:48:55.558 --> 02:48:57.627
AREAS WE HAVE NINE THOUSAND
02:48:57.694 --> 02:48:59.929
TELEPHONE ACCESS LINES SEVENTY
02:48:59.996 --> 02:49:00.630
THREE HUNDRED DSL INTERNET
02:49:00.697 --> 02:49:03.700
CUSTOMERS CURRENTLY ABOUT 10%
02:49:03.766 --> 02:49:04.300
OF OUR BASES SERVE WITH FIBER
02:49:04.367 --> 02:49:08.872
DIRECTOR HOME. BOB WE SERVE THE
02:49:08.938 --> 02:49:10.073
EASTERN PART OF AMADOR COUNTY
02:49:10.139 --> 02:49:11.508
TO THE KIRKWOOD SKI AREA- IN
02:49:11.574 --> 02:49:13.643
THE MOUNTAINS HAND ALSO SERVE
02:49:13.710 --> 02:49:14.277
VERY SMALL PORTIONS OF ELDORADO
02:49:14.344 --> 02:49:17.480
ALPINE COUNTY. IN ADDITION WE
02:49:17.547 --> 02:49:18.014
SERVE NORTHERN PORTIONS OF
02:49:18.081 --> 02:49:22.652
CALAVERAS COUNTY. IT'S THE
02:49:22.719 --> 02:49:24.387
OTHER SMALL WORKS IN THE STATE
02:49:24.454 --> 02:49:25.722
ARE VERY SIMILAR IN NATURE TO
02:49:25.788 --> 02:49:27.290
THE TRAIN AND CANARIES THEY
02:49:27.357 --> 02:49:29.225
COVER AND MANY OF A REPRESENT
02:49:29.292 --> 02:49:30.927
IN THIS ROOM THIS MORNING
02:49:30.994 --> 02:49:31.528
BECAUSE THEY FEEL THIS IS THE-
02:49:31.594 --> 02:49:36.866
IMPORTANT. SITUATION. TO GIVE
02:49:36.933 --> 02:49:37.567
YOU A LITTLE FLAVOR WE HAVE
02:49:37.634 --> 02:49:40.303
ALMOST TWO HUNDRED SPERRY SMALL
02:49:40.370 --> 02:49:43.940
REMOTES TO SERVE OUR CUSTOMER
02:49:44.007 --> 02:49:47.443
BASE- FIFTY OF WHICH HAVE AC
02:49:47.510 --> 02:49:48.545
COMMERCIAL POWER TO THE
02:49:48.611 --> 02:49:51.681
REMAINDER OF THEM WE USE THE
02:49:51.748 --> 02:49:52.315
EXISTING COPPER NETWORK WE HAVE
02:49:52.382 --> 02:49:54.918
TO ONE POWER. SO THIS IS IN
02:49:54.984 --> 02:49:57.220
ORDER TO GET WITHIN FOUR
02:49:57.287 --> 02:50:00.189
THOUSAND FOOT LOPS OF COPPER
02:50:00.256 --> 02:50:00.757
TO GET BROADBAND OUT TO OUR
02:50:00.823 --> 02:50:05.495
CUSTOMERS THE DISTANCE BATES. I
02:50:05.562 --> 02:50:09.032
AM KIND OF PROGRESS.
02:50:09.098 --> 02:50:09.566
APPROACHING THIS FROM MORE
02:50:09.632 --> 02:50:12.268
BOOTS ON THE GROUND ABOUT.
02:50:12.335 --> 02:50:13.703
APPROACHES THAT ACTUALLY
02:50:13.770 --> 02:50:15.705
ACTUALLY GOING OUT ON SOME OF
02:50:15.772 --> 02:50:16.239
THESE CALLS MYSELF AND CAN
02:50:16.306 --> 02:50:19.275
WORKING THROUGH THESE THINGS.
02:50:19.342 --> 02:50:20.710
THE CALIFORNIA UNTIL THE
02:50:20.777 --> 02:50:23.613
EMERGENCY ASSOCIATION AFTER THE
02:50:23.680 --> 02:50:24.180
FIRST P. S. P. S. SENT OUT A
02:50:24.247 --> 02:50:27.216
QUESTIONNAIRE. AM I THOUGHT IT
02:50:27.283 --> 02:50:29.319
WOULD JUST BE THE BEST WAY TO
02:50:29.385 --> 02:50:31.521
CONNECTING CAPS LATE KIND WHAT
02:50:31.588 --> 02:50:33.323
WE EXPERIENCE JUST BY. KIND OF
02:50:33.389 --> 02:50:33.890
REVIEW THAT WITH YOU WHAT I
02:50:33.957 --> 02:50:40.863
WHAT I SENT BACK TO THEM. SO. I
02:50:40.930 --> 02:50:42.432
SHOULD START OUT BY INDICATING
02:50:42.498 --> 02:50:43.032
THAT AT LEAST FOR THE FOR THE
02:50:43.099 --> 02:50:43.967
AREA OF ALL CAN A TELEPHONE
02:50:44.033 --> 02:50:45.702
COMEY SERVICE THIS IS NOT THE
02:50:45.768 --> 02:50:46.836
FIRST EVENT LIKE THIS WE HAVE
02:50:46.903 --> 02:50:49.272
EXPERIENCE THROUGH THE YEARS WE
02:50:49.339 --> 02:50:50.873
HAVE HAD NUMEROUS SNOWSTORMS
02:50:50.940 --> 02:50:52.375
LIGHTNING STORMS THE BUTTE FIRE
02:50:52.442 --> 02:50:54.444
IN TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN ANOTHER
02:50:54.510 --> 02:50:56.512
EVENTS THAT HAVE COST P. GINNY
02:50:56.579 --> 02:50:57.080
SERVICE TO BE DISRUPTED FOR
02:50:57.146 --> 02:50:59.649
EXTENDED PERIODS OF TIME. OVER
02:50:59.716 --> 02:51:00.483
THE YEAR WE'VE DEVELOPED A
02:51:00.550 --> 02:51:01.117
BACKUP SYSTEMS AND THEIR
02:51:01.184 --> 02:51:02.685
PRACTICE FOR AN EVENT LIKE
02:51:02.752 --> 02:51:04.120
THIS. BUT FOR DIFFERENT
02:51:04.187 --> 02:51:06.823
REASONS. THE IRONIC THING ABOUT
02:51:06.889 --> 02:51:07.657
THIS EVENT WAS IT WAS PRETTY
02:51:07.724 --> 02:51:10.960
MUCH LAID OUT. AS TO WHAT WAS
02:51:11.027 --> 02:51:11.594
GOING TO FAIL MORE OR LESS WHEN
02:51:11.661 --> 02:51:14.030
AND WHERE. IF THE VANCE WE'VE
02:51:14.097 --> 02:51:15.765
BEEN INVOLVED IN HAVE AN
02:51:15.832 --> 02:51:16.966
UNPLANNED AND THE FAILURES ARE
02:51:17.033 --> 02:51:19.402
NOT KNOWN BEFORE THE BEGINNING
02:51:19.469 --> 02:51:19.969
OF THE EVENT. AND WE'RE THE
02:51:20.036 --> 02:51:23.940
FAILURES WORLD HER. TO I SHOULD
02:51:24.007 --> 02:51:26.242
PROBABLY HAVE THAT THIS WAS
02:51:26.309 --> 02:51:26.809
AFTER THE FIRST PSP US ABOUT
02:51:26.876 --> 02:51:31.047
THAT WE HAVE. WHAT IMPACTS DID
02:51:31.114 --> 02:51:31.681
THE PS PS INCIDENT HAVE ON YOUR
02:51:31.748 --> 02:51:35.385
TELLY. AS WE ARE BATTERIES AT
02:51:35.451 --> 02:51:36.886
ALL SITES AND GENERATORS AND
02:51:36.953 --> 02:51:38.087
ALMOST ALL OF OUR REMOTE
02:51:38.154 --> 02:51:39.522
SERVICES SITES FOR TELEPHONE
02:51:39.589 --> 02:51:41.591
SERVICE AS WELL AS INTERNET
02:51:41.658 --> 02:51:43.559
SERVICE DSL ADDRESS FIBER ONLY.
02:51:43.626 --> 02:51:45.128
WE WENT THROUGH MOST OF OUR
02:51:45.194 --> 02:51:47.397
OUTAGE WITHOUT ANY INCIDENTS.
02:51:47.463 --> 02:51:48.798
IN THE MOST CRITICAL PARTS OF
02:51:48.865 --> 02:51:50.233
OUR NETWORK AT THE PEAK OF THE
02:51:50.299 --> 02:51:52.468
PSP HOUSE. WE HAD FORTY SIX
02:51:52.535 --> 02:51:54.871
PLUS GENERATORS IN OPERATION.
02:51:54.937 --> 02:51:56.572
WHEN THE INCIDENT STARTED.
02:51:56.639 --> 02:51:57.807
THERE WERE FOUR SITES THE
02:51:57.874 --> 02:51:59.642
GENEROUS DID NOT START WE
02:51:59.709 --> 02:52:00.443
CORRECTED TO THE SITES BEFORE
02:52:00.510 --> 02:52:02.545
THE BATTERS RICH PLEADED SO.
02:52:02.612 --> 02:52:03.146
THOSE AREAS NEVER EXPERIENCED
02:52:03.212 --> 02:52:06.416
ANYTHING. ONE OF THOSE SITES
02:52:06.482 --> 02:52:07.050
WAS A LITTLE LARGER SO THAT WAS
02:52:07.116 --> 02:52:09.185
A GOOD THING. THERE WERE TWO
02:52:09.252 --> 02:52:10.353
SMALLER SITES THAT FAILED TO
02:52:10.420 --> 02:52:11.688
START AND THE BATTERIES WERE
02:52:11.754 --> 02:52:13.890
DEPLETED. AND WE HAD VERY VERY
02:52:13.956 --> 02:52:15.591
BRIEF OUTAGES ONE OF THE YEAR'S
02:52:15.658 --> 02:52:17.493
EXPERIENCE SEVENTY MINUTES OF
02:52:17.560 --> 02:52:19.195
DOWNTIME AFFECTED A PROXY ONE
02:52:19.262 --> 02:52:20.063
HUNDRED EIGHTY CUSTOMERS. THE
02:52:20.129 --> 02:52:21.297
OTHER SITE THAT FAILED
02:52:21.364 --> 02:52:22.865
EXPERIENCE ABOUT NINETY MINUTES
02:52:22.932 --> 02:52:25.802
DOWNTIME. BEFORE WAS CORRECTED
02:52:25.868 --> 02:52:26.436
IN THE AFFECTED ABOUT A HUNDRED
02:52:26.502 --> 02:52:28.905
AND FORTY FIVE CUSTOMERS. AS WE
02:52:28.971 --> 02:52:29.939
STRADDLED THE PHASE ONE AND
02:52:30.006 --> 02:52:32.809
PHASE TWO LINES. FOR THE FIRST
02:52:32.875 --> 02:52:35.445
PSP ELSE. BEING BEING IN BOTH
02:52:35.511 --> 02:52:36.479
AMADOR CALAVERAS COUNTY WE HAVE
02:52:36.546 --> 02:52:38.381
A SMALL AMOUNT OF AREA. THAT
02:52:38.448 --> 02:52:39.348
HAD THE POWER TURNED OFF ON THE
02:52:39.415 --> 02:52:42.852
SECOND DAY. IT'S MOSTLY A LINE
02:52:42.919 --> 02:52:43.453
THAT FEEDS THE QUIRK WITH SKI
02:52:43.519 --> 02:52:45.988
RESORT DIRECTLY. THERE'S ONE
02:52:46.055 --> 02:52:47.990
VERY SMALL REMOTE SITE. IN THE
02:52:48.057 --> 02:52:49.192
BEAR RIVER AREA THAT FEEDS OFF
02:52:49.258 --> 02:52:51.794
OF THIS PLANET KERR QUIT. WE
02:52:51.861 --> 02:52:52.395
ALSO HAVE A GENERATOR FAILURE
02:52:52.462 --> 02:52:54.764
AT THAT SITE. THE BATTERIES DID
02:52:54.831 --> 02:52:56.699
ALSO GOOD DAD BEFORE ABLE TO
02:52:56.766 --> 02:52:58.801
RECTIFY THE SITUATION AS IT
02:52:58.868 --> 02:52:59.435
TURNS OUT THIS GENERATOR HAVE A
02:52:59.502 --> 02:53:02.071
MUCH MORE SERIOUS ISSUE. AND WE
02:53:02.138 --> 02:53:02.672
HAD TO PLAY TEMPORARY PORTABLE
02:53:02.739 --> 02:53:06.275
UNIT TO CORRECT. BY THE TIME WE
02:53:06.342 --> 02:53:07.376
HAVE SERVICE IN THE RESTORED
02:53:07.443 --> 02:53:09.412
ABOUT SIX HOURS AND EFFECTIVE
02:53:09.479 --> 02:53:10.480
NO MORE THAN FORTY ONE
02:53:10.546 --> 02:53:11.881
CUSTOMERS AS A MATTER OF FACT
02:53:11.948 --> 02:53:14.817
IT'S A VERY REMOTE- RESORT AREA
02:53:14.884 --> 02:53:16.586
AND- BY THAT TIME OF THE YEAR
02:53:16.652 --> 02:53:18.454
I'M NOT EVEN SURE ANYBODY WAS
02:53:18.521 --> 02:53:22.024
THERE. BUT WE STILL GOT RUNNING.
02:53:22.091 --> 02:53:23.459
THAT WAS THE EXTENT OF
02:53:23.526 --> 02:53:24.193
ORGANIZATIONS RESPECT OUR
02:53:24.260 --> 02:53:26.496
TELEPHONE INTERNET SERVICES. WE
02:53:26.562 --> 02:53:28.264
ALSO PROVIDE VIDEO CABLE
02:53:28.331 --> 02:53:30.032
TELEVISION OTHER INTERNET CABLE
02:53:30.099 --> 02:53:31.934
MODEM SERVICE AND A SELECT AREA
02:53:32.001 --> 02:53:34.003
BOTH COUNTIES THESE ARE ALL
02:53:34.070 --> 02:53:36.672
AREAS WHERE WE ARE NOT THE LACK.
02:53:36.739 --> 02:53:38.541
THIS IS A DIFFERENT NETWORK.
02:53:38.608 --> 02:53:39.809
AND THERE ARE ONLY BATTERIES
02:53:39.876 --> 02:53:40.910
AND NOT GENEROUS AND MOST OF
02:53:40.977 --> 02:53:42.979
THE SITES WE LOST MOST OF THESE
02:53:43.045 --> 02:53:44.981
AREAS WHEN THE BATTERIES DIED.
02:53:45.047 --> 02:53:47.784
THIS NETWORK IS LARGELY. NOT
02:53:47.850 --> 02:53:49.652
MISSION CRITICAL AND THAT'S WHY
02:53:49.719 --> 02:53:52.321
I SAY THAT IS WE ONLY DO VIDEO
02:53:52.388 --> 02:53:52.922
ACROSS THAT NETWORK EXCEPT FOR
02:53:52.989 --> 02:53:55.224
THE CHAIRMAN EMERITUS. ENHANCE
02:53:55.291 --> 02:53:55.758
HISTORICALLY HAD NOT BEEN
02:53:55.825 --> 02:53:59.395
BACKED UP THE SAME. AS A MORE
02:53:59.462 --> 02:53:59.896
CRITICAL PARTS OF OTHER
02:53:59.962 --> 02:54:02.031
NETWORKS IN ADDITION VOLCANO
02:54:02.098 --> 02:54:03.800
PROVIDES WIRELESS INTERNET
02:54:03.866 --> 02:54:04.367
SERVICE TO SOME OF THE MORE
02:54:04.433 --> 02:54:05.301
REMOTE OR HIS FAMILY- CALORIES
02:54:05.368 --> 02:54:06.969
COUNTY. ONCE AGAIN WE HAVE
02:54:07.036 --> 02:54:07.970
BANNERS TO VIRTUALLY ALL THE
02:54:08.037 --> 02:54:10.773
SITES BUT NO GENERATORS WITH
02:54:10.840 --> 02:54:11.374
THE EXCEPTION OF TWO CRITICAL
02:54:11.440 --> 02:54:13.309
BACK WHOLE SITES. WHERE WE DID
02:54:13.376 --> 02:54:16.979
DEPLOY PORTABLE GENERATORS. ANY
02:54:17.046 --> 02:54:18.481
SITES WITHOUT POWER QUIT AFTER
02:54:18.548 --> 02:54:19.048
THAT IS A COMPLETELY SWIRLS
02:54:19.115 --> 02:54:21.651
AREAS. SOME OF THE AREAS THAT
02:54:21.717 --> 02:54:22.585
WE SERVE WITH THE WIRELESS
02:54:22.652 --> 02:54:23.820
INTERNET WAS NOT AFFECTED BY
02:54:23.886 --> 02:54:25.788
THE PSP HOUSE. WHICH IS THE
02:54:25.855 --> 02:54:26.422
REASON THAT WE ONE HAND PULLING
02:54:26.489 --> 02:54:30.560
THE GENERATORS. DID YOU HAVE
02:54:30.626 --> 02:54:31.861
SUFFICIENT RESOURCES TO FORTY
02:54:31.928 --> 02:54:34.096
RESPONSIBILITIES AND MISSION IF
02:54:34.163 --> 02:54:34.697
NOT COULD YOU ACQUIRE THEM BY
02:54:34.764 --> 02:54:37.533
OTHER MEANS. WHILE WE HAD
02:54:37.600 --> 02:54:41.037
ENOUGH PROPANE. IS A RESOURCE
02:54:41.103 --> 02:54:42.872
THAT MIGHT HAVE BECOME AN ISSUE
02:54:42.939 --> 02:54:43.673
A CERTAIN POINT THE VENDOR WE
02:54:43.739 --> 02:54:46.776
USE IS VERY RESPONSIVE BUT THEY
02:54:46.843 --> 02:54:47.443
HAVE THEIR HANDS FULL TRYING TO
02:54:47.510 --> 02:54:48.611
KEEP PROPANE TANKS FILLED IN
02:54:48.678 --> 02:54:51.013
THE AREA AS MANY CUSTOMERS ARE
02:54:51.080 --> 02:54:55.418
AREAS HAVE HOME GENERATORS. HOW
02:54:55.484 --> 02:54:57.119
DID YOU SET PRIORITIES AND
02:54:57.186 --> 02:54:57.687
WHERE WERE THEY- I WHAT WERE
02:54:57.753 --> 02:55:00.923
THEY- FOR THIS INSTANCE. AS
02:55:00.990 --> 02:55:03.292
WITH MOST OF THEM WE HAVE
02:55:03.359 --> 02:55:03.926
EXPERIENCED OUR COMPANY LARGELY
02:55:03.993 --> 02:55:05.795
DISCONTINUES OUR CONSTRUCTION
02:55:05.862 --> 02:55:07.363
AND DAY TO DAY OPERATION AND
02:55:07.430 --> 02:55:08.865
GOES INTO NETWORK MAINTAIN
02:55:08.931 --> 02:55:11.167
VOTE. FOR EXAMPLE WITH NUMEROUS
02:55:11.234 --> 02:55:13.603
GENERATORS WE ALSO HAVE AN EVEN
02:55:13.669 --> 02:55:14.203
LARGER AMOUNT OF PROPANE TANKS
02:55:14.270 --> 02:55:16.572
AT THE SITES. MANY SITES HAVE
02:55:16.639 --> 02:55:17.740
TO LEARN FOR THE GALLON PROPANE
02:55:17.807 --> 02:55:19.976
TANKS. THAT ON AVERAGE ALLOW
02:55:20.042 --> 02:55:21.611
SITE TO RUN FROM THREE TO SEVEN
02:55:21.677 --> 02:55:23.746
DAYS IF THE TANKS ARE FULL MANY
02:55:23.813 --> 02:55:25.481
OTHER SITES ONLY HAVE FIFTY
02:55:25.548 --> 02:55:26.616
GALLON TANKS OR IN SOME CASES
02:55:26.682 --> 02:55:28.484
TO FOR THE CONTACTS. AND CAN
02:55:28.551 --> 02:55:29.685
ONLY RUN THE SITE FOR TWO DAYS
02:55:29.752 --> 02:55:31.854
OR LESS IT IS NECESSARY FIRST
02:55:31.921 --> 02:55:33.890
TO REFILL FIFTY GALLON TANKS.
02:55:33.956 --> 02:55:35.758
WHICH WE HAVE A PORTABLE
02:55:35.825 --> 02:55:36.192
FILLING STATION. OUR
02:55:36.259 --> 02:55:39.061
CONSTRUCTION HARD. AND THEN
02:55:39.128 --> 02:55:40.329
HALL TANKS THE VERY SITES IN
02:55:40.396 --> 02:55:40.963
EXCHANGE THE TANKS FOR THE
02:55:41.030 --> 02:55:43.933
EMPTY ONES. ANOTHER EXAMPLE IS
02:55:44.000 --> 02:55:44.500
OUR TO VEHICLE MECHANICS ARE
02:55:44.567 --> 02:55:48.471
PRETTY MUCH. CLEARLY CONSUMED
02:55:48.537 --> 02:55:49.005
KEEPING ALL THE GENERATORS
02:55:49.071 --> 02:55:49.505
RUNNING MAINTAINING THEM
02:55:49.572 --> 02:55:54.510
CHECKING THEM. HOW DID YOU
02:55:54.577 --> 02:55:56.512
TRIAGE ACTIVITIES AND HOW WERE
02:55:56.579 --> 02:55:59.181
THEY DRESSED IN THE PRIORITY.
02:55:59.248 --> 02:56:00.049
WITH THE EXCEPTION THE FIRST
02:56:00.116 --> 02:56:01.784
MORNING ACTIVITIES WE KEPT UP
02:56:01.851 --> 02:56:03.686
WITH HOLE OR NECESSARY TASKS
02:56:03.753 --> 02:56:04.654
LARGER IS MENTIONED IN THE
02:56:04.720 --> 02:56:07.290
FIRST QUESTION. IS POSSIBLY THE
02:56:07.356 --> 02:56:08.624
ONLY EXAMPLE OF TRIAGE AND
02:56:08.691 --> 02:56:10.559
PROBABLY MOSTLY WHY WE HAVE THE
02:56:10.626 --> 02:56:11.093
SEVENTY MIN AVERAGE AT THE
02:56:11.160 --> 02:56:12.762
SECOND SITE. AS WE WERE
02:56:12.828 --> 02:56:16.432
CORRECTING LARGER SITE FIRST.
02:56:16.499 --> 02:56:17.500
WHAT LESSONS WERE LEARNED IN
02:56:17.566 --> 02:56:18.567
ADDITION SHARE ANY OTHER
02:56:18.634 --> 02:56:21.137
THOUGHTS THAT YOU MAY HAVE THE
02:56:21.203 --> 02:56:21.704
MEMBERS UTILITIES TO BENEFIT
02:56:21.771 --> 02:56:24.106
FROM THIS EXPERIENCE. PROBABLY
02:56:24.173 --> 02:56:25.908
LESSON LEARNED FROM THIS OUTAGE
02:56:25.975 --> 02:56:26.475
IN KNOWING MORE THESE EVENTS
02:56:26.542 --> 02:56:28.978
ARE PROBABLY COMING. IS TO
02:56:29.045 --> 02:56:30.212
BEGIN TO IDENTIFY SOME OF THE
02:56:30.279 --> 02:56:31.547
LARGER IS THAT WE PROVIDE KILL
02:56:31.614 --> 02:56:33.049
MODEM INTERNET SERVICE AN
02:56:33.115 --> 02:56:34.884
ATTEMPT TO HAVE BACKUP POWER TO
02:56:34.951 --> 02:56:38.087
THOSE SITES. AS A START AND WE
02:56:38.154 --> 02:56:38.554
HAVE A RECORDING ORDER
02:56:38.621 --> 02:56:40.756
APPOINTMENT TO DO SUCH AS- IT
02:56:40.823 --> 02:56:42.858
WOULD REQUIRE MORE THAN SEVENTY
02:56:42.925 --> 02:56:44.327
ADDITIONAL GENERATORS TO COVER
02:56:44.393 --> 02:56:45.528
ALL OF OUR VIDEO AREAS THE
02:56:45.594 --> 02:56:49.498
FAILED DURING THIS PSP US. THIS
02:56:49.565 --> 02:56:50.032
IS JUST NOT PRACTICAL WAS
02:56:50.099 --> 02:56:53.002
CONSIDERING OUR SIZE. WITH THE
02:56:53.069 --> 02:56:53.602
ADDITIONAL MANPOWER THAT WOULD
02:56:53.669 --> 02:56:57.606
REQUIRE. ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF A
02:56:57.673 --> 02:56:59.175
LESSON LEARNED A LONG TIME
02:56:59.241 --> 02:57:00.710
BEFORE THIS EVER HAPPENS WITH
02:57:00.776 --> 02:57:02.611
OUR FIBER THE PRIM SERVICE IN
02:57:02.678 --> 02:57:03.579
MANY OF OUR READERS WE PROVIDE
02:57:03.646 --> 02:57:05.414
FIBER TO THE PLAN WE USE OUR
02:57:05.481 --> 02:57:07.950
EXISTING COPPER NETWORK TO
02:57:08.017 --> 02:57:08.484
POWER THE OPTICAL NETWORK
02:57:08.551 --> 02:57:09.685
TERMINAL THAT'S ON THE SIDE OF
02:57:09.752 --> 02:57:11.287
THE HOUSE. AND DO NOT RELY ON
02:57:11.354 --> 02:57:11.787
THE COMMERCIAL POWER OR
02:57:11.854 --> 02:57:14.156
BATTERIES. AS LONG AS WE KEEP
02:57:14.223 --> 02:57:15.925
OUR REMOTE SITES RUNNING WITH
02:57:15.992 --> 02:57:16.625
GENERATORS AND BATTERIES WILL
02:57:16.692 --> 02:57:18.494
CONTINUE TO PROVIDE TELEPHONE
02:57:18.561 --> 02:57:20.997
SERVICE. TO THE CUSTOMERS.
02:57:21.063 --> 02:57:22.565
LEGACY TELEPHONE SERVICE TO THE
02:57:22.631 --> 02:57:26.502
CUSTOMERS ARE. IN THE HOME AS
02:57:26.569 --> 02:57:28.070
WELL AS INTERNET SERVICE AGAIN
02:57:28.137 --> 02:57:28.671
AS LONG AS THE CUSTOMER HAS A
02:57:28.738 --> 02:57:33.309
GENERATOR IN YOUR HOME. VERSION
02:57:33.376 --> 02:57:34.276
AND I'M GONNA I'M GONNA CUT YOU
02:57:34.343 --> 02:57:36.412
OFF THERE OKAY I JUST WANTED
02:57:36.479 --> 02:57:38.948
ASK BABY THE PANEL A QUESTION
02:57:39.015 --> 02:57:42.518
REGARDING. THE WAY. RESPONSES
02:57:42.585 --> 02:57:44.520
ARE COORDINATED IN THE STATE OF
02:57:44.587 --> 02:57:45.855
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE FIFTY
02:57:45.921 --> 02:57:47.823
COUNTIES. THEY RANGE FROM
02:57:47.890 --> 02:57:49.959
COUNTIES LIKE THE ONE YOU SERVE
02:57:50.026 --> 02:57:51.093
AN ALPINE WHICH HAS ABOUT A
02:57:51.160 --> 02:57:52.628
THOUSAND PEOPLE AND I'M TO. LA
02:57:52.695 --> 02:57:55.398
COUNTY WHICH HAS TEN MILLION.
02:57:55.464 --> 02:57:57.533
AND NOT EVERY COUNTY HAS A
02:57:57.600 --> 02:57:59.335
RESOURCES TO COME UP WITH
02:57:59.402 --> 02:58:01.871
EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS PLAN SO
02:58:01.937 --> 02:58:02.471
WHERE WE DO HAVE A COUNTY LIKE
02:58:02.538 --> 02:58:08.044
ALPINE. IS THERE ARE SPECIFIC.
02:58:08.110 --> 02:58:09.678
INFRASTRUCTURE IN THAT COUNTY
02:58:09.745 --> 02:58:12.281
TO HELP IN CASE OF EMERGENCIES
02:58:12.348 --> 02:58:14.583
OR IS THAT SOMETHING THAT THE
02:58:14.650 --> 02:58:15.184
STATE OF CALIFORNIA TAKES OVER
02:58:15.251 --> 02:58:17.987
WITHIN ITS RESOURCES. PROBABLY
02:58:18.054 --> 02:58:20.856
DEPENDS A LOT ON WORKS OUT- WE
02:58:20.923 --> 02:58:23.092
HAVE FIBER AND MUCH MUCH OF THE
02:58:23.159 --> 02:58:25.194
JANUARY UP IN THAT AREA BUT WE
02:58:25.261 --> 02:58:26.228
ONLY JUST VERY TOUCH A VERY
02:58:26.295 --> 02:58:28.497
SMALL PORTION OF ALPINE COUNTY.
02:58:28.564 --> 02:58:29.165
IN THE QUICKLY MASON WHETHER
02:58:29.231 --> 02:58:31.801
SKI RESORT US IS IN IN YOUR
02:58:31.867 --> 02:58:34.070
EXPERIENCE AS THE INDUSTRY IS
02:58:34.136 --> 02:58:35.404
THERE DO YOU COORDINATE WHAT
02:58:35.471 --> 02:58:37.306
THE COUNTIES TO COME UP WITH A
02:58:37.373 --> 02:58:38.774
RESPONSE PLAN IN CASE OF
02:58:38.841 --> 02:58:40.109
EMERGENCIES. ANY KIND OF
02:58:40.176 --> 02:58:41.644
EMERGENCY IS SOME AND WE KNOW
02:58:41.710 --> 02:58:43.446
THAT IN SOME PARTS OF THE STATE
02:58:43.512 --> 02:58:46.449
THEY HAVE REVERSED NINE ONE ONE
02:58:46.515 --> 02:58:49.151
AND THEY HAVE. DIFFERENT KIND
02:58:49.218 --> 02:58:50.953
OF COMMUNICATIONS OR
02:58:51.020 --> 02:58:53.456
TELECOMMUNICATIONS- PROGRAMS.
02:58:53.522 --> 02:58:56.192
TO ASSISTANT. BUT TO THE COUNTY
02:58:56.258 --> 02:58:57.326
SPECIFICALLY COME UP WITH A
02:58:57.393 --> 02:58:58.794
PLAN THAT YOU'RE INVOLVED IN
02:58:58.861 --> 02:59:00.830
THANK YOU TO HELP DESIGN THAT
02:59:00.896 --> 02:59:02.998
YOU PROVIDE INPUT INTO IN TERMS
02:59:03.065 --> 02:59:05.367
OF.WHAT YOU'RE YOU WHAT-
02:59:05.434 --> 02:59:07.103
SERVICES YOU CAN PROVIDE IN THE
02:59:07.169 --> 02:59:11.707
IN THE. IN THE CASE OF AN
02:59:11.774 --> 02:59:14.477
EMERGENCY- WHERE THE COUNTY HAS
02:59:14.543 --> 02:59:15.611
HIS RESPONSIBILITIES YOU HAVE
02:59:15.678 --> 02:59:17.680
THERE'S AN EXAMPLE IN SAINT
02:59:17.746 --> 02:59:19.982
EQUAL WE HAD WHAT DURING THESE
02:59:20.049 --> 02:59:23.185
OUTAGES INCENDIO COUNTY WE HAD
02:59:23.252 --> 02:59:27.456
A LOT OF ELDERLY- INDIVIDUALS
02:59:27.523 --> 02:59:29.658
WITH SOME OF THAT WERE HATS
02:59:29.725 --> 02:59:33.028
MOBILITY ISSUES THAT ONCE THEIR
02:59:33.095 --> 02:59:35.297
POWER WAS CUT OFF THEY COULDN'T.
02:59:35.364 --> 02:59:37.600
TRANSPORTERS SELVES TO. A
02:59:37.666 --> 02:59:41.270
HOSPITAL CLINIC OR TO AN AREA
02:59:41.337 --> 02:59:41.837
THAT HAD AIR CONDITIONING OR
02:59:41.904 --> 02:59:44.039
HAVE THAT OUR FOOD OR WATER.
02:59:44.106 --> 02:59:46.342
AND SO THERE THEY WERE CALLING
02:59:46.408 --> 02:59:47.810
MY OFFICE ASKING FOR
02:59:47.877 --> 02:59:49.612
TRANSPORTATION ASKING FOR
02:59:49.678 --> 02:59:50.112
SUPPORT THAT WAS NOT BE
02:59:50.179 --> 02:59:54.316
PROVIDED. IF THAT IS NOT
02:59:54.383 --> 02:59:56.318
INCLUDED IN TO DELIVER IT
02:59:56.385 --> 02:59:58.687
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE COUNTY
02:59:58.754 --> 02:59:59.288
IS I MEAN WHAT WHAT CURRENTLY
02:59:59.355 --> 03:00:01.290
EXISTS AND INFRASTRUCTURE WITH
03:00:01.357 --> 03:00:03.125
REGARDS TO THE COUNTIES OR EVEN
03:00:03.192 --> 03:00:04.927
THE STATE IN RESPONDING IN
03:00:04.994 --> 03:00:07.496
THESE ELEMENTS YEAH I CAN SPEAK
03:00:07.563 --> 03:00:08.697
FOR EIGHTEEN T. SPECIFICALLY SO
03:00:08.764 --> 03:00:10.566
WE HAVE EXTERNAL AFFAIRS-
03:00:10.633 --> 03:00:12.568
RESOURCES TO ENGAGE WITH
03:00:12.635 --> 03:00:14.003
GOVERNMENT AT EVERY LEVEL RIGHT
03:00:14.069 --> 03:00:16.338
AT THE LOCAL. CITY LEVEL AT THE
03:00:16.405 --> 03:00:17.673
COUNTY LEVEL AT THE STATE WHAT
03:00:17.740 --> 03:00:20.042
LEVEL AS WELL A INCLUDING
03:00:20.109 --> 03:00:21.911
INTERFACING WITH- EMERGENCY
03:00:21.977 --> 03:00:23.879
RESPONDING OR FIRST IS ON THE
03:00:23.946 --> 03:00:25.915
ORGANIZATIONS AS WELL TOO SO
03:00:25.981 --> 03:00:26.749
WHAT WE DO IS BASED ON THOSE
03:00:26.815 --> 03:00:28.651
ENGAGEMENTS AND THE FEEDBACK
03:00:28.717 --> 03:00:30.753
THAT WE GET IN TERMS OF THOSE
03:00:30.819 --> 03:00:32.154
CRITICAL SITUATION THAT YOU
03:00:32.221 --> 03:00:34.723
DESCRIBED HEREIN- WHAT WHAT IT
03:00:34.790 --> 03:00:36.091
IS A CLEAR TO YOU WHAT
03:00:36.158 --> 03:00:38.427
RESOURCES ARE AVAILABLE BY
03:00:38.494 --> 03:00:38.994
EVERY GOVERNMENT. AGENCY IN
03:00:39.061 --> 03:00:40.196
TERMS OF WHAT THEY CAN TO
03:00:40.262 --> 03:00:41.797
PROVIDE SUPPORT TO THE PEOPLE
03:00:41.864 --> 03:00:43.199
IN THE STATE NOT TO ME
03:00:43.265 --> 03:00:44.700
SPECIFICALLY BUT- I RUN THE
03:00:44.767 --> 03:00:46.268
NETWORK AND I'M NOT NEXT DOOR
03:00:46.335 --> 03:00:48.671
FERTILIZATION BUT WHAT IS CLEAR
03:00:48.737 --> 03:00:50.105
TO ME THOUGH IS THAT WE DO GET
03:00:50.172 --> 03:00:51.473
CLEAR COMMUNICATION TO WHERE
03:00:51.540 --> 03:00:53.876
THE CRITICAL AREAS ARE AND WE
03:00:53.943 --> 03:00:56.145
PRIORITIZE OUR WE- INSURE. HELP
03:00:56.212 --> 03:00:58.180
PATIENT NETWORK STAYS UP TO
03:00:58.247 --> 03:01:00.216
SUPPORT THE CRITICAL IT IS A
03:01:00.282 --> 03:01:03.219
CLEAR TO ANYBODY AT THIS TABLE
03:01:03.285 --> 03:01:07.790
TERMS. OF WHAT'S AVAILABLE. AND
03:01:07.856 --> 03:01:11.961
SOME. A GOVERNMENT PLAN
03:01:12.027 --> 03:01:13.829
AMOUNTS. TO THE PEOPLE OF THE
03:01:13.896 --> 03:01:14.897
STATE IN CASE OF EMERGENCY I'VE
03:01:14.964 --> 03:01:15.497
NOTICED A CHAIRMAN THAT. DOES
03:01:15.564 --> 03:01:16.098
REQUIRE LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO
03:01:16.165 --> 03:01:17.166
DEVELOP A LOCAL EMERGENCY
03:01:17.233 --> 03:01:18.000
SERVICES PLAN. THAT WE AND
03:01:18.067 --> 03:01:19.768
OTHERS AT THE LOCAL LEVEL HAVE
03:01:19.835 --> 03:01:21.403
N OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE
03:01:21.470 --> 03:01:23.272
IN. I'M NOT CERTAIN HOW
03:01:23.339 --> 03:01:24.840
FREQUENTLY THEY UPDATE THOSE
03:01:24.907 --> 03:01:27.376
PLANS- BUT THOSE PLAN SHOULD IN
03:01:27.443 --> 03:01:29.712
FACT INCLUDE IDENTIFICATION OF
03:01:29.778 --> 03:01:30.980
MANY THE TYPES OF THINGS THAT
03:01:31.046 --> 03:01:33.115
YOU'RE ASKING ABOUT. OKAY LET'S
03:01:33.182 --> 03:01:34.483
FOR HELP AND I CAN I CAN SAY IN
03:01:34.550 --> 03:01:35.818
OUR CASE WE HAVE SHARED THAT
03:01:35.884 --> 03:01:37.653
WITH THE VARIOUS COUNTIES THAT.
03:01:37.720 --> 03:01:40.723
WERE CRITICAL INFRASTRUCTURE ISAND- YOU KNOW KIND OF MADE THEM
03:01:40.789 --> 03:01:42.424
AWARE OF. WHERE THE KEY POINT
03:01:42.491 --> 03:01:43.525
I'M INTERESTED IN KNOWING LIKE
03:01:43.592 --> 03:01:44.727
IN A AND THAT MY COUNTY LIKE
03:01:44.793 --> 03:01:45.561
ALPINE WHAT RESOURCES ARE
03:01:45.628 --> 03:01:49.298
AVAILABLE FOR THAT. BUT WE
03:01:49.365 --> 03:01:49.932
COULD DEFINITELY LOOK INTO THAT
03:01:49.999 --> 03:01:52.001
CENTER SKINNER. THANK YOU
03:01:52.067 --> 03:01:56.472
BRADFORD AFTER. MY HOPE MY
03:01:56.538 --> 03:01:57.139
INITIAL COMMENTS ARE JUST ON A
03:01:57.206 --> 03:01:58.073
REFLECTION OF THE WHOLE PANEL
03:01:58.140 --> 03:01:59.041
SO FAR AND EVERYTHING THAT WE
03:01:59.108 --> 03:02:01.944
FACED AN INTERESTINGLY EVERYONE
03:02:02.011 --> 03:02:04.246
IS INDICATED THESE ARE ON THIS
03:02:04.313 --> 03:02:06.615
UNPRECEDENTED SITUATION AND I
03:02:06.682 --> 03:02:07.950
REFLECTED ON DURING THE
03:02:08.017 --> 03:02:10.786
BLACKOUTS OF ART IN OUR INCLUDE
03:02:10.853 --> 03:02:13.122
INCLUDE ELECTRICITY CRISIS IN
03:02:13.188 --> 03:02:15.491
THE EARLY TWO THOUSANDS TWO
03:02:15.557 --> 03:02:16.458
THOUSAND PROBABLY MANY MANY
03:02:16.525 --> 03:02:17.726
MORE CUSTOMERS ACROSS THE STATE
03:02:17.793 --> 03:02:18.994
OF CALIFORNIA WERE AFFECTED BY
03:02:19.061 --> 03:02:20.796
BLACKOUTS THAN THESE POWER
03:02:20.863 --> 03:02:22.898
OUTAGES THE IT WAS
03:02:22.965 --> 03:02:24.500
UNPREDICTABLE. AND MAYBE NOT AS
03:02:24.566 --> 03:02:26.568
LONG OF DURATION FOR EXAMPLE IN
03:02:26.635 --> 03:02:28.837
THE CASE OF HOW LONG SAY MARIN
03:02:28.904 --> 03:02:30.172
COUNTY'S POWER CINEMA COUNTIES
03:02:30.239 --> 03:02:33.309
POWER WAS OUT DURING THIS LAST
03:02:33.375 --> 03:02:34.877
FIRE BUT- IT WAS CERTAINLY.
03:02:34.943 --> 03:02:36.512
CUSTOMERS ALL ACROSS THE STATE.
03:02:36.578 --> 03:02:40.382
AND UNPREDICTABLE AND SEMI
03:02:40.449 --> 03:02:40.883
CONSTANT SO THIS IS NOT
03:02:40.949 --> 03:02:44.953
UNPRECEDENTED. AND YET WHAT TO
03:02:45.020 --> 03:02:47.756
DO ONE BIG DIFFERENCE IS. FOR
03:02:47.823 --> 03:02:48.290
MORE DEPEND ON A LAND LINE
03:02:48.357 --> 03:02:52.394
STAND. I AM LESS DEPENDENT ON
03:02:52.461 --> 03:02:53.696
THE COMMUNICATION THING THAT
03:02:53.762 --> 03:02:59.068
REQUIRED A- POWER SOURCE NOW.
03:02:59.134 --> 03:03:03.639
IN THIS CONCEPT OF THAT. WOULD
03:03:03.706 --> 03:03:06.809
WOULD THE DIFFICULTY IS. THE
03:03:06.875 --> 03:03:09.745
LEGISLATURE DID NOT DIRECT. OUR
03:03:09.812 --> 03:03:11.547
TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANIES TO
03:03:11.613 --> 03:03:11.980
DEVELOP ALL OF THEIR
03:03:12.047 --> 03:03:16.118
TECHNOLOGIES. IN A POWER SOURCE.
03:03:16.185 --> 03:03:19.388
YOU ALL DID YOU CHOSE TO. AND
03:03:19.455 --> 03:03:22.257
SO NOW WE'RE IN A SITUATION AND
03:03:22.324 --> 03:03:23.292
EFFECTIVE BEING TOLD LIKE WILL
03:03:23.359 --> 03:03:25.294
DON'T REGULATE US DON'T
03:03:25.361 --> 03:03:28.931
REGULATE VOICEOVER PROTOCOL.
03:03:28.997 --> 03:03:29.531
BUT MAKE SURE THERE'S POWER SO
03:03:29.598 --> 03:03:33.669
ARE. OUR SERVICE THAT WE ARE
03:03:33.736 --> 03:03:36.338
PROVIDING TO RESIDENTS THAT
03:03:36.405 --> 03:03:37.306
WE'VE SOLD TO CONSUMERS AS
03:03:37.373 --> 03:03:38.273
SOMETHING THAT'S GOING TO BE
03:03:38.340 --> 03:03:40.609
THERE THAT THE COMMUNICATION
03:03:40.676 --> 03:03:43.746
THAT THEY CAN RELY ON. THE
03:03:43.812 --> 03:03:45.514
SERVER THE EMAIL THOSE ARE
03:03:45.581 --> 03:03:47.216
KINDA UNTENABLE. AND I THINK WE
03:03:47.282 --> 03:03:49.852
HAVE TO PARTNER. AND WE HAVE TO
03:03:49.918 --> 03:03:53.489
LOOK AT HOW WE CAN ACHIEVE A
03:03:53.555 --> 03:03:55.124
COMMUNICATION SERVICE THAT IS
03:03:55.190 --> 03:03:57.793
LESS DEPENDENT ON POWER BECAUSE
03:03:57.860 --> 03:03:58.360
WE CANNOT ALWAYS GOING TO BE
03:03:58.427 --> 03:03:58.994
ABLE TO GUARANTEE IT WE'RE JUST
03:03:59.061 --> 03:04:01.263
NOT. AND FOR A WHOLE. REASONS
03:04:01.330 --> 03:04:04.333
LOOK AT AUSTRALIA. AND WE COULD
03:04:04.400 --> 03:04:07.002
FACE THAT OR AN EARTHQUAKE OF
03:04:07.069 --> 03:04:09.738
THE MAGNITUDE OF THE YOU KNOW
03:04:09.805 --> 03:04:11.206
EVERY EVERY PREDICTION THE
03:04:11.273 --> 03:04:12.674
VARIOUS FAULTS IN THE STATE OF
03:04:12.741 --> 03:04:15.110
CALIFORNIA CAN EASILY HAVE THE
03:04:15.177 --> 03:04:16.478
TYPE OF EARTHQUAKES THAT ARE
03:04:16.545 --> 03:04:18.280
FAR WORSE MAGNITUDE THAT WE
03:04:18.347 --> 03:04:20.282
CURRENTLY HAVE SO WE NEED TO BE
03:04:20.349 --> 03:04:21.550
PARTNERS IN THIS AND THEY'RE
03:04:21.617 --> 03:04:22.818
PROBABLY WILL NEED TO BE
03:04:22.885 --> 03:04:25.587
ADDITIONAL REGULATION AS MUCH
03:04:25.654 --> 03:04:27.156
AS THE INDUSTRY DOES NOT LOVE
03:04:27.222 --> 03:04:29.458
IT SO. PARTNER WITH US TO
03:04:29.525 --> 03:04:31.393
FIGURE OUT HOW TO DO IT RIGHT
03:04:31.460 --> 03:04:33.862
BECAUSE ARE CONSUMERS BELIEVE
03:04:33.929 --> 03:04:36.231
THAT THEY HAVE. A COMMUNICATION
03:04:36.298 --> 03:04:38.434
SYSTEM THAT THEY CAN RELY ON.
03:04:38.500 --> 03:04:40.102
AND THEN ALL OF OUR EMERGENCY
03:04:40.169 --> 03:04:41.770
PROTOCOLS OR BASED ON IT NOW
03:04:41.837 --> 03:04:44.973
INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH. IN MY
03:04:45.040 --> 03:04:48.777
AREA WHERE THE EARTHQUAKE
03:04:48.844 --> 03:04:50.979
PREPAREDNESS PEOPLE COME TO YOU
03:04:51.046 --> 03:04:51.513
AND ORIENT YOU TO WHAT YOU
03:04:51.580 --> 03:04:55.384
SHOULD GET. THEY ADVOCATE FOR
03:04:55.451 --> 03:04:56.985
BATTERY OPERATED OR SOLAR CRANK
03:04:57.052 --> 03:05:00.022
OPERATED RADIOS. AND THEY TELL
03:05:00.088 --> 03:05:02.558
EVERYONE TO MAKE SURE THAT IN
03:05:02.624 --> 03:05:03.625
YOUR PUTTING TOGETHER YOUR
03:05:03.692 --> 03:05:05.294
EARTHQUAKE PREPAREDNESS THAT
03:05:05.360 --> 03:05:08.063
YOU MAY NOT RELY ON YOUR
03:05:08.130 --> 03:05:10.232
CELLULAR PHONE NOW THE PROBLEM
03:05:10.299 --> 03:05:12.868
IS THAT PEOPLE THAT IS NOT A
03:05:12.935 --> 03:05:14.770
UNIVERSAL UNDERSTOOD THING AND
03:05:14.837 --> 03:05:17.105
WE'VE NOT SET UP OUR EMERGENCY
03:05:17.172 --> 03:05:18.574
COMMUNICATIONS TO BE THROUGH
03:05:18.640 --> 03:05:20.509
THAT TYPE OF SYSTEM. BUT IF
03:05:20.576 --> 03:05:23.412
THAT'S THE TYPE OF SYSTEM WE
03:05:23.479 --> 03:05:24.046
NEED TO MOVE TOWARDS THEN AGAIN
03:05:24.112 --> 03:05:24.646
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO PARTNER
03:05:24.713 --> 03:05:29.618
TO DO THAT. BUT TO. TO KIND OF
03:05:29.685 --> 03:05:34.022
TURN TO US NOW AND SAY. THAT WE
03:05:34.089 --> 03:05:37.559
HAVE TO GUARANTEE THAT POWERS
03:05:37.626 --> 03:05:38.560
TWENTY FOUR SEVEN IN ORDER FOR
03:05:38.627 --> 03:05:40.696
YOUR SYSTEMS TO WORK JUST IS
03:05:40.762 --> 03:05:44.299
NOT GOING TO WORK TEN OF TEN OF.
03:05:44.366 --> 03:05:46.268
BRADFORD THANK YOU I'M GONNA
03:05:46.335 --> 03:05:48.303
HAVE GOAL A LOT OF WHAT CENTER
03:05:48.370 --> 03:05:49.805
SKINNER JUST STATED BUT I'M
03:05:49.872 --> 03:05:54.276
ALSO- EMBRACE WHAT. MS MCINTYRE
03:05:54.343 --> 03:05:54.810
STATED I THINK IT'S TRULY
03:05:54.877 --> 03:05:56.812
UNFAIR TO EXPECT. THESE
03:05:56.879 --> 03:05:58.981
ENTITIES TO PROVIDE BACKUP
03:05:59.047 --> 03:06:02.050
POWER TO ALL. THEIR RESOURCES
03:06:02.117 --> 03:06:03.285
AND ALL THE SERVICES THAT THEY
03:06:03.352 --> 03:06:05.487
PROVIDE- WE HEAR THE CHALLENGES
03:06:05.554 --> 03:06:07.189
OF GENERATORS AND THINGS OF
03:06:07.256 --> 03:06:09.525
THAT NATURE BUT MY QUESTION
03:06:09.591 --> 03:06:11.493
STILL SPEAKS TO I THINK WHAT
03:06:11.560 --> 03:06:13.028
THE REPRESENTED FROM THAT FOR A
03:06:13.095 --> 03:06:16.865
BLACK. BOOK RICK BUT QUENEAU ON
03:06:16.932 --> 03:06:19.735
WHY CONSIDER THAT FOR STATED AS
03:06:19.801 --> 03:06:22.104
IT RELATES TO THE DEPENDENCY
03:06:22.170 --> 03:06:25.173
ON. THE COPPER WIRE. AND THAT'S
03:06:25.240 --> 03:06:28.277
CRITICAL AND I WE HEAR EIGHTEEN
03:06:28.343 --> 03:06:28.777
TO USE IN THEIR SPENDING
03:06:28.844 --> 03:06:30.145
MILLIONS BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
03:06:30.212 --> 03:06:32.414
OF- INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENT
03:06:32.481 --> 03:06:33.916
BUT WHAT PERCENTAGES THAT IT'S
03:06:33.982 --> 03:06:36.418
BEING. GOING TORTURE MAINTAIN
03:06:36.485 --> 03:06:37.953
THE COPPER WIRE BECAUSE
03:06:38.020 --> 03:06:39.454
REGARDLESS AGAIN WHETHER IT'S
03:06:39.521 --> 03:06:40.622
ON THE CELL PHONE WITH THERE'S
03:06:40.689 --> 03:06:43.058
A VOICE. INTERNET PROTOCOL YOU
03:06:43.125 --> 03:06:45.360
STEAL DEPEND ON THAT COPPER
03:06:45.427 --> 03:06:48.497
INFRASTRUCTURE AND AGAIN. EIGHT
03:06:48.564 --> 03:06:50.165
YEARS AGO NINE YEARS AGO YOUR
03:06:50.232 --> 03:06:51.900
OWN EMPLOYEES SAID YOU WERE NOT
03:06:51.967 --> 03:06:53.569
MAINTAINING THAT SO I WOULD
03:06:53.635 --> 03:06:57.272
LIKE TO KNOW FROM RISE IN AND
03:06:57.339 --> 03:06:57.906
EIGHTEEN T. WHAT COMMITMENT ARE
03:06:57.973 --> 03:07:02.010
YOU REALLY MAKING TO THE COUPLE.
03:07:02.077 --> 03:07:03.612
THANK YOU CENTER. THIS A COUPLE
03:07:03.679 --> 03:07:04.112
POINTS HERE OF FOR SOFT
03:07:04.179 --> 03:07:05.380
ADDRESSING CENTER SCANNERS-
03:07:05.447 --> 03:07:06.181
COMMENT ABOUT THE UNPRECEDENTED
03:07:06.248 --> 03:07:08.850
NATURE OF THIS- THESE EVENTS
03:07:08.917 --> 03:07:10.619
pOCCURRED IN OCTOBER AND ALSO
03:07:10.686 --> 03:07:13.388
PREVIOUS COMMENTS ABOUT HOW-
03:07:13.455 --> 03:07:15.057
HOW WHETHER OR NOT THE IN THE
03:07:15.123 --> 03:07:17.159
SHE WAS PREPARE FOR THE WORST.
03:07:17.225 --> 03:07:18.961
IN TERMS OF THE PS PS EVENTS
03:07:19.027 --> 03:07:20.762
ALITALIA FROM FROM MY
03:07:20.829 --> 03:07:22.731
EXPERIENCE- COUPLE ITEMS ARE IN
03:07:22.798 --> 03:07:23.999
THE INTERVENING IT'S OF THE
03:07:24.066 --> 03:07:25.767
ENERGY ISSUES IN THE PAST I'VE
03:07:25.834 --> 03:07:27.936
LIVED IN CALIFORNIA FROM WAS MY
03:07:28.003 --> 03:07:30.138
LIFE. I WAS HERE MANAGING SOME
03:07:30.205 --> 03:07:31.306
OF THOSE POWER OUTAGES ACKER
03:07:31.373 --> 03:07:33.275
ROLLING BLACKOUTS BROWNOUTS HAD
03:07:33.342 --> 03:07:34.876
OCCURS. DURING THE ENERGY
03:07:34.943 --> 03:07:36.912
CRISIS THE DIFFERENCE THERE WAS
03:07:36.979 --> 03:07:38.680
THAT THE RULING BROWN EYES WERE
03:07:38.747 --> 03:07:43.652
POWER IF YOU SHUT OFF FOR A FEW
03:07:43.719 --> 03:07:44.252
HOURS. THIS IS THE BALLOT BOB
03:07:44.319 --> 03:07:54.129
BARR. YEAH YEAH. PLEASE LET LET
03:07:54.196 --> 03:07:55.230
LET LET HIM BEEN TRUCK OUT OF
03:07:55.297 --> 03:07:57.099
SO WE IN TERMS OF THE- THE
03:07:57.165 --> 03:07:58.333
DEPLOYMENTS- WE WERE YOU KNOW
03:07:58.400 --> 03:07:59.835
WE HAD- GENERATOR IS DEPLOYED
03:07:59.901 --> 03:08:01.303
THAT WAS FIVE TO TEN TIMES MORE
03:08:01.370 --> 03:08:01.870
THAN WHAT OTHER P. S. P. S.
03:08:01.937 --> 03:08:03.939
EVENTS THAT HAS OCCURRED- AND
03:08:04.006 --> 03:08:06.174
WE ARE INVESTING IN TERMS OF
03:08:06.241 --> 03:08:08.276
GROWING THAT- GENERATING
03:08:08.343 --> 03:08:09.811
CAPACITY TO ADDRESS THAT RIGHT
03:08:09.878 --> 03:08:10.912
BUT THAT TO ADDRESS YOUR
03:08:10.979 --> 03:08:13.148
QUESTION SENATE REFEREE ABOUT-
03:08:13.215 --> 03:08:15.917
INVESTMENT IN TERMS OF- COPPER
03:08:15.984 --> 03:08:18.654
WIRES- WE ARE INVESTING IN FROM
03:08:18.720 --> 03:08:20.022
A COPPER WIRE PERFECT-
03:08:20.088 --> 03:08:22.457
PERSPECTIVE IN PROPORTION IT
03:08:22.524 --> 03:08:25.927
TOO WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE
03:08:25.994 --> 03:08:26.561
REQUIRED RIGHT WOULD YOU SEE OF
03:08:26.628 --> 03:08:28.764
ABOUT TWELVE MILLION. CUSTOMERS
03:08:28.830 --> 03:08:30.666
ON THE COPPER WIRE WITH MILLION
03:08:30.732 --> 03:08:32.467
ON THE RIGHT NOW- I HAVE
03:08:32.534 --> 03:08:34.102
RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE OVERALL
03:08:34.169 --> 03:08:35.604
NETWORK WE DON'T LOOK AT
03:08:35.671 --> 03:08:37.305
INVESTMENT IN TERMS OF A SINGLE
03:08:37.372 --> 03:08:39.808
TECHNOLOGY. WE LOOK AT-
03:08:39.875 --> 03:08:41.109
INVESTMENT FROM A NETWORK
03:08:41.176 --> 03:08:42.477
PERSPECTIVE IN TERMS OF THE
03:08:42.544 --> 03:08:44.246
OVERARCHING NETWORK TO ENSURE
03:08:44.312 --> 03:08:52.020
THAT WE GET THAT TYPE. GETS TO
03:08:52.087 --> 03:08:53.288
ADEQUATE AMOUNT OF INVESTMENT
03:08:53.355 --> 03:08:54.923
TO SHIP SUPPORT THAT AND GROW
03:08:54.990 --> 03:08:56.958
THAT CAPABILITY SO THAT THEY
03:08:57.025 --> 03:08:59.294
HAVE THESE ADDITIONAL-
03:08:59.361 --> 03:09:00.996
CAPABILITIES THAT WE WILL ALL
03:09:01.063 --> 03:09:03.632
TALK ABOUT IN TERMS OF HOUSE IS
03:09:03.699 --> 03:09:04.566
CENTRAL TO OUR AT THE
03:09:04.633 --> 03:09:06.601
ACTIVITIES. ARE YOU I TOTALLY
03:09:06.668 --> 03:09:07.502
UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE SAYING
03:09:07.569 --> 03:09:09.938
BUT I TOTALLY DISAGREE I SOLD.
03:09:10.005 --> 03:09:12.374
TELECOMMUNICATIONS FOR IBM I.
03:09:12.441 --> 03:09:14.276
SO THE SYSTEM THAT INSIDE THIS
03:09:14.342 --> 03:09:16.144
BUILDING RIGHT HERE YOU STEAL
03:09:16.211 --> 03:09:18.313
DEPEND WHETHER USING A WIRELESS
03:09:18.380 --> 03:09:19.981
SYSTEM YOU STILL DEPEND ON THAT
03:09:20.048 --> 03:09:21.450
IT FOR STRUCTURE. THOSE
03:09:21.516 --> 03:09:23.785
INDEPENDENT PHONE COMPANIES DO
03:09:23.852 --> 03:09:27.322
SPEND ON THOSE AND DEPENDED-
03:09:27.389 --> 03:09:28.990
INFRASTRUCTURE THAT COPPER WIRE
03:09:29.057 --> 03:09:31.727
TO MEETING CUSTOMER RELIABILITY
03:09:31.793 --> 03:09:33.161
TO THEIR CUSTOMER.THAT DOES
03:09:33.228 --> 03:09:34.963
NEED TO BE MAINTAINED WITH YOUR
03:09:35.030 --> 03:09:36.798
CUSTOMER MIGRATES AWAY FROM ALL
03:09:36.865 --> 03:09:38.233
OUR LINE GOES TO WIRELESS
03:09:38.300 --> 03:09:39.067
THAT'S DEAL VITAL TO THE
03:09:39.134 --> 03:09:40.635
COMMUNICATION IN OVERALL
03:09:40.702 --> 03:09:45.540
SERVERS LIABILITY. EVEN. FOR
03:09:45.607 --> 03:09:46.074
YOUR CABLE NETWORK AT SOME
03:09:46.141 --> 03:09:51.546
POINT YOU'RE ON THAT BACK BALL.
03:09:51.613 --> 03:09:52.147
TACKLE IN TERMS OF FIBER OPTIC
03:09:52.214 --> 03:09:53.515
CABLE AND CALDWELL YOUR YOUR-
03:09:53.582 --> 03:09:55.417
YOUR COPPER CONNECTS DOES SOME
03:09:55.484 --> 03:09:57.219
YOUR FIBER- SOME OF IT YEAH I
03:09:57.285 --> 03:09:58.353
BUT I'M BE SANDWICH BECAUSE
03:09:58.420 --> 03:09:59.254
YOU'RE MY GREEN AWAY FROM BUT
03:09:59.321 --> 03:10:00.489
IT'S STILL A NEEDED
03:10:00.555 --> 03:10:01.056
INFRASTRUCTURE. FOR SERVICE
03:10:01.123 --> 03:10:03.024
RELIABILITY. THANK YOU CENTER
03:10:03.091 --> 03:10:08.263
MCGUIRE. THANK YOU SO MUCH
03:10:08.330 --> 03:10:12.968
MISTER CHAIR THEM. DC HAVE SOME
03:10:13.034 --> 03:10:13.802
QUICK COMMENTS ARE DISABLED FOR
03:10:13.869 --> 03:10:15.303
SOME RESPONSES AND ADD THEIR IS
03:10:15.370 --> 03:10:16.304
AT A COMMENT THAT WE NEED TO
03:10:16.371 --> 03:10:17.072
HOLD LIKE I'M PARAPHRASING
03:10:17.139 --> 03:10:18.907
ELECTRIC UTILITIES RESPONSIBLE
03:10:18.974 --> 03:10:19.808
AND ACCOUNTABLE. ABSOLUTELY I
03:10:19.875 --> 03:10:21.543
THINK THAT YOU'RE SEEN ALL
03:10:21.610 --> 03:10:22.110
LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT IN THE
03:10:22.177 --> 03:10:24.746
STATE- TAKE ACTION TO BE ABLE
03:10:24.813 --> 03:10:26.248
TO HOLD IN PARTICULAR- UNBIASED
03:10:26.314 --> 03:10:27.315
HERE PACIFIC GAS ELECTRIC
03:10:27.382 --> 03:10:29.818
ACCOUNTABLE FOR THEIR ACTIONS
03:10:29.885 --> 03:10:32.420
IN THESE MASSIVE POWER OUTAGES
03:10:32.487 --> 03:10:34.022
AND I THINK THAT WE NEED TO BE
03:10:34.089 --> 03:10:35.490
PREPARED FOR THE WORST A MATTER
03:10:35.557 --> 03:10:38.026
IF YOU ARE- SL PROVIDER. PER
03:10:38.093 --> 03:10:40.695
CABLE PROVIDER WHETHER IT IS A
03:10:40.762 --> 03:10:44.032
POWER SHUT OFF. AN EARTHQUAKE A
03:10:44.099 --> 03:10:47.536
CYBER ATTACK- WE HAVE TO BE
03:10:47.602 --> 03:10:48.136
PREPARED WITH RESILIENT AND WE
03:10:48.203 --> 03:10:51.239
DONE SYSTEMS. SO FIRST OF ALL
03:10:51.306 --> 03:10:52.274
LET MEANS WE START TALKING
03:10:52.340 --> 03:10:54.643
ABOUT REAL NUMBERS I APPRECIATE
03:10:54.709 --> 03:10:56.912
ABOUT THE 7% OF RISING DISCUSS
03:10:56.978 --> 03:10:58.580
I THINK WE NEED TO LOOK AT THE
03:10:58.647 --> 03:10:59.014
REAL NUMBERS. ABOUT
03:10:59.080 --> 03:11:01.349
CALIFORNIANS. IN THE STAFF
03:11:01.416 --> 03:11:03.518
REPORT IS ONE POINT ONE
03:11:03.585 --> 03:11:03.952
APPROXIMATE MILLION
03:11:04.019 --> 03:11:05.654
CALIFORNIANS WE HEARD TODAY.
03:11:05.720 --> 03:11:07.889
FROM REPRESENTATIVES TWO
03:11:07.956 --> 03:11:08.490
MILLION CALIFORNIANS THAT WERE
03:11:08.557 --> 03:11:13.428
IMPACTED. FROM THEIR CELL CABLE
03:11:13.495 --> 03:11:20.135
OUR LAND LINES BEING DOWN. FOUR
03:11:20.202 --> 03:11:20.735
HUNDRED FIFTY FOUR THOUSAND ON
03:11:20.802 --> 03:11:21.803
CABLE LAND LINE ALONE AND
03:11:21.870 --> 03:11:22.537
THAT'S A MULTIPLYING FACTOR BY
03:11:22.604 --> 03:11:27.209
THREE. SO I THINK THAT'S THE
03:11:27.275 --> 03:11:27.843
REAL NUMBER WE NEED TO FOCUS IN
03:11:27.909 --> 03:11:28.343
ON IN HOW WE'RE GOING TO
03:11:28.410 --> 03:11:34.683
IMPROVE THAT. BACKUP POWER IS
03:11:34.749 --> 03:11:37.786
ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY NOW. AND
03:11:37.853 --> 03:11:38.720
JUST BEING CANDID MANY OF YOU
03:11:38.787 --> 03:11:40.322
WERE IN THE ROOM. I REPRESENT
03:11:40.388 --> 03:11:44.359
IS TOLD US. THAT YOU ALL WERE
03:11:44.426 --> 03:11:50.365
PREPARED FOR THE WORST. AND WE
03:11:50.432 --> 03:11:52.133
FAST FORWARD TO LATE SUMMER AND
03:11:52.200 --> 03:11:54.135
INTO THE FALL. AND THE WORST
03:11:54.202 --> 03:11:57.372
HAPPENED. AND WE SHOULD HAVE
03:11:57.439 --> 03:12:01.009
BEEN PREPARED FOR THAT. SO NOW
03:12:01.076 --> 03:12:05.180
WE'RE HERE. THREE THAT WE'RE
03:12:05.247 --> 03:12:05.680
NOT GONNA HIT A HUNDRED
03:12:05.747 --> 03:12:07.415
PERCENT. AGREE WITH THAT. BUT
03:12:07.482 --> 03:12:10.719
YOU NEED TO START WITH THE PLAN.
03:12:10.785 --> 03:12:12.153
SO WHAT I WOULD HOPE IS GOING
03:12:12.220 --> 03:12:12.787
TO COME FROM THIS HEARING VIEW
03:12:12.854 --> 03:12:15.390
FULL NUMBER ONE A PLANE'S GONNA
03:12:15.457 --> 03:12:16.558
BE PROVIDED BY BOTH
03:12:16.625 --> 03:12:17.559
TELECOMMUNICATION CABLE TO THE
03:12:17.626 --> 03:12:19.628
OFFICE EMERGENCY SERVICES ABOUT
03:12:19.694 --> 03:12:20.128
HOW YOU CAN MAKE A MORE
03:12:20.195 --> 03:12:23.865
RESILIENT SYSTEM. NUMBER TWO IF
03:12:23.932 --> 03:12:24.299
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
03:12:24.366 --> 03:12:26.067
COLLABORATION. IT'S A TWO WAY
03:12:26.134 --> 03:12:28.236
STREET. WE CAN'T HIDE BEHIND
03:12:28.303 --> 03:12:29.437
WERE FEDERALLY REGULATED
03:12:29.504 --> 03:12:32.274
UTILITY WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO
03:12:32.340 --> 03:12:32.807
MOVE FORWARD AND SAY WE'RE
03:12:32.874 --> 03:12:34.342
GONNA BE COLLABORATIVE. WE'RE
03:12:34.409 --> 03:12:36.745
GONNA PROVIDE INFORMATION. AND
03:12:36.811 --> 03:12:38.413
WE'RE GONNA TALK ABOUT NOT JUST
03:12:38.480 --> 03:12:40.649
LARGE NUMBERS ABOUT HOW MUCH
03:12:40.715 --> 03:12:41.082
WE'RE INVESTING BUT
03:12:41.149 --> 03:12:41.549
SPECIFICALLY HOW WE'RE
03:12:41.616 --> 03:12:43.551
INVESTING IN. AND WHAT THE
03:12:43.618 --> 03:12:45.020
OUTCOME OF THAT INVESTMENTS CAN
03:12:45.086 --> 03:12:45.587
BE FOR RESILIENCY WITHIN THE
03:12:45.654 --> 03:12:47.989
SYSTEM. BECAUSE OTHERWISE WE
03:12:48.056 --> 03:12:49.758
WILL NOT HAVE THE METRICS TO BE
03:12:49.824 --> 03:12:52.827
ABLE TO DEFINE SUCCESS. THE
03:12:52.894 --> 03:12:56.197
LAST PIECES STREAMLINING ALL
03:12:56.264 --> 03:12:56.798
FOR STREAMLINING BUT HAS BEEN
03:12:56.865 --> 03:12:59.301
THE NAME OF PUBLIC SAFETY. IT
03:12:59.367 --> 03:13:01.569
CAN'T BE SMS SAID A NEW
03:13:01.636 --> 03:13:04.739
BUSINESS MODEL IN THE STATE. SO
03:13:04.806 --> 03:13:06.274
WHAT I WOULD HOPE IS THAT THERE
03:13:06.341 --> 03:13:07.842
ARE GONNA BE COMPROMISES WE
03:13:07.909 --> 03:13:09.778
MOVE FOR THIS YEAR OBVIOUSLY I
03:13:09.844 --> 03:13:12.614
HAVE A BIAS AS THE AREA THAT I
03:13:12.681 --> 03:13:13.815
PROBABLY REPRESENT WITH SENATOR
03:13:13.882 --> 03:13:16.418
DODD WAS IMPACTED DRAMATICALLY
03:13:16.484 --> 03:13:17.552
BY THE LOSS OF
03:13:17.619 --> 03:13:20.488
TELECOMMUNICATIONS CABLE
03:13:20.555 --> 03:13:22.624
LANDLINE CELL. CABLE MAINLINE.
03:13:22.691 --> 03:13:24.726
AND WHAT I WOULD HOPE. IS THAT
03:13:24.793 --> 03:13:26.227
THIS COLLABORATION WILL BE A
03:13:26.294 --> 03:13:28.563
TWO WAY STREET. WE WILL BE ABLE
03:13:28.630 --> 03:13:30.632
TO BE CONFIDENTIAL MOVING
03:13:30.699 --> 03:13:32.934
FORWARD ON CONCERNS. AS WE SIT
03:13:33.001 --> 03:13:35.337
AROUND THAT TABLE- AND THEN
03:13:35.403 --> 03:13:36.671
HOPEFULLY BE ABLE TO MOVE
03:13:36.738 --> 03:13:38.673
FORWARD TOGETHER NINETEEN SURE
03:13:38.740 --> 03:13:39.941
THE CALIFORNIANS HAVE THE
03:13:40.008 --> 03:13:42.077
SYSTEM THAT THEY HAVE COME TO
03:13:42.143 --> 03:13:45.413
RELY ON. I AND THAT WOULD BE MY
03:13:45.480 --> 03:13:46.014
OWN COMES THINK THANK YOU SIR
03:13:46.081 --> 03:13:49.751
MCGUIRE A CENTER DOLLY. THE US
03:13:49.818 --> 03:13:50.251
CHAIR THANK YOU FOR YOUR
03:13:50.318 --> 03:13:54.289
TESTIMONY TODAY SO. I'M MORE
03:13:54.356 --> 03:13:58.360
I'M MORE CONCERNED ABOUT. AND
03:13:58.426 --> 03:14:00.095
THE INFRASTRUCTURE ITSELF THAT
03:14:00.161 --> 03:14:03.031
AS YOU KNOW I STATED EARLIER
03:14:03.098 --> 03:14:05.800
WHEN THE PC WAS UP HERE ABOUT.
03:14:05.867 --> 03:14:07.469
WE HAVE A LOT OF I HAVE A LAND
03:14:07.535 --> 03:14:08.103
LINE IN MY HOME BECAUSE MY CELL
03:14:08.169 --> 03:14:12.440
SERVICE. THE SOCKS HOUSE OUT
03:14:12.507 --> 03:14:15.343
FOR NEW POLITICAL STATEMENT. IN
03:14:15.410 --> 03:14:16.945
A LOT OF MY CONSTITUENTS DO IN
03:14:17.012 --> 03:14:18.913
THE IN THE ROLE AREAS BUT WE
03:14:18.980 --> 03:14:20.615
KNOW THAT THERE ARE LIKE EIGHT
03:14:20.682 --> 03:14:22.617
MILLION PEOPLE THAT HAVE LAND
03:14:22.684 --> 03:14:24.252
LINES AND FORTY FOUR MILLION
03:14:24.319 --> 03:14:26.955
PEOPLE THAT USE. NEWS IS THIS
03:14:27.022 --> 03:14:30.625
FOR THEIR MAIN HOME USE AND
03:14:30.692 --> 03:14:32.460
IT'S ABOUT MAKING MONEY IN
03:14:32.527 --> 03:14:34.729
PROFITS AND THAT'S WHERE THE
03:14:34.796 --> 03:14:35.697
THAT'S WORSE DRIVING THE MOVE
03:14:35.764 --> 03:14:39.367
TO. YOU KNOW SELL SERVICES AND
03:14:39.434 --> 03:14:40.635
MOBILE DEVICES. IT IS ALSO WHAT
03:14:40.702 --> 03:14:42.837
THE PUBLIC WANTS. BUT THE SAME
03:14:42.904 --> 03:14:44.539
TIME WE STILL NEED TO HAVE THAT
03:14:44.606 --> 03:14:45.974
INFRASTRUCTURE SO YOU CENTER
03:14:46.041 --> 03:14:47.609
FOR CENTER BRADFORD PRODUCTS OF
03:14:47.675 --> 03:14:49.210
WHAT I'M I'M NOT EXPERT IN.
03:14:49.277 --> 03:14:51.246
WHAT THE INFRASTRUCTURE REALLY
03:14:51.312 --> 03:14:52.280
NEEDS BUT I KNOW ONE THING THAT
03:14:52.347 --> 03:14:55.917
IT DOESN'T WORK FOR. THE
03:14:55.984 --> 03:14:56.484
CONSTITUENTS I REPRESENT IS
03:14:56.551 --> 03:15:00.688
THAT. WHEN WE HAD A CAMPFIRE WE
03:15:00.755 --> 03:15:01.956
COULDN'T COMMUNICATE WITH
03:15:02.023 --> 03:15:03.725
PEOPLE TO GET THEM GOING IN THE
03:15:03.792 --> 03:15:04.325
RIGHT DIRECTION BECAUSE THEY
03:15:04.392 --> 03:15:05.326
WERE GOING IN THE WRONG
03:15:05.393 --> 03:15:08.663
DIRECTION. TWICE VOTED FOR THE
03:15:08.730 --> 03:15:10.331
FEE ON THE NINE ONE ONE IS TO
03:15:10.398 --> 03:15:13.101
GET THAT IN PLACE. SO IS IT THE
03:15:13.168 --> 03:15:15.236
LAN IS IT THE COPPER LINES OR
03:15:15.303 --> 03:15:17.138
THE FIBER OPTIC LINES THAT THAT
03:15:17.205 --> 03:15:19.174
REALLY CARRY THE LOAD THEY DO.
03:15:19.240 --> 03:15:21.976
SOME POINT THIS HAS TO GO TO
03:15:22.043 --> 03:15:22.544
SOMETHING THAT TRANSMITS IT
03:15:22.610 --> 03:15:25.480
SOMEWHERE I'M ASSUMING. SO I
03:15:25.547 --> 03:15:27.449
WANT TO KNOW WHO'S RESPONSIBLE
03:15:27.515 --> 03:15:27.849
FOR THAT BACKBONE
03:15:27.916 --> 03:15:32.720
INFRASTRUCTURE. IS IT EIGHTEEN
03:15:32.787 --> 03:15:34.189
T. IS IT COMCAST WHO WHO
03:15:34.255 --> 03:15:37.792
ACTUALLY. IS RESPONSIBLE TO
03:15:37.859 --> 03:15:40.161
MAKE THAT HAPPEN IS IT YES.
03:15:40.228 --> 03:15:40.728
KITTERY ANSWER THAT QUESTION
03:15:40.795 --> 03:15:45.233
FOR ME. OR DO WE JUST SELL IT
03:15:45.300 --> 03:15:46.835
TO WHOEVER I WANNA BREAKS IT'S
03:15:46.901 --> 03:15:48.870
BROKEN AND NOBODY MAINTAINS IT
03:15:48.937 --> 03:15:49.471
BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE DAY.
03:15:49.537 --> 03:15:52.707
I CAN'T GET. PROVIDERS TO COME
03:15:52.774 --> 03:15:55.643
TO MY COMMUNITIES. WHERE THEY
03:15:55.710 --> 03:15:56.277
CAN'T MAKE A PROFIT EVEN THOUGH
03:15:56.344 --> 03:15:56.878
WE ARE SUBSIDIZING THEM TO DO
03:15:56.945 --> 03:16:00.048
IT. IT IS ALL ABOUT PROFITS AT
03:16:00.115 --> 03:16:01.816
THE END OF THE DAY I NEED TO BE
03:16:01.883 --> 03:16:03.918
ABLE TO COMMUNICATE WITH MY
03:16:03.985 --> 03:16:05.653
CONSTITUENTS WHEN THERE'S A
03:16:05.720 --> 03:16:07.155
FIRE. OR THERE'S AN EARTHQUAKE
03:16:07.222 --> 03:16:08.656
OR THERE'S A MUD SLIDE OR
03:16:08.723 --> 03:16:11.092
WHATEVER IT IS. AND WE AND I AS
03:16:11.159 --> 03:16:13.962
I STATED EARLIER WE STEPPED UP
03:16:14.028 --> 03:16:14.562
TO THE PLATE WE PUT THE MONEY
03:16:14.629 --> 03:16:18.600
IN PLACE. FOUR EIGHT AB SIXTEEN
03:16:18.666 --> 03:16:19.167
SIXTY TWO I BELIEVE WAS THE
03:16:19.234 --> 03:16:21.069
NUMBER. I WORKED WITH THAT I
03:16:21.136 --> 03:16:22.170
WAS A CO AUTHOR JOINT AUTHORED
03:16:22.237 --> 03:16:25.507
WITH- MY FRIENDS FROM- THE-
03:16:25.573 --> 03:16:27.108
IMPERIAL THAT HAVE THE SAME
03:16:27.175 --> 03:16:29.577
ISSUES I HOP IN LASSEN. AND YOU
03:16:29.644 --> 03:16:30.879
KNOW WHAT THE MONEY IS THERE
03:16:30.945 --> 03:16:32.247
AND NOBODY'S ACCESS AND THAT
03:16:32.313 --> 03:16:33.081
MONEY BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT
03:16:33.148 --> 03:16:34.449
THERE'S OUR PROFIT IN EVEN
03:16:34.516 --> 03:16:36.851
THOUGH WE'RE SUBSIDIZING. SO I
03:16:36.918 --> 03:16:38.253
WANT SOMEBODY ANSWER WHO WHO'S
03:16:38.319 --> 03:16:39.354
MAINTAIN THAT BACKBONE
03:16:39.420 --> 03:16:40.321
INFRASTRUCTURE SO THAT WHEN
03:16:40.388 --> 03:16:42.457
THERE'S A FIRE I CAN ACTUALLY
03:16:42.524 --> 03:16:43.091
GET A LAND LINE OR WHATEVER IT
03:16:43.158 --> 03:16:44.759
IS OR GETS SELL SERVICES OUT
03:16:44.826 --> 03:16:47.162
THERE. SO WE CAN COMMUNICATE
03:16:47.228 --> 03:16:50.265
WHO DO WHO DOES THAT. UP TO
03:16:50.331 --> 03:16:51.599
ADDRESS YOUR QUESTION SO- IN
03:16:51.666 --> 03:16:52.901
TERMS OF WHAT TYPE OF
03:16:52.967 --> 03:16:56.271
FACILITIES FEED- CELL SITES- I
03:16:56.337 --> 03:16:57.472
COULD SPEAK SPECIFICALLY FROM
03:16:57.539 --> 03:16:59.007
EIGHTEEN T. PERSPECTIVE. I AM
03:16:59.073 --> 03:17:01.242
NOT AWARE OF A SINGLE CELL
03:17:01.309 --> 03:17:03.611
SITES BEING FED BY COPPER-
03:17:03.678 --> 03:17:05.313
ANYMORE ADDED TO MAYBE ONE DAY
03:17:05.380 --> 03:17:06.681
MAYBE TWO BUT- FROM MY
03:17:06.748 --> 03:17:07.882
KNOWLEDGE I'M NOT AWARE OF A
03:17:07.949 --> 03:17:09.918
SINGLE ONE. THAT STEP BY COOPER
03:17:09.984 --> 03:17:13.388
ALMOST THE VAST MAJORITY OF OUR
03:17:13.454 --> 03:17:14.455
CELL SIZE ARE FED BY FIBER
03:17:14.522 --> 03:17:16.925
OPTIC CABLES- BECAUSE OF THE
03:17:16.991 --> 03:17:18.326
HIGH CAPACITY DEMANDS THAT ARE
03:17:18.393 --> 03:17:19.327
CELL SITES NEED ANY
03:17:19.394 --> 03:17:21.162
CAPABILITIES. THAT'S REQUIRED
03:17:21.229 --> 03:17:22.931
TO SUPPORT THE SERVICES THAT WE
03:17:22.997 --> 03:17:26.768
ALL VALUE AS CONSUMERS- AND THE
03:17:26.834 --> 03:17:28.169
VAST MAJORITY OF THOSE FIBER
03:17:28.236 --> 03:17:30.238
OPTIC CABLES. A HEARING THE
03:17:30.305 --> 03:17:32.774
STATE OF CALIFORNIA RELATIVE TO
03:17:32.840 --> 03:17:34.042
EIGHTEEN T. IS MAINTAINED AND
03:17:34.108 --> 03:17:38.680
MANAGED BY OUR WATER LINE
03:17:38.746 --> 03:17:39.280
EIGHTEEN T. TEAM WHICH IS ALSO
03:17:39.347 --> 03:17:43.418
AND MY RESPONSIBILITY. CENTER
03:17:43.484 --> 03:17:44.452
HIS HIS FROM MINE FROM VERIZON
03:17:44.519 --> 03:17:47.855
AGAIN. FROM VERIZON PERSPECTIVE
03:17:47.922 --> 03:17:49.791
WHEN WE ARE DEPLOYING A
03:17:49.857 --> 03:17:53.661
WIRELESS FACILITY ANYWHERE- WE
03:17:53.728 --> 03:17:55.697
HAVE TO GET AT LEAST TWO OTHER
03:17:55.763 --> 03:17:57.131
THINGS OTHER THAN OUR WIRELESS
03:17:57.198 --> 03:17:58.766
FACILITY ITSELF WE NEED TO GET
03:17:58.833 --> 03:18:00.335
THE BACK HALL OR SOMETIMES
03:18:00.401 --> 03:18:01.836
CALLED FROM HALL WHICH WE DO
03:18:01.903 --> 03:18:03.638
WITH FIBER. WE DON'T DEPLOY
03:18:03.705 --> 03:18:06.007
THAT OURSELVES WE LEASED OUT
03:18:06.074 --> 03:18:07.308
FROM OTHER CARRIERS LIKE AT AND
03:18:07.375 --> 03:18:08.743
T. THE CABLE COMPANIES AND OR
03:18:08.810 --> 03:18:11.679
SOME OTHER CARRIERS OUT THERE
03:18:11.746 --> 03:18:13.348
THAT SPECIFICALLY PROVIDE FIBRE
03:18:13.414 --> 03:18:16.517
MICRON CASTLE- WE ALSO NEED TO
03:18:16.584 --> 03:18:21.489
GET POWER TO OUR FACILITIES SO
03:18:21.556 --> 03:18:22.023
WE HAVE TO GET THAT FROM A
03:18:22.090 --> 03:18:22.557
THIRD PARTY TO WE DON'T DO
03:18:22.624 --> 03:18:25.860
POWER. JUST AS WE DON'T DO
03:18:25.927 --> 03:18:26.394
POWER WE'RE NOT DOING THE
03:18:26.461 --> 03:18:28.096
FIBERS- WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT
03:18:28.162 --> 03:18:31.032
WHOSE RESPONSIBILITY IS IT- I
03:18:31.099 --> 03:18:33.067
THINK THE QUESTION SHOULD BE
03:18:33.134 --> 03:18:36.304
TALKED ABOUT MORE AS- AS HOW OR
03:18:36.371 --> 03:18:39.540
WIRELESS. NETWORKS BUILT. AND
03:18:39.607 --> 03:18:43.478
WHO HAS THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF
03:18:43.544 --> 03:18:44.479
THE DIFFERENT PIECE PARTS OF
03:18:44.545 --> 03:18:46.814
IT. ON AND HOW MUCH OF THAT DO
03:18:46.881 --> 03:18:49.017
WE WANT TO ENCOURAGE BECAUSE WE
03:18:49.083 --> 03:18:50.685
ACTUALLY WANT TO GET CELLULAR
03:18:50.752 --> 03:18:52.687
SERVICES TO SOME OF THE PLACES
03:18:52.754 --> 03:18:54.088
WHERE THERE IS NO CELL SERVICE
03:18:54.155 --> 03:19:00.361
RIGHT- SO I THINK THAT- I AGREE
03:19:00.428 --> 03:19:01.696
WITH EIGHTEEN TEASE COMMENT
03:19:01.763 --> 03:19:04.432
THAT. COPPER REALLY IS NOT PART
03:19:04.499 --> 03:19:08.336
OF THIS EQUATION ITS FIBER- AND
03:19:08.403 --> 03:19:09.370
YOU GET FIBER YOU PUT IT IN THE
03:19:09.437 --> 03:19:11.673
GROUND AND YOU PUT IT ON- UP
03:19:11.739 --> 03:19:14.442
ON. HOLES BUT- IT'S CRITICAL
03:19:14.509 --> 03:19:16.544
POWER AND FIBER TO GET CELL
03:19:16.611 --> 03:19:19.881
SERVICE. OKAY SO I'M GONNA
03:19:19.947 --> 03:19:20.415
CLOSE MY COMMENT WITH THIS
03:19:20.481 --> 03:19:24.419
STATEMENT. SO I UNDERSTAND
03:19:24.485 --> 03:19:25.019
COMPETITION I UNDERSTAND FREE
03:19:25.086 --> 03:19:27.588
MARKETS AND I THINK IT'S UPON
03:19:27.655 --> 03:19:30.024
THE LEGISLATURE AND- YES TO
03:19:30.091 --> 03:19:32.260
FIGURE OUT HOW WITH ALL THE
03:19:32.327 --> 03:19:34.762
COPPER- ALL THE FIBER TO SAY
03:19:34.829 --> 03:19:36.164
FOR AND THE AND THE POWER IN
03:19:36.230 --> 03:19:38.433
THE STRUCTURE IS BUT AS UPON US
03:19:38.499 --> 03:19:39.167
IN THE P. YOU SEE TO FIGURE OUT
03:19:39.233 --> 03:19:40.935
HOW WE'RE GOING TO MANAGE. OUR
03:19:41.002 --> 03:19:42.704
PUBLIC SAFETY PROBLEMS THAT
03:19:42.770 --> 03:19:45.440
WE'RE HAVING SO WHEN WE TRY TO
03:19:45.506 --> 03:19:47.408
TACKLE THAT WHAT WE HEARD FROM
03:19:47.475 --> 03:19:49.077
THE P. YOU SEE AS WELL THEY
03:19:49.143 --> 03:19:51.212
WON'T SHARE THEIR INFORMATION
03:19:51.279 --> 03:19:51.813
US BECAUSE IS PROPRIETARY FOR
03:19:51.879 --> 03:19:55.717
TO THEIR BUSINESS MODEL. WHAT I
03:19:55.783 --> 03:19:56.250
HEAR FROM YOU SAYING IS P.
03:19:56.317 --> 03:19:56.884
GENIES THE PROBLEM BECAUSE THEY
03:19:56.951 --> 03:19:58.486
SHUT THE POWER OFF. SO
03:19:58.553 --> 03:20:01.689
SOMEWHERE THERE HAS TO BE. A
03:20:01.756 --> 03:20:03.925
CENTRAL COMMAND SAYS OKAY WE'RE
03:20:03.991 --> 03:20:05.293
GOING TO FIX THE PROBLEM HERE
03:20:05.360 --> 03:20:07.562
BECAUSE WITH THIS IS NOT GONNA
03:20:07.628 --> 03:20:08.129
GO WE'RE GONNA HAVE FIRES IN
03:20:08.196 --> 03:20:08.730
CALIFORNIA WE HAVE PLEDGE ARE
03:20:08.796 --> 03:20:09.764
GO. IF FOR THE SHORT
03:20:09.831 --> 03:20:13.901
TERM HOPEFULLY. THE MORE BUT
03:20:13.968 --> 03:20:16.437
POWER SAFETY SHUT OFF SITUATION
03:20:16.504 --> 03:20:17.438
SO WHO IS THAT- THAT'S ONE TO
03:20:17.505 --> 03:20:19.340
IS IT YEAH WE NEED ARE WE AS A
03:20:19.407 --> 03:20:22.610
LEGISLATIVE BODY GONNA SUPPORT
03:20:22.677 --> 03:20:23.277
TO ONE PERSON THIS IS A- YOU'RE
03:20:23.344 --> 03:20:23.911
GOING TO PUT THIS GREAT INTO
03:20:23.978 --> 03:20:25.146
PLACE AND YOU'RE GONNA MAKE ALL
03:20:25.213 --> 03:20:25.747
THESE PEOPLE PLAY THAT'S WHAT
03:20:25.813 --> 03:20:26.781
I'M HEARING THE LEGISLATORS SAY
03:20:26.848 --> 03:20:28.683
IS LEGISLATORS ASKED TODAY IS
03:20:28.750 --> 03:20:30.651
WHAT PIECE OF LEGISLATION DO WE
03:20:30.718 --> 03:20:31.252
NEED TO RUN. THIS THAT MAKES
03:20:31.319 --> 03:20:33.221
THAT COORDINATION HAPPEN
03:20:33.287 --> 03:20:33.955
BECAUSE WHAT'S HAPPENING IS
03:20:34.021 --> 03:20:35.556
WE'RE RUNNING A LITTLE PIECES
03:20:35.623 --> 03:20:39.627
ME CENTER REQUIRE MY SEAT MATE
03:20:39.694 --> 03:20:41.229
HAS BEEN FRUSTRATED BY THE FACT
03:20:41.295 --> 03:20:44.766
AND HE'S TRYING TO K<c.cyan> ÁI.</c>
03:20:44.832 --> 03:20:45.366
AND I AM HERE. SENATOR JACKSON
03:20:45.433 --> 03:20:50.571
I HEAR. BERKELEY FOLKS I HERE.
03:20:50.638 --> 03:20:51.939
YEAH I HOLDEN SAY SO. AND WHAT
03:20:52.006 --> 03:20:52.540
IT USUALLY HAPPENS IS WE DON'T
03:20:52.607 --> 03:20:53.174
GET IT RIGHT. BECAUSE WE DON'T
03:20:53.241 --> 03:20:53.741
HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION WE
03:20:53.808 --> 03:20:54.308
DON'T GIVE THE POWER TO THE
03:20:54.375 --> 03:20:55.276
RIGHT PERSON IS GOING TO FIGURE
03:20:55.343 --> 03:20:56.511
OUT HOW TO DO IT SO I'M I'M
03:20:56.577 --> 03:20:59.180
HERE TO. SHARE WITH YOU. YOU'RE
03:20:59.247 --> 03:21:00.548
NOT GOING TO GET. WHAT YOU WANT
03:21:00.615 --> 03:21:02.216
AND NEITHER IS- YES AND NEITHER
03:21:02.283 --> 03:21:05.119
IS. THE P. YOU SEE INTEL WE
03:21:05.186 --> 03:21:06.421
FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT PIECE OF
03:21:06.487 --> 03:21:07.054
LEGISLATION SAYS AND GIVE SOME
03:21:07.121 --> 03:21:08.623
OF THE POWER TO SAY WE'RE GOING
03:21:08.689 --> 03:21:10.091
TO FIX THIS PROBLEM ONCE AND
03:21:10.158 --> 03:21:11.993
FOR ALL. THAT WE'RE GONNA HAVE
03:21:12.059 --> 03:21:13.194
A SYSTEM SET UP WE HAVE THE
03:21:13.261 --> 03:21:14.729
BACK CALL ON THE FRONT HOLE. IN
03:21:14.796 --> 03:21:16.631
THE SIDE HOLE AND THE GENERATOR
03:21:16.697 --> 03:21:18.533
WERE SUPPOSED TO BE. SO THAT
03:21:18.599 --> 03:21:20.101
WHEN WE HAVE AN OUTAGE THAT
03:21:20.168 --> 03:21:21.836
WE'RE DOING EVERYTHING WE CAN
03:21:21.903 --> 03:21:24.071
TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE- AND
03:21:24.138 --> 03:21:24.605
CENTER DOLLY. I'M I'M JUST
03:21:24.672 --> 03:21:29.210
GONNA. WHAT I HEARD TODAY. AND
03:21:29.277 --> 03:21:30.111
WHEN WHAT WE WENT THROUGH TODAY
03:21:30.178 --> 03:21:33.848
IS THAT- YOU SEE. IS ASKING US
03:21:33.915 --> 03:21:35.216
ABOUT THAT THE INDUSTRY'S
03:21:35.283 --> 03:21:36.784
ASKING A SIT DOWN. WITH THE P.
03:21:36.851 --> 03:21:37.618
YOU SEE THROUGH AN INFORMAL
03:21:37.685 --> 03:21:39.487
PROCESS P. YOU SEE IS SAYING
03:21:39.554 --> 03:21:40.488
WE'RE GOING TO TRY TO EXPEDITE.
03:21:40.555 --> 03:21:41.889
OUR PROCESS WE'RE GOING TO.
03:21:41.956 --> 03:21:44.125
CREATE A SYSTEM IN WHICH WE'RE
03:21:44.192 --> 03:21:45.960
GOING TO. ADDRESS THESE ISSUES.
03:21:46.027 --> 03:21:48.229
AND I FROM IF I CAN ANSWER YOUR
03:21:48.296 --> 03:21:49.764
QUESTION I THINK IT'S GOING TO
03:21:49.831 --> 03:21:51.666
BE THE LEGISLATURE AND THE P.
03:21:51.732 --> 03:21:53.935
YOU SEE AND IN THE- INDUSTRY.
03:21:54.001 --> 03:21:55.169
WORKING AT TEN OO YES WORK IN
03:21:55.236 --> 03:21:58.739
IT TOGETHER TO IDENTIFY. THE
03:21:58.806 --> 03:22:00.975
MOST PRESSING CONCERNS AND COME
03:22:01.042 --> 03:22:01.876
UP WITH SOLUTIONS TO A MAN AND
03:22:01.943 --> 03:22:04.078
THAT'S WHAT WE'RE- THAT'S WHAT
03:22:04.145 --> 03:22:06.113
THIS PROCESS IS ABOUT. AGAIN
03:22:06.180 --> 03:22:07.081
FIND THAT GOING DOWN THE STEPS
03:22:07.148 --> 03:22:10.017
IF WE NEED LEGISLATION. WORK ON
03:22:10.084 --> 03:22:10.551
IT WE'RE GONNA TRY TO SELL
03:22:10.618 --> 03:22:12.620
LEGISLATION WERE CARD PASS AT.
03:22:12.687 --> 03:22:13.754
TEN IF WE NEED THE P. YOU SEE
03:22:13.821 --> 03:22:14.889
TO ACT WE'RE GONNA COURAGE THEM
03:22:14.956 --> 03:22:17.024
TO ACT QUICKLY AND OF COURSE
03:22:17.091 --> 03:22:18.693
THE INDUSTRY IS MAKING PROMISES
03:22:18.759 --> 03:22:19.393
THAT THERE MEGA MAKE
03:22:19.460 --> 03:22:21.562
INVESTMENTS. INTO THEIR INTO
03:22:21.629 --> 03:22:24.632
UPGRADES. ARE WE'RE GONNA MOVE
03:22:24.699 --> 03:22:26.300
ON UNFORTUNATELY WE WILL START
03:22:26.367 --> 03:22:27.668
THIS CENTER STERN IF YOU CAN
03:22:27.735 --> 03:22:29.804
HAVE A- OF VERY BRIEF BECAUSE
03:22:29.871 --> 03:22:30.571
WE HAD WE STILL HAVE. WITH
03:22:30.638 --> 03:22:32.073
THEY'RE ASKING US TO LEAVE THE
03:22:32.139 --> 03:22:34.375
ROOM- BY ONE O'CLOCK SO WE'RE
03:22:34.442 --> 03:22:36.043
GONNA TRY TO- GET TO OUR NEXT
03:22:36.110 --> 03:22:38.513
PANEL WHICH IS. THIRTY MINUTES
03:22:38.579 --> 03:22:42.617
AND WE STILL. HAVE PUBLIC
03:22:42.683 --> 03:22:43.217
COMMENT WHICH WOULD BE LONG AS
03:22:43.284 --> 03:22:46.220
WELL SO. UNDERSTOOD AS CHAIRMAN
03:22:46.287 --> 03:22:49.323
I'LL TRY TO PUT IT PUT A FINE
03:22:49.390 --> 03:22:51.092
POINT ON- MY COLLEAGUES TO THE
03:22:51.158 --> 03:22:53.561
NORTH A CENTER DOLLY MCGUIRE-
03:22:53.628 --> 03:22:55.296
JUST TO GET A SENSE FOR THE
03:22:55.363 --> 03:22:57.965
PANEL HERE DO YOU ALL OF YOU
03:22:58.032 --> 03:22:59.800
THINK IT'S FEASIBLE TO PUT
03:22:59.867 --> 03:23:02.270
FORTH YOUR FIRST DRAFT OF A
03:23:02.336 --> 03:23:05.840
PLAN TO MAKE THESE AREAS
03:23:05.907 --> 03:23:07.842
RESILIENT LAYING OUT YOUR
03:23:07.909 --> 03:23:09.410
INVESTMENT TIMELINE YOUR
03:23:09.477 --> 03:23:12.179
PRIORITIZATION PLANS AND CAN
03:23:12.246 --> 03:23:13.381
YOU BRING SOMETHING LIKE THAT
03:23:13.447 --> 03:23:14.949
AFTER THIS HEARING PLEASED TO
03:23:15.016 --> 03:23:15.950
GET THE PROCESS STARTED
03:23:16.017 --> 03:23:18.119
LEGISLATURE. AND PUT THAT FORD
03:23:18.185 --> 03:23:19.186
AT JUST AT LEAST GET THE
03:23:19.253 --> 03:23:21.055
CONVERSATION ROLLING IS THAT
03:23:21.122 --> 03:23:22.590
SOUND LIKE SOMETHING IS
03:23:22.657 --> 03:23:24.158
FEASIBLE- AT LEAST THROUGH US
03:23:24.225 --> 03:23:25.026
WE KNOW THIS CAN BE PARALLEL
03:23:25.092 --> 03:23:26.360
PROCESSES BUT I JUST WANT TO
03:23:26.427 --> 03:23:27.428
GET A SENSE I KNOW THEY BOTH
03:23:27.495 --> 03:23:30.197
BROUGHT THAT UP BUT WHEN YOU
03:23:30.264 --> 03:23:30.831
GET SOME FEEDBACK FROM YOU ALL
03:23:30.898 --> 03:23:31.399
AND THAT'S ALL I HAVE MISTER
03:23:31.465 --> 03:23:31.966
CHAIR. I THINK IT'S FEASIBLE
03:23:32.033 --> 03:23:34.302
BUT I'D I'D LIKE IT TO BE NOT
03:23:34.368 --> 03:23:38.072
JUST OUR IDEA BUT OUR IDEA IN
03:23:38.139 --> 03:23:40.274
CONCERT WITH TALK AND- YES AND
03:23:40.341 --> 03:23:42.577
TALK INTO BECAUSE WE ALL KNEW
03:23:42.643 --> 03:23:44.645
EACH OTHER AND LET ME MAY THINK
03:23:44.712 --> 03:23:47.081
MAINTAIN MISS SOMETHING THAT-
03:23:47.148 --> 03:23:48.316
YES NEEDS AND SO I MEAN I
03:23:48.382 --> 03:23:49.650
REALLY THINK IT'S GOT TO BE A-
03:23:49.717 --> 03:23:51.385
YOU KNOW IT AND IT SOUNDS LIKE
03:23:51.452 --> 03:23:52.920
POLYANDROUS BUT IT HAS TO BE A
03:23:52.987 --> 03:23:57.024
COLLABORATION AND I WILL SAY.
03:23:57.091 --> 03:24:02.630
THIS IS NOT TO. BE CRITICAL.
03:24:02.697 --> 03:24:06.267
THIS EVENT AS AS- DIFFICULT AS
03:24:06.334 --> 03:24:07.868
IT HAS BEEN I THINK HAS PUSHED.
03:24:07.935 --> 03:24:09.403
ALL OF US. INTO A DIFFERENT
03:24:09.470 --> 03:24:10.404
PLACE I MEAN I'M HEARING OUT
03:24:10.471 --> 03:24:12.106
REACH FROM. FOLKS THAT I HADN'T
03:24:12.173 --> 03:24:13.507
HEARD OUT REACH BEFORE IN TERMS
03:24:13.574 --> 03:24:15.776
OF SITTING DOWN AND TALKING TO
03:24:15.843 --> 03:24:17.078
EACH OTHER SO WE'RE PREPARED TO
03:24:17.144 --> 03:24:18.679
CERTAINLY THE WIRELESS IS.
03:24:18.746 --> 03:24:21.749
PREPARED I THANK YOU VERY MUCH
03:24:21.816 --> 03:24:22.350
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA MOVE ON TO
03:24:22.416 --> 03:24:22.950
THE NEXT PANEL ANSWER FROM THE
03:24:23.017 --> 03:24:29.123
OTHER. ANOTHER ONE BUT WILL ASK
03:24:29.190 --> 03:24:35.096
MR AMANDA. THE ANSWER'S YES YES.
03:24:35.162 --> 03:24:38.065
ABSOLUTELY WORKING THROUGH YES
03:24:38.132 --> 03:24:40.034
YES THINKING OF PERFECT OKAY-
03:24:40.101 --> 03:24:41.369
WE'RE GONNA NOW HERE FROM THE
03:24:41.435 --> 03:24:43.471
IMPACTS TO THE CONSUMERS FROM
03:24:43.537 --> 03:24:45.573
VARIOUS OF REPRESENTATIVES FROM
03:24:45.640 --> 03:24:46.374
OUT OF THE CONSUMERS IN OUR
03:24:46.440 --> 03:24:48.175
STATE BEGINNING WITH ANNA MARIA
03:24:48.242 --> 03:24:50.411
JOHNSON SHE IS THE- WITH THE
03:24:50.478 --> 03:24:51.545
PUBLIC ADVOCATE'S OFFICE.
03:24:51.612 --> 03:24:53.514
REPRESENTING A COMMUNICATIONS
03:24:53.581 --> 03:24:56.751
WATER. I'M SORRY SHE'S A BRENT
03:24:56.817 --> 03:24:58.352
THE BRANCH PROGRAM MANAGER OF
03:24:58.419 --> 03:25:00.354
COMMUNICATIONS AND WATER POLICY
03:25:00.421 --> 03:25:02.056
THAN WE HAVE REGION ACOSTA THE
03:25:02.123 --> 03:25:04.158
TO THE DIRECTOR OF TELECOM PAUL
03:25:04.225 --> 03:25:04.759
POLICY WITH THE UTILITY REFORM
03:25:04.825 --> 03:25:07.928
NETWORK. AND WE SET HAVE STEVE
03:25:07.995 --> 03:25:10.364
MOVE. MY CAR GAR THE OWNER OF
03:25:10.431 --> 03:25:14.168
THE FARM TABLE IN PLACERVILLE.
03:25:14.235 --> 03:25:14.802
WELCOME AND THANK YOU VERY MUCH
03:25:14.869 --> 03:25:19.640
FOR BEING HERE. BEGIN WITH A
03:25:19.707 --> 03:25:24.612
MESS SANTA MARIA JOHNSON. PRESS
03:25:24.679 --> 03:25:27.581
BUTTON THERE THERE YOU GO.
03:25:27.648 --> 03:25:28.949
CHAIRMAN WESSEL AND MEMBERS OF
03:25:29.016 --> 03:25:31.352
THE COMMITTEE THANK YOU FOR
03:25:31.419 --> 03:25:31.886
INVITING ME HERE TODAY TO
03:25:31.952 --> 03:25:32.420
TESTIFY IN THIS IMPORTANT
03:25:32.486 --> 03:25:35.289
HEARING. MY NAME IS ANNA MARIA
03:25:35.356 --> 03:25:37.224
JOHNSON PROGRAM MANION PROGRAM
03:25:37.291 --> 03:25:37.925
MANAGER AT THE PUBLIC
03:25:37.992 --> 03:25:39.894
ADVOCATE'S OFFICE THE PUBLIC
03:25:39.960 --> 03:25:41.429
ADVOCATE'S OFFICE IS AN
03:25:41.495 --> 03:25:42.963
INDEPENDENT ORGANIZATION IN THE
03:25:43.030 --> 03:25:44.331
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITY
03:25:44.398 --> 03:25:46.200
COMMISSION THAT ADVOCATES ON
03:25:46.267 --> 03:25:48.703
BEHALF OF CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS.
03:25:48.769 --> 03:25:50.705
FOR SAFE AND RELIABLE SERVICE
03:25:50.771 --> 03:25:52.339
OF ENERGY WATER AND
03:25:52.406 --> 03:25:54.475
COMMUNICATION I'M HERE TO TALK
03:25:54.542 --> 03:25:58.379
TO YOU ABOUT COMMUNICATION. AS
03:25:58.446 --> 03:25:59.947
YOU HAVE HEARD THROUGHOUT THIS
03:26:00.014 --> 03:26:01.248
MORNING THE OCTOBER PUBLIC
03:26:01.315 --> 03:26:03.517
SAFETY POWER SHUT OFF.
03:26:03.584 --> 03:26:04.652
HIGHLIGHTED THE VULNERABILITY
03:26:04.719 --> 03:26:05.953
AND FAILURES OF THE
03:26:06.020 --> 03:26:09.056
COMMUNICATION NETWORK FOR BOTH
03:26:09.123 --> 03:26:11.092
WIRELESS AND WIRELINE SERVICE.
03:26:11.158 --> 03:26:13.661
IT'S SIMPLY A FACT WHEN POWER
03:26:13.728 --> 03:26:15.763
WENT DOWN A NUMBER OF CRITICAL
03:26:15.830 --> 03:26:16.931
INFRASTRUCTURE SUCH AS CELL
03:26:16.997 --> 03:26:19.033
SITES THAT TRANSMIT WIRELESS
03:26:19.100 --> 03:26:19.600
PHONE AND DATA SIGNALS WENT
03:26:19.667 --> 03:26:24.038
DOWN. WIRELINE NETWORKS WENT
03:26:24.105 --> 03:26:24.638
DOWN THE ROUTE TRAFFIC TO AND
03:26:24.705 --> 03:26:27.808
FROM CELL SITES. AND AS MORE
03:26:27.875 --> 03:26:29.643
COMMUNICATION COMPANIES ARE ARE
03:26:29.710 --> 03:26:31.679
MOVING TO VOICE OVER INTERNET
03:26:31.746 --> 03:26:34.315
PROTOCOL WHICH IS VOIGTS. DOES
03:26:34.381 --> 03:26:37.184
SERVICES ALSO WENT DOWN
03:26:37.251 --> 03:26:39.153
CUSTOMERS WERE OUT OF TOUCH
03:26:39.220 --> 03:26:40.821
BUSINESSES WERE OUT OF TOUCH
03:26:40.888 --> 03:26:42.990
FIRST RESPONDERS RUN OUT OF
03:26:43.057 --> 03:26:44.525
TOUCH WHEN THE SERVICES DIDN'T
03:26:44.592 --> 03:26:46.727
WORK THIS IS A MATTER OF PUBLIC
03:26:46.794 --> 03:26:49.330
HEALTH AND SAFETY. AND IT'S
03:26:49.396 --> 03:26:50.664
SOME IT'S CRITICAL THAT THESE
03:26:50.731 --> 03:26:52.466
SERVICES ARE WORKING SO THAT
03:26:52.533 --> 03:26:54.168
CONSUMERS CAN GET EMERGENCY
03:26:54.235 --> 03:26:57.071
EVACUATION ALERT. DIAL NINE ONE
03:26:57.138 --> 03:26:59.073
ONE. OBTAIN INFORMATION ON
03:26:59.140 --> 03:27:01.041
WHAT'S HAPPENING IN THE
03:27:01.108 --> 03:27:01.642
COMMUNITY AND COMMUNICATE WITH
03:27:01.709 --> 03:27:02.910
THE LOVE ONCE. WE MUST BE CLEAR
03:27:02.977 --> 03:27:07.314
HERE. CONSUMERS ARE DOING THEIR
03:27:07.381 --> 03:27:09.683
DUE DILIGENCE THEY ARE CHARGING
03:27:09.750 --> 03:27:11.919
THEIR PHONES SOME HAVE ALREADY
03:27:11.986 --> 03:27:14.088
BACKUP POWER AT THEIR HOMES FOR
03:27:14.155 --> 03:27:15.923
MODEMS FOR THOSE THAT HAVE
03:27:15.990 --> 03:27:18.526
VOICE OVER INTERNET PROTOCOL.
03:27:18.592 --> 03:27:19.794
CONSUMERS ARE PAYING THEIR
03:27:19.860 --> 03:27:22.062
BILLS. CONSUMERS PAY SURCHARGES
03:27:22.129 --> 03:27:27.401
ON THOSE BILLS. THE BURDEN IS
03:27:27.468 --> 03:27:29.503
ON THE COMMUNICATION PROVIDERS
03:27:29.570 --> 03:27:30.838
AND THE ACCOUNTABILITY AND
03:27:30.905 --> 03:27:33.107
RESPONSIBILITY IS ON THEM TO
03:27:33.174 --> 03:27:34.742
ENSURE THAT THE NETWORK IS
03:27:34.809 --> 03:27:37.812
WORKING WE CAN NO LONGER PUT
03:27:37.878 --> 03:27:39.146
CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS TO BIRD
03:27:39.213 --> 03:27:41.248
AND TO DO THINGS THAT IT'S THE
03:27:41.315 --> 03:27:43.117
COMMUNICATIONS JOB AND
03:27:43.184 --> 03:27:45.452
RESPONSIBILITY TO DO WHICH IS
03:27:45.519 --> 03:27:46.053
TO MAINTAIN THE COMMUNICATIONS
03:27:46.120 --> 03:27:50.758
NETWORK. AS SUCH WIRELESS
03:27:50.825 --> 03:27:53.561
WIRELINE CABLE COMPANIES MUST
03:27:53.627 --> 03:27:54.562
BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE TO ENSURES
03:27:54.628 --> 03:27:56.063
CUSTOMERS CAN USE THEIR
03:27:56.130 --> 03:27:59.033
WIRELESS AND WIRELINE SERVICE
03:27:59.099 --> 03:27:59.567
DURING EMERGENCY AND POWER
03:27:59.633 --> 03:28:02.670
OUTAGES. AND THEY MUST SHARE
03:28:02.736 --> 03:28:04.338
DETAIL ADDED INFORMATION WITH
03:28:04.405 --> 03:28:05.806
FIRST RESPONDERS SUCH AS CAL
03:28:05.873 --> 03:28:07.474
FIRE AND CALLOW YES BECAUSE
03:28:07.541 --> 03:28:09.777
THIS IS CRITICAL INFORMATION
03:28:09.844 --> 03:28:11.879
FOR FIRST RESPONDERS TO LOCATE
03:28:11.946 --> 03:28:12.413
AND CONTACT WILL THE BOOKS
03:28:12.479 --> 03:28:16.116
CUSTOMERS. NOW I'VE BEEN
03:28:16.183 --> 03:28:18.185
SITTING HERE HEARING THE PANEL
03:28:18.252 --> 03:28:20.688
COMMUNICATIONS ARE COMPANIES
03:28:20.754 --> 03:28:24.024
AND I CANNOT HELP BUT HIGHLIGHT
03:28:24.091 --> 03:28:25.893
TO YOU THAT THIS IS NOT
03:28:25.960 --> 03:28:26.493
UNPRECEDENTED AND THIS IS NOT
03:28:26.560 --> 03:28:29.597
NEW. POWER OUTAGES HAVE
03:28:29.663 --> 03:28:34.935
OCCURRED. DECADES AGO. JUST
03:28:35.002 --> 03:28:37.438
RECENTLY IN THE TWENTY
03:28:37.504 --> 03:28:39.106
SEVENTEEN STORMS IN JANUARY AND
03:28:39.173 --> 03:28:41.108
FEBRUARY THE TWENTY EIGHTEEN
03:28:41.175 --> 03:28:42.977
REPORT I WILL RE FROM THE
03:28:43.043 --> 03:28:44.778
REPORT FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS
03:28:44.845 --> 03:28:46.447
SAYING THAT MANY OF THOSE
03:28:46.513 --> 03:28:48.582
OUTAGES FROM THE STORMS COULD
03:28:48.649 --> 03:28:50.251
HAVE BEEN PREVENTED WITH BETTER
03:28:50.317 --> 03:28:52.620
AVAILABILITY OF BACKUP POWER
03:28:52.686 --> 03:28:54.455
FOR WIRELESS PROVIDERS AND
03:28:54.521 --> 03:28:57.057
IMPROVE RELIABILITY OF CABLE
03:28:57.124 --> 03:28:57.558
FACILITIES FOR WIRELINE
03:28:57.625 --> 03:29:01.962
PROVIDERS. THE PUBLIC SAFETY
03:29:02.029 --> 03:29:04.665
POWER SHOT US CANNOT BE USED AS
03:29:04.732 --> 03:29:05.966
AN EXCUSE TO HOLD
03:29:06.033 --> 03:29:07.268
COMMUNICATIONS PROVIDERS
03:29:07.334 --> 03:29:09.470
ACCOUNTABLE FOR MAINTAINING
03:29:09.536 --> 03:29:10.938
THEIR COMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS
03:29:11.005 --> 03:29:13.474
WORKING DURING A POWER OUTAGE.
03:29:13.540 --> 03:29:16.744
IT IS A MATTER OF PUBLIC SAFETY.
03:29:16.810 --> 03:29:18.779
YOU HAVE HAD OR HEARD YOU KNOW
03:29:18.846 --> 03:29:20.281
THAT MANY HEARINGS HAVE BEEN
03:29:20.347 --> 03:29:22.249
HELD FOR FIRST RESPONDERS CAL
03:29:22.316 --> 03:29:25.386
FIRE CALLOW YES HAVE STATED I
03:29:25.452 --> 03:29:28.522
EVEN AS EARLY AS- MAY OF LAST
03:29:28.589 --> 03:29:32.126
YEAR. THAT LACK OF BACKUP POWER
03:29:32.192 --> 03:29:34.061
IS ESSENTIAL FOR COMMUNICATIONS
03:29:34.128 --> 03:29:36.063
NETWORK IT WAS ALSO MENTIONED
03:29:36.130 --> 03:29:36.864
THAT THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE'S
03:29:36.931 --> 03:29:39.166
OFFICE FILE A MOTION FOR THE
03:29:39.233 --> 03:29:40.467
COMMISSION TO TAKE IMMEDIATE
03:29:40.534 --> 03:29:43.203
ACTION IN MAY TWENTY ONE OF
03:29:43.270 --> 03:29:45.072
TWENTY NINETEEN. AND ONE OF
03:29:45.139 --> 03:29:46.707
THOSE ITEMS WE ASK FOR
03:29:46.774 --> 03:29:48.075
IMMEDIATE ACTION TO REQUIRE
03:29:48.142 --> 03:29:49.843
BACKUP POWER A WIRELESS
03:29:49.910 --> 03:29:52.146
FACILITIES IN HIGH FIRE THREAT
03:29:52.212 --> 03:29:56.717
AREAS AND FLOODPLAINS. ACTION
03:29:56.784 --> 03:29:58.118
IS THE MEDIA N. AS DIRECTOR
03:29:58.185 --> 03:30:00.654
JOEL DO SHE- OF THE OFFICE OF
03:30:00.721 --> 03:30:02.389
EMERGENCY SERVICE STATED TO YOU
03:30:02.456 --> 03:30:04.992
TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE THIS IS
03:30:05.059 --> 03:30:07.161
A DIRE SITUATIONS WE ARE WE ARE
03:30:07.227 --> 03:30:10.698
IN. AND CONSUMERS CANNOT BE
03:30:10.764 --> 03:30:12.199
CONTINUE TO BE PUT IN PUBLIC
03:30:12.266 --> 03:30:13.968
HARM. THEY ARE IN HARM RIGHT
03:30:14.034 --> 03:30:16.070
NOW BECAUSE THIS COMMUNICATIONS
03:30:16.136 --> 03:30:19.006
NETWORKS ARE NOT RELIABLE. AS
03:30:19.073 --> 03:30:21.709
SUCH ARE ASKED IT'S CLEAR.
03:30:21.775 --> 03:30:23.010
THERE ARE PROCEDURAL VEHICLES
03:30:23.077 --> 03:30:24.345
AVAILABLE RIGHT NOW IN THE
03:30:24.411 --> 03:30:25.512
COMMISSION TO TAKE IMMEDIATE
03:30:25.579 --> 03:30:27.448
ACTION TO REQUIRE WIRELESS
03:30:27.514 --> 03:30:29.183
CARRIERS TO TAKE ALL MEANS
03:30:29.249 --> 03:30:30.651
NECESSARY TO KEEP WIRELESS
03:30:30.718 --> 03:30:33.087
SERVICE WORKING DURING A POWER
03:30:33.153 --> 03:30:33.721
OUTAGE. INCLUDING HAVING BACKUP
03:30:33.787 --> 03:30:37.725
POWER. DOES BACK UP POWER
03:30:37.791 --> 03:30:39.927
REQUIREMENTS CAN USE EXISTING
03:30:39.994 --> 03:30:41.762
WIRELINE REQUIREMENTS WHICH
03:30:41.829 --> 03:30:44.298
REQUIRE SEVENTY TWO HOURS IN
03:30:44.365 --> 03:30:47.001
CENTRAL OFFICES THE ROUTE NINE
03:30:47.067 --> 03:30:47.601
ONE ONE CALLS TO NINE ONE ONE
03:30:47.668 --> 03:30:52.539
CENTERS. SECOND COMMUNICATIONS
03:30:52.606 --> 03:30:54.108
PROVIDER MUST IMMEDIATELY
03:30:54.174 --> 03:30:55.809
PROVIDE REAL TIME DETAIL
03:30:55.876 --> 03:30:57.177
ADDRESS INFORMATION TO FIRST
03:30:57.244 --> 03:30:59.213
RESPONDERS SUCH AS CAL FIRE AND
03:30:59.279 --> 03:31:03.851
CALORIE AS- AND LASTLY. THE
03:31:03.917 --> 03:31:05.986
COMMISSION WAS ACTIVELY MONITOR
03:31:06.053 --> 03:31:07.988
AND IN FOR COMPLIANCE WITH ANY
03:31:08.055 --> 03:31:10.157
ORDER LEGISLATIVE ORDER
03:31:10.224 --> 03:31:12.793
COMMISSION ORDER ANY ORDER MUST
03:31:12.860 --> 03:31:14.995
BE MONITOR AND ENFORCE TO
03:31:15.062 --> 03:31:16.697
ENSURE COMMUNICATION PROVIDERS
03:31:16.764 --> 03:31:19.900
ARE MEETING THOSE REQUIREMENTS.
03:31:19.967 --> 03:31:21.802
AS I STATED WE CAN NO LONGER
03:31:21.869 --> 03:31:24.104
SHIFT THE BURDEN TO CONSUMERS
03:31:24.171 --> 03:31:26.473
CONSUMERS PAY THEIR BILL AND
03:31:26.540 --> 03:31:31.078
THOSE BILLS ARE NOT CHEAP. THEY
03:31:31.145 --> 03:31:32.846
EXPECT SERVICE TO WORK AND
03:31:32.913 --> 03:31:35.015
SERVICE MUST WORK ESPECIALLY
03:31:35.082 --> 03:31:37.851
DOING EMERGENCY SITUATION.
03:31:37.918 --> 03:31:40.421
PUBLIC SAFETY POWERSHOT UPS
03:31:40.487 --> 03:31:40.854
PROVIDE A NOTICE TO
03:31:40.921 --> 03:31:44.358
COMMUNICATION PROVIDERS. BUT
03:31:44.425 --> 03:31:46.927
THE ISSUE IS POWER OUTAGES HAVE
03:31:46.994 --> 03:31:49.096
BEEN KNOWN TO BE THE ROOT CAUSE
03:31:49.163 --> 03:31:51.365
OF MANY OUTAGES IN ACTION MUST
03:31:51.432 --> 03:31:53.500
BE TAKEN NOW TO RESOLVE THE
03:31:53.567 --> 03:31:56.670
IMMEDIATE PROBLEM. THE PUBLIC
03:31:56.737 --> 03:31:58.605
ADVOCATE'S OFFICE AND MYSELF
03:31:58.672 --> 03:32:00.641
WILL CONTINUE TO PARTNER WITH
03:32:00.707 --> 03:32:02.309
THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES
03:32:02.376 --> 03:32:04.711
COMMISSION AND THE
03:32:04.778 --> 03:32:07.714
COMMUNICATIONS PROVIDER TO FIND
03:32:07.781 --> 03:32:10.117
SOLUTIONS BUT WE ARE VERY CLEAR
03:32:10.184 --> 03:32:11.585
THAT THOSE SOLUTIONS MUST BE
03:32:11.652 --> 03:32:13.921
IMMEDIATE. AS ONGOING
03:32:13.987 --> 03:32:16.390
CONVERSATIONS ARE HAPPENING ON
03:32:16.457 --> 03:32:18.525
WHAT ELSE NEEDS TO TAKE PLACE
03:32:18.592 --> 03:32:20.661
HAVING REQUIREMENTS OF BACKUP
03:32:20.727 --> 03:32:23.530
POWER WILL GO A LONG WAY OF
03:32:23.597 --> 03:32:24.098
ENSURING THAT COMMUNICATION
03:32:24.164 --> 03:32:27.134
SERVICE WORKS. AND WE CAN NO
03:32:27.201 --> 03:32:30.704
LONGER RELY ON VOLUNTARY PLANS
03:32:30.771 --> 03:32:33.507
OR JUST PLANTING GENERAL'S THAT
03:32:33.574 --> 03:32:35.075
THE COMPANIES ARE SAYING WILL
03:32:35.142 --> 03:32:37.478
CARRY OUT. ANYMORE SOME ALSO
03:32:37.544 --> 03:32:39.746
NOTE THAT IT'S VERY UNFORTUNATE
03:32:39.813 --> 03:32:42.516
THAT CONSUMERS WERE PUT AT RISK
03:32:42.583 --> 03:32:43.851
FOR COMPANIES SUCH AS EIGHTEEN
03:32:43.917 --> 03:32:45.686
T. TO TAKE ACTION TO INVEST
03:32:45.752 --> 03:32:48.255
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS AND NOW SAY
03:32:48.322 --> 03:32:51.125
THEY WILL HAVE FIX. OUR BACKUP
03:32:51.191 --> 03:32:54.328
POWER IN HUNDREDS OF CELL SITES.
03:32:54.394 --> 03:32:55.195
THEY HAVE KNOWN THIS ISSUE FOR
03:32:55.262 --> 03:32:58.098
A VERY LONG TIME. AND THE FOCUS
03:32:58.165 --> 03:33:01.401
HERE IS IMMEDIATE ACTION AND
03:33:01.468 --> 03:33:04.404
ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE COMPANIES.
03:33:04.471 --> 03:33:06.206
THANK YOU AND I LOOK FORWARD TO
03:33:06.273 --> 03:33:07.508
YOUR QUESTIONS THANK YOU MS
03:33:07.574 --> 03:33:10.577
JOHNSON. MISS COSTA. THANK YOU
03:33:10.644 --> 03:33:11.612
AND THANK YOU FOR THE
03:33:11.678 --> 03:33:13.046
OPPORTUNITY TO APPEAR TODAY ON
03:33:13.113 --> 03:33:14.715
VIRGIN ACOSTA AND THE TELECOM
03:33:14.781 --> 03:33:16.517
POLICY DIRECTOR FOR TURN THE
03:33:16.583 --> 03:33:19.019
UTILITY REFORM NETWORK I WANT
03:33:19.086 --> 03:33:21.622
TO ADDRESS THREE GENERAL POINTS.
03:33:21.688 --> 03:33:23.090
INFORMATION FROM CUSTOMERS
03:33:23.157 --> 03:33:26.126
ABOUT TYPES OF OUTAGES. THAT WE
03:33:26.193 --> 03:33:27.761
WANT TO MAKE SURE DO NOT FLY
03:33:27.828 --> 03:33:29.263
UNDER THE RADAR SOME OF THESE
03:33:29.329 --> 03:33:32.132
RELATE TO POINTS THAT WERE.
03:33:32.199 --> 03:33:33.367
REST BY EARLIER SPEAKERS IN BY
03:33:33.433 --> 03:33:35.269
QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE POSED
03:33:35.335 --> 03:33:37.171
SECOND IS CONFIDENTIALITY OF
03:33:37.237 --> 03:33:38.505
INFORMATION REGARDING THESE
03:33:38.572 --> 03:33:41.141
OUTAGES AND THE THIRD AREA IS
03:33:41.208 --> 03:33:42.843
WHAT CAN STATE OFFICIALS DO. TO
03:33:42.910 --> 03:33:46.513
BEGIN. THERE ARE WIDESPREAD
03:33:46.580 --> 03:33:48.448
REPORTS OF WIRELESS AND VOIP
03:33:48.515 --> 03:33:49.783
OUTAGES BUT WHAT ELSE WAS
03:33:49.850 --> 03:33:50.851
MENTIONED EARLIER THERE WERE
03:33:50.918 --> 03:33:52.753
ALSO LANDLINE OUTAGES WE
03:33:52.819 --> 03:33:54.221
RECEIVED INFORMATION FROM
03:33:54.288 --> 03:33:56.924
CUSTOMERS INDICATING THAT
03:33:56.990 --> 03:33:58.625
SERVICE WAS LOST IN THE SANTA
03:33:58.692 --> 03:34:00.327
CRUZ MOUNTAINS DUE TO
03:34:00.394 --> 03:34:01.828
INADEQUATE BACKUP POWER FOR
03:34:01.895 --> 03:34:03.564
REMOTE TERMINALS REMOTE
03:34:03.630 --> 03:34:05.732
TERMINALS ARE BOXES THAT YOU
03:34:05.799 --> 03:34:07.801
WILL SEE THAT TAKE LONG
03:34:07.868 --> 03:34:09.336
TELECOMMUNICATIONS LINES ARE
03:34:09.403 --> 03:34:10.737
TYPICALLY LOCATED IN RURAL
03:34:10.804 --> 03:34:13.941
AREAS THEY COMBINE THAT TRAFFIC
03:34:14.007 --> 03:34:14.942
AND THEY SEND IT OFF TO THE
03:34:15.008 --> 03:34:16.677
TELEPHONE COMPANY SWITCH THEY
03:34:16.743 --> 03:34:20.280
RELY ON COMMERCIAL POWER IF THE
03:34:20.347 --> 03:34:20.881
POWER GOES OUT THERE NEEDS TO
03:34:20.948 --> 03:34:24.518
BE BACK UP. WE HAVE INFORMATION
03:34:24.585 --> 03:34:25.652
FROM A CUSTOMER THAT EIGHTEEN
03:34:25.719 --> 03:34:27.854
T. TERMINALS FILED. BASED ON
03:34:27.921 --> 03:34:29.056
PRESS REPORTS WE BELIEVE THE
03:34:29.122 --> 03:34:29.923
SAME THING OCCURRED IN
03:34:29.990 --> 03:34:31.858
MENDOCINO COUNTY AND FROM THE
03:34:31.925 --> 03:34:33.560
STATEMENT OF THE REPRESENTATIVE
03:34:33.627 --> 03:34:35.295
FROM MORAN EARLIER THIS MORNING
03:34:35.362 --> 03:34:37.631
IT IS A DISTINCT POSSIBILITY
03:34:37.698 --> 03:34:38.232
THAT SOME OF THESE LINES WERE
03:34:38.298 --> 03:34:40.634
SERVED BY A REMOTE TERMINALS-
03:34:40.701 --> 03:34:42.336
THE COMMISSION HAS THE
03:34:42.402 --> 03:34:43.971
AUTHORITY. TO REQUIRE THESE
03:34:44.037 --> 03:34:46.273
CARRIERS TO MAINTAIN THIS
03:34:46.340 --> 03:34:48.041
EQUIPMENT AND TO ENSURE THAT
03:34:48.108 --> 03:34:49.743
THERE IS ADEQUATE BACKUP POWER
03:34:49.810 --> 03:34:51.578
THIS IS PART AND PARCEL OF THE
03:34:51.645 --> 03:34:54.047
REGULATED COPPER NETWORK. AND
03:34:54.114 --> 03:34:55.182
WE BELIEVE THE COMMISSION
03:34:55.249 --> 03:34:58.719
SHOULD ACT PROMPTLY TO INST TO
03:34:58.785 --> 03:35:01.822
DO THIS TO ENFORCE IT TO MAKE
03:35:01.888 --> 03:35:03.690
SURE THAT. THERE IS AN HOUR AND
03:35:03.757 --> 03:35:05.525
WE ANTICIPATE THE NETWORK
03:35:05.592 --> 03:35:07.294
EXAMINATION TO SEE WHAT THEY
03:35:07.361 --> 03:35:09.830
HAVE TO SAY- THE SECOND THING
03:35:09.896 --> 03:35:12.633
IS THAT. WE DON'T HAVE THE DATA
03:35:12.699 --> 03:35:16.536
YOU DO. SO OUR QUESTION IS IF
03:35:16.603 --> 03:35:17.771
YOU IF YOU LOOK AT THE FCC
03:35:17.838 --> 03:35:19.640
REPORT IT'S JUST A GENERAL
03:35:19.706 --> 03:35:21.008
SUMMARY OF OKAY A HANDFUL LEASE
03:35:21.074 --> 03:35:22.309
LAND LINES ONE OUT HERE IN THE
03:35:22.376 --> 03:35:23.443
COMBINED EVERYTHING TOGETHER.
03:35:23.510 --> 03:35:25.579
WHAT WE'RE CURIOUS ABOUT IS WAS
03:35:25.646 --> 03:35:28.982
INFORMATION PROVIDED TO HELLO
03:35:29.049 --> 03:35:32.552
YES TO THE CPUC POSSIBLY TO YOU
03:35:32.619 --> 03:35:35.422
SAYING HERE'S WHAT ONE OUT IT
03:35:35.489 --> 03:35:38.592
WAS CAUSED BY THIS- THAT
03:35:38.659 --> 03:35:40.460
INFORMATION SHOULD NOT JUST BE
03:35:40.527 --> 03:35:41.528
SUBSUMED INTO THE GENERAL
03:35:41.595 --> 03:35:43.096
CATEGORY OF LANDLINE OUT IT IS
03:35:43.163 --> 03:35:46.033
IF YOU'RE GOING TO FIX
03:35:46.099 --> 03:35:46.500
PROBLEMS. YOU NEED TO
03:35:46.566 --> 03:35:49.202
UNDERSTAND WHAT HAPPENED. SO
03:35:49.269 --> 03:35:49.736
WE'RE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
03:35:49.803 --> 03:35:51.338
REPORTING OF THOSE ISSUES WE
03:35:51.405 --> 03:35:53.874
HAVE A REPORT FROM LAFAYETTE.
03:35:53.940 --> 03:35:56.209
ON ANOTHER ISSUE THAT WE DON'T
03:35:56.276 --> 03:35:58.945
SAKE HAS GOTTEN ANY ATTENTION.
03:35:59.012 --> 03:36:00.213
SHE IS A CUSTOMER OF A
03:36:00.280 --> 03:36:02.249
COMPETITOR. WHO LEASES
03:36:02.316 --> 03:36:04.851
FACILITIES FROM AT AND T. WHEN
03:36:04.918 --> 03:36:06.286
THE POWER WAS RESTORED HER
03:36:06.353 --> 03:36:08.822
SERVICE STILL DID NOT WORK SHE
03:36:08.889 --> 03:36:11.124
WAS TOLD BY. THE COMPANY THAT
03:36:11.191 --> 03:36:13.360
YOU GET SERVICE FROM WAS THAT
03:36:13.427 --> 03:36:15.495
AND I'M QUOTING FROM HER EMAIL
03:36:15.562 --> 03:36:17.297
TO ME- EIGHTEEN T. HAD A HUGE
03:36:17.364 --> 03:36:18.999
OUT ITS PROBLEM FOR HOME PHONE
03:36:19.066 --> 03:36:20.701
AND INTERNET SERVICE DUE TO
03:36:20.767 --> 03:36:21.768
PROBLEMS WITH THEIR BATTERY
03:36:21.835 --> 03:36:24.438
BACKUP SYSTEM. AND THEN THE
03:36:24.504 --> 03:36:26.406
CUSTOMER PROVIDED TO TURN- A
03:36:26.473 --> 03:36:29.142
NOTICE THAT WAS FROM THE CITY
03:36:29.209 --> 03:36:30.210
OF LAFAYETTE REFLECTING A
03:36:30.277 --> 03:36:33.547
CONVERSATION AT THE TT PROVIDED
03:36:33.613 --> 03:36:34.715
ON A LOCAL COMMUNITY WEBSITE
03:36:34.781 --> 03:36:36.049
AND HERE'S WHAT THEY SAID. IN
03:36:36.116 --> 03:36:38.251
CHECKING WITH MY NETWORK TEAM
03:36:38.318 --> 03:36:39.286
THEY INDICATED THAT ONCE PGA
03:36:39.353 --> 03:36:41.655
ANY POWER WAS RESTORED A PIECE
03:36:41.722 --> 03:36:42.789
OF EQUIPMENT IN A NUMBER OF OUR
03:36:42.856 --> 03:36:44.491
NEIGHBORHOOD CABINETS THAT
03:36:44.558 --> 03:36:45.525
PROVIDE INTERNET AND PHONE
03:36:45.592 --> 03:36:47.260
SERVICE WAS AFFECTED AND NEEDS
03:36:47.327 --> 03:36:48.929
TO BE REPLACED. THEY'RE HAVING
03:36:48.995 --> 03:36:50.597
TO LOCATE THE REPLACEMENT CARDS
03:36:50.664 --> 03:36:52.966
AND EXPECT TO HAVE SOME OF THEM
03:36:53.033 --> 03:36:54.434
REINSTALLED LATER TODAY AND THE
03:36:54.501 --> 03:36:55.235
SEATING. THE SHOULD BE
03:36:55.302 --> 03:36:57.971
VERIFIED. AND WE NEED TO KNOW
03:36:58.038 --> 03:36:58.905
IF THIS HAPPENED IN LAFAYETTE
03:36:58.972 --> 03:37:02.042
TODAY IN ANOTHER PLACE WHY DID
03:37:02.109 --> 03:37:04.478
IT HAPPEN- WHEN IT. WHAT THE
03:37:04.544 --> 03:37:06.613
SERVER REPORT TO AND ONE THAT
03:37:06.680 --> 03:37:09.082
THE SITUATION WAS. EXISTING AND
03:37:09.149 --> 03:37:13.353
IN REPORTS WAS INFORMATION
03:37:13.420 --> 03:37:14.688
PROVIDED ABOUT WHAT REALLY
03:37:14.755 --> 03:37:17.357
HAPPENED SO ONCE AGAIN. YOU
03:37:17.424 --> 03:37:19.559
THERE IT'S- YES THE CITY. YOU
03:37:19.626 --> 03:37:21.061
CAN GET TO THE BOTTOM OF THIS
03:37:21.128 --> 03:37:23.363
AND TRY TO FIX IT- SECOND THING
03:37:23.430 --> 03:37:25.065
IS FINALLY IS BACK CALL. THAT
03:37:25.132 --> 03:37:26.333
IS A HUGE THING AND WE'VE HEARD
03:37:26.400 --> 03:37:28.335
ABOUT THAT EARLIER TODAY I'LL
03:37:28.402 --> 03:37:29.870
JUST NOTE THAT DURING THE TECH
03:37:29.936 --> 03:37:31.071
FIRE ON OCTOBER TWENTY FIFTH
03:37:31.138 --> 03:37:32.339
DECEMBER MEDINA COUNTY
03:37:32.406 --> 03:37:33.607
SHERIFF'S OFFICE SENT THIS
03:37:33.673 --> 03:37:35.075
TWEET. WIRELESS CALLERS WITHIN
03:37:35.142 --> 03:37:36.510
THE HIGH DESERT AREA MAY NOT BE
03:37:36.576 --> 03:37:37.711
ABLE TO CONNECT ON NINE ONE ONE
03:37:37.778 --> 03:37:39.112
LINES SO PHONE CALLERS ARE
03:37:39.179 --> 03:37:41.181
EXPERIENCING A FAST BUSY SIGNAL
03:37:41.248 --> 03:37:42.916
OR DEAD AIR AND THEN THE LINE
03:37:42.983 --> 03:37:45.585
DISCONNECTS CARRIERS AFFECTED
03:37:45.652 --> 03:37:50.690
EIGHTEEN TT. MOBILE SPRINT
03:37:50.757 --> 03:37:56.963
METROPCS AND VERIZON NO. TO
03:37:57.030 --> 03:37:58.732
REPAIR AT THE TIME. THAT SOUNDS
03:37:58.799 --> 03:38:00.834
TO ME LIKE A TRANSPORT PROBLEM.
03:38:00.901 --> 03:38:01.835
MAYBE THE TECH FLYER MAYBE A
03:38:01.902 --> 03:38:04.571
BACKHOE WE DON'T KNOW BUT MY
03:38:04.638 --> 03:38:05.105
QUESTION IS SOMEBODY WHO'S
03:38:05.172 --> 03:38:06.807
FOLLOWING THIS FOR CONSUMERS.
03:38:06.873 --> 03:38:08.608
IS WASN'T REPORTED. HASN'T BEEN
03:38:08.675 --> 03:38:09.209
VERIFIED AND HAVE THEY GOTTEN
03:38:09.276 --> 03:38:10.444
TO THE BOTTOM OF IT. OKAY SO
03:38:10.510 --> 03:38:15.015
MOVING TO CONFIDENTIALITY. WE
03:38:15.081 --> 03:38:15.615
WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT THAT
03:38:15.682 --> 03:38:16.817
THE FCC IN OTHER JURISDICTIONS
03:38:16.883 --> 03:38:17.851
HAVE CONDUCTED IN DEPTH
03:38:17.918 --> 03:38:19.019
INVESTIGATIONS ABOUT MAJOR
03:38:19.085 --> 03:38:21.254
TELECOM OUTAGES AND ISSUE
03:38:21.321 --> 03:38:22.956
PUBLIC REPORTS THAT DESCRIBE IN
03:38:23.023 --> 03:38:24.591
DETAIL THE CIRCUMSTANCES
03:38:24.658 --> 03:38:26.993
IMPACTS AND EQUIPMENT FAILURES
03:38:27.060 --> 03:38:31.431
INVOLVED. TWO EXAMPLES ARE THE
03:38:31.498 --> 03:38:32.065
TWO THOUSAND TWELVE FAILURE OF
03:38:32.132 --> 03:38:34.267
VERIZON NINE ONE ONE FACILITIES
03:38:34.334 --> 03:38:36.136
THAT AFFECTED THREE POINT FIVE
03:38:36.203 --> 03:38:37.671
MILLION CUSTOMERS IN ARLINGTON
03:38:37.737 --> 03:38:39.372
VIRGINIA FOLLOWING THE
03:38:39.439 --> 03:38:40.807
DIRECTIONS STORM THIS WAS
03:38:40.874 --> 03:38:42.209
INVESTIGATED BOTH BY THE
03:38:42.275 --> 03:38:44.611
VIRGINIA STATE COMMISSION AND
03:38:44.678 --> 03:38:45.145
THE FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS
03:38:45.212 --> 03:38:50.317
COMMISSION. PUBLIC. THE NEXT
03:38:50.383 --> 03:38:51.651
THING IS WHAT CAN YOU DO NUMBER
03:38:51.718 --> 03:38:55.789
ONE DIVERSE ROUTING. THE POSTER
03:38:55.856 --> 03:38:56.623
CHILD FOR THE NEED FOR DIVERSE
03:38:56.690 --> 03:38:57.958
ROUTING I THINK IS MENDOCINO
03:38:58.024 --> 03:39:00.060
COUNTY BECAUSE WHEN THE FIBER
03:39:00.126 --> 03:39:02.395
WAS CAUGHT IN TWO THOUSAND
03:39:02.462 --> 03:39:04.197
FIFTEEN ALL SERVICE ANY KIND OF
03:39:04.264 --> 03:39:04.798
SERVICE WAS OUT. TO WATCH WHAT
03:39:04.865 --> 03:39:07.868
THE COUNTY. THE REDWOOD FIRE
03:39:07.934 --> 03:39:09.803
BURNED A FIBER OPTIC CABLE ALL
03:39:09.870 --> 03:39:12.772
SERVICE NORTH OF THAT DAMAGED.
03:39:12.839 --> 03:39:16.409
PART WAS OUT AT LEAST- HUMBLED
03:39:16.476 --> 03:39:17.777
I'M NOT SURE ABOUT DEL NORD BUT
03:39:17.844 --> 03:39:20.814
DEFINITELY HUMBOLDT. I'M. BUT
03:39:20.881 --> 03:39:22.449
TO COMPANIES DIDN'T LOSE
03:39:22.516 --> 03:39:24.217
SERVICE ONE OF THEM WAS
03:39:24.284 --> 03:39:25.986
SUDDENLINK AND THE OTHER ONE
03:39:26.052 --> 03:39:28.488
WAS ONE OH ONE THAT LINK WHICH
03:39:28.555 --> 03:39:29.022
IS A LOCAL HUMBOLDT COUNTY
03:39:29.089 --> 03:39:33.627
COMPANY. WHY BECAUSE THEY LEAST
03:39:33.693 --> 03:39:36.830
CAPACITY FROM ANOTHER COMPANY.
03:39:36.897 --> 03:39:38.999
ON THE LINE OWN BY PGD RUN BY
03:39:39.065 --> 03:39:40.233
ANOTHER TELECOM COMPANY IT WAS
03:39:40.300 --> 03:39:41.768
IN EAST WEST ROUTE IT WASN'T
03:39:41.835 --> 03:39:44.204
DAMAGED SO IF YOU'RE SITTING AT
03:39:44.271 --> 03:39:45.539
HOME ALL COUNTY YOU COULD BE
03:39:45.605 --> 03:39:46.473
FOLLOWING WHAT WAS GOING ON
03:39:46.540 --> 03:39:50.877
DOWN SOUTH. THE OTHER THING IS
03:39:50.944 --> 03:39:56.049
THAT ONE OH ONE NETLINK HAD.
03:39:56.116 --> 03:39:57.918
FIBER WRAP OR OR- MICROWAVE
03:39:57.984 --> 03:39:58.518
ROUTE MIKE WITH CLUBS RUNNING
03:39:58.585 --> 03:40:01.655
UP ONE ONE. THEY WILL NOT
03:40:01.721 --> 03:40:03.890
DAMAGED IN THE FIRE BUT THEY
03:40:03.957 --> 03:40:05.292
SAID THEY TOLD THE HUMBOLDT
03:40:05.358 --> 03:40:06.259
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
03:40:06.326 --> 03:40:07.394
THAT IF THEY HAD BEEN DAMAGE
03:40:07.460 --> 03:40:08.261
THEY STILL WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE
03:40:08.328 --> 03:40:10.163
TO PROVIDE SERVICE BECAUSE THEY
03:40:10.230 --> 03:40:11.932
HAD THAT EXTRA CAPACITY AT
03:40:11.998 --> 03:40:12.866
LEAST ON A SEPARATE LINE THAT
03:40:12.933 --> 03:40:14.668
WAS NOT AFFECTED. ROUTE
03:40:14.734 --> 03:40:17.203
DIVERSITY IS PART AND PARCEL OF
03:40:17.270 --> 03:40:19.606
A RELIABLE RESILIENT NETWORK
03:40:19.673 --> 03:40:20.473
PEOPLE AT LOCAL OFFICIALS HAVE
03:40:20.540 --> 03:40:21.641
BEEN CALLING FOR THIS FOR A
03:40:21.708 --> 03:40:23.476
LONG TIME WE BELIEVE THE
03:40:23.543 --> 03:40:24.778
COMMISSION HAS THE AUTHORITY TO
03:40:24.844 --> 03:40:26.947
ORDER THESE COMPANIES. TO
03:40:27.013 --> 03:40:28.481
UTILIZE SUFFICIENT DIVERSE
03:40:28.548 --> 03:40:32.152
ROUTING IT CAN SIGNIFICANTLY
03:40:32.218 --> 03:40:37.824
MITIGATE OUTAGES OKAY. LASTING
03:40:37.891 --> 03:40:38.425
WHAT YOU CAN DO A MINUTE OKAY
03:40:38.491 --> 03:40:43.496
ONE MINUTE. S. DIVERSE ROUTING
03:40:43.563 --> 03:40:44.664
ADDRESS BACKUP POWER UNDER
03:40:44.731 --> 03:40:47.200
MARIA DRESS THAT WHAT SEVEN TEN
03:40:47.267 --> 03:40:49.536
THE WHOLE IT'S SUNSET LET IT
03:40:49.603 --> 03:40:50.770
STAY THAT WAY WHAT THE D.
03:40:50.837 --> 03:40:52.872
COMPANIES CAN'T THROW THAT IN
03:40:52.939 --> 03:40:53.506
THE FACE OF THE COMMISSION WHEN
03:40:53.573 --> 03:40:54.040
THEY'RE TRYING TO ADDRESS
03:40:54.107 --> 03:40:58.612
ISSUES. FIVE THEY SAY WE'RE
03:40:58.678 --> 03:40:59.446
DOING THIS MAKE SURE THAT
03:40:59.512 --> 03:41:00.647
THEY'RE DOING IT IF THEY SAY
03:41:00.714 --> 03:41:01.181
WE'RE INVESTING MAKE SURE
03:41:01.247 --> 03:41:03.450
THEY'RE INVESTING AND LET THE
03:41:03.516 --> 03:41:05.418
COMMISSION HAVE THE EXPERTISE
03:41:05.485 --> 03:41:06.019
NECESSARY TO DO. THE FOLLOW AT
03:41:06.086 --> 03:41:09.189
G. GO AND LOOK AT WHAT THEY'RE
03:41:09.255 --> 03:41:10.790
DOING AND VERIFY. THANK YOU
03:41:10.857 --> 03:41:11.358
THANK YOU MISS COSTA MISTER
03:41:11.424 --> 03:41:14.260
MCCARTY. THANK YOU FOR LETTING
03:41:14.327 --> 03:41:17.697
ME SPEAK TODAY. MY NAME IS
03:41:17.764 --> 03:41:19.499
STEVE MCCARTY- ON THE OWNER OF
03:41:19.566 --> 03:41:19.966
THE RESTAURANT UP AND
03:41:20.033 --> 03:41:21.401
PLACERVILLE CALL PERFORM TABLE
03:41:21.468 --> 03:41:23.670
AND I WAS ASKED TO SPEAK TO
03:41:23.737 --> 03:41:25.672
DATE- AND NOT ABOUT. YOU KNOW
03:41:25.739 --> 03:41:27.107
WHAT THE PROBLEMS ARE WHAT THE
03:41:27.173 --> 03:41:28.942
PROBLEMS OF COME TO BE BUT BUT
03:41:29.009 --> 03:41:32.012
MORE ABOUT THE IMPACT OF THE
03:41:32.078 --> 03:41:33.847
LACK TELECOMMUNICATIONS HAS ON
03:41:33.913 --> 03:41:36.516
A OF LOCAL BUSINESS AND AMONG
03:41:36.583 --> 03:41:38.218
THE OTHER BUSINESSES THAT THAT
03:41:38.284 --> 03:41:39.853
I WORK AROUND IN THAT.
03:41:39.919 --> 03:41:42.856
PARTICULAR AREA. REALLY WHAT WE
03:41:42.922 --> 03:41:45.191
WANT TO DO IS JUST TALK ABOUT
03:41:45.258 --> 03:41:46.860
THE FACT THAT THE ECONOMIC
03:41:46.926 --> 03:41:50.630
IMPACT IS HUGE- WHEN YOU LOOK
03:41:50.697 --> 03:41:52.499
AT A COMPANY LIKE MINE. IS A
03:41:52.565 --> 03:41:54.601
RELATIVELY SMALL RESTAURANT-
03:41:54.668 --> 03:41:58.405
BUT WE HAVE- TWENTY EMPLOYEES
03:41:58.471 --> 03:42:00.907
AND THAT. WITH OR WITHOUT
03:42:00.974 --> 03:42:02.142
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICES
03:42:02.208 --> 03:42:03.109
WITHOUT WHEN THE POWER WENT
03:42:03.176 --> 03:42:05.879
OUT- IT OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE THE
03:42:05.945 --> 03:42:08.348
GENERAL ISSUES OF REFRIGERATION
03:42:08.415 --> 03:42:09.616
ELECTRICITY POWER THINGS LIKE
03:42:09.683 --> 03:42:11.785
THAT. WE WERE FORTUNATE IN THAT
03:42:11.851 --> 03:42:13.720
THE CITY HAD ARRANGED FOR AFTER
03:42:13.787 --> 03:42:16.056
THE FIRST- POWER OUTAGE- TO
03:42:16.122 --> 03:42:18.358
HAVE A GENERATOR. THAT PROVIDED
03:42:18.425 --> 03:42:20.026
SOME POWER TO THE LOCAL
03:42:20.093 --> 03:42:23.063
DOWNTOWN DISTRICT BUSINESSES.
03:42:23.129 --> 03:42:25.065
AND I WAS FORTUNATE TO BE ON
03:42:25.131 --> 03:42:25.732
HAPPEN TO BE ON ONE SIDE OF THE
03:42:25.799 --> 03:42:27.901
STREET THAT ALLOW THAT POWER.
03:42:27.967 --> 03:42:30.136
BUT WHAT REALLY IMPACTED US WAS
03:42:30.203 --> 03:42:32.672
THE LACK OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS-
03:42:32.739 --> 03:42:35.975
WE HAD A LOT OF CUSTOMERS
03:42:36.042 --> 03:42:38.845
CALLING TRYING TO FIND OUT ARE
03:42:38.912 --> 03:42:43.416
WE OPEN. WE HAD NO IDEA THEY
03:42:43.483 --> 03:42:44.117
WERE CALLING BECAUSE OUR FOR
03:42:44.184 --> 03:42:45.185
OUR PHONES WERE OUT. MORE
03:42:45.251 --> 03:42:46.252
IMPORTANTLY WHEN WE TAKE
03:42:46.319 --> 03:42:47.187
BUSINESS MOST BUSINESSES THAT
03:42:47.253 --> 03:42:48.855
I'VE TALKED TO IN THE STREET
03:42:48.922 --> 03:42:50.824
HAVE THE CAPABILITY OF STORING
03:42:50.890 --> 03:42:53.860
CREDIT CARD DATA IN THERE-
03:42:53.927 --> 03:42:57.130
POINT OF SALE SYSTEMS. BUT. YOU
03:42:57.197 --> 03:42:59.632
CAN'T YOU CAN'T GET PAID UNLESS
03:42:59.699 --> 03:43:01.101
YOU CAN TRANSMIT THAT DATA. TO
03:43:01.167 --> 03:43:03.803
THE MERCHANT- PROCESSORS AND SO
03:43:03.870 --> 03:43:05.772
YOU END UP HAVING FOR FIVE DAYS
03:43:05.839 --> 03:43:07.240
WORTH OF CREDIT CARD
03:43:07.307 --> 03:43:08.975
TRANSACTIONS SITTING IN YOUR
03:43:09.042 --> 03:43:11.745
REGISTER- UNABLE TO GET PAID.
03:43:11.811 --> 03:43:14.514
OBVIOUSLY THE- BILLS DON'T STOP
03:43:14.581 --> 03:43:15.548
AND WHEN YOU HAVE THAT
03:43:15.615 --> 03:43:18.218
CAPABILITY OF NOT HAVING THAT
03:43:18.284 --> 03:43:21.321
INCOME IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S A
03:43:21.387 --> 03:43:23.256
HUGE STRAIN ON ON MY BUSINESS
03:43:23.323 --> 03:43:24.724
SOME OF THE OTHER BUSINESSES
03:43:24.791 --> 03:43:25.725
THAT ARE IN THAT PARTICULAR
03:43:25.792 --> 03:43:28.261
AREA- SO IT WAS IT SOMETHING
03:43:28.328 --> 03:43:30.363
THAT WAS SOMETHING THAT. WE'D
03:43:30.430 --> 03:43:32.899
HAVE TO FIGURE OUT WHAT TO DO
03:43:32.966 --> 03:43:34.701
AND HAND HOW TO DO IT- IT'S
03:43:34.768 --> 03:43:35.602
JUST SOMETHING I WANNA MAKE
03:43:35.668 --> 03:43:36.669
SURE YOU GUYS ARE AWARE OF THAT
03:43:36.736 --> 03:43:38.204
THERE IS. AND I'M SURE YOU ARE
03:43:38.271 --> 03:43:40.106
THAT THERE IS A HUGE ECONOMIC
03:43:40.173 --> 03:43:41.574
IMPACT AND THESE ARE THE KIND
03:43:41.641 --> 03:43:42.909
OF THINGS THAT HAPPEN FOR FROM
03:43:42.976 --> 03:43:44.878
A BUSINESS STANDPOINT THAT A
03:43:44.944 --> 03:43:47.680
LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE.ALSO THE FACT THAT SOME
03:43:47.747 --> 03:43:50.750
EMPLOYEES HAVE. NO IN ABILITY
03:43:50.817 --> 03:43:51.351
THEY DON'T HAVE A CELL PHONE
03:43:51.417 --> 03:43:53.586
MAYBE- THEY CAN'T COMMUNICATE
03:43:53.653 --> 03:43:54.721
WITH THE RESTAURANT THEY DON'T
03:43:54.788 --> 03:43:55.688
KNOW IF WE'RE GONNA BE OPEN
03:43:55.755 --> 03:43:56.656
THEY DON'T KNOW WHETHER TO
03:43:56.723 --> 03:43:59.225
REPORT TO WORK- IF THEY REPORT
03:43:59.292 --> 03:44:00.860
TO WORK AND THEN- I MAY HAVE TO
03:44:00.927 --> 03:44:02.729
PAY THEM THE- TO BASICALLY DO
03:44:02.796 --> 03:44:06.699
NOTHING- IF I'M OPEN- CUSTOMERS
03:44:06.766 --> 03:44:08.902
ARE COMING AND THEY DON'T KNOW
03:44:08.968 --> 03:44:09.836
WE'RE OPEN. SO MY BUSINESS
03:44:09.903 --> 03:44:11.237
CLOSED DOWN SIGNIFICANTLY-
03:44:11.304 --> 03:44:12.806
BECAUSE OF THAT. SO ALL THESE
03:44:12.872 --> 03:44:14.574
THINGS ARE ARE REALLY IMPORTANT
03:44:14.641 --> 03:44:15.742
THINGS TO KNOW AND I CAN
03:44:15.809 --> 03:44:17.777
APPRECIATE THE HEADACHE THAT IT
03:44:17.844 --> 03:44:20.413
IS TO TRY TO FIGURE OUT HOW TO.
03:44:20.480 --> 03:44:22.015
GET A RUN AROUND ALL THESE
03:44:22.081 --> 03:44:24.951
PROBLEMS BUT- I ALSO WANT TO
03:44:25.018 --> 03:44:27.320
MAKE SURE THAT IT'S- IN
03:44:27.387 --> 03:44:29.022
EVERYBODY'S FOR FRONT THAT THAT
03:44:29.088 --> 03:44:30.089
THEY UNDERSTAND THAT THERE IS A
03:44:30.156 --> 03:44:32.592
HUGE ECONOMIC IMPACT ON
03:44:32.659 --> 03:44:35.328
BUSINESSES AND- HILL AND NEVER
03:44:35.395 --> 03:44:36.863
WANT TO DOWNPLAY THE SAFETY AND
03:44:36.930 --> 03:44:40.133
THE EMERGENCY MEDICAL AND HAND
03:44:40.200 --> 03:44:41.634
JUST BASIC COMMUNICATION NEEDS
03:44:41.701 --> 03:44:43.469
BUT- OTHERS ALSO THAT
03:44:43.536 --> 03:44:45.505
ADDITIONAL COST AND THE COST
03:44:45.572 --> 03:44:49.108
FOR TO US. IS FAR GREATER THAN
03:44:49.175 --> 03:44:53.379
JUST THE LOS. BIZ FOR THE DAY
03:44:53.446 --> 03:44:56.549
OR WEEK OR WHATEVER. BOB. IS
03:44:56.616 --> 03:44:57.383
SOMETHING THAT WE WANT TO MAKE
03:44:57.450 --> 03:44:58.952
SURE THAT EVERYBODY IS AWARE OF.
03:44:59.018 --> 03:45:01.955
I THINK THAT'S IT. YOU'RE ALL
03:45:02.021 --> 03:45:02.856
COMING IN HANGING IN FOR THE
03:45:02.922 --> 03:45:04.624
LAST PANEL REALLY APPRECIATED.
03:45:04.691 --> 03:45:05.625
ANY QUESTIONS FROM MY COLLEAGUE
03:45:05.692 --> 03:45:08.795
THAT NO I JUST WANT TO TAKE
03:45:08.862 --> 03:45:10.396
THIS OPPORTUNITY NO QUESTIONS
03:45:10.463 --> 03:45:11.497
BUT TO EVERYONE THAT THAT'S
03:45:11.564 --> 03:45:12.866
BEEN HERE THIS ENTIRE TIME AND
03:45:12.932 --> 03:45:14.767
OTHER PREVIOUS PANELISTS AND
03:45:14.834 --> 03:45:15.368
YOURSELF THANK YOU FOR COMING
03:45:15.435 --> 03:45:16.502
AND GOING AS REALLY APPRECIATED
03:45:16.569 --> 03:45:18.204
THANK YOU SENATOR RUBIO- THAT
03:45:18.271 --> 03:45:20.907
CONCLUDES THIS PANEL WE KNOW
03:45:20.974 --> 03:45:22.575
WILL. ACCEPT PUBLIC COMMENTS.
03:45:22.642 --> 03:45:27.914
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AGAIN.
03:45:27.981 --> 03:45:28.915
AFTER MAN MISTER TERRY BRIEFLY
03:45:28.982 --> 03:45:30.083
IGNACE YOUR HERNANDEZ A BEHALF
03:45:30.149 --> 03:45:31.517
THE COMMUNICATION WORKERS OF
03:45:31.584 --> 03:45:32.785
AMERICA DISTRICT NINE
03:45:32.852 --> 03:45:34.687
CALIFORNIA HAWAII NEVADA WITH
03:45:34.754 --> 03:45:36.456
OF COURSE THOUSANDS OF WORKERS
03:45:36.522 --> 03:45:38.224
HERE IN CALIFORNIA- PARTICULAR
03:45:38.291 --> 03:45:38.791
WITH EIGHTEEN TEAM AND OTHER
03:45:38.858 --> 03:45:42.295
COMPANIES. WE'RE HERE I WANT TO
03:45:42.362 --> 03:45:43.963
FIRST OF ALL THANK- ALL OF THE
03:45:44.030 --> 03:45:45.331
MEMBERS WERE HERE THROUGHOUT
03:45:45.398 --> 03:45:47.834
THE TESTIMONY- WE REALLY
03:45:47.901 --> 03:45:49.469
APPRECIATE THE FRANKNESS OF FOR
03:45:49.535 --> 03:45:50.770
A LOT OF THE DISCUSSION TODAY.
03:45:50.837 --> 03:45:52.372
AND THE WILLINGNESS TO- IT
03:45:52.438 --> 03:45:53.740
APPEARS ON BEHALF OF THE
03:45:53.806 --> 03:45:55.008
LEGISLATORS TO DO SOMETHING
03:45:55.074 --> 03:45:56.843
GOING FOR TO DO MORE WORK GOING
03:45:56.910 --> 03:45:58.544
FORWARD- AS ONE OF THE-
03:45:58.611 --> 03:46:00.947
WITNESSES. TESTIFIED THIS SOME
03:46:01.014 --> 03:46:02.548
OF THESE ISSUES ARE NOT NOW
03:46:02.615 --> 03:46:03.816
SOME OF THESE ISSUES WE HAVE
03:46:03.883 --> 03:46:05.051
BEEN FIGHTING AND DISCUSSING
03:46:05.118 --> 03:46:07.453
FOR NUMBER OF YEARS- SO WE DO
03:46:07.520 --> 03:46:09.188
LOOK FORWARD TO A VERY ROBUST
03:46:09.255 --> 03:46:11.024
AND AGGRESSIVE. APPROACH TO
03:46:11.090 --> 03:46:14.227
THESE ISSUES- CW A DOES LOOK
03:46:14.294 --> 03:46:15.361
FORWARD TO BEING AT THE TABLE
03:46:15.428 --> 03:46:16.930
BOTH IN THE FORMAL AND INFORMAL
03:46:16.996 --> 03:46:18.998
DISCUSSIONS. OR WORKERS ARE
03:46:19.065 --> 03:46:20.867
OFTEN THE ONES THAT HAVE THE
03:46:20.934 --> 03:46:22.802
DIRECT CONTACT WITH THE
03:46:22.869 --> 03:46:24.570
CUSTOMERS THE CONSUMERS AND WE
03:46:24.637 --> 03:46:25.805
FIND OUT WHAT'S GOING ON ON THE
03:46:25.872 --> 03:46:27.440
GROUND WE CAN PROVIDE THE REAL
03:46:27.507 --> 03:46:30.476
STORIES. WE CAN HEAR THAT IF
03:46:30.543 --> 03:46:31.611
YOU'RE HEARING ONE THING THAT
03:46:31.678 --> 03:46:32.545
THIS IS WHAT THE POLICY IS BUT
03:46:32.612 --> 03:46:33.780
WE'RE HEARING ON THE GROUND
03:46:33.846 --> 03:46:34.614
SOMETHING ELSE IS ACTUALLY
03:46:34.681 --> 03:46:36.616
HAPPENING OR NOT HAPPENING. WE
03:46:36.683 --> 03:46:38.718
HAVE ABOUT THE STORIES WE WILL
03:46:38.785 --> 03:46:39.585
CONTINUE TO PROVIDE THOSE
03:46:39.652 --> 03:46:43.156
STORIES. ONE FOUR WE LOOK FOR.
03:46:43.222 --> 03:46:43.756
LOOK FORWARD TO BEING PART OF
03:46:43.823 --> 03:46:47.827
ALL OF THOSE DISCUSS. THE LAST
03:46:47.894 --> 03:46:50.029
THING JUST WANT TO MENTION IS
03:46:50.096 --> 03:46:51.297
HIGHLIGHTED EARLIER THE SUNSET
03:46:51.364 --> 03:46:54.334
AT SEVEN TEN. SHOOT ME SECTION
03:46:54.400 --> 03:46:54.934
SEVEN TEN ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL
03:46:55.001 --> 03:46:55.601
IT REALLY OPENS UP THE WORLD TO
03:46:55.668 --> 03:46:56.135
DO A LOT MORE AND FOR THE
03:46:56.202 --> 03:46:57.136
COMMISSION TO DO A LOT MORE.
03:46:57.203 --> 03:46:57.937
AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO BEING
03:46:58.004 --> 03:46:59.639
PART OF THAT WE LOOK FORWARD TO
03:46:59.706 --> 03:47:00.807
THE CREST OF ACTION AND SWIFT
03:47:00.873 --> 03:47:03.876
ACTION- BUT THAT SUNSET NEEDS
03:47:03.943 --> 03:47:04.911
TO REMAIN OTHERWISE IT'S GOING
03:47:04.978 --> 03:47:06.813
TO REALLY REALLY HOLD BACK. ANY
03:47:06.879 --> 03:47:09.749
EFFORTS- THAT WE HAVE GOING
03:47:09.816 --> 03:47:10.583
FORWARD SO WITH THAT WANT TO
03:47:10.650 --> 03:47:12.318
THANK YOU AGAIN SEE W. A. IS
03:47:12.385 --> 03:47:14.187
POISED TO BE THERE TO WORK
03:47:14.253 --> 03:47:15.655
EVERY STEP OF THE WAY TO
03:47:15.722 --> 03:47:17.623
REALLY. FIND SOME REAL
03:47:17.690 --> 03:47:19.092
SOLUTIONS FOR CALIFORNIA THANK
03:47:19.158 --> 03:47:23.196
YOU. THANK YOU. GOOD AFTERNOON
03:47:23.262 --> 03:47:24.230
TRACY WRI WROTE COUNTY
03:47:24.297 --> 03:47:25.898
REPRESENTS OF CALIFORNIA I WILL
03:47:25.965 --> 03:47:28.634
BE VERY BRIEF- WE REPRESENT THE
03:47:28.701 --> 03:47:30.103
THIRTY SEVEN COUNTIES- THAT
03:47:30.169 --> 03:47:31.070
HISTORICALLY ARE
03:47:31.137 --> 03:47:33.606
DISPROPORTIONATELY. AFFECTED BY
03:47:33.673 --> 03:47:35.842
THESE TYPES OF OUTAGES AND THAT
03:47:35.908 --> 03:47:38.144
WAS EVEN BEFORE PS PS EVENTS-
03:47:38.211 --> 03:47:40.480
IN FACT. LAST YEAR IN FEBRUARY-
03:47:40.546 --> 03:47:41.881
BEAR VALLEY AREA WAS OUT OF
03:47:41.948 --> 03:47:44.550
PHONE AND INTERNET SERVICE FOR
03:47:44.617 --> 03:47:45.785
FIVE WEEKS. AND THAT WAS NOT A
03:47:45.852 --> 03:47:48.421
P. S. P. S. ABOUT- THESE AREAS
03:47:48.488 --> 03:47:51.190
ALSO ARE AREAS THAT SEE MORE
03:47:51.257 --> 03:47:52.925
DISASTERS AND HAVE MORE OF A
03:47:52.992 --> 03:47:53.826
NEED FOR A RELIABLE
03:47:53.893 --> 03:47:56.496
TELECOMMUNICATION. AND SO WE
03:47:56.562 --> 03:47:57.897
WANT TO CONTINUE TO HAVE THIS
03:47:57.964 --> 03:48:01.067
DISCUSSION- WE THINK THAT- THE
03:48:01.134 --> 03:48:03.603
P. YOU SEE IN THE N. O. YES IS
03:48:03.669 --> 03:48:05.371
IN A GOOD PLACE TO ASK FOR THE
03:48:05.438 --> 03:48:06.205
DATE I THINK WE NEED TO START
03:48:06.272 --> 03:48:07.006
WITH THE DATA. BEFORE CRAFT THE
03:48:07.073 --> 03:48:08.207
SOLUTION IT WE ARE SPUR OF
03:48:08.274 --> 03:48:09.108
THOSE EFFORTS AND ALSO THE
03:48:09.175 --> 03:48:10.576
DISCUSSION ABOUT BATTERY BACKUP
03:48:10.643 --> 03:48:14.680
THANK YOU. THANK YOU. ANYONE
03:48:14.747 --> 03:48:15.248
ELSE WISHING TO SPEAK UNDER
03:48:15.314 --> 03:48:17.884
PUBLIC COMMENTS. THAT CONCLUDES
03:48:17.950 --> 03:48:19.786
OUR COMMITTEE MEETING THANK YOU
03:48:19.852 --> 03:48:23.623
FOR ATTENDING AND. SURE IT AT
03:48:23.689 --> 03:48:24.724
THE CHURCH WHERE HER YOU HAVE
03:48:24.791 --> 03:48:26.626
SOME SAGE REMARKS BUT I DO NOT
03:48:26.692 --> 03:48:43.076
SO THANK YOU FOR COMING