THE MADAM SECRETARY FEET PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL PSEUDO SALAS
REFORM.
MITCHELL HERE NIELSEN ANDERSON
BELL.
GLAZER [inaudible]
JACKSON MCGUIRE.
MONNING MONTH MORE LOCK
[inaudible]
PAN.
PORTANTINO ROTH HERE SKINNER.
STERN HERE STONE.
MAJKOWSKI.
WILK PRESIDENT [inaudible]
YOU.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
WE NOTICED THE PRESENCE OF A
QUORUM TODAY WE'LL BE HEARING
THE LATEST BUDGET PACKED THE
LAST NOT LATEST THE LAST BUDGET
PACKAGE OF THE YEAR.
CONSISTED OF A CLEAN UP BUDGET
BILL AND TEN TRAILER BILLS.
ALL COLLEAGUES WE HAVE AN HOUR
BEFORE FLOOR SESSION BEGINS IF
WE DO NOT MAKE IT THROUGH ALL OF
THE BILLS WE WILL CONVENE AGAIN
IN ROOM ONE THIRTEEN UPON
ADJOURNMENT --
WITHOUT LET'S LOOKING DEPARTMENT
FINANCE AND START WITH OUR FIRST
BILL A BE.
EIGHTEEN TWENTY EIGHT GOOD
MORNING GOOD MORNING KARLA
CASTING OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
FINANCE FROM THE FIRST BILL
EIGHTEEN A. B..
EIGHTEEN TWENTY EIGHT MAKES A
NUMBER OF AMENDMENTS TO THE
BUDGET ACT OF AMONG THESE
CHANGES ARE.
EXTENSIONS OF INCUMBENTS
LIQUIDATION PERIODS.
A HANDFUL OF CORRECTIONS TO
FISCAL YEARS AND CODE REFERENCES.
AS WELL AS A FEW APPROPRIATIONS
REFLECTING --
RECENT FEDERAL GRANTS AND
CONTINUE BUDGET DISCUSSIONS.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH COLLEAGUES
IN THE QUESTIONS [inaudible]
THE BILL.
BUT SENATOR MORLOCK.
COULD YOU CLARIFY A WITH REGARD
TO THE DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR
VEHICLES WHAT --
ANY AMOUNT JUSTIFIED MEANS.
THE CLIP THAT ADDITIONAL PEOPLE
COMING TO THE TABLE.
I MARK ORDERED FROM THE FINANCE
ON THE AND WE UNDERSTAND THAT IN
PULLING TOGETHER AT THE THEIR
WORKLOAD ESTIMATES IT THERE WERE
SOME COMPONENTS THAT THAT.
DEPARTMENT DIDN'T DIDN'T
IDENTIFY AND WE DIDN'T.
I HAVE ENOUGH POSITIONS IN THEIR
AND IT'S YOUR QUESTION.
WERE STILL IDENTIFYING WHAT THAT --
CRACK STAFFING THAT WILL BE AND
HOW THAT'S GOING TO AFFECT WAIT
TIMES.
AND SO WILL WORK WITH THE
LEGISLATURE OBVIOUSLY TO ON AND
TO CLARIFY THAT SO THAT AS WE IF
WE CAN FORWARD WITH A REQUEST.
WILL IDENTIFIED AT THAT TIME.
INTO DEPARTMENT HEAD ASK YOU FOR
MORE POSITIONS WHEN YOU PREPARED
THE BUDGET.
THE BILL WE WORK WITH THE
DEPARTMENT TO WORK ON THE
WORKLOAD ESTIMATE AND WHAT WE
CAN AFFORD WITH WAS.
THE REQUEST.
SO WE'VE SORT OF BEEN MAKING A
JOKE AT THE DMV.
FOR DECADES --
TO MOVIES IT'S LIKE SO.
WHY I COME FROM COUNTY LEVEL AND
YOU GO TO THE SUPERVISOR AND SAY
YOU KNOW I'M UNDERSTAFFED WHAT
CAN YOU DO?
TO HELP ME --
BECAUSE CRISIS MANAGEMENT IS NOT
FUN WE JUST BEEN DEALING WITH
CRISIS AFTER CRISIS BUT IF.
IF SHE'S BEEN COMING TO YOU
SAYING IM UNDERSTAFFED.
WHY DID WE DEDICATE MORE FUNDS
TO THE DEPARTMENT MOTOR VEHICLES
IN THE BUDGET?
WE WORKED THROUGH --
I DETAILED WORKLOAD ANALYSIS
WITH THE DEPARTMENT.
AND AND IT WAS.
A GOOD WORKLOAD ANALYSIS IT
MISSED ONE MAJOR COMPONENT THAT
WE ARE NONE OF US REALLY PRICKLY
ANTICIPATED IN TERS OF HOW THE
DEPARTMENT HEAD AND UP.
A ROBUST PUBLIC OUTREACH
CAMPAIGN --
THROUGH FLIERS THROUGH --
MEDIA THROUGH THE INTERNET. TO
BE VERY CLEAR ON WHAT REAL ID
WAS AND WHAT WAS REQUIRED.
AND WHAT WE FOUND STILL AS THE
TECHNICIANS AT THE DESK ARE RUN.
SPENDING ON AVERAGE YOU KNOW
BETWEEN FOUR AND FIVE MINUTES
HAVING TO EXPLAIN TO CUSTOMERS.
WHAT RELATED YEARS?
AND SO THAT WAS BASICALLY THE
ONE BIG PIECE THAT WE MESSED AND
SO.
MOVING FORWARD WERE PUT INTO
THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO
ADDRESS.
I'VE BEEN INFORMED THAT MAYBE
ABOUT 5% OF THOSE THAT COME
INNER THEY'RE FOR REAL IDEAS AT
ACCURATE [inaudible]
I'M.
IN TERMS OF THE MOON. TO IN
TERMS OF THE PEOPLE THAT COME IN --
I'M NOT CERTAIN ABOUT THAT I
KNOW THAT WE HAVE OF UNSAFE.
ABOUT 30% OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE
APPLYING FOR A DRIVER'S LICENSES
OPT FOR RELATING--
BUTTON IN TERMS OF THE WORKLOAD.
WHICH SOUGHT TO EXPLAIN IT TO
EVERYBODY.
BUT I THINK THAT'S THE THING
THAT THINK THEY WEREN'T
ANTICIPATING IF A PERSON COMES
UP AND AND TO OF THE TECHNICIANS
YOU KNOW WE HAVE.
A THAT THE DMP HAS INFORMATION.
SHOULD BE TO BRING IN.
AND THE INDIVIDUAL SAYS WHAT'S
REALLY DE.
THE TECHNICIAN.
STILL EXPLAINS IT TO THEM IT
STILL TAKES THAT AMOUNT OF TIME.
WHICH THEN SNOWBALLS THROUGHOUT
THE DAY IF THAT HAPPENS
REPEATEDLY WHAT THANK YOU I'M
JUST TRYING TO STILL FIGURE OUT
HOW WE RUN THE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA AND IT SEEMS LIKE
IT'S THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT OF
FINANCE AND ALL WE DO IS MAYBE
THROW MONEY AT A SOLUTION.
YOU AT AN ISSUE.
AND AND SO I'M JUST KIND OF
TRYING TO READ HOW DO WE FIND
METRICS.
HOW DO WE FIND GOOD MANAGEMENT
OUT A WEEK?
HOW I WOULD HAVE HIM MEASURE THE
DMV UP CALIFORNIA TO THE FORTY
NINE OTHER STATES AND?
ARE WE THE MOST EFFICIENT WHERE
WE IN THE MIDDLE ARE WE AT THE
BOTTOM.
SIDE I JUST WOULD LIKE TO KNOW.
WHEN WE MANAGE?
GOOD HOW'RE DOING IT AND THEN
HOW DO WE DETERMINE WHAT TAKE TO
GIVE BECAUSE IN ANY AMOUNT
JUSTIFIED HIS LITTLE SCARY THAT
SOMEONE LIKE ME WHO HAS MORE OF
AN EXECUTIVE TYPE IN A
LEGISLATIVE TYPE SO.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR FOR A
QUESTION THANK YOU SENATOR US
SENATOR WHITE HOUSE KEY FOLLOWED
BY SENATOR MONEY YET MADAM I
CHAIRMAN THE DMB BUT YOU CAME
BEFORE SEPT --
TO EARLIER THIS SPRING THE FOCUS
OR TO REQUEST THAT THEY HAD WAS
FOR AN AUGMENTATION --
FOR CONSTRUCTION AND ASSISTANCE
DEALING WITH HOMELESSNESS THE
THE HOMELESS ARE A CRISIS THAT
WE'RE HAVING NOT ONLY IMPACTS
OUR CITIES BUT IT IMPACTS THE
DMV PROPERTIES BECAUSE THEY'RE
BREAKING AT NIGHT AND THEY WERE.
IN THERE IS A WHOLE CLEAN UP
THAT HAD TO GO THERE AND THERE
WAS SOME ADDITIONAL MONEY FOR
THE REAL ID BUT I DON'T THINK
THAT THEY EXPECT THAT THE THE
THE LUGE THAT THEY HAD SO I
THINK THAT.
THAT IS IN PART ANSWER YOUR
QUESTION IN FULL BUT THAT WAS
THE FOCUS WHEN THEY CAME IN
FURTHER THEIR MAJOR BUDGET
AUGMENTATION.
THANK YOU SIR MONEY.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR QUESTION
FOR DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE.
ARE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR RELY DE
ARE THOSE REQUIREMENTS OF THE
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
YES THEY'RE THINKING
[inaudible]
SENATOR STERN.
VENTURA QUESTION ANOTHER ITEM OF
WERE.
WE'RE DONE HERE QUESTION AB
THREE SEVENTY FIVE
IMPLEMENTATION ALREADY HIT OKAY
THANK YOU --
QUESTION ABOUT THE BOB BEGINNING
IMPLEMENTATION OF AB THREE SEVEN
FIVE IMPLEMENTATION FOR DOJ
THERE'S SEVEN HUNDRED THOUSAND
WONDERING ABOUT THE BASES HERE
[inaudible]
TIMING WISE [inaudible]
IS THIS.
THIS BASED ON A JANUARY FIRST
TWENTY NINETEEN IMPLEMENTATION
DATE JUST TRYING TO GET A SENSE
OF IT'S IS BEGINNING.
YES SO JOSH DUGGAR DEPARTMENT OF
FINANCE SO THE SEVEN HUNDRED
THOUSAND INCLUDED IN THE BUDGET
IS --
BASICALLY CURRENT YOUR WORKLOAD
IN EIGHTEEN NINETEEN PREPARING
FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF AB THREE
SEVENTY FIVE AND IT'S BASED ON
AN ESTIMATED COMPLETION DATE OF
THE REGULATIONS BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE BY.
A JUNE TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN I
THINK THE BILL REQUIRED THAT
REGULATIONS BE PROMULGATED
WITHIN ONE YEAR OF PASSAGE SO
THIS IS KIND OF THAT --
PRELIMINARY WORK TO GET THE
REGULATIONS COMPLETED ACCORDING
TO THE SCHEDULE AND THE OTHER
THE TIMELINE IN THE BILL.
WHO SHOULD SHOULD --
THAT FRAMEWORK CHANGE IN THE
LEGISLATURE WILL THAT AFFECT
YOUR WORKLOAD HAD YOU AND HIS.
ADDITIONAL MEASURES ADDED
THERE'S TALK ABOUT CLEAN UP --
HOW ARE YOU I MEAN HOW DOES THE
DEPARTMENT PLANNED TO SHIFT WITH
THAT -- I'M
NOT SURE I COULD SPEAK TO
POTENTIAL BUT IF TO EXACT
POTENTIAL CHANGES BUT I GUESS
PRESUMABLY IF --
THE TIMELINE TO COMPLETE
REGULATIONS WERE SIGNIFICANTLY
DIFFERENT --
THAT WOULD MAYBE NEED TO BE A
YOU KNOW A REVISITING OF THE
AMOUNT ESTIMATED IN THE BUDGET.
BUT THIS IS THE INITIAL AMOUNT
NOT THE ON GOING THIS IS THAT
CORRECT THIS IS FOR THE
DEVELOPMENT OF REGULATIONS THERE
WOULD LIKELY BE AN ON GOING
COMPONENT THAT IS YET TO BE
DETERMINED.
BASED ON THE ACTUAL --
REQUIREMENTS OF THE BILL AND
YEAH THEN ON ONGOING PEACE THIS
IS THAT ONE TIME KIND OF
PRELIMINARY WORK TO PREPARE THE
REGULATIONS.
THANK YOU VENTURE.
SENATE A GLACIER FOLLOWED BY
SENATOR STONE AND WILL
POLITICALLY.
ONITSHA GO BACK TO THE DMV ISSUE
TASK OF FOLLOWING OR YOU KNOW
WHATEVER IT SHOULD THE BILL'S
LINE [inaudible]
OKAY -- I
WAS WONDERING IF THERE COULD BE
THAT THIS SEEMS LIKE A AT AN
OPEN ENDED ALLOCATION AYE I
RECOGNIZE THAT THERE'S A
REPORTING REQUIREMENT
[inaudible] TO THE THE JOINT
BUDGET COMMITTEE --
BUT CAN WE GET A RANGE OF HOW
MUCH YOU THINK WE'RE TALKING
ABOUT HERE.
WELL AND IN A I THINK IF I WERE --
TO IF IF WE ARE TO ESTIMATE A
RANGE YOU KNOW IN SOME OF THE
EARLIER VERSIONS WE DISCUSSED
ANOTHER TWENTY SIX MILLION --
AND BUT THE DEPARTMENT OF
VEHICLES IS WORKING ON A NUMBER
OF UP THE STEPS OF STREAMLINING
RIGHT NOW AND THAT WAS YOU KNOW
WHAT A QUICK ESTIMATE I THINK
ONE OF ONE OF THE CONCERNS THAT
WE WE HAD FROM THE ORIGINAL --
REQUEST WAS SUBMITTED --
WAS THAT YOU KNOW THERE WERE AS
I MENTIONED EARLIER THERE WERE
SOME.
SOME QUIRK OF COMPONENTS WHICH
WORK CONSIDER.
WE WANNA MAKE SURE THAT WERE
CONSIDERING EVERYTHING AS WE
COME FORWARD AND AND I THINK
THERE HAS BEEN YOU KNOW MORE
INTEREST IN HAVING NOW A CLEARER
PICTURE OF WHERE NEW RESOURCES
WILL GO HEALTH WILL BE USED AND
HOW THEY WILL REDUCE WAIT TIMES
AND THIS PROVISIONAL LIKE WHICH
PROVIDES. FOR ALL OF THAT.
BUT IT DOESN'T HAVE A NUMBER IN
IT SO YOU'RE SAYING TWENTY SIX
MILLION IS YOU ASKED ABOUT.
I'M SAYING THAT WAS AND AN EARLY
ESTIMATE I REALLY DON'T KNOW.
WAS THERE AN UPPER AND A WHAT
YOU THINK THIS COULD BE IF ALL
THE BAD THINGS CONTINUE TO
HAPPEN THAT YOU SEE WHAT IS
HEARD.
AND UPPER AND HERE'S A HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS. TWO HUNDRED
MILLION DOLLARS I DON'T HAVE I
DON'T HAVE A THE ANYTHING
SPECIFIC LIKE THAT I KNOW THAT
WHEN.
WHEN AND IF WE COME FORWARD WITH
A REQUEST WE WILL WORK WITH THE
LEGISLATURE TO EXPLAIN IT WILL
EXPLAIN THE WORKLOAD HOW THIS IS
GOING TO REDUCE WAIT TIMES?
AND ALL OF THESE REQUIREMENTS
ARE IN THE LANGUAGE SO --
THIS PROVISION IN WHICH WOULD
ALLOW US TO DO ANYTHING WITHOUT.
WORKING IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THE
LEGISLATURE AND JUST TO REMIND
COLLEAGUES OF THE PROCESS THAT
WE WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY AS
BUDGET COMMITTEE WHEN THEY COME
BACK BOMB --
TO ASK --
MID APRIL FOR SUPPLEMENTAL
FUNDING WILL HELP THEY'LL BE
CLEAR ABOUT THAT THE FIGURE AND
WILL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
WEIGH IN ON THIS.
PRECISE FIGURE THEN RATE IN
TERMS OF THE NORMAL BUDGET
PROCESS THAT'S NOT OUT OF THE
NORM VERY GOOD AND HAD A FOLLOW
UP QUESTION TO THAT IS THAT.
YOUR YOUR MEASURING THIS AGAINST
CURRENT WAIT TIMES AT THE DMV SO
WHAT ARE THE CURRENT.
AVERAGE WAIT TIMES AT THE DMV
[inaudible]
NO.
I YOU KNOW I DON'T KNOW
CURRENTLY WHAT THEY ARE I KNOW
THEY'RE IN THE HOURS.
I I I I UNDERSTAND BUT A TIGHT
I'M TIGHT ABOUT IT SUBMITS IT TO
ME WE WERE IT WHAT'S THE BEFORE
THE REAL ID HAPPENS.
I'M GOING TO THE DMV LAST YEAR.
WHAT'S MY TYPICAL WAIT TIME. TO
SEE SOMEONE IT DMT.
THE YOU'RE GONNA HEAR WAYNE THIS
AGAINST SOME SORT OF AN AVERAGE
WHAT IT SHOULD BE A STANDARD
WHAT ETCHED PUTS A REASONABLE
AMOUNT OF WEIGHT SO WHAT WHAT
REALLY HAS THAT MUCH THE
STANDARD WAY TIME AT A DMV THAT
YOU'RE GONNA.
NOW TRY TO GET BACK TO WITH THIS
A SUPPLEMENTAL APPROPRIATION.
THE STANDARD WAIT TIME BEFORE
REALLY DE I BELIEVE WAS FIFTEEN
MINUTES FOR A AN INDIVIDUAL WITH
AN APPOINTMENT.
AND FORTY FIVE MINUTES FOR AN
INDIVIDUAL WITHOUT AN
APPOINTMENT SO IT'S YOUR HOPE
THAT THE SUPPLEMENTAL ALLOCATION
WILL COME BACK TO THAT.
WHAT WOULD BE CONSIDERED THE
TYPICAL WAY TIME A FIFTEEN WITH
AN APPOINTMENT AND FORTY FIVE
MINUTES WITHOUT?
I KNOW THAT WOULD BE THE
DEPARTMENT MOTOR VEHICLES
PREFERENCE THAT THAT'S WHAT
THEY'RE WORKING TOWARDS.
OKAY VERY GOOD THANK YOU.
I DON'T THINK YOU CAN THANK YOU --
MADAM CHAIR --
ME.
YOU KNOW THE MOST PROMINENT
INTERACTION PROBABLY THAT
CITIZENS HAVE THE STATE A
CALIFORNIA'S WITH THE DEPARTMENT
OF MOTOR VEHICLES.
AND SO YOU KNOW.
AT A MANY OF US LIKE WOULD LIKE
THE FACT THAT FIRST IMPRESSION
TO BE A GOOD IMPRESSION THAT
THEY'RE RECEIVING
OF THE BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE
POSSIBLE.
I KNOW IT SAID IN THE SACRAMENTO
BEE TODAY THAT THERE WERE SOME
MIGHTY ISSUES THAT --
MAY BE PARTLY RESPONSIBLE.
FOR SOME OF THE STRONG THE
LADIES AND THEN CERTAINLY --
WHAT THE REAL ID --
BUT WE'VE KNOWN ABOUT THE REAL
ID.
ISSUE SINCE TWO THOUSAND FIVE IS
NOT CORRECT THAT WE NEEDED TO BE
IMPLEMENTING A PROGRAM TO
ACHIEVE --
COMPLIANCE WITH AROUND TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN OF AN OCTOBER
CITY DOES NOT CRASH.
THE HE S. OF THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT DID PASS THROUGH THE
REAL ID ACT I BELIEVE IN --
TWO THOUSAND FIVE BUT IN TERMS
OF WHAT THAT LOOKED LIKE THE
REASON THAT THIS IS HAPPENING
NOW AND NOT IN TWO THOUSAND FIVE
IS THAT --
THERE ARE NUMBER OF SPECIFIC
ISSUES THAT NEEDED TO BE WORKED
OUT AND SO --
THE STATE CALIFORNIA'S BEEN
WORKING WITH THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT AND AND GOING BACK
AND FORTH AND AND IN TERMS OF
WELL WHAT.
WHAT REALLY QUALIFIES AS
COMPLIANCE IMAGES STATE OF
CALIFORNIA EVERY STATE HAS BEEN
DOING THIS?
AND SO THAT --
WE CAN SAY THAT THE FACT HOUSE
IN TWO THOUSAND FIVE BUT IN
TERMSOF WHAT THAT ACTUALLY LOOK
WHAT LOOKED LIKE WHAT THAT MEANT --
THAT HAS BEEN.
IT'S IT'S SOMETHING THAT.
I THINK WE ONLY GOT A GOOD GRASP
ON WHEN WE ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED
A OF FUNDINGREQUEST IN.
FOR SEVENTEEN EIGHTEEN AND SO WE
BOB CAN FORWARD WITH --
SET FIVE OR SIX YEAR PROPOSAL
FOR A TWO HUNDRED AND TWENTY ONE
MILLION DOLLARS AND BELIEVE IN
THE IN THE CURRENT YEAR THEY HAD
FIVE HUNDRED AND FIFTY POSITIONS.
UP TO ADDRESS IT BUT THAT WAS
THAT THIS KIND OF THE GENESIS OF
OR WEAKENED HOW WE GOT HERE IT
WASN'T LIKE THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT DID SOMETHING --
YOU KNOW THIRTEEN YEARS AGO AND
WE'RE JUST NOW.
DOING IT IT IT'S TAKEN THAT MUCH
TIME TO SORT OUT WHAT EXACTLY
THE DEPARTMENT THE STATE NEEDED
TO I CAN UNDERSTAND IT CAN TAKE --
SOMETIME BUT I ALSO KNOW THAT
THERE ARE OTHER STATES THAT ARE
HAVE ROLLED OUT THE REAL ID
PROGRAM.
FLAWLESSLY AND MUCH EARLIER THAN
STOOD A CALIFORNIA WHEN DID YOU
HAVE ALL THE PARAMETERS THAT
WERE NECESSARY TO ISSUE RELY DE
WHEN YOU FEEL CONFIDENT THAT YOU
KNEW WHAT YOU HAD TO DO.
NOT NECESSARILY HAVE THE IT --
BACKGROUND TO DO IT WHEN WHEN.
CONFIRM THAT YOU KNOW EXACTLY
WHAT THE MANDATE WAS THAT WE HAD
TO FULFILL.
ALONG GO.
INTO THOUSAND SIXTEEN SEVENTEEN
WHEN WE SUBMITTED A BUDGET
REQUEST FOR TWO THOUSAND
SEVENTEEN EIGHTEEN OKAY --
ONE OF THE CURRENT SINNERS THAT
I HAVE IS IT SAYS THIS PROVDES
IF ALREADY TO AUGMENT THE DMB
WITH ANY AMOUNTTESTIFIED TO
ADDRESS LINK THE WAIT TIMES OF
THE MP -- IT
MANY TIMES THAT THEY MY TWENTY
SIX YEARS OUR GOVERNMENT NIRVANA
FEELING HERE'S THROW MONEY AT A
PROBLEM THAT THE PROBLEM GOES
AWAY.
I ONE THING WE LEARNED DURING
THE CHI LACK --
REVIEW -- TO
AUDIT THE DMP WHICH I THINK WAS
A MISSED OPPORTUNITY.
WAS THAT THIS LEGISLATURE
AUGMENTED A BUDGET TO THE TUNE
OF SEVENTY MILLION DOLLARS TO
THE DIRECTOR.
AND THAT WAS TO OPEN ON
SATURDAYS. TO LEVY IT THE LINES
IN THE WEIGHTS DURING THE WEEK.
AND THE DIRECTOR INSTEAD TOOK
THAT MONEY.
AND CLOSED ON SATURDAYS AND PAID
OVERTIME [inaudible]
SO.
I THINK THAT IF WE'RE GOING TO
BE ALLOCATE IN THE KIND OF MONEY
THAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT.
THAT WE SHOULD HAVE AT LEAST
SOME KIND OF PERFORMANCE
STANDARDS.
BETTER REPORTING TO MAKE SURE
THAT.
THE DIRECTORS FOLLOWING.
HOW THE WILL OF THE LEGISLATURE
TO EXPEDITIOUSLY REDUCE?
I'LL WAIT TIMES GET THE DMB.
SO.
WHY DO I NOT SEE ANY KIND OF
PERFORMANCE STANDARDS INSTEAD OF
AN OPEN ENDED?
CHECKBOOK TO THE NB THAT HAS NOT
SHOWN A GOOD HISTORY.
INTENT WITH MONEY THAT IS BEEN
ALLOCATED TO THEM.
THE WELL AND I THINK THIS TO
PROVISIONAL LANGUAGE HERE
PROVIDES.
FOR THAT SORT OF THE SORT OF
REPORTING AND SO AS WE COME
FORWARD TO THE EXTENT WE COME
FORWARD WITH ADDITIONAL
BUDGETARY QUESTION AND I'M GONNA
FOR AUTHORITY.
FOR DIFFERENT ADDITIONAL
POSITIONS OR ANY OTHER MEASURES.
WE WOULD HAVE.
TO PROVIDE THAT INFORMATION.
OKAY LAST QUESTION.
DURING THE BUDGET CRISIS --
MANY AGENCIES TOOK SIGNIFICANT
HITS.
WE HAD A FORTY BILLION DOLLAR
HOLE THAT WE HAD TO FILL WE
UNDERSTAND THAT EVERYBODY HAD TO
DO MORE WITH LESS AND ALLOCATE
FUNDS.
IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT THE
DMP WAS ALSO.
A PART OF THAT.
SHARING THE BURDEN IF YOU WILL
TO THE TUNE OF EIGHTY EIGHT
MILLION A YEAR [inaudible]
AND THE GOVERNOR WENT TO THE
TAXPAYERS AND SAID YOU KNOW WHEN
HE GOT ELECTED I NEED YOU TO
PASS A HIGHER INCOME TAX SALES
TAX BECAUSE WE GOT TO GET
OURSELVES OUT OF THIS ECONOMIC
ABYSS.
IT'S GONNA BE TEMPORARY TAXES.
ANY TAXES THAT ARE GONNA BE
BROUGHT ABOUT ARE TO BE BROUGHT
BY THE PEOPLE.
SO THOSE TAXES BECAME PERMANENT
AS WE KNOW.
BUT NOT GOING TO THE TAXES
BECOME PERMANENT BUT THE THE
TAKE AWAY FROM THE DMV HAS
PERPETUATED EVEN WHEN WE HAVE
RECOVERED ECONOMICALLY IN THE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA WITH THE
HIGHEST REVENUE STREAMS OF EVER
HAD SINCE MY UNDERSTANDING THAT
WE'VE.
COLLECTIVELY TAKEN SIX HUNDRED
AND FIFTY MILLION DOLLARS FROM
THE DMV SENSE ECONOMIC ABYSS.
WHY ARE WE STILL TAKING EIGHTY
EIGHT MILLION DOLLARS AWAY FROM
THE D. M. B. AND IT ON THE OTHER
HAND WE GET THE?
MONEY BACK BECAUSE WE FEEL THEY
DON'T HAVE ENOUGH MONEY TO RUN
AN EFFICIENT OPERATION.
BUT THE THE PRIMER FUNDING
SOURCE FOR THE DMP IS OUR OUR
REGISTRATION FEES EN AND LICENSE
FEES -- SO
YOU'RE CORRECT THERE IS --
THERE ARE A CERTAIN NUMBER OF A
CAN OF FAT.
MEN REVENUES THAT THE DEPARTMENT
MONEY VEHICLES KLAX ARE FROM
LIKE THE SALE OF DOCUMENTS THEY
WORK WITH INSURANCE COMPANIES A
CERTAIN THINGS THAT ARE NOT PART
OF THEIR THEIR REGULAR REVENUE
SOURCE.
SO IN THE AND THE PAST THEY HAVE
THAT HAD ACCESS TO THAT AND THAT
WAS DURING THE THE CRISIS --
REDIRECTED ON AN ONGOING BASIS.
TO THE GENERAL FUND SO OBVIOUSLY
IF THAT WERE TO BE REDUCED THAT
WOULD BE.
ENOUGH AN AFFECTED INCREASE IN
GENERAL FUND.
EXPENDITURES ARE REDUCTION
AGENDA FUND BY REVENUE DOLLARS A
YEAR SO.
THE IT'S APPROPRIATE WHEN WE
HAVE THE HIGHEST REVENUE STREAMS
AND WE HAVE SOME OF THE HIGHEST
TAXES IN THE COUNTRY.
THE EIGHTY EIGHT MILLION DOLLARS
IS PAID TO THE DMV FOR A NEXUS
FOR DMV SERVICES.
SHOULD WE SAY.
WE'RE NOT GONNA TAKE THAT FROM
ME MORE.
DMB YOU KEEP THAT MONEY AND YOU
KNOW WHAT.
THIS PICTURE IT SYSTEMS LET'S
GET THE PROFESSIONALS AND SO WE
CAN DELIVER THE RELY DNA.
TIME SENSITIVE HUESO THE WE
DON'T HAVE PEOPLE IN MY DISTRICT.
WORKS A HUNDRED AND TWENTY
DEGREES OUTSIDE AND GOT SENIOR
CITIZENS FAINTING STANDING IN
LINE TRYING TO GET INSIDE TO GET
THEIR LICENSES RENEWED --
WE NEED TO I THINK BE FAIR TO
TAXPAYERS.
WE NEEDED TO ALLEVIATE THAT
RETURNED TO THE GENERAL FUND OF
EIGHTY EIGHT MILLION COMING FROM
THE DMP WE'RE GIVING ON THE ONE
HAND TAKING WITH ANOTHER AND I
HOPE THAT YOU'LL TAKE ARITHMETIC
A LOOK AT THAT AND SEE IF WE CAN
MITIGATE THAT.
APPRECIATE YOUR ANSWERS THANK
YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR JUST TO
FOLLOW UP ON SENATOR STONE'S
COMMENTS --
MOST PEOPLE GONNA WANT A REAL ID
CARD HAS ARGUED GONNA NEEDED TO
TRAVEL SO BASED UPON YOUR
PROJECTIONS WHAT PERCENTAGE OF
OURS OF OUR RESIDENTS
[inaudible]
CURRENTLY HAVE.
A REAL ID CARD AND WHAT'S THE ON
GOING POPULATION THAT WE NEED.
TO TO MEET THEIR NEEDS --
SO OF THE PEOPLE TO COME IN FOR
A DRIVER'S LICENSE --
SO FAR AND I'M.
THERE IS I THINK IT'S ABOUT 29% --
THAT HAVE BEEN REQUESTING.
ONE AND I THINK WE'VE ONLY DONE
ORIGINAL REQUEST WE ASSUME
SOMETHING A MORE ROBUST LIKE BUT
FORTY AM I THINK.
THE EFFORT TO TO THE EXTENT THAT
SOME PEOPLE COME IN AND THEY
DON'T THINK THEY REALIZE THEY
DON'T HAVE THE RIGHT PAPERWORK
AND IT'S EASIER JUST.
TO GET THEIR DRIVER'S LICENSE
NOW THAN IN A NON RELATED
COMPLAINT.
ONE THEN THEY THAT WE EXPECT
THAT THEY WILL COME IN FOR A
REAL EIGHTY ONE BEFORE THE
TWENTY TWENTY DEADLINE.
WELL WHAT'S THE DEPARTMENT DOING
IN TERMS OF COMMUNITY OUTREACH
TO INFORM PEOPLE OF THESE NEW
REQUIREMENTS.
SO THEY PUT ON A MILLER'S IN THE
CLINTON PEOPLE RECEIVE THERAPY
THEIR REGISTRATION RENEWALS THE
DRIVER'S LICENSE RENEWALS TO PUT
IN.
THE FLYERS THERE TO BE VERY
CLEAR ABOUT WHAT IT IS AND AND
AND WHAT THEY NEED TO DO.
A FEW GO TO THEIR WEBSITE COM
AND YOU KNOW WE'VE.
BUT WITH THIS AND TRY TO PLAY
WITH A NUMBER OF QUESTIONS A
NUMBER OF WAYS HAVE ALWAYS COMES
UP -- THE
HERE'S A REAL IDEAS AND HERE'S
WHAT YOU WOULD NEED TO TO BRING
BRING IT IS A TO DO IT IF YOU
SHOW UP AT A DEPARTMENT OR
VEHICLES OFFICE.
YOU'LL SEE POSTERS YOU'LL SEE
LOTS OF OTHER INSTRUCTIONS ARE
THINK THEY'VE DONE A YOU KNOW A
FAIRLY ROBUST --
A CAMPAIGN IN TERMS OF OUR REACH.
I'M MORE IN MAY WE SHOULD CHANGE
THE THE PARADIGM A LITTLE BIT
SINCE IT DOESN'T SEEM LIKE IT'S
WORKING.
I MEANS CERTAIN WHICH HAVE THE
TECHNOLOGY TO HAVE MAYBE KIOSKS
AT MALLS.
IT DOES GET HOT DOWN THE CENTER
STONE'S DISTRICT I'M AND RETELLS
DYING SURE I'M SURE MY ALSO LOVE
TO HAVE FUNDS TO KEEP ONLINE IN.
IN THEIR IN THEIR STORES I DON'T
KNOW I JUST.
I READ SOMEWHERE AND I CAN
REMEMBER THE SOURCE SO YOU KNOW
TAKE IT FOR WHAT IT'S WORTH LIKE
ONLY 5%.
HAVE ALREADY 5% PROJECTED
POPULATION THAT'S GOING TO GET
IT SO THIS IS GOING.
TO ACCELERATE GETTING WORSE NOT
NOT.
AND SO YOU KNOW.
GOOD LUCK IMPLEMENTING IT BUT I
I HAVE GRAVE CONCERNS WITHOUT
THE PROPER MATRIXES.
AND REALLY DOESN'T SEEM LIKE ANY
PLAN WE'RE GOING TO THE SAME OLD
THING THAT WE'VE CONTINUED TO DO
SO BUTTHANK YOU FOR YOUR
ANSWERS PAULA AND AND I WOULD
ALSO NOTE THAT IN TERMS OF THE
KIOSKS THAT YOU'RE SPEAKING OF I
MEAN.
WE DID A REQUEST A FEW YEARS AGO
AND SO THOSE ARE GOING OUT INTO
REAL ESTATE ASSEMBLY OR OR TURN --
ESTABLISHMENTS IN STORES WHEN
ONE NOT --
AND SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT
THEY'RE LOOKING INTO AND IN
TERMS OF RESPONSE TO THIS
THEY'RE CONTINUING TO LOOK AT
YOU KNOW EXPANDING THAT PROGRAM
BECAUSE ANYBODY ANY ANYWAY WE
CAN.
AT ANY OF THE TRANSACTIONS LIKE
REGISTRATIONS NORMAL
TRANSACTIONS THAT WE CAN GET OUT
OF THE DMP OFFICE --
HELP REDUCE THAT THEN THAT WAY
TIME.
SENATOR JACKSON'S.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH I THINK
REALLY THE ISSUE HERE --
IS NOT TALKING ABOUT CALIFORNIA
HAVING THE HIGHEST TAXES IN THE
COUNTRY WHICH IS NOT TRUE --
I THINK THE ISSUE IS THAT THE
PUBLIC FOR MANY PEOPLE THE THE
DMV IS THE FACE OF GOVERNMENT
FOR PEOPLE.
AND WE NEED TO PUT ON AN
EFFECTIVE FACE FOR THOSE PEOPLE
FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE IT'S THE
ONLY TIME THEY INTERACT WITH THE
STATE GOVERNMENT.
AND THAT'S THE ISSUE --
AND AYE I APPRECIATE SENATOR
WILL TALKING ABOUT.
TECHNOLOGY MAY BE HAVING KIOSKS
AND THAT'S A GREAT IDEA EXCEPT
IN THOSE QUESTIONS SECURITY AND
IT CAN ALL SORTS OF THINGS THAT
THAT NEED TO BE CONSIDERED SO I
WOULD SUGGEST THE GOOD OLD.
WAY.
OF HAVING ENOUGH PEOPLE WHO ARE
TRAINED EFFECTIVELY BECAUSE YOU
CAN GOING TO THE DMV AND TALK TO
SOMEONE WHO DOESN'T HAVE A CLUE
AS TO WHAT THEY'RE SUPPOSED TO
BE DOING.
AND THAT'S EQUALLY AS
FRUSTRATING SO I THINK THE
MESSAGE HERE IS NOT GOING INTO
ALL OF THIS MEANING ABOUT --
HOW WE OVER FINDER WHAT HAVE YOU
AYE IN ARGUABLY THE DMV'S FUNDED
BY THE VEHICLE LICENSE FEE AND
ALL THESE OTHER TAXES THAT SOME
OF OUR FRIENDS WHO ARE
COMPLAINING ABOUT THIS?
WANT TO REMOVE WHICH WILL GIVE
THEM EVEN LESS.
OF FEWER RESOURCES I THINK THE
ISSUE IS PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD
YOU NEED ENOUGH PEOPLE WHO ARE
TRAINED BECAUSE SOME OF THESE
REQUIREMENTS THAT --
SOONER MONNING POINTED OUT THIS
IS A FEDERAL REQUIREMENT AND I
SUSPECT THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
HASN'T GIVEN US ANY MONEY TO
IMPLEMENT THIS PROGRAM.
YOU NEED A PASSPORT YOU NEED AN
ORIGINAL BIRTH CERTIFICATE ANY
PROOF OF YOUR SOCIAL SECURITY
NUMBER THAT'S A LOT TO ASK
PEOPLE.
HOOK AND THE I MEAN I WOULD
SUSPECT MEMBERS IN THE DIS HERE.
DO YOU HAVE AN ORIGINAL BIRTH
CERTIFICATE I SUSPECT THAT THE
AND WHEN PEOPLE GO INTO THE DMV
TO HAVE THIS CONVERSATION
THEY'RE GOING TO GET FRUSTRATED.
SO I THINK THE KEY IS TO BETTER
TRAIN OUR PEOPLE MAKE SURE WE
HAVE ENOUGH OF THEM AND BE USER
FRIENDLY BECAUSE THE D. M. V. IS
IN MANY RESPECTS THE FACE.
OF GOVERNMENT IN CALIFORNIA AND
WE OWE THAT TO THE PEOPLE WHO DO
PAY THE TAXES WHO WANT TO BE
ABLE TO GO IN AND HAVE AN
EFFICIENT AND A PLEASANT ENOUGH
EXPERIENCE.
AND THAT'S REALLY IF THIS MONEY
IS GOING TO HELP WITH THAT THEN
LET'S DO IT AND LET'S DO IT
QUICKLY --
SO THAT WE DON'T END UP WITH
THIS EFFORT TO TO START ADDING
ON AND AND YOU KNOW GOING AFTER
GOVERNMENT CALIFORNIA WE STILL
ARE THE FIFTH LARGEST ECONOMY IN
THE WORLD.
AND WE'RE MORE THAN THE SIZE OF
MANY NATIONS SO IS IT PERFECT
HEAVENS NO BUT BUT LET'S FOCUS
ON THE ISSUE HERE.
AND LET'S MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
DOING WHAT WE'RE SUPPOSED TO BE
DOING FOR OUR CONSTITUENTS
[inaudible]
SENATOR NIELSEN.
RIGHT THIS SENATORIAL
[inaudible]
COMMENT. FOR OUR STAFF THE MOST
COMPLAINED ABOUT AGENCY THE DMV.
AND I CONCLUDED.
THE CONVERSATION WITH A DIRECTOR.
ABOUT TWO YEARS AGO [inaudible]
OBSERVING.
THE PEOPLE OF CALIFORNIA DESERVE
MORE.
NOW THE PROBLEM WE'RE WHY SHE
WE'RE HEADED WITH PROPOSALS
COMING FROM THE ADMINISTRATION
RIGHT NOW.
IS INDEED WE ARE SHADING MORE OF
THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY.
AND WE SHOULD BE THE OVERSIGHT.
BUT WE'RE GIVING MORE AUTHORITY.
TO THE AGENCY.
THE DASSAULT TROUBLE AND WE DARE
NOT DO THAT.
AND WE DARE NOT JUST GIVE THEM
MONEY.
ASSUMING THEY'LL BUY THEIR WAY
OUT OF IT EVERY AGENCY WHEN THEY
GET INTO TROUBLE.
WITH THINGS LIKE BACKLOG IN
RESPONSIVENESS TO THE
CONSTITUENTS SAY COME AND SAY WE
NEED MORE P. WISE WE NEED MORE
MONEY.
AND THE BLOOD JUST NATURE GIVES
A MORE MONEY.
AND THEY COME BACK THE NEXT YEAR.
STILL HAVE A BACKLOG STILL HAVE
PROBLEMS.
THIS IS A TIME OF RECKONING.
AND WE SHOULD START WITH THIS
AGENCY.
AND WE SHOULD NOT START BY
EMPOWERING THEM EVEN MORE.
COLLEAGUES WE'VE HAD THE FOR
SEVERAL YEARS NOW --
LENGTHY CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
METRICS AND HOW TO APPROPRIATELY
FUND GOVERNMENT WE HAVE A COUPLE
OF US STATE AGENCIES THAT ENGAGE
IN THE ZERO BASED BUDGETING
PROCESS AND SO I THINK IT'S AN
IMPORTANT CONVERSATION PROCEED
CONTINUE TO ENGAGE IN.
ON IN REAL TIME IN TERMS OF HOW
DO WE AS A LEGISLATIVE BODY I'M
AS THE BUDGET COMMITTEE CREATE
THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE SURE
THAT.
WE ARE APPROPRIATELY FUNDING
GOVERNMENT TO MEET THE NEEDS OF
THE RESIDENTS OF CALIFORNIA SO
THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTIONS AND
COMMENTS TODAY.
IT WILL BE A DISCUSSION THAT ONE
IN TODAY ON THE VOTE OF THIS
BILL BUT HOPEFULLY SOMETHING
THAT WE WILL COMMIT TO US THE
BUDGET COMMITTEE TO CONTINUE A
PROACTIVE BASIS COMING IN THE
NEW YEAR.
ARE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS ON OUR
FIRST BILL UP TODAY.
SEEN NONE OF PUBLIC COMMENT
[inaudible]
PUBLIC COMMENT.
THE FUN AB EIGHTEEN TWENTY A WE
HAD A MOTION BY SENATOR
WIECKOWSKI.
ALL I'M SORRY YES.
ANYWAY THAT'S WHAT THE KING
HONECKER'S COMPANY ON BEHALF OF
CAST THE COALITION TO ABOLISH
SLAVERY AND TRAFFICKING
ESPECIALLY SUPPORTIVE OF SECTION
FIVE PROVISION WHICH
REINSTATES FUNDING FOR SERVICES
FOR HUMAN TRAFFICKING VICTIMS
WHICH IS CUT EARLIER THIS YEAR
SO.
WE THINK THE COMMITTEE FOR THEIR
WORK ON THAT THANK YOU VERY MUCH
OF THE OF THE PURPOSE OF PUBLIC
COMMENT.
SEEING NONE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
A. B. EIGHTEEN TWENTY EIGHT THE
MOTION IS THE PAST MITCHELL.
I MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE MONEY
MONEY IN AYE MORLOCK
[inaudible]
PAN.
PORTANTINO ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE.
WIECKOWSKI QUICK BECAUSE THE AYE
WILK NO WILK NOW.
WILL HOLD THAT ITEM OPENLY
YOU'VE GOT A MEMBER TO THAT HAVE
IT MADE AND YET COLLEAGUES I'M
GONNA SUGGESTS IN LOOKING AT THE
CLOCK IN RECOGNIZING --
THAT WILL TURN INTO PUMPKINS AT
NINE THAT WE MOVE --
TO BIT AYE A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY
THE EDUCATION TRAILER BILL.
AB [inaudible]
EIGHTEEN FORTY EDUCATION.
AW AFTER THAT WE'LL GO BACK TO
THE REGULAR ORDER IF WE'RE ABLE
TO GET TO KNOW THE BILL BEFORE
WE TAKE A TEMPORARY RECESS
[inaudible]
GOOD MORNING.
WHICH IS TO ONE VOTE IN THE
FIRST BILL MY HELD UP A POINT.
OKAY.
GOOD MORNING AND THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS
ON JEFF BOTH PARTNER FINANCE --
FOR EDUCATION TRAILER BILL S. B.
EIGHT SEVEN FOUR DOES A NUMBER
OF THINGS --
THIS MEASURE APPROPRIATES A TWO
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS FOR THE
LOCAL CONTROL ACCOUNTABILITY
PLAN REDESIGN IT EXTENDS THE
IMPLEMENTATION DATE FOR SCHOOL
BUS TELL SAFETY.
ALERT SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS IT HAS
A NUMBER OF OTHER TECHNICAL
ADJUSTMENTS INCLUDING CHILDCARE
REIMBURSEMENT RATE ADJUSTMENT
FACTORS.
IT EXTENDS LIQUIDATION REPORTING
ERIOD FOR THE LOCALS US
SOLUTIONS GRANT PROGRAM FROM
THREE TO FIVE YEARS --
ANNEX DOES SOME ADJUSTMENTS
MAKES TECHNICAL --
REQUIREMENTS CHANGES FOR THE
EMERGENCY AVERAGE DAILY
ATTENDANCE PROVISIONS THAT ARE
CONTAINED IN STATUTES --
THERE ARE ALSO SOME COMMITTEE
AMENDMENT CENTER BEFORE YOU THIS
MORNING --
SEVERAL OF THEM.
INVOLVING THE COMMUNITY COLLEGES
FUNDING FORMULA OVERSIGHT
COMMITTEE HE WILL NOTICE THOSE
IN YOUR PACKETS.
AS WELL AS TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS
FOR THE CLASSIFIED SCHOOL
EMPLOYEES PROGRAMS.
AND TECHNICAL CORRECTIONS FOR
THE AFTER CODE PROGRAM --
LASTLY AND PERHAPS MOST --
DUH.
SIGNIFICANT SIZE IS THERE'S A
PROPOSAL BEFORE YOU FOR SCHOOL
DISTRICTS IN STATE RECEIVERSHIP.
IT HAS A A COUPLE KEY COMPONENTS
IN IT -- ONE
OF THOSE MAIN COMPONENTS
STRENGTHENS THE PROCESS SEES
THAT ARE UTILIZED WHEN SCHOOL
DISTRICTS FIND THEMSELVES IN
FISCAL DISTRESS YOU'LL FIND
SEVERAL COMPONENTS THAT THAT ARE
ASSOCIATED WITH THAT.
AND THERE ARE NONE MEASURES IN
PLACE TO ASSIST --
INGLEWOOD UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT AND OAKLAND UNIFIED
SCHOOL THE SICKEST PART OF THAT
PACKAGE.
I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS YOU MAY HAVE AS A
RESULT THOSE PEOPLE VERY MUCH
COLLEAGUES QUESTIONS.
SENATOR MORLOCK.
THANK YOU MADAM CHAIR I JUST
WITH REGARDS TO THE SCHOOL
DISTRICTS IN FISCAL DISTRESS.
WE HAVE ABOUT NINE HUNDRED AND
THIRTY SIX SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
THEY'RE MORE BUT A FEW COMBINED
THEIR COMPREHENSIVE ANNUAL
FINANCIAL REPORTS AND OAKLAND
HAS A UNRESTRICTED NET.
POSITION THAT'S A DEFICIT OF
FOUR HUNDRED TWENTY SEVEN
MILLION DOLLARS IT'S UNDER WATER
BY A HALF BILLION.
AND INGLEWOOD HASN'T EVEN.
SUBMITTED THEIR KAFFIR FOR THIS
YEAR YET.
OF THEIR A HUNDRED AND TWENTY
ONE MILLION.
UNRESTRICTED NET DEFICIT SO.
WITH NINE HUNDRED AND THIRTY SIX
SIDE DISTRICTS OAKLAND PLACES.
NINE THIRTY TO AT THE BOTTOM.
AND SO I'M WONDERING --
WITH THAT IN THE WOODS EIGHT
FORTY TWO I'M JUST I'M JUST
WONDERING WHAT WE DO FOR ALL THE
REST OF THEM.
HIS WRISTS WERE THIS IS TWO OUT
OF A THOUSAND NOW YOU GOTTA
WORRY ABOUT.
SURE -- AND
THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THAT UP
SENATOR ON THE WHAT WE'RE WHAT
WE'RE LOOKING AT IS.
A IMPROVING THE SYSTEM BY WHICH
WHEN DISTRICTS FIND THEMSELVES
IN FISCAL DISTRESS THE STATE
SYSTEM --
IMPROVES THE PROCESS HE'S --
FOR HELPING THOSE DISTRICTS WHEN
THEY FIND THEMSELVES IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES AND PERHAPS EVEN
ASSISTING THEM BEFORE THEY GET
TO THAT PLACE.
OTHERS MEASURES IN PLACE TO HELP
OF THE FISCAL CRISIS MANAGEMENT
SYSTEMS THEME --
HELP DISTRICTS ON IT YEAH
PERHAPS BEFORE THEY FIND
THEMSELVES IN THOSE
CIRCUMSTANCES BEEF UP THAT
PROCESS BY WHICH FIX BAD THAT'S
THE THE FISCAL CRISIS MANAGEMENT
ASSISTANCE TEAM HELP THEM --
ALONG THAT ROAD BEFORE THEY GET
TO THAT PLACE WE'RE WORKING ON
THAT COMPONENT IS WELL YOU'LL
SEE MEASURES IN THE IN THE
STATUTES THAT ARE PROPOSED
BEFORE YOU TO HELP THEM ALONG
THEIR AS WELL.
I SEE MICHAEL FINE IS RUNNING.
THAT IS DIRECTLY PICK MATTHEW
CELTIC MATT YES I I THINK WE'D
BE BETTER START PREPARING. TO
ALLOCATE MORE FUNDING TO THE
SCHOOLS GROUP WE HAVE A BUMP.
IN OUR ECONOMY IS NOT GONNA BE
PRETTY IN THERE READY FACING
HIGHER PENSION CONTRIBUTIONS SO
COLLEGE I JUST SAY WE'VE GOT.
SOMETHING ON THE HORIZON THAT WE
SHOULD BE PUTTING INTO OUR
THOUGHT PROCESS AS WE MOVE
FORWARD THANK YOU MANY THANK YOU
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS [inaudible]
SENATOR GLAZER.
WANT TO DO I'VE GOT TO ASK A
QUESTION ON THE STUDENT SUCCESS
FUNDING FORMULA OVERSIGHT
COMMITTEE.
AS I LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE FOR
HOW THIS COMMITTEE IS TO BE
ESTABLISHED.
PUBLIC APPOINTMENTS SAID THAT
SPEAKER THE GOVERNOR.
SOME FOLKS ARE CALLED OUT TO BE
INCLUDED WHICH I THINK IS VERY
VALUABLE AND IMPORTANT FACULTY
FACULTY MEMBER.
A CLASSIFIED --
EMPLOYEE.
BUT NOTHING NOTHING IS BAD IN IT
AS I CAN SEE.
CALLS OUT THE IMPORTANCE OF
HAVING ASTUDENT SERVE --
ON THIS COMMITTEE COULD YOU
ADDRESS WHY THAT.
THIS IS NOT NOT CALLED OUT AND
WHY WE SHOULDN'T ENSURE THAT.
STUDENTS WHO REPRESENTED ON THIS
IMPORTANT GROUP.
CERTAINLY I THINK WE CALLED OUT
THREE SPECIFIC MEMBERS UP ON THE
COMMITTEE --
EACH SHOW BRAND SHYAM THE SENATE
THE ASSEMBLY AND THE
ADMINISTRATION --
SELECTING ONE OF THOSE MEMBERS
WHAT I WOULD SAY IS NOTHING IN.
THE WAY THAT THIS IS CONSTRUCTED
WOULD PRECLUDE A STUDENT FROM
BEING SELECTED BY ONE OF THEY
THE EITHER THAT THE SENATE THE
ASSEMBLY OR THE ADMINISTRATION
TO SERVE ON THIS COMMITTEE.
I'M AND GIVEN THAT THE EDUCATION
CODE IS PERMISSIVE --
IT CERTAINLY IS AN OPTION FOR
MEMBER TO BE A STUDENT.
SO I GUESS BY ME BACK TO THAT IS
THAT I AGE I THINK IT'S NICE TO
SHOW RESPECT TO ADMINISTRATOR TO
A FACULTY TO THE CLASSIFIED
EMPLOYEE BUT WHY THAT.
THE CONSTITUENCY WHICH WE'LL
ALLEGE WERE TRYING TO HELP THE
MOST IS EXCLUDED DOESN'T REALLY
MAKE ANY SENSE TO ME.
SO OF MANAGER I DON'T KNOW WHAT
THE OPTIONS ARE TO US. TO
DESIGNATE THAT LEASE WITH ONE OF
THESE A IS THAT IT.
BE A STUDENT I THINK THAT WOULD
BE AN IMPORTANT THING TO DO.
A BIG A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FEET
OUT THE DIRECT CONVERSATION WITH
THE LEADERSHIP AND PERHAPS
THEY'LL TAKE THREATEN
CONSIDERATION WHEN THEY MAKE
THEIR POINT.
SENATOR JACKSON'S ASIDE LIKE TO
A AGREE WITH THE ALIGN MY
FEELINGS AND COMMENTS WITH US
SENATOR GLAZER IF WE ARE
POINTING OUT THESE OTHERS.
FREQUENTLY WE FORGET.
THAT WE ARE SERVING STUDENTS AND
THEIR VOICE IS.
AS IMPORTANT IF NOT MORE
IMPORTANT THAN SOME THE OTHER
PEOPLE THAT WERE CONSIDERING AND
I THINK IT'S SOMETHING THAT
GOING FORWARD WE SHOULD
ACKNOWLEDGE --
BY INCLUDING THAT INTO THE
STATUTORY FRAMEWORK IF WE DECIDE
NOT -- TO
THEN I'M HOPEFUL THAT THE
COMMITTEES OR DID THAT THIS
ASSEMBLY AND SENATE WILL DO THAT
BUT I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT A
GOING FORWARD TO RECOGNIZE
IMPORTANCE OF STUDENTS ON THESE --
ENTITY SO I I WILL.
THANK MY COLLEAGUE THANK YOU
SENATOR STERN.
A TO PILE ON HERE I'D I'D THIRD
THAT NOTION BUT ALSO JUST AND
COMMEND YOU IN THAT PROCESS OF
FOR THAT THAT APPOINTMENT
PROCESS THE OUT REACH IS REALLY
IMPORTANT ESPECIALLY TO ENGAGE
WITH THE STUDENT COMMUNITY.
TRIANGLE BOTTOM UP AND ACTUALLY
DOING A DECENT JOB OF LEADING
YOUNG PEOPLE KNOW THAT THERE IS
AN OPPORTUNITY ENGAGE IN
ACTUALLY MAKING THAT A A PROCESS
THAT MAYBE REACHES DISADVANTAGED
COMMUNITIES ARE KIDS WHO ARE
OFTEN ARE PRESENT IN THE SYSTEM
THAT WOULD JUST BE MIKE.
COMMENDATION TO YOU ALL THANK
YOU AND THANK YOU ANY FURTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
LET'S OPEN UP TO A PUBLIC
COMMENT.
GOOD MORNING JENNIFER BAKER WITH
THE CALIFORNIA TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION WE APPRECIATE ALL
THE WORK THAT'S BEEN DONE WERE
PARTICULARLY THANKFUL FOR THE
HELP AND SUPPORT THAT'S BEEN
PROVIDED FOR BALK INGLEWOOD IN
OAKLAND.
WE ARE NEUTRAL ON THE LANGUAGE
REGARDING SURPLUS PROPERTY COM
PROVIDED THAT THAT LANGUAGE IS
NOT FURTHER AMENDED.
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
THE MORNING SONG OR WHAT THE
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION --
WHERE HERE TO EXPRESS OUR
SUPPORT FOR THE FIVE MILLION
DOLLAR ALLOCATION INTO A
CLASSIFIED EMPLOYEES IN
COMMUNITY COLLEGES FOR
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT AS WELL
AS FOR THE?
EXTENSION OF THEIR RETROFITTING
DECLINE OF OUR A SCHOOL BUSES
AND WE ALSO WOULD LIKE TO THANK
THE COMMITTEE STAFF FOR ALL THE
WORK ON THESE TWO IMPORTANT
ISSUES THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
GOOD MORNING SEVEN EIGHT OUT OF
THE FACULTY ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY COLLEGES.
REGARDING THE PROPOSED OVERSIGHT
COMMITTEE FOR THE COMMUNITY
COLLEGES WE HAVE SUBMITTED A
LETTER WE ARE OFFICIALLY NEUTRON
THAT HOWEVER WE'D LIKE TO IT
OFFERED ASSISTANCE IN ANY WAY.
AND WE APPRECIATE ALL THE WORK
THAT THE LEGISLATURE IS
NONETHELESS.
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS BRIAN
REVIEWS SOME BEHALF OF THE
EDUCATION TRUST WEST WE'RE
ASKING THAT YOU AND ACT THE
PROVISIONS OF THE BILL RELATING
TO LCF HAVE FISCAL TRANSPARENCY.
AND WE THINK IT'S GOOD WORK BUT
WE ALSO ASK YOU TO KNOW MEMBERS
OF THE EQUITY COALITION DON'T
BELIEVE THIS COMPLETES THE TASK
THERE'S STILL MORE WORK TO BE
DONE.
AROUND --
TRANSPARENCY ON A SCHOOL SITE
SPENDING AND ALSO WE THINK SOME
MORE WORK NEEDS TO BE DONE
AROUND IDENTIFYING HOW MUCH THE
STATE IS SPENDING TO INCREASE OR
IMPROVE SERVICES. FOR A AND
DUPLICATED OR TARGETED STUDENTS
BUT OVERALL APPRECIATE THE WORK
ENCOURAGE THE ENACTMENT.
THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
A GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS --
CHECK PRINTER WITH THE CAMPAIGN
FOR COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY I'D LIKE
TO THANK SENATOR GLAZIER --
JACKSON AND STERN FOR REALLY
CALLING OUT THE NEED FOR STUDENT
VOICE IN THE OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE
FOR THE FUNDING FORMULA TO TRULY
MAKE THAT SUCCESSFUL IN DRIVING
STUDENT SUCCESS.
I'D ALSO LIKE TO ENCOURAGE THE
COMMITTEE AND SENATE RULES AS
YOU MAKE THOSE APPOINTMENTS TO
ENSURE THAT THE COMMITTEE IS
REFLECTIVE OF CALIFORNIA'S
DIVERSITY AS WELL AS INCLUSIVE
OF BOTH INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL
STAKEHOLDERS WHO CARE ABOUT.
THE COLLEGES IN OUR STUDENTS
THANK THANK YOU NEXT.
GOOD MORNING WHISKEY AND WITH
PUBLIC ADVOCATES.
OF I WANNA ECHO OBJECTS COMMENTS
ABOUT THE INCLUSION OF STUDENTS
ON THE OVERSIGHT COMMITTEE --
AS TO THE UP PROVISIONS
REGARDING THE LOCAL CONTROL
ACCOUNTABILITY PLAN THAT AL CAPP.
WE APPRECIATE THE WORK THAT'S
GOT INTO GONE INTO IT --
BUT WE URGE YOU NOT TO LET THE
VOTE ON THIS BILL BE THE END OF
THE WORK FOR FISCAL TRANSPARENCY
THERE'S WAY MORE TO BE DONE AND
THE QUESTIONS WE'VE BEEN ASKING
THAT IN AND YOU'VE BEEN ASKING.
FROM THE BEGINNING STILL ARE NOT
ANSWERED THANK THANK YOU.
THANK YOU BRAD STRONG SENIOR
DIRECTOR EDUCATION FOR CHILDREN
NOW LIKE DISSOCIATE BY OUR
COMMENTS AND WITH THE COMMENTS
OF EDUCATION TRUSTS WESSON
PUBLIC ADVOCATES.
I'M ALSO SIGNED ON TO EQUITY
COALITION LETTER OF OVER TWENTY
ORGANIZATIONS COME SIMILARLY
CONCERNED ABOUT THE FISCAL
TRANSPARENCY.
WE ARE SUPPORTIVE OF THE THE THE
PROGRESS MADE THAT SUMMARY
CHARTS THE INCREASED IMPROVE
SUMMARY --
CHARTS ARE A GOOD STEP FORWARD --
BUT WE DO BELIEVE THAT THE AND
TRANSPARENCY ON ACTUAL
EXPENDITURES --
IT'S ESSENTIAL AND THERE'S EVERY
FEW SEATS ACT AND FEDERAL --
REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE ACTUALLY
INTENDED TO ADDRESS WHAT USED TO
BE CALLED SUPPLEMENT NOT
SUPPLANT.
AND THIS IS NOW NOT ABOUT HOW
WHAT THOSE DOLLARS ARE
PURCHASING BUT BY HOW THE
ALLOCATION OF RESOURCES TO THE
SITES SO THAT THAT'S TRANSPARENT
LOOKED TO THE PUBLIC.
WE'D LIKE TO SEE THAT AND MAKE
SURE THAT THAT'S VERY VERY
TRANSPARENT THANK THANK YOU NEXT
WITNESS. TO SEE NOT THAT GOOD
WITH YOU WITH THAT VOICE I'VE
CONCURRENT PREVIOUS COMMENTS
ABOUT.
A POSITIVE STEPS BEING MADE ON
IT FISCAL TRANSPARENCY OUGHT NOT
AS FAR AS NEEDS TO GOVERN OUR
VIEW FOR PARENTS AND OTHERS
LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS TO BE.
PARTNERS WITH SCHOOL DISTRICTS
IN MAKING SURE THAT THE
RESOURCES TARGETED FOR THE MOST
DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS ACTUALLY
GETTING TO THE STUDENTS AT THE
SCHOOL SITE.
BUT IT'S IT IS A STEP IN THE
RIGHT DIRECTION.
A WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONSIDER
IF THERE'S ANY OPPORTUNITIES
THAT DOWN THE ROAD FOR
AMENDMENTS IN THIS RAINY RELATED
VEHICLES FOR A FORMAL
STAKEHOLDER GROUP TO REPORT BACK
TO THE LEGISLATURE.
CITY CAN EXERCISE ITS OVERSIGHT
ROLE IN A FORMAL WAY ON THE
TOPIC OF A TRANSPARENCY WITH
REGARD TO THE FISCAL DISTRESS
PROVISIONS THAT WERE MENTIONED.
BUT NO OBJECTION WITH --
THE RECOMMENDATIONS AND THE
LANGUAGE ON THE POINT OUT THAT
THE THE FISCAL DISTRESS UP
APPROACH FOR THE REMAINDER OF
THE STATE FOR ALL THE OTHER
DISTRICTS THAT WERE TALKED ABOUT.
IS A SIGNIFICANT POLICY CHANGE
FISCAL AND POLICY CHANGES HASN'T
BEEN CONSIDERED IN THE
LEGISLATURE IN ANY FORMAT IN
BUDGET OR POLICY COMMITTEE AND
WOULD POINT OUT THERE.
AT ONE LEVEL THE LANGUAGE
CERTAINLY IS HIGHLIGHTING THE
DERELICTION OF THE LAST EIGHT
YEARS OF THIS CURRENT
SUPERINTENDENT IF THE FORTIES
BEING TAKEN AWAY.
ON BUT ALSO FROM THE STANDPOINT
OF STRUCTURE THERE'S NO QUESTION
FROM AN INTERNAL CONTROL PROCESS
THAT THE COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT.
IS IN FACT AN APPROVING
AUTHORITY FOR STATE THAT THE
LOCAL BUDGETS THE ALWAYS BUDGETS
SOON THE COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT
IN FACT WAS COMPLICITOUS IN A
FOUR HUNDRED MILLION DOLLAR HOLE.
IN OAKLAND AND LIKEWISE IN
INGLEWOOD INSERTED TURNAROUND IN
ASK THAT PERSON TO SUPERVISE IN
THE FUTURE THE PERSON THAT'S
GOING TO HELP CLEAN UP BEGS THE
QUESTION OF WHO'S IN CHARGE.
AND DO THEY REALLY HAVE THE
COMPETENCY AND THE COURAGE TO
MAKE THE TOUGH DECISIONS THANK
YOU THANK YOU NEXT WITNESS.
MEMBERS MICHAEL HOLE SIZE HERE
ON BEHALF OF THE KERN COUNTY A
SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS OFFICE
I JUST WANT TO UNDERSCORE MISTER
BILLS RESPONSE TO SENATOR MORE
LOCKS.
QUESTION WE BELIEVE THE LANGUAGE
IN THE BILL --
REALLY MORE TIGHTLY ALIGNS THE
AUTHORITY OF COUNTY
SUPERINTENDENTS WITH THEIR
ALREADY EXISTING RESPONSIBILITY
WE STRONGLY SUPPORT THIS
LANGUAGE.
WE ALSO WOULD UP POINT OUT THAT
TERRIFIC MATT HAS BEEN VERY
INVOLVED IN IN THE DEVELOPMENT
OF THE LANGUAGE.
AND WE'RE VERY COMFORTABLE WITH
THE INCREASED RESPONSIBILITY
THAT'S BEING GIVEN THE FACT MATT
TO SUPPORT THE COUNTY
SUPERINTENDENTS.
AND REALLY TO BE MORE PROACTIVE
WITH SCHOOL DISTRICTS THAT ARE
IN DISTRESS WE THINK THIS IS A
POSITIVE STEP FORWARD.
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
GOOD MORNING MADAM CHAIR AND
MEMBERS PAMELA GIVES
REPRESENTING THE LOS ANGELES
COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION.
WACO HAS BEEN SUPPORTIVE OF
EFFORTS THIS YEAR AND
LEGISLATION TO ADDRESS THE NEEDS
OF OAKLAND UNIFIED SCHOOL
DISTRICT AND INGLEWOOD UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT REGARDING THE
SURPLUS PROPERTY.
WE ALSO CONTINUE TO WORK VERY
CLOSELY WITH THE LEGISLATORS AND
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE TO JUSTICE
ISSUE GOING FORWARD AND SO FOR
THAT.
A WE SUPPORT A. B. EIGHTEEN
FORTY MOVING FORWARD SO THAT WE
CAN ADDRESS ANY TECHNICAL ISSUES
THANK YOU.
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS JEFF BACA
REPRESENTING THE RIVERSIDE
COUNTY SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS.
ABOUT EXPRESSING SUPPORT FOR THE
PROVISIONS IN THE BILL REGARDING
THE CHANGES AND THE PROCESS FOR
THE SELECTION OF THE STATE
ADMINISTRATOR.
OF DISTRICTS IN FINANCIAL
DISTRESS WE DO BELIEVE THAT THE
COUNTY SEAT TENANTS SHOULD.
UP PLAY THAT ROLE AND ARE
PREPARED TO DO SO IN A OUT
COMPETENT AND THAT EXCEPTIONAL
Y. THANK YOU THANK YOU.
SHARON MEMBERS ON THE OTHER
NUMBER PER SE NEXT IN CALIFORNIA
FOR THE SAKE OF NOT BEING
REPETITIVE ALL JUST A MINOR
COMMENTS.
WITH THOSE MADE BY THE CAMPAIGN
FOR COLLEGE OPPORTUNITY THINK NQ.
GOOD MORNING PATTY HER RARE ON
BEHALF OF THE OAKLAND UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT WE REALLY
APPRECIATE THE PARTNERSHIP WITH
THE STATE. TO TRY TO HELP OUR
DISTRICT GET ON SOUND FISCAL
FOOTING --
WE UNDERSTAND THAT WITH --
THE AID THAT IS BEING PROPOSED
IN THIS BILL WE WILL HAVE TO
MAKE A VERY DIFFICULT LOCAL
DECISIONS AND WE ARE PREPARED TO
DO THAT.
WE LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING
OUR CONVERSATION WITH BOTH THE
SENATE THE ASSEMBLY AND THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE TO MAKE
SURE THAT --
WE CAN DO WHAT WE NEED TO DO FOR
OUR STUDENTS IN OAKLAND THANK
YOU THANK YOU FINAL.
PUBLIC COMMENT BARRETT CENTER BY
THE ALAMEDA COUNTY --
SUPERINTENDENT OF SCHOOLS --
KAREN ROE WE'VE ONLY HAD ABOUT
TWENTY FOUR HOURS THROUGH THE
LANGUAGE I THINK WE'VE GOT SOME.
WHICH GENERALLY SUPPORT OF SOME
CLARIFY STAFF TRY AND RESOLVE
BUT OTHER THAN THAT APPRECIATE
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY MUCH
SENATOR WIECKOWSKI THE BILL'S
BEEN MOVED PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY THE MOTION IS
TO PASS MITCHELL AYE AYE
MITCHELL AYE NIELSEN.
NIELSEN NO ANDERSON BELL.
BILL I PLACER GLAZER AYE JACKSON.
JACKSON I MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE
MONNING MONEY I'M MORE LOCK.
MORE LUCK AYE PAN PAN AYE
PORTANTINO.
PORTANTINO AYE ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE STONO Y.
KASKI BECAUSE THE AYE WILK.
WILK AYE.
LIKE IN THE QUICKLY. FOURTEEN
KNIFE TWO DAYS THE MEASURE
PASSES WOULD YOU PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ON A. B. EIGHTEEN
TWENTY A AB EIGHTEEN TWENTY
EIGHT ANDERSON.
PAN.
PAN AYE PORTANTINO PORTANTINO
AYE.
ALRIGHT GONNA MAKE.
LET ME CALL THE VOTE NOT BE
APPETITE OKAY. TO WRITE. TWELVE
ICE TO KNOWS THE MEASURE PASSES
SENATOR NIELSEN.
I JUST A QUICK REMARK ON THE
EDUCATION BILL EIGHTEEN FORTY
THERE'S SOME GOOD IN IT LIKE THE
HELP FOR THE DISTRICTS AFFECTED
BY THE FIRES.
BUT FOR THESE TROUBLED DISTRICTS.
THAT'S THE SHOULD BE ALONE AT
LEAST THAT THEN GIVES SOME
OBLIGATION ON THEIR PART.
OR IN FACT THAT BIT OF
CONSCIENCE.
BECAUSE THE TROUBLE DISTRICT
STATE DROPPED.
LOANS DON'T GET REPAID.
NOW WE'RE JUST.
GIVEN THE MONEY AND I WOULD ALSO
ARGUE THERE'S A PROP TWENTY FIVE
ISSUE HERE I BELIEVE.
THAT PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT.
EXCEED.
THE AUTHORITY IT IS NOT WRITTEN
THEY GETS ARE THEY ARE NOT
REQUIRED TO IMPLEMENT THE BUDGET
AND WE'VE GOTTEN IN THE HABIT OF
ROUND HERE OF OF OF USING THAT
THE DEGREE JUST.
SO THAT EXPLAINS MY NO VOTE ON
THIS PARTICULAR BILL THANK YOU.
THANK YOUR THANK YOU VERY MUCH
SIR IN THE TWO MEASURES HAVE
PASSED -- WE
WILL TAKE A REEF TO ALLOW US ALL
TO REPORT TO THE SENATE FLOOR
FOR NINE O'CLOCK SESSION AGAIN
WE ILL RECONVENE IN ROOM.
ONE THIRTEEN IMMEDIATELY UPON
ADJOURNMENT OF SENATE FLOOR
THANK YOU
AND FOR BUT WE DON'T HAVE TO
WAIT FOR QUORUM I WAS JUST
REMINDED BECAUSE WE ESTABLISHED
TO PERFORM THIS MORNING.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
SO WE WILL RECONVENE AFTER
HAVING TAKEN A RECESS THIS
MORNING.
WE WILL BEGIN WITH A BE.
EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINE THE
MORTGAGE SETTLEMENT [inaudible]
TRAILER BILL.
FINANCE WILL COME ON TO THE
TABLE.
AND BEGIN WHEN YOU'RE READY
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
JOSH DUGGAR DEPARTMENT FINANCE
SO -- EIGHTY
EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINE IS A BUDGET
TRAILER BILL.
WHICH CLARIFIES THE ALLOCATIONS
BY THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE FROM
THE NATIONAL MORTGAGE A SPECIAL
DEPOSIT FUND IN 200-011-1212
THIRTEEN AND THIRTEEN FOURTEEN
WHERE CONSISTENT WITH
LEGISLATIVE.
DIRECTION PROVIDED IN GOVERNMENT
CODE SECTION ONE TWO FIVE THREE
ONE SUBDIVISION .
AN ACTING THIS CLARIFICATION IS
ALSO THE INTENT TO ABROGATE THE
HOLDING OF THE COURT OF APPEALS
RELATED TO THIS MATTER.
HOW TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS?
WHO DO NIELSEN?
WHAT APPEARED TO ME THAT YOU'RE
REINTERPRETING? FOR THE
ADMINISTRATION'S OWN PURPOSES.
BUT LEGISLATIVE INTENT WAS.
I'M MORE CONFIDENT IN WHAT THE
THIRD DCA [inaudible]
SAID [inaudible]
AND IT'S JUST WHAT IT APPEARS TO
ME [inaudible]
THAT.
ADMINISTRATION DECIDES WITH
WHATEVER PART OF MONEY IS.
AND THIS IS BY FAR NOT THE ONLY
INSTANCE WHERE THIS IS HAPPENING.
THAT THEY'LL DECIDE WHERE THE
MONEY GOES.
AND I THINK THE LEGISLATURE.
HAS THE SAME.
AND THIS TAKES MONEY AWAY AS I
SEE IT [inaudible]
FROM HOMEOWNERS.
I'M I READ IT WRONG WHAT WHAT
ARE YOU DOING FOR HOMEOWNERS AND
WHY IS IS BEING TAKEN AWAY FROM
HOMEOWNERS [inaudible]
SO.
WE COULDN'T SPEAK A LITTLE BIT --
TO IN THE RECENT BUDGETS AND ALL
OF THE INVESTMENTS THAT ARE MADE
RELATIVE TO HOUSING AND
HOMEOWNERS --
BUT JUST TO CLARIFY THAT AND WE
BELIEVE THAT THEY HAVE THE
CURRENT OPINION --
HINGES ON FINANCES
MISINTERPRETATION OF THE
ORIGINAL LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION
AND IN OUR OPINION THIS A
TRAILER BILL SIMPLY CLARIFIES
THAT AND THE ALLEGATIONS MADE BY
THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE WHERE IN
FACT CONSISTENT WITH LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTION.
AND AT THE TIME THE LEGISLATIVE
DIRECTION --
THAT'S IN EXISTING STATUTE A
STATED NOT WITHSTANDING ANY
OTHER LAW THE DIRECTOR OF
FINANCE NOW NAY ALLOCATE OR
OTHERWISE YOU.
THE FUNDS IN THE NATIONAL
MORTGAGE SPECIAL DEPOSIT FUND TO
OFFSET GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES
IN THE 200-011-1212 THIRTEEN AND
THIRTEEN FOURTEEN FISCAL YEARS.
AND IT WENT ON TO SPECIFY THAT
THE EXPENDITURE PLAN OF FROM THE
ADMINISTRATION SHOULD ALSO BE
INCLUDED IN A JOINT LEGISLATIVE
AND BUDGET NOTIFICATION WHICH
WAS SUBSEQUENTLY SUBMITTED BY
THE ADMINISTRATION PROPOSING THE
EXPENDITURE PLAN.
AND THEY FUTURE --
ALLOCATIONS OF FROM.
FUND WERE ALSO OPPOSED TO THE
LEGISLATURE AND FUTURE BUDGET AX
THAT STEP TO YOU JUST MENTIONED.
APPROVED BY THE LEGISLATURE OR
SUBMITTED YOU SAID SUBMITTED WAS
THE WORD YOU USED WAS APPROVED
AT A GO THROUGH THE PROCESS WAS
IT HURTING COMMITTEE.
JUST SHOW UP AND AMENDMENT.
I DON'T RECALL OR OUR HAVE
KNOWLEDGE OF WHETHER OR NOT
THERE WAS A HEARING ON THE
NOTIFICATION AT THE TIME THERE
WAS.
CERTAINLY IT WOULD CRIER THE
NOTIFICATION WE KNOW THE
NOTIFICATION WASN'T VACCINATED I
DON'T HAVE IN FRONT OF ME ANY
INFORMATION ON HOW MUCH DIALOGUE
WAS OCCURRED AT THE TIME.
BUT THERE WAS AND AND THAT THE
LEGISLATURE DID NOT DISAPPROVE
OF THE PLAN AND THEN AS I
MENTIONED IN FUTURE --
BUDGET --
DEVELOPMENT --
THE DEPARTMENT PROPOSED FUTURE
EXPENDITURES FROM THE SPECIAL
DEPOSIT FUND AND WE BELIEVE THAT --
THE LEGISLATURE RATIFIED THOSE
EXPENDITURES IN ADOPTING THE
FINAL BUDGET.
SO WE DO BELIEVE THE ALLOCATIONS
WERE CONSISTENT WITH LEGISLATIVE
INTENT.
YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND FOR THIS
NOT PERSONAL BUT THERE IS NO
TRUST HERE.
I'VE JUST BEEN APPRISED OF
ANOTHER --
EFFORT BY THE ADMINISTRATION IN
A TRAILER BILL. TO THROUGH ARE
THE LAWSUIT PROFFERED BY THE
COUNTY OF BUTTE.
BECAUSE OF LIKE GORE THE
OROVILLE SPILLWAY.
AND THAT'S A CORRUPTION.
OF THE PROCESS.
TO AND THAT WOULD NOT BE HEARD
ANY COMMITTEE SLIPPED IN A
TRAILER BILL SO THE FUNDAMENTAL
ISSUE.
YOU'RE DEALING WITH HERE FROM MY
POINT OF VIEW.
IS NO TRUST.
THANK YOU SIR LOOK LET ME JUST
ASK BEFORE I THIEF PLUG Y.
KOWSKI AND THEN FOLLOWED BY
CENTER MORE LOT CAN YOU --
CLARIFY FOR THE COMMITTEE.
BOMB.
AREAS IN WHICH THE LAWSUIT
DOLLARS WERE ALLOCATED TO SO
WE'RE CLEAR ABOUT.
CATEGORIES ARE HAVE YOU COULD
EXPLAIN IT THROUGH THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S OFFICE WHERE THE
ALLOCATIONS THAT ARE NOT THE
MONEY THEY CAN TO THE GENERAL
FUND.
OTHER RESOURCES.
SURE SO I THINK THE SO ADDRESS
THE QUESTION BUT HAPPY TO GO
INTO MORE DETAIL IF NEEDED SO
JUST AS A LITTLE BIT OF
BACKGROUND IT WAS A TWO THOUSAND
TWELVE SETTLEMENT.
AGREEMENT THAT --
PROVIDED TWENTY BILLION DOLLARS
IN RELIEF DIRECTLY TO CONSUMERS
AND THERE WAS ALSO A SEPARATE
POT OF MONEY AS PART OF THAT
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT THAT'S THE
POT OF MONEY BEING DISCUSSED NOW.
THAT -- POT
OF MONEY WAS INTENDED TO
COMPENSATE STATES THEMSELVES FOR
DAMAGES SO THIS WOULD BE FOR
EXAMPLE IMPACTS ON PROPERTY
TAXES INCOME TAXES EXPENDITURES
THAT STATES MADE AND SUPPORT OF
THEIR RESIDENTS.
AND ON THE OVERALL ECONOMIC
IMPACT --
AGAIN THAT'S THE POT OF MONEY
THAT'S CONTEMPLATED HERE NOT THE
TWENTY BILLION THAT WENT DIRECT
TO CONSUMERS.
AND I HAD STATE'S ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S --
IN IN SOME CASES WEIGHED IN ON
THEIR INTENT ON HOW AND THOSE
SETTLEMENT FUNDS WOULD BE USED
BY THE CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY
GENERAL IS ONE OF THOSE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S THAT WEIGHED IN WITH --
INTENSE AND THAT'S KIND OF THE
THE MATTER BEING DISCUSSED NOW.
NO I THINK THAT THAT THAT
EXPLANATION I GOT MY POINT
BECAUSE THAT FORMER INTENT
MILLION THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
WAS TO COMPENSATE STATE OF
CALIFORNIA IN GENERAL FOR THE
FOR THE ACTIVITIES OF THE
MORTGAGE --
LENDING AND IT WASN'T SPIT
SPECIFIED ON HOW EACH STATE WAS
SUPPOSED TO SPEND IT IS I
UNDERSTOOD [inaudible]
THE SETTLEMENT.
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL A CRACKED
WEIGHED IN WITH INTENSE ON THE
USE OF THOSE THAT THIS PART OF
SETTLEMENT MONEY AND IN THE
HEART OF THE RECESSION THE STATE
DID OF THE BEST THAT IT COULD TO
FOLLOW THE INTENSE AND ALLOCATE
MONEY -- FOR
HOUSING PRIORITIES SIMPLY.
THANK YOU MANAGER THIS REMINDS
ME OF THE TOBACCO SETTLEMENT.
THIS IS A NATIONAL.
AGREEMENT BETWEEN STATES AND
MORTGAGE PROVIDERS. TWENTY
BILLION WAS ISSUED THE STATE GOT
ITS PORTION [inaudible]
IT USED.
IT'S SET UP BY THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL SET UP IN A SPECIAL
ACCOUNT.
STATE USED THREE HUNDRED AND
THIRTY ONE MILLION DOLLARS FOR
GENERAL FUND PURPOSES.
A JUDGE CAME ALONG AND SAID THAT
WASN'T THE APPROPRIATE USE OF
THAT.
SOURCE OF REVENUES.
I WON'T EVEN GET INTO TOBACCO
SETTLEMENT HOW THAT WAS PROBABLY
MISUSED TO SWELL BUT AND AND NOW
WE'RE SAYING WITH THIS BILL.
THAT IT WAS OKAY. TO USE THE
MONEY THE WAY THAT THE STATE DID.
AND I'M JUST WONDERING WHAT.
HAPPENS NOW WHAT OF THE
REVERBERATIONS WHILE THE COURT
COME BACK AND SAY WAIT A SECOND.
WE DISAGREE WITH YOU AGAIN YOU
STILL OWE THE THREE HUNDRED
THIRTY ONE OR DOES THE COURT SAY
IF YOU'RE ABSOLVED YOU'RE RIGHT
YOU [inaudible]
CLARIFIED.
RIGHT SO THE INTENT OF THIS
LEGISLATION IS TO RESOLVE THE
QUESTION OF WHETHER NOT FINANCE
UNDERSTOOD.
THE DIRECTION OF THE LEGISLATURE
THAT WAS PUT INTO STATUTE WE
THINK THAT THIS.
THIS CLARIFIES THAT --
CLEARLY THE DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
OPERATED WITHIN THE LEGISLATIVE
INTENT AND DIRECTION SO I THINK
FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE --
ONCE THE LEGISLATURE PASSES THIS
LEGISLATION THAT THE COURTS
WOULD RECOMMEND THAT THE
UNDERLYING --
AND BASIS FOR THE OPINION WOULD
BE ABROGATED US OF THE REMEDY
THAT WAS SUPPOSE TO FLOW FROM
THAT DECISION --
WOULD NO LONGER STAND DID NOT
REQUIRE THIS OUT MORE LESS THIS
TRANSFER BACK TO THE SPECIAL
DEPOSIT FUND FOODS MY GENERAL
UNDERSTANDING OF THAT THE NEXT
STEPS FROM HERE.
YOU THINK YOU MANAGE.
YOU SAID A MARK I THINK.
SIMILARLY TO THE THE TO THE
TOBACCO LAWSUITS IN THE
SUBSEQUENT.
ON THE BALLOT INITIATIVES THERE
WAS AN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT THAT
THERE WERE GENERAL FUND --
HIT -- BOMB
EXPENSES AS A RESULT IN THE
RESULTING FROM YOU KNOW MEDICAL
EXPENSES AND SOLD DOLLARS DID
COME TO THE GENERAL FUND AS A
RESULT OF BOTH THE LAWSUIT THE
BALLOT INITIATIVE BECAUSE OF
THOSE EXPENDITURES THAT HAVE
BEEN MADE FROM.
OF THE GENERAL FUND --
OVER THE COURSE OF MANY YEARS
ANY OF THE SENATE IS DOWN.
I'M SORRY THAT I GOT YOUR LITTLE
TOO LATE AND I'M I MIGHT'VE
MISSED YOUR SOME OF YOUR
EXPLANATION BUT COULD YOU JUST
STUMBLED AGAIN JUST REITERATE
DATA.
THAT THE THREE HUNDRED THIRTY
ONE MILLION WAS --
AS AS I CAN HEARD LATELY I THINK
YOU'RE SAYING THAT IT WAS MORE
FOR THE THE STATE'S --
IMPACTS TO MORTGAGE CRISIS
[inaudible]
MY BACKGROUND.
SEEMS TO INFER THAT --
THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO HELP
HOMEOWNERS.
IN THE HOUSING CRISIS SO THEY
COULD.
STAY IN THEIR HOMES AND THAT
THERE MIGHT HAVE BEEN SOME.
STATE SLEIGHT OF HAND THAT COULD
BE PUT TO PUT IT INTO THE
GENERAL FUND INSTEAD OF GOING TO
THE PEOPLE THAT REALLY NEED IT
AT THE TIME SO COULD YOU
[inaudible]
IS CLARIFIED.
SO I THINK THAT THE
CLARIFICATION US PROVIDING
EARLIER IS THAT THESE SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT IN TWO THOUSAND TWELVE
DID INCLUDE TWENTY BILLION
DOLLARS OF DIRECT RELIEF TO THE
CONSUMERS THERE WAS SEPARATE A
SEPARATE POT OF MONEY. TO GO TO
THE STATES THEMSELVES FOR
DAMAGES THAT'S THE POT DISCUSSED
HERE AND IN.
CERTAIN CASES STATE ATTORNEY
GENERAL'S WEIGHED IN ON THE
INTENSE OF HOW THOSE --
STATE FUNDS WOULD BE UMPS SPENT
AND THAT'S THAT THE PART WE'RE
DISCUSSING HERE AND THE STATE
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S --
INTENT ON THE EXPENDITURES OF
MAY HAVE INCLUDED OF SOME OF THE
THE PRIORITIES THAT YOU
MENTIONED AS YOU KNOW CONSISTENT
WITH CONSUMER ISSUES BUT THE
ORIGINAL SETTLEMENT ALSO
INCLUDED MONEY DIRECTLY TO
CONSUMERS.
OKAY SO --
THEN AGAIN NOT BEING AN ATTORNEY.
UP.
WERE FORCED TO TAKE THIS ACTION
TODAY [inaudible] TO BASICALLY
CODIFY.
THAT MONEY THAT.
THE STATE VIEWED AS MITIGATION
FOR THE MORTGAGE CRISIS WOULD BE
USED FOR THE STATE'S IMPACTS.
AS OPPOSED.
TO THE COURTS BELIEVE WERE
INTENDED --
FOR HOMEOWNERS AND THEIR ABILITY
TO STAY IN THEIR HOMES THAT'S
WHY WE'RE DOING THIS TODAY.
BUT I THINK IT.
IT IS WHAT WE'RE DOING TODAY IS --
TAKE IS --
LEGISLATION THAT CLARIFIES THAT
THE EXPENDITURES --
DIRECTED BY THE DIRECTOR OF
FINANCE WERE CONSISTENT WITH THE
STATUTE THAT WAS PREVIOUSLY
ENACTED BY.
THE LEGISLATURE BECAUSE THE
CURRENT OPINION --
HINGES ON THE FACT THAT OR THE
FINDING THAT FINANCE
MISINTERPRETED THE ORIGINAL
LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION SO WE'RE
CLARIFYING THAT FINANCE OPERATED
WITHIN THE INTENT OF THE
ORIGINAL LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION
WHICH IS THE OF IT THE DIRECTION
THAT I READ EARLIER ABOUT.
USING THE FUNDS TO OFFSET
GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES IN THE
THREE FISCAL YEARS AND THEN
PROVIDE A REPORT TO THE JOINT
LEGISLATIVE BUDGET COMMITTEE FOR
REVIEW.
AND A PROPOSED ADDITIONAL
EXPENDITURES IN THE FOLLOWING
BUDGET ACTS THAT WERE RATIFIED
IN IF WE DON'T TAKE THIS ACTION
WOULD IS THE WHAT IS THE RESULT.
WELL THAT THE STATE IS --
CURRENTLY SEEKING REVIEW OF THE
SUPREME COURT --
WHICH WOULD AND I CLEAR LEAF AND
FURTHER --
DEFINED DEFINED THE FOR THEIR
COURSE OF ACTION OR REMEDIES AND
SO PART OF THE CHALLENGES ALSO
TIME MEAN WHERE --
AND WE WILL NOT KNOW --
AND WHETHER OR NOT THE SUPREME
COURT WILL BE TAKING UP THIS
ISSUE UNTIL AFTER.
AND SO WE THINK THAT THIS IS
THAT PRUDENT COURSE OF ACTION TO
CLARIFY THAT THE THE
APPLICATIONS WERE CONSISTENT
WITH LEGISLATIVE INTENT PRIOR TO
SEEKING THE REVIEW BECAUSE OF
HER TO SAY WITH OR IN
CONJUNCTION WITH DESIRE TO SAY
WITH ALL LEGISLATIVE IN TOWN.
THAT THE TWENTY BILLION DOLLARS.
AND OTHER FUNDS.
THAT WORD TO BE DIRECTED TO
STRUGGLING.
HOMEOWNERS TO STAY IN THEIR
HOMES.
IS A FAIR TO SAY THAT THE STATE
USED EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO DIVERT
THOSE FUNDS TO ARE STRUGGLING
HOMEOWNERS --
INSTEAD OF STICKING IT INTO THE
GENERAL FUND FOR ALTERNATIVE
PURPOSES.
I THINK THAT IT'S FAIR TO SAY
THAT THE OUR DIRECTOR OF FINANCE
FOLLOWED LEGISLATIVE DIRECTION
AND INTENDS ENACTED IN THE
STATUTE AND THAT THE EXPENDITURE
PLANS WERE ALSO PROPOSE IN THE
HEART OF A RECESSION AND EVERY
EFFORT WAS MADE --
TO BE CONSISTENT WITH OF THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S INTENT.
OF THAT WAS WAITING TO THE
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND THAT'S
BIRTH BUT CLARIFICATION WERE
TRYING TO AND IT CAN'T DECLARE
PRESIDENT TO STONE THIS PROBABLY
DIDN'T COME FROM THAT ORIGINAL
TWENTY BILLION THAT WAS TO SET.
AND SO TWENTY BILLION DID GO AS
INTENDED.
MOVE THE BILL.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
SEEING NONE THANK YOU FOR THE
MOTION MR Y. KOWSKI PUBLIC
COMMENT.
THE NUN PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
THE EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINE THE
MOTION TO PASS MITCHELL FIVE AYE
NIELSEN.
ANDERSON WILL GLAZER JACKSON.
MCGUIRE JACKSON AYE MCGUIRE AYE
MONEY.
ON IT AYE.
WARLOCK.
WARLOCK NO PAN.
AN AYE PORTANTINO ROTH I SKINNER.
SKINNER AYE STERN STERN AYE
STONE.
STONE NO MAJKOWSKI BECAUSE HE I
WILL.
WELCOME THEM.
PULLED KEEP THAT ITEM OPEN --
AS MEMBERS --
JOIN US [inaudible]
THANK YOU.
AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE PUBLIC
EMPLOYMENT.
GOOD AFTERNOON MARC TOLSON
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE.
AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE IS THE
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT TRAILER BILL.
HOW THIS BILL ALLOWS KELLY
CHARRED PUBLISHED ITS EFFORTS
RELATED TO REASONABLE
ACCOMMODATION POLICY
IMPROVEMENTS INTO AN EXISTING
REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE?
IT'S DUE ON NOVEMBER FIFTEENTH --
OF EACH YEAR AND IT ALSO
REQUIRES EDS TO PUBLISH ON ITS
WEBSITE SEAT PURCHASES THE
RESULT IN REASONABLE
ACCOMMODATION.
ON THIS BILL MAKES
CLARIFICATIONS REGARDING THE
AUTHORITY OF THE KERN COUNTY
EMPLOYERS ASSOCIATION BOARD AND
ALSO APPROPRIATES ONE POINT
THREE MILLION TO THE DEPARTMENT
OF INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS --
FOR FEDERAL FUNDS TO RECEIVE AN
APPRENTICESHIP U. S. A GRANT FOR
EFFORTS TO SUPPORT EXISTING --
AND TO EXPAND INTO NEW
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS.
I WITH THAT I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER
ANY QUESTIONS.
THANK YOU QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE MEMBERS [inaudible]
MOVE.
THE WE HAVE A MOTION PUBLIC
COMMENT PLEASE ON EIGHTEEN
THIRTY THREE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT.
THEME NONE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE THE
MOTION IS TO PASS MITCHELL BY.
NIELSEN ANDERSON.
ANDERSON NO BELL.
LASER JACKSON.
JACKSON AYE MCGUIRE.
MCGUIRE AYE MONNING MONNING AYE
MORE LOTS.
MORE LOOK AYE PAN AND I
PORTANTINO.
ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER [inaudible]
STERN.
STERN AYE STONE.
STONO Y. KASKI BECAUSE I WILL
[inaudible]
WILK NO.
MORE LIKE I DUNNO.
THANK YOU WILL HOLD THAT ITEM
OPEN.
A. B. EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE
WORKPLACE KONDA.
NGUYEN COUNTERPART MAN A FINANCE --
A. B. EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE IS A
BUDGET TRAILER BILL THAT
REQUIRES THE LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL
TO ESTABLISH A UNIT.
WITHIN THE LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL
BUREAU TO PROVIDE ADVICE AND
INVESTIGATION SERVICES TO THE
LEGISLATURE.
RELATED TO WORKPLACE MISCONDUCT
THE BILL REQUIRES THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF A DIRECTOR OF
THE UNIT ONE OR MORE
INVESTIGATORS AND ADDITIONAL
STAFF HAS APPROPRIATED AS
APPROPRIATE.
ARE THE BILL ALSO REQUIRES THE
LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL TO RETAIN BY
CONTRACT A ROTATING PANEL OF
EXPERTS TO REVIEW AND THE
INVESTIGATIONS UNDERTAKEN BY THE
UNIT.
AND MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE
LEGISLATURE REGARDING MATTERS
UNDER INVESTIGATION.
I ALSO INCLUDES ONE POINT FIVE
MILLION DOLLARS GENERAL FUND FOR
EIGHTEEN NINETEEN IMPLEMENTATION
COST OF THE UNIT.
THANK YOU QUESTION OF COLLEAGUES
WITH BILL THANK YOU ANY
QUESTIONS IT'S BEEN MOVED BY
SENATOR STONE ANY PUBLIC COMMENT
[inaudible]
SEEN.
CLEANUP PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
IF THE EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE THE
MOTION IS TO BE.
HELD BY AYE NIELSEN ANDERSON.
ANDERSON NO BELL LASER JACKSON.
TEXAN I'VE MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE
MONNING AYE MONEY I OR LOS.
MORE LIKE I PAN PAN AYE
PORTANTINO ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE AYE STONE
AYE WIECKOWSKI BECAUSE HE I WILL.
I WILK AYE.
AIR AYE AYE THIS ITEM. FOR
EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE WORKPLACE
CONDUCT YES.
ALRIGHT MANGO FROM NO TIGHTLY
CERTAINLY MONEY.
I TO KNOW.
WELL NO NO NO YOU WOULDN'T KNOW
IT I KNEW IT NOTE AYE SIR.
IT IS A. BE EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE
ANDERSON IS VOTING BY.
THANK YOU WILL LEAVE THAT ITEM
OPEN WE ALREADY DISPENSED WITH
A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY THIS
MORNING SO WE'LL MOVE ON TO A.
B.. EIGHTEEN FORTY ONE RESOURCES --
I HAVE SO IT WOULD BE BEFORE WE
BEFORE WE PROCEED --
BECAUSE WE WE'RE HOLDING THE
ITEMS UP THE FOR THE THE PEOPLE
SO ITEM.
EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE CHANGED MY
MIND.
SENATOR ANDERSON ON A BE
EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE IS A NO
VOTE.
AB EIGHTEEN THIRTY FIVE SENATOR
ANDERSON IS A NOBLE.
ALRIGHT.
WE ARE NOW GOING TO HEAR A. B.
EIGHTEEN FORTY ONE RESOURCES
FINANCE.
AND MEMBERS SIR JOH AGAR WITH
THE PART OF FINANCE THIS TRAILER
BILL INCLUDE VERY TECHNICAL
CLEAN UP AMENDMENTS NECESSARILY
TO AFFECTIVELY IMPLEMENT THE
CURRENT BUDGET --
THESE CHANGES INCLUDE TECH VOTE
CHANGES TO THE LOS ANGELES RIVER
RECREATION PARK DISTRICT WATER
CONSERVATION THAT DEALT A LOT
WITH A VENGEANCE PROGRAM AND THE
PLASTICS MARKET DEVELOPMENT
PROGRAM.
THANK YOU ANY QUESTIONS.
IT'S BEEN MOVES PUBLIC COMMENT.
AB.
EIGHTEEN FORTY ONE MANAGER
MEMBERS MORE TOP ON BEHALF OF
THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO WE ARE IN
SUPPORT OF THE PROVISION RELATED
TO PURE WATER WELL IT'S A
TECHNICAL PROVISION BUT WILL
HELP US I GET OUR PROJECT OFF
THE GROUND THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
THE NO FURTHER COMMENT PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL. EIGHTEEN FORTY
ONE THE PASSES THE MOTION
MITCHELL AYE.
NIELSEN.
ANDERSON ANDERSON NO BELL.
LASER.
JACKSON TEXAN AYE MCGUIRE
MCGUIRE AYE MONEY MONEY I MORE
LOTS.
MORE LIKE I CAN I CAN I
PORTANTINO ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE.
STONO MAJKOWSKI BECAUSE HE I
WILL.
WILK AYE.
THANK YOU WILL HOLD THAT ITEM
OPEN EIGHTEEN FORTY TWO HUMAN
SERVICES [inaudible]
FINANCE.
GOOD AFTERNOON KRISTIN SHELTON
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND AB
EIGHTEEN FORTY TWO MAKES
TECHNICAL CLARIFYING CHANGES TO
HUMAN SERVICES PROGRAMS TO
IMPLEMENT THE BUDGET OF TWENTY
EIGHTEEN CRIME PRIMARILY FOCUSED
ON THE POWER SOME VISITING
PROGRAM IN HOME SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES AND CHILD WELFARE.
THANK YOU THE BILL HAS BEEN
MOVED BY THE SUB CHAIR IN THE
QUESTIONS OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
THE NUN PUBLIC COMMENT.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL FIFTY
EIGHTEEN FORTY TO THE MOTION IS
TO PASS MITCHELL AYE.
YELTSIN ANDERSON ANDERSON AYE
BELL.
IF YOU'RE JACKSON JACKSON AYE
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE MONNING.
AYE HONEY AYE MORE LUCK MORE
LIKE I CAN PAN AYE PORTANTINO
ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE
STERN.
STERN AYE STONE STONE AYE WAY
KASKI BECAUSE HE AYE WILK.
AYE WILK AYE.
THANK YOU.
A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY THREE
GENERAL GOVERNMENT [inaudible]
WELCOME BACK.
PORTALS AND DEPARTMENT OF
FINANCE
SO AB EIGHTEEN FORTY
THREE IS THE GENERAL GOVERNMENT
TRAILER BILL THIS BILL MAKES
TECHNICAL CLEAN UP THAT'S BEEN
NINETY TWO I THINK COMMITTEE AND
THE DEPARTMENT FINANCE AND DR
FOR WORKING ON THIS IS GONNA.
AYE DEFTLY HELP OUR MEMBERS
RESPOND QUICKLY TO NATURAL
DISASTERS ON GOING THROUGHOUT
THE STATE THANK YOU THANK YOU
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL AB EIGHTEEN
FORTY THREE THE MOTION TO SEE
PAST MITCHELL BY.
AYE NIELSEN ANDERSON ANDERSON NO
BELL PLACER JACKSON.
JACKSON AYE MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE
MONEY.
MONEY AYE MORLOCK.
CAN.
AND I PORTANTINO ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE NO STONE
ESTO NO WAY KASKI ACOSTA I WILL.
NO WILK NOW.
THANK YOU WAS AT EIGHTEEN FORTY
FOUR MADAM SECRETARY.
NO.
KNOW FORTY THREE OKAY I'M GET
AHEAD OF MYSELF OR MY CHECK
MARKS ON MY LAST.
BUT WILL PROCEED NOW TO A. B.
EIGHTEEN FORTY FOUR TAXATION
[inaudible]
FINANCE.
AFTERNOON HIGH CHAMBERLAIN
DEPARTMENT FINANCE.
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY FOUR MAKE SOME
TECHNICAL CHANGES --
TO BUDGET TRAILER BILL S. B.
EIGHT SEVENTY ONE WHICH EXTENDED
THE STATE'S FILM CREDIT FOR AN
ADDITIONAL. FIVE YEARS AYE DOES
THREE THINGS AT FIRST IT CHANGES
THE DUE DATE FOR NOBODY A REPORT --
SECOND IT CLARIFIES THE
DEFINITION OF THE OF THE
CARRYOVER CREDITS AT THE FILM
COMMISSION.
IS ALLOWED TO ALLOCATE AT THE
END OF THE PROGRAM THAT IS AFTER
JULY FIRST.
TWO THOUSAND TWENTY FIVE AND
THIRTY IT APPROPRIATE FIVE
THOUSAND DOLLARS TO THE
COMMISSION FOR THE PURPOSE OF
DRYING UP RULES FOR IMPLEMENTING.
THE PROGRAM THROUGH THE BILL.
THANK YOU THE BILL HAS BEEN
MOVED ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
FROM COMMITTEE MEMBERS THIRD IT
WILL ADD A COMMENT THIS THIS
MEASURES INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT.
TO MY DISTRICT IS NOT ONLY ABOUT
ACT NOT AYE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
A BETTER QUALITY OF LIFE ISSUES
FOR MY CONSTITUENTS AND I WANT
TO THANK THE CHAIR FOR ALL OF
HER WORK ON MAKING THIS HAPPEN
THANK YOU SIR ANY OTHER
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS.
THEME NONE A PUBLIC COMMENT.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL IF BE
EIGHTEEN FORTY FOR THE MOTION IS
TO PASS MITCHELL AYE.
I THINK NIELSEN ANDERSON
ANDERSON AYE BELL.
LASER JACKSON JACKSON AYE
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE.
MONEY.
MONEY AYE MORLOCK MARLA. TEN AND
I PORTANTINO ROTH ROTH AYE
SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE STERN.
STERN AYE STONE STONE AYE
BECAUSE I WILL.
WILK AYE.
THANK YOU FINAL BILL BEFORE US
TODAY A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX
ELECTIONS [inaudible]
WE MISS.
UNITED.
FORTY FIVE I HAVE A RUNAWAY
CONSIDERABLY.
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE PUBLIC
SAFETY FORGIVE ME IF SENATOR
SKINNER.
JOSH DUGGAR DEPARTMENT FINANCE
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE IS THE
PUBLIC SAFETY BUDGET TRAILER
BILL THIS BILL INCLUDES FOUR
MAIN COMPONENTS THE FIRST
CLARIFIES THAT THE TWO NEW
JUDGESHIPS AUTHORIZED IN THE TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN NINETEEN
BUDGET --
COME OUT OF THE FIFTY PREVIOUSLY
AUTHORIZED IN STATUTE --
THE SECOND APPROPRIATE FIVE
MILLION SITE EVERY APPROPRIATES
FIVE MILLION IN UNSPENT FUNDS
FROM THE PEACE OFFICER TRAINING
FUND FOR REIMBURSEMENT TO LOCAL
LAW ENFORCEMENT FOR PEACE
OFFICER TRAINING.
THE THIRD CLARIFIES EXISTING
STATUTE RELATED TO THE PUBLIC
DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION BY THE
CALIFORNIA STATE AUDITOR.
AND LASTLY THE BILL CLARIFIES
THAT THE EMERGENCY MEDICAL
RESPONSE CERTIFICATION PROCESS
FOR PAROLEES PARTICIPATING IN
THE CAL FIRE TRAINING PROGRAM.
IS NON PROVISIONAL FOOD THE BILL.
THE BILL HAS BEEN MOVED IN THE
COMMENTS.
ANY PUBLIC COMMENT.
THEME NONE PLEASE CALL HE ROLL
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE THE
MOTION IS TO PASS MITCHELL BY I
NIELSEN ANDERSON.
ANDERSON I FELL PLACER JACKSON
JACKSON AYE.
MCGUIRE MCGUIRE AYE MONEY MONEY
AYE MORLOCK MORE LIKE I PAN PAN
AYE PORTANTINO ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE
STERN STERN AYE STONE STONE AYE
WIECKOWSKI.
AYE MAKOVSKY AYE WILK
[inaudible]
WILK.
WHICH WAS THIS PUBLIC SAFETY
[inaudible]
EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE AREAS OF
WELCOME I EXCELLENT --
NOW MOVING ON TO THE FINAL --
THROUGH THE BILL BEFORE US
EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX ELECTION
FINANCE.
COULD COME DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX OF THE
GENERAL GOVERNMENT TRAILER BILL
RELATED TO ELECTIONS THE BILL
CLARIFIES HOW THE CALCULATION OF
QUALIFIED ELECTORS IS COMPUTED
FOR AN AMENDMENT TO THE CHARTER.
OF THE COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO AND
OTHER RELATED CHANGES ADDITION
THIS BILL INCLUDES FEDERAL TRUST
FUND AUGMENTATION THAT WILL
ALLOW FOR THE SECRETARY OF STATE
TO SEND FEDERAL FUNDS TO THE
COUNTIES TO IMPROVE AND SECURE
ELECTION SYSTEMS.
THANK YOU QUESTIONS FROM
COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
THIRD REQUIRES MOVE THE BILL.
ANY PUBLIC COMMENT ON EIGHTEEN
FORTY SIX LAST BILL --
MADAM CHAIR IT SENATORS TERRY
BRAND BEHALF SEIU CALIFORNIA
THIS.
BILL RELATED TO THE BUDGET
AUGMENTATION INSURERS.
THAT THE PEOPLE OF SAN DIEGO
WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO VOTE
ON THE CHARTER AMENDMENT IN THIS
NOVEMBER --
WITHOUT INTERRUPTION THANK YOU.
YOU'RE WELCOME NEXT WITNESS.
GOOD AFTERNOON MADAM CHAIR
COMMITTEE MEMBERS JOHN AND CLAIM
TO HAVE TO THE COUNTY SAN DIEGO
HERE IN OPPOSITION TO THIS
MEASURE.
OF THIS IS CLEAN UP TO A BILL
LAST YEAR A. B. NINE ONE
DISOBEDIENCE SECOND TIME THIS
YEAR THAT WE'VE TRIED.
TO FIX THIS IN THE BUDGET
PROCESS WHICH BRINGS UP ONE OF
OUR ISSUES WHICH THIS.
SHOULD BE ADDRESSED THROUGH
GOING THROUGH THE POLICY
COMMITTEES RECAP OF MORE FULLY
VETTING OF THE LANGUAGE WE THINK
THERE'S PROBLEMS WITH THE WAY
THIS LANGUAGES ARE.
WRITTEN.
I ENDED ALSO GOES BEYOND THE
SCOPE OF EIGHTY NINETY NINE A
ONE AND NOT.
IT EFFECTIVELY NOW GOES AROUND
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS AND THE
PUBLIC HEARING PROCESS THAT YOU
WOULD HAVE.
IF YOU'RE PLACING A CHARTER
AMENDMENT BEFORE THE VOTERS ARE
THAT ALSO THEN OF DUST
ELIMINATES THE PUBLIC
PARTICIPATION THAT PROCESS
BECAUSE IT BASICALLY ALLOWS ROV
NOW.
TO DIRECTLY PLACE THIS ON THE
BALLOT WITHOUT GOING THROUGH
THAT PROCESS THERE'S A MOTHER
ASPECTS OF THE BILL RELATED TO
WRITE IN VOTES --
CANDIDATES THAT WE THINK IT
SHOULD BE VETTED MORE FULLY
THROUGH THAT PROCESS.
AND I THINK FINALLY I THINK WE
LOOK AT THIS FIRM A SINGLE
SUBJECT WILL NOT SINGLE SUBJECT
BUT FROM BEING SPECIFIC TO SAN
DIEGO COUNTY.
AND HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE
JUSTIFICATION FOR MAKING IT
SPECIFIC TO SAN DIEGO COUNTY
WITHOUT WE ARE OPPOSED.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
TESTIMONY THEATER MORE LOS.
WE SAT PARA [inaudible]
BUT MAYBE.
PLAYING WHY THIS IS A BUDGET
[inaudible]
YOUR BILL.
A POLICY FIELD FOR SOME OF THE
WORDS THE NEXUS.
AS SIR THAT THE BUDGET --
THEBUDGET ACT DOES INCLUDE A
SMALL A TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLAR
APPROPRIATION OF TO HELP
IMPLEMENT AND THE PROVISIONS
THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THIS
TRAILER BILL SO I'M.
THERE'S A BUDGET NEXUS THERE --
AND SEEM TO BE PRETTY
STRAIGHTFORWARD TECHNICAL
CLARIFICATION ON THE VOTE
THRESHOLD --
THAT WAS IN PLACE IN THE POLICY.
THE MISS IT ADDS THOSE BEEN IN
PLACE.
HAVING TROUBLE WITH THAT THAT.
OKAY WILL WE GIVE IT TO THE
QUESTION ANY OTHER QUESTIONS.
SEEING NONE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX THE MOTION
IS TO PASS MITCHELL [inaudible]
MOVING OVER.
SENATOR MCGUIRE DEAR.
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX AND
MOTIONS TO PASS MITCHELL.
I I NIELSEN.
ANDERSON ANDERSON NO BELL LASER
JACKSON JACKSON AYE MCGUIRE.
MCGUIRE AYE MONNING MONEY AYE
MORLOCK MORE LOOK NO PAN PAN AYE
PORTANTINO [inaudible]
ROTH.
ROTH AYE SKINNER.
SKINNER AYE STERN AYE STERN AYE
STONE.
NO NO MAKOVSKY BECAUSE THE AYE
WILL.
KNOW WILK NOW [inaudible]
MORE SO [inaudible]
MBMBAM.
WITHOUT A NOW CLICK A SO HAVE
MEMBERS --
BOTH A CENTER WILL.
MADAM CHAIRMAN ITEMS THREE I
WOULD LIKE TO CHANGE MY VOTE.
ON A. B. EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT WAS LIKE TO
CHANGE IT FROM NOTE TO AYE --
SENATOR LOOKS VOTE IN AB
EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE IS BY.
EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE PUBLIC
EMPLOYMENT.
SENATOR WELL AS AND I GOT IT
THANK YOU --
APPROPRIATIONS IS GOING TO BREAK
TO ALLOW OUR COLLEAGUES TO COME
JOIN US AND ADD ON IN A AFTER
THEY ARRIVE WE WILL --
CALL THE FINAL VOTE SO WE'RE
WAITING FOR THEM [inaudible]
BUT HE
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS FOR ATV.
TALKING NOW WORKING WITHOUT
[inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
I EARLIER.
YEAH THE MEMBERS STARTED.
OUT AFTER THE REFER A. B..
EIGHTEEN TWENTY NINE I THINK YOU.
I JUST LOVE.
ICE TWELVE NOTES FIVE THE
MEASURE CARRIES WE CALLED AGAIN
BECAUSE MISTER GLAZIER WALKED IN
THE DOOR.
THAT'S WHY YOU HEARD IT TWICE.
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS PLEASE
FOR A. B. EIGHTEEN THIRTY THREE
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT [inaudible]
NIELSEN.
NO YELTSIN NOW.
WELL I FELT I PLAYED
[inaudible]
I PORTANTINO IVERSON'S ENOUGH
[inaudible]
CRISIS WELCOME [inaudible]
I'VE.
TWELVE NO FOUR THE MEASURE
CARRIES BABY EIGHTEEN THIRTY
FIVE WORKPLACE CONDUCT PLEASE
CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
YES AND I I WELL.
I AM PLACER.
I PORTANTINO IVERSON. SIXTEEN I
WAS. FIVE ONE NO THE MEASURE
CARRIES A. B. EIGHTEEN FORTY ONE
RESOURCES CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
NO [inaudible]
NOW.
YOU KNOW I'VE EVER SEEN
[inaudible]
I FORESEE. FIVE PORTANTINO'S
THREE THE MEASURE CARRIES A. B.
EIGHTEEN FORTY THREE GENERAL
GOVERNMENT CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS PLEASE.
WE EIGHTEEN FORTY TWO HUMAN
SERVICES ALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
PLEASE [inaudible]
I WE DID. SEVENTEEN EYES NO ZERO
THE MEASURE CARRY.
THAT WAS HUMAN SERVICES CORRECT
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY THREE GENERAL
GOVERNMENT PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS [inaudible]
I I WELL I AM I I YOU KNOW I
PAGE IT BRADFORD MY BOTH FROM
EITHER.
I YEAH WHO.
THAT'S ALL I'VE. TWELVE I FIVE
KNOW THE MEASURE CARRIES.
AB EIGHTEEN FORTY FOUR TAXATION
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
I AM NOT.
LYING [inaudible]
I WE'RE A LOT QUESTIONS YOU AT
ONE THIRTY PM I SIXTEEN AYE.
OF THE MEASURE CARRIES. EIGHT
THE EIGHTEEN FORTY FIVE PUBLIC
SAFETY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS [inaudible]
VOTING [inaudible]
WELL [inaudible]
I THINK [inaudible]
I RESIDENCIA.
THERE. SIXTEEN ZERO THE MEASURE
PASSES.
VITAL TRAILER BILL UP TODAY A.
B. EIGHTEEN FORTY SIX ELECTIONS
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS
[inaudible]
NO
[inaudible]
YEAH LIKE. TWELVE A I FIVE KNOW
THE MEASURE CARRIES.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH OF MEMBERS
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE FOR
COMING BACK.
BUDGET COMMITTEE IS ADJOURNED