THANK YOU ALL FOR JOINING US.
WE SHOULD ALL BE BEING YOU'RE
WELCOME TO THE CALIFORNIA STATE
SENATE'S GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
COMMITTEE HAVE WE HAVE A QUICK
AGENDA HERE TODAY WE ARE GOING.
TO START OUT --
WITH SOME HOUSEKEEPING ITEM
NUMBER THREE ON OUR AGENDA
ASSEMBLY BILL SEVENTEEN NINETY
TWO HAS BEEN PULLED BY THE
AUTHOR WE WILL NOT BE HEARING AB
SEVENTEEN NINETY TWO TODAY --
THAT THERE WILL GOING BACK WILL
GO BACK TO ITS ORIGINAL FORM --
IN WILL SOON BE ON THE SENATE
FLOOR BUT WE'VE TWO BILLS IN
FRONT OF US WERE GONNA START
WITH SENATOR PAN.
WANNA SAY THANK YOU TO SENATOR
PAN FOR ALL OF HIS WORK ON THIS
AT SOLVING A CHALLENGE BETWEEN.
BY THE COUNTY SACRAMENTO CITY
SACRAMENTO AND FOCUSING ON
HOUSING.
BUT VERY VERY GRATEFUL THIS IS
SENATE BILL FOUR EIGHTY ONE WE
WELCOME I HAD THE GOOD DOCTOR --
WHO IS GOING TO BE PROVIDING AYE
HALF OFF HIPS FOR THE REST OF
THE DAY TODAY SO --
SKIN NO I JUST DIDN'T DO DO
APPRECIATE AT ALL OF THE WORK
THAT CENTERS ON THIS IS BEEN A
LONG STANDING ISSUE IN
APPRECIATE YOUR PROBLEMS ON THIS
AND WE WELCOME.
THANK YOU AND FOR AS FAR AS HIPS
CONCERNED ONLY THE KIDS I GUESS
BECAUSE IMPEACHMENT.
I THINK YOU CHAIR MEMBERS --
AS BEFORE ANYONE IS A DISTRICT
BILL DEL PROVIDE THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO WITH THE MUCH NEEDED
OPPORTUNITY PROVIDE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AT THE SITE OF THE
FORMER SAN ONE MOTEL.
IN MOBILE HOME SITE ON STOCKTON
BOULEVARD SO ALLOW THE COW
[inaudible]
COMMANDOS REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO DISPOSE OF
THE PROPERTY FOR BELOW MARKET
VALUE THE SAN JUAN LAND PARCELS
ONE OF EIGHT PARCELS ARE
PURCHASING CLEARED FOR
REDEVELOPMENT BACK IN TWO
THOUSAND AND EIGHT SITUATED
ALONG OF PORTENT TRANSPORTATION
QUARTER IN IT AND UNDERSERVED
AREA OF THE CITY THE PARCELS
PRESENT.
AN IDEAL OPPORTUNITY FOR
DEVELOPMENT OF FOR THE HOUSING.
HOWEVER ONE REDEVELOPMENT
ELIMINATE IN TWENTY TWELVE THE
SEVEN SMALLER DECENT PROPERTIES
WERE TRANSFERRED TO THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO'S HOUSING AUTHORITIES
SUCCESSOR AGENCY HOWEVER THE ST
ONE PARCEL.
WAS TRANSFERRED TO THE COUNTY OF
SACRAMENTO'S REDEVELOPMENT
AGENCY SUCCESSOR AGENCY.
THAT'S BEFORE YOU WANT TO ALLOW
THE SAN JUAN PROPERTY BE
TRANSFERRED FROM THE COUNTY TO
THE CITY FOR BELOW MARKET VALUE
OR TO FACILITATE DEVELOPMENT A
MUCH NEEDED AFFORDABLE HOUSING
EXISTING LAWS REQUIRE THAT THESE.
PROPERTIES FORMALLY TARGET FOR
ME DEVELOP BE DISPOSED OF
EXPEDITIOUSLY AND MAXIMIZE VALUE
HOWEVER EACH MONTH MORE
SACRAMENTO RESIDENTS WERE FORCED
ONTO THE STREETS DUE TO HOW.
RISING HOUSING COSTS AT THE
FORTY ONE ALLOWS US TO ACT NOW
TO JUST A TECHNICALITY IS
STANDING IN THE WAY IT
DEVELOPMENT OF THIS VERY
IMPORTANT FOR THE HOUSING.
SITE I WOULD MAKE NOTE THAT UP
ALL PARTIES INVOLVED THE CITY IN
THE COUNTY ARE IN SUPPORT OF
THIS.
HIGH FISHY YOUR SUPPORT RESPECT
AN AYE VOTE AND I'M PLEASED TO
PRESENT TO US SECOND A CITY
COUNCIL MEMBER AREA GARAK WHO
REPRESENTS THIS REGION THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND MISS
GUZMAN ALWAYS GOOD TO SEE SIR
THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK INCREASE
SHE WORKED WITH THE SENATOR ON
BRINGING THIS DEAL AYE IT TO
FRUITION. FOR VERY MUCH MISTER
CHAIR GOOD MORNING MISTER
CHAIRMAN AS SENATORS OF THE
COMMITTEE AREA GET AYE COUNCIL
MEMBER FOR THE CITY OF
SACRAMENTO DISTRICT SIX IN
SUPPORT.
OF SB FORTY ONE I THINK YOU
SENATOR YOUR COMMITTEE SUPPORT
OF SB FORTY ONE WOULD HELP THE
CITY AND COUNTY OF SACRAMENTO TO
BETTER UTILIZE THIS BLIGHTED
VACANT PROPERTY RIDDLED WITH
ILLEGAL DUMPING.
ON STOCKTON BOULEVARD THAT WAS
ONCE THE OLD SAN JUAN MOTEL.
LIKE MANY CITIES SACRAMENTO'S
FACING A HOUSING CRISIS AND IS
IN DESPERATE NEED OF GROWING ITS
AFFORDABLE HOUSING STOCK THIS IS
THIS TECHNICAL BILL WOULD ALLOW
THE CITY. TO ACQUIRE THIS
BLIGHTED PROPERTIES FROM THE
REDEVELOPMENT SUCCESSOR AGENCY
FOR THE CLEAR PURPOSE OF
CREATING AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
THE CITY IN AND COUNTY THROUGH
OUR HOUSING SUCCESSOR AGENCY
OWNS THE ADJACENT.
PARCELS AND LOTS AROUND IT
UNFORTUNATELY THIS PROPERTY OF
THE OLD SAN JUAN MOTEL IS THE
LARGEST PARCEL IN RIGHT IN THE
MIDDLE OF THESE PROPERTIES.
THE REQUIREMENTS AND CURRENT LAW
AFTER THE DISSOLUTION OF
REDEVELOPMENT HAVE IMPEDED THE
ABILITY TO JOIN THESE PARCELS
TOGETHER AND EXECUTE AND
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECT.
THE OLD SAN JUAN MOTEL WAS
ESSENTIALLY THE ONLY AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FOR MANY FOLKS AND FOR
THE PROPERTY SHOULD BE TREATED
AS A HOUSING SUCCESSOR PROPERTY.
YOUR VOTE.
S. VACANT PROPERTIES IT PROPERTY
TO USE SPECIFICALLY FOR MUCH
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND CLEAN A
BLIGHTED AREA THE SET FAKE IT
FOR YEARS I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
AND ASK FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
THANK YOU SO MUCH KATHARINE WE
NOW LIKE A WELCOME ANYONE ELSE
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT
OF THIS BILL THAT PLEASE COMPORT
THIS TIME PERSON LAST NAME ALONG
WITH YOUR ORGANIZATION.
GOOD MORNING SIR MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS DAVID JOB ON THAT THE
CITY SACRAMENTO I AGREE IT IS
VERY STRONG SUPPORT IMPORTANT
PROJECT BLIGHTED NEIGHBORHOOD OF
IN THE FORMAL OBVIOUS FOR THE
REDEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION I
UNDERSTAND HOW THIS PROCESS
WORKS ALL THE UNDERLYING TAX.
BY AGENCIES HAVE SIGNED
COMPENSATION AGREEMENTS AND
AGREED TO ALLOW THIS TO GO AT
LESS THAN FAIR MARKET VALUE SO.
EVERYBODY THAT HAS A DOG IN THE
FIGHT HAS AGREED TO LESS THAN
FAIR MARKET VALUE ON THIS
PROPERTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS A
CRISIS AND WE ASK FOR MY BOAT.
THINKS MUCH OUR THANKS FOR BEING
HERE ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT THE
CRUISE COMPORT THIS TIME BY
SCOTT FOR SUPPORT.
NOW LIKE BASICALLY OF ANYONE WHO
MAY BE OPPOSED IF YOU COULD
PLEASE ADVANCE.
ANYONE OPPOSED LAST CALL TO
BRING BACK THE COMMITTEE TO BE A
SECRET QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
ANIMAL.
MISTER CHAIR I WAS A CHAIRMAN OF
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS OF ORANGE
COUNTY WHEN.
RDAS FOR ELIMINATED IN WE HAD
THAT APPOINT PEOPLE TO SUCCESS
FOR AGENCIES AND I AM.
TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT WE'RE
DOING YOU'RE TRYING TO SOLVE A-PROBLEM AND I DON'T SEE DOING
THE BRIEFING.
THAT HELPED ME RELEASE MY
BRIEFING THAT.
BUT HELP ME TRY TO FIGURE OUT
WHAT.
THE PROBLEM WAS --
SO WE'RE TRYING TO GET IT FROM
THE COUNTY TO THE CITY.
AT A LOWER PRICE AND ARE AYE AND
I'M JUST WONDERING WHY THE
LEGISLATION AND AND MAYBE I'M
MISSING SOMETHING BUT I WOULD I
WOULD HAVE SAID WELLONE I JUST
WORK WITH THE COUNTY.
AND AND WILL PAY YOU FAIR MARKET
VALUE BUT YOU PUT IN YOUR BUDGET.
THE AMOUNTOF THE DISCOUNT THAT
WE NEED AND THAT WE JOINT
VENTURE AND THEY BUDGET THAT
AMOUNT AND WE STILL GET THAT.
WHEN THEY GIVE US A CHECK FOR
THAT THE DELTA?
AND WE STILL GOT COMP WHICH THE
SAME THING YOU DON'T HAVE TO DO
LEGISLATION AND THAT A PRESIDENT
SO I JUST WANNA KNOW.
WHAT WHAT I'M MISSING IN THAT
TRANSACTION?
SURE I'LL AND I'LL ASK OR STAFF
FROM THE REDEVELOPMENT SUCCESSOR
AGENCY AND AS A JURY TO COME UP
HERE AND TALK ABOUT THAT BUT
ESSENTIALLY THE CHALLENGE HAS
BEEN FOR FOUR YEARS SINCE
REDEVELOPMENT HAPPEN.
IS THAT WE HAVEN'T BEEN ABLE TO
PIECE TO GET A PROJECT MOVING
FOR TO DO TO MAKE THAT
TRANSACTION.
AND THIS IS ESSENTIALLY WHAT
WHAT WERE ATTEMPTING TO DO HERE
USE.
I JOIN ALL THOSE PIECES TOGETHER
SO THAT WE CAN ACTUALLY HAVE
SOMEONE WHO WANTS TO TAKE IT ON
AS YOU KNOW --
ANY WHETHER YOU'RE A NONPROFIT
OR FOR PROFIT DEVELOPER ANY
OBSTACLES IN TRYING TO MOVE LAND
TOGETHER TO BUILD SOMETHING.
FOLKS WILL GO TO ANOTHER
LOCATION SO BECAUSE OF THAT THIS
AREA HERE HAS SET BEACON FOR A
LONG TIME BECAUSE IT LET ME LET
ME ASK A LITTLE DIFFERENTLY
BECAUSE A SUCCESSOR AGENCY TO DO.
SOMETHING WITH THESE PROPERTIES
HAD TO GET APPROVAL FROM THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE IS THE
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE HOLDING UP.
THE TRANSACTION WOULD.
WHAT AM I MISSING WHAT WHAT WILL
PROMPT SO BUT BEFORE YOU ANSWER
IF YOU DON'T MIND IS INTRODUCING
YOURSELF AND ORGANIZATION WITH
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND WE WELCOME
YOU TO COMMITTEE?
SHARON ROGER WILLIAMS DIRECTOR
OF DEVELOPMENT.
ON THE SACRAMENTO HOUSING AND
REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY WE ARE
JOINT OP POWERS AGENCY THAT
SERVES.
BOTH THE CITY AND THE COUNCIL --
AND THE COUNTY.
THROUGH AND WE ARE THE SUCCESSOR
AGENCY FOR BOTH THE CITY AND THE
COUNTY.
AND THE CHALLENGE OF THE I HAVE.
A DIAGRAM THAT SHOWS THE THE THE
SITE IF ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO IT
THAT WOULD HELP OF THE VISUAL
OKAY.
TALK ABOUT THAT TO YOUR QUESTION
WHY IS IT GOING TO BE SOMETHING
THAT'S GONNA BE USED BY OTHERS I
WOULD THINK YOU.
YOU'RE SOLVING A SO A PROBLEM
AND IT'S SO IT'LL BE REPLICATED
SO I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE WE ONE
OF THE CHALLENGES THAT WE HAVE
IS THAT.
BECAUSE IT HAS TO BE SOLD AT THE
MARKET.
RATE PRICE FOR THE HOUSING ON
THE SITE.
THE GOAL IS REALLY TO BE ABLE TO
SELL.
THE PROPER TO TO ASSEMBLE ALL OF
THE PARCELS AND BE ABLE TO OFFER
THEM TO A DEVELOPER.
BOMB WHO WOULD COMMIT TO LONG
TERM HOUSING AFFORDABILITY.
THE QUESTION THAT YOU ASK IS WHY
WOULDN'T IT JUST BE FALL TO THE
CITY OR THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY AT
THE MARKET RATE.
WILD PRICE AND THEN --
USE THAT DELTA AS KIND OF ARE
YOU THE KIND.
OF THE APPROACH WHICH HAS AS
PART OF ITS RIGHT YOU KNOW
BUDGET FOR PROVIDING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING IS IT BECAUSE WE HAVE AN
ISSUE CONSTITUTIONALLY WITH SAY.
IF THE PUBLIC FUNDS I DON'T KNOW
ABOUT THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF
IT BUT WHAT WE DO HAVE IS A
CHALLENGE WHERE WE HAVE BOTH THE
CITY AND THE COUNTY.
THE COUNTY ARE COMMITTED TO
AFFORDABLE HOUSING BUT HAVE
EXTREMELY LIMITED RESOURCES IS
ALREADY VERY CLEAR THAT EVEN IN
THE EVENT THAT WE ARE ABLE TO
GET YOUR SUPPORT IN THIS BILL
PASSES.
YOU'RE STILL GOING TO NEED TO BE
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES COMING FROM
THE COUNTY AND THE CITY TO
ACTUALLY MAKE DEVELOPMENT HAPPEN.
SO TO THE DEGREE THAT BOTH THE
COUNTY AND THE CITY CAN LOWER
THE ACQUISITION THE AMOUNT OF
FUNDS THAT THEY HAVE TO PUT UP
FRONT NOW TO ASSEMBLE THE
PROPERTY.
KNOWING THAT ON THE BACK AND
THEY'RE GOING HOW TO PROVIDE DE.
SUBSIDIES ALMOST EIGHTY THOUSAND
DOLLARS PER UNIT BUT TO MAKE
THAT A REALITY.
APPLE IT IT IT'S WORTH THREE
MILLION DOLLARS YOU WANT TO PAY
TWO MILLION [inaudible]
AND YOU GO TO THE COUNTY SEAT
WILL PAY OF THREE MILLION BUT IN
YOUR BUDGET YOU.
YOU YOU GIVE US A GRANT OF A
MILLION SO THAT THE IN A DAY
WERE STILL ONLY PAYING TWO
MILLION.
WELL AYE WHY WHY WHY WHY CAN'T
IT.
IS AND THAT AND THAT LIKE IT'S
SIMPLER CLEANER.
WAIT TO DO IT INSTEAD OF GOING
TO THIS ROOM.
AND ASKING SENATORS TO HELP OUT
I'M.
WELL I DIDN'T.
THAT'S ONE WAY OF SOLVING ONE
PORTION OF THE PROBLEM WHICH
ACTUALLY ALLOWS THE OF THE
PROPERTY BE TRANSFERRED BUT
WHILE WE'RE HERE IS BECAUSE IT
WAS LEGISLATION THAT CREATED THE
SITUATION.
AND SO THE THE THINKING WAS THAT
LEGISLATION WAS NEEDED TO
RESOLVE IT COMPLETELY SOLD OUT
WHATEVER RESOURCES BOTH THE CITY
AND THE COUNTY HAVE COULD BE
SPENT TOWARDS MAKING AFFORDABLE
HOUSING AS OPPOSED. TO PAYING
EACH OTHER MARKET RATE --
PRICES FOR LAND THAT VAN IS
GOING TO BE PUT ON THEM OFFER TO
A DEVELOPER FOR MUCH LOWER
AROUND UNTIL DOUBTS THE REASON
WHY.
THE THINKING WAS THAT WE WOULD
NEED TO HAVE LEGISLATION.
BOB IMMIGRANT GROUP WHERE
PATRIOTISM IS OUR DIRECTOR THING
WHEN ANYA TURNED RIGHT OVER TO
US IN A MORE LIKE I THINK CENTER
PAINS ONE AND ALSO --
HELP ASSIST AN INTERNIST AS WELL.
BUT OSES AT OUR THIS WHEN --
AND NOW WE ARE HERE.
WITH A LEGISLATIVE REMEDY.
ON WHAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE IS A
BLIGHTED LOT --
THAT THAT COULD BE USED FOR
AFFORDABLE HOUSING DURING THIS
CRISIS.
I HAVING WHICH I THINK IS
CONVENIENT IN INNOVATIVE HAD IN
THIS JOINT AGENCY.
A ALLOWING THE CITY'S SACRAMENTO
BEE A BIG GET MOVING ON THIS.
NOT HAVE TO ENCUMBER THOSE COSTS
OF THE DIRT WHICH WE KNOW IS A
CHALLENGE WHEN IT COMES TO
DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING --
WHICH WOULD THEN ALLOW THE CITY
SACRAMENTO NOW TO FIND THE MOVE
ON GETTING RID OF THE HOTEL
WHICH WE HAVE SIGNIFICANT CHECK
OUT THE OLD HOTEL WHICH IS
SIGNIFICANT CHALLENGES WITH LONG
ABADONED --
AND WILL FINALLY ALLOW THIS
DEVELOPMENT TO BE ABLE TO
PROCEED CENTER PAN.
AND AND I HOPE THAT APPRECIATE
US SIR MORE LAKSA.
QUESTION I GUESS I JUST MAKE
NOTE THAT --
THAT AND ONE LEVEL WHAT THIS
WOULD REQUIRE IF WE WERE TRYING
TO DO --
WHAT'S BEING SUGGESTED IS THAT
THAT MEANS THAT THE BOTH THE
CITY AND THE COUNTY.
ESSENTIALLY WOULD HAVE TO HAVE.
I GUESS I'M A CALL ACCESS BUT
YOU KNOW.
FUNDS BASICALLY BE TRANSFERRING
AROUND AND YELLED AT GIMME DOT
DID SURVIVE AND COUNTY
GOVERNMENT I KNOW AND NO SIMPLE
MORE LIKE HAS.
YEAH -- YEAH
SOMETIMES YEAH YOU HAVE KID TO
CERTAIN THINGS RATE DESIGNATED
AND THEN WHAT HAPPENS NOW YOU
GOTTA FIND SOME MONEY THAT
SERVED SO YOU CAN JUST IT MEANS
THAT IN SOME SENSES IT MAY JUST
BE ON PAPER BUT YEAH I THINK I
THINK THAT TO CREATE A CREATES
CERTAIN.
BARRIERS AND AND AND AND AND
CONFUSION --
AT AT AND IN TERMS OF HOW YOU'D
YOU'D HAVE TO TRANSFER THE MONEY
BACK IN FORCE AND AND DID END OF
BLASTING WE WANT TO HAVE HAPPEN
IS IS THAT.
AT ME IS TO CREATE ANY SENSE
THAT THIS REALLY SETTLE WHAT'S
BECAUSE EVENTUALLY GO DEVELOPER
YOU WANNA SAY THAT LOOK YOU KNOW
UNTITLED SAID ARE THERE IT'S ONE
PIECE YOU'RE NOT GOING TO GET
CAUGHT UP BECAUSE OF THERE'S ONE
PIECE HERE AND THAT SO THAT. TO
AND THAT'S WHAT THE CITY NEEDS
TO DO IS ACTUALLY UNIFY ALL
THESE PROPERTIES RIGHT BECAUSE
IT IS ONE BIG ONE HERE THAT HAS
TO COUNT.
THAN THE BUT OTHER ONES ARE
OWNED BY THE CITY AND THEY ALL
NEED TO COME TOGETHER SO --
WE DIE CREE SITUATION WHERE --
YOU KNOW THERE'S WELL THE COUNTY
KIND OF THERE'S THIS TRANSFER
NOW WHO LEARNED MONEY AND
THERE'S SOME QUESTION ABOUT WELL
WHICH MONEY DO WE TAKE THAT
BORROW THEY GIVE BACK AND SO
FORTH AND I THINK --
IT WAS CERTAINLY I THINK THAT --
I THINK THIS IS A MORE STRAIGHT
FOR SOLUTION WE HAD TO DO IT
WITH THE TALK OF THE PART OF
FINANCE THERE SO ALL THE
DIFFERENT PARTIES HAVE SIGNED
OFF ON SAYING LOOK LET'S MAKE
THIS THE PREFERRED SOLUTION TO
MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT.
SELF SO CERTAINLY I GUESS
THERE'S PERHAPS ALTERNATE WAYS
TO DO IT BUT THIS IS AND THIS IS
WHY THIS BILLS BEFORE YOU TODAY
YOU KNOW MISTER CHAIR.
SENATOR PAN I'M I'M STILL NOT
GETTING THE WHY BECAUSE I'VE GOT
FOUR HUNDRED EIGHTY ONE MORE
CITIES.
AT FIFTY SEVEN OTHER COUNTIES
AND IF WE HAVE TO FORCE THEM TO
DO A BILL. TO DO TRANSACTIONS OF
THIS NATURE THAT JUST SEEMS A
LITTLE OWNERS I'M.
SO SO I I GUESS I'M SAYING IT
YOU KNOW APART.
I'M BLIND TO THE PROPERTY OF
JUST LOOKING.
AT THAT THIRTY THOUSAND FOOT
LEVEL COMING HAVE IT BUT IF IF
IF CITY SAYS THE COUNTY WILL PAY
YOU. THREE MILLION WHICH IS THE
FAIR MARKET VALUE AND THEN YOU.
GIVE US A GRANT OF ONE MILLION.
THEN YOUR NET IS TWO MILLION AS
OPPOSED TO YOU PAYING TWO
MILLION CATCH IT SO IT'S NOT A
CASH FLOW ISSUE IT'S JUST.
WELL YOU HAVE FOR IT'S IT'S SORT
LIKE A DOUBLE ESCROW IT'S JUST
WHAT DONE.
COMMONLY AND AND IN THE PRIVATE
ARTS I'M.
I'M TRYING TO SIGNATURE WITH
WITH THAT MAKE THIS SIMPLER FOR
THE CITY AND THE COUNTY LIKE
THIS BUT THE WAY THE CITY AND
COUNTY AND THE STATE GOVERNMENT
WHICH OF COURSE IMPOSE RULES
WHEN.
HAVE AGREED TO IS THIS MECHANISM
SO I I I I SO.
SO WHILE THERE MAY BE OTHER
OPTIONS THIS IS THE MECHANISM
THAT EVERYONE'S AGREED TO SPUR
FOR IT MECHANISM. TO TRY TO
ACHIEVE STUDY AIMS IMPROVING
FORMAL HOUSING AND CERTAINLY
THAT IS A DISTRICT BILL AND
THAT'S THE SOLUTION THAT WAS
COME UP WITH.
A WITH THE STATE AND THE CITY
AND THE COUNTY AND I WOULD
APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT FOR THIS
EFFORT IN MY DISTRICT TO BE SURE
WE CAN TRY TO SERVE THE PEOPLE
MY DISTRICT WITH NO COST TO THE
STATE.
BIGGEST INNER PAIN.
QUICKLY FOR IT SO RIGHT WITH THE
SENATE OVER AND ESTABLISH A
QUORUM MISLIM CHESTER.
MCGUIRE HERE.
CHOIR PRESIDENT [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ PRESIDENT.
I UN WIN.
WIN PRESENT MORLOCK.
MORE LIKE PRESIDENT.
THE BEST THINK YOU DO HAVE A
MOTION ON THE FLOOR WOULD LIKE.
ANY OTHER ITEMS THAT HE THAT
BEARD TO ADVANCE.
REALLY.
TAPE MISTER CHAIR SO I NO I I I
I THINK THIS IS AN AWKWARD.
APPROACH TO DEALING WITH A
SIMPLE PROBLEM.
AND I DON'T.
I THINK THE I RECEIVED A LOT OF
ACTIVITY GOING ON TO GET TO THE
SOLUTION.
AND SO I RESPECT THAT I JUST.
I'M JUST SAYING HURT BY WHAT
WE'VE GOT TO MAKE THIS A LITTLE
EASIER.
FOR BUT WHEN LA COUNTY EN EL IN
THE CITY OF LA ONE A DO A
TRANSACTION AFTER SOME MILLIONS
WOULD.
IT'S IT'S GOT TO BE A LITTLE.
WE WE'VE WITH THE CUSTOMER
SERVICE YOUR NEEDS TO BE
IMPROVED THAT'S ALL I'M SAYING
DON'T THINK IN CENTER MADAM VICE
CHAIR.
AYE AYES WOMAN COMING ICE ONE
THING AND THE SENATOR PAN FOR
BRING AFFORD I NORMALLY WON'T BE
SUPPORTING THIS BILL BUT I
UNDERSTANDIT IS A DISTRICT BILL
YOU'VE WORKED VERY HARD.
ON IT AND I AM I WOULD BE.
YOU KNOW NOT THE PERSON TO BE AN
EXPERT IN SACRAMENTO AREAS.
BUT YOU ARE AND SO I WILL
SUPPORT IT TODAY ON AND AND AND
YOU KNOW IF THERE'S ANYTHING
ELSE WE COULD DO IN TERMS OF
HELPING YOUR DISHES LETTERS NOW
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE HAVE A
MOTION BY SENATE HERNANDEZ AND
UP PURSUING --
TO RULE TWENTY NINETEEN THIS IS
WHY WE'RE HERE IN THE BILL TODAY
HUNGER TO HAVE EYES IN EUROPEAN
PROVIDE A CLOSE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AGAIN I THAT
I THINK EACH OF US IS REPRESENTS
AROUND SENATE DISTRICTS I TRIED
TO HELP WORK WITH ARE LOCALS TO
TRY TO SOLVE PROBLEMS SOMETIMES
THEY ASK US.
TO YEAH BUT IT'S CARRY
LEGISLATION OTHER TYPES OF
ACTIVITIES --
CERTAINLY I HOPE I THINK THAT I
TRY TO WORK WITH ALL OF YOU THAT
IS INDIA FREAKED OUT SUPPORT
THINGS IN YOUR INDIVIDUAL
DISTRICTS I APPRECIATE THE SAME
COURTESY.
EXPECT WE ASK WHEN I DON'T THINK
IT'S TOO MUCH OF A CENTER FOR
ALL YOUR WORK ON THIS I KNOW
THIS IS BEEN -
LONG ROAD BACK TO BE A TO GET
WHERE YOU'RE.
SINCE MR KATZMAN THANK YOU SO
MUCH FOR ALL OF YOUR WORK AS
WELL PARTNERSHIP MISTER DIRECTOR
ALWAYS GOOD TO HAVE YOU HERE I
IN COMMITTEE THANK YOU ALL FOR
THE TEAM WORK ON THIS.
CUT THIS EMOTION IS RETURN THE
BILL TO THE SENATE FLOOR FOR
CONSIDERATION OF THE BILL AS
AMENDED IN THE ASSEMBLY.
A MOTION BY SENATE HERNANDEZ
MISSING CHESTER BROKE UP PLEASE
REQUIRE HIGH WIRE I WIN.
WIN AYE BELL HERNANDEZ.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG LARA
MORE LOCK. THREE ZERO THREE
EIGHT ZERO OVER AND KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN AND AND SENATOR WE
WILL ADD ON AS FOLKS COMING
THANK YOU SO MUCH THINKING
SKILLS BEEN VERY MUCH.
THAT IS A GERMAN WERE NOW BENIGN
TO OUR FINAL ITEM THIS IS S. R. --
ONE THIRTEEN THIS IS NOT CENTER
GAINES --
BUT WE DO HAVE THE VICE CHAIR
THE VICE CHAIR IS READY TO ROLL --
IN REGARDS --
TO CENTER RESOLUTION ONE
THIRTEEN PRESSURE NGUYEN KNOW
THAT YOU HAVE A BUSY DAY IN A
LOT OF FOLKS IN APPROACH AS I AS
I AM AFTER YOU.
OKAY THANK THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN I'D BUY THE NASTY
PRESENT ON BEHALF OF SENATOR TED
GAINES --
FOR S. R. ONE ONE THREE UP THERE --
AM I JUST READ HIS STATEMENT FOR
FOR THE COMMITTEE THERE CAN BE
NO DENYING THAT PROP THIRTEEN
HAS LED TO PROPERTY TAX THE
ABILITY FOR ALL PROPERTY OWNERS
WHILE AT THE SAME TIME
INCREASING.
PROBABLY TAX AND REVENUE
HOMEOWNERS NOW KNOW WHEN THE
WHEN THEY BUY THEIR HOME JUST
HOW MUCH THEY WILL BE PAY
IMPROPER TAXES OVER. FIVE TWENTY
OR FORTY YEARS AND LOW REVENUE
THEY WILL BE BRINGING IN.
THE FACTS BEAR.
THIS OUT WHICH EXPLAINS WHY PROP
THIRTEEN X. CONTINUES TO
MAINTAIN A 60% APPROVAL RATING --
AMONG --
CALIFORNIANS THROUGH --
THE PUBLIC POLICY INSTITUTE OF
CALIFORNIA PP I SEE. FOR EXAMPLE
IN THE FORTY YEARS FOLLOWING THE
PASSAGE OF PROP THIRTEEN A
FAMILY WHO HAS OWNED THEIR HOME
TEN YEARS HAS SIR SAVE AN
AVERAGE OF SIXTY THOUSAND
DOLLARS.
AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT HAVE SEEN A
NEARLY FORTY BILLION DOLLARS
INCREASE IN REVENUE SINCE
NINETEEN SEVENTY EIGHT PROP
THIRTEEN IS ENTITLED TO BE A
WELL DESERVED FORTIETH.
ANNIVERSARY CELEBRATION HERE
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
SUPPORT OF SR ONE ONE THREE IS
DAY WERE FROM HOWEVER JOBS
TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION BIGGEST A
MUCH BETTER VICE CHAIR WE LOVE
IT FOR MR WOLF IS HERE AT RAINY
MISERABLE TWICE YESTERDAY --
INTO IT WAS GOOD TO SEE HIM MISS
WHAT IT'S GOOD TO SEE BACK IN
COMMITTEE MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS IT'S ALWAYS GOOD TO BE
HERE IS AS YOU GUYS ALL KNOW --
GOOD MORNING DAVID WOLFE THE
HOWARD JARVIS TAXPAYERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF THIS
RESOLUTION.
I THOUGHT MEMBERS AND JUST START
BY PROVIDING A LITTLE HISTORY IF
I MY IN ORDER TO UNDERSTAND THE
VALUE PROPOSITION THIRTEEN
REALLY HAVE TO UNDERSTAND OUR
PROPERTY TAXES WORK PRIOR.
TO NINETEEN SEVENTY EIGHT BACK
THEN THE TAX RATE WAS 3% AND IT
WASN'T UNCOMMON FOR PROPERTY
TAXES TO DOUBLE IN ANY GIVEN
YEAR BECAUSE PROPERTY AXES WERE
BASED.
ON A PROPERTIES HIGHEST AND BEST
USE THE FISCAL IMPLICATIONS
ESPECIALLY FOR SENIORS AND THOSE
ON FIXED INCOMES WERE
DEVASTATING --
SO MANY INDIVIDUALS BACK IN THE
NINETEEN SEVENTIES HAD PAID OFF
THEIR MORTGAGES --
AND YOU KNOW WE'RE TIRED OF PAID
OFF THEIR MORTGAGES BUT THEY
COULDN'T FOR THE PROPERTY TAXES
FOR THE PROPERTIES WERE
FORECLOSED ON THERE'S A HUGE
PROBLEM BACK IN NINETEEN SEVENTY
EIGHT DD INFLATION.
THE PROPOSITION THIRTEEN HELP TO
CAP.
NOW IT'S IMPORTANT TO KNOW THAT
IT'S NOT JUST SENIORS THE
BENEFIT FROM PROP THIRTEEN
EVERYBODY DOES IN CASE IN POINT
MILLENNIALS EVEN LIKE MYSELF.
MEMBERS I'VE OWNED A HOME FOR
FIVE YEARS.
AND YOU KNOW GRAN THEM PAYING
FAR MORE PROPERTY TAXES THAN MY
NEIGHBOR DOWN THE STREET WHO'S
LIVED IN HER HOUSE FOR FORTY
EIGHT YEARS SO YOU WOULD THINK I
WOULD BE MAKING THE POINT THE
PROP THIRTEEN ITS ACQUISITION
VALUE BASED SYSTEM IS NOT FAIR.
BUT OF COURSE I DON'T MAKE THAT
ARGUMENT BECAUSE I KNOW IT'S
ENTIRELY FAIR AND THE UNITED
STATES SUPREME COURT ACTUALLY
BACKED OUT UP IN A CASE CALLED
NORDLINGER VERSUS HIGH AND WHERE
THEY SAID YOU KNOW MUCH AS
SENATOR WAYNE JUST MENTION.
THAT BECAUSE YOU KNOW WHAT YOUR
PROPERTY TAXES I MEAN THIRTY
YEARS DOWN THE LINE IT'S
INHERENTLY FAIR IF THIS PROPERTY
TAXES ARE GONNA BE TOO MUCH.
DON'T BY THE HOUSE AND IT'S THAT
STABILITY THAT.
WHEN WHY I THINK PROP THIRTEEN
REMAINS SO POPULAR AND
SUCCESSFUL OVER FORTY YEARS WITH
60% SUPPORT IS PRECISELY BECAUSE
OF THE STABILITY?
NOT JEST FOR HOMEOWNERS --
BUT ALSO FOR COMMERCIAL PROPERTY
OWNERS AND OBVIOUSLY FOR
APARTMENT OWNERS AS WELL MEMBERS
A SUPPORT ROLE INITIATIVE FOR
THE TWENTY TWENTY BALLOT.
JUST QUALIFIED THIS IS GOING TO
PUT --
APARTMENT OWNERS AND TENANTS IN
PARTICULAR IN A WORLD OF HURT IT
WILL INCREASE RENTS IF IT PASSES --
AND SO AGAIN THAT WOULD JUST BE
A FURTHER ARGUMENT OF PROP
THIRTEEN STABILITY NOT JUST FOR
HOMEOWNERS NOT JUST FOR SENIORS
NOT JUST FROM ONE MALES BUT
EVERYONE I DO THINK THAT'S WERE
CELEBRATING AND ASK FOR AN AYE
VOTE ON THE ROSA.
THANK YOU SO MUCH MR WOLF WOULD
LIKE TO INVITE ANYONE ELSE WOULD
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THIS
BILL IF YOU COULD PLEASE ADVANCE
IN THIS TIME FIRST AND LAST NAME
AN ORGANIZATION DOESN'T SUPPORT.
BUT SCOTT FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT.
WE NOW LIKE THEY'RE INVITE
ANYONE WHO MAY BE OPPOSED TO
THIS RESOLUTION --
I SAID BILL IT SHOULD BE
RESOLUTION TO PLEASE ADVANCE AT
THIS TIME ANYONE WHO ARE WHO MAY
BE OPPOSED [inaudible]
LAST CALL. TO BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE INSIPID ANY QUESTIONS
OR COMMENTS THERMAL LOCK.
MISTER CHAIR I THE MOON WHO.
ON THE FLIPSIDE IS A FORMER
SUPERVISOR --
PROPERTY TAXES CERTAINLY BECAME.
THAT THE DOMINANT REVENUE SOURCE
FOR ORANGE COUNTY.
ESPECIALLY AFTER GOVERNOR
SCHWARZENEGGER.
DID THE TRIPLE FLIP BACK IN TWO
THOUSAND FOUR WE LOST SALES TAX
AND VEHICLE LICENSE FEE REVENUES
SURGED 492% OF OUR REVENUES AT
THE COUNTY WHERE WILL.
ARE OUR PROPERTY TAXES.
BUT IT BECAUSE IT IT HAS BEEN
STABLE EVEN THROUGH A RECESSION
BABY LEVEL BIT BUT NOW WE'RE
STILL SEEING.
YOU KNOW A PREDICTABLE REVENUE
SOURCE WHICH IS.
A REAL COMFORT.
AT THE COUNTY LEVEL WE DON'T
HAVE THAT KIND OF PREDICTABILITY
AT THAT AT ANY RATE STATE LEVEL.
SO -- THE
ONLY QUESTION I WOULD HAVE IS
MAYBE FOR MISTER WOLF EYES SINCE
YOU JUST BOUGHT YOUR HOME FIVE
YEARS AGO.
IS THAT A LOT OF PEOPLE THAT.
YOU KNOW BY NOW --
YOU KNOW HAVE A HIGHER.
UP PROP.
ALL TIME HIGHS AGAIN --
Y..
WHY HAS PROP THIRTEEN NOT?
COOL BUT DOWN OUR HOUSING MARKET
IN CALIFORNIA YOU.
YOU MIGHT THINK IT WOULD BE A
NEGATIVE BUT IT IT DOESN'T SEEM.
FROM MY VANTAGE POINT THAT IT'S
BEEN HURTING THE SALE OF HOMES
[inaudible]
WHEN?
SENATE ROTH NO I DON'T THINK
IT'S BEEN HURTING THE SALE OF
HOMES AT ALL IN FACT LIKE I SAID
I DO THINK IT PROVIDES.
THAT STABILITY --
YOU KNOW I WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN
ABLE TO PURCHASE MY HOME AT AGE
THIRTY WITHOUT PROPOSITION
THIRTEEN YOU KNOW I WAS ABLE TO
STRETCH AND EXTEND A LITTLE BIT.
IN THE PURCHASE PRICE AND THE
PRICE THAT I MADE BECAUSE I KNEW
PROP THIRTEEN WAS THERE.
AND I KNEW THAT THAT PROPERTY
TAX IS GOING TO BE STABLE AS I
PUT MY BUDGET TOGETHER.
YOU KNOW AND THE REALTORS KNOW
THAT TILL I'M IN THE REALTORS
ARGUE BOYER ARE BEST FRIENDS IN
CONTINUNG TO GET.
YOU KNOW THE KNOWLEDGE OF PROP
THIRTEEN OUT TO INDIVIDUALS
BECAUSE THEY HELP THE PEOPLE
BUDGET AND PROP THIRTEEN IS A
HUGE HUGE PART OF THAT.
AND SO YEAH HOME PRICES CONTINUE-TO GO UP --
BUT YOU KNOW MORE NIELSEN OTHERS
YOU BUY HOMES TODAY ARE STILL
ABLE TO BENEFIT I THINK BECAUSE
THAT AND JUST TO SPEAK TO THE
POINT THAT YOU MADE REGARDING.
MUNICIPAL FINANCE WE KNOW THAT
70% OF THE REVENUE MUNICIPALITY
BRINGS IN EVERY YEAR COMES FROM
PROPERTY AND SALES TAXES ROUGHLY
SALES TAX IS VERY VOLATILE
OBVIOUSLY SPIKE UP AND DOWN.
WITH THE UPS AND DOWNS ECONOMY
SO THAT DOES MAKE PROPERTY TAX
IS VERY IMPORTANT.
ONLY YEAR IN THE LAST FOUR YEAR
RECESSION WHERE THIS STATEWIDE
PROPERTY TAX ASSESSMENT ROLL
SIGN OVERALL DECREASE WHICH TWO
THOUSAND EIGHT IN 200-092-00010.
TWO THOUSAND ELEVEN THE OVERALL
PROPERTY TAX ROLE IN THE STATE
WENT UP OBVIOUSLY TOOK
INDIVIDUAL COUNTIES IN SOME
CASES ARE A BIT LONGER TO
RECOVER.
BUT I DOT DOES SPEAK TO THE
VALUE OF PROP THIRTEEN CAP.
THERE IS NOT A LOCAL GOVERNMENT
IN SHOULD NOT BE THANKING AND
PRAISING PROPOSITION THIRTEEN
FOR PROVIDING STABLE SOURCES OF
REVENUE IN THE MIDST OF AN
ECONOMIC DOWNTURN BECAUSE WE
STILL HAVEN'T SOLVED.
AS YOU KNOW MISTER CHAIRMAN THE
BOOM AND BUST ECONOMIC CYCLES IN
THE STATE.
AND PROP THIRTEEN IS ONE OF THE
WAYS THAT --
YOU KNOW UNTIL WE HAVE A FIX FOR
THAT KEEPS EVERYTHING STABLE SO.
KIM MISTER OF ALL OF THE BILL
EGGS WHICH WE'VE MOTION FOR BY
CENTER MORE LUCK WITH A GOOD
LOOK I HAVE A FEW COMMENTS.
I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE YOUR
CLOTHES BEFORE I MAKE COMMENTS
OR RESPECTFULLY ASKS FOR NIVEAU
DON'T THINK IS A MUCH AMEND
INVESTOR AND I WERE SITTING HERE
THE VICE CHAIR FOR A STEP IN AND
GET A PRESENTED I THINK SO MUCH
WONDERFUL JOB IS ALWAYS.
AND WHAT I WOULD HOPE I IS AS WE
LOOK.
THIS COMMITTEE IS GOING TO SEE
THIS RESOLUTION EVERY YEAR.
ARM AND GRATEFUL FOR THAT UP
WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO BE A TO DO
WE START EARLIER --
IN FIGURE OUT IF THERE'S AN
ABILITY I TO BE ABLE TO COME TO
SOME CONSENSUS ON THE RESOLUTION --
LOOK I THINK THAT --
THIS RESOLUTION.
DOES SPEAK TO A MONUMENTAL
CHANGE -- OF
THE FISCAL POLICY THAT WE HAVE
HERE IN CITY CALIFORNIA BUT AND
BY ALSO BELIEVE AS MISTER WOLF
IN THE VICE CHAIR HAS TALKED
ABOUT IT'S VERY APPROPRIATE.
OUGHT TO RECOGNIZE AND
MEMORIALIZE A PROP.
THIRTEEN BUT I'M IN IT HAS
PROVIDED BENEFITS ABSOLUTELY IS
PROVIDED BENEFITS --
TO EACH HOMEOWNER IN THIS STATE --
IN LIKE THAT MR BOTH --
MY WIFE AND I STRUGGLE TO BE
ABLE TO BUY OUR HOME IN THE
COMMUNITY LIVIN.
ON AND WE SEE THE BENEFIT.
AND WITH EVERYTHING WITH EVERY
PROPOSITION --
AND MANY ISSUES THAT WE DEAL
WITH --
THERE ARE SOME CHALLENGES AS
WELL.
I AND EVERY YEAR WE GO THROUGH
THIS DANCE OF THE RESOLUTION
BEING ADVANCED WE OFFERING THE
MEN WE OFFER AMENDMENTS --
IN VERY COMMONSENSE AMENDMENTS
AND I DO WANT TO SAY THANK YOU
TO CENTER GAINES CONSIDER GAINES
DID.
TAKE SOME --
AMENDMENTS IN VERY VERY GRATEFUL
AND BUT WHAT I WOULD HOPE IS.
AND THERE ARE SOME CHALLENGES
WITH PROP THIRTEEN ON AND THAT
WE RECOGNIZE AND CELEBRATE.
THE BENEFIT THAT HOMEOWNERS ARE
HAVING AND IN A BALANCED
APPROACH ALSO TALK ABOUT THERE
ARE SOME CHALLENGES AS WELL AND
WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO THROW OUT
TWO DAYS.
HOW WE CAN GET UPSTREAM ON THIS
THING FOR THAT WERE NOT HERE
AGAIN NEXT YEAR?
ON HAVING WHAT I WOULD MOST
LIKELY THINK MAY BE A PARTISAN --
VOTE ARE AND HOW WE CAN WORK
TOGETHER TO BE ABLE TO BRING --
BOTH SIDES TOGETHER AND THAT'S
FOR US AS WELL AS WHOEVER WILL
BRING FOR THAT RESOLUTION IS ONE
TO SAY THAT HERE TODAY --
IS WELL BECAUSE WE WE OFFER SOME
AMENDMENTS AMENDMENTS THAT WERE
NOT ACCEPTED I GET IT.
ON AND WHAT CAN WE DO TO BETTER
WORK TOGETHER FOR NEXT YEAR.
SO WITH THAT WE HAVE --
THE MOTION THAT BY SENATOR MORE
LOCK ON SR ONE THIRTEEN A IN
AGAIN THANK YOU SO MUCH OF THE
VICE CHAIR THINKING MISTER WOLF.
A CHAIR WILL NOT BE SUPPORTING
THE RESOLUTION HERE TODAY OUT
ROLL CALL PLEASE MISS MANCHESTER
IN THIS IT IS DEAD TO BE --
TO TO BE ADOPTED THAT'S OUR
MOTION.
REQUIRE NO REQUIRED NO WIN.
FIVE I FELL.
BILL NO HERNANDEZ.
HERTZBERG LARA KNOW LORD NO.
MORE LOT.
MORE LIKE I OKAY THAT CURRENTLY
IS A TWO THREE WE'RE GONNA KEEP
THAT ROLE OPEN AND HAVE FOLKS AT
ON HERE IN.
A BIT I THINK YOU SO MUCH
MINIMIZE YOUR PC RECONSIDER ó
YES ABSOLUTELY GUY RECONSIDER
SHALL BE GRANTED IN GIN
MEGABYTES YOUR THANK YOU AND
POLICING CENTER GAINS AS WELL
FOR US YEAH I THINK YOU VERY
MUCH --
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA OPEN THE
ROLE JUST SOME QUICK
HOUSEKEEPING RIGHT NOW ROUGH
COUNT WE PROBABLY HAVE SIX BILLS
THAT MAYBE HITTING US NEXT WEEK --
OR THE WEEK AFTER SO WILL
PROBABLY BE HAVING HEARINGS OFF
THE FLOOR ON BILLS THAT WILL BE --
ADVANCE --
BOTH ON THE SENATE SIDE AS WELL
AS THE SIMPLY THINK HE CENTER
MORLOCK IS WELL SO WE'RE GONNA
OPEN UP THE ROLE OPEN UP THE
ROLE ON SP [inaudible]
FOUR EIGHTY ONE THANK YOU.
AS BEFORE ANYONE CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A THREE ZERO VOTE THE
MOTION WAS RETURNED THE BILL TO
THE SENATE FLOOR FOR
CONSIDERATION THE BILL AS
AMENDED IN THE ASSEMBLY.
CURRENT VOTE THREE ZERO CHAIR
VOTING AYE MISSING CHESTER WELL.
I HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA.
LARA AYE SIX SO.
SIX ZERO USING THE ROLE.
MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEMS NUMBER ONE SR ONE
THIRTEEN THE MOTION IS BE
ADOPTED.
CURRENT VOTE IS CHOOSE THREE
CHAIR VOTING NO MISS LANE
CHESTER [inaudible]
HERNANDEZ [inaudible]
LARA.
WHICH WAS WRITTEN A HUNDRED
TIMES [inaudible]
HERTZBERG.
OKAY PROMOTING CHO.
THAT'S WHAT WAS WRONG
[inaudible]
ARE HERTZBERG [inaudible]
PROBABLY.
YEAH THE FINAL VOTE IS TWO THREE
THE BILL FAILS --
IN RECONSIDERATION IS GRANTED.
WE'RE GOING TO BE A CLOSE IN THE
ROLE ON THAT.
WANT TO SAY THANK YOU SO MUCH TO
IN CENTER HERTZBERG AT FILE ITEM
THREE WAS AN AUTHOR PULL TODAY --
AND GOING BACK TO ITS ORIGINAL
FORM ON THE FLOOR.
AGAIN WILL HAVE SIX BILLS --
IT MAY BE LESS WILL FORGET
WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN.
TOMORROW I DO APPRECIATE IT AND
THANK YOU ALL I THINK IT IS THE
INCREDIBLE GOTTEN FIGHTING UP
FOR ALL THE WORK.
UNTIL NEXT TIME RETURNED