WEBVTT
00:00:11.077 --> 00:00:12.746
GOOD MORNING AT ITS STATE THIRTY
00:00:12.812 --> 00:00:13.613
LET'S I GET STARTED THE LIKE TO
00:00:13.680 --> 00:00:15.582
BRING THE WELCOME EVERYBODY TO
00:00:15.648 --> 00:00:17.784
THE SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL --
00:00:17.851 --> 00:00:19.052
CALL THE COMMITTEE I'M I'M CALL
00:00:19.119 --> 00:00:20.887
THE MEETING TO ORDER WILL PURSUE.
00:00:20.954 --> 00:00:22.689
SUBCOMMITTEE I KNOW THERE'S LOTS
00:00:22.756 --> 00:00:24.457
OF SIDEBAR CONVERSATIONS THAT
00:00:24.524 --> 00:00:27.694
ARE GOING ON TODAY WE HAVE FIFTY
00:00:27.761 --> 00:00:28.895
ITEM CENTER --
00:00:28.962 --> 00:00:31.431
BEFORE THE THE COMMITTEE THERE
00:00:31.498 --> 00:00:34.367
ARE TEN MATTERS AROUND CONSENT
00:00:34.434 --> 00:00:34.934
OF LIKE TO GO THROUGH THOSE
00:00:35.001 --> 00:00:37.737
SYMBOL WE I HAVE A QUORUM --
00:00:37.804 --> 00:00:39.038
THEM WILL --
00:00:39.105 --> 00:00:40.306
ACT ON THOSE MATTERS CAESAR ITEM
00:00:40.373 --> 00:00:43.777
NUMBER ELEVEN WHICH IS AB.
00:00:43.843 --> 00:00:44.811
NINETEEN THIRTY THREE ITEM
00:00:44.878 --> 00:00:46.012
FOURTEEN WHICH IS A BE.
00:00:46.079 --> 00:00:48.548
A TWO ZERO ZERO SIX ITEM
00:00:48.615 --> 00:00:51.618
NINETEEN WHICH IS AB TWO ZERO
00:00:51.684 --> 00:00:52.786
SEVEN THREE ITEM TWENTY ONE
00:00:52.852 --> 00:00:53.853
WHICH IS.
00:00:53.920 --> 00:00:56.956
TO AB TWO ONE TWO SEVEN ITEM
00:00:57.023 --> 00:00:59.325
TWENTY TWO WHICH IS AB TWO ONE
00:00:59.392 --> 00:01:02.328
FOUR FIVE ITEM TWENTY FIVE AB
00:01:02.395 --> 00:01:03.763
TWO TWO ONE ONE ITEM.
00:01:03.830 --> 00:01:06.666
THIRTY TWO AB.
00:01:06.733 --> 00:01:07.233
TWENTY FOUR FIFTY THREE ITEM
00:01:07.300 --> 00:01:11.371
FORTY FOUR AB TWO FIVE ITEM.
00:01:11.438 --> 00:01:14.040
FORTY EIGHT AB TWO EIGHT THREE
00:01:14.107 --> 00:01:16.309
TWO AN ITEM.
00:01:16.376 --> 00:01:20.079
FIFTY THREE AB. THREE ZERO ONE
00:01:20.146 --> 00:01:20.680
TWO THE FOUGHT THE FOLLOWING
00:01:20.747 --> 00:01:22.816
ITEMS HAVE BEEN REMOVED FROM.
00:01:22.882 --> 00:01:25.485
THE AGENDA ITEM NUMBER SEVEN BY
00:01:25.552 --> 00:01:27.120
ASSEMBLY --
00:01:27.187 --> 00:01:32.692
WOMAN CRISTINA GARCIA A. B. S..
00:01:32.759 --> 00:01:33.293
SIXTEEN THIRTY EIGHTEEN SIXTY
00:01:33.359 --> 00:01:34.461
THREE ITEM NUMBER TEN BY SOMEONE
00:01:34.527 --> 00:01:37.397
MEMBER OBERNOLTE AB NINETEEN A
00:01:37.464 --> 00:01:40.700
ONE ITEM NUMBER SIXTEEN AB TWO
00:01:40.767 --> 00:01:41.267
ZERO FIVE SEVEN BY ASSEMBLY
00:01:41.334 --> 00:01:42.669
MEMBER SALAS.
00:01:42.735 --> 00:01:45.505
ITEM NUMBER TWENTY SEVEN AB TWO
00:01:45.572 --> 00:01:46.072
THREE THREE SIX BY ASSEMBLY
00:01:46.139 --> 00:01:47.240
MEMBER SALAS.
00:01:47.307 --> 00:01:51.077
ITEM NUMBER FORTY AB TWENTY SIX
00:01:51.144 --> 00:01:52.212
THIRTY SIX BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:01:52.278 --> 00:01:53.713
AYE EDUARDO GARCIA.
00:01:53.780 --> 00:01:57.016
ITEM NUMBER FORTY ONE AB TWENTY
00:01:57.083 --> 00:01:57.817
SIX FORTY NINE BY ASSEMBLY
00:01:57.884 --> 00:01:58.351
MEMBER.
00:01:58.418 --> 00:02:01.154
ARAMBULA AND ITEM NUMBER FORTY
00:02:01.221 --> 00:02:01.754
TWO BY.
00:02:01.821 --> 00:02:08.228
A ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK --
00:02:08.294 --> 00:02:09.762
BEFORE WE'VE GOT CALLER FOR
00:02:09.829 --> 00:02:10.763
SPELLED.
00:02:10.830 --> 00:02:13.233
LET ME ACKNOWLEDGE THAT WE HAVE
00:02:13.299 --> 00:02:15.802
ABOUT A DOZEN SEQUEL RELATED --
00:02:15.869 --> 00:02:18.238
BILLS BEFORE US TODAY ARM.
00:02:18.304 --> 00:02:20.573
IN ANOTHER DAY AND ANOTHER YEAR
00:02:20.640 --> 00:02:21.140
IN WHICH WE HAVE A SLEW OF
00:02:21.207 --> 00:02:23.743
PROPOSED OUR BILLS BEFORE US.
00:02:23.810 --> 00:02:24.944
THAT A DESIGNED IN SOME WAY
00:02:25.011 --> 00:02:27.714
EITHER TO WEAKEN ALTER ALTER
00:02:27.780 --> 00:02:30.149
CIRCUMVENT OR SIMPLY DISREGARD
00:02:30.216 --> 00:02:31.217
TO CALIFORNIA FIRE MIDDLE
00:02:31.284 --> 00:02:32.652
QUALITY ACT.
00:02:32.719 --> 00:02:35.188
AND LET ME EMPHASIZE THIS IS.
00:02:35.255 --> 00:02:36.055
THE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
00:02:36.122 --> 00:02:37.390
COMMITTEE MRS CALIFORNIA'S
00:02:37.457 --> 00:02:39.492
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT.
00:02:39.559 --> 00:02:41.895
WHY HAVE BEEN OPEN --
00:02:41.961 --> 00:02:43.329
TO THE IDEA OF A SERIOUS WELL
00:02:43.396 --> 00:02:45.498
FOUGHT OUT REFORM OF ANY MEASURE
00:02:45.565 --> 00:02:47.200
THAT HAS BEEN ON THE BOOKS FOR
00:02:47.267 --> 00:02:48.668
ALMOST FIFTY YEARS I'M NOT
00:02:48.735 --> 00:02:50.870
INCLINED TO SUPPORT EFFORTS TO
00:02:50.937 --> 00:02:52.772
RENDER S MANY OFF RAMPS HOLES
00:02:52.839 --> 00:02:54.107
AND BY PASSES.
00:02:54.173 --> 00:02:55.909
AS TO RENDER WHAT IS PERHAPS THE
00:02:55.975 --> 00:02:57.844
MOST IMPORTANT SOURCE OF PUBLIC
00:02:57.911 --> 00:02:59.379
PARTICIPATION MODE.
00:02:59.445 --> 00:03:01.381
I FURTHER REFORMS MUST REFLECT
00:03:01.447 --> 00:03:03.349
ACTUAL AND REAL ISSUES.
00:03:03.416 --> 00:03:05.285
AND AT THE CRUX OF THIS.
00:03:05.351 --> 00:03:06.419
THAT IS ALL FOR ME WHAT SEQUENCE
00:03:06.486 --> 00:03:07.954
ABOUT.
00:03:08.021 --> 00:03:09.455
CRITICAL PORTAL FOR PUBLIC
00:03:09.522 --> 00:03:11.558
PARTICIPATION IN A PROJECT THAT
00:03:11.624 --> 00:03:13.159
MAY ADVERSELY AFFECT THE
00:03:13.226 --> 00:03:13.793
COMMUNITY WHETHER THE
00:03:13.860 --> 00:03:15.662
COMMUNITIES DISADVANTAGED RISK
00:03:15.728 --> 00:03:17.263
RICH OR WHATEVER.
00:03:17.330 --> 00:03:19.198
WITHOUT SEQUEL THAT COMMUNITIES
00:03:19.265 --> 00:03:21.134
VOICE MAY BE SILENCE.
00:03:21.200 --> 00:03:22.802
BILLS THAT PROVIDE EXEMPTIONS
00:03:22.869 --> 00:03:24.070
ARE LIMIT REVIEW.
00:03:24.137 --> 00:03:26.105
UNDER SEPA HURT NOT HELP THE
00:03:26.172 --> 00:03:27.073
COMMUNITIES IN WHICH THEY'RE
00:03:27.140 --> 00:03:28.942
BUILT AND THE DAMAGE CANNOT BE
00:03:29.008 --> 00:03:30.176
UNDONE.
00:03:30.243 --> 00:03:31.945
FINALLY LET REMIND THIS
00:03:32.011 --> 00:03:32.712
COMMITTEE.
00:03:32.779 --> 00:03:34.847
OF TWO IMPORTANT SENATE STUDIES
00:03:34.914 --> 00:03:36.583
RECENTLY UNDERTAKEN.
00:03:36.649 --> 00:03:38.618
THE FIRST WAS RELEASED BY THIS
00:03:38.685 --> 00:03:39.419
COMMITTEE.
00:03:39.485 --> 00:03:40.119
AT THE END OF LAST YEAR WHICH
00:03:40.186 --> 00:03:43.323
INVOLVED PROJECTS OVER FORTY
00:03:43.389 --> 00:03:45.024
SEVEN STATE AGENCIES.
00:03:45.091 --> 00:03:46.960
AGENCIES WE FOUND THAT LESS THAN
00:03:47.026 --> 00:03:49.662
1% OF MORE THAN FIFTEEN THOUSAND
00:03:49.729 --> 00:03:50.597
SEVEN HAD PROJECTS RESULTED IN
00:03:50.663 --> 00:03:52.632
SECRET LITIGATION.
00:03:52.699 --> 00:03:53.900
THE SECOND WAS CONDUCTED BY OUR
00:03:53.967 --> 00:03:55.568
SENATE OFFICE OF RESEARCH AND
00:03:55.635 --> 00:03:57.236
THEY EXAMINED SEQUEL AND
00:03:57.303 --> 00:03:59.272
CALTRANS ARE TRANSPORTATION
00:03:59.339 --> 00:04:00.673
PROJECTS COMPLETED OVER A THREE
00:04:00.740 --> 00:04:02.008
YEAR PERIOD.
00:04:02.075 --> 00:04:03.943
S. REPORT CONCLUDES AFTER
00:04:04.010 --> 00:04:05.645
CONSIDERING THE DATA IN ISSUES
00:04:05.712 --> 00:04:08.114
DISCUSS THIS REVIEW SUGGEST THAT
00:04:08.181 --> 00:04:09.215
SEQUEL DID NOT HAVE A
00:04:09.282 --> 00:04:10.783
SIGNIFICANT ADVERSE.
00:04:10.850 --> 00:04:11.918
AFFECT ON PROJECT DELIVERY
00:04:11.985 --> 00:04:12.885
OVERALL [inaudible]
00:04:12.952 --> 00:04:14.821
MEMBERS.
00:04:14.887 --> 00:04:16.889
I BELIEVE THAT SEPAL WORKS IT
00:04:16.956 --> 00:04:17.790
DOES NOT CONSTITUTE DELAYS AS
00:04:17.857 --> 00:04:19.892
MANY CLAIMS.
00:04:19.959 --> 00:04:21.361
AND I'M UNABLE TO SUPPORT A
00:04:21.427 --> 00:04:23.529
CONSTANCE DREAM OF EFFORTS TO
00:04:23.596 --> 00:04:25.698
WEAKEN OF THE POSITIVE IMPACT
00:04:25.765 --> 00:04:27.533
THAT THIS LEGISLATION LANDMARK
00:04:27.600 --> 00:04:28.635
LEGISLATION HAS ON OUR
00:04:28.701 --> 00:04:29.669
COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
00:04:29.736 --> 00:04:31.604
OF CALIFORNIA [inaudible]
00:04:31.671 --> 00:04:33.840
SO.
00:04:33.906 --> 00:04:36.843
WE HAVE A LONG AGENDA TODAY --
00:04:36.909 --> 00:04:39.078
I A AS FOLKS THAT ARE FAMILIAR
00:04:39.145 --> 00:04:40.913
WITH MY COMMITTEE I DON'T HAVE
00:04:40.980 --> 00:04:42.815
ANY LIMITATIONS ON TO INTO IN
00:04:42.882 --> 00:04:44.817
WITNESSES BUT I WILL STOP YOU
00:04:44.884 --> 00:04:46.686
MID SENTENCE IF YOU SIMPLY
00:04:46.753 --> 00:04:48.488
REPEAT WHAT'S ALREADY BEEN HEARD.
00:04:48.554 --> 00:04:50.456
WE'VE HAD A LOT OF OFF WE'VE HAD
00:04:50.523 --> 00:04:52.592
A LOT OF DISCUSSIONS YEAH SINCE
00:04:52.659 --> 00:04:54.727
THE STAFF REPORTS HAVE BEEN DONE
00:04:54.794 --> 00:04:56.062
ON SEVERAL BILLS SO.
00:04:56.129 --> 00:04:58.464
I'M WITNESSES THERE TESTIFYING
00:04:58.531 --> 00:05:00.299
SIMPLY YOU KNOW KEEP THAT IN
00:05:00.366 --> 00:05:02.301
MIND AND WITH THAT.
00:05:02.368 --> 00:05:04.170
LET'S BEGIN WE HAVE ASSEMBLY
00:05:04.237 --> 00:05:05.605
MEMBER GIPSON THIS IS FILE ITEM
00:05:05.672 --> 00:05:08.875
NUMBER ONE AB THREE TWO SEVEN
00:05:08.941 --> 00:05:09.909
THE SOUTH COAST AIR QUALITY
00:05:09.976 --> 00:05:10.877
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT FLEETS GOOD
00:05:10.943 --> 00:05:27.060
MORNING
00:05:40.373 --> 00:05:40.440
.
00:05:40.440 --> 00:05:41.274
I ORDER MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
00:05:41.340 --> 00:05:42.742
MEMBERS THANK YOU ALLOW ME TO
00:05:42.809 --> 00:05:45.645
PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY
00:05:45.712 --> 00:05:46.245
THREE TWENTY SEVEN WHICH SEEKS
00:05:46.312 --> 00:05:48.147
TO IMPROVE THE AIR QUALITY IN
00:05:48.214 --> 00:05:49.482
THE SOUTH COAST AIR QUALITY
00:05:49.549 --> 00:05:50.883
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT.
00:05:50.950 --> 00:05:53.252
SPIKE MAJOR PROGRESS OVER THE
00:05:53.319 --> 00:05:55.221
RECENT DECADE LOS ANGELES REGION
00:05:55.288 --> 00:05:55.988
STILL.
00:05:56.055 --> 00:05:58.324
HAS THE WORSE --
00:05:58.391 --> 00:06:01.661
SMALL IN THE COUNTRY IN TWO
00:06:01.728 --> 00:06:02.929
THOUSAND EIGHT THE U. S. EPA
00:06:02.995 --> 00:06:05.131
EXTRAPOLATION AN OZONE STANDARD
00:06:05.198 --> 00:06:07.633
THAT SET A BENCHMARK FOR AIR
00:06:07.700 --> 00:06:10.002
QUALITY ACROSS THE NATION.
00:06:10.069 --> 00:06:11.838
THROUGH THIS STANDARD THE AIR
00:06:11.904 --> 00:06:13.973
QUALITY THERE TO THE SOUTH COAST
00:06:14.040 --> 00:06:16.375
AIR BASIN I'M WHICH INCLUDE LOS
00:06:16.442 --> 00:06:17.710
ANGELES COUNTY.
00:06:17.777 --> 00:06:20.246
WAS DESIGNATED AS BEING EXTREME
00:06:20.313 --> 00:06:22.315
NON ATTAINMENT.
00:06:22.381 --> 00:06:24.317
THIS DEGREE OF NON ATTAINMENT
00:06:24.383 --> 00:06:27.453
REFLECTS HOW FAR AWAY THE REGION.
00:06:27.520 --> 00:06:29.422
IS FROM BEING ALIGNED WITH THE
00:06:29.489 --> 00:06:30.923
FEDERAL STANDARDS WHICH IS
00:06:30.990 --> 00:06:32.425
EXTREME ATTAINMENTS BEING THE
00:06:32.492 --> 00:06:33.993
WORST.
00:06:34.060 --> 00:06:35.928
AFTER THIS DESIGNATION THE BASIN
00:06:35.995 --> 00:06:40.333
WAS GIVEN UNTIL JULY TWENTIETH.
00:06:40.399 --> 00:06:40.933
TWENTY THIRTY TWO TO COME INTO
00:06:41.000 --> 00:06:42.635
COMPLIANCE.
00:06:42.702 --> 00:06:43.836
SINCE THE AIR SINCE THE SOUTH
00:06:43.903 --> 00:06:44.737
COAST AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT
00:06:44.804 --> 00:06:46.072
DISTRICT.
00:06:46.139 --> 00:06:47.807
A WHICH HAS JURISDICTION OVER
00:06:47.874 --> 00:06:50.710
THE BASIN HAS ADOPTED A PLAN TO
00:06:50.777 --> 00:06:53.079
COME INTO COMPLIANCE AS PART OF
00:06:53.146 --> 00:06:54.747
THAT PLAN THIS BILL SEEKS TO
00:06:54.814 --> 00:06:55.748
PROVIDE THE DISTRICT.
00:06:55.815 --> 00:06:57.550
WITH THE LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY
00:06:57.617 --> 00:07:00.353
TO REQUIRE THE OF PURCHASE OF
00:07:00.419 --> 00:07:02.021
THE NEAR.
00:07:02.088 --> 00:07:03.523
ZERO AND ZERO EMISSION VEHICLES
00:07:03.589 --> 00:07:05.191
WITH AND THE PUBLIC FLEET
00:07:05.258 --> 00:07:07.627
OPERATING IN A SOUTH COAST.
00:07:07.693 --> 00:07:09.629
I WANT TO BE VERY VERY CLEAR
00:07:09.695 --> 00:07:12.031
THIS BILL WOULD NOT DIRECTLY
00:07:12.098 --> 00:07:13.566
CREATE A RULE.
00:07:13.633 --> 00:07:15.735
IT WOULD SIMPLY AUTHORIZE THE
00:07:15.802 --> 00:07:17.503
DISTRICT TO GO THROUGH THE
00:07:17.570 --> 00:07:19.138
LENGTHY LOCAL RULE MAKING
00:07:19.205 --> 00:07:21.641
PROCESS ON THIS ISSUE WHICH
00:07:21.707 --> 00:07:24.110
WOULD INCLUDE --
00:07:24.177 --> 00:07:25.578
STAKEHOLDERS INPUT AND ALSO
00:07:25.645 --> 00:07:28.281
PUBLIC INPUT THIS WOULD
00:07:28.347 --> 00:07:29.615
ULTIMATELY BENEFIT THE AIR
00:07:29.682 --> 00:07:31.617
QUALITY AND THE PUBLIC HEALTH IN
00:07:31.684 --> 00:07:34.020
THE SOUTH COAST REGION TODAY
00:07:34.086 --> 00:07:35.721
WITH ME WE HAVE REPRESENTATIVES
00:07:35.788 --> 00:07:37.190
OF FROM THE SOUTH COAST AIR
00:07:37.256 --> 00:07:38.624
QUALITY MANAGEMENT WHO WAS SELF
00:07:38.691 --> 00:07:39.959
INTRODUCED THEMSELVES.
00:07:40.026 --> 00:07:42.061
WHO ARE HERE TO IN SUPPORT OF
00:07:42.128 --> 00:07:43.930
ASSEMBLY BILL THREE TWENTY SEVEN
00:07:43.996 --> 00:07:45.364
AND I PRESUME A?
00:07:45.431 --> 00:07:47.133
ASSEMBLY MEMBER THAT THE THIS
00:07:47.200 --> 00:07:48.701
SOUTH COAST IS GOING TO BE GIVEN --
00:07:48.768 --> 00:07:50.570
THE FLEXIBILITY OF GIVING.
00:07:50.636 --> 00:07:52.538
SEPARATION FOR THE USEFUL LIFE
00:07:52.605 --> 00:07:53.673
OF THE VEHICLE THAT THEY WOULD
00:07:53.739 --> 00:07:55.441
HAVE BECAUSE AS WE EXPERIENCE IN
00:07:55.508 --> 00:07:57.376
THE LAST RECESSION WE HAD.
00:07:57.443 --> 00:07:58.945
NOW OUR FLEETS THAT WE'RE GOING
00:07:59.011 --> 00:08:00.580
THERE WERE SAID LES MILES OR PUT
00:08:00.646 --> 00:08:01.214
IT BE PUT ON CARS AND THAT WOULD
00:08:01.280 --> 00:08:02.915
BE TAKEN IN INCINERATION I
00:08:02.982 --> 00:08:03.616
THOUGHT THAT AYE.
00:08:03.683 --> 00:08:05.051
ABSOLUTE CLEAN FROM THE BILL
00:08:05.117 --> 00:08:07.453
PLEASE FIRST WITNESS.
00:08:07.520 --> 00:08:08.888
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR AND
00:08:08.955 --> 00:08:10.223
COMMITTEE MEMBERS MY NAME IS OR
00:08:10.289 --> 00:08:11.424
ACTIVATION I'M A PLANNING IT WAS
00:08:11.490 --> 00:08:13.059
MANAGER WITH THE SOUTH COAST AIR
00:08:13.125 --> 00:08:15.261
QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT.
00:08:15.328 --> 00:08:16.863
IN CHARGE OF OUR FLEET RULES.
00:08:16.929 --> 00:08:18.231
OF THE SOUTH WAS A COUNTIES
00:08:18.297 --> 00:08:20.733
PLEASED TO SPONSOR AB
00:08:20.800 --> 00:08:21.033
[inaudible]
00:08:21.100 --> 00:08:23.669
THREE TWENTY SEVEN THIS BILL.
00:08:23.736 --> 00:08:25.371
GIVE US PART OF THE TWENTY
00:08:25.438 --> 00:08:26.706
SIXTEEN AIR QUALITY MANAGEMENT
00:08:26.772 --> 00:08:28.307
PLAN FOR THE SOUTH COAST REGION.
00:08:28.374 --> 00:08:30.009
THE SCA COUNTY GOVERNING BOARD
00:08:30.076 --> 00:08:31.611
DIRECTED STAFF TO SEEK
00:08:31.677 --> 00:08:36.182
LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITY --
00:08:36.249 --> 00:08:37.884
TO AUTHORIZES YOU CAN BE TO HAVE
00:08:37.950 --> 00:08:39.385
THE FLEXIBILITY TO REQUIRED TO
00:08:39.452 --> 00:08:41.187
ACCEPT A GOOD PURCHASE ANDUSE
00:08:41.254 --> 00:08:43.489
OF NEW ZERO ZERO MISSION HEAVY
00:08:43.556 --> 00:08:46.192
DUTY ON ROAD VEHICLES. FOR
00:08:46.259 --> 00:08:46.792
PUBLIC FLEETS WITHIN THE SOUTH
00:08:46.859 --> 00:08:49.762
BECAUSE THIS BILL IS IN LINE
00:08:49.829 --> 00:08:51.063
WITH THAT DIRECTIVE --
00:08:51.130 --> 00:08:52.198
DISABILITY AUTHORIZED OR
00:08:52.265 --> 00:08:53.933
GOVERNING BOARD TO ADOPT RULES
00:08:54.000 --> 00:08:55.001
THAT REQUIRE PUBLIC FLEET
00:08:55.067 --> 00:08:56.569
OPERATORS WE FIFTEEN OR MORE
00:08:56.636 --> 00:08:58.437
VEHICLES TO PURCHASE THE
00:08:58.504 --> 00:09:00.106
CLEANEST COMMERCIALLY.
00:09:00.172 --> 00:09:02.575
OF AVAILABLE VEHICLES AS DEFINED
00:09:02.642 --> 00:09:04.277
BY THE SCA CAN YOU BOARD.
00:09:04.343 --> 00:09:06.545
WHICH MEETS OPERATIONAL NEEDS OF
00:09:06.612 --> 00:09:07.813
THE FLEET OPERATORS.
00:09:07.880 --> 00:09:09.548
THE TERM COMMERCIAL CLEAN IS
00:09:09.615 --> 00:09:10.883
COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE ALLOWS
00:09:10.950 --> 00:09:12.585
FOR FLEXIBILITY IN TERMS OF COST
00:09:12.652 --> 00:09:14.320
EFFECTIVENESS AND TECHNOLOGICAL
00:09:14.387 --> 00:09:15.655
FEASIBILITY.
00:09:15.721 --> 00:09:17.323
AMONG OTHER FACTORS ALL TO BE
00:09:17.390 --> 00:09:18.491
TAKING INTO ACCOUNT DURING THE
00:09:18.557 --> 00:09:20.359
RULE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS.
00:09:20.426 --> 00:09:22.495
FURTHER NO MORE THAN 15% OF ANY
00:09:22.561 --> 00:09:23.763
PUBLICLY COULD BE REQUIRED TO BE
00:09:23.829 --> 00:09:25.531
REPLACED PER YEAR.
00:09:25.598 --> 00:09:27.233
WE DO CONSIDERATION GIVEN TO A
00:09:27.300 --> 00:09:27.800
VEHICLES USEFUL LIFE AS YOU
00:09:27.867 --> 00:09:30.636
MIGHT.
00:09:30.703 --> 00:09:32.238
FINANCIAL INCENTIVES WOULD BE
00:09:32.305 --> 00:09:34.140
AVAILABLE TO HELP MEET THIS
00:09:34.206 --> 00:09:35.875
BILLS REQUIREMENTS THIS INCLUDES
00:09:35.942 --> 00:09:37.276
CALM WAY PROGRAM FUNDING IN
00:09:37.343 --> 00:09:39.245
ADDITION TO OTHER INCENTIVE
00:09:39.312 --> 00:09:39.478
FUNDING.
00:09:39.545 --> 00:09:41.013
A SOURCES.
00:09:41.080 --> 00:09:42.248
IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT
00:09:42.315 --> 00:09:43.115
THIS BILL WOULD ONLY IMPACT
00:09:43.182 --> 00:09:44.917
PUBLIC FLEETS.
00:09:44.984 --> 00:09:46.285
AND FLEECE THAT ARE UNDER
00:09:46.352 --> 00:09:47.653
CONTRACT WITH CALIFORNIA PUBLIC
00:09:47.720 --> 00:09:49.855
AGENCIES.
00:09:49.922 --> 00:09:51.424
A DEBATE OVER WOULD FURTHER
00:09:51.490 --> 00:09:52.258
LIMIT.
00:09:52.325 --> 00:09:53.793
WITH FURTHER LIMITED DEFINITION
00:09:53.859 --> 00:09:55.027
OF THE COMMERCIAL FLEET TO
00:09:55.094 --> 00:09:56.929
SPECIFIED VEHICLE TYPES.
00:09:56.996 --> 00:09:58.764
ULTIMATELY THIS WILL BILL WOULD
00:09:58.831 --> 00:10:00.967
FACILITATE A LOCAL RULES THAT
00:10:01.033 --> 00:10:03.169
BENEFITS AIR QUALITY AND PUBLIC
00:10:03.235 --> 00:10:04.737
HEALTH IN THE SOUTH COAST REGION
00:10:04.804 --> 00:10:05.471
BY ELIMINATING CRITERIA
00:10:05.538 --> 00:10:07.173
POLLUTANT.
00:10:07.239 --> 00:10:08.441
AT TOXIC EMISSIONS FROM HEAVY
00:10:08.507 --> 00:10:10.509
DUTY VEHICLES.
00:10:10.576 --> 00:10:12.111
FURTHER PUBLICLY TURNOVER IS AN
00:10:12.178 --> 00:10:13.846
EFFECTIVE DEMONSTRATIVE METHOD
00:10:13.913 --> 00:10:15.314
FOR CREATING A MARKETPLACE AND
00:10:15.381 --> 00:10:17.750
ENCOURAGING LARGER SCALE
00:10:17.817 --> 00:10:19.318
DEPLOYMENT OF CLEANER VEHICLES.
00:10:19.385 --> 00:10:20.353
THANK YOU AND WE'RE HAPPY TO
00:10:20.419 --> 00:10:21.320
ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS A NEXT
00:10:21.387 --> 00:10:23.956
WITNESS.
00:10:24.023 --> 00:10:25.624
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN OF MY
00:10:25.691 --> 00:10:27.226
NAME'S BARBARA BEARD I'M A CHIEF
00:10:27.293 --> 00:10:28.794
DEPUTY COUNSEL WITH THE SOUTH
00:10:28.861 --> 00:10:30.496
COAST TAKE MD PRIMARILY HERE TO
00:10:30.563 --> 00:10:31.797
ANSWER QUESTIONS JUST WANTED TO
00:10:31.864 --> 00:10:33.232
EMPHASIZE.
00:10:33.299 --> 00:10:35.134
OF THAT DESERVE BILL ADDRESSES
00:10:35.201 --> 00:10:37.937
VEHICLE TYPES THAT ARE ALREADY
00:10:38.004 --> 00:10:39.772
COVERED BY SOUTH CHO SEEKING DE
00:10:39.839 --> 00:10:41.540
RULES AND ARE OF MODERNIZES AND
00:10:41.607 --> 00:10:42.675
UPDATES AND STANDARDS THAT WE
00:10:42.742 --> 00:10:43.809
CAN APPLY.
00:10:43.876 --> 00:10:45.311
A WIN ADOPTING FLEET ÙES
00:10:45.378 --> 00:10:47.380
HAD THESE RULES IN EFFECT SINCE
00:10:47.446 --> 00:10:49.048
TWO THOUSAND ARE AND IT'S BEEN A
00:10:49.115 --> 00:10:50.616
SUCCESSFUL PROGRAM.
00:10:50.683 --> 00:10:53.619
OTHERS IN FAVOR OF AB A THREE
00:10:53.686 --> 00:10:54.186
TWO SEVEN ARE GOOD MORNING
00:10:54.253 --> 00:10:55.221
MISTER CHAIRMAN BILL MCGOVERN
00:10:55.287 --> 00:10:56.789
WITH THE COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR.
00:10:56.856 --> 00:10:57.490
WE SUPPORT THIS BILL WE THINK
00:10:57.556 --> 00:10:59.992
IT'S AN ESSENTIAL TO SOUTH COAST
00:11:00.059 --> 00:11:01.894
DISTRICT TO HAVE AND IT'S NEVER
00:11:01.961 --> 00:11:03.562
ENDING BATTLE AGAINST SMOG.
00:11:03.629 --> 00:11:04.196
AND I WOULD NOTE THAT THE
00:11:04.263 --> 00:11:06.265
CURRENT STATUTORY AUTHORITY IS
00:11:06.332 --> 00:11:09.101
SO OUTDATED THAT IT IS BASED ON
00:11:09.168 --> 00:11:10.770
METHANOL WHICH IS NOT TURNING A
00:11:10.836 --> 00:11:12.304
FUEL THAT WAS POPULAR DURING THE
00:11:12.371 --> 00:11:14.306
PETE WILSON ADMINISTRATION
00:11:14.373 --> 00:11:14.607
[inaudible]
00:11:14.673 --> 00:11:17.243
GOOD NEXT.
00:11:17.309 --> 00:11:18.711
HE WILL BEAR WITH THE AMERICAN
00:11:18.778 --> 00:11:22.481
LUNG ASSOCIATION ALSO IN SUPPORT.
00:11:22.548 --> 00:11:23.783
RENDON TOOK ON BEHALF OF THE
00:11:23.849 --> 00:11:25.184
CALIFORNIA AIR POLLUTION CONTROL
00:11:25.251 --> 00:11:28.020
OFFICERS ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT.
00:11:28.087 --> 00:11:29.722
IT'S THEIR OPPOSITION TO A. B.
00:11:29.789 --> 00:11:45.805
AT
00:11:51.710 --> 00:11:52.111
THREE TWO SEVEN THANK YOU
00:11:52.178 --> 00:11:54.914
MISTER CHAIRMAN.
00:11:54.980 --> 00:11:56.515
DETERMINE A MEMBERS WHERE TOP ON
00:11:56.582 --> 00:11:57.683
BEHALF OF THE ORANGE COUNTY
00:11:57.750 --> 00:11:59.018
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY AYE WE
00:11:59.085 --> 00:12:00.519
APOLOGIZE FOR OUR LATE
00:12:00.586 --> 00:12:01.654
OPPOSITION --
00:12:01.720 --> 00:12:03.522
BUT THE BOY DID I TAKE POSITION
00:12:03.589 --> 00:12:04.924
LAST WEEK.
00:12:04.990 --> 00:12:06.225
I'M AT US IN OPPOSE IN
00:12:06.292 --> 00:12:08.961
OPPOSITION TO THE BILL --
00:12:09.028 --> 00:12:11.097
MAINLY WE HAVE BEEN WORKING A
00:12:11.163 --> 00:12:12.832
COLLABORATIVE LEAVE FOR YEARS
00:12:12.898 --> 00:12:14.333
ACTUALLY WITH THE AIR RESOURCES
00:12:14.400 --> 00:12:18.237
BOARD ON A STATEWIDE --
00:12:18.304 --> 00:12:20.072
REQUIREMENTS FOR ZERO EMISSION
00:12:20.139 --> 00:12:21.841
BUSES -- FOR
00:12:21.907 --> 00:12:23.109
THAT WOULD --
00:12:23.175 --> 00:12:25.044
CONFLICT WE THINK WITH THIS BILL
00:12:25.111 --> 00:12:26.879
SPECIFICALLY --
00:12:26.946 --> 00:12:28.948
Y. WHILE WE APPRECIATE I WHAT
00:12:29.014 --> 00:12:30.249
THE AUTHOR IS TRYING TO DO AND
00:12:30.316 --> 00:12:31.851
WANT TO WORK TOWARDS THAT GOAL
00:12:31.917 --> 00:12:33.219
WE THINK THERE ARE A LOT OF
00:12:33.285 --> 00:12:34.920
NUANCES --
00:12:34.987 --> 00:12:35.955
THAT REALLY NEED TO BE CLARIFIED
00:12:36.021 --> 00:12:37.256
WHEN WE SEE THESE TYPES OF BILLS
00:12:37.323 --> 00:12:39.492
THAT ALLOW --
00:12:39.558 --> 00:12:42.328
AGENCIES TO US OFFER --
00:12:42.394 --> 00:12:44.063
REGULATORY STRUCTURES NORMALLY
00:12:44.130 --> 00:12:45.598
WE WILL SEE A LITTLE BIT MORE
00:12:45.664 --> 00:12:47.233
PARAMETERS IN TERMS OF YOU TALK
00:12:47.299 --> 00:12:50.936
ABOUT USEFUL LIFE AND AND
00:12:51.003 --> 00:12:53.572
ECONOMICALLY VIABLE ALTERNATIVES --
00:12:53.639 --> 00:12:54.807
USUALLY WE SEEM BILLS LIKE THAT
00:12:54.874 --> 00:12:56.175
THAT ACTUALLY SPECIFY IT BECAUSE
00:12:56.242 --> 00:12:58.477
OUR OUR USABLE LIFE IS ACTUALLY
00:12:58.544 --> 00:12:59.912
LONGER THAN MOST AGENCIES SO
00:12:59.979 --> 00:13:01.247
THAT THOSE OF THE KINDS OF
00:13:01.313 --> 00:13:02.715
THINGS HAT WE WOULD WANT TO SEE.
00:13:02.781 --> 00:13:04.350
IN A ARE BE READ AS WELL AS THIS%
00:13:04.416 --> 00:13:04.650
[inaudible]
00:13:04.717 --> 00:13:06.418
NEXT.
00:13:06.485 --> 00:13:07.786
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
00:13:07.853 --> 00:13:08.888
MEMBERS STATES AND AYE OCCURRED
00:13:08.954 --> 00:13:10.189
WITH IT'LL STING GILBERT ROPES
00:13:10.256 --> 00:13:11.290
AND SMITH ON BEHALF OF THE
00:13:11.357 --> 00:13:12.825
CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL UTILITIES
00:13:12.892 --> 00:13:14.326
ASSOCIATION.
00:13:14.393 --> 00:13:15.694
ALSO WANT TO APOLOGIZE FOR AWAY
00:13:15.761 --> 00:13:16.996
LETTER ON THE BILL WE DID TAKE
00:13:17.062 --> 00:13:18.197
IT UP AT OUR FIRST MUCH
00:13:18.264 --> 00:13:19.832
COMMITTEE AFTER IT WAS PUT INTO
00:13:19.899 --> 00:13:21.433
PRINT -- BUT
00:13:21.500 --> 00:13:23.469
LOOKING FORWARD TO MEETING MORE
00:13:23.536 --> 00:13:25.538
OF THE AUTHOR AND A STAFF --
00:13:25.604 --> 00:13:26.172
SEEMINGLY HAS AN OPPOSING LESS
00:13:26.238 --> 00:13:27.606
MINUTE POSITION ON THE BILL OUR
00:13:27.673 --> 00:13:28.541
MEMBERSHIP --
00:13:28.607 --> 00:13:28.941
WERE --
00:13:29.008 --> 00:13:31.343
PROVIDES WATER AND POWER SERVICE
00:13:31.410 --> 00:13:33.279
THEIR MUNICIPAL UTILITIES --
00:13:33.345 --> 00:13:34.713
THEY KIND OF VEHICLES THAT THEY
00:13:34.780 --> 00:13:35.281
HAVE IN THEIR FLEET PROVIDE
00:13:35.347 --> 00:13:36.582
SPECIFIC.
00:13:36.649 --> 00:13:38.417
YOU KNOW FUNCTIONS THEY THEY
00:13:38.484 --> 00:13:40.219
HAVE TO PERFORM UP TO A CERTAIN
00:13:40.286 --> 00:13:41.921
STANDARD TO KEEP THE LIGHTS ON
00:13:41.987 --> 00:13:42.521
AND THE WATER RUNNING IN YOUR
00:13:42.588 --> 00:13:43.956
HOMES.
00:13:44.023 --> 00:13:45.291
IF THERE'S AN OUTAGE THEY HAVE
00:13:45.357 --> 00:13:46.392
TO BE ABLE TO GET TO WHERE IT IS
00:13:46.458 --> 00:13:47.626
AND SOME COMMUNITIES
00:13:47.693 --> 00:13:48.694
PARTICULARLY IF YOU'RE SERVING A
00:13:48.761 --> 00:13:50.062
RURAL DISTRICT.
00:13:50.129 --> 00:13:51.030
YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO TRACK
00:13:51.096 --> 00:13:53.098
TRAVERSAL LONG DISTANCE THE FUEL
00:13:53.165 --> 00:13:55.000
THAT YOU HAVE TO USE AND HAS TO
00:13:55.067 --> 00:13:56.368
BE AVAILABLE WHERE YOU'RE GOING
00:13:56.435 --> 00:13:57.603
SO YOU CAN GET BACK TO WHERE.
00:13:57.670 --> 00:13:59.471
YOU'RE BASED --
00:13:59.538 --> 00:14:02.141
SO THE BILL THAT WE NOTICE IT
00:14:02.208 --> 00:14:03.676
PROVIDES AN EXEMPTION FOR
00:14:03.742 --> 00:14:05.644
PARAMEDICS FIRE AND POLICE
00:14:05.711 --> 00:14:06.579
SERVICE WHICH SEEMS ENTIRELY
00:14:06.645 --> 00:14:07.846
APPROPRIATE BECAUSE THESE ARE
00:14:07.913 --> 00:14:09.481
CENTRAL PUBLIC SERVICES.
00:14:09.548 --> 00:14:10.816
WE BELIEVE THAT THE SERVICES
00:14:10.883 --> 00:14:12.351
OFFERED BY SEEM YOU WAYS MEMBERS
00:14:12.418 --> 00:14:13.686
AGAIN KEEPING THE LIGHTS ON IN
00:14:13.752 --> 00:14:14.887
THE WATER RUNNING ARE ALSO
00:14:14.954 --> 00:14:16.455
ESSENTIAL AND SO.
00:14:16.522 --> 00:14:17.856
WE WOULD REMOVE OUR OPPOSITION
00:14:17.923 --> 00:14:19.158
OR THE BILL AMENDED TO ALSO
00:14:19.225 --> 00:14:21.193
ACCEPT THOSE SERVICES.
00:14:21.260 --> 00:14:22.695
THANK YOU NEXT THANK YOU MISTER
00:14:22.761 --> 00:14:23.862
CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS MICHAEL
00:14:23.929 --> 00:14:25.364
PENINSULA CALIFORNIA TRANSIT
00:14:25.431 --> 00:14:27.499
ASSOCIATION I WANT TO NOTE THAT
00:14:27.566 --> 00:14:28.400
WE DO HAVE AN OPPOSING WAS
00:14:28.467 --> 00:14:29.935
AMENDED OPPOSITION ON THE BILL
00:14:30.002 --> 00:14:31.170
WE ARE WORKING WITH THE AUTHORS
00:14:31.237 --> 00:14:32.771
OFFICE AND THE SPONSOR TO COME
00:14:32.838 --> 00:14:34.406
TO SOME RESOLUTION.
00:14:34.473 --> 00:14:36.508
WERE SEEKING SPECIFICALLY ON IS
00:14:36.575 --> 00:14:37.810
A RECOGNITION OF THE ONGOING
00:14:37.876 --> 00:14:39.211
RULE MAKING AT THE CALIFORNIA
00:14:39.278 --> 00:14:40.546
RESOUCES BOARD.
00:14:40.613 --> 00:14:42.014
AND WHAT WOULD BE SEEKING WOULD
00:14:42.081 --> 00:14:43.349
BE AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD
00:14:43.415 --> 00:14:45.884
RECOGNIZE THAT IF THAT RULE ON
00:14:45.951 --> 00:14:47.653
BY THE AIRPORT GOES INTO A FACT.
00:14:47.720 --> 00:14:48.988
AND HAS --
00:14:49.054 --> 00:14:49.755
CERTAIN STANDARDS IN PLACE THAT
00:14:49.822 --> 00:14:51.690
WOULD BE --
00:14:51.757 --> 00:14:55.127
THE LOW KNOCKS ENGINES.
00:14:55.194 --> 00:14:56.829
CLEANER THAN TODAY'S FUELS AYE
00:14:56.895 --> 00:14:59.164
AS WELL AS A OF PURCHASE MANDATE
00:14:59.231 --> 00:15:00.432
FOR ZERO MISSION BUSES ON THAT
00:15:00.499 --> 00:15:02.668
THIS BILL WOULD ESSENTIALLY I AM
00:15:02.735 --> 00:15:04.169
NOT APPLY.
00:15:04.236 --> 00:15:05.804
TO ON THE TRANSIT AGENCIES AND
00:15:05.871 --> 00:15:06.639
SO WE ARE WORKING WITH THE
00:15:06.705 --> 00:15:07.906
OTHERS OFFICE HAVE TO COME TO
00:15:07.973 --> 00:15:08.941
SOME RESOLUTION FOR NEXT
00:15:09.008 --> 00:15:09.575
COMMITTEE THANK YOU [inaudible]
00:15:09.642 --> 00:15:13.078
NEXT.
00:15:13.145 --> 00:15:14.446
SHARON A MEMBERS ANDREAS WEEK
00:15:14.513 --> 00:15:15.981
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE LOS
00:15:16.048 --> 00:15:17.182
ANGELES COUNTY METROPOLITAN
00:15:17.249 --> 00:15:18.784
TRANSPORTATION AGENCY WHERE THE
00:15:18.851 --> 00:15:20.753
LARGEST TRANSIT AGENCY.
00:15:20.819 --> 00:15:22.588
IN THE SOUTH COAST A QUEUE OF
00:15:22.655 --> 00:15:24.089
THESE DISTRICT WHERE LARGE TRANS
00:15:24.156 --> 00:15:24.757
AGENCY IN THE STATE.
00:15:24.823 --> 00:15:26.191
WE SHARE THE CONCERNS RAISED BY
00:15:26.258 --> 00:15:27.593
ALL CTA.
00:15:27.660 --> 00:15:29.295
AND BY OF THE CALIFORNIA TRANSIT
00:15:29.361 --> 00:15:31.363
ASSOCIATION WE ALREADY HAVE A
00:15:31.430 --> 00:15:33.232
COMMITMENT AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL
00:15:33.299 --> 00:15:35.267
TO CHANGE OUT OUR ENTIRE FLEET.
00:15:35.334 --> 00:15:37.269
BY -- TWENTY
00:15:37.336 --> 00:15:38.871
THIRTY TO ALL ELECTRIC AND SO WE
00:15:38.937 --> 00:15:40.172
THINK THE AUTHORS OFFICE AND THE
00:15:40.239 --> 00:15:41.674
SPONSORS FOR HEARING US OUT WE
00:15:41.740 --> 00:15:43.409
HAVE BEEN CONVERSATION WITH THEM
00:15:43.475 --> 00:15:44.877
AT THIS POINT THIS BILLS HEADED
00:15:44.943 --> 00:15:45.944
TOWARD PORT.
00:15:46.011 --> 00:15:47.880
SO HERE EXPRESSED CONCERN
00:15:47.946 --> 00:15:48.180
[inaudible]
00:15:48.247 --> 00:15:49.615
VERY GOOD.
00:15:49.682 --> 00:15:51.717
I'D OTHERS WHO OPPOSE THEM A. B.
00:15:51.784 --> 00:15:55.321
YEAH. THREE TWO SEVEN I WAS
00:15:55.387 --> 00:15:56.822
CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING BRING IT
00:15:56.889 --> 00:15:58.590
BACK TO THE DAY S. QUESTIONS OF
00:15:58.657 --> 00:16:01.760
THE AUTHOR.
00:16:01.827 --> 00:16:02.861
AS SOMEONE WOULD YOU LIKE TO
00:16:02.928 --> 00:16:04.129
COMMENT ON SOME OF THE CONCERNS
00:16:04.196 --> 00:16:05.764
THAT THE PUBLIC AGENCIES HAVE
00:16:05.831 --> 00:16:07.566
OVER LET'S SAY THE TIME TABLE
00:16:07.633 --> 00:16:09.535
SERRANO HOWEVER TO THE AIR.
00:16:09.601 --> 00:16:11.637
QUALITY CONTROL.
00:16:11.704 --> 00:16:13.339
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN FIRST
00:16:13.405 --> 00:16:14.873
WITH RESPECT TO THE TRANSIT
00:16:14.940 --> 00:16:17.509
AGENCIES ARE WE ARE WELL AWARE
00:16:17.576 --> 00:16:19.078
OF THE GUY.
00:16:19.144 --> 00:16:21.013
RULE MAKING ON BEING UNDERTAKEN
00:16:21.080 --> 00:16:22.614
BY THE CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES
00:16:22.681 --> 00:16:24.483
BOARD WE SUPPORT THAT RULE
00:16:24.550 --> 00:16:26.618
MAKING AND I HOPE IT TURNS OUT
00:16:26.685 --> 00:16:28.153
TO BE VERY SUCCESSFUL.
00:16:28.220 --> 00:16:29.855
ONE A WE HAVE PROVIDED TO THE
00:16:29.922 --> 00:16:30.823
TRANSIT AGENCIES A PROPOSED
00:16:30.889 --> 00:16:32.691
AMENDMENT.
00:16:32.758 --> 00:16:34.293
I TO THE BILL WHICH WOULD --
00:16:34.360 --> 00:16:36.362
PROVIDE THAT --
00:16:36.428 --> 00:16:37.996
ASSUMING THE AIR RESOURCES BOARD
00:16:38.063 --> 00:16:39.698
ADOPTS A REGULATION THAT
00:16:39.765 --> 00:16:41.467
REQUIRES A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF
00:16:41.533 --> 00:16:43.001
EMISSION REDUCTIONS WHICH IS IN
00:16:43.068 --> 00:16:44.636
LINE WITH WHAT THEY'RE CURRENTLY
00:16:44.703 --> 00:16:46.171
PROPOSING --
00:16:46.238 --> 00:16:47.940
BUT LESS STRINGENT THAN GOING
00:16:48.006 --> 00:16:49.742
ALL THE WAY TO ZERO EMISSION DEN
00:16:49.808 --> 00:16:51.243
WE WOULD BE PRECLUDED FROM
00:16:51.310 --> 00:16:52.845
ADOPTING THE REGULATION FOR
00:16:52.911 --> 00:16:54.313
TRANSIT BUSES.
00:16:54.380 --> 00:16:56.482
OUR UNTIL AT LEAST TWENTY THIRTY
00:16:56.548 --> 00:16:57.649
SO WE HAVE PROPOSED THAT
00:16:57.716 --> 00:16:59.151
LANGUAGE FOR THE TRANSIT
00:16:59.218 --> 00:17:00.953
ASSOCIATIONS THAT ARE HOPING TO
00:17:01.019 --> 00:17:02.955
HEAR BACK FROM THEM --
00:17:03.021 --> 00:17:05.290
SO MEMBER.
00:17:05.357 --> 00:17:06.759
YOUR DESIRE TO TAKE THAT
00:17:06.825 --> 00:17:08.761
AMENDMENT NOW OR TO IN TEACHING
00:17:08.827 --> 00:17:10.462
AGO SHAPE WITH THE WITH THE
00:17:10.529 --> 00:17:11.397
PARTIES THIS IS [inaudible]
00:17:11.463 --> 00:17:15.000
A THE MOTION IS TO REFER TO
00:17:15.067 --> 00:17:16.668
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING RIGHT SO
00:17:16.735 --> 00:17:18.003
WHAT WE'RE ON FIRST OF ALL LET
00:17:18.070 --> 00:17:19.805
ME JUST CLARIFY WE'RE WILLING TO
00:17:19.872 --> 00:17:20.572
WORK WITH --
00:17:20.639 --> 00:17:22.074
ALL THE ONES WHO HAVE CONCERNS
00:17:22.141 --> 00:17:23.809
YOU TRY TO MOVE THEM TO SUPPORT
00:17:23.876 --> 00:17:25.244
POSITION UNUSUAL POSITION SO WE
00:17:25.310 --> 00:17:26.945
HAVE THAT COMMITMENT FROM MY
00:17:27.012 --> 00:17:28.847
OFFICE AND WILL BE ON ACCEPTING
00:17:28.914 --> 00:17:30.149
THIS OF IT [inaudible]
00:17:30.215 --> 00:17:31.717
OKAY WON'T.
00:17:31.784 --> 00:17:33.152
YOU KNOW I'M PRETTY I HAD TO TRY
00:17:33.218 --> 00:17:34.653
TO STAY IN MY LANE SO THIS IS
00:17:34.720 --> 00:17:35.354
THE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
00:17:35.421 --> 00:17:37.055
COMMITTEE SO WHILE IT MAY HAVE
00:17:37.122 --> 00:17:38.624
AN IMPACT ON THE TRANSPORTATION
00:17:38.690 --> 00:17:40.359
AT LEAST FROM AIR QUALITY.
00:17:40.426 --> 00:17:42.261
WHILE IT MAY BE TOO AGGRESSIVE
00:17:42.327 --> 00:17:42.828
FOR FOR FOLKS IT CERTAINLY
00:17:42.895 --> 00:17:44.296
IMPROVES HERE QUALITY THAT WE
00:17:44.363 --> 00:17:46.165
HAVE SO I AM A MEMBER OF THE
00:17:46.231 --> 00:17:47.399
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING
00:17:47.466 --> 00:17:48.434
COMMITTEES ALL HAVE A DIFFERENT
00:17:48.500 --> 00:17:50.369
HAT ON AT THAT TIME WHEN IT.
00:17:50.436 --> 00:17:51.970
WHEN IT COMES TO THE FEASIBILITY
00:17:52.037 --> 00:17:54.173
I'M ALREADY ADD THAT WE HAVEN'T
00:17:54.239 --> 00:17:57.009
ESTABLISH A QUORUM SO WE'RE NOT
00:17:57.075 --> 00:17:58.076
APPROPRIATE THINK OF EMOTIONS
00:17:58.143 --> 00:17:59.511
RIGHT NOW BUT IF YOU'D LIKE TO
00:17:59.578 --> 00:18:01.747
CLOSE WE WILL CONSIDER THAT?
00:18:01.814 --> 00:18:03.382
WE HAVE A MISTER CHAIRMAN CAN I
00:18:03.449 --> 00:18:04.716
RESPOND TO THE MUNICIPAL
00:18:04.783 --> 00:18:06.752
UTILITIES ALSO OFFICE I'M SORRY
00:18:06.819 --> 00:18:08.787
PLEA OF MUNICIPAL UTILITIES HAD
00:18:08.854 --> 00:18:10.422
INDICATED THAT OF OCT EXISTING
00:18:10.489 --> 00:18:12.891
LANGUAGE PROVIDES AN EXEMPTION.
00:18:12.958 --> 00:18:14.393
FOR EMERGENCY VEHICLES SUCH AS
00:18:14.460 --> 00:18:16.628
POLICE AND TO HAVE A SIMILAR
00:18:16.695 --> 00:18:18.330
EXEMPTION.
00:18:18.397 --> 00:18:20.332
I WOULD SIMPLY NOTE THAT THE
00:18:20.399 --> 00:18:22.434
EXISTING EXEMPTION FOR EMERGENCY
00:18:22.501 --> 00:18:24.002
VEHICLES IS NOT A COMPLETE
00:18:24.069 --> 00:18:25.070
EXEMPTION.
00:18:25.137 --> 00:18:27.840
OWE IT MERELY PROVIDES THAT THE
00:18:27.906 --> 00:18:29.808
AUTHORITY WOULD NOT APPLY ON
00:18:29.875 --> 00:18:31.310
UNLESS AND UNTIL THE SOFTNESS
00:18:31.376 --> 00:18:33.545
DISTRICT BOARD DETERMINES THAT.
00:18:33.612 --> 00:18:35.080
ARE APPLYING THOSE RULES WOULD
00:18:35.147 --> 00:18:37.483
NOT IMPAIR EMERGENCY RESPONSE.
00:18:37.549 --> 00:18:39.718
AND SO THE BIT LEGISLATION THAT
00:18:39.785 --> 00:18:41.453
YOU HAVE BEFORE YOU THAT --
00:18:41.520 --> 00:18:43.388
OUR AUTHOR HAS PROPOSED UP
00:18:43.455 --> 00:18:45.557
PROVIDE SIMILARLY FOR ALL
00:18:45.624 --> 00:18:47.125
VEHICLE TYPES THAT.
00:18:47.192 --> 00:18:48.460
WE CAN ONLY REQUIRED THE
00:18:48.527 --> 00:18:49.728
CLEANEST COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE
00:18:49.795 --> 00:18:51.563
EQUIPMENT THAT CAN MEET
00:18:51.630 --> 00:18:53.365
OPERATIONAL NEEDS INDOORS NEEDS
00:18:53.432 --> 00:18:54.566
WOULD INCLUDE THE NEEDS OF THAT
00:18:54.633 --> 00:18:56.368
MUNICIPAL UTILITY SO WE THINK
00:18:56.435 --> 00:18:57.736
THAT THEIR CONCERN IS ADDRESS SO
00:18:57.803 --> 00:18:59.271
THAT WE DID FOR INSTANCE.
00:18:59.338 --> 00:19:01.006
YOU HAVE COMMUNITY SERVICE
00:19:01.073 --> 00:19:01.573
VEHICLES ARE PART OF POLICE
00:19:01.640 --> 00:19:04.610
FORCE AND THE SENIORS GIVE US
00:19:04.676 --> 00:19:05.911
TICKETS WHEREVER PEOPLE A MARKET
00:19:05.978 --> 00:19:06.745
THAT WOULD BE THEY COULD DO TEN
00:19:06.812 --> 00:19:08.614
ELECTRIC VEHICLE PRESUMABLY.
00:19:08.680 --> 00:19:10.949
AND WITH IT BUT IT WOULD BE AND
00:19:11.016 --> 00:19:11.483
STUFF LIKE LOT INCIDENT
00:19:11.550 --> 00:19:12.751
EMERGENCY VEHICLE BUT IF IT WERE
00:19:12.818 --> 00:19:13.986
YES I'M.
00:19:14.052 --> 00:19:15.053
WE COULD ONLY REQUIRE WHAT'S
00:19:15.120 --> 00:19:18.790
CONSISTENT WITH OPERATIONAL NEED.
00:19:18.857 --> 00:19:20.259
IF I MAY ADD.
00:19:20.325 --> 00:19:21.793
MUSCLE DID CURRENT RULES CAN
00:19:21.860 --> 00:19:22.528
GIVE ME AT AL ALSO INCLUDE
00:19:22.594 --> 00:19:24.263
PROVISIONS THAT ALLOW LEAD UP
00:19:24.329 --> 00:19:26.131
REDUCE TO COMING AND REQUESTS
00:19:26.198 --> 00:19:28.133
FOR EXEMPTIONS AS LONG AS THEY
00:19:28.200 --> 00:19:28.967
CAN DEMONSTRATE THAT.
00:19:29.034 --> 00:19:30.669
A SPECIFIC APPLICATION IS NOT
00:19:30.736 --> 00:19:32.037
TECHNICALLY OR OPERATIONALLY
00:19:32.104 --> 00:19:33.805
FEASIBLE FOR THAT PROVISION IS
00:19:33.872 --> 00:19:36.174
ALREADY IN THE RULE THAT WE CAN
00:19:36.241 --> 00:19:36.775
EXPAND ON IT IN OUR NEXT WILL
00:19:36.842 --> 00:19:38.010
MAKE OKAY EXCELLENT WELL.
00:19:38.076 --> 00:19:39.912
WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE SIMPLY
00:19:39.978 --> 00:19:40.913
ASKED WHEN I VOTE APPROPRIATE
00:19:40.979 --> 00:19:42.314
TIME VERY GOOD THANK YOU THANK
00:19:42.381 --> 00:19:43.949
ALREADY.
00:19:44.016 --> 00:19:45.250
I LET'S MOVE ON TO OUR NEXT
00:19:45.317 --> 00:19:47.185
AUTHOR WE HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:19:47.252 --> 00:19:49.354
NO I WON MORE OVERSEAS MEDIA
00:19:49.421 --> 00:19:50.088
RIGHT.
00:19:50.155 --> 00:19:51.189
ASSEMBLYMEMBER GIPSON HAVE I
00:19:51.256 --> 00:19:54.059
DON'T OVER SIX ONE FIVE SEVEN
00:19:54.126 --> 00:19:58.664
SEVEN BOOTH NUMBERS.
00:19:58.730 --> 00:20:00.933
IT'S PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD BILL.
00:20:00.999 --> 00:20:02.568
AND I THINK STEFFI TELL US
00:20:02.634 --> 00:20:03.769
ANGELES COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
00:20:03.835 --> 00:20:05.904
TVS.
00:20:05.971 --> 00:20:07.072
SO MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:20:07.139 --> 00:20:08.073
THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO
00:20:08.140 --> 00:20:09.675
PRESENTS FIRST OF ALL LET ME
00:20:09.741 --> 00:20:11.610
UNDERSCORE --
00:20:11.677 --> 00:20:14.179
THIS COMES WITH A HEAVY HEART --
00:20:14.246 --> 00:20:16.281
IN TERMS OF PRESENTING THIS
00:20:16.348 --> 00:20:17.349
PARTICULAR BILL WAS ONE OF THAT
00:20:17.416 --> 00:20:19.151
THINK IS NECESSARY --
00:20:19.217 --> 00:20:20.986
THIS BILL FIFTEEN SEVEN SEVEN
00:20:21.053 --> 00:20:22.621
WHICH WOULD HELP PROVIDE CLEAN
00:20:22.688 --> 00:20:24.289
DRINKING WATER TO THOSE
00:20:24.356 --> 00:20:26.792
RESIDENTS BEING SERVICE VICE THE
00:20:26.858 --> 00:20:29.161
TIVO WATER DISTRICT --
00:20:29.227 --> 00:20:31.363
LET ME ALSO AGREED --
00:20:31.430 --> 00:20:32.464
WITH THE COMMENTS SUGGESTED
00:20:32.531 --> 00:20:34.700
AMENDMENTS --
00:20:34.766 --> 00:20:36.602
UNDER COMMENTS TO IN THE
00:20:36.668 --> 00:20:38.103
ANALYSIS I WILL BE ACCEPTING
00:20:38.170 --> 00:20:39.605
THESE AMENDMENTS AS COMMITTEE
00:20:39.671 --> 00:20:41.340
AMENDMENTS.
00:20:41.406 --> 00:20:42.274
THIS IS --
00:20:42.341 --> 00:20:44.176
THERE IS CURRENTLY A WATER
00:20:44.242 --> 00:20:46.845
CRISIS IN MY DISTRICT RESIDENTS
00:20:46.912 --> 00:20:49.615
BEING SERVICED BY THE TIVO.
00:20:49.681 --> 00:20:51.717
ARE EXPERIENCING WATER IS US
00:20:51.783 --> 00:20:53.085
SERVICES --
00:20:53.151 --> 00:20:59.057
THAT YOU ARE I WILL NOT TOLERATE --
00:20:59.124 --> 00:21:00.926
THIS INCLUDES BROWN WATER.
00:21:00.993 --> 00:21:02.427
COMING FROM THE KITCHEN FAUCET
00:21:02.494 --> 00:21:02.728
[inaudible]
00:21:02.794 --> 00:21:04.663
BATHTUBS.
00:21:04.730 --> 00:21:06.398
CORRODED PIPES POORLY MAINTAINED
00:21:06.465 --> 00:21:09.601
INFRASTRUCTURE AN AGING WELLS.
00:21:09.668 --> 00:21:12.871
THE TEAM ALSO HAS FIRE HYDRANTS
00:21:12.938 --> 00:21:14.539
THAT DO NOT HAVE ENOUGH WATER
00:21:14.606 --> 00:21:16.074
PRESSURE.
00:21:16.141 --> 00:21:18.777
IN CASE OF FIRE OR EMERGENCY.
00:21:18.844 --> 00:21:20.646
WHAT'S TO TAKE PLACE THERE ARE
00:21:20.712 --> 00:21:22.314
SEVERAL QUAN CRISIS A CRITICAL
00:21:22.381 --> 00:21:24.049
CHALLENGES.
00:21:24.116 --> 00:21:25.317
THAT HAVE --
00:21:25.384 --> 00:21:26.985
BEEN PROVIDED HAS BEEN IN THE
00:21:27.052 --> 00:21:29.287
NEWS REGARDING --
00:21:29.354 --> 00:21:31.523
WATER AT THE TIVO FIRST THE TEVA
00:21:31.590 --> 00:21:33.558
HAS AN INSUFFICIENT CUSTOMER
00:21:33.625 --> 00:21:34.192
BASE.
00:21:34.259 --> 00:21:37.429
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO IMPROVE.
00:21:37.496 --> 00:21:39.865
US THE TIVO HAS ALSO --
00:21:39.931 --> 00:21:41.767
APPROXIMATELY I'M SIXTEEN
00:21:41.833 --> 00:21:43.201
HUNDRED RATE PAYERS BUT NEEDS TO
00:21:43.268 --> 00:21:45.537
EXPAND OVER TEN MILLION IN
00:21:45.604 --> 00:21:48.273
INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS.
00:21:48.340 --> 00:21:50.242
GIVEN ITS SIZE TO TEVA ASSEMBLY
00:21:50.308 --> 00:21:52.144
DOES NOT HAVE SUFFICIENT REVENUE
00:21:52.210 --> 00:21:55.013
STREAM TO ADDRESS THESE --
00:21:55.080 --> 00:21:56.948
GROWING ISSUES IN ADDITION. TO
00:21:57.015 --> 00:21:57.749
ITS FINANCIAL CHALLENGES THE
00:21:57.816 --> 00:21:59.818
TIBA HAS.
00:21:59.885 --> 00:22:01.920
THAT IT HAS --
00:22:01.987 --> 00:22:03.655
STATUE OF TECHNICAL AND
00:22:03.722 --> 00:22:04.556
MANAGERIAL --
00:22:04.623 --> 00:22:06.992
ISSUES --
00:22:07.059 --> 00:22:09.728
WHERE'S THE TEVA TRY TO ADDRESS
00:22:09.795 --> 00:22:11.296
OF THE BROWN WATER PROBLEM
00:22:11.363 --> 00:22:13.899
FLUSHING OTHER PIPES WITHOUT
00:22:13.965 --> 00:22:16.535
UNDERSTANDING THAT ADDITION NO --
00:22:16.601 --> 00:22:18.236
CORROSION WOULD WORSEN THE
00:22:18.303 --> 00:22:21.373
SITUATION EVEN FURTHER --
00:22:21.440 --> 00:22:23.842
THESE TROUBLESOME INCIDENTS I'M
00:22:23.909 --> 00:22:25.544
UNDERSCORES A LONGSTANDING
00:22:25.610 --> 00:22:27.279
DEFICIENCY ASSOCIATED WITH THE
00:22:27.345 --> 00:22:29.281
TIVO IS LACK OF PROPER FINANCIAL
00:22:29.347 --> 00:22:31.083
MANAGEMENT AND OPERATION
00:22:31.149 --> 00:22:32.918
CAPACITY THIS BILL WITH
00:22:32.984 --> 00:22:34.653
THEREFORE EMPOWER.
00:22:34.720 --> 00:22:37.022
THE STATE WATER BOARD ONTO WATER
00:22:37.089 --> 00:22:38.690
CITY BUT TO ACCEPT AND
00:22:38.757 --> 00:22:40.759
ADMINISTRATIVE AND MANAGERIAL
00:22:40.826 --> 00:22:42.694
SERVICES FOR AN APPOINTED
00:22:42.761 --> 00:22:44.796
ADMINISTRATOR --
00:22:44.863 --> 00:22:46.732
THIS WILL ENSURE THAT CITY OF I
00:22:46.798 --> 00:22:49.267
HAS THE EXPERTISE CAPACITY IT
00:22:49.334 --> 00:22:50.635
NEEDS TO ADDRESS ITS WATER
00:22:50.702 --> 00:22:52.571
QUALITY PROBLEMS AND WORK
00:22:52.637 --> 00:22:54.973
TOWARDS A LONG TERM SOLUTION.
00:22:55.040 --> 00:22:58.310
I'M ASSEMBLY BILL --
00:22:58.376 --> 00:22:58.944
FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN WE HAVE A
00:22:59.010 --> 00:23:00.512
REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE LOCAL
00:23:00.579 --> 00:23:02.180
AGENCY --
00:23:02.247 --> 00:23:03.415
FORMATION COMMITTEE CALL AFTER
00:23:03.482 --> 00:23:04.616
CALL FROM LOS ANGELES COUNTY WHO
00:23:04.683 --> 00:23:06.284
WILL SELF INTRODUCED ALSO
00:23:06.351 --> 00:23:08.320
PROVIDE SUPPORTING ON TESTIMONY
00:23:08.386 --> 00:23:09.921
RIGHT IN WERE A WHERE IS HE NOW
00:23:09.988 --> 00:23:12.424
SAYS POINTS OUT THAT THE PROP
00:23:12.491 --> 00:23:13.725
SIXTY EIGHT AND PROP ONE ONLY A
00:23:13.792 --> 00:23:15.494
PROVIDE FOR CAPITAL.
00:23:15.560 --> 00:23:17.095
IMPROVEMENTS SO THERE'S JUST A
00:23:17.162 --> 00:23:18.630
LIMITATION BUT THE PROBLEM
00:23:18.697 --> 00:23:20.432
PROBLEMS BEEN IDENTIFIED THINK
00:23:20.499 --> 00:23:21.767
PLEASE.
00:23:21.833 --> 00:23:22.901
MORNING UNABLE CHAIR AND MEMBERS
00:23:22.968 --> 00:23:23.935
MY NAME IS PAUL NOVAK AND I'M
00:23:24.002 --> 00:23:25.137
THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF LA
00:23:25.203 --> 00:23:26.071
LAUGH GO.
00:23:26.138 --> 00:23:27.172
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:23:27.239 --> 00:23:30.475
SPEAK BRIEFLY ABOUT AB.
00:23:30.542 --> 00:23:31.042
FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN AND I
00:23:31.109 --> 00:23:31.676
WOULD VERY MUCH LIKE TO THINK
00:23:31.743 --> 00:23:33.078
ASSEMBLYMAN GIBSON FOR AUTHORING
00:23:33.145 --> 00:23:35.447
THIS CRITICAL BILL.
00:23:35.514 --> 00:23:37.048
THE COMMISSION MEETING LAST WEEK
00:23:37.115 --> 00:23:38.550
LA LEFT VOTED TO TAKE A SUPPORT
00:23:38.617 --> 00:23:40.919
POSITION ANY BE.
00:23:40.986 --> 00:23:41.520
FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN THE DAY
00:23:41.586 --> 00:23:42.521
BEFORE ON JUNE TWELFTH THE LA
00:23:42.587 --> 00:23:44.289
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS ALSO
00:23:44.356 --> 00:23:46.825
VOTED TO TAKE A SUPPORT POSITION.
00:23:46.892 --> 00:23:48.093
IT IS WITHOUT QUESTION THAT THE
00:23:48.160 --> 00:23:49.461
CITY OF A COUNTY WATER DISTRICT
00:23:49.528 --> 00:23:50.562
IS IN CRISIS AND THAT TIME IS OF
00:23:50.629 --> 00:23:52.364
THE ESSENCE.
00:23:52.430 --> 00:23:53.732
RESIDENTS TURNED ON THE FAUCETS
00:23:53.799 --> 00:23:55.500
AND ENCOUNTER BROWN MURKY WATER
00:23:55.567 --> 00:23:57.636
THAT IS HIGH AND MANGANESE.
00:23:57.702 --> 00:23:58.503
CITY WERE BOARD MEMBERS AND
00:23:58.570 --> 00:24:00.172
STAFF CANNOT ABSTURZ EVEN SIMPLE
00:24:00.238 --> 00:24:01.706
QUESTIONS ABOUT THE DISTRICT'S
00:24:01.773 --> 00:24:03.341
FINANCES.
00:24:03.408 --> 00:24:04.976
OPERATIONS OR INFRASTRUCTURE.
00:24:05.043 --> 00:24:06.311
LEGAL COUNSEL FOR SEVERAL
00:24:06.378 --> 00:24:08.079
RATEPAYERS HAS FILED A FOUR
00:24:08.146 --> 00:24:08.947
POINT SEVEN MILLION DOLLAR CLAIM
00:24:09.014 --> 00:24:10.816
AGAINST THE DISTRICT.
00:24:10.882 --> 00:24:11.883
AND ALL FIVE BOARD MEMBERS HAVE
00:24:11.950 --> 00:24:14.052
BEEN SERVED WITH RECALL NOTICES.
00:24:14.119 --> 00:24:15.854
WHAT YOU SEE IN IT ASSEMBLYMAN
00:24:15.921 --> 00:24:17.289
GIBSON'S BILL IS ONE COMPONENT
00:24:17.355 --> 00:24:18.523
OF AN EFFECTIVE COLLABORATION
00:24:18.590 --> 00:24:19.958
AMONGST THE STATE?
00:24:20.025 --> 00:24:21.259
SECULAR EARLY ASSEMBLYMAN GIBSON
00:24:21.326 --> 00:24:22.828
IN THE WATER BOARDS THE COUNTY
00:24:22.894 --> 00:24:24.329
OF LOS ANGELES IN LA LAUGH GO.
00:24:24.396 --> 00:24:26.131
WHICH INCLUDES THE FOLLOWING.
00:24:26.198 --> 00:24:27.432
ON APRIL TWENTY FOURTH THE LA
00:24:27.499 --> 00:24:28.533
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
00:24:28.600 --> 00:24:30.335
FORMED A TASK FORCE. TO
00:24:30.402 --> 00:24:31.636
SPECIFICALLY ADDRESS ISSUES
00:24:31.703 --> 00:24:33.505
INVOLVING THE DISTRICT.
00:24:33.572 --> 00:24:35.307
ON JUNE FIRST YOUR STATE WATER
00:24:35.373 --> 00:24:37.142
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD ISSUED A
00:24:37.209 --> 00:24:38.877
COMPLIANCE ORDER TO THE DISTRICT.
00:24:38.944 --> 00:24:40.612
THIS COMPLIANCE ORDER IDENTIFIED
00:24:40.679 --> 00:24:42.347
NUMEROUS ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT
00:24:42.414 --> 00:24:43.448
TECHNICAL FAILURES ON THE PART
00:24:43.515 --> 00:24:45.250
OF DISTRICT STAFF.
00:24:45.317 --> 00:24:46.318
MOST IMPORTANTLY DISTRICT
00:24:46.384 --> 00:24:48.286
OPERATIONS HAVE AT TIMES REDUCE
00:24:48.353 --> 00:24:49.421
WATER PRESSURE.
00:24:49.487 --> 00:24:51.122
BELOW SAFE LEVELS FOR FIRE FLOW
00:24:51.189 --> 00:24:52.324
AND THEREBY ENDANGERING PUBLIC
00:24:52.390 --> 00:24:54.526
SAFETY.
00:24:54.593 --> 00:24:56.294
ON JUNE THIRTEENTH LAST WEEK OUR
00:24:56.361 --> 00:24:57.963
COMMISSION LA LASKO ALSO VOTED
00:24:58.029 --> 00:24:59.397
UNANIMOUSLY TO INITIATE THE
00:24:59.464 --> 00:25:00.799
DISSOLUTION OF THE CITY THE
00:25:00.866 --> 00:25:02.067
COUNTY WATER DISTRICT.
00:25:02.133 --> 00:25:03.902
THAT PROCESS UNFORTUNATELY DUE
00:25:03.969 --> 00:25:05.670
TO SOME STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS
00:25:05.737 --> 00:25:06.972
WILL TAKE AT LEAST SIX TO NINE
00:25:07.038 --> 00:25:08.673
MONTHS AND POTENTIALLY LONGER.
00:25:08.740 --> 00:25:11.009
THE INTENT OF AB FIFTY SEVEN E.
00:25:11.076 --> 00:25:12.644
BE FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN OF THIS
00:25:12.711 --> 00:25:13.211
FOR THE STATE WATER REESE'S
00:25:13.278 --> 00:25:14.813
CONTROL BOARD. TO APPOINT A
00:25:14.880 --> 00:25:15.947
STATE ADMINISTRATOR WHO COULD
00:25:16.014 --> 00:25:17.182
MANAGE THE DISTRICT'S AFFAIRS IN
00:25:17.249 --> 00:25:18.483
THE INTERIM.
00:25:18.550 --> 00:25:20.685
AND I'VE VOTE ANY BE FIFTEEN
00:25:20.752 --> 00:25:21.286
SEVENTY SEVEN WHICH SIR WOULD
00:25:21.353 --> 00:25:22.888
INSURE THAT AN EXPERIENCED
00:25:22.954 --> 00:25:24.556
ADMINISTRATORS BROUGHT AND
00:25:24.623 --> 00:25:26.224
ALMOST IMMEDIATELY TO MANAGE THE
00:25:26.291 --> 00:25:27.692
CITY THE COUNTY WATER DISTRICT.
00:25:27.759 --> 00:25:29.160
THE ADMINISTRATOR THEN WORK WITH
00:25:29.227 --> 00:25:30.495
THE STATE THE COUNTY AND LAUGH
00:25:30.562 --> 00:25:31.162
CHO TO ENSURE A SMOOTH
00:25:31.229 --> 00:25:33.398
TRANSITION. TO AN APPROPRIATE
00:25:33.465 --> 00:25:35.467
FUTURE SERVICE PROVIDER.
00:25:35.533 --> 00:25:36.735
IN CONCLUSION AND ON BEHALF A
00:25:36.801 --> 00:25:38.270
LOCAL AGENCY FORMATION
00:25:38.336 --> 00:25:38.904
COMMISSION FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS
00:25:38.970 --> 00:25:40.038
ANGELES.
00:25:40.105 --> 00:25:41.172
I RESPECTFULLYASK FOR AN AYE
00:25:41.239 --> 00:25:42.607
VOTE TODAY AND THANK YOU AGAIN
00:25:42.674 --> 00:25:44.342
FOR THIS OPPORTUNITY OTHER SINCE
00:25:44.409 --> 00:25:48.179
SUPPORT OF A. B. --
00:25:48.246 --> 00:25:48.813
FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN EVIDENTLY
00:25:48.880 --> 00:25:49.681
I'LL BE HEARING MORE ABOUT THE
00:25:49.748 --> 00:25:50.682
CITY VENN LOSS AND S. WATER
00:25:50.749 --> 00:25:53.518
DISTRICT HUGE PLEASE.
00:25:53.585 --> 00:25:54.986
A GOOD MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS OF
00:25:55.053 --> 00:25:56.354
PAMELA MILLER REPRESENTING THE
00:25:56.421 --> 00:25:58.089
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF LOCAL
00:25:58.156 --> 00:25:59.891
AGENCY FORMATION COMMISSIONS AND
00:25:59.958 --> 00:26:00.492
WE ARE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
00:26:00.558 --> 00:26:04.362
THANK YOU.
00:26:04.429 --> 00:26:06.131
THE MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS JUST
00:26:06.197 --> 00:26:06.765
TO THE GATES WOULD LA COUNTY IN
00:26:06.831 --> 00:26:08.033
SUPPORT.
00:26:08.099 --> 00:26:12.370
OPPOSITION TO A. B..
00:26:12.437 --> 00:26:13.004
FIFTEEN SEVENTY SEVEN OKAY LET'S
00:26:13.071 --> 00:26:14.005
BRING AFFECTED DAIS QUESTIONS OF
00:26:14.072 --> 00:26:16.775
THE AUTHOR.
00:26:16.841 --> 00:26:18.310
SEEING THEM WE DON'T STILL DON'T
00:26:18.376 --> 00:26:18.677
HAVE A QUORUM --
00:26:18.743 --> 00:26:22.447
I'M APPEAR TO SUPPORT THE BILL --
00:26:22.514 --> 00:26:23.982
LIKE I SAID I THINK WE'RE GONNA
00:26:24.049 --> 00:26:25.951
SEE MORE OF THIS HAVE BUT YOU
00:26:26.017 --> 00:26:27.218
MAY CLOSE THANK YOU VERY MUCH
00:26:27.285 --> 00:26:28.019
AGAIN THIS COMES WITH A HEAVY
00:26:28.086 --> 00:26:31.056
HEART -- WE
00:26:31.122 --> 00:26:32.223
THERE'S BEEN A NUMBER OF
00:26:32.290 --> 00:26:34.059
INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS
00:26:34.125 --> 00:26:35.860
TRIED TO WORK --
00:26:35.927 --> 00:26:37.395
TO RESOLVE THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE
00:26:37.462 --> 00:26:40.065
WITH THE TEVA AND WHICH HAS
00:26:40.131 --> 00:26:41.866
BROUGHT US TO THIS POINT A WE'VE
00:26:41.933 --> 00:26:43.835
HAD OUR HEAD AGAINST THE WALL --
00:26:43.902 --> 00:26:44.369
AS YOU HEARD THAT THE LOS
00:26:44.436 --> 00:26:47.138
ANGELES COUNTY VAI'S TAKEN
00:26:47.205 --> 00:26:48.239
ACTIONS WAS LAUGHED BECAUSE
00:26:48.306 --> 00:26:48.873
TAKEN.
00:26:48.940 --> 00:26:50.075
ACTION --
00:26:50.141 --> 00:26:51.109
AND WILL BE DERELICT IN OUR
00:26:51.176 --> 00:26:52.744
RESPONSIBILITY IF IN FACT WE
00:26:52.811 --> 00:26:53.812
DIDN'T MOVE IN THIS DIRECTION
00:26:53.878 --> 00:26:55.513
AND SO AT THE PROPER TIME WE
00:26:55.580 --> 00:26:57.382
WERE CERTAINLY* WHEN I VOTE.
00:26:57.449 --> 00:26:58.783
TO MOVE FORWARD --
00:26:58.850 --> 00:27:00.485
BUT THE NEXT PROCESS IN GETTING
00:27:00.552 --> 00:27:02.721
OF THE RESIDENTS IN CITYVILLE OF
00:27:02.787 --> 00:27:04.656
CLEAN DRINKING WATER EXCELLENT
00:27:04.723 --> 00:27:05.757
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
00:27:05.824 --> 00:27:06.758
OKAY --
00:27:06.825 --> 00:27:08.760
LET'S MOVE ON TO OUR NEXT AUTHOR
00:27:08.827 --> 00:27:10.829
WILL BE ASSEMBLY.
00:27:10.895 --> 00:27:13.965
A WOMAN CABALLERO YOU HAVE THREE
00:27:14.032 --> 00:27:14.733
MATTERS --
00:27:14.799 --> 00:27:17.335
IF IT'S ALRIGHT WITH YOU --
00:27:17.402 --> 00:27:18.937
MISS COVER EUROPE WE COULD YOU
00:27:19.004 --> 00:27:22.107
ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN A. B. TWO
00:27:22.173 --> 00:27:22.941
ZERO FIVE O. FIRST.
00:27:23.008 --> 00:27:26.378
I HAVE --
00:27:26.444 --> 00:27:32.083
CHANGE OF HEART ON MY ANALYSIS
00:27:32.150 --> 00:27:33.184
ALTHOUGH IT'S A COMPLICATED
00:27:33.251 --> 00:27:33.485
[inaudible]
00:27:33.551 --> 00:27:36.921
S.. THREE TIERED SYSTEM I'M
00:27:36.988 --> 00:27:39.391
PREPARED TO SUPPORT THE BILL IF
00:27:39.457 --> 00:27:40.692
WE CAN GET SOME AMENDMENTS TO
00:27:40.759 --> 00:27:41.826
ACHIEVE.
00:27:41.893 --> 00:27:43.061
MOVES DOWN THE PATH WHERE I
00:27:43.128 --> 00:27:45.630
THINK WE ALL WANT TO GO BUT MAKE
00:27:45.697 --> 00:27:45.797
IT.
00:27:45.864 --> 00:27:49.200
A LITTLE BIT MORE --
00:27:49.267 --> 00:27:50.468
STREAMLINED AS ADDING OUTLINED
00:27:50.535 --> 00:27:52.404
IN THE I'M --
00:27:52.470 --> 00:27:54.372
ANALYSIS BUT PLEASE GOOD MORNING
00:27:54.439 --> 00:27:56.941
AND WELCOME GOOD MORNING.
00:27:57.008 --> 00:27:58.777
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS THANK
00:27:58.843 --> 00:27:59.878
YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
00:27:59.944 --> 00:28:01.679
PRESENT AB TWENTY FIFTY THE
00:28:01.746 --> 00:28:03.448
SMALL SYSTEMS WATER AUTHORITY
00:28:03.515 --> 00:28:05.517
ACTIVE.
00:28:05.583 --> 00:28:06.384
TWENTY EIGHTEEN THE STATE WATER.
00:28:06.451 --> 00:28:07.719
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD HAS
00:28:07.786 --> 00:28:09.320
IDENTIFIED NEARLY THREE HUNDRED
00:28:09.387 --> 00:28:10.822
WATER SYSTEM STATEWIDE THE
00:28:10.889 --> 00:28:12.857
CHRONICALLY SERVE CONTAMINATED
00:28:12.924 --> 00:28:14.159
DRINKING WATER AND CANNOT
00:28:14.225 --> 00:28:15.527
PROVIDE THE RESIDENTS WITH A
00:28:15.593 --> 00:28:17.262
RELIABLE WATER SERVICE.
00:28:17.328 --> 00:28:18.329
IT IS UNACCEPTABLE FOR
00:28:18.396 --> 00:28:19.798
CALIFORNIANS TO BE SO POORLY
00:28:19.864 --> 00:28:20.598
SERVED MANY OF WHOM ARE MY
00:28:20.665 --> 00:28:22.734
CONSTITUENTS. ONE METHOD FOR
00:28:22.801 --> 00:28:24.102
ADDRESSING THIS PROBLEM IS TO
00:28:24.169 --> 00:28:25.970
MERGE FAILING SYSTEMS.
00:28:26.037 --> 00:28:27.639
TRADITIONAL CONSOLIDATIONS MUST
00:28:27.705 --> 00:28:30.442
RELY ON A LARGER HOST AGENCY TO
00:28:30.508 --> 00:28:32.343
FACILITATE THE CONSOLIDATION.
00:28:32.410 --> 00:28:33.945
AB TWENTY FIFTY PROVIDES AN
00:28:34.012 --> 00:28:35.713
ALTERNATE SOLUTION BY MERGING
00:28:35.780 --> 00:28:38.049
SMALL NONCOMPLIANT WATER SYSTEMS
00:28:38.116 --> 00:28:40.051
INTO A LARGER MORE ROBUST PUBLIC
00:28:40.118 --> 00:28:41.119
WATER SYSTEM THAT CAN TAKE
00:28:41.186 --> 00:28:42.420
ADVANTAGE OF IMPROVED ECONOMIES
00:28:42.487 --> 00:28:43.788
OF SCALE.
00:28:43.855 --> 00:28:45.723
STREAMLINED MANAGERIAL FUNCTIONS
00:28:45.790 --> 00:28:48.226
AND ENHANCED FINANCIAL CAPACITY
00:28:48.293 --> 00:28:50.195
WITH A LARGER RATE PAYER BASE.
00:28:50.261 --> 00:28:52.197
THE MERCH SYSTEM WILL BE FORMED
00:28:52.263 --> 00:28:53.932
AS INDEPENDENT SPECIAL DISTRICTS
00:28:53.998 --> 00:28:55.500
AND PROVIDED WITH NEW INTERNAL
00:28:55.567 --> 00:28:56.534
AND EXTERNAL FINANCING
00:28:56.601 --> 00:28:58.903
OPPORTUNITIES AND INCREASED
00:28:58.970 --> 00:29:00.672
TRANSPARENCY INCLUDING AN
00:29:00.738 --> 00:29:02.307
ELECTED BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
00:29:02.373 --> 00:29:03.741
THE NEW PUBLIC AUTHORITIES WILL
00:29:03.808 --> 00:29:06.077
BE SCALED TO DEVELOP COORDINATE.
00:29:06.144 --> 00:29:07.745
OR CONTRACT THROUGH REGIONAL
00:29:07.812 --> 00:29:09.347
AGREEMENTS IN ORDER TO PROVIDE
00:29:09.414 --> 00:29:11.149
THE NECESSARY INFRASTRUCTURE. TO
00:29:11.216 --> 00:29:13.084
TREAT CONTAMINATED ISSUES.
00:29:13.151 --> 00:29:14.953
THIS IN TURN WILL LEAD TO A MORE
00:29:15.019 --> 00:29:16.221
SUSTAINABLE WATER SYSTEM.
00:29:16.287 --> 00:29:17.889
THAT CAN EFFECTIVELY DELIVER
00:29:17.956 --> 00:29:18.456
SAFE AND AFFORDABLE DRINKING
00:29:18.523 --> 00:29:20.191
WATER.
00:29:20.258 --> 00:29:22.060
NEWLY FORMED LOCAL PUBLIC
00:29:22.127 --> 00:29:23.128
AUTHORITIES WILL INCUR THE COST
00:29:23.194 --> 00:29:24.863
OF CONSOLIDATION AND AS A
00:29:24.929 --> 00:29:26.064
CALIFORNIA LAB COAT.
00:29:26.131 --> 00:29:28.233
SUPPORT LETTER INDICATES AB
00:29:28.299 --> 00:29:29.367
TWENTY FIFTY ADEQUATELY PROVIDES
00:29:29.434 --> 00:29:30.535
FUNDING FOR THE LOCAL
00:29:30.602 --> 00:29:31.069
AUTHORITIES TO MEET THEIR
00:29:31.136 --> 00:29:32.504
OBLIGATIONS.
00:29:32.570 --> 00:29:33.938
THE DISTRICTS GAIN ADVANTAGE OF
00:29:34.005 --> 00:29:35.473
STATE BACKING AS ALL LOCAL
00:29:35.540 --> 00:29:37.075
DISTRICTS OPERATE TODAY.
00:29:37.142 --> 00:29:39.110
AB TWENTY FIFTY CHANGES NOTHING
00:29:39.177 --> 00:29:40.211
THERE AND SHIFTS NO DIRECT COSTS
00:29:40.278 --> 00:29:42.380
TO TAXPAYERS.
00:29:42.447 --> 00:29:44.082
IT ESTABLISHES A ROADMAP FOR THE
00:29:44.149 --> 00:29:45.116
CONSOLIDATION OF MULTIPLE
00:29:45.183 --> 00:29:47.152
SYSTEMS AND DOES NOT RELY ON A
00:29:47.218 --> 00:29:48.686
LARGER HOST AGENCY WHICH IS
00:29:48.753 --> 00:29:50.021
IMPORTANT AS MANY OF THE SYSTEMS
00:29:50.088 --> 00:29:51.289
MAY NOT BE ADJACENT TO A LARGER
00:29:51.356 --> 00:29:52.991
SYSTEM.
00:29:53.057 --> 00:29:54.792
THAT ROADMAP UTILIZES THE
00:29:54.859 --> 00:29:56.528
EXISTING STATUTORY PROVISIONS
00:29:56.594 --> 00:29:58.062
FOR MERGERS THE SOLUTIONS AND
00:29:58.129 --> 00:29:59.931
CONSOLIDATIONS IN THE LAUGH CHO
00:29:59.998 --> 00:30:00.832
LAW.
00:30:00.899 --> 00:30:02.167
COMING FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENT I
00:30:02.233 --> 00:30:04.135
FEEL STRONGLY THAT THE PROCESSES
00:30:04.202 --> 00:30:05.737
NEED TO BE DRIVEN LOCALLY IN AN
00:30:05.803 --> 00:30:07.972
OPEN PUBLIC FORUM SO AFFECTED
00:30:08.039 --> 00:30:09.741
PARTIES MAY PARTICIPATE.
00:30:09.807 --> 00:30:10.742
THAT IS WHY THE BILL DOES NOT
00:30:10.808 --> 00:30:12.076
SOLELY GIVE THE STATE WATER
00:30:12.143 --> 00:30:13.344
RESOURCES CONTROL BOARD
00:30:13.411 --> 00:30:15.079
OWNERSHIP OVER ALL PARTS OF THE
00:30:15.146 --> 00:30:16.714
CONSOLIDATION PROCESS BUT
00:30:16.781 --> 00:30:18.082
EMPOWERS THE BOARD WITH AN
00:30:18.149 --> 00:30:19.717
IMPORTANT NEW TOOL. TO FINALLY
00:30:19.784 --> 00:30:24.155
ROLL UP SMALL FAILING OPERATORS --
00:30:24.222 --> 00:30:26.057
AND IT DOES REQUIRE IN THE FIRST
00:30:26.124 --> 00:30:27.025
STEP IS WHAT THE STATE BY
00:30:27.091 --> 00:30:29.027
RESOURCE POOR TO DO YOU KNOW
00:30:29.093 --> 00:30:30.161
THAT LIKE AND WHAT THEY'VE WHAT
00:30:30.228 --> 00:30:31.963
THEY'VE BEEN DOING IT WE'VE GOT
00:30:32.030 --> 00:30:33.498
A VARIETY OF BILLS TO TRY.
00:30:33.565 --> 00:30:35.533
TO PUT SOME TEETH INTO THAT --
00:30:35.600 --> 00:30:37.468
EFFICIENCY STEP BY CORRECT
00:30:37.535 --> 00:30:40.271
MEDICINE PLAN STEP TO MY GUESS
00:30:40.338 --> 00:30:42.207
WOULD A NEW STEP.
00:30:42.273 --> 00:30:42.874
TO THAT'S CORRECT YOU ARE IN IN
00:30:42.941 --> 00:30:44.075
THE CHALLENGES OBVIOUSLY ARE
00:30:44.142 --> 00:30:47.512
THAT AND IN IN THE CURRENT
00:30:47.579 --> 00:30:49.147
PROCESS THERE ARE AREAS THAT
00:30:49.214 --> 00:30:50.815
HAVE BEEN GOING TO THIS PROCESS
00:30:50.882 --> 00:30:52.050
FOR YEARS AND HAVEN'T BEEN
00:30:52.116 --> 00:30:53.718
SUCCESSFUL IN PARTICULAR LIT IN
00:30:53.785 --> 00:30:54.719
PARTICULAR.
00:30:54.786 --> 00:30:56.054
TILLERY COUNTY WITH THINK WHERE
00:30:56.120 --> 00:30:57.555
THE CONSOLIDATION OF SEVEN SMALL
00:30:57.622 --> 00:30:58.957
SYSTEMS HAS BEEN ONGOING FOR
00:30:59.023 --> 00:31:00.458
OVER TEN YEARS.
00:31:00.525 --> 00:31:01.726
THIS BILL GIVES THE BOARD A NEW
00:31:01.793 --> 00:31:03.361
TOOL TO FINALLY DELIVER AND DATE
00:31:03.428 --> 00:31:04.762
CERTAIN FOR THOSE RESIDENTS IN
00:31:04.829 --> 00:31:06.297
TULARE COUNTY AND IN MONTEREY
00:31:06.364 --> 00:31:07.498
COUNTY AND THROUGHOUT THE STATE
00:31:07.565 --> 00:31:08.833
THAT HAVE SUFFERED WITH POOR
00:31:08.900 --> 00:31:10.335
WATER QUALITY.
00:31:10.401 --> 00:31:12.303
AND THAT AND AND IT'S A PROBLEM
00:31:12.370 --> 00:31:14.072
IS ATTAINABLE AND NOT TOO FAR
00:31:14.138 --> 00:31:15.807
AWAY. THREE YEARS AGO THE
00:31:15.873 --> 00:31:16.975
LEGISLATURE GAVE THE BOARD
00:31:17.041 --> 00:31:17.642
AUTHORITY TO ORDER
00:31:17.709 --> 00:31:19.310
CONSOLIDATIONS BETWEEN LARGE
00:31:19.377 --> 00:31:21.112
SYSTEMS AND SMALL SYSTEMS.
00:31:21.179 --> 00:31:22.647
IN THAT TIME JUST TO
00:31:22.714 --> 00:31:24.148
CONSOLIDATIONS HAVE OCCURRED
00:31:24.215 --> 00:31:24.616
MEANWHILE MANY OF MY
00:31:24.682 --> 00:31:26.751
CONSTITUENTS CONTINUE TO GO
00:31:26.818 --> 00:31:27.852
WITHOUT CLEAN WATER AND THE
00:31:27.919 --> 00:31:29.654
SOLUTION IN STATURE CLEARLY IS
00:31:29.721 --> 00:31:30.421
NOT SUFFICIENT TO PROTECT
00:31:30.488 --> 00:31:31.289
CALIFORNIANS.
00:31:31.356 --> 00:31:32.724
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
00:31:32.790 --> 00:31:34.192
VOTE AND THANK YOU FOR THE
00:31:34.259 --> 00:31:34.826
OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT THIS BILL
00:31:34.892 --> 00:31:35.393
TODAY [inaudible]
00:31:35.460 --> 00:31:37.629
FIRST WITNESS.
00:31:37.695 --> 00:31:39.264
THE FUTURE CHARACTERISTIC MEMBER
00:31:39.330 --> 00:31:40.932
SPOKE THANK YOU CHAIR WIECKOWSKI
00:31:40.999 --> 00:31:42.200
MEMBERS THE COMMITTEE ON PAUL
00:31:42.267 --> 00:31:44.068
JONES GENERAL MANAGER OF EASTERN
00:31:44.135 --> 00:31:45.136
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT AN
00:31:45.203 --> 00:31:46.838
AGENCY THAT PROVIDES WATER WASTE
00:31:46.904 --> 00:31:48.840
WATER RECYCLE WATER SERVICES.
00:31:48.906 --> 00:31:50.508
DAY EIGHT HUNDRED TWENTY
00:31:50.575 --> 00:31:51.109
THOUSAND RESIDENTS IN WESTERN
00:31:51.175 --> 00:31:52.810
RIVERSIDE COUNTY FIRST I'D LIKE
00:31:52.877 --> 00:31:53.745
TO THANK THE COMMITTEE FOR
00:31:53.811 --> 00:31:55.913
TAKING UP AB TWENTY FIFTY TODAY
00:31:55.980 --> 00:31:57.215
THAT LIKE TO ESPECIALLY THANK
00:31:57.282 --> 00:31:58.983
ASSEMBLY MEMBER CAVIAR FOR HER
00:31:59.050 --> 00:32:00.685
COMMITMENT AND DEDICATION TO
00:32:00.752 --> 00:32:01.386
THIS ISSUE.
00:32:01.452 --> 00:32:02.353
AS MENTIONED BY THE AUTHOR
00:32:02.420 --> 00:32:03.388
HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF
00:32:03.454 --> 00:32:04.656
CALIFORNIANS AND DISADVANTAGED
00:32:04.722 --> 00:32:05.957
COMMUNITIES THROUGHOUT THE STATE
00:32:06.024 --> 00:32:06.691
ARE REGULARLY SERVED
00:32:06.758 --> 00:32:07.992
CONTAMINATED DRINKING WATER
00:32:08.059 --> 00:32:10.194
THROUGH SMALL FAILING PUBLIC AND
00:32:10.261 --> 00:32:11.929
PRIVATE WATER SYSTEMS.
00:32:11.996 --> 00:32:13.231
OVER THE PAST DECADE I'VE HAD
00:32:13.298 --> 00:32:14.532
THE OPPORTUNITY TO BE INVOLVED
00:32:14.599 --> 00:32:15.900
IN NUMEROUS SUCCESSFUL
00:32:15.967 --> 00:32:17.435
CONSOLIDATIONS INCLUDING MOST
00:32:17.502 --> 00:32:19.704
RECENTLY A SMALL FAILING SYSTEM
00:32:19.771 --> 00:32:20.972
SERVING DISADVANTAGE COMMUNITY
00:32:21.039 --> 00:32:22.740
IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY.
00:32:22.807 --> 00:32:23.808
THE VAST MAJORITY OF THESE
00:32:23.875 --> 00:32:25.576
FAILING SYSTEMS LACK FINANCIAL
00:32:25.643 --> 00:32:27.745
RESOURCES ECONOMIES OF SCALE
00:32:27.812 --> 00:32:28.846
RATE BASIS OUR TECHNICAL
00:32:28.913 --> 00:32:30.948
CAPABILITIES TO MEET THEIR BASIC
00:32:31.015 --> 00:32:32.684
A CUSTOMER'S NEEDS.
00:32:32.750 --> 00:32:34.585
CLEARLY THE MOST EFFICIENT AND
00:32:34.652 --> 00:32:36.387
EFFECTIVE WAY TO ENSURE SAFE
00:32:36.454 --> 00:32:36.854
DRINKING WATER FOR THE
00:32:36.921 --> 00:32:38.589
COMMUNITIES IS TO REALLY CHANGE
00:32:38.656 --> 00:32:40.158
THE SERVICE DELIVERY MODEL BY
00:32:40.224 --> 00:32:42.126
REFORMING THE SMALL CHRONICALLY
00:32:42.193 --> 00:32:44.295
NONCOMPLIANT SYSTEMS INTO LARGER
00:32:44.362 --> 00:32:46.297
COMPETENT WATER AGENCIES.
00:32:46.364 --> 00:32:47.865
WHILE THERE ARE EXISTING
00:32:47.932 --> 00:32:49.267
STATUTORY AUTHORITIES TO
00:32:49.334 --> 00:32:50.902
IMPLEMENT CONSOLIDATIONS WE
00:32:50.968 --> 00:32:53.071
BELIEVE AB TWENTY FIFTY PROVIDES
00:32:53.137 --> 00:32:54.739
A POWERFUL DISH WILL TOOL WITH A
00:32:54.806 --> 00:32:56.808
DEFINED PROACTIVE PROCESS THAT
00:32:56.874 --> 00:32:58.843
WILL SIGNIFICANTLY ACCELERATE.
00:32:58.910 --> 00:33:00.111
THE NUMBER OF COMMUNITY WATER
00:33:00.178 --> 00:33:01.245
SYSTEMS THAT CAN BE BROUGHT INTO
00:33:01.312 --> 00:33:02.847
COMPLIANCE.
00:33:02.914 --> 00:33:04.515
IN DEVELOPING THE BILL WAS CMU
00:33:04.582 --> 00:33:06.050
AYE AND THE AUTHORS OFFICE WE
00:33:06.117 --> 00:33:07.185
COORDINATED WITH MULTIPLE
00:33:07.251 --> 00:33:10.288
pINCLUDING MUTUAL PRIVATE WATER
00:33:10.355 --> 00:33:11.989
COMPANY ASSOCIATIONS LAUGHTER
00:33:12.056 --> 00:33:13.725
REPRESENTATIVES PUBLIC WATR
00:33:13.791 --> 00:33:15.259
PROVIDERS ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
00:33:15.326 --> 00:33:16.227
ADVOCATES.
00:33:16.294 --> 00:33:17.962
IN STATE BOARD REPRESENTATIVES
00:33:18.029 --> 00:33:19.497
THE RESULT IS A BILL THAT DEFY
00:33:19.564 --> 00:33:21.666
PROVIDES IT TO FIND STEP BY STEP
00:33:21.733 --> 00:33:23.067
PROCESS AND MORE IMPORTANTLY A
00:33:23.134 --> 00:33:24.135
TIMELINE.
00:33:24.202 --> 00:33:26.070
EITHER BRING INTO COMPLIANCE OR
00:33:26.137 --> 00:33:28.473
DISSOLVE IN REFORM SMALL SYSTEMS
00:33:28.539 --> 00:33:29.807
THAT ARE CHRONICALLY SERVING
00:33:29.874 --> 00:33:31.242
CONTAMINATED WATER AND
00:33:31.309 --> 00:33:32.477
THREATENING PUBLIC HEALTH.
00:33:32.543 --> 00:33:34.245
THE BILL RELIES ON THE STATUTORY
00:33:34.312 --> 00:33:35.947
ROLE OF THE STATE BOARD EVALUATE
00:33:36.013 --> 00:33:37.582
SYSTEMS FOR WATER QUALITY
00:33:37.648 --> 00:33:39.183
COMPLIANCE AND IDENTIFY FOR
00:33:39.250 --> 00:33:40.585
DISSOLUTION THOSE SYSTEMS THAT
00:33:40.651 --> 00:33:41.652
ARE DEEMED INCAPABLE MEETING
00:33:41.719 --> 00:33:43.287
THOSE STANDARDS.
00:33:43.354 --> 00:33:45.089
USING A QUALIFIED APPOINTED
00:33:45.156 --> 00:33:46.758
ADMINISTRATOR THEIR FORMATION OF
00:33:46.824 --> 00:33:48.760
MORE COMPETENT SUCCESSOR WATER
00:33:48.826 --> 00:33:51.829
pTHE LOCALLY MANAGE LAUGH GO
00:33:51.896 --> 00:33:53.898
PUBLIC PROCESS USING EXISTING
00:33:53.965 --> 00:33:55.566
STATUTORY PROCEDURES.
00:33:55.633 --> 00:33:57.135
LEFT GO THEN --
00:33:57.201 --> 00:33:58.703
REVIEW THE PROPOSED FORMATIONS
00:33:58.770 --> 00:34:00.571
AND CONDITION EACH AMP TO
00:34:00.638 --> 00:34:02.140
IMPLEMENT PRESCRIBED OPERATING
00:34:02.206 --> 00:34:03.541
AND CAPITAL PLANTS THAT WILL
00:34:03.608 --> 00:34:04.842
RESULT IN WATER CAUGHT IT
00:34:04.909 --> 00:34:06.577
QUALITY COMLIANCE IN A
00:34:06.644 --> 00:34:08.212
SUSTAINABLE OPERATION. FOR
00:34:08.279 --> 00:34:09.881
DISSOLVE PRIVATE WATER COMPANIES
00:34:09.947 --> 00:34:11.382
FORMER OWNERS ARE COMPENSATED
00:34:11.449 --> 00:34:13.684
THROUGH DEFINE VALUATION PROCESS
00:34:13.751 --> 00:34:15.219
WHICH TAKES INTO ACCOUNT THE SIX
00:34:15.286 --> 00:34:17.121
SYSTEMS ASSETS BUT DEDUCTS ALL
00:34:17.188 --> 00:34:19.190
LIABILITIES INCLUDING THE COST
00:34:19.257 --> 00:34:20.458
TO BRING THOSE SYSTEMS.
00:34:20.525 --> 00:34:22.393
FAILING SYSTEMS INTO COMPLIANCE
00:34:22.460 --> 00:34:24.162
ANY RESIDUAL VALUE PAYMENTS
00:34:24.228 --> 00:34:25.763
WOULD BE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF
00:34:25.830 --> 00:34:26.931
THE NEWLY FORMED SUCCESSOR WATER
00:34:26.998 --> 00:34:29.467
AGENCY AND NOT THE STATE.
00:34:29.534 --> 00:34:30.768
THE BILL ALSO PROVIDES AN
00:34:30.835 --> 00:34:32.170
INDEPENDENT REVIEW PROCESS WITH
00:34:32.236 --> 00:34:33.638
A REPORT TO THE LEGISLATURE
00:34:33.704 --> 00:34:34.705
PREPARED BY THE COMPTROLLER'S
00:34:34.772 --> 00:34:36.340
OFFICE STATE BOARD AND OTHER
00:34:36.407 --> 00:34:37.875
STAKEHOLDERS TWO YEARS AFTER
00:34:37.942 --> 00:34:39.610
FORMATION.
00:34:39.677 --> 00:34:41.112
IN SUMMARY WHAT TRADITIONAL
00:34:41.179 --> 00:34:42.513
CONSOLIDATION PROCESS WITH
00:34:42.580 --> 00:34:44.449
LARGER HOST AGENCY PROVIDED
00:34:44.515 --> 00:34:45.516
UNDER CURRENT LAW STONE
00:34:45.583 --> 00:34:48.786
IMPORTANT TOOL WE BELIEVE AB
00:34:48.853 --> 00:34:49.320
TWENTY FIFTY TAKES A MORE
00:34:49.387 --> 00:34:51.022
COMPREHENSIVE SYSTEMATIC
00:34:51.088 --> 00:34:52.323
APPROACH THAT WILL RESULT IN
00:34:52.390 --> 00:34:53.658
PERMANENT REDUCTION.
00:34:53.724 --> 00:34:54.692
OF HUNDREDS OF FAILING WATER
00:34:54.759 --> 00:34:57.228
SYSTEMS AND MORE IMPORTANTLY IT
00:34:57.295 --> 00:34:58.930
WILL ULTIMATELY ENSURE THOUSANDS
00:34:58.996 --> 00:35:00.965
OF FAMILY SUAVE ACCESS TO SAFE
00:35:01.032 --> 00:35:02.166
AND RELIABLE DRINKING WATER ON A
00:35:02.233 --> 00:35:04.635
DAILY BASIS. FOR THESE REASONS I
00:35:04.702 --> 00:35:06.170
RESPECTFULLY URGE YOUR AYE VOTE
00:35:06.237 --> 00:35:07.271
ON AB TWENTY FIFTY THANK YOU
00:35:07.338 --> 00:35:09.474
VERY MUCH OUR PRESENTATION
00:35:09.540 --> 00:35:10.875
SOMEWHAT DIFFERENT FROM THE
00:35:10.942 --> 00:35:13.010
ANALYSIS THAT WE MAY BECAUSE
00:35:13.077 --> 00:35:15.046
THAT COST TO THE COMPENSATION TO
00:35:15.112 --> 00:35:15.780
THIS PRIVATE.
00:35:15.847 --> 00:35:18.516
WATER DISTRICTS OUR OUR NEMESIS
00:35:18.583 --> 00:35:19.650
IS THAT IT WILL BE BORNE BY THE
00:35:19.717 --> 00:35:20.618
STATE AS WELL AS THE
00:35:20.685 --> 00:35:22.119
ADMINISTRATORS WELL AS THE COST
00:35:22.186 --> 00:35:23.788
OF LAUGH GO SO THAT'S OBVIOUSLY
00:35:23.855 --> 00:35:25.356
ONE OF THE CONCERNS IS.
00:35:25.423 --> 00:35:26.357
YOU KNOW IT'S GREAT.
00:35:26.424 --> 00:35:28.292
IT INTENT HAVE THIS IS THAT THIS
00:35:28.359 --> 00:35:29.794
IS OUR FIRST FIX AND STATE JUST
00:35:29.861 --> 00:35:31.395
WRITE A CHECK AND AND WE DID WE
00:35:31.462 --> 00:35:33.498
BIN AND IN THIS BED SO YOU'RE
00:35:33.564 --> 00:35:35.066
SAYING THAT LIABILITY WOULD GO
00:35:35.132 --> 00:35:37.034
WANT TO THE NEWLY FORMED ENTITY
00:35:37.101 --> 00:35:37.335
[inaudible]
00:35:37.401 --> 00:35:41.672
WHICH FOR SAKE OF ARGUMENT.
00:35:41.739 --> 00:35:42.907
STILL GET HAVE SOME CHALLENGES
00:35:42.974 --> 00:35:43.774
BECAUSE JUST OF THE WHAT WERE
00:35:43.841 --> 00:35:45.877
WHAT WERE CONSOLIDATING I'M.
00:35:45.943 --> 00:35:47.512
SO I AM CONCERNED ABOUT HOW THAT
00:35:47.578 --> 00:35:48.913
THAT WHILE IT IS WE OWE YOU
00:35:48.980 --> 00:35:50.448
MONEY HOW THAT ACTUALLY GETS
00:35:50.515 --> 00:35:52.216
PAID OR WHAT THAT THAT WHAT THE
00:35:52.283 --> 00:35:53.518
CALCULATION WOULD BE SO THAT'S
00:35:53.584 --> 00:35:54.986
SORT OF WHEN YOU WHEN I'M
00:35:55.052 --> 00:35:56.087
TALKING ABOUT AMENDMENTS THE
00:35:56.153 --> 00:35:56.521
SUIT.
00:35:56.587 --> 00:35:57.855
THAT THE LOOK THE GRITTY LITTLE
00:35:57.922 --> 00:35:59.857
THINGS I'D LIKE TO IRON OUT SO
00:35:59.924 --> 00:36:01.659
THAT WE YOU KNOW.
00:36:01.726 --> 00:36:03.728
WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING TO
00:36:03.794 --> 00:36:05.663
FACILITATE THE THE CONSOLIDATION
00:36:05.730 --> 00:36:06.697
THAT WE HAVE [inaudible]
00:36:06.764 --> 00:36:08.466
NEXT WITNESS.
00:36:08.533 --> 00:36:09.567
DANIEL BLESSED WITH CALIFORNIA
00:36:09.634 --> 00:36:11.302
MUNICIPAL UTILITIES ASSOCIATION
00:36:11.369 --> 00:36:12.470
THANK YOU CHAIR AND MEMBERS FOR
00:36:12.537 --> 00:36:14.138
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK TODAY
00:36:14.205 --> 00:36:15.573
WE ARE PROUD BECAUSE SPONSORS
00:36:15.640 --> 00:36:16.641
AND SUPPORTERS.
00:36:16.707 --> 00:36:18.409
OF AB TWENTY FIFTY AS NOTED
00:36:18.476 --> 00:36:20.745
EARLIER AB TWENTY FIFTY SIX TO
00:36:20.811 --> 00:36:21.946
RETURN IMPORTANT GAP IN THE
00:36:22.013 --> 00:36:23.748
STATE'S CONSOLIDATION AUTHORITY.
00:36:23.814 --> 00:36:25.082
IT'S TRUE THAT THE BILL SAID
00:36:25.149 --> 00:36:26.117
THAT THE UNIQUE PROCESS FOR
00:36:26.183 --> 00:36:27.685
CONSOLIDATION THAT DOESN'T MAYOR
00:36:27.752 --> 00:36:29.220
EXISTING AUTHORITIES BUT WE
00:36:29.287 --> 00:36:30.321
BELIEVE THERE ARE SEVERAL
00:36:30.388 --> 00:36:32.123
IMPORTANT REASONS FOR THAT --
00:36:32.189 --> 00:36:33.257
FIRST WE BELIEVE A LOCALLY
00:36:33.324 --> 00:36:34.926
CONTROLLED PUBLIC PROCESS IS
00:36:34.992 --> 00:36:36.193
ESSENTIAL TO LONG LASTING GOOD
00:36:36.260 --> 00:36:37.828
GOVERNANCE WE BELIEVE CUSTOMERS
00:36:37.895 --> 00:36:39.597
CAN AND SHOULD FULLY PARTICIPATE
00:36:39.664 --> 00:36:41.866
IN DECISIONS RELATED TO THE SAFE
00:36:41.933 --> 00:36:42.366
DRINKING WATER IN THEIR
00:36:42.433 --> 00:36:43.301
COMMUNITIES.
00:36:43.367 --> 00:36:44.769
AB TWENTY FIFTY IS A COMPLEX
00:36:44.835 --> 00:36:46.070
BILL BECAUSE IT ENSHRINES
00:36:46.137 --> 00:36:47.638
FUNDAMENTAL STEPS THAT ENSURE
00:36:47.705 --> 00:36:49.140
COMMUNITIES WILL HAVE A VOICE IN
00:36:49.206 --> 00:36:50.608
THE FUTURE OF THEIR WATER SUPPLY
00:36:50.675 --> 00:36:52.243
FROM ENGAGEMENT IN COUNTY LAST
00:36:52.310 --> 00:36:54.345
GOES. TO SURVEYING ON AND
00:36:54.412 --> 00:36:55.846
LOCALLY ELECTED BOARD OF
00:36:55.913 --> 00:36:57.582
DIRECTORS SECOND --
00:36:57.648 --> 00:36:58.749
AS NOTED BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
00:36:58.816 --> 00:37:00.451
COVER EURO IT INCLUDES FIRM
00:37:00.518 --> 00:37:01.953
DEADLINES THROUGHOUT THE PROCESS
00:37:02.019 --> 00:37:03.588
IT'S BEEN SHOWN WHEN THE STATE
00:37:03.654 --> 00:37:05.089
BOARD HAS INCLUDED.
00:37:05.156 --> 00:37:06.591
FROM DEADLINES IN THEIR
00:37:06.657 --> 00:37:07.458
MANDATORY CONSOLIDATION
00:37:07.525 --> 00:37:10.361
AUTHORITY THEY DO WORK AND
00:37:10.428 --> 00:37:10.995
PEOPLE ARE GETTING SAFE DRINKING
00:37:11.062 --> 00:37:11.629
WATER.
00:37:11.696 --> 00:37:13.331
IT'S ALSO TRUE THIS WILL REQUIRE
00:37:13.397 --> 00:37:14.799
SIGNIFICANT RESOURCES TO
00:37:14.865 --> 00:37:15.933
IMPLEMENT --
00:37:16.000 --> 00:37:16.534
BUT WE ALL MUST STOP AND THINK
00:37:16.601 --> 00:37:20.204
FOR A MOMENT.
00:37:20.271 --> 00:37:21.272
OR IF WE CONTINUE WITH THE
00:37:21.339 --> 00:37:23.341
CURRENT PATTERN OF THE EXISTING
00:37:23.407 --> 00:37:24.575
AUTHORITIES WHERE THERE'S ONLY
00:37:24.642 --> 00:37:26.344
BEEN TWO CONSOLIDATIONS OVER
00:37:26.410 --> 00:37:27.244
THREE YEARS.
00:37:27.311 --> 00:37:29.213
EVEN AFTER INCLUDING VOLUNTARY
00:37:29.280 --> 00:37:30.748
CONSOLIDATIONS AND THAT NUMBER
00:37:30.815 --> 00:37:32.283
THERE STILL OVER THREE HUNDRED
00:37:32.350 --> 00:37:33.184
SYSTEMS AND HUNDREDS OF
00:37:33.250 --> 00:37:34.552
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE WHO DO NOT
00:37:34.619 --> 00:37:35.853
HAVE SAFE DRINKING WATER.
00:37:35.920 --> 00:37:37.221
WE BELIEVE THE TIME IS NOW TO
00:37:37.288 --> 00:37:38.456
ADDRESS THESE CHALLENGES WE
00:37:38.522 --> 00:37:40.257
BELIEVE AB TWENTY FIFTY PROVIDE
00:37:40.324 --> 00:37:41.792
SUSTAINABLE PATH FORWARD TOWARDS
00:37:41.859 --> 00:37:43.561
ACHIEVING THAT GOAL WE URGE OF
00:37:43.628 --> 00:37:45.096
AYE VOTE RIGHT WHERE WE WANT ONE
00:37:45.162 --> 00:37:46.263
QUIBBLE OVER.
00:37:46.330 --> 00:37:48.232
THE IDEA OF THE BENEFITS OF
00:37:48.299 --> 00:37:50.134
LOCAL CONTROL AND HAVING ARE THE
00:37:50.201 --> 00:37:51.902
QUEUE COMMUNITY PARTICIPATE WE
00:37:51.969 --> 00:37:53.537
KNOW THAT ONE THE PROBLEMS IS
00:37:53.604 --> 00:37:55.006
PUT ASIDE THE FINANCIAL.
00:37:55.072 --> 00:37:56.574
IT'S THE MANAGEMENT SKILLS THAT
00:37:56.641 --> 00:37:58.242
THAT WITHOUT THE SIR THIS IS
00:37:58.309 --> 00:38:00.745
WE'RE IN A DIFFERENT AGE WHEN A
00:38:00.811 --> 00:38:02.146
YOU KNOW A SCHOOL DISTRICT CAN
00:38:02.213 --> 00:38:03.981
ACT LIKE THE PREDICTABLY THE
00:38:04.048 --> 00:38:05.149
PRINCIPLE AND THAT.
00:38:05.216 --> 00:38:07.418
ARE THE HEAD OF THE WATER AGENCY
00:38:07.485 --> 00:38:08.619
THAT THE SCHOOL THE SCHOOLS ON
00:38:08.686 --> 00:38:10.554
SO WHILE I RESPECT THE LOCAL
00:38:10.621 --> 00:38:12.790
CONTROL WE THE BIGGER PROBLEM IS
00:38:12.857 --> 00:38:13.958
THAT THERE'S GONNA BE SOME
00:38:14.025 --> 00:38:15.626
INTERFACE WITH FOLKS BECAUSE
00:38:15.693 --> 00:38:18.295
BECAUSE THE EVIDENCE IS SHOWING
00:38:18.362 --> 00:38:19.563
THAT THEY'RE FEELING AND IT AND
00:38:19.630 --> 00:38:20.264
THEY REALLY.
00:38:20.331 --> 00:38:22.833
LACK THE MANAGERIAL CAPACITY
00:38:22.900 --> 00:38:25.036
FORGET THE DOUGH FOR A MINUTE
00:38:25.102 --> 00:38:27.204
THE MAC YOUR MANAGERIAL CAPACITY
00:38:27.271 --> 00:38:29.273
OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF AB TWO ZERO
00:38:29.340 --> 00:38:32.309
FIVE OO PLEASE COME FORWARD.
00:38:32.376 --> 00:38:34.345
SO LET'S ESTABLISHED QUORUM.
00:38:34.412 --> 00:38:35.746
ASSISTANT PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:38:35.813 --> 00:38:45.656
IT'S BECOME.
00:38:45.723 --> 00:38:47.391
FOR I HAVE MY CASTING HERE.
00:38:47.458 --> 00:38:48.693
S. DOWN HERE [inaudible]
00:38:48.759 --> 00:38:49.994
GAINES [inaudible]
00:38:50.061 --> 00:38:51.929
HILL [inaudible]
00:38:51.996 --> 00:38:53.698
LARA [inaudible]
00:38:53.764 --> 00:38:55.199
SKINNER [inaudible]
00:38:55.266 --> 00:38:57.068
STERN.
00:38:57.134 --> 00:38:58.969
QUORUM ESTABLISH THANK YOU FIRST
00:38:59.036 --> 00:39:00.571
WITNESS OUR NEXT WITNESS GOOD
00:39:00.638 --> 00:39:01.505
MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN THE
00:39:01.572 --> 00:39:02.940
MEMBERS MARINO HARASSING THE
00:39:03.007 --> 00:39:04.775
IRVINE RANCH WATER DISTRICT AND
00:39:04.842 --> 00:39:08.479
VERY STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
00:39:08.546 --> 00:39:09.747
GOOD MORNING A CHAIR OF MEMBERS
00:39:09.814 --> 00:39:11.148
OF THE COMMITTEE PAMELA MILLER
00:39:11.215 --> 00:39:12.316
REPRESENTING THIS STATE
00:39:12.383 --> 00:39:14.652
ASSOCIATION OF LAUGH BECAUSE AND
00:39:14.719 --> 00:39:16.420
WE AREN'T SUPPORT I WANT TO JUST
00:39:16.487 --> 00:39:18.122
TAKE A BRIEF MOMENT AND I THINK
00:39:18.189 --> 00:39:19.290
THE AUTHOR.
00:39:19.356 --> 00:39:21.392
AND THE SPONSORS OF THIS IS A
00:39:21.459 --> 00:39:23.461
VERY COMPLICATED PROCESS.
00:39:23.527 --> 00:39:24.929
VERY BIG PROBLEM NOT EASY TO
00:39:24.995 --> 00:39:26.297
SOLVE IF IT WAS.
00:39:26.363 --> 00:39:28.299
WE WOULDN'T HAVE THESE PROBLEMS.
00:39:28.365 --> 00:39:30.234
I AND THERE WAS A LOT OF DETAIL
00:39:30.301 --> 00:39:32.336
TO WORK THROUGH AND SO WE REALLY
00:39:32.403 --> 00:39:33.804
APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY.
00:39:33.871 --> 00:39:34.839
TO WORK THROUGH THE DETAILED
00:39:34.905 --> 00:39:37.875
PROCESS TO TRY TO GET IT RIGHT.
00:39:37.942 --> 00:39:39.477
AND SO WE WE THANK THEM FOR THAT
00:39:39.543 --> 00:39:41.245
ON IT IT'S IMPORTANT BECAUSE
00:39:41.312 --> 00:39:42.113
LAUGH BECAUSE DON'T HAVE
00:39:42.179 --> 00:39:43.914
AUTHORITY OVER THE MAJORITY OF
00:39:43.981 --> 00:39:46.317
THESE OF FAILING SYSTEMS AND SO.
00:39:46.383 --> 00:39:48.552
WE APPRECIATE THE OPPORTUNITY.
00:39:48.619 --> 00:39:50.788
TO BE INVOLVED IN THE PROCESS TO
00:39:50.855 --> 00:39:51.355
HELP GET IT RIGHT THANK YOU
00:39:51.422 --> 00:39:52.990
THANK YOU.
00:39:53.057 --> 00:39:53.491
GOOD MORNING --
00:39:53.557 --> 00:39:55.159
SPENCER SACKS OF FROM THE VOCAL
00:39:55.226 --> 00:39:56.727
GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE LONG
00:39:56.794 --> 00:39:57.995
BEACH WATER DEPARTMENT IN
00:39:58.062 --> 00:40:00.598
SUPPORT AND ALSO THE ASSEMBLY
00:40:00.664 --> 00:40:01.732
DINO VALLEY MINUTES FOR WATER
00:40:01.799 --> 00:40:03.968
DISTRICTS BOARD JUST MOVED FOR A
00:40:04.034 --> 00:40:05.436
SUPPORT POSITION ON THIS BILL.
00:40:05.503 --> 00:40:07.271
SO WILL BE FOLLOWING UP WITH A
00:40:07.338 --> 00:40:09.940
FORMAL LETTER SAYING THANK YOU.
00:40:10.007 --> 00:40:11.876
GOOD MORNING CURE ROUGHLY HALF
00:40:11.942 --> 00:40:12.443
OF THE CITY OF SACRAMENTO IN
00:40:12.510 --> 00:40:14.512
SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
00:40:14.578 --> 00:40:15.746
CAMERON'S AND ON BEHALF OF THE
00:40:15.813 --> 00:40:17.414
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
00:40:17.481 --> 00:40:21.418
COUNTIES IN SUPPORT.
00:40:21.485 --> 00:40:22.720
GOOD MORNING ROSY THOMPSON ON
00:40:22.787 --> 00:40:23.621
BEHALF OF METROPOLITAN WATER
00:40:23.687 --> 00:40:24.789
DISTRICT OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
00:40:24.855 --> 00:40:27.925
IN SUPPORT.
00:40:27.992 --> 00:40:29.226
GOOD MORNING STUFF ANYMORE WELL
00:40:29.293 --> 00:40:30.361
ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:40:30.427 --> 00:40:31.762
ASSOCIATION OF MUTUAL WATER
00:40:31.829 --> 00:40:36.333
COMPANIES IN SUPPORT.
00:40:36.400 --> 00:40:37.601
GOOD MORNING BETH A LOSS ON
00:40:37.668 --> 00:40:38.469
BEHALF OF INLAND EMPIRE
00:40:38.536 --> 00:40:40.237
UTILITIES AGENCY CUCAMONGA
00:40:40.304 --> 00:40:41.405
VALLEY WATER DISTRICT SEEN IN A
00:40:41.472 --> 00:40:42.873
WATERSHED PROJECT THIRTY ON
00:40:42.940 --> 00:40:43.574
SUPPORT.
00:40:43.641 --> 00:40:46.110
ALSO HERE FOR WESTERN MUNICIPAL
00:40:46.177 --> 00:40:46.710
WATER DISTRICT WHO COULDN'T BE
00:40:46.777 --> 00:40:48.646
HERE THINKING.
00:40:48.712 --> 00:40:49.680
GOOD MORNING AND CAN UNITS ON
00:40:49.747 --> 00:40:50.848
BEHALF OF THE ASSOCIATION OF
00:40:50.915 --> 00:40:51.782
CALIFORNIA WATER AGENCIES IN
00:40:51.849 --> 00:40:55.219
SUPPORT.
00:40:55.286 --> 00:40:56.787
MORNING GENE HURST HERE TODAY ON
00:40:56.854 --> 00:40:58.155
BEHALF OF THE RURAL COUNTY
00:40:58.222 --> 00:40:58.789
REPRESENTATIVES OF CALIFORNIANS
00:40:58.856 --> 00:41:01.058
SUPPORT.
00:41:01.125 --> 00:41:02.226
MORNINGS ARE STEELERS ON HAPPY
00:41:02.293 --> 00:41:03.360
LAS VIRGENES WATER DISTRICT
00:41:03.427 --> 00:41:05.129
MUNICIPAL WATER DISTRICT OF
00:41:05.196 --> 00:41:08.465
ORANGE COUNTY IN SUPPORT.
00:41:08.532 --> 00:41:09.567
GOOD MORNING ADAM ROBIN NORTHERN
00:41:09.633 --> 00:41:11.001
CALIFORNIA WATER ASSOCIATION IN
00:41:11.068 --> 00:41:14.371
SPORTS THAT YOU.
00:41:14.438 --> 00:41:16.040
MORNING AROUND YOUR BOSS YOU
00:41:16.106 --> 00:41:17.341
WITH THE CALIFORNIA SPECIAL
00:41:17.408 --> 00:41:21.078
DISTRICTS ASSOCIATIONS.
00:41:21.145 --> 00:41:22.279
WERE MISTER CHAIR OF SANDERS
00:41:22.346 --> 00:41:23.681
GLEN FOR ALL SAN DIEGO COUNTY
00:41:23.747 --> 00:41:25.883
WATER AUTHORITY ALSO IN SUPPORT.
00:41:25.950 --> 00:41:27.518
OPPOSITION TO A. B. TWO ZERO
00:41:27.585 --> 00:41:29.153
FIVE OO --
00:41:29.220 --> 00:41:45.536
PLEASE COME FORWARD
00:41:47.638 --> 00:41:47.705
.
00:41:47.705 --> 00:41:48.973
THE SENIOR LEADERSHIP COUNCIL
00:41:49.039 --> 00:41:50.674
FOR JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
00:41:50.741 --> 00:41:53.244
I'M WE HAVE WORKED ON THEY ISSUE
00:41:53.310 --> 00:41:55.012
OF SAFE DRINKING WATER IN SMALL
00:41:55.079 --> 00:41:56.480
COMMUNITIES FOR SEVERAL YEARS.
00:41:56.547 --> 00:41:58.015
ON ALONG WITH OTHER PEOPLE WHO
00:41:58.082 --> 00:41:59.717
WILL SPEAK TODAY AND WE ARE VERY
00:41:59.783 --> 00:42:01.452
VERY APPRECIATIVE OF THE AUTHOR
00:42:01.518 --> 00:42:02.820
AND THE SPONSORS ATTENTION TO
00:42:02.887 --> 00:42:03.954
THIS ISSUE.
00:42:04.021 --> 00:42:05.756
AND COMMITMENT TO ADDRESSING
00:42:05.823 --> 00:42:06.223
SAFE DRINKING WATER IN
00:42:06.290 --> 00:42:07.591
CALIFORNIA.
00:42:07.658 --> 00:42:09.793
AND A LOT OF OUR CONCERNS ARE
00:42:09.860 --> 00:42:11.829
ALSO REFLECTED IN THE ANALYSIS.
00:42:11.896 --> 00:42:13.998
THAT WE FEEL THAT THERE ARE
00:42:14.064 --> 00:42:15.299
BETTER WAYS TO ADDRESS WANT.
00:42:15.366 --> 00:42:16.867
TRICK WATER ISSUES IN SMALL
00:42:16.934 --> 00:42:17.768
COMMUNITIES.
00:42:17.835 --> 00:42:23.574
AND THAT THIS BILL LAYS OUT IN --
00:42:23.641 --> 00:42:24.775
WE HAVE.
00:42:24.842 --> 00:42:26.543
ON THE SPOKEN WITH THE SPONSORS
00:42:26.610 --> 00:42:28.846
AND AND THE AUTHORS OFFICE IN
00:42:28.913 --> 00:42:31.081
VERY AGAIN APPRECIATIVE OF THEIR
00:42:31.148 --> 00:42:31.749
I'M INTERESTED IN TALKING TO US
00:42:31.815 --> 00:42:32.750
IN WORKING WITH US.
00:42:32.816 --> 00:42:33.951
UNFORTUNATELY WE DID PRESENT
00:42:34.018 --> 00:42:35.386
SOME AMENDMENTS WHICH WE FELT
00:42:35.452 --> 00:42:37.087
ADDRESS SOME OF THIS ISSUE OF OF
00:42:37.154 --> 00:42:39.556
COST IN AND IN COMPLEXITY.
00:42:39.623 --> 00:42:41.725
ON WE ALSO FEEL THAT THERE ARE
00:42:41.792 --> 00:42:43.394
AGAIN AS THE ANALYSIS MENTIONED
00:42:43.460 --> 00:42:45.129
SEVERAL OTHER TOOLS CURRENTLY.
00:42:45.195 --> 00:42:47.131
IN THE STATE'S TOOLBOX THAT CAN
00:42:47.197 --> 00:42:48.232
BE CAN FURTHER UTILIZING
00:42:48.299 --> 00:42:50.301
IMPROVED AND THAT THIS CAN BE
00:42:50.367 --> 00:42:53.470
ADDED TO THAT TO THAT TOOLBOX --
00:42:53.537 --> 00:42:55.272
AND IF THIS AS AS THIS BILL
00:42:55.339 --> 00:42:57.541
PROCEEDS LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING
00:42:57.608 --> 00:42:58.175
WITH COMMITTEE AND THAT AUTHORS
00:42:58.242 --> 00:42:59.743
OFFICE IN THE SPONSORS TO
00:42:59.810 --> 00:43:01.078
IMPROVE THE BILL.
00:43:01.145 --> 00:43:02.780
EXPOSURE AS YOU MAY HAVE HEARD
00:43:02.846 --> 00:43:05.049
I'VE PASSED THE AUTHOR IF WE CAN
00:43:05.115 --> 00:43:07.151
IF IT TAKES YOU WILL BE INCLINED
00:43:07.217 --> 00:43:08.619
TO TAKE AMENDMENTS AS WE WORK
00:43:08.686 --> 00:43:10.120
THROUGH SOME OF THAT.
00:43:10.187 --> 00:43:11.855
NARROWING THE COSTLY IN THIS IN
00:43:11.922 --> 00:43:13.357
THE COMPLICATED MESS THAT'S BEEN
00:43:13.424 --> 00:43:15.125
RAISED BY THE OPPOSITION SO.
00:43:15.192 --> 00:43:16.527
WE'LL HEAR FROM THAT AUTHOR
00:43:16.593 --> 00:43:17.561
LATER.
00:43:17.628 --> 00:43:19.296
TAX WELL I'M GOING TO IT ANDREA
00:43:19.363 --> 00:43:20.631
ENTER WITH CLEAN WATER ACTION
00:43:20.698 --> 00:43:21.665
I'M GOING TO RESPECT YOUR
00:43:21.732 --> 00:43:23.100
REQUEST THAT WE NOT REITERATE
00:43:23.167 --> 00:43:24.802
COMMENTS ABOUT THAT WE HAVE
00:43:24.868 --> 00:43:25.903
ALREADY BEEN MADE.
00:43:25.970 --> 00:43:27.204
BUT I WOULD SUPPORT EVERYTHING
00:43:27.271 --> 00:43:29.606
THAT I MISS EATEN HAS JUST SAID
00:43:29.673 --> 00:43:31.308
WE DO THANK THE AUTHOR FOR HER
00:43:31.375 --> 00:43:32.910
COMMITMENT TO PROVIDING CLEAN
00:43:32.977 --> 00:43:35.212
AND SAFE AFFORDABLE WATER.
00:43:35.279 --> 00:43:36.413
TO ALL COMMUNITIES --
00:43:36.480 --> 00:43:37.781
BUT WE THINK THAT THERE ARE SOME
00:43:37.848 --> 00:43:39.950
STRUCTURAL PROBLEMS HERE THAT WE
00:43:40.017 --> 00:43:40.918
NEED TO WORK THERE.
00:43:40.985 --> 00:43:42.853
SO CAN I REASON WE'RE NOT IN
00:43:42.920 --> 00:43:44.588
SUPPORT YET OTHERS AND
00:43:44.655 --> 00:43:46.156
OPPOSITION TO A. B. GOT TWO ZERO
00:43:46.223 --> 00:43:49.093
FIVE OO.
00:43:49.159 --> 00:43:50.327
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS W. OARS
00:43:50.394 --> 00:43:52.062
WITH COMMITTEE WATER CENTER I
00:43:52.129 --> 00:43:54.498
WOULD JUST LIKE --
00:43:54.565 --> 00:43:56.133
TO I REITERATE ARE NOT REITERATE
00:43:56.200 --> 00:43:57.968
BUT TO SIDE WITH THE COMMENTS
00:43:58.035 --> 00:43:58.736
FROM MY COLLEAGUES WHO
00:43:58.802 --> 00:43:59.570
LEADERSHIP COUNCIL CLEAN WATER
00:43:59.636 --> 00:44:01.238
ACTION WE'VE BEEN CONTINUE TO
00:44:01.305 --> 00:44:02.106
WORK WITH.
00:44:02.172 --> 00:44:04.308
THE AUTHORS OFFICE AND HOPE TO
00:44:04.375 --> 00:44:06.210
CONTINUE --
00:44:06.276 --> 00:44:06.810
TO NARROWED KNOW THE SCOPE OF
00:44:06.877 --> 00:44:07.711
THIS BILL.
00:44:07.778 --> 00:44:09.747
THANK YOU OKAY.
00:44:09.813 --> 00:44:11.315
I LET'S CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING
00:44:11.382 --> 00:44:12.049
BRING IT TO THE DAIS QUESTIONS
00:44:12.116 --> 00:44:14.518
OF THE AUTHOR.
00:44:14.585 --> 00:44:16.286
SENATE STONE GOOD MORNING MISTER
00:44:16.353 --> 00:44:18.722
CHAIR OF COLLEAGUES --
00:44:18.789 --> 00:44:20.624
IS CABALLERO --
00:44:20.691 --> 00:44:21.792
I REALLY APPRECIATE YOU BRINGING
00:44:21.859 --> 00:44:23.627
THIS BILL FORWARD I THINK IT
00:44:23.694 --> 00:44:24.928
SHOULD BE ERA RIGHT.
00:44:24.995 --> 00:44:26.830
OF EVERY CALIFORNIAN TO BE ABLE
00:44:26.897 --> 00:44:30.134
TO HAVE SAFE DRINKING WATER --
00:44:30.200 --> 00:44:31.802
IT'S ALSO AGREED TO SEE MY
00:44:31.869 --> 00:44:32.803
FRIEND PAUL JONES HERE WHO I
00:44:32.870 --> 00:44:34.571
WORKED WITH FOR A NUMBER OF
00:44:34.638 --> 00:44:35.939
YEARS ON THE BOARD OF
00:44:36.006 --> 00:44:37.908
SUPERVISORS AND I'M DELIGHTED
00:44:37.975 --> 00:44:39.877
THAT AN AGENCY OF HIS SIZE IS
00:44:39.943 --> 00:44:41.612
HERE TO SUPPORT THIS BECAUSE I
00:44:41.678 --> 00:44:42.613
THINK WHEN YOU'RE.
00:44:42.679 --> 00:44:44.114
DEALING WITH --
00:44:44.181 --> 00:44:45.816
ROUGHLY THREE HUNDRED SYSTEMS
00:44:45.883 --> 00:44:46.316
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
00:44:46.383 --> 00:44:47.918
CALIFORNIA THAT ARE NOT
00:44:47.985 --> 00:44:50.087
FUNCTIONING PROPERLY --
00:44:50.154 --> 00:44:51.121
I THINK YOU SEE AN ECONOMY OF
00:44:51.188 --> 00:44:52.423
SCALE WHEN YOU'RE ABLE TO USE
00:44:52.489 --> 00:44:54.792
THEIR ENGINEERS ARE MANAGERIAL --
00:44:54.858 --> 00:44:56.693
OVERSIGHT AND YES THIS PROCESS
00:44:56.760 --> 00:45:00.898
IS GOING TO PENSIVE TO MODERNIZE
00:45:00.964 --> 00:45:02.066
IF YOU WILL THREE HUNDRED
00:45:02.132 --> 00:45:03.734
SYSTEMS BUT I WAS JUST CURIOUS
00:45:03.801 --> 00:45:05.235
SO WE WE MENTION THE BILL.
00:45:05.302 --> 00:45:06.537
OF THE WAS PASSED A COUPLE YEARS
00:45:06.603 --> 00:45:08.806
AGO TO FACILITATE THESE
00:45:08.872 --> 00:45:10.441
CONSOLIDATIONS AND YOU MENTIONED
00:45:10.507 --> 00:45:12.376
THAT THERE'S ONLY BEEN --
00:45:12.443 --> 00:45:14.144
TWO GERMAN IDEA WHY IT'S BEEN SO
00:45:14.211 --> 00:45:15.846
SPARSE LE AND HOW YOUR
00:45:15.913 --> 00:45:18.282
LEGISLATION CAN --
00:45:18.348 --> 00:45:20.217
MAKE THAT MUCH MORE SUCCESSFUL.
00:45:20.284 --> 00:45:21.018
WELL I AM I AM.
00:45:21.085 --> 00:45:22.653
I WOULD BE.
00:45:22.719 --> 00:45:24.988
FORCED TO SPECULATE BUT MY SENSE
00:45:25.055 --> 00:45:26.223
IS THAT IT THE THESE ARE JUST
00:45:26.290 --> 00:45:27.691
VERY DIFFICULT TO DO.
00:45:27.758 --> 00:45:30.394
AND UNLESS YOU HAVE WILLING.
00:45:30.461 --> 00:45:31.829
UP THE WAY THE SYSTEM IS SET UP
00:45:31.895 --> 00:45:32.896
IS YOU YOU DO YOUR
00:45:32.963 --> 00:45:33.964
CONSOLIDATIONS WITH NEIGHBORING
00:45:34.031 --> 00:45:35.933
WATER.
00:45:35.999 --> 00:45:37.634
ORGANIZATION INTO ENTITIES AND
00:45:37.701 --> 00:45:39.169
UNLESS THEY'RE WILLING TO TAKE
00:45:39.236 --> 00:45:41.605
YOU ON RIGHT AND THEN THAT MEANS
00:45:41.672 --> 00:45:43.107
TO ASSUME SOME OF THE DEBT AND
00:45:43.173 --> 00:45:44.508
THE BURDEN THEN IT BECOMES
00:45:44.575 --> 00:45:46.543
DIFFICULT TO FIND SOMEONE. TO TO
00:45:46.610 --> 00:45:47.878
COORDINATE WITH AND SO YEAH --
00:45:47.945 --> 00:45:49.413
THAT'S PART OF THE CHALLENGE I
00:45:49.480 --> 00:45:50.781
THINK IS THAT --
00:45:50.848 --> 00:45:52.182
IS THAT IS IT YOU KNOW WE NEED
00:45:52.249 --> 00:45:54.485
TO SET UP A SYSTEM THAT ALLOWS
00:45:54.551 --> 00:45:55.986
AND KIND AND ORDERLY TRANSFER
00:45:56.053 --> 00:45:56.887
AND THEN --
00:45:56.954 --> 00:45:59.289
IF YOU PUT --
00:45:59.356 --> 00:46:01.458
SYSTEMS TOGETHER THAT OR NOT.
00:46:01.525 --> 00:46:03.193
BIT ART DON'T.
00:46:03.260 --> 00:46:04.895
THAT AREN'T IN THE SAME A
00:46:04.962 --> 00:46:06.663
GEOGRAPHICAL AREA YOU'LL GET THE
00:46:06.730 --> 00:46:08.332
ECONOMIES OF SCALE THAT ALLOW
00:46:08.398 --> 00:46:09.833
YOU TO BE ABLE TO DO THINGS A
00:46:09.900 --> 00:46:10.801
LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY RIGHT.
00:46:10.868 --> 00:46:12.102
A I KNOW THAT ONE OF THE
00:46:12.169 --> 00:46:13.737
SUCCESSFUL CONSOLIDATIONS THAT
00:46:13.804 --> 00:46:15.305
WE HAD WAS ONE I THINK PAUL YOU
00:46:15.372 --> 00:46:16.473
WERE INVOLVED WITH LAKE ELSINORE
00:46:16.540 --> 00:46:17.841
FROM A MISTAKEN.
00:46:17.908 --> 00:46:19.776
AND I KNOW THE ISSUE OF
00:46:19.843 --> 00:46:22.880
LIABILITY WAS A BIG ISSUE --
00:46:22.946 --> 00:46:24.915
HAS THAT BEEN MITIGATED AS A
00:46:24.982 --> 00:46:27.384
PART OF THIS BILL OR POLITICS AT
00:46:27.451 --> 00:46:27.918
SOMETHING THAT WE NEED TO
00:46:27.985 --> 00:46:29.486
FURTHER REFINE.
00:46:29.553 --> 00:46:31.221
THAT THERE IS EXISTING STATUTORY
00:46:31.288 --> 00:46:33.891
PROTECTION FOR LIABILITIES.
00:46:33.957 --> 00:46:34.992
OKAY SO WE DON'T NEED TO DO ANY
00:46:35.058 --> 00:46:35.526
KIND OF AMENDMENTS TO THAT
00:46:35.592 --> 00:46:36.827
EFFECT --
00:46:36.894 --> 00:46:37.895
WILL THEN I WOULD JUST LIKE TO
00:46:37.961 --> 00:46:38.762
SAY THAT I'M THANK YOU FOR
00:46:38.829 --> 00:46:41.265
BRINGING THIS FORWARD --
00:46:41.331 --> 00:46:44.001
I KNOW ITS --
00:46:44.067 --> 00:46:45.335
A CHALLENGING TO SOME OF THE
00:46:45.402 --> 00:46:46.170
SMALLER DISTRICTS TO HAVE A
00:46:46.236 --> 00:46:47.337
LARGER DISTRICT COME AND TAKE
00:46:47.404 --> 00:46:48.472
OVER BUT THE BOTTOM LINE IS THAT
00:46:48.539 --> 00:46:50.040
WE HAVE FAILING SYSTEMS THAT ARE
00:46:50.107 --> 00:46:51.708
FAILING OUR CONSTITUENTS.
00:46:51.775 --> 00:46:52.176
AND I THINK THAT THE
00:46:52.242 --> 00:46:54.411
CONSOLIDATION WITHOUT THESE MORE --
00:46:54.478 --> 00:46:55.812
SUCCESSFUL --
00:46:55.879 --> 00:46:57.814
WATER AGENCIES AS A IS IS GOING
00:46:57.881 --> 00:46:58.982
TO BE AN ASSET WE KNOW IT'S
00:46:59.049 --> 00:47:00.284
GOING TO BE AN EXPENSE BUT CAN
00:47:00.350 --> 00:47:02.219
BE EXPENSE NO MATTER WHO --
00:47:02.286 --> 00:47:04.655
HAS TO UPGRADE THE SYSTEM SO
00:47:04.721 --> 00:47:05.923
SOMEBODY'S GOT TO PAY FOR IT I
00:47:05.989 --> 00:47:06.590
THINK WE'RE GONNA SEE SOME
00:47:06.657 --> 00:47:07.724
REFINEMENTS AND AMENDMENTS THAT
00:47:07.791 --> 00:47:09.726
ARE GOING TO DICTATE THAT --
00:47:09.793 --> 00:47:11.762
SHARING OF COST IF YOU WILL AND
00:47:11.828 --> 00:47:12.996
SO -- I
00:47:13.063 --> 00:47:13.630
WOULD LIKE TO TO MOVE YOUR BILL
00:47:13.697 --> 00:47:16.333
IN JUST SO WE'RE CLEAR ON THE
00:47:16.400 --> 00:47:18.769
MOTION IS THE AUTHOR --
00:47:18.835 --> 00:47:21.071
ACCEPTING OR DID TO WORK WITH
00:47:21.138 --> 00:47:22.339
THE COMMITTEE IN MYSELF IS TO AS
00:47:22.406 --> 00:47:23.874
HE GOES INTO GOVERNMENTS AND
00:47:23.941 --> 00:47:26.643
FINANCE TO A CRYSTAL I SOME OF
00:47:26.710 --> 00:47:27.477
THE AMENDMENTS THAT WILL.
00:47:27.544 --> 00:47:29.580
REDUCE THE COMPLICATED NISSEN
00:47:29.646 --> 00:47:31.682
COST OF IT OF THE AVAIL SENATOR
00:47:31.748 --> 00:47:33.650
I'M ALWAYS WILLING TO WORK IN
00:47:33.717 --> 00:47:36.353
AND TRY TO GET A BETTER PRODUCT.
00:47:36.420 --> 00:47:38.789
MORE THAN HAPPY TO DO THAT --
00:47:38.855 --> 00:47:40.791
AT IT.
00:47:40.857 --> 00:47:42.459
EIGHT A LITTLE BIT OF MY MY
00:47:42.526 --> 00:47:43.827
FRUSTRATION IS BANNED THAT THE
00:47:43.894 --> 00:47:45.662
PROCESS HAS BEEN SO EXPEDITED TO
00:47:45.729 --> 00:47:47.097
GET ALL OF THE BELLS.
00:47:47.164 --> 00:47:48.332
INTO THIS COMMITTEE THAT WE
00:47:48.398 --> 00:47:49.833
HAVEN'T HAD A CHANCE TO SIT DOWN
00:47:49.900 --> 00:47:50.601
AND KIND OF WORK THROUGH AND
00:47:50.667 --> 00:47:52.302
LOOK IT LANGUAGE BUT LET ME JUST
00:47:52.369 --> 00:47:53.971
SAY THAT FROM MY PERSPECTIVE
00:47:54.037 --> 00:47:55.906
THAT IF WE CAN DO THESE ON THESE
00:47:55.973 --> 00:47:56.506
COMPLICATED BILLS I'M I'M WITH
00:47:56.573 --> 00:47:57.674
YOU.
00:47:57.741 --> 00:47:59.209
SO THE ANSWER IS YES I DON'T AS
00:47:59.276 --> 00:48:00.377
I I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE SCHEDULE
00:48:00.444 --> 00:48:01.645
I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE HAD AN
00:48:01.712 --> 00:48:03.046
INPUT ON THAT OKAYED THERE IS A
00:48:03.113 --> 00:48:04.081
MOTION.
00:48:04.147 --> 00:48:07.851
OTHER OTHER QUESTIONS OF MEMBERS.
00:48:07.918 --> 00:48:10.254
THING OUT SO YOU'D LIKE TO ADD.
00:48:10.320 --> 00:48:11.755
AND IT JUST I RESPECTFULLY ASK
00:48:11.822 --> 00:48:13.156
YOUR AYE BOTH MARTY SENATOR FOR
00:48:13.223 --> 00:48:14.658
ALL OF THE HELP THAT YOUR STAFF
00:48:14.725 --> 00:48:15.826
HAS GIVEN IT'S BEEN.
00:48:15.892 --> 00:48:17.861
GREAT WORKING THINK YOU SENATOR
00:48:17.928 --> 00:48:19.529
ALRIGHT THERE'S A MOTION --
00:48:19.596 --> 00:48:21.898
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
00:48:21.965 --> 00:48:25.702
ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN AB TWENTY
00:48:25.769 --> 00:48:26.203
FIFTY BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
00:48:26.270 --> 00:48:27.004
CABALLERO.
00:48:27.070 --> 00:48:28.605
MOTION AS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
00:48:28.672 --> 00:48:30.040
THE SEVEN SENATE GOVERNANCE AND
00:48:30.107 --> 00:48:31.441
FINANCE COMMITTEE.
00:48:31.508 --> 00:48:33.810
AYE CASKEY AYE [inaudible]
00:48:33.877 --> 00:48:38.148
STONE.
00:48:38.215 --> 00:48:41.184
AS THE REST OF THE DAY.
00:48:41.251 --> 00:48:43.887
AB ON MEXICO BI AND NEVER ONCE.
00:48:43.954 --> 00:48:44.921
I'M SORRY I KNOW THAT YOU'RE
00:48:44.988 --> 00:48:45.222
[inaudible]
00:48:45.289 --> 00:48:48.292
AND IN A MOMENT OF EPIPHANY
00:48:48.358 --> 00:48:50.727
MOTION AS DO PASS AND MY CAL
00:48:50.794 --> 00:48:51.995
SCHEME AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE STONE.
00:48:52.062 --> 00:48:53.964
AYE STONE AYE GAINES.
00:48:54.031 --> 00:48:54.531
HILL.
00:48:54.598 --> 00:48:56.199
HILL AYE LARA [inaudible]
00:48:56.266 --> 00:48:58.468
SKINNER.
00:48:58.535 --> 00:49:01.171
STERN STERN AYE.
00:49:01.238 --> 00:49:02.673
OKAY THAT'S WILL KEEP THE ROLE
00:49:02.739 --> 00:49:04.441
OPEN PINCERS.
00:49:04.508 --> 00:49:05.409
IT'S A BUSY DAY TODAY FOLKS
00:49:05.475 --> 00:49:08.545
THERE LET SO MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER
00:49:08.612 --> 00:49:11.181
TWO BY MEMBERS THIS IS A BE AT
00:49:11.248 --> 00:49:11.882
THREE FOUR FIVE WITCHES.
00:49:11.948 --> 00:49:13.717
DEALS WITH EXEMPTIONS ON VEHICLE
00:49:13.784 --> 00:49:17.087
AIR POLLUTION [inaudible]
00:49:17.154 --> 00:49:19.222
PLEASE PROCEED.
00:49:19.289 --> 00:49:20.257
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
00:49:20.324 --> 00:49:21.925
SENATORS I AM PLEASED TO PRESENT
00:49:21.992 --> 00:49:23.393
AB.
00:49:23.460 --> 00:49:23.960
THREE FOUR FIVE WHICH WOULD
00:49:24.027 --> 00:49:25.495
STATUTORILY CLARIFY THE DIESEL
00:49:25.562 --> 00:49:27.731
BE VEHICLES DRIVING LESS THAN
00:49:27.798 --> 00:49:28.332
FIVE THOUSAND MILES ANNUALLY
00:49:28.398 --> 00:49:29.266
CALIFORNIA.
00:49:29.333 --> 00:49:30.367
ARE EXEMPT FROM THE CALIFORNIA
00:49:30.434 --> 00:49:31.635
AIR RESOURCES BOARD TRUCK AND
00:49:31.702 --> 00:49:33.403
BUS ROLE.
00:49:33.470 --> 00:49:35.105
IN DECEMBER OF TWO THOUSAND
00:49:35.172 --> 00:49:36.707
EIGHT R. BE ADOPTED ITS TRUCK
00:49:36.773 --> 00:49:37.307
AND BUS ROLE WHICH REQUIRED
00:49:37.374 --> 00:49:38.809
UPGRADES TO DIESEL TRUCKS TO
00:49:38.875 --> 00:49:41.111
REDUCE THEIR EMISSIONS.
00:49:41.178 --> 00:49:42.479
IT'S ESTIMATED THAT CALIFORNIA.
00:49:42.546 --> 00:49:44.314
HAD AT THAT TIME NEARLY ONE
00:49:44.381 --> 00:49:45.782
MILLION TRUCK SUBJECT TO THAT
00:49:45.849 --> 00:49:46.650
TRUCK RURAL.
00:49:46.717 --> 00:49:47.984
AND ACCORDING TO AIR BE THERE
00:49:48.051 --> 00:49:49.353
WERE FEWER THAN TWENTY THOUSAND
00:49:49.419 --> 00:49:50.487
TRUCKS REPORTING MILEAGE BELOW
00:49:50.554 --> 00:49:52.222
THE FIVE THOUSAND ANNUAL MILE
00:49:52.289 --> 00:49:53.690
MILEAGE THRESHOLDS.
00:49:53.757 --> 00:49:55.025
REPLACING THE STRUCK TO BE
00:49:55.092 --> 00:49:56.660
EXPENSIVE WITH LITTLE OVERALL
00:49:56.727 --> 00:49:58.328
MISSION BENEFITS TO DO THAT
00:49:58.395 --> 00:50:00.097
THEIR LOW LEVELS OF USE.
00:50:00.163 --> 00:50:02.999
FURTHERMORE THESE LOW USE TRUCKS.
00:50:03.066 --> 00:50:04.234
ARE NOT ELIGIBLE FOR FUNDING
00:50:04.301 --> 00:50:05.869
ASSISTANCE UNDER CALIFORNIA'S
00:50:05.936 --> 00:50:07.237
CARL MAURY PROGRAM WHICH
00:50:07.304 --> 00:50:09.005
PROVIDES FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO
00:50:09.072 --> 00:50:10.674
BE CALLS --
00:50:10.741 --> 00:50:11.742
TO REPLACE THE HIGH POLLUTING
00:50:11.808 --> 00:50:12.876
ENGINES WITH LOWER OR NON
00:50:12.943 --> 00:50:14.811
POLLUTING OPTIONS AND THE REASON
00:50:14.878 --> 00:50:15.779
FOR THAT IS BECAUSE THEY DON'T
00:50:15.846 --> 00:50:17.180
MEET THE COST EFFECTIVENESS
00:50:17.247 --> 00:50:18.415
STANDARDS REQUIRED BY THE
00:50:18.482 --> 00:50:19.916
PROGRAM.
00:50:19.983 --> 00:50:21.351
WE'RE SO AM IN OTHER WORDS
00:50:21.418 --> 00:50:22.986
REQUIRING REPLACEMENT OF THESE
00:50:23.053 --> 00:50:24.087
VEHICLES WHEN THEY ARE RARELY
00:50:24.154 --> 00:50:26.022
USED AT SIGNIFICANT COST WITHOUT
00:50:26.089 --> 00:50:27.357
PROVIDING THE COMMENSURATE AIR
00:50:27.424 --> 00:50:29.326
QUALITY BENEFITS. TO COMPLICATE
00:50:29.393 --> 00:50:31.261
THINGS FURTHER A RECENT
00:50:31.328 --> 00:50:32.195
APPELLATE COURT RULING HAS
00:50:32.262 --> 00:50:33.630
CREATED AN IMMEDIATE NEED FOR
00:50:33.697 --> 00:50:35.599
LEGISLATIVE CLARITY FOR THESE
00:50:35.665 --> 00:50:37.401
LOW LOW USE TRUCKS SUBJECT TO
00:50:37.467 --> 00:50:39.403
THE TRUCK ROLLED.
00:50:39.469 --> 00:50:41.405
I'M IN THE LITIGATION --
00:50:41.471 --> 00:50:43.874
BE TRUCKING ASSOCIATION SUIT THE
00:50:43.940 --> 00:50:46.743
ARB TO INVALIDATE THE TWO
00:50:46.810 --> 00:50:47.377
THOUSAND FOURTEEN AMENDMENTS TO
00:50:47.444 --> 00:50:48.545
THE TRUCK WELL WHICH WOULD HAVE.
00:50:48.612 --> 00:50:49.079
GIVEN SOME RELIEF TO THESE
00:50:49.146 --> 00:50:50.580
TRUCKS.
00:50:50.647 --> 00:50:52.449
OWNERS THE OUT ULTIMATE OUTCOME
00:50:52.516 --> 00:50:54.351
OF THAT LAWSUIT WAS DECIDED IN
00:50:54.418 --> 00:50:55.285
THE FIFTH DISTRICT COURT OF
00:50:55.352 --> 00:50:56.820
APPEALS EARLIER THIS YEAR ON A
00:50:56.887 --> 00:50:58.855
TECHNICAL PROCEDURAL BASIS AND
00:50:58.922 --> 00:51:00.190
THE TWO THOUSAND FOURTEEN
00:51:00.257 --> 00:51:01.258
AMENDMENTS. TO THE TRUCK ROVER
00:51:01.324 --> 00:51:02.426
SATISFIED.
00:51:02.492 --> 00:51:03.693
THIS DECISION MEANS THAT THE LOW
00:51:03.760 --> 00:51:05.896
USE TRUCKS CAN ONLY BE DRIVEN
00:51:05.962 --> 00:51:07.964
ONE THOUSAND MILES OR FEWER TO
00:51:08.031 --> 00:51:08.565
REMAIN IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE
00:51:08.632 --> 00:51:09.800
TRUCK WILL.
00:51:09.866 --> 00:51:11.768
IT REINSTATED THE OTHER THE OLD
00:51:11.835 --> 00:51:13.637
ORDER SO AB THREE FORTY FIVE
00:51:13.703 --> 00:51:14.771
WILL ALLOW FARMERS AND RANCHERS
00:51:14.838 --> 00:51:16.540
TO REPORT AGRICULTURAL TRACTS TO
00:51:16.606 --> 00:51:18.708
ARB AGAIN ALLOWING TRUCKS NOT
00:51:18.775 --> 00:51:20.710
SIGNED UP BY THE TWO THOUSAND
00:51:20.777 --> 00:51:22.312
FIFTY BY. TWO THOUSAND FIFTEEN
00:51:22.379 --> 00:51:23.413
TO GAIN ELIGIBILITY UNDER THE
00:51:23.480 --> 00:51:25.015
AGRICULTURAL VEHICLE EXTENSION
00:51:25.081 --> 00:51:27.117
PROGRAM SO LONG AS THEY SIGN UP
00:51:27.184 --> 00:51:29.853
BY JANUARY THIRTY FIRST.
00:51:29.920 --> 00:51:30.454
TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN THE BILL
00:51:30.520 --> 00:51:33.089
ALSO MAINTAINS THAT THE LOW.
00:51:33.156 --> 00:51:35.091
FIVE THOUSAND MILES ANNUALLY
00:51:35.158 --> 00:51:36.693
THIS WILL ALLOW THESE TRUCKS TO
00:51:36.760 --> 00:51:37.260
REMAIN IN USE FOR THE USEFUL
00:51:37.327 --> 00:51:38.462
LIFE.
00:51:38.528 --> 00:51:39.496
AND AVOID THE SIGNIFICANT
00:51:39.563 --> 00:51:41.164
INVESTMENT NECESSARY TO UPGRADE
00:51:41.231 --> 00:51:42.632
TRACKS THAT ARE DRIVEN SO
00:51:42.699 --> 00:51:43.667
INFREQUENTLY.
00:51:43.733 --> 00:51:45.035
AS THESE VEHICLES ARE DEEMED
00:51:45.101 --> 00:51:46.503
INELIGIBLE FOR THE CALL CARL
00:51:46.570 --> 00:51:48.772
MOYER FUNDING.
00:51:48.839 --> 00:51:50.073
THEY ARE BE HAS RECOGNIZED THE
00:51:50.140 --> 00:51:51.408
LOW LEVELS OF CUMULATIVE
00:51:51.475 --> 00:51:52.776
ADMISSIONS FROM THEM.
00:51:52.843 --> 00:51:54.478
AND WITHOUT SIGNIFICANT IMPACT
00:51:54.544 --> 00:51:57.314
TO OUR AIR QUALITY GOALS AB
00:51:57.380 --> 00:51:57.881
THREE FORTY FIVE WILL ALLOW
00:51:57.948 --> 00:51:58.849
BUSINESSES WHO HAVE VERY.
00:51:58.915 --> 00:52:00.484
LOW USE TRUCKS TO CONTINUE TO
00:52:00.550 --> 00:52:02.652
USE THEM --
00:52:02.719 --> 00:52:03.453
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR VOTE
00:52:03.520 --> 00:52:05.655
FIRST WITNESS.
00:52:05.722 --> 00:52:06.523
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
00:52:06.590 --> 00:52:07.858
MEMBERS KNOW CREAMERS OF
00:52:07.924 --> 00:52:08.325
CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU
00:52:08.391 --> 00:52:10.327
FEDERATION.
00:52:10.393 --> 00:52:12.128
AB THREE FORTY FIVE IS A PRETTY
00:52:12.195 --> 00:52:14.965
NARROW SIMPLE BELL FOR A A
00:52:15.031 --> 00:52:16.900
COMPLEX ISSUE.
00:52:16.967 --> 00:52:17.834
THE BILL WOULD HELP FARMERS AND
00:52:17.901 --> 00:52:18.835
RANCHERS WHO DEPEND ON TRUCKS TO
00:52:18.902 --> 00:52:21.271
HELP PLANT CARE FOR HARVESTING
00:52:21.338 --> 00:52:21.972
TRANSPORT THEIR CROPS AND
00:52:22.038 --> 00:52:24.374
LIVESTOCK.
00:52:24.441 --> 00:52:25.742
THE CALIFORNIA RESOURCES BOARD
00:52:25.809 --> 00:52:26.977
RECOGNIZE THE IMPACT THAT IT'S
00:52:27.043 --> 00:52:28.345
DIESEL TRUCK AND BUS REGULATION
00:52:28.411 --> 00:52:30.013
WOULD HAVE ON THE MANY TRUCKS
00:52:30.080 --> 00:52:31.715
YOU SEASONALLY BY AGRICULTURE.
00:52:31.781 --> 00:52:33.450
WHEN IT ADOPTED ITS REGULATIONS
00:52:33.517 --> 00:52:35.218
BY CREATING COMPLIANCE OPTION
00:52:35.285 --> 00:52:36.553
FOR AGRICULTURAL VEHICLES AND
00:52:36.620 --> 00:52:38.922
LOW USE VEHICLES?
00:52:38.989 --> 00:52:40.257
AB THREE FORTY FIVE ON SURE THAT
00:52:40.323 --> 00:52:41.224
AS MANY TRUCKS ELIGIBLE FOR
00:52:41.291 --> 00:52:43.326
COMPLIANCE WELL BE ABLE TO
00:52:43.393 --> 00:52:44.628
REGISTER WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF
00:52:44.694 --> 00:52:47.063
MOTOR VEHICLES BEGINNING AND
00:52:47.130 --> 00:52:47.631
TWENTY TWENTY WHEN DMB WILL
00:52:47.697 --> 00:52:48.832
BEGIN CHECKING WITH.
00:52:48.899 --> 00:52:50.233
CARP COMPLIANCE WHEN TRUCKS ARE
00:52:50.300 --> 00:52:52.736
REGISTERED SO THE COMPLIANCE
00:52:52.802 --> 00:52:54.337
OPTION IS FOR AGRICULTURAL
00:52:54.404 --> 00:52:56.139
TRUCKS.
00:52:56.206 --> 00:52:57.541
CURRENTLY AS LONG AS THEY'RE
00:52:57.607 --> 00:52:59.676
DRIVEN THEY SIGNED UP BY TWENTY
00:52:59.743 --> 00:53:00.544
FIFTEEN AND THEY'RE DRIVEN LESS
00:53:00.610 --> 00:53:01.845
THAN FIFTEEN THOUSAND MILES AND
00:53:01.912 --> 00:53:02.846
THEN STARTING IN TWENTY TWENTY
00:53:02.913 --> 00:53:03.880
THEY HAVE TO BE DRIVEN LESS THAN
00:53:03.947 --> 00:53:05.282
TEN THOUSAND MILES.
00:53:05.348 --> 00:53:06.483
AND THEN THOSE TRUCKS HAVE TO BE
00:53:06.550 --> 00:53:08.485
REPLACED BY TWENTY TWENTY THREE
00:53:08.552 --> 00:53:09.953
WHAT THIS BILL DOES ASSEMBLY
00:53:10.020 --> 00:53:11.221
GIVE A SECOND CHANCE FOR FOLKS
00:53:11.288 --> 00:53:13.223
TO SIGN THEIR TRUCKS.
00:53:13.290 --> 00:53:14.324
DOESN'T CHANGE THE MILEAGE
00:53:14.391 --> 00:53:16.026
LIMITATION AND THOSE TRUCKS WILL
00:53:16.092 --> 00:53:18.995
STILL HAVE TO BE REPLACED IN.
00:53:19.062 --> 00:53:19.596
TWENTY TWENTY THREE THE OTHER
00:53:19.663 --> 00:53:21.231
THING THAT THIS BILL DOES IS IT
00:53:21.298 --> 00:53:23.300
KEEPS THE LOW USE VEHICLE
00:53:23.366 --> 00:53:26.169
MILEAGE AT FIVE THOUSAND MILES
00:53:26.236 --> 00:53:28.572
ANNUALLY OR LESS RATHER THAN
00:53:28.638 --> 00:53:28.872
[inaudible]
00:53:28.939 --> 00:53:30.774
ONE THOUSAND OR LESS.
00:53:30.840 --> 00:53:32.976
NOW THE LAWSUIT THAT WAS FILED
00:53:33.043 --> 00:53:35.879
AND DROPPED THE FIVE THOUSAND
00:53:35.946 --> 00:53:37.981
TWO THOUSAND AND THE FIFTEEN
00:53:38.048 --> 00:53:38.949
THOUSAND TO TEN IMMEDIATELY BUT
00:53:39.015 --> 00:53:41.017
THIS BILL REALLY IS TO DEAL WITH
00:53:41.084 --> 00:53:42.919
THE FACT OF TRUCKS.
00:53:42.986 --> 00:53:45.522
BEING REGISTERED AT DMV IN
00:53:45.589 --> 00:53:46.489
TWENTY TWENTY THIS WILL ALLOW
00:53:46.556 --> 00:53:47.891
THEM TO BE MORE TRUCKS TO BE IN
00:53:47.958 --> 00:53:49.292
COMPLIANCE.
00:53:49.359 --> 00:53:50.727
NOW THAT FIVE THOUSAND MILE
00:53:50.794 --> 00:53:51.995
LIMIT I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT
00:53:52.062 --> 00:53:53.897
EVERYONE UNDERSTANDS.
00:53:53.964 --> 00:53:56.199
THERE ARE FORTY ONE HUNDRED
00:53:56.266 --> 00:53:57.667
TRUCKS APPROXIMATELY THAT ARE
00:53:57.734 --> 00:54:00.036
DRIVEN BETWEEN A THOUSAND MILES
00:54:00.103 --> 00:54:01.638
AND FOUR THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED
00:54:01.705 --> 00:54:03.173
NINETY NINE MILES.
00:54:03.239 --> 00:54:04.040
SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT FORTY ONE
00:54:04.107 --> 00:54:05.909
HUNDRED TRUCKS.
00:54:05.976 --> 00:54:08.445
NOW BUT THE AUTHOR.
00:54:08.511 --> 00:54:10.046
MENTIONED THAT THESE TRUCKS ARE
00:54:10.113 --> 00:54:11.715
NOT ELIGIBLE FOR CARL MOYER
00:54:11.781 --> 00:54:13.583
FUNDING THE LOW USE TRUCKS
00:54:13.650 --> 00:54:14.551
BECAUSE THEY DON'T MEET THE COST
00:54:14.618 --> 00:54:16.453
EFFECTIVENESS STANDARDS SO THAT
00:54:16.519 --> 00:54:18.555
MEANS THE STATE IS SAME YOU HAVE
00:54:18.622 --> 00:54:19.823
TO REPLACE THESE TRUCKS TO CLEAN
00:54:19.889 --> 00:54:21.625
OUR AIR.
00:54:21.691 --> 00:54:22.926
HOWEVER WE WON'T HELP YOU
00:54:22.993 --> 00:54:24.127
BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT GOING TO
00:54:24.194 --> 00:54:25.528
CLEAN THE AIR ENOUGH FOR IT TO
00:54:25.595 --> 00:54:26.496
MAKE MONEY FOR TO US INVEST IN
00:54:26.563 --> 00:54:28.832
THOSE [inaudible]
00:54:28.898 --> 00:54:32.068
EXACTLY INFREQUENTLY SO I'M WE
00:54:32.135 --> 00:54:33.770
THINK THAT THIS IS A VERY NARROW
00:54:33.837 --> 00:54:36.072
NARROWLY TAILORED BILL THAT WILL
00:54:36.139 --> 00:54:38.141
BE VERY HELPFUL FOR FOLKS WHO
00:54:38.208 --> 00:54:39.643
MISSED THE SIGN UP DEADLINE OR
00:54:39.709 --> 00:54:41.945
WHO DRIVE VERY LOW USE TRUCKS.
00:54:42.012 --> 00:54:42.479
AND WE WOULD RESPECTFULLY
00:54:42.545 --> 00:54:43.680
REQUEST YOUR AYE VOTE THIS NEXT
00:54:43.747 --> 00:54:47.584
WITNESS.
00:54:47.651 --> 00:54:49.052
A GOOD MORNING PAGES AB TWENTY
00:54:49.119 --> 00:54:50.620
MY NAME'S PETER RECI NORMALLY
00:54:50.687 --> 00:54:52.222
I'M ON THOSE TRACTORS AND TRUCKS
00:54:52.288 --> 00:54:52.856
IN THE MORNING --
00:54:52.922 --> 00:54:54.724
SO THIS IS ALL THERE FOR ME BUT
00:54:54.791 --> 00:54:56.192
I'M A FIFTH GENERATION FARMER.
00:54:56.259 --> 00:54:58.828
AND THE WE OWN OPERATE A SMALL
00:54:58.895 --> 00:55:00.597
FLEET OF COMMODITY VEHICLES THAT
00:55:00.664 --> 00:55:02.265
PUT OUT SOIL AMENDMENTS SUCH AS
00:55:02.332 --> 00:55:04.534
COMPOST IN GYPSUM --
00:55:04.601 --> 00:55:06.636
THOSE VEHICLES WOULD FIT IN THAT
00:55:06.703 --> 00:55:08.605
RANGE OF FIVE TO TEN THOUSAND
00:55:08.672 --> 00:55:09.873
MILES AT THE BEGINNING THEIR
00:55:09.939 --> 00:55:11.207
VERY EXPENSIVE VEHICLES THERE.
00:55:11.274 --> 00:55:12.242
ARE ANYWHERE FROM A QUARTER
00:55:12.308 --> 00:55:13.510
MILLION TO HAVE MILLION DOLLAR
00:55:13.576 --> 00:55:16.379
VEHICLES HE SAID WE HAVE ABOUT.
00:55:16.446 --> 00:55:17.847
SIX TO TEN OF THEM DEPEND ON THE
00:55:17.914 --> 00:55:19.315
SEASON -- I
00:55:19.382 --> 00:55:20.650
RECENTLY JOINED THE FAMILY
00:55:20.717 --> 00:55:21.317
BUSINESS HAVE BEEN FAR MY WHOLE
00:55:21.384 --> 00:55:22.585
LIFE I RECENTLY JOINED THE
00:55:22.652 --> 00:55:23.920
FAMILY BUSINESS.
00:55:23.987 --> 00:55:26.923
AND TO FIND OUT THAT WE HAVE A
00:55:26.990 --> 00:55:28.591
SHOULD SPECIFICALLY VEHICLES ARE
00:55:28.658 --> 00:55:30.694
OUT OF COMPLIANCE AND WE MISS
00:55:30.760 --> 00:55:32.529
THE TWENTY FIFTEEN DEADLINE TO
00:55:32.595 --> 00:55:34.464
SIGN UP SOME OF THESE VEHICLES
00:55:34.531 --> 00:55:35.632
THAT WE'VE ALWAYS JUST.
00:55:35.699 --> 00:55:37.567
DEEMED AS TRACTORS BUT THEY'RE
00:55:37.634 --> 00:55:39.736
BEING VIEWED AS TRUCKS BUT I
00:55:39.803 --> 00:55:41.037
WANT.
00:55:41.104 --> 00:55:42.505
TO I WANT TO MAKE THINGS RIGHT
00:55:42.572 --> 00:55:43.940
ONE SIGN HIM UP I WANT TO GET --
00:55:44.007 --> 00:55:46.609
GET ON THE ON THE GOOD SIDE --
00:55:46.676 --> 00:55:49.245
SO I APPRECIATE THIS OPPORTUNITY
00:55:49.312 --> 00:55:51.014
FOR PEOPLE LIKE US AND OUR
00:55:51.081 --> 00:55:52.382
CULTURE THAT YOU KNOW THE OLDER
00:55:52.449 --> 00:55:53.850
GENERATIONS GOING OUT.
00:55:53.917 --> 00:55:55.218
THE KIND THAT WERE REALLY PAY
00:55:55.285 --> 00:55:56.820
ATTENTION TO YOU KNOW THEY'VE
00:55:56.886 --> 00:55:57.821
BEEN RUN THE STRUCTURAL LIVES
00:55:57.887 --> 00:55:59.656
AND THEN THINK THEY REALLY NEED
00:55:59.723 --> 00:56:01.191
TO HAVE THIS STUFF SIGNED UP AND
00:56:01.257 --> 00:56:01.991
HARRY M..
00:56:02.058 --> 00:56:03.393
COMING AND GOING OKAY WE NEED TO
00:56:03.460 --> 00:56:04.360
MAKE THIS RIGHT IT'S NOT REALLY
00:56:04.427 --> 00:56:06.362
FEASIBLE REPLACE ALL THOSE
00:56:06.429 --> 00:56:07.831
VEHICLES THAT THOSE COSTS --
00:56:07.897 --> 00:56:09.265
ALL AT ONE TIME FOR THE BUSINESS
00:56:09.332 --> 00:56:10.400
JUST IN THEIR ELECTION THEIR
00:56:10.467 --> 00:56:12.001
SEASONAL VEHICLES WILL USE THEM
00:56:12.068 --> 00:56:12.802
FOR TWO THREE MONTHS.
00:56:12.869 --> 00:56:14.204
AND THEY MIGHT BE PARKED FOR THE
00:56:14.270 --> 00:56:17.307
REST OF THE YEAR --
00:56:17.373 --> 00:56:19.175
A THAT'S WITH BUT ALL I HAVE TO
00:56:19.242 --> 00:56:21.544
SAY I APPRECIATE IT NEXT PERSON
00:56:21.611 --> 00:56:23.980
IN FAVOR OF AB THREE FOUR FIVE
00:56:24.047 --> 00:56:24.547
HERE SINGLE BECKY WITH THE
00:56:24.614 --> 00:56:26.149
CALIFORNIA FORESTRY ASSOCIATION
00:56:26.216 --> 00:56:27.517
ALSO IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL.
00:56:27.584 --> 00:56:28.451
WE BELIEVE THAT THIS BILL COULD
00:56:28.518 --> 00:56:29.686
BE HELPFUL TO MEMBERS OF OUR
00:56:29.753 --> 00:56:31.254
ASSOCIATION AS WELL AS
00:56:31.321 --> 00:56:33.156
CONTRACTORS AND ESPECIALLY SMALL
00:56:33.223 --> 00:56:34.557
LANDOWNERS --
00:56:34.624 --> 00:56:38.661
ESPECIALLY FOR LOW USE VEHICLES --
00:56:38.728 --> 00:56:42.432
SELDOM USED ON ROAD VEHICLES
00:56:42.499 --> 00:56:43.800
WHAT IN THE FORESTRY WHAT.
00:56:43.867 --> 00:56:44.768
WHEN WHAT WHAT HOW WITH WHAT
00:56:44.834 --> 00:56:47.737
TYPE OF VEHICLE WE TALK ABOUT --
00:56:47.804 --> 00:56:49.539
WE COULD USE --
00:56:49.606 --> 00:56:51.941
LOT SELF LOADING LOGGING TRUCKS --
00:56:52.008 --> 00:56:53.009
INCIDENCES OF MIGHT BE WATER
00:56:53.076 --> 00:56:55.445
TRUCKS MOST OF OUR LOGGING
00:56:55.512 --> 00:56:57.380
TRUCKS WOULD PROBABLY EXCEED THE
00:56:57.447 --> 00:56:58.581
MILEAGE SO THEY WOULDN'T.
00:56:58.648 --> 00:57:00.750
PROBABLY QUALIFY.
00:57:00.817 --> 00:57:04.254
OKAY THANK YOU NECKS.
00:57:04.320 --> 00:57:05.121
GOOD MORNING JASON BROWN OF THE
00:57:05.188 --> 00:57:06.489
HALF THE WESTERN AYE DURING IN
00:57:06.556 --> 00:57:07.590
THE CALIFORNIA CATTLEMEN'S
00:57:07.657 --> 00:57:08.558
ASSOCIATION OR SUPPORT BILL
00:57:08.625 --> 00:57:12.495
THANK YOU THANK YOU.
00:57:12.562 --> 00:57:13.630
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
00:57:13.696 --> 00:57:14.898
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE LARA NO
00:57:14.964 --> 00:57:16.633
INTELLIGENT ON BEHALF OF AFRICAN
00:57:16.699 --> 00:57:18.368
AMERICAN FARMERS OF CALIFORNIA.
00:57:18.434 --> 00:57:19.435
CALIFORNIA CITRUS MUTUAL
00:57:19.502 --> 00:57:21.371
CALIFORNIA AGRICULTURAL AIRCRAFT
00:57:21.437 --> 00:57:22.739
ASSOCIATIONS CALIFORNIA DAIRY
00:57:22.806 --> 00:57:23.973
SINK.
00:57:24.040 --> 00:57:24.874
CALIFORNIA FRESH FRUIT
00:57:24.941 --> 00:57:27.143
ASSOCIATION NISSI FARMERS SLEEK
00:57:27.210 --> 00:57:28.244
AND WESTERN PLAN HEALTH
00:57:28.311 --> 00:57:29.879
ASSOCIATION AND CALIFORNIA RACE
00:57:29.946 --> 00:57:33.917
COMMISSION IN SUPPORT.
00:57:33.983 --> 00:57:35.051
GOOD MORNING CHAIRED MEMBERS SO
00:57:35.118 --> 00:57:36.085
SINBAD NOT WITH WHITE HOUSE
00:57:36.152 --> 00:57:37.787
PUBLIC AFFAIRS I'M HERE ON
00:57:37.854 --> 00:57:39.055
BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
00:57:39.122 --> 00:57:40.557
BEEKEEPERS ASSOCIATION SUPPORT
00:57:40.623 --> 00:57:43.927
ABOUT THANK YOU.
00:57:43.993 --> 00:57:44.427
GOOD MORNING KERR BLACK
00:57:44.494 --> 00:57:45.662
PRINTABLES LISTEN HAVE YOU SEE
00:57:45.728 --> 00:57:46.930
HERE ON BEHALF OF THE CALIFORNIA
00:57:46.996 --> 00:57:49.499
TOW TRUCK ASSOCIATION AND THE
00:57:49.566 --> 00:57:49.999
WESTERN STATES TRUCKING
00:57:50.066 --> 00:57:51.501
ASSOCIATION AND SUPPORT.
00:57:51.568 --> 00:57:54.270
OPPOSITION TO A. B. I HAVE THREE
00:57:54.337 --> 00:58:06.349
FOUR FIVE YOU CAN COME FORWARD.
00:58:06.416 --> 00:58:07.183
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
00:58:07.250 --> 00:58:08.251
MEMBERS BILL MCGOVERN WITH
00:58:08.318 --> 00:58:09.752
COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR YOU'LL
00:58:09.819 --> 00:58:11.221
BE HEARING THIS MORNING FROM A
00:58:11.287 --> 00:58:13.623
HANDFUL OF THE SEVENTEEN OR SO
00:58:13.690 --> 00:58:15.024
GROUPS ARE OPPOSING THIS BILL
00:58:15.091 --> 00:58:17.093
BECAUSE OF OUR CONCERNS ABOUT
00:58:17.160 --> 00:58:18.895
DIESEL POLLUTION.
00:58:18.962 --> 00:58:20.163
ART TO ME.
00:58:20.230 --> 00:58:22.165
THERE IS NO MORE IMPORTANT TASK
00:58:22.232 --> 00:58:25.301
THAN THIS COMMITTEE HAS VAN TO
00:58:25.368 --> 00:58:27.804
START BILLS LIKE THIS ONE THAT
00:58:27.871 --> 00:58:29.472
WOULD PUT EXEMPTIONS.
00:58:29.539 --> 00:58:31.140
IN LAWS THAT PROTECT OUR PUBLIC
00:58:31.207 --> 00:58:32.876
HEALTH.
00:58:32.942 --> 00:58:35.812
IN THIS CASE YOUR ANALYSIS SAYS
00:58:35.879 --> 00:58:37.814
GIVEN THAT AB THREE FORTY FIVE
00:58:37.881 --> 00:58:39.148
SETS A DANGEROUS PRECEDENT OF
00:58:39.215 --> 00:58:40.817
SUBVERTING THE STATE'S LAWS.
00:58:40.884 --> 00:58:43.052
OPEN AND FAIR REGULATORY PROCESS
00:58:43.119 --> 00:58:44.787
AND LEGAL SYSTEM BY SEEKING
00:58:44.854 --> 00:58:46.389
REDRESS IN THE LEGISLATURE.
00:58:46.456 --> 00:58:47.957
AND WILL HAVE HARMFUL IMPACTS ON
00:58:48.024 --> 00:58:49.659
PUBLIC HEALTH THE COMMITTEE
00:58:49.726 --> 00:58:50.994
SHOULD HOLD THIS MEASURE.
00:58:51.060 --> 00:58:53.596
AND WE AGREE THE DIESEL TRUCK
00:58:53.663 --> 00:58:55.198
AND BUS RULE WHICH HAS BEEN IN
00:58:55.265 --> 00:58:57.567
EFFECT NOW FOR ALMOST TEN YEARS.
00:58:57.634 --> 00:59:00.637
IS PROBABLY THE MOST IMPORTANT
00:59:00.703 --> 00:59:02.805
AND SUCCESSFUL MEASURE ADOPTED
00:59:02.872 --> 00:59:03.907
IN AT LEAST THE LAST TWENTY
00:59:03.973 --> 00:59:06.576
YEARS. FOR IMPROVING AIR QUALITY
00:59:06.643 --> 00:59:08.444
IN THIS STATE.
00:59:08.511 --> 00:59:11.414
SO WHILE WE STRONGLY URGE YOU TO
00:59:11.481 --> 00:59:12.682
HOLD THE BILL AND I'D LIKE TO
00:59:12.749 --> 00:59:14.250
TURN IT OVER TO KEVIN HALL CAME
00:59:14.317 --> 00:59:14.817
ALL THE WAY FROM FRESNO THIS
00:59:14.884 --> 00:59:16.386
MORNING.
00:59:16.452 --> 00:59:18.087
GOOD MORNING SENATOR SENATORS.
00:59:18.154 --> 00:59:19.756
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
00:59:19.822 --> 00:59:20.390
FOR YOUR TIME I DON'T HEAR VERY
00:59:20.456 --> 00:59:21.291
OFTEN --
00:59:21.357 --> 00:59:22.058
WE'VE ESTABLISHED A NEW
00:59:22.125 --> 00:59:22.859
ORGANIZATION CALLED VALLEY
00:59:22.926 --> 00:59:24.560
CLIMATE TO ADDRESS BOTH CLIMATE
00:59:24.627 --> 00:59:25.995
CHANGE IN THE POLITICAL CLIMATE
00:59:26.062 --> 00:59:27.196
IN THE SILICON VALLEY AND THE OF
00:59:27.263 --> 00:59:29.065
FAILURES THERE. TO ADDRESS BOTH
00:59:29.132 --> 00:59:31.467
ISSUES OF GROUND LEVEL.
00:59:31.534 --> 00:59:33.169
CLIMATE CHANGE OUR GREENHOUSE
00:59:33.236 --> 00:59:34.938
GAS EMISSIONS AND WE'RE HERE TO
00:59:35.004 --> 00:59:36.806
OPPOSE THIS BILL AND AND PERHAPS
00:59:36.873 --> 00:59:38.041
ADD TO THE STAFF REPORT IN DOING
00:59:38.107 --> 00:59:39.642
SO ON THE BACKGROUND NUMBER
00:59:39.709 --> 00:59:41.377
THREE WHAT'S NOT MENTIONED IS.
00:59:41.444 --> 00:59:42.845
TWENTY YEARS OF RESEARCH DONE IN
00:59:42.912 --> 00:59:45.949
FRESNO ON ON CHILDREN'S --
00:59:46.015 --> 00:59:47.583
CHANGES TO CHILDREN'S DNA A
00:59:47.650 --> 00:59:49.118
MUTAGENIC CHANGES THAT APPEAR TO
00:59:49.185 --> 00:59:50.687
BE HEREDITARY AND AFFECT THEIR
00:59:50.753 --> 00:59:52.088
IMMUNE SYSTEMS DIRECTLY THIS
00:59:52.155 --> 00:59:53.423
COMPOUNDED IN THE VALLEY BUYER
00:59:53.489 --> 00:59:54.891
STAGNANT AIR CONDITIONS.
00:59:54.958 --> 00:59:56.359
BOTH IN SUMMER AND FALL.
00:59:56.426 --> 00:59:58.962
ON MY DISTRIBUTED THIS HANDOUT
00:59:59.028 --> 01:00:00.163
HERE WITH JUST SOME QUICK
01:00:00.229 --> 01:00:01.597
EXAMPLES OF SOME OF THE ISSUES
01:00:01.664 --> 01:00:02.832
ONE OF WHICH SENATE YOU ASKED
01:00:02.899 --> 01:00:04.467
DIRECTLY QUESTION ABOUT.
01:00:04.534 --> 01:00:06.235
AND WE'VE OBSERVED AND FILMED ON
01:00:06.302 --> 01:00:07.670
THE SEASONAL ACT TRUCKS HAULING
01:00:07.737 --> 01:00:09.238
DOWN.
01:00:09.305 --> 01:00:11.541
S. OF FORESTRY WASTE MATERIALS
01:00:11.607 --> 01:00:13.476
GRINDING GROUND MATERIALS AND
01:00:13.543 --> 01:00:15.611
MATERIALS TO BE GROUND INTO THE
01:00:15.678 --> 01:00:18.047
RIO BRAVO --
01:00:18.114 --> 01:00:19.582
BIOMASS PLANT WHICH IS THE
01:00:19.649 --> 01:00:21.284
BOTTOM PICTURE ON THE THIRD PAGE
01:00:21.351 --> 01:00:24.554
EXCUSE ME BACK PAGE AND IT IS A
01:00:24.620 --> 01:00:26.456
MILE FROM AN ELEMENTARY SCHOOL.
01:00:26.522 --> 01:00:28.358
US THIS IS NO TRUCKS AND ON
01:00:28.424 --> 01:00:30.326
FIELD EQUIPMENT ARE VERY GROSS
01:00:30.393 --> 01:00:33.196
POLLUTERS AND INFREQUENT USE ICE.
01:00:33.262 --> 01:00:34.864
FRANKLY SUSPECT MILEAGES IS
01:00:34.931 --> 01:00:36.032
UNDER REPORTED.
01:00:36.099 --> 01:00:37.033
I ALSO INCLUDE A PICTURE THERE
01:00:37.100 --> 01:00:38.935
OF MEGA DARIUS YOU CAN SEE THE
01:00:39.002 --> 01:00:39.569
SCALE OF THESE OPERATIONS WHICH
01:00:39.635 --> 01:00:41.671
ARE -- NOT
01:00:41.738 --> 01:00:43.806
VERY WELL REGULATED AND OUR
01:00:43.873 --> 01:00:48.911
INDUSTRIAL SCALE OPERATIONS.
01:00:48.978 --> 01:00:50.346
DO YOU DO IT DISAGREE WITH THE
01:00:50.413 --> 01:00:51.981
ANALYSIS ON PAGE SIX THAT SAYS
01:00:52.048 --> 01:00:53.983
THAT THE AIRPORT COULD AMEND
01:00:54.050 --> 01:00:55.718
THIS OF A TRUCK AND BUS
01:00:55.785 --> 01:00:57.854
REGULATIONS INCLUDE SOME
01:00:57.920 --> 01:00:58.588
PROVISIONS THAT WERE STRUCK BY
01:00:58.654 --> 01:00:59.322
THE COURT.
01:00:59.389 --> 01:01:00.757
NOT HAVE NOTICED DISCRIMINATE
01:01:00.823 --> 01:01:01.624
ANY PART OF ANALYSIS
01:01:01.691 --> 01:01:01.924
[inaudible]
01:01:01.991 --> 01:01:05.161
NEXT WITNESS.
01:01:05.228 --> 01:01:06.262
GOOD MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS TOM
01:01:06.329 --> 01:01:07.497
EDISON WITH THE BAY AREA AIR
01:01:07.563 --> 01:01:08.931
QUALITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
01:01:08.998 --> 01:01:10.666
ADHERE TO RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE
01:01:10.733 --> 01:01:11.667
THE MEASURE.
01:01:11.734 --> 01:01:13.603
ARE A FEW POINTS THAT HAVEN'T
01:01:13.669 --> 01:01:14.804
BEEN MADE ARM [inaudible]
01:01:14.871 --> 01:01:16.439
FIRST.
01:01:16.506 --> 01:01:18.508
THERE'S THE ISSUE AS WE SEE IT
01:01:18.574 --> 01:01:20.510
OF A HUGE COMPETITIVE
01:01:20.576 --> 01:01:23.279
DISADVANTAGE TO THE LAW ABIDING
01:01:23.346 --> 01:01:25.448
FOLKS WHO PLAYED BY THE RULES.
01:01:25.515 --> 01:01:27.216
REPLACE THEIR VEHICLES.
01:01:27.283 --> 01:01:29.786
I END THIS BILL WILL FAVOR THOSE
01:01:29.852 --> 01:01:32.388
WHO DELAYED REPLACEMENT WHO
01:01:32.455 --> 01:01:34.223
DIDN'T SPEND THE CAPITAL.
01:01:34.290 --> 01:01:36.292
AND GIVE THOSE FOLKS A
01:01:36.359 --> 01:01:37.760
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE.
01:01:37.827 --> 01:01:39.328
OVER THE PEOPLE WHO DID PLAY BY
01:01:39.395 --> 01:01:41.130
THE RULES THAT'S AN ISSUE IN A
01:01:41.197 --> 01:01:42.899
PROBLEM AS WE SEE IT.
01:01:42.965 --> 01:01:44.967
THE SECOND ISSUE I THE BILL WAS
01:01:45.034 --> 01:01:46.436
OF COURSE NOT JUST ABOUT
01:01:46.502 --> 01:01:47.904
AGRICULTURAL VEHICLES THOUGH
01:01:47.970 --> 01:01:49.605
WILL USE EXEMPTION IS FOR ANY
01:01:49.672 --> 01:01:51.507
VEHICLE THE STATE OVER FOURTEEN
01:01:51.574 --> 01:01:52.875
THOUSAND POUNDS THAT'S A VERY
01:01:52.942 --> 01:01:54.777
SIGNIFICANT WEAKENING.
01:01:54.844 --> 01:01:56.746
OF TODAY'S AIR QUALITY
01:01:56.813 --> 01:01:57.847
REGULATIONS THAT INCREASE IN A
01:01:57.914 --> 01:01:59.849
MEASURE EARNS --
01:01:59.916 --> 01:02:01.484
WERE CONCERNED ABOUT THE PUBLIC
01:02:01.551 --> 01:02:02.718
HEALTH ASPECTS OF IT WERE
01:02:02.785 --> 01:02:04.554
CONCERNED THAT IN TWO THOUSAND
01:02:04.620 --> 01:02:06.022
AND EIGHT INTERFERE OPEN
01:02:06.089 --> 01:02:07.723
TRANSPARENT PROCESS.
01:02:07.790 --> 01:02:09.926
HOW WHERE COST EFFECTIVENESS AND
01:02:09.992 --> 01:02:11.828
TECHNICAL FEASIBILITY HAD TO BE
01:02:11.894 --> 01:02:13.729
CONSIDERED?
01:02:13.796 --> 01:02:14.831
A RULE WAS ADOPTED IT DECIDED
01:02:14.897 --> 01:02:18.234
UPON AND THERE WAS A COMPROMISE
01:02:18.301 --> 01:02:20.636
MADE THEN BY THE AIR RESOURCES
01:02:20.703 --> 01:02:21.804
BOARD AND PROPONENTS OF A
01:02:21.871 --> 01:02:23.072
TOUGHER RULE.
01:02:23.139 --> 01:02:25.174
THAT GRANTED THE CURRENT LOW USE
01:02:25.241 --> 01:02:26.342
EXEMPTION IN THE CURRENT
01:02:26.409 --> 01:02:28.811
AGRICULTURE REQUIREMENTS THAT WE
01:02:28.878 --> 01:02:30.346
HAVE IN PLACE TODAY.
01:02:30.413 --> 01:02:33.416
ARMED AND THIS WOULD CHANGE THAT.
01:02:33.483 --> 01:02:34.784
IN IN A WAY THAT WE THINK IS
01:02:34.851 --> 01:02:35.351
INAPPROPRIATE FROM A PUBLIC
01:02:35.418 --> 01:02:37.820
HEALTH PERSPECTIVE.
01:02:37.887 --> 01:02:41.791
NEXT'S ARE IN OPPOSITION TO AB.
01:02:41.858 --> 01:02:42.725
THREE FOUR FIVE ROBERT WITH THE
01:02:42.792 --> 01:02:43.793
AMERICAN LUNG ASSOCIATION ALSO
01:02:43.860 --> 01:02:45.428
IN OPPOSITION FOR ALL THE
01:02:45.495 --> 01:02:46.062
REASONS STATED BY THE WITNESSES
01:02:46.129 --> 01:02:48.965
THANK YOU.
01:02:49.031 --> 01:02:50.700
GOOD MORNING MA'AM AT THE END OF
01:02:50.766 --> 01:02:51.367
US BECAUSE WE HAVE FOR THE
01:02:51.434 --> 01:02:52.034
CALIFORNIA ROOMS JUSTICE
01:02:52.101 --> 01:02:54.237
ALLIANCE ALSO IN OPPOSITION FOR
01:02:54.303 --> 01:02:56.205
THE REASONS STATED THANK YOU.
01:02:56.272 --> 01:02:57.006
RETURN MEMBERS NIKITA CROWDED
01:02:57.073 --> 01:02:58.040
WITH THE NATURAL RESOURCES
01:02:58.107 --> 01:03:01.277
DEFENSE COUNCIL WOULD LIKE TO
01:03:01.344 --> 01:03:01.844
WHEN ARE COMMENTS WITH THE
01:03:01.911 --> 01:03:02.478
COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR IN THE
01:03:02.545 --> 01:03:04.547
BAY AREA YOU INTO THINKING.
01:03:04.614 --> 01:03:05.915
HE BE SEEING THEIR SHIP COUNCIL
01:03:05.982 --> 01:03:06.749
FOR JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY
01:03:06.816 --> 01:03:09.819
ALSO IN OPPOSITION.
01:03:09.886 --> 01:03:10.520
KYLE JOHNSON CIRCLE CALIFORNIA
01:03:10.586 --> 01:03:12.388
ALSO IN OPPOSITION.
01:03:12.455 --> 01:03:14.557
OKAY LET'S CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING
01:03:14.624 --> 01:03:15.992
BRING IT BACK TO THE DAY S.
01:03:16.058 --> 01:03:16.592
MEMBERS HAVE QUESTIONS CENTER
01:03:16.659 --> 01:03:19.896
STONE.
01:03:19.962 --> 01:03:22.298
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR --
01:03:22.365 --> 01:03:23.566
YOU KNOW THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
01:03:23.633 --> 01:03:24.901
PROBABLY HAS THE MOST AMBITIOUS
01:03:24.967 --> 01:03:26.202
AIR QUALITY STANDARDS AND
01:03:26.269 --> 01:03:27.336
REGULATIONS OF OF OF ANY OTHER
01:03:27.403 --> 01:03:28.871
STATE [inaudible]
01:03:28.938 --> 01:03:33.576
AND WE ACCEPT SOME MILESTONES --
01:03:33.643 --> 01:03:35.511
TO GET TRUCKS --
01:03:35.578 --> 01:03:36.913
TO BE CONVERTED TO MUCH --
01:03:36.979 --> 01:03:38.548
CLEANER --
01:03:38.614 --> 01:03:40.783
CLEAN AIR STANDARDS.
01:03:40.850 --> 01:03:43.319
AND AS I SEE THIS BILL IT'S THAT
01:03:43.386 --> 01:03:44.620
THE AUTHOR IS POINTED OUT ITS
01:03:44.687 --> 01:03:46.189
CAN AFFECT ABOUT FORTY ONE
01:03:46.255 --> 01:03:47.156
HUNDRED TRUCKS THAT ARE GONNA BE
01:03:47.223 --> 01:03:48.124
LIMITED TO FIVE THOUSAND MILES
01:03:48.191 --> 01:03:49.325
ON IT.
01:03:49.392 --> 01:03:50.660
WHILE THERE MAY BE OTHER
01:03:50.726 --> 01:03:52.328
INDUSTRIES BESIDES ADD THAT ARE
01:03:52.395 --> 01:03:53.563
GOING TO BE ABLE TO TAKE
01:03:53.629 --> 01:03:56.065
ADVANTAGE OF THAT THE SIGN ON TO
01:03:56.132 --> 01:03:59.001
THIS STANDARD --
01:03:59.068 --> 01:04:00.770
I THINK THAT'S GOING TO HAVE A
01:04:00.836 --> 01:04:02.772
DE MINIMIS EFFECT ON AIR QUALITY
01:04:02.838 --> 01:04:04.774
THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
01:04:04.840 --> 01:04:07.176
OF AG WE WE RECOGNIZED AS ONE OF
01:04:07.243 --> 01:04:08.611
THE LARGEST INDUSTRIES --
01:04:08.678 --> 01:04:11.380
IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA --
01:04:11.447 --> 01:04:11.647
NEXT -- TO
01:04:11.714 --> 01:04:13.149
ATTACK.
01:04:13.216 --> 01:04:14.317
ON NEXT TO ENTERTAINMENT A
01:04:14.383 --> 01:04:15.918
THROUGH THAT'S A THREE LEGGED
01:04:15.985 --> 01:04:17.220
STOOL OF OUR ECONOMY IN THE
01:04:17.286 --> 01:04:18.621
STATE OF CALIFORNIA.
01:04:18.688 --> 01:04:20.590
AND I THINK THIS IS A VERY SMALL
01:04:20.656 --> 01:04:22.358
CONCESSION --
01:04:22.425 --> 01:04:23.693
TO MAKE TO OF FARMERS.
01:04:23.759 --> 01:04:25.261
OF THEM IN STRUGGLING WITH SUCH
01:04:25.328 --> 01:04:27.496
THINGS AS HAS DROUGHT HIGHER
01:04:27.563 --> 01:04:29.298
COSTS FOR LABOR --
01:04:29.365 --> 01:04:30.733
RECENTLY --
01:04:30.800 --> 01:04:31.300
IT'S GOOD NOW ALLOW THEM TO
01:04:31.367 --> 01:04:33.836
BETTER COMPETE.
01:04:33.903 --> 01:04:35.371
WE'RE IN THERE THE PRODUCTS INTO
01:04:35.438 --> 01:04:36.706
THE STATE --
01:04:36.772 --> 01:04:38.441
AND IN AND IN THERE SHOULD BE A
01:04:38.507 --> 01:04:41.310
PHASE IN PERIOD TO ALLOW THEM TO
01:04:41.377 --> 01:04:44.413
INVEST AND MUCH MORE EXPENSIVE.
01:04:44.480 --> 01:04:45.047
CLEANER BURNING ENGINE
01:04:45.114 --> 01:04:45.348
[inaudible]
01:04:45.414 --> 01:04:46.816
FLEETS.
01:04:46.882 --> 01:04:49.085
AND SO I THINK IT'S GREAT THAT
01:04:49.151 --> 01:04:52.755
THEY'VE ALL SIGNED ON TO TWENTY
01:04:52.822 --> 01:04:53.856
TWENTY THREE ARE ONLY TALKING
01:04:53.923 --> 01:04:55.791
ABOUT ANOTHER --
01:04:55.858 --> 01:04:56.859
FIVE YEARS FOR THEM TO UTILIZE
01:04:56.926 --> 01:04:59.462
THE INVESTMENT ALLOW THEM TO
01:04:59.528 --> 01:05:00.830
CONTINUE TO DEPRECIATE THE THE
01:05:00.896 --> 01:05:02.131
SIGNIFICANT INVESTMENT THAT
01:05:02.198 --> 01:05:02.732
THEY'VE ALREADY MADE IN THEIR
01:05:02.798 --> 01:05:04.066
TRUCKS.
01:05:04.133 --> 01:05:05.268
AND SO --
01:05:05.334 --> 01:05:07.903
YOU KNOW I THINK THIS IS A A
01:05:07.970 --> 01:05:10.339
SMALL TOKEN OF OF OUR COMMITMENT
01:05:10.406 --> 01:05:11.407
TO THE AG INDUSTRIES THAT WE
01:05:11.474 --> 01:05:13.809
VALUE THEM AND WE WANT TO HELP
01:05:13.876 --> 01:05:14.543
THEM.
01:05:14.610 --> 01:05:17.146
A COMPLY WITH THE STANDARDS AT
01:05:17.213 --> 01:05:18.414
THE STATE HAS A AGGRESSIVELY SET
01:05:18.481 --> 01:05:21.083
ON ON BEHALF OF ALL CALIFORNIANS
01:05:21.150 --> 01:05:22.518
TO HAVE CLEANER.
01:05:22.585 --> 01:05:23.052
SO -- ALBEIT
01:05:23.119 --> 01:05:26.155
LOOKING TO SUPPORT THE BILL.
01:05:26.222 --> 01:05:27.123
CENTER.
01:05:27.189 --> 01:05:28.190
GIVES TO CHAIR.
01:05:28.257 --> 01:05:29.325
IT AND I REALLY APPRECIATE THE
01:05:29.392 --> 01:05:32.495
AUTHOR'S CAN USE.
01:05:32.561 --> 01:05:34.463
EFFORTS TO TRY TO SUPPORT HER
01:05:34.530 --> 01:05:37.566
COMMUNITIES AND THE THOSE THAT
01:05:37.633 --> 01:05:38.868
REALLY ARE STRUGGLING IN
01:05:38.934 --> 01:05:40.836
CALIFORNIA TO TRY TO MAKE IT.
01:05:40.903 --> 01:05:42.171
MAKE ENDS MEET BASICALLY BECAUSE
01:05:42.238 --> 01:05:43.906
IT IS A CHALLENGE.
01:05:43.973 --> 01:05:45.441
THE DIFFICULTY I HAVE WITH THIS
01:05:45.508 --> 01:05:47.443
IS I SAT ON CARBON TWO THOUSAND
01:05:47.510 --> 01:05:49.145
AND EIGHT AND VOTED FOR THE
01:05:49.211 --> 01:05:51.914
DIESEL AND TRUCK RULES SO IT --
01:05:51.981 --> 01:05:53.516
AT THAT TIME IT --
01:05:53.582 --> 01:05:55.418
WE HAD A CONSIDERABLE AMOUNT OF
01:05:55.484 --> 01:05:56.819
CONTROVERSY IN A CONSIDERABLE
01:05:56.886 --> 01:05:58.120
AMOUNT OF CONVERSATION AND
01:05:58.187 --> 01:06:00.389
DISCUSSION AND IN OPPOSITION TO
01:06:00.456 --> 01:06:02.091
THAT IT WAS A TOUGH DECISION AT
01:06:02.158 --> 01:06:03.426
THE TIME --
01:06:03.492 --> 01:06:04.660
AS THE TRUCKS WERE DRIVING
01:06:04.727 --> 01:06:06.329
AROUND THE BUILDING ON THAT DAY
01:06:06.395 --> 01:06:07.830
THE D. STIFF DIESEL TRUCKS
01:06:07.897 --> 01:06:09.865
LETTING US KNOW OF THEIR THEIR
01:06:09.932 --> 01:06:12.835
THOUGHTS TO IT BUT I I FELT THE
01:06:12.902 --> 01:06:15.338
AT THAT TIME THE THE STRUGGLE IN
01:06:15.404 --> 01:06:16.439
THE PAIN OF THOSE WHO HAVE A
01:06:16.505 --> 01:06:17.473
DIFFICULT TIME BREATHING.
01:06:17.540 --> 01:06:19.108
IN IN THE VALLEY AND AND THE
01:06:19.175 --> 01:06:20.576
AGRICULTURAL COMMUNITIES AND SO
01:06:20.643 --> 01:06:21.344
I WAS.
01:06:21.410 --> 01:06:22.611
COMMITTED TO MAKING THE CHANGES
01:06:22.678 --> 01:06:23.679
TO MAKE THAT.
01:06:23.746 --> 01:06:26.148
THAT WORK AND SO UNFORTUNATELY.
01:06:26.215 --> 01:06:28.484
THIS IS GONNA CONTRARY TO THAT
01:06:28.551 --> 01:06:29.585
VOTE IN THAT --
01:06:29.652 --> 01:06:31.687
THAT COMMITMENT I MADE IN TWO
01:06:31.754 --> 01:06:33.422
THOUSAND AND EIGHT AND WON'T BE
01:06:33.489 --> 01:06:35.358
ABLE TO SUPPORT IT TODAY.
01:06:35.424 --> 01:06:38.194
BUT I APPRECIATE THE WORK.
01:06:38.260 --> 01:06:39.929
ALRIGHT I AM.
01:06:39.995 --> 01:06:43.232
YOU MAY CLOSE.
01:06:43.299 --> 01:06:44.600
I THINK APPRECIATE THE LIVELY
01:06:44.667 --> 01:06:45.835
DISCUSSION --
01:06:45.901 --> 01:06:47.103
AT PART OF THE CHALLENGE I THINK
01:06:47.169 --> 01:06:49.171
WE HAVE BOMB IN TERMS OF SOME OF
01:06:49.238 --> 01:06:51.407
THESE RULES IS AN AT AND I THINK.
01:06:51.474 --> 01:06:52.708
THE AIRPORT TO THE RIGHT.
01:06:52.775 --> 01:06:54.643
THE RIGHT STANCE IN TERMS OF
01:06:54.710 --> 01:06:56.812
COMING UP WITH SOME --
01:06:56.879 --> 01:06:59.815
RULES AFTER UP THE INITIAL RULES
01:06:59.882 --> 01:07:01.717
WERE WRITTEN TO ALLOW --
01:07:01.784 --> 01:07:03.986
THE LITTLE USE VEHICLES ARE THAT
01:07:04.053 --> 01:07:08.057
LOW VEHICLE LOW MILEAGE VEHICLES
01:07:08.124 --> 01:07:10.860
UP TO HAVE A AID.
01:07:10.926 --> 01:07:14.563
EXTENSION ON IN TERMS OF IN THAT
01:07:14.630 --> 01:07:16.499
THEIR USAGE AND I WAS REALLY
01:07:16.565 --> 01:07:18.567
IMPORTANT UNFORTUNATELY WERE IN
01:07:18.634 --> 01:07:20.136
A POSITION WHERE THE COURT HAS.
01:07:20.202 --> 01:07:21.570
BASICALLY --
01:07:21.637 --> 01:07:24.740
UPON US OR STOP THAT PROCESS AND
01:07:24.807 --> 01:07:26.876
OUT ON IT ON ON PROCEDURAL
01:07:26.942 --> 01:07:29.145
ISSUES AND SO WE HAVE A NUMBER
01:07:29.211 --> 01:07:30.946
OF SMALL BUSINESSES IN MY
01:07:31.013 --> 01:07:32.681
COMMUNITY THAT ARE STRUGGLING --
01:07:32.748 --> 01:07:34.016
AND THAT --
01:07:34.083 --> 01:07:35.785
ARE WILL BE REQUIRED TO SPEND A
01:07:35.851 --> 01:07:39.188
WHOLE HECK OF A LOT OF MONEY ON
01:07:39.255 --> 01:07:41.957
REPLACEMENTS [inaudible] FOR IT
01:07:42.024 --> 01:07:45.027
VEHICLES AS YOU HEARD MR RE SAY
01:07:45.094 --> 01:07:46.295
THAT THEY THOUGHT WERE TRACTORS
01:07:46.362 --> 01:07:48.531
AS OPPOSED TO TRUCKS --
01:07:48.597 --> 01:07:49.365
AND SO IT ENDS UP HAVING A
01:07:49.432 --> 01:07:51.167
DISPROPORTIONATE IMPACT ON SMALL
01:07:51.233 --> 01:07:52.668
BUSINESSES AND PART OF THAT FEAR
01:07:52.735 --> 01:07:54.270
THAT I HAVE AS MUCH OF OUR
01:07:54.336 --> 01:07:55.938
REGULATION IS DRIVING BIGGER AND
01:07:56.005 --> 01:07:56.772
BIGGER.
01:07:56.839 --> 01:07:58.340
BUSINESSES THE SMALL BUSINESS
01:07:58.407 --> 01:07:59.909
OWNERS SCISSOR SELLING OUT TO
01:07:59.975 --> 01:08:01.510
THE BIGGER AG COMPANIES AND
01:08:01.577 --> 01:08:03.612
WE'RE GONNA SEE THE DEMISE OF
01:08:03.679 --> 01:08:04.680
THE FAMILY FARM.
01:08:04.747 --> 01:08:08.717
AND AND THE BIGGER ORGANIZATIONS
01:08:08.784 --> 01:08:09.919
AND WHILE THAT'S GOOD BECAUSE
01:08:09.985 --> 01:08:11.587
THEY PRODUCE.
01:08:11.654 --> 01:08:13.522
MUCH MORE AND THEY HAVE A CONDOM
01:08:13.589 --> 01:08:15.591
IS A SCALE I'M VERY SUPPORTIVE
01:08:15.658 --> 01:08:17.092
OF THE FAMILY FARMERS AND SO
01:08:17.159 --> 01:08:18.494
IT'S FOR THAT REASON THAT I
01:08:18.561 --> 01:08:19.595
PROPOSE THIS BILL.
01:08:19.662 --> 01:08:22.097
AS A WAITED TO ALLOW THEM.
01:08:22.164 --> 01:08:24.600
AT SUFFICIENT TIME TO BE ABLE.
01:08:24.667 --> 01:08:27.269
TO LICENSE THEIR VEHICLES AND
01:08:27.336 --> 01:08:29.505
EVENTUALLY TO BUY NEW VEHICLES
01:08:29.572 --> 01:08:31.707
DRAMATIZE THE COST.
01:08:31.774 --> 01:08:33.375
THANK YOU AND I I RESPECTFULLY
01:08:33.442 --> 01:08:35.144
ASK YOUR AYE VOTE I UNDERSTAND
01:08:35.211 --> 01:08:35.511
THE POSITION --
01:08:35.578 --> 01:08:37.446
THAT'S BEEN EXPRESSED.
01:08:37.513 --> 01:08:40.149
I'M OKAY DOES IS OUR MOST BY
01:08:40.216 --> 01:08:41.250
SENATOR STUNT.
01:08:41.317 --> 01:08:43.752
IS MOST BY CENTER STONE ARM I'M
01:08:43.819 --> 01:08:45.788
NOT PREPARED TO SUPPORT THE BILL
01:08:45.855 --> 01:08:47.923
TODAY I AM PREPARED GIVEN THE
01:08:47.990 --> 01:08:49.892
TESTIMONY THAT WE'VE HAD TO
01:08:49.959 --> 01:08:51.861
PANEL LETTER.
01:08:51.927 --> 01:08:54.363
TO A CHAIR NICHOLS SAID. TO HAVE
01:08:54.430 --> 01:08:57.833
HER TAKE ANOTHER LOOK AT THAT.
01:08:57.900 --> 01:08:58.734
THE TRUCKS THAT ARE AFFECTED BY
01:08:58.801 --> 01:08:59.768
THIS SO WITH THAT PLEASE CALL
01:08:59.835 --> 01:09:03.072
THE ROLL.
01:09:03.138 --> 01:09:07.643
ITEM NUMBER TWO AB.
01:09:07.710 --> 01:09:08.277
THREE FOUR FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
01:09:08.344 --> 01:09:09.044
COME A YEAR AGO.
01:09:09.111 --> 01:09:10.980
MOTION IS DUE PASSED THE SENATE
01:09:11.046 --> 01:09:12.815
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING COMMITTEE
01:09:12.882 --> 01:09:15.284
BY CASKEY NO.
01:09:15.351 --> 01:09:16.719
NO WIECKOWSKI NO STONE.
01:09:16.785 --> 01:09:17.987
STONE AYE GAINES [inaudible]
01:09:18.053 --> 01:09:19.588
HILL.
01:09:19.655 --> 01:09:22.358
HILL NO LARA [inaudible]
01:09:22.424 --> 01:09:24.627
SKINNER [inaudible]
01:09:24.693 --> 01:09:25.861
STERN NO [inaudible]
01:09:25.928 --> 01:09:28.364
STERN NO.
01:09:28.430 --> 01:09:30.499
I WILL KEEP THAT MATTER ON HOLD --
01:09:30.566 --> 01:09:32.868
LET'S MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER FIFTY
01:09:32.935 --> 01:09:36.105
FOUR THIS IS A B. --
01:09:36.171 --> 01:09:36.672
THIRTY THIRTY A OPPORTUNITY
01:09:36.739 --> 01:09:40.910
CELLS.
01:09:40.976 --> 01:09:42.077
PLEASE PROCEED THANK YOU MISTER
01:09:42.144 --> 01:09:43.546
CHAIRMAN SENATORS --
01:09:43.612 --> 01:09:44.747
FOR THE OPPORTUNITY PERCENT A.
01:09:44.813 --> 01:09:46.382
B. THIRTY THIRTY WHICH IS A
01:09:46.448 --> 01:09:48.183
MODEST ATTEMPT TO JOIN FORCES
01:09:48.250 --> 01:09:49.852
WITH THE FEDERAL CAO CAPITAL
01:09:49.919 --> 01:09:51.287
GAINS TAX CREDIT.
01:09:51.353 --> 01:09:53.522
DESIGNED TO FUNNEL AN ESTIMATED
01:09:53.589 --> 01:09:54.623
SIX TRILLION DOLLARS FROM
01:09:54.690 --> 01:09:56.759
CAPITAL GAINS EARNINGS INTO
01:09:56.825 --> 01:09:58.627
AMERICA'S POOREST NEIGHBORHOODS.
01:09:58.694 --> 01:09:59.762
EACH STATE WAS REQUIRED TO
01:09:59.828 --> 01:10:01.363
IDENTIFY OPPORTUNITIES ZONES
01:10:01.430 --> 01:10:02.932
WHICH ARE CENSUS TRACKS WHERE
01:10:02.998 --> 01:10:04.500
POVERTY IS THE HIGHEST AND MOST
01:10:04.567 --> 01:10:06.168
INTRACTABLE.
01:10:06.235 --> 01:10:07.303
THE DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY JUST
01:10:07.369 --> 01:10:09.338
CLOSE THIS NOMINATION PROCESS
01:10:09.405 --> 01:10:10.606
AND THEIR OVER EIGHTY SEVEN
01:10:10.673 --> 01:10:11.774
HUNDRED CENSUS TRACKS ACROSS THE
01:10:11.840 --> 01:10:13.676
UNITED STATES DESIGNATED AS
01:10:13.742 --> 01:10:15.377
OPPORTUNITIES OWNS.
01:10:15.444 --> 01:10:17.513
CALIFORNIA IDENTIFIED EIGHT
01:10:17.580 --> 01:10:18.747
HUNDRED AND SEVENTY NINE
01:10:18.814 --> 01:10:20.449
OPPORTUNITY SOUNDS DESPITE
01:10:20.516 --> 01:10:22.117
HAVING THE FIFTH LARGEST ECONOMY
01:10:22.184 --> 01:10:24.019
IN THE WORLD.
01:10:24.086 --> 01:10:26.255
AB THIRTY THIRTY ATTACKS POVERTY
01:10:26.322 --> 01:10:28.223
IN THESE EIGHT HUNDRED AND
01:10:28.290 --> 01:10:28.824
SEVENTY NINE DESIGNATED
01:10:28.891 --> 01:10:30.626
OPPORTUNITIES OWNS BY CREATING
01:10:30.693 --> 01:10:32.561
MARKET CONDITIONS FOR PRIVATE
01:10:32.628 --> 01:10:33.829
INVESTMENT CAPITAL TO REACH
01:10:33.896 --> 01:10:35.864
COMMUNITIES MOST IMPACTED BY
01:10:35.931 --> 01:10:37.433
CHRONIC PROPERTY WITHOUT
01:10:37.499 --> 01:10:38.667
COMMITTING A DOLLAR OF LOCAL OR
01:10:38.734 --> 01:10:40.302
STATE FUNDS.
01:10:40.369 --> 01:10:42.371
PRIVATE INVESTMENTS WILL CLOSE
01:10:42.438 --> 01:10:44.106
IN TWENTY TWENTY SIX SO THERE'S
01:10:44.173 --> 01:10:45.341
A SEVEN YEAR WINDOW TO TAP INTO
01:10:45.407 --> 01:10:46.775
THIS.
01:10:46.842 --> 01:10:47.977
A TRILLION DOLLAR MARKET A
01:10:48.043 --> 01:10:49.111
PRIVATE INVESTMENT THAT'S REALLY
01:10:49.178 --> 01:10:51.880
IMPORTANT IT'S IT IT'S A SEVEN
01:10:51.947 --> 01:10:52.581
YEAR --
01:10:52.648 --> 01:10:55.351
PROCESS AND AS YOU KNOW IF ANY
01:10:55.417 --> 01:10:56.919
PROJECT I DID START.
01:10:56.986 --> 01:10:58.887
OUT BE PROPOSED AND GO THROUGH
01:10:58.954 --> 01:11:00.189
AND IT AG AND A SEQUEL.
01:11:00.255 --> 01:11:02.958
PROCESS ON ITS OWN OUT WE
01:11:03.025 --> 01:11:03.559
WOULDN'T GET IT DONE IN SEVEN
01:11:03.626 --> 01:11:06.462
YEARS SO THAT WOULD BASICALLY.
01:11:06.528 --> 01:11:09.698
PROHIBIT THE USE OF THIS.
01:11:09.765 --> 01:11:11.567
GREAT OPPORTUNITIES OWN
01:11:11.634 --> 01:11:14.837
DESIGNATION IN CALIFORNIA AB
01:11:14.903 --> 01:11:15.671
THIRTY THIRTY CREATES A FAST
01:11:15.738 --> 01:11:16.639
TRACK TO NEW ECONOMIC
01:11:16.705 --> 01:11:17.673
DEVELOPMENT IN AFFORDABLE
01:11:17.740 --> 01:11:20.142
HOUSING IN OUR POOREST COMMUNITY
01:11:20.209 --> 01:11:21.644
BY EXEMPTING FROM SEAQUEST
01:11:21.710 --> 01:11:22.344
CERTAIN PROJECTS THAT MEET
01:11:22.411 --> 01:11:23.746
STRINGENT CONDITIONS ON THIS
01:11:23.812 --> 01:11:25.381
DOESN'T MEAN THAT THE PROJECTS
01:11:25.447 --> 01:11:26.248
HAVEN'T BEEN SECRET.
01:11:26.315 --> 01:11:27.850
ARE READY.
01:11:27.916 --> 01:11:29.151
EITHER THROUGH A GENERAL PLANTER
01:11:29.218 --> 01:11:30.552
SPECIFIC PLAN PROCESS IN THE IN
01:11:30.619 --> 01:11:32.454
THE COMMUNITIES.
01:11:32.521 --> 01:11:33.555
THE PROJECT IS EXEMPT FROM
01:11:33.622 --> 01:11:34.857
SECRET IF ITS FINANCED BY A
01:11:34.923 --> 01:11:37.059
QUALIFIED OPPORTUNITY FUND.
01:11:37.126 --> 01:11:39.094
AT LEAST 50% OF THE PROJECT IS
01:11:39.161 --> 01:11:40.562
AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND AT LEAST
01:11:40.629 --> 01:11:41.697
TWO THIRDS OF THE DEVELOPMENT
01:11:41.764 --> 01:11:43.032
SQUARE FOOTAGE IS DESIGNATED
01:11:43.098 --> 01:11:44.533
RESIDENTIAL.
01:11:44.600 --> 01:11:46.268
IT'S NOT LOCATED ON THE SITE
01:11:46.335 --> 01:11:47.236
REQUIRED DEMOLITION OF
01:11:47.302 --> 01:11:48.570
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR
01:11:48.637 --> 01:11:50.439
CONVERSION OF RENTAL PROPERTIES
01:11:50.506 --> 01:11:51.306
WHICH MEANS THERE'S NO
01:11:51.373 --> 01:11:53.542
DISPLACEMENT OF THE EXISTING
01:11:53.609 --> 01:11:54.710
RESIDENTS.
01:11:54.777 --> 01:11:55.944
IS CONSISTENT WITH THE GENERAL
01:11:56.011 --> 01:11:57.880
PLAN LAND USE DESIGNATIONS IN
01:11:57.946 --> 01:12:00.382
POLICIES ZONING AND MUNICIPAL OR
01:12:00.449 --> 01:12:02.418
COUNTY ORDINANCES POLICIES AND
01:12:02.484 --> 01:12:03.452
MEDICATION.
01:12:03.519 --> 01:12:04.720
COMPLIED WITH PREVIOUSLY
01:12:04.787 --> 01:12:06.789
APPROVED APPLICABLE MITIGATION
01:12:06.855 --> 01:12:08.691
MEASURES AND STANDARDS AND DOES
01:12:08.757 --> 01:12:10.492
NOT REQUIRE A WATER SUPPLY
01:12:10.559 --> 01:12:12.061
ASSESSMENT HAS AVAILABLE AND
01:12:12.127 --> 01:12:13.796
EXISTING UTILITIES AND SCHOOLS
01:12:13.862 --> 01:12:15.164
TO SERVE THE PROJECT.
01:12:15.230 --> 01:12:16.231
DOES NOT HAVE ANY RISK OF
01:12:16.298 --> 01:12:18.434
EXPOSURE TO HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES
01:12:18.500 --> 01:12:20.202
THAT EXCEED STATE LOCAL OR
01:12:20.269 --> 01:12:22.404
FEDERAL STANDARDS IS NOT LOCATED
01:12:22.471 --> 01:12:24.006
ON A SITE THAT HAS CULTURAL OR
01:12:24.073 --> 01:12:25.808
HISTORIC RESOURCES.
01:12:25.874 --> 01:12:27.309
AND IS NOT LOCATED ON THE SITE
01:12:27.376 --> 01:12:28.711
THAT IS FARMLAND WETLAND FLOOD
01:12:28.777 --> 01:12:30.579
AREA.
01:12:30.646 --> 01:12:31.914
THE LAND SUBJECT TO GROUND
01:12:31.980 --> 01:12:33.015
FAILURE DESIGNATED FOR
01:12:33.082 --> 01:12:35.117
PROTECTION OF NATURAL RESOURCES
01:12:35.184 --> 01:12:36.685
IT'S NOT UNDER A CONSERVATION
01:12:36.752 --> 01:12:38.053
EASEMENT AND DOESN'T HAVE ANY
01:12:38.120 --> 01:12:39.688
SIGNIFICANT IMPACT THAT YOU HAVE
01:12:39.755 --> 01:12:41.256
NOT BEEN PUBLICLY DISCLOSED
01:12:41.323 --> 01:12:42.825
ANALYZED AND MITIGATED AND I
01:12:42.891 --> 01:12:44.126
READ ALL OF THAT SO THAT YOU
01:12:44.193 --> 01:12:45.527
UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE.
01:12:45.594 --> 01:12:47.463
REAL PROTECTIONS --
01:12:47.529 --> 01:12:50.766
IN IN TERMS IN TERMS OF THE BILL --
01:12:50.833 --> 01:12:52.534
AB THIRTY THIRTY CREATES A LEVEL
01:12:52.601 --> 01:12:54.169
PLAYING FIELD ACROSS ALL OF
01:12:54.236 --> 01:12:56.538
CALIFORNIA'S OPPORTUNITIES JONES.
01:12:56.605 --> 01:12:58.674
AND IT MEANS THAT THE URBAN
01:12:58.741 --> 01:13:00.642
OPPORTUNITIES OWN IS NOT A STE
01:13:00.709 --> 01:13:02.845
IS NOT AT A STRATEGIC ADVANTAGE
01:13:02.911 --> 01:13:04.246
TO AN INVESTMENT OVER RURAL
01:13:04.313 --> 01:13:06.215
OPPORTUNITIES ONS IN IN THE WERE
01:13:06.281 --> 01:13:08.117
TO CREATE A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD.
01:13:08.183 --> 01:13:09.718
THIS IS BECAUSE EXISTING
01:13:09.785 --> 01:13:11.420
EXEMPTIONS HAVE AN URBAN OR A
01:13:11.487 --> 01:13:13.422
DENSITY OR A BUS ROUTE FREQUENCY
01:13:13.489 --> 01:13:15.290
OR SOME OTHER PRECONDITION TO
01:13:15.357 --> 01:13:16.425
GAIN AN EXEMPTION THAT WILL
01:13:16.492 --> 01:13:18.026
PRECLUDE OFFERS OPPORTUNITIES
01:13:18.093 --> 01:13:19.661
OWNS FOR ONE REASON OR ANOTHER
01:13:19.728 --> 01:13:21.130
IN OTHER WORDS THE OTHER.
01:13:21.196 --> 01:13:22.898
SECRET EXEMPTIONS.
01:13:22.965 --> 01:13:24.233
COME WITH A LOT OF BELLS AND
01:13:24.299 --> 01:13:25.300
WHISTLES THAT DIFFERENT
01:13:25.367 --> 01:13:27.336
COMMUNITIES MAY NOT BE ABLE TO
01:13:27.402 --> 01:13:29.271
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF IF.
01:13:29.338 --> 01:13:30.839
WE DIDN'T CREATE A LEVEL PLAYING
01:13:30.906 --> 01:13:32.875
FIELD -- FOR
01:13:32.941 --> 01:13:34.343
ALL OF THE OPPORTUNITIES ZONES
01:13:34.409 --> 01:13:35.444
IN CALIFORNIA WHETHER THEY'RE
01:13:35.511 --> 01:13:37.880
URBAN OR RURAL NEAR A TRANSLATOR
01:13:37.946 --> 01:13:39.114
OR REMOTE BY GIVING ALL
01:13:39.181 --> 01:13:40.315
CALIFORNIA OPPORTUNITIES OWNS
01:13:40.382 --> 01:13:41.517
THE SAME ROLES [inaudible]
01:13:41.583 --> 01:13:43.952
AND THIS [inaudible]
01:13:44.019 --> 01:13:46.288
OPPORTUNITIES ZONE.
01:13:46.355 --> 01:13:48.624
SEQUEL EXEMPTION IS VOLUNTARY.
01:13:48.690 --> 01:13:51.226
NO PROJECT IS MANDATED TO SEEK
01:13:51.293 --> 01:13:55.197
pEXEMPTION IN AN OPPORTUNITIES ON
01:13:55.264 --> 01:13:57.199
OPPONENTS OF AB THIRTY THIRTY
01:13:57.266 --> 01:13:58.200
WORRY THAT DEVELOPERS WILL
01:13:58.267 --> 01:13:59.601
SIMPLY TARGET ALREADY
01:13:59.668 --> 01:14:00.936
GENTRIFYING AREAS THAT NEED
01:14:01.003 --> 01:14:01.637
LITTLE.
01:14:01.703 --> 01:14:02.805
THAT HAVE LITTLE NEED FOR NEW
01:14:02.871 --> 01:14:05.374
INCENTIVES TO ATTRACT INVESTMENT.
01:14:05.440 --> 01:14:07.309
BUT FEW OPPORTUNITIES OWNS
01:14:07.376 --> 01:14:09.478
NATIONALLY EXPERIENCE HIGH LEVEL
01:14:09.545 --> 01:14:12.147
OF SOCIO ECONOMIC CHANGE FROM
01:14:12.214 --> 01:14:13.816
200-020-0016 ACCORDING TO DATA
01:14:13.882 --> 01:14:15.450
FROM THE URBAN INSTITUTE IF THE
01:14:15.517 --> 01:14:16.852
REASON THAT THESE OPPORTUNITIES
01:14:16.919 --> 01:14:18.320
OWNS OR WERE CREATED.
01:14:18.387 --> 01:14:19.922
IN FACT THE AVERAGE
01:14:19.988 --> 01:14:21.390
OPPORTUNITIES OWN HOUSING STOCK
01:14:21.456 --> 01:14:23.392
HAS A MEDIAN AGE OF FIFTY YEARS
01:14:23.458 --> 01:14:25.160
MORE THAN TEN YEARS OLDER THAN
01:14:25.227 --> 01:14:27.596
THE U. S. MEDIUM.
01:14:27.663 --> 01:14:29.097
IN MY DISCUSSIONS WITH SENATORS
01:14:29.164 --> 01:14:30.732
AND AND I HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO
01:14:30.799 --> 01:14:31.800
MEET WITH YOU ALL I HEARD
01:14:31.867 --> 01:14:33.101
CONCERNS AT SOME LOCAL
01:14:33.168 --> 01:14:34.002
GOVERNMENTS HAVE NOT KEPT THEIR
01:14:34.069 --> 01:14:34.903
HOUSING.
01:14:34.970 --> 01:14:36.371
THEIR GENERAL PLANS IN THE
01:14:36.438 --> 01:14:38.607
HOUSING NEEDS ASSESSMENT PLANS
01:14:38.674 --> 01:14:40.475
CURRENT ON AND IT WAS REALLY
01:14:40.542 --> 01:14:42.611
EXCELLENT FEEDBACK --
01:14:42.678 --> 01:14:43.178
TO THIS I WOULD SAY THE DIS
01:14:43.245 --> 01:14:44.179
COMMUNITY COMMUNITIES ARE
01:14:44.246 --> 01:14:46.114
BREAKING STATE LAW AND SO I
01:14:46.181 --> 01:14:48.083
DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM WITH SAYING.
01:14:48.150 --> 01:14:48.784
THAT THEY CAN NOT AVAILED
01:14:48.851 --> 01:14:52.754
HIMSELF OF DESIGNATED FOR THOSE
01:14:52.821 --> 01:14:53.689
THAT ARE FOLLOWING THE RULES AND
01:14:53.755 --> 01:14:55.524
THAT I REALLY DO HAVE.
01:14:55.591 --> 01:14:56.358
CURRENT GENERAL PLANTS IN
01:14:56.425 --> 01:14:58.961
CURRENT HOUSING ELEMENTS --
01:14:59.027 --> 01:15:00.429
EVERY SENATOR ON THIS COMMITTEE
01:15:00.495 --> 01:15:01.864
HAS OPPORTUNITIES ZONES
01:15:01.930 --> 01:15:03.332
DESIGNATED IN THEIR DISTRICTS
01:15:03.398 --> 01:15:04.733
COMMUNITIES THAT COULD BENEFIT
01:15:04.800 --> 01:15:06.335
BY ATTRACTING CAPITAL FROM
01:15:06.401 --> 01:15:08.470
PRIVATE INVESTORS.
01:15:08.537 --> 01:15:10.138
IN THIS IN THE ASSEMBLY THE BILL
01:15:10.205 --> 01:15:12.774
HAS ENJOYED BIPARTISAN SUPPORT.
01:15:12.841 --> 01:15:14.109
ON THE SUPPORT OF THE BUSINESS
01:15:14.176 --> 01:15:16.211
COMMUNITY AND THE BUILDING
01:15:16.278 --> 01:15:18.213
TRADES AND SO I'M I'M VERY PROUD
01:15:18.280 --> 01:15:20.315
OF THAT OUR POOREST COMMUNITIES
01:15:20.382 --> 01:15:22.584
NEED A ROBUST PLAN PLATFORM TO
01:15:22.651 --> 01:15:24.286
GO INTO THE PRIVATE MARKET.
01:15:24.353 --> 01:15:25.287
AND COMPETE FOR OPPORTUNITIES ON
01:15:25.354 --> 01:15:26.889
FUNDS.
01:15:26.955 --> 01:15:28.657
VOTING AYE ON AB THIRTY THIRTY
01:15:28.724 --> 01:15:30.959
CAN ACCOMPLISH THIS I'M BEFORE
01:15:31.026 --> 01:15:32.261
WE HEAR FROM YOUR WITNESSES ON
01:15:32.327 --> 01:15:33.795
PAGE NINETEEN OF THE STAFF
01:15:33.862 --> 01:15:34.830
ANALYSIS TALKS ABOUT.
01:15:34.897 --> 01:15:36.999
SEEK WORK IS THE VEHICLE THAT
01:15:37.065 --> 01:15:39.768
ALLOWS US TO GET ALL THIS GATHER
01:15:39.835 --> 01:15:41.837
ALL THIS INFORMATION ABOUT NO
01:15:41.904 --> 01:15:43.405
WATER SUPPLY ASSESSMENT AND
01:15:43.472 --> 01:15:45.007
CONSISTENT WITH THE PLAN NOT A
01:15:45.073 --> 01:15:47.075
WETLAND NOT THAT HOW WOULD THAT
01:15:47.142 --> 01:15:48.744
HAPPEN UNDER.
01:15:48.810 --> 01:15:50.646
HOW HOW WOULD WE FACILITY WITH
01:15:50.712 --> 01:15:52.147
ANY WOULD KNOW THAT WELL THAT
01:15:52.214 --> 01:15:53.081
THAT --
01:15:53.148 --> 01:15:55.918
EVERY EVERY COMMUNITY.
01:15:55.984 --> 01:15:57.119
HOUSE A GENERAL PLAN AND THEY'VE
01:15:57.185 --> 01:15:59.221
DONE A SEQUINED NOW SITS ON THE
01:15:59.288 --> 01:16:01.323
GENERAL PLAN AND I ADDITION FOR
01:16:01.390 --> 01:16:02.457
THE HOUSING ELEMENT.
01:16:02.524 --> 01:16:05.060
ON YOU YOU'VE DONE THE THE
01:16:05.127 --> 01:16:07.229
ASSESSMENT ON THE NOT ONLY THE
01:16:07.296 --> 01:16:08.764
NEEDS IN THE COMMUNITY BUT WHAT
01:16:08.830 --> 01:16:10.299
THE CHALLENGES ARE IN TERMS OF
01:16:10.365 --> 01:16:12.367
THAT ON THIS SITES THAT YOU'VE
01:16:12.434 --> 01:16:13.268
LOCATED.
01:16:13.335 --> 01:16:15.637
AND AND HOW IT MAY BE AND WHAT
01:16:15.704 --> 01:16:16.805
KIND OF MEDICATION WOULD BE
01:16:16.872 --> 01:16:18.173
NECESSARY IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO
01:16:18.240 --> 01:16:19.241
DO SO.
01:16:19.308 --> 01:16:20.609
ALL OF THESE PROPERTIES WILL
01:16:20.676 --> 01:16:22.945
HAVE HAD SOME SEQUENCE ANALYSIS
01:16:23.011 --> 01:16:24.713
WITHIN A A FAIRLY CURRENT PERIOD
01:16:24.780 --> 01:16:25.948
OF TIME WHETHER IT'S THROUGH A
01:16:26.014 --> 01:16:27.282
SPECIFIC PLAN THAT YOU'VE
01:16:27.349 --> 01:16:29.351
PREPARED AS AN OVERLAY WHETHER
01:16:29.418 --> 01:16:32.888
IT'S A GENERAL PLAN WHETHER IT'S
01:16:32.955 --> 01:16:33.989
BUT IT YOU KNOW SOME.
01:16:34.056 --> 01:16:35.457
ANY OF THOSE PROCESSES WILL HAVE
01:16:35.524 --> 01:16:37.693
CREATED A DOCUMENT THAT GIVE YOU
01:16:37.759 --> 01:16:39.061
THE MITIGATION.
01:16:39.127 --> 01:16:39.795
MEASURES THAT YOU'RE GONNA HAVE
01:16:39.861 --> 01:16:42.197
TO UNDERTAKEN OR ARE YOU TO BE
01:16:42.264 --> 01:16:43.665
ABLE TO BUILD ON THAT PROPERTY
01:16:43.732 --> 01:16:45.067
SO THERE WILL HAVE BEEN
01:16:45.133 --> 01:16:46.368
ENVIRONMENTAL BECAUSE I'M
01:16:46.435 --> 01:16:47.436
THINKING OF OF IF.
01:16:47.502 --> 01:16:48.236
IT WITHIN THE GENERAL FUND YOU
01:16:48.303 --> 01:16:49.738
HAVE OBVIOUSLY IF YOU'RE SELLING
01:16:49.805 --> 01:16:51.573
AND THAT THEY CITY MAY HATE FAT
01:16:51.640 --> 01:16:53.642
IDENTIFIED SOME SITES THAT ARE
01:16:53.709 --> 01:16:55.177
AVAILABLE FOR IN THEIR HOUSING
01:16:55.243 --> 01:16:58.513
ELEMENT. FOR FOR HOUSING AND SO.
01:16:58.580 --> 01:16:59.881
THE THRESHOLD WOULD BE LOOKING
01:16:59.948 --> 01:17:02.417
AT 50% IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING AND
01:17:02.484 --> 01:17:04.052
ALL THAT BUT WHETHER IT HAS
01:17:04.119 --> 01:17:06.621
ACTUAL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL AS I I
01:17:06.688 --> 01:17:08.090
DON'T THINK THEY'VE DONE THAT
01:17:08.156 --> 01:17:09.725
WORK COMMITTEE WOULD KNOW UNTIL.
01:17:09.791 --> 01:17:11.526
YOU KNOW EVEN IF IT WAS SUCH A
01:17:11.593 --> 01:17:13.662
RE USE OF A GUARD PARA GIRL.
01:17:13.729 --> 01:17:15.364
A SHOPPING CENTER SOMETHING THAT
01:17:15.430 --> 01:17:16.698
WILL WE HAD YOU KNOW THE OLD
01:17:16.765 --> 01:17:20.035
FASHION DRY CLEANERS I'M JUST.
01:17:20.102 --> 01:17:20.969
THIS WITH SOME OF THE CONCERNS
01:17:21.036 --> 01:17:22.537
THAT WERE RAISED I WANTED.
01:17:22.604 --> 01:17:23.138
TO IT YOU WOULD YOU BEFORE HER
01:17:23.205 --> 01:17:24.606
FOR ME WITNESSES OR JUST HAVE
01:17:24.673 --> 01:17:26.174
THE YOUR INPUT.
01:17:26.241 --> 01:17:26.742
ALRIGHT LET'S HEAR FROM THE
01:17:26.808 --> 01:17:29.411
FIRST WITNESS.
01:17:29.478 --> 01:17:30.746
GERMAN RECESS IDEA TO HAVE THIS
01:17:30.812 --> 01:17:31.947
THE BUILDING CONSTRUCTION TRADES
01:17:32.014 --> 01:17:33.949
COUNCIL I THANK THIS COMMITTEE
01:17:34.016 --> 01:17:35.617
FOR A THOROUGH ANALYSIS AS WELL
01:17:35.684 --> 01:17:37.019
AS THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER FOR
01:17:37.085 --> 01:17:38.720
TRYING TO FIND INNOVATIVE WAYS.
01:17:38.787 --> 01:17:40.122
TO PRODUCE MORE HOUSING --
01:17:40.188 --> 01:17:41.623
AS YOU KNOW WE'VE BEEN ENGAGED
01:17:41.690 --> 01:17:43.658
AND HOUSING POLICY AND BY HAVING
01:17:43.725 --> 01:17:45.027
THIS STRIKE THE BALANCE BETWEEN
01:17:45.093 --> 01:17:46.661
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS BUT
01:17:46.728 --> 01:17:48.096
ALSO STRIKE WORKFORCE
01:17:48.163 --> 01:17:49.398
PROTECTIONS AS WELL.
01:17:49.464 --> 01:17:50.599
ARE HAVING WORKED WITH THE
01:17:50.665 --> 01:17:52.000
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WE ALSO SHARE
01:17:52.067 --> 01:17:53.602
HER COMMITMENT TO TRY TO PRODUCE
01:17:53.668 --> 01:17:55.070
MORE AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN SOME
01:17:55.137 --> 01:17:56.438
OF THE MOST IMPOVERISHED AREAS
01:17:56.505 --> 01:17:58.306
WHILE ALSO TRYING TO FIND THOSE
01:17:58.373 --> 01:17:59.041
ISSUES.
01:17:59.107 --> 01:18:00.409
THAT YOU SILVA BASICALLY
01:18:00.475 --> 01:18:02.110
ELOQUENTLY PUT OUT ABOUT
01:18:02.177 --> 01:18:04.546
MITIGATION IN CASE THERE IS A A
01:18:04.613 --> 01:18:06.148
HAZARDOUS MATERIAL AND HOW TO
01:18:06.214 --> 01:18:07.849
CLEAN THAT UP --
01:18:07.916 --> 01:18:09.885
WE BELIEVE OF THIS BILL WILL TRY
01:18:09.951 --> 01:18:11.486
TO BALANCE THAT OUT IN A WAY
01:18:11.553 --> 01:18:13.021
THAT PRODUCES MORE HOUSING.
01:18:13.088 --> 01:18:14.656
WE UNDERSTAND THAT MIGHT BE SOME
01:18:14.723 --> 01:18:16.224
MORE TECHNICAL CHANGES TO
01:18:16.291 --> 01:18:17.559
ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES ABOUT
01:18:17.626 --> 01:18:18.894
RESPECT WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT
01:18:18.960 --> 01:18:20.295
BECAUSE I THINK IT TRY TRY TO
01:18:20.362 --> 01:18:22.764
STRIKE A GOOD BALANCE FOR
01:18:22.831 --> 01:18:23.365
INNOVATIVE WAYS TO CREATE MORE
01:18:23.432 --> 01:18:23.732
HOUSING.
01:18:23.799 --> 01:18:25.901
OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF AB --
01:18:25.967 --> 01:18:28.837
THIRTY THIRTY AND MORE SO CREAM
01:18:28.904 --> 01:18:29.771
GREASY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:18:29.838 --> 01:18:31.073
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
01:18:31.139 --> 01:18:34.776
REALTORS IN SUPPORT.
01:18:34.843 --> 01:18:36.211
GOOD MORNING DEBORAH CARL TO THE
01:18:36.278 --> 01:18:37.379
CALIFORNIA APARTMENT ASSOCIATION
01:18:37.446 --> 01:18:38.280
I DON'T HAVE TO TELL YOU HOW
01:18:38.346 --> 01:18:39.548
DESPERATE WE ARE FOR HOUSING
01:18:39.614 --> 01:18:41.550
ESPECIALLY IN THESE OPPORTUNITY
01:18:41.616 --> 01:18:42.050
ZONES.
01:18:42.117 --> 01:18:43.552
ARE HOMELESS POPULATIONS ARE
01:18:43.618 --> 01:18:44.486
STRUGGLING --
01:18:44.553 --> 01:18:46.321
AND SO WE STRONGLY URGE YOUR AYE
01:18:46.388 --> 01:18:49.758
VOTE THANK YOU.
01:18:49.825 --> 01:18:51.059
ADAMANTLY ON BEHALF OF THE
01:18:51.126 --> 01:18:52.394
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
01:18:52.461 --> 01:18:54.196
AMONG OTHER LE LOCAL CHAMBERS AS
01:18:54.262 --> 01:18:55.831
WELL ALSO IN SUPPORT --
01:18:55.897 --> 01:18:56.932
AND AS WELL AS THE GENERAL
01:18:56.998 --> 01:18:59.534
BUSINESS COMMUNITY CAN.
01:18:59.601 --> 01:19:00.368
SCOTT WHAT YOU BEHALF THE
01:19:00.435 --> 01:19:01.670
COMPANY'S TO ASSOCIATION OF
01:19:01.736 --> 01:19:02.904
ELECTRICAL WORKERS A CALPERS THE
01:19:02.971 --> 01:19:03.972
PATRIOTS COUNCIL IN WESTERN
01:19:04.039 --> 01:19:05.307
STATES CONSERVE SHEET METAL
01:19:05.373 --> 01:19:06.842
WORKERS AND ELEVATOR
01:19:06.908 --> 01:19:08.944
CONSTRUCTORS UNION IN SUPPORT.
01:19:09.010 --> 01:19:10.178
IS THERE ANYONE HERE OPPOSED TO
01:19:10.245 --> 01:19:18.353
AB.
01:19:18.420 --> 01:19:19.254
THIRTY THREE A GOOD MORNING
01:19:19.321 --> 01:19:20.288
CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE
01:19:20.355 --> 01:19:21.656
HOW KYLE JOINS US HERE CALL
01:19:21.723 --> 01:19:24.192
CALIFORNIA WE ARE OPPOSED TO AB
01:19:24.259 --> 01:19:26.495
I THIRTY THIRTY I'M AS WAS LAID
01:19:26.561 --> 01:19:27.362
OUT THIS MORNING I THINK WE
01:19:27.429 --> 01:19:29.197
THERE'S INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE TO
01:19:29.264 --> 01:19:29.865
SUPPORT THE CLAIM THAT SEQUENCE
01:19:29.931 --> 01:19:31.299
THIS LARGE BARRIER TO HOUSING
01:19:31.366 --> 01:19:32.868
CONSTRUCTION ACROSS.
01:19:32.934 --> 01:19:33.502
THE STATE THAT IT IS MADE OUT TO
01:19:33.568 --> 01:19:34.703
BE -- AND IN
01:19:34.769 --> 01:19:36.204
FACT ALL THE EVIDENCES SHE IS
01:19:36.271 --> 01:19:38.974
SHOWN OTHERWISE --
01:19:39.040 --> 01:19:40.242
IN ADDITION THERE HAVE BEEN
01:19:40.308 --> 01:19:42.144
NUMEROUS EXEMPTIONS OVER THE
01:19:42.210 --> 01:19:43.478
YEARS FOR THESE TYPES OF
01:19:43.545 --> 01:19:45.413
PROJECTS AND WE THINK THAT THOSE
01:19:45.480 --> 01:19:45.981
WOULD BE SUFFICIENT TO COVER
01:19:46.047 --> 01:19:47.415
THESE ARE.
01:19:47.482 --> 01:19:48.884
AND IN THOSE WERE YOU KNOW AFTER
01:19:48.950 --> 01:19:49.951
CAREFUL CONSIDERATION THROUGH
01:19:50.018 --> 01:19:52.387
THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS --
01:19:52.454 --> 01:19:54.422
SO.
01:19:54.489 --> 01:19:55.590
YOU KNOW I THINK ANNOUNCES LAYS
01:19:55.657 --> 01:19:57.058
OUT EXACTLY SOME REALLY GOOD
01:19:57.125 --> 01:19:59.027
POINTS --
01:19:59.094 --> 01:20:00.829
WHEN I WE DO HAVE EXISTING
01:20:00.896 --> 01:20:02.764
EXEMPTIONS OR STREAMLINING STE
01:20:02.831 --> 01:20:05.433
FOR PROJECTS CONSISTENT WITH --
01:20:05.500 --> 01:20:07.636
MY GENERAL PLANTS OR COMMUNITY
01:20:07.702 --> 01:20:09.905
PLAN EXEMPTIONS OR BOB PROJECT
01:20:09.971 --> 01:20:10.972
EXEMPTIONS FOR PROJECTS
01:20:11.039 --> 01:20:12.240
CONSISTENT WITH SPECIFIC PLANS.
01:20:12.307 --> 01:20:14.476
DOES REQUIRE NO SITE SPECIFIC
01:20:14.543 --> 01:20:15.610
IMPACTS AND OFTEN YOU KNOW
01:20:15.677 --> 01:20:16.978
THAT'S REALLY THE KICKER IS
01:20:17.045 --> 01:20:19.247
THERE SOMETHING I ON THAT SITE
01:20:19.314 --> 01:20:21.316
THAT THAT COULD BE DISTURBED
01:20:21.383 --> 01:20:22.851
DURING THE CONSTRUCTION PROCESS
01:20:22.918 --> 01:20:25.086
OR OR JUST WASN'T ANALYZE
01:20:25.153 --> 01:20:26.188
BECAUSE THE GENERAL PLAN THE
01:20:26.254 --> 01:20:27.622
SPECIFIC PLAN WAS IT DOWN ON THE
01:20:27.689 --> 01:20:29.024
GROUND AT THAT LEVEL --
01:20:29.090 --> 01:20:30.325
THAT COULD POTENTIALLY HAVE
01:20:30.392 --> 01:20:31.393
IMPACTS THAT NEED TO BE
01:20:31.459 --> 01:20:32.961
MITIGATED ADDRESSED AND SO --
01:20:33.028 --> 01:20:35.964
THIS NEW PROCESS LAID OUT --
01:20:36.031 --> 01:20:37.399
DOES KIND OF CREATE THAT YOU
01:20:37.465 --> 01:20:38.900
KNOW CONCERNS ABOUT HOW IS THIS
01:20:38.967 --> 01:20:40.135
GOING TO WORK HOWARD COMMUNITY
01:20:40.202 --> 01:20:42.103
MEMBERS AND AND PEOPLE REALLY
01:20:42.170 --> 01:20:44.239
ABLE TO KNOW --
01:20:44.306 --> 01:20:45.840
YOU KNOW WHAT'S WHAT'S GOING ON
01:20:45.907 --> 01:20:47.242
WITH THIS --
01:20:47.309 --> 01:20:47.809
IN ORDER TO QUALIFY FOR THE
01:20:47.876 --> 01:20:50.045
EXEMPTION --
01:20:50.111 --> 01:20:51.880
AND SO I YOU KNOW I THINK.
01:20:51.947 --> 01:20:53.515
IT IT YOU COULD POTENTIALLY ALSO
01:20:53.582 --> 01:20:55.083
IT INTER SITUATION WHERE
01:20:55.150 --> 01:20:55.884
LITIGATION COULD INCREASE
01:20:55.951 --> 01:20:59.087
BECAUSE PEOPLE AREN'T GIVEN THIS
01:20:59.154 --> 01:21:01.389
THE USUAL AVENUES OF OF COMMENTS
01:21:01.456 --> 01:21:02.891
OF REVIEW --
01:21:02.958 --> 01:21:04.793
AND YET THEY STILL HAVE ISSUES
01:21:04.859 --> 01:21:07.462
THEY CAN CHALLENGE THE USE OF
01:21:07.529 --> 01:21:10.532
THE EXEMPTION AS AN APPROPRIATE --
01:21:10.599 --> 01:21:12.867
SO WE ARE STILL OPPOSED TO THE
01:21:12.934 --> 01:21:14.035
BILL -- FOR
01:21:14.102 --> 01:21:15.537
THE SEQUEL PROVISIONS --
01:21:15.604 --> 01:21:17.606
DELAY PROVISIONS WE HAVE NO
01:21:17.672 --> 01:21:17.906
[inaudible]
01:21:17.973 --> 01:21:19.674
I AM.
01:21:19.741 --> 01:21:21.910
THE AUTHOR HAS HIGHLIGHT TEST
01:21:21.977 --> 01:21:24.045
THAT THE THE OPPORTUNITY IS A
01:21:24.112 --> 01:21:25.780
SEVEN YEAR WINDOW AND CLOSING --
01:21:25.847 --> 01:21:28.049
ED.
01:21:28.116 --> 01:21:30.685
YOU TOUCHED ON COMMITTEE PLANS
01:21:30.752 --> 01:21:33.555
SPECIFIC PLANS AND I KNOW YOU'RE
01:21:33.622 --> 01:21:34.789
OPPOSE WHAT WOULD YOU.
01:21:34.856 --> 01:21:37.359
IF IT WHAT WOULD YOU SEE A MORE
01:21:37.425 --> 01:21:38.460
COMFORTABLE --
01:21:38.526 --> 01:21:40.895
FOR YOUR OPPOSITION AVENUE TO
01:21:40.962 --> 01:21:42.564
TRY TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OFTHESE
01:21:42.631 --> 01:21:43.965
AYE CAPITAL GAINS OPPORTUNITIES
01:21:44.032 --> 01:21:45.867
THAT ARE THERE HELP OUT WITH THE
01:21:45.934 --> 01:21:47.302
HOUSING ELEMENT --
01:21:47.369 --> 01:21:49.738
BUT NOT HAVE THIS A SORT OF GO
01:21:49.804 --> 01:21:51.439
FROM EXPEDITED JUDICIAL REVIEW
01:21:51.506 --> 01:21:53.575
TO KNOW JUDICIAL REVIEW.
01:21:53.642 --> 01:21:54.709
YOU KNOW I THINK I THINK I THINK
01:21:54.776 --> 01:21:57.012
IT'S A BIG FOR US I THINK ABIG.
01:21:57.078 --> 01:21:58.079
ISSUE WITH HOUSING AND WHAT
01:21:58.146 --> 01:21:59.981
REALLY COULD HELP GET A LOT OF
01:22:00.048 --> 01:22:01.383
PROJECTS INCLUDING OPPORTUNITY
01:22:01.449 --> 01:22:03.084
ZONES BUT JUST ACROSS THE BOARD
01:22:03.151 --> 01:22:04.252
OUT THERE IS IS LOOKING AT
01:22:04.319 --> 01:22:06.321
EGGPLANTS AND MAKING SURE PLANS
01:22:06.388 --> 01:22:08.023
ARE CURRENT AND UPDATED.
01:22:08.089 --> 01:22:09.724
I AT AND SO THAT WORK CAN SPEAK
01:22:09.791 --> 01:22:12.961
STARTED BEFORE FEDERAL DOLLARS-ARE STARTED ARE ARE MADE
01:22:13.028 --> 01:22:14.462
AVAILABLE --
01:22:14.529 --> 01:22:15.664
I KOW THAT THERE THERE'S
01:22:15.730 --> 01:22:16.364
FUNDING OUT THERE FOR DOING
01:22:16.431 --> 01:22:17.299
THINGS LIKE SUSTAINABLE
01:22:17.365 --> 01:22:18.566
COMMUNITY STRATEGIES AYE AYE
01:22:18.633 --> 01:22:19.634
SPEECH HE WAS PASSED WHICH
01:22:19.701 --> 01:22:20.702
ALLOWS FOR FUNDING FOR TO PLAN
01:22:20.769 --> 01:22:21.870
UPDATES.
01:22:21.936 --> 01:22:22.904
SO THERE ARE OPTIONS OUT THERE
01:22:22.971 --> 01:22:24.139
FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO UPDATE
01:22:24.205 --> 01:22:25.874
THOSE PLANS AND WHEN THOSE PLANS
01:22:25.940 --> 01:22:27.175
ARE UPDATED MORE CURRENT.
01:22:27.242 --> 01:22:28.243
AYE AND GO THROUGH THE PUBLIC
01:22:28.310 --> 01:22:30.378
PROCESS THEN THERE'S A WHOLE
01:22:30.445 --> 01:22:32.681
SUITE OF OF OF SEEK WITH --
01:22:32.747 --> 01:22:34.549
YOU KNOW AT EXEMPTIONS AND WHAT
01:22:34.616 --> 01:22:35.717
NOT THAT YOU KNOW MAYBE I DON'T
01:22:35.784 --> 01:22:37.218
LIKE MALL BUT THEY'RE THEY'RE
01:22:37.285 --> 01:22:38.920
ALREADY AND AND THAT WOULD THEN
01:22:38.987 --> 01:22:40.355
BE MORE AVAILABLE FOR THESE
01:22:40.422 --> 01:22:42.257
COMMUNITIES FORGET OTHERS
01:22:42.324 --> 01:22:44.426
OPPOSED TO A. B..
01:22:44.492 --> 01:22:45.360
THIRTY THIRTY I PLEASE CLOSE
01:22:45.427 --> 01:22:46.961
PUBLIC HEARING BRING IT TO THE
01:22:47.028 --> 01:22:47.829
US STATE SENATOR SKINNER.
01:22:47.896 --> 01:22:50.932
HAVE A QUESTION.
01:22:50.999 --> 01:22:53.501
THANK YOU CHAIR --
01:22:53.568 --> 01:22:57.072
SO ON THE PLAINTIFF THINKING
01:22:57.138 --> 01:22:58.306
THAT THE CHAIR WAS ASKING
01:22:58.373 --> 01:22:58.606
[inaudible]
01:22:58.673 --> 01:23:05.513
THE RIGHT NOW THIS IS --
01:23:05.580 --> 01:23:07.515
A BROAD EXEMPTION.
01:23:07.582 --> 01:23:11.152
SO YOU COULD HAVE HAD THE ONLY A
01:23:11.219 --> 01:23:12.520
SECRET DOCUMENT ON A GENERAL
01:23:12.587 --> 01:23:14.723
PLAN THAT WAS KIND. EIGHTEEN
01:23:14.789 --> 01:23:17.592
YEARS AGO SAY OR EVEN LONGER.
01:23:17.659 --> 01:23:18.593
AND SO IN THAT SERIES
01:23:18.660 --> 01:23:19.994
CIRCUMSTANCE YOU COULD
01:23:20.061 --> 01:23:21.563
POTENTIALLY HAVE.
01:23:21.629 --> 01:23:22.897
A SITE WITHIN THESE
01:23:22.964 --> 01:23:25.200
OPPORTUNITIES UNKNOWNS.
01:23:25.266 --> 01:23:27.502
THAT COULD BE CONTAMINATED SITE
01:23:27.569 --> 01:23:29.437
THAT HAD NOT BEEN.
01:23:29.504 --> 01:23:30.805
DONE THAT IF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
01:23:30.872 --> 01:23:32.207
OR THE ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS
01:23:32.273 --> 01:23:33.575
HAD NOT BEEN DONE YET
01:23:33.641 --> 01:23:33.875
[inaudible]
01:23:33.942 --> 01:23:36.344
I'M --
01:23:36.411 --> 01:23:37.946
UNFORTUNATELY CURIOUSLY BECAUSE
01:23:38.012 --> 01:23:39.381
I AM WHO I WAS HOPING TO GET
01:23:39.447 --> 01:23:41.149
SOME RESPONSE FROM THE CHAIR.
01:23:41.216 --> 01:23:42.951
WHAT THE --
01:23:43.017 --> 01:23:44.552
POINTED I'M BRINGING UP IS THAT
01:23:44.619 --> 01:23:49.391
INTO PRISON I YEAH I AM --
01:23:49.457 --> 01:23:52.494
BECAUSE THE FEDERAL FUNDS OURS
01:23:52.560 --> 01:23:54.129
IN AVAILABLE ONLY FOR SUCH A
01:23:54.195 --> 01:23:55.497
LIMITED WINDOW [inaudible]
01:23:55.563 --> 01:23:58.833
AND IT SEEMS TO ME THAT WE
01:23:58.900 --> 01:24:01.736
SHOULD.
01:24:01.803 --> 01:24:02.904
DO EVERYTHING WE CAN TO TO
01:24:02.971 --> 01:24:04.839
ACCESS THEM.
01:24:04.906 --> 01:24:07.742
AND BUT STILL WITH STILL
01:24:07.809 --> 01:24:09.444
ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THERE WE WANT
01:24:09.511 --> 01:24:10.545
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE DON'T HAVE
01:24:10.612 --> 01:24:12.013
SITES.
01:24:12.080 --> 01:24:13.948
THAT I MEAN FOR EXAMPLE WHEN --
01:24:14.015 --> 01:24:15.617
BAYVIEW HUNTERS POINT NOW THERE
01:24:15.683 --> 01:24:17.152
WAS ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW DONE
01:24:17.218 --> 01:24:19.954
BUT THE CLEANUP WAS INADEQUATE
01:24:20.021 --> 01:24:21.556
AND WE'VE HAD WE NOW HAVE THE
01:24:21.623 --> 01:24:24.025
DEVELOPMENT ON A ON A SITE THAT.
01:24:24.092 --> 01:24:26.060
IS HAS TOXIC CONTAMINATION AND
01:24:26.127 --> 01:24:27.729
THAT'S WHAT YOU WANT TO AVOID.
01:24:27.796 --> 01:24:30.565
BUT IT SEEMS TO ME IF WE MARK IF
01:24:30.632 --> 01:24:31.833
WE WERE TO AMEND THE BILL
01:24:31.900 --> 01:24:32.133
[inaudible]
01:24:32.200 --> 01:24:33.768
SO THAT.
01:24:33.835 --> 01:24:35.270
EITHER A SPECIFIC PLAN HAD TO
01:24:35.336 --> 01:24:36.471
ALREADY BE IN PLACE THAT HAD
01:24:36.538 --> 01:24:38.339
SECRET REVIEW WITHIN A CERTAIN
01:24:38.406 --> 01:24:40.775
TIME PERIOD. FOR GENERAL PLANT
01:24:40.842 --> 01:24:41.443
IN OTHER WORDS IF WE NARROW THE
01:24:41.509 --> 01:24:42.944
WINDOW.
01:24:43.011 --> 01:24:45.880
OF OF OF ONE OF PLAN REVIEW WAS
01:24:45.947 --> 01:24:48.750
DONE POORER IF THE PLAN UPDATE
01:24:48.817 --> 01:24:50.285
IS DYING.
01:24:50.351 --> 01:24:52.253
WITHIN BECAUSE AGAIN AND AND
01:24:52.320 --> 01:24:53.988
MAKE THIS BE --
01:24:54.055 --> 01:24:55.957
PUT A SUNSET ON THIS WITH THE
01:24:56.024 --> 01:24:57.625
SUNSET BEING WITHIN THE
01:24:57.692 --> 01:24:59.160
OPPORTUNITIES OWN WINDOW.
01:24:59.227 --> 01:25:02.297
AND THEN EITHER ALLOWING.
01:25:02.363 --> 01:25:03.198
FOR CIVIC OUR GENERAL PLAN
01:25:03.264 --> 01:25:04.432
HAVING BEEN DONE IN EXPERIENCE
01:25:04.499 --> 01:25:05.800
OF TIME.
01:25:05.867 --> 01:25:07.135
THAT THEN WE'VE AT LEAST
01:25:07.202 --> 01:25:08.670
NARROWED.
01:25:08.736 --> 01:25:10.738
THAT AND WE'VE GIVEN OURSELVES A
01:25:10.805 --> 01:25:12.674
LITTLE MORE CONFIDENCE THAT THE
01:25:12.740 --> 01:25:14.008
TYPE OF ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
01:25:14.075 --> 01:25:15.176
THAT WE'D WANT TO HAVE
01:25:15.243 --> 01:25:15.477
[inaudible]
01:25:15.543 --> 01:25:17.212
HAD HAPPENED.
01:25:17.278 --> 01:25:18.746
IN IT SEEMS TO ME THAT WHILE
01:25:18.813 --> 01:25:20.081
THAT DOES NOT.
01:25:20.148 --> 01:25:21.583
FULLY ADDRESS EVERYONE WHO DOES
01:25:21.649 --> 01:25:23.384
NOT WHO FEELS THAT YOU SHOULD
01:25:23.451 --> 01:25:25.153
NEVER HAVE A SECRET EXEMPTION IT
01:25:25.220 --> 01:25:27.922
AT LEAST COMES CLOSER TO
01:25:27.989 --> 01:25:29.324
RESPECTING THE PURPOSE OF SEQUEL.
01:25:29.390 --> 01:25:31.025
WHILE STILL TRYING TO ENSURE
01:25:31.092 --> 01:25:32.360
THAT WE TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THESE
01:25:32.427 --> 01:25:35.630
FEDERAL FUNDS.
01:25:35.697 --> 01:25:37.432
BUT YOURS NOT HERE SO --
01:25:37.499 --> 01:25:40.068
AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS THIS IS
01:25:40.134 --> 01:25:41.269
OUR ONLY HEARING.
01:25:41.336 --> 01:25:42.971
SO IT SEEMS TO ME I MEAN I AM
01:25:43.037 --> 01:25:44.439
NOT WILLING TO VOTE AGAINST THE
01:25:44.506 --> 01:25:47.075
BILL -- WHEN
01:25:47.141 --> 01:25:48.409
THERE HASN'T HAD THAT KIND OF
01:25:48.476 --> 01:25:49.978
CONVERSATION BECAUSE IF I VOTE
01:25:50.044 --> 01:25:51.579
AGAINST THE BILL THERE'S NO
01:25:51.646 --> 01:25:53.581
ABILITY TO UNLESS WE ARE TOLD
01:25:53.648 --> 01:25:54.415
THAT WE'RE GONNA HAVE ANOTHER
01:25:54.482 --> 01:25:55.850
HEARING THERE'S NO ABILITY TO
01:25:55.917 --> 01:25:57.552
TRY TO FINESSE THAT?
01:25:57.619 --> 01:25:58.987
SO OTHERWISE I HAVE TO KEEP THE
01:25:59.053 --> 01:26:00.955
BILL MOVING AND HOPE THAT WE CAN
01:26:01.022 --> 01:26:04.292
FINESSE IT SOMEWHERE ELSE.
01:26:04.359 --> 01:26:04.859
THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS
01:26:04.926 --> 01:26:05.760
SENATORS SKINNER --
01:26:05.827 --> 01:26:08.329
CENTER LARA THINK YOU THANK YOU
01:26:08.396 --> 01:26:09.964
A SUMMER CHO YOU KNOW I WANTED.
01:26:10.031 --> 01:26:11.099
TO APPRECIATE RECIPROCAL
01:26:11.165 --> 01:26:12.567
MUSICIAN WE HAD IN MY OFFICE IN
01:26:12.634 --> 01:26:13.835
THE QUESTION THAT I HAD.
01:26:13.902 --> 01:26:15.436
I REGARDING TO THIS ISSUE AND I
01:26:15.503 --> 01:26:17.105
DID SEE THE PROMISE ZONES AND IN
01:26:17.171 --> 01:26:18.439
MY DISTRICT.
01:26:18.506 --> 01:26:22.410
AND A LOT OF THOSE AREAS ALREADY --
01:26:22.477 --> 01:26:25.079
AND MY QUESTION WOULD BE THEN.
01:26:25.146 --> 01:26:27.215
SHOULD THIS BILL PASSED.
01:26:27.282 --> 01:26:28.182
AND I KNOW THIS IS ONLY FOR
01:26:28.249 --> 01:26:29.851
HOUSING -- I
01:26:29.918 --> 01:26:31.085
JUST WANNA MAKE SURE THAT
01:26:31.152 --> 01:26:31.719
THERE'S SOME SORT OF PROTECTION
01:26:31.786 --> 01:26:34.088
SO THAT --
01:26:34.155 --> 01:26:35.690
YOU KNOW LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
01:26:35.757 --> 01:26:38.660
THE SUMMIT ON HOUSING ELEMENT OR
01:26:38.726 --> 01:26:39.827
YOU KNOW A VERY INFLUENTIAL
01:26:39.894 --> 01:26:41.095
PERSON COMES IN AND STARTS
01:26:41.162 --> 01:26:42.363
BUILDING HOUSING.
01:26:42.430 --> 01:26:44.766
IN AREAS THAT MAY NEED SOME
01:26:44.832 --> 01:26:46.034
ADDITIONAL MEDICATION.
01:26:46.100 --> 01:26:48.202
SO IF YOU CAN RUN ME THROUGH HOW
01:26:48.269 --> 01:26:49.938
WE WOULD PROTECT AGAINST.
01:26:50.004 --> 01:26:51.139
THAT FROM HAPPENING RELEASE
01:26:51.205 --> 01:26:52.907
MAKING SURE THAT THE THE THE
01:26:52.974 --> 01:26:54.709
GROUND --
01:26:54.776 --> 01:26:55.810
DISLOYAL IS NOT CONTAMINATE OUR
01:26:55.877 --> 01:26:57.378
LEASE MITIGATED TO A POINT WHERE
01:26:57.445 --> 01:26:58.580
WE ACTUALLY CAN CREATE SOME
01:26:58.646 --> 01:26:59.681
HOUSING.
01:26:59.747 --> 01:27:01.916
IN IN THOSE AREAS.
01:27:01.983 --> 01:27:03.217
THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR THAT
01:27:03.284 --> 01:27:03.952
QUESTION AND AND THIS REALLY I
01:27:04.018 --> 01:27:04.986
THINK.
01:27:05.053 --> 01:27:06.654
DEALS WITH THE ISSUE THAT --
01:27:06.721 --> 01:27:08.022
SENATOR SKINNER WAS BRINGING UP
01:27:08.089 --> 01:27:09.724
WHICH IS THAT I'M WHAT WE REALLY
01:27:09.791 --> 01:27:12.427
WANT TO DO IS MAKE SURE THAT THE
01:27:12.493 --> 01:27:13.227
THE GENERAL PLANS FOR THOSE
01:27:13.294 --> 01:27:13.861
AREAS.
01:27:13.928 --> 01:27:16.164
OUR CURRENT --
01:27:16.230 --> 01:27:17.899
WHICH MEANS THAT THEY HAVE BEEN
01:27:17.966 --> 01:27:19.701
ALL OF THE ANALYSIS IS BEEN DONE
01:27:19.767 --> 01:27:21.402
WITHIN THE PAST TEN YEARS --
01:27:21.469 --> 01:27:23.638
SO ANYTHING THAT'S FIFTEEN YEARS
01:27:23.705 --> 01:27:24.839
OLD.
01:27:24.906 --> 01:27:26.140
AND THAT'S THE KIND OF AMENDMENT
01:27:26.207 --> 01:27:27.175
THAT MAKES A LOT OF SENSE IN
01:27:27.241 --> 01:27:28.776
TURN TO YOU HAVE TO HAVE A A
01:27:28.843 --> 01:27:30.144
GENERAL PLAN THAT'S THAT'S
01:27:30.211 --> 01:27:30.678
CURRENT.
01:27:30.745 --> 01:27:32.480
YET HAVE A HOUSING ELEMENT THAT
01:27:32.547 --> 01:27:34.782
IS CERTIFIED BY THE STATE --
01:27:34.849 --> 01:27:36.551
AND YOU KNOW THEY'RE THEY'RE
01:27:36.618 --> 01:27:38.453
THEORETICALLY COULD BE A PROCESS
01:27:38.519 --> 01:27:39.887
WHERE -- YOU
01:27:39.954 --> 01:27:42.123
IN ORDER TO BE ABLE TO ACTUALLY
01:27:42.190 --> 01:27:43.591
MOVE FORWARD YOU GO TO THE
01:27:43.658 --> 01:27:45.393
STRATEGIC GROWTH COUNSELING GET
01:27:45.460 --> 01:27:46.694
THE SEAL OF APPROVAL IT SAID
01:27:46.761 --> 01:27:47.795
YOU'VE DONE.
01:27:47.862 --> 01:27:50.865
YOUR CURRENT WITH THESE SO THAT
01:27:50.932 --> 01:27:52.166
USE THE OPPORTUNITIES OWNING
01:27:52.233 --> 01:27:53.568
THAT THE SEQUEL EXEMPTION IN
01:27:53.635 --> 01:27:55.036
OTHER WORDS I'M LOOKING.
01:27:55.103 --> 01:27:56.337
FOR THINGS THAT THAT CREATE THE
01:27:56.404 --> 01:27:57.572
CERTAINTY SO WE DON'T END UP IN
01:27:57.639 --> 01:27:59.807
A SITUATION THAT YOU ARTICULATED
01:27:59.874 --> 01:28:01.342
WHERE IT'S IT'S AN OLD GENERAL
01:28:01.409 --> 01:28:03.311
PLAN THEY HAVEN'T DONE ANY OF
01:28:03.378 --> 01:28:04.912
THE ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS.
01:28:04.979 --> 01:28:06.180
IN THE GENERAL PLANTS WILL
01:28:06.247 --> 01:28:08.149
GENERALLY IDENTIFY WHERE THERE'S
01:28:08.216 --> 01:28:09.584
THE POLLUTANTS IN IN IN THE
01:28:09.651 --> 01:28:10.952
COMMUNITY AND WHAT THE
01:28:11.019 --> 01:28:12.920
MITIGATION IS GOING TO BE --
01:28:12.987 --> 01:28:14.689
AND IN IN AREAS WHERE THEY'VE
01:28:14.756 --> 01:28:17.959
GOT AN OVERVIEW OR I PLAN --
01:28:18.026 --> 01:28:19.694
FOR CYST AS SUSTAINABLE
01:28:19.761 --> 01:28:22.330
COMMUNITIES PLAN YOU GOT THE
01:28:22.397 --> 01:28:24.065
ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION
01:28:24.132 --> 01:28:25.867
BECAUSE YOU'VE DONE THE WORK.
01:28:25.933 --> 01:28:28.069
YOU'VE DONE AN E. IR AS PART OF
01:28:28.136 --> 01:28:29.404
PART OF THESE PLANS.
01:28:29.470 --> 01:28:32.173
AND SO THERE IS THERE'S DATA
01:28:32.240 --> 01:28:33.341
THERE'S INFORMATION ON WHAT KIND
01:28:33.408 --> 01:28:34.575
OF CONTAMINANTS YOU'RE LIKELY TO
01:28:34.642 --> 01:28:35.977
FIND WHAT KIND OF MEDICATION YOU
01:28:36.044 --> 01:28:37.345
YOU WOULD HAVE TO DO.
01:28:37.412 --> 01:28:39.147
SO SO I I AM IS CONCERNED AS YOU
01:28:39.213 --> 01:28:40.615
ARE I DON'T I'M NOT INTERESTED
01:28:40.682 --> 01:28:42.083
IN HAVING SOMEONE JUST COME IN
01:28:42.150 --> 01:28:44.185
INTO IN USE PRIVATE FUNDS AND DO
01:28:44.252 --> 01:28:45.820
WHATEVER THEY WANT TO DO --
01:28:45.887 --> 01:28:47.555
BUT WE NEED THE COMMUNITY
01:28:47.622 --> 01:28:49.123
THEY'RE STILL ALL OF THE HEARING
01:28:49.190 --> 01:28:50.058
REQUIREMENTS --
01:28:50.124 --> 01:28:51.893
THERE'S IT IT'S THE COUNCIL HAS
01:28:51.959 --> 01:28:53.895
TO MAKE A FINDING IN OR THE
01:28:53.961 --> 01:28:55.396
COUNSELOR THAT BOARD SUPERVISORS
01:28:55.463 --> 01:28:56.597
HAS TO MAKE A FINDING.
01:28:56.664 --> 01:28:58.232
A CONSISTENT WITH WHAT'S IN THE
01:28:58.299 --> 01:29:01.903
BILL UP THAT THE EXACTLY WHAT
01:29:01.969 --> 01:29:03.438
THE MEDICATIONS ARE ARE GOING TO
01:29:03.504 --> 01:29:05.640
BE REQUIRED IF IT DOESN'T WAVE
01:29:05.707 --> 01:29:07.208
ALL OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL ON
01:29:07.275 --> 01:29:08.910
INFORMATION THAT THAT'S WITHIN
01:29:08.976 --> 01:29:10.311
THEIR THEIR PURVIEW AT THE
01:29:10.378 --> 01:29:11.546
JURISDICTION.
01:29:11.612 --> 01:29:12.113
AND THEY HAVE TO BE ABLE TO
01:29:12.180 --> 01:29:13.915
ARTICULATE.
01:29:13.981 --> 01:29:15.416
AND KEPT FAVOR CLARIFICATION THE
01:29:15.483 --> 01:29:17.118
CENTER LARGEST TO BE CLEAR TO
01:29:17.185 --> 01:29:18.920
QUALIFY FOR A SEQUEL EXEMPTION
01:29:18.986 --> 01:29:20.354
YOU'RE GONNA HAVE A SUBSET
01:29:20.421 --> 01:29:21.656
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE STANDARD
01:29:21.723 --> 01:29:22.990
UNDER SEAQUEST OVER THE LEAD
01:29:23.057 --> 01:29:23.891
AGENCIES.
01:29:23.958 --> 01:29:25.660
AREN'T GOING TO JUST BE ABLE TO
01:29:25.727 --> 01:29:26.894
SAY WHY THEY QUALIFIED AS PART
01:29:26.961 --> 01:29:28.529
OF QUALIFIES UNDER THIRTY THIRTY
01:29:28.596 --> 01:29:30.465
WITHOUT GOING THROUGH --
01:29:30.531 --> 01:29:31.399
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE STANDARD
01:29:31.466 --> 01:29:33.534
FOR EACH OF THE QUALIFICATIONS
01:29:33.601 --> 01:29:35.002
UNDER THIRTY THIRTY WHETHER YOU
01:29:35.069 --> 01:29:36.070
NEED TO WSA WHETHER THERE'S
01:29:36.137 --> 01:29:37.205
HAZARDOUS POLLUTANTS.
01:29:37.271 --> 01:29:39.040
THAT THE DIFFERENCE HERE BEING
01:29:39.107 --> 01:29:40.041
IS STREAMLINED THAT SUCH A LOT
01:29:40.108 --> 01:29:41.743
DO A FULL BLOWN NEW <c.green> I ARE</c>
01:29:41.809 --> 01:29:44.545
WHEN YOU ARE WAS ALREADY DONE --
01:29:44.612 --> 01:29:45.847
FOR AT THE JEEP GENERAL PLAN
01:29:45.913 --> 01:29:47.782
LEVELS PACIFIC LEVEL ETCETERA SO
01:29:47.849 --> 01:29:50.752
THERE'S THAT SAFEGUARD UNDER
01:29:50.818 --> 01:29:51.352
SEQUENCE WHILE THE SUBSTANTIAL
01:29:51.419 --> 01:29:53.821
EVIDENCE AND FORGET.
01:29:53.888 --> 01:29:55.490
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS --
01:29:55.556 --> 01:29:56.190
SENATORS COULD HURT YOU.
01:29:56.257 --> 01:29:59.427
LOADERS YOU WANT TO RESPOND
01:29:59.494 --> 01:29:59.827
FIRST.
01:29:59.894 --> 01:30:02.830
YEAH -- SO I
01:30:02.897 --> 01:30:05.099
ALSO REFERENCE SPECIFIC PLANS
01:30:05.166 --> 01:30:08.002
AND I I CAN SHARE THE CONCERN
01:30:08.069 --> 01:30:09.637
THAT GENERAL PLANS DEPENDING ON
01:30:09.704 --> 01:30:12.006
THE COMMUNITY CAN SOMETIMES NOT.
01:30:12.073 --> 01:30:13.741
BE AS MUCH AS THEY'RE SUPPOSED
01:30:13.808 --> 01:30:14.509
TO COVER BROADLY THINGS LIKE
01:30:14.575 --> 01:30:16.244
CONTAMINANTS.
01:30:16.310 --> 01:30:17.779
THEY DON'T GET INTO THE LEVEL OF
01:30:17.845 --> 01:30:21.315
DETAIL. FOUR AT YOU KNOW EVERY
01:30:21.382 --> 01:30:22.850
PARCEL OR WHATEVER.
01:30:22.917 --> 01:30:25.486
AND BUT AREA SPECIFIC PLANS
01:30:25.553 --> 01:30:28.222
WOULD HAVE MORE WOULD HAVE BEEN
01:30:28.289 --> 01:30:30.691
A LITTLE MORE --
01:30:30.758 --> 01:30:31.359
YEAH IN SO.
01:30:31.425 --> 01:30:32.460
THANK YOU [inaudible]
01:30:32.527 --> 01:30:38.032
ON SO IS THE AUTHOR OPEN AND
01:30:38.099 --> 01:30:40.501
AGAIN WITHOUT THE CHAIR HERE-DON'T KNOW IF THE CHARITY OPEN
01:30:40.568 --> 01:30:44.138
BUT IS THE AUTHOR OPEN TO HAVING --
01:30:44.205 --> 01:30:46.140
IF THE AREA HAS A SPECIFIC PLAN
01:30:46.207 --> 01:30:48.676
OR IF THE SPACE PLAN IS UPDATED
01:30:48.743 --> 01:30:51.913
WITHIN A CERTAIN WINDOW --
01:30:51.979 --> 01:30:53.414
FOR THEN THE EXCEPTION TO BE. TO
01:30:53.481 --> 01:30:56.584
BE PUT IN EFFECT.
01:30:56.651 --> 01:30:58.619
YOU A YES I BELIEVE IT BUT I
01:30:58.686 --> 01:31:00.955
BELIEVE THE LANGUAGE.
01:31:01.022 --> 01:31:01.556
IN CAPSULE IT'S WHAT YOU'RE
01:31:01.622 --> 01:31:03.591
TALKING ABOUT BUT IF IT DOESN'T
01:31:03.658 --> 01:31:05.393
I WOULDN'T HAVE I I WOULD AGREE
01:31:05.459 --> 01:31:06.460
THAT THAT MAKES SENSE IN AND
01:31:06.527 --> 01:31:09.463
I'VE AND I'VE.
01:31:09.530 --> 01:31:10.998
ASSUMING THERE'S AN OPPORTUNITY
01:31:11.065 --> 01:31:12.500
TO DO AMENDMENTS AYE I'M
01:31:12.567 --> 01:31:14.435
INTERESTED IN AMENDMENTS THAT
01:31:14.502 --> 01:31:15.803
MAKE IT VERY CLEAR THAT YOU HAVE
01:31:15.870 --> 01:31:17.305
TO HAVE [inaudible]
01:31:17.371 --> 01:31:19.841
CURRENT DATA.
01:31:19.907 --> 01:31:21.242
ON READ OUT YET TRINITY ZONES
01:31:21.309 --> 01:31:22.677
AND THAT CURRENT DATE ON SO THAT
01:31:22.743 --> 01:31:24.412
WE BECAUSE NONE OF US WANT I
01:31:24.478 --> 01:31:25.847
WANT THAT HOUSING SO THAT'S PART
01:31:25.913 --> 01:31:27.348
OF MY MOTIVATION.
01:31:27.415 --> 01:31:29.016
BUT NONE OF US WANT TO HOUSING
01:31:29.083 --> 01:31:30.384
AND LEARN LATER THAT.
01:31:30.451 --> 01:31:32.320
DUE TO INADEQUATE ENVIRONMENTAL
01:31:32.386 --> 01:31:33.187
REVIEW.
01:31:33.254 --> 01:31:35.056
HOUSING WAS BUILT ON A ABSOLUTE
01:31:35.122 --> 01:31:37.792
EMANATED SITE ABSOLUTELY YEAH
01:31:37.859 --> 01:31:38.092
[inaudible]
01:31:38.159 --> 01:31:39.827
SO.
01:31:39.894 --> 01:31:41.362
ANYWAY THAT'S WHAT I'M LOOKING
01:31:41.429 --> 01:31:44.866
FOR AND WHEN SHE RETURNED SHE IF
01:31:44.932 --> 01:31:46.267
THERE'S ANY INTEREST IN SUCH A
01:31:46.334 --> 01:31:46.467
THING.
01:31:46.534 --> 01:31:48.202
SENATOR.
01:31:48.269 --> 01:31:49.670
OF THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR --
01:31:49.737 --> 01:31:52.640
OR VICE CHAIR.
01:31:52.707 --> 01:31:54.976
I WE WE WENT THROUGH THE THE MAP
01:31:55.042 --> 01:31:57.011
IN MY OFFICE AND THAT THE KIND
01:31:57.078 --> 01:31:58.813
OF OPPORTUNITY ZONES OF THIS
01:31:58.880 --> 01:32:01.849
BILL IDENTIFIES I THINK.
01:32:01.916 --> 01:32:03.851
WE CAN ALL AGREE I MEAN I JUST
01:32:03.918 --> 01:32:05.786
LOOK RIGHT HOME IT CANOGA PARK
01:32:05.853 --> 01:32:07.989
AND THIS IS A COMMUNITY THAT.
01:32:08.055 --> 01:32:10.458
IS STRUGGLING BUT SO CLOSE TO
01:32:10.524 --> 01:32:13.294
TRACK TRANSCENDING THAT CYCLE OF
01:32:13.361 --> 01:32:15.363
POVERTY AND FLIPPING INTO
01:32:15.429 --> 01:32:16.797
SOMETHING REALLY PROSPEROUS AND
01:32:16.864 --> 01:32:19.767
EXCITING SO I YOU KNOW I'D I
01:32:19.834 --> 01:32:20.768
DON'T --
01:32:20.835 --> 01:32:22.270
LEVY ANY THESE CRITICISMS
01:32:22.336 --> 01:32:23.771
LIGHTLY BECAUSE I I FRANKLY
01:32:23.838 --> 01:32:26.007
THINK WE NEED TO TAKE ADVANTAGE
01:32:26.073 --> 01:32:27.141
OF THAT MONEY.
01:32:27.208 --> 01:32:28.409
I THINK THAT THERE'S A LOT IN
01:32:28.476 --> 01:32:29.844
HERE THAT ACTUALLY CAN GET US TO
01:32:29.911 --> 01:32:31.312
THAT POINT.
01:32:31.379 --> 01:32:33.781
BUT GOING BACK TO THIS SPECIFIC
01:32:33.848 --> 01:32:35.449
AREA THE SOME OF THE THINGS
01:32:35.516 --> 01:32:36.050
WE'VE BEEN TALKING THAT WE'RE
01:32:36.117 --> 01:32:38.352
GOING THROUGH --
01:32:38.419 --> 01:32:40.454
A MASTER PLAN REVISION FOR AN
01:32:40.521 --> 01:32:42.123
AREA SPECIFIC PLAN RIGHT NOW IN
01:32:42.189 --> 01:32:43.557
THAT IN THAT CAN OF THE PARKER
01:32:43.624 --> 01:32:45.726
AND WARNER CENTER SO IT'S A OLD
01:32:45.793 --> 01:32:47.428
RETAIL MALL SITE.
01:32:47.495 --> 01:32:48.796
WITH THE BACK END OF IT THAT WAS
01:32:48.863 --> 01:32:50.998
AN OLD ROCKET --
01:32:51.065 --> 01:32:52.967
RESEARCH LABORATORY SO.
01:32:53.034 --> 01:32:54.435
PICTURE THAT BIG PLOT READ THE
01:32:54.502 --> 01:32:56.170
MAIL SAN FERNANDO VALLEY.
01:32:56.237 --> 01:32:59.006
LONG ARDUOUS PROCESS TO DEVELOP
01:32:59.073 --> 01:33:00.107
WITH THE PLAN TO BE FOR THAT
01:33:00.174 --> 01:33:00.942
SURROUNDING COMMUNITY HOW THEY
01:33:01.008 --> 01:33:03.177
WOULD DEAL WITH.
01:33:03.244 --> 01:33:05.179
YOU KNOW NEW HIGH RISES MIXED
01:33:05.246 --> 01:33:10.051
USE RETAIL AND THROUGH ABOUT TEN
01:33:10.117 --> 01:33:11.819
YEARS FRANKLY OF CONVERSATION
01:33:11.886 --> 01:33:14.021
WITH DEVELOPERS AND REALLY TRY
01:33:14.088 --> 01:33:15.256
TO WORK OUT ISSUES.
01:33:15.323 --> 01:33:17.959
WE WE DID PHASE ONE AND HIGH
01:33:18.025 --> 01:33:19.260
RISES ARE GOING UP IN THEIR
01:33:19.327 --> 01:33:20.361
APARTMENTS GOING UP AND THINGS
01:33:20.428 --> 01:33:22.129
ARE THINGS ARE HAPPENING.
01:33:22.196 --> 01:33:24.799
BUT FACE TO NOW INVOLVES THIS.
01:33:24.865 --> 01:33:26.100
THEY SAID THERE WERE HARD TO
01:33:26.167 --> 01:33:27.568
PROPERTY THE ROCKET SIDE RIGHT
01:33:27.635 --> 01:33:30.538
AND SO MY QUESTION IS A BIT MORE
01:33:30.604 --> 01:33:32.340
TECHNICAL ONE WHICH IS.
01:33:32.406 --> 01:33:34.108
IF IF WE'RE GOING IF THE
01:33:34.175 --> 01:33:35.476
COMMUNITY BEFORE SORT OF
01:33:35.543 --> 01:33:36.377
REASSESSING THE ENVIRONMENTAL
01:33:36.444 --> 01:33:38.846
IMPACTS WHICH IS REALLY WHAT'S
01:33:38.913 --> 01:33:40.014
BEING ANTICIPATE HONEST VERY
01:33:40.081 --> 01:33:42.183
SITE SPECIFIC A PROJECT SPECIFIC
01:33:42.249 --> 01:33:43.017
PLAN.
01:33:43.084 --> 01:33:44.552
AS WELL AS A SORT OF BROADER
01:33:44.618 --> 01:33:46.053
REVISION TO THIS MASTER PLAN FOR
01:33:46.120 --> 01:33:48.122
THE WHOLE AREA.
01:33:48.189 --> 01:33:50.591
WITH IF IF WE PASS THIS BILL
01:33:50.658 --> 01:33:52.259
WOULD WOULD THAT PROCESS BE
01:33:52.326 --> 01:33:53.894
TRUNCATED IN OTHER WORDS.
01:33:53.961 --> 01:33:55.830
DID WE HAVE TO SHUT OFF PUBLIC
01:33:55.896 --> 01:33:58.399
PUBLIC COMMENT ON THAT SPECIFIC
01:33:58.466 --> 01:34:01.936
PLAN -- YEAH.
01:34:02.003 --> 01:34:03.237
I I JUST WANNA KNOW HOW THE
01:34:03.304 --> 01:34:04.905
INTERACTION OF OF LAW AND SERVE
01:34:04.972 --> 01:34:06.807
EXISTING LOCAL UPDATES COULD I
01:34:06.874 --> 01:34:08.442
GET IF YOU'RE DONE AYE I
01:34:08.509 --> 01:34:09.777
APPRECIATE ACTUALLY THAT.
01:34:09.844 --> 01:34:11.212
THAT'S WHAT A CONCESSION OR
01:34:11.278 --> 01:34:12.680
OPENNESS TO MODIFICATION SAYING
01:34:12.747 --> 01:34:13.781
OKAY WE HAVE TO HAVE THEM LOOK
01:34:13.848 --> 01:34:15.416
IF YOU'RE AN UPDATED I GENERAL
01:34:15.483 --> 01:34:16.717
PLAN OR EVEN.
01:34:16.784 --> 01:34:18.619
MAYBE EVEN AREA SPECIFIC BUT
01:34:18.686 --> 01:34:20.054
WHAT IF YOUR MID.
01:34:20.121 --> 01:34:21.155
MID UPDATE WHAT WHAT HAPPENS
01:34:21.222 --> 01:34:23.724
THEN.
01:34:23.791 --> 01:34:25.793
YEAH THOUGHT ON THAT.
01:34:25.860 --> 01:34:27.228
I I DON'T SORT OF A LOT HEAVIER
01:34:27.294 --> 01:34:28.763
MID UPDATE BUT I WOULD SAY THE
01:34:28.829 --> 01:34:30.831
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD --
01:34:30.898 --> 01:34:32.133
WOULD HAVE ALREADY OCCURED UNDER
01:34:32.199 --> 01:34:33.634
SPECIFIC PLANNER GENERALPLAN
01:34:33.701 --> 01:34:34.502
<c.green> I ARE.</c>
01:34:34.568 --> 01:34:36.704
A FOR THE SPECIFIC SITE.
01:34:36.771 --> 01:34:38.339
THE EXEMPTION DOESN'T ALLOW THE
01:34:38.406 --> 01:34:40.141
AGENCY TO JUST MAGICALLY WAVE
01:34:40.207 --> 01:34:41.509
IT'S WANTED SAY THIS PROJECTS
01:34:41.575 --> 01:34:43.978
GONNA QUALIFY UNDER AB.
01:34:44.045 --> 01:34:44.578
THIRTY THIRTY THEY HAVE TO GO
01:34:44.645 --> 01:34:46.147
THROUGH EACH OF THE REQUIREMENTS
01:34:46.213 --> 01:34:47.515
UNDER THIS BILL AND MAKE A
01:34:47.581 --> 01:34:49.150
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE FINDING TO
01:34:49.216 --> 01:34:50.017
SUPPORT.
01:34:50.084 --> 01:34:54.221
THAT SO THAT'S ON THE COUNTY THE
01:34:54.288 --> 01:34:55.456
WHATEVER THE AGENCY OKAY RIGHT
01:34:55.523 --> 01:34:58.092
AND SIEBEL EXEMPTIONS ARE
01:34:58.159 --> 01:34:59.994
SPECIFICALLY TO STREAMLINE THE
01:35:00.061 --> 01:35:01.629
PROCESS SO THERE ARE SOME.
01:35:01.695 --> 01:35:03.330
PUBLIC COMMENT --
01:35:03.397 --> 01:35:04.832
REMOVAL BUT I GUESS I SHOULD SAY
01:35:04.899 --> 01:35:06.167
THERE ISN'T PUBLIC COMMENT FOR
01:35:06.233 --> 01:35:08.502
EXEMPTION BUT THEY DO NOTICE THE
01:35:08.569 --> 01:35:09.136
COMMUNITY THAT THEY'RE GOING TO
01:35:09.203 --> 01:35:10.237
DO EXEMPTION.
01:35:10.304 --> 01:35:11.906
OR OTHER SUCH LIMITATIONS IS SIX
01:35:11.972 --> 01:35:14.108
MONTHS RADICALLY SO I JUST
01:35:14.175 --> 01:35:14.775
PICTURING THAT NOTICE TO THE
01:35:14.842 --> 01:35:17.978
COMMUNITY AND THE I MEAN THERE'S
01:35:18.045 --> 01:35:18.679
ALREADY SUCH A FERVENT BECAUSE
01:35:18.746 --> 01:35:19.780
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT.
01:35:19.847 --> 01:35:20.881
ON THE EDGE OF THE SUBURBS YOU
01:35:20.948 --> 01:35:21.949
WANT TO BUILD A LITTLE BIT OF
01:35:22.016 --> 01:35:23.884
HER VANITY AND THE TENSION OF
01:35:23.951 --> 01:35:25.186
THAT CONVERSATION IT'S HARD.
01:35:25.252 --> 01:35:26.420
SO BALANCE --
01:35:26.487 --> 01:35:28.756
I AGREE SO I LISTEN I APPRECIATE
01:35:28.823 --> 01:35:30.658
THAT THE NEED IS THERE.
01:35:30.724 --> 01:35:31.225
YOU I'M STRUGGLING WITH THIS
01:35:31.292 --> 01:35:33.861
BECAUSE I I DON'T WANT TO CUT
01:35:33.928 --> 01:35:36.163
OFF THAT PROCESS I WANT TO FIND
01:35:36.230 --> 01:35:37.598
A WAY TO WORK IT THROUGH.
01:35:37.665 --> 01:35:39.433
I THINK THERE SOME PATH TO
01:35:39.500 --> 01:35:41.202
ALLOWING THOSE KINDS OF UPDATES
01:35:41.268 --> 01:35:45.339
TO OCCUR AND EVEN PUSHING THEM
01:35:45.406 --> 01:35:46.173
TO SORT OF TAKE ADVANTAGE OF
01:35:46.240 --> 01:35:46.941
THIS RIGHT LIKE HOW DO WE GO
01:35:47.007 --> 01:35:48.542
HOME AND SELL THIS IS WHAT WE
01:35:48.609 --> 01:35:49.710
TALKED ABOUT THIS AND SO SO THE
01:35:49.777 --> 01:35:51.612
WAY I SEE THIS IS THAT THERE'S
01:35:51.679 --> 01:35:51.912
OPPORTUNITY.
01:35:51.979 --> 01:35:53.114
AT THAT.
01:35:53.180 --> 01:35:54.682
THE FUND HAS TO BE PUT TOGETHER.
01:35:54.748 --> 01:35:57.318
THAT WOULD UP WOULD COME IN AND
01:35:57.384 --> 01:36:02.223
DO A PROPOSAL OR IT IT OR DO A
01:36:02.289 --> 01:36:04.725
YEAH A PROPOSAL AND IN IF YOU'VE
01:36:04.792 --> 01:36:07.161
GOT IT AN EXISTING --
01:36:07.228 --> 01:36:09.196
PROCESS IT'S GOING THROUGH THAT
01:36:09.263 --> 01:36:11.265
PROCESS WOULD CONTINUE --
01:36:11.332 --> 01:36:15.836
BUT POSTAL COULD COME FORWARD.
01:36:15.903 --> 01:36:17.905
AND IF IF IF THEIR IS --
01:36:17.972 --> 01:36:21.208
INTEREST IN THAT.
01:36:21.275 --> 01:36:23.744
LEVEL OF INVESTMENT IN THE
01:36:23.811 --> 01:36:25.146
COMMUNITY WHATEVER IT WOULD BE
01:36:25.212 --> 01:36:27.148
IT WOULD FIT IN WITH WHATEVER IT
01:36:27.214 --> 01:36:28.482
THE COMMUNITY IS GOING TO I
01:36:28.549 --> 01:36:29.650
DON'T SEE IT BEING OKAY WE'RE
01:36:29.717 --> 01:36:30.451
TAKING IT AWAY AND WE'RE GOING
01:36:30.518 --> 01:36:31.485
TO RUN WITH IT BECAUSE YOU'RE
01:36:31.552 --> 01:36:32.887
NOT GOING TO GET THE LOCAL.
01:36:32.953 --> 01:36:36.423
JURISDICTION TO WANT TO SUBVERT
01:36:36.490 --> 01:36:38.025
A PROCESS THAT'S BEEN GOING ON
01:36:38.092 --> 01:36:40.194
THAT'S BEEN ONGOING --
01:36:40.261 --> 01:36:41.662
WHOEVER THE LEAD AGENCIES BENT.
01:36:41.729 --> 01:36:43.097
THEY'RE GOING TO WANT TO MAKE
01:36:43.164 --> 01:36:44.532
SURE THAT WHATEVER THEY DO IS IN
01:36:44.598 --> 01:36:45.799
LINE WITH WHATEVER IT IS THE
01:36:45.866 --> 01:36:47.034
COMMUNITY HAS BEEN WORKING
01:36:47.101 --> 01:36:49.136
TOWARDS SO THAT'S THAT'S A WANT
01:36:49.203 --> 01:36:52.907
TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE FUNDING.
01:36:52.973 --> 01:36:54.508
DON'T AND THEY CAN DO IT BECAUSE
01:36:54.575 --> 01:36:56.877
IT'S NOT MANDATORY AND NOBODY
01:36:56.944 --> 01:36:58.345
CAN FORCE THE JURISDICTION TO DO
01:36:58.412 --> 01:36:59.914
IT THERE ARE SO MANY THINGS THAT
01:36:59.980 --> 01:37:01.048
JURISDICTION HAS.
01:37:01.115 --> 01:37:02.683
TO PASS DEFINED AS PART OF THEIR
01:37:02.750 --> 01:37:04.251
FINDING PROCESS THAT THEY COULD
01:37:04.318 --> 01:37:05.419
TELL.
01:37:05.486 --> 01:37:06.687
THE INVESTORS WERE NOT
01:37:06.754 --> 01:37:08.289
INTERESTED IN IT WE HAVE OUR OWN
01:37:08.355 --> 01:37:09.690
IDEAS ABOUT WHAT WAS GOING TO
01:37:09.757 --> 01:37:11.659
OUR FOLKS IN CAN APARTMENT TO GO
01:37:11.725 --> 01:37:13.494
THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES THAT AND
01:37:13.561 --> 01:37:15.529
PLEAD TO SAY YOU KNOW.
01:37:15.596 --> 01:37:16.664
SLOW IT DOWN A LITTLE
01:37:16.730 --> 01:37:17.965
UNIVERSALLY TO COUNTY
01:37:18.032 --> 01:37:19.366
INCORPORATED PROJECT I SAID
01:37:19.433 --> 01:37:20.267
GETTING CORPORATES WITH AN
01:37:20.334 --> 01:37:21.869
INCORPORATED CITY OF LOS ANGELES
01:37:21.936 --> 01:37:22.770
BUT THERE'S A LOT OF THEM I MEAN
01:37:22.836 --> 01:37:24.772
THEY'RE SEVEN UNINCORPORATED AS
01:37:24.838 --> 01:37:26.807
WELL SO THERE'S SOMEONE LA
01:37:26.874 --> 01:37:27.875
COUNTY COMMUNITIES ALL OVER THE
01:37:27.942 --> 01:37:29.043
PLACE WE THOUSAND OAKS I MEAN
01:37:29.109 --> 01:37:29.410
THERE'S A LOT.
01:37:29.476 --> 01:37:32.746
OF OTHER THOUSAND IS NOT THE
01:37:32.813 --> 01:37:34.014
THAT'S WORKS OUT.
01:37:34.081 --> 01:37:35.849
INTERESTING DISTRICTS RIGHT THAT.
01:37:35.916 --> 01:37:37.451
YOU WERE INTERESTING SO ANYWAY
01:37:37.518 --> 01:37:39.420
THANK YOU FOR THE OPEN THIS AND
01:37:39.486 --> 01:37:40.854
YEAH I I I I I ALSO STRUGGLE
01:37:40.921 --> 01:37:42.756
WITH THE JUST TIMING OF IT ALL
01:37:42.823 --> 01:37:44.458
ON OUR TRUNCATED PERIOD DID TO
01:37:44.525 --> 01:37:45.526
WORK THESE THINGS THROUGH
01:37:45.593 --> 01:37:47.895
BECAUSE I ACTUALLY DO THINK
01:37:47.962 --> 01:37:49.263
THERE SOME DAYLIGHT HERE.
01:37:49.330 --> 01:37:49.863
FEDERAL.
01:37:49.930 --> 01:37:52.333
THANK YOU I JUST.
01:37:52.399 --> 01:37:53.601
HEARING THE QUESTION FROM
01:37:53.667 --> 01:37:53.901
[inaudible]
01:37:53.968 --> 01:37:56.837
QUESTION FROM SENATE STERN.
01:37:56.904 --> 01:37:58.272
I JUST BROUGHT SOME OTHER OF
01:37:58.339 --> 01:37:59.873
QUESTIONS FOR ME.
01:37:59.940 --> 01:38:02.409
OKAY SO WE DON'T DO SEEK WERE
01:38:02.476 --> 01:38:05.946
AND SAY WE BUILD A HOUSING --
01:38:06.013 --> 01:38:06.513
DEVELOPMENT IN ONE OF THESE
01:38:06.580 --> 01:38:08.315
AREAS.
01:38:08.382 --> 01:38:09.817
AND SAY.
01:38:09.883 --> 01:38:11.485
THE SOIL STILL CONTAMINATED THE
01:38:11.552 --> 01:38:13.821
WATER INTO THE WATER MAYBE
01:38:13.887 --> 01:38:15.589
CONTAMINATE THERE'S OTHER TOXINS
01:38:15.656 --> 01:38:17.391
WHICH HAPPENS ALL THROUGHOUT MY
01:38:17.458 --> 01:38:19.193
ENTIRE DISTRICT OF THE TIME.
01:38:19.260 --> 01:38:21.161
WHAT'S THAT WHO.
01:38:21.228 --> 01:38:22.062
WELL HELD LIABLE THEM IN THAT
01:38:22.129 --> 01:38:23.998
SITUATION.
01:38:24.064 --> 01:38:25.065
THE LEAD AGENCY WOULD BE HELD
01:38:25.132 --> 01:38:26.834
LIABLE BECAUSE THEIR FINDINGS
01:38:26.900 --> 01:38:28.202
UNDER THIS BILL.
01:38:28.269 --> 01:38:29.036
WERE NOT BASED ON SUBSTANTIAL
01:38:29.103 --> 01:38:30.237
EVIDENCE.
01:38:30.304 --> 01:38:31.071
IT'S NOT AS THOUGH THERE'S NO
01:38:31.138 --> 01:38:32.806
SEQUEL IT'S PEOPLE EXEMPTION SO
01:38:32.873 --> 01:38:34.508
YOU GO THROUGH THE LIMITED STEEP
01:38:34.575 --> 01:38:35.943
A PROCESS WE DON'T DO A FULL
01:38:36.010 --> 01:38:38.612
BLOWN MND OR YEAH I ARE SO THEN
01:38:38.679 --> 01:38:39.780
HOW WOULD YOU FIND OUT.
01:38:39.847 --> 01:38:41.482
WHAT THEIR NOTICE THAT THE X.
01:38:41.548 --> 01:38:42.750
BOB LIVES?
01:38:42.816 --> 01:38:43.517
WHEN I WAS IN PRIVATE PRACTICE
01:38:43.584 --> 01:38:45.085
I'VE SUED UNDER --
01:38:45.152 --> 01:38:47.087
SEQUEL EXEMPTION TO BASICALLY
01:38:47.154 --> 01:38:48.756
HOLDEN AGENCY LIABLE FOR FAILING
01:38:48.822 --> 01:38:49.890
TO MAKE.
01:38:49.957 --> 01:38:51.125
THEIR FINDINGS UNDER --
01:38:51.191 --> 01:38:53.160
SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE STANDARDS.
01:38:53.227 --> 01:38:55.195
THERE'S BASICALLY --
01:38:55.262 --> 01:38:58.198
SEE GRAVITY OF THAT PROCESS.
01:38:58.265 --> 01:39:00.334
Q. IS A SUMMARY OF FROM.
01:39:00.401 --> 01:39:02.703
OPPOSITION I CAN CLARIFY AND I
01:39:02.770 --> 01:39:07.207
JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE WHENEVER.
01:39:07.274 --> 01:39:08.942
YEAH HOW DO YOU [inaudible]
01:39:09.009 --> 01:39:10.811
RIGHT.
01:39:10.878 --> 01:39:12.313
SO -- UNDER
01:39:12.379 --> 01:39:13.647
THIS PROCESS IF THERE'S NOTICE
01:39:13.714 --> 01:39:15.115
OF AN EXEMPTION FILES AND THE
01:39:15.182 --> 01:39:16.750
NOTICES PROPERLY GIVE AND I
01:39:16.817 --> 01:39:17.851
BELIEVE THERE'S A THIRTY DAY
01:39:17.918 --> 01:39:19.119
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS THAT BEN
01:39:19.186 --> 01:39:20.754
RUNS INTO CHALLENGE THAT
01:39:20.821 --> 01:39:21.622
EXEMPTION.
01:39:21.689 --> 01:39:22.489
AND AFTER THAT WINDOW CLOSES THE
01:39:22.556 --> 01:39:25.459
ABILITY GONE.
01:39:25.526 --> 01:39:27.127
UNDER SEAQUEST NAM IF THERE IS
01:39:27.194 --> 01:39:28.429
EXISTING CONTAMINATION ON THE
01:39:28.495 --> 01:39:29.697
SITE THERE COULD BE RESPONSIBLE
01:39:29.763 --> 01:39:31.498
PARTIES UNDER NUMEROUS OTHER
01:39:31.565 --> 01:39:33.033
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS --
01:39:33.100 --> 01:39:34.168
SOME OF WHICH COULD BE HARD TO
01:39:34.234 --> 01:39:35.769
FIND IF THEY'RE GONE OUT OF
01:39:35.836 --> 01:39:37.571
BUSINESS OR YOU KNOW AS WE'VE
01:39:37.638 --> 01:39:38.706
SEEN A LOT OF GROUND MARK
01:39:38.772 --> 01:39:39.740
CONTAMINATION ISSUES THERE'S
01:39:39.807 --> 01:39:40.374
NUMEROUS.
01:39:40.441 --> 01:39:41.942
RESPONSIVE PARTIES IT'S HARD TO
01:39:42.009 --> 01:39:43.644
FIGURE OUT WHO WHO'S AT FAULT --
01:39:43.711 --> 01:39:45.245
IN THOSE CASES SOMETIMES IT
01:39:45.312 --> 01:39:46.714
WOULD FALL THE GENERAL TAXPAYERS
01:39:46.780 --> 01:39:47.781
IF IT'S SOMETHING THAT WE DO
01:39:47.848 --> 01:39:48.849
THROUGH A GROUNDWATER
01:39:48.916 --> 01:39:50.651
REMEDIATION PROGRAM OR SOME
01:39:50.718 --> 01:39:52.486
OTHER SORT PROGRAM --
01:39:52.553 --> 01:39:53.754
AND IF THERE ARE HEALTH ISSUES
01:39:53.821 --> 01:39:54.988
AS BEFORE AN OBVIOUS THE BY THE
01:39:55.055 --> 01:39:57.224
RESIDENTS AND AND AND THE COUNTY
01:39:57.291 --> 01:39:58.826
PROGRAMS OR WHATEVER SINCE.
01:39:58.892 --> 01:40:00.527
SENATOR LET ME LET ME JUST
01:40:00.594 --> 01:40:02.029
BECAUSE THIS GETS REALLY AS YOU
01:40:02.096 --> 01:40:02.830
START.
01:40:02.896 --> 01:40:04.331
WHO CAN SUE AND ALL THAT KIND OF
01:40:04.398 --> 01:40:05.999
GOOD STUFF LET ME JUST SAY THAT
01:40:06.066 --> 01:40:08.068
PART OF THE PROCESS IS THAT THAT
01:40:08.135 --> 01:40:10.170
THE LEAD AGENCY HAS TO MAKE A
01:40:10.237 --> 01:40:11.805
SERIES OF FINDINGS?
01:40:11.872 --> 01:40:14.408
SO SO IN THOSE IF.
01:40:14.475 --> 01:40:15.309
THE CONTAMINATION YOU'RE TALKING
01:40:15.376 --> 01:40:18.145
ABOUT IT'S NOT A SURPRISE.
01:40:18.212 --> 01:40:20.147
IT IT I MEAN IN TERMS OF KNOWING
01:40:20.214 --> 01:40:22.149
THAT THERE ARE CERTAIN AREAS.
01:40:22.216 --> 01:40:24.385
ANY OLD CITY [inaudible] FOR
01:40:24.451 --> 01:40:27.121
EXAMPLE --
01:40:27.187 --> 01:40:29.056
WHERE THERE HAVE BEEN?
01:40:29.123 --> 01:40:31.091
INDEX IT AT REDUCES SUCH AS GAS
01:40:31.158 --> 01:40:32.826
STATIONS.
01:40:32.893 --> 01:40:35.362
CLEANERS BOMB IT REQUIRES YOU TO
01:40:35.429 --> 01:40:36.597
GOING INTO SOIL TESTING AND
01:40:36.663 --> 01:40:38.365
WATER TESTING.
01:40:38.432 --> 01:40:41.201
AND THE THAT THEY THEN LOCAL
01:40:41.268 --> 01:40:42.770
JURISDICTION THE LEAD AGENCY.
01:40:42.836 --> 01:40:45.038
CAN CAN ASK FOR THAT SPECIFIC
01:40:45.105 --> 01:40:46.273
KIND OF DATA.
01:40:46.340 --> 01:40:47.841
BEFORE MAKING THEIR FINDING IN
01:40:47.908 --> 01:40:49.877
PROBABLY ABSOLUTELY SHOULD IT'S
01:40:49.943 --> 01:40:51.879
IT'S NOT A WAY TO GET AROUND
01:40:51.945 --> 01:40:52.413
SEQUENCE.
01:40:52.479 --> 01:40:53.847
IT'S A WAY TO EXPEDITE THE
01:40:53.914 --> 01:40:55.516
PROCESS AND SO I I DON'T IN
01:40:55.582 --> 01:40:57.050
TERMS OF THE PROCESS.
01:40:57.117 --> 01:40:58.552
YOU WOULD WANT THEM TO GET THAT
01:40:58.619 --> 01:41:00.087
KIND OF DATA SO THAT BEFORE
01:41:00.154 --> 01:41:01.688
ANYTHING IS CONSTRUCTED.
01:41:01.755 --> 01:41:03.223
THAT YOU YOU HAVE THAT
01:41:03.290 --> 01:41:04.558
INFORMATION AND YOU KNOW AND
01:41:04.625 --> 01:41:05.692
THEY CAN MAKE THE FINDINGS TO
01:41:05.759 --> 01:41:07.861
SAY WE HAVE DETERMINED BASED ON
01:41:07.928 --> 01:41:09.663
THE STUDIES THAT WE'VE ASKED.
01:41:09.730 --> 01:41:12.666
FOR THAT THERE IS IS NO CONTENT
01:41:12.733 --> 01:41:15.536
BE MITIGATED BY AB IN CND AND SO
01:41:15.602 --> 01:41:16.804
ON AND PART OF THAT HAPPENS IN
01:41:16.870 --> 01:41:18.806
ANY IN ANY CONSTRUCTION PROJECT
01:41:18.872 --> 01:41:20.574
THAT THAT HAPPENED SO.
01:41:20.641 --> 01:41:22.543
SO -- IF THE
01:41:22.609 --> 01:41:24.411
DATA.
01:41:24.478 --> 01:41:27.514
WAS NOT CORRECT THEN THERE'S
01:41:27.581 --> 01:41:29.283
THERE'S THERE'S REMEDIES BUT THE
01:41:29.349 --> 01:41:31.118
WHOLE IDEA BEHIND THIS IS TO
01:41:31.185 --> 01:41:32.386
MAKE SURE THAT EVERYTHING GETS
01:41:32.453 --> 01:41:34.354
CLEANED UP BECAUSE WHAT WE FOUND
01:41:34.421 --> 01:41:35.522
IN OUR STUDY.
01:41:35.589 --> 01:41:38.292
IS THAT OUT OF THAT THAT.
01:41:38.358 --> 01:41:41.295
A HIGH PERCENTAGE OVER 60%.
01:41:41.361 --> 01:41:44.698
OF THE OPPORTUNITIES OWNS ALL
01:41:44.765 --> 01:41:45.632
OVER THE COUNTRY.
01:41:45.699 --> 01:41:47.868
WERE UP BROWNFIELDS SO THEY HAVE
01:41:47.935 --> 01:41:49.603
TO BE CLEANED UP.
01:41:49.670 --> 01:41:52.372
AND CALIFORNIA WOULD THAT HAS TO
01:41:52.439 --> 01:41:53.574
DO THE SAME THING I MEAN THAT
01:41:53.640 --> 01:41:54.875
WE'RE NOT SAYING THAT YOU DON'T
01:41:54.942 --> 01:41:57.044
SO RIGHT NOW I I UNDERSTAND WHAT
01:41:57.110 --> 01:41:57.678
YOU'RE WHERE YOU'RE TRYING TO DO
01:41:57.744 --> 01:41:58.645
I JUST WANNA MAKE SURE.
01:41:58.712 --> 01:42:00.714
IN MY HEAD YOU KNOW IF I SUPPORT
01:42:00.781 --> 01:42:02.349
THIS I WANT YOU KNOW WE'VE HAD
01:42:02.416 --> 01:42:04.084
ISSUES IN MY DISTRICT WHERE.
01:42:04.151 --> 01:42:05.919
WE BUILD A SCHOOL WITHOUT A MOVE
01:42:05.986 --> 01:42:06.920
THE KIDS OUT BECAUSE THE KIDS
01:42:06.987 --> 01:42:08.088
ARE BEING THINK.
01:42:08.155 --> 01:42:09.590
WE HAVE TO MOVE RESIDENTS OUT
01:42:09.656 --> 01:42:11.124
BECAUSE YOU KNOW IT'S JUST THE
01:42:11.191 --> 01:42:13.494
NATURE OF THE REGION HEAVY MAN.
01:42:13.560 --> 01:42:15.262
WITH HEAVY MANUFACTURING IN OLD
01:42:15.329 --> 01:42:17.898
STEEL MILLS THIS IS A REALITY --
01:42:17.965 --> 01:42:19.266
AND YOU KNOW YOU LOOK AT
01:42:19.333 --> 01:42:20.033
PARAMOUNT MY DISTRICT FOR
01:42:20.100 --> 01:42:22.035
EXAMPLE WHERE YOU KNOW FUMES
01:42:22.102 --> 01:42:24.605
STILL COME OUT AND YOU KNOW WHAT
01:42:24.671 --> 01:42:25.405
KIND OF FIGURE OUT.
01:42:25.472 --> 01:42:27.541
HOW WE WENT TO MANY MEDIATE THAT
01:42:27.608 --> 01:42:30.444
WHILE WE HAVE?
01:42:30.511 --> 01:42:32.412
SO THESE ARE ALL BIG ISSUE SO
01:42:32.479 --> 01:42:34.081
WHEN I GO HOME SHOULD SUPPORT
01:42:34.147 --> 01:42:35.816
THIS I WANT TO BE ABLE TO SAY.
01:42:35.883 --> 01:42:37.718
YOU KNOW THIS IS WHY I'M DOING
01:42:37.784 --> 01:42:38.886
THIS ON A SURE WE'D WE NEED
01:42:38.952 --> 01:42:39.887
HOUSING.
01:42:39.953 --> 01:42:41.255
BUT WE ALSO HAVE A HISTORY IN
01:42:41.321 --> 01:42:42.523
OUR REGION.
01:42:42.589 --> 01:42:43.857
OF OF SUFFERING THROUGH MAJOR
01:42:43.924 --> 01:42:45.659
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ISSUES AND
01:42:45.726 --> 01:42:46.493
I UNDERSTAND THERE'S A NEED TO
01:42:46.560 --> 01:42:48.362
BUILD HOUSING AND SO MAKE SURE.
01:42:48.428 --> 01:42:49.263
THAT THERE'S STILL SOME SORT OF
01:42:49.329 --> 01:42:50.998
RECOURSE THAT THERE'S DOZENS OF
01:42:51.064 --> 01:42:53.734
OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE TO BE
01:42:53.800 --> 01:42:53.934
ABLE.
01:42:54.001 --> 01:42:55.469
TO NOT ONLY.
01:42:55.536 --> 01:42:57.170
GET SOME REMEDIES BUT HE WILL
01:42:57.237 --> 01:42:58.839
HOLD SOMEBODY ACCOUNTABLE.
01:42:58.906 --> 01:43:00.140
NOW HOW DO YOU DO THAT WITHOUT
01:43:00.207 --> 01:43:01.942
THE TOOL.
01:43:02.009 --> 01:43:02.576
LAKE SEQUEL TO BE ABLE TO PROVE
01:43:02.643 --> 01:43:04.211
THAT.
01:43:04.278 --> 01:43:05.512
THIS WAS INITIALLY SO THAT'S WHY
01:43:05.579 --> 01:43:06.446
I'M JUST GONNA WRAP MY HEAD
01:43:06.513 --> 01:43:08.415
AROUND THANK YOU.
01:43:08.482 --> 01:43:10.918
THANK YOU CENTER LARA --
01:43:10.984 --> 01:43:12.352
THIS CABALLERO IS IT WAS IT WAS
01:43:12.419 --> 01:43:14.187
VERY NICE TO MEET YOU IN PERSON
01:43:14.254 --> 01:43:16.690
IN MY OFFICE INTO IT TO GO OVER --
01:43:16.757 --> 01:43:17.024
MY CONCERNS --
01:43:17.090 --> 01:43:17.991
WITH THE BILL [inaudible]
01:43:18.058 --> 01:43:22.629
AND YOU KNOW IF IT WAS EASY TO
01:43:22.696 --> 01:43:23.530
BUILD AFFORDABLE HOUSING STATE
01:43:23.597 --> 01:43:25.165
OF CALIFORNIA WE WOULD HAVE
01:43:25.232 --> 01:43:25.732
HOUSING CRISIS THAT WE HAVE
01:43:25.799 --> 01:43:27.668
TODAY [inaudible]
01:43:27.734 --> 01:43:32.406
AND WITH REGARD TO OF LIABILITY
01:43:32.472 --> 01:43:34.141
ISSUES YOU KNOW IT.
01:43:34.207 --> 01:43:35.642
I THINK ONE IMPORTANT PART OF
01:43:35.709 --> 01:43:36.877
YOUR BILL IS THAT THIS IS A
01:43:36.944 --> 01:43:38.712
VOLUNTARY DOES NOT MANDATORY.
01:43:38.779 --> 01:43:39.947
AND COMING FROM A BOARD OF
01:43:40.013 --> 01:43:41.682
SUPERVISORS AND THE CITY COUNCIL
01:43:41.748 --> 01:43:42.749
FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS WE ALWAYS
01:43:42.816 --> 01:43:43.750
PUT IN OUR GRIEVANCE
01:43:43.817 --> 01:43:44.051
[inaudible]
01:43:44.117 --> 01:43:45.719
THAT.
01:43:45.786 --> 01:43:47.921
IF A LAWSUIT [inaudible]
01:43:47.988 --> 01:43:49.990
IS.
01:43:50.057 --> 01:43:52.159
LODGED AGAINST THE MUNICIPALITY.
01:43:52.225 --> 01:43:55.729
THAT THE DEVELOPER HATS.
01:43:55.796 --> 01:43:57.264
TO HOLD THE COUNTY OR THE CITY
01:43:57.331 --> 01:43:58.732
HARMLESS ANNOUNCED.
01:43:58.799 --> 01:44:00.167
TO ASSUME THAT LIABILITY IT'S OF
01:44:00.233 --> 01:44:01.335
ASSUMING THEY'RE IN BUSINESS AND
01:44:01.401 --> 01:44:03.704
I'M BANKRUPT --%
01:44:03.770 --> 01:44:05.539
BUT ALSO SAY THAT YOU KNOW WE WE
01:44:05.606 --> 01:44:07.274
WE DISCOUNT FACT THAT AT THE
01:44:07.341 --> 01:44:08.275
LOCAL LEVEL THERE'S A
01:44:08.342 --> 01:44:10.811
COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW --
01:44:10.877 --> 01:44:13.347
WITH OR WITHOUT SECA BECAUSE NO
01:44:13.413 --> 01:44:14.781
COUNTY AND NO CITY IS GOING TO
01:44:14.848 --> 01:44:15.749
WANT TO PUT THEMSELVES ON THE
01:44:15.816 --> 01:44:18.151
LINE IF YOU HAVE A TOXIC SITE.
01:44:18.218 --> 01:44:19.519
AND ARE GONNA PUT RESIDENTIAL
01:44:19.586 --> 01:44:20.754
THAT'S GONNA PUT THE TAXPAYERS
01:44:20.821 --> 01:44:23.290
AND IN HARM'S WAY I'M NOT SAYING
01:44:23.357 --> 01:44:24.725
IT'S A FULL PROOF MECHANISM.
01:44:24.791 --> 01:44:26.627
BUT IT IS A MECHANISM.
01:44:26.693 --> 01:44:27.527
I KNOW IN THE COUNTY OF
01:44:27.594 --> 01:44:28.829
RIVERSIDE WHEN I WAS HERE WE DID
01:44:28.895 --> 01:44:29.896
EXHAUSTIVE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS
01:44:29.963 --> 01:44:31.365
THAT WERE.
01:44:31.431 --> 01:44:32.366
MANY OF WHICH WERE PROBABLY
01:44:32.432 --> 01:44:33.667
RESPONSE TO SEEK WHAT MANY OF
01:44:33.734 --> 01:44:35.102
ARMOR JUST IN RESPONSE TO TRYING
01:44:35.168 --> 01:44:36.536
TO PROTECT COUNTY AND AND TO TRY
01:44:36.603 --> 01:44:38.372
TO PROTECT THE TAXPAYERS.
01:44:38.438 --> 01:44:40.240
ARE WE SAYING WITH THE ABOLITION
01:44:40.307 --> 01:44:41.775
OF OF REDEVELOPMENT AGENCIES
01:44:41.842 --> 01:44:42.442
THAT THERE'S VERY LITTLE
01:44:42.509 --> 01:44:43.844
INCENTIVE TO PROVIDE LOW TO
01:44:43.910 --> 01:44:44.444
MODERATE INCOME HOUSING IN THE
01:44:44.511 --> 01:44:45.646
STATE.
01:44:45.712 --> 01:44:47.514
AND UP WITH THESE OPPORTUNITIES
01:44:47.581 --> 01:44:48.882
OWNS -- YOU
01:44:48.949 --> 01:44:50.283
KNOW IT'S NOT A ONE SIZE FITS
01:44:50.350 --> 01:44:51.485
ALL FOR EVERYBODY BUT IN THE
01:44:51.551 --> 01:44:53.253
COACHELLA VALLEY YOU ARTICULATED --
01:44:53.320 --> 01:44:55.055
SOME SITES THAT COULD VERY WELL
01:44:55.122 --> 01:44:56.723
USE THOSE INVESTMENTS AND WE
01:44:56.790 --> 01:44:58.158
COULD USE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING
01:44:58.225 --> 01:44:59.593
ESPECIALLY FOR A LOT OF ARE
01:44:59.660 --> 01:45:01.028
MIGRANT WORKERS AT WORK.
01:45:01.094 --> 01:45:02.496
A IN THE COACHELLA VALLEY
01:45:02.562 --> 01:45:02.796
[inaudible]
01:45:02.863 --> 01:45:04.765
AND SO.
01:45:04.831 --> 01:45:07.234
I GUESS THE BOTTOM LINE IS THAT.
01:45:07.300 --> 01:45:08.502
WE'RE GONNA NEED TO COMPROMISE
01:45:08.568 --> 01:45:09.436
YOU KNOW I'M NOT REALLY HAPPY
01:45:09.503 --> 01:45:10.737
WITH THE PREVAILING WAGE ISSUES
01:45:10.804 --> 01:45:13.540
OF YOUR BILL --
01:45:13.607 --> 01:45:14.174
BUT I'M ALSO REALLY HAPPY TO SEE
01:45:14.241 --> 01:45:16.009
THAT -- THE
01:45:16.076 --> 01:45:17.477
APPRENTICESHIP PROGRAMS THAT --
01:45:17.544 --> 01:45:20.113
THEY'RE GOING TO USE 60% OR 50%
01:45:20.180 --> 01:45:21.281
OF THE GRADUATES ARE GOING TO BE
01:45:21.348 --> 01:45:23.483
VIRTUALLY GUARANTEE JOBS TO TO
01:45:23.550 --> 01:45:25.886
BUILD THESE THESE PRODUCTS HAS.
01:45:25.952 --> 01:45:27.854
NOT ONLY GOING --
01:45:27.921 --> 01:45:29.222
TO ADD VALUE BECAUSE WE'RE
01:45:29.289 --> 01:45:30.524
PUTTING PEOPLE INTO THE JOB
01:45:30.590 --> 01:45:32.092
MARKET THE PREVIOUSLY WORKED IN
01:45:32.159 --> 01:45:34.361
THE JOB MARKET WITH THE SKILLS --
01:45:34.428 --> 01:45:36.797
INTAKE EVANDER CERTAINLY OF OF
01:45:36.863 --> 01:45:39.199
THE FEDERAL FUNDS AND ALSO LIKE
01:45:39.266 --> 01:45:39.833
THE FACT THAT THERE'S NO PUBLIC
01:45:39.900 --> 01:45:40.967
MONEY.
01:45:41.034 --> 01:45:42.402
THAT'S INVOLVED HERE SO.
01:45:42.469 --> 01:45:43.270
ARE.
01:45:43.336 --> 01:45:44.771
I KNOW OUR CHAIR IS NOT HERE BUT
01:45:44.838 --> 01:45:46.273
I'M HEARING THE CONCERNS OF OF
01:45:46.339 --> 01:45:48.809
THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS --
01:45:48.875 --> 01:45:49.943
I GUESS TO BE FAIR TO ASK.
01:45:50.010 --> 01:45:51.344
ESPECIALLY RESPONSE TO MY
01:45:51.411 --> 01:45:51.778
COLLEAGUE FROM --
01:45:51.845 --> 01:45:54.581
FROM OAKLAND ARE YOU OPEN.
01:45:54.648 --> 01:45:56.583
OF AB -- AN
01:45:56.650 --> 01:45:57.918
AMENDMENT THAT YOU WOULD EVER
01:45:57.984 --> 01:46:00.253
PUT TO WORK OUT WITH THE CHAIR.
01:46:00.320 --> 01:46:01.555
OF THAT WOULD --
01:46:01.621 --> 01:46:03.657
INSURE THAT THERE IS SOME TYPE
01:46:03.724 --> 01:46:05.759
OF TIMELY REVIEW OF
01:46:05.826 --> 01:46:06.960
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES WITH
01:46:07.027 --> 01:46:08.295
RESPECT TO THE GENERAL PLAN OR
01:46:08.361 --> 01:46:09.362
SPECIFIC PLANS.
01:46:09.429 --> 01:46:10.764
OF THE RESPECTIVE COUNTIES OR
01:46:10.831 --> 01:46:11.998
CITIES ARE JURISDICTIONS OVER
01:46:12.065 --> 01:46:13.533
THE OVERSEEING THESE PROJECTS
01:46:13.600 --> 01:46:15.102
WOULD BE OPEN.
01:46:15.168 --> 01:46:16.036
TO I'M I DON'T KNOW WHAT THOSE
01:46:16.103 --> 01:46:17.404
AMENDMENT LIKE WHAT THAT
01:46:17.471 --> 01:46:18.605
AMENDMENT LANGUAGE LOOK LIKE I'M
01:46:18.672 --> 01:46:19.539
I'M SPEAKING FOR MY COLLEAGUE
01:46:19.606 --> 01:46:20.607
WHO'S NOT HERE BUT I'M TRYING TO
01:46:20.674 --> 01:46:21.942
DO WHAT I CAN TO FACILITATE THE
01:46:22.008 --> 01:46:23.577
MOVEMENT OF YOUR BILL.
01:46:23.643 --> 01:46:24.711
YES SENATOR WOULD.
01:46:24.778 --> 01:46:25.479
ARE THERE ANY --
01:46:25.545 --> 01:46:27.414
FOR THE QUESTIONS OF THE AUTHOR.
01:46:27.481 --> 01:46:29.783
IS IT I HAVE NOT IN.
01:46:29.850 --> 01:46:30.517
EIGHT I WANT TO GET THERE YOU
01:46:30.584 --> 01:46:32.586
KNOW TO MAKE THIS THIS THIS WORK
01:46:32.652 --> 01:46:34.087
BUT THERE ISN'T JUST A NUMBER OF
01:46:34.154 --> 01:46:35.856
ISSUES THAT ARE.
01:46:35.922 --> 01:46:37.524
YOU CAN UNCLEAR SPECIAL THE
01:46:37.591 --> 01:46:38.658
HAZARDOUS ISSUE THAT YOU KNOW
01:46:38.725 --> 01:46:39.426
THE HAZARDOUS --
01:46:39.493 --> 01:46:41.828
SITE ISSUE THE THE UPDATED PLANS
01:46:41.895 --> 01:46:42.863
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE COVERING
01:46:42.929 --> 01:46:44.798
ALL THE BASES IN THE PUBLIC
01:46:44.865 --> 01:46:45.832
COMMENT IN INVOLVED IN.
01:46:45.899 --> 01:46:48.568
AND OTHER THINGS AND SO I I
01:46:48.635 --> 01:46:50.737
GUESS UNWILLING TO MOVE IN VOTE
01:46:50.804 --> 01:46:52.472
SUPPORT THE BILL WITH THE
01:46:52.539 --> 01:46:54.307
UNDERSTANDING AND WOULD NOT
01:46:54.374 --> 01:46:55.976
KNOWING AND KNOWING THE CHAIRS.
01:46:56.042 --> 01:46:57.511
CERTAIN YOU KNOW INITIAL
01:46:57.577 --> 01:46:59.212
COMMENTS TODAY.
01:46:59.279 --> 01:47:00.814
MAKES IT A LITTLE DIFFICULT TO
01:47:00.881 --> 01:47:02.816
EXPECT HIM TO WORK WITH.
01:47:02.883 --> 01:47:04.351
YOU ON THE BILL AS IT GOES TO
01:47:04.417 --> 01:47:06.720
HOUSING AND TRANSPORTATION.
01:47:06.787 --> 01:47:09.189
BUT I THINK THAT --
01:47:09.256 --> 01:47:11.091
THERE MAY BE A REASON TO DO THAT
01:47:11.158 --> 01:47:12.659
BASED ON THE FACT IF WE DO.
01:47:12.726 --> 01:47:14.861
SUPPORT THE BILL TODAY.
01:47:14.928 --> 01:47:18.031
AND WITH YOUR COMMITMENT. TO TO
01:47:18.098 --> 01:47:19.733
MAKE SURE THAT THAT WORKS
01:47:19.800 --> 01:47:20.534
BECAUSE I DON'T I THINK THERE
01:47:20.600 --> 01:47:21.902
ARE THE IT IS WORKABLE IN HERE
01:47:21.968 --> 01:47:23.904
AND SO THAT'S THAT'S WHERE I
01:47:23.970 --> 01:47:25.972
WOULD WHICH HOPEFULLY WE CAN
01:47:26.039 --> 01:47:27.040
COME DOWN ON AT THE END OF THE
01:47:27.107 --> 01:47:28.275
DAY WITH THAT.
01:47:28.341 --> 01:47:29.776
THERE'S NEGOTIATIONS AND CAN
01:47:29.843 --> 01:47:30.977
KIND OF FINE TUNE THAT BETWEEN
01:47:31.044 --> 01:47:32.045
NOW AND THEN.
01:47:32.112 --> 01:47:34.281
SO WITH THAT YOU'RE.
01:47:34.347 --> 01:47:35.282
AND THAT'S MY INTENTION
01:47:35.348 --> 01:47:36.783
ABSOLUTELY.
01:47:36.850 --> 01:47:38.351
I I WANTED TO WORK I THINK IT
01:47:38.418 --> 01:47:40.153
CAN WORK.
01:47:40.220 --> 01:47:43.156
AND SO AM I I ONE OF THE THINGS
01:47:43.223 --> 01:47:44.324
I DID AT THE VERY BEGINNING AND
01:47:44.391 --> 01:47:45.725
THERE WEREN'T VERY MANY OF YOU
01:47:45.792 --> 01:47:47.227
HERE BUT I'D LISTED OUT ALL THE
01:47:47.294 --> 01:47:48.495
CONDITIONS.
01:47:48.562 --> 01:47:50.997
THAT WOULD MAKE IT NOT --
01:47:51.064 --> 01:47:53.133
POSSIBLE TO USE.
01:47:53.200 --> 01:47:55.168
THIS EXEMPTION AND ONE OF THEM
01:47:55.235 --> 01:47:57.838
WAS THE RISK OF EXPOSURE TO
01:47:57.904 --> 01:47:59.573
HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES.
01:47:59.639 --> 01:48:01.374
AT THAT EXCEED STATE LOCAL OR
01:48:01.441 --> 01:48:03.476
FELT FEDERAL LEVELS AND WE CAN
01:48:03.543 --> 01:48:04.845
MAKE IT VERY CLEAR.
01:48:04.911 --> 01:48:06.012
THAT -- THAT
01:48:06.079 --> 01:48:08.415
THOSE THOSE SITES.
01:48:08.481 --> 01:48:09.449
WE CAN MAKE IT CLEAR GOING WHICH
01:48:09.516 --> 01:48:10.951
MIGHT IDENTIFY THOSE SITES YES
01:48:11.017 --> 01:48:13.019
YES ADVENTURE THAT WE CAN
01:48:13.086 --> 01:48:14.287
IDENTIFY AND THEN THEN WE CAN.
01:48:14.354 --> 01:48:15.121
MAKE SURE THAT THEY'RE THEY'RE
01:48:15.188 --> 01:48:16.690
EXCLUDED.
01:48:16.756 --> 01:48:18.758
I I THAT'S THAT'S THE INTENTION
01:48:18.825 --> 01:48:20.060
SO IF IT'S NOT IT'S NOT CLEAR WE
01:48:20.126 --> 01:48:21.328
NEED TO MAKE IT --
01:48:21.394 --> 01:48:25.365
MUCH MORE --
01:48:25.432 --> 01:48:27.667
FOCUSED WE CAN DO THAT YET ARGUE
01:48:27.734 --> 01:48:29.302
COMENZó THIS BILL DOUBLE
01:48:29.369 --> 01:48:31.638
REFERRED RIGHT YES IT HASN'T
01:48:31.705 --> 01:48:33.607
COLLEAGUES IN AUGUST PIC A QUICK.
01:48:33.673 --> 01:48:36.476
COMMENT SORRY TO INTERRUPT YOU
01:48:36.543 --> 01:48:37.077
THE NUMBER OF THE CHAIR THE
01:48:37.143 --> 01:48:37.978
CHAIR AS THAT REQUESTED THAT WE
01:48:38.044 --> 01:48:38.645
NOT TAKE A VOTE ON THIS AT THIS
01:48:38.712 --> 01:48:39.946
TIME I THINK HE WANTS TO ADD HIS
01:48:40.013 --> 01:48:41.348
INPUT SO --
01:48:41.414 --> 01:48:43.650
INVESTORS ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS --
01:48:43.717 --> 01:48:45.051
WE'RE GOING --
01:48:45.118 --> 01:48:47.354
TO A DELAY A. B. EMOTION OR LACK
01:48:47.420 --> 01:48:49.789
THEREOF UNTIL CHAIR COMES BACK.
01:48:49.856 --> 01:48:52.158
OTHERS IN NEED ANY OTHER FURTHER
01:48:52.225 --> 01:48:53.693
QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME.
01:48:53.760 --> 01:48:55.829
CENTER LARGELY FOR QUESTIONS NOW
01:48:55.896 --> 01:48:57.597
OKAY THEN WE'RE GONNA OF TABLE
01:48:57.664 --> 01:48:59.065
THIS.
01:48:59.132 --> 01:49:00.300
FOR A SHORT PERIOD OF TIME AND
01:49:00.367 --> 01:49:01.568
DOUBLE PROCEDURE PRESENTATION
01:49:01.635 --> 01:49:02.936
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND THANK YOU
01:49:03.003 --> 01:49:04.838
FOR THAT ROBUST CONSIDERATION I
01:49:04.905 --> 01:49:05.805
REALLY APPRECIATE IT I
01:49:05.872 --> 01:49:07.741
UNDERSTAND IT'S A IT'S A IT'S A
01:49:07.807 --> 01:49:08.909
DIFFICULT ISSUE --%
01:49:08.975 --> 01:49:09.409
AND TO THANK YOU FOR THE
01:49:09.476 --> 01:49:11.778
OPPORTUNITY PERCENT [inaudible]
01:49:11.845 --> 01:49:19.853
THANK YOU.
01:49:19.920 --> 01:49:21.688
OKAY WE HAVE ASSEMBLYMAN BONTA
01:49:21.755 --> 01:49:24.491
AB [inaudible]
01:49:24.557 --> 01:49:31.364
SEVEN THIRTY FOUR WELCOME SIR
01:49:31.431 --> 01:49:31.665
[inaudible]
01:49:31.731 --> 01:49:36.169
GOOD MORNING.
01:49:36.236 --> 01:49:40.273
THIS MORNING STORY.
01:49:40.340 --> 01:49:41.675
MORNING MR CHAIRED MORNING
01:49:41.741 --> 01:49:43.009
COLLEAGUES GOOD MORNING STOP
01:49:43.076 --> 01:49:44.277
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
01:49:44.344 --> 01:49:46.446
PRESENT AB. SEVEN THIRTY FOR
01:49:46.513 --> 01:49:47.681
TODAY I APPRECIATE ALL THE WORK
01:49:47.747 --> 01:49:49.449
FROM THEM THE CHAIR AND STAFF ON
01:49:49.516 --> 01:49:50.984
THIS BILL WOULD LIKE TO START.
01:49:51.051 --> 01:49:51.918
BY INFORMING THE COMMITTEE THAT
01:49:51.985 --> 01:49:52.852
I'M COMMITTED TO MAKING THE
01:49:52.919 --> 01:49:54.854
FOLLOWING AMENDMENTS TO ADDRESS
01:49:54.921 --> 01:49:56.089
SOME OF THE CONCERNS RAISED IN
01:49:56.156 --> 01:49:58.124
THE ANALYSIS FIRST.
01:49:58.191 --> 01:49:59.292
WE WILL COMMIT TO ESTABLISHING
01:49:59.359 --> 01:50:00.894
LEAD GOLD AS THE BASELINE FOR
01:50:00.961 --> 01:50:03.096
THE BALLPARK AND THE COMMERCIAL.
01:50:03.163 --> 01:50:04.564
DEVELOPMENT RESIDENTIAL
01:50:04.631 --> 01:50:06.266
DEVELOPMENT WILL CONTINUE TO BE
01:50:06.333 --> 01:50:07.534
LEAD SILVER CONSISTENT WITH THE
01:50:07.600 --> 01:50:09.235
CITY OF OAKLAND'S REQUIREMENTS.
01:50:09.302 --> 01:50:10.136
WE ARE ALSO COMMITTED TO
01:50:10.203 --> 01:50:12.105
REMOVING THE ANTI INJUNCTION
01:50:12.172 --> 01:50:13.873
LANGUAGE TO ENSURE JUDICIAL
01:50:13.940 --> 01:50:15.642
REVIEW OF SECRET COMPLIANCE.
01:50:15.709 --> 01:50:17.277
IS NOT LIMITED IN SCOPE WITH
01:50:17.344 --> 01:50:18.311
THESE CHANGES WE BELIEVE THE
01:50:18.378 --> 01:50:19.279
BILL IS MUCH STRONGER
01:50:19.346 --> 01:50:19.579
[inaudible]
01:50:19.646 --> 01:50:22.415
AND ADDRESS DRESSES SOME OF THE
01:50:22.482 --> 01:50:23.817
CONCERNS THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED
01:50:23.883 --> 01:50:25.452
IN THIS COMMITTEE ANALYSIS.
01:50:25.518 --> 01:50:26.219
AS MANY OF YOU KNOW THE CITY OF
01:50:26.286 --> 01:50:27.554
OAKLAND AND OAKLAND ATHLETICS
01:50:27.620 --> 01:50:28.655
BASEBALL TEAM HAVE BEEN WORKING
01:50:28.722 --> 01:50:30.824
TOGETHER ON A PLAN FOR PRIVATELY
01:50:30.890 --> 01:50:32.158
FOUGHT FOR A PRIVATELY FINANCED
01:50:32.225 --> 01:50:33.994
BALLPARK IN INSULAR DEVELOPMENT
01:50:34.060 --> 01:50:34.661
THAT WILL ENSURE.
01:50:34.728 --> 01:50:36.830
THAT THE EIGHTIES STAY IN
01:50:36.896 --> 01:50:38.798
OAKLAND AB SEVEN THIRTY FOUR
01:50:38.865 --> 01:50:39.432
WILL HELP BRING THIS PROJECT TO
01:50:39.499 --> 01:50:40.567
LIFE.
01:50:40.633 --> 01:50:42.002
BY EXPEDITING JUDICIAL REVIEW
01:50:42.068 --> 01:50:43.103
FOR THE EDUCATION OF LEGAL
01:50:43.169 --> 01:50:44.471
CHALLENGES WITHIN A TWO HUNDRED
01:50:44.537 --> 01:50:46.606
AND SEVENTY DAYS. TO THE EXTENT
01:50:46.673 --> 01:50:48.808
FEASIBLE SIMILAR TO OTHER BILLS
01:50:48.875 --> 01:50:49.743
THAT HAVE PASSED THROUGH THIS
01:50:49.809 --> 01:50:50.677
LEGISLATION LEGISLATURE AND
01:50:50.744 --> 01:50:52.278
BECOME LAW.
01:50:52.345 --> 01:50:53.546
THE PROJECT WILL STILL COMPLETE
01:50:53.613 --> 01:50:55.648
A FULL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
01:50:55.715 --> 01:50:57.283
REPORT CONSISTENT WITH SEQUENT
01:50:57.350 --> 01:50:58.718
WHICH IS ESTIMATED TO BE.
01:50:58.785 --> 01:51:00.253
AND EIGHTEEN TWENTY FOUR MONTH
01:51:00.320 --> 01:51:01.521
PROCESS BUT WHAT WE KNOW FROM
01:51:01.588 --> 01:51:02.722
PAST LEGAL CHALLENGES THAT
01:51:02.789 --> 01:51:05.825
SEQUEL LAWSUITS CAN ADD. FOUR TO
01:51:05.892 --> 01:51:06.426
FIVE YEARS TO THE LIFE OF THE
01:51:06.493 --> 01:51:07.560
PROJECT.
01:51:07.627 --> 01:51:08.862
JUST WHY THE PRINCIPLE BENEFIT
01:51:08.928 --> 01:51:10.363
OF EXPEDITED JUDICIAL REVIEW.
01:51:10.430 --> 01:51:12.165
IN THIS BILL IS NEEDED.
01:51:12.232 --> 01:51:13.900
THIS BILL IS MODELED CLOSELY ON
01:51:13.967 --> 01:51:15.735
LEGISLATION PREVIOUSLY ENACTED
01:51:15.802 --> 01:51:16.636
FOR THE SACRAMENTO KINGS THE
01:51:16.703 --> 01:51:17.837
GOLDEN STATE WARRIORS AND OTHER
01:51:17.904 --> 01:51:18.571
ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP
01:51:18.638 --> 01:51:20.774
PROJECTS UNDER A. B.. NINE
01:51:20.840 --> 01:51:22.042
HUNDRED HOWEVER THIS BILL.
01:51:22.108 --> 01:51:23.543
AND NOT THE AB NINE HUNDRED
01:51:23.610 --> 01:51:24.577
PROCESSES NEEDED FOR THREE
01:51:24.644 --> 01:51:27.213
PRIMARY REASONS FIRST AB NINE
01:51:27.280 --> 01:51:28.882
HUNDRED EXPIRES IN.
01:51:28.948 --> 01:51:29.449
TWENTY TWENTY ONE BUT AIDS
01:51:29.516 --> 01:51:30.417
PROJECT THE STATUTE WE NEED TO
01:51:30.483 --> 01:51:32.585
BE EXTENDED.
01:51:32.652 --> 01:51:33.219
TO TWENTY TWENTY FOUR IT'S THIS
01:51:33.286 --> 01:51:35.188
BILL WOULD ADDRESS SECOND WE
01:51:35.255 --> 01:51:36.256
NEED TO CRAFT A SITE SPECIFIC
01:51:36.322 --> 01:51:37.624
SET OF STANDARDS BECAUSE FROM
01:51:37.690 --> 01:51:38.525
OUR UNDERSTANDING.
01:51:38.591 --> 01:51:40.560
OF THEY ARE BI METHODOLOGY FOR
01:51:40.627 --> 01:51:43.363
CALCULATING NET NEW EMISSIONS
01:51:43.430 --> 01:51:44.497
THE FORMULA DOESN'T WORK FOR
01:51:44.564 --> 01:51:44.731
THESE.
01:51:44.798 --> 01:51:46.933
TWO ARE KNOWN TO INFILL SITES
01:51:47.000 --> 01:51:48.334
THIRD AB NINE HUNDRED REQUIRES
01:51:48.401 --> 01:51:49.869
LEAD GOLD ACROSS THE BOARD FOR
01:51:49.936 --> 01:51:52.205
THE PROJECT BUT THE PROJECT.
01:51:52.272 --> 01:51:53.073
WITH THIS PROJECT THE PLAN IS TO
01:51:53.139 --> 01:51:54.808
MEET LEGAL STANDARDS.
01:51:54.874 --> 01:51:55.675
THE BALLPARK AND SURROUNDING
01:51:55.742 --> 01:51:57.110
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT.
01:51:57.177 --> 01:51:58.311
BUT THE RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT
01:51:58.378 --> 01:51:59.612
AGAIN WILL BE AT THE LEAD
01:51:59.679 --> 01:51:59.913
[inaudible]
01:51:59.979 --> 01:52:01.815
SILVER LEVEL THE TEAM IS
01:52:01.881 --> 01:52:03.116
CURRENTLY EVALUATING TO
01:52:03.183 --> 01:52:04.651
POTENTIAL SITES HOWARD TERMINAL
01:52:04.717 --> 01:52:06.019
AND THE CURRENT COLISEUM SITE
01:52:06.086 --> 01:52:06.953
THEY ARE IN DIRECT NEGOTIATIONS
01:52:07.020 --> 01:52:08.688
WITH THE CITY COUNTY.
01:52:08.755 --> 01:52:09.289
AND PORT OF OAKLAND WHO OWNED
01:52:09.355 --> 01:52:11.357
THE SITES BOTH AREAS WILL NOT
01:52:11.424 --> 01:52:11.991
ONLY HELP THE TEAM BECOME MORE
01:52:12.058 --> 01:52:13.259
COMPETITIVE.
01:52:13.326 --> 01:52:14.561
BUT ALSO PRESENT A TREMENDOUS
01:52:14.627 --> 01:52:15.261
OPPORTUNITY TO REVITALIZE
01:52:15.328 --> 01:52:17.664
OAKLAND AND THE SURROUNDING
01:52:17.730 --> 01:52:19.766
COMMUNITIES A JUNE TWENTY
01:52:19.833 --> 01:52:20.567
SEVENTEEN STUDY BY THE BAY AREA
01:52:20.633 --> 01:52:22.335
COUNCIL ECONOMIC INSTITUTE
01:52:22.402 --> 01:52:23.803
ESTIMATED THAT A NEW BALLPARK
01:52:23.870 --> 01:52:25.004
WOULD GENERATE.
01:52:25.071 --> 01:52:26.539
OVER THREE BILLION DOLLARS OF
01:52:26.606 --> 01:52:27.774
ECONOMIC IMPACT FOR OPEN
01:52:27.841 --> 01:52:29.876
RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES OVER
01:52:29.943 --> 01:52:31.578
THE FIRST TEN YEARS OF OPERATION.
01:52:31.644 --> 01:52:32.745
THE ULTIMATE SUCCESS OF THE
01:52:32.812 --> 01:52:33.780
BALLPARK ALSO REQUIRES
01:52:33.847 --> 01:52:36.416
COMPLEMENTARY AND ADJACENT MIXED
01:52:36.483 --> 01:52:38.184
USE RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL AND
01:52:38.251 --> 01:52:39.352
RETAIL DEVELOPMENT THESE
01:52:39.419 --> 01:52:40.386
DEVELOPMENTS WILL FURTHER THE
01:52:40.453 --> 01:52:41.888
REGION'S GOALS FOR SUSTAINABLE
01:52:41.955 --> 01:52:43.456
TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT.
01:52:43.523 --> 01:52:44.991
CREATE AN INCREASE IN THE SUPPLY
01:52:45.058 --> 01:52:46.493
OF HOUSING AND PROVIDE MORE
01:52:46.559 --> 01:52:47.427
AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE
01:52:47.494 --> 01:52:48.928
REGION.
01:52:48.995 --> 01:52:49.529
IN ADDITION THE CONSTRUCTION
01:52:49.596 --> 01:52:50.630
ALONE WILL PROVIDE SIGNIFICANT
01:52:50.697 --> 01:52:52.065
BOOST TO THE AREA DURING THE
01:52:52.132 --> 01:52:53.533
CONSTRUCTION PHASE IT IS
01:52:53.600 --> 01:52:55.635
ESTIMATED THAT APPROXIMATELY TWO
01:52:55.702 --> 01:52:56.302
THOUSAND CONSTRUCTION JOBS WILL
01:52:56.369 --> 01:52:57.303
BE CREATED.
01:52:57.370 --> 01:52:58.404
THESE POSITIONS WILL BE HIGH
01:52:58.471 --> 01:53:00.907
WAGE HIGHLY SKILLED UNION JOBS
01:53:00.974 --> 01:53:02.642
THAT PAY PREVAILING WAGES.
01:53:02.709 --> 01:53:03.877
AND YOU BALLPARK IS SEEN AS
01:53:03.943 --> 01:53:04.811
CRITICAL TO STRENGTHENING THE
01:53:04.878 --> 01:53:06.112
EIGHTIES AND ALLOWING THEM TO BE
01:53:06.179 --> 01:53:07.380
COMPETITIVE WHILE STAYING IN
01:53:07.447 --> 01:53:08.748
THEIR HOME CITY.
01:53:08.815 --> 01:53:09.582
THAT THEY CALLED HOME FOR THE
01:53:09.649 --> 01:53:11.251
LAST FIFTY YEARS WITH THE
01:53:11.317 --> 01:53:12.218
IMPENDING LOSS OF THE RAIDERS TO
01:53:12.285 --> 01:53:13.620
LAS VEGAS.
01:53:13.686 --> 01:53:14.954
AND THE GOLDEN STATE WARRIORS TO
01:53:15.021 --> 01:53:16.689
SAN FRANCISCO IT'S ESSENTIAL TO
01:53:16.756 --> 01:53:17.891
BOTH THE CITY AND THE ENTIRE
01:53:17.957 --> 01:53:19.626
EAST BAY REGION TO RETAIN.
01:53:19.692 --> 01:53:20.793
A PROFESSIONAL SPORTS TEAM
01:53:20.860 --> 01:53:22.195
ULTIMATELY THIS IS A SIGNIFICANT
01:53:22.262 --> 01:53:24.030
OPPORTUNITY TO SUPPORT A PROJECT
01:53:24.097 --> 01:53:25.031
THAT WILL GREATLY BENEFIT.
01:53:25.098 --> 01:53:26.799
MY DISTRICT OAKLAND AND THE
01:53:26.866 --> 01:53:28.301
ENTIRE EAST BAY REGION I
01:53:28.368 --> 01:53:29.869
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU AYE VOTES
01:53:29.936 --> 01:53:30.503
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION
01:53:30.570 --> 01:53:31.404
COLLEAGUES.
01:53:31.471 --> 01:53:32.772
WITH ME TODAY TO TESTIFY IN
01:53:32.839 --> 01:53:34.707
SUPPORT IS CITY OF OAKLAND MAYOR
01:53:34.774 --> 01:53:36.609
LIBBY SCHAAF PRESIDENT OF THE
01:53:36.676 --> 01:53:38.044
OAKLAND A.'S DAVE CAVIL.
01:53:38.111 --> 01:53:40.013
AND ROB STOKER WITH THE BUILDING
01:53:40.079 --> 01:53:41.247
AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
01:53:41.314 --> 01:53:44.284
OF ALAMEDA COUNTY.
01:53:44.350 --> 01:53:45.885
YOUR WITNESSES FOR MAYOR
01:53:45.952 --> 01:53:46.186
[inaudible]
01:53:46.252 --> 01:53:48.821
GREAT WELL THANK YOU SO MUCH AND
01:53:48.888 --> 01:53:50.290
I DO WANT TO START BY ALSO
01:53:50.356 --> 01:53:51.691
THINKING --
01:53:51.758 --> 01:53:53.693
THE ENTIRE BODY FOR THE
01:53:53.760 --> 01:53:55.261
HOMELESSNESS FUNDING --
01:53:55.328 --> 01:53:57.297
THAT THE MAYORS OF CALIFORNIA
01:53:57.363 --> 01:54:01.067
ASKED FOR SO THANK YOU FOR THAT --
01:54:01.134 --> 01:54:03.069
I WANTED TO FOCUS MY COMMENTS
01:54:03.136 --> 01:54:05.338
BECAUSE I THINK --
01:54:05.405 --> 01:54:07.173
MY ASSEMBLY MEMBER HE IS MY
01:54:07.240 --> 01:54:09.475
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ROB BONTA AYE
01:54:09.542 --> 01:54:11.344
AND AND THE OTHER TESTIFY OURS
01:54:11.411 --> 01:54:13.179
WILL TALK ABOUT THE OVERALL
01:54:13.246 --> 01:54:14.747
BENEFITS OF THE PROJECT.
01:54:14.814 --> 01:54:15.782
THERE WERE TWO THINGS I REALLY
01:54:15.848 --> 01:54:19.085
WANTED TO FOCUS ON THE EXTREME
01:54:19.152 --> 01:54:21.054
LEVEL OF LOCAL SUPPORT FOR THIS
01:54:21.120 --> 01:54:22.655
PROJECT.
01:54:22.722 --> 01:54:24.857
AND BELIEVE ME IN OAKLAND YOU
01:54:24.924 --> 01:54:28.127
KNOW WE WE WE TEND TO BE VERY
01:54:28.194 --> 01:54:30.363
ROBUST IN OUR DISCUSSIONS.
01:54:30.430 --> 01:54:32.999
THIS IS A PROJECT EVERYONE LOVES
01:54:33.066 --> 01:54:34.934
AND IS EXCITED ABOUT THERE IS
01:54:35.001 --> 01:54:37.303
TREMENDOUS COMMUNITY SUPPORT FOR
01:54:37.370 --> 01:54:39.272
IT I WOULD NOT BE HERE IF THERE
01:54:39.339 --> 01:54:42.442
WERE NOT THAT LEVEL OF SUPPORT.
01:54:42.508 --> 01:54:43.610
THE OTHER THING THOUGH THAT I
01:54:43.676 --> 01:54:45.311
REALLY WANTED TO FOCUS ON AND I
01:54:45.378 --> 01:54:46.813
AM SORRY THAT THE CHAIR IS NOT
01:54:46.879 --> 01:54:48.648
HERE TO HEAR MY COMMENTS BECAUSE
01:54:48.715 --> 01:54:50.216
I WAS MADE AWARE OF SOME OF HIS
01:54:50.283 --> 01:54:52.185
OPENING COMMENTS.
01:54:52.252 --> 01:54:53.920
EXPRESSING SOME CONCERNS AND
01:54:53.987 --> 01:54:56.289
LUMPING THIS LEGISLATION INTO A
01:54:56.356 --> 01:54:57.724
GROUP OF BILLS THAT ARE BEFORE
01:54:57.790 --> 01:54:59.726
YOU TODAY WHERE I BELIEVE THAT
01:54:59.792 --> 01:55:01.761
THIS BILL IS A DISTINCT
01:55:01.828 --> 01:55:04.130
PARTICULARLY WITH THE AMENDMENTS
01:55:04.197 --> 01:55:06.499
THAT YOU JUST HURT.
01:55:06.566 --> 01:55:10.470
I THIS BILL IS TRULY COMPLIANT
01:55:10.536 --> 01:55:13.539
WITH THE INTENT OF A. B. NIGHT.
01:55:13.606 --> 01:55:15.441
NOT THAT IS IMPORTANT TO ME AS
01:55:15.508 --> 01:55:16.743
THE MAYOR OF OAKLAND THAT IS
01:55:16.809 --> 01:55:18.478
IMPORTANT TO ME AS SOMEONE WHO
01:55:18.544 --> 01:55:20.546
CONSIDERS MYSELF I IN
01:55:20.613 --> 01:55:22.982
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARD AND
01:55:23.049 --> 01:55:24.851
CHAMPION WARRIOR. FOR OUR
01:55:24.917 --> 01:55:25.952
ENVIRONMENT [inaudible]
01:55:26.019 --> 01:55:30.423
I THIS THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE
01:55:30.490 --> 01:55:33.726
US TO DO A FULL E. AYE ARE.
01:55:33.793 --> 01:55:35.995
THIS IS NOT AN EXEMPTION FROM
01:55:36.062 --> 01:55:36.629
SEQUEL.
01:55:36.696 --> 01:55:39.732
ALL IT ASKS FOR IS THE VERY SAME
01:55:39.799 --> 01:55:41.834
CONSIDERATION THAT ALREADY EXIST
01:55:41.901 --> 01:55:44.103
UNDER AB NINE HUNDRED WHICH IS
01:55:44.170 --> 01:55:46.039
CERTAINTY AROUND THAT SEQUEL
01:55:46.105 --> 01:55:48.041
APPEAL TIMELINE.
01:55:48.107 --> 01:55:50.376
A AGAIN I AM VERY APPRECIATIVE
01:55:50.443 --> 01:55:51.978
THAT THE AIDS ARE FULLY
01:55:52.045 --> 01:55:54.881
COMMITTED TO DOING LEAD GOLD.
01:55:54.947 --> 01:55:57.950
I LEAVE GOLD I AS A STANDARD FOR
01:55:58.017 --> 01:55:59.886
THE DEVELOPMENT AND THEN LEAD
01:55:59.952 --> 01:56:01.688
SILVER FOR RESIDENTIAL WHICH
01:56:01.754 --> 01:56:04.390
WILL HAVE A ROBUST AMOUNT OF
01:56:04.457 --> 01:56:06.092
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN IT.
01:56:06.159 --> 01:56:07.860
AGAIN THIS IS THE STANDARD THAT
01:56:07.927 --> 01:56:09.162
THE GOLDEN STATE WARRIORS ARE
01:56:09.228 --> 01:56:11.364
BUILDING TO ACROSS THE BAY IN
01:56:11.431 --> 01:56:13.099
SAN FRANCISCO.
01:56:13.166 --> 01:56:15.868
FINALLY THEY HAVE ALSO AGREED TO
01:56:15.935 --> 01:56:18.137
ANY RESIDENTIAL PARKING BEING ON
01:56:18.204 --> 01:56:20.406
BUNDLED SOMETHING ALSO THAT IS
01:56:20.473 --> 01:56:23.443
PART OF AB.
01:56:23.509 --> 01:56:24.577
NINE HUNDRED THE REASON THAT WE
01:56:24.644 --> 01:56:28.948
BELIEVE IT IS UNNECESSARY. TO DO
01:56:29.015 --> 01:56:30.249
THE G. H. G. CERTIFICATION
01:56:30.316 --> 01:56:32.885
PROCESS IS THAT THIS IS A
01:56:32.952 --> 01:56:34.921
REPLACEMENT PROJECT.
01:56:34.987 --> 01:56:37.690
THIS NEW FACILITY THIS LEAD GOLD
01:56:37.757 --> 01:56:40.126
FACILITY WILL BE REPLACING A
01:56:40.193 --> 01:56:42.829
DINOSAUR OF A SPORTS FACILITY
01:56:42.895 --> 01:56:44.864
THANK YOU FOR CHUCKLING DAVE IT
01:56:44.931 --> 01:56:47.266
IS TRUE IT'S A DINOSAUR.
01:56:47.333 --> 01:56:49.302
THAT -- THIS
01:56:49.369 --> 01:56:51.337
IS NOT A NEW USE THIS IS A
01:56:51.404 --> 01:56:54.006
REPLACEMENT.
01:56:54.073 --> 01:56:56.442
IN BALLPARK WILL BE AT LEAST
01:56:56.509 --> 01:56:59.712
[inaudible] 5% SMALLER SO WE
01:56:59.779 --> 01:57:01.381
KNOW IT WILL HAVE A SMALLER
01:57:01.447 --> 01:57:03.683
CARBON FOOTPRINT.
01:57:03.750 --> 01:57:06.152
WE KNOW THAT IT WILL HAVE EITHER
01:57:06.219 --> 01:57:08.988
EXACTLY THE SAME BIKE ABILITY
01:57:09.055 --> 01:57:10.923
WALKABILITY AND TRANSIT ACCESS
01:57:10.990 --> 01:57:12.925
BECAUSE ONE OF THE SPECIFIC
01:57:12.992 --> 01:57:14.861
FLIGHTS IF EXACTLY WHERE THE
01:57:14.927 --> 01:57:16.729
BALLPARK IS RIGHT NOW.
01:57:16.796 --> 01:57:18.197
AND THE OTHER SITE HAVE
01:57:18.264 --> 01:57:21.300
COMPARATO LIKABILITY WALKABILITY
01:57:21.367 --> 01:57:23.302
AND TRANSIT ACCESS.
01:57:23.369 --> 01:57:26.105
AND THAT IS WHY WE WOULD RATHER
01:57:26.172 --> 01:57:27.640
TAKE THE DOLLARS THAT WOULD BE
01:57:27.707 --> 01:57:28.908
SPENT ON VERY EXPENSIVE
01:57:28.975 --> 01:57:31.477
CONSULTANTS GO THROUGH THE
01:57:31.544 --> 01:57:34.013
CERTIFICATION PROCESS AND HAVE
01:57:34.080 --> 01:57:34.781
THOSE FUNDS AVAILABLE FOR
01:57:34.847 --> 01:57:37.183
COMMUNITY BENEFITS.
01:57:37.250 --> 01:57:39.318
AND THAT IS WHERE I WILL REMIND
01:57:39.385 --> 01:57:42.021
YOU THAT THIS IS OAKLAND.
01:57:42.088 --> 01:57:44.557
THIS COMMUNITY AND THIS MAYOR
01:57:44.624 --> 01:57:45.858
WILL NOT ALLOW IN
01:57:45.925 --> 01:57:47.460
ENVIRONMENTALLY IRRESPONSIBLE
01:57:47.527 --> 01:57:50.062
PROJECT TO BE BUILT IN OUR CITY.
01:57:50.129 --> 01:57:51.431
ALL YOU HAVE SEEN US FIGHT A
01:57:51.497 --> 01:57:53.800
COLD TERMINAL IN OUR CITY WITH
01:57:53.866 --> 01:57:56.736
GREAT PASSION AND CONVICTION.
01:57:56.803 --> 01:57:59.138
YOU KNOW ARE COMMUNITY YOU KNOW
01:57:59.205 --> 01:58:01.374
OUR TRACK RECORD AS LEADERS IN
01:58:01.441 --> 01:58:02.642
THE ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
01:58:02.708 --> 01:58:04.510
MOVEMENT THERE IS A REASON THAT
01:58:04.577 --> 01:58:06.446
OAKLAND ONCE ONE OF ONLY TEN
01:58:06.512 --> 01:58:08.347
CITIES INVITED TO BE AT THE
01:58:08.414 --> 01:58:10.783
PARIS CLIMATE ACCORDS BECAUSE OF
01:58:10.850 --> 01:58:12.118
OUR HISTORY.
01:58:12.185 --> 01:58:13.653
OF CHAMPION THE ENVIRONMENTAL
01:58:13.719 --> 01:58:15.288
MOVEMENT.
01:58:15.354 --> 01:58:17.723
AND FOR THOSE REASONS I BELIEVE
01:58:17.790 --> 01:58:20.193
THAT THIS BILL STANDS APART FROM
01:58:20.259 --> 01:58:21.994
A NUMBER OF THE OTHER BILLS THAT
01:58:22.061 --> 01:58:23.296
THE CHAIR EXPRESSED CONCERNS
01:58:23.362 --> 01:58:24.897
OVER.
01:58:24.964 --> 01:58:26.632
TYPICALLY WITH THESE AMENDMENTS
01:58:26.699 --> 01:58:28.601
AND SO WITH THAT I RESPECTFULLY
01:58:28.668 --> 01:58:31.003
ASK YOU ALL FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND
01:58:31.070 --> 01:58:32.872
I WOULD AT LEAST HOPE THAT THE
01:58:32.939 --> 01:58:33.906
CHAIR HE DOES COME.
01:58:33.973 --> 01:58:35.541
OUT WOULD.
01:58:35.608 --> 01:58:37.577
HAPPY NO AND NO RECOMMENDATION
01:58:37.643 --> 01:58:40.713
POSITION BOMB WE AYE IT IS
01:58:40.780 --> 01:58:42.148
DIFFICULT FOR ME TO BELIEVE THAT
01:58:42.215 --> 01:58:44.050
I AM NOT ALIGNED.
01:58:44.116 --> 01:58:45.751
WITH SENATOR WHITE HOUSE SKI ON
01:58:45.818 --> 01:58:47.787
IT ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUE --
01:58:47.854 --> 01:58:50.022
I'VE AGAIN I ASSURE YOU YOU CAN
01:58:50.089 --> 01:58:52.258
TRUST THIS COMMUNITY TO BE
01:58:52.325 --> 01:58:55.194
RESPONSIBLE WITH THE LATITUDE
01:58:55.261 --> 01:58:56.295
THAT WOULD BE GRANTED BY THIS
01:58:56.362 --> 01:58:57.430
LEGISLATION [inaudible]
01:58:57.497 --> 01:59:01.267
WINCKLER TESTIMONY.
01:59:01.334 --> 01:59:03.469
I YES I DAVE CAVALIER PRESIDENT
01:59:03.536 --> 01:59:04.971
OF THE OAKLAND MAYES AS YOU GUYS
01:59:05.037 --> 01:59:06.539
MAY KNOW WERE CELEBRATING FIFTY
01:59:06.606 --> 01:59:07.773
YEARS IN OAKLAND OR HAVING A LOT
01:59:07.840 --> 01:59:09.075
OF FANFARE IT'S BEEN A GREAT
01:59:09.141 --> 01:59:11.544
SEASON OR HONORING GREAT PLAYERS
01:59:11.611 --> 01:59:13.579
LIKE ROLLIE FINGERS AND I'D.
01:59:13.646 --> 01:59:15.214
KEEP JIM CATFISH HUNTER AND
01:59:15.281 --> 01:59:16.516
RICKY HENDERSON BUT THAT
01:59:16.582 --> 01:59:18.518
FACILITY THAT WE PLAY IT IS
01:59:18.584 --> 01:59:20.553
DATED IT'S ALL LIKE --
01:59:20.620 --> 01:59:22.288
THE MAYOR SAID WE NEED A NEW
01:59:22.355 --> 01:59:23.923
STATE OF THE ART BALLPARK TO BE
01:59:23.990 --> 01:59:25.291
SUCCESSFUL OR CAN.
01:59:25.358 --> 01:59:27.093
WERE THE LAST TEAM LAST WITH THE
01:59:27.159 --> 01:59:28.194
WARRIORS AND ALSO THE RAIDERS
01:59:28.261 --> 01:59:31.330
LEAVING WORK PROPOSING A 100%
01:59:31.397 --> 01:59:33.165
PRIVATELY FINANCED STADIUM WE
01:59:33.232 --> 01:59:34.634
HAVE A GREAT PARTNERSHIP WITH
01:59:34.700 --> 01:59:35.535
LABOR.
01:59:35.601 --> 01:59:37.169
WE HAVE A P. LA THIS CAN EXIST
01:59:37.236 --> 01:59:39.205
FOR THE STADIUM ALL THE WORKERS
01:59:39.272 --> 01:59:40.206
THEY'RE GONNA BE UNIONIZED IS
01:59:40.273 --> 01:59:41.908
GOING TO BE AMAZING PROJECT FOR
01:59:41.974 --> 01:59:42.875
COMMUNITY.
01:59:42.942 --> 01:59:44.677
WE'VE NEGOTIATED AND START OF
01:59:44.744 --> 01:59:45.945
THE NEGOTIATION A COMMUNITY
01:59:46.012 --> 01:59:47.213
BENEFITS PLAN.
01:59:47.280 --> 01:59:48.247
SO WHEN WE LOOK AT ALL THE
01:59:48.314 --> 01:59:49.382
DIFFERENT ASPECTS OF OF THIS
01:59:49.448 --> 01:59:51.083
PROJECT WHAT IT CAN MEAN FOR OUR
01:59:51.150 --> 01:59:52.518
COMMUNITY HE CAN REALLY BE
01:59:52.585 --> 01:59:54.053
TRANSFORMATIVE AND IT'S
01:59:54.120 --> 01:59:55.254
SOMETHING THAT.
01:59:55.321 --> 01:59:56.856
YOU KNOW WERE EXCITED ABOUT IT'S
01:59:56.923 --> 01:59:58.591
A RARE CONFLUENCE OF FACTORS
01:59:58.658 --> 02:00:00.126
WITH THE CITY.
02:00:00.192 --> 02:00:01.460
PRIVATE OWNERSHIP AND THE
02:00:01.527 --> 02:00:03.496
COMMUNITY ALL BEHIND THIS EFFORT
02:00:03.563 --> 02:00:05.264
IN A COHERENT WAY AND THAT'S
02:00:05.331 --> 02:00:08.167
SOMETHING THAT SUPER IMPORTANT.
02:00:08.234 --> 02:00:08.701
FOR SIX ONE OTHER REALLY
02:00:08.768 --> 02:00:10.136
CRITICAL ASPECT OF THIS IS THE
02:00:10.202 --> 02:00:11.837
REASON WERE HERE AND PROBABLY
02:00:11.904 --> 02:00:13.439
OUR BIGGEST RISK IS IF WE FACE A
02:00:13.506 --> 02:00:14.707
SEQUEL LAWSUIT.
02:00:14.774 --> 02:00:16.175
A GOOD DELAY OUR ABILITY TO OPEN
02:00:16.242 --> 02:00:18.444
THE STADIUM BY TWENTY TWENTY
02:00:18.511 --> 02:00:19.412
THREE WHICH IS AN IMPORTANT GOAL
02:00:19.478 --> 02:00:21.180
FOR US AS THE EIGHTIES WERE
02:00:21.247 --> 02:00:22.448
LOOKING TO CONTEND FOR MORE
02:00:22.515 --> 02:00:23.316
WORLD SERIES WE WANT TO MAKE
02:00:23.382 --> 02:00:25.217
SURE WE HAVE A NEW --
02:00:25.284 --> 02:00:27.186
BEAUTIFUL STADIUM TO DO THAT.
02:00:27.253 --> 02:00:28.721
WE'RE STILL EVALUATING TWO SITES
02:00:28.788 --> 02:00:29.322
OBVIOUSLY THIS WOULD APPLY TO
02:00:29.388 --> 02:00:31.490
BOTH SIDES AND WE'RE WORKING
02:00:31.557 --> 02:00:32.725
HAND IN HAND WITH THE CITY
02:00:32.792 --> 02:00:34.560
SUPPORT THE COUNTY AND ALL THE
02:00:34.627 --> 02:00:35.494
LOCAL STAKEHOLDERS TO HAVE
02:00:35.561 --> 02:00:37.730
SUCCESS IN THAT AREA --
02:00:37.797 --> 02:00:39.365
I THINK THE FINAL POINT IS THAT
02:00:39.432 --> 02:00:40.466
YOU KNOW THIS PROJECT IT'S GONNA
02:00:40.533 --> 02:00:41.834
BRING OVER THREE BILLION AND
02:00:41.901 --> 02:00:43.569
ECONOMIC IMPACTS IT'S GONNA HAVE
02:00:43.636 --> 02:00:44.937
OVER TWO THOUSAND CONSTRUCTION
02:00:45.004 --> 02:00:47.273
JOBS ALONE ON THE BALLPARK SELF.
02:00:47.340 --> 02:00:49.875
AND BASEBALL TEAMS ARE IMPORTANT
02:00:49.942 --> 02:00:51.377
FOR THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND
02:00:51.444 --> 02:00:53.412
CIVIC PRIDE OF THE COMMUNITY.
02:00:53.479 --> 02:00:54.480
THE FACT THAT WE'RE THE ONLY
02:00:54.547 --> 02:00:56.482
PROFESSIONAL SPORTS TEAM LAST
02:00:56.549 --> 02:00:57.783
THAT WERE BUILDING A 100%
02:00:57.850 --> 02:00:59.685
PRIVATELY FINANCED STADIUM.
02:00:59.752 --> 02:01:00.686
ALL WE'RE LOOKING FOR IS A
02:01:00.753 --> 02:01:01.887
LITTLE BIT OF HELP TO GET IT
02:01:01.954 --> 02:01:04.457
DONE ON TIME BY.
02:01:04.523 --> 02:01:05.091
TWENTY TWENTY THREE SO THANK YOU
02:01:05.157 --> 02:01:07.026
VERY MUCH AND LET'S PLAY BALL.
02:01:07.093 --> 02:01:10.329
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
02:01:10.396 --> 02:01:11.631
THANK YOU GOOD MORNING EVERYONE
02:01:11.697 --> 02:01:13.032
MY NAME IS ROB STOKER AND I'M
02:01:13.099 --> 02:01:14.767
HERE TODAY IS THE PRESIDENT OF
02:01:14.834 --> 02:01:15.568
THE BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
02:01:15.635 --> 02:01:17.870
TRADES COUNCIL OF ALAMEDA COUNTY.
02:01:17.937 --> 02:01:20.106
AND WE JUST LIKE MR CABLE SAID
02:01:20.172 --> 02:01:21.107
THAT WE ARE.
02:01:21.173 --> 02:01:23.075
PROUD PARTNERS IN THIS PROJECT
02:01:23.142 --> 02:01:24.977
AND WE ARE STRONGLY SUPPORTING
02:01:25.044 --> 02:01:26.412
AB.
02:01:26.479 --> 02:01:27.413
SEVEN THIRTY FOUR AM THAT BILL
02:01:27.480 --> 02:01:28.781
WILL HELP ENSURE THE DEVELOPMENT
02:01:28.848 --> 02:01:31.350
OF THE FUTURE BASEBALL PARK AND
02:01:31.417 --> 02:01:32.585
BRING A QUALITY LIFE AND
02:01:32.652 --> 02:01:33.919
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES TO
02:01:33.986 --> 02:01:35.421
OAKLAND AS WELL AS EAST BAY
02:01:35.488 --> 02:01:37.023
REGION.
02:01:37.089 --> 02:01:38.457
OF THE PROPOSED PLAN WOULD ALSO
02:01:38.524 --> 02:01:40.259
INCLUDE THOUSANDS OF MUCH NEEDED
02:01:40.326 --> 02:01:42.294
HOUSING UNIT.
02:01:42.361 --> 02:01:44.030
JUST FOR THE COMMUNITY BUT
02:01:44.096 --> 02:01:45.731
INCLUDING OUR MEMBERS AND IN
02:01:45.798 --> 02:01:46.799
FAMILIES THAT WE REPRESENT AS
02:01:46.866 --> 02:01:48.634
WELL -- AS
02:01:48.701 --> 02:01:49.935
THE BAY AREA IN THE STATE ARE
02:01:50.002 --> 02:01:51.570
EXPERIENCING EPIC LEVELS OF
02:01:51.637 --> 02:01:53.472
INCOME INEQUALITY AND WORKING
02:01:53.539 --> 02:01:54.974
CLASS FAMILIES ARE BEING PRICED
02:01:55.041 --> 02:01:56.108
OUT OF THE AREA.
02:01:56.175 --> 02:01:58.077
NOW IS THE TIME TO CAPITALIZE ON
02:01:58.144 --> 02:01:59.578
THIS DEVELOPMENT OF A NEW
02:01:59.645 --> 02:02:01.781
BASEBALL PARK TO MAXIMIZE THE
02:02:01.847 --> 02:02:04.016
ECONOMIC BENEFIT OF THE TEAM.
02:02:04.083 --> 02:02:05.985
AND ITS FACILITIES FOR OAKLAND
02:02:06.052 --> 02:02:08.220
ALAMEDA COUNTY AND THE WHOLE.
02:02:08.287 --> 02:02:10.389
EAST BAY REGION.
02:02:10.456 --> 02:02:12.058
IT IS ANTICIPATED THAT THE
02:02:12.124 --> 02:02:12.992
PROJECT WILL GENERATE MANY
02:02:13.059 --> 02:02:15.561
THOUSANDS OF FULL TIME JOBS.
02:02:15.628 --> 02:02:17.296
NOT JUST THE CONSTRUCTION BUT
02:02:17.363 --> 02:02:18.964
ALSO THE OPERATIONAL JOBS WORKED
02:02:19.031 --> 02:02:20.499
WHICH ARE EQUALLY AS IMPORTANT
02:02:20.566 --> 02:02:22.702
TO THESE PEOPLE --
02:02:22.768 --> 02:02:25.037
AS THE STATE'S ACT ECONOMY HAS
02:02:25.104 --> 02:02:27.306
IMPROVED THE COSTS OF RUNNING
02:02:27.373 --> 02:02:28.641
AND HOMEOWNERSHIP IN OAKLAND AND
02:02:28.708 --> 02:02:30.076
OTHER BAY AREA CITIES HAS
02:02:30.142 --> 02:02:31.944
INCREASED DRAMATICALLY AND
02:02:32.011 --> 02:02:33.512
WORKING CLASS FAMILIES ARE BEING
02:02:33.579 --> 02:02:35.047
DRIVEN FURTHER AND FURTHER AWAY
02:02:35.114 --> 02:02:36.215
FROM JOB CENTERS.
02:02:36.282 --> 02:02:39.485
AND PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION HUBS.
02:02:39.552 --> 02:02:41.921
IN TWO THOUSAND AND TEN BETWEEN
02:02:41.987 --> 02:02:43.489
TWO THOUSAND AND TEN AND TWO
02:02:43.556 --> 02:02:44.490
THOUSAND FOURTEEN THE BAY AREA
02:02:44.557 --> 02:02:46.192
ADDED ROUGHLY A HALF A MILLION
02:02:46.258 --> 02:02:48.494
PRIVATE SECTOR JOBS.
02:02:48.561 --> 02:02:50.629
BUT IN TERMS OF HOUSING WE BUILT
02:02:50.696 --> 02:02:53.099
FIFTY FOUR THOUSAND MORE UNITS.
02:02:53.165 --> 02:02:55.334
FAR SHORT OF WHERE WE SHOULD BE.
02:02:55.401 --> 02:02:57.169
THIS HOUSING SCARCITY IS FURTHER
02:02:57.236 --> 02:02:59.271
EXASPERATING THE REGIONAL
02:02:59.338 --> 02:03:00.706
AFFORDABILITY CRISIS FOR
02:03:00.773 --> 02:03:02.007
VULNERABLE AND LONG TIME
02:03:02.074 --> 02:03:04.777
RESIDENTS THE BAY AREA. TO HELP
02:03:04.844 --> 02:03:07.146
OFFSET THIS WE NEED MUCH MORE
02:03:07.213 --> 02:03:08.748
WELL PAYING JOBS AND ECONOMIC
02:03:08.814 --> 02:03:10.483
OPPORTUNITIES.
02:03:10.549 --> 02:03:11.751
SO IN CLOSING I JUST WANT TO SAY
02:03:11.817 --> 02:03:14.019
AGAIN THE PARTNERSHIP THAT WE
02:03:14.086 --> 02:03:15.755
SHOULD HAVE WITH NOT JUST.
02:03:15.821 --> 02:03:17.356
THE LEADERSHIP THAT THE CITY HAS
02:03:17.423 --> 02:03:19.258
TAKEN ON THIS IN THE MAYOR.
02:03:19.325 --> 02:03:21.694
BUT ALSO WITH THE EIGHTIES IN
02:03:21.761 --> 02:03:23.629
PARTNERING TO MAKE SURE THAT WE
02:03:23.696 --> 02:03:24.730
BUILD A PROJECT RIGHT AND
02:03:24.797 --> 02:03:26.632
RESPONSIBLY.
02:03:26.699 --> 02:03:28.167
SHOULD SAID IT WAS IT REALLY
02:03:28.234 --> 02:03:28.834
SUCH AN EXAMPLE FOR OTHER
02:03:28.901 --> 02:03:31.837
PROJECTS YOU KNOW WHEN IN IN THE
02:03:31.904 --> 02:03:33.372
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY.
02:03:33.439 --> 02:03:34.507
I MEAN WE HAVE THE UNIQUE
02:03:34.573 --> 02:03:35.841
POSITION THE MEN AND WOMEN THAT
02:03:35.908 --> 02:03:37.743
BUILD THESE PROJECTS OF WORKING
02:03:37.810 --> 02:03:40.913
OUR WAY OUT OF A JOB RIGHT AND
02:03:40.980 --> 02:03:42.681
TO HAVE A PROJECT LIKE THIS THAT
02:03:42.748 --> 02:03:43.682
IS COMING UP.
02:03:43.749 --> 02:03:44.850
THAT IS GOING TO PROVIDE NOT
02:03:44.917 --> 02:03:46.719
ONLY ADDITIONAL HOUSING FOR MANY
02:03:46.786 --> 02:03:48.053
OF OUR MEMBERS BUT JOB
02:03:48.120 --> 02:03:50.122
OPPORTUNITIES AND OPPORTUNITIES
02:03:50.189 --> 02:03:52.558
FOR THE YOUTH AND OTHERS TO GET
02:03:52.625 --> 02:03:54.560
INTO A PARTNERSHIP PROGRAMS.
02:03:54.627 --> 02:03:55.861
IS SOMETHING THAT'S THAT YOU
02:03:55.928 --> 02:03:57.363
THAT YOU CAN'T EVEN PORTER A
02:03:57.429 --> 02:03:59.165
DOLLAR SIGN ON IT IS IT IS
02:03:59.231 --> 02:04:02.168
SOMETHING THAT THIS AREA NEEDS.
02:04:02.234 --> 02:04:04.170
AND WE'RE WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR
02:04:04.236 --> 02:04:06.539
SUPPORT TODAY WITHIN A VOTE ON
02:04:06.605 --> 02:04:08.440
THIS THANK YOU.
02:04:08.507 --> 02:04:09.775
IF YOUR TESTIMONY WOULD LIKE
02:04:09.842 --> 02:04:10.743
CALL UP OTHERS ITS SUPPORT.
02:04:10.810 --> 02:04:12.945
PLEASE COME FORWARD THAT HAD
02:04:13.012 --> 02:04:13.813
CHAIRPERSON MEMBERS OF THE
02:04:13.879 --> 02:04:15.147
COMMITTEE NICOLO DELUCA HERE
02:04:15.214 --> 02:04:16.849
BEHALF OF THE MAYOR SAN LEANDRO
02:04:16.916 --> 02:04:18.284
PAULINE CUTTER THE MAYOR FAMILY
02:04:18.350 --> 02:04:20.553
FILL JOHN POWDERS THE MAYOR OF
02:04:20.619 --> 02:04:21.587
BERKLEY JESSE AIR AGAIN.
02:04:21.654 --> 02:04:23.155
STRONG SUPPORT RASH HE'S PLAYING
02:04:23.222 --> 02:04:24.623
OAKLAND GREAT REGIONAL BENEFITS
02:04:24.690 --> 02:04:25.224
OF THANK YOU VERY MUCH THANKS
02:04:25.291 --> 02:04:29.328
FOR TESTING.
02:04:29.395 --> 02:04:29.962
SURE MEMBER SOCIETY AS A BEHALF
02:04:30.029 --> 02:04:31.163
THE STATE BUILDING AND
02:04:31.230 --> 02:04:32.731
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL ALSO
02:04:32.798 --> 02:04:35.301
IN STRONG SUPPORT.
02:04:35.367 --> 02:04:36.168
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS MATT BROWN
02:04:36.235 --> 02:04:37.336
ON BEHALF THE TEAMSTERS AND
02:04:37.403 --> 02:04:39.972
SUPPORT THANK YOU.
02:04:40.039 --> 02:04:41.407
MORNING SCOTT SATTLER BEHALF OF
02:04:41.473 --> 02:04:44.610
THE POOR VOCAL IN SUPPORT.
02:04:44.677 --> 02:04:45.511
RESEARCHERS GOT WHICH ON BEHALF
02:04:45.578 --> 02:04:46.679
THE STATE ASSOCIATION OF
02:04:46.745 --> 02:04:47.680
ELECTRICAL WORKERS A CALIFORNIA
02:04:47.746 --> 02:04:48.881
STEEP PATRIOTS COUNCIL THE
02:04:48.948 --> 02:04:50.015
WESTERN STATES COUNCIL SHEET
02:04:50.082 --> 02:04:51.217
METAL WORKERS.
02:04:51.283 --> 02:04:52.751
THE ELEVATOR CONSTRUCTORS UNION
02:04:52.818 --> 02:04:54.019
THE CALIFORNIA COALITION OF
02:04:54.086 --> 02:04:54.720
UTILITY EMPLOYEES IN SUPPORT
02:04:54.787 --> 02:04:57.723
THANK YOU.
02:04:57.790 --> 02:04:58.524
THEY WAS CHAIR KEEFE DOWN ON
02:04:58.591 --> 02:04:59.491
BEHALF OF THE DISTRICT COUNCIL
02:04:59.558 --> 02:05:00.893
FIRE WORKERS OF CALIFORNIANS
02:05:00.960 --> 02:05:02.962
SUPPORT THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:05:03.028 --> 02:05:07.132
TESTIMONY ANY OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
02:05:07.199 --> 02:05:09.435
IT'S A CHAIR MEMBERS ON BEHALF
02:05:09.501 --> 02:05:09.969
OF THE FIFTEENTH ASSEMBLY
02:05:10.035 --> 02:05:10.870
DISTRICT.
02:05:10.936 --> 02:05:12.972
AND THE BEST REGION AND THE BEST
02:05:13.038 --> 02:05:15.875
FRANCHISE IN SPORTS HISTORY.
02:05:15.941 --> 02:05:18.377
I ASK FOR YOUR SUPPORT THIS BILL.
02:05:18.444 --> 02:05:20.946
BEFORE YOU IF SUPPORT IT WILL BE
02:05:21.013 --> 02:05:22.514
AMENDED TO MAKE ME TO AN AUTHOR.
02:05:22.581 --> 02:05:24.316
I LIKE KNOWLEDGE OUR MAYOR AND
02:05:24.383 --> 02:05:26.252
MY FUTURE CO AUTHOR ON BEHALF OF
02:05:26.318 --> 02:05:28.387
ALL A SENSE.
02:05:28.454 --> 02:05:29.021
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOU RIGHT VOTE
02:05:29.088 --> 02:05:31.891
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY.
02:05:31.957 --> 02:05:33.759
BOB YOUR ON WE HAVE THE PAINTERS
02:05:33.826 --> 02:05:35.027
AND ALLIED TRADES IN SUPPORT.
02:05:35.094 --> 02:05:37.196
THANK YOU FOR TESTIMONY LAST
02:05:37.263 --> 02:05:40.699
CALL FOR ANY OTHER SUPPORTERS.
02:05:40.766 --> 02:05:41.367
IT THIS TIME OVER YOU
02:05:41.433 --> 02:05:42.368
RESPECTFULLY ASK THE OPPONENTS
02:05:42.434 --> 02:05:44.336
TO COME FORWARD.
02:05:44.403 --> 02:05:44.904
WE CAN MAKE SOME ROOM AT THE
02:05:44.970 --> 02:05:49.808
BEST PLACE.
02:05:49.875 --> 02:05:51.076
YOU NEED TO TEMPORARILY.
02:05:51.143 --> 02:05:57.383
VACATE THANK YOU.
02:05:57.449 --> 02:06:04.490
MARY EXISTE WHERE FROM.
02:06:04.556 --> 02:06:06.058
WHEN MORNING CHAIR MEMBERS DAMN
02:06:06.125 --> 02:06:07.826
POEM FOR THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL?
02:06:07.893 --> 02:06:08.661
WE ARE RESPECTFULLY IN
02:06:08.727 --> 02:06:10.095
OPPOSITION HERE TODAY TO THIS
02:06:10.162 --> 02:06:11.096
BILL.
02:06:11.163 --> 02:06:12.898
UP INCLUDING THIS BILL AND TO
02:06:12.965 --> 02:06:14.700
OTHER SIMILAR BILLS THAT ARE ON
02:06:14.767 --> 02:06:16.402
YOUR AGENDA TODAY.
02:06:16.468 --> 02:06:18.504
THERE HAVE NOW BEEN.
02:06:18.570 --> 02:06:19.271
THIRTY FOUR SEPARATE PIECES
02:06:19.338 --> 02:06:21.206
LEGISLATION INTRODUCED SINCE THE
02:06:21.273 --> 02:06:22.775
ENACTMENT OF BABY NINE HUNDRED
02:06:22.841 --> 02:06:25.377
AND SB TWO NINETY TWO IN.
02:06:25.444 --> 02:06:25.978
TWENTY ELEVEN THE THOUGHT TO
02:06:26.045 --> 02:06:27.579
EXPAND THOSE EXPEDITED JUDICIAL
02:06:27.646 --> 02:06:28.847
REVIEW PROVISIONS IN SOME
02:06:28.914 --> 02:06:30.382
FASHION.
02:06:30.449 --> 02:06:32.051
OR IMPOSE SOME IDIOT LIMITS ON
02:06:32.117 --> 02:06:32.885
INJECTED RELIEF AND THANK YOU
02:06:32.952 --> 02:06:34.687
FOR THAT AMENDMENT.
02:06:34.753 --> 02:06:35.220
I AM -- OR
02:06:35.287 --> 02:06:37.056
BOTH OR MANDATE THE CREATION
02:06:37.122 --> 02:06:38.824
ESPECIALLY SECRET COURTS IN THE
02:06:38.891 --> 02:06:40.159
COUNCIL'S BEEN ON RECOR IN
02:06:40.225 --> 02:06:41.894
OPPOSITION TO ALL OF THOSE.
02:06:41.961 --> 02:06:44.196
PIECES OF LEGISLATION.
02:06:44.263 --> 02:06:46.532
THE OPPOSITION TO THIS
02:06:46.598 --> 02:06:48.500
LEGISLATION BY THE COUNCIL.
02:06:48.567 --> 02:06:51.003
IS FOCUSED SOLELY ON THE COURT
02:06:51.070 --> 02:06:52.771
IMPACT IMPACTS TO THE COURTS IN
02:06:52.838 --> 02:06:53.305
THAT MORE IMPORTANTLY THE
02:06:53.372 --> 02:06:54.440
IMPACTS.
02:06:54.506 --> 02:06:55.574
ON LITIGANTS ON THE COURT'S
02:06:55.641 --> 02:06:57.142
DOCKET THAT WE ARE RESPONSIBLE
02:06:57.209 --> 02:06:58.677
FOR ADJUDICATING.
02:06:58.744 --> 02:07:00.546
WE TAKE NO POSITION.
02:07:00.612 --> 02:07:02.181
SECRET GENERALLY THE MERITS OF
02:07:02.247 --> 02:07:03.882
THESE PARTICULAR PROJECTS THE
02:07:03.949 --> 02:07:05.250
IMPORTANCE OF THE COMMUNITY OF
02:07:05.317 --> 02:07:07.019
THE PROJECTS WE STIPULATE THESE
02:07:07.086 --> 02:07:07.886
ARE IMPORTANT --
02:07:07.953 --> 02:07:10.956
EFFORTS AND THOSE ISSUES ARE
02:07:11.023 --> 02:07:13.158
OUTSIDE OUR PURVIEW.
02:07:13.225 --> 02:07:14.460
SO FOCUS AGAIN.
02:07:14.526 --> 02:07:16.395
IS ALONG THE WAY IN WHICH THIS
02:07:16.462 --> 02:07:18.163
PARTICULAR STREAMLINED QUOTE
02:07:18.230 --> 02:07:19.932
UNQUOTE LITIGATION --
02:07:19.999 --> 02:07:21.000
ADVERSELY IMPACTS OUR ENTIRE
02:07:21.066 --> 02:07:24.403
JUSTICE SYSTEM.
02:07:24.470 --> 02:07:26.372
A SECRET CASES AS YOU KNOW AND
02:07:26.438 --> 02:07:27.973
AS THE A VERY COMPREHENSIVE
02:07:28.040 --> 02:07:29.475
ANALYSIS POINTED OUT.
02:07:29.541 --> 02:07:31.343
OR ENTITLED ALREADY TO CALENDAR
02:07:31.410 --> 02:07:33.178
PREFERENCE AS WELL AS SPECIALLY
02:07:33.245 --> 02:07:34.680
TRAINED JUDGES TO PRESIDE OVER
02:07:34.747 --> 02:07:35.781
THEM IN THE OVERWHELMING
02:07:35.848 --> 02:07:37.082
MAJORITY OF THE COUNTIES HERE IN
02:07:37.149 --> 02:07:38.517
CALIFORNIA.
02:07:38.584 --> 02:07:40.319
THE TWO HUNDRED SEVENTY DAY
02:07:40.386 --> 02:07:41.987
TIMELINE IS COMPLETELY ARBITRARY
02:07:42.054 --> 02:07:44.256
IT STARTED OUT AS A HUNDRED
02:07:44.323 --> 02:07:45.691
SEVENTY FIVE DAY TIMELINE GOING
02:07:45.758 --> 02:07:47.059
STRAIGHT TO THE COURT OF APPEAL
02:07:47.126 --> 02:07:48.560
SKIPPING THE TRIAL COURT.
02:07:48.627 --> 02:07:49.328
THAT WAS LATER FOUND
02:07:49.395 --> 02:07:51.663
UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN AND ALAMEDA
02:07:51.730 --> 02:07:53.365
COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT CASE AND
02:07:53.432 --> 02:07:55.934
THIS THE QUOTE UNQUOTE FIX. TO
02:07:56.001 --> 02:07:57.703
AB NINE HUNDRED LIVES TO TACK ON
02:07:57.770 --> 02:07:59.338
AN ADDITIONAL NINETY FIVE DAY IS.
02:07:59.405 --> 02:08:01.206
THIS TIMELINE WAS DRIVEN BY
02:08:01.273 --> 02:08:02.941
ISSUES LIKE.
02:08:03.008 --> 02:08:05.177
NBA BOND COUNSEL BUT DID NOT
02:08:05.244 --> 02:08:06.879
HAVE ANY CONNECTION.
02:08:06.945 --> 02:08:09.014
WHATSOEVER AND WAS NOT BASED ON
02:08:09.081 --> 02:08:10.916
ANY CONSULTATION WITH THE
02:08:10.983 --> 02:08:12.918
JUDICIAL COUNCIL OR THE COURTS
02:08:12.985 --> 02:08:14.253
OF THE JUDGES THAT HAVE THE
02:08:14.319 --> 02:08:16.955
EXPERTISE TO HEAR THESE CASES.
02:08:17.022 --> 02:08:17.556
BUT EVEN MORE IMPORTANTLY THAN
02:08:17.623 --> 02:08:18.957
THAT.
02:08:19.024 --> 02:08:20.459
THE ALTAR THIS ALTAR COUNTER
02:08:20.526 --> 02:08:22.294
PREFERENCE LITERALLY HAVE THE
02:08:22.361 --> 02:08:23.996
EFFECT.
02:08:24.063 --> 02:08:25.197
OF TAKING THESE CASES TO THE
02:08:25.264 --> 02:08:26.598
ABSOLUTE FRONT OF THE LINE AT
02:08:26.665 --> 02:08:28.300
THE EXPENSE OF EVERY OTHER CASE
02:08:28.367 --> 02:08:29.835
ON THE COURT'S DOCKET.
02:08:29.902 --> 02:08:31.170
AND THAT'S JUST FUNDAMENTALLY AT
02:08:31.236 --> 02:08:32.204
ODDS WITH OUR COURTS ARE
02:08:32.271 --> 02:08:33.806
SUPPOSED TO OPERATE WE ARE
02:08:33.872 --> 02:08:35.541
CHARGED WITH DISPENSING.
02:08:35.607 --> 02:08:37.209
EQUAL ACCESS TO JUSTICE FOR
02:08:37.276 --> 02:08:39.044
EVERY CASE ON THE COURT'S DOCKET
02:08:39.111 --> 02:08:41.180
WITHOUT REGARD TO THE PARTICULAR
02:08:41.246 --> 02:08:42.714
SUBJECT MATTER.
02:08:42.781 --> 02:08:44.750
THE POLITICAL PERSUASION AND YOU
02:08:44.817 --> 02:08:46.685
KNOW INFLUENCE OR PERSUASION OR
02:08:46.752 --> 02:08:48.720
THE FINANCIAL RESOURCES BEHIND
02:08:48.787 --> 02:08:49.955
PARTICULAR CASES.
02:08:50.022 --> 02:08:51.423
EVERY CASE ON THE COURT'S DOCKET
02:08:51.490 --> 02:08:53.225
IS IMPORTANT TO THOSE LITIGANTS
02:08:53.292 --> 02:08:55.260
IMPORTANT ISSUES ARE AT STAKE.
02:08:55.327 --> 02:08:56.495
AND VOTING FOR GOES LIKE THIS
02:08:56.562 --> 02:08:57.830
YOU'RE BASICALLY SAYING TO ALL
02:08:57.896 --> 02:08:59.531
OF THE OTHER LITIGANTS WHO ARE
02:08:59.598 --> 02:09:00.132
WORKING THEIR WAY THROUGH THE
02:09:00.199 --> 02:09:01.166
SYSTEM.
02:09:01.233 --> 02:09:01.667
THAT THEIR CASE IS LESS
02:09:01.733 --> 02:09:03.368
IMPORTANT.
02:09:03.435 --> 02:09:04.803
THAT THEIR CASE NEEDS TO MOVED
02:09:04.870 --> 02:09:06.872
BACK IN LINE.
02:09:06.939 --> 02:09:08.173
AND THAT THESE CASES HAVE THE
02:09:08.240 --> 02:09:09.208
ULTIMATE CALENDAR PREFERENCE
02:09:09.274 --> 02:09:11.810
IT'S I HATE TO SAY IT BUT IT IS
02:09:11.877 --> 02:09:13.545
A ZERO GET SOME GAME BUT IT'S
02:09:13.612 --> 02:09:15.080
NOT AGAIN PEOPLE'S LIVES ARE AT
02:09:15.147 --> 02:09:16.515
STAKE THEIR WELL BE IN YOUR
02:09:16.582 --> 02:09:17.916
FINANCIAL SECURITY.
02:09:17.983 --> 02:09:19.585
ARE IN THE CASES THAT THE COURTS
02:09:19.651 --> 02:09:21.053
ARE CHARGED WITH.
02:09:21.120 --> 02:09:23.122
HEARING AND THE COURTS CAN'T
02:09:23.188 --> 02:09:24.623
LOOK.
02:09:24.690 --> 02:09:26.692
IT OR NOT SUPPOSED TO LOOK AT
02:09:26.758 --> 02:09:28.460
THE SPECIAL CATEGORIES OF CASES
02:09:28.527 --> 02:09:30.295
BEYOND THE EXISTING CALENDAR
02:09:30.362 --> 02:09:32.631
PREFERENCES THAT ALREADY EXIST.
02:09:32.698 --> 02:09:34.466
I ALSO OWN A HEARD FROM THE
02:09:34.533 --> 02:09:36.135
PROPONENTS THAT SOME OF WHAT'S
02:09:36.201 --> 02:09:37.870
BEING SOUGHT HERE IS CERTAINTY.
02:09:37.936 --> 02:09:39.204
WITH RESPECT TO THE SEQUEL
02:09:39.271 --> 02:09:41.140
LITIGATION BUT THAT CERTAINTY IS
02:09:41.206 --> 02:09:42.040
NOT GUARANTEED BY BILLS LIKE
02:09:42.107 --> 02:09:43.775
THIS.
02:09:43.842 --> 02:09:45.377
AS THE ANNOUNCES POINTS OUT.
02:09:45.444 --> 02:09:48.514
NOW AND AS YOU'LL HEAR IN A
02:09:48.580 --> 02:09:49.114
LATER BILL THAT'S BEING HEARD
02:09:49.181 --> 02:09:50.048
TODAY.
02:09:50.115 --> 02:09:51.917
ANY THERE ARE IN THESE KIND OF
02:09:51.984 --> 02:09:53.252
CASES THAT DO END UP BEING
02:09:53.318 --> 02:09:54.786
LITIGATED THERE ARE TYPICALLY
02:09:54.853 --> 02:09:56.588
VERY CONTENTIOUS LITIGATION
02:09:56.655 --> 02:09:58.357
THERE ARE OFTEN MULTIPLE CAUSES
02:09:58.423 --> 02:09:59.591
OF ACTION OR MULTIPLE LAWSUITS
02:09:59.658 --> 02:10:01.193
THAT ARE BEING FILED.
02:10:01.260 --> 02:10:02.794
ALL OF THOSE OTHER LAWSUITS WILL
02:10:02.861 --> 02:10:03.962
PROCEED ON THAN NORMAL TIME
02:10:04.029 --> 02:10:05.831
LINES --
02:10:05.898 --> 02:10:07.766
THAT THE COURT WILL HANDLE THEM
02:10:07.833 --> 02:10:10.235
AS EFFICIENTLY AS POSSIBLE AND
02:10:10.302 --> 02:10:12.037
YOU ARE TAKING ONLY A SUBSET OF
02:10:12.104 --> 02:10:14.706
LITIGATION THAT IS POTENTIALLY
02:10:14.773 --> 02:10:16.408
TO BE BROUGHT AGAINST THESE-PROJECTS.
02:10:16.475 --> 02:10:17.442
MOVING IT TO THE FRONT OF THE
02:10:17.509 --> 02:10:18.810
LINE WHERE ALL OTHER PENDING
02:10:18.877 --> 02:10:19.978
LITIGATION IS GOING TO HAPPEN ON
02:10:20.045 --> 02:10:21.613
THE NORMAL.
02:10:21.680 --> 02:10:22.781
I HAVE TIMELINE SO WE WOULD
02:10:22.848 --> 02:10:24.416
RESPECTFULLY SUGGEST THAT THE
02:10:24.483 --> 02:10:25.884
GUARANTEE THIS BEING SOUGHT.
02:10:25.951 --> 02:10:27.452
BY THIS KIND OF APPROACHES IS
02:10:27.519 --> 02:10:28.654
NOT GONNA --
02:10:28.720 --> 02:10:32.157
COME TO FRUITION I'M AS THE AS
02:10:32.224 --> 02:10:33.659
THE SAYING GOES AND IS EVERYONE
02:10:33.725 --> 02:10:34.927
FAMILIAR.
02:10:34.993 --> 02:10:36.395
JUSTICE DELAYED IS TRULY JUSTICE
02:10:36.461 --> 02:10:37.896
DENIED AND FOR ALL THE OTHER
02:10:37.963 --> 02:10:39.031
LIVE AGAINST THAT WOULD BE
02:10:39.097 --> 02:10:40.566
ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY THIS SORT
02:10:40.632 --> 02:10:41.466
OF SCHEME.
02:10:41.533 --> 02:10:43.368
WE ARE OPPOSED TO THE BILL AND
02:10:43.435 --> 02:10:44.269
WE RESPECTFULLY REQUEST THE NOVA
02:10:44.336 --> 02:10:45.270
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY
02:10:45.337 --> 02:10:45.571
[inaudible]
02:10:45.637 --> 02:10:49.174
SEAT.
02:10:49.241 --> 02:10:50.008
KYLE JOHNSON CIRCLE CALIFORNIA --
02:10:50.075 --> 02:10:52.277
AND WE ARE CONSISTENTLY OPPOSED
02:10:52.344 --> 02:10:53.745
TO THESE KINDS OF MEASURES --
02:10:53.812 --> 02:10:56.114
AND THEIR HOUSE AS DODD JUDICIAL
02:10:56.181 --> 02:10:57.449
COUNSELOR THERE HAS BEEN --
02:10:57.516 --> 02:10:59.918
NUMEROUS OF THEM AND IT IS.
02:10:59.985 --> 02:11:00.752
TENDER ELEVEN TIME --
02:11:00.819 --> 02:11:02.387
EITHER ONE OF THESE TABLES WITH
02:11:02.454 --> 02:11:04.122
THE AND ARE ON THESE ISSUES --
02:11:04.189 --> 02:11:05.390
AND I DID WANT TO THANK THE
02:11:05.457 --> 02:11:06.858
AUTHOR AND THE SPONSORS FOR
02:11:06.925 --> 02:11:07.859
REMOVING --
02:11:07.926 --> 02:11:09.294
THE INJUNCTION LANGUAGE AND I
02:11:09.361 --> 02:11:10.495
THINK THAT IS VERY HOPEFUL FOR
02:11:10.562 --> 02:11:12.464
US -- BUT
02:11:12.531 --> 02:11:13.131
UNFORTUNATELY JUST
02:11:13.198 --> 02:11:15.334
PHILOSOPHICALLY WE ARE OPPOSED
02:11:15.400 --> 02:11:18.203
TO THESE KINDS OF TIME LINES AND
02:11:18.270 --> 02:11:21.006
FOCUSES ON STREAMLINING GOT
02:11:21.073 --> 02:11:22.341
SECRET LITIGATION IN THAT.
02:11:22.407 --> 02:11:23.141
SENSE IT CAN PREJUDICE --
02:11:23.208 --> 02:11:26.044
ATTEND --
02:11:26.111 --> 02:11:27.179
YOU KNOW IF YOU'RE TRYING AND
02:11:27.246 --> 02:11:28.880
STRUGGLING TO MAKE IT TWO
02:11:28.947 --> 02:11:29.648
HUNDRED SEVENTY EIGHT TIMES.
02:11:29.715 --> 02:11:31.650
TIMELINE IN LITIGATION IT COULD
02:11:31.717 --> 02:11:34.152
BE UNFAIR ON SOME PARTIES I IN
02:11:34.219 --> 02:11:34.753
IN IT YOU KNOW WHO MAYBE JUST
02:11:34.820 --> 02:11:35.554
NEED.
02:11:35.621 --> 02:11:37.289
YOU KNOW TOTALLY IN GOOD FAITH
02:11:37.356 --> 02:11:39.558
NEED MORE TIME TO GET YOU KNOW A
02:11:39.625 --> 02:11:40.392
BRIEF DONE OR SOMETHING LIKE
02:11:40.459 --> 02:11:41.093
THAT.
02:11:41.159 --> 02:11:42.227
THE COURTS MIGHT BE MORE
02:11:42.294 --> 02:11:43.328
INCLINED TO DENY THOSE THOSE
02:11:43.395 --> 02:11:45.230
MOTIONS --
02:11:45.297 --> 02:11:47.366
NOW WE DON'T HAVE ANY ISSUE WITH
02:11:47.432 --> 02:11:50.168
THE PROJECT WE ARE FULLY IN
02:11:50.235 --> 02:11:50.969
SUPPORT OF THE A. STAYING IN
02:11:51.036 --> 02:11:51.236
OAKLAND --
02:11:51.303 --> 02:11:52.838
IF.
02:11:52.904 --> 02:11:54.239
THE TEAM WERE TO MOVE I THINK MY
02:11:54.306 --> 02:11:56.441
OPERATIONS MANAGER IN THE OFFICE
02:11:56.508 --> 02:11:57.042
WOULD KILL ME --
02:11:57.109 --> 02:12:00.646
BUT BUT I'M THERE ARE JUST SOME
02:12:00.712 --> 02:12:02.047
ISSUES THAT I WANTED TO POINT
02:12:02.114 --> 02:12:03.015
OUT THE COMMITTEE WITH WITH
02:12:03.081 --> 02:12:04.950
PROJECTS AND AND AND OUT WITH
02:12:05.017 --> 02:12:06.285
THE PROPOSED SITES --
02:12:06.351 --> 02:12:09.187
AND AND THAT WE DON'T THINK THAT.
02:12:09.254 --> 02:12:11.423
THIS MIGHT BE NECESSARY I'M ONE
02:12:11.490 --> 02:12:13.091
OF THE SITES IS HOWARD TERMINAL
02:12:13.158 --> 02:12:14.726
ON THE NORTH SIDE OF JACK LONDON
02:12:14.793 --> 02:12:16.295
SQUARE AYE IT IS DIRECTLY ON THE
02:12:16.361 --> 02:12:17.596
WATER.
02:12:17.663 --> 02:12:20.532
I'D IS CURRENTLY A OUT.
02:12:20.599 --> 02:12:21.867
AS I UNDERSTAND IT HAS BEEN USED
02:12:21.933 --> 02:12:22.968
IN AWHILE BUT IT IS A FORMER
02:12:23.035 --> 02:12:24.636
INDUSTRIAL SITES --
02:12:24.703 --> 02:12:25.671
ON THE WATER --
02:12:25.737 --> 02:12:27.973
ADJACENT TO AMTRAK LINES AT
02:12:28.040 --> 02:12:29.007
GRADE -- AND
02:12:29.074 --> 02:12:31.209
THEN THERE'S A FREEWAY NEARBY --
02:12:31.276 --> 02:12:32.210
AND SO.
02:12:32.277 --> 02:12:33.278
EVEN YOU KNOW I THINK WITH THE
02:12:33.345 --> 02:12:34.746
REMOVAL INJUNCTIONS --
02:12:34.813 --> 02:12:35.847
WE WERE CONCERNED ABOUT
02:12:35.914 --> 02:12:37.649
POTENTIALLY CONSTRUCTION IMPACTS
02:12:37.716 --> 02:12:38.550
DURING OF THINGS GETTING IN THE
02:12:38.617 --> 02:12:39.985
WATER -- IT
02:12:40.052 --> 02:12:41.153
AND YOU KNOW THERE'S GOING TO BE
02:12:41.219 --> 02:12:42.688
I THINK A VERY.
02:12:42.754 --> 02:12:43.955
DODD MEET THERE'S GONNA BE A
02:12:44.022 --> 02:12:45.023
NEED FOR REALLY STRONG PUBLIC
02:12:45.090 --> 02:12:46.558
SAFETY DEBATE WITH THE AMTRAK
02:12:46.625 --> 02:12:47.559
LINE AT GRADE THERE.
02:12:47.626 --> 02:12:49.027
I THINK REMOVING THE INJECTION
02:12:49.094 --> 02:12:50.062
WILL HELP --
02:12:50.128 --> 02:12:53.231
ALONG WITH.
02:12:53.298 --> 02:12:54.599
WITH THAT SITE --
02:12:54.666 --> 02:12:57.002
BUT I THINK WE'RE STILL CONCERT
02:12:57.069 --> 02:12:58.537
AGAIN FOR THE OTHER REASONS BELL --
02:12:58.603 --> 02:13:00.639
THE OTHER SITE WHICH IS THE THE
02:13:00.706 --> 02:13:01.707
DOWNSIZING OF THE EXISTING
02:13:01.773 --> 02:13:04.443
COLISEUM DINOSAUR --
02:13:04.509 --> 02:13:05.877
IS ALREADY UNDERGONE A SPECIFIC
02:13:05.944 --> 02:13:06.845
PLAN --
02:13:06.912 --> 02:13:07.946
<c.green> I ARE WHICH IS BEEN</c>
02:13:08.013 --> 02:13:10.549
CERTIFIED AS OF TWENTY FIFTY SO
02:13:10.615 --> 02:13:11.883
I YOU KNOW USING THAT THE SEQUEL
02:13:11.950 --> 02:13:12.984
GUIDELINES --
02:13:13.051 --> 02:13:14.586
THE COMMUNITY PLAN EXCEPTIONAL
02:13:14.653 --> 02:13:15.654
US FOR PROJECTS CONSISTENT WITH
02:13:15.721 --> 02:13:17.689
SPECIFIC PLANS TO ONLY HAVE TO
02:13:17.756 --> 02:13:19.458
CONSIDER SITE SPECIFIC --
02:13:19.524 --> 02:13:21.093
NON CUMULATIVE IMPACTS PROVIDED
02:13:21.159 --> 02:13:22.461
THOSE OF RT BEEN ADDRESSED AND
02:13:22.527 --> 02:13:23.795
IF THAT'S THE CASE THEN THERE'S
02:13:23.862 --> 02:13:24.696
ALREADY STREAMLINING IN LA
02:13:24.763 --> 02:13:26.031
FAILED WILL FOR THE PROJECT AT
02:13:26.098 --> 02:13:27.632
THAT SITE --
02:13:27.699 --> 02:13:29.501
AND SO WHILE WE THINK YOU KNOW
02:13:29.568 --> 02:13:30.702
THE AUTHOR THE SPONSORS FOR
02:13:30.769 --> 02:13:32.437
TAKING AMENDMENTS TO TRY TO
02:13:32.504 --> 02:13:33.338
IMPROVE --
02:13:33.405 --> 02:13:35.240
THE ENVIRONMENTAL AYE THAT
02:13:35.307 --> 02:13:37.909
QUALITY IMPACTS OF THEIR
02:13:37.976 --> 02:13:40.712
PROJECTS AND TO NOTS THAT LIMIT
02:13:40.779 --> 02:13:42.414
INJUNCTIONS WE STILL DO HAVE
02:13:42.481 --> 02:13:43.615
CONCERNS ABOUT THAT AND THINK
02:13:43.682 --> 02:13:44.549
THERE'S A THAT THIS BILL IS
02:13:44.616 --> 02:13:46.284
UNNECESSARY.
02:13:46.351 --> 02:13:47.319
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY IF
02:13:47.386 --> 02:13:48.387
THERE'S OTHER OPPONENTS COULD
02:13:48.453 --> 02:13:54.092
YOU PLEASE COME FORWARD.
02:13:54.159 --> 02:13:55.427
GOOD MORNING MATTHEW BAKER WITH
02:13:55.494 --> 02:13:56.661
PLANNING CONSERVATION THE FOR
02:13:56.728 --> 02:13:57.696
THE REASONS PREVIOUSLY STATED
02:13:57.763 --> 02:13:59.197
PARTICULARLY THAT OF THE
02:13:59.264 --> 02:14:00.966
JUDICIAL COUNCIL --
02:14:01.032 --> 02:14:03.168
PCO IS OPPOSED TO THIS BILL TUNE
02:14:03.235 --> 02:14:04.603
NOT SPEAKING TO THE MERITS OF
02:14:04.669 --> 02:14:05.837
THE PROJECT BUT WE DO.
02:14:05.904 --> 02:14:08.540
HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT EXPERTLY
02:14:08.607 --> 02:14:09.975
JUDICIAL REVIEW.
02:14:10.041 --> 02:14:11.443
I FEEL THAT THERE ARE SOME
02:14:11.510 --> 02:14:13.678
SPECIAL CASES SOME URGENT CASES
02:14:13.745 --> 02:14:15.347
THAT COULD WARRANT SUCH.
02:14:15.414 --> 02:14:17.015
EXPLODED JUDICIAL REVIEW BUT WE
02:14:17.082 --> 02:14:20.585
DON'T FEEL THAT SPORTS COMPLEX.
02:14:20.652 --> 02:14:21.620
I'D BE ONE OF THOSE I CAN MAKE
02:14:21.686 --> 02:14:23.021
EVER TESTIMONY LAST CALL FOR ANY
02:14:23.088 --> 02:14:25.190
OTHER OPPONENTS.
02:14:25.257 --> 02:14:26.725
IF NOT I WILL GO BACK TO THE
02:14:26.792 --> 02:14:28.727
AUTHOR TO GIVE NO OPPORTUNITY
02:14:28.794 --> 02:14:29.694
RESPOND TO SOME OF THE CRITICISM
02:14:29.761 --> 02:14:29.995
[inaudible]
02:14:30.061 --> 02:14:32.898
THE OPPONENTS.
02:14:32.964 --> 02:14:34.499
YOUR THANK YOU I AM I I FIRST
02:14:34.566 --> 02:14:36.935
JUST WANT TO KNOW THAT --
02:14:37.002 --> 02:14:39.004
OUR AMENDMENT REMOVING ANTI
02:14:39.070 --> 02:14:40.272
JUNCTION LANGUAGES SOMETHING
02:14:40.338 --> 02:14:41.740
FORCED ONE HIGHLIGHT FACT YOUR
02:14:41.807 --> 02:14:43.041
CLUB IS VERY HAPPY WITH THAT
02:14:43.108 --> 02:14:44.142
THAT THAT WAS ONE OF THEIR KEY
02:14:44.209 --> 02:14:45.877
CONCERN TO WE REMOVE THAT
02:14:45.944 --> 02:14:47.179
CONCERNED GOT AN IMPORTANT STEP.
02:14:47.245 --> 02:14:48.547
ALSO WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT
02:14:48.613 --> 02:14:49.548
ABOUT THAT JUDICIAL COUNCILS
02:14:49.614 --> 02:14:49.848
[inaudible]
02:14:49.915 --> 02:14:54.085
COMMENTS --
02:14:54.152 --> 02:14:55.787
THE THE CONCEPT.
02:14:55.854 --> 02:14:57.255
THAT WAS USED TO DESCRIBE
02:14:57.322 --> 02:14:57.556
[inaudible]
02:14:57.622 --> 02:15:00.525
THAT. TWO DID SEVENTY EIGHT DAY
02:15:00.592 --> 02:15:02.027
JEWISH REVIEW I DON'T THINK IS.
02:15:02.093 --> 02:15:03.261
DYNAMIC ENOUGH FOR HOW THE OURT
02:15:03.328 --> 02:15:04.930
SYSTEM REALLY WORKS WE IT'S NOT
02:15:04.996 --> 02:15:06.731
UP A SINGLE LINEAR LINE THAT
02:15:06.798 --> 02:15:07.866
SOMEONE GETS IN IT GETS BUMPED
02:15:07.933 --> 02:15:09.234
FROM THE FRONT.
02:15:09.301 --> 02:15:10.735
THERE'S NOT SOME THIS BILL
02:15:10.802 --> 02:15:11.736
DOESN'T CREATE SOME SITUATION
02:15:11.803 --> 02:15:12.037
[inaudible]
02:15:12.103 --> 02:15:12.838
WHERE [inaudible]
02:15:12.904 --> 02:15:14.673
THE MOST.
02:15:14.739 --> 02:15:16.041
URGENT SYMPATHETIC CASE YOU CAN
02:15:16.107 --> 02:15:17.409
THINK OF SOMEHOW GETS BUMPED IN
02:15:17.476 --> 02:15:18.710
THE FINAL LINE GETS PUT TO THE
02:15:18.777 --> 02:15:19.744
BACK OF THE LINE WE HAVE
02:15:19.811 --> 02:15:21.313
HUNDREDS OF COURSE.
02:15:21.379 --> 02:15:22.180
RIGHT OUR STATE WITH THOUSANDS
02:15:22.247 --> 02:15:23.949
OF HEARING TIMES.
02:15:24.015 --> 02:15:26.351
AND THEY THE OPERATE AS ONE
02:15:26.418 --> 02:15:27.152
SIMULTANEOUSLY ON MULTIPLE
02:15:27.219 --> 02:15:29.921
TRACKS.
02:15:29.988 --> 02:15:30.088
SO.
02:15:30.155 --> 02:15:31.690
MOST FOLKS WON'T FEEL ANY
02:15:31.756 --> 02:15:33.625
DIFFERENCE AT ALL FROM THIS.
02:15:33.692 --> 02:15:35.627
A WE WE JUST SEEK AT A HEARING
02:15:35.694 --> 02:15:36.695
OR SET OF HEARINGS WITHIN A
02:15:36.761 --> 02:15:37.829
TWENTY ASSEMBLY PERIOD.
02:15:37.896 --> 02:15:39.297
SO I DON'T THINK THAT'S QUITE
02:15:39.364 --> 02:15:40.866
ACCURATE I LIKE TO JUST I'M SURE
02:15:40.932 --> 02:15:43.001
MY OWN PERSPECTIVE OF WHAT OUR
02:15:43.068 --> 02:15:44.102
COURT SYSTEM HOW WOULD BE
02:15:44.169 --> 02:15:45.303
IMPACTED OR RATHER NOT.
02:15:45.370 --> 02:15:46.705
AT IMPACTED ADVERSELY BUT BY
02:15:46.771 --> 02:15:48.540
THIS BILL.
02:15:48.607 --> 02:15:50.041
I'M NOT I THINK THE THE KEY
02:15:50.108 --> 02:15:51.309
POINTS [inaudible]
02:15:51.376 --> 02:15:53.111
ARE.
02:15:53.178 --> 02:15:54.880
WE'RE GOING THROUGH.
02:15:54.946 --> 02:15:56.815
THE SECRET PROCESS THE ENTIRE
02:15:56.882 --> 02:15:58.517
SECRET PROCESS WE'RE GONNA HAVE
02:15:58.583 --> 02:16:00.418
ANY AYE ARE.
02:16:00.485 --> 02:16:02.587
WE JUST NEED SOME CERTAINTY ON
02:16:02.654 --> 02:16:03.688
THE JUDICIAL REVIEW THEY WILL
02:16:03.755 --> 02:16:05.156
STILL BE A JUDICIAL REVIEW THEY
02:16:05.223 --> 02:16:07.359
WILL STILL BE ALL --
02:16:07.425 --> 02:16:10.795
MANNER AND THE FULL MENU OF OF
02:16:10.862 --> 02:16:12.497
SOLUTIONS INCLUDING INJUNCTIVE
02:16:12.564 --> 02:16:14.466
RELIEF AVAILABLE TO A COURT --
02:16:14.533 --> 02:16:16.268
BUT THAT THAT THE FIVE THE
02:16:16.334 --> 02:16:17.936
POSSIBILITY OF A FIVE YEAR DELAY
02:16:18.003 --> 02:16:19.471
FOR ANY BUSINESS A IS A REAL
02:16:19.538 --> 02:16:20.572
PROBLEM IN TERMS OF THE NEED FOR
02:16:20.639 --> 02:16:21.673
CERTAINTY THAT WE NEED NO ALL
02:16:21.740 --> 02:16:23.041
BUSINESSES NEED THIS IS NOT
02:16:23.108 --> 02:16:23.975
UNPRECEDENTED.
02:16:24.042 --> 02:16:26.378
UNLESS IT'S UNPRECEDENTED IN THE
02:16:26.444 --> 02:16:27.979
WEIGHT SCALE BACK ON SOME OF
02:16:28.046 --> 02:16:29.247
THINGS THAT WE'VE DONE BEFORE.
02:16:29.314 --> 02:16:30.549
LEGISLATION THAT LEGISLATION
02:16:30.615 --> 02:16:32.350
THAT THIS BODY HAS PASSED AND
02:16:32.417 --> 02:16:33.852
BECOME LAW THAT HAS EMINENT
02:16:33.919 --> 02:16:34.586
DOMAIN ARE BILL DOES NOT HAVE
02:16:34.653 --> 02:16:35.587
EMINENT DOMAIN.
02:16:35.654 --> 02:16:37.088
WE'VE HAD BILLS THAT HAVE BEEN
02:16:37.155 --> 02:16:38.823
PASSED AT THAT DO HAVE THE
02:16:38.890 --> 02:16:40.225
INJUNCTIVE --
02:16:40.292 --> 02:16:41.126
THEN TANGENTIAL LANGUAGE WE'VE
02:16:41.192 --> 02:16:42.861
REMOVED THAT LANGUAGE THERE'S
02:16:42.928 --> 02:16:43.995
BILLS THAT HAVE PASSED THAT HAVE
02:16:44.062 --> 02:16:45.497
LIMITED THAT THE USE OF OUR OUR
02:16:45.564 --> 02:16:45.697
THAT.
02:16:45.764 --> 02:16:49.267
THE JURISDICTION OF OF I SPDC
02:16:49.334 --> 02:16:50.769
AND THE STATE THAILAND'S
02:16:50.835 --> 02:16:52.103
COMMISSION.
02:16:52.170 --> 02:16:53.538
AT THOSE BEEN PASSED AND SIGNED
02:16:53.605 --> 02:16:56.074
INTO LAW AND AND AND EFFECTIVE.
02:16:56.141 --> 02:16:56.708
THIS MOMENT WE'RE NOT ASKING FOR
02:16:56.775 --> 02:16:58.043
THAT.
02:16:58.109 --> 02:16:59.911
SO WE THINK WITH RESPECT TO THIS
02:16:59.978 --> 02:17:02.881
TEAM THIS CITY THIS UNIQUE SET
02:17:02.948 --> 02:17:04.649
OF CIRCUMSTANCES.
02:17:04.716 --> 02:17:05.584
BEFORE YOU THAT THIS IS A
02:17:05.650 --> 02:17:07.686
REASONABLE APPROACH --
02:17:07.752 --> 02:17:09.120
THAT BOUNCES OUR DUTY TO PROTECT
02:17:09.187 --> 02:17:11.790
OUR ENVIRONMENT --
02:17:11.856 --> 02:17:13.992
WITH OUR OUR COMMITMENT TO
02:17:14.059 --> 02:17:15.627
CREATE GOOD JOBS IN A CITY THAT
02:17:15.694 --> 02:17:17.162
NEED THEM DESPERATELY OP
02:17:17.228 --> 02:17:18.430
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IT'S
02:17:18.496 --> 02:17:20.599
PRIVATELY FINANCED I'M A WHOLE
02:17:20.665 --> 02:17:22.233
SET OF COMMUNITY BENEFITS.
02:17:22.300 --> 02:17:24.202
AND IN TOTAL --
02:17:24.269 --> 02:17:25.270
AND ON BALANCE I THINK IT'S IT'S
02:17:25.337 --> 02:17:26.571
WORTHY OF YOUR SUPPORT WHICH I
02:17:26.638 --> 02:17:27.973
RESPECTFULLY ASK.
02:17:28.039 --> 02:17:29.074
FOR BIG SENATE IN AND ALSO JUST
02:17:29.140 --> 02:17:30.809
OF A CODIFIED THAT DAY YOU TAKE
02:17:30.875 --> 02:17:32.477
AN AMENDMENT THAT WOULD --
02:17:32.544 --> 02:17:33.278
FIGURE FROM --
02:17:33.345 --> 02:17:35.614
SOBRE LEED CERTIFIED GOLD SIR
02:17:35.680 --> 02:17:37.682
LEVITE RIGHT.
02:17:37.749 --> 02:17:39.150
AT MAY BE SPECIFIC ON THAT YES I
02:17:39.217 --> 02:17:42.287
AM YES ON THE BASELINE FOR THE
02:17:42.354 --> 02:17:42.954
BALLPARK AND COMMERCIAL
02:17:43.021 --> 02:17:45.957
DEVELOPMENT YET STILL SILVER.
02:17:46.024 --> 02:17:47.959
FOR RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT.
02:17:48.026 --> 02:17:49.327
IT COMPLIES WITH OAKLAND'S
02:17:49.394 --> 02:17:52.197
REQUIREMENT THAT NEW HOUSING.
02:17:52.263 --> 02:17:56.501
B. HAVE A LEAD CERTIFICATION.
02:17:56.568 --> 02:17:57.168
THANK YOU YOUR CLASSIFICATION ON
02:17:57.235 --> 02:17:58.837
THAT AND AND MAYOR WE'VE WE'VE
02:17:58.903 --> 02:18:00.071
HEARD ABOUT THE OVERWHELMING
02:18:00.138 --> 02:18:02.774
TESTIMONY ABOUT THE BENEFITS --
02:18:02.841 --> 02:18:06.211
THAT THIS CLUB HAS TO YOUR CITY --
02:18:06.277 --> 02:18:08.313
COULD YOU ARTICULATE.
02:18:08.380 --> 02:18:08.880
IF.
02:18:08.947 --> 02:18:10.415
AB SEVEN THIRTY FOUR IS NOT
02:18:10.482 --> 02:18:12.083
PASSED WITH THE CONSEQUENCES
02:18:12.150 --> 02:18:12.617
WOULD HAVE ON THE CITY OF
02:18:12.684 --> 02:18:14.619
OAKLAND.
02:18:14.686 --> 02:18:16.655
I WANT TO RECOGNIZE THAT THE
02:18:16.721 --> 02:18:18.857
EIGHTIES ARE PRIVATELY FINANCING
02:18:18.923 --> 02:18:20.792
THEIR BALLPARK.
02:18:20.859 --> 02:18:22.327
THIS IS SOMETHING THAT IS NOT
02:18:22.394 --> 02:18:25.196
THE PRACTICE ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
02:18:25.263 --> 02:18:28.233
THIS TEAM IS MAKING A COMMITMENT
02:18:28.299 --> 02:18:30.902
TO THE CITY WHERE IT IS ROOTED
02:18:30.969 --> 02:18:34.139
IN AND WE LOVE THAT TAGLINE --
02:18:34.205 --> 02:18:35.807
AND THIS IS A MATTER OF CIVIC
02:18:35.874 --> 02:18:37.942
PRIDE.
02:18:38.009 --> 02:18:39.077
THE FACT THAT THEY ARE PUTTING
02:18:39.144 --> 02:18:41.246
THEIR OWN MONEY UP --
02:18:41.312 --> 02:18:42.747
REALLY REQUIRES THAT WE MEET
02:18:42.814 --> 02:18:44.749
THEM --
02:18:44.816 --> 02:18:47.385
RESPONSIBLY HALFWAY.
02:18:47.452 --> 02:18:49.154
AND GIVE THEM CERTAINTY.
02:18:49.220 --> 02:18:51.189
OBVIOUSLY INFILL DEVELOPMENT IN
02:18:51.256 --> 02:18:52.490
A CITY LIKE OAKLAND IS VERY
02:18:52.557 --> 02:18:54.659
COMPLICATED.
02:18:54.726 --> 02:18:56.327
AND SO TO JUST GIVE THEM
02:18:56.394 --> 02:18:58.463
CERTAINTY THERE IN NOT ASKING TO
02:18:58.530 --> 02:19:00.832
CUT ANY ENVIRONMENTAL CORNERS.
02:19:00.899 --> 02:19:02.500
THEY ARE JUST ASKING FOR TIME
02:19:02.567 --> 02:19:05.470
CERTAINTY THAT IS REASONABLE IT
02:19:05.537 --> 02:19:07.338
IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE INTENT
02:19:07.405 --> 02:19:09.007
OF AB.
02:19:09.074 --> 02:19:09.507
NINE HUNDRED AND IT IS
02:19:09.574 --> 02:19:11.076
CONSISTENT WITH I THINK THE
02:19:11.142 --> 02:19:13.378
VALUES OF OAKLAND THAT LOVES OUR
02:19:13.445 --> 02:19:15.313
TEAM THAT LOVES THE PRIDE THAT
02:19:15.380 --> 02:19:17.082
THE OAKLAND ACE HAVE BROUGHT.
02:19:17.148 --> 02:19:19.350
FOR GENERATIONS AND GENERATIONS
02:19:19.417 --> 02:19:20.852
AND I GOTTA SAY AS A AS AN
02:19:20.919 --> 02:19:22.187
OAKLAND NATIVE.
02:19:22.253 --> 02:19:24.756
THERE'S NO SUBSTITUTE. FOR THAT
02:19:24.823 --> 02:19:27.225
FEELING AND THIS IS A CITY THAT
02:19:27.292 --> 02:19:29.694
HAS BEEN REALLY WOUNDED RECENTLY
02:19:29.761 --> 02:19:31.362
BY OTHER TEAMS LEAVING US ALL AT
02:19:31.429 --> 02:19:33.031
ONCE.
02:19:33.098 --> 02:19:34.766
HERE WE HAVE A TEAM THAT IS
02:19:34.833 --> 02:19:35.900
WILLING TO INVEST IN OUR
02:19:35.967 --> 02:19:39.104
COMMUNITY THAT IS WILLING TO NOT
02:19:39.170 --> 02:19:41.506
ABANDON BUT LIFT UP THE PRIDE
02:19:41.573 --> 02:19:41.806
[inaudible]
02:19:41.873 --> 02:19:44.542
CIVIC IDENTITY AND DO IT ANYWAY
02:19:44.609 --> 02:19:46.544
THAT IS FINANCIALLY RESPONSIBLE
02:19:46.611 --> 02:19:48.079
THAT IS RESPONSIBLE TO THE WORK
02:19:48.146 --> 02:19:49.647
FORCE AND IS RESPONSIBLE TO THE
02:19:49.714 --> 02:19:51.783
ENVIRONMENT THIS IS A WIN WIN
02:19:51.850 --> 02:19:54.352
WIN.
02:19:54.419 --> 02:19:55.286
SIGH SO MAY MY QUESTION IS IT
02:19:55.353 --> 02:19:57.255
WOULD HAVE A DEVASTATING CON THE
02:19:57.322 --> 02:19:57.822
QUESTION ON THE TABLE SO HE
02:19:57.889 --> 02:19:58.690
WOULD HAVE DEVASTATING
02:19:58.757 --> 02:20:01.793
CONSEQUENCES AND THIS PROJECT IS
02:20:01.860 --> 02:20:04.529
A HOME RUN.
02:20:04.596 --> 02:20:04.996
TAKING YOUR HERE GREAT
02:20:05.063 --> 02:20:06.030
CHEERLEADER.
02:20:06.097 --> 02:20:08.900
FOR SENATOR STERN SENATOR LARA.
02:20:08.967 --> 02:20:10.068
SKINNER SAM'S OURSELVES
02:20:10.135 --> 02:20:10.368
[inaudible]
02:20:10.435 --> 02:20:12.203
THANK YOU.
02:20:12.270 --> 02:20:14.272
COLLEGES I HAD TO GO AND PRESENT
02:20:14.339 --> 02:20:15.607
A BILL ON ANOTHER COMMITTEE SO
02:20:15.673 --> 02:20:16.941
WAS NOT PRESENT FOR THE ENTIRE
02:20:17.008 --> 02:20:20.612
DISCUSSION BUT AND I THINK THAT --
02:20:20.678 --> 02:20:22.280
EVERYTIME WE'RE FACED WITH THESE
02:20:22.347 --> 02:20:24.315
THINGS THERE ARE YOU KNOW SO
02:20:24.382 --> 02:20:25.750
MUCH WE HAVE TO WAY.
02:20:25.817 --> 02:20:28.052
AND WHEN WE LOOK AT THE HISTORY
02:20:28.119 --> 02:20:29.454
OF THE LEGISLATURE IN TERMS OF
02:20:29.521 --> 02:20:32.056
PROVIDING SOME LEVEL OF SECRET
02:20:32.123 --> 02:20:34.092
EXEMPTION IT IS NEVER IT.
02:20:34.159 --> 02:20:35.860
IT'S NOT BEEN CONSISTENT.
02:20:35.927 --> 02:20:37.095
SOME PEOPLE COULD SAY THE
02:20:37.162 --> 02:20:38.696
CONSISTENCY IS --
02:20:38.763 --> 02:20:40.331
NOT SOMETHING ANYONE SHOULD BE
02:20:40.398 --> 02:20:41.199
PROUD OF SO I THINK THE
02:20:41.266 --> 02:20:44.903
LEGISLATURE'S OF FIND THEIR BUT
02:20:44.969 --> 02:20:46.404
WE DO HAVE TO LOOK AT EACH
02:20:46.471 --> 02:20:47.972
PROJECT IN ITS OWN UNIQUE
02:20:48.039 --> 02:20:49.707
CIRCUMSTANCE.
02:20:49.774 --> 02:20:52.043
AND UNLIKE MANY OF THE STADIUM
02:20:52.110 --> 02:20:54.312
PROJECTS THAT WE HAVE CONSIDERED
02:20:54.379 --> 02:20:56.548
SOME LEVEL OF STREAMLINING FOR
02:20:56.614 --> 02:20:57.949
THIS ONE IS NOT ASKING FOR ANY
02:20:58.016 --> 02:20:59.918
PUBLIC FUNDS NOW IS CERTAINLY
02:20:59.984 --> 02:21:01.886
ONE COULD SAY THAT THIS IS BY
02:21:01.953 --> 02:21:04.155
CREATING SOME CERTAINTY.
02:21:04.222 --> 02:21:05.723
IN EFFECT A PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
02:21:05.790 --> 02:21:08.493
BECAUSE IT DOES INSURER IF IT IS
02:21:08.560 --> 02:21:11.262
BUT IT IS NOTHING LIKE MANY OF
02:21:11.329 --> 02:21:12.831
THE OTHER STADIUM SET OF PEOPLE
02:21:12.897 --> 02:21:14.332
BEN BEFORE US WHERE.
02:21:14.399 --> 02:21:16.301
THAT SPORTS TEAM IS EXPECTING
02:21:16.367 --> 02:21:18.570
THE PUBLIC TO CARRY MUCH OF THE
02:21:18.636 --> 02:21:21.606
WATER FOR THEM IN THIS CASE.
02:21:21.673 --> 02:21:24.576
THE THE AIDS THEMSELVES.
02:21:24.642 --> 02:21:26.044
ALONG WITH OTHER ARAB PRIVATE
02:21:26.110 --> 02:21:27.912
INVESTORS ARE GOING TO BE TAKING
02:21:27.979 --> 02:21:29.581
CARE OF ALL OF THAT.
02:21:29.647 --> 02:21:31.382
AND WHAT WE ARE DOING IF WE
02:21:31.449 --> 02:21:33.318
SUPPORT THIS IS HELPING TO GIVE
02:21:33.384 --> 02:21:35.086
THEM.
02:21:35.153 --> 02:21:37.222
THAT TYPE OF ASSURANCE THAT
02:21:37.288 --> 02:21:40.358
WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THEIR IF
02:21:40.425 --> 02:21:41.659
FRANCHISE AGREEMENTS AND OTHERS
02:21:41.726 --> 02:21:43.494
THAT THAT THIS COULD WORK.
02:21:43.561 --> 02:21:45.363
NOW CLEARLY WE HAVE A SOMEWHAT
02:21:45.430 --> 02:21:46.931
UNIQUE SITUATION IN THAT WE
02:21:46.998 --> 02:21:48.700
DON'T HAVE A SINGLE PERSON WERE
02:21:48.766 --> 02:21:49.968
CONSIDERING WORD --
02:21:50.034 --> 02:21:51.736
CONSIDERING --
02:21:51.803 --> 02:21:53.671
TO BUT AT LEAST WITH ONE OF THE
02:21:53.738 --> 02:21:55.640
PARCELS WHICH IS STILL IT PLAY.
02:21:55.707 --> 02:21:58.376
IT THE ENTIRE SEEK WERE YOU HAS
02:21:58.443 --> 02:21:59.944
OCCURRED IT IS FULLY OCCURRED
02:22:00.011 --> 02:22:02.013
AND IN THE SECOND PARCEL THEIR
02:22:02.080 --> 02:22:04.082
HAT IS MORE --
02:22:04.148 --> 02:22:08.586
ENVIRONMENT REVIEW DOCUMENT.
02:22:08.653 --> 02:22:10.788
WE COMPARE AND AGAIN I'M.
02:22:10.855 --> 02:22:12.056
GONNA USE THIS COMPARISON I'M
02:22:12.123 --> 02:22:13.892
NOT NOW ARGUING AGAINST MISS
02:22:13.958 --> 02:22:16.427
COPIERS BILL I'M I'M INDICATING
02:22:16.494 --> 02:22:17.795
THAT I THINK IT NEEDED MORE.
02:22:17.862 --> 02:22:19.964
ASSURANCES --
02:22:20.031 --> 02:22:22.934
BECAUSE IT COVERS SO MANY MORE
02:22:23.001 --> 02:22:24.202
PARCELS UP AND DOWN THE STATE
02:22:24.269 --> 02:22:25.703
WHERE IS IN THIS CASE.
02:22:25.770 --> 02:22:28.640
THIS IS A PARCEL THAT HAS HAD
02:22:28.706 --> 02:22:30.708
MUCH MORE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
02:22:30.775 --> 02:22:33.344
DOING HOWARD TERMINAL --
02:22:33.411 --> 02:22:36.414
SO I AM COMFORTABLE WITH WHAT
02:22:36.481 --> 02:22:38.783
THE CITY AND THE TEAM ARE ASKING.
02:22:38.850 --> 02:22:41.753
FOR AND I KNOW THERE'S OTHER --
02:22:41.819 --> 02:22:43.121
AND OF THEIR OF MY COLLEAGUES
02:22:43.187 --> 02:22:44.289
ONE EITHER ASK QUESTIONS OR MAKE
02:22:44.355 --> 02:22:45.957
COLLEAGUES BUT I'M PREPARED TO
02:22:46.024 --> 02:22:46.824
MOVE THE BILL WHEN IT'S
02:22:46.891 --> 02:22:47.358
APPROPRIATE.
02:22:47.425 --> 02:22:49.260
OKAY SAW ALSO MENTIONED THAT THE
02:22:49.327 --> 02:22:50.895
CHAIR IS ALSO REQUESTED THAT WE
02:22:50.962 --> 02:22:52.630
TABLE THIS UNTIL HE'S ABLE TO
02:22:52.697 --> 02:22:53.464
RETURN WHICH HOPEFULLY WILL BE
02:22:53.531 --> 02:22:54.599
PROMPTLY.
02:22:54.666 --> 02:22:56.467
AND SO WE'LL GO TO SENATOR STERN
02:22:56.534 --> 02:22:57.268
FATHER BISON PARA.
02:22:57.335 --> 02:22:59.804
THANK YOU MISTER VICE CHAIR --
02:22:59.871 --> 02:23:00.972
THANK YOU MAYOR CHEF FOR JOINING
02:23:01.039 --> 02:23:02.840
US IN.
02:23:02.907 --> 02:23:04.575
AND A BRIEF STINT IN THE BAY
02:23:04.642 --> 02:23:10.481
AREA I AM ANGELINO BUT YEAH.
02:23:10.548 --> 02:23:12.050
I'M NOT GONNA LET ANY OF OF MY
02:23:12.116 --> 02:23:14.018
LOYALTIES [inaudible]
02:23:14.085 --> 02:23:16.020
IN BASEBALL.
02:23:16.087 --> 02:23:17.755
I FIND MY ANALYSIS OF HIS BILL
02:23:17.822 --> 02:23:19.757
HERE.
02:23:19.824 --> 02:23:22.193
WE APPRECIATE THE ENTHUSIASM AND
02:23:22.260 --> 02:23:24.062
WE KNOW THAT ALSO EIGHTIES FANS
02:23:24.128 --> 02:23:25.897
ARE AT A SPECIAL GROUP THERE'S A
02:23:25.964 --> 02:23:28.166
THERE'S A DEEP LOYALTY THERE.
02:23:28.232 --> 02:23:30.335
AND IT'S ALWAYS BEEN THAT SORT
02:23:30.401 --> 02:23:32.637
OF YOU KNOW THAT BLUE COLLAR
02:23:32.704 --> 02:23:33.905
FEEL AROUND THAT STADIUM YOU
02:23:33.972 --> 02:23:35.640
KNOW DICK TAILGATING OUT THERE
02:23:35.707 --> 02:23:37.208
AND LIKE PEOPLE JUST YOU KNOW
02:23:37.275 --> 02:23:40.244
IT'S IT'S REAL FOLKS AND IT'S
02:23:40.311 --> 02:23:41.512
THEY DESERVE.
02:23:41.579 --> 02:23:43.514
A REAL STADIUM SO I I'M I'M
02:23:43.581 --> 02:23:45.516
THERE I'M THERE WITH YOU ON THAT
02:23:45.583 --> 02:23:46.617
AYE I FIND MYSELF IN AN AWKWARD
02:23:46.684 --> 02:23:48.186
POSITION.
02:23:48.252 --> 02:23:49.654
TO BE TRYING TO THINK THROUGH
02:23:49.721 --> 02:23:51.055
YOUR OWN LOCAL LAND USE
02:23:51.122 --> 02:23:52.557
JUDGMENTS AND EXACTLY WHAT TESTS
02:23:52.623 --> 02:23:55.493
A TO IMPOSE ON THIS DEVELOPMENT
02:23:55.560 --> 02:23:57.595
BECAUSE WHERE IN HERE IN
02:23:57.662 --> 02:23:59.430
SACRAMENTO AND I REPRESENT LOS
02:23:59.497 --> 02:24:02.734
ANGELES AND SO. TO MICROMANAGE
02:24:02.800 --> 02:24:04.702
EXACTLY WHAT THE PROJECT LOOKS
02:24:04.769 --> 02:24:06.838
LIKE IT'S AN AWKWARD POSITION
02:24:06.904 --> 02:24:09.107
BUT I SO I'M TRYING.
02:24:09.173 --> 02:24:11.809
WHAT HOWEVER IMPERFECT TO FIND
02:24:11.876 --> 02:24:14.345
SOME KIND A CONSISTENCY AND AND
02:24:14.412 --> 02:24:15.313
THAT THE QUESTION I WANTED TO
02:24:15.380 --> 02:24:16.981
POSE IN --
02:24:17.048 --> 02:24:19.917
THE ISN'T IT MORE IN THE THE
02:24:19.984 --> 02:24:21.285
CLIMATE AND ENERGY SAID WE'RE IN
02:24:21.352 --> 02:24:22.787
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE.
02:24:22.854 --> 02:24:23.921
AND I'M TRYING TO SORT OF LOOK
02:24:23.988 --> 02:24:25.790
AT IT THROUGH THAT LENS.
02:24:25.857 --> 02:24:26.591
NOT EVEN JUST THROUGH THE
02:24:26.657 --> 02:24:28.259
HOUSING CRISIS OR THROUGH THE
02:24:28.326 --> 02:24:29.527
BROADER ISSUE AROUND DEVELOPMENT
02:24:29.594 --> 02:24:31.362
OR HOW MUCH --
02:24:31.429 --> 02:24:33.097
IS GONNA DO FOR THE COMMUNITY
02:24:33.164 --> 02:24:34.232
BUT REALLY.
02:24:34.298 --> 02:24:35.800
ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY SAID
02:24:35.867 --> 02:24:37.201
THAT THE STRUGGLE IN HEAVEN
02:24:37.268 --> 02:24:37.502
[inaudible]
02:24:37.568 --> 02:24:39.871
IS.
02:24:39.937 --> 02:24:41.172
THE ENGINE CLIMATE ACTION PLAN
02:24:41.239 --> 02:24:42.940
FOR OAKLAND IS ONE THE MOST
02:24:43.007 --> 02:24:44.942
ROBUST IN THE WORLD.
02:24:45.009 --> 02:24:47.211
AND YOU'VE BEEN A LEADER --
02:24:47.278 --> 02:24:49.080
SENATOR SKINNER --
02:24:49.147 --> 02:24:52.316
AND AND THE ENTIRE YEAR THAT IS
02:24:52.383 --> 02:24:54.052
SOMEWHERE BONTA YOU YOUR
02:24:54.118 --> 02:24:55.053
COMMUNITY YOU YOU'RE.
02:24:55.119 --> 02:24:56.287
YOUR YOUR WORLD LEADERS IN THAT
02:24:56.354 --> 02:24:58.556
YOU TAKE PRIDE IN IT YOUR CODES
02:24:58.623 --> 02:24:59.791
YOUR LOCAL RENEWABLE ENERGY
02:24:59.857 --> 02:25:00.892
GENERATION COMMITMENTS YOUR
02:25:00.958 --> 02:25:02.293
WASTE REDUCTION COMMITMENTS I
02:25:02.360 --> 02:25:04.629
THINK YOU'VE GOT A MAYBE A MORE
02:25:04.695 --> 02:25:05.630
AGGRESSIVE TIMELINE IN
02:25:05.696 --> 02:25:07.598
CALIFORNIA ON THE TWENTY TWENTY
02:25:07.665 --> 02:25:08.032
BASIS -- TO
02:25:08.099 --> 02:25:09.801
OUTPACE US.
02:25:09.867 --> 02:25:12.470
SO WHEN IT COMES IT IS.
02:25:12.537 --> 02:25:14.305
YOU TALK ABOUT THE EXPENSE OF
02:25:14.372 --> 02:25:16.207
THE CONSULTING AND DOING THE
02:25:16.274 --> 02:25:17.942
MATH RIGHT AND THAT THAT WILL WE
02:25:18.009 --> 02:25:19.477
KNOW WE KNOW ON THE WHOLE IT'S
02:25:19.544 --> 02:25:21.345
GONNA BE A LOWER IMPACT BECAUSE
02:25:21.412 --> 02:25:21.879
IT'S GOING TO BE A SMALLER
02:25:21.946 --> 02:25:23.281
STADIUM AND WE'RE GOING TO
02:25:23.347 --> 02:25:25.550
DESIGN IT BETTER BUT I I DON'T
02:25:25.616 --> 02:25:26.784
UNDERSTAND THE DOWNSIDE.
02:25:26.851 --> 02:25:28.786
IN DOING THE MATH.
02:25:28.853 --> 02:25:30.154
AND TRYING TO ACTUALLY GET TO
02:25:30.221 --> 02:25:31.956
THAT NET ZERO CHICHI THRESHOLD
02:25:32.023 --> 02:25:35.059
BECAUSE THERE'S SO MUCH
02:25:35.126 --> 02:25:36.594
OPPORTUNITY FOR FURTHER ECONOMIC
02:25:36.661 --> 02:25:38.196
DEVELOPMENT THAT I WOULD SEE IN
02:25:38.262 --> 02:25:39.931
MEETING THAT THRESHOLD.
02:25:39.997 --> 02:25:41.165
IF YOU'RE GENERATING EMISSIONS
02:25:41.232 --> 02:25:43.167
REDUCTIONS LOCALLY.
02:25:43.234 --> 02:25:44.168
IN OTHER WORDS IF YOU'RE FEEDING
02:25:44.235 --> 02:25:45.236
BACK INTO YOUR ENERGY AND
02:25:45.303 --> 02:25:46.404
CLIMATE PLAN.
02:25:46.471 --> 02:25:48.840
AND SAY YOU ARE WORKING WITH --
02:25:48.906 --> 02:25:50.641
ALLIED TRADES IN THE REGION TO
02:25:50.708 --> 02:25:52.076
BOOST MORE --
02:25:52.143 --> 02:25:53.578
ELECTRICAL YOU KNOW RENEWABLE
02:25:53.644 --> 02:25:55.847
GENERATION IN THE AREA OR YOU
02:25:55.913 --> 02:25:57.181
KNOW WORKING WITH YOUR WASTE
02:25:57.248 --> 02:25:59.183
AUTHORITIES TO FIND. TO FIND
02:25:59.250 --> 02:26:01.319
NEWT NEW TOOLS AYE AYE I GET
02:26:01.385 --> 02:26:03.955
THAT TO THE V. M. T. THE
02:26:04.021 --> 02:26:06.124
QUESTION IS IT IT'S A LITTLE
02:26:06.190 --> 02:26:08.926
DIFFERENT FRAME BUT I THINK
02:26:08.993 --> 02:26:09.227
[inaudible]
02:26:09.293 --> 02:26:11.262
I MEAN.
02:26:11.329 --> 02:26:13.331
THAT THRESHOLD THERE'S SOMETHING
02:26:13.397 --> 02:26:14.966
IN THAT TO BE PROUD OF EVEN IF
02:26:15.032 --> 02:26:17.001
THE MATH MAY COST SOMETHING TO
02:26:17.068 --> 02:26:19.070
DO -- THAT
02:26:19.137 --> 02:26:19.971
THAT'S WHERE I'M STRUGGLING
02:26:20.037 --> 02:26:21.739
BECAUSE I THINK.
02:26:21.806 --> 02:26:23.407
THAT IS THAT SORT OF LEADERSHIP
02:26:23.474 --> 02:26:25.443
PROJECT POTENTIAL IF WE'RE ABLE
02:26:25.510 --> 02:26:27.545
TO SHOW THAT YOU CAN HIT THIS
02:26:27.612 --> 02:26:29.113
THRESHOLD YOU CAN BE A ZERO
02:26:29.180 --> 02:26:30.114
EMISSIONS PROJECT.
02:26:30.181 --> 02:26:35.319
AND OAKLAND CAN BE OAKLAND I
02:26:35.386 --> 02:26:36.687
MEAN THAT THERE THAT THEY THEY
02:26:36.754 --> 02:26:37.622
WANT IT SO I JUST WANT TO
02:26:37.688 --> 02:26:39.490
COMMENT IF YOU'VE EXPLORED THAT
02:26:39.557 --> 02:26:40.925
NEXUS BETWEEN YOUR CLIMATE AND
02:26:40.992 --> 02:26:42.326
ENERGY PLAN IN THIS PROJECT AND
02:26:42.393 --> 02:26:43.828
WHETHER CAN FEEDBACK THROUGH IT
02:26:43.895 --> 02:26:45.029
AND AND MAYBE THERE'S SOMETHING
02:26:45.096 --> 02:26:45.897
THAT'S ACTUALLY COST EFFECTIVE
02:26:45.963 --> 02:26:46.797
AND THAT.
02:26:46.864 --> 02:26:48.232
ISN'T JUST AN ADDED EXPENSE BUT
02:26:48.299 --> 02:26:49.534
SOME IT ACTUALLY WOULD FEED THE
02:26:49.600 --> 02:26:50.601
ECONOMICS OF THE COMMUNION IT
02:26:50.668 --> 02:26:51.869
PROJECTS SO JUST PLEASE COMMENT
02:26:51.936 --> 02:26:54.539
ON THAT AND IF YOU RESPECT.
02:26:54.605 --> 02:26:56.541
YOUR YOUR GUYS ENTHUSIASM.
02:26:56.607 --> 02:26:57.875
MISTER SENATOR.
02:26:57.942 --> 02:26:59.210
ON THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTION I
02:26:59.277 --> 02:27:00.411
PROMISE YOU OAKLAND WILL BE
02:27:00.478 --> 02:27:02.880
OAKLAND --
02:27:02.947 --> 02:27:04.215
THERE'S NOTHING IN THIS BILL
02:27:04.282 --> 02:27:04.782
THAT PROHIBITS THAT TYPE OF
02:27:04.849 --> 02:27:06.450
ANALYSIS.
02:27:06.517 --> 02:27:08.386
IT MERELY DOESN'T ARBITRARILY
02:27:08.452 --> 02:27:11.489
PICK THIS PARTICULAR PROCESS
02:27:11.556 --> 02:27:12.823
UPON WHICH TO CONDITION THE
02:27:12.890 --> 02:27:16.127
APPEAL CERTAINTY.
02:27:16.194 --> 02:27:18.963
BY IT NOT MANDATING A VERY
02:27:19.030 --> 02:27:20.831
PARTICULAR PRESCRIBED.
02:27:20.898 --> 02:27:22.934
ANALYTICAL PROCESS WE HAVE
02:27:23.000 --> 02:27:24.902
FLEXIBILITY TO WORK WITH ARE
02:27:24.969 --> 02:27:27.305
VERY ROBUST COMMUNITY STANDARDS
02:27:27.371 --> 02:27:28.639
THAT LOOK AT ALL SORTS OF
02:27:28.706 --> 02:27:29.974
DIFFERENT STANDARD.
02:27:30.041 --> 02:27:32.143
LIKE ZERO WASTE --
02:27:32.210 --> 02:27:34.779
LIKE WATER CONSERVATION ALL THE
02:27:34.845 --> 02:27:36.147
THINGS AND AGAIN THANK YOU FOR
02:27:36.214 --> 02:27:38.115
RECOGNIZING HOW SERIOUSLY WE
02:27:38.182 --> 02:27:39.850
TAKE OUR ENVIRONMENTAL
02:27:39.917 --> 02:27:41.852
RESPONSIBILITIES.
02:27:41.919 --> 02:27:43.187
SO THAT IS PART OF MY ARGUMENT
02:27:43.254 --> 02:27:47.391
ON THIS PROVIDES CERTAINTY BUT
02:27:47.458 --> 02:27:51.329
IT ALSO GIVES US THE FLEXIBILITY
02:27:51.395 --> 02:27:52.797
TO DELIVER A COMMUNITY BENEFIT
02:27:52.863 --> 02:27:55.166
PACKAGE THAT IS RESPONSIVE TO
02:27:55.233 --> 02:27:56.334
OUR COMMUNITY.
02:27:56.400 --> 02:27:58.402
AND WE AGAIN BELIEVE THAT WE
02:27:58.469 --> 02:27:59.604
HAVE A TRACK RECORD THAT YOU CAN
02:27:59.670 --> 02:28:01.706
TRUST.
02:28:01.772 --> 02:28:03.441
THAT THIS IS CONSISTENT WITH THE
02:28:03.507 --> 02:28:05.910
INTENT OF AB.
02:28:05.977 --> 02:28:08.012
NINE WITH ALL DUE RESPECT IT'S
02:28:08.079 --> 02:28:09.747
TRUST BUT VERIFY WHEN IT WHEN IT
02:28:09.814 --> 02:28:11.716
COMES TO TO TO ENVIRONMENTAL
02:28:11.782 --> 02:28:13.384
POLICY HERE AND I JUST WHAT HAVE
02:28:13.451 --> 02:28:14.619
YOU LOOKED AT THE COST OF DOING
02:28:14.685 --> 02:28:15.987
THE MATH LIKE IF YOU ACTUALLY
02:28:16.053 --> 02:28:17.121
HAVE YOU GUYS LOOK AND MAYBE
02:28:17.188 --> 02:28:18.289
THIS IS BETTER FOR THE PRESIDENT
02:28:18.356 --> 02:28:18.990
OF THE PROJECT.
02:28:19.056 --> 02:28:20.524
DEVELOPERS BUT IF YOU IF YOU
02:28:20.591 --> 02:28:21.692
WANNA COME UP IN A WAY AND I I
02:28:21.759 --> 02:28:22.660
DON'T WANT.
02:28:22.727 --> 02:28:23.661
TO GET TOO DEEP IN THE WEEDS BUT
02:28:23.728 --> 02:28:25.463
TO ME HERE THE WEEDS MATTER JUST
02:28:25.529 --> 02:28:28.966
IN TERMS OF IS THIS IT IS IF.
02:28:29.033 --> 02:28:30.034
WE DN'T IMPOSE SOMETHING
02:28:30.101 --> 02:28:31.702
ARBITRARY WE DON'T WANT IT
02:28:31.769 --> 02:28:33.037
INHIBIT YOUR FLEXIBILITY A
02:28:33.104 --> 02:28:34.739
CREATIVE HERE THAT'S NOT THE
02:28:34.805 --> 02:28:35.406
THAT THAT'S ABSOLUTE ON THE GOAL
02:28:35.473 --> 02:28:36.907
SO.
02:28:36.974 --> 02:28:38.175
BUT JUST HAVE YOU LOOKED AT THAT.
02:28:38.242 --> 02:28:39.577
WHAT DOES IT DO TO THE PROJECT
02:28:39.644 --> 02:28:41.178
IF YOU IF YOU ADOPT THAT STAND
02:28:41.245 --> 02:28:43.014
SENATOR OUT JUST YUBA PARTNER
02:28:43.080 --> 02:28:44.148
THESE ON THE DEVELOPMENT SIDE OF
02:28:44.215 --> 02:28:45.483
THIS PROJECT?
02:28:45.549 --> 02:28:46.450
OUT WE'RE IN THE PROCESS OF
02:28:46.517 --> 02:28:47.818
LOOKING AT IT AS MERE POINTED
02:28:47.885 --> 02:28:50.388
OUT THAT THE STUDIES THEMSELVES.
02:28:50.454 --> 02:28:52.423
A QUITE COSTLY AND SO THERE IS A
02:28:52.490 --> 02:28:53.791
TRADE OFF TO SPENDING INVESTING
02:28:53.858 --> 02:28:54.992
TIME AND CONSULTANTSWHEN THAT
02:28:55.059 --> 02:28:57.161
MONEY COULD BE INVESTED IN TOO
02:28:57.228 --> 02:28:59.697
COSTLY GIVES IN MILLIONS --
02:28:59.764 --> 02:29:01.799
BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY I THINK TO
02:29:01.866 --> 02:29:03.534
THE MAYOR'S POINT A OAKLAND
02:29:03.601 --> 02:29:05.069
THROUGH THIS CLIMATE ACTION PLAN
02:29:05.136 --> 02:29:06.470
THAT THEY'VE ADOPTED.
02:29:06.537 --> 02:29:07.772
TAKES A CITYWIDE LOOK AT THESE
02:29:07.838 --> 02:29:09.440
ISSUES.
02:29:09.507 --> 02:29:11.709
AND THE CHALLENGE WITH THIS
02:29:11.776 --> 02:29:14.345
SPECIFIC ANALYSIS ON THIS SITE.
02:29:14.412 --> 02:29:15.279
AND LET ME GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE
02:29:15.346 --> 02:29:16.213
OF A RECENT PROJECT THAT WENT
02:29:16.280 --> 02:29:18.049
THROUGH THE ANALYSIS.
02:29:18.115 --> 02:29:19.283
WHICH IS THE WORST PROJECT THE
02:29:19.350 --> 02:29:20.851
WORST PROJECT.
02:29:20.918 --> 02:29:22.887
WAS ABLE TO USE AN EXISTING AND
02:29:22.953 --> 02:29:25.723
SEVEN TITLE MINCE ON THE SITE
02:29:25.790 --> 02:29:26.324
THAT THEY'RE MOVING TO IN SAN
02:29:26.390 --> 02:29:29.226
FRANCISCO AS A BASELINE AGAINST
02:29:29.293 --> 02:29:30.661
WHICH TO COMPARE.
02:29:30.728 --> 02:29:32.997
THE GHG IMPACTS OF AN ARENA.
02:29:33.064 --> 02:29:34.765
AND THE ENTITLEMENTS EXISTED ON
02:29:34.832 --> 02:29:37.001
THAT SITE FOR FOR A MILLION FEET
02:29:37.068 --> 02:29:39.036
OF OFFICE DEVELOPMENT.
02:29:39.103 --> 02:29:40.604
SO WHEN THEY NOW ANALYZED AND
02:29:40.671 --> 02:29:42.173
ARENA AGAINST THEM MILLION FEET
02:29:42.239 --> 02:29:43.708
THEY WILL BE ABLE TO FIND THAT
02:29:43.774 --> 02:29:45.109
THEIR IMPACT YOU'RE GOING UP
02:29:45.176 --> 02:29:46.677
AGAINST YOUR ONLY COSTED RIGHT
02:29:46.744 --> 02:29:47.211
COST FOUR HUNDRED THOUSAND
02:29:47.278 --> 02:29:48.612
DOLLARS.
02:29:48.679 --> 02:29:49.780
IN THIS CASE WE DON'T HAVE AN
02:29:49.847 --> 02:29:51.916
APPROVED BASELINE DEVELOPMENT
02:29:51.982 --> 02:29:53.017
PLAN FOR HOWARD TERMINAL IT'S A
02:29:53.084 --> 02:29:54.518
PARKING.
02:29:54.585 --> 02:29:57.154
AND SO WERE PENALIZED FOR THAT
02:29:57.221 --> 02:29:58.422
WENT IT BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE
02:29:58.489 --> 02:30:01.492
WHOLE CD. FOR EXAMPLE RIGHT NEXT
02:30:01.559 --> 02:30:02.793
DOOR THERE'S THAT A DIESEL FIRED
02:30:02.860 --> 02:30:04.962
PEAK.
02:30:05.029 --> 02:30:06.597
A HUNDRED FORTY FIVE MEGAWATT
02:30:06.664 --> 02:30:08.265
PEAK OF THAT OUR PROJECT IS
02:30:08.332 --> 02:30:10.701
GONNA HELP BECAUSE TO GET --
02:30:10.768 --> 02:30:12.236
CONVERTED TO A RENEWED RENEWABLE
02:30:12.303 --> 02:30:13.871
ENERGY PROJECTS THEREBY LOWERING
02:30:13.938 --> 02:30:15.272
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS MORE
02:30:15.339 --> 02:30:16.440
THAN WE WOULD EVER IMAGINE THAT
02:30:16.507 --> 02:30:18.209
ARE PROJECTS SPECIFIC.
02:30:18.275 --> 02:30:18.843
HOWEVER WE CANNOT GET CREDIT FOR
02:30:18.909 --> 02:30:20.411
THAT.
02:30:20.478 --> 02:30:21.212
BECAUSE OF THAT WE'RE WE'RE
02:30:21.278 --> 02:30:22.947
REQUIRED LITTLE BECAUSE IT'S
02:30:23.013 --> 02:30:23.914
ONLY SITE DRIVEN THAT THEY ARE
02:30:23.981 --> 02:30:26.050
GAY SENT BUT IS NOT WITHIN OUR
02:30:26.117 --> 02:30:27.985
SITE MAYBE THAT'S SOMETHING.
02:30:28.052 --> 02:30:28.819
THAT IS SOMETHING WE COULD
02:30:28.886 --> 02:30:30.287
CONSIDER WE'VE ALSO TALKED ABOUT
02:30:30.354 --> 02:30:32.156
THE FACT MERE REFERENCE.
02:30:32.223 --> 02:30:34.792
OUR STADIUM ITSELF WILL BE.
02:30:34.859 --> 02:30:36.293
SOMEWHERE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD OF
02:30:36.360 --> 02:30:38.062
25% OR LESS IN TERMS OF TOTAL
02:30:38.129 --> 02:30:39.830
CAPACITY EXISTING COLISEUM.
02:30:39.897 --> 02:30:41.599
HOW DO WE GET CREDIT FOR THAT?
02:30:41.665 --> 02:30:43.334
SO I THINK WHAT WE'RE SAYING IS
02:30:43.401 --> 02:30:45.703
IT YOU TAKE A SCALPEL TO THIS
02:30:45.770 --> 02:30:47.538
IT'S NOT IT IT IT IT'S YEAH THE
02:30:47.605 --> 02:30:48.205
BLUNT INSTRUMENT OF THE
02:30:48.272 --> 02:30:49.373
FRAMEWORK THAT.
02:30:49.440 --> 02:30:50.875
WE WERE WORKING WITH.
02:30:50.941 --> 02:30:52.276
UNDER AB NINE HUNDRED DIDN'T
02:30:52.343 --> 02:30:53.177
WORK BUT THERE MAY BE AN
02:30:53.244 --> 02:30:54.678
ALTERNATE WAY TO APPROACH IT YET
02:30:54.745 --> 02:30:57.415
I WONDER IF WITH STILL WITH THAT
02:30:57.481 --> 02:30:59.150
ZERO NET GOAL BUT NOT BEING AS
02:30:59.216 --> 02:31:00.418
CONSTRAINTS STILL TRYING TO
02:31:00.484 --> 02:31:01.719
DELIVER THOSE EMISSIONS
02:31:01.786 --> 02:31:03.354
REDUCTION BENEFIT LOCALLY RIGHT
02:31:03.421 --> 02:31:04.989
I MEAN I THINK WHEN WE WE WENT
02:31:05.055 --> 02:31:05.289
THROUGH --
02:31:05.356 --> 02:31:07.358
AB THREE NINETY EIGHT LAST YEAR
02:31:07.425 --> 02:31:08.292
AND THAT'S A BIG PART OF NOW
02:31:08.359 --> 02:31:10.327
THAT YOU CAP AND TRADE PROGRAM
02:31:10.394 --> 02:31:11.295
RIGHT WE WANT.
02:31:11.362 --> 02:31:14.165
DIRECT LOCAL EMISSIONS FIRST.
02:31:14.231 --> 02:31:15.433
THAT KIND OF POWER PLANT
02:31:15.499 --> 02:31:16.801
CONVERSION I MEAN THOSE ARE
02:31:16.867 --> 02:31:18.302
EXACTLY THE KINDS OF THINGS WERE
02:31:18.369 --> 02:31:19.203
ANTICIPATING SO.
02:31:19.270 --> 02:31:20.805
AND I'M I'M OPEN TO THAT
02:31:20.871 --> 02:31:21.705
DISCUSSION I JUST WANTED TO
02:31:21.772 --> 02:31:23.340
RAISE THE ISSUE AND AND BUT I
02:31:23.407 --> 02:31:24.275
ALSO.
02:31:24.341 --> 02:31:25.843
I'M NOT I DON'T WANT TO GET IN
02:31:25.910 --> 02:31:27.812
THE WAY OF OAKLAND BEING OPEN
02:31:27.878 --> 02:31:29.580
AND HAVING THIS TEAM SO I YOU
02:31:29.647 --> 02:31:31.048
KNOW THAT.
02:31:31.115 --> 02:31:34.618
ALL OF NEW MYSELF AT THAT
02:31:34.685 --> 02:31:34.919
[inaudible]
02:31:34.985 --> 02:31:42.760
OR IS BACK --
02:31:42.827 --> 02:31:44.929
CENTER LARA THINK YOU THINK YOU --
02:31:44.995 --> 02:31:46.497
I THINK IT'S FITTING I'M WEARING
02:31:46.564 --> 02:31:48.699
MY BLUE SUIT TODAY --
02:31:48.766 --> 02:31:50.000
OTHER THOUGHT DODGER BLUE BUT
02:31:50.067 --> 02:31:52.336
YEAH CITY ORANGE HURRY AND OR
02:31:52.403 --> 02:31:53.404
YOU KNOW WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU
02:31:53.471 --> 02:31:55.473
HAVE A DODGER FANS GIANTS FANS
02:31:55.539 --> 02:31:57.575
AND HIS FRIENDS IN ONE ROOM
02:31:57.641 --> 02:31:59.810
THAT'S REALLY INTERESTING --
02:31:59.877 --> 02:32:00.744
I I WANT TO ASK MY QUESTION IS
02:32:00.811 --> 02:32:02.046
AROUND AB NINE HUNDRED OBVIOUSLY
02:32:02.112 --> 02:32:03.113
WE'VE AND I MIGHT HAVE MISSED
02:32:03.180 --> 02:32:04.014
SOME OF THE SOME OF THE
02:32:04.081 --> 02:32:04.915
CONVERSATION.
02:32:04.982 --> 02:32:06.951
EARLIER BECAUSE THE CRAZINESS OF
02:32:07.017 --> 02:32:09.487
THE DAY BUT I WANT TO KNOW.
02:32:09.553 --> 02:32:11.355
SO WE DID AB.
02:32:11.422 --> 02:32:12.456
NINE HUNDRED WHY CAN'T YOU WORK
02:32:12.523 --> 02:32:15.059
WITHIN THE PARAMETERS OF AB.
02:32:15.125 --> 02:32:16.093
NINE HUNDRED I'D JUST TO CLARIFY
02:32:16.160 --> 02:32:16.393
FOR ME -- AS
02:32:16.460 --> 02:32:18.295
I'M.
02:32:18.362 --> 02:32:21.699
TRAFFIC NOT A DECISION HERE.
02:32:21.765 --> 02:32:25.870
HE SAID THIRTY THREE THINGS I'M.
02:32:25.936 --> 02:32:27.071
A FIRST AB NINE HUNDRED EXPIRES
02:32:27.137 --> 02:32:28.572
IN.
02:32:28.639 --> 02:32:29.173
TWENTY TWENTY ONE AND WE NEED
02:32:29.240 --> 02:32:30.774
ARM.
02:32:30.841 --> 02:32:32.910
A A PLAN IN PLACE THAT GOES
02:32:32.977 --> 02:32:33.210
[inaudible]
02:32:33.277 --> 02:32:34.578
TO TWENTY TWENTY FOUR SECOND.
02:32:34.645 --> 02:32:37.081
WE DON'T THINK THAT AS WAS JUST
02:32:37.147 --> 02:32:40.284
DISCUSSED THAT THE THE NET ZERO
02:32:40.351 --> 02:32:42.620
GHG EMISSIONS COMPONENT WORKS
02:32:42.686 --> 02:32:43.988
BECAUSE OF THE OF THE VACANT
02:32:44.054 --> 02:32:45.589
SITE THAT THAT WE HAVE AND HOW
02:32:45.656 --> 02:32:46.891
TROUBLE THAT ESSENTIALLY
02:32:46.957 --> 02:32:47.725
GENERALLY KNOW JAKE SHE'S IT
02:32:47.791 --> 02:32:48.792
WE'RE GONNA ACTIVATE THE SITE
02:32:48.859 --> 02:32:50.628
IT'S GONNA GENERATE GHGS.
02:32:50.694 --> 02:32:52.162
IT'S IT'S HARD TO BE NEUTRAL
02:32:52.229 --> 02:32:52.796
EVEN THOUGH WE'RE PUTTING A LOT
02:32:52.863 --> 02:32:53.998
OF OTHER.
02:32:54.064 --> 02:32:55.533
OF ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS AND
02:32:55.599 --> 02:32:57.101
THEN THIRD WE'RE GONNA BE WITH
02:32:57.167 --> 02:32:58.836
COMMITTEE LEAD GOLD FOR AT THE
02:32:58.903 --> 02:33:02.673
STADIUM AND ALL OF THAT --
02:33:02.740 --> 02:33:04.241
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT BUT
02:33:04.308 --> 02:33:04.842
REALLY WANT TO STAY LEADS OVER
02:33:04.909 --> 02:33:05.442
FOR THE RESIDENTS [inaudible]
02:33:05.509 --> 02:33:08.012
GOT IT IT WAS THE THREE ITEMS.
02:33:08.078 --> 02:33:10.381
SO YOU KNOW AGAIN RECOGNIZING
02:33:10.447 --> 02:33:12.283
OAKLAND HAS BEEN.
02:33:12.349 --> 02:33:13.817
FAR MORE INNOVATIVE WHEN IT
02:33:13.884 --> 02:33:15.019
COMES TO MEETING OUR TIME A
02:33:15.085 --> 02:33:16.220
CHANGE BECAUSE I WANT TO THANK
02:33:16.287 --> 02:33:17.988
YOU MAYOR FOR FOR THE WORK THAT
02:33:18.055 --> 02:33:18.689
YOU'VE DONE.
02:33:18.756 --> 02:33:20.758
OUT WE RECOGNIZE THAT IN THE
02:33:20.824 --> 02:33:21.091
STATE.
02:33:21.158 --> 02:33:22.459
OUR AND YOUR LEADERSHIP ON A
02:33:22.526 --> 02:33:24.161
WHOLE HOST OF OTHER ISSUES THAT
02:33:24.228 --> 02:33:25.996
ARE CRITICAL --
02:33:26.063 --> 02:33:28.165
NOW MORE THAN EVER AS WE EMBARK
02:33:28.232 --> 02:33:29.733
ON THIS NEW.
02:33:29.800 --> 02:33:31.802
ERA WITH THIS PRESIDENT BUT I I
02:33:31.869 --> 02:33:33.571
WANTED.
02:33:33.637 --> 02:33:36.707
TO ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT YOU KNOW.
02:33:36.774 --> 02:33:39.410
A PROJECT OF THIS NATURE --
02:33:39.476 --> 02:33:41.779
AND YOU BEING HERE IT IS SPEAKS
02:33:41.845 --> 02:33:42.846
VOLUMES GIVEN.
02:33:42.913 --> 02:33:45.182
I KNOW OAKLAND.
02:33:45.249 --> 02:33:46.684
I KNOW WHAT THE RESIDENTS DEMAND
02:33:46.750 --> 02:33:48.152
IN ANOTHER THAN A REQUIRE THAT
02:33:48.218 --> 02:33:49.720
YOU MEET.
02:33:49.787 --> 02:33:51.322
VERY STRICT ENVIRONMENTAL
02:33:51.388 --> 02:33:54.325
GUIDELINES AND WOOD JUST SAY.
02:33:54.391 --> 02:33:56.093
USE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO BE AS
02:33:56.160 --> 02:33:57.628
INNOVATIVE AS POSSIBLE.
02:33:57.695 --> 02:33:58.963
TRAVELED ALL OVER THE WORLD AND
02:33:59.029 --> 02:34:00.631
LOOK AT WHAT'S STADIUMS HAVE
02:34:00.698 --> 02:34:02.299
DONE TO USE RECYCLED WATER.
02:34:02.366 --> 02:34:04.535
A FURTHER PITCH --
02:34:04.602 --> 02:34:08.405
USED VERY IT AND FOR THEIR
02:34:08.472 --> 02:34:11.275
FACILITIES AS WELL [inaudible]
02:34:11.342 --> 02:34:14.178
PUT US.
02:34:14.244 --> 02:34:15.446
AND AS AN EXAMPLE FOR THE REST
02:34:15.512 --> 02:34:17.014
THE WORLD FOLLOW AND AS WE
02:34:17.081 --> 02:34:18.248
CONTINUE TO HAVE THESE
02:34:18.315 --> 02:34:19.483
DISCUSSIONS.
02:34:19.550 --> 02:34:21.051
ARE I THINK YOU DO HAVE AN
02:34:21.118 --> 02:34:22.553
ARGUMENT FOR WHY.
02:34:22.620 --> 02:34:23.554
YOU KNOW YOU COULDN'T WORK
02:34:23.621 --> 02:34:25.556
WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF AB NINE
02:34:25.623 --> 02:34:26.690
HUNDRED THAT MAKES IT UNIQUE.
02:34:26.757 --> 02:34:28.859
ARE AND SO YOU KNOW I THINK YOU
02:34:28.926 --> 02:34:30.527
YOU BILL THE GUARD HIM AND OF
02:34:30.594 --> 02:34:31.996
COURSE --
02:34:32.062 --> 02:34:33.163
BICU KNOWS IS THE DE DODGER
02:34:33.230 --> 02:34:35.733
FANS WILL INTO TO CAST A VOTE TO
02:34:35.799 --> 02:34:36.967
SUPPORT --
02:34:37.034 --> 02:34:37.768
BECAUSE THE STADIUM OF THIS
02:34:37.835 --> 02:34:39.036
NATURE BECAUSE I GIVE AND I KNOW
02:34:39.103 --> 02:34:40.938
THAT THE COMMUNITY --
02:34:41.005 --> 02:34:42.439
IS GONNA HOLD YOU ACCOUNTABLE.
02:34:42.506 --> 02:34:44.141
OF THE BALKAN RESIDENTS ARE
02:34:44.208 --> 02:34:45.509
GONNA HOLD YOU ACCOUNTABLE.
02:34:45.576 --> 02:34:46.877
NOT TO MAKE SURE THAT THIS IS
02:34:46.944 --> 02:34:48.812
SOMETHING THAT IS THAT MEETS THE
02:34:48.879 --> 02:34:50.614
GOALS OF OUR CLIMATE CHANGE AND
02:34:50.681 --> 02:34:51.248
AGAIN.
02:34:51.315 --> 02:34:52.750
UNDERSTANDING THE WORK THAT YOU
02:34:52.816 --> 02:34:55.052
ALREADY HAVE DONE AS A CITY TO
02:34:55.119 --> 02:34:56.754
TRY TO MEET OUR GOALS.
02:34:56.820 --> 02:34:57.955
IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S LOT OF ONE
02:34:58.022 --> 02:34:59.556
I WISH OTHER CITIES WHAT WOULD
02:34:59.623 --> 02:35:01.492
TAKE PARTICULARLY ON THAT SO --
02:35:01.558 --> 02:35:02.660
I'M PREPARED TO SUPPORT NEED
02:35:02.726 --> 02:35:03.894
TODAY THANK YOU [inaudible]
02:35:03.961 --> 02:35:04.428
CENTER SKINNER [inaudible]
02:35:04.495 --> 02:35:05.195
THANK YOU.
02:35:05.262 --> 02:35:07.464
I'M SO APPRECIATE MY COLLEAGUE
02:35:07.531 --> 02:35:09.066
FROM BELL GARDENS COMMENTS IS
02:35:09.133 --> 02:35:10.401
NOW IN --
02:35:10.467 --> 02:35:12.970
AND OTHERS THAT.
02:35:13.037 --> 02:35:14.672
EVEN NINE HUNDRED WAS A GREAT
02:35:14.738 --> 02:35:16.807
BILL AND IT --
02:35:16.874 --> 02:35:18.575
IT YOU KNOW IT TRIED
02:35:18.642 --> 02:35:20.110
LEGITIMATELY TO SET SOME
02:35:20.177 --> 02:35:22.112
STANDARDS. FOR FOR OUR
02:35:22.179 --> 02:35:24.314
STREAMLINING PROCESS BUT AS
02:35:24.381 --> 02:35:26.116
WE'VE HEARD IN THIS DISCUSSION
02:35:26.183 --> 02:35:27.818
THIS IS A UNIQUE PROJECT THIS
02:35:27.885 --> 02:35:30.287
STADIUM WOULD REPLACE A STADIUM.
02:35:30.354 --> 02:35:32.489
THAT CURRENTLY HAS A MUCH LARGER
02:35:32.556 --> 02:35:35.059
FOOTPRINT BECAUSE IT IS MUCH
02:35:35.125 --> 02:35:35.793
MUCH BIGGER.
02:35:35.859 --> 02:35:36.727
NOW.
02:35:36.794 --> 02:35:38.729
THE THE TRANSPORTATION ISSUES
02:35:38.796 --> 02:35:40.998
COULD FACTOR IN THIS STADIUM IF
02:35:41.065 --> 02:35:43.767
IF THE SITE IS NOT --
02:35:43.834 --> 02:35:46.103
THE COLISEUM SITE THEN THERE.
02:35:46.170 --> 02:35:47.271
THERE'S SOME TRANSPORTATION
02:35:47.337 --> 02:35:48.739
ISSUES THAT COULD BE TRICKY BUT
02:35:48.806 --> 02:35:51.475
REQUIRING THE WHOLE PROJECT. TO
02:35:51.542 --> 02:35:53.110
BE LEAD GOLD FOR EXAMPLE WON'T
02:35:53.177 --> 02:35:54.645
NECESSARILY ADDRESS THOSE IN
02:35:54.712 --> 02:35:56.313
THIS IS WHERE.
02:35:56.380 --> 02:35:58.082
I THINK THAT THE ART LEAD
02:35:58.148 --> 02:35:59.283
STANDARD REMEMBER WAS NOT BUILT
02:35:59.349 --> 02:36:00.918
BY THE STATE.
02:36:00.984 --> 02:36:03.153
IT WAS A PRIVATE ENTITY THAT
02:36:03.220 --> 02:36:05.055
DEVELOPED LEAD STANDARDS.
02:36:05.122 --> 02:36:07.458
AND LEAP IS IT'S A GREAT TOOL
02:36:07.524 --> 02:36:08.525
BUT IT IS THE NOISE FACTOR
02:36:08.592 --> 02:36:09.660
EVERYTHING IN YOU CAN
02:36:09.727 --> 02:36:11.395
POTENTIALLY MEET LEAD FOR A
02:36:11.462 --> 02:36:11.662
BUILDING.
02:36:11.729 --> 02:36:14.298
AND STILL INCREASED GHG
02:36:14.364 --> 02:36:16.734
EMISSIONS SO --
02:36:16.800 --> 02:36:20.237
I'M NOT READY TO JUST IMPOSE A
02:36:20.304 --> 02:36:21.538
LEADS THE AYE HIGHER LEAD
02:36:21.605 --> 02:36:23.574
STANDARD ON THE REST THE PROJECT
02:36:23.640 --> 02:36:23.941
NOW.
02:36:24.007 --> 02:36:25.743
I WOULD BE --
02:36:25.809 --> 02:36:28.145
INTERESTED IN AND I KNOW THAT
02:36:28.212 --> 02:36:29.179
CITY ALREADY HAS STRONG GOALS
02:36:29.246 --> 02:36:31.682
AND SUCH THE PROJECT ITSELF.
02:36:31.749 --> 02:36:33.817
COMMITTING TO SOME KIND OF
02:36:33.884 --> 02:36:36.487
HIGHER GHG MITIGATION.
02:36:36.553 --> 02:36:38.422
DOESN'T HAVE TO BE IN THE
02:36:38.489 --> 02:36:40.224
BUILDINGS OF COURSE BUT IN AS
02:36:40.290 --> 02:36:42.326
WAS DISCUSSED IT COULD IMPACT
02:36:42.392 --> 02:36:43.393
THIS --
02:36:43.460 --> 02:36:47.030
PICKER PLANT SO SO HAVING THE
02:36:47.097 --> 02:36:49.166
THE DEVELOPERS THE PROPONENTS
02:36:49.233 --> 02:36:50.567
THE IT THE WHOLE THING.
02:36:50.634 --> 02:36:54.505
ON HAVING A COMMITMENT TO A TO A
02:36:54.571 --> 02:36:56.607
TO SOME.
02:36:56.673 --> 02:36:58.642
THE MORE THAN [inaudible]
02:36:58.709 --> 02:37:00.911
QUANTITATIVE.
02:37:00.978 --> 02:37:02.913
G. H. GENE EARNED THEIR WHICH IS
02:37:02.980 --> 02:37:04.882
INDEPENDENT OF WHAT THE GHG
02:37:04.948 --> 02:37:06.383
FOOTPRINT IS UP THE EXISTING
02:37:06.450 --> 02:37:08.919
STADIUM BECAUSE THERE WERE YOU
02:37:08.986 --> 02:37:09.720
KNOW THERE'S APPLES AND ORANGES.
02:37:09.787 --> 02:37:10.954
BUT SOMETHING ABOUT HOW THIS
02:37:11.021 --> 02:37:12.890
PROCEEDS I THINK THAT WOULD BE
02:37:12.956 --> 02:37:13.657
HELPFUL.
02:37:13.724 --> 02:37:16.293
BUT I THINK IT'S TO HARD PRESSED
02:37:16.360 --> 02:37:17.628
TO DO IT HERE AND JUST
02:37:17.694 --> 02:37:19.963
ARBITRARILY REQUIRING ELITE
02:37:20.030 --> 02:37:21.999
STANDARD BECAUSE THAT DOESN'T
02:37:22.065 --> 02:37:24.034
CAPTURE IT QUITE --
02:37:24.101 --> 02:37:26.136
ESPECIALLY WHEN FOR EXAMPLE THAT
02:37:26.203 --> 02:37:28.071
WOULD NEED BEEN IMPACT THE
02:37:28.138 --> 02:37:29.573
BIGGER PLANT THAT'S NEXT DOOR
02:37:29.640 --> 02:37:32.709
WHEREAS THE SOME TYPE OF GHG
02:37:32.776 --> 02:37:33.644
COMMITMENT COULD BE MET
02:37:33.710 --> 02:37:33.944
[inaudible]
02:37:34.011 --> 02:37:35.445
THROUGH.
02:37:35.512 --> 02:37:38.315
THINGS THAT ARE NOT.
02:37:38.382 --> 02:37:40.484
SOLELY AND ONLY ON THE SITE
02:37:40.551 --> 02:37:44.955
RIGHT SO ANYWAY SO --
02:37:45.022 --> 02:37:46.857
THAT MAY NOT BE AN AMENDMENT
02:37:46.924 --> 02:37:48.692
THAT WE COULD TAKE TODAY THEN IT
02:37:48.759 --> 02:37:50.894
MAY BE JUST A COMMITMENT WE ASK.
02:37:50.961 --> 02:37:54.665
FOR A BUT I THINK THE AS I
02:37:54.731 --> 02:37:56.867
INDICATED EARLIER I'M WILLING TO
02:37:56.934 --> 02:37:58.936
SUPPORT THE BILL AND I'M WILLING
02:37:59.002 --> 02:38:00.170
TO MAKE THE MOTION.
02:38:00.237 --> 02:38:02.439
WHO LEFT AND LET THE CHAIR BE?
02:38:02.506 --> 02:38:04.708
BECAUSE I APOLOGIZE FOR ACTUALLY
02:38:04.775 --> 02:38:05.275
HAVE A COUPLE BILLS HAVE TO
02:38:05.342 --> 02:38:06.877
PRESENT.
02:38:06.944 --> 02:38:08.645
ARE WE TALKING ABOUT AN
02:38:08.712 --> 02:38:10.414
EQUIVALENT AND SEE.
02:38:10.480 --> 02:38:12.683
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS LEVELS
02:38:12.749 --> 02:38:15.152
TO THE A. B. NINE HUNDRED OR WE
02:38:15.219 --> 02:38:17.454
TALKING ABOUT SOME OTHER LEVEL
02:38:17.521 --> 02:38:19.022
OF OF GREENHOUSE GAS
02:38:19.089 --> 02:38:19.323
[inaudible]
02:38:19.389 --> 02:38:22.726
YOU LOOKING AT THE BASELINE AT
02:38:22.793 --> 02:38:24.428
THAT CURRENT POLICY AND WHAT.
02:38:24.494 --> 02:38:26.697
ARE IN YOUR MIND THAT WHAT WE
02:38:26.763 --> 02:38:27.931
WHAT WE WHICH SHOULD THAT THOSE
02:38:27.998 --> 02:38:29.066
BECAUSE THOSE ARE TWO DIFFERENT
02:38:29.132 --> 02:38:30.868
THINGS TO WE GO BACK TO WHAT THE
02:38:30.934 --> 02:38:32.269
WHAT THE BASELINE IS.
02:38:32.336 --> 02:38:34.471
AN ESTABLISHED THAT IN IN NINE
02:38:34.538 --> 02:38:35.973
HUNDRED IT'S LOOKING 415%
02:38:36.039 --> 02:38:39.343
IMPROVEMENT ON THAT SU WHAT.
02:38:39.409 --> 02:38:40.644
AGAIN I APOLOGIZE BECAUSE I
02:38:40.711 --> 02:38:41.678
MISSED A LOT OF THAT THIS GREAT
02:38:41.745 --> 02:38:43.380
SURE WAS ANIMATED I THINK THE
02:38:43.447 --> 02:38:44.681
WOULD LIKE I'D LIKE TO HEAR FROM
02:38:44.748 --> 02:38:50.520
THE OPPONENTS.
02:38:50.587 --> 02:38:51.889
IF IT'S AROUND.
02:38:51.955 --> 02:38:55.692
IF IT'S A AND NOW YOU STAVING
02:38:55.759 --> 02:38:55.993
[inaudible]
02:38:56.059 --> 02:38:58.562
NINE HUNDRED BUT THE FLEXIBILITY
02:38:58.629 --> 02:39:00.831
TO IMMEDIATE.
02:39:00.898 --> 02:39:02.466
WITH KNOWING THAT THE PROJECT
02:39:02.532 --> 02:39:04.134
COULD IMPACT FOR EXAMPLE THAT
02:39:04.201 --> 02:39:05.869
PETER PLANT NEXT DOOR WHICH LEAD
02:39:05.936 --> 02:39:07.371
THE WAY EIGHTY NINE HUNDRED IS
02:39:07.437 --> 02:39:09.206
CONSTRUCTED THAT WOULDN'T COUNT.
02:39:09.273 --> 02:39:12.509
RIGHT SO SO IF WE CAN
02:39:12.576 --> 02:39:13.777
CONCEPTUALIZE IT THAT WAY I
02:39:13.844 --> 02:39:16.346
THINK IT'S ACHIEVABLE BUT I'D
02:39:16.413 --> 02:39:19.249
LIKE TO HEAR FROM THEM.
02:39:19.316 --> 02:39:20.717
A SIMILAR BONTA YOUR WITNESSES
02:39:20.784 --> 02:39:22.219
YEAH -- I
02:39:22.286 --> 02:39:25.489
WOULD SUBMIT CHAIR THAT --
02:39:25.555 --> 02:39:29.459
CITY'S
02:39:29.526 --> 02:39:30.594
OF THE CITY WILL BE THE LEAD
02:39:30.661 --> 02:39:31.828
AGENCY UNDER SEQUEL.
02:39:31.895 --> 02:39:34.231
OF FOR THIS PROJECT --
02:39:34.298 --> 02:39:35.866
AND I THINK IT HAS THE ABILITY
02:39:35.933 --> 02:39:38.702
TO LOOK AT ON THE ADJACENT USES
02:39:38.769 --> 02:39:41.305
AND THE CLIMATE IMPACTS FROM
02:39:41.371 --> 02:39:43.006
THINGS LIKE REDUCING.
02:39:43.073 --> 02:39:45.976
ON THE THE GREENHOUSE GASES FROM
02:39:46.043 --> 02:39:47.044
CONVERTING A PEAK A PLANT TO
02:39:47.110 --> 02:39:48.045
RENEWAL ENERGY.
02:39:48.111 --> 02:39:49.913
PROJECT WITHOUT.
02:39:49.980 --> 02:39:51.949
BEING BEHOLDEN TO THE ON KIND OF
02:39:52.015 --> 02:39:53.884
NARROW PARAMETERS THAT EXIST
02:39:53.951 --> 02:39:55.485
UNDER AB NINE HUNDRED WHERE YOU
02:39:55.552 --> 02:39:57.187
HAVE TO DO A SITE SPECIFIC.
02:39:57.254 --> 02:39:59.690
ANALYSIS TO KIND OF MAKE THE GHQ
02:39:59.756 --> 02:40:00.490
FINDING.
02:40:00.557 --> 02:40:02.159
ON WE CAN'T DO THAT ON HOWARD
02:40:02.225 --> 02:40:03.393
TERMINAL ITSELF BECAUSE WE'RE
02:40:03.460 --> 02:40:04.494
BURDEN BY THE FACT THAT THERE'S
02:40:04.561 --> 02:40:05.562
NO BASELINE TO COMPARE IT
02:40:05.629 --> 02:40:06.697
AGAINST.
02:40:06.763 --> 02:40:08.398
I HAVE FOR AN EXISTING.
02:40:08.465 --> 02:40:09.900
SO I'M I'M SAYING THAT.
02:40:09.967 --> 02:40:12.135
GIVEN THE CITY'S FRAMEWORK FOR
02:40:12.202 --> 02:40:13.570
HOW IT LOOKS IT CRAP CLIMATE
02:40:13.637 --> 02:40:15.305
IMPACTS CITYWIDE THAT THERE'S AN
02:40:15.372 --> 02:40:16.840
ABILITY FOR THEM AND YOU HAVE TO
02:40:16.907 --> 02:40:17.975
DO AN AIR QUALITY ANALYSIS
02:40:18.041 --> 02:40:19.343
THROUGH ANY AYE ARE ANYWAY.
02:40:19.409 --> 02:40:21.511
TAKE ALL THAT INTO CONSIDERATION
02:40:21.578 --> 02:40:22.813
CAN GET OUR PRICE I MEAN ONE OF
02:40:22.879 --> 02:40:24.915
THE CONCERNS IS DOUBLE COUNTING
02:40:24.982 --> 02:40:25.983
BECAUSE YOU KNOW IF THE PICKER
02:40:26.049 --> 02:40:27.718
PLAN COMES OFF LINE THOSE PEOPLE
02:40:27.784 --> 02:40:29.453
GET CREDIT FOR THE EMISSION
02:40:29.519 --> 02:40:32.222
REDUCTION AND AND WERE.
02:40:32.289 --> 02:40:34.257
WERE SAYING IS IT.
02:40:34.324 --> 02:40:35.492
YOU KNOW WE CAN'T HAVE PEOPLE WE
02:40:35.559 --> 02:40:37.127
CAN HAVE YOUR FACILITY I MEAN
02:40:37.194 --> 02:40:39.129
THAT THAT IS CITY BENEFITS AT A
02:40:39.196 --> 02:40:40.797
AND THAT LEVEL BUT WE CAN'T HAVE.
02:40:40.864 --> 02:40:41.565
WE'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO HAVE
02:40:41.631 --> 02:40:43.433
DOUBLE COUNTING IF WE DO THAT
02:40:43.500 --> 02:40:44.735
LET'S BE OPEN ABOUT IT AND SAY
02:40:44.801 --> 02:40:45.936
WE'RE GONNA COUNT WE GET YOUR
02:40:46.003 --> 02:40:47.104
CREDIT CARD A CREDIT DEAR
02:40:47.170 --> 02:40:48.405
BECAUSE WE THINK THAT THERE'S
02:40:48.472 --> 02:40:51.108
OVERRIDING BENEFITS.
02:40:51.174 --> 02:40:53.577
SO THAT'S THAT'S WHAT I'M
02:40:53.643 --> 02:40:55.045
TALKING ABOUT I GUESS YOU KNOW
02:40:55.112 --> 02:40:57.381
WE'VE I'VE HAD SOME DISCUSSIONS
02:40:57.447 --> 02:40:58.715
YOU KNOW THERE'S SAID THERE'S A
02:40:58.782 --> 02:41:00.484
DIFFERENCE OF OPINION OF WHERE
02:41:00.550 --> 02:41:02.152
THE BASELINE IS YOU KNOW THE
02:41:02.219 --> 02:41:03.987
BASELINE TO MY ANALYSIS AND
02:41:04.054 --> 02:41:05.188
STAFF ANALYSIS IS AT THE OAKLAND
02:41:05.255 --> 02:41:06.056
COLISEUM.
02:41:06.123 --> 02:41:08.291
THAT'S THE BEAST Y. ANALYSIS FOR
02:41:08.358 --> 02:41:10.394
HOW MANY TRANSIT STOPS WE HAVE
02:41:10.460 --> 02:41:12.996
WHAT'S THE THE I MEAN I'VE I'VE
02:41:13.063 --> 02:41:14.364
BEEN INSIDE THIS AND THE
02:41:14.431 --> 02:41:15.799
COLISEUM SEVERAL TIMES FOR BALL
02:41:15.866 --> 02:41:17.534
GAMES SO I SORT OF KNOW THE
02:41:17.601 --> 02:41:19.369
BEAUTY OF THE FACILITY.
02:41:19.436 --> 02:41:21.304
NOW IF YOU IF YOU HAVE.
02:41:21.371 --> 02:41:22.039
IF THE IF THEY'RE ANY GOOD YOU
02:41:22.105 --> 02:41:23.440
KNOW YOU CAR REALLY TOUCH THE
02:41:23.507 --> 02:41:25.542
PLAYERS HONEST TO GOD IT'S THAT
02:41:25.609 --> 02:41:29.179
EXACT CLOTHES SO SO THAT IS.
02:41:29.246 --> 02:41:31.381
I'M SURE THAT YOU WOULD EXPLAIN
02:41:31.448 --> 02:41:32.983
THOSE BENEFITS WOULD WHAT WE'RE
02:41:33.050 --> 02:41:35.118
TRYING OUR I THINK.
02:41:35.185 --> 02:41:36.353
WHAT DISCUSSIONS GOINGS ON THAT
02:41:36.420 --> 02:41:38.655
ELEMENT HOW WE QUANTIFY THAT HOW
02:41:38.722 --> 02:41:39.890
DO WE MAKE SURE WE DON'T YOU
02:41:39.956 --> 02:41:41.091
KNOW SO WITH THAT WE KNOW THAT
02:41:41.158 --> 02:41:43.060
WE GET TO SOME?
02:41:43.126 --> 02:41:44.694
UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THE WHAT
02:41:44.761 --> 02:41:45.862
THE BASELINE GREENHOUSE GAS
02:41:45.929 --> 02:41:47.330
EMISSIONS FOR THE OLD STADIUM
02:41:47.397 --> 02:41:48.999
AND THAT TRANSIT IN YET ANOTHER
02:41:49.066 --> 02:41:50.934
THAT WHATEVER THAT IS IN AND IF
02:41:51.001 --> 02:41:52.769
THE NEW FACILITY IS RIGHT AT THE
02:41:52.836 --> 02:41:53.970
COLISEUM.
02:41:54.037 --> 02:41:55.906
CLEAR TO ME THAT IF IT'S GOLD
02:41:55.972 --> 02:41:56.606
FROM.
02:41:56.673 --> 02:41:57.441
WHATEVER IT IS IT'S GOING TO BE
02:41:57.507 --> 02:42:00.811
LESS THAN WHETHER YOU CAN.
02:42:00.877 --> 02:42:03.713
MEAN THAT'S DEMANDED BY. 50%
02:42:03.780 --> 02:42:06.516
THAT'S DEMANDED BY A A AB NINE
02:42:06.583 --> 02:42:07.084
HUNDRED BUT I DON'T KNOW A
02:42:07.150 --> 02:42:08.285
MINUTE THAT'S NOT MY BUSINESS
02:42:08.351 --> 02:42:10.620
BUT BUT THAT'S THE VARIABLE SO
02:42:10.687 --> 02:42:14.091
WE'RE LOOKING AT THE OTHER.
02:42:14.157 --> 02:42:15.759
OTHERS ON THIS ISSUE SENATOR
02:42:15.826 --> 02:42:17.427
HILL IT THEN THANK YOU MISTER
02:42:17.494 --> 02:42:20.097
CHAIR AND THEM IN I OF I REALLY
02:42:20.163 --> 02:42:21.865
APPRECIATE THE THE OPPORTUNITY
02:42:21.932 --> 02:42:24.901
OF OF HEARING THE PASSION FROM.
02:42:24.968 --> 02:42:25.635
THE GREAT MAYOR OF OAKLAND AND
02:42:25.702 --> 02:42:26.937
AND YOU'RE.
02:42:27.003 --> 02:42:28.271
YOUR COMMENTS TODAY BECAUSE IT
02:42:28.338 --> 02:42:29.473
REALLY BROUGHT HOME TO ME SOME
02:42:29.539 --> 02:42:30.974
OF THE ISSUES THAT ARE REALLY
02:42:31.041 --> 02:42:32.509
UNIQUE TO OPEN.
02:42:32.576 --> 02:42:33.110
AND ESPECIALLY UNIQUE TO THIS
02:42:33.176 --> 02:42:34.478
PROJECT --
02:42:34.544 --> 02:42:36.980
AS I OF WALKED IN HERE TODAY I
02:42:37.047 --> 02:42:38.381
WAS.
02:42:38.448 --> 02:42:39.950
CERN DUH THERE WERE MEETINGS
02:42:40.016 --> 02:42:41.751
THAT THE MEMBERS OF MY STAFF HAD
02:42:41.818 --> 02:42:43.453
AND IN.
02:42:43.520 --> 02:42:44.888
THEY THEY WERE THEY WERE FINE
02:42:44.955 --> 02:42:46.089
BUT SOME OF THE COMMUNICATIONS
02:42:46.156 --> 02:42:47.390
AND I'M JUST KIND OF KOREAN SO
02:42:47.457 --> 02:42:49.192
THE NOTES THAT I THAT I HAVE
02:42:49.259 --> 02:42:49.893
THAT -- IN
02:42:49.960 --> 02:42:51.228
THE REALLY WASN'T A LOT OF
02:42:51.294 --> 02:42:53.130
INTEREST IN TRYING TO MEET THE
02:42:53.196 --> 02:42:53.296
UP.
02:42:53.363 --> 02:42:56.266
THE AB NINE HUNDRED GOALS AND
02:42:56.333 --> 02:42:58.101
BUT I I HEAR OBVIOUSLY SOME OF
02:42:58.168 --> 02:42:59.102
THE CHANGES.
02:42:59.169 --> 02:43:02.639
IN THINKING PERHAPS OR IN THE IN
02:43:02.706 --> 02:43:04.708
INFLEXIBILITY IN IN MOVING OUT
02:43:04.774 --> 02:43:05.976
TO REALLY COLD WHICH I THINK IS
02:43:06.042 --> 02:43:07.210
IMPORTANT SOME OF THE OTHER.
02:43:07.277 --> 02:43:09.579
CONDITIONS AND CHANGES THAT
02:43:09.646 --> 02:43:10.080
YOU'VE MADE THE AND I AM
02:43:10.147 --> 02:43:11.414
JUNCTURE BUT BUT I THINK IT'S
02:43:11.481 --> 02:43:12.482
THE IT'S THE HEART OF THIS IS.
02:43:12.549 --> 02:43:14.985
IS HOW CLOSE CAN WE COME. TO
02:43:15.051 --> 02:43:18.021
MEETING THOSE STANDARDS AND AND
02:43:18.088 --> 02:43:20.924
HERE AGAIN IT'S WE SOMETIMES TRY
02:43:20.991 --> 02:43:22.492
TO LOOK INTO LEGISLATION THE ONE
02:43:22.559 --> 02:43:24.094
SIZE FITS ALL BECAUSE THAT'S HOW
02:43:24.161 --> 02:43:25.896
WE WE DO THINGS IN.
02:43:25.962 --> 02:43:27.197
IT I DO SEE THAT WE HAVE A
02:43:27.264 --> 02:43:30.767
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY HERE AND THE
02:43:30.834 --> 02:43:32.936
ABILITY TO GET WHAT WE WILL NEED
02:43:33.003 --> 02:43:34.037
GET WHAT WE WANT AND AND
02:43:34.104 --> 02:43:34.938
CERTAINLY.
02:43:35.005 --> 02:43:36.072
THE CONFIDENCE I AND I IF YOU
02:43:36.139 --> 02:43:37.774
HEARD FROM MY COLLEAGUES I DON'T
02:43:37.841 --> 02:43:39.309
REPEAT WITH THEY'VE ALL SAID BUT
02:43:39.376 --> 02:43:40.677
YOU KNOW THERE IS A A TRUST
02:43:40.744 --> 02:43:42.078
FACTOR IN OPEN AND I THINK
02:43:42.145 --> 02:43:44.047
ESPECIALLY RELATED TO TO THE
02:43:44.114 --> 02:43:46.049
ISSUES OF FOR OF ENVIRONMENTAL
02:43:46.116 --> 02:43:47.350
CONSIDERATIONS CONCERNS AND IN.
02:43:47.417 --> 02:43:50.320
THE AND SO I THINK OF AT THE END
02:43:50.387 --> 02:43:52.122
OF THE DAY WITH THE CHANGES IN
02:43:52.189 --> 02:43:53.023
THE AMENDMENTS ALL ON PETER'S
02:43:53.089 --> 02:43:53.456
WELTS.
02:43:53.523 --> 02:43:56.293
YOU VERY MUCH.
02:43:56.359 --> 02:43:57.861
OKAY LET'S MOVE ONTO THE
02:43:57.928 --> 02:43:59.663
CERTIFICATION IS JUST ANOTHER
02:43:59.729 --> 02:44:01.531
ELEMENT THAT I HAVE UNLESS YOU
02:44:01.598 --> 02:44:02.299
GUYS TALK ABOUT BY PROBABLY
02:44:02.365 --> 02:44:05.135
DIDN'T HE SAID UNDER AB NINE
02:44:05.202 --> 02:44:06.436
HUNDRED WE HAVE THE LEADERSHIP
02:44:06.503 --> 02:44:08.371
PROJECT GET CERTIFIED BY THE BY
02:44:08.438 --> 02:44:09.239
THE GOVERNOR.
02:44:09.306 --> 02:44:11.274
ALRIGHT ADAM THE ENFORCEMENT
02:44:11.341 --> 02:44:13.210
MECHANISM IS THE WITH THE OFFICE
02:44:13.276 --> 02:44:14.578
OF PLANNING AND RESEARCH SO WE
02:44:14.644 --> 02:44:17.547
CAN TALK ABOUT 15% GREENHOUSE
02:44:17.614 --> 02:44:19.216
GASES GOAL LEAD CERTIFIED AND
02:44:19.282 --> 02:44:21.384
ALL THAT BUT THE MUSCLE THAT WE
02:44:21.451 --> 02:44:22.986
HAVE FROM THE STATE BECAUSE IT
02:44:23.053 --> 02:44:24.421
IS THE STATE SEEK WERE.
02:44:24.487 --> 02:44:26.923
EXEMPTION EDWARD WERE GRANNY IS
02:44:26.990 --> 02:44:28.892
IS CONTROLLED BY OPR SO WHERE
02:44:28.959 --> 02:44:30.260
YOU SORT OF HAVE A GAUGE OF WHAT
02:44:30.327 --> 02:44:31.895
THEY'RE GOING TO DO.
02:44:31.962 --> 02:44:33.597
THAT'S NOT IN THIS BILL.
02:44:33.663 --> 02:44:36.800
MY SON IN THIS BILL SO HOW IT
02:44:36.866 --> 02:44:39.169
HOW WOULD.
02:44:39.236 --> 02:44:40.437
S. SIMILAR BONTA HOW WOULD YOU
02:44:40.503 --> 02:44:42.405
ENFORCE ALL THE GREAT PROMISES
02:44:42.472 --> 02:44:43.707
THAT ARE BEING MADE [inaudible]
02:44:43.773 --> 02:44:48.178
HOW -- I
02:44:48.245 --> 02:44:49.145
IT'S BEGUN TO HAVE THE CENTER I
02:44:49.212 --> 02:44:50.680
MEAN WE WE'VE WE COULD CERTAINLY
02:44:50.747 --> 02:44:52.716
OPEN A CONVERSATION ABOUT AN OPR
02:44:52.782 --> 02:44:53.984
INVOLVEMENT I MEAN THE THAT THE
02:44:54.050 --> 02:44:55.218
MAKE THE MAIN.
02:44:55.285 --> 02:44:56.620
CRITERIA FOR QUALIFYING A
02:44:56.686 --> 02:44:58.855
PROJECT THROUGH IP ARE UNDER THE
02:44:58.922 --> 02:45:00.590
AB NINE HUNDRED FRAMEWORK IS THE
02:45:00.657 --> 02:45:01.891
GGN HOUSES.
02:45:01.958 --> 02:45:03.093
SO FRANK --
02:45:03.159 --> 02:45:04.194
WERE PROPOSING DIFFERENT
02:45:04.261 --> 02:45:06.696
CONSTRUCT FOR THAT SO HOW OPR I
02:45:06.763 --> 02:45:08.131
MEAN I GUESS O. PACKET CERTIFY
02:45:08.198 --> 02:45:09.266
THAT WERE CERTIFYING THE
02:45:09.332 --> 02:45:10.734
PROJECTS IS LEGAL THEIR SILVER
02:45:10.800 --> 02:45:13.470
BUT BEYOND THAT I'M NOT SURE.
02:45:13.536 --> 02:45:14.371
AND YOU KNOW WE HAVE OTHER
02:45:14.437 --> 02:45:15.105
REQUIREMENTS LIKE WE HAVE TO
02:45:15.171 --> 02:45:16.773
CREATE A TRANSPORTATION DEMAND
02:45:16.840 --> 02:45:18.808
MANAGEMENT PLAN WE HAVE THE
02:45:18.875 --> 02:45:20.810
ACHIEVE A PREVAILING WAGE
02:45:20.877 --> 02:45:23.880
VARIOUS OTHER THINGS --
02:45:23.947 --> 02:45:25.915
NO I'M NOT AWARE OF THEM.
02:45:25.982 --> 02:45:27.317
NEEDING TO CERTIFY THOSE
02:45:27.384 --> 02:45:29.152
ELEMENTS BUT IF THAT'S THE WILL
02:45:29.219 --> 02:45:30.220
OF THE COMMITTEE I THINK THAT
02:45:30.287 --> 02:45:31.655
COULD BE A STOP IN THE PROCESS
02:45:31.721 --> 02:45:33.556
RIP BECAUSE BECAUSE ORDINARILY
02:45:33.623 --> 02:45:35.225
IN LAND USE DECISION THAT WOULD
02:45:35.292 --> 02:45:37.460
FALL UNDER THE JURISDICTION THE
02:45:37.527 --> 02:45:38.862
CITY AND THE COUNTY DEPENDING.
02:45:38.928 --> 02:45:40.664
GRAPHIC YOU STOLEN HERE STILL ON
02:45:40.730 --> 02:45:43.099
A WE HAVE TO CERTIFY THE IR YEAH.
02:45:43.166 --> 02:45:44.401
YOU'RE STILL IN RELATIONSHIP
02:45:44.467 --> 02:45:46.403
WITH IF IT'S THE COLISEUM SITE
02:45:46.469 --> 02:45:48.104
THAT'S A JOINT OWNERSHIP SO THAT
02:45:48.171 --> 02:45:49.005
THOSE.
02:45:49.072 --> 02:45:50.373
BUT THE CITY STILL HOLDS THE
02:45:50.440 --> 02:45:52.776
LAND USE AUTHORITY SO ACTUALLY
02:45:52.842 --> 02:45:53.910
ONLY THE CITY WITH CERTIFIED ER.
02:45:53.977 --> 02:45:56.212
GOTCHA --
02:45:56.279 --> 02:45:58.615
BECAUSE AGAIN THAT'S JUST.
02:45:58.682 --> 02:45:59.582
I HEARD SOMEBODY TALK ABOUT THE
02:45:59.649 --> 02:46:01.718
TRUST I MISSED THE FIRST PART OF
02:46:01.785 --> 02:46:04.120
THE PRESENTATION ARM ART LET'S
02:46:04.187 --> 02:46:05.522
HEAR FROM.
02:46:05.588 --> 02:46:06.456
HAVE WE HAD OPEN UP THE PUBLIC
02:46:06.523 --> 02:46:08.558
HERE.
02:46:08.625 --> 02:46:09.426
SO WE'RE DONE WE'RE THE WRAP UP
02:46:09.492 --> 02:46:11.661
I'M.
02:46:11.728 --> 02:46:13.530
ARE THERE LATE.
02:46:13.596 --> 02:46:16.800
OPINIONS ON THIS BILL BEFORE I
02:46:16.866 --> 02:46:17.767
SORRY MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
02:46:17.834 --> 02:46:19.169
MEMBERS CORNELIUS BURKE WITH THE
02:46:19.235 --> 02:46:21.104
BARE A COUNCIL STRONG SUPPORT
02:46:21.171 --> 02:46:30.513
THIS BILL SCORE I'M RENTAL.
02:46:30.580 --> 02:46:32.182
CHAIR WHY CAN'T SHE YOU MISS MY
02:46:32.248 --> 02:46:33.750
BEAUTIFUL SOLILOQUY WITH ALL
02:46:33.817 --> 02:46:36.219
THEIR ACTED AT YOU AND REALLY
02:46:36.286 --> 02:46:38.221
REALLY CALM YOU KNOW I'VE HEARD
02:46:38.288 --> 02:46:39.823
YOUR CONCERNS.
02:46:39.889 --> 02:46:41.758
AND WITH THE TWO VERY
02:46:41.825 --> 02:46:43.793
SIGNIFICANT AMENDMENTS THE
02:46:43.860 --> 02:46:45.628
BILL'S AUTHOR HAS PROPOSE.
02:46:45.695 --> 02:46:47.530
AS WELL AS OAKLAND'S TRACK
02:46:47.597 --> 02:46:49.299
RECORD.
02:46:49.366 --> 02:46:50.600
AND REMEMBERING THAT WE ARE
02:46:50.667 --> 02:46:53.069
STILL DOING A FULL III ARE THAT
02:46:53.136 --> 02:46:54.471
HAS TO BE CERTIFIED BY THE
02:46:54.537 --> 02:46:55.939
POLITICAL BODY OF THE CITY OF
02:46:56.005 --> 02:46:57.674
OAKLAND --
02:46:57.741 --> 02:47:01.778
WE RESPECTFULLY ASK THAT THIS
02:47:01.845 --> 02:47:04.080
BILL IS MUCH DIFFERENT.
02:47:04.147 --> 02:47:05.749
FROM THE OTHER ONES THAT I KNOW
02:47:05.815 --> 02:47:07.517
YOU HAVE OPPOSITION.
02:47:07.584 --> 02:47:08.585
TO BECAUSE ASSIST CHANGED
02:47:08.651 --> 02:47:09.986
SIGNIFICANTLY SINCE IT WAS
02:47:10.053 --> 02:47:11.721
INTRODUCED AND WE DO HOPE TO
02:47:11.788 --> 02:47:14.591
HAVE YOUR SUPPORT OR AT LEAST NO
02:47:14.657 --> 02:47:16.726
POSITION. FIVE AS WELL AND AS WE
02:47:16.793 --> 02:47:18.728
CONTINUE TO DIALOGUE WITH YOU
02:47:18.795 --> 02:47:20.830
ABOUT HOW WE NEED MORE
02:47:20.897 --> 02:47:21.865
FLEXIBILITY THAN THE
02:47:21.931 --> 02:47:24.434
CERTIFICATION PROCESS THAT AB
02:47:24.501 --> 02:47:25.802
NINE HUNDRED PUT IN PLACE. TO BE
02:47:25.869 --> 02:47:27.270
RESPONSIVE TO OAKLAND UNIQUE
02:47:27.337 --> 02:47:31.808
SITUATION. FOR THE AUTHOR.
02:47:31.875 --> 02:47:34.344
WHERE ARE YOU AT THE GREENHOUSE
02:47:34.411 --> 02:47:36.780
GAS EMISSIONS?
02:47:36.846 --> 02:47:39.849
EQUIVALENCY OR COMMITMENT AT IN
02:47:39.916 --> 02:47:42.018
BECAUSE THAT'S NOT SPOKEN OF IN
02:47:42.085 --> 02:47:43.720
THE AMENDMENT TO AMENDMENTS THAT
02:47:43.787 --> 02:47:44.921
WE HAVE --
02:47:44.988 --> 02:47:46.790
IS THERE SOME LEVEL THAT YOU
02:47:46.856 --> 02:47:47.757
FEEL COMFORTABLE.
02:47:47.824 --> 02:47:49.959
WITH THAT MY COMMITTEE MEMBERS
02:47:50.026 --> 02:47:51.494
BECAUSE RIGHT NOW WE HAVE NO
02:47:51.561 --> 02:47:54.230
COMMITMENT TO EQUIVALENCY FROM
02:47:54.297 --> 02:47:56.633
THE PROS UP PROPOSED SITE FOR
02:47:56.699 --> 02:47:57.901
REDUCTION OF GREENHOUSE GAS
02:47:57.967 --> 02:48:00.603
EMISSIONS OR THAT THE SPIRIT OF
02:48:00.670 --> 02:48:02.005
NINE HUNDRED OR 50% OF NINE
02:48:02.071 --> 02:48:02.439
HUNDRED OR SOME IDEA
02:48:02.505 --> 02:48:02.739
[inaudible]
02:48:02.806 --> 02:48:06.276
I BECAUSE AS MY SPIKE FREMONT
02:48:06.342 --> 02:48:08.244
OAKLAND A SPIDER THIS IS ONE OF
02:48:08.311 --> 02:48:10.313
TWO SO I HAD A LOT OF STUFF I
02:48:10.380 --> 02:48:11.648
DON'T HAVE ANYTHING IN FRONT OF
02:48:11.714 --> 02:48:12.015
ME.
02:48:12.081 --> 02:48:13.983
AS FAR AS WHAT I'VE GOT IDEAS
02:48:14.050 --> 02:48:16.119
BUT WHEN OAKLAND CAME TO FREMONT
02:48:16.186 --> 02:48:17.420
I GOT THIS.
02:48:17.487 --> 02:48:19.222
SO I DON'T HAVE I MEAN THE
02:48:19.289 --> 02:48:20.657
COMMITTEE DOESN'T HAVE.
02:48:20.723 --> 02:48:23.092
RENDERINGS DRAWINGS AND ALL THAT
02:48:23.159 --> 02:48:24.761
WE'VE GOT WE'VE TALKED WE HAVE.
02:48:24.828 --> 02:48:26.696
COMMITMENTS I GUESS MY THE FINAL
02:48:26.763 --> 02:48:28.765
LITTLE PIECE BECAUSE I'VE.
02:48:28.832 --> 02:48:31.768
GOT THE CERTIFICATION IS ON THE
02:48:31.835 --> 02:48:33.303
MEETING THE GREENHOUSE GAS
02:48:33.369 --> 02:48:34.237
REDUCTIONS OR SOME SORT OF
02:48:34.304 --> 02:48:36.206
EQUIVALENCY.
02:48:36.272 --> 02:48:36.773
YES THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR I
02:48:36.840 --> 02:48:37.974
THINK.
02:48:38.041 --> 02:48:39.042
WE HAVE PROPOSED AN ALTERNATIVE
02:48:39.108 --> 02:48:40.810
APPROACH THAT BECAUSE OF WHAT WE
02:48:40.877 --> 02:48:43.413
DEEM TO BE THAT THE BASELINE
02:48:43.480 --> 02:48:44.247
COMPARISON AND THE FACT THAT
02:48:44.314 --> 02:48:45.582
IT'S ESSENTIALLY A VACANT SITE
02:48:45.648 --> 02:48:47.150
NOT GENERATING MUCH IF ANY.
02:48:47.217 --> 02:48:48.485
GHGS AND AND THE FACT WILL
02:48:48.551 --> 02:48:50.119
ACTIVATE THE SITE AND WILL WILL
02:48:50.186 --> 02:48:51.421
BE GENERATING J. SHE'S.
02:48:51.488 --> 02:48:52.722
AYE WE'VE ALSO TALKED A BIT
02:48:52.789 --> 02:48:54.924
THROUGH THIS COMMITTEE ARM ABOUT
02:48:54.991 --> 02:48:56.459
HAVING SOME FLEXIBILITY THAT
02:48:56.526 --> 02:48:58.061
GOES OUTSIDE OF AB NINE HUNDRED
02:48:58.127 --> 02:48:59.095
TO TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THINGS LIKE
02:48:59.162 --> 02:49:00.296
THE PETER PLANT.
02:49:00.363 --> 02:49:01.431
AYE WHICH WOULD BE HAVE
02:49:01.498 --> 02:49:02.565
REPLACING WITH THAT OR WHICH
02:49:02.632 --> 02:49:04.801
WOULD HELP BECAUSE TO BE
02:49:04.868 --> 02:49:05.668
REPLACED BY A NEW ENERGY --
02:49:05.735 --> 02:49:08.505
FACILITY. ONE THING WE CAN OFFER
02:49:08.571 --> 02:49:10.607
AYE AYE I THINK AT THIS POINT
02:49:10.673 --> 02:49:12.575
AND I WE WERE OPEN AT TALK ABOUT
02:49:12.642 --> 02:49:14.277
THIS MORE IS THAT.
02:49:14.344 --> 02:49:15.545
JUST ANA APPLES TO APPLES
02:49:15.612 --> 02:49:17.313
STRAIGHT ONE TO ONE COMPARISON
02:49:17.380 --> 02:49:18.014
STADIUM.
02:49:18.081 --> 02:49:19.482
UP THE CURRENT STADIUM TO NEW
02:49:19.549 --> 02:49:22.118
STADIUM WE WILL HAVE --
02:49:22.185 --> 02:49:27.023
NET ZERO GHGS OR OR OR BETTER.
02:49:27.090 --> 02:49:30.093
OKAY I'LL TAKE THAT AS FROM THE
02:49:30.159 --> 02:49:31.127
STATE WHEN THE STATE INVADING
02:49:31.194 --> 02:49:37.433
SPECIFICALLY.
02:49:37.500 --> 02:49:38.835
TOGETHER SO OFTEN AMENDMENT
02:49:38.902 --> 02:49:40.870
CENTER STONE'S GRAPHIC YOU
02:49:40.937 --> 02:49:41.271
MISTER CHAIRMAN --
02:49:41.337 --> 02:49:42.772
THE PRESIDENT.
02:49:42.839 --> 02:49:44.641
SOME ALLEN BONTA MAYOR THANK YOU
02:49:44.707 --> 02:49:47.277
FOR FOR BEING HERE TODAY --
02:49:47.343 --> 02:49:48.912
IN ALL THE PROJECTS OF THIS
02:49:48.978 --> 02:49:50.847
MAGNITUDE THAT I'VE SEEN IN MY
02:49:50.914 --> 02:49:51.447
TWENTY SIX YEARS I HAVE NEVER
02:49:51.514 --> 02:49:54.751
SEEN A A PROPONENT.
02:49:54.817 --> 02:49:58.087
DO THE ENVIRONMENTAL --
02:49:58.154 --> 02:49:58.688
COMMITMENTS THAT YOU'VE YOU'VE
02:49:58.755 --> 02:50:00.456
UNDERTAKEN --
02:50:00.523 --> 02:50:01.591
I APPRECIATE THAT THERE'S NO
02:50:01.658 --> 02:50:02.759
PUBLIC MONEY GOING INTO THE
02:50:02.825 --> 02:50:04.727
STADIUM I APPRECIATE THERE'S
02:50:04.794 --> 02:50:05.995
GONNA BE A FULL THE IR.
02:50:06.062 --> 02:50:07.430
I APPRECIATE IS GOING TO HAVE A
02:50:07.497 --> 02:50:09.132
LEAD CERTIFICATIONS IT'S GOING
02:50:09.198 --> 02:50:10.867
TO BRING TWO THOUSAND JOBS THREE
02:50:10.934 --> 02:50:12.335
BILLION DOLLARS AND ECONOMIC
02:50:12.402 --> 02:50:14.137
BENEFITS.
02:50:14.203 --> 02:50:15.438
AND SOMETIMES WE HAVE TO LEARN
02:50:15.505 --> 02:50:18.508
BY LESSONS PASSED --
02:50:18.575 --> 02:50:19.409
WHEN WE SAW IN SOUTHERN
02:50:19.475 --> 02:50:21.144
CALIFORNIA I'M ANGELENOS WELBORN
02:50:21.210 --> 02:50:22.612
IN LA RESTORE REASON ORANGE
02:50:22.679 --> 02:50:24.013
COUNTY IN?
02:50:24.080 --> 02:50:25.448
LIVE IN RIVERSIDE COUNTY NOW FOR
02:50:25.515 --> 02:50:27.350
THE PAST THIRTY FIVE YEARS.
02:50:27.417 --> 02:50:29.052
OUR WHEN WE SEE IN MAJOR LEAGUE
02:50:29.118 --> 02:50:29.819
TEAMS --
02:50:29.886 --> 02:50:32.188
LEAVE.
02:50:32.255 --> 02:50:33.489
CITIES IT HAS A DEVASTATING
02:50:33.556 --> 02:50:34.924
ECONOMIC [inaudible]
02:50:34.991 --> 02:50:37.160
CONSEQUENCES --
02:50:37.226 --> 02:50:38.661
CERTAINLY WE SEEMED --
02:50:38.728 --> 02:50:40.063
SAN DIEGO --
02:50:40.129 --> 02:50:42.498
WITH THEIR FOOTBALL TEAM TO LA.
02:50:42.565 --> 02:50:43.399
IT HAD SOME DEVASTATING
02:50:43.466 --> 02:50:45.635
CONSEQUENCES ON SAN DIEGO AND
02:50:45.702 --> 02:50:46.903
YEARS AGO.
02:50:46.970 --> 02:50:48.571
WE SAW THE LAKERS --
02:50:48.638 --> 02:50:49.973
LEAVE --
02:50:50.039 --> 02:50:50.473
INGLEWOOD --
02:50:50.540 --> 02:50:54.811
WHICH WE SAW AN ECONOMICALLY
02:50:54.877 --> 02:50:56.312
HAVE A NEGATIVE.
02:50:56.379 --> 02:50:58.982
EFFECT ON ON THAT AREA.
02:50:59.048 --> 02:50:59.949
WHAT WE HOPE TO SEE REJUVENATED
02:51:00.016 --> 02:51:00.950
HERE WITH MAYBE ANOTHER BILL
02:51:01.017 --> 02:51:03.786
THAT MIGHT BE COMING FORWARD --
02:51:03.853 --> 02:51:05.855
NEVER THEY LEFT MINNESOTA BEFORE
02:51:05.922 --> 02:51:07.490
THAT THEY WERE THE LAKERS.
02:51:07.557 --> 02:51:09.292
PLANET TEN THOUSAND LAKES
02:51:09.359 --> 02:51:09.592
[inaudible]
02:51:09.659 --> 02:51:13.663
AND I IF YOU'RE GONNA TRUST A
02:51:13.730 --> 02:51:17.166
CITY FOR ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE --
02:51:17.233 --> 02:51:19.235
AND ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP I
02:51:19.302 --> 02:51:21.170
AGREE WITH MY COLLEAGUES --
02:51:21.237 --> 02:51:23.272
OAKLAND.
02:51:23.339 --> 02:51:24.507
CERTAINLY --
02:51:24.574 --> 02:51:27.110
DESERVES THAT THAT TRUST --
02:51:27.176 --> 02:51:28.711
INDUSTRY POURED THAT THE MAYOR
02:51:28.778 --> 02:51:29.679
WAS HERE.
02:51:29.746 --> 02:51:32.448
TO REITERATE THOSE.
02:51:32.515 --> 02:51:35.451
THOSE COMMITMENTS --
02:51:35.518 --> 02:51:36.586
THERE WAS START OFF THAT YOU
02:51:36.653 --> 02:51:37.387
HAVE -- A
02:51:37.453 --> 02:51:39.522
CONSENSUS WITH.
02:51:39.589 --> 02:51:40.957
THE CITY LABOR THE PRIVATE
02:51:41.024 --> 02:51:43.159
SECTOR --
02:51:43.226 --> 02:51:46.062
ENVIRONMENTALISTS --
02:51:46.129 --> 02:51:47.664
IT I THINK THEY WERE DONE AS
02:51:47.730 --> 02:51:49.766
GOOD OF A JOB IS A POSSIBLY CAM
02:51:49.832 --> 02:51:50.767
TO ADDRESS THAT THE GREENHOUSE
02:51:50.833 --> 02:51:52.735
GAS EMISSIONS.
02:51:52.802 --> 02:51:53.770
IF IT HAD VERY.
02:51:53.836 --> 02:51:54.837
BASED ON WHAT I HEARD EARLIER
02:51:54.904 --> 02:51:56.339
MISTER CHAIR THAT THEY USE
02:51:56.406 --> 02:51:58.541
STADIUM.
02:51:58.608 --> 02:51:59.108
DON'T THEY'RE ALL LOOKING AT
02:51:59.175 --> 02:52:01.077
JUST A THE SAME GREENHOUSE GAS
02:52:01.144 --> 02:52:02.612
REDUCTIONS BUT IT'LL 25%.
02:52:02.679 --> 02:52:04.013
POSSIBLE REDUCTION BECAUSE
02:52:04.080 --> 02:52:05.948
STOCKHOLDERS MANY PEOPLE.
02:52:06.015 --> 02:52:08.184
SO UP WITH EXISTING SITE OR WITH
02:52:08.251 --> 02:52:09.419
THE OTHER SITE YOU KNOW OU'RE
02:52:09.485 --> 02:52:10.486
DEALING WITH A PIECE OF VACANT
02:52:10.553 --> 02:52:11.788
LAND YOU KNOW THAT'S A THAT'S A
02:52:11.854 --> 02:52:13.322
VERY DIFFICULT STANDARD TO MEET.
02:52:13.389 --> 02:52:15.625
BUT OUTSIDE OF AB NINE HUNDRED
02:52:15.692 --> 02:52:16.459
WHEN YOU GOT THE SPEAKER PLANT
02:52:16.526 --> 02:52:17.460
ISSUES THAN.
02:52:17.527 --> 02:52:19.128
THE NET EFFECTS ON THE CITY I
02:52:19.195 --> 02:52:20.596
THINK ARE GOING TO BE --
02:52:20.663 --> 02:52:22.799
VERY POSITIVE --
02:52:22.865 --> 02:52:25.668
SO -- HOW
02:52:25.735 --> 02:52:27.170
ONE APPLIED TO THE AIDS FOR THE
02:52:27.236 --> 02:52:28.304
GREAT JOB THAT YOU'VE DONE AND
02:52:28.371 --> 02:52:30.239
AND COMING HERE TODAY AND MAKING
02:52:30.306 --> 02:52:32.141
A GOOD CASE THAT THIS IS A?
02:52:32.208 --> 02:52:35.011
DESERVING OF SOME STREAMLINING.
02:52:35.078 --> 02:52:36.045
YEAH YOU'RE GONNA GO FOR THE
02:52:36.112 --> 02:52:37.947
FULLY IRE PROCESS AND SO. ONE
02:52:38.014 --> 02:52:40.249
THING THAT.
02:52:40.316 --> 02:52:41.117
I KNOW FROM BEING A PRIVATE
02:52:41.184 --> 02:52:42.418
SECTOR GUY I MEAN NIGHT I GOT
02:52:42.485 --> 02:52:44.153
INTO POLITICS BY AN ACCIDENT BUT
02:52:44.220 --> 02:52:45.354
ONE THING I'VE KNOWN AS A
02:52:45.421 --> 02:52:47.390
SUCCESSFUL BUSINESSMAN.
02:52:47.457 --> 02:52:48.958
IS THAT YOU NEED CHARITY.
02:52:49.025 --> 02:52:49.826
AND WHEN YOU'RE INVESTING A
02:52:49.892 --> 02:52:51.661
BILLION HALF DOLLARS YOU WANT TO
02:52:51.728 --> 02:52:52.261
MAKE SURE THAT YOU'RE GONNA BE
02:52:52.328 --> 02:52:55.031
ABLE TO GET TO THE OVER THOUGH
02:52:55.098 --> 02:52:56.332
THE HOME RUN FENCE RIGHT IN US
02:52:56.399 --> 02:52:58.835
IN A TIMELY WAY --
02:52:58.901 --> 02:53:00.636
CLAY DOESN'T HAVE TEN YEARS TO
02:53:00.703 --> 02:53:01.204
WAIT FOR YOU TO COME TO FOR
02:53:01.270 --> 02:53:02.205
FRUITION.
02:53:02.271 --> 02:53:03.272
AND A AND THEY WANT TO DO
02:53:03.339 --> 02:53:04.540
WHATEVER THEY CAN TO CEMENT THE
02:53:04.607 --> 02:53:06.175
RELATIONSHIP THE COMMITMENT TO
02:53:06.242 --> 02:53:07.043
KEEPING YOU.
02:53:07.110 --> 02:53:09.145
IN OAKLAND WHERE I THINK THERE'S
02:53:09.212 --> 02:53:10.646
A LOT OF PRIDE OF OWNERSHIP IF
02:53:10.713 --> 02:53:11.414
YOU'LL BY THE CITIZENS F
02:53:11.481 --> 02:53:12.548
OAKLAND SO.
02:53:12.615 --> 02:53:13.282
I'M DELIGHTED TO SUPPORT THE
02:53:13.349 --> 02:53:14.083
BILL.
02:53:14.150 --> 02:53:15.318
AND I WOULD EVEN BE DELIGHTED TO
02:53:15.384 --> 02:53:16.819
BE A CO AUTHOR WITH YOU ON
02:53:16.886 --> 02:53:18.287
MCAFEE COULD LOBBY MY NAME TO BE
02:53:18.354 --> 02:53:19.622
ON THERE BECAUSE THIS IS THE
02:53:19.689 --> 02:53:21.691
KIND OF PROJECT THAT.
02:53:21.758 --> 02:53:23.760
REALLY MAKES CALIFORNIA SHINE.
02:53:23.826 --> 02:53:26.496
UNTIL THE ANGELS.
02:53:26.562 --> 02:53:27.063
THANK YOU SENATOR STIMULATED
02:53:27.130 --> 02:53:27.497
HAVE YOU [inaudible]
02:53:27.563 --> 02:53:29.732
CENTER SKINNER.
02:53:29.799 --> 02:53:31.167
THANK YOU I WON'T REPEAT MANY
02:53:31.234 --> 02:53:32.535
THE GOOD COMMENTS BY MY
02:53:32.602 --> 02:53:33.970
COLLEAGUE FROM TO MACULA OTHER
02:53:34.036 --> 02:53:35.605
THAN --
02:53:35.671 --> 02:53:37.206
THERE'S NO WAY THAT I'M GOING TO
02:53:37.273 --> 02:53:38.141
WALK OUT OF THIS ROOM AND
02:53:38.207 --> 02:53:39.942
ALLOWED THE LAST SPORTS TEAM IN
02:53:40.009 --> 02:53:43.246
OAKLAND TO LEAVE --
02:53:43.312 --> 02:53:47.683
AND AFTER --
02:53:47.750 --> 02:53:51.254
MY COLLEAGUE THE AUTHOR --
02:53:51.320 --> 02:53:52.922
SPOKE ON THE FLOOR IN THE
02:53:52.989 --> 02:53:59.028
ASSEMBLY FOR THE THE AND MINOR
02:53:59.095 --> 02:53:59.896
FOR WELL WHATEVER YOU CALL IT
02:53:59.962 --> 02:54:01.330
WHATEVER YOU WANT BUT EXEMPTION
02:54:01.397 --> 02:54:02.565
THAT ALLOWED.
02:54:02.632 --> 02:54:04.267
THAT STREAMLINED.
02:54:04.333 --> 02:54:05.935
PROCESS FOR OUR GOLDEN STATE
02:54:06.002 --> 02:54:09.272
WARRIORS TO GO TO SAN FRANCISCO.
02:54:09.338 --> 02:54:10.773
WHICH OF COURSE HAS BEEN LONG
02:54:10.840 --> 02:54:11.974
PLANNING BUT I DID NOT SUPPORT
02:54:12.041 --> 02:54:14.310
THAT -- IN
02:54:14.377 --> 02:54:15.144
TRUE -- EAST
02:54:15.211 --> 02:54:17.280
BAY --
02:54:17.346 --> 02:54:18.981
PROTECT MY RESIDENTS DON'T LOSE
02:54:19.048 --> 02:54:21.551
YOUR TEAMS SO ANYWAY BUT I THINK
02:54:21.617 --> 02:54:24.153
THE MOST GERMANE POINT.
02:54:24.220 --> 02:54:25.822
IS THAT THE MAYOR HAS MADE IS
02:54:25.888 --> 02:54:27.990
THAT THE <c.green> ARE WILL HAVE TO</c>
02:54:28.057 --> 02:54:29.926
BE CERTIFIED BY THE ENTIRE
02:54:29.992 --> 02:54:31.260
OAKLAND CITY COUNCIL WHICH
02:54:31.327 --> 02:54:33.996
REMEMBER STOPPED THE COAL TRAINS.
02:54:34.063 --> 02:54:36.299
SO WITH THAT I WILL MOVE THE
02:54:36.365 --> 02:54:37.333
BILL.
02:54:37.400 --> 02:54:41.737
AND CHAIR IF THERE WERE SPECIFIC
02:54:41.804 --> 02:54:42.371
AMENDMENTS THAT YOU WANT ME TO
02:54:42.438 --> 02:54:44.373
INCLUDE IN THAT MOTION I'M HAPPY
02:54:44.440 --> 02:54:45.441
TO DO SO.
02:54:45.508 --> 02:54:47.510
I THINK WHAT WE DO BECAUSE THIS
02:54:47.577 --> 02:54:49.278
GOES TO JUDICIARY SO WHAT I'D
02:54:49.345 --> 02:54:51.314
LIKE TO HAVE THE MOTION IS TO
02:54:51.380 --> 02:54:52.915
AGREE TO THAT.
02:54:52.982 --> 02:54:54.684
PACIFIC AMENDMENTS EVEN THOUGH I
02:54:54.750 --> 02:54:55.218
WASN'T HERE WHEN THEY WERE
02:54:55.284 --> 02:54:56.819
ARTICULATED --
02:54:56.886 --> 02:54:58.688
THAT BE DRAFTED BY THE THE
02:54:58.754 --> 02:55:00.156
COMMITTEE AND BEFORE THE
02:55:00.223 --> 02:55:00.923
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE IF THAT'S
02:55:00.990 --> 02:55:02.391
YOU KNOW.
02:55:02.458 --> 02:55:05.595
SORRY I DO IT.
02:55:05.661 --> 02:55:06.529
THAT'S FINE OKAY THEN THAT WOULD
02:55:06.596 --> 02:55:08.364
BE.
02:55:08.431 --> 02:55:09.799
THE MOTION RIGHT THEN I WILL
02:55:09.866 --> 02:55:14.203
ACCEPT THAT IS THE MOST.
02:55:14.270 --> 02:55:16.806
MR CENTER STONE ANYBODY.
02:55:16.873 --> 02:55:18.341
AND JUST TO BE CLEAR MISTER
02:55:18.407 --> 02:55:20.276
CHAIR I AT I MEAN WE'RE HAPPY
02:55:20.343 --> 02:55:21.611
WITH YOU'D DRAFTING A HAPPY
02:55:21.677 --> 02:55:22.812
JUDICIARY WHATEVER THE WORKLOAD.
02:55:22.879 --> 02:55:24.847
SHARES IS BETTER.
02:55:24.914 --> 02:55:26.315
BUT THE CONCEPTS OF WHAT WE'VE
02:55:26.382 --> 02:55:27.350
AGREED ON THE TWO THAT I START
02:55:27.416 --> 02:55:28.517
OFF WITH AND THEN THE ONE FROM
02:55:28.584 --> 02:55:30.286
ONE STADIUM --
02:55:30.353 --> 02:55:33.256
GHG CORRECT THAT'S NOT ENOUGH IT
02:55:33.322 --> 02:55:34.156
IS IT IS WHAT YOU'VE AGREED
02:55:34.223 --> 02:55:34.457
[inaudible]
02:55:34.523 --> 02:55:36.392
TO ALRIGHT.
02:55:36.459 --> 02:55:36.959
IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU'D
02:55:37.026 --> 02:55:39.295
LIKE TO ADD.
02:55:39.362 --> 02:55:40.696
IF WE HAD A THOROUGH DISCUSSION
02:55:40.763 --> 02:55:41.731
HIGH APPRECIATING GAUGE MINUTES
02:55:41.797 --> 02:55:42.899
REFILL THE COMMENTS FROM
02:55:42.965 --> 02:55:44.367
COLLEAGUES AND ALL THE INPUT.
02:55:44.433 --> 02:55:45.801
AND RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE
02:55:45.868 --> 02:55:46.502
VOTE THANK YOU.
02:55:46.569 --> 02:55:49.639
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
02:55:49.705 --> 02:55:52.642
ITEM NUMBER THREE AB SEVEN
02:55:52.708 --> 02:55:53.276
THIRTY FOUR BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
02:55:53.342 --> 02:55:55.745
BONTA THE MOTION IS DO PASS TO
02:55:55.811 --> 02:55:56.679
THE SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
02:55:56.746 --> 02:55:58.214
ESTIMATES.
02:55:58.281 --> 02:55:59.682
NONE OF OF NO DEPLOY THEM AND
02:55:59.749 --> 02:56:01.250
IT'S AMERICA BE THERE AND CLEAR
02:56:01.317 --> 02:56:02.685
THE NEXT [inaudible]
02:56:02.752 --> 02:56:03.119
ALRIGHT [inaudible]
02:56:03.185 --> 02:56:04.453
YOU PASS DID SENATE JUDICIARY
02:56:04.520 --> 02:56:06.155
COMMITTEE.
02:56:06.222 --> 02:56:07.623
LIKE HOW SCHEME AYE AYE CASKEY
02:56:07.690 --> 02:56:10.226
AYE STONE STONE AYE GAINES
02:56:10.293 --> 02:56:10.526
[inaudible]
02:56:10.593 --> 02:56:11.961
HILL [inaudible]
02:56:12.028 --> 02:56:13.062
LARA [inaudible]
02:56:13.129 --> 02:56:14.664
SKINNER.
02:56:14.730 --> 02:56:16.565
SKINNER AYE STERN.
02:56:16.632 --> 02:56:18.434
STERN AYE I WILL KEEP THAT
02:56:18.501 --> 02:56:19.068
MATTER UNCLE THANK YOU FOR YOUR
02:56:19.135 --> 02:56:19.435
TIME [inaudible]
02:56:19.502 --> 02:56:24.507
I SORRY MR IT'S BUD ASSEMBLY
02:56:24.573 --> 02:56:25.908
MEMBER TEEN.
02:56:25.975 --> 02:56:27.643
AND I'M GONNA BLOW THIS
02:56:27.710 --> 02:56:27.944
[inaudible]
02:56:28.010 --> 02:56:31.414
WILL [inaudible] FOR OR PER
02:56:31.480 --> 02:56:32.915
FULLER ROLE ALKYL AND POLY
02:56:32.982 --> 02:56:34.684
FLORAL.
02:56:34.750 --> 02:56:37.253
OUT GOAL SUBSTANCES [inaudible]
02:56:37.320 --> 02:56:38.688
AND ARE.
02:56:38.754 --> 02:56:39.989
LITTLE NOTICES GOOD MORNING
02:56:40.056 --> 02:56:41.958
ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
02:56:42.024 --> 02:56:43.259
THANK YOU SENATORS I HAVE THE
02:56:43.326 --> 02:56:44.126
DISTINCT HONOR OF BEING
02:56:44.193 --> 02:56:46.929
SANDWICHED BETWEEN --
02:56:46.996 --> 02:56:48.631
TWO FABULOUS STADIUM PROPOSALS
02:56:48.698 --> 02:56:50.232
EARTH FROM MY LUCKY DAY I'M
02:56:50.299 --> 02:56:52.735
GONNA GO BACK AND WATER TICKETS --
02:56:52.802 --> 02:56:55.371
AB NINE FIVE EIGHT WOULD REQUIRE
02:56:55.438 --> 02:56:56.639
MANUFACTURES OF FOOD PACKAGING
02:56:56.706 --> 02:56:57.773
COOKWARE DISCLOSED ON THE
02:56:57.840 --> 02:56:58.874
PACKAGES.
02:56:58.941 --> 02:57:01.243
IF THE PRODUCTS CONTAINED P.
02:57:01.310 --> 02:57:02.678
FASTER CHEMICAL.
02:57:02.745 --> 02:57:04.680
THAT A TWENTY FIFTEEN DUPONT
02:57:04.747 --> 02:57:06.515
STUDY FOUND TO CAUSE CANCEROUS
02:57:06.582 --> 02:57:07.717
TUMORS IN THE LIVER.
02:57:07.783 --> 02:57:09.518
PANCREAS AND* AS WELL AS
02:57:09.585 --> 02:57:11.253
KIDNEY DISEASE LIVER GENERATION
02:57:11.320 --> 02:57:11.787
AND YOU TO RUN [inaudible]
02:57:11.854 --> 02:57:14.523
POLYPS -- WE
02:57:14.590 --> 02:57:15.858
HAVE --
02:57:15.925 --> 02:57:17.259
TAKEN GREAT STEPS TO BAND LONG
02:57:17.326 --> 02:57:19.428
CHAIN P. FASTENERS BIRD THIS IS
02:57:19.495 --> 02:57:22.031
REALLY REQUIRING THE DISCLOSURE
02:57:22.098 --> 02:57:24.000
OF SHORT CHAIN --
02:57:24.066 --> 02:57:26.535
P. FAXES AND COOKWARE AS WELL AS
02:57:26.602 --> 02:57:28.437
IN -- FAST
02:57:28.504 --> 02:57:30.473
FOOD CONTAINERS OR TO GO
02:57:30.539 --> 02:57:31.874
CONTAINERS AND FOOD WRAPPERS
02:57:31.941 --> 02:57:33.542
THAT'S FOR THE COMMONLY FOUND.
02:57:33.609 --> 02:57:36.512
ARE FOR FOR LAY PEOPLE THE MOST
02:57:36.579 --> 02:57:38.948
COMMON WAY THAT WE SEE P..
02:57:39.015 --> 02:57:41.550
WHERE LIKE TEFLON AS WELL AS IN
02:57:41.617 --> 02:57:43.419
THE WAXY SUBSTANCE OF THE FOOD
02:57:43.486 --> 02:57:44.653
WRAPPER SO KIND OF --
02:57:44.720 --> 02:57:46.122
DOESN'T CREATE THESAME AMOUNT
02:57:46.188 --> 02:57:48.324
OF LEAKAGE WHAT WHAT WE ARE
02:57:48.391 --> 02:57:49.992
CONCERNED ABOUT IS WE SEE.
02:57:50.059 --> 02:57:52.528
IN OUR SURVEY BY THE
02:57:52.595 --> 02:57:54.430
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP.
02:57:54.497 --> 02:57:55.931
THEY DID HEIR OWN SURVEY WHERE
02:57:55.998 --> 02:57:57.400
THEY ONLY FOUND --
02:57:57.466 --> 02:58:00.069
THAT 40% OF FOOD WRAPPERS HAD P.
02:58:00.136 --> 02:58:02.338
FASTEST 260% DIDN'T.
02:58:02.405 --> 02:58:04.106
AND SO THE QUESTION REALLY IS IS
02:58:04.173 --> 02:58:05.641
IS THERE REALLY A PURPOSE TO
02:58:05.708 --> 02:58:06.475
HAVE.
02:58:06.542 --> 02:58:08.511
THE P. FAST CHEMICAL THERE ON
02:58:08.577 --> 02:58:09.912
OUR FOOD WRAPPERS TED TOUCHING
02:58:09.979 --> 02:58:11.280
OUR FOOD --
02:58:11.347 --> 02:58:12.782
WE BELIEVE THAT BY HAVING
02:58:12.848 --> 02:58:15.184
DISCLOSURE OF THIS MATERIAL
02:58:15.251 --> 02:58:16.152
WOULD ALLOW CONSUMERS TO KNOW
02:58:16.218 --> 02:58:17.887
WHAT P. FAXES ARE AS WELL AS TO
02:58:17.953 --> 02:58:19.622
ALLOW CONSUMERS TO GO MAKE THEIR
02:58:19.688 --> 02:58:20.356
OWN.
02:58:20.423 --> 02:58:21.557
DECISIONS ABOUT WHETHER THEY
02:58:21.624 --> 02:58:23.259
WOULD LIKE P. FAST IS ON THOSE
02:58:23.325 --> 02:58:25.461
MATERIALS I'M WITHOUT I RESPECT
02:58:25.528 --> 02:58:27.329
FOR US FIVE VOTE WE HAVE A THREE
02:58:27.396 --> 02:58:28.531
WITNESSES HERE --
02:58:28.597 --> 02:58:30.099
TASHA STOLBERG WHO'S A SCIENTIST
02:58:30.166 --> 02:58:30.966
WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING
02:58:31.033 --> 02:58:31.767
GROUP --
02:58:31.834 --> 02:58:33.502
ENTRY VENTURA WHOSE WITH THE
02:58:33.569 --> 02:58:35.037
CLEAN WATER ACTION AS WELL AS
02:58:35.104 --> 02:58:36.405
SUSAN LITTLE WITH THE
02:58:36.472 --> 02:58:38.507
ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP
02:58:38.574 --> 02:58:39.008
AVAILABLE TO ANSWER ANY
02:58:39.075 --> 02:58:39.775
QUESTIONS.
02:58:39.842 --> 02:58:44.847
FIRST WITNESSES PERKS WITNESSES.
02:58:44.914 --> 02:58:47.550
WITH CLEAN WATER ACTION AND WE
02:58:47.616 --> 02:58:48.918
HAVE CO SPONSORED THIS BILL AND
02:58:48.984 --> 02:58:50.519
THANK.
02:58:50.586 --> 02:58:52.154
ASSEMBLYMEMBER TANG FOR BECAUSE
02:58:52.221 --> 02:58:54.156
INDEPENDENT SCIENTISTS FROM
02:58:54.223 --> 02:58:56.492
HARVARD UNIVERSITY UC BERKELEY
02:58:56.559 --> 02:58:57.660
AND AROUND THE WORLD ARE
02:58:57.726 --> 02:58:59.428
SOUNDING THE ALARM ABOUT THE
02:58:59.495 --> 02:59:01.530
DANGERS OF THE ENTIRE CLASS OF
02:59:01.597 --> 02:59:03.332
CHEMICALS KNOWN AS P. FAST.
02:59:03.399 --> 02:59:05.167
AND THOSE DANGERS THAT THEY POST
02:59:05.234 --> 02:59:06.702
HUMAN HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
02:59:06.769 --> 02:59:08.571
UP THE JUST A REMINDER THAT THE
02:59:08.637 --> 02:59:10.239
U. S. -- EPA
02:59:10.306 --> 02:59:12.708
HAS CONFIRMED THAT FOOD FOOD
02:59:12.775 --> 02:59:14.877
PACKAGING AND COOKWARE ARE MAJOR
02:59:14.944 --> 02:59:17.346
PATHWAYS OF YOU MEAN EXPOSURE TO
02:59:17.413 --> 02:59:19.482
THESE CHEMICALS.
02:59:19.548 --> 02:59:22.318
AND YET THE FDA ARE WHICH IS
02:59:22.384 --> 02:59:24.053
REGULATING THEM IN FOOD.
02:59:24.120 --> 02:59:27.022
JEAN PRIMARILY DEPENDS ON A SELF
02:59:27.089 --> 02:59:28.257
INTO INDUSTRY BASED SELF
02:59:28.324 --> 02:59:29.792
CERTIFICATION.
02:59:29.859 --> 02:59:32.027
OF SAFETY OF CHEMICALS
02:59:32.094 --> 02:59:34.130
CONSEQUENTLY WE ARE SEEN --
02:59:34.196 --> 02:59:36.332
KNOWN AND SUSPECTED CARCINOGENS
02:59:36.398 --> 02:59:37.700
MUTAGENS NANDOR CURRENT
02:59:37.766 --> 02:59:41.270
DISRUPTORS ALLOWED BY THE FDA
02:59:41.337 --> 02:59:42.805
INTO FOOD PACKAGING BUT WE DO
02:59:42.872 --> 02:59:45.341
NOT HAVE OUR GREEN CHEMISTRY.
02:59:45.407 --> 02:59:47.076
WELL ABOVE WHICH WAS LAST YEAR'S
02:59:47.143 --> 02:59:48.744
FULLER JUST GOING TO ADDRESS
02:59:48.811 --> 02:59:49.979
THAT -- JUST
02:59:50.045 --> 02:59:51.914
TO SAY THAT TODAY WE HAVE NO
02:59:51.981 --> 02:59:53.415
COMMITMENT FROM THAT PROGRAM THE
02:59:53.482 --> 02:59:54.884
SAFER CONSUMER PRODUCTS PROGRAM
02:59:54.950 --> 02:59:56.085
THAT WILL ADDRESS THESE
02:59:56.152 --> 02:59:58.120
CHEMICALS IN FOOD PACKAGING --
02:59:58.187 --> 03:00:01.157
AND IF THEY ACTUALLY DO DECIDE
03:00:01.223 --> 03:00:03.058
TO TAKE THIS ON IN THE NEXT FEW
03:00:03.125 --> 03:00:05.261
YEARS IT COULD TAKE UPWARDS OF
03:00:05.327 --> 03:00:06.262
TEN YEARS --
03:00:06.328 --> 03:00:07.963
DURING WHICH OF THE PUBLIC WILL
03:00:08.030 --> 03:00:10.032
CONTINUE TO BE EXPOSED AND GIVEN
03:00:10.099 --> 03:00:11.767
THE URGENCY EXPRESSED BY
03:00:11.834 --> 03:00:13.302
SCIENTISTS WORLDWIDE WE FEEL
03:00:13.369 --> 03:00:14.670
THAT WE CAN'T WAIT.
03:00:14.737 --> 03:00:16.138
AS THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER SAID
03:00:16.205 --> 03:00:18.407
THERE ARE ALTERNATIVES OUT THERE
03:00:18.474 --> 03:00:20.543
ARE CALIFORNIANS HAVE THE RIGHT
03:00:20.609 --> 03:00:21.277
TO KNOW WHAT THEY ARE CONSUMING
03:00:21.343 --> 03:00:22.545
AND MAYBE NINE FIFTY WOULD DO
03:00:22.611 --> 03:00:23.078
THAT.
03:00:23.145 --> 03:00:24.914
AND THE LABELING WILL HELP OUT
03:00:24.980 --> 03:00:27.950
EXACTLY DROPS NEXT WITNESS.
03:00:28.017 --> 03:00:30.152
Q. COMMITTEE AND CHAIR ON MONDAY
03:00:30.219 --> 03:00:31.320
MASSAGE SERVER IN A SENIOR
03:00:31.387 --> 03:00:32.888
SCIENTIST WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL
03:00:32.955 --> 03:00:34.223
WORKING GROUP AND I HOLD THE PGA
03:00:34.290 --> 03:00:36.592
AN ENVIRONMENTAL COME.
03:00:36.659 --> 03:00:37.793
THE ENVIRONMENTAL WORKING GROUP
03:00:37.860 --> 03:00:39.495
ASKED THE COMMITTEE APPROVE AB
03:00:39.562 --> 03:00:40.930
NINE FIFTY EIGHT AS URGENT THAT
03:00:40.996 --> 03:00:42.431
WE ADDRESS CONSUMER EXPOSURES TO
03:00:42.498 --> 03:00:43.732
FLORA NEEDED CHEMICALS IN FOOD
03:00:43.799 --> 03:00:46.435
PACKAGING NOW.
03:00:46.502 --> 03:00:47.870
AS MANY AS TEN YEARS AGO FTA
03:00:47.937 --> 03:00:49.572
SCIENTISTS FOUND THAT THESE
03:00:49.638 --> 03:00:51.073
CHEMICALS ARE GETTING INTO FOOD
03:00:51.140 --> 03:00:52.508
FROM FOOD PACKAGING --
03:00:52.575 --> 03:00:53.542
ESPECIALLY WHEN THE FOOD
03:00:53.609 --> 03:00:54.843
PACKAGING IS HEATED OR WHEN THE
03:00:54.910 --> 03:00:56.445
FOOD IS GREASY.
03:00:56.512 --> 03:00:57.713
WE ALSO KNOW FROM STUDIES FROM
03:00:57.780 --> 03:00:59.848
SCIENTISTS AT DUKE THAT BEHAVIOR
03:00:59.915 --> 03:01:01.483
SUCH AS EATING MICROWAVED FOODS
03:01:01.550 --> 03:01:03.252
ARE LINKED TO HIGHER LEVELS OF
03:01:03.319 --> 03:01:04.720
THESE FLORA NEEDED SHORT CHAIN
03:01:04.787 --> 03:01:06.188
CHEMICALS IN BLOOD.
03:01:06.255 --> 03:01:07.690
AND THESE ARE THE SAME COMPOUNDS
03:01:07.756 --> 03:01:09.058
THE INDEPENDENT SCIENTISTS AT
03:01:09.124 --> 03:01:10.426
HARVARD HAVE FOUND TO BE TOXIC
03:01:10.492 --> 03:01:12.528
TO BE MEAN SYSTEM.
03:01:12.595 --> 03:01:13.662
INDEPENDENT SCIENTISTS HAVE NOW
03:01:13.729 --> 03:01:14.697
DETERMINED THAT THE DAILY
03:01:14.763 --> 03:01:16.665
EXPOSURE LIMITS OF PEOPLE ASSN
03:01:16.732 --> 03:01:18.534
P. PFOA IN DIETARY SOURCES
03:01:18.601 --> 03:01:20.069
SHOULD BE DRASTICALLY REDUCED BY
03:01:20.135 --> 03:01:22.504
AS MUCH AS TWO THOUSAND TIMES.
03:01:22.571 --> 03:01:23.772
AND THIS NEW EXPOSURE LIMIT
03:01:23.839 --> 03:01:25.074
MAKES THE MIGRATION FROM PANTS
03:01:25.140 --> 03:01:26.842
AND BAKEWARE AND RAPPERS ARE
03:01:26.909 --> 03:01:29.044
VERY RELEVANT SOURCE OF EXPOSURE.
03:01:29.111 --> 03:01:30.379
THE LEVEL OF CONCERN ABOUT THESE
03:01:30.446 --> 03:01:32.548
CHEMICALS HAS INCREASED OVER THE
03:01:32.615 --> 03:01:33.749
PAST DECADE TO THE POINT THAT WE
03:01:33.816 --> 03:01:35.584
ARE CONCERNED ABOUT --
03:01:35.651 --> 03:01:36.919
LEVELS AS LOW AS ONE PER PER
03:01:36.986 --> 03:01:38.687
TRILLION IN DRINKING WATER AND
03:01:38.754 --> 03:01:40.189
IN SHORT ANY ADDITIONAL EXPOSURE
03:01:40.256 --> 03:01:43.959
FROM FOOD OR WATER IS A CONCERN.
03:01:44.026 --> 03:01:45.160
SEARCHING PEOPLE ASKING LOCALS
03:01:45.227 --> 03:01:46.495
SHOULD NOT.
03:01:46.562 --> 03:01:47.696
BE YEAR --
03:01:47.763 --> 03:01:49.431
VIEWED AS A VIABLE ALTERNATIVE
03:01:49.498 --> 03:01:50.733
AS THEY HAVE NOT BEEN ADEQUATELY
03:01:50.799 --> 03:01:52.735
TESTED AND SOME OF THE SAME
03:01:52.801 --> 03:01:54.536
ALTERNATIVES EXHIBIT SIMILAR
03:01:54.603 --> 03:01:57.506
HEALTH IMPACTS. TO LONG CHAIN AS
03:01:57.573 --> 03:01:59.375
LAUNCHING CHEMICALS SUCH AS
03:01:59.441 --> 03:02:00.876
TOXIC CITY TO THE MEAN SYSTEM
03:02:00.943 --> 03:02:01.877
LIVER TOXICITY IN HORMONE
03:02:01.944 --> 03:02:03.345
DISRUPTION.
03:02:03.412 --> 03:02:04.680
AND THEY ALSO HAVE THE SAME
03:02:04.747 --> 03:02:06.382
PERSISTENCE IN THE ENVIRONMENT
03:02:06.448 --> 03:02:08.183
AS LONG CHAIN P. FAST.
03:02:08.250 --> 03:02:10.252
AND THEREFORE HAVE THE POTENTIAL
03:02:10.319 --> 03:02:11.487
TO CONTAMINATE DRINKING WATER AS
03:02:11.553 --> 03:02:12.421
WE'RE NOW SEEING WITH GEN X.
03:02:12.488 --> 03:02:14.590
CHEMICALS.
03:02:14.657 --> 03:02:15.758
FURTHER STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT
03:02:15.824 --> 03:02:17.159
SHORT CHAIN P. FAST ACCUMULATE
03:02:17.226 --> 03:02:19.028
IN BODY ORGANS FROM STUDIES FROM
03:02:19.094 --> 03:02:20.863
HUMAN CADAVERS AND ALSO A RECENT
03:02:20.929 --> 03:02:21.597
STUDY.
03:02:21.664 --> 03:02:22.898
BY SCIENTISTS AT NOTRE DAME IN
03:02:22.965 --> 03:02:24.333
THE UNIVERSITY OF ALABAMA THEY
03:02:24.400 --> 03:02:26.035
FOUND P. FOSS.
03:02:26.101 --> 03:02:27.436
IN EVERY ORGAN THE EXAMINED
03:02:27.503 --> 03:02:29.271
INCLUDING LONGS.
03:02:29.338 --> 03:02:32.708
BRAIN LIVER AND KIDNEYS --
03:02:32.775 --> 03:02:34.376
LAUNCHING P. FAST AS WE'VE SAID
03:02:34.443 --> 03:02:35.811
WERE USED FOR DECADES BEFORE WE
03:02:35.878 --> 03:02:36.945
FULLY UNDERSTAND THE SERIOUS
03:02:37.012 --> 03:02:38.080
HEALTH RISK THAT THEY POSE
03:02:38.147 --> 03:02:39.581
INCLUDING CANCER.
03:02:39.648 --> 03:02:41.050
THYROID DISEASE REDUCED IMMUNITY
03:02:41.116 --> 03:02:42.718
HORMONE DISRUPTION LOW BIRTH
03:02:42.785 --> 03:02:44.320
RATE AND OTHERS.
03:02:44.386 --> 03:02:46.021
SO WE FEEL CONSUMER SHOULD HAVE
03:02:46.088 --> 03:02:47.289
THE INFORMATION THAT THEY NEED
03:02:47.356 --> 03:02:49.692
TO EASILY AVOID ALL EXPOSURES TO
03:02:49.758 --> 03:02:50.759
FLORIDA CHEMICALS IN FOOD
03:02:50.826 --> 03:02:51.994
PACKAGING AND COOKWARE.
03:02:52.061 --> 03:02:53.495
AND THIS IS POSSIBLE SINCE
03:02:53.562 --> 03:02:54.063
ALTERNATIVES ARE ALREADY IN
03:02:54.129 --> 03:02:56.265
PLACE -- FOR
03:02:56.332 --> 03:02:58.300
THESE REASONS AND THAT FLORIDA
03:02:58.367 --> 03:02:59.935
CHEMICALS ARE FOUND IN THE BLOOD
03:03:00.002 --> 03:03:01.670
OF VIRTUALLY ALL AMERICANS.
03:03:01.737 --> 03:03:03.205
AT LEVELS THAT CAN CAUSE HEALTH
03:03:03.272 --> 03:03:04.540
IMPACTS ANY ADDITIONAL
03:03:04.606 --> 03:03:05.808
CONTROLLABLE EXPOSURE SHOULD BE
03:03:05.874 --> 03:03:07.843
AVOIDED.
03:03:07.910 --> 03:03:09.311
THEREFORE CONSUMERS HAVE A RIGHT
03:03:09.378 --> 03:03:09.912
TO KNOW WHAT IS IN THEIR FOOD
03:03:09.978 --> 03:03:11.113
PACKAGING.
03:03:11.180 --> 03:03:14.383
THANK YOU THANK YOU DOCTOR NEXT.
03:03:14.450 --> 03:03:15.017
IF YOU'RE JUST BEGINNING
03:03:15.084 --> 03:03:15.317
[inaudible]
03:03:15.384 --> 03:03:17.753
COMMITTEES.
03:03:17.820 --> 03:03:18.721
ASK FOR THE COMMITTEE SUPPORT
03:03:18.787 --> 03:03:20.022
FOR THE SPELL THANK YOU OTHER
03:03:20.089 --> 03:03:24.259
OTHERS HERE IN SUPPORT OF AB AND
03:03:24.326 --> 03:03:25.094
NINE FIFTY EIGHT BY.
03:03:25.160 --> 03:03:26.495
SOMEONE PICKING IT MISTER
03:03:26.562 --> 03:03:27.596
CHAIRMAN AMHERST POLIO OR BEHALF
03:03:27.663 --> 03:03:29.031
OF SITTING COUNTY SAN FRANCISCO
03:03:29.098 --> 03:03:29.798
FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENT
03:03:29.865 --> 03:03:31.200
PERSPECTIVE THESE CHEMICALS
03:03:31.266 --> 03:03:32.768
DON'T BREAK DOWN TO CONTAMINATE
03:03:32.835 --> 03:03:34.269
COMPOST THE COST LOCAL
03:03:34.336 --> 03:03:36.004
GOVERNMENTS MONEY PERJURE SPORT
03:03:36.071 --> 03:03:38.874
IN THE BILL THANK YOU.
03:03:38.941 --> 03:03:40.075
THE TERM JUST MALONE FLEW LOCAL
03:03:40.142 --> 03:03:41.276
ENVIRONMENT HEALTH DIRECTORS FOR
03:03:41.343 --> 03:03:42.878
THE REASONS STATED WE VERY MUCH
03:03:42.945 --> 03:03:46.048
IN SUPPORT OF IT.
03:03:46.115 --> 03:03:47.349
THERESA BURKE MITCH ON BEHALF OF
03:03:47.416 --> 03:03:49.118
HE'LL AVE WHICH TOYOTA MASH
03:03:49.184 --> 03:03:50.552
FOUNDATION THE FIVE DRYERS
03:03:50.619 --> 03:03:51.987
INSTITUTE. SEVEN GENERATION
03:03:52.054 --> 03:03:53.756
ADVISER CENTER FOR OCEANIC
03:03:53.822 --> 03:03:54.790
AWARENESS POSSE POLLUTION
03:03:54.857 --> 03:03:56.225
COALITION AND UPSTREAM AND
03:03:56.291 --> 03:03:59.128
SUPPORT.
03:03:59.194 --> 03:04:00.095
I HAVE A COUSIN OF VOTE THE
03:04:00.162 --> 03:04:00.696
SENATE FROM BERMAN HEALTH AND
03:04:00.763 --> 03:04:02.798
SUPPORT.
03:04:02.865 --> 03:04:04.266
NIKITA CRIED WITH THE NATURAL
03:04:04.333 --> 03:04:04.833
RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL IN
03:04:04.900 --> 03:04:07.436
SUPPORT.
03:04:07.503 --> 03:04:08.637
PERO I AM ON BEHALF OF THE
03:04:08.704 --> 03:04:09.571
BREAST CANCER PREVENTION
03:04:09.638 --> 03:04:12.374
PARTNERS IN SUPPORT.
03:04:12.441 --> 03:04:13.675
KELLY MAY BE WITH CALIFORNIANS
03:04:13.742 --> 03:04:16.345
AGAINST WASTE IN SUPPORT.
03:04:16.412 --> 03:04:20.249
LET'S HEAR FROM OPPOSITION THIS
03:04:20.315 --> 03:04:20.883
NINE FIFTY NINE ITEM NUMBER FOUR
03:04:20.949 --> 03:04:33.195
ON OUR AGENDA.
03:04:33.262 --> 03:04:33.796
IT'S A LITTLE BIT MORE THAN A
03:04:33.862 --> 03:04:39.034
LIGHTLY DEL.
03:04:39.101 --> 03:04:40.803
PLEASE GOOD MORNING.
03:04:40.869 --> 03:04:42.137
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
03:04:42.204 --> 03:04:43.105
ATTEMPTS JUST IT WITH THE
03:04:43.172 --> 03:04:44.840
AMERICAN CHEMISTRY COUNCIL A WE
03:04:44.907 --> 03:04:46.442
ARE OPPOSED TO THE BILL --
03:04:46.508 --> 03:04:47.876
IN ITS CURRENT FORM --
03:04:47.943 --> 03:04:48.444
IN OUR VIEW OF THE CREATE A
03:04:48.510 --> 03:04:50.846
SWEEPING.
03:04:50.913 --> 03:04:52.581
IN ACCURATE LABELING REQUIREMENT
03:04:52.648 --> 03:04:54.116
FOR FOOD PACKAGING AND COOKWARE
03:04:54.183 --> 03:04:55.384
THAT CONTAINS ALL THESE
03:04:55.451 --> 03:04:56.985
PERFORMED EIGHTY CHEMISTRIES.
03:04:57.052 --> 03:04:58.754
I ARGUE IT'S BASED ON A
03:04:58.821 --> 03:04:59.922
PRESUMPTION THAT THE MERE
03:04:59.988 --> 03:05:01.290
DETECTION OF THESE CHEMISTRIES
03:05:01.356 --> 03:05:02.458
IN THESE PRODUCTS --
03:05:02.524 --> 03:05:03.625
EQUATES TO A NEGATIVE IMPACT ON
03:05:03.692 --> 03:05:04.993
HUMAN HEALTH.
03:05:05.060 --> 03:05:06.628
AND IN OUR VIEW THAT PREMISE IS
03:05:06.695 --> 03:05:08.730
FALSE AND IS NOT AN ISSUE TO ME
03:05:08.797 --> 03:05:10.165
DOES CONTRADICT A GENERAL
03:05:10.232 --> 03:05:11.867
SCIENTIFIC PRINCIPLES.
03:05:11.934 --> 03:05:13.936
WHILE PEOPLE US ANOTHER
03:05:14.002 --> 03:05:15.037
SUBSTANCES CAN CERTAINLY BE
03:05:15.103 --> 03:05:18.006
DETECTED OF YEAR BIOMONITORING --
03:05:18.073 --> 03:05:19.608
PROGRAMS AND TESTING DETECTION
03:05:19.675 --> 03:05:20.542
ALONE.
03:05:20.609 --> 03:05:22.911
DOES NOT EQUATE TO AN ADVERSE
03:05:22.978 --> 03:05:24.179
HEALTH IMPACT AND THAT --
03:05:24.246 --> 03:05:25.647
POINT IS --
03:05:25.714 --> 03:05:26.682
STIPULATED --
03:05:26.748 --> 03:05:28.016
BY THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE
03:05:28.083 --> 03:05:29.518
CONTROL AND PREVENTION THEY
03:05:29.585 --> 03:05:30.185
MANAGE THE WORLD'S MOST
03:05:30.252 --> 03:05:31.720
PREEMINENT OF BY A MONITORING
03:05:31.787 --> 03:05:32.921
PROGRAM THAT ASSESSES HUMAN
03:05:32.988 --> 03:05:34.456
EXPOSURE --
03:05:34.523 --> 03:05:36.658
TO ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMICALS --
03:05:36.725 --> 03:05:38.827
THE PROPOSED LABEL.
03:05:38.894 --> 03:05:40.929
ACQUIRED BY EIGHTY NINE FIFTY
03:05:40.996 --> 03:05:42.064
EIGHT FALSELY SUGGEST THAT THESE
03:05:42.130 --> 03:05:43.465
PERFORMED A CHEMISTRIES ALL
03:05:43.532 --> 03:05:44.633
SHARE THE SAME PROPERTIES AND
03:05:44.700 --> 03:05:46.068
HAS OUR PROFILES.
03:05:46.134 --> 03:05:48.036
THAT IS NOT THE CASE.
03:05:48.103 --> 03:05:49.605
I IN FACT A SUBSTANTIAL BODY OF
03:05:49.671 --> 03:05:51.073
EVIDENCE SUGGESTS THAT THE
03:05:51.139 --> 03:05:52.274
CONCLUSION THAT A HANDFUL OF
03:05:52.341 --> 03:05:53.442
PEOPLE US IS THAT ARE CURRENTLY
03:05:53.509 --> 03:05:54.610
APPROVED FOR USE IN FOOD
03:05:54.676 --> 03:05:56.345
PACKAGING AND COOKWARE.
03:05:56.411 --> 03:05:58.213
ARE SAFE FOR THEIR INTENDED USE.
03:05:58.280 --> 03:06:00.916
THE PROPOSED BILL AND LABELING
03:06:00.983 --> 03:06:03.085
LANGUAGE ON ON ON THE LABEL --
03:06:03.151 --> 03:06:04.286
IN ARGUES EXTREMELY MISLEADING
03:06:04.353 --> 03:06:06.088
TO CONSUMERS.
03:06:06.154 --> 03:06:07.489
ARE THE SECOND POINT I WOULD
03:06:07.556 --> 03:06:08.891
MAKE IS THAT THERE ARE TWO A
03:06:08.957 --> 03:06:10.158
LABELING REQUIREMENTS AND
03:06:10.225 --> 03:06:11.593
PROGRAMS IN PLACE THAT WE THINK
03:06:11.660 --> 03:06:13.061
THIS PROGRAM OR THIS YOU SEE
03:06:13.128 --> 03:06:14.796
THIS BILL SIDE STEPS IN AND LEAP
03:06:14.863 --> 03:06:15.430
FROGS.
03:06:15.497 --> 03:06:16.765
OF YOU ALREADY MENTIONED THAT
03:06:16.832 --> 03:06:18.267
THE DTS HE PROGRAM A SAFER
03:06:18.333 --> 03:06:19.902
CONSUMER PRODUCTS PROGRAM --
03:06:19.968 --> 03:06:21.370
ESTABLISHING A PROCESS TO
03:06:21.436 --> 03:06:23.272
IDENTIFY PRIORITIZE AND AS
03:06:23.338 --> 03:06:24.806
NECESSARY EVALUATE --
03:06:24.873 --> 03:06:26.675
CHEMICALS OF CONCERN IN CONSUMER
03:06:26.742 --> 03:06:28.477
PRODUCTS --
03:06:28.544 --> 03:06:30.479
AS THE COMMITTEE KNOWS THAT --
03:06:30.546 --> 03:06:32.281
DTS HE HAS A BROAD AUTHORITY TO
03:06:32.347 --> 03:06:34.516
REGULATE IF IT DETERMINES --
03:06:34.583 --> 03:06:36.218
THAT A REGULATORY RESPONSE IS
03:06:36.285 --> 03:06:38.353
WARRANTED NOT ONLY JUST LABELING
03:06:38.420 --> 03:06:40.122
REQUIREMENTS BUT ALSO OUT RIGHT --
03:06:40.188 --> 03:06:41.223
BANDS --
03:06:41.290 --> 03:06:43.091
JUST THIS YEAR DTC IDIOCY ADDED
03:06:43.158 --> 03:06:44.359
FOOD PACKAGING --
03:06:44.426 --> 03:06:46.461
TO ITS TWENTY EIGHTEEN TWENTY
03:06:46.528 --> 03:06:47.062
TWENTY PRIORITY PRODUCT WORK
03:06:47.129 --> 03:06:47.696
PLAN.
03:06:47.763 --> 03:06:48.664
OUT FURTHER --
03:06:48.730 --> 03:06:50.966
VALIDATING IN OUR VIEW THAT
03:06:51.033 --> 03:06:52.401
PREMATURE THIS.
03:06:52.467 --> 03:06:54.236
I THINK DISCUSSION IN SITUATION
03:06:54.303 --> 03:06:56.071
WE HAVE TODAY THE FORCE IS
03:06:56.138 --> 03:06:57.272
EXACTLY THE SORT OF SITUATION
03:06:57.339 --> 03:06:59.374
THE LEGISLATURE HOPE TO AVOID --
03:06:59.441 --> 03:07:00.242
WENT PAST --
03:07:00.309 --> 03:07:01.810
THE GREEN CHEMISTRY LAW A
03:07:01.877 --> 03:07:03.912
SEVERAL YEARS AGO.
03:07:03.979 --> 03:07:05.614
ARE THE BILL ALSO --
03:07:05.681 --> 03:07:07.182
IN OUR VIEW CIRCUMVENT A
03:07:07.249 --> 03:07:09.851
PROPHECY FIVE PROCESS --
03:07:09.918 --> 03:07:11.119
AND REQUIRES MANUFACTURERS TO
03:07:11.186 --> 03:07:12.888
LABEL THEIR PRODUCTS REGARDLESS
03:07:12.955 --> 03:07:13.722
OF WHETHER THE SCIENTIFIC
03:07:13.789 --> 03:07:14.823
EVIDENCE.
03:07:14.890 --> 03:07:16.658
AYE JUSTIFIES SUCH ACTION IN
03:07:16.725 --> 03:07:17.693
FACT THERE ARE PEOPLE ASKING
03:07:17.759 --> 03:07:18.994
MYSTERIES ARE PROOFREAD TO
03:07:19.061 --> 03:07:20.829
COOKWARE FOOD PACKAGING OF THAT
03:07:20.896 --> 03:07:21.897
YOU NOT MEET THE LISTING
03:07:21.964 --> 03:07:23.465
CRITERION ACROSS.
03:07:23.532 --> 03:07:24.099
SIXTY FIVE IT WOULD BE CALLED
03:07:24.166 --> 03:07:26.234
OUT FOR NEARLY EQUIVALENT
03:07:26.301 --> 03:07:27.169
LABELING REQUIREMENTS --
03:07:27.235 --> 03:07:29.338
UNDER THIS BILL.
03:07:29.404 --> 03:07:30.806
SO AS YOU AFTER THIS BILL WOULD
03:07:30.872 --> 03:07:32.274
RESULT IN OUR VIEW A CONFUSING
03:07:32.341 --> 03:07:33.675
WARNING ON THE SOLE BASIS OF THE
03:07:33.742 --> 03:07:35.210
PRODUCT CONTAINS A CHEMICAL.
03:07:35.277 --> 03:07:37.245
RATHER THAT POSES ANY SORT OF
03:07:37.312 --> 03:07:39.381
RISK AND THIS WOULD CONTRIBUTE
03:07:39.448 --> 03:07:40.315
TO THE OVER WARNING PROBLEM THAT
03:07:40.382 --> 03:07:41.283
WE'VE HAD A NUMBER OF
03:07:41.350 --> 03:07:42.818
DISCUSSIONS ABOUT --
03:07:42.884 --> 03:07:44.286
IN THIS IN THIS LEGISLATIVE BODY
03:07:44.353 --> 03:07:45.554
OVER THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS AND
03:07:45.621 --> 03:07:46.989
SO FOR THESE REASONS WE WOULD
03:07:47.055 --> 03:07:48.090
URGE A NO VOTE THANK YOU.
03:07:48.156 --> 03:07:49.825
NEXT WITNESS.
03:07:49.891 --> 03:07:51.059
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
03:07:51.126 --> 03:07:51.927
TO THE COMMITTEE FOR THE
03:07:51.994 --> 03:07:53.128
OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH YOU
03:07:53.195 --> 03:07:53.528
TODAY.
03:07:53.595 --> 03:07:55.163
MY NAME IS JESSICA BERMAN AND I
03:07:55.230 --> 03:07:56.398
REPRESENT THE FLORA COUNCIL
03:07:56.465 --> 03:07:57.499
WHICH IS AN ASSOCIATION
03:07:57.566 --> 03:07:59.067
REPRESENTING MAJOR MANUFACTURERS
03:07:59.134 --> 03:08:00.869
OF PRODUCTS BASED ON PER POLY
03:08:00.936 --> 03:08:02.170
FLORA KILL SUBSTANCES ARE P.
03:08:02.237 --> 03:08:03.005
FAST.
03:08:03.071 --> 03:08:04.539
A WITH REGARD TO THIS BILL WE
03:08:04.606 --> 03:08:06.308
RESPECTFULLY OPPOSE IT AFRICA
03:08:06.375 --> 03:08:07.843
REASONS FIRST WE THINK THE BILL
03:08:07.909 --> 03:08:09.177
INAPPROPRIATELY CHARACTERIZES
03:08:09.244 --> 03:08:10.579
ALL P. FAST AS PRESENTING
03:08:10.646 --> 03:08:13.115
SIMILAR TOXICITY CONCERNS.
03:08:13.181 --> 03:08:14.316
ARE AND THEN WE ALSO THINK THE
03:08:14.383 --> 03:08:16.084
BILL CONTRADICTS FDA'S SAFETY
03:08:16.151 --> 03:08:18.520
FINDINGS ON THE SPECIFIC P. FAST
03:08:18.587 --> 03:08:20.455
THAT ARE USED IN FOOD PACKAGING
03:08:20.522 --> 03:08:21.890
AND COOKWARE.
03:08:21.957 --> 03:08:22.991
SO IT'S IMPORTANT UNDERSTAND
03:08:23.058 --> 03:08:25.260
THAT P. FAST IS VERY BROAD AND
03:08:25.327 --> 03:08:26.628
DIVERSE FAMILY OF CHEMISTRY
03:08:26.695 --> 03:08:28.563
INCLUDES OVER FOUR THOUSAND A
03:08:28.630 --> 03:08:30.298
DIFFERENT SUBSTANCES THEIR VERY
03:08:30.365 --> 03:08:31.133
SIGNIFICANTLY IN THEIR
03:08:31.199 --> 03:08:31.867
PROPERTIES.
03:08:31.933 --> 03:08:33.368
IN THERE YOU SAYS AND IN THEIR
03:08:33.435 --> 03:08:35.537
TOXICITY PROFILES THEREFORE IT'S
03:08:35.604 --> 03:08:37.539
WHOLLY INACCURATE TO MAKE BROAD
03:08:37.606 --> 03:08:39.541
SWEEPING STATEMENTS ABOUT ALL P.
03:08:39.608 --> 03:08:41.943
FAST AS THIS BILL AIMS TO DO.
03:08:42.010 --> 03:08:43.211
SOME P. FAST HAVE BEEN
03:08:43.278 --> 03:08:44.613
ASSOCIATED WITH POTENTIAL
03:08:44.680 --> 03:08:46.081
ADVERSE HEALTH EFFECTS ON THESE
03:08:46.148 --> 03:08:47.516
DO INCLUDE TO SPECIFIC
03:08:47.582 --> 03:08:49.184
SUBSTANCES IN THIS P. FAST
03:08:49.251 --> 03:08:50.485
FAMILY.
03:08:50.552 --> 03:08:51.586
PFOS AND PFOA WHICH YOU'VE
03:08:51.653 --> 03:08:53.221
ALREADY HEARD ABOUT THOSE
03:08:53.288 --> 03:08:54.222
SUBSTANCES HAVEN'T BEEN
03:08:54.289 --> 03:08:56.391
MANUFACTURED IN THE U. S. EUROPE
03:08:56.458 --> 03:08:58.660
OR JAPAN IN YEARS.
03:08:58.727 --> 03:08:59.594
ALTHOUGH PRODUCTION DOES
03:08:59.661 --> 03:09:01.329
CONTINUE AND OTHER PLACES IN THE
03:09:01.396 --> 03:09:02.230
WORLD.
03:09:02.297 --> 03:09:03.098
I'M EATIN POORLY THOSE
03:09:03.165 --> 03:09:05.534
SUBSTANCES ARE NOT USED IN FOOD
03:09:05.600 --> 03:09:08.170
PACKAGING OR AND COOKWARE.
03:09:08.236 --> 03:09:09.171
HOWEVER AT THOSE SPEEDS OUT
03:09:09.237 --> 03:09:10.772
SUBSTANCES DO COMPRISE MOST OF
03:09:10.839 --> 03:09:11.506
THE DISCUSSION --
03:09:11.573 --> 03:09:12.174
IN THE COMMITTEES AND THE
03:09:12.240 --> 03:09:14.810
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS.
03:09:14.876 --> 03:09:17.145
FROM A CHEMISTRY INTO TOXICITY
03:09:17.212 --> 03:09:18.747
STANDPOINT THE P. FAST THAT ARE
03:09:18.814 --> 03:09:20.749
USED IN FOOD PACKAGING AND AND
03:09:20.816 --> 03:09:22.784
COOKWARE DIFFER SIGNIFICANTLY
03:09:22.851 --> 03:09:24.853
FROM THOSE PHASE OUT SUBSTANCES
03:09:24.920 --> 03:09:26.755
AND THEY'RE NOT FOUND.
03:09:26.822 --> 03:09:28.056
IN HUMANS THROUGH BY MONITORING
03:09:28.123 --> 03:09:29.825
STUDIES AND THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
03:09:29.891 --> 03:09:31.093
POINT BECAUSE WHAT'S ACTUALLY
03:09:31.159 --> 03:09:32.761
USED IN.
03:09:32.828 --> 03:09:34.262
FOOD PACKAGING AND COOKWARE ARE
03:09:34.329 --> 03:09:35.964
POLYMERS PALMER'S ARE NOT
03:09:36.031 --> 03:09:37.899
BIOAVAILABLE WHICH MEANS YOUR
03:09:37.966 --> 03:09:39.968
BODY CAN ABSORB THEM --
03:09:40.035 --> 03:09:41.069
AND THERE THEY DON'T PRESENT
03:09:41.136 --> 03:09:43.605
TOXICITY CONCERNS --
03:09:43.672 --> 03:09:45.674
AND AND I'D ALSO POINT OUT THAT
03:09:45.741 --> 03:09:47.609
ONLY P. FAUSTIN PFOA HAVE BEEN
03:09:47.676 --> 03:09:50.078
ADDED TO A PROP SIXTY FIVE BY A
03:09:50.145 --> 03:09:50.645
WEEK ON THAT HAPPENED A FEW
03:09:50.712 --> 03:09:51.947
MONTHS AGO.
03:09:52.013 --> 03:09:53.515
SO WITHIN THE FAMILY THIS BROAD
03:09:53.582 --> 03:09:54.883
FAMILY OF P. FAST CHEMISTRY
03:09:54.950 --> 03:09:56.718
THERE'S A SMALL SUBSET OF THOSE
03:09:56.785 --> 03:09:58.220
SUBSTANCES THAT ARE USED IN FOOD
03:09:58.286 --> 03:09:59.354
PACKAGING.
03:09:59.421 --> 03:10:01.389
SPECIFICALLY IN SOME PAPER AND
03:10:01.456 --> 03:10:02.924
PAPERBOARD PACKAGING WHERE OIL
03:10:02.991 --> 03:10:05.026
INCREASE REPELLENCY PROPERTIES
03:10:05.093 --> 03:10:06.228
ARE NEEDED CERTAINLY NOT USED IN
03:10:06.294 --> 03:10:08.463
ALL FOOD PACKAGING.
03:10:08.530 --> 03:10:10.398
AND IMPORTANTLY FOOD PACKAGING
03:10:10.465 --> 03:10:11.700
TREATED WITH P. FAST CAN BE
03:10:11.767 --> 03:10:13.635
RECYCLED OR COMPOSTED WHEREAS
03:10:13.702 --> 03:10:15.637
MOST ALTERNATIVES CANNOT.
03:10:15.704 --> 03:10:17.405
THERE'S ANOTHER SMALL SUBSET OF
03:10:17.472 --> 03:10:18.974
PEAPOD'S CHEMISTRY THAT USING
03:10:19.040 --> 03:10:20.575
COOKWARE WORDS USED TO PROVIDE
03:10:20.642 --> 03:10:21.910
NONSTICK PROPERTIES IN PRODUCTS
03:10:21.977 --> 03:10:23.678
LIKE FRYING PANS.
03:10:23.745 --> 03:10:25.514
BECAUSE BOTH OF THESE ARE FOOD
03:10:25.580 --> 03:10:27.149
CONTACT APPLICATIONS THEY'RE
03:10:27.215 --> 03:10:28.917
SUBJECT TO REGULATION AT THE
03:10:28.984 --> 03:10:30.752
FEDERAL LEVEL BY THE US FOOD AND
03:10:30.819 --> 03:10:32.788
DRUG ADMINISTRATION.
03:10:32.854 --> 03:10:34.055
THE PRODUCTS THAT ARE USED IN
03:10:34.122 --> 03:10:35.991
THESE APPLICATIONS TODAY WERE
03:10:36.057 --> 03:10:37.526
ROUTE REVIEW BY FDA HAD A DECADE
03:10:37.592 --> 03:10:38.460
AGO WELL BEFORE THE CURRENT
03:10:38.527 --> 03:10:40.128
ADMINISTRATION.
03:10:40.195 --> 03:10:41.630
AND BEFORE ANY FOOD CONTACT
03:10:41.696 --> 03:10:43.365
SUBSTANCE CAN ENTER THE MARKET
03:10:43.431 --> 03:10:45.967
FDA REQUIRES SIGNIFICANT UPFRONT
03:10:46.034 --> 03:10:47.502
DATA ON FROM MANUFACTURES
03:10:47.569 --> 03:10:49.337
REGARDING THE TOXICITY OF THE
03:10:49.404 --> 03:10:50.939
SPECIFIC SUBSTANCE THAT ARE USED.
03:10:51.006 --> 03:10:52.307
HOW MUCH OF THOSE SUBSTANCES IS
03:10:52.374 --> 03:10:54.409
MIGRATING FROM THE PRODUCT TO
03:10:54.476 --> 03:10:56.344
THE FOOD AND HOW MUCH A PERSON
03:10:56.411 --> 03:10:58.713
EATING THAT FOOD MIGHT AND TAKE?
03:10:58.780 --> 03:11:01.016
AND BASED ON THAT DATA FTA HAS
03:11:01.082 --> 03:11:02.350
DETERMINED THAT THE SUBSTANCE IS
03:11:02.417 --> 03:11:04.252
MEET THEIR VERY STRINGENT SAFETY
03:11:04.319 --> 03:11:06.154
STANDARD OF REASONABLE CERTAINTY
03:11:06.221 --> 03:11:07.222
OF NO HARM.
03:11:07.289 --> 03:11:08.290
FINDING THESE CHEMISTRY SAFE FOR
03:11:08.356 --> 03:11:10.225
THEIR INTENDED USE.
03:11:10.292 --> 03:11:11.593
WE HAVE SIGNIFICANT CONCERNS
03:11:11.660 --> 03:11:12.828
THIS BILL WOULD NOW REQUIRE A
03:11:12.894 --> 03:11:13.929
LEGAL TO BE PLACED ON THE SAME
03:11:13.995 --> 03:11:15.297
PRODUCTS.
03:11:15.363 --> 03:11:16.765
THAT WOULD INDICATE THE P. FUSS
03:11:16.832 --> 03:11:18.800
CHEMICALS USED IN THESE PRODUCTS
03:11:18.867 --> 03:11:20.302
PRESENT ADVERSE HEALTH EFFECTS
03:11:20.368 --> 03:11:22.737
ON THEIR PRESENCE ALONE WITH NO
03:11:22.804 --> 03:11:24.339
CONSIDERATION OF ACTUAL RISK
03:11:24.406 --> 03:11:25.874
IRONICALLY THE VERY ASSESSMENT
03:11:25.941 --> 03:11:27.375
THAT FDA HAS ALREADY DONE.
03:11:27.442 --> 03:11:30.846
IN MAKING IT SAFETY TERMINATION.
03:11:30.912 --> 03:11:32.280
THIS LABEL CONTRADICTS FDA'S
03:11:32.347 --> 03:11:33.582
STRINGENT SAFETY FINDINGS
03:11:33.648 --> 03:11:35.383
INCREASE PUBLIC CONCERN THAT IS
03:11:35.450 --> 03:11:36.685
NEITHER JUSTIFIED NOR
03:11:36.751 --> 03:11:38.787
SCIENTIFICALLY BASED FOR THESE
03:11:38.854 --> 03:11:39.387
REASONS WE ASK YOU OPPOSE THE
03:11:39.454 --> 03:11:41.256
BILL.
03:11:41.323 --> 03:11:42.224
I'M GOING TO WEAR WE'RE GOING TO
03:11:42.290 --> 03:11:43.825
CONTINUE THIS CONVERSATION ON
03:11:43.892 --> 03:11:45.293
THE P. FAST FAMILY BUT LET'S
03:11:45.360 --> 03:11:47.963
HEAR FROM OTHERS OPPOSED.
03:11:48.029 --> 03:11:51.533
TO A AB.
03:11:51.600 --> 03:11:52.133
NINE FIFTY EIGHT DENNIS ALBION
03:11:52.200 --> 03:11:52.868
AB HAVE THE GROCERY
03:11:52.934 --> 03:11:54.236
MANUFACTURERS AMERICA WE OPPOSE
03:11:54.302 --> 03:11:55.604
THE BILL WITH THIS IS CLEARLY AN
03:11:55.670 --> 03:11:57.239
END RUN AROUND THE GREEN CAP SHE
03:11:57.305 --> 03:11:58.807
PROCESS WHICH WE SUPPORTED.
03:11:58.874 --> 03:12:00.141
WHEN WAS ENACTED KNOWS
03:12:00.208 --> 03:12:01.610
LEGISLATION SO THAT'S THE
03:12:01.676 --> 03:12:05.447
PROCESS THAT SHOULD A LEAD BACK?
03:12:05.513 --> 03:12:06.381
AND RIGHTLY ON BEHALF OF THE
03:12:06.448 --> 03:12:07.682
CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
03:12:07.749 --> 03:12:08.717
ALSO IN OPPOSITION FOR THE
03:12:08.783 --> 03:12:11.386
REASONS STATED THANK YOU.
03:12:11.453 --> 03:12:12.520
THANK YOU JOHN CAP KEY MCCUE
03:12:12.587 --> 03:12:13.889
CAPTAIN ASSOCIATE SOMEHOW THE
03:12:13.955 --> 03:12:15.090
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURERS AND
03:12:15.156 --> 03:12:16.825
TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION ALSO IN
03:12:16.892 --> 03:12:17.592
OPPOSE.
03:12:17.659 --> 03:12:19.628
A POSITION I ALSO JUST ECHO THE
03:12:19.694 --> 03:12:21.162
COMMENTS REGARDING THE DTS CEASE
03:12:21.229 --> 03:12:22.530
EVER CONSUMER PRODUCTS PROGRAM
03:12:22.597 --> 03:12:23.932
AND THAT PROGRAM BASED ON THE
03:12:23.999 --> 03:12:25.567
SCIENCE AND REVIEW OF THE
03:12:25.634 --> 03:12:26.801
ALTERNATIVES AVAILABLE.
03:12:26.868 --> 03:12:28.169
WOULD ACTUALLY PROVIDE A
03:12:28.236 --> 03:12:30.105
LABELING OUTSIDE OPTION TERMS OF%
03:12:30.171 --> 03:12:31.773
REGULATORY RESPONSES SO WE'D
03:12:31.840 --> 03:12:34.309
AGAIN WOULD URGE YOU TO DEFER TO
03:12:34.376 --> 03:12:36.211
THAT PROCESS THANK YOU.
03:12:36.278 --> 03:12:37.612
TOM JACOB ON BEHALF OF THE
03:12:37.679 --> 03:12:38.813
CHEMICAL INDUSTRY COUNCIL OF
03:12:38.880 --> 03:12:40.515
CALIFORNIA IN OPPOSITION FOR THE
03:12:40.582 --> 03:12:43.718
REASONS STATED.
03:12:43.785 --> 03:12:44.719
MONNING MISTER CHAIRMAN KATHY
03:12:44.786 --> 03:12:46.121
LET REPRESENT AMERICAN FOREST
03:12:46.187 --> 03:12:47.889
AND PAPER ASSOCIATION OPPOSITION
03:12:47.956 --> 03:12:48.924
AGAIN DIFFERENT OF GREEN
03:12:48.990 --> 03:12:50.558
CHEMISTRY PROCESSES OUR
03:12:50.625 --> 03:12:53.128
PREFERENCE THANK YOU.
03:12:53.194 --> 03:12:54.729
THE CHAIRMAN IS JOE ACURA BEHALF
03:12:54.796 --> 03:12:56.298
THE PLASTICS INDUSTRY
03:12:56.364 --> 03:13:00.635
ASSOCIATION ROLE SO POST.
03:13:00.702 --> 03:13:01.670
PEOPLE ARE GONNA HAVE TO THE
03:13:01.736 --> 03:13:02.337
CIVIL DISASSOCIATION CALIFORNIAN
03:13:02.404 --> 03:13:03.939
OPPOSITION.
03:13:04.005 --> 03:13:06.141
THANK YOU I'M.
03:13:06.207 --> 03:13:07.442
ASSEMBLYMEMBER CHAIN WE'RE GOING
03:13:07.509 --> 03:13:09.444
TO CHALLENGE ALL OF OURS --
03:13:09.511 --> 03:13:11.079
CHEMISTRY SKILLS I WISH MY
03:13:11.146 --> 03:13:12.580
LITTLE SISTER WAS HERE WHO HAS A
03:13:12.647 --> 03:13:14.249
DEGREE IN IT --
03:13:14.316 --> 03:13:16.751
THE COMPLEXITIES OF P. FAST AND
03:13:16.818 --> 03:13:18.453
THE OPPOSITION'S CONCERNED THAT
03:13:18.520 --> 03:13:20.455
THIS LEGISLATION IS TOO BROAD
03:13:20.522 --> 03:13:21.656
THAT THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS
03:13:21.723 --> 03:13:23.458
THE HAS.
03:13:23.525 --> 03:13:24.893
WE'VE BEEN LOOKING AT P. FAST
03:13:24.960 --> 03:13:26.861
AND IT'S ALL NOT THE SAME AND
03:13:26.928 --> 03:13:29.164
THAT THE SOMEHOW THE BLANKET
03:13:29.230 --> 03:13:30.832
LABEL ON ALL.
03:13:30.899 --> 03:13:33.468
NEP FAST WOULD BE.
03:13:33.535 --> 03:13:35.837
AND I DIDN'T SAY MISLEADING BUT
03:13:35.904 --> 03:13:37.939
NOT JUST TOO BROAD IN THEIR
03:13:38.006 --> 03:13:38.940
APPLICATION CAN PLEASE RESPOND
03:13:39.007 --> 03:13:40.542
THAT I I THINK IT SOUNDS LIKE A
03:13:40.608 --> 03:13:41.776
HOME.
03:13:41.843 --> 03:13:44.846
VERY CONVINCING ARGUMENT --
03:13:44.913 --> 03:13:46.848
BUT OF COURSE I THINK IF WE ALL
03:13:46.915 --> 03:13:49.784
WERE TO PUT OUR LIFE IN THE FTA
03:13:49.851 --> 03:13:51.353
I THINK ARE.
03:13:51.419 --> 03:13:53.421
WE MAY ARE COME UP SHORT --
03:13:53.488 --> 03:13:55.323
IT'S INTERESTING THEY'RE THE
03:13:55.390 --> 03:13:56.524
DISCUSSION AROUND THE FDA
03:13:56.591 --> 03:13:57.592
PROCESS BEING EXTRAORDINARY
03:13:57.659 --> 03:13:58.960
STRINGENT.
03:13:59.027 --> 03:14:01.963
AND RELIABLE THAT THE SAME THING
03:14:02.030 --> 03:14:03.264
HAPPENED WITH LAUNCHING P. FAST
03:14:03.331 --> 03:14:06.101
IS WHERE LAUNCH MP FAST IS WAR --
03:14:06.167 --> 03:14:07.802
OKAYED BY THE FDA UNTIL THEY
03:14:07.869 --> 03:14:09.371
WORKED.
03:14:09.437 --> 03:14:10.905
SO THEY WENT THROUGH THAT
03:14:10.972 --> 03:14:12.040
PROCESS THEY WERE RELEASED THEN
03:14:12.107 --> 03:14:13.108
ALL THE SUDDEN WE FOUND AT THAT
03:14:13.174 --> 03:14:15.176
THEY WERE HIGHLY TOXIC AND THEN
03:14:15.243 --> 03:14:15.777
HAD TO BE REMOVED OF AND THEY
03:14:15.844 --> 03:14:17.812
HAD TO BE --
03:14:17.879 --> 03:14:19.047
EVENTUALLY CARAVAN.
03:14:19.114 --> 03:14:21.316
SO WE'VE HAD THE SAME PROCESS WE
03:14:21.383 --> 03:14:22.183
WOULD THAT ALSO BELOV TALK ABOUT
03:14:22.250 --> 03:14:26.888
THE RELIABILITY IN TERMS OF THE
03:14:26.955 --> 03:14:28.723
GREEN CHEMISTRY PROCESS AS OUR
03:14:28.790 --> 03:14:31.259
INSISTENCE ON RELIEF FOLLOWING
03:14:31.326 --> 03:14:32.727
THE TSC WELL.
03:14:32.794 --> 03:14:33.762
I'LL JUST PUT IT THIS WAY IF I
03:14:33.828 --> 03:14:35.897
IF I WAS GONNA PUT UP MY LIFE
03:14:35.964 --> 03:14:38.533
EITHE YOU KNOW IN RELY ON DTS
03:14:38.600 --> 03:14:39.034
SEE I THINK.
03:14:39.100 --> 03:14:40.335
WE'D ALL BE IN TROUBLE WE'LL GET
03:14:40.402 --> 03:14:41.503
TO THAT.
03:14:41.569 --> 03:14:42.771
AGENCY NEXT YEAR BUT NOT THIS
03:14:42.837 --> 03:14:44.172
YEAR YOUR WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO
03:14:44.239 --> 03:14:45.640
DO IS JUST LET THE SCIENTISTS
03:14:45.707 --> 03:14:47.442
EITHER --
03:14:47.509 --> 03:14:50.645
SUSAN OR TASHA REALLY TALK ABOUT.
03:14:50.712 --> 03:14:52.547
ISSUES JUST VERY ADDRESS THIS
03:14:52.614 --> 03:14:55.183
COMPLEXITY OF THE BECAUSE THE
03:14:55.250 --> 03:14:58.887
CLAIM IS BEEN MADE THAT AND THE
03:14:58.953 --> 03:15:01.356
POLYMERS THAT HE USED ON THE P.
03:15:01.423 --> 03:15:03.525
FAST IT'S ACTUALLY ON THE
03:15:03.591 --> 03:15:04.426
COOKWARE.
03:15:04.492 --> 03:15:08.296
IS NOT SOLUBLE SO IT CAN'T.
03:15:08.363 --> 03:15:09.864
ENTER INTO DISTRICT DOES THE
03:15:09.931 --> 03:15:10.999
BODY [inaudible]
03:15:11.066 --> 03:15:13.601
WHAT SEE?
03:15:13.668 --> 03:15:15.236
I'M GONNA ACTUALLY DEFER TO
03:15:15.303 --> 03:15:17.238
TASHA OUR SCIENTISTS ARE STILL
03:15:17.305 --> 03:15:18.473
HOT SHOT I THINK JONES SAWYER TV
03:15:18.540 --> 03:15:25.613
SHOW. FOR DOCTOR TASHA PLEASE.
03:15:25.680 --> 03:15:26.514
COULD YOU ANSWER --
03:15:26.581 --> 03:15:28.116
EDUCATING ME ON THIS.
03:15:28.183 --> 03:15:30.185
THEN THE CLAIM IS BEEN MADE THAT
03:15:30.251 --> 03:15:34.522
THE PART OF THE THE FAST FAMILY
03:15:34.589 --> 03:15:36.758
IS COMPLICATED AND THAT THE FOR
03:15:36.825 --> 03:15:39.094
CHEMICAL CONNECTIONS.
03:15:39.160 --> 03:15:41.129
AND THE POLYMERS THAT WEEK THAT
03:15:41.196 --> 03:15:43.865
YOU HAVE ON THE P. FAST THAT ARE
03:15:43.932 --> 03:15:45.433
ACTUALLY ON THE COOK WHERE
03:15:45.500 --> 03:15:46.668
THAT'S GOING TO GET THE LABEL.
03:15:46.734 --> 03:15:49.471
ARE NOT SOLUBLE SO THEY CAN'T
03:15:49.537 --> 03:15:51.606
ENTER THE BODY TAKE THEIR THEIR
03:15:51.673 --> 03:15:53.741
THEIR THAT SOME LEVEL BUT THE
03:15:53.808 --> 03:15:54.576
BECAME ACTIVE BODY.
03:15:54.642 --> 03:15:56.111
FROM THE STUDIES THAT I HAVE
03:15:56.177 --> 03:15:58.179
REVIEWED --
03:15:58.246 --> 03:15:59.747
THEY'VE LOOKED OUT --
03:15:59.814 --> 03:16:01.683
NUMEROUS TYPES OF COOKWARE EVEN
03:16:01.749 --> 03:16:03.084
COOKWARE THAT HAS SUPPOSED TO
03:16:03.151 --> 03:16:04.352
HAVE BEEN --
03:16:04.419 --> 03:16:06.588
P. FOR FREE AND THEY HAVE
03:16:06.654 --> 03:16:09.624
MEASURED EMISSIONS DURING --
03:16:09.691 --> 03:16:11.292
REGULAR HEATING --
03:16:11.359 --> 03:16:12.961
ELEVATED TEMPERATURE HEATING AND
03:16:13.027 --> 03:16:14.929
THESE CHEMICALS IS MONOMERS ARE
03:16:14.996 --> 03:16:16.297
IN FACT BEING EMITTED FROM THE
03:16:16.364 --> 03:16:17.499
COOK WHEN THEY CAN GET INTO YOUR
03:16:17.565 --> 03:16:19.334
FRUIT.
03:16:19.400 --> 03:16:20.835
DO YOU DISCIPLINE AYE OCCUR NOT
03:16:20.902 --> 03:16:21.970
START ONE MORE POINT ON AND I
03:16:22.036 --> 03:16:23.404
THINK ALSO THE ISSUE IS TO AS
03:16:23.471 --> 03:16:25.340
WHEN THESE CHEMICALS ARE BEING
03:16:25.406 --> 03:16:28.276
MADE -- THE
03:16:28.343 --> 03:16:30.111
BUILDING BLOCKS THAT ARE THAT
03:16:30.178 --> 03:16:31.279
ARE USED TO MAKE THESE POLYMERS
03:16:31.346 --> 03:16:33.047
THOSE ARE ALSO --
03:16:33.114 --> 03:16:35.283
A CONCERN THAT THEY CAN --
03:16:35.350 --> 03:16:36.618
THEIR SOURCE OF CONTAMINATION
03:16:36.684 --> 03:16:37.619
AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION
03:16:37.685 --> 03:16:39.454
THAT CAN PROCESSED.
03:16:39.521 --> 03:16:40.688
DO YOU DISAGREE WITH THIS
03:16:40.755 --> 03:16:43.057
SUGGESTION THAT THESE.
03:16:43.124 --> 03:16:44.025
THERE THERE COMPLEMENT OF
03:16:44.092 --> 03:16:47.295
PROFILES SAID THAT THERE'S A I
03:16:47.362 --> 03:16:48.463
GUESS IT IS I WAS VISUALIZING A
03:16:48.530 --> 03:16:50.832
CONTINUUM OF SOME.
03:16:50.899 --> 03:16:52.534
EVEN THE CHEMISTRY COUNCIL WOULD
03:16:52.600 --> 03:16:53.968
AGREE THAT IF THOSE POLYMER
03:16:54.035 --> 03:16:55.336
SUPPORT ON COOPER THAT'S GOING
03:16:55.403 --> 03:16:56.871
TO BE DANGEROUS TO YOUR HEALTH
03:16:56.938 --> 03:16:59.174
VERSES SOME OTHERS BECAUSE OF
03:16:59.240 --> 03:17:00.808
THE CONFIGURATION.
03:17:00.875 --> 03:17:02.477
BY LOOKING AT IT.
03:17:02.544 --> 03:17:03.678
THE PROPER WAY OR WOULD YOU
03:17:03.745 --> 03:17:07.282
DISAGREE THAT ONE PROBLEM. ONE
03:17:07.348 --> 03:17:09.083
ONE P. FAMILY.
03:17:09.150 --> 03:17:10.585
IS THE SAME AS AN NEXT BE FAMILY
03:17:10.652 --> 03:17:13.021
THERE'S NO IT'S NOT TOO BROAD IN
03:17:13.087 --> 03:17:14.189
IN THAT THE DEFINITION THAT
03:17:14.255 --> 03:17:16.624
WE'RE USING IN THIS BILL.
03:17:16.691 --> 03:17:18.426
I THINK I MEAN THE CONCERN A IS
03:17:18.493 --> 03:17:20.795
IS DEFINITELY FOR ALL OF THESE
03:17:20.862 --> 03:17:22.130
CHEMICALS --
03:17:22.197 --> 03:17:24.065
THE SHORT OR THE LONG CHAIN OF
03:17:24.132 --> 03:17:25.533
COURSE ARE HAVE BEEN THE MOST
03:17:25.600 --> 03:17:27.101
STUDIED --
03:17:27.168 --> 03:17:28.803
AND WE HAVE --
03:17:28.870 --> 03:17:30.972
THE MOST EVIDENCE TO SHOW DIRECT
03:17:31.039 --> 03:17:32.140
HEALTH EFFECTS FOR THOSE AND NOW
03:17:32.207 --> 03:17:33.608
WE'RE JUST FINDING.
03:17:33.675 --> 03:17:35.610
MORE ABOUT SHORT CHAIN CHEMICALS
03:17:35.677 --> 03:17:36.978
ON FOR EXAMPLE I'M THE BEST
03:17:37.045 --> 03:17:39.547
INDICATORS --
03:17:39.614 --> 03:17:40.615
I HAVE NOT FOR FINDING THOSE
03:17:40.682 --> 03:17:43.952
CHEMICALS IN YOUR BODY IS NOT --
03:17:44.018 --> 03:17:45.353
BLOOD SERUM SAMPLES BUT WE'RE
03:17:45.420 --> 03:17:46.788
ACTUALLY SEEING THAT ON THE
03:17:46.854 --> 03:17:48.022
WHOLE BLOOD IS A BIT BETTER
03:17:48.089 --> 03:17:49.157
INDICATOR OF THOSE ENDING UP IN
03:17:49.224 --> 03:17:50.358
YOUR HUMAN BODY.
03:17:50.425 --> 03:17:51.459
AND ALSO --
03:17:51.526 --> 03:17:53.628
STUDIES WHERE YOU SEARCHING
03:17:53.695 --> 03:17:55.230
CHEMICALS ACCUMULATE IN YOUR
03:17:55.296 --> 03:17:57.532
BODY'S ORGANS --
03:17:57.599 --> 03:18:02.136
AND BUT THAT DOESN'T RECENT
03:18:02.203 --> 03:18:04.072
STUDIES HER I MEAN I GUESS RATE
03:18:04.138 --> 03:18:05.073
THE AUDIO OF THE ALL WHICH OUT
03:18:05.139 --> 03:18:06.774
THERE IS THAT THE LONG CHAIN YES
03:18:06.841 --> 03:18:08.376
THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE AN ADVERSE
03:18:08.443 --> 03:18:10.211
AFFECT THE SHORT CHAIN.
03:18:10.278 --> 03:18:13.348
MAYBE WE DIDN'T BELIEVE IT AT
03:18:13.414 --> 03:18:14.182
YEARS AGO FIFTEEN YEARS AGO BUT
03:18:14.249 --> 03:18:16.484
RAIL WITH ADDITIONAL RESEARCH
03:18:16.551 --> 03:18:17.385
AND CHARGING STUDY THAT I
03:18:17.452 --> 03:18:19.988
REFERRED TO ONE WAS --
03:18:20.054 --> 03:18:21.155
TWENTY FIFTEEN I'M LOOKING AT
03:18:21.222 --> 03:18:22.790
HUMANS AND OTHER CITY VERY
03:18:22.857 --> 03:18:24.525
RECENTLY TWENTY SEVENTEEN WHERE
03:18:24.592 --> 03:18:26.094
THE USED RADIO CHEMISTRY. TO TAG
03:18:26.160 --> 03:18:27.695
THE SHORT CHAIN CHEMICALS AND
03:18:27.762 --> 03:18:30.265
THEY FOUND THEM AND EVERY ORGAN --
03:18:30.331 --> 03:18:31.666
IN AN ANIMAL STUDY THAT THEY
03:18:31.733 --> 03:18:32.734
THAT THEY LOOKED AT EVERY TISSUE
03:18:32.800 --> 03:18:35.370
THAT THEY LOOKED OUT AND COMMENT
03:18:35.436 --> 03:18:35.803
ON THAT.
03:18:35.870 --> 03:18:37.805
PACIFIC TOXICITY OF THAT
03:18:37.872 --> 03:18:38.106
[inaudible]
03:18:38.172 --> 03:18:39.874
CONFIGURATION.
03:18:39.941 --> 03:18:42.610
OTHER SHORT TERM TO SIT.
03:18:42.677 --> 03:18:43.811
WAS RIGHT NINE WAS IT YOU KNOW
03:18:43.878 --> 03:18:45.513
FATAL.
03:18:45.580 --> 03:18:47.348
RIGHT AND SO AND SO AGAIN THE
03:18:47.415 --> 03:18:49.183
LONG CHAIN ARE --
03:18:49.250 --> 03:18:50.151
WE HAVE DEFINITELYMORE CITIES
03:18:50.218 --> 03:18:51.286
ON THOSE AND WE'RE JUST FINDING
03:18:51.352 --> 03:18:53.154
OUT NOW ABOUT THE TOXICITY OF
03:18:53.221 --> 03:18:54.756
THE SHORT CHAIN CHEMICALS --
03:18:54.822 --> 03:18:56.791
SOME OF WHICH CAN BE JUST AS IN
03:18:56.858 --> 03:18:58.826
YOU KNOW TOXIC AS A LAUNCHING
03:18:58.893 --> 03:19:00.595
CHEMICALS EVERY SCENE FROM.
03:19:00.662 --> 03:19:03.164
RESEARCH FROM HARVARD OF LOOKING
03:19:03.231 --> 03:19:04.732
AT AND YOU KNOW TOXICITY --
03:19:04.799 --> 03:19:06.267
THAT THAT [inaudible]
03:19:06.334 --> 03:19:08.202
SHORT CHAIN.
03:19:08.269 --> 03:19:09.637
IS IS IS NOT A VIABLE
03:19:09.704 --> 03:19:11.139
ALTERNATIVE AND THAT THE SAME
03:19:11.205 --> 03:19:12.974
CONCERNS ARM PURSED ARE ARE
03:19:13.041 --> 03:19:13.641
THERE [inaudible]
03:19:13.708 --> 03:19:15.276
OKAY.
03:19:15.343 --> 03:19:17.445
WE HAVE A PHARMACIST HERE.
03:19:17.512 --> 03:19:19.647
SENATOR STOP YOU HAVE A QUESTION
03:19:19.714 --> 03:19:22.483
YEAH SHUT BICU ACTUALLY --
03:19:22.550 --> 03:19:24.052
THE LONG CHAIN THAT THE WAY I
03:19:24.118 --> 03:19:25.320
UNDERSTAND THAT THESE ARE LARGE
03:19:25.386 --> 03:19:27.155
POLYMERS SAID WE WILL TALK ABOUT
03:19:27.221 --> 03:19:28.556
BIOAVAILABILITY THEIR YOU'RE
03:19:28.623 --> 03:19:30.458
BASICALLY NOT ABSORBED.
03:19:30.525 --> 03:19:33.061
RIGHT SO --
03:19:33.127 --> 03:19:34.495
THE SHORTER CHAIN MAYBE A MAKE
03:19:34.562 --> 03:19:35.663
AN ARGUMENT THAT THEY THEY CAN
03:19:35.730 --> 03:19:37.565
BE ABSORBED.
03:19:37.632 --> 03:19:39.334
BUT JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE HAS A
03:19:39.400 --> 03:19:40.635
PRESENCE IN MY BODY DOESN'T MEAN
03:19:40.702 --> 03:19:42.770
THAT IT'S TOXIC --
03:19:42.837 --> 03:19:43.705
AND I WOULD IMAGINE SOME OF THE
03:19:43.771 --> 03:19:45.139
STUDIES MAYBE YOU'RE REFERRING
03:19:45.206 --> 03:19:46.841
TO BE ELABORATE ON THAT WASN'T
03:19:46.908 --> 03:19:48.042
ON HUMANS WAS A DOWN THE RATS.
03:19:48.109 --> 03:19:50.178
BOTH OKAY SO WE TALKING ABOUT
03:19:50.244 --> 03:19:51.312
SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER
03:19:51.379 --> 03:19:53.748
CONCENTRATIONS IN THESE ORGANS
03:19:53.815 --> 03:19:55.850
AND WOULD BE TYPICALLY SEEN OF
03:19:55.917 --> 03:19:57.819
SOMEBODY USES A GREAT JUST JUST
03:19:57.885 --> 03:19:58.953
BECAUSE SOMETHING IS NEARBY
03:19:59.020 --> 03:20:00.855
DOESN'T MEAN IT'S TOXIC BUT WE
03:20:00.922 --> 03:20:02.924
ARE FINDING INFORMATION NOW.
03:20:02.990 --> 03:20:03.591
THAT WE'RE ABLE TO MEASURE THESE
03:20:03.658 --> 03:20:04.959
CHEMICALS --
03:20:05.026 --> 03:20:06.728
THAT YOU.
03:20:06.794 --> 03:20:08.596
THE HEALTH EFFECTS --
03:20:08.663 --> 03:20:09.464
ARE THERE I MEAN JUST BECAUSE
03:20:09.530 --> 03:20:10.598
IT'S NOBODY ALSO DOESN'T MEAN
03:20:10.665 --> 03:20:12.233
THAT IT'S NOT.
03:20:12.300 --> 03:20:13.701
TOXIC AS WE'RE JUST FINDING OUT
03:20:13.768 --> 03:20:16.437
NOW -- RIGHT
03:20:16.504 --> 03:20:18.039
BUT BEFORE WE MISSION LABELS
03:20:18.106 --> 03:20:19.674
SCARING THE HECK OUT OF CONCERN
03:20:19.741 --> 03:20:19.974
[inaudible]
03:20:20.041 --> 03:20:22.009
OUR TAXPAYERS.
03:20:22.076 --> 03:20:23.311
DON'T YOU THINK THAT WE SHOULD
03:20:23.378 --> 03:20:25.179
GO THROUGH A COMPREHENSIVE
03:20:25.246 --> 03:20:26.514
PROCESS AND I UNDERSTAND WERE
03:20:26.581 --> 03:20:28.182
KIND SIDESTEPPING THE GREEN
03:20:28.249 --> 03:20:29.851
CHEMISTRY COUNCIL HERE.
03:20:29.917 --> 03:20:31.519
BEFORE WE I MEAN LITTLE LABELS
03:20:31.586 --> 03:20:32.887
ON EVERYTHING CALIFORNIA PRETTY
03:20:32.954 --> 03:20:34.422
SOON WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO UNCOVER
03:20:34.489 --> 03:20:35.890
PAPERS BEFORE WE CAN WE GET TO
03:20:35.957 --> 03:20:36.724
THE PRODUCT.
03:20:36.791 --> 03:20:37.792
BECAUSE AS A WARNING ABOUT
03:20:37.859 --> 03:20:39.227
EVERYTHING THERE'S A VERY
03:20:39.293 --> 03:20:40.595
SIGNIFICANT WARNING.
03:20:40.661 --> 03:20:43.064
ON THINGS THAT WE KNOW HAVE --
03:20:43.131 --> 03:20:45.233
TOXICITY IF THEY'RE USED BY THE
03:20:45.299 --> 03:20:46.401
PUBLIC AND WE HAVE TO PUT A
03:20:46.467 --> 03:20:48.569
WARNING ON THEIR WELL I THINK I
03:20:48.636 --> 03:20:49.804
THINK THERE'S A SENSE OF URGENCY
03:20:49.871 --> 03:20:51.139
HERE AND I THINK THAT THE STATE
03:20:51.205 --> 03:20:53.174
OF CALIFORNIA SHOULD ACT --
03:20:53.241 --> 03:20:55.109
THE STATE OF WASHINGTON HAS.
03:20:55.176 --> 03:20:57.044
ALREADY DECIDED TO TAKE ACTION
03:20:57.111 --> 03:20:58.646
ON THIS ISSUE AND THERE ARE IN
03:20:58.713 --> 03:21:01.215
THE PROCESS OF PUTTING TOGETHER
03:21:01.282 --> 03:21:02.683
SCOPING DOCUMENTS TO LOOK AT
03:21:02.750 --> 03:21:04.585
ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS TO BAN THE
03:21:04.652 --> 03:21:06.587
WHOLE CLASS OF THESE CHEMICALS
03:21:06.654 --> 03:21:08.389
IN FOOD PACKAGING SO I WOULDN'T
03:21:08.456 --> 03:21:09.857
BE INCIDENTS OF MORTALITY AND
03:21:09.924 --> 03:21:12.260
MORBIDITY ASSOCIATED WITH --
03:21:12.326 --> 03:21:13.828
THE PF A. S. IS WITH THE
03:21:13.895 --> 03:21:16.097
EXCEPTION OF PFOS AND PFOA WHICH
03:21:16.164 --> 03:21:16.798
I'M.
03:21:16.864 --> 03:21:17.832
UNDERSTANDING IS NOT EVEN USED
03:21:17.899 --> 03:21:19.567
IN THE UNITED STATES.
03:21:19.634 --> 03:21:20.802
HOW MANY PEOPLE HAVE GONE TO THE
03:21:20.868 --> 03:21:22.470
EMERGENCY ROOM AND FOUND THAT
03:21:22.537 --> 03:21:23.404
THEY HAVE TOXIC LEVELS AND
03:21:23.471 --> 03:21:24.505
EITHER DIRE NEED TO BE
03:21:24.572 --> 03:21:27.475
DETOXIFIED?
03:21:27.542 --> 03:21:29.977
WE HAVE MILLIONS OF PEOPLE IN
03:21:30.044 --> 03:21:31.813
THE UNITED STATES CURRENTLY THAT
03:21:31.879 --> 03:21:33.047
HAVE DRINKING WATER THAT IS
03:21:33.114 --> 03:21:34.282
CONTAMINATED WITH THESE
03:21:34.348 --> 03:21:36.150
CHEMICALS AS A RESULT OF OF
03:21:36.217 --> 03:21:36.918
PRODUCTION.
03:21:36.984 --> 03:21:40.888
CALM AND AND THERE ARE I DON'T
03:21:40.955 --> 03:21:41.556
HAVE.
03:21:41.622 --> 03:21:43.057
CASES ON THE TOP OF MY HEAD BUT
03:21:43.124 --> 03:21:44.258
WE KNOW THAT --
03:21:44.325 --> 03:21:44.792
AS A RESULT OF USING THESE
03:21:44.859 --> 03:21:47.628
CHEMICAL VIEW THE CONTAMINATED
03:21:47.695 --> 03:21:48.196
DRINKING WATER IN THE UNITED
03:21:48.262 --> 03:21:50.264
STATES.
03:21:50.331 --> 03:21:51.799
AND NOW THAT WE'RE SEEING BE AND
03:21:51.866 --> 03:21:53.401
WE HAVE THE CASES WITH DIFFERENT
03:21:53.468 --> 03:21:55.203
PEOPLE OFFICE --
03:21:55.269 --> 03:21:56.838
AND NOW WE'RE ALSO SEEING SEVERE
03:21:56.904 --> 03:21:58.239
CONTAMINATION WHICH AN AXE AND
03:21:58.306 --> 03:21:59.807
IN NORTH CAROLINA AND OTHER
03:21:59.874 --> 03:22:00.808
PLACES SO --
03:22:00.875 --> 03:22:03.945
THERE HAVE.
03:22:04.011 --> 03:22:06.047
THE MADRID STATEMENT PUBLISHED
03:22:06.113 --> 03:22:06.814
IN.
03:22:06.881 --> 03:22:08.816
TWENTY FIFTEEN CALM.
03:22:08.883 --> 03:22:10.585
AS THE SUPPORT OF HUNDREDS OF OF
03:22:10.651 --> 03:22:13.020
OF SCIENTISTS --
03:22:13.087 --> 03:22:14.755
EXPRESSING CONCERN FOR THIS
03:22:14.822 --> 03:22:16.491
WHOLE ACROSS THE CHEMICALS FOR
03:22:16.557 --> 03:22:17.458
NUMEROUS REASONS OF
03:22:17.525 --> 03:22:19.927
ENVIRONMENTAL PERSISTENCE --
03:22:19.994 --> 03:22:24.065
AND AND AND I I BELIEVE THEY
03:22:24.131 --> 03:22:24.632
SHOULD BE TREATED AS A CLASS
03:22:24.699 --> 03:22:27.702
BECAUSE BECAUSE OF THESE REASONS
03:22:27.768 --> 03:22:28.569
ARE FOR SURE MISTER CHAIRMAN I
03:22:28.636 --> 03:22:29.937
DON'T.
03:22:30.004 --> 03:22:31.506
THEY THANK YOU --
03:22:31.572 --> 03:22:32.106
MISTER CHAIR HAVE US SOME VERY
03:22:32.173 --> 03:22:33.574
STRONG CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL
03:22:33.641 --> 03:22:34.775
VERSUS THE LACK OF SCIENTIFIC
03:22:34.842 --> 03:22:36.310
FOUNDATION --
03:22:36.377 --> 03:22:37.812
THIS BILL WOULD REQUIRE WARNING
03:22:37.879 --> 03:22:39.046
LABELS AND PACKAGING ON COOKWARE
03:22:39.113 --> 03:22:40.314
THE KANEPI A PHASE BECAUSE THE
03:22:40.381 --> 03:22:42.016
SUBSTANCE COULD BEAT JUST
03:22:42.083 --> 03:22:43.818
DETECTED BY BIO MONITORING.
03:22:43.885 --> 03:22:44.652
HOW THE CENTERS FOR DISEASE
03:22:44.719 --> 03:22:46.254
CONTROL EXPRESSLY STATES THAT
03:22:46.320 --> 03:22:47.121
THE PRESENCE OF ENVIRONMENTAL
03:22:47.188 --> 03:22:48.523
CHEMICAL WITH PEOPLE'S BLOOD OR
03:22:48.589 --> 03:22:49.590
URINE DOES NOT MEAN THAT IT WILL
03:22:49.657 --> 03:22:50.791
BECAUSE OF?
03:22:50.858 --> 03:22:51.559
A FAX -- OR
03:22:51.626 --> 03:22:53.661
DISEASE --
03:22:53.728 --> 03:22:55.830
THIS ALSO CIRCUMVENT SO THE PROF
03:22:55.897 --> 03:22:57.331
SIXTY FIVE PROCESS THIS BILL
03:22:57.398 --> 03:22:58.466
WOULD REQUIRE WARNINGS.
03:22:58.533 --> 03:23:00.334
ON FOOD PACKAGING PRODUCTS AT PF
03:23:00.401 --> 03:23:02.003
ESSAYS EVEN THOUGH THE OFFICE
03:23:02.069 --> 03:23:03.137
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH HAZARD
03:23:03.204 --> 03:23:04.872
ASSESSMENT IS NEVER REQUIRED
03:23:04.939 --> 03:23:06.841
THAT THEY CARRY THEIR CHOIR PROP
03:23:06.908 --> 03:23:07.742
SIXTY FIVE WARNING. FOR ANY
03:23:07.808 --> 03:23:09.377
PRODUCT KNOWN TO CAUSE CANCER
03:23:09.443 --> 03:23:10.545
REPRODUCTIVE HARM THIS BILL
03:23:10.611 --> 03:23:11.712
WOULD --
03:23:11.779 --> 03:23:13.447
VIRTUALLY TREAT THEM EXACTLY THE
03:23:13.514 --> 03:23:15.249
SAME I THINK THAT'S PRESIDENT
03:23:15.316 --> 03:23:17.018
SETTING AND WILL BE THE
03:23:17.084 --> 03:23:19.353
BEGINNING OF SAYING --
03:23:19.420 --> 03:23:20.454
MANY MORE PRODUCTS THAT ARE
03:23:20.521 --> 03:23:22.123
SUSPECTED.
03:23:22.189 --> 03:23:23.958
OF MAYBE --
03:23:24.025 --> 03:23:26.861
CAUSING ISSUES BUT THE WITNESS
03:23:26.928 --> 03:23:28.396
COULD EVEN GIVE ME ONE EXAMPLE
03:23:28.462 --> 03:23:29.764
OF SOMEBODY'S BEEN EMERGENCY
03:23:29.830 --> 03:23:32.133
ROOM WITH TOXICITY SET ARE ALL
03:23:32.199 --> 03:23:33.935
ALARMING --
03:23:34.001 --> 03:23:35.703
IT ALSO CIRCUMVENT CALIFORNIA'S
03:23:35.770 --> 03:23:37.271
SAFER CONSUMER PRODUCTS
03:23:37.338 --> 03:23:38.573
REGULATION THE BILL WHAT SITES
03:23:38.639 --> 03:23:40.207
AT THE STATE FOR SAFER CONSUMER
03:23:40.274 --> 03:23:41.475
PRODUCTS REGULATION ALSO KNOWN
03:23:41.542 --> 03:23:43.210
AS THE GREEN CHEMISTRY PROGRAM.
03:23:43.277 --> 03:23:44.812
SO ARTICULATED IN THE TO MAKE
03:23:44.879 --> 03:23:45.746
THE COMPLAINT THAT A PRECISE
03:23:45.813 --> 03:23:47.081
STEP IN THAT PROCESS THE
03:23:47.148 --> 03:23:48.883
CONTOURED IT CONTRADICTS THE
03:23:48.950 --> 03:23:50.017
FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION THE
03:23:50.084 --> 03:23:51.986
AUTHOR KIND OF DISCOUNTS THE OF
03:23:52.053 --> 03:23:55.690
THE REVIEW OF CREATION --
03:23:55.756 --> 03:23:56.857
LET ME TELL YOU AT THE HAVE SOME
03:23:56.924 --> 03:23:58.092
VERY COMPREHENSIVE PROCESSES
03:23:58.159 --> 03:23:59.327
THAT'S WHY TAKES A LONG TO GET A
03:23:59.393 --> 03:24:01.162
DRUG ON THE MARKET HERE IN THE
03:24:01.228 --> 03:24:02.363
UNITED STATES OUT THERE IS
03:24:02.430 --> 03:24:04.432
COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW --
03:24:04.498 --> 03:24:05.733
OVER TEN YEARS.
03:24:05.800 --> 03:24:08.235
DEALING WITH THEM VIA FACE AND I
03:24:08.302 --> 03:24:09.904
HAVE NOT ISSUED --
03:24:09.971 --> 03:24:11.439
A WARNING ON THESE AND AND
03:24:11.505 --> 03:24:13.240
FRANKLY IT'S A IT'S A VIOLATION
03:24:13.307 --> 03:24:15.042
OF FREE SPEECH BECAUSE THE BILL
03:24:15.109 --> 03:24:16.110
WILL VIOLATE FREE SPEECH RIGHTS
03:24:16.177 --> 03:24:17.712
OF THESE COMPANIES THAT ARE.
03:24:17.778 --> 03:24:18.779
DOING BUSINESS IN THE UNITED
03:24:18.846 --> 03:24:21.549
STATES AND IT CAN BE INFERRED AT
03:24:21.616 --> 03:24:23.217
THIS EASIER THESE NEW WARNINGS
03:24:23.284 --> 03:24:25.086
ARE DECEPTIVE IN THEIR ONE SIDED.
03:24:25.152 --> 03:24:26.754
AND THEY KNOW THAT THE HORSE I
03:24:26.821 --> 03:24:28.789
HEALTH A WARNING REQUIREMENT FOR
03:24:28.856 --> 03:24:30.491
SUGARY STOPED SUGARY SODAS WHICH
03:24:30.558 --> 03:24:31.659
WAS LITIGATED.
03:24:31.726 --> 03:24:32.860
WAS STRUCK DOWN BY THE FEDERAL
03:24:32.927 --> 03:24:34.662
NIGHT COURT OF APPEALS ON
03:24:34.729 --> 03:24:36.063
PRECISELY THE SAME GROUNDS.
03:24:36.130 --> 03:24:37.932
THAT -- THE
03:24:37.999 --> 03:24:39.367
OPPONENTS COULD USE TO
03:24:39.433 --> 03:24:40.968
INVALIDATE THIS IT FOREVER TO
03:24:41.035 --> 03:24:41.602
BECAME.
03:24:41.669 --> 03:24:44.372
COME THE LAW SO I THINK WE NEED
03:24:44.438 --> 03:24:44.972
LETTER GREEN.
03:24:45.039 --> 03:24:46.340
CHEMICAL COUNCIL DO THEIR JOB
03:24:46.407 --> 03:24:47.608
LET'S FIND OUT IF THERE REALLY
03:24:47.675 --> 03:24:49.310
IS A HEALTH HAZARD BEFORE WE
03:24:49.377 --> 03:24:50.211
START SCARING FORTY MILLION
03:24:50.277 --> 03:24:51.512
PEOPLE ABOUT --
03:24:51.579 --> 03:24:53.547
POTS AND PANS AND AND PRODUCTS
03:24:53.614 --> 03:24:54.382
OF EQUIPMENT MAKE WE'VE EVERY
03:24:54.448 --> 03:24:57.318
DAY TO TO FEED THEIR FAMILIES.
03:24:57.385 --> 03:24:59.553
THANK YOU CENTER STERN.
03:24:59.620 --> 03:25:02.390
YEAH THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR.
03:25:02.456 --> 03:25:03.991
I THANK YOU SIMILAR FOR BRINGING
03:25:04.058 --> 03:25:04.659
US FOR IT I WAS HOPING WE COULD
03:25:04.725 --> 03:25:05.259
JUST DIG IN A LITTLE BIT MORE
03:25:05.326 --> 03:25:09.096
INTO THIS QUESTION OF POTENTIAL
03:25:09.163 --> 03:25:11.232
RISK AYE AYE AYE.
03:25:11.298 --> 03:25:13.701
IN CALIFORNIA WE MAY BE A LITTLE
03:25:13.768 --> 03:25:15.302
MORE CAUTIOUS THAN SAY THE
03:25:15.369 --> 03:25:17.104
FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ABOUT HEALTH
03:25:17.171 --> 03:25:21.475
STANDARDS AND I STRONGLY --
03:25:21.542 --> 03:25:22.777
ABIDE BY THAT SORT A
03:25:22.843 --> 03:25:24.245
PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE IF THERE
03:25:24.311 --> 03:25:27.882
IS SORT OF DEVELOPING RISK OR NO
03:25:27.948 --> 03:25:29.550
SORT OF VERIFIED RISK IT I I
03:25:29.617 --> 03:25:31.952
THINK AS THE OPPONENTS USED TO
03:25:32.019 --> 03:25:33.654
THE TERM AT THERE'S NO ROOM.
03:25:33.721 --> 03:25:35.022
AS A FREE OF THIS AND WHAT
03:25:35.089 --> 03:25:36.824
WRITTEN A REASONABLE CERTAINTY
03:25:36.891 --> 03:25:38.426
REASONABLE CERTAINTY OF NO HARM
03:25:38.492 --> 03:25:39.760
IS THE FDA'S ARE REASONABLE
03:25:39.827 --> 03:25:41.762
FDA'S ISN'T REASONABLE CERTAINTY
03:25:41.829 --> 03:25:43.998
OF NO HARM RIGHT NOW BUT FOR HE
03:25:44.065 --> 03:25:45.700
IN THE IN THE UPDATED STUDIES ON
03:25:45.766 --> 03:25:49.503
THE SHORT CHAIN --
03:25:49.570 --> 03:25:51.105
IS SHORT CHAIN PRODUCTS WHAT
03:25:51.172 --> 03:25:52.106
WHAT ARE YOU SEEING INITIALLY
03:25:52.173 --> 03:25:54.141
IMMINENT IN COMING OUT OF THE
03:25:54.208 --> 03:25:55.042
TESTING I KNOW THERE'S NOTHING
03:25:55.109 --> 03:25:57.344
SORT OF FINALIZED YET IT HASN'T
03:25:57.411 --> 03:25:58.679
GONE THROUGH THE SAME A WE HAVE
03:25:58.746 --> 03:26:00.214
PROCESS FOR THE DTS THE PROCESS
03:26:00.281 --> 03:26:01.916
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT BUT WILL.
03:26:01.982 --> 03:26:03.350
GIVE US A LITTLE MORE THERE.
03:26:03.417 --> 03:26:05.252
IF YOU COULD ON SORT OF WHAT
03:26:05.319 --> 03:26:06.220
YOU'RE SEEING INITIALLY FROM.
03:26:06.287 --> 03:26:08.122
SURVEYS AND FIELD STUDIES I'M
03:26:08.189 --> 03:26:10.091
SURE I'LL JUST REITERATE COME
03:26:10.157 --> 03:26:12.993
FROM STUDIES FROM OF FELIPE
03:26:13.060 --> 03:26:14.328
GRANDJEAN AT HARVARD.
03:26:14.395 --> 03:26:15.963
FOUND THAT THEY HAVE LOOKED AT
03:26:16.030 --> 03:26:16.464
SOME OF THE SHORT CHAIN
03:26:16.530 --> 03:26:18.399
CHEMICALS AND THEY ARE FINDING
03:26:18.466 --> 03:26:19.800
SIMILAR --
03:26:19.867 --> 03:26:22.536
IMMUNO TOXICITY THEM TOXICITIES
03:26:22.603 --> 03:26:24.371
SIMILAR --
03:26:24.438 --> 03:26:26.674
TO LAUNCHING CHEMICALS.
03:26:26.741 --> 03:26:28.476
AND ALSO --
03:26:28.542 --> 03:26:31.145
THE SYRIAN IN HUMANS --
03:26:31.212 --> 03:26:33.647
LAB RATS BOTH FOUGHT IN ANIMAL
03:26:33.714 --> 03:26:35.716
STUDIES.
03:26:35.783 --> 03:26:37.384
AND I AM CERTAIN.
03:26:37.451 --> 03:26:38.986
AND ALSO --
03:26:39.053 --> 03:26:41.122
THE FLORA TOMAHAWK ALCOHOLS
03:26:41.188 --> 03:26:42.123
WHICH ARE USED TO YOU.
03:26:42.189 --> 03:26:44.158
ADAM.
03:26:44.225 --> 03:26:45.860
A MANUFACTURER THAT A FEW
03:26:45.926 --> 03:26:47.928
CONTACT MATERIALS --
03:26:47.995 --> 03:26:50.931
THEY ARE ALSO --
03:26:50.998 --> 03:26:54.335
THE SIX CARBON FLORA TOLERABLE --
03:26:54.401 --> 03:26:57.805
MONOMERS AND EAT CARBON --
03:26:57.872 --> 03:27:00.641
MONOMERS EXHIBIT SIMILAR --
03:27:00.708 --> 03:27:03.077
ESTROGENIC ACTIVITY AS WELL SO
03:27:03.144 --> 03:27:04.178
THE ANSWER IS NO MONOMERS OR
03:27:04.245 --> 03:27:05.846
THOSE ARE SHORT CHAINS.
03:27:05.913 --> 03:27:07.481
SIT AT THE SHORT CHAIN AND A
03:27:07.548 --> 03:27:09.316
LONG CHAIN ARE.
03:27:09.383 --> 03:27:09.850
EXHIBITING SIMILAR HEALTH
03:27:09.917 --> 03:27:11.185
EFFECTS.
03:27:11.252 --> 03:27:14.622
GOT IT THAT IN THE SIR I'M.
03:27:14.688 --> 03:27:15.823
RIGHT UNTIL LIKE EIGHT EIGHT
03:27:15.890 --> 03:27:17.191
<c.green>ARBON YEAH CARD IS A LONG CHAIN</c>
03:27:17.258 --> 03:27:19.426
AND AND ANYTHING SIX CARBON
03:27:19.493 --> 03:27:20.227
RIGHT ORDER.
03:27:20.294 --> 03:27:22.396
LAST IS A SHORT CHAIN AND SELF
03:27:22.463 --> 03:27:23.831
AND IN WHAT CONTEXT YOU THOSE
03:27:23.898 --> 03:27:26.934
ARE THE EXHIBITING SIMILAR --
03:27:27.001 --> 03:27:28.068
BEHAVIOR AND OBVIOUSLY
03:27:28.135 --> 03:27:29.670
ESTROGENIC ACTIVITY SO HORMONE
03:27:29.737 --> 03:27:32.173
DISRUPTION HORMONE DISRUPTION
03:27:32.239 --> 03:27:32.740
UNDERSTOOD.
03:27:32.807 --> 03:27:33.808
AND CAN YOU TALK THROUGH
03:27:33.874 --> 03:27:35.776
ALTERNATIVES JUSTIN JEREMY WE'RE
03:27:35.843 --> 03:27:37.711
SORT OF FOCUSED HERE ON THIS
03:27:37.778 --> 03:27:39.213
KIND OF PRODUCT FOR THIS KIND OF
03:27:39.280 --> 03:27:40.815
COOKWARE THIS APPLICATION BUT
03:27:40.881 --> 03:27:41.749
WHAT ELSE IS OUT THERE IN THE
03:27:41.816 --> 03:27:42.950
MARKETPLACE TO ME IF.
03:27:43.017 --> 03:27:44.485
IF IF THE IF THE CONSUMER
03:27:44.552 --> 03:27:45.953
MARKETPLACE ARE TO GO AWAY FROM
03:27:46.020 --> 03:27:47.521
THIS KIND OF PRODUCT IS THEY'RE
03:27:47.588 --> 03:27:48.923
SUFFICIENT RIGHT LIVE ALSO
03:27:48.989 --> 03:27:50.224
THERE'S RIGHT THERE ARE ALREADY
03:27:50.291 --> 03:27:51.358
ALTERNATIVES IN PLACE IN THE
03:27:51.425 --> 03:27:53.360
STUDY THAT WAS DONE --
03:27:53.427 --> 03:27:55.296
LAST YEAR WE LOOKED AT NUMEROUS
03:27:55.362 --> 03:27:56.664
DIFFERENT TYPES OF FOOD CONTACT
03:27:56.730 --> 03:27:57.731
MATERIALS AND RAPPERS AND
03:27:57.798 --> 03:27:59.133
WHATNOT AND WE DID FIND A
03:27:59.200 --> 03:28:01.335
SYCOPHANT SIGNIFICANT PERCENTAGE
03:28:01.402 --> 03:28:02.770
THAT HOW THE VOTE FLORA
03:28:02.837 --> 03:28:05.105
CHEMICALS BUT THERE WERE 60%
03:28:05.172 --> 03:28:06.507
THAT DID NOT.
03:28:06.574 --> 03:28:08.309
SO THERE ARE CURRENTLY.
03:28:08.375 --> 03:28:10.711
FOOD CONTACT MATERIALS OUT THERE
03:28:10.778 --> 03:28:12.246
THAT AREN'T A CONCERN SO THERE
03:28:12.313 --> 03:28:13.681
ARE ALTERNATIVES THERE AND BEEN
03:28:13.747 --> 03:28:15.482
HUTUS YOU IS IT IS IT COMING
03:28:15.549 --> 03:28:16.684
FROM PARTICULAR CORPORATIONS
03:28:16.750 --> 03:28:17.852
THAT ARE SORT OF ADOPTING THIS
03:28:17.918 --> 03:28:19.887
PRINCIPLES OR IS IT.
03:28:19.954 --> 03:28:21.722
SORT A SPORADIC WITHIN THE
03:28:21.789 --> 03:28:22.957
MARKETPLACE THEY HAVE WHO'S
03:28:23.023 --> 03:28:24.058
PRETTY WELL THERE'S DOING THIS
03:28:24.124 --> 03:28:24.992
NOW -- THERE
03:28:25.059 --> 03:28:28.596
IT'S IT IS HARD TO PINPOINT --
03:28:28.662 --> 03:28:31.899
THAT.
03:28:31.966 --> 03:28:34.268
OFTEN SOME SUPPLIERS AREN'T --
03:28:34.335 --> 03:28:35.736
ALLOW THE COMPANIES WEREN'T EVEN
03:28:35.803 --> 03:28:37.371
AWARE ACTUALLY THAT THEY HAD OR
03:28:37.438 --> 03:28:39.039
DIDN'T HAVE THE FLOOR CHEMICALS
03:28:39.106 --> 03:28:39.840
IN THEIR WRAPPERS SO THAT'S WHY
03:28:39.907 --> 03:28:41.542
IT'S IMPORTANT.
03:28:41.609 --> 03:28:43.143
YOU HAVE THIS I BELIEVE HIM SO
03:28:43.210 --> 03:28:51.685
WE KNOW WHERE THEY ARE.
03:28:51.752 --> 03:28:52.186
JUST THE JUST DOT WAS A
03:28:52.253 --> 03:28:53.787
CONSISTENT.
03:28:53.854 --> 03:28:54.989
HOW THE P. FAST CHEMICAL SOME DO
03:28:55.055 --> 03:28:58.459
NOT SO DOES NOT NECESSARILY --
03:28:58.525 --> 03:29:00.194
ANYBODY SAYING WE HAVE TO HAVE
03:29:00.261 --> 03:29:01.595
THIS OR WE DON'T HAVE TO HAVE
03:29:01.662 --> 03:29:02.563
THIS NO NO ONE'S MAKING A
03:29:02.630 --> 03:29:03.964
CONSCIOUS DECISION I THINK.
03:29:04.031 --> 03:29:05.566
THE THE REASON WE'RE PUSHING FOR
03:29:05.633 --> 03:29:07.434
THE LABEL IS BECAUSE WE BELIEVE
03:29:07.501 --> 03:29:08.936
THERE SHOULD BE A LITTLE MORE
03:29:09.003 --> 03:29:10.237
CAUTIOUS THOUGHT.
03:29:10.304 --> 03:29:12.039
FROM SUPPLIERS RESTAURANTS
03:29:12.106 --> 03:29:13.807
AROUND WHETHER THEY REALLY WANT
03:29:13.874 --> 03:29:15.709
THIS CHEMICAL OR NEED THIS
03:29:15.776 --> 03:29:17.344
CHEMICAL AND IT DOESN'T EVEN
03:29:17.411 --> 03:29:18.412
REALLY APPEAR THAT THEY'D NEED
03:29:18.479 --> 03:29:20.915
THIS CHEMICAL SO WHY WHY EVEN.
03:29:20.981 --> 03:29:24.485
GO THAT STEP AFTER PURCHASE A A
03:29:24.551 --> 03:29:26.153
CHEMICAL IN A PRODUCT THAT.
03:29:26.220 --> 03:29:28.956
HE MAY I INTENDED PEERS ALL THE
03:29:29.023 --> 03:29:30.124
RESEARCH THAT WE'RE TRYING TO
03:29:30.190 --> 03:29:30.291
SEE.
03:29:30.357 --> 03:29:32.092
HAVE SERIOUS SERIOUS SIDE
03:29:32.159 --> 03:29:34.161
EFFECTS AND AND HAVE YOU SEEN
03:29:34.228 --> 03:29:35.562
ANY SIGNIFICANT ECONOMIC
03:29:35.629 --> 03:29:36.530
DIFFERENCE MEAN PRICING
03:29:36.597 --> 03:29:38.032
DIFFERENCE SAY BETWEEN A PART
03:29:38.098 --> 03:29:39.266
LIKE ONE PARTICULAR PRODUCT IN
03:29:39.333 --> 03:29:40.868
ANOTHER COMING OUT WITH P.
03:29:40.935 --> 03:29:42.369
FASTER WITHOUT IN IT --
03:29:42.436 --> 03:29:44.038
TERMS ACTUAL COST IN THE
03:29:44.104 --> 03:29:44.872
MARKETPLACE I MEAN IF YOU'RE
03:29:44.939 --> 03:29:45.940
SAYING IT'S OUR SPORADICALLY
03:29:46.006 --> 03:29:47.675
WITHIN THE SUPPLY CHAIN AND EVEN
03:29:47.741 --> 03:29:49.276
THE MANUFACTURES REALLY ARE
03:29:49.343 --> 03:29:50.945
DISTINGUISHING RIGHT.
03:29:51.011 --> 03:29:52.046
EVERY SCENE THAT [inaudible]
03:29:52.112 --> 03:29:57.017
PRICE DIFFERENTIAL.
03:29:57.084 --> 03:29:59.119
I CAN'T I CAN'T SMOKE AT HIM AS
03:29:59.186 --> 03:30:00.521
HE WON A THERE IS.
03:30:00.587 --> 03:30:01.655
THERE IS A SLIGHT PRICE
03:30:01.722 --> 03:30:02.723
DIFFERENTIAL ON SOME OF THE
03:30:02.790 --> 03:30:04.425
PRODUCT FOR INSTANCE THINGS LIKE
03:30:04.491 --> 03:30:06.460
THIS WHICH ARE MADE OF BE GOSS.
03:30:06.527 --> 03:30:08.095
OF WHICH IS NOT CHLORINATED
03:30:08.162 --> 03:30:09.697
PAPER PRODUCT --
03:30:09.763 --> 03:30:11.365
MAY BE A FEW CENTS MORE
03:30:11.432 --> 03:30:13.133
EXPENSIVE OTHER THINGS THAT
03:30:13.200 --> 03:30:16.303
CONTAIN WAXMAN AND BUT ALUMINUM
03:30:16.370 --> 03:30:18.205
FOIL AND THINGS LIKE THAT HAVE
03:30:18.272 --> 03:30:19.340
NOT PROVEN TO BE.
03:30:19.406 --> 03:30:21.608
SO SO US THAT YOU KNOW I MIGHT
03:30:21.675 --> 03:30:23.677
NOT WHEN MCDONALD'S IS ORDERING
03:30:23.744 --> 03:30:25.646
HAMBURGER WRAPPERS THEY'RE GOING
03:30:25.713 --> 03:30:27.314
BY PRICE AND SIZE AND WHATEVER
03:30:27.381 --> 03:30:28.282
IT IS THEY NEED TO WRAP THEIR
03:30:28.349 --> 03:30:29.483
HAMBURGERS AND SOME OF IT IS
03:30:29.550 --> 03:30:31.151
COMING OUT PERFLUORINATED SOME
03:30:31.218 --> 03:30:33.620
OF IT IS NOT.
03:30:33.687 --> 03:30:34.855
THUNDERSTONE YET FOLLOW YEAH
03:30:34.922 --> 03:30:36.824
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND AFTER
03:30:36.890 --> 03:30:37.658
MY FOLLOW UP I'D LIKE TO GET
03:30:37.725 --> 03:30:39.093
MUCH OPPORTUNITY OPPOSITION TO
03:30:39.159 --> 03:30:40.661
RESPOND TO SOME OF THE THE
03:30:40.728 --> 03:30:42.096
CLAIMS --
03:30:42.162 --> 03:30:44.398
YOU DOCTOR YOU MENTIONED --
03:30:44.465 --> 03:30:46.133
THAT THE SMALL CHAIN AND LARGER
03:30:46.200 --> 03:30:47.701
CHAIN HAVE --
03:30:47.768 --> 03:30:51.038
BECAUSE I ESTROGENIC I WAS ASIDE
03:30:51.105 --> 03:30:52.406
AND RATS --
03:30:52.473 --> 03:30:53.907
OR ANIMALS OR WAS IT DONE SEEN
03:30:53.974 --> 03:30:55.843
HIM AS WELL --
03:30:55.909 --> 03:30:57.277
I'M REFERRING TO THE STUDIES ARE
03:30:57.344 --> 03:30:58.779
REFERENCED IN --
03:30:58.846 --> 03:31:01.315
THE DANISH MINISTRY OF THE
03:31:01.382 --> 03:31:02.649
ENVIRONMENT REVIEW --
03:31:02.716 --> 03:31:04.852
AND I BELIEVE IT WAS ANIMAL
03:31:04.918 --> 03:31:06.220
STUDIES OKAY SO THESE ARE ANIMAL
03:31:06.286 --> 03:31:07.855
STUDIES IN AND I UNDERSTAND THAT
03:31:07.921 --> 03:31:09.790
THE CONCERN THE CONCERN IS THAT.
03:31:09.857 --> 03:31:11.525
WHEN YOU HAVE --
03:31:11.592 --> 03:31:14.328
CHEMICALS THAT MIMIC ESTROGENS --
03:31:14.395 --> 03:31:15.229
IN THE BODY --
03:31:15.295 --> 03:31:16.230
ESTROGEN DIFFERENT IS
03:31:16.296 --> 03:31:17.631
RESPONSIBLE FOR MITOSIS AS YOU
03:31:17.698 --> 03:31:19.066
AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW.
03:31:19.133 --> 03:31:21.035
THE UNCONTROLLED MITOSIS LEADS
03:31:21.101 --> 03:31:24.371
TUMORS WHICH LISA CANCER SO --
03:31:24.438 --> 03:31:25.506
I DON'T THINK WE'VE SEEN ANY
03:31:25.572 --> 03:31:26.306
STUDIES --
03:31:26.373 --> 03:31:28.409
THAT -- SHOW
03:31:28.475 --> 03:31:30.277
ANY KIND EPIDEMIOLOGICAL
03:31:30.344 --> 03:31:34.248
EVIDENCE THAT P. FAT* CAUSE
03:31:34.314 --> 03:31:35.649
THAT I I WOULD.
03:31:35.716 --> 03:31:38.519
I WOULD CERTAINLY LIKE TO SEE IT--
03:31:38.585 --> 03:31:39.119
DO YOU HAVE A STUDY THAT DOES
03:31:39.186 --> 03:31:43.857
THAT.
03:31:43.924 --> 03:31:45.726
IF NOT I I LIKE TO HAVE THE
03:31:45.793 --> 03:31:46.427
OPPOSITION.
03:31:46.493 --> 03:31:49.163
ANSWERS NATIONAL.
03:31:49.229 --> 03:31:50.597
AT S. YOU SEE SAID IT WAS
03:31:50.664 --> 03:31:53.934
ESTROGEN THERE WASN'T CANCER WAS
03:31:54.001 --> 03:31:54.334
IT MISTER JERICHO.
03:31:54.401 --> 03:31:54.668
FEIGEN.
03:31:54.735 --> 03:31:58.138
WHEN YOU HAVE --
03:31:58.205 --> 03:31:59.973
ENTITIES THAT ARE ESTROGENIC
03:32:00.040 --> 03:32:00.874
ACTIVITY THAT ARE NOT TRUE
03:32:00.941 --> 03:32:03.644
ESTROGENS THE DANGER IS THAT
03:32:03.710 --> 03:32:07.014
ESTROGEN CAUSES MITOSIS. FOR
03:32:07.081 --> 03:32:07.948
NATURAL ESTROGEN FOR MEN AND
03:32:08.015 --> 03:32:08.348
WOMEN [inaudible]
03:32:08.415 --> 03:32:12.419
OKAY THE BODY HAS A SCRIBE
03:32:12.486 --> 03:32:14.421
PROCESS FOR CELL DIVISION.
03:32:14.488 --> 03:32:15.556
THE PROBLEM IS WHEN YOU GET
03:32:15.622 --> 03:32:17.091
UNCONTROLLED CELL DIVISION BY
03:32:17.157 --> 03:32:19.026
KWAZII ESTROGENS THAT'S WHAT
03:32:19.093 --> 03:32:20.894
LEADS TO TUMOR FORMATION.
03:32:20.961 --> 03:32:21.695
THAT'S WHY THERE'S THIS BIG
03:32:21.762 --> 03:32:22.796
DEBATE ABOUT --
03:32:22.863 --> 03:32:24.231
ESTROGENS THAT ARE DERIVED FROM
03:32:24.298 --> 03:32:24.531
THAT POINT.
03:32:24.598 --> 03:32:26.500
THAT SEEM TO HAVE A HIGHER
03:32:26.567 --> 03:32:28.001
INCIDENCE OF ENDOMETRIAL AND
03:32:28.068 --> 03:32:29.670
BREAST CANCER BECAUSE THE USER
03:32:29.736 --> 03:32:31.505
FOREIGN TO THE HUMAN BODY.
03:32:31.572 --> 03:32:33.774
SO SHE WAS ST HAS ESTROGENIC
03:32:33.841 --> 03:32:35.309
ACTIVITY WILL WHAT'S THE DANGER
03:32:35.375 --> 03:32:36.443
OF WHAT THE DANGER ABOUT.
03:32:36.510 --> 03:32:38.412
IF IT WAS VALIDATED IN HUMANS IS
03:32:38.479 --> 03:32:39.913
THAT IT COULD CAUSE TUMOR
03:32:39.980 --> 03:32:41.248
FORMATION AND POTENTIALLY CANCER
03:32:41.315 --> 03:32:42.883
I THINK THAT WAS.
03:32:42.950 --> 03:32:45.886
THAT WAS NOT THE OKAY.
03:32:45.953 --> 03:32:46.386
HAVE A QUESTION FOR THE
03:32:46.453 --> 03:32:48.155
OPPOSITION.
03:32:48.222 --> 03:32:49.490
YES THAT I LIKE OPPOSITION TO BE
03:32:49.556 --> 03:32:50.090
ABLE TO RESPOND TO SOME OF THE
03:32:50.157 --> 03:32:54.428
CLAIMS.
03:32:54.495 --> 03:33:01.335
WHAT WAS UP [inaudible] FOR
03:33:01.401 --> 03:33:03.270
THERE ARE NUMEROUS STUDIES THAT
03:33:03.337 --> 03:33:04.571
LINK THE LONG CHAIN.
03:33:04.638 --> 03:33:06.607
BUMPY COST CHEMICALS TO CANCER
03:33:06.673 --> 03:33:06.907
[inaudible]
03:33:06.974 --> 03:33:12.312
I I FOUND.
03:33:12.379 --> 03:33:12.913
I THINK THAT THERE'S CLEARANCE
03:33:12.980 --> 03:33:15.082
THERE.
03:33:15.149 --> 03:33:16.783
THERE'S ALSO EIGHT TWO YEAR
03:33:16.850 --> 03:33:18.385
CANCER STUDY ON THE SHORT CHANGE
03:33:18.452 --> 03:33:20.587
ON THEIR NOT CARCINOGENIC.
03:33:20.654 --> 03:33:21.455
I THINK THAT WHAT'S RELEVANT TO
03:33:21.522 --> 03:33:24.591
WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE.
03:33:24.658 --> 03:33:26.326
BUT IF I COULD RESPOND A SOME OF
03:33:26.393 --> 03:33:27.261
THE OTHER POINTS THAT HAVE BEEN
03:33:27.327 --> 03:33:29.229
RAISED --
03:33:29.296 --> 03:33:29.796
AND KNOW SOMEONE MEMBER TING
03:33:29.863 --> 03:33:31.331
MENTIONED THE FDA REVIEW PROCESS
03:33:31.398 --> 03:33:32.933
AND I THINK THE FACT THAT THEY
03:33:33.000 --> 03:33:34.735
NO LONGER ALLOW THE USE OF LONG
03:33:34.801 --> 03:33:36.236
CHAINS SHOWS THAT THEIR PROCESS
03:33:36.303 --> 03:33:37.171
IS WORKING.
03:33:37.237 --> 03:33:39.339
SO AS THEY ALLOW A PRODUCT TO GO
03:33:39.406 --> 03:33:40.674
TO MARKET.
03:33:40.741 --> 03:33:42.142
FTA BURKE SORT OF APPROVAL
03:33:42.209 --> 03:33:44.144
LETTER ESSENTIALLY SAYS IF YOU
03:33:44.211 --> 03:33:45.479
OR ANYONE BECOMES AWARE OF ANY
03:33:45.546 --> 03:33:46.947
STUDY THAT SHOWS.
03:33:47.014 --> 03:33:48.749
THAT THIS PRODUCT OR CHEMISTRY
03:33:48.815 --> 03:33:50.117
CONTINUED WILL NOT MEET OUR
03:33:50.184 --> 03:33:51.485
SAFETY STANDARD.
03:33:51.552 --> 03:33:53.086
TAKE A WE WILL LOOK AT IT AND
03:33:53.153 --> 03:33:54.588
CAN PULL IT OFF OF THE MARKET
03:33:54.655 --> 03:33:55.222
THAT'S WHAT THEY'VE DONE WITH
03:33:55.289 --> 03:33:56.089
THELONG CHAINS.
03:33:56.156 --> 03:33:57.457
THEY HAVE NOT TAKEN ANY ACTION
03:33:57.524 --> 03:33:59.193
LIKE THAT ON THE SHORT CHAINS.
03:33:59.259 --> 03:34:00.594
I'M I ALSO FEELING WERE SPENDING
03:34:00.661 --> 03:34:01.895
A LOT OF TIME TALKING ABOUT SOME
03:34:01.962 --> 03:34:04.498
OF THE SOME OF THE ON THE
03:34:04.565 --> 03:34:06.133
SCIENCE BUT AGAIN WAS IMPORTANT
03:34:06.200 --> 03:34:08.402
UNDERSTAND HERE IS WHAT'S USED
03:34:08.468 --> 03:34:09.503
IN FOOD PACKAGING.
03:34:09.570 --> 03:34:11.705
IS A POLYMER.
03:34:11.772 --> 03:34:13.407
WHAT'S OF CONCERN IS WHAT MIGHT
03:34:13.473 --> 03:34:15.676
THAT PALMER BREAKDOWN TO THOSE
03:34:15.742 --> 03:34:16.643
OF THE SMALLER MOLECULES THAT'S
03:34:16.710 --> 03:34:18.712
WHAT'S OF INTEREST.
03:34:18.779 --> 03:34:19.613
THERE'S NEW DATA WAS HAVE WHICH
03:34:19.680 --> 03:34:20.747
HASN'T YET BEEN PUBLISHED BUT
03:34:20.814 --> 03:34:22.182
HAS BEEN PROVIDED TO REGULATORS
03:34:22.249 --> 03:34:23.450
SHOWING THAT IT CAN TAKE
03:34:23.517 --> 03:34:25.385
THOUSANDS OF YEARS FOR THOSE
03:34:25.452 --> 03:34:26.887
POLYMERS TO BREAK DOWN.
03:34:26.954 --> 03:34:27.754
SO WHAT YOU'RE REALLY BEING
03:34:27.821 --> 03:34:29.489
EXPOSED TO IS A POLYMER YOU NOT
03:34:29.556 --> 03:34:30.791
BEING EXPOSED TO THOSE SMALLER
03:34:30.857 --> 03:34:33.060
SUBSTANCES IN THE HOUR THAT
03:34:33.126 --> 03:34:34.861
YOU'RE EATING YOUR FAST FOOD OR
03:34:34.928 --> 03:34:36.496
WHATEVER IT IS SO THAT'S THAT'S
03:34:36.563 --> 03:34:38.065
REALLY IMPORTANT.
03:34:38.131 --> 03:34:39.566
SOME OF THE THE STATEMENTS MADE
03:34:39.633 --> 03:34:40.968
BY THE SUPPOSED SUPPORTERS OF
03:34:41.034 --> 03:34:43.637
THE BILL REGARDING --
03:34:43.704 --> 03:34:45.072
SOME OF THE POTENTIAL CONCERNS
03:34:45.138 --> 03:34:46.907
ARE NOT LOOKING AT THE ROBUST
03:34:46.974 --> 03:34:48.408
BODY OF DATA ON THIS CHEMISTRY
03:34:48.475 --> 03:34:49.977
IT'S ESSENTIALLY PICKING A
03:34:50.043 --> 03:34:51.011
COUPLE STUDIES THERE ARE
03:34:51.078 --> 03:34:52.412
CONSISTENT WITH WHAT WE'RE
03:34:52.479 --> 03:34:53.981
SEEING IN OTHER STUDIES SO FOR
03:34:54.047 --> 03:34:55.515
EXAMPLE THE TWENTY SEVENTEEN
03:34:55.582 --> 03:34:56.116
STUDY.
03:34:56.183 --> 03:34:57.851
THAT THAT LOOKED AT THE SHOW
03:34:57.918 --> 03:34:58.919
WHERE SOME THESE CHEMICALS MIGHT
03:34:58.986 --> 03:35:00.854
GO AND I THINK IT WAS RATS OR
03:35:00.921 --> 03:35:02.356
MICE -- THAT
03:35:02.422 --> 03:35:04.024
WAS A FOUR HOUR STUDY IT LOOKED
03:35:04.091 --> 03:35:05.692
AT WHERE MIGHT THESE CHEMICALS
03:35:05.759 --> 03:35:07.461
GO IN FOUR HOURS THERE'S A MORE
03:35:07.527 --> 03:35:09.296
ROBUST STUDY THAT LOOKS AT WHERE
03:35:09.363 --> 03:35:10.731
THESE CHEMICALS GO OVER A LONGER
03:35:10.797 --> 03:35:11.798
PERIOD OF TIME.
03:35:11.865 --> 03:35:13.200
AND IT SHOWS THAT IN TWENTY FOUR
03:35:13.267 --> 03:35:15.736
HOURS THEY CLEARED BODY SO WHERE
03:35:15.802 --> 03:35:17.437
THEY GO IN FOR HOURS.
03:35:17.504 --> 03:35:18.372
I REALLY THEIR RELEVANT THEY'RE
03:35:18.438 --> 03:35:20.140
GONE ENACT IN A DAY.
03:35:20.207 --> 03:35:22.042
SO THAT'S IMPORTANT ALSO THE
03:35:22.109 --> 03:35:25.112
FACT THAT THESE CHEMICALS OR IN
03:35:25.178 --> 03:35:26.647
60% OF FOOD WRAPPING DOESN'T
03:35:26.713 --> 03:35:27.981
MEAN THERE'S ALTERNATIVES
03:35:28.048 --> 03:35:28.915
AVAILABLE.
03:35:28.982 --> 03:35:32.953
AS I SAID EARLIER YOU DON'T NEED.
03:35:33.020 --> 03:35:34.521
YOU DON'T NEED AN A CUP YOU
03:35:34.588 --> 03:35:36.590
DON'T NEED A NAPKIN YOU NEED IT
03:35:36.657 --> 03:35:38.525
WHEN YOU'RE WRAPPING SOMETHING
03:35:38.592 --> 03:35:39.760
GREASY OILY.
03:35:39.826 --> 03:35:42.896
YOUR HASH BROWNS YOUR BURGER AND
03:35:42.963 --> 03:35:44.564
THOSE THE COMPANIES ARE SELLING
03:35:44.631 --> 03:35:46.533
THOSE PRODUCTS HAVE SPECIFIC
03:35:46.600 --> 03:35:47.868
PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS THAT
03:35:47.934 --> 03:35:49.503
THEY'RE LOOKING FOR AND THAT'S
03:35:49.569 --> 03:35:51.638
WHAT THIS CHEMISTRY PROVIDES.
03:35:51.705 --> 03:35:53.173
THERE MAY BE SOME ALTERNATIVES
03:35:53.240 --> 03:35:54.441
THEY ARE MORE EXPENSIVE AND LIKE
03:35:54.508 --> 03:35:56.810
I SAID CAN'T ALWAYS BE RECYCLED
03:35:56.877 --> 03:35:58.178
CAN'T ALWAYS BE.
03:35:58.245 --> 03:36:00.147
ON COMPOST SO THERE'S SOME
03:36:00.213 --> 03:36:02.015
DRAWBACKS WITH THAT ASSEMBLY
03:36:02.082 --> 03:36:04.217
MEMBER TING OKAY LET YOU --
03:36:04.284 --> 03:36:06.486
CLOSE OTHERWISE WE WILL BE HERE
03:36:06.553 --> 03:36:07.321
TILL THREE O'CLOCK IN THE
03:36:07.387 --> 03:36:09.022
MORNING YEAH BUT I HAD WE'VE HAD
03:36:09.089 --> 03:36:10.590
EXHAUSTED CONVERSATION --
03:36:10.657 --> 03:36:12.559
WHICH IS.
03:36:12.626 --> 03:36:13.727
BUCKLEY THE RULE IN THIS
03:36:13.794 --> 03:36:15.228
COMMITTEE SO PLEASE CLOSE IF THE
03:36:15.295 --> 03:36:16.730
FAQ --
03:36:16.797 --> 03:36:18.632
MISTER CHAIR OR THE VERY ROBUST
03:36:18.699 --> 03:36:20.100
CONVERSATION I THINK.
03:36:20.167 --> 03:36:21.535
NOT AGAIN HERE WE'VE TALKED
03:36:21.601 --> 03:36:24.237
ABOUT THE THE FDA PROT PROCESS
03:36:24.304 --> 03:36:25.939
THE LONG CHAIN SHORTENING.
03:36:26.006 --> 03:36:27.841
THAT ULTIMATELY WHAT WE'RE
03:36:27.908 --> 03:36:29.042
STARTING TO SEE IS.
03:36:29.109 --> 03:36:30.344
AS THE BODY OF EVIDENCE
03:36:30.410 --> 03:36:31.912
CONTINUES TO BUILD THAT THE
03:36:31.978 --> 03:36:33.947
SHORT CHAINS ARE PROVING TO BE --
03:36:34.014 --> 03:36:35.716
AS DANGEROUS AS A LONG CHAINS WE
03:36:35.782 --> 03:36:37.184
BELIEVE THAT AGAIN --
03:36:37.250 --> 03:36:38.685
CONSUMERS ARE BEST OFF WHEN THEY
03:36:38.752 --> 03:36:40.887
HAVE THE RIGHT INFORMATION THE
03:36:40.954 --> 03:36:42.222
RIGHT DECISION.
03:36:42.289 --> 03:36:43.790
WE ALSO HAVE SEEN THAT THERE'S
03:36:43.857 --> 03:36:46.460
NOT NECESSARILY A REASON WHY --
03:36:46.526 --> 03:36:48.328
THESE MATERIALS HAVE TO EXIST
03:36:48.395 --> 03:36:49.896
EVEN EVEN IN CERTAIN WRAPPINGS
03:36:49.963 --> 03:36:54.634
THAT'S WHAT THE ENVIRONMENTAL --
03:36:54.701 --> 03:36:56.570
FOR THE SHOW TO START AGAIN NOT
03:36:56.636 --> 03:36:57.471
EVERY --
03:36:57.537 --> 03:36:58.972
COMPANY EVEN HAD MADE THESE
03:36:59.039 --> 03:37:01.475
DECISIONS CONSCIOUSLY SO --
03:37:01.541 --> 03:37:02.809
WE BELIEVE THAT THIS LABELLING
03:37:02.876 --> 03:37:04.544
IT'S A VERY SMALL STEP IN THE
03:37:04.611 --> 03:37:05.712
PROCESS --
03:37:05.779 --> 03:37:07.180
WE WOULD ALSO NOTE THAT THE
03:37:07.247 --> 03:37:08.615
GREEN CHEMISTRY PROCESS DOES NOT
03:37:08.682 --> 03:37:09.983
TOUCH COOKWARE ONLY WITH FOOD
03:37:10.050 --> 03:37:11.184
WRAPPING AND DIPPED AS A
03:37:11.251 --> 03:37:12.919
PRESENCE IN BOTH OF THESE ITEMS.
03:37:12.986 --> 03:37:13.487
AND WITHOUT A RESPECT FOR US
03:37:13.553 --> 03:37:14.554
RIGHT.
03:37:14.621 --> 03:37:17.557
SURE ONE CAN IN MOTION.
03:37:17.624 --> 03:37:19.092
THERE'S A MOTION BY CENTER STERN
03:37:19.159 --> 03:37:20.160
THIS IS TO PASS TO
03:37:20.227 --> 03:37:21.328
APPROPRIATIONS PLEASE CALL THE
03:37:21.395 --> 03:37:24.464
ROLL.
03:37:24.531 --> 03:37:28.068
ITEM NUMBER FOUR AB.
03:37:28.135 --> 03:37:28.635
NINE FIVE EIGHT BY ASSEMBLY
03:37:28.702 --> 03:37:29.703
MEMBER TEAM.
03:37:29.770 --> 03:37:31.271
THE MOTION ES DE PASSED IN THE
03:37:31.338 --> 03:37:33.240
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE.
03:37:33.306 --> 03:37:34.841
WIECKOWSKI AYE MCCASKEY AYE
03:37:34.908 --> 03:37:36.309
STONE.
03:37:36.376 --> 03:37:37.778
STONE NO GAMES [inaudible]
03:37:37.844 --> 03:37:39.312
HILL [inaudible]
03:37:39.379 --> 03:37:40.380
LARA [inaudible]
03:37:40.447 --> 03:37:42.382
SKINNER.
03:37:42.449 --> 03:37:43.049
STERN.
03:37:43.116 --> 03:37:44.785
STERN AYE OKAY WILL KEEP THAT
03:37:44.851 --> 03:37:46.753
MATTER AND CALL YOUR OTHER
03:37:46.820 --> 03:37:47.721
MATTERS ON CONSENT THANK YOU
03:37:47.788 --> 03:37:57.164
VERY MUCH I WE TAKE QUICK PAUSE
03:37:57.230 --> 03:37:59.366
AND I'LL BE RIGHT BACK
03:37:59.433 --> 03:37:59.666
[inaudible]
03:37:59.733 --> 03:38:01.268
TO CALL UP.
03:38:01.334 --> 03:38:14.981
ITEM NUMBER FIVE A. B.
03:38:15.048 --> 03:38:15.282
[inaudible]
03:38:15.348 --> 03:38:31.698
NINE EIGHT SEVEN YEAH
03:38:45.445 --> 03:38:45.679
[inaudible]
03:38:45.745 --> 03:39:01.795
HOW
03:39:16.510 --> 03:39:16.676
[inaudible]
03:39:16.743 --> 03:39:32.792
YES
03:39:45.572 --> 03:39:45.739
[inaudible]
03:39:45.805 --> 03:39:51.444
MAINLY [inaudible]
03:39:51.511 --> 03:40:07.627
BECAUSE
03:40:19.406 --> 03:40:29.015
CANADA WILL GET
03:40:29.082 --> 03:40:29.316
[inaudible]
03:40:29.382 --> 03:40:31.618
OKAY OKAY [inaudible]
03:40:31.685 --> 03:40:37.958
THE MONEY.
03:40:38.024 --> 03:40:39.559
MY NO FALSE.
03:40:39.626 --> 03:40:43.763
ART LET'S I GO BACK ON THE A
03:40:43.830 --> 03:40:45.565
COMMITTEE ARE LET'S CALL UP ITEM
03:40:45.632 --> 03:40:46.099
NUMBER [inaudible]
03:40:46.166 --> 03:40:48.335
FIVE S. ASSEMBLYMEMBER.
03:40:48.401 --> 03:40:50.704
CALM LAGER.
03:40:50.770 --> 03:40:53.139
THANK YOU FOR BEING SO PATIENT --
03:40:53.206 --> 03:40:54.307
THEY TOLD YOU THAT THINGS ARE
03:40:54.374 --> 03:40:55.108
DIFFERENT IN THE SENATE
03:40:55.175 --> 03:40:56.409
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE
03:40:56.476 --> 03:40:57.377
AND YOU'RE GETTING FIRST HAND
03:40:57.444 --> 03:40:58.578
EXPERIENCE [inaudible]
03:40:58.645 --> 03:41:00.046
ME.
03:41:00.113 --> 03:41:01.848
WE DON'T GO CHEAPLY ON OUR
03:41:01.915 --> 03:41:03.850
ANALYSIS SO --
03:41:03.917 --> 03:41:05.452
WELCOME HERE FOR THOSE FOLKS
03:41:05.518 --> 03:41:10.423
THAT -- THAT
03:41:10.490 --> 03:41:12.225
HAVE THE BENEFIT I HAVE HAD
03:41:12.292 --> 03:41:14.160
NUMEROUS DISCUSSIONS WITH
03:41:14.227 --> 03:41:15.895
PROPONENTS.
03:41:15.962 --> 03:41:18.264
AND LOOKED AT VARIOUS VERSIONS
03:41:18.331 --> 03:41:20.900
OF PLEDGES OF OF LANGUAGE THAT
03:41:20.967 --> 03:41:22.636
WOULD BE ACCEPTABLE NOT BE
03:41:22.702 --> 03:41:24.070
ACCEPTABLE SO.
03:41:24.137 --> 03:41:26.006
IN ABUNDANCE OF EXPAND OUR
03:41:26.072 --> 03:41:27.707
DISCLOSURE --
03:41:27.774 --> 03:41:29.442
GIVEN THE PREVIOUS BILL THAT WAS
03:41:29.509 --> 03:41:30.477
HERE PLEASE [inaudible]
03:41:30.543 --> 03:41:31.578
PROCEED [inaudible]
03:41:31.645 --> 03:41:34.381
THANK YOU.
03:41:34.447 --> 03:41:35.915
MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS I AM
03:41:35.982 --> 03:41:38.685
HONORED TO PRESENT AB NINE EIGHT
03:41:38.752 --> 03:41:39.486
SEVEN WHICH WILL BRING TO MY
03:41:39.552 --> 03:41:40.654
DISTRICT AND TO SURROUNDING
03:41:40.720 --> 03:41:41.721
COMMUNITIES.
03:41:41.788 --> 03:41:43.690
A JOBS AND CONTRACT CONSTRUCTION
03:41:43.757 --> 03:41:45.358
INVESTMENT OF NEARLY ONE POINT
03:41:45.425 --> 03:41:47.127
FIVE BILLION DOLLARS.
03:41:47.193 --> 03:41:47.994
I WANT TO THANK YOU COMMITTEE
03:41:48.061 --> 03:41:49.129
STAFF FOR THEIR THOROUGH
03:41:49.195 --> 03:41:50.530
ANALYSIS.
03:41:50.597 --> 03:41:51.865
IT INCLUDES CONTEXTUAL
03:41:51.931 --> 03:41:53.033
BACKGROUND AND AN UNDERSTANDING
03:41:53.099 --> 03:41:55.368
OF THE PLAYERS.
03:41:55.435 --> 03:41:56.469
AS YOU CONSIDER THIS IMPORTANT
03:41:56.536 --> 03:41:58.471
LEGISLATION I URGE YOU TO
03:41:58.538 --> 03:42:00.240
REMEMBER THATTHIS BILL IS AS
03:42:00.306 --> 03:42:01.374
MUCH ABOUT ECONOMIC
03:42:01.441 --> 03:42:03.510
ENFRANCHISEMENT AS IT IS ABOUT
03:42:03.576 --> 03:42:05.311
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY.
03:42:05.378 --> 03:42:07.180
THEIR ARE ENDEAVORS FOR THE
03:42:07.247 --> 03:42:09.049
COMMUNITIES BENEFIT THAT ARE
03:42:09.115 --> 03:42:11.851
WORTH CONTENTIOUS COMPETITION.
03:42:11.918 --> 03:42:13.887
WHEN IS IT WORTH IT TO FIGHT?
03:42:13.953 --> 03:42:15.655
IT'S WORTH IT TO FIGHT WHEN IN
03:42:15.722 --> 03:42:17.057
THE END PRODUCT CAN BE A
03:42:17.123 --> 03:42:21.361
MITIGATION. 29% OF THE CHILDREN.
03:42:21.428 --> 03:42:22.562
IN MY DISTRICT IN IN THE
03:42:22.629 --> 03:42:24.497
IMMEDIATE SURROUNDING AREAS THAT
03:42:24.564 --> 03:42:26.633
LIVE BELOW THE POVERTY LINE.
03:42:26.700 --> 03:42:27.934
WHY WHEN UNEMPLOYMENT RATES IN
03:42:28.001 --> 03:42:29.202
MY DISTRICT AND IN IMMEDIATE
03:42:29.269 --> 03:42:30.570
SURROUNDING AREAS ARE A
03:42:30.637 --> 03:42:32.038
STAGGERING THREE TIMES THE
03:42:32.105 --> 03:42:34.107
STATEWIDE AVERAGE?
03:42:34.174 --> 03:42:35.008
AND WHEN THE CREATION OF
03:42:35.075 --> 03:42:36.976
SUSTAINABLE JOBS.
03:42:37.043 --> 03:42:38.445
IS AVAILABLE THAT WILL CHANGE
03:42:38.511 --> 03:42:40.714
COMMUNITIES AND LIVES.
03:42:40.780 --> 03:42:41.948
THE WAY TO TACKLE THESE VERY
03:42:42.015 --> 03:42:43.983
REAL ISSUES.
03:42:44.050 --> 03:42:45.351
CAN BE FROM DEVELOPMENT
03:42:45.418 --> 03:42:48.388
IRRESPONSIBLE TAX BASE AND JOBS.
03:42:48.455 --> 03:42:49.923
AB NINE EIGHT SEVEN WOULD DO
03:42:49.989 --> 03:42:51.624
JUST THAT AND MAYBE ONE OF THE
03:42:51.691 --> 03:42:53.293
MOST DIRECT WAYS WE HERE IN
03:42:53.359 --> 03:42:55.195
SACRAMENTO CAN DEMONSTRATE OUR
03:42:55.261 --> 03:42:56.863
SUPPORT FOR NEIGHBORHOODS AND
03:42:56.930 --> 03:42:59.165
DISTRICTS LIKE MINE.
03:42:59.232 --> 03:43:00.467
THIS BILL WOULD ALLOW THE LA
03:43:00.533 --> 03:43:01.868
CLIPPERS TO EMBARK ON A
03:43:01.935 --> 03:43:03.369
TRANSFORMATIVE TECH FORWARD
03:43:03.436 --> 03:43:05.071
SPORTS ARENA AND COMMUNITY
03:43:05.138 --> 03:43:07.073
COMPLEX IN INGLEWOOD.
03:43:07.140 --> 03:43:08.875
THEY ARE THE ONLY NBA FRANCHISE
03:43:08.942 --> 03:43:10.610
THAT HAS TO SHARE A FACILITY
03:43:10.677 --> 03:43:13.313
WITH NOT ONE BUT TWO OTHER TEAMS.
03:43:13.379 --> 03:43:15.014
THIS BILL ROLE WILL REQUIRE A
03:43:15.081 --> 03:43:16.516
FULL AND COMPREHENSIVE III ARE
03:43:16.583 --> 03:43:18.585
WITH NO SHORT CUTS.
03:43:18.651 --> 03:43:19.452
THE CONSTRUCTION WILL BE
03:43:19.519 --> 03:43:21.554
COMPLETED WITH NO PUBLIC FUNDS
03:43:21.621 --> 03:43:24.057
AND WILL BE GOLD LEED CERTIFIED.
03:43:24.124 --> 03:43:25.725
IN THE RELATIVELY SHORT TIME
03:43:25.792 --> 03:43:27.327
THAT I HAVE CARRIED THIS BILL.
03:43:27.393 --> 03:43:28.895
I'VE TRIED TO BE RESPONSIVE TO
03:43:28.962 --> 03:43:30.130
THE CONCERNS AND WE HAVE OFFERED
03:43:30.196 --> 03:43:32.132
AMENDMENTS THAT MEET THE SAME
03:43:32.198 --> 03:43:33.867
CARBONI CHALABI STANDARDS FOR
03:43:33.933 --> 03:43:35.869
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS AS AS
03:43:35.935 --> 03:43:36.936
WE HAVE SEEN IN OTHER PROJECTS
03:43:37.003 --> 03:43:38.571
LIKE THIS.
03:43:38.638 --> 03:43:40.473
AND TO MANDATE NOT SUGGEST BUT
03:43:40.540 --> 03:43:41.841
TO MANDATE A TRANSPORTATION
03:43:41.908 --> 03:43:43.877
MANAGEMENT PLAN THAT RESULTS IN
03:43:43.943 --> 03:43:46.112
A 15% REDUCTION IN VEHICLE TRIPS
03:43:46.179 --> 03:43:47.514
TO THE ARENA [inaudible]
03:43:47.580 --> 03:43:49.482
IN ADDITION.
03:43:49.549 --> 03:43:50.850
I HAVE LISTENED TO THE CHAIR
03:43:50.917 --> 03:43:52.385
ABOUT YOUR CONCERNS REGARDING
03:43:52.452 --> 03:43:54.454
ENFORCEMENT AND WOULD LIKE TO
03:43:54.521 --> 03:43:57.690
OFFER TO ALLOW CA RP TO CERTIFY
03:43:57.757 --> 03:43:59.492
THE METHODOLOGY USED TO ACHIEVE
03:43:59.559 --> 03:44:00.994
CARBON NEUTRALITY.
03:44:01.060 --> 03:44:02.295
AND REQUIRE THAT THE AGENCY
03:44:02.362 --> 03:44:04.864
REQUIRE ADDITIONAL MITIGATION IF
03:44:04.931 --> 03:44:06.399
NET ZERO IS NOT ACHIEVED AFTER
03:44:06.466 --> 03:44:08.468
THE FIRST YEAR.
03:44:08.535 --> 03:44:09.335
THOSE AND I STOPPED THERE
03:44:09.402 --> 03:44:10.904
BECAUSE I'M.
03:44:10.970 --> 03:44:12.172
BECAUSE IS STATIONARY SOURCE
03:44:12.238 --> 03:44:14.007
FROM NOT SURE I GET THE INTENT
03:44:14.073 --> 03:44:15.942
THAT IT WILL BE CARB MATE DO
03:44:16.009 --> 03:44:18.511
MOBILE SOURCES AT THE LOCAL.
03:44:18.578 --> 03:44:20.146
AIR DISTRICT MADE YOU.
03:44:20.213 --> 03:44:21.347
STATIONARY SOURCES BUT I GET THE
03:44:21.414 --> 03:44:25.518
INTENT AYE I GET.
03:44:25.585 --> 03:44:26.820
THOSE STANDARDS ON THE MINI
03:44:26.886 --> 03:44:28.488
COMMUNITY BENEFITS OFFERED ARE
03:44:28.555 --> 03:44:30.223
IMPROVEMENTS THAT QUITE FRANKLY
03:44:30.290 --> 03:44:31.558
HAVE NOT BEEN OFFERED BY OTHER
03:44:31.624 --> 03:44:33.092
DEVELOPERS ARE EVEN CURRENT
03:44:33.159 --> 03:44:35.094
PROPERTY OWNERS IN THE AREA.
03:44:35.161 --> 03:44:37.964
DOWNTOWN LA WAS NOT A HOT ZIP
03:44:38.031 --> 03:44:40.099
CODE UNTIL STAPLE CENTER CAME
03:44:40.166 --> 03:44:42.569
AND COMMITTED ITSELF TO THE AREA.
03:44:42.635 --> 03:44:44.504
IT WAS THAT INITIAL DEVELOPMENT
03:44:44.571 --> 03:44:46.472
THAT LEVERAGE THE REVITALIZATION
03:44:46.539 --> 03:44:47.707
THAT WE HAVE WITNESSED IN
03:44:47.774 --> 03:44:49.242
DOWNTOWN LA CREATING MORE
03:44:49.309 --> 03:44:51.377
HOUSING BUSINESS ESTABLISHMENTS
03:44:51.444 --> 03:44:53.079
WALKABLE NEIGHBORHOODS
03:44:53.146 --> 03:44:54.414
ACCESSIBLE EFFICIENT PUBLIC
03:44:54.480 --> 03:44:56.249
TRANSPORTATION ACCESS AND A NEW
03:44:56.316 --> 03:44:58.251
TAX BASE.
03:44:58.318 --> 03:44:59.752
WHY WOULD WE DENY INGLEWOOD THE
03:44:59.819 --> 03:45:01.754
SAME OPPORTUNITIES?
03:45:01.821 --> 03:45:03.456
AB NINE EIGHT SEVEN REQUIRES
03:45:03.523 --> 03:45:04.557
THAT LOCAL MITIGATION BE
03:45:04.624 --> 03:45:06.626
CONDUCTED ON SITE AND IN THE
03:45:06.693 --> 03:45:08.294
SURROUNDING COMMUNITIES CARBON
03:45:08.361 --> 03:45:09.662
OFFSET CREDITS WOULD ALSO BE
03:45:09.729 --> 03:45:11.164
USED SOMETHING THAT WOULD
03:45:11.231 --> 03:45:12.966
BENEFIT THE ENTIRE STATE.
03:45:13.032 --> 03:45:14.434
AB NINE EIGHT SEVEN HAS A
03:45:14.500 --> 03:45:16.469
PROJECT LABOR AGREEMENT ASSURING
03:45:16.536 --> 03:45:17.003
THAT THE JOBS WILL BE HIGH
03:45:17.070 --> 03:45:18.204
PAYING.
03:45:18.271 --> 03:45:20.807
THIS PROJECT HAS A 3235% LOCAL
03:45:20.874 --> 03:45:22.642
HIRE PROVISION.
03:45:22.709 --> 03:45:24.043
AS WE CONTINUE TO HEAR FROM
03:45:24.110 --> 03:45:25.645
BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITIES WHO
03:45:25.712 --> 03:45:27.413
FEEL EDGED OUT OF CAREER
03:45:27.480 --> 03:45:28.848
OPPORTUNITIES IN CONSTRUCTION
03:45:28.915 --> 03:45:30.316
AND OPERATIONAL SECTORS A
03:45:30.383 --> 03:45:31.751
COMMITMENT TO LOCAL HIGHER IS
03:45:31.818 --> 03:45:34.687
VERY IMPORTANT. EIGHTY NINE
03:45:34.754 --> 03:45:36.155
EIGHT SEVEN FOCUSES ON TWENTY
03:45:36.222 --> 03:45:37.490
SEVEN ACRES OF LAND THAT IS
03:45:37.557 --> 03:45:38.925
UNDER A FLIGHT PATH AND
03:45:38.992 --> 03:45:41.094
ACCORDING TO THE FAA IS NOT
03:45:41.160 --> 03:45:41.594
SUITABLE FOR RESIDENTIAL
03:45:41.661 --> 03:45:42.829
DEVELOPMENT.
03:45:42.896 --> 03:45:44.831
IT IS TRUE.
03:45:44.898 --> 03:45:45.965
BUT INGLEWOOD NEEDS MORE
03:45:46.032 --> 03:45:48.101
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IT IS ALSO
03:45:48.167 --> 03:45:49.269
TRUE THAT INGLEWOOD NEEDS A
03:45:49.335 --> 03:45:51.204
DIVERSIFIED TAX REVENUE BASE
03:45:51.271 --> 03:45:52.705
HELP WITH THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT
03:45:52.772 --> 03:45:54.107
AND SOME RECOGNITION FROM THE
03:45:54.173 --> 03:45:55.375
STATE THAT IT HAS BEEN
03:45:55.441 --> 03:45:56.609
OVERLOOKED WHEN IT COMES TO
03:45:56.676 --> 03:45:58.678
FINANCIAL SUPPORTS.
03:45:58.745 --> 03:46:00.046
THIS BILL ACCOMPLISHES
03:46:00.113 --> 03:46:01.147
OBJECTIVES AND AN ENHANCED TIME
03:46:01.214 --> 03:46:02.515
FRAME.
03:46:02.582 --> 03:46:04.384
IT DOES SPEED UP LITIGATION AND
03:46:04.450 --> 03:46:05.919
PROVIDES FOR EXTENSIVE PUBLIC
03:46:05.985 --> 03:46:07.353
COMMENT AND AN OPEN FRAME FOR
03:46:07.420 --> 03:46:09.055
CHALLENGE AS WELL AS A FULL AND
03:46:09.122 --> 03:46:10.156
COMPREHENSIVE III ARE WITH NO
03:46:10.223 --> 03:46:12.125
COMPROMISES.
03:46:12.191 --> 03:46:14.260
THERE MUST BE PARITY IN HOW WE
03:46:14.327 --> 03:46:16.296
TREAT SAN FRANCISCO SACRAMENTO
03:46:16.362 --> 03:46:18.031
IN INGLEWOOD.
03:46:18.097 --> 03:46:19.866
HOW WE FIGHT AND FOR WHICH
03:46:19.933 --> 03:46:21.834
COMMUNITIES WE FIGHT DEFINES THE
03:46:21.901 --> 03:46:22.568
VERY CHARACTER OF THIS
03:46:22.635 --> 03:46:25.071
LEGISLATIVE BODY?
03:46:25.138 --> 03:46:28.908
CHAIR STAFF MEMBERS I INVITE YOU
03:46:28.975 --> 03:46:30.376
TO PULL UP TO THE DRIVE THRU IT
03:46:30.443 --> 03:46:31.911
RANDY'S DONUTS ON MANCHESTER
03:46:31.978 --> 03:46:33.012
BOULEVARD.
03:46:33.079 --> 03:46:35.481
GET THE GLAZE TWIST AND A MOCHA
03:46:35.548 --> 03:46:37.583
AND SEE THE DIVERSITY BUT ALSO
03:46:37.650 --> 03:46:39.218
THE NEED FOR IMPROVEMENTS.
03:46:39.285 --> 03:46:41.521
STOP BY DARBY PARK AND VISIT THE
03:46:41.587 --> 03:46:43.790
MLK CENTER THAT HOSTS DALY
03:46:43.856 --> 03:46:45.558
SENIOR ACTIVITIES AND MY
03:46:45.625 --> 03:46:46.559
STEPSON'S YOUTH BASKETBALL
03:46:46.626 --> 03:46:48.528
LEAGUE.
03:46:48.594 --> 03:46:50.863
AND WAIT IN LINE AT DYLAN'S FOR
03:46:50.930 --> 03:46:53.066
OXTAILS AND SWEET POTATO PIE.
03:46:53.132 --> 03:46:54.600
THIS SMALL BUSINESS HAS A RICH
03:46:54.667 --> 03:46:56.035
MENU AND AN EVEN RICHER CIVIC
03:46:56.102 --> 03:46:57.470
LEGACY.
03:46:57.537 --> 03:46:59.572
TAKE THESE TOURS WITH ME AND SEE
03:46:59.639 --> 03:47:01.607
WHERE THIS CITY IS AND HOW IT
03:47:01.674 --> 03:47:04.477
COULD BENEFIT FROM AB.
03:47:04.544 --> 03:47:05.111
NINE EIGHT SEVEN I HAVE SEVERAL
03:47:05.178 --> 03:47:07.113
WITNESSES REPRESENTING ORGANIZED
03:47:07.180 --> 03:47:08.915
LABOR AND THE TEAM HOPING TO
03:47:08.982 --> 03:47:10.416
BRING THIS PROJECT TO THE SOUTH
03:47:10.483 --> 03:47:13.086
LA IN INGLEWOOD AREAS.
03:47:13.152 --> 03:47:14.821
AND ACTIVATE TENS OF THOUSANDS
03:47:14.887 --> 03:47:16.589
OF JOBS CONNECTED TO THIS
03:47:16.656 --> 03:47:18.157
DEVELOPMENT THERE ARE ALSO
03:47:18.224 --> 03:47:19.926
PEOPLE FROM THE COMMUNITY HERE
03:47:19.993 --> 03:47:21.260
WHO ARE IN SUPPORT.
03:47:21.327 --> 03:47:22.695
I CERTAINLY APPRECIATE THIS TIME
03:47:22.762 --> 03:47:24.263
WITH YOU AND RESPECTFULLY ASK
03:47:24.330 --> 03:47:26.733
YOUR AYE VOTE.
03:47:26.799 --> 03:47:27.767
PART WELL LET'S START UP FOR
03:47:27.834 --> 03:47:31.070
THEIR FIRST WITNESSES SUPPORT.
03:47:31.137 --> 03:47:32.805
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS JOE
03:47:32.872 --> 03:47:33.740
LAYING REPRESENTING MURPHY'S
03:47:33.806 --> 03:47:34.941
BOWL IN AFFILIATE OF THE LOS
03:47:35.008 --> 03:47:38.811
ANGELES CA.
03:47:38.878 --> 03:47:41.314
HAPPY TO BE HERE TO DESCRIBE THE
03:47:41.381 --> 03:47:43.282
INVESTMENT COMMITMENT THAT THE
03:47:43.349 --> 03:47:45.385
TEAM AND THE DEVELOPER AND OWNER
03:47:45.451 --> 03:47:47.286
MAKING TO A DISADVANTAGE LOW
03:47:47.353 --> 03:47:49.589
INCOME COMMUNITY.
03:47:49.655 --> 03:47:51.024
THEY'RE EXCITED ABOUT MAKING
03:47:51.090 --> 03:47:52.425
THAT INVESTMENT.
03:47:52.492 --> 03:47:54.861
THE REASON WE'RE HERE.
03:47:54.927 --> 03:47:56.829
IN LIGHT OF OTHER BILLS DISCUSS
03:47:56.896 --> 03:47:59.232
TODAY IS THAT WE HAVE BASS HARD
03:47:59.298 --> 03:48:02.535
STOP DEADLINE OF TWENTY TWENTY
03:48:02.602 --> 03:48:03.436
FOUR IN WHICH WE HAVE TO BE ABLE
03:48:03.503 --> 03:48:05.071
A DEMONSTRATE THAT THE DOORS TO
03:48:05.138 --> 03:48:07.006
THE ARENA WILL BE OPEN.
03:48:07.073 --> 03:48:08.474
IF WE CAN'T DEMONSTRATE THAT WE
03:48:08.541 --> 03:48:09.542
CAN MEET THAT TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
03:48:09.609 --> 03:48:12.045
DEADLINE.
03:48:12.111 --> 03:48:13.679
TEAM AND THE OWNER WILL BE
03:48:13.746 --> 03:48:17.750
FORCED TO LOOK AT OTHER OPTIONS.
03:48:17.817 --> 03:48:19.552
WITH THAT HARD DEADLINE
03:48:19.619 --> 03:48:21.220
ESSENTIALLY WE DIVIDE THAT THAT
03:48:21.287 --> 03:48:23.289
THAT PERIOD THAT SIX YEAR PERIOD
03:48:23.356 --> 03:48:25.858
AND THREE TWO YEAR PERIOD.
03:48:25.925 --> 03:48:27.226
THE FIRST TWO YEARS.
03:48:27.293 --> 03:48:29.028
ALREADY STARTING.
03:48:29.095 --> 03:48:31.097
INVOLVES COMMUNITY INPUT.
03:48:31.164 --> 03:48:32.398
TOWN HALL MEETINGS OR LAWYER
03:48:32.465 --> 03:48:33.499
BEEN THIRTY SO FAR [inaudible]
03:48:33.566 --> 03:48:36.035
GETTING COMMITTEE INPUT ON THE
03:48:36.102 --> 03:48:37.904
COMMUNITY BENEFITS BEGINNING TO
03:48:37.970 --> 03:48:39.572
DEVELOP III OUR THAT FIRST TWO
03:48:39.639 --> 03:48:41.007
YEAR PERIOD IS ALL ABOUT THOSE
03:48:41.074 --> 03:48:43.776
HEARINGS THAT TRANSPARENCY
03:48:43.843 --> 03:48:45.511
DEVELOPING THAT YOU ARE.
03:48:45.578 --> 03:48:46.646
THE SECOND TWO YEAR PERIOD IS
03:48:46.712 --> 03:48:48.314
ESSENTIALLY.
03:48:48.381 --> 03:48:49.215
WITH THE BENEFITS OF THIS
03:48:49.282 --> 03:48:51.117
LEGISLATION [inaudible]
03:48:51.184 --> 03:48:53.152
PROVIDING.
03:48:53.219 --> 03:48:54.987
FOR ER OUR REVIEW CERTIFICATION
03:48:55.054 --> 03:48:57.356
AND LEGAL CHALLENGES.
03:48:57.423 --> 03:48:59.092
THE THIRD TWO YEAR PERIOD.
03:48:59.158 --> 03:49:01.094
WHICH IS A VERY VERY SHORT
03:49:01.160 --> 03:49:01.661
PERIOD IS TO ACTUALLY COULD
03:49:01.727 --> 03:49:04.397
STRUCK THE ARENA.
03:49:04.464 --> 03:49:05.198
THAT'S HOW THAT SIX YEAR PERIOD
03:49:05.264 --> 03:49:06.699
GOES.
03:49:06.766 --> 03:49:08.301
IF WE DIDN'T HAVE THE HEART STOP
03:49:08.367 --> 03:49:09.702
I WOULDN'T BE HERE IN FRONT OF
03:49:09.769 --> 03:49:10.503
YOU NOW REQUESTING THE
03:49:10.570 --> 03:49:11.404
STREAMLINING THAT'S THE NEED FOR
03:49:11.471 --> 03:49:13.506
IT.
03:49:13.573 --> 03:49:14.674
NOW IN TALKING ABOUT THE
03:49:14.740 --> 03:49:15.842
AMENDMENTS WERE OFFERED BY THINK
03:49:15.908 --> 03:49:17.743
THAT MISTER CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS
03:49:17.810 --> 03:49:21.114
IS A KEY INTEREST TO YOU ALL.
03:49:21.180 --> 03:49:22.815
WHAT THE AUTHOR HAS OFFERED
03:49:22.882 --> 03:49:24.650
ESSENTIALLY EIGHTY TWO COMPLY
03:49:24.717 --> 03:49:26.319
WITH THE GREENHOUSE GAS
03:49:26.385 --> 03:49:28.421
EMISSIONS STANDARD OF MET ZERO
03:49:28.488 --> 03:49:30.123
COMPARED TO THE CURRENT FACILITY
03:49:30.189 --> 03:49:32.325
IN STAPLES CENTER?
03:49:32.391 --> 03:49:32.825
WITHIN THE FIRST YEAR OF
03:49:32.892 --> 03:49:34.727
OPERATION.
03:49:34.794 --> 03:49:35.561
BUT IS THE AB NINE HUNDRED
03:49:35.628 --> 03:49:38.064
STANDARD.
03:49:38.131 --> 03:49:38.931
THE AUTHORS ALSO SUBMITTED
03:49:38.998 --> 03:49:41.000
AMENDMENTS SAYING THAT WE WILL
03:49:41.067 --> 03:49:43.102
COME WITH IT WE WILL COMPLY WITH
03:49:43.169 --> 03:49:45.171
THE TRANSPORTATION EFFICIENCY
03:49:45.238 --> 03:49:46.606
STANDARD OF AB NINE HUNDRED
03:49:46.672 --> 03:49:48.674
WHICH ESSENTIALLY IS A 15%
03:49:48.741 --> 03:49:50.943
REDUCTION OF VEHICLE TRIPS. TO
03:49:51.010 --> 03:49:52.745
THIS FACILITY.
03:49:52.812 --> 03:49:56.015
COMPARED TO THE BASELINE WITCHES
03:49:56.082 --> 03:49:56.315
[inaudible]
03:49:56.382 --> 03:49:58.484
STAPLES ARENA.
03:49:58.551 --> 03:49:59.919
THAT IS A VERY DIFFICULT
03:49:59.986 --> 03:50:02.288
STANDARD FOR US TO MEET.
03:50:02.355 --> 03:50:04.190
BECAUSE WE ARE IN A LOW INCOME
03:50:04.257 --> 03:50:06.659
TRANSIT STARVE COMMUNITY.
03:50:06.726 --> 03:50:08.794
SO WHAT THAT MAMET HAS REQUESTED
03:50:08.861 --> 03:50:10.630
IS THAT WE BE GIVEN A LITTLE
03:50:10.696 --> 03:50:13.900
MORE TIME. TO MEET THAT STANDARD
03:50:13.966 --> 03:50:15.601
BECAUSE WE ARE IN FACT IN A LOW
03:50:15.668 --> 03:50:18.304
INCOME TRANSIT STAR COMMUNITY.
03:50:18.371 --> 03:50:19.772
AND WE'RE COMING FROM DOWNTOWN
03:50:19.839 --> 03:50:22.708
LOS ANGELES WHICH IS THE AUTHOR.
03:50:22.775 --> 03:50:24.443
HAS SAID THAT THERE.
03:50:24.510 --> 03:50:27.413
THAT HAS BECOME MORE POPULAR AND
03:50:27.480 --> 03:50:29.649
IS SERVED BY TRANSIT.
03:50:29.715 --> 03:50:31.350
AND SO WE'RE ADDED DISADVANTAGE
03:50:31.417 --> 03:50:32.585
BECAUSE OF THAT SO WHAT WE NEED
03:50:32.652 --> 03:50:34.387
IS JUST A LITTLE BIT MORE TIME
03:50:34.453 --> 03:50:35.988
TO MEET THAT 15% STANDARD WERE
03:50:36.055 --> 03:50:37.390
BUT BUT THE FOR THE ANALYSIS
03:50:37.456 --> 03:50:37.690
[inaudible]
03:50:37.757 --> 03:50:39.492
IS.
03:50:39.559 --> 03:50:41.060
IT IS YOUR ANTICIPATION IS
03:50:41.127 --> 03:50:44.564
MIRRORS THEN THE YOU KNOW. NINE
03:50:44.630 --> 03:50:46.098
HUNDRED SERIES LEARNED THAT HAVE
03:50:46.165 --> 03:50:47.533
I THINK BACK ON A CAR THAT WE'RE
03:50:47.600 --> 03:50:48.734
LOOKING AT THE BASELINE TO
03:50:48.801 --> 03:50:50.002
STAPLE CENTER WE'RE GOING
03:50:50.069 --> 03:50:52.071
THROUGH THE TYPICAL --
03:50:52.138 --> 03:50:53.406
A WORK THAT WOULD BE DONE AND
03:50:53.472 --> 03:50:55.174
THAT AND THAT JUST DID THE
03:50:55.241 --> 03:50:56.909
DIFFERENCE BEING THE THEY YOUR
03:50:56.976 --> 03:50:57.543
DAY.
03:50:57.610 --> 03:50:59.111
CORRECTNESS RETIREMENT THAT'S
03:50:59.178 --> 03:50:59.912
THAT'S ESSENTIALLY RIGHT IT
03:50:59.979 --> 03:51:01.647
WOULD BE IN THE SAME ANALYSIS
03:51:01.714 --> 03:51:05.218
AND THE SAME GOAL WHICH IS A 15%
03:51:05.284 --> 03:51:07.486
VEHICLE TO A PRODUCTION.
03:51:07.553 --> 03:51:10.223
WHAT THE AUTHOR ALSO HAD POINTED
03:51:10.289 --> 03:51:12.024
TO AS MAJOR AMENDMENTS IS TO
03:51:12.091 --> 03:51:14.026
MAKE SURE THAT THE ENFORCEMENT
03:51:14.093 --> 03:51:16.529
IN THIS BILL IN FACT HAS?
03:51:16.596 --> 03:51:18.030
TO AND SO IT'S BEEN PROPOSED THE
03:51:18.097 --> 03:51:19.031
CAR --
03:51:19.098 --> 03:51:20.866
MISTER CHAIRMAN YOU POINTED OUT --
03:51:20.933 --> 03:51:21.968
CARD HAS A LOT OF DIFFERENT
03:51:22.034 --> 03:51:23.269
ROLES -- WE
03:51:23.336 --> 03:51:24.470
CHECKED IN CARP ACTUALLY WOULD
03:51:24.537 --> 03:51:25.871
BE DOING NAY --
03:51:25.938 --> 03:51:27.273
AB NINE HUNDRED CERTIFICATION SO
03:51:27.340 --> 03:51:29.342
THERE THE THAT'S WHY WE I THINK
03:51:29.408 --> 03:51:31.611
SUGGESTED THAT THEY BE THE ONE
03:51:31.677 --> 03:51:33.512
TO CERTIFIED THE METHODOLOGY BY
03:51:33.579 --> 03:51:36.215
WHICH THE NET.
03:51:36.282 --> 03:51:36.816
ZERO GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS
03:51:36.882 --> 03:51:41.153
STANDARD WAS TO IN THE ARE.
03:51:41.220 --> 03:51:43.623
THAT THEY WOULD BE REQUIRED TO
03:51:43.689 --> 03:51:45.925
CERTIFY THAT AND THAT ON THE
03:51:45.992 --> 03:51:46.425
BACKEND FOR ADDITIONAL
03:51:46.492 --> 03:51:47.760
ENFORCEMENT.
03:51:47.827 --> 03:51:49.562
IF IN FACT.
03:51:49.629 --> 03:51:51.497
THAT NET ZERO STANDARD WAS NOT
03:51:51.564 --> 03:51:53.466
MET THE LEAD AGENCY WOULD BE
03:51:53.532 --> 03:51:56.702
REQUIRED. TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
03:51:56.769 --> 03:52:00.573
MITIGATION TO MEET THAT STANDARD.
03:52:00.640 --> 03:52:02.308
SO WHAT WE TRIED TO DO IN THESE
03:52:02.375 --> 03:52:03.476
AMENDMENTS IS TO PROVIDE BOTH
03:52:03.542 --> 03:52:06.379
FRONT AND CERTIFICATION AND
03:52:06.445 --> 03:52:08.047
ENFORCEMENT AND BACK.
03:52:08.114 --> 03:52:09.715
CERTIFICATION AND ESSENTIALLY
03:52:09.782 --> 03:52:11.250
WHAT THE PEOPLE ARE ALWAYS
03:52:11.317 --> 03:52:13.452
CONCERNED ABOUT IS A A A LAWSUIT
03:52:13.519 --> 03:52:15.154
THAT COMES UP AND WE NEED TO THE
03:52:15.221 --> 03:52:17.356
ANALYSIS THAT'S ESSENTIALLY WHAT
03:52:17.423 --> 03:52:18.591
THE JUDGE WOULD DO IS SEE SAY.
03:52:18.658 --> 03:52:20.159
I'M GONNA REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
03:52:20.226 --> 03:52:21.827
MITIGATION THAT YOU'RE GOING TO
03:52:21.894 --> 03:52:23.195
DO ALTHOUGH IT'S NOT IN THE
03:52:23.262 --> 03:52:26.065
JUDICIAL ARENA IT'S IN CARP.
03:52:26.132 --> 03:52:26.999
RIGHT THAT THEY'RE DOING I MEAN
03:52:27.066 --> 03:52:28.267
OKAY I'M FOLLOWING YOU PRIZE
03:52:28.334 --> 03:52:29.769
CONSISTS OF MISTER CHAIRMAN THAT
03:52:29.835 --> 03:52:31.370
THAT'S THE CONCEPT IS THAT.
03:52:31.437 --> 03:52:32.438
IS THE CARBON LOOK AT THE
03:52:32.505 --> 03:52:34.674
METHODOLOGY BECAUSE THEY DO HAVE
03:52:34.740 --> 03:52:35.908
THE EXPERTS AND BILL WORK WITH
03:52:35.975 --> 03:52:38.110
OUR CONSULTANTS AND DETERMINE IF
03:52:38.177 --> 03:52:39.679
IN FACT.
03:52:39.745 --> 03:52:42.581
THE METHODOLOGY USED.
03:52:42.648 --> 03:52:44.884
TO DEMONSTRATE THAT WE MEET.
03:52:44.950 --> 03:52:46.585
THE GREENHOUSE GAS NET ZERO
03:52:46.652 --> 03:52:49.655
EMISSION STANDARD IS APPROPRIATE.
03:52:49.722 --> 03:52:51.357
AND SO THEN WE KNOW GOING IN
03:52:51.424 --> 03:52:52.858
THAT THE METHODOLOGY IS CRACKED
03:52:52.925 --> 03:52:55.061
BUT THERE'S A SECOND BACKUP
03:52:55.127 --> 03:52:56.595
PROVIDED IN THESE AMENDMENTS AND
03:52:56.662 --> 03:52:57.763
THAT IS AFTER THE FIRST YEAR OF
03:52:57.830 --> 03:52:59.432
OPERATION.
03:52:59.498 --> 03:53:00.833
THE LEAD AGENCY IS REQUIRED TO
03:53:00.900 --> 03:53:02.501
IN FACT SAGE DID YOU MEET THE
03:53:02.568 --> 03:53:03.869
STANDARD AND IF YOU DIDN'T THEN
03:53:03.936 --> 03:53:04.670
YOU'RE REQUIRED TO DO MORE
03:53:04.737 --> 03:53:07.940
MITIGATES.
03:53:08.007 --> 03:53:09.442
FOR THAT'S THE CONCEPT TO THIS
03:53:09.508 --> 03:53:11.377
IMPORTANT WHICH WE THINK THE IS
03:53:11.444 --> 03:53:13.079
THE STRONGEST ENFORCEMENT ITS
03:53:13.145 --> 03:53:14.914
ITS DEADLY STARTED SOME OF THE
03:53:14.980 --> 03:53:16.048
OTHER PIECE OF LEGISLATION EVER
03:53:16.115 --> 03:53:18.451
PASSED.
03:53:18.517 --> 03:53:19.885
THE AMENDMENTS THAT ARE PROVIDED
03:53:19.952 --> 03:53:21.053
IN THE MOCK UP ALSO.
03:53:21.120 --> 03:53:24.423
INCLUDE A SUNSET CLAUSE.
03:53:24.490 --> 03:53:25.624
AND THE REASON FOR THAT SANTA
03:53:25.691 --> 03:53:27.126
CLAUS IS TO DEMONSTRATE THAT IF
03:53:27.193 --> 03:53:29.028
IN FACT.
03:53:29.095 --> 03:53:31.630
THE PROJECT IS NOT BUILT.
03:53:31.697 --> 03:53:33.733
BY TWENTY TWENTY FIVE BUT THE
03:53:33.799 --> 03:53:34.934
ENTIRE PROVISIONS SUNSET AND GO
03:53:35.000 --> 03:53:35.935
AWAY [inaudible]
03:53:36.001 --> 03:53:38.270
RIGHT.
03:53:38.337 --> 03:53:39.472
AND AND WHAT THAT MEANS IS IS
03:53:39.538 --> 03:53:41.707
THAT.
03:53:41.774 --> 03:53:42.675
BUT YEAH I WOULD HAVE TO BE
03:53:42.742 --> 03:53:44.110
CERTIFIED.
03:53:44.176 --> 03:53:46.679
AND IF NOT BY.
03:53:46.746 --> 03:53:47.413
TWENTY TWENTY FIVE ALL OF THIS
03:53:47.480 --> 03:53:48.814
LAW WOULD SUNSET AWAY SO THAT
03:53:48.881 --> 03:53:50.249
SOMEBODY CAN'T SAY THAT THIS
03:53:50.316 --> 03:53:52.251
SEQUEL STREAMLINING PROVISION
03:53:52.318 --> 03:53:54.487
WOULD APPLY TO SOME FUTURE
03:53:54.553 --> 03:53:58.023
PROJECTS THAT WERE UNAWARE --
03:53:58.090 --> 03:53:59.925
I THINK IN ADDITION THERE'S TWO
03:53:59.992 --> 03:54:01.060
OTHER AMENDMENTS THAT WE HAVE
03:54:01.127 --> 03:54:03.028
THAT I KNOW HAVE BEEN DISCUSSED --
03:54:03.095 --> 03:54:05.698
THERE HAS BEEN A CONCERN BECAUSE
03:54:05.765 --> 03:54:09.335
IN THE HOLLYWOOD PARK FOOT PRINT.
03:54:09.402 --> 03:54:11.170
JASON TO WHERE THE ARENA WOULD
03:54:11.237 --> 03:54:13.239
BE BELT THERE IS CURRENTLY A
03:54:13.305 --> 03:54:15.207
LICENSE CARD CLUB FACILITY.
03:54:15.274 --> 03:54:17.109
AND THERE HAVE BEEN SOME TRIBES
03:54:17.176 --> 03:54:17.943
THAT HAVE INDICATED THAT THEY
03:54:18.010 --> 03:54:19.545
WERE CONCERNED.
03:54:19.612 --> 03:54:21.747
THAT THE SEQUEL STREAMLINING
03:54:21.814 --> 03:54:24.850
COULD IN FACT BE USED.
03:54:24.917 --> 03:54:26.852
TO PROVIDE FOR THE BUILDING OF A
03:54:26.919 --> 03:54:29.321
NEW CAR CLUB FACILITY.
03:54:29.388 --> 03:54:30.856
THE FACTS ARE THERE IS A BRAND
03:54:30.923 --> 03:54:32.291
NEW CAR CLUB FACILITY THAT WAS
03:54:32.358 --> 03:54:33.959
JUST OPENED A YEAR AGO THERE AND
03:54:34.026 --> 03:54:35.761
THE AUTHORS --
03:54:35.828 --> 03:54:37.029
PROPOSING AMENDMENTS THAT WE
03:54:37.096 --> 03:54:38.531
JUST PROHIBITS THE USE OF THE
03:54:38.597 --> 03:54:40.566
SEQUESTERING LINING ON A GAMING
03:54:40.633 --> 03:54:42.935
FACILITY PERIODS OF WE WANT TO
03:54:43.002 --> 03:54:43.502
MAKE SURE THAT WAS NEVER THE
03:54:43.569 --> 03:54:44.804
INTENT.
03:54:44.870 --> 03:54:46.172
NEVER CONSIDERED IN THE PROJECT
03:54:46.238 --> 03:54:48.040
NEVER CONSIDERED.
03:54:48.107 --> 03:54:51.477
IN THE PLANNING AND WERE HAPPY.
03:54:51.544 --> 03:54:53.746
TO LIVE WITHOUT AMENDMENT.
03:54:53.813 --> 03:54:55.681
AND THEN THE LAST AMENDMENT IS A
03:54:55.748 --> 03:54:58.384
FURTHER --
03:54:58.451 --> 03:54:59.452
LABOR AMENDMENT JUST THAT
03:54:59.518 --> 03:55:00.686
CLARIFIES THAT IN FACT THIS
03:55:00.753 --> 03:55:01.587
PROJECT.
03:55:01.654 --> 03:55:03.489
IS SUBJECT TO PROJECT LABOR
03:55:03.556 --> 03:55:04.957
AGREEMENTS AND NOT INTENDED TO
03:55:05.024 --> 03:55:06.625
UNDERCUT.
03:55:06.692 --> 03:55:08.761
OTHER LABOR LANGUAGE THAT IS
03:55:08.828 --> 03:55:10.796
BOILERPLATE.
03:55:10.863 --> 03:55:12.731
AND AND WITH THAT THAT'S THE
03:55:12.798 --> 03:55:14.533
DESCRIPTION OF THE AMENDMENTS --
03:55:14.600 --> 03:55:16.535
HAPPY TO ANSWER QUESTIONS.
03:55:16.602 --> 03:55:17.670
I CAN TELL YOU THAT MISTER
03:55:17.736 --> 03:55:20.506
PALMER THE OWNER OF THE TEAM.
03:55:20.573 --> 03:55:22.208
IS COMMITTED IN A WAY THAT IN
03:55:22.274 --> 03:55:23.108
FORTY YEARS I'VE NEVER SEEN
03:55:23.175 --> 03:55:24.643
SOMEONE COMMITTED TO A
03:55:24.710 --> 03:55:25.978
DISADVANTAGE LOW INCOME AREA
03:55:26.045 --> 03:55:26.278
[inaudible]
03:55:26.345 --> 03:55:28.747
WE HE COULD CHOOSE TO GO A
03:55:28.814 --> 03:55:31.350
NUMBER OF PLACES.
03:55:31.417 --> 03:55:33.018
PERHAPS A NUMBER OF PLACES THAT
03:55:33.085 --> 03:55:34.987
ARE SERVED WITH MORE TRANSIT.
03:55:35.054 --> 03:55:35.988
PERHAPS PLACES THAT MIGHT IN
03:55:36.055 --> 03:55:37.656
FACT.
03:55:37.723 --> 03:55:40.059
MAKE THIS TRANSITION EASIER.
03:55:40.125 --> 03:55:42.027
HE'S TAKEN THE HARD PATH BECAUSE
03:55:42.094 --> 03:55:44.063
QUITE FRANKLY HE BELIEVES.
03:55:44.129 --> 03:55:45.965
THAT'S THE IMPORTANT THING TO DO
03:55:46.031 --> 03:55:48.868
FOR GOING TO TRY AND PROVIDE.
03:55:48.934 --> 03:55:50.703
JOBS ECONOMIC STIMULUS AND
03:55:50.769 --> 03:55:53.906
SUPPORT. TO FAMILIES IN PLACES
03:55:53.973 --> 03:55:56.075
WHERE 29% OF CHILDREN LIVE UNDER
03:55:56.141 --> 03:55:57.209
THE POVERTY RATE IN THE
03:55:57.276 --> 03:55:59.144
UNEMPLOYMENT RATE IS THREE TIMES
03:55:59.211 --> 03:56:00.112
LEVEL STATE.
03:56:00.179 --> 03:56:01.680
IT'S RISKY ITS HEART.
03:56:01.747 --> 03:56:03.315
THAT'S WHY WE NEED THIS HELP BUT
03:56:03.382 --> 03:56:04.450
IT'S THE RIGHT THING TO DO
03:56:04.517 --> 03:56:04.750
[inaudible]
03:56:04.817 --> 03:56:06.819
NEXT WITNESS [inaudible]
03:56:06.886 --> 03:56:12.291
CONNECT.
03:56:12.358 --> 03:56:13.759
YES GOOD AFTERNOON THANK YOU FOR
03:56:13.826 --> 03:56:15.694
ALLOWING ME TO COME HERE TODAY.
03:56:15.761 --> 03:56:17.296
I REPRESENT OF WORLD START WITH
03:56:17.363 --> 03:56:19.064
MONIES MIKE LAYTON AND I
03:56:19.131 --> 03:56:20.332
REPRESENT THE SOUTHERN
03:56:20.399 --> 03:56:22.134
CALIFORNIA PIPE TRADES.
03:56:22.201 --> 03:56:24.003
I GOT A LITTLE OVER FIFTEEN
03:56:24.069 --> 03:56:24.937
THOUSAND BROTHERS AND SISTERS
03:56:25.004 --> 03:56:27.006
THAT -- THAT
03:56:27.072 --> 03:56:28.774
MADE THEIR LIFE BASIS ON PART
03:56:28.841 --> 03:56:30.876
TIME JOBS.
03:56:30.943 --> 03:56:31.810
WE ARE NO DIFFERENT THAN A
03:56:31.877 --> 03:56:35.147
CARDIOLOGISTS A PHARMACIST. FOR
03:56:35.214 --> 03:56:36.916
ANYONE ELSE WE ARE BASED ON WERE
03:56:36.982 --> 03:56:38.083
REPEATED [inaudible]
03:56:38.150 --> 03:56:40.119
ARE PROJECTS.
03:56:40.185 --> 03:56:42.154
TODAY WE ARE CURRENTLY WORKING
03:56:42.221 --> 03:56:43.656
ON THE NFL STADIUM RIGHT ACROSS
03:56:43.722 --> 03:56:45.424
THE PARKING LOT.
03:56:45.491 --> 03:56:47.126
IT CARRIES THE SAME MANDATES OF
03:56:47.192 --> 03:56:48.761
THE 30% HELPED COME FROM THAT
03:56:48.827 --> 03:56:50.696
LOCAL HIGHER.
03:56:50.763 --> 03:56:51.864
WE HAVE A LITTLE OVER THREE
03:56:51.931 --> 03:56:53.966
THOUSAND APPRENTICES.
03:56:54.033 --> 03:56:55.534
MEN WOMEN OF ALL COLORS ALL
03:56:55.601 --> 03:56:57.770
RACES.
03:56:57.836 --> 03:56:59.572
AND WE HAVE APPROXIMATELY FIVE
03:56:59.638 --> 03:57:01.340
THOUSAND RETIREES HOW DO YOU GET
03:57:01.407 --> 03:57:02.575
FROM BEING AN APPRENTICE
03:57:02.641 --> 03:57:04.410
[inaudible] TO RETIREE.
03:57:04.476 --> 03:57:05.978
I HAVING MULTIPLE YEARS A PART
03:57:06.045 --> 03:57:08.414
TIME EMPLOYMENT.
03:57:08.480 --> 03:57:10.049
THIS IS MY FORTY THIRD YEAR OF
03:57:10.115 --> 03:57:11.317
PUTTING TOGETHER PART TIME
03:57:11.383 --> 03:57:12.818
EMPLOYMENT.
03:57:12.885 --> 03:57:13.552
I WAS BORN IN THE GREAT CITY OF
03:57:13.619 --> 03:57:15.354
INGLEWOOD.
03:57:15.421 --> 03:57:17.323
SO WHEN I HAD THIS OPPORTUNITY
03:57:17.389 --> 03:57:19.058
TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF IT.
03:57:19.124 --> 03:57:22.795
IT WAS VERY EASY FOR ME TO DO SO --
03:57:22.861 --> 03:57:25.230
WE HAVE HAD A COUPLE OF
03:57:25.297 --> 03:57:26.765
OPPORTUNITIES TO SIT DOWN WITH
03:57:26.832 --> 03:57:29.602
THE AUTHOR COAUTHOR OF THIS BILL.
03:57:29.668 --> 03:57:30.469
AND THEY'VE BEEN MORE THAN
03:57:30.536 --> 03:57:32.071
GRACIOUS TO ADDRESS ANY OF THE
03:57:32.137 --> 03:57:33.138
CONCERNS THAT UP THAT HAVE COME
03:57:33.205 --> 03:57:35.140
UP.
03:57:35.207 --> 03:57:36.642
SO IT SO YOU KNOW GREAT HONOR
03:57:36.709 --> 03:57:37.977
THAT I AM ABLE TO COME UP HERE
03:57:38.043 --> 03:57:40.613
TODAY AND SPEAK ON BEHALF.
03:57:40.679 --> 03:57:42.715
OF THIS BILL AND I WOULD HOPE
03:57:42.781 --> 03:57:43.015
THAT -- YOU
03:57:43.082 --> 03:57:44.149
WOULD SEE THE WEIGHT.
03:57:44.216 --> 03:57:46.418
AND UNDER THE LEADERSHIP
03:57:46.485 --> 03:57:47.419
CERTIFICATION PROCESS THAT WE
03:57:47.486 --> 03:57:49.054
HAVE WITH AB NINE HUNDRED IT
03:57:49.121 --> 03:57:50.389
REQUIRES THAT THE PROJECT
03:57:50.456 --> 03:57:52.524
CREATES HIGH WAGE HIGHLY SKILLED
03:57:52.591 --> 03:57:54.293
JOBS THAT PAY PREVAILING WAGES
03:57:54.360 --> 03:57:55.394
AND LIVING WAGES PROVIDE
03:57:55.461 --> 03:57:57.096
CONSTRUCTION JOBS AND PERMANENT
03:57:57.162 --> 03:57:58.964
JOBS. FOR CALIFORNIANS AND HELPS
03:57:59.031 --> 03:58:00.432
REDUCE UNEMPLOYMENT ALTHOUGH
03:58:00.499 --> 03:58:01.834
I'VE SAID A HUNDRED TIMES THIS
03:58:01.900 --> 03:58:03.869
IS THE EQ COMMITTEE I'M TRYING
03:58:03.936 --> 03:58:05.170
TO FOCUS ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL
03:58:05.237 --> 03:58:06.505
BENEFITS OF HERE.
03:58:06.572 --> 03:58:08.307
LEAST YOUR TESTIMONY TODAY'S
03:58:08.374 --> 03:58:09.008
THAT YOU BELIEVE THAT THAT
03:58:09.074 --> 03:58:12.177
MIRRORS THE AB --
03:58:12.244 --> 03:58:13.946
NINE HUNDRED LEADERSHIP PROJECT
03:58:14.013 --> 03:58:15.714
IN AGAIN TO FIND PERMANENT. FOR
03:58:15.781 --> 03:58:18.517
ME IT'S A STRING OF PART TIME
03:58:18.584 --> 03:58:20.285
JOBS.
03:58:20.352 --> 03:58:21.820
IN THAT UP YOU KNOW I'VE HEARD
03:58:21.887 --> 03:58:23.856
THE COMMUNITY YOU KNOW SAY THESE
03:58:23.922 --> 03:58:25.557
ARE JUST TEMPORARY JOBS.
03:58:25.624 --> 03:58:27.259
AS I SAID THIS IS MY FORTY THIRD
03:58:27.326 --> 03:58:30.429
YEAR OF TEMPORARY JOBS --
03:58:30.496 --> 03:58:31.697
UNDERSTOOD OKAY AND LET HIS
03:58:31.764 --> 03:58:35.434
WITNESS.
03:58:35.501 --> 03:58:36.535
BUT ROGER FOR TECHNICAL QUESTION
03:58:36.602 --> 03:58:37.936
OKAY.
03:58:38.003 --> 03:58:42.641
OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF A V.. EIGHT
03:58:42.708 --> 03:58:43.642
NINE EIGHT SEVEN ARE I THANK YOU
03:58:43.709 --> 03:58:44.510
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS BROOKS
03:58:44.576 --> 03:58:46.378
ALISON ON BEHALF OF THE CITY OF
03:58:46.445 --> 03:58:47.646
INGLEWOOD AND NOW.
03:58:47.713 --> 03:58:48.681
IT'S MY PLEASURE TO BE HERE I%
03:58:48.747 --> 03:58:50.015
I'VE REPRESENTING A WITH FOR
03:58:50.082 --> 03:58:51.083
ABOUT TWENTY YEARS AND THERE WAS
03:58:51.150 --> 03:58:52.117
A TIME.
03:58:52.184 --> 03:58:53.485
WHEN YOU TALKED ABOUT INGLEWOOD
03:58:53.552 --> 03:58:55.721
THAT NOBODY WANTED TO LISTEN IT
03:58:55.788 --> 03:58:57.222
WAS SORT OF FORGOTTEN CITY?
03:58:57.289 --> 03:58:58.991
THAT HAD ALL OF THE ISSUES THAT
03:58:59.058 --> 03:59:00.793
NOBODY WANTED TO TALK ABOUT AND
03:59:00.859 --> 03:59:02.027
THEY HAVE BEEN TRANSFORMING
03:59:02.094 --> 03:59:03.328
THEMSELVES IN FACT IT'S ONE OF
03:59:03.395 --> 03:59:04.897
THE BIGGEST IN I THINK GREATEST
03:59:04.963 --> 03:59:05.998
TRANSFORMATIONS ANYWHERE IN THE
03:59:06.065 --> 03:59:07.199
COUNTRY.
03:59:07.266 --> 03:59:08.534
AND THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL
03:59:08.600 --> 03:59:10.302
DESERVE A LOT OF CREDIT BUT IT'S
03:59:10.369 --> 03:59:11.904
NOT EASY I THINK AS MR LYING AND
03:59:11.970 --> 03:59:12.638
OTHERS HAVE SAID AND I
03:59:12.705 --> 03:59:14.106
APPRECIATE YOU SETTLEMENT.
03:59:14.173 --> 03:59:15.874
THROUGH A SORT OF THE HISTORY SO
03:59:15.941 --> 03:59:17.509
I WON'T DUPLICATE THAT WITH THIS
03:59:17.576 --> 03:59:19.978
MEANS A LOT I MEAN TEN THOUSAND
03:59:20.045 --> 03:59:21.146
CONSTRUCTION DROPS A THOUSAND
03:59:21.213 --> 03:59:23.248
PERMANENT ARENA JOBS NEW REVENUE
03:59:23.315 --> 03:59:24.717
FOR THE CITY SO FOR POLICE AND
03:59:24.783 --> 03:59:26.452
FIRE IN LIBRARIES AND COMMUNITY
03:59:26.518 --> 03:59:27.453
SERVICES.
03:59:27.519 --> 03:59:28.554
MEAN THIS IS TRANSPORT OF
03:59:28.620 --> 03:59:31.056
TRANSFORMATIVE.
03:59:31.123 --> 03:59:32.591
TO HUGE DEAL AND WE APPRECIATE
03:59:32.658 --> 03:59:33.092
EVERYBODY BEING HERE AND
03:59:33.158 --> 03:59:35.227
SUPPORTING.
03:59:35.294 --> 03:59:37.029
OTHER SINCE SUPPORT OF THE
03:59:37.096 --> 03:59:38.530
MEASURE AS AMENDED YET IS
03:59:38.597 --> 03:59:39.665
USUALLY MEMBER SCOTT WHICH ARE
03:59:39.732 --> 03:59:40.933
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
03:59:40.999 --> 03:59:41.834
ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICAL
03:59:41.900 --> 03:59:43.035
WORKERS TO CALIFORNIA THE
03:59:43.102 --> 03:59:44.236
PATRIOTS COUNCIL.
03:59:44.303 --> 03:59:45.571
WESTERN STATES KELSO SHEET METAL
03:59:45.637 --> 03:59:47.005
WORKERS CALIFORNIA COALITION OF
03:59:47.072 --> 03:59:48.607
UTILITY EMPLOYEES AND ELEVATOR
03:59:48.674 --> 03:59:49.975
CONSTRUCTORS UNION.
03:59:50.042 --> 03:59:51.477
I WOULD JUST ADD WE HAVE TAKEN
03:59:51.543 --> 03:59:54.580
ON HUNDREDS OF NEW APPRENTICES
03:59:54.646 --> 03:59:57.382
IN THE TRADES FOR THE RAMS
03:59:57.449 --> 03:59:58.584
STADIUM PROJECT.
03:59:58.650 --> 04:00:00.119
THIS IS GOING TO ALLOW US TO
04:00:00.185 --> 04:00:02.121
TRANSITION THOSE NEW YOUNG
04:00:02.187 --> 04:00:03.622
TRADES PEOPLE.
04:00:03.689 --> 04:00:05.424
INTO CONTINUED JOBS IN THEIR
04:00:05.491 --> 04:00:06.992
LOCAL COMMUNITIES THAT'S WHY
04:00:07.059 --> 04:00:09.294
THIS IS SO URGENT IN THAT HAVING
04:00:09.361 --> 04:00:10.763
WORKED ON ALL OF THE VERY STEVEN
04:00:10.829 --> 04:00:12.464
ARENA BILLS WE THINK THIS ONE
04:00:12.531 --> 04:00:14.133
HAS THE HIGHEST BAR --
04:00:14.199 --> 04:00:15.834
THAT WE'VE SEEN SO WE ARE URGING
04:00:15.901 --> 04:00:16.435
AYE VOTE THANK YOU [inaudible]
04:00:16.502 --> 04:00:19.471
NEXT.
04:00:19.538 --> 04:00:21.340
WHAT S. RILEY RESIDENT IN
04:00:21.406 --> 04:00:22.374
BUSINESS HONORING AND WHAT
04:00:22.441 --> 04:00:23.909
CALIFORNIA BORN AND RAISED?
04:00:23.976 --> 04:00:26.411
I'M HERE IN SUPPORT OF AB NINE
04:00:26.478 --> 04:00:27.613
EIGHT SEVEN I WAS THERE EIGHTEEN
04:00:27.679 --> 04:00:29.114
YEARS AGO WE LOST THE LAKERS
04:00:29.181 --> 04:00:29.848
BECAUSE WE DIDN'T TO PASS A TAX
04:00:29.915 --> 04:00:31.383
BILL.
04:00:31.450 --> 04:00:33.218
I SAW WHAT THAT DID AND HOW MUCH
04:00:33.285 --> 04:00:34.653
ECONOMIC LOSS WE HAD.
04:00:34.720 --> 04:00:35.921
AND I'M HERE TO SUPPORT AND SAY
04:00:35.988 --> 04:00:37.289
THIS IS A COMPANY THAT I FEEL
04:00:37.356 --> 04:00:38.624
WILL BE GOOD FOR OUR COMMUNITY
04:00:38.690 --> 04:00:39.191
SOMETHING THAT WE NEED BACK
04:00:39.258 --> 04:00:39.491
[inaudible]
04:00:39.558 --> 04:00:42.060
NEXT.
04:00:42.127 --> 04:00:43.195
MISTER CHAIR MEMBERS MAP BROUGHT
04:00:43.262 --> 04:00:44.663
ON BEHALF THE TEAMSTERS AND
04:00:44.730 --> 04:00:48.066
STRONG SUPPORT THANK YOU.
04:00:48.133 --> 04:00:49.301
GOOD AFTERNOON MISTER CHAIRMAN
04:00:49.368 --> 04:00:51.003
AND MEMBERS CATATONIA DURAN WITH
04:00:51.069 --> 04:00:51.570
THE CITY COUNCIL LABORERS IN
04:00:51.637 --> 04:00:54.540
SUPPORT.
04:00:54.606 --> 04:00:56.241
GOOD AFTERNOON.
04:00:56.308 --> 04:00:57.543
MY NAME IS CHRIS MARTIN AND I'M --
04:00:57.609 --> 04:00:58.977
ARE LIKE TIME RESIDENT OF
04:00:59.044 --> 04:01:01.046
INGLEWOOD AND ALSO A BUSINESS
04:01:01.113 --> 04:01:01.280
OWNER.
04:01:01.346 --> 04:01:03.582
ARM AND ARE ABOUT ONE OF OUR
04:01:03.649 --> 04:01:05.617
SHIRTS ONE OF OUR RESTAURANTS --
04:01:05.684 --> 04:01:06.885
WE WERE THE CITY OF INGLEWOOD
04:01:06.952 --> 04:01:07.986
HERE PROBABLY --
04:01:08.053 --> 04:01:09.755
WE OPEN THE DOOR SUFFERS FROM
04:01:09.822 --> 04:01:12.124
TWO THOUSAND AND NINE AND
04:01:12.191 --> 04:01:13.325
THROUGH A LOT OF HARDWORK AND
04:01:13.392 --> 04:01:14.693
DEDICATION --
04:01:14.760 --> 04:01:16.662
WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO SUCCESSFULLY
04:01:16.728 --> 04:01:17.563
OPENED THREE OTHER RESTAURANTS
04:01:17.629 --> 04:01:19.331
WE HAVE FOUR RESTAURANTS IN THE
04:01:19.398 --> 04:01:20.432
CITY OF INGLEWOOD.
04:01:20.499 --> 04:01:22.034
AND MY FAMILY MY MOM MY DAD MY
04:01:22.100 --> 04:01:23.836
BROTHERS WE ALL LIVE AND WORK IN
04:01:23.902 --> 04:01:25.003
THE CITY OF INGLEWOOD.
04:01:25.070 --> 04:01:27.039
AND WE ARE IN FAVOR OF THIS BILL
04:01:27.105 --> 04:01:29.208
BECAUSE IS SOON AS YOU START
04:01:29.274 --> 04:01:30.375
CONSTRUCTION MEAN WE SEE PEOPLE
04:01:30.442 --> 04:01:32.544
COMING AND THEY'RE EATING FOOD
04:01:32.611 --> 04:01:35.013
AND OBVIOUSLY WITH A WITH THE
04:01:35.080 --> 04:01:35.781
GAMES AND ALL THESE THINGS WE
04:01:35.848 --> 04:01:37.282
ARE -- DEATH
04:01:37.349 --> 04:01:38.717
IN SUPPORT OF IT IN FEAR THAT IT
04:01:38.784 --> 04:01:40.319
NOT ONLY IS A GREAT THING FOR
04:01:40.385 --> 04:01:41.787
THE BUSINESS OWNERS BUT ALSO FOR
04:01:41.854 --> 04:01:42.321
THE RESIDENTS LIKE MYSELF
04:01:42.387 --> 04:01:42.621
[inaudible]
04:01:42.688 --> 04:01:43.055
THANK YOU.
04:01:43.121 --> 04:01:45.691
THANK YOU NECKS [inaudible]
04:01:45.757 --> 04:01:47.526
GOOD AFTERNOON.
04:01:47.593 --> 04:01:49.661
IF IN GERMAN NAME IS EDWARD
04:01:49.728 --> 04:01:51.597
EDWARDS.
04:01:51.663 --> 04:01:53.599
I'M ONE OF THE BUSINESSMEN.
04:01:53.665 --> 04:01:54.700
RESIDENTS OF INGLEWOOD
04:01:54.766 --> 04:01:56.468
CALIFORNIA BEEN NEAR FOR SIXTY
04:01:56.535 --> 04:01:58.871
YEARS IN BUSINESS [inaudible]
04:01:58.937 --> 04:01:59.905
ALSO [inaudible]
04:01:59.972 --> 04:02:02.474
REPRESENT.
04:02:02.541 --> 04:02:05.544
SPORTS AND ENTERTAINMENT WORLD.
04:02:05.611 --> 04:02:07.079
WE'RE REPRESENTED WORLD BOXING
04:02:07.145 --> 04:02:08.981
HALL OF FAME.
04:02:09.047 --> 04:02:10.682
SURE THEY'RE GONNA HELP BOXING
04:02:10.749 --> 04:02:12.751
IN THIS ARENA.
04:02:12.818 --> 04:02:13.852
ENTERTAINMENT I REPRESENT THE
04:02:13.919 --> 04:02:15.587
FIFTH DIMENSION.
04:02:15.654 --> 04:02:17.089
ABOVE IS THE FOUNDER OF THE
04:02:17.155 --> 04:02:18.957
FIFTH DIMENSION.
04:02:19.024 --> 04:02:22.594
ALSO REPRESENTS A THOUSANDS OF
04:02:22.661 --> 04:02:24.229
VOTERS IN MY AREA.
04:02:24.296 --> 04:02:26.765
AND THEY ALL [inaudible]
04:02:26.832 --> 04:02:29.067
IN FAVOR.
04:02:29.134 --> 04:02:31.837
OF THE LA CLIPPERS COMING INTO.
04:02:31.904 --> 04:02:34.239
ENGLEWOOD NEW JOBS THAT WILL
04:02:34.306 --> 04:02:37.376
BENEFIT FROM IT THE ENTERTAINERS.
04:02:37.442 --> 04:02:40.545
YOUNG KIDS THERE WILL BE
04:02:40.612 --> 04:02:40.846
[inaudible]
04:02:40.913 --> 04:02:44.816
ENJOYING THE SPORTS IN.
04:02:44.883 --> 04:02:45.651
DIFFERENT ENTERTAINMENT THAT
04:02:45.717 --> 04:02:47.486
WILL BE IN THE AREA.
04:02:47.552 --> 04:02:48.687
BE BENEFICIAL IN THE LOCATION OF
04:02:48.754 --> 04:02:50.289
THIS [inaudible]
04:02:50.355 --> 04:02:51.390
ABSOLUTELY IS [inaudible]
04:02:51.456 --> 04:02:53.292
A ONE THANK YOU THANK YOU VERY
04:02:53.358 --> 04:02:57.696
NEXT
04:02:57.763 --> 04:02:58.263
GOOD AFTERNOON.
04:02:58.330 --> 04:03:00.198
OF WITH THE CHAIRMEN MEMBERS OF
04:03:00.265 --> 04:03:01.033
THE OF THE COMMITTEE I NAME SAN
04:03:01.099 --> 04:03:03.368
PENA ON THE VICE OF THE
04:03:03.435 --> 04:03:05.070
EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT OF THE
04:03:05.137 --> 04:03:06.338
INGLEWOOD AIRPORT CHAMBER OF
04:03:06.405 --> 04:03:07.606
COMMERCE.
04:03:07.673 --> 04:03:09.341
AND I'M HERE TO REALLY OUR
04:03:09.408 --> 04:03:12.377
SUPPORT FOR A BI NINE EIGHTY
04:03:12.444 --> 04:03:12.945
SEVEN WE LIKE TO THANK THE
04:03:13.011 --> 04:03:14.346
ASSEMBLY WOMAN SENATOR BRADFORD
04:03:14.413 --> 04:03:16.548
EVERYBODY WHO BROUGHT THIS BILL
04:03:16.615 --> 04:03:17.849
HERE -- WE
04:03:17.916 --> 04:03:19.418
DON'T THINK OF IT SO MUCH AS
04:03:19.484 --> 04:03:20.919
BRINGING THE CLIPPERS TO
04:03:20.986 --> 04:03:22.688
INGLEWOOD DEBRIS AND BRING IN AN
04:03:22.754 --> 04:03:24.790
ECONOMIC INFUSION INTO THE AREA
04:03:24.856 --> 04:03:26.358
NOT ONLY TO INGLEWOOD BUT THE
04:03:26.425 --> 04:03:28.961
SURROUNDING AREAS OF LOS ANGELES.
04:03:29.027 --> 04:03:30.595
OF THE SOUTH BAY THE SOUTH EAST
04:03:30.662 --> 04:03:31.964
YEAH I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF
04:03:32.030 --> 04:03:33.031
JOBS OUT THERE THAT ARE GOING TO
04:03:33.098 --> 04:03:34.599
GO TO ALL THESE LOCAL PEOPLE
04:03:34.666 --> 04:03:37.069
AROUND HERE SO WE THANK YOU VERY
04:03:37.135 --> 04:03:37.636
MUCH FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.
04:03:37.703 --> 04:03:42.541
THANK YOU.
04:03:42.607 --> 04:03:45.043
ALRIGHT DOT OPPOSITION --
04:03:45.110 --> 04:03:50.148
TO A. B.. EIGHT NINE EIGHT SEVEN
04:03:50.215 --> 04:03:52.784
OH SORRY YOU SUPPORT.
04:03:52.851 --> 04:03:54.486
HELLO PAID ANYWAYS MY NAME'S
04:03:54.553 --> 04:03:55.253
ROBERT SMITH OF WITH THE
04:03:55.320 --> 04:03:56.688
PAINTERS AND ALLIED TRADES IN
04:03:56.755 --> 04:03:57.189
LOS ANGELES [inaudible]
04:03:57.255 --> 04:04:00.859
AND INGLEWOOD IS KIND OF SPECIAL
04:04:00.926 --> 04:04:02.294
TO MY UNION WE ACTUALLY AND HEAR
04:04:02.361 --> 04:04:03.695
PAINTERS YOU WOULDN'T THINK IT
04:04:03.762 --> 04:04:05.297
BUT WE ACTUALLY.
04:04:05.364 --> 04:04:06.531
REPRESENT THE CLASSIFIED WORKERS
04:04:06.598 --> 04:04:08.867
AT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT
04:04:08.934 --> 04:04:09.167
[inaudible]
04:04:09.234 --> 04:04:13.038
NO AND NO WORD AND WE'RE TO THE
04:04:13.105 --> 04:04:13.839
POINT WITH THAT BUT THAT WITH
04:04:13.905 --> 04:04:14.773
THE SCHOOL DISTRICT IT'S IN
04:04:14.840 --> 04:04:15.741
RECEIVERSHIP.
04:04:15.807 --> 04:04:17.743
BECAUSE FUNDS AND MISMANAGEMENT
04:04:17.809 --> 04:04:19.478
OF WHATEVER IT BE BUT YOU KNOW
04:04:19.544 --> 04:04:21.113
AS WE SAID IN NEGOTIATIONS WE
04:04:21.179 --> 04:04:23.248
SAY HEY --
04:04:23.315 --> 04:04:24.616
THEY'RE GONNA DO SOMETHING YOU
04:04:24.683 --> 04:04:26.184
KNOW OF WHAT WE GET ISSUES WITH
04:04:26.251 --> 04:04:28.020
OUR THIS COMES ALL BACK --
04:04:28.086 --> 04:04:30.489
TO TAX REVENUE.
04:04:30.555 --> 04:04:31.523
OUR EMPLOYEES THERE --
04:04:31.590 --> 04:04:33.358
THERE.
04:04:33.425 --> 04:04:35.327
THERE PAYER FOR THEIR IN THEIR
04:04:35.394 --> 04:04:36.862
HEALTH CARE IS IF THERE'S GONNA
04:04:36.928 --> 04:04:38.830
BE TWO PEOPLE OF THE NINETEEN
04:04:38.897 --> 04:04:39.931
GRAND A PIECE WHATEVER I MEAN.
04:04:39.998 --> 04:04:42.467
THERE'S NO MONEY.
04:04:42.534 --> 04:04:44.036
COMING INTO THE SCHOOL DISTRICT
04:04:44.102 --> 04:04:45.103
PROJECTS LIKE THIS PROJECTS LIKE
04:04:45.170 --> 04:04:46.538
THE RAMS.
04:04:46.605 --> 04:04:48.340
BRINGS MONEY REVENUE WILL HELP
04:04:48.407 --> 04:04:51.710
HEAL THAT DISTRICT.
04:04:51.777 --> 04:04:53.278
YOU KNOW I MEAN IT REALLY AND
04:04:53.345 --> 04:04:55.514
WE'RE WORK WE HAVE.
04:04:55.580 --> 04:04:57.215
I DON'T KNOW OVER A THOUSAND
04:04:57.282 --> 04:04:57.849
MEMBERS RIGHT IN THAT DISTRICT
04:04:57.916 --> 04:04:59.518
OKAY.
04:04:59.584 --> 04:05:01.853
IN AND OUT WE STRONGLY STRONGLY
04:05:01.920 --> 04:05:03.088
SUPPORT US BUT THEN AGAIN LIKE
04:05:03.155 --> 04:05:04.990
IT'S JUST I'M JUST GOING BACK TO
04:05:05.057 --> 04:05:07.359
SCHOOL DISTRICT CREATING MONEY.
04:05:07.426 --> 04:05:08.760
YOU KNOW TO HELP THAT SCHOOL
04:05:08.827 --> 04:05:10.328
DISTRICT AND THIS PROJECT WILL
04:05:10.395 --> 04:05:11.129
DO IT AS WILL THE RANCH.
04:05:11.196 --> 04:05:19.538
THANK YOU NEXT.
04:05:19.604 --> 04:05:23.341
YEAH THIS IS OPPOSITION.
04:05:23.408 --> 04:05:26.111
HELLO MY NAME IS XI'AN AND I AM
04:05:26.178 --> 04:05:29.214
WITH THE UPLIFTING BOARD COOLEY.
04:05:29.281 --> 04:05:31.583
COALITION WE ARE A COURAGE
04:05:31.650 --> 04:05:34.052
ENOUGH RESIDENTS FAITH GROUPS
04:05:34.119 --> 04:05:35.554
LOCAL BUSINESSES.
04:05:35.620 --> 04:05:38.090
AND COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS
04:05:38.156 --> 04:05:40.659
WORKING TOGETHER TO ENSURE THEIR
04:05:40.725 --> 04:05:41.660
VISION.
04:05:41.726 --> 04:05:44.096
COURAGE THE JUNE CRUDE AND
04:05:44.162 --> 04:05:46.832
BENEFIT EVERYONE ESPECIALLY THE
04:05:46.898 --> 04:05:50.102
MOST AT RISK TODAY WE HAVE.
04:05:50.168 --> 04:05:56.274
ME MY MOM AND DAD.
04:05:56.341 --> 04:05:57.776
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS SARAH
04:05:57.843 --> 04:05:58.577
I AM WITH HERE WITH THE
04:05:58.643 --> 04:05:59.744
UPLIFTING WHO WOULD COALITION
04:05:59.811 --> 04:06:01.079
AND WE WANT OUR ELECTED
04:06:01.146 --> 04:06:02.347
OFFICIALS TO PRIORITIZE HOMES
04:06:02.414 --> 04:06:04.182
BEFORE ARENAS.
04:06:04.249 --> 04:06:05.250
WE LIVE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD
04:06:05.317 --> 04:06:06.585
WHERE THEY ARE TRYING TO BUILD
04:06:06.651 --> 04:06:08.620
THE CLIPPERS ARENA MY RENT HAS
04:06:08.687 --> 04:06:10.789
BEEN PREMATURELY INCREASED BY
04:06:10.856 --> 04:06:11.990
THREE HUNDRED DOLLARS WITHIN ONE
04:06:12.057 --> 04:06:12.424
YEAR.
04:06:12.491 --> 04:06:13.592
THERE ARE PEOPLE IN MY COMMITTEE
04:06:13.658 --> 04:06:16.027
WHOSE RENT INCREASE UP TO A
04:06:16.094 --> 04:06:16.661
THOUSAND DOLLARS ACTUALLY SHE'S
04:06:16.728 --> 04:06:17.596
HERE RIGHT NOW.
04:06:17.662 --> 04:06:18.663
WE WOULD HAVE MORE PEOPLE HERE
04:06:18.730 --> 04:06:20.532
BUT THEY CAN'T AFFORD TO MISS
04:06:20.599 --> 04:06:21.500
WORK WHERE THEY CAN'T AFFORD A
04:06:21.566 --> 04:06:22.467
PLANE TICKET TO COME HERE WHICH
04:06:22.534 --> 04:06:24.436
WE DID.
04:06:24.503 --> 04:06:25.704
IN A TIME WHERE MANY OF US ARE
04:06:25.770 --> 04:06:27.272
FINDING IT HARDER AND HARDER TO
04:06:27.339 --> 04:06:28.740
REMAIN A PART OF OUR CITY.
04:06:28.807 --> 04:06:30.275
WE BELIEVE THAT OUR ELECTED
04:06:30.342 --> 04:06:31.076
OFFICIALS APART.
04:06:31.143 --> 04:06:32.144
HOUSING THAT OUR CURRENT
04:06:32.210 --> 04:06:34.279
WORKFORCE CAN AFFORD WE NEED
04:06:34.346 --> 04:06:35.780
TRUE LASTING INVESTMENTS IN OUR
04:06:35.847 --> 04:06:37.282
COMMUNITY WE NEED HOMES FOR
04:06:37.349 --> 04:06:39.584
INGLEWOOD RESIDENTS NOT ARENAS.
04:06:39.651 --> 04:06:40.886
WE BELIEVE YOU SHOULD DO THIS BY
04:06:40.952 --> 04:06:42.587
ADOPTING A RENT STABILIZATION
04:06:42.654 --> 04:06:44.656
ORDINANCE AND PRIORITY THING
04:06:44.723 --> 04:06:46.658
AFFORDABLE HOUSING. FOR OUR
04:06:46.725 --> 04:06:49.227
RESIDENTS INSTEAD HOUSING FOR A
04:06:49.294 --> 04:06:50.962
BILLIONAIRE NBA OWNER THE
04:06:51.029 --> 04:06:52.964
CLIPPERS ARENA IAN A CONFLICT
04:06:53.031 --> 04:06:54.533
CONTEMPLATE SELLING PUBLIC LAND
04:06:54.599 --> 04:06:55.867
TO A PRIVATE DEVELOPER.
04:06:55.934 --> 04:06:56.935
WE BELIEVE THAT LAND SHOULD BE
04:06:57.002 --> 04:06:58.336
USED FOR THE COMMUNITY BENEFITS
04:06:58.403 --> 04:06:59.638
AND SHOULD BE RESPONSIVE TO REAL
04:06:59.704 --> 04:07:01.439
COMMUNITY NEEDS YESTERDAY
04:07:01.506 --> 04:07:02.841
WITHOUT THE LAWSUIT ON BEHALF OF
04:07:02.908 --> 04:07:04.309
UPLIFT INTO A COALITION.
04:07:04.376 --> 04:07:05.944
AGAINST THE CITY OF INGLEWOOD WE
04:07:06.011 --> 04:07:07.012
ARE ALLEGING THAT THE CITY OF
04:07:07.078 --> 04:07:08.647
INGLEWOOD VIOLATED THE SURPLUS
04:07:08.713 --> 04:07:10.715
LAND ACT BY ENTERING INTO AN
04:07:10.782 --> 04:07:12.717
EXCLUSIVE NEGOTIATING AGREEMENT
04:07:12.784 --> 04:07:15.654
OR IN A WITH MURPHY'S BOWL.
04:07:15.720 --> 04:07:16.988
A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE LA
04:07:17.055 --> 04:07:18.990
CLIPPERS TO SELL PUBLICLY OWNED
04:07:19.057 --> 04:07:21.426
LAND FOR AN MBA ARENA.
04:07:21.493 --> 04:07:23.195
THE SURPLUS LAND ACT WAS CREATED
04:07:23.261 --> 04:07:24.729
TO PRIORITIZE THE DEVELOPMENT OF
04:07:24.796 --> 04:07:26.231
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ON LAND THE
04:07:26.298 --> 04:07:27.799
GOVERNMENT NO LONGER NEEDS.
04:07:27.866 --> 04:07:32.204
WE OPPOSE A BEAT [inaudible]
04:07:32.270 --> 04:07:34.139
NINETY SEVEN CANON WE'RE HERE ON
04:07:34.206 --> 04:07:38.743
THE BILL AND S. HE'S A. B. RIGHT.
04:07:38.810 --> 04:07:39.244
NINE EIGHT SEVEN SO FOR
04:07:39.311 --> 04:07:40.378
EVERYBODY WHO'S HERE.
04:07:40.445 --> 04:07:42.347
IF WE COULD LIMITED ON WHAT THE
04:07:42.414 --> 04:07:43.748
BILL DOES I KNOW THERE'S OTHER
04:07:43.815 --> 04:07:44.749
COUNSELOR FREE ISSUES.
04:07:44.816 --> 04:07:47.052
WITH INGLEWOOD AND THAT'S ALL
04:07:47.118 --> 04:07:48.386
FINE BUT I'M JUST I HAVE THE
04:07:48.453 --> 04:07:49.654
BILL IN FRONT OF ME ABSOLUTE
04:07:49.721 --> 04:07:51.823
NOTABLY AND THE THING IS THIS
04:07:51.890 --> 04:07:53.625
WHOLE PROJECT FROM THE VERY
04:07:53.692 --> 04:07:54.993
BEGINNING HAS BEEN RAMMED DOWN.
04:07:55.060 --> 04:07:56.695
COMMITTEE MEMBERS THROATS. FOR
04:07:56.761 --> 04:07:58.630
THE VERY BEGINNING A 64% OF THE
04:07:58.697 --> 04:08:00.332
CITY OF INGLEWOOD ARE PRINTERS.
04:08:00.398 --> 04:08:01.499
AND SO WHAT THEY'RE TRYING TO DO
04:08:01.566 --> 04:08:04.336
IS EVEN FAST TRACK EVEN FASTER --
04:08:04.402 --> 04:08:05.604
BY TRYING TO GET ALL THESE
04:08:05.670 --> 04:08:06.871
QUALITIES ARE.
04:08:06.938 --> 04:08:09.407
A OPPORTUNITIES TO TO MAKE IT.
04:08:09.474 --> 04:08:11.076
GO BEYOND THE SCOPE OF WHAT IT
04:08:11.142 --> 04:08:12.043
ALREADY IS I FEEL LIKE THE
04:08:12.110 --> 04:08:13.645
SEQUEL PROCESS GIVES US AN
04:08:13.712 --> 04:08:15.113
OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE A VOICE.
04:08:15.180 --> 04:08:16.414
AND WE'VE ALREADY ENGAGED IN A
04:08:16.481 --> 04:08:17.983
PROCESS AND SOME OF AND PARTS OF
04:08:18.049 --> 04:08:19.351
THIS IS ALREADY AS YOU DO FROM
04:08:19.417 --> 04:08:20.385
YOUR REVIEW.
04:08:20.452 --> 04:08:22.387
RD SAYS YOU KNOW THEY THEY WANT
04:08:22.454 --> 04:08:24.022
TO LIMIT THE AMOUNT OF COMMENTS
04:08:24.089 --> 04:08:25.490
THAT CAN ACTUALLY COME IN AS A
04:08:25.557 --> 04:08:26.024
CHANGE A PRODUCT THEY WANT
04:08:26.091 --> 04:08:26.958
EXPAND.
04:08:27.025 --> 04:08:27.892
BEYOND THE TWENTY SEVEN ACRES
04:08:27.959 --> 04:08:31.563
AND TO LIKE THREE HUNDRED PLUS
04:08:31.630 --> 04:08:33.365
ACRES YOU KNOW ME SO I LIKE THEM
04:08:33.431 --> 04:08:35.100
AMENDMENTS MEAN I'M.
04:08:35.166 --> 04:08:36.735
CONSCIOUS OF YET UP WHERE IT
04:08:36.801 --> 04:08:38.770
THIS ISN'T A EVOLVING PROJECT
04:08:38.837 --> 04:08:40.805
YEAH THAT'S EVOLVING BILL SO I
04:08:40.872 --> 04:08:43.308
CAN PART OF THE DISCUSSIONS ON
04:08:43.375 --> 04:08:44.909
AND CHANGES I'VE ASKED SOME
04:08:44.976 --> 04:08:46.344
QUESTIONS ABOUT IT SO.
04:08:46.411 --> 04:08:49.147
I HOPE WE DO HAVE A MORE LIMITED
04:08:49.214 --> 04:08:50.215
YES I'M.
04:08:50.282 --> 04:08:51.983
BILL THAT'S AS AMENDED THAT'S
04:08:52.050 --> 04:08:53.518
BEFORE US RIGHT NOW RUSH YOU
04:08:53.585 --> 04:08:54.319
KNOW.
04:08:54.386 --> 04:08:55.253
HOPES ADDRESS WHERE THEY
04:08:55.320 --> 04:08:56.988
ADEQUATELY ADDRESS THE PARALLELS
04:08:57.055 --> 04:08:59.324
ARE MADE BETWEEN AB NINE HUNDRED
04:08:59.391 --> 04:09:00.125
WHICH IS SORT OF OUR BASELINE
04:09:00.191 --> 04:09:01.993
AND UP IN THE SEQUEL PROCESS AND
04:09:02.060 --> 04:09:04.529
WHAT'S BEFORE US.
04:09:04.596 --> 04:09:05.330
WE'LL HAVE A DISCUSSION BUT
04:09:05.397 --> 04:09:07.232
AFTER THAT SO WELL I GUESS THE
04:09:07.299 --> 04:09:09.301
SHORT OF BOTTOM LINE THERE
04:09:09.367 --> 04:09:10.435
HASN'T EVEN BEEN IN THE
04:09:10.502 --> 04:09:11.870
ENGAGEMENT COMMUNITY AS I I'VE
04:09:11.936 --> 04:09:13.071
NEVER EVEN HAD THE OPPORTUNITY
04:09:13.138 --> 04:09:15.006
TO SIT DOWN IN THE SAME ROOM.
04:09:15.073 --> 04:09:17.676
AS THE ASSEMBLY WOMAN --
04:09:17.742 --> 04:09:18.843
TO ACTUALLY TALK ABOUT THIS
04:09:18.910 --> 04:09:20.245
PARTICULAR PROJECT IN PARTICULAR
04:09:20.312 --> 04:09:21.513
THIS PARTICULAR BILL.
04:09:21.579 --> 04:09:23.581
SO ASK COMMUTING MEMBERS WE WANT
04:09:23.648 --> 04:09:25.784
HOMES NOT REMISS IT'S SO WHERE
04:09:25.850 --> 04:09:26.418
WE ACTUALLY OPPOSE --
04:09:26.484 --> 04:09:27.085
THIS LEGISLATION THANK YOU
04:09:27.152 --> 04:09:27.385
[inaudible]
04:09:27.452 --> 04:09:34.125
NEXT.
04:09:34.192 --> 04:09:36.494
BUT HAS A GLOSS ARE.
04:09:36.561 --> 04:09:38.563
DOES IT THAT WAY.
04:09:38.630 --> 04:09:40.498
LIKE ASKING MIGHT GO SKIING
04:09:40.565 --> 04:09:42.834
EVERYONE ELSE ON SEEN IN THIS
04:09:42.901 --> 04:09:43.568
CHAMBER TODAY.
04:09:43.635 --> 04:09:45.236
UP WHAT'S UP JUST REALLY BRIEFLY
04:09:45.303 --> 04:09:46.705
WAS REITERATED MY NAME IS
04:09:46.771 --> 04:09:49.140
MICHAEL MUSCLE UPLIFT AND WOOD.
04:09:49.207 --> 04:09:50.675
I'M MUCH MORE TALK ABOUT --
04:09:50.742 --> 04:09:51.810
THE SURPLUS LAND AT THAT
04:09:51.876 --> 04:09:53.645
REQUIRES THE COUNTY TO NOTIFY
04:09:53.712 --> 04:09:55.080
CERTAIN GOVERNMENT --
04:09:55.146 --> 04:09:56.614
AGENCIES OF WATER BY HOUSING
04:09:56.681 --> 04:09:58.416
DEVELOPERS WHENEVER THERE'S A
04:09:58.483 --> 04:09:59.517
SURPLUS LAND AVAILABLE FOR
04:09:59.584 --> 04:10:00.885
AFFORDABLE HOUSING PARKS AND
04:10:00.952 --> 04:10:02.954
OPEN SPACES --
04:10:03.021 --> 04:10:04.456
CITIES AND COUNTIES MUST DO THIS
04:10:04.522 --> 04:10:06.591
BEFORE SELLING SURPLUS LAND THAT
04:10:06.658 --> 04:10:09.294
I UNDERSTAND SITUATION AT
04:10:09.361 --> 04:10:10.929
CITIBANK WITH HOWEVER TO
04:10:10.995 --> 04:10:11.596
CITIBANK WOULD DO NOT FOLLOW THE
04:10:11.663 --> 04:10:12.764
PROPER PROCEDURE.
04:10:12.831 --> 04:10:14.866
MANDATED BY THE SURPLUS LAND ACT
04:10:14.933 --> 04:10:15.600
AND THAT IS WHY WE ARE ASKING
04:10:15.667 --> 04:10:18.503
THE COURTS. TO INVALIDATE THE
04:10:18.570 --> 04:10:19.304
IAN.
04:10:19.371 --> 04:10:21.139
EIGHT I'M JUST REALLY QUICKLY --
04:10:21.206 --> 04:10:22.674
I WANT TO SAY IT IS MY NAME IS
04:10:22.741 --> 04:10:23.708
MICHAEL A LOOK UP WITHIN WHAT I
04:10:23.775 --> 04:10:25.610
GREW UP IN INGLEWOOD I WAS I'M A
04:10:25.677 --> 04:10:27.045
MOTHER GREW UP IN INGLEWOOD.
04:10:27.112 --> 04:10:28.179
EVERYONE THAT I GREW UP AROUND
04:10:28.246 --> 04:10:30.949
IS.
04:10:31.015 --> 04:10:32.550
WE TALK ABOUT THIS BRINGING JOBS
04:10:32.617 --> 04:10:34.452
WE WANT EQUITY.
04:10:34.519 --> 04:10:36.154
AND I AM AN ARTIST NOW WE WE
04:10:36.221 --> 04:10:38.256
WANT TO BE ABLE TO LIVE.
04:10:38.323 --> 04:10:39.958
AND RIGHT NOW WE ARE SEEING
04:10:40.024 --> 04:10:41.326
PEOPLE BEING PUSHED OUT WHO HAVE
04:10:41.393 --> 04:10:43.161
BEEN THERE FOREVER WHO HAVE THE
04:10:43.228 --> 04:10:44.562
RIGHT TO STATE IT AS AS
04:10:44.629 --> 04:10:47.298
PREVIOUSLY STATED. 68% OF
04:10:47.365 --> 04:10:49.234
INGLEWOOD'S RESIDENTS ARE
04:10:49.300 --> 04:10:51.503
RANCHERS AND THAT RANCHERS
04:10:51.569 --> 04:10:53.838
POPULATION IS WHAT DROVE THIS --
04:10:53.905 --> 04:10:56.641
THIS SURPLUS IN THE ECONOMIC IN
04:10:56.708 --> 04:10:58.343
INGLEWOOD ECONOMICS YET THEY'RE
04:10:58.410 --> 04:10:59.911
NOT BEING PROTECTED IF THEY'RE
04:10:59.978 --> 04:11:01.746
NOT BEING SOUGHT AFTER FIRST WE
04:11:01.813 --> 04:11:02.981
UNDERSTAND ENTERTAINMENT IS
04:11:03.047 --> 04:11:04.649
GREAT WE HAVE THE RAMS.
04:11:04.716 --> 04:11:05.683
WE HAVE A WHOLE LOT OF
04:11:05.750 --> 04:11:06.818
ENTERTAINMENT COMING TO LA
04:11:06.885 --> 04:11:09.654
COUNTY HOWEVER WE HAVE A WHOLE
04:11:09.721 --> 04:11:13.057
LOT MORE HOMELESSNESS CRISIS
04:11:13.124 --> 04:11:15.460
HAPPENING THROUGHOUT OUR COUNTY.
04:11:15.527 --> 04:11:16.828
AND IT INGLEWOOD SHOULD HAVE
04:11:16.895 --> 04:11:18.696
BEEN THE SPEAR HEAD AND AND AN
04:11:18.763 --> 04:11:20.532
INNOVATOR IN THE PROTECTION OF
04:11:20.598 --> 04:11:22.634
HUMAN LIFE.
04:11:22.700 --> 04:11:24.602
NOT THE ADVANCEMENT OF PROFIT.
04:11:24.669 --> 04:11:26.137
AND I UNDERSTAND THE REALITY OF
04:11:26.204 --> 04:11:27.906
THE EVERYONE WANTED TO MAKE A
04:11:27.972 --> 04:11:30.508
BUCK I UNDERSTAND THE ASPECT OF
04:11:30.575 --> 04:11:31.876
EVERYONE WANTING TO HAVE THEIR
04:11:31.943 --> 04:11:34.345
NAME STAMPED ON Y. INGLEWOOD
04:11:34.412 --> 04:11:36.381
MADE MORE MONEY.
04:11:36.448 --> 04:11:37.482
BUT UP WITH BINGO WOOD IS HERE
04:11:37.549 --> 04:11:39.784
TODAY THE AXE YOU ALL TO TAKE
04:11:39.851 --> 04:11:41.286
INTO ACCOUNT THE REALITY OF
04:11:41.352 --> 04:11:44.255
MAKING SURE HUMAN LIFE.
04:11:44.322 --> 04:11:46.458
IS SOUGHT AFTER PROTECTED BEFORE
04:11:46.524 --> 04:11:48.560
THAT TOP DOLLAR BECAUSERIGHT
04:11:48.626 --> 04:11:49.661
NOW THAT'S WILL RAT I THINK YOU
04:11:49.727 --> 04:11:54.732
THINK YOU NEXT.
04:11:54.799 --> 04:11:56.734
MY NAME'S KITSCH AND I STRONGLY
04:11:56.801 --> 04:11:59.370
OPPOSE A. B..
04:11:59.437 --> 04:12:00.104
NINE EIGHTY SEVEN I'M A SINGLE
04:12:00.171 --> 04:12:00.839
MOTHER --
04:12:00.905 --> 04:12:02.373
INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR WITH SONY
04:12:02.440 --> 04:12:03.708
IN CULVER CITY.
04:12:03.775 --> 04:12:04.776
AND I'M ALSO HERE WITH UPLIFTING
04:12:04.843 --> 04:12:07.812
AWAY -- I AM
04:12:07.879 --> 04:12:10.415
ALSO IMPACTED.
04:12:10.482 --> 04:12:11.683
I MEAN IMPACTED INGLEWOOD
04:12:11.749 --> 04:12:13.351
RESIDENT DIRECTLY AFFECTED BY
04:12:13.418 --> 04:12:14.419
THE HOUSING CRISIS THAT THE CITY
04:12:14.486 --> 04:12:17.021
OF INGLEWOOD IS A EXPERIENCING
04:12:17.088 --> 04:12:19.791
DO TO THE FAST TRACK METHODOLOGY.
04:12:19.858 --> 04:12:21.459
THE CITY HAS PUT INTO MOTION ARE
04:12:21.526 --> 04:12:23.094
ATTEMPTING TO PUT IN THE MOTION
04:12:23.161 --> 04:12:25.864
TO DO IT DIRECTLY ADDRESS.
04:12:25.930 --> 04:12:29.334
THE A. B..
04:12:29.400 --> 04:12:29.901
NINE EIGHTY SEVEN WE WANT TO
04:12:29.968 --> 04:12:31.436
MAKE IT CLEAR.
04:12:31.503 --> 04:12:34.172
IT WE ARE NOT ANTI DEVELOPMENT.
04:12:34.239 --> 04:12:36.875
WE ARE ADVOCATES FOR RESPONSIBLE
04:12:36.941 --> 04:12:38.810
COMMUNITY SERVICE IN DEVELOPMENT.
04:12:38.877 --> 04:12:40.111
BASED ON THE DAY.
04:12:40.178 --> 04:12:41.679
DEEP IMPACT AND RESIDENTS
04:12:41.746 --> 04:12:43.414
DAMAGED I'M SORRY BASED ON THE
04:12:43.481 --> 04:12:44.582
DEEP IMPACT AND RESIDENT
04:12:44.649 --> 04:12:46.050
ENGAGEMENT.
04:12:46.117 --> 04:12:47.619
WE HAVE DEVELOPED --
04:12:47.685 --> 04:12:48.786
COMPREHENSIVE PROPOSAL WE WOULD
04:12:48.853 --> 04:12:50.522
LIKE.
04:12:50.588 --> 04:12:52.423
THE PUBLIC LAND THAT IS BEING
04:12:52.490 --> 04:12:53.725
CONSIDERED FOR THE CLIPPERS ARE
04:12:53.791 --> 04:12:55.593
WE NEED TO INSTEAD BE USE FOR
04:12:55.660 --> 04:12:57.028
COMMUNITY INVESTMENTS SUCH AS
04:12:57.095 --> 04:12:58.096
YOUTH CENTERS [inaudible]
04:12:58.162 --> 04:12:59.764
SENIOR CENTERS.
04:12:59.831 --> 04:13:00.798
IN WHOLE GROWN BUSINESS
04:13:00.865 --> 04:13:02.967
INCUBATION CENTERS.
04:13:03.034 --> 04:13:04.569
WE'VE BEEN TOLD BY THE SITES
04:13:04.636 --> 04:13:05.637
ONCE OUR WE'VE BEEN TOLD THAT
04:13:05.703 --> 04:13:06.971
THE FIGHTS ARE NOT SUITABLE FOR
04:13:07.038 --> 04:13:09.574
HOUSING.
04:13:09.641 --> 04:13:11.309
BUT THE CITY HAS YET TO PRODUCE
04:13:11.376 --> 04:13:13.077
EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THIS CLAIM
04:13:13.144 --> 04:13:13.378
[inaudible]
04:13:13.444 --> 04:13:15.046
IN FACT.
04:13:15.113 --> 04:13:16.281
WE HAVE GONE AND DONE OUR OWN
04:13:16.347 --> 04:13:18.349
RESEARCH. TO TO SUGGEST THAT THE
04:13:18.416 --> 04:13:19.984
SITES.
04:13:20.051 --> 04:13:23.054
MAY INDEED BE USED FOR HOUSING.
04:13:23.121 --> 04:13:24.722
THAT WE CAN SPEAK TO EACH OF
04:13:24.789 --> 04:13:25.690
THESE.
04:13:25.757 --> 04:13:28.226
THREE SUPPORTED [inaudible]
04:13:28.293 --> 04:13:31.195
BARRIERS ZONING.
04:13:31.262 --> 04:13:31.563
FAA [inaudible]
04:13:31.629 --> 04:13:34.198
ASSURANCES.
04:13:34.265 --> 04:13:37.535
AN ABROGATION AN EASEMENT.
04:13:37.602 --> 04:13:40.872
OKAY THANK YOU NEXT.
04:13:40.939 --> 04:13:42.774
GOOD AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
04:13:42.840 --> 04:13:44.108
COMMITTEE I'M CATHY DEPUTY I'M
04:13:44.175 --> 04:13:46.644
WITH UPLIFTING WOULD I OPPOSE.
04:13:46.711 --> 04:13:49.314
HOME NINE EIGHTY SEVEN OR SEVEN
04:13:49.380 --> 04:13:51.115
EIGHTY NINE OR WHATEVER THAT
04:13:51.182 --> 04:13:52.517
NUMBER IS STARTING TO NINE
04:13:52.584 --> 04:13:53.685
EIGHTY SO YOU LOSE IT.
04:13:53.751 --> 04:13:55.219
AROUND THAT NUMBER.
04:13:55.286 --> 04:13:57.088
HOME WE ARE A RESIDENTS OF
04:13:57.155 --> 04:13:59.190
ENGLEWOOD AND WE'RE HERE ON
04:13:59.257 --> 04:14:00.091
THEIR OWN DIME --
04:14:00.158 --> 04:14:01.459
TODAY UNLIKE SOME OTHERS BECAUSE
04:14:01.526 --> 04:14:02.860
WE REALLY CARE ABOUT OUR
04:14:02.927 --> 04:14:04.629
COMMUNITY AND WE CARE ABOUT THE
04:14:04.696 --> 04:14:05.630
FACT THAT THERE'S SO MANY
04:14:05.697 --> 04:14:06.998
HOMELESS PEOPLE.
04:14:07.065 --> 04:14:09.767
IN OUR IN OUR COMMUNITIES.
04:14:09.834 --> 04:14:11.469
AND THAT THIS IS PUBLIC LAND
04:14:11.536 --> 04:14:12.770
SHOULD BE USED FOR FOR PUBLIC
04:14:12.837 --> 04:14:14.238
PURPOSES [inaudible]
04:14:14.305 --> 04:14:16.040
I'M.
04:14:16.107 --> 04:14:17.976
THE ZONING IS NOT A PROBLEM IT'S
04:14:18.042 --> 04:14:20.511
NOT TRUE THAT THE SITE IS NOT
04:14:20.578 --> 04:14:22.447
SUITABLE FOR HOUSING.
04:14:22.513 --> 04:14:23.881
BECAUSE THE ZONING --
04:14:23.948 --> 04:14:25.516
WHILE THERE ARE MANY SITES THAT
04:14:25.583 --> 04:14:27.151
ARE CURRENTLY ZONED AND ONE EL
04:14:27.218 --> 04:14:28.886
THE CITY DOES HAVE THE LEGAL
04:14:28.953 --> 04:14:30.989
DISTRICTS DISCRETION TO CHANGE
04:14:31.055 --> 04:14:31.923
THE ZONING.
04:14:31.990 --> 04:14:33.558
WHEN APPROPRIATE TO SUPPORT
04:14:33.625 --> 04:14:34.859
HOUSING DEVELOPMENT THAT'S
04:14:34.926 --> 04:14:36.527
WRITTEN RIGHT INTO THE CITY'S
04:14:36.594 --> 04:14:39.163
OWN HOUSING ELEMENT PLAN?
04:14:39.230 --> 04:14:41.599
THAT THAT EXPRESSLY CONTEMPLATES
04:14:41.666 --> 04:14:44.202
CHANGING ZONES AS A STRATEGY TO
04:14:44.268 --> 04:14:45.937
ADDRESS A HOUSING NEEDS.
04:14:46.004 --> 04:14:47.205
AND THERE'S PRECEDENT THE
04:14:47.271 --> 04:14:49.674
HOLLYWOOD PARK SPECIFIC PLANNED
04:14:49.741 --> 04:14:51.209
RIGHT ACROSS THE STREET HAD ITS
04:14:51.275 --> 04:14:53.778
OWN CHANGED BY THE CITY.
04:14:53.845 --> 04:14:55.913
OF FOR THAT CONVENIENCE SO THEY
04:14:55.980 --> 04:14:57.148
CAN DO IT THERE THEY CAN DO IT.
04:14:57.215 --> 04:14:59.083
HOME AGAIN AND IT SHOULD BE DONE
04:14:59.150 --> 04:15:01.185
AGAIN THANK YOU I DO OPPOSE
04:15:01.252 --> 04:15:04.756
THANK YOU MIND IF SAID.
04:15:04.822 --> 04:15:05.857
GOOD AFTERNOON MY NAME IS KATIE
04:15:05.923 --> 04:15:07.492
MCEWAN I'M AN ATTORNEY WITH
04:15:07.558 --> 04:15:09.394
PUBLIC COUNSEL A CIVIL RIGHTS
04:15:09.460 --> 04:15:11.062
ORGANIZATION WORKING IN LA
04:15:11.129 --> 04:15:12.697
COUNTY AND WITH UPLIFTING GOAL
04:15:12.764 --> 04:15:12.930
WOULD.
04:15:12.997 --> 04:15:14.432
OUR PUBLIC COUNCIL STRONGLY
04:15:14.499 --> 04:15:15.733
OPPOSES AB NINETY SEVEN THANK
04:15:15.800 --> 04:15:19.470
YOU.
04:15:19.537 --> 04:15:20.805
GOOD MORNING AGAIN MATTHEW BAKER
04:15:20.872 --> 04:15:22.407
WITH PLANNING CONSERVATION THE
04:15:22.473 --> 04:15:26.010
WE ARE OPPOSED TO THIS BILL --
04:15:26.077 --> 04:15:27.445
WE ARE GREATLY CONCERNED ABOUT
04:15:27.512 --> 04:15:28.813
THE DISRUPTION AND DISPLACEMENT
04:15:28.880 --> 04:15:31.849
OF THIS EXISTING COMMUNITY AND
04:15:31.916 --> 04:15:33.484
BEYOND THAT AS WE SAID EARLIER
04:15:33.551 --> 04:15:35.486
AND SEVEN THIRTY FOUR WE YOU
04:15:35.553 --> 04:15:36.187
KNOW.
04:15:36.254 --> 04:15:37.955
BUILDING ON AGREE WITH THE
04:15:38.022 --> 04:15:39.323
COMMITMENT THAT YOU ADDITIONAL
04:15:39.390 --> 04:15:41.559
COUNSEL AND SHARE THOSE CONCERNS
04:15:41.626 --> 04:15:44.162
ABOUT THE THE CHALLENGES THAT.
04:15:44.228 --> 04:15:46.297
EXPEDITED JUDICIAL REVIEW POSES
04:15:46.364 --> 04:15:47.732
TO THE G. TISSUE AREA THERE
04:15:47.799 --> 04:15:49.367
TERRACE IS DISPENSING COOL
04:15:49.434 --> 04:15:50.968
ACCESS TO JUSTICE.
04:15:51.035 --> 04:15:52.136
WE DON'T THINK THAT STADIUMS
04:15:52.203 --> 04:15:54.005
MEET THE THE LEVEL OF URGENCY
04:15:54.072 --> 04:15:55.139
THAT SOME OTHER SPECIAL
04:15:55.206 --> 04:15:56.774
SITUATIONS WOULD WARRANT THAT
04:15:56.841 --> 04:15:57.275
KIND OF EXPLODED REVIEW
04:15:57.341 --> 04:15:57.575
[inaudible]
04:15:57.642 --> 04:15:59.577
THANK YOU [inaudible]
04:15:59.644 --> 04:16:02.947
NEXT.
04:16:03.014 --> 04:16:04.482
HI MY NAME IS CRYSTAL GREER I
04:16:04.549 --> 04:16:09.120
WITH UPLIFTING WERE COALITION --
04:16:09.187 --> 04:16:11.055
I'M ALSO HERE MY OWN DYING --
04:16:11.122 --> 04:16:13.257
AND I WANTED TO I'M STRONGLY
04:16:13.324 --> 04:16:14.992
OPPOSE --
04:16:15.059 --> 04:16:17.028
BILL NINE EIGHTY SEVEN SORRY
04:16:17.095 --> 04:16:17.328
[inaudible]
04:16:17.395 --> 04:16:19.931
THAT IT.
04:16:19.997 --> 04:16:21.899
THANK CAPITA YES THAT'S OKAY AND
04:16:21.966 --> 04:16:23.434
I WANT TO SAY SOMETHING FEDERAL
04:16:23.501 --> 04:16:24.969
STATE AND LOCAL REGULATIONS ALL
04:16:25.036 --> 04:16:26.971
INDICATE THAT RESIDENTIAL USE
04:16:27.038 --> 04:16:28.740
CAN BE CONSIDERED COMPATIBLE.
04:16:28.806 --> 04:16:30.608
AT THE SIXTY FIVE TO SEVENTY
04:16:30.675 --> 04:16:32.677
DECIBEL RANGE IF NOISE
04:16:32.744 --> 04:16:34.378
INSULATION STANDARDS ARE MET.
04:16:34.445 --> 04:16:35.480
WE BELIEVE HOUSING WILL BE
04:16:35.546 --> 04:16:37.548
COMPATIBLE WITH GREAT ASSURANCES
04:16:37.615 --> 04:16:39.350
IN NAVIGATION EASEMENTS AS LONG
04:16:39.417 --> 04:16:40.818
AS PROPER NOISE INSULATION
04:16:40.885 --> 04:16:42.520
MEASURES ARE ATTACHED.
04:16:42.587 --> 04:16:44.689
IN LIGHT OF OUR HOUSING CRISIS
04:16:44.756 --> 04:16:45.757
THE CITY SHOULD GIVE THIS
04:16:45.823 --> 04:16:47.992
SERIOUS CONSIDERATION WE URGE
04:16:48.059 --> 04:16:50.328
THE COUNCIL TO PRIORITIZE PUBLIC
04:16:50.394 --> 04:16:52.296
LAND FOR THE PUBLIC GOOD AND TO
04:16:52.363 --> 04:16:53.998
COMPLY WITH STATE LAW TO
04:16:54.065 --> 04:16:56.300
PRIORITIZE AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO
04:16:56.367 --> 04:16:57.869
MEET THE COMMUNITIES NEEDS FOR
04:16:57.935 --> 04:16:58.469
STABLE.
04:16:58.536 --> 04:17:01.239
AFFORDABLE IN WORKFORCE HOUSING
04:17:01.305 --> 04:17:03.674
WE URGE YOU TO PRIORITIZE ALL
04:17:03.741 --> 04:17:04.509
THE FOUR ARENAS ESPECIALLY
04:17:04.575 --> 04:17:07.145
SOMEONE WHO DRAFTED THE BILL AND
04:17:07.211 --> 04:17:09.046
AND IS NOT EVEN BEING NEGATIVE.
04:17:09.113 --> 04:17:10.481
NEGATIVELY AFFECTED IN THAT AREA
04:17:10.548 --> 04:17:11.349
THANK YOU.
04:17:11.415 --> 04:17:16.921
OUR NEXT WITNESS.
04:17:16.988 --> 04:17:18.389
HOW DOES A CIRCLE CALIFORNIA
04:17:18.456 --> 04:17:20.291
ALSO POSED OUT FOR THE REASONS
04:17:20.358 --> 04:17:21.425
MENTIONED EARLIER IN DURING THE
04:17:21.492 --> 04:17:23.027
OTHER TESTIMONY REGARDING THE
04:17:23.094 --> 04:17:23.661
TWO HUNDRED SEVENTY DAY LANGUAGE
04:17:23.728 --> 04:17:25.263
I DID WANT TO JUST BRING UP TO
04:17:25.329 --> 04:17:26.564
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THIS?
04:17:26.631 --> 04:17:28.499
SHE DROVE PROCEDURALLY BETWEEN
04:17:28.566 --> 04:17:30.101
THIS BILL AND AB NINE HUNDRED
04:17:30.168 --> 04:17:31.302
AND THAT IS THE LIMITATION ON
04:17:31.369 --> 04:17:33.604
COMMENTS I IN THIS BILL THERE'S
04:17:33.671 --> 04:17:36.040
A LIMITATION OF COMMENTS BETWEEN --
04:17:36.107 --> 04:17:36.908
TO JUST THE PUBLIC COMMENT
04:17:36.974 --> 04:17:38.910
PERIOD WHERE IS NORMALLY UNDER
04:17:38.976 --> 04:17:40.444
SEQUEL YOU HAVE AN AND UNDER IN
04:17:40.511 --> 04:17:42.046
ITS AND UNDER A BENIGN HENDRED
04:17:42.113 --> 04:17:42.713
YOU HAVE UNTIL THE CLOSE THE
04:17:42.780 --> 04:17:43.714
PUBLIC HEARING.
04:17:43.781 --> 04:17:45.116
THERE'S A A DIFFERENCE IN TIME
04:17:45.183 --> 04:17:46.117
THERE --
04:17:46.184 --> 04:17:48.286
SOMETIMES EASY I ARE THE PAGES
04:17:48.352 --> 04:17:51.689
AND FOR ATTORNEYS I THINK THAT
04:17:51.756 --> 04:17:52.790
CAN BE MANAGEABLE BUT I THINK
04:17:52.857 --> 04:17:53.891
WHEN YOU HAVE COMMUNITY GROUPS
04:17:53.958 --> 04:17:55.259
THE CAN BE VERY DIFFICULT TO
04:17:55.326 --> 04:17:56.594
MEET THAT THIRTY DAYTIME OF IT
04:17:56.661 --> 04:17:57.128
AND THAT'S WHY.
04:17:57.195 --> 04:17:58.462
SEQUEL ALLOWS FOR A LONGER
04:17:58.529 --> 04:17:59.630
PERIOD OF TIME IN WHICH TO BRING
04:17:59.697 --> 04:18:01.098
CLAIMS --
04:18:01.165 --> 04:18:02.233
WHAT'S IMPORTANT IS IF THOSE
04:18:02.300 --> 04:18:03.100
CLAIMS ARE REYES THEN THEY'RE
04:18:03.167 --> 04:18:05.002
NOT LIVEABLE --
04:18:05.069 --> 04:18:06.637
AND SO.
04:18:06.704 --> 04:18:07.738
THAT THAT IS A BIG CONCERN FOR
04:18:07.805 --> 04:18:09.207
US AND THEN ALSO THIS BILL DOES
04:18:09.273 --> 04:18:10.908
CONTAIN HOUR LIMITATION ON
04:18:10.975 --> 04:18:12.343
INDUCTION INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND
04:18:12.410 --> 04:18:13.311
AS WE KNOW IF THERE ARE ANY
04:18:13.377 --> 04:18:14.912
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ARE
04:18:14.979 --> 04:18:16.080
IMPACTS THAT CAN OCCUR DURING.
04:18:16.147 --> 04:18:17.949
YOU KNOW DID THE CONSTRUCTION
04:18:18.015 --> 04:18:19.784
PHASE DAY ONE THAT DOES KEEP
04:18:19.851 --> 04:18:21.118
THIS CAN'T BE STOPPED BY THE
04:18:21.185 --> 04:18:21.752
COURT THOSE WILL BE BORNE BY THE
04:18:21.819 --> 04:18:23.020
COMMUNITY.
04:18:23.087 --> 04:18:25.957
I SWEAR IF YOU KNOW I THINK.
04:18:26.023 --> 04:18:27.391
CHAIR MEMBER SCOTT GOVERNOR
04:18:27.458 --> 04:18:28.926
BEHALF OF MORONGO BAND OF
04:18:28.993 --> 04:18:30.394
MISSION INDIANS WE HAVE AN
04:18:30.461 --> 04:18:32.196
OPPOSING WAS AMENDED OF LIKE TO
04:18:32.263 --> 04:18:33.698
THINK THE OFTEN PROPONENTS. FOR
04:18:33.764 --> 04:18:35.867
NARROWING THE SCOPE OF THE BILL.
04:18:35.933 --> 04:18:37.168
WANTS TO REVIEW THE LANGUAGE
04:18:37.235 --> 04:18:38.536
WILL BE HAPPY TO REMOVE HER
04:18:38.603 --> 04:18:42.573
OPPOSITION THANK YOU.
04:18:42.640 --> 04:18:43.374
THE AFTERNOON MEMBERS OF THE
04:18:43.441 --> 04:18:44.775
COMMITTEE MY NME START CANYON
04:18:44.842 --> 04:18:46.210
SCORES ON THE EXECUTOR TO ASSIST
04:18:46.277 --> 04:18:47.545
US LEARNING INSTITUTE WE ARE A
04:18:47.612 --> 04:18:49.280
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION
04:18:49.347 --> 04:18:50.615
CALIFORNIA.
04:18:50.681 --> 04:18:52.250
I AM FROM INGLEWOOD I GREW UP IN
04:18:52.316 --> 04:18:54.418
THIS AREA I WALK DOWN THE STREET
04:18:54.485 --> 04:18:55.019
TECH WRITER FROM EXPERT HIGH
04:18:55.086 --> 04:18:55.720
SCHOOL.
04:18:55.786 --> 04:18:56.921
WHICH IS WITHIN TWO BLOCKS OF
04:18:56.988 --> 04:18:58.789
THE YEAH STUDY AREA AND THIS
04:18:58.856 --> 04:19:00.591
PROPOSAL IS ARENA.
04:19:00.658 --> 04:19:01.359
I'M ALSO A SCHOOL REMEMBER THIS
04:19:01.425 --> 04:19:02.693
LIVING.
04:19:02.760 --> 04:19:03.394
ONE MY FIRST SCRIPT WRITTEN A
04:19:03.461 --> 04:19:04.528
COUPLE THINGS SCHOOLS WILL NOT
04:19:04.595 --> 04:19:06.097
RECEIVE REVENUE AS A RESULT OF
04:19:06.163 --> 04:19:06.998
THIS PROJECT YOU'RE NOT A BASIC
04:19:07.064 --> 04:19:08.199
EIGHT DISTRICT.
04:19:08.266 --> 04:19:09.834
ALL THE ADDITIONAL TAXES WILL GO
04:19:09.901 --> 04:19:10.668
TO THE STATE AND THE BE
04:19:10.735 --> 04:19:12.069
REALLOCATED IT TO US DIRECTLY
04:19:12.136 --> 04:19:13.271
THREE SFF.
04:19:13.337 --> 04:19:15.306
THERE WILL BE DEVELOPER FEES.
04:19:15.373 --> 04:19:17.441
THOSE FEES WILL BE RESTRICTED
04:19:17.508 --> 04:19:18.409
SCHOOLS ARE DIRECTLY NEARBY
04:19:18.476 --> 04:19:19.911
ELECTED TO THE ANY CCOUNTS THAT
04:19:19.977 --> 04:19:21.145
WILL BE NO DIRECT BENEFITS TO
04:19:21.212 --> 04:19:22.280
SCHOOLS AND IN FACT.
04:19:22.346 --> 04:19:23.214
IT'S ONE OF THE REASONS WHY I
04:19:23.281 --> 04:19:24.715
PERSONALLY OPPOSE BECAUSE THIS
04:19:24.782 --> 04:19:25.616
PROJECT DOES NOT HAVE A
04:19:25.683 --> 04:19:27.351
COMMUNITY BENEFITS AGREEMENT.
04:19:27.418 --> 04:19:28.419
AND HAS NO DIRECT BENEFIT NIGHT
04:19:28.486 --> 04:19:30.288
OUT NEITHER UPON THE SCHOOLS OR
04:19:30.354 --> 04:19:31.956
UPON THE ADVANCEMENT GREEN SPACE.
04:19:32.023 --> 04:19:33.524
IN FACT MANY OF US HAVE BEEN
04:19:33.591 --> 04:19:35.126
VERY AND EXTREMELY CONCERNED IN
04:19:35.192 --> 04:19:36.360
THE DISTRICT ABOUT THE LACK OF
04:19:36.427 --> 04:19:37.895
INVESTMENTS WILL CURRENT HELPERS.
04:19:37.962 --> 04:19:39.363
I INCLUDING THOSE WHO ARE
04:19:39.430 --> 04:19:41.866
BUILDING A MAJOR PROJECTS NOW.
04:19:41.933 --> 04:19:42.967
AN ADDITIONAL THAT MANY OF OUR
04:19:43.034 --> 04:19:44.702
FOLK OR DEALING WITH SIGNIFICANT --
04:19:44.769 --> 04:19:45.670
ISSUES IN THE COMMUNITY HEALTH
04:19:45.736 --> 04:19:47.238
ISSUES.
04:19:47.305 --> 04:19:49.774
THOSE INCLUDE A EMPHYSEMA LUNG
04:19:49.840 --> 04:19:51.742
DISEASE OUT A LUNG CANCER AND
04:19:51.809 --> 04:19:53.544
OTHER AIR POLLUTION AND TRAFFIC
04:19:53.611 --> 04:19:54.645
CONCERNS SUPPORT AND KNOW THAT
04:19:54.712 --> 04:19:55.846
WE ARE ALREADY IN THE LA
04:19:55.913 --> 04:19:56.948
EXPLAINED PATHWAY.
04:19:57.014 --> 04:19:58.582
SO TONS OF PARTICULATE MATTER
04:19:58.649 --> 04:19:59.917
FALLS IN OUR COMMUNITY IN
04:19:59.984 --> 04:20:01.852
ADDITION TO THE NOISE POLLUTION.
04:20:01.919 --> 04:20:03.421
AT THIS ARENA WILL BECAUSE THERE
04:20:03.487 --> 04:20:05.089
MAY BE VERY LITTLE THAT THIS
04:20:05.156 --> 04:20:06.991
BODY CAN DO TO MITIGATE --
04:20:07.058 --> 04:20:07.525
AIR POLLUTION CONCERNS AND
04:20:07.591 --> 04:20:09.360
TRAFFIC CONCERNS.
04:20:09.427 --> 04:20:11.162
AS WE'VE ALREADY SEEN NOW.
04:20:11.228 --> 04:20:12.964
WITH TWO OTHER STADIUMS AND A
04:20:13.030 --> 04:20:14.899
RENT WHAT WITH ONE ADDITIONAL
04:20:14.966 --> 04:20:15.533
ARENA AND ANOTHER STADIUM IN THE
04:20:15.599 --> 04:20:16.600
AREA.
04:20:16.667 --> 04:20:18.636
TRAFFIC IS ALREADY EXACERBATED
04:20:18.703 --> 04:20:20.104
IT IS LITERALLY DOUBLE THE
04:20:20.171 --> 04:20:21.539
COMMUTE THAT I TAKE TO DROP MY
04:20:21.605 --> 04:20:22.773
SON OFF AT SCHOOL.
04:20:22.840 --> 04:20:24.842
WITHIN TWO MILES IT IS WENT FROM
04:20:24.909 --> 04:20:26.410
TWENTY MINUTES ALMOST. FORTY
04:20:26.477 --> 04:20:28.446
FORTY FIVE MINUTE SO THERE'S
04:20:28.512 --> 04:20:29.447
DEEP TRAFFIC CONCERNS PEOPLE
04:20:29.513 --> 04:20:31.349
HAVE OUR COMMUNITY.
04:20:31.415 --> 04:20:32.583
SOME DETAILS WE ALSO THIS BILL
04:20:32.650 --> 04:20:33.718
THAT IS LIMITATION OF PUBLIC
04:20:33.784 --> 04:20:35.152
PARTICIPATION.
04:20:35.219 --> 04:20:36.754
AND I AB IN NINE HUNDRED EARLY
04:20:36.821 --> 04:20:37.822
ALLOWS FOR THIS AND SO WE DON'T
04:20:37.888 --> 04:20:39.991
SEE THE NEED. FOR EXPEDITING
04:20:40.057 --> 04:20:42.626
THIS BILL WHEN THERE'S LITERALLY.
04:20:42.693 --> 04:20:44.996
SIX HERE TO GET THIS THING DONE.
04:20:45.062 --> 04:20:46.864
I AND THEN FINALLY THIS
04:20:46.931 --> 04:20:48.099
LEGISLATURE IS VOTING DOWN
04:20:48.165 --> 04:20:50.701
SEQUEL EXEMPTION FROM HOUSING
04:20:50.768 --> 04:20:51.002
[inaudible]
04:20:51.068 --> 04:20:52.737
HOW CAN?
04:20:52.803 --> 04:20:54.572
A SEQUEL EXEMPTION FOR AN ARENA
04:20:54.638 --> 04:20:55.706
IN THE MIST OF A HOUSING CRISIS
04:20:55.773 --> 04:20:57.441
BE APPROVED.
04:20:57.508 --> 04:20:59.110
WHEN THIS BODY IS ACTUALLY
04:20:59.176 --> 04:21:01.012
VOTING DOWN EXEMPTIONS TO BUILD
04:21:01.078 --> 04:21:02.179
HOUSING FOR COMMUNITIES TO MAKES
04:21:02.246 --> 04:21:03.714
NO SENSE?
04:21:03.781 --> 04:21:05.883
SO ARE ON BEHALF OF OUR
04:21:05.950 --> 04:21:06.717
COALITION ARE COMMITTEE WE
04:21:06.784 --> 04:21:08.252
STRONGLY OPPOSE [inaudible]
04:21:08.319 --> 04:21:11.255
OTHER SUPPOSED.
04:21:11.322 --> 04:21:11.922
YEAH I'M JUST SO EVERYBODY MEAN
04:21:11.989 --> 04:21:13.224
I I APPRECIATE PEOPLE OF COME
04:21:13.290 --> 04:21:14.492
HERE.
04:21:14.558 --> 04:21:16.260
UNDER THE NINE HUNDRED
04:21:16.327 --> 04:21:17.395
LEADERSHIP --
04:21:17.461 --> 04:21:19.196
I STREAMLINING AND WILL TALK WE
04:21:19.263 --> 04:21:20.865
CIC JUDICIAL COUNCIL IN FOLKS
04:21:20.931 --> 04:21:22.867
THERE THIS IS WHICH IS WHAT
04:21:22.933 --> 04:21:25.302
WE'RE OUR DISCUSSION HAD THE
04:21:25.369 --> 04:21:27.204
PREVIOUS IS GONE AND IT'S THIS
04:21:27.271 --> 04:21:28.606
STREAMLINING CAN INCLUDE
04:21:28.672 --> 04:21:30.408
RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL AND A
04:21:30.474 --> 04:21:31.642
STADIUM OR WHATEVER IT IS
04:21:31.709 --> 04:21:32.943
JUSTICE.
04:21:33.010 --> 04:21:34.745
WE'RE NOT.
04:21:34.812 --> 04:21:36.147
IS NOT MY BUILT THIS IS WE'RE
04:21:36.213 --> 04:21:37.782
LOOKING AT THE PROCESSES AND
04:21:37.848 --> 04:21:39.150
SOME OF THE ANALYSIS THAT WE'RE
04:21:39.216 --> 04:21:41.318
GOING THROUGH IS WHY IS IT NOT
04:21:41.385 --> 04:21:43.354
LIKE AB NINE HUNDRED AND THAT
04:21:43.421 --> 04:21:45.089
WOULD INCLUDE OTHER USES THAT.
04:21:45.156 --> 04:21:48.059
THE CHOICE OF THE USES IS.
04:21:48.125 --> 04:21:49.794
UP FOR GRABS RIGHT BUT BID LEASE
04:21:49.860 --> 04:21:51.562
THE ANALYSIS THAT WE'RE DOING ON
04:21:51.629 --> 04:21:55.599
ON WHAT IT THE DISCLOSURE IS AN
04:21:55.666 --> 04:21:56.967
ENVIRONMENTAL --
04:21:57.034 --> 04:21:59.103
TRADEOFFS ARE ARE THERE SO.
04:21:59.170 --> 04:22:03.908
I'VE NEXT WITNESS.
04:22:03.974 --> 04:22:05.176
WAY OF LIFE AMEND WATKINS FOR
04:22:05.242 --> 04:22:07.211
MSG FORUM.
04:22:07.278 --> 04:22:09.914
THE MYSTERY FORUM OPPOSES AB.
04:22:09.980 --> 04:22:10.581
NINE EIGHTY SEVEN IN ADDITION TO
04:22:10.648 --> 04:22:11.916
THE SERIOUS CONCERN FOR USE BY
04:22:11.982 --> 04:22:13.617
OTHERS I WANT TO EMPHASIZE THAT
04:22:13.684 --> 04:22:16.387
THIS BILL MAKES A SHAM OF SEQUEL.
04:22:16.454 --> 04:22:17.488
THIS BILL DOES NOT JUST
04:22:17.555 --> 04:22:19.390
STREAMLINED THE PROCESS IT
04:22:19.457 --> 04:22:20.691
REDUCES THE ANALYSIS REQUIRED IN
04:22:20.758 --> 04:22:22.526
THE AYE ARE.
04:22:22.593 --> 04:22:23.561
IT TAKES AWAY THE POWER OF THE
04:22:23.627 --> 04:22:25.029
COURT TO FASHION A REMEDY IF THE
04:22:25.096 --> 04:22:26.864
IRS WRONG.
04:22:26.931 --> 04:22:28.666
IT CUTS OFF PUBLIC COMMENT.
04:22:28.732 --> 04:22:30.267
AND IT APPLIES TO AN UNSPECIFIED
04:22:30.334 --> 04:22:31.802
PROJECT AS WRITTEN A COULD
04:22:31.869 --> 04:22:33.838
PERMIT OVER THIRTY THREE THIRTY
04:22:33.904 --> 04:22:34.872
MILLION SQUARE FEET OF UNKNOWN
04:22:34.939 --> 04:22:37.007
USES.
04:22:37.074 --> 04:22:39.276
THE CITY HAS SAID THE PROPOSED
04:22:39.343 --> 04:22:40.478
ARENA DESERVES THE SAME
04:22:40.544 --> 04:22:42.213
LEGISLATIVE PROTECTIONS SPORTS
04:22:42.279 --> 04:22:44.348
VENUES RECEIVED.
04:22:44.415 --> 04:22:45.950
AB NINE HUNDRED IS GOOD ENOUGH
04:22:46.016 --> 04:22:48.319
FOR OTHER CITIES AND VENUES WHY
04:22:48.385 --> 04:22:48.953
IS IT NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR ANGLE
04:22:49.019 --> 04:22:50.421
WENT.
04:22:50.488 --> 04:22:51.889
AB NINE HUNDRED STREAMLINES THE
04:22:51.956 --> 04:22:53.491
PROCESS WITHOUT REMOVING
04:22:53.557 --> 04:22:55.726
PROTECTIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY.
04:22:55.793 --> 04:22:56.994
AS THE LEGISLATIVE ANALYSIS
04:22:57.061 --> 04:22:58.829
SHOWS THIS BILL GOES WELL BEYOND
04:22:58.896 --> 04:23:03.067
AB.
04:23:03.134 --> 04:23:03.868
NINE HUNDRED WE NOTE THAT THERE
04:23:03.934 --> 04:23:05.369
SIGNIFICANT COMMUNITY OPPOSITION
04:23:05.436 --> 04:23:07.138
AND THAT THREE LAWSUITS HAVE
04:23:07.204 --> 04:23:07.705
BEEN FILED CHALLENGING THIS
04:23:07.771 --> 04:23:09.540
PROJECT.
04:23:09.607 --> 04:23:10.841
EMISHI FORUM IS AN ACTIVE
04:23:10.908 --> 04:23:12.877
LITIGATION WITH THE CITY OVER
04:23:12.943 --> 04:23:13.911
THE PROPOSED ARENA PROPERTY AND
04:23:13.978 --> 04:23:15.045
THE CITY'S FAILURE TO PROVIDE
04:23:15.112 --> 04:23:16.514
PUBLIC DOCUMENTS.
04:23:16.580 --> 04:23:18.149
AS DETAILED IN THE COMPLAINT THE
04:23:18.215 --> 04:23:19.350
CITY BREACHED ITS AGREEMENTS
04:23:19.416 --> 04:23:20.651
WITH THE MYSTERY FORUM IN ORDER
04:23:20.718 --> 04:23:21.752
TO MAKE THE LAND AVAILABLE TO
04:23:21.819 --> 04:23:23.654
THE CLIPPERS FOR AN ARENA.
04:23:23.721 --> 04:23:25.422
THE RIGHTS OF EXISTING
04:23:25.489 --> 04:23:27.024
BUSINESSES AND RESIDENTS HAVE
04:23:27.091 --> 04:23:28.159
BEEN INGLEWOOD SHOULD NOT BE
04:23:28.225 --> 04:23:30.728
TRAMPLED UNNECESSARILY FAST
04:23:30.794 --> 04:23:32.062
TRACK AND ARENA.
04:23:32.129 --> 04:23:33.297
AS A LEGISLATIVE ANALYSIS
04:23:33.364 --> 04:23:37.101
EXPLAINS THE CLIPPERS HAVE UNTIL
04:23:37.168 --> 04:23:37.701
TWENTY TWENTY FOUR PLENTY OF
04:23:37.768 --> 04:23:40.204
TIME TO COMPLY WITH AB.
04:23:40.271 --> 04:23:41.405
NINE HUNDRED AND IN THE SIX
04:23:41.472 --> 04:23:42.973
YEARS THAT WERE LAID OUT AS I
04:23:43.040 --> 04:23:44.108
UNDERSTOOD IT IT'S JUST THAT
04:23:44.175 --> 04:23:45.943
THERE WAS TWO YEARS OF COMMUNITY
04:23:46.010 --> 04:23:47.678
INPUT IN TWO YEARS OF THE I. R..
04:23:47.745 --> 04:23:48.712
AND TWO YEARS OF CONSTRUCTION
04:23:48.779 --> 04:23:50.714
BUT THE OUR PROCESS STARTED AND
04:23:50.781 --> 04:23:53.384
AND P. HAS BEEN ALREADY
04:23:53.450 --> 04:23:55.386
PUBLISHED FOR THIS PROJECT SO.
04:23:55.452 --> 04:23:55.986
BOB STARTED IN THERE SIX YEARS
04:23:56.053 --> 04:23:56.387
TO GO [inaudible]
04:23:56.453 --> 04:24:00.191
THANK YOU OKAY NECKS.
04:24:00.257 --> 04:24:01.058
GOOD AFTERNOON HONORABLE
04:24:01.125 --> 04:24:02.760
CHAIRMAN AND HONORABLE COMMITTEE
04:24:02.826 --> 04:24:03.861
MEMBERS MY NAME IS DOUGLAS
04:24:03.928 --> 04:24:05.563
CARSTEN SIMON ATTORNEY WHICH AT
04:24:05.629 --> 04:24:07.431
BROWN CARSTENSZ AND WE REPRESENT.
04:24:07.498 --> 04:24:09.099
THE INGLEWOOD RESIDENTS AGAINST
04:24:09.166 --> 04:24:10.768
TAKINGS AND EVICTIONS AND WE
04:24:10.834 --> 04:24:12.002
SUBMITTED A LETTER TO THE
04:24:12.069 --> 04:24:14.071
COMMITTEE I APPRECIATE THE
04:24:14.138 --> 04:24:15.573
CONSIDERATION OF IT.
04:24:15.639 --> 04:24:17.141
I ALSO REALLY APPRECIATED THE
04:24:17.208 --> 04:24:18.309
CHAIRMAN'S REMARKS RIGHT AT THE
04:24:18.375 --> 04:24:20.277
BEGINNING OF THIS AGENDA ABOUT
04:24:20.344 --> 04:24:21.512
FOUR HOURS AGO WISH I COULD
04:24:21.579 --> 04:24:23.914
REPEAT EVERY WORD ABOUT SEQUEL.
04:24:23.981 --> 04:24:26.984
SEQUEL IS AN ENVIRONMENTAL --
04:24:27.051 --> 04:24:28.152
IT'S A BILL OF RIGHTS FOR
04:24:28.219 --> 04:24:30.120
ENVIRONMENTAL DEMOCRACY IS THE
04:24:30.187 --> 04:24:31.789
PREMIER ENVIRONMENTAL LAW OF
04:24:31.855 --> 04:24:34.558
CALIFORNIA IN SO WE UTTERLY
04:24:34.625 --> 04:24:35.893
OPPOSE AN EXEMPTION --
04:24:35.960 --> 04:24:38.395
TO THIS --
04:24:38.462 --> 04:24:39.597
THERE WAS A CONSIDERATION OF A
04:24:39.663 --> 04:24:41.031
VERY SIMILAR BILL AND I THINK
04:24:41.098 --> 04:24:42.166
IT'S MENTIONED IN THE STAFF
04:24:42.233 --> 04:24:44.568
REPORT IT WAS BACK IN SEPTEMBER
04:24:44.635 --> 04:24:46.470
OF LAST YEAR AND THERE WAS THE
04:24:46.537 --> 04:24:48.739
ASSEMBLY MEMBER NAY MURATSUCHI
04:24:48.806 --> 04:24:49.873
WHO IS ACTUALLY MY ASSEMBLY
04:24:49.940 --> 04:24:51.308
MEMBER AND I'M VERY PROUD OF HIM
04:24:51.375 --> 04:24:52.710
AT LIKE THREE TWO SENTENCES.
04:24:52.776 --> 04:24:54.211
FROM HIS TESTIMONY IT IS VERY
04:24:54.278 --> 04:24:55.379
RELEVANT TODAY.
04:24:55.446 --> 04:24:56.814
HE SAID THAT THE PROPONENT OF
04:24:56.880 --> 04:24:58.716
THAT BILL WHICH WAS SEVENTY NINE
04:24:58.782 --> 04:25:00.217
WHICH IS VERY SIMILAR TO NINETY
04:25:00.284 --> 04:25:01.018
SEVEN EVEN THE NUMBERS ARE THE
04:25:01.085 --> 04:25:01.785
SAME LITTLE DISLIKED BUT IT'S
04:25:01.852 --> 04:25:03.087
THE SAME.
04:25:03.153 --> 04:25:04.488
HE SAID THE PROPONENT TALKED
04:25:04.555 --> 04:25:05.656
ABOUT HOW THIS IS A SPECIAL
04:25:05.723 --> 04:25:07.391
PROJECT ESPECIALLY BECAUSE IT'S
04:25:07.458 --> 04:25:09.026
GOING TO BE BENEFITING IT'S
04:25:09.093 --> 04:25:10.327
GOING TO BE AND INVESTMENT IN
04:25:10.394 --> 04:25:11.862
THE BLACK AND BROWN COMMUNITY.
04:25:11.929 --> 04:25:13.230
BUT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THE
04:25:13.297 --> 04:25:14.965
CIVIL RIGHTS OF THE BLACK AND
04:25:15.032 --> 04:25:16.467
BROWN COMMUNITY THAT SECRET
04:25:16.533 --> 04:25:18.802
PROVIDES I COMMEND YOU SIR THE
04:25:18.869 --> 04:25:20.371
PROJECT PROPONENT. FOR WHAT
04:25:20.437 --> 04:25:22.139
YOU'RE TRYING TO DO TO BRING
04:25:22.206 --> 04:25:23.340
FURTHER INVESTMENT AND JOB
04:25:23.407 --> 04:25:25.075
CREATION IN YOUR COMMUNITY BUT I
04:25:25.142 --> 04:25:27.278
DO SEE SEQUEL AS A CIVIL RIGHT
04:25:27.344 --> 04:25:29.280
THAT YOUR COMMUNITY DESERVES TO
04:25:29.346 --> 04:25:31.448
HAVE TO PROTECT YOUR COMMUNITY.
04:25:31.515 --> 04:25:32.082
VERY POWERFUL TESTIMONY I
04:25:32.149 --> 04:25:34.618
THOUGHT AMONG THAT --
04:25:34.685 --> 04:25:36.754
ASSEMBLY --
04:25:36.820 --> 04:25:39.290
NATURAL RESOURCES A HEARING THAT
04:25:39.356 --> 04:25:40.958
IN PARTICULAR DESERVE MENTION.
04:25:41.025 --> 04:25:42.693
THERE WAS IN THE STAFF REPORT
04:25:42.760 --> 04:25:44.762
WHICH IS VERY THOROUGH AND VERY
04:25:44.828 --> 04:25:46.697
A DETAILED ANALYTICAL INSIGHT
04:25:46.764 --> 04:25:47.665
FALL.
04:25:47.731 --> 04:25:49.400
A COMPARISON WITH AB NINE
04:25:49.466 --> 04:25:50.401
HUNDRED I UNDERSTAND A LOT OF
04:25:50.467 --> 04:25:52.403
THESE AMENDMENTS WILL BE FIXING
04:25:52.469 --> 04:25:53.904
OR AMENDING THIS BILL TO BECOME
04:25:53.971 --> 04:25:55.539
MORE LIKE AB NINE HUNDRED SO
04:25:55.606 --> 04:25:57.274
THAT REASONS THE QUESTION WHY
04:25:57.341 --> 04:25:59.043
NOT RELY ON A. B..
04:25:59.109 --> 04:25:59.910
NINE HUNDRED THAT WAS A VERY
04:25:59.977 --> 04:26:01.879
HARD FOUGHT BILL IT WAS YOU KNOW
04:26:01.945 --> 04:26:03.614
WENT THROUGH THE PROCESS AND
04:26:03.681 --> 04:26:05.616
IT'S BEEN IMPLEMENTED BY ABOUT
04:26:05.683 --> 04:26:06.483
ELEVEN PROJECTS.
04:26:06.550 --> 04:26:08.519
IN ITS HISTORY SINCE TWO
04:26:08.585 --> 04:26:09.620
THOUSAND AND ELEVEN SO IT'S A
04:26:09.687 --> 04:26:11.488
VERY EFFECTIVE BILL FOR THESE
04:26:11.555 --> 04:26:13.724
LARGE PROJECTS IN IN PROVIDING A
04:26:13.791 --> 04:26:16.026
REVIEW AND AND EXEMPTION.
04:26:16.093 --> 04:26:17.895
SPECIAL LEGISLATION LIKE THIS IS
04:26:17.961 --> 04:26:19.897
NOT NECESSARY WE RESPECTFULLY
04:26:19.963 --> 04:26:21.999
ASK THAT YOU VOTE NO ON THIS I
04:26:22.066 --> 04:26:22.599
THINK YOU FOR YOUR TIME THANK
04:26:22.666 --> 04:26:23.667
YOU.
04:26:23.734 --> 04:26:26.937
AND THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL.
04:26:27.004 --> 04:26:28.305
JERRY MEMBERS DAMPEN FOR THE
04:26:28.372 --> 04:26:29.973
JUDICIAL COUNCIL.
04:26:30.040 --> 04:26:31.575
NOT WITHSTANDING MY GREAT
04:26:31.642 --> 04:26:33.744
FONDNESS FOR THE FIFTH DIMENSION.
04:26:33.811 --> 04:26:36.447
I'M HERE IN OPPOSITION. TO TWO
04:26:36.513 --> 04:26:37.548
THIS BILL.
04:26:37.614 --> 04:26:38.449
I'M NOT GONNA REPEAT ALL THE
04:26:38.515 --> 04:26:40.818
TESTIMONY THAT I GAVE ON SEVEN
04:26:40.884 --> 04:26:41.251
THIRTY FOUR EARLIER
04:26:41.318 --> 04:26:42.419
UNFORTUNATELY THE CHAIR.
04:26:42.486 --> 04:26:43.787
WITH ABSENT DURING THAT TIME BUT
04:26:43.854 --> 04:26:45.089
YOU'VE HEARD ME IN THE PAST ON
04:26:45.155 --> 04:26:47.491
VERY SIMILAR BILL THIRTY TWO
04:26:47.558 --> 04:26:48.692
TIMES OR UP.
04:26:48.759 --> 04:26:50.194
THIRTY WHAT I INDICATED IS THAT
04:26:50.260 --> 04:26:52.763
AT LEAST ACCORDING TO OUR CALVET
04:26:52.830 --> 04:26:54.932
SINCE TWENTY ELEVEN WHEN A. B..
04:26:54.998 --> 04:26:55.833
NINE HUNDRED S. B. TO NINETY TO
04:26:55.899 --> 04:26:59.069
WEAR PASSWORD NOW IT BILL NUMBER --
04:26:59.136 --> 04:26:59.870
THIRTY FOUR IN ADDITION TO THE
04:26:59.937 --> 04:27:01.605
IT AND OTHER BILLION BECAUSE
04:27:01.672 --> 04:27:02.973
HEARING LATER THIS AFTERNOON.
04:27:03.040 --> 04:27:04.842
I'M SO LET ME JUST FOCUS ON A
04:27:04.908 --> 04:27:06.877
COUPLE OF QUICK POINTS.
04:27:06.944 --> 04:27:08.979
SOME ONE AND AS WAS MENTIONED BY
04:27:09.046 --> 04:27:10.347
A COUPLE OF OTHERS THIS BILL
04:27:10.414 --> 04:27:11.882
DOES RETAIN.
04:27:11.949 --> 04:27:12.549
THE LIMITS ON THE COURT'S
04:27:12.616 --> 04:27:14.685
ABILITY TO ISSUE INJUNCTIVE
04:27:14.752 --> 04:27:15.319
RELIEF THAT WERE TAKEN OUT OF A.
04:27:15.386 --> 04:27:19.056
B.. SEVEN THIRTY FOUR AND M. AND
04:27:19.123 --> 04:27:20.391
WHAT THAT MEANS IS THAT
04:27:20.457 --> 04:27:21.692
REGARDLESS OF THE FACTUAL
04:27:21.759 --> 04:27:22.960
FINDINGS OF THE COURT IN THE
04:27:23.026 --> 04:27:24.395
INDIVIDUAL CASE WHICH ARE
04:27:24.461 --> 04:27:26.130
USUALLY VERY TARGETED BASED ON
04:27:26.196 --> 04:27:26.563
SOME.
04:27:26.630 --> 04:27:28.432
PARTICULAR DEFECTS IN THE
04:27:28.499 --> 04:27:30.367
PROCESS THE COURT HAS TO IGNORE
04:27:30.434 --> 04:27:32.536
THOSE FACTS AND THE LAW AND CAN
04:27:32.603 --> 04:27:34.805
ONLY ISSUE AN INJUNCTION IF IT
04:27:34.872 --> 04:27:35.906
IF THE PROJECT WOULD INERFERE
04:27:35.973 --> 04:27:37.541
WITH THAT CREATED IMMINENT
04:27:37.608 --> 04:27:38.776
THREAT OF HARM TO THE PUBLIC
04:27:38.842 --> 04:27:39.009
HEALTH.
04:27:39.076 --> 04:27:39.710
OR INTERFERE WITH NATIVE
04:27:39.777 --> 04:27:42.513
AMERICAN ARTIFACTS WHICH IS --
04:27:42.579 --> 04:27:44.915
AND SECONDLY THAT GUARANTEED OR
04:27:44.982 --> 04:27:47.751
THE CERTAINTY THAT IS BEING
04:27:47.818 --> 04:27:49.920
DESIRED BY THE PROPONENTS OF THE
04:27:49.987 --> 04:27:51.488
SCHEME I WOULD RESPECTFULLY
04:27:51.555 --> 04:27:53.624
SUBMIT SIMPLY DOES NOT EXIST AS
04:27:53.690 --> 04:27:54.625
WAS MENTIONED.
04:27:54.691 --> 04:27:55.993
THERE ARE SEVERAL OTHER PENDING
04:27:56.059 --> 04:27:58.162
LAWSUITS AGAINST THIS PARTICULAR
04:27:58.228 --> 04:27:59.863
PROJECT PROJECTS LIKE THIS
04:27:59.930 --> 04:28:01.365
USUALLY ARE.
04:28:01.432 --> 04:28:02.166
CONTENTIOUS AND HEAVILY
04:28:02.232 --> 04:28:03.667
LITIGATED IF THERE'S ANY
04:28:03.734 --> 04:28:05.369
LITIGATION THAT DOESN'T SUE AND
04:28:05.436 --> 04:28:07.304
ALL OF THOSE OTHER CASES WITH
04:28:07.371 --> 04:28:08.472
ALL OF THE OTHER CAUSES OF
04:28:08.539 --> 04:28:09.373
ACTION.
04:28:09.440 --> 04:28:10.340
WE'RE GONNA PROCEED UNDER THE
04:28:10.407 --> 04:28:11.942
NORMAL TIME LINES AND ONLY THE
04:28:12.009 --> 04:28:13.343
SEQUEL PORTION.
04:28:13.410 --> 04:28:15.045
OF THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE THE
04:28:15.112 --> 04:28:16.880
SUPER ACCELERATED TIMELINE AS
04:28:16.947 --> 04:28:18.615
YOU'VE HEARD ME SAY MANY TIMES.
04:28:18.682 --> 04:28:21.051
I'M WILD I'M SURE THIS IS A VERY --
04:28:21.118 --> 04:28:22.352
BEYOND NOT COMMENTINGON THE
04:28:22.419 --> 04:28:23.987
PROJECT IT MADE.
04:28:24.054 --> 04:28:26.657
BE VERY WELL YOU HAVE LOTS OF
04:28:26.723 --> 04:28:27.825
MERITS IN CREATE LOTS OF JOBS
04:28:27.891 --> 04:28:29.560
AND SO FORTH BUT WHAT YOU DO
04:28:29.626 --> 04:28:31.195
WHEN YOU CREATE A SUPER
04:28:31.261 --> 04:28:32.696
ACCELERATED SCHEME LIKE THIS.
04:28:32.763 --> 04:28:34.131
IS YOU SAY THAT TO ALL THE OTHER
04:28:34.198 --> 04:28:35.766
LITIGANTS WHO ARE WORKING THEIR
04:28:35.833 --> 04:28:37.401
WAY THROUGH OUR COURT DOCKETS
04:28:37.468 --> 04:28:37.901
THAT THEIR CASE IS LESS
04:28:37.968 --> 04:28:39.203
IMPORTANT.
04:28:39.269 --> 04:28:40.204
THAT THEY HAVE TO MOVE BACK IN
04:28:40.270 --> 04:28:41.472
LINE -- AND
04:28:41.538 --> 04:28:42.973
AND THAT THAT JUST FUNDAMENTALLY
04:28:43.040 --> 04:28:45.108
AT ODDS WITH OUR COURT SYSTEM
04:28:45.175 --> 04:28:46.710
THERE ARE GUIDING PRINCIPLE IN
04:28:46.777 --> 04:28:47.945
IT'S FOR THAT REASON THAT WE%
04:28:48.011 --> 04:28:49.880
HAVE BEEN IN OPPOSITION FOR THIS
04:28:49.947 --> 04:28:51.148
AND SIMILAR BILLS.
04:28:51.215 --> 04:28:52.683
OVER THIS LAST EIGHT YEARS.
04:28:52.749 --> 04:28:53.951
OKAY THANK YOU [inaudible]
04:28:54.017 --> 04:28:55.819
I'M.
04:28:55.886 --> 04:28:56.353
WE GET A CLOSE THE PUBLIC
04:28:56.420 --> 04:28:57.554
HEARING.
04:28:57.621 --> 04:28:59.723
BRING IT BACK TO THE DAY S..
04:28:59.790 --> 04:29:00.958
I'M LET'S HAVE SOME
04:29:01.024 --> 04:29:03.827
CLARIFICATION ON THE REPULSIVE
04:29:03.894 --> 04:29:06.497
BECAUSE AND AGAIN I'LL JUST
04:29:06.563 --> 04:29:07.831
REITERATE THERE'S BEEN
04:29:07.898 --> 04:29:09.032
DISCUSSIONS THERE'S BEEN
04:29:09.099 --> 04:29:12.369
DIFFERENT TRAPS OF OF OF CHANGES
04:29:12.436 --> 04:29:13.637
THAT WILL BE MADE TO OUR
04:29:13.704 --> 04:29:15.305
PROPOSED CHANGES WOULD BE
04:29:15.372 --> 04:29:17.341
AUTHORS AMENDMENTS TO TAKE IT.
04:29:17.407 --> 04:29:20.177
ON THE ISSUE OF THE INJUNCTIVE
04:29:20.244 --> 04:29:23.080
RELIEF OR THE A. B. NINE HUNDRED
04:29:23.146 --> 04:29:25.015
I STREAMLINING THAT WE JUST.
04:29:25.082 --> 04:29:26.984
DISCUSS THAT WAS ONE THING THAT
04:29:27.050 --> 04:29:28.752
WE FORGOT TO MENTION SO WE WANT
04:29:28.819 --> 04:29:30.053
TO AND IT HAS COME UP A COUPLE
04:29:30.120 --> 04:29:31.555
OF TIMES I THINK AND SOME OF THE
04:29:31.622 --> 04:29:32.823
PUBLIC COMMENT SO CERTAINLY ONE
04:29:32.890 --> 04:29:35.792
RESPOND TO THAT NOW.
04:29:35.859 --> 04:29:38.662
SO MISTER CHAIRMAN --
04:29:38.729 --> 04:29:40.397
THE REASON WE HAD REQUESTED THAT
04:29:40.464 --> 04:29:42.666
DETECTIVE RELIEF WHICH IS EXACT.
04:29:42.733 --> 04:29:43.700
DETECTIVE RELIEF THAT WAS
04:29:43.767 --> 04:29:44.902
GRANTED TO THE SACRAMENTO KINGS
04:29:44.968 --> 04:29:46.603
ARENA HERE.
04:29:46.670 --> 04:29:48.505
IS THAT AS DEMONSTRATED BY AT
04:29:48.572 --> 04:29:49.806
LEAST ONE OF OUR OPPONENTS WE
04:29:49.873 --> 04:29:52.509
HAVE VERY WELL FUNDED OPPONENTS
04:29:52.576 --> 04:29:54.444
AND THE CONCERN IS THAT BECAUSE
04:29:54.511 --> 04:29:56.747
OF THEIR SIGNIFICANT RESOURCES.
04:29:56.813 --> 04:29:59.583
THAT THEY WOULD IN FACT IN.
04:29:59.650 --> 04:30:01.552
DAY ONE IN THE SEQUEL.
04:30:01.618 --> 04:30:03.387
CHALLENGE PROCESS.
04:30:03.453 --> 04:30:05.088
SEE INJUNCTION TO STOP THE
04:30:05.155 --> 04:30:07.491
PROJECT.
04:30:07.558 --> 04:30:08.992
WHICH OTHERWISE WE WOULD TAKE
04:30:09.059 --> 04:30:11.562
THE RISK OF STARTING TO WORK ON
04:30:11.628 --> 04:30:13.330
IT DURING THE CHALLENGE BECAUSE
04:30:13.397 --> 04:30:15.165
WE COULD LOSE IN THE CHALLENGE
04:30:15.232 --> 04:30:15.465
[inaudible]
04:30:15.532 --> 04:30:17.367
HOWEVER --
04:30:17.434 --> 04:30:19.136
SEEING THAT IN THE PREVIOUS BILL
04:30:19.202 --> 04:30:22.639
DEALING WITH THE OAKLAND --
04:30:22.706 --> 04:30:23.907
A SMALL STADIUM [inaudible]
04:30:23.974 --> 04:30:25.676
THAT.
04:30:25.742 --> 04:30:27.044
AND UNDERSTANDING THEIR SPECIAL
04:30:27.110 --> 04:30:28.545
CONCERNS BEING SO CLOSE TO THE
04:30:28.612 --> 04:30:30.314
WATER IF IT'S A DESIRE THIS
04:30:30.380 --> 04:30:32.449
COMMITTEE THAT IN FACT WE SHOULD
04:30:32.516 --> 04:30:35.819
REMOVE INDUCTIVE RELIEF THE BILL --
04:30:35.886 --> 04:30:37.921
WE WOULD BE HAPPY TO DO THAT WE
04:30:37.988 --> 04:30:39.456
JUST WANT EVERYBODY TO
04:30:39.523 --> 04:30:40.490
UNDERSTAND WHAT THE NEED WAS
04:30:40.557 --> 04:30:41.725
BECAUSE WE HAVE A WELL FUNDED
04:30:41.792 --> 04:30:43.193
OPPONENT WHO WILL ATTEMPT TO USE
04:30:43.260 --> 04:30:43.393
THAT.
04:30:43.460 --> 04:30:46.229
BUT UNDERSTANDING THE WILL OF
04:30:46.296 --> 04:30:48.098
THE COMMITTEE IF IF IT'S IT'S AS
04:30:48.165 --> 04:30:50.667
I REMOVE IT WE WOULD REMOVE.
04:30:50.734 --> 04:30:52.836
SIR AT THAT ALSO LIKE TO POINT
04:30:52.903 --> 04:30:53.337
OUT THAT THERE IS NOT AN
04:30:53.403 --> 04:30:55.172
ACCURATE STATEMENT SPOKE OF THAT
04:30:55.238 --> 04:30:56.640
INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND IT CAN BE
04:30:56.707 --> 04:30:57.307
UNDER THIS BILL COULD BE ISSUE
04:30:57.374 --> 04:30:58.742
NOT JUST FOR PUBLIC HEALTH AND
04:30:58.809 --> 04:30:59.242
SAFETY THREATS OR NATIVE
04:30:59.309 --> 04:31:00.243
AMERICAN.
04:31:00.310 --> 04:31:01.044
THREATS TO NATIVE AMERICAN
04:31:01.111 --> 04:31:02.512
ARTIFACTS BUT ALSO.
04:31:02.579 --> 04:31:04.982
PRESS THE ECOLOGICAL RESOURCES
04:31:05.048 --> 04:31:05.849
ARCHAEOLOGICAL OUR HISTORICAL
04:31:05.916 --> 04:31:08.919
RESOURCES [inaudible]
04:31:08.986 --> 04:31:13.991
OKAY I'M. FOR CLARITY LET'S
04:31:14.057 --> 04:31:16.693
REMOVE THE INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND
04:31:16.760 --> 04:31:20.931
GO TO THE A. B.. NINE HUNDRED
04:31:20.998 --> 04:31:22.065
TWO HUNDRED AND SEVENTY DAYS
04:31:22.132 --> 04:31:24.835
STREAMLINED PROCESS WHICH THE
04:31:24.901 --> 04:31:26.837
JUDICIAL COUNCIL ACCORDS HATE
04:31:26.903 --> 04:31:28.305
BUT LEAST THEIR FAMILIAR WITH
04:31:28.372 --> 04:31:28.772
THAT.
04:31:28.839 --> 04:31:29.573
BY -- AND
04:31:29.640 --> 04:31:31.241
THEN THAT WOULD BE I THINK THAT
04:31:31.308 --> 04:31:32.643
THERE'S BEEN SOME CONCERNS BY
04:31:32.709 --> 04:31:33.777
SOME MEMBERS.
04:31:33.844 --> 04:31:35.379
COMMITTEE ON THAT ALAMAIN IS
04:31:35.445 --> 04:31:37.414
WEAK IS AYE WE PICK THROUGH AT
04:31:37.481 --> 04:31:40.183
LEAST HAVE SOME CLARITY.
04:31:40.250 --> 04:31:44.087
SENATOR YEAH SENTINEL.
04:31:44.154 --> 04:31:46.990
THE TIME PERIOD SPECIFIED UNDER.
04:31:47.057 --> 04:31:48.525
ACCUSE ME AB NINE HUNDRED DOES
04:31:48.592 --> 04:31:49.760
THAT THEN LINK FROM THE PUBLIC
04:31:49.826 --> 04:31:51.228
COMMENT PERIOD.
04:31:51.294 --> 04:31:52.396
THE TWO CONCERNS I WAS GONNA
04:31:52.462 --> 04:31:53.797
REYES WAS THE INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
04:31:53.864 --> 04:31:55.298
BUT YOU'VE DDRESSED THAT.
04:31:55.365 --> 04:31:57.434
IN THE OTHER WAS THAT RIGHT NOW
04:31:57.501 --> 04:31:59.036
THERE'S A THIRTY DAY LIMIT ON A
04:31:59.102 --> 04:32:00.470
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD WHEN I
04:32:00.537 --> 04:32:01.838
DIDN'T KNOW WHETHER WHAT YOU'RE
04:32:01.905 --> 04:32:03.573
SUGGESTING WOULD AUTOMATICALLY
04:32:03.640 --> 04:32:08.545
ADDRESS THAT.
04:32:08.612 --> 04:32:10.113
IF IT'S SOLID JEEZ I SHOULD HAVE
04:32:10.180 --> 04:32:11.615
SENATOR HILL HAD TO LEAVE AND
04:32:11.682 --> 04:32:13.283
THOSE WERE THE TWO ITEMS THAT HE
04:32:13.350 --> 04:32:15.385
ALSO WANTED TO BRING TO THE
04:32:15.452 --> 04:32:16.019
ATTENTION THAT HE WAS CONCERNED
04:32:16.086 --> 04:32:18.855
ABOUT.
04:32:18.922 --> 04:32:21.191
I'LL ASK THE AUTHOR ON THAT AND
04:32:21.258 --> 04:32:23.527
EXTENDED.
04:32:23.593 --> 04:32:24.094
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD WE'VE
04:32:24.161 --> 04:32:24.928
HEARD [inaudible]
04:32:24.995 --> 04:32:27.397
FOLKS.
04:32:27.464 --> 04:32:28.365
WHICH WE DIDN'T HEAR AN INDIE
04:32:28.432 --> 04:32:30.167
OAKLAND SITUATION WITH AT THEIR
04:32:30.233 --> 04:32:31.301
MAY BE PEOPLE OPPOSE ESTIMATES
04:32:31.368 --> 04:32:33.804
OAKLAND FOR GOD SAKES SO.
04:32:33.870 --> 04:32:36.106
THERE WILL BE PEOPLE OPPOSED.
04:32:36.173 --> 04:32:37.808
JUST LIKE HERE WELL FUNDED
04:32:37.874 --> 04:32:40.177
OPPOSITION THE NAME YOU NEED.
04:32:40.243 --> 04:32:41.745
I'M WE ARE CERTAINLY OPEN TO
04:32:41.812 --> 04:32:43.146
THOSE I THINK THAT WAS ONE OF
04:32:43.213 --> 04:32:45.348
THE REASONS WHY WE BROUGHT IT UP
04:32:45.415 --> 04:32:48.151
ESPECIALLY NOW UPON HEARING --
04:32:48.218 --> 04:32:50.053
SOME OF THE CONCERNS OUR RESUME
04:32:50.120 --> 04:32:52.222
RESONATING AROUND THE DIET --
04:32:52.289 --> 04:32:54.291
AND THAT'S I'M I THINK OF FLUID
04:32:54.357 --> 04:32:55.959
OPPORTUNITY FOR US TO BE
04:32:56.026 --> 04:32:57.661
RESPONSIVE TO THE CONCERNS THAT
04:32:57.728 --> 04:32:59.362
YOU'VE RAISED.
04:32:59.429 --> 04:32:59.963
RIGHT I MEAN I THINK I THINK
04:33:00.030 --> 04:33:01.364
THAT THE YOU KNOW WHAT THE
04:33:01.431 --> 04:33:02.933
PEOPLE WANT THE ASSURANCE WHEN
04:33:02.999 --> 04:33:04.568
WE LOOK AT THE SECRET PROCESSES
04:33:04.634 --> 04:33:06.069
THAT THERE'S THE ASSURANCE THAT
04:33:06.136 --> 04:33:08.438
PROJECT AS WE DESCRIBED IN THEY
04:33:08.505 --> 04:33:08.839
CAN.
04:33:08.905 --> 04:33:10.807
AFTER IF WE'VE SHOW NOTHING ELSE
04:33:10.874 --> 04:33:13.744
THE FIRST. THREE AND A HALF
04:33:13.810 --> 04:33:14.711
HOURS HERE WE LIVE A LOT OF
04:33:14.778 --> 04:33:15.779
PUBLIC COMMENT SIR YOU HAD A
04:33:15.846 --> 04:33:18.448
COMMENT ON YEAH JUST DONE ON THE
04:33:18.515 --> 04:33:19.649
WRITTEN COMMENTS JUST WANT TO
04:33:19.716 --> 04:33:21.618
CLARIFY THAT IT'S NOT THAT THAT.
04:33:21.685 --> 04:33:23.320
COMMENT PERIOD ENDS IT'S THAT.
04:33:23.386 --> 04:33:25.522
COMMENTS AFTER THE DRAFT DIR
04:33:25.589 --> 04:33:26.089
COMMENT PERIOD PEOPLE CAN'T
04:33:26.156 --> 04:33:28.191
SUBMIT COMMENTS THAT OTHERWISE
04:33:28.258 --> 04:33:29.593
COULD HAVE BEEN SUBMITTED ON THE
04:33:29.659 --> 04:33:31.094
SAME INFORMATION THAT WAS IN A
04:33:31.161 --> 04:33:32.596
DRAFTY ARE OF SOME WE HAD IF
04:33:32.662 --> 04:33:33.630
THERE'S A CHANGE TO THE PROJECT
04:33:33.697 --> 04:33:35.265
SOME HAS A COMMENT ON THAT IF
04:33:35.332 --> 04:33:36.900
THERE'S NEW INFORMATION --
04:33:36.967 --> 04:33:38.435
THERE'LL BE BUILT CONTINUE TO BE
04:33:38.502 --> 04:33:39.302
OPPORTUNITIES TO COMMENT ON NEW
04:33:39.369 --> 04:33:40.036
INFORMATION [inaudible]
04:33:40.103 --> 04:33:41.605
PAGE.
04:33:41.671 --> 04:33:43.273
FINALLY PART OF THE OPPOSITION
04:33:43.340 --> 04:33:45.475
WAS THE UNSPECIFIED NESS OF THE
04:33:45.542 --> 04:33:47.310
THE PROJECT.
04:33:47.377 --> 04:33:48.879
I MEAN I I CAN PULL UP MY BINDER
04:33:48.945 --> 04:33:51.314
FROM THE OAKLAND EIGHTIES --
04:33:51.381 --> 04:33:51.915
WHEN I WAS ON THE FREMONT CITY
04:33:51.982 --> 04:33:53.383
COUNCIL WITH?
04:33:53.450 --> 04:33:55.152
LOTS OF SEWER THERE'S WE'VE
04:33:55.218 --> 04:33:56.720
TALKED ABOUT IT WITH HAD
04:33:56.787 --> 04:33:57.754
CONCEPTUAL.
04:33:57.821 --> 04:33:59.623
DISCUSSIONS BUT WE DON'T HAVE AN
04:33:59.689 --> 04:34:02.125
IS A REYES WITH THE MISTER BONTA
04:34:02.192 --> 04:34:03.360
SAT I DON'T HAVE A PIECE OF
04:34:03.426 --> 04:34:04.828
PAPER OF WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE WHAT
04:34:04.895 --> 04:34:06.563
IT'S GOING TO BE WE'VE GONE BACK
04:34:06.630 --> 04:34:09.666
AND FORTH IN THE AB NINE HUNDRED
04:34:09.733 --> 04:34:10.901
PARADIGM IN THE BILL AS
04:34:10.967 --> 04:34:12.702
INTRODUCED AND HAD.
04:34:12.769 --> 04:34:13.336
THAT SORT OF BEEN MY FOCUS CAN
04:34:13.403 --> 04:34:15.772
YOU SHED SOME.
04:34:15.839 --> 04:34:17.641
WELL PART OF IT IS THAT --
04:34:17.707 --> 04:34:21.244
THE SPONSOR OF THIS BILL IS
04:34:21.311 --> 04:34:23.346
TRYING TO ACTUALLY BE RESPONSIVE
04:34:23.413 --> 04:34:24.648
AND INTERACTIVE TO END WITH THE
04:34:24.714 --> 04:34:25.615
COMMUNITY [inaudible]
04:34:25.682 --> 04:34:27.818
I THINK.
04:34:27.884 --> 04:34:28.985
A THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
04:34:29.052 --> 04:34:31.087
COMMUNITY BENEFITS THAT ARE A
04:34:31.154 --> 04:34:32.589
PART OF THIS --
04:34:32.656 --> 04:34:34.224
PROPOSAL IT'S NOT JUST TO
04:34:34.291 --> 04:34:35.525
DEVELOP A STATE OF THE ARTS
04:34:35.592 --> 04:34:36.626
ARENA --
04:34:36.693 --> 04:34:37.894
THAT WILL GENERATE JOBS BUT IT'S
04:34:37.961 --> 04:34:39.896
ALSO ABOUT PROVIDING A COMMUNITY
04:34:39.963 --> 04:34:42.065
CLINIC A COMMUNITY SPORTS CLINIC
04:34:42.132 --> 04:34:43.366
TO OFFER THE TRANSPORTATION
04:34:43.433 --> 04:34:44.734
MANAGEMENT PLAN THAT WAS
04:34:44.801 --> 04:34:46.703
MENTIONED EARLIER TO OFFER GREEN
04:34:46.770 --> 04:34:48.505
SPACE IN OPEN SPACE TO OFFER
04:34:48.572 --> 04:34:50.507
ACTIVITY SPACE THERE WILL BE
04:34:50.574 --> 04:34:54.344
OPPORTUNITIES FOR I'M RETAIL --
04:34:54.411 --> 04:34:56.179
AND AND OTHER ESTABLISHMENTS I
04:34:56.246 --> 04:34:58.081
THINK IT IS THE INTENT OF ALL OF
04:34:58.148 --> 04:34:58.882
US TO HAVE THOSE KINDS OF
04:34:58.949 --> 04:35:01.117
CONVERSATIONS WITH THE COMMUNITY
04:35:01.184 --> 04:35:03.453
TO FIGURE OUT WHAT.
04:35:03.520 --> 04:35:05.722
MAKES THE MOST SENSE IN TERMS OF
04:35:05.789 --> 04:35:07.724
WHAT THOSE OPPORTUNITIES ARE --
04:35:07.791 --> 04:35:09.426
BETTER AS I MENTIONED BEFORE.
04:35:09.492 --> 04:35:11.828
THIS IS -- A
04:35:11.895 --> 04:35:13.330
PARCEL OF LAND THAT IS NOT
04:35:13.396 --> 04:35:14.164
SUITED FOR RESIDENTIAL
04:35:14.231 --> 04:35:15.665
DEVELOPMENT IS DIRECTLY UNDER AN
04:35:15.732 --> 04:35:17.601
FAA FLIGHT PATH AND I WOULD NOT
04:35:17.667 --> 04:35:18.735
WANT -- TO
04:35:18.802 --> 04:35:21.504
SUPPORT QUITE FRANKLY SUGGESTING
04:35:21.571 --> 04:35:23.874
THAT YOU BUILD INCOME LOW INCOME
04:35:23.940 --> 04:35:24.507
OR MIDDLE INCOME HOUSING AND PUT
04:35:24.574 --> 04:35:26.276
BLACK AROUND PEOPLE FIGHT TO GET
04:35:26.343 --> 04:35:27.410
FEET UNDERNEATH WHERE PLANES ARE
04:35:27.477 --> 04:35:29.246
GOING THAT'S NOT ESPECIALLY IN
04:35:29.312 --> 04:35:31.882
EQ -- BODY
04:35:31.948 --> 04:35:33.183
THAT'S NOT THE KIND OF THING
04:35:33.250 --> 04:35:34.718
THAT I WANT TO SUPPORT BUT THERE
04:35:34.784 --> 04:35:36.453
ARE THOSE COMMUNITY BENEFITS
04:35:36.519 --> 04:35:37.787
THAT HAVE BEEN PROPOSED AND IT
04:35:37.854 --> 04:35:39.422
IS THE INTENT OF ALL OF US TO BE
04:35:39.489 --> 04:35:41.358
ENGAGED AND VERY INTERACTIVE AND
04:35:41.424 --> 04:35:43.493
ROBUST COMMUNITY CONVERSATIONS
04:35:43.560 --> 04:35:44.127
WITH THE COMMUNITY TO FIGURE OUT
04:35:44.194 --> 04:35:45.795
IN THE YOU KNOW.
04:35:45.862 --> 04:35:46.363
WHAT THAT ALL LOOKS LIKE FOR
04:35:46.429 --> 04:35:52.168
THEM FOR US --
04:35:52.235 --> 04:35:52.769
I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE IF
04:35:52.836 --> 04:35:56.873
THERE'S A SPECIFIC QUESTION --
04:35:56.940 --> 04:35:57.674
BECAUSE OF NEEDING TO GO THAT WE
04:35:57.741 --> 04:35:59.776
CALLED -- WE
04:35:59.843 --> 04:36:01.044
ARE IN THE PROCESS NOW THERE ARE
04:36:01.111 --> 04:36:02.946
TWO DIFFERENT DESIGNS BE.
04:36:03.013 --> 04:36:04.547
THAT'S WHY YOU DON'T HAVE WHAT
04:36:04.614 --> 04:36:06.650
OTHERWISE WOULD BE.
04:36:06.716 --> 04:36:08.718
REALLY DETAIL ARTISTS CONCEPTUAL
04:36:08.785 --> 04:36:10.053
DRAWINGS OF THE WE DO HAVE A
04:36:10.120 --> 04:36:11.922
SCHEMATIC OF HOW THE LAYOUT
04:36:11.988 --> 04:36:13.423
WOULD GO AND WHERE THE
04:36:13.490 --> 04:36:14.758
BASKETBALL COURTS THAT MEDICAL
04:36:14.824 --> 04:36:16.893
CLINIC WHERE THE PUBLIC FACILITY
04:36:16.960 --> 04:36:18.395
WITH -- AND
04:36:18.461 --> 04:36:20.530
WE CAN FURNISH THOSE.
04:36:20.597 --> 04:36:22.265
WE HAVE HOPE QUITE FRANKLY TO
04:36:22.332 --> 04:36:23.366
HAVE THE ARCHITECTURAL DRAWINGS
04:36:23.433 --> 04:36:26.002
READY FOR YOU AND UNFORTUNATELY.
04:36:26.069 --> 04:36:27.370
WITH THE DEBATE OVER THE TWO
04:36:27.437 --> 04:36:28.638
DIFFERENT DESIGNS TRYING TO
04:36:28.705 --> 04:36:30.840
EXCEED THE LEAD GOLD STANDARD
04:36:30.907 --> 04:36:32.642
WERE WERE DISTILLED DEBATING TO
04:36:32.709 --> 04:36:34.210
DECIDES CENTER STONE YOU HAVE
04:36:34.277 --> 04:36:38.148
QUESTION --
04:36:38.214 --> 04:36:39.382
TO SOME COMMENTS BECAUSE I
04:36:39.449 --> 04:36:40.850
PROBABLY GOT A CHANCE.
04:36:40.917 --> 04:36:41.584
TO SEE THIS --
04:36:41.651 --> 04:36:42.852
ASSUMING IT PASSES OUT HERE
04:36:42.919 --> 04:36:45.989
UNTIL THE FLOOR --
04:36:46.056 --> 04:36:48.758
YOU NO I KNOW FOR A FACT THAT --
04:36:48.825 --> 04:36:50.393
WHEN THE LAKERS LEFT INGLEWOOD
04:36:50.460 --> 04:36:52.162
YEARS AGO IT WAS FINANCIALLY
04:36:52.228 --> 04:36:52.929
DEVASTATING --
04:36:52.996 --> 04:36:55.398
FOR INGLEWOOD [inaudible]
04:36:55.465 --> 04:36:58.335
AND I CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND THE
04:36:58.401 --> 04:36:59.736
THE NEW OWNERS OF THE FORUM THAT
04:36:59.803 --> 04:37:01.237
WANT.
04:37:01.304 --> 04:37:04.207
TO OPPOSES THIS PROJECT.
04:37:04.274 --> 04:37:06.309
I ALSO APPRECIATE --
04:37:06.376 --> 04:37:08.478
MR BOMBER WHO I'M SURE --
04:37:08.545 --> 04:37:12.148
WAS THE BENEFICIARY OF MANY --
04:37:12.215 --> 04:37:15.852
REQUESTS TO MOVE THAT BALL CLUB --
04:37:15.919 --> 04:37:17.320
TO OTHER VENUES IN THE STATE AND
04:37:17.387 --> 04:37:19.155
MAYBE EVEN OUT OF STATE AND I
04:37:19.222 --> 04:37:21.658
REALLY APPLAUD HIM.
04:37:21.725 --> 04:37:23.460
AND GOING BACK TO INGLEWOOD.
04:37:23.526 --> 04:37:25.795
AND REINVIGORATING THE ECONOMY
04:37:25.862 --> 04:37:28.064
THERE IT'S TRUE THAT 68% OF THE
04:37:28.131 --> 04:37:29.599
PEOPLE THAT THERE'RE IN.
04:37:29.666 --> 04:37:32.836
A RENTAL UNITS --
04:37:32.902 --> 04:37:34.637
WE SEE YOU KNOW IN ADDITION TO
04:37:34.704 --> 04:37:35.872
THE TWO BILLION HE PAID FOR THE
04:37:35.939 --> 04:37:37.640
CAMERA BILLION HALF DOLLARS OR
04:37:37.707 --> 04:37:39.075
MORE TO BUILD THE STADIUM.
04:37:39.142 --> 04:37:41.244
ON LAND SOME OF WHICH IS
04:37:41.311 --> 04:37:42.879
PUBLICLY OWNED THAT'S NOT GONNA
04:37:42.946 --> 04:37:44.447
GO ON THE TAX ROLLS IS GOING TO
04:37:44.514 --> 04:37:46.249
CREATE HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF
04:37:46.316 --> 04:37:48.485
DOLLARS FOR LA COUNTY TO HELP.
04:37:48.551 --> 04:37:48.752
A BAIT --
04:37:48.818 --> 04:37:50.487
LOW INCOME.
04:37:50.553 --> 04:37:52.422
HOUSING ISSUES UP HOMELESS
04:37:52.489 --> 04:37:54.090
ISSUES NOT TO MENTION THE
04:37:54.157 --> 04:37:56.026
THOUSANDS OF JOBS.
04:37:56.092 --> 04:37:58.161
THEY'RE GONNA BE CREATED BUT BUT
04:37:58.228 --> 04:37:59.562
THIRD I THINK THE REASON WHY
04:37:59.629 --> 04:38:01.331
WE'RE SAYING THIS --
04:38:01.398 --> 04:38:03.967
SEAQUEST STREAMLINING --
04:38:04.034 --> 04:38:05.602
BILL -- IS
04:38:05.668 --> 04:38:08.304
NOT THAT THEY WANT.
04:38:08.371 --> 04:38:09.406
TO NOT GO THROUGH THE SECRET
04:38:09.472 --> 04:38:10.740
PROCESS WE'RE GOING TO GO.
04:38:10.807 --> 04:38:13.376
THROUGH THE SIMPLE PROCESS.
04:38:13.443 --> 04:38:16.012
BUT YOU HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THAT --
04:38:16.079 --> 04:38:17.947
MISTER BOMBER IN HIS.
04:38:18.014 --> 04:38:19.382
ASSOCIATES THESE ARE THESE ARE
04:38:19.449 --> 04:38:21.051
BUSINESS PEOPLE.
04:38:21.117 --> 04:38:21.684
THAT ARE GOING TO HAVE TO MAKE A
04:38:21.751 --> 04:38:23.153
DECISION.
04:38:23.219 --> 04:38:24.587
THE DECISION IS THEY'RE EITHER
04:38:24.654 --> 04:38:26.089
GOING TO RENEW THEIR LEASE AND
04:38:26.156 --> 04:38:26.923
ARE GETTING OFF ON THE
04:38:26.990 --> 04:38:28.324
ENVIRONMENT PAGEANTS CHAIR.
04:38:28.391 --> 04:38:29.325
THE THEY'RE GONNA HAVE TO RENEW
04:38:29.392 --> 04:38:31.995
THEIR LEASE OUT TO PROTECT THEIR
04:38:32.062 --> 04:38:33.396
THEIR FAN BASE IF YOU WILL --
04:38:33.463 --> 04:38:34.764
AT THE STAPLES CENTER OR THEY'RE
04:38:34.831 --> 04:38:35.565
GONNA HAVE TO MOVE IT SOMEWHERE
04:38:35.632 --> 04:38:37.500
ELSE.
04:38:37.567 --> 04:38:38.668
WEATHERBY INGLEWOOD OR WHETHER
04:38:38.735 --> 04:38:41.471
BE SOMEPLACE ELSE.
04:38:41.538 --> 04:38:42.572
I PREFER TO SEE IT IN A BILL
04:38:42.639 --> 04:38:44.441
WHICH I PREFER TO SEE IT IN.
04:38:44.507 --> 04:38:46.076
CALIFORNIA [inaudible]
04:38:46.142 --> 04:38:49.512
AND THIS IS A PRIVATELY FUNDED
04:38:49.579 --> 04:38:51.414
PROJECT.
04:38:51.481 --> 04:38:55.018
I APPRECIATE THE THE CONCERNS
04:38:55.085 --> 04:38:56.486
THAT THE SITE SHOULD BE BETTER
04:38:56.553 --> 04:38:59.055
SERVED TO BE --
04:38:59.122 --> 04:39:02.192
AFFORDABLE HOUSING --
04:39:02.258 --> 04:39:04.194
I AGREE WITH THE AUTHOR THAT.
04:39:04.260 --> 04:39:06.629
PUT A HOMES THERE.
04:39:06.696 --> 04:39:08.164
IN THE DIRECT FLIGHT PATH OF ONE
04:39:08.231 --> 04:39:09.032
OF THE BUSIEST AIRPORTS IN THE
04:39:09.099 --> 04:39:13.603
ENTIRE WORLD.
04:39:13.670 --> 04:39:14.170
IS NOT GOOD NOT ONLY FROM A
04:39:14.237 --> 04:39:14.804
NOISE STANDPOINT BUT FROM AN
04:39:14.871 --> 04:39:15.472
EMISSIONS STANDPOINT AND I DON'T
04:39:15.538 --> 04:39:17.640
THINK THAT WOULD --
04:39:17.707 --> 04:39:19.209
SURVIVE ANY KIND OF SECRET
04:39:19.275 --> 04:39:20.310
CHALLENGE TO TO PUT HOUSE THERE
04:39:20.376 --> 04:39:21.344
I THINK IT IS TO TOTALLY
04:39:21.411 --> 04:39:25.148
INAPPROPRIATE --
04:39:25.215 --> 04:39:26.149
THE FACT THAT THEIR OF THEIR
04:39:26.216 --> 04:39:28.418
BUILDING A LEAD LEAD CERTIFIED --
04:39:28.485 --> 04:39:31.187
FACILITY --
04:39:31.254 --> 04:39:32.322
ALL THEY'RE ASKING FOR IS A
04:39:32.388 --> 04:39:35.225
PARTNERSHIP THAT CAN LIMIT THEIR
04:39:35.291 --> 04:39:37.660
THEIR EXPOSURE BECAUSE AGAIN.
04:39:37.727 --> 04:39:38.294
ONE THING A BUSINESSMAN WANTS A
04:39:38.361 --> 04:39:39.796
SHIRT.
04:39:39.863 --> 04:39:40.630
AND I THINK WHEN YOU'RE
04:39:40.697 --> 04:39:42.365
INVESTING THIS KIND OF MONEY YOU
04:39:42.432 --> 04:39:44.033
WANT TO KNOW THAT THE GOAL POSTS
04:39:44.100 --> 04:39:44.901
ARE NOT GONNA BE MOVED ON
04:39:44.968 --> 04:39:46.035
YOURSELF AND FIND YOURSELF WITH
04:39:46.102 --> 04:39:47.303
NO HOME.
04:39:47.370 --> 04:39:48.271
THE TWO BILLION DOLLAR
04:39:48.338 --> 04:39:49.572
INVESTMENT IN THE TEAM WITH A
04:39:49.639 --> 04:39:50.874
VERY LOYAL FAN BASE IN LOS
04:39:50.940 --> 04:39:52.542
ANGELES COUNTY.
04:39:52.609 --> 04:39:54.511
SO FOR THOSE REASONS --
04:39:54.577 --> 04:39:56.246
I FIRST WANT TO APPLAUD THE
04:39:56.312 --> 04:39:57.647
AUTHOR FOR BRINGING FORWARD I
04:39:57.714 --> 04:39:59.983
APPRECIATE THE TESTIMONY OF THE
04:40:00.049 --> 04:40:01.417
PROPONENTS AND APPRECIATE THE
04:40:01.484 --> 04:40:03.353
TESTIMONY OF THE OPPONENTS.
04:40:03.419 --> 04:40:04.621
BUT I THINK THIS IS IN THE BEST
04:40:04.687 --> 04:40:05.788
INTERESTS OF NOT ONLY THE
04:40:05.855 --> 04:40:07.991
CITIZENS OF OF INGLEWOOD'S IS IN
04:40:08.057 --> 04:40:08.925
THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE
04:40:08.992 --> 04:40:11.261
CITIZENS OF CALIFORNIA.
04:40:11.327 --> 04:40:13.062
AND HAVING AND OUR ARMED A MAJOR.
04:40:13.129 --> 04:40:14.764
BASKETBALL FRANCHISE STAYING IN
04:40:14.831 --> 04:40:16.399
OUR STATE IN GOING BACK TO AN
04:40:16.466 --> 04:40:17.267
AREA.
04:40:17.333 --> 04:40:18.902
OF THAT ONCE HAD --
04:40:18.968 --> 04:40:21.905
FRANCHISES OF THIS MAGNITUDE.
04:40:21.971 --> 04:40:23.673
I THINK IT IS TREMENDOUS.
04:40:23.740 --> 04:40:25.175
PROVIDE TREMENDOUS BENEFIT SIDE
04:40:25.241 --> 04:40:26.809
YOU'RE NOT ONLY.
04:40:26.876 --> 04:40:28.511
PROVIDING ENTERTAINMENT --
04:40:28.578 --> 04:40:31.714
AND AND JOBS BUT THIS THE
04:40:31.781 --> 04:40:33.750
MULTIPLIER EFFECT OF OTHER JOBS
04:40:33.816 --> 04:40:34.384
THAT ARE GONNA HAVE TO BE THERE
04:40:34.450 --> 04:40:35.485
TO SUPPORT.
04:40:35.552 --> 04:40:36.953
AGAIN YOU OUT A COALITION OF
04:40:37.020 --> 04:40:38.521
LABOR THAT ARE GOING TO SEE
04:40:38.588 --> 04:40:40.089
THESE JOBS SAID YES THE MAYBE
04:40:40.156 --> 04:40:41.391
PART TIME BUT PART TIME FOR
04:40:41.457 --> 04:40:42.725
PROBABLY A FEW YEARS.
04:40:42.792 --> 04:40:43.626
IT'S GOING TO FULL TIME WORK FOR
04:40:43.693 --> 04:40:44.661
A FEW YEARS TO GET THIS
04:40:44.727 --> 04:40:45.728
BEAUTIFUL FACILITY BUILT
04:40:45.795 --> 04:40:46.029
[inaudible]
04:40:46.095 --> 04:40:47.997
AND SO.
04:40:48.064 --> 04:40:49.232
NOW I APPRECIATE THAT THE
04:40:49.299 --> 04:40:50.667
COMMENTS OF THE CHAIR.
04:40:50.733 --> 04:40:52.001
I'D LIKE TO MOVE THE BILL AND
04:40:52.068 --> 04:40:53.403
LIKE ASK THE AUTHOR FIGHT WE HAD
04:40:53.469 --> 04:40:57.640
IS A CO AUTHOR OF BEYOND.
04:40:57.707 --> 04:40:58.675
YEAH.
04:40:58.741 --> 04:41:01.811
IT IS LUDICROUS BECAUSE WE'RE
04:41:01.878 --> 04:41:06.149
TALKING ABOUT THIS HAVE TAKEN MY
04:41:06.216 --> 04:41:07.083
NO NO IT [inaudible]
04:41:07.150 --> 04:41:09.219
REALLY.
04:41:09.285 --> 04:41:11.621
HE'S GOT IT HE'S NOT AB THAT'S
04:41:11.688 --> 04:41:12.388
WHY SOMETHING ELSE IS
04:41:12.455 --> 04:41:13.723
CONTROLLING AT START.
04:41:13.790 --> 04:41:14.257
UP PAYS OR MAKE IT CLEAR
04:41:14.324 --> 04:41:14.857
PROVISIONS WERE TALKING ABOUT
04:41:14.924 --> 04:41:15.725
THIS AS REQUIRING A FULL III
04:41:15.792 --> 04:41:16.626
HARDER BUT IT REALLY DOESN'T
04:41:16.693 --> 04:41:17.560
BECAUSE IN TWO IMPORTANT AREAS
04:41:17.627 --> 04:41:18.795
WHICH IS TRAFFIC AND GHG.
04:41:18.861 --> 04:41:20.697
IF THE ERROR IS AN ADEQUATE OR
04:41:20.763 --> 04:41:22.765
DEFICIENT THAT'S JUST NOT FOUND
04:41:22.832 --> 04:41:25.802
TO BE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT YOU
04:41:25.868 --> 04:41:26.703
CAN'T YOU CAN MAKE THE COMMENT.
04:41:26.769 --> 04:41:28.137
BUT THE BILL SAYS THAT IT JUST
04:41:28.204 --> 04:41:29.305
WON'T BE DEEMED TO BE A
04:41:29.372 --> 04:41:31.007
SIGNIFICANT IMPACT SO THERE'S NO
04:41:31.074 --> 04:41:32.909
REAL TEETH OR MEANING TO THAT.
04:41:32.976 --> 04:41:34.177
SO I WOULD SEEM TO VERY
04:41:34.244 --> 04:41:35.645
SIGNIFICANT AREAS IT'S NOT
04:41:35.712 --> 04:41:37.947
REALLY TRULY AND FULLY ARE.
04:41:38.014 --> 04:41:39.415
AND EVEN THAT'S NOT CLEAR TO ME
04:41:39.482 --> 04:41:40.283
AS WE TALKED ABOUT THAT I
04:41:40.350 --> 04:41:42.385
MENTIONED UNSPECIFIED PROJECT
04:41:42.452 --> 04:41:43.886
THE BILL AS I'VE SEEN I HAVEN'T
04:41:43.953 --> 04:41:45.088
SEEN THE AMENDMENTS.
04:41:45.154 --> 04:41:46.456
ARE OVER THREE HUNDRED ACRES ARE
04:41:46.522 --> 04:41:48.691
COVERED BY THE BILL AND THERE'S
04:41:48.758 --> 04:41:50.159
BEEN DISCUSSION ABOUT THE TWENTY
04:41:50.226 --> 04:41:51.427
NINE ACRES ON WHICH THE ARENA IS
04:41:51.494 --> 04:41:52.929
SUPPOSED TO GO BUT NOT.
04:41:52.996 --> 04:41:54.797
THE BALANCE AND OF ANYTHING THAT
04:41:54.864 --> 04:41:55.999
CAN BE DONE THAT'S CONSISTENT
04:41:56.065 --> 04:42:00.069
WITH THE GENERAL PLAN IN. TWENTY
04:42:00.136 --> 04:42:00.637
TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN IT HAS
04:42:00.703 --> 04:42:02.272
BEEN FLOW IT LET'S HEAR FROM THE
04:42:02.338 --> 04:42:04.307
AUTHOR OR YOU'RE A SUPPORTERS ON
04:42:04.374 --> 04:42:09.145
THE ISSUE OF TRAFFIC AND
04:42:09.212 --> 04:42:10.246
GREENHOUSE GAS [inaudible]
04:42:10.313 --> 04:42:14.450
EMISSIONS [inaudible]
04:42:14.517 --> 04:42:16.486
SO GENERALLY.
04:42:16.552 --> 04:42:19.188
MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS --
04:42:19.255 --> 04:42:20.323
THOSE TWO ISSUES SORT OF DEALT
04:42:20.390 --> 04:42:21.391
WITH SEPARATELY THERE'S A
04:42:21.457 --> 04:42:24.193
TRAFFIC DEMAND MANAGEMENT.
04:42:24.260 --> 04:42:25.028
TRANSPORTATION DEMAND MANAGEMENT
04:42:25.094 --> 04:42:28.097
PLAN THAT WOULD REQUIRE THE 15%
04:42:28.164 --> 04:42:31.200
PERCENT REDUCTION OF VEHICLE
04:42:31.267 --> 04:42:33.303
TRIPS IN ADDITION.
04:42:33.369 --> 04:42:34.904
THE I ARE WOULD REQUIRE A
04:42:34.971 --> 04:42:37.340
TRAFFIC CONGESTION ANALYSIS IT
04:42:37.407 --> 04:42:39.309
WILL BE PART OF OF WHAT'S DONE
04:42:39.375 --> 04:42:40.009
SO.
04:42:40.076 --> 04:42:41.311
IN THAT REGARD WE'RE LOOKING AT
04:42:41.377 --> 04:42:44.180
TRAFFIC AND REDUCING THE VEHICLE
04:42:44.247 --> 04:42:45.148
TRIPS THAT WERE PUTTING THAT IN
04:42:45.214 --> 04:42:47.150
THE BILL.
04:42:47.216 --> 04:42:48.017
OF RELATIVE TO THE GREENHOUSE
04:42:48.084 --> 04:42:50.119
GAS AND AND AND AND THE THE
04:42:50.186 --> 04:42:51.554
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A NINE
04:42:51.621 --> 04:42:52.989
HUNDRED INTENDED IS THAT YOU'RE
04:42:53.056 --> 04:42:55.325
ASKING FOR AN ADDITIONAL YEAR TO
04:42:55.391 --> 04:42:58.094
COMPLETE THAT PORTIONS OF BONO
04:42:58.161 --> 04:43:00.163
ACTUALLY MISTER CHAIRMAN GOOD
04:43:00.229 --> 04:43:01.731
LET ME CLARIFY THAT I'M SORRY --
04:43:01.798 --> 04:43:03.599
BECAUSE IT PRETTY I UNDERSTAND
04:43:03.666 --> 04:43:04.734
YOUR QUESTION NOW.
04:43:04.801 --> 04:43:05.568
TO PACIFIC WE WHAT WE'RE
04:43:05.635 --> 04:43:07.704
DISCUSSING HERE --
04:43:07.770 --> 04:43:09.205
BECAUSE OF THE NATURE OF OUR OF
04:43:09.272 --> 04:43:10.440
THIS COMMUNITY PURSES DOWNTOWN
04:43:10.506 --> 04:43:12.742
LOS ANGELES --
04:43:12.809 --> 04:43:13.910
UNLIKE THE SACRAMENTO EXAMPLE OR
04:43:13.976 --> 04:43:15.712
THE WARRIORS.
04:43:15.778 --> 04:43:18.348
WE'RE HAPPY TO HAVE THE 15%.
04:43:18.414 --> 04:43:20.483
VEHICLE TO PRODUCTION STANDARDS
04:43:20.550 --> 04:43:22.618
IN THE BILL BUT BECAUSE WE ARE
04:43:22.685 --> 04:43:24.721
TRANSIT START WE NEED A FEW MORE
04:43:24.787 --> 04:43:26.255
YEARS TO COMPLY WITH THAT
04:43:26.322 --> 04:43:28.257
STANDARD AND SO WHAT WE WOULD.
04:43:28.324 --> 04:43:30.093
ASK FOR IS THAT.
04:43:30.159 --> 04:43:31.694
THAT WE HAVE --
04:43:31.761 --> 04:43:34.764
WHAT WOULD NORMALLY IN THE AB
04:43:34.831 --> 04:43:35.865
NINE HUNDRED PROVISION YOU GET
04:43:35.932 --> 04:43:37.400
ONE YEAR TO COMPLY WITH THAT
04:43:37.467 --> 04:43:39.469
WE'D LIKE TO HAVE?
04:43:39.535 --> 04:43:41.204
AN ADDITIONAL FIVE YEARS TO
04:43:41.270 --> 04:43:43.606
COMPLY WITH THAT AGAIN SUBJECT
04:43:43.673 --> 04:43:45.775
TO THE REQUIREMENT OF ADDITIONAL
04:43:45.842 --> 04:43:46.075
[inaudible]
04:43:46.142 --> 04:43:47.710
MITIGATION [inaudible]
04:43:47.777 --> 04:43:49.912
SO.
04:43:49.979 --> 04:43:51.714
WE HAVE CARPETS LOOKING AT THE
04:43:51.781 --> 04:43:53.182
DEAD THE TRAFFIC IN THE IN THE
04:43:53.249 --> 04:43:56.719
GREENHOUSE GAS GREENHOUSE GAS.
04:43:56.786 --> 04:43:57.687
AND THEY'RE GOING TO SIGN OFF
04:43:57.754 --> 04:44:01.057
AND SO THE QUESTION IS IS THAT
04:44:01.124 --> 04:44:03.393
WHAT WILL THEY BE USING AS THE
04:44:03.459 --> 04:44:04.694
WHEN THEY'RE GONNA GO.
04:44:04.761 --> 04:44:06.162
LOOK A A LOOK AT THE PROJECT
04:44:06.229 --> 04:44:06.796
PUNDITS AND SEE WHAT'S HAPPENING
04:44:06.863 --> 04:44:08.631
AT STAPLES CENTER HOW MANY
04:44:08.698 --> 04:44:10.800
PEOPLE USE THE METRO HOW MANY
04:44:10.867 --> 04:44:13.102
CAR RIDES ARE HOW MANY PEOPLE
04:44:13.169 --> 04:44:14.771
WATCH IS THE STADIUM AND I THINK
04:44:14.837 --> 04:44:16.339
THAT'S WHAT AT THE BASELINE.
04:44:16.406 --> 04:44:17.874
IN THIS PROJECT HAS THAT THEY'RE
04:44:17.940 --> 04:44:19.675
THEY'RE RIGHT THERE THE BASELINE
04:44:19.742 --> 04:44:21.411
AT STAPLES CENTER RECI STAPLES
04:44:21.477 --> 04:44:22.912
CENTER SO THEY HAVE THAT IN AND
04:44:22.979 --> 04:44:24.514
A LOOK AT THE STAPLES CENTER
04:44:24.580 --> 04:44:26.282
CONTINUES.
04:44:26.349 --> 04:44:26.849
RIGHT RIGHT BUT THAT'S THE
04:44:26.916 --> 04:44:28.718
BASELINE FOR THEM 15%
04:44:28.785 --> 04:44:30.620
CALCULATION HOW DO YOU HOW DO
04:44:30.686 --> 04:44:32.622
YOU IMPROVE ON THAT.
04:44:32.688 --> 04:44:33.656
SO ACTUALLY MISTER CHAIRMAN I
04:44:33.723 --> 04:44:35.124
THINK THOUGH WHAT WAS INTENDED
04:44:35.191 --> 04:44:36.759
IN THAT REGARD IS THAT THE
04:44:36.826 --> 04:44:38.861
BASELINE WOULD BE.
04:44:38.928 --> 04:44:40.196
IF THE ARENA WERE BUILT WITHOUT
04:44:40.263 --> 04:44:42.331
THIS 50% HARM NO MITIGATION
04:44:42.398 --> 04:44:45.067
CHOIR.
04:44:45.134 --> 04:44:47.403
WE WOULD REDUCE VEHICLE TIPS BY
04:44:47.470 --> 04:44:50.306
15% WHEN COMPARED TO THAT.
04:44:50.373 --> 04:44:51.774
OKAY SO THAT'S THE CENTURY WHAT
04:44:51.841 --> 04:44:53.476
THE WARRIORS DID AND THEY'RE A
04:44:53.543 --> 04:44:54.777
BAND UNDER THE APPLICATION.
04:44:54.844 --> 04:44:56.345
RIGHT SO THAT SO SO WE'RE GONNA
04:44:56.412 --> 04:44:58.748
LOOK AT A STADIUM IN INGLEWOOD
04:44:58.815 --> 04:45:00.082
WITH.
04:45:00.149 --> 04:45:02.485
AS IT IS IS IT'S WE JUST PLOPPED
04:45:02.552 --> 04:45:03.553
DOWN THERE AND WHAT WOULD BE DAY
04:45:03.619 --> 04:45:04.720
HOW MANY PEOPLE TAKE TRANSIT HOW
04:45:04.787 --> 04:45:06.289
MY PEOPLE RATHER BY COMING
04:45:06.355 --> 04:45:06.622
PEOPLE WOULD.
04:45:06.689 --> 04:45:07.924
WOULD --
04:45:07.990 --> 04:45:09.725
DRIVE AND THEN THAT THAT
04:45:09.792 --> 04:45:13.329
CALCULATION AND IN THE THE GOAL
04:45:13.396 --> 04:45:15.431
WOULD BE TO GET 215% PRE
04:45:15.498 --> 04:45:17.533
REDUCTION OF THAT.
04:45:17.600 --> 04:45:19.402
IN THE YEAR.
04:45:19.469 --> 04:45:20.269
TWENTY THIRTY SO THE QUESTION
04:45:20.336 --> 04:45:22.338
COMES UP IS THAT HOW DO WE
04:45:22.405 --> 04:45:25.708
ENFORCE THAT AFTER THE AFTER THE
04:45:25.775 --> 04:45:27.677
PROJECT IS BUILT WE WE WE HAVE
04:45:27.743 --> 04:45:28.377
THE BEST INTENTIONS LET'S SAY
04:45:28.444 --> 04:45:28.678
[inaudible]
04:45:28.744 --> 04:45:31.113
THE BEST BEST INTENTION LET'S
04:45:31.180 --> 04:45:33.082
SAY HALF LA.
04:45:33.149 --> 04:45:34.450
DECIDED THEY'RE GOING TO HAVE
04:45:34.517 --> 04:45:37.753
ACCESS TO THE ARM --
04:45:37.820 --> 04:45:39.856
OLYMPICS THAT ARE COMING.
04:45:39.922 --> 04:45:42.258
RIGHT HOW HOW DO WE IMPROVE THE
04:45:42.325 --> 04:45:45.528
BUS TRANSPORTATION OR LOVE RAIL
04:45:45.595 --> 04:45:47.663
OR THE CONNECTOR WITH --
04:45:47.730 --> 04:45:49.932
ALLIE X..
04:45:49.999 --> 04:45:51.934
ASSUME MY MISTER SHARON I THINK
04:45:52.001 --> 04:45:53.703
I THINK I'M GONNA ALLOW EXPERTS
04:45:53.769 --> 04:45:54.837
TO RESPOND.
04:45:54.904 --> 04:45:55.872
WHEN THEY EXIT THE AMENDMENTS
04:45:55.938 --> 04:45:57.673
THAT WE'VE PROPOSED IS DONE HAS
04:45:57.740 --> 04:45:59.075
ACTUALLY MANDATED?
04:45:59.141 --> 04:46:00.977
THE PROVIDING OF SHUTTLE BUSES
04:46:01.043 --> 04:46:04.247
CHARTER BUSES. TO TRANSIT
04:46:04.313 --> 04:46:05.915
LOCATIONS FOR EVERY EVENT AT THE
04:46:05.982 --> 04:46:07.583
ARENA.
04:46:07.650 --> 04:46:09.218
SO THAT WILL BE A WAY OF THAT'S
04:46:09.285 --> 04:46:11.287
OUR WAY OF INITIALLY ON TOP OF
04:46:11.354 --> 04:46:12.622
MEETING THIS 15% WE'RE GONNA
04:46:12.688 --> 04:46:14.290
MANDATE THAT THAT WILL HOPEFULLY
04:46:14.357 --> 04:46:15.658
HELP US TO MEET THAT 50%
04:46:15.725 --> 04:46:16.759
REDUCTIONS [inaudible]
04:46:16.826 --> 04:46:18.794
AGAIN.
04:46:18.861 --> 04:46:20.563
BUT IT THE OTHER DAY DOWN ALLEGE
04:46:20.630 --> 04:46:22.231
THAT THE EXPERTS TALK ABOUT.
04:46:22.298 --> 04:46:26.536
THE ADDITIONAL REQUIREENTS IF.
04:46:26.602 --> 04:46:28.471
IF THAT SENATORS AMANDA AND IN
04:46:28.538 --> 04:46:29.705
AND TOUCH ON THE PIECES Y.
04:46:29.772 --> 04:46:31.207
THINGS WE HAVEN'T AB NINE
04:46:31.274 --> 04:46:32.942
HUNDRED IS THE EMPLOYEES SO WE
04:46:33.009 --> 04:46:35.077
HAVE ANDERSON PLOY EAST WE HEARD.
04:46:35.144 --> 04:46:36.379
HERE FROM THE TRAITS AND HOW HOW
04:46:36.445 --> 04:46:39.248
THEY ARE ENTHUSIASTIC BUT
04:46:39.315 --> 04:46:40.816
THERE'S THERE'S EMPLOYEES
04:46:40.883 --> 04:46:41.450
NORMALLY WHAT WE'D BE LOOKING AT
04:46:41.517 --> 04:46:43.085
IT.
04:46:43.152 --> 04:46:44.687
IS WORKING ON BUILDING IT WHEN
04:46:44.754 --> 04:46:46.722
IT'S THERE WHO'S GOING TO WORK
04:46:46.789 --> 04:46:48.090
THERE THE IS EVERYBODY DRIVING
04:46:48.157 --> 04:46:50.459
WHAT'S THAT PLAN LOOK LIKE.
04:46:50.526 --> 04:46:54.163
OR WHATPROPOSED SIR IDEA.
04:46:54.230 --> 04:46:55.231
RIGHT THAT WOULD BE THAT WOULD
04:46:55.298 --> 04:46:56.799
BE THE CONSTRUCTION [inaudible]
04:46:56.866 --> 04:46:58.434
WORKERS EMPLOYMENT.
04:46:58.501 --> 04:46:59.335
PERIOD WORKERS DURING
04:46:59.402 --> 04:47:00.469
CONSTRUCTION ARE IN PLACE DURING
04:47:00.536 --> 04:47:01.671
CONSTRUCTION WOULD BE HANDLED IN
04:47:01.737 --> 04:47:02.972
THE TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT
04:47:03.039 --> 04:47:05.274
PLAN IT WOULDN'T BE BECAUSE THAT.
04:47:05.341 --> 04:47:07.410
GOAL FOR THE TTM OR T. MP WOULD
04:47:07.476 --> 04:47:10.613
BE THE YEAR TWENTY THIRTY OF THE-STATE WOULD BE CONSTRUCTED BY
04:47:10.680 --> 04:47:11.080
THEM SO THEY WOULDN'T
04:47:11.147 --> 04:47:11.948
NECESSARILY BE.
04:47:12.014 --> 04:47:14.116
REQUIRED TO MEET THAT 15% GOAL
04:47:14.183 --> 04:47:16.352
DURING CONSTRUCTION --
04:47:16.419 --> 04:47:18.254
BUT THEY WOULD BE THERE WOULD BE
04:47:18.321 --> 04:47:20.022
THEY WOULD BE PART OF THE TEDIUM
04:47:20.089 --> 04:47:21.490
TO TRY TO FIND MEASURES.
04:47:21.557 --> 04:47:23.059
TO WAYS TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT OF
04:47:23.125 --> 04:47:23.659
VEHICLE TRIPS BY CONSTRUCTION
04:47:23.726 --> 04:47:25.895
EMPLOYEES.
04:47:25.962 --> 04:47:27.597
AMBER ALERT MISTER CHAIRMAN THE
04:47:27.663 --> 04:47:30.166
PERMIT EMPLOYEES IS WELL OF OUR
04:47:30.232 --> 04:47:32.568
PART OF THAT STANDARD.
04:47:32.635 --> 04:47:33.569
THAT ABSOLUTELY THAT'S NORMALLY
04:47:33.636 --> 04:47:35.504
AT A GOAL THAT THEY HAD LEASE
04:47:35.571 --> 04:47:36.272
WITH THAT.
04:47:36.339 --> 04:47:37.273
THOUGH WARRIORS TO SING
04:47:37.340 --> 04:47:38.541
COMMITMENT THAT WE'RE GOING TO
04:47:38.608 --> 04:47:39.275
GET THE PEOPLE THAT ACTUALLY
04:47:39.342 --> 04:47:41.510
WORKED THERE TAKING TRANSIT AND
04:47:41.577 --> 04:47:41.811
COMING IN.
04:47:41.877 --> 04:47:44.146
OKAY I'M JUST.
04:47:44.213 --> 04:47:50.052
AS YOU CAN IMAGINE WE'RE AS WITH
04:47:50.119 --> 04:47:53.356
THE MOTION ON THE BONTA BILL.
04:47:53.422 --> 04:47:55.558
IT'S GOOD TO BE.
04:47:55.625 --> 04:47:58.494
MY COMMITTEES JOB.
04:47:58.561 --> 04:48:00.563
TO PRODUCE ART REDUCED DOWN TO
04:48:00.630 --> 04:48:01.964
WRITING WHAT.
04:48:02.031 --> 04:48:04.667
ANY AMENDMENTS ARE THAT WE HAVE
04:48:04.734 --> 04:48:07.503
EITHER AGREE TO ORALLY WE'VE
04:48:07.570 --> 04:48:09.739
PREVIOUSLY YOU KNOW --
04:48:09.805 --> 04:48:13.743
SWAT PAPERS AND AND OR MODIFIED.
04:48:13.809 --> 04:48:15.645
THE PAPER --
04:48:15.711 --> 04:48:16.712
THEY HAD THE CHANGES I'M JUST
04:48:16.779 --> 04:48:17.780
TRYING TO GET MORE CLARITY
04:48:17.847 --> 04:48:18.914
BECAUSE WE'RE GONNA BE LOOKING
04:48:18.981 --> 04:48:20.449
AT THESE TAPES AND UNDERSTAND
04:48:20.516 --> 04:48:22.151
WHAT DID WHAT EXACTLY DID THE
04:48:22.218 --> 04:48:23.986
AUTHOR AGREE WITH.
04:48:24.053 --> 04:48:24.920
YEAH ENTERED INTO CLARIFY THE
04:48:24.987 --> 04:48:26.155
PROPOSED AMENDMENT THAT'S BEEN
04:48:26.222 --> 04:48:27.490
DRAFTED THE TEDIUM WOULD APPLY
04:48:27.556 --> 04:48:31.160
TO VISITORS ATTENDEES EMPLOYEES.
04:48:31.227 --> 04:48:33.496
IT'S BETTER SO IT WOULD INVITE
04:48:33.562 --> 04:48:34.397
ALL VEHICLE TRIPS TO THE I MEAN
04:48:34.463 --> 04:48:52.448
I'M --
04:48:52.982 --> 04:48:53.015
TO
04:48:53.082 --> 04:48:54.884
CLARIFY.
04:48:54.950 --> 04:48:56.652
WE ARE STUCK WITH [inaudible]
04:48:56.719 --> 04:48:59.855
THE THE BILL AS IT'S BEFORE US
04:48:59.922 --> 04:49:01.824
AND IT IS A BILL AND PRINT.
04:49:01.891 --> 04:49:04.660
THE THE WERE VOTING ON THE BILL
04:49:04.727 --> 04:49:06.362
THAT'S BEFORE US WE'VE HAD
04:49:06.429 --> 04:49:07.596
ASSURANCES BY THE AUTHOR IN THE
04:49:07.663 --> 04:49:09.465
PROPONENTS THAT THESE ARE
04:49:09.532 --> 04:49:11.167
AMENDMENTS THAT WOULD BE AUTHORS
04:49:11.233 --> 04:49:12.568
AMENDMENTS THAT.
04:49:12.635 --> 04:49:14.136
I THINK IT'S YOU PASSED THE
04:49:14.203 --> 04:49:15.705
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE NEXT WEEK SO
04:49:15.771 --> 04:49:16.839
WOULD FOLLOW.
04:49:16.906 --> 04:49:18.040
ALL THE LEADER THAT THEY WOULD
04:49:18.107 --> 04:49:19.709
GO TO JUDICIARY COMMITTEE AND IN
04:49:19.775 --> 04:49:22.978
THE INTERIM. TO REDUCE THOSE
04:49:23.045 --> 04:49:24.647
INTO A WRITING THAT THAT
04:49:24.714 --> 04:49:26.515
COMMITTEE WOULD ACTUALLY BE
04:49:26.582 --> 04:49:28.651
VOTING ON THOSE AMENDMENTS.
04:49:28.718 --> 04:49:31.921
JUST FOR PROCESS THAT'S HAPPENS
04:49:31.987 --> 04:49:33.923
ALL THE TIME AND I IT YOU JUST
04:49:33.989 --> 04:49:35.024
TO PAY I'M PRETTY CLEAR VISION
04:49:35.091 --> 04:49:36.192
ON THIS TRAFFIC.
04:49:36.258 --> 04:49:37.660
PLANTED THE TEDIUM BUT IT SOUNDS
04:49:37.727 --> 04:49:38.861
LIKE THE WAY IT'S BEEN PROPOSED
04:49:38.928 --> 04:49:40.563
THAT THIS IS WHAT MAKES IT A
04:49:40.629 --> 04:49:42.865
QUALIFYING PROJECT.
04:49:42.932 --> 04:49:43.833
BUT THAT.
04:49:43.899 --> 04:49:46.001
WITHIN THE ER CONTACTS YOU'D
04:49:46.068 --> 04:49:47.136
STILL HAVE TO DO A TRAFFIC
04:49:47.203 --> 04:49:48.704
CONGESTION ANALYSIS AND WHAT
04:49:48.771 --> 04:49:50.139
THIS BILL SAYS USE.
04:49:50.206 --> 04:49:51.674
IF YOU DO THAT YOU DON'T HAVE TO
04:49:51.741 --> 04:49:52.541
FIND SIGNIFICANT IMPACTS YOU
04:49:52.608 --> 04:49:54.410
DON'T HAVE TO MITIGATE THOSE SO
04:49:54.477 --> 04:49:56.278
EVEN IF THEY DID THE TEDIUM PLAN
04:49:56.345 --> 04:49:56.779
AND YOU.
04:49:56.846 --> 04:49:58.614
DO A TRAFFIC ANALYSIS YOU DON'T
04:49:58.681 --> 04:49:59.615
HAVE TO CONCLUDE ANYTHING
04:49:59.682 --> 04:50:01.150
SIGNIFICANT EVEN IF YOU HAVE.
04:50:01.217 --> 04:50:02.518
SIGNIFICANT INTRUSION INTO THIS
04:50:02.585 --> 04:50:04.053
RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD THAT'S
04:50:04.120 --> 04:50:04.653
RIGHT NEXT OR WITH CUT THROUGH
04:50:04.720 --> 04:50:05.788
TRAFFIC.
04:50:05.855 --> 04:50:07.623
IF YOU'VE GOT IT TERRIBLE
04:50:07.690 --> 04:50:09.391
CONGESTION INTO YOUR ACCESS
04:50:09.458 --> 04:50:11.794
POINTS INTO THIS AREA AND OTHER
04:50:11.861 --> 04:50:13.262
VENUES IN THIS AREA.
04:50:13.329 --> 04:50:15.231
SO IT SOUNDS MAKE IT STILL A BIG
04:50:15.297 --> 04:50:16.899
GAP BETWEEN AB NINE HUNDRED AND
04:50:16.966 --> 04:50:18.567
OTHER BILLS --
04:50:18.634 --> 04:50:20.236
IN TERMS OF ELIMINATING REALLY
04:50:20.302 --> 04:50:21.003
THE MEANINGFULNESS OF THESE TWO
04:50:21.070 --> 04:50:23.472
ANALYSES.
04:50:23.539 --> 04:50:24.340
BUT BATTLING WHICH IS NO LONGER
04:50:24.406 --> 04:50:25.407
IN THE BILL IT WAS IN THE
04:50:25.474 --> 04:50:27.676
VERSION OF THE BILL IN THE FALL
04:50:27.743 --> 04:50:28.344
BUT IT'S NOT IN THE BILL ANYMORE
04:50:28.411 --> 04:50:30.579
IF IT'S IN THE BILL OF TODAY.
04:50:30.646 --> 04:50:32.381
I MEAN I DON'T OF THE AMENDMENTS
04:50:32.448 --> 04:50:32.982
BUT VISIT THE BILL BEFORE THE
04:50:33.048 --> 04:50:33.716
COMMITTEE TODAY.
04:50:33.783 --> 04:50:36.085
NO THAT'S NOT TRUE [inaudible]
04:50:36.152 --> 04:50:37.887
SO [inaudible]
04:50:37.953 --> 04:50:41.257
BUT LET'S SPEAK.
04:50:41.323 --> 04:50:43.826
TO SPEAK TO WHAT THE BILL AS
04:50:43.893 --> 04:50:45.361
PROPOSED APPROACH AMENDMENTS
04:50:45.427 --> 04:50:47.263
WHAT THE AUTHOR WOULD LIKE IT TO
04:50:47.329 --> 04:50:49.231
HAVE ON THE ON THE TRACK EITHER
04:50:49.298 --> 04:50:50.432
ON THE TRAFFIC.
04:50:50.499 --> 04:50:52.234
AND GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS.
04:50:52.301 --> 04:50:54.537
IS YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF IT SO
04:50:54.603 --> 04:50:55.838
MY UNDERSTANDING THAT I THINK I
04:50:55.905 --> 04:50:58.874
SORT OF SHARED IN MY OPENING
04:50:58.941 --> 04:51:00.075
STATEMENT IS THAT IT WILL BE A
04:51:00.142 --> 04:51:01.877
MANDATED TRANSPORTATION --
04:51:01.944 --> 04:51:03.946
MANAGEMENT PLAN THAT RESULTS IN
04:51:04.013 --> 04:51:06.015
A 15% REDUCTION IN VEHICLE TRIPS
04:51:06.081 --> 04:51:07.550
TO THE ARENA --
04:51:07.616 --> 04:51:11.086
WE ARE ALSO --
04:51:11.153 --> 04:51:13.455
INCORPORATING LANGUAGE REGARDING
04:51:13.522 --> 04:51:14.323
ENFORCEMENT.
04:51:14.390 --> 04:51:17.927
RIGHT ARM TO OFFER THAT CARP
04:51:17.993 --> 04:51:20.196
ASSERTED BY THE METHODOLOGY USED
04:51:20.262 --> 04:51:21.463
TO ACHIEVE CARBON NEUTRALITY IN
04:51:21.530 --> 04:51:22.598
THAT IF THAT DOESN'T HIT.
04:51:22.665 --> 04:51:25.167
THEY GO BACK --
04:51:25.234 --> 04:51:26.502
I THINK IT WAS MENTIONED THAT
04:51:26.569 --> 04:51:28.470
THERE IS A HAD ANOTHER COSTS BUT
04:51:28.537 --> 04:51:29.839
IT'S HUGE I WANNA SAY OVER A
04:51:29.905 --> 04:51:31.974
MILLION DOLLARS OF A DEDICATED
04:51:32.041 --> 04:51:34.109
TRANSPORTATION STUDY. TO LINK
04:51:34.176 --> 04:51:35.377
ALL OF THE WORK THAT'S HAPPENING
04:51:35.444 --> 04:51:37.513
IN THAT AREA --
04:51:37.580 --> 04:51:39.481
THE BILL ALSO TALKS ABOUT HAVING
04:51:39.548 --> 04:51:40.783
SOLAR RULES FOR ELECTRIC
04:51:40.850 --> 04:51:42.451
CHARGING --
04:51:42.518 --> 04:51:43.652
STATIONS --
04:51:43.719 --> 04:51:46.455
OUT WALKABILITY ACCESS --
04:51:46.522 --> 04:51:48.457
BIKES -- AT
04:51:48.524 --> 04:51:50.492
A SHUTTLE SERVICE ARE FOR BOTH
04:51:50.559 --> 04:51:51.827
THOSE THAT ARE VISITING AND
04:51:51.894 --> 04:51:54.129
ACCESSING ALL OF THE FACILITIES
04:51:54.196 --> 04:51:57.366
AS WELL AS FOR A THERE ARE OTHER
04:51:57.433 --> 04:51:57.967
AMENDMENTS THAT WE'VE TALKED
04:51:58.033 --> 04:51:58.701
ABOUT.
04:51:58.767 --> 04:52:01.103
ALSO BUT THEY DON'T RELATE TO
04:52:01.170 --> 04:52:02.338
MANAGEMENT I MEAN TO
04:52:02.404 --> 04:52:03.706
TRANSPORTATION SO I DON'T KNOW
04:52:03.772 --> 04:52:04.773
IF YOU WANT ME TO REITERATE THAT
04:52:04.840 --> 04:52:07.376
NO THAT'S LET'S TRY [inaudible]
04:52:07.443 --> 04:52:09.478
TO PARSE THIS.
04:52:09.545 --> 04:52:12.848
OUT AS BEST WE CAN --
04:52:12.915 --> 04:52:14.850
AND ALSO CARBON NEUTRALITY I
04:52:14.917 --> 04:52:15.484
DON'T KNOW IF I MENTIONED THAT
04:52:15.551 --> 04:52:16.452
BUT THAT WAS ALSO PART OF IT
04:52:16.518 --> 04:52:16.752
[inaudible]
04:52:16.819 --> 04:52:18.888
OKAY.
04:52:18.954 --> 04:52:20.589
WHEN WE TALK ABOUT CARBON
04:52:20.656 --> 04:52:23.058
NEUTRALITY I'M?
04:52:23.125 --> 04:52:25.060
WE DON'T BACK TO STAPLE CENTER I
04:52:25.127 --> 04:52:26.862
WE GOING BACK --
04:52:26.929 --> 04:52:28.764
TO THE STATE THE ART.
04:52:28.831 --> 04:52:30.866
BUT COLISEUM ARE THE OAKLAND
04:52:30.933 --> 04:52:32.534
PROJECT OUTLETS TO THE BASELINE
04:52:32.601 --> 04:52:34.136
WHICH INCLUDE STE EXISTING
04:52:34.203 --> 04:52:35.871
OPERATIONS AT THE STAPLES CENTER.
04:52:35.938 --> 04:52:38.007
OKAY SET THAT GOES BACK TO THAT
04:52:38.073 --> 04:52:39.541
YOU'RE LOOKING AT STAPLES CENTER
04:52:39.608 --> 04:52:41.911
WHAT'S THEIR CARBON.
04:52:41.977 --> 04:52:43.679
BUT BRENT AND MOVE ON TO CENTER
04:52:43.746 --> 04:52:45.180
STERN WELCOME BACK --
04:52:45.247 --> 04:52:47.016
THANKS.
04:52:47.082 --> 04:52:48.784
PLUS THERE WAS ACTUALLY I I JUST
04:52:48.851 --> 04:52:49.518
WANT TO CHIME IN BECAUSE THAT
04:52:49.585 --> 04:52:51.387
WAS MY ESSENTIAL QUESTION FOR
04:52:51.453 --> 04:52:52.554
Y'ALL WAS THE CERTAIN NATURE OF
04:52:52.621 --> 04:52:54.957
THE GREENHOUSE GAS BASE LINING
04:52:55.024 --> 04:52:56.525
IN THE ANALYSIS CONSIDERING.
04:52:56.592 --> 04:52:58.193
SCOPE OF THE PROJECT AND WE JUST
04:52:58.260 --> 04:52:59.295
WENT THROUGH THIS DISCUSSION ON
04:52:59.361 --> 04:53:00.562
THE CONTEXT OF DIFFERENT STADIUM
04:53:00.629 --> 04:53:01.196
WHICH WHICH IS A STADIUM IN THIS
04:53:01.263 --> 04:53:01.964
IS [inaudible]
04:53:02.031 --> 04:53:03.565
STADIUM PLUS --
04:53:03.632 --> 04:53:05.701
SO [inaudible]
04:53:05.768 --> 04:53:08.804
BASELINE IS THE WHOLE THING OR
04:53:08.871 --> 04:53:10.606
THE WHOLE PROJECT OR JUST THE
04:53:10.673 --> 04:53:15.377
STADIUM PART OF THE PROJECT.
04:53:15.444 --> 04:53:17.446
SO THE SENATE'S TURN.
04:53:17.513 --> 04:53:18.514
THE REQUIREMENT IN THE BILL IS
04:53:18.580 --> 04:53:20.950
THE THAT.
04:53:21.016 --> 04:53:22.985
NOT JUST THE ARENA BUT THE
04:53:23.052 --> 04:53:25.521
ANCILLARY RESTAURANT --
04:53:25.587 --> 04:53:27.957
PRACTICE FACILITY THE SPORTS
04:53:28.023 --> 04:53:29.692
MEDICINE AND COMMUNITY CLINIC
04:53:29.758 --> 04:53:31.126
AND THE COMMUNITY MEETING SPACE
04:53:31.193 --> 04:53:33.495
ALL MEET THE GOAL.
04:53:33.562 --> 04:53:36.298
THEY'RE ALL THEM TIED TOGETHER
04:53:36.365 --> 04:53:38.968
AND THAT THE BASELINE.
04:53:39.034 --> 04:53:40.302
AS I UNDERSTAND IT AND HOW THIS
04:53:40.369 --> 04:53:41.837
WOULD BE MEASURED IS.
04:53:41.904 --> 04:53:44.673
THAT ENTIRE FACILITY WOULD HAVE
04:53:44.740 --> 04:53:47.776
TO HAVE A NET ZERO EMISSION.
04:53:47.843 --> 04:53:50.346
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION.
04:53:50.412 --> 04:53:52.948
STANDARD VERSES THE OPERATION OF
04:53:53.015 --> 04:53:53.716
STAPLES CENTER WHICH WOULD BE
04:53:53.782 --> 04:53:57.553
THE BASELINE.
04:53:57.619 --> 04:53:59.555
SO IN OTHER WORDS ADDING UP.
04:53:59.621 --> 04:54:01.523
BASELINE INCLUDES ALL EXISTING
04:54:01.590 --> 04:54:03.192
ACTIVITIES THAT.
04:54:03.258 --> 04:54:04.560
IS THE STADIUM.
04:54:04.626 --> 04:54:07.129
YOU'RE GONNA TRY SAYING NO NET
04:54:07.196 --> 04:54:09.264
ADDITIONAL GREENHOUSE GASES OVER
04:54:09.331 --> 04:54:11.066
THAT AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THEN
04:54:11.133 --> 04:54:13.002
THAT IT INCLUDES NOT JUST THE
04:54:13.068 --> 04:54:15.504
STADIUM BUT BUT JUST HEARING
04:54:15.571 --> 04:54:17.673
ABOUT THE RESTAURANTS YEAH ALL
04:54:17.740 --> 04:54:19.808
THAT SORT OF ACTIVITY AROUND IT
04:54:19.875 --> 04:54:21.944
TRANSPORTATION AROUND IT --
04:54:22.011 --> 04:54:24.413
AND EVEN WHATEVER SORT OF
04:54:24.480 --> 04:54:26.448
DEVELOPMENT MIXED USE OR
04:54:26.515 --> 04:54:27.249
WHATEVER ENDS UP.
04:54:27.316 --> 04:54:29.485
OKAY.
04:54:29.551 --> 04:54:31.153
DO SO IT'S IMPORTANT OBSERVERS
04:54:31.220 --> 04:54:32.988
TURNED JUST IN THAT REGARD TRIPS.
04:54:33.055 --> 04:54:34.156
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS WHILE
04:54:34.223 --> 04:54:35.290
THEY'RE INVOLVED IN VEHICLES
04:54:35.357 --> 04:54:36.558
ALSO WERE SEPARATE STANDARD
04:54:36.625 --> 04:54:38.227
RELATIVE TO THE BUILDINGS AND
04:54:38.293 --> 04:54:39.461
EVERYTHING AROUND IT SO OUR
04:54:39.528 --> 04:54:41.430
INTENT IS TO MAKE SURE THAT.
04:54:41.497 --> 04:54:43.032
THAT THE NET ZERO PLACED ALL THE
04:54:43.098 --> 04:54:44.299
BUILDINGS THE DEVELOPMENTS AND
04:54:44.366 --> 04:54:46.035
THEN IN ADDITION TO THAT WERE
04:54:46.101 --> 04:54:48.804
AGREEING TO A 15% VEHICLE TRIP
04:54:48.871 --> 04:54:50.506
PRODUCTION I STAND RIGHT AND
04:54:50.572 --> 04:54:51.206
THAT'S THAT TRANSPORTATION
04:54:51.273 --> 04:54:52.541
ELEMENT OF THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
04:54:52.608 --> 04:54:54.309
JUST DESCRIBED SO IT'S IT'S THAT
04:54:54.376 --> 04:54:55.978
IS THE TRANSPORTATION PIECE PLUS
04:54:56.045 --> 04:54:56.412
ALL IS.
04:54:56.478 --> 04:54:57.079
GREED AND THAT'S IT AND THAT'S
04:54:57.146 --> 04:54:59.281
AN AMENDMENT THAT YOU'D BE
04:54:59.348 --> 04:55:03.152
TAKING HERE --
04:55:03.218 --> 04:55:04.787
YEAH JUSTICE IN THE MARKET.
04:55:04.853 --> 04:55:08.123
RIGHT I'M LOOKING AT PAGE TEN OF
04:55:08.190 --> 04:55:09.324
THE PHONE WHEN WERE [inaudible]
04:55:09.391 --> 04:55:11.126
LET'S.
04:55:11.193 --> 04:55:12.795
LET'S BE CLEAR BECAUSE THERE'S A
04:55:12.861 --> 04:55:14.263
LITTLE CONFUSION HERE IS THAT.
04:55:14.329 --> 04:55:16.131
WE HAVE BEFORE US THE ORIGINAL
04:55:16.198 --> 04:55:18.100
BILL OKAY WHEN WE'RE SAYING THE
04:55:18.167 --> 04:55:20.102
MARKETS IN THE MOCK UP IT'S NOT
04:55:20.169 --> 04:55:23.806
THERE SO WE'RE READING I'M PAGE --
04:55:23.872 --> 04:55:26.642
TEN SUBSECTION.
04:55:26.708 --> 04:55:29.144
YEAH DEF ONE THE BILL THAT THE
04:55:29.211 --> 04:55:31.113
MODEL METHODOLOGY QUANTITATIVE
04:55:31.180 --> 04:55:32.481
AND QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS
04:55:32.548 --> 04:55:33.916
PERFORMANCE STANDARDS AND
04:55:33.982 --> 04:55:35.951
THRESHOLDS OF SIGNIFICANT USE IN
04:55:36.018 --> 04:55:37.820
THE ANALYSIS OF GREENHOUSE GAS.
04:55:37.886 --> 04:55:38.921
EMISSIONS IMPACT OR THE
04:55:38.987 --> 04:55:40.189
DETERMINATION AS TO THE
04:55:40.255 --> 04:55:41.590
SIGNIFICANCE OF THOSE IMPACTS IN
04:55:41.657 --> 04:55:43.325
THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
04:55:43.392 --> 04:55:44.293
FOR THE PROJECT SHALL NOT BE
04:55:44.359 --> 04:55:46.061
GROUNDS FOR RELIEF AND SHALL NOT
04:55:46.128 --> 04:55:48.497
BE DEEMED AN ABUSE OF DISCRETION.
04:55:48.564 --> 04:55:49.131
IN THE ACTION PROCEEDING BROUGHT
04:55:49.198 --> 04:55:51.467
PURSUANT WERE SAYING THAT THAT
04:55:51.533 --> 04:55:55.170
IN THE IN THE WORKING DRAFT IS
04:55:55.237 --> 04:55:58.507
OUT BUT IT'S NOT OUT OF THERE'S
04:55:58.574 --> 04:56:01.410
SIGNIFICANT COMPUTER OF I I I I
04:56:01.477 --> 04:56:02.377
I GET BECAUSE WE HAVE.
04:56:02.444 --> 04:56:03.045
HAD.
04:56:03.112 --> 04:56:05.614
DIFFERENT MODEL SAID OF ME
04:56:05.681 --> 04:56:05.914
[inaudible]
04:56:05.981 --> 04:56:09.218
BACK IN WE HAVE PRINT AS AND AS
04:56:09.284 --> 04:56:10.285
OF JUNE SEVENTH.
04:56:10.352 --> 04:56:13.689
SEEMS LIKE A LONG AGO.
04:56:13.755 --> 04:56:15.657
YEAH BUT THAT'S JUST SO WE YEAH
04:56:15.724 --> 04:56:16.825
WE'RE ALL.
04:56:16.892 --> 04:56:18.127
WHAT THE WHAT THE COMMITTEE IS
04:56:18.193 --> 04:56:19.595
CONSIDERING IS THAT WE'VE GOT A
04:56:19.661 --> 04:56:21.063
VARIETY OF DIFFERENT?
04:56:21.130 --> 04:56:23.265
OPPONENTS THAT WE'VE GONE
04:56:23.332 --> 04:56:25.200
THROUGH TRIED IT TRY TO LOOK WHY
04:56:25.267 --> 04:56:26.802
NOT AB NINE HUNDRED AND WHAT'S
04:56:26.869 --> 04:56:27.569
THE DIFFERENCE [inaudible]
04:56:27.636 --> 04:56:29.671
THAT -- MISS
04:56:29.738 --> 04:56:34.710
A KAMLAGER-DOVE OF HAS PROVIDED
04:56:34.776 --> 04:56:36.245
US WITH WITH AND WITH.
04:56:36.311 --> 04:56:38.280
ITEMS FOR X. EXPLANATIONS OF
04:56:38.347 --> 04:56:40.482
DIFFERENT ELEMENTS.
04:56:40.549 --> 04:56:43.385
THAT THAT WE'RE GETTING.
04:56:43.452 --> 04:56:44.586
A IF THE COMPARISON OF AND THAT
04:56:44.653 --> 04:56:46.155
IN THE TRANSPORTATION GREENHOUSE
04:56:46.221 --> 04:56:47.956
EMISSIONS OR WHATEVER WHATEVER
04:56:48.023 --> 04:56:51.426
IT IS I HOW WHAT'S CLOSE. TO
04:56:51.493 --> 04:56:52.594
NINE HUNDRED OR THIS IS THE
04:56:52.661 --> 04:56:53.829
RESPONSE TO NINE HUNDRED SIR
04:56:53.896 --> 04:56:54.129
[inaudible]
04:56:54.196 --> 04:56:56.999
SO. TO CLARIFY.
04:56:57.065 --> 04:56:58.167
ON THAT POINT THEY'LL THE A
04:56:58.233 --> 04:57:00.135
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS RELATED TO
04:57:00.202 --> 04:57:01.670
TRANSPORTATION AND CHICHI WOULD
04:57:01.737 --> 04:57:03.071
NOT CHANGE THAT LANGUAGE.
04:57:03.138 --> 04:57:05.574
IN SECTION F..
04:57:05.641 --> 04:57:06.909
THE POINT IS THAT SECTION SOME
04:57:06.975 --> 04:57:08.143
LANGUAGE SIMILAR TO SECTION F.
04:57:08.210 --> 04:57:09.678
BEFORE.
04:57:09.745 --> 04:57:11.146
IN THE FALL VERSION OF THE BILL
04:57:11.213 --> 04:57:12.714
HAD SAID THAT COME.
04:57:12.781 --> 04:57:15.117
SOMETHING ALONG THE LINES OF THE
04:57:15.184 --> 04:57:16.985
CONCLUSIONS OF THEATER ON INTO
04:57:17.052 --> 04:57:18.320
AND ON GHG WOULD NOT BE
04:57:18.387 --> 04:57:20.155
CONSIDERED.
04:57:20.222 --> 04:57:21.089
A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT OF CERTAIN
04:57:21.156 --> 04:57:22.758
STANDARDS WERE MET.
04:57:22.824 --> 04:57:24.927
THE LANGUAGE NOW JUST CERTAINLY
04:57:24.993 --> 04:57:26.128
JUST CLARIFIES THE METHODOLOGY
04:57:26.195 --> 04:57:27.563
THAT NEEDS TO BE IS IT DOESN'T
04:57:27.629 --> 04:57:30.199
DICTATE WHAT THE NOW SIGNIFICANT
04:57:30.265 --> 04:57:31.633
CONCLUSIONS SHALL BE IT DOESN'T
04:57:31.700 --> 04:57:31.867
PREVENT.
04:57:31.934 --> 04:57:34.836
A CHALLENGE TO THE CONCLUSION AS
04:57:34.903 --> 04:57:35.771
A SIGNIFICANT THAT IT DOESN'T
04:57:35.837 --> 04:57:36.305
PREVENT THE IMPOSITION OF
04:57:36.371 --> 04:57:38.207
MITIGATION.
04:57:38.273 --> 04:57:39.841
AND SAME FOR THE FIFTY MT AND
04:57:39.908 --> 04:57:41.343
OFFICES INTENDED TO CLARIFY
04:57:41.410 --> 04:57:43.545
STANDARDS.
04:57:43.612 --> 04:57:45.480
IN THESE BODIES OF LAW.
04:57:45.547 --> 04:57:47.449
I NEEDS AREAS OF SEQUEL
04:57:47.516 --> 04:57:47.749
[inaudible]
04:57:47.816 --> 04:57:49.918
YEAH.
04:57:49.985 --> 04:57:50.552
CENTER STERN.
04:57:50.619 --> 04:57:51.954
I'M SORRY I THOUGHT IT WOULD I
04:57:52.020 --> 04:57:52.821
THOUGHT IT WAS CLEARED THE
04:57:52.888 --> 04:57:57.759
CLARIFYING MADE ME FEEL LESS
04:57:57.826 --> 04:57:58.060
CLEAR NOW --
04:57:58.126 --> 04:57:59.194
GO FIX YOU UP AND YOU WOULDN'T
04:57:59.261 --> 04:58:00.729
BE STRAIGHT CAN CAN WE GET A
04:58:00.796 --> 04:58:02.331
MOCK UP LIKE THIS SOMEHOW WERE
04:58:02.397 --> 04:58:03.765
SUMMONED BEFORE VOTING MEANS SO
04:58:03.832 --> 04:58:11.940
AFTER SAYING NO STRIKING OF F..
04:58:12.007 --> 04:58:16.745
ONE ADDING ADDITIONAL PERMIT
04:58:16.812 --> 04:58:17.045
[inaudible]
04:58:17.112 --> 04:58:20.749
SO -- WE'RE
04:58:20.816 --> 04:58:22.551
ADDING.
04:58:22.618 --> 04:58:23.652
ON TOP OF THE BILL YOU SEEM --
04:58:23.719 --> 04:58:31.260
WE ASSEMBLY MAY.
04:58:31.326 --> 04:58:36.164
CAN WE JUST SKIP.
04:58:36.231 --> 04:58:37.232
SO I DON'T.
04:58:37.299 --> 04:58:40.469
LOOKING AT SOMETHING
04:58:40.535 --> 04:58:40.769
[inaudible]
04:58:40.836 --> 04:58:45.140
OF BUT THERE'S BEEN MODERNIZE
04:58:45.207 --> 04:58:46.975
KNOW WE'RE GONNA FIND TIME RIGHT.
04:58:47.042 --> 04:58:48.610
BUT SOME TURN WHICH A RECEBER TO
04:58:48.677 --> 04:58:50.145
LOOK AT PARTICULAR WITH REGARD --
04:58:50.212 --> 04:58:51.546
TO SUBPARAGRAPH ES.
04:58:51.613 --> 04:58:53.015
IS AN ATTEMPT TO TRY AND SAY
04:58:53.081 --> 04:58:55.751
THAT THE METHODOLOGY USED TO
04:58:55.817 --> 04:58:57.152
COME UP WITH THE ANALYSIS SHOULD
04:58:57.219 --> 04:58:57.753
BE AYE ARE THE CONCLUSIONS OF
04:58:57.819 --> 04:59:00.055
THE OF THE I. R. JUST THE
04:59:00.122 --> 04:59:01.890
METHODOLOGY.
04:59:01.957 --> 04:59:04.026
IT'S NOT SUBJECT CHALLENGE IF
04:59:04.092 --> 04:59:05.460
YOU MEET THE STANDARDS THE
04:59:05.527 --> 04:59:07.396
GREENHOUSE GAS STANDARD.
04:59:07.462 --> 04:59:09.097
THE OTHER STANDARDS THAT WE'RE
04:59:09.164 --> 04:59:10.599
PUTTING IN THE BILL.
04:59:10.666 --> 04:59:11.600
WHAT CAN OFTEN HAPPEN IS THAT
04:59:11.667 --> 04:59:13.101
YOU CAN HAVE A CIRCULAR ARGUMENT
04:59:13.168 --> 04:59:15.003
OVER METHODOLOGY RIGHT AND
04:59:15.070 --> 04:59:16.338
DIFFERENT EXPERTS HAVE DIFFERENT
04:59:16.405 --> 04:59:17.472
METHODOLOGY?
04:59:17.539 --> 04:59:19.941
WHAT'S IMPORTANT IS WHAT ARE THE
04:59:20.008 --> 04:59:21.677
IMPACTS IDENTIFIED BY THE ARE IN
04:59:21.743 --> 04:59:23.045
THE MITIGATION.
04:59:23.111 --> 04:59:23.979
THERE WERE ONLY TRYING TO
04:59:24.046 --> 04:59:26.848
PROTECT THE METHODOLOGY USED NOT
04:59:26.915 --> 04:59:30.485
THE END RESULT AND RIGHT BUT IN
04:59:30.552 --> 04:59:32.421
THIS IN F..
04:59:32.487 --> 04:59:34.823
ONE I GET THAT THE METHODOLOGY
04:59:34.890 --> 04:59:37.693
CAN'T BE CHALLENGED BUT THAT'S
04:59:37.759 --> 04:59:38.827
THAT'S CONTINGENT ON THOSE
04:59:38.894 --> 04:59:40.295
CONDITIONS BEING MET ARE WE
04:59:40.362 --> 04:59:41.163
CHANGING WHAT THOSE CONDITIONS
04:59:41.229 --> 04:59:44.032
ARE.
04:59:44.099 --> 04:59:45.934
SO I KNOW MORE NOW NO WE'RE NOT
04:59:46.001 --> 04:59:47.836
WE'RE ADDING ON TO THOSE THOSE
04:59:47.903 --> 04:59:49.171
CONDITIONS IN ARE WE ADDING A
04:59:49.237 --> 04:59:51.306
THIRD CONDITION RATTING ON THE
04:59:51.373 --> 04:59:54.343
NET ZERO AND OTHER THINGS I SAID
04:59:54.409 --> 04:59:54.976
YOU DO YOU ANTICIPATE THAT BEING
04:59:55.043 --> 04:59:58.380
AT SUBSECTION SEE YOUR DE.
04:59:58.447 --> 04:59:59.381
IN THAT IT WOULD NOT WAS IT NOT
04:59:59.448 --> 05:00:00.615
REALLY GERMANE TO THE MODELING
05:00:00.682 --> 05:00:02.517
POINT RIDE I WOULD ACTUALLY BE
05:00:02.584 --> 05:00:04.119
SEPARATE IN THE QUALIFICATION TO
05:00:04.186 --> 05:00:06.254
QUALIFY FOR STREAMLINING
05:00:06.321 --> 05:00:07.255
PROVISIONS IT WOULD BE ABOUT
05:00:07.322 --> 05:00:08.290
SECTION.
05:00:08.357 --> 05:00:10.892
IT WOULD IT WOULD BE REQUIRED AT
05:00:10.959 --> 05:00:11.993
ITS OF THE MOCK UP THERE SO
05:00:12.060 --> 05:00:14.629
INGENIOUS THREE MORE AND MORE IN
05:00:14.696 --> 05:00:16.298
OWINGS THREE NOT ANGIE THAT IN
05:00:16.365 --> 05:00:17.532
THE NEXT SECTION.
05:00:17.599 --> 05:00:19.501
PAGE THREE HAS THE THE CRITERIA
05:00:19.568 --> 05:00:21.803
THAT YOU HAVE TO MEET TO GET.
05:00:21.870 --> 05:00:23.305
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF STREAMLINED
05:00:23.372 --> 05:00:25.207
QUALIFIED FOR THE STREAMLINING
05:00:25.273 --> 05:00:28.176
THAT'S WHERE THE NET ZERO
05:00:28.243 --> 05:00:29.745
STANDARD IS SO YOU HAVE.
05:00:29.811 --> 05:00:30.779
TO DEMONSTRATE YOU'RE GOING TO
05:00:30.846 --> 05:00:31.847
ACHIEVE THE NET ZERO BEFORE YOU
05:00:31.913 --> 05:00:33.648
GET.
05:00:33.715 --> 05:00:35.317
STREAMLINED THAT WILL BE
05:00:35.384 --> 05:00:37.319
DEMONSTRATED TO CARP.
05:00:37.386 --> 05:00:39.988
YES SO CARP IS GOING TO LOOK AT
05:00:40.055 --> 05:00:40.589
THE METHODOLOGY THAT.
05:00:40.655 --> 05:00:44.593
IS TO BE DEVELOPED HAN AND THEN
05:00:44.659 --> 05:00:47.129
THEY WOULD SIGN OFF ON THAT AND
05:00:47.195 --> 05:00:50.298
AND THEY'RE SIGNING OFF WOULD BE
05:00:50.365 --> 05:00:51.700
THAT IT'S NOT SUBJECT.
05:00:51.767 --> 05:00:54.002
TO BECAUSE I REALLY.
05:00:54.069 --> 05:00:55.637
JUST THE METHODOLOGY IS NOT
05:00:55.704 --> 05:00:56.905
SIMPLY GO TO A CHALLENGE BECAUSE
05:00:56.972 --> 05:00:58.573
WE HAVE IT.
05:00:58.640 --> 05:01:00.675
PROJECT PRISON PRESUMABLY IF
05:01:00.742 --> 05:01:01.643
CARP SIGNED OFF.
05:01:01.710 --> 05:01:03.278
FOR THE MAINTENANCE.
05:01:03.345 --> 05:01:05.147
IT MEETS THAT THRESHOLD
05:01:05.213 --> 05:01:06.481
RESPECTFULLY WHISTLE LANGUAGES
05:01:06.548 --> 05:01:08.583
CHANGE THAT'S NOT WHAT IT SAYS.
05:01:08.650 --> 05:01:11.219
RIGHT BUT THAT'S WHEN WE GET
05:01:11.286 --> 05:01:13.088
INTO THE THE GOOD THE NEXT
05:01:13.155 --> 05:01:14.523
GREATER LEAP IS THAT ALL THESE
05:01:14.589 --> 05:01:15.924
THINGS WERE TALKING ABOUT IF
05:01:15.991 --> 05:01:17.926
THERE WERE.
05:01:17.993 --> 05:01:20.295
MY THIS STE EQ STAFF IS GOING TO
05:01:20.362 --> 05:01:24.366
HAVE TO WRITE THESE I'M. FIVE
05:01:24.433 --> 05:01:25.967
THIS LANGUAGE BASED ON THE TRAPS
05:01:26.034 --> 05:01:28.036
AND BASED ON THAT CONVERSATIONS
05:01:28.103 --> 05:01:29.070
THAT WERE HERE TO DETERMINE YOU
05:01:29.137 --> 05:01:30.372
KNOW.
05:01:30.439 --> 05:01:32.574
SO THAT I HAVE SOME COMFORT OR
05:01:32.641 --> 05:01:34.476
NO COMFORT WITH HAT WHAT THEY
05:01:34.543 --> 05:01:36.812
ARE MEMBERS HERE IT'S RIGHT I
05:01:36.878 --> 05:01:37.446
JUST UNDERSTOOD THAT THEY SAID
05:01:37.512 --> 05:01:37.813
WE ARE.
05:01:37.879 --> 05:01:39.481
NOT PROPOSING AN AMENDMENT TO
05:01:39.548 --> 05:01:41.183
THIS LANGUAGE SHOWING THE
05:01:41.249 --> 05:01:42.818
GENERAL OR THE CENTER WIECKOWSKI
05:01:42.884 --> 05:01:44.786
IN REVIEWING A RIGHT NOW I I
05:01:44.853 --> 05:01:45.954
THINK I UNDERSTAND THE CONCERN.
05:01:46.021 --> 05:01:46.922
OUR INTENT HERE IS THAT THE
05:01:46.988 --> 05:01:48.657
MONTH METHODOLOGY IS PROTECTED
05:01:48.723 --> 05:01:50.392
NOT THE END RESULT.
05:01:50.459 --> 05:01:51.793
IF YOU READ THE SENTENCE SOME IT
05:01:51.860 --> 05:01:53.061
MIGHT BE ACTUALLY THINKING IT
05:01:53.128 --> 05:01:55.063
DOES IMPACT SO WE'RE HAPPY TO
05:01:55.130 --> 05:01:56.565
CLARIFY.
05:01:56.631 --> 05:01:57.699
THAT WERE ONLY THING WE'RE
05:01:57.766 --> 05:01:58.733
PROTECTING HERE IS THE
05:01:58.800 --> 05:01:59.701
METHODOLOGY AND NOT THE END
05:01:59.768 --> 05:02:01.603
RESULT.
05:02:01.670 --> 05:02:02.637
BECAUSE YOU SEE VERY THE
05:02:02.704 --> 05:02:04.639
CONDITIONS ON THE METHOD
05:02:04.706 --> 05:02:06.208
PRODUCING THE METHODOLOGY
05:02:06.274 --> 05:02:08.610
ACTUALLY ARE A NET ZERO JUST
05:02:08.677 --> 05:02:10.178
HAVEN'T JUST HAVING READ RIGHT
05:02:10.245 --> 05:02:12.414
NOW AGAIN READING I REALIZED
05:02:12.481 --> 05:02:14.082
THAT I UNDERSTOOD WHAT MOVES
05:02:14.149 --> 05:02:15.884
RAISING AND SO WE'RE HAPPY. TO
05:02:15.951 --> 05:02:17.886
MAKE THAT CLEAR SO WONDER OKAY
05:02:17.953 --> 05:02:18.987
SO AS EFFECTIVE IF I'M FOLLOWING
05:02:19.054 --> 05:02:22.491
THE BOUNCING BALL UNDER.
05:02:22.557 --> 05:02:23.325
EIGHTY NINE HUNDRED NORMALLY
05:02:23.391 --> 05:02:24.392
CARP WHICH DEVELOPED THE
05:02:24.459 --> 05:02:25.894
METHODOLOGY.
05:02:25.961 --> 05:02:27.963
THIS DIFFERENCE IS THAT THE
05:02:28.029 --> 05:02:30.131
PROPONENTS CAN.
05:02:30.198 --> 05:02:32.067
CAN PROPOSED THE METHODOLOGY BUT
05:02:32.133 --> 05:02:33.735
CARP WOULD HAVE TO SIGN OFF ON
05:02:33.802 --> 05:02:34.769
IT IF THERE'S IN MY IS THAT A
05:02:34.836 --> 05:02:35.871
CLEAR [inaudible]
05:02:35.937 --> 05:02:37.472
FAIR.
05:02:37.539 --> 05:02:38.707
DESCRIPTION OF WHAT THE
05:02:38.773 --> 05:02:39.875
DIFFERENCE IS BECAUSE I'M TRYING.
05:02:39.941 --> 05:02:41.409
TO CLARIFY FOR PEOPLE WHAT THE
05:02:41.476 --> 05:02:44.579
DIFFERENCES ARE FROM A STREET
05:02:44.646 --> 05:02:45.213
NINE EIGHTY NINE HUNDRED TO WHAT
05:02:45.280 --> 05:02:46.047
WE HAVE RIGHT HERE.
05:02:46.114 --> 05:02:48.750
IN THE BILL.
05:02:48.817 --> 05:02:49.818
WHETHER IT ENDS UP BEING A BIG
05:02:49.885 --> 05:02:51.720
DEAL OR NOT A BIG DEAL THAT'S
05:02:51.786 --> 05:02:53.488
THAT'S THAT'S STILL NOT GOING.
05:02:53.555 --> 05:02:54.856
TO VENTURE INTO THAT HAS JUST SO
05:02:54.923 --> 05:02:55.924
THAT WE KNOW WHAT THE
05:02:55.991 --> 05:02:57.492
DIFFERENCES ARE BECAUSE I'VE
05:02:57.559 --> 05:02:59.060
TRIED TO ITS STRUCTURE RELEASE
05:02:59.127 --> 05:03:01.463
ASK THE STAFF TO STRUCTURE.
05:03:01.530 --> 05:03:05.100
THE ANALYSIS IN A AB NINE
05:03:05.166 --> 05:03:06.001
HUNDRED VERSES THIS IS WHAT THE
05:03:06.067 --> 05:03:08.003
BILL DOES WE'VE HAD SOME
05:03:08.069 --> 05:03:10.539
INTERMEDIATE CHANGES AND MARKUPS
05:03:10.605 --> 05:03:11.673
NOW WE HAVE SOME MORE CHANGES SO.
05:03:11.740 --> 05:03:13.942
SO.
05:03:14.009 --> 05:03:16.378
IF I DON'T SEE ANY MORE QUESTION
05:03:16.444 --> 05:03:17.512
I SUGGEST I'M SORRY I DON'T
05:03:17.579 --> 05:03:19.147
REALLY ONE MORE AND I APOLOGIZE
05:03:19.214 --> 05:03:21.283
FOR NITPICKING ON HIS* --
05:03:21.349 --> 05:03:22.317
THAT THE ONE OTHER CLARIFICATION
05:03:22.384 --> 05:03:23.852
I WAS GET OUT THE METHODOLOGY
05:03:23.919 --> 05:03:25.353
SECTION DOUBTS GO BACK TO THAT
05:03:25.420 --> 05:03:26.721
EARLIER.
05:03:26.788 --> 05:03:30.225
SECTION THREE OF EQUATOR DATE
05:03:30.292 --> 05:03:31.059
AND IS A THREE WHERE YOU SAID
05:03:31.126 --> 05:03:32.394
THE CONDITION THAT THE ACTUAL
05:03:32.460 --> 05:03:33.895
PROJECT DEFINITION IS RIGHT IN
05:03:33.962 --> 05:03:35.163
SECTION.
05:03:35.230 --> 05:03:37.065
THREE SO A EMISSIONS OFFSET
05:03:37.132 --> 05:03:38.567
CREDIT THIS IS THIS IS MORE
05:03:38.633 --> 05:03:39.301
ABOUT.
05:03:39.367 --> 05:03:41.436
SORT OF LOCAL COMMUNITY BENEFITS
05:03:41.503 --> 05:03:42.704
I KNOW THERE'S BEEN A BIG ISSUE
05:03:42.771 --> 05:03:43.705
THAT ARE CAP AND TRADE DEBATES
05:03:43.772 --> 05:03:45.206
DIRECT EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS
05:03:45.273 --> 05:03:47.676
LOCALIZED --
05:03:47.742 --> 05:03:48.577
TRYING TO MAKE SURE THOSE
05:03:48.643 --> 05:03:49.511
BENEFITS COME BACK TO THIS
05:03:49.578 --> 05:03:50.845
COMMUNITY AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE WE
05:03:50.912 --> 05:03:52.080
DON'T WANT IS FOLKS YOU KNOW BY
05:03:52.147 --> 05:03:53.114
IN THEIR WAY OUT THROUGH A
05:03:53.181 --> 05:03:55.083
FOREST IN THE NORTH COAST OF
05:03:55.150 --> 05:03:56.851
CALIFORNIA AND IN MEANWHILE THE
05:03:56.918 --> 05:03:57.185
COMMUNITY SO.
05:03:57.252 --> 05:03:58.587
IT JUST.
05:03:58.653 --> 05:03:59.521
THOUGH THE LANGUAGE RIGHT NOW
05:03:59.588 --> 05:04:00.455
JUST SAYS EMISSIONS OFFSET
05:04:00.522 --> 05:04:03.158
CREDITS IN THE MARK UP YOU ALL
05:04:03.224 --> 05:04:05.560
PROVIDED --
05:04:05.627 --> 05:04:09.731
BUT IS THERE OPENNESS TO THAT
05:04:09.798 --> 05:04:10.031
[inaudible]
05:04:10.098 --> 05:04:13.068
LOCAL LOCALIZING.
05:04:13.134 --> 05:04:14.502
THOSE OFFSETS OR MIGHT MIND THAT.
05:04:14.569 --> 05:04:16.237
IN MY READING THE WRONG PART
05:04:16.304 --> 05:04:17.672
AGAIN I'M ON PAGE CERTAINLY IT
05:04:17.739 --> 05:04:19.007
SESSION.
05:04:19.074 --> 05:04:21.142
THREE AND AND AND AND INSIGHTS.
05:04:21.209 --> 05:04:24.145
SUBSECTION FOUR OF THERE'S A
05:04:24.212 --> 05:04:27.282
SEPARATE SECTION UNDER.
05:04:27.349 --> 05:04:30.852
OKAY THAT PRIORITIZES LOCAL.
05:04:30.919 --> 05:04:32.320
AFFECT CREDITS ENOUGH THAT
05:04:32.387 --> 05:04:33.254
CREDITS WITHIN THE LAW THE
05:04:33.321 --> 05:04:35.123
REGIONAL AIR DISTRICT.
05:04:35.190 --> 05:04:36.891
ABOVE OTHER OFF THAT CREDIT SO
05:04:36.958 --> 05:04:38.927
DOESN'T REQUIRE IT BUT
05:04:38.994 --> 05:04:40.795
PRIORITIZE FIRED IS IF FEASIBLE
05:04:40.862 --> 05:04:42.764
THEY NEED TO BE PURCHASED.
05:04:42.831 --> 05:04:44.232
LOCAL LOCAL IF MORE WITHIN IT
05:04:44.299 --> 05:04:46.601
WHERE THERE'S A FEASIBLE ME.
05:04:46.668 --> 05:04:47.102
BASICALLY IF IF THEY'RE
05:04:47.168 --> 05:04:50.005
AVAILABLE. TO BE PERFECTLY
05:04:50.071 --> 05:04:51.906
CAPABLE BUT AND NOT IF BUT NOT
05:04:51.973 --> 05:04:54.009
AN ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY ECONOMIC
05:04:54.075 --> 05:04:55.310
REASONS SLIPPER WELL IN THE
05:04:55.377 --> 05:04:57.145
FOREST AND ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY
05:04:57.212 --> 05:04:58.246
COULD PLAY INTO IT IF IT'S TO
05:04:58.313 --> 05:04:59.848
THE POINT WHERE IT WOULD BE.
05:04:59.914 --> 05:05:03.118
ULTIMATE FOR WITH THE PROJECT.
05:05:03.184 --> 05:05:04.085
PERHAPS YOU KEEP CLARIFIED
05:05:04.152 --> 05:05:05.687
BECAUSE WHAT THE CRITERIA YOU'RE
05:05:05.754 --> 05:05:07.656
TALKING ABOUT IS WHAT WOULD GO
05:05:07.722 --> 05:05:10.125
INTO THE E. IR VERSES A
05:05:10.191 --> 05:05:13.662
LEADERSHIP PROJECT UNDER A. B..
05:05:13.728 --> 05:05:14.262
NINE HUNDRED EVERYTHING'S AND
05:05:14.329 --> 05:05:16.064
RIGHT ITS INTEL EN OP R.
05:05:16.131 --> 05:05:18.967
CERTIFIES IT SO SO WE'RE IT
05:05:19.034 --> 05:05:21.970
LOOKS IS THE WORD WERE.
05:05:22.037 --> 05:05:23.738
HAD I I THINK GUYS CALLING OUT
05:05:23.805 --> 05:05:24.906
THESE GOOD THINGS THAT YOU CAN
05:05:24.973 --> 05:05:27.676
LOOK AT WHICH VERSES OKAY IT'S
05:05:27.742 --> 05:05:29.611
THE ER WHATEVER IT IS I THINK
05:05:29.678 --> 05:05:31.046
TELEVISION AND HOME MISTER
05:05:31.112 --> 05:05:32.580
CHAIRMAN.
05:05:32.647 --> 05:05:33.748
SO THERE'S CENTER STARTED TO
05:05:33.815 --> 05:05:36.117
SECTIONS HERE TO PROCESSES.
05:05:36.184 --> 05:05:37.686
ABOUT RIGHT THERE IS THE PROCESS
05:05:37.752 --> 05:05:39.320
BY WHICH YOU QUALIFIED FOR THE
05:05:39.387 --> 05:05:41.656
SICK.
05:05:41.723 --> 05:05:42.824
THAT'S WHERE WE'RE PUTTING IN
05:05:42.891 --> 05:05:44.292
THE NET ZERO STANDARD THAT'S
05:05:44.359 --> 05:05:45.894
WERE PUTTING THE 15% VEHICLE
05:05:45.960 --> 05:05:46.961
TRIPS STANDARD.
05:05:47.028 --> 05:05:47.696
SO WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO
05:05:47.762 --> 05:05:49.064
DEMONSTRATE IN THE HOUR THAT
05:05:49.130 --> 05:05:50.365
WE'RE GOING TO MEET THOSE I
05:05:50.432 --> 05:05:52.033
THINK CARP IS GOING TO NOW BE
05:05:52.100 --> 05:05:53.301
REQUIRED TO SIGN OFF ON THE
05:05:53.368 --> 05:05:55.670
METHODOLOGY THAT GOT US THERE
05:05:55.737 --> 05:05:56.938
WITH THE NET [inaudible]
05:05:57.005 --> 05:05:59.274
ZERO SECONDLY THERE'S THERE'S
05:05:59.340 --> 05:06:01.009
THE PROVISIONS LATER IN THE BILL
05:06:01.076 --> 05:06:02.677
THAT SAY WHEN YOU DO YOUR YEAH I
05:06:02.744 --> 05:06:04.479
ARE.
05:06:04.546 --> 05:06:08.650
YOU HAVE TO DO MITIGATION AND
05:06:08.717 --> 05:06:10.285
WE'D LIKE YOU TO DO.
05:06:10.351 --> 05:06:12.120
IGNITION ONSITE AND THERE'S A
05:06:12.187 --> 05:06:13.488
WHOLE LIST OF THINGS THAT WE
05:06:13.555 --> 05:06:14.823
HOPE TO DO.
05:06:14.889 --> 05:06:16.691
THINGS LIKE ELECTRIC VEHICLES
05:06:16.758 --> 05:06:21.129
THINGS LIKE OTHER THINGS.
05:06:21.196 --> 05:06:22.197
SO OVER YOUR HANDWRITING SO
05:06:22.263 --> 05:06:22.964
THEY'RE READY RIGHT PROVIDING
05:06:23.031 --> 05:06:24.966
COOL ROOFS ALL OF THOSE THINGS
05:06:25.033 --> 05:06:27.769
BICYCLE PARKING THEN WE GO DOWN
05:06:27.836 --> 05:06:29.671
TO OFF SITE BUT STILL LOCAL
05:06:29.738 --> 05:06:31.539
MITIGATION.
05:06:31.606 --> 05:06:33.041
WHICH COULD BE A PRIDE THING
05:06:33.108 --> 05:06:33.341
[inaudible]
05:06:33.408 --> 05:06:35.610
AND THEN.
05:06:35.677 --> 05:06:38.847
HELP THEM OFFSET CREDITS AS WELL.
05:06:38.913 --> 05:06:40.548
AND WE MAY NEED TO USE OFF SITE
05:06:40.615 --> 05:06:41.416
CREDITS BECAUSE WE'RE SETTING
05:06:41.483 --> 05:06:43.151
THE BAR SO HIGH.
05:06:43.218 --> 05:06:44.486
BUT OUR DESIRE ON THE PART OF
05:06:44.552 --> 05:06:45.620
THE DEVELOPER AND THE TEAM
05:06:45.687 --> 05:06:46.755
OWNERS TO MAKE SURE THAT ALL THE
05:06:46.821 --> 05:06:52.427
MITIGATION KERR'S LOCALLY
05:06:52.494 --> 05:06:52.727
[inaudible]
05:06:52.794 --> 05:06:56.064
IT'S NOT.
05:06:56.131 --> 05:06:56.765
ALL THE BOUNCING BALL AND I SURE
05:06:56.831 --> 05:06:58.166
DID WE A CLARIFICATION ON WHAT
05:06:58.233 --> 05:07:00.702
PROPERTY THE BILL COVERS IS IT
05:07:00.769 --> 05:07:01.903
JUST THE TWENTY NINE ACRES OF
05:07:01.970 --> 05:07:03.505
THE FIFTY NINE ACRES IS A THREE
05:07:03.571 --> 05:07:04.439
HUNDRED AND SOME MAKE OUR
05:07:04.506 --> 05:07:06.107
TICKETS TO TWENTY SEVEN ACRES
05:07:06.174 --> 05:07:06.307
RACK.
05:07:06.374 --> 05:07:09.410
THE FOR MY HEAD SO IMPRESSED THE
05:07:09.477 --> 05:07:10.278
PROPER TIME
05:07:10.345 --> 05:07:11.613
RIGHT SO SO I'M MISTER CHAIRMAN
05:07:11.679 --> 05:07:13.148
AND MEMBERS.
05:07:13.214 --> 05:07:13.748
THERE'S A COUPLE THINGS IN THE
05:07:13.815 --> 05:07:15.617
BILL.
05:07:15.683 --> 05:07:18.453
WE HAD THERE WERE TWENTY SEVEN
05:07:18.520 --> 05:07:19.487
POINT WHAT I BELIEVE TWENTY
05:07:19.554 --> 05:07:20.755
SEVEN POINT TWO ACRES I
05:07:20.822 --> 05:07:22.023
SUBSEQUENTLY LEARNED THAT
05:07:22.090 --> 05:07:23.424
THERE'S ACTUALLY ONE ADDITIONAL
05:07:23.491 --> 05:07:25.193
PARCEL WHICH BRINGS IT UP TO
05:07:25.260 --> 05:07:26.861
ALMOST THIRTY ACRES TOLD IF YOU
05:07:26.928 --> 05:07:29.964
INCLUDE SOME OF THE ACTUAL STORY.
05:07:30.031 --> 05:07:31.432
SPACE THAT YOU HAVE TO INCLUDE
05:07:31.499 --> 05:07:33.635
THAT ARE INCLUDED IN PARCELS.
05:07:33.701 --> 05:07:35.470
THE REASON YOU SEE BEFORE YOU
05:07:35.537 --> 05:07:36.471
THE TWO HUNDRED NINETY EIGHT
05:07:36.538 --> 05:07:37.839
ACRES.
05:07:37.906 --> 05:07:39.574
THAT'S REFERENCE IS IN THE
05:07:39.641 --> 05:07:40.608
DESCRIPTION THE LEGAL
05:07:40.675 --> 05:07:41.976
DESCRIPTION THAT THE CITY OF
05:07:42.043 --> 05:07:43.778
INGLEWOOD CREATED WHEN THEY
05:07:43.845 --> 05:07:45.613
CREATED THE SPORTS.
05:07:45.680 --> 05:07:46.247
AND ENTERTAINMENT DISTRICT THAT
05:07:46.314 --> 05:07:48.650
WAS AS AS THE AUTHORS POINTING
05:07:48.716 --> 05:07:50.819
OUT WAS PASSED --
05:07:50.885 --> 05:07:52.921
INITIALLY WITH OF INITIATIVE OF
05:07:52.987 --> 05:07:54.289
THE VOTERS HAVING AWARDED THEN
05:07:54.355 --> 05:07:55.356
SUBSEQUENTLY RATIFIED BY THE
05:07:55.423 --> 05:07:56.691
CITY COUNCIL.
05:07:56.758 --> 05:07:59.227
THAT CREATED THIS DISTRICT WHEN
05:07:59.294 --> 05:08:01.429
THE COUNCIL DID THAT AND WENT
05:08:01.496 --> 05:08:02.630
THROUGH THE SECRET PROCESS.
05:08:02.697 --> 05:08:05.700
IT IN THAT TIME. TWO HUNDRED
05:08:05.767 --> 05:08:06.668
THIRTY EIGHT OF THOSE TWO
05:08:06.734 --> 05:08:07.302
HUNDRED NINETY EIGHT ACRES WERE
05:08:07.368 --> 05:08:08.403
ACTUALLY.
05:08:08.469 --> 05:08:09.804
COVERED IN THE SECRET PROCESS
05:08:09.871 --> 05:08:12.307
THAT OCCURRED BACK IN.
05:08:12.373 --> 05:08:13.308
TWENTY FIFTEEN THERE WERE SIXTY
05:08:13.374 --> 05:08:14.909
ACRES INCLUDED IN THE GENERAL
05:08:14.976 --> 05:08:16.411
PLAN INCLUDING IN THE
05:08:16.477 --> 05:08:19.414
DESCRIPTION OF OF THE DISTRICT.
05:08:19.480 --> 05:08:21.115
THAT WORD NOT AT THAT POINT
05:08:21.182 --> 05:08:21.716
DETERMINED WHAT THEY USE WOULD
05:08:21.783 --> 05:08:23.718
BE.
05:08:23.785 --> 05:08:26.421
SO THAT IS CITY DECIDED IT
05:08:26.487 --> 05:08:28.356
FIFTEEN LET'S NOT INCLUDE THAT
05:08:28.423 --> 05:08:29.891
SIXTY ACRES BECAUSE WE'RE NOT
05:08:29.958 --> 05:08:31.059
SURE WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN
05:08:31.125 --> 05:08:32.126
THERE ALTHOUGH IT IS PLANNED TO
05:08:32.193 --> 05:08:34.095
THE GENERAL PLAN.
05:08:34.162 --> 05:08:35.363
NOW THAT THE CLIPPERS HAVE COME
05:08:35.430 --> 05:08:37.699
ALONG AD RECOGNIZING THAT AS
05:08:37.765 --> 05:08:38.867
WELL -- OUR
05:08:38.933 --> 05:08:40.368
OPPONENTS --
05:08:40.435 --> 05:08:42.937
THE FORM AMNESTY AND THE NEW
05:08:43.004 --> 05:08:44.539
FOOTBALL STADIUM WILL ALL NEED
05:08:44.606 --> 05:08:46.207
MORE PARKING.
05:08:46.274 --> 05:08:47.809
THE THOUGHT WAS THAT THAT SIXTY
05:08:47.876 --> 05:08:48.977
ACRES AMONG OTHER THINGS WOULD
05:08:49.043 --> 05:08:50.945
BE USED FOR A SHARED PARKING
05:08:51.012 --> 05:08:55.083
FACILITY FOR ALL THREE FACILITY.
05:08:55.149 --> 05:08:57.385
THE BASKETBALL ARENA THEN COMES
05:08:57.452 --> 05:08:58.386
TO THIS TWENTY SEVEN POINT TWO
05:08:58.453 --> 05:09:00.955
ACRES UNFORTUNATELY IN THE BILL.
05:09:01.022 --> 05:09:03.291
WE USED THE LEGAL DEFINITION
05:09:03.358 --> 05:09:06.828
FROM THE NEGOTIATING AGREEMENT
05:09:06.895 --> 05:09:07.996
WITH THE CITY THAT'S THE FIFTY
05:09:08.062 --> 05:09:09.998
NINE ACRE REFERENCE.
05:09:10.064 --> 05:09:11.900
IN FACT WE ONLY NEED JUST UNDER
05:09:11.966 --> 05:09:13.902
THIRTY ACRES OF THAT --
05:09:13.968 --> 05:09:15.270
DESTROY SOME POINT TWO PLUS THIS
05:09:15.336 --> 05:09:17.939
ONE OTHER PARCEL --
05:09:18.006 --> 05:09:19.841
AND WE ARE IN THE PROCESS NOW OF
05:09:19.908 --> 05:09:22.410
GETTING EACH PARCEL NUMBER SO WE
05:09:22.477 --> 05:09:23.278
WILL BE ABLE TO SAY IN AN
05:09:23.344 --> 05:09:26.047
AMENDMENT --
05:09:26.114 --> 05:09:27.682
SAID A FIFTY NINE ACRES IT WILL
05:09:27.749 --> 05:09:30.218
SAY TWENTY NINE POINT SOMETHING
05:09:30.285 --> 05:09:33.087
AND ILL HAVE EVERY PARCEL.
05:09:33.154 --> 05:09:35.256
NUMBER THAT IS INCLUDED IN THAT
05:09:35.323 --> 05:09:37.558
A COURT SO YOU KNOW EXACTLY WHAT
05:09:37.625 --> 05:09:38.326
IS A WHAT THE READER PROJECT
05:09:38.393 --> 05:09:38.626
[inaudible]
05:09:38.693 --> 05:09:42.530
CSUS OF WHAT THE BILL APPLIES TO
05:09:42.597 --> 05:09:43.831
AND WHAT IT DOESN'T APPLY TO AND
05:09:43.898 --> 05:09:44.933
THAT WILL I THINK HELP TO
05:09:44.999 --> 05:09:46.267
CLARIFY.
05:09:46.334 --> 05:09:47.769
TURNS IT SOME PEOPLE HAVE ABOUT
05:09:47.835 --> 05:09:50.305
WHAT'S INCLUDED --
05:09:50.371 --> 05:09:51.205
WE HAD A THREE IS THE BEST
05:09:51.272 --> 05:09:52.707
DEFINITION WE COULD BUT I THINK
05:09:52.774 --> 05:09:54.075
WE WILL PROVIDE FOR YOU PARCEL
05:09:54.142 --> 05:09:55.643
NUMBERS.
05:09:55.710 --> 05:09:56.244
EXACTLY BRIDGE AND THAT SHOULD
05:09:56.311 --> 05:09:59.047
CLAIRE [inaudible]
05:09:59.113 --> 05:10:01.215
PERHAPS THIS.
05:10:01.282 --> 05:10:04.552
AS YOUR CONCLUSION --
05:10:04.619 --> 05:10:06.321
I I THINK I ASKED ASSEMBLY
05:10:06.387 --> 05:10:08.256
MEMBER BONTA YOU KNOW WE HAVE
05:10:08.323 --> 05:10:08.556
[inaudible]
05:10:08.623 --> 05:10:12.727
WHY NOT?
05:10:12.794 --> 05:10:13.661
FORMS ARE HERE.
05:10:13.728 --> 05:10:15.096
BECAUSE SOME CENTER GAINES I DID
05:10:15.163 --> 05:10:16.898
NOT SEE YOU THERE PLEASE.
05:10:16.965 --> 05:10:17.532
THE FLOOR IS YOURS IF I IF I
05:10:17.598 --> 05:10:19.033
COULD I JUST --
05:10:19.100 --> 05:10:21.536
IT'S ONE THE WAY END BECAUSE MY
05:10:21.602 --> 05:10:22.770
PERSPECTIVE IS --
05:10:22.837 --> 05:10:24.772
WITH SEGMENT KINGS ARENA.
05:10:24.839 --> 05:10:25.406
THE PROCESS THAT WE WENT THROUGH
05:10:25.473 --> 05:10:26.274
HERE [inaudible]
05:10:26.341 --> 05:10:28.810
THE CIVIC.
05:10:28.876 --> 05:10:32.146
RELOCATE OUR ARENA. TO THE
05:10:32.213 --> 05:10:34.983
DOWNTOWN AREA AND TRANSFORMED
05:10:35.049 --> 05:10:37.785
OUR DOWNTOWN HERE'S OUR I KNOW.
05:10:37.852 --> 05:10:39.487
AND I'M JUST VERY EXCITED AND
05:10:39.554 --> 05:10:41.222
WANT TO THANK THE ASSEMBLY
05:10:41.289 --> 05:10:42.490
MEMBER FOR BRINGING THIS BILL
05:10:42.557 --> 05:10:43.858
FORWARD ON THE OPPORTUNITY THAT
05:10:43.925 --> 05:10:45.626
EXISTS.
05:10:45.693 --> 05:10:48.062
INGLEWOOD TO BE TRANSFORMED AND
05:10:48.129 --> 05:10:49.263
IT WAS A COUPLE YEARS AGO THAT
05:10:49.330 --> 05:10:50.598
WE HAD A BILL COME THROUGH FOR
05:10:50.665 --> 05:10:52.533
THE RAMPS STADIUM.
05:10:52.600 --> 05:10:55.269
AND TO TO SEE THE SUCCESS BEGETS
05:10:55.336 --> 05:10:58.172
SUCCESS --
05:10:58.239 --> 05:10:59.507
IS VERY ENCOURAGING AND VERY
05:10:59.574 --> 05:11:02.210
EXCITING APPEAR DISTRACTED.
05:11:02.276 --> 05:11:04.112
JUST LOOKING AT THE INFORMATION
05:11:04.178 --> 05:11:05.680
THAT I'VE LOOKED AT TERMS OF
05:11:05.747 --> 05:11:06.547
TOWN TEN THOUSAND JOBS BEING
05:11:06.614 --> 05:11:08.182
CREATED.
05:11:08.249 --> 05:11:09.684
AND THEN AFTER THE CONSTRUCTION
05:11:09.751 --> 05:11:10.985
THOUGH BE I'M SURE THOUSANDS OF
05:11:11.052 --> 05:11:12.787
JOBS THAT ARE PERMANENT.
05:11:12.854 --> 05:11:16.624
THAT WILL IMPACT YOUR COMMUNITY --
05:11:16.691 --> 05:11:18.493
THE FACT THAT THE SECOND KINGS
05:11:18.559 --> 05:11:20.361
ARENA I BELIEVE WAS SILVER LEAD
05:11:20.428 --> 05:11:22.030
CERTIFIED AND I THINK YOU'RE AT
05:11:22.096 --> 05:11:23.564
HIGHER LEVELS WHAT IS BEEN
05:11:23.631 --> 05:11:25.033
EXPLAINED TO ME.
05:11:25.099 --> 05:11:26.200
YOUR GOLD.
05:11:26.267 --> 05:11:28.636
SO VERY ENCOURAGING THAT RESPECT
05:11:28.703 --> 05:11:30.505
AND I'M HOPING THAT YOU'LL BE
05:11:30.571 --> 05:11:32.240
RECEIVING GOOD TAX REVENUE INTO
05:11:32.306 --> 05:11:33.941
THE CITY OF INGLEWOOD.
05:11:34.008 --> 05:11:35.476
AS A RESULT OF THIS THAT WILL
05:11:35.543 --> 05:11:37.178
HELP THE CITY AND PROVIDE
05:11:37.245 --> 05:11:39.514
BENEFITS TO THE COMMUNITY AND
05:11:39.580 --> 05:11:41.482
PROSPERITY FOR THE FUTURE.
05:11:41.549 --> 05:11:43.451
SO HOPE.
05:11:43.518 --> 05:11:46.220
YES SO I I'M --
05:11:46.287 --> 05:11:48.122
AND THIS HAD HAPPY THAT I'M HERE
05:11:48.189 --> 05:11:50.825
TO MAKE THE VOTE AND I DON'T UP
05:11:50.892 --> 05:11:51.959
THERE'S BEEN A MOTION MAJOR.
05:11:52.026 --> 05:11:54.495
YOU NEED A MOTION THAT.
05:11:54.562 --> 05:11:55.096
I'LL MAKE IT IF SOMEONE HASN'T
05:11:55.163 --> 05:11:59.367
DONE THAT YET.
05:11:59.434 --> 05:12:06.607
I THINK THERE WAS A MOTION AND
05:12:06.674 --> 05:12:10.645
BUT THAT.
05:12:10.711 --> 05:12:10.845
YEAH.
05:12:10.912 --> 05:12:16.551
I HEARD.
05:12:16.617 --> 05:12:18.219
CELEBRATED.
05:12:18.286 --> 05:12:18.686
SO I WANT TO TELL YOU.
05:12:18.753 --> 05:12:22.790
WHAT? ONE OF THE ANALYSIS I
05:12:22.857 --> 05:12:24.292
THINK EVERYBODY HERE INCLUDING
05:12:24.358 --> 05:12:26.027
THE CHAIR IS TRYING TO DO IS TO
05:12:26.094 --> 05:12:26.694
SAY.
05:12:26.761 --> 05:12:29.997
WHY NOT A SIMPLE EXTENSION OF AB
05:12:30.064 --> 05:12:32.033
NINE HUNDRED WE HAD WOOD EARLIER
05:12:32.100 --> 05:12:33.668
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA TRIED TO
05:12:33.734 --> 05:12:34.702
ARTICULATE?
05:12:34.769 --> 05:12:36.137
Y..
05:12:36.204 --> 05:12:38.439
AB NINE HUNDRED DID NOT WORK FOR
05:12:38.506 --> 05:12:41.142
THAT HIS HIS BILL AND WHAT THEN
05:12:41.209 --> 05:12:42.877
ASSURANCES TO THE TO THE
05:12:42.944 --> 05:12:44.679
COMMITTEE THAT THIS IS.
05:12:44.745 --> 05:12:45.780
THIS IS GOING TO BE SORT OF
05:12:45.847 --> 05:12:47.849
REALLY LIKE.
05:12:47.915 --> 05:12:49.150
AB NINE HUNDRED IT'S GOOD IF IS
05:12:49.217 --> 05:12:50.485
GOING TO BE A PROJECT THAT IS
05:12:50.551 --> 05:12:52.120
THE ENVIRONMENTAL.
05:12:52.186 --> 05:12:53.988
CALL THE COMMITTEE'S CONCERN OR
05:12:54.055 --> 05:12:55.423
IS CONCERNED IS GOING TO BE
05:12:55.490 --> 05:12:58.092
EMBLEMATIC OF THESE LEADERSHIP.
05:12:58.159 --> 05:12:59.560
YOU KNOW SOMETHING THAT TO BE
05:12:59.627 --> 05:13:01.395
PROUD OF SO IF YOU IN YOUR
05:13:01.462 --> 05:13:04.132
pCLOTHES BECAUSE WE HAVE.
05:13:04.198 --> 05:13:05.700
IT'S IT WE HAVE A BIG LEAP HERE --
05:13:05.766 --> 05:13:07.568
OR IT WOULD.
05:13:07.635 --> 05:13:09.670
SO MANY DIFFERENT DRAFTS THAT
05:13:09.737 --> 05:13:10.771
WE'RE VOTING ON SOMETHING THAT'S
05:13:10.838 --> 05:13:13.374
GOING TO GO TO JUDICIARY.
05:13:13.441 --> 05:13:17.712
THAT MAY HAVE SOME YOU KNOW.
05:13:17.778 --> 05:13:19.447
A WHAT'S IT CALLED A
05:13:19.514 --> 05:13:21.449
COMMUNICATION PROBLEMS OR OF HER
05:13:21.516 --> 05:13:23.851
ARE OR WHAT I THOUGHT I RE
05:13:23.918 --> 05:13:25.219
SCREENING WITH WHATEVER'S WHAT
05:13:25.286 --> 05:13:25.520
IT DIDN'T.
05:13:25.586 --> 05:13:26.654
CENTER STERN I SIT ON THAT
05:13:26.721 --> 05:13:28.789
COMMITTEE TOO SO I I WOULD ASK
05:13:28.856 --> 05:13:29.357
IF YOU COULD DO THAT BECAUSE
05:13:29.423 --> 05:13:30.691
THAT WOULD.
05:13:30.758 --> 05:13:33.528
MAYBE CLARIFY THINGS.
05:13:33.594 --> 05:13:35.696
I WELCOME THE OPPORTUNITY AND
05:13:35.763 --> 05:13:37.965
AND AND MAYBE SOME OF THOSE --
05:13:38.032 --> 05:13:39.567
MISS CLARIFYING MOMENTS WHERE
05:13:39.634 --> 05:13:41.502
BECAUSE I'M SO NEW.
05:13:41.569 --> 05:13:44.338
I JUST HERE THREE MONTHS I I I
05:13:44.405 --> 05:13:46.541
AS YOU CAN SEE FROM THE ROBUST
05:13:46.607 --> 05:13:47.175
IN THAT.
05:13:47.241 --> 05:13:49.577
THE VIBRANT CONVERSATION --
05:13:49.644 --> 05:13:50.711
THERE'S A LOT GOING ON WITH THIS
05:13:50.778 --> 05:13:52.513
AREA -- AND
05:13:52.580 --> 05:13:54.348
I DO WANNA RESPOND TO SOME OF
05:13:54.415 --> 05:13:55.149
THE COMMENTS THAT COME UP AS
05:13:55.216 --> 05:13:56.918
WELL I'M CERTAINLY NOT GOING TO
05:13:56.984 --> 05:13:57.885
RESPOND TO SOME OF THE DOG
05:13:57.952 --> 05:13:59.287
WHISTLE COMMENTS THAT WERE MADE
05:13:59.353 --> 05:14:00.788
EARLIER BUT IT IS ABSOLUTELY
05:14:00.855 --> 05:14:02.123
EVIDENT THAT THIS IS A COMMUNITY
05:14:02.190 --> 05:14:04.158
THAT IS AND HAS BEEN STARVED FOR
05:14:04.225 --> 05:14:04.959
RESOURCES FOR QUITE.
05:14:05.026 --> 05:14:06.761
SOMETIME.
05:14:06.827 --> 05:14:09.630
AND IT IS ALSO EVIDENT FROM THE
05:14:09.697 --> 05:14:11.132
COMMUNITY FOLKS WHO HAVE COME UP
05:14:11.199 --> 05:14:12.600
THAT THEY ARE INTERESTED AND
05:14:12.667 --> 05:14:15.670
THEY WELCOME SOME RENEWED ENERGY
05:14:15.736 --> 05:14:16.537
AND COMMITMENT.
05:14:16.604 --> 05:14:18.639
TO INGLEWOOD.
05:14:18.706 --> 05:14:20.608
S. PLACEMENT IS VERY REAL.
05:14:20.675 --> 05:14:21.475
BUT THAT IS A LARGER
05:14:21.542 --> 05:14:23.044
CONVERSATION THAT PROBABLY GOES
05:14:23.110 --> 05:14:24.178
WELL BEYOND THE BODY OF
05:14:24.245 --> 05:14:25.479
ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ON THE
05:14:25.546 --> 05:14:27.181
SENATE SIDE YOU KNOW ALL OF US
05:14:27.248 --> 05:14:28.416
SHOULD BE CONTINUING TO TALK
05:14:28.482 --> 05:14:29.850
ABOUT DISPLACEMENT.
05:14:29.917 --> 05:14:32.553
AS IT IMPACTS RURAL URBAN DANCE
05:14:32.620 --> 05:14:34.355
AND LESLIE POPULATED COMMUNITIES
05:14:34.422 --> 05:14:35.923
THROUGHOUT THE STATE I'M SOME
05:14:35.990 --> 05:14:38.459
COMMENTS WERE MADE ABOUT HOUSING.
05:14:38.526 --> 05:14:40.261
THE ENTIRE INGLEWOOD DEVELOPMENT
05:14:40.328 --> 05:14:41.262
THAT HAS BEEN REFERENCED A
05:14:41.329 --> 05:14:42.230
LITTLE BIT AND SOME OF THE
05:14:42.296 --> 05:14:44.232
COMMENTS WILL AND TWENTY FIVE
05:14:44.298 --> 05:14:45.766
HUNDRED HOMES AND WILL ADD ONE
05:14:45.833 --> 05:14:46.500
THOUSAND APARTMENT UNITS NOW
05:14:46.567 --> 05:14:47.802
THAT IS NOT IN THIS BILL BUT I
05:14:47.868 --> 05:14:49.170
AM TALKING ABOUT AN OVERALL
05:14:49.237 --> 05:14:50.771
LARGER CONVERSATION AS IT
05:14:50.838 --> 05:14:53.574
RELATES TO INGLEWOOD --
05:14:53.641 --> 05:14:55.176
IT'S CERTAINLY NOT APPROPRIATE
05:14:55.243 --> 05:14:56.978
TO DISCUSS SOME OF THE ONGOING
05:14:57.044 --> 05:14:58.446
LITIGATION --
05:14:58.512 --> 05:14:59.747
THAT'S HAPPENING WITH THE CITY
05:14:59.814 --> 05:15:02.683
OF INGLEWOOD BUT I WILL SAY --
05:15:02.750 --> 05:15:04.352
AS THE CHICAGO WOMEN'S A PART
05:15:04.418 --> 05:15:07.054
TIME I'M BROOKLYNITE ON THAT
05:15:07.121 --> 05:15:09.156
IT'S DISHEARTENING REALLY TO SEE
05:15:09.223 --> 05:15:11.025
HIGHLY FUNDED NEW YORKERS COME
05:15:11.092 --> 05:15:12.293
INTO THIS STATE AND PIT
05:15:12.360 --> 05:15:13.828
ANGELENOS AGAINST ANGELENOS WHEN
05:15:13.894 --> 05:15:15.196
WE SHOULD ALL BE WORKING
05:15:15.263 --> 05:15:16.497
TOGETHER TO FIGURE OUT WAYS.
05:15:16.564 --> 05:15:18.899
HOW TO UPLIFT THE CITY OF
05:15:18.966 --> 05:15:19.500
INGLEWOOD AND ITS SURROUNDING
05:15:19.567 --> 05:15:21.969
COMMUNITIES THIS IS ABOUT?
05:15:22.036 --> 05:15:24.438
INVESTING IN INGLEWOOD.
05:15:24.505 --> 05:15:25.306
NOT IN ONE PERSON OR ONE GROUP'S
05:15:25.373 --> 05:15:28.175
POCKETS.
05:15:28.242 --> 05:15:29.610
THE REASON WHY WE ARE ASKING FOR
05:15:29.677 --> 05:15:30.811
THIS BILL.
05:15:30.878 --> 05:15:33.014
IS BECAUSE OF TIMING.
05:15:33.080 --> 05:15:34.715
IF WE COULD DO IT ANY OTHER WAY
05:15:34.782 --> 05:15:36.817
WE WOULD THIS IS A DIFFICULT
05:15:36.884 --> 05:15:39.053
PROCESS TO COME HERE AND I THINK
05:15:39.120 --> 05:15:40.988
BEFORE YOU OFF YEAH I GUESS WE
05:15:41.055 --> 05:15:42.256
HAVE TALKED ABOUT THE TRYING TO
05:15:42.323 --> 05:15:43.858
STOP BEING TWENTY TWENTY FOUR
05:15:43.924 --> 05:15:44.825
WHICH I THINK I'M WAS MENTIONED
05:15:44.892 --> 05:15:45.760
EARLIER.
05:15:45.826 --> 05:15:47.295
AND WE ALSO TALKED ABOUT THE
05:15:47.361 --> 05:15:48.896
NEED -- TO
05:15:48.963 --> 05:15:51.532
MEET THE 15% OUT REDUCTION THAT
05:15:51.599 --> 05:15:53.901
WE ARE IN ENTIRELY IN COMMITTED
05:15:53.968 --> 05:15:56.037
UNTIE REALLY A 100% COMMITTED TO
05:15:56.103 --> 05:15:57.405
MEETING --
05:15:57.471 --> 05:15:59.307
THIS IS A GROUP THAT IS
05:15:59.373 --> 05:16:01.876
COMMITTED. TO REACHING ALL OF
05:16:01.942 --> 05:16:03.444
THE THINGS THAT WE HAVE
05:16:03.511 --> 05:16:04.712
STIPULATED IN THE BILL AND IN
05:16:04.779 --> 05:16:07.014
THE CONTINUING CONVERSATIONS OUT
05:16:07.081 --> 05:16:09.250
AND IN THE AMENDMENTS --
05:16:09.317 --> 05:16:10.584
THIS IS --
05:16:10.651 --> 05:16:12.386
PROBABLY GOING TO BE VERY HARD
05:16:12.453 --> 05:16:13.621
BUT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE
05:16:13.688 --> 05:16:14.889
WANT TO DO BECAUSE IT'S ACTUALLY
05:16:14.955 --> 05:16:15.656
SOMETHING THAT THE CITY OF
05:16:15.723 --> 05:16:19.894
INGLEWOOD DESERVES --
05:16:19.960 --> 05:16:22.196
IT WILL BE GETTING TO THE NINE
05:16:22.263 --> 05:16:23.531
HUNDRED AYE AYE THERE'S A LOT
05:16:23.597 --> 05:16:24.732
HERE AND THERE.
05:16:24.799 --> 05:16:26.867
BUT BUT I THINK TO HELP MY
05:16:26.934 --> 05:16:29.070
COMMITTEE MEMBERS WE'VE GOT SOME
05:16:29.136 --> 05:16:31.706
ANALYSIS ON PAGE SEVENTEEN
05:16:31.772 --> 05:16:33.607
THERE'S BEEN SOME AMENDMENTS.
05:16:33.674 --> 05:16:35.276
AND THEN THERE'S BEEN SOME.
05:16:35.343 --> 05:16:38.612
OUR ORAL REPRESENTATIONS WE HAVE
05:16:38.679 --> 05:16:40.981
THE IT AND TO SEE IF I'M MISSING
05:16:41.048 --> 05:16:42.516
ANYTHING YOU KNOW WE HAVE.
05:16:42.583 --> 05:16:44.051
AB NINE HUNDRED REQUIRES
05:16:44.118 --> 05:16:45.519
COMPLETE COMPLIANCE WITH SECRET
05:16:45.586 --> 05:16:47.355
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ANALYSIS.
05:16:47.421 --> 05:16:49.323
WE'VE HAD SOME DISCUSSIONS ABOUT
05:16:49.390 --> 05:16:50.925
WHAT WOULD BE AND IT WILL BE THE
05:16:50.991 --> 05:16:52.226
FACTORS TO CONTINUE.
05:16:52.293 --> 05:16:54.662
ARE HAD TO CONSIDER.
05:16:54.729 --> 05:16:57.331
AND DO YOUR UNDERSTANDING IT YOU
05:16:57.398 --> 05:16:59.066
KNOW THAT THE STAFF REPORT SAYS
05:16:59.133 --> 05:17:00.701
IT WEAKENS THE STANDARDS FOR
05:17:00.768 --> 05:17:02.770
GREENHOUSE AT EMISSIONS ANALYSIS
05:17:02.837 --> 05:17:04.105
AND TRANSPORTATION HOUSES WE
05:17:04.171 --> 05:17:05.506
TALKED ABOUT.
05:17:05.573 --> 05:17:07.675
ABOUT THOSE REFUTE BICU.
05:17:07.742 --> 05:17:10.511
LET BURKE COMMITTEE MEMBERS KNOW.
05:17:10.578 --> 05:17:11.812
YES THAT'S TRUE WITH IT IF IT
05:17:11.879 --> 05:17:13.147
DOESN'T OR NO I THINK OUR
05:17:13.214 --> 05:17:14.915
AMENDMENTS THAT WE BELIEVE ARE
05:17:14.982 --> 05:17:16.517
AMENDMENTS MEET THOSE THREE
05:17:16.584 --> 05:17:18.252
REQUIREMENTS BECAUSE THERE COULD
05:17:18.319 --> 05:17:21.489
BE LOOKING AT THIS AND I WANT
05:17:21.555 --> 05:17:22.757
YOU TO I WANT I WANT TO BE SURE
05:17:22.823 --> 05:17:22.957
THAT.
05:17:23.023 --> 05:17:24.759
WHEN WE GET TO CERTIFICATION
05:17:24.825 --> 05:17:26.427
THAT DOESN'T REQUIRE IT WE HAVE
05:17:26.494 --> 05:17:27.628
THE CARP?
05:17:27.695 --> 05:17:30.264
CERTIFICATION BUT WE DON'T HAVE.
05:17:30.331 --> 05:17:32.466
THE MAYOR OF INGLEWOOD SAYING
05:17:32.533 --> 05:17:33.234
HERE THAT WHEN IT GOES THROUGH
05:17:33.300 --> 05:17:35.403
OUR IF WE GET WE GET THE CARBON
05:17:35.469 --> 05:17:36.771
I GET THAT BUT THERE'S THESE
05:17:36.837 --> 05:17:38.239
DEVELOPMENT PLANS WE DON'T HAVE.
05:17:38.305 --> 05:17:40.474
THE ENTITY THAT SOME MEMBERS HAD
05:17:40.541 --> 05:17:42.309
TALKED ABOUT THE CONFIDENCE THAT
05:17:42.376 --> 05:17:44.612
THEY HAD IN OAKLAND MAKING SURE
05:17:44.678 --> 05:17:48.749
THAT THEY WOULD --
05:17:48.816 --> 05:17:51.585
FULL LEAVE DISCUSS THE MERITS OF
05:17:51.652 --> 05:17:53.354
WHATEVER PROJECT CAME TO
05:17:53.421 --> 05:17:54.955
QUESTION BECAUSE BOTH PROJECTS.
05:17:55.022 --> 05:17:56.557
AGAIN I DON'T I'M IF I DON'T
05:17:56.624 --> 05:17:57.691
HAVE A PIECE OF PAPER OF WHAT
05:17:57.758 --> 05:17:59.093
THE PROJECTS COULD DO SO THEY
05:17:59.160 --> 05:18:00.828
HAVE THAT IN COMMON.
05:18:00.895 --> 05:18:03.597
SO I I I MAY BE REPETITIVE BUT I
05:18:03.664 --> 05:18:05.466
THINK NO NO I SHOULD HAVE MOVING
05:18:05.533 --> 05:18:07.334
YES YES AND I I CERTAINLY HERE
05:18:07.401 --> 05:18:08.702
YOU AYE WE DO HAVE THE CITY OF
05:18:08.769 --> 05:18:10.004
INGLEWOOD HERE.
05:18:10.070 --> 05:18:12.173
WHO I THINK DID SPEAK --
05:18:12.239 --> 05:18:14.542
IN SUPPORT OF THE ISSUE --
05:18:14.608 --> 05:18:18.012
AND THE MAYOR BINGO COUNSEL HAS
05:18:18.078 --> 05:18:19.814
A 100% ON BOARD AND ENTIRELY
05:18:19.880 --> 05:18:21.148
COMMITTED TO ALL OF THE THINGS
05:18:21.215 --> 05:18:22.483
THAT HAVE BEEN DISCUSSED I DO
05:18:22.550 --> 05:18:23.951
BELIEVE IN FACT THAT THE MAYOR I
05:18:24.018 --> 05:18:25.453
THINK OF ATTENDING A COMMUNITY
05:18:25.519 --> 05:18:26.687
MEETING --
05:18:26.754 --> 05:18:28.622
TO MAKE SURE --
05:18:28.689 --> 05:18:31.258
THAT -- THE
05:18:31.325 --> 05:18:32.660
COMMITMENTS ARE THERE IN TERMS
05:18:32.726 --> 05:18:34.061
OF BEING INTERACTIVE AND HAVING
05:18:34.128 --> 05:18:35.329
THAT KIND OF PROCESS AS IT
05:18:35.396 --> 05:18:36.931
RELATES TO THIS AND AND AND
05:18:36.997 --> 05:18:38.499
OTHER DEVELOPMENT ISSUES THAT
05:18:38.566 --> 05:18:43.604
ARE GOING ON AYE AYE AYE.
05:18:43.671 --> 05:18:46.874
YOUR CREDIBILITY IS ON THE LINE.
05:18:46.941 --> 05:18:50.444
THIS IS MY VERY FIRST BILL.
05:18:50.511 --> 05:18:53.013
THE LAST THING I WANNA DO.
05:18:53.080 --> 05:18:54.081
IS SAY THAT I'M GOING TO STAND
05:18:54.148 --> 05:18:55.983
FOR SOMETHING.
05:18:56.050 --> 05:18:56.817
AND THEN NOT STAND UP AND
05:18:56.884 --> 05:18:59.186
DELIVER.
05:18:59.253 --> 05:19:00.087
THAT'S NOT HOW I WOULD WANT TO
05:19:00.154 --> 05:19:01.388
START.
05:19:01.455 --> 05:19:03.624
MY LEGACY HERE.
05:19:03.691 --> 05:19:05.426
I'M I YOU PROBABLY HEARD THAT
05:19:05.493 --> 05:19:07.394
YOU KNOW FROM OTHER FOLKS --
05:19:07.461 --> 05:19:09.129
BUT THIS IS SOMETHING THAT THE
05:19:09.196 --> 05:19:11.832
DEVELOPERS THAT THE CITY COUNCIL
05:19:11.899 --> 05:19:13.067
AND THAT THE MAYOR OF ANYWAY.
05:19:13.133 --> 05:19:17.238
ON IN IS ENTIRELY COMMITTED.
05:19:17.304 --> 05:19:20.441
TO STERLING CAN YOU.
05:19:20.508 --> 05:19:22.977
ADD TO THAT ANYTHING TO THE
05:19:23.043 --> 05:19:24.078
PROJECT DEFINITION.
05:19:24.144 --> 05:19:25.746
SO OKAY ON THE PROJECT
05:19:25.813 --> 05:19:27.281
DEFINITION [inaudible]
05:19:27.348 --> 05:19:28.649
WE'VE GOT [inaudible]
05:19:28.716 --> 05:19:31.919
AND ARENA --
05:19:31.986 --> 05:19:33.921
ANCILLARY FACILITIES WHICH IS
05:19:33.988 --> 05:19:36.090
THE SPORTS MEDICAL CLINIC WHICH
05:19:36.156 --> 05:19:37.458
WILL BE AVAILABLE COMMUNITY
05:19:37.525 --> 05:19:37.758
[inaudible]
05:19:37.825 --> 05:19:45.699
WE WE HAVE THE OFFICE SPACE.
05:19:45.766 --> 05:19:46.300
I'M I'M GETTING GOOD HELPED
05:19:46.367 --> 05:19:47.868
WRITE THE PRACTICE FACILITY FOR
05:19:47.935 --> 05:19:48.669
THE TEAM --
05:19:48.736 --> 05:19:50.304
A FIVE FIFTY FIVE HUNDRED SQUARE
05:19:50.371 --> 05:19:51.772
FOOT COMMUNITY SPACE FOR
05:19:51.839 --> 05:19:55.376
COMMUNITY USE.
05:19:55.442 --> 05:19:57.645
FOR WE HAVE --
05:19:57.711 --> 05:19:59.513
OUTDOOR BASKETBALL COURTS WITH
05:19:59.580 --> 05:20:00.447
THE ARENA ITSELF I DON'T FORGET
05:20:00.514 --> 05:20:01.348
THAT.
05:20:01.415 --> 05:20:03.317
AND WE HAVE RETAIL SPACE AND
05:20:03.384 --> 05:20:08.155
RESTAURANTS BUT AND I THINK.
05:20:08.222 --> 05:20:09.924
AND THE SIX BIG OPEN SPACE PLAZA
05:20:09.990 --> 05:20:11.225
THAT WILL HAVE.
05:20:11.292 --> 05:20:14.862
SOME OF THE GOOD THINGS --
05:20:14.929 --> 05:20:16.864
AND THEN THERE'S PARKING AS WELL.
05:20:16.931 --> 05:20:19.266
I THINK I'VE.
05:20:19.333 --> 05:20:21.001
WITH THE HELP COVERS ALL.
05:20:21.068 --> 05:20:22.736
ALL OF THAT AND I THINK.
05:20:22.803 --> 05:20:23.938
I THINK THERE WHY BECAUSE YOU
05:20:24.004 --> 05:20:27.608
WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT IS --
05:20:27.675 --> 05:20:30.878
WHAT I EXPLAINED IN TERMS OF --
05:20:30.945 --> 05:20:32.413
THE SIXTY ACRE PARCEL WITH A
05:20:32.479 --> 05:20:34.381
SHARED PARKING FACILITY AND THEN
05:20:34.448 --> 05:20:37.284
THE TWENTY NINE THIRTY ACRES.
05:20:37.351 --> 05:20:39.787
WHERE ALL OF THE ARENA AND THE
05:20:39.853 --> 05:20:40.421
SIX WILL FIT THAT'S ESSENTIALLY
05:20:40.487 --> 05:20:40.988
THE PROJECT?
05:20:41.055 --> 05:20:42.423
THE TWO HUNDRED THIRTY EIGHT
05:20:42.489 --> 05:20:43.524
OTHER ACRES THAT ARE INCLUDED IN
05:20:43.591 --> 05:20:44.825
THAT LEGAL DEFINITION WERE
05:20:44.892 --> 05:20:47.261
ALREADY DONE TO SEE QUIRK AND
05:20:47.328 --> 05:20:49.863
RECEIVED THEIR REVIEW AND THEIR
05:20:49.930 --> 05:20:50.965
IMPACT SUPPORT SO.
05:20:51.031 --> 05:20:53.000
SO THE PROJECT IS THAT.
05:20:53.067 --> 05:20:56.103
OF IN TERMS OF THE CITY.
05:20:56.170 --> 05:20:58.072
WHAT WE'VE OFFERED IS THAT THE
05:20:58.138 --> 05:20:59.540
LEAD AGENCY WHICH WE HAVE A CITY
05:20:59.607 --> 05:21:01.308
IS ACTUALLY REQUIRED IN THE
05:21:01.375 --> 05:21:03.644
STATUTE? TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL
05:21:03.711 --> 05:21:05.512
MITIGATION.
05:21:05.579 --> 05:21:06.747
IF IT'S DETERMINED WE DON'T NEED
05:21:06.814 --> 05:21:11.185
THE PAN OF THE NETZERO.
05:21:11.251 --> 05:21:13.020
GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSION AFTER
05:21:13.087 --> 05:21:15.823
THE FIRST YEAR OF OPERATION SO.
05:21:15.889 --> 05:21:17.191
I I THINK I UNDERSTAND THE
05:21:17.257 --> 05:21:19.093
CREDIBILITY IS IMPORTANT.
05:21:19.159 --> 05:21:20.894
I THINK THE BEST WAY TO DO THAT.
05:21:20.961 --> 05:21:22.129
OBVIOUSLY THE MAYOR OF OAKLAND
05:21:22.196 --> 05:21:24.498
DEMONSTRATED THEIR THEIR TRUST
05:21:24.565 --> 05:21:26.266
AND THEIR COMMITMENT.
05:21:26.333 --> 05:21:27.835
IF YOU PUT IT IN THE STATUTE AND
05:21:27.901 --> 05:21:29.436
SAVE THE LEAD AGENCY MUST
05:21:29.503 --> 05:21:31.171
REQUIRE MITIGATION IF THEY
05:21:31.238 --> 05:21:33.407
DETERMINE THAT THE NOT SO.
05:21:33.474 --> 05:21:34.808
IS NOT MET AFTER THE FIRST YEAR
05:21:34.875 --> 05:21:38.579
THAT'S THE STRONGEST WAY.
05:21:38.646 --> 05:21:40.648
WE HER PRECLUSION THE SIXTY
05:21:40.714 --> 05:21:42.716
ACRES AND IS ONLY FOR PARKING.
05:21:42.783 --> 05:21:43.283
IT'S RESTRICT DOES IT FOR
05:21:43.350 --> 05:21:44.018
CURRENTLY SITS ANYTHING UNDER
05:21:44.084 --> 05:21:45.986
THE GENERAL.
05:21:46.053 --> 05:21:47.221
SO MAKE SURE THAT'S WHAT.
05:21:47.287 --> 05:21:48.722
I THINK THIS THE THIRTY POINT TO
05:21:48.789 --> 05:21:50.290
WEAR WHATEVER THAT DESCRIPTION
05:21:50.357 --> 05:21:52.760
IS.
05:21:52.826 --> 05:21:55.195
AND SO -- IT
05:21:55.262 --> 05:21:57.031
COULD BE AND THIS IS WHY IT
05:21:57.097 --> 05:21:58.732
WASN'T INCLUDED ORIGINALLY IT'S
05:21:58.799 --> 05:22:00.768
NOW THE SUBJECT OF A DISCUSSION
05:22:00.834 --> 05:22:01.969
FOR SHARED PARKING [inaudible]
05:22:02.036 --> 05:22:03.570
DREAM [inaudible]
05:22:03.637 --> 05:22:05.305
A FORM.
05:22:05.372 --> 05:22:08.642
THE RAM WHO IS A CLIENT THE RAMS.
05:22:08.709 --> 05:22:10.144
AND THE COVERAGE.
05:22:10.210 --> 05:22:11.578
IT COULD BE THAT IN FACT THERE
05:22:11.645 --> 05:22:13.480
MIGHT BE SOME.
05:22:13.547 --> 05:22:15.015
COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT TO
05:22:15.082 --> 05:22:17.251
SUPPORT THAT PARKING AND THE
05:22:17.317 --> 05:22:19.787
TWENTY FIVE HUNDRED HOMES.
05:22:19.853 --> 05:22:20.821
THAT A LOT BUT WE'RE TALKING
05:22:20.888 --> 05:22:22.056
ABOUT SIXTY ACRES AND THERE'S A
05:22:22.122 --> 05:22:23.057
NEED.
05:22:23.123 --> 05:22:24.725
MSG ALONG THE FORM HAS
05:22:24.792 --> 05:22:26.427
IDENTIFIED NEED OF THREE
05:22:26.493 --> 05:22:28.295
THOUSAND PARKING SPACES.
05:22:28.362 --> 05:22:29.596
THE RAMS STADIUM WILL MEAN
05:22:29.663 --> 05:22:31.432
SIGNIFICANTLY MORE THAN THAT AND
05:22:31.498 --> 05:22:32.499
THE OF COURSE THE CLIPPERS AS
05:22:32.566 --> 05:22:33.967
WELL WE CAN ONLY PUT SO MUCH
05:22:34.034 --> 05:22:35.402
PARKING ON THE TWENTY SEVEN ACRE
05:22:35.469 --> 05:22:36.203
SO.
05:22:36.270 --> 05:22:38.272
I I HAVE NO PROBLEM SAY THE VAST
05:22:38.338 --> 05:22:40.340
MAJORITY OF THAT SIXTY ACRES
05:22:40.407 --> 05:22:42.142
WILL BE PARK.
05:22:42.209 --> 05:22:43.510
I CAN'T SAY 1100% BUT THE VAST
05:22:43.577 --> 05:22:46.113
MAJORITY.
05:22:46.180 --> 05:22:46.880
OKAY I'M TRYING.
05:22:46.947 --> 05:22:48.949
TO SQUEEZE OUT SOME CLARITY AND
05:22:49.016 --> 05:22:51.218
AND AGAIN I KEEP FALL GOING BACK
05:22:51.285 --> 05:22:53.587
TO THE COMPARISONS WITH AB NINE
05:22:53.654 --> 05:22:54.555
HUNDRED BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THE
05:22:54.621 --> 05:22:57.257
THAT'S MEMBERS HERE HAVE ALREADY
05:22:57.324 --> 05:22:58.358
VOTED ON DAD.
05:22:58.425 --> 05:23:00.928
AND THEY THEY FEEL.
05:23:00.994 --> 05:23:03.530
NOTWITHSTANDING THE TWO HUNDRED
05:23:03.597 --> 05:23:04.331
SEVENTY EIGHT JUDICIAL REVIEW
05:23:04.398 --> 05:23:05.666
THAT THE JUDICIAL COUNCILS HERE
05:23:05.733 --> 05:23:07.901
THEY THEY FEEL THAT THERE'S SOME
05:23:07.968 --> 05:23:09.636
OUR CONFIDENCE THAT THAT WE'RE
05:23:09.703 --> 05:23:11.472
GOING TO GET THE END PRODUCT IS
05:23:11.538 --> 05:23:11.772
GOING TO BE.
05:23:11.839 --> 05:23:14.241
A A POSITIVE A POSITIVE THING
05:23:14.308 --> 05:23:18.145
AND WE'VE HEARD HOW DIFFERENT
05:23:18.212 --> 05:23:20.280
ELEMENTS ARE DIFFERENT FROM THE
05:23:20.347 --> 05:23:23.217
A. B..
05:23:23.283 --> 05:23:24.384
NINE HUNDRED IS THERE ANYTHING
05:23:24.451 --> 05:23:26.286
THAT MIRRORS THE EIGHT P. NINE
05:23:26.353 --> 05:23:26.887
HUNDRED THAT [inaudible]
05:23:26.954 --> 05:23:28.922
THAT.
05:23:28.989 --> 05:23:30.290
AND MAYBE IT HASN'T BEEN
05:23:30.357 --> 05:23:31.959
ARTICULATED IN THAT WAY BUT OF
05:23:32.025 --> 05:23:33.660
THAT YOU KNOW I I I THINK
05:23:33.727 --> 05:23:36.897
PROBABLY THE FEB COMPETENT JOB
05:23:36.964 --> 05:23:39.266
C. O. K. IT'S INFILL.
05:23:39.333 --> 05:23:41.401
BUT BUT IF YOU CAN HELP US OUT
05:23:41.468 --> 05:23:43.604
WITH WITH SORT OF THIS IS REALLY
05:23:43.670 --> 05:23:46.473
A MINOR DIFFERENCE OR THIS IS
05:23:46.540 --> 05:23:46.774
[inaudible]
05:23:46.840 --> 05:23:50.310
I I MAPPING OUT MISTER CHAIRMAN
05:23:50.377 --> 05:23:52.012
I I THINK FOR THE MOST PART.
05:23:52.079 --> 05:23:54.281
AS I RECALL.
05:23:54.348 --> 05:23:56.650
THE STANDARD OTHER STANDS IN AB
05:23:56.717 --> 05:23:57.751
NINE HUNDRED OTHER THAN THE NET
05:23:57.818 --> 05:23:58.719
ZERO IN THE TRANSPORTATION
05:23:58.786 --> 05:24:00.387
EFFICIENCY ARE.
05:24:00.454 --> 05:24:02.322
THE PREVAILING WAGE JOBS WE'VE
05:24:02.389 --> 05:24:04.291
COVERED THAT WITH PROJECT LABOR.
05:24:04.358 --> 05:24:05.759
THE ARE A HUNDRED MILLION
05:24:05.826 --> 05:24:07.227
DOLLARS INVESTMENT OR WE'RE
05:24:07.294 --> 05:24:07.761
GOING TO BE ONE POINT FIVE
05:24:07.828 --> 05:24:09.863
BILLION --
05:24:09.930 --> 05:24:11.298
IT'S INFILL ACQUIREMENT WERE
05:24:11.365 --> 05:24:14.434
DEATHLY INFILL --
05:24:14.501 --> 05:24:16.370
GOLD LEAD CERTIFIED GOLD WE'RE
05:24:16.436 --> 05:24:18.338
WE'RE GOING TO MEET THAT ONE SO
05:24:18.405 --> 05:24:19.973
BROAD THAT ARE THERE.
05:24:20.040 --> 05:24:20.574
I DON'T THINK WE MISSED ANY OF
05:24:20.641 --> 05:24:21.441
THOSE STANDARDS [inaudible]
05:24:21.508 --> 05:24:23.177
OTHER THAN.
05:24:23.243 --> 05:24:25.612
THE VEHICLE TRIPS HAVING A
05:24:25.679 --> 05:24:26.180
LITTLE BIT MORE TIME TO MEET
05:24:26.246 --> 05:24:28.982
THAT COULD.
05:24:29.049 --> 05:24:30.117
SO I THINK WE'VE HIT THE MALL
05:24:30.184 --> 05:24:32.252
WHERE I LEFT AND YOU KNOW.
05:24:32.319 --> 05:24:34.121
JUST SO YOU KNOW I KNOW THIS IS
05:24:34.188 --> 05:24:34.822
YOUR FIRST BILL I'M.
05:24:34.888 --> 05:24:38.392
GONNA MISS I CAN LARGER DOVE.
05:24:38.458 --> 05:24:40.427
I NEVER DO THIS.
05:24:40.494 --> 05:24:43.297
I NEVER NEGOTIATE A BILL AS
05:24:43.363 --> 05:24:45.632
COMPLEX IS THIS FROM THE DAIS
05:24:45.699 --> 05:24:45.933
[inaudible]
05:24:45.999 --> 05:24:48.435
EVER.
05:24:48.502 --> 05:24:51.638
EVER I I TRIED TO DO THIS IN THE
05:24:51.705 --> 05:24:53.207
OFFICE I TRIED TO DO EIGHT WHERE
05:24:53.273 --> 05:24:55.509
I FEEL COMFORTABLE AND I GIVE
05:24:55.576 --> 05:24:57.344
PEOPLE A BACKUP I'M.
05:24:57.411 --> 05:24:58.812
BECAUSE WE'VE GOT SO MANY THINGS
05:24:58.879 --> 05:25:02.616
GOING ON THAT THERE'S A NOTES A
05:25:02.683 --> 05:25:04.384
PUBLIC HEARING AND IT IT IT IT
05:25:04.451 --> 05:25:05.586
IS WITHIN IT IS WHAT IT IS WHEN
05:25:05.652 --> 05:25:08.455
WHENI HEAR FROM EVERYBODY SO --
05:25:08.522 --> 05:25:11.225
I'M IRAQ.
05:25:11.291 --> 05:25:12.392
THEN I JUST WANNA SAY I APPLAUD
05:25:12.459 --> 05:25:15.195
AND APPRECIATE YOUR RESILIENCE.
05:25:15.262 --> 05:25:17.831
SO SO WE HAVE.
05:25:17.898 --> 05:25:21.501
IT SEEMS AS THOUGH WE HAVE --
05:25:21.568 --> 05:25:22.803
THREE OPTIONS [inaudible]
05:25:22.870 --> 05:25:26.773
RIGHT -- ONE
05:25:26.840 --> 05:25:29.042
OPTION IS TO JUST THROW IT OUT
05:25:29.109 --> 05:25:32.646
THERE IS TO TO SIMPLY EXTEND AB
05:25:32.713 --> 05:25:33.680
NINE HIGHER FOR THREE YEARS TO
05:25:33.747 --> 05:25:35.349
GIVE.
05:25:35.415 --> 05:25:37.351
YOU'RE YOUR FOLKS THAT THE TIME
05:25:37.417 --> 05:25:39.086
THAT THEY NEED TAKE TO GET THE
05:25:39.152 --> 05:25:42.356
PROJECT DONE UNDER THE A. B..
05:25:42.422 --> 05:25:44.491
NINE HUNDRED THAT CREATES SOME.
05:25:44.558 --> 05:25:45.525
SOME CHALLENGES BUT AT LEAST
05:25:45.592 --> 05:25:47.527
FROM.
05:25:47.594 --> 05:25:48.562
THIS A BASKETBALL GAME SO
05:25:48.629 --> 05:25:49.897
RUNNING OUT THE CLOCK THAT THAT
05:25:49.963 --> 05:25:52.799
THAT'S ACHIEVES THAT.
05:25:52.866 --> 05:25:56.270
THAT THAT WE KNOW WHAT THAT IS.
05:25:56.336 --> 05:25:57.104
FOR PEOPLE ARE OPPOSED TO ENTER
05:25:57.170 --> 05:26:00.974
A AGREE TO IT.
05:26:01.041 --> 05:26:03.911
I'M PREPARED TO DO [inaudible]
05:26:03.977 --> 05:26:07.314
TO TO ACCEPT THAT AS A AS AS A
05:26:07.381 --> 05:26:09.049
VEHICLE GOING FORWARD.
05:26:09.116 --> 05:26:12.085
THE SECOND OPTION IS
05:26:12.152 --> 05:26:12.386
[inaudible]
05:26:12.452 --> 05:26:14.655
TO GO.
05:26:14.721 --> 05:26:15.989
FOR MOVE THE EARTH KILL THE BILL
05:26:16.056 --> 05:26:17.391
THE SUSPECT THAT SECOND OPTION
05:26:17.457 --> 05:26:19.893
IS KILLED BILL AND SAY WE HAVE
05:26:19.960 --> 05:26:23.363
SOME ASSURANCES BUT IT'S JUST
05:26:23.430 --> 05:26:23.897
TWO NEBULOUS TOO UNCERTAIN
05:26:23.964 --> 05:26:24.197
[inaudible]
05:26:24.264 --> 05:26:27.634
THIS IS THIS IS MAKES US NERVOUS
05:26:27.701 --> 05:26:30.637
I'M AND CHECK A COMEBACK AND
05:26:30.704 --> 05:26:31.638
THIRD OPTION IS.
05:26:31.705 --> 05:26:35.208
TO TAKE IT --
05:26:35.275 --> 05:26:38.578
MOVE THE BILL AS AMENDED.
05:26:38.645 --> 05:26:41.415
SUCH AS IT IS WHOEVER I I WISH I
05:26:41.481 --> 05:26:43.150
HAD A CLEAR UNDERSTANDING OF ALL
05:26:43.216 --> 05:26:44.685
THE DETAILS OF DIFFERENT DROPS
05:26:44.751 --> 05:26:46.253
THAT WE HAVE WHICH WE'VE.
05:26:46.320 --> 05:26:47.854
I KNOW I KNOW THIS IS ON TAPE ON
05:26:47.921 --> 05:26:50.057
THE TO BE ABLE TO GO OVER AND DO
05:26:50.123 --> 05:26:50.290
IT I'M.
05:26:50.357 --> 05:26:53.293
BUT FOLKS ARE LOOKING FOR ME FOR
05:26:53.360 --> 05:26:55.762
LEADERSHIP --
05:26:55.829 --> 05:26:57.230
AT THIS PARTICULAR MOMENT SINCE
05:26:57.297 --> 05:26:59.466
ON THE CHAIR SO I'M I'M I'VE
05:26:59.533 --> 05:27:01.401
EXPRESSED THOSE CONCERNS PRIOR
05:27:01.468 --> 05:27:05.872
TO THE HEARING SUITED ARM I HAVE --
05:27:05.939 --> 05:27:09.776
FELT SOME ASSURANCES WITH HAVING --
05:27:09.843 --> 05:27:11.578
AT THE AIRPORT I AT LEAST
05:27:11.645 --> 05:27:13.246
CERTIFY THE PROJECT YOU HAVE YOU
05:27:13.313 --> 05:27:14.181
HAVE THAT'S THAT'S ANSWER THE
05:27:14.247 --> 05:27:15.882
BIG QUESTION THAT THAT I HAVE.
05:27:15.949 --> 05:27:17.050
AND I'M.
05:27:17.117 --> 05:27:21.388
SOME OF THE OTHER --
05:27:21.455 --> 05:27:25.459
CONCERNS THAT'S BEEN RACING.
05:27:25.525 --> 05:27:26.760
SO THAT CITIZENS.
05:27:26.827 --> 05:27:28.562
THAT THOSE ARE THE THREE OPTIONS
05:27:28.628 --> 05:27:29.863
I THINK WE HAVE TODAY WHO.
05:27:29.930 --> 05:27:33.100
I DON'T KNOW IF [inaudible]
05:27:33.166 --> 05:27:35.335
RIGHT.
05:27:35.402 --> 05:27:37.270
GOT THAT THE CENTERS AYE STONE
05:27:37.337 --> 05:27:39.039
HAS MOVED THE THIRD OPTION THAT
05:27:39.106 --> 05:27:42.142
THAT WE WE ATTEMPT.
05:27:42.209 --> 05:27:43.410
TO REDUCE EVERYTHING HAS BEEN
05:27:43.477 --> 05:27:44.811
SAID HERE --
05:27:44.878 --> 05:27:46.246
TO A WRITING CENTER SOUND IT CAN
05:27:46.313 --> 05:27:47.447
THINK THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND
05:27:47.514 --> 05:27:48.982
AND I GOT I APPRECIATE YOUR
05:27:49.049 --> 05:27:50.484
LEADERSHIP IN THIS AND THE TIME
05:27:50.550 --> 05:27:52.652
THAT YOU SPENT ON ON THIS ISSUE
05:27:52.719 --> 05:27:53.286
AS WELL AS THE OTHERS FOR TODAY
05:27:53.353 --> 05:27:55.856
BECAUSE IT IS NOT EASY AND YOU
05:27:55.922 --> 05:27:57.290
HAVE SUCH A DEPTH AND BREADTH.
05:27:57.357 --> 05:27:58.558
OF KNOWLEDGE AND EIGHT AND
05:27:58.625 --> 05:28:00.093
SENSITIVITY TO THE ISSUE THAT
05:28:00.160 --> 05:28:01.194
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AND I KNOW
05:28:01.261 --> 05:28:02.963
ALSO A BROADER SENSITIVITY TO
05:28:03.030 --> 05:28:05.132
THE ISSUES THAT MEMBERS BRING.
05:28:05.198 --> 05:28:06.400
IN THE CONSTRAINTS WERE UNDER
05:28:06.466 --> 05:28:08.635
BECAUSE OF THE THE LOUSY
05:28:08.702 --> 05:28:10.337
SCHEDULE WHICH SUCH STUCK WITH
05:28:10.404 --> 05:28:11.938
IN THE LEGISLATURE.
05:28:12.005 --> 05:28:14.341
LATER I I I THINK AND I I I
05:28:14.408 --> 05:28:16.009
THINK THIS IS THE THIRD OPTION
05:28:16.076 --> 05:28:18.578
IT IS ONE THAT COULD WORK TODAY.
05:28:18.645 --> 05:28:19.379
MAINLY BECAUSE AND REALLY I
05:28:19.446 --> 05:28:22.349
THINK ONLY BACK AT YOU AND AND
05:28:22.416 --> 05:28:26.086
SENATORS TURNS IT ON JUDICIARY --
05:28:26.153 --> 05:28:27.587
AND IN MY COMFORT LEVEL
05:28:27.654 --> 05:28:27.888
[inaudible]
05:28:27.954 --> 05:28:31.558
WITH YOUR ABILITY TO TO SEE.
05:28:31.625 --> 05:28:33.260
THAT THERE.
05:28:33.326 --> 05:28:37.097
AND IN IN THAT IN THAT VENUE.
05:28:37.164 --> 05:28:38.865
AND IF YOU FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE.
05:28:38.932 --> 05:28:39.900
IF YOU FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE AT
05:28:39.966 --> 05:28:41.401
THAT TIME.
05:28:41.468 --> 05:28:43.270
WE WILL RESPECT AND I WOULD
05:28:43.336 --> 05:28:45.872
CERTAINLY RESPECT YOUR JUDGMENT.
05:28:45.939 --> 05:28:47.741
THAT THAT BRINGS US TO OUR
05:28:47.808 --> 05:28:49.309
SECOND CHALLENGE THAT WE HAVE IS
05:28:49.376 --> 05:28:51.611
THAT I DON'T THINK MECHANICALLY.
05:28:51.678 --> 05:28:53.380
WERE ABLE TO AMEND THE BILL
05:28:53.447 --> 05:28:55.382
BEFORE.
05:28:55.449 --> 05:28:57.217
WE GET TO JUDICIARY BECAUSE WE
05:28:57.284 --> 05:29:01.388
HAVE WE HAVE LIMITED THERE CAN.
05:29:01.455 --> 05:29:02.155
WELL AFTERTHE BUT I MEAN BUT
05:29:02.222 --> 05:29:02.956
THERE WILL GET AN OPPORTUNITY
05:29:03.023 --> 05:29:04.691
FOR YOU TO HAVE THE HAVE THE
05:29:04.758 --> 05:29:05.859
LAND COMMISSION HAVE THE THE
05:29:05.926 --> 05:29:08.128
CORRECT WORDING AND THE LANGUAGE.
05:29:08.195 --> 05:29:09.329
IN PLACE TO SEE IF IT'S
05:29:09.396 --> 05:29:10.997
SOMETHING THAT IS THAT THAT YOU
05:29:11.064 --> 05:29:12.432
FEEL REFLECTS WHAT WE HEARD
05:29:12.499 --> 05:29:13.433
TODAY.
05:29:13.500 --> 05:29:14.034
CERTAINLY THE SENTIMENT OF THE
05:29:14.101 --> 05:29:15.135
MEMBERSHIP [inaudible]
05:29:15.202 --> 05:29:18.805
CENTER SKINNER.
05:29:18.872 --> 05:29:23.310
WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS?
05:29:23.376 --> 05:29:24.578
OBVIOUSLY IT'S NOT THE SAME
05:29:24.644 --> 05:29:25.712
CONDITION THAT CIRCUMSTANCES ARE
05:29:25.779 --> 05:29:27.114
NOT.
05:29:27.180 --> 05:29:27.914
QUICKLY THE SAME BUT I THINK IN
05:29:27.981 --> 05:29:29.149
THE SAME WAY THAT WE WERE
05:29:29.216 --> 05:29:30.584
TWEAKING.
05:29:30.650 --> 05:29:32.018
THE BILL THAT WAS BROUGHT BEFORE
05:29:32.085 --> 05:29:34.688
US BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER BONTA.
05:29:34.754 --> 05:29:36.056
THERE ARE.
05:29:36.123 --> 05:29:37.724
DIFFERENT BUT ANALOGOUS TWO
05:29:37.791 --> 05:29:39.960
WEEKS THAT WE ARE --
05:29:40.026 --> 05:29:41.394
THE COMMITTEE WAS INTERESTED IN
05:29:41.461 --> 05:29:43.563
AS EXPRESSED BY YOU KNOW ME
05:29:43.630 --> 05:29:45.565
EARLIER STORY HAD TO KEEP GOING
05:29:45.632 --> 05:29:47.467
IN AND OUT 2% OTHER BILLS BUT IT
05:29:47.534 --> 05:29:49.069
SENATOR STERN SENATOR HILL.
05:29:49.136 --> 05:29:51.705
PINK OTHERS MAY HAVE BEEN OF
05:29:51.771 --> 05:29:53.340
COURSE THE CHAIRMAN HIMSELF.
05:29:53.406 --> 05:29:57.244
AND WE HAVE THE ABILITY STILL TO
05:29:57.310 --> 05:29:59.579
SHAPE THE BILL EVEN IF WE LET
05:29:59.646 --> 05:30:00.814
THIS OUT OF COMMITTEE.
05:30:00.881 --> 05:30:02.315
BECAUSE AMENDMENTS CAN BE TAKEN
05:30:02.382 --> 05:30:04.551
INTO DEBTS.
05:30:04.618 --> 05:30:06.019
AND THEN ADDITIONAL.
05:30:06.086 --> 05:30:07.320
BUT THERE IS SPACE FOR
05:30:07.387 --> 05:30:08.955
AMENDMENTS BEFORE IT EVEN HITS
05:30:09.022 --> 05:30:09.523
THE FLOOR.
05:30:09.589 --> 05:30:12.526
SO IT -- WE
05:30:12.592 --> 05:30:14.661
HAVE THE ABILITY TO STILL SHAPE
05:30:14.728 --> 05:30:16.163
THE BILL AND YOU CERTAINLY CAN
05:30:16.229 --> 05:30:18.798
CALL A SPECIAL HEARING IF NEEDED.
05:30:18.865 --> 05:30:21.334
IF YOU NEED TO TAKE IT BACK TO
05:30:21.401 --> 05:30:22.802
MAKE SURE THAT THE THINGS THAT
05:30:22.869 --> 05:30:24.871
YOU BROUGHT UP BEEN ADDRESSED OR
05:30:24.938 --> 05:30:25.172
NOT.
05:30:25.238 --> 05:30:27.207
BUT I THINK IT'S LEGITIMATE TO
05:30:27.274 --> 05:30:29.209
MOVE IT FORWARD AND I'M IN
05:30:29.276 --> 05:30:30.377
SUPPORT OF MEDINA [inaudible]
05:30:30.443 --> 05:30:33.513
FOR AND CENTER STERN
05:30:33.580 --> 05:30:33.813
[inaudible]
05:30:33.880 --> 05:30:35.649
THERE [inaudible]
05:30:35.715 --> 05:30:46.693
I THERE'S A MOTION I THERE'S A
05:30:46.760 --> 05:30:47.594
MOTION BY SENATORS --
05:30:47.661 --> 05:30:48.962
STONE.
05:30:49.029 --> 05:30:51.331
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL
05:30:51.398 --> 05:30:51.631
[inaudible]
05:30:51.698 --> 05:30:57.404
THAT. TO PASS THE JUDICIARY.
05:30:57.470 --> 05:31:00.106
ITEM NUMBER FIVE AB NINE EIGHT
05:31:00.173 --> 05:31:01.174
SEVEN BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
05:31:01.241 --> 05:31:03.210
KAMLAGER-DOVE OF MOTION IS DUE
05:31:03.276 --> 05:31:04.978
PASSED TO THE SENATE JUDICIARY
05:31:05.045 --> 05:31:05.645
COMMITTEE.
05:31:05.712 --> 05:31:07.714
LIKE ASKING AYE MAKOWSKI AYE
05:31:07.781 --> 05:31:08.982
STONE.
05:31:09.049 --> 05:31:12.385
STONE AYE GAINES GAINES AYE HILL.
05:31:12.452 --> 05:31:13.486
HILL AYE LARA [inaudible]
05:31:13.553 --> 05:31:16.489
SKINNER.
05:31:16.556 --> 05:31:17.791
STERN AYE AYE.
05:31:17.857 --> 05:31:19.292
SORRY.
05:31:19.359 --> 05:31:21.328
I THINK IT GOES WITHOUT SAYING
05:31:21.394 --> 05:31:23.363
THAT EVERYBODY RESERVES OVER
05:31:23.430 --> 05:31:24.864
THERE RIGHT TO CHANGE HER PHONE.
05:31:24.931 --> 05:31:27.400
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
05:31:27.467 --> 05:31:29.669
I'M ALRIGHT ITEM WHO IS HERE
05:31:29.736 --> 00:00:00.000
MISTER BERMAN [inaudible]