COMMITTEE MEETING AYE IT IS THE
JUNE THIRTEENTH EDITION WE'RE
GRATEFUL WE ARE EXCITED ASSEMBLY
WERE BLOOM IS HERE AT TO BE
EARLY TO SOFT. A PRIOR TO HAVING
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BLOOM KICKS OFF
WE'RE GONNA HAVE HIM COME
FORWARD THOUGH TO THE DYESS. ON
THAT WE HAVE SOME HOUSEKEEPING
ITEMS THAT WE'D LIKE TO BE TO
TAKE CARE OF. AB TWENTY SEVEN
SIXTY TWO ITEM NUMBER FOURTEEN
TWENTY SEVEN SIXTY TWO IS
CONTEMPORARY PULLED BY THE
AUTHOR.
WE HAVE SEVERAL BILLS THAT ARE
ON CONSENT TODAY ITEM NUMBER ONE.
ITEM NUMBER FOUR ITEM NUMBER
EIGHT.
ITEM NUMBER NINE ITEM EIGHTEEN
ITEM NINETEEN.
BUT WHAT I REMIND FOLKS THAT
THIS IS GOING TO BE THE LAST
YEAR FOR TAX CHECK OFF EACH.
OTHER PRETTY ROUTINE AROUND HERE
BUT.
AT A RESPECT FOR CENTER MORE
LOCK WILL BE WORKING A LONG TERM
SOLUTION TO TAX CHECK OFF THIS
WILL BE THE LAST YEAR. THAT I
THIS COMMITTEE WILL BE HEARING
IT FOR TWELVE MONTHS OF PREDICT
WHAT MONTH PIES TO OUT TO ALLOW
THE SENATOR BEACHWOOD ADVANCE AT
THE REASON I BRING THIS FOR NOW
WE SAID THE SAME THING AS WE
STARTED OUR SENATE SESSION IS
WELL. IT IS WE WELCOME ASSEMBLY
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE WE JUST
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE.
UP TRANSPARENT.
FINALLY AUGUST EIGHTH IS GOING
TO BE OUR NEXT HEARING ON.
SENATOR HERTZBERG PROPOSAL FOR
A SERVICE TAX HE STATEWIDE
SERVICE TAX IT WILL BE AUGUST
EIGHTH.
HERE IN COMMITTEE WILL BE OUR
NEXT HEARING ON THE SERVICE TAX.
THE LATEST GENERAL WITHOUT
FURTHER ADO LET'S GET STRAIGHT
INTO OUR AGENDA TODAY WE WELCOME
ASSEMBLY MEMBER BLOOM HE'S GONNA
BE PRESENTING AB FIFTEEN NINETY
FOUR WE'RE GONNA SEVERAL MEMBERS
IN AND OUT OF COMMITTEE TODAY.
WE HAVE BUDGET THAT IS ROLLING.
I'M GONNA HAVE TO ROLL OUT. FOR
BUDGET AND A CENTER MORE LOCK IS
THE COUNTRY'S GOING TO ROLL OUT
FOR BUDGET IN PLEASE EXCUSE US
AYE IT WE'RE NOT TRYING TO BE
RUDE. WITHOUT FURTHER ADO WE'RE
GRATEFUL FOR ALL THE HARD WORK
OF SIMILAR BLOOM THE FLOOR IS
YOURS SIR. THANK YOU AND THAT.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR FOR
STICKING AROUND FOR MY BILL GO.
MISTER CHAIR AND TECH COMMITTEE
MEMBERS I'M PRESENTING AB
FIFTEEN NINETY FOUR A BILL THAT
CLARIFIES THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION
AUTHORITY IS ABILITY TO ENTER
INTO. A PUBLIC PRIVATE
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENTS FOR
TRANSIT PROJECTS
SUCH AS RAPID TRANSIT NON
HIGHWAY SUBWAY. AND HEAVY RAIL
PROJECTS AB TWENTY SIX SIXTY WAS
SIGNED INTO STATUTE TO.
BACK WHEN I WAS STILL YOUNG IN
NINETEEN NINETY SIX AND ALLOWED
TO A P. THREE FOUR COMMUTER AND
LIGHT RAIL PROJECTS. THIS BILL
SIMPLY EXTENDS THAT SAME
PRIVILEGE TO OTHER SIMILAR
TRANSIT. AND A RAIL PROJECTS.
THIS BILL ALSO LOWERS THE TWO
THIRDS BOOK A BOARD VOTE
THRESHOLD FOR DESIGN BUILD
PROJECTS IN THE LA ENABLING
STATUTES.
THE ENABLING STATUTE THAT
CREATED LA METRO IN THE NINETEEN
NINETIES INCLUDED DISTRESS
ROLLED WHICH IS NOT RECORD OF
ANY OTHER TRANSIT AGENCY. THE UP
A TWO THIRDS.
THRESHOLD IS IN FACT BECOME A
CUMBERSOME FOR THE BOARD AND BY
MAKING IT A SIMPLE MAJORITY THIS
BILL WILL HELP STREAMLINE THE
APPROVAL PROCESS. EIGHTY FIFTEEN
NINETY FOUR WILL HELP LA COUNTY
BETTER OPTIMIZE THE
TRANSPORTATION DOLLARS RECENTLY
AUTHORIZED BY THE VOTERS IN LOS
ANGELES THROUGH MEASURE AM. OF
FOR TRANSIT PROJECTS
AND I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE BUT MICHAEL TURNER.
WAS INTENDING TO BE HERE. ON
BUT WAS CALLED AWAY ON THESE THE
A DEPUTY EXECUTIVE OFFICER FOR
GOVERNMENT RELATIONS FOR LA
METRO INTO SOBRE STUCK WITH
ANDREW AND TWEAK WHO'S HERE ON
BEHALF OF. ELEMENTARY Y. JANICE
AND TWEAK I LIKE IT AND IT'S A
MEMBER BLOOM WE HAVE RECEIVED
WORD THAT WE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
SOME STRANGE WEEK YOU DON'T MIND.
OF PROVIDING A TRUNCATED VERSION
OF YOUR STATEMENT WE ALL ALWAYS
LOVE HEARING FROM YOU WE LOOK ME
COMMITTEE SIR.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN AND
MEMBERS AND YOUR HANDS WE WE
THANK THE AUTHOR FOR BRINGING
THIS FORWARD.
THIS MAKES IT EASIER FOR US TO
UTILIZE DESIGN BUILD MP THREE
FOR TRANSIT PROJECTS AND LA
METRO.
JURISDICTION THE VOTERS HAVE
ENTRUSTED LA METRO WITH THE
AUTHORIZATION OF A ONE HUNDRED
TWENTY BILLION DOLLAR A SALES
TAX. AND WE WOULD LIKE TO.
DELIVER THOSE PROJECTS AS
QUICKLY AND WITH AS MUCH
INFORMATION AS POSSIBLE AND WE
ASK FOR YOUR VOTE THANK YOU SO
MUCH MR INTO WE WE NOW WOULD
LIKE TO WELCOME ANYONE WHO'S IN
SUPPORT IF YOU COULD PLEASE
ADVANCE THE MICROPHONE ALL THOSE
IN SUPPORT TO PLEASE ADVANCE.
LAST CALL FOR SUPPORT. WE'RE NOT
GONNA WELCOME ANYONE WHO'S IN
OPPOSITION IF YOU PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
LAST CALL IS BRINGING BACK TO
COMMITTEE BURGUNDY STARTING AS A
SUBCOMMITTEE WERE UNABLE TO TAKE
ACTION THE MOMENT WOULD LIKELY
RECEIVE ANY QUESTIONS I OR
COMMENTS BY CENTER MORLOCK.
SEE NINE ASSEMBLY WOULD YOU LIKE
TO CLOSE I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
YOUR VOTE AND THANK YOU FOR YOUR
CONSIDERATION HE DIDN'T THINK
YOU SO MUCH FOR ALL THE HARD
WORK SIR I DO APOLOGIZE WHEN I
CAN BE A TAKE. A VOTE ON IT
QUITE YET BUT IT SEEMS WE DO
WILL IN NO WAY CLOSER TO MY
NECESSARY THANK YOU THANK YOU.
WHAT I WOULD BE?
DOING THE HUNT DOWN OF AUTHOR
SO.
WERE ON THE HUNT FOR A SIMILAR
SPIRIT COME RUNNING COMMITTEE.
SO MEMBER BELL IS HERE.
IN WE HAVE OUR NEXT AUTHOR
LADIES AND GENTLEMEN THE MAN THE
MYTH THE LEGEND FROM THE EAST.
MY GOODNESS HERE JUST IN TIME.
CARE HOW ARE YOU MORNING WHAT'S
GOING ON SIR THANK YOU SO MUCH
ON MR.
BONTA HAS TWO ITEMS IN FRONT OF
US TODAY WE HAVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
OF WE HAVE AYE AB SEVENTEEN
FORTY ONE. WHICH WILL START OUT
WITH BY IN THE MURDER GOING TO
BE GOING TO ASSEMBLY BILL I AB
TWENTY NINE FIFTY FOUR. SIMILAR
BONTA ON YOUR FIRST ITEM ITEM
NUMBER THREE EIGHTY AYE
SEVENTEEN FORTY ONE WE DO OF
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON THIS.
UNTIL WE WELCOME A TRUNCATED
VERSION OF YOUR STATEMENT ALONG
WITH YOUR WITNESSES SUMMER BUT I
THINK YOU FOR ALL OF YOUR WORK
AT THE FLOORS OR SIR.
THANK YOU MISTER.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR THANK YOU
COLLEAGUES ARGUE FIRST WANT TO
START BY ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEE'S PROPOSED AMENDMENTS.
ON PAGE FOUR ANALYSIS WHICH
ADDED URGENCY COST OF THE BILL.
ARE WE THINK THIS IS A COMMON
SENSE BILL INCENTIVIZE THE
CANNABIS INDUSTRY TO LEGALLY
COMPLY WITH CALIFORNIA TAX CODE
WHICH WILL IN TURN GENERATE ORE
TAX REVENUE. FOR THE STIMULATING
CALIFORNIA'S ECONOMY. HERE WITH
ME TO SPEAK AND TRUNCATED
FASHION. WITH OUR SUPPORT OF THE
BILL ARE THAT CASE YOU'LL CONNOR
REPRESENTATIVE FROM THE OFFICE
OF ABOARD LEGALIZATION MEMBER
FIONA MA AND AMY JENKINS WITH
CALIFORNIA CANNABIS INDUSTRY
ASSOCIATION.
WE ALWAYS WELCOME OF MISSILES
OFFICE TO THE COMMITTEE WELCOMES
O'CONNOR.
YES THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR FOR
HAVING US AGAIN ALWAYS A
PLEASURE AND ALL MAKE IT BRIEF.
OF THE VICE CHAIR IS ALWAYS
BETTER AND I'M SUPPORTIVE OF
INCENTIVIZING VOLUNTARY
COMPLIANCE WE BELIEVE AB
SEVENTEEN FORTY ONE DOES THAT.
WE'VE SPONSOR SIMILAR MEASURES
IN THE PAST FAIR RESPECT THEIR
QUESTION I DON'T THINK YOU CAN
DO SO MUCH MICHIGAN'S ACQUIRE
SENATORS AMY JENKINS ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA CANNABIS
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION. I'M
DISCOURAGING HOUSE PAYMENTS ONLY
I AM INCREASES NONCOMPLIANCE IN
AN INDUSTRY THAT IS SEEKING TO
BECOME COMPLAIN AND DO THE RIGHT
THING SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME
AND WE ARE CHEN AYE VOTE. ICKY
SO MUCH WE NOW WOULD LIKE TO
WELCOME ANYONE ELSE WHO IS IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE STATE YOUR FIRST AND LAST
YEAR ORGANIZATION GOOD MORNING.
WRITING MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS
ANGIE MENTALITY HERE ON BEHALF
OF RIVER DISTRIBUTION IN SUPPORT
THINKING GEE GOOD MORNING.
THE MORNING CAME UP ON BEHALF OF
WE DROP CANNABIS DELIVERY IN THE
ONE BEACH COLLECTORS ASSOCIATION
BIG BIG YOU. GOOD MORNING.
PARDEE JASON BRIGHT ON BEHALF
THE CALIFORNIA GROWERS
ASSOCIATION AS WELL AS MY
COLLEAGUE HERE NOR WOULD I BE
HAVE TO CALIFORNIA'S
DISTRIBUTIONS ASSOCIATION WE ARE
IN SUPPORT THANK YOU THANK YOU
SO MUCH.
MORNING SIR.
THERE MEMBERS RAND MORE NUMB
BEHALF OF CMG CALL EVEN SUPPORT
THANK YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH.
THE MORNING THE MOORING LINE
BUDGET CO THE CALIFORNIA THIS
GOAL IS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR
THE COW FOR MINORITY ALLIANCE IS
BILLS GET WE PROPOSE IS
SPECIALLY WE WANT TO LOOK AT
MORE OPTIONS AS FAR AS
INCENTIVIZING ESPECIALLY FOR
FREE ENTERPRISE. AND SMALL
BUSINESSES ESPECIALLY FOR PEOPLE
ARE MAKING THEIR WAY INTO A
LEGITIMATE MARKET THANK YOU
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR.
THE MORNING MORNING FAMILY BOND
WITH THE CALIFORNIA SENATE
CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE AND THE
CALIFORNIA BLACK CHAMBER OF
COMMERCE IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL
THANK YOU SO MUCH.
BUT NOW LIKE TO BE THE ASK IF
THERE'S ANYONE ELSE WHO IS IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE COME FORWARD CITY LAST
CALL FOR SUPPORT.
YEAH I WOULD LIKE TO BE
DISCIPLINED ANYONE IN OPPOSITION
TO PLEASE ADVANCED MICRO DISARM.
SEE NOW I WOULD LIKE TO BE TO
BRING BACK TO COMMITTEE TO SEE
IF WE HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
WE DO NOT CURRENTLY HAVE A
QUORUM AM SAMANTA DO APOLOGIZE
THAT WE'D LIKE TO BE AT A YOU UP
TO DATE THAT I DO CLOSING
STATEMENT SIR.
THE BILL WAS BUCKLEY ASPIRIN YE
VOTE THANK YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN
COLLEAGUES THANK YOU SO MUCH I
DO APOLOGIZE IT WOULD HAVE TO
WAIT ON THAT.
BUT MORE TO COME.
MEMBERS WE NOW WOULD LIKE TO GET
A MOVE ON TO A FILE ITEM
SEVENTEEN THIS IS AB TWENTY NINE
FIFTY FOUR. BUT WE'RE GONNA ASK
FOR YEAR AT TRADITIONAL.
VISITATION ON THIS ONE MISTER
BONTA WELCOMING THEY TRY HARD
WORK ON THIS ONE.
THANK YOU MISTER KERRY AT ONCE
AGAIN THANK YOU COLLEAGUES FOR
THE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY NINE.
FIFTY FOUR. WHICH WOULD SIMPLY
CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF A SCHOOL
DISTRICTS AUTHORITY.
TO SEEK VOTER APPROVAL OF LOCAL
REVENUE MEASURES SO THEY CAN
MEET THE SPECIFIC NEEDS OF THEIR
LOCAL DISTRICT. BY
DISTINGUISHING BETWEEN IMPROVED
AND UNIMPROVED PROPERTY THE
SCHOOL DISTRICTS WILL BE ABLE TO
CONTINUE PROVIDING EDUCATIONAL
OPPORTUNITIES FOR THEIR
COMMUNITIES.
THROUGH VOTER APPROVED FUNDING
MEASURES AT LEAST FIFTEEN OTHER.
TYPES OF LOCAL AGENCIES
INCLUDING COMMUNITY COLLEGE
DISTRICTS HAVE THIS FLEXIBILITY
ALREADY TO TAX ON IMPROVE
PROPERTY AT A LOWER RATE THAN
IMPROVE PROPERTY. THIS BILL WILL
SIMPLY ALIGNING CLARIFY THE LOT
RELATED TO SCHOOL DISTRICTS TO
THESE OTHER AGENCIES.
AB TWENTY NINE FIFTY FOUR WAS ON
CONSENT IN ASSEMBLY REVENUE AND
TAXATION COMMITTEE AS WELL AS ON
THE ASSEMBLY FLOOR AND I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE.
I HAVE WITH. DEPRIVE WITH ME
HERE TODAY I'M JOHN THAT EVER
REPRESENTED ALAMEDA UNIFIED
SCHOOL DISTRICT AS WHERE. WELL
AS LARA PRESTON LEGISLATIVE
ADVOCATE ASSOCIATION OF
CALIFORNIA SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS
THINK SO MUCH FOR ALWAYS.
HONORED DAVE AND THE MAN WITH
THE LEGEND FROM CINEMA COUNTY
HERE IN THE ROOM MISTER LATIMER
THE FLOORS ARE SIR BUT I WAS
SPEAKING TO THE MAN THE MYTH.
WELL YEAH
BUT MISTER CHAIRMAN MEMBERS JOHN
LATTIMER ON BEHALF OF ALAMEDA
UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT WHERE
THE SPONSORS OF THE MEASURE.
BOMB URINALYSIS LAYS OUT THE
CASE THAT WE THINK FOR THE
MEASURE. QUITE SUCCINCTLY WE
WOULD CONCUR WITH THAT WITH THE.
THAT PRESENTATION I THINK THE
ONE THING WE WOULD SAY IS THIS
GIVES A LOCAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS A
TOOL TO BE ABLE TO SHAPING THEI
COMMUNITY. ON WHAT THEY THINK
ARE EQUITABLE INAPPROPRIATE
REVENUE RAISING MECHANISMS THAT
RECOGNIZES AGAIN DIFFERENT
ECONOMIC AYE IMPLICATIONS TO.
IMPROVED AND UNIMPROVED PROPERTY
SO WE THINK IT'S COMMONSENSE
MEASURE WE APPRECIATE BY THE
WORK OF THE COMMITTEE AND HAPPY
TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
IT'S SOURCE ELABORATE MORNING
MA'AM THANK YOU FOR JOINING US
THAT MORNING JENNIFER BAKER AT
THE CALIFORNIA TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION IN SUPPORT OF THE
MEASURE. THIS IS GOING TO GIVE
SCHOOL DISTRICTS AN ADDITIONAL
FISCAL TOOL IN THEIR TOOL BOX TO
HELP THEM BE AS EFFECTIVE AS
THEY CAN WHEN IT COMES TO THAT
MANAGING THEIR RESOURCES. WE
ARCHRIVAL THANK YOU SO MUCH WE
NOW LIKELY TO WELCOME FOLKS WHO
ARE ALSO IN SUPPORT OF THE
COMPLETE COMPORT MICROPHONE
FIRST AND LAST AS WELL AS YOUR
ORGANIZATION. THOSE IN SUPPORT
PLEASE ADVANCE.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE IN SUPPORT.
WE NOW LIKELY TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE WHO OPPOSED IT PLEASE
ADVANCE.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSED THIS BRING
BACK TO COMMITTEE TO BE
DISCIPLINED QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS.
THROUGH A LOT.
HE WAS SECURE.
.
WE OFFER OTHER BILL TODAY THAT
TRIES TO DETERMINE HOW TO.
APPLY.
AS THIS TYPE OF ACTIVITY.
HOW HOW DOES?
THE TAXING AUTHORITY WHERE I DO
OF A PROBABLY OUR CONTROLLER
THAT'S GOT IT.
SIGNIFY WHAT.
BID TAX RATE AREAS HOW'S THAT
GOING TO BE ACCOMPLISHED.
CENTER MORLOCK IF I UNDERSTAND
YOUR QUESTION THE THE SCHOOL
DISTRICT IN SHAPING THAT THE TAX
MEASURE WOULD DEFINE THE
CRITERIA FOR WHAT QUALIFIES IS
IMPROVED AND UNIMPROVED PROPERTY
AND THEN AS THEY CLEAR THAT
OBVIOUSLY WITH LEGAL COUNSEL OR
THEY PUT THAT FOR THEIR VOTERS
AND THEN THE VOTERS WOULD. BUT
SEE THAT THE TRANSPARENCY THAT
MEASURE AND HAVE A DECISION
WHETHER OR NOT THEY THINK THAT
APPROPRIATELY REFLECTS THE
VALUES FOR THEIR COMMUNITY THE
APPROPRIATE.
DISTINCTIONS OF IMPROVE
NONPARTISAN ANSWER MY QUESTION.
I'M NOT SURE THAT I UNDERSTAND
FORMER TREASURER TAX COLLECTOR.
AND SO I'M JUST TRYING TO SEE
HOW THIS IS IMPLEMENTED SO. OUR
IT DOES THE BILL REQUIRE THAT.
THE AUDITOR CONTROLLER IN THE
ASSESSOR GO THROUGH AND SAY IF
IT'S A LAND ONLY.
IF THERE ARE ZERO IMPROVEMENTS.
THAT IS A SPECIAL.
CATEGORY OR. IF THEIR DEMAND IN
THIS
IMPROVEMENTS FENCES AT CENTER
THAT HAPPEN TO BE ASSESSED.
YOU KNOW HOW DOES HOW'D YOU KNOW
HOW WOULD YOU HOW TO BE FAIR AND
THAT'S WHAT I'M TRYING TO GET TO.
THAT THE STATUTE THAT WERE
AMENDING DOESN'T DEFINE THOSE
CRITERIA.
OUR UNDERSTANDING IS THAT THERE
IS FLEXIBILITY ACT GIVEN TO THE
AUDITOR CONTROLLER WORKING WITH
THE GOVERNING BOARD AS THEY
DEFINE WHAT IS IMPROVED AND
UNIMPROVED BUT IF THE STATUTE
THE AMENDMENTS WERE MAKING TO IT
OR SIMILAR TO THE AUTHORITY
GRANTED OTHERS. THAT COMMUNITY
COLLEGE DISTRICTS AND WE'RE NOT
CHANGING ANY OF THOSE MECHANISMS
THAT'S AVAILABLE TO A COMMUNITY
COLLEGE DISTRICT NOW WE'D BE
GIVING TO A SCHOOL DISTRICT. ILL
WE HAVE A BILL BEFORE US TODAY
THAT. IDENTIFIES THAT SENIORS
AND THOSE THAT HAVE A
DISABILITIES OR.
YOU KNOW OUR OUR EGG ARE
EXEMPTED FROM.
SCHOOL PARCEL OR SCHOOL TAX.
BUT THEY HAVE TO ACTUALLY INFORM.
SOMEBODY BE THE SCHOOL WHERE
THAT.
ASSESSOR THAT HEY WE WE DON'T
QUALIFY FOR THIS TAX OR. I'M
JUST TRYING TO GET HOW DID YOU
ADMINISTRATIVELY.
ACCOUNT FOR THIS SO THAT. YOU
NINE AND I GOT PUT A BIG JOB ON
THE COUNTY TO FIGURE OUT.
WHAT IS?
ENCUMBERED PROPERTY WHAT IS
DEVELOP PROPERTY AND.
I'M SORRY TO BE KIND OF CRANKY
ABOUT IT AYE I'M ON TO ME
COMMITTEES THAT IT MAY.
BETTER MORE LOCKET FROM FROM
BEGIN ON BEHALF ALAMEDA COUNTY.
ASSUMING ALAMEDA SCHOOL BOARD
FUND THAT IS A VERY GOOD
QUESTION I APOLOGIZE YOU DO NOT
HAVE THE ANSWER TO WE WE HAVE
HAVE HAD A SIMILAR MEASURE IN
THE PAST.
THAT WAS CHALLENGED NOT FOR
THOSE REASONS BUT WAS CHALLENGE
WE HAVE AUTHORIZED DIFFERENTIAL
IN TERMS OF OUR VOTING POPULACE
BEFORE WE THOUGHT THIS
CLARIFICATION THAT IS CONSISTENT
WITH A CLARIFICATION GIVEN TO
OTHER SCHOOL DISTRICTS. AND
AGAIN I APOLOGIZE FOR THE
ASSUMPTION THAT I WOULD MAKE
HERE BUT IT IS AN ASSUMPTION
THAT THE AUDITOR CONTROLLER IS
CAN IS IS PART OF THAT PROCESS
AND IS HELPING US ESTABLISH.
THAT.
THAT COLLECTION METHODOLOGY AND
AND TAXPAYER INFORMATION SO
THERE IS CLARITY PUMP MORE THAN
HAPPY TO TAKE THAT BACK TAKE UP.
YOU KNOW YOU HAVE A MORE DIRECT
CONVERSATION IN ALAMEDA COUNTY
WITH THE AUDITOR CONTROLLER BUT
THEY FOR FOR ALSO CLARITY
PURPOSES THEY'VE SEEN THIS BILL
THEY HAVEN'T TAKEN NO ISSUE WITH
THE WORKLOAD OR DUTIES ATTACHED
HAS ESTABLISHED ATTACHED TO IT.
SO I THINK THEY ARE COMFORTABLE
WITH THE MECHANISM THAT THEY
HAVE TO. PUT IN PLACE AGAIN
THAT'S POINT INSUFFICIENT ANSWER
BUT HAPPY TO LOOK INTO IT
FURTHER PERHAPS COMMITTEE STAFF
MAY HAVE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
BUT THE ARGUMENT IS HATE. THERE
NO KIDS LIVING ON THIS PROPERTY
SO WHY.
SHOULD YOU BE TAXED FOR SCHOOL.
ASSESSMENT OF ITS OWN TO BE
RESIDENTIAL. YOU KIND OF ONE OF.
MAKE SURE THAT IT DOES.
IT INAPPROPRIATE PARTIAL TAX AT
SOME POINT TIME.
SO IT SUBJECT TO CHANGES.
YEAR BY YEAR IS IT.
SO SOME OF THOSE ADMINISTRATIVE.
ISSUES MISTER CHAIR ARE.
I APPRECIATE THAT AND ONE OF THE
ITEMS THAT WILL DO AYE IN YOU
HAVE OUR COMMITMENT IS THAT WE
WILL BE FOLLOWING UP WITH THE
SAME MEMBERS OFFICE TO BE ABLE
TO GET.
THOSE QUESTIONS ANSWERED IT
WILL MAKE SURE THAT EACH OF THE
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE HAVE
THOSE ANSWERS AYE AS WE MOVE
FORWARD.
OKAY IT IF IF I MIGHT. MISTER
SENATOR JUST A LITTLE BIT AYE
AYE FOR SOME UNLOCKING OF
ANSWERED BIG THE EXACT QUESTION
THAT YOU ASK I THINK IT'S A VERY
SPECIFIC OE ABOUT
IMPLEMENTATION ONCE THE. BOB
PARTS TAXES ALREADY PASSED IN
AND HOW THAT COLLECTION IS DONE
BUT I BUT I CAN GIVE YOU SOME
HIGHER LEVEL.
ONE THERE'S A UNIFORMITY
BECAUSE IN THE CURRENT LAW.
THAT REQUIRES A AS WE BELIEVE
AUTHORITY TO DIFFERENTIATE
BETWEEN. THE I'M IMPROVE AND
IMPROVE PROPERTIES.
THEN. IN IN A WAY THAT OTHER
AGENCIES ALREADY HAVE FIFTEEN TO
TWENTY BY OUR COUNT. SO THE
THIRTY THAT WERE PROVIDED HERE
IS SO MUCH THE AUTHORITY OF
FIFTEEN TO TWENTY WITH OTHER
AGENCIES HAVE INCLUDING
COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT WHICH
WE THINK IS MOST ANALYSIS. I'M
IN EACH OF THOSE. EXAMPLES THOSE
AGENCIES HAVE.
SOME AGENCIES THROUGHOUT THE
STATE OF THAT TYPE HAVE
PASSPORTS ARE TAXES THAT
DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN APPROVED
ON IMPROVE THE HAS BEEN
IMPLEMENTATION EXECUTION WE CAN
LOOK TO HOW THEY DID THAT TO SEE
I DON'T HAVE INFORMATION AT MY
FINGERTIPS RIGHT NOW. I'M BUT
WE'RE MOSTLY JUST GIVEN THE
AUTHORITY IN THE FACE OF THE
UNIFORMITY LANGUAGE THAT'S BEST
TO TO.
SHOW THAT I A SCHOOL DISTRICT
CAN DISTINGUISH BETWEEN IMPROVED
ON APPROVED AND TO TELL ME. THE
THEORY BEHIND IT IS THAT AN
UNIMPROVED PROPERTY IS LESS ABLE
TO GENERATE ECONOMIC REVENUE
BECAUSE OF ITS LACK OF IT IT'S.
THE WORD ZERO IMPROVEMENTS SO
THEY MIGHT WANT TO BE. GIVEN A
PART OF TALKS THAT LASTS OR
MAYBE EVEN EXEMPTED AT THE WILL
OF THE LOCALITY THEY'LL DECIDE.
WHAT'S BASS BUT THAT'S SORT OF
THAT THAT THE THEORY BEHIND THIS
APPROACH.
SOON BONTA.
REASON I ASK IS IF I DON'T ASK
I'M GONNA HAVE MY FORMER
COLLEAGUES SAY WHY DID YOU ASK
THAT QUESTION. OUT OF THIS GET
THROUGH YOU THAT YOU'RE ON
RECORD AS OFFICIALLY ASK. BUT I
DON'T KNOW FOR A RECORD IS
OFFICIALLY ANSWERING IT BUT WHAT
WE'RE GONNA GET BACK TO I JUST
WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT. WE WERE
NOT TO INCOME BRING INNOCENT
BYSTANDERS AT ALL THE SETS AT
ALL TO GET HIS WORKLOAD WHO PAYS
FOR THAT.
SO OUR UNIT CHANGED THE
TERMINOLOGY THEN IS IT A.
BIFURCATED PARCEL TAX THERE
REALLY JUST STILL USER
NOMENCLATURE PARCEL TAX.
IT'S STILL PART OF TAX IT IT
IT'S JUST A PART OF TAX THAT
WOULD. APPLY.
GENERALLY TOTE TALL PARCELS IN
IN A DISTRICT
EXCEPT IF THE LOCALITY DECIDES
THEY WANT TO PROVIDE TO AT A
DIFFERENT.
TREATMENT TO IMPROVE PROPERTIES
AS OPPOSED IMPROVE THEY MAY.
AND. THE I CAN ONLY THANK YOU
MISTER MISTER BONTA THANK YOU
MISTER DON'T THINK IT'S SO MUCH.
BUT IF YOU FEEL ANY ADDITIONAL
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM THE
COMMITTEE.
THEY WERE STILL TRYING TO
SALVAGE A QUORUM THAT WE WILL
HAVE SOME FOLLOW UP ON THIS IN
ADDITION THAT WE'RE GOING TO BE
A TAKE THAT VOTE ON FILE ITEM
SEVENTEEN.
WE WILL.
FOLLOW UP WITH MR MORLOCKS
QUESTIONS FUND AND AT WORK WITH
THE SUMMERS OFFICE REGISTER
BECAUSE ANSWERS I TO THE ROOF OF
THE MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
I'M.
IT'S ABOUT THAT WOULD YOU LIKE
TO GET A CLOSER.
THANK YOU FOR THE DISCUSSION
SENATOR MORE LIKE A PARTICULAR
THANK YOU FOR YOUR QUESTIONS
WILL GET BACK YOU. RESPECTFULLY
ASK FOR AYE VOTE THANK YOU FOR
YOUR CONSIDERATION REGRETFUL
SIMILAR THANK YOU SO MUCH THANK
YOU FOR BOTH BEING AS WELL.
MEMBERS ARE AND. WE'RE GONNA BE
LOSIN CENTER MORE LOCK HERE IN
JUST A BIT IS THEY STARTED
VOTING IN I'M IN BUDGET THEY
WILL BE PUTTING ITEMS ON CALL.
THE WE'RE GOING TO LOSE SOONER
MORE LOCK.
OKAY.
THEN YOU NEED TO AND THEN I'M.
THEY WERE GO.
THE NEW KNOW AND I NEED TO GO
VOTE IN BUDGET IS WELL.
SO I.
SO OF MORE TO COME ON THAT
AND WONDERED IF WE CAN ALSO GRAB
SENATOR HERTZBERG BEFORE WE GET
TOO FAR.
PAN. WHILE WE ARE REFERENCING
HERTZBERG WERE GRATEFUL IS
SIMILAR BRO IS HERE. BUT HE'S
GONNA BE PRESENTING ON FILE ITEM
NUMBER FIVE AB NINETEEN HUNDRED.
MORTON SHARON A GOOD MORNING SIR
IS A MEMBER YOU HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON YOUR BILL SUBURBAN
ASKING TO APPEAL TO PRISON IN A
TRUNCATED FASHION. ON IN NOW
WE'RE GRATEFUL FOR ALL OF YOUR
WORKS HERE IN FLOOR SOURCE THANK
YOU MISTER CHAIRMAN PROCEED TO
TIME TO PRESENT A BEAT NINETEEN
HUNDRED. A BASIC STANDS A
MANUFACTURING TAX CREDIT THAT
ALREADY EXISTS AND RESPECT LAST
DRIVE OF THANK YOU SO MUCH
ASSUME AND WE WOULD LIKE TO BE
TO SEE IF WE HAVE ANYONE IN
SUPPORT IF YOU COULD PLEASE
ADVANCE THE MIKE FRONT THIS TIME
ANYONE SUPPORT.
COMING FROM THE COMPANY
MANUFACTURES SITUATION WELCOME.
I THINK YOU CHAIRING THE
COMMITTEE I DROVE COOK FOR THE
CALIFORNIA MANUFACTURES AND
TECHNOLOGIES ASSOCIATION ONE
SPORT THANK YOU SO MUCH.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE.
LAST CALL IT'S IF THERE'S ANYONE
WHO'S OPPOSED TO PLEASE ADVANCE.
SCENE NINE WOULD LIKELY TO BRING
IT BACK TO COMMITTEE DEBATED
SUPREMELY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS
ON THIS.
SIMILAR WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE
A DISRESPECT LAUGHTER I THOUGH
WHEN YOU GET IT SOME SCORE IT
EVER GO.
THE WORLD'S QUICKEST
PRESENTATION TO NEVER THINK YOU
SO MUCH AND APOLOGIZE OR NOT
COMMIT A VOTE THANK YOU.
FOR NOW REPORTING.
NOPE. AS A MEMBER.
OF COURSE THAT ARE MORE LIKE
IT'S A LAST MINUTE QUESTION FOR
YOU A JUST A JUST A
CLARIFICATION TO SOMETHING
SIMILAR BUT. WHEN WHEN YOU
OFFERED A PROPERTY TAX BREAK HOW
IS IT ALLOCATED IS IS. DOES THE
CITY THE COUNTY IN THE.
AND THE.
.
SCHOOLS THEY'LL TAKE THE SAME
HAIRCUT.
BUT THIS IS UP TO THE LOCALITY
THEY CAN DECIDE AT THEIR OWN.
THAT THEIR OWN JURISDICTION
WHAT THEY WANT OFFER TO EITHER
KEEP OR.
LURE A MANUFACTURE INTO THEIR.
DISTRICT.
LIKE I SAID IT'S AN EXISTING
TAX CREDIT THAT EXISTED JUST
EXTENDING THE SUNSET FROM THE
FIVE YEARS. YEAH I JUST DID JUST
DORMANT THOSE WE DON'T KNOW HOW
IT ACTUALLY WORKS RIGHT. WELL
WHAT THIS BILL WAS ESTABLISHED
WHEN AMAZON ANNOUNCER BUILDING A
SECOND HEADQUARTERS YOU KNOW
THIS WE ARE VERY ACTIVE IN
ORANGE COUNTY IRVINE COMPANY
HUNTINGTON BEACH SEAL BEACH.
WILD WITH PROPOSALS TO THIS WAS
TO BRING BACK TAX CREDITS WE
LOST REDEVELOPMENT ADDITIONAL
THINGS.
.
TO TRY TO GET A SECOND
HEADQUARTERS IN BUT WE'VE.
NOW IT NOW THAT ONLY LOS
ANGELES'S IN THE FINAL.
SPOTS FOR AMAZON BUT.
VICIOUSLY SAYS A TAX CREDIT TO
KEEP BUSINESSES IN CALIFORNIA
GRIEF MASK. IS RESEARCHER AT THE
TIME OF THE BANKRUPTCY AFTER I
WAS APPOINTED BY ALL THESE CALLS.
AND THIS SHOULD WATCHES GIVES A
TWO PERCENT DISCOUNT.
IT WILL PAY EARLY.
AND WE THOUGHT WHAT'S A GREAT
IDEA YOU KNOW TO DO BUSINESS.
BUT IT TURNED OUT THAT.
ONLY THE COUNTY COULD OFFER THE
DISCOUNT THE SCHOOLS THE CITY'S.
I WOULDN'T TAKE.
THE CUT THAT CITY IS A HOAX
COULD SO THEN WHEAT WE GET SIX
CENTS ON THE DOLLAR. WHICH MEANT
THAT WE WOULD REDUCE OUR TAKE BY
ONE THIRD BY OFFERING A TWO
PERCENT DISCOUNT THAT'S WHY WE
DIDN'T DO IT. SO I DESPITE I
JUST THOUGHT OKAY NOW HOW MUCH
FUN IS IT GONNA BE TO. SEE WHO
TAKES THE HAIRCUT ON. ON THIS
WHEN IT WOULD PROBABLY HAVE TO
BE THE CITY THAT CITIES.
NEXT THE SCHOOLS ARE GONNA.
AN ACCOUNTING UNDER THE COUNTY
HAS TO BE EXCITED ABOUT
SOMETHING GOV BALDESSARI I WILL
BE BACK IN A FOR THE QUESTION.
THANK YOU RICHARD THANK YOU YOU
KNOW IT'S ALL GOOD THINGS MUCH
MORE LIKE. WILL BE TAKING A VOTE
HERE MOMENTARILY IN THE BILL
THANK YOU SO MUCH AND CENTERS.
BETTER GO.
MEMBERS OF WHAT WE THINK TO BE
TO DO IS ESTABLISH A QUORUM WE
DO APOLOGIZE ISN'T OVER AND
SENATOR. ON AND THEN WE'D LIKE
TO BE TO TAKE SOME QUICK VOTES
ON THE ITEMS THAT WE'VE ALREADY
TAKEN ACTION ON CASINO FOLKS ARE
IN THE IN THE NOW WE ONLY HAVE A
FEW THAT WE'RE GONNA NEED BETTER
CATCH UP ON.
SELECT A SUBSET QUORUM MISLEAD
CHESTER ROLL CALL PLEASE WIRE
HERE MCGUIRE CRESCENT WIN. WIN
PRESIDENT BELL.
HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG. FIRST
BIRTHDAY PRESENT LARA.
MORE LOCKED PRESIDENT ELECT
PRINT.
I GIVE A SIXTY SECONDS WE'RE
GONNA GET OUR BILLS TOGETHER AND
WE'RE GOING TO TAKE ACTION THE
CONSENT CALENDAR IN THE ITEMS
THAT WE'VE ALREADY TAKEN ACTION
ON. WE'RE GONNA INVITE SOMEONE
OVER TO BE A TO COME FORWARD AYE
AS WE ARE COMPILING A PAPERWORK
IN WILL GET GOING ON YOUR BILL
HERE IN ABOUT.
TWO MINUTES OF COMMON PORTS.
YES THANK YOU.
IN THE TIME WHEN.
WITH.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR
PATIENCE MEMBERS WOULD LIKE TO
BE TO TAKE THE PROPOSED CONSENT
COUNTER FIRST THAT'S ITEM ONE
ITEM FOUR EIGHT NINE EIGHTEEN IN
NINETEEN. ONE FOUR EIGHT NINE
EIGHTEEN IN NINETEEN WITH THE
MOTION BY SENATOR WIN.
ON THIS AND JUST A ROLL CALL
VOTE PLEASE MCGUIRE BY REQUIRE I.
I WHEN I TELL. HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE LARA
MORLOCK. MORE LIKE GUY.
THEY'RE CURRENTLY ENJOYS IT FOUR
ZERO OVER AND KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
MEMBERS WOULD LIKE TO HAVE TO
FILE ITEM NUMBER TWO IF YOU
FIFTEEN NINETY FOUR. IS OUR
MOTION.
MOVE IT WE'VE THE MOTION BY THE
VICE CHAIR THIS IS A DO PASS A
TRANSPORTATION HOUSING. ISN'T
JUST A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE
WIRE HIGH GROUND HIGH WHERE.
WELL SIR I.
WHEN HIS AYE WINTERS I. FELL.
HERNANDEZ AYE HERTZBERG. FIRST
BILL GUY LARA WARLOCK. WARLOCK
GUY.
THEY CURRENTLY ENJOYS OF FOUR
ZERO OVER AND KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
MEMBERS WOULD LIKE TO FLOW TO
ITEM NUMBER THREE. AB SEVENTEEN
FORTY ONE IS OUR MOTION.
PROBABLY. PATH FILE ITEM THREE.
SO.
WE THE MOST PRESSING HERTZBERG
IS IS THE DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS AS THE INTERESTS
OF LOCAL POLICE WIRE AYE MCGUIRE
AYE WAY NO NGUYEN NOBEL.
HERNANDEZ HERTZBERG HERTZBERG
AYE LARA MORE LAW.
MORE LIKE I.
THEY'RE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE
ONE WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OF
THINGS THANK YOU. FOR NOW MOVING
ON TO FILE ITEM.
FIVE.
AB NINETEEN HUNDRED IS OUR
MOTION.
BY THE MOST MY SENATOR HERTZBERG
SAYS IT TO PASS ON THE FLOOR
ROLL CALL PLEASE.
MCGUIRE AYE WIRE AYE NGUYEN.
THAT FILE ITEM FIVE.
WHEN I FELL HERNANDEZ AYE
HERTZBERG.
HERTZBERG AYE LARA MORE LA. ONE
DIED FOR THEIR CURRENTLY ENJOYS
A FOUR ZERO OVER AND KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN.
FINAL THAT WE'RE GONNA TAKE A
VOTE ON IT THIS MOMENT IS FILE
ITEM SEVENTEEN IN THE TWENTY
FIVE EXCUSE ME AB TWENTY NINE
FIFTY FOUR. AS OUR MOTION.
CENTER HERTZBERG DE HAS IS
MOTION WHICH IS A DO PASSED TO
THE FLOOR. BY IT WE WILL BE
FOLLOWING UP WITH THE QUESTIONS
ITS INNER MORLOCK CAT BUT THE
AUTHORS OFFICE. IS WINCHESTER.
VOCAL MCGUIRE AYE WHY I WIN. WIN
I'D SELL. FERNANDES HERTZBERG
HERTZBERG AYE LARA MORE LAW.
MORE LIKE I.
RECRUITING JOYCE A FOUR ZERO
THANK YOU SO MUCH MEMBERS AND
THINK OF YOUR PATIENTS
ASSEMBLYMEMBERS WELL SENATOR.
WE'RE GOING TO TURN IT OVER TO
ON THE CINEMA CARLA CARLA MY
GOSH I DO APOLOGIZE SIR ON THIS
IMMIGRANT THIS HAS BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT. SO WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR
TWENTY TWO PRESENTATION FROM
YUNIOR WITNESSES THE FLOORS OR
SIR.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AS CHAIR AND
SENATORS OF THE PROBE ALLOW ME
TO PRESENT AB TWENTY FOUR
HUNDRED WHICH A NEWS
CALIFORNIA'S VOLUNTARY TAX CHECK
OFF. BROWSE I'M IS RESEARCH AND
OTHER DEMENTIA RELATED DISEASES
THE CHECK OFFICE FIRST AUTHORIZE
NINETEEN EIGHTY SEVEN IS REYES
OVER TWENTY FOUR MILLION DOLLARS
WHAT FUNDING OVER ONE HUNDRED
AND THIRTY FOUR. RESEARCH
PROJECTS WITHOUT RENEWAL THE
FUNDS WILL EXPIRE AND NOT APPEAR
ON THE TWO THOUSAND NINETEEN
STATE TAX FORM. ABOUT WHAT THAT
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AND I BUT
I DO ACCEPT THE COMMITTEES
TECHNOL MEN MEN'S AND AND WITH
MEAN FOR VERY BRIEF COMMENTS ARE
SUSAN TO MORRIS THOUSAND
ASSOCIATION AND YOU KNOW.
HARBAUGH THEY ARE P. THANK YOU
SO MUCH IT WE'RE GRATEFUL FOR
YOUR WORK. AND THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING HERE IT'S GOOD TO SEE
YOU.
GOOD AFTERNOON SUSAN TO MORRIS
ON BEHALF OF THE ALZHEIMER'S
ASSOCIATION WE ARE PROUD TO
SPONSOR THIS BILL AND WE'RE
OBVIOUSLY IN STRONG SUPPORT WHEN
IT WAS FIRST ENACTED IN NINETEEN
EIGHTY SEVEN. ALZHEIMER'S WAS
THE SIXTH LEADING CAUSE OF DEATH
IN OUR STATE TODAY IT'S THIRD WE
STILL DO NOT KNOW THE CAUSE WE
DON'T HAVE A CURE OR A WAY TO
PREVENT ALZHEIMER'S RESEARCH IS
MORE IMPORTANT THAN EVER TODAY.
WE URGE YOUR AYE VOTE THANK YOU
SO MUCH GOOD MORNING NAM AND AND
GOOD MORNING MY NAME IS NINA
WHILE THE HARLEM HERE ON BEHALF
OF A. R. P. CALIFORNIA AS OUR
CARE GIVING LEAD IN AT A OUR P..
I HEAR DEVASTATING STORIES ALL
THE TIME OUR RESEARCH SHOWS THAT
THE TYPICAL CARE GIVER FOR SOME
OF THE COGNITIVE IMPAIRMENT
SPENDS OVER TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS
YOU'RE ON A LOVED ONE. A OR P.
SUPPORTS A SPOKE BECAUSE IT'LL
FURTHER RESEARCH INTO
PHARMACEUTICALS. ADMITTED SPACE
CAREGIVER SUPPORT PROGRAMS.
AS WELL AS EARLY DETECTION OF
ALZHEIMER'S AND DEMENTIA AND WE
WOULD APPRECIATE YOUR AYE VOTE
THINK YOU SO MUCH WE NOW WOULD
LIKE TO WELCOME ANYONE WHO'S IN
SUPPORT IF YOU COULD PLEASE
ADVANCE FOR SOLICITING YOUR
ORGANIZATION YOU POSITION ON THE
BILL AND WERE IN SUPPORT. BY OUR
MIKE MONTGOMERY WITH THE
CONGRESS OF CALIFORNIA SENIORS
WE SUPPORT THE BILL THANK YOU SO
MUCH LIKE THINKS FOR BEING WITH
US TODAY MORNING MA'AM.
MORNING LISA COLEMAN WITH CAL CO
OF CALIFORNIA LONG TERM CARE
OMBUDSMAN ASSOCIATION IN STRONG
SUPPORT LEASES BEEN BUSY THIS
WEEK. THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'D
LIKE TO BETTER INVITE ANYONE
ELSE IN SUPPORT TO PLEASE
ADVANCE THIS TIME SUPPORT. LAST
CALL. YOU KNOW WOULD LIKE TO BE
TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE OPPOSED.
LAST CALL.
THAT'S BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE DB TO SEE IF WE HAVE
ANY DISCUSSION OR DEBATE ON THIS
BILL.
WE HAVE A MOTION WHICH IF I
CENTER MORE LOCK WHICH IS A DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO PREPARATIONS
SEPTEMBER WE WELCOME A CLOSING
STATEMENT.
THAT WAS SHOT IN MY MOUTH SOME
ASSOCIATION TIE AND APPRECIATE
THE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR MY BOAT
PSERIES COORDINATED I LIKE IT'S.
LIKE YOU SO MUCH IN GRATEFUL FOR
YOUR WORKING THANK YOU BOTH FOR
BEING HERE AS WELL.
BUT WE HAVE A DO PASS AS AMENDED
DO PREPARATIONS MOTION THE FLOOR
BY MISTER MORLOCK MISLEAD
CHESTER ROLL CALL PLEASE WIREFLY
WIRE.
WELL.
HERNANDEZ AYE FERNANDO SIDE
HERTZBERG HERTZBERG AYE LARA
MORE LOCK. MORE LIKE I. THINK
YOU SO MUCH SO MEMBERS COULD YOU
SEE SIR.
THAT THAT CURRENTLY ENJOYS A
FOUR ZERO OVER AND KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN MEMBERS ARE NOW MOVING ON
TO FILE ITEM SIX.
BUT WE ARE SO GRATEFUL LISTENER
GALGIANI IS HERE AT TO BE A TO
PRESENT ON BEHALF IT'S AN AMBER
FRAZIER.
ON
SENATOR WE DO HAVE BIPARTISAN
SUPPORT ON THE SOMEONE MEMBERS
BILL LEE WHAT IS HE THINKING TO
YOU BEFORE I COME IN AND IT
SHOULDN'T. PRETTY SIMILAR WHO I
KNOW EVERYONE IS BUSY THIS WEEK.
CENTER THE FLOOR IS YOURS AND WE
ASK FOR TARGETED STATEMENT AS WE
HAVE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IT'S
ALWAYS GOOD TO SEE YOU. THANK
YOU VERY MUCH ASSEMBLYMEMBER
FRAZIER EXCEPT THE COMMITTEE'S
RECOMMENDED AMENDMENTS WHICH ARE
TECHNICAL IN NATURE. AND DONATE
LIFE WOULD USE THIS NEW CAPITAL
TO EXPAND ITS EDUCATION OUTREACH
PROGRAMS TO INCREASE
PARTICIPATION IN THE REGISTRY. I
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR A AYE VOTE.
THAT AGAIN JOHN IS COMING IN
LESS THAN THIRTY SECONDS WATCH
OUT HEY SEE THERE YOU GO KINKY
SO MUCH AS SENATOR I'M VERY VERY
GRATEFUL. THAT ME AND WE WELCOME
YOU PLEASE GIVE US YOUR PERSONAL
ASKING ORGANIZATION THANKS FOR
TAKING THE TIME. I MONICA
JOHNSON BOARD MEMBER TONY LIFE
CALIFORNIA WITH THE AUTHORIZED
STATE ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATION
REGISTRY WE WOULD USE THE FUNDS
FROM AB TWENTIES NINETY SIX TO.
INCREASE OUR EDUCATION AND
OUTREACH ON THE IMPORTANCE OF
ORGAN AND TISSUE DONATION.
IF YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU FOR
YOUR TESTIMONY WE WOULD NOW LIKE
TO WELCOME ANYONE ELSE WOULD
LIKE TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT OF THE
BILL IF YOU COULD PLEASE
ADVANCED TO THE MICROPHONE WE
WELCOME YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT. LAST
CALL. WE NOW WOULD LIKE TO GET A
TRANSITION TO THOSE WHO ARE
OPPOSED.
LAST CALL. THIS BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE DEBATED STEVE WE HAVE
A MOTION NOT BY SENATOR MORE
LOCK I NEED TO SHOW DISCUSSION
OR DEBATE FROM THE COMMITTEE.
CENTER WOULD YOU LIKE TO CLOSE I
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
LOOK AT THAT ADDISON RIVER NEEDS
A SITTER TO GO TO EVERY AYE
COMMITTEE FOR HIM WATCH OUT.
THAT'S WONDERFUL THIS IS A DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS MISLIM CHESTER
ROLL CALL PLEASE THE FLYER I
WHERE I WIN.
BELL. BELCHITE HERNANDEZ WITHIN
SIGHT HERTZBERG. WHICH ARE GUIDE
LARA. MORE LOCK AND I KIND. THAT
ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO VOTE THANK
YOU SO MUCH SENATOR THANK YOU
VERY MUCH.
FOR NOW MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN AB TWENTY ONE
THIRTY SEVEN. MISTER MAYES.
IS HERE IT'S GOOD TO SEE YOU
AGAIN SIR.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER YOU HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON THIS BILL
BY AND WE WELCOME A TRUNCATED
VERSION OF YOUR STATEMENT.
IN AGAIN THANK YOU FOR ALL YOUR
WORK SIR IT'S ALWAYS GOOD TO SEE
THE FLOOR IS YOURS. BY THANK YOU
MISS CHAIR AND SENATORS AB
TWENTY ONE THIRTY SEVEN WOULD
INCREASE HER KIDS RIVERSIDE
COUNTY REGIONAL PARK IN OPEN
SPACE TO SIX NO BID PURCHASING
AUTHORITY FROM TWENTY FIVE
THOUSAND. TO FIFTY THOUSAND THAT
THIS CHANGE WOULD BETTER SUPPORT
THE DISTRICT'S MISSION BY
ELIMINATING ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
FOR SMALL PROJECTS IN PROMOTING
EFFICIENT USE OF RESOURCES. BY
THE COMMITTEE RAISED A FAIR
POINT THAT IT MAY BE TIME TO
INCREASE THE BID THRESHOLDS FOR
ALL DISTRICTS TO FIFTY THOUSAND.
ADJUST FOR INFLATION AND SO I
APPRECIATE WORKING WITH ME IN
THE SENATE MCGUIRE HAVE YOU HAVE
TO ACCEPT THAT AS A COMMITTEE
AMENDMENT I RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
AN AYE VOTE AND I THINK IT MAY
IN HERE THAT'S GOING TO BE VERY
BRIEF.
IT YOU WANT TO SEE THINK IT IS
IN A RIVER OF WORKING WITH
ASSEMBLY AS IS YOU KNOW SOME
MEMBER AND WE SEE A LOT OF THESE
ARE COMING FORWARD I THINK IT'S
TIME TO BE ABLE TO MOVE FORWARD
ON. A STATEWIDE BASIS VERY
GRATEFUL TO WORK PROCESS IN
EARLY SKIP POLICY AND AGREED TO
WORK WITH I THINK YOU SO MUCH
SIR. THEY CAN WE WELCOME YOU.
THEY KICK MORNING MISTER
CHAIRMAN COMMITTEES MEMBERS OF
THE COMMITTEE ON MAKING GOMEZ
THE FISCAL MANAGER FOR RIVERSIDE
COUNTY PARK DISTRICT. AS THE
DISTRICT'S FINANCIAL STEWARD AYE
IN FULL SUPPORT OF AB TWENTY ONE
THIRTY SEVEN THAT WILL ALLOW US
TO PUT MORE DOLLARS IN THE DIRT
OR IN THE PARK GROUNDS AS IT MAY
BE. AND I'M A RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST YOUR AYE VOTE AND I'M
HERE TO ANSWER ANY TECHNICAL
QUESTIONS THAT YOU MIGHT HAVE
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'RE GONNA
WELCOME THOSE WHO ARE IN SUPPORT.
GOOD MORNING SIR MORNING HOW
FRIENDS ROSSI WITH THE
CALIFORNIA SPECIAL DISTRICTS
ASSOCIATION SPORT THAT. THANK
YOU SO MUCH WITH ACCURACY
THERE'S ANYONE ELSE WHO WAS IN
SUPPORT OF YOU TO PLEASE
COMPORTED THIS TIME.
ANYONE WHO IS SUPPOSE CAN YOU
PLEASE ADVANCE.
SCENE NINE WERE GONNA BRING BACK
TO COMMITTEE TO BE TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANY.
QUESTIONS WE HAVE A MOTION UP BY
CENTER MORE LOCK THIS IS A DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO THE FLOORS IN
THE MEMBER WOULD YOU LIKE TO
CLOSER.
I WOULD LOVE IT AYE VOTE THANK
YOU SO MUCH AND THE SCIENTISTS A
ROLL CALL PLEASE REQUIRE HIGH
WHY I WIN.
NGUYEN I BILL BELL ALRIGHT
HERNANDEZ AND THEN DECIDE
HERTZBERG.
WITH REGARD LARA MORE LOCKED.
MORE LIKE AYE SIX. THAT ENJOYS A
SIX YEAR VOTE AND MISTER SIMON
WE'RE GONNA. HOLD THE ROLE OPEN
IN HAVE FOLKS HAD ON.
THANK YOU SO MUCH GOOD TO SEE A
QUICK JOB.
MEMBERS.
WE ARE LOOKING FOR SOMEONE
MEMBERS BY AND THIS IS A
WONDERFUL TRADITION THAT WE'VE
STARTED HERE IN THE GOVERNMENT
FINANCE.
COMMITTEE.
VICE CHAIR THE WAY. TICKETS
OFFER.
NO.
COUPLE OF THINGS THAT. NEED TO
VOTE.
ALRIGHT WE'RE GONNA ADD FOLKS ON
THE TIME IN THE NOT I'S
WE'RE GOING TO GET A QUICK
UPDATE ON WHERE WE'RE AT WITH
BUDGET IN IN.
CINEMA LOCKING I MAY HAVE TO.
HEAD ON EL.
CENTRE BELL AS WELL AT SO WE'RE
GOING TO ADD ON FOLKS SO SOON
HERNANDEZ WILL ADD ON IS WELL AS
AS SENATOR WIN. IF YOU ALL DON'T
MIND WE TAKE CARE OF THE
HOUSEKEEPING HERE QUICKLY IT'S
GIVE A SIX
.
AND NINE THOSE ABSENT MEMBERS
WE'RE GONNA START WITH THE
PROPOSED CONSENT CALENDAR.
ITEMS ONE FOUR EIGHT NINE
EIGHTEEN IN NINETEEN CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO MISLAID
CHESTER ROLL CALL PLEASE.
DEL. VALLE I PREVENT THIS
HERNANDEZ AYE LARA.
SIX.
ZERO VOTE KEEP THE ROLE OPEN FOR
CENTER LARA.
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
TO.
DID YOU PASS YOUR TRANSPORTATION.
ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO MISLED.
YEAH.
BILL I HERNANDEZ I MEAN AND THE
SIZE LARA.
SIX ZERO WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN.
MEMBERS ARE MOVING ON TO FILE
ITEM THREE THIS IS A DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO PREPARATIONS
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A THREE ONE
VOTE ASSIGNED CHESTER VAL. WELL
I'D HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE LARA.
IT IS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE
ONE THAT WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN.
MEMBERS WERE GONNA MOVE FOR TO
FILE ITEM FIVE MAYBE NINETEEN
HUNDREDS IS TO DO PASS THE FLOOR
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR ZERO
MISS LANE CHESTER. AL.
WELL I HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE
LARA.
THAT ENJOYS A SIX ZERO OF WE'RE
GOING TO KEEP THE ROLE OPEN WE
WELCOME THIS WEBER TO THE
COMMITTEE WE'RE GOING TO BE
RIGHT WITH YOU BUT PLEASE COME
FORWARD. AND WE'RE MOVING ON TO
FILE ITEM TEN BY AB TWENTY FOUR
HUNDRED TO ADEQUATELY JOYS A
FOUR ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER.
WHEN.
I.
HERNANDEZ.
OKAY.
WELL. BILL I.
WHEN I WIN I MEAN IS.
HERNANDEZ.
IS HAVE ANY ARTICLE OF
DIFFERENCE ARE. WHAT I?
YEAH YOU ARE GOING TO.
SO WINNING INTO THE.
OKAY WE'RE CURRENTLY AT SIX ZERO
THANK YOU SO MUCH. MEMBERS ARE
NOW MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
SEVENTEEN AB TWENTY NINE FIFTY
FOUR THIS IS A TO PASS TO THE
FLOOR. CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FOUR
ZERO. MISLAID CHESTER BROKE UP
PLEASE BELL. BELL AYE HERNANDEZ
HERNANDEZ AYE LARA SIX.
SIX ZERO BRING KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN.
AND HIS WINTERS IN HALF OF. CASH.
NO THIS NO SIX SIX.
TWENTY NINETY FISH WHO'S NOT A.
OKAY. HILLARY'S THEIR. FILE
ITEMS.
OKAY MATTER IF NOT DONE SIX WE
NEED HER TWENTY NINETY
OKAY.
WE.
THERE IS DEMOCRATIC MESSAGE.
WHAT HAD HAPPENED?
WE NEED TO OPEN THAT.
IF.
NOTICED LITTLE.
MEMBERS WE'RE GONNA OPEN UP FILE
ITEM SIX AB TWENTY NINETY SIX
MUSLIM CHESTER WHEN. I WHEN I.
CURRENTLY JOYS A SIX ZERO VOTE
WE'RE GOING TO KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN ON THAT THANK YOU SO MUCH
MEMBERS AND I WANT TO APOLOGIZE.
TO SOME MEMBER WEBER.
FOR ACTUALLY TAKING SO LONG
THERE WAS WEBER IT'S ALWAYS
WONDERFUL TO SEE YOU. ON THIS
WEBER WE DO HAVE.
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN YOUR BILL
SUBURBAN ASK FOR TRUNCATED
STATEMENT AND SOME EVER THANK
YOU FOR ATTENDING IN THE FLOOR
IS YOURS MA'AM.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND I WANT
TO THANK THE OF THE COMMITTEE
CHAIR AND THE STAFF WORKING WITH
US ON THAT DAY AMENDMENTS.
AND WE ACCEPT ALL OF THE
COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS.
I'M THRILLED PLEASED TO PRESENT
TWENTY FOUR FIFTY EIGHT WHICH
WERE EIGHT SENIOR AND SEVERELY
DISABLED HOMEOWNERS IN LOCATING
INFORMATION. ON HOW TO APPLY FOR
PARCEL TAX EXEMPTION. ANOTHER
REVIEW ALL THE BACKGROUND I'M
JUST GOING TO SAY I RESPECTFULLY
ASK WHEN I VOTE.
AND WE HAVE WITH ME MISTER KARIM
GREASY WHO IS THE CALIFORNIA
ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS THANK
YOU SO MUCH AS A MEMBER. MYSTERY
SEE WELCOME SIR OF THE MORNING
MISTER CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
CREAM THREE C. ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF
REALTORS VERY PROUD TO BE THE
SPONSOR OF AB TWENTY FOUR FIFTY
EIGHT HERE T ANSWER ANY
QUESTIONS THE COMMITTEE MEMBERS
MAY HAVE BEEN RESPECTFULLY
REQUEST AN AYE. VOTE THANK YOU
THANK YOU SO MUCH YOU'VE PICKED
WONDERFUL PARTNER TO WORK WITH
THINK YOU OF WE NOW LIKE TO GET
TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE IN
SUPPORT OF THE BILL IF YOU COULD
PLEASE ADVANCED THIS TIME ANYONE
IN SUPPORT OF THE BILL PLEASE
ADVANCE.
ALL RIGHT WE'RE NOT GOING TO BE
GOING TO THOSE WHO ARE OPPOSED
TO PLEASE WELCOME.
YOUR MIND IS INTRODUCING
YOURSELF SIR SIR MISTER CHAIRMAN
OF OF THE MEMBERS POTTER SHUDDER
IT'S WE HAVE HERE TODAY. A PINCH
HITTING FOR CAROLINA BE HAVE THE
CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION OF.
COUNTY TAX COLLECTORS AND
TREASURES.
I'M PASSING OUT A COPY IT'S A A
MOCK OF IN LA COUNTY PROPERTY
TAX BILL.
TECH TECH IS STILL A OPPOSED THE
BILL APPRECIATE THE GOOD WORK
DONE BY YOU AND YOUR STAFF I
HAVE.
OBVIOUSLY IMMENSE RESPECT FOR
THE AUTHOR.
I DO WANT TO NOTE HOWEVER.
WE LOOK AT THAT TAX BILL.
WE CAN KEEP IN MIND THAT LA
COUNTY HAS EIGHTY DIFFERENT
SCHOOL DISTRICTS.
I THINK IT'S JUST IMPERATIVE
THAT THE SCHOOLS IN CALIFORNIA
THAT GIVE THESE EXEMPTIONS HAVE
SOME SKIN IN THE GAME.
EIGHTY SIX THANK YOU CENTER OF
THEIR SOME SKIN IN THE GAME IN
TERMS OF MAKING SURE THAT LOCAL
TREASURES AND TAX COLLECTORS.
HAVE THE EXEMPTION INFORMATION
IN THAT IT'S NOT THE ONUS IS ON
ON THE TREASURE TO GO AND GET
THAT INFORMATION SO THAT IT'S
POSTED CORRECTLY. WITH THAT A
CONCLUDE MY OPPOSITION TESTIMONY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'D LIKE TO
NOW AYE OPENING UP TO BE TO SEE
IF WE HAVE ANYONE ELSE WHO'S
OPPOSED IF YOU COULD PLEASE
COMPORTED A MICROPHONE ANYONE
ELSE IS SUPPOSED.
SCENE NINE WOULD LIKE TO BE TO
BRING BACK TO COMMITTEE CENTER
FOR LAW. COMMISSION TERRY GETS
BACK TO THIS WHOLE
ADMINISTRATIVE COST.
COMPONENT I'M JUST WONDERING IF
A.
THE REPRESENTATIVE FROM KACAK
COULD ANSWER A QUESTION OR TWO.
PLEASE.
IT SEEMS TO ME.
.
RECENTLY WHEN FOR PUTTING MAJOR
SOFTWARE.
UPDATING EVERYBODY'S ARE DOING
THE SAME.
I DON'T KNOW FUN UNTITLED TO WE
DO WE KNOW THE AGES OF PROPERTY
OWNERS OR IS THERE A POSSIBILITY
TO GET FEE AGES.
IS THAT EVEN IN THE REALM OF
FEASIBILITY TO THE CHAIR I DON'T
BELIEVE TREASURES HAVE THAT
INFORMATION. THERE IS IS IS IT
REQUIRED ALL LEARNERS AND I'M
THE ONE RIVERS AND I DIFFERENT
BILL TO MAKE IT A LITTLE EASIER.
IF YOU HAVE THE AGES OF THE
PROPERTY URGENTLY SHOULD TAKE
CARE OF THE.
SENIOR COMPONENT RIGHT. FROM
JUST WONDERING IF MAYBE THAT'S
SOMETHING KACAK IN THE AUTHOR
CAN WORK ON NEXT YEAR SOME APPS
I'M ACTUALLY HAPPY TO TAKE THAT
BACK TO THE TREASURES.
BUT IN THE MEANTIME YOU'RE
ASSUMING THAT.
THE ONUS IS ON YOU.
I THINK IT MEMBERS GO A LONG WAY
INTO IN ADDRESSING THE TREASURES
OPPOSITION AND HOPEFULLY WE CAN
MAYBE KEEP WORKING ON STUFF.
SO IT'S IT'S I THINK THE LA
EXAMPLE IS REALLY THE MOST
EXTREME THAT'S WHY I'M JUST
pCOMMITTEE TODAY. THINK ORANGE
COUNTY WOULD BE INVOLVED SO GALA
A LOT OF SCHOOL DISTRICTS THERE
TO. COME TO MAKE SURE THAT THE
INFORMATION IS CORRECT.
SO THAT THE TAXPAYERS CAN RELY
ON IT.
YOU KNOW JUST AGAIN IN LA IT'S
GOING TO TAKE A LOT OF WORK FROM
THE TREASURER'S OFFICE TO TO DO
THAT SO THAT THE PUBLIC. IS
ACTUALLY GETTING THE INFORMATION
THAT THEY'RE LOOKING FOR.
MENTOR IN YOUR SAYING THAT DID
THAT THE MEMBER WHO REALLY WANTS
AT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT SHOULD BE
RESPONSIBLE FOR.
FOR THAT BUT THEY'RE STILL GOTTA
FEED THE DATA TO THE TO THE
TREASURER AND THE AND THE OUT OF
CONTROL RIGHT IT WOULD BE GREAT
SCHOOL DISTRICTS IF YOU'RE
LISTENING IT WOULD BE GREAT IF
YOU COULD HELP. AT A MINIMUM IF
THEY COULD HELP THE TREASURES
MAKE SURE THAT THE INFORMATION
POSTED IS IN FACT CORRECT WE'RE
TALKING ABOUT. LINKS RIGHT ON
THE INTERNET.
ONE ONE DIGIT IS OFF THEN THE
LINK IS BAD AND.
THAT'S THE KIND I.
THAT'S THE KIND OF STUFF THAT
THE TREASURES WANNA MAKE SURE IS
ABSOLUTELY ACCURATE SO THAT TO
TAXPAYERS CAN ACCESS WITH THE
NEED TO ACCESS. USES A
BLOCKCHAIN.
OPPORTUNITY.
YEAH EVERY OPPORTUNITY BUT YOU
KNOW. I THINK YOU THINK YOU BUT
RICHARD THANK YOU SO MUCH SOONER
WOULD THAT BE TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR
QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMITTEE
THIS TIME.
WE HAVE A MOTION RIGHT NOW BY S.
IN HERNANDEZ WHICH IS A DO
PASSES A MINUTE APPROPRIATIONS.
PRODUCE TAKING ACTION THT WOULD
LIKE TO BE ABLE TO OPEN UP TO
SOME OF FOR CLOSING COMMENTS
YEAH THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND WE
AND WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH.
WITH THE OPPONENT TO AND TAKEN
A LOT OF THEIR AMENDMENTS AND WE
WILL CONTINUE TO DO THAT I WILL
ALSO PLEASED TO TINK OF FURTHER
MEANING THE BILL TO MAKE CLEAR
THAT THE TAX COLLECTORS NOT
REQUIRED TO PROVIDE PARCEL TAX
EXEMPTION. INFORMATION IS
WEBSITE ON THE COUNTY TAX BILL
IF THE SCHOOL DISTRICT BILLS TO
PROVIDE A TAX COLLECTOR WITH THE
SPECIFIED INFORMATION WHILE ALSO
ENSURING THAT THE TAX COLLECTED
DOES NOT HAVE TO PROVIDE INVALID
HYPERLINKS TO THE PUBLIC SO. WE
STILL WORKING ON THAT IN TERMS
OF MAKING SURE OF THE WE DO
BELIEVE THAT IT IS A TAX
COLLECTORS RESPONSIBILITY THOUGH
TO UNDERSTAND THE TAXES AND TO
MAKE THAT INFORMATION THERE. SO
WE JUST WANT TO MAKE IT OBVIOUS
EASIER FOR SENIORS AND THOSE
WILL DISABLE THE TAKE ADVANTAGE
OF THE OPPORTUNITY TO HAVE THE
EXEMPTION.
SO RESPECTFULLY ASK ME I VOTE
BECAUSE SO MUCH SOME EVER WE DO
OF THE MOTION THE FLOOR BY
SENATOR NAMED IS THIS IS A DO
PASS AS AMENDED TO PREPARATIONS
SHS A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE.
MCGUIRE AYE MCGUIRE AYE. WIN.
WIN AYE BELL. BELL AYE HERNANDEZ
HAD DECIDED TO BURKE.
CHRIS O'DONNELL ARE MORE LAW.
MORE LIKE GUYS. CRINGE AS A SIX
YEAR VOTERS AND THE RED KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN ALLOW MISTER LARD AND
I THINK YOU SO MUCH.
MEMBERS WERE GONNA NOW INVITE
MISS QUIRK SILVA UP AS A MEMBER
QUIRK SILVA NINE NOW FILE ITEM
THIRTEEN AB TWENTY SIX FIFTY
FOUR. FOUR THEN GONNA HAVE
ASSEMBLY MEMBER JONES SAWYER ON
FILE ITEM SIXTEEN IN OF COURSE
WERE ALWAYS GONNA WELCOME
MINISTER MEDINA. FOR AYE AB
TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE AS WELL
THE FIRST WE'RE GONNA KICK IT
OFF WITH MISS QUIRK SILVA AB
TWENTY SIX FIFTY FOUR. AND
ASSEMBLY WOMAN WE DO HAVE
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT IN YOUR BILL
SO WE'RE GONNA ASK FOR A
TRUNCATED VERSION OF THE
STATEMENT BUT WE ALWAYS WELCOME
YOU AND THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR
TAKING THE TIME. WE WILL KEEP IT
SHORT TEN WAY.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR WORKING
WITH US ON THIS BILL AND HAPPILY
ACCEPTED MEN MEN'S I'D AGAIN ON
THE DESIGN BUILD I JUST HOOKED
GIVE YOU A LITTLE BACKGROUND
WITH MYSELF RELATED DESIGN BILL
AS I WAS ON SANITATION IN ORANGE
COUNTY. AND THAT TRADITIONAL BUT
DESIGNED A BILL BID AND THEN
BUILD UP DID OFTEN. OCCUR WITH
HAVING CHANGE ORDERS SO WE FEEL
LIKE THIS WILL I DEFINITELY MOVE
FORWARD PROJECTS AND THE
SPECIFIC PROJECT WHAT THE.
FLOOD CONTROL AND WE WOULD JUST
OF.
LET ARE A GUEST HERE MAKE A
FREAKY REMARKS AND THEN MOVE
THROUGH THIS I KNOW THERE'S A
LOT OF BILLS.
SOMEONE PLEASE WELCOME IF YOU
DON'T GIVE US YOUR FIRST LAST
YEAR ORGANIZATION WELCOME. FROM
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE.
MINORITY CON DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF
ORANGE COUNTY PUBLIC WORKS I
THINK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO
SPEAK TODAY AND I WILL KEEP MY
COMMENTS BRIEF. AB TWENTY SIX
FIFTY FOUR WILL PROVIDE THE
COUNTY OF ORANGE AND THE ORANGE
COUNTY FLOOD CONTROL DISTRICT
WITH THE OPTION OF DELIVERING
COMPLEX PROJECTS. THROUGH A TEAM
APPROACH UTILIZING PROVEN DESIGN
BUILD ADVANTAGES SUCH AS EARLY
CONTRACTOR INVOLVEMENT CONTRACT
ACROSS PREDICTABILITY ENHANCE
SCHEDULE CONTROLS AND RISK
MITIGATION. EIGHT.
THANK YOU.
MOTION ON THE FLOOR BUT.
FOR AB TWENTY SIX FIFTY FOUR BY
CENTER MORE LOCKS YOU DO IS
WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE ABLE TO HOW
AS CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE AS WE
HAVE THE STATE BUILDING
CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL IN
SUPPORT. MICKEY SO MUCH WHEN I
WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME ANYONE
ELSE WHO SINCE FORTY COMPLETE
ADVANCE WELCOME CERTAIN ON
BEHALF OF THE AMERICAN COUNCIL
OF ENGINEERING COMPANIES.
OUR CONCERNS ARE CORRECTLY
IDENTIFIED IN PARAGRAPH OR
COMMENT THREE AND SOLVE BY THE
AMENDMENT SO WE STRONGLY SUPPORT
DESIGN BUILD AND HAVE ALWAYS
BEEN ADVOCATES OF DESIGN. OF
ALTERNATIVE PROJECT DELIVERY
MECHANISMS THANK YOU SO MUCH.
IN SUPPORT MISTER CHAIRMAN
MEMBERS PACMAN WITH THEIR IN
READING ASSOCIATES REPRESENTING
THE ORANGE COUNTY EMPLOYEES
ASSOCIATION SUPPORT THE BILL
THANK YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT OF THE PLEASE ADVANCE.
WHEN I WOULD LIKE TO BE A
WELCOME ANYONE WHO'S OPPOSED IF
YOU COULD PLEASE COME FORWARD.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSED.
THAT B. TO BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE WE DO HAVE A MOTION ON
THE FLOOR CURRENTLY BY CENTER
MORE LOCK LIKELY TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR. COMMENTS
FROM THE COMMITTEE THIS TIME.
ASSEMBLY MEMBER WOULD YOU LIKE
TO IT A CLOSE AT JUST
RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR AYE VOTE
AND I'M YEAR JUST SO SNIP SNAP
HERE AND THERE WE GO ANY SOURCE
I THINK YOU SOMEONE FOR A
WORKING WITH THE COMMITTEE AS
WELL WE'RE REALLY GRATEFUL FOR
ALL YOUR WORK.
SO I JUST RECALL PLEASE.
WHY DON'T I WHY I WIN?
WITH BROAD BELL TO HIBERNATE
THIS.
IT'S BURKE.
I LARA.
MORE LOCKED
MORE LIKE I.
I CURRENTLY JURIES A FIVE ZERO
SILLY WOMAN WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE
ROLE OPEN IN THEN ADD ON IS
FOLKS.
THANK YOU SENATOR THANK YOU SO
MUCH.
PLEASE IN GENERAL WERE NOT GOING
TO BE WELCOMING MISTER JONES
SAWYER TO THE FLOOR. BY AB
TWENTY NINE FORTY FOUR THIS IS
FILE ITEM SIXTEEN. SIMMER WE DO
HAVE BIPARTISAN SUPPORT ON YOUR
BILL SUPERGRASS FOR TRUNCATED
VERSION OF YOUR PRESENTATION
WE'RE REALLY GRATEFUL FOR ALL
YOUR WORK CERTAINLY ALWAYS
WELCOMING COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU A.
AND I KNOW I NEED TO SAY THIS
FIRST I WOULD LIKE TO START BY
ACCEPTING THE TECHNICAL
COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS OUTLINED ON
PAGE FORTY ANALYSIS.
THIS BILL WILL ALLOW CALIFORNIA
TO DONATE A PORTION OF THE TAX
RETURN TO PROJECTS. THAT AND TO
SCHOOL TO PRISON PIPELINE TO A
COMPETITIVE GRANT PROCESS TO
CONTRIBUTION WILL FUND PROJECTS
SAID ADVANCE YOUTH LEADERSHIP
DEVELOPMENT OF LIFE SKILLS WORK.
FORCE READINESS AND MENTORSHIP
FOR MOST OF OUR VULNERABLE
STUDENTS ACROSS THE STATE TO
TESTIFY IN SUPPORT OF THIS BILL
I HAVE WITH ME TODAY. MICHAEL
LYNCH CO FOUNDER ABOUT AND CEO
OF IMPROVE IT TOMORROW AND
JUSTIN THEORY WITH THE ALLIANCE
FOR BOYS TO MEN OF COLOR I
RESPECTFULLY ANSWERING AYE VOTE.
THAN EVER THINK YOU SO MUCH WORK
WITH US ON THIS VERY GRATEFUL
WHO LIKED IT KICKS OFF.
CUSTOMERS OFTEN I THINK IF
YOU'RE GOING TO LOOK AT YOUR FOR
SOME LASSEN ORGANIZATION WE DO A
BIPARTISAN SUPPORT THINGS FOR
COMING TODAY PROSPECT DELAMAR OF
MICHAEL AND SEAN. WITH A WITH
IMPROVED TOMORROW WE HELP YOUNG
MEN OF COLOR DUE TO A TO COLLEGE
FOR THE CO SPONSOR THE MEASURE
ON. PERSONAL TIME WE THANK YOU
FOR YOUR SUPPORT AND FOR LIBEL
RIGHT I THINK YOU SOME LESSER.
GOOD MORNING JORDAN THEORY THE
LIGHTS WISEMAN A COLOR.
RESPECTFULLY ASKING FOR YOUR
AYE VOTE AND ALSO I JUST WANT TO
POINT OUT THE FACT THAT THIS IS
A NEAT UNIQUE CONTRIBUTION FIVE
DON'T EXPECT IT WILL COMPETE
WITH THE OTHER. OF FUNDS BUT
ACTUALLY INSPIRE NEW DONORS.
AND HAS THE POTENTIAL TO SAVE
THE STATE MONEY ON CORRECTIONS
AND PROBATION.
IS SAVING OUR OWN PEOPLE FOR
STRICTLY AFTER A VOTE THANK YOU.
THE REALLY IMPORTANT I THINK IS
SO MUCH WE DO HAVE A MOTION THE
FLOOR YOU DO WANT TO SEE IF WE
HAVE ANYONE ELSE IN SUPPORT OF
THE BILL ECCLES ADVANCE THIS
TIME FIRST AND LAST NAME AND
ORGANIZATION. WELCOME SIR WERE
IN SUPPORT VINCENT AND SUPPORT
VINCE NOR OF MAHJONG WITH WHITE
AND UP ON THE HAPPEN NEXT GEN IN
SUPPORT. THANK YOU SO MUCH GOOD
TO SEE YOU.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO ARE IN
SUPPORT OF YOU TO PLEASE ADVANCE
THIS TIME.
NOW THEY GO TO SEE IF THERE'S
ANYONE OPPOSED TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD. OPPOSED.
WE'RE GONNA BRING IT BACK TO
COMMITTEE DEBATE TO SEE PUT ANY
QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS WE HAVE A
IS A DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
APPROPRIATIONS. ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FROM THE COMMITTEE.
MR SILLIMAN FORESHORES FOR
CLOSING STATEMENT JUST WANT TO
QUICKLY SAY I'M REALLY PROUD OF
MICHAEL LIND SE STARS IN
INTERNET MAIL OFFICE HE NOW HAS
A MULTI MILLION DOLLAR
ORGANIZATION TO HELP YOUNG MEN.
AND OF COLOR IN SACRAMENTO IT IS
FANTASTIC ONE FITS THE PURPOSE
OF THIS FUND IN A WONDERFUL
MENTORS WELL SO THAT I COULD ASK
YOU AYE VOTE IN A WONDERFUL
THANK YOU SO MUCH ASSEMBLY.
SUGGESTS A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE
WIRE TIME WHERE I WIN.
AND I BILL. SELF AYE HERNANDEZ.
WHICH BURKE.
WHICH WORK AYE LARA MORE LIVE.
MORE LIKE NINE FIVE SEE
THE CURTAIN ENJOYS A FIVE ZERO
VOTE WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN THANK YOU SO MUCH THANK YOU
THANK JOB SIR.
WE DID HAVE I KNOW IT MR BERMAN
IN THE ART IS FOR ONE TO SEE IF
WE SERVICE IN THEIR MEDINA IN
HERE HE WAS HERE JUST A BIT AGO.
I DO NOT SEE CENTER MEDINA SO.
WE'RE GONNA ASK MISTER BERMAN TO
BE TO COME FORWARD WELCOME SIR.
BUTTON MISTER BERMAN.
IT'S GONNA BE PRESENTING ON AB
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE WE
WELCOME ME SIR THANK YOU SO MUCH
FOR BEING HERE TODAY IT'S GOOD
TO SEE YOU. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
MISTER CHAIRMAN SENATORS I COME
BEFORE YOU TODAY TO PRESENT AB
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE. A BILL
TO MODERNIZE THE SHARING OF
INFORMATION BETWEEN ASSESSORS
AND TAXPAYERS.
INCREASINGLY DOCUMENTS CAN BE
PROVIDED BY ASSESSORS AND
TAXPAYERS IN A MORE EFFICIENT
AND COST EFFECTIVE MANNER BY
MAIL AND IN SOME INSTANCES
ELECTRONICALLY. UNFORTUNATELY
EXISTING LAWS WOEFULLY OUT OF
DATE.
AS MY COUNTY ASSESSOR CAN SHARE
THEIR BEEN TIMES WHEN HIS STAFF
IS NEEDED TO TRAVEL TO VARIOUS
LOCATIONS AROUND THE STATE TO
OBTAIN THE NECESSARY INFORMATION
TO DO THE JOB.
SIMILARLY WHEN A TAXPAYER NEEDS
INFORMATION FROM ASSESSORS
OFFICE THE TAXPAYERS TRAVELS TO
YOU AND MAY WAIT IN LINE AT A
COUNTY OFFICE.
WE'VE WORKED CLOSELY WITH THE
CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION
TO ENSURE THAT THIS BILL
PROVIDES A BENEFIT TO BOTH
ASSESSORS AND TAXPAYERS.
ACCORDINGLY THIS BILL CREATES
THE RECIPROCAL RIGHT OF AN
ASSESSOR OR TAXPAYER TO REQUEST
THE INFORMATION BE MAILED TO
THEM OR SENT ELECTRONICALLY IF
AVAILABLE.
IN TWENTY EIGHTEEN WE SHOULD
EMBRACE TECHNOLOGY AS A MEANS OF
INCREASING GOVERNMENT EFFICIENCY.
THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT AB TWENTY
FOUR TWENTY FIVE WOULD
ACCOMPLISH I RESPECTFULLY ASK
FOR YOUR AYE VOTE.
AND WITH ME IS.
LARRY STONE THE ASSESSOR FROM
THE SENATE CLARA COUNTY.
THANK YOU SO SHIRT SYSTEM
SOMEBODY DAD'S WHOLE SIDE OF THE
FAMILY.
AND FOLLOWED YOU FOR YEARS SO
WHAT I IT'S IT'S GREAT TO SEE
DAY I WOULD TO SANTA RECENT
BELLARINE SO WATCH OUT WHILE
OKAY THERE YOU KNOW AS A MISTER
BELL AS WELL SO A FEW DAYS AGO
OF COURSE. WE WHAT WE SIR.
I'M SPEAKING ON BEHALF OF THE
CALIFORNIA ASSESSORS ASSOCIATION
AND MY CAN IN MY CAPACITY AS THE.
SANTA CLARA COUNTY ASSESSOR AB
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE DOES ONE
THING AND ONLY ONE THING IT
ALLOWS FOR THE ELECTRONIC
TRANSMISSION OF DOCUMENTS
BETWEEN THE TAXPAYER AND THE
ASSESSOR. IT IS THAT SIMPLE.
IN ORDER TO RENDER A FAIR AND
ACCURATE SETTLEMENTS OF
COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES.
ASSESSORS NEED AND HAVE THE
LEGAL RIGHT TO REQUEST AND
RECEIVE. FROM BASIC INFORMATION
LIKE RENTS VACANCIES.
INVOICES AND SO FORTH ALL ARE
MANAGED QUICKLY. CONFIDENTIALLY.
CURRENTLY BE LAW EMPOWERING
ASSESSORS TO REQUEST RECORDS WAS
WRITTEN DECADES BEFORE THE
INTERNET AND EMAIL AND SPECIFIES
ONLY ONE METHOD.
TRAVELING TO A TAXPAYERS PLACE
OF BUSINESS.
CLEARLY IT'SAN IT'S AN EXPENSE
EVEN VERY INEFFICIENT FOR
APPRAISERS AND AUDITOR'S TO
TRAVEL TO A CORPORATION'S
HEADQUARTERS WHICH ARE OFTEN OUT
OF STATE. TO RECEIVE IMPORTANT
INFORMATION NECESSARY FOR A FAIR
AND EQUITABLE ASSESSMENT.
AND THE TWENTY FIRST CENTURY THE
SAME INFORMATION IS READILY
AVAILABLE AND IN MOST CASES CAN
BE TRANSMITTED ELECTRONICALLY.
MODERNIZING IN OUR QUE CODE IS
SIMPLY ABOUT EFFICIENT
GOVERNMENT NOTHING MORE THAN
THAT.
ASSESSORS HAVE WORKED CLOSELY
WITH ASSEMBLY MEMBER BERMAN AND
CAL TAX TO CLARIFY AND IMPROVE
THE BILL.
FOR EXAMPLE THE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
AMENDED THE BILL AS SUGGESTED BY
CAL TAX WHICH WILL ALLOW THE
TRANSMISSION OF DOCUMENTS FROM
TAXPAYER TO ASSESSOR. AND. FROM
ASSESSOR TO TAXPAYERS.
FAIR ENOUGH.
AB TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE
ALLOWS FOR THE ELECTRONIC OF
TRANSMISSION OF INFORMATION AND
DOCUMENTS ONLY UNDERSCORE ONLY.
WHEN THEY ARE AVAILABLE IN
ELECTRONIC FORMAT.
IF NOT AVAILABLE TAXPAYERS CAN
USE THE U. S. MAIL OR PRIVATE
DELIVERY SERVICES SUCH AS FED EX
AND UPS AS THEY DO NOW.
NOTHING ELSE CHANGES.
PROPERTY TAXES ARE THE BACKBONE
AS WE ALL KNOW OF FUNDING FOR
PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND LOCAL
COMMUNITIES.
IT IS A VITAL THAT ASSESSORS BE
EMPOWERED TO USE TWENTY FIRST
CENTURY TOOLS TO RECEIVE VITAL
INFORMATION.
I URGE THE COMMITTEE TO SUPPORT
AB TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE THANK
YOU SO MUCH TURN THANK YOU FOR
BEING HERE TODAY WE WOULD LIKELY
TO SEE IF THERE'S ANYONE SUPPORT
IF YOU COULD PLEASE COMPORTED A
MICROPHONE. STATE YOU FIRST
LASSEN ORGANIZATION THAT MORNING
MISTER CHAIRMAN BUT SOCIAL MUCH
LARA BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA STATE
SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION SUPPORT
BECAUSE MUCH GOOD TO SEE YOU
GOOD MORNING. TRACY SULLIVAN OF
CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF
COUNTIES IN SUPPORT THE CONSOLE.
LAST CALL FOR THOSE WHO AREN'T
SUPPORTED ECCLES COMPORTED.
THREE NINE WOULD LIKELY TO SEE
IF THERE'S ANYONE OPPOSE IF YOU
COULD PLEASE ADVANCE THIS TIME.
PLEASE.
WE HAVE AN AWFUL AT. THIS
PREFACE COMPORT. WITH WELCOME.
IF YOU'RE GOING TO STATE YOUR
NAME AND ORGANIZATIONS COULD SEE
SIR.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE MARKET IT IS A STATE WIDE TRADE
ASSOCIATION MADE UP OF TAX
AGENTS WHO REPRESENT.
TAXPAYERS BEFORE COUNTY
ASSESSORS ASSESSMENT APPEALS
BOARDS. AT AS WELL AS THE BOARD
OF EQUALIZATION ON STATE ASSESS
A TAX MATTERS.
I.
I JUST WANTED TO.
RELATE TO YOU THAT.
WE HAVE.
MODIFIED OUR POSITION FROM
OPPOSED TO OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED
IN IT SO REFLECTED IN A LETTER
THAT WAS SENT OUT LATE FRIDAY.
I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT BEFORE.
WE GET INTO THE SUBSTANCE OF
THE OF THE BILL IS TO REMEMBER
THAT.
WHEN AN ASSESSOR ASSESSES A
PROPERTY OF THE BURDEN IS ON THE
SSE THE PROPERTY OWNER.
TO DO TWO THINGS ONE IS TO PROVE
THE TAX ASSESSMENT WRONG. AND TO
PURSUE THAT AND TO PROVE THAT
THEIR OPINION OF VALUE IS
CORRECT.
AND WHILE.
WE ARE CONCERNED THAT THE
MEASURE.
SHIFTS.
THE.
ABILITY TO HAVE FOR TAXPAYERS
TO.
.
LIMIT.
THE ASSESSORS ABILITY TO ENGAGE
AND UNREASONABLE INFORMATION
REQUESTS. ARE PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS SEEK TO ADDRESS THAT.
BY ENSURING THAT.
THE STATEMENT MADE BY LARRY
STONE THAT WHERE INFORMATION IS
BEING PRICE PREVIOUSLY
DIGITALIZED THAT THAT BE SUBJECT
TO SENDING IT ELECTRONICALLY.
BUT THAT IF IT IS NOT THAT THAT
REQUIREMENT.
DOES NOT REQUIRE THAT OF THE
BILL DOES NOT REQUIRE THAT THEY
MOVE FORWARD AND HAVE TO SKINNER
FOR OR DIGITIZED DATA.
THE OTHER IT RELATES TO THE
SCOPE AND NATURE AND SIZE OF THE
REQUESTS.
AND WHILE I'M NOT HERE TO
SUGGEST TO YOU THAT EVERY
ASSESSORS INFORMATION REQUESTS.
RESULTS IN THOUSANDS OF
DOCUMENTS TO BE PRODUCED THAT'S
NOT AN UNUSUAL CIRCUMSTANCE.
AND SO WE WANT TO INSURE THAT
THE INFORMATION THAT IS
REQUESTED WHETHER ELECTRONICALLY
OR BY MAIL. IS IN FACT A
REASONABLE IN ITS SIZE AND SCOPE
SO THAT IT ADDRESSES.
A IT THE ISSUE OF NOT BEING
UNREASONABLY BURDENED.
IT IS OUR EXPERIENCE THAT MANY
TAXPAYERS SIMPLY GIVE UP.
BECAUSE OF THE A BURDENSOME
REQUESTS FOR INFORMATION AND
THAT.
INFORMATION REQUESTS THAT
RESULT IN THOUSANDS OF PAGES OR
FOR.
DOT DETAILED DATA THAT REALLY
WOULD REVIVE BE BEST SERVED IF
THE ASSESSOR CAME TO THEIR
OFFICE.
AND LOOKED AT IT.
WE APPRECIATE THE AUTHOR TAKING
AMENDMENTS.
IN THEY PRIOR HOUSE
TO MAKE SURE THAT THE MEASURE
HAD PROVIDED FOR RECIPROCITY.
AND THEN FINALLY WE'RE
CONCERNED ABOUT ISSUES REGARDING
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
AND THAT IS THAT IF THERE IS
PROPRIETARY INFORMATION WHILE
THERE IS NO ABSOLUTE PROTECTION
AND.
AGAINST THAT THAT THERE IS AN
OPPORTUNITY TO ADDRESS THAT
ISSUE SO THAT IN A WHILE SENDING
IT ELECTRONICALLY.
OR VIA MAIL OR IN PERSON
DOESN'T.
THERE'S NO ABSOLUTE PROTECTION
THAT WE KNEW THAT THE THERE IS A
REASONABLE LESS.
STANDARD ESTABLISHED SO THAT IN
FACT PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
NEED NOT BE SENT ELECTRONICALLY
TO SO AS TO LESSEN THE RISK OF
BEING TRANSMITTED TO OTHERS.
BECAUSE MUCH DEPRAVED WE'RE
GRATEFUL GONNA BE HOLD THEIR FOR
NOW TO TNCS WITH ANY QUESTIONS
WE'RE GONNA INVITE ANYONE ELSE
WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK IN
OPPOSITION WE WELCOME YOU PERSON
LASSEN ORGANIZATION THAT MORNING
KATE BALLOT CAPITAL ADVOCACY ON
BEHALF OF RYAN WHERE MEMBERS OF
CAVEAT OF SORTS HERE COMMENTS.
WITH PREVIOUS TESTIMONY THANK
YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH.
THANK YOU.
ANYONE ELSE IN OPPOSITION VIC
PLEASE ADVANCING MIKE FROM THIS
TIME.
LAST CALL FOR OPPOSITION.
IT'S BRING IT BACK TO COMMITTEE
TO BE RECEIVING ANY QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS I DO BELIEVE WE HAVE A
MOTION. UP BY SENATOR HERTZBERG
WAS IT.
YOU DO NOW. BUT NO I I'M SORRY
HEARD BEFORE ON THE SUPREME WAS
COMING IN. AT THAT IS A DO PASS
APPROPRIATIONS BUT I DO KNOW
THAT WE HAVE SOME QUESTIONS OR
COMMENTS FIRST
SO LET'S GO TO CENTER MORLOCK.
MR OPREA IT IT SEEMS THAT YOU'RE.
MAKING UP.
A CLAIM THAT MAYBE THERE'S SOME
BAD ACTORS.
IN THE FIFTY EIGHT COUNTIES
WHERE THEY'RE JUST ASKING FOR
ONEROUS REQUEST IS THAT.
WELL WHAT I'M UNDERSTAND LET LET
ME STATE THAT.
I BUT I BELIEVE THAT.
WE ALL ASPIRE TO OUR BETTER
SELVES AND BOTH THE ASSESSORS
AND AND OUR ASSOCIATION.
AS WELL AS TAXPAYERS.
SPEAK TO FINDING THE RIGHT
NUMBER.
BUT WE ALSO KNOW THAT THE
ASSESSMENT APPEALS PROCESS IS A
TRIAL.
AND JUST AS THOSE WHO ARE
LAWYERS OR WHO'VE BEEN INVOLVED
IN LITIGATION KNOW THAT THE THE.
PROTAGONISTS IN THAT EVENT
OFTEN USE.
PAPERING HAVE FOLKS WITH A
INFORMATION REQUESTS NOW STATE
THAT THAT GOES BACK BUT A BACK
AND FORTH IT'S ON BOTH SIDES.
WILL OVERREACH IN ASKING FOR FOR
DOCUMENTATION AS A WAY OF.
PROVIDING SOME LEVERAGE IN THE
SITUATION AND GETTING A BETTER
DEAL OR PERHAPS PERSUADING
SOMEONE TO BACK OFF.
THEIR APPEAL AND SO THAT IS OUR
EXPERIENCE I'M NOT SUGGESTING
THAT EVERY AT EVERY ENGAGEMENT
IS IN THAT REGARD. BUT WE HAVE
HAD CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE THAT HAS
OCCURRED AND WE'RE LOOKING AT
PROTECTING AGAINST THAT.
EVENT. IF YOU LOOK AT THE AT
THE.
AT AT THE BILL IT SAYS A
REQUIRE THAT THE ASSESSOR MAY
REQUIRE.
SO IF YOU'RE GOING TO REQUIRES.
SOMETHING OF THE TAXPAYER THERE
SHOULD BE IN OUR VIEW SOME
PROTECTION AGAINST A
UNREASONABLY BROAD INFORMATION
REQUEST. AHEAD THAT NOT THAT
THEY SHOULDN'T GET THE
INFORMATION BUT THAT THE MEANS
FOR DELIVERING IT DOES NOT
BURDEN THE TAXPAYER UNREASONABLY.
AND.
IT ARE YOU OR IS IT DOES THE
BILL ALSO STATE THAT IF.
YOU DON'T PROVIDE.
THE INFORMATION THAT WAS
REQUESTED OR REQUIRED.
THAT THAT WOULD JEOPARDIZE THE
WELL HERE'S HERE'S WHAT HAPPENS
AND I THINK THAT MISS THAT THAT
THE ASSESSORS ASSOCIATION AND
OUR ASSOCIATION WILL DISAGREE.
AS TO HOW THIS PLAYS OUT. BUT I
KNOW THAT I IN AND MULTIPLE
COUNTIES I CAN'T SAY THAT IT'S
IN ALL. THAT IF A TAXPAYER FAILS
TO RESPOND TO ALL THE
INFORMATION REQUESTED.
THAT THE ASSESSOR THEN ASKS THE
ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD TEND
NOT HERE HERE THE MATTER AND
PUSH IT OVER UNTIL THE DATA CAN
BE PROVIDED.
NOW THE TAXPAYER OFTENTIMES WILL
SAY I DON'T HAVE THAT
INFORMATION.
AND THEREFORE YOU ARE IN ESSENCE
JEOPARDIZING MY DUE PROCESS
BEFORE THE ASSESSMENT APPEALS
BOARD IN SUCH A MANNER IN WHICH
I CAN'T COMPLY WITH THE.
INFORMATION REQUEST AND THE ONLY
RELIEF TO THAT IS TO GO TO THE
SUPERIOR COURT AND HAVE THE
SUPERIOR COURT RENDER A DECISION
ON WHETHER OR NOT THE HEARING
SHOULD GO FORWARD OR NOT.
NOW THERE THERE ARE OFTEN. THAT
THE ISSUE WAS IS WORKED OUT BUT
I WILL I WILL REMIND YOU THAT
RIGHT NOW MUCH
IF NOT MOST OF THE INFORMATION.
THAT IS EXCHANGED TAXPAYERS AND
ASSESSORS IS ALREADY DONE
ELECTRONICALLY OR VIA THE U. S.
MAIL. THIS IS NOT SOMETHING THAT
IS THAT IF IT'S NOT HAPPENING
NOW AND BUT FOR THIS BILL NO ONE
WOULD BE AUTHORIZED TO EXCHANGE
INFORMATION. WITH THE FACT OF
THE MATTER IS IS THAT PEOPLE DO
ENGAGE AND IT DIVIDE DEVISING A
AN APPROACH TO A CASE.
TO ADVANTAGE THEIR POSITION AND
THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE WE'RE NOT
HERE TO PROTECT AGAINST THE
EVERY DAY BUT TO WRITE PROTECT
AGAINST THE ABUSES THANK YOU
VERY MUCH HOPE. SO MOST CASES AT
LEAST FOR AWHILE DURING THE
RECESSION WERE.
VALUATION APPEAL SAYING OUR
VALUES HAVE GONE DOWN SO THE
AUDITOR SHOULD BE DISASTER
DOESN'T GET THOSE COMPLETED IN
TWO YEARS THEN.
THE REQUESTED AUTOMATICALLY
HONORED CORRECT SO.
SO THERE'S SHOULD BE.
REASON FOR THE ASSESSOR THAT.
IT TOO PERSNICKETY BECAUSE IT
WOULD HURT THEIR CASE.
SO I'M I'M TRYING TO.
PINPOINT.
BUT WHETHER OR NOT THE AUTHOR
UNDERSTANDS THE AMENDMENTS THAT
YOU'RE TRYING TO.
REQUEST IS THIS THAT MAKES SENSE
SOMEONE BERMAN.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH A QUESTION
SENATOR OUT SO WE JUST RECEIVE
THE AMENDMENTS ON FRIDAY SO
WE'RE STILL.
EVALUATING THEM AND MAKING SURE
THAT THERE AREN'T UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES TO THE FAIRLY VAGUE
LANGUAGE THAT WAS SUGGESTED IN
THE AMENDMENTS OUT SO WE'RE
GONNA CONTINUE TO HAVE THOSE
CONVERSATIONS. ABOUT CURRENTLY
AND I'LL LET DE ACESSAR STONE
YOU SPEAK TO THE DETAILS BUT
CURRENTLY ASSESSORS CAN REQUEST.
INFORMATION NEEDED TO MAKE AN
ASSESSMENT.
AND SO I DON'T KNOW THAT. YOU
KNOW THE AMENDMENTS WOULD LIMIT
REQUEST BY. ME BY TAXPAYERS OF
ASSESSORS IN THE SENSE OF
TAXPAYERS TO THAT WHICH IS A
REASONABLE AND NATURE SCOPE AND
SIZE.
AND WE NEED TO BETTER UNDERSTAND
THE CONSEQUENCES OF OF WHAT THAT
WOULD MEAN A EXISTING LAWS VERY
BROAD ESSENTIALLY REQUIRES A
TAXPAYERS MUST PROVIDE THE
INFORMATION NEEDED BY AN
ASSESSOR.
SO I DON'T THINK WE WANT TO
DRAFT LANGUAGE THAT CAN ALLOW A
PERSON TO SUBJECTIVELY DECIDE
WHAT IS REASONABLE TO PROVIDE OR
NOT.
THE EXISTING THOSE VERY SIMPLE
IT HAS TO DO WITH THE MEANS OF
TRANSMISSION OF THAT INFORMATION
GETTING INTO MUCH DEEPER ISSUES
OF WHAT'S TRANSMITTED THAT'S A
MUCH BROADER CONVERSATION IN
THAT OUT WERE MORE THAN WILLING
TO ENGAGE IN BUT I DON'T KNOW
NECESSARILY. IF WILL END UP
INCORPORATING THAT INTO THE BILL
I DON'T KNOW SAYS JUST DON'T DO
ANYTHING THAT. WELL THE QUESTION
OF REASONABLENESS.
.
HIS.
REASONABLE BY WHAT STANDARDS OF
HO MAKES THE DECISIONS AS TO
WHAT'S REASONABLE IS THAT THE
TAXPAYER.
I WOULD WEIRD JUST SIMPLY
TALKING ABOUT I MEAN THE VOLUMES
OF INFORMATION ANYBODY THAT HAS
MASSIVE VOLUMES OF INFORMATION.
UNDOUBTEDLY HAS THEM
ELECTRONICALLY.
AND IF THEY DON'T HAVE THEM
ELECTRONICALLY THEY'RE ALLOWED
TO PROVIDE THEM IN DIFFERENT
WAYS SO WE'RE NOT REQUIRING
PEOPLE TO PROVIDE THINGS THEY
DON'T HAVE.
IF IT OF FOR TAXPAYERS SAYS
DANTE ASSESSOR ASK FOR
INFORMATION THAT TAXPAYERS SAYS
IT DOESN'T EXIST I DON'T HAVE IT.
BEEN WE CANNOT DEMAND THEY
PRODUCE INFORMATION THAT THEY
DON'T HAVE.
I THINK IT'S REALLY A RED
HERRING ABOUT MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF
INFORMATION WE HAVE. A MAJOR
APPEAL GOING ON RIGHT NOW THAT'S
VERY COMPLICATED IT'S CALLED
LEVI STADIUM FOR THE SAN
FRANCISCO FORTY NINERS THEY HAVE
MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF. DATA THAT
THEY WANTED TRANSMIT TO US THEY
CAME TO US AND SAID CAN WE
TRANSMITTED ELECTRONICALLY
RATHER THAN GO THROUGH. THE THE
DIFFICULT TASK OF PROVIDING
THESE THINGS CAN PAPER.
WORD THAT WERE IN THE TWENTY
FIRST CENTURY.
PEOPLE THAT HAVE THAT AMOUNT OF
DATA UNDOUBTEDLY HAVE IT IN
ELECTRONIC FORMAT IN OF THE HAVE
AN ELECTRONIC FORMAT. IT SHOULD
BE PROVIDED THAT WAY FOR BOTH
THE BENEFIT OF THE TAXPAYER HAS
WILLOWS.
IT DOESN'T AS WELL SHE'S FASTER.
AND BELIEVE ME ASSESSORS WANT TO
CLEAR ASSESSMENT APPEALS AS FAST
AS WE CAN FOR THE VERY REASON
THAT YOU MET CAN SENATOR. AND
THAT IS THERE'S A TWO YEAR
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS AND IF WE
DON'T GET THEM CLEARED WITHOUT
HIM THAT TIME OF THE TAXPAYER
DOESN'T SIGN A WAIVER. IN THE
TAXPAYERS OPINION OF VALUE HOLES
WE HAVE. TAXPAYERS IT TRIED TO
PLAY GAMES THEY PUT ONE DOLLAR
DOWN IS THEIR OPINION OF VALUE
HOPING THAT IT'LL RUN THE
STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS. AND AND
AND I'M TALKING ABOUT TAXPAYERS
WITH MULTI BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
OF.
A TAXABLE ASSESSMENTS
SO THERE IS A GAME BEING PLAYED.
WORKS ITSELF OUT WE REALLY DON'T
HAVE A PROBLEM.
THE HYPE SAID BEFORE THAT THIS
IS A.
THIS IS A SOLUTION WORK OF THE
LOOKING FOR A PROBLEM FROM
RESEARCH DONE I I HAD THE
PRIVILEGE OF WORKING WITH
WEBSTER GUILLORY YOUR COLLEAGUE
FOR. ABOUT TWENTY YEARS YES AND.
AND HE WOULDN'T TAKE EMAILS.
I WAS JUST POLICY SO WAS SORT OF
LIKE WHEN IS THIS GUY GONNA.
MOVE INTO THE TWENTY FIRST
CENTURY SO I I COME FROM THAT
PARADIGM. AYE WHERE THERE WAS A
REAL FEAR OF HAVING ANY KIND
RECORDS I'M. TRYING TO BALANCE
THAT THE MISTER CHAIR.
THE HEARING BOARD IS COMPRISED
OF MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC
AND THAT IS THE TAXPAYERS.
BUFFER AND IT VIA ASSESSOR HAS
THE ABILITY TO BODY BLOCK YOU
FROM GETTING TO THAT HEARING
BOARD. BEEN THAT THERE'S A
PROBLEM AND SO I'M.
TRYING TO MAKE SURE THAT.
THE TAXPAYERS THE CONSTITUENTS
HAVE A FAIR SHOT.
IN GETTING IN FRONT OF THEIR.
PEERS.
FOR A FAIR HEARING AND I. I OUR
SON JUST I WOULD JUST SAY.
ASSUME BERMAN LET'S MAKE SURE WE
GET. WE GET THERE BECAUSE WE
DON'T WANT IT TO LOOK LIKE IT'S.
GONNA BE ABUSED ON EITHER SIDE.
BUT IN THE FUTURE NOTHING SO I
CENTER WE'RE GONNA GO TO THE
VICE CHAIR. THANK YOU MISTER
CHAIRMAN A. SETTLEMENT I'VE I
APPRECIATE THE BILL IN THE NIGHT.
AND I THINK IT NEEDS TO BE A
LITTLE MORE COOK. A I'VE GOT A
FEW CONCERNS I MEAN I HAVEN'T.
YOU'RE RIGHT IN THIS DAY AND AGE
WISH THAT MOST PEOPLE USE THAT
CHRONIC.
BUT WHAT'S WRONG THOUGH IS WHEN
YOU.
PEEL IT DOWN DEEPER WHEN YOU'RE
A SMALL BUSINESS OWNER. BE A MOM
AND POP BUSINESS WHO ALL
EVERYTHING YOU DO ISSUES IN
THESE LITTLE TRANSACTION THESE
LITTLE PAPERS.
AND YOU DON'T SPEAK ENGLISH WELL
EITHER IT BECOMES EXTREMELY
DIFFICULT. FOR SOMEONE IN MY
DISTRICT.
I'M JUST IN MY DISTRICT ALONG
WITH A LARGE POPULATION LATINO
AND LARGE POPULATION OF ASIAN
AMERICAN MOST OF THEM.
NINETY PERCENT OF THESE
AMERICANS HAVE BEEN THESE MEREKA.
SO IF YOU LOOK AT MY DISTRICT
JUST LET'S JUST SAY THE
RESTAURANT INDUSTRY. THERE'S
THOUSANDS OF RATIONALIZING BUT
THEY'RE ALL MOM AND POPS. THREE
THOUSAND SQUARE FEET. RESTAURANT
OR SMALLER OR SOME OR MAYBE.
FIVE HUNDRED FEE UP SQUARE
FOOTAGE FOR JUST ENOUGH I'M
STANDING ROOM.
FORT JUST HANDFUL OF FOLKS AND
SO. MY CONCERN HERE IS WHEN YOU
HAVE A BILL. THAT.
THAT COULD CAUSE A BURDEN TO
THESE INDIVIDUALS.
ONE THEY DON'T SPEAK ENGLISH
WELL.
AND TWO IS. THEY ARE LITERALLY
MOM AND POPS
BUSINESSES.
THAT DOESN'T HAVE THE ABILITY TO
HAVE THESE SOPHISTICATED MULTI
MILLION DOLLAR DATA SYSTEM.
VIA POS SYSTEM OF YOUR
RESTAURANT ON EXAGGERATE AND SO
I THINK YOU KNOW I'M WE QUESTION
FOR THESE INFORMATION
ELECTRONICALLY IS GREAT.
BUT ALSO THE OTHER THING PART OF
MY DISTRICT IS THAT NOT
EVERYBODY HAS ACCESS THE
INTERNET STILL. AND I'M AN
ORANGE COUNTY.
I'M NINE OR AREAS WHERE IN THE
NET IS NOT AVAILABLE.
IN MY DISTRICT ARE PEOPLE WHO
DON'T HAVE A BECAUSE THEY CAN'T
AFFORD IT.
BOB AND SO THE IDEA OF FORCING
THIS UPON THEM. BY IN LESSER
TIME I THINK PUTTING A HUGE
BURDEN. ON THE.
SMALL BUSINESS ETHNIC COMMUNITY.
WHO?
BUT TO GLEAN THE VIETNAMESE
MARKET VIEW MEETING.
DON'T LIKE GOVERNMENT.
GOVERNMENT'S NEVER FRIENDLY TO
US IN VIETNAM.
ON AND AND SO WE'RE ACTUALLY
FEARFUL OF VIEW. OF GOVERNMENT.
OF. THAT AND SO. SO I I BELIEVE
THERE NEEDS TO BE SET MORE
PROTECTION. ON A SPECIAL WITHIN
THE ETHIC COMMUNITY AND A SMALL
BUSINESS OWNERS.
SO AND AS I MEAN I LIKE THAT CAN
KIND OF BE A QUESTION CAN TIE BE
A STATEMENT IF YOU CAN COMMIT TO
THAT YEAH. IT'S ARTS CENTER NOT
WE DON'T COMMIT TO ADD TO THAT I
THINK WE HAVE A COMMITTED TO
THAT BECAUSE IN IN THE BILL AND
THREE. THE US SPECIFIC LOCATIONS
IT SAYS IF AVAILABLE.
AND SO IT'S UPON WRITTEN
REQUEST OF AN ASSESSOR THE SS
ERA THE SAYS HE DOESN'T A
REPRESENTATIVE. SO TRANSMIT THE
INFORMATION OR RECORDS DESCRIBED
IN PARAGRAPH ONE BY MAIL OR IN
ELECTRONIC FORMAT IF AVAILABLE
SO IF THEY DON'T HAVE IT SO
WE'RE NOT FORCING ANYBODY. TO
MAKE IT'S TRANSCRIBE IT TO
DIGITIZE IT.
IT'S ONLY IF IT'S ALREADY
AVAILABLE IN A DIGITIZED FORMAT
DO THEY HAVE TO BUY OR WOUD
THAT BE REQUIRED UNDER THIS BILL.
TO SUPPLY ELECTRONIC AS YOU GO
FORWARD IS.
TO MAKE SURE THAT.
NO ASSESSORS GETS TO SAY.
THERE'S A LOOPHOLE IN THEIR SAY
WELL IF OF VELLUM MEANS THAT YOU
DO HAVE TWO COMPUTER SYSTEM SO
YOU SHOULD HAVE A DEVELOPER. OR
YOU HAVE ONE PO AS SYSTEM THAT
SHOULD BE AVAILABLE GETS YOU
CAN'T TELL ME THAT THAT'S NOT
AVAILABLE.
YOU KNOW YOU HAVE AN IPHONE. UP
FOR YOUR CREDIT CARD THAT SHOULD
BE LOOKED SO I JUST WANNA MAKE
SURE THAT THE IF AVAILABLE I
KNOW THAT WE ALWAYS DO A LOT
AMENDMENTS IN THIS BUILDING. ON
IS THAT THERE'S NO UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES FOR THESE
INDIVIDUALS. A THE SO SO I.
YOU KNOW I JUST DON'T WANT THEM
TO FEEL SO BURDENSOME THAT THEY
DON'T EVEN BOTHER TO APPEAL HER
AND WE'VE WE'VE WHEN I WAS A
COUNTY SUPERVISOR WE HAD A LOT
OF THOSE CALLS TO MY OFFICE
WHICH COUNTY SUPERVISOR REALLY
WORK ON THEM. BUT BECAUSE OF THE
ETHNIC COMMUNITY I SERVE.
WE WERE GUSHING VERY CLOSELY. OF
WITH WITH MY. TO THE ASSESSMENT
BOARD ON AND HELP THE
INDIVIDUALS OR THE BUSINESSES TO
ACTUALLY GO THROUGH THE PROCESS
SENIOR ACTUALLY SIT THERE AND.
OKAY SHOW THEM TO UNDERSTAND
WHAT THEY'RE WHAT THE APPEAL
PROCESSES AND WHAT.
THE ISSUE S..
I'M SO WE'VE WE'VE DONE A LOT OF
CONSTITUENT CASES ON THIS IS
SOME GUY WHO MOVED MUCH MORE
AMILIAR WITH IT. ON MORE LET.
TEN FIVE THOUSAND FOOT LEVEL I'M
AS WE ARE WORKING WITH
CONSTITUENTS. UP THE OTHER THING
IS MY UNDERSTANDING THOSE AT THE
BEALE WE IS CURRENTLY ENGAGED IN
A PROCESS.
TO ADDRESS.
THE ISSUE RAISED IN THIS BILL.
AS WELL AS OTHER ISSUES
ASSOCIATE WITH THE PROPERTY
TAXES REST ASSESSMENT APPEALS.
IT IS THIS BILL LITTLE BIT.
TOO FAST.
TRACK.
AND NOT WORKING WITH THE BE A WE
KNOW THE.
ANY OF THE ISSUES RIGHT NOW THAT
ARE BEING DISCUSSED BETWEEN
ASSESSORS AND CATER AND THE
VIDEO WE. I WOULD HAVE NOTHING
TO DO WITH WHAT WE'RE TAUGHT
THAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE
THEIR SERIOUS ISSUES AND WE'RE
CONFRONTING THEM THROUGH THE
NORMAL PROCESS TO THE. BOARD OF
EQUALIZATION HAS FOR THESE KINDS
OF PROCESS THIS DOESN'T.
E. HIM YOU INVADE THAT OR OR
CHANGE THAT IN ANY WAY.
I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO SAY YOU
KNOW IN SANTA CLARA COUNTY WE
HAVE A LARGE ASIAN COMMUNITY AND
ONE OF THE LARGEST VIETNAMESE
COMMUNITIES AROUND WE DEAL WITH
HUNDREDS OF. OF.
ETHNIC HUB ETHNIC BUSINESSES
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY AND I
UNDERSTAND IT PERFECTLY. WORK
WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT
REQUIRING PEOPLE TO DEVELOP A
DIGITIZED SYSTEM THAT THEY DON'T
HAVE WHEN WE CAN GET THE
INFORMATION FROM SMALL
BUSINESSES WHICH IS USUALLY.
REALLY SIMPLE STUFF.
EITHER BY MAIL OR OR OR OTHER
MEANS
SO WE HAVE NO INTENT WHATSOEVER
IT'S ONLY HAS SAID SENATOR IT
HAS ASSEMBLY MEMBER HE INDICATED
IT'S ONLY IF THE INFORMATION
EXIST ELECTRONICALLY.
CAN WE ASK FOR ELECTRONICALLY
SOBRE USUALLY DEALING WITH
LARGER COMPANIES THEN.
BEEN A
SMALL. RESTAURANTS FOR EXAMPLE
AND I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS IN
YOUR ABSENT RIGHT SANTA CLARA IN
SAN JOSE AND.
AS SENATE ABOUT NOSES YOU'VE GOT
THE LARGEST VIETNAMESE RESIDENTS
OUTS AS A CITY. SO THERE'S YOU
KNOW GOOD ALMOST HUNDRED
THOUSAND VIETNAMESE AMERICANS
JUST IN THE CITY OF SAN JOSE.
AND. I APPRECIATE THE COMMENTS
ON MY ONLY CONCERN IS THAT
SOMETIMES.
DIFFERENT PEOPLE.
READ BILLS DIFFERENTLY.
ON A DIFFERENT LEGAL COUNSEL AS
WELL ALTHOUGH YOU MIGHT HAVE
THAT INTENTION AND YOU DO YOU
ARE FROM AN AREA THAT. YOU'RE
FAMILIAR WITH. THE DIFFERENT
ETHNIC COMMUNITY. THERE'S OTHER
SASSER'S NOT TO SAY THAT BAD
APPLES BUT EYES WOULD MAKE SURE
THAT WE'RE ON THE SAME PAGE. ON
AND THAT THIS IS THE HAS NO
UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES BECAUSE.
I'VE I'VE BEEN IN GOVERNMENT.
QUITE LONG ENOUGH.
ON THAT I I'VE SEEN. YELLED FROM
DIFFERENT ELECTED OFFICIALS TO
LEGAL COUNSEL COMING ON BOARD
THERE'S DIFFERENT INTERPRETATION
OF WHAT WAS DONE A YEAR AGO.
AT THE SAME BILL OR SAME LAW AND
YOU'RE LIKE WAIT A MINUTE WE
WERE JUST TOLD THIS LAST YEAR
AND THIS ONE TIME WHEN I WAS AT
THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS. SO I
WANT TO BRING IT UP SO THAT WE
UNDERSTAND AND MAKE SURE THAT
YOU KNOW I. IF AVAILABLE DOESN'T
MEAN THAT BECAUSE I HAVE ONE
COMPUTER SYSTEM IT MEANS THAT
IT'S AVAILABLE BECAUSE MY NOT BE.
IF THEY DO SO MUCH BETTER BY
SHARING THEIR MISTER PRAYER HERE
WITH THROUGH THE CHAIR CENTER NO
AND.
THE FACT THE MATTER IS IS THAT
THE CONTENT OF THIS MEASURE AND
THE CONSEQUENCES OF THIS
HOW IT HAS TO BE TRANSMITTED
WATER THE CONSEQUENCES IF THE
INFORMATION THAT IS REQUESTED.
CANNOT OR IS NOT PROVIDED THE
RIGHT TO DUE PROCESS --
THE TIMING OF INFORMATION
REQUEST PRIOR TO A HEARING SO
THAT AND AGAIN I'M GOING --
TO STATE THAT THIS IS ON BOTH
SIDES OF THE EQUATION THAT
PEOPLE CANNOT REQUEST
INFORMATION SO CLOSE TO THE
HEARING THAT BY DEFAULT BY
DEFAULT IT FORCES THE HEARING TO
BE KICKED OVER.
AND SO THERE HAS BEEN A LOT OF
DISCUSSION ON THIS --
BUT I WON TO COMPLIMENT THE THE
FOLKS AT C. A. WE BROUGHT TO
THEIR ATTENTION AND TO THE BOARD
OF EQUALIZATION.
UP FOR FORTY ONE D. REQUESTS
CONTENT THAT THRATENED --
TAXPAYERS WITH CIVIL AND
CRIMINAL ACTION AND TO THEIR
CREDIT THEY CORRECTED THAT
PROCESS BUT THERE ARE A WHOLE
HOST OF OTHER ISSUES.
AND IN FACT THIS VERY ISSUE AS
TO WHETHER ASSESSORS WOULD I
HAVE TO GO TO THE PERSON'S PLACE
OF BUSINESS OR WHETHER IT COULD
BE.
SENT ELECTRONICALLY IS WAS PART
OF THAT --
IP PROCESS DISCUSSION AS WELL AS
COMMENT LETTERS GOING BACK AND
FORTH SO TO YOUR QUESTION THIS
IS VERY MUCH A PART AND PARCEL
OF THAT.
AND BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE
DAY IT IS NOT JUST ABOUT THE
REQUEST FOR INFORMATION OR THE
MEANS OF TRANSMITTAL.
BUT HOW DOES THAT HOW IS THAT
USED TO DELAY OR DENY SOMEONE A
OR A HEARING BEFORE THE
ASSESSMENT APPEALS BOARD OR DOES
IT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR.
THAT ENCOURAGES PEOPLE TO DRAW
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU SO MUCH WE'RE LIKELY
TO SEE IF WE HAVE ANY ADDITIONAL
DISCUSSION OR DEBATE FROM
COMMITTEE.
ASSN HERTZBERG DID ADVANCE --
A MOTION HERE BUT AGO WHICH IS A
DO PASS APPROPRIATIONS WHICH
MEANS.
THERE'S SOME TIME TO BE A TO
WORK THIS OUT.
BOB BUT I WANTED TO BE OFFERED
THE SOMEONE NUMBER AN
OPPORTUNITY FOR A CLOSING
STATEMENT.
YEAH JUST WELL VON TO SAY REALLY
PRETTY THE CONVERSATION IN THE
QUESTIONS --
AND AND WE'VE BEEN WORKING WITH
OF THE OPPONENTS AND OTHERS TO
MAKE SURE THAT WE ADDRESS ANY.
KIND YEAH CONCERNS OR
COMPLICATIONS AROUND IT AND MAKE
SURE THERE ARE THOSE UNINTENDED
CONSEQUENCES THAT AND ONE
CONCERN WE HAVE IS A FREE
IRONICALLY FIX OF THEM AT THE
AMENDMENTS THAT WERE PUT FORTH
BY THE OPPOSITION.
THAT I THINK IT DIRECTLY PUTS
THIS BILL --
IN CONTRADICTION WITH WHAT'S
HAPPENING AT THE BO WE I THINK
THE CURRENT BILL DOESN'T AT ALL
A AS THE SAYS ARE CLEARLY STATED
BUT IF WE ACCEPT THE OPPONENTS
AMENDMENTS THAT IT DEFINITELY
WOULD -- SO
THAT'S A LITTLE IRONIC BUT
REALLY --
APPRECIATE THE CONVERSATION IN
ONE THROUGHOUT THE WORK ROBUST
DISCUSSION FROM BOTH SIDES AS
WELL APPRECIATE THAT PRINT
SENATORS MUSLIM CHESTER RECALL
VOTE PLEASE LIAR I REQUIRE AYE
NGUYEN.
WHEN NOBEL BILL I'M HERNANDEZ
HERTZBERG LARA MORE LAW? TWO
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO ONE WE'RE
GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN AND
ALLOW MEMBERS TO BE ABLE TO ADD
ON IF YOU.
THINK YOU SO MUCH MEMBERS FOR
THAT PARTICULAR SO QUICK
HOUSEKEEPING NOON OUNCE MEAN
THERE ARE THREE OF US.
THAT ARE GOING TO HAVE TO GO TO
BUDGET THERE ARE TWO BILLS THAT
ARE CURRENTLY LEFT I STILL TAKE
ACTION ON A IN BUDGET THERE'S
TWO BILLS --
TO BE A TAKE ACTION ON AYE AND
THEY'RE MOVING FAIRLY QUICKLY.
BOB SO WHAT WE'D LIKE TO BE ABLE
TO DO IF IT IS --
PURVIEW OF BOTH CENTER BALLOTS
IN MOROCCO ALSO SAID.
THAT WE WILL BE HEADING OFF TO
GO VOTE IN BUDGET AS THEY'RE
MOVING PRETTY QUICKLY THROUGH --
AND THEN WE'LL COME BACK AND BE
ABLE TO ADD ON ODDNESS MEDINA
AND NOT AT ALL TRYING TO BE RUDE
WHATSOEVER LOOKING HAPPY PRESENT.
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN.
I AND HAVE MEMBERS HAD ON SO
WE'RE GOING TO TURN THE GAVEL
OVER TO THE VICE CHAIR VICE
CHAIR WYNN.
WE WELCOME MR MEDINA TO BE ABLE
TO ADVANCE HE PREPARED TO GET A
PRESENT.
AYE THIS IS ITEM NUMBER FIFTEEN
MAYBE TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE
AND AGAIN.
THERE MORE LOCKS IN A BELL
MYSELF FOR GOING TO HAVE TO VOTE
IN BUDGET WE DO APOLOGIZE BUT
WILL KEEP THE ROLE OPEN SIR.
FIVE CENTER WENT FUNDING TO PASS
A GAVEL OVER TO YOU.
MR CHAIRMAN I THINK WE'LL HAVE
ONE BILL GRAY AYE NOT WE'VE TWO
BILLS AND BUDGET THAT ARE LEFT
IN THIS IS OUR THIS IS OUR LAST
BILL HERE.
THIS IS OUR FINAL BILL.
WE GET TO PARTICIPATE EVERY
GALLON.
SHE CAN THANK YOU SO MUCH.
ASSEMBLYMAN PLEASE A LIST FOR
ITEM FIFTEEN AB [inaudible]
TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE GOOD
MORNING.
MADAM CHAIR AND MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE.
TODAY OUR PRESENT ASSEMBLY BILL.
TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE FIRST
I'D LIKE TO ACCEPT THE
AMENDMENTS IS SUGGESTED UNDER
THE NAME MEAN NAME SECTION OF
THE ANALYSIS.
DEVELOPMENT OF WAREHOUSES IN
CALIFORNIA HAS GROWN
TREMENDOUSLY.
IN RECENT YEARS IN LARGE PART
DUE THE SUBSIDIES PROVIDED BY
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS.
MANY OF THE JOBS IN THESE
WAREHOUSES ARE GRUELING AND HIGH
STRESS.
THE MAN BENEFITS MAY BE ENTICING
BUT DON'T BECOME AVAILABLE UNTIL
AFTER YEAR OF EMPLOYMENT.
ALSO THE JOBS ARE TEMPORARY OR
SEASONAL CAUSING EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITIES TO FLUCTUATE AND
THROWING FAMILIES INTO ECONOMIC
INSTABILITY.
AB TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE
ENJOYED SOME BIPARTISAN SUPPORT
IN THE ASSEMBLY AND HAS NO
OPPOSITION.
AB TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY THREE IS A
MODEST TRANSPARENCY LEGISLATION
BUT VERY IMPORTANT TO HOLDING
COMPANIES ACCOUNTABLE. FOR
PUBLIC FUNDED SUBSIDIES THEY
RECEIVED.
WITH ME TODAY IS MICHAEL YOUNG
WITH THE CALIFORNIA LABOR
FEDERATION.
PIECE OF WOOD THANK YOU UP A
MICHAEL DEL WHAT THE CALIFORNIA
LABOR FEDERATION A SPONSORED A.
B. SWEENEY FIFTY THREE WHAT THEY
MISTER MEDINA FOR BRINGING THE
BILL AND HE'S DONE A LOT OF WORK
ON THIS ISSUE.
AS YOU STATED THIS IS A SIMPLE
TRANSPARENCY MEASURE TO ENSURE
THEIR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS IN THE
PUBLIC HAVE A MORE INFORMATION
FOR PROVING TAX BREAKS AND
SUBSIDIES FOR WAREHOUSING
DISTRIBUTION CENTERS --
THINGS LIKE HOW MANY JOBS ARE
CREATED --
WHAT WAS THE QUALITY OF THOSE
JOBS ARE --
THE GOAL IS TO MAKE SURE THAT
DECISION MAKERS HAVE ACCESS TO
MORE INFORMATION MAKE GOOD
DECISIONS FOR THE PUBLIC IN FOR
THE COMMUNITIES I RESPECTFULLY
ASK THE IDLE.
NEED FOR THEIR SUPPORT.
MADAM CHAIR MEMBERS OF THE
COMMITTEE CHRISTY BAUM ON BEHALF
OF THE CALIFORNIA PROFESSIONAL
FIREFIGHTERS.
ALSO PLEASED TO BE IN SUPPORT
FIGURE MAKES SENSE YOU KNOW
CITIES OFTEN FIND THEMSELVES
PITTED AGAINST EACH OTHER MAKING
DECISIONS OFFERING SUBSIDIES.
A BETTER THOSE DECISIONS ARE
DATA DRIVEN WE URGE YOUR SUPPORT
[inaudible]
THANK YOU.
ANY OTHER SUPPORT ANY OPPOSITION
TO TESTIFY AS A WITNESS OR TWO
STATE AND OPPOSITION.
WELL THIS IS EASY.
WE LIKE THAT ALONE I WAS GONNA
ASK QUESTION IF AT ONE I'VE GOT
A FEW HERE --
ASSEMBLY WHICH I LIKE TO CLOSE.
RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR YOUR AYE
VOTE WHEN YOU COME BACK.
THANK YOU I DON'T THINK I CAN
MAKE THE MOTION THAT.
SO WE'LL JUST WAIT.
THANK YOU WHEN DID ONCE WE GET
OF WALCOTT WAS WE GET MORE
MEMBERS WILL.
AB THE WILL CALL THANK YOU VERY
MUCH THANK YOU
.
NONE IDEM.
WHAT WAS IT IS?
FIFTEEN I NEED A MOTION.
I KNOW A OKAY WHICH WE WHICH
WENT.
LIKE THIS ELEVEN OKAY WHERE WE
OPEN ELEVEN FIRST.
PLEASE UP BUT WILL BUT THE WILL
CALL.
FOR IT ITEM LEVIN AB.
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ SIGN.
THREE ONE WE ONE WILL KEEP THE
WILL CALL OPEN.
ITEM. THIRTEEN AB [inaudible]
TWENTY SIX FIFTY FOUR HERNANDEZ
[inaudible]
HERNANDEZ SIDE.
S. B.. SIX ZERO WILL KEEP THE
WILL CALL OPEN [inaudible]
ITEM [inaudible] FIFTEEN I FOR
OF THAT'S BEEN PULLED.
AND THEN I'D ITEM FOR I NEED A
MOTION.
BUT ITEM.
FIFTEEN AND THIS IS MOVE DO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR.
THERE'S A MOTION PLEASE CALL FOR
THE VOTE.
CHOIR WHEN AYE AYE BELL
HERNANDEZ IN AND DECIDE
HERTZBERG LARA BOARDWALK. TO HE
LOW WE WILL KEEP THE WILL CALL
OPEN [inaudible]
ITEM.
SIXTEEN A B. TWENTY NINE FORTY
FOUR PLEASE CALL FOR THE VOTE.
HERNANDEZ HERNANDEZ AYE. SIX
ZERO WILL KEEP THE POLKA OPEN
SAID IT.
YOU DON'T THINK YOU
[inaudible]
NO
.
ON THE GOVERNOR FINANCE
COMMITTEE FOR HALF AN HOUR.
SO WE WIL BE BACK AT ELEVEN
THIRTY FIVE AND THE CHAIR WILL
RE OPEN THAT HEARING
[inaudible]
THANK YOU
EIGHTEEN ALONE ITEM
THAT --
SITTER MORLOCK.
SO ONCE THEY ALSO IT'S IN A LOT
FROM HIS WORK ON THE CAR WE NEED%
EVEN LIVING THE DREAM CENTER
WILL LOCK.
YEAH I KNOW.
A NICE JOB.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH SIR.
HERE THAT FOR THAT.
YOU KNOW IT'S TRUE THOUGH THAT.
HEY THERE YOU GO ALRIGHT HAY HIM
TURNED OVER SO ITEM --
FIFTEEN AB TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY
THREE THIS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A
TWO ZERO VOTE.
SENATE BILL WHERE ANA LAST ITEM
ITEM FIFTEEN AB TWENTY EIGHT
FIFTY THREE THIS IS MR MEDINA.
BOB THIS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A TWO
ZERO EIGHT IS A DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO THE FLORIDA WITH THE
MOTION THIS AS WELL YES FROM HER
NAME BUT WE HAVE A MOTION BY SEN
HERNANDEZ'S DO PASSES INTO THE
FLOOR.
ISN'T JUST A ROLL CALL PLEASE
REQUIRE I REQUIRE ALRIGHT BILL.
BILL ONLINE LARA MORLOCK.
WELL I KNOW. FOR KERN THE JOYS
O FOUR ONE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN WE'RE GONNA GRAB A CENTER
LARA.
A CS.
THANK YOU HURTS HER DISCOVERY
[inaudible]
HE THOUGHT [inaudible]
OKAY MNBOUND
SENATOR LARA'S HERE.
ALRIGHT EVERYBODY WE'RE GOING TO
MOVE IN ON WE GOT A PROPOSED
CONSENT CALENDAR ITEM ONE FOUR
EIGHT NINE EIGHTEEN CURRENT IS
SIX ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER LARA.
I WHO ARE ICN THAT SQUEAKED IN
SEVEN ZERO WE'RE GONNA CLOSE TO
ROLL THE BILL IS OUT ITEM NUMBER
TWO A. B. FIFTEEN NINETY FOUR
THIS CURRENTLY ENJOYS A SIX ZERO
MUSLIM CHESTER.
LA HIGH.
ON THIS SEVEN ZERO THE BILL IS
OUR CLOTHES IN THE ROLE ITEM
THREE AB SEVENTEEN FORTY ONE
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A FIVE ONE MISS
LANE CHESTER.
LA I SIX WILL ON SIX ONE THE
BILL IS OUT WERE CLOSE IN THE
ROLE THANK YOU SO MUCH ITEM FIVE
AB NINETEEN HUNDRED CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A SIX ZERO WAS SLAIN
CHESTER ARE.
ARE [inaudible]
WELL I FIFTY SEVEN IS ZERO THIS
BILL IS OUR CLOTHES IN THE ROLE
ITEM -- SIX
CURRENTLY ENJOYS A SIX ZERO MISS
LANE CHESTER LARA.
ARE I SEVEN SEVEN ZERO THE BILL
IS OUT OF WORK CLOTHES IN THE
ROLE ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB TWENTY
ONE THIRTY SEVEN CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A SIX ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER
ARE.
LARA ON SEVEN IS ZERO THE BILL
IS OUT WE'RE CLOSING THE ROLE
ITEM TIN AB --
TWENTY FOUR HUNDRED CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A SIX ZERO MUSLIM CHESTER
LARA AYE.
AYE. SEVEN ZERO THE BILL IS OUT
WE'RE CLOSING THE ROLE ITEM
ELEVEN CURRENTLY IN AB TWENTY
FOUR TWENTY FIVE CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A THREE ONE CHAIR VOTING
AYE MUSLIM CHESTER LAW.
ON LARA AND FOR THAT BILL IS OUT
ON A FOUR ONE VOTE.
BUT BILL HOME WILL SEE WE'RE
GONNA PUT THAT ASIDE WE'RE GONNA
KEEP THE ROLE OPEN --
TEMPORARILY ACKERLEY JOYS A FOUR
ONE VOTE ON ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN A
KEY ELEMENT OF THE OTHER ONE
THAT PERSON HERTZBERG MISSING ON
HER ITEM OR FIFTEEN THINK.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR NOW MOVING
ON TO ITEM NUMBER 1-224-408-2450
EIGHTY EXCUSE ME CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A SIX ZERO MISS LANE.
LARA LA LA OUR ARMS. SEVEN ZERO
THE BILL IS OUT FOR CLOSE IN THE
ROLE ITEM NUMBER THIRTEEN AB
TWENTY SIX FIFTY FOUR CURRENTLY
ENJOYS A SIX ZERO MOSTLY
INTEREST LARA. FIVE SEVEN OH THE
BILL IS OUT FOR CLOSING THE ROLE.
I NEVER FIFTEEN AB TWENTY EIGHT
FIFTY THREE CURRENTLY ENJOYS A
FOUR ONE CHAIR VOTING I MISS
LANE CHESTER LARA ARE. FIVE ONE
WE'RE GONNA KEEP THE ROLE OPEN
TEMPORARILY.
AYE WE'RE MOVING ON TO FILE ITEM
SIXTEEN AB TWENTY NINE FORTY
FOUR CURRENTLY ENJOYS A SIX ZERO
MUSLIM CHESTER ARE.
ARE ARE ON THE SEVEN ZERO THE
BILL IS OUT FOR CLOSING THE ROLE
FINALLY A FINAL ITEM HIGHLIGHTED
SEVENTEEN AB TWENTY NINE FIFTY
FOUR CURRENTLY JOINS A SIX ZERO
MISSILE INTERESTS LARA.
AYE LARA AYE SEVEN OH WITH THE
BILL IS OUR CLOTHES IN THE ROLE.
BUT WE ARE GOING TO BE RECESSED
SEEMED -- DO
WE DO CONTENT WE NEED TO
CONSIDER [inaudible]
CORRECT YEAH [inaudible]
YEAH.
THANK YOU WITHOUT A YOUR HELP
PAY THE SENATE.
WILL BE RECESSED SEEM
TEMPORARILY.
NOT A SCREEN ORDER ARE
TWELVE
THIRTY WILL.
WHEN WILL RECONVENE IN HAVE A
SENATOR HERTZBERG ADD ON TO FILE
ITEM FIFTEEN IN SEASON FILE ITEM
ELEVEN IN FILE ITEM FIFTEEN WILL
RECONVENE?
A FROM A RECESS AT TWELVE THIRTY
PM SHARP THANK YOU SO MUCH
YOU'RE WELCOME BACK TO OUR
GOVERNANCE FINANCE COMMITTEE WE
AND THE SCIENTISTS WITH ABOUT.
TWENTY FOUR BILLS TO GO CORRECT.
THE RED HEAD THEY'RE AGO WE'VE
TWO BILLS --
YOU KNOW WHATEVER THE LAST VOTE
IS AMENDING MY SERVICE TAX BILL
INTO THAT ONE TE.
HIGH PAYING MUCH OUT A LIKE A
LIKE IT ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN ITEM
NUMBER FIFTEEN THAT TART WITH
ITEM NUMBER ELEVEN EIGHTY TWENTY
FOUR TWENTY FIVE CURRENT VOTERS
FOR ONE CHAIR VOTING AYE.
MISLED CHESTER BUT OTHER NUMBER
ELEVEN THIS IS --
AYE MR BURMAN AB.
TWENTY FOUR TWENTY FIVE A
CURRENT VOTERS.
FOR ONE CHAIR BUT YOU KNOW THAT.
IT'S GOOD TIMES THAT HAVE HIT
EVERY GO HOT DAY HERTY.
LOT LIKE ENERGY THERE WASN'T
JUST HURTS PARA [inaudible]
YEAH [inaudible]
HERTZBERG [inaudible]
AND THINKING.
ASSEMBLY ARE BERMAN LISTENING
AND THINKING.
YOU KNOW THE OLD STORY OF ON THE
ONE HAND SOME FRIENDS ARE FOR
THIS AND THAT AND I AND SOME
FRIENDS ARE AGAINST IT I'M WITH
MY FRIENDS RIGHT IT'S RELEASED
TO SAY IN THE OLD DAYS BUT ALL.
BUT THIS IS TWENTY EIGHT FIFTY
THREE CURRENT VOTE IS FIVE TO
ONE MISLAID GESTURE BROKAW.
HERTZBERG AYE HERTZBERG AYE.
SIX ONE SIX ONE LATEST GERMAN
THAT IT'S GOING TO GET A SAID
THROUGH THANK YOU SO MUCH IN HER
I JUST WANT TO SAY MISTER
CHAIRMAN THIS OF CHAIRMAN
EMERITUS OF THIS COMMITTEE I AM
DEEPLY APPRECIATIVE FOR YOUR
GRACIOUSNESS AND THEN PULLING
HIS TO COME BACK TO ACCOMMODATE
ME.
AND MY LEAVING THE COMMITTEE
EARLY WHICH I APOLOGIZE WELL
YOU'RE GOOD YOU'RE GOOD SIR
THANK YOU SO MUCH HATE WE HAVE.
I THINK HEARINGS --
NEXT WEEK IT'S GOING TO BE A
LONG ONE IN THE WEEK AFTER COULD
BE WORSE.
SO WHY AS WE ARE PUT IN ALL THE
CONTROVERSIAL STUFF OFF THE LAST
WEEK.
BUT AND THEN WE HAVE ANOTHER
HEARING ON AUGUST EIGHTH WHICH
IS GOING TO BE --
COLLINS FAVORITE HE HAS HIS OWN --
TAX LEVY TIED THAT HE'LL BE
WEARING THAT DAY IT WILL BE A
TAX LEVY A HEARING AS WELL AS
SENATOR HERTZBERG AYE SERVICE
TAX OUR SECOND HEARING ON THAT.
I THINK IS MUCH WILL BE IN TURN
UNTIL NEXT WEDNESDAY