.
TO ORDER WE WILL PROCEED AS A
SUBCOMMITTEE UNTIL WE ASK
ESTABLISH A QUORUM I SEE THAT WE
HAVE.
.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER COOLIES HERE
WHO'S ON ITEM TWELVE THREE ZERO.
A THREE SIX
REGARDING THE DEFINITION OF
SOLID WASTE.
.
SOME MEMBER COOLEY PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
YEAH.
AND GOOD MORNING.
GOOD MORNING COLLEAGUES GOOD TO
BE HERE THIS MORNING.
OF RESEARCHER MEMBERS I'M HERE
TODAY PRESENT A. B. THIRTY
THIRTY SIX WHICH CLARIFIES A
DEFINITION OF SOLID WASTE.
I WANT TO NOTE THAT THE
COMMITTEE ANALYSIS.
SO JUST WORKING ON THE A
DEFINITIONAL INDUSTRIAL SOURCES
AS A CURRENTLY APPEARS IN THE
BILL.
AND BELT LINE HOPING TO MOVE THE
BILL ALONG AND ACTUALLY VERY
HAPPY TO CONTINUE WORK WITH YOUR
COMMITTEE STAFF. ON THAT ISSUE.
.
FOOD PROCESSING BY PRODUCTS ARE
CURRENTLY CLASSIFIED AS HUESO
THE CALIFORNIA LAW.
OTHERS ARE CLASSIFICATION CAN
TRIGGER A LICENSURE AND
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS AND LOCAL
FRANCHISE AGREEMENTS
FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO TRANSPORT
THESE PRODUCTS. PRODUCTS.
.
SUCH REQUIREMENTS PUT
SIGNIFICANT BURDENS ON LIVESTOCK
AND POULTRY PRODUCERS.
WHO COULD COLLECTED NEWSIES
PRODUCTS IN FEE FOR THEIR
ANIMALS?
IN DOING SO ACTUALLY DIVERT
THESE PRODUCTS IN THE LANDFILL
WHICH IS A POSITIVE OUTCOME.
THIS BILL RE CLASSIFIES
BYPRODUCTS FROM AB CULTURAL FOOD
FEED.
SO IT IS NOT CONSIDERED WASTE.
THEREBY PRESERVING THE BELIEVE
THESE LIVESTOCK POULTRY
PRODUCERS TO USE AND TRANSPORT.
FOODS BY PRODUCT FOR THEIR FEET.
HARM.
THATIS THE ESSENCE OF THE BILL
AND AS I SAY.
.
I'VE
AS IS BILLS PROCEEDED I WORK
WITH ALL PARTIES IN.
AND I THINK.
PEOPLE ARE GENERALLY HAPPY BUT I
DO THINK THERE'S THIS INTEREST
TO WORK ON INDUSTRIAL SOURCE I.
COULD TO DO THAT RIGHT I THINK
WE WERE MOST CONCERNED ON PAGE
TWO WHEN YOU GET TO PARAGRAPH
FOUR OF WHAT THE BY PRODUCTS ARE
AND YOU HAVE TO MEET ALL THOSE
CONDITIONS
SEEMS AS THOUGH. THAT YES YOU
KNOW IT'S NOT DISCARDED IT'S
IT'S THEIR DESTINED FOR USE IN
ANIMAL FEED THEIR CONCLUSIVE AND
IN THE BUTTONS OF CAUTION IT
JUST SEEMS LIKE IT'S GOOD FOR
BUT I THINK WE ALL GET THE IDEA
THAT THIS.
INDUSTRIAL BUT IT'S A FOOD
SUBSTANCE
YEAH THERE'S NOT FEATHER SO
WHAT'S YOUR FOR YOUR FIRST
WITNESS AND.
GOOD MORNING NOELLE KRAMER'S OF
CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU
FEDERATION.
.
AB THIRTY THIRTY SIX THE INTENT
IS TO ALLOW. LIFESTYLE
COMPLETELY PRODUCERS WHO HAVE
BEEN USING THESE FOOD BY
PRODUCTS FOR MANY MANY YEARS TO
FEED THEIR LIVESTOCK TIME. THAT
DAIRY INDUSTRY I CALIFORNIA
USES ABOUT A MORE THAN FORTY
PERCENT OF THEIR. DIETS ARE MADE
UP OF THESE FUN
FOOD BY PART FOOD PROCESSING BY
PRODUCTS. AND WE WANT TO MAKE
SURE THAT AND THAT CAN CONTINUE
AND SO WE WERE LOOKING FOR
CLARIFICATION THAT.
THESE BY PRODUCTS ARE NOT.
WASTE AND SHOULD NOT BE TREATED
AS WASTE I'M MORE HAPPY TO WORK
ON. FIGURING OUT THE RIGHT
LANGUAGE ON ON INDUSTRIAL WE WE
CERTAINLY AREN'T TRYING TO. TO
EXPAND ANYTHING BEYOND THE FOOD
BY PRESSING FOOD PROCESSING BY
PRODUCTS WE JUST WANNA MAKE SURE
THAT THAT THAT UNIVERSES ON
CAPTURED ACCURATELY. EXPORTING
OUR IT.
LOOKS
ESTABLISH A QUORUM IF.
JUST IF YOU CAN CALL THE RULES
WORK IF THAT.
IN CARE OF.
AND PLEASE CULTURAL.
CAME Y. CASKEY.
HERE.
STONE HERE.
GAINES.
HILL.
LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
QUORUM STAB WISHED LETS OTHERS
IN SUPPORT OF A. B. AT THIRTY
THIRTY SIX
THIS IS.
.
DEFINITIONS OR.
SOLID WASTE BYPRODUCTS SEEING
NONE LET'S BRING IT BACK TO THAT
IF A MOTION BY.
.
WELL OPPOSITION OPPOSITION.
FUNDS YOU HAVE ENOUGH MONEY TO
THE COMPASS COALITION THEY WEAR
TWEENER WE WANT TO THANK THE
COMMITTEE FOR ADDRESSING THIS
ISSUE AND ALSO THE THE AUTHOR
FOR AGREEING TO FIX THIS. WE DO
PROPOSE THAT YOU JUST SIMPLY USE
THE DEFINITION IN TITLE FOURTEEN
IS ALREADY A DIFFERENT
DEFINITION CHO AGRICULTURE
BYPRODUCT MATERIAL. NETTLE
CERTAINLY SATISFY MOST THE
PEOPLE WE WORKED WITH THANKS
VERY MUCH.
THERE IS A MOTION BY.
CENTER STONE QUESTIONS.
SEEING THEN.
IS KALRA.
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE AB THIRTIES.
THIRTY SIX
BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER COOLEY.
THE MOTION IS DO PASS TO THE
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE
BY CASKEY. BY.
STONE.
AND I GAINES
GAINES AYE HILL.
HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
WE'LL KEEP IT PIERCE YOU HAVE
SUFFICIENT VOTES TO GET THE
MATTER OUT OF FAT COMMITTEE WILL
KEEP IT OPEN UNTIL THE OTHER
MATTER. AT ARMS HAVE PLAYED IS
ONE WOMAN'S.
OKAY THANK YOU ITEM MEMBERS FIVE
AS PART OF AN ANNOUNCEMENT WE
HAVE ITEMS ONE.
AT THREE IN FIVE.
NUMBER ITEM ONE BY A ASSUME
EVER OBERNOLTE IN ITEM THREE. AT
A. B..
TWENTY FIFTY SEVEN BY
ASSEMBLYMEMBER SALAS AND. ITEM
NUMBER FIVE AB TWO TWO SIX SEVEN
BY SOME MEMBER WOULD HAVE BEEN
PULLED WE DO HAVE A TO MATTERS
THAT ARE.
ON A CONSENT BEFORE WE CALL UP
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ACOSTA I SEE
THERE I JUST WE HAVE ITEMS.
EIGHT IN.
ELEVEN BUT.
THERE'S A MOTION BY CENTER STONE
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL ON THE
CONSENT CALENDAR.
BY CASKEY.
I.
CASKEY AYE STONE.
STONE AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE HILL.
HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
OKAY GETS APPEARS HAPPENS
FISHING BOATS WILL KEEP THE ROLE
OPEN FOR THE MEMBERS ARE ABSENT
ASSEMBLY MEMBER ACOSTA PLEASE
COME FORWARD YOU HAVE ITEM
NUMBER FOUR THIS IS A BE. ARE
TWO ZERO NINE SEVEN.
SPENDING DE OR CHANGING THE DATE
FOR THE REPORT FROM THE CARPET.
THE CARE PEOPLE.
PLEASE PROCEED THAT'S GREAT
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR GOOD
MORNING WHO SHARE IN MEMBERS IN
TWO THOUSAND AND TEN THE
LEGISLATION WAS SIGNED CREATING
A CARPET STEWARDSHIP PROGRAM
WHICH REQUIRED THE CARPET
INDUSTRY. EITHER INDIVIDUALLY OR
THROUGH A CARPET STEWARDSHIP
PROFILE ORGANIZATION.
SUBMIT A PLAN AND ANNUAL REPORT
TO CAO RECYCLE REGARDING THE
RECOVERY AND RECYCLING.
AND RECYCLING OF CARPETING
CALIFORNIA.
EDITION TO THE ORIGINAL
LEGISLATION LAST YEAR'S AB
ELEVEN FIFTY EIGHT. CREATED AN
REQUIRED THE ANNUAL REPORT TO BE
SUBMITTED TO THE COMMITTEE PRIOR
TO THE SUBMISSION TO CAL
RECYCLE.
IT ALSO REQUIRES THE CARPET
STEWARDSHIP ORGANIZATION TO
INCORPORATE THE RECOMMENDATIONS
OF THE COMMITTEE INTO THE
REPORT.
AB TWENTY NINETY SEVEN CHANGES
THE DATE OF THE SUBMISSION OF
THE AND REPORT FROM CORPORATE
STEWARDSHIP ORGANIZATION FROM
JULY FIRST SEPTEMBER FIRST. IN
ORDER TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE TIME
TO GATHER DATA DRAFT REPORT
PROVIDED TO THIS NEW ADVISORY
COMMITTEE. FOR FEEDBACK AND
STILL SUBMIT ON TIME TO CAL
RECYCLE.
THE ADDITIONAL TIME OF SIXTY
DAYS IS APPROPRIATE TO ALLOW FOR
THE ADEQUATE PREPARATION REVIEW
OF THE PLAN BEFORE TO SUBMITTED
TO CAL RECYCLE.
I HAVE ALREADY PUBLIC WITH YOU
THIS MORNING ON BEHALF OF THE
CARPET AND A RUCKUS TO TESTIFY
IN SUPPORT. RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
RIGHT ABOUT THANK YOU SO WE'RE
CLEAR CAL RECYCLES ALREADY GIVEN
THEM UNTIL SEPTEMBER OF THIS
YEAR ILL THIS WILL BE TWENTY
NINETEEN AND.
FOREVER CORRECT
SO WHEN WE GET THE CARPET
RECYCLING PROGRAM IN SHAPE
PLEASE MISTER POLLOCK.
YOUR PRESENT WHEN MISTER
CHAIRMAN RAINY POWER CAN BE HAVE
THE CABIN RUG INSTITUTE I THINK
THE BILL IS PRETTY SELF
EXPLANATORY JUST ADDITIONAL
SIXTY DAYS SO THAT WE CAN HAVE
ADDITIONAL TIME TO PROVIDE
INFORMATION TO ADVISORY
COMMITTEE. BEFORE THE ANNUAL
REPORT ESTIMATED KELLY CYCLE
WHO WOULD ASK US FOR YEAR I'VE.
OTHER FATHERS AND HERE IN
SUPPORT OF A. B. AND TWO ZERO
NINE SEVEN FROM ACOSTA.
OKAY I THERE IS OUR OPPOSITION
EXTENDING THE DATE FROM JULY
FIRST TO SEPTEMBER FIRST FOR THE
CARE PROGRAM.
IT'S NOT POSITION THERE'S A
MOTION QUESTIONS MEMBER.
SEEING THEN YOU MAY CLOSE.
I RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR AYE VOTE
THEY CAN THANK YOU.
I HAVE PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ITEM NUMBER FOUR AB TWENTY
NINETY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
ACOSTA THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED
TO THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE.
MY CASKET. BY MY CASKET AYE
STONE. STONE AYE GAINES GAINES
AYE HILL. HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
OKAY PEARCY HAVE SUFFICIENT
VOTES WILL KEEP THE MATTER OPEN
FOR THOSE ABSENT MEMBERS.
LET'S MOVE TO ITEM NUMBER SIX
DISS PARA AB TWO THREE FOUR ONE
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER MATHIS GOOD
MORNINGS.
THIS IS THE LAP RELATED AND
AESTHETIC.
CONCERNS FOR SEEK WHAT.
GOOD MORNING.
SHARE SENATORS.
I'D LIKE TO START BY ACCEPTING
THE.
COMMITTEE SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
TO MEASURES.
NUMBERS THREE AND FOUR ON THE
COMMENT SECTION OF THE COMMITTEE
ANALYSIS.
AND I LIKE TO THINK THAT
COMMITTEE STAFF.
IN THE CHAIR FOR WORKING WITH ME
ON THIS.
VERY VITAL PIECE OF LEGISLATION.
WINNERS AB TWENTY THREE FORTY
ONE AS A BIPARTISAN MEASURE.
WHICH WOULD PROVIDE LITIGATION
REALLY FOR HOUSING PROJECTS
INVOLVING THE REFURBISHMENT.
CONVERSION REPURPOSE SCENE OR
REPLACEMENT WHEN EXISTING
BUILDING THAT IS ABANDONED
DILAPIDATED OR HAS BEEN VACANT
FOR MORE THAN ONE YEAR.
THIS NARROWLY TAILORED MEASURE.
WOULD EXEMPT A LEAD AGENCY.
FROM HAVING TO CONSIDER OR
MITIGATE THAT HOUSING PROJECTS
AESTHETIC IMPACTS.
IS IMPORTANT TO KNOW.
A PROJECTS WITH POTENTIALLY
SIGNIFICANT. CAN'T AESTHETIC
IMPACTS.
ON.
AND OFFICIAL STATE SCENIC
HIGHWAY OR.
HISTORIC OR CULTURAL RESOURCE.
FURTHERMORE.
IT HAS NOT CHANGED LOCAL
OBLIGATIONS TO CONSIDER.
AND MITIGATE ASCETIC IMPACTS.
UNDER ANY OTHER LOS.
IT ALSO DOES NOT APPLY WHEN THE
PROJECT SUBSTANTIALLY EXCEEDS
THE HEIGHT OF THE EXISTING
STRUCTURE.
OR WHERE
THE PROJECT CREATES A NEW SOURCE
OF SUBSTANTIAL.
WHITE OR GLARE.
THIS BILL SIMPLY PROVIDES THAT
AESTHETIC IMPACTS OF HOUSING
PROJECTS.
NEED NOT BE CONSIDERED OR
MITIGATED THEREBY AVOIDING. A
LITIGATION TRAP.
WE ARE NOT TRYING TO HINDER
SEQUEL WITH THIS MEASURE WE ARE
SIMPLY TRYING TO ENSURE. THAT
ENTITIES DO NOT STALL OR HALL A
HOUSING PROJECT UNDER THE
ARGUMENTS OF AESTHETIC APPEAL.
GIVEN THE STATE OF OUR HOUSING
CRISIS IN THE DRASTIC NEED FOR
MORE AFFORDABLE ACCESS HOUSING.
FOR STATES WORKING FAMILIES THE
RELIEF OFFERED BY AB TWENTY
THREE FORTY ONE.
CRUCIAL RESPECTFULLY ASK FOR
I'VE.
HOME AWAY HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT.
A CONCRETE EXAMPLE OF WEIRD
THIS IS.
HOME WHERE RECEIVED BEING.
IT WILL BE APPLIED YOU KNOW
WHAT IF WE KNEW OF SOME OF THE
SAID.
BUILDINGS THAT THAT SEQUENCE
ACTUALLY.
.
DELAYED DID USE I NOTE THAT THE
US STAFF REPORT TALKS ABOUT THE
SECRETARY OF NATURAL RESOURCES
DOING AN AMENDMENT TO SECTION
ONE TO SORT OF FURTHER
STREAMLINED. THAT THE RAKES SO.
.
I I GUESS WERE I WAS JUST
WONDERING IF YOU KNEW OF.
PROJECT OR. DEAD.
YEAH IT WILL NECESSITY IS CENTER
THING WITH THIS IS IS I MEAN
THERE THERE SEVERAL. NAM IN ALL
MY CAN NAME ANY OFF THE TOP OF
MY HEAD BOY IS WE'RE LOOKING AT
IN FILLING.
IN A GETTING OUR NEIGHBORHOOD'S
CLEANED UP WITH THESE HOUSES.
IN PROVIDING MORE HOUSING STOCK.
IT IS VITAL TO LOOK AT WAYS THAT
WE CAN NO.
SPEED UP THAT PROCESS AND MAKE
IT EASIER FOR PEOPLE TO DO SO
AND THAT'S ALL THAT'S WHY THIS
IS SO FAMILY CAN I JUST DIDN'T
NEVER HEARD OF WE HAVE A LOT OF.
PEOPLE YEAH COMMUTER WITH IDEAS
AND I AM CHANGING SEQUIN I NEVER
HEARD OF THE AESTHETIC.
CATEGORY OF THE EIGHTEEN BE IN
THAT OLD THAT'S THE ONE THAT
HELD US UP HERE SO WE HAVE A
QUESTION FROM SENATOR GAINES.
IF I COULD HELP THEM THROUGH THE
CONVERSATION WE DID HAVE A CASE
IN SACRAMENTO COUNTY YOU HAD TO
DO WITH PAINT COLOR.
AND SO YOU HAD NEIGHBORS AND THE
ADJACENT AT NEIGHBORHOOD.
I USING SEQUEL AS A MEANS OF
STOPPING THE PROJECT.
BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T WANT
ADDITIONAL HOUSING NEXT TO THEIR
COMMUNITY.
BUT NORMALLY IT EXAMPLE HAVE A
LITTLE EROTIC RESULT OF
AESTHETICS.
YEP I'D NORMAL ORDINANCES THAT'S
THAT'S THE LOCAL ORDINANCE THAT
THAT THAT GOES IN ON WHAT THE
PAIN POLICE THAT'S THAT THAT'S
OF THE CITY. OUR CHALLENGE BUT
THEN ONCE THE BUILDINGS APPROVED
AND IT'S BUILT YOU CAN CHANGE
THE PAINT COLOR MEAN THAT'S SORT
OF THE IRONY OF THE WHOLE BIT IS
THAT IT'S YOU JUST GET.
CONTROLLED ON THE FIRST ONE.
ALRIGHT LET'S SEE YOUR FROM
OPPONENTS WILL IN ENOUGH
EVIDENCE THAT THAT THAT'S WHY
WE'RE LOOKING AT HAVING THIS BE
AT A LOCAL LEVEL.
THEY CAN DECIDE AND MAKE THOSE.
THOSE IN FAVOR OF AB TWENTY
THREE FORTY ONE.
GOOD MORNING GALLAGHER HAVOC
WITH THE CALIFORNIA ASSOCIATION
OF REALTORS IN SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
GOOD MORNING ADAM RIGHTLY ON
BEHALF THE CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF
COMMERCE ALSO SUPPORT THINKING.
ALRIGHT LET'S SEE OPPONENTS
OTHER FOLKS HERE OPPOSED TO.
AB TWO THREE FOUR ONE.
WET MORNING KYLE JONES A SIERRA
CLUB CALIFORNIA.
AND WE CONTINUE TO BE OPPOSE
THE MEASURE.
WE
THROUGHOUT THE RESEARCH DONE
THROUGH THIS COMMUNITY ARE THIS
COMMITTEE OUR OTHER STUDIES OUT
THERE WE DON'T FEEL THAT SEEK
WAS A SIGNIFICANT BARRIER
CONSTRUCTION OF NEW HOMES IN
CALIFORNIA.
WITH THIS SPECIFIC PIECE OF
LEGISLATION WE CONTINUE TO BE
CONCERNED ABOUT HOW DO YOU
DEFINE DILAPIDATED I THINK THE
MIDEAST AND WONDERFUL DRUG
TAKING A STAB AT IT ULTIMATELY
THAT DOES KIND OF COME DOWN TO A
SUBJUNCTIVE.
JUDGMENT MADE BY ONE PERSON
THAT IT MIGHT NOT BE AGREED WITH
AND I THINK WE SAW A DIFFICULTY
WITH THIS KIND OF TERM.
WITH REDEVELOPMENT AND WE'RE
BLIGHT. AND HOW I GOT DEFINE
MULTIPLE WAYS ACROSS THE STATE
AYE IT AND SO IF IF ONE PERSON
FEELS LIKE THAT IS USED WRONG
THEN THIS. WOULD ACTUALLY THIS
BILL COULD CREATE MORE
LITIGATION INCIDENT LAST.
.
AND AND JUST ONE KIND OF OTHER
POINT I WANTED TO MAKE GOING FOR
DISEASES.
.
YOU KNOW I THINK IT'S GREAT AT
THE SUNSET ON THEIR AND
APPRECIATE THAT BECAUSE THEY GET
PARTICLE BACK AND LOOK AT THESE
THINGS BUT. I WOULD JUST REQUEST
THAT THE COMMITTEE CONSIDER
ADDING REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
WITH SUNSETS ARE IN THE FUTURE.
US OF THE.
WE CAN SEE YOU KNOW HOW MANY
TIMES IF IF THIS EXEMPTION HAS
BEEN FILED THAT NOTICE BE SENT
OPR. US SO THAT WE CAN GET THE
DATA ON HOW USEFUL.
THESE EXEMPTIONS ARE GOING
FORWARD UP BUT BECAUSE OF THE
ISSUES REGARDING AT THE OPTICIAN
AND AND THAT WE DON'T FEEL THAT
THERE'S A NEED FOR THIS BILL WE
ARE AYE. OPPOSED TODAY.
OTHER THAN NOT.
AND.
NOT BELIEVING THERE'S A NEED
FOR THE BILL CAN YOU THINK OF A
SITUATION WHERE THERE WOULD BE
A.
AN INFILL PROJECT AND HOUSING
THAT BUT FOR THE.
NEW DEFINITION OF DILAPIDATED
THIS THING WOULD NOT TRIGGER
BECAUSE OF OTHER OTHER. ELEMENTS
OF IT YOU KNOW THE THE DENSITY
OR THE.
.
I THINK COMPLETELY THE RADICAL
CHANGE OF WHAT THE BUILDING
ENVELOPE LESS RIGHT BECAUSE I
THINK WE HAVE OTHER OTHER.
TRIGGERS THAT IF IT'S IF IT'S
REALLY INCREASED IN SIZE OR
GLARE.
RIGHT.
THAT WOULD THAT WOULD TRIGGER.
THAT AT LEAST HE'D LEAD AGENCY
TO HAVE TO. ADDRESS THAT.
IT'S IT'S HARD FOR ME TO THINK
EXAMPLE.
TO WEAR.
EXACTLY THIS BILL WOULD APPLY
AND THAT THAT IS BECAUSE I THINK
IT'S THE COMMITTEE ANALYSIS
NOTED A RECONSTRUCTION OF
EXISTING BUILDINGS RT FELIKS
UNDER SEQUEL. ARE.
AT AN END ESPECIALLY IF YOU'RE
ALREADY IN AN INFILL AREA EVEN
NEW CONSTRUCTION IS EXEMPTED
UNDER CATEGORICAL EXEMPTIONS
ARE.
STEPPING SAID IT'S JUST
YOU KNOW.
I DON'T LIKE CODE POLLUTION
PICKED UP AND AND SO IT'S IT'S
YOU KNOW THAT IT'S.
MEMBERS QUESTIONS OF THE AUTHOR.
CENTER GAINES YEAH I THINK IT'S.
.
SELF EVIDENT THAT SECRET NEEDS
TO BE REFORMED. IN MANY AREAS.
IT'S
IT'S GONE WAY BEYOND.
ITS ORIGINAL PURPOSE WHICH IS
TO.
MITIGATE THE ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT.
AS RESULT OF THE PROJECT.
WE KNOW THAT LABOR'S USE IT VERY
EFFECTIVELY FOR PLA'S.
WE KNOW THAT.
COMPETITOR DEVELOPERS ABUSE
THAT.
TO SQUASH A PROJECT.
AND WE KNOW IT'S BEEN USED BY
COMMUNITIES THAT DON'T WANT
GROWTH.
WITHIN THEIR COMMUNITY SO.
I I CAN MAKE A MOTION ON.
OF. THAT.
.
I THINK THIS IS A WORTHY ASPECT
IT'S ONE PIECE OF. I THINK MANY
ELEMENTS THAT STILL NEED TO BE.
BROUGHT FORWARD TO REFORM
SEQUENCE AND WE CAN. WE CAN KEEP
SEAQUARIUM WE CAN GO BACK TO ITS
ORIGINAL INTENT THAT.
IT'S GONE WAY BEYOND AND.
THIS IS JUST THEM ALL A SMALL
STEP FORWARD.
BRINGING IT BACK TO ITS ORIGINAL
INTENT.
THANK YOU.
SENATOR HILL THANK YOU VERY MUCH
FOR FEAR OF.
YOU KNOW I OF.
AND I APPRECIATE THE QUESTIONS
THAT YOU ASK RELATED TO THE.
THE PURPOSE OF THE LEGISLATION
OR THE NEED FOR THE LEGISLATION
AND I ALSO APPRECIATE THE. THE
GREAT WORK IN THE STAFF ANALYSIS
OF THE OF A COUPLE OF THE BILLS
THAT WERE NOT SEEN TODAY. AND
THOSE WERE EXEMPTION EXCEPTIONS
THAT UP.
EXEMPTIONS THAT WERE WERE IN
PLACE.
FOR AND WHERE WE HAVEN'T SEEN.
ANY.
PARTICULAR ADVANTAGE FOR THAT OR
USE OR BENEFIT FROM THEM THAT.
THAT CAN BE QUANTIFIED.
.
SO I I LIKE THE SUNSET IN THIS
AND I THINK IT'S IT'S AN
OPPORTUNITY AND IF IT'S NOT USED
IN FIVE YEARS THAN THERE'S BEEN
NO HARM IF WE'RE LOOKING AT
PRESERVING THE SEQUEL.
ENVIRONMENT IS WE HAVE IT.
AND.
.
AND THEN WEAKENED.
CERTAINLY AT THAT TIME LOOK AT
WHETHER IT SHOULD BE CONTINUED
OR NOT SO I.
AB HAVE YOU TO SUPPORT THE BILL
TO THE END CECILIA.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER TOOK THE AND
AMENDMENTS I THINK THAT'S IT.
ORIGINS
I FORGOT TO ASK YOU A SOME.
MATHIS IS THE OPPOSITION ASKED
ABOUT OF REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.
DO YOU THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE.
ONEROUS WOULD BE IF THERE IF THE
LEAD AGENCY COULD LET OPR KNOW
ABOUT HAD LEGALLY STRAIGHT THE
USE OF THIS THAT. IS IT IS IT
REALLY A CENTERS YOU KNOW I'M
ALWAYS ONE.
WITH.
YOU AND OTHERS IN AND THE
OPPOSITION WHICH IS WHY WE TOOK
THE AMENDMENT ON THE DEFINITION.
AND THE AMENDMENTS ON THE
SUNSET.
MADE IF THEY HAVE AMENDMENTS IT
MIGHT COME OFF RIGHT LOVE TO SEE
THEM
HE REACHED OUT AND OTHER
COMMITTEE STAFF REACHED OUT AS
WELL.
ARM AND INTO YOUR QUESTION
EARLIER.
GOT GOTTA THINK GREAT STAFF OF.
THEY THEY JUST BROUGHT ME THREE
EXAMPLES. WHERE AESTHETICS HAVE
BEEN USED TO DELAY THE
IMPORTANCE OF PROJECTS?
ON ONE BEING BROKER TO
WASHINGTON COMMUNITY SERVICE
CENTER IN SAN FRANCISCO.
.
ANOTHER ONE BEING THE.
SACRAMENTO'S INNER HOUSING AND
BERKELEY WHICH WAS.
BOWMAN VERSUS CITY OF BERKELEY.
AND ALSO THE SKYWALKER RANCH IN
MARIN.
SO WE CAN GET THOSE TO USE WHILE
SO THERE'S THREE EXAMPLES THERE.
HE SAYS IT WOULD YOU KNOW IF
THAT WAS THOSE.
THERE WAS JUST ONE OF THEM
BECAUSE OF ACTIONS I I I I CAN I
CAN REDEEM BECAUSE THAT GOES
FURTHER TWO PAGES IF YOU LIE
OKAY. IF NOT I
CENTER STONE YET QUESTION ARE
MISTER EARLIER COMMENT MISTER
HEROES IS GONNA MENTIONED AB
EXAMPLES THAT.
SOMEWHERE MATHIS AS WAS.
GONNA BE CITING THAT THERE THERE
IS SOME. ISSUES OUT THERE AT A
TIME WHEN.
YOU NO WE IS A STATE ARE DOING
EVERYTHING WE CAN TO.
NOT ONLY BUILD AFFORDABLE
HOUSING BUT TO EXPEDITE THE
DELIVERY OF.
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN SOME
PEOPLE FOR NIMBY REASONS AS WE
KNOW.
WE WILL USE SEAQUEST WAITED THE
LAYER CHO PROJECTS AND IT REALLY
SERIOUS ABOUT PROVIDING
AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS INFILL IN
CITIES.
THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT TO
OPENING UP THE BUILDING
INTRIGUED REALLY STANDS BEHIND.
AND FOR THOSE REASONS I WANTED
TO SUPPORT THE MOTION OF MY GOOD
COLLEAGUE OVER HERE IS GOING TO
MOVE IT.
YOU MAY CLOSE.
SENATORS.
A AS WE'VE HEARD AND AS AS
WE'VE JUST GONE OUR I THINK THIS
IS A GREAT HOLE.
WITH THE SUN SAY THAT GIVES US
THE OPPORTUNITY TO SEE. HOW WELL
THIS WILL WORK?
AND GIVE US THE OPPORTUNITY TO
REALLY FIX THE AND HEALTH
PROBLEM THAT WE HAVE.
BOMBING GETTING OUR
NEIGHBORHOOD'S CLEANED UP AND
PROVIDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO
OUR CITIZENS.
AND WITHOUT I ASK YOU FOR
NEITHER. GOOD ARM FOR THE MOMENT
I'M JUST GONNA STAY OFF BUT
WILL.
HAVE TO VOTE AND LET THE OTHER
MEMBERS COMING THEM BOTH THEIR
CONSCIOUSNESS PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL.
ITEM NUMBER SIX AB TWO THREE
FOUR ONE ASSEMBLY MEMBER MATHIS
THE MOTION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED
TO THE SENATE FLOOR.
WIECKOWSKI NOT VOTING.
STONE.
STONE AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE HILL.
HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
WILL KEEP THE MATTER OPEN THANK
YOU FOR YOUR PRESENTATION MS
MISTER SHERIFF SIDE DOES NOT GET
THROWN IN LIKE FAST FREAKING
JAIL AYE AYE THAT'S AUTOMATIC IN
THIS.
THANK YOU.
A WE HAVE A SUMMER RODRIGUEZ
SAYS TWO MATTERS ITEMS NUMBER
NINE AND TEN YOUR PLEASURE WHICH
WHEN YOU WANNA GO FIRST ON.
AB
FIVE SIX ARMATURE WHICH ONE IS
THAT THE TEACHERS ITEM NUMBER
NINE. THIS IS.
THAT INCREASING THE MINIMUM
CIVIL PENALTY TO TWENTY FIVE
THOUSAND FOR.
YES LIGHTER VEHICLE.
WE ALL KNOW LICKLIDER VEHICLES
ARE NOW.
LEAST PRISON THANK YOU CHAIRED
IN TWENTY STAFF OF ACCEPTING THE
COMMITTEES AMENDMENTS.
AB TWENTY FIVE SIXTY FORMER
INCREASED INCREASED PENALTIES
FOR COMMERCIAL TRUCKS.
BUT USE GLIDERS WHICH ARE TRUCKS
THAT RUN ON OUTDATED ENGINES.
BUT OUR HIDDEN BEHIND A NEW
TRUCK BODY PARTS.
GLIDERS COMMIT UP TO FOUR
HUNDRED FIFTY TIMES MORE
POLLUTION BECAUSE THEY LACK
MODERN EMISSION CONTROLS MAKING
THEM MUCH MORE CHEAPER TO
PURCHASE. THAN A COMPLIANT
TRUCK.
AS A RESULT THEY ARE THREATENING
BUSINESSES WHO ARE COMPLYING
WITH CURRENT LAW.
I REPRESENT A DISTRICT WHOSE
ECONOMY RELIES HEAVILY ON THE
TRUCKING INDUSTRY. AND HAVING
GLIDERS ON THE ROAD WHAT IMPACT
SMALL LOCAL BUSINESSES AND THEIR
QUALITY.
IN CALIFORNIA IT IS ALREADY
ILLEGAL TO OWN AND OPERATE A
GLIDER VEHICLE. BUT THERE'S
NOTHING STOPPING TRUCKS COMING
FROM OUT OF STATE FROM DRIVING
THROUGH CALIFORNIA.
THIS ISSUE WAS ADDRESSED AT THE
FEDERAL LEVEL BUT DUE TO RECENT
ADMINISTRATION AND.
EPA IS PROPOSING TO REPEAL THE
ADMISSION STANDARDS FOR HEAVY
DUTY COLLATERAL TRUCKS UNDER THE
PROPOSED.
INTERPRETATIONS EPA WERE LACK
AUTHORITY TO REGULATE CRIED
RECALLS THIS LEGISLATION WILL
NOT ONLY HELP WITH THE
REDUCTION.
OF GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS BUT
ALSO HOP STOP THE THREAT TO
PUBLIC HEALTH. WITH ME TODAY
TESTIFYING AND HELP ANSWER
QUESTIONS IS LYNETTE BROWN FROM
KK W. TRUCKING AND PRESIDENT OF
THE CALIFORNIA TRUCKING
ASSOCIATION AND NOT ROMAN WHO
REPRESENTS THE CALIFORNIA
TRUCKING ASSOCIATION.
S. BROWN PRETTY PLEASE PROCEED.
GOOD MORNING CHAIR AND MEMBERS.
OF THE COMMITTEE MY NAME IS
LYNETTE BROWN AND THE CFO AT KGW
TRUCKING IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.
AND ALSO THE TWO THOUSAND
EIGHTEEN PRESIDENT OF THE
CALIFORNIA TRUCKING ASSOCIATION.
CTA IS A PROUD SPONSOR OF TWENTY
FIVE SIXTY FOUR.
WHICH WILL DETER THE HIGH
EMITTING GLIDER TRUCKS IN
CALIFORNIA.
IN RECENT YEARS OUR MEMBERS HAVE
SPENT BILLIONS.
UPGRADE EQUIPMENT TO COMPLY WITH
CALIFORNIA'S TOUGH AIR QUALITY
REGULATIONS.
TODAY'S TRUCKS VIRTUALLY
ELIMINATE DIESEL PARTICULATES
AND CUT SMOG FORMING EMISSIONS
BY OVER NINETY PERCENT.
LATER KIDS ARE NEW TRUCK BODIES
THAT CAN BE PAIRED WITH NEW OR
USED POWERTRAINS INCLUDING
ENGINES.
LAST YEAR DO YOU TO THE FEDERAL
LEVEL I'M ACTIONS AT THE FEDERAL
LEVEL. PRODUCTION LIMITS FOR
GLIDER KIT VEHICLES WITH
REFURBISHED ENGINES LACKING
MODERN EMISSION CONTROLS WAS
LIFTED.
CARB ESTIMATES THAT SEVEN
PERCENT OF THE TRUCK IF IF SEVEN
PERCENT OF TRUCKS OPERATING IN
CALIFORNIA. WERE NONCOMPLIANT
GLIDER KITS.
THIS WAY IT WOULD ELIMINATE THE
BENEFITS THAT WE'VE ACHIEVED
THROUGH THE CALIFORNIA DIESEL
REGULATION PROGRAM.
THOSE OPERATING GLIDERS.
WOULD BE MODE WHAT ALSO UNDERCUT
CALIFORNIA COMPLIANT TRUCKING
COMPANIES LIKE MINE.
WHO HAVE SPENT BILLIONS OF
DOLLARS TO UPGRADE AND DO THEIR
BEST TO MEET CALIFORNIA'S STRONG
STANDARDS?
CREATING A MINIMUM PENALTY FOR
SUCH OPERATORS OF THESE GLIDER
NONCOMPLIANT GLIDERS.
WHO WERE IN THE POSSESSION?
HER IN THE POSITION TO PURCHASE
AND A NEW COMPLIANT TRUCK BUT
CHOSE NOT TO.
MAKES SENSE FOR DOES NOT MAKE
SENSE FOR CALIFORNIA'S AIR OR
CALIFORNIA BUSINESSES.
WE ASK FOR AN IDOL.
MR RAHMAN ABOUT REMOTE FY
TRUCKING ASSOCIATION HERE IN
SUPPORT AND ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS
THAT THE COMMITTEE MAY HAVE. SO
IS TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS
COULD BE ENOUGH I MEAN I.
WE HAVE.
YOU NO MORE ABOUT TRUCKS THE
NINETY ONE ABOUT RETROFITTING
THAT I SAM.
I'M THOUGH IT IS ARE INITIATED
THESE THE GLIDER TRUCKS
TYPICALLY COST ABOUT A HUNDRED
THOUSAND DOLLARS TO PURCHASE AND
YOUR TYPICAL TRUCK COSTS ABOUT A
HUNDRED AND FIFTY THOUSAND.
WE'VE FELT THEY YOU KNOW TWENTY
FIVE THOUSAND WAS A GOOD FIRST
WITH THE GET STEP TO A MINIMUM
TWENTY FIVE THOUSAND WAS A GOOD
STEP TO.
TO TRY AND YOU KNOW KILL THAT
DEALT IN THERE AND. TRY TO
DISINCENTIVE IE PEOPLE FROM
BUYING THEM.
OTHERS LET'S COLUMN SUPPORTERS
THIS IS A.
AB TWO FIVE SIX FOUR RODRIGUEZ.
THANK YOU CHAIR MEMBERS READ OUT
ASSEMBLY HALF A CAL START IN
STRONG SUPPORT TODAY IMPORTANT
POLICY AS I MENTIONED BY THE
WITNESSES. THANK YOU VERY MUCH
VERY GOOD.
I.
OPPOSITION MISTER OPPOSITION TO
AB TWO FIVE SIX FOUR.
I IT WAS CLOSED DOWN THERE'S
EMOTION OTHER QUESTIONS.
CENTER GAINES.
ARE YOU JUST GET CLARIFICATION
TERMS HOW YOU ENFORCE IT.
SO CURRENT FOR.
NO CURRENT FORCE AND IS DONE
THROUGH A RB THEY HAVE. THEIR.
THEY HAVE. THE COMPLIANCE
OFFICERS THAT GO THROUGHOUT THE
STATE.
UNDER SB ONE A COUPLE
PROVISIONS NASTY ONE FROM LAST
YEAR I HAD IT WILL ALSO EXPAND
YOUR TRUCK REGISTRATION.
SO IN ORDER TO GET REGISTRATION
BILL RICHARD TRUCKING CHO AND
CALIFORNIA YOU'LL HAVE TO COMPLY
WITH THESE RULES.
BUT HOW WOULD YOU WHEN YOU GET
HIM SOME MODERN WITH THEIR.
THAT'S BE LIKE THAT AND NUMBER.
SO A GLIDER VIN NUMBER STARTS
WITH G. L. THE THAT'S ONE WAY
THAT SOMEONE WOULD NOW. I IT IS
DIFFICULT TO FIND ONE JUST ON
THE ROAD THEY DO YOU LOOK JUST
LIKE YOUR EVERYDAY. LOOKS LIKE A
TWENTY EIGHTEEN PETERBILT.
SO THERE IS THERE IS THAT
DIFFICULTY WHICH IS WHY I THINK
YOU YOU'VE SEEN.
WHICH ONE WOULD PROP FOR THE
BILL BECAUSE IT IS DIFFICULT TO
FIND THESE TRUCKS AS IT IS RIGHT
NOW AFTER JUST WATCHING THEM ON
THE ROAD THEY GO THROUGH
ENORMOUS OF SMOG. TESTING
PROCESS LIKE A CAR WITTER ó WE
DON'T HAVE A SMART PROCESS RIGHT
NOW IN PLACE IN CALIFORNIA I
BELIEVE THERE'S A BILL GOING
THROUGH THE AND THE ASSEMBLY ARE
NOW SPEAK TO TEN.
THAT.
BOYD PUT THAT MANDATE ON US.
WE DO HAVE TO.
.
COMPLY WITH EVERY TIME YOU BUY A
TRUCK IN CALIFORNIA YOU DO HAVE
TO COMPLY WITH A.
AND.
SHOW THAT IS COMPLIANT TRUCK
NINE.
THANK YOU CENTER STONE DOES THE
US CHP PLAYED A ROLE IN.
.
AND ENFORCING THESE TYPE OF
RULES OF EIGHT DO THEY KNOW IT'S
LOOK FOR WITH THESE TRUCKS
THEY CAN OF THE TYPICALLY THEY
WILL. OF THE DEFERRED TO THE AIR
BE AGENTS OR OUT AS WELL
THROUGHOUT THE STATE. AYE
HOWEVER THEY DO HAVE ENFORCEMENT
ABILITY.
OKAY.
ARE YOU MAY CLOSE.
PROGRESS RIGHT.
THERE IS A MOTION ARE PLEASE
CALL THE ROLL.
ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TWO FIVE SIX
FOUR.
BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER RODRIGUEZ
MOTION IS DO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE. AYE
CASKEY AYE.
I STONE STONE AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE HILL.
LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
OKAY MATTER OPEN FOR ABSENT
MEMBERS NONE LET'S MOVE TO ITEM.
TEN THIS IS A BE Q. EIGHT EIGHT
FIVE ABOUT PRIORITIZING REBATES
WITH THE. CB R. P..
PROGRAM.
BUT WAS CHAIR MEMBERS I WANT TO
BEGIN BY ACCEPTING THE MEMONS AS
PROPOSED A NON ANALYSIS.
ASSEMBLY BILL TWENTY EIGHT
EIGHTY FIVE INTEREST COMMUNITIES
ARE RECEIVING THE NECESSARY
RESOURCES IN THE EIGHT TO FIGHT
AGAINST.
POOR AIR QUALITY CLIMATE CHANGE.
THE CLEAN VEHICLE REBATE PROJECT
WAS CREATED TO PROVIDE REBATES
TO CONSUMERS WHO PURCHASE.
ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY
VEHICLES HOWEVER MOT OF THE
REBATES HAVE NOT GONE TO
COMMUNITIES THAT NEED THEM THE
MOST.
DESIRE IS LIKE MY DISTRICT I
SUFFER FROM EXTREMELY POOR AIR
QUALITY LOW INCOMES AND POOR
QUALITY OF HEALTH.
AB TWENTY EIGHT EIGHTY FIVE
PRIORITIZE REBATES TO LOW INCOME
CONSUMERS. AND REQUIRES OUR
REACH TO LOW INCOME COMMITTEES
TO HELP HARDWORKING FAMILIES DO
THEIR PART.
TO COMBAT CLIMATE CHANGE.
ALRIGHT EITHER OTHERS IN SUPPORT
OF AB AT TWO EIGHT EIGHT FIVE.
GOOD MORNING MISTER CHAIR ISRAEL
SALAS WITH SAN DIEGO GAS AND
ELECTRIC HAPPY TO BE IN SUPPORT
THE BILL THANK YOU.
THAT HOW JONES A CIRCLE
CALIFORNIA ONE THINK THE
COMMITTEE IN THE AUTHOR FOR HIM
AMENDMENTS WITH THE AMENDMENTS
WERE IN SPORTS BILL THANK YOU.
JERRY MEMBERS RJ SAMANTHA SOME
HALF A SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
EDISON AND STRONG SUPPORT THANK
YOU.
OKAY.
I OPPOSITION CUBA AB TWO EIGHT
EIGHT FIVE.
OKAY LET'S BRING IT BACK AND.
YEAH I GUESS MONEY MY CONCERN IS
THAT WE HAVE A GLOBAL PROBLEM
AND EVERY ELECTRIC VEHICLES ON
THE ON THE. HOT.
ROADS IN CALIFORNIA WHETHER IT
THERE IN.
LOW INCOME AREAS OR OR MEDIA
MAKE CARRIERS THE DRIVE AROUND
AND IT'S IT'S GREAT SO HOPEFULLY
WE HAVE FIXED THE PROBLEM WITH
THE. WITH THE STICKERS AND THEY
HAD REBATES.
SO THAT EVERYBODY CAN
PARTICIPATE IN NYC IS WILL NEVER
GET TO FIVE MILLION DOLLARS BUT
I THINK I'M.
.
ENCOURAGED BY THE OUT REACH
PORTIONS OF THE BILL I'M MORE SO
THAN THE OTHERS BUT THAT'S JUST
MY. THOUGHTS ON IT SO WE WILL WE
HAVE A MOTION.
I INVEST FOR AND I VOTE RESPECT
YEAH I DON'T. GET IT.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL.
ITEM NUMBER TEN AB TWO EIGHT
EIGHT FIVE ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ THE MOTION IS DO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE TRANSPORTATION
HOUSING COMMITTEE.
I CASKET BY ASKING AYE STONE.
STONE I GAIN. GAINES AYE HILL.
LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
IT WILL KEEP THAT MATTER OPEN
FOR THE REST OF THE MEMBERS ON
THIS COMMITTEE.
THANK YOU THANK YOU. A WE WILL
I WILL TURN THE GAVEL OVER TO
THE VICE CHAIR AND I WILL BE
PRESENTING FOR ASSEMBLY MEMBER
QUIRK THIS IS ITEM NUMBER TWO.
AB NINETEEN EIGHTY.
THE A COMING UP.
OKAY GOOD MORNING THIS AB
NINETEEN EIGHTY QUIRK PRESIDENT
BUYER CHAIRMAN. A COSTLY.
GOOD MORNING.
WELCOME.
BUT.
I THINK THAT'S REALLY GREAT TO
SEE IT VICE CHAIR AND THEATER ME
HERE. OF THIS IS AB AT NINETEEN
EIGHTY WHICH EXTENSIVE STATURE
LIMITATIONS FOR COMMENCING A
CIVIL ENFORCEMENT ACTION FOR
ABOVE.
GROUND PETROLEUM STORAGE AT ACT
OR A P..
S. A VIOLATIONS FROM ONE YEAR TO
FIVE YEARS THE ONE YEAR STATUTE
OF LIMITATION IS INSUFFICIENT
STAFF REPORT.
CALLS OUT BECAUSE IT TYPICALLY
TAKES A YEAR OR MORE TO COMPLETE
THE INVESTIGATIONS INVOLVING A
PSA.
VIOLATIONS
A EPSA WAS ENACTED IN NINETEEN
NINETY IS A DIRECT RESULT A
RESPONSE TO SPILLED OVER FOUR
HUNDRED THOUSAND.
GALLONS OF PETROLEUM FROM AND
ABOUT ABOVE GROUND PETROLEUM
TANKS INSENSITIVE MARCHES IN THE
DELTA BAY. A.
ARE BAY DELTA ESTUARY.
.
THE FIVE YEAR AYE APSA STATURE
LIMITATIONS WOULD BE CONSISTENT
WITH OTHER LAWS AND THAT THE
UNIFIED OUR PROGRAM WHICH
ENFORCES A. HAZARDOUS MATERIALS
AND LAWS WITH ME I HAVE I CAN
LOAN FROM THE ALAMEDA COUNTY.
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE WHICH
BROUGHT HIS TO ASSEMBLY MEMBER.
.
RECORD AND I JUST WANT WITH
THEIR. COOPER'S.
THANK YOU.
WHEN ASSEMBLY.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU MISTER CHAIR AND A
GOOD MORNING AND COMMITTEE
MEMBERS.
.
MY NAME IS KEVIN WONG A I'M A
DEPUTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY WITH
THE ALAMEDA COUNTY DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICE ON BEHALF OF.
NANCY O'MALLEY WHO IS THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY OF ALAMEDA
COUNTY AND SPONSOR OF THIS BILL.
.
YES IS THIS BILL SEEKS TO.
.
BAND THE STATURE LIMITATIONS
FROM ONE YEAR TO FIVE YEARS FOR
BRINGING.
ACTION FOR CIVIL PENALTIES FOR.
VIOLATIONS OF THE ABOVE GROUND
PETROLEUM STORAGE ACT.
APSA.
ABSA IS A AN IMPORTANT LAW THAT
SEEKS TO PROTECT.
OF THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE
PUBLIC FROM.
SPILLS.
AND.
LIKE OTHER AREAS OF
ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS LIKE THE
HAZARDOUS WASTE CONTROL LAW.
UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK LAW.
HAS MATURED BUSINESS PLAN LAW.
THOSE AREAS HAVE A FIVE YEAR
STATURE LIMITATIONS TO PRINCIPLE
ACTIONS
SO THIS WOULD BRING CONSISTENCY.
AND TO ALL THOSE AREAS OF VARMA
LA.
BESIDES BRING CONSISTENCY
REFLECTS THE REALITIES. OF THESE
INVESTIGATIONS THESE
INVESTIGATIONS COME FROM
REGULATORS.
COOPER IS TO DO INSPECTIONS OF
THESE FACILITIES.
.
WHEN ED A VIOLATION IS OBSERVE.
THOSE REGULATORS OFTEN WORK WITH
THE FACILITY OWNERS TO TRY AND
BRING BRINGING THE FACILITY BACK
TO COMPLIANCE.
OFTEN THAT THAT CAN HAPPEN AND
IF THAT DOESN'T HAPPEN THEN. THE
REGULATORS.
USER OF OF ENFORCEMENT TOOLS
TO TRY AND BRING THE FACILITY
BACK INTO COMPLIANCE.
IF THAT DOESN'T WORK THEN THE
CASES I REFERRED TO THE DISTRICT
ATTORNEY'S OFFICES.
SO WHEN THEY COME TO THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICES OR
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL IT'S ALL
IT'S ALREADY ON TO DEFLATE
SCHEDULE.
ON TOP OF THAT ONCE OUR OFFICES.
RECEIVE A CASE WE LOOK AT ALL
THE AREAS OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
TO TRY AND SEE WHAT OTHER
VIOLATIONS TO. ADDRESS NOT JUST
APSA AND WHAT WE FOUND IS THAT
THESE KIDS ARE COMPLEX AND WE
NEED MORE TIME TO INVESTIGATE
THEM.
SO WE'D AT RESPECTFULLY REQUEST
YOUR AYE BUT.
PARTICULAR TESTIMONY. CHAIR
MEMBERS JUST MULLIN FOR THE
COOPER SPEECH JUST ECHO THAT THE
RATIONALE FOR THIS BILL I IT IS
ACTUALLY TRUE WE DO TRY TO USE
ADMINISTRATIVE ENFORCEMENT
AUTHORITY FIRST SO WE DON'T CLOG
UP THE COURTS. AND OFTEN THAT
DOES TAKE SOME TIME SO THIS IS
NECESSARY WE THINK THAT THEY
SHOULD BE EQUAL PROTECTION FOR
ALL OF THE SIX A COOPER PROGRAMS
AND MUCHO AYE VOTE THANK YOU.
IF YOU VERY TESTIMONY.
.
YES UP QUESTIONS FOR THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY A SENSE THE.
APSA ACT HAS PASSED
HAVE THERE BEEN EXAMPLES OF
WHERE THE STATURE LIMITATIONS
WOULD APPROVE BENTON DUH
PROSECUTING.
AN ACCIDENT IF YOU'LL YES AFFECT
YOU.
.
THERE IS.
THERE WAS A CASE IN TWO
THOUSAND EIGHTEEN THAT RECENTLY
SETTLED MY OFFICE WAS APART OF
IT ALONG WITH.
MANY OTHER DA'S OFFICES
IT'S THE ALTERNATION MATTER.
IT WAS REFERRED TO SANTA CLARA.
BASED ON.
.
HAZARDOUS WASTE VIOLATIONS AND
SO WHEN THAT CAME OVER.
IT WAS AFTER REPEATED EFFORTS
TO GET THAT OUR NATION INTO
COMPLIANCE.
.
WHEN HE CAME OVER TO US AND WE
INVESTIGATE THE CASE MORE
THOROUGHLY AND LOOK AT ALL THE
FACILITIES AND ALL THE
VIOLATIONS.
WE SAID THAT THERE WERE NOT ONLY
HAZARDOUS WASTE VIOLATIONS BUT
ABSENT VIOLATIONS.
AT THAT POINT WAS ALREADY PASSED
THE ONE YEAR STATUTE
LIMITATIONS.
AND SO THERE WERE VIOLATIONS
THAT WE COULD NOT PROCEED ON.
FORTUNATELY WE WORK WITH THE
COMPANY TO GET THEM BACK INTO
COMPLIANCE AND WERE ABLE TO
SETTLE THE CASE BUT WORRIED IF
GOING TO LITIGATION. THERE WOULD
BE VIOLATIONS THAT WE WOULD NOT
BE ABLE TO ACT ON.
WITH THE.
STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL
BOARD AND DEPARTMENT TALKS
SUBSTANCE CNTROL STILL. ABLE TO
PROSECUTE.
THESE DEFICIENCIES OF ALL OF
THE ABOVE GROUND STORAGE JE
BREACHES.
AND LOOK IN THOSE CASES.
.
I DON'T I DON'T I DON'T THINK SO
AYE CONSUMER IN OUR REPORT.
.
ITSAYS IT ALL CARRILLO
PROPENSITY INDUSTRY TURNS FROM
PURSUING CLAIMS THAT ALL OF THEM
WHEN YOU'RE ADMINISTRATIVE
AGENCIES SUCH AS THE STATE.
WATER RESOURCES BOARD CONTROL
BORN AND APARTMENT TO TALK TO
SUBSTANCE CONTROL ARE STILL ABLE
TO BRING ADMINISTRATIVE ACTIONS
THE VIOLATION BE ON WHEN YOU'RE
STAGE THESE CAN RECOVER THE SAME
ON THE PENALTIES.
SO I WAS CURIOUS.
YEAH I'M MISTER.
YEAH PROBABLY THAT IS CORRECT
BUT IT'S VERY VERY SELDOM DONE
THESE PROGRAMS ARE DELEGATED TO
LOCAL AGENCIES SO WE TRY TO HAVE
THAT DIVISION OF LOCAL AND STATE
OVERSIGHT. THAT STATE OVERSIGHT
IS. OVER AND ABOVE NGUYEN OFTEN
FRANKLY WHEN A LOCAL
JURISDICTION FAILS TO DO WHAT IT
SHOULD DO ALL OF THE STATE FEELS
THAT THE LOCAL JURISDICTION IS
DEFICIENT IN. IN PURSUING ITS
STATE SO WE PREFER TO HAVE THE
FULL SUITE OF OF AUTHORITY FOR
ALL OF OUR PROGRAMS. EQUAL AND
IT'S FRANKLY SOMETHING THAT THE
THE INDUSTRY OFTEN ASKS FOR.
MOST OFTEN US FOR CONSISTENCY IN
OUR PROGRAM SO THE CONSISTENCY
WE SHOULD BE HELPFUL HERE.
SHE THEN THE OTHER QUESTIONS.
SENATE AGAINST IF I COULD WITH A
MISTER MALONEY MADE SOME.
COMMENTS AT THIS
WONDER IF YOU COULD.
STAND ON THIS ADMINISTRATIVE
PROCESS SO.
WHAT YOU'RE SAYING?
IF I UNDERSTAND CORRECTLY IS IF
WE EXPAND FROM ONE TO FIVE
YEARS.
MORE THE CASE COULD BE HANDLED
OMINOUS RADICALLY.
THAT.
COULD REDUCE LITIGATION.
IS THAT IS THAT THE.
NO WE WE HAVE.
WE HAVE THE ADMINISTRATIVE
ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY WHICH IS
THE FIRST LINE OF DEFENSE.
THE USUALLY THE LOCAL
JURISDICTION ISSUE A NOTICE OF
VIOLATION IF ITS NOT CORRECTED
WILL GO TO ADMINISTRATIVE
ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITY AND THAT
IS. THAT THE AUTHORITY IS VESTED
IN ALL THE PROGRAMS IN THIS THE
SIX PROGRAMS IN THE COOPER
PROGRAM AT THE LOCAL LEVEL.
BECAUSE THESE PROGRAMS OR
DELEGATED TO THE LOCALS IT IS
OUR COMMON INTEREST TO RESOLVE
THESE AT THE LOCAL LEVEL
RESPONSIBILITIES SO. YOU MAY BE
CORRECT THAT THE STATE MAY
RETAIN THAT AUTHORITY AFTER YET
TO INTERVENE. BUT IT'S NOT A
VERY EFFICIENT WAY OF RUNNING A
PROGRAM AND THAT'S THE REASON WE
HAVE IT FOR ALL THE THE OTHER
ELEMENTS AND STRICTLY ALONG
CONSISTENCY LINES IT MAKES SENSE
FOR US TO. TALK ABOUT THE
MINISTRY TO FLEE A LOCAL WELL.
CORRECT AND THIS WOULD EXPAND
AND THEN YOU'RE TO FIVE.
NO NOT IN THE ADMINISTRATION ARE
ON THE ON THE AUTHORITY OF THE
DISTRICT ATTORNEY TO STAY OPEN
DERISIVE DIFFERENTLY TO BRING
CIVIL ACTIONS THAT WILL LET US
COME OVER FROM THE LOCALS.
GRACE ENTERS OKAY.
IT WOULD STILL EXTENSIVELY.
LITIGATION ASPECT BITE
ADDITIONAL FOR YEARS.
THANK YOU.
XENA NUMBER QUESTIONS.
ALL THOSE IN FAVOR IF YOU COULD
PLEASE COME SPEAK AT THE
MICROPHONE.
SEAN OFTEN OF THE CALIFORNIA
DISTRICT ATTORNEYS ASSOCIATION
SUPPORT THANK YOU FOR YOUR
TESTIMONY NAY OTHERS IN SUPPORT.
OTHER NEWS AND ANYBODY IN
OPPOSITION TO PLEASE COME
FORWARD.
SAVE THEM CENTER MCCLOSKEY.
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PARITY AS
WE'VE IFS THE COOP IS A POINTED
OUT THIS IS GOING TO GIVE OUR
PROSECUTORS.
THE EFFECTIVE.
ENFORCEMENT TOOLS THAT THEY
NEED TO UP BALANCE OFF ALL
THESE.
OUT VIOLATIONS TO COMMAND AND
WITH THAT I WOULD URGE AND IVA.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMENTS.
IF DATA ON THE BILL.
.
IT'S A CLOSE.
AFTER CLOSE THANK YOU I
CERTAINLY URGE.
BUT PLEASE CALL ROLL OVER DISCO.
WHAT IS THIS PROJECT ADMITTED?
JUDICIARY THANK YOU.
ITEM NUMBER TWO A. B. NINETEEN
EIGHTY BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER QUIRK
MOTION IS DUE PASSED THE SENATE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
LIKE ASKING AYE WIECKOWSKI AYE
STONE AYE STONE AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE HILL.
LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
THANK YOU VERY TESTIMONIES
GERMAN.
LADIES.
THE.
TO BRING CASES.
NBCU.
LET'S CALL UP BUT ASSEMBLY
MEMBER MCCARTY THIS IS ITEM
NUMBER SEVEN A. B. TWO FOUR. ONE
ONE ABOUT.
COMPOSTING ON OUR STATE HIGHWAYS
YEAH EXCITING TOPIC AND
COMPOSTING I MISTER CHAIR I
BEFORE WE HAVE A BIPARTISAN THAT
MEASURE. THAT I WANT TO PRESENT
TO YOU TODAY FIRST OF ALL WANT
TO START BY I THINK THAT.
COMMITTEE STAFF WORKING SO
CLOSELY WITH US AND GIVING US
SOME. SOME NEEDED IMPROVEMENTS
AND SO I'D LIKE TO OUT EXCEPT
THE COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS.
AT THIS MEASURE WILL HELP SPUR
THE MARKET DEMAND FOR COMPOST IN
CALIFORNIA BY REQUIRING OUR
STATE PUBLIC AGENCIES TO LOOK AT
THE FEASIBILITY AND BEST
PRACTICES FOR USING. COMPOST
AROUND OUR GRAYSON CALIFORNIA
YOU NOTE THAT COMPOST IS THE END
RESULT OF DIVERTING ORGANIC
WASTE FROM OUR LANDFILLS.
THE FACILITIES GREATLY REDUCING
A CLIMATE CHANGE CAUSING
EMISSIONS A COMPOSTING IS THE
MOST EFFECTIVE AND EFFICIENT
METHOD FOR REDUCING GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSIONS ALSO A JOB
CREATOR.
OF THIS WILL HELP SPUR A AND
NEEDED A MARKET DEMAND FOR
COMPOST IN CALIFORNIA. AND RAMP
UP PRODUCTION TO MEET OUR.
GHG REDUCTION GOALS.
AND ENSURING A HEALTHY MARKET
FOR COMPOST IS VITAL TO OUR
STATES PLAN IN TACKLING CLIMATE
CHANGE I RESPECTFULLY ASK YOUR
AYE VOTE THIS MORNING. AND WITH
ME ARE NICK LAPIS WITH
CALIFORNIA'S AGAINST WASTE AND
READ ADDIS WITH THAT THE MARINE
CARBON PROJECT LIBERAL.
BUT YOUR MORNING CYCLOPS
CALIFORNIANS AGAINST WASTE.
AS YOU'RE WELL AWARE WE'VE
PASSED SEVERAL PIECES OF
LEGISLATION IN THE LAST FEW
YEARS REQUIRING ORGANIC WASTE BE
DIVERTED FROM LANDFILLS.
AND TO COMPOSTING FACILITY IS AN
ANAEROBIC DIE JUST YOURS.
PART OF THE PUZZLE OF MAKING THE
ECONOMICS WORK FOR THAT. IS
FINDING GOOD SOLID MARKETS FOR
THE COMPOST.
AND THIS BILL REALLY TACKLES
THAT TO PROBABLY LOW'S HANGING
FRUITS IN THAT AREA.
THE FIRST BEING.
CLEAN UP AFTER FIRES THE SECOND
BEING CALTRANS HE'S.
IN THE CASE OF FIRES.
THE STATUS FUNDED A VARIETY OF
STUDIES ON THIS OVER THE YEARS.
AND THEY'VE SHOWN THAT WHEN YOU
APPLY COMPOST.
IT CHANGES THE SOIL STRUCTURE IN
A WAY THAT.
BASICALLY MAKES THIS SOIL MORE
RESILIENT AND MORE.
SPONGY
WHICH REDUCES THEIR THE RISK OF
LANDSLIDES AND WATER.
PULLING THE SOILED OFF OF THAT A
FIRE HILLSIDE.
AND ADDITIONALLY BY PROVIDING
NUTRIENTS THAT HELPS REESTABLISH
VEGETATION MORE QUICKLY WHICH
ALSO HAVE SOMEWHERE BENEFITS.
AS WE SAW IN THE MOST RECENT
WILDFIRES AND.
WE HAD A TRAGIC A LOSS OF TWENTY
ONE LIVES.
FOLLOWING.
THE THAT WILDFIRES THROUGH
LANDSLIDES.
AND YOU KNOW IT'S NOT CLEAR THAT
COMPOST WOULD HAVE PREVENTED ALL
OF THEM.
OR EVEN A SURLY ANY OF THEM BUT
IT DEFINITELY IS ONE OF THE BEST
MANAGER PRACTICES WE SHOULD
IMPLEMENT.
SO MORALLY WEB THAT CALTRANS
THAT THE BENEFITS ARE VERY
SIMILAR AND THE LEGISLATURE'S
ACTUALLY DIRECTED CALTRANS
HUGHES MORE COMPOST IN THE PAST.
AND SOME F THAT BUT CALTRANS
DISTRICTS HAVE TAKEN THAT TO
HEART AND HAVE REALLY.
BEEN USING IT SUCCESSFULLY THEY
GO SPEAK ABOUT A DIFFERENT
CONFERENCE AS A FEDERAL.
BUT OTHERS HAVE BEEN EMBRACE IT
AS AS MUCH
AND SO THE BILL SAYS LETS LOOK
AT WHAT'S WORKING AND THE
DISTRICTS THAT ARE USING AT. AND
LET'S SEE IF WE CAN APPLY THAT
IN OTHER DISTRICTS.
AND YOU ALSO GET THE BENEFIT OF
THOSE VOLUNTEER TOMATO PLANTS
THAT COME UP WITH THAT AS LONG
ON TOP OF THAT NEXT WITNESS
DIDN'T THINK YOU CHAIR MEMBERS
READ OUT ASSEMBLY AFTER JOHN
WICK CO FOUNDER THE MARINE
CARBON PROJECT. IN STRONG
SUPPORT TODAY OUT OVER THE YEARS
WE'VE CONDUCTED A LOT OF SCIENCE
RIGHT HEALTHY SOILS THAT WHICH
INCLUDES A BETTER UNDERSTANDING
ABOUT COMPOST WORKS. IN FOR ALL
THE REASONS MY COLLEAGUE
MENTIONED IN VERY STRONG SUPPORT
THE POLICY TODAY THANK YOU VERY
MUCH OTHERS IN SUPPORT OF TWO
FOUR ONE ONE.
DOESN'T ON FOR THE CALIFORNIA
COMPOSED COALITION OBVIOUSLY
VERY MUCH IN SUPPORT.
OTHERS PLEASE COME FORWARD.
GOOD MORNING MELISSA AND MO WITH
SHY ORDER ENTRY ON BEHALF OF THE
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
THE SOLID WASTE ASSOCIATION OF
NORTH AMERICA AND THE WESTERN
CLOSER WASTE MANAGEMENT
AUTHORITY IN SUPPORT.
IS THERE OPPOSITION TO IT TWO
FOUR ONE ONE.
THERE IS A MOTION.
XENA OPPOSITION CLOSE PUBLIC
HEARING.
I'VE HAD MY SAY YOU MAY CLOSE
AYE THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR
THAT.
CONVERSATION AND
MY SHIRT PULLING OVER ON I FIVE
GRABBING SOME FAIRLY TONIGHT IS
A GOOD IDEA.
EVERY SOMETHING LOOK FORWARD TO
WHEN OUR BEAUTIFUL HIGHWAY
SYSTEM.
THAT GOLDEN POPPY WILL HAVE
ANOTHER MEANING.
PLEASE CALL THE ROLL THIS IS I.
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB TWO FOUR
ONE ONE.
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB TWO FOUR
ONE ONE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
MCCARTY THE MOTION IS DO PASS AS
AMENDED TO SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE.
SENATOR WHY CASCADE BY BY CASKEY
AYE STONE.
STONE AYE GAINES.
GAINES AYE HILL.
LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
OKAY WE HAVE THREE VOTES ON MY
TWO COLLEAGUES WHO HAVE BEEN
HERE ALL MORNING R. EXCUSE WERE
DONE WITH ALL THE.
ITEMS THANK YOU VERY MUCH SAID.
ASSEMBLYMEMBER.
WE'RE GOING TO.
KICKED THE ROLE OPEN I WILL.
.
I HAD.
FIND OUT THAT WILL CALL THE
OFFICES TO SEE WHAT WE'RE GOING
TO DO SO WILL HAVE A PAUSE HERE
RIGHT ASSISTANCE CAN WE OPEN THE
ROLE ON ITEM NUMBER TWO A. B..
AND PAT NINETEEN EIGHTY BY
QUIRK.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER TWO A. B. NINETEEN
EIGHTY BY SOME REMEMBER QUIRK.
MISSION IS TO PASS THE SENATE
JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
ADAM THE CHAIR VOTED AYE. VICE
CHAIR VOTED AYE.
HILL.
HILL AYE.
LARA.
STERN
OKAY WILL KEEP THAT ARE MATTER
OPEN ITEM NUMBER SEVEN A. B..
TWENTY FOUR ELEVEN BY
ASSEMBLYMAN MCCARTY PLEASE CALL
THE ABSENT MEMBERS
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB TWENTY FOUR
ELEVEN BYSIMPLY MEMBER MCCARTY
MISSION IS TO PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE.
SHARE VOTED AYE VICE CHAIR VOTED
AYE.
HILL. NO I LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
I'M OPEN THE ROLL ON ITEM NUMBER
NINE AB TWENTY FIVE SIXTY FOUR
BY RODRIGUEZ PLEASE CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TWENTY FIVE
SIXTY FOUR BY ASSEMBLYMEMBER
RODRIGUEZ THE MOTION IS DO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE. CHAIRED BY CHAIR
VOTED AYE VICE CHAIR VOTED AYE.
HILL. HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
AND LET'S OPEN THE OF ROLE ON
ITEM NUMBER CAN AB TWO EIGHT
EIGHT FIVE BY RODRIGUEZ PLEASE
CALL THE UPS MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER TEN AB TWO EIGHT
EIGHT FIVE BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ THE MOTION IS TO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE TRANSPORTATION
AND HOUSING COMMITTEE.
SHARE VICE CHAIR VOTED AYE. VICE
CHAIR VOTED AYE.
HILL. HILL AYE LARA.
SKINNER.
STERN.
OKAY PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS AGAIN I'M ITEM NUMBER
TEN RODRIGUEZ.
THE ABSENT MEMBERS TO TO LARA.
SKINNER.
TEN ITEM NUMBER TEN AB TWENTY
EIGHT EIGHTY FIVE BY SIMPLY
MEMBER RODRIGUEZ.
SKINNER AYE.
OKAY LET'S OPEN THE ROLE.
I THINK THAT IF.
OKAY SIR WILLIAM CLOSER ROLE ON
ITEM NUMBER. TEN.
MATTER.
TAKE A MOMENT.
YOU WANT BULLETIN WE CAN RUN.
WE'RE GONNA GO RUN GET.
AND.
ALSO.
AND.
WHAT?
THAT'S SIMPLY
BUT. I UNDERSTAND THAT.
IN CENTERS LAUREN CENTER STERN
SCHOOL AND BE UNABLE TO MAKE IT
SO WE WILL OPEN THE ROLE ONE
MORE TIME AND THEN I'LL CLOSE
RULES ON EACH OF THE ITEMS SO.
I'M ITEM.
NUMBER TWO I HAVE.
BY QUIRK A BE NINETEEN EIGHTY
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
AND THE NUMBER TWO AB NINETEEN
EIGHTY BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK
THE MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO THE
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE.
CHAIR VOTED I BUT VICE CHAIR
VOTED AYE.
LARA.
SKINNER AYE SKINNER AYE STERN.
I THAT MATTERS OUT FROM TO THE
KEY ISSUE COMMITTEE ITEM NUMBER
FOUR ITEM.
I AB TWO ZERO NINE SEVEN BY
ACOSTA PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT
MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER FOUR AB TWENTY
NINETY SEVEN BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
ACOSTA AT THE MOTION IS DO PASS
TO THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE. CHAIR VOTED AYE VICE
CHAIR VOTED AYE. LARA.
SKINNER WIFE SKINNER AYE STERN.
THAT MATTERS OUT WILL CLOSE THE
ROLE I'M ITEM NUMBER SIX.
AB TWO THREE FOUR ONE BY MATHIS
PLEASE.
PLEASE CALL THE.
.
ABSENT MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER SIX AB TWENTY THREE
FORTY ONE ASSEMBLY MEMBER MATHIS
MOTION IS DUE PASS AS AMENDED TO
THE SENATE FLOOR.
VICE CHAIR NO VOTE STONE I'M
SORRY VICE CHAIR.
I.
AND LARA.
SKINNER.
THIS ONE THE.
CORRECT.
SKINNER AYE STERN.
THE WILL CLOSE ROLE THAT MATTER
HAS FOUR VOTES TO OUT.
I'M.
ITEM NUMBER SEVEN.
AB I.
NO WE CLOSED RULE ON THAT.
WELL AS I DO KNOW LET'S CALL THE
ABSENT MEMBERS ON A.
SOMEWHERE MCCARTY MCCARTY SPILL
TWENTY FOUR ELEVEN THEM ITEM
SEVEN. ITEM NUMBER SEVEN AB
TWENTY FOUR ELEVEN BY ASSEMBLY
MEMBER MCCARTY MOTION IS DUE
PASSED AS AMENDED TO THE SENATE
APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE. CHAIR
VOTED AYE VICE CHAIR VOTED AYE.
LARA.
SKINNER AYE
SKINNER AYE STERN.
THEM CLOSE ROLE THAT MATTERS
OUT.
I'M ITEM NUMBER NINE BY
RODRIGUEZ DISS AB TWENTY FIVE
SIXTY FOUR ON GLIDER VEHICLES
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER NINE AB TWENTY FIVE
SIXTY FOUR BY ASSEMBLY MEMBER
RODRIGUEZ THE MOTION IS TO PASS
AS AMENDED TO THE JUDICIARY
COMMITTEE.
CHAIR VOTED AYE VICE CHAIR BUT
IT AYE. LARA.
SKINNER.
SKINNER AYE STERN.
CLOSE ROLE THAT MATTERS OUT ON A
FIVE VOTE COUNT ITEM NUMBER TEN
ALSO BY RODRIGUEZ A. B.. TO
EIGHT EIGHT FIVE PLEASE CALL THE
ROLL THAT WE CLOSE DOWN BY THIN
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE.
.
A. B..
THREE ZERO THREE SIX BY COOLEY.
I AM.
PLEASE CALL THE ABSENT MEMBERS.
ITEM NUMBER TWELVE A. B. THIRTY
THIRTY SIX BY SIMPLY MEMBER
COOLEY MOTION IS DUE PASSED TO
THE SENATE APPROPRIATIONS
COMMITTEE.
CHAIR VOTED AYE VICE CHAIR VOTED
BY.
LARA.
SKINNER.
SKINNER AYE STERN.
LOOK CLOSER AND.
ROLL THAT MATTERS OUT ON A FIVE
ONE FINALLY THE CONSENT CALENDAR
THIS IS ITEM NUMBER.
.
EIGHT BY SALAS AT AB TWO FIVE
FOUR ONE AN ITEM.
NUMBER ELEVEN A. B. TO NINE OH
TWO BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL. SAFETY
AND TOXIC MATERIALS COMMITTEE
PLEASE CALL THE UPS MEMBERS.
ADAMS NUMBER OUT EIGHT ITEM
NUMBER ELEVEN.
CHAIR VOTED AYE. VICE CHAIR
WOULD IT BY LARA.
SKINNER BY
SKINNER AYE STERN.
RIGHT THAT MATTERS OUT BY FIVE
THOUGH VOTE WE ARE ADJOURNED
UNTIL.
THIS TWENTIETH OF JUNE
MEMBERS WHO ARE LISTENING.
PROBABLY BETWEEN EIGHTY AND
NINETY BILLS ARE COME INTO OUR
LITTLE COMMITTEE FOR OUR ONE
DATE.
PIPE WE ARE ADJOURNED